diff options
| author | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 04:42:31 -0700 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 04:42:31 -0700 |
| commit | 7adac71a969804177734c8f4e26158e3c0793fb6 (patch) | |
| tree | 697dabe02c76139ff32b5341513511cb36635ee8 | |
| -rw-r--r-- | .gitattributes | 3 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 13614-0.txt | 13107 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 13614-h/13614-h.htm | 13299 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | LICENSE.txt | 11 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | README.md | 2 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/13614-8.txt | 13500 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/13614-8.zip | bin | 0 -> 290991 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/13614-h.zip | bin | 0 -> 310053 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/13614-h/13614-h.htm | 13703 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/13614.txt | 13501 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/13614.zip | bin | 0 -> 290576 bytes |
11 files changed, 67126 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/.gitattributes b/.gitattributes new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6833f05 --- /dev/null +++ b/.gitattributes @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +* text=auto +*.txt text +*.md text diff --git a/13614-0.txt b/13614-0.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9250bb8 --- /dev/null +++ b/13614-0.txt @@ -0,0 +1,13107 @@ +*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK 13614 *** + +STUDIES IN THE PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX, VOLUME V + + Erotic Symbolism + The Mechanism of Detumescence + The Psychic State in Pregnancy + +by + +HAVELOCK ELLIS + +1927 + + + + + + + +PREFACE. + + +In this volume the terminal phenomena of the sexual process are discussed, +before an attempt is finally made, in the concluding volume, to consider +the bearings of the psychology of sex on that part of morals which may be +called "social hygiene." + +Under "Erotic Symbolism" I include practically all the aberrations of the +sexual instinct, although some of these have seemed of sufficient +importance for separate discussion in previous volumes. It is highly +probable that many readers will consider that the name scarcely suffices +to cover manifestations so numerous and so varied. The term "sexual +equivalents" will seem preferable to some. While, however, it may be fully +admitted that these perversions are "sexual equivalents"--or at all events +equivalents of the normal sexual impulse--that term is merely a +descriptive label which tells us nothing of the phenomena. "Sexual +Symbolism" gives us the key to the process, the key that makes all these +perversions intelligible. In all of them--very clearly in some, as in +shoe-fetichism; more obscurely in others, as in exhibitionism--it has come +about by causes congenital, acquired, or both, that some object or class +of objects, some act or group of acts, has acquired a dynamic power over +the psycho-physical mechanism of the sexual process, deflecting it from +its normal adjustment to the whole of a beloved person of the opposite +sex. There has been a transmutation of values, and certain objects, +certain acts, have acquired an emotional value which for the normal person +they do not possess. Such objects and acts are properly, it seems to me, +termed symbols, and that term embodies the only justification that in most +cases these manifestations can legitimately claim. + +"The Mechanism of Detumescence" brings us at last to the final climax for +which the earlier and more prolonged stage of tumescence, which has +occupied us so often in these _Studies_, is the elaborate preliminary. +"The art of love," a clever woman novelist has written, "is the art of +preparation." That "preparation" is, on the physiological side, the +production of tumescence, and all courtship is concerned in building up +tumescence. But the final conjugation of two individuals in an explosion +of detumescence, thus slowly brought about, though it is largely an +involuntary act, is still not without its psychological implications and +consequences; and it is therefore a matter for regret that so little is +yet known about it. The one physiological act in which two individuals are +lifted out of all ends that center in self and become the instrument of +those higher forces which fashion the species, can never be an act to be +slurred over as trivial or unworthy of study. + +In the brief study of "The Psychic State in Pregnancy" we at last touch +the point at which the whole complex process of sex reaches its goal. A +woman with a child in her womb is the everlasting miracle which all the +romance of love, all the cunning devices of tumescence and detumescence, +have been invented to make manifest. The psychic state of the woman who +thus occupies the supreme position which life has to offer cannot fail to +be of exceeding interest from many points of view, and not least because +the maternal instinct is one of the elements even of love between the +sexes. But the psychology of pregnancy is full of involved problems, and +here again, as so often in the wide field we have traversed, we stand at +the threshold of a door it is not yet given us to pass. + +HAVELOCK ELLIS. + +Carbis Water, Lelant, Cornwall. + + + + +CONTENTS. + + +EROTIC SYMBOLISM. + +I. + +The Definition of Erotic Symbolism. Symbolism of Act and Symbolism of +Object. Erotic Fetichism. Wide Extension of the Symbols of Sex. The +Immense Variety of Possible Erotic Fetiches. The Normal Foundations of +Erotic Symbolism. Classification of the Phenomena. The Tendency to +Idealize the Defects of a Beloved Person. Stendhal's "Crystallization". + +II. + +Foot-fetichism and Shoe-fetichism. Wide Prevalence and Normal Basis. +Restif de la Bretonne. The Foot a Normal Focus of Sexual Attraction Among +Some Peoples. The Chinese, Greeks, Romans, Spaniards, etc. The Congenital +Predisposition in Erotic Symbolism. The Influence of Early Association and +Emotional Shock. Shoe-fetichism in Relation to Masochism. The Two +Phenomena Independent Though Allied. The Desire to be Trodden On. The +Fascination of Physical Constraint. The Symbolism of Self-inflicted Pain. +The Dynamic Element in Erotic Symbolism. The Symbolism of Garments. + +III. + +Scatalogic Symbolism. Urolagnia. Coprolagnia. The Ascetic Attitude Towards +the Flesh. Normal Basis of Scatalogic Symbolism. Scatalogic Conceptions +Among Primitive Peoples. Urine as a Primitive Holy Water. Sacredness of +Animal Excreta. Scatalogy in Folk-lore. The Obscene as Derived from the +Mythological. The Immature Sexual Impulse Tends to Manifest Itself in +Scatalogic Forms. The Basis of Physiological Connection Between the +Urinary and Genital Spheres. Urinary Fetichism Sometimes Normal in +Animals. The Urolagnia of Masochists. The Scatalogy of Saints. Urolagnia +More Often a Symbolism of Act Than a Symbolism of Object. Only +Occasionally an Olfactory Fetichism. Comparative Rarity of Coprolagnia. +Influence of Nates Fetichism as a Transition to Coprolagnia, Ideal +Coprolagnia. Olfactory Coprolagnia. Urolagnia and Coprolagnia as Symbols +of Coitus. + +IV. + +Animals as Sources of Erotic Symbolism. Mixoscopic Zoophilia. The +Stuff-fetichisms. Hair-fetichism. The Stuff-fetichisms Mainly on a Tactile +Base. Erotic Zoophilia. Zooerastia. Bestiality. The Conditions that Favor +Bestiality. Its Wide Prevalence Among Primitive Peoples and Among +Peasants. The Primitive Conception of Animals. The Goat. The Influence of +Familiarity With Animals. Congress Between Women and Animals. The Social +Reaction Against Bestiality. + +V. + +Exhibitionism. Illustrative Cases. A Symbolic Perversion of Courtship. The +Impulse to Defile. The Exhibitionist's Psychic Attitude. The Sexual Organs +as Fetiches. Phallus Worship. Adolescent Pride in Sexual Development. +Exhibitionism of the Nates. The Classification of the Forms of +Exhibitionism. Nature of the Relationship of Exhibitionism to Epilepsy. + +VI. + +The Forms of Erotic Symbolism are Simulacra of Coitus. Wide Extension of +Erotic Symbolism. Fetichism Not Covering the Whole Ground of Sexual +Selection. It is Based on the Individual Factor in Selection. +Crystallization. The Lover and the Artist. The Key to Erotic Symbolism is +to be Found in the Emotional Sphere. The Passage to Pathological Extremes. + + + +THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE. + +I. + +The Psychological Significance of Detumescence. The Testis and the Ovary. +Sperm Cell and Germ Cell. Development of the Embryo. The External Sexual +Organs. Their Wide Range of Variation. Their Nervous Supply. The Penis. +Its Racial Variations. The Influence of Exercise. The Scrotum and +Testicles. The Mons Veneris. The Vulva. The Labia Majora and their +Varieties. The Public Hair and Its Characters. The Clitoris and Its +Functions. The Anus as an Erogenous Zone. The Nymphæ and their Function. +The Vagina. The Hymen. Virginity. The Biological Significance of the +Hymen. + +II. + +The Object of Detumescence. Erogenous Zones. The Lips. The Vascular +Characters of Detumescence. Erectile Tissue. Erection in Woman. Mucous +Emission in Women. Sexual Connection. The Human Mode of Intercourse. +Normal Variations. The Motor Characters of Detumescence. Ejaculation. The +Virile Reflex. The General Phenomena of Detumescence. The Circulatory and +Respiratory Phenomena. Blood Pressure. Cardiac Disturbance. Glandular +Activity. Distillatio. The Essentially Motor Character of Detumescence. +Involuntary Muscular Irradiation to Bladder, etc. Erotic Intoxication. +Analogy of Sexual Detumescence and Vesical Tension. The Specifically +Sexual Movements of Detumescence in Man. In Woman. The Spontaneous +Movements of the Genital Canal in Woman. Their Function in Conception. +Part Played by Active Movement of the Spermatozoa. The Artificial +Injection of Semen. The Facial Expression During Detumescence. The +Expression of Joy. The Occasional Serious Effects of Coitus. + +III. + +The Constituents of Semen. Function of the Prostate. The Properties of +Semen. Aphrodisiacs. Alcohol, Opium, etc. Anaphrodisiacs. The Stimulant +Influence of Semen in Coitus. The Internal Effects of Testicular +Secretions. The Influence of Ovarian Secretion. + +IV. + +The Aptitude for Detumescence. Is There an Erotic Temperament? The +Available Standards of Comparison. Characteristics of the Castrated. +Characteristics of Puberty. Characteristics of the State of Detumescence. +Shortness of Stature. Development of the Secondary Sexual Characters. Deep +Voice. Bright Eyes. Glandular Activity. Everted Lips. Pigmentation. +Profuse Hair. Dubious Significance of Many of These Characters. + + +THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY. + +The Relationship of Maternal and Sexual Emotion. Conception and Loss of +Virginity. The Anciently Accepted Signs of This Condition. The Pervading +Effects of Pregnancy on the Organism. Pigmentation. The Blood and +Circulation. The Thyroid. Changes in the Nervous System. The Vomiting of +Pregnancy. The Longings of Pregnant Women. Mental Impressions. Evidence +for and Against Their Validity. The Question Still Open. Imperfection of +Our Knowledge. The Significance of Pregnancy. + + +APPENDIX. + +Histories of Sexual Development. + + +INDEX OF AUTHORS. + + +INDEX OF SUBJECTS. + + + + +EROTIC SYMBOLISM. + +I. + +The Definition of Erotic Symbolism--Symbolism of Act and Symbolism of +Object--Erotic Fetichism--Wide extension of the symbols of Sex--The +Immense Variety of Possible Erotic Fetiches--The Normal Foundations of +Erotic Symbolism--Classification of the Phenomena--The Tendency to +Idealize the Defects of a Beloved Person--Stendhal's "Crystallization." + + +By "erotic symbolism" I mean that tendency whereby the lover's attention +is diverted from the central focus of sexual attraction to some object or +process which is on the periphery of that focus, or is even outside of it +altogether, though recalling it by association of contiguity or of +similarity. It thus happens that tumescence, or even in extreme cases +detumescence, may be provoked by the contemplation of acts or objects +which are away from the end of sexual conjugation.[1] + +In considering the phenomena of sexual selection in a previous volume,[2] +it was found that there are four or five main factors in the constitution +of beauty in so far as beauty determines sexual selection. Erotic +symbolism is founded on the factor of individual taste in beauty; it +arises as a specialized development of that factor, but it is, +nevertheless, incorrect to merge it in sexual selection. The attractive +characteristics of a beloved woman or man, from the point of view of +sexual selection, are a complex but harmonious whole leading up to a +desire for the complete possession of the person who displays them. There +is no tendency to isolate and dissociate any single character from the +individual and to concentrate attention upon that character at the expense +of the attention bestowed upon the individual generally. As soon as such a +tendency begins to show itself, even though only in a slight or temporary +form, we may say that there is erotic symbolism. + +Erotic symbolism is, however, by no means confined to the individualizing +tendency to concentrate amorous attention upon some single characteristic +of the adult woman or man who is normally the object of sexual love. The +adult human being may not be concerned at all, the attractive object or +act may not even be human, not even animal, and we may still be concerned +with a symbol which has parasitically rooted itself on the fruitful site +of sexual emotion and absorbed to itself the energy which normally goes +into the channels of healthy human love having for its final end the +procreation of the species. Thus understood in its widest sense, it may be +said that every sexual perversion, even homosexuality, is a form of erotic +symbolism, for we shall find that in every case some object or act that +for the normal human being has little or no erotic value, has assumed such +value in a supreme degree; that is to say, it has become a symbol of the +normal object of love. Certain perversions are, however, of such great +importance on account of their wide relationships, that they cannot be +adequately discussed merely as forms of erotic symbolism. This is notably +the case as regards homosexuality, auto-erotism, and algolagnia, all of +which phenomena have therefore been separately discussed in previous +studies. We are now mainly concerned with manifestations which are more +narrowly and exclusively symbolical. + +A portion of the field of erotic symbolism is covered by what Binet +(followed by Lombroso, Krafft-Ebing, and others) has termed "erotic +fetichism," or the tendency whereby sexual attraction is unduly exerted by +some special part or peculiarity of the body, or by some inanimate object +which has become associated with it. Such erotic symbolism of object +cannot, however, be dissociated from the even more important erotic +symbolism of process, and the two are so closely bound together that we +cannot attain a truly scientific view of them until we regard them broadly +as related parts of a common psychic tendency. If, as Groos asserts,[3] a +symbol has two chief meanings, one in which it indicates a physical +process which stands for a psychic process, and another in which it +indicates a part which represents the whole, erotic symbolism of act +corresponds to the first of these chief meanings, and erotic symbolism of +object to the other. + +Although it is not impossible to find some germs of erotic symbolism in +animals, in its more pronounced manifestations it is only found in the +human species. It could not be otherwise, for such symbolism involves not +only the play of fancy and imagination, the idealizing aptitude, but also +a certain amount of power of concentrating the attention on a point +outside the natural path of instinct and the ability to form new mental +constructions around that point. There are, indeed, as we shall see, +elementary forms of erotic symbolism which are not uncommonly associated +with feeble-mindedness, but even these are still peculiarly human, and in +its less crude manifestations erotic symbolism easily lends itself to +every degree of human refinement and intelligence. + + "It depends primarily upon an increase of the psychological + process of representation," Colin Scott remarks of sexual + symbolism generally, "involving greater powers of comparison and + analysis as compared with the lower animals. The outer + impressions come to be clearly distinguished as such, but at the + same time are often treated as symbols of inner experiences, and + a meaning read into them which they would not otherwise possess. + Symbolism or fetichism is, indeed, just the capacity to see + meaning, to emphasize something for the sake of other things + which do not appear. In brain terms it indicates an activity of + the higher centers, a sort of side-tracking or long-circuiting of + the primitive energy; ... Rosetti's poem, 'The Woodspurge,' + gives a concrete example of the formation of such a symbol. Here + the otherwise insignificant presentation of the three-cupped + woodspurge, representing originally a mere side-current of the + stream of consciousness, becomes the intellectual symbol or + fetich of the whole psychosis forever after. It seems, indeed, as + if the stronger the emotion the more likely will become the + formation of an overlying symbolism, which serves to focus and + stand in the place of something greater than itself; nowhere at + least is symbolism a more characteristic feature than as an + expression of the sexual instinct. The passion of sex, with its + immense hereditary background, in early man became centered often + upon the most trivial and unimportant features.... This + symbolism, now become fetichistic, or symbolic in a bad sense, is + at least an exercise of the increasing representative power of + man, upon which so much of his advancement has depended, while it + also served to express and help to purify his most perennial + emotion." (Colin Scott, "Sex and Art," _American Journal of + Psychology_, vol. vii, No. 2, p. 189.) + +In the study of "Love and Pain" in a previous volume, the analysis of the +large and complex mass of sexual phenomena which are associated with pain, +gradually resolved them to a considerable extent into a special case of +erotic symbolism; pain or restraint, whether inflicted on or by the loved +person, becomes, by a psychic process that is usually unconscious, the +symbol of the sexual mechanism, and hence arouses the same emotions as +that mechanism normally arouses. We may now attempt to deal more broadly +and comprehensively with the normal and abnormal aspects of erotic +symbolism in some of their most typical and least mixed forms. + +"When our human imagination seeks to animate artificial things," Huysmans +writes in _Là -bas_, "it is compelled to reproduce the movements of animals +in the act of propagation. Look at machines, at the play of pistons in the +cylinders; they are Romeos of steel in Juliets of cast-iron." And not only +in the work of man's hands but throughout Nature we find sexual symbols +which are the less deniable since, for the most part, they make not the +slightest appeal to even the most morbid human imagination. Language is +full of metaphorical symbols of sex which constantly tend to lose their +poetic symbolism and to become commonplace. Semen is but seed, and for the +Latins especially the whole process of human sex, as well as the male and +female organs, constantly presented itself in symbols derived from +agricultural and horticultural life. The testicles were beans (_fabæ_) and +fruit or apples (_poma_ and _mala_); the penis was a tree (_arbor_), or a +stalk (_thyrsus_), or a root (_radix_), or a sickle (_falx_), or a +ploughshare (_vomer_). The semen, again, was dew (_ros_). The labia majora +or minora were wings (_alæ_); the vulva and vagina were a field (_ager_ +and _campus_), or a ploughed furrow (_sulcus_), or a vineyard (_vinea_), +or a fountain (_fons_), while the pudendal hair was herbage +(_plantaria_).[4] In other languages it is not difficult to trace similar +and even identical imagery applied to sexual organs and sexual acts. Thus +it is noteworthy that Shakespeare more than once applies the term +"ploughed" to a woman who has had sexual intercourse. The Talmud calls the +labia minora the doors, the labia majora hinges, and the clitoris the key. +The Greeks appear not only to have found in the myrtle-berry, the fruit of +a plant sacred to Venus, the image of the clitoris, but also in the rose +an image of the feminine labia; in the poetic literature of many +countries, indeed, this imagery of the rose may be traced in a more or +less veiled manner.[5] + +The widespread symbolism of sex arose in the theories and conceptions of +primitive peoples concerning the function of generation and its nearest +analogies in Nature; it was continued for the sake of the vigorous and +expressive terminology which it furnished both for daily life and for +literature; its final survivals were cultivated because they furnished a +delicately æsthetic method of approaching matters which a growing +refinement of sentiment made it difficult for lovers and poets to approach +in a more crude and direct manner. Its existence is of interest to us now +because it shows the objective validity of the basis on which erotic +symbolism, as we have here to understand it, develops. But from first to +last it is a distinct phenomenon, having a more or less reasoned and +intellectual basis, and it scarcely serves in any degree to feed the +sexual impulse. Erotic symbolism is not intellectual but emotional in its +origin; it starts into being, obscurely, with but a dim consciousness or +for the most part none at all, either suddenly from the shock of some +usually youthful experience, or more gradually through an instinctive +brooding on those things which are most intimately associated with a +sexually desirable person. + + The kind of soil on which the germs of erotic symbolism may + develop is well seen in cases of sexual hyperæsthesia. In such + cases all the emotionally sexual analogies and resemblances, + which in erotic symbolism are fixed and organized, may be traced + in vague and passing forms, a single hyperæsthetic individual + perhaps presenting a great variety of germinal symbolisms. + + Thus it has been recorded of an Italian nun (whose sister became + a prostitute) that from the age of 8 she had desire for coitus, + from the age of 10 masturbated, and later had homosexual + feelings, that the same feelings and practices continued after + she had taken the veil, though from time to time they assumed + religious equivalents. The mere contact, indeed, of a priest's + hand, the news of the presentation of an ecclesiastic she had + known to a bishopric, the sight of an ape, the contemplation of + the crucified Christ, the figure of a toy, the picture of a + demon, the act of defecation in the children entrusted to her + care (whom, on this account, and against the regulations, she + would accompany to the closets), especially the sight and the + mere recollection of flies in sexual connection--all these things + sufficed to produce in her a powerful orgasm. (_Archivio di + Psichiatria_, 1902, fasc. II-III, p. 338.) + + A boy of 15 (given to masturbation), studied by Macdonald in + America, was similarly hyperæsthetic to the symbols of sexual + emotion. "I like amusing myself with my comrades," he told + Macdonald, "rolling ourselves into a ball, which gives one a + funny kind of warmth. I have a special pleasure in talking about + some things. It is the same when the governess kisses me on + saying good night or when I lean against her breast. I have that + sensation, too, when I see some of the pictures in the comic + papers, but only in those representing a woman, as when a young + man skating trips up a girl so that her clothes are raised a + little. When I read how a man saved a young girl from drowning, + so that they swam together, I had the same sensation. Looking at + the statues of women in the museum produces the same effect, or + when I see naked babies, or when a mother suckles a child. I + have often had that sensation when reading novels I ought not to + read, or when looking at a new-born calf, or seeing dogs and cows + and horses mounting on each other. When I see a girl flirting + with a boy, or leaning on his shoulder or with his arm round her + waist, I have an erection. It is the same when I see women and + little girls in bathing costume, or when boys talk of what their + fathers and mothers do together. In the Natural History Museum I + often see things which give me that sensation. One day when I + read how a man killed a young girl and carried her into a wood + and undressed her I had a feeling of enjoyment. When I read of + men who were bastards the idea of a woman having a child in that + way gives me this sensation. Some dances, and seeing young girls + astride a horse, excited me, too, and so in a circus when a woman + was shot out of a cannon and her skirts flew in the air. It has + no effect on me when I see men naked. Sometimes I enjoy seeing + women's underclothes in a shop, or when I see a lady or a girl + buying them, especially if they are drawers. When I saw a lady in + a dress which buttoned from top to bottom it had more effect on + me than seeing underclothes. Seeing dogs coupling gives me more + pleasure than looking at pretty women, but less than looking at + pretty little girls." In order of increasing intensity he placed + the phenomena that affected him thus: The coupling of flies, then + of horses, then the sight of women's undergarments, then a boy + and a girl flirting, then cows mounting on each other, the + statues of women with naked breasts, then contact with the + governess's body and breasts, finally coitus. (Arthur Macdonald, + _Le Criminel-Type_, pp. 126 et seq.) + + It is worthy of remark that the instinct of nutrition, when + restrained, may exhibit something of an analogous symbolism, + though in a minor degree, to that of sex. The ways in which a + hyperæsthetic hunger may seek its symbols are illustrated in the + case of a young woman called Nadia, who during several years was + carefully studied by Janet. It is a case of obsession ("maladie + du scrupule"), simulating hysterical anorexia, in which the + patient, for fear of getting fat, reduced her nourishment to the + smallest possible amount. "Nadia is generally hungry, even very + hungry. One can tell this by her actions; from time to time she + forgets herself to such an extent as to devour greedily anything + she can put her hands on. At other times, when she cannot resist + the desire to eat, she secretly takes a biscuit. She feels + horrible remorse for the action, but, all the same, she does it + again. Her confidences are very curious. She recognizes that a + great effort is needed to avoid eating, and considers she is a + heroine to resist so long. 'Sometimes I spent whole hours in + thinking about food, I was so hungry; I swallowed my saliva, I + bit my handkerchief, I rolled on the floor, I wanted to eat so + badly. I would look in books for descriptions of meals and + feasts, and tried to deceive my hunger by imagining that I was + sharing all these good things,'" (P. Janet, "La Maladie du + Scrupule," _Revue Philosophique_, May, 1901, p. 502.) The + deviations of the instinct of nutrition are, however, confined + within narrow limits, and, in the nature of things, hunger, + unlike sexual desire, cannot easily accept a fetich. + +"There is almost no feature, article of dress, attitude, act," Stanley +Hall declares, "or even animal or perhaps object in nature, that may not +have to some morbid soul specialized erogenic and erethic power."[6] Even +a mere shadow may become a fetich. Goron tells of a merchant in Paris--a +man with a reputation for ability, happily married and the father of a +family, altogether irreproachable in his private life--who was returning +home one evening after a game of billiards with a friend, when, on +chancing to raise his eyes, he saw against a lighted window the shadow of +a woman changing her chemise. He fell in love with that shadow and +returned to the spot every evening for many months to gaze at the window. +Yet--and herein lies the fetichism--he made no attempt to see the woman or +to find out who she was; the shadow sufficed; he had no need of the +realty.[7] It is even possible to have a negative fetich, the absence of +some character being alone demanded, and the case has been recorded in +Chicago of an American gentleman of average intelligence, education, and +good habits who, having as a boy cherished a pure affection for a girl +whose leg had been amputated, throughout life was relatively impotent with +normal women, but experienced passion and affection for women who had lost +a leg; he was found by his wife to be in extensive correspondence with +one-legged women all over the country, expending no little money on the +purchase of artificial legs for his various protegées.[8] + +It is important to remember, however, that while erotic symbolism becomes +fantastic and abnormal in its extreme manifestations, it is in its +essence absolutely normal. It is only in the very grossest forms of sexual +desire that it is altogether absent. Stendhal described the mental side of +the process of tumescence as a crystallization, a process whereby certain +features of the beloved person present points around which the emotions +held in solution in the lover's mind may concentrate and deposit +themselves in dazzling brilliance. This process inevitably tends to take +place around all those features and objects associated with the beloved +person which have most deeply impressed the lover's mind, and the more +sensitive and imaginative and emotional he is the more certainly will such +features and objects crystallize into erotic symbols. "Devotion and love," +wrote Mary Wollstonecraft, "may be allowed to hallow the garments as well +as the person, for the lover must want fancy who has not a sort of sacred +respect for the glove or slipper of his mistress. He would not confound +them with vulgar things of the same kind." And nearly two centuries +earlier Burton, who had gathered together so much of the ancient lore of +love, clearly asserted the entirely normal character of erotic symbolism. +"Not one of a thousand falls in love," he declares, "but there is some +peculiar part or other which pleaseth most, and inflames him above the +rest.... If he gets any remnant of hers, a busk-point, a feather of her +fan, a shoe-tie, a lace, a ring, a bracelet of hair, he wears it for a +favor on his arm, in his hat, finger, or next his heart; as Laodamia did +by Protesilaus, when he went to war, sit at home with his picture before +her: a garter or a bracelet of hers is more precious than any Saint's +Relique, he lays it up in his casket (O blessed Relique) and every day +will kiss it: if in her presence his eye is never off her, and drink he +will where she drank, if it be possible, in that very place," etc.[9] + + Burton's accuracy in describing the ways of lovers in his century + is shown by a passage in Hamilton's _Mémoires de Gramont_. Miss + Price, one of the beauties of Charles II's court, and Dongan were + tenderly attached to each other; when the latter died he left + behind a casket full of all possible sorts of love-tokens + pertaining to his mistress, including, among other things, "all + kinds of hair." And as regards France, Burton's contemporary, + Howell, wrote in 1627 in his _Familiar Letters_ concerning the + repulse of the English at Rhé: "A captain told me that when they + were rifling the dead bodies of the French gentlemen after the + first invasion they found that many of them had their mistresses' + favors tied about their genitories." + + Schurig (_Spermatologia_, p. 357) at the beginning of the + eighteenth century knew a Belgian lady who, when her dearly loved + husband died, secretly cut off his penis and treasured it as a + sacred relic in a silver casket. She eventually powdered it, he + adds, and found it an efficacious medicine for herself and + others. An earlier example, of a lady at the French court who + embalmed and perfumed the genital organs of her dead husband, + always preserving them in a gold casket, is mentioned by + Brantôme. Mantegazza knew a man who kept for many years on his + desk the skull of his dead mistress, making it his dearest + companion. "Some," he remarks, "have slept for months and years + with a book, a garment, a trifle. I once had a friend who would + spend long hours of joy and emotion kissing a thread of silk + which _she_ had held between her fingers, now the only relic of + love." (Mantegazza, _Fisiologia dell' Amore_, cap. X.) In the + same way I knew a lady who in old age still treasured in her + desk, as the one relic of the only man she had ever been + attracted to, a fragment of paper he had casually twisted up in a + conversation with her half a century before. + +The tendency to treasure the relics of a beloved person, more especially +the garments, is the simplest and commonest foundation of erotic +symbolism. It is without doubt absolutely normal. It is inevitable that +those objects which have been in close contact with the beloved person's +body, and are intimately associated with that person in the lover's mind, +should possess a little of the same virtue, the same emotional potency. It +is a phenomenon closely analogous to that by which the relics of saints +are held to possess a singular virtue. But it becomes somewhat less normal +when the garment is regarded as essential even in the presence of the +beloved person.[10] + +While an extremely large number of objects and acts may be found to +possess occasionally the value of erotic symbols, such symbols most +frequently fall into certain well-defined groups. A vast number of +isolated objects or acts may be exceptionally the focus of erotic +contemplation, but the objects and acts which frequently become thus +symbolic are comparatively few. + +It seems to me that the phenomena of erotic symbolism may be most +conveniently grouped in three great classes, on the basis of the objects +or acts which arouse them. + +I. PARTS OF THE BODY.--_A. Normal:_ Hand, foot, breasts, nates, hair, +secretions and excretions, etc. + +_B. Abnormal:_ Lameness, squinting, pitting of smallpox, etc. Paidophilia +or the love of children, presbyophilia or the love of the aged, and +necrophilia or the attraction for corpses, may be included under this +head, as well as the excitement caused by various animals. + + +II. INANIMATE OBJECTS.[11]--_A. Garments:_ Gloves, shoes and stockings and +garters, caps, aprons, handkerchiefs, underlinen. + +_B. Impersonal Objects:_ Here may be included all the various objects that +may accidentally acquire the power of exciting sexual feeling in +auto-erotism. Pygmalionism may also be included. + + +III. ACTS AND ATTITUDES.--_A. Active:_ Whipping, cruelty, exhibitionism. +_B. Passive:_ Being whipped, experiencing cruelty. Personal odors and the +sound of the voice may be included under this head. _C. Mixoscopic:_ The +vision of climbing, swinging, etc. The acts of urination and defecation. +The coitus of animals. + +Although the three main groups into which the phenomena of erotic +symbolism are here divided may seem fairly distinct, they are yet very +closely allied, and indeed overlap, so that it is possible, as we shall +see, for a single complex symbol to fall into all three groups. + +A very complete kind of erotic symbolism is furnished by Pygmalionism or +the love of statues.[12] It is exactly analogous to the child's love of a +doll, which is also a form of sexual (though not erotic) symbolism. In a +somewhat less abnormal form, erotic symbolism probably shows itself in its +simplest shape in the tendency to idealize unbeautiful peculiarities in a +beloved person, so that such peculiarities are ever afterward almost or +quite essential in order to arouse sexual attraction. In this way men have +become attracted to limping women. Even the most normal man may idealize a +trifling defect in a beloved woman. The attention is inevitably +concentrated on any such slight deviation from regular beauty, and the +natural result of such concentration is that a complexus of associated +thoughts and emotions becomes attached to something that in itself is +unbeautiful. A defect becomes an admired focus of attention, the embodied +symbol of the lover's emotion. + + Thus a mole is not in itself beautiful, but by the tendency to + erotic symbolism it becomes so. Persian poets especially have + lavished the richest imagery on moles (_Anis El-Ochchâq_ in + _Bibliothèque des Hautes Etudes_, fasc, 25, 1875); the Arabs, as + Lane remarks (_Arabian Society in the Middle Ages_, p. 214), are + equally extravagant in their admiration of a mole. + + Stendhal long since well described the process by which a defect + becomes a sexual symbol. "Even little defects in a woman's face," + he remarked, "such as a smallpox pit, may arouse the tenderness + of a man who loves her, and throw him into deep reverie when he + sees them in another woman. It is because he has experienced a + thousand feelings in the presence of that smallpox mark, that + these feelings have been for the most part delicious, all of the + highest interest, and that, whatever they may have been, they are + renewed with incredible vivacity on the sight of this sign, even + when perceived on the face of another woman. If in such a case we + come to prefer and love _ugliness_, it is only because in such a + case ugliness is beauty. A man loved a woman who was very thin + and marked by smallpox; he lost her by death. Three years later, + in Rome, he became acquainted with two women, one very beautiful, + the other thin and marked by smallpox, on that account, if you + will, rather ugly. I saw him in love with this plain one at the + end of a week, which he had employed in effacing her plainness by + his memories." (_De l'Amour_, Chapter XVII.) + +In the tendency to idealize the unbeautiful features of a beloved person +erotic symbolism shows itself in a simple and normal form. In a less +simple and more morbid form it appears in persons in whom the normal paths +of sexual gratification are for some reasons inhibited, and who are thus +led to find the symbols of natural love in unnatural perversions. It is +for this reason that so many erotic symbolisms take root in childhood and +puberty, before the sexual instincts have reached full development. It is +for the same reason also, that, at the other end of life, when the sexual +energies are failing, erotic symbols sometimes tend to be substituted for +the normal pleasures of sex. It is for this reason, again, that both men +and women whose normal energies are inhibited sometimes find the symbols +of sexual gratification in the caresses of children. + + The case of a schoolmistress recorded by Penta instructively + shows how an erotic symbolism of this last kind may develop by no + means as a refinement of vice, but as the one form in which + sexual gratification becomes possible when normal gratification + has been pathologically inhibited. F.R., aged 48, schoolmistress; + she was some years ago in an asylum with religious mania, but + came out well in a few months. At the age of 12 she had first + experienced sexual excitement in a railway train from the jolting + of the carriage. Soon after she fell in love with a youth who + represented her ideal and who returned her affection. When, + however, she gave herself to him, great was her disillusion and + surprise to find that the sexual act which she had looked forward + to could not be accomplished, for at the first contact there was + great pain and spasmodic resistance of the vagina. There was a + condition of vaginismus. After repeated attempts on subsequent + occasions her lover desisted. Her desire for intercourse + increased, however, rather than diminished, and at last she was + able to tolerate coitus, but the pain was so great that she + acquired a horror of the sexual embrace and no longer sought it. + Having much will power, she restrained all erotic impulses during + many years. It was not until the period of the menopause that the + long repressed desires broke out, and at last found a symbolical + outlet that was no longer normal, but was felt to supply a + complete gratification. She sought the close physical contact of + the young children in her care. She would lie on her bed naked, + with two or three naked children, make them suck her breasts and + press them to every part of her body. Her conduct was discovered + by means of other children who peeped through the keyhole, and + she was placed under Penta for treatment. In this case the loss + of moral and mental inhibition, due probably to troubles of the + climacteric, led to indulgence, under abnormal conditions, in + those primitive contacts which are normally the beginning of + love, and these, supported by the ideal image of the early lover, + constituted a complete and adequate symbol of natural love in a + morbidly perverted individual. (P. Penta, _Archivio delle + Psicopatie Sessuali_, January, 1896.) + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[1] The term "erotic symbolism" has already been employed by Eulenburg +(_Sexuale Neuropathie_, 1895, p. 101). It must be borne in mind that this +term, implying the specific emotion, is much narrower than the term +"sexual symbolism," which may be used to designate a great variety of +ritual and social practices which have played a part in the evolution of +civilization. + +[2] _Sexual Selection in Man_, iv, "Vision." + +[3] K. Groos, _Der Æsthetische Genuss_, p. 122. The psychology of the +associations of contiguity and resemblance through which erotic symbolism +operates its transference is briefly discussed by Ribot in the _Psychology +of the Emotions_, Part 1, Chapter XII; the early chapters of the same +author's _Logique des Sentiments_ may also be said to deal with the +emotional basis on which erotic symbolism arises. + +[4] A number of synonyms for the female pudenda are brought together by +Schurig--cunnus, hortus, concha, navis, fovea, larva, canis, annulus, +focus, cymba, antrum, delta, myrtus, etc.--and he discusses many of them. +(_Muliebria_, Section I, cap. I.) + +[5] Kleinpaul, _Sprache Ohne Worte_, pp. 24-29; cf. K. Pearson, on the +general and special words for sex, _Chances of Death_, vol. ii, pp. +112-245; a selection of the literature of the rose will be found in a +volume of translations entitled _Ros Rosarum_. + +[6] G.S. Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. i, p. 470. + +[7] Goron, _Les Parias de l'Amour_, p. 45. + +[8] A.R. Reynolds, _Medical Standard_, vol. x, cited by Kiernan, +"Responsibility in Sexual Perversion," _American Journal of Neurology and +Psychiatry_, 1882. + +[9] R. Burton, _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. II, +Subs. II, and Mem. III, Subs. I. + +[10] Numerous examples are given by Moll, _Konträre Sexualempfindung_, +third edition, pp. 265-268. + +[11] Chevalier (_De l'Inversion_, 1885; id., _L'Inversion Sexuelle_, 1892, +p. 52), followed by E. Laurent (_L'Amour Morbide_, 1891, Chapter X), +separates this group from other fetichistic perversions, under the head of +"azoöphilie." I see no adequate ground for this step. The various forms of +fetichism are too intimately associated to permit of any group of them +being violently separated from the others. + +[12] This has already been considered as a perversion founded on vision, +in discussing _Sexual Selection in Man_. IV. + + + + +II. + +Foot-fetichism and Shoe-fetichism--Wide Prevalence and Normal +Basis--Restif de la Bretonne--The Foot a Normal Focus of Sexual Attraction +Among Some Peoples--The Chinese, Greeks, Romans, Spaniards, etc.--The +Congenital Predisposition in Erotic Symbolism--The Influence of Early +Association and Emotional Shock--Shoe-fetichism in Relation to +Masochism--The Two Phenomena Independent Though Allied--The Desire to be +Trodden On--The Fascination of Physical Constraint--The Symbolism of +Self-inflicted Pain--The Dynamic Element in Erotic Symbolism--The +Symbolism of Garments. + + +Of all forms of erotic symbolism the most frequent is that which idealizes +the foot and the shoe. The phenomena we here encounter are sometimes so +complex and raise so many interesting questions that it is necessary to +discuss them somewhat fully. + +It would seem that even for the normal lover the foot is one of the most +attractive parts of the body. Stanley Hall found that among the parts +specified as most admired in the other sex by young men and women who +answered a _questionnaire_ the feet came fourth (after the eyes, hair, +stature and size).[13] Casanova, an acute student and lover of women who +was in no degree a foot fetichist, remarks that all men who share his +interest in women are attracted by their feet; they offer the same +interest, he considers, as the question of the particular edition offers +to the book-lover.[14] + + In a report of the results of a _questionnaire_ concerning + children's sense of self, to which over 500 replies were + received, Stanley Hall thus summarizes the main facts ascertained + with reference to the feet: "A special period of noticing the + feet comes somewhat later than that in which the hands are + discovered to consciousness. Our records afford nearly twice as + many cases for feet as for hands. The former are more remote from + the primary psychic focus or position, and are also more often + covered, so that the sight of them is a more marked and + exceptional event. Some children become greatly excited whenever + their feet are exposed. Some infants show signs of fear at the + movement of their own knees and feet covered, and still more + often fright is the first sensation which signalizes the child's + discovery of its feet.... Many are described as playing with them + as if fascinated by strange, newly-discovered toys. They pick + them up and try to throw them away, or out of the cradle, or + bring them to the mouth, where all things tend to go.... Children + often handle their feet, pat and stroke them, offer them toys and + the bottle, as if they, too, had an independent hunger to + gratify, an _ego_ of their own.... Children often develop [later] + a special interest in the feet of others, and examine, feel them, + etc., sometimes expressing surprise that the pinch of the + mother's toe hurts her and not the child, or comparing their own + and the feet of others point by point. Curious, too, are the + intensifications of foot-consciousness throughout the early years + of childhood, whenever children have the exceptional privilege of + going barefoot, or have new shoes. The feet are often + apostrophized, punished, beaten sometimes to the point of pain + for breaking things, throwing the child down, etc. Several + children have habits, which reach great intensity, and then + vanish, of touching or tickling the feet, with gales of laughter, + and a few are described as showing an almost morbid reluctance to + wear anything upon the feet, or even to having them touched by + others.... Several almost fall in love with the great toe or the + little one, especially admiring some crease or dimple in it, + dressing it in some rag of silk or bit of ribbon, or cut-off + glove fingers, winding it with string, prolonging it by tying on + bits of wood. Stroking the feet of others, especially if they are + shapely, often becomes almost a passion with young children, and + several adults confess a survival of the same impulse which it is + an exquisite pleasure to gratify. The interest of some mothers in + babies' toes, the expressions of which are ecstatic and almost + incredible, is a factor of great importance." (G. Stanley Hall, + "Some Aspects of the Early Sense of Self," _American Journal of + Psychology_, April, 1898.) In childhood, Stanley Hall remarks + elsewhere (_Adolescence_, vol. ii, p. 104), "a form of courtship + may consist solely in touching feet under the desk." It would + seem that even animals have a certain amount of sexual + consciousness in the feet; I have noticed a male donkey, just + before coitus, bite the feet of his partner. + +At the same time it is scarcely usual for the normal lover, in most +civilized countries to-day, to attach primary importance to the foot, such +as he very frequently attaches to the eyes, though the feet play a very +conspicuous part in the work of certain novelists.[15] + +In a small but not inconsiderable minority of persons, however, the foot +or the boot becomes the most attractive part of a woman, and in some +morbid cases the woman herself is regarded as a comparatively unimportant +appendage to her feet or her boots. The boots under civilized conditions +much more frequently constitute the sexual symbol than do the feet +themselves; this is not surprising since in ordinary life the feet are not +often seen. + + It is usually only under exceptionally favoring conditions that + foot-fetichism occurs, as in the case recorded by Marandon de + Montyel of a doctor who had been brought up in the West Indies. + His mother had been insane and he himself was subject to + obsessions, especially of being incapable of urinating; he had + had nocturnal incontinence of urine in childhood. All the women + of the people in the West Indies go about with naked feet, which + are often beautiful. His puberty evolved under this influence, + and foot-fetichism developed. He especially admired large, fat, + arched feet, with delicate skin and large, regular toes. He + masturbated with images of feet. At 15 he had relations with a + colored chambermaid, but feared to mention his fetichism, though + it was the touch of her feet that chiefly excited him. He now + gave up masturbation, and had a succession of mistresses, but was + always ashamed to confess his fancies until, at the age of 33, in + Paris, a very intelligent woman who had become his mistress + discovered his mania and skillfully enabled him to yield to it + without shock to his modesty. He was devoted to this mistress, + who had very beautiful feet (he had been horrified by the feet of + Europeans generally), until she finally left him. (_Archives de + Neurologie_, October, 1904.) + + Probably the first case of shoe-fetichism ever recorded in any + detail is that of Restif de la Bretonne (1734-1806), publicist + and novelist, one of the most remarkable literary figures of the + later eighteenth century in France. Restif was a neurotic + subject, though not to an extreme degree, and his shoe-fetichism, + though distinctly pronounced, was not pathological; that is to + say, that the shoe was not itself an adequate gratification of + the sexual impulse, but simply a highly important aid to + tumescence, a prelude to the natural climax of detumescence; only + occasionally, and _faute de mieux_, in the absence of the beloved + person, was the shoe used as an adjunct to masturbation. In + Restif's stories and elsewhere the attraction of the shoe is + frequently discussed or used as a motive. His first decided + literary success, _Le Pied de Fanchette_, was suggested by a + vision of a girl with a charming foot, casually seen in the + street. While all such passages in his books are really founded + on his own personal feelings and experiences, in his elaborate + autobiography, _Monsieur Nicolas_, he has frankly set forth the + gradual evolution and cause of his idiosyncrasy. The first + remembered trace dated from the age of 4, when he was able to + recall having remarked the feet of a young girl in his native + place. Restif was a sexually precocious youth, and at the age of + 9, though both delicate in health and shy in manners, his + thoughts were already absorbed in the girls around him. "While + little Monsieur Nicolas," he tells us, "passed for a Narcissus, + his thoughts, as soon as he was alone, by night or by day, had no + other object than that sex he seemed to flee from. The girls most + careful of their persons were naturally those who pleased him + most, and as the part least easy to keep clean is that which + touches the earth it was to the foot-gear that he mechanically + gave his chief attention. Agathe, Reine, and especially + Madeleine, were the most elegant of the girls at that time; their + carefully selected and kept shoes, instead of laces or buckles, + which were not yet worn at Sacy, had blue or rose ribbon, + according to the color of the skirt. I thought of these girls + with emotion; I desired--I knew not what; but I desired + something, if it were only to subdue them." The origin Restif + here assigns to his shoe-fetichism may seem paradoxical; he + admired the girls who were most clean and neat in their dress, he + tells us, and, therefore, paid most attention to that part of + their clothing which was least clean and neat. But, however + paradoxical the remark may seem, it is psychologically sound. All + fetichism is a kind of not necessarily morbid obsession, and as + the careful work of Janet and others in that field has shown, an + obsession is a fascinated attraction to some object or idea + which gives the subject a kind of emotional shock by its + contrast to his habitual moods or ideas. The ordinary morbid + obsession cannot usually be harmoniously co-ordinated with the + other experiences of the subject's daily life, and shows, + therefore, no tendency to become pleasurable. Sexual fetichisms, + on the other hand, have a reservoir of agreeable emotion to draw + on, and are thus able to acquire both stability and harmony. It + will also be seen that no element of masochism is involved in + Restif's fetichism, though the mistake has been frequently made + of supposing that these two manifestations are usually or even + necessarily allied. Restif wishes to subject the girl who + attracts him, he has no wish to be subjected by her. He was + especially dazzled by a young girl from another town, whose shoes + were of a fashionable cut, with buckles, "and who was a charming + person besides." She was delicate as a fairy, and rendered his + thoughts unfaithful to the robust beauties of his native Sacy. + "No doubt," he remarks, "because, being frail and weak myself, it + seemed to me that it would be easier to subdue her." "This taste + for the beauty of the feet," he continues, "was so powerful in me + that it unfailingly aroused desire and would have made me + overlook ugliness. It is excessive in all those who have it." He + admired the foot as well as the shoe: "The factitious taste for + the shoe is only a reflection of that for pretty feet. When I + entered a house and saw the boots arranged in a row, as is the + custom, I would tremble with pleasure; I blushed and lowered my + eyes as if in the presence of the girls themselves. With this + vivacity of feeling and a voluptuousness of ideas inconceivable + at the age of 10 I still fled, with an involuntary impulse of + modesty, from the girls I adored." + + We may clearly see how this combination of sensitive and + precocious sexual ardor with extreme shyness, furnished the soil + on which the germ of shoe-fetichism was able to gain a firm root + and persist in some degree throughout a long life very largely + given up to a pursuit of women, abnormal rather by its + excessiveness than its perversity. A few years later, he tells + us, he happened to see a pretty pair of shoes in a bootmaker's + shop, and on hearing that they belonged to a girl whom at that + time he reverently adored at a distance he blushed and nearly + fainted. + + In 1749 he was for a time attracted to a young woman very much + older than himself; he secretly carried away one of her slippers + and kept it for a day; a little later he again took away a shoe + of the same woman which had fascinated him when on her foot, and, + he seems to imply, he used it to masturbate with. + + Perhaps the chief passion of Restif's life was his love for + Colette Parangon. He was still a boy (1752), she was the young + and virtuous wife of the printer whose apprentice Restif was and + in whose house he lived. Madame Parangon, a charming woman, as + she is described, was not happily married, and she evidently + felt a tender affection for the boy whose excessive love and + reverence for her were not always successfully concealed. + "Madonna Parangon," he tells us, "possessed a charm which I could + never resist, a pretty little foot; it is a charm which arouses + more than tenderness. Her shoes, made in Paris, had that + voluptuous elegance which seems to communicate soul and life. + Sometimes Colette wore shoes of simple white drugget or with + silver flowers; sometimes rose-colored slippers with green heels, + or green with rose heels; her supple feet, far from deforming her + shoes, increased their grace and rendered the form more + exciting." One day, on entering the house, he saw Madame Parangon + elegantly dressed and wearing rose-colored shoes with tongues, + and with green heels and a pretty rosette. They were new and she + took them off to put on green slippers with rose heels and + borders which he thought equally exciting. As soon as she had + left the room, he continues, "carried away by the most impetuous + passion and idolizing Colette, I seemed to see her and touch her + in handling what she had just worn; my lips pressed one of these + jewels, while the other, deceiving the sacred end of nature, from + excess of exaltation replaced the object of sex (I cannot express + myself more clearly). The warmth which she had communicated to + the insensible object which had touched her still remained and + gave a soul to it; a voluptuous cloud covered my eyes." He adds + that he would kiss with rage and transport whatever had come in + close contact with the woman he adored, and on one occasion + eagerly pressed his lips to her cast-off underlinen, _vela + secretiora penetralium_. + + At this period Restif's foot-fetichism reached its highest point + of development. It was the aberration of a highly sensitive and + very precocious boy. While the preoccupation with feet and shoes + persisted throughout life, it never became a complete perversion + and never replaced the normal end of sexual desire. His love for + Madam Parangon, one of the deepest emotions in his whole life, + was also the climax of his shoe-fetichism. She represented his + ideal woman, an ethereal sylph with wasp-waist and a child's + feet; it was always his highest praise for a woman that she + resembled Madame Parangon, and he desired that her slipper should + be buried with him. (Restif de la Bretonne, _Monsieur Nicolas_, + vols. i-iv, vol. xiii, p. 5; id., _Mes Inscriptions_, pp. ci-cv.) + + Shoe-fetichism, more especially if we include under this term all + the cases of real or pseudo-masochism in which an attraction to + the boots or slippers is the chief feature, is a not infrequent + phenomenon, and is certainly the most frequently occurring form + of fetichism. Many cases are brought together by Krafft-Ebing in + his _Psychopathia Sexualis_. Every prostitute of any experience + has known men who merely desire to gaze at her shoes, or possibly + to lick them, and who are quite willing to pay for this + privilege. In London such a person is known as a "bootman," in + Germany as a "Stiefelfrier." + +The predominance of the foot as a focus of sexual attraction, while among +us to-day it is a not uncommon phenomenon, is still not sufficiently +common to be called normal; the majority of even ardent lovers do not +experience this attraction in any marked degree. But these manifestations +of foot-fetichism which with us to-day are abnormal, even when they are +not so extreme as to be morbid, may perhaps become more intelligible to us +when we realize that in earlier periods of civilization, and even to-day +in some parts of the world, the foot is generally recognized as a focus of +sexual attraction, so that some degree of foot-fetichism becomes a normal +phenomenon. + +The most pronounced and the best known example of such normal +foot-fetichism at the present day is certainly to be found among the +Southern Chinese. For a Chinese husband his wife's foot is more +interesting than her face. A Chinese woman is as shy of showing her feet +to a man as a European woman her breasts; they are reserved for her +husband's eyes alone, and to look at a woman's feet in the street is +highly improper and indelicate. Chinese foot-fetichism is connected with +the custom of compressing the feet. This custom appears to rest on the +fact that Chinese women naturally possess a very small foot and is thus an +example of the universal tendency in the search for beauty to accentuate, +even by deformation, the racial characteristics. But there is more than +this. Beauty is largely a name for sexual attractiveness, and the energy +expended in the effort to make the Chinese woman's small foot still +smaller is a measure of the sexual fascination which it exerts. The +practice arose on the basis of the sexual attractiveness of the foot, +though it has doubtless served to heighten that attractiveness, just as +the small waist, which (if we may follow Stratz) is a characteristic +beauty of the European woman, becomes to the average European man still +more attractive when accentuated, even to the extent of deformity, by the +compression of the corset. + + Referring to the sexual fascination exerted by the foot in China, + Matignon writes: "My attention has been drawn to this point by a + large number of pornographic engravings, of which the Chinese are + very fond. In all these lascivious scenes we see the male + voluptuously fondling the woman's foot. When a Celestial takes + into his hand a woman's foot, especially if it is very small, the + effect upon him is precisely the same as is provoked in a + European by the palpation of a young and firm bosom. All the + Celestials whom I have interrogated on this point have replied + unanimously: 'Oh, a little foot! You Europeans cannot understand + how exquisite, how sweet, how exciting it is!' The contact of the + genital organ with the little foot produces in the male an + indescribable degree of voluptuous feeling, and women skilled in + love know that to arouse the ardor of their lovers a better + method than all Chinese aphrodisiacs--including 'giusen' and + swallows' nests--is to take the penis between their feet. It is + not rare to find Chinese Christians accusing themselves at + confession of having had 'evil thoughts on looking at a woman's + foot.'" (Dr. J. Matignon, "A propos d'un Pied de Chinoise," + _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, 1898.) + + It is said that a Chinese Empress, noted for her vice and having + a congenital club foot, about the year 1100 B.C., desired all + women to resemble her, and that the practice of compressing the + foot thus arose. But this is only tradition, since, in 300 B.C., + Chinese books were destroyed (Morache, Art. "Chine," + _Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des Sciences Médicales_, p. 191). It + is also said that the practice owes its origin to the wish to + keep women indoors. But women are not secluded in China, nor does + foot compression usually render a woman unable to walk. Many + intelligent Chinese are of opinion that its object is to promote + the development of the sexual parts and of the thighs, and so to + aid both intercourse and parturition. There is no ground for + believing that it has any such influence, though Morache found + that the mons veneris and labia are largely developed in Chinese + women, and not in Tartar women living in Pekin (who do not + compress the foot). If there is any correlation between the feet + and the pelvic regions, it is more probably congenital than due + to the artificial compression of the feet. The ancients seem to + have believed that a small foot indicated a small vagina. Restif + de la Bretonne, who had ample opportunities for forming an + opinion on a matter in which he took so great an interest, + believed that a small foot, round and short, indicated a large + vagina (_Monsieur Nicolas_, vol. i, reprint of 1883, p. 92). + Even, however, if we admit that there is a real correlation + between the foot and the vagina, that would by no means suffice + to render the foot a focus of sexual attraction. + + It remains the most reasonable view that the foot bandage must be + regarded as strictly analogous to the waist bandage or corset + which also tends to produce deformity of the constricted region. + Stratz has ingeniously remarked (_Frauenkleidung_, third edition, + p. 101) that the success of the Chinese in dwarfing trees may + have suggested a similar attempt in regard to women's feet, and + adds that in any case both dwarfed trees and bound feet bear + witness in the Mongolian to the same love for small and elegant, + not to say deformed, things. For a Chinaman the deformed foot is + a "golden water-lily." + + Many facts (together with illustrations) bearing on Chinese + deformation of the foot will be found in Ploss, _Das Weib_, vol. + i, Section IV. + +The significance of the sexual emotion aroused by the female foot in China +and the origin of its compression begin to become clear when we realize +that this foot-fetichism is merely an extreme development of a tendency +which is fairly well marked among nearly all the peoples of yellow race. +Jacoby, who has brought together a number of interesting facts bearing on +the sexual significance of the foot, states that a similar tendency is to +be found among the Mongol and Turk peoples of Siberia, and in the east and +central parts of European Russia, among the Permiaks, the Wotiaks, etc. +Here the woman, at all events when young, has always her feet, as well as +head, covered, however little clothing she may otherwise wear. + + "On hot nights or on baking days," Jacoby states, "you may see + these women with uncovered breasts, or even entirely naked + without embarrassment, but you will never see them with bare + feet, and no male relations, except the husband, will ever see + the feet and lower part of the legs of the women in the house. + These women have their modesty in their feet, and also their + coquetry; to unbind the feet of a woman is for a man a voluptuous + act, and the touch of the bands produces the same effect as a + corset still warm from a woman's body on a European man. A + woman's beauty, that which attracts and excites a man, lies in + her foot; in Mordvin love poems celebrating the beauty of women + there is much about her attire, especially her embroidered + chemise, but as regards the charms of her person the poet is + content to state that 'her feet are beautiful;' with that + everything is said. The young peasant woman of the central + provinces as part of her holiday raiment puts on great woolen + stockings which come up to the groin and are then folded over to + below the knee. To uncover the feet of a person of the opposite + sex is a sexual act, and has thus become the symbol of sexual + possession, so that the stocking or foot-gear became the emblem + of marriage, as later the ring. (It was so among the Jews, as we + see in the book of _Ruth_, Chapter III, v. 4, and Chapter IV, vv. + 7 and 8). St. Vladimir the Great asked in marriage the daughter + of Prince Rogvold; as Vladimir's mother had been a serf, the + princess proudly replied that she 'would not uncover the feet of + a slave.' At the present time in the east of Russia when a young + girl tries to find out by divination whom she will have as a + husband the traditional formula is 'Come and take my stockings + off.' Among the populations of the north and east, it is + sometimes the bride who must do this for her husband on the + wedding night, and sometimes the bridegroom for his wife, not as + a token of love, but as a nuptial ceremony. Among the + professional classes and small nobility in Russia parents place + money in the stocking of their child at marriage as a present for + the other partner, it being supposed that the couple mutually + remove each other's foot raiment, as an act of sexual possession, + the emblem of coitus." (Paul Jacoby, _Archives d'Anthropologie + Criminelle_, December, 1903, p. 793.) The practice among + ourselves of children hanging up their stockings at night for + presents would seem to be a relic of the last-mentioned custom. + +While we may witness the sexual symbolism of the foot, with or without an +associated foot-fetichism, most highly developed in Asia and Eastern +Europe, it has by no means been altogether unknown in some stages of +western civilization, and traces of it may be found here and there even +yet. Schinz refers to the connection between the feet and sexual pleasure +as existing not only among the Egyptians and the Arabs, but among the +ancient Germans and the modern Spaniards,[16] while Jacoby points out that +among the Greeks, the Romans, and especially the Etruscans, it was usual +to represent chaste and virgin goddesses with their feet covered, even +though they might be otherwise nude. Ovid, again, is never weary of +dwelling on the sexual charm of the feminine foot. He represents the +chaste matron as wearing a weighted _stola_ which always fell so as to +cover her feet; it was only the courtesan, or the nymph who is taking part +in an erotic festival, who appears with raised robes, revealing her +feet.[17] So grave a historian as Strabo, as well as Ælian, refers to the +story of the courtesan Rhodope whose sandal was carried off by an eagle +and dropped in the King of Egypt's lap as he was administering justice, so +that he could not rest until he had discovered to whom this delicately +small sandal belonged, and finally made her his queen. Kleinpaul, who +repeats this story, has collected many European sayings and customs +(including Turkish), indicating that the slipper is a very ancient symbol +of a woman's sexual parts.[18] + + In Rome, Dufour remarks, "Matrons having appropriated the use of + the shoe (_soccus_) prostitutes were not allowed to use it, and + were obliged to have their feet always naked in sandals or + slippers (_crepida_ and _solea_), which they fastened over the + instep with gilt bands. Tibullus delights to describe his + mistress's little foot, compressed by the band that imprisoned + it: _Ansaque compressos colligat arcta pedes_. Nudity of the foot + in woman was a sign of prostitution, and their brilliant + whiteness acted afar as a pimp to attract looks and desires." + (Dufour, _Histoire de la Prostitution_, vol. II., ch. xviii.) + + This feeling seems to have survived in a more or less vague and + unconscious form in mediæval Europe. "In the tenth century," + according to Dufour (_Histoire de la Prostitution_, vol. VI., p. + 11), "shoes _a la poulaine_, with a claw or beak, pursued for + more than four centuries by the anathemas of popes and the + invectives of preachers, were always regarded by mediæval + casuists as the most abominable emblems of immodesty. At a first + glance it is not easy to see why these shoes--terminating in a + lion's claw, an eagle's beak, the prow of a ship, or other metal + appendage--should be so scandalous. The excommunication inflicted + on this kind of foot-gear preceded the impudent invention of some + libertine, who wore _poulaines_ in the shape of the phallus, a + custom adopted also by women. This kind of _poulaine_ was + denounced as _mandite de Dicu_ (Ducange's Glossary, at the word + Poulainia) and prohibited by royal ordinances (see letter of + Charles V., 17 October, 1367, regarding the garments of the women + of Montpellier). Great lords and ladies continued, however, to + wear _poulaines_." In Louis XL's court they were still worn of a + quarter of an ell in length. + + Spain, ever tenacious of ancient ideas, appears to have preserved + longer than other countries the ancient classic traditions in + regard to the foot as a focus of modesty and an object of sexual + attraction. In Spanish religious pictures it was always necessary + that the Virgin's feet should be concealed, the clergy ordaining + that her robe should be long and flowing, so that the feet might + be covered with decent folds. Pacheco, the master and + father-in-law of Velasquez, writes in 1649 in his _Arte de la + Pintura_: "What can be more foreign from the respect which we owe + to the purity of Our Lady the Virgin than to paint her sitting + down with one of her knees placed over the other, and often with + her sacred feet uncovered and naked. Let thanks be given to the + Holy Inquisition which commands that this liberty should be + corrected!" It was Pacheco's duty in Seville to see that these + commands were obeyed. At the court of Philip IV. at this time the + princesses never showed their feet, as we may see in the pictures + of Velasquez. When a local manufacturer desired to present that + monarch's second bride, Mariana of Austria, with some silk + stockings the offer was indignantly rejected by the Court + Chamberlain: "The Queen of Spain has no legs!" Philip V.'s, queen + was thrown from her horse and dragged by the feet; no one + ventured to interfere until two gentlemen bravely rescued her and + then fled, dreading punishment by the king: they were, however, + graciously pardoned. Reinach ("Pieds Pudiques," _Cultes, Mythes + et Religions_, pp. 105-110) brings together several passages from + the Countess D'Aulnoy's account of the Madrid Court in the + seventeenth century and from other sources, showing how careful + Spanish ladies were as regards their feet, and how jealous + Spanish husbands were in this matter. At this time, when Spanish + influence was considerable, the fashion of Spain seems to have + spread to other countries. One may note that in Vandyck's + pictures of English beauties the feet are not visible, though in + the more characteristically English painters of a somewhat later + age it became usual to display them conspicuously, while the + French custom in this matter is the farthest removed from the + Spanish. At the present day a well-bred Spanish woman shows as + little as possible of her feet in walking, and even in some of + the most characteristic Spanish dances there is little or no + kicking, and the feet may even be invisible throughout. It is + noteworthy that in numerous figures of Spanish women (probably + artists' models) reproduced in Ploss's _Das Weib_ the stockings + are worn, although the women are otherwise, in most cases, quite + naked. Max Dessoir mentions ("Psychologie der Vita Sexualis," + _Zeitschrift für Psychiatrie_, 1894, p. 954) that in Spanish + pornographic photographs women always have their shoes on, and he + considers this an indication of perversity. I have seen the + statement (attributed to Gautier's _Voyage en Espagne_, where, + however, it does not occur) that Spanish prostitutes uncover + their feet in sign of assent, and Madame d'Aulnoy stated that in + her time to show her lover her feet was a Spanish woman's final + favor. + +The tendency, which we thus find to be normal at some earlier periods of +civilization, to insist on the sexual symbolism of the feminine foot or +its coverings, and to regard them as a special sexual fascination, is not +without significance for the interpretation of the sporadic manifestations +of foot-fetichism among ourselves. Eccentric as foot-fetichism may appear +to us, it is simply the re-emergence, by a pseudo-atavism or arrest of +development, of a mental or emotional impulse which was probably +experienced by our forefathers, and is often traceable among young +children to-day.[19] The occasional reappearance of this bygone impulse +and the stability which it may acquire are thus conditioned by the +sensitive reaction of an abnormally nervous and usually precocious +organism to influences which, among the average and ordinary population of +Europe to-day, are either never felt, or quickly outgrown, or very +strictly subordinated in the highly complex crystallizations which the +course of love and the process of tumescence create within us. + + It may be added that this is by no means true of foot-fetichism + only. In some other fetichisms a seemingly congenital + predisposition is even more marked. This is not only the case as + regards hair-fetichism and fur-fetichism (see, e.g., + Krafft-Ebing, _Psychopathia Sexualis_, English translation of + tenth edition, pp. 233, 255, 262). In many cases of fetichisms of + all kinds not only is there no record of any commencement in a + definite episode (an absence which may be accounted for by the + supposition that the original incident has been forgotten), but + it would seem in some cases that the fetichism developed very + slowly. + +In this sense, it will be seen, although it is hazardous to speak of +foot-fetichism as strictly an atavism, it may certainly be said to arise +on a congenital basis. It represents the rare development of an inborn +germ, usually latent among ourselves, which in earlier stages of +civilization frequently reached a normal and general fruition. + +It is of interest to emphasize this congenital element of foot symbolism, +because more than any other forms of sexual perversion the fetichisms are +those which are most vaguely conditioned by inborn states of the organism +and most definitely aroused by seemingly accidental associations or shocks +in early life. Inversion is sometimes so fundamentally ingrained in the +individual's constitution that it arises and develops in spite of the very +strongest influence in a contrary direction. But a fetichism, while it +tends to occur in sensitive, nervous, timid, precocious individuals--that +is to say, individuals of more or less neuropathic heredity--can usually, +though not always, be traced to a definite starting point in the shock of +some sexually emotional episode in early life. + + A few examples of the influences of such association may here be + given, referring miscellaneously to various forms of erotic + symbolism. Magnan has recorded the case of a hair-fetichist, + living in a district where the women wore their hair done up, who + at the age of 15 experienced pleasurable feelings with erection + at the sight of a village beauty combing her hair; from that time + flowing hair became his fetich, and he could not resist the + temptation to touch it and if possible sever it, thus becoming a + hair-despoiler, for which he was arrested but not sentenced. + (_Archives de l'Anthropologie Criminelle_, vol. v, No. 28.) + + I have elsewhere recorded the history of a boy of 14, having + already had imperfect connection with a grown-up woman, who + associated much with a young married lady; he had no sexual + relations with her, but one day she urinated in his presence, and + he saw that her mons veneris was covered by very thick hair; from + that time he worshiped this woman in secret and acquired a + life-long fetichistic attraction to women whose pubic hair was + similarly abundant (_Studies in the Psychology of Sex_, vol. iii, + Appendix B, History V). + + Roubaud reported the case of a general's son, sexually initiated + at the age of 14 by a blonde young lady of 21 who, in order to + avoid detection, always retained her clothing: gaiters, a corset + and a silk dress; when the boy's studies were completed and he + was sent to a garrison where he could enjoy freedom he found that + his sexual desires could only be aroused by blonde women dressed + like the lady who had first aroused his sexual desires; + consequently he gave up all thoughts of matrimony, as a woman in + nightclothes produced impotence (_Traité de l'Impuissance_, p. + 439). Krafft-Ebing records the somewhat similar case of a nervous + Polish boy of old family seduced at the age of 17 by a French + governess, who during several months practiced mutual + masturbation with him; in this way his attention became + attracted by her very elegant boots, and in the end he became a + confirmed boot-fetichist (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, English + translation, p. 249). + + A boy of 7, of bad heredity, was taught to masturbate by a + servant girl; on one occasion she practiced this on him with her + foot without taking off her shoe; it was the first time the + manoeuvre gave him any pleasure, and an association was thus + established which led to shoe-fetichism (Hammond, _Sexual + Impotence_, p. 44). A government official whose first coitus in + youth took place on a staircase; the sound of his partner's + creaking shoes against the stairs, produced by her efforts to + accelerate orgasm, formed an association which developed into an + auditory shoe-fetichism; in the streets he was compelled to + follow ladies whose shoes creaked, ejaculation being thus + produced, while to obtain complete satisfaction he would make a + prostitute, otherwise naked, sit in front of him in her shoes, + moving her feet so that the shoes creaked. (Moraglia, _Archivio + di Psichiatria_, vol. xiii, p. 568.) + + Bechterew, in St. Petersburg, has recorded the case of a man who + when a child used to fall asleep at the knees of his nurse with + his head buried in the folds of her apron; in this position he + first experienced erection and voluptuous sensations; when a + youth he had no attraction to naked women, and in real life and + in dreams was only excited sexually under conditions recalling + his early experience; in his relations with women he preferred + them dressed, and was excited by the rustling sound of their + skirts; in this case there was no traceable neuropathic taint nor + any other personal peculiarity. (Summarized in _Journal de + Psychologie Normale et Pathologique_, January-February, 1904, p. + 72.) + + In a curious case recorded in detail by Moll, a philologist of + sensitive temperament but sound heredity, who had always been + fond of flowers, at the age of 21 became engaged to a young lady + who wore large roses fastened in her jacket; from this time roses + became to him a sexual fetich, to kiss them caused erection, and + his erotic dreams were accompanied by visions of roses and the + hallucination of their odor; the engagement was finally broken + off and the rose-fetichism disappeared (_Untersuchungen über + Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 540). + +Such associations may naturally occur in the early experiences of even the +most normal persons. The degree to which they will influence the +subsequent life and thought and feeling depends on the degree of the +individual's morbid emotional receptivity, on the extent to which he is +hereditarily susceptible of abnormal deviation. Precocity is undoubtedly a +condition which favors such deviation; a child who is precociously and +abnormally sensitive to persons of the opposite sex before puberty has +established the normal channels of sexual desire, is peculiarly liable to +become the prey of a chance symbolism. All degrees of such symbolism are +possible. While the average insensitive person may fail to perceive them +at all, for the more alert and imaginative lover they are a fascinating +part of the highly charged crystallization of passion. A more nervously +exceptional person, when once such a symbolism has become firmly +implanted, may find it an absolutely essential element in the charm of a +beloved and charming person. Finally, for the individual who is thoroughly +unsound the symbol becomes generalized; a person is no longer desired at +all, being merely regarded as an appendage of the symbol, or being +dispensed with altogether; the symbol is alone desired, and is fully +adequate to impart by itself complete sexual gratification. While it must +be considered a morbid state to demand a symbol as an almost essential +part of the charm of a desired person, it is only in the final condition, +in which the symbol becomes all-sufficing, that we have a true and +complete perversion. In the less complete forms of symbolism it is still +the woman who is desired, and the ends of procreation may be served; when +the woman is ignored and the mere symbol is an adequate and even preferred +stimulus to detumescence the pathological condition becomes complete. + +Krafft-Ebing regarded shoe-fetichism as, in large measure, a more or less +latent form of masochism, the foot or the shoe being the symbol of the +subjection and humiliation which the masochist feels in the presence of +the beloved object. Moll is also inclined to accept such a connection. + + "The very numerous class of boot-and-shoe-fetichists," + Krafft-Ebing wrote, "forms the transition to the manifestations + of another independent perversion, i.e., fetichism itself; but it + stands in closer relationship to the former.... It is highly + probable, and shown by a correct classification of the observed + cases, that the majority, and perhaps all of the cases of + shoe-fetichism, rest upon a basis of more or less conscious + masochistic desire for self-humiliation.... The majority or all + may be looked upon as instances of latent masochism (the motive + remaining unconscious) in which the _female foot or shoe, as the + masochist's fetich_, has acquired an independent significance." + (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, English translation of tenth edition, + pp. 159, et seq.) "Though Krafft-Ebing may not have cleared up + the whole matter," Moll remarks, "I regard his deductions + concerning the connection of foot-and-shoe fetichism to masochism + as the most important progress that has been made in the + theoretic study of sexual perversions.... In any case, the + connection is very frequent." (_Konträre Sexualempfindung_, third + edition, p. 306.) + +It is quite easy to see that this supposed identity of masochism and +foot-fetichism forms a seductive theory. It is also undoubtedly true that +a masochist may very easily be inclined to find in his mistress's foot an +aid to the ecstatic self-abnegation which he desires to attain.[20] But +only confusion is attained by any general attempt to amalgamate masochism +and foot-fetichism. In the broad sense in which erotic symbolism is here +understood, both masochism and foot-fetichism may be coördinated as +symbolisms; for the masochist his self-humiliating impulses are the symbol +of ecstatic adoration; for the foot-fetichist his mistress's foot or shoe +is the concentrated symbol of all that is most beautiful and elegant and +feminine in her personality. But if in this sense they are coördinated, +they remain entirely distinct and have not even any necessary tendency to +become merged. Masochism merely simulates foot-fetichism; for the +masochist the boot is not strictly a symbol, it is only an instrument +which enables him to carry out his impulse; the true sexual symbol for him +is not the boot, but the emotion of self-subjection. For the +foot-fetichist, on the other hand, the foot or the shoe is not a mere +instrument, but a true symbol; the focus of his worship, an idealized +object which he is content to contemplate or reverently touch. He has no +necessary impulse to any self-degrading action, nor any constant emotion +of subjection. It may be noted that in the very typical case of +foot-fetichism which is presented to us in the person of Restif de la +Bretonne (_ante_, p. 18), he repeatedly speaks of "subjecting" the woman +for whom he feels this fetichistic adoration, and mentions that even when +still a child he especially admired a delicate and fairy-like girl in this +respect because she seemed to him easier to subjugate. Throughout life +Restif's attitude toward women was active and masculine, without the +slightest trace of masochism.[21] + +To suppose that a fetichistic admiration of his mistress's foot is due to +a lover's latent desire to be kicked, is as unreasonable as it would be to +suppose that a fetichistic admiration for her hand indicated a latent +desire to have his ears boxed. In determining whether we are concerned +with a case of foot-fetichism or of masochism we must take into +consideration the whole of the subject's mental and emotional attitude. An +act, however definite, will not suffice as a criterion, for the same act +in different persons may have altogether different implications. To +amalgamate the two is the result of inadequate psychological analysis and +only leads to confusion. + +It is, however, often very difficult to decide whether we are dealing with +a case which is predominantly one of masochism or of foot-fetichism. The +nature of the action desired, as we have seen, will not suffice to +determine the psychological character of the perversion. Krafft-Ebing +believed that the desire to be trodden on, very frequently experienced by +masochists, is absolutely symptomatic of masochism.[22] This is scarcely +the case. The desire to be trodden on may be fundamentally an erotic +symbolism, closely approaching foot-fetichism, and such slight indications +of masochism as appear may be merely a parasitic growth on the symbolism, +a growth perhaps more suggested by the circumstances involved in the +gratification of the abnormal desire than inherent in the innate impulse +of the subject. This may be illustrated by the interesting case of a very +intelligent man with whom I am well acquainted. + + C.P., aged 38. Heredity good. Parents both healthy and normal. + Several children of the marriage, all sexually normal so far as + is known. C.P. is the youngest of the family and separated from + the others by an interval of many years. He was a seven-months' + child. He has always enjoyed good health and is active and + vigorous, both mentally and physically. + + From the age of 9 or 10 to 14 he masturbated occasionally for the + sake of physical relief, having discovered the act for himself. + He was, however, quite innocent and knew nothing of sexual + matters, never having been initiated either by servants or by + other boys. + + "When I encounter a woman who very strongly attracts me and whom + I very greatly admire," he writes, "my desire is never that I may + have sexual connection with her in the ordinary sense, but that I + may lie down upon the floor on my back and be trampled upon by + her. This curious desire is seldom present unless the object of + my admiration is really a lady, and of fine proportions. She must + be richly dressed--preferably in an evening gown, and wear dainty + high-heeled slippers, either quite open so as to show the curve + of the instep, or with only one strap or 'bar' across. The skirts + should be raised sufficiently to afford me the pleasure of seeing + her feet and a liberal amount of ankle, but in no case above the + knee, or the effect is greatly reduced. Although I often greatly + admire a woman's intellect and even person, sexually no other + part of her has any serious attraction for me except the leg, + from the knee downwards, and the foot, and these must be + exquisitely clothed. Given this condition, my desire amounts to a + wish to gratify my sexual sense by contact with the (to me) + attractive part of the woman. Comparatively few women have a leg + or foot sufficiently beautiful to my mind to excite any serious + or compelling desire, but when this is so, or I suspect it, I am + willing to spend any time or trouble to get her to tread upon me + and am anxious to be trampled on with the greatest severity. + + "The treading should be inflicted for a few minutes all over the + chest, abdomen and groin, and lastly on the penis, which is, of + course, lying along the belly in a violent state of erection, and + consequently too hard for the treading to damage it. I also enjoy + being nearly strangled by a woman's foot. + + "If the lady finally stands facing my head and places her slipper + upon my penis so that the high heel falls about where the penis + leaves the scrotum, the sole covering most of the rest of it and + with the other foot upon the abdomen, into which I can _see_ as + well as feel it sink as she shifts her weight from one foot to + the other, orgasm takes place almost at once. Emission under + these conditions is to me an agony of delight, during which + practically the lady's whole weight should rest upon the penis. + + "One reason for my special pleasure in this method seems to be + that first the heel and afterwards the sole of the slipper as it + treads upon the penis greatly check the passage of the semen and + consequently the pleasure is considerably prolonged. There is + also a curious mental side to the affair. I love to imagine that + the lady who is treading upon me is my mistress and I her slave, + and that she is doing it to punish me for some fault, or to give + _herself_ (not me) pleasure. + + "It follows that the greater the contempt and severity with which + I am 'punished,' the greater becomes my pleasure. The idea of + 'punishment' or 'slavery' is seldom aroused except when I have + great difficulty in accomplishing my desire and the treader is + more than usually handsome and heavy and the trampling + mercilessly inflicted. I have been trampled so long and so + mercilessly several times, that I have flinched each time the + slipper pressed its way into my aching body and have been black + and blue for days afterwards. I take the greatest interest in + leading ladies on to do this for me where I think I will not + offend, and have been surprisingly successful. I must have lain + beneath the feet of quite a hundred women, many of them of good + social position, who would never dream of permitting any ordinary + sexual intercourse, but who have been so interested or amused by + the idea as to do it for me--many of them over and over again. It + is perhaps needless to say that none of my own or the ladies' + clothing is ever removed, or disarranged, for the accomplishment + of orgasm in this manner. After a long and varied experience, I + may say that my favorite weight is 10 to 11 stone, and that + black, very high-heeled slippers, in combination with tan silk + stockings, seem to give me the greatest pleasure and create in me + the strongest desires. + + "Boots, or outdoor shoes, do not attract me to anything like the + same degree, although I have, upon several occasions, enjoyed + myself fairly well by their use. Nude women repel me, and I find + no pleasure in seeing a woman in tights. I am not averse to + normal sexual connection and occasionally employ it. To me, + however, the pleasure is far inferior to that of being trampled + upon. I also derive keen pleasure--and usually have a strong + erection--from seeing a woman, dressed as I have described, tread + upon anything which yields under her foot--such as the seat of a + carriage, the cushions of a punt, a footstool, etc., and I enjoy + seeing her crush flowers by treading upon them. I have often + strolled along in the wake of some handsome lady at a picnic or + garden party, for the pleasure of seeing the grass upon which she + has trodden rise slowly again after her foot has pressed it. I + delight also to see a carriage sway as a woman leaves or enters + it--anything which needs the pressure of the foot. + + "To pass now to the origin of this direction of my feelings. + + "Even in early childhood I admired pretty feminine foot-gear, and + in the contemplation of it experienced vague sensations which I + now recognize as sexual. When a lad of 14 or so, I stayed a good + deal at the house of some intimate friends of my parents, the + daughter of the house--an only child--a beautiful and powerful + girl, about six years my senior, being my special chum. This girl + was always daintily dressed, and having most lovely feet and + ankles not unnaturally knew it. Whenever possible she dressed so + as to show off their beauty to the best advantage--rather short + skirts and usually little high-heeled slippers--and was not + averse to showing them in a most distractingly coquettish manner. + She seemed to have a passion for treading upon things which would + scrunch or yield under her foot, such as flowers, little + windfallen apples and pears, acorns, etc., or heaps of hay, straw + or cut grass. As we wandered about the gardens--for we were left + to do exactly as we liked--I got quite accustomed to seeing her + hunt out and tread upon such things, and used to chaff her about + it. At that time I was--as I am still--fond of lying at full + length on a thick hearthrug before a good fire. One evening as I + was lying in this way and we were alone, A. crossed the room to + reach a bangle from the mantelpiece. Instead of reaching over me, + she playfully stepped upon my body, saying that she would show me + how the hay and straw felt. Naturally I fell in with the joke and + laughed. After standing upon me a few moments she raised her + skirt slightly and, holding on to the mantelpiece for support, + stretched out one dainty foot in its brown silk stocking and + high-heeled slipper to the blaze to warm, while looking down and + laughing at my scarlet, excited face. She was a perfectly frank + and charming girl, and I feel pretty certain that, although she + evidently enjoyed my excitement and the feeling of my body + yielding under her feet, she did not on this first occasion + clearly understand my condition; nor can I remember that, though + the desire for sexual gratification drove me nearly mad, it + appeared to awaken in her any reciprocal feeling. I took hold of + her raised foot and, after kissing it, guided it by an absolutely + irresistible impulse on to my penis, which was as hard as wood + and seemed almost bursting. Almost at the moment that her weight + was thrown upon it, orgasm took place for the first time in my + life thoroughly and effectively. No description can give any idea + of what I felt--I only know that from that moment my distorted + sexual focus was fixed forever. Numberless times, after that + evening, I felt the weight of her dainty slippers, and nothing + will ever cause the memory of the pleasure she thus gave me to + fade. I know that A. came to enjoy treading upon me, as much as I + enjoyed having her do it. She had a liberal dress allowance and, + seeing the pleasure they gave me, she was always buying pretty + stockings and ravishing slippers with the highest and most + slender Louis heels she could find and would show them to me with + the greatest glee, urging me to lie down that she might try them + on me. She confessed that she loved to see and feel them sink + into my body as she trod upon me and enjoyed the crunch of the + muscles under her heel as she moved about. After some minutes of + this, I always guided her slipper on to my penis, and she would + tread carefully, but with her whole weight--probably about 9 + stone--and watch me with flashing eyes, flushed cheeks, and + quivering lips, as she felt--as she must have done plainly--the + throbbing and swelling of my penis under her foot as emission + took place. I have not the smallest doubt that orgasm took place + simultaneously with her, though we never at any time spoke openly + of it. This went on for several years on almost every favorable + opportunity we had, and after a month or two of separation + sometimes four or five times during a single day. Several times + during A.'s absence I masturbated by getting her slipper and + pressing it with all my strength against the penis while + imagining that she was treading upon me. The pleasure was, of + course, very inferior to her attentions. There was never at any + time between us any question of normal sexual intercourse, and we + were both well content to let things drift as they were. + + "A little after 20 I went abroad, and on my return about three + years later I found her married. Although we met often, the + subject was never alluded to, though we remained firm friends. I + confess I often, when I could do so without being seen, looked + longingly at her feet and would have gladly accepted the pleasure + she could have given me by an occasional resumption of our + strange practice--but it never came. + + "I went abroad again, and now neither she nor her husband are + alive and leave no issue. From time to time I have had occasional + relations with prostitutes, but always in this manner, though I + much prefer to find some lady of or above my own social position + who will do the treading for me. This is, however, interestingly + difficult. + + "Out of say a hundred women (which at home and abroad is what I + should estimate must have stood upon my body) I should say quite + 80 or 85 were _not_ prostitutes. Certainly not more than 10 to 12 + shared any _sexual_ excitement, but while they were evidently + excited they were not gratified. A. alone, so far as I know, had + complete sexual satisfaction of it. I have never asked a woman in + so many words to tread upon me for the purpose of gratifying my + sexual desires (prostitutes excepted), but have always tempted + them to do it in a jocular or teasing manner, and it is very + doubtful if more than a few (married) women really understood, + even after they had given me the extreme pleasure, that they had + done so, because any flushing and movement on my part under their + feet was not unnaturally put down to the trampling to which they + were subjecting me, and it was easy for me to guide the foot as + often as was necessary on to the penis till orgasm took place, + and even to keep it there by laying hold of the other one to kiss + it or on some other pretext during emission. Of course many + understood after once doing it (most have done it only once) what + I was at, and, although they did not ever discuss it nor did I, + they were not unwilling to give me as many treadings as I cared + to playfully suggest. I don't think they got any pleasure + sexually out of it themselves, though they could see plainly that + I did, and they did not object to give it me. I have spent as + long as twelve months with some women working gradually nearer + and nearer to my desire--often getting what I want in the end, + but more often failing. I _never_ risk it till I am certain it + would be safe to ask it, and have never had a serious rebuff. In + very many cases I should say the doing of what I want has simply + been regarded by the woman as gratifying a silly and perhaps + amusing whim, in which, beyond the novelty of treading on a man's + body, she has taken but little interest. + + "As in normal seduction, the endeavor to win the woman over to do + what I want without arousing her antagonism is a great part of + the charm to me, and naturally the better her social position the + more difficult this becomes--and the more attractive. I have + found that in three instances prostitutes have performed the same + office for other men and knew all about it. It is not + uninteresting to note that these three women were all of fine, + massive build--one standing about 5 feet 10 inches and weighing + nearly 14 stone--but with comparatively uninteresting faces. The + weight, build and clothing count for a good deal in exciting me. + I find that a sudden check to a man at the supreme moment of + sexual pleasure tends to heighten and prolong the pleasure. My + physical satisfaction is due to the fact that by getting the lady + to stand with all her weight upon my penis (as it lies between + her foot and the soft bed of my own body into which it is deeply + pressed) the act of emission is enormously prolonged, with + corresponding enjoyment. For this reason also I prefer a very + high-heeled slipper. The seminal fluid has to be forced past two + separate obstacles--the pressure of the heel close at the root of + the penis and afterwards the ball of the foot which compresses + the outer half, leaving a free portion between them under the + arched sole of the slipper. I may add that the pleasure is + greatly increased by the retention of the urine, and I always try + to retain as much water as I dare. I have an unconquerable + aversion to red in slippers or stockings; it will even cause + impotence. Why, I know not. Strange as it may seem, although pain + and bruising are often inflicted by a severe treading, I have + never been in any way injured by the practice, and my pleasure in + it seems not to diminish by constant repetition. The comparative + difficulty of obtaining the pleasure from just the woman I want + has a never-ending, if inexplicable, charm for me." + + It will be observed that in this case special importance is + attached to shoes with high heels, and the subject considers that + the pressure of such shoes is for mechanical reasons most + favorable for procuring ejaculation. Nearly all heterosexual + shoe-fetichists seem, however, to be equally attracted by high + heels. Restif de la Bretonne frequently referred to this point, + and he gave a number of reasons for the attractiveness of high + heels: (1) They are unlike men's boots and, therefore, have a + sexual fascination; (2) they make the leg and foot look more + charming; (3) they give a less bold and more sylph-like character + to the walk; (4) they keep the feet clean. (Restif de la + Bretonne, _Nuits de Paris_, vol. v, quoted in Preface to his _Mes + Inscriptions_, p. ciii.) It is doubtless the first reason--the + fact that high heels are a kind of secondary sexual + character--which is most generally potent in this attraction. + +The foregoing history, while it very distinctly brings before us a case of +erotic symbolism, is not strictly an example of shoe-fetichism. The +symbolism is more complex. The focus of beauty in a desirable woman is +transferred and concentrated in the region below the knee; in that sense +we have foot-fetichism. But the act of coitus itself is also symbolically +transferred. Not only has the foot become the symbol of the vulva, but +trampling has become the symbol of coitus; intercourse takes place +symbolically _per pedem_. It is a result of this symbolization of the foot +and of trampling that all acts of treading take on a new and symbolical +sexual charm. The element of masochism--of pleasure in being a woman's +slave--is a parasitic growth; that is to say, it is not founded in the +subject's constitution, but chances to have found a favorable soil in the +special circumstances under which his sexual life developed. It is not +primary, but secondary, and remains an unimportant and merely occasional +element. + +It may be instructive to bring forward for comparison a case in which also +we have a symbolism involving boot-fetichism, but extending beyond it. In +this case there is a basis of inversion (as is not infrequent in erotic +symbolisms), but from the present point of view the psychological +significance of the case remains the same. + + A.N., aged 29, unmarried, healthy, though not robust, and without + any known hereditary taint. Has followed various avocations + without taking great interest in them, but has shown some + literary ability. + + "I am an Englishman," his own narrative runs, "the third of three + children. At my birth my father was 41 and my mother 34. My + mother died of cancer when I was 15. My father is still alive, a + reserved man, who still nurses his sorrow for his wife's death. I + have no reason to believe my parents anything but normal and + useful members of society. My sister is normal and happily + married. My brother I have reason to believe to be an invert. + + "A horoscope cast for me describes me in a way I think correct, + and so do my friends: 'A mild, obliging, gentle, amiable person, + with many fine traits of character; timid in nature, fond of + society, loving peace and quietude, delighting in warm and close + friendships. There is much that is firm, steadfast and + industrious, some self-love, a good deal of diplomacy, a little + that is subtle, or what is called finesse. You are reserved with + those you dislike. There is a serious and sad side to your + character; you are very thoughtful and contemplative when in + these moods. But you are not pessimistic. You have superior + abilities, for they are intuitively intellectual. There is a cold + reticence which restrains generous impulses and which inclines to + acquisitiveness; it will make you deliberate, inventive, adding + self-esteem, some vanity.' + + "At an early age I was left much alone in the nursery and there + contracted the habit of masturbation long before the age of + puberty. I use the word 'masturbation' for want of a better, + though it may not quite describe my case. I have never used my + hand to the penis. As far back as I can remember I have had what + a Frenchman has described as 'le fetichisme de la chaussure,' and + in those early days, before I was 6 years old, I would put on my + father's boots, taken from a cupboard at hand, and then tying or + strapping my legs together would produce an erection, and all the + pleasurable feelings experienced, I suppose, by means of + masturbation. I always did this secretly, but couldn't tell why. + I continued this practice on and off all my boyhood and youth. + When I discovered the first emission I was much surprised. I + always did this thing without loosening my trousers. As to how + these feelings arose I am totally unable to say. I can't remember + being without such feelings, and they seem to me perfectly + normal. The sight, or even thought, of high boots, or leggings, + especially if well polished or in patent leather, would set all + my sexual passions aflame, and does yet. As a boy my great desire + was to wear these things. A soldier in boots and spurs, a groom + in tops, or even an errand-boy in patent leather leggings, + fascinated me, and to this day, despite reason and everything + else. The sight of such things produced an erection. An emission + I could always produce by tightly tying my legs together, but + only when wearing boots, and preferably leggings, which when I + had pocket money I bought for this purpose. (At the present + moment I have five pairs in the house and two pairs of high + boots, quite unjustified by ordinary use.) This habit I lapse + into yet at times. The smell of leather affects me, but I never + know how far this may be due to association with boots; the smell + suggests the image. Restraint by a leather strap is more exciting + than by cords. Erotic dreams always take the form of restraint on + the limbs when booted. + + "Uniforms and liveries have a great temptation for me, but only + when of a tight-fitting nature and smart, as soldiers', grooms', + etc., but not sailors'; most powerfully when the person is in + boots or leggings and breeches. + + "I was a quiet, sensitive boy, taking no part in games or sports. + Have always been indifferent to them. I made few friends, but + didn't want them. The craving for friendship came much later, + after I was 21. I was a day boy at a private school, and never + had any conversation with any boy on sexual matters, though I was + dimly aware of much 'nastiness' about the school. I knew nothing + of sodomy. But all these things were repulsive to me, + notwithstanding my secret practices. I was a 'good boy.' + + "Up to the age of 21 I was perfectly satisfied with my own + society, something of a prig, fond of books and reading, etc. I + was and ever have been absolutely insensible to the influence of + the other sex. I am not a woman hater, and take intellectual + pleasure in the society of certain ladies, but they are nearly + all much older than myself. I have a strong repulsion from sexual + relations with women. I should not mind being married for the + sake of companionship and for the sake of having boys of my own. + But the sexual act would frighten me. I could not in my present + frame of mind go to bed with a woman. Yet I feel an immense envy + of my married friends in that they are able to give out, and find + satisfaction for, their affection in a way that is quite + impossible for me. I picture certain boys in the place of the + wife. + + "I am now only happy in the society of men younger than myself, + age 17 to (say) 23 or 24, youths with smooth faces, or first sign + of hair on lip, well groomed, slightly effeminate in feature, of + sympathetic, perhaps weak nature. I feel I want to help them, do + something for them, devote myself entirely to their welfare. + + "With such there is no fixed line between friendship and love. I + yearn for intimacy with particular friends, but never dare + express it. I find so many people object to any strong expression + of feeling that I dare not run the risk of appearing ridiculous + in the eyes of these desired intimates. + + "I have no desire for _pædicatio_, but the idea itself does not + repulse me or seem unnatural, though personally it repels me a + little. But I think this to be mere prejudice on my part, which + might be broken down if the loved person showed a willingness to + act a passive part. I should never dare to make an advance, + however. + + "I am restrained by moral and religious considerations from + making my real feelings known, and I feel I should sink in my own + estimation if I gave way, though my natural desire is to do so. + In the face of opportunities (not I mean of _pædicatio_, but of + expression of excessive affection, etc.), or what might be such, + I always fail to speak lest I should forfeit the esteem of the + other person. I have a feeling of surprise when any one I like + evinces a liking for me. I feel that those I love are + immeasurably my superiors, though my reason may tell me it is not + so. I would grovel at their feet, do anything to win a smile from + them, or to make them give me their company. + + "Ordinary bodily contact with the boy I love gives me most + exquisite pleasure, and I never lose an opportunity of bringing + such contact about when it can be done naturally. I feel an + immense desire to embrace, kiss, squeeze, etc., the person, to + generally maul him, and say nice things--the kind of things a man + usually says to a woman. A handshake, the mere presence of the + person, makes me happy and content. + + "I can say with the Albanian: 'If I find myself in the presence + of the beloved, I rest absorbed in gazing on him. Absent, I think + of nought but him. If the beloved unexpectedly appears I fall + into confusion. My heart beats faster. I have eyes and ears only + for the beloved.' + + "I feel that my capacity of affection is finer and more spiritual + than that which commonly subsists between persons of different + sexes. And so, while trying to fight my instincts by religion, I + find my natural feeling to be part of my religion, and its + highest expression. In this sense I can speak from experience in + my own case, and more especially in that of my brother, that what + you have said about philanthropic activity resulting from + repressed homosexuality is very true indeed. I can say with one + of your female cases: 'Love is to me a religion. The very nature + of my affection for my friends precludes the possibility of any + element entering into it which is not absolutely pure and + sacred.' I am, however, madly jealous. I want entire possession, + and I can't bear for a moment that any one I do not care for + should know the person I love. + + "I am never attracted by men older than myself. The youths who + attract me may be of any class, though preferably, I think, of a + class a little lower than myself. I am not quite sure of this, + however, as circumstances may have contributed more than + deliberate choice to bring certain youths under my notice. Those + who have exercised the most powerful influence on me have been an + Oxford undergraduate, a barber's assistant, and a plumber's + apprentice. Though naturally fond of intellectual society, I do + not ask for intellect in those I love. It goes for nothing. I + always prefer their company to that of the most educated persons. + This preference has alienated me to some extent from more refined + and educated circles that formerly I was intimate with. + + "I have been led entirely out of my old habits by association + with younger friends, and now do things which before I should + never have dreamed of doing. My thoughts now are always with + certain youths, and if they speak of leaving the town, or in any + way talk of a future that I cannot share, I suffer horrid + sinkings of the heart and depression of spirits." + +This case, while it concerns a person of quite different temperament, with +a more innate predisposition to specific perversions, is yet in many +respects analogous to the previous case. There is boot-fetichism; nothing +is felt to be so attractive as the foot-gear, and there is also at the +same time more than this; there is the attraction of repression and +constraint developed into a sexual symbol. In C.P.'s case that symbolism +arises from the experience of an abnormal heterosexual relationship; in +A.N.'s case it is founded on auto-erotic experiences associated with +inversion; in both alike the entire symbolism has become diffused and +generalized. + +In the two cases just brought forward we have an erotic symbolism of act +founded on, and closely associated with, an erotic symbolism of object. It +may be instructive to bring forward another case in which no fetichistic +feeling toward an object can be traced, but an erotic symbolism still +clearly exists. In this case pain, even when self-inflicted, has acquired +a symbolic value as a stimulus to tumescence, without any element of +masochism. Such a case serves to indicate how the sexual attraction of +pain is really a special case of the erotic symbolism with which we are +here concerned. + + A.W., aged 50, a writer and lecturer, physically and mentally + energetic and enjoying good health. He is, however, very + emotional and of nervous temperament, but self-controlled. Though + physically well developed, the sexual organs are small. He is + married to an attractive woman, to whom he is much attached, and + has two healthy children. + + At 10 or 12 years of age he had a frequent desire to be whipped, + his parents never having struck him, and on one occasion he asked + a brother to go with him to the closet to get him to whip him on + the posterior; but on arrival he was too shy to make the request. + He did not recognize the cause of these desires, knowing nothing + of such things except from the misinformation of his + school-fellows' talk. As far as he can remember, he was an + entirely normal, healthy boy up to the age of about 15, when his + attention was arrested by an advertisement of a quack medicine + for the results of "youthful excesses." + + Being a city boy, he was unfamiliar with the coupling even of + animals, had never had a conscious erection and did not know of + frictional excitement. Experiment, however, resulted in an + orgasm, and, though believing that it was wicked or at least weak + and degrading, he indulged in masturbation at intervals, usually + about six times a month, and has continued even up to the + present. + + He had an abnormally small opening in the prepuce, making the + uncovering of the glans almost impossible. (At the age of about + 37, he himself slit the prepuce by three or four cuts of a + scissors at intervals of about ten days. This was followed by a + marked decrease in desire, especially as he shortly afterwards + learned the importance of local cleanliness.) While in college at + about the age of 19 he began to have nocturnal emissions + occasionally and once or twice a week when at stool. Alarmed by + these, he consulted a physician, who warned him of the danger, + gave him bromide and prescribed cold bathing of the parts, with a + hard, cool bed. These stopped the emissions. + + He never had connection with women until the age of about 25, and + then only three times until his marriage at 30 years of age, + being deterred partly by conscientious scruples, but more by + shyness and convention, and deriving very little pleasure from + these instances. Even since marriage he has derived more pleasure + from sexual excitement than from coitus, and can maintain + erection for as long as two hours. + + He has always been accustomed to torture himself in various + ingenious ways, nearly always connected with sex. He would burn + his skin deeply with red hot wire in inconspicuous places. These + and similar acts were generally followed by manual excitation + nearly always brought to a climax. + + He considers that he is attracted to refined and intellectual + women. But he is without very ardent desires, having several + times gone to bed with attractive women who stripped themselves + naked, but without attempting any sexual intercourse with them. + He became interested in the "Karezza" theory and has tried to + practice it with his wife, but could never entirely control the + emission. + + He has hired a masseur to whip him, as children are whipped, with + a heavy dog whip, which caused pleasurable excitement. During + this time he had relations with his wife generally about once a + week without any great ecstasy. She was cold and sexually slow, + owing to conventional sex repression and to an idea that the + whole thing was "like animals" and to fear of child-bearing, + usually necessitating the use of a cover or withdrawal. It was + only eight years after their marriage that she desired and + obtained a child. During these years he would often stick pins + through his mammæ and tie them together by a string round the + pins drawn so short as to cause great pain and then indulge + himself in the sexual act. He used strong wooden clips with a + tack fixed in them, so as to pierce and pinch the mammæ, and once + he drove a pin entirely through the penis itself, then obtaining + orgasm by friction. He was never able to get an automatic + emission in this way, though he often tried, not even by walking + briskly during an erection. + +In another class of cases a purely ideal symbolism may be present by means +of a fetich which acts as a powerful stimulus without itself being felt to +possess any attraction. A good illustration of this condition is furnished +by a case which has been communicated to me by a medical correspondent in +New Zealand. + + "The patient went out to South Africa as a trooper with the + contingent from New Zealand, throwing up a good position in an + office to do so. He had never had any trouble as regards + connection with women before going out to South Africa. While in + active service at the front he sustained a nasty fall from his + horse, breaking his leg. He was unconscious for four days, and + was then invalided down to Cape Town. Here he rapidly got well, + and his accustomed health returning to him he started having what + he terms 'a good time.' He repeatedly went to brothels, but was + unable to have more than a temporary erection, and no ejaculation + would take place. In one of these places he was in company with a + drunken trooper, who suggested that they should perform the + sexual act with their boots and spurs (only) on. My patient, who + was also drunk, readily assented, and to his surprise was enabled + to perform the act of copulation without any difficulty at all. + He has repeatedly tried since to perform the act without any + spurs, but is quite unable to do so; with the spurs he has no + difficulty at all in obtaining all the gratification he desires. + His general health is good. His mother was an extremely nervous + woman, and so is his sister. His father died when he was quite + young. His only other relation in the colony is a married sister, + who seems to enjoy vigorous health." + +The consideration of the cases here brought forward may suffice to show +that beyond those fetichisms which find their satisfaction in the +contemplation of a part of the body or a garment, there is a more subtle +symbolism. The foot is a center of force, an agent for exerting pressure, +and thus it furnishes a point of departure not alone for the merely static +sexual fetich, but for a dynamic erotic symbolization. The energy of its +movements becomes a substitute for the energy of the sexual organs +themselves in coitus, and exerts the same kind of fascination. The young +girl (page 35) "who seemed to have a passion for treading upon things +which would scrunch or yield under her foot," already possessed the germs +of an erotic symbolism which, under the influence of circumstances in +which she herself took an active part, developed into an adequate method +of sexual gratification.[23] The youth who was her partner learned, in the +same way, to find an erotic symbolism in all the pressure reactions of +attractive feminine feet, the swaying of a carriage beneath their weight, +the crushing of the flowers on which they tread, the slow rising of the +grass which they have pressed. Here we have a symbolism which is +altogether different from that fetichism which adores a definite object; +it is a dynamic symbolism finding its gratification in the spectacle of +movements which ideally recall the fundamental rhythm and pressure +reactions of the sexual process. + +We may trace a very similar erotic symbolism in an absolutely normal form. +The fascination of clothes in the lover's eyes is no doubt a complex +phenomenon, but in part it rests on the aptitudes of a woman's garments to +express vaguely a dynamic symbolism which must always remain indefinite +and elusive, and on that account always possess fascination. No one has so +acutely described this symbolism as Herrick, often an admirable +psychologist in matters of sexual attractiveness. Especially instructive +in this respect are his poems, "Delight in Disorder," "Upon Julia's +Clothes," and notably "Julia's Petticoat." "A sweet disorder in the +dress," he tells us, "kindles in clothes a wantonness;" it is not on the +garment itself, but on the character of its movement that he insists; on +the "erring lace," the "winning wave" of the "tempestuous petticoat;" he +speaks of the "liquefaction" of clothes, their "brave vibration each way +free," and of Julia's petticoat he remarks with a more specific symbolism +still, + + "Sometimes 'twould pant and sigh and heave, + As if to stir it scarce had leave; + But having got it, thereupon, + 'Twould make a brave expansion." + +In the play of the beloved woman's garment, he sees the whole process of +the central act of sex, with its repressions and expansions, and at the +sight is himself ready to "fall into a swoon." + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[13] G. Stanley Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. ii, p. 113. It will be noted +that the hand does not appear among the parts of the body which are +normally of supreme interest. An interest in the hand is by no means +uncommon (it may be noted, for instance, in the course of History XII in +Appendix B to vol. iii of these _Studies_), but the hand does not possess +the mystery which envelops the foot, and hand-fetichism is very much less +frequent than foot-fetichism, while glove-fetichism is remarkably rare. An +interesting case of hand-fetichism, scarcely reaching morbid intensity, is +recorded by Binet, _Etudes de Psychologie Expérimentale_, pp. 13-19; and +see Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, pp. 214 et seq. + +[14] _Mémoires_, vol. i, Chapter VII. + +[15] Among leading English novelists Hardy shows an unusual but by no +means predominant interest in the feet and shoes of his heroines; see, +e.g., the observations of the cobbler in _Under the Greenwood Tree_, +Chapter III. A chapter in Goethe's _Wahlverwandtschaften_ (Part I, Chapter +II) contains an episode involving the charm of the foot and the kissing of +the beloved's shoe. + +[16] Schinz, "Philosophie des Conventions Sociales," _Revue +Philosophique_, June, 1903, p. 626. Mirabeau mentions in his _Erotika +Biblion_ that modern Greek women sometimes use their feet to provoke +orgasm in their lovers. I may add that simultaneous mutual masturbation by +means of the feet is not unknown to-day, and I have been told by an +English shoe-fetichist that he at one time was accustomed to practice this +with a married lady (Brazilian)--she with slippers on and he without--who +derived gratification equal to his own. + +[17] Jacoby (loc. cit. pp. 796-7) gives a large number of references to +Ovid's works bearing on this point. "In reading him," he remarks, "one is +inclined to say that the psychology of the Romans was closely allied to +that of the Chinese." + +[18] R. Kleinpaul, _Sprache ohne Worte_, p. 308. See also Moll, _Konträre +Sexualempfindung_, third edition, pp. 306-308. Bloch brings together many +interesting references bearing on the ancient sexual and religious +symbolism of the shoe, _Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, +Teil II, p. 324. + +[19] Jacoby (loc. cit. p. 797) appears to regard shoe-fetichism as a true +atavism: "The sexual adoration of feminine foot-gear," he concludes, +"perhaps the most enigmatic and certainly the most singular of +degenerative insanities, is thus merely a form of atavism, the return of +the degenerate to the very ancient and primitive psychology which we no +longer understand and are no longer capable of feeling." + +[20] Moll has reported in detail (_Untersuchungen über die Libido +Sexualis_, bd. i, Teil II, pp. 320-324) a case which both he and +Krafft-Ebing regard as illustrative of the connection between +boot-fetichism and masochism. It is essentially a case of masochism, +though manifesting itself almost exclusively in the desire to perform +humiliating acts in connection with the attractive person's boots. + +[21] Krafft-Ebing goes so far as to assert (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, +English translation of tenth edition, p. 174) that "when in cases of +shoe-fetichism the female shoe appears alone as the excitant of sexual +desire one is justified in presuming that masochistic motives have +remained latent.... Latent masochism may always be assumed as the +unconscious motive." In this way he hopelessly misinterprets some of his +own cases. + +[22] Krafft-Ebing goes so far as to assert (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, +English translation, pp. 159 and 174). Yet some of the cases he brings +forward (e.g., Coxe's as quoted by Hammond) show no sign of masochism, +since, according to Krafft-Ebing's own definition (p. 116), the idea of +subjugation by the opposite sex is of the essence of masochism. + +[23] Her actions suggest that there is often a latent sexual consciousness +in regard to the feet in women, atavistic or pseudo-atavistic, and +corresponding to the sexual attraction which the feet formerly aroused, +almost normally, in men. This is also suggested by the case, referred to +by Shufeldt, of an unmarried woman, belonging to a family exhibiting in a +high degree both erotic and neurotic traits, who had "a certain +uncontrollable fascination for shoes. She delights in new shoes, and +changes her shoes all day long at regular intervals of three hours each. +She keeps this row of shoes out in plain sight in her apartment." (R.W. +Shufeldt, "On a Case of Female Impotency," 1896, p. 10.) + + + + +III. + +Scatalogic Symbolism--Urolagnia--Coprolagnia--The Ascetic Attitude Towards +the Flesh--Normal basis of Scatalogic Symbolism--Scatalogic Conceptions +Among Primitive Peoples--Urine as a Primitive Holy Water--Sacredness of +Animal Excreta--Scatalogy in Folk-lore--The Obscene as Derived from the +Mythological--The Immature Sexual Impulse Tends to Manifest Itself in +Scatalogic Forms--The basis of Physiological Connection Between the +Urinary and Genital Spheres--Urinary Fetichism Sometimes Normal in +Animals--The Urolagnia of Masochists--The Scatalogy of Saints--Urolagnia +More Often a Symbolism of Act Than a Symbolism of Object--Only +Occasionally an Olfactory Fetichism--Comparative Rarity of +Coprolagnia--Influence of Nates Fetichism as a Transition to +Coprolagnia--Ideal Coprolagnia--Olfactory Coprolagnia--Urolagnia and +Coprolagnia as Symbols of Coitus. + + +We meet with another group of erotic symbolisms--alike symbolisms of +object and of act--in connection with the two functions adjoining the +anatomical sexual focus: the urinary and alvine excretory functions. These +are sometimes termed the scatalogical group, with the two subdivisions of +urolagnia and Coprolagnia.[24] _Inter fæces et urinam nascimur_ is an +ancient text which has served the ascetic preachers of old for many +discourses on the littleness of man and the meanness of that reproductive +power which plays so large a part in man's life. "The stupid bungle of +Nature," a correspondent writes, "whereby the generative organs serve as a +means of relieving the bladder, is doubtless responsible for much of the +disgust which those organs excite in some minds." + +At the same time, it is necessary to point out, such reflex influence may +act not in one direction only, but also in the reverse direction. From +the standpoint of ascetic contemplation eager to belittle humanity, the +excretory centers may cast dishonor upon the genital center which they +adjoin. From the more ecstatic standpoint of the impassioned lover, eager +to magnify the charm of the woman he worships, it is not impossible for +the excretory centers to take on some charm from the irradiating center of +sex which they enclose. + +Even normally such a process is traceable. The normal lover may not +idealize the excretory functions of his mistress, but the fact that he +finds no repulsion in the most intimate contacts and feels no disgust at +the proximity of the excretory orifices or the existence of their +functions, indicates that the idealization of love has exerted at all +events a neutralizing influence; indeed, the presence of an acute +sensibility to the disturbing influence of this proximity of the excretory +orifices and their functions must be considered abnormal; Swift's +"Strephon and Chloe"--with the conviction underlying it that it is an easy +matter for the excretory functions to drown the possibilities of +love--could only have proceeded from a morbidly sensitive brain.[25] + +A more than mere neutralizing influence, a positively idealizing influence +of the sexual focus on the excretory processes adjoining it, may take +place in the lover's mind without the normal variations of sexual +attraction being over-passed, and even without the creation of an +excretory fetichism. + + Reflections of this attitude may be found in the poets. In the + _Song of Songs_ the lover says of his mistress, "Thy navel is + like a round goblet, wherein no mingled wine is wanting;" in his + lyric "To Dianeme," Herrick says with clear reference to the + mons veneris:-- + + "Show me that hill where smiling love doth sit, + Having a living fountain under it;" + + and in the very numerous poems in various languages which have + more or less obscurely dealt with the rose as the emblem of the + feminine pudenda there are occasional references to the stream + which guards or presides over the rose. It may, indeed, be + recalled that even in the name _nymphæ_ anatomists commonly apply + to the _labia minora_ there is generally believed to be a poetic + allusion to the Nymphs who presided over streams, since the + _labia minora_ exert an influence on the direction of the urinary + stream. + + In _Wilhelm Meister_ (Part I, Chapter XV), Goethe, on the basis + of his own personal experiences, describes his hero's emotions in + the humble surroundings of Marianne's little room as compared + with the stateliness and order of his own home. "It seemed to him + when he had here to remove her stays in order to reach the + harpsichord, there to lay her skirt on the bed before he could + seat himself, when she herself with unembarrassed frankness would + make no attempt to conceal from him many natural acts which + people are accustomed to hide from others out of decency--it + seemed to him, I say, that he became bound to her by invisible + bands." We are told of Wordsworth (Findlay's _Recollections of De + Quincey_, p. 36) that he read _Wilhelm Meister_ till "he came to + the scene where the hero, in his mistress's bedroom, becomes + sentimental over her dirty towels, etc., which struck him with + such disgust that he flung the book out of his hand, would never + look at it again, and declared that surely no English lady would + ever read such a work." I have, however, heard a woman of high + intellectual distinction refer to the peculiar truth and beauty + of this very passage. + + In one of his latest novels, _Les Rencontres de M. de Bréot_, + Henri de Régnier, one of the most notable of recent French + novelists, narrates an episode bearing on the matter before us. A + personage of the story is sitting for a moment in a dark grotto + during a night fête in a nobleman's park, when two ladies enter + and laughingly proceed to raise their garments and accomplish a + natural necessity. The man in the background, suddenly overcome + by a sexual impulse, starts forward; one lady runs away, the + other, whom he detains, offers little resistance to his advances. + To M. de Bréot, whom he shortly after encounters, he exclaims, + abashed at his own actions: "Why did I not flee? But could I + imagine that the spectacle of so disgusting a function would have + any other effect than to give me a humble opinion of human + nature?" M. de Bréot, however, in proceeding to reproach his + interlocutor for his inconsiderate temerity, observes: "What you + tell me, sir, does not entirely surprise me. Nature has placed + very various instincts within us, and the impulse that led you to + what you have just now done is not so peculiar as you think. One + may be a very estimable man and yet love women even in what is + lowliest in their bodies." In harmony with this passage from + Régnier's novel are the remarks of a correspondent who writes to + me of the function of urination that it "appeals sexually to most + normal individuals. My own observations and inquiries prove this. + Women themselves instinctively feel it. The secrecy surrounding + the matter lends, too, I think, a sexual interest." + + The fact that scatalogic processes may in some degree exert an + attraction even in normal love has been especially emphasized by + Bloch (_Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil + II, pp. 222, et seq.): "The man whose intellect and æsthetic + sense has been 'clouded by the sexual impulse' sees these things + in an entirely different light from him who has not been overcome + by the intoxication of love. For him they are idealized (sit + venia verbo) since they are a part of the beloved person, and in + consequence associated with love." Bloch quotes the _Memoiren + einer Sängerin_ (a book which is said to be, though this seems + doubtful, genuinely autobiographical) in the same sense: "A man + who falls in love with a girl is not dragged out of his poetic + sphere by the thought that his beloved must relieve certain + natural necessities every day. It seems, indeed, to him to be + just the opposite. If one loves a person one finds nothing + obscene or disgusting in the object that pleases me." The + opposite attitude is probably in extreme cases due to the + influence of a neurotic or morbidly sensitive temperament. Swift + possessed such a temperament. The possession of a similar + temperament is doubtless responsible for the little prose poem, + "L'Extase," in which Huysmans in his first book, _Le Drageloir á + Epices_, has written an attenuated version of "Strephon and + Chloe" to express the disillusionment of love; the lover lies in + a wood clasping the hand of the beloved with rapturous emotion; + "suddenly she rose, disengaged her hand, disappeared in the + bushes, and I heard as it were the rustling of rain on the + leaves." His dream has fled. + +In estimating the significance of the lover's attitude in this matter, it +is important to realize the position which scatologic conceptions took in +primitive belief. At certain stages of early culture, when all the +emanations of the body are liable to possess mysterious magic properties +and become apt for sacred uses, the excretions, and especially the urine, +are found to form part of religious ritual and ceremonial function. Even +among savages the excreta are frequently regarded as disgusting, but under +the influence of these conceptions such disgust is inhibited, and those +emanations of the body which are usually least honored become religious +symbols. + + Urine has been regarded as the original holy water, and many + customs which still survive in Italy and various parts of Europe, + involving the use of a fluid which must often be yellow and + sometimes salt, possibly indicate the earlier use of urine. (The + Greek water of aspersion, according to Theocritus, was mixed + with salt, as is sometimes the modern Italian holy water. J.J. + Blunt, _Vestiges of Ancient Manners and Customs_, p. 173.) Among + the Hottentots, as Kolbein and others have recorded, the medicine + man urinated alternately on bride and bridegroom, and a + successful young warrior was sprinkled in the same way. Mungo + Park mentions that in Africa on one occasion a bride sent a bowl + of her urine which was thrown over him as a special mark of honor + to a distinguished guest. Pennant remarked that the Highlanders + sprinkled their cattle with urine, as a kind of holy water, on + the first Monday in every quarter. (Bourke, _Scatalogic Rites_, + pp. 228, 239; Brand, _Popular Antiquities_, "Bride-Ales.") + + Even the excreta of animals have sometimes been counted sacred. + This is notably so in the case of the cow, of all animals the + most venerated by primitive peoples, and especially in India. + Jules Bois (_Visions de l'Inde_, p. 86) describes the spectacle + presented in the temple of the cows at Benares: "I put my head + into the opening of the holy stables. It was the largest of + temples, a splendor of precious stones and marble, where the + venerated heifers passed backwards and forwards. A whole people + adored them. They take no notice, plunged in their divine and + obscure unconsciousness. And they fulfil with serenity their + animal functions; they chew the offerings, drink water from + copper vessels, and when they are filled they relieve themselves. + Then a stercoraceous and religious insanity overcomes these + starry-faced women and venerable men; they fall on their knees, + prostrate themselves, eat the droppings, greedily drink the + liquid, which for them is miraculous and sacred." (Cf. Bourke, + _Scatalogic Rites_, Chapter XVII.) + + Among the Chevsurs of the Caucasus, perhaps an Iranian people, a + woman after her confinement, for which she lives apart, purifies + herself by washing in the urine of a cow and then returns home. + This mode of purification is recommended in the Avesta, and is + said to be used by the few remaining followers of this creed. + +We have not only to take into account the frequency with which among +primitive peoples the excretions possess a religious significance. It is +further to be noted that in the folk-lore of modern Europe we everywhere +find plentiful evidence of the earlier prevalence of legends and practices +of a scatalogical character. It is significant that in the majority of +cases it is easy to see a sexual reference in these stories and customs. +The legends have lost their earlier and often mythical significance, and +frequently take on a suggestion of obscenity, while the scatalogical +practices have become the magical devices of lovelorn maidens or forsaken +wives practiced in secrecy. It has happened to scatalogical rites to be +regarded as we may gather from the _Clouds_ of Aristophanes, that the +sacred leathern phallus borne by the women in the Bacchanalia was becoming +in his time, an object to arouse the amusement of little boys. + + Among many primitive peoples throughout the world, and among the + lower social classes of civilized peoples, urine possesses magic + properties, more especially, it would seem, the urine of women + and that of people who stand, or wish to stand, in sexual + relationship to each other. In a legend of the Indians of the + northwest coast of America, recorded by Boas, a woman gives her + lover some of her urine and says: "You can wake the dead if you + drop some of my urine in their ears and nose." (_Zeitschrift für + Ethnologie_, 1894, Heft IV, p. 293.) Among the same Indians there + is a legend of a woman with a beautiful white skin who found on + bathing every morning in the river that the fish were attracted + to her skin and could not be driven off even by magical + solutions. At last she said to herself: "I will make water on + them and then they will leave me alone." She did so, and + henceforth the fish left her. But shortly after fire came from + Heaven and killed her. (Ib., 1891, Heft V, p. 640.) Among both + Christians and Mohammedans a wife can attach an unfaithful + husband by privately putting some of her urine in his drink. (B. + Stern, _Medizin in der Türkei_, vol. ii, p. 11.) This practice is + world-wide; thus among the aborigines of Brazil, according to + Martius, the urine and other excretions and secretions are potent + for aphrodisiacal objects. (Bourke's _Scatalogic Rites of All + Nations_ contains many references to the folk-lore practices in + this matter; a study of popular beliefs in the magic power of + urine, published in Bombay by Professor Eugen Wilhelm in 1889, I + have not seen.) + + The legends which narrate scatalogic exploits are numerous in the + literature of all countries. Among primitive peoples they often + have a purely theological character, for in the popular + mythologies of all countries (even, as we learn from + Aristophanes, among the Greeks) natural phenomena such as the + rain, are apt to be regarded as divine excretions, but in course + of time the legends take on a more erotic or a more obscene + character. In the Irish _Book of Leinster_ (written down + somewhere about the twelfth century, but containing material of + very much older date) we are told how a number of princesses in + Emain Macha, the seat of the Ulster Kings, resolved to find out + which of them could by urinating on it melt a snow pillar which + the men had made, the woman who succeeded to be regarded as the + best among them. None of them succeeded, and they sent for + Derbforgaill, who was in love with Cuchullain, and she was able + to melt the pillar; whereupon the other women, jealous of the + superiority she had thus shown, tore out her eyes. (Zimmer, + "Keltische Beiträge," _Zeitschrift für Deutsche Alterthum_, vol. + xxxii, Heft II, pp. 216-219.) Rhys considers that Derbforgaill + was really a goddess of dawn and dusk, "the drop glistening in + the sun's rays," as indicated by her name, which means a drop or + tear. (J. Rhys, _Lectures on the Origin and Growth of Religion as + Illustrated by Celtic Heathendom_, p. 466.) It is interesting to + compare the legend of Derbforgaill with a somewhat more modern + Picardy folk-lore _conte_ which is clearly analogous but no + longer seems to show any mythologic element, "La Princesse qui + pisse par dessus les Meules." This princess had a habit of + urinating over hay-cocks; the king, her father, in order to break + her of the habit, offered her in marriage to anyone who could + make a hay-cock so high that she could not urinate over it. The + young men came, but the princess would merely laugh and at once + achieve the task. At last there came a young man who argued with + himself that she would not be able to perform this feat after she + had lost her virginity. He therefore seduced her first and she + then failed ignobly, merely wetting her stockings. Accordingly, + she became his bride. (Kryptadia, vol. i. p. 333.) Such legends, + which have lost any mythologic elements they may originally have + possessed and have become merely _contes_, are not uncommon in + the folk-lore of many countries. But in their earlier more + religious forms and in their later more obscene forms, they alike + bear witness to the large place which scatalogic conceptions play + in the primitive mind. + +It is a notable fact in evidence of the close and seemingly normal +association with the sexual impulse of the scatalogic processes, that an +interest in them, arising naturally and spontaneously, is one of the most +frequent channels by which the sexual impulse first manifests itself in +young boys and girls. + + Stanley Hall, who has made special inquiries into the matter, + remarks that in childhood the products of excretion by bladder + and bowels are often objects of interest hardly less intense for + a time than eating and drinking. ("Early Sense of Self," + _American Journal of Psychology_, April, 1898, p. 361.) + "Micturitional obscenities," the same writer observes again, + "which our returns show to be so common before adolescence, + culminate at 10 or 12, and seem to retreat into the background as + sex phenomena appear." They are, he remarks, of two classes: + "Fouling persons or things, secretly from adults, but openly with + each other," and less often "ceremonial acts connected with the + act or the product that almost suggest the scatalogical rites of + savages, unfit for description here, but of great interest and + importance." (G. Stanley Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. i, p. 116.) + The nature of such scatalogical phenomena in childhood--which are + often clearly the instinctive manifestations of an erotic + symbolism--and their wide prevalence among both boys and girls, + are very well illustrated in a narrative which I include in + Appendix B, History II. + +In boys as they approach the age of puberty, this attraction to the +scatalogic, when it exists, tends to die out, giving place to more normal +sexual conceptions, or at all events it takes a subordinate and less +serious place in the mind. In girls, on the other hand, it often tends to +persist. Edmond de Goncourt, a minute observer of the feminine mind, +refers in _Chérie_ to "those innocent and triumphant gaieties which +scatalogic stories have the privilege of arousing in women who have +remained still children, even the most distinguished women." The extent to +which innocent young women, who would frequently be uninterested or +repelled in presence of the sexually obscene are sometimes attracted by +the scatalogically obscene, becomes intelligible, however, if we realize +that a symbolism comes here into play. In women the more specifically +sexual knowledge and experience of life frequently develop much later than +in men or even remains in abeyance, and the specifically sexual phenomena +cannot therefore easily lend themselves to wit, or humor, or imagination. +But the scatalogic sphere, by the very fact that in women it is a +specially intimate and secret region which is yet always liable to be +unexpectedly protruded into consciousness, furnishes an inexhaustible +field for situations which have the same character as those furnished by +the sexually obscene. It thus happens that the sexually obscene which in +men tends to overshadow the scatalogically obscene, in women--partly from +inexperience and partly, it is probable, from their almost physiological +modesty--plays a part subordinate to the scatalogical. In a somewhat +analogous way scatalogical wit and humor play a considerable part in the +work of various eminent authors who were clergymen or priests. + +In addition to the anatomical and psychological associations which +contribute to furnish a basis on which erotic symbolisms may spring up, +there are also physiological connections between the genital and urinary +spheres which directly favor such symbolisms. In discussing the analysis +of the sexual impulse in a previous volume of these _Studies_, I have +pointed out the remarkable relationship--sometimes of transference, +sometimes of compensation--which exists between genital tension and +vesical tension, both in men and women. In the histories of normal sexual +development brought together at the end of that and subsequent volumes the +relationship may frequently be traced, as also in the case of C.P. in the +present study (p. 37). Vesical power is also commonly believed to be in +relation with sexual potency, and the inability to project the urinary +stream in a normal manner is one of the accepted signs of sexual +impotency.[26] Féré, again, has recorded the history of a man with +periodic crises of sexual desire, and subsequently sexual obsession +without desire, which were always accompanied by the impulse to urinate +and by increased urination.[27] In the case, recorded by Pitres and Régis, +of a young girl who, having once at the sight of a young man she liked in +a theater been overcome by sexual feeling accompanied by a strong desire +to urinate, was afterward tormented by a groundless fear of experiencing +an irresistible desire to urinate at inconvenient times,[28] we have an +example of what may be called a physiological scatalogic symbolism of sex, +an emotion which was primarily erotic becoming transferred to the bladder +and then remaining persistent. From such a physiological symbolism it is +but a step to the psychological symbolisms of scatalogic fetichism. + + It is worthy of note, as an indication that such phenomena are + scarcely abnormal, that a urinary symbolism, and even a strictly + sexual fetichism, are normal among many animals. + + The most familiar example of this kind is furnished by the dog, + who is sexually excited in this manner by traces of the bitch and + himself takes every opportunity of making his own path + recognizable. "This custom," Espinas remarks (_Des Sociétés + Animales_, p. 228), "has no other aim than to spread along the + road recognizable traces of their presence for the benefit of + individuals of the other sex, the odor of these traces doubtless + causing excitement." + + It is noteworthy, also, that in animals as well as in man, sexual + excitement may manifest itself in the bladder. Thus Daumas states + (_Chevaux de Sahara_, p. 49) that if the mare urinates when she + hears the stallion neigh it is a sign that she is ready for + connection. + +It is in masochism, or passive algolagnia, that we may most frequently +find scatalogic symbolism in its fully developed form. The man whose +predominant impulse is to subjugate himself to his mistress and to receive +at her hands the utmost humiliation, frequently finds the climax of his +gratification in being urinated on by her, whether in actual fact or only +in imagination. + +In many such cases, however, it is evident that we have a mixed +phenomenon; the symbolism is double. The act becomes desirable because it +is the outward and visible sign of an inwardly experienced abject slavery +to an adored person. But it is also desirable because of intimately sexual +associations in the act itself, as a symbolical detumescence, a simulacrum +of the sexual act, and one which proceeds from the sexual focus itself. + + Krafft-Ebing records various cases of masochism in which the + emission of urine on to the body or into the mouth formed the + climax of sexual gratification, as, for instance (_Psychopathia + Sexualis_, English translation, p. 183) in the case of a Russian + official who as a boy had fancies of being bound between the + thighs of a woman, compelled to sleep beneath her nates and to + drink her urine, and in later life experienced the greatest + excitement when practicing the last part of this early + imagination. + + In another case, recorded by Krafft-Ebing and by him termed + "ideal masochism" (_Op. cit._, pp. 127-130), the subject from + childhood indulged in voluptuous day-dreams in which he was the + slave of a beautiful mistress who would compel him to obey all + her caprices, stand over him with one foot on his breast, sit on + his face and body, make him wait on her in her bath, or when she + urinated, and sometimes insist on doing this on his face; though + a highly intellectual man, he was always too timid to attempt to + carry any of his ideas into execution; he had been troubled by + nocturnal enuresis up to the age of 20. + + Neri, again (_Archivio delle Psicopatie Sessuali_, vol. i, fasc. + 7 and 8, 1896), records the case of an Italian masochist who + experienced the greatest pleasure when both urination and + defecation were practiced in this manner by the woman he was + attached to. + + In a previous volume of these _Studies_ ("Sexual Inversion," + History XXVI) I have recorded the masochistic day-dreams of a boy + whose impulses were at the same time inverted; in his reveries + "the central fact," he states, "became the discharge of urine + from my lover over my body and limbs, or, if I were very fond of + him, I let it be in my face." In actual life the act of urination + casually witnessed in childhood became the symbol, even the + reality, of the central secret of sex: "I stood rooted and + flushing with downcast eyes till the act was over, and was + conscious for a considerable time of stammering speech and + bewildered faculties.... I was overwhelmed with emotion and could + barely drag my feet from the spot or my eyes from the damp + herbage where he had deposited the waters of secrecy. Even to-day + I cannot dissociate myself from the shuddering charm that moment + had for me." + +It is not only the urine and the fæces which may thus acquire a symbolic +fascination and attractiveness under the influence of masochistic +deviations of sexual idealization. In some cases extreme rapture has been +experienced in licking sweating feet. There is, indeed, no excretion or +product of the body which has not been a source of ecstasy: the sweat from +every part of the body, the saliva and menstrual fluid, even the wax from +the ears. + + Krafft-Ebing very truly points out (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, + English translation, p. 178) that this sexual scatalogic + symbolism is precisely paralleled by a religious scatalogic + symbolism. In the excesses of devout enthusiasm the ascetic + performs exactly the same acts as are performed in these excesses + of erotic enthusiasm. To mix excreta with the food, to lick up + excrement, to suck festering sores--all these and the like are + acts which holy and venerated women have performed. + + Not only the saint, but also the prophet and medicine-man have + been frequently eaters of human excrement; it is only necessary + to refer to the instance of the prophet Ezekiel, who declared + that he was commanded to bake his bread with human dung, and to + the practices of medicine-men at Torres Straits, in whose + training the eating of human excrement takes a recognized part. + (Deities, notably Baal-Phegor, were sometimes supposed to eat + excrement, so that it was natural that their messengers and + representatives among men should do so. As regards Baal-Phegor, + see Dulaure, _Des Divinités Génératrices_, Chapter IV, and J.G. + Bourke, _Scatalogic Rites of All Nations_, p. 241. See also + Ezekiel, Chapter IV, v. 12, and _Reports Anthropological + Expedition to Torres Straits_, vol. v, p. 321.) + + It must be added, however, that while the masochist is overcome + by sexual rapture, so that he sees nothing disgusting in his act, + the medicine-man and the ascetic are not so invariably overcome + by religious rapture, and several ascetic writers have referred + to the horror and disgust they experienced, at all events at + first, in accomplishing such acts, while the medicine-men when + novices sometimes find the ordeal too severe and have to abandon + their career. Brénier de Montmorand, while remarking, not without + some exaggeration, that "the Christian ascetics are almost all + eaters of excrement" ("Ascétisme et Mysticisme," _Revue + Philosophique_, March, 1904, p. 245), quotes the testimonies of + Marguerite-Marie and Madame Guyon as to the extreme repugnance + which they had to overcome. They were impelled by a merely + intellectual symbolism of self-mortification rather than by the + profoundly felt emotional symbolism which moves the masochist. + + Coprophagic acts, whether under the influences of religious + exaltation or of sexual rapture, inevitably excite our disgust. + We regard them as almost insane, fortified in that belief by the + undoubted fact that coprophagia is not uncommon among the insane. + It may, therefore, be proper to point out that it is not so very + long since the ingestion of human excrement was carried out by + our own forefathers in the most sane and deliberate manner. It + was administered by medical practitioners for a great number of + ailments, apparently with entirely satisfactory results. Less + than two centuries ago, Schurig, who so admirably gathered + together and arranged the medical lore of his own and the + immediately preceding ages, wrote a very long and detailed + chapter, "De Stercoris Humani Usu Medico" (_Chylologia_, 1725, + cap. XIII; in the Paris _Journal de Médecine_ for February 19, + 1905, there appeared an article, which I have not seen, entitled + "Médicaments oubliées: l'urine et la fiente humaine.") The + classes of cases in which the drug was found beneficial would + seem to have been extremely various. It must not be supposed that + it was usually ingested in the crude form. A common method was to + take the fæces of boys, dry them, mix them with the best honey, + and administer an electuary. (At an earlier period such drugs + appear to have met with some opposition from the Church, which + seems to have seen in them only an application of magic; thus I + note that in Burchard's remarkable Penitential of the fourteenth + century, as reproduced by Wasserschleben, 40 days' penance is + prescribed for the use of human urine or excrement as a medicine. + Wasserschleben _Die Bussordnungen der Abendländlichen Kirche_, p. + 651.) + +The urolagnia of masochism is not a simple phenomenon; it embodies a +double symbolism: on the one hand a symbolism of self-abnegation, such as +the ascetic feels, on the other hand a symbolism of transferred sexual +emotion. Krafft-Ebing was disposed to regard all cases in which a +scatalogical sexual attraction existed as due to "latent masochism." Such +a point of view is quite untenable. Certainly the connection is common, +but in the majority of cases of slightly marked scatalogical fetichism no +masochism is evident. And when we bear in mind the various considerations, +already brought forward, which show how widespread and clearly realized is +the natural and normal basis furnished for such symbolism, it becomes +quite unnecessary to invoke any aid from masochism. There is ample +evidence to show that, either as a habitual or more usually an occasional +act, the impulse to bestow a symbolic value on the act of urination in a +beloved person, is not extremely uncommon; it has been noted of men of +high intellectual distinction; it occurs in women as well as men; when +existing in only a slight degree, it must be regarded as within the normal +limits of variation of sexual emotion. + + The occasional cases in which the urine is drunk may possibly + suggest that the motive lies in the properties of the fluid + acting on the system. Support for this supposition might be found + in the fact that urine actually does possess, apart altogether + from its magic virtues embodied in folk-lore, the properties of a + general stimulant. In composition (as Masterman first pointed + out) "beef-tea differs little from healthy urine," containing + exactly the same constituents, except that in beef-tea there is + less urea and uric acid. Fresh urine--more especially that of + children and young women--is taken as a medicine in nearly all + parts of the world for various disorders, such as epistaxis, + malaria and hysteria, with benefit, this benefit being almost + certainly due to its qualities as a general stimulant and + restorative. William Salmon's _Dispensatory_, 1678 (quoted in + _British Medical Journal_, April 21, 1900, p. 974), shows that in + the seventeenth century urine still occupied an important place + as a medicine, and it frequently entered largely into the + composition of Aqua Divina. + + Its use has been known even in England in the nineteenth century. + (Masterman, _Lancet_, October 2, 1880; R. Neale, "Urine as a + Medicine," _Practitioner_, November, 1881; Bourke brings together + a great deal of evidence as to the therapeutic uses of urine in + his _Scatalogic Rites_, especially pp. 331-335; Lusini has shown + that normal urine invariably increases the frequency of the heart + beats, _Archivio di Farmacologia_, fascs. 19-21, 1893.) + + But it is an error to suppose that these facts account for the + urolagnic drinking of urine. As in the gratification of a normal + sexual impulse, the intense excitement of gratifying a scatalogic + sexual impulse itself produces a degree of emotional stimulation + far greater than the ingestion of a small amount of animal + extractives would be adequate to effect. In such cases, as much + as in normal sexuality, the stimulation is clearly psychic. + +When, as is most commonly the case, it is the process of urination and not +the urine itself which is attractive, we are clearly concerned with a +symbolism of act and not with the fetichistic attraction of an excretion. +When the excretion, apart from the act, provides the attraction, we seem +usually to be in the presence of an olfactory fetichism. These fetichisms +connected with the excreta appear to be experienced chiefly by individuals +who are somewhat weak-minded, which is not necessarily the case in regard +to those persons for whom the act, rather than its product apart from the +beloved person, is the attractive symbol. + + The sexually symbolic nature of the act of urination for many + people is indicated by the existence, according to Bloch, who + enumerates various kinds of indecent photographs, of a group + which he terms "the notorious _pisseuses_." It is further + indicated by several of the reproductions in Fuch's _Erotsiche + Element in der Karikatur_, such as Delorme's "La Necessitê n'a + point de Loi." (It should be added that such a scene by no means + necessarily possesses any erotic symbolism, as we may see in + Rembrandt's etching commonly called "Le Femme qui Pisse," in + which the reflected lights on the partly shadowed stream furnish + an artistic motive which is obviously free from any trace of + obscenity.) In the case which Krafft-Ebing quotes from Maschka of + a young man who would induce young girls to dance naked in his + room, to leap, and to urinate in his presence, whereupon seminal + ejaculation would take place, we have a typical example of + urolagnic symbolism in a form adequate to produce complete + gratification. A case in which the urolagnic form of scatalogic + symbolism reached its fullest development as a sexual perversion + has been described in Russia by Sukhanoff (summarized in + _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, November, 1900, and + _Annales Medico-psychologiques_, February, 1901), that of a young + man of 27, of neuropathic temperament, who when he once chanced + to witness a woman urinating experienced voluptuous sensations. + From that moment he sought close contact with women urinating, + the maximum of gratification being reached when he could place + himself in such a position that a woman, in all innocence, would + urinate into his mouth. All his amorous adventures were concerned + with the search for opportunities for procuring this difficult + gratification. Closets in which he was able to hide, winter + weather and dull days he found most favorable to success. (A + somewhat similar case is recorded in the _Archives de + Neurologie_, 1902, p. 462.) + + In the case of a robust man of neuropathic heredity recorded by + Pelanda some light is shed on the psychic attitude in these + manifestations; there was masturbation up to the age of 16, when + he abandoned the practice, and up to the age of 30 found complete + satisfaction in drinking the still hot urine of women. When a + lady or girl in the house went to her room to satisfy a need of + this kind, she had hardly left it but he hastened in, overcome by + extreme excitement, culminating in spontaneous ejaculation. The + younger the woman the greater the transport he experienced. It is + noteworthy that in this, as possibly in all similar cases, there + was no sensory perversion and no morbid attraction of taste or + smell; he stated that the action of his senses was suspended by + his excitement, and that he was quite unable to perceive the odor + or taste of the fluid. (Pelanda, "Pornopatice," _Archivio di + Psichiatria_, facs. iii-iv, 1889, p. 356.) It is in the emotional + symbolism that the fascination lies and not in any sensory + perversion. + + Magnan records the spontaneous development of this sexual + symbolism in a girl of 11, of good intellectual development but + alcoholic heredity, who seduced a boy younger than herself to + mutual masturbation, and on one occasion, lying on the ground and + raising her clothes, asked him to urinate on her. (_International + Congress of Criminal Anthropology_, 1889.) This case (except for + the early age of the subject) illustrates sporadically occurring + urolagnic symbolism in a woman, to whom such symbolism is fairly + obvious on account of the close resemblance between the emission + of urine and the ejaculation of semen in the man, and the fact + that the same conduit serves for both fluids. (A urolagnic + day-dream of this kind is recorded in the history of a lady + contained in the third volume of these _Studies_, Appendix B, + History VIII.) The natural and inevitable character of this + symbolism is shown by the fact that among primitive peoples urine + is sometimes supposed to possess the fertilizing virtues of + semen. J.G. Frazer in his edition of Pausanias (vol. iv, p. 139) + brings together various stories of women impregnated by urine. + Hartland also (_Legend of Perseus_, vol. i, pp. 76, 92) records + legends of women who were impregnated by accidentally or + intentionally drinking urine. + + The symbolic sexual significance of urolagnia has hitherto + usually been confused with the fetichistic and mainly olfactory + perversion by which the excretion itself becomes a source of + sexual excitement. Long since Tardieu referred, under the name of + "renifleurs," to persons who were said to haunt the neighborhood + of quiet passages, more especially in the neighborhood of + theatres, and who when they perceived a woman emerge after + urination, would hasten to excite themselves by the odor of the + excretion. Possibly a fetichism of this kind existed in a case + recorded by Belletrud and Mercier (_Annales d'Hygiène Publique_, + June, 1904, p. 48). A weak-minded, timid youth, who was very + sexual but not attractive to women, would watch for women who + were about to urinate and immediately they had passed on would go + and lick the spot they had moistened, at the same time + masturbating. Such a fetichistic perversion is strictly analogous + to the fetichism by which women's handkerchiefs, aprons or + underlinen become capable of affording sexual gratification. A + very complete case of such urolagnic fetichism--complete because + separated from association with the person accomplishing the act + of urination--has been recorded by Moraglia in a woman. It is the + case of a beautiful and attractive young woman of 18, with thick + black hair, and expressive vivacious eyes, but sallow complexion. + Married a year previously, but childless, she experienced a + certain amount of pleasure in coitus, but she preferred + masturbation, and frankly acknowledged that she was highly + excited by the odor of fermented urine. So strong was this + fetichism that when, for instance, she passed a street urinal she + was often obliged to go aside and masturbate; once she went for + this purpose into the urinal itself and was almost discovered in + the act, and on another occasion into a church. Her perversion + caused her much worry because of the fear of detection. She + preferred, when she could, to obtain a bottle of urine--which + must be stale and a man's (this, she said, she could detect by + the smell)--and to shut herself up in her own room, holding the + bottle in one hand and repeatedly masturbating with the other. + (Moraglia, "Psicopatie Sessuali," _Archivio di Psichiatria_, vol. + xiii, fasc. 6, p. 267, 1892.) This case is of especial interest + because of the great rarity of fully developed fetichism in + women. In a slight and germinal degree I believe that cases of + fetichism are not uncommon in women, but they are certainly rare + in a well-marked form, and Krafft-Ebing declared, even in the + late editions of his _Psychopathia Sexualis_, that he knew of no + cases in women. + +So far we have been concerned with the urolagnic rather than the +coprolagnic variety of scatalogical symbolism. Although the two are +sometimes associated there is no necessary connection, and most usually +there is no tendency for the one to involve the other. Urolagnia is +certainly much the more frequently found; the act of urination is far more +apt to suggest erotically symbolical ideas than the idea of defecation. +It is not difficult to understand why this should be so. The act of +urination lends itself more easily to sexual symbolism; it is more +intimately associated with the genital function; its repetition is +necessary at more frequent intervals so that it is more in evidence; +moreover, its product, unlike that of the act of defecation, is not +offensive to the senses. Still coprolagnia occurs and not so very +infrequently. Burton remarked that even the normal lover is affected by +this feeling: "immo nec ipsum amicæ stercus foctet."[29] + +Of Caligula who, however, was scarcely sane, it was said "et quidem +stercus uxoris degustavit."[30] In Parisian brothels (according to Taxil +and others) provision is made for those who are sexually excited by the +spectacle of the act of defecation (without reference to contact or odor) +by means of a "tabouret de verre," from under the glass floor of which the +spectacle of the defecating women may be closely observed. It may be added +that the erotic nature of such a spectacle is referred to in the Marquis +de Sade's novels. + +There is one motive for the existence of coprolagnia which must not be +passed over, because it has doubtless frequently served as a mode of +transition to what, taken by itself, may well seem the least æsthetically +attractive of erotic symbols. I refer to the tendency of the nates to +become a sexual fetich. The nates have in all ages and in all parts of the +world been frequently regarded as one of the most æsthetically beautiful +parts of the feminine body.[31] It is probable that on the basis of this +entirely normal attraction more than one form of erotic symbolism is at +all events in part supported. Dühren and others have considered that the +æsthetic charm of the nates is one of the motives which prompt the desire +to inflict flagellation on women. In the same way--certainly in some and +probably in many cases--the sexual charm of the nates progressively +extends to the anal region, to the act of defecation, and finally to the +feces. + + In a case of Krafft-Ebing's (_Op. cit._, p. 183) the subject, + when a child of 6, accidentally placed his hand in contact with + the nates of the little girl who sat next to him in school, and + experienced so great a pleasure in this contact that he + frequently repeated it; when he was 10 a nursery governess, to + gratify her own desires, placed his finger in her vagina; in + adult life he developed urolagnic tendencies. + + In a case of Moll's the development of a youthful admiration for + the nates in a coprolagnic direction may be clearly traced. In + this case a young man, a merchant, in a good position, sought to + come in contact with women defecating; and with this object would + seek to conceal himself in closets; the excretal odor was + pleasurable to him, but was not essential to gratification, and + the sight of the nates was also exciting and at the same time not + essential to gratification; the act of defecation appears, + however, to have been regarded as essential. He never sought to + witness prostitutes in this situation; he was only attracted to + young, pretty and innocent women. The coprolagnia here, however, + had its source in a childish impression of admiration for the + nates. When 5 or 6 years old he crawled under the clothes of a + servant girl, his face coming in contact with her nates, an + impression that remained associated in his mind with pleasure. + Three or four years later he used to experience much pleasure + when a young girl cousin sat on his face; thus was strengthened + an association which developed naturally into coprolagnia. (Moll, + _Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 837.) + + It is scarcely necessary to remark that an admiration for the + nates, even when reaching a fetichistic degree, by no means + necessarily involves, even after many years, any attraction to + the excreta. A correspondent for whom the nates have constituted + a fetich for many years writes: "I find my craving for women with + profuse pelvic or posterior development is growing and I wish to + copulate from behind; but I would feel a sickening feeling if any + part of my person came in contact with the female anus. It is + more pleasing to me to see the nates than the mons, yet I loathe + everything associated with the anal region." + +Moll has recorded in detail a case of what may be described as "ideal +coprolagnia"--that is to say, where the symbolism, though fully developed +in imagination, was not carried into real life--which is of great interest +because it shows how, in a very intelligent subject, the deviated +symbolism may become highly developed and irradiate all the views of life +in the same way as the normal impulse. (The subject's desires were also +inverted, but from the present point of view the psychological interest of +the case is not thereby impaired.) Moll's case was one of symbolism of +act, the excreta offering no attraction apart from the process of +defecation. In a case which has been communicated to me there was, on the +other hand, an olfactory fetichistic attraction to the excreta even in the +absence of the person. + + In Moll's case, the patient, X., 23 years of age, belongs to a + family which he himself describes as nervous. His mother, who is + anæmic, has long suffered from almost periodical attacks of + excitement, weakness, syncope and palpitation. A brother of the + mother died in a lunatic asylum, and several other brothers + complain much of their nerves. The mother's sisters are very + good-natured, but liable to break out in furious passions; this + they inherit from their father. There appears to be no nervous + disease on the patient's father's side. X.'s sisters are also + healthy. + + X. himself is of powerful undersized build and enjoys good + health, injured by no excesses. He considers himself nervous. He + worked hard at school and was always the first in his class; he + adds, however, that this is due less to his own abilities than + the laziness of his school-fellows. He is, as he remarks, very + religious and prays frequently, but seldom goes to church. + + In regard to his psychic characters he says that he has no + specially prominent talent, but is much interested in languages, + mathematics, physics and philosophy, in fact, in abstract + subjects generally. "While I take a lively interest in every kind + of intellectual work," he says, "it is only recently that I have + been attracted to real life and its requirements. I have never + had much skill in physical exercises. For external things until + recently I have only had contempt. I have a delicately + constituted nature, loving solitude, and only associating with a + few select persons. I have a decided taste for fiction, poetry + and music; my temperament is idealistic and religious, with + strict conceptions of duty and morality, and aspirations towards + the good and beautiful. I detest all that is common and coarse, + and yet I can think and act in the way you will learn from the + following pages." + + Regarding his sexual life, X. made the following communication: + "During the last two years I have become convinced of the + perversion of my sexual instinct. I had often previously thought + that in me the impulse was not quite normal, but it is only + lately that I have become convinced of my complete perversion. I + have never read or heard of any case in which the sexual feelings + were of the same kind. Although I can feel a lively inclination + towards superior representatives of the female sex, and have + twice felt something like love, the sight or the recollection + even of a beautiful woman have never caused sexual excitement." + In the two exceptional instances mentioned it appears that X. had + an inclination to kiss the women in question, but that the + thought of coitus had no attraction. "In my voluptuous dreams, + connected with the emission of semen, women in seductive + situations have never appeared. I have never had any desire to + visit a _puella publica_. The love-stories of my fellow-students + seemed very silly, dances and balls were a horror to me, and only + on very rare occasions could I be persuaded to go into society. + It will be easy to guess the diagnosis in my case: I suffer from + the sexual attraction of my own sex, I am a lover of boys. + + "You cannot imagine what a world of thoughts, wishes, feelings + and impulses the words 'knabe,' 'pais,' 'garcon,' 'boy,' + 'ragazzo' have for me; one of these words, even in an unmeaning + clause of a translation-book, calls before me the whole sum of + associations which in course of time have become bound up with + this idea, and it is only with an effort that I can scare away + the wild band. This group of thoughts shows a wonderful mixture + of warm sensuality and ideal love, it unites my lowest and + highest impulses, the strength and the weakness of my nature, my + curse and my blessing. My inclination is especially towards boys + of the age of 12 to 15; though they may be rather younger or + older. That I should prefer beautiful and intelligent boys is + comprehensible. I do not want a prostitute, but a friend or a + son, whose soul I love, whom I can help to become a more perfect + man, such as I myself would willingly be. + + "When I myself belonged to that happy age (i.e., below 15) I had + no dearer wish than to possess a friend of similar tastes. I have + sought, hoped, waited, grieved, and been at last disillusioned, + overcome by desire and despair, and have not found that friend. + Even later the hope often reappeared, but always in vain, and I + cannot boast of that sure recognition which one reads of in the + autobiographies of Urnings. I do not know personally a single + fellow-sufferer. It is also doubtful whether such an + acquaintanceship would greatly help me, for I have a very + peculiar conception of homosexuality. As you will see, I have + little more in common with what are called pæderasts than sexual + indifference to the female sex, and I often ask myself: 'Does any + other man in the whole world feel like you? Are you alone in the + earth with your morbid desires? Are you a pariah of pariahs, or + is there, perhaps, another soul with similar longings living near + you? How often in summer have I gone to the lakes and streams + outside cities to seek boys bathing; but I always came back + unsatisfied, whether I found any or not. And in winter I have + been irresistibly impelled to return to the same spots, as if it + were sanctified by the boys, but my darlings had vanished and + cold winds blew over the icy floods, so that I would return + feeling as though I had buried all my happiness. + + "It must be borne in mind, therefore, that what I have to say + regarding my sexual impulses only refers to fancies and never to + their practical realization. My sensual impulses are not + connected with the sexual organs; all my voluptuous ideas are not + in the least connected with these parts. For this reason I have + never practiced onanism and _immissio membri in anum_ is as + repulsive to me as to a normal man. Even every imitation of + coitus is, for me, without attraction. In a boy's body two things + specially excite me: _his belly and his nates_, the first as + containing the digestive tract, the second as holding the opening + of the bowels. Of the vegetable processes of life in the boy none + interest me nearly so much as the progress of his digestion and + the process of defecation. It is incredible to what an extent + this part of physiology has occupied me from youth. If as a boy I + wanted to read something of a piquantly exciting character I + sought in my father's encyclopædia for articles like: + Obstruction, Constipation, Hæmorrhoids, Fæces, etc. No function + of the body seemed to be so significant as this, and I regarded + its disturbances as the most important in the whole mechanism of + life. The description of other disorders I could read in cold + blood, but intussusception of the bowels makes me ill even + to-day. I am always extremely pleased to hear that the digestion + of the people around me is in good condition. A man who did not + sufficiently watch over his digestion aroused distrust in me, and + I imagined that wicked men must be horribly indifferent regarding + this weighty matter. Even more than in ordinary persons was I + interested in the digestion of more mysterious beings, like + magicians in legends, or men of other nations. I would willingly + have made an anthropological study of my favorite subject, only + to my annoyance books nearly always pass over the matter in + silence. In history and fiction I regretted the absence of + information concerning the state of my heroes' digestion when + they languished in prison or in some unaccustomed or unhealthy + spot. For this reason I held no book more precious than one which + describes how a young man after being shipwrecked lived for a + long time in a narrow snow-hut, and it was conscientiously stated + that he became aware of digestive disturbances. No immorality + angers me more than the foolish practice of ladies who in society + neglect the satisfaction of their natural needs from misplaced + motives of modesty. On a railway journey I suffer horribly from + the thought that one of my fellow-travelers may be prevented from + fulfilling some imperative natural necessity. + + "I naturally devote the greatest attention to my own digestion. + With painful conscientiousness I go to stool every day at the + same hour; if the operation does not come off to my satisfaction + I feel not so much physical as mental discomfort. To this quite + useful hygienic interest became associated at puberty a sensual + interest. Since my fourteenth year I have had no greater + enjoyment than to defecate undressed (I do not do so now) after + having first carefully examined the distension of my abdomen. In + summer I would go into the woods, undress myself in a secluded + spot and indulge in the voluptuous pleasures of defecation. I + would sometimes combine with this a bath in a stream. I would + exhaust my imagination in the effort to invent specially + enjoyable variations, longed for a desert island where I could go + about naked, fill my body with much nourishing food, hold in the + excrement as long as possible and then discharge it in some + subtly-thought-out spot. These practices and ideas often caused + erections and later on emissions, but the genitals played no part + in my conceptions; their movements were uncomfortable and gave no + pleasure. + + "I soon longed to be associated in these orgies with some boy of + the same age, but I wanted not only a companion in my passion, + but also a real friend. Since there could be no question of + masturbation or pæderasty, our love would have been limited to + kisses, embraces, and--as a compensation for coitus--defecation + together. That would have been perfect bliss to me. I will spare + you the unæsthetic contents of my voluptuous dreams. But I + remained without a companion, and, therefore, without real + enjoyment. [He has, however, on various occasions experienced + erections, and even emissions, on seeing, by chance, men or boys + defecate.] Hinc illæ lacrimæ; the excitement over my own + defecation only took place _faute de mieux_. + + "I knew very well that my thoughts and practices were impure and + contemptible. Ah! how often, when the intoxication was over, have + I thrown myself remorsefully on my knees, praying to God for + pardon! For some weeks I repressed my longing; but at last it was + too strong for me, I tried to justify myself and fell into my + vice anew. That I was guilty of licentiousness and loved boys + sexually first became clear to me later on, when I knew the + significance of erection as a sign of sexual excitement. + + "No one can imagine with what demoniacal joy I am possessed at + the thought of a beautiful naked boy whose abdomen is filled as + the result of long abstinence from stool. The thought powerfully + excites me, a flood of passion goes through my blood and my limbs + tremble. I would never grow tired of feeling that belly and + looking at it. My passion would express itself in tempestuous + caresses, and the boy would have to assume various positions in + order to show off the beauty of his form, i.e., to bring the + parts in question into better view. To observe defecation would + still further increase this peculiar enjoyment. If the boy's + bowels were not sufficiently filled I would feed him with all + sorts of food which produces much excrement, such as potatoes, + coarse bread, etc. If possible I would seek to delay defecation + for two or three days, so that it might be as copious as + possible. When at last it occurred it would be an unspeakable joy + for me to watch the fæces--which would have to be fairly + firm--emerging from the anus." + + X. would like to be a teacher and thinks he could exert a + beneficial influence on boys. In spite of the pain he has + suffered he does not think he would like to be cured of his + perverse inclinations, for they have given him joy as well as + pain, and the pain has chiefly been owing to the fact that he + could not gratify his inclinations. X. smokes and drinks in + moderation, and has no feminine habits. (The foregoing is a + condensed summary of the case which is fully reported by Moll, + _Konträre Sexualempfindung_, third edition, pp. 295-305.) + + The case of coprolagnia communicated to me is that of a married + man, normal in all other respects, intellectually brilliant and + filling successfully a very responsible position. When a child + the women of his household were always indifferent as to his + presence in their bedrooms, and would satisfy all natural calls + without reserve before him. He would dream of this with + erections. His sexual interests became slowly centered in the act + of defecation, and this fetich throughout life never appealed to + him so powerfully as when associated with the particular type of + household furniture which was used for this purpose in his own + house. The act of defecation in the opposite sex or anything + pertaining to or suggesting the same caused uncontrollable sexual + excitement; the nates also exerted a great attraction. The alvine + excreta exerted this influence even in the absence of the woman; + it was, however, necessary that she should be a sexually + desirable person. The perversion in this case was not complete; + that is to say, that the excitement produced by the act of + defecation or the excretion itself was not actually preferred to + coitus; the sexual idea was normal coitus in the normal manner, + but preceded by the visual and olfactory enjoyment of the + exciting fetich. When coitus was not possible the enjoyment of + the fetich was accompanied by masturbation (as in the analogous + case of urolagnia in a woman summarized on p. 62.) On one + occasion he was discovered by a friend in a bedroom belonging to + a woman, engaged in the act of masturbation over a vessel + containing the desired fetich. In an agony of shame he begged the + mercy of silence concerning this episode, at the same time + revealing his life-history. He has constantly been haunted by the + dread of detection, as well as by remorse and the consciousness + of degradation, also by the fear that his unconquerable obsession + may lead him to the asylum. + +The scatalogic groups of sexual perversions, urolagnia and coprolagnia, as +may be sufficiently seen in this brief summary, are not merely olfactory +fetiches. They are, in a larger proportion of cases, dynamic symbols, a +preoccupation with physiological acts which, by associations of contiguity +and still more of resemblance, have gained the virtue of stimulating in +slight cases, and replacing in more extreme cases, the normal +preoccupation with the central physiological act itself. We have seen that +there are various considerations which amply suffice to furnish a basis +for such associations. And when we reflect that in the popular mind, and +to some extent in actual fact, the sexual act itself is, like urination +and defecation, an excretory act, we can understand that the true +excretory acts may easily become symbols of the pseudo-excretory act. It +is, indeed, in the muscular release of accumulated pressures and tensions, +involved by the act of liberating the stored-up excretion, that we have +the closest simulacrum of the tumescence and detumescence of the sexual +process.[32] + +In this way the erotic symbolism of urolagnia and coprolagnia is +completely analogous with that dynamic symbolism of the clinging and +swinging garments which Herrick has so accurately described, with the +complex symbolism of flagellation and its play of the rod against the +blushing and trembling nates, with the symbols of sexual strain and stress +which are embodied in the foot and the act of treading. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[24] Fuchs (_Das Erotische Element In der Karikatur_, p. 26), +distinguishing sharply between the "erotic" and the "obscene," reserves +the latter term exclusively for the representation of excretory organs and +acts. He considers that this is etymologically the most exact usage. +However that may be, it seems to me that, in any case, "obscene" has +become so vague a term that it is now impracticable to give it a +restricted and precise sense. + +[25] In this connection we may profitably contemplate the hand and recall +the vast gamut of functions, sacred and profane, which that organ +exercises. Many savages strictly reserve the left hand to the lowlier +purposes of life; but in civilization that is not considered necessary, +and it may be wholesome for some of us to meditate on the more humble uses +of the same hand which is raised in the supreme gesture of benediction and +which men have often counted it a privilege to kiss. + +[26] See, e.g., Morselli, _Una Causa di Nullità del Matrimonio_, 1902, p. +39. + +[27] Féré, _Comptes-Rendus Société de Biologie_, July 23, 1904. + +[28] Transactions of the International Medical Congress, Moscow, vol. iv, +p. 19. A similar symbolism may be traced in many of the cases in which the +focus of modesty becomes in modest women centered in the excretory sphere +and sometimes exaggerated to the extent of obsession. It must not be +supposed, however, that every obsession in this sphere has a symbolical +value of an erotic kind. In the case, for instance, which has been +recorded by Raymond and Janet (_Les Obsessions_, vol. ii, p. 306) of a +woman who spent much of her time in the endeavor to urinate perfectly, +always feeling that she failed in some respect, the obsession seems to +have risen fortuitously on a somewhat neurotic basis without reference to +the sexual life. + +[29] _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. III, Subs. I. + +[30] It may be remarked here that while the eating of excrement (apart +from its former use as a magic charm and as a therapeutic agent) is in +civilization now confined to sexual perverts and the insane, among some +animals it is normal as a measure of hygiene in relation to their young. +Thus, as, e.g., the Rev. Arthur East writes, the mistle thrush swallows +the droppings of its young. (_Knowledge_, June 1, 1899, p. 133.) In the +dog I have observed that the bitch licks her puppies shortly after birth +as they urinate, absorbing the fluid. + +[31] See, e.g., the previous volume of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection +in Man," pp. 165 et seq., and Dühren, _Geschlechtsleben in England_, bd. +ii, pp. 258, et seq. + +[32] In the study of _Love and Pain_ in a previous volume (p. 130) I have +quoted the remarks of a lady who refers to the analogy between sexual +tension and vesical tension--"Cette volupté que ressentent les bords de la +mer, d'être toujours pleins sans jamais déborder"--and its erotic +significance. + + + + +IV. + +Animals as Sources of Erotic Symbolism--Mixoscopic Zoophilia--The +Stuff-fetichisms--Hair-fetichism--The Stuff-fetichisms Mainly on a Tactile +Base--Erotic Zoophilia--Zooerastia--Bestiality--The Conditions that Favor +Bestiality--Its Wide Prevalence Among Primitive Peoples and Among +Peasants--The Primitive Conception of Animals--The Goat--The Influence of +Familiarity with Animals--Congress Between Women and Animals--The Social +Reaction Against Bestiality. + + +The erotic symbols with which we have so far been concerned have in every +case been portions of the body, or its physiological processes, or at +least the garments which it has endowed with life. The association on +which the symbol has arisen has in every case been in large measure, +although not entirely, an association of contiguity. It is now necessary +to touch on a group of sexual symbols in which the association of +contiguity with the human body is absent: the various methods by which +animals or animal products or the sight of animal copulation may arouse +sexual desire in human persons. Here we encounter a symbolism mainly +founded on association by resemblance; the animal sexual act recalls the +human sexual act; the animal becomes the symbol of the human being. + +The group of phenomena we are here concerned with includes several +subdivisions. There is first the more or less sexual pleasure sometimes +experienced, especially by young persons, in the sight of copulating +animals. This I would propose to call Mixoscopic Zoophilia; it falls +within the range of normal variation. Then we have the cases in which the +contact of animals, stroking, etc., produces sexual excitement or +gratification; this is a sexual fetichism in the narrow sense, and is by +Krafft-Ebing termed _Zoophilia Erotica_. We have, further, the class of +cases in which a real or simulated sexual intercourse with animals is +desired. Such cases are not regarded as fetichism by Krafft-Ebing,[33] +but they come within the phenomena of erotic symbolism as here understood. +This class falls into two divisions: one in which the individual is fairly +normal, but belongs to a low grade of culture; the other in which he may +belong to a more refined social class, but is affected by a deep degree of +degeneration. In the first case we may properly apply the term bestiality; +in the second case it may perhaps be better to use the term _zooerastia_, +proposed by Krafft-Ebing.[34] + +Among children, both boys and girls, it is common to find that the +copulation of animals is a mysteriously fascinating spectacle. It is +inevitable that this should be so, for the spectacle is more or less +clearly felt to be the revelation of a secret which has been concealed +from them. It is, moreover, a secret of which they feel intimate +reverberations within themselves, and even in perfectly innocent and +ignorant children the sight may produce an obscure sexual excitement.[35] +It would seem that this occurs more frequently in girls than in boys. Even +in adult age, it may be added, women are liable to experience the same +kind of emotion in the presence of such spectacles. One lady recalls, as a +girl, that on several occasions an element of physical excitement entered +into the feelings with which she watched the coquetry of cats. Another +lady mentions that at the age of about 25, and when still quite ignorant +of sexual matters, she saw from a window some boys tickling a dog and +inducing sexual excitement in the animal; she vaguely divined what they +were doing, and though feeling disgust at their conduct she at the same +time experienced in a strong degree what she now knows was sexual +excitement. The coupling of the larger animals is often an impressive and +splendid spectacle which is far, indeed, from being obscene, and has +commended itself to persons of intellectual distinction;[36] but in young +or ill-balanced minds such sights tend to become both prurient and morbid. +I have already referred to the curious case of a sexually hyperæsthetic +nun who was always powerfully excited by the sight or even the +recollection of flies in sexual connection, so that she was compelled to +masturbate; this dated from childhood. After becoming a nun she recorded +having had this experience, followed by masturbation, more than four +hundred times.[37] Animal spectacles sometimes produce a sexual effect on +children even when not specifically sexual; thus a correspondent, a +clergyman, informs me that when a young and impressionable boy, he was +much affected by seeing a veterinary surgeon insert his hand and arm into +a horse's rectum, and dreamed of this several times afterward with +emissions. + +While the contemplation of animal coitus is an easily intelligible and in +early life, perhaps, an almost normal symbol of sexual emotion, there is +another subdivision of this group of animal fetichisms which forms a more +natural transition from the fetichisms which have their center in the +human body: the stuff-fetichisms, or the sexual attraction exerted by +various tissues, perhaps always of animal origin. Here we are in the +presence of a somewhat complicated phenomenon. In part we have, in a +considerable number of such cases, the sexual attraction of feminine +garments, for all such tissues are liable to enter into the dress. In +part, also, we have a sexual perversion of tactile sensibility, for in a +considerable proportion of these cases it is the touch sensations which +are potent in arousing the erotic sensations. But in part, also, it would +seem, we have here the conscious or subconscious presence of an animal +fetich, and it is notable that perhaps all these stuffs, and especially +fur, which is by far the commonest of the groups, are distinctively animal +products. We may perhaps regard the fetich of feminine hair--a much more +important and common fetich, indeed, than any of the stuff fetichisms--as +a link of transition. Hair is at once an animal and a human product, while +it may be separated from the body and possesses the qualities of a stuff. +Krafft-Ebing remarks that the senses of touch, smell, and hearing, as well +as sight, seem to enter into the attraction exerted by hair. + + The natural fascination of hair, on which hair-fetichism is + founded, begins at a very early age. "The hair is a special + object of interest with infants," Stanley Hall concludes, "which + begins often in the latter part of the first year.... The hair, + no doubt, gives quite unique tactile sensations, both in its own + roots and to hands, and is plastic and yielding to the motor + sense, so that the earliest interest may be akin to that in fur, + which is a marked object in infant experience. Some children + develop an almost fetichistic propensity to pull or later to + stroke the hair or beard of every one with whom they come in + contact." (G. Stanley Hall, "The Early Sense of Self," _American + Journal of Psychology_, April, 1898, p. 359.) + + It should be added that the fascination of hair for the infantile + and childish mind is not necessarily one of attraction, but may + be of repulsion. It happens here, as in the case of so many + characteristics which are of sexual significance, that we are in + the presence of an object which may exert a dynamic emotional + force, a force which is capable of repelling with the same energy + that it attracts. Féré records the instructive case of a child of + 3, of psychopathic heredity, who when he could not sleep was + sometimes taken by his mother into her bed. One night his hand + came in contact with a hairy portion of his mother's body, and + this, arousing the idea of an animal, caused him to leap out of + the bed in terror. He became curious as to the cause of his + terror and in time was able to observe "the animal," but the + train of feelings which had been set up led to a life-long + indifference to women and a tendency to homosexuality. It is + noteworthy that he was attracted to men in whom the hair and + other secondary sexual characters were well developed. (Féré, + _L'Instinct Sexuel_, second edition, pp. 262-267.) + + As a sexual fetich hair strictly belongs to the group of parts of + the body; but since it can be removed from the body and is + sexually effective as a fetich in the absence of the person to + whom it belongs, it is on a level with the garments which may + serve in a similar way, with shoes or handkerchiefs or gloves. + Psychologically, hair-fetichism presents no special problem, but + the wide attraction of hair--it is sexually the most generally + noted part of the feminine body after the eyes--and the peculiar + facility with which when plaited it may be removed, render + hair-fetichism a sexual perversion of specially great + medico-legal interest. + + The frequency of hair-fetichism, as well as of the natural + admiration on which it rests, is indicated by a case recorded by + Laurent. "A few years ago," he states, "one constantly saw at the + Bal Bullier, in Paris, a tall girl whose face was lean and bony, + but whose black hair was of truly remarkable length. She wore it + flowing down her shoulders and loins. Men often followed her in + the street to touch or kiss the hair. Others would accompany her + home and pay her for the mere pleasure of touching and kissing + the long black tresses. One, in consideration of a relatively + considerable sum, desired to pollute the silky hair. She was + obliged to be always on her guard, and to take all sorts of + precautions to prevent any one cutting off this ornament, which + constituted her only beauty as well as her livelihood." (E. + Laurent, _L'Amour Morbide_, 1891, p. 164; also the same author's + _Fétichistes et Erotomanes_, p. 23.) + + The hair despoiler (_Coupeur des Nattes_ or _Zopfabschneider_) + may be found in any civilized country, though the most carefully + studied cases have occurred in Paris. (Several medico-legal + histories of hair-despoilers are summarized by Krafft-Ebing, _Op. + cit._, pp. 329-334). Such persons are usually of nervous + temperament and bad heredity; the attraction to hair occasionally + develops in early life; sometimes the morbid impulse only appears + in later life after fever. The fetich may be either flowing hair + or braided hair, but is usually one or the other, and not both. + Sexual excitement and ejaculation may be produced in the act of + touching or cutting off the hair, which is subsequently, in many + cases, used for masturbation. As a rule the hair-despoiler is a + pure fetichist, no element of sadistic pleasure entering into his + feelings. In the case of a "capillary kleptomaniac" in Chicago--a + highly intelligent and athletic married young man of good + family--the impulse to cut off girls' braids appeared after + recovery from a severe fever. He would gaze admiringly at the + long tresses and then clip them off with great rapidity; he did + this in some fifty cases before he was caught and imprisoned. He + usually threw the braids away before he reached home. (_Alienist + and Neurologist_, April, 1889, p. 325.) In this case there is no + history of sexual excitement, probably because no proper + medico-legal examination was made. (It may be added that + hair-despoilers have been specially studied by Motet, "Les + Coupeurs de Nattes," _Annales d'Hygiène_, 1890.) + +The stuff-fetiches are most usually fur and velvet; feathers, silk, and +leathers also sometimes exert this influence; they are all, it will be +noted, animal substances.[38] The most interesting is probably fur, the +attraction of which is not uncommon in association with passive +algolagnia. As Stanley Hall has shown, the fear of fur, as well as the +love of it, is by no means uncommon in childhood; it may appear even in +infancy and in children who have never come in contact with animals.[39] +It is noteworthy that in most cases of uncomplicated stuff-fetichism the +attraction apparently arises on a congenital basis, as it appears in +persons of nervous or sensitive temperament at an early age and without +being attached to any definite causative incident. The sexual excitation +is nearly always produced by the touch rather than by the sight. As we +found, when dealing with the sense of touch in the previous volume, the +specific sexual sensations may be regarded as a special modification of +ticklishness. The erotic symbolism in the case of these stuff-fetichisms +would seem to be a more or less congenital perversion of ticklishness in +relation to specific animal contacts. + +A further degree of perversion in this direction is reached in a case of +erotic _zoophilia_, recorded by Krafft-Ebing.[40] In this case a +congenital neuropath, of good intelligence but delicate and anæmic, with +feeble sexual powers, had a great love of domestic animals, especially +dogs and cats, from an early age; when petting them he experienced sexual +emotions, although he was innocent in sexual matters. At puberty he +realized the nature of his feelings and tried to break himself of his +habits. He succeeded, but then began erotic dreams accompanied by images +of animals, and these led to masturbation associated with ideas of a +similar kind. At the same time he had no wish for any sort of sexual +intercourse with animals, and was indifferent as to the sex of the animals +which attracted him; his sexual ideals were normal. Such a case seems to +be fundamentally one of fetichism on a tactile basis, and thus forms a +transition between the stuff-fetichisms and the complete perversions of +sexual attraction toward animals. + + In some cases sexually hyperæsthetic women have informed me that + sexual feeling has been produced by casual contact with pet dogs + and cats. In such cases there is usually no real perversion, but + it seems probable that we may here have an occasional foundation + for the somewhat morbid but scarcely vicious excesses of + affection which women are apt to display towards their pet dogs + or cats. In most cases of this affection there is certainly no + sexual element; in the case of childless women, it may rather be + regarded as a maternal than as an erotic symbolism. (The excesses + of this non-erotic zoophilia have been discussed by Féré, + _L'Instinct Sexuel_, second edition, pp. 166-171.) + +Krafft-Ebing considers that complete perversion of sexual attraction +toward animals is radically distinct from erotic _zoophilia_. This view +cannot be accepted. Bestiality and _zooerastia_ merely present in a more +marked and profoundly perverted form a further degree of the same +phenomenon which we meet with in erotic _zoophilia_; the difference is +that they occur either in more insensitive or in more markedly degenerate +persons. + +A fairly typical case of _zooerastia_ has been recorded in America by +Howard, of Baltimore. This was the case of a boy of 16, precociously +mature and fairly bright. He was, however, indifferent to the opposite +sex, though he had ample opportunity for gratifying normal passions. His +parents lived in the city, but the youth had an inordinate desire for the +country and was therefore sent to school in a village. On the second day +after his arrival at school a farmer missed a sow which was found secreted +in an outhouse on the school grounds. This was the first of many similar +incidents in which a sow always took part. So strong was his passion that +on one occasion force had to be used to take him away from the sow he was +caressing. He did not masturbate, and even when restrained from +approaching sows he had no sexual inclination for other animals. His +nocturnal pollutions, which were frequent, were always accompanied by +images of wallowing swine. Notwithstanding careful treatment no cure was +effected; mental and physical vigor failed, and he died at the age of +23.[41] + +It is, however, somewhat doubtful whether we can always or even usually +distinguish between zooerastia and bestiality. Dr. G.F. Lydston, of +Chicago, has communicated to me a case (in which he was consulted) which +seems fairly typical and is instructive in this respect. The subject was a +young man of 21, a farmer's son, not very bright intellectually, but very +healthy and strong, of great assistance on the farm, very capable and +industrious, such a good farm hand that his father was unwilling to send +him away and to lose his services. There was no history of insanity or +neurosis in the family, and no injury or illness in his own history. He +had spells of moroseness and irritability, however, and had also been a +masturbator. Women had no attraction for him, but he would copulate with +the mares upon his father's farm, and this without regard to time, place, +or spectators. Such a case would seem to stand midway between ordinary +bestiality and pathological zooerastia as defined by Krafft-Ebing, yet it +seems probable that in most cases of ordinary bestiality some slight +traces of mental anomaly might be found, if such cases always were, as +they should be, properly investigated.[42] + +We have here reached the grossest and most frequent perversion in this +group; bestiality, or the impulse to attain sexual gratification by +intercourse, or other close contact, with animals. In seeking to +comprehend this perversion it is necessary to divest ourselves of the +attitude toward animals which is the inevitable outcome of refined +civilization and urban life. Most sexual perversions, if not in large +measure the actual outcome of civilized life, easily adjust themselves to +it. Bestiality (except in one form to be noted later) is, on the other +hand, the sexual perversion of dull, insensitive and unfastidious persons. +It flourishes among primitive peoples and among peasants. It is the vice +of the clodhopper, unattractive to women or inapt to court them. + +Three conditions have favored the extreme prevalence of bestiality: (1) +primitive conceptions of life which built up no great barrier between man +and the other animals; (2) the extreme familiarity which necessarily +exists between the peasant and his beasts, often combined with separation +from women; (3) various folk-lore beliefs such as the efficacy of +intercourse with animals as a cure for venereal disease, etc.[43] + +The beliefs and customs of primitive peoples, as well as their mythology +and legends, bring before us a community of man and animals altogether +unlike anything we know in civilization. Men may become animals and +animals may become men; animals and men may communicate with each other +and live on terms of equality; animals may be the ancestors of human +tribes; the sacred totems of savages are most usually animals. There is no +shame or degradation in the notion of a sexual relationship between men +and animals, because in primitive conceptions animals are not inferior +beings separated from man by a great gulf. They are much more like men in +disguise, and in some respects possess powers which make them superior to +men. This is recognized in those plays, festivals, and religious dances, +so common among primitive peoples, in which animal disguises are worn.[44] +When men admire and emulate the qualities of animals and are proud to +believe that they descend from them, it is not surprising that they should +sometimes see nothing derogatory in sexual intercourse with them.[45] + +A significant relic of primitive conceptions in this matter may perhaps be +found in the religious rites connected with the sacred goat of Mendes +described by Herodotus. After telling how the Mendesians reverence the +goat, especially the he-goat, out of their veneration for Pan, whom they +represent as a goat ("the real motive which they assign for this custom I +do not choose to relate"), he adds: "It happened in this country, and +within my remembrance, and was indeed universally notorious, that a goat +had indecent and public communication with a woman."[46] The meaning of +the passage evidently is that in the ordinary intercourse of women with +the sacred goat, connection was only simulated or incomplete on account of +the natural indifference of the goat to the human female, but that in rare +cases the goat proved sexually excitable with the woman and capable of +connection.[47] The goat has always been a kind of sacred emblem of lust. +In the middle ages it became associated with the Devil as one of the +favorite forms he assumed. It is significant of a primitively religious +sexual association between men and animals, that witches constantly +confessed, or were made to confess, that they had had intercourse with the +Devil in the shape of an animal, very frequently a dog. The figures of +human beings and animals in conjunction carved on temples in India, also +seem to indicate the religious significance which this phenomenon +sometimes presents. There is, indeed, no need to go beyond Europe even in +her moments of highest culture to find a religious sanction for sexual +union between human beings, or gods in human shape, and animals. The +legends of Io and the bull, of Leda and the swan, are among the most +familiar in Greek mythology, and in a later pictorial form they constitute +some of the most cherished works of the painters of the Renaissance. + +As regards the prevalence of occasional sexual intercourse between men or +women and animals among primitive peoples at the present time, it is +possible to find many scattered references by travelers in all parts of +the world. Such references by no means indicate that such practices are, +as a rule, common, but they usually show that they are accepted with a +good-humored indifference.[48] + +Bestiality is very rarely found in towns. In the country this vice of the +clodhopper is far from infrequent. For the peasant, whose sensibilities +are uncultivated and who makes but the most elementary demands from a +woman, the difference between an animal and a human being in this respect +scarcely seems to be very great. "My wife was away too long," a German +peasant explained to the magistrate, "and so I went with my sow." It is +certainly an explanation that to the uncultivated peasant, ignorant of +theological and juridical conceptions, must often seem natural and +sufficient. + + Bestiality thus resembles masturbation and other abnormal + manifestations of the sexual impulse which may be practiced + merely _faute de mieux_ and not as, in the strict sense, + perversions of the impulse. Even necrophily may be thus + practiced. A young man who when assisting the grave-digger + conceived and carried out the idea of digging up the bodies of + young girls to satisfy his passions with, and whose case has + been recorded by Belletrud and Mercier, said: "I could find no + young girl who would agree to yield to my desires; that is why I + have done this. I should have preferred to have relations with + living persons. I found it quite natural to do what I did: I saw + no harm in it, and I did not think that any one else could. As + living women felt nothing but repulsion for me, it was quite + natural I should turn to the dead, who have never repulsed me. I + used to say tender things to them like 'my beautiful, my love, I + love you.'" (Belletrud and Mercier "Perversion de l'Instinct + Genésique," _Annales d'Hygiène Publique_, June, 1903.) But when + so highly abnormal an act is felt as natural we are dealing with + a person who is congenitally defective so far as the finer + developments of intelligence are concerned. It was so in this + case of necrophily; he was the son of a weak-minded woman of + unrestrainable sexual inclinations, and was himself somewhat + feeble-minded; he was also, it is instructive to observe, + anosmic. + +But it is by no means only their dulled sensibility or the absence of +women, which accounts for the frequency of bestiality among peasants. A +highly important factor is their constant familiarity with animals. The +peasant lives with animals, tends them, learns to know all their +individual characters; he understands them far better than he understands +men and women; they are his constant companions, his friends. He knows, +moreover, the details of their sexual lives, he witnesses the often highly +impressive spectacle of their coupling. It is scarcely surprising that +peasants should sometimes regard animals as being not only as near to them +as their fellow human beings, but even nearer. + +The significance of the factor of familiarity is indicated by the great +frequency of bestiality among shepherds, goatherds, and others whose +occupation is exclusively the care of animals. Mirabeau, in the eighteenth +century, stated, on the evidence of Basque priests, that all the shepherds +in the Pyrenees practice bestiality. It is apparently much the same in +Italy.[49] In South Italy and Sicily, especially, bestiality among +goatherds and peasants is said to be almost a national custom.[50] In the +extreme north of Europe, it is reported, the reindeer, in this respect, +takes the place of the goat. + +The importance of the same factor is also shown by the fact that when +among women in civilization animal perversions appear, the animal is +nearly always a pet dog. Usually in these cases the animal is taught to +give gratification by _cunnilinctus_. In some cases, however, there is +really sexual intercourse between the animal and the woman. + + Moll mentions that in a case of _cunnilinctus_ by a dog in + Germany there was a difficulty as to whether the matter should be + considered an unnatural offence or simply an offence against + decency; the lower court considered it in the former light, while + the higher court took the more merciful view. (Moll, + _Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 697.) In a + case reported by Pfaff and mentioned by Moll, a country girl was + accused of having sexual intercourse with a large dog. On + examination Pfaff found in the girl's thick pubic hair a loose + hair which under the microscope proved to belong to the dog. + (_Loc. cit._, p. 698.) In such a case it must be noted that while + this evidence may be held to show sexual contact with the dog, it + scarcely suffices to show sexual intercourse. This has, however, + undoubtedly occurred from time to time, even more or less openly. + Bloch (_Op. cit._, pp. 277 and 282) remarks that this is not an + infrequent exhibition given by prostitutes in certain brothels. + Maschka has referred to such an exhibition between a woman and a + bull-dog, which was given to select circles in Paris. Rosse + refers to a case in which a young unmarried woman in Washington + was surprised during intercourse with a large English mastiff, + who in his efforts to get loose caused such severe injuries that + the woman died from hæmorrhage in about an hour. Rosse also + mentions that some years ago a performance of this kind between a + prostitute and a Newfoundland dog could be witnessed in San + Francisco by paying a small sum; the woman declared that a woman + who had once copulated with a dog would ever afterwards prefer + this animal to a man. Rosse adds that he was acquainted with a + similar performance between a woman and a donkey, which used to + take place in Europe (Irving Rosse, "Sexual Hypochondriasis and + Perversion of the Genesic Instinct," _Virginia Medical Monthly_, + October, 1892, p. 379). Juvenal mentions such relations between + the donkey and woman (vi, 332). Krauss (quoted by Bloch, + _Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil II, p. + 276) states that in Bosnia women sometimes carry on these + practices with dogs and also--as he would not have believed had + he not on one occasion observed it--with cats. "It seems to me," + writes Dr. Kiernan, of Chicago, (private letter) "that what Rosse + says of the animal exhibitions in San Francisco is true of all + great cities. The animal employed in such exhibitions here has + usually been a donkey, and in one instance death occurred from + the animal trampling the girl partner. The practice described + occurs in country regions quite frequently. Thus in a case + reported in the suburbs of Omaha, Nebraska, a sixteen-year-old + boy engaged in rectal coitus with a large dog. In attempting to + extricate his swollen penis from the boy's rectum the dog tore + through the _sphincter ani_ an inch into the gluteus muscles. + (_Omaha Clinic_, March, 1893.) In a Missouri case, which I + verified, a smart, pretty, well-educated country girl was found + with a profuse offensive vaginal discharge which had been present + for about a week, coming on suddenly. After washing the external + genitals and opening the labia three rents were discovered, one + through the fourchette and two through the left nymphæ. The + vagina was excessively congested and covered with points bleeding + on the slightest irritation. The patient confessed that one day + while playing with the genitals of a large dog she became excited + and thought she would have slight coitus. After the dog had made + an entrance she was unable to free herself from him, as he + clasped her so firmly with his fore legs. The penis became so + swollen that the dog could not free himself, although for more + than an hour she made persistent efforts to do so. (_Medical + Standard_, June, 1903, p. 184). In an Indiana case, concerning + which I was consulted, the girl was a hebephreniac who had + resorted to this procedure with a Newfoundland dog at the + instance of another girl, seemingly normal as regards mentality, + and had been badly injured; a discharge resulted which resembled + gonorrhoea, but contained no gonococci. These cases are probably + more frequent than is usually assumed." + + Women are known to have had intercourse with various other + animals, occasionally or habitually, in various parts of the + world. Monkeys have been mentioned in this connection. Moll + remarks that it seems to be an indication of an abnormal interest + in monkeys that some women are observed by the attendants in the + monkey-house of zoölogical gardens to be very frequent visitors. + Near the Amazon the traveler Castelnau saw an enormous Coati + monkey belonging to an Indian woman and tried to purchase it; + though he offered a large sum, the woman only laughed. "Your + efforts are useless," remarked an Indian in the same cabin, "he + is her husband." (So far as the early literature of this subject + is concerned, a number of facts and fables regarding the congress + of women with dogs, goats and other animals was brought together + at the beginning of the eighteenth century by Schurig in his + _Gynæcologia_, Section II, cap. VII; I have not drawn on this + collection.) + + In some cases women, and also men, find gratification in the + sexual manipulation of animals without any kind of congress. This + may be illustrated by an observation communicated to me by a + correspondent, a clergyman. "In Ireland, my father's house + adjoined the residence of an archdeacon of the established + church. I was then about 20 and was still kept in religious awe + of evil ways. The archdeacon had two daughters, both of whom he + brought up in great strictness, resolved that they should grow up + examples of virtue and piety. Our stables adjoined, and were + separated only by a thin wall in which was a doorway closed up by + some boards, as the two stables had formerly been one. One night + I had occasion to go to our stable to search for a garden tool I + had missed, and I heard a door open on the other side, and saw a + light glimmer through the cracks of the boards. I looked through + to ascertain who could be there at that late hour, and soon + recognized the stately figure of one of the daughters, F.F. was + tall, dark and handsome, but had never made any advances to me, + nor had I to her. She was making love to her father's mare after + a singular fashion. Stripping her right arm, she formed her + fingers into a cone, and pressed on the mare's vulva. I was + astonished to see the beast stretching her hind legs as if to + accommodate the hand of her mistress, which she pushed in + gradually and with seeming ease to the elbow. At the same time + she seemed to experience the most voluptuous sensation, crisis + after crisis arriving." My correspondent adds that, being + exceedingly curious in the matter, he tried a somewhat similar + experiment himself with one of his father's mares and experienced + what he describes as "a most powerful sexual battery" which + produced very exciting and exhausting effects. Näcke + (_Psychiatrische en Neurologische Bladen_, 1899, No. 2) refers to + an idiot who thus manipulated the vulva of mares in his charge. + The case has been recorded by Guillereau (_Journal de Médicine + Véterinaire et de Zootechnie_, January, 1899) of a youth who was + accustomed to introduce his hand into the vulva of cows in order + to obtain sexual excitement. + + The possibility of sexual excitement between women and animals + involves a certain degree of sexual excitability in animals from + contact with women. Darwin stated that there could be no doubt + that various quadrumanous animals could distinguish women from + men--in the first place probably by smell and secondarily by + sight--and be thus liable to sexual excitement. He quotes the + opinions on this point of Youatt, Brehm, Sir Andrew Smith and + Cuvier (_Descent of Man_, second edition, p. 8). Moll quotes the + opinion of an experienced observer to the same effect + (_Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, Bd. i, p. 429). + Hufeland reported the case of a little girl of three who was + playing, seated on a stool, with a dog placed between her thighs + and locked against her. Seemingly excited by this contact the + animal attempted a sort of copulation, causing the genital parts + of the child to become inflamed. Bloch (_Op. cit._, p. 280, _et + seq._) discusses the same point; he does not consider that + animals will of their own motion sexually cohabit with women, but + that they may be easily trained to it. There can be no doubt that + dogs at all events are sometimes sexually excited by the presence + of women, perhaps especially during menstruation, and many women + are able to bear testimony to the embarrassing attentions they + have sometimes received from strange dogs. There can be no + difficulty in believing that, so far as _cunnilinctus_ is + concerned dogs would require no training. In a case recorded by + Moll (_Konträre Sexualempfindung_, third edition, p. 560) a lady + states that this was done to her when a child, as also to other + children, by dogs who, she said, showed signs of sexual + excitement. In this case there was also sexual excitement thus + produced in the child, and after puberty mutual _cunnilinctus_ + was practiced with girl friends. Guttceit (_Dreissig Jahre + Praxis_, Theil I, p. 310) remarks that some Russian officers who + were in the Turkish campaign of 1828 told him that from fear of + veneral infection in Wallachia they refrained from women and + often used female asses which appeared to show signs of sexual + pleasure. + +A very large number of animals have been recorded as having been employed +in the gratification of sexual desire at some period or in some country, +by men and sometimes by women. Domestic animals are naturally those which +most frequently come into question, and there are few if any of these +which can altogether be excepted. The sow is one of the animals most +frequently abused in this manner.[51] Cases in which mares, cows, and +donkeys figure constantly occur, as well as goats and sheep. Dogs, cats, +and rabbits are heard of from time to time. Hens, ducks, and, especially +in China, geese, are not uncommonly employed. The Roman ladies were said +to have had an abnormal affection for snakes. The bear and even the +crocodile are also mentioned.[52] + +The social and legal attitude toward bestiality has reflected in part the +frequency with which it has been practiced, and in part the disgust mixed +with mystical and sacrilegious horror which it has aroused. It has +sometimes been met merely by a fine, and sometimes the offender and his +innocent partner have been burnt together. In the middle ages and later +its frequency is attested by the fact that it formed a favorite topic with +preachers of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. It is significant that +in the Penitentials,--which were criminal codes, half secular and half +spiritual, in use before the thirteenth century, when penance was +relegated to the judgment of the confessor,--it was thought necessary to +fix the periods of penance which should be undergone respectively by +bishops, priests and deacons who should be guilty of bestiality. + + In Egbert's Penitential, a document of the ninth and tenth + centuries, we read (V. 22): "Item Episcopus cum quadrupede + fornicans VII annos, consuetudinem X, presbyter V, diaconus III, + clerus II." There was a great range in the penances for + bestiality, from ten years to (in the case of boys) one hundred + days. The mare is specially mentioned (Haddon and Stubbs, + _Councils and Ecclesiastical Documents_, vol. iii, p. 422). In + Theodore's Penitential, another Anglo-Saxon document of about the + same age, those who habitually fornicate with animals are + adjudged ten years of penance. It would appear from the + _Penitentiale Pseudo-Romanum_ (which is earlier than the eleventh + century) that one year's penance was adequate for fornication + with a mare when committed by a layman (exactly the same as for + simple fornication with a widow or virgin), and this was + mercifully reduced to half a year if he had no wife. + (Wasserschleben, _Die Bussordnungen der Abendländlichen Kirche_, + p. 366). The _Penitentiale Hubertense_ (emanating from the + monastery of St. Hubert in the Ardennes) fixes ten years' penance + for sodomy, while Fulbert's Penitential (about the eleventh + century) fixes seven years for either sodomy or bestiality. + Burchard's Penitential, which is always detailed and precise, + specially mentions the mare, the cow and the ass, and assigns + forty days bread and water and seven years penance, raised to ten + years in the case of married men. A woman having intercourse with + a horse is assigned seven years penance in Burchard's + Penitential. (Wasserschleben, ib. pp. 651, 659.) + +The extreme severity which was frequently exercised toward those guilty of +this offense, was doubtless in large measure due to the fact that +bestiality was regarded as a kind of sodomy, an offense which was +frequently viewed with a mystical horror apart altogether from any actual +social or personal injury it caused. The Jews seem to have felt this +horror; it was ordered that the sinner and his victim should both be put +to death (Exodus, Ch. 22, v. 19; Leviticus, Ch. 20, v. 15). In the middle +ages, especially in France, the same rule often prevailed. Men and sows, +men and cows, men and donkeys were burnt together. At Toulouse a woman was +burnt for having intercourse with a dog. Even in the seventeenth century a +learned French lawyer, Claude Lebrun de la Rochette, justified such +sentences.[53] It seems probable that even to-day, in the social and legal +attitude toward bestiality, sufficient regard is not paid to the fact that +this offense is usually committed either by persons who are morbidly +abnormal or who are of so low a degree of intelligence that they border on +feeble-mindedness. To what extent, and on what grounds, it ought to be +punished is a question calling for serious reconsideration. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[33] For Krafft-Ebing's discussion of the subject see _Op. cit._, pp. +530-539. + +[34] In England it is not uncommon to use the term "unnatural offence;" +this is an awkward and possibly misleading practice which should not be +followed. In Germany a similar confusion is caused by applying the term +"sodomy" to these cases as well as to pederasty. Krafft-Ebing considers +that this error is due to the jurists, while the theologians have always +distinguished correctly. In this matter, he adds, science must be _ancilla +theologiæ_ and return to the correct usage of words. + +[35] This childish interest, with later abnormal developments, may be seen +in History I of the Appendix to this volume. + +[36] The Countess of Pembroke, Sir Philip Sidney's sister, appears to have +found sexual enjoyment in the contemplation of the sexual prowess of +stallions. Aubrey writes that she "was very salacious and she had a +contrivance that in the spring of the year ... the stallions ... were to +be brought before such a part of the house where she had a vidette to look +on them." (_Short Lives_, 1898, vol. i, p. 311.) Although the modern +editor's modesty has caused the disappearance of several lines from this +passage, the general sense is clear. In the same century Burchard, the +faithful secretary of Pope Alexander VI, describes in his invaluable diary +how four race horses were brought to two mares in a court of the Vatican, +the horses clamorously fighting for the possession of the mares and +eventually mounting them, while the Pope and his daughter Lucrezia looked +on from a window "cum magno risu et delectatione." (_Diarium_, ed Thuasne, +vol. III, p. 169.) + +[37] _Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1902, fasc. ii-iii, p. 338. In the case of +pathological sexuality in a boy of 15, reported by A. MacDonald, and +already summarized, the sight of copulating flies is also mentioned among +many other causes of sexual excitation. + +[38] Krafft-Ebing presents or quotes typical cases of all these fetiches, +_Op. cit._, pp. 255-266. + +[39] G. Stanley Hall, "A study of Fears," _American Journal of +Psychology_, 1897, pp. 213-215. + +[40] _Op. cit._, p. 268. + +[41] W. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," _Alienist and Neurologist_, January, +1896. Krafft-Ebing (op. cit., p. 532) quotes from Boeteau the somewhat +similar case of a gardener's boy of 16--an illegitimate child of +neuropathic heredity and markedly degenerate--who had a passion, of +irresistible and impulsive character, for rabbits. He was declared +irresponsible. Moll (_Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, pp. +431-433) presents the case of a neurotic man who from the age of 15 had +been sexually excited by the sight of animals or by contact with them. He +had repeatedly had connection with cows and mares; he was also sexually +excited by sheep, donkeys, and dogs, whether female or male; the normal +sexual instinct was weak and he experienced very slight attraction to +women. + +[42] Moll also remarks ("Perverse Sexualempfindung," in Senator's and +Kaminer's _Krankheiten und Ehe_) that in this matter it is often hardly +possible to draw a sharp line between vice and disease. + +[43] Instances of this widespread belief--found among the Tamils of Ceylon +as well as in Europe--are quoted from various authors by Bloch, _Beiträge +zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil II, p. 278, and Moll, +_Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 700. On the frequency +of bestiality, from one cause or another, in the East, see, e.g., Stern, +_Medizin und Geschlechtsleben in der Türkei_, bd. ii, p. 219. + +[44] Sometimes (as among the Aleuts) the animal pantomime dances of +savages may represent the transformation of a captive bird into a lovely +woman who falls exhausted into the arms of the hunter. (H.H. Bancroft, +_Native Races of the Pacific_, vol. i, p. 93.) A system of beliefs which +accepts the possibility that a human being may be latent in an animal +obviously favors the practice of bestiality. + +[45] For an example of the primitive confusion between the intercourse of +women with animals and with men see, e.g., Boas, "Sagen aus +British-Columbia," _Zeitschrift für Ethnologie_, heft V, p. 558. + +[46] Herodotus, Book II, Chapter 46. + +[47] Dulare (_Des Divinités Génératrices_, Chapter II) brings together the +evidence showing that in Egypt women had connection with the sacred goat, +apparently in order to secure fertility. + +[48] Various facts and references bearing on this subject are brought +together by Blumenbach, _Anthropological Memoirs_, translated by Bendyshe, +p. 80; Block, _Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil II, +pp. 276-283; also Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, seventh edition, p. 520. + +[49] Mantegazza mentions (_Gli Amori degli Uomini_, cap V) that at Rimini +a young goatherd of the Apennines, troubled with dyspepsia and nervous +symptoms, told him this was due to excesses with the goats in his care. A +finely executed marble group of a satyr having connection with a goat, +found at Herculaneum and now in the Naples Museum (reproduced in Fuchs's +_Erotische Element in der Karikatur_), perhaps symbolizes a traditional +and primitive practice of the goatherd. + +[50] Bayle (_Dictionary_, Art, Bathyllus) quotes various authorities +concerning the Italian auxiliaries in the south of France in the sixteenth +century and their custom of bringing and using goats for this purpose. +Warton in the eighteenth century was informed that in Sicily priests in +confession habitually inquired of herdsmen if they had anything to do with +their sows. In Normandy priests are advised to ask similar questions. + +[51] It is worth noting that in Greek the work choiros means both a sow +and a woman's pudenda; in the _Acharnians_ Aristophanes plays on this +association at some length. The Romans also (as may be gathered from +Varro's _De Re Rustica_) called the feminine pudenda _porcus_. + +[52] Schurig, _Gynæcologia_, pp. 280-387; Bloch, op. cit., 270-277. The +Arabs, according to Kocher, chiefly practice bestiality with goats, sheep +and mares. The Annamites, according to Mondière, commonly employ sows and +(more especially the young women) dogs. Among the Tamils of Ceylon +bestiality with goats and cows is said to be very prevalent. + +[53] Mantegazza (_Gli Amori degli Uomini_, cap. V) brings together some +facts bearing on this matter. + + + + +V. + +Exhibitionism--Illustrative Cases--A Symbolic Perversion of Courtship--The +Impulse to Defile--The Exhibitionist's Psychic Attitude--The Sexual Organs +as Fetichs--Phallus Worship--Adolescent Pride in Sexual +Development--Exhibitionism of the Nates--The Classification of the Forms +of Exhibitionism--Nature of the Relationship of Exhibitionism to Epilepsy. + + +There is a remarkable form of erotic symbolism--very definite and standing +clearly apart from all other forms--in which sexual gratification is +experienced in the simple act of exhibiting the sexual organ to persons of +the opposite sex, usually by preference to young and presumably innocent +persons, very often children. This is termed exhibitionism.[54] It would +appear to be a not very infrequent phenomenon, and most women, once or +more in their lives, especially when young, have encountered a man who has +thus deliberately exposed himself before them. + +The exhibitionist, though often a young and apparently vigorous man, is +always satisfied with the mere act of self-exhibition and the emotional +reaction which that act produces; he makes no demands on the woman to whom +he exposes himself; he seldom speaks, he makes no effort to approach her; +as a rule, he fails even to display the signs of sexual excitation. His +desires are completely gratified by the act of exhibition and by the +emotional reaction it arouses in the woman. He departs satisfied and +relieved. + + A case recorded by Schrenck-Notzing very well represents both the + nature of the impulse felt by the exhibitionist and the way in + which it may originate. It is the case of a business man of 49, + of neurotic heredity, an affectionate husband and father of a + family, who, to his own grief and shame, is compelled from time + to time to exhibit his sexual organs to women in the street. As a + boy of 10 a girl of 12 tried to induce him to coitus; both had + their sexual parts exposed. From that time sexual contacts, as of + his own naked nates against those of a girl, became attractive, + as well as games in which the boys and girls in turn marched + before each other with their sexual parts exposed, and also + imitation of the copulation of animals. Coitus was first + practiced about the age of 20, but sight and touch of the woman's + sexual parts were always necessary to produce sexual excitement. + It was also necessary--and this consideration is highly important + as regards the development of the tendency to exhibition--that + the woman should be excited by the sight of his organs. Even when + he saw or touched a woman's parts orgasm often occurred. It was + the naked sexual organs in an otherwise clothed body which + chiefly excited him. He was not possessed of a high degree of + potency. Girls between the ages of 10 and 17 chiefly excited him, + and especially if he felt that they were quite ignorant of sexual + matters. His self-exhibition was a sort of psychic defloration, + and it was accompanied by the idea that other people felt as he + did about the sexual effects of the naked organs, that he was + shocking but at the same time sexually exciting a young girl. He + was thus gratifying himself through the belief that he was + causing sexual gratification to an innocent girl. This man was + convicted several times, and was finally declared to be suffering + from impulsive insanity. (Schrenck-Notzing, + _Kriminal-psychologische und Psycho-pathologische Studien_, 1902, + pp. 50-57.) In another case of Schrenck-Notzing's, an actor and + portrait painter, aged 31, in youth masturbated and was fond of + contemplating the images of the sexual organs of both sexes, + finding little pleasure in coitus. At the age of 24, at a bathing + establishment, he happened to occupy a compartment next to that + occupied by a lady, and when naked he became aware that his + neighbor was watching him through a chink in the partition. This + caused him powerful excitement and he was obliged to masturbate. + Ever since he has had an impulse to exhibit his organs and to + masturbate in the presence of women. He believes that the sight + of his organs excites the woman (Ib., pp. 57-68). The presence of + masturbation in this case renders it untypical as a case of + exhibitionism. Moll at one time went so far as to assert that + when masturbation takes place we are not entitled to admit + exhibitionism, (_Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, + p. 661), but now accepts exhibitionism with masturbation + ("Perverse Sexualempfindung," _Krankheiten und Ehe_). The act of + exhibition itself gratifies the sexual impulse, and usually it + suffices to replace both tumescence and detumescence. + + A fairly typical case, recorded by Krafft-Ebing, is that of a + German factory worker of 37, a good, sober and intelligent + workman. His parents were healthy, but one of his mother's and + also one of his father's sisters were insane; some of his + relatives are eccentric in religion. He has a languishing + expression and a smile of self-complacency. He never had any + severe illness, but has always been eccentric and imaginative, + much absorbed in romances (such as Dumas's novels) and fond of + identifying himself with their heroes. No signs of epilepsy. In + youth moderate masturbation, later moderate coitus. He lives a + retired life, but is fond of elegant dress and of ornament. + Though not a drinker, he sometimes makes himself a kind of punch + which has a sexually exciting effect on him. The impulse to + exhibitionism has only developed in recent years. When the + impulse is upon him he becomes hot, his heart beats violently, + the blood rushes to his head, and he is oblivious of everything + around him that is not connected with his own act. Afterwards he + regards himself as a fool and makes vain resolutions never to + repeat the act. In exhibition the penis is only half erect and + ejaculation never occurs. (He is only capable of coitus with a + woman who shows great attraction to him.) He is satisfied with + self-exhibition, and believes that he thus gives pleasure to the + woman, since he himself receives pleasure in contemplating a + woman's sexual parts. His erotic dreams are of self-exhibition to + young and voluptuous women. He had been previously punished for + an offense of this kind; medico-legal opinion now recognized the + incriminated man's psychopathic condition. (Krafft-Ebing, _Op. + cit._, pp. 492-494.) + + Trochon has reported the case of a married man of 33, a worker in + a factory, who for several years had exhibited himself at + intervals to shop-girls, etc., in a state of erection, but + without speaking or making other advances. He was a hard-working, + honest, sober man of quiet habits, a good father to his family + and happy at home. He showed not the slightest sign of insanity. + But he was taciturn, melancholic and nervous; a sister was an + idiot. He was arrested, but on the report of the experts that he + committed these acts from a morbid impulse he could not control + he was released. (Trochon, _Archives de l'Anthropologie + Criminelle_, 1888, p. 256.) + + In a case of Freyer's (_Zeitschrift für Medizinalbeamte_, third + year, No. 8) the occasional connection of exhibitionism with + epilepsy is well illustrated by a barber's assistant, aged 35, + whose father suffered from chronic alcoholism and was also said + to have committed the same kind of offense as his son. The mother + and a sister suffered nervously. From ages of 7 to 18 the subject + had epileptic convulsions. From 16 to 21 he indulged in normal + sexual intercourse. At about that time he had often to pass a + playground and at times would urinate there; it happened that the + children watched him with curiosity. He noticed that when thus + watched sexual excitement was caused, inducing erection and even + ejaculation. He gradually found pleasure in this kind of sexual + gratification; finally he became indifferent to coitus. His + erotic dreams, though still usually about normal coitus, were now + sometimes concerned with exhibition before little girls. When + overcome by the impulse he could see and hear nothing around him, + though he did not lose consciousness. After the act was over he + was troubled by his deed. In all other respects he was entirely + reasonable. He was imprisoned many times for exhibiting himself + to young schoolgirls, sometimes vaunting the beauty of his organs + and inviting inspection. On one occasion he underwent mental + examination, but was considered to be mentally sound. He was + finally held to be a hereditarily tainted individual with + neuropathic constitution. The head was abnormally broad, penis + small, patellar reflex absent, and there were many signs of + neurasthenia. (Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, pp. 490-492.) + + The prevalence of epilepsy among exhibitionists is shown by the + observations of Pelanda in Verona. He has recorded six cases of + this perversion, all of which eventually reached the asylum and + were either epileptics or with epileptic relations. One had a + brother who was also an exhibitionist. In some cases the penis + was abnormally large, in others abnormally small. Several had + very weak sexual impulse; one, at the age of 62, had never + effected coitus, and was proud of the fact that he was still a + virgin, considering, he would say, the epoch of demoralization in + which we live. (Pelanda, "Pornopatici," _Archivio di + Psichiatria_, fasc. ii-iv, 1889.) + + In a very typical case of exhibitionism which Garnier has + recorded, a certain X., a gentleman engaged in business in Paris, + had a predilection for exhibiting himself in churches, more + especially in Saint-Roch. He was arrested several times for + exposing his sexual organs here before ladies in prayer. In this + way he finally ruined his commercial position in Paris and was + obliged to establish himself in a small provincial town. Here + again he soon exposed himself in a church and was again sent to + prison, but on his liberation immediately performed the same act + in the same church in what was described as a most imperturbable + manner. Compelled to leave the town, he returned to Paris, and in + a few weeks' time was again arrested for repeating his old + offense in Saint Roch. When examined by Garnier, the information + he supplied was vague and incomplete, and he was very embarrassed + in the attempt to explain himself. He was unable to say why he + chose a church, but he felt that it was to a church that he must + go. He had, however, no thought of profanation and no wish to + give offense. "Quite the contrary!" he declared. He had the sad + and tired air of a man who is dominated by a force stronger than + his will. "I know," he added, "what repulsion my conduct must + inspire. Why am I made thus? Who will cure me?" (P. Garnier, + "Perversions Sexuelles," _Comptes Rendus_, International Congress + of Medicine at Paris in 1900, _Section de Psychiatrie_, pp. + 433-435.) + + In some cases, it would appear, the impulse to exhibitionism may + be overcome or may pass away. This result is the more likely to + come about in those cases in which exhibitionism has been largely + conditioned by chronic alcoholism or other influences tending to + destroy the inhibiting and restraining action of the higher + centers, which may be overcome by hygiene and treatment. In this + connection I may bring forward a case which has been communicated + to me by a medical correspondent in London. It is that of an + actor, of high standing in his profession and extremely + intelligent, 49 years of age, married and father of a large + family. He is sexually vigorous and of erotic temperament. His + general health has always been good, but he is a high-strung, + neurotic man, with quick mental reactions. His habits had for a + long time been decidedly alcoholic, but two years ago, a small + quantity of albumen being found in the urine, he was persuaded to + leave off alcohol, and has since been a teetotaller. Though + ordinarily very reticent about sexual matters, he began four or + five years ago to commit acts of exhibitionism, exposing himself + to servants in the house and occasionally to women in the + country. This continued after the alcohol had been abandoned and + lasted for several years, though the attention of the police was + never attracted to the matter, and so far as possible he was + quietly supervised by his friends. Nine months after, the acts of + exhibitionism ceased, apparently in a spontaneous manner, and + there has so far been no relapse. + +Exhibitionism is an act which, on the face of it, seems nonsensical and +meaningless, and as such, as an inexplicable act of madness, it has +frequently been treated both by writers on insanity and on sexual +perversion. "These acts are so lacking in common sense and intelligent +reflection that no other reason than insanity can be offered for the +patient," Ball concluded.[55] Moll, also, who defines exhibitionism +somewhat too narrowly as a condition in which "the charm of the exhibition +lies for the subject in the display itself," not sufficiently taking into +consideration the imagined effect on the spectator, concludes that "the +psychological basis of exhibitionism is at present by no means cleared +up."[56] + +We may probably best approach exhibitionism by regarding it as +fundamentally a symbolic act based on a perversion of courtship. The +exhibitionist displays the organ of sex to a feminine witness, and in the +shock of modest sexual shame by which she reacts to that spectacle, he +finds a gratifying similitude of the normal emotions of coitus.[57] He +feels that he has effected a psychic defloration. + + Exhibitionism is thus analogous, and, indeed, related, to the + impulse felt by many persons to perform indecorous acts or tell + indecent stories before young and innocent persons of the + opposite sex. This is a kind of psychic exhibitionism, the + gratification it causes lying exactly, as in physical + exhibitionism, in the emotional confusion which it is felt to + arouse. The two kinds of exhibitionism may be combined in the + same person: Thus, in a case reported by Hoche (p. 97), the + exhibitionist an intellectual and highly educated man, with a + doctor's degree, also found pleasure in sending indecent poems + and pictures to women, whom, however, he made no attempt to + seduce; he was content with the thought of the emotions he + aroused or believed that he aroused. + + It is possible that within this group should come the agent in + the following incident which was lately observed by a lady, a + friend of my own. An elderly man in an overcoat was seen standing + outside a large and well-known draper's shop in the outskirts of + London; when able to attract the attention of any of the + shop-girls or of any girl in the street he would fling back his + coat and reveal that he was wearing over his own clothes a + woman's chemise (or possibly bodice) and a woman's drawers; there + was no exposure. The only intelligible explanation of this action + would seem to be that pleasure was experienced in the mild shock + of interested surprise and injured modesty which this vision was + imagined to cause to a young girl. It would thus be a + comparatively innocent form of psychic defloration. + +It is of interest to point out that the sexual symbolism of active +flagellation is very closely analogous to this symbolism of exhibitionism. +The flagellant approaches a woman with the rod (itself a symbol of the +penis and in some countries bearing names which are also applied to that +organ) and inflicts on an intimate part of her body the signs of blushing +and the spasmodic movements which are associated with sexual excitement, +while at the same time she feels, or the flagellant imagines that she +feels, the corresponding emotions of delicious shame.[58] This is an even +closer mimicry of the sexual act than the exhibitionist attains, for the +latter fails to secure the consent of the woman nor does he enjoy any +intimate contact with her naked body. The difference is connected with the +fact that the active flagellant is usually a more virile and normal person +than the exhibitionist. In the majority of cases the exhibitionist's +sexual impulse is very feeble, and as a rule he is either to some degree a +degenerate, or else a person who is suffering from an early stage of +general paralysis, dementia, or some other highly enfeebling cause of +mental disorganization, such as chronic alcoholism. Sexual feebleness is +further indicated by the fact that the individuals selected as witnesses +are frequently mere children. + + It seems probable that a form of erotic symbolism somewhat + similar to exhibitionism is to be found in the rare cases in + which sexual gratification is derived from throwing ink, acid or + other defiling liquids on women's dresses. Thoinot has recorded a + case of this kind (_Attentats aux Moeurs_, 1898, pp. 484, _et + seq._). An instructive case has been presented by Moll. In this + case a young man of somewhat neuropathic heredity had as a youth + of 16 or 17, when romping with his young sister's playfellows, + experienced sexual sensations on chancing to see their white + underlinen. From that time white underlinen and white dresses + became to him a fetich and he was only attracted to women so + attired. One day, at the age of 25, when crossing the street in + wet weather with a young lady in a white dress, a passing vehicle + splashed the dress with mud. This incident caused him strong + sexual excitement, and from that time he had the impulse to throw + ink, perchloride of iron, etc., on to ladies' white dresses, and + sometimes to cut and tear them, sexual excitement and ejaculation + taking place every time he effected this. (Moll, "Gutachten über + einem Sexual Perversen [Besudelungstrieb]," _Zeitschrift für + Medizinalbeamte_, Heft XIII, 1900). Such a case is of + considerable psychological interest. Thoinot considers that in + these cases the fleck is a fetich. That is an incorrect account + of the matter. In this case the white garments constituted the + primary fetich, but that fetich becomes more acutely realized, + and at the same time both parties are thrown into an emotional + state which to the fetichist becomes a mimicry of coitus, by the + act of defilement. We may perhaps connect with this phenomenon + the attraction which muddy shoes often exert over the + shoe-fetichist, and the curious way in which, as we have seen (p. + 18), Restif de la Bretonne associates his love of neatness in + women with his attraction to the feet, the part, he remarks, + least easy to keep clean. + + Garnier applied the term _sadi-fetichism_ to active flagellation + and many similar manifestations such as we are here concerned + with, on the grounds that they are hybrids which combine the + morbid adoration for a definite object with the impulse to + exercise a more or less degree of violence. From the standpoint + of the conception of erotic symbolism I have adopted there is no + need for this term. There is here no hybrid combination of two + unlike mental states. We are simply concerned with states of + erotic symbolism, more or less complete, more or less complex. + +The conception of exhibitionism as a process of erotic symbolism, involves +a conscious or unconscious attitude of attention in the exhibitionist's +mind to the psychic reaction of the woman toward whom his display is +directed. He seeks to cause an emotion which, probably in most cases, he +desires should be pleasurable. But from one cause or another his finer +sensibilities are always inhibited or in abeyance, and he is unable to +estimate accurately either the impression he is likely to produce or the +general results of his action, or else he is moved by a strong impulsive +obsession which overpowers his judgment. In many cases he has good reason +for believing that his act will be pleasurable, and frequently he finds +complacent witnesses among the low-class servant girls, etc. + + It may be pointed out here that we are quite justified in + speaking of a penis-fetichism and also of a vulva-fetichism. This + might be questioned. We are obviously justified in recognizing a + fetichism which attaches itself to the pubic hair, or, as in a + case with which I am acquainted, to the clitoris, but it may seem + that we cannot regard the central sexual organs as symbols of + sex, symbols, as it were, of themselves. Properly regarded, + however, it is the sexual act rather than the sexual organ which + is craved in normal sexual desire; the organ is regarded merely + as the means and not as the end. Regarded as a means the organ is + indeed an object of desire, but it only becomes a fetich when it + arrests and fixes the attention. An attention thus pleasurably + fixed, a vulva-fetichism or a penis-fetichism, is within the + normal range of sexual emotion (this point has been mentioned in + the previous volume when discussing the part played by the + primary sexual organs in sexual selection), and in coarse-grained + natures of either sex it is a normal allurement in its + generalized shape, apart from any attraction to the person to + whom the organs belong. In some morbid cases, however, this + penis-fetichism may become a fully developed sexual perversion. A + typical case of this kind has been recorded by Howard in the + United States. Mrs. W., aged 39, was married at 20 to a strong, + healthy man, but derived no pleasure from coitus, though she + received great pleasure from masturbation practiced immediately + after coitus, and nine years after marriage she ceased actual + coitus, compelling her husband to adopt mutual masturbation. She + would introduce men into the house at all times of the day or + night, and after persuading them to expose their persons would + retire to her room to masturbate. The same man never aroused + desire more than once. This desire became so violent and + persistent that she would seek out men in all sorts of public + places and, having induced them to expose themselves, rapidly + retreat to the nearest convenient spot for self-gratification. + She once abstracted a pair of trousers she had seen a man wear + and after fondling them experienced the orgasm. Her husband + finally left her, after vainly attempting to have her confined in + an asylum. She was often arrested for her actions, but through + the intervention of friends set free again. She was a highly + intelligent woman, and apart from this perversion entirely + normal. (W.L. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," _Alienist and + Neurologist_, January, 1896.) It is on the existence of a more or + less developed penis-fetichism of this kind that the + exhibitionist, mostly by an ignorant instinct, relies for the + effects he desires to produce. + +The exhibitionist is not usually content to produce a mere titillated +amusement; he seeks to produce a more powerful effect which must be +emotional whether or not it is pleasurable. A professional man in +Strassburg (in a case reported by Hoche[59]) would walk about in the +evening in a long cloak, and when he met ladies would suddenly throw his +cloak back under a street lamp, or igniting a red-fire match, and thus +exhibit his organs. There was an evident effort--on the part of a weak, +vain, and effeminate man--to produce a maximum of emotional effect. The +attempt to heighten the emotional shock is also seen in the fact that the +exhibitionist frequently chooses a church as the scene of his exploits, +not during service, for he always avoids a concourse of people, but +perhaps toward evening when there are only a few kneeling women scattered +through the edifice. The church is chosen, often instinctively rather than +deliberately, from no impulse to commit a sacrilegious outrage--which, as +a rule, the exhibitionist does not feel his act to be--but because it +really presents the conditions most favorable to the act and the effects +desired. The exhibitionist's attitude of mind is well illustrated by one +of Garnier's patients who declared that he never wished to be seen by more +than two women at once, "just what is necessary," he added, "for an +exchange of impressions." After each exhibition he would ask himself +anxiously: "Did they see me? What are they thinking? What do they say to +each other about me? Oh! how I should like to know!" Another patient of +Garnier's, who haunted churches for this purpose, made this very +significant statement: "Why do I like going to churches? I can scarcely +say. _But I know that it is only there that my act has its full +importance_. The woman is in a devout frame of mind, and she must see that +such an act in such a place is not a joke in bad taste or a disgusting +obscenity; _that if I go there it is not to amuse myself; it is more +serious than that!_ I watch the effect produced on the faces of the ladies +to whom I show my organs. I wish to see them express a profound joy. I +wish, in fact, that they may be forced to say to themselves: _How +impressive Nature is when thus seen!_" + + Here we trace the presence of a feeling which recalls the + phenomena of the ancient and world-wide phallic worship, still + liable to reappear sporadically. Women sometimes took part in + these rites, and the osculation of the male sexual organ or its + emblematic representation by women is easily traceable in the + phallic rites of India and many other lands, not excluding Europe + even in comparatively recent times. (Dulaure in his _Divinités + Génératices_ brings together much bearing on these points; cf.: + Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter XVII, and Bloch, + _Beiträge zur Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil I, pp. 115-117. Colin + Scott has some interesting remarks on phallic worship and the + part it has played in aiding human evolution, "Sex and Art," + _American Journal of Psychology_, vol. vii, No. 2, pp. 191-197. + Irving Rosse describes some modern phallic rites in which both + men and women took part, similar to those practiced in vaudouism, + "Sexual Hypochondriasis," _Virginia Medical Monthly_, October, + 1892.) + + Putting aside any question of phallic worship, a certain pride + and more or less private feeling of ostentation in the new + expansion and development of the organs of virility seems to be + almost normal at adolescence. "We have much reason to assume," + Stanley Hall remarks, "that in a state of nature there is a + certain instinctive pride and ostentation that accompanies the + new local development. I think it will be found that + exhibitionists are usually those who have excessive growth here, + and that much that modern society stigmatizes as obscene is at + bottom more or less spontaneous and perhaps in some cases not + abnormal. Dr. Seerley tells me he has never examined a young man + largely developed who had the usual strong instinctive tendency + of modesty to cover himself with his hands, but he finds this + instinct general with those whose development is less than the + average." (G. Stanley Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. ii, p. 97.) This + instinct of ostentation, however, so far as it is normal, is held + in check by other considerations, and is not, in the strict + sense, exhibitionism. I have observed a full-grown telegraph boy + walking across Hampstead Heath with his sexual organs exposed, + but immediately he realized that he was seen he concealed them. + The solemnity of exhibitionism at this age finds expression in + the climax of the sonnet, "Oraison du Soir," written at 16 by + Rimbaud, whose verse generally is a splendid and insolent + manifestation of rank adolescence:-- + + "Doux comme le Seigneur du cèdre et des hysopes, + Je pisse vers les cieux bruns très haut et très loin, + Avec l'assentiment des grands héliotropes." + + (J.A. Rimbaud, _Oeuvres_, p. 68.) + + In women, also, there would appear to be traceable a somewhat + similar ostentation, though in them it is complicated and largely + inhibited by modesty, and at the same time diffused over the body + owing to the absence of external sexual organs. "Primitive + woman," remarks Madame Renooz, "proud of her womanhood, for a + long time defended her nakedness which ancient art has always + represented. And in the actual life of the young girl to-day + there is a moment when by a secret atavism she feels the pride of + her sex, the intuition of her moral superiority, and cannot + understand why she must hide its cause. At this moment, wavering + between the laws of Nature and social conventions, she scarcely + knows if nakedness should or should not affright her. A sort of + confused atavistic memory recalls to her a period before clothing + was known, and reveals to her as a paradisaical ideal the customs + of that human epoch." (Céline Renooz, _Psychologie Comparée de + l'Homme et de la Femme_, p. 85.) It may be added that among + primitive peoples, and even among some remote European + populations to-day, the exhibition of feminine nudity has + sometimes been regarded as a spectacle with religious or magic + operation. (Ploss, _Das Weib_, seventh edition, vol. ii, pp. + 663-680; Havelock Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, p. + 304.) It is stated by Gopcevic that in the long struggle between + the Albanians and the Montenegrians the women of the former + people would stand in the front rank and expose themselves by + raising their skirts, believing that they would thus insure + victory. As, however, they were shot down, and as, moreover, + victory usually fell to the Montenegrians, this custom became + discredited. (Quoted by Bloch, _Op. cit._, Teil II, p. 307.) + + With regard to the association, suggested by Stanley Hall, + between exhibitionism and an unusual degree of development of the + sexual organs, it must be remarked that both extremes--a very + large and a very small penis--are specially common in + exhibitionists. The prevalence of the small organ is due to an + association of exhibitionism with sexual feebleness. The + prevalence of the large organ may be due to the cause suggested + by Hall. Among Mahommedans the sexual organs are sometimes + habitually exposed by religious penitents, and I note that + Bernhard Stern, in his book on the medical and sexual aspects of + life in Turkey, referring to a penitent of this sort whom he saw + on the Stamboul bridge at Constantinople, remarks that the organ + was very largely developed. It may well be in such a case that + the penitent's religious attitude is reinforced by some lingering + relic of a more fleshly ostentation. + +It is by a pseudo-atavism that this phallicism is evoked in the +exhibitionist. There is no true emergence of an ancestrally inherited +instinct, but by the paralysis or inhibition of the finer and higher +feelings current in civilization, the exhibitionist is placed on the same +mental level as the man of a more primitive age, and he thus presents the +basis on which the impulses belonging to a higher culture may naturally +take root and develop. + + Reference may here be made to a form of primitive exhibitionism, + almost confined to women, which, although certainly symbolic, is + absolutely non-sexual, and must not, therefore, be confused with + the phenomena we are here occupied with. I refer to the + exhibition of the buttocks as a mark of contempt. In its most + primitive form, no doubt, this exhibitionism is a kind of + exorcism, a method of putting evil spirits, primarily, and + secondarily evil-disposed persons, to flight. It is the most + effective way for a woman to display sexual centers, and it + shares in the magical virtues which all unveiling of the sexual + centers is believed by primitive peoples to possess. It is + recorded that the women of some peoples in the Balkan peninsula + formerly used this gesture against enemies in battle. In the + sixteenth century so distinguished a theologian as Luther when + assailed by the Evil One at night was able to put the adversary + to flight by protruding his uncovered buttocks from the bed. But + the spiritual significance of this attitude is lost with the + decay of primitive beliefs. It survives, but merely as a gesture + of insult. The symbolism comes to have reference to the nates as + the excretory focus, the seat of the anus. In any case it ignores + any sexual attractiveness in this part of the body. Exhibitionism + of this kind, therefore, can scarcely arise in persons of any + sensitiveness or æsthetic perception, even putting aside the + question of modesty, and there seems to be little trace of it in + classic antiquity when the nates were regarded as objects of + beauty. Among the Egyptians, however, we gather from Herodotus + (Bk. II, Chapter LX) that at a certain popular religious festival + men and women would go in boats on the Nile, singing and playing, + and when they approached a town the women on the boats would + insult the women of the town by injurious language and by + exposing themselves. Among the Arabs, however, the specific + gesture we are concerned with is noted, and a man to whom + vengeance is forbidden would express his feelings by exposing his + posterior and strewing earth on his head (Wellhausen, _Rests + Arabischen Heidentums_, 1897, p. 195). It is in Europe and in + mediæval and later times that this emphatic gesture seems to have + flourished as a violent method of expressing contempt. It was by + no means confined to the lower classes, and Kleinpaul, in + discussing this form of "speech without words," quotes examples + of various noble persons, even princesses, who are recorded thus + to have expressed their feelings. (Kleinpaul, _Sprache ohne + Worte_, pp. 271-273.) In more recent times the gesture has become + merely a rare and extreme expression of unrestrained feeling in + coarse-grained peasants. Zola, in the figure of Mouquette in + _Germinal_, may be said to have given a kind of classic + expression to the gesture. In the more remote parts of Europe it + appears to be still not altogether uncommon. This seems to be + notably the case among the South Slavs, and Krauss states that + "when a South Slav woman wishes to express her deepest contempt + for anyone she bends forward, with left hand raising her skirts, + and with the right slapping her posterior, at the same time + exclaiming: 'This for you!'" (Kryptadia, vol. vi, p. 200.) + + A verbal survival of this gesture, consisting in the contemptuous + invitation to kiss this region, still exists among us in remote + parts of the country, especially as an insult offered by an angry + woman who forgets herself. It is said to be commonly used in + Wales. ("Welsh Ædoelogy," Kryptadia, vol. ii, pp. 358, et seq.) + In Cornwall, when addressed by a woman to a man it is sometimes + regarded as a deadly insult, even if the woman is young and + attractive, and may cause a life-long enmity between related + families. From this point of view the nates are a symbol of + contempt, and any sexual significance is excluded. (The + distinction is brought out by Diderot in _Le Neveu de Rameau:_ + "_Lui:_--Il y a d'autres jours ou il ne m'en coûterait rien pour + être vil tant qu'on voudrait; ces jours-là , pour un liard, je + baiserais le cul à la petite Hus. _Moi:_--Eh! mais, l'ami, elle + est blanche, jolie, douce, potelée, et c'est un acte d'humilité + auquel un plus delicat que vous pourrait quelquefois s'abaisser. + _Lui:_--Entendons-nous; c'est qu'il y a baiser le cul au simple, + et baiser le cul au figuré.") + + It must be added that a sexual form of exhibitionism of the nates + must still be recognized. It occurs in masochism and expresses + the desire for passive flagellation. Rousseau, whose emotional + life was profoundly affected by the castigations which as a child + he received from Mlle Lambercier, has in his _Confessions_ told + us how, when a youth, he would sometimes expose himself in this + way in the presence of young women. Such masochistic + exhibitionism seems, however, to be rare. + +While the manifestations of exhibitionism are substantially the same in +all cases, there are many degrees and varieties of the condition. We may +find among exhibitionists, as Garnier remarks, dementia, states of +unconsciousness, epilepsy, general paralysis, alcoholism, but the most +typical cases, he adds, if not indeed the cases to which the term properly +belongs, are those in which it is an impulsive obsession. Krafft-Ebing[60] +divides exhibitionists into four clinical groups: (1) acquired states of +mental weakness, with cerebral or spinal disease clouding consciousness +and at the same time causing impotence; (2) epileptics, in whom the act is +an abnormal organic impulse performed in a state of imperfect +consciousness; (3) a somewhat allied group of neurasthenic cases; (4) +periodical impulsive cases with deep hereditary taint. This classification +is not altogether satisfactory. Garnier's classification, placing the +group of obsessional cases in the foreground and leaving the other more +vaguely defined groups in the background, is probably better. I am +inclined to consider that most of the cases fall into one or other of two +mixed groups. The first class includes cases in which there is more or +less congenital abnormality, but otherwise a fair or even complete degree +of mental integrity; they are usually young adults, they are more or less +precisely conscious of the end they wish to attain, and it is often only +with a severe struggle that they yield to their impulses. In the second +class the beginnings of mental or nervous disease have diminished the +sensibility of the higher centers; the subjects are usually old men whose +lives have been absolutely correct; they are often only vaguely aware of +the nature of the satisfaction they are seeking, and frequently no +struggle precedes the manifestation; such was the case of the overworked +clergyman described by Hughes,[61] who, after much study, became morose +and absent-minded, and committed acts of exhibitionism which he could not +explain but made no attempt to deny; with rest and restorative treatment +his health improved and the acts ceased. It is in the first class of cases +alone that there is a developed sexual perversion. In the cases of the +second class there is a more or less definite sexual intention, but it is +only just conscious, and the emergence of the impulse is due not to its +strength but to the weakness, temporary or permanent, of the higher +inhibiting centers. + +Epileptic cases, with loss of consciousness during the act, can only be +regarded as presenting a pseudo-exhibitionism. They should be excluded +altogether. It is undoubtedly true that many cases of real or apparent +exhibitionism occur in epileptics.[62] We must not, however, too hastily +conclude that because these acts occur in epileptics they are necessarily +unconscious acts. Epilepsy frequently occurs on a basis of hereditary +degeneration, and the exhibitionism may be, and not infrequently is, a +stigma of the degeneracy and not an indication of the occurrence of a +minor epileptic fit. When the act of pseudo-exhibitionism is truly +epileptic, it will usually have no psychic sexual content, and it will +certainly be liable to occur under all sorts of circumstances, when the +patient is alone or in a miscellaneous concourse of people. It will be on +a level with the acts of the highly respectable young woman who, at the +conclusion of an attack of _petit mal_, consisting chiefly of a sudden +desire to pass urine, on one occasion lifted up her clothes and urinated +at a public entertainment, so that it was with difficulty her friends +prevented her from being handed over to the police.[63] Such an act is +automatic, unconscious, and involuntary; the spectators are not even +perceived; it cannot be an act of exhibitionism. Whenever, on the other +hand, the place and the time are evidently chosen deliberately,--a quiet +spot, the presence of only one or two young women or children,--it is +difficult to admit that we are in the presence of a fit of epileptic +unconsciousness, even when the subject is known to be epileptic. + +Even, however, when we exclude those epileptic pseudo-exhibitionists who, +from the legal point of view, are clearly irresponsible, it must still be +remembered that in every case of exhibitionism there is a high degree of +either mental abnormality on a neuropathic basis, or else of actual +disease. This is true to a greater extent in exhibitionism than in almost +any other form of sexual perversion. No subject of exhibitionism should be +sent to prison without expert medical examination. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[54] Lasège first drew attention to this sexual perversion and gave it its +generally accepted name, "Les Exhibitionistes," _L'Union Médicale_, May, +1877. Magnan, on various occasions (for example, "Les Exhibitionistes," +_Archives de l'Anthropologie Criminelle_, vol. v, 1890, p. 456), has given +further development and precision to the clinical picture of the +exhibitionist. + +[55] B. Ball. _La Folie Erotique_, p. 86. + +[56] Moll, _Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 661. + +[57] "Exhibitionism in its most typical form is," Garnier truly says, "a +_systematic act_, manifesting itself as the _strange equivalent of a +sexual connection_, or its _substitution_." The brief account of +exhibitionism (pp. 433-437) in Garnier's discussion of "Perversions +Sexuelles" at the International Medical Congress at Paris in 1900 +(_Section de Psychiatrie: Comptes-Rendus_) is the most satisfactory +statement of the psychological aspects of this perversion with which I am +acquainted. Garnier's unrivalled clinical knowledge of these +manifestations, due to his position during many years as physician at the +Depôt of the Prefecture of Police in Paris, adds great weight to his +conclusions. + +[58] The symbolism of coitus involved in flagellation has been touched on +by Eulenburg (_Sexuale Neuropathie_, p. 121), and is more fully developed +by Dühren (_Geschlechtsleben in England_, bd. ii, pp. 366, _et seq._). + +[59] A. Hoche, _Neurologische Centralblatt_, 1896, No. 2. + +[60] _Op. cit._, pp. 478, et seq. + +[61] C.H. Hughes, "Morbid Exhibitionism," _Alienist and Neurologist_, +August, 1904. Another somewhat similar American case, also preceded by +overwork, and eventually adjudged insane by the courts, is recorded by +D.S. Booth, _Alienist and Neurologist_, February, 1905. + +[62] Exhibitionism in epilepsy is briefly discussed by Féré, _L'Instinct +Sexuel_, second edition, pp. 194-195. + +[63] W.S. Colman, "Post-Epileptic Unconscious Automatic Actions," +_Lancet_, July 5, 1890. + + + + +VI. + +The Forms of Erotic Symbolism are Simulacra of Coitus--Wide +Extension of Erotic Symbolism--Fetichism Not Covering the Whole +Ground of Sexual Selection--It is Based on the Individual Factor in +Selection--Crystallization--The Lover and the Artist--The Key to Erotic +Symbolism to be Found in the Emotional Sphere--The Passage to Pathological +Extremes. + + +We have now examined several very various and yet very typical +manifestations in all of which it is not difficult to see how, in some +strange and eccentric form--on a basis of association through resemblance +or contiguity or both combined--there arises a definite mimicry of the +normal sexual act together with the normal emotions which accompany that +act. It has become clear in what sense we are justified in recognizing +erotic symbolism. + + The symbolic and, as it were, abstracted nature of these + manifestations is shown by the remarkable way in which they are + sometimes capable of transference from the object to the subject. + That is to say that the fetichist may show a tendency to + cultivate his fetich in his own person. A foot-fetichist may like + to go barefoot himself; a man who admired lame women liked to + halt himself; a man who was attracted by small waists in women + found sexual gratification in tight-lacing himself; a man who was + fascinated by fine white skin and wished to cut it found + satisfaction in cutting his own skin; Moll's coprolagnic + fetichist found a voluptuous pleasure in his own acts of + defecation. (See, e.g., Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, p. 221, 224, + 226; Hammond, _Sexual Impotence_, p. 74; cf. _ante_, p. 68.) Such + symbolic transference seems to have a profoundly natural basis, + for we may see a somewhat similar phenomenon in the well-known + tendency of cows to mount a cow in heat. This would appear to be, + not so much a homosexual impulse, as the dynamic psychic action + of an olfactory sexual symbol in a transformed form. + + We seem to have here a psychic process which is a curious + reversal of that process of _Einfühlung_--the projection of one's + own activities into the object contemplated--which Lipps has so + fruitfully developed as the essence of every æsthetic condition. + (T. Lipps, _Æsthetik_, Teil I, 1903.) By _Einfühlung_ our own + interior activity becomes the activity of the object perceived, + a thing being beautiful in proportion as it lends itself to our + _Einfühlung_. But by this action of erotic symbolism, on the + other hand, we transfer the activity of the object into + ourselves. + +When the idea of erotic symbolism as manifested in such definite and +typical forms becomes realized, it further becomes clear that the vaguer +manifestations of such symbolism are exceedingly widespread. When in a +previous volume we were discussing and drawing together the various +threads which unite "Love and Pain," it will now be understood that we +were standing throughout on the threshold of erotic symbolism. Pain +itself, in the sense in which we slowly learned to define it in this +relationship--as a state of intense emotional excitement--may, under a +great variety of special circumstances, become an erotic symbol and afford +the same relief as the emotions normally accompanying the sexual act. +Active algolagnia or sadism is thus a form of erotic symbolism; passive +algolagnia or masochism is (in a man) an inverted form of erotic +symbolism. Active flagellation or passive flagellation are, in exactly the +same way, manifestations of erotic symbolism, the imaginative mimicry of +coitus. + +Binet and also Krafft-Ebing[64] have argued in effect that the whole of +sexual selection is a matter of fetichism, that is to say, of erotic +symbolism of object. "Normal love," Binet states, "appears as the result +of a complicated fetichism." Tarde also seems to have regarded love as +normally a kind of fetichism. "We are a long time before we fall in love +with a woman," he remarks; "we must wait to see the detail which strikes +and delights us, and causes us to overlook what displeases us. Only in +normal love the details are many and always changing. Constancy in love is +rarely anything else but a voyage around the beloved person, a voyage of +exploration and ever new discoveries. The most faithful lover does not +love the same woman in the same way for two days in succession."[65] + +From that point of view normal sexual love is the sway of a fetich--more +or less arbitrary, more or less (as Binet terms it) polytheistic--and it +can have little objective basis. But, as we saw when considering "Sexual +Selection in Man" in the previous volume, more especially when analyzing +the notion of beauty, we are justified in believing that beauty has to a +large extent an objective basis, and that love by no means depends simply +on the capricious selection of some individual fetich. The individual +factor, as we saw, is but one of many factors which constitute beauty. In +the study of sexual selection that individual factor was passed over very +lightly. We now see that it is often a factor of great importance, for in +it are rooted all these outgrowths--normal in their germs, highly abnormal +in their more extreme developments--which make up erotic symbolism. + +Erotic symbolism is therefore concerned with all that is least generic, +least specific, all that is most intimately personal and individual, in +sexual selection. It is the final point in which the decreasing circle of +sexual attractiveness is fixed. In the widest and most abstract form +sexual selection in man is merely human, and we are attracted to that +which bears most fully the marks of humanity; in a less abstract form it +is sexual, and we are attracted to that which most vigorously presents the +secondary sexual characteristics; still narrowing, it is the type of our +own nation and people that appeals most strongly to us in matters of love; +and still further concentrating we are affected by the ideal--in +civilization most often the somewhat exotic ideal--of our own day, the +fashion of our own city. But the individual factor still remains, and amid +the infinite possibilities of erotic symbolism the individual may evolve +an ideal which is often, as far as he knows and perhaps in actuality, an +absolutely unique event in the history of the human soul. + +Erotic symbolism works in its finer manifestations by means of the +idealizing aptitudes; it is the field of sexual psychology in which that +faculty of crystallization, on which Stendhal loved to dwell, achieves its +most brilliant results. In the solitary passage in which we seem to see a +smile on the face of the austere poet of the _De Rerum Naturâ_, Lucretius +tells us how every lover, however he may be amused by the amorous +extravagances of other men, is himself blinded by passion: if his mistress +is black she is a fascinating brunette, if she squints she is the rival of +Pallas, if too tall she is majestic, if too short she is one of the +Graces, _tota merum sal_; if too lean it is her delicate refinement, if +too fat then a Ceres, dirty and she disdains adornment, a chatterer and +brilliantly vivacious, silent and it is her exquisite modesty.[66] Sixteen +hundred years later Robert Burton, when describing the symptoms of love, +made out a long and appalling list of the physical defects which the lover +is prepared to admire.[67] + +Yet we must not be too certain that the lover is wrong in this matter. We +too hastily assume that the casual and hasty judgment of the world is +necessarily more reliable, more conformed to what we call "truth," than +the judgment of the lover which is founded on absorbed and patient study. +In some cases where there is lack of intelligence in the lover and +dissimulation in the object of his love, it may be so. But even a poem or +a picture will often not reveal its beauty except by the expenditure of +time and study. It is foolish to expect that the secret beauty of a human +person will reveal itself more easily. The lover is an artist, an artist +who constructs an image, it is true, but only by patient and concentrated +attention to nature; he knows the defects of his image, probably better +than anyone, but he knows also that art lies, not in the avoidance of +defects, but in the realization of those traits which swallow up defects +and so render them non-existent. A great artist, Rodin, after a life spent +in the study of Nature, has declared that for art there is no ugliness in +Nature. "I have arrived at this belief by the study of Nature," he said; +"I can only grasp the beauty of the soul by the beauty of the body, but +some day one will come who will explain what I only catch a glimpse of and +will declare how the whole earth is beautiful, and all human beings +beautiful. I have never been able to say this in sculpture so well as I +wish and as I feel it affirmed within me. For poets Beauty has always +been some particular landscape, some particular woman; but it should be +all women, all landscapes. A negro or a Mongol has his beauty, however +remote from ours, and it must be the same with their characters. There is +no ugliness. When I was young I made that mistake, as others do; I could +not undertake a woman's bust unless I thought her pretty, according to my +particular idea of beauty; to-day I should do the bust of any woman, and +it would be just as beautiful. And however ugly a woman may look, when she +is with her lover she becomes beautiful; there is beauty in her character, +in her passions, and beauty exists as soon as character or passion becomes +visible, for the body is a casting on which passions are imprinted. And +even without that, there is always the blood that flows in the veins and +the air that fills the lungs."[68] + +The saint, also, is here at one with the lover and the artist. The man who +has so profoundly realized the worth of his fellow men that he is ready +even to die in order to save them, feels that he has discovered a great +secret. Cyples traces the "secret delights" that have thus risen in the +hearts of holy men to the same source as the feelings generated between +lovers, friends, parents, and children. "A few have at intervals walked in +the world," he remarks, "who have, each in his own original way, found out +this marvel.... Straightway man in general has become to them so sweet a +thing that the infatuation has seemed to the rest of their fellows to be a +celestial madness. Beggars' rags to their unhesitating lips grew fit for +kissing, because humanity had touched the garb; there were no longer any +menial acts, but only welcome services.... Remember by how much man is the +subtlest circumstance in the world; at how many points he can attach +relationships; how manifold and perennial he is in his results. All other +things are dull, meager, tame beside him."[69] + +It may be added that even if we still believe that lover and artist and +saint are drawing the main elements of their conceptions from the depths +of their own consciousness, there is a sense in which they are coming +nearer to the truth of things than those for whom their conceptions are +mere illusions. The aptitude for realizing beauty has involved an +adjustment of the nerves and the associated brain centers through +countless ages that began before man was. When the vision of supreme +beauty is slowly or suddenly realized by anyone, with a reverberation that +extends throughout his organism, he has attained to something which for +his species, and for far more than his species, is truth, and can only be +illusion to one who has artificially placed himself outside the stream of +life. + + In an essay on "The Gods as Apparitions of the Race-Life," Edward + Carpenter, though in somewhat Platonic phraseology, thus well + states the matter: "The youth sees the girl; it may be a chance + face, a chance outline, amid the most banal surroundings. But it + gives the cue. There is a memory, a confused reminiscence. The + mortal figure without penetrates to the immortal figure within, + and there rises into consciousness a shining form, glorious, not + belonging to this world, but vibrating with the agelong life of + humanity, and the memory of a thousand love-dreams. The waking of + this vision intoxicates the man; it glows and burns within him; a + goddess (it may be Venus herself) stands in the sacred place of + his temple; a sense of awe-struck splendor fills him, and the + world is changed." "He sees something" (the same writer continues + in a subsequent essay, "Beauty and Duty") "which, in a sense, is + more real than the figures in the street, for he sees something + that has lived and moved for hundreds of years in the heart of + the race; something which has been one of the great formative + influences of his own life, and which has done as much to create + those very figures in the street as qualities in the circulation + of the blood may do to form a finger or other limb. He comes into + touch with a very real Presence or Power--one of those organic + centers of growth in the life of humanity--and feels this larger + life within himself, subjective, if you like, and yet intensely + objective. And more. For is it not also evident that the woman, + the mortal woman who excites his Vision, _has_ some closest + relation to it, and is, indeed, far more than a mere mask or + empty formula which reminds him of it? For she indeed has within + her, just as much as the man has, deep subconscious Powers + working; and the ideal which has dawned so entrancingly on the + man is in all probability closely related to that which has been + working most powerfully in the heredity of the woman, and which + has most contributed to mold _her_ form and outline. No wonder, + then, that her form should remind him of it. Indeed, when he + looks into her eyes he sees _through_ to a far deeper life even + than she herself may be aware of, and yet which is truly hers--a + life perennial and wonderful. The more than mortal in him beholds + the more than mortal in her; and the gods descend to meet." + (Edward Carpenter, _The Art of Creation_, pp. 137, 186.) + +It is this mighty force which lies behind and beneath the aberrations we +have been concerned with, a great reservoir from which they draw the +life-blood that vivifies even their most fantastic shapes. Fetichism and +the other forms of erotic symbolism are but the development and the +isolation of the crystallizations which normally arise on the basis of +sexual selection. Normal in their basis, in their extreme forms they +present the utmost pathological aberrations of the sexual instinct which +can be attained or conceived. In the intermediate space all degrees are +possible. In the slightest degree the symbol is merely a specially +fascinating and beloved feature in a person who is, in all other respects, +felt to be lovable; as such its recognition is a legitimate part of +courtship, an effective aid to tumescence. In a further degree the symbol +is the one arresting and attracting character of a person who must, +however, still be felt as a sexually attractive individual. In a still +further degree of perversion the symbol is effective, even though the +person with whom it is associated is altogether unattractive. In the final +stage the person and even all association with a person disappear +altogether from the field of sexual consciousness; the abstract symbol +rules supreme. + +Long, however, before the symbol has reached that final climax of morbid +intensity we may be said to have passed beyond the sphere of sexual love. +A person, not an abstracted quality, must be the goal of love. So long as +the fetich is subordinated to the person it serves to heighten love. But +love must be based on a complexus of attractive qualities, or it has no +stability.[70] As soon as the fetich becomes isolated and omnipotent, so +that the person sinks into the background as an unimportant appendage of +the fetich, all stability is lost. The fetichist now follows an impersonal +and abstract symbol withersoever it may lead him. + +It has been seen that there are an extraordinary number of forms in which +erotic symbolism may be felt. It must be remembered, and it cannot be too +distinctly emphasized, that the links that bind together the forms of +erotic symbolism are not to be found in objects or even in acts, but in +the underlying emotion. A feeling is the first condition of the symbol, a +feeling which recalls, by a subtle and unconscious automatic association +of resemblance or of contiguity, some former feeling. It is the similarity +of emotion, instinctively apprehended, which links on a symbol only +partially sexual, or even apparently not sexual at all, to the great +central focus of sexual emotion, the great dominating force which brings +the symbol its life-blood.[71] + +The cases of sexual hyperæsthesia, quoted at the beginning of this study, +do but present in a morbidly comprehensive and sensitive form those +possibilities of erotic symbolism which, in some degree, or at some +period, are latent in most persons. They are genuinely instinctive and +automatic, and have nothing in common with that fanciful and deliberate +play of the intelligence around sexual imagery--not infrequently seen in +abnormal and insane persons--which has no significance for sexual +psychology. + +It is to the extreme individualization involved by the developments of +erotic symbolism that the fetichist owes his morbid and perilous +isolation. The lover who is influenced by all the elements of sexual +selection is always supported by the fellow-feeling of a larger body of +other human beings; he has behind him his species, his sex, his nation, or +at the very least a fashion. Even the inverted lover in most cases is soon +able to create around him an atmosphere constituted by persons whose +ideals resemble his own. But it is not so with the erotic symbolist. He is +nearly always alone. He is predisposed to isolation from the outset, for +it would seem to be on a basis of excessive shyness and timidity that the +manifestations of erotic symbolism are most likely to develop. When at +length the symbolist realizes his own aspirations--which seem to him for +the most part an altogether new phenomenon in the world--and at the same +time realizes the wide degree in which they deviate from those of the rest +of mankind, his natural secretiveness is still further reinforced. He +stands alone. His most sacred ideals are for all those around him a +childish absurdity, or a disgusting obscenity, possibly a matter calling +for the intervention of the policeman. We have forgotten that all these +impulses which to us seem so unnatural--this adoration of the foot and +other despised parts of the body, this reverence for the excretory acts +and products, the acceptance of congress with animals, the solemnity of +self-exhibition--were all beliefs and practices which, to our remote +forefathers, were bound up with the highest conceptions of life and the +deepest ardors of religion. + +A man cannot, however, deviate at once so widely and so spontaneously in +his impulses from the rest of the world in which he himself lives without +possessing an aboriginally abnormal temperament. At the very least he +exhibits a neuropathic sensitiveness to abnormal impressions. Not +infrequently there is more than this, the distinct stigmata of +degeneration, sometimes a certain degree of congenital feeble-mindedness +or a tendency to insanity. + +Yet, regarded as a whole, and notwithstanding the frequency with which +they witness to congenital morbidity, the phenomena of erotic symbolism +can scarcely fail to be profoundly impressive to the patient and impartial +student of the human soul. They often seem absurd, sometimes disgusting, +occasionally criminal; they are always, when carried to an extreme degree, +abnormal. But of all the manifestations of sexual psychology, normal and +abnormal, they are the most specifically human. More than any others they +involve the potently plastic force of the imagination. They bring before +us the individual man, not only apart from his fellows, but in opposition, +himself creating his own paradise. They constitute the supreme triumph of +human idealism. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[64] Binet, _Etudes de Psychologie Expérimentale_, esp., p. 84; +Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, p. 18. + +[65] G. Tarde, "L'Amour Morbide," _Archives de l'Anthropologie +Criminelle_, 1890, p. 585. + +[66] Lucretius, Lib. IV, vv. 1150-1163. + +[67] Burton, _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. III, +Subs. I. + +[68] Judith Cladel, _Auguste Rodin Pris sur la Vie_, 1903, pp. 103-104. +Some slight modifications have been made in the translation of this +passage on account of the conversational form of the original. + +[69] W. Cyples, _The Process of Human Experience_, p. 462. Even if (as we +have already seen, _ante_, p. 58) the saint cannot always feel actual +physical pleasure in the intimate contact of humanity, the ardor of +devoted service which his vision of humanity arouses remains unaffected. + +[70] "To love," as Stendhal defined it (_De l'Amour_, Chapter II), "is to +have pleasure in seeing, touching, and feeling by all the senses, and as +near as possible, a beloved object by whom one is oneself loved." + +[71] Pillon's study of "La Mémoire Affective" (_Revue Philosophique_, +February, 1901) helps to explain the psychic mechanism of the process. + + + + +THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE. + +I. + +The Psychological Significance of Detumescence--The Testis and the +Ovary--Sperm Cell and Germ Cell--Development of the Embryo--The External +Sexual Organs--Their Wide Range of Variation--Their Nervous Supply--The +Penis--Its Racial Variations--The Influence of Exercise--The Scrotum and +Testicles--The Mons Veneris--The Vulva--The Labia Majora and their +Varieties--The Pubic Hair and Its Characters--The Clitoris and Its +Functions--The Anus as an Erogenous Zone--The Nymphæ and their +Function--The Vagina--The Hymen--Virginity--The Biological Significance of +the Hymen. + + +In analyzing the sexual impulse we have seen that the process whereby the +conjunction of the sexes is achieved falls naturally into two phases: the +first phase, of tumescence, during which force is generated in the +organism, and the second phase, of detumescence, in which that force is +discharged during conjugation.[72] Hitherto we have been occupied mainly +with the first phase, that of tumescence, and with its associated psychic +phenomena. It was inevitable that this should be so, for it is during the +slow process of tumescence that sexual selection is decided, the +crystallizations of love elaborated, and, to a large extent, the +individual erotic symbols determined. But we can by no means altogether +pass over the final phase of detumescence. Its consideration, it is true, +brings us directly into the field of anatomy and physiology; while +tumescence is largely under control of the will, when the moment of +detumescence arrives the reins slip from the control of the will; the more +fundamental and uncontrollable impulses of the organism gallop on +unchecked; the chariot of Phaëthon dashes blindly down into a sea of +emotion. + +Yet detumescence is the end and climax of the whole drama; it is an +anatomico-physiological process, certainly, but one that inevitably +touches psychology at every point.[73] It is, indeed, the very key to the +process of tumescence, and unless we understand and realize very precisely +what it is that happens during detumescence, our psychological analysis of +the sexual impulse must remain vague and inadequate. + +From the point of view we now occupy, a man and a woman are no longer two +highly sensitive organisms vibrating, voluptuously it may indeed be, but +vaguely and indefinitely, to all kinds of influences and with fluctuating +impulses capable of being directed into any channel, even in the highest +degree divergent from the proper ends of procreation. They are now two +genital organisms who exist to propagate the race, and whatever else they +may be, they must be adequately constituted to effect the act by which the +future of the race is ensured. We have to consider what are the material +conditions which ensure the most satisfactory and complete fulfillment of +this act, and how those conditions may be correlated with other +circumstances in the organism. In thus approaching the subject we shall +find that we have not really abandoned the study of the psychic aspects of +sex. + +The two most primary sexual organs are the testis and the ovary; it is the +object of conjugation to bring into contact the sperm from the testis with +the germ from the ovary. There is no reason to suppose that the germ-cell +and the sperm-cell are essentially different from each other. Sexual +conjugation thus remains a process which is radically the same as the +non-sexual mode of propagation which preceded it. The fusion of the nuclei +of the two cells was regarded by Van Beneden, who in 1875 first accurately +described it, as a process of conjugation comparable to that of the +protozoa and the protophyta. Boveri, who has further extended our +knowledge of the process, considers that the spermatozoon removes an +inhibitory influence preventing the commencement of development in the +ovum; the spermatozoon replaces a portion of the ovum which has already +undergone degeneration, so that the object of conjugation is chiefly to +effect the union of the properties of two cells in one, sexual +fertilization achieving a division of labor with reciprocal inhibition; +the two cells have renounced their original faculty of separate +development in order to attain a fusion of qualities and thus render +possible that production of new forms and qualities which has involved the +progress of the organized world.[74] + +While in fishes this conjugation of the male and female elements is +usually ensured by the female casting her spawn into an artificial nest +outside the body, on to which the male sheds his milt, in all animals +(and, to some extent, birds, who occupy an intermediate position) there is +an organic nest, or incubation chamber as Bland Sutton terms it, the womb, +in the female body, wherein the fertilized egg may develop to a high +degree of maturity sheltered from those manifold risks of the external +world which make it necessary for the spawn of fishes to be so enormous in +amount. Since, however, men and women have descended from remote ancestors +who, in the manner of aquatic creatures, exercised functions of +sperm-extrusion and germ-extrusion that were exactly analogous in the two +sexes, without any specialized female uterine organization, the early +stages of human male and female foetal development still display the +comparatively undifferentiated sexual organization of those remote +ancestors, and during the first months of foetal life it is practically +impossible to tell by the inspection of the genital regions whether the +embryo would have developed into a man or into a woman. If we examine the +embryo at an early stage of development we see that the hind end is the +body stalk, this stalk in later stages becoming part of the umbilical +cord. The urogenital region, formed by the rapid extension of the hind +end beyond its original limit, which corresponds to what is later the +umbilicus, develops mainly by the gradual differentiation of structures +(the Wolffian and Müllerian bodies) which originally exist identically in +both sexes. This process of sexual differentiation is highly complex, so +that it cannot yet be said that there is complete agreement among +investigators as to its details. When some irregularity or arrest of +development occurs in the process we have one or other of the numerous +malformations which may affect this region. If the arrest occurs at a very +early stage we may even find a condition of things which seems to +approximate to that which normally exists in the adult reptilia.[75] Owing +to the fact that both male and female organs develop from more primitive +structures which were sexually undifferentiated, a fundamental analogy in +the sexual organs of the sexes always remains; the developed organs of one +sex exist as rudiments in the other sex; the testicles correspond to the +ovaries; the female clitoris is the homologue of the male penis; the +scrotum of one sex is the labia majora in the other sex, and so +throughout, although it is not always possible at present to be quite +certain in regard to these homologics. + +Since the object to be attained by the sexual organs in the human species +is identical with that which they subserve in their pre-human ancestors, +it is not surprising to find that these structures have a clear +resemblance to the corresponding structures in the apes, although on the +whole there would appear to be in man a higher degree of sexual +differentiation. Thus the uterus of various species of _semnopithecus_ +seems to show a noteworthy correspondence with the same organ in +woman.[76] The somewhat less degree of sexual differentiation is well +shown in the gorilla; in the male the external organs are in the passive +state covered by the wrinkled skin of the abdomen, while in the female, +on the contrary, they are very apparent, and in sexual excitement the +large clitoris and nymphæ become markedly prominent. The penis of the +gorilla, however, more nearly resembles that of man, according to +Hartmann, than does that of the other anthropoid apes, which diverge from +the human type in this respect more than do the cynocephalic apes and some +species of baboon. + +From the psychological point of view we are less interested in the +internal sexual organs, which are most fundamentally concerned with the +production and reception of the sexual elements, than with the more +external parts of the genital apparatus which serve as the instruments of +sexual excitation, and the channels for the intromission and passage of +the seminal fluid. It is these only which can play any part at all in +sexual selection; they are the only part of the sexual apparatus which can +enter into the formation of either normal or abnormal erotic conceptions; +they are the organs most prominently concerned with detumescence; they +alone enter normally into the conscious process of sex at any time. It +seems desirable, therefore, to discuss them briefly at this point. + + Our knowledge of the individual and racial variations of the + external sexual organs is still extremely imperfect. A few + monographs and collections of data on isolated points may be + found in more or less inaccessible publications. As regards + women, Ploss and Bartels have devoted a chapter to the sexual + organs of women which extends to a hundred pages, but remains + scanty and fragmentary. (_Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter VI.) The + most systematic series of observations have been made in the case + of the various kinds of degenerates--idiots, the insane, + criminals, etc.--but it would be obviously unsafe to rely too + absolutely on such investigations for our knowledge of the sexual + organs of the ordinary population. + + There can be no doubt, however, that the external sexual organs + in normal men and women exhibit a peculiarly wide range of + variation. This is indicated not only by the unsystematic results + attained by experienced observers, but also by more systematic + studies. Thus Herman has shown by detailed measurements that + there are great normal variations in the conformation of the + parts that form the floor of the female pelvis. He found that the + projection of the pelvic floor varied from nothing to as much as + two inches, and that in healthy women who had borne no children + the distance between the coccyx and anus, the length of the + perineum, the distance between the fourchette and the symphysis + pubis, and the length of the vagina are subject to wide + variations. (_Lancet_, October 12, 1889.) Even the female + urethral opening varies very greatly, as has been shown by Bergh, + who investigated it in nearly 700 women and reproduces the + various shapes found; while most usually (in about a third of the + cases observed), a longitudinal slit, it may be cross-shaped, + star-shaped, crescentic, etc.; and while sometimes very small, in + about 6 per cent. of the cases it admitted the tip of the little + finger. (Bergh, _Monatsheft für Praktische Dermatologie_, 15 + Sept., 1897.) + + As regards both sexes, Stanley Hall states that "Dr. F.N. + Seerley, who has examined over 2000 normal young men as well as + many young women, tells me that in his opinion individual + variations in these parts are much greater even than those of + face and form, and that the range of adult and apparently normal + size and proportion, as well as function, and of both the age and + order of development, not only of each of the several parts + themselves, but of all their immediate annexes, and in females as + well as males, is far greater than has been recognized by any + writer. This fact is the basis of the anxieties and fears of + morphological abnormality so frequent during adolescence." (G.S. + Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. i, p. 414). + +In accordance with the supreme importance of the part they play, and the +intimately psychic nature of that part, the sexual organs, both internal +and external, are very richly supplied with nerves. While the internal +organs are very abundantly furnished with sympathetic nerves and ganglia, +the external organs show the highest possible degree of specialization of +the various peripheral nervous devices which the organism has developed +for receiving, accumulating, and transmitting stimuli to the brain.[77] + + "The number of conducting cords which attach the genitals to the + nervous centers is simply enormous," writes Bryan Robinson; "the + pudic nerve is composed of nearly all the third sacral and + branches from the second and fourth sacral. As one examines this + nerve he is forced to the conclusion that it is an enormous + supply for a small organ. The periphery of the pudic nerve + spreads itself like a fan over the genitals." The lesser sciatic + nerve supplies only one muscle--the gluteus maximus--and then + sends the large pudendal branch to the side of the penis, and + hence the friction of coitus induces active contraction of the + gluteus maximus, "the main muscle of coition." The large pudic + and the pudendal constitute the main supply of the external + genitals. In women the pudic nerve is equally large, but the + pudendal much smaller, possibly, Bryan Robinson suggests, because + women take a less active part in coitus. The nerve supply of the + clitoris, however, is three or four times as large as that of the + penis in proportion to size. (F.B. Robinson, "The Intimate + Nervous Connection of the Genito-Urinary Organs With the + Cerebro-Spinal and Sympathetic Systems," _New York Medical + Journal_, March 11, 1893; id., _The Abdominal Brain_, 1899.) + +Of all the sexual organs the penis is without doubt that which has most +powerfully impressed the human imagination. It is the very emblem of +generation, and everywhere men have contemplated it with a mixture of +reverence and shuddering awe that has sometimes, even among civilized +peoples, amounted to horror and disgust. Its image is worn as an amulet to +ward off evil and invoked as a charm to call forth blessing. The sexual +organs were once the most sacred object on which a man could place his +hands to swear an inviolate oath, just as now he takes up the Testament. +Even in the traditions of the great classic civilization which we inherit +the penis is _fascinus_, the symbol of all fascination. In the history of +human culture it has had far more than a merely human significance; it has +been the symbol of all the generative force of Nature, the embodiment of +creative energy in the animal and vegetable worlds alike, an image to be +held aloft for worship, the sign of all unconscious ecstasy. As a symbol, +the sacred phallus, it has been woven in and out of all the highest and +deepest human conceptions, so intimately that it is possible to see it +everywhere, that it is possible to fail to see it anywhere. + +In correspondence with the importance of the penis is the large number of +names which men have everywhere bestowed upon it. In French literature +many hundred synonyms may be found. They were also numerous in Latin. In +English the literary terms for the penis seem to be comparatively few, but +a large number of non-literary synonyms exist in colloquial and perhaps +merely local usage. The Latin term penis, which has established itself +among us as the most correct designation, is generally considered to be +associated with _pendere_ and to be connected therefore with the usually +pendent position of the organ. In the middle ages the general literary +term throughout Europe was _coles_ (or _colis_) from _caulis_, a stalk, +and _virga_, a rod. The only serious English literary term, yard (exactly +equivalent to _virga_), as used by Chaucer--almost the last great English +writer whose vocabulary was adequate to the central facts of life--has now +fallen out of literary and even colloquial usage. + + Pierer and Chaulant, in their anatomical and physiological + _Real-Lexicon_ (vol. vi, p. 134), give nearly a hundred synonyms + for the penis. Hyrtl (_Topographisches Anatomie_, seventh + edition, vol. ii, pp. 67-69), adds others. Schurig, in his + _Spermatologia_ (1720, pp. 89-91), also presents a number of + names for the penis; in Chapter III (pp. 189-192) of the same + book he discusses the penis generally with more fullness than + most authors. Louis de Landes, in his _Glossaire Erotique_ of the + French language (pp. 239-242), enumerates several hundred + literary synonyms for the penis, though many of them probably + only occur once. + + There is no thorough and comprehensive modern study of the penis + on an anthropological basis (though I should mention a valuable + and fully illustrated study of anthropological and pathological + variations of the penis in a series of articles by Marandon de + Montyel, "Des Anomalies des Organs Génitaux Externes Chez les + Aliénées," etc., _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, 1895), + and it would be out of place here to attempt to collect the + scattered notices regarding racial and other variations. It may + suffice to note some of the evidence showing that such variations + seem to be numerous and important. The Arab penis (according to + Kocher) is slender and long (a third longer than the average + European penis) and with a club-shaped glans. It undergoes little + change when it enters the erect state. The clothes leaves it + quite free, and the Arab practices manual excitement at an early + age to favor its development. + + Among the Fuegians, also, according to Hyades and Deniker (_Cap + Horn_, vol. vii, p. 153), the average length of the penis is 77 + millimeters, which is longer than in Europeans. + + In men of black race, also, the penis is decidedly large. Thus + Sir H.H. Johnston (_British Central Africa_, p. 399) states this + to be a universal rule. Among the Wankenda of Northern Nyassa, + for instance, he remarks that, while the body is of medium size, + the penis is generally large. He gives the usual length as about + six inches, reaching nine or ten in erection. The prepuce, it is + added, is often very long, and circumcision is practiced by many + tribes. + + Among the American negroes Hrdlicka has found, also (_Proceedings + American Association for the Advancement of Science_, vol. xlvii, + p. 475), that the penis in black boys is larger than in white + boys. + + The passages cited above suggest the question whether the penis + becomes larger by exercise of its generative functions. Most old + authors assert that frequent erection makes the penis large and + long (Schurig, _Spermatologia_, p. 107). Galen noted that in + singers and athletes, who were chaste in order to preserve their + strength, the sexual parts were small and rugrose, like those of + old men, and that exercise of the organs from youth develops + them; Roubaud, quoting this observation (_Traité de + l'Impuissance_, p. 373), agrees with the statement. It seems + probable that there is an element of truth in this ancient + belief. At the same time it must be remembered that the penis is + only to small extent a muscular organ, and that the increase of + size produced by frequent congestion of erectile tissues cannot + be either rapid or pronounced. Variations in the size of the + sexual organs are probably on the whole mainly inherited, though + it is impossible to speak decisively on this point until more + systematic observations become customary. + +The scrotum has usually, in the human imagination, been regarded merely as +an appendage of the penis, of secondary importance, although it is the +garment of the primary and essential organs of sex, and the fact that it +is not the seat of any voluptuous sensation has doubtless helped to +confirm this position. Even the name is merely a mediæval perversion of +_scortum_, skin or hide. In classic times it was usually called the pouch +or purse. The importance of the testicles has not, however, been +altogether ignored, as the very word _testis_ itself shows, for the +_testis_ is simply the _witness_ of virility.[78] + +It is easy to understand why the penis should occupy this special place in +man's thoughts as the supreme sexual organ. It is the one conspicuous and +prominent portion of the sexual apparatus, while its aptitude for swelling +and erecting itself involuntarily, under the influence of sexual emotion, +gives it a peculiar and almost unique position in the body. At the same +time it is the point at which, in the male body, all voluptuous sensation +is concentrated, the only normal masculine center of sex.[79] + +It is not easy to find any correspondingly conspicuous symbol of sex in +the sexual region of women. In the normal position nothing is visible but +the peculiarly human cushion of fat picturesquely termed the Mons Veneris +(because, as Palfyn said, all those who enroll themselves under the banner +of Venus must necessarily scale it), and even that is veiled from view in +the adult by the more or less bushy plantation of hair which grows upon +it. A triangle of varyingly precise definition is thus formed at the lower +apex of the trunk, and this would sometimes appear to have been regarded +as a feminine symbol.[80] But the more usual and typical symbol of +femininity is the idealized ring (by some savages drawn as a lozenge) of +the vulvar opening--the _yoni_ corresponding to the masculine +_lingam_--which is normally closed from view by the larger lips arising +from beneath the shadow of the _mons_. It is a symbol that, like the +masculine phallus, has a double meaning among primitive peoples and is +sometimes used to call down a blessing and sometimes to invoke a +curse.[81] + +This external opening of the feminine genital passage with its two +enclosing lips is now generally called the vulva. It would appear that +originally (as by Celsus and Pliny) this term included the womb, also, but +when the term "uterus" came into use "vulva" was confined (as its sense of +folding doors suggests that it should be) to the external entrance. The +classic term _cunnus_ for the external genitals was chiefly used by the +poets; it has been the etymological source of various European names for +this region, such as the old French _con_, which has now, however, +disappeared from literature while even in popular usage it has given place +to _lapin_ and similar terms. But there is always a tendency, marked in +most parts of the world, for the names of the external female parts to +become indecorous. Even in classic antiquity this part was the _pudendum_, +the part to be ashamed of, and among ourselves the mass of the +population, still preserving the traditions of primitive times, continue +to cherish the same notion. + + The anatomy, anthropology, folk-lore, and terminology of the + external and to some extent the internal feminine sexual region + may be studied in the following publications, among others: + Ploss, _Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter VI; Hyrtl, _Topographisches + Anatomie_, vol. ii, and other publications by the same scholarly + anatomist; W.J. Stewart Mackay, _History of Ancient Gynæcology_, + especially pp. 244-250; R. Bergh, "Symbolæ ad Cognitionem + Genitalium Externorum Foeminearum" (in Danish), + _Hospitalstidende_, August, 1894; and also in _Monatshefte für + Praktische Dermatologie_, 1897. D.S. Lamb, "The Female External + Genital Organs," _New York Journal of Gynæcology_, August, 1894; + R.L. Dickinson, "Hypertrophies of the Labia Minora and Their + Significance," _American Gynecology_, September, 1902; Kryptadia + (in various languages), vol. viii, pp. 3-11, 11-13, and many + other passages. Several of Schurig's works (especially + _Gynæcologia_, _Muliebria_, and _Parthenologia_) contain full + summaries of the statements of the early writers. + +The external or larger lips, like the mons veneris, are specifically human +in their full development, for in the anthropoid apes they are small as is +the mons, and in the lower apes absent altogether; they are, moreover, +larger in the white than in the other human races. Thus in the negro, and +to a less degree in the Japanese (Wernich) and the Javanese (Scherzer) +they are less developed than in women of white race. The greater lips +develop in the foetus later than the lesser lips, which are thus at first +uncovered; this condition thus constitutes an infantile state which +occasionally (in less than 2 per cent. of cases, according to Bergh) +persists in the adult. Their generally accepted name, labia majora, is +comparatively modern.[82] + + The outer sides of the labia majora are covered with hair, and on + the inner sides, which are smooth and moist, but are not true + mucous membrane, there are a few sweat glands and numerous large + sebaceous glands. Bergh considers that there is little or no hair + on the inner sides of the labia majora, but Lamb states that + careful examination shows that from one- to two-thirds of the + inner surface in adult women show hairs like those of the + external surface. In brunettes and women of dark races this + surface is pigmented; in dark races it is usually a slate gray. + From an examination of 2200 young Danish prostitutes Bergh has + found that there are two main varieties in the shape of the labia + majora, with transitional forms. In the first and most frequent + form the labia tend to be less marked and more effaced and + separated at the upper and anterior part, often being lost in the + sides of the mons and presenting a fissure which is broader in + its upper part and showing the inner lips more or less bare. In + the second form the labia are thicker and more outstanding and + the inner edges lie in contact throughout their whole length, + showing the _rima pudendi_ as a long narrow fissure. Whatever the + form, the labia close more tightly together in virgins and in + young individuals generally than in the deflowered and the + elderly. In children, as Martineau pointed out, the vulva appears + to look directly forward and the clitoris and urinary meatus + easily appear, while in adult women, and especially after + attempts at coitus have been made, the vulva appears directed + more below and behind, and the clitoris and meatus more covered + by the labia majora; so that the child urinates forward, while + the adult woman is usually able to urinate almost directly + downwards in the erect position, though in some cases (as may + occasionally be observed in the street) she can only do so when + bending slightly forwards. This difference in the direction of + the stream formerly furnished one of the methods of diagnosing + virginity, an uncertain one, since the difference is largely due + to age and individual variation. The main factor in the position + and aspect of the vulva is pelvic inclination. (See Havelock + Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, p. 64; Stratz, _Die + Schönheit des Weiblichen Körpers_, Chapter XII.) In the European + woman, according to Stratz, a considerable degree of pelvic + inclination is essential to beauty, concealing all but the + anterior third of the vulva. In negresses and other women of + lower race the vulva, however, usually lies further back, being + more conspicuous from behind than in European women; in this + respect lower races resemble the apes. Those women of dark race, + therefore, whose modesty is focused behind rather than in front + thus have sound anatomical considerations on their side. + + As Ploss and Bartels remark, a very common variation among + European women consists in an unusually posterior position of the + vulva and vaginal entrance, so that unless a cushion is placed + under the buttocks it is difficult for the man to effect coitus + in the usual position without giving much pain to the woman. They + add that another anomaly, less easy to remedy, consists in an + abnormally anterior position of the vaginal entrance close + beneath the pelvic bone, so that, although intromission is easy, + the spasmodic contraction of the vagina at the culmination of + orgasm presses the penis against the bone and causes intolerable + pain to the man. + +The mons veneris and the labia majora are, after the age of puberty, +always normally covered by a more or less profuse growth of hair. It is +notable that the apes, notwithstanding their general tendency to +hairiness, show no such special development of hair in this region. We +thus see that all the external and more conspicuous portions of the sexual +sphere in woman--the mons veneris, the labia majora, and the +hair--represent not so much an animal inheritance, such as we commonly +misrepresent them to be, but a higher and genuinely human development. As +none of these structures subserve any clear practical use, it would appear +that they must have developed by sexual selection to satisfy the æsthetic +demands of the eye.[83] + + The character and arrangement of the pubic hair, investigated by + Eschricht and Voigt more than half a century ago, have been more + recently studied by Bergh. As these observers have pointed out, + there are various converging hair streams from above and below, + the clitoris seeming to be the center towards which they are + directed. The hair-covering thus formed is usually ample and, as + a rule, is more so in brunettes than in blondes. It is nearly + always bent, curly and more or less spirally twisted.[84] There + are frequently one or two curls at the commencement of the + fissure, rolled outwards, and occasionally a well marked tuft in + the middle line. In abundance the pubic hair corresponds with the + axillary hair; when one region is defective in hair the other is + usually so also. Strong eyebrows also usually indicate a strong + development of pubic hair. But the hair of the head usually + varies independently, and Bergh found that of 154 women with + spare pubic hair 72 had good and often profuse hair on the head. + Complete or almost complete absence of pubic hair is in Bergh's + experience only found in about 3 per cent. of women; these were + all young and blonde. + +Rothe, in his investigation of the pubic hair of 1000 Berlin women, found +that no two women were really alike in this respect, but there was a +tendency to two main types of arrangement, with minor subdivisions, +according as the hair tended to grow chiefly in the middle line extending +laterally from that line, or to grow equally over the whole extent of the +pubic region; these two groups included half the cases investigated. + + In men the pubic hair normally ascends anteriorly in a faint line + up to the navel, with tendency to form a triangle with the apex + above, and posteriorly extends backwards to the anus. In women + these anterior and posterior extensions are comparatively rare, + or at all events are only represented by a few stray hairs. Rothe + found this variation in 4 per cent. of North German women, though + a triangle of hair was only found in 2 per cent.; Lombroso found + it in 5 per cent, of Italian women; Bergh found it in only 1.6 + per cent. among 1000 Danish prostitutes, all sixteen of whom with + three exceptions were brunettes. In Vienna, among 600 women, Coe + found only 1 per cent, with this distribution of hair, and states + that they were women of decidedly masculine type, though Ploss + and Bartels, as well as Rothe, find, however, that heterogeny, as + they term the masculine distribution, is more common in blondes. + The anterior extension of hair is usually accompanied by the + posterior extension around the anus, usually very slight, but + occasionally as pronounce as in men. (According to Rothe, + however, anterior heterogeny comparatively rare.) These masculine + variations in the extension of the pubic hair appear to be not + uncommonly associated with other physical and psychic anomalies; + it is on this account that they have sometimes been regarded as + indications of a vicious or a criminal temperament; they are, + however, found in quite normal women. + + The pubic hair of women is usually shorter than that of men, but + thick, and the individual hairs stronger and larger in diameter + than those of men, as Pfaff first showed; dark hair is usually + stronger than light. In both length and size the individual + variations are considerable. The usual length is about 2 inches, + or 3-5 centimeters, occasionally reaching about 4 inches, or 9-10 + centimeters, in the larger curls. In a series of 100 women + attended during confinement in London and the north of England I + have only once (in a rather blonde Lancashire woman) found the + hair on labia reaching a conspicuous length of several inches and + forming an obstruction to the manipulations involved in delivery. + But Jahn delivered a woman whose pubic hair was longer than that + of her head, reaching below her knee; Paulini also knew a woman + whose pubic hair nearly reached her knees and was sold to make + wigs; Bartholin mentions a soldier's wife who plaited her pubic + hair behind her back; while Brantôme has several references to + abnormally long hair in ladies of the French court during the + sixteenth century. In 8 cases out of 2200 Bergh found the pubic + hair forming a large curly wig extending to the iliac spines. The + individual hairs have occasionally been found so stiff and + brush-like as to render coitus difficult. + + In color the pubic hair, while generally approximating to that of + the head, is sometimes (according to Rothe, in Germany, in + one-third cases) lighter, and sometimes somewhat darker, as is + found to be the case by Coe, especially in brunettes, and also by + Bergh, in Denmark. Bergh remarks that it is generally + intermediate in color between the eyebrows and the axillary hair, + the latter being more or less decolorized by sweat, and that, + owing to the influence of the urine and vaginal discharges, the + labial hair is paler than that on the mons; blondes with dark + eyebrows usually have dark hair on the mons. The hair on this + spot, as Aristotle observed, is usually the last to turn gray. + +The key to the genital apparatus in women from the psychic point of view, +and, indeed, to some extent, its anatomical center, is to be found in the +clitoris. Anatomically and developmentally the clitoris is the rudimentary +analogue of the masculine penis. Functionally, however, its scope is very +much smaller. While the penis both receives and imparts specific +voluptuous sensations, and is at the same time both the intromittent organ +for the semen and the conduit for the urine, the sole function of the +clitoris is to enter into erection under the stress of sexual emotion and +receive and transmit the stimulatory voluptuous sensations imparted to it +by friction with the masculine genital apparatus. It is so insignificant +an organ that it is only within recent times that its homology with the +penis has been realized. In 1844 Kobelt wrote in his important book, _Die +Mannlichen und Weiblichen Wollust-Organe_, that in his attempt to show +that the female organs are exactly analogous to the male the reader will +probably be unable to follow him, while even Johannes Müller, the father +of scientific physiology, declared at about the same period that the +clitoris is essentially different from the penis. It is indeed but three +centuries since the clitoris was so little known that (in 1593) Realdus +Columbus actually claimed the honor of discovering it. Columbus was not +its discoverer, for Fallopius speedily showed that Avicenna and Albucasis +had referred to it.[85] The Arabs appear to have been very familiar with +it, and, from the various names they gave it, clearly understood the +important part it plays in generating voluptuous emotion.[86] But it was +known in classic antiquity; the Greeks called it myrton, the myrtle-berry; +Galen and Soranus called it nymphê because it is covered as a bride is +veiled, while the old Latin name was _tentigo_, from its power of entering +into erection, and _columella_, the little pillar, from its shape. The +modern term, which is Greek and refers to the sensitiveness of the part to +voluptuous titillation, is said to have originated with Suidas and +Pollux.[87] It was mentioned, though not adopted, by Rufus. + +"The clitoris," declared Haller, "is a part extremely sensible and +wonderfully prurient." It is certainly the chief though by no means the +only point through which the immediate call to detumescence is conveyed to +the female organism. It is, indeed, as Bryan Robinson remarks, "a +veritable electrical bell button which, being pressed or irritated, rings +up the whole nervous system." + + The nervous supply of this little organ is very large, and the + dorsal nerve of the clitoris is relatively three or four times + larger than that of the penis. Yet the sensitive point of this + organ is only 5 to 7 millimeters in extent. The length of the + clitoris is usually rather over 2 centimeters (or about an inch) + and 3 centimeters when erect; a length of 4 centimeters or more + was regarded by Martineau as within the normal range of + variation. It is not usual to find the clitoris longer than this + in Europe (for among some races like the negro the clitoris is + generally large), but all degrees of magnitude may be found as + rare exceptions. (See, e.g., Sir J.Y. Simpson, "Hermaphrodites," + _Obstetric Memoirs and Contributions_, vol. ii, pp. 217-226; also + Dickinson, loc. cit.) It was formerly thought that the clitoris + is easily enlarged by masturbation, and Martineau believed that + in this way it might be doubled in length. It is probable that + slight enlargement of the clitoris may be caused by very + frequent masturbation, but only to an insignificant extent, and + it is impossible to diagnose masturbation from the size of the + clitoris. Among the women of Lake Nyassa, as well as in the + Caroline Islands, special methods are practiced for elongating + the clitoris, but in Europe, at all events, it is probable that + the variations in the size of the organ are mainly congenital. It + may well be that a congenitally large clitoris is associated with + an abnormally developed excitability of the sexual apparatus. + Tilt stated (_On Uterine and Ovarian Inflammation_, p. 37) that + in his experience there was a frequent though not invariable + connection between a large clitoris and sexual proclivity. + (Schurig referred to a case of intense and life-long sexual + obsession associated with an extremely large clitoris, + _Gynæcologia_, pp. 16-17.) Of recent years considerable + importance has been attached by some gynecologists (e.g., R.T. + Morris, "Is Evolution Trying to Do Away With the Clitoris?" + _Transactions American Association of Obstetricians and + Gynecologists_, vol. v, 1893) to preputial adhesions around the + clitoris as a source of nervous disturbance and invalidism in + young women. + +While the clitoris is anatomically analogous to the penis, its actual +mechanism under the stress of sexual excitement is somewhat different. As +Liétaud long since pointed out, it cannot rise freely in erection as the +penis can; it is apparently bound down by its prepuce and its frenulum. +Waldeyer, in his book on the pelvis, states more precisely that, unlike +the penis, when erect it retains its angle, only this becomes somewhat +rounded so that the organ is to some slight extent lifted and protruded. +Waldeyer considered that the clitoris was thus perfectly fitted to fulfill +its part as the recipient of erotic stimulation from friction by the +penis. Adler, however, has pointed out with considerable justice, that +this is not altogether the case. The clitoris was developed in mammals who +practiced the posterior mode of coitus; in this position the clitoris was +beneath the penis, which was thus easily able in coitus to press it +against the pubic bone close beneath which it is situated, and thus impart +the compression and friction which the feminine organ craves. But in the +human anterior mode of coitus it is not necessarily brought into close +contact with the penis during the act of coitus, and thus fails to receive +powerful stimulation. Its restricted position, which is an advantage in +posterior coitus, is a disadvantage in anterior coitus. Adler observes +that it thus comes about that the human method of coitus, while by +bringing breast to breast and face to face it has added a new dignity and +refinement, a fresh source of enjoyment, to the embrace of the sexes, has +not been an unmixed advantage to woman, for while man has lost nothing by +the change, woman has now to contend with an increased difficulty in +attaining an adequate amount of pressure on that "electric button" which +normally sets the whole mechanism in operation.[88] + +We may well bring into connection with the changed conditions brought +about by anterior coitus the interesting fact that while the clitoris +remains the most exquisitely sensitive of the sexual centers in woman, +voluptuous sensitivity is much more widely diffused in woman than in man. +Over the whole body, indeed, it is apt to be more distinctly marked than +is usually the case in man. But even if we confine ourselves to the +genital region, while in man that portion of the penis which enters the +vagina, and especially the glans, is normally the only portion which, even +during turgescence, is sensitive to voluptuous contacts, in woman the +whole of the region comprised within the larger lips, including even the +anus and internally the vagina and the vaginal portion of the womb,[89] +become sensitive to voluptuous contacts. Deprived of the penis the ability +of a man to experience specifically sexual sensations becomes very limited +indeed. But the loss of the clitoris or of any other structure involves no +correspondingly serious disability on women. Ablation of the clitoris for +sexual hyperæsthesia has for this reason been abandoned, except under +special circumstances. The members of the Russian Skoptzy sect habitually +amputate the clitoris, nymphæ, and breasts, yet many young Skoptzy women +told the Russian physician, Guttceit, that they were perfectly well able +to enjoy coitus. + + Freud believes that in very young girls the clitoris is the + exclusive seat of sexual sensation, masturbation at this age + being directed to the clitoris alone, and spontaneous sexual + excitement being confined to twitchings and erection of this + organ, so that young girls are able, from their own experience, + to recognize without instruction the signs of sexual excitement + in boys. At a later age sexual excitability spreads from the + clitoris to other regions--just as the easy inflammability of + wood sets light to coal--though in the male the penis remains + from first to last normally the almost exclusive seat of specific + excitability. (S. Freud, _Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie_, + p. 62.) + + The anus would, however, seem to be sometimes an erogenous zone + even at an early age. Titillation of the anus appears to be + frequently pleasurable in women; and this is not surprising + considering the high degree of erotic sensitivity which is easily + developed at the body orifices where skin meets mucous membrane. + (Thus the meatus of the urethra is a highly erogenous zone, as is + sufficiently shown by the frequency with which hair-pins and + other articles used in masturbation find their way into the + bladder.) It is in this germinal sensitivity, undoubtedly, that + we find a chief key to the practice of _pedicatio_. Freud + attaches great importance to the anus as a sexually erogenous + zone at a very early age, and considers that it very frequently + makes its influence felt in this respect. He believes that + intestinal catarrhs in very early life and hæmorrhoids later tend + to develop sensibility in the anus. He finds an indication that + the anus has become a sexually erogenous zone when children wish + to allow the contents of the rectum to accumulate so that + defecation may by its increased difficulty involve voluptuous + sensations, and adds that masturbatory excitation of the anus + with the fingers is by no means rare in older children. (S. + Freud, _Op. cit._, pp. 40-42.) A medical correspondent in India + tells me of a European lady who derived, she said, "quite as + much, indeed more," pleasure from digitally titillating her + rectum as from vulvo-vaginal titillation; she had several times + submitted to _pedicatio_ and enjoyed it, though it was painful + during penetration. The anus may retain this erogenous + irritability even in old age, and Routh mentions the case of a + lady of over 70, the reverse of lustful, who was so excited by + the act of defecation that she was invariably compelled to + masturbate, although this state of things was a source of great + mental misery to her. (C.H.F. Routh, _British Gynæcological + Journal_, February, 1887, p. 48.) + + Bölsche has sought the explanation of the erogenous nature of the + anus, and the key to _pedicatio_, in an atavistic return to the + very remote amphibian days when the anus was combined with the + sexual parts in a common cloaca. But it is unnecessary to invoke + any vestigial inheritance from a vastly remote past when we bear + in mind that the innervation of these two adjoining regions is + inevitably very closely related. The presence of a body exit with + its marked and special sensitivity at a point where it can + scarcely fail to receive the nervous overflow from an immensely + active center of nervous energy quite adequately accounts for the + phenomenon in question. + +The inner lips, the nymphæ or labia minora, running parallel with the +greater lips which enclose them, embrace the clitoris anteriorly and +extend backward, enclosing the urethral exit between them as well as the +vaginal entrance. They form little wings whence their old Latin name, +_alæ_, and from their resemblance to the cock's comb were by Spigelius +termed crista galli. The red and (especially in brunettes) dark appearance +of the nymphæ suggests that they are mucous membrane and not +integumentary; it is, however, now considered that even on the inner +surface they are covered by skin and separated from the mucous membrane by +a line.[90] In structure, as described by Waldeyer, they consist of fine +connective tissue rich in elastic fibers as well as some muscular tissue, +and full of large veins, so that they are capable of a considerable degree +of turgescence resembling erection during sexual excitement, while +Ballantyne finds that the nymphæ are supplied to a notable extent with +nervous end-organs. + +More than any other part of the sexual apparatus in either sex, the lesser +lips, on account of their shape, their position, and their structure, are +capable of acquired modifications, more especially hypertrophy and +elongation. By stretching, it is stated, a labium can be doubled in its +dimensions. The "Hottentot apron," or elongated nymphæ, commonly found +among some peoples in South Africa, has long been a familiar phenomenon. +In such cases a length or transverse diameter of 3 to 5 centimeters is +commonly found. But such elongated nymphæ are by no means confined to one +part of the world or to one race; they are quite common among women of +European race, and reach a size equal to most of the more reliably +recorded Hottentot cases. Dickinson, who has very carefully studied this +question in New York, finds that in 1000 consecutive gynæcological cases +the labia showed some form of hypertrophy in 36 per cent., or more than 1 +in 3; while among 150 of these cases who were neurasthenic, the proportion +reached 56 per cent., even when minor or doubtful enlargements were +disregarded. Bergh, in about 16 per cent. cases, found very enlarged +nymphæ, the height reached in about 5 per cent. of the cases of +enlargement being nearly six centimeters. Ploss and Bartels, in a full +discussion: of the "Hottentot apron," come to the conclusion that this +condition is perhaps in most cases artificially produced. It is known that +among the Basutos it is the custom for the elder girls to manipulate the +nymphæ of younger children, when alone with them, almost from birth, and +on account of the elastic nature of these structures such manipulation +quite adequately accounts for the elongation. It is not necessary to +suppose that the custom is practiced for the sake of producing sexual +stimulation--though this may frequently occur--since there are numerous +similar primitive customs involving deformation of the sexual organs +without the production of sexual excitement. Dickinson has come to a +similar conclusion as regards the corresponding elongation of the nymphæ +in civilized European women. In 361 out of 1000 women of good social class +he found elongation or thickening, often with a notable degree of +wrinkling and pigmentation, and believes that this is always the result of +frequently repeated masturbation practiced with the separation of the +nymphæ; in 30 per cent. of the cases admission of masturbation was +made.[91] While this conclusion is probably correct in the main, it +requires some qualification. To assert that whenever in women who have +not been pregnant the marked protrusion of the inner lips beyond the outer +lips means that at some period manipulation has been practiced with or +without the production of sexual excitement is to make too absolute a +statement. It is highly probable that the nymphæ, like the clitoris, are +congenitally more prominent in some of the lower human races, as they are +also in the apes; among the Fuegians, for instance, according to Hyades +and Deniker, the labia minora descend lower than in Europeans, although +there is not the slightest reason to suppose that these women practice any +manipulations. Among European women, again, the nymphæ sometimes protrude +very prominently beyond the labia majora in women who are organically of +somewhat infantile type; this occurs in cases in which we may be convinced +that no manipulations have ever been practiced.[92] + +It is difficult to speak very decisively as to the function of the labia +minora. They doubtless exert some amount of protective influence over the +entrance to the vagina, and in this way correspond to the lips of the +mouth after which they are called. They fulfill, however, one very +definite though not obviously important function which is indicated by the +mythologic name they have received. There is, indeed, some obscurity in +the origin of this term, nymphæ, which has not, I believe, been +satisfactorily cleared up. It has been stated that the Greek name nymphê +has been transferred from the clitoris to the labia minora. Any such +transfer could only have taken place when the meaning of the word had been +forgotten, and nymphê had become the totally different word _nymphæ_, the +goddesses who presided over streams. The old anatomists were much +exercised in their minds as to the meaning of the name, but on the whole +were inclined to believe that it referred to the action of the labia +minora in directing the urinary stream. The term nymphæ was first applied +in the modern sense, according to Bergh, in 1599, by Pinæus, mainly from +the influence of these structures on the urinary stream, and he dilated in +his _De Virginitate_ on the suitability of the term to designate so poetic +a spot.[93] In more modern times Luschka and Sir Charles Bell considered +that it is one of the uses of the nymphæ to direct the stream of urine, +and Lamb from his own observation thinks the same conclusion probable. In +reality there cannot be the slightest doubt about the function of the +nymphæ, as, in Hyrtl's phrase, "the naiads of the urinary source," and it +can be demonstrated by the simplest experiment.[94] + +The nymphæ form the intermediate portal of the vagina, as the canal which +conducts to the womb was in anatomy first termed (according to Hyrtl) by +De Graaf.[95] It is a secreting, erectile, more or less sensitive canal +lined by what is usually considered mucous membrane, though some have +regarded it as integument of the same character as that of the external +genitals; it certainly resembles such integument more than, for instance, +the mucous membrane of the rectum. In the woman who has never had sexual +intercourse and has been subjected to no manipulations or accidents +affecting this region, the vagina is closed by a last and final gate of +delicate membrane--scarcely admitting more than a slender finger--called +the hymen. + + The poets called the hymen "fios virginitatis," the flower of + virginity, whence the medico-legal term _defloratio_. + Notwithstanding the great significance which has long been + attached to the phenomena connected with it, the hymen was not + accurately known until Vesalius, Fallopius, and Spigelius + described and named it. It was, however, recognized by the Arab + authors, Avicenna and Averroes. The early literature concerning + it is summarized by Schurig, _Muliebria_, 1729, Section II, cap. + V. The same author's _Parthenologia_ is devoted to the various + ancient problems connected with the question of virginity. + +To say that this delicate piece of membrane is from the non-physical point +of view a more important structure than any other part of the body is to +convey but a feeble idea of the immense importance of the hymen in the +eyes of the men of many past ages and even of our own times and among our +own people.[96] For the uses of the feminine body, or for its beauty, +there is no part which is more absolutely insignificant. But in human +estimation it has acquired a spiritual value which has made it far more +than a part of the body. It has taken the place of the soul, that whose +presence gives all her worth and dignity, even her name, to the unmarried +woman, her purity, her sexual desirability, her market value. Without +it--though in all physical and mental respects she might remain the same +person--she has sometimes been a mark for contempt, a worthless +outcast.[97] + + So fragile a membrane scarcely possesses the reliability which + should be possessed by a structure whose presence or absence has + often meant so much. Its absence by no means necessarily + signifies that a woman has had intercourse with a man. Its + presence by no means signifies that she has never had such + intercourse. + + There are many ways in which the hymen may be destroyed apart + from coitus. Among the Chinese (and also, it would appear, in + India and some other parts of the East) the female parts are from + infancy kept so scrupulously clean by daily washing, the finger + being introduced into the vagina, that the hymen rapidly + disappears, and its existence is unknown even to Chinese doctors. + Among some Brazilian Indians a similar practice exists among + mothers as regards their young children, less, however, for the + sake of cleanliness than in order to facilitate sexual + intercourse in future years. (Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. + i, Chapter VI.) The manipulations of vaginal masturbation will, + of course, similarly destroy the hymen. It is also quite possible + for the hymen to be ruptured by falls and other accidents. (See, + e.g., a lengthy study by Nina-Rodrigues, "Des Ruptures de l'Hymen + dans les Chutes," _Annales d'Hygiène Publique_, September, 1903.) + + On the other hand, integrity of the hymen is no proof of + virginity, apart from the obvious fact that there may be + intercourse without penetration. (The case has even been recorded + of a prostitute with syphilitic condylomata, a somewhat masculine + type of pubic arch, and vulva rather posteriorly placed, whose + hymen had never been penetrated.) The hymen may be of a yielding + or folding type, so that complete penetration may take place and + yet the hymen be afterwards found unruptured. It occasionally + happens that the hymen is found intact at the end of pregnancy. + In some, though not all, of these cases there has been conception + without intromission of the penis. This has occurred even when + the entrance was very minute. The possibility of such conception + has long been recognized, and Schurig (_Syllepsilogia_, 1731, + Section I, cap. VIII, p. 2) quotes ancient authors who have + recorded cases. For some typical modern cases see Guérard + (_Centralblatt für Gynäkologie_, No. 15, 1895), in one of whose + cases the hymen of the pregnant woman scarcely admitted a hair; + also Braun (ib., No. 23, 1895). + +The hymen has played a very definite and pronounced part in the social and +moral life of humanity. Until recently it has been more difficult to +decide what precise biological function it has exercised to ensure its +development and preservation. Sexual selection, no doubt, has worked in +its favor, but that influence has been very limited and comparatively very +recent. Virginity is not usually of any value among peoples who are +entirely primitive. Indeed, even in the classic civilization which we +inherit, it is easy to show that the virgin and the admiration for +virginity are of late growth; the virgin goddesses were not originally +virgins in our modern sense. Diana was the many-breasted patroness of +childbirth before she became the chaste and solitary huntress, for the +earliest distinction would appear to have been simply between the woman +who was attached to a man and the woman who followed an earlier rule of +freedom and independence; it was a later notion to suppose that the latter +woman was debarred from sexual intercourse. We certainly must not seek the +origin of the hymen in sexual selection; we must find it in natural +selection. And here it might seem at first sight that we come upon a +contradiction in Nature, for Nature is always devising contrivances to +secure the maximum amount of fertilization. "Increase and multiply" is so +obviously the command of Nature that the Hebrews, with their usual +insight, unhesitatingly dared to place it in the mouth of Jehovah. But the +hymen is a barrier to fertilization. It has, however, always to be +remembered that as we rise in the zoölogical scale, and as the period of +gestation lengthens and the possible number of offspring is fewer, it +becomes constantly more essential that fertilization shall be effective +rather than easy; the fewer the progeny the more necessary it is that they +shall be vigorous enough to survive. There can be little doubt that, as +one or two writers have already suggested, the hymen owes its development +to the fact that its influence is on the side of effective fertilization. +It is an obstacle to the impregnation of the young female by immature, +aged, or feeble males. The hymen is thus an anatomical expression of that +admiration of force which marks the female in her choice of a mate. So +regarded, it is an interesting example of the intimate manner in which +sexual selection is really based on natural selection. Sexual selection is +but the translation into psychic terms of a process which has already +found expression in the physical texture of the body. + + It may be added that this interpretation of the biological + function of the hymen is supported by the facts of its evolution. + It is unknown among the lower mammals, with whom fertilization is + easy, gestation short and offspring numerous. It only begins to + appear among the higher mammals in whom reproduction is already + beginning to take on the characters which become fully developed + in man. Various authors have found traces of a rudimentary hymen, + not only in apes, but in elephants, horses, donkeys, bitches, + bears, pigs, hyenas, and giraffes. (Hyrtl, _Op. cit._, vol. ii, + p. 189; G. Gellhoen, "Anatomy and Development of the Hymen," + _American Journal Obstetrics_, August, 1904.) It is in the human + species that the tendency to limitation of offspring is most + marked, combined at the same time with a greater aptitude for + impregnation than exists among any lower mammals. It is here, + therefore, that a physical check is of most value, and + accordingly we find that in woman alone, of all animals, is the + hymen fully developed. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[72] "Analysis of the Sexual Impulse," in vol. iii of these _Studies_. + +[73] "The accomplishment of no other function," Hyrtl remarks, "is so +intimately connected with the mind and yet so independent of it." + +[74] The process is still, however, but imperfectly understood; see Art. +"Fécondation," by Ed. Retterer, in Richet's _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_, +vol. vi, 1905. + +[75] Thus a male foetus showing reptilian characters in sexual ducts was +exhibited by Shattock at the Pathological Society of London, February 19, +1895. + +[76] J. Kohlbrugge, "Die Umgestaltung des Uterus der Affen nach den +Geburt," _Zeitschrift für Morphologie_, bd. iv, p. 1, 1901. + +[77] There are, however, no special nerve endings (Krause corpuscles), as +was formerly supposed. The nerve endings in the genital region are the +same as elsewhere. The difference lies in the abundance of superposed +arboreal ramifications. See, e.g., Ed. Retterer, Art. "Ejaculation," +Richet's _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_, vol. v. + +[78] Hyrtl, _Op. cit._, vol. ii, p. 39. + +[79] Sensations of pleasure without those of touch appear to be normal at +the tip of the penis, as pointed out by Scripture, quoted in _Alienist and +Neurologist_, January, 1898. + +[80] See the previous volume of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection in +Man," p. 161. + +[81] See, e.g., Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, beginning of +chapter VI. + +[82] Hyrtl states that the name _labia_ was first used by Haller in the +middle of the eighteenth century in his _Elements of Physiology_, being +adopted by him from the Greek poet Erotion, who gave these structures the +very obvious name cheilea, lips. But this seems to be a mistake, for the +seventeenth century anatomists certainly used the name "labia" for these +parts. + +[83] Bergh tentatively suggests, as regards the pubic hair, that its +appearance may be due to the upright walk in man and the human position +during coitus, the hair preventing irritation of the genitals from the +sweat pouring down from the body and protecting the skin from direct +friction in coitus. (In both these suggestions he was, however, long +previously anticipated by Fabricius ab Aquapendente.) The fanciful +suggestion of Louis Robinson that the pubic hair has developed in order to +enable the human infant to cling securely to his mother is very poorly +supported by facts, and has not met with acceptance. It may be mentioned +that (as stated by Ploss and Bartels) the women of the Bismarck +Archipelago, whose pubic hair is very abundant, use it as a kind of +handkerchief on which to clean their hands. + +[84] Routh and Heywood Smith have noted that the pubic hair tends to lose +its curliness and become straight in women who masturbate. (_British +Gynæcological Journal_, February, 1887, p. 505.) + +[85] Schurig, _Muliebria_, p. 75. Plazzon in 1621 said that in Italian it +had a popular name, _il besneegio_. + +[86] Schurig brought together in his _Gynæcologia_ (pp. 2-4) various early +opinions concerning the clitoris as the seat of voluptuous feeling. + +[87] Hyrtl, _Op. cit._, vol. ii, p. 193. + +[88] Adler, _Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, 1904, pp. +117-119. + +[89] The voluptuous sensations caused by sexual contacts producing +movements of the womb are probably normal and usual. They may even occur +under circumstances unconnected with sexual emotion, and Mundé +(_International Journal of Surgery_, March, 1893) mentions incidentally +that in one case while titillating the cervix with a sound the woman very +plainly showed voluptuous manifestations. + +[90] Henle stated that fine hairs are frequently visible on the nymphæ; +Stieda (_Zeitschrift für Morphologie_, 1902, p. 458) remarks that he has +never been able to see them with the naked eye. + +[91] R.L. Dickinson, "Hypertrophies of the Labia Minora and Their +Significance," _American Gynæcologist_, September, 1902. It is perhaps +noteworthy that Bergh found that in 302 cases in which the nymphæ were of +unequal length, in all but 24 the left was longer. + +[92] It may be remarked that Bergh believes that the nymphæ, and indeed +the external genitals generally, are congenitally more strongly developed +in libidinous persons, and at the same time in brunettes, while in public +prostitutes this is not usually the case, which confirms the belief that +exalted sexual sensibility does not usually lead to prostitution. He adds +that prostitution, unless carried on for many years, has little effect on +the shape of the external genitals. + +[93] Schurig (_Muliebria_, 1729, Section II, cap. II) gives numerous +quotations on this point; thus De Graaf wrote in his book on the sexual +organs of women: "Tales protuberantiæ nymphæ appellantur ea propter quod +aquis e vesica prosilientibus proxime adstare reperiantur, quandoquidem +inter illas, tanquam duos parietes, urina magno impetu cum sibilo sæpe et +absque labiorum irrigatione erumpit, vel quod sint castitatis præsides, +aut sponsam primo intromittant." + +[94] Havelock Ellis, "The Bladder as a Dynamometer," _American Journal of +Dermatology_, May, 1902. If a woman who has never been pregnant, standing +in the erect position before commencing the act of urination presses apart +the labia minora with index and middle fingers the stream will be +projected forward so as to fall usually at a considerable distance in +front of a vertical line from the meatus; if when the act is half +completed the fingers are removed, the labia close together and the +stream, though maintained at a constant pressure, at once changes its +character and direction. + +[95] In poetry this term was employed by Plautus, _Pseudolus_, Act IV, Sc. +7. The Greek aidoion sometimes meant vagina and sometimes the external +sexual parts; kolpos was used for the vagina alone. + +[96] It is curious, however, that the European physicians of the +seventeenth and even eighteenth centuries were doubtful of its value as a +sign of virginity and considered it often absent. + +[97] For a summary of the beliefs and practices of various peoples with +regard to the hymen and virginity see Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. +i, Chapter XVI. + + + + +II + +The Object of Detumescence--Erogenous Zones--The Lips--The Vascular +Characters of Detumescence--Erectile Tissue--Erection in Woman--Mucous +Emission in Women--Sexual Connection--The Human Mode of +Intercourse--Normal Variations--The Motor Characters of +Detumescence--Ejaculation--The Virile Reflex--The General Phenomena of +Detumescence--The Circulatory and Respiratory Phenomena--Blood +Pressure--Cardiac Disturbance--Glandular Activity--Distillatio--The +Essentially Motor Character of Detumescence--Involuntary Muscular +Irradiation to Bladder, etc.--Erotic Intoxication--Analogy of Sexual +Detumescence and Vesical Tension--The Specifically Sexual Movements of +Detumescence in Man--In Woman--The Spontaneous Movements of the Genital +Canal in Woman--Their Function in Conception--Part Played by Active +Movement of the Spermatozoa--The Artificial Injection of Semen--The Facial +Expression During Detumescence--The Expression of Joy--The Occasional +Serious Effects of Coitus. + + +We have seen what the object of detumescence is, and we have briefly +considered the organs and structures which are chiefly concerned in the +process. We have now to inquire what are the actual phenomena which take +place during the act of detumescence. + +Detumescence is normally linked closely to tumescence. Tumescence is the +piling on of the fuel; detumescence is the leaping out of the devouring +flame whence is lighted the torch of life to be handed on from generation +to generation. The whole process is double and yet single; it is exactly +analogous to that by which a pile is driven into the earth by the raising +and then the letting go of a heavy weight which falls on to the head of +the pile. In tumescence the organism is slowly wound up and force +accumulated; in the act of detumescence the accumulated force is let go +and by its liberation the sperm-bearing instrument is driven home. +Courtship, as we commonly term the process of tumescence which takes place +when a woman is first sexually approached by a man, is usually a highly +prolonged process. But it is always necessary to remember that every +repetition of the act of coitus, to be normally and effectively carried +out on both sides, demands a similar double process; detumescence must be +preceded by an abbreviated courtship. + +This abbreviated courtship by which tumescence is secured or heightened in +the repetition of acts of coitus which have become familiar, is mainly +tactile.[98] Since the part of the man in coitus is more active and that +of the woman more passive, the sexual sensitivity of the skin seems to be +more pronounced in women. There are, moreover, regions of the surface of a +woman's body where contact, when sympathetic, seems specially liable to +arouse erotic excitement. Such erogenous zones are often specially marked +in the breasts, occasionally in the palm of the hand, the nape of the +neck, the lobule of the ear, the little finger; there is, indeed, perhaps +no part of the surface of the body which may not, in some individuals at +some time, become normally an erogenous zone. In hysteria the erotic +excitability of these zones is sometimes very intense. The lips are, +however, without doubt, the most persistently and poignantly sensitive +region of the whole body outside the sphere of the sexual organs +themselves. Hence the significance of the kiss as a preliminary of +detumescence.[99] + + The importance of the lips as a normal erogenous zone is shown by + the experiments of Gualino. He applied a thread, folded on itself + several times, to the lips, thus stimulating them in a simple + mechanical manner. Of 20 women, between the ages of 18 and 35, + only 8 felt this as a merely mechanical operation, 4 felt a + vaguely erotic element in the proceeding, 3 experienced a desire + for coitus and in 5 there was actual sexual excitement with + emission of mucus. Of 25 men, between the ages of 20 and 30, in + 15 all sexual feeling was absent, in 7 erotic ideas were + suggested with congestion of the sexual organs without erection, + and in 3 there was the beginning of erection. It should be added + that both the women and the men in whom this sexual reflex was + more especially marked were of somewhat nervous temperament; in + such persons erotic reactions of all kinds generally occur most + easily. (Gualino, "Il Rifflesso Sessuale nell' eccitamento alle + labbre," _Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1904, p. 341.) + +As tumescence, under the influence of sensory stimulation, proceeds toward +the climax when it gives place to detumescence, the physical phenomena +become more and more acutely localized in the sexual organs. The process +which was at first predominantly nervous and psychic now becomes more +prominently vascular. The ancient sexual relationship of the skin asserts +itself; there is marked surface congestion showing itself in various ways. +The face tends to become red, and exactly the same phenomenon is taking +place in the genital organs; "an erection," it has been said, "is a +blushing of the penis." The difference is that in the genital organs this +heightened vascularity has a definite and specific function to +accomplish--the erection of the male organ which fits it to enter the +female parts--and that consequently there has been developed in the penis +that special kind of vascular mechanism, consisting of veins in connective +tissue with unstriped muscular fibers, termed erectile tissue.[100] + +It is not only the man who is supplied with erectile tissue which in the +process of tumescence becomes congested and swollen. The woman also, in +the corresponding external genital region, is likewise supplied with +erectile tissue now also charged with blood, and exhibits the same changes +as have taken place in her partner, though less conspicuously visible. In +the anthropoid apes, as the gorilla, the large clitoris and the nymphæ +become prominent in sexual excitement, but the less development of the +clitoris in women, together with the specifically human evolution of the +mons veneris and larger lips, renders this sexual turgescence practically +invisible, though it is perceptible to touch in an increased degree of +spongy and elastic tension. The whole feminine genital canal, including +the uterus, indeed, is richly supplied with blood-vessels, and is capable +during sexual excitement of a very high degree of turgescence, a kind of +erection. + +The process of erection in woman is accompanied by the pouring out of +fluid which copiously bathes all parts of the vulva around the entrance to +the vagina. This is a bland, more or less odorless mucus which, under +ordinary circumstances, slowly and imperceptibly suffuses the parts. When, +however, the entrance to the vagina is exposed and extended, as during a +gynæcological examination which occasionally produces sexual excitement, +there may be seen a real ejaculation of the fluid which, as usually +described, comes largely from the glands of Bartholin, situated at the +mouth of the vagina. Under these circumstances it is sometimes described +as being emitted in a jet which is thrown to a distance.[101] This mucous +ejaculation was in former days regarded as analogous to the seminal +ejaculation in man, and hence essential to conception. Although this +belief was erroneous the fluid poured out in this manner whenever a high +degree of tumescence is attained, and before the onset of detumescence, +certainly performs an important function in lubricating the entrance to +the genital canal and so facilitating the intromission of the male +organ.[102] Menstruation has a similar influence in facilitating coitus, +as Schurig long since pointed out.[103] A like process takes place during +parturition when the same parts are being lubricated and stretched in +preparation for the protrusion of the foetal head. The occurrence of the +mucous flow in tumescence always indicates that that process is actively +affecting the central sexual organs, and that voluptuous emotions are +present.[104] + + The secretions of the genital canal and outlet in women are + somewhat numerous. We have the odoriferous glands of sebaceous + origin, and with them the prepuce of the clitoris which has been + described as a kind of gigantic sebaceous follicle with the + clitoris occupying its interior. (Hyrtl.) There is the secretion + from the glands of Bartholin. There is again the vaginal + secretion, opaque and albuminous, which appears to be alkaline + when secreted, but becomes acid under the decomposing influence + of bacteria, which are, however, harmless and not pathogenic. + (Gow, _Obstetrical Society of London_, January 3, 1894.) There + is, finally, the mucous uterine secretion, which is alkaline, + and, being poured out during orgasm, is believed to protect the + spermatozoa from destruction by the acid vaginal secretion. + + The belief that the mucus poured out in women during sexual + excitement is feminine semen and therefore essential to + conception had many remarkable consequences and was widespread + until the seventeenth century. Thus, in the chapter "De Modo + coeundi et de regimine eorum qui coeunt" of _De Secretis + Mulierum_, there is insistence on the importance of the proper + mixture of the male semen with the female semen and of arranging + that it shall not escape from the vagina. The woman must lie + quiet for several hours at least, not rising even to urinate, and + when she gets up, be very temperate in eating and drinking, and + not run or jump, pretending that she has a headache. It was the + belief in feminine semen which led some theologians to lay down + that a woman might masturbate if she had not experienced orgasm + in coitus. Schurig in his _Muliebria_ (1729, pp. 159, et seq.) + discusses the opinions of old authors regarding the nature, + source, and uses of the female genital secretions, and quotes + authorities against the old view that it was female semen. In a + subsequent work (_Syllepsilogia_, 1731, pp. 3, et seq.) he + returns to the same question, quotes authors who accept a + feminine semen, shows that Harvey denied it any significance, and + himself decides against it. It has not seriously been brought + forward since. + +When erection is completed in both the man and the woman the conditions +necessary for conjugation have at last been fulfilled. In all animals, +even those most nearly allied to man, coitus is effected by the male +approaching the female posteriorly. In man the normal method of male +approach is anteriorly, face to face. Leonardo da Vinci, in a well-known +drawing representing a sagittal section of a man and a woman connected in +this position of so-called Venus obversa; has shown how well adapted the +position is to the normal position of the organs in the human +species.[105] + + Among monkeys, it is stated, congress is sometimes performed when + the female is on all fours; at other times the male brings the + female between his thighs when he is sitting, holding her with + his forepaws. Froriep informed Lawrence that the male sometimes + supported his feet on the female's calves. (Sir W. Lawrence, + _Lectures on Physiology_, 1823, p. 186.) A summary of the methods + of congress practiced by the various animals below mammals will + be found in the article "Copulation" by H. de Varigny in Richet's + _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_, vol. iv. + + The anterior position in coitus, with the female partner lying + supine, is so widespread throughout the world that it may fairly + be termed the most typically human attitude in sexual congress. + It is found represented in Egyptian graves at Benihassan, + belonging to the Twelfth Dynasty; it is regarded by Mohammedans + as the normal position, although other positions are permitted by + the Prophet: "Your wives are your tillage: go in unto your + tillage in what manner soever you will;" it is that adopted in + Malacca; it appears, from Peruvian antiquities, to have been the + position generally, though not exclusively, adopted in ancient + Peru; it is found in many parts of Africa, and seems also to have + been the most usual position among the American aborigines. + + Various modifications of this position are, however, found. Thus, + in some parts of the world, as among the Suahelis in Zanzibar, + the male partner adopts the supine position. In Loango, according + to Pechuel-Loesche, coitus is performed lying on the side. + Sometimes, as on the west coast of Africa, the woman is supine + and the man more or less erect; or, as among the Queenslanders + (as described by Roth) the woman is supine and the man squats on + his heels with her thighs clasping his flanks, while he raises + her buttocks with his hands. + + The position of coitus in which the man is supine is without + doubt a natural and frequent variation of the specifically human + obverse method of coitus. It was evidently familiar to the + Romans. Ovid mentions it (_Ars Amatoria_, III, 777-8), + recommending it to little women, and saying that Andromache was + too tall to practice it with Hector. Aristophanes refers to it, + and there are Greek epigrams in which women boast of their skill + in riding their lovers. It has sometimes been viewed with a + certain disfavor because it seems to confer a superiority on the + woman. "Cursed be he," according to a Mohammedan saying, "who + maketh woman heaven and man earth." + + Of special interest is the wide prevalence of an attitude in + coitus recalling that which prevails among quadrupeds. The + frequency with which on the walls of Pompeii coitus is + represented with the woman bending forward and her partner + approaching her posteriorly has led to the belief that this + attitude was formerly very common in Southern Italy. However that + may be, it is certainly normal at the present day among various + more or less primitive peoples in whom the vulva is often placed + somewhat posteriorly. It is thus among the Soudanese, as also, in + an altogether different part of the world, among the Eskimo + Innuit and Koniags. The New Caledonians, according to Foley, + cohabit in the quadrupedal manner, and so also the Papuans of New + Guinea (Bongu), according to Vahness. The same custom is also + found in Australia, where, however other postures are also + adopted. In Europe the quadrupedal posture would seem to prevail + among some of the South Slavs, notably the Dalmatians. (The + different methods of coitus practiced by the South Slavs are + described in Kryptadia vol. vi, pp. 220, et seq.) + + This method of coitus was recommended by Lucretius (lib. iv) and + also advised by Paulus Æginetus as favorable to conception. (The + opinions of various early physicians are quoted by Schurig, + _Spermatologia_, 1720, pp. 232, et seq.). It seems to be a + position that is not infrequently agreeable to women, a fact + which may be brought into connection with the remarks of Adler + already quoted (p. 131) concerning the comparative lack of + adjustment of the feminine organs to the obverse position. It is + noteworthy that in the days of witchcraft hysterical women + constantly believed that they had had intercourse with the Devil + in this manner. This circumstance, indeed, probably aided in the + very marked disfavor in which coitus _a posteriori_ fell after + the decay of classic influences. The mediæval physicians + described it as _mos diabolicus_ and mistakenly supposed that it + produced abortion (Hyrtl, op. cit., vol. ii, p. 87). The + theologians, needless to say, were opposed to the _mos + diabolicus_, and already in the Anglo-Saxon Penitential of + Theodore, at the end of the seventh century, 40 days' penance is + prescribed for this method of coitus. + + From the frequency with which they have been adopted by various + peoples as national customs, most of the postures in coitus here + referred to must be said to come within the normal range of + variation. It is a mistake to regard them as vicious perversions. + +Up to the point to which we have so far considered it, the process of +detumescence has been mainly nervous and vascular in character; it has, in +fact, been but the more acute stage of a process which has been going on +throughout tumescence. But now we reach the point at which a new element +comes in: muscular action. With the onset of muscular action, which is +mainly involuntary, even when it affects the voluntary muscles, +detumescence proper begins to take place. Henceforward purposeful psychic +action, except by an effort, is virtually abolished. The individual, as a +separate person, tends to disappear. He has become one with another +person, as nearly one as the conditions of existence ever permit; he and +she are now merely an instrument in the hands of a higher power--by +whatever name we may choose to call that Power--which is using them for an +end not themselves. + +The decisive moment in the production of the instinctive and involuntary +orgasm occurs when, under the influence of the stimulus applied to the +penis by friction with the vagina, the tension of the seminal fluid poured +into the urethra arouses the ejaculatory center in the spinal cord and the +bulbo-cavernosus muscle surrounding the urethra responsively contracts in +rhythmic spasms. Then it is that ejaculation occurs.[106] + +"The circulation quickens, the arteries beat strongly," wrote Roubaud in a +description of the physical state during coitus which may almost be termed +classic; "the venous blood, arrested by muscular contraction, increases +the general heat, and this stagnation, more pronounced in the brain by the +contraction of the muscles of the neck and the throwing of the head +backward, causes a momentary cerebral congestion, during which +intelligence is lost and the faculties abolished. The eyes, violently +injected, become haggard, and the look uncertain, or, in the majority of +cases, the eyes are closed spasmodically to avoid the contact of the +light. The respiration is hurried, sometimes interrupted, and may be +suspended by the spasmodic contraction of the larynx, and the air, for a +time compressed, is at last emitted in broken and meaningless words. The +congested nervous centers only communicate confused sensations and +volitions; mobility and sensation show extreme disorder; the limbs are +seized by convulsions and sometimes by cramps, or are thrown wildly about +or become stiff like iron bars. The jaws, tightly pressed, grind the +teeth, and in some persons the delirium is carried so far that they bite +to bleeding the shoulders their companions have imprudently abandoned to +them. This frantic state of epilepsy lasts but a short time, but it +suffices to exhaust the forces of the organism, especially in man. It is, +I believe, Galen, who said: 'Omne animal post coitum triste præter +mulierem gallumque.'"[107] Most of the elements that make up this typical +picture of the state of coitus are not absolutely essential to that state, +but they all come within the normal range of variation. There can be no +doubt that this range is considerable. There would appear to be not only +individual, but also racial, differences; there is a remarkable passage in +Vatsyayana's _Kama Sutra_ describing the varying behavior of the women of +different races in India under the stress of sexual excitement--Dravidian +women with difficulty attaining erethism, women of the Punjaub fond of +being caressed with the tongue, women of Oude with impetuous desire and +profuse flow of mucus, etc.--and it is highly probable, Ploss and Bartels +remark, that these characterizations are founded on exact +observations.[108] + +The various phenomena included in Roubaud's description of the condition +during coitus may all be directly or indirectly reduced to two groups: the +first circulatory and respiratory, the second motor. It is necessary to +consider both these aspects of the process of detumescence in somewhat +greater detail, although while it is most convenient to discuss them +separately, it must be borne in mind that they are not really separable; +the circulatory phenomena are in large measure a by-product of the +involuntary motor process. + +With the approach of detumescence the respiration becomes shallow, rapid, +and to some extent arrested. This characteristic of the breathing during +sexual excitement is well recognized; so that in, for instance, the +_Arabian Nights_, it is commonly noted of women when gazing at beautiful +youths whose love they desired, that they ceased breathing.[109] It may be +added that exactly the same tendency to superficial and arrested +respiration takes place whenever there is any intense mental +concentration, as in severe intellectual work.[110] + +The arrest of respiration tends to render the blood venous, and thus aids +in stimulating the vasomotor centers, raising the blood-pressure in the +body generally, and especially in the erectile tissues. High +blood-pressure is one of the most marked features of the state of +detumescence. The heart beats are stronger and quicker, the surface +arteries are more visible, the conjunctivæ become red. The precise degree +of blood-pressure attained during coitus has been most accurately +ascertained in the dog. In Bechterew's laboratory in St. Petersburg a +manometer was introduced into the central end of the carotid artery of a +bitch; a male dog was then introduced, and during coitus observations were +made on the blood-pressure at the peripheral and central ends of the +artery. It was found that there was a great general elevation of +blood-pressure, intense hyperæmia of the brain, rapid alternations, during +the act, of vasoconstriction and vasodilatation of the brain, with +increase and diminution of the general arterial tension in relation with +the various phases of the act, the greatest cerebral vasodilatation and +hyperæmia coinciding with the moment following the intromission of the +penis; the end of the act is followed by a considerable fall in the +blood-pressure.[111] I am not acquainted with any precise observations on +the blood-pressure in human subjects during detumescence, and there are +obvious difficulties in the way of such observations. It is probable, +however, that the conditions found would be substantially the same. This +is indicated, so far as the very marked increase of blood-pressure is +concerned, by some observations made by Vaschide and Vurpas with the +sphygmanometer on a lady under the influence of sexual excitement. In this +case there was a relationship of sympathy and friendly tenderness between +the experimenter and the subject, Madame X, aged 25. Experimenter and +subject talked sympathetically, and finally, we are told, while the latter +still had her hands in the sphygmanometer, the former almost made a +declaration of love. Madame X was greatly impressed, and afterward +admitted that her emotions had been genuine and strong. The +blood-pressure, which was in this subject habitually 65 millimeters, rose +to 150 and even 160, indicating a very high pressure, which rarely occurs; +at the same time Madame X looked very emotional and troubled.[112] + + Some authorities are of opinion that irregularities in the + accomplishment of the sexual act are specially liable to cause + disturbances in the circulation. Thus Kisch, of Prague, refers to + the case of a couple practising coitus interruptus--the husband + withdrawing before ejaculation--in which the wife, a vigorous + woman, became liable after some years to attacks termed by Kisch + _neurasthenia cordis vasomotoria_, in which there was at daily or + longer intervals palpitation, with feelings of anxiety, headache, + dizziness, muscular weakness and tendency to faint. He regards + coitus as a cause of various heart troubles in women: (1) Attacks + of tachycardia in very excitable and sexually inclined women; (2) + attacks of tachycardia with dyspnoea in young women, with + vaginismus; (3) cardiac symptoms with lowered vascular tone in + women who for a long time have practised coitus interruptus + without complete sexual gratification (Kisch, "Herzbeschwerden + der Frauen verursacht durch den Cohabitationsact," _Münchener + Medizinisches Wochenschrift_, 1897, p. 617). In this connection, + also, reference may probably be made to those attacks of anxiety + which Freud associates with psychic sexual lesions of an + emotional character. + +Associated with this vascular activity in detumescence we find a general +tendency to glandular activity. Various secretions are formed abundantly. +Perspiration is copious, and the ancient relationship between the +cutaneous and sexual systems seems to evoke a general activity of the skin +and its odoriferous secretions. Salivation, which also occurs, is very +conspicuous in many lower animals, as for instance in the donkey, notably +the female, who just before coitus stands with mouth open, jaws moving, +and saliva dribbling. In men, corresponding to the more copious secretion +in women, there is, during the latter stages of tumescence, a slight +secretion of mucus--Fürbringer's _urethrorrhoea ex libidine_--which +appears in drops at the urethral orifice. It comes from the small glands +of Littré and Cowper which open into the urethra. This phenomenon was well +known to the old theologians, who called it _distillatio_, and realized +its significance as at once distinct from semen and an indication that the +mind was dwelling on voluptuous images; it was also known in classic +times[113]; more recently it has often been confused with semen and has +thus sometimes caused needless anxiety to nervous persons. There is also +an increased secretion of urine, and it is probable that if the viscera +were more accessible to observation we might be able to demonstrate that +the glands throughout the body share in this increased activity. + +The phenomena of detumescence culminate, however, and have their most +obvious manifestation in motor activity. The genital act, as Vaschide and +Vurpas remark, consists essentially in "a more and more marked tension of +the motor state which, reaching its maximum, presents a short tonic phase, +followed by a clonic phase, and terminates in a period of adynamia and +repose." This motor activity is of the essence of the impulse of +detumescence, because without it the sperm cells could not be brought into +the neighborhood of the germ cell and be propelled into the organic nest +which is assigned for their conjunction and incubation. + +The motor activity is general as well as specifically sexual. There is a +general tendency to more or less involuntary movement, without any +increase of voluntary muscular power, which is, indeed, decreased, and +Vaschide and Vurpas state that dynamometric results are somewhat lower +than normal during sexual excitement, and the variations greater.[114] The +tendency to diffused activity of involuntary muscle is well illustrated by +the contraction of the bladder associated with detumescence. While this +occurs in both sexes, in men erection produces a mechanical impediment to +any evacuation of the bladder. In women there is not only a desire to +urinate but, occasionally, actual urination. Many quite healthy and normal +women have, as a rare accident supervening on the coincidence of an +unusually full bladder with an unusual degree of sexual excitement, +experienced a powerful and quite involuntary evacuation of the bladder at +the moment of orgasm. In women with less normal nervous systems this has, +more rarely, been almost habitual. Brantôme has perhaps recorded the +earliest case of this kind in referring to a lady he knew who "quand on +lui faisait cela elle se compissait à bon escient."[115] The tendency to +trembling, constriction of throat, sneezing, emission of internal gas, and +the other similar phenomena occasionally associated with detumescence, are +likewise due to diffusion of the motor disturbance. Even in infancy the +motor signs of sexual excitement are the most obvious indications of +orgasm; thus West, describing masturbation in a child of six or nine +months who practiced thigh-rubbing, states that when sitting in her high +chair she would grasp the handles, stiffen herself, and stare, rubbing her +thighs quickly together several times, and then come to herself with a +sigh, tired, relaxed, and sweating, these seizures, which lasted one or +two minutes, being mistaken by the relations for epileptic fits.[116] + + The essentially motor character of detumescence is well shown by + the extreme forms of erotic intoxication which sometimes appear + as the result of sexual excitement. Féré, who has especially + called attention to the various manifestations of this condition, + presents an instructive case of a man of neurotic heredity and + antecedents, in whom it occasionally happened that sexual + excitement, instead of culminating in the normal orgasm, attained + its climax in a fit of uncontrollable muscular excitement. He + would then sing, dance, gesticulate, roughly treat his partner, + break the objects around him, and finally sink down exhausted and + stupefied. (Féré, _L'Instinct Sexuel_, Chapter X.) In such a case + a diffused and general detumescence has taken the place of the + normal detumescence which has its main focus in the sexual + sphere. + + The same relationship is shown in a case of impotence accompanied + by cramps in the calves and elsewhere, which has been recorded by + Brügelmann ("Zur Lehre vom Perversen Sexualismus," _Zeitschrift + für Hypnotismus_, 1900, Heft I). These muscular conditions ceased + for several days whenever coitus was effected. + + An instructive analogy to the motor irradiations preceding the + moment of sexual detumescence may be found in the somewhat + similar motor irradiations which follow the delayed expulsion of + a highly distended bladder. These sometimes become very marked in + a child or young woman unable to control the motor system + absolutely. The legs are crossed, the foot swung, the thighs + tightly pressed together, the toes curled. The fingers are flexed + in rhythmic succession. The whole body slowly twists as though + the seat had become uncomfortable. It is difficult to concentrate + the mind; the same remark may be automatically repeated; the eyes + search restlessly, and there is a tendency to count surrounding + objects or patterns. When the extreme degree of tension is + reached it is only by executing a kind of dance that the + explosive contraction of the bladder is restrained. + + The picture of muscular irradiation presented under these + circumstances differs but slightly from that of the onset of + detumescence. In one case the explosion is sought, in the other + case it is dreaded; but in both cases there is a retarded + muscular tension,--in the one case involuntary, in the other case + voluntary--maintained at a point of acute intensity, and in both + cases the muscular irradiations of this tension spread over the + whole body. + + The increased motor irritability of the state of detumescence + somewhat resembles the conditions produced by a weak anæsthetic + and there is some interest in noting the sexual excitement liable + to occur in anæsthesia. I am indebted to Dr. J.F.W. Silk for some + remarks on this point:-- + + "I. Sexual emotions may apparently be aroused during the stage of + excitement preceding or following the administration of any + anæsthetic; these emotions may take the form of mere delirious + utterances, or may be associated with what is apparently a sexual + orgasm. Or reflex phenomena connected with the sexual organs may + occasionally be observed under special circumstances; or, to put + it in another way, such reflex possibilities are not always + abolished by the condition of narcosis or anæsthesia. + + "II. Of the particular anæsthetics employed I am inclined to + think that the possibility of such conditions arising is + inversely proportionate to their strength, e.g., they are more + frequently observed with a weak anæsthetic like nitrous oxide + than with chloroform. + + "III. Sexual emotions I believe to be rarely observable in men, + and this is remarkable, or, I should say, particularly + noticeable, for the presence of nurses, female students, etc., + might almost have led one to expect that the contrary would have + been the case. On the other hand, it is among men that I have + frequently observed a reflex phenomenon which has usually taken + the shape of an erection of the penis when the structures in the + neighborhood of the spermatic cord have been handled. + + "IV. Among females the emotional sexual phenomena most frequently + obtrude themselves, and I believe that if it were possible to + induce people to relate their dreams they would very often be + found to be of a sexual character." + +Much more important than the general motor phenomena, more purposive +though involuntary, are the specifically sexual muscular movements. From +the very beginning of detumescence, indeed, muscular activity makes itself +felt, and the peripheral muscles of sex act, according to Kobelt's +expression, as a peripheral sexual heart. In the male these movements are +fairly obvious and fairly simple. It is required that the semen should be +expressed from the vesiculæ seminales, propelled along the urethra, in +combination with the prostatic fluid which is equally essential, and +finally ejected with a certain amount of force from the urethral orifice. +Under the influence of the stimulation furnished by the contact and +friction of the vagina, this process is effectively carried out, mainly by +the rhythmic contractions of the bulbo-cavernosus muscle, and the semen is +emitted in a jet which may be ejaculated to a distance varying from a few +centimeters to a meter or more. + + With regard to the details of the psychic sides of this process a + correspondent, a psychologist, writes as follows:-- + + "I have never noticed in my reading any attempt to analyze the + sensations which accompany the orgasm, and, as I have made a good + many attempts to make such an analysis myself, I will append the + results on the chance that they may be of some value. I have + checked my results so far as possible by comparing them with the + experience of such of my friends as had coitus frequently and + were willing to tell me as much as they could of the psychology + of the process. + + "The first fact that I hit upon was the importance of pressure. + As one of my informants picturesquely phrases it--'the tighter + the fit the greater the pleasure.' This agrees, too, with their + unanimous testimony that the pleasurable sensations were much + greater when the orgasm occurred simultaneously in the man and + woman. Their analysis seldom went further than this, but a few + remarked that the distinctive sensations accompanying the orgasm + seem to begin near the root of the penis or in the testes, and + that they are qualitatively different from the tickling + sensations which precede them. + + "These tickling sensations are caused, I think, by the friction + of the glands against the vaginal walls, and are supplemented by + other sensations from the urethra, whose nerves are stimulated by + pressure of the vaginal walls and sphincter. The specific + sensation of the orgasm begins, I believe, with a strong + contraction of the muscles of the urethral walls along the entire + length of the canal, and is felt as a peculiar ache starting + from the base of the penis and quickly becoming diffused through + the whole organ. This sensation reaches its climax with the + expulsion of the semen into the urethra and the consequent + feeling of distention, which is instantly followed by the + rhythmic peristaltic contractions of the urethral muscles which + mark the climax of the orgasm. + + "The most careful introspection possible under the circumstances + seems to show that these sensations arise almost wholly from the + urethra and in a far less degree from the corona. During periods + of great sexual excitement the nerves of the urethra and corona + seem to possess a peculiar sensitivity and are powerfully + stimulated by the violent peristaltic contractions of the muscles + in the urethral walls during ejaculation. It seems possible that + the intensity and volume of sensation felt at the glans may be + due in part to the greater area of sensitive surface presented in + the fossa as well as to the sensitivity of the corona, and in + part to the fact that during the orgasm the glans is more highly + congested than at any other time, and the nerve endings thus + subjected to additional pressure. + + "If the foregoing statements are true, it is easy to see why the + pleasure of the man is much increased when the orgasm occurs at + the same time in his partner and himself, for the contractions of + the vagina upon the penis would increase the stimulation of all + the nerve endings in that organ for which a mechanical stimulus + is adequate, and the prominence of the corpus spongiosum and + corona would ensure them the greatest stimulation. It seems not + improbable that the specific sensation of orgasm rises from the + stimulation of the peculiar form of nerve end-bulbs which Krause + found in the corpus spongiosum and in the glans. + + "The characteristic massiveness of the experience is probably due + largely to the great number of sensations of strain and pressure + caused by the powerful reflex contraction of so many of the + voluntary muscles. + + "Of course, the foregoing analysis is purely tentative, and I + offer it only on the chance that it may suggest some line of + inquiry which may lead to results of value to the student of + sexual psychology." + + In man the whole process of detumescence, when it has once really + begun, only occupies a few moments. It is so likewise in many + animals; in the genera Bos, Ovis, etc., it is very short, almost + instantaneous, and rather short also in the Equidæ (in a vigorous + stallion, according to Colin, ten to twelve seconds). As + Disselhorst has pointed out, this is dependent on the fact that + these animals, like man, possess a vas deferens which broadens + into an ampulla serving as a receptacle which holds the semen + ready for instant emission when required. On the other hand, in + the dog, cat, boar, and the Canidæ, Felidæ, and Suidæ generally, + there is no receptacle of this kind, and coitus is slow, since a + longer time is required for the peristaltic action of the vas to + bring the semen to the urogenital sinus. (R. Disselhorst, _Die + Accessorischen Geschlechtsdrusen der Wirbelthiere_, 1897, p. + 212.) + + In man there can be little doubt that detumescence is more + rapidly accomplished in the European than in the East, in India, + among the yellow races, or in Polynesia. This is probably in part + due to a deliberate attempt to prolong the act in the East, and + in part to a greater nervous erethism among Westerns. + +In the woman the specifically sexual muscular process is less visible, +more obscure, more complex, and uncertain. Before detumescence actually +begins there are at intervals involuntary rhythmic contractions of the +walls of the vagina, seeming to have the object of at once stimulating and +harmonizing with those that are about to begin in the male organ. It would +appear that these rhythmic contractions are the exaggeration of a +phenomenon which is normal, just as slight contraction is normal and +constant in the bladder. Jastreboff has shown, in the rabbit, that the +vagina is in constant spontaneous rhythmic contraction from above +downward, not peristaltic, but in segments, the intensity of the +contractions increasing with age and especially with sexual development. +This vaginal contraction which in women only becomes well marked just +before detumescence, and is due mainly to the action of the sphincter +cunni (analogous to the bulbo-cavernosus in the male), is only a part of +the localized muscular process. At first there would appear to be a reflex +peristaltic movement of the Fallopian tubes and uterus. Dembo observed +that in animals stimulation of the upper anterior wall of the vagina +caused gradual contraction of the uterus, which is erected by powerful +contraction of its muscular fiber and round ligaments while at the same +time it descends toward the vagina, its cavity becoming more and more +diminished and mucus being forced out. In relaxing, Aristotle long ago +remarked, it aspirates the seminal fluid. + +Although the active participation of the sexual organs in woman, to the +end of directing the semen into the womb at the moment of detumescence, is +thus a very ancient belief, and harmonizes with the Greek view of the womb +as an animal in the body endowed with a considerable amount of +activity,[117] precise observation in modern times has offered but little +confirmation of the reality of this participation. Such observations as +have been made have usually been the accidental result of sexual +excitement and orgasm occurring during a gynæcological examination. As, +however, such a result is liable to occur in erotic subjects, a certain +number of precise observations have accumulated during the past century. +So far as the evidence goes, it would seem that in women, as in mares, +bitches, and other animals, the uterus becomes shorter, broader, and +softer during the orgasm, at the same time descending lower into the +pelvis, with its mouth open intermittently, so that, as one writer +remarks, spontaneously recurring to the simile which commended itself to +the Greeks, "the uterus might be likened to an animal gasping for +breath."[118] This sensitive, responsive mobility of the uterus is, +indeed, not confined to the moment of detumescence, but may occur at other +times under the influence of sexual emotion. + +It would seem probable that in this erection, contraction, and descent of +the uterus, and its simultaneous expulsion of mucus, we have the decisive +moment in the completion of detumescence in woman, and it is probable that +the thick mucus, unlike the earlier more limpid secretion, which women are +sometimes aware of after orgasm, is emitted from the womb at this time. +This is, however, not absolutely certain. Some authorities regard +detumescence in women as accomplished in the pouring out of secretions, +others in the rhythmic genital contractions; the sexual parts may, +however, be copiously bathed in mucus for an indefinitely long period +before the final stage of detumescence is achieved, and the rhythmic +contractions are also taking place at a somewhat early period; in neither +respect is there any obvious increase at the final moment of orgasm. In +women this would seem to be more conspicuously a nervous manifestation +than in men. On the subjective side it is very pronounced, with its +feeling of relieved tension and agreeable repose--a moment when, as one +woman expresses it, together with intense pleasure, there is, as it were, +a floating up into a higher sphere, like the beginning of chloroform +narcosis--but on the objective side this culminating moment is less easy +to define. + + Various observations and remarks made during the past two or + three centuries by Bond, Valisneri, Dionis, Haller, Günther, and + Bischoff, tending to show a sucking action of the uterus in both + women and other female animals, have been brought together by + Litzmann in R. Wagner's _Handwörterbuch der Physiologie_ (1846, + vol. iii, p. 53). Litzmann added an experience of his own: "I had + an opportunity lately, while examining a young and very erethic + woman, to observe how suddenly the uterus assumed a more erect + position, and descended deeper in the pelvis; the lips of the + womb became equal in length, the cervix rounded, softer, and more + easily reached by the finger, and at the same time a high state + of sexual excitement was revealed by the respiration and voice." + + The general belief still remained, however, that the woman's part + in conjugation is passive, and that it is entirely by the energy + of the male organ and of the male sexual elements, the + spermatozoa, that conjunction with the germ cell is attained. + According to this theory, it was believed that the spermatozoa + were, as Wilkinson expresses it, in a history of opinion on this + question, "endowed with some sort of intuition or instinct; that + they would turn in the direction of the os uteri, wading through + the acid mucus of the vagina; travel patiently upward and around + the vaginal portion of the uterus; enter the uterus and proceed + onward in search of the waiting ovum." (A.D. Wilkinson, + "Sterility in the Female," _Transactions of the Lincoln Medical + Society_, Nebraska, 1896.) + + About the year 1859 Fichstedt seems to have done something to + overthrow this theory by declaring his belief that the uterus was + not, as commonly supposed, a passive organ in coitus, but was + capable of sucking in the semen during the brief period of + detumescence. Various authorities then began to bring forward + arguments and observations in the same sense. Wernich, + especially, directed attention to this point in 1872 in a paper + on the erectile properties of the lower segment of the uterus + ("Die Erectionsfahigkeit des untern Uterus-Abschnitts," _Beiträge + zur Geburtshülfe und Gynäkologie_, vol. i, p. 296). He made + precise observations and came to the conclusion that owing to + erectile properties in the neck of the uterus, this part of the + womb elongates during congress and reaches down into the pelvis + with an aspiratory movement, as if to meet the glans of the male. + A little later, in a case of partial prolapse, Beck, in ignorance + of Wernich's theory, was enabled to make a very precise + observation of the action of the uterus during excitement. In + this case the woman was sexually very excitable even under + ordinary examination, and Beck carefully noted the phenomena that + took place during the orgasm. "The os and cervix uteri," he + states, "had been about as firm as usual, moderately hard and, + generally speaking, in a natural and normal condition, with the + external os closed to such an extent as to admit of the uterine + probe with difficulty; but the instant that the height of + excitement was at hand, the os opened itself to the extent of + fully an inch, as nearly as my eye can judge, made five or six + successive gasps as if it were drawing the external os into the + cervix, each time powerfully, and, it seemed to me, with a + regular rhythmical action, at the same time losing its former + density and hardness and becoming quite soft to the touch. Upon + the cessation of the action, as related, the os suddenly closed, + the cervix again hardened itself, and the intense congestion was + dissipated." (J.R. Beck, "How do the Spermatozoa Enter the + Uterus?" _American Journal of Obstetrics_, 1874.) It would appear + that in the early part of this final process of detumescence the + action of the uterus is mainly one of contraction and ejaculation + of any mucus that may be contained; Dr. Paul Mundé has described + "the gushing, almost in jets," of this mucus which he has + observed in an erotic woman under a rather long digital and + specular examination. (_American Journal of Obstetrics_, 1893.) + It is during the latter part of detumescence, it would seem, and + perhaps for a short time after the orgasm is over, that the + action of the uterus is mainly aspiratory. + +While the active part played by the womb in detumescence can no longer be +questioned, it need not too hastily be assumed that the belief in the +active movements of the spermatozoa must therefore be denied. The vigorous +motility of the tadpole-like organisms is obvious to anyone who has ever +seen fresh semen under the microscope; and if it is correct, as Clifton +Edgar states, that the spermatozoa may retain their full activity in the +female organs for at least seventeen days, they have ample time to exert +their energies. The fact that impregnation sometimes occurs without +rupture of the hymen is not decisive evidence that there has been no +penetration, as the hymen may dilate without rupturing; but there seems no +reason to doubt that conception has sometimes taken place when ejaculation +has occurred without penetration; this is indicated in a fairly objective +manner when, as has been occasionally observed, conception has occurred in +women whose vaginas were so narrow as scarcely to admit the entrance of a +goose-quill; such was the condition in the case of a pregnant woman +brought forward by Roubaud. The stories, repeated in various books, of +women who have conceived after homosexual relations with partners who had +just left their husbands' beds are not therefore inherently +impossible.[119] Janke quotes numerous cases in which there has been +impregnation in virgins who have merely allowed the penis to be placed in +contact with the vulva, the hymen remaining unruptured until +delivery.[120] + +It must be added, however, that even if the semen is effused merely at the +mouth of the vagina, without actual penetration, the spermatozoa are still +not entirely without any resource save their own motility in the task of +reaching the ovum. As we have seen, it is not only the uterus which takes +an active part in detumescence; the vagina also is in active movement, and +it seems highly probable that, at all events in some women and under some +circumstances, such movement favoring aspiration toward the womb may be +communicated to the external mouth of the vagina. + + Riolan (_Anthropographia_, 1626, p. 294) referred to the + constriction and dilation of the vulva under the influence of + sexual excitement. It is said that in Abyssinia women can, when + adopting the straddling posture of coitus, by the movements of + their own vaginal muscles alone, grasp the male organ and cause + ejaculation, although the man remains passive. According to + Lorion the Annamites, adopting the normal posture of coitus, + introduce the penis when flaccid or only half erect, the + contraction of the vaginal walls completing the process; the + penis is very small in this people. It is recognized by + gynæcologists that the condition of vaginismus, in which there is + spasmodic contraction of the vagina, making intercourse painful + or impossible, is but a morbid exaggeration of the normal + contraction which occurs in sexual excitement. Even in the + absence of sexual excitement there is a vague affection, + occurring in both married and unmarried women, and not, it would + seem, necessarily hysterical, characterized by quivering or + twitching of the vulva; I am told that this is popularly termed + "flackering of the shape" in Yorkshire and "taittering of the + lips" in Ireland. It may be added that quivering of the gluteal + muscles also takes place during detumescence, and that in Indian + medicine this is likewise regarded as a sign of sexual desire in + women, apart from coitus. + + A non-medical correspondent in Australia, W.J. Chidley, from whom + I have received many communications on this subject, is strongly + of opinion from his own observations that not only does the + uterus take an active part in coitus, but that under natural + conditions the vagina also plays an active part in the process. + He was led to suspect such an action many years ago, as well by + an experience of his own, as also by hearing from a young woman + who met her lover after a long absence that by the excitement + thus aroused a tape attached to the underclothes had been drawn + into the vagina. Since then the confidences of various friends, + together with observations of animals, have confirmed him in the + view that the general belief that coitus must be effected by + forcible entry of the male organ into a passive vagina is + incorrect. He considers that under normal circumstances coitus + should take place but rarely, and then only under the most + favorable circumstances, perhaps exclusively in spring, and, most + especially, only when the woman is ready for it. Then, when in + the arms of the man she loves, the vagina, in sympathy with the + active movements of the womb, becomes distended at the touch of + the turgescent, but not fully erect, penis, "flashes open and + draws in the male organ." "All animals," he adds, "have sexual + intercourse by the male organ being _drawn_, not forced, into the + female. I have been borne out in this by friends who have seen + horses, camels, mules and other large animals in the coupling + season. What is more absurd, for instance, than to say that an + entire _penetrates_ the mare? His penis is a sensitive, beautiful + piece of mechanism, which brings its light head here and there + till it touches the right spot, when the mare, _if ready_, takes + it in. An entire's penis could not penetrate anything; it is a + curve, a beautiful curve which would easily bend. A bull's, + again, is turned down at the end and, more palpably still, would + fold on itself if pressed with force. The womb and vagina of a + beautiful and healthy woman constitute a living, vital, moving + organ, sensitive to a look, a word, a thought, a hand on the + waist." + + A well-known American author thus writes in confirmation of the + foregoing view: "In nature the woman wooes. When impassioned her + vagina becomes erect and dilated, and so lubricated with abundant + mucus to the lips that entrance is easy. This dilatation and + erectile expansion of vagina withdraws the hymen so close to the + walls that penetration need not tear it or cause pain. The more + muscular, primitive and healthy the woman the tougher and less + sensitive the hymen, and the less likely to break or bleed. I + think one great function of the foreskin also is to moisten the + glans, so that it can be lubricated for entrance, and then to + retract, moist side out, to make entrance still easier. I think + that in nature the glans penetrates within the labia, is + withstood a moment, vibrating, and then all resistance is + withdrawn by a sudden 'flashing open' of the gates, permitting + easy entrance, and that the sudden giving up of resistance, and + substitution of welcome, with its instantaneous deep entrance, + causes an almost immediate male orgasm (the thrill being + irresistibly exciting). Certainly this is the process as observed + in horses, cattle, goats, etc., and it seems likely something + analogous is natural in man." + + While it is easily possible to carry to excess a view which would + make the woman rather than the man the active agent in coitus + (and it may be recalled that in the Cebidæ the penis, as also the + clitoris, is furnished with a bone), there is probably an element + of truth in the belief that the vagina shares in the active part + which, there can now be little doubt, is played by the uterus in + detumescence. Such a view certainly enables us to understand how + it is that semen effused on the exterior sexual organs can be + conveyed to the uterus. + + It was indeed the failure to understand the vital activity of the + semen and the feminine genital canal, co-operating together + towards the junction of sperm cell and germ cell, which for so + long stood in the way of the proper understanding of conception. + Even the genius of Harvey, which had grappled successfully with + the problem of the circulation, failed in the attempt to + comprehend the problem of generation. Mainly on account of this + difficulty, he was unable to see how the male element could + possibly enter the uterus, although he devoted much observation + and study to the question. Writing of the uterus of the doe after + copulation, he says: "I began to doubt, to ask myself whether the + semen of the male could by any possibility make its way by + attraction or injection to the seat of conception, and repeated + examination led me to the conclusion that none of the semen + reached this seat." (_De-Generatione Animalium_, Exercise lxvii.) + "The woman," he finally concluded, "after contact with the + spermatic fluid _in coitu_, seems to receive an influence and + become fecundated without the co-operation of any sensible + corporeal agent, in the same way as iron touched by the magnet is + endowed with its powers." + +Although the specifically sexual muscular process of detumescence in +women--as distinguished from the general muscular phenomena of sexual +excitement which may be fairly obvious--is thus seen to be somewhat +complex and obscure, in women as well as in men detumescence is a +convulsion which discharges a slowly accumulated store of nervous force. +In women also, as in men, the motor discharge is directed to a specific +end--the intromission of the semen in the one sex, its reception in the +other. In both sexes the sexual orgasm and the pleasure and satisfaction +associated with it, involve, as their most essential element, the motor +activity of the sexual sphere.[121] + + The active co-operation of the female organs in detumescence is + probably indicated by the difficulty which is experienced in + achieving conception by the artificial injection of semen. Marion + Sims stated in 1866, in _Clinical Notes on Uterine Surgery_, that + in 55 injections in six women he had only once been successful; + he believed that that was the only case at that time on record. + Jacobi had, however, practiced artificial fecundation in animals + (in 1700) and John Hunter in man. See Gould and Pyle, _Anomalies + and Curiosities of Medicine_, p. 43; also Janke (_Die + Willkürliche Hervorbringen des Geschlechts_, pp. 230 et seq.) who + discusses the question of artificial fecundation and brings + together a mass of data. + +The facial expression when tumescence is completed is marked by a high +degree of energy in men and of loveliness in women. At this moment, when +the culminating act of life is about to be accomplished, the individual +thus reaches his supreme state of radiant beauty. The color is heightened, +the eyes are larger and brighter, the facial muscles are more tense, so +that in mature individuals any wrinkles disappear and youthfulness +returns. + +At the beginning of detumescence the features are frequently more +discomposed. There is a general expression of eager receptivity to sensory +impressions. The dilatation of the pupils, the expansion of the nostrils, +the tendency to salivation and to movements of the tongue, all go to make +up a picture which indicates an approaching gratification of sensory +desires; it is significant that in some animals there is at this moment +erection of the ears.[122] There is sometimes a tendency to utter broken +and meaningless words, and it is noted that sometimes women have called +out on their mothers.[123] The dilatation of the pupils produces +photophobia, and in the course of detumescence the eyes are frequently +closed from this cause. At the beginning of sexual excitement, Vaschide +and Vurpas have observed, tonicity of the eye-muscles seems to increase; +the elevators of the upper lids contract, so that the eyes look larger and +their mobility and brightness are heightened; with the increase of +muscular tonicity strabismus occurs, owing to the greater strength of the +muscles that carry the eyes inward.[124] + + The facial expression which marks the culmination of tumescence, + and the approach of detumescence is that which is generally + expressive of joy. In an interesting psycho-physical study of the + emotion of joy, Dearborn thus summarizes its characteristics: + "The eyes are brighter and the upper eyelid elevated, as also are + the brows, the skin over the glabella, the upper lip and the + corners of the mouth, while the skin at the outer canthi of the + eye is puckered. The nostrils are moderately dilated, the tongue + slightly extended and the cheeks somewhat expanded, while in + persons with largely developed pinnal muscles the ears tend + somewhat to incline forwards. The whole arterial system is + dilated, with consequent blushing from this effect on the dermal + capillaries of the face, neck, scalp and hands, and sometimes + more extensively even; from the same cause the eyes slightly + bulge. The whole glandular system likewise is stimulated, causing + the secretions,--gastric, salivary, lachrymal, sudoral, mammary, + genital, etc.--to be increased, with the resulting rise of + temperature and increase in the katobolism generally. Volubility + is almost regularly increased, and is, indeed, one of the most + sensitive and constant of the correlations in emotional + delight.... Pleasantness is correlated in living organisms by + vascular, muscular and glandular extension or expansion, both + literal and figurative." (G. Dearborn, "The Emotion of Joy," + _Psychological Review Monograph Supplements_, vol. ii, No. 5, p. + 62.) All these signs of joy appear to occur at some stage of the + process of sexual excitement. + + In some monkeys it would seem that the muscular movement which in + man has become the smile is the characteristic facial expression + of sexual tumescence or courtship. Discussing the facial + expression of pleasure in children, S.S. Buckman has the + following remarks: "There is one point in such expression which + has not received due consideration, namely, the raising of lumps + of flesh each side of the nose as an indication of pleasure. + Accompanying this may be seen small furrows, both in children and + adults, running from the eyes somewhat obliquely towards the + nose. What these characters indicate may be learned from the male + mandril, whose face, particularly in the breeding season, shows + colored fleshy prominences each side of the nose, with + conspicuous furrows and ridges. In the male mandril these + characters have been developed because, being an unmistakable + sign of sexual ardor, they gave the female particular evidence of + sexual feelings. Thus such characters would come to be recognized + as habitually symptomatic of pleasurable feelings. Finding + similar features in human beings, and particularly in children, + though not developed in the same degree, we may assume that in + our monkey-like ancestors facial characters similar to those of + the mandril were developed, though to a less extent, and that + they were symptomatic of pleasure, because connected with the + period of courtship. Then they became conventionalized as + pleasurable symptoms." (S.S. Buckmann, "Human Babies: What They + Teach," _Nature_, July 5, 1900.) If this view is accepted, it may + be said that the smile, having in man become a generalized sign + of amiability, has no longer any special sexual significance. It + is true that a faint and involuntary smile is often associated + with the later stages of tumescence, but this is usually lost + during detumescence, and may even give place to an expression of + ferocity. + +When we have realized how profound is the organic convulsion involved by +the process of detumescence, and how great the general motor excitement +involved, we can understand how it is that very serious effects may follow +coitus. Even in animals this is sometimes the case. Young bulls and +stallions have fallen in a faint after the first congress; boars may be +seriously affected in a similar way; mares have been known even to fall +dead.[125] In the human species, and especially in men--probably, as Bryan +Robinson remarks, because women are protected by the greater slowness with +which detumescence occurs in them--not only death itself, but innumerable +disorders and accidents have been known to follow immediately after +coitus, these results being mainly due to the vascular and muscular +excitement involved by the processes of detumescence. Fainting, vomiting, +urination, defæcation have been noted as occurring in young men after a +first coitus. Epilepsy has been not infrequently recorded. Lesions of +various organs, even rupture of the spleen, have sometimes taken place. In +men of mature age the arteries have at times been unable to resist the +high blood-pressure, and cerebral hæmorrhage with paralysis has occurred. +In elderly men the excitement of intercourse with strange women has +sometimes caused death, and various cases are known of eminent persons who +have thus died in the arms of young wives or of prostitutes.[126] + +These morbid results, are, however, very exceptional. They usually occur +in persons who are abnormally sensitive, or who have imprudently +transgressed the obvious rules of sexual hygiene. Detumescence is so +profoundly natural a process; it is so deeply and intimately a function of +the organism, that it is frequently harmless even when the bodily +condition is far from absolutely sound. Its usual results, under favorable +circumstances, are entirely beneficial. In men there normally supervenes, +together with the relief from the prolonged tension of tumescence, with +the muscular repose and falling blood-pressure,[127] a sense of profound +satisfaction, a glow of diffused well-being,[128] perhaps an agreeable +lassitude, occasionally also a sense of mental liberation from an +overmastering obsession. Under reasonably happy circumstances there is no +pain, or exhaustion, or sadness, or emotional revulsion. The happy lover's +attitude toward his partner is not expressed by the well-known Sonnet +(CXXIX) of Shakespeare:-- + + "Past reason hunted, and no sooner had + Past reason hated." + +He feels rather with Boccaccio that the kissed mouth loses not its charm, + + "Bocca baciata non perde ventura." + +In women the results of detumescence are the same, except that the +tendency to lassitude is not marked unless the act has been several times +repeated; there is a sensation of repose and self-assurance, and often an +accession of free and joyous energy. After completely satisfactory +detumescence she may experience a feeling as of intoxication, lasting for +several hours, an intoxication that is followed by no evil reaction. + +Such, so far as our present vague and imperfect knowledge extends, are the +main features in the process of detumescence. In the future, without +doubt, we shall learn to know more precisely a process which has been so +supremely important in the life of man and of his ancestors. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[98] The elements furnished by the sense of touch in sexual selection have +been discussed in the first section of the previous volume of these +_Studies_. + +[99] See Appendix A. "The Origins of the Kiss," in the previous volume. + +[100] See, e.g., Art. "Erection," by Retterer, in Richet's _Dictionnaire +de Physiologie_, vol. v. + +[101] Guibaut, _Traité Clinique des Maladies des Femmes_, p. 242. Adler +discusses the sexual secretions in women and their significance, _Die +Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, pp. 19-26. + +[102] In some parts of the world this is further aided by artificial +means. Thus it is stated by Riedel (as quoted by Ploss and Bartels) that +in the Gorong Archipelago the bridegroom, before the first coitus, anoints +the bride's pudenda with an ointment containing opium, musk, etc. I have +been told of an English bride who was instructed by her mother to use a +candle for the same purpose. + +[103] _Parthenologia_, pp. 302, et seq. + +[104] The connection of this mucous flow with sexual emotion was discussed +early in the eighteenth century by Schurig in his _Gynæcologia_, pp. 8-11; +it is frequently passed over by more modern writers. + +[105] The drawing is reproduced by Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, +Chapter XVII; many facts bearing on the ethnography of coitus are brought +together in this chapter. + +[106] Onanoff (Paris Société de Biologie, May 3, 1890) proposed the name +of bulbo-cavernous reflex for the smart contraction of the ischio-and +bulbo-cavernosus muscles (erector penis and accelerator urinæ) produced by +mechanical excitation of the glans. This reflex is clinically elicited by +placing the index-finger of the left hand on the region of the bulb while +the right hand rapidly rubs the dorsal surface of the glands with the edge +of a piece of paper or lightly pinches the mucous membrane; a twitching of +the region of the bulb is then perceived. This reflex is always present in +healthy adult subjects and indicates the integrity of the physical +mechanism of detumescence. It has been described by Hughes. (C.H. Hughes, +"The Virile or Bulbo-cavernous Reflex," _Alienist and Neurologist_, +January, 1898.) + +[107] Roubaud, _Traité de l'Impuissance_, 1855, p. 39. + +[108] _Das Weib_, seventh edition, vol. i, p. 510. + +[109] The influence of impeded respiration in exciting more or less +perverted forms of sexual gratification has been discussed in a section of +"Love and Pain" in the third volume of these _Studies_. + +[110] See, e.g., the experiments of Obici on this point, _Revista +Sperimentale di Freniatria_, 1903, pp. 689, et seq. + +[111] Summarized in _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, March, 1903, p. +188. The tendency to closure of the eyes noted by Roubaud, to avoid +contact of the light, indicates dilatation of the pupils, for which we +need not seek other explanation than the general tendency of all +peripheral stimulation, according to Schiff's law, to produce such +dilatation. + +[112] Vaschide and Vurpas, "Du Coefficient Sexuel de l'Impulsion +Musicale," _Archives de Neurologie_, May, 1904. + +[113] In the _Priapeia_ is an inscription which has thus been +translated:-- + + "You see this organ, after which I'm called + And which is my certificate, is humid; + This moisture is not dew nor drops of rain, + It is the outcome of sweet memory, + Recalling thoughts of a complacent maid." + +The translator supposes that semen is referred to, but without doubt the +allusion is to the theologians' _distillatio_. + +[114] A woman of 30, normal and intelligent, after conversing on love and +passion, and then listening to the music of Grieg and Schumann, felt real +and strong sexual excitement, increased by memories recalled by the +presence of a sympathetic person. When then tested by the dynamometer the +average of ten efforts with the right hand was found to be 28.2 (her +normal average being 31.1) and with the left hand 28.0 (the normal being +30.0). There was, however, great variability in the individual pressures +which sometimes equaled and even exceeded the subject's normal efforts. +The voluntary muscles are thus in harmony with the approaching general +sexual avalanche. (Vaschide and Vurpas, "Quelques Données Expérimentales +sur l'Influence de l'Excitation Sexuelle," _Archivio di Psichiatria_, +1903, fasc. v-vi.) + +[115] Cf. MacGillicuddy, _Functional Disorders of the Nervous System in +Women_, p. 110; Féré, _L'Instinct Sexuel_, second edition, p. 238; id., +"Note sur une Anomalie de l'instinct Sexuel," _Belgique Médicale_, 1905; +also "Analysis of the Sexual Impulse," in an earlier volume of these +_Studies_. + +[116] J.P. West, "Masturbation in Early Childhood," _Medical Standard_, +November, 1895. + +[117] Cf. the discussion of hysteria in "Auto-Erotism," vol. i of these +_Studies_. + +[118] Hirst, _Text-Book of Obstetrics_, 1899, p. 67. + +[119] The earliest story of the kind with which I am acquainted, that of a +widow who was thus impregnated by a married friend, is quoted in Schurig's +_Spermatologia_ (p. 224) from Amatus Lusitanus, _Curationum Centuriæ +Septum_, 1629. + +[120] Janke, _Die Willkürliche Hervorbringen des Geschlechts_, p. 238. + +[121] Cf. Adler, _Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, pp. +29-38. + +[122] Féré, _Pathologie des Emotions_, p. 51. + +[123] This is an instinctive impulse under all strong emotion in primitive +persons. "The Australian Dieri," says A.W. Howitt (_Journal +Anthropological Institute_, August, 1890), "when in pain or grief cry out +for their father or mother." + +[124] Vaschide and Vurpas, _Archives de Neurologie_, May, 1904. + +[125] F.B. Robinson, _New York Medical Journal_, March 11, 1893. + +[126] Féré deals fully with the various morbid results which may follow +coitus, _L' Instinct Sexuel_, Chapter X; id., _Pathologie des Emotions_, +p. 99. + +[127] With regard to the relationship of detumescence to the +blood-pressure Haig remarks: "I think that as the sexual act produces low +and falling blood-pressure, it will of necessity relieve conditions which +are due to high and rising blood-pressure, such, for instance, as mental +depression and bad temper; and, unless my observation deceives me, we have +here a connection between conditions of high blood-pressure, with mental +and bodily depression, and the act of masturbation, for this act will +relieve those conditions, and will tend to be practiced for this purpose." +(A. Haig, _Uric Acid_, sixth edition, p. 154.) + +[128] A medical correspondent speaks of subjective feelings of temperature +coming over the body from 20 to 24 hours after congress, and marked by +sensations of cooling of body and glow of cheeks. In another case, though +lassitude appears on the second day after congress, the first day after is +marked by a notable increase in mental and physical activity. + + + + +III. + +The Constituents of Semen--Function of the Prostate--The Properties of +Semen--Aphrodisiacs--Alcohol, Opium, etc.--Anaphrodisiacs--The Stimulant +Influence of Semen in Coitus--The Internal Effects of Testicular +Secretions--The Influence of Ovarian Secretion. + + +The germ cell never comes into the sphere of consciousness and cannot +therefore concern us in the psychological study of the phenomena of the +sexual instinct. But it is otherwise with the sperm cell, and the seminal +fluid has a relationship, both direct and indirect, to psychic phenomena +which it is now necessary to discuss. + +While the spermatozoa are formed in the glandular tissue of the testes, +the seminal fluid as finally emitted in detumescence is not a purely +testicular product, but is formed by mixture with the fluids poured out at +or before detumescence by various glands which open into the urethra, and +notably the prostate.[129] This is a purely sexual gland, which in animals +only becomes large and active during the breeding season, and may even be +hardly distinguishable at other times; moreover, if the testes are removed +in infancy, the prostate remains rudimentary, so that during recent years +removal of the testes has been widely advocated and practiced for that +hypertrophy of the prostate which is sometimes a distressing ailment of +old age. It is the prostatic fluid, according to Fürbringer, which imparts +its characteristic odor to semen. It appears, however, to be the main +function of the prostatic fluid to arouse and maintain the motility of the +spermatozoa; before meeting the prostatic fluid the spermatozoa are +motionless; that fluid seems to furnish a thinner medium in which they +for the first time gain their full vitality.[130] + +When at length the semen is ejaculated, it contains various substances +which may be separated from it,[131] and possesses various qualities, some +of which have only lately been investigated, while others have evidently +been known to mankind from a very early period. "When held for some time +in the mouth," remarked John Hunter, "it produces a warmth similar to +spices, which lasts some time."[132] Possibly this fact first suggested +that semen might, when ingested, possess valuable stimulant qualities, a +discovery which has been made by various savages, notably by the +Australian aborigines, who, in many parts of Australia, administer a +potion of semen to dying or feeble members of the tribe.[133] It is +perhaps noteworthy that in Central Africa the testes of the goat are +consumed as an aphrodisiac.[134] In eighteenth century Europe, Schurig, in +his _Spermatologia_, still found it necessary to discuss at considerable +length the possible medical properties of human semen, giving many +prescriptions which contained it.[135] The stimulation produced by the +ingestion of semen would appear to form in some cases a part of the +attraction exerted by _fellatio_; De Sade emphasized this point; and in a +case recorded by Howard semen appears to have acted as a stimulant for +which the craving was as irresistible as is that for alcohol in +dipsomania.[136] + + It must be remembered that the early history of this subject is + more or less inextricably commingled with folk-lore practices of + magical origin, not necessarily founded on actual observation of + the physiological effects of consuming the semen or testes. Thus, + according to W.H. Pearse (_Scalpel_, December, 1897), it is the + custom in Cornwall for country maids to eat the testicles of the + young male lambs when they are castrated in the spring, the + survival, probably, of a very ancient religious cult. (I have not + myself been able to hear of this custom in Cornwall.) In + Burchard's Penitential (Cap. CLIV, Wasserschleben, op. cit., p. + 660) seven years' penance is assigned to the woman who swallows + her husband's semen to make him love her more. In the seventeenth + century (as shown in William Salmon's _London Dispensatory_, + 1678) semen was still considered to be good against witchcraft + and also valuable as a love-philter, in which latter capacity its + use still survives. (Bourke, _Scatalogic Rites_, pp. 343, 355.) + In an earlier age (Picart, quoted by Crawley, _The Mystic Rose_, + p. 109) the Manichæans, it is said, sprinkled their eucharistic + bread with human semen, a custom followed by the Albigenses. + + The belief, perhaps founded in experience, that semen possesses + medical and stimulant virtues was doubtless fortified by the + ancient opinion that the spinal cord is the source of this fluid. + This was not only held by the highest medical authorities in + Greece, but also in India and Persia. + + The semen is thus a natural stimulant, a physiological + aphrodisiac, the type of a class of drugs which have been known + and cultivated in all parts of the world from time immemorial. + (Dufour has discussed the aphrodisiacs used in ancient Rome, + _Histoire de la Prostitution_, vol. II, ch. 21.) It would be vain + to attempt to enumerate all the foods and medicaments to which + has been ascribed an influence in heightening the sexual impulse. + (Thus, in the sixteenth century, aphrodisiacal virtues were + attributed to an immense variety of foods by Liébault in his + _Thresor des Remèdes Secrets pour les Maladies des Femmes_, 1585, + pp. 104, et seq.) A large number of them certainly have no such + effect at all, but have obtained this credit either on some + magical ground or from a mistaken association. Thus the potato, + when first introduced from America, had the reputation of being a + powerful aphrodisiac, and the Elizabethan dramatists contain many + references to this supposed virtue. As we know, potatoes, even + when taken in the largest doses, have not the slightest + aphrodisiac effect, and the Irish peasantry, whose diet consists + very largely of potatoes, are even regarded as possessing an + unusually small measure of sexual feeling. It is probable that + the mistake arose from the fact that potatoes were originally a + luxury, and luxuries frequently tend to be regarded as + aphrodisiacs, since they are consumed under circumstances which + tend to arouse the sexual desires. It is possible also that, as + has been plausibly suggested, the misunderstanding may have been + due to sailors--the first to be familiar with the potato--who + attributed to this particular element of their diet ashore the + generally stimulating qualities of their life in port. The eryngo + (_Eryngium maritimum_), or sea holly, which also had an erotic + reputation in Elizabethan times, may well have acquired it in the + same way. Many other vegetables have a similar reputation, which + they still retain. Thus onions are regarded as aphrodisiacal, and + were so regarded by the Greeks, as we learn from Aristophanes. It + is noteworthy that Marro, a reliable observer, has found that in + Italy, both in prisons and asylums, lascivious people are fond of + onions (_La Pubertà _, p. 297), and it may perhaps be worth while + to recall the observation of Sérieux that in a woman in whom the + sexual instinct only awoke in middle age there was a horror of + leeks. In some countries, and especially in Belgium, celery is + popularly looked upon as a sexual stimulant. Various condiments, + again, have the same reputation, perhaps because they are hot and + because sexual desire is regarded, rightly enough, as a kind of + heat. Fish--skate, for instance, and notably oysters and other + shellfish--are very widely regarded as aphrodisiacs, and Kisch + attributes this property to caviar. It is probable that all these + and other foods which have obtained this reputation, in so far as + they have any action whatever on the sexual appetite, only + possess it by virtue of their generally nutritious and + stimulating qualities, and not by the presence of any special + principle having a selective action on the sexual sphere. A + beefsteak is probably as powerful a sexual stimulant as any food; + a nutritious food, however, which is at the same time easily + digestible, and thus requiring less expenditure of energy for its + absorption, may well exert a specially rapid and conspicuous + stimulant effect. But it is not possible to draw a line, and, as + Aquinas long since said, if we wish to maintain ourselves in a + state of purity we shall fear even an immoderate use of bread and + water. + + More definitely aphrodisiacal effects are produced by drugs, and + especially by drugs which in large doses are poisons. The + aphrodisiac with the widest popular reputation is cantharides, + but its sexually exciting effects are merely an accidental result + of its action in causing inflammation of the genito-urinary + passage, and it is both an uncertain and a dangerous result, + except in skillful hands and when administered in small doses. + Nux vomica (with its alkaloid strychnia), by virtue of its + special action on the spinal cord, has a notably pronounced + effect in heightening the irritability of the spinal ejaculatory + center, though it by no means necessarily exerts any + strengthening influence. Alcohol exerts a sexually exciting + effect, but in a different manner; it produces little stimulation + of the cord and, indeed, even paralyzes the lumbar sexual center + in large doses, but it has an influence on the peripheral + nerve-endings and on the skin, and also on the cerebral centers, + tending to arouse desire and to diminish inhibition. In this + latter way, as Adler remarks, it may, in small doses, under some + circumstances, be beneficial in men with an excessive + nervousness or dread of coitus, and women, in whom orgasm has + been difficult to reach, have frequently found this facilitated + by some previous indulgence in alcohol. The aphrodisiac effect of + alcohol seems specially marked on women. But against the use of + alcohol as an aphrodisiac it must be remembered that it is far + from being a tonic to detumescence, at all events in men, and + that there is much evidence tending to show that not only chronic + alcoholism, but even procreation during intoxication is perilous + to the offspring (see, e.g., Andriezen, _Journal of Mental + Science_, January, 1905, and cf. W.C. Sullivan, "Alcoholism and + Suicidal Impulses," ib., April, 1898, p. 268); it may be added + that Bunge has found a very high proportion of cases of + immoderate use of alcohol in the fathers of women unable to + suckle their infants (G. von Bunge, _Die Zunehmende Unfähigkeit + der Frauen ihre Kinder zu Stillen_, 1903) while even an + approximation to the drunken state is far from being a desirable + prelude to the creation of a new human being. It is obvious that + those who wish, for any reason, to cultivate a strict chastity of + thought and feeling would do well to avoid alcohol altogether, or + only in its lightest forms and in moderation. The aphrodisiacal + effects of wine have long been known; Ovid refers to them (e.g., + _Ars Am._, Bk. III, 765). Clement of Alexandria, who was + something of a man of science as well as a Christian moralist, + points out the influence of wine in producing lasciviousness and + sexual precocity. (_Pædagogus_, Bk. II, Chapter II). Chaucer + makes the Wife of Bath say in the Wife of Bath's Prologue:-- + + "And, after wyn, on Venus moste [needs] I thinke: + For al so siken as cold engendreth hayl, + A likerous mouth moste have a likerous tayl, + In womman vinolent is no defense, + This knowen lechours by experience." + + Alcohol, as Chaucer pointed out, comes to the aid of the man, who + is unscrupulous in his efforts to overcome a woman, and this not + merely by virtue of its aphrodisiacal effects, and the apparently + special influence which it seems to exert on women, but also + because it lulls the mental and emotional characteristics which + are the guardians of personality. A correspondent who has + questioned on this point a number of prostitutes he has known, + writes: "Their accounts of the first fall were nearly always the + same. They got to know a 'gentleman,' and on one occasion they + drank too much; before they quite realized what was happening + they were no longer virgins." "In the mental areas, under the + influence of alcohol," Schmiedeberg remarks (in his _Elements of + Pharmacology_), "the finer degrees of observation, judgment, and + reflection are the first to disappear, while the remaining mental + functions remain in a normal condition. The soldier acts more + boldly because he notices dangers less and reflects over them + less; the orator does not allow himself to be influenced by any + disturbing side-considerations as to his audience, hence he + speaks more freely and spiritedly; self-consciousness is lost to + a very great extent, and many are astounded at the ease with + which they can express their thoughts, and at the acuteness of + their judgment in matters which, when they are perfectly sober, + with difficulty reach their minds; and then afterwards they are + ashamed at their mistakes." + + The action of opium in small doses is also to some extent + aphrodisiacal; it slightly stimulates both the brain and the + spinal cord, and has sensory effects on the skin like alcohol; + these effects are favored by the state of agreeable dreaminess it + produces. In the seventeenth century Venette (_La Génération de + l'Homme_, Part II, Chapter V) strongly recommended small doses of + opium, then little known, for this purpose; he had himself, he + says, in illness experienced its joys, "a shadow of those of + heaven." In India opium (as well as cannabis indica) has long + been a not uncommon aphrodisiac; it is specially used to diminish + local sensibility, delaying the orgasm and thus prolonging the + sexual act. (W.D. Sutherland, "De Impotentia," _Indian Medical + Gazette_, January, 1900). Its more direct and stimulating + influence on the sexual emotions seems indicated by the statement + that prostitutes are found standing outside the opium-smoking + dens of Bombay, but not outside the neighboring liquor shops. + (G.C. Lucas, _Lancet_, February 2, 1884.) Like alcohol, opium + seems to have a marked aphrodisiacal effect on women. The case is + recorded of a mentally deranged girl, with no nymphomania though + she masturbated, who on taking small doses of opium at once + showed signs of nymphomania, following men about, etc. (_American + Journal Obstetrics_, May, 1901, p. 74.) It may well be believed + that opium acts beneficially in men when the ejaculatory centers + are weak but irritable; but its actions are too widespread over + the organism to make it in any degree a valuable aphrodisiac. + Various other drugs have more or less reputation as aphrodisiacs; + thus bromide of gold, a nervous and glandular stimulant, is said + to have as one of its effects a heightening of sexual feeling. + Yohimbin, an alkaloid derived from the West African Yohimbehe + tree, has obtained considerable repute during recent years in the + treatment of impotence; in some cases (see, e.g., Toff's results, + summarized in _British Medical Journal_, February 18, 1905) it + has produced good results, apparently by increasing the blood + supply to the sexual organs, but has not been successful in all + cases or in all hands. It must always be remembered that in cases + of psychical impotence suggestion necessarily exerts a beneficial + influence, and this may work through any drug or merely with the + aid of bread pills. All exercise, often even walking, may be a + sexual stimulant, and it is scarcely necessary to add that + powerful stimulation of the skin in the sexual sphere, and more + especially of the nates, is often a more effective aphrodisiac + than any drug, whether the irritation is purely mechanical, as by + flogging, or mechanico-chemical, as by urtication or the + application of nettles. Among the Malays (with whom both men and + women often use a variety of plants as aphrodisiacs, according to + Vaughan Stevens) Breitenstein states (_21 Jahre in India_, Theil + I, p. 228) that both massage and gymnastics are used to increase + sexual powers. The local application of electricity is one of the + most powerful of aphrodisiacs, and McMordie found on applying one + pole to a uterine sound in the uterus and the other to the + abdominal wall that in the majority of healthy women the orgasm + occurred. + + Among anaphrodisiacs, or sexual sedatives, bromide of potassium, + by virtue of its antidotal relationship to strychnia, is one of + the drugs whose action is most definite, though, while it dulls + sexual desire, it also dulls all the nervous and cerebral + activities. Camphor has an ancient reputation as an + anaphrodisiac, and its use in this respect was known to the Arabs + (as may be seen by a reference to it in the _Perfumed Garden_), + while, as Hyrtl mentions (loc. cit. ii, p. 94), rue (_Ruta + graveolens_) was considered a sexual sedative by the monks of + old, who on this account assiduously cultivated it in their + cloister gardens to make _vinum rutæ_. Recently heroin in large + doses (see, e.g., Becker, _Berliner Klinische Wochenschrift_, + November 23, 1903) has been found to have a useful effect in this + direction. It may be doubted, however, whether there is any + satisfactory and reliable anaphrodisiac. Charcot, indeed, it is + said, used to declare that the only anaphrodisiac in which he had + any confidence was that used by the uncle of Heloïse in the case + of Abelard. "_Cela_ (he would add with a grim smile) _tranche la + difficulte_." + +If semen is a stimulant when ingested, it is easy to suppose that it may +exert a similar action on the woman who receives it into the vagina in +normal sexual congress. It is by no means improbable that, as Mattei +argued in 1878, this is actually the case. It is known that the vagina +possesses considerable absorptive power. Thus Coen and Levi, among others, +have shown that if a tampon soaked in a solution of iodine is introduced +into the vagina, iodine will be found in the urine within an hour. And the +same is true of various other substances.[137] If the vagina absorbs drugs +it probably absorbs semen. Toff, of Braila (Roumania), who attaches much +importance to such absorption, considers that it must be analogous to the +ingestion of organic extractives. It is due to this influence, he +believes, that weak and anæmic girls so often become full-blooded and +robust after marriage, and lose their nervous tendencies and shyness.[138] + +It is, however, most certainly a mistake to suppose that the beneficial +influence of coitus on women is exclusively, or even mainly, dependent +upon the absorption of semen. This is conclusively demonstrated by the +fact that such beneficial influence is exerted, and in full measure, even +when all precautions have been taken to avoid any contact with the semen. +In so far as _coitus reservatus_ or _interruptus_ may lead to haste or +discomfort which prevents satisfactory orgasm on the part of the woman, it +is without doubt a cause of defective detumescence and incomplete +satisfaction. But if orgasm is complete the beneficial effects of coitus +follow even if there has been no possibility of the absorption of semen. +Even after _coitus interruptus_, if it can be prolonged for a period long +enough for the woman to attain full and complete satisfaction, she is +enabled to experience what she may describe as a feeling of intoxication, +lasting for several hours. It is in the action of the orgasm itself, and +the vascular, secretory, and metabolic activities set up by the psychic +and nervous influence of coitus with a beloved person, that we must seek +the chief key to the effects produced by coitus on women, however these +effects may possibly be still further heightened by the actual absorption +of semen.[139] + +The positive action of semen, or rather of the testicular products, has +been much investigated during recent years, and appears on the whole to be +demonstrated. The notable discovery by Brown-Séquard, a quarter of a +century ago, that the ingestion of the testicular juices in states of +debility and senility acted as a beneficial stimulant and tonic, opened +the way to a new field of therapeutics. Many investigators in various +countries have found that testicular extracts, and more especially the +spermin as studied by Poehl,[140] and by him regarded as a positive +katalysator or accelerator of metabolic processes, exert a real influence +in giving tone to the heart and other muscles, and in improving the +metabolism of the tissues even when all influences of mental suggestion +have been excluded.[141] + + As the ovaries are strictly analogous to the testes, it was + surmised that ovarian extract might prove a drug equally valuable + with testicular products. As a matter of fact, ovarian extract, + in the form of ovarin, etc., would seem to have proved beneficial + in various disorders, more especially in anæmia and in troubles + due to the artificial menopause. In most conditions, however, in + which it has been employed the results are doubtful or uncertain, + and some authorities believe that the influence of suggestion + plays a considerable part here. + +There is, however, another use which is subserved by the testicular +products, a use which may indeed be said to be implied in those uses to +which reference has already been made, but is yet historically the latest +to be realized and studied. It was not until 1869 that Brown-Séquard first +suggested that an important secretion was elaborated by the ductless +glands and received into the circulation, but that suggestion proved to be +epoch-making. If these glandular secretions are so valuable when +administered as drugs to other persons, must they not be of far greater +value when naturally secreted and poured out into the circulation in the +living body? It is now generally believed, on the basis of a large and +various body of evidence, that this is undoubtedly so. In a very crude +form, indeed, this belief is by no means modern. In opposition to the old +writers who were inclined to regard the semen as an excretion which it was +beneficial to expel, there were other ancient authorities who argued that +it was beneficial to retain it as being a vital fluid which, if +reabsorbed, served to invigorate the body. The great physiologist, Haller, +in the middle of the eighteenth century, came very near to the modern +doctrine when he stated in his _Elements of Physiology_ that the sperm +accumulated in the seminical vesicles is pumped back into the blood, and +thus produces the beard and the hair together with the other surprising +changes of puberty which are absent in the eunuch. The reabsorption of +semen can scarcely be said to be a part of the modern physiological +doctrine, but it is at least now generally held that the testes secrete +substances which pass into the circulation and are of immense importance +in the development of the organism. + +The experiments of Shattock and Seligmann indicate that the semen and its +reabsorption in the seminal vesicles, or the nervous reactions produced by +its presence, can have no part in the formation of secondary sexual +characters. These investigators occluded the vas deferens in sheep by +ligature, at an early age, rendering them later sterile though not +impotent. The secondary sexual characters appeared as in ordinary sheep. +Spermatogenesis, these inquirers conclude, may be the initial factor, but +the results must be attributed to the elaboration by the testicles of an +internal secretion and its absorption into the general circulation.[142] + +When animals are castrated there is enlargement of the ductless glands in +the body, notably the thyroid and the suprarenal capsules.[143] It is +evident, therefore, that the secretions of these ductless glands are in +some degree compensatory to those of the testes. But this compensatory +action is inadequate to produce any sexual development in the absence of +the testes. + +We see, therefore, how extremely important is the function of the testis. +Its significance is not alone for the race, it is not simply concerned +with the formation of the spermatozoa which share equally with the ova the +honor of making the mankind of the future. It also has a separate and +distinct function which has reference to the individual. It elaborates +those internal secretions which stimulate and maintain the physical and +mental characters, constituting all that is most masculine in the male +animal, all that makes the man in distinction from the eunuch. Among +various primitive peoples, including those of the European race whence we +ourselves spring, the most solemn form of oath was sworn by placing the +hand on the testes, dimly recognized as the most sacred part of the body. +A crude and passing phase of civilization has ignorantly cast ignominy +upon the sexual organs; the more primitive belief is now justified by our +advancing knowledge. + + In these as in other respects the ovaries are precisely analogous + to the testes. They not only form the ova, but they elaborate for + internal use a secretion which develops and maintains the special + physical and mental qualities of womanhood, as the testicular + secretion those of manhood. Moreover, as Cecca and Zappi found, + removal of the ovaries has exactly the same effect on the + abnormal development of the other ductless glands as has removal + of the testes. It is of interest to point out that the internal + secretion of the ovaries and its important functions seem to have + been suggested before any other secretion than the sperm was + attributed to the testes. Early in the nineteenth century Cabanis + argued ("De l'Influence des Sexes sur le Caractère des Idées et + des Affections Morales," _Rapport du Physique et du Moral de + l'Homme_, 1824, vol. ii, p. 18) that the ovaries are secreting + glands, forming a "particular humor" which is reabsorbed into the + blood and imparts excitations which are felt by the whole system + and all its organs. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[129] The composite character of the semen was recognized by various old +authors, some of whom said, (e.g., Wharton) that it had three +constituents, which they usually considered to be: (1) The noblest and +most essential part, from the testicles; (2) a watery element from the +vesiculæ; (3) an oily element from the prostate. Schurig, _Spermatologia_, +1720, p. 17. + +[130] See, e.g., C. Mansell Moulin, "A Contribution to the Morphology of +the Prostate," _Journal of Anatomy and Physiology_, January, 1895; G. +Walker, "A Contribution to the Anatomy and Physiology of the Prostate +Gland, and a Few Observations on Ejaculation," _Johns Hopkins Hospital +Bulletin_, October, 1900. + +[131] For a study of the semen and its constituents, see Florence, "Du +Sperme," _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, 1895. + +[132] J. Hunter, _Essays and Observations_, vol. i, p. 189. + +[133] As regards one part of Australia, Walter Roth, _Ethnological Studies +Among the Queensland Aborigines_, p. 174. + +[134] Sir H.H. Johnston, _British Central Africa_, p. 438. + +[135] Cap. VII, pp. 327-357, "De Spermaticis virilis usu Medico," + +[136] W.L. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," _Alienist and Neurologist_, +January, 1896. + +[137] _Zentralblatt für Gynäkologie_, 1894, No. 49. + +[138] E. Toff, "Uber Imprägnierung," _Zentralblatt für Gynäkologie_, +April, 1903. In a similar but somewhat more precise manner Dufougère has +argued ("La Chlorose, ses rapports avec le marriage, son traitement par le +liquide orchitique," Thèse de Bordeaux, 1902) that semen when absorbed by +the vagina stimulates the secretion of the ovaries and thus exerts an +influence over the blood in anæmia; in this way he seeks to explain why it +is that coitus is the best treatment for chlorosis. + +[139] In this connection I may refer to an interesting and suggestive +paper by Harry Campbell on "The Craving for Stimulants" (_Lancet_, October +21, 1899). No reference is made to coitus, but the author discusses +stimulants as normal and beneficial products of the organism, and deals +with the nature of the "physiological intoxication" they produce. + +[140] Spermin was first discovered in the sperm by Schreiner in 1878; it +has also been found in the thyroid, ovaries and various other glands. "The +spermin secreting and elaborating organs," Howard Kelly remarks (_British +Medical Journal_, January 29, 1898), "may be called the apothecaries' of +the body, secreting many important medicaments, much more active and more +accurately representing its true wants than artificially administered +drugs." + +[141] See, e.g., a summary of Buschan's comprehensive discussion of the +subject of organotherapy (Eulenburg's _Real-Encyclopædie der Gesammten +Heilkunde_) in _Journal of Mental Science_, April, 1899, p. 355. + +[142] "Observations Upon the Acquirement of Secondary Sexual Characters, +Indicating the Formation of an Internal Secretion by the Testicles," +_Proceedings Royal Society_, vol. lxxiii, p. 49. + +[143] See, e.g., the experiments of Cecca and Zappi, summarized in +_British Medical Journal_, July 2, 1904. + + + + +IV. + +The Aptitude for Detumescence--Is There an Erotic Temperament?--The +Available Standards of Comparison--Characteristics of the +Castrated--Characteristics of Puberty--Characteristics of the State of +Detumescence--Shortness of Stature--Development of the Secondary Sexual +Characters--Deep Voice--Bright Eyes--Glandular Activity--Everted +Lips--Pigmentation--Profuse Hair--Dubious Significance of Many of These +Characters. + + +What, if any, are the indications which the body generally may furnish as +to the individual's aptitude and vigor for the orgasm of detumescence? Is +there an erotic temperament outwardly and visibly displayed? That is a +question which has often occupied those who have sought to penetrate the +more intimate mysteries of human nature, and since we are here concerned +with human beings in their relationship to the process of detumescence, we +cannot altogether pass over this question, difficult as it is to discuss +it with precision. + + The old physiognomists showed much confidence in dealing with the + matter. Possibly they had more opportunities for observation than + we have, since they often wrote in days when life was lived more + nakedly than among ourselves, but their descriptions, while + sometimes showing much insight, are inextricably mixed up with + false science and superstition. + + In the _De Secretis Mulierum_, wrongly attributed to Albertus + Magnus, we find a chapter entitled "Signa mulieris calidæ naturæ + et quæ coit libenter," which may be summarized here. "The signs," + we are told, "of a woman of warm temperament, and one who + willingly cohabits are these: youth, an age of over 12, or + younger, if she has been seduced, small, high breasts, full and + hard, hair in the usual positions; she is bold of speech, with a + delicate and high voice, haughty and even cruel of disposition, + of good complexion, lean rather than stout, inclined to like + drinking. Such a woman always desires coitus, and receives + satisfaction in the act. The menstrual flow is not abundant nor + always regular. If she becomes pregnant the milk is not abundant. + Her perspiration is less odorous than that of the woman of + opposite temperament; she is fond of singing, and of moving + about, and delights in adornments if she has any." + + Polemon, in his _Sulla Physionomia_, has given among the signs of + libidinous impulse: knees turned inwards, abundance of hairs on + the legs, squint, bright eyes, a high and strident voice, and in + women length of leg below the knee. Aristotle had mentioned among + the signs of wantonness: paleness, abundance of hair on the body, + thick and black hair, hairs covering the temples, and thick + eyelids. + + In the seventeenth century Bouchet, in his _Serées_ (Troisième + Serée), gave as the signs of virility which indicated that a man + could have children: a great voice, a thick rough black beard, a + large thick nose. + + G. Tourdes (Art. "Aphrodisie," _Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des + Sciences Médicales_) thus summarized the ancient beliefs on this + subject: "The erotic temperament has been described as marked by + a lean figure, white and well-ranged teeth, a developed hairy + system, a characteristic voice, air, and expression, and even a + special odor." + +In approaching the question of the general physical indications of a +special aptitude to the manifestation of vigorous detumescence, the most +obvious preliminary would seem to be a study of the castrated. If we know +the special peculiarities of those who by removal of the sexual glands at +a very early age have been deprived of all ability to present the +manifestations of detumescence, we shall probably be in possession of a +type which is the reverse of that which we may expect in persons of a +vigorously erotic temperament. + +The most general characteristics of eunuchs would appear to be an unusual +tendency to put on fat, a notably greater length of the legs, absence of +hair in the sexual and secondary sexual regions, a less degree of +pigmentation, as noted both in the castrated negro and the white man, a +puerile larynx and puerile voice. In character they are usually described +as gentle, conciliatory, and charitable. + + There can be little doubt that castration in man tends to lead to + lengthening of the legs (tibia and fibula) at puberty, from + delayed ossification of the epiphyses. The hands and feet are + also frequently longer and sometimes the forearms. At the same + time the bones are more slender. The pelvis also is narrower. The + eunuchs of Cairo are said to be easily seen in a crowd from their + tall stature. (Collineau, quoting Lortet, _Revue Mensuelle de + l'Ecole d'Anthropologie_, May, 1896.) The castrated Skoptzy show + increased stature, and, it seems, large ears, with decreased + chest and head (L. Pittard, _Revue Scientifique_, June 20, 1903.) + Féré shows that in most of these respects the eunuch resembles + beardless and infantile subjects. ("Les Proportions des Membres + et les Caractères Sexuels," _Journal de l'Anatomie et de la + Physiologie_, November-December, 1897.) Similar phenomena are + found in animals generally. Sellheim, carefully investigating + castrated horses, swine, oxen and fowls, found retardation of + ossification, long and slender extremities, long, broad, but low + skull, relatively smaller pelvis and small thorax. ("Zur Lehre + von den Sekundären Geschlechtscharakteren," _Beiträge zur + Geburtshülfe und Gynäkologie_, 1898, summarized in _Centralblatt + für Anthropologie_, 1900, Heft IV.) + + As regards the mental qualities and moral character of the + castrated, Griffiths considers that there is an undue prejudice + against eunuchs, and refers to Narses, who was not only one of + the first generals of the Roman Empire, but a man of highly + estimable character. (_Lancet_, March 30, 1895.) Matignon, who + has carefully studied Chinese eunuchs, points out that they + occupy positions of much responsibility, and, though regarded in + many respects as social outcasts, possess very excellent and + amiable moral qualities (_Archives Cliniques de Bordeaux_, May, + 1896.) In America Everett Flood finds that epileptics and + feeble-minded boys are mentally and morally benefited by + castration. ("Notes on the Castration of Idiot Children," + _American Journal of Psychology_, January, 1899.) It is often + forgotten that the physical and psychic qualities associated with + and largely dependent on the ability to experience the impulse of + detumescence, while essential to the perfect man, involve many + egoistic, aggressive and acquisitive characteristics which are of + little intellectual value, and at the same time inimical to many + moral virtues. + +We have a further standard--positive this time rather than negative--to +aid us in determining the erotic temperament: the phenomena of puberty. +The efflorescence of puberty is essentially the manifestation of the +ability to experience detumescence. It is therefore reasonable to suppose +that the individuals in whom the special phenomena of puberty develop most +markedly are those in whom detumescence is likely to be most vigorous. If +such is the case we should expect to find the erotic temperament marked by +developed larynx and deep voice, a considerable degree of pigmentary +development in hair and skin, and a marked tendency to hairiness; while +in women there should be a pronounced growth of the breasts and +pelvis.[144] + +There is yet another standard by which we may measure the individual's +aptitude for detumescence: the presence of those activities which are most +prominently brought into play during the process of detumescence. The +individual, that is to say, who is organically most apt to manifest the +physiological activities which mainly make up the process of detumescence, +is most likely to be of pronounced erotic temperament. + +"Erotic persons are of motor type," remark Vaschide and Vurpas, "and we +may say generally that nearly all persons of motor type are erotic." The +state of detumescence is one of motor and muscular energy and of great +vascular activity, so that habitual energy of motor response and an active +circulation may reasonably be taken to indicate an aptitude for the +manifestation of detumescence. + +These three types may be said, therefore, to furnish us valuable though +somewhat general indications. The individual who is farthest removed from +the castrated type, who presents in fullest degree the characters which +begin to emerge at the period of puberty, and who reveals a physiological +aptitude for the vigorous manifestation of those activities which are +called into action during detumescence, is most likely to be of erotic +temperament. The most cautious description of the characteristics of this +temperament given by modern scientific writers, unlike the more detailed +and hazardous descriptions of the early physiognomists, will be found to +be fairly true to the standards thus presented to us. + + The man of sexual type, according to Biérent (_La Puberté_, p. + 148), is hairy, dark and deep-voiced. + + "The men most liable to satyriasis," Bouchereau states (art. + "Satyriasis," _Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des Sciences + Médicales_), "are those with vigorous nervous system, developed + muscles, abundant hair on body, dark complexion, and white + teeth." + + Mantegazza, in his _Fisiologia del Piacere_, thus describes the + sexual temperament: "Individuals of nervous temperament, those + with fine and brown skins, rounded forms, large lips and very + prominent larynx enjoy in general much more than those with + opposite characteristics. A universal tradition," he adds, + "describes as lascivious humpbacks, dwarfs, and in general + persons of short stature and with long noses." + + In a case of nymphomania in a young woman, described by Alibert + (and quoted by Laycock, _Nervous Diseases of Women_, p. 28) the + hips, thighs and legs were remarkably plump, while the chest and + arms were completely emaciated. In a somewhat similar case + described by Marc in his _De la Folie_ a peasant woman, who from + an early age had experienced sexual hyperæsthesia, so that she + felt spasmodic voluptuous feelings at the sight of a man, and was + thus the victim of solitary excesses and of spasmodic movements + which she could not repress, the upper part of the body was very + thin, the hips, legs and thighs highly developed. + + In his work on _Uterine and Ovarian Inflammation_ (1862, p. 37) + Tilt observes: "The restless, bashful eye, and changing + complexion, in presence of a person of the opposite sex, and a + nervous restlessness of body, ever on the move, turning and + twisting on sofa or chair, are the best indications of sexual + temperament." + + An extremely sensual little girl of 8, who was constantly + masturbating when not watched, although brought up by nuns, was + described by Busdraghi (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, fas. i, 1888, + p. 53) as having chestnut hair, bright black eyes, an elevated + nose, small mouth, pleasant round face, full colored cheeks, and + plump and healthy aspect. + + A highly intelligent young Italian woman with strong and somewhat + perverted sexual impulses is described as of attractive + appearance, with olive complexion, small black almond-shaped + eyes, dilated pupils, oblique thin eyebrows, very thick black + hair, rather prominent cheek-bones, largely developed jaw, and + with abundant down on lower part of cheeks and on upper lip. + (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1899, fasc. v-vi.) + + As the type of the sensual woman in word and act, led by her + passions to commit various sexual offenses, Ottolenghi describes + (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, vol. xii, fasc. v-vi, p. 496) a woman + of 32 who attempted to kill her lover. The daughter of parents + who were neurotic and themselves very erotic, she was a highly + intelligent and vivacious woman, with a pleasing and open face, + very thick dark chestnut hair, large cheek-bones, adipose + buttocks almost resembling those of a Hottentot, and very thick + pubic hair. She was very fond of salt things. Sexual inclination + began at the age of 7. + +Adler and Moll remark, very truly, that, so far at least as women are +concerned, sexual anæsthesia or sexual proclivity cannot be unfailingly +read on the features. Every woman desires to please, and coquetry is the +sign of a cold, rather than of an erotic temperament.[145] It may be added +that a considerable degree of congenital sexual anæsthesia by no means +prevents a woman from being beautiful and attractive, though it must +probably still always be said that, as Roubaud points out,[146] the woman +of cold and intellectual temperament, the "femme de tête," however +beautiful and skillful she may be, cannot compete in the struggle for love +with the woman whose qualities are of the heart and of the emotions. But +it seems sufficiently clear that the practical observations of skilled and +experienced observers agree in attributing to persons of erotic type +certain general characteristics which accord with those negative and +positive standards we may frame on the basis of castration, of puberty, +and of detumescence. It may be worth while to note a few of these +characteristics briefly. + +The abnormal lengthening of the long bones at the age of puberty in the +castrated is, as we have seen, very pronounced. There is little tendency +to associate length of limb with an erotic temperament, and a certain +amount of data as well as of more vague opinion points in the opposite +direction. The Arabs would appear to believe that it is short rather than +tall people in whom the sexual instinct is strongly developed, and we read +in the _Perfumed Garden_: "Under all circumstances little women love +coitus more and evince a stronger affection for the virile member than +women of a large size." In his elaborate investigation of criminals Marro +found that prostitutes and women guilty of sexual offenses, as also male +sexual offenders, tend to be short and thick set.[147] In European +folk-lore the thick, bull neck is regarded as a sign of strong +sexuality.[148] Mantegazza refers to a strong sexual temperament as being +associated with arrest or disorder of bony development, and Marro suggests +that the proverbial salacity of rachitic individuals may be due to an +increased activity of the sexual organs.[149] It may be added that +acromegaly, with its excessive bony growths, tends to be associated with +premature sexual involution. + +A further point which is frequently mentioned in the case of women is the +development of the chief secondary sexual regions: the pelvis and the +breasts. It is, indeed, almost inevitable that there should be some degree +of correlation between the aptitude for bearing children and the aptitude +for experiencing detumescence. The reality of such a connection is not +only evidenced by medical observations, but receives further testimony in +popular beliefs. In Italy women with large buttocks are considered wanton, +and among the South Slavs they are regarded as especially fruitful.[150] +Blumenbach asserted that precocious venery will enlarge the breasts, and +believed that he had found evidence of this among young London +prostitutes.[151] + +The association of the aptitude for detumescence with a tendency to a deep +rather than to a high voice, both in men and women, has frequently been +noted and has seldom been denied. The onset of puberty always affects the +voice; in general, Biérent states, the more bass the voice is the more +marked is the development of the sexual apparatus; "a very robust man, +with very developed sexual organs, and very dark and abundant hairy +system, a man of strong puberty in a word, is nearly always a bass."[152] +The influence of sexual excitement in deepening the voice is shown by the +rules of sexual hygiene prescribed to tenors, while a bass has less need +to observe similar precautions. In women every phase of sexual +life--puberty, menstruation, coitus, pregnancy--tends to affect the voice +and always by giving it a deeper character. The deepening of the voice by +sexual intercourse was an ancient Greek observation, and Martial refers to +a woman's good or bad singing as an index to her recent sexual habits. +Prostitutes tend to have a deep voice. Venturi points out that married +women preserve a fresh voice to a more advanced age than spinsters, this +being due to the precocious senility in the latter of an unused function. +Such a phenomenon indicates that the relationship of detumescence to the +deepening of the voice is not quite simple. This is further indicated by +the fact that in robust men abstinence still further deepens the voice +(the monk of melodrama always has a bass voice), while excessive or +precocious sexual indulgence tends to be associated with the same kind of +puerile voice as is found in those persons in whom pubertal development +has not been carried very far, or who are of what Griffiths terms +eunuchoid type. Idiot boys, who are often sexually undeveloped, tend to +have a high voice, while idiot girls (who often manifest marked sexual +proclivities) not infrequently have a deep voice.[153] + +Bright dilated eyes are among the phenomena of detumescence, and are very +frequently noted in persons of a pronounced erotic temperament. This is, +indeed, an ancient observation, and Burton says of people with a black, +lively, and sparkling eye, "without question they are most amorous," +drawing his illustrations mostly from classic literature.[154] Tardieu +described the erotic woman as having bright eyes, and Heywood Smith states +that the eyes of lascivious women resemble, though in a less degree, those +of the insane.[155] Sexual excitement is one among many +causes--intellectual excitement, pain, a loud noise, even any sensory +irritation--which produce dilatation of the pupils and enlargement of the +palpebral fissure, with some protrusion of the eyeball. The influence of +the sexual system upon the eye appears to be far less potent in men than +in women.[156] Sexual desire is, however, by no means the only irritant +within the sexual sphere which may thus influence the eye; morbid +irritations may produce the same effect. Milner Fothergill, in his book on +_Indigestion_, vividly describes the appearance of the eyes sometimes +seen in ovarian disorder: "The glittering flash which glances out from +some female irides is the external indication of ovarian irritation, and +'the ovarian gleam' has features quite its own. The most marked instance +which ever came under my notice was due to irritation in the ovaries, +which had been forced down in front of the uterus and been fixed there by +adhesions. Here there was little sexual proclivity, but the eyes were very +remarkable. They flashed and glittered unceasingly, and at times perfect +lightning bolts shot from them. Usually there is a bright glittering sheen +in them which contrasts with the dead look in the irides of sexual excess +or profuse uterine discharges." + +The activity of the glandular secretions, and especially those of the +skin, during detumescence, would lead us to expect that such secretory +activity is an index to an aptitude for detumescence. As a matter of fact +it is occasionally, though not frequently, noted by medical observers. It +is stated that the erotic temperament is characterized by a special +odor.[157] The activity of the sweat-glands is seldom referred to by +medical observers in describing persons of erotic temperament, although +the descriptions of novelists not infrequently contain allusions to this +point, and the literature of an earlier age shows that the tendency to +perspiration, especially the moist hand, was regarded as a sure sign of a +sensual temperament. "The moist-handed Madonna Imperia, a most rare and +divine creature," remarks Lazarillo in Middleton's comedy _Blurt, +Master-Constable_, to quote one of many allusions to this point in the +Elizabethan drama. + +The lips are sometimes noted as red and everted, perhaps thick[158]; +Tardieu remarked that the typically erotic woman has thick red lips. This +corresponds with the characteristic type of the satyr in classic statues +as in later paintings; his lips are always thick and everted. Fullness, +redness, and eversion of the lips are correlated with good breathing, the +absence of anæmia, laughter, a well-fleshed face. + + This kind of mouth indicates, perhaps, not so much a congenitally + erotic temperament, as an abandonment to impulse. The opposite + type of mouth--with inverted, thin, and retracted lips--would + appear to be found with especial frequency in persons who + habitually repress their impulses on moral grounds. Any kind of + effort to restrain involuntary muscular action may lead to + retraction of the lips: the effort to overcome anger or fear, or + even the resistance to a strong desire to urinate or defecate. In + religious young men, however, it becomes habitual and fixed. I + recall a small band of medical students, gathered together from a + large medical school, who were accustomed to meet together for + prayer and Bible-reading; the majority showed this type of mouth + to a very marked degree: pale faces, with drawn, retracted lips. + It may be termed the Christian or pious _facies_. It is much less + frequently seen in religious women (unless of masculine type), + doubtless because religion for women is in a much less degree + than for men a moral discipline. + + It may be added that an interesting form of this contraction of + the lips, and one that is not purely repressive, is that which + indicates the state of muscular tension associated with the + impulse to guard and protect. In this form the contracted mouth + is the index of tenderness, and is characteristic of the mother + who is watching over the infant she is suckling at her breast. I + have observed precisely the same expression in the face of a boy + of 14 with a large congenital scrotal hernia; when the tumor was + being examined his lower lip became retracted, well marked lines + appearing from the angles downwards, though the upper lip + retained its normal expression It was precisely the tender look + we may see in the faces of mothers who are watching anxiously + over their offspring, and the emotion is evidently the same in + both cases: solicitude for a sensitive and tenderly guarded + object. + +The degree of pigmentation is clearly correlated with sexual vigor. "In +general," Heusinger laid down, in 1823, "the quantity of pigment is +proportional to the functional effectiveness of the genital organs." This +connection is so profound that it may be traced very widely throughout the +organic world. + +The connection between pigmentation and sexual activity is very ancient. +Even leaving out of account the wedding apparel of animals, nearly always +gorgeous in scales and plumage and hair, the sexual orifice shows a more +or less marked tendency to pigmentation during the breeding season from +fishes upward, while in mammals the darker pigmentation of this region is +a constant phenomenon in sexually mature individuals.[159] + +In the human species both the negative standard of castration and the +positive standard of puberty alike indicate a correlation of this kind. +Those individuals in whom puberty never fully develops and who are +consequently said to be affected by infantilism, reveal a relative absence +of pigment in the sexual centers which are normally pigmented to a high +degree.[160] Among those Asiatic races who extirpate the ovaries in young +girls the skin remains white in the perineum, round the anus, and in the +armpits.[161] Even in mature women who undergo ovariotomy, as Kepler +found, the pigmentation of the nipples and areola disappears, as well as +of the perineum and anus, the skin taking on a remarkable whiteness. + +Normally the sexual centers, and in a high degree the genital orifice, +represent the maximum of pigmentation, and under some circumstances this +is clearly visible even in infancy. Thus babies of mixed black and white +blood may show no traces of negro ancestry at birth, but there will always +be increased pigmentation about the external genitalia.[162] The linea +fusca, which reaches from the pubes to the navel and occasionally to the +ensiform cartilage, is a line of sexual pigmentation sometimes regarded as +characteristic of pregnancy, but as Andersen, of Copenhagen, has found by +the examination of several hundred children of both sexes, it exists in a +slight form in about 75 per cent. of young girls, and in almost as large a +proportion of boys. But there is no doubt that it tends to increase with +age as well as to become marked at pregnancy. At puberty there is a +general tendency to changes in pigmentation; thus Godin found that in 28 +per cent, adolescent changes occurred in the eyes and hair at this period, +the hair becoming darker, though the eyes sometimes become lighter. Ammon, +in his investigation of conscripts at the age of 20 (_post_, p. 196), +discovered the significant fact that the eyes and hair darken _pari passu_ +with sexual development. In women, during menstruation, there is a general +tendency to pigmentation; this is especially obvious around the eyes, and +in some cases black rings of true pigment form in this position. Even the +skin of the negro women of Loango sometimes becomes a few shades darker +during menstruation.[163] During pregnancy this tendency to pigmentation +reaches its climax. Pregnancy constantly gives rise to pigmentation of the +face, the neck, the nipples, the abdomen, and this is especially marked in +brunettes. + +This association of pigmentation and sexual aptitudes has been recognized +in the popular lore of some peoples. Thus the Sicilians, who admire brown +skin and have no liking either for a fair skin or light hair, believe that +a white woman is incapable of responding to love. It is the brown woman +who feels love; as it is said in Sicilian dialect: "Fimmina scura, fimmina +amurusa."[164] + + The dependence of pigmentation upon the sexual system is shown by + the fact that irritation of the genital organs by disease will + frequently suffice to produce a high degree of pigmentation. This + may the neck, the trunk, the hands. Simpson long since noted that + uterine irritation apart from pregnancy may produce pigmentation + of the areolæ of the nipples (_Obstetric Works_, vol. i, p. 345). + Engelmann discussed the subject and gave cases, "The + Hystero-Neuroses," pp. 124-139, in _Gynæcological Transactions_, + vol. xii, 1887; and a summary of a memoir by Fouquet on this + subject in _La Gynécologie_, February, 1903, will be found in + _British Medical Journal_, March 28, 1903, + +Of all physical traits vigor of the hairy system has most frequently +perhaps been regarded as the index of vigorous sexuality. In this matter +modern medical observations are at one with popular belief and ancient +physiognomical assertions.[165] The negative test of castration and the +positive test of puberty point in the same direction. + +It is at puberty that all the hair on the body, except that on the head, +begins to develop; indeed, the very word "puberty" has reference to this +growth as the most obvious sign of the whole process. When castration +takes place at an early age all this development of pubescent hair is +arrested. When the primary sexual organs are undeveloped the sexual hair +is also undeveloped, as in a case, recorded by Plant,[166] of a girl with +rudimentary uterus and ovaries who had little or no axillary and pubic +hair, although the hair of the head was long and strong.[167] + + The pseudo-Michael Scot among the _Signa mulieris calidæ naturæ + et quæ coit libenter_ stated that her hair, both on the head and + body, is thick and coarse and crisp, and Della Porta, the + greatest of the physiognomists, said that thickness of hair in + women meant wantonness. Venette, in his _Generation de l'Homme_, + remarked that men who have much hair on the body are most + amorous. At a more recent period Roubaud has said that pubic hair + in its quantity, color and curliness is an index of genital + energy. A poor pilous system, on the other hand, Roubaud regarded + as a probable though not an irrefragable proof of sexual + frigidity in women. "In the cold woman the pilous system is + remarkable for the languor of its vitality; the hairs are fair, + delicate, scarce and smooth, while in ardent natures there are + little curly tufts about the temples." (_Traité de + l'Impuissance_, pp. 124, 523.) Martineau declared (_Leçons sur + les Déformations Vulvaires_, p. 40) that "the more developed the + genital organs the more abundant the hair covering them; + abundance of hair appears to be in relation to the perfect + development of the organs." Tardieu described the typically + erotic woman as very hairy. + + Bergh found that among 2200 young Danish prostitutes those who + showed an unusual extension and amount of pubic hair included + several women who were believed to be libidinous in a very high + degree. (Bergh, "Symbolæ," etc., _Hospitalstidende_, August, + 1894.) Moraglia, again, in Italy, in describing various women, + mostly prostitutes, of unusually strong sexual proclivities, + repeatedly notes very thick hair, with down on the face. + (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, vol. xvi, fasc. iv-v.) + + Marro, also, in Italy found that abundance of hair and down is + especially marked in women who are guilty of infanticide (as also + Pasini has found), though criminal women generally, in his + experience, tend to have abnormally abundant hair. (_Caratteri + del Delinquenti_, cap. XXII.) Lombroso finds that prostitutes + generally tend to be hairy (_Donna Delinquente_, p. 320.) + + A lad of 14, guilty of numerous crimes of violence having a + sexual source, is described by Arthur Macdonald in America as + having hair on the chest as well as all over the pubes. (A. + Macdonald, _Archives de L'Anthropologie Criminelle_, January, + 1893, p. 55.) The association of hairiness with abnormal + sexuality in the weak-minded has been noted at Bicêtre + (_Recherches Cliniques sur l'Epilepsie_, vol. xix, pp. 69, 77.) + + Hypertrichosis universalis, a general hairiness of body, has been + described by Cascella in a woman with very strong sexual desires, + who eventually became insane. (_Revista Mensile di Psichiatria_, + 1903, p. 408.) Bucknill and Tuke give the case of a religiously + minded girl, with very strong and repressed sexual desires, who + became insane; the only abnormal feature in her physical + development was the marked growth of hair over the body. + + Brantôme refers to a great lady known to him whose body was very + hairy, and quotes a saying to the effect that hairy people are + either rich or wanton; the lady in question, he adds, was both. + (Brantôme, _Vie des Dames Galantes_, Discours II.) + + De Sade, whose writings are now regarded as a treasure house of + true observations in the domain of sexual psychology, makes the + Rodin of _Justine_ dark, with much hair and thick eyebrows, while + his very sexual sister is described as dark, thin and very hairy. + (Dühren, _Der Marquis de Sade_, third edition, p. 440.) + + A correspondent who has always taken a special interest in the + condition as regards hairiness of the women to whom he has been + attracted, has sent me notes concerning a series of 12 women. It + may be gathered from these notes that 5 women were neither + markedly sexual nor markedly hairy (either as regards head or + pubes), 6 cases both hairy and sexual, 1 was sexual and not + hairy, none were hairy and not sexual. My correspondent remarks: + "There may be women with scanty pubic hair possessing very strong + sexual emotions. My own experience is quite the opposite." He has + also independently reached the conclusion, arrived at by many + medical observers and clearly suggested by some of the facts here + brought together, that profuse hair frequently denotes a neurotic + temperament. + + It may be added that Mirabeau, as we learn from an anecdote told + by an eyewitness and recorded by Legouvé, had a very hairy chest, + while the same is recorded of Restif de la Bretonne. + +It is a very ancient and popular belief that if a hairy man is not sensual +he is strong: _vir pilosus aut libidinosus aut fortis_. The Greeks +insisted on the hairy nates of Hercules, and Ninon de l'Enclos, when the +great Condé shared her bed without touching her, remarked, on seeing his +hairy body: "Ah, Monseigneur, que vous devez être fort!" It may be doubted +whether there is any exact parallelism between muscular strength and +hairiness, for strength is largely a matter of training, but there can be +no doubt that hairiness really tends to be associated with a generally +vigorous development of the body. + +Although the observations concerning hairiness of body as an index of +vigor, whether sexual or only generally physical, are so ancient, until +recent years no attempts have been made to demonstrate on a large scale +whether there is actually a correlation between hairiness and sexual or +general development of the body. Some importance, therefore, attaches to +Ammon's careful observations of many thousand conscripts in Baden. These +observations fully justify this ancient belief, since they show that on +the one hand the size of the testicles, and on the other hand girth of +chest and stature, are correlated with hairiness of body. + + Ammon's observations were made on nearly 4000 conscripts of the + age of 20. From the point of view of the hairy system he divided + them, into four classes:-- + + I. To which 6.1 per cent, of the men belonged, with smooth + bodies. + + II. Including 25.3 per cent., only slight hairiness. + + III. 53.8 per cent., more developed hairy system, but belly, + breast and back smooth. + + IV. 14.7 per cent., hair all over body. + + V. 0.1 per cent., extreme cases of hairiness. + + The beardless were 12.1 per cent., those with no axillary hair 9 + per cent., those with no hair on pubis 0.4 per cent. This + corresponds with the fact that hair appears first on the pubis + and last on the chin. + + In the first class 69 per cent, were beardless, 54 per cent, + without any axillary hair and 6 per cent, without pubic hair. In + the second class 24 per cent, were beardless, 17 per cent, + without axillary hair. In the third class 3 per cent, were + beardless and 3 per cent without axillary hair. + + Below puberty the diameter of testicles is below 14 millimeters. + There were 13 conscripts having a testicular diameter of less + than 14 millimeters. These infantile individuals all belonged to + the first three classes and mostly to the first. The average + testicular diameter in the first class was nearly 24 millimeters, + and progressively rose in the succeeding classes to over 26 + millimeters in the fourth. + + While there was not much difference in height, the first class + was the shortest, the fourth the tallest. The fourth class also + showed the greatest chest perimeter. The cephalic index of all + classes was 84. (O. Ammon, "L'Infantilisme et le Feminisme au + Conseil de Révision," _L'Anthropologie_, May-June, 1896.) + +We thus see that it is quite justifiable to admit a type of person who +possesses a more than average aptitude for detumescence. Such persons are +more likely to be short than tall; they will show a full development of +the secondary sexual characters; the voice will tend to be deep and the +eyes bright; the glandular activity of the skin will probably be marked, +the lips everted; there is a tendency to a more than average degree of +pigmentation, and there is frequently an abnormal prevalence of hair on +some parts of the body. While none of these signs, taken separately, can +be said to have any necessary connection with the sexual impulse, taken +altogether they indicate an organism that responds to the instinct of +detumescence with special aptitude or with marked energy. In these +respects observation, both scientific and popular, concords with the +probabilities suggested by the three standards in this matter which have +already been set forth. + +No generalization, however, can here be set down in an absolute and +unqualified manner. There are definite reasons why this should be so. +There is, for instance, the highly important consideration that the sexual +impulse of the individual may be conspicuous in two quite distinct ways. +It may assume prominence because the individual possesses a highly +vigorous and well-nourished organism, or its prominence may be due to +mental irritation in a very morbid individual. In the latter +case--although occasionally the two sets of conditions are combined--most +of the signs we might expect in the former case may be absent. Indeed, the +sexual impulses which proceed from a morbid psychic irritability do not in +most cases indicate any special aptitude for detumescence at all; in that +largely lies their morbid character. + +Again, just in the same way that the exaggerated impulse itself may either +be healthy or morbid, so the various characters which we have found to +possess some value as signs of the impulse may themselves either be +healthy or morbid. This is notably the case as regards an abnormal growth +of hair on the body, more especially when it appears on regions where +normally there is little or no hair. Such hypertrichosis is frequently +degenerative in character, though still often associated with the sexual +system. When, however, it is thus a degenerative character of sexual +nature, having its origin in some abnormal foetal condition or later +atrophy of the ovaries, it is no necessary indication of any aptitude for +detumescence. + + Idiots, more especially it would seem idiot girls, tend to show a + highly developed hairy system. Thus Voisin, when investigating + 150 idiot and imbecile girls, found the hair long and thick and + tending to occupy a large surface; one girl had hair on the + areolæ of the mamma. (J. Voisin, "Conformation des organes + génitaux chez les Idiots," _Annales d'Hygiène Publique_, June, + 1894.) It should be said that in idiot boys puberty is late, and + the sexual organs as well as the sexual instinct frequently + undeveloped, while in idiot girls there is no delay in puberty, + and the sexual organs and instinct are frequently fully and even + abnormally developed. + + Hegar has described an interesting case showing an association, + of foetal origin, between sexual anomaly and abnormal hairness. + In this case a girl of 16 had a uterus duplex, an infantile + pelvis, very slight menstruation and undeveloped breasts. She was + very hairy on the face, the anterior aspects of the chest and + abdomen, the sexual regions, and the thighs, but not specially so + on the rest of the body. The hairs were of lanugo-like character, + but dark in color. (A. Hegar, _Beiträge zur Geburtshülfe und + Gynäkologie_, vol. i, p. III, 1898.) Sometimes hiruties of the + face and abdomen begin to appear during pregnancy, apparently + from disease or degeneration of the ovaries. (A case is noted in + _British Medical Journal_, August 2 and 16, pp. 375 and 436, + 1902.) Laycock many years ago referred to the popular belief that + women who have hair on the upper lip seldom bear children, and + regarded this opinion as "questionless founded on fact." + (Laycock, _Nervous Diseases of Women_, p. 22.) When this is so, + we may suppose that the abnormal hairy growth is associated with + degeneration of the ovaries. + +There is another factor which enters into this question and renders the +definition of a physical sexual type less precise than it would otherwise +be. The sexual instinct is common to all persons, and while it seems +probable that there is a type of person in whom sexual energies are +predominant, it would also appear that the people who otherwise show a +very high level of energy in life usually exhibit a more than average +degree of energy in matters of love. The predominantly sexual type, as we +have seen, tends to be associated with a high degree of pigmentation; the +person specially apt for detumescence inclines to belong to the dark +rather than to the purely fair group of the population. On the other hand, +the active, energetic, practical man, the man who is most apt for the +achievement of success in life, tends to belong to the fair rather than to +the dark type.[168] Thus we have a certain conflict of tendencies, and it +becomes possible to assert that while persons with pronounced aptitude for +sexual detumescence tend to be dark, persons whose pronounced energy in +sexual matters tends to ensure success are most likely to be fair. + + The tendency of the fair energetic type, the type of the northern + European man, to sexuality may be connected with the fact that + the violent and criminal man who commits sexual crimes tends to + be fair even amid a dark population. Criminals on the whole would + appear to tend to be dark rather than fair; but Marro found in + Italy that the group of sexual offenders differed from all other + groups of criminals in that their hair was predominantly fair. + (_Caratteri del Delinquenti_, p. 374.) Ottolenghi, in the same + way, in examining 100 sexual offenders, found that they showed 17 + per cent., of fair hair, though criminals generally (on a basis + of nearly 2000) showed only 6 per cent., and normal persons + (nearly 1000) 9 per cent. Similarly while the normal persons + showed only 20 per cent. of blue eyes and criminals generally 36 + per cent., the sexual offenders showed 50 per cent. of blue eyes. + (Ottolenghi, _Archivio di Psichiatria_, fasc. vi, 1888, p. 573.) + Burton remarked (_Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, + Mem. II, Subs. II) that in all ages most amorous young men have + been yellow-haired, adding, "Synesius holds every effeminate + fellow or adulterer is fair-haired." In folk-lore, it has been + noted (Kryptadia, vol. ii, p. 258), red or yellow hair is + sometimes regarded as a mark of sexuality. + + In harmony with this fairness, sexual offenders would appear to + be more dolichocephalic than other criminals. In Italy Marro + found the foreheads of sexual offenders to be narrow, and in + California Drähms found that while murderers had an average + cephalic index of 83.5, and thieves of 80.5, that of sexual + offenders was 79. + + On the other hand, high cheek-bones and broad faces--a condition + most usually found associated with brachycephaly--have sometimes + been noted as associated with undue or violent sexuality. Marro + noted the excess of prominent cheek-bones in sexual offenders, + and in America it has been found that unchaste girls tend to have + broad faces. (_Pedagogical Seminary_, December, 1896, pp. 231, + 235.) + +It will be seen that, when we take a comprehensive view of the facts and +considerations involved, it is possible to obtain a more definite and +coherent picture of the physical signs of a marked aptitude for +detumescence than has hitherto been usually supposed possible. But we also +see that while the _ensemble_ of these signs is probably fairly reliable +as an index of marked sexuality, the separate signs have no such definite +significance, and under some circumstances their significance may even be +reversed. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[144] See Biérent, _La Puberté_; Marro, _La Pubertà _ (and enlarged French +translation, _La Puberté_), and portions of G.S. Hall's _Adolescence_; +also Havelock Ellis, _Man and Woman_ (fourth edition, revised and +enlarged). + +[145] Adler, _Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, p. 174; +Moll, "Perverse Sexualempfindung, Psychische Impotenz und Ehe" (Section +II), in Senator and Kaminer, _Krankheiten und Ehe_. + +[146] Roubaud, _Traité de l'Impuissance_, p. 524. + +[147] Marro, _Caratteri del Delinquenti_, p. 374. + +[148] Kryptadia, vol. ii, p. 258. + +[149] Marro, _La Pubertà _, p. 196. In Italy, the sensuality of the lame is +the subject of proverbs. + +[150] _Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1896, p. 515; Kryptadia, vol. vi, p. 212. + +[151] Blumenbach, _Anthropological Treatises_, p. 248. + +[152] Biérent, _La Puberté_, p. 148. + +[153] Venturi, _Degenerazioni Psico-sessuali_, pp. 408-410. + +[154] _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. II, Sub. II. + +[155] _British Gynæcological Journal_, February, 1887, p. 505. + +[156] Power, _Lancet_, November 26, 1887. + +[157] With regard to the sexual relationships of personal odor, see the +previous volume of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection in Man," section on +Smell. + +[158] In European folk-lore thick lips in a woman are sometimes regarded +as a sign of sensuality, Kryptadia, vol. ii, p, 258. + +[159] The direct dependence of sexual pigmentation on the primary sexual +glands is well illustrated by a true hermaphroditic adult finch exhibited +at the Academy of Sciences of Amsterdam (May 31, 1890); this bird had a +testis on the right side and an ovary on the left, and on the right side +its plumage was of the male's colors, on the left of the female's color. + +[160] See. e.g., Papillault, _Bulletin Société d'Anthropologie_, 1899, p. +446. + +[161] Guinard, Art. "Castration," Richet's _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_. + +[162] J. Whitridge Williams, _Obstetrics_, 1903, p. 132. + +[163] _Zeitschrift für Ethnologie_, 1878, p. 19. + +[164] C. Pitre, _Medicina Populare Siciliana_, p. 47. In England, from +notes sent to me by one correspondent, it would appear that the proportion +of dark and sexually apt women to fair and sexually apt women is as 3 to +1. The experience of others would doubtless give varying results, and in +any case the fallacies are numerous. See, in the previous volume of these +_Studies_, "Sexual Selection in Man," Section IV. + +[165] In Japan the same belief would appear to be held. In a nude figure +representing the typical voluptuous woman by the Japanese painter Marugama +Okio (reproduced in Ploss's _Das Weib_) the pubic and axillary hair is +profuse, though usually sparse in Japan. + +[166] _Centralblatt für Gynäkologie_, No. 9, 1896. + +[167] It is important to remember that there is little correlation in this +matter between the hair of the head and the sexual hair, if not a certain +opposition. (See _ante_, p. 127.) According to one of the aphorisms of +Hippocrates, repeated by Buffon, eunuchs do not become bald, and Aristotle +seems to have believed that sexual intercourse is a cause of baldness in +men. (Laycock, _Nervous Diseases of Women_, p. 23.) + +[168] For some of the evidence on this point, see Havelock Ellis, "The +Comparative Abilities of the Fair and the Dark," _Monthly Review_, August, +1901; cf. id., _A Study of British Genius_, Chapter X. + + + + +THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY. + +The Relationship of Maternal and Sexual Emotion--Conception and Loss of +Virginity--The Anciently Accepted Signs of This Condition--The Pervading +Effects of Pregnancy on the Organism--Pigmentation--The Blood and +Circulation--The Thyroid--Changes in the Nervous System--The Vomiting of +Pregnancy--The Longings of Pregnant Women--Maternal Impressions--Evidence +for and Against Their Validity--The Question Still Open--Imperfection of +Our Knowledge--The Significance of Pregnancy. + + +In analyzing the sexual impulse I have so far deliberately kept out of +view the maternal instinct. This is necessary, for the maternal instinct +is specific and distinct; it is directed to an aim which, however +intimately associated it may be with that of the sexual impulse proper, +can by no means be confounded with it. Yet the emotion of love, as it has +finally developed in the world, is not purely of sexual origin; it is +partly sexual, but it is also partly parental.[169] + +In so far as it is parental it is certainly mainly maternal. There is a +drawing by Bronzino in the Louvre of a woman's head gazing tenderly down +at some invisible object; is it her child or her lover? Doubtless her +child, yet the expression is equally adequate to the emotion evoked by a +lover. If we were here specifically dealing with the emotion of love as a +complex whole, and not with the psychology of the sexual impulse, it would +certainly be necessary to discuss the maternal instinct and its associated +emotions. In any case it seems desirable to touch on the psychic state of +pregnancy, for we are here concerned not only with emotions very closely +connected with the sexual emotions in the narrower sense, but we here at +last approach that state which it is the object of the whole sexual +process to achieve. + +In civilized life a period of weeks, months, even years, may elapse +between the establishment of sexual relations and the occurrence of +conception. Under primitive conditions the loss of the virginal condition +practically involves the pregnant condition, so that under primitive +conditions very little allowance is made for the state, so common among +civilized peoples, of the woman who is no longer a virgin, yet not about +to become a mother. + + There is some interest in noting the signs of loss of virginity + chiefly relied upon by ancient authors. In doing this it is + convenient to follow mainly the full summary of authorities given + by Schurig in his _Barthenologia_ early in the eighteenth + century. The ancient custom, known in classic times, of measuring + the neck the day after marriage was frequently practiced to + ascertain if a girl was or was not a virgin. There were various + ways of doing this. One was to measure with a thread the + circumference of the bride's neck before she went to bed on the + bridal night. If in the morning the same thread would not go + around her neck it was a sure sign that she had lost her + virginity during the night; if not, she was still a virgin or had + been deflowered at an earlier period. Catullus alluded to this + custom, which still exists, or existed until lately, in the south + of France. It is perfectly sound, for it rests on the intimate + response by congestion of the thyroid gland to sexual excitement. + (_Parthenologia_, p. 283; Biérent, _La Puberté_, p. 150; Havelock + Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, p. 267.) + + Some say, Schurig tells us, that the voice, which in the virgin + is shrill, becomes rougher and deeper after the first coitus. He + quotes Riolan's statement that it is certain that the voice of + those who indulge in venery is changed. On that account the + ancients bound down the penis of their singers, and Martial said + that those who wish to preserve their voices should avoid coitus. + Democritus who one day had greeted a girl as "maiden" on the + following day addressed her as "woman," while in the same way it + is said that Albertus Magnus, observing from his study a girl + going for wine for her master, knew that she had had sexual + intercourse by the way because on her return her voice had become + deeper. Here, again, the ancient belief has a solid basis, for + the voice and the larynx are really affected by sexual + conditions. (_Parthenologia_, p. 286; Marro, _La Puberté_, p. + 303; Havelock Ellis, op. cit., pp. 271, 289.) + + Others, again, Schurig proceeds, have judged that the goaty smell + given out in the armpits during the venereal act is also no + uncertain sign of defloration, such odor being perceptible in + those who use much venery, and not seldom in harlots and the + newly married, while, as Hippocrates said, it is not perceived in + boys and girls. (_Parthenologia_, p. 286; cf. the previous volume + of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection in Man," p. 64.) + + In virgins, Schurig remarks, the pubic hair is said to be long + and not twisted, while in women accustomed to coitus it is + crisper. But it is only after long and repeated coitus, some + authors add, that the pubic hairs become crisp. Some recent + observers, it may be remarked, have noted a connection between + sexual excitation and the condition of the pubic hair in women. + (Cf. the present volume, _ante_ p. 127.) + + A sign to which the old authors often attached much importance + was furnished by the urinary stream. In the _De Secretis + Mulierum_, wrongly attributed to Albertus Magnus, it is laid down + that "the virgin urinates higher than the woman." Riolan, in his + _Anthropographia_, discussing the ability of virgins to ejaculate + urine to a height, states that Scaliger had observed women who + were virgins emit urine in a high jet against a wall, but that + married women could seldom do this. Bouaciolus also stated that + the urine of virgins is emitted in a small stream to a distance + with an acute hissing sound. (_Parthenologia_, p. 281.) A + folk-lore belief in the reality of this influence is evidenced by + the Picardy _conte_ referred to already (_ante_, p. 53), "La + Princesse qui pisse au dessus les Meules." There is no doubt a + tendency for the various stresses of sexual life to produce an + influence in this direction, though they act far too slowly and + uncertainly to be a reliable index to the presence or the absence + of virginity. + + Another common ancient test of virginity by urination rests on a + psychic basis, and appears in a variety of forms which are really + all reducible to the same principle. Thus we are told in _De + Secretis Mulierum_ that to ascertain if a girl is seduced she + should be given to eat of powdered crocus flowers, and if she has + been seduced she immediately urinates. We are here concerned with + auto-suggestion, and it may well be believed that with nervous + and credulous girls this test often revealed the truth. + + A further test of virginity discussed by Schurig is the presence + of modesty of countenance. If a woman blushes her virtue is safe. + In this way girls who have themselves had experience of the + marriage bed are said to detect the virgin. The virgin's eyes are + cast down and almost motionless, while she who has known a man + has eyes that are bright and quick. But this sign is equivocal, + says Schurig, for girls are different, and can simulate the + modesty they do not feel. Yet this indication also rests on a + fundamentally sound psychological basis. (See "The Evolution of + Modesty," in the first volume of these _Studies_.) + + In his _Syllepsilogia_ (Section V, cap. I-II), published in 1731, + Schurig discusses further the anciently recognized signs of + pregnancy. The real or imaginary signs of pregnancy sought by + various primitive peoples of the past and present are brought + together by Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, bd. i, Chapter XXVII. + +Both physically and psychically the occurrence of pregnancy is, however, a +distinct event. It marks the beginning of a continuous physical process, +which cannot fail to manifest psychic reactions. A great center of vital +activity--practically a new center, for only the germinal form of it in +menstruation had previously existed--has appeared and affects the whole +organism. "From the moment that the embryo takes possession of the woman," +Robert Barnes puts it, "every drop of blood, every fiber, every organ, is +affected."[170] + +A woman artist once observed to Dr. Stratz, that as the final aim of a +woman is to become a mother and pregnancy is thus her blossoming time, a +beautiful woman ought to be most beautiful when she is pregnant. That is +so, Stratz replied, if her moment of greatest physical perfection +corresponds with the early months of pregnancy, for with the beginning of +pregnancy metabolism is increased, the color of the skin becomes more +lively and delicate, the breasts firmer.[171] Pregnancy may, indeed, often +become visible soon after conception by the brighter eye, the livelier +glance, resulting from greater vascular activity, though later, with the +increase of strain, the face may tend to become somewhat thin and +distorted. The hair, Barnes states, assumes a new vigor, even though it +may have been falling out before. The temperature rises; the weight +increases, even apart from the growth of the foetus. The efflorescence of +pregnancy shows itself, as in the blossoming and fecundated flower, by +increased pigmentation.[172] The nipples with their areolæ, and the +mid-line of the belly, become darker; brown flecks (lentigo) tend to +appear on the forehead, neck, arms, and body; while striæ--at first +blue-red, then a brilliant white--appear on the belly and thighs, though +these are scarcely normal, for they are not seen in women with very +elastic skins and are rare among peasants and savages.[173] The whole +carriage of the woman tends to become changed with the development of the +mighty seed of man planted within her; it simulates the carriage of pride +with the arched back and protruded abdomen.[174] The pregnant woman has +been lifted above the level of ordinary humanity to become the casket of +an inestimable jewel. + +It is in the blood and the circulation that the earliest of the most +prominent symptoms of pregnancy are to be found. The ever increasing +development of this new focus of vascular activity involves an increased +vascular activity in the whole organism. This activity is present almost +from the first--a few days after the impregnation of the ovum--in the +breasts, and quickly becomes obvious to inspection and palpation. Before a +quite passive organ, the breast now rapidly increases in activity of +circulation and in size, while certain characteristic changes begin to +take place around the nipples.[175] As a result of the additional work +imposed upon it the heart tends to become slightly hypertrophied in order +to meet the additional strain; there may be some dilatation also.[176] + + The recent investigations of Stengel and Stanton tend to show + that the increase of the heart's work during pregnancy is less + considerable than has generally been supposed, and that beyond + some enlargement and dilatation of the right ventricle there is + not usually any hypertrophy of the heart. + +The total quantity of blood is raised. While increased in quantity, the +blood appears on the whole to be somewhat depreciated in quality, though +on this point there are considerable differences of opinion. Thus, as +regards hæmoglobin, some investigators have found that the old idea as to +the poverty of hæmoglobin in pregnancy is quite unfounded; a few have even +found that the hæmoglobin is increased. Most authorities have found the +red cells diminished, though some only slightly, while the white cells, +and also the fibrin, are increased. But toward the end of pregnancy there +is a tendency, perhaps due to the establishment of compensation, for the +blood to revert to the normal condition.[177] + +It would appear probable, however, that the vascular phenomena of +pregnancy are not altogether so simple as the above statement would imply. +The activity of various glands at this time--well illustrated by the +marked salivation which sometimes occurs--indicates that other modifying +forces are at work, and it has been suggested that the changes in the +maternal circulation during pregnancy may best be explained by the theory +that there are two opposing kinds of secretion poured into the blood in +unusual degree during pregnancy: one contracting the vessels, the other +dilating them, one or the other sometimes gaining the upper hand. +Suprarenal extract, when administered, has a vaso-constricting influence, +and thyroid extract a vasodilating influence; it may be surmised that +within the body these glands perform similar functions.[178] + +The important part played by the thyroid gland is indicated by its marked +activity at the very beginning of pregnancy. We may probably associate the +general tendency to vasodilatation during early pregnancy with the +tendency to goitre; Freund found an increase of the thyroid in 45 per +cent. of 50 cases. The thyroid belongs to the same class of ductless +glands as the ovary, and, as Bland Sutton and others have insisted, the +analogies between the thyroid and the ovary are very numerous and +significant. It may be added that in recent years Armand Gautier has noted +the importance of the thyroid in elaborating nucleo-proteids containing +arsenic and iodine, which are poured into the circulation during +menstruation and pregnancy. The whole metabolism of the body is indeed +affected, and during the latter part of pregnancy study of the ingesta and +egesta has shown that a storage of nitrogen and even of water is taking +place.[179] The woman, as Pinard puts it, forms the child out of her own +flesh, not merely out of her food; the individual is being sacrificed to +the species. + +The changes in the nervous system of the pregnant woman correspond to +those in the vascular system. There is the same increase of activity, a +heightening of tension. Bruno Wolff, from experiments on bitches, +concluded that the central nervous system in women is probably more easily +excited in the pregnant than in the non-pregnant state, though he was not +prepared to call this cerebral excitability "specific."[180] Direct +observations on pregnant women have shown, without doubt, a heightened +nervous irritability. Reflex action generally is increased. Neumann +investigated the knee-jerk in 500 women during pregnancy, labor, and the +puerperium, and in a large number found that there was a progressive +exaggeration with the advance of pregnancy, little or no change being +observed in the early months; sometimes when no change was observed during +pregnancy the knee-jerk still increased during labor, reaching its maximum +at the moment of the expulsion of the foetus; the return to the normal +condition took place gradually during the puerperium. Tridandani found in +pregnant women that though the superficial reflexes, with the exception of +the abdominal, were diminished, the deep and tendon reflexes were markedly +increased, especially that of the knee, these changes being more marked in +primiparæ than in multiparæ, and more pronounced as pregnancy advanced, +the normal condition returning with ten days after labor. Electrical +excitability was sensibly diminished.[181] + +One of the first signs of high nervous tension is vomiting. As is well +known, this phenomenon commonly appears early in pregnancy, and it is by +many considered entirely physiological. Barnes regards it as a kind of +safety valve, a regulating function, letting off excessive tension and +maintaining equilibrium.[182] Vomiting is, however, a convulsion, and is +thus the simplest form of a kind of manifestation--to which the heightened +nervous tension of pregnancy easily lends itself--that finds its extreme +pathological form in eclampsia. In this connection it is of interest to +point out that the pregnant woman here manifests in the highest degree a +tendency which is marked in women generally, for the female sex, apart +altogether from pregnancy, is specially liable to convulsive +phenomena.[183] + + There is some slight difference of opinion among authorities as + to the precise nature and causation of the sickness of pregnancy. + Barnes, Horrocks and others regard it as physiological; but many + consider it pathological; this is, for instance, the opinion of + Giles. Graily Hewitt attributed it to flexion of the gravid + uterus, Kaltenbach to hysteria, and Zaborsky terms it a neurosis. + Whitridge Williams considers that it may be (1) reflex, or (2) + neurotic (when it is allied to hysteria and amenable to + suggestion), or (3) toxæmic. It really appears to lie on the + borderland between healthy and diseased manifestations. It is + said to be unknown to farmers and veterinary surgeons. It appears + to be little known among savages; it is comparatively infrequent + among women of the lower social classes, and, as Giles has found, + women who habitually menstruate in a painless and normal manner + suffer comparatively little from the sickness of pregnancy. + + We owe a valuable study of the sickness of pregnancy to Giles, + who analyzed the records of 300 cases. He concluded that about + one-third of the pregnant women were free from sickness + throughout pregnancy, 45 per cent. were free during the first + three months. When sickness occurred it began in 70 per cent. of + cases in the first month, and was most frequent during the second + month. The duration varied from a few days to all through. + Between the ages of 20 and 25 sickness was least frequent, and + there was less sickness in the third than in any other pregnancy. + (This corresponds with the conclusion of Matthews Duncan that 25 + is the most favorable age for pregnancy.) To some extent in + agreement with Guéniot, Giles believes that the vomiting of + pregnancy is "one form of manifestation of the high nervous + irritability of pregnancy." This high nervous tension may + overflow into other channels, into the vascular and excretory + system, causing eclampsia; into the muscular system, causing + chorea, or, expending itself in the brain, give rise to hysteria + when mild or insanity when severe. But the vagi form a very ready + channel for such overflow, and hence the frequency of sickness in + pregnancy. There are thus three main factors in the causation of + this phenomenon: (1) An increased nervous irritability; (2) a + local source of irritation; (3) a ready efferent channel for + nervous energy. (Arthur Giles, "Observations on the Etiology of + the Sickness of Pregnancy," _Transactions Obstetrical Society of + London_, vol. xxv, 1894.) + + Martin, who regards the phenomenon as normal, points out that + when nausea and vomiting are absent or suddenly cease there is + often reason to suspect something wrong, especially the death of + the embryo. He also remarks that women who suffer from large + varicose veins are seldom troubled by the nausea of pregnancy. + (J.M.H. Martin, "The Vomiting of Pregnancy," _British Medical + Journal_, December 10, 1904.) These observations may be connected + with those of Evans (_American Gynæcological and Obstetrical + Journal_, January, 1900), who attributes primary importance to + the undoubtedly active factor of the irritation set up by the + uterus, more especially the rhythmic uterine contractions; + stimulation of the breasts produces active uterine contractions, + and Evans found that examination of the breasts sufficed to bring + on a severe attack of vomiting, while on another occasion this + was produced by a vaginal examination. Evans believes that the + purpose of these contractions is to facilitate the circulation of + the blood through the large venous sinuses, the surcharging of + the relatively stagnant pools with effete blood producing the + irritation which leads to rhythmic contractions. + +It is on the basis of the increased vascular and glandular activity and +the heightened nervous tension that the special psychic phenomena of +pregnancy develop. The best known, and perhaps the most characteristic of +these manifestations, is that known as "longings." By this term is meant +more or less irresistible desires for some special food or drink, which +may be digestible or indigestible, sometimes a substance which the woman +ordinarily likes, such as fruit, and occasionally one which, under +ordinary circumstances, she dislikes, as in one case known to me of a +young country woman who, when bearing her child, was always longing for +tobacco and never happy except when she could get a pipe to smoke, +although under ordinary circumstances, like other young women of her +class, she was without any desire to smoke. Occasionally the longings lead +to actions which are more unscrupulous than is common in the case of the +same person at other times; thus in one case known to me a young woman, +pregnant with her first child, insisted to her sister's horror on entering +a strawberry field and eating a quantity of fruit. These "longings" in +their extreme form may properly be considered as neurasthenic obsessions, +but in their simple and less pronounced forms they may well be normal and +healthy. + + The old medical authors abound in narratives describing the + longings of pregnant women for natural and unnatural foods. This + affection was commonly called _pica_, sometimes _citra_ or + _malatia_. Schurig, whose works are a comprehensive treasure + house of ancient medical lore, devotes a long chapter (cap. II) + of his _Chylologia_, published in 1725, to pica as manifested + mainly, though not exclusively, in pregnant women. Some women, he + tells us, have been compelled to eat all sorts of earthy + substances, of which sand seems the most common, and one Italian + woman when pregnant ate several pounds of sand with much + satisfaction, following it up with a draught of her own urine. + Lime, mud, chalk, charcoal, cinders, pitch are also the desired + substances in other cases detailed. One pregnant woman must eat + bread fresh from the oven in very large quantities, and a certain + noble matron ate 140 sweet cakes in one day and night. Wheat and + various kinds of corn as well as of vegetables were the foods + desired by many longing women. One woman was responsible for 20 + pounds of pepper, another ate ginger in large quantities, a third + kept mace under her pillow; cinnamon, salt, emulsion of almonds, + treacle, mushrooms were desired by others. Cherries were longed + for by one, and another ate 30 or 40 lemons in one night. Various + kinds of fish--mullet, oysters, crabs, live eels, etc.--are + mentioned, while other women have found delectation in lizards, + frogs, spiders and flies, even scorpions, lice and fleas. A + pregnant woman, aged 33, of sanguine temperament, ate a live fowl + completely with intense satisfaction. Skin, wool, cotton, thread, + linen, blotting paper have been desired, as well as more + repulsive substances, such as nasal mucus and feces (eaten with + bread). Vinegar, ice, and snow occur in other cases. One woman + stilled a desire for human flesh by biting the nates of children + or the arms of men. Metals are also swallowed, such as iron, + silver, etc. One pregnant woman wished to throw eggs in her + husband's face, and another to have her husband throw eggs in her + face. + + In the next chapter of the same work Schurig describes cases of + acute antipathy which may arise under the same circumstances + (cap. III, "De Nausea seu Antipathia certorum ciborum"). The list + includes bread, meat, fowls, fish, eels (a very common + repulsion), crabs, milk, butter (very often), cheese (often), + honey, sugar, salt, eggs, caviar, sulphur, apples (especially + their odor), strawberries, mulberries, cinnamon, mace, capers, + pepper, onions, mustard, beetroot, rice, mint, absinthe, roses + (many pages are devoted to this antipathy), lilies, elder + flowers, musk (which sometimes caused vomiting), amber, coffee, + opiates, olive oil, vinegar, cats, frogs, spiders, wasps, swords. + + More recently Gould and Pyle (_Anomalies and Curiosities of + Medicine_, p. 80) have briefly summarized some of the ancient and + modern records concerning the longings of pregnant women. + +Various theories are put forward concerning the causation of the longings +of pregnant women, but none of these seems to furnish by itself a complete +and adequate explanation of all cases. Thus it is said that the craving is +the expression of a natural instinct, the system of the pregnant woman +really requiring the food she longs for. It is quite probable that this is +so in many cases, but it is obviously not so in the majority of cases, +even when we confine ourselves to the longings for fairly natural foods, +while we know so little of the special needs of the organism during +pregnancy that the theory in any case is insusceptible of clear +demonstration. + +Allied to this theory is the explanation that the longings are for things +that counteract the tendency to nausea and sickness. Giles, however, in +his valuable statistical study of the longings of a series of 300 pregnant +women, has shown that the percentage of women with longings is exactly the +same (33 per cent.) among women who had suffered at some time during +pregnancy from sickness as among the women who had not so suffered. +Moreover, Giles found that the period of sickness frequently bore no +relation to the time when there were cravings, and the patient often had +cravings after the sickness had ceased. + +According to another theory these longings are mainly a matter of +auto-suggestion. The pregnant woman has received the tradition of such +longings, persuades herself that she has such a longing, and then becomes +convinced that, according to a popular belief, it will be bad for the +child if the longing is not gratified. Giles considers that this process +of auto-suggestion takes place "in a certain number, perhaps even in the +majority of cases."[184] + + The Duchess d'Abrantès, the wife of Marshal Junot, in her + _Mémoires_ gives an amusing account of how in her first pregnancy + a longing was apparently imposed upon her by the anxious + solicitude of her own and her husband's relations. Though + suffering from constant nausea and sickness, she had no longings. + One day at dinner after the pregnancy had gone on for some months + her mother suddenly put down her fork, exclaiming: "I have never + asked you what longing you have!" She replied with truth that she + had none, her days and her nights being occupied with suffering. + "No _envie!_" said the mother, "such a thing was never heard of. + I must speak to your mother-in-law." The two old ladies consulted + anxiously and explained to the young mother how an unsatisfied + longing might produce a monstrous child, and the husband also now + began to ask her every day what she longed for. Her + sister-in-law, moreover, brought her all sorts of stories of + children born with appalling mother's marks due to this cause. + She became frightened and began to wonder what she most wanted, + but could think of nothing. At last, when eating a pastille + flavored with pineapple, it occurred to her that pineapple is an + excellent fruit, and one, moreover, which she had never seen, for + at that time it was extremely rare. Thereupon she began to long + for pineapple, and all the more when she was told that at that + season they could not be obtained. She now began to feel that she + must have pineapple or die, and her husband ran all over Paris, + vainly offering twenty louis for a pineapple. At last he + succeeded in obtaining one through the kindness of Mme. + Bonaparte, and drove home furiously just as his wife, always + talking of pineapples, had gone to bed. He entered the room with + the pineapple, to the great satisfaction of the Duchess's mother. + (In one of her own pregnancies, it appears, she longed in vain + for cherries in January, and the child was born with a mark on + her body resembling a cherry--in scientific terminology, a + _nævus_.) The Duchess effusively thanked her husband and wished + to eat of the fruit immediately, but her husband stopped her and + said that Corvisart, the famous physician, had told him that she + must on no account touch it at night, as it was extremely + indigestible. She promised not to do so, and spent the night in + caressing the pineapple. In the morning the husband came and cut + up the fruit, presenting it to her in a porcelain bowl. Suddenly, + however, there was a revulsion of feeling; she felt that she + could not possibly eat pineapple; persuasion was useless; the + fruit had to be taken away and the windows opened, for the very + smell of it had become odious. The Duchess adds that henceforth, + throughout her life, though still liking the flavor, she was only + able to eat pineapple by doing a sort of violence to herself. + (_Mémories de la Duchesse d'Abrantès_, vol. iii, Chapter VIII.) + It should be added that, in old age, the Duchess d'Abrantès + appears to have become insane. + +The influence of suggestion must certainly be accepted as, at all events, +increasing and emphasizing the tendency to longings. It can scarcely, +however, be regarded as a radical and adequate explanation of the +phenomenon generally. If it is a matter of auto-suggestion due to a +tradition, then we should expect to find longings most frequent and most +pronounced in multiparous women, who are best acquainted with the +tradition and best able to experience all that is expected of a pregnant +woman. But, as a matter of fact, the women who have borne most children +are precisely those who are least likely to be affected by the longings +which tradition demands they should manifest. Giles has shown that +longings occur much more frequently in the first than in any subsequent +pregnancy; there is a regular decrease with the increase in number of +pregnancies until in women with ten or more children the longings scarcely +occur at all. + +We must probably regard longings as based on a physiological and psychic +tendency which is of universal extension and almost or quite normal. They +are known throughout Europe and were known to the medical writers of +antiquity. Old Indian as well as old Jewish physicians recognized them. +They have been noted among many savage races to-day: among the Indians of +North and South America, among the peoples of the Nile and the Soudan, in +the Malay archipelago.[185] In Europe they are most common among the +women of the people, living simple and natural lives.[186] + +The true normal relationship of the longings of pregnancy is with the +impulsive and often irresistible longings for food delicacies which are +apt to overcome children, and in girls often persist or revive through +adolescence and even beyond. Such sudden fits of greediness belong to +those kind of normal psychic manifestations which are on the verge of the +abnormal into which they occasionally pass. They may occur, however, in +healthy, well-bred, and well-behaved children who, under the stress of the +sudden craving, will, without compunction and apparently without +reflection, steal the food they long for or even steal from their parents +the money to buy it. The food thus seized by a well-nigh irresistible +craving is nearly always a fruit. Fruit is usually doled out to children +in small quantities as a luxury, but we are descended from primitive human +peoples and still more remote ape-like ancestors, by whom fruit was in its +season eaten copiously, and it is not surprising that when that season +comes round the child, more sensitive than the adult to primitive +influences, should sometimes experience the impulse of its ancestors with +overwhelming intensity, all the more so if, as is probable, the craving is +to some extent the expression of a physiological need. + + Sanford Bell, who has investigated the food impulses of children + in America, finds that girls have a greater number of likes and + dislikes in foods than boys of the same age, though at the same + time they have less dislikes to some foods than boys. The + proclivity for sweets and fruits shows itself as soon as a child + begins to eat solids. The chief fruits liked are oranges, + bananas, apples, peaches, and pears. This strong preference for + fruits lasts till the age of 13 or 14, though relatively weaker + from 10 to 13. In girls, however, Bell notes the significant fact + from our present point of view that at mid-adolescence there is a + revived taste for sweets and fruits. He believes that the growth + of children in taste in foods recapitulates the experience of the + race. (S. Bell, "An Introductory Study of the Psychology of + Foods." _Pedagogical Seminary_, March, 1904.) + +The heightened nervous impressionability of pregnancy would appear to +arouse into activity those primitive impulses which are liable to occur in +childhood and in the unmarried girl continue to the nubile age. It is a +significant fact that the longings of pregnant women are mainly for fruit, +and notably for so wholesome a fruit as the apple, which may very well +have a beneficial effect on the system of the pregnant woman. Giles, in +his tabulation of the foods longed for by 300 pregnant women, found that +the fruit group was by far the largest, furnishing 79 cases; apples were +far away at the head, occurring in 34 cases out of the 99 who had +longings, while oranges followed at a distance (with 13 cases), and in the +vegetable group tomatoes came first (with 6 cases). Several women declared +"I could have lived on apples," "I was eating apples all day," "I used to +sit up in bed eating apples."[187] Pregnant women appear seldom to long +for the possession of objects outside the edible class, and it seems +doubtful whether they have any special tendency to kleptomania. Pinard has +pointed out that neither Lasègue nor Lunier, in their studies of +kleptomania, have mentioned a single shop robbery committed by a pregnant +woman.[188] Brouardel has indeed found such cases, but the object stolen +was usually a food. + +A further significant fact connecting the longings of pregnant women with +the longings of children is to be found in the fact that they occur mainly +in young women. We have, indeed, no tabulation of the ages of pregnant +women who have manifested longings, but Giles has clearly shown that these +chiefly occur in primiparæ, and steadily and rapidly decrease in each +successive pregnancy. This fact, otherwise somewhat difficult of +explanation, is natural if we look upon the longings of pregnancy as a +revival of those of childhood. It certainly indicates also that we can by +no means regard these longings as exclusively the expression of a +physiological craving, for in that case they would be liable to occur in +any pregnancy unless, indeed, it is argued that with each successive +pregnancy the woman becomes less sensitive to her own physiological state. + + There has been a frequent tendency, more especially among + primitive peoples, to regard a pregnant woman's longings as + something sacred and to be indulged, all the more, no doubt, as + they are usually of a simple and harmless character. In the Black + Forest, according to Ploss and Bartels, a pregnant woman may go + freely into other people's gardens and take fruit, provided she + eats it on the spot, and very similar privileges are accorded to + her elsewhere. Old English opinion, as reflected, for instance, + in Ben Jonson's plays (as Dr. Harriet C.B. Alexander has pointed + out), regards the pregnant woman as not responsible for her + longings, and Kiernan remarks ("Kleptomania and Collectivism," + _Alienist and Neurologist_, November, 1902) that this is in "a + most natural and just view." In France at the Revolution a law of + the 28th Germinal, in the year III, to some extent admitted the + irresponsibility of the pregnant woman generally,--following the + classic precedent, by which a woman could not be brought before a + court of justice so long as she was pregnant,--but the Napoleonic + code, never tender to women, abrogated this. Pinard does not + consider that the longings of pregnant women are irresistible, + and, consequently, regards the pregnant woman as responsible. + This is probably the view most widely held. In any case these + longings seldom come up for medico-legal consideration. + +The phenomena of the longings of pregnancy are linked to the much more +obscure and dubious phenomena of the influence of maternal impressions on +the child within the womb. It is true, indeed, that there is no real +connection whatever between these two groups of manifestations, but they +have been so widely and for so long closely associated in the popular mind +that it is convenient to pass directly from one to the other. The same +name is sometimes given to the two manifestations; thus in France a +pregnant longing is an _envie_, while a mother's mark on the child is also +called an _envie_, because it is supposed to be due to the mother's +unsatisfied longing. + +The conception of a "maternal impression" (the German _Versehen_) rests on +the belief that a powerful mental influence working on the mother's mind +may produce an impression, either general or definite, on the child she is +carrying. It makes a great deal of difference whether the effect of the +impression on the child is general, or definite and circumscribed. It is +not difficult to believe that a general effect--even, as Sir Arthur +Mitchell first gave good reason for believing, idiocy--may be produced on +the child by strong and prolonged emotional influence working on the +mother, because such general influence may be transmitted through a +deteriorated blood-stream. But it is impossible at present to understand +how a definite and limited influence working on the mother could produce a +definite and limited effect on the child, for there are no channels of +nervous communications for the passage of such influences. Our difficulty +in conceiving of the process must, however, be put aside if the fact +itself can be demonstrated by convincing evidence. + + In order to illustrate the nature of maternal impressions, I will + summarize a few cases which I have collected from the best + medical periodical literature during the past fifteen years. I + have exercised no selection and in no way guarantee the + authenticity of the alleged facts or the alleged explanation. + They are merely examples to illustrate a class of cases published + from time to time by medical observers in medical journals of + high repute. + + Early in pregnancy a woman found her pet rabbit killed by a cat + which had gnawed off the two forepaws, leaving ragged stumps; she + was for a long time constantly thinking of this. Her child was + born with deformed feet, one foot with only two toes, the other + three, the os calcis in both feet being either absent or little + developed. (G.B. Beale, Tottenham, _Lancet_, May 4, 1889). + + Three months and a half before birth of the child the father, a + glazier, fell through the roof of a hothouse, severely cutting + his right arm, so that he was lying in the infirmary for a long + time, and it was doubtful whether the hand could be saved. The + child was healthy, but on the flexor surface of the radial side + of the right forearm just above the wrist--the same spot as the + father's injury--there was a nævus the size of a sixpence. (W. + Russell, Paisley, _Lancet_, May 11, 1889.) + + At the beginning of pregnancy a woman was greatly scared by being + kicked over by a frightened cow she was milking; she hung on to + the animal's teats, but thought she would be trampled to death, + and was ill and nervous for weeks afterwards. The child was a + monster, with a fleshy substance--seeming to be prolonged from + the spinal cord and to represent the brain--projecting from the + floor of the skull. Both doctor and nurse were struck by the + resemblance to a cow's teats before they knew the woman's story, + and this was told by the woman immediately after delivery and + before she knew to what she had given birth. (A. Ross Paterson, + Reversby, Lincolnshire, _Lancet_, September 29, 1889.) + + During the second month of pregnancy the mother was terrified by + a bullock as she was returning from market. The child reached + full term and was a well-developed male, stillborn. Its head + "exactly resembled a miniature cow's head;" the occipital bone + was absent, the parietals only slightly developed, the eyes were + placed at the top of the frontal bone, which was quite flat, with + each of its superior angles twisted into a rudimentary horn. + (J.T. Hislop, Tavistock, Devon, _Lancet_, November 1, 1890.) + + When four months pregnant the mother, a multipara of 30, was + startled by a black and white collie dog suddenly pushing against + her and rushing out when she opened the door. This preyed on her + mind, and she felt sure her child would be marked. The whole of + the child's right thigh was encircled by a shining black mole, + studded with white hairs; there was another mole on the spine of + the left scapula. (C.F. Williamson, Horley, Surrey, _Lancet_, + October 11, 1890.) + + A lady in comfortable circumstances, aged 24, not markedly + emotional, with one child, in all respects healthy, early in her + pregnancy saw a man begging whose arms and legs were "all doubled + up." This gave her a shock, but she hoped no ill effects would + follow. The child was an encephalous monster, with the + extremities rigidly flexed and the fingers clenched, the feet + almost sole to sole. In the next pregnancy she frequently passed + a man who was a partial cripple, but she was not unduly + depressed; the child was a counterpart of the last, except that + the head was normal. The next child was strong and well formed. + (C.W. Chapman, London, _Lancet_, October 18, 1890.) + + When the pregnant mother was working in a hayfield her husband + threw at her a young hare he had found in the hay; it struck her + on the cheek and neck. Her daughter has on the left cheek an + oblong patch of soft dark hair, in color and character clearly + resembling the fur of a very young hare. (A. Mackay, Port Appin, + N.B., _Lancet_, December 19, 1891. The writer records also four + other cases which have happened in his experience.) + + When the mother was pregnant her husband had to attend to a sow + who could not give birth to her pigs; he bled her freely, cutting + a notch out of both ears. His wife insisted on seeing the sow. + The helix of each ear of her child at birth was gone, for nearly + or quite half an inch, as if cut purposely. (R.P. Roons, _Medical + World_, 1894.) + + A lady when pregnant was much interested in a story in which one + of the characters had a supernumerary digit, and this often + recurred to her mind. Her baby had a supernumerary digit on one + hand. (J. Jenkyns, Aberdeen, _British Medical Journal_, March 2, + 1895. The writer also records another case.) + + When pregnant the mother saw in the forest a new-born fawn which + was a double monstrosity. Her child was a similar double + monstrosity (_cephalothora copagus_). (Hartmann, _Münchener + Medicinisches Wochenschrift_, No. 9, 1895.) + + A well developed woman of 30, who had ten children in twelve + years, in the third month of her tenth pregnancy saw a child run + over by a street car, which crushed the upper and back part of + its head. Her own child was anencephalic and acranial, with + entire absence of vault of skull. (F.A. Stahl, _American Journal + of Obstetrics_, April, 1896.) + + A healthy woman with no skin blemish had during her third + pregnancy a violent appetite for sunfish. During or after the + fourth month her husband, as a surprise, brought her some sunfish + alive, placing them in a pail of water in the porch. She stumbled + against the pail and the shock caused the fish to flap over the + pail and come in violent contact with her leg. The cold wriggling + fish produced a nervous shock, but she attached no importance to + this. The child (a girl) had at birth a mark of bronze pigment + resembling a fish with the head uppermost (photograph given) on + the corresponding part of the same leg. Daughter's health good; + throughout life she has had a strong craving for sunfish, which + she has sometimes eaten till she has vomited from repletion. + (C.F. Gardiner, Colorado Springs, _American Journal Obstetrics_, + February, 1898.) + + The next case occurred in a bitch. A thoroughbred fox terrier + bitch strayed and was discovered a day or two later with her + right foreleg broken. The limb was set under chloroform with the + help of Röntgen rays, and the dog made a good recovery. Several + weeks later she gave birth to a puppy with a right foreleg that + was ill-developed and minus the paw. (J. Booth, Cork, _British + Medical Journal_, September 16, 1899.) + + Four months before the birth of her child a woman with four + healthy children and no history of deformity in the family fell + and cut her left wrist severely against a broken bowl; she had a + great fright and shock. Her child, otherwise perfect, was born + without left hand and wrist, the stump of arm terminating at + lower end of radius and ulna. (G. Ainslie Johnston, Ambleside, + _British Medical Journal_, April 18, 1903.) + +The belief in the reality of the transference of strong mental or physical +impressions on the mother into physical changes in the child she is +bearing is very ancient and widespread. Most writers on the subject begin +with the book of Genesis and the astute device of Jacob in influencing the +color of his lambs by mental impressions on his ewes. But the belief +exists among even more primitive people than the early Hebrews, and in all +parts of the world.[189] Among the Greeks there is a trace of the belief +in Hippocrates, the first of the world's great physicians, while Soranus, +the most famous of ancient gynæcologists, states the matter in the most +precise manner, with instances in proof. The belief continued to persist +unquestioned throughout the Middle Ages. The first author who denied the +influence of maternal impressions altogether appears to have been the +famous anatomist, Realdus Columbus, who was a professor at Padua, Pisa, +and Rome at the beginning of the sixteenth century. In the same century, +however, another and not less famous Neapolitan, Della Porta, for the +first time formulated a definite theory of maternal impressions. A little +later, early in the seventeenth century, a philosophic physician at Padua, +Fortunatus Licetus, took up an intermediate position which still finds, +perhaps reasonably, a great many adherents. He recognized that a very +frequent cause of malformation in the child is to be found in morbid +antenatal conditions, but at the same time was not prepared to deny +absolutely and in every case the influence of maternal impression on such +conditions. Malebranche, the Platonic philosopher, allowed the greatest +extension to the power of the maternal imagination. In the eighteenth +century, however, the new spirit of free inquiry, of radical criticism, +and unfettered logic, led to a sceptical attitude toward this ancient +belief then flourishing vigorously.[190] In 1727, a few years after +Malebranche's death, James Blondel, a physician of extreme acuteness, who +had been born in Paris, was educated at Leyden, and practiced in London, +published the first methodical and thorough attack on the doctrine of +maternal impressions, _The Strength of Imagination of Pregnant Women +Examined_, and exercised his great ability in ridiculing it. Haller, +Roederer, and Sömmering followed in the steps of Blondel, and were either +sceptical or hostile to the ancient belief. Blumenbach, however, admitted +the influence of maternal impressions. Erasmus Darwin, as well as Goethe +in his _Wahlverwandtschaften_, even accepted the influence of paternal +impressions on the child. By the beginning of the nineteenth century the +majority of physicians were inclined to relegate maternal impressions to +the region of superstition. Yet the exceptions were of notable importance. +Burdach, when all deductions were made, still found it necessary to retain +the belief in maternal impressions, and Von Baer, the founder of +embryology, also accepted it, supported by a case, occurring in his own +sister, which he was able to investigate before the child's birth. L.W.T. +Bischoff, also, while submitting the doctrine to acute criticism, found it +impossible to reject maternal impressions absolutely, and he remarked that +the number of adherents to the doctrine was showing a tendency to increase +rather than diminish. Johannes Müller, the founder of modern physiology in +Germany, declared himself against it, and his influence long prevailed; +Valentin, Rudolf Wagner, and Emil du Bois-Reymond were on the same side. +On the other hand various eminent gynæcologists--Litzmann, Roth, Hennig, +etc.--have argued in favor of the reality of maternal impressions.[191] + +The long conflict of opinion which has taken place over this opinion has +still left the matter unsettled. The acutest critics of the ancient +belief constantly conclude the discussion with an expression of doubt and +uncertainty. Even if the majority of authorities are inclined to reject +maternal impressions, the scientific eminence of those who accept them +makes a decisive opinion difficult. The arguments against such influence +are perfectly sound: (1) it is a primitive belief of unscientific origin; +(2) it is impossible to conceive how such influence can operate since +there is no nervous connection between mother and child; (3) comparatively +few cases have been submitted to severe critical investigation; (4) it is +absurd to ascribe developmental defects to influences which arise long +after the foetus had assumed its definite shape[192]; (5) in any case the +phenomenon must be rare, for William Hunter could not find a coincidence +between maternal impressions and foetal marks through a period of several +years, and Bischoff found no case in 11,000 deliveries. These statements +embody the whole of the argument against maternal impressions, yet it is +clear that they do not settle the matter. Edgar, in a manual of obstetrics +which is widely regarded as a standard work, states that this is "yet a +mooted question."[193] Ballantyne, again, in a discussion of this +influence at the Edinburgh Obstetrical Society, summarizing the result of +a year's inquiry, concluded that it is still "_sub judice_."[194] In a +subsequent discussion of the question he has somewhat modified his +opinion, and is inclined to deny that definite impressions on the pregnant +woman's mind can cause similar defects in the foetus; they are "accidental +coincidences," but he adds that a few of the cases are difficult to +explain away. At the same time he fully believes that prolonged and +strongly marked mental states of the mother may affect the development of +the foetus in her uterus, causing vascular and nutritive disturbances, +irregularities of development, and idiocy.[195] + + Whether and in how far mental impressions on the mother can + produce definite mental and emotional disposition in the child is + a special aspect of the question to which scarcely any inquiry + has been devoted. So distinguished a biologist as Mr. A.W. + Wallace has, however, called attention to this point, bringing + forward evidence on the question and emphasizing the need of + further investigation. "Such transmission of mental influence," + he remarks, "will hardly be held to be impossible or even very + improbable," (A.W. Wallace, "Prenatal Influences on Character," + _Nature_, August 24, 1893.) + +It has already been pointed out that a large number of cases of foetal +deformities, supposed to be due to maternal impressions, cannot possibly +be so caused because the impression took place at a period when the +development of the foetus must already have been decided. In this +connection, however, it must be noted that Dabney has observed a +relationship between the time of supposed mental impressions and the +nature of the actual defect which is of considerable significance as an +argument in favor of the influence of mental impressions. He tabulated 90 +carefully reported cases from recent medical literature, and found that 21 +of them were concerned with defects of structure of the lips and palate. +In all but 2 of these 21 the defect was referred to an impression +occurring within the first three months of pregnancy. This is an important +point as showing that the assigned cause really falls within a period when +a defect of development actually could produce the observed result, +although the person reporting the cases was in many instances manifestly +ignorant of the details of embryology and teratology. There was no such +preponderance of early impressions among the defects of skin and hair +which might well, so far as development is concerned, have been caused at +a later period; here, in 7 out of 15 cases, it was distinctly stated that +the impression was made later than the fourth month.[196] + +It would seem, on the whole, that while the influence of maternal +impressions in producing definite effects on the child within the womb has +by no means been positively demonstrated, we are not entitled to reject it +with any positive assurance. Even if we accept it, however, it must +remain, for the present, an inexplicable fact; the _modus operandi_ we can +scarcely even guess at. General influences from the mother on the child we +can easily conceive of as conveyed by the mother's blood; we can even +suppose that the modified blood might act specifically on one particular +kind of tissue. We can, again, as suggested by Féré, very well believe +that the maternal emotions act upon the womb and produce various kinds and +degrees of pressure on the child within, so that the apparently active +movements of the foetus may be really consecutive on unconscious maternal +excitations.[197] We may also believe that, as suggested by John Thomson, +there are slight incoördinations _in utero_, a kind of developmental +neurosis, produced by some slight lack of harmony of whatever origin, and +leading to the production of malformations.[198] We know, finally, that, +as Féré and others have repeatedly demonstrated during recent years by +experiments on chickens, etc., very subtle agents, even odors, may +profoundly affect embryonic development and produce deformity. But how the +mother's psychic disposition can, apart from heredity, affect specifically +the physical conformation or even the psychic disposition of the child +within her womb must remain for the present an insoluble mystery, even if +we feel disposed to conclude that in some cases such action seems to be +indicated. + + In comprehending such a connection, however at present + undemonstrated, it may well be borne in mind that the + relationship of the mother to the child within her womb is of a + uniquely intimate character. It is of interest in this + connection to quote some remarks by an able psychologist, Dr. + Henry Rutgers Marshall; the remarks are not less interesting for + being brought forward without any connection with the question of + maternal impressions: "It is true that, so far as we know, the + nervous system of the embryo never has a direct connection with + the nervous system of the mother: nevertheless, as there is a + reciprocity of reaction between the physical body of the mother + and its embryonic parasite, the relation of the embryonic nervous + system to the nervous system of the mother is not very far + removed from the relation of the pre-eminent part of the nervous + system of a man to some minor nervous system within his body + which is to a marked extent dissociated from the whole neural + mass. + + "Correspondingly, then, and within the consciousness of the + mother, there develops a new little minor consciousness which, + although but lightly integrated with the mass of her + consciousness, nevertheless has its part in her consciousness + taken as a whole, much as the psychic correspondents of the + action of the nerve which govern the secretions of the glands of + the body have their part in her consciousness taken as a whole. + + "It is very much as if the optic ganglia developed fully in + themselves, without any closer connection with the rest of the + brain than existed at their first appearance. They would form a + little complex nervous system almost but not quite apart from the + brain system; and it would be difficult to deny them a + consciousness of their own; which would indeed form part of the + whole consciousness of the individual, but which would be in a + manner self-dependent." It must, if this is so, be said that + before birth, on the psychic side, the embryo's activities "form + part of a complex consciousness which is that of the mother and + embryo together." "Without subscribing to the strange stories of + telepathy, of the solemn apparition of a person somewhere at the + moment of his death a thousand miles away, of the unquiet ghost + haunting the scenes of its bygone hopes and endeavors, one may + ask" (with the author of the address in medicine at the Leicester + gathering of the British Medical Association, _British Medical + Journal_, July 29, 1905) "whether two brains cannot be so tuned + in sympathy as to transmit and receive a subtile transfusion of + mind without mediation of sense. Considering what is implied by + the human brain with its countless millions of cells, its + complexities of minute structure, its innumerable chemical + compositions, and the condensed forces in its microscopic and + ultramicroscopic elements--the whole a sort of microcosm of + cosmic forces to which no conceivable compound of electric + batteries is comparable; considering, again, that from an + electric station waves of energy radiate through the viewless air + to be caught up by a fit receiver a thousand miles distant, it is + not inconceivable that the human brain may send off still more + subtile waves to be accepted and interpreted by the fitly tuned + receiving brain. Is it, after all, mere fancy that a mental + atmosphere or effluence emanates from one person to affect + another, either soothing sympathetically or irritating + antipathically?" These remarks (like Dr. Marshall's) were made + without reference to maternal impressions, but it may be pointed + out that under no conceivable circumstance could we find a brain + in so virginal and receptive a state as is the child's in the + womb. + +On the whole we see that pregnancy induces a psychic state which is at +once, in healthy persons, one of full development and vigor, and at the +same time one which, especially in individuals who are slightly abnormal, +is apt to involve a state of strained or overstrained nervous tension and +to evoke various manifestations which are in many respects still +imperfectly understood. Even the specifically sexual emotions tend to be +heightened, more especially during the earlier period of pregnancy. In 24 +cases of pregnancy in which the point was investigated by Harry Campbell, +sexual feeling was decidedly increased in 8, in one case (of a woman aged +31 who had had four children) being indeed only present during pregnancy, +when it was considerable; in only 7 cases was there diminution or +disappearance of sexual feeling.[199] Pregnancy may produce mental +depression;[200] but on the other hand it frequently leads to a change of +the most favorable character in the mental and general well-being. Some +women indeed are only well during pregnancy. It is remarkable that some +women who habitually suffer from various nervous troubles--neuralgias, +gastralgia, headache, insomnia--are only free from them at this moment. +This "paradox of gestation," as Vinay has termed it, is specially marked +in the hysterical and those suffering from slight nervous disorders, but +it is by no means universal, so that although it is possible, Vinay +states, to confirm the opinion of the ancients as to the beneficial +action of marriage on hysteria, that is only true of slight cases and +scarcely enables us to counsel marriage in hysteria.[201] Even a woman's +intelligence is sometimes heightened by pregnancy, and Tarnier, as quoted +by Vinay, knew many women whose intelligence, habitually somewhat obtuse, +has only risen to the normal level during pregnancy.[202] The pregnant +woman has reached the climax of womanhood; she has attained to that state +toward which the periodically recurring menstrual wave has been drifting +her at regular intervals throughout her sexual life[203]; she has achieved +that function for which her body has been constructed, and her mental and +emotional disposition adapted, through countless ages. + +And yet, as we have seen, our ignorance of the changes effected by the +occurrence of this supremely important event--even on the physical +side--still remains profound. Pregnancy, even for us, the critical and +unprejudiced children of a civilized age, still remains, as for the +children of more primitive ages, a mystery. Conception itself is a mystery +for the primitive man, and may be produced by all sorts of subtle ways +apart from sexual connection, even by smelling a flower.[204] The pregnant +woman was surrounded by ceremonies, by reverence and fear, often shut up +in a place apart.[205] Her presence, her exhalations, were of extreme +potency; even in some parts of Europe to-day, as in the Walloon districts +of Belgium, a pregnant woman must not kiss a child for her breath is +dangerous, or urinate on plants for she will kill them.[206] The mystery +has somewhat changed its form; it still remains. The future of the race is +bound up with our efforts to fathom the mystery of pregnancy. "The early +days of human life," it has been truly said, "are entirely one with the +mother. On her manner of life--eating, drinking, sleeping, and +thinking--what greatness may not hang?"[207] Schopenhauer observed, with +misapplied horror, that there is nothing a woman is less modest about than +the state of pregnancy, while Weininger exclaims: "Never yet has a +pregnant woman given expression in any form--poem, memoirs, or +gynæcological monograph--to her sensations or feelings."[208] Yet when we +contemplate the mystery of pregnancy and all that it involves, how trivial +all such considerations become! We are here lifted into a region where our +highest intelligence can only lead us to adoration, for we are gazing at a +process in which the operations of Nature become one with the divine task +of Creation. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[169] See, e.g., Groos, _Æsthetische Genuss_, p. 249. "We have to admit," +Groos observes, "the entrance of another instinct, the impulse to tend and +foster, so closely connected with the sexual life. It is seemingly due to +the co-operation of this impulse that the little female bird during +courtship is so often fed by the male like a young fledgling. In man +'love' from the biological standpoint is also an amalgamation of two +needs; when the tender need to protect and foster and serve is lacking the +emotion is not quite perfect. Heine's expression, 'With my mantle I +protect you from the storm,' has always seemed to me very characteristic." +Sometimes the sexual impulse may undergo a complete transformation in this +direction. "I believe there is really a tendency in women," a lady writes +in a letter, "to allow maternal feeling to take the place of sexual +feeling. Very often a woman's feeling for her husband becomes this (though +he may be twenty years older than herself); sometimes it does not, +remaining purely sex feeling. Sometimes it is for some other man she has +this curious self-obliterating maternal feeling. It is not necessarily +connected with sex intercourse. A prostitute, who has relations with +dozens of men, may have it for some feeble drunken fool, who perhaps goes +after other women. I once saw the change from sex feeling to mother +feeling, as I call it, come almost suddenly over a woman after she had +lived about four years with a man who was unfaithful to her. Then, when +all real sex feeling, the hatred of the woman he followed, the desire he +should give her love and tenderness, had all gone, came the other feeling, +and she said to me, 'You don't understand at all; he's only my little +baby; nothing he does can make any difference to me now.' As I grow older +and understand women's natures better, I can see almost at once which +relation it is a woman has to her husband, or any given man. It is this +feeling, and not sex passion, that keeps woman from being free." Not only +is there a sexual association in the impulse to foster and protect, there +would appear to be a similar element also in the response to that impulse. +Freud has especially insisted on the partly sexual character of the +child's feelings for those who care for it and tend it and satisfy its +needs. It is begun in earliest infancy; "whoever has seen the sated infant +sink back from the breast, to fall asleep with flushed cheeks and happy +smile, must say that the picture is adequate to the expression of the +sexual satisfaction of later life." The lips, moreover, are the earliest +erogenous zone. "There will, perhaps, be some opposition," Freud remarks +(_Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie_, pp. 36, 64), "to the +identification of the child's feelings of tenderness and appreciation for +those who tend it with sexual love, but I believe that exact psychological +analysis will place the identity beyond doubt. The relationship of the +child with the person who tends it is for it a continual source of sexual +excitement and satisfaction flowing from the erogenous zones, especially +since the fostering person--as a rule the mother--regards the child with +emotions which proceed from her sexual life; strokes it, kisses it, rocks +it, and very plainly treats it as a compensation for a fully valid sexual +object." Freud remarks that girls who retain the childish character of +their love for their parents to adult age are apt to make cold wives and +to be sexually anæsthetic. + +[170] Esbach (in his _Thèse de Paris_, published in 1876) showed that even +the finger nails are affected in pregnancy and become measurably thinner. + +[171] C.H. Stratz, _Die Schönheit des Weiblichen Körpers_, Chapter VI. + +[172] Iron appears to be liberated in the maternal organism during +pregnancy, and Wychgel has shown (_Zeitschrift für Geburtshülfe und +Gynäkologie_, bd. xlvii, Heft II) that the pigment of pregnant women +contains iron, and that the amount of iron in the urine is increased. + +[173] Vinay, _Maladies de la Grossesse_, Chapter VIII; K. Hennig, +"Exploratio Externa," _Comptes-rendus du XIIe. Congrès International de +Médècine_, vol. vi, Section XIII, pp. 144-166. A bibliography of the +literature concerning the physiology of pregnancy, extending to ten pages, +is appended by Pinard to his article "Grossesse," _Dictionnaire +Encyclopédique des Sciences Médicales_. + +[174] Stratz, op. cit., Chapter XII. + +[175] W.S.A. Griffith, "The Diagnosis of Pregnancy," _British Medical +Journal_, April 11, 1903. + +[176] J. Mackenzie and H.O. Nicholson, "The Heart in Pregnancy," _British +Medical Journal_, October 8, 1904; Stengel and Stanton, "The Condition of +the Heart in Pregnancy," _Medical Record_, May 10, 1902 and _University +Pennsylvania Medical Bulletin_, Sept., 1904 (summarized in _British +Medical Journal_, August 16, 1902, and Sept. 23, 1905.) + +[177] J. Henderson, "Maternal Blood at Term," _Journal of Obstetrics and +Gynæcology_, February, 1902; C. Douglas, "The Blood in Pregnant Women," +_British Medical Journal_, March 26, 1904; W.L. Thompson, "The Blood in +Pregnancy," _Johns Hopkins Hospital Bulletin_, June, 1904. + +[178] H.O. Nicholson, "Some Remarks on the Maternal Circulation in +Pregnancy," _British Medical Journal_, October 3, 1903. + +[179] J. Morris Slemans, "Metabolism During Pregnancy," _Johns Hopkins +Hospital Reports_, vol. xii, 1904. + +[180] B. Wolff, _Zentralblatt für Gynäkologie_, 1904, No. 26. + +[181] Tridandani, _Annali di Ostetrica_, March, 1900. + +[182] R. Barnes, "The Induction of Labor," _British Medical Journal_, +December 22, 1894. + +[183] See, e.g., Havelock Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, pp. 344, +et seq. + +[184] Arthur Giles, "The Longings of Pregnant Women," _Transactions +Obstetrical Society of London_, vol. xxxv, 1893. + +[185] Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, Chapter XXX. + +[186] Thus, in Cornwall, "to be in the longing way" is a popular synonym +for pregnancy. + +[187] The apple, wherever it is known, has nearly always been a sacred or +magic fruit (as J.F. Campbell shows, _Popular Tales of West Highlands_, +vol. I, p. lxxv. et seq.), and the fruit of the forbidden tree which +tempted Eve is always popularly imagined to be an apple. One may perhaps +refer in this connection to the fact that at Rome and elsewhere the +testicles have been called apples. I may add that we find a curious proof +of the recognition of the feminine love of apples in an old Portuguese +ballad, "Donna Guimar," in which a damsel puts on armour and goes to the +wars; her sex is suspected and as a test, she is taken into an orchard, +but Donna Guimar is too wary to fall into the trap, and turning away from +the apples plucks a citron. + +[188] A. Pinard, Art. "Grossesse," _Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des +Sciences Médicales_, p. 138. On the subject of violent, criminal and +abnormal impulses during pregnancy, see Cumston, "Pregnancy and Crime," +_American Journal Obstetrics_, December, 1903. + +[189] See especially Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter XXXI. +Ballantyne in his work on the pathology of the foetus adds Loango negroes, +the Eskimo and the ancient Japanese. + +[190] In 1731 Schurig, in his _Syllepsilogia_, devoted more than a hundred +pages (cap. IX) to summarizing a vast number of curious cases of maternal +impressions leading to birth-marks of all kinds. + +[191] J.W. Ballantyne has written an excellent history of the doctrine of +maternal impressions, reprinted in his _Manual of Antenatal Pathology: The +Embryo_, 1904, Chapter IX; he gives a bibliography of 381 items. In +Germany the history of the question has been written by Dr. Iwan Bloch +(under the pseudonym of Gerhard von Welsenburg), _Das Versehen der +Frauen_, 1899. Cf., in French, G. Variot, "Origine des Préjugés Populaires +sur les Envies," _Bulletin Société d'Anthropologie_, Paris, June 18, 1891. +Variot rejects the doctrine absolutely, Bloch accepts it, Ballantyne +speaks cautiously. + +[192] J.G. Kiernan has shown how many of the alleged cases are negatived +by the failure to take this fact into consideration. (_Journal of American +Medical Association_, December 9, 1899.) + +[193] J. Clifton Edgar, _The Practice of Obstetrics_, second edition, +1904, p. 296. In an important discussion of the question at the American +Gynæcological Society in 1886, introduced by Fordyce Barker, various +eminent gynæcologists declared in favor of the doctrine, more or less +cautiously. (_Transactions of the American Gynæcological Society_, vol. +xi, 1886, pp. 152-196.) Gould and Pyle, bringing forward some of the data +on the question (_Anomalies and Curiosities of Medicine_, pp. 81, _et +seq._) state that the reality of the influence of maternal impressions +seems fully established. On the other side, see G.W. Cook, _American +Journal of Obstetrics_, September, 1889, and H.F. Lewis, ib., July, 1899. + +[194] _Transactions Edinburgh Obstetrical Society_, vol. xvii, 1892. + +[195] J.W. Ballantyne, _Manual of Antenatal Pathology: The Embryo_, p. 45. + +[196] W.C. Dabney, "Maternal Impressions," Keating's _Cyclopædia of +Diseases of Children_, vol. i, 1889, pp. 191-216. + +[197] Féré, _Sensation et Mouvement_, Chapter XIV, "Sur la Psychologie du +Foetus." + +[198] J. Thomson, "Defective Co-ordination in Utero," _British Medical +Journal_, September 6, 1902. + +[199] H. Campbell, _Nervous Organization of Man and Woman_, p. 206; cf. +Moll, _Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 264. Many +authorities, from Soranus of Ephesus onward, consider, however, that +sexual relations should cease during pregnancy, and certainly during the +later months. Cf. Brénot, _De l'influence de la copulation pendant la +grosseisse_, 1903. + +[200] Bianchi terms this fairly common condition the neurasthenia of +pregnancy. + +[201] Vinay, _Traité des Maladies de la Grossesse_, 1894, pp. 51, 577; +Mongeri, "Nervenkrankungen und Schwangerschaft." _Allegemeine Zeitschrift +für Psychiatrie_, bd. LVIII, Heft 5. Haig remarks (_Uric Acid_, sixth +edition, p. 151) that during normal pregnancy diseases with excess of uric +acid in the blood (headaches, fits, mental depression, dyspepsia, asthma) +are absent, and considers that the common idea that women do not easily +take colds, fevers, etc., at this time is well founded. + +[202] Founding his remarks on certain anatomical changes and on a +suggestion of Engel's, Donaldson observes: "It is impossible to escape the +conclusion that in women natural education is complete only with +maternity, which we know to effect some slight changes in the sympathetic +system and possibly the spinal cord, and which may be fairly laid under +suspicion of causing more structural modifications than are at present +recognized." H.H. Donaldson, _The Growth of the Brain_, p. 352. + +[203] The state of menstruation is in many respects an approximation to +that of pregnancy; see, e.g., Edgar's _Practice of Obstetrics_, plates 6 6 +and 7, showing the resemblance of the menstrual changes in the breasts and +the external sexual parts to the changes of pregnancy; cf. Havelock Ellis, +_Man and Woman_, fourth edition, Chapter XI, "The Functional Periodicity +of Woman." + +[204] Thus the gypsies say of an unmarried woman who becomes pregnant, +"She has smelt the moon-flower"--a flower believed to grow on the +so-called moon-mountain and to possess the property of impregnating by its +smell. Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, bd. I, Chapter XXVII. + +[205] This was a sound instinct, for it is now recognized as an extremely +important part of puericulture that a woman should rest at all events +during the latter part of pregnancy; see, e.g., Pinard, _Gazette des +Hôpitaux_, November 28, 1895, and _Annales de Gynécologie_, August, 1898. + +[206] Ploss and Bartels, op. cit., Chapter XXIX; Kryptadia, vol. viii, p. +143. + +[207] Griffith Wilkin, _British Medical Journal_, April 8, 1905. + +[208] Weininger, _Geschlecht und Charakter_, p. 107. I may remark that a +recent book, Ellis Meredith's _Heart of My Heart_, is devoted to a +seemingly autobiographical account of a pregnant woman's emotions and +ideas. The relations of maternity to intellectual work have been carefully +and impartially investigated by Adele Gerhard and Helena Simon, who seem +to conclude that the conflict between the inevitable claims of maternity +and the scarcely less inevitable claims of the intellectual life cannot be +avoided. + + + + +APPENDIX. + +HISTORIES OF SEXUAL DEVELOPMENT. + + HISTORY I.--The following narrative has been written by a + university man trained in psychology:-- + + So far as I have been able to learn, none of my ancestors for at + least three generations have suffered from any nervous or mental + disease; and of those more remote I can learn nothing at all. It + appears probable, then, that any peculiarities of my own sexual + development must be explained by reference to the somewhat + peculiar environment. + + I was the first child and was, naturally, somewhat spoiled--a + process which tended to increase my natural tendency to + sentimentality. On the other hand, I was shy and undemonstrative + with all except my nearest relatives, and with them as well after + my seventh or eighth year. And here it may be well to describe my + "mental type," as this is probably the most important factor in + determining the direction of one's mental development. Of mental + types the "visual" is, of course, by far the most common, but in + my own case visual imagery was never strong or vivid, and has + constantly grown weaker. The dominant part has been played by + tactual, muscular and organic sensations, placing me as one of + the "tactual motor" type, with strong "verbal motor" and + "organic" tendencies. In reading a novel I seldom have a mental + picture of the character or situation, but easily imagine the + sensations (except the visual) and feel something of the emotions + described. When telling of any event I have a strong impulse to + make the movements described and to gesticulate. I remember + events in terms of movements and the words to be used in giving + an account of them; and in thinking of any subject I can feel the + movements of the larynx and, in a less degree, of the lips and + tongue that would be involved in putting my thoughts into words. + I am easily moved to emotion, even to sentimentality, but am + seldom if ever deeply affected and am so averse to any display of + my feelings that I have the reputation among my acquaintances of + being cold, unfeeling and unemotional. I am naturally quiet and + bashful to a degree, which has rendered all forms of social + intercourse painful through much of my life, and this in spite of + a real longing to associate with people on terms of intimacy. As + a child I was sensitive and solitary; later I became morbid as + well. In a character so constituted the feelings and impulses of + the moment are likely to rule, and such has been my constant + experience, though a large element of obstinacy in my character + has kept me from appearing impulsive, and slight influences will + bring about reactions which seem out of all proportion to their + cause. For instance, I cannot, even now, read the more erotic of + Boccaccio's stories without a good deal of sexual excitement and + restlessness, which can be relieved only by vigorous exercise or + masturbation. + + The first ten years of my life were passed on a farm, most of the + time without playmates or companions of my own age. + + As far back as I can remember I indulged in elaborate day-dreams + in which I figured as the chief character along with a few others + who were chiefly creatures of my imagination, but at times + borrowed from reality. These others were always boys until I + learned the proper function of the sexual organs, when girls + usurped the whole stage in numbers beyond the limits of a Turkish + harem. Even at school my day-dreams were scarcely interrupted, + for my shyness and timidity made me very unpopular among my + schoolmates, who tormented me after the fashion of small boys or + neglected me, as the spirit moved them. To make matters worse, I + was brought up under the "sheltered life system," kept carefully + away from the "bad boys," which category included nearly all the + youngsters of the community, and deluged with moral homilies and + tirades on things religious until I was thoroughly convinced that + goodness and discomfort, the right and the unpleasant, were + strictly synonymous; and I was kept through much of the time + facing the prospect of an early death, to be followed by the good + old orthodox hell or the equal miseries of its gorgeous + alternative. I may say in all seriousness that this is a + conservative and unexaggerated account of one phase of my early + life--the one, I think, that tended most strongly to make me + introspective and morbid. Later on, when I was trying to abandon + the habit of masturbation, this early training greatly increased + the despair I felt at each successive failure. + + The first traces of sexual excitement that I can now recall + occurred when I was about 4 years old. I had erections quite + frequently and found a mild pleasure in fondling my genitals when + these occurred, especially just after waking in the morning. I + had no notion of an orgasm, and never succeeded in producing one + until I was 13 years of age. In the summer of my sixth year I + experienced pleasurable sensations in daubing my genitals with + oil and then fondling or rubbing them, but I abandoned this + amusement after getting some irritating substance into the + meatus. A year later my mother warned me that playing with my + penis would "make me very sick," but since experience had taught + me that this was not true, my conviction that what was forbidden + must necessarily be pleasant, sent me directly to my favorite + retreat in the barn loft to experiment. Since, however, I failed, + in spite of persistent effort, to produce any such pleasant + results as I had expected, I soon gave up my attempts for other + kinds of amusement. + + A few months after this, in midsummer, a very sensual servant + girl began a series of attempts to satisfy herself sexually with + my help. She came nearly every day into the loft where I was + playing and did her best to initiate me into the mysteries of + sexual relationships, but I proved a sorry pupil. She would rub + my penis until it became erect and then, placing me upon her, + would insert the penis in her vulva and make movements of her + thighs and hips calculated to cause friction. At times she varied + the program by lying upon me and embracing me passionately. I can + remember distinctly her quick, gasping breath and convulsive + movements. She generally ended the seance by persuading me to + perform cunnilingus upon her. None of these performances were + intelligible to me and I invariably protested against being + compelled to leave my play to amuse her. Even her fondling of my + genitals annoyed me; and, stranger still, I preferred satisfying + her by cunnilingus to the attempts at coitus. + + It was nearly a year later that I experienced the first + unmistakable manifestations of the sexual impulse--erections + accompanied by lustful feeling and vague desires of whose proper + satisfaction I had no notion whatever. It never occurred to me to + associate my experiences with the servant girl with these new + sensations. The peculiar fact about them was that they were + generally occasioned by the infliction of pain upon animals. I do + not remember how I first discovered that they could be evoked in + this way, but I can clearly recollect many of my efforts to + arouse this pleasurable excitement by abusing the dog or the + cats, or by prodding the calves with a nail set in the end of a + broom handle. I seldom manipulated my genitals at this time, and + when I did it was for the purpose of causing sexual excitement + rather than allaying it. + + During this same year I got my first idea of sexual intercourse + by watching animals copulate; but my powers of observation must + have been limited, for I supposed that the penis of the male + entered the anus of the female. In watching the coitus of animals + I experienced lively sexual excitement and lustful sensations, + located not only in the genitals, but apparently in the anus as + well. I often excited, myself by imagining myself playing the + part of the female animal--a peculiar combination of passive + pederasty and bestiality. A servant girl put me to right on the + error of observation just mentioned, but neglected to apply the + principle to human animals, and I remained for another year in + complete ignorance of the structure of woman's sexual organs and + of the intercourse between man and woman. In the meantime I + cultivated my fancies of intercourse with animals, often still + perversely imagining myself taking the part of the female; and + the notion of such relationships gradually became so familiar as + to seem possible and desirable. This is especially significant in + view of later developments. + + Up to my eleventh or twelfth year the erotic element in my + daydreaming varied with the seasons. In the summer it played a + dominant part, while in the winter it was almost entirely absent, + owing, it may be, to the fact that most of my time was spent + indoors or on long, tiresome tramps to and from school, and the + further fact that during the winter I saw but little of the + animals which had acted as a stimulus to sexual excitement. So + little was I troubled in winter and so ignorant was I of normal + intercourse that sleeping with a cousin, a girl of about my own + age (7 or 8 years), resulted in no addition to my knowledge of + things sexual. + + It was early in my ninth year that I first learned something of + the anatomical difference between man and woman and of the + functions of the sexual organs in coitus. These were explained to + me by a young male servant, who, however, told me nothing of + conception or pregnancy. At first I was very little interested, + as it did not immediately occur to me to associate my own erotic + experiences with the matter of these revelations; but under the + faithful tuition of my new instructor I soon began to desire + normal coitus, and my interest in the sexual affairs of animals + weakened accordingly. His teachings went still further, for he + masturbated before me, then persuaded me to masturbate him, and + finally practiced coitus inter femora upon me. He also tried to + masturbate me, but was unable to produce an orgasm, though I + found the experiment mildly pleasurable. + + Early in my eleventh year we left the farm and lived in the city + for several months. In the meantime there had been no + developments in my sexual life beyond what has already been + indicated. In the city I found so much to interest and amuse me + that I almost entirely forgot my erotic day-dreams and desires. + Though my chief playmates were two girls of about my own age I + never thought of attempting sexual intercourse with them, as I + might easily have done, for they were much wiser and more + experienced in these things than myself. Shortly before the end + of our stay in town an older schoolmate explained to me as much + of the process of reproduction as is usually known by a + precocious youngster of 12 years, but I firmly refused to credit + his statements. He adduced the fact of lactation in proof of the + correctness of his views, but I had been too thoroughly steeped + in supernaturalism to be very amenable to naturalistic evidence + of this sort and remained obdurate. But the suggestion stayed + with me and perplexed me not a little; when we returned to the + farm I began to watch the reproductive process in animals. + + The following two years were decidedly unpleasant. I was growing + rapidly and was sluggish, awkward and stupid. At school I was + more unpopular than ever and seemed to have a positive genius + for doing the wrong thing. On the rare occasions when my + companions admitted me to their counsels I was a willing dupe and + catspaw, with the result that I was much in trouble with my + teachers. Being morbidly sensitive I suffered keenly under these + circumstances and, as my health was not at all good, I often made + of my frequent headaches excuses to stay at home, where I would + lie abed brooding over my small troubles or, more often, dreaming + erotic day-dreams and making repeated attempts to produce an + orgasm. But though these efforts were accompanied by the most + lustful thoughts and my imagination created situations of + oriental extravagance, I was 13 years old when they first met + with success. I remember the occasion very distinctly, the more + so because I thought of it much and bitterly when shortly + afterwards I tried to abandon a habit which the family "doctor + book" assured me must result in every variety of damnation. At + the moment, however, I was greatly surprised and gratified and + tried at once to repeat the delightful sensation, but was unable + to do so until the following day. From that time to the present I + think I have masturbated an average of ten times per week, and + this is certainly a very conservative estimate; for though up to + my sixteenth year I could seldom produce an orgasm more than once + a day I have often, during the last four or five years, produced + it from four to seven times per day without difficulty and this + for days and even weeks in succession. During these periods of + excessive masturbation very little liquid was ejaculated and the + pleasurable sensations were slight or entirely lacking. + + From the time when I began masturbating regularly practically my + whole interest centered in things pertaining to sex. I read the + chapters of the family "doctor book" which treated of sexual + matters; my day-dreams were almost exclusively erotic; I sought + opportunities to talk about sex-relationships with my + schoolmates, with whom I was now slowly getting on better terms; + I collected pictures of nude women, learned a great number of + obscene stories, read such obscene books as I could obtain and + even searched the dictionary for words having a sexual + connotation. Up to my fifteenth year, when ejaculation of semen + began, there was a strong sadistic coloring to my day-dreams. + Through this period, too, my bashfulness in the presence of the + opposite sex increased until it reached the point of absurdity. + + When fifteen years old I began to practice coitus inter femora on + my brother and continued it intermittently for about two years. + The experience was disappointing, for I had confidently expected + a great increase of pleasure over masturbation in this act; and + in casting about for some stronger stimulus I recurred to the + forgotten idea of intercourse with animals. I promptly tried to + put the idea to a test, but failed several times, and finally + succeeded, only to find that the result fell far short of my + expectations. Nevertheless I continued the practice irregularly + for about three years--or rather through that part of the three + years that I spent at home, for while I was at school opportunity + for such indulgence was lacking. Long familiarity with the idea + of intercourse with animals had made it impossible for me to feel + the disgust with the practice which it inspires in most people; + and even the perusal of Exodus xxii: 19 failed to make me abandon + it. Firmly as I believed in the Mosaic law the supremacy of the + sexual impulse was complete. + + As early as my sixteenth year I tried to abandon "self-abuse" in + all its forms and have repeatedly made the same effort since that + time but never with more than very partial success. On two or + three occasions I have stopped for periods of several weeks, but + only to begin again and indulge more recklessly than before. The + deep depression which followed each failure, and often each act + of masturbation, I attributed solely to the loss of semen, + leaving out of account the fact that I expected to feel depressed + and the utter discouragement and self-contempt which accompanied + the sense of failure and weakness when, in the face of my + resolution, I repeatedly gave way and yielded to the temptation + to an act whose consequences I firmly believed must be ruinous. I + am now convinced that by far the greater part of this depression + was due to suggestion and the humiliating sense of defeat. And + this feeling of moral impotence, this seeming helplessness + against an overpowering impulse which, on the other hand, seemed + so trivial when viewed without passion, eventually weakened my + self-control to a degree guessed by no one but myself and sapped + the foundations of my moral life in a way which I have constant + occasion to deplore. + + The foregoing paragraphs give, I think, a fair idea of my + condition when I left home for a boarding school at the beginning + of my seventeenth year. From this time my experiences may be said + to have run on in two distinct cycles--that of the summer months + when I was at home, and that of the remainder of the year when I + was at school. This fact will make some confusion and apparent + inconsistency in the rest of this "history" unavoidable. When I + left home I was shy, retiring, totally ignorant of social usage, + without self-confidence, unambitious, dreamy, and subject to fits + of melancholy. I masturbated at least once a day, though I was in + almost constant rebellion against the habit. In my more idle + moments I elaborated erotic day dreams in which there was a + peculiar mixture of the purely sensual and the purely ideal + element; which never fused in my experience, but held the field + alternately or mingled somewhat in the manner of air and water. + One person usually served as the object of my ideal attachment, + another as the center round which I grouped my sensual dreams and + desires. + + At school I found more congenial companions than I had fallen in + with elsewhere, and the necessary contact with people of both + sexes gradually wore off some of the rougher corners and brought + a measure of self-confidence. I had two or three incipient love + affairs which my backwardness kept from growing serious. Out of + this change of environment came a sense of expansion, of escape + from self, which was distinctly pleasant. I still masturbated + regularly, but no longer experienced the former depression except + when at home during vacation. Relatively to the past, life was + now so varied and interesting that I had less and less time for + melancholy; and the discovery that I could lead my classes and + hold my own in athletic sports seemed to indicate that my past + fears had been exaggerated. Nevertheless I was never reconciled + to the habit and often rebelled at the weakness that kept me its + slave. + + When I entered the university the effects of my useless struggle + with the practice of masturbation were pretty well developed. I + could no longer fix my attention steadily upon my work and found + that only by "cribbing" and "bluffing" could I keep my place at + the head of my classes. I was troubled not a little by the + shoddiness of my work, and tried again and again during the + course of the two years spent at this college to shake off the + habit. At the university I was introduced gradually to a wider + social circle and so far outgrew my bashfulness that I began to + seek the society of the opposite sex assiduously. As I gained + self-confidence I became reckless, getting at one time into + serious trouble with the authorities which came near resulting in + my expulsion. I became one of the more popular members of the + clique to which I belonged--much to my surprise and even more to + that of my acquaintances. The physical culture craze attacked me + at this time and my pet ambition was the attainment of strength + and agility. My bump of vanity also grew apace, but an unmeasured + hatred of all kinds of foppishness kept me on the safe side of + moderation in my dress and behavior. + + During my second year of university life I had two love affairs + in the course of which I found that my interest in any particular + member of the fair sex disappeared as soon as it was returned. + The pursuit was fascinating enough, but I cared nothing at all + for the prize when once it was within reach. I may add that the + interest I had in the girls was purely ideal. While at this + school I do not think I masturbated half as often as while at the + preparatory school. + + When I left this college for ---- University I took with me a + formidable catalogue of good resolutions, first among which was + the determination to abandon all kinds of "self-abuse." I think I + kept this one about a month. As I had gone from a comparatively + small school to one of the largest of American universities the + change was great and the revelations it brought me frequently + humiliating. I was lonesome, home-sick, and my bump of + self-esteem was woefully bruised; and not unnaturally I soon + began to seek a partial solace in day-dreams and masturbation. + After I had become somewhat adapted to my new environment I + indulged less frequently in either, and from that time to the + present I have masturbated very irregularly, sometimes but little + and again to excess. + + Not long after I came to this place I met a young lady with whom + I soon became quite intimate. For over a year our friendship was + strictly platonic and then swung suddenly around to a sexual + basis. We were ardent lovers for a few weeks, after which I tired + of the game as I had before in other cases, and broke off all + relations with her as abruptly as was possible. Since then I have + almost wholly withdrawn from the society and companionship of + women and have almost entirely lost whatever tact and assurance I + once possessed in their company. Things pertaining to sexual life + have interested me rather more than less, but have occupied my + attention much less exclusively than before this episode. Though + I have never intended to marry, my breaking off relations with + this girl affected me much. At any rate it marked an abrupt + change in the character of my sexual experiences. The sexual + impulse seems to have lost its power to rouse me to action. + Hitherto I had practiced masturbation always under protest, as it + were--as the only available form of sexual satisfaction; while + now I resigned myself to it as all that there was to hope for in + that field. Of course I knew that a little effort or a little + money would procure natural satisfaction of my sexual needs, but + I also knew that I would never, under any ordinary circumstances, + put forth the necessary effort, and fear of venereal disease has + been more than enough to keep me away from houses of + prostitution. + + Some months ago I refrained from masturbation for a period of + about six weeks and watched carefully for any change in my health + or spirits, but noticed none at all. The only impulse to + masturbate was occasioned by fits of restlessness accompanied by + erections and a mildly pleasurable feeling of fullness in the + penis and scrotum. I think that over 75 per cent, of my acts of + masturbation are provoked by these fits of restlessness and are + unaccompanied by fancy images, erotic thoughts, lustful desires, + or marked pleasure. At other times the act is occasioned by + erotic thoughts and images, and is accompanied by a considerable + degree of lustful pleasure which, however, is never so intense as + in my earlier experiences and has steadily decreased from the + first. Usually the orgasm is accompanied by a strong contraction + of all the voluntary muscles, particularly the extensors, + followed by a slight giddiness and slight feeling of exhaustion. + If repeated several times in the course of a single day the acts + are followed by dullness and lassitude; otherwise the feeling of + exhaustion passes away quickly and a sense of relief and quiet + takes its place. So natural or rather habitual has this resort + to masturbation as a means of relief from nervousness and + restlessness become that the act is almost instinctive in its + unconsciousness. + + I am extremely sensitive to all kinds of sexual influences, and + have an insatiable curiosity regarding everything that pertains + to the sexual life of men or women. I am not, however, excited + sexually by conversation about sexual facts and relationships, no + matter what its nature, though in reading erotic literature my + excitement is often intense. + + The tendency to day dream has never left me, but there are no + longer any elaborate scenes or long-continued "stories," these + having been replaced by vaguely imagined incidents which are + usually broken off before they reach a satisfactory climax. They + are always interrupted by the intrusion of other matters, usually + of more practical interest; and the long-continued habit of + satisfying myself by masturbation has made erotic dreams rather + tantalizing than pleasurable. I dream very seldom at night--at + least I can scarcely ever remember any dreams upon waking--and + practically never of sexual relations. I have not had a nocturnal + emission for over three years, and probably not more than + twenty-five in my life. + + In my "love passages" with girls there has been no serious + thought of coitus on my part, and I have never had intercourse + with a woman--unless my early experiences with the servant girl + be called such. Like all masturbators I always idealized "love" + to the utter exclusion of all sensual cravings; and the notion + that the physical act of coitus was something degrading and + destructive of real love rather than its consummation was, of all + prejudices I have ever formed, the most difficult to escape--a + circumstance due, I suppose, to the fact that all I had ever been + taught on the subject tended to the complete divorce of what was + called "love" from what was stigmatized as a "base sensual + desire." Judging from my own experience and observation I should + say that "ideal love" is a mere surface feeling, bound to + disappear as soon as it has gained its object by arousing a + reciprocal interest on the part of the one to whom it is + directed. So little did I "materialize" the objects of my "love" + that I have never cared for kissing or the warm embraces in which + lovers usually indulge. I have never kissed but one girl, and her + with far too little enthusiasm to satisfy her. My last sweetheart + was a very passionate girl, the warmth of whose embraces was + somewhat torrid and, to me, both puzzling and annoying. The + intensity of feeling which demanded such strenuous expression was + beyond my knowledge of human nature. A somewhat peculiar + circumstance in connection with these experiences is the fact + that I often found myself trying to analyze my emotions with a + purely psychological interest while playing the part of the + intoxicated lover in his mistress's arms. + + There is but little left to say on the subject of my sexual + development. During the last two or three years my knowledge of + the facts of the sexual life has been very greatly increased, + and I have become acquainted with phases of human nature which + were wholly unknown to me before. The part played by things + sexual in my life is still, I suppose, abnormally large; it is + undoubtedly the largest single interest, though my outer life is + determined almost wholly by other considerations. + + Of course I know nothing of the effect which long-continued + masturbation may have had on my ability to perform normal coitus. + I do not think I am subject to any kind of sexual perversion, for + all my indulgence has been _faute de mieux_ and, at least since I + began masturbation, all my desires and erotic day-dreams have had + to do only with normal coitus. The mystery which surrounds the + sexual act seems at times to be regaining its former influence + and power of fascination. I have no doubt, however, but that I + should be greatly disillusioned should I ever perform coitus; and + I greatly regret that I have not been able to test this + conviction and so round out and complete this "history." + + It may be worth while to say a word about my religious + experiences, as, in many cases, they are closely bound up with + the sexual impulse. I was never "converted," but on a dozen or + more occasions approached the crisis more or less closely. The + dominant emotion in these experiences was always fear, sometimes + with anger and despair intermixed in varying proportions. A + complete analysis of these experiences is, of course, impossible, + but the various pleasurable feelings of which converts spoke in + the revivals which I attended were a closed book to me. Following + my revival-meeting experiences came a few days spent in a sort of + moral exaltation during which I eschewed all my habits of which + conventional morality disapproved, save masturbation, and felt no + small satisfaction with my moral conditions. I became a + first-rate Pharisee. Toward the women who had figured in my day + dreams I suddenly conceived the chastest affection, resolutely + smothering every sensual thought and fancy when thinking of them, + and putting in place of these elements ideal love, + self-sacrifice, knightly devotion--Sunday-school Garden-of-Eden + pictures with a mediæval, romantic coloring. These day-dreams + were always sexual, involving situations of extreme complexity + and monumental silliness. Masturbation was always continued and + usually with increased frequency. The end of these periods was + always abrupt and much like awaking from a dream in which the + dreamer has been behaving in a manner to arouse his own disgust. + They were followed by feelings of sheepishness and self-contempt + mingled with anger and a dislike of all things having to do with + religion. My inability to pass the conversion crisis and a + growing contempt for empty enthusiasm finally led me to a saner + attitude toward religion, from which I passed easily into + religious scepticism; and later the study of philosophy and + science, and particularly of psychology, banished the last + lingering remnant of faith in a supernatural agency and led me + to the passion for facts and indifference to values which have + caused me to be often called "dead to all morality." + + + HISTORY II.--C.A., aged 25, unmarried; tutor, preparing to take + Holy Orders:-- + + My paternal ancestry (which is largely Huguenot) is noteworthy + for its patriotism and its large families. My father, who died + when I was a year old, is remembered for the singular uprightness + and purity of his life from his earliest childhood. The + photograph which I have shows him as possessed of a rare classic + beauty of features. He was an ideal husband and father. At the + time of his death he was a Master of Arts and a school principal. + My mother is an extraordinarily neurotic woman, yet famed among + her friends for her great domesticity, attachment to her + husbands, and an almost abnormal love of babies. She has nobly + borne the ill-treatment of her second husband, who for several + years has been in a state of melancholia. My mother has been + "highly-wrought" all her life, and has suffered intensely from + fears of all kinds. As a young girl she was somnambulistic, and + once fell down a stairhead during sleep. In spite of her bodily + sufferings with indigestion, eye-strain, and depression she + retains her youthfulness. She has slight powers of reasoning. She + has had times of unconsciousness and rigidity, I have never heard + any mention of epilepsy. She has a horror of showing prudishness + in regard to the healthful manifestations of sex life, and is + always praising examples of what she terms "a natural woman." + + I have heard that during my first year my mother detected my + nurse in the act of putting a morphine powder on my tongue for + the purpose of keeping me quiet. I was subject to convulsions at + this period, and narrowly escaped a permanent hernia. My family + tell me that from the beginning I was a well-developed and boyish + boy, full of mischief, impulsive, good to look upon, unusually + affectionate, beloved by all. + + In my third year I took pleasure in crawling under the bed with + my boy-cousin who was nine months my senior, and after we had + taken down our drawers, in kissing each other's nates. I do not + remember which of us first thought of this pastime. + + At the age of 4 I gave myself a treat by gazing upward through a + cellar window at the nates of a woman who was defecating from + several feet above into a cesspool that lay beneath. It was + during this summer also that I frightened myself by pulling back + my prepuce far enough to disclose the purple glans, which I had + never seen before. But this act gave me no desire to masturbate. + + When 5 years old, and living in a great city, I drew indecent + pictures in company with a little girl and her younger brother. + These pictures represented men in the act of urinating. The + penes were drawn large, and the streams of urine plainly + indicated. One afternoon I induced the boy to go to the + bath-room, lie on his back, and allow me to perform _fellatio_ on + him. I did not ask him to return the favor. I remember the + curious tar-like smell of his clothing and the region about his + genitals. It is possible that I gained my knowledge of _fellatio_ + from an unknown boy of 10, who had induced me, during the + preceding summer to enter a sandy lot with him, watch him + urinate, and then, kneeling before him, commit _fellatio_. A year + later, as I was walking home in the rain to our summer cottage, + with an open umbrella over my shoulder, a boy of 15, who was + leaning against our fence, exhibited a large, erect penis, and + when I had passed him urinated upon me and my umbrella. I never + saw the boy again. I felt peculiarly insulted by his act. Back of + the house there lived a 12-year-old boy who invited me to watch + him defecate in the outdoor privy, and during the act told me a + number of indecent stories and words which I cannot remember. + + About this time I fell in love with a little Jewish boy next + door. Often I cried myself to sleep over the thought that perhaps + he was lying on a sofa alone and crying with a stomach-ache. I + longed to embrace him; and yet I saw little of him, and made + little of him when I was with him. + + Living in a Western city a few months later, some girls of 12 and + 14 led me to their barn, where they dressed themselves in boys' + clothing and made believe that they were cowboys. One of them + told me to "shut my eyes, open my mouth, and get a surprise." + When I opened my eyes once more a piece of hen-dung lay in my + mouth. I have a vague remembrance of one of the girls asking me + to enter a water-closet with her. She uttered some indelicate + phrase, but I performed no act with her. In the house where I + lived I once entered the bedroom of a half-grown girl while she + was dressing. She knelt to kiss me innocently enough, and I, by a + sudden impulse, ran my hand between her bare neck and her corset + as far as I could reach. Apparently she took no notice of my + movement. Although I did not masturbate, yet during this winter I + experienced a tickling sensation about my genitals when I placed + my hand beneath them as I lay on my stomach in bed. One evening I + pulled up my night-dress and, holding my penis in my hand, I + danced to and fro on the carpet. I imagined that I was one of a + line of naked men and women who were advancing toward another + similar line that faced them. I imagined myself as pleasurably + coming in contact with my female partner who possessed male + genitals. + + The following summer I lived in the woods. My next-door playmate + was a little girl of my own age--6 years. She sat down before me + in the barn and exposed her genitals. This was the first time I + had seen female organs, or had thought for a moment that they + differed from my own. In great perplexity I asked the little + girl: "Has it been cut off?" She and I defecated in peach baskets + that we found in the upper part of the barn. + + When I was 7 years old and back in the Eastern city I lived in + the house of a physician. Alone with his 3-year-old daughter one + day, I showed her my erect organ, and felt a delicious + gratification when she stroked it with the words: "Nice! Nice!" I + confessed my fault to my guardian that night after I had said my + prayers. I had complained to my mother a year before of the + inconvenience I found in my penis being "so long sometimes." She + said that she would "see about having the end taken off." But I + was never circumcised. Her words gave me the doubly unpleasant + impression that my _glans_ was to be cut off. + + There came occasionally to the kitchen of Dr. W.'s house a + foul-mouthed Irish laundress who used coarse language to me + concerning urination. I loathed the woman, and yet one night I + dreamed that I was embracing her naked form and rolling over and + over with her on the bed; and in spite of my sight of female + genitals a few months before, I thought of her as having organs + of my own kind and size. At my first school I watched a + red-haired boy of 12 expose the penis of a 7-year-old boy as he + lay on his back in the bath-room. I do not remember that the + sight gave me sexual pleasure. + + I spent the summer before I was 8 in a double house. The adopted + daughter of our neighbor (a neurotic, retired physician) was a + girl of 13 who had been taken from a poor laboring family. She + got me to show her my parts, touched them, and asked whether I + urinated from my scrotum. She also induced me to play with her + genitals as we sat on a sofa in the twilight, and to spank her + naked nates with the back of a hair-brush as she lay on a bed; + but from none of these performances did I derive physical + satisfaction. The girl E. and I took delight in "talking dirty + secrets," as she expressed it. Her young cousin H. (nephew of her + adopted mother) never heard me use the word "thing" without + suggestively smiling. E. recalled the pleasant hours that she had + spent with her cousin when they were in their night-gowns. She + did not particularize these sexual relations. Under the + board-walk the boy H. and I once defecated in bottles. Some + little girls who lived opposite us pulled up their dresses one + night and "dared" each other to dance out beyond the end of the + house, in full view of the road. We boys merely looked on. + + I now fell passionately in love with a remarkably handsome little + boy of my own age. I longed to kiss and hug him, but I did not + dare to do so, for he was haughty and intolerant of my + attentions. I even allowed him to stand with one foot on me and + remark in a loud tone: "I am Conqueror!" I endured no end of + petty insults and much ill-treatment from this boy. I reached the + height of my passion on the night that he appeared at our + cottage in a tight-fitting suit of pepper-and-salt. I gloried in + his perfect legs and besought my guardian that she would buy me a + similar suit of clothes. + + For the summer after I was 8 years old I lived in a cottage in a + country town. The servant maid M. was a young girl of 16 who + listened eagerly to my accounts of the "secrets" and actions in + which the girl E. and I had taken delight a year before. I think + that M. arranged a meeting between a little black-haired girl and + me in order that we might take a walk and play sexually with each + other. Just as we were starting on our walk one of my relatives + said that I must not leave the yard. + + The little girl and I had see-sawed together and I had been + interested in her legs as she rose in the air. (When I was 13 + years old and see-sawing at a picnic with a stout girl, the + motion of the board and the sight of her straddled form filled me + with longing to embrace her sexually.) One afternoon M. took me + to the house of an acquaintance of hers. M's brother was in the + room and made a number of unremembered remarks which struck me as + being rather "free," and M. told me later that she and the girl + once dressed as ballet dancers and danced before M.'s brother. I + felt that he was lascivious. I was always remarkably intuitive. + + I fell in love with a handsome, stout, black-haired boy who lived + on a farm; but he was not a "farmer's son" in the common sense of + the word. I visited him for two or three days, and we slept with + each other, to my boundless joy. For his freckled girl cousin I + did not care the turn of my wrist, although she was a nice enough + little thing. One night when we three lay on a bed in the dark, + and neither of us boys had eyes or words for her, she silently + left us. He and I never committed the slightest sexual fault. I + left him with tears at the summer-end, and I often kissed his + photograph during the following winter. + + In the flat-house where I began to live when I was 8 years old, I + once practiced mutual tickling of a very slight character with a + boy of my own age. We sat on chairs placed opposite to each other + and we inserted our fingers through the openings in our trousers. + Just as we were beginning to enjoy the titillation we were + interrupted by the approach of one of my family who, however, was + not quick enough to discover us. Down cellar I often saw the + genitals of the janitor's little girls--they were fond of lifting + their skirts and they did not wear drawers--but I had no desire + to attempt conjunction. I once caught an older friend of mine (he + was 13) in the act of leaving one of the girls. The pair had been + in a coal-compartment. The boy was buttoning his trousers and I + guessed what he had been doing. When I began to sleep alone in my + tenth year I had no desire to masturbate, and was loath to do so + by reason of ample warnings given me by my guardian and by the + family physician. One afternoon a stunted friend of mine sat down + in the back yard and astonished me by tying a piece of string to + his penis. At a large private school which I now attended I made + the acquaintance of the principal's son, and wondered why he had + such a fancy for dressing his 5-year-old sister in boy's clothes. + He closed the door on me while he was thus engaged. At my house + we went to the bath-room together, and he showed me his + circumcised and much-ridged penis. Neither of us made any mention + of masturbating. + + At this period I fell slightly in love with a 5-year-old boy with + intensely black eyes. I would kiss him whenever we were alone, + but I had no wish to seduce him. I was always interested in + watching the urination of younger children. When I was 5 years + old I went on my knees to a strange little boy in order to + whisper in his ear an inquiry as to whether he wanted to urinate. + I experienced a pleasurable thrill when I was 10 years old in + leading a small girl cousin to the outdoor privy, in helping her + on and off the open seat, in buttoning and unbuttoning her + drawers, and in gazing at her vulva. + + The summer before I was 10 I lived a wild life in the mountains. + My companions were a negro girl, the two daughters of a + clergyman, the two sons of a questionable woman hotel-keeper, and + the daughter of the Irish scavenger. All of these children were + extraordinarily sensual. Their leading pastime, from morning + until night, was varying forms of indecency, with the supreme + caress--which they termed "raising dickie"--as the most frequent + enjoyment. The 5-year-old daughter of the scavenger explained to + us how she had seen her father approaching her stout mother with + an erect penis, the pair standing up before the lamplight during + the act. This curly-headed, rosy-cheeked child handled her + genitals so much that they were inflamed. I once saw her sitting + in the road and rubbing dust against her vulva. I saw little of + the elder daughter of the minister (she was 12 years old). She + persuaded me to expose myself before her in the cellar of a + partially-built house. In return for my favor she allowed me to + look at her genitals. She did not ask for _conjunctio_. The two + younger daughters were my intimates. With the middle one I was + forever performing a weak conjunction that consisted in the + laying of my member against her vulva. Notwithstanding all the + entreaties of my little friend, I could not be persuaded to + protrude my penis against her vagina; and not on one occasion can + I remember obtaining an erection or extreme pleasure. Up in the + garret she straddled slanting beams with her genitals exposed, + and I followed her example. The negro girl and my little friend + both urinated on a tent floor at my request. I did not fancy the + odor of a girl's genitals, nor the appearance of the vulva when + the labia were held apart. + + The following summer, when I was almost 11, I took a long walk + one day with my old friend, the girl E. We entered a patch of + woods and ate our lunch, but no sense of sexual drawing toward + the girl came over me and she did not offer to entice me. I + slept with her boy-cousin one night, and her neuropathic aunt, a + retired lady physician, bothered us by repeatedly creeping into + our room. I felt intuitively that she was watching to see whether + we would commit mutual masturbation--which we had no thought of + doing. Three years before I had opened the door of her bedroom + suddenly and saw E.'s naked form. The physician had been + examining her, E. told me later. My guardian also annoyed me by + repeated warnings not to play with myself. + + Just before I turned 11 I was sent to a small and so-called + "home" boarding-school. Eight of us lived in the smaller + dormitory. The matron roomed downstairs. There was no resident + master--a serious error. We small boys were told to strip one + evening. We were then tied neck-to-neck and made to dance a + "slave-dance," which was marked by no sexuality. A boy of 15, R., + one afternoon gave me the astonishing information that my father + had taken a part in my procreation. Up to this moment I had known + only of the maternal offices, information of which had been + beautifully supplied to me by my guardian when I was 7 years old. + At that time I talked freely about the coming of a baby brother + in a distant city; I watched the construction of baby clothes; I + named the newcomer, and I was momentarily disappointed when he + proved to be a girl. This same R., a strong boy with a large + penis, got into the custom of lying in bed with me just before + lights were put out. He would read to himself and occasionally + pause to pump his penis and make with his lips the sound of a + laboring locomotive. I felt impelled to handle his organ, for I + was fascinated by its size, and stiffness, and warmth. Rarely he + would titillate my then small and unerect penis. R. never + ejaculated when he was with me; hence not until my third year was + I acquainted with the appearance of a flow of semen. Sometimes R. + would stop during his dressing to manipulate his penis, but was + such a picture of rosy health that I doubt whether he brought + himself often to ejaculation. R. told me that he had been to a + brothel where his genitals were examined to determine whether + they were large enough and not diseased. He also related how he + "played cow" with a girl of his own age, she consenting to + perform _fellatio_ upon him. A dark-skinned, unwashed, pimpled + but fairly vigorous boy of 16, with an irritable domineering + manner, told me the delights of coitus with a girl in a + bath-house, and I overheard his conversation with another "old" + boy concerning the purchase of a girl in a big city for the sum + of five dollars. No details were given. + + I will now pass to my third year, when I was 13 years old. A + large, well-set-up boy of 16, A., became my idol. His toleration + of my presence in his room filled me with endless love. When I + lied about a matter in which he was concerned, his denunciation + of me brought me to a state of shuddering and weeping + unspeakable. When our relations were established again A. + allowed me to creep into his bed after the lights were out, and + there I passionately embraced him, but without performing any + definite act. When I turned over on my side with my back to him + he drew my prepuce back and forth until I experienced orgasm, but + not ejaculation. I would return his favor by pumping his erect + penis, but with no ejaculation on his part. He did not propose + _fellatio_, and I did not think of it. One night when he was in + my bed I began to masturbate very slightly, whereupon he laughed, + saying: "So that is the way you amuse yourself!" As a matter of + fact the habit was not fastened upon me. He always laughed when + the rubbing of his finger on my exposed glans caused me to + shrink. Another boy, H., now began to show me his erect penis and + we practiced mutual manipulations. A. laughingly told me how me + had caught H. in the act of masturbating as he stood in the + bath-tub. A. told me a number of sexual stories--how he enjoyed + coitus in the bushes with a girl on the way home from + entertainments; how half a dozen boys and girls stripped in the + basement of a church and performed coitus on the velvet chairs + which stood behind the pulpit; and how he and a younger boy, who + camped out together, played with each other's genitals. F., a boy + of 11, was highly nervous, subject to timidity and tears on the + slightest provocation, often morose, and under treatment for + kidney trouble. His penis was erect whenever I saw him undress. + He told me that a partially idiotic man taught F. and his + companion how to masturbate. The man invited the boys to his tent + and there pumped his organ until "some white stuff came out of + it." F. also told me that an Indian princess in his part of the + country would permit coitus for fifty cents. A. sometimes slept + with F., and I could imagine their embraces. S., a secretive, + handsome boy of 13, wetted his bed with urine every night. The + only sign that he gave of an interest in sexuality was his + laughing remark concerning the coupling of rose-bugs. Of his + chum, my beloved C., I will speak later. My small room-mate + handled himself only slightly. I never had a desire to lie with + him, since I disliked him, nor with my first room-mate, a + "chunky," fiery boy of 10, whose penis interested me merely + because it was circumcised and almost always erect. His + masturbation was also so slight as not to attract any particular + attention. A lusty German boy, B., showed no signs of sexuality + until his third year, when he laughed about his newly-appearing + pubic hair, and told several of us openly of how he enjoyed to + play "a drum-beat" on his penis before going to sleep. "I don't + do it too much, though," he explained. He showed a mild curiosity + when I gave him the resumé of a book on cohabitation which + contained illustrations of the erect penis and the female organs. + I had found this book in the woods and I read it eagerly during + my third year. + + I came to the point of agreeing with A., who said: "Everyone is + smutty." Indeed I lived in a lustful world, and yet my mind was + bent also on books, and writing, and the outdoor world. I was + overgrown and splendidly developed, with a medium-sized penis and + a scant growth of pubic hair. My face wore a somewhat infantile + expression. My mouth was a perfect "Cupid's bow," my hair thin + and light. I was troubled about my snub-nose, which gave the boys + a great deal of amusement. As a matter of fact I exaggerated its + upward tendency out of my morbid self-consciousness and + cowardice. My imagination was extraordinarily intense, as it had + always been. I was sensitive to smells and sounds and colors and + personalities, and to the subtle influence of the night. I was + timid and easily moved to tears, but not from any physical + weakness until after. At the lower house there was the boy Z., + famed for his large penis; and the older G., a boy of 15, who was + the leader in sexuality at his dormitory. Z. showed me his penis + and exposed his glans often enough, but we did not manipulate + each other. G. told us to notice how large a space his penis + occupied in his trousers, and laughed over Z.'s custom of + masturbating by means of a narrow vase. G.'s special lover was a + nervous boy of ten. It is remarkable that none of us mentioned + _fellatio_ or _pædicatio_. These acts may have occurred at + school, but not to my knowledge. We did not have much to say + sexually about the girls. We heard rumors of a 16-year-old, V., + who had been sent away from school for coitus; and my first + room-mate was said to have obtained _conjunctio_ with a girl + under cover of the chapel shed. Once A. and I pointed a telescope + at the open windows of the girls' dormitory, but we saw nothing + to interest us. A day-scholar, J., a pale, nervous, bright boy of + 13, took me into the study of his uncle-physician and together we + gloated over pictures of the sexual organs. A. was with us on one + occasion. J. told me how he liked to roll over and over in bed + with his hand placed under his scrotum. This act, he said, made + him imagine that he was obtaining coitus. He advised me to slide + my penis back and forth in the vagina whenever I should actually + obtain coitus. In my room at school J. once drew an imaginary map + of a bagnio, in which the water-closet was carefully displayed + _en suite_ with the bedrooms. J. and I never masturbated + together. Indeed, I cannot remember seeing his organ. A hulking + boy of 16, who lived opposite the school-grounds, became intimate + with J., and we three went on a walk up the railroad track. The + big boy, W., tried to inflame my passions by telling me how he + and J. had had coitus with a handsome black-haired widow in town, + but I remained cold. + + During this year I fell in love with C., a popular, talkative, + witty boy of my own age, or perhaps a year younger. He fancied me + and we slept together one night under the most innocent + circumstances. I never dreamed of having sexual relations with + him, and yet I fairly burned with love for him. My stay at his + beautiful home over Sunday while his parents were away was one + long delight. We slept in each other's arms, but there was no + sexuality. En route to C.'s home he pointed with a glove to a + little working-girl, saying he would like to have intercourse + with her, but this was the only remark of the kind that ever + passed his lips in my presence. When undressed save for his + undershirt, he laughingly held his unerect organ in his hand and + made the motions of obtaining conjunction with an imaginary + partner. Once we spoke of masturbation (I could recite the + information of my good physician with a marvelous show of + virtue), and C. remarked: "Yes, doing that makes boys crazy." C. + finally grew tired of my deceptive, babyish nature and + ultra-interest in books and puzzles, but I cherished an + undiminished affection for him, and when he was detained at home + for a fortnight with a broken arm, I wrote him a passionate + letter, which I sobbed over and actually wetted with my tears. + But the fervor of my passion died at the close of the year. I + consider this unsullied friendship to be the only redeeming + feature of my sensual days at school. + + Versed as I was in the warnings against masturbation, I found + pleasure one afternoon when I was alone in slipping my penis + through the open handle of a pair of scissors and in violently + flapping my partially erect organ until a strange, sweet thrill + crept over me from top to toe and a drop of clear liquid oozed + from my member. But I gave up the manipulation with scissors, + finding a greater satisfaction in masturbating while I was + defecating or just after it. I either pumped my organ by slipping + the prepuce back and forth, or I grasped the organ at its root + and violently jerked it back and forth. I soon began to + masturbate not only every time that I defecated, but also at + night just before I went to sleep, and sometimes early in the + morning. On the whole I preferred the jerking just described. I + always brought about ejaculation after perhaps five minutes of + violent exertion. + + My penis became chafed at the root, but I did not especially + care. I remember the afternoon that I masturbated for the first + time while I was defecating in the school water-closet. I cannot + recall that at first I thought of coitus while I masturbated. On + one occasion I masturbated over the _vase de nuit_ after a + delightful afternoon of tobogganing exploration up and down the + mountain. + + During this first year of abuse, I felt no ill effects + whatsoever, although I realized, in an unthinking way, that I was + doing wrong. But sexuality had assumed the proportion of a + regular feature of our school life. It was difficult for me to + place a "universal" view in its true perspective. I used to smile + at the glazed, dull morning eye of poor H., who was a stunted boy + of 15, and thus could not endure his losses so well as I could + endure them. The qualms of conscience which I suffered were lost + in my delight in my dawning sexual life. Sometimes I lay on my + stomach in bed, and by placing my hand under my scrotum, + according to the directions of J., brought up a pretty girl to + mind. Just before Sunday school G., our chief reprobate, and the + rest of us would hunt out what we considered to be nasty texts of + Scripture. The chapter concerning the whoredoms of Aholah and + Aholibah gave me an especial pleasure. T. mentioned the giggling + that occurred at prayers in the lower dormitory when the details + of Esau's birth were read out. A few days before G. was + expelled--for exactly what cause I do not know--he told me of how + greatly he enjoyed coitus on his grandmother's sofa with a girl + of fifteen. When I went home on the boat for holidays I noted the + large, black-haired penis of the strong boy of our school. He + occupied a state-room with me, but made no sexual overtures. + + Since my twelfth year I had been wrapped up all summer long in a + boy who was six months my senior. We slept together constantly, + but not once did we think of obtaining mutual gratification. On + the contrary, we held up high ideals to each other and frowned on + masturbation. I took delight in saying that I never had handled + myself, and never would do so. Even at the height of my + "auto-erotic" period, I skillfully concealed my habits from all + my boy friends. A neurotic solo choir boy friend once spoke of + obtaining ejaculation, whereupon I expressed utter ignorance of + such an act, little hypocrite that I was. This boy told how the + house servants joked with him about coitus and made laughing + lunges at his organs. + + But much as I loved my chum, my most passionate regard went out + in my thirteenth year to N., a chubby, blue-eyed, choir-boy of + 12. He was a pretty boy to any eye. He was not gifted, except in + water-sports, and anything but popular either with girls or with + boys; yet I grew warm at the mention of his name. He did not care + a fig for me. From first to last I had no consciousness of the + sexual nature of my passion, and the thought of doing more than + embrace and kiss him in an innocent manner never crossed my mind. + For two summers I had nights of tossing on my bed (although I + almost never was sleepless for any cause) when I would see his + dear face and form, in and out of the swimming pool, or engaged + perhaps in singing or in showing his beautiful teeth. I seldom + was smitten with little girls, and I found myself embarrassed in + their company after my ninth year; yet I thought well enough of + their looks and ways to enjoy their company at dances. The girls + liked me in a platonic way, for I was accounted a good, big, + kind, blundering boy with a helping hand for the smallest fry. + + During the summer after I was 13, I imagined myself in the early + morning, when I was half awake, as persuading my wife to have + coitus with me. In the course of my spoken words I kept my hand + under my scrotum. + + A plump girl-cousin of my own age was visiting at my uncle's + during the summer after I was 13. With her I greatly desired to + satisfy myself, but I could not be sure that my boy cousin (5 + years old) might not find us out, even though she should consent. + Once when we three were in the hay-loft a wave of lust rolled + over me, but I made no proposal. Night and gaslight greatly + increased my _libido_. On one occasion my aunt had gone to the + village for ice-cream, and L. and I were left alone in the + dining-room. I took her on my lap and had a powerful erection. I + almost asked her to play sexually with me in the barn, but + instead I spoke of an imaginary girl, the first letters of whose + successive names spelled an indecent word for coitus--a word + known to almost every Anglo-Saxon child, I fear. L. laughed, but + gave no sign of assent. For a neighboring girl of 15 I felt such + a drawing that early in the morning I would roll on the floor + with my erect organ in my hand in riotous imagining of coitus + with her. I walked with her in the woods and sat at her feet, but + although I felt instinctively that she would satisfy me without + much persuasion, yet I _could not_ ask her. One night I started + to church in order to walk home with her, and lead her (if + possible) to a field where we might gratify ourselves (I picked + out the exact grassy spot where we might lie); but when I was + almost at the church door my "moral sense" (if that is what it + was) rose and dragged me home again. + + During the swimming hour I watched the genitals of the boys, + comparing them carefully in the most minute details. Circumcised + organs affected me as being disagreeable, and men's hairy, coarse + genitals I abhorred. + + When 13 I became acquainted with the new mail-boy at the inn. He + was a city "street-boy," and got me into smoking cigarettes + occasionally. I did not definitely take up smoking until I was + 16. He told me that a mason once offered him ten cents if he + would masturbate the man in a cellar. The boy said that he + refused. I slept a few times with an ill-favored boy of fine + parentage. He was of my own age, and I had played with him in a + natural way for several years, but my increasing sexual desires + led me to mutually masturbate with him, and even unsuccessfully + to attempt with him mutual pædicatio. On the morning after our + nights of sensuality I felt "gone" and miserable, but not + repentant. By afternoon I was myself again. My relations with G. + were purely animal, for I disliked his jealous disposition, his + horse-laugh, his features, his form, his withdrawn scrotum and + his undersized penis. At home in the evening I often found myself + inflamed with a mental picture of active _fellatio_ with him, but + I never performed this act, so far as I remember. + + One of my great sexual desires was to walk along a fence on which + a girl was seated. In order that I might feast my eyes on her + pudenda she must not wear drawers. + + When I turned 14 I had been, from my unusual size, in long + trousers for several months. I entered a private day-school and + progressed brilliantly in my studies. I kept up masturbation + almost daily, sometimes twice a day, both in the water closet and + in bed. I can remember ejaculating before urination in the school + _cabinet_. At night I often found myself longing for the return + of my sister, seven years my junior, in order that I might + embrace her in bed and fondle her genitals. I had done these + things during my Christmas vacation of the year before. I mildly + reproached myself for such incestuous desires, but they recurred + continually. I dreamed little. And I cannot remember the + character of my dreams. My waking _libido_ spent itself mostly in + longings to embrace (without lustful acts) the forms of little + boys of exquisite blonde beauty and thick hair. Narcissism may + have been present, for in my twelfth year I had been told that at + the age of 5 and 6 I was an extraordinarily beautiful little + creature with long, lint-white hair. The preferable age was from + 6 to 9. My eye was alert on the streets for boys answering to + this description, and a street boy with long, white hair so won + my passion that I followed him to his home and asked his mother + if he might call on me and "play some games." As I did not even + know the boy's name and had never seen him before, I was + wonderingly refused. I sought in vain to find the whereabouts of + another long-haired street boy whom I burned to embrace and load + with benefits. I had a boundless desire for such a boy as this to + idolize me--to look into my face out of big eyes and lose himself + in love for me--to call me by endearing pet names--of his own + accord to throw his arms around my neck. This second actual boy + disappeared from my horizon by presumably moving away from the + vast city neighborhood. I took a fancy to a small boy at school, + who possessed the requisite delicacy, timidity, and sweetness, if + not the physical requisites, of my beau ideal. I walked with him + in the park and planned to have him at the house; but the matter + was not arranged. At boarding-school I had associated much with + younger and weaker boys, and had been ridiculed much for my + cowardice in sports, but at the city school I moved with my + equals and won their recognition. Our gymnasium director was + middle-aged and of an indolent disposition. He liked to recall + his youthful erections and to answer my sexual queries too fully, + and cheerfully volunteered information on brothels. Yet I doubt + whether he had an evil purpose in conversing with me. I thought I + should never dare or want to enter one. I always conjured up the + picture of a row of naked women from whom I could take my pick, + and the smell of the women I imagined to be identical with the + smell of my big friend A. at boarding-school. When I was + traveling down town on an elevated train one afternoon the + brakeman asked me whether I had ever been in a brothel, and told + me that disorderly houses abounded in my neighborhood. "I have + had connection with women," said this red-haired young man, + waving his hand in greeting to a woman who nodded at him from a + window, "since I was 15 years old. Not long ago a fine-looking, + young woman in black offered to pay all my expenses if I would + live with her and connect with her." + + When a girl of perhaps 7, a distant cousin of mine, visited us + for a few days, I gratified my lust by placing my hand under her + genitals and swinging her to and fro. She giggled with pleasure. + That summer I began to experience the evil effects of the + masturbation which I had practiced daily for a year and a half. + Pimples began to break out on my chin (my complexion up to this + time had been white and delicate). The family ascribed my + condition to digestive difficulties. In playing with the boys and + girls I found myself seized with a terrible shyness and a + tendency to look down and weep. I had lost all the courage I + had--it had never been great--in the presence of a crowd of + children. I was fairly at ease with a single companion. My + self-consciousness was something more painful to me than I can + convey in words. At home I wept in my room and cursed myself for + a baby. I little realized the cause of my nervous collapse. Yet I + had too robust a frame not to be able to sleep and to play hard. + The sympathetic pleasure which I had found in swinging my + girl-cousin to and fro I now doubled by letting a 7-year-old boy + ride cock-horse on my feet. I experienced an erection during the + process, and I almost induced ejaculation when I tickled the boy + with my feet in the region of his genitals. To see his shrinking, + giggling joy gave me an exquisite sexual thrill. I longed to + sleep with the boy, but I was afraid of causing comment. At the + new and large boarding school which I entered in the fall my most + lustful dreams and ejaculations were concerned with standing this + little boy on the footboard of a bed, taking down his + knickerbockers, and performing _fellatio_ on him. But I dreamed + also of natural coitus. I fell in love with the handsome, + 12-year-old son of the aged headmaster. The boy, O., sat next me + at the table, and I never tired of gazing at him. It gave me a + special sense of pleasure to look at him when he wore a certain + flowing, scarlet, four-in-hand necktie. But O. was not attracted + to me--for one thing I was in a disagreeably pimpled + condition--and I could not induce him to linger in my room nor to + sleep with me. My passion for O. did not diminish, and it rose to + its supremacy on the evening when he appeared in our hallway (he + roomed on the girls' side of the house and hinted at the sexual + sights that he saw) in a costume of white satin, lace, and wings. + He was ready for a costume party. + + I now masturbated less frequently, for I was beginning to + appreciate the horrible consequences of my indulgence. I had + frequent pollutions, with dreams. My day was one long agony of + fear. How I dreaded to go to sleep in the same bed with my older + chum, who never made any advances beyond embracing me passively + _cum erectione_ while he was asleep. My day was one long agony of + fear. At meal time my feet constantly writhed in agony for fear + that the headmaster's grown up young ladies should make fun of + me, or that my lack of facial composure and my inability to look + people in the eye might be commented upon. I tingled with + apprehension, especially in the region of my stomach. Every nerve + was taut in the effort I made to appear composed. I masturbated + with erections over nothing. Greek recitations were for me an + _auto da fe_. My heart beat like a trip-hammer at the thought of + getting up to recite, and once on my feet my voice shook and my + mind wandered. I hated the thought of people behind me looking at + me. I rarely summoned the courage to turn my head either one way + or the other. I vastly admired the "bravery" of the small, + 15-year-old boy who recited so calmly and so well. I was too + cowardly to play foot-ball and base-ball, and I dreaded even my + favorite tennis because the spectators put me in a state of + scared self-consciousness. Knowing my own condition, I was yet so + blind to it most of the time, and such a Jekyll-and-Hyde, that I + actually pitied a boy of 19 who was an eccentric and a scared + victim of masturbation. But in spite of my neuropathic condition + I developed intellectually. I do not touch upon this aspect of my + life, however, because I am trying to limit myself strictly to + sexual manifestations. At the present time I have not the courage + to continue the narrative. + + + HISTORY III.--The following narrative is written by a clergyman, + age 40, unmarried:-- + + My childhood and early boyhood were unmarked by sexual phenomena, + beyond occasional erections, which commenced when about 5 years + of age, without any exciting causes. These were accompanied by + some degree of excitement, of the same nature as that which I + experienced in later years. I was absolutely ignorant of sexual + matters, but always had an idea that the essential difference + between man and woman was to be found in the genital organs. This + was sometimes a matter for thought and curiosity. + + Being for many years an only child I saw little of other + children, and formed the habit of amusing myself with making + things--boats, houses, etc.--and acquired a taste for science. + When I could read I preferred biography, history, and poetry to + anything else. + + When I was 13 years old and at a large school I heard for the + first time of coitus, but very imperfectly. For a few days it + filled my thoughts and mind, but feeling it was too engrossing a + subject and one which took me off better things, I put it out of + my mind. Later, another boy gave me a fuller description of the + matter, and I began to have a great desire to know more and to be + old enough to practice it. I also discovered that boys + masturbated, and about a year after tried the experiment for + myself. This vice was largely indulged in by my school-fellows. + It never occurred to me that it was sinful, until I was nearly + 16, when I came across a passage in Kenns's _Manual of + Schoolboys_, in which it was hinted such things were wrong + morally and spiritually. Previously I had felt it was an + indelicate and shameful thing, and bad for health. This last idea + was held as a solemn fact by all my boy friends. Gradually + religion began to exert an influence over my sexual nature, + obtaining as years passed a greater and greater restraining + power. It is simply impossible for me to write a history of my + sexual development without also describing the action which + Christianity has had in determining its growth. The two have been + so intimately bound together that my life history would not be a + faithful record of facts if I left religion out of it. + + At school I took part, with great keenness, in cricket and + foot-ball, and was very ambitious to excel in everything in which + I took an interest, but I always had other tastes as well, which + were more precious to me, for example, the love for science, + history, and poetry. Until I was past 16 years my desire was + simply for coitus, girls and women attracted me only as affording + the means of gratifying this desire; but when I was nearly 17 I + began to regard girls as beautiful objects, apart from this, and + to desire their love and companionship. At the same time it + dawned upon me that life held much of joy in the love of women + and in domestic life--so henceforth I regarded them in a higher + and purer light, and apart from sexual gratification. In fact, + from this period till I was over 20, this idea so dominated my + whole being that the lower side of my nature was entirely held in + subjection and abeyance by it. It was rather repulsive to think + of girls as objects of lust. This state of mind was not brought + about by any romantic attachment or through any acquaintance or + through circumstances. I was living in great seclusion and had no + girl friends. After this period the lower side of my nature woke + up as a giant refreshed with wine, and I underwent for many years + a constant struggle with my nature, in which religion always + triumphed in the end. I never fell into fornication, though + sometimes into the vice of masturbation. These outbursts of + desire were periodic, about ten or fourteen days apart, and would + last several days. I must record also the fact that from the time + this awakening took place my ideal views of woman no longer + seemed incompatible with sexual relations. I noticed that at + about 27 there was a lessening of the desire, but that may have + been due to overwork and consequent nervous exhaustion. I had a + good deal of worry and studied daily for about eight hours. In + any case the impulse was strongest during the years above + mentioned. A little later in life, for a time, I became attached + to a girl, and eventually engaged. I then observed, greatly to my + sorrow and annoyance, that whenever I met this lady, or even + thought of her, erections took place. This was particularly + painful to me, as my thoughts were not of a lustful or impure + character. Sometimes sitting by her at a religious service this + would occur, when certainly my mind was far away from anything of + the kind. That was the first woman ever kissed by me, except of + course members of my immediate family circle. Later on my + thoughts turned to marriage, and there was a great longing at + times for this event to take place. However, as this attachment + afterward became the great sorrow of my life for years, it needs + no more comment. This closes one chapter of my history, and at + present I do not propose to add another, as in a great measure it + is only partly written. It may be well here to state that there + has never been in me the slightest homosexual desire; in fact it + has always appeared as a thing utterly inconceivable and + disgustingly loathsome. I am fond of the society of both men and + women, but on the whole prefer the latter. I have had several + warm and intimate though platonic friendships, and get on + exceedingly well with the other sex, although not a good-looking + man. I have always been attracted to women by their spiritual or + mental qualities, rather than by physical beauty, and feel + strongly that the latter alone would never cause me to desire + coitus. Unless there was an attraction other than that of the + flesh, I should feel that I was following simply a brute + instinct, and it would jar with my higher nature and cause + revulsion. This was not the case in my earlier years to the same + extent. I have often wondered whether the sexual impulse was + strong in me or not, but if not, there is nothing in my physical + state or family history to account for it. I am fairly cognizant + with the lives of my ancestors, being descended from two old + families. The sexual instinct was certainly not weak or abnormal + in them. Personally, I am tall and healthy, well built, but + sensitive and highly strung. Smell has never played any part in + my life as a stimulant of sexual desire, and the mere thought of + body odors would have a very decided effect in the opposite + direction. Touch and sight appeal to me strongly, and of the two + the former most. + + I am convinced, after many years careful thought, that sexual + vice and perversion could be greatly reduced if the young were + instructed in the elements of physiology as they bear on this + question. Personally, had I been thus enlightened much sin would + have been avoided in my schoolboy days, and a perverted view of + sexual matters would never have arisen in my mind. It took years + to overcome the feeling that all such things were unclean and + defiling. Eventually light came to me through reading a passage + in a tractate on the Creed by Rufinus. He was defending the + doctrine, of the Incarnation against the pagan objection that it + was an unclean and disgusting idea that God should enter the + world through the womb of the Blessed Virgin Mary, and he meets + it by showing that God created the sexual organs, therefore the + objection is invalid--otherwise God would not be clean or pure, + having Himself designed them and their functions. This passage is + slight in itself, but gave birth to a line of thought which has + influenced me profoundly. I no longer regard sexual matters as + disgusting and unholy, but as intensely sacred, being the outcome + of the Divine Mind. Further, the Incarnation of the Saviour has + not only sanctioned motherhood and all that is implied by it, but + has eternally sanctified it as the means chosen for the + manifestation of God to the world. I should not obtrude my + theological conceptions, but for the fact that they have + determined my life-history in that aspect. + + + HISTORY IV.--When I was 9 years old a boy at the preparatory + school, which I attended, showed me the act of masturbation, + which he said he had practiced for a long time, and which he + urged me to imitate, if I wished to become a father when I grew + up, and married! Boy-like I believed him and tried, but the + sensation obtained was not a pleasant one (I suppose that I was + too rough with myself) and I desisted. + + When I was about 12 years old, a schoolfellow told me that he had + seen his nurse copulating with the groom, and he and I used to + haunt the woods in the hope that we might see an amorous couple + so engaged, but without success. We often talked of the act, as + to how it was done. Neither he nor I had any clear ideas on the + subject, save as to the organs involved. I was about 15 when a + maidservant of the house in which I was a boarder, came to my + bedroom one night and taught me how to masturbate her. She said + that this was a good thing for me to do, and warned me never to + "play with myself" as it would kill me, or drive me mad. I told + her that I had tried it, but could not bring on a pleasurable + feeling, so she did it to me, and although I did not have an + emission, I derived great pleasure from the act. She told me that + it never did a boy any harm to let a girl play with his parts, + and promised that if I would keep the secret, she would often do + this for me. Naturally I promised to say nothing, and she often + came up to my room. Later on she used to insert my penis into her + vulva, while she was rubbing it, at the same time giving me a + pigeon kiss. This _modus operandi_ was much appreciated by me. + One night, after we had been together thus, I dreamt of her and + her maneuvers and had my first emission. I was very proud of + this, as I considered that I had at last attained to man's + estate, and told her of it. She never allowed me to insert my + penis into her vulva after that, alleging that she did not want + to have a baby. + + I was about 16½ years old when I had my first real coitus, my + partner in the act being a girl some two years older than I, who + lived near us. I enjoyed the act very much, as she permitted, nay + insisted on, emission _intra vaginam_, and told her that this was + much nicer than my amours with the maidservant which of course I + had confided to her. She laughed, and said: "Of course." We often + copulated, as long as I was at home, and then I lost sight of + her. Of all the women with whom I have had to do, save one, she + had the most copious secretion of mucus, which in those days I + believed was the woman's semen. Her thighs used to be wet with + it. + + At the University I had regular relations with women of all + sorts, rarely missing a week. Two of them were married women, one + the wife of a solicitor, the other of a doctor. How proud I felt + of my first intrigue with a married woman! I felt that I was + really a man of the world now! + + But though my friends used to tell me all about their love + affairs, and I longed to confide in them, I did not do so. This + was because when I went up to the University, my uncle said that + he would give me a word of advice and hoped that I would follow + it--never to give away a woman, and never to refuse to respond to + a woman's advances, whoever she were. To neglect this advice + would, he said, be foolish, and to break the rules "damned + ungentlemanly." I wish I had always followed advice proffered, as + closely as I have followed this. One night, when I was somewhat + disguised in liquor, as our grandfathers would have put it, I + picked up a girl, who was a private prostitute, if the phrase be + permissible. She declined copulation, and proposed other means of + satisfaction. I insisted, being stubborn in my cups. Had I been + sober I should have done as she suggested, for I have always made + it a point to allow the woman to choose the method of + gratification, and not to demand, or even suggest, anything + myself. I like to please women, and I have always been curious as + to their wants and desires, as revealed, without outside + influence, by themselves. The result of my refusing all methods + of gratification save the most ordinary was that the girl, who + must have known that she was not all right, but shrank from + saying so in so many words, gave me a gonorrhoea, which lasted + nine weeks and much interfered with my amours, as I naturally + declined to run the risk of infecting my partner, a risk which to + my certain knowledge many a young fellow has run, with disastrous + consequence to the confiding woman. As it was due to my tipsy + obstinacy, I could not blame the girl, but resolved never to + drink too much again, a resolve which I have kept, save once, + unbroken. In those days we youngsters thought that it was manly + to be able to carry one's liquor well, and did all in our power + to attain to the seasoned head; but I considered that the risks + entailed were too serious to be neglected. + + I was well on in my 26th year when I met a widow with whom I fell + in love, with the result that I married her. She is a most + sensible woman, and it was her intellectual gifts which were the + attraction to me. In my amours intellect has never played a part. + She has all along been cognizant of, and lenient to, my + polygamous tendencies; for she recognizes the fact that whatever + _fredaine_ I may have on hand makes not the slightest difference + in my love and respect for her. Were she a more sensual woman, + perhaps things would be different. + + In all I have had to do with 81 other women, of whose special + characteristics I kept a careful note at the time. Twenty-six + were normal women with whom my _liasons_ have lasted long, so I + know more about them than I do about the other fifty-five, who + were prostitutes, and with some of whom my dealings were but for + an afternoon. + + The races represented have been these, for I have seen a bit of + the world: English, Scotch, Irish, Welsh, French, German, + Italian, Greek, Danish, Hungarian, Roumanian, Indian, and + Japanese. Taking them all round, the only difference that I found + between old and young women is that the older ones are less + selfish, and more complaisant, and less inclined to resent one's + being unable to attain to the height of their desire, for from + time to time I have been unable to "come up to the scratch" after + a heavy night's labor, or when I was afraid of being caught in + the act of coition, a fear which, in my experience, acts as a + stimulus to desire in women, unlike its action in men. Of all the + women with whom I have had to do the nicest in every way have + been the French women. The English women of the town drink too + much, and are far too keen on getting as much money as they can + for as little as they can, to please me. Were the London girls to + recognize that men do not like a tipsy woman, and that where + there is so much competition the person who is most skillful and + most polite gets the most custom, the alien invasion in Regent + street would soon come to an end. + + Of the fifty-five prostitutes: eighteen informed me that they + were in the habit of masturbating; eight of their own free will, + without asking for reward, did _fellatio_; six asked me to do + _cunnilingus_, which I naturally declined to do; three proposed + anal coitus. Of those who did _fellatio_, two (one French and one + German) told me that they had taken to it because they had heard + that human semen was an excellent remedy against consumption, + which disease had carried off some of their relatives, and that + they had gradually come to like doing it. All who told me that + they masturbated, asked me whether I did so too, and two desired + me to show them the act, one alleging that she liked to see a man + do it; she had been married late in life, after a "stormy youth" + and had had, she said, a large experience of the male sex. They + all seemed to think that however much the practice of + self-excitement might hurt a man, and all thought that it would + hurt him, a woman might masturbate as often as she liked, failing + better means of satisfaction, as she had no such loss of + substance as a man. + + Of the twenty-six normal women, whom I knew more intimately than + I did the fifty-five prostitutes, thirteen, without being + questioned by me, blurted out the fact that they were habitual + masturbators, apparently all required to think of the loved + person to obtain full satisfaction. _Fellatio_ was proposed, and + fully performed, by nine, of whom three experienced the orgasm as + soon as they perceived that I had attained to it. All were more + or less excited while doing it. One proposed anal coitus, "just + to see what it was like;" and three proposed _cunnilingus_, one + having been initiated by a girl friend, and one by her husband. + The third had, I believe, evolved the act out of her own inner + consciousness in her desire to experience pleasure with me. My + relations with one of the twenty-six were confined to my + masturbation of her, the while she did _fellatio_, as she said + that she "had no feeling inside down there." + + With two exceptions my partings from these normal women have not + been tragic and all whom I have met in after life (seven) have + been very ready to resume relations with me, four of them having + made the proposal themselves. + + One thing has struck me, and that is the, often great, difference + that exists between what a woman's looks lead one to think she + is, and what she is when one becomes her lover; the most sensual + woman that I have met might have sat for her portrait as the + Madonna, and she was the only one who took pleasure in hearing + and relating "smoking-room stories," a form of amusement which, + perhaps from their want of appreciation of humor and wit, women + do not indulge in--at least in my experience. + + + HISTORY V.--(A continuation of History III in Appendix B to the + previous volume.) + + As I became better I commenced to dream of true love. I wondered, + too, if my horrible past really could be lived down and a young + woman come to love _me_. I took pleasure in reading love poems, + especially Browning's, and illustrated some with little + water-colors.... + + I was sitting in the stalls one night seeing a performance by a + company of English actors when one of them played so badly that I + thought to myself: "Why, hang it, I could play it better myself!" + The next minute another thought followed: "Why not try?" I came + out of the stalls the proverbial stage-struck youth. I was + sitting in the same place another night when the young man next + to me entered into conversation. By a strange coincidence he knew + a few young men, amateurs, who were going to form a company, give + up their situations and travel, if they could induce a few more + to join them and put a little money in. I made an appointment for + the following evening.... + + There were lots of meetings in bedrooms and rehearsals between + the beds, but ultimately I was told a school-room had been + engaged and a professional actress, A.F. I went to the + school-room and found all the boys there, and a young woman with + a pale, rice-powder complexion. On introduction she gazed at me + as if struck dumb. If she had been better-looking (I thought her + vulgar and puffy) I would have been flattered. I was + disappointed, but rather frightened (she had a stage presence) of + her professional ability, especially when we commenced to + rehearse. I had to make love to her, too, which embarrassed me. + She had a good profile, I noticed, and would have been better + looking, I thought, if she were in better condition, for she was + young, about my own age, twenty-three or four. We were all + young--enjoyed our rehearsals, and had lots of fun--but I did not + respond to the advances A. was evidently making to me. Finally we + started on our tour. As the weeks went on A.F., like the others, + improved wonderfully in health and appearance. If we had had + anything like houses it would have been a pleasant trip. My + strangeness did not escape the notice of the boys altogether, for + I was still a bit strange in mind and nerves--and deeply + religious, bowing my head before each meal and reading my little + Bible and prayer-book at odd times. I drank no alcohol. I spent a + good deal of time by myself of with my faithful companion A., who + was nearly always at my side, she and her appealing eyes. I was + surprised to see how quickly she had improved; she looked quite + attractive and ladylike some evenings at meals, but I only + tolerated her. I was selfish and conceited. + + Things had been going on like this for a week--always playing to + empty houses and our money lower and lower--when A. said to our + other lady, Mrs. T., on a train in my presence: "I shall have to + give him up, I suppose; he will have nothing to do with me." Mrs. + T. said: "You give him up, do you?" and looked at me as if she + were going to try her hand. A. said "Yes," and looked at me, + smiling sadly. I don't know what motive prompted me--whether my + vanity was alarmed at her threatened desertion or that she had + really made some impression on me by her love, probably a little + of both--but I said: "No, don't; come and sit down here," making + way for her, and she joyfully came and nestled against me. From + that time I ceased to treat her with ridicule, and kissed her at + other times than when on the stage. I was subject still to black + moods, and would not speak to her for hours sometimes, but she + seemed content to walk with me and was infinitely patient. I had + heard she was living with--if not married to--an actor. I asked + her about him once, and she said she did not love him; she loved + me and had never loved before. Her face had a touching sadness; + her life had been unhappy and stormy, with no love and little + rest in it. Her face, when she had lost her dissipated look and + unhealthy pallor, was exquisite, delicate as a cameo. Love had + improved her manners, too; she was more gentle and refined. I let + things drift without thinking of the future, when one night + after the performance--I was lying on the sofa and A. was sitting + at my side, as usual--I suddenly thought, with the brutality that + characterized me in these matters--"I will ask her to let me + sleep with her." I still fought against any premonitory thought + of self-abuse, but here, I thought to myself, is a chance of + something better that will do me no harm and perhaps good. When + she understood me she turned very red and walked away, shaking + her head. But I let her understand that was the only way of + retaining me, and finally, when they had all gone to bed, she + gave herself to me, reluctantly and sadly; for she, too, had been + drifting on without thinking of anything of this sort (she hated + it at this time), but just living for her love of me, her first + true love. + + Before this occurred, I must tell you, I had been so much better + that I sometimes felt capable of doing anything, a sense of power + and grasp of intellect which was combined with delicacy of + feeling and sensitiveness to beauty, to skies and clouds and + flowers. I seemed to be awakening to true manhood, to my true + self. And at meals, it is worth recording, I commenced to have a + distaste for meat. + + These glimpses of a better state of things left me on cohabiting + with A., and for a time my gloom and black religious mania came + on me once more. I now thought of my promise at confirmation, and + it seemed to me I had offended beyond pardon. When we came to the + next town, however, I openly slept with A. all night, leaving my + own bed untouched. When we returned to Adelaide one of our party + remarked: "The only man who had any success with the women on the + tour was a Bible-reading, praying, and good, pious, confirmed + Christian." + + A.'s nascent beauty and delicacy and improvement were gradually + impaired, too. My own conduct became so morose at times that, + besides increasing her misery, I offended the others, and + bickerings ensued. I heard the other actress say "He's mad; that + what's the matter." And I was so wrapped up in myself and my + religious mania that I did not mind their thinking so. + + After the tour was over A. asked me to come and see her at her + home, and as I missed her very much I went one night to tea. She + had a room in her father's house to herself. A. was dressed in + her best and we had an affectionate meeting. After tea I asked + her if she were married to E. She said "No." Then I said: "Who + are you married to?" She commenced to cry then, and told me + something of her life, the saddest I ever heard. When only 17 she + had been courted by a young man she did not care for, but who + prevailed on her parents by pretending he had seduced her, but + wished to marry her. Strange as it may seem, A. did not know what + marriage meant, her mother being one of those silly women who + don't like talking of these things and let their daughters grow + up in ignorance, expecting they will learn from some one. In nine + cases out of ten this happens, but A. was an exception. It was + this, and the fact that she had not a particle of love for her + husband, that gave her such a hatred of coition. When her mother + saw the sheets the morning after the marriage she burst out + crying; she did not like the young man and saw she had been + deceived. + + A.'s husband soon showed his true character; he was in reality a + gaol-bird. He beat her, drank, and even wanted her to go on the + streets to earn money for him. She left him and went home; it was + then she began her theatrical career by entering the ballet. At + intervals her husband, drunk and desperate, would waylay and + threaten her in the street. One day after a rehearsal he + attempted to stab her. She got on in spite of all, being a born + actress, and played small parts in traveling companies. Then E., + who had also gone on the stage, courted her and she listened to + him, not because she cared for him, but he protected her and + offered her a home. She joined him; but his drunkenness and + sensuality were so gross that he ruined his health and he + attempted to maltreat A. in a nameless way. And whenever she was + in the family way he would leave her alone and half-conscious in + the cellar for days. To add to her misery she had epileptic fits. + Then sometimes they would be out of an engagement and starving. + They had been so hungry as to steal raw potatoes out of a sack + and eat them thus, having no fire. She would often have had + engagements, but E. was jealous and would not let her act without + him. And he beat her as her husband had done, and her health + became undermined. It was just after one of the forced + miscarriages that she joined our traveling company, and that + accounted for her yellow and puffy appearance. E. was now away + up-country with a circus, but was expected down any time. A. told + me a good deal of all this, between her tears, while sitting at + my feet, and her tone carried conviction. When I ought to have + gone home I persuaded her to let me stay all night. We had been + in bed some time when her mother knocked at the door and wanted + to come in for something in a chest of drawers there. "Why don't + you open the door, A.? Who have you got there? Hasn't that fellow + gone?" A. was confused and told me to get under the bed, but I + refused, and she covered me up with the bed clothes as well as + she could and opened the door. She had hid my clothes, but missed + one of my shoes, and her mother saw it. "Oh, A.," was all she + said; "you've got that fellow in bed," and went out crying. + "Well, Fred" (my stage name), "you've got me into a nice row," A. + said. She gave me my breakfast in the morning and I walked out of + the front door without being molested. Another night I entered + her window by a ladder and stayed all night. In the middle of the + night E. came home drunk. She would not let him in and told him + she would have nothing more to do with him. He attempted to break + in the door, when A. called to me, and hearing a man in the room + he went away, saying, as he went downstairs: "Oh, A.! Oh, A.!" + as if he thought she would not have done such a thing. He never + molested us after that night. + + I think it was my intention, at first, to break off with A. + gradually. I found, however, I could not keep away from her, and + it commenced to be evident to me that a bachelor's life in + lodgings again would be dreary and lonely. And all this time the + fear that I had offended God troubled me more than I have said, + and it occurred to me (there may have been a touch of sophistry + in this, or not) that if I were a true husband to her for the + future--stuck to her and worked for her for the rest of my + days--perhaps it would find favor in God's sight and be an + atonement for my sin. Had she been free I would have married her, + I believe. But she began to be harassed by her mother and + bothered about my incessantly coming there and staying all night. + It ended in my telling her I would be a husband to her, and she + came and lived with me at my lodgings. We had one room and our + meals cost us sixpence each. Cheap as it was, it was a struggle + for me to earn money at all. I remember feeling ill and anxious + once, and sustaining myself by the thought of my father wheeling + the heavy truck up the street when he married my mother. And I + decided to wheel my truck, too. + + A. seemed happy and her love increased, if possible; at first, + though, she must have found me a trying lover, for I made her + kneel and pray with me two or three times a day, which she did + with such a queer expression of face. Sometimes her feelings got + the better of her, and she would say: "Oh, damn it, Fred, you are + always praying." And then I would be shocked and she would be + sorry.... Coitus was frequent; she commenced to like it now.... + + A. was not looking well one evening when she came in, and lay + down on the bed. Presently she commenced to make a strange noise, + and I saw her eyes were closed and her hands clenched. "Ah," said + the landlady, who came in to help me; "she has epileptic fits." + When her convulsions were over she looked blankly at us, knitting + her brows and evidently puzzling her poor brain to remember who + we were. For many years it was my fate to see her looking at me + thus, at first stony and estranged, like a dweller in another + star, then half-recalling with extended hand, then forgetting + again with hand to mouth, then the gradual dawn of memory and + love, and final full recognition. "It's Fred, my Fred!" I never + got used to it; it always moved me to tears.... It was not to be + thought that we had no quarrels. I still had fits of bad temper, + and sometimes they came into collision with A.'s temper. It hurt + my vanity considerably to see how soon she relinquished the + respectful, patient, spaniel-bearing she had when we were + traveling. I said some cruel things to her and she retorted. One + would have thought, to hear us, that all affection was over. But + when the mood of rage wore itself out we would both be sorry and + make it up with tears, and be very happy in spite of our poverty. + + I think it was lust that prevented me from striving to fulfill my + ambitions. A. let me do anything I liked, at all times of day or + night, although she seemed surprised at my proceedings sometimes, + for it was becoming a fever of lubricity with me. She still + thought only of her love. I remember her coming in one day, + tired, pale, perspiring, and worried--we had hardly anything in + the house and she had been to the theater ineffectually--and when + her eyes lighted on me the whole expression of her face changed, + softened and brightened at once, and she came and kissed me and + said: "It is so strange, I was thinking all sorts of nasty things + coming along, but as soon as I see my pet's face I feel happy--I + don't care for anything--I would sooner share a crust with him + than have all the money in the world!" + + I commenced to feel libidinous curiosity to examine her--this was + mostly on Sundays--and she let me, blushing at first, but + laughing. Then I would try new positions in coitus I had heard + of. Still she did not enter into my mood. + + She was engaged at this time to play in a pantomime and I + commenced to lead a miserable, jealous existence. I heard scandal + about her, baseless enough, but in the diseased, nervous, anxious + state I had brought myself to it nearly drove me mad. I would go + with her sometimes to visit her mother, whom I began to like. Her + brother I still saluted coldly. It caused me horror and jealousy + to see A. kissing him and letting him tickle her. In my rage, + when we came home, I even said that perhaps she would let him do + something else, naming it brutally and coarsely. I remember her + shame, astonishment, indignation and tears. If ever a man tried a + woman's love I did. But she forgave me, even that. + + We went to live in a little cottage. It was in this cottage that + A. first showed signs of lust, and in the diseased state of my + mind, instead of regretting it, I encouraged her. She told me one + day that the orgasm very often did not occur at the same time + with her as with me, and that it would not unless I put my little + finger into the anus. This her husband taught her, and she would + rather have died than confess it to me when we first met. We + would often devote our Sundays to having a picnic as we termed + our lustful bouts, stimulating ourselves with wine. Her temper + was not improved thereby (though her fits entirely stopped for a + twelvemonth)--we had wordy warfares, but we made it up again + always with tears. Nor did I allow myself to deteriorate without + reactions and excursions into better things. I was always reading + Emerson; it was he who rescued me from orthodox Christianity and + taught me to trust in myself and in Nature. I have never ceased + this struggle towards better things to this day. There, in a + nutshell, is my life; I have always been defeated when + temptation came, but I have never ceased to struggle. I + determined to be more abstemious in sexual indulgence and asked + her to help me. She agreed willingly, for she was easily led. + Whenever we fell back again into excess it was my fault. + + At a theatrical performance we first met a Miss T., a young + German who sang. She was about 25, with modest, quiet and + engaging manners. A. and she became very friendly. I liked her; + she was tall, dark and lithe, but had bad teeth. + + I had been ill and at this time A. and I had a quarrel, my temper + suddenly breaking out in murderous frenzy. I called her names and + finally put her outside the house, telling her to go to her + mother. I suffered a very hell of remorse and misery. Everything + in the quiet, lonely house reminded me of her, seemed fragrant of + her; my anguish became so keen I could not stop in the house, + though I was just as wretched walking about. I kept this up for + two days, when I met her coming to look for me. One look was + enough--"A.!" "Pet!" in broken sobs--and in tears we kissed and + made it up. Miss T. was with her, and I greeted her, too, with + happy tears in my eyes. Another time, when A. was giving way to + _her_ temper, and one would have thought all love was dead, I + said "Don't you love me then?" and the word alone was a talisman, + her face changed, she held out her arms and began to sob + quietly.... She accepted an offer to travel with a small + theatrical company who were going up-country. She was not looking + well when I left and after a time I received a telegram telling + me to come to her at once as she was ill. Dreading all sorts of + things I borrowed my fare and went to her. I knew nothing of + women, of their point of view and different code of honor, and + was very far from the attitude of Guy de Maupassant who said he + liked women all the better for their charmingly deceitful ways. + A. wanted to see me and had taken the surest means to ensure my + coming. I was angry at first, but she looked so well and was so + loving that I could not be angry long. + + One day when I was working the landlady came in and began talking + about A. and her conduct before I came. She had gone into the + actors' rooms at all hours, the woman said, and drank and been as + bad as the rest in her conversation. It was the second time a + married woman had run her down to me, and I commenced to think + there might be something in it, and suffered all my mad jealousy + over again. Not knowing the freedom actors and actresses allow + themselves on tour, without there being necessarily anything in + it, I worried till I thought I had nothing to do but die. And + then one of the great struggles of my life occurred. Walking the + country roads, I asked myself: "If it _is_ true, if she has been + unfaithful, will you forgive her and help her to arrive at her + best?" For a long time the answer was "No!" But perhaps my + striving for unity with myself had done some good, and the final + resolution was for forgiveness. I felt more peace of mind then, + and when I told a dying consumptive lodger in the house what the + landlady had said, he replied, "Don't you believe a word of it. I + know she loves you!".... + + After an absence I found myself one evening in a town where A. + was performing. I went round to the back and they told me she had + gone to a room in the hotel to change for another part. I + followed and entered the room, with a glass of spirits I found + that an effeminate young actor was bringing to her. She was half + undressed, her beautiful arms and shoulders bare. My arrival was + unexpected and she looked at me surprised, I thought coldly, as I + reproached her for not keeping a promise she had made to me to + touch no alcohol during the tour, but soon her arms were round my + neck. She cried like a child. She was bigger and handsomer and + healthier. There was not only an increased strength and size, but + an increased delicacy and sweetness; her eyes and brows were + lovely; there was an indescribable bloom and fragrance on her, + such as the sun leaves on a peach; the traveling, country air, + and freedom from coitus (had I known it) had enabled her to + arrive at her true self, not only a beautiful woman, but a woman + of fascination, of wit, vivacity and universal _camaraderie_. Her + face was like the dawn; all my fears and jealousy left me like a + cloud that melts before the sun. I remember the look on her face + as she embraced me in bed that night. It had just the very + smallest touch of sensuality, but was more like some beautiful + child's who is being caressed by one she loves; this divine, + drowsy-eyed, adorable look I had never seen on her face + before--nor have I since. + + We fell back into our old lustful ways. Later on A. became ill + and the black devil of epilepsy returned. I became gloomy.... A + restlessness and selfish brutality came over me; our love and + peace were gone. I persuaded A. to go to Melbourne and look out + for an engagement. The day before she was to sail we went to + Glenelg for a trip. The sea air, as often happened, precipitated + A.'s fits. We had gone down to the pier and A. said she felt bad. + I just managed to support her to the hotel before she became + stiff, and I made some impatient remark (for she nearly dragged + me down) which she heard, not being quite unconscious and said + half incoherently and very pitiably: "Be kind, oh, be kind!" + repeating it after consciousness left her. Her heart had been + breaking all day at the prospect of parting, and also, I expect, + because I was so ready to part with her. That moment was a crisis + in my life. I was in a murderous humor, but she looked so + unutterably wretched that it seemed impossible to be anything but + kind. I made myself speak lovingly to her, in moments of partial + consciousness, hired a room, carried her up, and nursed her and + petted her all night. The act of self-control, and forcing + myself to be kind whatever I felt, became a habit in time, a sort + of second nature. + + In a few days she sailed. When she had gone I was remorseful and + mad with myself. How could I let her go by herself? I resolved to + follow her as speedily as possible, and did so. + + If I remember rightly I came to the conclusion about this time + that we ought not to have coition unless we felt great love for + each other. It seemed to corroborate this to a certain extent + that A. always seemed more electric and pleasant to the touch + when we had connection for love and not for lust. Leave it to + Nature, I would say to myself. I began to feel how much my + struggles, efforts and temperate living had improved me. I had + more self-respect, though something of the old self-consciousness + was still left. I did not get better continuously, but in an + up-and-down zigzag. I still had moods of rage approaching madness + and periods of neurotic depression. Long walks decidedly helped + to cure me, and the sea, sun, wind, clouds and trees colored my + dreams at night very sweetly. I frequently dreamed I was walking + in orchards or forests, and a deeper, slightly melancholy but + potent savor, as of a diviner destiny, was on my soul. + + After a long absence, during which she had frequently been ill, + A. joined me. I could see she was recovering from fits, which I + began to realize that she had more frequently in absence from me, + and also from drinking, perhaps. She was small and thin, but + fresh and sweet as honey, and all signs of fits and tempers + passed away from her face, so wonderful in its changes. I had + become so healthy through my abstinence, temperance and long + walks that our meeting was a new revelation to me of how + delicate, fragrant and divine a convalescent woman may be. She + was glad and surprised to see me looking so well, and if she put + her hand on my arm I felt a joyous thrill. I was certainly a + better man for abstaining and she a better woman and I determined + not to have connection unless we were carried away by our love. + As a matter of fact we did not give way to excess, though we were + very loving. I tried to persuade myself that we had not gone back + to our old ways, but I could not do so long. + + Miss T. put in an appearance every day. She did not look so + innocent, but as it was no business of mine I did not trouble. + She seemed more attached to A. than ever.... A. was still very + loving with me, but it was an effort to me to keep up to her + pitch, and when A. proposed to go to Melbourne with Miss T, to + sell off the furniture before settling in Adelaide, I was rather + glad of the opportunity of abstaining from coitus and of watching + myself to see if I again improved. When A. and Miss T. came to + see me before going down to the steamer, A. was nearly crying and + Miss T., changed from the old welcome friend, was not only pale + and anxious, but looked guilty as if she had some treachery in + her mind; she could not meet my eye. I thought less of it then + than afterwards. And once more I took long walks at night and + rose early to catch the freshness of the mornings. + + Some time before this I had read a book advocating a vegetarian + diet, and at this time I chanced to read Pater's beautiful "Denys + L'Auxerrois," the imaginary portrait of a young vine-dresser, who + was attractive beyond ordinary mortals and lived, until his fall + and deterioration, on fruit and water. The words, "a natural + simplicity in living" remained in my memory. I resolved to read + more carefully the book on scientific diet. Who can say, I + thought, what changes for the better may come to me if I live on + a strictly scientific and natural diet? + + I fasted one whole day, and then had a breakfast of cherries, in + the middle of the day a meal of fruit, and walking in the + afternoon--a gray, rainy day--I felt so light, so different, and + the gray sky looked so sweet and familiar, that I was reminded of + the luminous visions of my boyhood. It was a distinct revelation. + This Pan-like, almost Bacchic feeling, did not last, however, nor + was I always able to maintain my new method of diet, though I + tried to do so. I made the attempt, however, but I imagine I was + more than usually run down. I would walk miles in the hope of + feeling less restless. One holiday I walked down to Glenelg, + having only had grapes for my dinner, and lying on the beach I + looked through a strong binocular glass I had borrowed at the + girls bathing. And the beauty of their faces in their frames of + hair, of their arms, of their figures, seen through their wet + clinging dresses, satisfied me and filled me with joy, gave me + for a short time that peace and content--in harmony with the + strong sunlight on the waves and the rhythmic surf on the + shore--I was seeking. The summer evenings on the pier or along + the beach had a peculiar savor; one felt the youth and beauty + there even on dark nights, the air was fragrant with them, white + dresses and summer hats disappearing down the beach or over the + sand hills. It was easy--doubtless justifiable sometimes--to put + a lewd construction on these disappearances; but I felt it need + not have been so; that it was not necessary that youth and + beauty, even the sexual act itself if led up to by love, should + be a subject of giggling and sniggering. I always left the beach + and its flitting summer dresses with a sigh. + + A., after writing once, ceased writing at all and once more her + mother and I were left in a state of anxiety and suspense. At + last I determined to go to Melbourne to look for her, the only + clue I had being a remark in her letter that a certain actor was + giving her an engagement. In Melbourne I could not find any + traces of her for some days and what traces I did find of her + were not calculated to allay my anxious fears. One hotel-keeper + told me that some one of A's name had stayed there with another + hussy (giving Miss T's stage name): "There were nice carryings on + with the pair of them." I thought of Miss T's strange looks, but + could not imagine what hold she had on A., for A. loved me, I + knew. I seemed to be in an inextricable maze. I could settle to + nothing and was thinking of applying to the police when I heard + that the actor A. had mentioned had taken his company to the + Gippsland lakes. I followed to Sale, found the actor and was told + that A. was not there. "She slipped me at the last moment," he + said, "and remained in Melbourne." I returned to my lodgings, + with my anxiety and nervous restlessness increased tenfold. But + suddenly my fear and restlessness left me like a cloud. I felt + quiet, young, peaceful, able to enjoy the country, A. was + doubtless all right and would be able to explain her silence. I + undressed leisurely and happily, thinking of the stars. + + The next day, Sunday, I awoke refreshed and still at peace. After + breakfast, hearing children's voices, I went out into the garden + and there was a collision of souls who somehow were affinities. A + young girl about twelve or younger with a fine presence and + handsome face fixed her eyes on me for half a minute and then + came and sat on my knee. She was one of those children I am + accustomed to call "love-children," because they are so much + brighter, healthier, larger and more loving than others. I always + imagine more love went to their making. We fell in love and she + said, stroking my beard, "Oh, you are pretty!" and I said, "And + so are you!" We were so affectionate that the servant called the + child away and I went for a walk, finding my little sweetheart + waiting for me on my return. The touch of her hand was electric + and her voice fresh and musical. I kissed her, but had become + more self-conscious since the morning and wondered if her mother + or the servant were looking, or even of they would appear. I was + not so frank and natural as my little chum. I have often thought + of her since. She had the breadth of forehead, the strength and + yet lightness of limb, together with the hands and feet, not too + small, that I always imagine the dwellers in Paradise will have. + + I returned to Melbourne and continued trying to find A. At the + same time I commenced in earnest to live on fruit and brown bread + only, and enjoyed better tone and health every day, so that it + was a joy to walk down the street in the sun and exchange glances + with passengers à la old Walt. One day in the Botanical Gardens + veils seemed to be lifted off my eyes. I could look straight at + the sun and taking my note of color from that golden light I + turned my eyes on the flowers, the mown grass, the trees, and for + the first time perceived what a heavenly color green is, what + divine companions flowers are, and what a blue sky really means. + For half an hour I was in Paradise, and to complete my joy Nature + revealed to me a new and unexpected secret. + + I was lying on a bench, basking, and my silk shirt coming open + the strong sun made its way to my breast and presently I felt a + totally new sensation there. I had discovered the last joy of the + skin. My skin, fed by healthy fruit-made blood, must have + functioned normally under the excitation of the sun just then + (for a brief space only, alas!). I cannot describe the joy, any + more than I could describe the taste of a peach to one who has + only eaten apples: it was satisfying, divine. I opened my shirt + wider, but the feeling only spread faintly, and indeed this + halcyon sunny hour terminated in a restlessness that sent me + walking into town to look for A. + + At last I heard, not of A., but of Miss T. She was in a ballet. I + went round during rehearsal and while waiting entered into + conversation with a little chorus girl with a good face, who was + sewing. On my telling her whom I was seeking she stopped sewing + and looked at me quickly: "Oh, are you her husband? I know her. + _I have seen them together_." She looked as if she were going to + tell me something, but merely shook her old-fashioned head in a + mournful, indescribable way, saying "Why don't you keep your wife + with you?" I went to the door and presently saw Miss T. She tried + to avoid me, I thought, and looked more vicious than ever, but + after a minute's thought reluctantly told me where she and A. + were staying. To hide my fears and suspicions I had assumed a + careless demeanor, but I think I should have strangled her had + she refused to tell me. I hastily went to the place indicated and + going up the stairs (to the astonishment of the people) opened + the door and found myself face to face with A.--but how changed! + She had the hard, harlot, loveless look I detested. I felt for a + few minutes that I did not love her, and she regarded me coldly + too, but presently old habits reinstated themselves. She put out + her hands, very pitiably, and then was sobbing in my arms. I + could get nothing out of her but sobs, and to this day do not + know where she spent all these weeks nor why she did not write. + Miss T. came in after rehearsal, pale and hard-faced. I greeted + her politely, but was watching her, trying to puzzle out why A. + did not look as she usually did after long absence from coition. + Miss T. took another room in the same house and was soon joined + by another ballet girl, young and very pretty, who soon began to + have fits. A. was always crying until Miss T. went away with her + pretty friend. I knew nothing, could hardly be said to suspect + anything definite, and yet I pitied that pretty girl whose eyes + looked so helpless and appealing. + + I set to work again. But I continued to live on fruit and bread, + and taking off my clothes I would stand up at the window in the + sun. A lot of prostitutes, however, who lived at the back saw me + and were scandalized or shocked or thought me mad. The landlady + heard of it and spoke to A. So I had to desist from my glorious + sun-baths. + + We slept on a single bed, and though I did my best to avoid + coitus (I wanted to wait and think out some theory of it), A., + who knew nothing of this, wanted to resume our old habits, and + finally I surrendered. But my sufferings next day were intense, + and I had the sense of having fallen from some high estate. My + thoughts were divided between two theories: one that our misery + was caused by our diet, more or less; the other that we had + fallen into some error as regards coitus, and this was becoming + almost a certainty with me. + + There is one incident I think worthy of note which happened + before the "fall" just mentioned and when I was living on fruit + and in splendid health. At a performance I saw a girl on the + stage with handsome legs in tights, and once as she straightened + her leg the knee-cap going into position gave me such a strange + and keen joy--of that quality I call divine or musical--that I + was like one suddenly awakened to the divinity and beauty of the + female form. The joy was so keen and yet peaceful, familiar, and + subjective that I could not help comparing it to a happy chemical + change in the tissues of my own brain. Like the unexpected + functioning of my skin in the sun it was a sign of a partial + return to a normal condition, another glimpse of Paradise. + + I stuck to my new diet and gained a fresh elation and joy in + life. Gradually clothes became insupportable, and I went down to + the beach as often as possible to take them off, and at nights, + beside the patient and astonished A., I would lie naked. One + evening, passing some grass, I looked over the fence like a gipsy + and felt a longing to take off my clothes and sleep in the grass + all night. It was of course impossible. And A. looked unhappily + in my face; she began to think her mother, who now thought I was + mad, must be right. + + That night I woke up and found myself having coition. I was angry + and felt I had been put back in my progress, but a fever of lust + now came over me. I would sit under the tap and let the cold + water run over me to conquer the fever, but at the end of a week + my hopes were frustrated and I even turned against my natural + diet, on which I had made flesh. A., as I expected, went through + her usual fits, and slowly recovered. (If we had connection only + once she in about three weeks had a mild attack of fits; if we + had coition more than once the fits were more severe.) I relapsed + more than once and as a means of impressing my resolution for + future abstinence I would walk for miles in the middle of + pitch-black nights.... + + Miss T. came over to Adelaide and as I knew nothing definite + against her and heard that she was engaged, I thought perhaps my + suspicions were unfounded and was friendly. But one day in town I + saw her and A. on a tram going out to our cottage. Even then my + suspicions might not have been awakened, but I saw Miss T. say + something rapidly to A., and A. called out to me, "Will you be + coming home soon?" And I answered "No." When the tram had gone on + I found myself vaguely wondering what Miss T. wanted to know that + for, for my perceptions were becoming acute enough to understand + women's ways. In another minute I was walking rapidly home. When + I came to the door it was locked. I knocked and knocked and no + one came. I called out and threatened to kick in the door. Still + no one came. Mad with rage I commenced to put my threat into + execution, when the door was opened by Miss T., half-naked, in + her petticoats, and pale as death, but no longer defiant. "So + I've caught you, have I?" I _looked_, but could not trust myself + to speak. Wondering why A. did not appear I went into the + bedroom. She was lying on the bed, just as Miss T. had left her, + on the verge of a fit, and on seeing me she held out her hands + piteously, and when I stooped over her she whispered, "Send her + away, send her away." Then she became unconscious and going into + the next room I ordered Miss T. (who had managed to scramble on + her dress) out of the house. I spoke scornfully as if addressing + a dog, and she slinked out with a malignant but cowed look I hope + never to see on a woman's face again. What they had been doing + with their clothes off I do not know; women will rather die than + confess. When A. had recovered from her fit she denied that there + had been anything between them, and stuck to it doggedly, but + with such a forlorn look I had not the heart to prosecute my + inquiries. + + For my part, all the efforts I had been making for so long seemed + for a time to be in vain; for some weeks I sank into a sort of + satyriasis, and even my anger against Miss T. turned to a + prurient curiosity. At the same time I was not always able to + adhere to my diet. But both as regards coition and diet I was + still fighting, and on the whole successfully. My fits of temper, + however, were excessive and my ennui became gloomy despair. One + day I blasphemed on crossing the Park and spoke contemptuously of + "God and his twopenny ha'penny revolving balls," referring to the + planetary system. But for long walks I should have gone mad. A. + was drinking in the intervals of her fits. I found half-empty + bottles of wine hidden away. This did not improve my temper, and + one day--this was when she was well and up--I struck her a heavy + blow on the face, and she aimed a glass decanter at me. She went + home to her mother and I lived alone in the cottage. I heard soon + afterwards that her husband had come back and that they had made + it up. Our parting was not, however, destined to be final. + + Even out of that month's sufferings I made capital. I was better + after my tendency to lubricity, my gloom, rage, restlessness and + degradation. They had been but the irritations of convalescence. + + + +INDEX OF AUTHORS. + +Abrantès, duchesse d' +Adler +Albucasis +Alexander, H.C.B. +Amatus Lusitanus +Ammon +Andersen +Andriezen +Aquinas +Aristophanes +Aristotle +Averroes +Avicenna +Aubrey +Aulnoy, Madame d' + +Baer +Ball +Ballantyne, J.W. +Bancroft, H.H. +Barker, Fordyce +Barnes, R. +Bartholin +Bayle +Beale, G.B. +Bechterew +Beck, J.R. +Becker +Bell, Sir C. +Bell, Sanford +Belletrud +Beneden +Bergh +Bianchi +Biérent +Binet +Bischoff, T.L.W. +Bloch, J. +Blondel +Blumenbach +Blunt, J.J. +Boas +Boccaccio +Boeteau +Bois, J. +Bois-Reymond, E. du +Bölsche +Booth, D.S. +Booth, J. +Bouchereau +Bouchet +Bourke, J.G. +Boveri +Brand +Braun +Brantôme +Brehm +Breitenstein +Brénier de Montmorand +Brénot +Brouardel +Brown-Séquard +Brügelmann +Buckman, S.S. +Bucknill +Bunge +Burchard +Burdach +Burton, Robert +Buschan +Busdraghi + +Cabanis +Campbell, J.F. +Campbell, H. +Carpenter, E. +Casanova +Cascella +Castelnau +Catullus +Cecca +Celsus +Chapman, C.W. +Charcot +Chaucer +Chaulant +Chevalier +Chidley, W. +Cladel, J. +Clement, of Alexandria +Coe +Coen +Collineau +Colman, W.S. +Columbus, R. +Cook, G.W. +Crawley +Cumston +Cuvier +Cyples + +Dabney +Darwin, C. +Darwin, E. +Daumas +Dearborn, G. +Dembo +Deniker +Dessoir, Max +Dickinson, R.L. +Diderot +Disselhorst +Donaldson, H.H. +Douglas, C. +Drähms +Dühren, E. +Dufougère +Dufour +Dulaure +Duncan, Matthews + +East, A. +Edgar, Clifton +Ellis, Havelock +Engelmann +Erotion +Esbach +Eschricht +Espinas +Eulenburg +Evans +Ezekiel + +Fabricius +Fallopius +Féré +Fichstedt +Flood, E. +Florence +Fothergill, Milner +Frazer, J.G. +Freud +Freyer +Froriep +Fuchs +Fürbringer + +Galen +Gardiner, C.F. +Garnier +Gautier, A. +Gautier, T. +Gellhoen +Gerhard, A. +Giles, A. +Godin +Goethe +Goncourt, E. de +Gopcevic +Goron +Gould +Gow +Graaf, de +Griffiths +Groos, K. +Gualino +Guéniot +Guibaut +Guillereau +Guinard +Guttceit + +Hack +Haddon +Haig +Hall, G. Stanley +Haller +Hamilton, A. +Hammond +Hardy, Thomas +Hartland, E.S. +Harvey +Hegar +Henderson, J. +Henle +Hennig +Herman +Herodotus +Herrick +Heusinger +Hewitt, Graily +Hippocrates +Hirst +Hislop, J.T. +Hoche +Horrocks +Howard, W.L. +Howell +Howitt, A.W. +Hrdlicka +Hughes, C.H. +Hunter, John +Hunter, William +Huysmans +Hyades +Hyrtl + +Jacobi +Jacoby, P. +Jahn +Janet +Janke +Jastreboff +Jenkyns, J. +Johnston, G.A. +Johnston, Sir H.H. +Jonson, Ben +Juvenal + +Kaltenbach +Kelly, H. +Kepler +Kiernan, J.G. +Kisch +Kleinpaul +Kobelt +Kocher +Kohlbrugge +Kolbein +Krafft-Ebing +Krauss + +Lamb, D.S. +Landes, L. de +Lane +Lasègue +Laurent, E. +Lawrence, Sir W. +Laycock +Levi +Licetus +Liébault +Liétaud +Lipps +Litzmann +Lombroso +Lorion +Lortet +Lucas, J.C. +Lucretius +Lunier +Luschka +Lusini +Lydston + +Macdonald, A. +MacGillicuddy +McKay, A. +Mackay, W.J.S. +Mackenzie, J. +Magnan +Malebranche +Mantegazza +Marandon de Montyel +Marc +Marro +Marshall, H.R. +Martial +Martin, J.M.H. +Martineau +Maschka +Masterman +Matignon +Mattel +McMordie +Mercier +Meredith, Ellis +Middleton, T. +Mirabeau +Mitchell, Sir A. +Moll +Mongeri +Morache +Moraglia +Morris, R.T. +Morselli +Motet +Moulin, J. Mansell +Müller, J. +Mundé, P. + +Näcke +Neale, R. +Neri +Nicholson, H.O. +Nina Rodrigues + +Obici +Onanoff +Ottolenghi +Ovid + +Pacheco +Palfyn +Park, Mungo +Papillault +Pasini +Paterson, A.R. +Paulini +Paulus Æginetus +Pearse, W.H. +Pearson, Karl +Pechuel-Loesche +Pelanda +Pennant +Penta +Pfaff +Pierer +Pillon +Pinæus +Pinard +Pitre, C. +Pitres +Pittard +Plant +Plautus +Pliny +Ploss +Poehl +Polemon +Pollux +Porta, Della +Power +Pyle + +Raymond +Régis +Régnier, H. de +Reinach, S. +Renooz, Céline +Restif de la Bretonne +Retterer, E. +Reynolds, A.R. +Rhys, J. +Ribot +Riedel +Rimbaud +Riolan +Robinson, Bryan +Robinson, Louis +Rodin +Roederer +Roons, R.P. +Rosse, Irving +Roth, W. +Rothe +Roubaud +Rousseau +Routh, C.H.F. +Rufus +Russell, W. + +Sade, de +Salmon, W. +Scherzer +Schinz +Schmiedeberg +Schreiner +Schrenck-Notzing +Schurig +Scott, Colin +Scripture, E.W. +Seerley +Seligmann +Sellheim +Shakespeare +Shattock +Shufeldt +Silk, J.F.W. +Simon, H. +Simpson, Sir J. +Sims, Marion +Smith, Sir A. +Smith, Haywood +Sömmering +Soranus +Spigelius +Stahl, F.A. +Stanton +Stendhal +Stengel +Stern, B. +Stevens, Vaughan +Stieda +Stratz +Stubbs +Suidas +Sukhanoff +Sullivan, W.C. +Sutherland, W.D. +Sutton, Bland +Swift + +Tarde +Tardieu +Tarnier +Taxil +Theocritus +Thoinot +Thompson, W.L. +Thomson, J. +Tilt +Toff +Tourdes, G. +Tridandani +Trochon + +Vahness +Valentin +Varigny, H de +Variot, G. +Varro +Vaschide +Vatsyayana +Venette +Venturi +Vesalius +Vinay +Vinci, L. da +Voigt +Voisin, J. +Vurpas + +Wagner, R. +Waldeyer +Walker, G. +Wallace, A.W. +Warton +Wasserschleben +Weininger, O. +Wellhausen +Werner +Wernich +West, J.P. +Wharton +Wilhelm, Eugen +Wilkin, G. +Wilkinson, A.D. +Williams, J.W. Whitridge +Williamson, C.F. +Wolff, B. +Wollstonecraft, Mary +Wordsworth +Wychgel + +Youatt + +Zaborsky +Zoppi +Zimmer +Zola + + + + +INDEX OF SUBJECTS. + +Abyssinians, + coitus among +Acquired element in erotic symbolism +Acromegaly and sexual development +Alcohol, + aphrodisiac effects of +Algolagnia, + in relation to scatologic symbolism + as a form of erotic symbolism +Anæsthesia, + sexual +Anæsthetics in relation to sexual excitement +Anaphrodisiacs +Animal copulation, + attraction of +Animals, + detumescence in +Annamites, + coitus among +Antipathies of pregnant women +Anus in relation to pubic hair + as an erogenous zone +Apes, + sexual organs of + sexual congress in +Aphrodisiacs +Apples, + longings of women for +Arabs, + penis in +Artist, + compared to lover +Associations of contiguity and resemblance in erotic symbolism +Australian method of sexual congress +Auto-suggestions, + longings of pregnancy as + +Bartholin, + glands of +Beard in relation to sexual development +Beauty, + the objective element in +Bestiality +Bladder in relation to sexual excitement +Blood during pregnancy +Blood-pressure during detumescence +Breasts, + and erotic temperament + during pregnancy +Bromide as an anaphrodisiac +Bulbo-cavernous reflex + +Camphor as an anaphrodisiac +Cantharides, + effects of +Castration, + results of +Celery as an aphrodisiac +Children, + attracted to foot + to scatology + to copulation of animals + to hair + food impulses of +Chinese, + foot-fetichism of +Circulatory conditions during coitus + during pregnancy +Clitoris +Clothes, + erotic fascination of +Coitus, + the phenomena of + the methods of + ethnic variations in methods of + respiratory and circulatory conditions during + interruptus as a cause of vasomotor disturbance + glandular activity during + motor activity during + psychic state during + serious effects of +Congenital element in erotic symbolism +Contiguity in erotic symbolism, + associations of +Coprolagnia +Coprophagia, + religious and sexual +Courtship +Crystallization, + Stendhal's + +Defile, + the impulse to +Distillatio +Dog, + human sexual intercourse with +Dynamometric experiments during sexual excitement + +Ejaculation, the mechanism of +Embryo +Epilepsy and exhibitionism + compared to coitus + as a result of coitus +Erectility during coitus +Erogenous zone, + anus as + lips as +Erotic intoxication +Erotic temperament +Eryngo as an aphrodisiac +Ethnic variations in coitus +Etruscans, + sexual significance of foot among +Eunuchs, + characteristics of +Exercise on sexual organs, + influence of +Exhibitionism +Eyes during detumescence + in relation to erotic temperament + darker at puberty + +Face during detumescence, + expression of +Fæces as a drug +Fecundation, + the phenomena of + artificial +Feet as a sexual symbol, + uncovering +Fellatio +Fetichism, + erotic +Flagellation +Foot-fetichism, + _see_ Shoe-fetichism. +Fuegians, + penis in +Fur as a fetich + +Garments as fetiches +Genital organs as fetiches +Goat as a human sexual fetich +Greeks, + sexual significance of foot among + +Hair as a fetich + despoilers of + pubic + darkens at puberty + in relation to erotic temperament + in pregnancy +Hand as fetich +Heart during pregnancy +Homosexuality as a form of erotic symbolism +Hottentot apron +Hymen +Hyperæsthesia, sexual +Hypertrichosis universalis +Hysteria + +Ideal coprolagnia +Idiocy as result of maternal impressions +Idiots, + sexual development of +Impregnation without rupture of hymen + without conjunctions + artificial +Impressions, + maternal +Intellectual work, + relation of pregnancy to +Intoxication, + erotic + +Japanese, + labia majora in +Joy, + the expression of + +Kiss, the +Kleptomania and pregnancy +Knee-jerk in pregnancy + +Labia majora +Labia minora +Larynx in relation to sexual state +Linea fusca +Lips, + as an erogenous zone + in relation to erotic temperament +Longings of pregnancy + theories of + as auto-suggestions + physiological basis of + relation to the longings of childhood + +Masochism, + in relation to shoe-fetichism + in relation to scatalogic symbolism + in relation to exhibitionism of nates + as a form of erotic symbolism +Masturbation and pubic hair + hypertrophy of clitoris ascribed to + part played by clitoris in + why some theologians permitted + phenomena during +Maternal element in sexual love +Maternal impressions +Menstruation in relation to coitus + metabolism during + in relation to sickness of pregnancy + compared to pregnancy +Mental state during pregnancy +Metabolism during pregnancy +Mixoscopic zoophilia +Modesty a supposed sign of virginity +Mohammedan method of sexual congress +Mole as a fetich +Mongol peoples, + foot fetichism among various +Mons veneris +Mordvins, + foot-fetichism among +Motor activity during coitus +Mouth in relation to erotic temperament +Muscular movements during coitus + +Nates in relation to coprolagnia + in relation to exhibitionism + in relation to erotic temperament +Necrophilia +Negative fetich +Negro, + penis in + labia majora in + clitoris in + labia minora in + method of sexual congress among +Nervous system during pregnancy +Neurasthenia cordis vasomotoria +Nipples, + pigmentation of +Nudity, + religious +Nutrition, + symbolism of +Nymphæ +Nymphomania + +Obsessions of scruple + longings of pregnancy as +Obsessional exhibitionism +Odor an alleged sign of defloration +Onion as an aphrodisiac +Opium as an aphrodisiac +Organs, + sexual +Ova and spermatozoa, + union of +Ovarian extract, effects of +Ovaries, + function of + analogy of with thyroid + +Paidophilia +Pain and erotic symbolism +Pedicatio +Pelvic development and erotic temperament +Pelvic floor, variability of +Pelvic inclination +Penis +Penis-fetichism +Phallic worship +Physiognomists and the erotic temperament +Pica +Pigmentation in relation to erotic temperament + in pregnancy +Potatoes, + the supposed aphrodisiac effects of +Precocity, + influence of +Pregnancy and pigmentation + psychic state in + sexual desire during + relation of to intellectual work +Presbyophilia +Prostate +Prostitutes, + external genitals of + stature of +Psychic exhibitionism +Psychic condition during coitus +Puberty, + the phenomena of + pigmentary changes at +Pubic hair +Puericulture +Pygmalionism + +Quadrupedal method of coitus in man + +Rachitic, + sexual tendencies of the +Reflex, bulbo-cavernous +Reflexes during pregnancy +Religious scatalogic symbolism +Resemblance in erotic symbolism, + associations of +Respiration during coitus +Responsibility of pregnant women +Restif de la Bretonne's shoe-fetichism +Romans, + sexual significance of foot among + methods of coitus among +Rousseau +Rue as an anaphrodisiac + +Sadism +Saint compared to lover +Salivation during coitus +Satyriasis +Scatalogic symbolism +Scrotum +Scruple, obsessions of +Secretions of genital canal +Semen, + alleged female + in coitus + in female genital canal + vital activity of + artificial injection of + constituents of + as a stimulant +Sexual anæsthesia +Sexual conjugation +Sexual desire during pregnancy +Sexual organs +Sexual selection in relation to erotic symbolism + in relation to external sexual organs + the probable cause of the hymen +Shadow as a fetich +Shoe, + sexual significance of +Shoe-fetichism frequency of + normal basis of + illustrated by Restif de la Bretonne + prevalence of among Chinese, etc. + former prevalence in Europe + congenital basis of + acquired element in + favored by precocity + relation to masochism + illustrative cases of + dynamic element in +Sickness of pregnancy +Skin, + sexual significance of + condition of during coitus + in relation to erotic temperament + sexual pigmentation of +Slipper as a sexual symbol +Smile, + origin of the +Sodomy, + the term +Spain, + sexual attractiveness of foot in +Spermatozoa reach ova, + how the +Spermin +Sphygmanometer experiments during sexual excitement +Stature and erotic temperament +Stimulants +Stuff-fetichisms +Strychnine, + aphrodisiac effects of +Suggestion in relation to longings of pregnancy +Symbols, + nature of + of sex in language + +Temperament, + alleged erotic +Testicular juices, + effects of +Testes +Thyroid, + condition during sexual excitement + during pregnancy +Ticklishness in relation to stuff-fetichisms +Tumescence in relation to detumescence + +Unnatural offence, + the term +Urethra, + variability of female + an erogenous zone +Urethrorrhoea ex libidine +Urinary stream, + in relation to nymphæ + an alleged index to virginity +Urine in religious rites + possesses magical virtues + in legends + in medicine + during coitus +Urolagnia +Uterus + +Vagina +Vaginismus +Vasomotor conditions during coitus +Vaudonism +Virginity, + ancient diagnosis of +Virile reflex +Voice, + in relation to erotic temperament + in relation to virginity +Vomiting of pregnancy +Vulva +Vulva-fetichism + +Waist, + origin of admiration for small + +Yohimbin as an aphrodisiac + +Zooerastia +Zoophilia erotica +Zoophilia non-erotic + +*** END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK 13614 *** diff --git a/13614-h/13614-h.htm b/13614-h/13614-h.htm new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4dd0195 --- /dev/null +++ b/13614-h/13614-h.htm @@ -0,0 +1,13299 @@ +<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01 Transitional//EN"> +<html> +<head> +<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"> +<title>The Project Gutenberg eBook of Studies in the Psychology of Sex, Volume 5 (of 6), by Havelock Ellis</title> + <style type="text/css"> +/*<![CDATA[ XML blockout */ +<!-- + P { margin-top: .75em; + text-align: justify; + margin-bottom: .75em; + } + H1,H2,H3,H4,H5,H6 { + text-align: center; /* all headings centered */ + } + hr {text-align: center; width: 50%;} + html>body hr {margin-right: 25%; margin-left: 25%; width: 50%;} + hr.full {width: 100%;} + html>body hr.full {margin-right: 0%; margin-left: 0%; width: 100%;} + hr.short {text-align: center; width: 20%;} + html>body hr.short {margin-right: 40%; margin-left: 40%; width: 20%;} + + BODY{margin-left: 10%; + margin-right: 10%; + } + img {border: none;} + .ctr {text-align: center;} + .linenum {position: absolute; top: auto; left: 4%;} /* poetry number */ + .note {margin-left: 2em; margin-right: 2em; margin-bottom: 1em;} /* footnote */ + .blkquot {margin-left: 4em; margin-right: 4em;} /* block indent */ + .pagenum {position: absolute; left: 92%; font-size: smaller; text-align: right;} /* page numbers */ + .sidenote {width: 20%; margin-bottom: 1em; margin-top: 1em; padding-left: 1em; font-size: smaller; float: right; clear: right;} + + .poem {margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align: left;} + .poem br {display: none;} + .poem .stanza {margin: 1em 0em 1em 0em;} + .poem span {display: block; margin: 0; padding-left: 3em; text-indent: -3em;} + .poem span.i2 {display: block; margin-left: 2em;} + .poem span.i4 {display: block; margin-left: 4em;} + .poem span.i1 {display: block; margin-left: 1em;} + .poem .caesura {vertical-align: -200%;} + hr.pg { width: 100%; + height: 5px; } + a:link {color:#0000ff; + text-decoration:none} + link {color:#0000ff; + text-decoration:none} + a:visited {color:#0000ff; + text-decoration:none} + a:hover {color:#ff0000} + pre {font-size: 8pt;} + // --> + /* XML end ]]>*/ + </style> +</head> +<body> +<div>*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK 13614 ***</div> +<h1>The Project Gutenberg eBook, Studies in the Psychology of Sex, Volume 5 +(of 6), by Havelock Ellis</h1> +<hr class="pg" noshade> +<br> +<br> +<br> +<a name='5_Page_iii'></a> + +<h1>STUDIES<br /> +<br /> +IN THE<br /> +<br /> +PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX</h1> +<br /> +<h2>VOLUME V</h2> +<br /> +<h3>EROTIC SYMBOLISM<br /> +THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE<br /> +THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY</h3><br /> +<br /> +<h3>BY</h3> +<br /> +<h2>HAVELOCK ELLIS</h2> +<br /> +<h5>1927</h5><br /> +<hr class="full" /> +<br> +<a name='5_PREFACE'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_v'></a>PREFACE.</h2> +<br /> + +<p>In this volume the terminal phenomena of the sexual process are discussed, +before an attempt is finally made, in the concluding volume, to consider +the bearings of the psychology of sex on that part of morals which may be +called "social hygiene."</p> + +<p>Under "Erotic Symbolism" I include practically all the aberrations of the +sexual instinct, although some of these have seemed of sufficient +importance for separate discussion in previous volumes. It is highly +probable that many readers will consider that the name scarcely suffices +to cover manifestations so numerous and so varied. The term "sexual +equivalents" will seem preferable to some. While, however, it may be fully +admitted that these perversions are "sexual equivalents"—or at all events +equivalents of the normal sexual impulse—that term is merely a +descriptive label which tells us nothing of the phenomena. "Sexual +Symbolism" gives us the key to the process, the key that makes all these +perversions intelligible. In all of them—very clearly in some, as in +shoe-fetichism; more obscurely in others, as in exhibitionism—it has come +about by causes congenital, acquired, or both, that some object or class +of objects, some act or group of acts, has acquired a dynamic power over +the psycho-physical mechanism of the sexual process, deflecting it from +its normal adjustment to the whole of a beloved person of the opposite +sex. There has been a transmutation of values, and certain objects, +certain acts, have acquired an emotional value which for the normal person +they do not possess. Such objects and acts are properly, it seems to me, +termed symbols, and that term embodies the only justification that in most +cases these manifestations can legitimately claim.</p> + +<p>"The Mechanism of Detumescence" brings us at last to the final climax for +which the earlier and more prolonged stage <a name='5_Page_vi'></a>of tumescence, which has +occupied us so often in these <i>Studies</i>, is the elaborate preliminary. +"The art of love," a clever woman novelist has written, "is the art of +preparation." That "preparation" is, on the physiological side, the +production of tumescence, and all courtship is concerned in building up +tumescence. But the final conjugation of two individuals in an explosion +of detumescence, thus slowly brought about, though it is largely an +involuntary act, is still not without its psychological implications and +consequences; and it is therefore a matter for regret that so little is +yet known about it. The one physiological act in which two individuals are +lifted out of all ends that center in self and become the instrument of +those higher forces which fashion the species, can never be an act to be +slurred over as trivial or unworthy of study.</p> + +<p>In the brief study of "The Psychic State in Pregnancy" we at last touch +the point at which the whole complex process of sex reaches its goal. A +woman with a child in her womb is the everlasting miracle which all the +romance of love, all the cunning devices of tumescence and detumescence, +have been invented to make manifest. The psychic state of the woman who +thus occupies the supreme position which life has to offer cannot fail to +be of exceeding interest from many points of view, and not least because +the maternal instinct is one of the elements even of love between the +sexes. But the psychology of pregnancy is full of involved problems, and +here again, as so often in the wide field we have traversed, we stand at +the threshold of a door it is not yet given us to pass.</p> + +<p>HAVELOCK ELLIS.</p> + +<p>Carbis Water, Lelant, Cornwall.</p> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_CONTENTS'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_vii'></a>CONTENTS.</h2> +<h4><a href='#5_PREFACE'>PREFACE.</a></h4> +<br /> +<h4><a href='#5_EROTIC_SYMBOLISM'>EROTIC SYMBOLISM.</a></h4> +<h5><a href='#5_E_I'>I.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Definition of Erotic Symbolism. Symbolism of Act and Symbolism of +Object. Erotic Fetichism. Wide Extension of the Symbols of Sex. The +Immense Variety of Possible Erotic Fetiches. The Normal Foundations of +Erotic Symbolism. Classification of the Phenomena. The Tendency to +Idealize the Defects of a Beloved Person. Stendhal's "Crystallization"</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_E_II'>II.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>Foot-fetichism and Shoe-fetichism. Wide Prevalence and Normal Basis. +Restif de la Bretonne. The Foot a Normal Focus of Sexual Attraction Among +Some Peoples. The Chinese, Greeks, Romans, Spaniards, etc. The Congenital +Predisposition in Erotic Symbolism. The Influence of Early Association and +Emotional Shock. Shoe-fetichism in Relation to Masochism. The Two +Phenomena Independent Though Allied. The Desire to be Trodden On. The +Fascination of Physical Constraint. The Symbolism of Self-inflicted Pain. +The Dynamic Element in Erotic Symbolism. The Symbolism of Garments.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_E_III'>III.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>Scatalogic Symbolism. Urolagnia. Coprolagnia. The Ascetic Attitude Towards +the Flesh. Normal Basis of Scatalogic Symbolism. Scatalogic Conceptions +Among Primitive Peoples. Urine as a Primitive Holy Water. Sacredness of +Animal Excreta. Scatalogy in Folk-lore. The Obscene as Derived from the +Mythological. The Immature Sexual Impulse Tends to Manifest Itself in +Scatalogic Forms. The Basis of Physiological Connection Between the +Urinary and Genital Spheres. Urinary Fetichism Sometimes Normal in +Animals. The Urolagnia of Masochists. The Scatalogy of Saints. Urolagnia +More Often a Symbolism of Act Than a Symbolism of Object. Only +Occasionally an Olfactory Fetichism. Comparative Rarity of Coprolagnia. +Influence of Nates Fetichism as a Transition to Coprolagnia, Ideal +Coprolagnia.<a name='5_Page_viii'></a> Olfactory Coprolagnia. Urolagnia and Coprolagnia as Symbols +of Coitus.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_E_IV'>IV.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>Animals as Sources of Erotic Symbolism. Mixoscopic Zoophilia. The +Stuff-fetichisms. Hair-fetichism. The Stuff-fetichisms Mainly on a Tactile +Base. Erotic Zoophilia. Zooerastia. Bestiality. The Conditions that Favor +Bestiality. Its Wide Prevalence Among Primitive Peoples and Among +Peasants. The Primitive Conception of Animals. The Goat. The Influence of +Familiarity With Animals. Congress Between Women and Animals. The Social +Reaction Against Bestiality.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_E_V'>V.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>Exhibitionism. Illustrative Cases. A Symbolic Perversion of Courtship. The +Impulse to Defile. The Exhibitionist's Psychic Attitude. The Sexual Organs +as Fetiches. Phallus Worship. Adolescent Pride in Sexual Development. +Exhibitionism of the Nates. The Classification of the Forms of +Exhibitionism. Nature of the Relationship of Exhibitionism to Epilepsy.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_E_VI'>VI.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Forms of Erotic Symbolism are Simulacra of Coitus. Wide Extension of +Erotic Symbolism. Fetichism Not Covering the Whole Ground of Sexual +Selection. It is Based on the Individual Factor in Selection. +Crystallization. The Lover and the Artist. The Key to Erotic Symbolism is +to be Found in the Emotional Sphere. The Passage to Pathological Extremes.</p></div> +<br /> +<h4><a href='#5_THE_MECHANISM_OF_DETUMESCENCE'>THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE.</a></h4> +<h5><a href='#5_M_I'>I.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Psychological Significance of Detumescence. The Testis and the Ovary. +Sperm Cell and Germ Cell. Development of the Embryo. The External Sexual +Organs. Their Wide Range of Variation. Their Nervous Supply. The Penis. +Its Racial Variations. The Influence of Exercise. The Scrotum and +Testicles. The Mons Veneris. The Vulva. The Labia Majora and their +Varieties. The Public Hair and Its Characters. The Clitoris and Its +Functions. The Anus as an Erogenous Zone. The Nymphæ and their Function. +The Vagina. The Hymen. Virginity. The Biological Significance of the +Hymen.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_M_II'>II</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Object of Detumescence. Erogenous Zones. The Lips. The Vascular +Characters of Detumescence. Erectile Tissue. Erection in Woman. Mucous +Emission in Women. Sexual Connection. The Human Mode of Intercourse. +Normal Variations. The Motor Characters of Detumescence. Ejaculation. The +Virile Reflex. The General Phenomena of Detumescence. The Circulatory and +Respiratory Phenomena. Blood Pressure. Cardiac Disturbance. Glandular +Activity. Distillatio. The Essentially Motor Character of Detumescence. +Involuntary Muscular Irradiation to Bladder, etc. Erotic Intoxication. +Analogy of Sexual Detumescence and Vesical Tension. The Specifically +Sexual Movements of Detumescence in Man. In Woman. The Spontaneous +Movements of the Genital Canal in Woman. Their Function in Conception. +Part Played by Active Movement of the Spermatozoa. The Artificial +Injection of Semen. The Facial Expression During Detumescence. The +Expression of Joy. The Occasional Serious Effects of Coitus.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_M_III'>III.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Constituents of Semen. Function of the Prostate. The Properties of +Semen. Aphrodisiacs. Alcohol, Opium, etc. Anaphrodisiacs. The Stimulant +Influence of Semen in Coitus. The Internal Effects of Testicular +Secretions. The Influence of Ovarian Secretion.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_M_IV'>IV.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Aptitude for Detumescence. Is There an Erotic Temperament? The +Available Standards of Comparison. Characteristics of the Castrated. +Characteristics of Puberty. Characteristics of the State of Detumescence. +Shortness of Stature. Development of the Secondary Sexual Characters. Deep +Voice. Bright Eyes. Glandular Activity. Everted Lips. Pigmentation. +Profuse Hair. Dubious Significance of Many of These Characters.</p></div> + +<br /> + +<h4><a href='#5_THE_PSYCHIC_STATE_IN_PREGNANCY'>THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY.</a></h4> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Relationship of Maternal and Sexual Emotion. Conception and Loss of +Virginity. The Anciently Accepted Signs of This Condition. The Pervading +Effects of Pregnancy on the Organism. Pigmentation. The Blood and +Circulation. The Thyroid. Changes in the Nervous System. The Vomiting of +Pregnancy.<a name='5_Page_x'></a> The Longings of Pregnant Women. Mental Impressions. Evidence +for and Against Their Validity. The Question Still Open. Imperfection of +Our Knowledge. The Significance of Pregnancy.</p></div> +<br /> + +<h4><a href='#5_APPENDIX'>APPENDIX.</a></h4> +<center>Histories of Sexual Development.</center> +<br /> +<h4><a href='#5_INDEX_OF_AUTHORS'>INDEX OF AUTHORS.</a></h4> +<h4><a href='#5_INDEX_OF_SUBJECTS'>INDEX OF SUBJECTS.</a></h4> + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_EROTIC_SYMBOLISM'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_1'></a>EROTIC SYMBOLISM.</h2> + +<a name='5_E_I'></a><h3>I.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Definition of Erotic Symbolism—Symbolism of Act and Symbolism of +Object—Erotic Fetichism—Wide extension of the symbols of Sex—The +Immense Variety of Possible Erotic Fetiches—The Normal Foundations of +Erotic Symbolism—Classification of the Phenomena—The Tendency to +Idealize the Defects of a Beloved Person—Stendhal's "Crystallization."</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>By "erotic symbolism" I mean that tendency whereby the lover's attention +is diverted from the central focus of sexual attraction to some object or +process which is on the periphery of that focus, or is even outside of it +altogether, though recalling it by association of contiguity or of +similarity. It thus happens that tumescence, or even in extreme cases +detumescence, may be provoked by the contemplation of acts or objects +which are away from the end of sexual conjugation.<a name='5_FNanchor_1'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_1'><sup>[1]</sup></a></p> + +<p>In considering the phenomena of sexual selection in a previous volume,<a name='5_FNanchor_2'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_2'><sup>[2]</sup></a> +it was found that there are four or five main factors in the constitution +of beauty in so far as beauty determines sexual selection. Erotic +symbolism is founded on the factor of individual taste in beauty; it +arises as a specialized development of that factor, but it is, +nevertheless, incorrect to merge it in sexual selection. The attractive +characteristics of a beloved woman or man, from the point of view of +sexual selection, are a complex but harmonious whole leading up to a +desire for the complete possession of the person who displays them.<a name='5_Page_2'></a> There +is no tendency to isolate and dissociate any single character from the +individual and to concentrate attention upon that character at the expense +of the attention bestowed upon the individual generally. As soon as such a +tendency begins to show itself, even though only in a slight or temporary +form, we may say that there is erotic symbolism.</p> + +<p>Erotic symbolism is, however, by no means confined to the individualizing +tendency to concentrate amorous attention upon some single characteristic +of the adult woman or man who is normally the object of sexual love. The +adult human being may not be concerned at all, the attractive object or +act may not even be human, not even animal, and we may still be concerned +with a symbol which has parasitically rooted itself on the fruitful site +of sexual emotion and absorbed to itself the energy which normally goes +into the channels of healthy human love having for its final end the +procreation of the species. Thus understood in its widest sense, it may be +said that every sexual perversion, even homosexuality, is a form of erotic +symbolism, for we shall find that in every case some object or act that +for the normal human being has little or no erotic value, has assumed such +value in a supreme degree; that is to say, it has become a symbol of the +normal object of love. Certain perversions are, however, of such great +importance on account of their wide relationships, that they cannot be +adequately discussed merely as forms of erotic symbolism. This is notably +the case as regards homosexuality, auto-erotism, and algolagnia, all of +which phenomena have therefore been separately discussed in previous +studies. We are now mainly concerned with manifestations which are more +narrowly and exclusively symbolical.</p> + +<p>A portion of the field of erotic symbolism is covered by what Binet +(followed by Lombroso, Krafft-Ebing, and others) has termed "erotic +fetichism," or the tendency whereby sexual attraction is unduly exerted by +some special part or peculiarity of the body, or by some inanimate object +which has become associated with it. Such erotic symbolism of object +cannot, however, be dissociated from the even more important erotic +symbolism <a name='5_Page_3'></a>of process, and the two are so closely bound together that we +cannot attain a truly scientific view of them until we regard them broadly +as related parts of a common psychic tendency. If, as Groos asserts,<a name='5_FNanchor_3'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_3'><sup>[3]</sup></a> a +symbol has two chief meanings, one in which it indicates a physical +process which stands for a psychic process, and another in which it +indicates a part which represents the whole, erotic symbolism of act +corresponds to the first of these chief meanings, and erotic symbolism of +object to the other.</p> + +<p>Although it is not impossible to find some germs of erotic symbolism in +animals, in its more pronounced manifestations it is only found in the +human species. It could not be otherwise, for such symbolism involves not +only the play of fancy and imagination, the idealizing aptitude, but also +a certain amount of power of concentrating the attention on a point +outside the natural path of instinct and the ability to form new mental +constructions around that point. There are, indeed, as we shall see, +elementary forms of erotic symbolism which are not uncommonly associated +with feeble-mindedness, but even these are still peculiarly human, and in +its less crude manifestations erotic symbolism easily lends itself to +every degree of human refinement and intelligence.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>"It depends primarily upon an increase of the psychological + process of representation," Colin Scott remarks of sexual + symbolism generally, "involving greater powers of comparison and + analysis as compared with the lower animals. The outer + impressions come to be clearly distinguished as such, but at the + same time are often treated as symbols of inner experiences, and + a meaning read into them which they would not otherwise possess. + Symbolism or fetichism is, indeed, just the capacity to see + meaning, to emphasize something for the sake of other things + which do not appear. In brain terms it indicates an activity of + the higher centers, a sort of side-tracking or long-circuiting of + the primitive energy; ... Rosetti's poem, 'The Woodspurge,'<a name='5_Page_4'></a> + gives a concrete example of the formation of such a symbol. Here + the otherwise insignificant presentation of the three-cupped + woodspurge, representing originally a mere side-current of the + stream of consciousness, becomes the intellectual symbol or + fetich of the whole psychosis forever after. It seems, indeed, as + if the stronger the emotion the more likely will become the + formation of an overlying symbolism, which serves to focus and + stand in the place of something greater than itself; nowhere at + least is symbolism a more characteristic feature than as an + expression of the sexual instinct. The passion of sex, with its + immense hereditary background, in early man became centered often + upon the most trivial and unimportant features.... This + symbolism, now become fetichistic, or symbolic in a bad sense, is + at least an exercise of the increasing representative power of + man, upon which so much of his advancement has depended, while it + also served to express and help to purify his most perennial + emotion." (Colin Scott, "Sex and Art," <i>American Journal of + Psychology</i>, vol. vii, No. 2, p. 189.)</p></div> + +<p>In the study of "Love and Pain" in a previous volume, the analysis of the +large and complex mass of sexual phenomena which are associated with pain, +gradually resolved them to a considerable extent into a special case of +erotic symbolism; pain or restraint, whether inflicted on or by the loved +person, becomes, by a psychic process that is usually unconscious, the +symbol of the sexual mechanism, and hence arouses the same emotions as +that mechanism normally arouses. We may now attempt to deal more broadly +and comprehensively with the normal and abnormal aspects of erotic +symbolism in some of their most typical and least mixed forms.</p> + +<p>"When our human imagination seeks to animate artificial things," Huysmans +writes in <i>Là-bas</i>, "it is compelled to reproduce the movements of animals +in the act of propagation. Look at machines, at the play of pistons in the +cylinders; they are Romeos of steel in Juliets of cast-iron." And not only +in the work of man's hands but throughout Nature we find sexual symbols +which are the less deniable since, for the most part, they make not the +slightest appeal to even the most morbid human imagination. Language is +full of metaphorical symbols of sex which constantly tend to lose their +poetic symbolism and to become commonplace. Semen is but seed, and for the +Latins especially the whole process of human sex, as well as the male <a name='5_Page_5'></a>and +female organs, constantly presented itself in symbols derived from +agricultural and horticultural life. The testicles were beans (<i>fabæ</i>) and +fruit or apples (<i>poma</i> and <i>mala</i>); the penis was a tree (<i>arbor</i>), or a +stalk (<i>thyrsus</i>), or a root (<i>radix</i>), or a sickle (<i>falx</i>), or a +ploughshare (<i>vomer</i>). The semen, again, was dew (<i>ros</i>). The labia majora +or minora were wings (<i>alæ</i>); the vulva and vagina were a field (<i>ager</i> +and <i>campus</i>), or a ploughed furrow (<i>sulcus</i>), or a vineyard (<i>vinea</i>), +or a fountain (<i>fons</i>), while the pudendal hair was herbage +(<i>plantaria</i>).<a name='5_FNanchor_4'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_4'><sup>[4]</sup></a> In other languages it is not difficult to trace similar +and even identical imagery applied to sexual organs and sexual acts. Thus +it is noteworthy that Shakespeare more than once applies the term +"ploughed" to a woman who has had sexual intercourse. The Talmud calls the +labia minora the doors, the labia majora hinges, and the clitoris the key. +The Greeks appear not only to have found in the myrtle-berry, the fruit of +a plant sacred to Venus, the image of the clitoris, but also in the rose +an image of the feminine labia; in the poetic literature of many +countries, indeed, this imagery of the rose may be traced in a more or +less veiled manner.<a name='5_FNanchor_5'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_5'><sup>[5]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The widespread symbolism of sex arose in the theories and conceptions of +primitive peoples concerning the function of generation and its nearest +analogies in Nature; it was continued for the sake of the vigorous and +expressive terminology which it furnished both for daily life and for +literature; its final survivals were cultivated because they furnished a +delicately æsthetic method of approaching matters which a growing +refinement of sentiment made it difficult for lovers and poets to approach +in a more crude and direct manner. Its existence is of interest to us now +because it shows the objective validity of the basis on <a name='5_Page_6'></a>which erotic +symbolism, as we have here to understand it, develops. But from first to +last it is a distinct phenomenon, having a more or less reasoned and +intellectual basis, and it scarcely serves in any degree to feed the +sexual impulse. Erotic symbolism is not intellectual but emotional in its +origin; it starts into being, obscurely, with but a dim consciousness or +for the most part none at all, either suddenly from the shock of some +usually youthful experience, or more gradually through an instinctive +brooding on those things which are most intimately associated with a +sexually desirable person.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The kind of soil on which the germs of erotic symbolism may + develop is well seen in cases of sexual hyperæsthesia. In such + cases all the emotionally sexual analogies and resemblances, + which in erotic symbolism are fixed and organized, may be traced + in vague and passing forms, a single hyperæsthetic individual + perhaps presenting a great variety of germinal symbolisms.</p> + +<p> Thus it has been recorded of an Italian nun (whose sister became + a prostitute) that from the age of 8 she had desire for coitus, + from the age of 10 masturbated, and later had homosexual + feelings, that the same feelings and practices continued after + she had taken the veil, though from time to time they assumed + religious equivalents. The mere contact, indeed, of a priest's + hand, the news of the presentation of an ecclesiastic she had + known to a bishopric, the sight of an ape, the contemplation of + the crucified Christ, the figure of a toy, the picture of a + demon, the act of defecation in the children entrusted to her + care (whom, on this account, and against the regulations, she + would accompany to the closets), especially the sight and the + mere recollection of flies in sexual connection—all these things + sufficed to produce in her a powerful orgasm. (<i>Archivio di + Psichiatria</i>, 1902, fasc. II-III, p. 338.)</p> + +<p> A boy of 15 (given to masturbation), studied by Macdonald in + America, was similarly hyperæsthetic to the symbols of sexual + emotion. "I like amusing myself with my comrades," he told + Macdonald, "rolling ourselves into a ball, which gives one a + funny kind of warmth. I have a special pleasure in talking about + some things. It is the same when the governess kisses me on + saying good night or when I lean against her breast. I have that + sensation, too, when I see some of the pictures in the comic + papers, but only in those representing a woman, as when a young + man skating trips up a girl so that her clothes are raised a + little. When I read how a man saved a young girl from drowning, + so that they swam together, I had the same sensation. Looking at + the statues of women in the museum produces the same effect, or + when I <a name='5_Page_7'></a>see naked babies, or when a mother suckles a child. I + have often had that sensation when reading novels I ought not to + read, or when looking at a new-born calf, or seeing dogs and cows + and horses mounting on each other. When I see a girl flirting + with a boy, or leaning on his shoulder or with his arm round her + waist, I have an erection. It is the same when I see women and + little girls in bathing costume, or when boys talk of what their + fathers and mothers do together. In the Natural History Museum I + often see things which give me that sensation. One day when I + read how a man killed a young girl and carried her into a wood + and undressed her I had a feeling of enjoyment. When I read of + men who were bastards the idea of a woman having a child in that + way gives me this sensation. Some dances, and seeing young girls + astride a horse, excited me, too, and so in a circus when a woman + was shot out of a cannon and her skirts flew in the air. It has + no effect on me when I see men naked. Sometimes I enjoy seeing + women's underclothes in a shop, or when I see a lady or a girl + buying them, especially if they are drawers. When I saw a lady in + a dress which buttoned from top to bottom it had more effect on + me than seeing underclothes. Seeing dogs coupling gives me more + pleasure than looking at pretty women, but less than looking at + pretty little girls." In order of increasing intensity he placed + the phenomena that affected him thus: The coupling of flies, then + of horses, then the sight of women's undergarments, then a boy + and a girl flirting, then cows mounting on each other, the + statues of women with naked breasts, then contact with the + governess's body and breasts, finally coitus. (Arthur Macdonald, + <i>Le Criminel-Type</i>, pp. 126 <i>et seq.</i>)</p> + +<p> It is worthy of remark that the instinct of nutrition, when + restrained, may exhibit something of an analogous symbolism, + though in a minor degree, to that of sex. The ways in which a + hyperæsthetic hunger may seek its symbols are illustrated in the + case of a young woman called Nadia, who during several years was + carefully studied by Janet. It is a case of obsession ("maladie + du scrupule"), simulating hysterical anorexia, in which the + patient, for fear of getting fat, reduced her nourishment to the + smallest possible amount. "Nadia is generally hungry, even very + hungry. One can tell this by her actions; from time to time she + forgets herself to such an extent as to devour greedily anything + she can put her hands on. At other times, when she cannot resist + the desire to eat, she secretly takes a biscuit. She feels + horrible remorse for the action, but, all the same, she does it + again. Her confidences are very curious. She recognizes that a + great effort is needed to avoid eating, and considers she is a + heroine to resist so long. 'Sometimes I spent whole hours in + thinking about food, I was so hungry; I swallowed my saliva, I + bit my handkerchief, I rolled on the floor, I wanted to eat so + badly. I would look in books for descriptions of meals <a name='5_Page_8'></a>and + feasts, and tried to deceive my hunger by imagining that I was + sharing all these good things,'" (P. Janet, "La Maladie du + Scrupule," <i>Revue Philosophique</i>, May, 1901, p. 502.) The + deviations of the instinct of nutrition are, however, confined + within narrow limits, and, in the nature of things, hunger, + unlike sexual desire, cannot easily accept a fetich.</p></div> + +<p>"There is almost no feature, article of dress, attitude, act," Stanley +Hall declares, "or even animal or perhaps object in nature, that may not +have to some morbid soul specialized erogenic and erethic power."<a name='5_FNanchor_6'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_6'><sup>[6]</sup></a> Even +a mere shadow may become a fetich. Goron tells of a merchant in Paris—a +man with a reputation for ability, happily married and the father of a +family, altogether irreproachable in his private life—who was returning +home one evening after a game of billiards with a friend, when, on +chancing to raise his eyes, he saw against a lighted window the shadow of +a woman changing her chemise. He fell in love with that shadow and +returned to the spot every evening for many months to gaze at the window. +Yet—and herein lies the fetichism—he made no attempt to see the woman or +to find out who she was; the shadow sufficed; he had no need of the +realty.<a name='5_FNanchor_7'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_7'><sup>[7]</sup></a> It is even possible to have a negative fetich, the absence of +some character being alone demanded, and the case has been recorded in +Chicago of an American gentleman of average intelligence, education, and +good habits who, having as a boy cherished a pure affection for a girl +whose leg had been amputated, throughout life was relatively impotent with +normal women, but experienced passion and affection for women who had lost +a leg; he was found by his wife to be in extensive correspondence with +one-legged women all over the country, expending no little money on the +purchase of artificial legs for his various protegées.<a name='5_FNanchor_8'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_8'><sup>[8]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is important to remember, however, that while erotic symbolism becomes +fantastic and abnormal in its extreme manifestations, <a name='5_Page_9'></a>it is in its +essence absolutely normal. It is only in the very grossest forms of sexual +desire that it is altogether absent. Stendhal described the mental side of +the process of tumescence as a crystallization, a process whereby certain +features of the beloved person present points around which the emotions +held in solution in the lover's mind may concentrate and deposit +themselves in dazzling brilliance. This process inevitably tends to take +place around all those features and objects associated with the beloved +person which have most deeply impressed the lover's mind, and the more +sensitive and imaginative and emotional he is the more certainly will such +features and objects crystallize into erotic symbols. "Devotion and love," +wrote Mary Wollstonecraft, "may be allowed to hallow the garments as well +as the person, for the lover must want fancy who has not a sort of sacred +respect for the glove or slipper of his mistress. He would not confound +them with vulgar things of the same kind." And nearly two centuries +earlier Burton, who had gathered together so much of the ancient lore of +love, clearly asserted the entirely normal character of erotic symbolism. +"Not one of a thousand falls in love," he declares, "but there is some +peculiar part or other which pleaseth most, and inflames him above the +rest.... If he gets any remnant of hers, a busk-point, a feather of her +fan, a shoe-tie, a lace, a ring, a bracelet of hair, he wears it for a +favor on his arm, in his hat, finger, or next his heart; as Laodamia did +by Protesilaus, when he went to war, sit at home with his picture before +her: a garter or a bracelet of hers is more precious than any Saint's +Relique, he lays it up in his casket (O blessed Relique) and every day +will kiss it: if in her presence his eye is never off her, and drink he +will where she drank, if it be possible, in that very place," etc.<a name='5_FNanchor_9'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_9'><sup>[9]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Burton's accuracy in describing the ways of lovers in his century + is shown by a passage in Hamilton's <i>Mémoires de Gramont</i>. Miss + Price, one of the beauties of Charles II's court, and Dongan were + tenderly <a name='5_Page_10'></a>attached to each other; when the latter died he left + behind a casket full of all possible sorts of love-tokens + pertaining to his mistress, including, among other things, "all + kinds of hair." And as regards France, Burton's contemporary, + Howell, wrote in 1627 in his <i>Familiar Letters</i> concerning the + repulse of the English at Rhé: "A captain told me that when they + were rifling the dead bodies of the French gentlemen after the + first invasion they found that many of them had their mistresses' + favors tied about their genitories."</p> + +<p> Schurig (<i>Spermatologia</i>, p. 357) at the beginning of the + eighteenth century knew a Belgian lady who, when her dearly loved + husband died, secretly cut off his penis and treasured it as a + sacred relic in a silver casket. She eventually powdered it, he + adds, and found it an efficacious medicine for herself and + others. An earlier example, of a lady at the French court who + embalmed and perfumed the genital organs of her dead husband, + always preserving them in a gold casket, is mentioned by + Brantôme. Mantegazza knew a man who kept for many years on his + desk the skull of his dead mistress, making it his dearest + companion. "Some," he remarks, "have slept for months and years + with a book, a garment, a trifle. I once had a friend who would + spend long hours of joy and emotion kissing a thread of silk + which <i>she</i> had held between her fingers, now the only relic of + love." (Mantegazza, <i>Fisiologia dell' Amore</i>, cap. X.) In the + same way I knew a lady who in old age still treasured in her + desk, as the one relic of the only man she had ever been + attracted to, a fragment of paper he had casually twisted up in a + conversation with her half a century before.</p></div> + +<p>The tendency to treasure the relics of a beloved person, more especially +the garments, is the simplest and commonest foundation of erotic +symbolism. It is without doubt absolutely normal. It is inevitable that +those objects which have been in close contact with the beloved person's +body, and are intimately associated with that person in the lover's mind, +should possess a little of the same virtue, the same emotional potency. It +is a phenomenon closely analogous to that by which the relics of saints +are held to possess a singular virtue. But it becomes somewhat less normal +when the garment is regarded as essential even in the presence of the +beloved person.<a name='5_FNanchor_10'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_10'><sup>[10]</sup></a></p> + +<p>While an extremely large number of objects and acts may be found to +possess occasionally the value of erotic symbols, such <a name='5_Page_11'></a>symbols most +frequently fall into certain well-defined groups. A vast number of +isolated objects or acts may be exceptionally the focus of erotic +contemplation, but the objects and acts which frequently become thus +symbolic are comparatively few.</p> + +<p>It seems to me that the phenomena of erotic symbolism may be most +conveniently grouped in three great classes, on the basis of the objects +or acts which arouse them.</p> +<br /> +<p><b>I. PARTS OF THE BODY.—</b></p> + +<p><i>A. Normal:</i> Hand, foot, breasts, nates, hair, +secretions and excretions, etc.</p> + +<p><i>B. Abnormal:</i> Lameness, squinting, pitting of smallpox, etc. Paidophilia +or the love of children, presbyophilia or the love of the aged, and +necrophilia or the attraction for corpses, may be included under this +head, as well as the excitement caused by various animals.</p> +<br /> + +<p><b>II. INANIMATE OBJECTS.<a name='5_FNanchor_11'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_11'><sup>[11]</sup></a>—</b></p> + +<p><i>A. Garments:</i> Gloves, shoes and stockings and +garters, caps, aprons, handkerchiefs, underlinen.</p> + +<p><i>B. Impersonal Objects:</i> Here may be included all the various objects that +may accidentally acquire the power of exciting sexual feeling in +auto-erotism. Pygmalionism may also be included.</p> +<br /> + +<p><b>III. ACTS AND ATTITUDES.—</b></p> + +<p><i>A. Active:</i> Whipping, cruelty, exhibitionism.</p> + +<p><i>B. Passive:</i> Being whipped, experiencing cruelty. Personal odors and the +sound of the voice may be included under this head. </p> + +<p><i>C. Mixoscopic:</i> The +vision of climbing, swinging, etc. The acts of urination and defecation. +The coitus of animals.</p> + +<p>Although the three main groups into which the phenomena of erotic +symbolism are here divided may seem fairly distinct, they are yet very +closely allied, and indeed overlap, so that it <a name='5_Page_12'></a>is possible, as we shall +see, for a single complex symbol to fall into all three groups.</p> + +<p>A very complete kind of erotic symbolism is furnished by Pygmalionism or +the love of statues.<a name='5_FNanchor_12'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_12'><sup>[12]</sup></a> It is exactly analogous to the child's love of a +doll, which is also a form of sexual (though not erotic) symbolism. In a +somewhat less abnormal form, erotic symbolism probably shows itself in its +simplest shape in the tendency to idealize unbeautiful peculiarities in a +beloved person, so that such peculiarities are ever afterward almost or +quite essential in order to arouse sexual attraction. In this way men have +become attracted to limping women. Even the most normal man may idealize a +trifling defect in a beloved woman. The attention is inevitably +concentrated on any such slight deviation from regular beauty, and the +natural result of such concentration is that a complexus of associated +thoughts and emotions becomes attached to something that in itself is +unbeautiful. A defect becomes an admired focus of attention, the embodied +symbol of the lover's emotion.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Thus a mole is not in itself beautiful, but by the tendency to + erotic symbolism it becomes so. Persian poets especially have + lavished the richest imagery on moles (<i>Anis El-Ochchâq</i> in + <i>Bibliothèque des Hautes Etudes</i>, fasc, 25, 1875); the Arabs, as + Lane remarks (<i>Arabian Society in the Middle Ages</i>, p. 214), are + equally extravagant in their admiration of a mole.</p> + +<p> Stendhal long since well described the process by which a defect + becomes a sexual symbol. "Even little defects in a woman's face," + he remarked, "such as a smallpox pit, may arouse the tenderness + of a man who loves her, and throw him into deep reverie when he + sees them in another woman. It is because he has experienced a + thousand feelings in the presence of that smallpox mark, that + these feelings have been for the most part delicious, all of the + highest interest, and that, whatever they may have been, they are + renewed with incredible vivacity on the sight of this sign, even + when perceived on the face of another woman. If in such a case we + come to prefer and love <i>ugliness</i>, it is only because in such a + case ugliness is beauty. A man loved a woman who <a name='5_Page_13'></a>was very thin + and marked by smallpox; he lost her by death. Three years later, + in Rome, he became acquainted with two women, one very beautiful, + the other thin and marked by smallpox, on that account, if you + will, rather ugly. I saw him in love with this plain one at the + end of a week, which he had employed in effacing her plainness by + his memories." (<i>De l'Amour</i>, Chapter XVII.)</p></div> + +<p>In the tendency to idealize the unbeautiful features of a beloved person +erotic symbolism shows itself in a simple and normal form. In a less +simple and more morbid form it appears in persons in whom the normal paths +of sexual gratification are for some reasons inhibited, and who are thus +led to find the symbols of natural love in unnatural perversions. It is +for this reason that so many erotic symbolisms take root in childhood and +puberty, before the sexual instincts have reached full development. It is +for the same reason also, that, at the other end of life, when the sexual +energies are failing, erotic symbols sometimes tend to be substituted for +the normal pleasures of sex. It is for this reason, again, that both men +and women whose normal energies are inhibited sometimes find the symbols +of sexual gratification in the caresses of children.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The case of a schoolmistress recorded by Penta instructively + shows how an erotic symbolism of this last kind may develop by no + means as a refinement of vice, but as the one form in which + sexual gratification becomes possible when normal gratification + has been pathologically inhibited. F. R., aged 48, schoolmistress; + she was some years ago in an asylum with religious mania, but + came out well in a few months. At the age of 12 she had first + experienced sexual excitement in a railway train from the jolting + of the carriage. Soon after she fell in love with a youth who + represented her ideal and who returned her affection. When, + however, she gave herself to him, great was her disillusion and + surprise to find that the sexual act which she had looked forward + to could not be accomplished, for at the first contact there was + great pain and spasmodic resistance of the vagina. There was a + condition of vaginismus. After repeated attempts on subsequent + occasions her lover desisted. Her desire for intercourse + increased, however, rather than diminished, and at last she was + able to tolerate coitus, but the pain was so great that she + acquired a horror of the sexual embrace and no longer sought it. + Having much will power, she restrained all erotic impulses during + many years. It was not until the period of the menopause that the + long repressed desires broke out, and at last found a <a name='5_Page_14'></a>symbolical + outlet that was no longer normal, but was felt to supply a + complete gratification. She sought the close physical contact of + the young children in her care. She would lie on her bed naked, + with two or three naked children, make them suck her breasts and + press them to every part of her body. Her conduct was discovered + by means of other children who peeped through the keyhole, and + she was placed under Penta for treatment. In this case the loss + of moral and mental inhibition, due probably to troubles of the + climacteric, led to indulgence, under abnormal conditions, in + those primitive contacts which are normally the beginning of + love, and these, supported by the ideal image of the early lover, + constituted a complete and adequate symbol of natural love in a + morbidly perverted individual. (P. Penta, <i>Archivio delle + Psicopatie Sessuali</i>, January, 1896.)</p></div> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_1'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_1'>[1]</a><div class='note'><p> The term "erotic symbolism" has already been employed by +Eulenburg (<i>Sexuale Neuropathie</i>, 1895, p. 101). It must be borne in mind +that this term, implying the specific emotion, is much narrower than the +term "sexual symbolism," which may be used to designate a great variety of +ritual and social practices which have played a part in the evolution of +civilization.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_2'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_2'>[2]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Sexual Selection in Man</i>, iv, "Vision."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_3'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_3'>[3]</a><div class='note'><p> K. Groos, <i>Der Æsthetische Genuss</i>, p. 122. The psychology of +the associations of contiguity and resemblance through which erotic +symbolism operates its transference is briefly discussed by Ribot in the +<i>Psychology of the Emotions</i>, Part 1, Chapter XII; the early chapters of +the same author's <i>Logique des Sentiments</i> may also be said to deal with +the emotional basis on which erotic symbolism arises.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_4'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_4'>[4]</a><div class='note'><p> A number of synonyms for the female pudenda are brought +together by Schurig—cunnus, hortus, concha, navis, fovea, larva, canis, +annulus, focus, cymba, antrum, delta, myrtus, etc.—and he discusses many +of them. (<i>Muliebria</i>, Section I, cap. I.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_5'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_5'>[5]</a><div class='note'><p> Kleinpaul, <i>Sprache Ohne Worte</i>, pp. 24-29; <i>cf.</i> K. Pearson, +on the general and special words for sex, <i>Chances of Death</i>, vol. ii, pp. +112-245; a selection of the literature of the rose will be found in a +volume of translations entitled <i>Ros Rosarum</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_6'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_6'>[6]</a><div class='note'><p> G. S. Hall, <i>Adolescence</i>, vol. i, p. 470.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_7'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_7'>[7]</a><div class='note'><p> Goron, <i>Les Parias de l'Amour</i>, p. 45.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_8'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_8'>[8]</a><div class='note'><p> A. R. Reynolds, <i>Medical Standard</i>, vol. x, cited by Kiernan, +"Responsibility in Sexual Perversion," <i>American Journal of Neurology and +Psychiatry</i>, 1882.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_9'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_9'>[9]</a><div class='note'><p> R. Burton, <i>Anatomy of Melancholy</i>, Part III, Section II, +Mem. II, Subs. II, and Mem. III, Subs. I.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_10'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_10'>[10]</a><div class='note'><p> Numerous examples are given by Moll, <i>Konträre +Sexualempfindung</i>, third edition, pp. 265-268.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_11'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_11'>[11]</a><div class='note'><p> Chevalier (<i>De l'Inversion</i>, 1885; <i>id.</i>, <i>L'Inversion +Sexuelle</i>, 1892, p. 52), followed by E. Laurent (<i>L'Amour Morbide</i>, 1891, +Chapter X), separates this group from other fetichistic perversions, under +the head of "azoöphilie." I see no adequate ground for this step. The +various forms of fetichism are too intimately associated to permit of any +group of them being violently separated from the others.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_12'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_12'>[12]</a><div class='note'><p> This has already been considered as a perversion founded on +vision, in discussing <i>Sexual Selection in Man</i>. IV.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_E_II'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_15'></a>II.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Foot-fetichism and Shoe-fetichism—Wide Prevalence and Normal +Basis—Restif de la Bretonne—The Foot a Normal Focus of Sexual Attraction +Among Some Peoples—The Chinese, Greeks, Romans, Spaniards, etc.—The +Congenital Predisposition in Erotic Symbolism—The Influence of Early +Association and Emotional Shock—Shoe-fetichism in Relation to +Masochism—The Two Phenomena Independent Though Allied—The Desire to be +Trodden On—The Fascination of Physical Constraint—The Symbolism of +Self-inflicted Pain—The Dynamic Element in Erotic Symbolism—The +Symbolism of Garments.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>Of all forms of erotic symbolism the most frequent is that which idealizes +the foot and the shoe. The phenomena we here encounter are sometimes so +complex and raise so many interesting questions that it is necessary to +discuss them somewhat fully.</p> + +<p>It would seem that even for the normal lover the foot is one of the most +attractive parts of the body. Stanley Hall found that among the parts +specified as most admired in the other sex by young men and women who +answered a <i>questionnaire</i> the feet came fourth (after the eyes, hair, +stature and size).<a name='5_FNanchor_13'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_13'><sup>[13]</sup></a> Casanova, an acute student and lover of women who +was in no degree a foot fetichist, remarks that all men who share his +interest in women are attracted by their feet; they offer <a name='5_Page_16'></a>the same +interest, he considers, as the question of the particular edition offers +to the book-lover.<a name='5_FNanchor_14'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_14'><sup>[14]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In a report of the results of a <i>questionnaire</i> concerning + children's sense of self, to which over 500 replies were + received, Stanley Hall thus summarizes the main facts ascertained + with reference to the feet: "A special period of noticing the + feet comes somewhat later than that in which the hands are + discovered to consciousness. Our records afford nearly twice as + many cases for feet as for hands. The former are more remote from + the primary psychic focus or position, and are also more often + covered, so that the sight of them is a more marked and + exceptional event. Some children become greatly excited whenever + their feet are exposed. Some infants show signs of fear at the + movement of their own knees and feet covered, and still more + often fright is the first sensation which signalizes the child's + discovery of its feet.... Many are described as playing with them + as if fascinated by strange, newly-discovered toys. They pick + them up and try to throw them away, or out of the cradle, or + bring them to the mouth, where all things tend to go.... Children + often handle their feet, pat and stroke them, offer them toys and + the bottle, as if they, too, had an independent hunger to + gratify, an <i>ego</i> of their own.... Children often develop [later] + a special interest in the feet of others, and examine, feel them, + etc., sometimes expressing surprise that the pinch of the + mother's toe hurts her and not the child, or comparing their own + and the feet of others point by point. Curious, too, are the + intensifications of foot-consciousness throughout the early years + of childhood, whenever children have the exceptional privilege of + going barefoot, or have new shoes. The feet are often + apostrophized, punished, beaten sometimes to the point of pain + for breaking things, throwing the child down, etc. Several + children have habits, which reach great intensity, and then + vanish, of touching or tickling the feet, with gales of laughter, + and a few are described as showing an almost morbid reluctance to + wear anything upon the feet, or even to having them touched by + others.... Several almost fall in love with the great toe or the + little one, especially admiring some crease or dimple in it, + dressing it in some rag of silk or bit of ribbon, or cut-off + glove fingers, winding it with string, prolonging it by tying on + bits of wood. Stroking the feet of others, especially if they are + shapely, often becomes almost a passion with young children, and + several adults confess a survival of the same impulse which it is + an exquisite pleasure to gratify. The interest of some mothers in + babies' toes, the expressions of which are ecstatic and almost + incredible, is a factor of great importance." (G. Stanley Hall, + "Some Aspects of the<a name='5_Page_17'></a> Early Sense of Self," <i>American Journal of + Psychology</i>, April, 1898.) In childhood, Stanley Hall remarks + elsewhere (<i>Adolescence</i>, vol. ii, p. 104), "a form of courtship + may consist solely in touching feet under the desk." It would + seem that even animals have a certain amount of sexual + consciousness in the feet; I have noticed a male donkey, just + before coitus, bite the feet of his partner.</p></div> + +<p>At the same time it is scarcely usual for the normal lover, in most +civilized countries to-day, to attach primary importance to the foot, such +as he very frequently attaches to the eyes, though the feet play a very +conspicuous part in the work of certain novelists.<a name='5_FNanchor_15'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_15'><sup>[15]</sup></a></p> + +<p>In a small but not inconsiderable minority of persons, however, the foot +or the boot becomes the most attractive part of a woman, and in some +morbid cases the woman herself is regarded as a comparatively unimportant +appendage to her feet or her boots. The boots under civilized conditions +much more frequently constitute the sexual symbol than do the feet +themselves; this is not surprising since in ordinary life the feet are not +often seen.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It is usually only under exceptionally favoring conditions that + foot-fetichism occurs, as in the case recorded by Marandon de + Montyel of a doctor who had been brought up in the West Indies. + His mother had been insane and he himself was subject to + obsessions, especially of being incapable of urinating; he had + had nocturnal incontinence of urine in childhood. All the women + of the people in the West Indies go about with naked feet, which + are often beautiful. His puberty evolved under this influence, + and foot-fetichism developed. He especially admired large, fat, + arched feet, with delicate skin and large, regular toes. He + masturbated with images of feet. At 15 he had relations with a + colored chambermaid, but feared to mention his fetichism, though + it was the touch of her feet that chiefly excited him. He now + gave up masturbation, and had a succession of mistresses, but was + always ashamed to confess his fancies until, at the age of 33, in + Paris, a very intelligent woman who had become his mistress + discovered his <a name='5_Page_18'></a>mania and skillfully enabled him to yield to it + without shock to his modesty. He was devoted to this mistress, + who had very beautiful feet (he had been horrified by the feet of + Europeans generally), until she finally left him. (<i>Archives de + Neurologie</i>, October, 1904.)</p> + +<p> Probably the first case of shoe-fetichism ever recorded in any + detail is that of Restif de la Bretonne (1734-1806), publicist + and novelist, one of the most remarkable literary figures of the + later eighteenth century in France. Restif was a neurotic + subject, though not to an extreme degree, and his shoe-fetichism, + though distinctly pronounced, was not pathological; that is to + say, that the shoe was not itself an adequate gratification of + the sexual impulse, but simply a highly important aid to + tumescence, a prelude to the natural climax of detumescence; only + occasionally, and <i>faute de mieux</i>, in the absence of the beloved + person, was the shoe used as an adjunct to masturbation. In + Restif's stories and elsewhere the attraction of the shoe is + frequently discussed or used as a motive. His first decided + literary success, <i>Le Pied de Fanchette</i>, was suggested by a + vision of a girl with a charming foot, casually seen in the + street. While all such passages in his books are really founded + on his own personal feelings and experiences, in his elaborate + autobiography, <i>Monsieur Nicolas</i>, he has frankly set forth the + gradual evolution and cause of his idiosyncrasy. The first + remembered trace dated from the age of 4, when he was able to + recall having remarked the feet of a young girl in his native + place. Restif was a sexually precocious youth, and at the age of + 9, though both delicate in health and shy in manners, his + thoughts were already absorbed in the girls around him. "While + little Monsieur Nicolas," he tells us, "passed for a Narcissus, + his thoughts, as soon as he was alone, by night or by day, had no + other object than that sex he seemed to flee from. The girls most + careful of their persons were naturally those who pleased him + most, and as the part least easy to keep clean is that which + touches the earth it was to the foot-gear that he mechanically + gave his chief attention. Agathe, Reine, and especially + Madeleine, were the most elegant of the girls at that time; their + carefully selected and kept shoes, instead of laces or buckles, + which were not yet worn at Sacy, had blue or rose ribbon, + according to the color of the skirt. I thought of these girls + with emotion; I desired—I knew not what; but I desired + something, if it were only to subdue them." The origin Restif + here assigns to his shoe-fetichism may seem paradoxical; he + admired the girls who were most clean and neat in their dress, he + tells us, and, therefore, paid most attention to that part of + their clothing which was least clean and neat. But, however + paradoxical the remark may seem, it is psychologically sound. All + fetichism is a kind of not necessarily morbid obsession, and as + the careful work of Janet and others in that field has shown, an + obsession is a fascinated attraction to some object or idea + <a name='5_Page_19'></a>which gives the subject a kind of emotional shock by its + contrast to his habitual moods or ideas. The ordinary morbid + obsession cannot usually be harmoniously co-ordinated with the + other experiences of the subject's daily life, and shows, + therefore, no tendency to become pleasurable. Sexual fetichisms, + on the other hand, have a reservoir of agreeable emotion to draw + on, and are thus able to acquire both stability and harmony. It + will also be seen that no element of masochism is involved in + Restif's fetichism, though the mistake has been frequently made + of supposing that these two manifestations are usually or even + necessarily allied. Restif wishes to subject the girl who + attracts him, he has no wish to be subjected by her. He was + especially dazzled by a young girl from another town, whose shoes + were of a fashionable cut, with buckles, "and who was a charming + person besides." She was delicate as a fairy, and rendered his + thoughts unfaithful to the robust beauties of his native Sacy. + "No doubt," he remarks, "because, being frail and weak myself, it + seemed to me that it would be easier to subdue her." "This taste + for the beauty of the feet," he continues, "was so powerful in me + that it unfailingly aroused desire and would have made me + overlook ugliness. It is excessive in all those who have it." He + admired the foot as well as the shoe: "The factitious taste for + the shoe is only a reflection of that for pretty feet. When I + entered a house and saw the boots arranged in a row, as is the + custom, I would tremble with pleasure; I blushed and lowered my + eyes as if in the presence of the girls themselves. With this + vivacity of feeling and a voluptuousness of ideas inconceivable + at the age of 10 I still fled, with an involuntary impulse of + modesty, from the girls I adored."</p> + +<p> We may clearly see how this combination of sensitive and + precocious sexual ardor with extreme shyness, furnished the soil + on which the germ of shoe-fetichism was able to gain a firm root + and persist in some degree throughout a long life very largely + given up to a pursuit of women, abnormal rather by its + excessiveness than its perversity. A few years later, he tells + us, he happened to see a pretty pair of shoes in a bootmaker's + shop, and on hearing that they belonged to a girl whom at that + time he reverently adored at a distance he blushed and nearly + fainted.</p> + +<p> In 1749 he was for a time attracted to a young woman very much + older than himself; he secretly carried away one of her slippers + and kept it for a day; a little later he again took away a shoe + of the same woman which had fascinated him when on her foot, and, + he seems to imply, he used it to masturbate with.</p> + +<p> Perhaps the chief passion of Restif's life was his love for + Colette Parangon. He was still a boy (1752), she was the young + and virtuous wife of the printer whose apprentice Restif was and + in whose house he lived. Madame Parangon, a charming woman, as + she is described, <a name='5_Page_20'></a>was not happily married, and she evidently + felt a tender affection for the boy whose excessive love and + reverence for her were not always successfully concealed. + "Madonna Parangon," he tells us, "possessed a charm which I could + never resist, a pretty little foot; it is a charm which arouses + more than tenderness. Her shoes, made in Paris, had that + voluptuous elegance which seems to communicate soul and life. + Sometimes Colette wore shoes of simple white drugget or with + silver flowers; sometimes rose-colored slippers with green heels, + or green with rose heels; her supple feet, far from deforming her + shoes, increased their grace and rendered the form more + exciting." One day, on entering the house, he saw Madame Parangon + elegantly dressed and wearing rose-colored shoes with tongues, + and with green heels and a pretty rosette. They were new and she + took them off to put on green slippers with rose heels and + borders which he thought equally exciting. As soon as she had + left the room, he continues, "carried away by the most impetuous + passion and idolizing Colette, I seemed to see her and touch her + in handling what she had just worn; my lips pressed one of these + jewels, while the other, deceiving the sacred end of nature, from + excess of exaltation replaced the object of sex (I cannot express + myself more clearly). The warmth which she had communicated to + the insensible object which had touched her still remained and + gave a soul to it; a voluptuous cloud covered my eyes." He adds + that he would kiss with rage and transport whatever had come in + close contact with the woman he adored, and on one occasion + eagerly pressed his lips to her cast-off underlinen, <i>vela + secretiora penetralium</i>.</p> + +<p> At this period Restif's foot-fetichism reached its highest point + of development. It was the aberration of a highly sensitive and + very precocious boy. While the preoccupation with feet and shoes + persisted throughout life, it never became a complete perversion + and never replaced the normal end of sexual desire. His love for + Madam Parangon, one of the deepest emotions in his whole life, + was also the climax of his shoe-fetichism. She represented his + ideal woman, an ethereal sylph with wasp-waist and a child's + feet; it was always his highest praise for a woman that she + resembled Madame Parangon, and he desired that her slipper should + be buried with him. (Restif de la Bretonne, <i>Monsieur Nicolas</i>, + vols. i-iv, vol. xiii, p. 5; <i>id.</i>, <i>Mes Inscriptions</i>, pp. + ci-cv.)</p> + +<p> Shoe-fetichism, more especially if we include under this term all + the cases of real or pseudo-masochism in which an attraction to + the boots or slippers is the chief feature, is a not infrequent + phenomenon, and is certainly the most frequently occurring form + of fetichism. Many cases are brought together by Krafft-Ebing in + his <i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>. Every prostitute of any experience + has known men who merely desire to gaze at her shoes, or possibly + to lick them, and who are quite willing to pay for this + privilege. In London such a person is known as a "bootman," in + Germany as a "Stiefelfrier."</p></div><a name='5_Page_21'></a> + +<p>The predominance of the foot as a focus of sexual attraction, while among +us to-day it is a not uncommon phenomenon, is still not sufficiently +common to be called normal; the majority of even ardent lovers do not +experience this attraction in any marked degree. But these manifestations +of foot-fetichism which with us to-day are abnormal, even when they are +not so extreme as to be morbid, may perhaps become more intelligible to us +when we realize that in earlier periods of civilization, and even to-day +in some parts of the world, the foot is generally recognized as a focus of +sexual attraction, so that some degree of foot-fetichism becomes a normal +phenomenon.</p> + +<p>The most pronounced and the best known example of such normal +foot-fetichism at the present day is certainly to be found among the +Southern Chinese. For a Chinese husband his wife's foot is more +interesting than her face. A Chinese woman is as shy of showing her feet +to a man as a European woman her breasts; they are reserved for her +husband's eyes alone, and to look at a woman's feet in the street is +highly improper and indelicate. Chinese foot-fetichism is connected with +the custom of compressing the feet. This custom appears to rest on the +fact that Chinese women naturally possess a very small foot and is thus an +example of the universal tendency in the search for beauty to accentuate, +even by deformation, the racial characteristics. But there is more than +this. Beauty is largely a name for sexual attractiveness, and the energy +expended in the effort to make the Chinese woman's small foot still +smaller is a measure of the sexual fascination which it exerts. The +practice arose on the basis of the sexual attractiveness of the foot, +though it has doubtless served to heighten that attractiveness, just as +the small waist, which (if we may follow Stratz) is a characteristic +beauty of the European woman, becomes to the average European man still +more attractive when accentuated, even to the extent of deformity, by the +compression of the corset.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Referring to the sexual fascination exerted by the foot in China, + Matignon writes: "My attention has been drawn to this point by a + large number of pornographic engravings, of which the Chinese are + very fond. In all these lascivious scenes we see the male + voluptuously fondling <a name='5_Page_22'></a>the woman's foot. When a Celestial takes + into his hand a woman's foot, especially if it is very small, the + effect upon him is precisely the same as is provoked in a + European by the palpation of a young and firm bosom. All the + Celestials whom I have interrogated on this point have replied + unanimously: 'Oh, a little foot! You Europeans cannot understand + how exquisite, how sweet, how exciting it is!' The contact of the + genital organ with the little foot produces in the male an + indescribable degree of voluptuous feeling, and women skilled in + love know that to arouse the ardor of their lovers a better + method than all Chinese aphrodisiacs—including 'giusen' and + swallows' nests—is to take the penis between their feet. It is + not rare to find Chinese Christians accusing themselves at + confession of having had 'evil thoughts on looking at a woman's + foot.'" (Dr. J. Matignon, "A propos d'un Pied de Chinoise," + <i>Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, 1898.)</p> + +<p> It is said that a Chinese Empress, noted for her vice and having + a congenital club foot, about the year 1100 B.C., desired all + women to resemble her, and that the practice of compressing the + foot thus arose. But this is only tradition, since, in 300 B.C., + Chinese books were destroyed (Morache, Art. "Chine," + <i>Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des Sciences Médicales</i>, p. 191). It + is also said that the practice owes its origin to the wish to + keep women indoors. But women are not secluded in China, nor does + foot compression usually render a woman unable to walk. Many + intelligent Chinese are of opinion that its object is to promote + the development of the sexual parts and of the thighs, and so to + aid both intercourse and parturition. There is no ground for + believing that it has any such influence, though Morache found + that the mons veneris and labia are largely developed in Chinese + women, and not in Tartar women living in Pekin (who do not + compress the foot). If there is any correlation between the feet + and the pelvic regions, it is more probably congenital than due + to the artificial compression of the feet. The ancients seem to + have believed that a small foot indicated a small vagina. Restif + de la Bretonne, who had ample opportunities for forming an + opinion on a matter in which he took so great an interest, + believed that a small foot, round and short, indicated a large + vagina (<i>Monsieur Nicolas</i>, vol. i, reprint of 1883, p. 92). + Even, however, if we admit that there is a real correlation + between the foot and the vagina, that would by no means suffice + to render the foot a focus of sexual attraction.</p> + +<p> It remains the most reasonable view that the foot bandage must be + regarded as strictly analogous to the waist bandage or corset + which also tends to produce deformity of the constricted region. + Stratz has ingeniously remarked (<i>Frauenkleidung</i>, third edition, + p. 101) that the success of the Chinese in dwarfing trees may + have suggested a similar attempt in regard to women's feet, and + adds that in any case both dwarfed trees and bound feet bear + witness in the Mongolian to the same <a name='5_Page_23'></a>love for small and elegant, + not to say deformed, things. For a Chinaman the deformed foot is + a "golden water-lily."</p> + +<p> Many facts (together with illustrations) bearing on Chinese + deformation of the foot will be found in Ploss, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. + i, Section IV.</p></div> + +<p>The significance of the sexual emotion aroused by the female foot in China +and the origin of its compression begin to become clear when we realize +that this foot-fetichism is merely an extreme development of a tendency +which is fairly well marked among nearly all the peoples of yellow race. +Jacoby, who has brought together a number of interesting facts bearing on +the sexual significance of the foot, states that a similar tendency is to +be found among the Mongol and Turk peoples of Siberia, and in the east and +central parts of European Russia, among the Permiaks, the Wotiaks, etc. +Here the woman, at all events when young, has always her feet, as well as +head, covered, however little clothing she may otherwise wear.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>"On hot nights or on baking days," Jacoby states, "you may see + these women with uncovered breasts, or even entirely naked + without embarrassment, but you will never see them with bare + feet, and no male relations, except the husband, will ever see + the feet and lower part of the legs of the women in the house. + These women have their modesty in their feet, and also their + coquetry; to unbind the feet of a woman is for a man a voluptuous + act, and the touch of the bands produces the same effect as a + corset still warm from a woman's body on a European man. A + woman's beauty, that which attracts and excites a man, lies in + her foot; in Mordvin love poems celebrating the beauty of women + there is much about her attire, especially her embroidered + chemise, but as regards the charms of her person the poet is + content to state that 'her feet are beautiful;' with that + everything is said. The young peasant woman of the central + provinces as part of her holiday raiment puts on great woolen + stockings which come up to the groin and are then folded over to + below the knee. To uncover the feet of a person of the opposite + sex is a sexual act, and has thus become the symbol of sexual + possession, so that the stocking or foot-gear became the emblem + of marriage, as later the ring. (It was so among the Jews, as we + see in the book of <i>Ruth</i>, Chapter III, v. 4, and Chapter IV, vv. + 7 and 8). St. Vladimir the Great asked in marriage the daughter + of Prince Rogvold; as Vladimir's mother had been a serf, the + princess proudly replied that she 'would not uncover the feet of + a slave.' At the present time in the <a name='5_Page_24'></a>east of Russia when a young + girl tries to find out by divination whom she will have as a + husband the traditional formula is 'Come and take my stockings + off.' Among the populations of the north and east, it is + sometimes the bride who must do this for her husband on the + wedding night, and sometimes the bridegroom for his wife, not as + a token of love, but as a nuptial ceremony. Among the + professional classes and small nobility in Russia parents place + money in the stocking of their child at marriage as a present for + the other partner, it being supposed that the couple mutually + remove each other's foot raiment, as an act of sexual possession, + the emblem of coitus." (Paul Jacoby, <i>Archives d'Anthropologie + Criminelle</i>, December, 1903, p. 793.) The practice among + ourselves of children hanging up their stockings at night for + presents would seem to be a relic of the last-mentioned custom.</p></div> + +<p>While we may witness the sexual symbolism of the foot, with or without an +associated foot-fetichism, most highly developed in Asia and Eastern +Europe, it has by no means been altogether unknown in some stages of +western civilization, and traces of it may be found here and there even +yet. Schinz refers to the connection between the feet and sexual pleasure +as existing not only among the Egyptians and the Arabs, but among the +ancient Germans and the modern Spaniards,<a name='5_FNanchor_16'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_16'><sup>[16]</sup></a> while Jacoby points out that +among the Greeks, the Romans, and especially the Etruscans, it was usual +to represent chaste and virgin goddesses with their feet covered, even +though they might be otherwise nude. Ovid, again, is never weary of +dwelling on the sexual charm of the feminine foot. He represents the +chaste matron as wearing a weighted <i>stola</i> which always fell so as to +cover her feet; it was only the courtesan, or the nymph who is taking part +in an erotic festival, who appears with raised robes, revealing her +feet.<a name='5_FNanchor_17'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_17'><sup>[17]</sup></a> So grave a historian as Strabo, as well as Ælian, <a name='5_Page_25'></a>refers to the +story of the courtesan Rhodope whose sandal was carried off by an eagle +and dropped in the King of Egypt's lap as he was administering justice, so +that he could not rest until he had discovered to whom this delicately +small sandal belonged, and finally made her his queen. Kleinpaul, who +repeats this story, has collected many European sayings and customs +(including Turkish), indicating that the slipper is a very ancient symbol +of a woman's sexual parts.<a name='5_FNanchor_18'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_18'><sup>[18]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In Rome, Dufour remarks, "Matrons having appropriated the use of + the shoe (<i>soccus</i>) prostitutes were not allowed to use it, and + were obliged to have their feet always naked in sandals or + slippers (<i>crepida</i> and <i>solea</i>), which they fastened over the + instep with gilt bands. Tibullus delights to describe his + mistress's little foot, compressed by the band that imprisoned + it: <i>Ansaque compressos colligat arcta pedes</i>. Nudity of the foot + in woman was a sign of prostitution, and their brilliant + whiteness acted afar as a pimp to attract looks and desires." + (Dufour, <i>Histoire de la Prostitution</i>, vol. II., ch. xviii.)</p> + +<p> This feeling seems to have survived in a more or less vague and + unconscious form in mediæval Europe. "In the tenth century," + according to Dufour (<i>Histoire de la Prostitution</i>, vol. VI., p. + 11), "shoes <i>a la poulaine</i>, with a claw or beak, pursued for + more than four centuries by the anathemas of popes and the + invectives of preachers, were always regarded by mediæval + casuists as the most abominable emblems of immodesty. At a first + glance it is not easy to see why these shoes—terminating in a + lion's claw, an eagle's beak, the prow of a ship, or other metal + appendage—should be so scandalous. The excommunication inflicted + on this kind of foot-gear preceded the impudent invention of some + libertine, who wore <i>poulaines</i> in the shape of the phallus, a + custom adopted also by women. This kind of <i>poulaine</i> was + denounced as <i>mandite de Dicu</i> (Ducange's Glossary, at the word + Poulainia) and prohibited by royal ordinances (see letter of + Charles V., 17 October, 1367, regarding the garments of the women + of Montpellier). Great lords and ladies continued, however, to + wear <i>poulaines</i>." In Louis XL's court they were still worn of a + quarter of an ell in length.</p> + +<p> Spain, ever tenacious of ancient ideas, appears to have preserved + <a name='5_Page_26'></a>longer than other countries the ancient classic traditions in + regard to the foot as a focus of modesty and an object of sexual + attraction. In Spanish religious pictures it was always necessary + that the Virgin's feet should be concealed, the clergy ordaining + that her robe should be long and flowing, so that the feet might + be covered with decent folds. Pacheco, the master and + father-in-law of Velasquez, writes in 1649 in his <i>Arte de la + Pintura</i>: "What can be more foreign from the respect which we owe + to the purity of Our Lady the Virgin than to paint her sitting + down with one of her knees placed over the other, and often with + her sacred feet uncovered and naked. Let thanks be given to the + Holy Inquisition which commands that this liberty should be + corrected!" It was Pacheco's duty in Seville to see that these + commands were obeyed. At the court of Philip IV. at this time the + princesses never showed their feet, as we may see in the pictures + of Velasquez. When a local manufacturer desired to present that + monarch's second bride, Mariana of Austria, with some silk + stockings the offer was indignantly rejected by the Court + Chamberlain: "The Queen of Spain has no legs!" Philip V.'s, queen + was thrown from her horse and dragged by the feet; no one + ventured to interfere until two gentlemen bravely rescued her and + then fled, dreading punishment by the king: they were, however, + graciously pardoned. Reinach ("Pieds Pudiques," <i>Cultes, Mythes + et Religions</i>, pp. 105-110) brings together several passages from + the Countess D'Aulnoy's account of the Madrid Court in the + seventeenth century and from other sources, showing how careful + Spanish ladies were as regards their feet, and how jealous + Spanish husbands were in this matter. At this time, when Spanish + influence was considerable, the fashion of Spain seems to have + spread to other countries. One may note that in Vandyck's + pictures of English beauties the feet are not visible, though in + the more characteristically English painters of a somewhat later + age it became usual to display them conspicuously, while the + French custom in this matter is the farthest removed from the + Spanish. At the present day a well-bred Spanish woman shows as + little as possible of her feet in walking, and even in some of + the most characteristic Spanish dances there is little or no + kicking, and the feet may even be invisible throughout. It is + noteworthy that in numerous figures of Spanish women (probably + artists' models) reproduced in Ploss's <i>Das Weib</i> the stockings + are worn, although the women are otherwise, in most cases, quite + naked. Max Dessoir mentions ("Psychologie der Vita Sexualis," + <i>Zeitschrift für Psychiatrie</i>, 1894, p. 954) that in Spanish + pornographic photographs women always have their shoes on, and he + considers this an indication of perversity. I have seen the + statement (attributed to Gautier's <i>Voyage en Espagne</i>, where, + however, it does not occur) that Spanish prostitutes uncover + their feet in sign of assent, and Madame d'Aulnoy stated that in + her time to show her lover her feet was a Spanish woman's final + favor.</p></div><a name='5_Page_27'></a> + +<p>The tendency, which we thus find to be normal at some earlier periods of +civilization, to insist on the sexual symbolism of the feminine foot or +its coverings, and to regard them as a special sexual fascination, is not +without significance for the interpretation of the sporadic manifestations +of foot-fetichism among ourselves. Eccentric as foot-fetichism may appear +to us, it is simply the re-emergence, by a pseudo-atavism or arrest of +development, of a mental or emotional impulse which was probably +experienced by our forefathers, and is often traceable among young +children to-day.<a name='5_FNanchor_19'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_19'><sup>[19]</sup></a> The occasional reappearance of this bygone impulse +and the stability which it may acquire are thus conditioned by the +sensitive reaction of an abnormally nervous and usually precocious +organism to influences which, among the average and ordinary population of +Europe to-day, are either never felt, or quickly outgrown, or very +strictly subordinated in the highly complex crystallizations which the +course of love and the process of tumescence create within us.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It may be added that this is by no means true of foot-fetichism + only. In some other fetichisms a seemingly congenital + predisposition is even more marked. This is not only the case as + regards hair-fetichism and fur-fetichism (see, <i>e.g.</i>, + Krafft-Ebing, <i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, English translation of + tenth edition, pp. 233, 255, 262). In many cases of fetichisms of + all kinds not only is there no record of any commencement in a + definite episode (an absence which may be accounted for by the + supposition that the original incident has been forgotten), but + it would seem in some cases that the fetichism developed very + slowly.</p></div> + +<p>In this sense, it will be seen, although it is hazardous to speak of +foot-fetichism as strictly an atavism, it may certainly be said to arise +on a congenital basis. It represents the rare development of an inborn +germ, usually latent among ourselves, which in earlier stages of +civilization frequently reached a normal and general fruition.</p> +<a name='5_Page_28'></a> +<p>It is of interest to emphasize this congenital element of foot symbolism, +because more than any other forms of sexual perversion the fetichisms are +those which are most vaguely conditioned by inborn states of the organism +and most definitely aroused by seemingly accidental associations or shocks +in early life. Inversion is sometimes so fundamentally ingrained in the +individual's constitution that it arises and develops in spite of the very +strongest influence in a contrary direction. But a fetichism, while it +tends to occur in sensitive, nervous, timid, precocious individuals—that +is to say, individuals of more or less neuropathic heredity—can usually, +though not always, be traced to a definite starting point in the shock of +some sexually emotional episode in early life.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>A few examples of the influences of such association may here be + given, referring miscellaneously to various forms of erotic + symbolism. Magnan has recorded the case of a hair-fetichist, + living in a district where the women wore their hair done up, who + at the age of 15 experienced pleasurable feelings with erection + at the sight of a village beauty combing her hair; from that time + flowing hair became his fetich, and he could not resist the + temptation to touch it and if possible sever it, thus becoming a + hair-despoiler, for which he was arrested but not sentenced. + (<i>Archives de l'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, vol. v, No. 28.)</p> + +<p> I have elsewhere recorded the history of a boy of 14, having + already had imperfect connection with a grown-up woman, who + associated much with a young married lady; he had no sexual + relations with her, but one day she urinated in his presence, and + he saw that her mons veneris was covered by very thick hair; from + that time he worshiped this woman in secret and acquired a + life-long fetichistic attraction to women whose pubic hair was + similarly abundant (<i>Studies in the Psychology of Sex</i>, vol. iii, + Appendix B, History V).</p> + +<p> Roubaud reported the case of a general's son, sexually initiated + at the age of 14 by a blonde young lady of 21 who, in order to + avoid detection, always retained her clothing: gaiters, a corset + and a silk dress; when the boy's studies were completed and he + was sent to a garrison where he could enjoy freedom he found that + his sexual desires could only be aroused by blonde women dressed + like the lady who had first aroused his sexual desires; + consequently he gave up all thoughts of matrimony, as a woman in + nightclothes produced impotence (<i>Traité de l'Impuissance</i>, p. + 439). Krafft-Ebing records the somewhat similar case of a nervous + Polish boy of old family seduced at the age of 17 by a French + governess, who during several months practiced mutual + masturbation <a name='5_Page_29'></a>with him; in this way his attention became + attracted by her very elegant boots, and in the end he became a + confirmed boot-fetichist (<i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, English + translation, p. 249).</p> + +<p> A boy of 7, of bad heredity, was taught to masturbate by a + servant girl; on one occasion she practiced this on him with her + foot without taking off her shoe; it was the first time the + manœuvre gave him any pleasure, and an association was + thus established which led to shoe-fetichism (Hammond, <i>Sexual + Impotence</i>, p. 44). A government official whose first coitus in + youth took place on a staircase; the sound of his partner's + creaking shoes against the stairs, produced by her efforts to + accelerate orgasm, formed an association which developed into an + auditory shoe-fetichism; in the streets he was compelled to + follow ladies whose shoes creaked, ejaculation being thus + produced, while to obtain complete satisfaction he would make a + prostitute, otherwise naked, sit in front of him in her shoes, + moving her feet so that the shoes creaked. (Moraglia, <i>Archivio + di Psichiatria</i>, vol. xiii, p. 568.)</p> + +<p> Bechterew, in St. Petersburg, has recorded the case of a man who + when a child used to fall asleep at the knees of his nurse with + his head buried in the folds of her apron; in this position he + first experienced erection and voluptuous sensations; when a + youth he had no attraction to naked women, and in real life and + in dreams was only excited sexually under conditions recalling + his early experience; in his relations with women he preferred + them dressed, and was excited by the rustling sound of their + skirts; in this case there was no traceable neuropathic taint nor + any other personal peculiarity. (Summarized in <i>Journal de + Psychologie Normale et Pathologique</i>, January-February, 1904, p. + 72.)</p> + +<p> In a curious case recorded in detail by Moll, a philologist of + sensitive temperament but sound heredity, who had always been + fond of flowers, at the age of 21 became engaged to a young lady + who wore large roses fastened in her jacket; from this time roses + became to him a sexual fetich, to kiss them caused erection, and + his erotic dreams were accompanied by visions of roses and the + hallucination of their odor; the engagement was finally broken + off and the rose-fetichism disappeared (<i>Untersuchungen über + Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. 540).</p></div> + +<p>Such associations may naturally occur in the early experiences of even the +most normal persons. The degree to which they will influence the +subsequent life and thought and feeling depends on the degree of the +individual's morbid emotional receptivity, on the extent to which he is +hereditarily susceptible of abnormal deviation. Precocity is undoubtedly a +condition which favors such deviation; a child who is precociously and +<a name='5_Page_30'></a>abnormally sensitive to persons of the opposite sex before puberty has +established the normal channels of sexual desire, is peculiarly liable to +become the prey of a chance symbolism. All degrees of such symbolism are +possible. While the average insensitive person may fail to perceive them +at all, for the more alert and imaginative lover they are a fascinating +part of the highly charged crystallization of passion. A more nervously +exceptional person, when once such a symbolism has become firmly +implanted, may find it an absolutely essential element in the charm of a +beloved and charming person. Finally, for the individual who is thoroughly +unsound the symbol becomes generalized; a person is no longer desired at +all, being merely regarded as an appendage of the symbol, or being +dispensed with altogether; the symbol is alone desired, and is fully +adequate to impart by itself complete sexual gratification. While it must +be considered a morbid state to demand a symbol as an almost essential +part of the charm of a desired person, it is only in the final condition, +in which the symbol becomes all-sufficing, that we have a true and +complete perversion. In the less complete forms of symbolism it is still +the woman who is desired, and the ends of procreation may be served; when +the woman is ignored and the mere symbol is an adequate and even preferred +stimulus to detumescence the pathological condition becomes complete.</p> + +<p>Krafft-Ebing regarded shoe-fetichism as, in large measure, a more or less +latent form of masochism, the foot or the shoe being the symbol of the +subjection and humiliation which the masochist feels in the presence of +the beloved object. Moll is also inclined to accept such a connection.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>"The very numerous class of boot-and-shoe-fetichists," + Krafft-Ebing wrote, "forms the transition to the manifestations + of another independent perversion, <i>i.e.</i>, fetichism itself; but + it stands in closer relationship to the former.... It is highly + probable, and shown by a correct classification of the observed + cases, that the majority, and perhaps all of the cases of + shoe-fetichism, rest upon a basis of more or less conscious + masochistic desire for self-humiliation.... The majority <a name='5_Page_31'></a>or all + may be looked upon as instances of latent masochism (the motive + remaining unconscious) in which the <i>female foot or shoe, as the + masochist's fetich</i>, has acquired an independent significance." + (<i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, English translation of tenth edition, + pp. 159, <i>et seq.</i>) "Though Krafft-Ebing may not have cleared up + the whole matter," Moll remarks, "I regard his deductions + concerning the connection of foot-and-shoe fetichism to masochism + as the most important progress that has been made in the + theoretic study of sexual perversions.... In any case, the + connection is very frequent." (<i>Konträre Sexualempfindung</i>, third + edition, p. 306.)</p></div> + +<p>It is quite easy to see that this supposed identity of masochism and +foot-fetichism forms a seductive theory. It is also undoubtedly true that +a masochist may very easily be inclined to find in his mistress's foot an +aid to the ecstatic self-abnegation which he desires to attain.<a name='5_FNanchor_20'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_20'><sup>[20]</sup></a> But +only confusion is attained by any general attempt to amalgamate masochism +and foot-fetichism. In the broad sense in which erotic symbolism is here +understood, both masochism and foot-fetichism may be coördinated as +symbolisms; for the masochist his self-humiliating impulses are the symbol +of ecstatic adoration; for the foot-fetichist his mistress's foot or shoe +is the concentrated symbol of all that is most beautiful and elegant and +feminine in her personality. But if in this sense they are coördinated, +they remain entirely distinct and have not even any necessary tendency to +become merged. Masochism merely simulates foot-fetichism; for the +masochist the boot is not strictly a symbol, it is only an instrument +which enables him to carry out his impulse; the true sexual symbol for him +is not the boot, but the emotion of self-subjection. For the +foot-fetichist, on the other hand, the foot or the shoe is not a mere +instrument, but a true symbol; the focus of his worship, an idealized +object which he is content to contemplate or reverently touch. He has no +necessary impulse to any self-degrading action, nor any constant emotion +of subjection.<a name='5_Page_32'></a> It may be noted that in the very typical case of +foot-fetichism which is presented to us in the person of Restif de la +Bretonne (<i>ante</i>, p. 18), he repeatedly speaks of "subjecting" the woman +for whom he feels this fetichistic adoration, and mentions that even when +still a child he especially admired a delicate and fairy-like girl in this +respect because she seemed to him easier to subjugate. Throughout life +Restif's attitude toward women was active and masculine, without the +slightest trace of masochism.<a name='5_FNanchor_21'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_21'><sup>[21]</sup></a></p> + +<p>To suppose that a fetichistic admiration of his mistress's foot is due to +a lover's latent desire to be kicked, is as unreasonable as it would be to +suppose that a fetichistic admiration for her hand indicated a latent +desire to have his ears boxed. In determining whether we are concerned +with a case of foot-fetichism or of masochism we must take into +consideration the whole of the subject's mental and emotional attitude. An +act, however definite, will not suffice as a criterion, for the same act +in different persons may have altogether different implications. To +amalgamate the two is the result of inadequate psychological analysis and +only leads to confusion.</p> + +<p>It is, however, often very difficult to decide whether we are dealing with +a case which is predominantly one of masochism or of foot-fetichism. The +nature of the action desired, as we have seen, will not suffice to +determine the psychological character of the perversion. Krafft-Ebing +believed that the desire to be trodden on, very frequently experienced by +masochists, is absolutely symptomatic of masochism.<a name='5_FNanchor_22'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_22'><sup>[22]</sup></a> This is scarcely +the case. The desire to be trodden on may be fundamentally an <a name='5_Page_33'></a>erotic +symbolism, closely approaching foot-fetichism, and such slight indications +of masochism as appear may be merely a parasitic growth on the symbolism, +a growth perhaps more suggested by the circumstances involved in the +gratification of the abnormal desire than inherent in the innate impulse +of the subject. This may be illustrated by the interesting case of a very +intelligent man with whom I am well acquainted.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>C. P., aged 38. Heredity good. Parents both healthy and normal. + Several children of the marriage, all sexually normal so far as + is known. C. P. is the youngest of the family and separated from + the others by an interval of many years. He was a seven-months' + child. He has always enjoyed good health and is active and + vigorous, both mentally and physically.</p> + +<p> From the age of 9 or 10 to 14 he masturbated occasionally for the + sake of physical relief, having discovered the act for himself. + He was, however, quite innocent and knew nothing of sexual + matters, never having been initiated either by servants or by + other boys.</p> + +<p> "When I encounter a woman who very strongly attracts me and whom + I very greatly admire," he writes, "my desire is never that I may + have sexual connection with her in the ordinary sense, but that I + may lie down upon the floor on my back and be trampled upon by + her. This curious desire is seldom present unless the object of + my admiration is really a lady, and of fine proportions. She must + be richly dressed—preferably in an evening gown, and wear dainty + high-heeled slippers, either quite open so as to show the curve + of the instep, or with only one strap or 'bar' across. The skirts + should be raised sufficiently to afford me the pleasure of seeing + her feet and a liberal amount of ankle, but in no case above the + knee, or the effect is greatly reduced. Although I often greatly + admire a woman's intellect and even person, sexually no other + part of her has any serious attraction for me except the leg, + from the knee downwards, and the foot, and these must be + exquisitely clothed. Given this condition, my desire amounts to a + wish to gratify my sexual sense by contact with the (to me) + attractive part of the woman. Comparatively few women have a leg + or foot sufficiently beautiful to my mind to excite any serious + or compelling desire, but when this is so, or I suspect it, I am + willing to spend any time or trouble to get her to tread upon me + and am anxious to be trampled on with the greatest severity.</p> + +<p> "The treading should be inflicted for a few minutes all over the + chest, abdomen and groin, and lastly on the penis, which is, of + course, lying along the belly in a violent state of erection, and + consequently too hard for the treading to damage it. I also enjoy + being nearly strangled by a woman's foot.</p><a name='5_Page_34'></a> + +<p> "If the lady finally stands facing my head and places her slipper + upon my penis so that the high heel falls about where the penis + leaves the scrotum, the sole covering most of the rest of it and + with the other foot upon the abdomen, into which I can <i>see</i> as + well as feel it sink as she shifts her weight from one foot to + the other, orgasm takes place almost at once. Emission under + these conditions is to me an agony of delight, during which + practically the lady's whole weight should rest upon the penis.</p> + +<p> "One reason for my special pleasure in this method seems to be + that first the heel and afterwards the sole of the slipper as it + treads upon the penis greatly check the passage of the semen and + consequently the pleasure is considerably prolonged. There is + also a curious mental side to the affair. I love to imagine that + the lady who is treading upon me is my mistress and I her slave, + and that she is doing it to punish me for some fault, or to give + <i>herself</i> (not me) pleasure.</p> + +<p> "It follows that the greater the contempt and severity with which + I am 'punished,' the greater becomes my pleasure. The idea of + 'punishment' or 'slavery' is seldom aroused except when I have + great difficulty in accomplishing my desire and the treader is + more than usually handsome and heavy and the trampling + mercilessly inflicted. I have been trampled so long and so + mercilessly several times, that I have flinched each time the + slipper pressed its way into my aching body and have been black + and blue for days afterwards. I take the greatest interest in + leading ladies on to do this for me where I think I will not + offend, and have been surprisingly successful. I must have lain + beneath the feet of quite a hundred women, many of them of good + social position, who would never dream of permitting any ordinary + sexual intercourse, but who have been so interested or amused by + the idea as to do it for me—many of them over and over again. It + is perhaps needless to say that none of my own or the ladies' + clothing is ever removed, or disarranged, for the accomplishment + of orgasm in this manner. After a long and varied experience, I + may say that my favorite weight is 10 to 11 stone, and that + black, very high-heeled slippers, in combination with tan silk + stockings, seem to give me the greatest pleasure and create in me + the strongest desires.</p> + +<p> "Boots, or outdoor shoes, do not attract me to anything like the + same degree, although I have, upon several occasions, enjoyed + myself fairly well by their use. Nude women repel me, and I find + no pleasure in seeing a woman in tights. I am not averse to + normal sexual connection and occasionally employ it. To me, + however, the pleasure is far inferior to that of being trampled + upon. I also derive keen pleasure—and usually have a strong + erection—from seeing a woman, dressed as I have described, tread + upon anything which yields under her foot—such as the seat of a + carriage, the cushions of a punt, a footstool, etc., and I enjoy + seeing her crush flowers by treading upon them. I have often + <a name='5_Page_35'></a>strolled along in the wake of some handsome lady at a picnic or + garden party, for the pleasure of seeing the grass upon which she + has trodden rise slowly again after her foot has pressed it. I + delight also to see a carriage sway as a woman leaves or enters + it—anything which needs the pressure of the foot.</p> + +<p> "To pass now to the origin of this direction of my feelings.</p> + +<p> "Even in early childhood I admired pretty feminine foot-gear, and + in the contemplation of it experienced vague sensations which I + now recognize as sexual. When a lad of 14 or so, I stayed a good + deal at the house of some intimate friends of my parents, the + daughter of the house—an only child—a beautiful and powerful + girl, about six years my senior, being my special chum. This girl + was always daintily dressed, and having most lovely feet and + ankles not unnaturally knew it. Whenever possible she dressed so + as to show off their beauty to the best advantage—rather short + skirts and usually little high-heeled slippers—and was not + averse to showing them in a most distractingly coquettish manner. + She seemed to have a passion for treading upon things which would + scrunch or yield under her foot, such as flowers, little + windfallen apples and pears, acorns, etc., or heaps of hay, straw + or cut grass. As we wandered about the gardens—for we were left + to do exactly as we liked—I got quite accustomed to seeing her + hunt out and tread upon such things, and used to chaff her about + it. At that time I was—as I am still—fond of lying at full + length on a thick hearthrug before a good fire. One evening as I + was lying in this way and we were alone, A. crossed the room to + reach a bangle from the mantelpiece. Instead of reaching over me, + she playfully stepped upon my body, saying that she would show me + how the hay and straw felt. Naturally I fell in with the joke and + laughed. After standing upon me a few moments she raised her + skirt slightly and, holding on to the mantelpiece for support, + stretched out one dainty foot in its brown silk stocking and + high-heeled slipper to the blaze to warm, while looking down and + laughing at my scarlet, excited face. She was a perfectly frank + and charming girl, and I feel pretty certain that, although she + evidently enjoyed my excitement and the feeling of my body + yielding under her feet, she did not on this first occasion + clearly understand my condition; nor can I remember that, though + the desire for sexual gratification drove me nearly mad, it + appeared to awaken in her any reciprocal feeling. I took hold of + her raised foot and, after kissing it, guided it by an absolutely + irresistible impulse on to my penis, which was as hard as wood + and seemed almost bursting. Almost at the moment that her weight + was thrown upon it, orgasm took place for the first time in my + life thoroughly and effectively. No description can give any idea + of what I felt—I only know that from that moment my distorted + sexual focus was fixed forever. Numberless times, after that + evening, I felt the weight of her dainty slippers, and nothing + will ever <a name='5_Page_36'></a>cause the memory of the pleasure she thus gave me to + fade. I know that A. came to enjoy treading upon me, as much as I + enjoyed having her do it. She had a liberal dress allowance and, + seeing the pleasure they gave me, she was always buying pretty + stockings and ravishing slippers with the highest and most + slender Louis heels she could find and would show them to me with + the greatest glee, urging me to lie down that she might try them + on me. She confessed that she loved to see and feel them sink + into my body as she trod upon me and enjoyed the crunch of the + muscles under her heel as she moved about. After some minutes of + this, I always guided her slipper on to my penis, and she would + tread carefully, but with her whole weight—probably about 9 + stone—and watch me with flashing eyes, flushed cheeks, and + quivering lips, as she felt—as she must have done plainly—the + throbbing and swelling of my penis under her foot as emission + took place. I have not the smallest doubt that orgasm took place + simultaneously with her, though we never at any time spoke openly + of it. This went on for several years on almost every favorable + opportunity we had, and after a month or two of separation + sometimes four or five times during a single day. Several times + during A.'s absence I masturbated by getting her slipper and + pressing it with all my strength against the penis while + imagining that she was treading upon me. The pleasure was, of + course, very inferior to her attentions. There was never at any + time between us any question of normal sexual intercourse, and we + were both well content to let things drift as they were.</p> + +<p> "A little after 20 I went abroad, and on my return about three + years later I found her married. Although we met often, the + subject was never alluded to, though we remained firm friends. I + confess I often, when I could do so without being seen, looked + longingly at her feet and would have gladly accepted the pleasure + she could have given me by an occasional resumption of our + strange practice—but it never came.</p> + +<p> "I went abroad again, and now neither she nor her husband are + alive and leave no issue. From time to time I have had occasional + relations with prostitutes, but always in this manner, though I + much prefer to find some lady of or above my own social position + who will do the treading for me. This is, however, interestingly + difficult.</p> + +<p> "Out of say a hundred women (which at home and abroad is what I + should estimate must have stood upon my body) I should say quite + 80 or 85 were <i>not</i> prostitutes. Certainly not more than 10 to 12 + shared any <i>sexual</i> excitement, but while they were evidently + excited they were not gratified. A. alone, so far as I know, had + complete sexual satisfaction of it. I have never asked a woman in + so many words to tread upon me for the purpose of gratifying my + sexual desires (prostitutes excepted), but have always tempted + them to do it in a jocular or teasing manner, and it is very + doubtful if more than a few (married) women <a name='5_Page_37'></a>really understood, + even after they had given me the extreme pleasure, that they had + done so, because any flushing and movement on my part under their + feet was not unnaturally put down to the trampling to which they + were subjecting me, and it was easy for me to guide the foot as + often as was necessary on to the penis till orgasm took place, + and even to keep it there by laying hold of the other one to kiss + it or on some other pretext during emission. Of course many + understood after once doing it (most have done it only once) what + I was at, and, although they did not ever discuss it nor did I, + they were not unwilling to give me as many treadings as I cared + to playfully suggest. I don't think they got any pleasure + sexually out of it themselves, though they could see plainly that + I did, and they did not object to give it me. I have spent as + long as twelve months with some women working gradually nearer + and nearer to my desire—often getting what I want in the end, + but more often failing. I <i>never</i> risk it till I am certain it + would be safe to ask it, and have never had a serious rebuff. In + very many cases I should say the doing of what I want has simply + been regarded by the woman as gratifying a silly and perhaps + amusing whim, in which, beyond the novelty of treading on a man's + body, she has taken but little interest.</p> + +<p> "As in normal seduction, the endeavor to win the woman over to do + what I want without arousing her antagonism is a great part of + the charm to me, and naturally the better her social position the + more difficult this becomes—and the more attractive. I have + found that in three instances prostitutes have performed the same + office for other men and knew all about it. It is not + uninteresting to note that these three women were all of fine, + massive build—one standing about 5 feet 10 inches and weighing + nearly 14 stone—but with comparatively uninteresting faces. The + weight, build and clothing count for a good deal in exciting me. + I find that a sudden check to a man at the supreme moment of + sexual pleasure tends to heighten and prolong the pleasure. My + physical satisfaction is due to the fact that by getting the lady + to stand with all her weight upon my penis (as it lies between + her foot and the soft bed of my own body into which it is deeply + pressed) the act of emission is enormously prolonged, with + corresponding enjoyment. For this reason also I prefer a very + high-heeled slipper. The seminal fluid has to be forced past two + separate obstacles—the pressure of the heel close at the root of + the penis and afterwards the ball of the foot which compresses + the outer half, leaving a free portion between them under the + arched sole of the slipper. I may add that the pleasure is + greatly increased by the retention of the urine, and I always try + to retain as much water as I dare. I have an unconquerable + aversion to red in slippers or stockings; it will even cause + impotence. Why, I know not. Strange as it may seem, although pain + and bruising are often inflicted <a name='5_Page_38'></a>by a severe treading, I have + never been in any way injured by the practice, and my pleasure in + it seems not to diminish by constant repetition. The comparative + difficulty of obtaining the pleasure from just the woman I want + has a never-ending, if inexplicable, charm for me."</p> + +<p> It will be observed that in this case special importance is + attached to shoes with high heels, and the subject considers that + the pressure of such shoes is for mechanical reasons most + favorable for procuring ejaculation. Nearly all heterosexual + shoe-fetichists seem, however, to be equally attracted by high + heels. Restif de la Bretonne frequently referred to this point, + and he gave a number of reasons for the attractiveness of high + heels: (1) They are unlike men's boots and, therefore, have a + sexual fascination; (2) they make the leg and foot look more + charming; (3) they give a less bold and more sylph-like character + to the walk; (4) they keep the feet clean. (Restif de la + Bretonne, <i>Nuits de Paris</i>, vol. v, quoted in Preface to his <i>Mes + Inscriptions</i>, p. ciii.) It is doubtless the first reason—the + fact that high heels are a kind of secondary sexual + character—which is most generally potent in this attraction.</p></div> + +<p>The foregoing history, while it very distinctly brings before us a case of +erotic symbolism, is not strictly an example of shoe-fetichism. The +symbolism is more complex. The focus of beauty in a desirable woman is +transferred and concentrated in the region below the knee; in that sense +we have foot-fetichism. But the act of coitus itself is also symbolically +transferred. Not only has the foot become the symbol of the vulva, but +trampling has become the symbol of coitus; intercourse takes place +symbolically <i>per pedem</i>. It is a result of this symbolization of the foot +and of trampling that all acts of treading take on a new and symbolical +sexual charm. The element of masochism—of pleasure in being a woman's +slave—is a parasitic growth; that is to say, it is not founded in the +subject's constitution, but chances to have found a favorable soil in the +special circumstances under which his sexual life developed. It is not +primary, but secondary, and remains an unimportant and merely occasional +element.</p> + +<p>It may be instructive to bring forward for comparison a case in which also +we have a symbolism involving boot-fetichism, but extending beyond it. In +this case there is a basis of inversion (as is not infrequent in erotic +symbolisms), but from the present point of view the psychological +significance of the case remains the same.</p><a name='5_Page_39'></a> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>A. N., aged 29, unmarried, healthy, though not robust, and without + any known hereditary taint. Has followed various avocations + without taking great interest in them, but has shown some + literary ability.</p> + +<p> "I am an Englishman," his own narrative runs, "the third of three + children. At my birth my father was 41 and my mother 34. My + mother died of cancer when I was 15. My father is still alive, a + reserved man, who still nurses his sorrow for his wife's death. I + have no reason to believe my parents anything but normal and + useful members of society. My sister is normal and happily + married. My brother I have reason to believe to be an invert.</p> + +<p> "A horoscope cast for me describes me in a way I think correct, + and so do my friends: 'A mild, obliging, gentle, amiable person, + with many fine traits of character; timid in nature, fond of + society, loving peace and quietude, delighting in warm and close + friendships. There is much that is firm, steadfast and + industrious, some self-love, a good deal of diplomacy, a little + that is subtle, or what is called finesse. You are reserved with + those you dislike. There is a serious and sad side to your + character; you are very thoughtful and contemplative when in + these moods. But you are not pessimistic. You have superior + abilities, for they are intuitively intellectual. There is a cold + reticence which restrains generous impulses and which inclines to + acquisitiveness; it will make you deliberate, inventive, adding + self-esteem, some vanity.'</p> + +<p> "At an early age I was left much alone in the nursery and there + contracted the habit of masturbation long before the age of + puberty. I use the word 'masturbation' for want of a better, + though it may not quite describe my case. I have never used my + hand to the penis. As far back as I can remember I have had what + a Frenchman has described as 'le fetichisme de la chaussure,' and + in those early days, before I was 6 years old, I would put on my + father's boots, taken from a cupboard at hand, and then tying or + strapping my legs together would produce an erection, and all the + pleasurable feelings experienced, I suppose, by means of + masturbation. I always did this secretly, but couldn't tell why. + I continued this practice on and off all my boyhood and youth. + When I discovered the first emission I was much surprised. I + always did this thing without loosening my trousers. As to how + these feelings arose I am totally unable to say. I can't remember + being without such feelings, and they seem to me perfectly + normal. The sight, or even thought, of high boots, or leggings, + especially if well polished or in patent leather, would set all + my sexual passions aflame, and does yet. As a boy my great desire + was to wear these things. A soldier in boots and spurs, a groom + in tops, or even an errand-boy in patent leather leggings, + fascinated me, and to this day, despite reason and everything + else. The sight of such things produced an erection. An emission + I could always produce by tightly tying my legs together, but + only when wearing boots, and preferably leggings, which when I + had pocket money<a name='5_Page_40'></a> I bought for this purpose. (At the present + moment I have five pairs in the house and two pairs of high + boots, quite unjustified by ordinary use.) This habit I lapse + into yet at times. The smell of leather affects me, but I never + know how far this may be due to association with boots; the smell + suggests the image. Restraint by a leather strap is more exciting + than by cords. Erotic dreams always take the form of restraint on + the limbs when booted.</p> + +<p> "Uniforms and liveries have a great temptation for me, but only + when of a tight-fitting nature and smart, as soldiers', grooms', + etc., but not sailors'; most powerfully when the person is in + boots or leggings and breeches.</p> + +<p> "I was a quiet, sensitive boy, taking no part in games or sports. + Have always been indifferent to them. I made few friends, but + didn't want them. The craving for friendship came much later, + after I was 21. I was a day boy at a private school, and never + had any conversation with any boy on sexual matters, though I was + dimly aware of much 'nastiness' about the school. I knew nothing + of sodomy. But all these things were repulsive to me, + notwithstanding my secret practices. I was a 'good boy.'</p> + +<p> "Up to the age of 21 I was perfectly satisfied with my own + society, something of a prig, fond of books and reading, etc. I + was and ever have been absolutely insensible to the influence of + the other sex. I am not a woman hater, and take intellectual + pleasure in the society of certain ladies, but they are nearly + all much older than myself. I have a strong repulsion from sexual + relations with women. I should not mind being married for the + sake of companionship and for the sake of having boys of my own. + But the sexual act would frighten me. I could not in my present + frame of mind go to bed with a woman. Yet I feel an immense envy + of my married friends in that they are able to give out, and find + satisfaction for, their affection in a way that is quite + impossible for me. I picture certain boys in the place of the + wife.</p> + +<p> "I am now only happy in the society of men younger than myself, + age 17 to (say) 23 or 24, youths with smooth faces, or first sign + of hair on lip, well groomed, slightly effeminate in feature, of + sympathetic, perhaps weak nature. I feel I want to help them, do + something for them, devote myself entirely to their welfare.</p> + +<p> "With such there is no fixed line between friendship and love. I + yearn for intimacy with particular friends, but never dare + express it. I find so many people object to any strong expression + of feeling that I dare not run the risk of appearing ridiculous + in the eyes of these desired intimates.</p> + +<p> "I have no desire for <i>pædicatio</i>, but the idea itself does not + repulse me or seem unnatural, though personally it repels me a + little. But I think this to be mere prejudice on my part, which + might be broken <a name='5_Page_41'></a>down if the loved person showed a willingness to + act a passive part. I should never dare to make an advance, + however.</p> + +<p> "I am restrained by moral and religious considerations from + making my real feelings known, and I feel I should sink in my own + estimation if I gave way, though my natural desire is to do so. + In the face of opportunities (not I mean of <i>pædicatio</i>, but of + expression of excessive affection, etc.), or what might be such, + I always fail to speak lest I should forfeit the esteem of the + other person. I have a feeling of surprise when any one I like + evinces a liking for me. I feel that those I love are + immeasurably my superiors, though my reason may tell me it is not + so. I would grovel at their feet, do anything to win a smile from + them, or to make them give me their company.</p> + +<p> "Ordinary bodily contact with the boy I love gives me most + exquisite pleasure, and I never lose an opportunity of bringing + such contact about when it can be done naturally. I feel an + immense desire to embrace, kiss, squeeze, etc., the person, to + generally maul him, and say nice things—the kind of things a man + usually says to a woman. A handshake, the mere presence of the + person, makes me happy and content.</p> + +<p> "I can say with the Albanian: 'If I find myself in the presence + of the beloved, I rest absorbed in gazing on him. Absent, I think + of nought but him. If the beloved unexpectedly appears I fall + into confusion. My heart beats faster. I have eyes and ears only + for the beloved.'</p> + +<p> "I feel that my capacity of affection is finer and more spiritual + than that which commonly subsists between persons of different + sexes. And so, while trying to fight my instincts by religion, I + find my natural feeling to be part of my religion, and its + highest expression. In this sense I can speak from experience in + my own case, and more especially in that of my brother, that what + you have said about philanthropic activity resulting from + repressed homosexuality is very true indeed. I can say with one + of your female cases: 'Love is to me a religion. The very nature + of my affection for my friends precludes the possibility of any + element entering into it which is not absolutely pure and + sacred.' I am, however, madly jealous. I want entire possession, + and I can't bear for a moment that any one I do not care for + should know the person I love.</p> + +<p> "I am never attracted by men older than myself. The youths who + attract me may be of any class, though preferably, I think, of a + class a little lower than myself. I am not quite sure of this, + however, as circumstances may have contributed more than + deliberate choice to bring certain youths under my notice. Those + who have exercised the most powerful influence on me have been an + Oxford undergraduate, a barber's assistant, and a plumber's + apprentice. Though naturally fond of intellectual society, I do + not ask for intellect in those I love. It goes for nothing. I + always prefer their company to that of the most educated persons. + This preference has alienated me to some extent from more refined + and educated circles that formerly I was intimate with.</p><a name='5_Page_42'></a> + +<p> "I have been led entirely out of my old habits by association + with younger friends, and now do things which before I should + never have dreamed of doing. My thoughts now are always with + certain youths, and if they speak of leaving the town, or in any + way talk of a future that I cannot share, I suffer horrid + sinkings of the heart and depression of spirits."</p></div> + +<p>This case, while it concerns a person of quite different temperament, with +a more innate predisposition to specific perversions, is yet in many +respects analogous to the previous case. There is boot-fetichism; nothing +is felt to be so attractive as the foot-gear, and there is also at the +same time more than this; there is the attraction of repression and +constraint developed into a sexual symbol. In C. P.'s case that symbolism +arises from the experience of an abnormal heterosexual relationship; in +A. N.'s case it is founded on auto-erotic experiences associated with +inversion; in both alike the entire symbolism has become diffused and +generalized.</p> + +<p>In the two cases just brought forward we have an erotic symbolism of act +founded on, and closely associated with, an erotic symbolism of object. It +may be instructive to bring forward another case in which no fetichistic +feeling toward an object can be traced, but an erotic symbolism still +clearly exists. In this case pain, even when self-inflicted, has acquired +a symbolic value as a stimulus to tumescence, without any element of +masochism. Such a case serves to indicate how the sexual attraction of +pain is really a special case of the erotic symbolism with which we are +here concerned.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>A. W., aged 50, a writer and lecturer, physically and mentally + energetic and enjoying good health. He is, however, very + emotional and of nervous temperament, but self-controlled. Though + physically well developed, the sexual organs are small. He is + married to an attractive woman, to whom he is much attached, and + has two healthy children.</p> + +<p> At 10 or 12 years of age he had a frequent desire to be whipped, + his parents never having struck him, and on one occasion he asked + a brother to go with him to the closet to get him to whip him on + the posterior; but on arrival he was too shy to make the request. + He did not recognize the cause of these desires, knowing nothing + of such things <a name='5_Page_43'></a>except from the misinformation of his + school-fellows' talk. As far as he can remember, he was an + entirely normal, healthy boy up to the age of about 15, when his + attention was arrested by an advertisement of a quack medicine + for the results of "youthful excesses."</p> + +<p> Being a city boy, he was unfamiliar with the coupling even of + animals, had never had a conscious erection and did not know of + frictional excitement. Experiment, however, resulted in an + orgasm, and, though believing that it was wicked or at least weak + and degrading, he indulged in masturbation at intervals, usually + about six times a month, and has continued even up to the + present.</p> + +<p> He had an abnormally small opening in the prepuce, making the + uncovering of the glans almost impossible. (At the age of about + 37, he himself slit the prepuce by three or four cuts of a + scissors at intervals of about ten days. This was followed by a + marked decrease in desire, especially as he shortly afterwards + learned the importance of local cleanliness.) While in college at + about the age of 19 he began to have nocturnal emissions + occasionally and once or twice a week when at stool. Alarmed by + these, he consulted a physician, who warned him of the danger, + gave him bromide and prescribed cold bathing of the parts, with a + hard, cool bed. These stopped the emissions.</p> + +<p> He never had connection with women until the age of about 25, and + then only three times until his marriage at 30 years of age, + being deterred partly by conscientious scruples, but more by + shyness and convention, and deriving very little pleasure from + these instances. Even since marriage he has derived more pleasure + from sexual excitement than from coitus, and can maintain + erection for as long as two hours.</p> + +<p> He has always been accustomed to torture himself in various + ingenious ways, nearly always connected with sex. He would burn + his skin deeply with red hot wire in inconspicuous places. These + and similar acts were generally followed by manual excitation + nearly always brought to a climax.</p> + +<p> He considers that he is attracted to refined and intellectual + women. But he is without very ardent desires, having several + times gone to bed with attractive women who stripped themselves + naked, but without attempting any sexual intercourse with them. + He became interested in the "Karezza" theory and has tried to + practice it with his wife, but could never entirely control the + emission.</p> + +<p> He has hired a masseur to whip him, as children are whipped, with + a heavy dog whip, which caused pleasurable excitement. During + this time he had relations with his wife generally about once a + week without any great ecstasy. She was cold and sexually slow, + owing to conventional sex repression and to an idea that the + whole thing was "like animals" and to fear of child-bearing, + usually necessitating the use of a cover or withdrawal. It was + only eight years after their marriage that she desired and + obtained a child. During these years he would often stick <a name='5_Page_44'></a>pins + through his mammæ and tie them together by a string round the + pins drawn so short as to cause great pain and then indulge + himself in the sexual act. He used strong wooden clips with a + tack fixed in them, so as to pierce and pinch the mammæ, and once + he drove a pin entirely through the penis itself, then obtaining + orgasm by friction. He was never able to get an automatic + emission in this way, though he often tried, not even by walking + briskly during an erection.</p></div> + +<p>In another class of cases a purely ideal symbolism may be present by means +of a fetich which acts as a powerful stimulus without itself being felt to +possess any attraction. A good illustration of this condition is furnished +by a case which has been communicated to me by a medical correspondent in +New Zealand.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>"The patient went out to South Africa as a trooper with the + contingent from New Zealand, throwing up a good position in an + office to do so. He had never had any trouble as regards + connection with women before going out to South Africa. While in + active service at the front he sustained a nasty fall from his + horse, breaking his leg. He was unconscious for four days, and + was then invalided down to Cape Town. Here he rapidly got well, + and his accustomed health returning to him he started having what + he terms 'a good time.' He repeatedly went to brothels, but was + unable to have more than a temporary erection, and no ejaculation + would take place. In one of these places he was in company with a + drunken trooper, who suggested that they should perform the + sexual act with their boots and spurs (only) on. My patient, who + was also drunk, readily assented, and to his surprise was enabled + to perform the act of copulation without any difficulty at all. + He has repeatedly tried since to perform the act without any + spurs, but is quite unable to do so; with the spurs he has no + difficulty at all in obtaining all the gratification he desires. + His general health is good. His mother was an extremely nervous + woman, and so is his sister. His father died when he was quite + young. His only other relation in the colony is a married sister, + who seems to enjoy vigorous health."</p></div> + +<p>The consideration of the cases here brought forward may suffice to show +that beyond those fetichisms which find their satisfaction in the +contemplation of a part of the body or a garment, there is a more subtle +symbolism. The foot is a center of force, an agent for exerting pressure, +and thus it furnishes a point of departure not alone for the merely static +sexual fetich, but for a dynamic erotic symbolization. The energy of its +movements <a name='5_Page_45'></a>becomes a substitute for the energy of the sexual organs +themselves in coitus, and exerts the same kind of fascination. The young +girl (page 35) "who seemed to have a passion for treading upon things +which would scrunch or yield under her foot," already possessed the germs +of an erotic symbolism which, under the influence of circumstances in +which she herself took an active part, developed into an adequate method +of sexual gratification.<a name='5_FNanchor_23'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_23'><sup>[23]</sup></a> The youth who was her partner learned, in the +same way, to find an erotic symbolism in all the pressure reactions of +attractive feminine feet, the swaying of a carriage beneath their weight, +the crushing of the flowers on which they tread, the slow rising of the +grass which they have pressed. Here we have a symbolism which is +altogether different from that fetichism which adores a definite object; +it is a dynamic symbolism finding its gratification in the spectacle of +movements which ideally recall the fundamental rhythm and pressure +reactions of the sexual process.</p> + +<p>We may trace a very similar erotic symbolism in an absolutely normal form. +The fascination of clothes in the lover's eyes is no doubt a complex +phenomenon, but in part it rests on the aptitudes of a woman's garments to +express vaguely a dynamic symbolism which must always remain indefinite +and elusive, and on that account always possess fascination. No one has so +acutely described this symbolism as Herrick, often an admirable +psychologist in matters of sexual attractiveness. Especially instructive +in this respect are his poems, "Delight in Disorder," "Upon Julia's +Clothes," and notably "Julia's Petticoat." "A sweet disorder in the +dress," he tells us, "kindles in clothes a wantonness;" it is not on the +garment itself, but on the <a name='5_Page_46'></a>character of its movement that he insists; on +the "erring lace," the "winning wave" of the "tempestuous petticoat;" he +speaks of the "liquefaction" of clothes, their "brave vibration each way +free," and of Julia's petticoat he remarks with a more specific symbolism +still,</p> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span>"Sometimes 'twould pant and sigh and heave,<br /></span> +<span class='i1'>As if to stir it scarce had leave;<br /></span> +<span class='i1'>But having got it, thereupon,<br /></span> +<span class='i1'>'Twould make a brave expansion."<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<p>In the play of the beloved woman's garment, he sees the whole process of +the central act of sex, with its repressions and expansions, and at the +sight is himself ready to "fall into a swoon."</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_13'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_13'>[13]</a><div class='note'><p> G. Stanley Hall, <i>Adolescence</i>, vol. ii, p. 113. It will be +noted that the hand does not appear among the parts of the body which are +normally of supreme interest. An interest in the hand is by no means +uncommon (it may be noted, for instance, in the course of History XII in +Appendix B to vol. iii of these <i>Studies</i>), but the hand does not possess +the mystery which envelops the foot, and hand-fetichism is very much less +frequent than foot-fetichism, while glove-fetichism is remarkably rare. An +interesting case of hand-fetichism, scarcely reaching morbid intensity, is +recorded by Binet, <i>Etudes de Psychologie Expérimentale</i>, pp. 13-19; and +see Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 214 <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_14'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_14'>[14]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Mémoires</i>, vol. i, Chapter VII.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_15'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_15'>[15]</a><div class='note'><p> Among leading English novelists Hardy shows an unusual but +by no means predominant interest in the feet and shoes of his heroines; +see, <i>e.g.</i>, the observations of the cobbler in <i>Under the Greenwood +Tree</i>, Chapter III. A chapter in Goethe's <i>Wahlverwandtschaften</i> (Part I, +Chapter II) contains an episode involving the charm of the foot and the +kissing of the beloved's shoe.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_16'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_16'>[16]</a><div class='note'><p> Schinz, "Philosophie des Conventions Sociales," <i>Revue +Philosophique</i>, June, 1903, p. 626. Mirabeau mentions in his <i>Erotika +Biblion</i> that modern Greek women sometimes use their feet to provoke +orgasm in their lovers. I may add that simultaneous mutual masturbation by +means of the feet is not unknown to-day, and I have been told by an +English shoe-fetichist that he at one time was accustomed to practice this +with a married lady (Brazilian)—she with slippers on and he without—who +derived gratification equal to his own.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_17'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_17'>[17]</a><div class='note'><p> Jacoby (<i>loc. cit.</i> pp. 796-7) gives a large number of +references to Ovid's works bearing on this point. "In reading him," he +remarks, "one is inclined to say that the psychology of the Romans was +closely allied to that of the Chinese."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_18'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_18'>[18]</a><div class='note'><p> R. Kleinpaul, <i>Sprache ohne Worte</i>, p. 308. See also Moll, +<i>Konträre Sexualempfindung</i>, third edition, pp. 306-308. Bloch brings +together many interesting references bearing on the ancient sexual and +religious symbolism of the shoe, <i>Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia +Sexualis</i>, Teil II, p. 324.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_19'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_19'>[19]</a><div class='note'><p> Jacoby (<i>loc. cit.</i> p. 797) appears to regard shoe-fetichism +as a true atavism: "The sexual adoration of feminine foot-gear," he +concludes, "perhaps the most enigmatic and certainly the most singular of +degenerative insanities, is thus merely a form of atavism, the return of +the degenerate to the very ancient and primitive psychology which we no +longer understand and are no longer capable of feeling."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_20'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_20'>[20]</a><div class='note'><p> Moll has reported in detail (<i>Untersuchungen über die Libido +Sexualis</i>, bd. i, Teil II, pp. 320-324) a case which both he and +Krafft-Ebing regard as illustrative of the connection between +boot-fetichism and masochism. It is essentially a case of masochism, +though manifesting itself almost exclusively in the desire to perform +humiliating acts in connection with the attractive person's boots.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_21'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_21'>[21]</a><div class='note'><p> Krafft-Ebing goes so far as to assert (<i>Psychopathia +Sexualis</i>, English translation of tenth edition, p. 174) that "when in +cases of shoe-fetichism the female shoe appears alone as the excitant of +sexual desire one is justified in presuming that masochistic motives have +remained latent.... Latent masochism may always be assumed as the +unconscious motive." In this way he hopelessly misinterprets some of his +own cases.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_22'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_22'>[22]</a><div class='note'><p> Krafft-Ebing goes so far as to assert (<i>Psychopathia +Sexualis</i>, English translation, pp. 159 and 174). Yet some of the cases he +brings forward (<i>e.g.</i>, Coxe's as quoted by Hammond) show no sign of +masochism, since, according to Krafft-Ebing's own definition (p. 116), the +idea of subjugation by the opposite sex is of the essence of masochism.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_23'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_23'>[23]</a><div class='note'><p> Her actions suggest that there is often a latent sexual +consciousness in regard to the feet in women, atavistic or +pseudo-atavistic, and corresponding to the sexual attraction which the +feet formerly aroused, almost normally, in men. This is also suggested by +the case, referred to by Shufeldt, of an unmarried woman, belonging to a +family exhibiting in a high degree both erotic and neurotic traits, who +had "a certain uncontrollable fascination for shoes. She delights in new +shoes, and changes her shoes all day long at regular intervals of three +hours each. She keeps this row of shoes out in plain sight in her +apartment." (R. W. Shufeldt, "On a Case of Female Impotency," 1896, p. +10.)</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_E_III'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_47'></a>III.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Scatalogic Symbolism—Urolagnia—Coprolagnia—The Ascetic Attitude Towards +the Flesh—Normal basis of Scatalogic Symbolism—Scatalogic Conceptions +Among Primitive Peoples—Urine as a Primitive Holy Water—Sacredness of +Animal Excreta—Scatalogy in Folk-lore—The Obscene as Derived from the +Mythological—The Immature Sexual Impulse Tends to Manifest Itself in +Scatalogic Forms—The basis of Physiological Connection Between the +Urinary and Genital Spheres—Urinary Fetichism Sometimes Normal in +Animals—The Urolagnia of Masochists—The Scatalogy of Saints—Urolagnia +More Often a Symbolism of Act Than a Symbolism of Object—Only +Occasionally an Olfactory Fetichism—Comparative Rarity of +Coprolagnia—Influence of Nates Fetichism as a Transition to +Coprolagnia—Ideal Coprolagnia—Olfactory Coprolagnia—Urolagnia and +Coprolagnia as Symbols of Coitus.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>We meet with another group of erotic symbolisms—alike symbolisms of +object and of act—in connection with the two functions adjoining the +anatomical sexual focus: the urinary and alvine excretory functions. These +are sometimes termed the scatalogical group, with the two subdivisions of +urolagnia and Coprolagnia.<a name='5_FNanchor_24'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_24'><sup>[24]</sup></a> <i>Inter fæces et urinam nascimur</i> is an +ancient text which has served the ascetic preachers of old for many +discourses on the littleness of man and the meanness of that reproductive +power which plays so large a part in man's life. "The stupid bungle of +Nature," a correspondent writes, "whereby the generative organs serve as a +means of relieving the bladder, is doubtless responsible for much of the +disgust which those organs excite in some minds."</p> + +<p>At the same time, it is necessary to point out, such reflex influence may +act not in one direction only, but also in the reverse <a name='5_Page_48'></a>direction. From +the standpoint of ascetic contemplation eager to belittle humanity, the +excretory centers may cast dishonor upon the genital center which they +adjoin. From the more ecstatic standpoint of the impassioned lover, eager +to magnify the charm of the woman he worships, it is not impossible for +the excretory centers to take on some charm from the irradiating center of +sex which they enclose.</p> + +<p>Even normally such a process is traceable. The normal lover may not +idealize the excretory functions of his mistress, but the fact that he +finds no repulsion in the most intimate contacts and feels no disgust at +the proximity of the excretory orifices or the existence of their +functions, indicates that the idealization of love has exerted at all +events a neutralizing influence; indeed, the presence of an acute +sensibility to the disturbing influence of this proximity of the excretory +orifices and their functions must be considered abnormal; Swift's +"Strephon and Chloe"—with the conviction underlying it that it is an easy +matter for the excretory functions to drown the possibilities of +love—could only have proceeded from a morbidly sensitive brain.<a name='5_FNanchor_25'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_25'><sup>[25]</sup></a></p> + +<p>A more than mere neutralizing influence, a positively idealizing influence +of the sexual focus on the excretory processes adjoining it, may take +place in the lover's mind without the normal variations of sexual +attraction being over-passed, and even without the creation of an +excretory fetichism.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Reflections of this attitude may be found in the poets. In the + <i>Song of Songs</i> the lover says of his mistress, "Thy navel is + like a round goblet, wherein no mingled wine is wanting;" in his + lyric "To Dianeme," Herrick says with clear reference to the mons veneris:—</p></div> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span class='i4'>"Show me that hill where smiling love doth sit,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>Having a living fountain under it;"<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>and in the very numerous poems in various languages which have + more <a name='5_Page_49'></a>or less obscurely dealt with the rose as the emblem of the + feminine pudenda there are occasional references to the stream + which guards or presides over the rose. It may, indeed, be + recalled that even in the name <i>nymphæ</i> anatomists commonly apply + to the <i>labia minora</i> there is generally believed to be a poetic + allusion to the Nymphs who presided over streams, since the + <i>labia minora</i> exert an influence on the direction of the urinary + stream.</p> + +<p> In <i>Wilhelm Meister</i> (Part I, Chapter XV), Goethe, on the basis + of his own personal experiences, describes his hero's emotions in + the humble surroundings of Marianne's little room as compared + with the stateliness and order of his own home. "It seemed to him + when he had here to remove her stays in order to reach the + harpsichord, there to lay her skirt on the bed before he could + seat himself, when she herself with unembarrassed frankness would + make no attempt to conceal from him many natural acts which + people are accustomed to hide from others out of decency—it + seemed to him, I say, that he became bound to her by invisible + bands." We are told of Wordsworth (Findlay's <i>Recollections of De + Quincey</i>, p. 36) that he read <i>Wilhelm Meister</i> till "he came to + the scene where the hero, in his mistress's bedroom, becomes + sentimental over her dirty towels, etc., which struck him with + such disgust that he flung the book out of his hand, would never + look at it again, and declared that surely no English lady would + ever read such a work." I have, however, heard a woman of high + intellectual distinction refer to the peculiar truth and beauty + of this very passage.</p> + +<p> In one of his latest novels, <i>Les Rencontres de M. de Bréot</i>, + Henri de Régnier, one of the most notable of recent French + novelists, narrates an episode bearing on the matter before us. A + personage of the story is sitting for a moment in a dark grotto + during a night fête in a nobleman's park, when two ladies enter + and laughingly proceed to raise their garments and accomplish a + natural necessity. The man in the background, suddenly overcome + by a sexual impulse, starts forward; one lady runs away, the + other, whom he detains, offers little resistance to his advances. + To M. de Bréot, whom he shortly after encounters, he exclaims, + abashed at his own actions: "Why did I not flee? But could I + imagine that the spectacle of so disgusting a function would have + any other effect than to give me a humble opinion of human + nature?" M. de Bréot, however, in proceeding to reproach his + interlocutor for his inconsiderate temerity, observes: "What you + tell me, sir, does not entirely surprise me. Nature has placed + very various instincts within us, and the impulse that led you to + what you have just now done is not so peculiar as you think. One + may be a very estimable man and yet love women even in what is + lowliest in their bodies." In harmony with this passage from + Régnier's novel are the remarks of a correspondent who writes to + me of the function of urination that it "appeals sexually to most + normal individuals. My own observations and inquiries prove this. + Women <a name='5_Page_50'></a>themselves instinctively feel it. The secrecy surrounding + the matter lends, too, I think, a sexual interest."</p> + +<p> The fact that scatalogic processes may in some degree exert an + attraction even in normal love has been especially emphasized by + Bloch (<i>Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, Teil + II, pp. 222, <i>et seq.</i>): "The man whose intellect and æsthetic + sense has been 'clouded by the sexual impulse' sees these things + in an entirely different light from him who has not been overcome + by the intoxication of love. For him they are idealized (sit + venia verbo) since they are a part of the beloved person, and in + consequence associated with love." Bloch quotes the <i>Memoiren + einer Sängerin</i> (a book which is said to be, though this seems + doubtful, genuinely autobiographical) in the same sense: "A man + who falls in love with a girl is not dragged out of his poetic + sphere by the thought that his beloved must relieve certain + natural necessities every day. It seems, indeed, to him to be + just the opposite. If one loves a person one finds nothing + obscene or disgusting in the object that pleases me." The + opposite attitude is probably in extreme cases due to the + influence of a neurotic or morbidly sensitive temperament. Swift + possessed such a temperament. The possession of a similar + temperament is doubtless responsible for the little prose poem, + "L'Extase," in which Huysmans in his first book, <i>Le Drageloir á + Epices</i>, has written an attenuated version of "Strephon and + Chloe" to express the disillusionment of love; the lover lies in + a wood clasping the hand of the beloved with rapturous emotion; + "suddenly she rose, disengaged her hand, disappeared in the + bushes, and I heard as it were the rustling of rain on the + leaves." His dream has fled.</p></div> + +<p>In estimating the significance of the lover's attitude in this matter, it +is important to realize the position which scatologic conceptions took in +primitive belief. At certain stages of early culture, when all the +emanations of the body are liable to possess mysterious magic properties +and become apt for sacred uses, the excretions, and especially the urine, +are found to form part of religious ritual and ceremonial function. Even +among savages the excreta are frequently regarded as disgusting, but under +the influence of these conceptions such disgust is inhibited, and those +emanations of the body which are usually least honored become religious +symbols.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Urine has been regarded as the original holy water, and many + customs which still survive in Italy and various parts of Europe, + involving the use of a fluid which must often be yellow and + sometimes salt, possibly indicate the earlier use of urine. (The + Greek water of aspersion, <a name='5_Page_51'></a>according to Theocritus, was mixed + with salt, as is sometimes the modern Italian holy water. J. J. + Blunt, <i>Vestiges of Ancient Manners and Customs</i>, p. 173.) Among + the Hottentots, as Kolbein and others have recorded, the medicine + man urinated alternately on bride and bridegroom, and a + successful young warrior was sprinkled in the same way. Mungo + Park mentions that in Africa on one occasion a bride sent a bowl + of her urine which was thrown over him as a special mark of honor + to a distinguished guest. Pennant remarked that the Highlanders + sprinkled their cattle with urine, as a kind of holy water, on + the first Monday in every quarter. (Bourke, <i>Scatalogic Rites</i>, + pp. 228, 239; Brand, <i>Popular Antiquities</i>, "Bride-Ales.")</p> + +<p> Even the excreta of animals have sometimes been counted sacred. + This is notably so in the case of the cow, of all animals the + most venerated by primitive peoples, and especially in India. + Jules Bois (<i>Visions de l'Inde</i>, p. 86) describes the spectacle + presented in the temple of the cows at Benares: "I put my head + into the opening of the holy stables. It was the largest of + temples, a splendor of precious stones and marble, where the + venerated heifers passed backwards and forwards. A whole people + adored them. They take no notice, plunged in their divine and + obscure unconsciousness. And they fulfil with serenity their + animal functions; they chew the offerings, drink water from + copper vessels, and when they are filled they relieve themselves. + Then a stercoraceous and religious insanity overcomes these + starry-faced women and venerable men; they fall on their knees, + prostrate themselves, eat the droppings, greedily drink the + liquid, which for them is miraculous and sacred." (<i>Cf.</i> Bourke, + <i>Scatalogic Rites</i>, Chapter XVII.)</p> + +<p> Among the Chevsurs of the Caucasus, perhaps an Iranian people, a + woman after her confinement, for which she lives apart, purifies + herself by washing in the urine of a cow and then returns home. + This mode of purification is recommended in the Avesta, and is + said to be used by the few remaining followers of this creed.</p></div> + +<p>We have not only to take into account the frequency with which among +primitive peoples the excretions possess a religious significance. It is +further to be noted that in the folk-lore of modern Europe we everywhere +find plentiful evidence of the earlier prevalence of legends and practices +of a scatalogical character. It is significant that in the majority of +cases it is easy to see a sexual reference in these stories and customs. +The legends have lost their earlier and often mythical significance, and +frequently take on a suggestion of obscenity, while the scatalogical +practices have become the magical devices of lovelorn maidens or forsaken +wives practiced in secrecy. It has happened <a name='5_Page_52'></a>to scatalogical rites to be +regarded as we may gather from the <i>Clouds</i> of Aristophanes, that the +sacred leathern phallus borne by the women in the Bacchanalia was becoming +in his time, an object to arouse the amusement of little boys.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Among many primitive peoples throughout the world, and among the + lower social classes of civilized peoples, urine possesses magic + properties, more especially, it would seem, the urine of women + and that of people who stand, or wish to stand, in sexual + relationship to each other. In a legend of the Indians of the + northwest coast of America, recorded by Boas, a woman gives her + lover some of her urine and says: "You can wake the dead if you + drop some of my urine in their ears and nose." (<i>Zeitschrift für + Ethnologie</i>, 1894, Heft IV, p. 293.) Among the same Indians there + is a legend of a woman with a beautiful white skin who found on + bathing every morning in the river that the fish were attracted + to her skin and could not be driven off even by magical + solutions. At last she said to herself: "I will make water on + them and then they will leave me alone." She did so, and + henceforth the fish left her. But shortly after fire came from + Heaven and killed her. (<i>Ib.</i>, 1891, Heft V, p. 640.) Among both + Christians and Mohammedans a wife can attach an unfaithful + husband by privately putting some of her urine in his drink. (B. + Stern, <i>Medizin in der Türkei</i>, vol. ii, p. 11.) This practice is + world-wide; thus among the aborigines of Brazil, according to + Martius, the urine and other excretions and secretions are potent + for aphrodisiacal objects. (Bourke's <i>Scatalogic Rites of All + Nations</i> contains many references to the folk-lore practices in + this matter; a study of popular beliefs in the magic power of + urine, published in Bombay by Professor Eugen Wilhelm in 1889, I + have not seen.)</p> + +<p> The legends which narrate scatalogic exploits are numerous in the + literature of all countries. Among primitive peoples they often + have a purely theological character, for in the popular + mythologies of all countries (even, as we learn from + Aristophanes, among the Greeks) natural phenomena such as the + rain, are apt to be regarded as divine excretions, but in course + of time the legends take on a more erotic or a more obscene + character. In the Irish <i>Book of Leinster</i> (written down + somewhere about the twelfth century, but containing material of + very much older date) we are told how a number of princesses in + Emain Macha, the seat of the Ulster Kings, resolved to find out + which of them could by urinating on it melt a snow pillar which + the men had made, the woman who succeeded to be regarded as the + best among them. None of them succeeded, and they sent for + Derbforgaill, who was in love with Cuchullain, and she was able + to melt the pillar; whereupon the other women, jealous of the + superiority she had thus shown, tore out her eyes. (Zimmer, + "Keltische Beiträge," <i>Zeitschrift für Deutsche Alterthum</i>, vol.<a name='5_Page_53'></a> + xxxii, Heft II, pp. 216-219.) Rhys considers that Derbforgaill + was really a goddess of dawn and dusk, "the drop glistening in + the sun's rays," as indicated by her name, which means a drop or + tear. (J. Rhys, <i>Lectures on the Origin and Growth of Religion as + Illustrated by Celtic Heathendom</i>, p. 466.) It is interesting to + compare the legend of Derbforgaill with a somewhat more modern + Picardy folk-lore <i>conte</i> which is clearly analogous but no + longer seems to show any mythologic element, "La Princesse qui + pisse par dessus les Meules." This princess had a habit of + urinating over hay-cocks; the king, her father, in order to break + her of the habit, offered her in marriage to anyone who could + make a hay-cock so high that she could not urinate over it. The + young men came, but the princess would merely laugh and at once + achieve the task. At last there came a young man who argued with + himself that she would not be able to perform this feat after she + had lost her virginity. He therefore seduced her first and she + then failed ignobly, merely wetting her stockings. Accordingly, + she became his bride. (Κρυπτάδια, vol. i. p. 333.) Such + legends, which have lost any mythologic elements they may + originally have possessed and have become merely <i>contes</i>, are + not uncommon in the folk-lore of many countries. But in their + earlier more religious forms and in their later more obscene + forms, they alike bear witness to the large place which + scatalogic conceptions play in the primitive mind.</p></div> + +<p>It is a notable fact in evidence of the close and seemingly normal +association with the sexual impulse of the scatalogic processes, that an +interest in them, arising naturally and spontaneously, is one of the most +frequent channels by which the sexual impulse first manifests itself in +young boys and girls.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Stanley Hall, who has made special inquiries into the matter, + remarks that in childhood the products of excretion by bladder + and bowels are often objects of interest hardly less intense for + a time than eating and drinking. ("Early Sense of Self," + <i>American Journal of Psychology</i>, April, 1898, p. 361.) + "Micturitional obscenities," the same writer observes again, + "which our returns show to be so common before adolescence, + culminate at 10 or 12, and seem to retreat into the background as + sex phenomena appear." They are, he remarks, of two classes: + "Fouling persons or things, secretly from adults, but openly with + each other," and less often "ceremonial acts connected with the + act or the product that almost suggest the scatalogical rites of + savages, unfit for description here, but of great interest and + importance." (G. Stanley Hall, <i>Adolescence</i>, vol. i, p. 116.) + The nature of such scatalogical phenomena in childhood—which are + often clearly the instinctive <a name='5_Page_54'></a>manifestations of an erotic + symbolism—and their wide prevalence among both boys and girls, + are very well illustrated in a narrative which I include in + Appendix B, History II.</p></div> + +<p>In boys as they approach the age of puberty, this attraction to the +scatalogic, when it exists, tends to die out, giving place to more normal +sexual conceptions, or at all events it takes a subordinate and less +serious place in the mind. In girls, on the other hand, it often tends to +persist. Edmond de Goncourt, a minute observer of the feminine mind, +refers in <i>Chérie</i> to "those innocent and triumphant gaieties which +scatalogic stories have the privilege of arousing in women who have +remained still children, even the most distinguished women." The extent to +which innocent young women, who would frequently be uninterested or +repelled in presence of the sexually obscene are sometimes attracted by +the scatalogically obscene, becomes intelligible, however, if we realize +that a symbolism comes here into play. In women the more specifically +sexual knowledge and experience of life frequently develop much later than +in men or even remains in abeyance, and the specifically sexual phenomena +cannot therefore easily lend themselves to wit, or humor, or imagination. +But the scatalogic sphere, by the very fact that in women it is a +specially intimate and secret region which is yet always liable to be +unexpectedly protruded into consciousness, furnishes an inexhaustible +field for situations which have the same character as those furnished by +the sexually obscene. It thus happens that the sexually obscene which in +men tends to overshadow the scatalogically obscene, in women—partly from +inexperience and partly, it is probable, from their almost physiological +modesty—plays a part subordinate to the scatalogical. In a somewhat +analogous way scatalogical wit and humor play a considerable part in the +work of various eminent authors who were clergymen or priests.</p> + +<p>In addition to the anatomical and psychological associations which +contribute to furnish a basis on which erotic symbolisms may spring up, +there are also physiological connections between the genital and urinary +spheres which directly favor such symbolisms. In discussing the analysis +of the sexual impulse <a name='5_Page_55'></a>in a previous volume of these <i>Studies</i>, I have +pointed out the remarkable relationship—sometimes of transference, +sometimes of compensation—which exists between genital tension and +vesical tension, both in men and women. In the histories of normal sexual +development brought together at the end of that and subsequent volumes the +relationship may frequently be traced, as also in the case of C. P. in the +present study (p. 37). Vesical power is also commonly believed to be in +relation with sexual potency, and the inability to project the urinary +stream in a normal manner is one of the accepted signs of sexual +impotency.<a name='5_FNanchor_26'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_26'><sup>[26]</sup></a> Féré, again, has recorded the history of a man with +periodic crises of sexual desire, and subsequently sexual obsession +without desire, which were always accompanied by the impulse to urinate +and by increased urination.<a name='5_FNanchor_27'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_27'><sup>[27]</sup></a> In the case, recorded by Pitres and Régis, +of a young girl who, having once at the sight of a young man she liked in +a theater been overcome by sexual feeling accompanied by a strong desire +to urinate, was afterward tormented by a groundless fear of experiencing +an irresistible desire to urinate at inconvenient times,<a name='5_FNanchor_28'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_28'><sup>[28]</sup></a> we have an +example of what may be called a physiological scatalogic symbolism of sex, +an emotion which was primarily erotic becoming transferred to the bladder +and then remaining persistent. From such a physiological symbolism it is +but a step to the psychological symbolisms of scatalogic fetichism.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It is worthy of note, as an indication that such phenomena are + scarcely abnormal, that a urinary symbolism, and even a strictly + sexual fetichism, are normal among many animals.</p><a name='5_Page_56'></a> + +<p> The most familiar example of this kind is furnished by the dog, + who is sexually excited in this manner by traces of the bitch and + himself takes every opportunity of making his own path + recognizable. "This custom," Espinas remarks (<i>Des Sociétés + Animales</i>, p. 228), "has no other aim than to spread along the + road recognizable traces of their presence for the benefit of + individuals of the other sex, the odor of these traces doubtless + causing excitement."</p> + +<p> It is noteworthy, also, that in animals as well as in man, sexual + excitement may manifest itself in the bladder. Thus Daumas states + (<i>Chevaux de Sahara</i>, p. 49) that if the mare urinates when she + hears the stallion neigh it is a sign that she is ready for + connection.</p></div> + +<p>It is in masochism, or passive algolagnia, that we may most frequently +find scatalogic symbolism in its fully developed form. The man whose +predominant impulse is to subjugate himself to his mistress and to receive +at her hands the utmost humiliation, frequently finds the climax of his +gratification in being urinated on by her, whether in actual fact or only +in imagination.</p> + +<p>In many such cases, however, it is evident that we have a mixed +phenomenon; the symbolism is double. The act becomes desirable because it +is the outward and visible sign of an inwardly experienced abject slavery +to an adored person. But it is also desirable because of intimately sexual +associations in the act itself, as a symbolical detumescence, a simulacrum +of the sexual act, and one which proceeds from the sexual focus itself.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Krafft-Ebing records various cases of masochism in which the + emission of urine on to the body or into the mouth formed the + climax of sexual gratification, as, for instance (<i>Psychopathia + Sexualis</i>, English translation, p. 183) in the case of a Russian + official who as a boy had fancies of being bound between the + thighs of a woman, compelled to sleep beneath her nates and to + drink her urine, and in later life experienced the greatest + excitement when practicing the last part of this early + imagination.</p> + +<p> In another case, recorded by Krafft-Ebing and by him termed + "ideal masochism" (<i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 127-130), the subject from + childhood indulged in voluptuous day-dreams in which he was the + slave of a beautiful mistress who would compel him to obey all + her caprices, stand over him with one foot on his breast, sit on + his face and body, make him <a name='5_Page_57'></a>wait on her in her bath, or when she + urinated, and sometimes insist on doing this on his face; though + a highly intellectual man, he was always too timid to attempt to + carry any of his ideas into execution; he had been troubled by + nocturnal enuresis up to the age of 20.</p> + +<p> Neri, again (<i>Archivio delle Psicopatie Sessuali</i>, vol. i, fasc. + 7 and 8, 1896), records the case of an Italian masochist who + experienced the greatest pleasure when both urination and + defecation were practiced in this manner by the woman he was + attached to.</p> + +<p> In a previous volume of these <i>Studies</i> ("Sexual Inversion," + History XXVI) I have recorded the masochistic day-dreams of a boy + whose impulses were at the same time inverted; in his reveries + "the central fact," he states, "became the discharge of urine + from my lover over my body and limbs, or, if I were very fond of + him, I let it be in my face." In actual life the act of urination + casually witnessed in childhood became the symbol, even the + reality, of the central secret of sex: "I stood rooted and + flushing with downcast eyes till the act was over, and was + conscious for a considerable time of stammering speech and + bewildered faculties.... I was overwhelmed with emotion and could + barely drag my feet from the spot or my eyes from the damp + herbage where he had deposited the waters of secrecy. Even to-day + I cannot dissociate myself from the shuddering charm that moment + had for me."</p></div> + +<p>It is not only the urine and the fæces which may thus acquire a symbolic +fascination and attractiveness under the influence of masochistic +deviations of sexual idealization. In some cases extreme rapture has been +experienced in licking sweating feet. There is, indeed, no excretion or +product of the body which has not been a source of ecstasy: the sweat from +every part of the body, the saliva and menstrual fluid, even the wax from +the ears.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Krafft-Ebing very truly points out (<i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, + English translation, p. 178) that this sexual scatalogic + symbolism is precisely paralleled by a religious scatalogic + symbolism. In the excesses of devout enthusiasm the ascetic + performs exactly the same acts as are performed in these excesses + of erotic enthusiasm. To mix excreta with the food, to lick up + excrement, to suck festering sores—all these and the like are + acts which holy and venerated women have performed.</p> + +<p> Not only the saint, but also the prophet and medicine-man have + been frequently eaters of human excrement; it is only necessary + to refer to the instance of the prophet Ezekiel, who declared + that he was commanded to bake his bread with human dung, and to + the practices of medicine-men at Torres Straits, in whose + training the eating of human excrement takes a recognized part. + (Deities, notably Baal-Phegor, were <a name='5_Page_58'></a>sometimes supposed to eat + excrement, so that it was natural that their messengers and + representatives among men should do so. As regards Baal-Phegor, + see Dulaure, <i>Des Divinités Génératrices</i>, Chapter IV, and J. G. + Bourke, <i>Scatalogic Rites of All Nations</i>, p. 241. See also + Ezekiel, Chapter IV, v. 12, and <i>Reports Anthropological + Expedition to Torres Straits</i>, vol. v, p. 321.)</p> + +<p> It must be added, however, that while the masochist is overcome + by sexual rapture, so that he sees nothing disgusting in his act, + the medicine-man and the ascetic are not so invariably overcome + by religious rapture, and several ascetic writers have referred + to the horror and disgust they experienced, at all events at + first, in accomplishing such acts, while the medicine-men when + novices sometimes find the ordeal too severe and have to abandon + their career. Brénier de Montmorand, while remarking, not without + some exaggeration, that "the Christian ascetics are almost all + eaters of excrement" ("Ascétisme et Mysticisme," <i>Revue + Philosophique</i>, March, 1904, p. 245), quotes the testimonies of + Marguerite-Marie and Madame Guyon as to the extreme repugnance + which they had to overcome. They were impelled by a merely + intellectual symbolism of self-mortification rather than by the + profoundly felt emotional symbolism which moves the masochist.</p> + +<p> Coprophagic acts, whether under the influences of religious + exaltation or of sexual rapture, inevitably excite our disgust. + We regard them as almost insane, fortified in that belief by the + undoubted fact that coprophagia is not uncommon among the insane. + It may, therefore, be proper to point out that it is not so very + long since the ingestion of human excrement was carried out by + our own forefathers in the most sane and deliberate manner. It + was administered by medical practitioners for a great number of + ailments, apparently with entirely satisfactory results. Less + than two centuries ago, Schurig, who so admirably gathered + together and arranged the medical lore of his own and the + immediately preceding ages, wrote a very long and detailed + chapter, "De Stercoris Humani Usu Medico" (<i>Chylologia</i>, 1725, + cap. XIII; in the Paris <i>Journal de Médecine</i> for February 19, + 1905, there appeared an article, which I have not seen, entitled + "Médicaments oubliées: l'urine et la fiente humaine.") The + classes of cases in which the drug was found beneficial would + seem to have been extremely various. It must not be supposed that + it was usually ingested in the crude form. A common method was to + take the fæces of boys, dry them, mix them with the best honey, + and administer an electuary. (At an earlier period such drugs + appear to have met with some opposition from the Church, which + seems to have seen in them only an application of magic; thus I + note that in Burchard's remarkable Penitential of the fourteenth + century, as reproduced by Wasserschleben, 40 days' penance is + prescribed for the use of human urine or excrement as a medicine. + Wasserschleben <i>Die Bussordnungen der Abendländlichen Kirche</i>, p. + 651.)</p></div><a name='5_Page_59'></a> + +<p>The urolagnia of masochism is not a simple phenomenon; it embodies a +double symbolism: on the one hand a symbolism of self-abnegation, such as +the ascetic feels, on the other hand a symbolism of transferred sexual +emotion. Krafft-Ebing was disposed to regard all cases in which a +scatalogical sexual attraction existed as due to "latent masochism." Such +a point of view is quite untenable. Certainly the connection is common, +but in the majority of cases of slightly marked scatalogical fetichism no +masochism is evident. And when we bear in mind the various considerations, +already brought forward, which show how widespread and clearly realized is +the natural and normal basis furnished for such symbolism, it becomes +quite unnecessary to invoke any aid from masochism. There is ample +evidence to show that, either as a habitual or more usually an occasional +act, the impulse to bestow a symbolic value on the act of urination in a +beloved person, is not extremely uncommon; it has been noted of men of +high intellectual distinction; it occurs in women as well as men; when +existing in only a slight degree, it must be regarded as within the normal +limits of variation of sexual emotion.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The occasional cases in which the urine is drunk may possibly + suggest that the motive lies in the properties of the fluid + acting on the system. Support for this supposition might be found + in the fact that urine actually does possess, apart altogether + from its magic virtues embodied in folk-lore, the properties of a + general stimulant. In composition (as Masterman first pointed + out) "beef-tea differs little from healthy urine," containing + exactly the same constituents, except that in beef-tea there is + less urea and uric acid. Fresh urine—more especially that of + children and young women—is taken as a medicine in nearly all + parts of the world for various disorders, such as epistaxis, + malaria and hysteria, with benefit, this benefit being almost + certainly due to its qualities as a general stimulant and + restorative. William Salmon's <i>Dispensatory</i>, 1678 (quoted in + <i>British Medical Journal</i>, April 21, 1900, p. 974), shows that in + the seventeenth century urine still occupied an important place + as a medicine, and it frequently entered largely into the + composition of Aqua Divina.</p> + +<p> Its use has been known even in England in the nineteenth century. + (Masterman, <i>Lancet</i>, October 2, 1880; R. Neale, "Urine as a + Medicine," <i>Practitioner</i>, November, 1881; Bourke brings together + a great deal of evidence as to the therapeutic uses of urine in + his <i>Scatalogic Rites</i>, <a name='5_Page_60'></a>especially pp. 331-335; Lusini has shown + that normal urine invariably increases the frequency of the heart + beats, <i>Archivio di Farmacologia</i>, fascs. 19-21, 1893.)</p> + +<p> But it is an error to suppose that these facts account for the + urolagnic drinking of urine. As in the gratification of a normal + sexual impulse, the intense excitement of gratifying a scatalogic + sexual impulse itself produces a degree of emotional stimulation + far greater than the ingestion of a small amount of animal + extractives would be adequate to effect. In such cases, as much + as in normal sexuality, the stimulation is clearly psychic.</p></div> + +<p>When, as is most commonly the case, it is the process of urination and not +the urine itself which is attractive, we are clearly concerned with a +symbolism of act and not with the fetichistic attraction of an excretion. +When the excretion, apart from the act, provides the attraction, we seem +usually to be in the presence of an olfactory fetichism. These fetichisms +connected with the excreta appear to be experienced chiefly by individuals +who are somewhat weak-minded, which is not necessarily the case in regard +to those persons for whom the act, rather than its product apart from the +beloved person, is the attractive symbol.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The sexually symbolic nature of the act of urination for many + people is indicated by the existence, according to Bloch, who + enumerates various kinds of indecent photographs, of a group + which he terms "the notorious <i>pisseuses</i>." It is further + indicated by several of the reproductions in Fuch's <i>Erotsiche + Element in der Karikatur</i>, such as Delorme's "La Necessitê n'a + point de Loi." (It should be added that such a scene by no means + necessarily possesses any erotic symbolism, as we may see in + Rembrandt's etching commonly called "Le Femme qui Pisse," in + which the reflected lights on the partly shadowed stream furnish + an artistic motive which is obviously free from any trace of + obscenity.) In the case which Krafft-Ebing quotes from Maschka of + a young man who would induce young girls to dance naked in his + room, to leap, and to urinate in his presence, whereupon seminal + ejaculation would take place, we have a typical example of + urolagnic symbolism in a form adequate to produce complete + gratification. A case in which the urolagnic form of scatalogic + symbolism reached its fullest development as a sexual perversion + has been described in Russia by Sukhanoff (summarized in + <i>Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, November, 1900, and + <i>Annales Medico-psychologiques</i>, February, 1901), that of a young + man of 27, of neuropathic temperament, who when he once chanced + to witness a <a name='5_Page_61'></a>woman urinating experienced voluptuous sensations. + From that moment he sought close contact with women urinating, + the maximum of gratification being reached when he could place + himself in such a position that a woman, in all innocence, would + urinate into his mouth. All his amorous adventures were concerned + with the search for opportunities for procuring this difficult + gratification. Closets in which he was able to hide, winter + weather and dull days he found most favorable to success. (A + somewhat similar case is recorded in the <i>Archives de + Neurologie</i>, 1902, p. 462.)</p> + +<p> In the case of a robust man of neuropathic heredity recorded by + Pelanda some light is shed on the psychic attitude in these + manifestations; there was masturbation up to the age of 16, when + he abandoned the practice, and up to the age of 30 found complete + satisfaction in drinking the still hot urine of women. When a + lady or girl in the house went to her room to satisfy a need of + this kind, she had hardly left it but he hastened in, overcome by + extreme excitement, culminating in spontaneous ejaculation. The + younger the woman the greater the transport he experienced. It is + noteworthy that in this, as possibly in all similar cases, there + was no sensory perversion and no morbid attraction of taste or + smell; he stated that the action of his senses was suspended by + his excitement, and that he was quite unable to perceive the odor + or taste of the fluid. (Pelanda, "Pornopatice," <i>Archivio di + Psichiatria</i>, facs. iii-iv, 1889, p. 356.) It is in the emotional + symbolism that the fascination lies and not in any sensory + perversion.</p> + +<p> Magnan records the spontaneous development of this sexual + symbolism in a girl of 11, of good intellectual development but + alcoholic heredity, who seduced a boy younger than herself to + mutual masturbation, and on one occasion, lying on the ground and + raising her clothes, asked him to urinate on her. (<i>International + Congress of Criminal Anthropology</i>, 1889.) This case (except for + the early age of the subject) illustrates sporadically occurring + urolagnic symbolism in a woman, to whom such symbolism is fairly + obvious on account of the close resemblance between the emission + of urine and the ejaculation of semen in the man, and the fact + that the same conduit serves for both fluids. (A urolagnic + day-dream of this kind is recorded in the history of a lady + contained in the third volume of these <i>Studies</i>, Appendix B, + History VIII.) The natural and inevitable character of this + symbolism is shown by the fact that among primitive peoples urine + is sometimes supposed to possess the fertilizing virtues of + semen. J. G. Frazer in his edition of Pausanias (vol. iv, p. 139) + brings together various stories of women impregnated by urine. + Hartland also (<i>Legend of Perseus</i>, vol. i, pp. 76, 92) records + legends of women who were impregnated by accidentally or + intentionally drinking urine.</p> + +<p> The symbolic sexual significance of urolagnia has hitherto + usually been confused with the fetichistic and mainly olfactory + perversion by <a name='5_Page_62'></a>which the excretion itself becomes a source of + sexual excitement. Long since Tardieu referred, under the name of + "renifleurs," to persons who were said to haunt the neighborhood + of quiet passages, more especially in the neighborhood of + theatres, and who when they perceived a woman emerge after + urination, would hasten to excite themselves by the odor of the + excretion. Possibly a fetichism of this kind existed in a case + recorded by Belletrud and Mercier (<i>Annales d'Hygiène Publique</i>, + June, 1904, p. 48). A weak-minded, timid youth, who was very + sexual but not attractive to women, would watch for women who + were about to urinate and immediately they had passed on would go + and lick the spot they had moistened, at the same time + masturbating. Such a fetichistic perversion is strictly analogous + to the fetichism by which women's handkerchiefs, aprons or + underlinen become capable of affording sexual gratification. A + very complete case of such urolagnic fetichism—complete because + separated from association with the person accomplishing the act + of urination—has been recorded by Moraglia in a woman. It is the + case of a beautiful and attractive young woman of 18, with thick + black hair, and expressive vivacious eyes, but sallow complexion. + Married a year previously, but childless, she experienced a + certain amount of pleasure in coitus, but she preferred + masturbation, and frankly acknowledged that she was highly + excited by the odor of fermented urine. So strong was this + fetichism that when, for instance, she passed a street urinal she + was often obliged to go aside and masturbate; once she went for + this purpose into the urinal itself and was almost discovered in + the act, and on another occasion into a church. Her perversion + caused her much worry because of the fear of detection. She + preferred, when she could, to obtain a bottle of urine—which + must be stale and a man's (this, she said, she could detect by + the smell)—and to shut herself up in her own room, holding the + bottle in one hand and repeatedly masturbating with the other. + (Moraglia, "Psicopatie Sessuali," <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, vol. + xiii, fasc. 6, p. 267, 1892.) This case is of especial interest + because of the great rarity of fully developed fetichism in + women. In a slight and germinal degree I believe that cases of + fetichism are not uncommon in women, but they are certainly rare + in a well-marked form, and Krafft-Ebing declared, even in the + late editions of his <i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, that he knew of no + cases in women.</p></div> + +<p>So far we have been concerned with the urolagnic rather than the +coprolagnic variety of scatalogical symbolism. Although the two are +sometimes associated there is no necessary connection, and most usually +there is no tendency for the one to involve the other. Urolagnia is +certainly much the more frequently found; the act of urination is far more +apt to suggest <a name='5_Page_63'></a>erotically symbolical ideas than the idea of defecation. +It is not difficult to understand why this should be so. The act of +urination lends itself more easily to sexual symbolism; it is more +intimately associated with the genital function; its repetition is +necessary at more frequent intervals so that it is more in evidence; +moreover, its product, unlike that of the act of defecation, is not +offensive to the senses. Still coprolagnia occurs and not so very +infrequently. Burton remarked that even the normal lover is affected by +this feeling: "immo nec ipsum amicæ stercus foctet."<a name='5_FNanchor_29'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_29'><sup>[29]</sup></a></p> + +<p>Of Caligula who, however, was scarcely sane, it was said "et quidem +stercus uxoris degustavit."<a name='5_FNanchor_30'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_30'><sup>[30]</sup></a> In Parisian brothels (according to Taxil +and others) provision is made for those who are sexually excited by the +spectacle of the act of defecation (without reference to contact or odor) +by means of a "tabouret de verre," from under the glass floor of which the +spectacle of the defecating women may be closely observed. It may be added +that the erotic nature of such a spectacle is referred to in the Marquis +de Sade's novels.</p> + +<p>There is one motive for the existence of coprolagnia which must not be +passed over, because it has doubtless frequently served as a mode of +transition to what, taken by itself, may well seem the least æsthetically +attractive of erotic symbols. I refer to the tendency of the nates to +become a sexual fetich. The nates have in all ages and in all parts of the +world been frequently regarded as one of the most æsthetically beautiful +parts of the feminine body.<a name='5_FNanchor_31'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_31'><sup>[31]</sup></a> It is probable that on the basis of this +entirely normal attraction more than one form of erotic symbolism <a name='5_Page_64'></a>is at +all events in part supported. Dühren and others have considered that the +æsthetic charm of the nates is one of the motives which prompt the desire +to inflict flagellation on women. In the same way—certainly in some and +probably in many cases—the sexual charm of the nates progressively +extends to the anal region, to the act of defecation, and finally to the +feces.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In a case of Krafft-Ebing's (<i>Op. cit.</i>, p. 183) the subject, + when a child of 6, accidentally placed his hand in contact with + the nates of the little girl who sat next to him in school, and + experienced so great a pleasure in this contact that he + frequently repeated it; when he was 10 a nursery governess, to + gratify her own desires, placed his finger in her vagina; in + adult life he developed urolagnic tendencies.</p> + +<p> In a case of Moll's the development of a youthful admiration for + the nates in a coprolagnic direction may be clearly traced. In + this case a young man, a merchant, in a good position, sought to + come in contact with women defecating; and with this object would + seek to conceal himself in closets; the excretal odor was + pleasurable to him, but was not essential to gratification, and + the sight of the nates was also exciting and at the same time not + essential to gratification; the act of defecation appears, + however, to have been regarded as essential. He never sought to + witness prostitutes in this situation; he was only attracted to + young, pretty and innocent women. The coprolagnia here, however, + had its source in a childish impression of admiration for the + nates. When 5 or 6 years old he crawled under the clothes of a + servant girl, his face coming in contact with her nates, an + impression that remained associated in his mind with pleasure. + Three or four years later he used to experience much pleasure + when a young girl cousin sat on his face; thus was strengthened + an association which developed naturally into coprolagnia. (Moll, + <i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. 837.)</p> + +<p> It is scarcely necessary to remark that an admiration for the + nates, even when reaching a fetichistic degree, by no means + necessarily involves, even after many years, any attraction to + the excreta. A correspondent for whom the nates have constituted + a fetich for many years writes: "I find my craving for women with + profuse pelvic or posterior development is growing and I wish to + copulate from behind; but I would feel a sickening feeling if any + part of my person came in contact with the female anus. It is + more pleasing to me to see the nates than the mons, yet I loathe + everything associated with the anal region."</p></div> + +<p>Moll has recorded in detail a case of what may be described as "ideal +coprolagnia"—that is to say, where the symbolism, <a name='5_Page_65'></a>though fully developed +in imagination, was not carried into real life—which is of great interest +because it shows how, in a very intelligent subject, the deviated +symbolism may become highly developed and irradiate all the views of life +in the same way as the normal impulse. (The subject's desires were also +inverted, but from the present point of view the psychological interest of +the case is not thereby impaired.) Moll's case was one of symbolism of +act, the excreta offering no attraction apart from the process of +defecation. In a case which has been communicated to me there was, on the +other hand, an olfactory fetichistic attraction to the excreta even in the +absence of the person.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In Moll's case, the patient, X., 23 years of age, belongs to a + family which he himself describes as nervous. His mother, who is + anæmic, has long suffered from almost periodical attacks of + excitement, weakness, syncope and palpitation. A brother of the + mother died in a lunatic asylum, and several other brothers + complain much of their nerves. The mother's sisters are very + good-natured, but liable to break out in furious passions; this + they inherit from their father. There appears to be no nervous + disease on the patient's father's side. X.'s sisters are also + healthy.</p> + +<p> X. himself is of powerful undersized build and enjoys good + health, injured by no excesses. He considers himself nervous. He + worked hard at school and was always the first in his class; he + adds, however, that this is due less to his own abilities than + the laziness of his school-fellows. He is, as he remarks, very + religious and prays frequently, but seldom goes to church.</p> + +<p> In regard to his psychic characters he says that he has no + specially prominent talent, but is much interested in languages, + mathematics, physics and philosophy, in fact, in abstract + subjects generally. "While I take a lively interest in every kind + of intellectual work," he says, "it is only recently that I have + been attracted to real life and its requirements. I have never + had much skill in physical exercises. For external things until + recently I have only had contempt. I have a delicately + constituted nature, loving solitude, and only associating with a + few select persons. I have a decided taste for fiction, poetry + and music; my temperament is idealistic and religious, with + strict conceptions of duty and morality, and aspirations towards + the good and beautiful. I detest all that is common and coarse, + and yet I can think and act in the way you will learn from the + following pages."</p> + +<p> Regarding his sexual life, X. made the following communication: + "During the last two years I have become convinced of the + perversion of my sexual instinct. I had often previously thought + that in <a name='5_Page_66'></a>me the impulse was not quite normal, but it is only + lately that I have become convinced of my complete perversion. I + have never read or heard of any case in which the sexual feelings + were of the same kind. Although I can feel a lively inclination + towards superior representatives of the female sex, and have + twice felt something like love, the sight or the recollection + even of a beautiful woman have never caused sexual excitement." + In the two exceptional instances mentioned it appears that X. had + an inclination to kiss the women in question, but that the + thought of coitus had no attraction. "In my voluptuous dreams, + connected with the emission of semen, women in seductive + situations have never appeared. I have never had any desire to + visit a <i>puella publica</i>. The love-stories of my fellow-students + seemed very silly, dances and balls were a horror to me, and only + on very rare occasions could I be persuaded to go into society. + It will be easy to guess the diagnosis in my case: I suffer from + the sexual attraction of my own sex, I am a lover of boys.</p> + +<p> "You cannot imagine what a world of thoughts, wishes, feelings + and impulses the words 'knabe,' 'παις,' 'garcon,' 'boy,' + 'ragazzo' have for me; one of these words, even in an unmeaning + clause of a translation-book, calls before me the whole sum of + associations which in course of time have become bound up with + this idea, and it is only with an effort that I can scare away + the wild band. This group of thoughts shows a wonderful mixture + of warm sensuality and ideal love, it unites my lowest and + highest impulses, the strength and the weakness of my nature, my + curse and my blessing. My inclination is especially towards boys + of the age of 12 to 15; though they may be rather younger or + older. That I should prefer beautiful and intelligent boys is + comprehensible. I do not want a prostitute, but a friend or a + son, whose soul I love, whom I can help to become a more perfect + man, such as I myself would willingly be.</p> + +<p> "When I myself belonged to that happy age (<i>i.e.</i>, below 15) I + had no dearer wish than to possess a friend of similar tastes. I + have sought, hoped, waited, grieved, and been at last + disillusioned, overcome by desire and despair, and have not found + that friend. Even later the hope often reappeared, but always in + vain, and I cannot boast of that sure recognition which one reads + of in the autobiographies of Urnings. I do not know personally a + single fellow-sufferer. It is also doubtful whether such an + acquaintanceship would greatly help me, for I have a very + peculiar conception of homosexuality. As you will see, I have + little more in common with what are called pæderasts than sexual + indifference to the female sex, and I often ask myself: 'Does any + other man in the whole world feel like you? Are you alone in the + earth with your morbid desires? Are you a pariah of pariahs, or + is there, perhaps, another soul with similar longings living near + you? How often in summer have I gone to the lakes and streams + outside cities to seek boys bathing; but I always came back + unsatisfied, whether I found any or not. And <a name='5_Page_67'></a>in winter I have + been irresistibly impelled to return to the same spots, as if it + were sanctified by the boys, but my darlings had vanished and + cold winds blew over the icy floods, so that I would return + feeling as though I had buried all my happiness.</p> + +<p> "It must be borne in mind, therefore, that what I have to say + regarding my sexual impulses only refers to fancies and never to + their practical realization. My sensual impulses are not + connected with the sexual organs; all my voluptuous ideas are not + in the least connected with these parts. For this reason I have + never practiced onanism and <i>immissio membri in anum</i> is as + repulsive to me as to a normal man. Even every imitation of + coitus is, for me, without attraction. In a boy's body two things + specially excite me: <i>his belly and his nates</i>, the first as + containing the digestive tract, the second as holding the opening + of the bowels. Of the vegetable processes of life in the boy none + interest me nearly so much as the progress of his digestion and + the process of defecation. It is incredible to what an extent + this part of physiology has occupied me from youth. If as a boy I + wanted to read something of a piquantly exciting character I + sought in my father's encyclopædia for articles like: + Obstruction, Constipation, Hæmorrhoids, Fæces, etc. No function + of the body seemed to be so significant as this, and I regarded + its disturbances as the most important in the whole mechanism of + life. The description of other disorders I could read in cold + blood, but intussusception of the bowels makes me ill even + to-day. I am always extremely pleased to hear that the digestion + of the people around me is in good condition. A man who did not + sufficiently watch over his digestion aroused distrust in me, and + I imagined that wicked men must be horribly indifferent regarding + this weighty matter. Even more than in ordinary persons was I + interested in the digestion of more mysterious beings, like + magicians in legends, or men of other nations. I would willingly + have made an anthropological study of my favorite subject, only + to my annoyance books nearly always pass over the matter in + silence. In history and fiction I regretted the absence of + information concerning the state of my heroes' digestion when + they languished in prison or in some unaccustomed or unhealthy + spot. For this reason I held no book more precious than one which + describes how a young man after being shipwrecked lived for a + long time in a narrow snow-hut, and it was conscientiously stated + that he became aware of digestive disturbances. No immorality + angers me more than the foolish practice of ladies who in society + neglect the satisfaction of their natural needs from misplaced + motives of modesty. On a railway journey I suffer horribly from + the thought that one of my fellow-travelers may be prevented from + fulfilling some imperative natural necessity.</p> + +<p> "I naturally devote the greatest attention to my own digestion. + With painful conscientiousness I go to stool every day at the + same <a name='5_Page_68'></a>hour; if the operation does not come off to my satisfaction + I feel not so much physical as mental discomfort. To this quite + useful hygienic interest became associated at puberty a sensual + interest. Since my fourteenth year I have had no greater + enjoyment than to defecate undressed (I do not do so now) after + having first carefully examined the distension of my abdomen. In + summer I would go into the woods, undress myself in a secluded + spot and indulge in the voluptuous pleasures of defecation. I + would sometimes combine with this a bath in a stream. I would + exhaust my imagination in the effort to invent specially + enjoyable variations, longed for a desert island where I could go + about naked, fill my body with much nourishing food, hold in the + excrement as long as possible and then discharge it in some + subtly-thought-out spot. These practices and ideas often caused + erections and later on emissions, but the genitals played no part + in my conceptions; their movements were uncomfortable and gave no + pleasure.</p> + +<p> "I soon longed to be associated in these orgies with some boy of + the same age, but I wanted not only a companion in my passion, + but also a real friend. Since there could be no question of + masturbation or pæderasty, our love would have been limited to + kisses, embraces, and—as a compensation for coitus—defecation + together. That would have been perfect bliss to me. I will spare + you the unæsthetic contents of my voluptuous dreams. But I + remained without a companion, and, therefore, without real + enjoyment. [He has, however, on various occasions experienced + erections, and even emissions, on seeing, by chance, men or boys + defecate.] Hinc illæ lacrimæ; the excitement over my own + defecation only took place <i>faute de mieux</i>.</p> + +<p> "I knew very well that my thoughts and practices were impure and + contemptible. Ah! how often, when the intoxication was over, have + I thrown myself remorsefully on my knees, praying to God for + pardon! For some weeks I repressed my longing; but at last it was + too strong for me, I tried to justify myself and fell into my + vice anew. That I was guilty of licentiousness and loved boys + sexually first became clear to me later on, when I knew the + significance of erection as a sign of sexual excitement.</p> + +<p> "No one can imagine with what demoniacal joy I am possessed at + the thought of a beautiful naked boy whose abdomen is filled as + the result of long abstinence from stool. The thought powerfully + excites me, a flood of passion goes through my blood and my limbs + tremble. I would never grow tired of feeling that belly and + looking at it. My passion would express itself in tempestuous + caresses, and the boy would have to assume various positions in + order to show off the beauty of his form, <i>i.e.</i>, to bring the + parts in question into better view. To observe defecation would + still further increase this peculiar enjoyment. If the boy's + bowels were not sufficiently filled I would feed him with all + sorts <a name='5_Page_69'></a>of food which produces much excrement, such as potatoes, + coarse bread, etc. If possible I would seek to delay defecation + for two or three days, so that it might be as copious as + possible. When at last it occurred it would be an unspeakable joy + for me to watch the fæces—which would have to be fairly + firm—emerging from the anus."</p> + +<p> X. would like to be a teacher and thinks he could exert a + beneficial influence on boys. In spite of the pain he has + suffered he does not think he would like to be cured of his + perverse inclinations, for they have given him joy as well as + pain, and the pain has chiefly been owing to the fact that he + could not gratify his inclinations. X. smokes and drinks in + moderation, and has no feminine habits. (The foregoing is a + condensed summary of the case which is fully reported by Moll, + <i>Konträre Sexualempfindung</i>, third edition, pp. 295-305.)</p> + +<p> The case of coprolagnia communicated to me is that of a married + man, normal in all other respects, intellectually brilliant and + filling successfully a very responsible position. When a child + the women of his household were always indifferent as to his + presence in their bedrooms, and would satisfy all natural calls + without reserve before him. He would dream of this with + erections. His sexual interests became slowly centered in the act + of defecation, and this fetich throughout life never appealed to + him so powerfully as when associated with the particular type of + household furniture which was used for this purpose in his own + house. The act of defecation in the opposite sex or anything + pertaining to or suggesting the same caused uncontrollable sexual + excitement; the nates also exerted a great attraction. The alvine + excreta exerted this influence even in the absence of the woman; + it was, however, necessary that she should be a sexually + desirable person. The perversion in this case was not complete; + that is to say, that the excitement produced by the act of + defecation or the excretion itself was not actually preferred to + coitus; the sexual idea was normal coitus in the normal manner, + but preceded by the visual and olfactory enjoyment of the + exciting fetich. When coitus was not possible the enjoyment of + the fetich was accompanied by masturbation (as in the analogous + case of urolagnia in a woman summarized on p. 62.) On one + occasion he was discovered by a friend in a bedroom belonging to + a woman, engaged in the act of masturbation over a vessel + containing the desired fetich. In an agony of shame he begged the + mercy of silence concerning this episode, at the same time + revealing his life-history. He has constantly been haunted by the + dread of detection, as well as by remorse and the consciousness + of degradation, also by the fear that his unconquerable obsession + may lead him to the asylum.</p></div> + +<p>The scatalogic groups of sexual perversions, urolagnia and coprolagnia, as +may be sufficiently seen in this brief summary, <a name='5_Page_70'></a>are not merely olfactory +fetiches. They are, in a larger proportion of cases, dynamic symbols, a +preoccupation with physiological acts which, by associations of contiguity +and still more of resemblance, have gained the virtue of stimulating in +slight cases, and replacing in more extreme cases, the normal +preoccupation with the central physiological act itself. We have seen that +there are various considerations which amply suffice to furnish a basis +for such associations. And when we reflect that in the popular mind, and +to some extent in actual fact, the sexual act itself is, like urination +and defecation, an excretory act, we can understand that the true +excretory acts may easily become symbols of the pseudo-excretory act. It +is, indeed, in the muscular release of accumulated pressures and tensions, +involved by the act of liberating the stored-up excretion, that we have +the closest simulacrum of the tumescence and detumescence of the sexual +process.<a name='5_FNanchor_32'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_32'><sup>[32]</sup></a></p> + +<p>In this way the erotic symbolism of urolagnia and coprolagnia is +completely analogous with that dynamic symbolism of the clinging and +swinging garments which Herrick has so accurately described, with the +complex symbolism of flagellation and its play of the rod against the +blushing and trembling nates, with the symbols of sexual strain and stress +which are embodied in the foot and the act of treading.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_24'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_24'>[24]</a><div class='note'><p> Fuchs (<i>Das Erotische Element In der Karikatur</i>, p. 26), +distinguishing sharply between the "erotic" and the "obscene," reserves +the latter term exclusively for the representation of excretory organs and +acts. He considers that this is etymologically the most exact usage. +However that may be, it seems to me that, in any case, "obscene" has +become so vague a term that it is now impracticable to give it a +restricted and precise sense.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_25'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_25'>[25]</a><div class='note'><p> In this connection we may profitably contemplate the hand +and recall the vast gamut of functions, sacred and profane, which that +organ exercises. Many savages strictly reserve the left hand to the +lowlier purposes of life; but in civilization that is not considered +necessary, and it may be wholesome for some of us to meditate on the more +humble uses of the same hand which is raised in the supreme gesture of +benediction and which men have often counted it a privilege to kiss.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_26'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_26'>[26]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, Morselli, <i>Una Causa di Nullità del +Matrimonio</i>, 1902, p. 39.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_27'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_27'>[27]</a><div class='note'><p> Féré, <i>Comptes-Rendus Société de Biologie</i>, July 23, 1904.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_28'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_28'>[28]</a><div class='note'><p> Transactions of the International Medical Congress, Moscow, +vol. iv, p. 19. A similar symbolism may be traced in many of the cases in +which the focus of modesty becomes in modest women centered in the +excretory sphere and sometimes exaggerated to the extent of obsession. It +must not be supposed, however, that every obsession in this sphere has a +symbolical value of an erotic kind. In the case, for instance, which has +been recorded by Raymond and Janet (<i>Les Obsessions</i>, vol. ii, p. 306) of +a woman who spent much of her time in the endeavor to urinate perfectly, +always feeling that she failed in some respect, the obsession seems to +have risen fortuitously on a somewhat neurotic basis without reference to +the sexual life.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_29'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_29'>[29]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Anatomy of Melancholy</i>, Part III, Section II, Mem. III, +Subs. I.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_30'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_30'>[30]</a><div class='note'><p> It may be remarked here that while the eating of excrement +(apart from its former use as a magic charm and as a therapeutic agent) is +in civilization now confined to sexual perverts and the insane, among some +animals it is normal as a measure of hygiene in relation to their young. +Thus, as, <i>e.g.</i>, the Rev. Arthur East writes, the mistle thrush swallows +the droppings of its young. (<i>Knowledge</i>, June 1, 1899, p. 133.) In the +dog I have observed that the bitch licks her puppies shortly after birth +as they urinate, absorbing the fluid.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_31'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_31'>[31]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, the previous volume of these <i>Studies</i>, "Sexual +Selection in Man," pp. 165 <i>et seq.</i>, and Dühren, <i>Geschlechtsleben in +England</i>, bd. ii, pp. 258, <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_32'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_32'>[32]</a><div class='note'><p> In the study of <i>Love and Pain</i> in a previous volume (p. +130) I have quoted the remarks of a lady who refers to the analogy between +sexual tension and vesical tension—"Cette volupté que ressentent les +bords de la mer, d'être toujours pleins sans jamais déborder"—and its +erotic significance.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_E_IV'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_71'></a>IV.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Animals as Sources of Erotic Symbolism—Mixoscopic Zoophilia—The +Stuff-fetichisms—Hair-fetichism—The Stuff-fetichisms Mainly on a Tactile +Base—Erotic Zoophilia—Zooerastia—Bestiality—The Conditions that Favor +Bestiality—Its Wide Prevalence Among Primitive Peoples and Among +Peasants—The Primitive Conception of Animals—The Goat—The Influence of +Familiarity with Animals—Congress Between Women and Animals—The Social +Reaction Against Bestiality.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>The erotic symbols with which we have so far been concerned have in every +case been portions of the body, or its physiological processes, or at +least the garments which it has endowed with life. The association on +which the symbol has arisen has in every case been in large measure, +although not entirely, an association of contiguity. It is now necessary +to touch on a group of sexual symbols in which the association of +contiguity with the human body is absent: the various methods by which +animals or animal products or the sight of animal copulation may arouse +sexual desire in human persons. Here we encounter a symbolism mainly +founded on association by resemblance; the animal sexual act recalls the +human sexual act; the animal becomes the symbol of the human being.</p> + +<p>The group of phenomena we are here concerned with includes several +subdivisions. There is first the more or less sexual pleasure sometimes +experienced, especially by young persons, in the sight of copulating +animals. This I would propose to call Mixoscopic Zoophilia; it falls +within the range of normal variation. Then we have the cases in which the +contact of animals, stroking, etc., produces sexual excitement or +gratification; this is a sexual fetichism in the narrow sense, and is by +Krafft-Ebing termed <i>Zoophilia Erotica</i>. We have, further, the class of +cases in which a real or simulated sexual intercourse with animals is +desired. Such cases are not regarded as fetichism by<a name='5_Page_72'></a> Krafft-Ebing,<a name='5_FNanchor_33'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_33'><sup>[33]</sup></a> +but they come within the phenomena of erotic symbolism as here understood. +This class falls into two divisions: one in which the individual is fairly +normal, but belongs to a low grade of culture; the other in which he may +belong to a more refined social class, but is affected by a deep degree of +degeneration. In the first case we may properly apply the term bestiality; +in the second case it may perhaps be better to use the term <i>zooerastia</i>, +proposed by Krafft-Ebing.<a name='5_FNanchor_34'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_34'><sup>[34]</sup></a></p> + +<p>Among children, both boys and girls, it is common to find that the +copulation of animals is a mysteriously fascinating spectacle. It is +inevitable that this should be so, for the spectacle is more or less +clearly felt to be the revelation of a secret which has been concealed +from them. It is, moreover, a secret of which they feel intimate +reverberations within themselves, and even in perfectly innocent and +ignorant children the sight may produce an obscure sexual excitement.<a name='5_FNanchor_35'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_35'><sup>[35]</sup></a> +It would seem that this occurs more frequently in girls than in boys. Even +in adult age, it may be added, women are liable to experience the same +kind of emotion in the presence of such spectacles. One lady recalls, as a +girl, that on several occasions an element of physical excitement entered +into the feelings with which she watched the coquetry of cats. Another +lady mentions that at the age of about 25, and when still quite ignorant +of sexual matters, she saw from a window some boys tickling a dog and +inducing sexual excitement in the animal; she vaguely divined what they +were doing, and though feeling disgust at their conduct she at the same +time experienced in a strong degree what she now knows was sexual +excitement. The coupling of the larger animals is <a name='5_Page_73'></a>often an impressive and +splendid spectacle which is far, indeed, from being obscene, and has +commended itself to persons of intellectual distinction;<a name='5_FNanchor_36'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_36'><sup>[36]</sup></a> but in young +or ill-balanced minds such sights tend to become both prurient and morbid. +I have already referred to the curious case of a sexually hyperæsthetic +nun who was always powerfully excited by the sight or even the +recollection of flies in sexual connection, so that she was compelled to +masturbate; this dated from childhood. After becoming a nun she recorded +having had this experience, followed by masturbation, more than four +hundred times.<a name='5_FNanchor_37'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_37'><sup>[37]</sup></a> Animal spectacles sometimes produce a sexual effect on +children even when not specifically sexual; thus a correspondent, a +clergyman, informs me that when a young and impressionable boy, he was +much affected by seeing a veterinary surgeon insert his hand and arm into +a horse's rectum, and dreamed of this several times afterward with +emissions.</p> + +<p>While the contemplation of animal coitus is an easily intelligible and in +early life, perhaps, an almost normal symbol of sexual emotion, there is +another subdivision of this group of animal fetichisms which forms a more +natural transition from the fetichisms which have their center in the +human body: the stuff-fetichisms, or the sexual attraction exerted by +various tissues, perhaps always of animal origin. Here we are in the +presence of a somewhat complicated phenomenon. In part we have, <a name='5_Page_74'></a>in a +considerable number of such cases, the sexual attraction of feminine +garments, for all such tissues are liable to enter into the dress. In +part, also, we have a sexual perversion of tactile sensibility, for in a +considerable proportion of these cases it is the touch sensations which +are potent in arousing the erotic sensations. But in part, also, it would +seem, we have here the conscious or subconscious presence of an animal +fetich, and it is notable that perhaps all these stuffs, and especially +fur, which is by far the commonest of the groups, are distinctively animal +products. We may perhaps regard the fetich of feminine hair—a much more +important and common fetich, indeed, than any of the stuff fetichisms—as +a link of transition. Hair is at once an animal and a human product, while +it may be separated from the body and possesses the qualities of a stuff. +Krafft-Ebing remarks that the senses of touch, smell, and hearing, as well +as sight, seem to enter into the attraction exerted by hair.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The natural fascination of hair, on which hair-fetichism is + founded, begins at a very early age. "The hair is a special + object of interest with infants," Stanley Hall concludes, "which + begins often in the latter part of the first year.... The hair, + no doubt, gives quite unique tactile sensations, both in its own + roots and to hands, and is plastic and yielding to the motor + sense, so that the earliest interest may be akin to that in fur, + which is a marked object in infant experience. Some children + develop an almost fetichistic propensity to pull or later to + stroke the hair or beard of every one with whom they come in + contact." (G. Stanley Hall, "The Early Sense of Self," <i>American + Journal of Psychology</i>, April, 1898, p. 359.)</p> + +<p> It should be added that the fascination of hair for the infantile + and childish mind is not necessarily one of attraction, but may + be of repulsion. It happens here, as in the case of so many + characteristics which are of sexual significance, that we are in + the presence of an object which may exert a dynamic emotional + force, a force which is capable of repelling with the same energy + that it attracts. Féré records the instructive case of a child of + 3, of psychopathic heredity, who when he could not sleep was + sometimes taken by his mother into her bed. One night his hand + came in contact with a hairy portion of his mother's body, and + this, arousing the idea of an animal, caused him to leap out of + the bed in terror. He became curious as to the cause of his + terror and in time was able to observe "the animal," but the + train of feelings which had been set up led to a life-long + indifference to women and a tendency to homosexuality. It is + noteworthy that he was attracted to <a name='5_Page_75'></a>men in whom the hair and + other secondary sexual characters were well developed. (Féré, + <i>L'Instinct Sexuel</i>, second edition, pp. 262-267.)</p> + +<p> As a sexual fetich hair strictly belongs to the group of parts of + the body; but since it can be removed from the body and is + sexually effective as a fetich in the absence of the person to + whom it belongs, it is on a level with the garments which may + serve in a similar way, with shoes or handkerchiefs or gloves. + Psychologically, hair-fetichism presents no special problem, but + the wide attraction of hair—it is sexually the most generally + noted part of the feminine body after the eyes—and the peculiar + facility with which when plaited it may be removed, render + hair-fetichism a sexual perversion of specially great + medico-legal interest.</p> + +<p> The frequency of hair-fetichism, as well as of the natural + admiration on which it rests, is indicated by a case recorded by + Laurent. "A few years ago," he states, "one constantly saw at the + Bal Bullier, in Paris, a tall girl whose face was lean and bony, + but whose black hair was of truly remarkable length. She wore it + flowing down her shoulders and loins. Men often followed her in + the street to touch or kiss the hair. Others would accompany her + home and pay her for the mere pleasure of touching and kissing + the long black tresses. One, in consideration of a relatively + considerable sum, desired to pollute the silky hair. She was + obliged to be always on her guard, and to take all sorts of + precautions to prevent any one cutting off this ornament, which + constituted her only beauty as well as her livelihood." (E. + Laurent, <i>L'Amour Morbide</i>, 1891, p. 164; also the same author's + <i>Fétichistes et Erotomanes</i>, p. 23.)</p> + +<p> The hair despoiler (<i>Coupeur des Nattes</i> or <i>Zopfabschneider</i>) + may be found in any civilized country, though the most carefully + studied cases have occurred in Paris. (Several medico-legal + histories of hair-despoilers are summarized by Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. + cit.</i>, pp. 329-334). Such persons are usually of nervous + temperament and bad heredity; the attraction to hair occasionally + develops in early life; sometimes the morbid impulse only appears + in later life after fever. The fetich may be either flowing hair + or braided hair, but is usually one or the other, and not both. + Sexual excitement and ejaculation may be produced in the act of + touching or cutting off the hair, which is subsequently, in many + cases, used for masturbation. As a rule the hair-despoiler is a + pure fetichist, no element of sadistic pleasure entering into his + feelings. In the case of a "capillary kleptomaniac" in Chicago—a + highly intelligent and athletic married young man of good + family—the impulse to cut off girls' braids appeared after + recovery from a severe fever. He would gaze admiringly at the + long tresses and then clip them off with great rapidity; he did + this in some fifty cases before he was caught and imprisoned. He + usually threw the braids away before he reached home. (<i>Alienist + and Neurologist</i>, April, 1889, p. 325.) In this case there <a name='5_Page_76'></a>is no + history of sexual excitement, probably because no proper + medico-legal examination was made. (It may be added that + hair-despoilers have been specially studied by Motet, "Les + Coupeurs de Nattes," <i>Annales d'Hygiène</i>, 1890.)</p></div> + +<p>The stuff-fetiches are most usually fur and velvet; feathers, silk, and +leathers also sometimes exert this influence; they are all, it will be +noted, animal substances.<a name='5_FNanchor_38'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_38'><sup>[38]</sup></a> The most interesting is probably fur, the +attraction of which is not uncommon in association with passive +algolagnia. As Stanley Hall has shown, the fear of fur, as well as the +love of it, is by no means uncommon in childhood; it may appear even in +infancy and in children who have never come in contact with animals.<a name='5_FNanchor_39'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_39'><sup>[39]</sup></a> +It is noteworthy that in most cases of uncomplicated stuff-fetichism the +attraction apparently arises on a congenital basis, as it appears in +persons of nervous or sensitive temperament at an early age and without +being attached to any definite causative incident. The sexual excitation +is nearly always produced by the touch rather than by the sight. As we +found, when dealing with the sense of touch in the previous volume, the +specific sexual sensations may be regarded as a special modification of +ticklishness. The erotic symbolism in the case of these stuff-fetichisms +would seem to be a more or less congenital perversion of ticklishness in +relation to specific animal contacts.</p> + +<p>A further degree of perversion in this direction is reached in a case of +erotic <i>zoophilia</i>, recorded by Krafft-Ebing.<a name='5_FNanchor_40'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_40'><sup>[40]</sup></a> In this case a +congenital neuropath, of good intelligence but delicate and anæmic, with +feeble sexual powers, had a great love of domestic animals, especially +dogs and cats, from an early age; when petting them he experienced sexual +emotions, although he was innocent in sexual matters. At puberty he +realized the nature of his feelings and tried to break himself of his +habits. He succeeded, but then began erotic dreams accompanied by images +of <a name='5_Page_77'></a>animals, and these led to masturbation associated with ideas of a +similar kind. At the same time he had no wish for any sort of sexual +intercourse with animals, and was indifferent as to the sex of the animals +which attracted him; his sexual ideals were normal. Such a case seems to +be fundamentally one of fetichism on a tactile basis, and thus forms a +transition between the stuff-fetichisms and the complete perversions of +sexual attraction toward animals.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In some cases sexually hyperæsthetic women have informed me that + sexual feeling has been produced by casual contact with pet dogs + and cats. In such cases there is usually no real perversion, but + it seems probable that we may here have an occasional foundation + for the somewhat morbid but scarcely vicious excesses of + affection which women are apt to display towards their pet dogs + or cats. In most cases of this affection there is certainly no + sexual element; in the case of childless women, it may rather be + regarded as a maternal than as an erotic symbolism. (The excesses + of this non-erotic zoophilia have been discussed by Féré, + <i>L'Instinct Sexuel</i>, second edition, pp. 166-171.)</p></div> + +<p>Krafft-Ebing considers that complete perversion of sexual attraction +toward animals is radically distinct from erotic <i>zoophilia</i>. This view +cannot be accepted. Bestiality and <i>zooerastia</i> merely present in a more +marked and profoundly perverted form a further degree of the same +phenomenon which we meet with in erotic <i>zoophilia</i>; the difference is +that they occur either in more insensitive or in more markedly degenerate +persons.</p> + +<p>A fairly typical case of <i>zooerastia</i> has been recorded in America by +Howard, of Baltimore. This was the case of a boy of 16, precociously +mature and fairly bright. He was, however, indifferent to the opposite +sex, though he had ample opportunity for gratifying normal passions. His +parents lived in the city, but the youth had an inordinate desire for the +country and was therefore sent to school in a village. On the second day +after his arrival at school a farmer missed a sow which was found secreted +in an outhouse on the school grounds. This was the first of many similar +incidents in which a sow always took part. So strong was his passion that +on one occasion force had to be used to take him away from the sow he was +caressing. He did <a name='5_Page_78'></a>not masturbate, and even when restrained from +approaching sows he had no sexual inclination for other animals. His +nocturnal pollutions, which were frequent, were always accompanied by +images of wallowing swine. Notwithstanding careful treatment no cure was +effected; mental and physical vigor failed, and he died at the age of +23.<a name='5_FNanchor_41'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_41'><sup>[41]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is, however, somewhat doubtful whether we can always or even usually +distinguish between zooerastia and bestiality. Dr. G. F. Lydston, of +Chicago, has communicated to me a case (in which he was consulted) which +seems fairly typical and is instructive in this respect. The subject was a +young man of 21, a farmer's son, not very bright intellectually, but very +healthy and strong, of great assistance on the farm, very capable and +industrious, such a good farm hand that his father was unwilling to send +him away and to lose his services. There was no history of insanity or +neurosis in the family, and no injury or illness in his own history. He +had spells of moroseness and irritability, however, and had also been a +masturbator. Women had no attraction for him, but he would copulate with +the mares upon his father's farm, and this without regard to time, place, +or spectators. Such a case would seem to stand midway between ordinary +bestiality and pathological zooerastia as defined by Krafft-Ebing, yet it +seems probable that in most cases of ordinary bestiality some slight +traces of mental anomaly might be found, if such cases always were, as +they should be, properly investigated.<a name='5_FNanchor_42'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_42'><sup>[42]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_79'></a> +<p>We have here reached the grossest and most frequent perversion in this +group; bestiality, or the impulse to attain sexual gratification by +intercourse, or other close contact, with animals. In seeking to +comprehend this perversion it is necessary to divest ourselves of the +attitude toward animals which is the inevitable outcome of refined +civilization and urban life. Most sexual perversions, if not in large +measure the actual outcome of civilized life, easily adjust themselves to +it. Bestiality (except in one form to be noted later) is, on the other +hand, the sexual perversion of dull, insensitive and unfastidious persons. +It flourishes among primitive peoples and among peasants. It is the vice +of the clodhopper, unattractive to women or inapt to court them.</p> + +<p>Three conditions have favored the extreme prevalence of bestiality: (1) +primitive conceptions of life which built up no great barrier between man +and the other animals; (2) the extreme familiarity which necessarily +exists between the peasant and his beasts, often combined with separation +from women; (3) various folk-lore beliefs such as the efficacy of +intercourse with animals as a cure for venereal disease, etc.<a name='5_FNanchor_43'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_43'><sup>[43]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The beliefs and customs of primitive peoples, as well as their mythology +and legends, bring before us a community of man and animals altogether +unlike anything we know in civilization. Men may become animals and +animals may become men; animals and men may communicate with each other +and live on terms of equality; animals may be the ancestors of human +tribes; the sacred totems of savages are most usually animals. There is no +shame or degradation in the notion of a sexual relationship between men +and animals, because in primitive conceptions animals are not inferior +beings separated from man by a great gulf. They are much more like men in +disguise, and in some respects possess powers which make them superior to +men.<a name='5_Page_80'></a> This is recognized in those plays, festivals, and religious dances, +so common among primitive peoples, in which animal disguises are worn.<a name='5_FNanchor_44'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_44'><sup>[44]</sup></a> +When men admire and emulate the qualities of animals and are proud to +believe that they descend from them, it is not surprising that they should +sometimes see nothing derogatory in sexual intercourse with them.<a name='5_FNanchor_45'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_45'><sup>[45]</sup></a></p> + +<p>A significant relic of primitive conceptions in this matter may perhaps be +found in the religious rites connected with the sacred goat of Mendes +described by Herodotus. After telling how the Mendesians reverence the +goat, especially the he-goat, out of their veneration for Pan, whom they +represent as a goat ("the real motive which they assign for this custom I +do not choose to relate"), he adds: "It happened in this country, and +within my remembrance, and was indeed universally notorious, that a goat +had indecent and public communication with a woman."<a name='5_FNanchor_46'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_46'><sup>[46]</sup></a> The meaning of +the passage evidently is that in the ordinary intercourse of women with +the sacred goat, connection was only simulated or incomplete on account of +the natural indifference of the goat to the human female, but that in rare +cases the goat proved sexually excitable with the woman and capable of +connection.<a name='5_FNanchor_47'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_47'><sup>[47]</sup></a> The goat has always been a kind of sacred emblem of lust. +In the middle ages it became associated with the Devil as one of the +favorite forms he assumed. It is significant of a primitively religious +sexual association between men and animals, that witches constantly +confessed, or were made to confess, that they had had intercourse with the +Devil in the shape of an animal, very frequently a dog. The figures <a name='5_Page_81'></a>of +human beings and animals in conjunction carved on temples in India, also +seem to indicate the religious significance which this phenomenon +sometimes presents. There is, indeed, no need to go beyond Europe even in +her moments of highest culture to find a religious sanction for sexual +union between human beings, or gods in human shape, and animals. The +legends of Io and the bull, of Leda and the swan, are among the most +familiar in Greek mythology, and in a later pictorial form they constitute +some of the most cherished works of the painters of the Renaissance.</p> + +<p>As regards the prevalence of occasional sexual intercourse between men or +women and animals among primitive peoples at the present time, it is +possible to find many scattered references by travelers in all parts of +the world. Such references by no means indicate that such practices are, +as a rule, common, but they usually show that they are accepted with a +good-humored indifference.<a name='5_FNanchor_48'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_48'><sup>[48]</sup></a></p> + +<p>Bestiality is very rarely found in towns. In the country this vice of the +clodhopper is far from infrequent. For the peasant, whose sensibilities +are uncultivated and who makes but the most elementary demands from a +woman, the difference between an animal and a human being in this respect +scarcely seems to be very great. "My wife was away too long," a German +peasant explained to the magistrate, "and so I went with my sow." It is +certainly an explanation that to the uncultivated peasant, ignorant of +theological and juridical conceptions, must often seem natural and +sufficient.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Bestiality thus resembles masturbation and other abnormal + manifestations of the sexual impulse which may be practiced + merely <i>faute de mieux</i> and not as, in the strict sense, + perversions of the impulse. Even necrophily may be thus + practiced. A young man who when assisting the grave-digger + conceived and carried out the idea of digging up the bodies of + young girls to satisfy his passions with, and whose case <a name='5_Page_82'></a>has + been recorded by Belletrud and Mercier, said: "I could find no + young girl who would agree to yield to my desires; that is why I + have done this. I should have preferred to have relations with + living persons. I found it quite natural to do what I did: I saw + no harm in it, and I did not think that any one else could. As + living women felt nothing but repulsion for me, it was quite + natural I should turn to the dead, who have never repulsed me. I + used to say tender things to them like 'my beautiful, my love, I + love you.'" (Belletrud and Mercier "Perversion de l'Instinct + Genésique," <i>Annales d'Hygiène Publique</i>, June, 1903.) But when + so highly abnormal an act is felt as natural we are dealing with + a person who is congenitally defective so far as the finer + developments of intelligence are concerned. It was so in this + case of necrophily; he was the son of a weak-minded woman of + unrestrainable sexual inclinations, and was himself somewhat + feeble-minded; he was also, it is instructive to observe, + anosmic.</p></div> + +<p>But it is by no means only their dulled sensibility or the absence of +women, which accounts for the frequency of bestiality among peasants. A +highly important factor is their constant familiarity with animals. The +peasant lives with animals, tends them, learns to know all their +individual characters; he understands them far better than he understands +men and women; they are his constant companions, his friends. He knows, +moreover, the details of their sexual lives, he witnesses the often highly +impressive spectacle of their coupling. It is scarcely surprising that +peasants should sometimes regard animals as being not only as near to them +as their fellow human beings, but even nearer.</p> + +<p>The significance of the factor of familiarity is indicated by the great +frequency of bestiality among shepherds, goatherds, and others whose +occupation is exclusively the care of animals. Mirabeau, in the eighteenth +century, stated, on the evidence of Basque priests, that all the shepherds +in the Pyrenees practice bestiality. It is apparently much the same in +Italy.<a name='5_FNanchor_49'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_49'><sup>[49]</sup></a> In South<a name='5_Page_83'></a> Italy and Sicily, especially, bestiality among +goatherds and peasants is said to be almost a national custom.<a name='5_FNanchor_50'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_50'><sup>[50]</sup></a> In the +extreme north of Europe, it is reported, the reindeer, in this respect, +takes the place of the goat.</p> + +<p>The importance of the same factor is also shown by the fact that when +among women in civilization animal perversions appear, the animal is +nearly always a pet dog. Usually in these cases the animal is taught to +give gratification by <i>cunnilinctus</i>. In some cases, however, there is +really sexual intercourse between the animal and the woman.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Moll mentions that in a case of <i>cunnilinctus</i> by a dog in + Germany there was a difficulty as to whether the matter should be + considered an unnatural offence or simply an offence against + decency; the lower court considered it in the former light, while + the higher court took the more merciful view. (Moll, + <i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. 697.) In a + case reported by Pfaff and mentioned by Moll, a country girl was + accused of having sexual intercourse with a large dog. On + examination Pfaff found in the girl's thick pubic hair a loose + hair which under the microscope proved to belong to the dog. + (<i>Loc. cit.</i>, p. 698.) In such a case it must be noted that while + this evidence may be held to show sexual contact with the dog, it + scarcely suffices to show sexual intercourse. This has, however, + undoubtedly occurred from time to time, even more or less openly. + Bloch (<i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 277 and 282) remarks that this is not an + infrequent exhibition given by prostitutes in certain brothels. + Maschka has referred to such an exhibition between a woman and a + bull-dog, which was given to select circles in Paris. Rosse + refers to a case in which a young unmarried woman in Washington + was surprised during intercourse with a large English mastiff, + who in his efforts to get loose caused such severe injuries that + the woman died from hæmorrhage in about an hour. Rosse also + mentions that some years ago a performance of this kind between a + prostitute and a Newfoundland dog could be witnessed in San + Francisco by paying a small sum; the woman declared that a woman + who had once copulated with a dog would ever afterwards prefer + this animal to a man. Rosse adds that he was acquainted with a + similar performance between a woman <a name='5_Page_84'></a>and a donkey, which used to + take place in Europe (Irving Rosse, "Sexual Hypochondriasis and + Perversion of the Genesic Instinct," <i>Virginia Medical Monthly</i>, + October, 1892, p. 379). Juvenal mentions such relations between + the donkey and woman (vi, 332). Krauss (quoted by Bloch, + <i>Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, Teil II, p. + 276) states that in Bosnia women sometimes carry on these + practices with dogs and also—as he would not have believed had + he not on one occasion observed it—with cats. "It seems to me," + writes Dr. Kiernan, of Chicago, (private letter) "that what Rosse + says of the animal exhibitions in San Francisco is true of all + great cities. The animal employed in such exhibitions here has + usually been a donkey, and in one instance death occurred from + the animal trampling the girl partner. The practice described + occurs in country regions quite frequently. Thus in a case + reported in the suburbs of Omaha, Nebraska, a sixteen-year-old + boy engaged in rectal coitus with a large dog. In attempting to + extricate his swollen penis from the boy's rectum the dog tore + through the <i>sphincter ani</i> an inch into the gluteus muscles. + (<i>Omaha Clinic</i>, March, 1893.) In a Missouri case, which I + verified, a smart, pretty, well-educated country girl was found + with a profuse offensive vaginal discharge which had been present + for about a week, coming on suddenly. After washing the external + genitals and opening the labia three rents were discovered, one + through the fourchette and two through the left nymphæ. The + vagina was excessively congested and covered with points bleeding + on the slightest irritation. The patient confessed that one day + while playing with the genitals of a large dog she became excited + and thought she would have slight coitus. After the dog had made + an entrance she was unable to free herself from him, as he + clasped her so firmly with his fore legs. The penis became so + swollen that the dog could not free himself, although for more + than an hour she made persistent efforts to do so. (<i>Medical + Standard</i>, June, 1903, p. 184). In an Indiana case, concerning + which I was consulted, the girl was a hebephreniac who had + resorted to this procedure with a Newfoundland dog at the + instance of another girl, seemingly normal as regards mentality, + and had been badly injured; a discharge resulted which resembled + gonorrhœa, but contained no gonococci. These cases are + probably more frequent than is usually assumed."</p> + +<p> Women are known to have had intercourse with various other + animals, occasionally or habitually, in various parts of the + world. Monkeys have been mentioned in this connection. Moll + remarks that it seems to be an indication of an abnormal interest + in monkeys that some women are observed by the attendants in the + monkey-house of zoölogical gardens to be very frequent visitors. + Near the Amazon the traveler Castelnau saw an enormous Coati + monkey belonging to an Indian woman and tried to purchase it; + though he offered a large sum, the woman only laughed. "Your + efforts are useless," remarked an<a name='5_Page_85'></a> Indian in the same cabin, "he + is her husband." (So far as the early literature of this subject + is concerned, a number of facts and fables regarding the congress + of women with dogs, goats and other animals was brought together + at the beginning of the eighteenth century by Schurig in his + <i>Gynæcologia</i>, Section II, cap. VII; I have not drawn on this + collection.)</p> + +<p> In some cases women, and also men, find gratification in the + sexual manipulation of animals without any kind of congress. This + may be illustrated by an observation communicated to me by a + correspondent, a clergyman. "In Ireland, my father's house + adjoined the residence of an archdeacon of the established + church. I was then about 20 and was still kept in religious awe + of evil ways. The archdeacon had two daughters, both of whom he + brought up in great strictness, resolved that they should grow up + examples of virtue and piety. Our stables adjoined, and were + separated only by a thin wall in which was a doorway closed up by + some boards, as the two stables had formerly been one. One night + I had occasion to go to our stable to search for a garden tool I + had missed, and I heard a door open on the other side, and saw a + light glimmer through the cracks of the boards. I looked through + to ascertain who could be there at that late hour, and soon + recognized the stately figure of one of the daughters, F. F. was + tall, dark and handsome, but had never made any advances to me, + nor had I to her. She was making love to her father's mare after + a singular fashion. Stripping her right arm, she formed her + fingers into a cone, and pressed on the mare's vulva. I was + astonished to see the beast stretching her hind legs as if to + accommodate the hand of her mistress, which she pushed in + gradually and with seeming ease to the elbow. At the same time + she seemed to experience the most voluptuous sensation, crisis + after crisis arriving." My correspondent adds that, being + exceedingly curious in the matter, he tried a somewhat similar + experiment himself with one of his father's mares and experienced + what he describes as "a most powerful sexual battery" which + produced very exciting and exhausting effects. Näcke + (<i>Psychiatrische en Neurologische Bladen</i>, 1899, No. 2) refers to + an idiot who thus manipulated the vulva of mares in his charge. + The case has been recorded by Guillereau (<i>Journal de Médicine + Véterinaire et de Zootechnie</i>, January, 1899) of a youth who was + accustomed to introduce his hand into the vulva of cows in order + to obtain sexual excitement.</p> + +<p> The possibility of sexual excitement between women and animals + involves a certain degree of sexual excitability in animals from + contact with women. Darwin stated that there could be no doubt + that various quadrumanous animals could distinguish women from + men—in the first place probably by smell and secondarily by + sight—and be thus liable to sexual excitement. He quotes the + opinions on this point of Youatt,<a name='5_Page_86'></a> Brehm, Sir Andrew Smith and + Cuvier (<i>Descent of Man</i>, second edition, p. 8). Moll quotes the + opinion of an experienced observer to the same effect + (<i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, Bd. i, p. 429). + Hufeland reported the case of a little girl of three who was + playing, seated on a stool, with a dog placed between her thighs + and locked against her. Seemingly excited by this contact the + animal attempted a sort of copulation, causing the genital parts + of the child to become inflamed. Bloch (<i>Op. cit.</i>, p. 280, <i>et + seq.</i>) discusses the same point; he does not consider that + animals will of their own motion sexually cohabit with women, but + that they may be easily trained to it. There can be no doubt that + dogs at all events are sometimes sexually excited by the presence + of women, perhaps especially during menstruation, and many women + are able to bear testimony to the embarrassing attentions they + have sometimes received from strange dogs. There can be no + difficulty in believing that, so far as <i>cunnilinctus</i> is + concerned dogs would require no training. In a case recorded by + Moll (<i>Konträre Sexualempfindung</i>, third edition, p. 560) a lady + states that this was done to her when a child, as also to other + children, by dogs who, she said, showed signs of sexual + excitement. In this case there was also sexual excitement thus + produced in the child, and after puberty mutual <i>cunnilinctus</i> + was practiced with girl friends. Guttceit (<i>Dreissig Jahre + Praxis</i>, Theil I, p. 310) remarks that some Russian officers who + were in the Turkish campaign of 1828 told him that from fear of + veneral infection in Wallachia they refrained from women and + often used female asses which appeared to show signs of sexual + pleasure.</p></div> + +<p>A very large number of animals have been recorded as having been employed +in the gratification of sexual desire at some period or in some country, +by men and sometimes by women. Domestic animals are naturally those which +most frequently come into question, and there are few if any of these +which can altogether be excepted. The sow is one of the animals most +frequently abused in this manner.<a name='5_FNanchor_51'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_51'><sup>[51]</sup></a> Cases in which mares, cows, and +donkeys figure constantly occur, as well as goats and sheep. Dogs, cats, +and rabbits are heard of from time to time. Hens, ducks, and, especially +in China, geese, are not uncommonly employed. The Roman ladies were said +to have had an abnormal <a name='5_Page_87'></a>affection for snakes. The bear and even the +crocodile are also mentioned.<a name='5_FNanchor_52'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_52'><sup>[52]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The social and legal attitude toward bestiality has reflected in part the +frequency with which it has been practiced, and in part the disgust mixed +with mystical and sacrilegious horror which it has aroused. It has +sometimes been met merely by a fine, and sometimes the offender and his +innocent partner have been burnt together. In the middle ages and later +its frequency is attested by the fact that it formed a favorite topic with +preachers of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. It is significant that +in the Penitentials,—which were criminal codes, half secular and half +spiritual, in use before the thirteenth century, when penance was +relegated to the judgment of the confessor,—it was thought necessary to +fix the periods of penance which should be undergone respectively by +bishops, priests and deacons who should be guilty of bestiality.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In Egbert's Penitential, a document of the ninth and tenth + centuries, we read (V. 22): "Item Episcopus cum quadrupede + fornicans VII annos, consuetudinem X, presbyter V, diaconus III, + clerus II." There was a great range in the penances for + bestiality, from ten years to (in the case of boys) one hundred + days. The mare is specially mentioned (Haddon and Stubbs, + <i>Councils and Ecclesiastical Documents</i>, vol. iii, p. 422). In + Theodore's Penitential, another Anglo-Saxon document of about the + same age, those who habitually fornicate with animals are + adjudged ten years of penance. It would appear from the + <i>Penitentiale Pseudo-Romanum</i> (which is earlier than the eleventh + century) that one year's penance was adequate for fornication + with a mare when committed by a layman (exactly the same as for + simple fornication with a widow or virgin), and this was + mercifully reduced to half a year if he had no wife. + (Wasserschleben, <i>Die Bussordnungen der Abendländlichen Kirche</i>, + p. 366). The <i>Penitentiale Hubertense</i> (emanating from the + monastery of St. Hubert in the Ardennes) fixes ten years' penance + for sodomy, while Fulbert's Penitential (about the eleventh + century) fixes seven years for either sodomy or bestiality. + Burchard's Penitential, <a name='5_Page_88'></a>which is always detailed and precise, + specially mentions the mare, the cow and the ass, and assigns + forty days bread and water and seven years penance, raised to ten + years in the case of married men. A woman having intercourse with + a horse is assigned seven years penance in Burchard's + Penitential. (Wasserschleben, <i>ib.</i> pp. 651, 659.)</p></div> + +<p>The extreme severity which was frequently exercised toward those guilty of +this offense, was doubtless in large measure due to the fact that +bestiality was regarded as a kind of sodomy, an offense which was +frequently viewed with a mystical horror apart altogether from any actual +social or personal injury it caused. The Jews seem to have felt this +horror; it was ordered that the sinner and his victim should both be put +to death (Exodus, Ch. 22, v. 19; Leviticus, Ch. 20, v. 15). In the middle +ages, especially in France, the same rule often prevailed. Men and sows, +men and cows, men and donkeys were burnt together. At Toulouse a woman was +burnt for having intercourse with a dog. Even in the seventeenth century a +learned French lawyer, Claude Lebrun de la Rochette, justified such +sentences.<a name='5_FNanchor_53'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_53'><sup>[53]</sup></a> It seems probable that even to-day, in the social and legal +attitude toward bestiality, sufficient regard is not paid to the fact that +this offense is usually committed either by persons who are morbidly +abnormal or who are of so low a degree of intelligence that they border on +feeble-mindedness. To what extent, and on what grounds, it ought to be +punished is a question calling for serious reconsideration.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_33'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_33'>[33]</a><div class='note'><p> For Krafft-Ebing's discussion of the subject see <i>Op. cit.</i>, +pp. 530-539.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_34'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_34'>[34]</a><div class='note'><p> In England it is not uncommon to use the term "unnatural +offence;" this is an awkward and possibly misleading practice which should +not be followed. In Germany a similar confusion is caused by applying the +term "sodomy" to these cases as well as to pederasty. Krafft-Ebing +considers that this error is due to the jurists, while the theologians +have always distinguished correctly. In this matter, he adds, science must +be <i>ancilla theologiæ</i> and return to the correct usage of words.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_35'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_35'>[35]</a><div class='note'><p> This childish interest, with later abnormal developments, +may be seen in History I of the Appendix to this volume.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_36'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_36'>[36]</a><div class='note'><p> The Countess of Pembroke, Sir Philip Sidney's sister, +appears to have found sexual enjoyment in the contemplation of the sexual +prowess of stallions. Aubrey writes that she "was very salacious and she +had a contrivance that in the spring of the year ... the stallions ... +were to be brought before such a part of the house where she had a vidette +to look on them." (<i>Short Lives</i>, 1898, vol. i, p. 311.) Although the +modern editor's modesty has caused the disappearance of several lines from +this passage, the general sense is clear. In the same century Burchard, +the faithful secretary of Pope Alexander VI, describes in his invaluable +diary how four race horses were brought to two mares in a court of the +Vatican, the horses clamorously fighting for the possession of the mares +and eventually mounting them, while the Pope and his daughter Lucrezia +looked on from a window "cum magno risu et delectatione." (<i>Diarium</i>, ed +Thuasne, vol. III, p. 169.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_37'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_37'>[37]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, 1902, fasc. ii-iii, p. 338. In +the case of pathological sexuality in a boy of 15, reported by A. +MacDonald, and already summarized, the sight of copulating flies is also +mentioned among many other causes of sexual excitation.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_38'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_38'>[38]</a><div class='note'><p> Krafft-Ebing presents or quotes typical cases of all these +fetiches, <i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 255-266.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_39'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_39'>[39]</a><div class='note'><p> G. Stanley Hall, "A study of Fears," <i>American Journal of +Psychology</i>, 1897, pp. 213-215.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_40'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_40'>[40]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Op. cit.</i>, p. 268.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_41'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_41'>[41]</a><div class='note'><p> W. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," <i>Alienist and Neurologist</i>, +January, 1896. Krafft-Ebing (<i>op. cit.</i>, p. 532) quotes from Boeteau the +somewhat similar case of a gardener's boy of 16—an illegitimate child of +neuropathic heredity and markedly degenerate—who had a passion, of +irresistible and impulsive character, for rabbits. He was declared +irresponsible. Moll (<i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, pp. +431-433) presents the case of a neurotic man who from the age of 15 had +been sexually excited by the sight of animals or by contact with them. He +had repeatedly had connection with cows and mares; he was also sexually +excited by sheep, donkeys, and dogs, whether female or male; the normal +sexual instinct was weak and he experienced very slight attraction to +women.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_42'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_42'>[42]</a><div class='note'><p> Moll also remarks ("Perverse Sexualempfindung," in Senator's +and Kaminer's <i>Krankheiten und Ehe</i>) that in this matter it is often +hardly possible to draw a sharp line between vice and disease.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_43'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_43'>[43]</a><div class='note'><p> Instances of this widespread belief—found among the Tamils +of Ceylon as well as in Europe—are quoted from various authors by Bloch, +<i>Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, Teil II, p. 278, and +Moll, <i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. 700. On the +frequency of bestiality, from one cause or another, in the East, see, +<i>e.g.</i>, Stern, <i>Medizin und Geschlechtsleben in der Türkei</i>, bd. ii, p. +219.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_44'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_44'>[44]</a><div class='note'><p> Sometimes (as among the Aleuts) the animal pantomime dances +of savages may represent the transformation of a captive bird into a +lovely woman who falls exhausted into the arms of the hunter. (H. H. +Bancroft, <i>Native Races of the Pacific</i>, vol. i, p. 93.) A system of +beliefs which accepts the possibility that a human being may be latent in +an animal obviously favors the practice of bestiality.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_45'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_45'>[45]</a><div class='note'><p> For an example of the primitive confusion between the +intercourse of women with animals and with men see, <i>e.g.</i>, Boas, "Sagen +aus British-Columbia," <i>Zeitschrift für Ethnologie</i>, heft V, p. 558.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_46'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_46'>[46]</a><div class='note'><p> Herodotus, Book II, Chapter 46.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_47'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_47'>[47]</a><div class='note'><p> Dulare (<i>Des Divinités Génératrices</i>, Chapter II) brings +together the evidence showing that in Egypt women had connection with the +sacred goat, apparently in order to secure fertility.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_48'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_48'>[48]</a><div class='note'><p> Various facts and references bearing on this subject are +brought together by Blumenbach, <i>Anthropological Memoirs</i>, translated by +Bendyshe, p. 80; Block, <i>Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia +Sexualis</i>, Teil II, pp. 276-283; also Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, +seventh edition, p. 520.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_49'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_49'>[49]</a><div class='note'><p> Mantegazza mentions (<i>Gli Amori degli Uomini</i>, cap V) that +at Rimini a young goatherd of the Apennines, troubled with dyspepsia and +nervous symptoms, told him this was due to excesses with the goats in his +care. A finely executed marble group of a satyr having connection with a +goat, found at Herculaneum and now in the Naples Museum (reproduced in +Fuchs's <i>Erotische Element in der Karikatur</i>), perhaps symbolizes a +traditional and primitive practice of the goatherd.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_50'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_50'>[50]</a><div class='note'><p> Bayle (<i>Dictionary</i>, Art, Bathyllus) quotes various +authorities concerning the Italian auxiliaries in the south of France in +the sixteenth century and their custom of bringing and using goats for +this purpose. Warton in the eighteenth century was informed that in Sicily +priests in confession habitually inquired of herdsmen if they had anything +to do with their sows. In Normandy priests are advised to ask similar +questions.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_51'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_51'>[51]</a><div class='note'><p> It is worth noting that in Greek the work χοιρος +means both a sow and a woman's pudenda; in the <i>Acharnians</i> Aristophanes +plays on this association at some length. The Romans also (as may be +gathered from Varro's <i>De Re Rustica</i>) called the feminine pudenda +<i>porcus</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_52'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_52'>[52]</a><div class='note'><p> Schurig, <i>Gynæcologia</i>, pp. 280-387; Bloch, <i>op. cit.</i>, +270-277. The Arabs, according to Kocher, chiefly practice bestiality with +goats, sheep and mares. The Annamites, according to Mondière, commonly +employ sows and (more especially the young women) dogs. Among the Tamils +of Ceylon bestiality with goats and cows is said to be very prevalent.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_53'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_53'>[53]</a><div class='note'><p> Mantegazza (<i>Gli Amori degli Uomini</i>, cap. V) brings +together some facts bearing on this matter.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_E_V'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_89'></a>V.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Exhibitionism—Illustrative Cases—A Symbolic Perversion of Courtship—The +Impulse to Defile—The Exhibitionist's Psychic Attitude—The Sexual Organs +as Fetichs—Phallus Worship—Adolescent Pride in Sexual +Development—Exhibitionism of the Nates—The Classification of the Forms +of Exhibitionism—Nature of the Relationship of Exhibitionism to Epilepsy.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>There is a remarkable form of erotic symbolism—very definite and standing +clearly apart from all other forms—in which sexual gratification is +experienced in the simple act of exhibiting the sexual organ to persons of +the opposite sex, usually by preference to young and presumably innocent +persons, very often children. This is termed exhibitionism.<a name='5_FNanchor_54'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_54'><sup>[54]</sup></a> It would +appear to be a not very infrequent phenomenon, and most women, once or +more in their lives, especially when young, have encountered a man who has +thus deliberately exposed himself before them.</p> + +<p>The exhibitionist, though often a young and apparently vigorous man, is +always satisfied with the mere act of self-exhibition and the emotional +reaction which that act produces; he makes no demands on the woman to whom +he exposes himself; he seldom speaks, he makes no effort to approach her; +as a rule, he fails even to display the signs of sexual excitation. His +desires are completely gratified by the act of exhibition and by the +emotional reaction it arouses in the woman. He departs satisfied and +relieved.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>A case recorded by Schrenck-Notzing very well represents both the + nature of the impulse felt by the exhibitionist and the way in + which it may originate. It is the case of a business man of 49, + of neurotic <a name='5_Page_90'></a>heredity, an affectionate husband and father of a + family, who, to his own grief and shame, is compelled from time + to time to exhibit his sexual organs to women in the street. As a + boy of 10 a girl of 12 tried to induce him to coitus; both had + their sexual parts exposed. From that time sexual contacts, as of + his own naked nates against those of a girl, became attractive, + as well as games in which the boys and girls in turn marched + before each other with their sexual parts exposed, and also + imitation of the copulation of animals. Coitus was first + practiced about the age of 20, but sight and touch of the woman's + sexual parts were always necessary to produce sexual excitement. + It was also necessary—and this consideration is highly important + as regards the development of the tendency to exhibition—that + the woman should be excited by the sight of his organs. Even when + he saw or touched a woman's parts orgasm often occurred. It was + the naked sexual organs in an otherwise clothed body which + chiefly excited him. He was not possessed of a high degree of + potency. Girls between the ages of 10 and 17 chiefly excited him, + and especially if he felt that they were quite ignorant of sexual + matters. His self-exhibition was a sort of psychic defloration, + and it was accompanied by the idea that other people felt as he + did about the sexual effects of the naked organs, that he was + shocking but at the same time sexually exciting a young girl. He + was thus gratifying himself through the belief that he was + causing sexual gratification to an innocent girl. This man was + convicted several times, and was finally declared to be suffering + from impulsive insanity. (Schrenck-Notzing, + <i>Kriminal-psychologische und Psycho-pathologische Studien</i>, 1902, + pp. 50-57.) In another case of Schrenck-Notzing's, an actor and + portrait painter, aged 31, in youth masturbated and was fond of + contemplating the images of the sexual organs of both sexes, + finding little pleasure in coitus. At the age of 24, at a bathing + establishment, he happened to occupy a compartment next to that + occupied by a lady, and when naked he became aware that his + neighbor was watching him through a chink in the partition. This + caused him powerful excitement and he was obliged to masturbate. + Ever since he has had an impulse to exhibit his organs and to + masturbate in the presence of women. He believes that the sight + of his organs excites the woman (<i>Ib.</i>, pp. 57-68). The presence + of masturbation in this case renders it untypical as a case of + exhibitionism. Moll at one time went so far as to assert that + when masturbation takes place we are not entitled to admit + exhibitionism, (<i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, + p. 661), but now accepts exhibitionism with masturbation + ("Perverse Sexualempfindung," <i>Krankheiten und Ehe</i>). The act of + exhibition itself gratifies the sexual impulse, and usually it + suffices to replace both tumescence and detumescence.</p> + +<p> A fairly typical case, recorded by Krafft-Ebing, is that of a + German factory worker of 37, a good, sober and intelligent + workman. His <a name='5_Page_91'></a>parents were healthy, but one of his mother's and + also one of his father's sisters were insane; some of his + relatives are eccentric in religion. He has a languishing + expression and a smile of self-complacency. He never had any + severe illness, but has always been eccentric and imaginative, + much absorbed in romances (such as Dumas's novels) and fond of + identifying himself with their heroes. No signs of epilepsy. In + youth moderate masturbation, later moderate coitus. He lives a + retired life, but is fond of elegant dress and of ornament. + Though not a drinker, he sometimes makes himself a kind of punch + which has a sexually exciting effect on him. The impulse to + exhibitionism has only developed in recent years. When the + impulse is upon him he becomes hot, his heart beats violently, + the blood rushes to his head, and he is oblivious of everything + around him that is not connected with his own act. Afterwards he + regards himself as a fool and makes vain resolutions never to + repeat the act. In exhibition the penis is only half erect and + ejaculation never occurs. (He is only capable of coitus with a + woman who shows great attraction to him.) He is satisfied with + self-exhibition, and believes that he thus gives pleasure to the + woman, since he himself receives pleasure in contemplating a + woman's sexual parts. His erotic dreams are of self-exhibition to + young and voluptuous women. He had been previously punished for + an offense of this kind; medico-legal opinion now recognized the + incriminated man's psychopathic condition. (Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. + cit.</i>, pp. 492-494.)</p> + +<p> Trochon has reported the case of a married man of 33, a worker in + a factory, who for several years had exhibited himself at + intervals to shop-girls, etc., in a state of erection, but + without speaking or making other advances. He was a hard-working, + honest, sober man of quiet habits, a good father to his family + and happy at home. He showed not the slightest sign of insanity. + But he was taciturn, melancholic and nervous; a sister was an + idiot. He was arrested, but on the report of the experts that he + committed these acts from a morbid impulse he could not control + he was released. (Trochon, <i>Archives de l'Anthropologie + Criminelle</i>, 1888, p. 256.)</p> + +<p> In a case of Freyer's (<i>Zeitschrift für Medizinalbeamte</i>, third + year, No. 8) the occasional connection of exhibitionism with + epilepsy is well illustrated by a barber's assistant, aged 35, + whose father suffered from chronic alcoholism and was also said + to have committed the same kind of offense as his son. The mother + and a sister suffered nervously. From ages of 7 to 18 the subject + had epileptic convulsions. From 16 to 21 he indulged in normal + sexual intercourse. At about that time he had often to pass a + playground and at times would urinate there; it happened that the + children watched him with curiosity. He noticed that when thus + watched sexual excitement was caused, inducing erection and even + ejaculation. He gradually found pleasure in this kind of <a name='5_Page_92'></a>sexual + gratification; finally he became indifferent to coitus. His + erotic dreams, though still usually about normal coitus, were now + sometimes concerned with exhibition before little girls. When + overcome by the impulse he could see and hear nothing around him, + though he did not lose consciousness. After the act was over he + was troubled by his deed. In all other respects he was entirely + reasonable. He was imprisoned many times for exhibiting himself + to young schoolgirls, sometimes vaunting the beauty of his organs + and inviting inspection. On one occasion he underwent mental + examination, but was considered to be mentally sound. He was + finally held to be a hereditarily tainted individual with + neuropathic constitution. The head was abnormally broad, penis + small, patellar reflex absent, and there were many signs of + neurasthenia. (Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 490-492.)</p> + +<p> The prevalence of epilepsy among exhibitionists is shown by the + observations of Pelanda in Verona. He has recorded six cases of + this perversion, all of which eventually reached the asylum and + were either epileptics or with epileptic relations. One had a + brother who was also an exhibitionist. In some cases the penis + was abnormally large, in others abnormally small. Several had + very weak sexual impulse; one, at the age of 62, had never + effected coitus, and was proud of the fact that he was still a + virgin, considering, he would say, the epoch of demoralization in + which we live. (Pelanda, "Pornopatici," <i>Archivio di + Psichiatria</i>, fasc. ii-iv, 1889.)</p> + +<p> In a very typical case of exhibitionism which Garnier has + recorded, a certain X., a gentleman engaged in business in Paris, + had a predilection for exhibiting himself in churches, more + especially in Saint-Roch. He was arrested several times for + exposing his sexual organs here before ladies in prayer. In this + way he finally ruined his commercial position in Paris and was + obliged to establish himself in a small provincial town. Here + again he soon exposed himself in a church and was again sent to + prison, but on his liberation immediately performed the same act + in the same church in what was described as a most imperturbable + manner. Compelled to leave the town, he returned to Paris, and in + a few weeks' time was again arrested for repeating his old + offense in Saint Roch. When examined by Garnier, the information + he supplied was vague and incomplete, and he was very embarrassed + in the attempt to explain himself. He was unable to say why he + chose a church, but he felt that it was to a church that he must + go. He had, however, no thought of profanation and no wish to + give offense. "Quite the contrary!" he declared. He had the sad + and tired air of a man who is dominated by a force stronger than + his will. "I know," he added, "what repulsion my conduct must + inspire. Why am I made thus? Who will cure me?" (P. Garnier, + "Perversions Sexuelles," <i>Comptes Rendus</i>, International Congress + of Medicine at Paris in 1900, <i>Section de Psychiatrie</i>, pp. + 433-435.)</p><a name='5_Page_93'></a> + +<p> In some cases, it would appear, the impulse to exhibitionism may + be overcome or may pass away. This result is the more likely to + come about in those cases in which exhibitionism has been largely + conditioned by chronic alcoholism or other influences tending to + destroy the inhibiting and restraining action of the higher + centers, which may be overcome by hygiene and treatment. In this + connection I may bring forward a case which has been communicated + to me by a medical correspondent in London. It is that of an + actor, of high standing in his profession and extremely + intelligent, 49 years of age, married and father of a large + family. He is sexually vigorous and of erotic temperament. His + general health has always been good, but he is a high-strung, + neurotic man, with quick mental reactions. His habits had for a + long time been decidedly alcoholic, but two years ago, a small + quantity of albumen being found in the urine, he was persuaded to + leave off alcohol, and has since been a teetotaller. Though + ordinarily very reticent about sexual matters, he began four or + five years ago to commit acts of exhibitionism, exposing himself + to servants in the house and occasionally to women in the + country. This continued after the alcohol had been abandoned and + lasted for several years, though the attention of the police was + never attracted to the matter, and so far as possible he was + quietly supervised by his friends. Nine months after, the acts of + exhibitionism ceased, apparently in a spontaneous manner, and + there has so far been no relapse.</p></div> + +<p>Exhibitionism is an act which, on the face of it, seems nonsensical and +meaningless, and as such, as an inexplicable act of madness, it has +frequently been treated both by writers on insanity and on sexual +perversion. "These acts are so lacking in common sense and intelligent +reflection that no other reason than insanity can be offered for the +patient," Ball concluded.<a name='5_FNanchor_55'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_55'><sup>[55]</sup></a> Moll, also, who defines exhibitionism +somewhat too narrowly as a condition in which "the charm of the exhibition +lies for the subject in the display itself," not sufficiently taking into +consideration the imagined effect on the spectator, concludes that "the +psychological basis of exhibitionism is at present by no means cleared +up."<a name='5_FNanchor_56'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_56'><sup>[56]</sup></a></p> + +<p>We may probably best approach exhibitionism by regarding it as +fundamentally a symbolic act based on a perversion of courtship. The +exhibitionist displays the organ of sex to a <a name='5_Page_94'></a>feminine witness, and in the +shock of modest sexual shame by which she reacts to that spectacle, he +finds a gratifying similitude of the normal emotions of coitus.<a name='5_FNanchor_57'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_57'><sup>[57]</sup></a> He +feels that he has effected a psychic defloration.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Exhibitionism is thus analogous, and, indeed, related, to the + impulse felt by many persons to perform indecorous acts or tell + indecent stories before young and innocent persons of the + opposite sex. This is a kind of psychic exhibitionism, the + gratification it causes lying exactly, as in physical + exhibitionism, in the emotional confusion which it is felt to + arouse. The two kinds of exhibitionism may be combined in the + same person: Thus, in a case reported by Hoche (p. 97), the + exhibitionist an intellectual and highly educated man, with a + doctor's degree, also found pleasure in sending indecent poems + and pictures to women, whom, however, he made no attempt to + seduce; he was content with the thought of the emotions he + aroused or believed that he aroused.</p> + +<p> It is possible that within this group should come the agent in + the following incident which was lately observed by a lady, a + friend of my own. An elderly man in an overcoat was seen standing + outside a large and well-known draper's shop in the outskirts of + London; when able to attract the attention of any of the + shop-girls or of any girl in the street he would fling back his + coat and reveal that he was wearing over his own clothes a + woman's chemise (or possibly bodice) and a woman's drawers; there + was no exposure. The only intelligible explanation of this action + would seem to be that pleasure was experienced in the mild shock + of interested surprise and injured modesty which this vision was + imagined to cause to a young girl. It would thus be a + comparatively innocent form of psychic defloration.</p></div> + +<p>It is of interest to point out that the sexual symbolism of active +flagellation is very closely analogous to this symbolism of exhibitionism. +The flagellant approaches a woman with the rod (itself a symbol of the +penis and in some countries bearing names which are also applied to that +organ) and inflicts on an <a name='5_Page_95'></a>intimate part of her body the signs of blushing +and the spasmodic movements which are associated with sexual excitement, +while at the same time she feels, or the flagellant imagines that she +feels, the corresponding emotions of delicious shame.<a name='5_FNanchor_58'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_58'><sup>[58]</sup></a> This is an even +closer mimicry of the sexual act than the exhibitionist attains, for the +latter fails to secure the consent of the woman nor does he enjoy any +intimate contact with her naked body. The difference is connected with the +fact that the active flagellant is usually a more virile and normal person +than the exhibitionist. In the majority of cases the exhibitionist's +sexual impulse is very feeble, and as a rule he is either to some degree a +degenerate, or else a person who is suffering from an early stage of +general paralysis, dementia, or some other highly enfeebling cause of +mental disorganization, such as chronic alcoholism. Sexual feebleness is +further indicated by the fact that the individuals selected as witnesses +are frequently mere children.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It seems probable that a form of erotic symbolism somewhat + similar to exhibitionism is to be found in the rare cases in + which sexual gratification is derived from throwing ink, acid or + other defiling liquids on women's dresses. Thoinot has recorded a + case of this kind (<i>Attentats aux Moeurs</i>, 1898, pp. 484, <i>et + seq.</i>). An instructive case has been presented by Moll. In this + case a young man of somewhat neuropathic heredity had as a youth + of 16 or 17, when romping with his young sister's playfellows, + experienced sexual sensations on chancing to see their white + underlinen. From that time white underlinen and white dresses + became to him a fetich and he was only attracted to women so + attired. One day, at the age of 25, when crossing the street in + wet weather with a young lady in a white dress, a passing vehicle + splashed the dress with mud. This incident caused him strong + sexual excitement, and from that time he had the impulse to throw + ink, perchloride of iron, etc., on to ladies' white dresses, and + sometimes to cut and tear them, sexual excitement and ejaculation + taking place every time he effected this. (Moll, "Gutachten über + einem Sexual Perversen [Besudelungstrieb]," <i>Zeitschrift für + Medizinalbeamte</i>, Heft XIII, 1900). Such a case is of + considerable psychological interest. Thoinot considers that in + these cases the fleck is a fetich. That is an incorrect account + of the matter. In this case the <a name='5_Page_96'></a>white garments constituted the + primary fetich, but that fetich becomes more acutely realized, + and at the same time both parties are thrown into an emotional + state which to the fetichist becomes a mimicry of coitus, by the + act of defilement. We may perhaps connect with this phenomenon + the attraction which muddy shoes often exert over the + shoe-fetichist, and the curious way in which, as we have seen (p. + 18), Restif de la Bretonne associates his love of neatness in + women with his attraction to the feet, the part, he remarks, + least easy to keep clean.</p> + +<p> Garnier applied the term <i>sadi-fetichism</i> to active flagellation + and many similar manifestations such as we are here concerned + with, on the grounds that they are hybrids which combine the + morbid adoration for a definite object with the impulse to + exercise a more or less degree of violence. From the standpoint + of the conception of erotic symbolism I have adopted there is no + need for this term. There is here no hybrid combination of two + unlike mental states. We are simply concerned with states of + erotic symbolism, more or less complete, more or less complex.</p></div> + +<p>The conception of exhibitionism as a process of erotic symbolism, involves +a conscious or unconscious attitude of attention in the exhibitionist's +mind to the psychic reaction of the woman toward whom his display is +directed. He seeks to cause an emotion which, probably in most cases, he +desires should be pleasurable. But from one cause or another his finer +sensibilities are always inhibited or in abeyance, and he is unable to +estimate accurately either the impression he is likely to produce or the +general results of his action, or else he is moved by a strong impulsive +obsession which overpowers his judgment. In many cases he has good reason +for believing that his act will be pleasurable, and frequently he finds +complacent witnesses among the low-class servant girls, etc.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It may be pointed out here that we are quite justified in + speaking of a penis-fetichism and also of a vulva-fetichism. This + might be questioned. We are obviously justified in recognizing a + fetichism which attaches itself to the pubic hair, or, as in a + case with which I am acquainted, to the clitoris, but it may seem + that we cannot regard the central sexual organs as symbols of + sex, symbols, as it were, of themselves. Properly regarded, + however, it is the sexual act rather than the sexual organ which + is craved in normal sexual desire; the organ is regarded merely + as the means and not as the end. Regarded as a means the organ is + indeed an object of desire, but it only becomes a fetich when it + arrests and fixes the attention. An attention thus pleasurably + fixed, a vulva-fetichism or a penis-fetichism, is within the + normal range <a name='5_Page_97'></a>of sexual emotion (this point has been mentioned in + the previous volume when discussing the part played by the + primary sexual organs in sexual selection), and in coarse-grained + natures of either sex it is a normal allurement in its + generalized shape, apart from any attraction to the person to + whom the organs belong. In some morbid cases, however, this + penis-fetichism may become a fully developed sexual perversion. A + typical case of this kind has been recorded by Howard in the + United States. Mrs. W., aged 39, was married at 20 to a strong, + healthy man, but derived no pleasure from coitus, though she + received great pleasure from masturbation practiced immediately + after coitus, and nine years after marriage she ceased actual + coitus, compelling her husband to adopt mutual masturbation. She + would introduce men into the house at all times of the day or + night, and after persuading them to expose their persons would + retire to her room to masturbate. The same man never aroused + desire more than once. This desire became so violent and + persistent that she would seek out men in all sorts of public + places and, having induced them to expose themselves, rapidly + retreat to the nearest convenient spot for self-gratification. + She once abstracted a pair of trousers she had seen a man wear + and after fondling them experienced the orgasm. Her husband + finally left her, after vainly attempting to have her confined in + an asylum. She was often arrested for her actions, but through + the intervention of friends set free again. She was a highly + intelligent woman, and apart from this perversion entirely + normal. (W. L. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," <i>Alienist and + Neurologist</i>, January, 1896.) It is on the existence of a more or + less developed penis-fetichism of this kind that the + exhibitionist, mostly by an ignorant instinct, relies for the + effects he desires to produce.</p></div> + +<p>The exhibitionist is not usually content to produce a mere titillated +amusement; he seeks to produce a more powerful effect which must be +emotional whether or not it is pleasurable. A professional man in +Strassburg (in a case reported by Hoche<a name='5_FNanchor_59'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_59'><sup>[59]</sup></a>) would walk about in the +evening in a long cloak, and when he met ladies would suddenly throw his +cloak back under a street lamp, or igniting a red-fire match, and thus +exhibit his organs. There was an evident effort—on the part of a weak, +vain, and effeminate man—to produce a maximum of emotional effect. The +attempt to heighten the emotional shock is also seen in the fact that the +exhibitionist frequently chooses a church as the scene of his exploits, +not during service, for he <a name='5_Page_98'></a>always avoids a concourse of people, but +perhaps toward evening when there are only a few kneeling women scattered +through the edifice. The church is chosen, often instinctively rather than +deliberately, from no impulse to commit a sacrilegious outrage—which, as +a rule, the exhibitionist does not feel his act to be—but because it +really presents the conditions most favorable to the act and the effects +desired. The exhibitionist's attitude of mind is well illustrated by one +of Garnier's patients who declared that he never wished to be seen by more +than two women at once, "just what is necessary," he added, "for an +exchange of impressions." After each exhibition he would ask himself +anxiously: "Did they see me? What are they thinking? What do they say to +each other about me? Oh! how I should like to know!" Another patient of +Garnier's, who haunted churches for this purpose, made this very +significant statement: "Why do I like going to churches? I can scarcely +say. <i>But I know that it is only there that my act has its full +importance</i>. The woman is in a devout frame of mind, and she must see that +such an act in such a place is not a joke in bad taste or a disgusting +obscenity; <i>that if I go there it is not to amuse myself; it is more +serious than that!</i> I watch the effect produced on the faces of the ladies +to whom I show my organs. I wish to see them express a profound joy. I +wish, in fact, that they may be forced to say to themselves: <i>How +impressive Nature is when thus seen!</i>"</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Here we trace the presence of a feeling which recalls the + phenomena of the ancient and world-wide phallic worship, still + liable to reappear sporadically. Women sometimes took part in + these rites, and the osculation of the male sexual organ or its + emblematic representation by women is easily traceable in the + phallic rites of India and many other lands, not excluding Europe + even in comparatively recent times. (Dulaure in his <i>Divinités + Génératices</i> brings together much bearing on these points; <i>cf.</i>: + Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. i, Chapter XVII, and Bloch, + <i>Beiträge zur Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, Teil I, pp. 115-117. Colin + Scott has some interesting remarks on phallic worship and the + part it has played in aiding human evolution, "Sex and Art," + <i>American Journal of Psychology</i>, vol. vii, No. 2, pp. 191-197. + Irving Rosse describes some modern phallic rites in which both + men and women took part, similar to those practiced in vaudouism, + "Sexual Hypochondriasis," <i>Virginia Medical Monthly</i>, October, + 1892.)</p><a name='5_Page_99'></a> + +<p> Putting aside any question of phallic worship, a certain pride + and more or less private feeling of ostentation in the new + expansion and development of the organs of virility seems to be + almost normal at adolescence. "We have much reason to assume," + Stanley Hall remarks, "that in a state of nature there is a + certain instinctive pride and ostentation that accompanies the + new local development. I think it will be found that + exhibitionists are usually those who have excessive growth here, + and that much that modern society stigmatizes as obscene is at + bottom more or less spontaneous and perhaps in some cases not + abnormal. Dr. Seerley tells me he has never examined a young man + largely developed who had the usual strong instinctive tendency + of modesty to cover himself with his hands, but he finds this + instinct general with those whose development is less than the + average." (G. Stanley Hall, <i>Adolescence</i>, vol. ii, p. 97.) This + instinct of ostentation, however, so far as it is normal, is held + in check by other considerations, and is not, in the strict + sense, exhibitionism. I have observed a full-grown telegraph boy + walking across Hampstead Heath with his sexual organs exposed, + but immediately he realized that he was seen he concealed them. + The solemnity of exhibitionism at this age finds expression in + the climax of the sonnet, "Oraison du Soir," written at 16 by + Rimbaud, whose verse generally is a splendid and insolent + manifestation of rank adolescence:—</p></div> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span class='i4'>"Doux comme le Seigneur du cèdre et des hysopes,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>Je pisse vers les cieux bruns très haut et très loin,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>Avec l'assentiment des grands héliotropes."<br /></span> +</div><div class='stanza'> +<span class='i4'>(J. A. Rimbaud, <i>Œuvres</i>, p. 68.)<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In women, also, there would appear to be traceable a somewhat + similar ostentation, though in them it is complicated and largely + inhibited by modesty, and at the same time diffused over the body + owing to the absence of external sexual organs. "Primitive + woman," remarks Madame Renooz, "proud of her womanhood, for a + long time defended her nakedness which ancient art has always + represented. And in the actual life of the young girl to-day + there is a moment when by a secret atavism she feels the pride of + her sex, the intuition of her moral superiority, and cannot + understand why she must hide its cause. At this moment, wavering + between the laws of Nature and social conventions, she scarcely + knows if nakedness should or should not affright her. A sort of + confused atavistic memory recalls to her a period before clothing + was known, and reveals to her as a paradisaical ideal the customs + of that human epoch." (Céline Renooz, <i>Psychologie Comparée de + l'Homme et de la Femme</i>, p. 85.) It may be added that among + primitive peoples, and even among some remote European + populations to-day, the exhibition of feminine nudity has + sometimes been regarded as a spectacle with religious or magic + operation. (Ploss, <i>Das Weib</i>, seventh edition, vol. ii, <a name='5_Page_100'></a>pp. + 663-680; Havelock Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i>, fourth edition, p. + 304.) It is stated by Gopcevic that in the long struggle between + the Albanians and the Montenegrians the women of the former + people would stand in the front rank and expose themselves by + raising their skirts, believing that they would thus insure + victory. As, however, they were shot down, and as, moreover, + victory usually fell to the Montenegrians, this custom became + discredited. (Quoted by Bloch, <i>Op. cit.</i>, Teil II, p. 307.)</p> + +<p> With regard to the association, suggested by Stanley Hall, + between exhibitionism and an unusual degree of development of the + sexual organs, it must be remarked that both extremes—a very + large and a very small penis—are specially common in + exhibitionists. The prevalence of the small organ is due to an + association of exhibitionism with sexual feebleness. The + prevalence of the large organ may be due to the cause suggested + by Hall. Among Mahommedans the sexual organs are sometimes + habitually exposed by religious penitents, and I note that + Bernhard Stern, in his book on the medical and sexual aspects of + life in Turkey, referring to a penitent of this sort whom he saw + on the Stamboul bridge at Constantinople, remarks that the organ + was very largely developed. It may well be in such a case that + the penitent's religious attitude is reinforced by some lingering + relic of a more fleshly ostentation.</p></div> + +<p>It is by a pseudo-atavism that this phallicism is evoked in the +exhibitionist. There is no true emergence of an ancestrally inherited +instinct, but by the paralysis or inhibition of the finer and higher +feelings current in civilization, the exhibitionist is placed on the same +mental level as the man of a more primitive age, and he thus presents the +basis on which the impulses belonging to a higher culture may naturally +take root and develop.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Reference may here be made to a form of primitive exhibitionism, + almost confined to women, which, although certainly symbolic, is + absolutely non-sexual, and must not, therefore, be confused with + the phenomena we are here occupied with. I refer to the + exhibition of the buttocks as a mark of contempt. In its most + primitive form, no doubt, this exhibitionism is a kind of + exorcism, a method of putting evil spirits, primarily, and + secondarily evil-disposed persons, to flight. It is the most + effective way for a woman to display sexual centers, and it + shares in the magical virtues which all unveiling of the sexual + centers is believed by primitive peoples to possess. It is + recorded that the women of some peoples in the Balkan peninsula + formerly used this gesture against enemies in battle. In the + sixteenth century so distinguished a theologian as Luther when + assailed by the Evil One at night was able to put the adversary + to flight by protruding his uncovered buttocks <a name='5_Page_101'></a>from the bed. But + the spiritual significance of this attitude is lost with the + decay of primitive beliefs. It survives, but merely as a gesture + of insult. The symbolism comes to have reference to the nates as + the excretory focus, the seat of the anus. In any case it ignores + any sexual attractiveness in this part of the body. Exhibitionism + of this kind, therefore, can scarcely arise in persons of any + sensitiveness or æsthetic perception, even putting aside the + question of modesty, and there seems to be little trace of it in + classic antiquity when the nates were regarded as objects of + beauty. Among the Egyptians, however, we gather from Herodotus + (Bk. II, Chapter LX) that at a certain popular religious festival + men and women would go in boats on the Nile, singing and playing, + and when they approached a town the women on the boats would + insult the women of the town by injurious language and by + exposing themselves. Among the Arabs, however, the specific + gesture we are concerned with is noted, and a man to whom + vengeance is forbidden would express his feelings by exposing his + posterior and strewing earth on his head (Wellhausen, <i>Rests + Arabischen Heidentums</i>, 1897, p. 195). It is in Europe and in + mediæval and later times that this emphatic gesture seems to have + flourished as a violent method of expressing contempt. It was by + no means confined to the lower classes, and Kleinpaul, in + discussing this form of "speech without words," quotes examples + of various noble persons, even princesses, who are recorded thus + to have expressed their feelings. (Kleinpaul, <i>Sprache ohne + Worte</i>, pp. 271-273.) In more recent times the gesture has become + merely a rare and extreme expression of unrestrained feeling in + coarse-grained peasants. Zola, in the figure of Mouquette in + <i>Germinal</i>, may be said to have given a kind of classic + expression to the gesture. In the more remote parts of Europe it + appears to be still not altogether uncommon. This seems to be + notably the case among the South Slavs, and Krauss states that + "when a South Slav woman wishes to express her deepest contempt + for anyone she bends forward, with left hand raising her skirts, + and with the right slapping her posterior, at the same time + exclaiming: 'This for you!'" (Κρυπτάδια, vol. vi, p. + 200.)</p> + +<p> A verbal survival of this gesture, consisting in the contemptuous + invitation to kiss this region, still exists among us in remote + parts of the country, especially as an insult offered by an angry + woman who forgets herself. It is said to be commonly used in + Wales. ("Welsh Ædœlogy," Κρυπτάδια, vol. ii, + pp. 358, <i>et seq.</i>) In Cornwall, when addressed by a woman to a + man it is sometimes regarded as a deadly insult, even if the + woman is young and attractive, and may cause a life-long enmity + between related families. From this point of view the nates are a + symbol of contempt, and any sexual significance is excluded. (The + distinction is brought out by Diderot in <i>Le Neveu de Rameau:</i> + "<i>Lui:</i>—Il y a d'autres jours ou il ne m'en coûterait rien pour + être vil tant <a name='5_Page_102'></a>qu'on voudrait; ces jours-là, pour un liard, je + baiserais le cul à la petite Hus. <i>Moi:</i>—Eh! mais, l'ami, elle + est blanche, jolie, douce, potelée, et c'est un acte d'humilité + auquel un plus delicat que vous pourrait quelquefois s'abaisser. + <i>Lui:</i>—Entendons-nous; c'est qu'il y a baiser le cul au simple, + et baiser le cul au figuré.")</p> + +<p> It must be added that a sexual form of exhibitionism of the nates + must still be recognized. It occurs in masochism and expresses + the desire for passive flagellation. Rousseau, whose emotional + life was profoundly affected by the castigations which as a child + he received from Mlle Lambercier, has in his <i>Confessions</i> told + us how, when a youth, he would sometimes expose himself in this + way in the presence of young women. Such masochistic + exhibitionism seems, however, to be rare.</p></div> + +<p>While the manifestations of exhibitionism are substantially the same in +all cases, there are many degrees and varieties of the condition. We may +find among exhibitionists, as Garnier remarks, dementia, states of +unconsciousness, epilepsy, general paralysis, alcoholism, but the most +typical cases, he adds, if not indeed the cases to which the term properly +belongs, are those in which it is an impulsive obsession. Krafft-Ebing<a name='5_FNanchor_60'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_60'><sup>[60]</sup></a> +divides exhibitionists into four clinical groups: (1) acquired states of +mental weakness, with cerebral or spinal disease clouding consciousness +and at the same time causing impotence; (2) epileptics, in whom the act is +an abnormal organic impulse performed in a state of imperfect +consciousness; (3) a somewhat allied group of neurasthenic cases; (4) +periodical impulsive cases with deep hereditary taint. This classification +is not altogether satisfactory. Garnier's classification, placing the +group of obsessional cases in the foreground and leaving the other more +vaguely defined groups in the background, is probably better. I am +inclined to consider that most of the cases fall into one or other of two +mixed groups. The first class includes cases in which there is more or +less congenital abnormality, but otherwise a fair or even complete degree +of mental integrity; they are usually young adults, they are more or less +precisely conscious of the end they wish to attain, and it is often only +with a severe struggle that they yield to their impulses. In the second +class the <a name='5_Page_103'></a>beginnings of mental or nervous disease have diminished the +sensibility of the higher centers; the subjects are usually old men whose +lives have been absolutely correct; they are often only vaguely aware of +the nature of the satisfaction they are seeking, and frequently no +struggle precedes the manifestation; such was the case of the overworked +clergyman described by Hughes,<a name='5_FNanchor_61'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_61'><sup>[61]</sup></a> who, after much study, became morose +and absent-minded, and committed acts of exhibitionism which he could not +explain but made no attempt to deny; with rest and restorative treatment +his health improved and the acts ceased. It is in the first class of cases +alone that there is a developed sexual perversion. In the cases of the +second class there is a more or less definite sexual intention, but it is +only just conscious, and the emergence of the impulse is due not to its +strength but to the weakness, temporary or permanent, of the higher +inhibiting centers.</p> + +<p>Epileptic cases, with loss of consciousness during the act, can only be +regarded as presenting a pseudo-exhibitionism. They should be excluded +altogether. It is undoubtedly true that many cases of real or apparent +exhibitionism occur in epileptics.<a name='5_FNanchor_62'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_62'><sup>[62]</sup></a> We must not, however, too hastily +conclude that because these acts occur in epileptics they are necessarily +unconscious acts. Epilepsy frequently occurs on a basis of hereditary +degeneration, and the exhibitionism may be, and not infrequently is, a +stigma of the degeneracy and not an indication of the occurrence of a +minor epileptic fit. When the act of pseudo-exhibitionism is truly +epileptic, it will usually have no psychic sexual content, and it will +certainly be liable to occur under all sorts of circumstances, when the +patient is alone or in a miscellaneous concourse of people. It will be on +a level with the acts of the highly respectable young woman who, at the +conclusion of an attack of <i>petit mal</i>, consisting chiefly of a sudden +desire to pass urine, on <a name='5_Page_104'></a>one occasion lifted up her clothes and urinated +at a public entertainment, so that it was with difficulty her friends +prevented her from being handed over to the police.<a name='5_FNanchor_63'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_63'><sup>[63]</sup></a> Such an act is +automatic, unconscious, and involuntary; the spectators are not even +perceived; it cannot be an act of exhibitionism. Whenever, on the other +hand, the place and the time are evidently chosen deliberately,—a quiet +spot, the presence of only one or two young women or children,—it is +difficult to admit that we are in the presence of a fit of epileptic +unconsciousness, even when the subject is known to be epileptic.</p> + +<p>Even, however, when we exclude those epileptic pseudo-exhibitionists who, +from the legal point of view, are clearly irresponsible, it must still be +remembered that in every case of exhibitionism there is a high degree of +either mental abnormality on a neuropathic basis, or else of actual +disease. This is true to a greater extent in exhibitionism than in almost +any other form of sexual perversion. No subject of exhibitionism should be +sent to prison without expert medical examination.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_54'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_54'>[54]</a><div class='note'><p> Lasège first drew attention to this sexual perversion and +gave it its generally accepted name, "Les Exhibitionistes," <i>L'Union +Médicale</i>, May, 1877. Magnan, on various occasions (for example, "Les +Exhibitionistes," <i>Archives de l'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, vol. v, 1890, +p. 456), has given further development and precision to the clinical +picture of the exhibitionist.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_55'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_55'>[55]</a><div class='note'><p> B. Ball. <i>La Folie Erotique</i>, p. 86.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_56'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_56'>[56]</a><div class='note'><p> Moll, <i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. +661.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_57'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_57'>[57]</a><div class='note'><p> "Exhibitionism in its most typical form is," Garnier truly +says, "a <i>systematic act</i>, manifesting itself as the <i>strange equivalent +of a sexual connection</i>, or its <i>substitution</i>." The brief account of +exhibitionism (pp. 433-437) in Garnier's discussion of "Perversions +Sexuelles" at the International Medical Congress at Paris in 1900 +(<i>Section de Psychiatrie: Comptes-Rendus</i>) is the most satisfactory +statement of the psychological aspects of this perversion with which I am +acquainted. Garnier's unrivalled clinical knowledge of these +manifestations, due to his position during many years as physician at the +Depôt of the Prefecture of Police in Paris, adds great weight to his +conclusions.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_58'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_58'>[58]</a><div class='note'><p> The symbolism of coitus involved in flagellation has been +touched on by Eulenburg (<i>Sexuale Neuropathie</i>, p. 121), and is more fully +developed by Dühren (<i>Geschlechtsleben in England</i>, bd. ii, pp. 366, <i>et +seq.</i>).</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_59'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_59'>[59]</a><div class='note'><p> A. Hoche, <i>Neurologische Centralblatt</i>, 1896, No. 2.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_60'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_60'>[60]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 478, <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_61'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_61'>[61]</a><div class='note'><p> C. H. Hughes, "Morbid Exhibitionism," <i>Alienist and +Neurologist</i>, August, 1904. Another somewhat similar American case, also +preceded by overwork, and eventually adjudged insane by the courts, is +recorded by D. S. Booth, <i>Alienist and Neurologist</i>, February, 1905.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_62'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_62'>[62]</a><div class='note'><p> Exhibitionism in epilepsy is briefly discussed by Féré, +<i>L'Instinct Sexuel</i>, second edition, pp. 194-195.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_63'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_63'>[63]</a><div class='note'><p> W. S. Colman, "Post-Epileptic Unconscious Automatic Actions," +<i>Lancet</i>, July 5, 1890.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_E_VI'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_105'></a>VI.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Forms of Erotic Symbolism are Simulacra of Coitus—Wide Extension of +Erotic Symbolism—Fetichism Not Covering the Whole Ground of Sexual +Selection—It is Based on the Individual Factor in +Selection—Crystallization—The Lover and the Artist—The Key to Erotic +Symbolism to be Found in the Emotional Sphere—The Passage to Pathological +Extremes.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>We have now examined several very various and yet very typical +manifestations in all of which it is not difficult to see how, in some +strange and eccentric form—on a basis of association through resemblance +or contiguity or both combined—there arises a definite mimicry of the +normal sexual act together with the normal emotions which accompany that +act. It has become clear in what sense we are justified in recognizing +erotic symbolism.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The symbolic and, as it were, abstracted nature of these + manifestations is shown by the remarkable way in which they are + sometimes capable of transference from the object to the subject. + That is to say that the fetichist may show a tendency to + cultivate his fetich in his own person. A foot-fetichist may like + to go barefoot himself; a man who admired lame women liked to + halt himself; a man who was attracted by small waists in women + found sexual gratification in tight-lacing himself; a man who was + fascinated by fine white skin and wished to cut it found + satisfaction in cutting his own skin; Moll's coprolagnic + fetichist found a voluptuous pleasure in his own acts of + defecation. (See, <i>e.g.</i>, Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. cit.</i>, p. 221, 224, + 226; Hammond, <i>Sexual Impotence</i>, p. 74; <i>cf.</i> <i>ante</i>, p. 68.) + Such symbolic transference seems to have a profoundly natural + basis, for we may see a somewhat similar phenomenon in the + well-known tendency of cows to mount a cow in heat. This would + appear to be, not so much a homosexual impulse, as the dynamic + psychic action of an olfactory sexual symbol in a transformed + form.</p> + +<p> We seem to have here a psychic process which is a curious + reversal of that process of <i>Einfühlung</i>—the projection of one's + own activities into the object contemplated—which Lipps has so + fruitfully developed as the essence of every æsthetic condition. + (T. Lipps, <i>Æsthetik</i>, Teil I, 1903.) By <i>Einfühlung</i> our own + interior activity becomes the activity <a name='5_Page_106'></a>of the object perceived, + a thing being beautiful in proportion as it lends itself to our + <i>Einfühlung</i>. But by this action of erotic symbolism, on the + other hand, we transfer the activity of the object into + ourselves.</p></div> + +<p>When the idea of erotic symbolism as manifested in such definite and +typical forms becomes realized, it further becomes clear that the vaguer +manifestations of such symbolism are exceedingly widespread. When in a +previous volume we were discussing and drawing together the various +threads which unite "Love and Pain," it will now be understood that we +were standing throughout on the threshold of erotic symbolism. Pain +itself, in the sense in which we slowly learned to define it in this +relationship—as a state of intense emotional excitement—may, under a +great variety of special circumstances, become an erotic symbol and afford +the same relief as the emotions normally accompanying the sexual act. +Active algolagnia or sadism is thus a form of erotic symbolism; passive +algolagnia or masochism is (in a man) an inverted form of erotic +symbolism. Active flagellation or passive flagellation are, in exactly the +same way, manifestations of erotic symbolism, the imaginative mimicry of +coitus.</p> + +<p>Binet and also Krafft-Ebing<a name='5_FNanchor_64'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_64'><sup>[64]</sup></a> have argued in effect that the whole of +sexual selection is a matter of fetichism, that is to say, of erotic +symbolism of object. "Normal love," Binet states, "appears as the result +of a complicated fetichism." Tarde also seems to have regarded love as +normally a kind of fetichism. "We are a long time before we fall in love +with a woman," he remarks; "we must wait to see the detail which strikes +and delights us, and causes us to overlook what displeases us. Only in +normal love the details are many and always changing. Constancy in love is +rarely anything else but a voyage around the beloved person, a voyage of +exploration and ever new discoveries. The most faithful lover does not +love the same woman in the same way for two days in succession."<a name='5_FNanchor_65'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_65'><sup>[65]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_107'></a> +<p>From that point of view normal sexual love is the sway of a fetich—more +or less arbitrary, more or less (as Binet terms it) polytheistic—and it +can have little objective basis. But, as we saw when considering "Sexual +Selection in Man" in the previous volume, more especially when analyzing +the notion of beauty, we are justified in believing that beauty has to a +large extent an objective basis, and that love by no means depends simply +on the capricious selection of some individual fetich. The individual +factor, as we saw, is but one of many factors which constitute beauty. In +the study of sexual selection that individual factor was passed over very +lightly. We now see that it is often a factor of great importance, for in +it are rooted all these outgrowths—normal in their germs, highly abnormal +in their more extreme developments—which make up erotic symbolism.</p> + +<p>Erotic symbolism is therefore concerned with all that is least generic, +least specific, all that is most intimately personal and individual, in +sexual selection. It is the final point in which the decreasing circle of +sexual attractiveness is fixed. In the widest and most abstract form +sexual selection in man is merely human, and we are attracted to that +which bears most fully the marks of humanity; in a less abstract form it +is sexual, and we are attracted to that which most vigorously presents the +secondary sexual characteristics; still narrowing, it is the type of our +own nation and people that appeals most strongly to us in matters of love; +and still further concentrating we are affected by the ideal—in +civilization most often the somewhat exotic ideal—of our own day, the +fashion of our own city. But the individual factor still remains, and amid +the infinite possibilities of erotic symbolism the individual may evolve +an ideal which is often, as far as he knows and perhaps in actuality, an +absolutely unique event in the history of the human soul.</p> + +<p>Erotic symbolism works in its finer manifestations by means of the +idealizing aptitudes; it is the field of sexual psychology in which that +faculty of crystallization, on which Stendhal loved to dwell, achieves its +most brilliant results. In the solitary passage in which we seem to see a +smile on the face of the austere <a name='5_Page_108'></a>poet of the <i>De Rerum Naturâ</i>, Lucretius +tells us how every lover, however he may be amused by the amorous +extravagances of other men, is himself blinded by passion: if his mistress +is black she is a fascinating brunette, if she squints she is the rival of +Pallas, if too tall she is majestic, if too short she is one of the +Graces, <i>tota merum sal</i>; if too lean it is her delicate refinement, if +too fat then a Ceres, dirty and she disdains adornment, a chatterer and +brilliantly vivacious, silent and it is her exquisite modesty.<a name='5_FNanchor_66'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_66'><sup>[66]</sup></a> Sixteen +hundred years later Robert Burton, when describing the symptoms of love, +made out a long and appalling list of the physical defects which the lover +is prepared to admire.<a name='5_FNanchor_67'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_67'><sup>[67]</sup></a></p> + +<p>Yet we must not be too certain that the lover is wrong in this matter. We +too hastily assume that the casual and hasty judgment of the world is +necessarily more reliable, more conformed to what we call "truth," than +the judgment of the lover which is founded on absorbed and patient study. +In some cases where there is lack of intelligence in the lover and +dissimulation in the object of his love, it may be so. But even a poem or +a picture will often not reveal its beauty except by the expenditure of +time and study. It is foolish to expect that the secret beauty of a human +person will reveal itself more easily. The lover is an artist, an artist +who constructs an image, it is true, but only by patient and concentrated +attention to nature; he knows the defects of his image, probably better +than anyone, but he knows also that art lies, not in the avoidance of +defects, but in the realization of those traits which swallow up defects +and so render them non-existent. A great artist, Rodin, after a life spent +in the study of Nature, has declared that for art there is no ugliness in +Nature. "I have arrived at this belief by the study of Nature," he said; +"I can only grasp the beauty of the soul by the beauty of the body, but +some day one will come who will explain what I only catch a glimpse of and +will declare how the whole earth is beautiful, and all human beings +beautiful. I have never been able to say this in sculpture so well as I +wish <a name='5_Page_109'></a>and as I feel it affirmed within me. For poets Beauty has always +been some particular landscape, some particular woman; but it should be +all women, all landscapes. A negro or a Mongol has his beauty, however +remote from ours, and it must be the same with their characters. There is +no ugliness. When I was young I made that mistake, as others do; I could +not undertake a woman's bust unless I thought her pretty, according to my +particular idea of beauty; to-day I should do the bust of any woman, and +it would be just as beautiful. And however ugly a woman may look, when she +is with her lover she becomes beautiful; there is beauty in her character, +in her passions, and beauty exists as soon as character or passion becomes +visible, for the body is a casting on which passions are imprinted. And +even without that, there is always the blood that flows in the veins and +the air that fills the lungs."<a name='5_FNanchor_68'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_68'><sup>[68]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The saint, also, is here at one with the lover and the artist. The man who +has so profoundly realized the worth of his fellow men that he is ready +even to die in order to save them, feels that he has discovered a great +secret. Cyples traces the "secret delights" that have thus risen in the +hearts of holy men to the same source as the feelings generated between +lovers, friends, parents, and children. "A few have at intervals walked in +the world," he remarks, "who have, each in his own original way, found out +this marvel.... Straightway man in general has become to them so sweet a +thing that the infatuation has seemed to the rest of their fellows to be a +celestial madness. Beggars' rags to their unhesitating lips grew fit for +kissing, because humanity had touched the garb; there were no longer any +menial acts, but only welcome services.... Remember by how much man is the +subtlest circumstance in the world; at how many points he can attach +relationships; how manifold and perennial he is in his results. All other +things are dull, meager, tame beside him."<a name='5_FNanchor_69'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_69'><sup>[69]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_110'></a> +<p>It may be added that even if we still believe that lover and artist and +saint are drawing the main elements of their conceptions from the depths +of their own consciousness, there is a sense in which they are coming +nearer to the truth of things than those for whom their conceptions are +mere illusions. The aptitude for realizing beauty has involved an +adjustment of the nerves and the associated brain centers through +countless ages that began before man was. When the vision of supreme +beauty is slowly or suddenly realized by anyone, with a reverberation that +extends throughout his organism, he has attained to something which for +his species, and for far more than his species, is truth, and can only be +illusion to one who has artificially placed himself outside the stream of +life.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In an essay on "The Gods as Apparitions of the Race-Life," Edward + Carpenter, though in somewhat Platonic phraseology, thus well + states the matter: "The youth sees the girl; it may be a chance + face, a chance outline, amid the most banal surroundings. But it + gives the cue. There is a memory, a confused reminiscence. The + mortal figure without penetrates to the immortal figure within, + and there rises into consciousness a shining form, glorious, not + belonging to this world, but vibrating with the agelong life of + humanity, and the memory of a thousand love-dreams. The waking of + this vision intoxicates the man; it glows and burns within him; a + goddess (it may be Venus herself) stands in the sacred place of + his temple; a sense of awe-struck splendor fills him, and the + world is changed." "He sees something" (the same writer continues + in a subsequent essay, "Beauty and Duty") "which, in a sense, is + more real than the figures in the street, for he sees something + that has lived and moved for hundreds of years in the heart of + the race; something which has been one of the great formative + influences of his own life, and which has done as much to create + those very figures in the street as qualities in the circulation + of the blood may do to form a finger or other limb. He comes into + touch with a very real Presence or Power—one of those organic + centers of growth in the life of humanity—and feels this larger + life within himself, subjective, if you like, and yet intensely + objective. And more. For is it not also evident that the woman, + the mortal woman who excites his Vision, <i>has</i> some closest + relation to it, and is, indeed, far more than a mere mask or + empty formula which reminds him of it? For she indeed has within + her, just as much as the <a name='5_Page_111'></a>man has, deep subconscious Powers + working; and the ideal which has dawned so entrancingly on the + man is in all probability closely related to that which has been + working most powerfully in the heredity of the woman, and which + has most contributed to mold <i>her</i> form and outline. No wonder, + then, that her form should remind him of it. Indeed, when he + looks into her eyes he sees <i>through</i> to a far deeper life even + than she herself may be aware of, and yet which is truly hers—a + life perennial and wonderful. The more than mortal in him beholds + the more than mortal in her; and the gods descend to meet." + (Edward Carpenter, <i>The Art of Creation</i>, pp. 137, 186.)</p></div> + +<p>It is this mighty force which lies behind and beneath the aberrations we +have been concerned with, a great reservoir from which they draw the +life-blood that vivifies even their most fantastic shapes. Fetichism and +the other forms of erotic symbolism are but the development and the +isolation of the crystallizations which normally arise on the basis of +sexual selection. Normal in their basis, in their extreme forms they +present the utmost pathological aberrations of the sexual instinct which +can be attained or conceived. In the intermediate space all degrees are +possible. In the slightest degree the symbol is merely a specially +fascinating and beloved feature in a person who is, in all other respects, +felt to be lovable; as such its recognition is a legitimate part of +courtship, an effective aid to tumescence. In a further degree the symbol +is the one arresting and attracting character of a person who must, +however, still be felt as a sexually attractive individual. In a still +further degree of perversion the symbol is effective, even though the +person with whom it is associated is altogether unattractive. In the final +stage the person and even all association with a person disappear +altogether from the field of sexual consciousness; the abstract symbol +rules supreme.</p> + +<p>Long, however, before the symbol has reached that final climax of morbid +intensity we may be said to have passed beyond the sphere of sexual love. +A person, not an abstracted quality, must be the goal of love. So long as +the fetich is subordinated to the person it serves to heighten love. But +love must be based on a complexus of attractive qualities, or it has no +<a name='5_Page_112'></a>stability.<a name='5_FNanchor_70'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_70'><sup>[70]</sup></a> As soon as the fetich becomes isolated and omnipotent, so +that the person sinks into the background as an unimportant appendage of +the fetich, all stability is lost. The fetichist now follows an impersonal +and abstract symbol withersoever it may lead him.</p> + +<p>It has been seen that there are an extraordinary number of forms in which +erotic symbolism may be felt. It must be remembered, and it cannot be too +distinctly emphasized, that the links that bind together the forms of +erotic symbolism are not to be found in objects or even in acts, but in +the underlying emotion. A feeling is the first condition of the symbol, a +feeling which recalls, by a subtle and unconscious automatic association +of resemblance or of contiguity, some former feeling. It is the similarity +of emotion, instinctively apprehended, which links on a symbol only +partially sexual, or even apparently not sexual at all, to the great +central focus of sexual emotion, the great dominating force which brings +the symbol its life-blood.<a name='5_FNanchor_71'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_71'><sup>[71]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The cases of sexual hyperæsthesia, quoted at the beginning of this study, +do but present in a morbidly comprehensive and sensitive form those +possibilities of erotic symbolism which, in some degree, or at some +period, are latent in most persons. They are genuinely instinctive and +automatic, and have nothing in common with that fanciful and deliberate +play of the intelligence around sexual imagery—not infrequently seen in +abnormal and insane persons—which has no significance for sexual +psychology.</p> + +<p>It is to the extreme individualization involved by the developments of +erotic symbolism that the fetichist owes his morbid and perilous +isolation. The lover who is influenced by all the elements of sexual +selection is always supported by the fellow-feeling of a larger body of +other human beings; he has behind him his species, his sex, his nation, or +at the very least a fashion. Even the inverted lover in most cases is soon +able to create <a name='5_Page_113'></a>around him an atmosphere constituted by persons whose +ideals resemble his own. But it is not so with the erotic symbolist. He is +nearly always alone. He is predisposed to isolation from the outset, for +it would seem to be on a basis of excessive shyness and timidity that the +manifestations of erotic symbolism are most likely to develop. When at +length the symbolist realizes his own aspirations—which seem to him for +the most part an altogether new phenomenon in the world—and at the same +time realizes the wide degree in which they deviate from those of the rest +of mankind, his natural secretiveness is still further reinforced. He +stands alone. His most sacred ideals are for all those around him a +childish absurdity, or a disgusting obscenity, possibly a matter calling +for the intervention of the policeman. We have forgotten that all these +impulses which to us seem so unnatural—this adoration of the foot and +other despised parts of the body, this reverence for the excretory acts +and products, the acceptance of congress with animals, the solemnity of +self-exhibition—were all beliefs and practices which, to our remote +forefathers, were bound up with the highest conceptions of life and the +deepest ardors of religion.</p> + +<p>A man cannot, however, deviate at once so widely and so spontaneously in +his impulses from the rest of the world in which he himself lives without +possessing an aboriginally abnormal temperament. At the very least he +exhibits a neuropathic sensitiveness to abnormal impressions. Not +infrequently there is more than this, the distinct stigmata of +degeneration, sometimes a certain degree of congenital feeble-mindedness +or a tendency to insanity.</p> + +<p>Yet, regarded as a whole, and notwithstanding the frequency with which +they witness to congenital morbidity, the phenomena of erotic symbolism +can scarcely fail to be profoundly impressive to the patient and impartial +student of the human soul. They often seem absurd, sometimes disgusting, +occasionally criminal; they are always, when carried to an extreme degree, +abnormal. But of all the manifestations of sexual psychology, normal and +abnormal, they are the most specifically human. More than any others they +involve the <a name='5_Page_114'></a>potently plastic force of the imagination. They bring before +us the individual man, not only apart from his fellows, but in opposition, +himself creating his own paradise. They constitute the supreme triumph of +human idealism.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_64'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_64'>[64]</a><div class='note'><p> Binet, <i>Etudes de Psychologie Expérimentale</i>, esp., p. 84; +Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. cit.</i>, p. 18.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_65'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_65'>[65]</a><div class='note'><p> G. Tarde, "L'Amour Morbide," <i>Archives de l'Anthropologie +Criminelle</i>, 1890, p. 585.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_66'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_66'>[66]</a><div class='note'><p> Lucretius, Lib. IV, vv. 1150-1163.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_67'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_67'>[67]</a><div class='note'><p> Burton, <i>Anatomy of Melancholy</i>, Part III, Section II, Mem. +III, Subs. I.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_68'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_68'>[68]</a><div class='note'><p> Judith Cladel, <i>Auguste Rodin Pris sur la Vie</i>, 1903, pp. +103-104. Some slight modifications have been made in the translation of +this passage on account of the conversational form of the original.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_69'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_69'>[69]</a><div class='note'><p> W. Cyples, <i>The Process of Human Experience</i>, p. 462. Even +if (as we have already seen, <i>ante</i>, p. 58) the saint cannot always feel +actual physical pleasure in the intimate contact of humanity, the ardor of +devoted service which his vision of humanity arouses remains unaffected.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_70'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_70'>[70]</a><div class='note'><p> "To love," as Stendhal defined it (<i>De l'Amour</i>, Chapter +II), "is to have pleasure in seeing, touching, and feeling by all the +senses, and as near as possible, a beloved object by whom one is oneself +loved."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_71'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_71'>[71]</a><div class='note'><p> Pillon's study of "La Mémoire Affective" (<i>Revue +Philosophique</i>, February, 1901) helps to explain the psychic mechanism of +the process.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_THE_MECHANISM_OF_DETUMESCENCE'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_115'></a>THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE.</h2> + +<a name='5_M_I'></a><h3>I.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Psychological Significance of Detumescence—The Testis and the +Ovary—Sperm Cell and Germ Cell—Development of the Embryo—The External +Sexual Organs—Their Wide Range of Variation—Their Nervous Supply—The +Penis—Its Racial Variations—The Influence of Exercise—The Scrotum and +Testicles—The Mons Veneris—The Vulva—The Labia Majora and their +Varieties—The Pubic Hair and Its Characters—The Clitoris and Its +Functions—The Anus as an Erogenous Zone—The Nymphæ and their +Function—The Vagina—The Hymen—Virginity—The Biological Significance of +the Hymen.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>In analyzing the sexual impulse we have seen that the process whereby the +conjunction of the sexes is achieved falls naturally into two phases: the +first phase, of tumescence, during which force is generated in the +organism, and the second phase, of detumescence, in which that force is +discharged during conjugation.<a name='5_FNanchor_72'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_72'><sup>[72]</sup></a> Hitherto we have been occupied mainly +with the first phase, that of tumescence, and with its associated psychic +phenomena. It was inevitable that this should be so, for it is during the +slow process of tumescence that sexual selection is decided, the +crystallizations of love elaborated, and, to a large extent, the +individual erotic symbols determined. But we can by no means altogether +pass over the final phase of detumescence. Its consideration, it is true, +brings us directly into the field of anatomy and physiology; while +tumescence is largely under control of the will, when the moment of +detumescence arrives the reins slip from the control of the will; the more +fundamental and uncontrollable impulses of the organism <a name='5_Page_116'></a>gallop on +unchecked; the chariot of Phaëthon dashes blindly down into a sea of +emotion.</p> + +<p>Yet detumescence is the end and climax of the whole drama; it is an +anatomico-physiological process, certainly, but one that inevitably +touches psychology at every point.<a name='5_FNanchor_73'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_73'><sup>[73]</sup></a> It is, indeed, the very key to the +process of tumescence, and unless we understand and realize very precisely +what it is that happens during detumescence, our psychological analysis of +the sexual impulse must remain vague and inadequate.</p> + +<p>From the point of view we now occupy, a man and a woman are no longer two +highly sensitive organisms vibrating, voluptuously it may indeed be, but +vaguely and indefinitely, to all kinds of influences and with fluctuating +impulses capable of being directed into any channel, even in the highest +degree divergent from the proper ends of procreation. They are now two +genital organisms who exist to propagate the race, and whatever else they +may be, they must be adequately constituted to effect the act by which the +future of the race is ensured. We have to consider what are the material +conditions which ensure the most satisfactory and complete fulfillment of +this act, and how those conditions may be correlated with other +circumstances in the organism. In thus approaching the subject we shall +find that we have not really abandoned the study of the psychic aspects of +sex.</p> + +<p>The two most primary sexual organs are the testis and the ovary; it is the +object of conjugation to bring into contact the sperm from the testis with +the germ from the ovary. There is no reason to suppose that the germ-cell +and the sperm-cell are essentially different from each other. Sexual +conjugation thus remains a process which is radically the same as the +non-sexual mode of propagation which preceded it. The fusion of the nuclei +of the two cells was regarded by Van Beneden, who in 1875 first accurately +described it, as a process of conjugation comparable to that of the +protozoa and the protophyta. Boveri, <a name='5_Page_117'></a>who has further extended our +knowledge of the process, considers that the spermatozoon removes an +inhibitory influence preventing the commencement of development in the +ovum; the spermatozoon replaces a portion of the ovum which has already +undergone degeneration, so that the object of conjugation is chiefly to +effect the union of the properties of two cells in one, sexual +fertilization achieving a division of labor with reciprocal inhibition; +the two cells have renounced their original faculty of separate +development in order to attain a fusion of qualities and thus render +possible that production of new forms and qualities which has involved the +progress of the organized world.<a name='5_FNanchor_74'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_74'><sup>[74]</sup></a></p> + +<p>While in fishes this conjugation of the male and female elements is +usually ensured by the female casting her spawn into an artificial nest +outside the body, on to which the male sheds his milt, in all animals +(and, to some extent, birds, who occupy an intermediate position) there is +an organic nest, or incubation chamber as Bland Sutton terms it, the womb, +in the female body, wherein the fertilized egg may develop to a high +degree of maturity sheltered from those manifold risks of the external +world which make it necessary for the spawn of fishes to be so enormous in +amount. Since, however, men and women have descended from remote ancestors +who, in the manner of aquatic creatures, exercised functions of +sperm-extrusion and germ-extrusion that were exactly analogous in the two +sexes, without any specialized female uterine organization, the early +stages of human male and female fœtal development still display +the comparatively undifferentiated sexual organization of those remote +ancestors, and during the first months of fœtal life it is +practically impossible to tell by the inspection of the genital regions +whether the embryo would have developed into a man or into a woman. If we +examine the embryo at an early stage of development we see that the hind +end is the body stalk, this stalk in later stages becoming part of the +umbilical cord.<a name='5_Page_118'></a> The urogenital region, formed by the rapid extension of +the hind end beyond its original limit, which corresponds to what is later +the umbilicus, develops mainly by the gradual differentiation of +structures (the Wolffian and Müllerian bodies) which originally exist +identically in both sexes. This process of sexual differentiation is +highly complex, so that it cannot yet be said that there is complete +agreement among investigators as to its details. When some irregularity or +arrest of development occurs in the process we have one or other of the +numerous malformations which may affect this region. If the arrest occurs +at a very early stage we may even find a condition of things which seems +to approximate to that which normally exists in the adult reptilia.<a name='5_FNanchor_75'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_75'><sup>[75]</sup></a> +Owing to the fact that both male and female organs develop from more +primitive structures which were sexually undifferentiated, a fundamental +analogy in the sexual organs of the sexes always remains; the developed +organs of one sex exist as rudiments in the other sex; the testicles +correspond to the ovaries; the female clitoris is the homologue of the +male penis; the scrotum of one sex is the labia majora in the other sex, +and so throughout, although it is not always possible at present to be +quite certain in regard to these homologics.</p> + +<p>Since the object to be attained by the sexual organs in the human species +is identical with that which they subserve in their pre-human ancestors, +it is not surprising to find that these structures have a clear +resemblance to the corresponding structures in the apes, although on the +whole there would appear to be in man a higher degree of sexual +differentiation. Thus the uterus of various species of <i>semnopithecus</i> +seems to show a noteworthy correspondence with the same organ in +woman.<a name='5_FNanchor_76'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_76'><sup>[76]</sup></a> The somewhat less degree of sexual differentiation is well +shown in the gorilla; in the male the external organs are in the passive +state covered by the wrinkled skin of the abdomen, while in the <a name='5_Page_119'></a>female, +on the contrary, they are very apparent, and in sexual excitement the +large clitoris and nymphæ become markedly prominent. The penis of the +gorilla, however, more nearly resembles that of man, according to +Hartmann, than does that of the other anthropoid apes, which diverge from +the human type in this respect more than do the cynocephalic apes and some +species of baboon.</p> + +<p>From the psychological point of view we are less interested in the +internal sexual organs, which are most fundamentally concerned with the +production and reception of the sexual elements, than with the more +external parts of the genital apparatus which serve as the instruments of +sexual excitation, and the channels for the intromission and passage of +the seminal fluid. It is these only which can play any part at all in +sexual selection; they are the only part of the sexual apparatus which can +enter into the formation of either normal or abnormal erotic conceptions; +they are the organs most prominently concerned with detumescence; they +alone enter normally into the conscious process of sex at any time. It +seems desirable, therefore, to discuss them briefly at this point.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Our knowledge of the individual and racial variations of the + external sexual organs is still extremely imperfect. A few + monographs and collections of data on isolated points may be + found in more or less inaccessible publications. As regards + women, Ploss and Bartels have devoted a chapter to the sexual + organs of women which extends to a hundred pages, but remains + scanty and fragmentary. (<i>Das Weib</i>, vol. i, Chapter VI.) The + most systematic series of observations have been made in the case + of the various kinds of degenerates—idiots, the insane, + criminals, etc.—but it would be obviously unsafe to rely too + absolutely on such investigations for our knowledge of the sexual + organs of the ordinary population.</p> + +<p> There can be no doubt, however, that the external sexual organs + in normal men and women exhibit a peculiarly wide range of + variation. This is indicated not only by the unsystematic results + attained by experienced observers, but also by more systematic + studies. Thus Herman has shown by detailed measurements that + there are great normal variations in the conformation of the + parts that form the floor of the female pelvis. He found that the + projection of the pelvic floor varied from nothing to as much as + two inches, and that in healthy women who had borne no children + the distance between the coccyx and anus, the length <a name='5_Page_120'></a>of the + perineum, the distance between the fourchette and the symphysis + pubis, and the length of the vagina are subject to wide + variations. (<i>Lancet</i>, October 12, 1889.) Even the female + urethral opening varies very greatly, as has been shown by Bergh, + who investigated it in nearly 700 women and reproduces the + various shapes found; while most usually (in about a third of the + cases observed), a longitudinal slit, it may be cross-shaped, + star-shaped, crescentic, etc.; and while sometimes very small, in + about 6 per cent. of the cases it admitted the tip of the little + finger. (Bergh, <i>Monatsheft für Praktische Dermatologie</i>, 15 + Sept., 1897.)</p> + +<p> As regards both sexes, Stanley Hall states that "Dr. F. N. + Seerley, who has examined over 2000 normal young men as well as + many young women, tells me that in his opinion individual + variations in these parts are much greater even than those of + face and form, and that the range of adult and apparently normal + size and proportion, as well as function, and of both the age and + order of development, not only of each of the several parts + themselves, but of all their immediate annexes, and in females as + well as males, is far greater than has been recognized by any + writer. This fact is the basis of the anxieties and fears of + morphological abnormality so frequent during adolescence." (G. S. + Hall, <i>Adolescence</i>, vol. i, p. 414).</p></div> + +<p>In accordance with the supreme importance of the part they play, and the +intimately psychic nature of that part, the sexual organs, both internal +and external, are very richly supplied with nerves. While the internal +organs are very abundantly furnished with sympathetic nerves and ganglia, +the external organs show the highest possible degree of specialization of +the various peripheral nervous devices which the organism has developed +for receiving, accumulating, and transmitting stimuli to the brain.<a name='5_FNanchor_77'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_77'><sup>[77]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>"The number of conducting cords which attach the genitals to the + nervous centers is simply enormous," writes Bryan Robinson; "the + pudic nerve is composed of nearly all the third sacral and + branches from the second and fourth sacral. As one examines this + nerve he is forced to the conclusion that it is an enormous + supply for a small organ. The periphery of the pudic nerve + spreads itself like a fan over the genitals." The lesser sciatic + nerve supplies only one muscle—the gluteus maximus—and <a name='5_Page_121'></a>then + sends the large pudendal branch to the side of the penis, and + hence the friction of coitus induces active contraction of the + gluteus maximus, "the main muscle of coition." The large pudic + and the pudendal constitute the main supply of the external + genitals. In women the pudic nerve is equally large, but the + pudendal much smaller, possibly, Bryan Robinson suggests, because + women take a less active part in coitus. The nerve supply of the + clitoris, however, is three or four times as large as that of the + penis in proportion to size. (F. B. Robinson, "The Intimate + Nervous Connection of the Genito-Urinary Organs With the + Cerebro-Spinal and Sympathetic Systems," <i>New York Medical + Journal</i>, March 11, 1893; <i>id.</i>, <i>The Abdominal Brain</i>, 1899.)</p></div> + +<p>Of all the sexual organs the penis is without doubt that which has most +powerfully impressed the human imagination. It is the very emblem of +generation, and everywhere men have contemplated it with a mixture of +reverence and shuddering awe that has sometimes, even among civilized +peoples, amounted to horror and disgust. Its image is worn as an amulet to +ward off evil and invoked as a charm to call forth blessing. The sexual +organs were once the most sacred object on which a man could place his +hands to swear an inviolate oath, just as now he takes up the Testament. +Even in the traditions of the great classic civilization which we inherit +the penis is <i>fascinus</i>, the symbol of all fascination. In the history of +human culture it has had far more than a merely human significance; it has +been the symbol of all the generative force of Nature, the embodiment of +creative energy in the animal and vegetable worlds alike, an image to be +held aloft for worship, the sign of all unconscious ecstasy. As a symbol, +the sacred phallus, it has been woven in and out of all the highest and +deepest human conceptions, so intimately that it is possible to see it +everywhere, that it is possible to fail to see it anywhere.</p> + +<p>In correspondence with the importance of the penis is the large number of +names which men have everywhere bestowed upon it. In French literature +many hundred synonyms may be found. They were also numerous in Latin. In +English the literary terms for the penis seem to be comparatively few, but +a large number of non-literary synonyms exist in colloquial and perhaps +merely local usage. The Latin term penis, which has <a name='5_Page_122'></a>established itself +among us as the most correct designation, is generally considered to be +associated with <i>pendere</i> and to be connected therefore with the usually +pendent position of the organ. In the middle ages the general literary +term throughout Europe was <i>coles</i> (or <i>colis</i>) from <i>caulis</i>, a stalk, +and <i>virga</i>, a rod. The only serious English literary term, yard (exactly +equivalent to <i>virga</i>), as used by Chaucer—almost the last great English +writer whose vocabulary was adequate to the central facts of life—has now +fallen out of literary and even colloquial usage.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Pierer and Chaulant, in their anatomical and physiological + <i>Real-Lexicon</i> (vol. vi, p. 134), give nearly a hundred synonyms + for the penis. Hyrtl (<i>Topographisches Anatomie</i>, seventh + edition, vol. ii, pp. 67-69), adds others. Schurig, in his + <i>Spermatologia</i> (1720, pp. 89-91), also presents a number of + names for the penis; in Chapter III (pp. 189-192) of the same + book he discusses the penis generally with more fullness than + most authors. Louis de Landes, in his <i>Glossaire Erotique</i> of the + French language (pp. 239-242), enumerates several hundred + literary synonyms for the penis, though many of them probably + only occur once.</p> + +<p> There is no thorough and comprehensive modern study of the penis + on an anthropological basis (though I should mention a valuable + and fully illustrated study of anthropological and pathological + variations of the penis in a series of articles by Marandon de + Montyel, "Des Anomalies des Organs Génitaux Externes Chez les + Aliénées," etc., <i>Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, 1895), + and it would be out of place here to attempt to collect the + scattered notices regarding racial and other variations. It may + suffice to note some of the evidence showing that such variations + seem to be numerous and important. The Arab penis (according to + Kocher) is slender and long (a third longer than the average + European penis) and with a club-shaped glans. It undergoes little + change when it enters the erect state. The clothes leaves it + quite free, and the Arab practices manual excitement at an early + age to favor its development.</p> + +<p> Among the Fuegians, also, according to Hyades and Deniker (<i>Cap + Horn</i>, vol. vii, p. 153), the average length of the penis is 77 + millimeters, which is longer than in Europeans.</p> + +<p> In men of black race, also, the penis is decidedly large. Thus + Sir H. H. Johnston (<i>British Central Africa</i>, p. 399) states this + to be a universal rule. Among the Wankenda of Northern Nyassa, + for instance, he remarks that, while the body is of medium size, + the penis is generally large. He gives the usual length as about + six inches, reaching nine or ten in erection. The prepuce, it is + added, is often very long, and circumcision is practiced by many + tribes.</p><a name='5_Page_123'></a> + +<p> Among the American negroes Hrdlicka has found, also (<i>Proceedings + American Association for the Advancement of Science</i>, vol. xlvii, + p. 475), that the penis in black boys is larger than in white + boys.</p> + +<p> The passages cited above suggest the question whether the penis + becomes larger by exercise of its generative functions. Most old + authors assert that frequent erection makes the penis large and + long (Schurig, <i>Spermatologia</i>, p. 107). Galen noted that in + singers and athletes, who were chaste in order to preserve their + strength, the sexual parts were small and rugrose, like those of + old men, and that exercise of the organs from youth develops + them; Roubaud, quoting this observation (<i>Traité de + l'Impuissance</i>, p. 373), agrees with the statement. It seems + probable that there is an element of truth in this ancient + belief. At the same time it must be remembered that the penis is + only to small extent a muscular organ, and that the increase of + size produced by frequent congestion of erectile tissues cannot + be either rapid or pronounced. Variations in the size of the + sexual organs are probably on the whole mainly inherited, though + it is impossible to speak decisively on this point until more + systematic observations become customary.</p></div> + +<p>The scrotum has usually, in the human imagination, been regarded merely as +an appendage of the penis, of secondary importance, although it is the +garment of the primary and essential organs of sex, and the fact that it +is not the seat of any voluptuous sensation has doubtless helped to +confirm this position. Even the name is merely a mediæval perversion of +<i>scortum</i>, skin or hide. In classic times it was usually called the pouch +or purse. The importance of the testicles has not, however, been +altogether ignored, as the very word <i>testis</i> itself shows, for the +<i>testis</i> is simply the <i>witness</i> of virility.<a name='5_FNanchor_78'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_78'><sup>[78]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is easy to understand why the penis should occupy this special place in +man's thoughts as the supreme sexual organ. It is the one conspicuous and +prominent portion of the sexual apparatus, while its aptitude for swelling +and erecting itself involuntarily, under the influence of sexual emotion, +gives it a peculiar and almost unique position in the body. At the same +time it is the point at which, in the male body, all voluptuous sensation +is concentrated, the only normal masculine center of sex.<a name='5_FNanchor_79'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_79'><sup>[79]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_124'></a> +<p>It is not easy to find any correspondingly conspicuous symbol of sex in +the sexual region of women. In the normal position nothing is visible but +the peculiarly human cushion of fat picturesquely termed the Mons Veneris +(because, as Palfyn said, all those who enroll themselves under the banner +of Venus must necessarily scale it), and even that is veiled from view in +the adult by the more or less bushy plantation of hair which grows upon +it. A triangle of varyingly precise definition is thus formed at the lower +apex of the trunk, and this would sometimes appear to have been regarded +as a feminine symbol.<a name='5_FNanchor_80'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_80'><sup>[80]</sup></a> But the more usual and typical symbol of +femininity is the idealized ring (by some savages drawn as a lozenge) of +the vulvar opening—the <i>yoni</i> corresponding to the masculine +<i>lingam</i>—which is normally closed from view by the larger lips arising +from beneath the shadow of the <i>mons</i>. It is a symbol that, like the +masculine phallus, has a double meaning among primitive peoples and is +sometimes used to call down a blessing and sometimes to invoke a +curse.<a name='5_FNanchor_81'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_81'><sup>[81]</sup></a></p> + +<p>This external opening of the feminine genital passage with its two +enclosing lips is now generally called the vulva. It would appear that +originally (as by Celsus and Pliny) this term included the womb, also, but +when the term "uterus" came into use "vulva" was confined (as its sense of +folding doors suggests that it should be) to the external entrance. The +classic term <i>cunnus</i> for the external genitals was chiefly used by the +poets; it has been the etymological source of various European names for +this region, such as the old French <i>con</i>, which has now, however, +disappeared from literature while even in popular usage it has given place +to <i>lapin</i> and similar terms. But there is always a tendency, marked in +most parts of the world, for the names of the external female parts to +become indecorous. Even in classic antiquity this part was the <i>pudendum</i>, +the part <a name='5_Page_125'></a>to be ashamed of, and among ourselves the mass of the +population, still preserving the traditions of primitive times, continue +to cherish the same notion.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The anatomy, anthropology, folk-lore, and terminology of the + external and to some extent the internal feminine sexual region + may be studied in the following publications, among others: + Ploss, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. i, Chapter VI; Hyrtl, <i>Topographisches + Anatomie</i>, vol. ii, and other publications by the same scholarly + anatomist; W. J. Stewart Mackay, <i>History of Ancient Gynæcology</i>, + especially pp. 244-250; R. Bergh, "Symbolæ ad Cognitionem + Genitalium Externorum Fœminearum" (in Danish), + <i>Hospitalstidende</i>, August, 1894; and also in <i>Monatshefte für + Praktische Dermatologie</i>, 1897. D. S. Lamb, "The Female External + Genital Organs," <i>New York Journal of Gynæcology</i>, August, 1894; + R. L. Dickinson, "Hypertrophies of the Labia Minora and Their + Significance," <i>American Gynecology</i>, September, 1902; Κρυπτάδια + (in various languages), vol. viii, pp. 3-11, 11-13, + and many other passages. Several of Schurig's works (especially + <i>Gynæcologia</i>, <i>Muliebria</i>, and <i>Parthenologia</i>) contain full + summaries of the statements of the early writers.</p></div> + +<p>The external or larger lips, like the mons veneris, are specifically human +in their full development, for in the anthropoid apes they are small as is +the mons, and in the lower apes absent altogether; they are, moreover, +larger in the white than in the other human races. Thus in the negro, and +to a less degree in the Japanese (Wernich) and the Javanese (Scherzer) +they are less developed than in women of white race. The greater lips +develop in the fœtus later than the lesser lips, which are thus +at first uncovered; this condition thus constitutes an infantile state +which occasionally (in less than 2 per cent. of cases, according to Bergh) +persists in the adult. Their generally accepted name, labia majora, is +comparatively modern.<a name='5_FNanchor_82'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_82'><sup>[82]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The outer sides of the labia majora are covered with hair, and on + the inner sides, which are smooth and moist, but are not true + mucous membrane, there are a few sweat glands and numerous large + sebaceous glands. Bergh considers that there is little or no hair + on the inner sides of the labia majora, but Lamb states that + careful examination shows that from one- to two-thirds of the + inner surface in adult women <a name='5_Page_126'></a>show hairs like those of the + external surface. In brunettes and women of dark races this + surface is pigmented; in dark races it is usually a slate gray. + From an examination of 2200 young Danish prostitutes Bergh has + found that there are two main varieties in the shape of the labia + majora, with transitional forms. In the first and most frequent + form the labia tend to be less marked and more effaced and + separated at the upper and anterior part, often being lost in the + sides of the mons and presenting a fissure which is broader in + its upper part and showing the inner lips more or less bare. In + the second form the labia are thicker and more outstanding and + the inner edges lie in contact throughout their whole length, + showing the <i>rima pudendi</i> as a long narrow fissure. Whatever the + form, the labia close more tightly together in virgins and in + young individuals generally than in the deflowered and the + elderly. In children, as Martineau pointed out, the vulva appears + to look directly forward and the clitoris and urinary meatus + easily appear, while in adult women, and especially after + attempts at coitus have been made, the vulva appears directed + more below and behind, and the clitoris and meatus more covered + by the labia majora; so that the child urinates forward, while + the adult woman is usually able to urinate almost directly + downwards in the erect position, though in some cases (as may + occasionally be observed in the street) she can only do so when + bending slightly forwards. This difference in the direction of + the stream formerly furnished one of the methods of diagnosing + virginity, an uncertain one, since the difference is largely due + to age and individual variation. The main factor in the position + and aspect of the vulva is pelvic inclination. (See Havelock + Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i>, fourth edition, p. 64; Stratz, <i>Die + Schönheit des Weiblichen Körpers</i>, Chapter XII.) In the European + woman, according to Stratz, a considerable degree of pelvic + inclination is essential to beauty, concealing all but the + anterior third of the vulva. In negresses and other women of + lower race the vulva, however, usually lies further back, being + more conspicuous from behind than in European women; in this + respect lower races resemble the apes. Those women of dark race, + therefore, whose modesty is focused behind rather than in front + thus have sound anatomical considerations on their side.</p> + +<p> As Ploss and Bartels remark, a very common variation among + European women consists in an unusually posterior position of the + vulva and vaginal entrance, so that unless a cushion is placed + under the buttocks it is difficult for the man to effect coitus + in the usual position without giving much pain to the woman. They + add that another anomaly, less easy to remedy, consists in an + abnormally anterior position of the vaginal entrance close + beneath the pelvic bone, so that, although intromission is easy, + the spasmodic contraction of the vagina at the culmination of + orgasm presses the penis against the bone and causes intolerable + pain to the man.</p></div><a name='5_Page_127'></a> + +<p>The mons veneris and the labia majora are, after the age of puberty, +always normally covered by a more or less profuse growth of hair. It is +notable that the apes, notwithstanding their general tendency to +hairiness, show no such special development of hair in this region. We +thus see that all the external and more conspicuous portions of the sexual +sphere in woman—the mons veneris, the labia majora, and the +hair—represent not so much an animal inheritance, such as we commonly +misrepresent them to be, but a higher and genuinely human development. As +none of these structures subserve any clear practical use, it would appear +that they must have developed by sexual selection to satisfy the æsthetic +demands of the eye.<a name='5_FNanchor_83'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_83'><sup>[83]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The character and arrangement of the pubic hair, investigated by + Eschricht and Voigt more than half a century ago, have been more + recently studied by Bergh. As these observers have pointed out, + there are various converging hair streams from above and below, + the clitoris seeming to be the center towards which they are + directed. The hair-covering thus formed is usually ample and, as + a rule, is more so in brunettes than in blondes. It is nearly + always bent, curly and more or less spirally twisted.<a name='5_FNanchor_84'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_84'><sup>[84]</sup></a> There + are frequently one or two curls at the commencement of the + fissure, rolled outwards, and occasionally a well marked tuft in + the middle line. In abundance the pubic hair corresponds with the + axillary hair; when one region is defective in hair the other is + usually so also. Strong eyebrows also usually indicate a strong + development of pubic hair. But the hair of the head usually + varies independently, and Bergh found that of 154 women with + spare pubic hair 72 had good and often profuse hair on the head. + Complete or almost <a name='5_Page_128'></a>complete absence of pubic hair is in Bergh's + experience only found in about 3 per cent. of women; these were + all young and blonde.</p></div> + +<p>Rothe, in his investigation of the pubic hair of 1000 Berlin women, found +that no two women were really alike in this respect, but there was a +tendency to two main types of arrangement, with minor subdivisions, +according as the hair tended to grow chiefly in the middle line extending +laterally from that line, or to grow equally over the whole extent of the +pubic region; these two groups included half the cases investigated.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In men the pubic hair normally ascends anteriorly in a faint line + up to the navel, with tendency to form a triangle with the apex + above, and posteriorly extends backwards to the anus. In women + these anterior and posterior extensions are comparatively rare, + or at all events are only represented by a few stray hairs. Rothe + found this variation in 4 per cent. of North German women, though + a triangle of hair was only found in 2 per cent.; Lombroso found + it in 5 per cent, of Italian women; Bergh found it in only 1.6 + per cent. among 1000 Danish prostitutes, all sixteen of whom with + three exceptions were brunettes. In Vienna, among 600 women, Coe + found only 1 per cent, with this distribution of hair, and states + that they were women of decidedly masculine type, though Ploss + and Bartels, as well as Rothe, find, however, that heterogeny, as + they term the masculine distribution, is more common in blondes. + The anterior extension of hair is usually accompanied by the + posterior extension around the anus, usually very slight, but + occasionally as pronounce as in men. (According to Rothe, + however, anterior heterogeny comparatively rare.) These masculine + variations in the extension of the pubic hair appear to be not + uncommonly associated with other physical and psychic anomalies; + it is on this account that they have sometimes been regarded as + indications of a vicious or a criminal temperament; they are, + however, found in quite normal women.</p> + +<p> The pubic hair of women is usually shorter than that of men, but + thick, and the individual hairs stronger and larger in diameter + than those of men, as Pfaff first showed; dark hair is usually + stronger than light. In both length and size the individual + variations are considerable. The usual length is about 2 inches, + or 3-5 centimeters, occasionally reaching about 4 inches, or 9-10 + centimeters, in the larger curls. In a series of 100 women + attended during confinement in London and the north of England I + have only once (in a rather blonde Lancashire woman) found the + hair on labia reaching a conspicuous length of several inches and + forming an obstruction to the manipulations involved in delivery. + But Jahn delivered a woman whose pubic hair was longer than that + of her head, reaching below her knee; Paulini also knew a woman + whose <a name='5_Page_129'></a>pubic hair nearly reached her knees and was sold to make + wigs; Bartholin mentions a soldier's wife who plaited her pubic + hair behind her back; while Brantôme has several references to + abnormally long hair in ladies of the French court during the + sixteenth century. In 8 cases out of 2200 Bergh found the pubic + hair forming a large curly wig extending to the iliac spines. The + individual hairs have occasionally been found so stiff and + brush-like as to render coitus difficult.</p> + +<p> In color the pubic hair, while generally approximating to that of + the head, is sometimes (according to Rothe, in Germany, in + one-third cases) lighter, and sometimes somewhat darker, as is + found to be the case by Coe, especially in brunettes, and also by + Bergh, in Denmark. Bergh remarks that it is generally + intermediate in color between the eyebrows and the axillary hair, + the latter being more or less decolorized by sweat, and that, + owing to the influence of the urine and vaginal discharges, the + labial hair is paler than that on the mons; blondes with dark + eyebrows usually have dark hair on the mons. The hair on this + spot, as Aristotle observed, is usually the last to turn gray.</p></div> + +<p>The key to the genital apparatus in women from the psychic point of view, +and, indeed, to some extent, its anatomical center, is to be found in the +clitoris. Anatomically and developmentally the clitoris is the rudimentary +analogue of the masculine penis. Functionally, however, its scope is very +much smaller. While the penis both receives and imparts specific +voluptuous sensations, and is at the same time both the intromittent organ +for the semen and the conduit for the urine, the sole function of the +clitoris is to enter into erection under the stress of sexual emotion and +receive and transmit the stimulatory voluptuous sensations imparted to it +by friction with the masculine genital apparatus. It is so insignificant +an organ that it is only within recent times that its homology with the +penis has been realized. In 1844 Kobelt wrote in his important book, <i>Die +Mannlichen und Weiblichen Wollust-Organe</i>, that in his attempt to show +that the female organs are exactly analogous to the male the reader will +probably be unable to follow him, while even Johannes Müller, the father +of scientific physiology, declared at about the same period that the +clitoris is essentially different from the penis. It is indeed but three +centuries since the clitoris was so little known that (in 1593) Realdus +Columbus actually claimed the honor of discovering it.<a name='5_Page_130'></a> Columbus was not +its discoverer, for Fallopius speedily showed that Avicenna and Albucasis +had referred to it.<a name='5_FNanchor_85'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_85'><sup>[85]</sup></a> The Arabs appear to have been very familiar with +it, and, from the various names they gave it, clearly understood the +important part it plays in generating voluptuous emotion.<a name='5_FNanchor_86'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_86'><sup>[86]</sup></a> But it was +known in classic antiquity; the Greeks called it μύρτον, the +myrtle-berry; Galen and Soranus called it νύμφη because it is +covered as a bride is veiled, while the old Latin name was <i>tentigo</i>, from +its power of entering into erection, and <i>columella</i>, the little pillar, +from its shape. The modern term, which is Greek and refers to the +sensitiveness of the part to voluptuous titillation, is said to have +originated with Suidas and Pollux.<a name='5_FNanchor_87'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_87'><sup>[87]</sup></a> It was mentioned, though not +adopted, by Rufus.</p> + +<p>"The clitoris," declared Haller, "is a part extremely sensible and +wonderfully prurient." It is certainly the chief though by no means the +only point through which the immediate call to detumescence is conveyed to +the female organism. It is, indeed, as Bryan Robinson remarks, "a +veritable electrical bell button which, being pressed or irritated, rings +up the whole nervous system."</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The nervous supply of this little organ is very large, and the + dorsal nerve of the clitoris is relatively three or four times + larger than that of the penis. Yet the sensitive point of this + organ is only 5 to 7 millimeters in extent. The length of the + clitoris is usually rather over 2 centimeters (or about an inch) + and 3 centimeters when erect; a length of 4 centimeters or more + was regarded by Martineau as within the normal range of + variation. It is not usual to find the clitoris longer than this + in Europe (for among some races like the negro the clitoris is + generally large), but all degrees of magnitude may be found as + rare exceptions. (See, <i>e.g.</i>, Sir J. Y. Simpson, + "Hermaphrodites," <i>Obstetric Memoirs and Contributions</i>, vol. ii, + pp. 217-226; also Dickinson, <i>loc. cit.</i>) It was formerly thought + that the clitoris is easily enlarged by masturbation, and + Martineau believed that in this way it might be doubled in + length. It is probable that slight enlargement of the clitoris + may be <a name='5_Page_131'></a>caused by very frequent masturbation, but only to an + insignificant extent, and it is impossible to diagnose + masturbation from the size of the clitoris. Among the women of + Lake Nyassa, as well as in the Caroline Islands, special methods + are practiced for elongating the clitoris, but in Europe, at all + events, it is probable that the variations in the size of the + organ are mainly congenital. It may well be that a congenitally + large clitoris is associated with an abnormally developed + excitability of the sexual apparatus. Tilt stated (<i>On Uterine + and Ovarian Inflammation</i>, p. 37) that in his experience there + was a frequent though not invariable connection between a large + clitoris and sexual proclivity. (Schurig referred to a case of + intense and life-long sexual obsession associated with an + extremely large clitoris, <i>Gynæcologia</i>, pp. 16-17.) Of recent + years considerable importance has been attached by some + gynecologists (<i>e.g.</i>, R. T. Morris, "Is Evolution Trying to Do + Away With the Clitoris?" <i>Transactions American Association of + Obstetricians and Gynecologists</i>, vol. v, 1893) to preputial + adhesions around the clitoris as a source of nervous disturbance + and invalidism in young women.</p></div> + +<p>While the clitoris is anatomically analogous to the penis, its actual +mechanism under the stress of sexual excitement is somewhat different. As +Liétaud long since pointed out, it cannot rise freely in erection as the +penis can; it is apparently bound down by its prepuce and its frenulum. +Waldeyer, in his book on the pelvis, states more precisely that, unlike +the penis, when erect it retains its angle, only this becomes somewhat +rounded so that the organ is to some slight extent lifted and protruded. +Waldeyer considered that the clitoris was thus perfectly fitted to fulfill +its part as the recipient of erotic stimulation from friction by the +penis. Adler, however, has pointed out with considerable justice, that +this is not altogether the case. The clitoris was developed in mammals who +practiced the posterior mode of coitus; in this position the clitoris was +beneath the penis, which was thus easily able in coitus to press it +against the pubic bone close beneath which it is situated, and thus impart +the compression and friction which the feminine organ craves. But in the +human anterior mode of coitus it is not necessarily brought into close +contact with the penis during the act of coitus, and thus fails to receive +powerful stimulation. Its restricted position, <a name='5_Page_132'></a>which is an advantage in +posterior coitus, is a disadvantage in anterior coitus. Adler observes +that it thus comes about that the human method of coitus, while by +bringing breast to breast and face to face it has added a new dignity and +refinement, a fresh source of enjoyment, to the embrace of the sexes, has +not been an unmixed advantage to woman, for while man has lost nothing by +the change, woman has now to contend with an increased difficulty in +attaining an adequate amount of pressure on that "electric button" which +normally sets the whole mechanism in operation.<a name='5_FNanchor_88'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_88'><sup>[88]</sup></a></p> + +<p>We may well bring into connection with the changed conditions brought +about by anterior coitus the interesting fact that while the clitoris +remains the most exquisitely sensitive of the sexual centers in woman, +voluptuous sensitivity is much more widely diffused in woman than in man. +Over the whole body, indeed, it is apt to be more distinctly marked than +is usually the case in man. But even if we confine ourselves to the +genital region, while in man that portion of the penis which enters the +vagina, and especially the glans, is normally the only portion which, even +during turgescence, is sensitive to voluptuous contacts, in woman the +whole of the region comprised within the larger lips, including even the +anus and internally the vagina and the vaginal portion of the womb,<a name='5_FNanchor_89'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_89'><sup>[89]</sup></a> +become sensitive to voluptuous contacts. Deprived of the penis the ability +of a man to experience specifically sexual sensations becomes very limited +indeed. But the loss of the clitoris or of any other structure involves no +correspondingly serious disability on women. Ablation of the clitoris for +sexual hyperæsthesia has for this reason been abandoned, except under +special circumstances. The members of the Russian Skoptzy sect habitually +amputate <a name='5_Page_133'></a>the clitoris, nymphæ, and breasts, yet many young Skoptzy women +told the Russian physician, Guttceit, that they were perfectly well able +to enjoy coitus.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Freud believes that in very young girls the clitoris is the + exclusive seat of sexual sensation, masturbation at this age + being directed to the clitoris alone, and spontaneous sexual + excitement being confined to twitchings and erection of this + organ, so that young girls are able, from their own experience, + to recognize without instruction the signs of sexual excitement + in boys. At a later age sexual excitability spreads from the + clitoris to other regions—just as the easy inflammability of + wood sets light to coal—though in the male the penis remains + from first to last normally the almost exclusive seat of specific + excitability. (S. Freud, <i>Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie</i>, + p. 62.)</p> + +<p> The anus would, however, seem to be sometimes an erogenous zone + even at an early age. Titillation of the anus appears to be + frequently pleasurable in women; and this is not surprising + considering the high degree of erotic sensitivity which is easily + developed at the body orifices where skin meets mucous membrane. + (Thus the meatus of the urethra is a highly erogenous zone, as is + sufficiently shown by the frequency with which hair-pins and + other articles used in masturbation find their way into the + bladder.) It is in this germinal sensitivity, undoubtedly, that + we find a chief key to the practice of <i>pedicatio</i>. Freud + attaches great importance to the anus as a sexually erogenous + zone at a very early age, and considers that it very frequently + makes its influence felt in this respect. He believes that + intestinal catarrhs in very early life and hæmorrhoids later tend + to develop sensibility in the anus. He finds an indication that + the anus has become a sexually erogenous zone when children wish + to allow the contents of the rectum to accumulate so that + defecation may by its increased difficulty involve voluptuous + sensations, and adds that masturbatory excitation of the anus + with the fingers is by no means rare in older children. (S. + Freud, <i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 40-42.) A medical correspondent in India + tells me of a European lady who derived, she said, "quite as + much, indeed more," pleasure from digitally titillating her + rectum as from vulvo-vaginal titillation; she had several times + submitted to <i>pedicatio</i> and enjoyed it, though it was painful + during penetration. The anus may retain this erogenous + irritability even in old age, and Routh mentions the case of a + lady of over 70, the reverse of lustful, who was so excited by + the act of defecation that she was invariably compelled to + masturbate, although this state of things was a source of great + mental misery to her. (C. H. F. Routh, <i>British Gynæcological + Journal</i>, February, 1887, p. 48.)</p> + +<p> Bölsche has sought the explanation of the erogenous nature of the + anus, and the key to <i>pedicatio</i>, in an atavistic return to the + very <a name='5_Page_134'></a>remote amphibian days when the anus was combined with the + sexual parts in a common cloaca. But it is unnecessary to invoke + any vestigial inheritance from a vastly remote past when we bear + in mind that the innervation of these two adjoining regions is + inevitably very closely related. The presence of a body exit with + its marked and special sensitivity at a point where it can + scarcely fail to receive the nervous overflow from an immensely + active center of nervous energy quite adequately accounts for the + phenomenon in question.</p></div> + +<p>The inner lips, the nymphæ or labia minora, running parallel with the +greater lips which enclose them, embrace the clitoris anteriorly and +extend backward, enclosing the urethral exit between them as well as the +vaginal entrance. They form little wings whence their old Latin name, +<i>alæ</i>, and from their resemblance to the cock's comb were by Spigelius +termed crista galli. The red and (especially in brunettes) dark appearance +of the nymphæ suggests that they are mucous membrane and not +integumentary; it is, however, now considered that even on the inner +surface they are covered by skin and separated from the mucous membrane by +a line.<a name='5_FNanchor_90'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_90'><sup>[90]</sup></a> In structure, as described by Waldeyer, they consist of fine +connective tissue rich in elastic fibers as well as some muscular tissue, +and full of large veins, so that they are capable of a considerable degree +of turgescence resembling erection during sexual excitement, while +Ballantyne finds that the nymphæ are supplied to a notable extent with +nervous end-organs.</p> + +<p>More than any other part of the sexual apparatus in either sex, the lesser +lips, on account of their shape, their position, and their structure, are +capable of acquired modifications, more especially hypertrophy and +elongation. By stretching, it is stated, a labium can be doubled in its +dimensions. The "Hottentot apron," or elongated nymphæ, commonly found +among some peoples in South Africa, has long been a familiar phenomenon. +In such cases a length or transverse diameter of 3 to 5 centimeters is +commonly found. But such elongated <a name='5_Page_135'></a>nymphæ are by no means confined to one +part of the world or to one race; they are quite common among women of +European race, and reach a size equal to most of the more reliably +recorded Hottentot cases. Dickinson, who has very carefully studied this +question in New York, finds that in 1000 consecutive gynæcological cases +the labia showed some form of hypertrophy in 36 per cent., or more than 1 +in 3; while among 150 of these cases who were neurasthenic, the proportion +reached 56 per cent., even when minor or doubtful enlargements were +disregarded. Bergh, in about 16 per cent. cases, found very enlarged +nymphæ, the height reached in about 5 per cent. of the cases of +enlargement being nearly six centimeters. Ploss and Bartels, in a full +discussion: of the "Hottentot apron," come to the conclusion that this +condition is perhaps in most cases artificially produced. It is known that +among the Basutos it is the custom for the elder girls to manipulate the +nymphæ of younger children, when alone with them, almost from birth, and +on account of the elastic nature of these structures such manipulation +quite adequately accounts for the elongation. It is not necessary to +suppose that the custom is practiced for the sake of producing sexual +stimulation—though this may frequently occur—since there are numerous +similar primitive customs involving deformation of the sexual organs +without the production of sexual excitement. Dickinson has come to a +similar conclusion as regards the corresponding elongation of the nymphæ +in civilized European women. In 361 out of 1000 women of good social class +he found elongation or thickening, often with a notable degree of +wrinkling and pigmentation, and believes that this is always the result of +frequently repeated masturbation practiced with the separation of the +nymphæ; in 30 per cent. of the cases admission of masturbation was +made.<a name='5_FNanchor_91'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_91'><sup>[91]</sup></a> While this conclusion is probably correct in the main, it +requires some qualification. To assert <a name='5_Page_136'></a>that whenever in women who have +not been pregnant the marked protrusion of the inner lips beyond the outer +lips means that at some period manipulation has been practiced with or +without the production of sexual excitement is to make too absolute a +statement. It is highly probable that the nymphæ, like the clitoris, are +congenitally more prominent in some of the lower human races, as they are +also in the apes; among the Fuegians, for instance, according to Hyades +and Deniker, the labia minora descend lower than in Europeans, although +there is not the slightest reason to suppose that these women practice any +manipulations. Among European women, again, the nymphæ sometimes protrude +very prominently beyond the labia majora in women who are organically of +somewhat infantile type; this occurs in cases in which we may be convinced +that no manipulations have ever been practiced.<a name='5_FNanchor_92'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_92'><sup>[92]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is difficult to speak very decisively as to the function of the labia +minora. They doubtless exert some amount of protective influence over the +entrance to the vagina, and in this way correspond to the lips of the +mouth after which they are called. They fulfill, however, one very +definite though not obviously important function which is indicated by the +mythologic name they have received. There is, indeed, some obscurity in +the origin of this term, nymphæ, which has not, I believe, been +satisfactorily cleared up. It has been stated that the Greek name νύμφη has been transferred from the clitoris to the labia minora. Any +such transfer could only have taken place when the meaning of the word had +been forgotten, and νύμφη had become the totally different +word <i>nymphæ</i>, the goddesses who presided over streams. The old anatomists +were much exercised in their minds as to the meaning of the name, but on +the whole were inclined to believe that it referred to the <a name='5_Page_137'></a>action of the +labia minora in directing the urinary stream. The term nymphæ was first +applied in the modern sense, according to Bergh, in 1599, by Pinæus, +mainly from the influence of these structures on the urinary stream, and +he dilated in his <i>De Virginitate</i> on the suitability of the term to +designate so poetic a spot.<a name='5_FNanchor_93'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_93'><sup>[93]</sup></a> In more modern times Luschka and Sir +Charles Bell considered that it is one of the uses of the nymphæ to direct +the stream of urine, and Lamb from his own observation thinks the same +conclusion probable. In reality there cannot be the slightest doubt about +the function of the nymphæ, as, in Hyrtl's phrase, "the naiads of the +urinary source," and it can be demonstrated by the simplest +experiment.<a name='5_FNanchor_94'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_94'><sup>[94]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The nymphæ form the intermediate portal of the vagina, as the canal which +conducts to the womb was in anatomy first termed (according to Hyrtl) by +De Graaf.<a name='5_FNanchor_95'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_95'><sup>[95]</sup></a> It is a secreting, erectile, more or less sensitive canal +lined by what is usually considered mucous membrane, though some have +regarded it as integument of the same character as that of the external +genitals; it certainly resembles such integument more than, for instance, +the mucous membrane of the rectum. In the woman who has never had sexual +intercourse and has been subjected to no manipulations or accidents +affecting this region, the vagina <a name='5_Page_138'></a>is closed by a last and final gate of +delicate membrane—scarcely admitting more than a slender finger—called +the hymen.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The poets called the hymen "fios virginitatis," the flower of + virginity, whence the medico-legal term <i>defloratio</i>. + Notwithstanding the great significance which has long been + attached to the phenomena connected with it, the hymen was not + accurately known until Vesalius, Fallopius, and Spigelius + described and named it. It was, however, recognized by the Arab + authors, Avicenna and Averroes. The early literature concerning + it is summarized by Schurig, <i>Muliebria</i>, 1729, Section II, cap. + V. The same author's <i>Parthenologia</i> is devoted to the various + ancient problems connected with the question of virginity.</p></div> + +<p>To say that this delicate piece of membrane is from the non-physical point +of view a more important structure than any other part of the body is to +convey but a feeble idea of the immense importance of the hymen in the +eyes of the men of many past ages and even of our own times and among our +own people.<a name='5_FNanchor_96'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_96'><sup>[96]</sup></a> For the uses of the feminine body, or for its beauty, +there is no part which is more absolutely insignificant. But in human +estimation it has acquired a spiritual value which has made it far more +than a part of the body. It has taken the place of the soul, that whose +presence gives all her worth and dignity, even her name, to the unmarried +woman, her purity, her sexual desirability, her market value. Without +it—though in all physical and mental respects she might remain the same +person—she has sometimes been a mark for contempt, a worthless +outcast.<a name='5_FNanchor_97'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_97'><sup>[97]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>So fragile a membrane scarcely possesses the reliability which + should be possessed by a structure whose presence or absence has + often meant so much. Its absence by no means necessarily + signifies that a woman has had intercourse with a man. Its + presence by no means signifies that she has never had such + intercourse.</p> + +<p> There are many ways in which the hymen may be destroyed apart + from coitus. Among the Chinese (and also, it would appear, in + India and some other parts of the East) the female parts are from + infancy <a name='5_Page_139'></a>kept so scrupulously clean by daily washing, the finger + being introduced into the vagina, that the hymen rapidly + disappears, and its existence is unknown even to Chinese doctors. + Among some Brazilian Indians a similar practice exists among + mothers as regards their young children, less, however, for the + sake of cleanliness than in order to facilitate sexual + intercourse in future years. (Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. + i, Chapter VI.) The manipulations of vaginal masturbation will, + of course, similarly destroy the hymen. It is also quite possible + for the hymen to be ruptured by falls and other accidents. (See, + <i>e.g.</i>, a lengthy study by Nina-Rodrigues, "Des Ruptures de + l'Hymen dans les Chutes," <i>Annales d'Hygiène Publique</i>, + September, 1903.)</p> + +<p> On the other hand, integrity of the hymen is no proof of + virginity, apart from the obvious fact that there may be + intercourse without penetration. (The case has even been recorded + of a prostitute with syphilitic condylomata, a somewhat masculine + type of pubic arch, and vulva rather posteriorly placed, whose + hymen had never been penetrated.) The hymen may be of a yielding + or folding type, so that complete penetration may take place and + yet the hymen be afterwards found unruptured. It occasionally + happens that the hymen is found intact at the end of pregnancy. + In some, though not all, of these cases there has been conception + without intromission of the penis. This has occurred even when + the entrance was very minute. The possibility of such conception + has long been recognized, and Schurig (<i>Syllepsilogia</i>, 1731, + Section I, cap. VIII, p. 2) quotes ancient authors who have + recorded cases. For some typical modern cases see Guérard + (<i>Centralblatt für Gynäkologie</i>, No. 15, 1895), in one of whose + cases the hymen of the pregnant woman scarcely admitted a hair; + also Braun (<i>ib.</i>, No. 23, 1895).</p></div> + +<p>The hymen has played a very definite and pronounced part in the social and +moral life of humanity. Until recently it has been more difficult to +decide what precise biological function it has exercised to ensure its +development and preservation. Sexual selection, no doubt, has worked in +its favor, but that influence has been very limited and comparatively very +recent. Virginity is not usually of any value among peoples who are +entirely primitive. Indeed, even in the classic civilization which we +inherit, it is easy to show that the virgin and the admiration for +virginity are of late growth; the virgin goddesses were not originally +virgins in our modern sense. Diana was the many-breasted patroness of +childbirth before she became the chaste and solitary huntress, for the +earliest distinction would appear <a name='5_Page_140'></a>to have been simply between the woman +who was attached to a man and the woman who followed an earlier rule of +freedom and independence; it was a later notion to suppose that the latter +woman was debarred from sexual intercourse. We certainly must not seek the +origin of the hymen in sexual selection; we must find it in natural +selection. And here it might seem at first sight that we come upon a +contradiction in Nature, for Nature is always devising contrivances to +secure the maximum amount of fertilization. "Increase and multiply" is so +obviously the command of Nature that the Hebrews, with their usual +insight, unhesitatingly dared to place it in the mouth of Jehovah. But the +hymen is a barrier to fertilization. It has, however, always to be +remembered that as we rise in the zoölogical scale, and as the period of +gestation lengthens and the possible number of offspring is fewer, it +becomes constantly more essential that fertilization shall be effective +rather than easy; the fewer the progeny the more necessary it is that they +shall be vigorous enough to survive. There can be little doubt that, as +one or two writers have already suggested, the hymen owes its development +to the fact that its influence is on the side of effective fertilization. +It is an obstacle to the impregnation of the young female by immature, +aged, or feeble males. The hymen is thus an anatomical expression of that +admiration of force which marks the female in her choice of a mate. So +regarded, it is an interesting example of the intimate manner in which +sexual selection is really based on natural selection. Sexual selection is +but the translation into psychic terms of a process which has already +found expression in the physical texture of the body.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It may be added that this interpretation of the biological + function of the hymen is supported by the facts of its evolution. + It is unknown among the lower mammals, with whom fertilization is + easy, gestation short and offspring numerous. It only begins to + appear among the higher mammals in whom reproduction is already + beginning to take on the characters which become fully developed + in man. Various authors have found traces of a rudimentary hymen, + not only in apes, but in elephants, horses, donkeys, bitches, + bears, pigs, hyenas, and giraffes. (Hyrtl, <i>Op. cit.</i>, vol. ii, + p. 189; G. Gellhoen, "Anatomy and Development<a name='5_Page_141'></a> of the Hymen," + <i>American Journal Obstetrics</i>, August, 1904.) It is in the human + species that the tendency to limitation of offspring is most + marked, combined at the same time with a greater aptitude for + impregnation than exists among any lower mammals. It is here, + therefore, that a physical check is of most value, and + accordingly we find that in woman alone, of all animals, is the + hymen fully developed.</p></div> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_72'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_72'>[72]</a><div class='note'><p> "Analysis of the Sexual Impulse," in vol. iii of these +<i>Studies</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_73'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_73'>[73]</a><div class='note'><p> "The accomplishment of no other function," Hyrtl remarks, +"is so intimately connected with the mind and yet so independent of it."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_74'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_74'>[74]</a><div class='note'><p> The process is still, however, but imperfectly understood; +see Art. "Fécondation," by Ed. Retterer, in Richet's <i>Dictionnaire de +Physiologie</i>, vol. vi, 1905.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_75'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_75'>[75]</a><div class='note'><p> Thus a male fœtus showing reptilian characters in +sexual ducts was exhibited by Shattock at the Pathological Society of +London, February 19, 1895.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_76'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_76'>[76]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Kohlbrugge, "Die Umgestaltung des Uterus der Affen nach +den Geburt," <i>Zeitschrift für Morphologie</i>, bd. iv, p. 1, 1901.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_77'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_77'>[77]</a><div class='note'><p> There are, however, no special nerve endings (Krause +corpuscles), as was formerly supposed. The nerve endings in the genital +region are the same as elsewhere. The difference lies in the abundance of +superposed arboreal ramifications. See, <i>e.g.</i>, Ed. Retterer, Art. +"Ejaculation," Richet's <i>Dictionnaire de Physiologie</i>, vol. v.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_78'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_78'>[78]</a><div class='note'><p> Hyrtl, <i>Op. cit.</i>, vol. ii, p. 39.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_79'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_79'>[79]</a><div class='note'><p> Sensations of pleasure without those of touch appear to be +normal at the tip of the penis, as pointed out by Scripture, quoted in +<i>Alienist and Neurologist</i>, January, 1898.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_80'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_80'>[80]</a><div class='note'><p> See the previous volume of these <i>Studies</i>, "Sexual +Selection in Man," p. 161.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_81'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_81'>[81]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. i, +beginning of chapter VI.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_82'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_82'>[82]</a><div class='note'><p> Hyrtl states that the name <i>labia</i> was first used by Haller +in the middle of the eighteenth century in his <i>Elements of Physiology</i>, +being adopted by him from the Greek poet Erotion, who gave these +structures the very obvious name χειλεα, lips. But this seems to +be a mistake, for the seventeenth century anatomists certainly used the +name "labia" for these parts.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_83'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_83'>[83]</a><div class='note'><p> Bergh tentatively suggests, as regards the pubic hair, that +its appearance may be due to the upright walk in man and the human +position during coitus, the hair preventing irritation of the genitals +from the sweat pouring down from the body and protecting the skin from +direct friction in coitus. (In both these suggestions he was, however, +long previously anticipated by Fabricius ab Aquapendente.) The fanciful +suggestion of Louis Robinson that the pubic hair has developed in order to +enable the human infant to cling securely to his mother is very poorly +supported by facts, and has not met with acceptance. It may be mentioned +that (as stated by Ploss and Bartels) the women of the Bismarck +Archipelago, whose pubic hair is very abundant, use it as a kind of +handkerchief on which to clean their hands.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_84'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_84'>[84]</a><div class='note'><p> Routh and Heywood Smith have noted that the pubic hair tends +to lose its curliness and become straight in women who masturbate. +(<i>British Gynæcological Journal</i>, February, 1887, p. 505.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_85'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_85'>[85]</a><div class='note'><p> Schurig, <i>Muliebria</i>, p. 75. Plazzon in 1621 said that in +Italian it had a popular name, <i>il besneegio</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_86'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_86'>[86]</a><div class='note'><p> Schurig brought together in his <i>Gynæcologia</i> (pp. 2-4) +various early opinions concerning the clitoris as the seat of voluptuous +feeling.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_87'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_87'>[87]</a><div class='note'><p> Hyrtl, <i>Op. cit.</i>, vol. ii, p. 193.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_88'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_88'>[88]</a><div class='note'><p> Adler, <i>Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes</i>, +1904, pp. 117-119.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_89'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_89'>[89]</a><div class='note'><p> The voluptuous sensations caused by sexual contacts +producing movements of the womb are probably normal and usual. They may +even occur under circumstances unconnected with sexual emotion, and Mundé +(<i>International Journal of Surgery</i>, March, 1893) mentions incidentally +that in one case while titillating the cervix with a sound the woman very +plainly showed voluptuous manifestations.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_90'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_90'>[90]</a><div class='note'><p> Henle stated that fine hairs are frequently visible on the +nymphæ; Stieda (<i>Zeitschrift für Morphologie</i>, 1902, p. 458) remarks that +he has never been able to see them with the naked eye.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_91'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_91'>[91]</a><div class='note'><p> R. L. Dickinson, "Hypertrophies of the Labia Minora and Their +Significance," <i>American Gynæcologist</i>, September, 1902. It is perhaps +noteworthy that Bergh found that in 302 cases in which the nymphæ were of +unequal length, in all but 24 the left was longer.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_92'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_92'>[92]</a><div class='note'><p> It may be remarked that Bergh believes that the nymphæ, and +indeed the external genitals generally, are congenitally more strongly +developed in libidinous persons, and at the same time in brunettes, while +in public prostitutes this is not usually the case, which confirms the +belief that exalted sexual sensibility does not usually lead to +prostitution. He adds that prostitution, unless carried on for many years, +has little effect on the shape of the external genitals.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_93'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_93'>[93]</a><div class='note'><p> Schurig (<i>Muliebria</i>, 1729, Section II, cap. II) gives +numerous quotations on this point; thus De Graaf wrote in his book on the +sexual organs of women: "Tales protuberantiæ nymphæ appellantur ea propter +quod aquis e vesica prosilientibus proxime adstare reperiantur, +quandoquidem inter illas, tanquam duos parietes, urina magno impetu cum +sibilo sæpe et absque labiorum irrigatione erumpit, vel quod sint +castitatis præsides, aut sponsam primo intromittant."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_94'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_94'>[94]</a><div class='note'><p> Havelock Ellis, "The Bladder as a Dynamometer," <i>American +Journal of Dermatology</i>, May, 1902. If a woman who has never been +pregnant, standing in the erect position before commencing the act of +urination presses apart the labia minora with index and middle fingers the +stream will be projected forward so as to fall usually at a considerable +distance in front of a vertical line from the meatus; if when the act is +half completed the fingers are removed, the labia close together and the +stream, though maintained at a constant pressure, at once changes its +character and direction.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_95'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_95'>[95]</a><div class='note'><p> In poetry this term was employed by Plautus, <i>Pseudolus</i>, +Act IV, Sc. 7. The Greek αιδοιον sometimes meant vagina and +sometimes the external sexual parts; κολπος was used for the +vagina alone.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_96'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_96'>[96]</a><div class='note'><p> It is curious, however, that the European physicians of the +seventeenth and even eighteenth centuries were doubtful of its value as a +sign of virginity and considered it often absent.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_97'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_97'>[97]</a><div class='note'><p> For a summary of the beliefs and practices of various +peoples with regard to the hymen and virginity see Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das +Weib</i>, vol. i, Chapter XVI.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_M_II'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_142'></a>II</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Object of Detumescence—Erogenous Zones—The Lips—The Vascular +Characters of Detumescence—Erectile Tissue—Erection in Woman—Mucous +Emission in Women—Sexual Connection—The Human Mode of +Intercourse—Normal Variations—The Motor Characters of +Detumescence—Ejaculation—The Virile Reflex—The General Phenomena of +Detumescence—The Circulatory and Respiratory Phenomena—Blood +Pressure—Cardiac Disturbance—Glandular Activity—Distillatio—The +Essentially Motor Character of Detumescence—Involuntary Muscular +Irradiation to Bladder, etc.—Erotic Intoxication—Analogy of Sexual +Detumescence and Vesical Tension—The Specifically Sexual Movements of +Detumescence in Man—In Woman—The Spontaneous Movements of the Genital +Canal in Woman—Their Function in Conception—Part Played by Active +Movement of the Spermatozoa—The Artificial Injection of Semen—The Facial +Expression During Detumescence—The Expression of Joy—The Occasional +Serious Effects of Coitus.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>We have seen what the object of detumescence is, and we have briefly +considered the organs and structures which are chiefly concerned in the +process. We have now to inquire what are the actual phenomena which take +place during the act of detumescence.</p> + +<p>Detumescence is normally linked closely to tumescence. Tumescence is the +piling on of the fuel; detumescence is the leaping out of the devouring +flame whence is lighted the torch of life to be handed on from generation +to generation. The whole process is double and yet single; it is exactly +analogous to that by which a pile is driven into the earth by the raising +and then the letting go of a heavy weight which falls on to the head of +the pile. In tumescence the organism is slowly wound up and force +accumulated; in the act of detumescence the accumulated force is let go +and by its liberation the sperm-bearing instrument is driven home. +Courtship, as we commonly term the process of tumescence which takes place +when a woman is first sexually approached by a man, is usually a highly +prolonged <a name='5_Page_143'></a>process. But it is always necessary to remember that every +repetition of the act of coitus, to be normally and effectively carried +out on both sides, demands a similar double process; detumescence must be +preceded by an abbreviated courtship.</p> + +<p>This abbreviated courtship by which tumescence is secured or heightened in +the repetition of acts of coitus which have become familiar, is mainly +tactile.<a name='5_FNanchor_98'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_98'><sup>[98]</sup></a> Since the part of the man in coitus is more active and that +of the woman more passive, the sexual sensitivity of the skin seems to be +more pronounced in women. There are, moreover, regions of the surface of a +woman's body where contact, when sympathetic, seems specially liable to +arouse erotic excitement. Such erogenous zones are often specially marked +in the breasts, occasionally in the palm of the hand, the nape of the +neck, the lobule of the ear, the little finger; there is, indeed, perhaps +no part of the surface of the body which may not, in some individuals at +some time, become normally an erogenous zone. In hysteria the erotic +excitability of these zones is sometimes very intense. The lips are, +however, without doubt, the most persistently and poignantly sensitive +region of the whole body outside the sphere of the sexual organs +themselves. Hence the significance of the kiss as a preliminary of +detumescence.<a name='5_FNanchor_99'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_99'><sup>[99]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The importance of the lips as a normal erogenous zone is shown by + the experiments of Gualino. He applied a thread, folded on itself + several times, to the lips, thus stimulating them in a simple + mechanical manner. Of 20 women, between the ages of 18 and 35, + only 8 felt this as a merely mechanical operation, 4 felt a + vaguely erotic element in the proceeding, 3 experienced a desire + for coitus and in 5 there was actual sexual excitement with + emission of mucus. Of 25 men, between the ages of 20 and 30, in + 15 all sexual feeling was absent, in 7 erotic ideas were + suggested with congestion of the sexual organs without erection, + and in 3 there was the beginning of erection. It should be added + that both the women and the men in whom this sexual reflex was + more especially <a name='5_Page_144'></a>marked were of somewhat nervous temperament; in + such persons erotic reactions of all kinds generally occur most + easily. (Gualino, "Il Rifflesso Sessuale nell' eccitamento alle + labbre," <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, 1904, p. 341.)</p></div> + +<p>As tumescence, under the influence of sensory stimulation, proceeds toward +the climax when it gives place to detumescence, the physical phenomena +become more and more acutely localized in the sexual organs. The process +which was at first predominantly nervous and psychic now becomes more +prominently vascular. The ancient sexual relationship of the skin asserts +itself; there is marked surface congestion showing itself in various ways. +The face tends to become red, and exactly the same phenomenon is taking +place in the genital organs; "an erection," it has been said, "is a +blushing of the penis." The difference is that in the genital organs this +heightened vascularity has a definite and specific function to +accomplish—the erection of the male organ which fits it to enter the +female parts—and that consequently there has been developed in the penis +that special kind of vascular mechanism, consisting of veins in connective +tissue with unstriped muscular fibers, termed erectile tissue.<a name='5_FNanchor_100'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_100'><sup>[100]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is not only the man who is supplied with erectile tissue which in the +process of tumescence becomes congested and swollen. The woman also, in +the corresponding external genital region, is likewise supplied with +erectile tissue now also charged with blood, and exhibits the same changes +as have taken place in her partner, though less conspicuously visible. In +the anthropoid apes, as the gorilla, the large clitoris and the nymphæ +become prominent in sexual excitement, but the less development of the +clitoris in women, together with the specifically human evolution of the +mons veneris and larger lips, renders this sexual turgescence practically +invisible, though it is perceptible to touch in an increased degree of +spongy and elastic tension. The whole feminine genital canal, including +the uterus, indeed, is richly supplied with blood-vessels, and is capable +<a name='5_Page_145'></a>during sexual excitement of a very high degree of turgescence, a kind of +erection.</p> + +<p>The process of erection in woman is accompanied by the pouring out of +fluid which copiously bathes all parts of the vulva around the entrance to +the vagina. This is a bland, more or less odorless mucus which, under +ordinary circumstances, slowly and imperceptibly suffuses the parts. When, +however, the entrance to the vagina is exposed and extended, as during a +gynæcological examination which occasionally produces sexual excitement, +there may be seen a real ejaculation of the fluid which, as usually +described, comes largely from the glands of Bartholin, situated at the +mouth of the vagina. Under these circumstances it is sometimes described +as being emitted in a jet which is thrown to a distance.<a name='5_FNanchor_101'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_101'><sup>[101]</sup></a> This mucous +ejaculation was in former days regarded as analogous to the seminal +ejaculation in man, and hence essential to conception. Although this +belief was erroneous the fluid poured out in this manner whenever a high +degree of tumescence is attained, and before the onset of detumescence, +certainly performs an important function in lubricating the entrance to +the genital canal and so facilitating the intromission of the male +organ.<a name='5_FNanchor_102'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_102'><sup>[102]</sup></a> Menstruation has a similar influence in facilitating coitus, +as Schurig long since pointed out.<a name='5_FNanchor_103'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_103'><sup>[103]</sup></a> A like process takes place during +parturition when the same parts are being lubricated and stretched in +preparation for the protrusion of the fœtal head. The occurrence +of the mucous flow in tumescence always indicates that that process is +actively affecting the central sexual organs, and that voluptuous emotions +are present.<a name='5_FNanchor_104'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_104'><sup>[104]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_146'></a> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The secretions of the genital canal and outlet in women are + somewhat numerous. We have the odoriferous glands of sebaceous + origin, and with them the prepuce of the clitoris which has been + described as a kind of gigantic sebaceous follicle with the + clitoris occupying its interior. (Hyrtl.) There is the secretion + from the glands of Bartholin. There is again the vaginal + secretion, opaque and albuminous, which appears to be alkaline + when secreted, but becomes acid under the decomposing influence + of bacteria, which are, however, harmless and not pathogenic. + (Gow, <i>Obstetrical Society of London</i>, January 3, 1894.) There + is, finally, the mucous uterine secretion, which is alkaline, + and, being poured out during orgasm, is believed to protect the + spermatozoa from destruction by the acid vaginal secretion.</p> + +<p> The belief that the mucus poured out in women during sexual + excitement is feminine semen and therefore essential to + conception had many remarkable consequences and was widespread + until the seventeenth century. Thus, in the chapter "De Modo + coeundi et de regimine eorum qui coeunt" of <i>De Secretis + Mulierum</i>, there is insistence on the importance of the proper + mixture of the male semen with the female semen and of arranging + that it shall not escape from the vagina. The woman must lie + quiet for several hours at least, not rising even to urinate, and + when she gets up, be very temperate in eating and drinking, and + not run or jump, pretending that she has a headache. It was the + belief in feminine semen which led some theologians to lay down + that a woman might masturbate if she had not experienced orgasm + in coitus. Schurig in his <i>Muliebria</i> (1729, pp. 159, <i>et seq.</i>) + discusses the opinions of old authors regarding the nature, + source, and uses of the female genital secretions, and quotes + authorities against the old view that it was female semen. In a + subsequent work (<i>Syllepsilogia</i>, 1731, pp. 3, <i>et seq.</i>) he + returns to the same question, quotes authors who accept a + feminine semen, shows that Harvey denied it any significance, and + himself decides against it. It has not seriously been brought + forward since.</p></div> + +<p>When erection is completed in both the man and the woman the conditions +necessary for conjugation have at last been fulfilled. In all animals, +even those most nearly allied to man, coitus is effected by the male +approaching the female posteriorly. In man the normal method of male +approach is anteriorly, face to face. Leonardo da Vinci, in a well-known +drawing representing a sagittal section of a man and a woman connected in +this position of so-called Venus obversa; has shown how well <a name='5_Page_147'></a>adapted the +position is to the normal position of the organs in the human +species.<a name='5_FNanchor_105'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_105'><sup>[105]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Among monkeys, it is stated, congress is sometimes performed when + the female is on all fours; at other times the male brings the + female between his thighs when he is sitting, holding her with + his forepaws. Froriep informed Lawrence that the male sometimes + supported his feet on the female's calves. (Sir W. Lawrence, + <i>Lectures on Physiology</i>, 1823, p. 186.) A summary of the methods + of congress practiced by the various animals below mammals will + be found in the article "Copulation" by H. de Varigny in Richet's + <i>Dictionnaire de Physiologie</i>, vol. iv.</p> + +<p> The anterior position in coitus, with the female partner lying + supine, is so widespread throughout the world that it may fairly + be termed the most typically human attitude in sexual congress. + It is found represented in Egyptian graves at Benihassan, + belonging to the Twelfth Dynasty; it is regarded by Mohammedans + as the normal position, although other positions are permitted by + the Prophet: "Your wives are your tillage: go in unto your + tillage in what manner soever you will;" it is that adopted in + Malacca; it appears, from Peruvian antiquities, to have been the + position generally, though not exclusively, adopted in ancient + Peru; it is found in many parts of Africa, and seems also to have + been the most usual position among the American aborigines.</p> + +<p> Various modifications of this position are, however, found. Thus, + in some parts of the world, as among the Suahelis in Zanzibar, + the male partner adopts the supine position. In Loango, according + to Pechuel-Loesche, coitus is performed lying on the side. + Sometimes, as on the west coast of Africa, the woman is supine + and the man more or less erect; or, as among the Queenslanders + (as described by Roth) the woman is supine and the man squats on + his heels with her thighs clasping his flanks, while he raises + her buttocks with his hands.</p> + +<p> The position of coitus in which the man is supine is without + doubt a natural and frequent variation of the specifically human + obverse method of coitus. It was evidently familiar to the + Romans. Ovid mentions it (<i>Ars Amatoria</i>, III, 777-8), + recommending it to little women, and saying that Andromache was + too tall to practice it with Hector. Aristophanes refers to it, + and there are Greek epigrams in which women boast of their skill + in riding their lovers. It has sometimes been viewed with a + certain disfavor because it seems to confer a superiority on the + woman. "Cursed be he," according to a Mohammedan saying, "who + maketh woman heaven and man earth."</p><a name='5_Page_148'></a> + +<p> Of special interest is the wide prevalence of an attitude in + coitus recalling that which prevails among quadrupeds. The + frequency with which on the walls of Pompeii coitus is + represented with the woman bending forward and her partner + approaching her posteriorly has led to the belief that this + attitude was formerly very common in Southern Italy. However that + may be, it is certainly normal at the present day among various + more or less primitive peoples in whom the vulva is often placed + somewhat posteriorly. It is thus among the Soudanese, as also, in + an altogether different part of the world, among the Eskimo + Innuit and Koniags. The New Caledonians, according to Foley, + cohabit in the quadrupedal manner, and so also the Papuans of New + Guinea (Bongu), according to Vahness. The same custom is also + found in Australia, where, however other postures are also + adopted. In Europe the quadrupedal posture would seem to prevail + among some of the South Slavs, notably the Dalmatians. (The + different methods of coitus practiced by the South Slavs are + described in Κρυπτάδια vol. vi, pp. 220, <i>et seq.</i>)</p> + +<p> This method of coitus was recommended by Lucretius (lib. iv) and + also advised by Paulus Æginetus as favorable to conception. (The + opinions of various early physicians are quoted by Schurig, + <i>Spermatologia</i>, 1720, pp. 232, <i>et seq.</i>). It seems to be a + position that is not infrequently agreeable to women, a fact + which may be brought into connection with the remarks of Adler + already quoted (p. 131) concerning the comparative lack of + adjustment of the feminine organs to the obverse position. It is + noteworthy that in the days of witchcraft hysterical women + constantly believed that they had had intercourse with the Devil + in this manner. This circumstance, indeed, probably aided in the + very marked disfavor in which coitus <i>a posteriori</i> fell after + the decay of classic influences. The mediæval physicians + described it as <i>mos diabolicus</i> and mistakenly supposed that it + produced abortion (Hyrtl, <i>op. cit.</i>, vol. ii, p. 87). The + theologians, needless to say, were opposed to the <i>mos + diabolicus</i>, and already in the Anglo-Saxon Penitential of + Theodore, at the end of the seventh century, 40 days' penance is + prescribed for this method of coitus.</p> + +<p> From the frequency with which they have been adopted by various + peoples as national customs, most of the postures in coitus here + referred to must be said to come within the normal range of + variation. It is a mistake to regard them as vicious perversions.</p></div> + +<p>Up to the point to which we have so far considered it, the process of +detumescence has been mainly nervous and vascular in character; it has, in +fact, been but the more acute stage of a process which has been going on +throughout tumescence.<a name='5_Page_149'></a> But now we reach the point at which a new element +comes in: muscular action. With the onset of muscular action, which is +mainly involuntary, even when it affects the voluntary muscles, +detumescence proper begins to take place. Henceforward purposeful psychic +action, except by an effort, is virtually abolished. The individual, as a +separate person, tends to disappear. He has become one with another +person, as nearly one as the conditions of existence ever permit; he and +she are now merely an instrument in the hands of a higher power—by +whatever name we may choose to call that Power—which is using them for an +end not themselves.</p> + +<p>The decisive moment in the production of the instinctive and involuntary +orgasm occurs when, under the influence of the stimulus applied to the +penis by friction with the vagina, the tension of the seminal fluid poured +into the urethra arouses the ejaculatory center in the spinal cord and the +bulbo-cavernosus muscle surrounding the urethra responsively contracts in +rhythmic spasms. Then it is that ejaculation occurs.<a name='5_FNanchor_106'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_106'><sup>[106]</sup></a></p> + +<p>"The circulation quickens, the arteries beat strongly," wrote Roubaud in a +description of the physical state during coitus which may almost be termed +classic; "the venous blood, arrested by muscular contraction, increases +the general heat, and this stagnation, more pronounced in the brain by the +contraction of the muscles of the neck and the throwing of the head +backward, causes a momentary cerebral congestion, during which +intelligence is lost and the faculties abolished. The eyes, violently +injected, become haggard, and the look uncertain, or, in the majority of +cases, the eyes are closed spasmodically to <a name='5_Page_150'></a>avoid the contact of the +light. The respiration is hurried, sometimes interrupted, and may be +suspended by the spasmodic contraction of the larynx, and the air, for a +time compressed, is at last emitted in broken and meaningless words. The +congested nervous centers only communicate confused sensations and +volitions; mobility and sensation show extreme disorder; the limbs are +seized by convulsions and sometimes by cramps, or are thrown wildly about +or become stiff like iron bars. The jaws, tightly pressed, grind the +teeth, and in some persons the delirium is carried so far that they bite +to bleeding the shoulders their companions have imprudently abandoned to +them. This frantic state of epilepsy lasts but a short time, but it +suffices to exhaust the forces of the organism, especially in man. It is, +I believe, Galen, who said: 'Omne animal post coitum triste præter +mulierem gallumque.'"<a name='5_FNanchor_107'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_107'><sup>[107]</sup></a> Most of the elements that make up this typical +picture of the state of coitus are not absolutely essential to that state, +but they all come within the normal range of variation. There can be no +doubt that this range is considerable. There would appear to be not only +individual, but also racial, differences; there is a remarkable passage in +Vatsyayana's <i>Kama Sutra</i> describing the varying behavior of the women of +different races in India under the stress of sexual excitement—Dravidian +women with difficulty attaining erethism, women of the Punjaub fond of +being caressed with the tongue, women of Oude with impetuous desire and +profuse flow of mucus, etc.—and it is highly probable, Ploss and Bartels +remark, that these characterizations are founded on exact +observations.<a name='5_FNanchor_108'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_108'><sup>[108]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The various phenomena included in Roubaud's description of the condition +during coitus may all be directly or indirectly reduced to two groups: the +first circulatory and respiratory, the second motor. It is necessary to +consider both these aspects of the process of detumescence in somewhat +greater detail, although while it is most convenient to discuss them +separately, <a name='5_Page_151'></a>it must be borne in mind that they are not really separable; +the circulatory phenomena are in large measure a by-product of the +involuntary motor process.</p> + +<p>With the approach of detumescence the respiration becomes shallow, rapid, +and to some extent arrested. This characteristic of the breathing during +sexual excitement is well recognized; so that in, for instance, the +<i>Arabian Nights</i>, it is commonly noted of women when gazing at beautiful +youths whose love they desired, that they ceased breathing.<a name='5_FNanchor_109'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_109'><sup>[109]</sup></a> It may be +added that exactly the same tendency to superficial and arrested +respiration takes place whenever there is any intense mental +concentration, as in severe intellectual work.<a name='5_FNanchor_110'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_110'><sup>[110]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The arrest of respiration tends to render the blood venous, and thus aids +in stimulating the vasomotor centers, raising the blood-pressure in the +body generally, and especially in the erectile tissues. High +blood-pressure is one of the most marked features of the state of +detumescence. The heart beats are stronger and quicker, the surface +arteries are more visible, the conjunctivæ become red. The precise degree +of blood-pressure attained during coitus has been most accurately +ascertained in the dog. In Bechterew's laboratory in St. Petersburg a +manometer was introduced into the central end of the carotid artery of a +bitch; a male dog was then introduced, and during coitus observations were +made on the blood-pressure at the peripheral and central ends of the +artery. It was found that there was a great general elevation of +blood-pressure, intense hyperæmia of the brain, rapid alternations, during +the act, of vasoconstriction and vasodilatation of the brain, with +increase and diminution of the general arterial tension in relation with +the various phases of the act, the greatest cerebral vasodilatation and +hyperæmia coinciding with the moment following the intromission of the +penis; the end of the act is followed by a considerable <a name='5_Page_152'></a>fall in the +blood-pressure.<a name='5_FNanchor_111'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_111'><sup>[111]</sup></a> I am not acquainted with any precise observations on +the blood-pressure in human subjects during detumescence, and there are +obvious difficulties in the way of such observations. It is probable, +however, that the conditions found would be substantially the same. This +is indicated, so far as the very marked increase of blood-pressure is +concerned, by some observations made by Vaschide and Vurpas with the +sphygmanometer on a lady under the influence of sexual excitement. In this +case there was a relationship of sympathy and friendly tenderness between +the experimenter and the subject, Madame X, aged 25. Experimenter and +subject talked sympathetically, and finally, we are told, while the latter +still had her hands in the sphygmanometer, the former almost made a +declaration of love. Madame X was greatly impressed, and afterward +admitted that her emotions had been genuine and strong. The +blood-pressure, which was in this subject habitually 65 millimeters, rose +to 150 and even 160, indicating a very high pressure, which rarely occurs; +at the same time Madame X looked very emotional and troubled.<a name='5_FNanchor_112'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_112'><sup>[112]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Some authorities are of opinion that irregularities in the + accomplishment of the sexual act are specially liable to cause + disturbances in the circulation. Thus Kisch, of Prague, refers to + the case of a couple practising coitus interruptus—the husband + withdrawing before ejaculation—in which the wife, a vigorous + woman, became liable after some years to attacks termed by Kisch + <i>neurasthenia cordis vasomotoria</i>, in which there was at daily or + longer intervals palpitation, with feelings of anxiety, headache, + dizziness, muscular weakness and tendency to faint. He regards + coitus as a cause of various heart troubles in women: (1) Attacks + of tachycardia in very excitable and sexually inclined women; (2) + attacks of tachycardia with dyspnœa in young women, with + vaginismus; (3) cardiac symptoms with lowered vascular tone in + women who for a long time have practised coitus interruptus + without complete sexual gratification (Kisch, "Herzbeschwerden + der Frauen verursacht <a name='5_Page_153'></a>durch den Cohabitationsact," <i>Münchener + Medizinisches Wochenschrift</i>, 1897, p. 617). In this connection, + also, reference may probably be made to those attacks of anxiety + which Freud associates with psychic sexual lesions of an + emotional character.</p></div> + +<p>Associated with this vascular activity in detumescence we find a general +tendency to glandular activity. Various secretions are formed abundantly. +Perspiration is copious, and the ancient relationship between the +cutaneous and sexual systems seems to evoke a general activity of the skin +and its odoriferous secretions. Salivation, which also occurs, is very +conspicuous in many lower animals, as for instance in the donkey, notably +the female, who just before coitus stands with mouth open, jaws moving, +and saliva dribbling. In men, corresponding to the more copious secretion +in women, there is, during the latter stages of tumescence, a slight +secretion of mucus—Fürbringer's <i>urethrorrhœa ex +libidine</i>—which appears in drops at the urethral orifice. It comes from +the small glands of Littré and Cowper which open into the urethra. This +phenomenon was well known to the old theologians, who called it +<i>distillatio</i>, and realized its significance as at once distinct from +semen and an indication that the mind was dwelling on voluptuous images; +it was also known in classic times<a name='5_FNanchor_113'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_113'><sup>[113]</sup></a>; more recently it has often been +confused with semen and has thus sometimes caused needless anxiety to +nervous persons. There is also an increased secretion of urine, and it is +probable that if the viscera were more accessible to observation we might +be able to demonstrate that the glands throughout the body share in this +increased activity.</p> + +<p>The phenomena of detumescence culminate, however, and have their most +obvious manifestation in motor activity. The genital act, as Vaschide and +Vurpas remark, consists essentially <a name='5_Page_154'></a>in "a more and more marked tension of +the motor state which, reaching its maximum, presents a short tonic phase, +followed by a clonic phase, and terminates in a period of adynamia and +repose." This motor activity is of the essence of the impulse of +detumescence, because without it the sperm cells could not be brought into +the neighborhood of the germ cell and be propelled into the organic nest +which is assigned for their conjunction and incubation.</p> + +<p>The motor activity is general as well as specifically sexual. There is a +general tendency to more or less involuntary movement, without any +increase of voluntary muscular power, which is, indeed, decreased, and +Vaschide and Vurpas state that dynamometric results are somewhat lower +than normal during sexual excitement, and the variations greater.<a name='5_FNanchor_114'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_114'><sup>[114]</sup></a> The +tendency to diffused activity of involuntary muscle is well illustrated by +the contraction of the bladder associated with detumescence. While this +occurs in both sexes, in men erection produces a mechanical impediment to +any evacuation of the bladder. In women there is not only a desire to +urinate but, occasionally, actual urination. Many quite healthy and normal +women have, as a rare accident supervening on the coincidence of an +unusually full bladder with an unusual degree of sexual excitement, +experienced a powerful and quite involuntary evacuation of the bladder at +the moment of orgasm. In women with less normal nervous systems this has, +more rarely, been almost habitual. Brantôme has perhaps recorded the +earliest case of this kind in referring to a lady he knew who "quand on +lui faisait cela <a name='5_Page_155'></a>elle se compissait à bon escient."<a name='5_FNanchor_115'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_115'><sup>[115]</sup></a> The tendency to +trembling, constriction of throat, sneezing, emission of internal gas, and +the other similar phenomena occasionally associated with detumescence, are +likewise due to diffusion of the motor disturbance. Even in infancy the +motor signs of sexual excitement are the most obvious indications of +orgasm; thus West, describing masturbation in a child of six or nine +months who practiced thigh-rubbing, states that when sitting in her high +chair she would grasp the handles, stiffen herself, and stare, rubbing her +thighs quickly together several times, and then come to herself with a +sigh, tired, relaxed, and sweating, these seizures, which lasted one or +two minutes, being mistaken by the relations for epileptic fits.<a name='5_FNanchor_116'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_116'><sup>[116]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The essentially motor character of detumescence is well shown by + the extreme forms of erotic intoxication which sometimes appear + as the result of sexual excitement. Féré, who has especially + called attention to the various manifestations of this condition, + presents an instructive case of a man of neurotic heredity and + antecedents, in whom it occasionally happened that sexual + excitement, instead of culminating in the normal orgasm, attained + its climax in a fit of uncontrollable muscular excitement. He + would then sing, dance, gesticulate, roughly treat his partner, + break the objects around him, and finally sink down exhausted and + stupefied. (Féré, <i>L'Instinct Sexuel</i>, Chapter X.) In such a case + a diffused and general detumescence has taken the place of the + normal detumescence which has its main focus in the sexual + sphere.</p> + +<p> The same relationship is shown in a case of impotence accompanied + by cramps in the calves and elsewhere, which has been recorded by + Brügelmann ("Zur Lehre vom Perversen Sexualismus," <i>Zeitschrift + für Hypnotismus</i>, 1900, Heft I). These muscular conditions ceased + for several days whenever coitus was effected.</p> + +<p> An instructive analogy to the motor irradiations preceding the + moment of sexual detumescence may be found in the somewhat + similar motor irradiations which follow the delayed expulsion of + a highly distended bladder. These sometimes become very marked in + a child or <a name='5_Page_156'></a>young woman unable to control the motor system + absolutely. The legs are crossed, the foot swung, the thighs + tightly pressed together, the toes curled. The fingers are flexed + in rhythmic succession. The whole body slowly twists as though + the seat had become uncomfortable. It is difficult to concentrate + the mind; the same remark may be automatically repeated; the eyes + search restlessly, and there is a tendency to count surrounding + objects or patterns. When the extreme degree of tension is + reached it is only by executing a kind of dance that the + explosive contraction of the bladder is restrained.</p> + +<p> The picture of muscular irradiation presented under these + circumstances differs but slightly from that of the onset of + detumescence. In one case the explosion is sought, in the other + case it is dreaded; but in both cases there is a retarded + muscular tension,—in the one case involuntary, in the other case + voluntary—maintained at a point of acute intensity, and in both + cases the muscular irradiations of this tension spread over the + whole body.</p> + +<p> The increased motor irritability of the state of detumescence + somewhat resembles the conditions produced by a weak anæsthetic + and there is some interest in noting the sexual excitement liable + to occur in anæsthesia. I am indebted to Dr. J. F. W. Silk for some + remarks on this point:—</p> + +<p> "I. Sexual emotions may apparently be aroused during the stage of + excitement preceding or following the administration of any + anæsthetic; these emotions may take the form of mere delirious + utterances, or may be associated with what is apparently a sexual + orgasm. Or reflex phenomena connected with the sexual organs may + occasionally be observed under special circumstances; or, to put + it in another way, such reflex possibilities are not always + abolished by the condition of narcosis or anæsthesia.</p> + +<p> "II. Of the particular anæsthetics employed I am inclined to + think that the possibility of such conditions arising is + inversely proportionate to their strength, <i>e.g.</i>, they are more + frequently observed with a weak anæsthetic like nitrous oxide + than with chloroform.</p> + +<p> "III. Sexual emotions I believe to be rarely observable in men, + and this is remarkable, or, I should say, particularly + noticeable, for the presence of nurses, female students, etc., + might almost have led one to expect that the contrary would have + been the case. On the other hand, it is among men that I have + frequently observed a reflex phenomenon which has usually taken + the shape of an erection of the penis when the structures in the + neighborhood of the spermatic cord have been handled.</p> + +<p> "IV. Among females the emotional sexual phenomena most frequently + obtrude themselves, and I believe that if it were possible to + induce people to relate their dreams they would very often be + found to be of a sexual character."</p></div><a name='5_Page_157'></a> + +<p>Much more important than the general motor phenomena, more purposive +though involuntary, are the specifically sexual muscular movements. From +the very beginning of detumescence, indeed, muscular activity makes itself +felt, and the peripheral muscles of sex act, according to Kobelt's +expression, as a peripheral sexual heart. In the male these movements are +fairly obvious and fairly simple. It is required that the semen should be +expressed from the vesiculæ seminales, propelled along the urethra, in +combination with the prostatic fluid which is equally essential, and +finally ejected with a certain amount of force from the urethral orifice. +Under the influence of the stimulation furnished by the contact and +friction of the vagina, this process is effectively carried out, mainly by +the rhythmic contractions of the bulbo-cavernosus muscle, and the semen is +emitted in a jet which may be ejaculated to a distance varying from a few +centimeters to a meter or more.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>With regard to the details of the psychic sides of this process a + correspondent, a psychologist, writes as follows:—</p> + +<p> "I have never noticed in my reading any attempt to analyze the + sensations which accompany the orgasm, and, as I have made a good + many attempts to make such an analysis myself, I will append the + results on the chance that they may be of some value. I have + checked my results so far as possible by comparing them with the + experience of such of my friends as had coitus frequently and + were willing to tell me as much as they could of the psychology + of the process.</p> + +<p> "The first fact that I hit upon was the importance of pressure. + As one of my informants picturesquely phrases it—'the tighter + the fit the greater the pleasure.' This agrees, too, with their + unanimous testimony that the pleasurable sensations were much + greater when the orgasm occurred simultaneously in the man and + woman. Their analysis seldom went further than this, but a few + remarked that the distinctive sensations accompanying the orgasm + seem to begin near the root of the penis or in the testes, and + that they are qualitatively different from the tickling + sensations which precede them.</p> + +<p> "These tickling sensations are caused, I think, by the friction + of the glands against the vaginal walls, and are supplemented by + other sensations from the urethra, whose nerves are stimulated by + pressure of the vaginal walls and sphincter. The specific + sensation of the orgasm begins, I believe, with a strong + contraction of the muscles of the urethral walls along the entire + length of the canal, and is felt as a peculiar <a name='5_Page_158'></a>ache starting + from the base of the penis and quickly becoming diffused through + the whole organ. This sensation reaches its climax with the + expulsion of the semen into the urethra and the consequent + feeling of distention, which is instantly followed by the + rhythmic peristaltic contractions of the urethral muscles which + mark the climax of the orgasm.</p> + +<p> "The most careful introspection possible under the circumstances + seems to show that these sensations arise almost wholly from the + urethra and in a far less degree from the corona. During periods + of great sexual excitement the nerves of the urethra and corona + seem to possess a peculiar sensitivity and are powerfully + stimulated by the violent peristaltic contractions of the muscles + in the urethral walls during ejaculation. It seems possible that + the intensity and volume of sensation felt at the glans may be + due in part to the greater area of sensitive surface presented in + the fossa as well as to the sensitivity of the corona, and in + part to the fact that during the orgasm the glans is more highly + congested than at any other time, and the nerve endings thus + subjected to additional pressure.</p> + +<p> "If the foregoing statements are true, it is easy to see why the + pleasure of the man is much increased when the orgasm occurs at + the same time in his partner and himself, for the contractions of + the vagina upon the penis would increase the stimulation of all + the nerve endings in that organ for which a mechanical stimulus + is adequate, and the prominence of the corpus spongiosum and + corona would ensure them the greatest stimulation. It seems not + improbable that the specific sensation of orgasm rises from the + stimulation of the peculiar form of nerve end-bulbs which Krause + found in the corpus spongiosum and in the glans.</p> + +<p> "The characteristic massiveness of the experience is probably due + largely to the great number of sensations of strain and pressure + caused by the powerful reflex contraction of so many of the + voluntary muscles.</p> + +<p> "Of course, the foregoing analysis is purely tentative, and I + offer it only on the chance that it may suggest some line of + inquiry which may lead to results of value to the student of + sexual psychology."</p> + +<p> In man the whole process of detumescence, when it has once really + begun, only occupies a few moments. It is so likewise in many + animals; in the genera Bos, Ovis, etc., it is very short, almost + instantaneous, and rather short also in the Equidæ (in a vigorous + stallion, according to Colin, ten to twelve seconds). As + Disselhorst has pointed out, this is dependent on the fact that + these animals, like man, possess a vas deferens which broadens + into an ampulla serving as a receptacle which holds the semen + ready for instant emission when required. On the other hand, in + the dog, cat, boar, and the Canidæ, Felidæ, and Suidæ generally, + there is no receptacle of this kind, and coitus is slow, since a + longer time is required for the peristaltic action of the vas to + bring the semen <a name='5_Page_159'></a>to the urogenital sinus. (R. Disselhorst, <i>Die + Accessorischen Geschlechtsdrusen der Wirbelthiere</i>, 1897, p. + 212.)</p> + +<p> In man there can be little doubt that detumescence is more + rapidly accomplished in the European than in the East, in India, + among the yellow races, or in Polynesia. This is probably in part + due to a deliberate attempt to prolong the act in the East, and + in part to a greater nervous erethism among Westerns.</p></div> + +<p>In the woman the specifically sexual muscular process is less visible, +more obscure, more complex, and uncertain. Before detumescence actually +begins there are at intervals involuntary rhythmic contractions of the +walls of the vagina, seeming to have the object of at once stimulating and +harmonizing with those that are about to begin in the male organ. It would +appear that these rhythmic contractions are the exaggeration of a +phenomenon which is normal, just as slight contraction is normal and +constant in the bladder. Jastreboff has shown, in the rabbit, that the +vagina is in constant spontaneous rhythmic contraction from above +downward, not peristaltic, but in segments, the intensity of the +contractions increasing with age and especially with sexual development. +This vaginal contraction which in women only becomes well marked just +before detumescence, and is due mainly to the action of the sphincter +cunni (analogous to the bulbo-cavernosus in the male), is only a part of +the localized muscular process. At first there would appear to be a reflex +peristaltic movement of the Fallopian tubes and uterus. Dembo observed +that in animals stimulation of the upper anterior wall of the vagina +caused gradual contraction of the uterus, which is erected by powerful +contraction of its muscular fiber and round ligaments while at the same +time it descends toward the vagina, its cavity becoming more and more +diminished and mucus being forced out. In relaxing, Aristotle long ago +remarked, it aspirates the seminal fluid.</p> + +<p>Although the active participation of the sexual organs in woman, to the +end of directing the semen into the womb at the moment of detumescence, is +thus a very ancient belief, and harmonizes with the Greek view of the womb +as an animal in <a name='5_Page_160'></a>the body endowed with a considerable amount of +activity,<a name='5_FNanchor_117'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_117'><sup>[117]</sup></a> precise observation in modern times has offered but little +confirmation of the reality of this participation. Such observations as +have been made have usually been the accidental result of sexual +excitement and orgasm occurring during a gynæcological examination. As, +however, such a result is liable to occur in erotic subjects, a certain +number of precise observations have accumulated during the past century. +So far as the evidence goes, it would seem that in women, as in mares, +bitches, and other animals, the uterus becomes shorter, broader, and +softer during the orgasm, at the same time descending lower into the +pelvis, with its mouth open intermittently, so that, as one writer +remarks, spontaneously recurring to the simile which commended itself to +the Greeks, "the uterus might be likened to an animal gasping for +breath."<a name='5_FNanchor_118'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_118'><sup>[118]</sup></a> This sensitive, responsive mobility of the uterus is, +indeed, not confined to the moment of detumescence, but may occur at other +times under the influence of sexual emotion.</p> + +<p>It would seem probable that in this erection, contraction, and descent of +the uterus, and its simultaneous expulsion of mucus, we have the decisive +moment in the completion of detumescence in woman, and it is probable that +the thick mucus, unlike the earlier more limpid secretion, which women are +sometimes aware of after orgasm, is emitted from the womb at this time. +This is, however, not absolutely certain. Some authorities regard +detumescence in women as accomplished in the pouring out of secretions, +others in the rhythmic genital contractions; the sexual parts may, +however, be copiously bathed in mucus for an indefinitely long period +before the final stage of detumescence is achieved, and the rhythmic +contractions are also taking place at a somewhat early period; in neither +respect is there any obvious increase at the final moment of orgasm. In +women this would seem to be more conspicuously a nervous manifestation +than in men. On the subjective side it is very <a name='5_Page_161'></a>pronounced, with its +feeling of relieved tension and agreeable repose—a moment when, as one +woman expresses it, together with intense pleasure, there is, as it were, +a floating up into a higher sphere, like the beginning of chloroform +narcosis—but on the objective side this culminating moment is less easy +to define.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Various observations and remarks made during the past two or + three centuries by Bond, Valisneri, Dionis, Haller, Günther, and + Bischoff, tending to show a sucking action of the uterus in both + women and other female animals, have been brought together by + Litzmann in R. Wagner's <i>Handwörterbuch der Physiologie</i> (1846, + vol. iii, p. 53). Litzmann added an experience of his own: "I had + an opportunity lately, while examining a young and very erethic + woman, to observe how suddenly the uterus assumed a more erect + position, and descended deeper in the pelvis; the lips of the + womb became equal in length, the cervix rounded, softer, and more + easily reached by the finger, and at the same time a high state + of sexual excitement was revealed by the respiration and voice."</p> + +<p> The general belief still remained, however, that the woman's part + in conjugation is passive, and that it is entirely by the energy + of the male organ and of the male sexual elements, the + spermatozoa, that conjunction with the germ cell is attained. + According to this theory, it was believed that the spermatozoa + were, as Wilkinson expresses it, in a history of opinion on this + question, "endowed with some sort of intuition or instinct; that + they would turn in the direction of the os uteri, wading through + the acid mucus of the vagina; travel patiently upward and around + the vaginal portion of the uterus; enter the uterus and proceed + onward in search of the waiting ovum." (A. D. Wilkinson, + "Sterility in the Female," <i>Transactions of the Lincoln Medical + Society</i>, Nebraska, 1896.)</p> + +<p> About the year 1859 Fichstedt seems to have done something to + overthrow this theory by declaring his belief that the uterus was + not, as commonly supposed, a passive organ in coitus, but was + capable of sucking in the semen during the brief period of + detumescence. Various authorities then began to bring forward + arguments and observations in the same sense. Wernich, + especially, directed attention to this point in 1872 in a paper + on the erectile properties of the lower segment of the uterus + ("Die Erectionsfahigkeit des untern Uterus-Abschnitts," <i>Beiträge + zur Geburtshülfe und Gynäkologie</i>, vol. i, p. 296). He made + precise observations and came to the conclusion that owing to + erectile properties in the neck of the uterus, this part of the + womb elongates during congress and reaches down into the pelvis + with an aspiratory movement, as if to meet the glans of the male. + A little later, in a case of partial prolapse, Beck, in ignorance + of Wernich's theory, was enabled to make <a name='5_Page_162'></a>a very precise + observation of the action of the uterus during excitement. In + this case the woman was sexually very excitable even under + ordinary examination, and Beck carefully noted the phenomena that + took place during the orgasm. "The os and cervix uteri," he + states, "had been about as firm as usual, moderately hard and, + generally speaking, in a natural and normal condition, with the + external os closed to such an extent as to admit of the uterine + probe with difficulty; but the instant that the height of + excitement was at hand, the os opened itself to the extent of + fully an inch, as nearly as my eye can judge, made five or six + successive gasps as if it were drawing the external os into the + cervix, each time powerfully, and, it seemed to me, with a + regular rhythmical action, at the same time losing its former + density and hardness and becoming quite soft to the touch. Upon + the cessation of the action, as related, the os suddenly closed, + the cervix again hardened itself, and the intense congestion was + dissipated." (J. R. Beck, "How do the Spermatozoa Enter the + Uterus?" <i>American Journal of Obstetrics</i>, 1874.) It would appear + that in the early part of this final process of detumescence the + action of the uterus is mainly one of contraction and ejaculation + of any mucus that may be contained; Dr. Paul Mundé has described + "the gushing, almost in jets," of this mucus which he has + observed in an erotic woman under a rather long digital and + specular examination. (<i>American Journal of Obstetrics</i>, 1893.) + It is during the latter part of detumescence, it would seem, and + perhaps for a short time after the orgasm is over, that the + action of the uterus is mainly aspiratory.</p></div> + +<p>While the active part played by the womb in detumescence can no longer be +questioned, it need not too hastily be assumed that the belief in the +active movements of the spermatozoa must therefore be denied. The vigorous +motility of the tadpole-like organisms is obvious to anyone who has ever +seen fresh semen under the microscope; and if it is correct, as Clifton +Edgar states, that the spermatozoa may retain their full activity in the +female organs for at least seventeen days, they have ample time to exert +their energies. The fact that impregnation sometimes occurs without +rupture of the hymen is not decisive evidence that there has been no +penetration, as the hymen may dilate without rupturing; but there seems no +reason to doubt that conception has sometimes taken place when ejaculation +has occurred without penetration; this is indicated in a fairly objective +manner when, as has been occasionally observed, conception has occurred in +<a name='5_Page_163'></a>women whose vaginas were so narrow as scarcely to admit the entrance of a +goose-quill; such was the condition in the case of a pregnant woman +brought forward by Roubaud. The stories, repeated in various books, of +women who have conceived after homosexual relations with partners who had +just left their husbands' beds are not therefore inherently +impossible.<a name='5_FNanchor_119'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_119'><sup>[119]</sup></a> Janke quotes numerous cases in which there has been +impregnation in virgins who have merely allowed the penis to be placed in +contact with the vulva, the hymen remaining unruptured until +delivery.<a name='5_FNanchor_120'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_120'><sup>[120]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It must be added, however, that even if the semen is effused merely at the +mouth of the vagina, without actual penetration, the spermatozoa are still +not entirely without any resource save their own motility in the task of +reaching the ovum. As we have seen, it is not only the uterus which takes +an active part in detumescence; the vagina also is in active movement, and +it seems highly probable that, at all events in some women and under some +circumstances, such movement favoring aspiration toward the womb may be +communicated to the external mouth of the vagina.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Riolan (<i>Anthropographia</i>, 1626, p. 294) referred to the + constriction and dilation of the vulva under the influence of + sexual excitement. It is said that in Abyssinia women can, when + adopting the straddling posture of coitus, by the movements of + their own vaginal muscles alone, grasp the male organ and cause + ejaculation, although the man remains passive. According to + Lorion the Annamites, adopting the normal posture of coitus, + introduce the penis when flaccid or only half erect, the + contraction of the vaginal walls completing the process; the + penis is very small in this people. It is recognized by + gynæcologists that the condition of vaginismus, in which there is + spasmodic contraction of the vagina, making intercourse painful + or impossible, is but a morbid exaggeration of the normal + contraction which occurs in sexual excitement. Even in the + absence of sexual excitement there is a vague affection, + occurring in both married and unmarried women, and not, it would + seem, <a name='5_Page_164'></a>necessarily hysterical, characterized by quivering or + twitching of the vulva; I am told that this is popularly termed + "flackering of the shape" in Yorkshire and "taittering of the + lips" in Ireland. It may be added that quivering of the gluteal + muscles also takes place during detumescence, and that in Indian + medicine this is likewise regarded as a sign of sexual desire in + women, apart from coitus.</p> + +<p> A non-medical correspondent in Australia, W. J. Chidley, from whom + I have received many communications on this subject, is strongly + of opinion from his own observations that not only does the + uterus take an active part in coitus, but that under natural + conditions the vagina also plays an active part in the process. + He was led to suspect such an action many years ago, as well by + an experience of his own, as also by hearing from a young woman + who met her lover after a long absence that by the excitement + thus aroused a tape attached to the underclothes had been drawn + into the vagina. Since then the confidences of various friends, + together with observations of animals, have confirmed him in the + view that the general belief that coitus must be effected by + forcible entry of the male organ into a passive vagina is + incorrect. He considers that under normal circumstances coitus + should take place but rarely, and then only under the most + favorable circumstances, perhaps exclusively in spring, and, most + especially, only when the woman is ready for it. Then, when in + the arms of the man she loves, the vagina, in sympathy with the + active movements of the womb, becomes distended at the touch of + the turgescent, but not fully erect, penis, "flashes open and + draws in the male organ." "All animals," he adds, "have sexual + intercourse by the male organ being <i>drawn</i>, not forced, into the + female. I have been borne out in this by friends who have seen + horses, camels, mules and other large animals in the coupling + season. What is more absurd, for instance, than to say that an + entire <i>penetrates</i> the mare? His penis is a sensitive, beautiful + piece of mechanism, which brings its light head here and there + till it touches the right spot, when the mare, <i>if ready</i>, takes + it in. An entire's penis could not penetrate anything; it is a + curve, a beautiful curve which would easily bend. A bull's, + again, is turned down at the end and, more palpably still, would + fold on itself if pressed with force. The womb and vagina of a + beautiful and healthy woman constitute a living, vital, moving + organ, sensitive to a look, a word, a thought, a hand on the + waist."</p> + +<p> A well-known American author thus writes in confirmation of the + foregoing view: "In nature the woman wooes. When impassioned her + vagina becomes erect and dilated, and so lubricated with abundant + mucus to the lips that entrance is easy. This dilatation and + erectile expansion of vagina withdraws the hymen so close to the + walls that penetration need not tear it or cause pain. The more + muscular, primitive and healthy the woman the tougher and less + sensitive the hymen, <a name='5_Page_165'></a>and the less likely to break or bleed. I + think one great function of the foreskin also is to moisten the + glans, so that it can be lubricated for entrance, and then to + retract, moist side out, to make entrance still easier. I think + that in nature the glans penetrates within the labia, is + withstood a moment, vibrating, and then all resistance is + withdrawn by a sudden 'flashing open' of the gates, permitting + easy entrance, and that the sudden giving up of resistance, and + substitution of welcome, with its instantaneous deep entrance, + causes an almost immediate male orgasm (the thrill being + irresistibly exciting). Certainly this is the process as observed + in horses, cattle, goats, etc., and it seems likely something + analogous is natural in man."</p> + +<p> While it is easily possible to carry to excess a view which would + make the woman rather than the man the active agent in coitus + (and it may be recalled that in the Cebidæ the penis, as also the + clitoris, is furnished with a bone), there is probably an element + of truth in the belief that the vagina shares in the active part + which, there can now be little doubt, is played by the uterus in + detumescence. Such a view certainly enables us to understand how + it is that semen effused on the exterior sexual organs can be + conveyed to the uterus.</p> + +<p> It was indeed the failure to understand the vital activity of the + semen and the feminine genital canal, co-operating together + towards the junction of sperm cell and germ cell, which for so + long stood in the way of the proper understanding of conception. + Even the genius of Harvey, which had grappled successfully with + the problem of the circulation, failed in the attempt to + comprehend the problem of generation. Mainly on account of this + difficulty, he was unable to see how the male element could + possibly enter the uterus, although he devoted much observation + and study to the question. Writing of the uterus of the doe after + copulation, he says: "I began to doubt, to ask myself whether the + semen of the male could by any possibility make its way by + attraction or injection to the seat of conception, and repeated + examination led me to the conclusion that none of the semen + reached this seat." (<i>De-Generatione Animalium</i>, Exercise lxvii.) + "The woman," he finally concluded, "after contact with the + spermatic fluid <i>in coitu</i>, seems to receive an influence and + become fecundated without the co-operation of any sensible + corporeal agent, in the same way as iron touched by the magnet is + endowed with its powers."</p></div> + +<p>Although the specifically sexual muscular process of detumescence in +women—as distinguished from the general muscular phenomena of sexual +excitement which may be fairly obvious—is thus seen to be somewhat +complex and obscure, in women as well as in men detumescence is a +convulsion which <a name='5_Page_166'></a>discharges a slowly accumulated store of nervous force. +In women also, as in men, the motor discharge is directed to a specific +end—the intromission of the semen in the one sex, its reception in the +other. In both sexes the sexual orgasm and the pleasure and satisfaction +associated with it, involve, as their most essential element, the motor +activity of the sexual sphere.<a name='5_FNanchor_121'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_121'><sup>[121]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The active co-operation of the female organs in detumescence is + probably indicated by the difficulty which is experienced in + achieving conception by the artificial injection of semen. Marion + Sims stated in 1866, in <i>Clinical Notes on Uterine Surgery</i>, that + in 55 injections in six women he had only once been successful; + he believed that that was the only case at that time on record. + Jacobi had, however, practiced artificial fecundation in animals + (in 1700) and John Hunter in man. See Gould and Pyle, <i>Anomalies + and Curiosities of Medicine</i>, p. 43; also Janke (<i>Die + Willkürliche Hervorbringen des Geschlechts</i>, pp. 230 <i>et seq.</i>) + who discusses the question of artificial fecundation and brings + together a mass of data.</p></div> + +<p>The facial expression when tumescence is completed is marked by a high +degree of energy in men and of loveliness in women. At this moment, when +the culminating act of life is about to be accomplished, the individual +thus reaches his supreme state of radiant beauty. The color is heightened, +the eyes are larger and brighter, the facial muscles are more tense, so +that in mature individuals any wrinkles disappear and youthfulness +returns.</p> + +<p>At the beginning of detumescence the features are frequently more +discomposed. There is a general expression of eager receptivity to sensory +impressions. The dilatation of the pupils, the expansion of the nostrils, +the tendency to salivation and to movements of the tongue, all go to make +up a picture which indicates an approaching gratification of sensory +desires; it is significant that in some animals there is at this moment +erection of the ears.<a name='5_FNanchor_122'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_122'><sup>[122]</sup></a> There is sometimes a tendency to utter broken +and meaningless words, and it is noted that sometimes <a name='5_Page_167'></a>women have called +out on their mothers.<a name='5_FNanchor_123'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_123'><sup>[123]</sup></a> The dilatation of the pupils produces +photophobia, and in the course of detumescence the eyes are frequently +closed from this cause. At the beginning of sexual excitement, Vaschide +and Vurpas have observed, tonicity of the eye-muscles seems to increase; +the elevators of the upper lids contract, so that the eyes look larger and +their mobility and brightness are heightened; with the increase of +muscular tonicity strabismus occurs, owing to the greater strength of the +muscles that carry the eyes inward.<a name='5_FNanchor_124'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_124'><sup>[124]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The facial expression which marks the culmination of tumescence, + and the approach of detumescence is that which is generally + expressive of joy. In an interesting psycho-physical study of the + emotion of joy, Dearborn thus summarizes its characteristics: + "The eyes are brighter and the upper eyelid elevated, as also are + the brows, the skin over the glabella, the upper lip and the + corners of the mouth, while the skin at the outer canthi of the + eye is puckered. The nostrils are moderately dilated, the tongue + slightly extended and the cheeks somewhat expanded, while in + persons with largely developed pinnal muscles the ears tend + somewhat to incline forwards. The whole arterial system is + dilated, with consequent blushing from this effect on the dermal + capillaries of the face, neck, scalp and hands, and sometimes + more extensively even; from the same cause the eyes slightly + bulge. The whole glandular system likewise is stimulated, causing + the secretions,—gastric, salivary, lachrymal, sudoral, mammary, + genital, etc.—to be increased, with the resulting rise of + temperature and increase in the katobolism generally. Volubility + is almost regularly increased, and is, indeed, one of the most + sensitive and constant of the correlations in emotional + delight.... Pleasantness is correlated in living organisms by + vascular, muscular and glandular extension or expansion, both + literal and figurative." (G. Dearborn, "The Emotion of Joy," + <i>Psychological Review Monograph Supplements</i>, vol. ii, No. 5, p. + 62.) All these signs of joy appear to occur at some stage of the + process of sexual excitement.</p> + +<p> In some monkeys it would seem that the muscular movement which in + man has become the smile is the characteristic facial expression + of sexual tumescence or courtship. Discussing the facial + expression of pleasure in children, S. S. Buckman has the + following remarks: "There <a name='5_Page_168'></a>is one point in such expression which + has not received due consideration, namely, the raising of lumps + of flesh each side of the nose as an indication of pleasure. + Accompanying this may be seen small furrows, both in children and + adults, running from the eyes somewhat obliquely towards the + nose. What these characters indicate may be learned from the male + mandril, whose face, particularly in the breeding season, shows + colored fleshy prominences each side of the nose, with + conspicuous furrows and ridges. In the male mandril these + characters have been developed because, being an unmistakable + sign of sexual ardor, they gave the female particular evidence of + sexual feelings. Thus such characters would come to be recognized + as habitually symptomatic of pleasurable feelings. Finding + similar features in human beings, and particularly in children, + though not developed in the same degree, we may assume that in + our monkey-like ancestors facial characters similar to those of + the mandril were developed, though to a less extent, and that + they were symptomatic of pleasure, because connected with the + period of courtship. Then they became conventionalized as + pleasurable symptoms." (S. S. Buckmann, "Human Babies: What They + Teach," <i>Nature</i>, July 5, 1900.) If this view is accepted, it may + be said that the smile, having in man become a generalized sign + of amiability, has no longer any special sexual significance. It + is true that a faint and involuntary smile is often associated + with the later stages of tumescence, but this is usually lost + during detumescence, and may even give place to an expression of + ferocity.</p></div> + +<p>When we have realized how profound is the organic convulsion involved by +the process of detumescence, and how great the general motor excitement +involved, we can understand how it is that very serious effects may follow +coitus. Even in animals this is sometimes the case. Young bulls and +stallions have fallen in a faint after the first congress; boars may be +seriously affected in a similar way; mares have been known even to fall +dead.<a name='5_FNanchor_125'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_125'><sup>[125]</sup></a> In the human species, and especially in men—probably, as Bryan +Robinson remarks, because women are protected by the greater slowness with +which detumescence occurs in them—not only death itself, but innumerable +disorders and accidents have been known to follow immediately after +coitus, these results being mainly due to the vascular and muscular +excitement involved by the processes of detumescence. Fainting, vomiting, +<a name='5_Page_169'></a>urination, defæcation have been noted as occurring in young men after a +first coitus. Epilepsy has been not infrequently recorded. Lesions of +various organs, even rupture of the spleen, have sometimes taken place. In +men of mature age the arteries have at times been unable to resist the +high blood-pressure, and cerebral hæmorrhage with paralysis has occurred. +In elderly men the excitement of intercourse with strange women has +sometimes caused death, and various cases are known of eminent persons who +have thus died in the arms of young wives or of prostitutes.<a name='5_FNanchor_126'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_126'><sup>[126]</sup></a></p> + +<p>These morbid results, are, however, very exceptional. They usually occur +in persons who are abnormally sensitive, or who have imprudently +transgressed the obvious rules of sexual hygiene. Detumescence is so +profoundly natural a process; it is so deeply and intimately a function of +the organism, that it is frequently harmless even when the bodily +condition is far from absolutely sound. Its usual results, under favorable +circumstances, are entirely beneficial. In men there normally supervenes, +together with the relief from the prolonged tension of tumescence, with +the muscular repose and falling blood-pressure,<a name='5_FNanchor_127'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_127'><sup>[127]</sup></a> a sense of profound +satisfaction, a glow of diffused well-being,<a name='5_FNanchor_128'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_128'><sup>[128]</sup></a> perhaps an agreeable +lassitude, occasionally also a sense of mental liberation from an +overmastering obsession. Under reasonably <a name='5_Page_170'></a>happy circumstances there is no +pain, or exhaustion, or sadness, or emotional revulsion. The happy lover's +attitude toward his partner is not expressed by the well-known Sonnet +(CXXIX) of Shakespeare:—</p> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span>"Past reason hunted, and no sooner had<br /></span> +<span>Past reason hated."<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<p>He feels rather with Boccaccio that the kissed mouth loses not its charm,</p> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span>"Bocca baciata non perde ventura."<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<p>In women the results of detumescence are the same, except that the +tendency to lassitude is not marked unless the act has been several times +repeated; there is a sensation of repose and self-assurance, and often an +accession of free and joyous energy. After completely satisfactory +detumescence she may experience a feeling as of intoxication, lasting for +several hours, an intoxication that is followed by no evil reaction.</p> + +<p>Such, so far as our present vague and imperfect knowledge extends, are the +main features in the process of detumescence. In the future, without +doubt, we shall learn to know more precisely a process which has been so +supremely important in the life of man and of his ancestors.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_98'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_98'>[98]</a><div class='note'><p> The elements furnished by the sense of touch in sexual +selection have been discussed in the first section of the previous volume +of these <i>Studies</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_99'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_99'>[99]</a><div class='note'><p> See Appendix A. "The Origins of the Kiss," in the previous +volume.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_100'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_100'>[100]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, Art. "Erection," by Retterer, in Richet's +<i>Dictionnaire de Physiologie</i>, vol. v.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_101'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_101'>[101]</a><div class='note'><p> Guibaut, <i>Traité Clinique des Maladies des Femmes</i>, p. 242. +Adler discusses the sexual secretions in women and their significance, +<i>Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes</i>, pp. 19-26.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_102'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_102'>[102]</a><div class='note'><p> In some parts of the world this is further aided by +artificial means. Thus it is stated by Riedel (as quoted by Ploss and +Bartels) that in the Gorong Archipelago the bridegroom, before the first +coitus, anoints the bride's pudenda with an ointment containing opium, +musk, etc. I have been told of an English bride who was instructed by her +mother to use a candle for the same purpose.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_103'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_103'>[103]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Parthenologia</i>, pp. 302, <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_104'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_104'>[104]</a><div class='note'><p> The connection of this mucous flow with sexual emotion was +discussed early in the eighteenth century by Schurig in his <i>Gynæcologia</i>, +pp. 8-11; it is frequently passed over by more modern writers.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_105'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_105'>[105]</a><div class='note'><p> The drawing is reproduced by Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, +vol. i, Chapter XVII; many facts bearing on the ethnography of coitus are +brought together in this chapter.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_106'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_106'>[106]</a><div class='note'><p> Onanoff (Paris Société de Biologie, May 3, 1890) proposed +the name of bulbo-cavernous reflex for the smart contraction of the +ischio-and bulbo-cavernosus muscles (erector penis and accelerator urinæ) +produced by mechanical excitation of the glans. This reflex is clinically +elicited by placing the index-finger of the left hand on the region of the +bulb while the right hand rapidly rubs the dorsal surface of the glands +with the edge of a piece of paper or lightly pinches the mucous membrane; +a twitching of the region of the bulb is then perceived. This reflex is +always present in healthy adult subjects and indicates the integrity of +the physical mechanism of detumescence. It has been described by Hughes. +(C. H. Hughes, "The Virile or Bulbo-cavernous Reflex," <i>Alienist and +Neurologist</i>, January, 1898.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_107'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_107'>[107]</a><div class='note'><p> Roubaud, <i>Traité de l'Impuissance</i>, 1855, p. 39.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_108'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_108'>[108]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Das Weib</i>, seventh edition, vol. i, p. 510.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_109'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_109'>[109]</a><div class='note'><p> The influence of impeded respiration in exciting more or +less perverted forms of sexual gratification has been discussed in a +section of "Love and Pain" in the third volume of these <i>Studies</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_110'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_110'>[110]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, the experiments of Obici on this point, +<i>Revista Sperimentale di Freniatria</i>, 1903, pp. 689, <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_111'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_111'>[111]</a><div class='note'><p> Summarized in <i>Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, March, +1903, p. 188. The tendency to closure of the eyes noted by Roubaud, to +avoid contact of the light, indicates dilatation of the pupils, for which +we need not seek other explanation than the general tendency of all +peripheral stimulation, according to Schiff's law, to produce such +dilatation.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_112'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_112'>[112]</a><div class='note'><p> Vaschide and Vurpas, "Du Coefficient Sexuel de l'Impulsion +Musicale," <i>Archives de Neurologie</i>, May, 1904.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_113'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_113'>[113]</a><div class='note'><p> In the <i>Priapeia</i> is an inscription which has thus been +translated:—</p> +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span>"You see this organ, after which I'm called<br /></span> +<span>And which is my certificate, is humid;<br /></span> +<span>This moisture is not dew nor drops of rain,<br /></span> +<span>It is the outcome of sweet memory,<br /></span> +<span>Recalling thoughts of a complacent maid."<br /></span> +</div></div> +<p>The translator supposes that semen is referred to, but without doubt the +allusion is to the theologians' <i>distillatio</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_114'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_114'>[114]</a><div class='note'><p> A woman of 30, normal and intelligent, after conversing on +love and passion, and then listening to the music of Grieg and Schumann, +felt real and strong sexual excitement, increased by memories recalled by +the presence of a sympathetic person. When then tested by the dynamometer +the average of ten efforts with the right hand was found to be 28.2 (her +normal average being 31.1) and with the left hand 28.0 (the normal being +30.0). There was, however, great variability in the individual pressures +which sometimes equaled and even exceeded the subject's normal efforts. +The voluntary muscles are thus in harmony with the approaching general +sexual avalanche. (Vaschide and Vurpas, "Quelques Données Expérimentales +sur l'Influence de l'Excitation Sexuelle," <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, +1903, fasc. v-vi.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_115'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_115'>[115]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Cf.</i> MacGillicuddy, <i>Functional Disorders of the Nervous +System in Women</i>, p. 110; Féré, <i>L'Instinct Sexuel</i>, second edition, p. +238; <i>id.</i>, "Note sur une Anomalie de l'instinct Sexuel," <i>Belgique +Médicale</i>, 1905; also "Analysis of the Sexual Impulse," in an earlier +volume of these <i>Studies</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_116'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_116'>[116]</a><div class='note'><p> J. P. West, "Masturbation in Early Childhood," <i>Medical +Standard</i>, November, 1895.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_117'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_117'>[117]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Cf.</i> the discussion of hysteria in "Auto-Erotism," vol. i +of these <i>Studies</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_118'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_118'>[118]</a><div class='note'><p> Hirst, <i>Text-Book of Obstetrics</i>, 1899, p. 67.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_119'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_119'>[119]</a><div class='note'><p> The earliest story of the kind with which I am acquainted, +that of a widow who was thus impregnated by a married friend, is quoted in +Schurig's <i>Spermatologia</i> (p. 224) from Amatus Lusitanus, <i>Curationum +Centuriæ Septum</i>, 1629.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_120'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_120'>[120]</a><div class='note'><p> Janke, <i>Die Willkürliche Hervorbringen des Geschlechts</i>, p. +238.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_121'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_121'>[121]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Cf.</i> Adler, <i>Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des +Weibes</i>, pp. 29-38.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_122'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_122'>[122]</a><div class='note'><p> Féré, <i>Pathologie des Emotions</i>, p. 51.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_123'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_123'>[123]</a><div class='note'><p> This is an instinctive impulse under all strong emotion in +primitive persons. "The Australian Dieri," says A. W. Howitt (<i>Journal +Anthropological Institute</i>, August, 1890), "when in pain or grief cry out +for their father or mother."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_124'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_124'>[124]</a><div class='note'><p> Vaschide and Vurpas, <i>Archives de Neurologie</i>, May, 1904.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_125'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_125'>[125]</a><div class='note'><p> F. B. Robinson, <i>New York Medical Journal</i>, March 11, 1893.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_126'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_126'>[126]</a><div class='note'><p> Féré deals fully with the various morbid results which may +follow coitus, <i>L' Instinct Sexuel</i>, Chapter X; <i>id.</i>, <i>Pathologie des +Emotions</i>, p. 99.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_127'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_127'>[127]</a><div class='note'><p> With regard to the relationship of detumescence to the +blood-pressure Haig remarks: "I think that as the sexual act produces low +and falling blood-pressure, it will of necessity relieve conditions which +are due to high and rising blood-pressure, such, for instance, as mental +depression and bad temper; and, unless my observation deceives me, we have +here a connection between conditions of high blood-pressure, with mental +and bodily depression, and the act of masturbation, for this act will +relieve those conditions, and will tend to be practiced for this purpose." +(A. Haig, <i>Uric Acid</i>, sixth edition, p. 154.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_128'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_128'>[128]</a><div class='note'><p> A medical correspondent speaks of subjective feelings of +temperature coming over the body from 20 to 24 hours after congress, and +marked by sensations of cooling of body and glow of cheeks. In another +case, though lassitude appears on the second day after congress, the first +day after is marked by a notable increase in mental and physical +activity.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_M_III'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_171'></a>III.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Constituents of Semen—Function of the Prostate—The Properties of +Semen—Aphrodisiacs—Alcohol, Opium, etc.—Anaphrodisiacs—The Stimulant +Influence of Semen in Coitus—The Internal Effects of Testicular +Secretions—The Influence of Ovarian Secretion.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>The germ cell never comes into the sphere of consciousness and cannot +therefore concern us in the psychological study of the phenomena of the +sexual instinct. But it is otherwise with the sperm cell, and the seminal +fluid has a relationship, both direct and indirect, to psychic phenomena +which it is now necessary to discuss.</p> + +<p>While the spermatozoa are formed in the glandular tissue of the testes, +the seminal fluid as finally emitted in detumescence is not a purely +testicular product, but is formed by mixture with the fluids poured out at +or before detumescence by various glands which open into the urethra, and +notably the prostate.<a name='5_FNanchor_129'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_129'><sup>[129]</sup></a> This is a purely sexual gland, which in animals +only becomes large and active during the breeding season, and may even be +hardly distinguishable at other times; moreover, if the testes are removed +in infancy, the prostate remains rudimentary, so that during recent years +removal of the testes has been widely advocated and practiced for that +hypertrophy of the prostate which is sometimes a distressing ailment of +old age. It is the prostatic fluid, according to Fürbringer, which imparts +its characteristic odor to semen. It appears, however, to be the main +function of the prostatic fluid to arouse and maintain the motility of the +spermatozoa; before meeting the prostatic fluid the spermatozoa are +motionless; that fluid seems to furnish <a name='5_Page_172'></a>a thinner medium in which they +for the first time gain their full vitality.<a name='5_FNanchor_130'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_130'><sup>[130]</sup></a></p> + +<p>When at length the semen is ejaculated, it contains various substances +which may be separated from it,<a name='5_FNanchor_131'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_131'><sup>[131]</sup></a> and possesses various qualities, some +of which have only lately been investigated, while others have evidently +been known to mankind from a very early period. "When held for some time +in the mouth," remarked John Hunter, "it produces a warmth similar to +spices, which lasts some time."<a name='5_FNanchor_132'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_132'><sup>[132]</sup></a> Possibly this fact first suggested +that semen might, when ingested, possess valuable stimulant qualities, a +discovery which has been made by various savages, notably by the +Australian aborigines, who, in many parts of Australia, administer a +potion of semen to dying or feeble members of the tribe.<a name='5_FNanchor_133'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_133'><sup>[133]</sup></a> It is +perhaps noteworthy that in Central Africa the testes of the goat are +consumed as an aphrodisiac.<a name='5_FNanchor_134'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_134'><sup>[134]</sup></a> In eighteenth century Europe, Schurig, in +his <i>Spermatologia</i>, still found it necessary to discuss at considerable +length the possible medical properties of human semen, giving many +prescriptions which contained it.<a name='5_FNanchor_135'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_135'><sup>[135]</sup></a> The stimulation produced by the +ingestion of semen would appear to form in some cases a part of the +attraction exerted by <i>fellatio</i>; De Sade emphasized this point; and in a +case recorded by Howard semen appears to have acted as a stimulant for +which the craving was as irresistible as is that for alcohol in +dipsomania.<a name='5_FNanchor_136'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_136'><sup>[136]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It must be remembered that the early history of this subject is + more or less inextricably commingled with folk-lore practices of + magical <a name='5_Page_173'></a>origin, not necessarily founded on actual observation of + the physiological effects of consuming the semen or testes. Thus, + according to W. H. Pearse (<i>Scalpel</i>, December, 1897), it is the + custom in Cornwall for country maids to eat the testicles of the + young male lambs when they are castrated in the spring, the + survival, probably, of a very ancient religious cult. (I have not + myself been able to hear of this custom in Cornwall.) In + Burchard's Penitential (Cap. CLIV, Wasserschleben, <i>op. cit.</i>, p. + 660) seven years' penance is assigned to the woman who swallows + her husband's semen to make him love her more. In the seventeenth + century (as shown in William Salmon's <i>London Dispensatory</i>, + 1678) semen was still considered to be good against witchcraft + and also valuable as a love-philter, in which latter capacity its + use still survives. (Bourke, <i>Scatalogic Rites</i>, pp. 343, 355.) + In an earlier age (Picart, quoted by Crawley, <i>The Mystic Rose</i>, + p. 109) the Manichæans, it is said, sprinkled their eucharistic + bread with human semen, a custom followed by the Albigenses.</p> + +<p> The belief, perhaps founded in experience, that semen possesses + medical and stimulant virtues was doubtless fortified by the + ancient opinion that the spinal cord is the source of this fluid. + This was not only held by the highest medical authorities in + Greece, but also in India and Persia.</p> + +<p> The semen is thus a natural stimulant, a physiological + aphrodisiac, the type of a class of drugs which have been known + and cultivated in all parts of the world from time immemorial. + (Dufour has discussed the aphrodisiacs used in ancient Rome, + <i>Histoire de la Prostitution</i>, vol. II, ch. 21.) It would be vain + to attempt to enumerate all the foods and medicaments to which + has been ascribed an influence in heightening the sexual impulse. + (Thus, in the sixteenth century, aphrodisiacal virtues were + attributed to an immense variety of foods by Liébault in his + <i>Thresor des Remèdes Secrets pour les Maladies des Femmes</i>, 1585, + pp. 104, <i>et seq.</i>) A large number of them certainly have no such + effect at all, but have obtained this credit either on some + magical ground or from a mistaken association. Thus the potato, + when first introduced from America, had the reputation of being a + powerful aphrodisiac, and the Elizabethan dramatists contain many + references to this supposed virtue. As we know, potatoes, even + when taken in the largest doses, have not the slightest + aphrodisiac effect, and the Irish peasantry, whose diet consists + very largely of potatoes, are even regarded as possessing an + unusually small measure of sexual feeling. It is probable that + the mistake arose from the fact that potatoes were originally a + luxury, and luxuries frequently tend to be regarded as + aphrodisiacs, since they are consumed under circumstances which + tend to arouse the sexual desires. It is possible also that, as + has been plausibly suggested, the misunderstanding may have been + due to sailors—the first to be familiar with the potato—who + <a name='5_Page_174'></a>attributed to this particular element of their diet ashore the + generally stimulating qualities of their life in port. The eryngo + (<i>Eryngium maritimum</i>), or sea holly, which also had an erotic + reputation in Elizabethan times, may well have acquired it in the + same way. Many other vegetables have a similar reputation, which + they still retain. Thus onions are regarded as aphrodisiacal, and + were so regarded by the Greeks, as we learn from Aristophanes. It + is noteworthy that Marro, a reliable observer, has found that in + Italy, both in prisons and asylums, lascivious people are fond of + onions (<i>La Pubertà</i>, p. 297), and it may perhaps be worth while + to recall the observation of Sérieux that in a woman in whom the + sexual instinct only awoke in middle age there was a horror of + leeks. In some countries, and especially in Belgium, celery is + popularly looked upon as a sexual stimulant. Various condiments, + again, have the same reputation, perhaps because they are hot and + because sexual desire is regarded, rightly enough, as a kind of + heat. Fish—skate, for instance, and notably oysters and other + shellfish—are very widely regarded as aphrodisiacs, and Kisch + attributes this property to caviar. It is probable that all these + and other foods which have obtained this reputation, in so far as + they have any action whatever on the sexual appetite, only + possess it by virtue of their generally nutritious and + stimulating qualities, and not by the presence of any special + principle having a selective action on the sexual sphere. A + beefsteak is probably as powerful a sexual stimulant as any food; + a nutritious food, however, which is at the same time easily + digestible, and thus requiring less expenditure of energy for its + absorption, may well exert a specially rapid and conspicuous + stimulant effect. But it is not possible to draw a line, and, as + Aquinas long since said, if we wish to maintain ourselves in a + state of purity we shall fear even an immoderate use of bread and + water.</p> + +<p> More definitely aphrodisiacal effects are produced by drugs, and + especially by drugs which in large doses are poisons. The + aphrodisiac with the widest popular reputation is cantharides, + but its sexually exciting effects are merely an accidental result + of its action in causing inflammation of the genito-urinary + passage, and it is both an uncertain and a dangerous result, + except in skillful hands and when administered in small doses. + Nux vomica (with its alkaloid strychnia), by virtue of its + special action on the spinal cord, has a notably pronounced + effect in heightening the irritability of the spinal ejaculatory + center, though it by no means necessarily exerts any + strengthening influence. Alcohol exerts a sexually exciting + effect, but in a different manner; it produces little stimulation + of the cord and, indeed, even paralyzes the lumbar sexual center + in large doses, but it has an influence on the peripheral + nerve-endings and on the skin, and also on the cerebral centers, + tending to arouse desire and to diminish inhibition. In this + latter way, as Adler remarks, it may, in small doses, under some + circumstances, be <a name='5_Page_175'></a>beneficial in men with an excessive + nervousness or dread of coitus, and women, in whom orgasm has + been difficult to reach, have frequently found this facilitated + by some previous indulgence in alcohol. The aphrodisiac effect of + alcohol seems specially marked on women. But against the use of + alcohol as an aphrodisiac it must be remembered that it is far + from being a tonic to detumescence, at all events in men, and + that there is much evidence tending to show that not only chronic + alcoholism, but even procreation during intoxication is perilous + to the offspring (see, <i>e.g.</i>, Andriezen, <i>Journal of Mental + Science</i>, January, 1905, and <i>cf.</i> W. C. Sullivan, "Alcoholism and + Suicidal Impulses," <i>ib.</i>, April, 1898, p. 268); it may be added + that Bunge has found a very high proportion of cases of + immoderate use of alcohol in the fathers of women unable to + suckle their infants (G. von Bunge, <i>Die Zunehmende Unfähigkeit + der Frauen ihre Kinder zu Stillen</i>, 1903) while even an + approximation to the drunken state is far from being a desirable + prelude to the creation of a new human being. It is obvious that + those who wish, for any reason, to cultivate a strict chastity of + thought and feeling would do well to avoid alcohol altogether, or + only in its lightest forms and in moderation. The aphrodisiacal + effects of wine have long been known; Ovid refers to them + (<i>e.g.</i>, <i>Ars Am.</i>, Bk. III, 765). Clement of Alexandria, who was + something of a man of science as well as a Christian moralist, + points out the influence of wine in producing lasciviousness and + sexual precocity. (<i>Pædagogus</i>, Bk. II, Chapter II). Chaucer + makes the Wife of Bath say in the Wife of Bath's Prologue:—</p></div> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span class='i4'>"And, after wyn, on Venus moste [needs] I thinke:<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>For al so siken as cold engendreth hayl,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>A likerous mouth moste have a likerous tayl,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>In womman vinolent is no defense,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>This knowen lechours by experience."<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Alcohol, as Chaucer pointed out, comes to the aid of the man, who + is unscrupulous in his efforts to overcome a woman, and this not + merely by virtue of its aphrodisiacal effects, and the apparently + special influence which it seems to exert on women, but also + because it lulls the mental and emotional characteristics which + are the guardians of personality. A correspondent who has + questioned on this point a number of prostitutes he has known, + writes: "Their accounts of the first fall were nearly always the + same. They got to know a 'gentleman,' and on one occasion they + drank too much; before they quite realized what was happening + they were no longer virgins." "In the mental areas, under the + influence of alcohol," Schmiedeberg remarks (in his <i>Elements of + Pharmacology</i>), "the finer degrees of observation, judgment, and + reflection are the first to disappear, while the remaining mental + functions remain in a normal condition. The soldier acts more + boldly because he notices <a name='5_Page_176'></a>dangers less and reflects over them + less; the orator does not allow himself to be influenced by any + disturbing side-considerations as to his audience, hence he + speaks more freely and spiritedly; self-consciousness is lost to + a very great extent, and many are astounded at the ease with + which they can express their thoughts, and at the acuteness of + their judgment in matters which, when they are perfectly sober, + with difficulty reach their minds; and then afterwards they are + ashamed at their mistakes."</p> + +<p> The action of opium in small doses is also to some extent + aphrodisiacal; it slightly stimulates both the brain and the + spinal cord, and has sensory effects on the skin like alcohol; + these effects are favored by the state of agreeable dreaminess it + produces. In the seventeenth century Venette (<i>La Génération de + l'Homme</i>, Part II, Chapter V) strongly recommended small doses of + opium, then little known, for this purpose; he had himself, he + says, in illness experienced its joys, "a shadow of those of + heaven." In India opium (as well as cannabis indica) has long + been a not uncommon aphrodisiac; it is specially used to diminish + local sensibility, delaying the orgasm and thus prolonging the + sexual act. (W. D. Sutherland, "De Impotentia," <i>Indian Medical + Gazette</i>, January, 1900). Its more direct and stimulating + influence on the sexual emotions seems indicated by the statement + that prostitutes are found standing outside the opium-smoking + dens of Bombay, but not outside the neighboring liquor shops. + (G. C. Lucas, <i>Lancet</i>, February 2, 1884.) Like alcohol, opium + seems to have a marked aphrodisiacal effect on women. The case is + recorded of a mentally deranged girl, with no nymphomania though + she masturbated, who on taking small doses of opium at once + showed signs of nymphomania, following men about, etc. (<i>American + Journal Obstetrics</i>, May, 1901, p. 74.) It may well be believed + that opium acts beneficially in men when the ejaculatory centers + are weak but irritable; but its actions are too widespread over + the organism to make it in any degree a valuable aphrodisiac. + Various other drugs have more or less reputation as aphrodisiacs; + thus bromide of gold, a nervous and glandular stimulant, is said + to have as one of its effects a heightening of sexual feeling. + Yohimbin, an alkaloid derived from the West African Yohimbehe + tree, has obtained considerable repute during recent years in the + treatment of impotence; in some cases (see, <i>e.g.</i>, Toff's + results, summarized in <i>British Medical Journal</i>, February 18, + 1905) it has produced good results, apparently by increasing the + blood supply to the sexual organs, but has not been successful in + all cases or in all hands. It must always be remembered that in + cases of psychical impotence suggestion necessarily exerts a + beneficial influence, and this may work through any drug or + merely with the aid of bread pills. All exercise, often even + walking, may be a sexual stimulant, and it is scarcely necessary + to add that powerful stimulation of the skin in the sexual + sphere, <a name='5_Page_177'></a>and more especially of the nates, is often a more + effective aphrodisiac than any drug, whether the irritation is + purely mechanical, as by flogging, or mechanico-chemical, as by + urtication or the application of nettles. Among the Malays (with + whom both men and women often use a variety of plants as + aphrodisiacs, according to Vaughan Stevens) Breitenstein states + (<i>21 Jahre in India</i>, Theil I, p. 228) that both massage and + gymnastics are used to increase sexual powers. The local + application of electricity is one of the most powerful of + aphrodisiacs, and McMordie found on applying one pole to a + uterine sound in the uterus and the other to the abdominal wall + that in the majority of healthy women the orgasm occurred.</p> + +<p> Among anaphrodisiacs, or sexual sedatives, bromide of potassium, + by virtue of its antidotal relationship to strychnia, is one of + the drugs whose action is most definite, though, while it dulls + sexual desire, it also dulls all the nervous and cerebral + activities. Camphor has an ancient reputation as an + anaphrodisiac, and its use in this respect was known to the Arabs + (as may be seen by a reference to it in the <i>Perfumed Garden</i>), + while, as Hyrtl mentions (<i>loc. cit.</i> ii, p. 94), rue (<i>Ruta + graveolens</i>) was considered a sexual sedative by the monks of + old, who on this account assiduously cultivated it in their + cloister gardens to make <i>vinum rutæ</i>. Recently heroin in large + doses (see, <i>e.g.</i>, Becker, <i>Berliner Klinische Wochenschrift</i>, + November 23, 1903) has been found to have a useful effect in this + direction. It may be doubted, however, whether there is any + satisfactory and reliable anaphrodisiac. Charcot, indeed, it is + said, used to declare that the only anaphrodisiac in which he had + any confidence was that used by the uncle of Heloïse in the case + of Abelard. "<i>Cela</i> (he would add with a grim smile) <i>tranche la + difficulte</i>."</p></div> + +<p>If semen is a stimulant when ingested, it is easy to suppose that it may +exert a similar action on the woman who receives it into the vagina in +normal sexual congress. It is by no means improbable that, as Mattei +argued in 1878, this is actually the case. It is known that the vagina +possesses considerable absorptive power. Thus Coen and Levi, among others, +have shown that if a tampon soaked in a solution of iodine is introduced +into the vagina, iodine will be found in the urine within an hour. And the +same is true of various other substances.<a name='5_FNanchor_137'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_137'><sup>[137]</sup></a> If the vagina absorbs drugs +it probably absorbs semen. Toff, of Braila (Roumania), who attaches much +importance to such absorption, considers that it must be analogous to the +ingestion of organic extractives. It is due to this influence, he +believes, <a name='5_Page_178'></a>that weak and anæmic girls so often become full-blooded and +robust after marriage, and lose their nervous tendencies and shyness.<a name='5_FNanchor_138'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_138'><sup>[138]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is, however, most certainly a mistake to suppose that the beneficial +influence of coitus on women is exclusively, or even mainly, dependent +upon the absorption of semen. This is conclusively demonstrated by the +fact that such beneficial influence is exerted, and in full measure, even +when all precautions have been taken to avoid any contact with the semen. +In so far as <i>coitus reservatus</i> or <i>interruptus</i> may lead to haste or +discomfort which prevents satisfactory orgasm on the part of the woman, it +is without doubt a cause of defective detumescence and incomplete +satisfaction. But if orgasm is complete the beneficial effects of coitus +follow even if there has been no possibility of the absorption of semen. +Even after <i>coitus interruptus</i>, if it can be prolonged for a period long +enough for the woman to attain full and complete satisfaction, she is +enabled to experience what she may describe as a feeling of intoxication, +lasting for several hours. It is in the action of the orgasm itself, and +the vascular, secretory, and metabolic activities set up by the psychic +and nervous influence of coitus with a beloved person, that we must seek +the chief key to the effects produced by coitus on women, however these +effects may possibly be still further heightened by the actual absorption +of semen.<a name='5_FNanchor_139'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_139'><sup>[139]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The positive action of semen, or rather of the testicular products, has +been much investigated during recent years, and appears on the whole to be +demonstrated. The notable discovery <a name='5_Page_179'></a>by Brown-Séquard, a quarter of a +century ago, that the ingestion of the testicular juices in states of +debility and senility acted as a beneficial stimulant and tonic, opened +the way to a new field of therapeutics. Many investigators in various +countries have found that testicular extracts, and more especially the +spermin as studied by Poehl,<a name='5_FNanchor_140'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_140'><sup>[140]</sup></a> and by him regarded as a positive +katalysator or accelerator of metabolic processes, exert a real influence +in giving tone to the heart and other muscles, and in improving the +metabolism of the tissues even when all influences of mental suggestion +have been excluded.<a name='5_FNanchor_141'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_141'><sup>[141]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>As the ovaries are strictly analogous to the testes, it was + surmised that ovarian extract might prove a drug equally valuable + with testicular products. As a matter of fact, ovarian extract, + in the form of ovarin, etc., would seem to have proved beneficial + in various disorders, more especially in anæmia and in troubles + due to the artificial menopause. In most conditions, however, in + which it has been employed the results are doubtful or uncertain, + and some authorities believe that the influence of suggestion + plays a considerable part here.</p></div> + +<p>There is, however, another use which is subserved by the testicular +products, a use which may indeed be said to be implied in those uses to +which reference has already been made, but is yet historically the latest +to be realized and studied. It was not until 1869 that Brown-Séquard first +suggested that an important secretion was elaborated by the ductless +glands and received into the circulation, but that suggestion proved to be +epoch-making. If these glandular secretions are so valuable when +administered as drugs to other persons, must they not be of far greater +value when naturally secreted and poured out into the circulation in the +living body? It is now generally <a name='5_Page_180'></a>believed, on the basis of a large and +various body of evidence, that this is undoubtedly so. In a very crude +form, indeed, this belief is by no means modern. In opposition to the old +writers who were inclined to regard the semen as an excretion which it was +beneficial to expel, there were other ancient authorities who argued that +it was beneficial to retain it as being a vital fluid which, if +reabsorbed, served to invigorate the body. The great physiologist, Haller, +in the middle of the eighteenth century, came very near to the modern +doctrine when he stated in his <i>Elements of Physiology</i> that the sperm +accumulated in the seminical vesicles is pumped back into the blood, and +thus produces the beard and the hair together with the other surprising +changes of puberty which are absent in the eunuch. The reabsorption of +semen can scarcely be said to be a part of the modern physiological +doctrine, but it is at least now generally held that the testes secrete +substances which pass into the circulation and are of immense importance +in the development of the organism.</p> + +<p>The experiments of Shattock and Seligmann indicate that the semen and its +reabsorption in the seminal vesicles, or the nervous reactions produced by +its presence, can have no part in the formation of secondary sexual +characters. These investigators occluded the vas deferens in sheep by +ligature, at an early age, rendering them later sterile though not +impotent. The secondary sexual characters appeared as in ordinary sheep. +Spermatogenesis, these inquirers conclude, may be the initial factor, but +the results must be attributed to the elaboration by the testicles of an +internal secretion and its absorption into the general circulation.<a name='5_FNanchor_142'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_142'><sup>[142]</sup></a></p> + +<p>When animals are castrated there is enlargement of the ductless glands in +the body, notably the thyroid and the suprarenal capsules.<a name='5_FNanchor_143'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_143'><sup>[143]</sup></a> It is +evident, therefore, that the secretions of <a name='5_Page_181'></a>these ductless glands are in +some degree compensatory to those of the testes. But this compensatory +action is inadequate to produce any sexual development in the absence of +the testes.</p> + +<p>We see, therefore, how extremely important is the function of the testis. +Its significance is not alone for the race, it is not simply concerned +with the formation of the spermatozoa which share equally with the ova the +honor of making the mankind of the future. It also has a separate and +distinct function which has reference to the individual. It elaborates +those internal secretions which stimulate and maintain the physical and +mental characters, constituting all that is most masculine in the male +animal, all that makes the man in distinction from the eunuch. Among +various primitive peoples, including those of the European race whence we +ourselves spring, the most solemn form of oath was sworn by placing the +hand on the testes, dimly recognized as the most sacred part of the body. +A crude and passing phase of civilization has ignorantly cast ignominy +upon the sexual organs; the more primitive belief is now justified by our +advancing knowledge.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In these as in other respects the ovaries are precisely analogous + to the testes. They not only form the ova, but they elaborate for + internal use a secretion which develops and maintains the special + physical and mental qualities of womanhood, as the testicular + secretion those of manhood. Moreover, as Cecca and Zappi found, + removal of the ovaries has exactly the same effect on the + abnormal development of the other ductless glands as has removal + of the testes. It is of interest to point out that the internal + secretion of the ovaries and its important functions seem to have + been suggested before any other secretion than the sperm was + attributed to the testes. Early in the nineteenth century Cabanis + argued ("De l'Influence des Sexes sur le Caractère des Idées et + des Affections Morales," <i>Rapport du Physique et du Moral de + l'Homme</i>, 1824, vol. ii, p. 18) that the ovaries are secreting + glands, forming a "particular humor" which is reabsorbed into the + blood and imparts excitations which are felt by the whole system + and all its organs.</p></div> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_129'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_129'>[129]</a><div class='note'><p> The composite character of the semen was recognized by +various old authors, some of whom said, (<i>e.g.</i>, Wharton) that it had +three constituents, which they usually considered to be: (1) The noblest +and most essential part, from the testicles; (2) a watery element from the +vesiculæ; (3) an oily element from the prostate. Schurig, <i>Spermatologia</i>, +1720, p. 17.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_130'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_130'>[130]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, C. Mansell Moulin, "A Contribution to the +Morphology of the Prostate," <i>Journal of Anatomy and Physiology</i>, January, +1895; G. Walker, "A Contribution to the Anatomy and Physiology of the +Prostate Gland, and a Few Observations on Ejaculation," <i>Johns Hopkins +Hospital Bulletin</i>, October, 1900.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_131'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_131'>[131]</a><div class='note'><p> For a study of the semen and its constituents, see +Florence, "Du Sperme," <i>Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, 1895.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_132'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_132'>[132]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Hunter, <i>Essays and Observations</i>, vol. i, p. 189.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_133'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_133'>[133]</a><div class='note'><p> As regards one part of Australia, Walter Roth, +<i>Ethnological Studies Among the Queensland Aborigines</i>, p. 174.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_134'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_134'>[134]</a><div class='note'><p> Sir H. H. Johnston, <i>British Central Africa</i>, p. 438.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_135'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_135'>[135]</a><div class='note'><p> Cap. VII, pp. 327-357, "De Spermaticis virilis usu +Medico,"</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_136'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_136'>[136]</a><div class='note'><p> W. L. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," <i>Alienist and +Neurologist</i>, January, 1896.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_137'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_137'>[137]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Zentralblatt für Gynäkologie</i>, 1894, No. 49.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_138'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_138'>[138]</a><div class='note'><p> E. Toff, "Uber Imprägnierung," <i>Zentralblatt für +Gynäkologie</i>, April, 1903. In a similar but somewhat more precise manner +Dufougère has argued ("La Chlorose, ses rapports avec le marriage, son +traitement par le liquide orchitique," Thèse de Bordeaux, 1902) that semen +when absorbed by the vagina stimulates the secretion of the ovaries and +thus exerts an influence over the blood in anæmia; in this way he seeks to +explain why it is that coitus is the best treatment for chlorosis.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_139'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_139'>[139]</a><div class='note'><p> In this connection I may refer to an interesting and +suggestive paper by Harry Campbell on "The Craving for Stimulants" +(<i>Lancet</i>, October 21, 1899). No reference is made to coitus, but the +author discusses stimulants as normal and beneficial products of the +organism, and deals with the nature of the "physiological intoxication" +they produce.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_140'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_140'>[140]</a><div class='note'><p> Spermin was first discovered in the sperm by Schreiner in +1878; it has also been found in the thyroid, ovaries and various other +glands. "The spermin secreting and elaborating organs," Howard Kelly +remarks (<i>British Medical Journal</i>, January 29, 1898), "may be called the +apothecaries' of the body, secreting many important medicaments, much more +active and more accurately representing its true wants than artificially +administered drugs."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_141'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_141'>[141]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, a summary of Buschan's comprehensive +discussion of the subject of organotherapy (Eulenburg's <i>Real-Encyclopædie +der Gesammten Heilkunde</i>) in <i>Journal of Mental Science</i>, April, 1899, p. +355.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_142'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_142'>[142]</a><div class='note'><p> "Observations Upon the Acquirement of Secondary Sexual +Characters, Indicating the Formation of an Internal Secretion by the +Testicles," <i>Proceedings Royal Society</i>, vol. lxxiii, p. 49.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_143'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_143'>[143]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, the experiments of Cecca and Zappi, summarized +in <i>British Medical Journal</i>, July 2, 1904.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_M_IV'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_182'></a>IV.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Aptitude for Detumescence—Is There an Erotic Temperament?—The +Available Standards of Comparison—Characteristics of the +Castrated—Characteristics of Puberty—Characteristics of the State of +Detumescence—Shortness of Stature—Development of the Secondary Sexual +Characters—Deep Voice—Bright Eyes—Glandular Activity—Everted +Lips—Pigmentation—Profuse Hair—Dubious Significance of Many of These +Characters.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>What, if any, are the indications which the body generally may furnish as +to the individual's aptitude and vigor for the orgasm of detumescence? Is +there an erotic temperament outwardly and visibly displayed? That is a +question which has often occupied those who have sought to penetrate the +more intimate mysteries of human nature, and since we are here concerned +with human beings in their relationship to the process of detumescence, we +cannot altogether pass over this question, difficult as it is to discuss +it with precision.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The old physiognomists showed much confidence in dealing with the + matter. Possibly they had more opportunities for observation than + we have, since they often wrote in days when life was lived more + nakedly than among ourselves, but their descriptions, while + sometimes showing much insight, are inextricably mixed up with + false science and superstition.</p> + +<p> In the <i>De Secretis Mulierum</i>, wrongly attributed to Albertus + Magnus, we find a chapter entitled "Signa mulieris calidæ naturæ + et quæ coit libenter," which may be summarized here. "The signs," + we are told, "of a woman of warm temperament, and one who + willingly cohabits are these: youth, an age of over 12, or + younger, if she has been seduced, small, high breasts, full and + hard, hair in the usual positions; she is bold of speech, with a + delicate and high voice, haughty and even cruel of disposition, + of good complexion, lean rather than stout, inclined to like + drinking. Such a woman always desires coitus, and receives + satisfaction in the act. The menstrual flow is not abundant nor + always regular. If she becomes pregnant the milk is not abundant. + Her perspiration is less odorous than that of the woman of + opposite <a name='5_Page_183'></a>temperament; she is fond of singing, and of moving + about, and delights in adornments if she has any."</p> + +<p> Polemon, in his <i>Sulla Physionomia</i>, has given among the signs of + libidinous impulse: knees turned inwards, abundance of hairs on + the legs, squint, bright eyes, a high and strident voice, and in + women length of leg below the knee. Aristotle had mentioned among + the signs of wantonness: paleness, abundance of hair on the body, + thick and black hair, hairs covering the temples, and thick + eyelids.</p> + +<p> In the seventeenth century Bouchet, in his <i>Serées</i> (Troisième + Serée), gave as the signs of virility which indicated that a man + could have children: a great voice, a thick rough black beard, a + large thick nose.</p> + +<p> G. Tourdes (Art. "Aphrodisie," <i>Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des + Sciences Médicales</i>) thus summarized the ancient beliefs on this + subject: "The erotic temperament has been described as marked by + a lean figure, white and well-ranged teeth, a developed hairy + system, a characteristic voice, air, and expression, and even a + special odor."</p></div> + +<p>In approaching the question of the general physical indications of a +special aptitude to the manifestation of vigorous detumescence, the most +obvious preliminary would seem to be a study of the castrated. If we know +the special peculiarities of those who by removal of the sexual glands at +a very early age have been deprived of all ability to present the +manifestations of detumescence, we shall probably be in possession of a +type which is the reverse of that which we may expect in persons of a +vigorously erotic temperament.</p> + +<p>The most general characteristics of eunuchs would appear to be an unusual +tendency to put on fat, a notably greater length of the legs, absence of +hair in the sexual and secondary sexual regions, a less degree of +pigmentation, as noted both in the castrated negro and the white man, a +puerile larynx and puerile voice. In character they are usually described +as gentle, conciliatory, and charitable.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>There can be little doubt that castration in man tends to lead to + lengthening of the legs (tibia and fibula) at puberty, from + delayed ossification of the epiphyses. The hands and feet are + also frequently longer and sometimes the forearms. At the same + time the bones are more slender. The pelvis also is narrower. The + eunuchs of Cairo are said to be easily seen in a crowd from their + tall stature. (Collineau, quoting Lortet, <i>Revue Mensuelle de + l'Ecole d'Anthropologie</i>, May, 1896.) The <a name='5_Page_184'></a>castrated Skoptzy show + increased stature, and, it seems, large ears, with decreased + chest and head (L. Pittard, <i>Revue Scientifique</i>, June 20, 1903.) + Féré shows that in most of these respects the eunuch resembles + beardless and infantile subjects. ("Les Proportions des Membres + et les Caractères Sexuels," <i>Journal de l'Anatomie et de la + Physiologie</i>, November-December, 1897.) Similar phenomena are + found in animals generally. Sellheim, carefully investigating + castrated horses, swine, oxen and fowls, found retardation of + ossification, long and slender extremities, long, broad, but low + skull, relatively smaller pelvis and small thorax. ("Zur Lehre + von den Sekundären Geschlechtscharakteren," <i>Beiträge zur + Geburtshülfe und Gynäkologie</i>, 1898, summarized in <i>Centralblatt + für Anthropologie</i>, 1900, Heft IV.)</p> + +<p> As regards the mental qualities and moral character of the + castrated, Griffiths considers that there is an undue prejudice + against eunuchs, and refers to Narses, who was not only one of + the first generals of the Roman Empire, but a man of highly + estimable character. (<i>Lancet</i>, March 30, 1895.) Matignon, who + has carefully studied Chinese eunuchs, points out that they + occupy positions of much responsibility, and, though regarded in + many respects as social outcasts, possess very excellent and + amiable moral qualities (<i>Archives Cliniques de Bordeaux</i>, May, + 1896.) In America Everett Flood finds that epileptics and + feeble-minded boys are mentally and morally benefited by + castration. ("Notes on the Castration of Idiot Children," + <i>American Journal of Psychology</i>, January, 1899.) It is often + forgotten that the physical and psychic qualities associated with + and largely dependent on the ability to experience the impulse of + detumescence, while essential to the perfect man, involve many + egoistic, aggressive and acquisitive characteristics which are of + little intellectual value, and at the same time inimical to many + moral virtues.</p></div> + +<p>We have a further standard—positive this time rather than negative—to +aid us in determining the erotic temperament: the phenomena of puberty. +The efflorescence of puberty is essentially the manifestation of the +ability to experience detumescence. It is therefore reasonable to suppose +that the individuals in whom the special phenomena of puberty develop most +markedly are those in whom detumescence is likely to be most vigorous. If +such is the case we should expect to find the erotic temperament marked by +developed larynx and deep voice, a considerable degree of pigmentary +development in hair and skin, <a name='5_Page_185'></a>and a marked tendency to hairiness; while +in women there should be a pronounced growth of the breasts and +pelvis.<a name='5_FNanchor_144'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_144'><sup>[144]</sup></a></p> + +<p>There is yet another standard by which we may measure the individual's +aptitude for detumescence: the presence of those activities which are most +prominently brought into play during the process of detumescence. The +individual, that is to say, who is organically most apt to manifest the +physiological activities which mainly make up the process of detumescence, +is most likely to be of pronounced erotic temperament.</p> + +<p>"Erotic persons are of motor type," remark Vaschide and Vurpas, "and we +may say generally that nearly all persons of motor type are erotic." The +state of detumescence is one of motor and muscular energy and of great +vascular activity, so that habitual energy of motor response and an active +circulation may reasonably be taken to indicate an aptitude for the +manifestation of detumescence.</p> + +<p>These three types may be said, therefore, to furnish us valuable though +somewhat general indications. The individual who is farthest removed from +the castrated type, who presents in fullest degree the characters which +begin to emerge at the period of puberty, and who reveals a physiological +aptitude for the vigorous manifestation of those activities which are +called into action during detumescence, is most likely to be of erotic +temperament. The most cautious description of the characteristics of this +temperament given by modern scientific writers, unlike the more detailed +and hazardous descriptions of the early physiognomists, will be found to +be fairly true to the standards thus presented to us.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The man of sexual type, according to Biérent (<i>La Puberté</i>, p. + 148), is hairy, dark and deep-voiced.</p> + +<p> "The men most liable to satyriasis," Bouchereau states (art. + "Satyriasis," <i>Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des Sciences + Médicales</i>), "are those with vigorous nervous system, developed + muscles, abundant hair on body, dark complexion, and white + teeth."</p><a name='5_Page_186'></a> + +<p> Mantegazza, in his <i>Fisiologia del Piacere</i>, thus describes the + sexual temperament: "Individuals of nervous temperament, those + with fine and brown skins, rounded forms, large lips and very + prominent larynx enjoy in general much more than those with + opposite characteristics. A universal tradition," he adds, + "describes as lascivious humpbacks, dwarfs, and in general + persons of short stature and with long noses."</p> + +<p> In a case of nymphomania in a young woman, described by Alibert + (and quoted by Laycock, <i>Nervous Diseases of Women</i>, p. 28) the + hips, thighs and legs were remarkably plump, while the chest and + arms were completely emaciated. In a somewhat similar case + described by Marc in his <i>De la Folie</i> a peasant woman, who from + an early age had experienced sexual hyperæsthesia, so that she + felt spasmodic voluptuous feelings at the sight of a man, and was + thus the victim of solitary excesses and of spasmodic movements + which she could not repress, the upper part of the body was very + thin, the hips, legs and thighs highly developed.</p> + +<p> In his work on <i>Uterine and Ovarian Inflammation</i> (1862, p. 37) + Tilt observes: "The restless, bashful eye, and changing + complexion, in presence of a person of the opposite sex, and a + nervous restlessness of body, ever on the move, turning and + twisting on sofa or chair, are the best indications of sexual + temperament."</p> + +<p> An extremely sensual little girl of 8, who was constantly + masturbating when not watched, although brought up by nuns, was + described by Busdraghi (<i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, fas. i, 1888, + p. 53) as having chestnut hair, bright black eyes, an elevated + nose, small mouth, pleasant round face, full colored cheeks, and + plump and healthy aspect.</p> + +<p> A highly intelligent young Italian woman with strong and somewhat + perverted sexual impulses is described as of attractive + appearance, with olive complexion, small black almond-shaped + eyes, dilated pupils, oblique thin eyebrows, very thick black + hair, rather prominent cheek-bones, largely developed jaw, and + with abundant down on lower part of cheeks and on upper lip. + (<i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, 1899, fasc. v-vi.)</p> + +<p> As the type of the sensual woman in word and act, led by her + passions to commit various sexual offenses, Ottolenghi describes + (<i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, vol. xii, fasc. v-vi, p. 496) a woman + of 32 who attempted to kill her lover. The daughter of parents + who were neurotic and themselves very erotic, she was a highly + intelligent and vivacious woman, with a pleasing and open face, + very thick dark chestnut hair, large cheek-bones, adipose + buttocks almost resembling those of a Hottentot, and very thick + pubic hair. She was very fond of salt things. Sexual inclination + began at the age of 7.</p></div> + +<p>Adler and Moll remark, very truly, that, so far at least as women are +concerned, sexual anæsthesia or sexual proclivity <a name='5_Page_187'></a>cannot be unfailingly +read on the features. Every woman desires to please, and coquetry is the +sign of a cold, rather than of an erotic temperament.<a name='5_FNanchor_145'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_145'><sup>[145]</sup></a> It may be added +that a considerable degree of congenital sexual anæsthesia by no means +prevents a woman from being beautiful and attractive, though it must +probably still always be said that, as Roubaud points out,<a name='5_FNanchor_146'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_146'><sup>[146]</sup></a> the woman +of cold and intellectual temperament, the "femme de tête," however +beautiful and skillful she may be, cannot compete in the struggle for love +with the woman whose qualities are of the heart and of the emotions. But +it seems sufficiently clear that the practical observations of skilled and +experienced observers agree in attributing to persons of erotic type +certain general characteristics which accord with those negative and +positive standards we may frame on the basis of castration, of puberty, +and of detumescence. It may be worth while to note a few of these +characteristics briefly.</p> + +<p>The abnormal lengthening of the long bones at the age of puberty in the +castrated is, as we have seen, very pronounced. There is little tendency +to associate length of limb with an erotic temperament, and a certain +amount of data as well as of more vague opinion points in the opposite +direction. The Arabs would appear to believe that it is short rather than +tall people in whom the sexual instinct is strongly developed, and we read +in the <i>Perfumed Garden</i>: "Under all circumstances little women love +coitus more and evince a stronger affection for the virile member than +women of a large size." In his elaborate investigation of criminals Marro +found that prostitutes and women guilty of sexual offenses, as also male +sexual offenders, tend to be short and thick set.<a name='5_FNanchor_147'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_147'><sup>[147]</sup></a> In European +folk-lore the thick, bull neck is regarded as a sign of strong +sexuality.<a name='5_FNanchor_148'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_148'><sup>[148]</sup></a> Mantegazza refers to a strong sexual temperament as being +associated with arrest or disorder of bony development, and Marro suggests +that <a name='5_Page_188'></a>the proverbial salacity of rachitic individuals may be due to an +increased activity of the sexual organs.<a name='5_FNanchor_149'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_149'><sup>[149]</sup></a> It may be added that +acromegaly, with its excessive bony growths, tends to be associated with +premature sexual involution.</p> + +<p>A further point which is frequently mentioned in the case of women is the +development of the chief secondary sexual regions: the pelvis and the +breasts. It is, indeed, almost inevitable that there should be some degree +of correlation between the aptitude for bearing children and the aptitude +for experiencing detumescence. The reality of such a connection is not +only evidenced by medical observations, but receives further testimony in +popular beliefs. In Italy women with large buttocks are considered wanton, +and among the South Slavs they are regarded as especially fruitful.<a name='5_FNanchor_150'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_150'><sup>[150]</sup></a> +Blumenbach asserted that precocious venery will enlarge the breasts, and +believed that he had found evidence of this among young London +prostitutes.<a name='5_FNanchor_151'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_151'><sup>[151]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The association of the aptitude for detumescence with a tendency to a deep +rather than to a high voice, both in men and women, has frequently been +noted and has seldom been denied. The onset of puberty always affects the +voice; in general, Biérent states, the more bass the voice is the more +marked is the development of the sexual apparatus; "a very robust man, +with very developed sexual organs, and very dark and abundant hairy +system, a man of strong puberty in a word, is nearly always a bass."<a name='5_FNanchor_152'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_152'><sup>[152]</sup></a> +The influence of sexual excitement in deepening the voice is shown by the +rules of sexual hygiene prescribed to tenors, while a bass has less need +to observe similar precautions. In women every phase of sexual +life—puberty, menstruation, coitus, pregnancy—tends to affect the voice +and always by giving it a deeper character. The deepening of the voice by +sexual intercourse was an ancient Greek observation, and Martial refers to +a woman's good or bad singing as an index to her recent <a name='5_Page_189'></a>sexual habits. +Prostitutes tend to have a deep voice. Venturi points out that married +women preserve a fresh voice to a more advanced age than spinsters, this +being due to the precocious senility in the latter of an unused function. +Such a phenomenon indicates that the relationship of detumescence to the +deepening of the voice is not quite simple. This is further indicated by +the fact that in robust men abstinence still further deepens the voice +(the monk of melodrama always has a bass voice), while excessive or +precocious sexual indulgence tends to be associated with the same kind of +puerile voice as is found in those persons in whom pubertal development +has not been carried very far, or who are of what Griffiths terms +eunuchoid type. Idiot boys, who are often sexually undeveloped, tend to +have a high voice, while idiot girls (who often manifest marked sexual +proclivities) not infrequently have a deep voice.<a name='5_FNanchor_153'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_153'><sup>[153]</sup></a></p> + +<p>Bright dilated eyes are among the phenomena of detumescence, and are very +frequently noted in persons of a pronounced erotic temperament. This is, +indeed, an ancient observation, and Burton says of people with a black, +lively, and sparkling eye, "without question they are most amorous," +drawing his illustrations mostly from classic literature.<a name='5_FNanchor_154'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_154'><sup>[154]</sup></a> Tardieu +described the erotic woman as having bright eyes, and Heywood Smith states +that the eyes of lascivious women resemble, though in a less degree, those +of the insane.<a name='5_FNanchor_155'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_155'><sup>[155]</sup></a> Sexual excitement is one among many +causes—intellectual excitement, pain, a loud noise, even any sensory +irritation—which produce dilatation of the pupils and enlargement of the +palpebral fissure, with some protrusion of the eyeball. The influence of +the sexual system upon the eye appears to be far less potent in men than +in women.<a name='5_FNanchor_156'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_156'><sup>[156]</sup></a> Sexual desire is, however, by no means the only irritant +within the sexual sphere which may thus influence the eye; morbid +irritations may produce the same effect. Milner Fothergill, in his book on +<i>Indigestion</i>, vividly describes the appearance of the <a name='5_Page_190'></a>eyes sometimes +seen in ovarian disorder: "The glittering flash which glances out from +some female irides is the external indication of ovarian irritation, and +'the ovarian gleam' has features quite its own. The most marked instance +which ever came under my notice was due to irritation in the ovaries, +which had been forced down in front of the uterus and been fixed there by +adhesions. Here there was little sexual proclivity, but the eyes were very +remarkable. They flashed and glittered unceasingly, and at times perfect +lightning bolts shot from them. Usually there is a bright glittering sheen +in them which contrasts with the dead look in the irides of sexual excess +or profuse uterine discharges."</p> + +<p>The activity of the glandular secretions, and especially those of the +skin, during detumescence, would lead us to expect that such secretory +activity is an index to an aptitude for detumescence. As a matter of fact +it is occasionally, though not frequently, noted by medical observers. It +is stated that the erotic temperament is characterized by a special +odor.<a name='5_FNanchor_157'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_157'><sup>[157]</sup></a> The activity of the sweat-glands is seldom referred to by +medical observers in describing persons of erotic temperament, although +the descriptions of novelists not infrequently contain allusions to this +point, and the literature of an earlier age shows that the tendency to +perspiration, especially the moist hand, was regarded as a sure sign of a +sensual temperament. "The moist-handed Madonna Imperia, a most rare and +divine creature," remarks Lazarillo in Middleton's comedy <i>Blurt, +Master-Constable</i>, to quote one of many allusions to this point in the +Elizabethan drama.</p> + +<p>The lips are sometimes noted as red and everted, perhaps thick<a name='5_FNanchor_158'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_158'><sup>[158]</sup></a>; +Tardieu remarked that the typically erotic woman has thick red lips. This +corresponds with the characteristic type of the satyr in classic statues +as in later paintings; his lips are <a name='5_Page_191'></a>always thick and everted. Fullness, +redness, and eversion of the lips are correlated with good breathing, the +absence of anæmia, laughter, a well-fleshed face.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>This kind of mouth indicates, perhaps, not so much a congenitally + erotic temperament, as an abandonment to impulse. The opposite + type of mouth—with inverted, thin, and retracted lips—would + appear to be found with especial frequency in persons who + habitually repress their impulses on moral grounds. Any kind of + effort to restrain involuntary muscular action may lead to + retraction of the lips: the effort to overcome anger or fear, or + even the resistance to a strong desire to urinate or defecate. In + religious young men, however, it becomes habitual and fixed. I + recall a small band of medical students, gathered together from a + large medical school, who were accustomed to meet together for + prayer and Bible-reading; the majority showed this type of mouth + to a very marked degree: pale faces, with drawn, retracted lips. + It may be termed the Christian or pious <i>facies</i>. It is much less + frequently seen in religious women (unless of masculine type), + doubtless because religion for women is in a much less degree + than for men a moral discipline.</p> + +<p> It may be added that an interesting form of this contraction of + the lips, and one that is not purely repressive, is that which + indicates the state of muscular tension associated with the + impulse to guard and protect. In this form the contracted mouth + is the index of tenderness, and is characteristic of the mother + who is watching over the infant she is suckling at her breast. I + have observed precisely the same expression in the face of a boy + of 14 with a large congenital scrotal hernia; when the tumor was + being examined his lower lip became retracted, well marked lines + appearing from the angles downwards, though the upper lip + retained its normal expression It was precisely the tender look + we may see in the faces of mothers who are watching anxiously + over their offspring, and the emotion is evidently the same in + both cases: solicitude for a sensitive and tenderly guarded + object.</p></div> + +<p>The degree of pigmentation is clearly correlated with sexual vigor. "In +general," Heusinger laid down, in 1823, "the quantity of pigment is +proportional to the functional effectiveness of the genital organs." This +connection is so profound that it may be traced very widely throughout the +organic world.</p> + +<p>The connection between pigmentation and sexual activity is very ancient. +Even leaving out of account the wedding apparel of animals, nearly always +gorgeous in scales and plumage and hair, the sexual orifice shows a more +or less marked tendency <a name='5_Page_192'></a>to pigmentation during the breeding season from +fishes upward, while in mammals the darker pigmentation of this region is +a constant phenomenon in sexually mature individuals.<a name='5_FNanchor_159'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_159'><sup>[159]</sup></a></p> + +<p>In the human species both the negative standard of castration and the +positive standard of puberty alike indicate a correlation of this kind. +Those individuals in whom puberty never fully develops and who are +consequently said to be affected by infantilism, reveal a relative absence +of pigment in the sexual centers which are normally pigmented to a high +degree.<a name='5_FNanchor_160'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_160'><sup>[160]</sup></a> Among those Asiatic races who extirpate the ovaries in young +girls the skin remains white in the perineum, round the anus, and in the +armpits.<a name='5_FNanchor_161'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_161'><sup>[161]</sup></a> Even in mature women who undergo ovariotomy, as Kepler +found, the pigmentation of the nipples and areola disappears, as well as +of the perineum and anus, the skin taking on a remarkable whiteness.</p> + +<p>Normally the sexual centers, and in a high degree the genital orifice, +represent the maximum of pigmentation, and under some circumstances this +is clearly visible even in infancy. Thus babies of mixed black and white +blood may show no traces of negro ancestry at birth, but there will always +be increased pigmentation about the external genitalia.<a name='5_FNanchor_162'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_162'><sup>[162]</sup></a> The linea +fusca, which reaches from the pubes to the navel and occasionally to the +ensiform cartilage, is a line of sexual pigmentation sometimes regarded as +characteristic of pregnancy, but as Andersen, of Copenhagen, has found by +the examination of several hundred children of both sexes, it exists in a +slight form in about 75 per cent. of young girls, and in almost as large a +proportion of boys. But there is no doubt that it tends to increase with +age as well as to become marked at pregnancy. At puberty there is a +general tendency to changes in pigmentation; thus Godin found <a name='5_Page_193'></a>that in 28 +per cent, adolescent changes occurred in the eyes and hair at this period, +the hair becoming darker, though the eyes sometimes become lighter. Ammon, +in his investigation of conscripts at the age of 20 (<i>post</i>, p. 196), +discovered the significant fact that the eyes and hair darken <i>pari passu</i> +with sexual development. In women, during menstruation, there is a general +tendency to pigmentation; this is especially obvious around the eyes, and +in some cases black rings of true pigment form in this position. Even the +skin of the negro women of Loango sometimes becomes a few shades darker +during menstruation.<a name='5_FNanchor_163'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_163'><sup>[163]</sup></a> During pregnancy this tendency to pigmentation +reaches its climax. Pregnancy constantly gives rise to pigmentation of the +face, the neck, the nipples, the abdomen, and this is especially marked in +brunettes.</p> + +<p>This association of pigmentation and sexual aptitudes has been recognized +in the popular lore of some peoples. Thus the Sicilians, who admire brown +skin and have no liking either for a fair skin or light hair, believe that +a white woman is incapable of responding to love. It is the brown woman +who feels love; as it is said in Sicilian dialect: "Fimmina scura, fimmina +amurusa."<a name='5_FNanchor_164'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_164'><sup>[164]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The dependence of pigmentation upon the sexual system is shown by + the fact that irritation of the genital organs by disease will + frequently suffice to produce a high degree of pigmentation. This + may the neck, the trunk, the hands. Simpson long since noted that + uterine irritation apart from pregnancy may produce pigmentation + of the areolæ of the nipples (<i>Obstetric Works</i>, vol. i, p. 345). + Engelmann discussed the subject and gave cases, "The + Hystero-Neuroses," pp. 124-139, in <i>Gynæcological Transactions</i>, + vol. xii, 1887; and a summary of a memoir by Fouquet on this + subject in <i>La Gynécologie</i>, February, 1903, will be found in + <i>British Medical Journal</i>, March 28, 1903,</p></div><a name='5_Page_194'></a> + +<p>Of all physical traits vigor of the hairy system has most frequently +perhaps been regarded as the index of vigorous sexuality. In this matter +modern medical observations are at one with popular belief and ancient +physiognomical assertions.<a name='5_FNanchor_165'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_165'><sup>[165]</sup></a> The negative test of castration and the +positive test of puberty point in the same direction.</p> + +<p>It is at puberty that all the hair on the body, except that on the head, +begins to develop; indeed, the very word "puberty" has reference to this +growth as the most obvious sign of the whole process. When castration +takes place at an early age all this development of pubescent hair is +arrested. When the primary sexual organs are undeveloped the sexual hair +is also undeveloped, as in a case, recorded by Plant,<a name='5_FNanchor_166'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_166'><sup>[166]</sup></a> of a girl with +rudimentary uterus and ovaries who had little or no axillary and pubic +hair, although the hair of the head was long and strong.<a name='5_FNanchor_167'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_167'><sup>[167]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The pseudo-Michael Scot among the <i>Signa mulieris calidæ naturæ + et quæ coit libenter</i> stated that her hair, both on the head and + body, is thick and coarse and crisp, and Della Porta, the + greatest of the physiognomists, said that thickness of hair in + women meant wantonness. Venette, in his <i>Generation de l'Homme</i>, + remarked that men who have much hair on the body are most + amorous. At a more recent period Roubaud has said that pubic hair + in its quantity, color and curliness is an index of genital + energy. A poor pilous system, on the other hand, Roubaud regarded + as a probable though not an irrefragable proof of sexual + frigidity in women. "In the cold woman the pilous system is + remarkable for the languor of its vitality; the hairs are fair, + delicate, scarce and smooth, while in ardent natures there are + little curly tufts about the temples." (<i>Traité de + l'Impuissance</i>, pp. 124, 523.) Martineau declared (<i>Leçons sur + les Déformations Vulvaires</i>, p. 40) that "the more developed the + genital organs the more abundant the hair covering them; + <a name='5_Page_195'></a>abundance of hair appears to be in relation to the perfect + development of the organs." Tardieu described the typically + erotic woman as very hairy.</p> + +<p> Bergh found that among 2200 young Danish prostitutes those who + showed an unusual extension and amount of pubic hair included + several women who were believed to be libidinous in a very high + degree. (Bergh, "Symbolæ," etc., <i>Hospitalstidende</i>, August, + 1894.) Moraglia, again, in Italy, in describing various women, + mostly prostitutes, of unusually strong sexual proclivities, + repeatedly notes very thick hair, with down on the face. + (<i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, vol. xvi, fasc. iv-v.)</p> + +<p> Marro, also, in Italy found that abundance of hair and down is + especially marked in women who are guilty of infanticide (as also + Pasini has found), though criminal women generally, in his + experience, tend to have abnormally abundant hair. (<i>Caratteri + del Delinquenti</i>, cap. XXII.) Lombroso finds that prostitutes + generally tend to be hairy (<i>Donna Delinquente</i>, p. 320.)</p> + +<p> A lad of 14, guilty of numerous crimes of violence having a + sexual source, is described by Arthur Macdonald in America as + having hair on the chest as well as all over the pubes. (A. + Macdonald, <i>Archives de L'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, January, + 1893, p. 55.) The association of hairiness with abnormal + sexuality in the weak-minded has been noted at Bicêtre + (<i>Recherches Cliniques sur l'Epilepsie</i>, vol. xix, pp. 69, 77.)</p> + +<p> Hypertrichosis universalis, a general hairiness of body, has been + described by Cascella in a woman with very strong sexual desires, + who eventually became insane. (<i>Revista Mensile di Psichiatria</i>, + 1903, p. 408.) Bucknill and Tuke give the case of a religiously + minded girl, with very strong and repressed sexual desires, who + became insane; the only abnormal feature in her physical + development was the marked growth of hair over the body.</p> + +<p> Brantôme refers to a great lady known to him whose body was very + hairy, and quotes a saying to the effect that hairy people are + either rich or wanton; the lady in question, he adds, was both. + (Brantôme, <i>Vie des Dames Galantes</i>, Discours II.)</p> + +<p> De Sade, whose writings are now regarded as a treasure house of + true observations in the domain of sexual psychology, makes the + Rodin of <i>Justine</i> dark, with much hair and thick eyebrows, while + his very sexual sister is described as dark, thin and very hairy. + (Dühren, <i>Der Marquis de Sade</i>, third edition, p. 440.)</p> + +<p> A correspondent who has always taken a special interest in the + condition as regards hairiness of the women to whom he has been + attracted, has sent me notes concerning a series of 12 women. It + may be gathered from these notes that 5 women were neither + markedly sexual nor markedly hairy (either as regards head or + pubes), 6 cases both hairy and sexual, 1 was sexual and not + hairy, none were hairy <a name='5_Page_196'></a>and not sexual. My correspondent remarks: + "There may be women with scanty pubic hair possessing very strong + sexual emotions. My own experience is quite the opposite." He has + also independently reached the conclusion, arrived at by many + medical observers and clearly suggested by some of the facts here + brought together, that profuse hair frequently denotes a neurotic + temperament.</p> + +<p> It may be added that Mirabeau, as we learn from an anecdote told + by an eyewitness and recorded by Legouvé, had a very hairy chest, + while the same is recorded of Restif de la Bretonne.</p></div> + +<p>It is a very ancient and popular belief that if a hairy man is not sensual +he is strong: <i>vir pilosus aut libidinosus aut fortis</i>. The Greeks +insisted on the hairy nates of Hercules, and Ninon de l'Enclos, when the +great Condé shared her bed without touching her, remarked, on seeing his +hairy body: "Ah, Monseigneur, que vous devez être fort!" It may be doubted +whether there is any exact parallelism between muscular strength and +hairiness, for strength is largely a matter of training, but there can be +no doubt that hairiness really tends to be associated with a generally +vigorous development of the body.</p> + +<p>Although the observations concerning hairiness of body as an index of +vigor, whether sexual or only generally physical, are so ancient, until +recent years no attempts have been made to demonstrate on a large scale +whether there is actually a correlation between hairiness and sexual or +general development of the body. Some importance, therefore, attaches to +Ammon's careful observations of many thousand conscripts in Baden. These +observations fully justify this ancient belief, since they show that on +the one hand the size of the testicles, and on the other hand girth of +chest and stature, are correlated with hairiness of body.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Ammon's observations were made on nearly 4000 conscripts of the + age of 20. From the point of view of the hairy system he divided + them, into four classes:—</p> + +<ul><li> I. To which 6.1 per cent, of the men belonged, with smooth + bodies.</li> + +<li> II. Including 25.3 per cent., only slight hairiness.</li> + +<li> III. 53.8 per cent., more developed hairy system, but belly, + breast and back smooth.</li> + +<li> IV. 14.7 per cent., hair all over body.</li> + +<li> V. 0.1 per cent., extreme cases of hairiness.</li></ul><a name='5_Page_197'></a> + +<p> The beardless were 12.1 per cent., those with no axillary hair 9 + per cent., those with no hair on pubis 0.4 per cent. This + corresponds with the fact that hair appears first on the pubis + and last on the chin.</p> + +<p> In the first class 69 per cent, were beardless, 54 per cent, + without any axillary hair and 6 per cent, without pubic hair. In + the second class 24 per cent, were beardless, 17 per cent, + without axillary hair. In the third class 3 per cent, were + beardless and 3 per cent without axillary hair.</p> + +<p> Below puberty the diameter of testicles is below 14 millimeters. + There were 13 conscripts having a testicular diameter of less + than 14 millimeters. These infantile individuals all belonged to + the first three classes and mostly to the first. The average + testicular diameter in the first class was nearly 24 millimeters, + and progressively rose in the succeeding classes to over 26 + millimeters in the fourth.</p> + +<p> While there was not much difference in height, the first class + was the shortest, the fourth the tallest. The fourth class also + showed the greatest chest perimeter. The cephalic index of all + classes was 84. (O. Ammon, "L'Infantilisme et le Feminisme au + Conseil de Révision," <i>L'Anthropologie</i>, May-June, 1896.)</p></div> + +<p>We thus see that it is quite justifiable to admit a type of person who +possesses a more than average aptitude for detumescence. Such persons are +more likely to be short than tall; they will show a full development of +the secondary sexual characters; the voice will tend to be deep and the +eyes bright; the glandular activity of the skin will probably be marked, +the lips everted; there is a tendency to a more than average degree of +pigmentation, and there is frequently an abnormal prevalence of hair on +some parts of the body. While none of these signs, taken separately, can +be said to have any necessary connection with the sexual impulse, taken +altogether they indicate an organism that responds to the instinct of +detumescence with special aptitude or with marked energy. In these +respects observation, both scientific and popular, concords with the +probabilities suggested by the three standards in this matter which have +already been set forth.</p> + +<p>No generalization, however, can here be set down in an absolute and +unqualified manner. There are definite reasons why this should be so. +There is, for instance, the highly important consideration that the sexual +impulse of the individual <a name='5_Page_198'></a>may be conspicuous in two quite distinct ways. +It may assume prominence because the individual possesses a highly +vigorous and well-nourished organism, or its prominence may be due to +mental irritation in a very morbid individual. In the latter +case—although occasionally the two sets of conditions are combined—most +of the signs we might expect in the former case may be absent. Indeed, the +sexual impulses which proceed from a morbid psychic irritability do not in +most cases indicate any special aptitude for detumescence at all; in that +largely lies their morbid character.</p> + +<p>Again, just in the same way that the exaggerated impulse itself may either +be healthy or morbid, so the various characters which we have found to +possess some value as signs of the impulse may themselves either be +healthy or morbid. This is notably the case as regards an abnormal growth +of hair on the body, more especially when it appears on regions where +normally there is little or no hair. Such hypertrichosis is frequently +degenerative in character, though still often associated with the sexual +system. When, however, it is thus a degenerative character of sexual +nature, having its origin in some abnormal fœtal condition or +later atrophy of the ovaries, it is no necessary indication of any +aptitude for detumescence.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Idiots, more especially it would seem idiot girls, tend to show a + highly developed hairy system. Thus Voisin, when investigating + 150 idiot and imbecile girls, found the hair long and thick and + tending to occupy a large surface; one girl had hair on the + areolæ of the mamma. (J. Voisin, "Conformation des organes + génitaux chez les Idiots," <i>Annales d'Hygiène Publique</i>, June, + 1894.) It should be said that in idiot boys puberty is late, and + the sexual organs as well as the sexual instinct frequently + undeveloped, while in idiot girls there is no delay in puberty, + and the sexual organs and instinct are frequently fully and even + abnormally developed.</p> + +<p> Hegar has described an interesting case showing an association, + of fœtal origin, between sexual anomaly and abnormal + hairness. In this case a girl of 16 had a uterus duplex, an + infantile pelvis, very slight menstruation and undeveloped + breasts. She was very hairy on the face, the anterior aspects of + the chest and abdomen, the sexual regions, and the thighs, but + not specially so on the rest of the body. The hairs were of + lanugo-like character, but dark in color. (A. Hegar, <i>Beiträge + zur<a name='5_Page_199'></a> Geburtshülfe und Gynäkologie</i>, vol. i, p. III, 1898.) + Sometimes hiruties of the face and abdomen begin to appear during + pregnancy, apparently from disease or degeneration of the + ovaries. (A case is noted in <i>British Medical Journal</i>, August 2 + and 16, pp. 375 and 436, 1902.) Laycock many years ago referred + to the popular belief that women who have hair on the upper lip + seldom bear children, and regarded this opinion as "questionless + founded on fact." (Laycock, <i>Nervous Diseases of Women</i>, p. 22.) + When this is so, we may suppose that the abnormal hairy growth is + associated with degeneration of the ovaries.</p></div> + +<p>There is another factor which enters into this question and renders the +definition of a physical sexual type less precise than it would otherwise +be. The sexual instinct is common to all persons, and while it seems +probable that there is a type of person in whom sexual energies are +predominant, it would also appear that the people who otherwise show a +very high level of energy in life usually exhibit a more than average +degree of energy in matters of love. The predominantly sexual type, as we +have seen, tends to be associated with a high degree of pigmentation; the +person specially apt for detumescence inclines to belong to the dark +rather than to the purely fair group of the population. On the other hand, +the active, energetic, practical man, the man who is most apt for the +achievement of success in life, tends to belong to the fair rather than to +the dark type.<a name='5_FNanchor_168'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_168'><sup>[168]</sup></a> Thus we have a certain conflict of tendencies, and it +becomes possible to assert that while persons with pronounced aptitude for +sexual detumescence tend to be dark, persons whose pronounced energy in +sexual matters tends to ensure success are most likely to be fair.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The tendency of the fair energetic type, the type of the northern + European man, to sexuality may be connected with the fact that + the violent and criminal man who commits sexual crimes tends to + be fair even amid a dark population. Criminals on the whole would + appear to tend to be dark rather than fair; but Marro found in + Italy that the group of sexual offenders differed from all other + groups of criminals in that their hair was predominantly fair. + (<i>Caratteri del Delinquenti</i>, <a name='5_Page_200'></a>p. 374.) Ottolenghi, in the same + way, in examining 100 sexual offenders, found that they showed 17 + per cent., of fair hair, though criminals generally (on a basis + of nearly 2000) showed only 6 per cent., and normal persons + (nearly 1000) 9 per cent. Similarly while the normal persons + showed only 20 per cent. of blue eyes and criminals generally 36 + per cent., the sexual offenders showed 50 per cent. of blue eyes. + (Ottolenghi, <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, fasc. vi, 1888, p. 573.) + Burton remarked (<i>Anatomy of Melancholy</i>, Part III, Section II, + Mem. II, Subs. II) that in all ages most amorous young men have + been yellow-haired, adding, "Synesius holds every effeminate + fellow or adulterer is fair-haired." In folk-lore, it has been + noted (Κρυπτάδια, vol. ii, p. 258), red or yellow hair + is sometimes regarded as a mark of sexuality.</p> + +<p> In harmony with this fairness, sexual offenders would appear to + be more dolichocephalic than other criminals. In Italy Marro + found the foreheads of sexual offenders to be narrow, and in + California Drähms found that while murderers had an average + cephalic index of 83.5, and thieves of 80.5, that of sexual + offenders was 79.</p> + +<p> On the other hand, high cheek-bones and broad faces—a condition + most usually found associated with brachycephaly—have sometimes + been noted as associated with undue or violent sexuality. Marro + noted the excess of prominent cheek-bones in sexual offenders, + and in America it has been found that unchaste girls tend to have + broad faces. (<i>Pedagogical Seminary</i>, December, 1896, pp. 231, + 235.)</p></div> + +<p>It will be seen that, when we take a comprehensive view of the facts and +considerations involved, it is possible to obtain a more definite and +coherent picture of the physical signs of a marked aptitude for +detumescence than has hitherto been usually supposed possible. But we also +see that while the <i>ensemble</i> of these signs is probably fairly reliable +as an index of marked sexuality, the separate signs have no such definite +significance, and under some circumstances their significance may even be +reversed.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_144'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_144'>[144]</a><div class='note'><p> See Biérent, <i>La Puberté</i>; Marro, <i>La Pubertà</i> (and +enlarged French translation, <i>La Puberté</i>), and portions of G. S. Hall's +<i>Adolescence</i>; also Havelock Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i> (fourth edition, +revised and enlarged).</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_145'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_145'>[145]</a><div class='note'><p> Adler, <i>Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes</i>, +p. 174; Moll, "Perverse Sexualempfindung, Psychische Impotenz und Ehe" +(Section II), in Senator and Kaminer, <i>Krankheiten und Ehe</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_146'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_146'>[146]</a><div class='note'><p> Roubaud, <i>Traité de l'Impuissance</i>, p. 524.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_147'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_147'>[147]</a><div class='note'><p> Marro, <i>Caratteri del Delinquenti</i>, p. 374.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_148'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_148'>[148]</a><div class='note'><p> Κρυπτάδια, vol. ii, p. 258.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_149'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_149'>[149]</a><div class='note'><p> Marro, <i>La Pubertà</i>, p. 196. In Italy, the sensuality of +the lame is the subject of proverbs.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_150'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_150'>[150]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, 1896, p. 515; +Κρυπτάδια, vol. vi, p. 212.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_151'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_151'>[151]</a><div class='note'><p> Blumenbach, <i>Anthropological Treatises</i>, p. 248.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_152'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_152'>[152]</a><div class='note'><p> Biérent, <i>La Puberté</i>, p. 148.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_153'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_153'>[153]</a><div class='note'><p> Venturi, <i>Degenerazioni Psico-sessuali</i>, pp. 408-410.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_154'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_154'>[154]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Anatomy of Melancholy</i>, Part III, Section II, Mem. II, +Sub. II.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_155'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_155'>[155]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>British Gynæcological Journal</i>, February, 1887, p. 505.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_156'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_156'>[156]</a><div class='note'><p> Power, <i>Lancet</i>, November 26, 1887.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_157'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_157'>[157]</a><div class='note'><p> With regard to the sexual relationships of personal odor, +see the previous volume of these <i>Studies</i>, "Sexual Selection in Man," +section on Smell.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_158'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_158'>[158]</a><div class='note'><p> In European folk-lore thick lips in a woman are sometimes +regarded as a sign of sensuality, Κρυπτάδια, vol. ii, p, 258.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_159'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_159'>[159]</a><div class='note'><p> The direct dependence of sexual pigmentation on the primary +sexual glands is well illustrated by a true hermaphroditic adult finch +exhibited at the Academy of Sciences of Amsterdam (May 31, 1890); this +bird had a testis on the right side and an ovary on the left, and on the +right side its plumage was of the male's colors, on the left of the +female's color.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_160'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_160'>[160]</a><div class='note'><p> See. <i>e.g.</i>, Papillault, <i>Bulletin Société +d'Anthropologie</i>, 1899, p. 446.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_161'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_161'>[161]</a><div class='note'><p> Guinard, Art. "Castration," Richet's <i>Dictionnaire de +Physiologie</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_162'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_162'>[162]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Whitridge Williams, <i>Obstetrics</i>, 1903, p. 132.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_163'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_163'>[163]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Zeitschrift für Ethnologie</i>, 1878, p. 19.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_164'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_164'>[164]</a><div class='note'><p> C. Pitre, <i>Medicina Populare Siciliana</i>, p. 47. In England, +from notes sent to me by one correspondent, it would appear that the +proportion of dark and sexually apt women to fair and sexually apt women +is as 3 to 1. The experience of others would doubtless give varying +results, and in any case the fallacies are numerous. See, in the previous +volume of these <i>Studies</i>, "Sexual Selection in Man," Section IV.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_165'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_165'>[165]</a><div class='note'><p> In Japan the same belief would appear to be held. In a nude +figure representing the typical voluptuous woman by the Japanese painter +Marugama Okio (reproduced in Ploss's <i>Das Weib</i>) the pubic and axillary +hair is profuse, though usually sparse in Japan.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_166'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_166'>[166]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Centralblatt für Gynäkologie</i>, No. 9, 1896.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_167'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_167'>[167]</a><div class='note'><p> It is important to remember that there is little +correlation in this matter between the hair of the head and the sexual +hair, if not a certain opposition. (See <i>ante</i>, p. 127.) According to one +of the aphorisms of Hippocrates, repeated by Buffon, eunuchs do not become +bald, and Aristotle seems to have believed that sexual intercourse is a +cause of baldness in men. (Laycock, <i>Nervous Diseases of Women</i>, p. 23.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_168'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_168'>[168]</a><div class='note'><p> For some of the evidence on this point, see Havelock Ellis, +"The Comparative Abilities of the Fair and the Dark," <i>Monthly Review</i>, +August, 1901; <i>cf.</i> <i>id.</i>, <i>A Study of British Genius</i>, Chapter X.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_THE_PSYCHIC_STATE_IN_PREGNANCY'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_201'></a>THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY.</h2> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Relationship of Maternal and Sexual Emotion—Conception and Loss of +Virginity—The Anciently Accepted Signs of This Condition—The Pervading +Effects of Pregnancy on the Organism—Pigmentation—The Blood and +Circulation—The Thyroid—Changes in the Nervous System—The Vomiting of +Pregnancy—The Longings of Pregnant Women—Maternal Impressions—Evidence +for and Against Their Validity—The Question Still Open—Imperfection of +Our Knowledge—The Significance of Pregnancy.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>In analyzing the sexual impulse I have so far deliberately kept out of +view the maternal instinct. This is necessary, for the maternal instinct +is specific and distinct; it is directed to an aim which, however +intimately associated it may be with that of the sexual impulse proper, +can by no means be confounded with it. Yet the emotion of love, as it has +finally developed in the world, is not purely of sexual origin; it is +partly sexual, but it is also partly parental.<a name='5_FNanchor_169'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_169'><sup>[169]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_202'></a> +<p>In so far as it is parental it is certainly mainly maternal. There is a +drawing by Bronzino in the Louvre of a woman's head gazing tenderly down +at some invisible object; is it her child or her lover? Doubtless her +child, yet the expression is equally adequate to the emotion evoked by a +lover. If we were here specifically dealing with the emotion of love as a +complex whole, and not with the psychology of the sexual impulse, it would +certainly be necessary to discuss the maternal instinct and its associated +emotions. In any case it seems desirable to touch on the psychic state of +pregnancy, for we are here concerned not only with emotions very closely +connected with the sexual emotions in the narrower sense, but we here at +last approach that state which it is the object of the whole sexual +process to achieve.</p> + +<p>In civilized life a period of weeks, months, even years, may elapse +between the establishment of sexual relations and the occurrence <a name='5_Page_203'></a>of +conception. Under primitive conditions the loss of the virginal condition +practically involves the pregnant condition, so that under primitive +conditions very little allowance is made for the state, so common among +civilized peoples, of the woman who is no longer a virgin, yet not about +to become a mother.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>There is some interest in noting the signs of loss of virginity + chiefly relied upon by ancient authors. In doing this it is + convenient to follow mainly the full summary of authorities given + by Schurig in his <i>Barthenologia</i> early in the eighteenth + century. The ancient custom, known in classic times, of measuring + the neck the day after marriage was frequently practiced to + ascertain if a girl was or was not a virgin. There were various + ways of doing this. One was to measure with a thread the + circumference of the bride's neck before she went to bed on the + bridal night. If in the morning the same thread would not go + around her neck it was a sure sign that she had lost her + virginity during the night; if not, she was still a virgin or had + been deflowered at an earlier period. Catullus alluded to this + custom, which still exists, or existed until lately, in the south + of France. It is perfectly sound, for it rests on the intimate + response by congestion of the thyroid gland to sexual excitement. + (<i>Parthenologia</i>, p. 283; Biérent, <i>La Puberté</i>, p. 150; Havelock + Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i>, fourth edition, p. 267.)</p> + +<p> Some say, Schurig tells us, that the voice, which in the virgin + is shrill, becomes rougher and deeper after the first coitus. He + quotes Riolan's statement that it is certain that the voice of + those who indulge in venery is changed. On that account the + ancients bound down the penis of their singers, and Martial said + that those who wish to preserve their voices should avoid coitus. + Democritus who one day had greeted a girl as "maiden" on the + following day addressed her as "woman," while in the same way it + is said that Albertus Magnus, observing from his study a girl + going for wine for her master, knew that she had had sexual + intercourse by the way because on her return her voice had become + deeper. Here, again, the ancient belief has a solid basis, for + the voice and the larynx are really affected by sexual + conditions. (<i>Parthenologia</i>, p. 286; Marro, <i>La Puberté</i>, p. + 303; Havelock Ellis, <i>op. cit.</i>, pp. 271, 289.)</p> + +<p> Others, again, Schurig proceeds, have judged that the goaty smell + given out in the armpits during the venereal act is also no + uncertain sign of defloration, such odor being perceptible in + those who use much venery, and not seldom in harlots and the + newly married, while, as Hippocrates said, it is not perceived in + boys and girls. (<i>Parthenologia</i>, p. 286; <i>cf.</i> the previous + volume of these <i>Studies</i>, "Sexual Selection in Man," p. 64.)</p><a name='5_Page_204'></a> + +<p> In virgins, Schurig remarks, the pubic hair is said to be long + and not twisted, while in women accustomed to coitus it is + crisper. But it is only after long and repeated coitus, some + authors add, that the pubic hairs become crisp. Some recent + observers, it may be remarked, have noted a connection between + sexual excitation and the condition of the pubic hair in women. + (<i>Cf.</i> the present volume, <i>ante</i> p. 127.)</p> + +<p> A sign to which the old authors often attached much importance + was furnished by the urinary stream. In the <i>De Secretis + Mulierum</i>, wrongly attributed to Albertus Magnus, it is laid down + that "the virgin urinates higher than the woman." Riolan, in his + <i>Anthropographia</i>, discussing the ability of virgins to ejaculate + urine to a height, states that Scaliger had observed women who + were virgins emit urine in a high jet against a wall, but that + married women could seldom do this. Bouaciolus also stated that + the urine of virgins is emitted in a small stream to a distance + with an acute hissing sound. (<i>Parthenologia</i>, p. 281.) A + folk-lore belief in the reality of this influence is evidenced by + the Picardy <i>conte</i> referred to already (<i>ante</i>, p. 53), "La + Princesse qui pisse au dessus les Meules." There is no doubt a + tendency for the various stresses of sexual life to produce an + influence in this direction, though they act far too slowly and + uncertainly to be a reliable index to the presence or the absence + of virginity.</p> + +<p> Another common ancient test of virginity by urination rests on a + psychic basis, and appears in a variety of forms which are really + all reducible to the same principle. Thus we are told in <i>De + Secretis Mulierum</i> that to ascertain if a girl is seduced she + should be given to eat of powdered crocus flowers, and if she has + been seduced she immediately urinates. We are here concerned with + auto-suggestion, and it may well be believed that with nervous + and credulous girls this test often revealed the truth.</p> + +<p> A further test of virginity discussed by Schurig is the presence + of modesty of countenance. If a woman blushes her virtue is safe. + In this way girls who have themselves had experience of the + marriage bed are said to detect the virgin. The virgin's eyes are + cast down and almost motionless, while she who has known a man + has eyes that are bright and quick. But this sign is equivocal, + says Schurig, for girls are different, and can simulate the + modesty they do not feel. Yet this indication also rests on a + fundamentally sound psychological basis. (See "The Evolution of + Modesty," in the first volume of these <i>Studies</i>.)</p> + +<p> In his <i>Syllepsilogia</i> (Section V, cap. I-II), published in 1731, + Schurig discusses further the anciently recognized signs of + pregnancy. The real or imaginary signs of pregnancy sought by + various primitive peoples of the past and present are brought + together by Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, bd. i, Chapter XXVII.</p></div><a name='5_Page_205'></a> + +<p>Both physically and psychically the occurrence of pregnancy is, however, a +distinct event. It marks the beginning of a continuous physical process, +which cannot fail to manifest psychic reactions. A great center of vital +activity—practically a new center, for only the germinal form of it in +menstruation had previously existed—has appeared and affects the whole +organism. "From the moment that the embryo takes possession of the woman," +Robert Barnes puts it, "every drop of blood, every fiber, every organ, is +affected."<a name='5_FNanchor_170'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_170'><sup>[170]</sup></a></p> + +<p>A woman artist once observed to Dr. Stratz, that as the final aim of a +woman is to become a mother and pregnancy is thus her blossoming time, a +beautiful woman ought to be most beautiful when she is pregnant. That is +so, Stratz replied, if her moment of greatest physical perfection +corresponds with the early months of pregnancy, for with the beginning of +pregnancy metabolism is increased, the color of the skin becomes more +lively and delicate, the breasts firmer.<a name='5_FNanchor_171'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_171'><sup>[171]</sup></a> Pregnancy may, indeed, often +become visible soon after conception by the brighter eye, the livelier +glance, resulting from greater vascular activity, though later, with the +increase of strain, the face may tend to become somewhat thin and +distorted. The hair, Barnes states, assumes a new vigor, even though it +may have been falling out before. The temperature rises; the weight +increases, even apart from the growth of the fœtus. The +efflorescence of pregnancy shows itself, as in the blossoming and +fecundated flower, by increased pigmentation.<a name='5_FNanchor_172'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_172'><sup>[172]</sup></a> The nipples with their +areolæ, and the mid-line of the belly, become darker; brown flecks +(lentigo) tend to appear on the forehead, neck, arms, and body; while +striæ—at first blue-red, then a brilliant white—appear on the belly and +thighs, <a name='5_Page_206'></a>though these are scarcely normal, for they are not seen in women +with very elastic skins and are rare among peasants and savages.<a name='5_FNanchor_173'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_173'><sup>[173]</sup></a> The +whole carriage of the woman tends to become changed with the development +of the mighty seed of man planted within her; it simulates the carriage of +pride with the arched back and protruded abdomen.<a name='5_FNanchor_174'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_174'><sup>[174]</sup></a> The pregnant woman +has been lifted above the level of ordinary humanity to become the casket +of an inestimable jewel.</p> + +<p>It is in the blood and the circulation that the earliest of the most +prominent symptoms of pregnancy are to be found. The ever increasing +development of this new focus of vascular activity involves an increased +vascular activity in the whole organism. This activity is present almost +from the first—a few days after the impregnation of the ovum—in the +breasts, and quickly becomes obvious to inspection and palpation. Before a +quite passive organ, the breast now rapidly increases in activity of +circulation and in size, while certain characteristic changes begin to +take place around the nipples.<a name='5_FNanchor_175'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_175'><sup>[175]</sup></a> As a result of the additional work +imposed upon it the heart tends to become slightly hypertrophied in order +to meet the additional strain; there may be some dilatation also.<a name='5_FNanchor_176'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_176'><sup>[176]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The recent investigations of Stengel and Stanton tend to show + that the increase of the heart's work during pregnancy is less + considerable than has generally been supposed, and that beyond + some enlargement and dilatation of the right ventricle there is + not usually any hypertrophy of the heart.</p></div><a name='5_Page_207'></a> + +<p>The total quantity of blood is raised. While increased in quantity, the +blood appears on the whole to be somewhat depreciated in quality, though +on this point there are considerable differences of opinion. Thus, as +regards hæmoglobin, some investigators have found that the old idea as to +the poverty of hæmoglobin in pregnancy is quite unfounded; a few have even +found that the hæmoglobin is increased. Most authorities have found the +red cells diminished, though some only slightly, while the white cells, +and also the fibrin, are increased. But toward the end of pregnancy there +is a tendency, perhaps due to the establishment of compensation, for the +blood to revert to the normal condition.<a name='5_FNanchor_177'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_177'><sup>[177]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It would appear probable, however, that the vascular phenomena of +pregnancy are not altogether so simple as the above statement would imply. +The activity of various glands at this time—well illustrated by the +marked salivation which sometimes occurs—indicates that other modifying +forces are at work, and it has been suggested that the changes in the +maternal circulation during pregnancy may best be explained by the theory +that there are two opposing kinds of secretion poured into the blood in +unusual degree during pregnancy: one contracting the vessels, the other +dilating them, one or the other sometimes gaining the upper hand. +Suprarenal extract, when administered, has a vaso-constricting influence, +and thyroid extract a vasodilating influence; it may be surmised that +within the body these glands perform similar functions.<a name='5_FNanchor_178'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_178'><sup>[178]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The important part played by the thyroid gland is indicated by its marked +activity at the very beginning of pregnancy. We may probably associate the +general tendency to vasodilatation during early pregnancy with the +tendency to goitre; Freund found an increase of the thyroid in 45 per +cent. of 50 cases. The thyroid belongs to the same class of ductless +glands as the <a name='5_Page_208'></a>ovary, and, as Bland Sutton and others have insisted, the +analogies between the thyroid and the ovary are very numerous and +significant. It may be added that in recent years Armand Gautier has noted +the importance of the thyroid in elaborating nucleo-proteids containing +arsenic and iodine, which are poured into the circulation during +menstruation and pregnancy. The whole metabolism of the body is indeed +affected, and during the latter part of pregnancy study of the ingesta and +egesta has shown that a storage of nitrogen and even of water is taking +place.<a name='5_FNanchor_179'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_179'><sup>[179]</sup></a> The woman, as Pinard puts it, forms the child out of her own +flesh, not merely out of her food; the individual is being sacrificed to +the species.</p> + +<p>The changes in the nervous system of the pregnant woman correspond to +those in the vascular system. There is the same increase of activity, a +heightening of tension. Bruno Wolff, from experiments on bitches, +concluded that the central nervous system in women is probably more easily +excited in the pregnant than in the non-pregnant state, though he was not +prepared to call this cerebral excitability "specific."<a name='5_FNanchor_180'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_180'><sup>[180]</sup></a> Direct +observations on pregnant women have shown, without doubt, a heightened +nervous irritability. Reflex action generally is increased. Neumann +investigated the knee-jerk in 500 women during pregnancy, labor, and the +puerperium, and in a large number found that there was a progressive +exaggeration with the advance of pregnancy, little or no change being +observed in the early months; sometimes when no change was observed during +pregnancy the knee-jerk still increased during labor, reaching its maximum +at the moment of the expulsion of the fœtus; the return to the +normal condition took place gradually during the puerperium. Tridandani +found in pregnant women that though the superficial reflexes, with the +exception of the abdominal, were diminished, the deep and tendon reflexes +were markedly increased, especially that of the knee, these changes being +more marked in primiparæ than in multiparæ, and more pronounced as +pregnancy advanced, the normal condition returning with <a name='5_Page_209'></a>ten days after +labor. Electrical excitability was sensibly diminished.<a name='5_FNanchor_181'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_181'><sup>[181]</sup></a></p> + +<p>One of the first signs of high nervous tension is vomiting. As is well +known, this phenomenon commonly appears early in pregnancy, and it is by +many considered entirely physiological. Barnes regards it as a kind of +safety valve, a regulating function, letting off excessive tension and +maintaining equilibrium.<a name='5_FNanchor_182'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_182'><sup>[182]</sup></a> Vomiting is, however, a convulsion, and is +thus the simplest form of a kind of manifestation—to which the heightened +nervous tension of pregnancy easily lends itself—that finds its extreme +pathological form in eclampsia. In this connection it is of interest to +point out that the pregnant woman here manifests in the highest degree a +tendency which is marked in women generally, for the female sex, apart +altogether from pregnancy, is specially liable to convulsive +phenomena.<a name='5_FNanchor_183'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_183'><sup>[183]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>There is some slight difference of opinion among authorities as + to the precise nature and causation of the sickness of pregnancy. + Barnes, Horrocks and others regard it as physiological; but many + consider it pathological; this is, for instance, the opinion of + Giles. Graily Hewitt attributed it to flexion of the gravid + uterus, Kaltenbach to hysteria, and Zaborsky terms it a neurosis. + Whitridge Williams considers that it may be (1) reflex, or (2) + neurotic (when it is allied to hysteria and amenable to + suggestion), or (3) toxæmic. It really appears to lie on the + borderland between healthy and diseased manifestations. It is + said to be unknown to farmers and veterinary surgeons. It appears + to be little known among savages; it is comparatively infrequent + among women of the lower social classes, and, as Giles has found, + women who habitually menstruate in a painless and normal manner + suffer comparatively little from the sickness of pregnancy.</p> + +<p> We owe a valuable study of the sickness of pregnancy to Giles, + who analyzed the records of 300 cases. He concluded that about + one-third of the pregnant women were free from sickness + throughout pregnancy, 45 per cent. were free during the first + three months. When sickness occurred it began in 70 per cent. of + cases in the first month, and was most frequent during the second + month. The duration varied from <a name='5_Page_210'></a>a few days to all through. + Between the ages of 20 and 25 sickness was least frequent, and + there was less sickness in the third than in any other pregnancy. + (This corresponds with the conclusion of Matthews Duncan that 25 + is the most favorable age for pregnancy.) To some extent in + agreement with Guéniot, Giles believes that the vomiting of + pregnancy is "one form of manifestation of the high nervous + irritability of pregnancy." This high nervous tension may + overflow into other channels, into the vascular and excretory + system, causing eclampsia; into the muscular system, causing + chorea, or, expending itself in the brain, give rise to hysteria + when mild or insanity when severe. But the vagi form a very ready + channel for such overflow, and hence the frequency of sickness in + pregnancy. There are thus three main factors in the causation of + this phenomenon: (1) An increased nervous irritability; (2) a + local source of irritation; (3) a ready efferent channel for + nervous energy. (Arthur Giles, "Observations on the Etiology of + the Sickness of Pregnancy," <i>Transactions Obstetrical Society of + London</i>, vol. xxv, 1894.)</p> + +<p> Martin, who regards the phenomenon as normal, points out that + when nausea and vomiting are absent or suddenly cease there is + often reason to suspect something wrong, especially the death of + the embryo. He also remarks that women who suffer from large + varicose veins are seldom troubled by the nausea of pregnancy. + (J. M. H. Martin, "The Vomiting of Pregnancy," <i>British Medical + Journal</i>, December 10, 1904.) These observations may be connected + with those of Evans (<i>American Gynæcological and Obstetrical + Journal</i>, January, 1900), who attributes primary importance to + the undoubtedly active factor of the irritation set up by the + uterus, more especially the rhythmic uterine contractions; + stimulation of the breasts produces active uterine contractions, + and Evans found that examination of the breasts sufficed to bring + on a severe attack of vomiting, while on another occasion this + was produced by a vaginal examination. Evans believes that the + purpose of these contractions is to facilitate the circulation of + the blood through the large venous sinuses, the surcharging of + the relatively stagnant pools with effete blood producing the + irritation which leads to rhythmic contractions.</p></div> + +<p>It is on the basis of the increased vascular and glandular activity and +the heightened nervous tension that the special psychic phenomena of +pregnancy develop. The best known, and perhaps the most characteristic of +these manifestations, is that known as "longings." By this term is meant +more or less irresistible desires for some special food or drink, which +may be digestible or indigestible, sometimes a substance which the <a name='5_Page_211'></a>woman +ordinarily likes, such as fruit, and occasionally one which, under +ordinary circumstances, she dislikes, as in one case known to me of a +young country woman who, when bearing her child, was always longing for +tobacco and never happy except when she could get a pipe to smoke, +although under ordinary circumstances, like other young women of her +class, she was without any desire to smoke. Occasionally the longings lead +to actions which are more unscrupulous than is common in the case of the +same person at other times; thus in one case known to me a young woman, +pregnant with her first child, insisted to her sister's horror on entering +a strawberry field and eating a quantity of fruit. These "longings" in +their extreme form may properly be considered as neurasthenic obsessions, +but in their simple and less pronounced forms they may well be normal and +healthy.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The old medical authors abound in narratives describing the + longings of pregnant women for natural and unnatural foods. This + affection was commonly called <i>pica</i>, sometimes <i>citra</i> or + <i>malatia</i>. Schurig, whose works are a comprehensive treasure + house of ancient medical lore, devotes a long chapter (cap. II) + of his <i>Chylologia</i>, published in 1725, to pica as manifested + mainly, though not exclusively, in pregnant women. Some women, he + tells us, have been compelled to eat all sorts of earthy + substances, of which sand seems the most common, and one Italian + woman when pregnant ate several pounds of sand with much + satisfaction, following it up with a draught of her own urine. + Lime, mud, chalk, charcoal, cinders, pitch are also the desired + substances in other cases detailed. One pregnant woman must eat + bread fresh from the oven in very large quantities, and a certain + noble matron ate 140 sweet cakes in one day and night. Wheat and + various kinds of corn as well as of vegetables were the foods + desired by many longing women. One woman was responsible for 20 + pounds of pepper, another ate ginger in large quantities, a third + kept mace under her pillow; cinnamon, salt, emulsion of almonds, + treacle, mushrooms were desired by others. Cherries were longed + for by one, and another ate 30 or 40 lemons in one night. Various + kinds of fish—mullet, oysters, crabs, live eels, etc.—are + mentioned, while other women have found delectation in lizards, + frogs, spiders and flies, even scorpions, lice and fleas. A + pregnant woman, aged 33, of sanguine temperament, ate a live fowl + completely with intense satisfaction. Skin, wool, cotton, thread, + linen, blotting paper have been desired, as well as more + repulsive substances, such as nasal mucus and feces (eaten with + bread). Vinegar, ice, and snow occur in <a name='5_Page_212'></a>other cases. One woman + stilled a desire for human flesh by biting the nates of children + or the arms of men. Metals are also swallowed, such as iron, + silver, etc. One pregnant woman wished to throw eggs in her + husband's face, and another to have her husband throw eggs in her + face.</p> + +<p> In the next chapter of the same work Schurig describes cases of + acute antipathy which may arise under the same circumstances + (cap. III, "De Nausea seu Antipathia certorum ciborum"). The list + includes bread, meat, fowls, fish, eels (a very common + repulsion), crabs, milk, butter (very often), cheese (often), + honey, sugar, salt, eggs, caviar, sulphur, apples (especially + their odor), strawberries, mulberries, cinnamon, mace, capers, + pepper, onions, mustard, beetroot, rice, mint, absinthe, roses + (many pages are devoted to this antipathy), lilies, elder + flowers, musk (which sometimes caused vomiting), amber, coffee, + opiates, olive oil, vinegar, cats, frogs, spiders, wasps, swords.</p> + +<p> More recently Gould and Pyle (<i>Anomalies and Curiosities of + Medicine</i>, p. 80) have briefly summarized some of the ancient and + modern records concerning the longings of pregnant women.</p></div> + +<p>Various theories are put forward concerning the causation of the longings +of pregnant women, but none of these seems to furnish by itself a complete +and adequate explanation of all cases. Thus it is said that the craving is +the expression of a natural instinct, the system of the pregnant woman +really requiring the food she longs for. It is quite probable that this is +so in many cases, but it is obviously not so in the majority of cases, +even when we confine ourselves to the longings for fairly natural foods, +while we know so little of the special needs of the organism during +pregnancy that the theory in any case is insusceptible of clear +demonstration.</p> + +<p>Allied to this theory is the explanation that the longings are for things +that counteract the tendency to nausea and sickness. Giles, however, in +his valuable statistical study of the longings of a series of 300 pregnant +women, has shown that the percentage of women with longings is exactly the +same (33 per cent.) among women who had suffered at some time during +pregnancy from sickness as among the women who had not so suffered. +Moreover, Giles found that the period of sickness frequently bore no +relation to the time when there were cravings, and the patient often had +cravings after the sickness had ceased.</p> + +<p>According to another theory these longings are mainly a <a name='5_Page_213'></a>matter of +auto-suggestion. The pregnant woman has received the tradition of such +longings, persuades herself that she has such a longing, and then becomes +convinced that, according to a popular belief, it will be bad for the +child if the longing is not gratified. Giles considers that this process +of auto-suggestion takes place "in a certain number, perhaps even in the +majority of cases."<a name='5_FNanchor_184'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_184'><sup>[184]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Duchess d'Abrantès, the wife of Marshal Junot, in her + <i>Mémoires</i> gives an amusing account of how in her first pregnancy + a longing was apparently imposed upon her by the anxious + solicitude of her own and her husband's relations. Though + suffering from constant nausea and sickness, she had no longings. + One day at dinner after the pregnancy had gone on for some months + her mother suddenly put down her fork, exclaiming: "I have never + asked you what longing you have!" She replied with truth that she + had none, her days and her nights being occupied with suffering. + "No <i>envie!</i>" said the mother, "such a thing was never heard of. + I must speak to your mother-in-law." The two old ladies consulted + anxiously and explained to the young mother how an unsatisfied + longing might produce a monstrous child, and the husband also now + began to ask her every day what she longed for. Her + sister-in-law, moreover, brought her all sorts of stories of + children born with appalling mother's marks due to this cause. + She became frightened and began to wonder what she most wanted, + but could think of nothing. At last, when eating a pastille + flavored with pineapple, it occurred to her that pineapple is an + excellent fruit, and one, moreover, which she had never seen, for + at that time it was extremely rare. Thereupon she began to long + for pineapple, and all the more when she was told that at that + season they could not be obtained. She now began to feel that she + must have pineapple or die, and her husband ran all over Paris, + vainly offering twenty louis for a pineapple. At last he + succeeded in obtaining one through the kindness of Mme. + Bonaparte, and drove home furiously just as his wife, always + talking of pineapples, had gone to bed. He entered the room with + the pineapple, to the great satisfaction of the Duchess's mother. + (In one of her own pregnancies, it appears, she longed in vain + for cherries in January, and the child was born with a mark on + her body resembling a cherry—in scientific terminology, a + <i>nævus</i>.) The Duchess effusively thanked her husband and wished + to eat of the fruit immediately, but her husband stopped her and + said that Corvisart, the famous physician, had told him that she + must on no <a name='5_Page_214'></a>account touch it at night, as it was extremely + indigestible. She promised not to do so, and spent the night in + caressing the pineapple. In the morning the husband came and cut + up the fruit, presenting it to her in a porcelain bowl. Suddenly, + however, there was a revulsion of feeling; she felt that she + could not possibly eat pineapple; persuasion was useless; the + fruit had to be taken away and the windows opened, for the very + smell of it had become odious. The Duchess adds that henceforth, + throughout her life, though still liking the flavor, she was only + able to eat pineapple by doing a sort of violence to herself. + (<i>Mémories de la Duchesse d'Abrantès</i>, vol. iii, Chapter VIII.) + It should be added that, in old age, the Duchess d'Abrantès + appears to have become insane.</p></div> + +<p>The influence of suggestion must certainly be accepted as, at all events, +increasing and emphasizing the tendency to longings. It can scarcely, +however, be regarded as a radical and adequate explanation of the +phenomenon generally. If it is a matter of auto-suggestion due to a +tradition, then we should expect to find longings most frequent and most +pronounced in multiparous women, who are best acquainted with the +tradition and best able to experience all that is expected of a pregnant +woman. But, as a matter of fact, the women who have borne most children +are precisely those who are least likely to be affected by the longings +which tradition demands they should manifest. Giles has shown that +longings occur much more frequently in the first than in any subsequent +pregnancy; there is a regular decrease with the increase in number of +pregnancies until in women with ten or more children the longings scarcely +occur at all.</p> + +<p>We must probably regard longings as based on a physiological and psychic +tendency which is of universal extension and almost or quite normal. They +are known throughout Europe and were known to the medical writers of +antiquity. Old Indian as well as old Jewish physicians recognized them. +They have been noted among many savage races to-day: among the Indians of +North and South America, among the peoples of the Nile and the Soudan, in +the Malay archipelago.<a name='5_FNanchor_185'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_185'><sup>[185]</sup></a> In Europe they are most <a name='5_Page_215'></a>common among the +women of the people, living simple and natural lives.<a name='5_FNanchor_186'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_186'><sup>[186]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The true normal relationship of the longings of pregnancy is with the +impulsive and often irresistible longings for food delicacies which are +apt to overcome children, and in girls often persist or revive through +adolescence and even beyond. Such sudden fits of greediness belong to +those kind of normal psychic manifestations which are on the verge of the +abnormal into which they occasionally pass. They may occur, however, in +healthy, well-bred, and well-behaved children who, under the stress of the +sudden craving, will, without compunction and apparently without +reflection, steal the food they long for or even steal from their parents +the money to buy it. The food thus seized by a well-nigh irresistible +craving is nearly always a fruit. Fruit is usually doled out to children +in small quantities as a luxury, but we are descended from primitive human +peoples and still more remote ape-like ancestors, by whom fruit was in its +season eaten copiously, and it is not surprising that when that season +comes round the child, more sensitive than the adult to primitive +influences, should sometimes experience the impulse of its ancestors with +overwhelming intensity, all the more so if, as is probable, the craving is +to some extent the expression of a physiological need.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Sanford Bell, who has investigated the food impulses of children + in America, finds that girls have a greater number of likes and + dislikes in foods than boys of the same age, though at the same + time they have less dislikes to some foods than boys. The + proclivity for sweets and fruits shows itself as soon as a child + begins to eat solids. The chief fruits liked are oranges, + bananas, apples, peaches, and pears. This strong preference for + fruits lasts till the age of 13 or 14, though relatively weaker + from 10 to 13. In girls, however, Bell notes the significant fact + from our present point of view that at mid-adolescence there is a + revived taste for sweets and fruits. He believes that the growth + of children in taste in foods recapitulates the experience of the + race. (S. Bell, "An Introductory Study of the Psychology of + Foods." <i>Pedagogical Seminary</i>, March, 1904.)</p></div><a name='5_Page_216'></a> + +<p>The heightened nervous impressionability of pregnancy would appear to +arouse into activity those primitive impulses which are liable to occur in +childhood and in the unmarried girl continue to the nubile age. It is a +significant fact that the longings of pregnant women are mainly for fruit, +and notably for so wholesome a fruit as the apple, which may very well +have a beneficial effect on the system of the pregnant woman. Giles, in +his tabulation of the foods longed for by 300 pregnant women, found that +the fruit group was by far the largest, furnishing 79 cases; apples were +far away at the head, occurring in 34 cases out of the 99 who had +longings, while oranges followed at a distance (with 13 cases), and in the +vegetable group tomatoes came first (with 6 cases). Several women declared +"I could have lived on apples," "I was eating apples all day," "I used to +sit up in bed eating apples."<a name='5_FNanchor_187'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_187'><sup>[187]</sup></a> Pregnant women appear seldom to long +for the possession of objects outside the edible class, and it seems +doubtful whether they have any special tendency to kleptomania. Pinard has +pointed out that neither Lasègue nor Lunier, in their studies of +kleptomania, have mentioned a single shop robbery committed by a pregnant +woman.<a name='5_FNanchor_188'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_188'><sup>[188]</sup></a> Brouardel has indeed found such cases, but the object stolen +was usually a food.</p> + +<p>A further significant fact connecting the longings of pregnant women with +the longings of children is to be found in the fact that they occur mainly +in young women. We have, indeed, no tabulation of the ages of pregnant +women who have manifested longings, but Giles has clearly shown that these +chiefly <a name='5_Page_217'></a>occur in primiparæ, and steadily and rapidly decrease in each +successive pregnancy. This fact, otherwise somewhat difficult of +explanation, is natural if we look upon the longings of pregnancy as a +revival of those of childhood. It certainly indicates also that we can by +no means regard these longings as exclusively the expression of a +physiological craving, for in that case they would be liable to occur in +any pregnancy unless, indeed, it is argued that with each successive +pregnancy the woman becomes less sensitive to her own physiological state.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>There has been a frequent tendency, more especially among + primitive peoples, to regard a pregnant woman's longings as + something sacred and to be indulged, all the more, no doubt, as + they are usually of a simple and harmless character. In the Black + Forest, according to Ploss and Bartels, a pregnant woman may go + freely into other people's gardens and take fruit, provided she + eats it on the spot, and very similar privileges are accorded to + her elsewhere. Old English opinion, as reflected, for instance, + in Ben Jonson's plays (as Dr. Harriet C. B. Alexander has pointed + out), regards the pregnant woman as not responsible for her + longings, and Kiernan remarks ("Kleptomania and Collectivism," + <i>Alienist and Neurologist</i>, November, 1902) that this is in "a + most natural and just view." In France at the Revolution a law of + the 28th Germinal, in the year III, to some extent admitted the + irresponsibility of the pregnant woman generally,—following the + classic precedent, by which a woman could not be brought before a + court of justice so long as she was pregnant,—but the Napoleonic + code, never tender to women, abrogated this. Pinard does not + consider that the longings of pregnant women are irresistible, + and, consequently, regards the pregnant woman as responsible. + This is probably the view most widely held. In any case these + longings seldom come up for medico-legal consideration.</p></div> + +<p>The phenomena of the longings of pregnancy are linked to the much more +obscure and dubious phenomena of the influence of maternal impressions on +the child within the womb. It is true, indeed, that there is no real +connection whatever between these two groups of manifestations, but they +have been so widely and for so long closely associated in the popular mind +that it is convenient to pass directly from one to the other. The same +name is sometimes given to the two manifestations; thus in France a +pregnant longing is an <i>envie</i>, while a mother's mark on the child is also +called an <i>envie</i>, because it is supposed to be due to the mother's +unsatisfied longing.</p><a name='5_Page_218'></a> + +<p>The conception of a "maternal impression" (the German <i>Versehen</i>) rests on +the belief that a powerful mental influence working on the mother's mind +may produce an impression, either general or definite, on the child she is +carrying. It makes a great deal of difference whether the effect of the +impression on the child is general, or definite and circumscribed. It is +not difficult to believe that a general effect—even, as Sir Arthur +Mitchell first gave good reason for believing, idiocy—may be produced on +the child by strong and prolonged emotional influence working on the +mother, because such general influence may be transmitted through a +deteriorated blood-stream. But it is impossible at present to understand +how a definite and limited influence working on the mother could produce a +definite and limited effect on the child, for there are no channels of +nervous communications for the passage of such influences. Our difficulty +in conceiving of the process must, however, be put aside if the fact +itself can be demonstrated by convincing evidence.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In order to illustrate the nature of maternal impressions, I will + summarize a few cases which I have collected from the best + medical periodical literature during the past fifteen years. I + have exercised no selection and in no way guarantee the + authenticity of the alleged facts or the alleged explanation. + They are merely examples to illustrate a class of cases published + from time to time by medical observers in medical journals of + high repute.</p> + +<p> Early in pregnancy a woman found her pet rabbit killed by a cat + which had gnawed off the two forepaws, leaving ragged stumps; she + was for a long time constantly thinking of this. Her child was + born with deformed feet, one foot with only two toes, the other + three, the os calcis in both feet being either absent or little + developed. (G. B. Beale, Tottenham, <i>Lancet</i>, May 4, 1889).</p> + +<p> Three months and a half before birth of the child the father, a + glazier, fell through the roof of a hothouse, severely cutting + his right arm, so that he was lying in the infirmary for a long + time, and it was doubtful whether the hand could be saved. The + child was healthy, but on the flexor surface of the radial side + of the right forearm just above the wrist—the same spot as the + father's injury—there was a nævus the size of a sixpence. (W. + Russell, Paisley, <i>Lancet</i>, May 11, 1889.)</p> + +<p> At the beginning of pregnancy a woman was greatly scared by being + kicked over by a frightened cow she was milking; she hung on to + the animal's teats, but thought she would be trampled to death, + and <a name='5_Page_219'></a>was ill and nervous for weeks afterwards. The child was a + monster, with a fleshy substance—seeming to be prolonged from + the spinal cord and to represent the brain—projecting from the + floor of the skull. Both doctor and nurse were struck by the + resemblance to a cow's teats before they knew the woman's story, + and this was told by the woman immediately after delivery and + before she knew to what she had given birth. (A. Ross Paterson, + Reversby, Lincolnshire, <i>Lancet</i>, September 29, 1889.)</p> + +<p> During the second month of pregnancy the mother was terrified by + a bullock as she was returning from market. The child reached + full term and was a well-developed male, stillborn. Its head + "exactly resembled a miniature cow's head;" the occipital bone + was absent, the parietals only slightly developed, the eyes were + placed at the top of the frontal bone, which was quite flat, with + each of its superior angles twisted into a rudimentary horn. + (J. T. Hislop, Tavistock, Devon, <i>Lancet</i>, November 1, 1890.)</p> + +<p> When four months pregnant the mother, a multipara of 30, was + startled by a black and white collie dog suddenly pushing against + her and rushing out when she opened the door. This preyed on her + mind, and she felt sure her child would be marked. The whole of + the child's right thigh was encircled by a shining black mole, + studded with white hairs; there was another mole on the spine of + the left scapula. (C. F. Williamson, Horley, Surrey, <i>Lancet</i>, + October 11, 1890.)</p> + +<p> A lady in comfortable circumstances, aged 24, not markedly + emotional, with one child, in all respects healthy, early in her + pregnancy saw a man begging whose arms and legs were "all doubled + up." This gave her a shock, but she hoped no ill effects would + follow. The child was an encephalous monster, with the + extremities rigidly flexed and the fingers clenched, the feet + almost sole to sole. In the next pregnancy she frequently passed + a man who was a partial cripple, but she was not unduly + depressed; the child was a counterpart of the last, except that + the head was normal. The next child was strong and well formed. + (C. W. Chapman, London, <i>Lancet</i>, October 18, 1890.)</p> + +<p> When the pregnant mother was working in a hayfield her husband + threw at her a young hare he had found in the hay; it struck her + on the cheek and neck. Her daughter has on the left cheek an + oblong patch of soft dark hair, in color and character clearly + resembling the fur of a very young hare. (A. Mackay, Port Appin, + N. B., <i>Lancet</i>, December 19, 1891. The writer records also four + other cases which have happened in his experience.)</p> + +<p> When the mother was pregnant her husband had to attend to a sow + who could not give birth to her pigs; he bled her freely, cutting + a notch out of both ears. His wife insisted on seeing the sow. + The helix of each ear of her child at birth was gone, for nearly + or quite half an inch, as if cut purposely. (R. P. Roons, <i>Medical + World</i>, 1894.)</p><a name='5_Page_220'></a> + +<p> A lady when pregnant was much interested in a story in which one + of the characters had a supernumerary digit, and this often + recurred to her mind. Her baby had a supernumerary digit on one + hand. (J. Jenkyns, Aberdeen, <i>British Medical Journal</i>, March 2, + 1895. The writer also records another case.)</p> + +<p> When pregnant the mother saw in the forest a new-born fawn which + was a double monstrosity. Her child was a similar double + monstrosity (<i>cephalothora copagus</i>). (Hartmann, <i>Münchener + Medicinisches Wochenschrift</i>, No. 9, 1895.)</p> + +<p> A well developed woman of 30, who had ten children in twelve + years, in the third month of her tenth pregnancy saw a child run + over by a street car, which crushed the upper and back part of + its head. Her own child was anencephalic and acranial, with + entire absence of vault of skull. (F. A. Stahl, <i>American Journal + of Obstetrics</i>, April, 1896.)</p> + +<p> A healthy woman with no skin blemish had during her third + pregnancy a violent appetite for sunfish. During or after the + fourth month her husband, as a surprise, brought her some sunfish + alive, placing them in a pail of water in the porch. She stumbled + against the pail and the shock caused the fish to flap over the + pail and come in violent contact with her leg. The cold wriggling + fish produced a nervous shock, but she attached no importance to + this. The child (a girl) had at birth a mark of bronze pigment + resembling a fish with the head uppermost (photograph given) on + the corresponding part of the same leg. Daughter's health good; + throughout life she has had a strong craving for sunfish, which + she has sometimes eaten till she has vomited from repletion. + (C. F. Gardiner, Colorado Springs, <i>American Journal Obstetrics</i>, + February, 1898.)</p> + +<p> The next case occurred in a bitch. A thoroughbred fox terrier + bitch strayed and was discovered a day or two later with her + right foreleg broken. The limb was set under chloroform with the + help of Röntgen rays, and the dog made a good recovery. Several + weeks later she gave birth to a puppy with a right foreleg that + was ill-developed and minus the paw. (J. Booth, Cork, <i>British + Medical Journal</i>, September 16, 1899.)</p> + +<p> Four months before the birth of her child a woman with four + healthy children and no history of deformity in the family fell + and cut her left wrist severely against a broken bowl; she had a + great fright and shock. Her child, otherwise perfect, was born + without left hand and wrist, the stump of arm terminating at + lower end of radius and ulna. (G. Ainslie Johnston, Ambleside, + <i>British Medical Journal</i>, April 18, 1903.)</p></div> + +<p>The belief in the reality of the transference of strong mental or physical +impressions on the mother into physical <a name='5_Page_221'></a>changes in the child she is +bearing is very ancient and widespread. Most writers on the subject begin +with the book of Genesis and the astute device of Jacob in influencing the +color of his lambs by mental impressions on his ewes. But the belief +exists among even more primitive people than the early Hebrews, and in all +parts of the world.<a name='5_FNanchor_189'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_189'><sup>[189]</sup></a> Among the Greeks there is a trace of the belief +in Hippocrates, the first of the world's great physicians, while Soranus, +the most famous of ancient gynæcologists, states the matter in the most +precise manner, with instances in proof. The belief continued to persist +unquestioned throughout the Middle Ages. The first author who denied the +influence of maternal impressions altogether appears to have been the +famous anatomist, Realdus Columbus, who was a professor at Padua, Pisa, +and Rome at the beginning of the sixteenth century. In the same century, +however, another and not less famous Neapolitan, Della Porta, for the +first time formulated a definite theory of maternal impressions. A little +later, early in the seventeenth century, a philosophic physician at Padua, +Fortunatus Licetus, took up an intermediate position which still finds, +perhaps reasonably, a great many adherents. He recognized that a very +frequent cause of malformation in the child is to be found in morbid +antenatal conditions, but at the same time was not prepared to deny +absolutely and in every case the influence of maternal impression on such +conditions. Malebranche, the Platonic philosopher, allowed the greatest +extension to the power of the maternal imagination. In the eighteenth +century, however, the new spirit of free inquiry, of radical criticism, +and unfettered logic, led to a sceptical attitude toward this ancient +belief then flourishing vigorously.<a name='5_FNanchor_190'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_190'><sup>[190]</sup></a> In 1727, a few years after +Malebranche's death, James Blondel, a physician of extreme acuteness, who +had <a name='5_Page_222'></a>been born in Paris, was educated at Leyden, and practiced in London, +published the first methodical and thorough attack on the doctrine of +maternal impressions, <i>The Strength of Imagination of Pregnant Women +Examined</i>, and exercised his great ability in ridiculing it. Haller, +Roederer, and Sömmering followed in the steps of Blondel, and were either +sceptical or hostile to the ancient belief. Blumenbach, however, admitted +the influence of maternal impressions. Erasmus Darwin, as well as Goethe +in his <i>Wahlverwandtschaften</i>, even accepted the influence of paternal +impressions on the child. By the beginning of the nineteenth century the +majority of physicians were inclined to relegate maternal impressions to +the region of superstition. Yet the exceptions were of notable importance. +Burdach, when all deductions were made, still found it necessary to retain +the belief in maternal impressions, and Von Baer, the founder of +embryology, also accepted it, supported by a case, occurring in his own +sister, which he was able to investigate before the child's birth. L. W. T. +Bischoff, also, while submitting the doctrine to acute criticism, found it +impossible to reject maternal impressions absolutely, and he remarked that +the number of adherents to the doctrine was showing a tendency to increase +rather than diminish. Johannes Müller, the founder of modern physiology in +Germany, declared himself against it, and his influence long prevailed; +Valentin, Rudolf Wagner, and Emil du Bois-Reymond were on the same side. +On the other hand various eminent gynæcologists—Litzmann, Roth, Hennig, +etc.—have argued in favor of the reality of maternal impressions.<a name='5_FNanchor_191'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_191'><sup>[191]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The long conflict of opinion which has taken place over this opinion has +still left the matter unsettled. The acutest critics <a name='5_Page_223'></a>of the ancient +belief constantly conclude the discussion with an expression of doubt and +uncertainty. Even if the majority of authorities are inclined to reject +maternal impressions, the scientific eminence of those who accept them +makes a decisive opinion difficult. The arguments against such influence +are perfectly sound: (1) it is a primitive belief of unscientific origin; +(2) it is impossible to conceive how such influence can operate since +there is no nervous connection between mother and child; (3) comparatively +few cases have been submitted to severe critical investigation; (4) it is +absurd to ascribe developmental defects to influences which arise long +after the fœtus had assumed its definite shape<a name='5_FNanchor_192'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_192'><sup>[192]</sup></a>; (5) in any +case the phenomenon must be rare, for William Hunter could not find a +coincidence between maternal impressions and fœtal marks through +a period of several years, and Bischoff found no case in 11,000 +deliveries. These statements embody the whole of the argument against +maternal impressions, yet it is clear that they do not settle the matter. +Edgar, in a manual of obstetrics which is widely regarded as a standard +work, states that this is "yet a mooted question."<a name='5_FNanchor_193'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_193'><sup>[193]</sup></a> Ballantyne, again, +in a discussion of this influence at the Edinburgh Obstetrical Society, +summarizing the result of a year's inquiry, concluded that it is still +"<i>sub judice</i>."<a name='5_FNanchor_194'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_194'><sup>[194]</sup></a> In a subsequent discussion of the question he has +somewhat modified his opinion, and is inclined to deny that definite +impressions on the pregnant woman's mind can cause similar defects in the +fœtus; they are "accidental coincidences," but he adds that a few +of the <a name='5_Page_224'></a>cases are difficult to explain away. At the same time he fully +believes that prolonged and strongly marked mental states of the mother +may affect the development of the fœtus in her uterus, causing +vascular and nutritive disturbances, irregularities of development, and +idiocy.<a name='5_FNanchor_195'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_195'><sup>[195]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Whether and in how far mental impressions on the mother can + produce definite mental and emotional disposition in the child is + a special aspect of the question to which scarcely any inquiry + has been devoted. So distinguished a biologist as Mr. A. W. + Wallace has, however, called attention to this point, bringing + forward evidence on the question and emphasizing the need of + further investigation. "Such transmission of mental influence," + he remarks, "will hardly be held to be impossible or even very + improbable," (A. W. Wallace, "Prenatal Influences on Character," + <i>Nature</i>, August 24, 1893.)</p></div> + +<p>It has already been pointed out that a large number of cases of fœtal +deformities, supposed to be due to maternal impressions, cannot +possibly be so caused because the impression took place at a period when +the development of the fœtus must already have been decided. In +this connection, however, it must be noted that Dabney has observed a +relationship between the time of supposed mental impressions and the +nature of the actual defect which is of considerable significance as an +argument in favor of the influence of mental impressions. He tabulated 90 +carefully reported cases from recent medical literature, and found that 21 +of them were concerned with defects of structure of the lips and palate. +In all but 2 of these 21 the defect was referred to an impression +occurring within the first three months of pregnancy. This is an important +point as showing that the assigned cause really falls within a period when +a defect of development actually could produce the observed result, +although the person reporting the cases was in many instances manifestly +ignorant of the details of embryology and teratology. There was no such +preponderance of early impressions among the defects of skin and hair +which might well, so far as development is concerned, have been caused at +a later period; here, in 7 out <a name='5_Page_225'></a>of 15 cases, it was distinctly stated that +the impression was made later than the fourth month.<a name='5_FNanchor_196'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_196'><sup>[196]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It would seem, on the whole, that while the influence of maternal +impressions in producing definite effects on the child within the womb has +by no means been positively demonstrated, we are not entitled to reject it +with any positive assurance. Even if we accept it, however, it must +remain, for the present, an inexplicable fact; the <i>modus operandi</i> we can +scarcely even guess at. General influences from the mother on the child we +can easily conceive of as conveyed by the mother's blood; we can even +suppose that the modified blood might act specifically on one particular +kind of tissue. We can, again, as suggested by Féré, very well believe +that the maternal emotions act upon the womb and produce various kinds and +degrees of pressure on the child within, so that the apparently active +movements of the fœtus may be really consecutive on unconscious +maternal excitations.<a name='5_FNanchor_197'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_197'><sup>[197]</sup></a> We may also believe that, as suggested by John +Thomson, there are slight incoördinations <i>in utero</i>, a kind of +developmental neurosis, produced by some slight lack of harmony of +whatever origin, and leading to the production of malformations.<a name='5_FNanchor_198'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_198'><sup>[198]</sup></a> We +know, finally, that, as Féré and others have repeatedly demonstrated +during recent years by experiments on chickens, etc., very subtle agents, +even odors, may profoundly affect embryonic development and produce +deformity. But how the mother's psychic disposition can, apart from +heredity, affect specifically the physical conformation or even the +psychic disposition of the child within her womb must remain for the +present an insoluble mystery, even if we feel disposed to conclude that in +some cases such action seems to be indicated.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In comprehending such a connection, however at present + undemonstrated, it may well be borne in mind that the + relationship of the mother to the child within her womb is of a + uniquely intimate character. It is <a name='5_Page_226'></a>of interest in this + connection to quote some remarks by an able psychologist, Dr. + Henry Rutgers Marshall; the remarks are not less interesting for + being brought forward without any connection with the question of + maternal impressions: "It is true that, so far as we know, the + nervous system of the embryo never has a direct connection with + the nervous system of the mother: nevertheless, as there is a + reciprocity of reaction between the physical body of the mother + and its embryonic parasite, the relation of the embryonic nervous + system to the nervous system of the mother is not very far + removed from the relation of the pre-eminent part of the nervous + system of a man to some minor nervous system within his body + which is to a marked extent dissociated from the whole neural + mass.</p> + +<p> "Correspondingly, then, and within the consciousness of the + mother, there develops a new little minor consciousness which, + although but lightly integrated with the mass of her + consciousness, nevertheless has its part in her consciousness + taken as a whole, much as the psychic correspondents of the + action of the nerve which govern the secretions of the glands of + the body have their part in her consciousness taken as a whole.</p> + +<p> "It is very much as if the optic ganglia developed fully in + themselves, without any closer connection with the rest of the + brain than existed at their first appearance. They would form a + little complex nervous system almost but not quite apart from the + brain system; and it would be difficult to deny them a + consciousness of their own; which would indeed form part of the + whole consciousness of the individual, but which would be in a + manner self-dependent." It must, if this is so, be said that + before birth, on the psychic side, the embryo's activities "form + part of a complex consciousness which is that of the mother and + embryo together." "Without subscribing to the strange stories of + telepathy, of the solemn apparition of a person somewhere at the + moment of his death a thousand miles away, of the unquiet ghost + haunting the scenes of its bygone hopes and endeavors, one may + ask" (with the author of the address in medicine at the Leicester + gathering of the British Medical Association, <i>British Medical + Journal</i>, July 29, 1905) "whether two brains cannot be so tuned + in sympathy as to transmit and receive a subtile transfusion of + mind without mediation of sense. Considering what is implied by + the human brain with its countless millions of cells, its + complexities of minute structure, its innumerable chemical + compositions, and the condensed forces in its microscopic and + ultramicroscopic elements—the whole a sort of microcosm of + cosmic forces to which no conceivable compound of electric + batteries is comparable; considering, again, that from an + electric station waves of energy radiate through the viewless air + to be caught up by a fit receiver a thousand miles distant, it is + not inconceivable that the human brain may send off still more + subtile <a name='5_Page_227'></a>waves to be accepted and interpreted by the fitly tuned + receiving brain. Is it, after all, mere fancy that a mental + atmosphere or effluence emanates from one person to affect + another, either soothing sympathetically or irritating + antipathically?" These remarks (like Dr. Marshall's) were made + without reference to maternal impressions, but it may be pointed + out that under no conceivable circumstance could we find a brain + in so virginal and receptive a state as is the child's in the + womb.</p></div> + +<p>On the whole we see that pregnancy induces a psychic state which is at +once, in healthy persons, one of full development and vigor, and at the +same time one which, especially in individuals who are slightly abnormal, +is apt to involve a state of strained or overstrained nervous tension and +to evoke various manifestations which are in many respects still +imperfectly understood. Even the specifically sexual emotions tend to be +heightened, more especially during the earlier period of pregnancy. In 24 +cases of pregnancy in which the point was investigated by Harry Campbell, +sexual feeling was decidedly increased in 8, in one case (of a woman aged +31 who had had four children) being indeed only present during pregnancy, +when it was considerable; in only 7 cases was there diminution or +disappearance of sexual feeling.<a name='5_FNanchor_199'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_199'><sup>[199]</sup></a> Pregnancy may produce mental +depression;<a name='5_FNanchor_200'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_200'><sup>[200]</sup></a> but on the other hand it frequently leads to a change of +the most favorable character in the mental and general well-being. Some +women indeed are only well during pregnancy. It is remarkable that some +women who habitually suffer from various nervous troubles—neuralgias, +gastralgia, headache, insomnia—are only free from them at this moment. +This "paradox of gestation," as Vinay has termed it, is specially marked +in the hysterical and those suffering from slight nervous disorders, but +it is by no means universal, so that although it is possible, Vinay +states, to confirm the opinion of the ancients as <a name='5_Page_228'></a>to the beneficial +action of marriage on hysteria, that is only true of slight cases and +scarcely enables us to counsel marriage in hysteria.<a name='5_FNanchor_201'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_201'><sup>[201]</sup></a> Even a woman's +intelligence is sometimes heightened by pregnancy, and Tarnier, as quoted +by Vinay, knew many women whose intelligence, habitually somewhat obtuse, +has only risen to the normal level during pregnancy.<a name='5_FNanchor_202'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_202'><sup>[202]</sup></a> The pregnant +woman has reached the climax of womanhood; she has attained to that state +toward which the periodically recurring menstrual wave has been drifting +her at regular intervals throughout her sexual life<a name='5_FNanchor_203'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_203'><sup>[203]</sup></a>; she has achieved +that function for which her body has been constructed, and her mental and +emotional disposition adapted, through countless ages.</p> + +<p>And yet, as we have seen, our ignorance of the changes effected by the +occurrence of this supremely important event—even on the physical +side—still remains profound. Pregnancy, even for us, the critical and +unprejudiced children of a civilized age, still remains, as for the +children of more primitive ages, a mystery. Conception itself is a mystery +for the primitive man, and may be produced by all sorts of subtle ways +apart from sexual connection, even by smelling a flower.<a name='5_FNanchor_204'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_204'><sup>[204]</sup></a> The pregnant +woman <a name='5_Page_229'></a>was surrounded by ceremonies, by reverence and fear, often shut up +in a place apart.<a name='5_FNanchor_205'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_205'><sup>[205]</sup></a> Her presence, her exhalations, were of extreme +potency; even in some parts of Europe to-day, as in the Walloon districts +of Belgium, a pregnant woman must not kiss a child for her breath is +dangerous, or urinate on plants for she will kill them.<a name='5_FNanchor_206'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_206'><sup>[206]</sup></a> The mystery +has somewhat changed its form; it still remains. The future of the race is +bound up with our efforts to fathom the mystery of pregnancy. "The early +days of human life," it has been truly said, "are entirely one with the +mother. On her manner of life—eating, drinking, sleeping, and +thinking—what greatness may not hang?"<a name='5_FNanchor_207'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_207'><sup>[207]</sup></a> Schopenhauer observed, with +misapplied horror, that there is nothing a woman is less modest about than +the state of pregnancy, while Weininger exclaims: "Never yet has a +pregnant woman given expression in any form—poem, memoirs, or +gynæcological monograph—to her sensations or feelings."<a name='5_FNanchor_208'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_208'><sup>[208]</sup></a> Yet when we +contemplate the mystery of pregnancy and all that it involves, how trivial +all such considerations become! We are here lifted into a region where our +highest intelligence can only lead us to adoration, for we are gazing at a +process in which the operations of Nature become one with the divine task +of Creation.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_169'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_169'>[169]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, Groos, <i>Æsthetische Genuss</i>, p. 249. "We have +to admit," Groos observes, "the entrance of another instinct, the impulse +to tend and foster, so closely connected with the sexual life. It is +seemingly due to the co-operation of this impulse that the little female +bird during courtship is so often fed by the male like a young fledgling. +In man 'love' from the biological standpoint is also an amalgamation of +two needs; when the tender need to protect and foster and serve is lacking +the emotion is not quite perfect. Heine's expression, 'With my mantle I +protect you from the storm,' has always seemed to me very characteristic." +Sometimes the sexual impulse may undergo a complete transformation in this +direction. "I believe there is really a tendency in women," a lady writes +in a letter, "to allow maternal feeling to take the place of sexual +feeling. Very often a woman's feeling for her husband becomes this (though +he may be twenty years older than herself); sometimes it does not, +remaining purely sex feeling. Sometimes it is for some other man she has +this curious self-obliterating maternal feeling. It is not necessarily +connected with sex intercourse. A prostitute, who has relations with +dozens of men, may have it for some feeble drunken fool, who perhaps goes +after other women. I once saw the change from sex feeling to mother +feeling, as I call it, come almost suddenly over a woman after she had +lived about four years with a man who was unfaithful to her. Then, when +all real sex feeling, the hatred of the woman he followed, the desire he +should give her love and tenderness, had all gone, came the other feeling, +and she said to me, 'You don't understand at all; he's only my little +baby; nothing he does can make any difference to me now.' As I grow older +and understand women's natures better, I can see almost at once which +relation it is a woman has to her husband, or any given man. It is this +feeling, and not sex passion, that keeps woman from being free." Not only +is there a sexual association in the impulse to foster and protect, there +would appear to be a similar element also in the response to that impulse. +Freud has especially insisted on the partly sexual character of the +child's feelings for those who care for it and tend it and satisfy its +needs. It is begun in earliest infancy; "whoever has seen the sated infant +sink back from the breast, to fall asleep with flushed cheeks and happy +smile, must say that the picture is adequate to the expression of the +sexual satisfaction of later life." The lips, moreover, are the earliest +erogenous zone. "There will, perhaps, be some opposition," Freud remarks +(<i>Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie</i>, pp. 36, 64), "to the +identification of the child's feelings of tenderness and appreciation for +those who tend it with sexual love, but I believe that exact psychological +analysis will place the identity beyond doubt. The relationship of the +child with the person who tends it is for it a continual source of sexual +excitement and satisfaction flowing from the erogenous zones, especially +since the fostering person—as a rule the mother—regards the child with +emotions which proceed from her sexual life; strokes it, kisses it, rocks +it, and very plainly treats it as a compensation for a fully valid sexual +object." Freud remarks that girls who retain the childish character of +their love for their parents to adult age are apt to make cold wives and +to be sexually anæsthetic.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_170'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_170'>[170]</a><div class='note'><p> Esbach (in his <i>Thèse de Paris</i>, published in 1876) showed +that even the finger nails are affected in pregnancy and become measurably +thinner.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_171'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_171'>[171]</a><div class='note'><p> C. H. Stratz, <i>Die Schönheit des Weiblichen Körpers</i>, +Chapter VI.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_172'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_172'>[172]</a><div class='note'><p> Iron appears to be liberated in the maternal organism +during pregnancy, and Wychgel has shown (<i>Zeitschrift für Geburtshülfe und +Gynäkologie</i>, bd. xlvii, Heft II) that the pigment of pregnant women +contains iron, and that the amount of iron in the urine is increased.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_173'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_173'>[173]</a><div class='note'><p> Vinay, <i>Maladies de la Grossesse</i>, Chapter VIII; K. Hennig, +"Exploratio Externa," <i>Comptes-rendus du XIIe. Congrès International de +Médècine</i>, vol. vi, Section XIII, pp. 144-166. A bibliography of the +literature concerning the physiology of pregnancy, extending to ten pages, +is appended by Pinard to his article "Grossesse," <i>Dictionnaire +Encyclopédique des Sciences Médicales</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_174'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_174'>[174]</a><div class='note'><p> Stratz, <i>op. cit.</i>, Chapter XII.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_175'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_175'>[175]</a><div class='note'><p> W. S. A. Griffith, "The Diagnosis of Pregnancy," <i>British +Medical Journal</i>, April 11, 1903.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_176'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_176'>[176]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Mackenzie and H. O. Nicholson, "The Heart in Pregnancy," +<i>British Medical Journal</i>, October 8, 1904; Stengel and Stanton, "The +Condition of the Heart in Pregnancy," <i>Medical Record</i>, May 10, 1902 and +<i>University Pennsylvania Medical Bulletin</i>, Sept., 1904 (summarized in +<i>British Medical Journal</i>, August 16, 1902, and Sept. 23, 1905.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_177'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_177'>[177]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Henderson, "Maternal Blood at Term," <i>Journal of +Obstetrics and Gynæcology</i>, February, 1902; C. Douglas, "The Blood in +Pregnant Women," <i>British Medical Journal</i>, March 26, 1904; W. L. Thompson, +"The Blood in Pregnancy," <i>Johns Hopkins Hospital Bulletin</i>, June, 1904.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_178'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_178'>[178]</a><div class='note'><p> H. O. Nicholson, "Some Remarks on the Maternal Circulation +in Pregnancy," <i>British Medical Journal</i>, October 3, 1903.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_179'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_179'>[179]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Morris Slemans, "Metabolism During Pregnancy," <i>Johns +Hopkins Hospital Reports</i>, vol. xii, 1904.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_180'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_180'>[180]</a><div class='note'><p> B. Wolff, <i>Zentralblatt für Gynäkologie</i>, 1904, No. 26.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_181'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_181'>[181]</a><div class='note'><p> Tridandani, <i>Annali di Ostetrica</i>, March, 1900.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_182'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_182'>[182]</a><div class='note'><p> R. Barnes, "The Induction of Labor," <i>British Medical +Journal</i>, December 22, 1894.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_183'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_183'>[183]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, Havelock Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i>, fourth +edition, pp. 344, <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_184'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_184'>[184]</a><div class='note'><p> Arthur Giles, "The Longings of Pregnant Women," +<i>Transactions Obstetrical Society of London</i>, vol. xxxv, 1893.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_185'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_185'>[185]</a><div class='note'><p> Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, Chapter XXX.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_186'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_186'>[186]</a><div class='note'><p> Thus, in Cornwall, "to be in the longing way" is a popular +synonym for pregnancy.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_187'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_187'>[187]</a><div class='note'><p> The apple, wherever it is known, has nearly always been a +sacred or magic fruit (as J. F. Campbell shows, <i>Popular Tales of West +Highlands</i>, vol. I, p. lxxv. <i>et seq.</i>), and the fruit of the forbidden +tree which tempted Eve is always popularly imagined to be an apple. One +may perhaps refer in this connection to the fact that at Rome and +elsewhere the testicles have been called apples. I may add that we find a +curious proof of the recognition of the feminine love of apples in an old +Portuguese ballad, "Donna Guimar," in which a damsel puts on armour and +goes to the wars; her sex is suspected and as a test, she is taken into an +orchard, but Donna Guimar is too wary to fall into the trap, and turning +away from the apples plucks a citron.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_188'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_188'>[188]</a><div class='note'><p> A. Pinard, Art. "Grossesse," <i>Dictionnaire Encyclopédique +des Sciences Médicales</i>, p. 138. On the subject of violent, criminal and +abnormal impulses during pregnancy, see Cumston, "Pregnancy and Crime," +<i>American Journal Obstetrics</i>, December, 1903.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_189'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_189'>[189]</a><div class='note'><p> See especially Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. i, +Chapter XXXI. Ballantyne in his work on the pathology of the fœtus +adds Loango negroes, the Eskimo and the ancient Japanese.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_190'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_190'>[190]</a><div class='note'><p> In 1731 Schurig, in his <i>Syllepsilogia</i>, devoted more than +a hundred pages (cap. IX) to summarizing a vast number of curious cases of +maternal impressions leading to birth-marks of all kinds.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_191'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_191'>[191]</a><div class='note'><p> J. W. Ballantyne has written an excellent history of the +doctrine of maternal impressions, reprinted in his <i>Manual of Antenatal +Pathology: The Embryo</i>, 1904, Chapter IX; he gives a bibliography of 381 +items. In Germany the history of the question has been written by Dr. Iwan +Bloch (under the pseudonym of Gerhard von Welsenburg), <i>Das Versehen der +Frauen</i>, 1899. <i>Cf.</i>, in French, G. Variot, "Origine des Préjugés +Populaires sur les Envies," <i>Bulletin Société d'Anthropologie</i>, Paris, +June 18, 1891. Variot rejects the doctrine absolutely, Bloch accepts it, +Ballantyne speaks cautiously.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_192'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_192'>[192]</a><div class='note'><p> J. G. Kiernan has shown how many of the alleged cases are +negatived by the failure to take this fact into consideration. (<i>Journal +of American Medical Association</i>, December 9, 1899.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_193'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_193'>[193]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Clifton Edgar, <i>The Practice of Obstetrics</i>, second +edition, 1904, p. 296. In an important discussion of the question at the +American Gynæcological Society in 1886, introduced by Fordyce Barker, +various eminent gynæcologists declared in favor of the doctrine, more or +less cautiously. (<i>Transactions of the American Gynæcological Society</i>, +vol. xi, 1886, pp. 152-196.) Gould and Pyle, bringing forward some of the +data on the question (<i>Anomalies and Curiosities of Medicine</i>, pp. 81, <i>et +seq.</i>) state that the reality of the influence of maternal impressions +seems fully established. On the other side, see G. W. Cook, <i>American +Journal of Obstetrics</i>, September, 1889, and H. F. Lewis, <i>ib.</i>, July, +1899.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_194'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_194'>[194]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Transactions Edinburgh Obstetrical Society</i>, vol. xvii, +1892.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_195'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_195'>[195]</a><div class='note'><p> J. W. Ballantyne, <i>Manual of Antenatal Pathology: The +Embryo</i>, p. 45.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_196'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_196'>[196]</a><div class='note'><p> W. C. Dabney, "Maternal Impressions," Keating's <i>Cyclopædia +of Diseases of Children</i>, vol. i, 1889, pp. 191-216.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_197'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_197'>[197]</a><div class='note'><p> Féré, <i>Sensation et Mouvement</i>, Chapter XIV, "Sur la +Psychologie du Fœtus."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_198'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_198'>[198]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Thomson, "Defective Co-ordination in Utero," <i>British +Medical Journal</i>, September 6, 1902.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_199'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_199'>[199]</a><div class='note'><p> H. Campbell, <i>Nervous Organization of Man and Woman</i>, p. +206; <i>cf.</i> Moll, <i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. 264. +Many authorities, from Soranus of Ephesus onward, consider, however, that +sexual relations should cease during pregnancy, and certainly during the +later months. <i>Cf.</i> Brénot, <i>De l'influence de la copulation pendant la +grosseisse</i>, 1903.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_200'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_200'>[200]</a><div class='note'><p> Bianchi terms this fairly common condition the neurasthenia +of pregnancy.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_201'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_201'>[201]</a><div class='note'><p> Vinay, <i>Traité des Maladies de la Grossesse</i>, 1894, pp. 51, +577; Mongeri, "Nervenkrankungen und Schwangerschaft." <i>Allegemeine +Zeitschrift für Psychiatrie</i>, bd. LVIII, Heft 5. Haig remarks (<i>Uric +Acid</i>, sixth edition, p. 151) that during normal pregnancy diseases with +excess of uric acid in the blood (headaches, fits, mental depression, +dyspepsia, asthma) are absent, and considers that the common idea that +women do not easily take colds, fevers, etc., at this time is well +founded.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_202'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_202'>[202]</a><div class='note'><p> Founding his remarks on certain anatomical changes and on a +suggestion of Engel's, Donaldson observes: "It is impossible to escape the +conclusion that in women natural education is complete only with +maternity, which we know to effect some slight changes in the sympathetic +system and possibly the spinal cord, and which may be fairly laid under +suspicion of causing more structural modifications than are at present +recognized." H. H. Donaldson, <i>The Growth of the Brain</i>, p. 352.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_203'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_203'>[203]</a><div class='note'><p> The state of menstruation is in many respects an +approximation to that of pregnancy; see, <i>e.g.</i>, Edgar's <i>Practice of +Obstetrics</i>, plates 6 6 and 7, showing the resemblance of the menstrual +changes in the breasts and the external sexual parts to the changes of +pregnancy; <i>cf.</i> Havelock Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i>, fourth edition, Chapter +XI, "The Functional Periodicity of Woman."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_204'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_204'>[204]</a><div class='note'><p> Thus the gypsies say of an unmarried woman who becomes +pregnant, "She has smelt the moon-flower"—a flower believed to grow on +the so-called moon-mountain and to possess the property of impregnating by +its smell. Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, bd. I, Chapter XXVII.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_205'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_205'>[205]</a><div class='note'><p> This was a sound instinct, for it is now recognized as an +extremely important part of puericulture that a woman should rest at all +events during the latter part of pregnancy; see, <i>e.g.</i>, Pinard, <i>Gazette +des Hôpitaux</i>, November 28, 1895, and <i>Annales de Gynécologie</i>, August, +1898.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_206'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_206'>[206]</a><div class='note'><p> Ploss and Bartels, <i>op. cit.</i>, Chapter XXIX; +Κρυπτάδια, vol. viii, p. 143.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_207'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_207'>[207]</a><div class='note'><p> Griffith Wilkin, <i>British Medical Journal</i>, April 8, 1905.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_208'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_208'>[208]</a><div class='note'><p> Weininger, <i>Geschlecht und Charakter</i>, p. 107. I may remark +that a recent book, Ellis Meredith's <i>Heart of My Heart</i>, is devoted to a +seemingly autobiographical account of a pregnant woman's emotions and +ideas. The relations of maternity to intellectual work have been carefully +and impartially investigated by Adele Gerhard and Helena Simon, who seem +to conclude that the conflict between the inevitable claims of maternity +and the scarcely less inevitable claims of the intellectual life cannot be +avoided.</p></div> + + + + +<a name='5_Page_230'></a> +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_APPENDIX'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_231'></a>APPENDIX.</h2> + +<h3>HISTORIES OF SEXUAL DEVELOPMENT.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p><b>HISTORY I.—</b>The following narrative has been written by a + university man trained in psychology:—</p> + +<p> So far as I have been able to learn, none of my ancestors for at + least three generations have suffered from any nervous or mental + disease; and of those more remote I can learn nothing at all. It + appears probable, then, that any peculiarities of my own sexual + development must be explained by reference to the somewhat + peculiar environment.</p> + +<p> I was the first child and was, naturally, somewhat spoiled—a + process which tended to increase my natural tendency to + sentimentality. On the other hand, I was shy and undemonstrative + with all except my nearest relatives, and with them as well after + my seventh or eighth year. And here it may be well to describe my + "mental type," as this is probably the most important factor in + determining the direction of one's mental development. Of mental + types the "visual" is, of course, by far the most common, but in + my own case visual imagery was never strong or vivid, and has + constantly grown weaker. The dominant part has been played by + tactual, muscular and organic sensations, placing me as one of + the "tactual motor" type, with strong "verbal motor" and + "organic" tendencies. In reading a novel I seldom have a mental + picture of the character or situation, but easily imagine the + sensations (except the visual) and feel something of the emotions + described. When telling of any event I have a strong impulse to + make the movements described and to gesticulate. I remember + events in terms of movements and the words to be used in giving + an account of them; and in thinking of any subject I can feel the + movements of the larynx and, in a less degree, of the lips and + tongue that would be involved in putting my thoughts into words. + I am easily moved to emotion, even to sentimentality, but am + seldom if ever deeply affected and am so averse to any display of + my feelings that I have the reputation among my acquaintances of + being cold, unfeeling and unemotional. I am naturally quiet and + bashful to a degree, which has rendered all forms of social + intercourse painful through much of my life, and this in spite of + a real longing to associate with people on terms of intimacy. As + a child I was sensitive and solitary; later I became morbid as + well. In a character so constituted the feelings and impulses <a name='5_Page_232'></a>of + the moment are likely to rule, and such has been my constant + experience, though a large element of obstinacy in my character + has kept me from appearing impulsive, and slight influences will + bring about reactions which seem out of all proportion to their + cause. For instance, I cannot, even now, read the more erotic of + Boccaccio's stories without a good deal of sexual excitement and + restlessness, which can be relieved only by vigorous exercise or + masturbation.</p> + +<p> The first ten years of my life were passed on a farm, most of the + time without playmates or companions of my own age.</p> + +<p> As far back as I can remember I indulged in elaborate day-dreams + in which I figured as the chief character along with a few others + who were chiefly creatures of my imagination, but at times + borrowed from reality. These others were always boys until I + learned the proper function of the sexual organs, when girls + usurped the whole stage in numbers beyond the limits of a Turkish + harem. Even at school my day-dreams were scarcely interrupted, + for my shyness and timidity made me very unpopular among my + schoolmates, who tormented me after the fashion of small boys or + neglected me, as the spirit moved them. To make matters worse, I + was brought up under the "sheltered life system," kept carefully + away from the "bad boys," which category included nearly all the + youngsters of the community, and deluged with moral homilies and + tirades on things religious until I was thoroughly convinced that + goodness and discomfort, the right and the unpleasant, were + strictly synonymous; and I was kept through much of the time + facing the prospect of an early death, to be followed by the good + old orthodox hell or the equal miseries of its gorgeous + alternative. I may say in all seriousness that this is a + conservative and unexaggerated account of one phase of my early + life—the one, I think, that tended most strongly to make me + introspective and morbid. Later on, when I was trying to abandon + the habit of masturbation, this early training greatly increased + the despair I felt at each successive failure.</p> + +<p> The first traces of sexual excitement that I can now recall + occurred when I was about 4 years old. I had erections quite + frequently and found a mild pleasure in fondling my genitals when + these occurred, especially just after waking in the morning. I + had no notion of an orgasm, and never succeeded in producing one + until I was 13 years of age. In the summer of my sixth year I + experienced pleasurable sensations in daubing my genitals with + oil and then fondling or rubbing them, but I abandoned this + amusement after getting some irritating substance into the + meatus. A year later my mother warned me that playing with my + penis would "make me very sick," but since experience had taught + me that this was not true, my conviction that what was forbidden + must necessarily be pleasant, sent me directly to my favorite + retreat in the barn loft to experiment. Since, however, I failed, + in spite of persistent <a name='5_Page_233'></a>effort, to produce any such pleasant + results as I had expected, I soon gave up my attempts for other + kinds of amusement.</p> + +<p> A few months after this, in midsummer, a very sensual servant + girl began a series of attempts to satisfy herself sexually with + my help. She came nearly every day into the loft where I was + playing and did her best to initiate me into the mysteries of + sexual relationships, but I proved a sorry pupil. She would rub + my penis until it became erect and then, placing me upon her, + would insert the penis in her vulva and make movements of her + thighs and hips calculated to cause friction. At times she varied + the program by lying upon me and embracing me passionately. I can + remember distinctly her quick, gasping breath and convulsive + movements. She generally ended the seance by persuading me to + perform cunnilingus upon her. None of these performances were + intelligible to me and I invariably protested against being + compelled to leave my play to amuse her. Even her fondling of my + genitals annoyed me; and, stranger still, I preferred satisfying + her by cunnilingus to the attempts at coitus.</p> + +<p> It was nearly a year later that I experienced the first + unmistakable manifestations of the sexual impulse—erections + accompanied by lustful feeling and vague desires of whose proper + satisfaction I had no notion whatever. It never occurred to me to + associate my experiences with the servant girl with these new + sensations. The peculiar fact about them was that they were + generally occasioned by the infliction of pain upon animals. I do + not remember how I first discovered that they could be evoked in + this way, but I can clearly recollect many of my efforts to + arouse this pleasurable excitement by abusing the dog or the + cats, or by prodding the calves with a nail set in the end of a + broom handle. I seldom manipulated my genitals at this time, and + when I did it was for the purpose of causing sexual excitement + rather than allaying it.</p> + +<p> During this same year I got my first idea of sexual intercourse + by watching animals copulate; but my powers of observation must + have been limited, for I supposed that the penis of the male + entered the anus of the female. In watching the coitus of animals + I experienced lively sexual excitement and lustful sensations, + located not only in the genitals, but apparently in the anus as + well. I often excited, myself by imagining myself playing the + part of the female animal—a peculiar combination of passive + pederasty and bestiality. A servant girl put me to right on the + error of observation just mentioned, but neglected to apply the + principle to human animals, and I remained for another year in + complete ignorance of the structure of woman's sexual organs and + of the intercourse between man and woman. In the meantime I + cultivated my fancies of intercourse with animals, often still + perversely imagining myself taking the part of the female; and + the notion of such <a name='5_Page_234'></a>relationships gradually became so familiar as + to seem possible and desirable. This is especially significant in + view of later developments.</p> + +<p> Up to my eleventh or twelfth year the erotic element in my + daydreaming varied with the seasons. In the summer it played a + dominant part, while in the winter it was almost entirely absent, + owing, it may be, to the fact that most of my time was spent + indoors or on long, tiresome tramps to and from school, and the + further fact that during the winter I saw but little of the + animals which had acted as a stimulus to sexual excitement. So + little was I troubled in winter and so ignorant was I of normal + intercourse that sleeping with a cousin, a girl of about my own + age (7 or 8 years), resulted in no addition to my knowledge of + things sexual.</p> + +<p> It was early in my ninth year that I first learned something of + the anatomical difference between man and woman and of the + functions of the sexual organs in coitus. These were explained to + me by a young male servant, who, however, told me nothing of + conception or pregnancy. At first I was very little interested, + as it did not immediately occur to me to associate my own erotic + experiences with the matter of these revelations; but under the + faithful tuition of my new instructor I soon began to desire + normal coitus, and my interest in the sexual affairs of animals + weakened accordingly. His teachings went still further, for he + masturbated before me, then persuaded me to masturbate him, and + finally practiced coitus inter femora upon me. He also tried to + masturbate me, but was unable to produce an orgasm, though I + found the experiment mildly pleasurable.</p> + +<p> Early in my eleventh year we left the farm and lived in the city + for several months. In the meantime there had been no + developments in my sexual life beyond what has already been + indicated. In the city I found so much to interest and amuse me + that I almost entirely forgot my erotic day-dreams and desires. + Though my chief playmates were two girls of about my own age I + never thought of attempting sexual intercourse with them, as I + might easily have done, for they were much wiser and more + experienced in these things than myself. Shortly before the end + of our stay in town an older schoolmate explained to me as much + of the process of reproduction as is usually known by a + precocious youngster of 12 years, but I firmly refused to credit + his statements. He adduced the fact of lactation in proof of the + correctness of his views, but I had been too thoroughly steeped + in supernaturalism to be very amenable to naturalistic evidence + of this sort and remained obdurate. But the suggestion stayed + with me and perplexed me not a little; when we returned to the + farm I began to watch the reproductive process in animals.</p> + +<p> The following two years were decidedly unpleasant. I was growing + rapidly and was sluggish, awkward and stupid. At school I was + more <a name='5_Page_235'></a>unpopular than ever and seemed to have a positive genius + for doing the wrong thing. On the rare occasions when my + companions admitted me to their counsels I was a willing dupe and + catspaw, with the result that I was much in trouble with my + teachers. Being morbidly sensitive I suffered keenly under these + circumstances and, as my health was not at all good, I often made + of my frequent headaches excuses to stay at home, where I would + lie abed brooding over my small troubles or, more often, dreaming + erotic day-dreams and making repeated attempts to produce an + orgasm. But though these efforts were accompanied by the most + lustful thoughts and my imagination created situations of + oriental extravagance, I was 13 years old when they first met + with success. I remember the occasion very distinctly, the more + so because I thought of it much and bitterly when shortly + afterwards I tried to abandon a habit which the family "doctor + book" assured me must result in every variety of damnation. At + the moment, however, I was greatly surprised and gratified and + tried at once to repeat the delightful sensation, but was unable + to do so until the following day. From that time to the present I + think I have masturbated an average of ten times per week, and + this is certainly a very conservative estimate; for though up to + my sixteenth year I could seldom produce an orgasm more than once + a day I have often, during the last four or five years, produced + it from four to seven times per day without difficulty and this + for days and even weeks in succession. During these periods of + excessive masturbation very little liquid was ejaculated and the + pleasurable sensations were slight or entirely lacking.</p> + +<p> From the time when I began masturbating regularly practically my + whole interest centered in things pertaining to sex. I read the + chapters of the family "doctor book" which treated of sexual + matters; my day-dreams were almost exclusively erotic; I sought + opportunities to talk about sex-relationships with my + schoolmates, with whom I was now slowly getting on better terms; + I collected pictures of nude women, learned a great number of + obscene stories, read such obscene books as I could obtain and + even searched the dictionary for words having a sexual + connotation. Up to my fifteenth year, when ejaculation of semen + began, there was a strong sadistic coloring to my day-dreams. + Through this period, too, my bashfulness in the presence of the + opposite sex increased until it reached the point of absurdity.</p> + +<p> When fifteen years old I began to practice coitus inter femora on + my brother and continued it intermittently for about two years. + The experience was disappointing, for I had confidently expected + a great increase of pleasure over masturbation in this act; and + in casting about for some stronger stimulus I recurred to the + forgotten idea of intercourse with animals. I promptly tried to + put the idea to a test, but failed several times, and finally + succeeded, only to find that the result <a name='5_Page_236'></a>fell far short of my + expectations. Nevertheless I continued the practice irregularly + for about three years—or rather through that part of the three + years that I spent at home, for while I was at school opportunity + for such indulgence was lacking. Long familiarity with the idea + of intercourse with animals had made it impossible for me to feel + the disgust with the practice which it inspires in most people; + and even the perusal of Exodus xxii: 19 failed to make me abandon + it. Firmly as I believed in the Mosaic law the supremacy of the + sexual impulse was complete.</p> + +<p> As early as my sixteenth year I tried to abandon "self-abuse" in + all its forms and have repeatedly made the same effort since that + time but never with more than very partial success. On two or + three occasions I have stopped for periods of several weeks, but + only to begin again and indulge more recklessly than before. The + deep depression which followed each failure, and often each act + of masturbation, I attributed solely to the loss of semen, + leaving out of account the fact that I expected to feel depressed + and the utter discouragement and self-contempt which accompanied + the sense of failure and weakness when, in the face of my + resolution, I repeatedly gave way and yielded to the temptation + to an act whose consequences I firmly believed must be ruinous. I + am now convinced that by far the greater part of this depression + was due to suggestion and the humiliating sense of defeat. And + this feeling of moral impotence, this seeming helplessness + against an overpowering impulse which, on the other hand, seemed + so trivial when viewed without passion, eventually weakened my + self-control to a degree guessed by no one but myself and sapped + the foundations of my moral life in a way which I have constant + occasion to deplore.</p> + +<p> The foregoing paragraphs give, I think, a fair idea of my + condition when I left home for a boarding school at the beginning + of my seventeenth year. From this time my experiences may be said + to have run on in two distinct cycles—that of the summer months + when I was at home, and that of the remainder of the year when I + was at school. This fact will make some confusion and apparent + inconsistency in the rest of this "history" unavoidable. When I + left home I was shy, retiring, totally ignorant of social usage, + without self-confidence, unambitious, dreamy, and subject to fits + of melancholy. I masturbated at least once a day, though I was in + almost constant rebellion against the habit. In my more idle + moments I elaborated erotic day dreams in which there was a + peculiar mixture of the purely sensual and the purely ideal + element; which never fused in my experience, but held the field + alternately or mingled somewhat in the manner of air and water. + One person usually served as the object of my ideal attachment, + another as the center round which I grouped my sensual dreams and + desires.</p> + +<p> At school I found more congenial companions than I had fallen in + with <a name='5_Page_237'></a>elsewhere, and the necessary contact with people of both + sexes gradually wore off some of the rougher corners and brought + a measure of self-confidence. I had two or three incipient love + affairs which my backwardness kept from growing serious. Out of + this change of environment came a sense of expansion, of escape + from self, which was distinctly pleasant. I still masturbated + regularly, but no longer experienced the former depression except + when at home during vacation. Relatively to the past, life was + now so varied and interesting that I had less and less time for + melancholy; and the discovery that I could lead my classes and + hold my own in athletic sports seemed to indicate that my past + fears had been exaggerated. Nevertheless I was never reconciled + to the habit and often rebelled at the weakness that kept me its + slave.</p> + +<p> When I entered the university the effects of my useless struggle + with the practice of masturbation were pretty well developed. I + could no longer fix my attention steadily upon my work and found + that only by "cribbing" and "bluffing" could I keep my place at + the head of my classes. I was troubled not a little by the + shoddiness of my work, and tried again and again during the + course of the two years spent at this college to shake off the + habit. At the university I was introduced gradually to a wider + social circle and so far outgrew my bashfulness that I began to + seek the society of the opposite sex assiduously. As I gained + self-confidence I became reckless, getting at one time into + serious trouble with the authorities which came near resulting in + my expulsion. I became one of the more popular members of the + clique to which I belonged—much to my surprise and even more to + that of my acquaintances. The physical culture craze attacked me + at this time and my pet ambition was the attainment of strength + and agility. My bump of vanity also grew apace, but an unmeasured + hatred of all kinds of foppishness kept me on the safe side of + moderation in my dress and behavior.</p> + +<p> During my second year of university life I had two love affairs + in the course of which I found that my interest in any particular + member of the fair sex disappeared as soon as it was returned. + The pursuit was fascinating enough, but I cared nothing at all + for the prize when once it was within reach. I may add that the + interest I had in the girls was purely ideal. While at this + school I do not think I masturbated half as often as while at the + preparatory school.</p> + +<p> When I left this college for —— University I took with me a + formidable catalogue of good resolutions, first among which was + the determination to abandon all kinds of "self-abuse." I think I + kept this one about a month. As I had gone from a comparatively + small school to one of the largest of American universities the + change was great and the revelations it brought me frequently + humiliating. I was lonesome, home-sick, and my bump of + self-esteem was woefully bruised; and not <a name='5_Page_238'></a>unnaturally I soon + began to seek a partial solace in day-dreams and masturbation. + After I had become somewhat adapted to my new environment I + indulged less frequently in either, and from that time to the + present I have masturbated very irregularly, sometimes but little + and again to excess.</p> + +<p> Not long after I came to this place I met a young lady with whom + I soon became quite intimate. For over a year our friendship was + strictly platonic and then swung suddenly around to a sexual + basis. We were ardent lovers for a few weeks, after which I tired + of the game as I had before in other cases, and broke off all + relations with her as abruptly as was possible. Since then I have + almost wholly withdrawn from the society and companionship of + women and have almost entirely lost whatever tact and assurance I + once possessed in their company. Things pertaining to sexual life + have interested me rather more than less, but have occupied my + attention much less exclusively than before this episode. Though + I have never intended to marry, my breaking off relations with + this girl affected me much. At any rate it marked an abrupt + change in the character of my sexual experiences. The sexual + impulse seems to have lost its power to rouse me to action. + Hitherto I had practiced masturbation always under protest, as it + were—as the only available form of sexual satisfaction; while + now I resigned myself to it as all that there was to hope for in + that field. Of course I knew that a little effort or a little + money would procure natural satisfaction of my sexual needs, but + I also knew that I would never, under any ordinary circumstances, + put forth the necessary effort, and fear of venereal disease has + been more than enough to keep me away from houses of + prostitution.</p> + +<p> Some months ago I refrained from masturbation for a period of + about six weeks and watched carefully for any change in my health + or spirits, but noticed none at all. The only impulse to + masturbate was occasioned by fits of restlessness accompanied by + erections and a mildly pleasurable feeling of fullness in the + penis and scrotum. I think that over 75 per cent, of my acts of + masturbation are provoked by these fits of restlessness and are + unaccompanied by fancy images, erotic thoughts, lustful desires, + or marked pleasure. At other times the act is occasioned by + erotic thoughts and images, and is accompanied by a considerable + degree of lustful pleasure which, however, is never so intense as + in my earlier experiences and has steadily decreased from the + first. Usually the orgasm is accompanied by a strong contraction + of all the voluntary muscles, particularly the extensors, + followed by a slight giddiness and slight feeling of exhaustion. + If repeated several times in the course of a single day the acts + are followed by dullness and lassitude; otherwise the feeling of + exhaustion passes away quickly and a sense of relief and quiet + takes its place. So natural or rather habitual has this resort + <a name='5_Page_239'></a>to masturbation as a means of relief from nervousness and + restlessness become that the act is almost instinctive in its + unconsciousness.</p> + +<p> I am extremely sensitive to all kinds of sexual influences, and + have an insatiable curiosity regarding everything that pertains + to the sexual life of men or women. I am not, however, excited + sexually by conversation about sexual facts and relationships, no + matter what its nature, though in reading erotic literature my + excitement is often intense.</p> + +<p> The tendency to day dream has never left me, but there are no + longer any elaborate scenes or long-continued "stories," these + having been replaced by vaguely imagined incidents which are + usually broken off before they reach a satisfactory climax. They + are always interrupted by the intrusion of other matters, usually + of more practical interest; and the long-continued habit of + satisfying myself by masturbation has made erotic dreams rather + tantalizing than pleasurable. I dream very seldom at night—at + least I can scarcely ever remember any dreams upon waking—and + practically never of sexual relations. I have not had a nocturnal + emission for over three years, and probably not more than + twenty-five in my life.</p> + +<p> In my "love passages" with girls there has been no serious + thought of coitus on my part, and I have never had intercourse + with a woman—unless my early experiences with the servant girl + be called such. Like all masturbators I always idealized "love" + to the utter exclusion of all sensual cravings; and the notion + that the physical act of coitus was something degrading and + destructive of real love rather than its consummation was, of all + prejudices I have ever formed, the most difficult to escape—a + circumstance due, I suppose, to the fact that all I had ever been + taught on the subject tended to the complete divorce of what was + called "love" from what was stigmatized as a "base sensual + desire." Judging from my own experience and observation I should + say that "ideal love" is a mere surface feeling, bound to + disappear as soon as it has gained its object by arousing a + reciprocal interest on the part of the one to whom it is + directed. So little did I "materialize" the objects of my "love" + that I have never cared for kissing or the warm embraces in which + lovers usually indulge. I have never kissed but one girl, and her + with far too little enthusiasm to satisfy her. My last sweetheart + was a very passionate girl, the warmth of whose embraces was + somewhat torrid and, to me, both puzzling and annoying. The + intensity of feeling which demanded such strenuous expression was + beyond my knowledge of human nature. A somewhat peculiar + circumstance in connection with these experiences is the fact + that I often found myself trying to analyze my emotions with a + purely psychological interest while playing the part of the + intoxicated lover in his mistress's arms.</p> + +<p> There is but little left to say on the subject of my sexual + development. During the last two or three years my knowledge of + the facts of <a name='5_Page_240'></a>the sexual life has been very greatly increased, + and I have become acquainted with phases of human nature which + were wholly unknown to me before. The part played by things + sexual in my life is still, I suppose, abnormally large; it is + undoubtedly the largest single interest, though my outer life is + determined almost wholly by other considerations.</p> + +<p> Of course I know nothing of the effect which long-continued + masturbation may have had on my ability to perform normal coitus. + I do not think I am subject to any kind of sexual perversion, for + all my indulgence has been <i>faute de mieux</i> and, at least since I + began masturbation, all my desires and erotic day-dreams have had + to do only with normal coitus. The mystery which surrounds the + sexual act seems at times to be regaining its former influence + and power of fascination. I have no doubt, however, but that I + should be greatly disillusioned should I ever perform coitus; and + I greatly regret that I have not been able to test this + conviction and so round out and complete this "history."</p> + +<p> It may be worth while to say a word about my religious + experiences, as, in many cases, they are closely bound up with + the sexual impulse. I was never "converted," but on a dozen or + more occasions approached the crisis more or less closely. The + dominant emotion in these experiences was always fear, sometimes + with anger and despair intermixed in varying proportions. A + complete analysis of these experiences is, of course, impossible, + but the various pleasurable feelings of which converts spoke in + the revivals which I attended were a closed book to me. Following + my revival-meeting experiences came a few days spent in a sort of + moral exaltation during which I eschewed all my habits of which + conventional morality disapproved, save masturbation, and felt no + small satisfaction with my moral conditions. I became a + first-rate Pharisee. Toward the women who had figured in my day + dreams I suddenly conceived the chastest affection, resolutely + smothering every sensual thought and fancy when thinking of them, + and putting in place of these elements ideal love, + self-sacrifice, knightly devotion—Sunday-school Garden-of-Eden + pictures with a mediæval, romantic coloring. These day-dreams + were always sexual, involving situations of extreme complexity + and monumental silliness. Masturbation was always continued and + usually with increased frequency. The end of these periods was + always abrupt and much like awaking from a dream in which the + dreamer has been behaving in a manner to arouse his own disgust. + They were followed by feelings of sheepishness and self-contempt + mingled with anger and a dislike of all things having to do with + religion. My inability to pass the conversion crisis and a + growing contempt for empty enthusiasm finally led me to a saner + attitude toward religion, from which I passed easily into + religious scepticism; and later the study of philosophy and + science, and particularly of psychology, banished the last + lingering remnant <a name='5_Page_241'></a>of faith in a supernatural agency and led me + to the passion for facts and indifference to values which have + caused me to be often called "dead to all morality."</p> +<br /> + +<p> <b>HISTORY II.—</b>C. A., aged 25, unmarried; tutor, preparing to take + Holy Orders:—</p> + +<p> My paternal ancestry (which is largely Huguenot) is noteworthy + for its patriotism and its large families. My father, who died + when I was a year old, is remembered for the singular uprightness + and purity of his life from his earliest childhood. The + photograph which I have shows him as possessed of a rare classic + beauty of features. He was an ideal husband and father. At the + time of his death he was a Master of Arts and a school principal. + My mother is an extraordinarily neurotic woman, yet famed among + her friends for her great domesticity, attachment to her + husbands, and an almost abnormal love of babies. She has nobly + borne the ill-treatment of her second husband, who for several + years has been in a state of melancholia. My mother has been + "highly-wrought" all her life, and has suffered intensely from + fears of all kinds. As a young girl she was somnambulistic, and + once fell down a stairhead during sleep. In spite of her bodily + sufferings with indigestion, eye-strain, and depression she + retains her youthfulness. She has slight powers of reasoning. She + has had times of unconsciousness and rigidity, I have never heard + any mention of epilepsy. She has a horror of showing prudishness + in regard to the healthful manifestations of sex life, and is + always praising examples of what she terms "a natural woman."</p> + +<p> I have heard that during my first year my mother detected my + nurse in the act of putting a morphine powder on my tongue for + the purpose of keeping me quiet. I was subject to convulsions at + this period, and narrowly escaped a permanent hernia. My family + tell me that from the beginning I was a well-developed and boyish + boy, full of mischief, impulsive, good to look upon, unusually + affectionate, beloved by all.</p> + +<p> In my third year I took pleasure in crawling under the bed with + my boy-cousin who was nine months my senior, and after we had + taken down our drawers, in kissing each other's nates. I do not + remember which of us first thought of this pastime.</p> + +<p> At the age of 4 I gave myself a treat by gazing upward through a + cellar window at the nates of a woman who was defecating from + several feet above into a cesspool that lay beneath. It was + during this summer also that I frightened myself by pulling back + my prepuce far enough to disclose the purple glans, which I had + never seen before. But this act gave me no desire to masturbate.</p> + +<p> When 5 years old, and living in a great city, I drew indecent + pictures in company with a little girl and her younger brother. + These pictures <a name='5_Page_242'></a>represented men in the act of urinating. The + penes were drawn large, and the streams of urine plainly + indicated. One afternoon I induced the boy to go to the + bath-room, lie on his back, and allow me to perform <i>fellatio</i> on + him. I did not ask him to return the favor. I remember the + curious tar-like smell of his clothing and the region about his + genitals. It is possible that I gained my knowledge of <i>fellatio</i> + from an unknown boy of 10, who had induced me, during the + preceding summer to enter a sandy lot with him, watch him + urinate, and then, kneeling before him, commit <i>fellatio</i>. A year + later, as I was walking home in the rain to our summer cottage, + with an open umbrella over my shoulder, a boy of 15, who was + leaning against our fence, exhibited a large, erect penis, and + when I had passed him urinated upon me and my umbrella. I never + saw the boy again. I felt peculiarly insulted by his act. Back of + the house there lived a 12-year-old boy who invited me to watch + him defecate in the outdoor privy, and during the act told me a + number of indecent stories and words which I cannot remember.</p> + +<p> About this time I fell in love with a little Jewish boy next + door. Often I cried myself to sleep over the thought that perhaps + he was lying on a sofa alone and crying with a stomach-ache. I + longed to embrace him; and yet I saw little of him, and made + little of him when I was with him.</p> + +<p> Living in a Western city a few months later, some girls of 12 and + 14 led me to their barn, where they dressed themselves in boys' + clothing and made believe that they were cowboys. One of them + told me to "shut my eyes, open my mouth, and get a surprise." + When I opened my eyes once more a piece of hen-dung lay in my + mouth. I have a vague remembrance of one of the girls asking me + to enter a water-closet with her. She uttered some indelicate + phrase, but I performed no act with her. In the house where I + lived I once entered the bedroom of a half-grown girl while she + was dressing. She knelt to kiss me innocently enough, and I, by a + sudden impulse, ran my hand between her bare neck and her corset + as far as I could reach. Apparently she took no notice of my + movement. Although I did not masturbate, yet during this winter I + experienced a tickling sensation about my genitals when I placed + my hand beneath them as I lay on my stomach in bed. One evening I + pulled up my night-dress and, holding my penis in my hand, I + danced to and fro on the carpet. I imagined that I was one of a + line of naked men and women who were advancing toward another + similar line that faced them. I imagined myself as pleasurably + coming in contact with my female partner who possessed male + genitals.</p> + +<p> The following summer I lived in the woods. My next-door playmate + was a little girl of my own age—6 years. She sat down before me + in the barn and exposed her genitals. This was the first time I + had seen female organs, or had thought for a moment that they + differed from <a name='5_Page_243'></a>my own. In great perplexity I asked the little + girl: "Has it been cut off?" She and I defecated in peach baskets + that we found in the upper part of the barn.</p> + +<p> When I was 7 years old and back in the Eastern city I lived in + the house of a physician. Alone with his 3-year-old daughter one + day, I showed her my erect organ, and felt a delicious + gratification when she stroked it with the words: "Nice! Nice!" I + confessed my fault to my guardian that night after I had said my + prayers. I had complained to my mother a year before of the + inconvenience I found in my penis being "so long sometimes." She + said that she would "see about having the end taken off." But I + was never circumcised. Her words gave me the doubly unpleasant + impression that my <i>glans</i> was to be cut off.</p> + +<p> There came occasionally to the kitchen of Dr. W.'s house a + foul-mouthed Irish laundress who used coarse language to me + concerning urination. I loathed the woman, and yet one night I + dreamed that I was embracing her naked form and rolling over and + over with her on the bed; and in spite of my sight of female + genitals a few months before, I thought of her as having organs + of my own kind and size. At my first school I watched a + red-haired boy of 12 expose the penis of a 7-year-old boy as he + lay on his back in the bath-room. I do not remember that the + sight gave me sexual pleasure.</p> + +<p> I spent the summer before I was 8 in a double house. The adopted + daughter of our neighbor (a neurotic, retired physician) was a + girl of 13 who had been taken from a poor laboring family. She + got me to show her my parts, touched them, and asked whether I + urinated from my scrotum. She also induced me to play with her + genitals as we sat on a sofa in the twilight, and to spank her + naked nates with the back of a hair-brush as she lay on a bed; + but from none of these performances did I derive physical + satisfaction. The girl E. and I took delight in "talking dirty + secrets," as she expressed it. Her young cousin H. (nephew of her + adopted mother) never heard me use the word "thing" without + suggestively smiling. E. recalled the pleasant hours that she had + spent with her cousin when they were in their night-gowns. She + did not particularize these sexual relations. Under the + board-walk the boy H. and I once defecated in bottles. Some + little girls who lived opposite us pulled up their dresses one + night and "dared" each other to dance out beyond the end of the + house, in full view of the road. We boys merely looked on.</p> + +<p> I now fell passionately in love with a remarkably handsome little + boy of my own age. I longed to kiss and hug him, but I did not + dare to do so, for he was haughty and intolerant of my + attentions. I even allowed him to stand with one foot on me and + remark in a loud tone: "I am Conqueror!" I endured no end of + petty insults and much ill-treatment from this boy. I reached the + height of my passion on the <a name='5_Page_244'></a>night that he appeared at our + cottage in a tight-fitting suit of pepper-and-salt. I gloried in + his perfect legs and besought my guardian that she would buy me a + similar suit of clothes.</p> + +<p> For the summer after I was 8 years old I lived in a cottage in a + country town. The servant maid M. was a young girl of 16 who + listened eagerly to my accounts of the "secrets" and actions in + which the girl E. and I had taken delight a year before. I think + that M. arranged a meeting between a little black-haired girl and + me in order that we might take a walk and play sexually with each + other. Just as we were starting on our walk one of my relatives + said that I must not leave the yard.</p> + +<p> The little girl and I had see-sawed together and I had been + interested in her legs as she rose in the air. (When I was 13 + years old and see-sawing at a picnic with a stout girl, the + motion of the board and the sight of her straddled form filled me + with longing to embrace her sexually.) One afternoon M. took me + to the house of an acquaintance of hers. M's brother was in the + room and made a number of unremembered remarks which struck me as + being rather "free," and M. told me later that she and the girl + once dressed as ballet dancers and danced before M.'s brother. I + felt that he was lascivious. I was always remarkably intuitive.</p> + +<p> I fell in love with a handsome, stout, black-haired boy who lived + on a farm; but he was not a "farmer's son" in the common sense of + the word. I visited him for two or three days, and we slept with + each other, to my boundless joy. For his freckled girl cousin I + did not care the turn of my wrist, although she was a nice enough + little thing. One night when we three lay on a bed in the dark, + and neither of us boys had eyes or words for her, she silently + left us. He and I never committed the slightest sexual fault. I + left him with tears at the summer-end, and I often kissed his + photograph during the following winter.</p> + +<p> In the flat-house where I began to live when I was 8 years old, I + once practiced mutual tickling of a very slight character with a + boy of my own age. We sat on chairs placed opposite to each other + and we inserted our fingers through the openings in our trousers. + Just as we were beginning to enjoy the titillation we were + interrupted by the approach of one of my family who, however, was + not quick enough to discover us. Down cellar I often saw the + genitals of the janitor's little girls—they were fond of lifting + their skirts and they did not wear drawers—but I had no desire + to attempt conjunction. I once caught an older friend of mine (he + was 13) in the act of leaving one of the girls. The pair had been + in a coal-compartment. The boy was buttoning his trousers and I + guessed what he had been doing. When I began to sleep alone in my + tenth year I had no desire to masturbate, and was loath to do so + by reason of ample warnings given me by my guardian and by the + family physician. One afternoon a stunted friend of mine sat down + in <a name='5_Page_245'></a>the back yard and astonished me by tying a piece of string to + his penis. At a large private school which I now attended I made + the acquaintance of the principal's son, and wondered why he had + such a fancy for dressing his 5-year-old sister in boy's clothes. + He closed the door on me while he was thus engaged. At my house + we went to the bath-room together, and he showed me his + circumcised and much-ridged penis. Neither of us made any mention + of masturbating.</p> + +<p> At this period I fell slightly in love with a 5-year-old boy with + intensely black eyes. I would kiss him whenever we were alone, + but I had no wish to seduce him. I was always interested in + watching the urination of younger children. When I was 5 years + old I went on my knees to a strange little boy in order to + whisper in his ear an inquiry as to whether he wanted to urinate. + I experienced a pleasurable thrill when I was 10 years old in + leading a small girl cousin to the outdoor privy, in helping her + on and off the open seat, in buttoning and unbuttoning her + drawers, and in gazing at her vulva.</p> + +<p> The summer before I was 10 I lived a wild life in the mountains. + My companions were a negro girl, the two daughters of a + clergyman, the two sons of a questionable woman hotel-keeper, and + the daughter of the Irish scavenger. All of these children were + extraordinarily sensual. Their leading pastime, from morning + until night, was varying forms of indecency, with the supreme + caress—which they termed "raising dickie"—as the most frequent + enjoyment. The 5-year-old daughter of the scavenger explained to + us how she had seen her father approaching her stout mother with + an erect penis, the pair standing up before the lamplight during + the act. This curly-headed, rosy-cheeked child handled her + genitals so much that they were inflamed. I once saw her sitting + in the road and rubbing dust against her vulva. I saw little of + the elder daughter of the minister (she was 12 years old). She + persuaded me to expose myself before her in the cellar of a + partially-built house. In return for my favor she allowed me to + look at her genitals. She did not ask for <i>conjunctio</i>. The two + younger daughters were my intimates. With the middle one I was + forever performing a weak conjunction that consisted in the + laying of my member against her vulva. Notwithstanding all the + entreaties of my little friend, I could not be persuaded to + protrude my penis against her vagina; and not on one occasion can + I remember obtaining an erection or extreme pleasure. Up in the + garret she straddled slanting beams with her genitals exposed, + and I followed her example. The negro girl and my little friend + both urinated on a tent floor at my request. I did not fancy the + odor of a girl's genitals, nor the appearance of the vulva when + the labia were held apart.</p> + +<p> The following summer, when I was almost 11, I took a long walk + one day with my old friend, the girl E. We entered a patch of + woods and ate our lunch, but no sense of sexual drawing toward + the girl came <a name='5_Page_246'></a>over me and she did not offer to entice me. I + slept with her boy-cousin one night, and her neuropathic aunt, a + retired lady physician, bothered us by repeatedly creeping into + our room. I felt intuitively that she was watching to see whether + we would commit mutual masturbation—which we had no thought of + doing. Three years before I had opened the door of her bedroom + suddenly and saw E.'s naked form. The physician had been + examining her, E. told me later. My guardian also annoyed me by + repeated warnings not to play with myself.</p> + +<p> Just before I turned 11 I was sent to a small and so-called + "home" boarding-school. Eight of us lived in the smaller + dormitory. The matron roomed downstairs. There was no resident + master—a serious error. We small boys were told to strip one + evening. We were then tied neck-to-neck and made to dance a + "slave-dance," which was marked by no sexuality. A boy of 15, R., + one afternoon gave me the astonishing information that my father + had taken a part in my procreation. Up to this moment I had known + only of the maternal offices, information of which had been + beautifully supplied to me by my guardian when I was 7 years old. + At that time I talked freely about the coming of a baby brother + in a distant city; I watched the construction of baby clothes; I + named the newcomer, and I was momentarily disappointed when he + proved to be a girl. This same R., a strong boy with a large + penis, got into the custom of lying in bed with me just before + lights were put out. He would read to himself and occasionally + pause to pump his penis and make with his lips the sound of a + laboring locomotive. I felt impelled to handle his organ, for I + was fascinated by its size, and stiffness, and warmth. Rarely he + would titillate my then small and unerect penis. R. never + ejaculated when he was with me; hence not until my third year was + I acquainted with the appearance of a flow of semen. Sometimes R. + would stop during his dressing to manipulate his penis, but was + such a picture of rosy health that I doubt whether he brought + himself often to ejaculation. R. told me that he had been to a + brothel where his genitals were examined to determine whether + they were large enough and not diseased. He also related how he + "played cow" with a girl of his own age, she consenting to + perform <i>fellatio</i> upon him. A dark-skinned, unwashed, pimpled + but fairly vigorous boy of 16, with an irritable domineering + manner, told me the delights of coitus with a girl in a + bath-house, and I overheard his conversation with another "old" + boy concerning the purchase of a girl in a big city for the sum + of five dollars. No details were given.</p> + +<p> I will now pass to my third year, when I was 13 years old. A + large, well-set-up boy of 16, A., became my idol. His toleration + of my presence in his room filled me with endless love. When I + lied about a matter in which he was concerned, his denunciation + of me brought me to a state of shuddering and weeping + unspeakable. When our relations <a name='5_Page_247'></a>were established again A. + allowed me to creep into his bed after the lights were out, and + there I passionately embraced him, but without performing any + definite act. When I turned over on my side with my back to him + he drew my prepuce back and forth until I experienced orgasm, but + not ejaculation. I would return his favor by pumping his erect + penis, but with no ejaculation on his part. He did not propose + <i>fellatio</i>, and I did not think of it. One night when he was in + my bed I began to masturbate very slightly, whereupon he laughed, + saying: "So that is the way you amuse yourself!" As a matter of + fact the habit was not fastened upon me. He always laughed when + the rubbing of his finger on my exposed glans caused me to + shrink. Another boy, H., now began to show me his erect penis and + we practiced mutual manipulations. A. laughingly told me how me + had caught H. in the act of masturbating as he stood in the + bath-tub. A. told me a number of sexual stories—how he enjoyed + coitus in the bushes with a girl on the way home from + entertainments; how half a dozen boys and girls stripped in the + basement of a church and performed coitus on the velvet chairs + which stood behind the pulpit; and how he and a younger boy, who + camped out together, played with each other's genitals. F., a boy + of 11, was highly nervous, subject to timidity and tears on the + slightest provocation, often morose, and under treatment for + kidney trouble. His penis was erect whenever I saw him undress. + He told me that a partially idiotic man taught F. and his + companion how to masturbate. The man invited the boys to his tent + and there pumped his organ until "some white stuff came out of + it." F. also told me that an Indian princess in his part of the + country would permit coitus for fifty cents. A. sometimes slept + with F., and I could imagine their embraces. S., a secretive, + handsome boy of 13, wetted his bed with urine every night. The + only sign that he gave of an interest in sexuality was his + laughing remark concerning the coupling of rose-bugs. Of his + chum, my beloved C., I will speak later. My small room-mate + handled himself only slightly. I never had a desire to lie with + him, since I disliked him, nor with my first room-mate, a + "chunky," fiery boy of 10, whose penis interested me merely + because it was circumcised and almost always erect. His + masturbation was also so slight as not to attract any particular + attention. A lusty German boy, B., showed no signs of sexuality + until his third year, when he laughed about his newly-appearing + pubic hair, and told several of us openly of how he enjoyed to + play "a drum-beat" on his penis before going to sleep. "I don't + do it too much, though," he explained. He showed a mild curiosity + when I gave him the resumé of a book on cohabitation which + contained illustrations of the erect penis and the female organs. + I had found this book in the woods and I read it eagerly during + my third year.</p> + +<p> I came to the point of agreeing with A., who said: "Everyone is + <a name='5_Page_248'></a>smutty." Indeed I lived in a lustful world, and yet my mind was + bent also on books, and writing, and the outdoor world. I was + overgrown and splendidly developed, with a medium-sized penis and + a scant growth of pubic hair. My face wore a somewhat infantile + expression. My mouth was a perfect "Cupid's bow," my hair thin + and light. I was troubled about my snub-nose, which gave the boys + a great deal of amusement. As a matter of fact I exaggerated its + upward tendency out of my morbid self-consciousness and + cowardice. My imagination was extraordinarily intense, as it had + always been. I was sensitive to smells and sounds and colors and + personalities, and to the subtle influence of the night. I was + timid and easily moved to tears, but not from any physical + weakness until after. At the lower house there was the boy Z., + famed for his large penis; and the older G., a boy of 15, who was + the leader in sexuality at his dormitory. Z. showed me his penis + and exposed his glans often enough, but we did not manipulate + each other. G. told us to notice how large a space his penis + occupied in his trousers, and laughed over Z.'s custom of + masturbating by means of a narrow vase. G.'s special lover was a + nervous boy of ten. It is remarkable that none of us mentioned + <i>fellatio</i> or <i>pædicatio</i>. These acts may have occurred at + school, but not to my knowledge. We did not have much to say + sexually about the girls. We heard rumors of a 16-year-old, V., + who had been sent away from school for coitus; and my first + room-mate was said to have obtained <i>conjunctio</i> with a girl + under cover of the chapel shed. Once A. and I pointed a telescope + at the open windows of the girls' dormitory, but we saw nothing + to interest us. A day-scholar, J., a pale, nervous, bright boy of + 13, took me into the study of his uncle-physician and together we + gloated over pictures of the sexual organs. A. was with us on one + occasion. J. told me how he liked to roll over and over in bed + with his hand placed under his scrotum. This act, he said, made + him imagine that he was obtaining coitus. He advised me to slide + my penis back and forth in the vagina whenever I should actually + obtain coitus. In my room at school J. once drew an imaginary map + of a bagnio, in which the water-closet was carefully displayed + <i>en suite</i> with the bedrooms. J. and I never masturbated + together. Indeed, I cannot remember seeing his organ. A hulking + boy of 16, who lived opposite the school-grounds, became intimate + with J., and we three went on a walk up the railroad track. The + big boy, W., tried to inflame my passions by telling me how he + and J. had had coitus with a handsome black-haired widow in town, + but I remained cold.</p> + +<p> During this year I fell in love with C., a popular, talkative, + witty boy of my own age, or perhaps a year younger. He fancied me + and we slept together one night under the most innocent + circumstances. I never dreamed of having sexual relations with + him, and yet I fairly burned with love for him. My stay at his + beautiful home over Sunday while his <a name='5_Page_249'></a>parents were away was one + long delight. We slept in each other's arms, but there was no + sexuality. En route to C.'s home he pointed with a glove to a + little working-girl, saying he would like to have intercourse + with her, but this was the only remark of the kind that ever + passed his lips in my presence. When undressed save for his + undershirt, he laughingly held his unerect organ in his hand and + made the motions of obtaining conjunction with an imaginary + partner. Once we spoke of masturbation (I could recite the + information of my good physician with a marvelous show of + virtue), and C. remarked: "Yes, doing that makes boys crazy." C. + finally grew tired of my deceptive, babyish nature and + ultra-interest in books and puzzles, but I cherished an + undiminished affection for him, and when he was detained at home + for a fortnight with a broken arm, I wrote him a passionate + letter, which I sobbed over and actually wetted with my tears. + But the fervor of my passion died at the close of the year. I + consider this unsullied friendship to be the only redeeming + feature of my sensual days at school.</p> + +<p> Versed as I was in the warnings against masturbation, I found + pleasure one afternoon when I was alone in slipping my penis + through the open handle of a pair of scissors and in violently + flapping my partially erect organ until a strange, sweet thrill + crept over me from top to toe and a drop of clear liquid oozed + from my member. But I gave up the manipulation with scissors, + finding a greater satisfaction in masturbating while I was + defecating or just after it. I either pumped my organ by slipping + the prepuce back and forth, or I grasped the organ at its root + and violently jerked it back and forth. I soon began to + masturbate not only every time that I defecated, but also at + night just before I went to sleep, and sometimes early in the + morning. On the whole I preferred the jerking just described. I + always brought about ejaculation after perhaps five minutes of + violent exertion.</p> + +<p> My penis became chafed at the root, but I did not especially + care. I remember the afternoon that I masturbated for the first + time while I was defecating in the school water-closet. I cannot + recall that at first I thought of coitus while I masturbated. On + one occasion I masturbated over the <i>vase de nuit</i> after a + delightful afternoon of tobogganing exploration up and down the + mountain.</p> + +<p> During this first year of abuse, I felt no ill effects + whatsoever, although I realized, in an unthinking way, that I was + doing wrong. But sexuality had assumed the proportion of a + regular feature of our school life. It was difficult for me to + place a "universal" view in its true perspective. I used to smile + at the glazed, dull morning eye of poor H., who was a stunted boy + of 15, and thus could not endure his losses so well as I could + endure them. The qualms of conscience which I suffered were lost + in my delight in my dawning sexual life. Sometimes I lay on my + stomach in bed, and by placing my hand under my scrotum, + according to <a name='5_Page_250'></a>the directions of J., brought up a pretty girl to + mind. Just before Sunday school G., our chief reprobate, and the + rest of us would hunt out what we considered to be nasty texts of + Scripture. The chapter concerning the whoredoms of Aholah and + Aholibah gave me an especial pleasure. T. mentioned the giggling + that occurred at prayers in the lower dormitory when the details + of Esau's birth were read out. A few days before G. was + expelled—for exactly what cause I do not know—he told me of how + greatly he enjoyed coitus on his grandmother's sofa with a girl + of fifteen. When I went home on the boat for holidays I noted the + large, black-haired penis of the strong boy of our school. He + occupied a state-room with me, but made no sexual overtures.</p> + +<p> Since my twelfth year I had been wrapped up all summer long in a + boy who was six months my senior. We slept together constantly, + but not once did we think of obtaining mutual gratification. On + the contrary, we held up high ideals to each other and frowned on + masturbation. I took delight in saying that I never had handled + myself, and never would do so. Even at the height of my + "auto-erotic" period, I skillfully concealed my habits from all + my boy friends. A neurotic solo choir boy friend once spoke of + obtaining ejaculation, whereupon I expressed utter ignorance of + such an act, little hypocrite that I was. This boy told how the + house servants joked with him about coitus and made laughing + lunges at his organs.</p> + +<p> But much as I loved my chum, my most passionate regard went out + in my thirteenth year to N., a chubby, blue-eyed, choir-boy of + 12. He was a pretty boy to any eye. He was not gifted, except in + water-sports, and anything but popular either with girls or with + boys; yet I grew warm at the mention of his name. He did not care + a fig for me. From first to last I had no consciousness of the + sexual nature of my passion, and the thought of doing more than + embrace and kiss him in an innocent manner never crossed my mind. + For two summers I had nights of tossing on my bed (although I + almost never was sleepless for any cause) when I would see his + dear face and form, in and out of the swimming pool, or engaged + perhaps in singing or in showing his beautiful teeth. I seldom + was smitten with little girls, and I found myself embarrassed in + their company after my ninth year; yet I thought well enough of + their looks and ways to enjoy their company at dances. The girls + liked me in a platonic way, for I was accounted a good, big, + kind, blundering boy with a helping hand for the smallest fry.</p> + +<p> During the summer after I was 13, I imagined myself in the early + morning, when I was half awake, as persuading my wife to have + coitus with me. In the course of my spoken words I kept my hand + under my scrotum.</p> + +<p> A plump girl-cousin of my own age was visiting at my uncle's + during the summer after I was 13. With her I greatly desired to + <a name='5_Page_251'></a>satisfy myself, but I could not be sure that my boy cousin (5 + years old) might not find us out, even though she should consent. + Once when we three were in the hay-loft a wave of lust rolled + over me, but I made no proposal. Night and gaslight greatly + increased my <i>libido</i>. On one occasion my aunt had gone to the + village for ice-cream, and L. and I were left alone in the + dining-room. I took her on my lap and had a powerful erection. I + almost asked her to play sexually with me in the barn, but + instead I spoke of an imaginary girl, the first letters of whose + successive names spelled an indecent word for coitus—a word + known to almost every Anglo-Saxon child, I fear. L. laughed, but + gave no sign of assent. For a neighboring girl of 15 I felt such + a drawing that early in the morning I would roll on the floor + with my erect organ in my hand in riotous imagining of coitus + with her. I walked with her in the woods and sat at her feet, but + although I felt instinctively that she would satisfy me without + much persuasion, yet I <i>could not</i> ask her. One night I started + to church in order to walk home with her, and lead her (if + possible) to a field where we might gratify ourselves (I picked + out the exact grassy spot where we might lie); but when I was + almost at the church door my "moral sense" (if that is what it + was) rose and dragged me home again.</p> + +<p> During the swimming hour I watched the genitals of the boys, + comparing them carefully in the most minute details. Circumcised + organs affected me as being disagreeable, and men's hairy, coarse + genitals I abhorred.</p> + +<p> When 13 I became acquainted with the new mail-boy at the inn. He + was a city "street-boy," and got me into smoking cigarettes + occasionally. I did not definitely take up smoking until I was + 16. He told me that a mason once offered him ten cents if he + would masturbate the man in a cellar. The boy said that he + refused. I slept a few times with an ill-favored boy of fine + parentage. He was of my own age, and I had played with him in a + natural way for several years, but my increasing sexual desires + led me to mutually masturbate with him, and even unsuccessfully + to attempt with him mutual pædicatio. On the morning after our + nights of sensuality I felt "gone" and miserable, but not + repentant. By afternoon I was myself again. My relations with G. + were purely animal, for I disliked his jealous disposition, his + horse-laugh, his features, his form, his withdrawn scrotum and + his undersized penis. At home in the evening I often found myself + inflamed with a mental picture of active <i>fellatio</i> with him, but + I never performed this act, so far as I remember.</p> + +<p> One of my great sexual desires was to walk along a fence on which + a girl was seated. In order that I might feast my eyes on her + pudenda she must not wear drawers.</p> + +<p> When I turned 14 I had been, from my unusual size, in long + trousers <a name='5_Page_252'></a>for several months. I entered a private day-school and + progressed brilliantly in my studies. I kept up masturbation + almost daily, sometimes twice a day, both in the water closet and + in bed. I can remember ejaculating before urination in the school + <i>cabinet</i>. At night I often found myself longing for the return + of my sister, seven years my junior, in order that I might + embrace her in bed and fondle her genitals. I had done these + things during my Christmas vacation of the year before. I mildly + reproached myself for such incestuous desires, but they recurred + continually. I dreamed little. And I cannot remember the + character of my dreams. My waking <i>libido</i> spent itself mostly in + longings to embrace (without lustful acts) the forms of little + boys of exquisite blonde beauty and thick hair. Narcissism may + have been present, for in my twelfth year I had been told that at + the age of 5 and 6 I was an extraordinarily beautiful little + creature with long, lint-white hair. The preferable age was from + 6 to 9. My eye was alert on the streets for boys answering to + this description, and a street boy with long, white hair so won + my passion that I followed him to his home and asked his mother + if he might call on me and "play some games." As I did not even + know the boy's name and had never seen him before, I was + wonderingly refused. I sought in vain to find the whereabouts of + another long-haired street boy whom I burned to embrace and load + with benefits. I had a boundless desire for such a boy as this to + idolize me—to look into my face out of big eyes and lose himself + in love for me—to call me by endearing pet names—of his own + accord to throw his arms around my neck. This second actual boy + disappeared from my horizon by presumably moving away from the + vast city neighborhood. I took a fancy to a small boy at school, + who possessed the requisite delicacy, timidity, and sweetness, if + not the physical requisites, of my beau ideal. I walked with him + in the park and planned to have him at the house; but the matter + was not arranged. At boarding-school I had associated much with + younger and weaker boys, and had been ridiculed much for my + cowardice in sports, but at the city school I moved with my + equals and won their recognition. Our gymnasium director was + middle-aged and of an indolent disposition. He liked to recall + his youthful erections and to answer my sexual queries too fully, + and cheerfully volunteered information on brothels. Yet I doubt + whether he had an evil purpose in conversing with me. I thought I + should never dare or want to enter one. I always conjured up the + picture of a row of naked women from whom I could take my pick, + and the smell of the women I imagined to be identical with the + smell of my big friend A. at boarding-school. When I was + traveling down town on an elevated train one afternoon the + brakeman asked me whether I had ever been in a brothel, and told + me that disorderly houses abounded in my neighborhood. "I have + had connection with women," said this red-haired young man, + waving his hand <a name='5_Page_253'></a>in greeting to a woman who nodded at him from a + window, "since I was 15 years old. Not long ago a fine-looking, + young woman in black offered to pay all my expenses if I would + live with her and connect with her."</p> + +<p> When a girl of perhaps 7, a distant cousin of mine, visited us + for a few days, I gratified my lust by placing my hand under her + genitals and swinging her to and fro. She giggled with pleasure. + That summer I began to experience the evil effects of the + masturbation which I had practiced daily for a year and a half. + Pimples began to break out on my chin (my complexion up to this + time had been white and delicate). The family ascribed my + condition to digestive difficulties. In playing with the boys and + girls I found myself seized with a terrible shyness and a + tendency to look down and weep. I had lost all the courage I + had—it had never been great—in the presence of a crowd of + children. I was fairly at ease with a single companion. My + self-consciousness was something more painful to me than I can + convey in words. At home I wept in my room and cursed myself for + a baby. I little realized the cause of my nervous collapse. Yet I + had too robust a frame not to be able to sleep and to play hard. + The sympathetic pleasure which I had found in swinging my + girl-cousin to and fro I now doubled by letting a 7-year-old boy + ride cock-horse on my feet. I experienced an erection during the + process, and I almost induced ejaculation when I tickled the boy + with my feet in the region of his genitals. To see his shrinking, + giggling joy gave me an exquisite sexual thrill. I longed to + sleep with the boy, but I was afraid of causing comment. At the + new and large boarding school which I entered in the fall my most + lustful dreams and ejaculations were concerned with standing this + little boy on the footboard of a bed, taking down his + knickerbockers, and performing <i>fellatio</i> on him. But I dreamed + also of natural coitus. I fell in love with the handsome, + 12-year-old son of the aged headmaster. The boy, O., sat next me + at the table, and I never tired of gazing at him. It gave me a + special sense of pleasure to look at him when he wore a certain + flowing, scarlet, four-in-hand necktie. But O. was not attracted + to me—for one thing I was in a disagreeably pimpled + condition—and I could not induce him to linger in my room nor to + sleep with me. My passion for O. did not diminish, and it rose to + its supremacy on the evening when he appeared in our hallway (he + roomed on the girls' side of the house and hinted at the sexual + sights that he saw) in a costume of white satin, lace, and wings. + He was ready for a costume party.</p> + +<p> I now masturbated less frequently, for I was beginning to + appreciate the horrible consequences of my indulgence. I had + frequent pollutions, with dreams. My day was one long agony of + fear. How I dreaded to go to sleep in the same bed with my older + chum, who never made any advances beyond embracing me passively + <i>cum erectione</i> while he was asleep. My day was one long agony of + fear. At meal time my feet <a name='5_Page_254'></a>constantly writhed in agony for fear + that the headmaster's grown up young ladies should make fun of + me, or that my lack of facial composure and my inability to look + people in the eye might be commented upon. I tingled with + apprehension, especially in the region of my stomach. Every nerve + was taut in the effort I made to appear composed. I masturbated + with erections over nothing. Greek recitations were for me an + <i>auto da fe</i>. My heart beat like a trip-hammer at the thought of + getting up to recite, and once on my feet my voice shook and my + mind wandered. I hated the thought of people behind me looking at + me. I rarely summoned the courage to turn my head either one way + or the other. I vastly admired the "bravery" of the small, + 15-year-old boy who recited so calmly and so well. I was too + cowardly to play foot-ball and base-ball, and I dreaded even my + favorite tennis because the spectators put me in a state of + scared self-consciousness. Knowing my own condition, I was yet so + blind to it most of the time, and such a Jekyll-and-Hyde, that I + actually pitied a boy of 19 who was an eccentric and a scared + victim of masturbation. But in spite of my neuropathic condition + I developed intellectually. I do not touch upon this aspect of my + life, however, because I am trying to limit myself strictly to + sexual manifestations. At the present time I have not the courage + to continue the narrative.</p> +<br /> + +<p> <b>HISTORY III.—</b>The following narrative is written by a clergyman, + age 40, unmarried:—</p> + +<p> My childhood and early boyhood were unmarked by sexual phenomena, + beyond occasional erections, which commenced when about 5 years + of age, without any exciting causes. These were accompanied by + some degree of excitement, of the same nature as that which I + experienced in later years. I was absolutely ignorant of sexual + matters, but always had an idea that the essential difference + between man and woman was to be found in the genital organs. This + was sometimes a matter for thought and curiosity.</p> + +<p> Being for many years an only child I saw little of other + children, and formed the habit of amusing myself with making + things—boats, houses, etc.—and acquired a taste for science. + When I could read I preferred biography, history, and poetry to + anything else.</p> + +<p> When I was 13 years old and at a large school I heard for the + first time of coitus, but very imperfectly. For a few days it + filled my thoughts and mind, but feeling it was too engrossing a + subject and one which took me off better things, I put it out of + my mind. Later, another boy gave me a fuller description of the + matter, and I began to have a great desire to know more and to be + old enough to practice it. I also discovered that boys + masturbated, and about a year after tried <a name='5_Page_255'></a>the experiment for + myself. This vice was largely indulged in by my school-fellows. + It never occurred to me that it was sinful, until I was nearly + 16, when I came across a passage in Kenns's <i>Manual of + Schoolboys</i>, in which it was hinted such things were wrong + morally and spiritually. Previously I had felt it was an + indelicate and shameful thing, and bad for health. This last idea + was held as a solemn fact by all my boy friends. Gradually + religion began to exert an influence over my sexual nature, + obtaining as years passed a greater and greater restraining + power. It is simply impossible for me to write a history of my + sexual development without also describing the action which + Christianity has had in determining its growth. The two have been + so intimately bound together that my life history would not be a + faithful record of facts if I left religion out of it.</p> + +<p> At school I took part, with great keenness, in cricket and + foot-ball, and was very ambitious to excel in everything in which + I took an interest, but I always had other tastes as well, which + were more precious to me, for example, the love for science, + history, and poetry. Until I was past 16 years my desire was + simply for coitus, girls and women attracted me only as affording + the means of gratifying this desire; but when I was nearly 17 I + began to regard girls as beautiful objects, apart from this, and + to desire their love and companionship. At the same time it + dawned upon me that life held much of joy in the love of women + and in domestic life—so henceforth I regarded them in a higher + and purer light, and apart from sexual gratification. In fact, + from this period till I was over 20, this idea so dominated my + whole being that the lower side of my nature was entirely held in + subjection and abeyance by it. It was rather repulsive to think + of girls as objects of lust. This state of mind was not brought + about by any romantic attachment or through any acquaintance or + through circumstances. I was living in great seclusion and had no + girl friends. After this period the lower side of my nature woke + up as a giant refreshed with wine, and I underwent for many years + a constant struggle with my nature, in which religion always + triumphed in the end. I never fell into fornication, though + sometimes into the vice of masturbation. These outbursts of + desire were periodic, about ten or fourteen days apart, and would + last several days. I must record also the fact that from the time + this awakening took place my ideal views of woman no longer + seemed incompatible with sexual relations. I noticed that at + about 27 there was a lessening of the desire, but that may have + been due to overwork and consequent nervous exhaustion. I had a + good deal of worry and studied daily for about eight hours. In + any case the impulse was strongest during the years above + mentioned. A little later in life, for a time, I became attached + to a girl, and eventually engaged. I then observed, greatly to my + sorrow and annoyance, that whenever I met this lady, or even + thought of her, <a name='5_Page_256'></a>erections took place. This was particularly + painful to me, as my thoughts were not of a lustful or impure + character. Sometimes sitting by her at a religious service this + would occur, when certainly my mind was far away from anything of + the kind. That was the first woman ever kissed by me, except of + course members of my immediate family circle. Later on my + thoughts turned to marriage, and there was a great longing at + times for this event to take place. However, as this attachment + afterward became the great sorrow of my life for years, it needs + no more comment. This closes one chapter of my history, and at + present I do not propose to add another, as in a great measure it + is only partly written. It may be well here to state that there + has never been in me the slightest homosexual desire; in fact it + has always appeared as a thing utterly inconceivable and + disgustingly loathsome. I am fond of the society of both men and + women, but on the whole prefer the latter. I have had several + warm and intimate though platonic friendships, and get on + exceedingly well with the other sex, although not a good-looking + man. I have always been attracted to women by their spiritual or + mental qualities, rather than by physical beauty, and feel + strongly that the latter alone would never cause me to desire + coitus. Unless there was an attraction other than that of the + flesh, I should feel that I was following simply a brute + instinct, and it would jar with my higher nature and cause + revulsion. This was not the case in my earlier years to the same + extent. I have often wondered whether the sexual impulse was + strong in me or not, but if not, there is nothing in my physical + state or family history to account for it. I am fairly cognizant + with the lives of my ancestors, being descended from two old + families. The sexual instinct was certainly not weak or abnormal + in them. Personally, I am tall and healthy, well built, but + sensitive and highly strung. Smell has never played any part in + my life as a stimulant of sexual desire, and the mere thought of + body odors would have a very decided effect in the opposite + direction. Touch and sight appeal to me strongly, and of the two + the former most.</p> + +<p> I am convinced, after many years careful thought, that sexual + vice and perversion could be greatly reduced if the young were + instructed in the elements of physiology as they bear on this + question. Personally, had I been thus enlightened much sin would + have been avoided in my schoolboy days, and a perverted view of + sexual matters would never have arisen in my mind. It took years + to overcome the feeling that all such things were unclean and + defiling. Eventually light came to me through reading a passage + in a tractate on the Creed by Rufinus. He was defending the + doctrine, of the Incarnation against the pagan objection that it + was an unclean and disgusting idea that God should enter the + world through the womb of the Blessed Virgin Mary, and he meets + it by showing that God created the sexual organs, therefore the + objection <a name='5_Page_257'></a>is invalid—otherwise God would not be clean or pure, + having Himself designed them and their functions. This passage is + slight in itself, but gave birth to a line of thought which has + influenced me profoundly. I no longer regard sexual matters as + disgusting and unholy, but as intensely sacred, being the outcome + of the Divine Mind. Further, the Incarnation of the Saviour has + not only sanctioned motherhood and all that is implied by it, but + has eternally sanctified it as the means chosen for the + manifestation of God to the world. I should not obtrude my + theological conceptions, but for the fact that they have + determined my life-history in that aspect.</p> +<br /> + +<p> <b>HISTORY IV.—</b>When I was 9 years old a boy at the preparatory + school, which I attended, showed me the act of masturbation, + which he said he had practiced for a long time, and which he + urged me to imitate, if I wished to become a father when I grew + up, and married! Boy-like I believed him and tried, but the + sensation obtained was not a pleasant one (I suppose that I was + too rough with myself) and I desisted.</p> + +<p> When I was about 12 years old, a schoolfellow told me that he had + seen his nurse copulating with the groom, and he and I used to + haunt the woods in the hope that we might see an amorous couple + so engaged, but without success. We often talked of the act, as + to how it was done. Neither he nor I had any clear ideas on the + subject, save as to the organs involved. I was about 15 when a + maidservant of the house in which I was a boarder, came to my + bedroom one night and taught me how to masturbate her. She said + that this was a good thing for me to do, and warned me never to + "play with myself" as it would kill me, or drive me mad. I told + her that I had tried it, but could not bring on a pleasurable + feeling, so she did it to me, and although I did not have an + emission, I derived great pleasure from the act. She told me that + it never did a boy any harm to let a girl play with his parts, + and promised that if I would keep the secret, she would often do + this for me. Naturally I promised to say nothing, and she often + came up to my room. Later on she used to insert my penis into her + vulva, while she was rubbing it, at the same time giving me a + pigeon kiss. This <i>modus operandi</i> was much appreciated by me. + One night, after we had been together thus, I dreamt of her and + her maneuvers and had my first emission. I was very proud of + this, as I considered that I had at last attained to man's + estate, and told her of it. She never allowed me to insert my + penis into her vulva after that, alleging that she did not want + to have a baby.</p> + +<p> I was about 16½ years old when I had my first real coitus, my + partner in the act being a girl some two years older than I, who + lived near us. I enjoyed the act very much, as she permitted, nay + insisted on, emission <i>intra vaginam</i>, and told her that this was + much nicer than my <a name='5_Page_258'></a>amours with the maidservant which of course I + had confided to her. She laughed, and said: "Of course." We often + copulated, as long as I was at home, and then I lost sight of + her. Of all the women with whom I have had to do, save one, she + had the most copious secretion of mucus, which in those days I + believed was the woman's semen. Her thighs used to be wet with + it.</p> + +<p> At the University I had regular relations with women of all + sorts, rarely missing a week. Two of them were married women, one + the wife of a solicitor, the other of a doctor. How proud I felt + of my first intrigue with a married woman! I felt that I was + really a man of the world now!</p> + +<p> But though my friends used to tell me all about their love + affairs, and I longed to confide in them, I did not do so. This + was because when I went up to the University, my uncle said that + he would give me a word of advice and hoped that I would follow + it—never to give away a woman, and never to refuse to respond to + a woman's advances, whoever she were. To neglect this advice + would, he said, be foolish, and to break the rules "damned + ungentlemanly." I wish I had always followed advice proffered, as + closely as I have followed this. One night, when I was somewhat + disguised in liquor, as our grandfathers would have put it, I + picked up a girl, who was a private prostitute, if the phrase be + permissible. She declined copulation, and proposed other means of + satisfaction. I insisted, being stubborn in my cups. Had I been + sober I should have done as she suggested, for I have always made + it a point to allow the woman to choose the method of + gratification, and not to demand, or even suggest, anything + myself. I like to please women, and I have always been curious as + to their wants and desires, as revealed, without outside + influence, by themselves. The result of my refusing all methods + of gratification save the most ordinary was that the girl, who + must have known that she was not all right, but shrank from + saying so in so many words, gave me a gonorrhœa, which + lasted nine weeks and much interfered with my amours, as I + naturally declined to run the risk of infecting my partner, a + risk which to my certain knowledge many a young fellow has run, + with disastrous consequence to the confiding woman. As it was due + to my tipsy obstinacy, I could not blame the girl, but resolved + never to drink too much again, a resolve which I have kept, save + once, unbroken. In those days we youngsters thought that it was + manly to be able to carry one's liquor well, and did all in our + power to attain to the seasoned head; but I considered that the + risks entailed were too serious to be neglected.</p> + +<p> I was well on in my 26th year when I met a widow with whom I fell + in love, with the result that I married her. She is a most + sensible woman, and it was her intellectual gifts which were the + attraction to me. In my amours intellect has never played a part. + She has all along been <a name='5_Page_259'></a>cognizant of, and lenient to, my + polygamous tendencies; for she recognizes the fact that whatever + <i>fredaine</i> I may have on hand makes not the slightest difference + in my love and respect for her. Were she a more sensual woman, + perhaps things would be different.</p> + +<p> In all I have had to do with 81 other women, of whose special + characteristics I kept a careful note at the time. Twenty-six + were normal women with whom my <i>liasons</i> have lasted long, so I + know more about them than I do about the other fifty-five, who + were prostitutes, and with some of whom my dealings were but for + an afternoon.</p> + +<p> The races represented have been these, for I have seen a bit of + the world: English, Scotch, Irish, Welsh, French, German, + Italian, Greek, Danish, Hungarian, Roumanian, Indian, and + Japanese. Taking them all round, the only difference that I found + between old and young women is that the older ones are less + selfish, and more complaisant, and less inclined to resent one's + being unable to attain to the height of their desire, for from + time to time I have been unable to "come up to the scratch" after + a heavy night's labor, or when I was afraid of being caught in + the act of coition, a fear which, in my experience, acts as a + stimulus to desire in women, unlike its action in men. Of all the + women with whom I have had to do the nicest in every way have + been the French women. The English women of the town drink too + much, and are far too keen on getting as much money as they can + for as little as they can, to please me. Were the London girls to + recognize that men do not like a tipsy woman, and that where + there is so much competition the person who is most skillful and + most polite gets the most custom, the alien invasion in Regent + street would soon come to an end.</p> + +<p> Of the fifty-five prostitutes: eighteen informed me that they + were in the habit of masturbating; eight of their own free will, + without asking for reward, did <i>fellatio</i>; six asked me to do + <i>cunnilingus</i>, which I naturally declined to do; three proposed + anal coitus. Of those who did <i>fellatio</i>, two (one French and one + German) told me that they had taken to it because they had heard + that human semen was an excellent remedy against consumption, + which disease had carried off some of their relatives, and that + they had gradually come to like doing it. All who told me that + they masturbated, asked me whether I did so too, and two desired + me to show them the act, one alleging that she liked to see a man + do it; she had been married late in life, after a "stormy youth" + and had had, she said, a large experience of the male sex. They + all seemed to think that however much the practice of + self-excitement might hurt a man, and all thought that it would + hurt him, a woman might masturbate as often as she liked, failing + better means of satisfaction, as she had no such loss of + substance as a man.</p> + +<p> Of the twenty-six normal women, whom I knew more intimately than + I did the fifty-five prostitutes, thirteen, without being + questioned <a name='5_Page_260'></a>by me, blurted out the fact that they were habitual + masturbators, apparently all required to think of the loved + person to obtain full satisfaction. <i>Fellatio</i> was proposed, and + fully performed, by nine, of whom three experienced the orgasm as + soon as they perceived that I had attained to it. All were more + or less excited while doing it. One proposed anal coitus, "just + to see what it was like;" and three proposed <i>cunnilingus</i>, one + having been initiated by a girl friend, and one by her husband. + The third had, I believe, evolved the act out of her own inner + consciousness in her desire to experience pleasure with me. My + relations with one of the twenty-six were confined to my + masturbation of her, the while she did <i>fellatio</i>, as she said + that she "had no feeling inside down there."</p> + +<p> With two exceptions my partings from these normal women have not + been tragic and all whom I have met in after life (seven) have + been very ready to resume relations with me, four of them having + made the proposal themselves.</p> + +<p> One thing has struck me, and that is the, often great, difference + that exists between what a woman's looks lead one to think she + is, and what she is when one becomes her lover; the most sensual + woman that I have met might have sat for her portrait as the + Madonna, and she was the only one who took pleasure in hearing + and relating "smoking-room stories," a form of amusement which, + perhaps from their want of appreciation of humor and wit, women + do not indulge in—at least in my experience.</p> +<br /> + +<p> <b>HISTORY V.—</b>(A continuation of History III in Appendix B to the + previous volume.)</p> + +<p> As I became better I commenced to dream of true love. I wondered, + too, if my horrible past really could be lived down and a young + woman come to love <i>me</i>. I took pleasure in reading love poems, + especially Browning's, and illustrated some with little + water-colors....</p> + +<p> I was sitting in the stalls one night seeing a performance by a + company of English actors when one of them played so badly that I + thought to myself: "Why, hang it, I could play it better myself!" + The next minute another thought followed: "Why not try?" I came + out of the stalls the proverbial stage-struck youth. I was + sitting in the same place another night when the young man next + to me entered into conversation. By a strange coincidence he knew + a few young men, amateurs, who were going to form a company, give + up their situations and travel, if they could induce a few more + to join them and put a little money in. I made an appointment for + the following evening....</p> + +<p> There were lots of meetings in bedrooms and rehearsals between + the beds, but ultimately I was told a school-room had been + engaged and <a name='5_Page_261'></a>a professional actress, A. F. I went to the + school-room and found all the boys there, and a young woman with + a pale, rice-powder complexion. On introduction she gazed at me + as if struck dumb. If she had been better-looking (I thought her + vulgar and puffy) I would have been flattered. I was + disappointed, but rather frightened (she had a stage presence) of + her professional ability, especially when we commenced to + rehearse. I had to make love to her, too, which embarrassed me. + She had a good profile, I noticed, and would have been better + looking, I thought, if she were in better condition, for she was + young, about my own age, twenty-three or four. We were all + young—enjoyed our rehearsals, and had lots of fun—but I did not + respond to the advances A. was evidently making to me. Finally we + started on our tour. As the weeks went on A. F., like the others, + improved wonderfully in health and appearance. If we had had + anything like houses it would have been a pleasant trip. My + strangeness did not escape the notice of the boys altogether, for + I was still a bit strange in mind and nerves—and deeply + religious, bowing my head before each meal and reading my little + Bible and prayer-book at odd times. I drank no alcohol. I spent a + good deal of time by myself of with my faithful companion A., who + was nearly always at my side, she and her appealing eyes. I was + surprised to see how quickly she had improved; she looked quite + attractive and ladylike some evenings at meals, but I only + tolerated her. I was selfish and conceited.</p> + +<p> Things had been going on like this for a week—always playing to + empty houses and our money lower and lower—when A. said to our + other lady, Mrs. T., on a train in my presence: "I shall have to + give him up, I suppose; he will have nothing to do with me." Mrs. + T. said: "You give him up, do you?" and looked at me as if she + were going to try her hand. A. said "Yes," and looked at me, + smiling sadly. I don't know what motive prompted me—whether my + vanity was alarmed at her threatened desertion or that she had + really made some impression on me by her love, probably a little + of both—but I said: "No, don't; come and sit down here," making + way for her, and she joyfully came and nestled against me. From + that time I ceased to treat her with ridicule, and kissed her at + other times than when on the stage. I was subject still to black + moods, and would not speak to her for hours sometimes, but she + seemed content to walk with me and was infinitely patient. I had + heard she was living with—if not married to—an actor. I asked + her about him once, and she said she did not love him; she loved + me and had never loved before. Her face had a touching sadness; + her life had been unhappy and stormy, with no love and little + rest in it. Her face, when she had lost her dissipated look and + unhealthy pallor, was exquisite, delicate as a cameo. Love had + improved her manners, too; she was more gentle and refined. I let + things drift without thinking <a name='5_Page_262'></a>of the future, when one night + after the performance—I was lying on the sofa and A. was sitting + at my side, as usual—I suddenly thought, with the brutality that + characterized me in these matters—"I will ask her to let me + sleep with her." I still fought against any premonitory thought + of self-abuse, but here, I thought to myself, is a chance of + something better that will do me no harm and perhaps good. When + she understood me she turned very red and walked away, shaking + her head. But I let her understand that was the only way of + retaining me, and finally, when they had all gone to bed, she + gave herself to me, reluctantly and sadly; for she, too, had been + drifting on without thinking of anything of this sort (she hated + it at this time), but just living for her love of me, her first + true love.</p> + +<p> Before this occurred, I must tell you, I had been so much better + that I sometimes felt capable of doing anything, a sense of power + and grasp of intellect which was combined with delicacy of + feeling and sensitiveness to beauty, to skies and clouds and + flowers. I seemed to be awakening to true manhood, to my true + self. And at meals, it is worth recording, I commenced to have a + distaste for meat.</p> + +<p> These glimpses of a better state of things left me on cohabiting + with A., and for a time my gloom and black religious mania came + on me once more. I now thought of my promise at confirmation, and + it seemed to me I had offended beyond pardon. When we came to the + next town, however, I openly slept with A. all night, leaving my + own bed untouched. When we returned to Adelaide one of our party + remarked: "The only man who had any success with the women on the + tour was a Bible-reading, praying, and good, pious, confirmed + Christian."</p> + +<p> A.'s nascent beauty and delicacy and improvement were gradually + impaired, too. My own conduct became so morose at times that, + besides increasing her misery, I offended the others, and + bickerings ensued. I heard the other actress say "He's mad; that + what's the matter." And I was so wrapped up in myself and my + religious mania that I did not mind their thinking so.</p> + +<p> After the tour was over A. asked me to come and see her at her + home, and as I missed her very much I went one night to tea. She + had a room in her father's house to herself. A. was dressed in + her best and we had an affectionate meeting. After tea I asked + her if she were married to E. She said "No." Then I said: "Who + are you married to?" She commenced to cry then, and told me + something of her life, the saddest I ever heard. When only 17 she + had been courted by a young man she did not care for, but who + prevailed on her parents by pretending he had seduced her, but + wished to marry her. Strange as it may seem, A. did not know what + marriage meant, her mother being one of those silly women who + don't like talking of these things and let their daughters grow + up in ignorance, expecting they will learn from some one. In nine + <a name='5_Page_263'></a>cases out of ten this happens, but A. was an exception. It was + this, and the fact that she had not a particle of love for her + husband, that gave her such a hatred of coition. When her mother + saw the sheets the morning after the marriage she burst out + crying; she did not like the young man and saw she had been + deceived.</p> + +<p> A.'s husband soon showed his true character; he was in reality a + gaol-bird. He beat her, drank, and even wanted her to go on the + streets to earn money for him. She left him and went home; it was + then she began her theatrical career by entering the ballet. At + intervals her husband, drunk and desperate, would waylay and + threaten her in the street. One day after a rehearsal he + attempted to stab her. She got on in spite of all, being a born + actress, and played small parts in traveling companies. Then E., + who had also gone on the stage, courted her and she listened to + him, not because she cared for him, but he protected her and + offered her a home. She joined him; but his drunkenness and + sensuality were so gross that he ruined his health and he + attempted to maltreat A. in a nameless way. And whenever she was + in the family way he would leave her alone and half-conscious in + the cellar for days. To add to her misery she had epileptic fits. + Then sometimes they would be out of an engagement and starving. + They had been so hungry as to steal raw potatoes out of a sack + and eat them thus, having no fire. She would often have had + engagements, but E. was jealous and would not let her act without + him. And he beat her as her husband had done, and her health + became undermined. It was just after one of the forced + miscarriages that she joined our traveling company, and that + accounted for her yellow and puffy appearance. E. was now away + up-country with a circus, but was expected down any time. A. told + me a good deal of all this, between her tears, while sitting at + my feet, and her tone carried conviction. When I ought to have + gone home I persuaded her to let me stay all night. We had been + in bed some time when her mother knocked at the door and wanted + to come in for something in a chest of drawers there. "Why don't + you open the door, A.? Who have you got there? Hasn't that fellow + gone?" A. was confused and told me to get under the bed, but I + refused, and she covered me up with the bed clothes as well as + she could and opened the door. She had hid my clothes, but missed + one of my shoes, and her mother saw it. "Oh, A.," was all she + said; "you've got that fellow in bed," and went out crying. + "Well, Fred" (my stage name), "you've got me into a nice row," A. + said. She gave me my breakfast in the morning and I walked out of + the front door without being molested. Another night I entered + her window by a ladder and stayed all night. In the middle of the + night E. came home drunk. She would not let him in and told him + she would have nothing more to do with him. He attempted to break + in the door, when A. called to me, and hearing a man in the room + he went away, saying, as he <a name='5_Page_264'></a>went downstairs: "Oh, A.! Oh, A.!" + as if he thought she would not have done such a thing. He never + molested us after that night.</p> + +<p> I think it was my intention, at first, to break off with A. + gradually. I found, however, I could not keep away from her, and + it commenced to be evident to me that a bachelor's life in + lodgings again would be dreary and lonely. And all this time the + fear that I had offended God troubled me more than I have said, + and it occurred to me (there may have been a touch of sophistry + in this, or not) that if I were a true husband to her for the + future—stuck to her and worked for her for the rest of my + days—perhaps it would find favor in God's sight and be an + atonement for my sin. Had she been free I would have married her, + I believe. But she began to be harassed by her mother and + bothered about my incessantly coming there and staying all night. + It ended in my telling her I would be a husband to her, and she + came and lived with me at my lodgings. We had one room and our + meals cost us sixpence each. Cheap as it was, it was a struggle + for me to earn money at all. I remember feeling ill and anxious + once, and sustaining myself by the thought of my father wheeling + the heavy truck up the street when he married my mother. And I + decided to wheel my truck, too.</p> + +<p> A. seemed happy and her love increased, if possible; at first, + though, she must have found me a trying lover, for I made her + kneel and pray with me two or three times a day, which she did + with such a queer expression of face. Sometimes her feelings got + the better of her, and she would say: "Oh, damn it, Fred, you are + always praying." And then I would be shocked and she would be + sorry.... Coitus was frequent; she commenced to like it now....</p> + +<p> A. was not looking well one evening when she came in, and lay + down on the bed. Presently she commenced to make a strange noise, + and I saw her eyes were closed and her hands clenched. "Ah," said + the landlady, who came in to help me; "she has epileptic fits." + When her convulsions were over she looked blankly at us, knitting + her brows and evidently puzzling her poor brain to remember who + we were. For many years it was my fate to see her looking at me + thus, at first stony and estranged, like a dweller in another + star, then half-recalling with extended hand, then forgetting + again with hand to mouth, then the gradual dawn of memory and + love, and final full recognition. "It's Fred, my Fred!" I never + got used to it; it always moved me to tears.... It was not to be + thought that we had no quarrels. I still had fits of bad temper, + and sometimes they came into collision with A.'s temper. It hurt + my vanity considerably to see how soon she relinquished the + respectful, patient, spaniel-bearing she had when we were + traveling. I said some cruel things to her and she retorted. One + would have thought, to hear us, that all affection was over. But + when the mood of rage wore <a name='5_Page_265'></a>itself out we would both be sorry and + make it up with tears, and be very happy in spite of our poverty.</p> + +<p> I think it was lust that prevented me from striving to fulfill my + ambitions. A. let me do anything I liked, at all times of day or + night, although she seemed surprised at my proceedings sometimes, + for it was becoming a fever of lubricity with me. She still + thought only of her love. I remember her coming in one day, + tired, pale, perspiring, and worried—we had hardly anything in + the house and she had been to the theater ineffectually—and when + her eyes lighted on me the whole expression of her face changed, + softened and brightened at once, and she came and kissed me and + said: "It is so strange, I was thinking all sorts of nasty things + coming along, but as soon as I see my pet's face I feel happy—I + don't care for anything—I would sooner share a crust with him + than have all the money in the world!"</p> + +<p> I commenced to feel libidinous curiosity to examine her—this was + mostly on Sundays—and she let me, blushing at first, but + laughing. Then I would try new positions in coitus I had heard + of. Still she did not enter into my mood.</p> + +<p> She was engaged at this time to play in a pantomime and I + commenced to lead a miserable, jealous existence. I heard scandal + about her, baseless enough, but in the diseased, nervous, anxious + state I had brought myself to it nearly drove me mad. I would go + with her sometimes to visit her mother, whom I began to like. Her + brother I still saluted coldly. It caused me horror and jealousy + to see A. kissing him and letting him tickle her. In my rage, + when we came home, I even said that perhaps she would let him do + something else, naming it brutally and coarsely. I remember her + shame, astonishment, indignation and tears. If ever a man tried a + woman's love I did. But she forgave me, even that.</p> + +<p> We went to live in a little cottage. It was in this cottage that + A. first showed signs of lust, and in the diseased state of my + mind, instead of regretting it, I encouraged her. She told me one + day that the orgasm very often did not occur at the same time + with her as with me, and that it would not unless I put my little + finger into the anus. This her husband taught her, and she would + rather have died than confess it to me when we first met. We + would often devote our Sundays to having a picnic as we termed + our lustful bouts, stimulating ourselves with wine. Her temper + was not improved thereby (though her fits entirely stopped for a + twelvemonth)—we had wordy warfares, but we made it up again + always with tears. Nor did I allow myself to deteriorate without + reactions and excursions into better things. I was always reading + Emerson; it was he who rescued me from orthodox Christianity and + taught me to trust in myself and in Nature. I have never ceased + this struggle towards better things to this day. There, in a + nutshell, is <a name='5_Page_266'></a>my life; I have always been defeated when + temptation came, but I have never ceased to struggle. I + determined to be more abstemious in sexual indulgence and asked + her to help me. She agreed willingly, for she was easily led. + Whenever we fell back again into excess it was my fault.</p> + +<p> At a theatrical performance we first met a Miss T., a young + German who sang. She was about 25, with modest, quiet and + engaging manners. A. and she became very friendly. I liked her; + she was tall, dark and lithe, but had bad teeth.</p> + +<p> I had been ill and at this time A. and I had a quarrel, my temper + suddenly breaking out in murderous frenzy. I called her names and + finally put her outside the house, telling her to go to her + mother. I suffered a very hell of remorse and misery. Everything + in the quiet, lonely house reminded me of her, seemed fragrant of + her; my anguish became so keen I could not stop in the house, + though I was just as wretched walking about. I kept this up for + two days, when I met her coming to look for me. One look was + enough—"A.!" "Pet!" in broken sobs—and in tears we kissed and + made it up. Miss T. was with her, and I greeted her, too, with + happy tears in my eyes. Another time, when A. was giving way to + <i>her</i> temper, and one would have thought all love was dead, I + said "Don't you love me then?" and the word alone was a talisman, + her face changed, she held out her arms and began to sob + quietly.... She accepted an offer to travel with a small + theatrical company who were going up-country. She was not looking + well when I left and after a time I received a telegram telling + me to come to her at once as she was ill. Dreading all sorts of + things I borrowed my fare and went to her. I knew nothing of + women, of their point of view and different code of honor, and + was very far from the attitude of Guy de Maupassant who said he + liked women all the better for their charmingly deceitful ways. + A. wanted to see me and had taken the surest means to ensure my + coming. I was angry at first, but she looked so well and was so + loving that I could not be angry long.</p> + +<p> One day when I was working the landlady came in and began talking + about A. and her conduct before I came. She had gone into the + actors' rooms at all hours, the woman said, and drank and been as + bad as the rest in her conversation. It was the second time a + married woman had run her down to me, and I commenced to think + there might be something in it, and suffered all my mad jealousy + over again. Not knowing the freedom actors and actresses allow + themselves on tour, without there being necessarily anything in + it, I worried till I thought I had nothing to do but die. And + then one of the great struggles of my life occurred. Walking the + country roads, I asked myself: "If it <i>is</i> true, if she has been + unfaithful, will you forgive her and help her to arrive at her + best?" For a long time the answer was "No!" But perhaps my + striving for unity with myself had done some good, and the <a name='5_Page_267'></a>final + resolution was for forgiveness. I felt more peace of mind then, + and when I told a dying consumptive lodger in the house what the + landlady had said, he replied, "Don't you believe a word of it. I + know she loves you!"....</p> + +<p> After an absence I found myself one evening in a town where A. + was performing. I went round to the back and they told me she had + gone to a room in the hotel to change for another part. I + followed and entered the room, with a glass of spirits I found + that an effeminate young actor was bringing to her. She was half + undressed, her beautiful arms and shoulders bare. My arrival was + unexpected and she looked at me surprised, I thought coldly, as I + reproached her for not keeping a promise she had made to me to + touch no alcohol during the tour, but soon her arms were round my + neck. She cried like a child. She was bigger and handsomer and + healthier. There was not only an increased strength and size, but + an increased delicacy and sweetness; her eyes and brows were + lovely; there was an indescribable bloom and fragrance on her, + such as the sun leaves on a peach; the traveling, country air, + and freedom from coitus (had I known it) had enabled her to + arrive at her true self, not only a beautiful woman, but a woman + of fascination, of wit, vivacity and universal <i>camaraderie</i>. Her + face was like the dawn; all my fears and jealousy left me like a + cloud that melts before the sun. I remember the look on her face + as she embraced me in bed that night. It had just the very + smallest touch of sensuality, but was more like some beautiful + child's who is being caressed by one she loves; this divine, + drowsy-eyed, adorable look I had never seen on her face + before—nor have I since.</p> + +<p> We fell back into our old lustful ways. Later on A. became ill + and the black devil of epilepsy returned. I became gloomy.... A + restlessness and selfish brutality came over me; our love and + peace were gone. I persuaded A. to go to Melbourne and look out + for an engagement. The day before she was to sail we went to + Glenelg for a trip. The sea air, as often happened, precipitated + A.'s fits. We had gone down to the pier and A. said she felt bad. + I just managed to support her to the hotel before she became + stiff, and I made some impatient remark (for she nearly dragged + me down) which she heard, not being quite unconscious and said + half incoherently and very pitiably: "Be kind, oh, be kind!" + repeating it after consciousness left her. Her heart had been + breaking all day at the prospect of parting, and also, I expect, + because I was so ready to part with her. That moment was a crisis + in my life. I was in a murderous humor, but she looked so + unutterably wretched that it seemed impossible to be anything but + kind. I made myself speak lovingly to her, in moments of partial + consciousness, hired a room, carried her up, and nursed her and + petted her all night. The act of self-control, <a name='5_Page_268'></a>and forcing + myself to be kind whatever I felt, became a habit in time, a sort + of second nature.</p> + +<p> In a few days she sailed. When she had gone I was remorseful and + mad with myself. How could I let her go by herself? I resolved to + follow her as speedily as possible, and did so.</p> + +<p> If I remember rightly I came to the conclusion about this time + that we ought not to have coition unless we felt great love for + each other. It seemed to corroborate this to a certain extent + that A. always seemed more electric and pleasant to the touch + when we had connection for love and not for lust. Leave it to + Nature, I would say to myself. I began to feel how much my + struggles, efforts and temperate living had improved me. I had + more self-respect, though something of the old self-consciousness + was still left. I did not get better continuously, but in an + up-and-down zigzag. I still had moods of rage approaching madness + and periods of neurotic depression. Long walks decidedly helped + to cure me, and the sea, sun, wind, clouds and trees colored my + dreams at night very sweetly. I frequently dreamed I was walking + in orchards or forests, and a deeper, slightly melancholy but + potent savor, as of a diviner destiny, was on my soul.</p> + +<p> After a long absence, during which she had frequently been ill, + A. joined me. I could see she was recovering from fits, which I + began to realize that she had more frequently in absence from me, + and also from drinking, perhaps. She was small and thin, but + fresh and sweet as honey, and all signs of fits and tempers + passed away from her face, so wonderful in its changes. I had + become so healthy through my abstinence, temperance and long + walks that our meeting was a new revelation to me of how + delicate, fragrant and divine a convalescent woman may be. She + was glad and surprised to see me looking so well, and if she put + her hand on my arm I felt a joyous thrill. I was certainly a + better man for abstaining and she a better woman and I determined + not to have connection unless we were carried away by our love. + As a matter of fact we did not give way to excess, though we were + very loving. I tried to persuade myself that we had not gone back + to our old ways, but I could not do so long.</p> + +<p> Miss T. put in an appearance every day. She did not look so + innocent, but as it was no business of mine I did not trouble. + She seemed more attached to A. than ever.... A. was still very + loving with me, but it was an effort to me to keep up to her + pitch, and when A. proposed to go to Melbourne with Miss T, to + sell off the furniture before settling in Adelaide, I was rather + glad of the opportunity of abstaining from coitus and of watching + myself to see if I again improved. When A. and Miss T. came to + see me before going down to the steamer, A. was nearly crying and + Miss T., changed from the old welcome friend, was not only pale + and anxious, but looked guilty as if she had some <a name='5_Page_269'></a>treachery in + her mind; she could not meet my eye. I thought less of it then + than afterwards. And once more I took long walks at night and + rose early to catch the freshness of the mornings.</p> + +<p> Some time before this I had read a book advocating a vegetarian + diet, and at this time I chanced to read Pater's beautiful "Denys + L'Auxerrois," the imaginary portrait of a young vine-dresser, who + was attractive beyond ordinary mortals and lived, until his fall + and deterioration, on fruit and water. The words, "a natural + simplicity in living" remained in my memory. I resolved to read + more carefully the book on scientific diet. Who can say, I + thought, what changes for the better may come to me if I live on + a strictly scientific and natural diet?</p> + +<p> I fasted one whole day, and then had a breakfast of cherries, in + the middle of the day a meal of fruit, and walking in the + afternoon—a gray, rainy day—I felt so light, so different, and + the gray sky looked so sweet and familiar, that I was reminded of + the luminous visions of my boyhood. It was a distinct revelation. + This Pan-like, almost Bacchic feeling, did not last, however, nor + was I always able to maintain my new method of diet, though I + tried to do so. I made the attempt, however, but I imagine I was + more than usually run down. I would walk miles in the hope of + feeling less restless. One holiday I walked down to Glenelg, + having only had grapes for my dinner, and lying on the beach I + looked through a strong binocular glass I had borrowed at the + girls bathing. And the beauty of their faces in their frames of + hair, of their arms, of their figures, seen through their wet + clinging dresses, satisfied me and filled me with joy, gave me + for a short time that peace and content—in harmony with the + strong sunlight on the waves and the rhythmic surf on the + shore—I was seeking. The summer evenings on the pier or along + the beach had a peculiar savor; one felt the youth and beauty + there even on dark nights, the air was fragrant with them, white + dresses and summer hats disappearing down the beach or over the + sand hills. It was easy—doubtless justifiable sometimes—to put + a lewd construction on these disappearances; but I felt it need + not have been so; that it was not necessary that youth and + beauty, even the sexual act itself if led up to by love, should + be a subject of giggling and sniggering. I always left the beach + and its flitting summer dresses with a sigh.</p> + +<p> A., after writing once, ceased writing at all and once more her + mother and I were left in a state of anxiety and suspense. At + last I determined to go to Melbourne to look for her, the only + clue I had being a remark in her letter that a certain actor was + giving her an engagement. In Melbourne I could not find any + traces of her for some days and what traces I did find of her + were not calculated to allay my anxious fears. One hotel-keeper + told me that some one of A's name had stayed there with another + hussy (giving Miss T's stage name): "There were nice carryings on + with the pair of them." I thought of Miss T's strange <a name='5_Page_270'></a>looks, but + could not imagine what hold she had on A., for A. loved me, I + knew. I seemed to be in an inextricable maze. I could settle to + nothing and was thinking of applying to the police when I heard + that the actor A. had mentioned had taken his company to the + Gippsland lakes. I followed to Sale, found the actor and was told + that A. was not there. "She slipped me at the last moment," he + said, "and remained in Melbourne." I returned to my lodgings, + with my anxiety and nervous restlessness increased tenfold. But + suddenly my fear and restlessness left me like a cloud. I felt + quiet, young, peaceful, able to enjoy the country, A. was + doubtless all right and would be able to explain her silence. I + undressed leisurely and happily, thinking of the stars.</p> + +<p> The next day, Sunday, I awoke refreshed and still at peace. After + breakfast, hearing children's voices, I went out into the garden + and there was a collision of souls who somehow were affinities. A + young girl about twelve or younger with a fine presence and + handsome face fixed her eyes on me for half a minute and then + came and sat on my knee. She was one of those children I am + accustomed to call "love-children," because they are so much + brighter, healthier, larger and more loving than others. I always + imagine more love went to their making. We fell in love and she + said, stroking my beard, "Oh, you are pretty!" and I said, "And + so are you!" We were so affectionate that the servant called the + child away and I went for a walk, finding my little sweetheart + waiting for me on my return. The touch of her hand was electric + and her voice fresh and musical. I kissed her, but had become + more self-conscious since the morning and wondered if her mother + or the servant were looking, or even of they would appear. I was + not so frank and natural as my little chum. I have often thought + of her since. She had the breadth of forehead, the strength and + yet lightness of limb, together with the hands and feet, not too + small, that I always imagine the dwellers in Paradise will have.</p> + +<p> I returned to Melbourne and continued trying to find A. At the + same time I commenced in earnest to live on fruit and brown bread + only, and enjoyed better tone and health every day, so that it + was a joy to walk down the street in the sun and exchange glances + with passengers à la old Walt. One day in the Botanical Gardens + veils seemed to be lifted off my eyes. I could look straight at + the sun and taking my note of color from that golden light I + turned my eyes on the flowers, the mown grass, the trees, and for + the first time perceived what a heavenly color green is, what + divine companions flowers are, and what a blue sky really means. + For half an hour I was in Paradise, and to complete my joy Nature + revealed to me a new and unexpected secret.</p> + +<p> I was lying on a bench, basking, and my silk shirt coming open + the strong sun made its way to my breast and presently I felt a + totally new sensation there. I had discovered the last joy of the + skin. My <a name='5_Page_271'></a>skin, fed by healthy fruit-made blood, must have + functioned normally under the excitation of the sun just then + (for a brief space only, alas!). I cannot describe the joy, any + more than I could describe the taste of a peach to one who has + only eaten apples: it was satisfying, divine. I opened my shirt + wider, but the feeling only spread faintly, and indeed this + halcyon sunny hour terminated in a restlessness that sent me + walking into town to look for A.</p> + +<p> At last I heard, not of A., but of Miss T. She was in a ballet. I + went round during rehearsal and while waiting entered into + conversation with a little chorus girl with a good face, who was + sewing. On my telling her whom I was seeking she stopped sewing + and looked at me quickly: "Oh, are you her husband? I know her. + <i>I have seen them together</i>." She looked as if she were going to + tell me something, but merely shook her old-fashioned head in a + mournful, indescribable way, saying "Why don't you keep your wife + with you?" I went to the door and presently saw Miss T. She tried + to avoid me, I thought, and looked more vicious than ever, but + after a minute's thought reluctantly told me where she and A. + were staying. To hide my fears and suspicions I had assumed a + careless demeanor, but I think I should have strangled her had + she refused to tell me. I hastily went to the place indicated and + going up the stairs (to the astonishment of the people) opened + the door and found myself face to face with A.—but how changed! + She had the hard, harlot, loveless look I detested. I felt for a + few minutes that I did not love her, and she regarded me coldly + too, but presently old habits reinstated themselves. She put out + her hands, very pitiably, and then was sobbing in my arms. I + could get nothing out of her but sobs, and to this day do not + know where she spent all these weeks nor why she did not write. + Miss T. came in after rehearsal, pale and hard-faced. I greeted + her politely, but was watching her, trying to puzzle out why A. + did not look as she usually did after long absence from coition. + Miss T. took another room in the same house and was soon joined + by another ballet girl, young and very pretty, who soon began to + have fits. A. was always crying until Miss T. went away with her + pretty friend. I knew nothing, could hardly be said to suspect + anything definite, and yet I pitied that pretty girl whose eyes + looked so helpless and appealing.</p> + +<p> I set to work again. But I continued to live on fruit and bread, + and taking off my clothes I would stand up at the window in the + sun. A lot of prostitutes, however, who lived at the back saw me + and were scandalized or shocked or thought me mad. The landlady + heard of it and spoke to A. So I had to desist from my glorious + sun-baths.</p> + +<p> We slept on a single bed, and though I did my best to avoid + coitus (I wanted to wait and think out some theory of it), A., + who knew nothing of this, wanted to resume our old habits, and + finally I surrendered. But my sufferings next day were intense, + and I had the sense <a name='5_Page_272'></a>of having fallen from some high estate. My + thoughts were divided between two theories: one that our misery + was caused by our diet, more or less; the other that we had + fallen into some error as regards coitus, and this was becoming + almost a certainty with me.</p> + +<p> There is one incident I think worthy of note which happened + before the "fall" just mentioned and when I was living on fruit + and in splendid health. At a performance I saw a girl on the + stage with handsome legs in tights, and once as she straightened + her leg the knee-cap going into position gave me such a strange + and keen joy—of that quality I call divine or musical—that I + was like one suddenly awakened to the divinity and beauty of the + female form. The joy was so keen and yet peaceful, familiar, and + subjective that I could not help comparing it to a happy chemical + change in the tissues of my own brain. Like the unexpected + functioning of my skin in the sun it was a sign of a partial + return to a normal condition, another glimpse of Paradise.</p> + +<p> I stuck to my new diet and gained a fresh elation and joy in + life. Gradually clothes became insupportable, and I went down to + the beach as often as possible to take them off, and at nights, + beside the patient and astonished A., I would lie naked. One + evening, passing some grass, I looked over the fence like a gipsy + and felt a longing to take off my clothes and sleep in the grass + all night. It was of course impossible. And A. looked unhappily + in my face; she began to think her mother, who now thought I was + mad, must be right.</p> + +<p> That night I woke up and found myself having coition. I was angry + and felt I had been put back in my progress, but a fever of lust + now came over me. I would sit under the tap and let the cold + water run over me to conquer the fever, but at the end of a week + my hopes were frustrated and I even turned against my natural + diet, on which I had made flesh. A., as I expected, went through + her usual fits, and slowly recovered. (If we had connection only + once she in about three weeks had a mild attack of fits; if we + had coition more than once the fits were more severe.) I relapsed + more than once and as a means of impressing my resolution for + future abstinence I would walk for miles in the middle of + pitch-black nights....</p> + +<p> Miss T. came over to Adelaide and as I knew nothing definite + against her and heard that she was engaged, I thought perhaps my + suspicions were unfounded and was friendly. But one day in town I + saw her and A. on a tram going out to our cottage. Even then my + suspicions might not have been awakened, but I saw Miss T. say + something rapidly to A., and A. called out to me, "Will you be + coming home soon?" And I answered "No." When the tram had gone on + I found myself vaguely wondering what Miss T. wanted to know that + for, for my perceptions were becoming acute enough to understand + women's ways. In another minute I was walking rapidly home. When + I came to the door <a name='5_Page_273'></a>it was locked. I knocked and knocked and no + one came. I called out and threatened to kick in the door. Still + no one came. Mad with rage I commenced to put my threat into + execution, when the door was opened by Miss T., half-naked, in + her petticoats, and pale as death, but no longer defiant. "So + I've caught you, have I?" I <i>looked</i>, but could not trust myself + to speak. Wondering why A. did not appear I went into the + bedroom. She was lying on the bed, just as Miss T. had left her, + on the verge of a fit, and on seeing me she held out her hands + piteously, and when I stooped over her she whispered, "Send her + away, send her away." Then she became unconscious and going into + the next room I ordered Miss T. (who had managed to scramble on + her dress) out of the house. I spoke scornfully as if addressing + a dog, and she slinked out with a malignant but cowed look I hope + never to see on a woman's face again. What they had been doing + with their clothes off I do not know; women will rather die than + confess. When A. had recovered from her fit she denied that there + had been anything between them, and stuck to it doggedly, but + with such a forlorn look I had not the heart to prosecute my + inquiries.</p> + +<p> For my part, all the efforts I had been making for so long seemed + for a time to be in vain; for some weeks I sank into a sort of + satyriasis, and even my anger against Miss T. turned to a + prurient curiosity. At the same time I was not always able to + adhere to my diet. But both as regards coition and diet I was + still fighting, and on the whole successfully. My fits of temper, + however, were excessive and my ennui became gloomy despair. One + day I blasphemed on crossing the Park and spoke contemptuously of + "God and his twopenny ha'penny revolving balls," referring to the + planetary system. But for long walks I should have gone mad. A. + was drinking in the intervals of her fits. I found half-empty + bottles of wine hidden away. This did not improve my temper, and + one day—this was when she was well and up—I struck her a heavy + blow on the face, and she aimed a glass decanter at me. She went + home to her mother and I lived alone in the cottage. I heard soon + afterwards that her husband had come back and that they had made + it up. Our parting was not, however, destined to be final.</p> + +<p> Even out of that month's sufferings I made capital. I was better + after my tendency to lubricity, my gloom, rage, restlessness and + degradation. They had been but the irritations of convalescence.</p></div> + + + +<a name='5_Page_274'></a> +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_INDEX_OF_AUTHORS'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_275'></a>INDEX OF AUTHORS.</h2> + + +<ul><li>Abrantès, duchesse d', <a href='#5_Page_213'>213</a>.</li> +<li>Adler, <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Albucasis, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>.</li> +<li>Alexander, H. C. B., <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a>.</li> +<li>Amatus Lusitanus, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li> +<li>Ammon, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>, <a href='#5_Page_196'>196</a>.</li> +<li>Andersen, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Andriezen, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Aquinas, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Aristophanes, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Aristotle, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>.</li> +<li>Averroes, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a></li> +<li>Avicenna, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>.</li> +<li>Aubrey, <a href='#5_Page_93'>93</a>.</li> +<li>Aulnoy, Madame d', <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Baer, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Ball, <a href='#5_Page_93'>93</a>.</li> +<li>Ballantyne, J. W., <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Bancroft, H. H., <a href='#5_Page_80'>80</a>.</li> +<li>Barker, Fordyce, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Barnes, R., <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Bartholin, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>.</li> +<li>Bayle, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>.</li> +<li>Beale, G. B., <a href='#5_Page_218'>218</a>.</li> +<li>Bechterew, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>.</li> +<li>Beck, J. R., <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a>.</li> +<li>Becker, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Bell, Sir C., <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Bell, Sanford, <a href='#5_Page_215'>215</a>.</li> +<li>Belletrud, <a href='#5_Page_62'>62</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>.</li> +<li>Beneden, <a href='#5_Page_116'>116</a>.</li> +<li>Bergh, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>, <a href='#5_Page_135'>135</a>, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Bianchi, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Biérent, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>, <a href='#5_Page_188'>188</a>, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li> +<li>Binet, <a href='#5_Page_2'>2</a>, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li> +<li>Bischoff, T. L. W., <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Bloch, J., <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>, <a href='#5_Page_50'>50</a>, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>, <a href='#5_Page_78'>78</a>, <a href='#5_Page_81'>81</a>, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Blondel, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li> +<li>Blumenbach, <a href='#5_Page_81'>81</a>, <a href='#5_Page_188'>188</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Blunt, J. J., <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Boas, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>, <a href='#5_Page_80'>80</a>.</li> +<li>Boccaccio, <a href='#5_Page_170'>170</a>.</li> +<li>Boeteau, <a href='#5_Page_78'>78</a>.</li> +<li>Bois, J., <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Bois-Reymond, E. du, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Bölsche, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li> +<li>Booth, D. S., <a href='#5_Page_103'>103</a>.</li> +<li>Booth, J., <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Bouchereau, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>.</li> +<li>Bouchet, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li> +<li>Bourke, J. G., <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>, <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Boveri, <a href='#5_Page_116'>116</a>.</li> +<li>Brand, <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Braun, <a href='#5_Page_139'>139</a>.</li> +<li>Brantôme, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Brehm, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>.</li> +<li>Breitenstein, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Brénier de Montmorand, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>.</li> +<li>Brénot, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Brouardel, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Brown-Séquard, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Brügelmann, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li> +<li>Buckman, S. S., <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>.</li> +<li>Bucknill, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Bunge, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Burchard, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Burdach, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Burton, Robert, <a href='#5_Page_9'>9</a>, <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>, <a href='#5_Page_108'>108</a>, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>, <a href='#5_Page_200'>200</a>.</li> +<li>Buschan, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Busdraghi, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Cabanis, <a href='#5_Page_181'>181</a>.</li> +<li>Campbell, J. F., <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Campbell, H., <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Carpenter, E., <a href='#5_Page_110'>110</a>.</li> +<li>Casanova, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>.</li> +<li>Cascella, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Castelnau, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>.</li> +<li>Catullus, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li> +<li>Cecca, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>.</li> +<li>Celsus, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>.</li> +<li>Chapman, C. W., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Charcot, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Chaucer, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Chaulant, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li> +<li>Chevalier, <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>.</li> +<li>Chidley, W., <a href='#5_Page_164'>164</a>.</li> +<li>Cladel, J., <a href='#5_Page_109'>109</a>.</li> +<li>Clement, of Alexandria, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Coe, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>.</li> +<li>Coen, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Collineau, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li> +<li>Colman, W. S., <a href='#5_Page_104'>104</a>.</li> +<li>Columbus, R., <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li> +<li>Cook, G. W., <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.<a name='5_Page_276'></a></li> +<li>Crawley, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Cumston, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Cuvier, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>.</li> +<li>Cyples, <a href='#5_Page_109'>109</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Dabney, <a href='#5_Page_224'>224</a>.</li> +<li>Darwin, C., <a href='#5_Page_85'>85</a>.</li> +<li>Darwin, E., <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Daumas, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>.</li> +<li>Dearborn, G., <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>.</li> +<li>Dembo, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>.</li> +<li>Deniker, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>.</li> +<li>Dessoir, Max, <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li> +<li>Dickinson, R. L., <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_135'>135</a>.</li> +<li>Diderot, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +<li>Disselhorst, <a href='#5_Page_158'>158</a>.</li> +<li>Donaldson, H. H., <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Douglas, C., <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li> +<li>Drähms, <a href='#5_Page_200'>200</a>.</li> +<li>Dühren, E., <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>, <a href='#5_Page_64'>64</a>, <a href='#5_Page_95'>95</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a> (and see Bloch, J.).</li> +<li>Dufougère, <a href='#5_Page_178'>178</a>.</li> +<li>Dufour, <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Dulaure, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>, <a href='#5_Page_80'>80</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>.</li> +<li>Duncan, Matthews, <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>East, A., <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>.</li> +<li>Edgar, Clifton, <a href='#5_Page_162'>162</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Ellis, Havelock, <a href='#5_Page_1'>1</a>, <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>, <a href='#5_Page_199'>199</a>, <a href='#5_Page_200'>200</a>, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Engelmann, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li> +<li>Erotion, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>.</li> +<li>Esbach, <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>.</li> +<li>Eschricht, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>.</li> +<li>Espinas, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>.</li> +<li>Eulenburg, <a href='#5_Page_1'>1</a>, <a href='#5_Page_95'>95</a>.</li> +<li>Evans, <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>.</li> +<li>Ezekiel, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Fabricius, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>.</li> +<li>Fallopius, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>.</li> +<li>Féré, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>, <a href='#5_Page_74'>74</a>, <a href='#5_Page_77'>77</a>, <a href='#5_Page_103'>103</a>, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>, <a href='#5_Page_169'>169</a>, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>, <a href='#5_Page_225'>225</a>.</li> +<li>Fichstedt, <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a>.</li> +<li>Flood, E., <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>.</li> +<li>Florence, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Fothergill, Milner, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>.</li> +<li>Frazer, J. G., <a href='#5_Page_61'>61</a>.</li> +<li>Freud, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>, <a href='#5_Page_202'>202</a>.</li> +<li>Freyer, <a href='#5_Page_91'>91</a>.</li> +<li>Froriep, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li> +<li>Fuchs, <a href='#5_Page_47'>47</a>, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>.</li> +<li>Fürbringer, <a href='#5_Page_171'>171</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Galen, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>.</li> +<li>Gardiner, C. F., <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Garnier, <a href='#5_Page_92'>92</a>, <a href='#5_Page_94'>94</a>, <a href='#5_Page_96'>96</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>.</li> +<li>Gautier, A., <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Gautier, T., <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li> +<li>Gellhoen, <a href='#5_Page_140'>140</a>.</li> +<li>Gerhard, A., <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Giles, A., <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>, <a href='#5_Page_212'>212</a>, <a href='#5_Page_214'>214</a>, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Godin, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Goethe, <a href='#5_Page_17'>17</a>, <a href='#5_Page_49'>49</a>.</li> +<li>Goncourt, E. de, <a href='#5_Page_54'>54</a>.</li> +<li>Gopcevic, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>.</li> +<li>Goron, <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>.</li> +<li>Gould, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>, <a href='#5_Page_212'>212</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Gow, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>.</li> +<li>Graaf, de, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Griffiths, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>.</li> +<li>Groos, K., <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>, <a href='#5_Page_201'>201</a>.</li> +<li>Gualino, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>.</li> +<li>Guéniot, <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>.</li> +<li>Guibaut, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>.</li> +<li>Guillereau, <a href='#5_Page_85'>85</a>.</li> +<li>Guinard, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Guttceit, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Hack, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Haddon, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>.</li> +<li>Haig, <a href='#5_Page_169'>169</a>, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Hall, G. Stanley, <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>, <a href='#5_Page_16'>16</a>, <a href='#5_Page_53'>53</a>, <a href='#5_Page_74'>74</a>, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>, <a href='#5_Page_99'>99</a>, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>.</li> +<li>Haller, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Hamilton, A., <a href='#5_Page_9'>9</a>.</li> +<li>Hammond, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>.</li> +<li>Hardy, Thomas, <a href='#5_Page_17'>17</a>.</li> +<li>Hartland, E. S., <a href='#5_Page_61'>61</a>.</li> +<li>Harvey, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>, <a href='#5_Page_165'>165</a>.</li> +<li>Hegar, <a href='#5_Page_198'>198</a>.</li> +<li>Henderson, J., <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li> +<li>Henle, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a>.</li> +<li>Hennig, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Herman, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>.</li> +<li>Herodotus, <a href='#5_Page_80'>80</a>, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +<li>Herrick, <a href='#5_Page_45'>45</a>, <a href='#5_Page_48'>48</a>, <a href='#5_Page_70'>70</a>.</li> +<li>Heusinger, <a href='#5_Page_191'>191</a>.</li> +<li>Hewitt, Graily, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Hippocrates, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>, <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Hirst, <a href='#5_Page_160'>160</a>.</li> +<li>Hislop, J. T., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Hoche, <a href='#5_Page_97'>97</a>.</li> +<li>Horrocks, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Howard, W. L., <a href='#5_Page_77'>77</a>, <a href='#5_Page_97'>97</a>, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Howell, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>.</li> +<li>Howitt, A. W., <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>.</li> +<li>Hrdlicka, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>.</li> +<li>Hughes, C. H., <a href='#5_Page_103'>103</a>, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>.</li> +<li>Hunter, John, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Hunter, William, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Huysmans, <a href='#5_Page_4'>4</a>, <a href='#5_Page_50'>50</a>.</li> +<li>Hyades, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>.</li> +<li>Hyrtl, <a href='#5_Page_116'>116</a>, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>, <a href='#5_Page_140'>140</a>, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.<a name='5_Page_277'></a></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Jacobi, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li> +<li>Jacoby, P., <a href='#5_Page_23'>23</a>, <a href='#5_Page_27'>27</a>.</li> +<li>Jahn, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>.</li> +<li>Janet, <a href='#5_Page_7'>7</a>, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>.</li> +<li>Janke, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li> +<li>Jastreboff, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>.</li> +<li>Jenkyns, J., <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Johnston, G. A., <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Johnston, Sir H. H., <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Jonson, Ben, <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a>.</li> +<li>Juvenal, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Kaltenbach, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Kelly, H., <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Kepler, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Kiernan, J. G., <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>, <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Kisch, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Kleinpaul, <a href='#5_Page_5'>5</a>, <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +<li>Kobelt, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>.</li> +<li>Kocher, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li> +<li>Kohlbrugge, <a href='#5_Page_118'>118</a>.</li> +<li>Kolbein, <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Krafft-Ebing, + <ul><li> <a href='#5_Page_2'>2</a>, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>, <a href='#5_Page_20'>20</a>, <a href='#5_Page_27'>27</a>, <a href='#5_Page_28'>28</a>, <a href='#5_Page_30'>30</a>, <a href='#5_Page_32'>32</a>, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>, <a href='#5_Page_57'>57</a>, <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>, <a href='#5_Page_62'>62</a>,</li> +<li> <a href='#5_Page_64'>64</a>, <a href='#5_Page_71'>71</a>, <a href='#5_Page_72'>72</a>, <a href='#5_Page_75'>75</a>, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>, <a href='#5_Page_78'>78</a>, <a href='#5_Page_90'>90</a>, <a href='#5_Page_92'>92</a>, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>, <a href='#5_Page_105'>105</a>, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Krauss, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Lamb, D. S., <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Landes, L. de, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li> +<li>Lane, <a href='#5_Page_12'>12</a>.</li> +<li>Lasègue, <a href='#5_Page_89'>89</a>, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Laurent, E., <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>, <a href='#5_Page_75'>75</a>.</li> +<li>Lawrence, Sir W., <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li> +<li>Laycock, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>, <a href='#5_Page_199'>199</a>.</li> +<li>Levi, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Licetus, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li> +<li>Liébault, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Liétaud, <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>.</li> +<li>Lipps, <a href='#5_Page_105'>105</a>.</li> +<li>Litzmann, <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Lombroso, <a href='#5_Page_2'>2</a>, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Lorion, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li> +<li>Lortet, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li> +<li>Lucas, J. C., <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>.</li> +<li>Lucretius, <a href='#5_Page_108'>108</a>, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li> +<li>Lunier, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Luschka, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Lusini, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>.</li> +<li>Lydston, <a href='#5_Page_78'>78</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Macdonald, A., <a href='#5_Page_6'>6</a>, <a href='#5_Page_73'>73</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>MacGillicuddy, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li> +<li>McKay, A., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Mackay, W. J. S., <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>.</li> +<li>Mackenzie, J., <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li> +<li>Magnan, <a href='#5_Page_28'>28</a>, <a href='#5_Page_61'>61</a>, <a href='#5_Page_89'>89</a>.</li> +<li>Malebranche, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li> +<li>Mantegazza, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>, <a href='#5_Page_88'>88</a>, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>, <a href='#5_Page_187'>187</a>.</li> +<li>Marandon de Montyel, <a href='#5_Page_17'>17</a>, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li> +<li>Marc, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Marro, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>, <a href='#5_Page_187'>187</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>, <a href='#5_Page_199'>199</a>, <a href='#5_Page_200'>200</a>.</li> +<li>Marshall, H. R., <a href='#5_Page_225'>225</a>.</li> +<li>Martial, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li> +<li>Martin, J. M. H., <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>.</li> +<li>Martineau, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>.</li> +<li>Maschka, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>.</li> +<li>Masterman, <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>.</li> +<li>Matignon, <a href='#5_Page_21'>21</a>, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>.</li> +<li>Mattel, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>McMordie, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Mercier, <a href='#5_Page_62'>62</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>.</li> +<li>Meredith, Ellis, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Middleton, T., <a href='#5_Page_190'>190</a>.</li> +<li>Mirabeau, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>.</li> +<li>Mitchell, Sir A., <a href='#5_Page_218'>218</a>.</li> +<li>Moll, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>, <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>, <a href='#5_Page_30'>30</a>, <a href='#5_Page_31'>31</a>, <a href='#5_Page_64'>64</a>, <a href='#5_Page_78'>78</a>, <a href='#5_Page_79'>79</a>, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>, <a href='#5_Page_90'>90</a>, <a href='#5_Page_93'>93</a>, <a href='#5_Page_95'>95</a>, <a href='#5_Page_105'>105</a>, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Mongeri, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Morache, <a href='#5_Page_22'>22</a>.</li> +<li>Moraglia, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>, <a href='#5_Page_62'>62</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Morris, R. T., <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>.</li> +<li>Morselli, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>.</li> +<li>Motet, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>.</li> +<li>Moulin, J. Mansell, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Müller, J., <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Mundé, P., <a href='#5_Page_132'>132</a>, <a href='#5_Page_162'>162</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Näcke, <a href='#5_Page_85'>85</a>.</li> +<li>Neale, R., <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>.</li> +<li>Neri, <a href='#5_Page_57'>57</a>.</li> +<li>Nicholson, H. O., <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>, <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li> +<li>Nina Rodrigues, <a href='#5_Page_139'>139</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Obici, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>.</li> +<li>Onanoff, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>.</li> +<li>Ottolenghi, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>, <a href='#5_Page_200'>200</a>.</li> +<li>Ovid, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Pacheco, <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li> +<li>Palfyn, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>.</li> +<li>Park, Mungo, <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Papillault, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Pasini, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Paterson, A. R., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Paulini, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>.</li> +<li>Paulus Æginetus, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li> +<li>Pearse, W. H., <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Pearson, Karl, <a href='#5_Page_5'>5</a>.<a name='5_Page_278'></a></li> +<li>Pechuel-Loesche, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li> +<li>Pelanda, <a href='#5_Page_61'>61</a>, <a href='#5_Page_92'>92</a>.</li> +<li>Pennant, <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Penta, <a href='#5_Page_13'>13</a>.</li> +<li>Pfaff, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>.</li> +<li>Pierer, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li> +<li>Pillon, <a href='#5_Page_112'>112</a>.</li> +<li>Pinæus, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Pinard, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Pitre, C., <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li> +<li>Pitres, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>.</li> +<li>Pittard, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>.</li> +<li>Plant, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>.</li> +<li>Plautus, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Pliny, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>.</li> +<li>Ploss, + <ul><li> <a href='#5_Page_23'>23</a>, <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>, <a href='#5_Page_81'>81</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>, <a href='#5_Page_99'>99</a>, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>, </li> +<li> <a href='#5_Page_135'>135</a>, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_150'>150</a>, <a href='#5_Page_204'>204</a>, <a href='#5_Page_214'>214</a>, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Poehl, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Polemon, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li> +<li>Pollux, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>.</li> +<li>Porta, Della, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li> +<li>Power, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>.</li> +<li>Pyle, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>, <a href='#5_Page_212'>212</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Raymond, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>.</li> +<li>Régis, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>.</li> +<li>Régnier, H. de, <a href='#5_Page_49'>49</a>.</li> +<li>Reinach, S., <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li> +<li>Renooz, Céline, <a href='#5_Page_99'>99</a>.</li> +<li>Restif de la Bretonne, <a href='#5_Page_18'>18</a>, <a href='#5_Page_22'>22</a>.</li> +<li>Retterer, E., <a href='#5_Page_117'>117</a>, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>, <a href='#5_Page_144'>144</a>.</li> +<li>Reynolds, A. R., <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>.</li> +<li>Rhys, J., <a href='#5_Page_53'>53</a>.</li> +<li>Ribot, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>.</li> +<li>Riedel, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>.</li> +<li>Rimbaud, <a href='#5_Page_99'>99</a>.</li> +<li>Riolan, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>, <a href='#5_Page_204'>204</a>.</li> +<li>Robinson, Bryan, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_168'>168</a>.</li> +<li>Robinson, Louis, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>.</li> +<li>Rodin, <a href='#5_Page_108'>108</a>.</li> +<li>Roederer, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Roons, R. P., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Rosse, Irving, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>.</li> +<li>Roth, W., <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Rothe, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>.</li> +<li>Roubaud, <a href='#5_Page_28'>28</a>, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>, <a href='#5_Page_187'>187</a>, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>.</li> +<li>Rousseau, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>.</li> +<li>Routh, C. H. F., <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li> +<li>Rufus, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>.</li> +<li>Russell, W., <a href='#5_Page_218'>218</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Sade, de, <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Salmon, W., <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Scherzer, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>.</li> +<li>Schinz, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>.</li> +<li>Schmiedeberg, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Schreiner, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Schrenck-Notzing, <a href='#5_Page_89'>89</a>.</li> +<li>Schurig, + <ul><li> <a href='#5_Page_5'>5</a>, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>, <a href='#5_Page_85'>85</a>, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>,</li> +<li> <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>, <a href='#5_Page_139'>139</a>, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>, <a href='#5_Page_211'>211</a>, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Scott, Colin, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>.</li> +<li>Scripture, E. W., <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>.</li> +<li>Seerley, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>.</li> +<li>Seligmann, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>.</li> +<li>Sellheim, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>.</li> +<li>Shakespeare, <a href='#5_Page_170'>170</a>.</li> +<li>Shattock, <a href='#5_Page_118'>118</a>, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>.</li> +<li>Shufeldt, <a href='#5_Page_45'>45</a>.</li> +<li>Silk, J. F. W., <a href='#5_Page_156'>156</a>.</li> +<li>Simon, H., <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Simpson, Sir J., <a href='#5_Page_7'>7</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li> +<li>Sims, Marion, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li> +<li>Smith, Sir A., <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>.</li> +<li>Smith, Haywood, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>.</li> +<li>Sömmering, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Soranus, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Spigelius, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a>, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>.</li> +<li>Stahl, F. A., <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Stanton, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li> +<li>Stendhal, <a href='#5_Page_9'>9</a>, <a href='#5_Page_12'>12</a>, <a href='#5_Page_107'>107</a>, <a href='#5_Page_112'>112</a>.</li> +<li>Stengel, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li> +<li>Stern, B., <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>, <a href='#5_Page_79'>79</a>, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>.</li> +<li>Stevens, Vaughan, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Stieda, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a>.</li> +<li>Stratz, <a href='#5_Page_21'>21</a>, <a href='#5_Page_22'>22</a>, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>.</li> +<li>Stubbs, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>.</li> +<li>Suidas, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>.</li> +<li>Sukhanoff, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>.</li> +<li>Sullivan, W. C., <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Sutherland, W. D., <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>.</li> +<li>Sutton, Bland, <a href='#5_Page_117'>117</a>, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Swift, <a href='#5_Page_48'>48</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Tarde, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li> +<li>Tardieu, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>, <a href='#5_Page_190'>190</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Tarnier, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Taxil, <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>.</li> +<li>Theocritus, <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Thoinot, <a href='#5_Page_95'>95</a>.</li> +<li>Thompson, W. L., <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li> +<li>Thomson, J., <a href='#5_Page_225'>225</a>.</li> +<li>Tilt, <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Toff, <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Tourdes, G., <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li> +<li>Tridandani, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Trochon, <a href='#5_Page_91'>91</a>.<a name='5_Page_279'></a></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Vahness, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li> +<li>Valentin, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Varigny, H de, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li> +<li>Variot, G., <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Varro, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>.</li> +<li>Vaschide, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>, <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>.</li> +<li>Vatsyayana, <a href='#5_Page_150'>150</a>.</li> +<li>Venette, <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>.</li> +<li>Venturi, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>.</li> +<li>Vesalius, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>.</li> +<li>Vinay, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Vinci, L. da, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>.</li> +<li>Voigt, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>.</li> +<li>Voisin, J., <a href='#5_Page_198'>198</a>.</li> +<li>Vurpas, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>, <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Wagner, R., <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Waldeyer, <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>.</li> +<li>Walker, G., <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Wallace, A. W., <a href='#5_Page_224'>224</a>.</li> +<li>Warton, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>.</li> +<li>Wasserschleben, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Weininger, O., <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Wellhausen, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +<li>Werner, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>.</li> +<li>Wernich, <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a>.</li> +<li>West, J. P., <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li> +<li>Wharton, <a href='#5_Page_171'>171</a>.</li> +<li>Wilhelm, Eugen, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>.</li> +<li>Wilkin, G., <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Wilkinson, A. D., <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a>.</li> +<li>Williams, J. W. Whitridge, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Williamson, C. F., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Wolff, B., <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Wollstonecraft, Mary, <a href='#5_Page_9'>9</a>.</li> +<li>Wordsworth, <a href='#5_Page_49'>49</a>.</li> +<li>Wychgel, <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Youatt, <a href='#5_Page_85'>85</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Zaborsky, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Zoppi, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>.</li> +<li>Zimmer, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>.</li> +<li>Zola, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<a name='5_Page_280'></a> + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_INDEX_OF_SUBJECTS'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_281'></a>INDEX OF SUBJECTS.</h2> + + +<ul><li>Abyssinians, + <ul><li>coitus among, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Acquired element in erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_28'>28</a>.</li> +<li>Acromegaly and sexual development, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Alcohol, + <ul><li>aphrodisiac effects of, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Algolagnia, + <ul><li>in relation to scatologic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>;</li> +<li> as a form of erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Anæsthesia, + <ul><li>sexual, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Anæsthetics in relation to sexual excitement, <a href='#5_Page_156'>156</a>.</li> +<li>Anaphrodisiacs, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Animal copulation, + <ul><li>attraction of, <a href='#5_Page_72'>72</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Animals, + <ul><li>detumescence in, <a href='#5_Page_158'>158</a>, <a href='#5_Page_160'>160</a>, <a href='#5_Page_168'>168</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Annamites, + <ul><li>coitus among, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Antipathies of pregnant women, <a href='#5_Page_212'>212</a>.</li> +<li>Anus in relation to pubic hair, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>; + <ul><li>as an erogenous zone, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Apes, + <ul><li>sexual organs of, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>, <a href='#5_Page_165'>165</a>;</li> +<li> sexual congress in, <a href='#5_Page_144'>144</a>, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Aphrodisiacs, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Apples, + <ul><li>longings of women for, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Arabs, + <ul><li>penis in, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Artist, + <ul><li>compared to lover, <a href='#5_Page_108'>108</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Associations of contiguity and resemblance in erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>.</li> +<li>Australian method of sexual congress, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li> +<li>Auto-suggestions, + <ul><li>longings of pregnancy as, <a href='#5_Page_213'>213</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Bartholin, + <ul><li>glands of, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Beard in relation to sexual development, <a href='#5_Page_197'>197</a>.</li> +<li>Beauty, + <ul><li>the objective element in, <a href='#5_Page_107'>107</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Bestiality, <a href='#5_Page_77'>77</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Bladder in relation to sexual excitement, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li> +<li>Blood during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li> +<li>Blood-pressure during detumescence, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>, <a href='#5_Page_169'>169</a>.</li> +<li>Breasts, + <ul><li>and erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_188'>188</a>;</li> +<li> during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Bromide as an anaphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Bulbo-cavernous reflex, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>, <a href='#5_Page_157'>157</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Camphor as an anaphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Cantharides, + <ul><li>effects of, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Castration, + <ul><li>results of, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Celery as an aphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Children, + <ul><li>attracted to foot, <a href='#5_Page_16'>16</a>;</li> +<li> to scatology, <a href='#5_Page_53'>53</a>;</li> +<li> to copulation of animals, <a href='#5_Page_72'>72</a>;</li> +<li> to hair, <a href='#5_Page_74'>74</a>;</li> +<li> food impulses of, <a href='#5_Page_215'>215</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Chinese, + <ul><li>foot-fetichism of, <a href='#5_Page_21'>21</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Circulatory conditions during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>; + <ul><li>during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Clitoris, <a href='#5_Page_118'>118</a>, <a href='#5_Page_121'>121</a>, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>.</li> +<li>Clothes, + <ul><li>erotic fascination of, <a href='#5_Page_45'>45</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Coitus, + <ul><li>the phenomena of, <a href='#5_Page_111'>111</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> the methods of, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> ethnic variations in methods of, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>;</li> +<li> respiratory and circulatory conditions during, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>;</li> +<li> interruptus as a cause of vasomotor disturbance, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>, <a href='#5_Page_178'>178</a>;</li> +<li> glandular activity during, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>;</li> +<li> motor activity during, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> psychic state during, <a href='#5_Page_157'>157</a>;</li> +<li> serious effects of, <a href='#5_Page_168'>168</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Congenital element in erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_27'>27</a>.</li> +<li>Contiguity in erotic symbolism, + <ul><li>associations of, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Coprolagnia, <a href='#5_Page_47'>47</a>, <a href='#5_Page_62'>62</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Coprophagia, + <ul><li>religious and sexual, <a href='#5_Page_57'>57</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Courtship, <a href='#5_Page_142'>142</a>.</li> +<li>Crystallization, + <ul><li>Stendhal's, <a href='#5_Page_9'>9</a>, <a href='#5_Page_107'>107</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Defile, + <ul><li>the impulse to, <a href='#5_Page_95'>95</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Distillatio, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>.</li> +<li>Dog, + <ul><li>human sexual intercourse with, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Dynamometric experiments during sexual excitement, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>.<a name='5_Page_282'></a></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Ejaculation, the mechanism of, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>.</li> +<li>Embryo, <a href='#5_Page_117'>117</a>.</li> +<li>Epilepsy and exhibitionism, <a href='#5_Page_91'>91</a>, <a href='#5_Page_103'>103</a>; + <ul><li>compared to coitus, <a href='#5_Page_150'>150</a>;</li> +<li> as a result of coitus, <a href='#5_Page_169'>169</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Erectility during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_144'>144</a>.</li> +<li>Erogenous zone, + <ul><li>anus as, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>;</li> +<li> lips as, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>, <a href='#5_Page_202'>202</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Erotic intoxication, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li> +<li>Erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_182'>182</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Eryngo as an aphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Ethnic variations in coitus, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_150'>150</a>, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li> +<li>Etruscans, + <ul><li>sexual significance of foot among, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Eunuchs, + <ul><li>characteristics of, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Exercise on sexual organs, + <ul><li>influence of, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Exhibitionism, <a href='#5_Page_89'>89</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Eyes during detumescence, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>; + <ul><li>in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>;</li> +<li> darker at puberty, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Face during detumescence, + <ul><li>expression of, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Fæces as a drug, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>.</li> +<li>Fecundation, + <ul><li>the phenomena of, <a href='#5_Page_117'>117</a>;</li> +<li> artificial, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Feet as a sexual symbol, + <ul><li>uncovering, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Fellatio, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Fetichism, + <ul><li>erotic, <a href='#5_Page_2'>2</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Flagellation, <a href='#5_Page_64'>64</a>, <a href='#5_Page_94'>94</a>, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li> +<li>Foot-fetichism, + <ul><li><i>see</i> Shoe-fetichism.</li></ul></li> +<li>Fuegians, + <ul><li>penis in, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Fur as a fetich, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Garments as fetiches, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>, <a href='#5_Page_74'>74</a></li> +<li>Genital organs as fetiches, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>.</li> +<li>Goat as a human sexual fetich, <a href='#5_Page_80'>80</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>.</li> +<li>Greeks, + <ul><li>sexual significance of foot among, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Hair as a fetich, <a href='#5_Page_74'>74</a>; + <ul><li>despoilers of, <a href='#5_Page_75'>75</a>;</li> +<li> pubic, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> darkens at puberty, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> in pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Hand as fetich, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>.</li> +<li>Heart during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li> +<li>Homosexuality as a form of erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_2'>2</a>.</li> +<li>Hottentot apron, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a>.</li> +<li>Hymen, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_162'>162</a>.</li> +<li>Hyperæsthesia, sexual, <a href='#5_Page_6'>6</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Hypertrichosis universalis, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Hysteria, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Ideal coprolagnia, <a href='#5_Page_64'>64</a>.</li> +<li>Idiocy as result of maternal impressions, <a href='#5_Page_218'>218</a>, <a href='#5_Page_224'>224</a>.</li> +<li>Idiots, + <ul><li>sexual development of, <a href='#5_Page_198'>198</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Impregnation without rupture of hymen, <a href='#5_Page_162'>162</a>; + <ul><li>without conjunctions, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>;</li> +<li> artificial, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Impressions, + <ul><li>maternal, <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Intellectual work, + <ul><li>relation of pregnancy to, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Intoxication, + <ul><li>erotic, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Japanese, + <ul><li>labia majora in, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Joy, + <ul><li>the expression of, <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Kiss, the, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>.</li> +<li>Kleptomania and pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Knee-jerk in pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Labia majora, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Labia minora, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Larynx in relation to sexual state, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li> +<li>Linea fusca, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Lips, + <ul><li>as an erogenous zone, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>, <a href='#5_Page_202'>202</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_190'>190</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Longings of pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>; + <ul><li>theories of, <a href='#5_Page_212'>212</a>;</li> +<li> as auto-suggestions, <a href='#5_Page_213'>213</a>;</li> +<li> physiological basis of, <a href='#5_Page_214'>214</a>;</li> +<li> relation to the longings of childhood, <a href='#5_Page_215'>215</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Masochism, + <ul><li>in relation to shoe-fetichism, <a href='#5_Page_31'>31</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to scatalogic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to exhibitionism of nates, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>;</li> +<li> as a form of erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Masturbation and pubic hair, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>; + <ul><li>hypertrophy of clitoris ascribed to, <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>;</li> +<li> part played by clitoris in, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>;</li> +<li> why some theologians permitted, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>;</li> +<li> phenomena during, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Maternal element in sexual love, <a href='#5_Page_201'>201</a>.</li> +<li>Maternal impressions, <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a> <i>et seq.</i><a name='5_Page_283'></a></li> +<li>Menstruation in relation to coitus, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>; + <ul><li>metabolism during, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to sickness of pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>;</li> +<li> compared to pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Mental state during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Metabolism during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Mixoscopic zoophilia, <a href='#5_Page_71'>71</a>.</li> +<li>Modesty a supposed sign of virginity, <a href='#5_Page_204'>204</a>.</li> +<li>Mohammedan method of sexual congress, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li> +<li>Mole as a fetich, <a href='#5_Page_12'>12</a>.</li> +<li>Mongol peoples, + <ul><li>foot fetichism among various, <a href='#5_Page_23'>23</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Mons veneris, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>.</li> +<li>Mordvins, + <ul><li>foot-fetichism among, <a href='#5_Page_23'>23</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Motor activity during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Mouth in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_191'>191</a>.</li> +<li>Muscular movements during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Nates in relation to coprolagnia, <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>; + <ul><li>in relation to exhibitionism, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Necrophilia, <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>, <a href='#5_Page_81'>81</a>.</li> +<li>Negative fetich, <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>.</li> +<li>Negro, + <ul><li>penis in, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>;</li> +<li> labia majora in, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>;</li> +<li> clitoris in, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>;</li> +<li> labia minora in, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a>;</li> +<li> method of sexual congress among, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Nervous system during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Neurasthenia cordis vasomotoria, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>.</li> +<li>Nipples, + <ul><li>pigmentation of, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Nudity, + <ul><li>religious, <a href='#5_Page_99'>99</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Nutrition, + <ul><li>symbolism of, <a href='#5_Page_7'>7</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Nymphæ, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Nymphomania, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Obsessions of scruple, <a href='#5_Page_7'>7</a>; + <ul><li>longings of pregnancy as, <a href='#5_Page_211'>211</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Obsessional exhibitionism, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>.</li> +<li>Odor an alleged sign of defloration, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li> +<li>Onion as an aphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Opium as an aphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>.</li> +<li>Organs, + <ul><li>sexual, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Ova and spermatozoa, + <ul><li>union of, <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Ovarian extract, effects of, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Ovaries, + <ul><li>function of, <a href='#5_Page_181'>181</a>;</li> +<li> analogy of with thyroid, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Paidophilia, <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>, <a href='#5_Page_13'>13</a>.</li> +<li>Pain and erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li> +<li>Pedicatio, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li> +<li>Pelvic development and erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Pelvic floor, variability of, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>.</li> +<li>Pelvic inclination, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>.</li> +<li>Penis, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>, <a href='#5_Page_121'>121</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>.</li> +<li>Penis-fetichism, <a href='#5_Page_96'>96</a>.</li> +<li>Phallic worship, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>.</li> +<li>Physiognomists and the erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_182'>182</a>.</li> +<li>Pica, <a href='#5_Page_211'>211</a>.</li> +<li>Pigmentation in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_191'>191</a>; + <ul><li>in pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Potatoes, + <ul><li>the supposed aphrodisiac effects of, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Precocity, + <ul><li>influence of, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Pregnancy and pigmentation, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>; + <ul><li>psychic state in, <a href='#5_Page_201'>201</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> sexual desire during, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>;</li> +<li> relation of to intellectual work, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Presbyophilia, <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>.</li> +<li>Prostate, <a href='#5_Page_171'>171</a>.</li> +<li>Prostitutes, + <ul><li>external genitals of, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>;</li> +<li> stature of, <a href='#5_Page_187'>187</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Psychic exhibitionism, <a href='#5_Page_94'>94</a>.</li> +<li>Psychic condition during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_157'>157</a>.</li> +<li>Puberty, + <ul><li>the phenomena of, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>;</li> +<li> pigmentary changes at, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Pubic hair, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a> <i>et seq.</i>; <a href='#5_Page_204'>204</a>.</li> +<li>Puericulture, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Pygmalionism, <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>, <a href='#5_Page_12'>12</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Quadrupedal method of coitus in man, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Rachitic, + <ul><li>sexual tendencies of the, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Reflex, bulbo-cavernous, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>.</li> +<li>Reflexes during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Religious scatalogic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_57'>57</a>.</li> +<li>Resemblance in erotic symbolism, + <ul><li>associations of, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Respiration during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>.</li> +<li>Responsibility of pregnant women, <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a>.<a name='5_Page_284'></a></li> +<li>Restif de la Bretonne's shoe-fetichism, <a href='#5_Page_18'>18</a>.</li> +<li>Romans, + <ul><li>sexual significance of foot among, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>;</li> +<li> methods of coitus among, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Rousseau, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>.</li> +<li>Rue as an anaphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Sadism, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li> +<li>Saint compared to lover, <a href='#5_Page_109'>109</a>.</li> +<li>Salivation during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>.</li> +<li>Satyriasis, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>.</li> +<li>Scatalogic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_47'>47</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Scrotum, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>.</li> +<li>Scruple, obsessions of, <a href='#5_Page_7'>7</a>.</li> +<li>Secretions of genital canal, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>.</li> +<li>Semen, + <ul><li>alleged female, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>;</li> +<li> in coitus, <a href='#5_Page_157'>157</a>;</li> +<li> in female genital canal, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>;</li> +<li> vital activity of, <a href='#5_Page_165'>165</a>;</li> +<li> artificial injection of, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>;</li> +<li> constituents of, <a href='#5_Page_171'>171</a>;</li> +<li> as a stimulant, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Sexual anæsthesia, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Sexual conjugation, <a href='#5_Page_116'>116</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Sexual desire during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Sexual organs, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Sexual selection in relation to erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>; + <ul><li>in relation to external sexual organs, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>;</li> +<li> the probable cause of the hymen, <a href='#5_Page_140'>140</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Shadow as a fetich, <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>.</li> +<li>Shoe, + <ul><li>sexual significance of, <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Shoe-fetichism frequency of, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>; + <ul><li>normal basis of, <a href='#5_Page_16'>16</a>, <a href='#5_Page_27'>27</a>;</li> +<li> illustrated by Restif de la Bretonne, <a href='#5_Page_18'>18</a>;</li> +<li> prevalence of among Chinese, etc., <a href='#5_Page_21'>21</a>;</li> +<li> former prevalence in Europe, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>;</li> +<li> congenital basis of, <a href='#5_Page_27'>27</a>;</li> +<li> acquired element in, <a href='#5_Page_28'>28</a>;</li> +<li> favored by precocity, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>;</li> +<li> relation to masochism, <a href='#5_Page_30'>30</a>;</li> +<li> illustrative cases of, <a href='#5_Page_33'>33</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> dynamic element in, <a href='#5_Page_45'>45</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Sickness of pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Skin, + <ul><li>sexual significance of, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>;</li> +<li> condition of during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_144'>144</a>, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_190'>190</a>;</li> +<li> sexual pigmentation of, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Slipper as a sexual symbol, <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>.</li> +<li>Smile, + <ul><li>origin of the, <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Sodomy, + <ul><li>the term, <a href='#5_Page_72'>72</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Spain, + <ul><li>sexual attractiveness of foot in, <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Spermatozoa reach ova, + <ul><li>how the, <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_171'>171</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Spermin, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Sphygmanometer experiments during sexual excitement, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>.</li> +<li>Stature and erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_187'>187</a>.</li> +<li>Stimulants, <a href='#5_Page_178'>178</a>.</li> +<li>Stuff-fetichisms, <a href='#5_Page_73'>73</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Strychnine, + <ul><li>aphrodisiac effects of, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Suggestion in relation to longings of pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_214'>214</a>.</li> +<li>Symbols, + <ul><li>nature of, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>;</li> +<li> of sex in language, <a href='#5_Page_4'>4</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Temperament, + <ul><li>alleged erotic, <a href='#5_Page_182'>182</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Testicular juices, + <ul><li>effects of, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Testes, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>, <a href='#5_Page_181'>181</a>, <a href='#5_Page_197'>197</a>.</li> +<li>Thyroid, + <ul><li>condition during sexual excitement, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>;</li> +<li> during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Ticklishness in relation to stuff-fetichisms, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>.</li> +<li>Tumescence in relation to detumescence, <a href='#5_Page_115'>115</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_142'>142</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Unnatural offence, + <ul><li>the term, <a href='#5_Page_72'>72</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Urethra, + <ul><li>variability of female, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>;</li> +<li> an erogenous zone, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Urethrorrhœa ex libidine, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>.</li> +<li>Urinary stream, + <ul><li>in relation to nymphæ, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>;</li> +<li> an alleged index to virginity, <a href='#5_Page_204'>204</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Urine in religious rites, <a href='#5_Page_50'>50</a>; + <ul><li>possesses magical virtues, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>;</li> +<li> in legends, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>;</li> +<li> in medicine, <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>;</li> +<li> during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Urolagnia, <a href='#5_Page_47'>47</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Uterus, <a href='#5_Page_118'>118</a>, <a href='#5_Page_132'>132</a>, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>, <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Vagina, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Vaginismus, <a href='#5_Page_13'>13</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li> +<li>Vasomotor conditions during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>.</li> +<li>Vaudonism, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>.</li> +<li>Virginity, + <ul><li>ancient diagnosis of, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Virile reflex, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>.<a name='5_Page_285'></a></li> +<li>Voice, + <ul><li>in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_188'>188</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to virginity, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Vomiting of pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Vulva, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a> <i>et seq.</i> <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li> +<li>Vulva-fetichism, <a href='#5_Page_96'>96</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Waist, + <ul><li>origin of admiration for small, <a href='#5_Page_21'>21</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Yohimbin as an aphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Zooerastia, <a href='#5_Page_77'>77</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Zoophilia erotica, <a href='#5_Page_71'>71</a>, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>.</li> +<li>Zoophilia non-erotic, <a href='#5_Page_77'>77</a>.</li> +</ul> +<br> +<br> +<div>*** END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK 13614 ***</div> +</body> +</html> diff --git a/LICENSE.txt b/LICENSE.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6312041 --- /dev/null +++ b/LICENSE.txt @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +This eBook, including all associated images, markup, improvements, +metadata, and any other content or labor, has been confirmed to be +in the PUBLIC DOMAIN IN THE UNITED STATES. + +Procedures for determining public domain status are described in +the "Copyright How-To" at https://www.gutenberg.org. + +No investigation has been made concerning possible copyrights in +jurisdictions other than the United States. Anyone seeking to utilize +this eBook outside of the United States should confirm copyright +status under the laws that apply to them. diff --git a/README.md b/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..526b47e --- /dev/null +++ b/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +Project Gutenberg (https://www.gutenberg.org) public repository for +eBook #13614 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/13614) diff --git a/old/13614-8.txt b/old/13614-8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b09976b --- /dev/null +++ b/old/13614-8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,13500 @@ +The Project Gutenberg eBook, Studies in the Psychology of Sex, Volume 5 +(of 6), by Havelock Ellis + + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + + + + +Title: Studies in the Psychology of Sex, Volume 5 (of 6) + +Author: Havelock Ellis + +Release Date: October 8, 2004 [eBook #13614] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 + + +***START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK STUDIES IN THE PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX, +VOLUME 5 (OF 6)*** + + +E-text prepared by Juliet Sutherland and the Project Gutenberg Online +Distributed Proofreading Team (https://www.pgdp.net) + + + +STUDIES IN THE PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX, VOLUME V + + Erotic Symbolism + The Mechanism of Detumescence + The Psychic State in Pregnancy + +by + +HAVELOCK ELLIS + +1927 + + + + + + + +PREFACE. + + +In this volume the terminal phenomena of the sexual process are discussed, +before an attempt is finally made, in the concluding volume, to consider +the bearings of the psychology of sex on that part of morals which may be +called "social hygiene." + +Under "Erotic Symbolism" I include practically all the aberrations of the +sexual instinct, although some of these have seemed of sufficient +importance for separate discussion in previous volumes. It is highly +probable that many readers will consider that the name scarcely suffices +to cover manifestations so numerous and so varied. The term "sexual +equivalents" will seem preferable to some. While, however, it may be fully +admitted that these perversions are "sexual equivalents"--or at all events +equivalents of the normal sexual impulse--that term is merely a +descriptive label which tells us nothing of the phenomena. "Sexual +Symbolism" gives us the key to the process, the key that makes all these +perversions intelligible. In all of them--very clearly in some, as in +shoe-fetichism; more obscurely in others, as in exhibitionism--it has come +about by causes congenital, acquired, or both, that some object or class +of objects, some act or group of acts, has acquired a dynamic power over +the psycho-physical mechanism of the sexual process, deflecting it from +its normal adjustment to the whole of a beloved person of the opposite +sex. There has been a transmutation of values, and certain objects, +certain acts, have acquired an emotional value which for the normal person +they do not possess. Such objects and acts are properly, it seems to me, +termed symbols, and that term embodies the only justification that in most +cases these manifestations can legitimately claim. + +"The Mechanism of Detumescence" brings us at last to the final climax for +which the earlier and more prolonged stage of tumescence, which has +occupied us so often in these _Studies_, is the elaborate preliminary. +"The art of love," a clever woman novelist has written, "is the art of +preparation." That "preparation" is, on the physiological side, the +production of tumescence, and all courtship is concerned in building up +tumescence. But the final conjugation of two individuals in an explosion +of detumescence, thus slowly brought about, though it is largely an +involuntary act, is still not without its psychological implications and +consequences; and it is therefore a matter for regret that so little is +yet known about it. The one physiological act in which two individuals are +lifted out of all ends that center in self and become the instrument of +those higher forces which fashion the species, can never be an act to be +slurred over as trivial or unworthy of study. + +In the brief study of "The Psychic State in Pregnancy" we at last touch +the point at which the whole complex process of sex reaches its goal. A +woman with a child in her womb is the everlasting miracle which all the +romance of love, all the cunning devices of tumescence and detumescence, +have been invented to make manifest. The psychic state of the woman who +thus occupies the supreme position which life has to offer cannot fail to +be of exceeding interest from many points of view, and not least because +the maternal instinct is one of the elements even of love between the +sexes. But the psychology of pregnancy is full of involved problems, and +here again, as so often in the wide field we have traversed, we stand at +the threshold of a door it is not yet given us to pass. + +HAVELOCK ELLIS. + +Carbis Water, Lelant, Cornwall. + + + + +CONTENTS. + + +EROTIC SYMBOLISM. + +I. + +The Definition of Erotic Symbolism. Symbolism of Act and Symbolism of +Object. Erotic Fetichism. Wide Extension of the Symbols of Sex. The +Immense Variety of Possible Erotic Fetiches. The Normal Foundations of +Erotic Symbolism. Classification of the Phenomena. The Tendency to +Idealize the Defects of a Beloved Person. Stendhal's "Crystallization". + +II. + +Foot-fetichism and Shoe-fetichism. Wide Prevalence and Normal Basis. +Restif de la Bretonne. The Foot a Normal Focus of Sexual Attraction Among +Some Peoples. The Chinese, Greeks, Romans, Spaniards, etc. The Congenital +Predisposition in Erotic Symbolism. The Influence of Early Association and +Emotional Shock. Shoe-fetichism in Relation to Masochism. The Two +Phenomena Independent Though Allied. The Desire to be Trodden On. The +Fascination of Physical Constraint. The Symbolism of Self-inflicted Pain. +The Dynamic Element in Erotic Symbolism. The Symbolism of Garments. + +III. + +Scatalogic Symbolism. Urolagnia. Coprolagnia. The Ascetic Attitude Towards +the Flesh. Normal Basis of Scatalogic Symbolism. Scatalogic Conceptions +Among Primitive Peoples. Urine as a Primitive Holy Water. Sacredness of +Animal Excreta. Scatalogy in Folk-lore. The Obscene as Derived from the +Mythological. The Immature Sexual Impulse Tends to Manifest Itself in +Scatalogic Forms. The Basis of Physiological Connection Between the +Urinary and Genital Spheres. Urinary Fetichism Sometimes Normal in +Animals. The Urolagnia of Masochists. The Scatalogy of Saints. Urolagnia +More Often a Symbolism of Act Than a Symbolism of Object. Only +Occasionally an Olfactory Fetichism. Comparative Rarity of Coprolagnia. +Influence of Nates Fetichism as a Transition to Coprolagnia, Ideal +Coprolagnia. Olfactory Coprolagnia. Urolagnia and Coprolagnia as Symbols +of Coitus. + +IV. + +Animals as Sources of Erotic Symbolism. Mixoscopic Zoophilia. The +Stuff-fetichisms. Hair-fetichism. The Stuff-fetichisms Mainly on a Tactile +Base. Erotic Zoophilia. Zooerastia. Bestiality. The Conditions that Favor +Bestiality. Its Wide Prevalence Among Primitive Peoples and Among +Peasants. The Primitive Conception of Animals. The Goat. The Influence of +Familiarity With Animals. Congress Between Women and Animals. The Social +Reaction Against Bestiality. + +V. + +Exhibitionism. Illustrative Cases. A Symbolic Perversion of Courtship. The +Impulse to Defile. The Exhibitionist's Psychic Attitude. The Sexual Organs +as Fetiches. Phallus Worship. Adolescent Pride in Sexual Development. +Exhibitionism of the Nates. The Classification of the Forms of +Exhibitionism. Nature of the Relationship of Exhibitionism to Epilepsy. + +VI. + +The Forms of Erotic Symbolism are Simulacra of Coitus. Wide Extension of +Erotic Symbolism. Fetichism Not Covering the Whole Ground of Sexual +Selection. It is Based on the Individual Factor in Selection. +Crystallization. The Lover and the Artist. The Key to Erotic Symbolism is +to be Found in the Emotional Sphere. The Passage to Pathological Extremes. + + + +THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE. + +I. + +The Psychological Significance of Detumescence. The Testis and the Ovary. +Sperm Cell and Germ Cell. Development of the Embryo. The External Sexual +Organs. Their Wide Range of Variation. Their Nervous Supply. The Penis. +Its Racial Variations. The Influence of Exercise. The Scrotum and +Testicles. The Mons Veneris. The Vulva. The Labia Majora and their +Varieties. The Public Hair and Its Characters. The Clitoris and Its +Functions. The Anus as an Erogenous Zone. The Nymphæ and their Function. +The Vagina. The Hymen. Virginity. The Biological Significance of the +Hymen. + +II. + +The Object of Detumescence. Erogenous Zones. The Lips. The Vascular +Characters of Detumescence. Erectile Tissue. Erection in Woman. Mucous +Emission in Women. Sexual Connection. The Human Mode of Intercourse. +Normal Variations. The Motor Characters of Detumescence. Ejaculation. The +Virile Reflex. The General Phenomena of Detumescence. The Circulatory and +Respiratory Phenomena. Blood Pressure. Cardiac Disturbance. Glandular +Activity. Distillatio. The Essentially Motor Character of Detumescence. +Involuntary Muscular Irradiation to Bladder, etc. Erotic Intoxication. +Analogy of Sexual Detumescence and Vesical Tension. The Specifically +Sexual Movements of Detumescence in Man. In Woman. The Spontaneous +Movements of the Genital Canal in Woman. Their Function in Conception. +Part Played by Active Movement of the Spermatozoa. The Artificial +Injection of Semen. The Facial Expression During Detumescence. The +Expression of Joy. The Occasional Serious Effects of Coitus. + +III. + +The Constituents of Semen. Function of the Prostate. The Properties of +Semen. Aphrodisiacs. Alcohol, Opium, etc. Anaphrodisiacs. The Stimulant +Influence of Semen in Coitus. The Internal Effects of Testicular +Secretions. The Influence of Ovarian Secretion. + +IV. + +The Aptitude for Detumescence. Is There an Erotic Temperament? The +Available Standards of Comparison. Characteristics of the Castrated. +Characteristics of Puberty. Characteristics of the State of Detumescence. +Shortness of Stature. Development of the Secondary Sexual Characters. Deep +Voice. Bright Eyes. Glandular Activity. Everted Lips. Pigmentation. +Profuse Hair. Dubious Significance of Many of These Characters. + + +THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY. + +The Relationship of Maternal and Sexual Emotion. Conception and Loss of +Virginity. The Anciently Accepted Signs of This Condition. The Pervading +Effects of Pregnancy on the Organism. Pigmentation. The Blood and +Circulation. The Thyroid. Changes in the Nervous System. The Vomiting of +Pregnancy. The Longings of Pregnant Women. Mental Impressions. Evidence +for and Against Their Validity. The Question Still Open. Imperfection of +Our Knowledge. The Significance of Pregnancy. + + +APPENDIX. + +Histories of Sexual Development. + + +INDEX OF AUTHORS. + + +INDEX OF SUBJECTS. + + + + +EROTIC SYMBOLISM. + +I. + +The Definition of Erotic Symbolism--Symbolism of Act and Symbolism of +Object--Erotic Fetichism--Wide extension of the symbols of Sex--The +Immense Variety of Possible Erotic Fetiches--The Normal Foundations of +Erotic Symbolism--Classification of the Phenomena--The Tendency to +Idealize the Defects of a Beloved Person--Stendhal's "Crystallization." + + +By "erotic symbolism" I mean that tendency whereby the lover's attention +is diverted from the central focus of sexual attraction to some object or +process which is on the periphery of that focus, or is even outside of it +altogether, though recalling it by association of contiguity or of +similarity. It thus happens that tumescence, or even in extreme cases +detumescence, may be provoked by the contemplation of acts or objects +which are away from the end of sexual conjugation.[1] + +In considering the phenomena of sexual selection in a previous volume,[2] +it was found that there are four or five main factors in the constitution +of beauty in so far as beauty determines sexual selection. Erotic +symbolism is founded on the factor of individual taste in beauty; it +arises as a specialized development of that factor, but it is, +nevertheless, incorrect to merge it in sexual selection. The attractive +characteristics of a beloved woman or man, from the point of view of +sexual selection, are a complex but harmonious whole leading up to a +desire for the complete possession of the person who displays them. There +is no tendency to isolate and dissociate any single character from the +individual and to concentrate attention upon that character at the expense +of the attention bestowed upon the individual generally. As soon as such a +tendency begins to show itself, even though only in a slight or temporary +form, we may say that there is erotic symbolism. + +Erotic symbolism is, however, by no means confined to the individualizing +tendency to concentrate amorous attention upon some single characteristic +of the adult woman or man who is normally the object of sexual love. The +adult human being may not be concerned at all, the attractive object or +act may not even be human, not even animal, and we may still be concerned +with a symbol which has parasitically rooted itself on the fruitful site +of sexual emotion and absorbed to itself the energy which normally goes +into the channels of healthy human love having for its final end the +procreation of the species. Thus understood in its widest sense, it may be +said that every sexual perversion, even homosexuality, is a form of erotic +symbolism, for we shall find that in every case some object or act that +for the normal human being has little or no erotic value, has assumed such +value in a supreme degree; that is to say, it has become a symbol of the +normal object of love. Certain perversions are, however, of such great +importance on account of their wide relationships, that they cannot be +adequately discussed merely as forms of erotic symbolism. This is notably +the case as regards homosexuality, auto-erotism, and algolagnia, all of +which phenomena have therefore been separately discussed in previous +studies. We are now mainly concerned with manifestations which are more +narrowly and exclusively symbolical. + +A portion of the field of erotic symbolism is covered by what Binet +(followed by Lombroso, Krafft-Ebing, and others) has termed "erotic +fetichism," or the tendency whereby sexual attraction is unduly exerted by +some special part or peculiarity of the body, or by some inanimate object +which has become associated with it. Such erotic symbolism of object +cannot, however, be dissociated from the even more important erotic +symbolism of process, and the two are so closely bound together that we +cannot attain a truly scientific view of them until we regard them broadly +as related parts of a common psychic tendency. If, as Groos asserts,[3] a +symbol has two chief meanings, one in which it indicates a physical +process which stands for a psychic process, and another in which it +indicates a part which represents the whole, erotic symbolism of act +corresponds to the first of these chief meanings, and erotic symbolism of +object to the other. + +Although it is not impossible to find some germs of erotic symbolism in +animals, in its more pronounced manifestations it is only found in the +human species. It could not be otherwise, for such symbolism involves not +only the play of fancy and imagination, the idealizing aptitude, but also +a certain amount of power of concentrating the attention on a point +outside the natural path of instinct and the ability to form new mental +constructions around that point. There are, indeed, as we shall see, +elementary forms of erotic symbolism which are not uncommonly associated +with feeble-mindedness, but even these are still peculiarly human, and in +its less crude manifestations erotic symbolism easily lends itself to +every degree of human refinement and intelligence. + + "It depends primarily upon an increase of the psychological + process of representation," Colin Scott remarks of sexual + symbolism generally, "involving greater powers of comparison and + analysis as compared with the lower animals. The outer + impressions come to be clearly distinguished as such, but at the + same time are often treated as symbols of inner experiences, and + a meaning read into them which they would not otherwise possess. + Symbolism or fetichism is, indeed, just the capacity to see + meaning, to emphasize something for the sake of other things + which do not appear. In brain terms it indicates an activity of + the higher centers, a sort of side-tracking or long-circuiting of + the primitive energy; ... Rosetti's poem, 'The Woodspurge,' + gives a concrete example of the formation of such a symbol. Here + the otherwise insignificant presentation of the three-cupped + woodspurge, representing originally a mere side-current of the + stream of consciousness, becomes the intellectual symbol or + fetich of the whole psychosis forever after. It seems, indeed, as + if the stronger the emotion the more likely will become the + formation of an overlying symbolism, which serves to focus and + stand in the place of something greater than itself; nowhere at + least is symbolism a more characteristic feature than as an + expression of the sexual instinct. The passion of sex, with its + immense hereditary background, in early man became centered often + upon the most trivial and unimportant features.... This + symbolism, now become fetichistic, or symbolic in a bad sense, is + at least an exercise of the increasing representative power of + man, upon which so much of his advancement has depended, while it + also served to express and help to purify his most perennial + emotion." (Colin Scott, "Sex and Art," _American Journal of + Psychology_, vol. vii, No. 2, p. 189.) + +In the study of "Love and Pain" in a previous volume, the analysis of the +large and complex mass of sexual phenomena which are associated with pain, +gradually resolved them to a considerable extent into a special case of +erotic symbolism; pain or restraint, whether inflicted on or by the loved +person, becomes, by a psychic process that is usually unconscious, the +symbol of the sexual mechanism, and hence arouses the same emotions as +that mechanism normally arouses. We may now attempt to deal more broadly +and comprehensively with the normal and abnormal aspects of erotic +symbolism in some of their most typical and least mixed forms. + +"When our human imagination seeks to animate artificial things," Huysmans +writes in _Là-bas_, "it is compelled to reproduce the movements of animals +in the act of propagation. Look at machines, at the play of pistons in the +cylinders; they are Romeos of steel in Juliets of cast-iron." And not only +in the work of man's hands but throughout Nature we find sexual symbols +which are the less deniable since, for the most part, they make not the +slightest appeal to even the most morbid human imagination. Language is +full of metaphorical symbols of sex which constantly tend to lose their +poetic symbolism and to become commonplace. Semen is but seed, and for the +Latins especially the whole process of human sex, as well as the male and +female organs, constantly presented itself in symbols derived from +agricultural and horticultural life. The testicles were beans (_fabæ_) and +fruit or apples (_poma_ and _mala_); the penis was a tree (_arbor_), or a +stalk (_thyrsus_), or a root (_radix_), or a sickle (_falx_), or a +ploughshare (_vomer_). The semen, again, was dew (_ros_). The labia majora +or minora were wings (_alæ_); the vulva and vagina were a field (_ager_ +and _campus_), or a ploughed furrow (_sulcus_), or a vineyard (_vinea_), +or a fountain (_fons_), while the pudendal hair was herbage +(_plantaria_).[4] In other languages it is not difficult to trace similar +and even identical imagery applied to sexual organs and sexual acts. Thus +it is noteworthy that Shakespeare more than once applies the term +"ploughed" to a woman who has had sexual intercourse. The Talmud calls the +labia minora the doors, the labia majora hinges, and the clitoris the key. +The Greeks appear not only to have found in the myrtle-berry, the fruit of +a plant sacred to Venus, the image of the clitoris, but also in the rose +an image of the feminine labia; in the poetic literature of many +countries, indeed, this imagery of the rose may be traced in a more or +less veiled manner.[5] + +The widespread symbolism of sex arose in the theories and conceptions of +primitive peoples concerning the function of generation and its nearest +analogies in Nature; it was continued for the sake of the vigorous and +expressive terminology which it furnished both for daily life and for +literature; its final survivals were cultivated because they furnished a +delicately æsthetic method of approaching matters which a growing +refinement of sentiment made it difficult for lovers and poets to approach +in a more crude and direct manner. Its existence is of interest to us now +because it shows the objective validity of the basis on which erotic +symbolism, as we have here to understand it, develops. But from first to +last it is a distinct phenomenon, having a more or less reasoned and +intellectual basis, and it scarcely serves in any degree to feed the +sexual impulse. Erotic symbolism is not intellectual but emotional in its +origin; it starts into being, obscurely, with but a dim consciousness or +for the most part none at all, either suddenly from the shock of some +usually youthful experience, or more gradually through an instinctive +brooding on those things which are most intimately associated with a +sexually desirable person. + + The kind of soil on which the germs of erotic symbolism may + develop is well seen in cases of sexual hyperæsthesia. In such + cases all the emotionally sexual analogies and resemblances, + which in erotic symbolism are fixed and organized, may be traced + in vague and passing forms, a single hyperæsthetic individual + perhaps presenting a great variety of germinal symbolisms. + + Thus it has been recorded of an Italian nun (whose sister became + a prostitute) that from the age of 8 she had desire for coitus, + from the age of 10 masturbated, and later had homosexual + feelings, that the same feelings and practices continued after + she had taken the veil, though from time to time they assumed + religious equivalents. The mere contact, indeed, of a priest's + hand, the news of the presentation of an ecclesiastic she had + known to a bishopric, the sight of an ape, the contemplation of + the crucified Christ, the figure of a toy, the picture of a + demon, the act of defecation in the children entrusted to her + care (whom, on this account, and against the regulations, she + would accompany to the closets), especially the sight and the + mere recollection of flies in sexual connection--all these things + sufficed to produce in her a powerful orgasm. (_Archivio di + Psichiatria_, 1902, fasc. II-III, p. 338.) + + A boy of 15 (given to masturbation), studied by Macdonald in + America, was similarly hyperæsthetic to the symbols of sexual + emotion. "I like amusing myself with my comrades," he told + Macdonald, "rolling ourselves into a ball, which gives one a + funny kind of warmth. I have a special pleasure in talking about + some things. It is the same when the governess kisses me on + saying good night or when I lean against her breast. I have that + sensation, too, when I see some of the pictures in the comic + papers, but only in those representing a woman, as when a young + man skating trips up a girl so that her clothes are raised a + little. When I read how a man saved a young girl from drowning, + so that they swam together, I had the same sensation. Looking at + the statues of women in the museum produces the same effect, or + when I see naked babies, or when a mother suckles a child. I + have often had that sensation when reading novels I ought not to + read, or when looking at a new-born calf, or seeing dogs and cows + and horses mounting on each other. When I see a girl flirting + with a boy, or leaning on his shoulder or with his arm round her + waist, I have an erection. It is the same when I see women and + little girls in bathing costume, or when boys talk of what their + fathers and mothers do together. In the Natural History Museum I + often see things which give me that sensation. One day when I + read how a man killed a young girl and carried her into a wood + and undressed her I had a feeling of enjoyment. When I read of + men who were bastards the idea of a woman having a child in that + way gives me this sensation. Some dances, and seeing young girls + astride a horse, excited me, too, and so in a circus when a woman + was shot out of a cannon and her skirts flew in the air. It has + no effect on me when I see men naked. Sometimes I enjoy seeing + women's underclothes in a shop, or when I see a lady or a girl + buying them, especially if they are drawers. When I saw a lady in + a dress which buttoned from top to bottom it had more effect on + me than seeing underclothes. Seeing dogs coupling gives me more + pleasure than looking at pretty women, but less than looking at + pretty little girls." In order of increasing intensity he placed + the phenomena that affected him thus: The coupling of flies, then + of horses, then the sight of women's undergarments, then a boy + and a girl flirting, then cows mounting on each other, the + statues of women with naked breasts, then contact with the + governess's body and breasts, finally coitus. (Arthur Macdonald, + _Le Criminel-Type_, pp. 126 et seq.) + + It is worthy of remark that the instinct of nutrition, when + restrained, may exhibit something of an analogous symbolism, + though in a minor degree, to that of sex. The ways in which a + hyperæsthetic hunger may seek its symbols are illustrated in the + case of a young woman called Nadia, who during several years was + carefully studied by Janet. It is a case of obsession ("maladie + du scrupule"), simulating hysterical anorexia, in which the + patient, for fear of getting fat, reduced her nourishment to the + smallest possible amount. "Nadia is generally hungry, even very + hungry. One can tell this by her actions; from time to time she + forgets herself to such an extent as to devour greedily anything + she can put her hands on. At other times, when she cannot resist + the desire to eat, she secretly takes a biscuit. She feels + horrible remorse for the action, but, all the same, she does it + again. Her confidences are very curious. She recognizes that a + great effort is needed to avoid eating, and considers she is a + heroine to resist so long. 'Sometimes I spent whole hours in + thinking about food, I was so hungry; I swallowed my saliva, I + bit my handkerchief, I rolled on the floor, I wanted to eat so + badly. I would look in books for descriptions of meals and + feasts, and tried to deceive my hunger by imagining that I was + sharing all these good things,'" (P. Janet, "La Maladie du + Scrupule," _Revue Philosophique_, May, 1901, p. 502.) The + deviations of the instinct of nutrition are, however, confined + within narrow limits, and, in the nature of things, hunger, + unlike sexual desire, cannot easily accept a fetich. + +"There is almost no feature, article of dress, attitude, act," Stanley +Hall declares, "or even animal or perhaps object in nature, that may not +have to some morbid soul specialized erogenic and erethic power."[6] Even +a mere shadow may become a fetich. Goron tells of a merchant in Paris--a +man with a reputation for ability, happily married and the father of a +family, altogether irreproachable in his private life--who was returning +home one evening after a game of billiards with a friend, when, on +chancing to raise his eyes, he saw against a lighted window the shadow of +a woman changing her chemise. He fell in love with that shadow and +returned to the spot every evening for many months to gaze at the window. +Yet--and herein lies the fetichism--he made no attempt to see the woman or +to find out who she was; the shadow sufficed; he had no need of the +realty.[7] It is even possible to have a negative fetich, the absence of +some character being alone demanded, and the case has been recorded in +Chicago of an American gentleman of average intelligence, education, and +good habits who, having as a boy cherished a pure affection for a girl +whose leg had been amputated, throughout life was relatively impotent with +normal women, but experienced passion and affection for women who had lost +a leg; he was found by his wife to be in extensive correspondence with +one-legged women all over the country, expending no little money on the +purchase of artificial legs for his various protegées.[8] + +It is important to remember, however, that while erotic symbolism becomes +fantastic and abnormal in its extreme manifestations, it is in its +essence absolutely normal. It is only in the very grossest forms of sexual +desire that it is altogether absent. Stendhal described the mental side of +the process of tumescence as a crystallization, a process whereby certain +features of the beloved person present points around which the emotions +held in solution in the lover's mind may concentrate and deposit +themselves in dazzling brilliance. This process inevitably tends to take +place around all those features and objects associated with the beloved +person which have most deeply impressed the lover's mind, and the more +sensitive and imaginative and emotional he is the more certainly will such +features and objects crystallize into erotic symbols. "Devotion and love," +wrote Mary Wollstonecraft, "may be allowed to hallow the garments as well +as the person, for the lover must want fancy who has not a sort of sacred +respect for the glove or slipper of his mistress. He would not confound +them with vulgar things of the same kind." And nearly two centuries +earlier Burton, who had gathered together so much of the ancient lore of +love, clearly asserted the entirely normal character of erotic symbolism. +"Not one of a thousand falls in love," he declares, "but there is some +peculiar part or other which pleaseth most, and inflames him above the +rest.... If he gets any remnant of hers, a busk-point, a feather of her +fan, a shoe-tie, a lace, a ring, a bracelet of hair, he wears it for a +favor on his arm, in his hat, finger, or next his heart; as Laodamia did +by Protesilaus, when he went to war, sit at home with his picture before +her: a garter or a bracelet of hers is more precious than any Saint's +Relique, he lays it up in his casket (O blessed Relique) and every day +will kiss it: if in her presence his eye is never off her, and drink he +will where she drank, if it be possible, in that very place," etc.[9] + + Burton's accuracy in describing the ways of lovers in his century + is shown by a passage in Hamilton's _Mémoires de Gramont_. Miss + Price, one of the beauties of Charles II's court, and Dongan were + tenderly attached to each other; when the latter died he left + behind a casket full of all possible sorts of love-tokens + pertaining to his mistress, including, among other things, "all + kinds of hair." And as regards France, Burton's contemporary, + Howell, wrote in 1627 in his _Familiar Letters_ concerning the + repulse of the English at Rhé: "A captain told me that when they + were rifling the dead bodies of the French gentlemen after the + first invasion they found that many of them had their mistresses' + favors tied about their genitories." + + Schurig (_Spermatologia_, p. 357) at the beginning of the + eighteenth century knew a Belgian lady who, when her dearly loved + husband died, secretly cut off his penis and treasured it as a + sacred relic in a silver casket. She eventually powdered it, he + adds, and found it an efficacious medicine for herself and + others. An earlier example, of a lady at the French court who + embalmed and perfumed the genital organs of her dead husband, + always preserving them in a gold casket, is mentioned by + Brantôme. Mantegazza knew a man who kept for many years on his + desk the skull of his dead mistress, making it his dearest + companion. "Some," he remarks, "have slept for months and years + with a book, a garment, a trifle. I once had a friend who would + spend long hours of joy and emotion kissing a thread of silk + which _she_ had held between her fingers, now the only relic of + love." (Mantegazza, _Fisiologia dell' Amore_, cap. X.) In the + same way I knew a lady who in old age still treasured in her + desk, as the one relic of the only man she had ever been + attracted to, a fragment of paper he had casually twisted up in a + conversation with her half a century before. + +The tendency to treasure the relics of a beloved person, more especially +the garments, is the simplest and commonest foundation of erotic +symbolism. It is without doubt absolutely normal. It is inevitable that +those objects which have been in close contact with the beloved person's +body, and are intimately associated with that person in the lover's mind, +should possess a little of the same virtue, the same emotional potency. It +is a phenomenon closely analogous to that by which the relics of saints +are held to possess a singular virtue. But it becomes somewhat less normal +when the garment is regarded as essential even in the presence of the +beloved person.[10] + +While an extremely large number of objects and acts may be found to +possess occasionally the value of erotic symbols, such symbols most +frequently fall into certain well-defined groups. A vast number of +isolated objects or acts may be exceptionally the focus of erotic +contemplation, but the objects and acts which frequently become thus +symbolic are comparatively few. + +It seems to me that the phenomena of erotic symbolism may be most +conveniently grouped in three great classes, on the basis of the objects +or acts which arouse them. + +I. PARTS OF THE BODY.--_A. Normal:_ Hand, foot, breasts, nates, hair, +secretions and excretions, etc. + +_B. Abnormal:_ Lameness, squinting, pitting of smallpox, etc. Paidophilia +or the love of children, presbyophilia or the love of the aged, and +necrophilia or the attraction for corpses, may be included under this +head, as well as the excitement caused by various animals. + + +II. INANIMATE OBJECTS.[11]--_A. Garments:_ Gloves, shoes and stockings and +garters, caps, aprons, handkerchiefs, underlinen. + +_B. Impersonal Objects:_ Here may be included all the various objects that +may accidentally acquire the power of exciting sexual feeling in +auto-erotism. Pygmalionism may also be included. + + +III. ACTS AND ATTITUDES.--_A. Active:_ Whipping, cruelty, exhibitionism. +_B. Passive:_ Being whipped, experiencing cruelty. Personal odors and the +sound of the voice may be included under this head. _C. Mixoscopic:_ The +vision of climbing, swinging, etc. The acts of urination and defecation. +The coitus of animals. + +Although the three main groups into which the phenomena of erotic +symbolism are here divided may seem fairly distinct, they are yet very +closely allied, and indeed overlap, so that it is possible, as we shall +see, for a single complex symbol to fall into all three groups. + +A very complete kind of erotic symbolism is furnished by Pygmalionism or +the love of statues.[12] It is exactly analogous to the child's love of a +doll, which is also a form of sexual (though not erotic) symbolism. In a +somewhat less abnormal form, erotic symbolism probably shows itself in its +simplest shape in the tendency to idealize unbeautiful peculiarities in a +beloved person, so that such peculiarities are ever afterward almost or +quite essential in order to arouse sexual attraction. In this way men have +become attracted to limping women. Even the most normal man may idealize a +trifling defect in a beloved woman. The attention is inevitably +concentrated on any such slight deviation from regular beauty, and the +natural result of such concentration is that a complexus of associated +thoughts and emotions becomes attached to something that in itself is +unbeautiful. A defect becomes an admired focus of attention, the embodied +symbol of the lover's emotion. + + Thus a mole is not in itself beautiful, but by the tendency to + erotic symbolism it becomes so. Persian poets especially have + lavished the richest imagery on moles (_Anis El-Ochchâq_ in + _Bibliothèque des Hautes Etudes_, fasc, 25, 1875); the Arabs, as + Lane remarks (_Arabian Society in the Middle Ages_, p. 214), are + equally extravagant in their admiration of a mole. + + Stendhal long since well described the process by which a defect + becomes a sexual symbol. "Even little defects in a woman's face," + he remarked, "such as a smallpox pit, may arouse the tenderness + of a man who loves her, and throw him into deep reverie when he + sees them in another woman. It is because he has experienced a + thousand feelings in the presence of that smallpox mark, that + these feelings have been for the most part delicious, all of the + highest interest, and that, whatever they may have been, they are + renewed with incredible vivacity on the sight of this sign, even + when perceived on the face of another woman. If in such a case we + come to prefer and love _ugliness_, it is only because in such a + case ugliness is beauty. A man loved a woman who was very thin + and marked by smallpox; he lost her by death. Three years later, + in Rome, he became acquainted with two women, one very beautiful, + the other thin and marked by smallpox, on that account, if you + will, rather ugly. I saw him in love with this plain one at the + end of a week, which he had employed in effacing her plainness by + his memories." (_De l'Amour_, Chapter XVII.) + +In the tendency to idealize the unbeautiful features of a beloved person +erotic symbolism shows itself in a simple and normal form. In a less +simple and more morbid form it appears in persons in whom the normal paths +of sexual gratification are for some reasons inhibited, and who are thus +led to find the symbols of natural love in unnatural perversions. It is +for this reason that so many erotic symbolisms take root in childhood and +puberty, before the sexual instincts have reached full development. It is +for the same reason also, that, at the other end of life, when the sexual +energies are failing, erotic symbols sometimes tend to be substituted for +the normal pleasures of sex. It is for this reason, again, that both men +and women whose normal energies are inhibited sometimes find the symbols +of sexual gratification in the caresses of children. + + The case of a schoolmistress recorded by Penta instructively + shows how an erotic symbolism of this last kind may develop by no + means as a refinement of vice, but as the one form in which + sexual gratification becomes possible when normal gratification + has been pathologically inhibited. F.R., aged 48, schoolmistress; + she was some years ago in an asylum with religious mania, but + came out well in a few months. At the age of 12 she had first + experienced sexual excitement in a railway train from the jolting + of the carriage. Soon after she fell in love with a youth who + represented her ideal and who returned her affection. When, + however, she gave herself to him, great was her disillusion and + surprise to find that the sexual act which she had looked forward + to could not be accomplished, for at the first contact there was + great pain and spasmodic resistance of the vagina. There was a + condition of vaginismus. After repeated attempts on subsequent + occasions her lover desisted. Her desire for intercourse + increased, however, rather than diminished, and at last she was + able to tolerate coitus, but the pain was so great that she + acquired a horror of the sexual embrace and no longer sought it. + Having much will power, she restrained all erotic impulses during + many years. It was not until the period of the menopause that the + long repressed desires broke out, and at last found a symbolical + outlet that was no longer normal, but was felt to supply a + complete gratification. She sought the close physical contact of + the young children in her care. She would lie on her bed naked, + with two or three naked children, make them suck her breasts and + press them to every part of her body. Her conduct was discovered + by means of other children who peeped through the keyhole, and + she was placed under Penta for treatment. In this case the loss + of moral and mental inhibition, due probably to troubles of the + climacteric, led to indulgence, under abnormal conditions, in + those primitive contacts which are normally the beginning of + love, and these, supported by the ideal image of the early lover, + constituted a complete and adequate symbol of natural love in a + morbidly perverted individual. (P. Penta, _Archivio delle + Psicopatie Sessuali_, January, 1896.) + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[1] The term "erotic symbolism" has already been employed by Eulenburg +(_Sexuale Neuropathie_, 1895, p. 101). It must be borne in mind that this +term, implying the specific emotion, is much narrower than the term +"sexual symbolism," which may be used to designate a great variety of +ritual and social practices which have played a part in the evolution of +civilization. + +[2] _Sexual Selection in Man_, iv, "Vision." + +[3] K. Groos, _Der Æsthetische Genuss_, p. 122. The psychology of the +associations of contiguity and resemblance through which erotic symbolism +operates its transference is briefly discussed by Ribot in the _Psychology +of the Emotions_, Part 1, Chapter XII; the early chapters of the same +author's _Logique des Sentiments_ may also be said to deal with the +emotional basis on which erotic symbolism arises. + +[4] A number of synonyms for the female pudenda are brought together by +Schurig--cunnus, hortus, concha, navis, fovea, larva, canis, annulus, +focus, cymba, antrum, delta, myrtus, etc.--and he discusses many of them. +(_Muliebria_, Section I, cap. I.) + +[5] Kleinpaul, _Sprache Ohne Worte_, pp. 24-29; cf. K. Pearson, on the +general and special words for sex, _Chances of Death_, vol. ii, pp. +112-245; a selection of the literature of the rose will be found in a +volume of translations entitled _Ros Rosarum_. + +[6] G.S. Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. i, p. 470. + +[7] Goron, _Les Parias de l'Amour_, p. 45. + +[8] A.R. Reynolds, _Medical Standard_, vol. x, cited by Kiernan, +"Responsibility in Sexual Perversion," _American Journal of Neurology and +Psychiatry_, 1882. + +[9] R. Burton, _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. II, +Subs. II, and Mem. III, Subs. I. + +[10] Numerous examples are given by Moll, _Konträre Sexualempfindung_, +third edition, pp. 265-268. + +[11] Chevalier (_De l'Inversion_, 1885; id., _L'Inversion Sexuelle_, 1892, +p. 52), followed by E. Laurent (_L'Amour Morbide_, 1891, Chapter X), +separates this group from other fetichistic perversions, under the head of +"azoöphilie." I see no adequate ground for this step. The various forms of +fetichism are too intimately associated to permit of any group of them +being violently separated from the others. + +[12] This has already been considered as a perversion founded on vision, +in discussing _Sexual Selection in Man_. IV. + + + + +II. + +Foot-fetichism and Shoe-fetichism--Wide Prevalence and Normal +Basis--Restif de la Bretonne--The Foot a Normal Focus of Sexual Attraction +Among Some Peoples--The Chinese, Greeks, Romans, Spaniards, etc.--The +Congenital Predisposition in Erotic Symbolism--The Influence of Early +Association and Emotional Shock--Shoe-fetichism in Relation to +Masochism--The Two Phenomena Independent Though Allied--The Desire to be +Trodden On--The Fascination of Physical Constraint--The Symbolism of +Self-inflicted Pain--The Dynamic Element in Erotic Symbolism--The +Symbolism of Garments. + + +Of all forms of erotic symbolism the most frequent is that which idealizes +the foot and the shoe. The phenomena we here encounter are sometimes so +complex and raise so many interesting questions that it is necessary to +discuss them somewhat fully. + +It would seem that even for the normal lover the foot is one of the most +attractive parts of the body. Stanley Hall found that among the parts +specified as most admired in the other sex by young men and women who +answered a _questionnaire_ the feet came fourth (after the eyes, hair, +stature and size).[13] Casanova, an acute student and lover of women who +was in no degree a foot fetichist, remarks that all men who share his +interest in women are attracted by their feet; they offer the same +interest, he considers, as the question of the particular edition offers +to the book-lover.[14] + + In a report of the results of a _questionnaire_ concerning + children's sense of self, to which over 500 replies were + received, Stanley Hall thus summarizes the main facts ascertained + with reference to the feet: "A special period of noticing the + feet comes somewhat later than that in which the hands are + discovered to consciousness. Our records afford nearly twice as + many cases for feet as for hands. The former are more remote from + the primary psychic focus or position, and are also more often + covered, so that the sight of them is a more marked and + exceptional event. Some children become greatly excited whenever + their feet are exposed. Some infants show signs of fear at the + movement of their own knees and feet covered, and still more + often fright is the first sensation which signalizes the child's + discovery of its feet.... Many are described as playing with them + as if fascinated by strange, newly-discovered toys. They pick + them up and try to throw them away, or out of the cradle, or + bring them to the mouth, where all things tend to go.... Children + often handle their feet, pat and stroke them, offer them toys and + the bottle, as if they, too, had an independent hunger to + gratify, an _ego_ of their own.... Children often develop [later] + a special interest in the feet of others, and examine, feel them, + etc., sometimes expressing surprise that the pinch of the + mother's toe hurts her and not the child, or comparing their own + and the feet of others point by point. Curious, too, are the + intensifications of foot-consciousness throughout the early years + of childhood, whenever children have the exceptional privilege of + going barefoot, or have new shoes. The feet are often + apostrophized, punished, beaten sometimes to the point of pain + for breaking things, throwing the child down, etc. Several + children have habits, which reach great intensity, and then + vanish, of touching or tickling the feet, with gales of laughter, + and a few are described as showing an almost morbid reluctance to + wear anything upon the feet, or even to having them touched by + others.... Several almost fall in love with the great toe or the + little one, especially admiring some crease or dimple in it, + dressing it in some rag of silk or bit of ribbon, or cut-off + glove fingers, winding it with string, prolonging it by tying on + bits of wood. Stroking the feet of others, especially if they are + shapely, often becomes almost a passion with young children, and + several adults confess a survival of the same impulse which it is + an exquisite pleasure to gratify. The interest of some mothers in + babies' toes, the expressions of which are ecstatic and almost + incredible, is a factor of great importance." (G. Stanley Hall, + "Some Aspects of the Early Sense of Self," _American Journal of + Psychology_, April, 1898.) In childhood, Stanley Hall remarks + elsewhere (_Adolescence_, vol. ii, p. 104), "a form of courtship + may consist solely in touching feet under the desk." It would + seem that even animals have a certain amount of sexual + consciousness in the feet; I have noticed a male donkey, just + before coitus, bite the feet of his partner. + +At the same time it is scarcely usual for the normal lover, in most +civilized countries to-day, to attach primary importance to the foot, such +as he very frequently attaches to the eyes, though the feet play a very +conspicuous part in the work of certain novelists.[15] + +In a small but not inconsiderable minority of persons, however, the foot +or the boot becomes the most attractive part of a woman, and in some +morbid cases the woman herself is regarded as a comparatively unimportant +appendage to her feet or her boots. The boots under civilized conditions +much more frequently constitute the sexual symbol than do the feet +themselves; this is not surprising since in ordinary life the feet are not +often seen. + + It is usually only under exceptionally favoring conditions that + foot-fetichism occurs, as in the case recorded by Marandon de + Montyel of a doctor who had been brought up in the West Indies. + His mother had been insane and he himself was subject to + obsessions, especially of being incapable of urinating; he had + had nocturnal incontinence of urine in childhood. All the women + of the people in the West Indies go about with naked feet, which + are often beautiful. His puberty evolved under this influence, + and foot-fetichism developed. He especially admired large, fat, + arched feet, with delicate skin and large, regular toes. He + masturbated with images of feet. At 15 he had relations with a + colored chambermaid, but feared to mention his fetichism, though + it was the touch of her feet that chiefly excited him. He now + gave up masturbation, and had a succession of mistresses, but was + always ashamed to confess his fancies until, at the age of 33, in + Paris, a very intelligent woman who had become his mistress + discovered his mania and skillfully enabled him to yield to it + without shock to his modesty. He was devoted to this mistress, + who had very beautiful feet (he had been horrified by the feet of + Europeans generally), until she finally left him. (_Archives de + Neurologie_, October, 1904.) + + Probably the first case of shoe-fetichism ever recorded in any + detail is that of Restif de la Bretonne (1734-1806), publicist + and novelist, one of the most remarkable literary figures of the + later eighteenth century in France. Restif was a neurotic + subject, though not to an extreme degree, and his shoe-fetichism, + though distinctly pronounced, was not pathological; that is to + say, that the shoe was not itself an adequate gratification of + the sexual impulse, but simply a highly important aid to + tumescence, a prelude to the natural climax of detumescence; only + occasionally, and _faute de mieux_, in the absence of the beloved + person, was the shoe used as an adjunct to masturbation. In + Restif's stories and elsewhere the attraction of the shoe is + frequently discussed or used as a motive. His first decided + literary success, _Le Pied de Fanchette_, was suggested by a + vision of a girl with a charming foot, casually seen in the + street. While all such passages in his books are really founded + on his own personal feelings and experiences, in his elaborate + autobiography, _Monsieur Nicolas_, he has frankly set forth the + gradual evolution and cause of his idiosyncrasy. The first + remembered trace dated from the age of 4, when he was able to + recall having remarked the feet of a young girl in his native + place. Restif was a sexually precocious youth, and at the age of + 9, though both delicate in health and shy in manners, his + thoughts were already absorbed in the girls around him. "While + little Monsieur Nicolas," he tells us, "passed for a Narcissus, + his thoughts, as soon as he was alone, by night or by day, had no + other object than that sex he seemed to flee from. The girls most + careful of their persons were naturally those who pleased him + most, and as the part least easy to keep clean is that which + touches the earth it was to the foot-gear that he mechanically + gave his chief attention. Agathe, Reine, and especially + Madeleine, were the most elegant of the girls at that time; their + carefully selected and kept shoes, instead of laces or buckles, + which were not yet worn at Sacy, had blue or rose ribbon, + according to the color of the skirt. I thought of these girls + with emotion; I desired--I knew not what; but I desired + something, if it were only to subdue them." The origin Restif + here assigns to his shoe-fetichism may seem paradoxical; he + admired the girls who were most clean and neat in their dress, he + tells us, and, therefore, paid most attention to that part of + their clothing which was least clean and neat. But, however + paradoxical the remark may seem, it is psychologically sound. All + fetichism is a kind of not necessarily morbid obsession, and as + the careful work of Janet and others in that field has shown, an + obsession is a fascinated attraction to some object or idea + which gives the subject a kind of emotional shock by its + contrast to his habitual moods or ideas. The ordinary morbid + obsession cannot usually be harmoniously co-ordinated with the + other experiences of the subject's daily life, and shows, + therefore, no tendency to become pleasurable. Sexual fetichisms, + on the other hand, have a reservoir of agreeable emotion to draw + on, and are thus able to acquire both stability and harmony. It + will also be seen that no element of masochism is involved in + Restif's fetichism, though the mistake has been frequently made + of supposing that these two manifestations are usually or even + necessarily allied. Restif wishes to subject the girl who + attracts him, he has no wish to be subjected by her. He was + especially dazzled by a young girl from another town, whose shoes + were of a fashionable cut, with buckles, "and who was a charming + person besides." She was delicate as a fairy, and rendered his + thoughts unfaithful to the robust beauties of his native Sacy. + "No doubt," he remarks, "because, being frail and weak myself, it + seemed to me that it would be easier to subdue her." "This taste + for the beauty of the feet," he continues, "was so powerful in me + that it unfailingly aroused desire and would have made me + overlook ugliness. It is excessive in all those who have it." He + admired the foot as well as the shoe: "The factitious taste for + the shoe is only a reflection of that for pretty feet. When I + entered a house and saw the boots arranged in a row, as is the + custom, I would tremble with pleasure; I blushed and lowered my + eyes as if in the presence of the girls themselves. With this + vivacity of feeling and a voluptuousness of ideas inconceivable + at the age of 10 I still fled, with an involuntary impulse of + modesty, from the girls I adored." + + We may clearly see how this combination of sensitive and + precocious sexual ardor with extreme shyness, furnished the soil + on which the germ of shoe-fetichism was able to gain a firm root + and persist in some degree throughout a long life very largely + given up to a pursuit of women, abnormal rather by its + excessiveness than its perversity. A few years later, he tells + us, he happened to see a pretty pair of shoes in a bootmaker's + shop, and on hearing that they belonged to a girl whom at that + time he reverently adored at a distance he blushed and nearly + fainted. + + In 1749 he was for a time attracted to a young woman very much + older than himself; he secretly carried away one of her slippers + and kept it for a day; a little later he again took away a shoe + of the same woman which had fascinated him when on her foot, and, + he seems to imply, he used it to masturbate with. + + Perhaps the chief passion of Restif's life was his love for + Colette Parangon. He was still a boy (1752), she was the young + and virtuous wife of the printer whose apprentice Restif was and + in whose house he lived. Madame Parangon, a charming woman, as + she is described, was not happily married, and she evidently + felt a tender affection for the boy whose excessive love and + reverence for her were not always successfully concealed. + "Madonna Parangon," he tells us, "possessed a charm which I could + never resist, a pretty little foot; it is a charm which arouses + more than tenderness. Her shoes, made in Paris, had that + voluptuous elegance which seems to communicate soul and life. + Sometimes Colette wore shoes of simple white drugget or with + silver flowers; sometimes rose-colored slippers with green heels, + or green with rose heels; her supple feet, far from deforming her + shoes, increased their grace and rendered the form more + exciting." One day, on entering the house, he saw Madame Parangon + elegantly dressed and wearing rose-colored shoes with tongues, + and with green heels and a pretty rosette. They were new and she + took them off to put on green slippers with rose heels and + borders which he thought equally exciting. As soon as she had + left the room, he continues, "carried away by the most impetuous + passion and idolizing Colette, I seemed to see her and touch her + in handling what she had just worn; my lips pressed one of these + jewels, while the other, deceiving the sacred end of nature, from + excess of exaltation replaced the object of sex (I cannot express + myself more clearly). The warmth which she had communicated to + the insensible object which had touched her still remained and + gave a soul to it; a voluptuous cloud covered my eyes." He adds + that he would kiss with rage and transport whatever had come in + close contact with the woman he adored, and on one occasion + eagerly pressed his lips to her cast-off underlinen, _vela + secretiora penetralium_. + + At this period Restif's foot-fetichism reached its highest point + of development. It was the aberration of a highly sensitive and + very precocious boy. While the preoccupation with feet and shoes + persisted throughout life, it never became a complete perversion + and never replaced the normal end of sexual desire. His love for + Madam Parangon, one of the deepest emotions in his whole life, + was also the climax of his shoe-fetichism. She represented his + ideal woman, an ethereal sylph with wasp-waist and a child's + feet; it was always his highest praise for a woman that she + resembled Madame Parangon, and he desired that her slipper should + be buried with him. (Restif de la Bretonne, _Monsieur Nicolas_, + vols. i-iv, vol. xiii, p. 5; id., _Mes Inscriptions_, pp. ci-cv.) + + Shoe-fetichism, more especially if we include under this term all + the cases of real or pseudo-masochism in which an attraction to + the boots or slippers is the chief feature, is a not infrequent + phenomenon, and is certainly the most frequently occurring form + of fetichism. Many cases are brought together by Krafft-Ebing in + his _Psychopathia Sexualis_. Every prostitute of any experience + has known men who merely desire to gaze at her shoes, or possibly + to lick them, and who are quite willing to pay for this + privilege. In London such a person is known as a "bootman," in + Germany as a "Stiefelfrier." + +The predominance of the foot as a focus of sexual attraction, while among +us to-day it is a not uncommon phenomenon, is still not sufficiently +common to be called normal; the majority of even ardent lovers do not +experience this attraction in any marked degree. But these manifestations +of foot-fetichism which with us to-day are abnormal, even when they are +not so extreme as to be morbid, may perhaps become more intelligible to us +when we realize that in earlier periods of civilization, and even to-day +in some parts of the world, the foot is generally recognized as a focus of +sexual attraction, so that some degree of foot-fetichism becomes a normal +phenomenon. + +The most pronounced and the best known example of such normal +foot-fetichism at the present day is certainly to be found among the +Southern Chinese. For a Chinese husband his wife's foot is more +interesting than her face. A Chinese woman is as shy of showing her feet +to a man as a European woman her breasts; they are reserved for her +husband's eyes alone, and to look at a woman's feet in the street is +highly improper and indelicate. Chinese foot-fetichism is connected with +the custom of compressing the feet. This custom appears to rest on the +fact that Chinese women naturally possess a very small foot and is thus an +example of the universal tendency in the search for beauty to accentuate, +even by deformation, the racial characteristics. But there is more than +this. Beauty is largely a name for sexual attractiveness, and the energy +expended in the effort to make the Chinese woman's small foot still +smaller is a measure of the sexual fascination which it exerts. The +practice arose on the basis of the sexual attractiveness of the foot, +though it has doubtless served to heighten that attractiveness, just as +the small waist, which (if we may follow Stratz) is a characteristic +beauty of the European woman, becomes to the average European man still +more attractive when accentuated, even to the extent of deformity, by the +compression of the corset. + + Referring to the sexual fascination exerted by the foot in China, + Matignon writes: "My attention has been drawn to this point by a + large number of pornographic engravings, of which the Chinese are + very fond. In all these lascivious scenes we see the male + voluptuously fondling the woman's foot. When a Celestial takes + into his hand a woman's foot, especially if it is very small, the + effect upon him is precisely the same as is provoked in a + European by the palpation of a young and firm bosom. All the + Celestials whom I have interrogated on this point have replied + unanimously: 'Oh, a little foot! You Europeans cannot understand + how exquisite, how sweet, how exciting it is!' The contact of the + genital organ with the little foot produces in the male an + indescribable degree of voluptuous feeling, and women skilled in + love know that to arouse the ardor of their lovers a better + method than all Chinese aphrodisiacs--including 'giusen' and + swallows' nests--is to take the penis between their feet. It is + not rare to find Chinese Christians accusing themselves at + confession of having had 'evil thoughts on looking at a woman's + foot.'" (Dr. J. Matignon, "A propos d'un Pied de Chinoise," + _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, 1898.) + + It is said that a Chinese Empress, noted for her vice and having + a congenital club foot, about the year 1100 B.C., desired all + women to resemble her, and that the practice of compressing the + foot thus arose. But this is only tradition, since, in 300 B.C., + Chinese books were destroyed (Morache, Art. "Chine," + _Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des Sciences Médicales_, p. 191). It + is also said that the practice owes its origin to the wish to + keep women indoors. But women are not secluded in China, nor does + foot compression usually render a woman unable to walk. Many + intelligent Chinese are of opinion that its object is to promote + the development of the sexual parts and of the thighs, and so to + aid both intercourse and parturition. There is no ground for + believing that it has any such influence, though Morache found + that the mons veneris and labia are largely developed in Chinese + women, and not in Tartar women living in Pekin (who do not + compress the foot). If there is any correlation between the feet + and the pelvic regions, it is more probably congenital than due + to the artificial compression of the feet. The ancients seem to + have believed that a small foot indicated a small vagina. Restif + de la Bretonne, who had ample opportunities for forming an + opinion on a matter in which he took so great an interest, + believed that a small foot, round and short, indicated a large + vagina (_Monsieur Nicolas_, vol. i, reprint of 1883, p. 92). + Even, however, if we admit that there is a real correlation + between the foot and the vagina, that would by no means suffice + to render the foot a focus of sexual attraction. + + It remains the most reasonable view that the foot bandage must be + regarded as strictly analogous to the waist bandage or corset + which also tends to produce deformity of the constricted region. + Stratz has ingeniously remarked (_Frauenkleidung_, third edition, + p. 101) that the success of the Chinese in dwarfing trees may + have suggested a similar attempt in regard to women's feet, and + adds that in any case both dwarfed trees and bound feet bear + witness in the Mongolian to the same love for small and elegant, + not to say deformed, things. For a Chinaman the deformed foot is + a "golden water-lily." + + Many facts (together with illustrations) bearing on Chinese + deformation of the foot will be found in Ploss, _Das Weib_, vol. + i, Section IV. + +The significance of the sexual emotion aroused by the female foot in China +and the origin of its compression begin to become clear when we realize +that this foot-fetichism is merely an extreme development of a tendency +which is fairly well marked among nearly all the peoples of yellow race. +Jacoby, who has brought together a number of interesting facts bearing on +the sexual significance of the foot, states that a similar tendency is to +be found among the Mongol and Turk peoples of Siberia, and in the east and +central parts of European Russia, among the Permiaks, the Wotiaks, etc. +Here the woman, at all events when young, has always her feet, as well as +head, covered, however little clothing she may otherwise wear. + + "On hot nights or on baking days," Jacoby states, "you may see + these women with uncovered breasts, or even entirely naked + without embarrassment, but you will never see them with bare + feet, and no male relations, except the husband, will ever see + the feet and lower part of the legs of the women in the house. + These women have their modesty in their feet, and also their + coquetry; to unbind the feet of a woman is for a man a voluptuous + act, and the touch of the bands produces the same effect as a + corset still warm from a woman's body on a European man. A + woman's beauty, that which attracts and excites a man, lies in + her foot; in Mordvin love poems celebrating the beauty of women + there is much about her attire, especially her embroidered + chemise, but as regards the charms of her person the poet is + content to state that 'her feet are beautiful;' with that + everything is said. The young peasant woman of the central + provinces as part of her holiday raiment puts on great woolen + stockings which come up to the groin and are then folded over to + below the knee. To uncover the feet of a person of the opposite + sex is a sexual act, and has thus become the symbol of sexual + possession, so that the stocking or foot-gear became the emblem + of marriage, as later the ring. (It was so among the Jews, as we + see in the book of _Ruth_, Chapter III, v. 4, and Chapter IV, vv. + 7 and 8). St. Vladimir the Great asked in marriage the daughter + of Prince Rogvold; as Vladimir's mother had been a serf, the + princess proudly replied that she 'would not uncover the feet of + a slave.' At the present time in the east of Russia when a young + girl tries to find out by divination whom she will have as a + husband the traditional formula is 'Come and take my stockings + off.' Among the populations of the north and east, it is + sometimes the bride who must do this for her husband on the + wedding night, and sometimes the bridegroom for his wife, not as + a token of love, but as a nuptial ceremony. Among the + professional classes and small nobility in Russia parents place + money in the stocking of their child at marriage as a present for + the other partner, it being supposed that the couple mutually + remove each other's foot raiment, as an act of sexual possession, + the emblem of coitus." (Paul Jacoby, _Archives d'Anthropologie + Criminelle_, December, 1903, p. 793.) The practice among + ourselves of children hanging up their stockings at night for + presents would seem to be a relic of the last-mentioned custom. + +While we may witness the sexual symbolism of the foot, with or without an +associated foot-fetichism, most highly developed in Asia and Eastern +Europe, it has by no means been altogether unknown in some stages of +western civilization, and traces of it may be found here and there even +yet. Schinz refers to the connection between the feet and sexual pleasure +as existing not only among the Egyptians and the Arabs, but among the +ancient Germans and the modern Spaniards,[16] while Jacoby points out that +among the Greeks, the Romans, and especially the Etruscans, it was usual +to represent chaste and virgin goddesses with their feet covered, even +though they might be otherwise nude. Ovid, again, is never weary of +dwelling on the sexual charm of the feminine foot. He represents the +chaste matron as wearing a weighted _stola_ which always fell so as to +cover her feet; it was only the courtesan, or the nymph who is taking part +in an erotic festival, who appears with raised robes, revealing her +feet.[17] So grave a historian as Strabo, as well as Ælian, refers to the +story of the courtesan Rhodope whose sandal was carried off by an eagle +and dropped in the King of Egypt's lap as he was administering justice, so +that he could not rest until he had discovered to whom this delicately +small sandal belonged, and finally made her his queen. Kleinpaul, who +repeats this story, has collected many European sayings and customs +(including Turkish), indicating that the slipper is a very ancient symbol +of a woman's sexual parts.[18] + + In Rome, Dufour remarks, "Matrons having appropriated the use of + the shoe (_soccus_) prostitutes were not allowed to use it, and + were obliged to have their feet always naked in sandals or + slippers (_crepida_ and _solea_), which they fastened over the + instep with gilt bands. Tibullus delights to describe his + mistress's little foot, compressed by the band that imprisoned + it: _Ansaque compressos colligat arcta pedes_. Nudity of the foot + in woman was a sign of prostitution, and their brilliant + whiteness acted afar as a pimp to attract looks and desires." + (Dufour, _Histoire de la Prostitution_, vol. II., ch. xviii.) + + This feeling seems to have survived in a more or less vague and + unconscious form in mediæval Europe. "In the tenth century," + according to Dufour (_Histoire de la Prostitution_, vol. VI., p. + 11), "shoes _a la poulaine_, with a claw or beak, pursued for + more than four centuries by the anathemas of popes and the + invectives of preachers, were always regarded by mediæval + casuists as the most abominable emblems of immodesty. At a first + glance it is not easy to see why these shoes--terminating in a + lion's claw, an eagle's beak, the prow of a ship, or other metal + appendage--should be so scandalous. The excommunication inflicted + on this kind of foot-gear preceded the impudent invention of some + libertine, who wore _poulaines_ in the shape of the phallus, a + custom adopted also by women. This kind of _poulaine_ was + denounced as _mandite de Dicu_ (Ducange's Glossary, at the word + Poulainia) and prohibited by royal ordinances (see letter of + Charles V., 17 October, 1367, regarding the garments of the women + of Montpellier). Great lords and ladies continued, however, to + wear _poulaines_." In Louis XL's court they were still worn of a + quarter of an ell in length. + + Spain, ever tenacious of ancient ideas, appears to have preserved + longer than other countries the ancient classic traditions in + regard to the foot as a focus of modesty and an object of sexual + attraction. In Spanish religious pictures it was always necessary + that the Virgin's feet should be concealed, the clergy ordaining + that her robe should be long and flowing, so that the feet might + be covered with decent folds. Pacheco, the master and + father-in-law of Velasquez, writes in 1649 in his _Arte de la + Pintura_: "What can be more foreign from the respect which we owe + to the purity of Our Lady the Virgin than to paint her sitting + down with one of her knees placed over the other, and often with + her sacred feet uncovered and naked. Let thanks be given to the + Holy Inquisition which commands that this liberty should be + corrected!" It was Pacheco's duty in Seville to see that these + commands were obeyed. At the court of Philip IV. at this time the + princesses never showed their feet, as we may see in the pictures + of Velasquez. When a local manufacturer desired to present that + monarch's second bride, Mariana of Austria, with some silk + stockings the offer was indignantly rejected by the Court + Chamberlain: "The Queen of Spain has no legs!" Philip V.'s, queen + was thrown from her horse and dragged by the feet; no one + ventured to interfere until two gentlemen bravely rescued her and + then fled, dreading punishment by the king: they were, however, + graciously pardoned. Reinach ("Pieds Pudiques," _Cultes, Mythes + et Religions_, pp. 105-110) brings together several passages from + the Countess D'Aulnoy's account of the Madrid Court in the + seventeenth century and from other sources, showing how careful + Spanish ladies were as regards their feet, and how jealous + Spanish husbands were in this matter. At this time, when Spanish + influence was considerable, the fashion of Spain seems to have + spread to other countries. One may note that in Vandyck's + pictures of English beauties the feet are not visible, though in + the more characteristically English painters of a somewhat later + age it became usual to display them conspicuously, while the + French custom in this matter is the farthest removed from the + Spanish. At the present day a well-bred Spanish woman shows as + little as possible of her feet in walking, and even in some of + the most characteristic Spanish dances there is little or no + kicking, and the feet may even be invisible throughout. It is + noteworthy that in numerous figures of Spanish women (probably + artists' models) reproduced in Ploss's _Das Weib_ the stockings + are worn, although the women are otherwise, in most cases, quite + naked. Max Dessoir mentions ("Psychologie der Vita Sexualis," + _Zeitschrift für Psychiatrie_, 1894, p. 954) that in Spanish + pornographic photographs women always have their shoes on, and he + considers this an indication of perversity. I have seen the + statement (attributed to Gautier's _Voyage en Espagne_, where, + however, it does not occur) that Spanish prostitutes uncover + their feet in sign of assent, and Madame d'Aulnoy stated that in + her time to show her lover her feet was a Spanish woman's final + favor. + +The tendency, which we thus find to be normal at some earlier periods of +civilization, to insist on the sexual symbolism of the feminine foot or +its coverings, and to regard them as a special sexual fascination, is not +without significance for the interpretation of the sporadic manifestations +of foot-fetichism among ourselves. Eccentric as foot-fetichism may appear +to us, it is simply the re-emergence, by a pseudo-atavism or arrest of +development, of a mental or emotional impulse which was probably +experienced by our forefathers, and is often traceable among young +children to-day.[19] The occasional reappearance of this bygone impulse +and the stability which it may acquire are thus conditioned by the +sensitive reaction of an abnormally nervous and usually precocious +organism to influences which, among the average and ordinary population of +Europe to-day, are either never felt, or quickly outgrown, or very +strictly subordinated in the highly complex crystallizations which the +course of love and the process of tumescence create within us. + + It may be added that this is by no means true of foot-fetichism + only. In some other fetichisms a seemingly congenital + predisposition is even more marked. This is not only the case as + regards hair-fetichism and fur-fetichism (see, e.g., + Krafft-Ebing, _Psychopathia Sexualis_, English translation of + tenth edition, pp. 233, 255, 262). In many cases of fetichisms of + all kinds not only is there no record of any commencement in a + definite episode (an absence which may be accounted for by the + supposition that the original incident has been forgotten), but + it would seem in some cases that the fetichism developed very + slowly. + +In this sense, it will be seen, although it is hazardous to speak of +foot-fetichism as strictly an atavism, it may certainly be said to arise +on a congenital basis. It represents the rare development of an inborn +germ, usually latent among ourselves, which in earlier stages of +civilization frequently reached a normal and general fruition. + +It is of interest to emphasize this congenital element of foot symbolism, +because more than any other forms of sexual perversion the fetichisms are +those which are most vaguely conditioned by inborn states of the organism +and most definitely aroused by seemingly accidental associations or shocks +in early life. Inversion is sometimes so fundamentally ingrained in the +individual's constitution that it arises and develops in spite of the very +strongest influence in a contrary direction. But a fetichism, while it +tends to occur in sensitive, nervous, timid, precocious individuals--that +is to say, individuals of more or less neuropathic heredity--can usually, +though not always, be traced to a definite starting point in the shock of +some sexually emotional episode in early life. + + A few examples of the influences of such association may here be + given, referring miscellaneously to various forms of erotic + symbolism. Magnan has recorded the case of a hair-fetichist, + living in a district where the women wore their hair done up, who + at the age of 15 experienced pleasurable feelings with erection + at the sight of a village beauty combing her hair; from that time + flowing hair became his fetich, and he could not resist the + temptation to touch it and if possible sever it, thus becoming a + hair-despoiler, for which he was arrested but not sentenced. + (_Archives de l'Anthropologie Criminelle_, vol. v, No. 28.) + + I have elsewhere recorded the history of a boy of 14, having + already had imperfect connection with a grown-up woman, who + associated much with a young married lady; he had no sexual + relations with her, but one day she urinated in his presence, and + he saw that her mons veneris was covered by very thick hair; from + that time he worshiped this woman in secret and acquired a + life-long fetichistic attraction to women whose pubic hair was + similarly abundant (_Studies in the Psychology of Sex_, vol. iii, + Appendix B, History V). + + Roubaud reported the case of a general's son, sexually initiated + at the age of 14 by a blonde young lady of 21 who, in order to + avoid detection, always retained her clothing: gaiters, a corset + and a silk dress; when the boy's studies were completed and he + was sent to a garrison where he could enjoy freedom he found that + his sexual desires could only be aroused by blonde women dressed + like the lady who had first aroused his sexual desires; + consequently he gave up all thoughts of matrimony, as a woman in + nightclothes produced impotence (_Traité de l'Impuissance_, p. + 439). Krafft-Ebing records the somewhat similar case of a nervous + Polish boy of old family seduced at the age of 17 by a French + governess, who during several months practiced mutual + masturbation with him; in this way his attention became + attracted by her very elegant boots, and in the end he became a + confirmed boot-fetichist (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, English + translation, p. 249). + + A boy of 7, of bad heredity, was taught to masturbate by a + servant girl; on one occasion she practiced this on him with her + foot without taking off her shoe; it was the first time the + manoeuvre gave him any pleasure, and an association was thus + established which led to shoe-fetichism (Hammond, _Sexual + Impotence_, p. 44). A government official whose first coitus in + youth took place on a staircase; the sound of his partner's + creaking shoes against the stairs, produced by her efforts to + accelerate orgasm, formed an association which developed into an + auditory shoe-fetichism; in the streets he was compelled to + follow ladies whose shoes creaked, ejaculation being thus + produced, while to obtain complete satisfaction he would make a + prostitute, otherwise naked, sit in front of him in her shoes, + moving her feet so that the shoes creaked. (Moraglia, _Archivio + di Psichiatria_, vol. xiii, p. 568.) + + Bechterew, in St. Petersburg, has recorded the case of a man who + when a child used to fall asleep at the knees of his nurse with + his head buried in the folds of her apron; in this position he + first experienced erection and voluptuous sensations; when a + youth he had no attraction to naked women, and in real life and + in dreams was only excited sexually under conditions recalling + his early experience; in his relations with women he preferred + them dressed, and was excited by the rustling sound of their + skirts; in this case there was no traceable neuropathic taint nor + any other personal peculiarity. (Summarized in _Journal de + Psychologie Normale et Pathologique_, January-February, 1904, p. + 72.) + + In a curious case recorded in detail by Moll, a philologist of + sensitive temperament but sound heredity, who had always been + fond of flowers, at the age of 21 became engaged to a young lady + who wore large roses fastened in her jacket; from this time roses + became to him a sexual fetich, to kiss them caused erection, and + his erotic dreams were accompanied by visions of roses and the + hallucination of their odor; the engagement was finally broken + off and the rose-fetichism disappeared (_Untersuchungen über + Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 540). + +Such associations may naturally occur in the early experiences of even the +most normal persons. The degree to which they will influence the +subsequent life and thought and feeling depends on the degree of the +individual's morbid emotional receptivity, on the extent to which he is +hereditarily susceptible of abnormal deviation. Precocity is undoubtedly a +condition which favors such deviation; a child who is precociously and +abnormally sensitive to persons of the opposite sex before puberty has +established the normal channels of sexual desire, is peculiarly liable to +become the prey of a chance symbolism. All degrees of such symbolism are +possible. While the average insensitive person may fail to perceive them +at all, for the more alert and imaginative lover they are a fascinating +part of the highly charged crystallization of passion. A more nervously +exceptional person, when once such a symbolism has become firmly +implanted, may find it an absolutely essential element in the charm of a +beloved and charming person. Finally, for the individual who is thoroughly +unsound the symbol becomes generalized; a person is no longer desired at +all, being merely regarded as an appendage of the symbol, or being +dispensed with altogether; the symbol is alone desired, and is fully +adequate to impart by itself complete sexual gratification. While it must +be considered a morbid state to demand a symbol as an almost essential +part of the charm of a desired person, it is only in the final condition, +in which the symbol becomes all-sufficing, that we have a true and +complete perversion. In the less complete forms of symbolism it is still +the woman who is desired, and the ends of procreation may be served; when +the woman is ignored and the mere symbol is an adequate and even preferred +stimulus to detumescence the pathological condition becomes complete. + +Krafft-Ebing regarded shoe-fetichism as, in large measure, a more or less +latent form of masochism, the foot or the shoe being the symbol of the +subjection and humiliation which the masochist feels in the presence of +the beloved object. Moll is also inclined to accept such a connection. + + "The very numerous class of boot-and-shoe-fetichists," + Krafft-Ebing wrote, "forms the transition to the manifestations + of another independent perversion, i.e., fetichism itself; but it + stands in closer relationship to the former.... It is highly + probable, and shown by a correct classification of the observed + cases, that the majority, and perhaps all of the cases of + shoe-fetichism, rest upon a basis of more or less conscious + masochistic desire for self-humiliation.... The majority or all + may be looked upon as instances of latent masochism (the motive + remaining unconscious) in which the _female foot or shoe, as the + masochist's fetich_, has acquired an independent significance." + (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, English translation of tenth edition, + pp. 159, et seq.) "Though Krafft-Ebing may not have cleared up + the whole matter," Moll remarks, "I regard his deductions + concerning the connection of foot-and-shoe fetichism to masochism + as the most important progress that has been made in the + theoretic study of sexual perversions.... In any case, the + connection is very frequent." (_Konträre Sexualempfindung_, third + edition, p. 306.) + +It is quite easy to see that this supposed identity of masochism and +foot-fetichism forms a seductive theory. It is also undoubtedly true that +a masochist may very easily be inclined to find in his mistress's foot an +aid to the ecstatic self-abnegation which he desires to attain.[20] But +only confusion is attained by any general attempt to amalgamate masochism +and foot-fetichism. In the broad sense in which erotic symbolism is here +understood, both masochism and foot-fetichism may be coördinated as +symbolisms; for the masochist his self-humiliating impulses are the symbol +of ecstatic adoration; for the foot-fetichist his mistress's foot or shoe +is the concentrated symbol of all that is most beautiful and elegant and +feminine in her personality. But if in this sense they are coördinated, +they remain entirely distinct and have not even any necessary tendency to +become merged. Masochism merely simulates foot-fetichism; for the +masochist the boot is not strictly a symbol, it is only an instrument +which enables him to carry out his impulse; the true sexual symbol for him +is not the boot, but the emotion of self-subjection. For the +foot-fetichist, on the other hand, the foot or the shoe is not a mere +instrument, but a true symbol; the focus of his worship, an idealized +object which he is content to contemplate or reverently touch. He has no +necessary impulse to any self-degrading action, nor any constant emotion +of subjection. It may be noted that in the very typical case of +foot-fetichism which is presented to us in the person of Restif de la +Bretonne (_ante_, p. 18), he repeatedly speaks of "subjecting" the woman +for whom he feels this fetichistic adoration, and mentions that even when +still a child he especially admired a delicate and fairy-like girl in this +respect because she seemed to him easier to subjugate. Throughout life +Restif's attitude toward women was active and masculine, without the +slightest trace of masochism.[21] + +To suppose that a fetichistic admiration of his mistress's foot is due to +a lover's latent desire to be kicked, is as unreasonable as it would be to +suppose that a fetichistic admiration for her hand indicated a latent +desire to have his ears boxed. In determining whether we are concerned +with a case of foot-fetichism or of masochism we must take into +consideration the whole of the subject's mental and emotional attitude. An +act, however definite, will not suffice as a criterion, for the same act +in different persons may have altogether different implications. To +amalgamate the two is the result of inadequate psychological analysis and +only leads to confusion. + +It is, however, often very difficult to decide whether we are dealing with +a case which is predominantly one of masochism or of foot-fetichism. The +nature of the action desired, as we have seen, will not suffice to +determine the psychological character of the perversion. Krafft-Ebing +believed that the desire to be trodden on, very frequently experienced by +masochists, is absolutely symptomatic of masochism.[22] This is scarcely +the case. The desire to be trodden on may be fundamentally an erotic +symbolism, closely approaching foot-fetichism, and such slight indications +of masochism as appear may be merely a parasitic growth on the symbolism, +a growth perhaps more suggested by the circumstances involved in the +gratification of the abnormal desire than inherent in the innate impulse +of the subject. This may be illustrated by the interesting case of a very +intelligent man with whom I am well acquainted. + + C.P., aged 38. Heredity good. Parents both healthy and normal. + Several children of the marriage, all sexually normal so far as + is known. C.P. is the youngest of the family and separated from + the others by an interval of many years. He was a seven-months' + child. He has always enjoyed good health and is active and + vigorous, both mentally and physically. + + From the age of 9 or 10 to 14 he masturbated occasionally for the + sake of physical relief, having discovered the act for himself. + He was, however, quite innocent and knew nothing of sexual + matters, never having been initiated either by servants or by + other boys. + + "When I encounter a woman who very strongly attracts me and whom + I very greatly admire," he writes, "my desire is never that I may + have sexual connection with her in the ordinary sense, but that I + may lie down upon the floor on my back and be trampled upon by + her. This curious desire is seldom present unless the object of + my admiration is really a lady, and of fine proportions. She must + be richly dressed--preferably in an evening gown, and wear dainty + high-heeled slippers, either quite open so as to show the curve + of the instep, or with only one strap or 'bar' across. The skirts + should be raised sufficiently to afford me the pleasure of seeing + her feet and a liberal amount of ankle, but in no case above the + knee, or the effect is greatly reduced. Although I often greatly + admire a woman's intellect and even person, sexually no other + part of her has any serious attraction for me except the leg, + from the knee downwards, and the foot, and these must be + exquisitely clothed. Given this condition, my desire amounts to a + wish to gratify my sexual sense by contact with the (to me) + attractive part of the woman. Comparatively few women have a leg + or foot sufficiently beautiful to my mind to excite any serious + or compelling desire, but when this is so, or I suspect it, I am + willing to spend any time or trouble to get her to tread upon me + and am anxious to be trampled on with the greatest severity. + + "The treading should be inflicted for a few minutes all over the + chest, abdomen and groin, and lastly on the penis, which is, of + course, lying along the belly in a violent state of erection, and + consequently too hard for the treading to damage it. I also enjoy + being nearly strangled by a woman's foot. + + "If the lady finally stands facing my head and places her slipper + upon my penis so that the high heel falls about where the penis + leaves the scrotum, the sole covering most of the rest of it and + with the other foot upon the abdomen, into which I can _see_ as + well as feel it sink as she shifts her weight from one foot to + the other, orgasm takes place almost at once. Emission under + these conditions is to me an agony of delight, during which + practically the lady's whole weight should rest upon the penis. + + "One reason for my special pleasure in this method seems to be + that first the heel and afterwards the sole of the slipper as it + treads upon the penis greatly check the passage of the semen and + consequently the pleasure is considerably prolonged. There is + also a curious mental side to the affair. I love to imagine that + the lady who is treading upon me is my mistress and I her slave, + and that she is doing it to punish me for some fault, or to give + _herself_ (not me) pleasure. + + "It follows that the greater the contempt and severity with which + I am 'punished,' the greater becomes my pleasure. The idea of + 'punishment' or 'slavery' is seldom aroused except when I have + great difficulty in accomplishing my desire and the treader is + more than usually handsome and heavy and the trampling + mercilessly inflicted. I have been trampled so long and so + mercilessly several times, that I have flinched each time the + slipper pressed its way into my aching body and have been black + and blue for days afterwards. I take the greatest interest in + leading ladies on to do this for me where I think I will not + offend, and have been surprisingly successful. I must have lain + beneath the feet of quite a hundred women, many of them of good + social position, who would never dream of permitting any ordinary + sexual intercourse, but who have been so interested or amused by + the idea as to do it for me--many of them over and over again. It + is perhaps needless to say that none of my own or the ladies' + clothing is ever removed, or disarranged, for the accomplishment + of orgasm in this manner. After a long and varied experience, I + may say that my favorite weight is 10 to 11 stone, and that + black, very high-heeled slippers, in combination with tan silk + stockings, seem to give me the greatest pleasure and create in me + the strongest desires. + + "Boots, or outdoor shoes, do not attract me to anything like the + same degree, although I have, upon several occasions, enjoyed + myself fairly well by their use. Nude women repel me, and I find + no pleasure in seeing a woman in tights. I am not averse to + normal sexual connection and occasionally employ it. To me, + however, the pleasure is far inferior to that of being trampled + upon. I also derive keen pleasure--and usually have a strong + erection--from seeing a woman, dressed as I have described, tread + upon anything which yields under her foot--such as the seat of a + carriage, the cushions of a punt, a footstool, etc., and I enjoy + seeing her crush flowers by treading upon them. I have often + strolled along in the wake of some handsome lady at a picnic or + garden party, for the pleasure of seeing the grass upon which she + has trodden rise slowly again after her foot has pressed it. I + delight also to see a carriage sway as a woman leaves or enters + it--anything which needs the pressure of the foot. + + "To pass now to the origin of this direction of my feelings. + + "Even in early childhood I admired pretty feminine foot-gear, and + in the contemplation of it experienced vague sensations which I + now recognize as sexual. When a lad of 14 or so, I stayed a good + deal at the house of some intimate friends of my parents, the + daughter of the house--an only child--a beautiful and powerful + girl, about six years my senior, being my special chum. This girl + was always daintily dressed, and having most lovely feet and + ankles not unnaturally knew it. Whenever possible she dressed so + as to show off their beauty to the best advantage--rather short + skirts and usually little high-heeled slippers--and was not + averse to showing them in a most distractingly coquettish manner. + She seemed to have a passion for treading upon things which would + scrunch or yield under her foot, such as flowers, little + windfallen apples and pears, acorns, etc., or heaps of hay, straw + or cut grass. As we wandered about the gardens--for we were left + to do exactly as we liked--I got quite accustomed to seeing her + hunt out and tread upon such things, and used to chaff her about + it. At that time I was--as I am still--fond of lying at full + length on a thick hearthrug before a good fire. One evening as I + was lying in this way and we were alone, A. crossed the room to + reach a bangle from the mantelpiece. Instead of reaching over me, + she playfully stepped upon my body, saying that she would show me + how the hay and straw felt. Naturally I fell in with the joke and + laughed. After standing upon me a few moments she raised her + skirt slightly and, holding on to the mantelpiece for support, + stretched out one dainty foot in its brown silk stocking and + high-heeled slipper to the blaze to warm, while looking down and + laughing at my scarlet, excited face. She was a perfectly frank + and charming girl, and I feel pretty certain that, although she + evidently enjoyed my excitement and the feeling of my body + yielding under her feet, she did not on this first occasion + clearly understand my condition; nor can I remember that, though + the desire for sexual gratification drove me nearly mad, it + appeared to awaken in her any reciprocal feeling. I took hold of + her raised foot and, after kissing it, guided it by an absolutely + irresistible impulse on to my penis, which was as hard as wood + and seemed almost bursting. Almost at the moment that her weight + was thrown upon it, orgasm took place for the first time in my + life thoroughly and effectively. No description can give any idea + of what I felt--I only know that from that moment my distorted + sexual focus was fixed forever. Numberless times, after that + evening, I felt the weight of her dainty slippers, and nothing + will ever cause the memory of the pleasure she thus gave me to + fade. I know that A. came to enjoy treading upon me, as much as I + enjoyed having her do it. She had a liberal dress allowance and, + seeing the pleasure they gave me, she was always buying pretty + stockings and ravishing slippers with the highest and most + slender Louis heels she could find and would show them to me with + the greatest glee, urging me to lie down that she might try them + on me. She confessed that she loved to see and feel them sink + into my body as she trod upon me and enjoyed the crunch of the + muscles under her heel as she moved about. After some minutes of + this, I always guided her slipper on to my penis, and she would + tread carefully, but with her whole weight--probably about 9 + stone--and watch me with flashing eyes, flushed cheeks, and + quivering lips, as she felt--as she must have done plainly--the + throbbing and swelling of my penis under her foot as emission + took place. I have not the smallest doubt that orgasm took place + simultaneously with her, though we never at any time spoke openly + of it. This went on for several years on almost every favorable + opportunity we had, and after a month or two of separation + sometimes four or five times during a single day. Several times + during A.'s absence I masturbated by getting her slipper and + pressing it with all my strength against the penis while + imagining that she was treading upon me. The pleasure was, of + course, very inferior to her attentions. There was never at any + time between us any question of normal sexual intercourse, and we + were both well content to let things drift as they were. + + "A little after 20 I went abroad, and on my return about three + years later I found her married. Although we met often, the + subject was never alluded to, though we remained firm friends. I + confess I often, when I could do so without being seen, looked + longingly at her feet and would have gladly accepted the pleasure + she could have given me by an occasional resumption of our + strange practice--but it never came. + + "I went abroad again, and now neither she nor her husband are + alive and leave no issue. From time to time I have had occasional + relations with prostitutes, but always in this manner, though I + much prefer to find some lady of or above my own social position + who will do the treading for me. This is, however, interestingly + difficult. + + "Out of say a hundred women (which at home and abroad is what I + should estimate must have stood upon my body) I should say quite + 80 or 85 were _not_ prostitutes. Certainly not more than 10 to 12 + shared any _sexual_ excitement, but while they were evidently + excited they were not gratified. A. alone, so far as I know, had + complete sexual satisfaction of it. I have never asked a woman in + so many words to tread upon me for the purpose of gratifying my + sexual desires (prostitutes excepted), but have always tempted + them to do it in a jocular or teasing manner, and it is very + doubtful if more than a few (married) women really understood, + even after they had given me the extreme pleasure, that they had + done so, because any flushing and movement on my part under their + feet was not unnaturally put down to the trampling to which they + were subjecting me, and it was easy for me to guide the foot as + often as was necessary on to the penis till orgasm took place, + and even to keep it there by laying hold of the other one to kiss + it or on some other pretext during emission. Of course many + understood after once doing it (most have done it only once) what + I was at, and, although they did not ever discuss it nor did I, + they were not unwilling to give me as many treadings as I cared + to playfully suggest. I don't think they got any pleasure + sexually out of it themselves, though they could see plainly that + I did, and they did not object to give it me. I have spent as + long as twelve months with some women working gradually nearer + and nearer to my desire--often getting what I want in the end, + but more often failing. I _never_ risk it till I am certain it + would be safe to ask it, and have never had a serious rebuff. In + very many cases I should say the doing of what I want has simply + been regarded by the woman as gratifying a silly and perhaps + amusing whim, in which, beyond the novelty of treading on a man's + body, she has taken but little interest. + + "As in normal seduction, the endeavor to win the woman over to do + what I want without arousing her antagonism is a great part of + the charm to me, and naturally the better her social position the + more difficult this becomes--and the more attractive. I have + found that in three instances prostitutes have performed the same + office for other men and knew all about it. It is not + uninteresting to note that these three women were all of fine, + massive build--one standing about 5 feet 10 inches and weighing + nearly 14 stone--but with comparatively uninteresting faces. The + weight, build and clothing count for a good deal in exciting me. + I find that a sudden check to a man at the supreme moment of + sexual pleasure tends to heighten and prolong the pleasure. My + physical satisfaction is due to the fact that by getting the lady + to stand with all her weight upon my penis (as it lies between + her foot and the soft bed of my own body into which it is deeply + pressed) the act of emission is enormously prolonged, with + corresponding enjoyment. For this reason also I prefer a very + high-heeled slipper. The seminal fluid has to be forced past two + separate obstacles--the pressure of the heel close at the root of + the penis and afterwards the ball of the foot which compresses + the outer half, leaving a free portion between them under the + arched sole of the slipper. I may add that the pleasure is + greatly increased by the retention of the urine, and I always try + to retain as much water as I dare. I have an unconquerable + aversion to red in slippers or stockings; it will even cause + impotence. Why, I know not. Strange as it may seem, although pain + and bruising are often inflicted by a severe treading, I have + never been in any way injured by the practice, and my pleasure in + it seems not to diminish by constant repetition. The comparative + difficulty of obtaining the pleasure from just the woman I want + has a never-ending, if inexplicable, charm for me." + + It will be observed that in this case special importance is + attached to shoes with high heels, and the subject considers that + the pressure of such shoes is for mechanical reasons most + favorable for procuring ejaculation. Nearly all heterosexual + shoe-fetichists seem, however, to be equally attracted by high + heels. Restif de la Bretonne frequently referred to this point, + and he gave a number of reasons for the attractiveness of high + heels: (1) They are unlike men's boots and, therefore, have a + sexual fascination; (2) they make the leg and foot look more + charming; (3) they give a less bold and more sylph-like character + to the walk; (4) they keep the feet clean. (Restif de la + Bretonne, _Nuits de Paris_, vol. v, quoted in Preface to his _Mes + Inscriptions_, p. ciii.) It is doubtless the first reason--the + fact that high heels are a kind of secondary sexual + character--which is most generally potent in this attraction. + +The foregoing history, while it very distinctly brings before us a case of +erotic symbolism, is not strictly an example of shoe-fetichism. The +symbolism is more complex. The focus of beauty in a desirable woman is +transferred and concentrated in the region below the knee; in that sense +we have foot-fetichism. But the act of coitus itself is also symbolically +transferred. Not only has the foot become the symbol of the vulva, but +trampling has become the symbol of coitus; intercourse takes place +symbolically _per pedem_. It is a result of this symbolization of the foot +and of trampling that all acts of treading take on a new and symbolical +sexual charm. The element of masochism--of pleasure in being a woman's +slave--is a parasitic growth; that is to say, it is not founded in the +subject's constitution, but chances to have found a favorable soil in the +special circumstances under which his sexual life developed. It is not +primary, but secondary, and remains an unimportant and merely occasional +element. + +It may be instructive to bring forward for comparison a case in which also +we have a symbolism involving boot-fetichism, but extending beyond it. In +this case there is a basis of inversion (as is not infrequent in erotic +symbolisms), but from the present point of view the psychological +significance of the case remains the same. + + A.N., aged 29, unmarried, healthy, though not robust, and without + any known hereditary taint. Has followed various avocations + without taking great interest in them, but has shown some + literary ability. + + "I am an Englishman," his own narrative runs, "the third of three + children. At my birth my father was 41 and my mother 34. My + mother died of cancer when I was 15. My father is still alive, a + reserved man, who still nurses his sorrow for his wife's death. I + have no reason to believe my parents anything but normal and + useful members of society. My sister is normal and happily + married. My brother I have reason to believe to be an invert. + + "A horoscope cast for me describes me in a way I think correct, + and so do my friends: 'A mild, obliging, gentle, amiable person, + with many fine traits of character; timid in nature, fond of + society, loving peace and quietude, delighting in warm and close + friendships. There is much that is firm, steadfast and + industrious, some self-love, a good deal of diplomacy, a little + that is subtle, or what is called finesse. You are reserved with + those you dislike. There is a serious and sad side to your + character; you are very thoughtful and contemplative when in + these moods. But you are not pessimistic. You have superior + abilities, for they are intuitively intellectual. There is a cold + reticence which restrains generous impulses and which inclines to + acquisitiveness; it will make you deliberate, inventive, adding + self-esteem, some vanity.' + + "At an early age I was left much alone in the nursery and there + contracted the habit of masturbation long before the age of + puberty. I use the word 'masturbation' for want of a better, + though it may not quite describe my case. I have never used my + hand to the penis. As far back as I can remember I have had what + a Frenchman has described as 'le fetichisme de la chaussure,' and + in those early days, before I was 6 years old, I would put on my + father's boots, taken from a cupboard at hand, and then tying or + strapping my legs together would produce an erection, and all the + pleasurable feelings experienced, I suppose, by means of + masturbation. I always did this secretly, but couldn't tell why. + I continued this practice on and off all my boyhood and youth. + When I discovered the first emission I was much surprised. I + always did this thing without loosening my trousers. As to how + these feelings arose I am totally unable to say. I can't remember + being without such feelings, and they seem to me perfectly + normal. The sight, or even thought, of high boots, or leggings, + especially if well polished or in patent leather, would set all + my sexual passions aflame, and does yet. As a boy my great desire + was to wear these things. A soldier in boots and spurs, a groom + in tops, or even an errand-boy in patent leather leggings, + fascinated me, and to this day, despite reason and everything + else. The sight of such things produced an erection. An emission + I could always produce by tightly tying my legs together, but + only when wearing boots, and preferably leggings, which when I + had pocket money I bought for this purpose. (At the present + moment I have five pairs in the house and two pairs of high + boots, quite unjustified by ordinary use.) This habit I lapse + into yet at times. The smell of leather affects me, but I never + know how far this may be due to association with boots; the smell + suggests the image. Restraint by a leather strap is more exciting + than by cords. Erotic dreams always take the form of restraint on + the limbs when booted. + + "Uniforms and liveries have a great temptation for me, but only + when of a tight-fitting nature and smart, as soldiers', grooms', + etc., but not sailors'; most powerfully when the person is in + boots or leggings and breeches. + + "I was a quiet, sensitive boy, taking no part in games or sports. + Have always been indifferent to them. I made few friends, but + didn't want them. The craving for friendship came much later, + after I was 21. I was a day boy at a private school, and never + had any conversation with any boy on sexual matters, though I was + dimly aware of much 'nastiness' about the school. I knew nothing + of sodomy. But all these things were repulsive to me, + notwithstanding my secret practices. I was a 'good boy.' + + "Up to the age of 21 I was perfectly satisfied with my own + society, something of a prig, fond of books and reading, etc. I + was and ever have been absolutely insensible to the influence of + the other sex. I am not a woman hater, and take intellectual + pleasure in the society of certain ladies, but they are nearly + all much older than myself. I have a strong repulsion from sexual + relations with women. I should not mind being married for the + sake of companionship and for the sake of having boys of my own. + But the sexual act would frighten me. I could not in my present + frame of mind go to bed with a woman. Yet I feel an immense envy + of my married friends in that they are able to give out, and find + satisfaction for, their affection in a way that is quite + impossible for me. I picture certain boys in the place of the + wife. + + "I am now only happy in the society of men younger than myself, + age 17 to (say) 23 or 24, youths with smooth faces, or first sign + of hair on lip, well groomed, slightly effeminate in feature, of + sympathetic, perhaps weak nature. I feel I want to help them, do + something for them, devote myself entirely to their welfare. + + "With such there is no fixed line between friendship and love. I + yearn for intimacy with particular friends, but never dare + express it. I find so many people object to any strong expression + of feeling that I dare not run the risk of appearing ridiculous + in the eyes of these desired intimates. + + "I have no desire for _pædicatio_, but the idea itself does not + repulse me or seem unnatural, though personally it repels me a + little. But I think this to be mere prejudice on my part, which + might be broken down if the loved person showed a willingness to + act a passive part. I should never dare to make an advance, + however. + + "I am restrained by moral and religious considerations from + making my real feelings known, and I feel I should sink in my own + estimation if I gave way, though my natural desire is to do so. + In the face of opportunities (not I mean of _pædicatio_, but of + expression of excessive affection, etc.), or what might be such, + I always fail to speak lest I should forfeit the esteem of the + other person. I have a feeling of surprise when any one I like + evinces a liking for me. I feel that those I love are + immeasurably my superiors, though my reason may tell me it is not + so. I would grovel at their feet, do anything to win a smile from + them, or to make them give me their company. + + "Ordinary bodily contact with the boy I love gives me most + exquisite pleasure, and I never lose an opportunity of bringing + such contact about when it can be done naturally. I feel an + immense desire to embrace, kiss, squeeze, etc., the person, to + generally maul him, and say nice things--the kind of things a man + usually says to a woman. A handshake, the mere presence of the + person, makes me happy and content. + + "I can say with the Albanian: 'If I find myself in the presence + of the beloved, I rest absorbed in gazing on him. Absent, I think + of nought but him. If the beloved unexpectedly appears I fall + into confusion. My heart beats faster. I have eyes and ears only + for the beloved.' + + "I feel that my capacity of affection is finer and more spiritual + than that which commonly subsists between persons of different + sexes. And so, while trying to fight my instincts by religion, I + find my natural feeling to be part of my religion, and its + highest expression. In this sense I can speak from experience in + my own case, and more especially in that of my brother, that what + you have said about philanthropic activity resulting from + repressed homosexuality is very true indeed. I can say with one + of your female cases: 'Love is to me a religion. The very nature + of my affection for my friends precludes the possibility of any + element entering into it which is not absolutely pure and + sacred.' I am, however, madly jealous. I want entire possession, + and I can't bear for a moment that any one I do not care for + should know the person I love. + + "I am never attracted by men older than myself. The youths who + attract me may be of any class, though preferably, I think, of a + class a little lower than myself. I am not quite sure of this, + however, as circumstances may have contributed more than + deliberate choice to bring certain youths under my notice. Those + who have exercised the most powerful influence on me have been an + Oxford undergraduate, a barber's assistant, and a plumber's + apprentice. Though naturally fond of intellectual society, I do + not ask for intellect in those I love. It goes for nothing. I + always prefer their company to that of the most educated persons. + This preference has alienated me to some extent from more refined + and educated circles that formerly I was intimate with. + + "I have been led entirely out of my old habits by association + with younger friends, and now do things which before I should + never have dreamed of doing. My thoughts now are always with + certain youths, and if they speak of leaving the town, or in any + way talk of a future that I cannot share, I suffer horrid + sinkings of the heart and depression of spirits." + +This case, while it concerns a person of quite different temperament, with +a more innate predisposition to specific perversions, is yet in many +respects analogous to the previous case. There is boot-fetichism; nothing +is felt to be so attractive as the foot-gear, and there is also at the +same time more than this; there is the attraction of repression and +constraint developed into a sexual symbol. In C.P.'s case that symbolism +arises from the experience of an abnormal heterosexual relationship; in +A.N.'s case it is founded on auto-erotic experiences associated with +inversion; in both alike the entire symbolism has become diffused and +generalized. + +In the two cases just brought forward we have an erotic symbolism of act +founded on, and closely associated with, an erotic symbolism of object. It +may be instructive to bring forward another case in which no fetichistic +feeling toward an object can be traced, but an erotic symbolism still +clearly exists. In this case pain, even when self-inflicted, has acquired +a symbolic value as a stimulus to tumescence, without any element of +masochism. Such a case serves to indicate how the sexual attraction of +pain is really a special case of the erotic symbolism with which we are +here concerned. + + A.W., aged 50, a writer and lecturer, physically and mentally + energetic and enjoying good health. He is, however, very + emotional and of nervous temperament, but self-controlled. Though + physically well developed, the sexual organs are small. He is + married to an attractive woman, to whom he is much attached, and + has two healthy children. + + At 10 or 12 years of age he had a frequent desire to be whipped, + his parents never having struck him, and on one occasion he asked + a brother to go with him to the closet to get him to whip him on + the posterior; but on arrival he was too shy to make the request. + He did not recognize the cause of these desires, knowing nothing + of such things except from the misinformation of his + school-fellows' talk. As far as he can remember, he was an + entirely normal, healthy boy up to the age of about 15, when his + attention was arrested by an advertisement of a quack medicine + for the results of "youthful excesses." + + Being a city boy, he was unfamiliar with the coupling even of + animals, had never had a conscious erection and did not know of + frictional excitement. Experiment, however, resulted in an + orgasm, and, though believing that it was wicked or at least weak + and degrading, he indulged in masturbation at intervals, usually + about six times a month, and has continued even up to the + present. + + He had an abnormally small opening in the prepuce, making the + uncovering of the glans almost impossible. (At the age of about + 37, he himself slit the prepuce by three or four cuts of a + scissors at intervals of about ten days. This was followed by a + marked decrease in desire, especially as he shortly afterwards + learned the importance of local cleanliness.) While in college at + about the age of 19 he began to have nocturnal emissions + occasionally and once or twice a week when at stool. Alarmed by + these, he consulted a physician, who warned him of the danger, + gave him bromide and prescribed cold bathing of the parts, with a + hard, cool bed. These stopped the emissions. + + He never had connection with women until the age of about 25, and + then only three times until his marriage at 30 years of age, + being deterred partly by conscientious scruples, but more by + shyness and convention, and deriving very little pleasure from + these instances. Even since marriage he has derived more pleasure + from sexual excitement than from coitus, and can maintain + erection for as long as two hours. + + He has always been accustomed to torture himself in various + ingenious ways, nearly always connected with sex. He would burn + his skin deeply with red hot wire in inconspicuous places. These + and similar acts were generally followed by manual excitation + nearly always brought to a climax. + + He considers that he is attracted to refined and intellectual + women. But he is without very ardent desires, having several + times gone to bed with attractive women who stripped themselves + naked, but without attempting any sexual intercourse with them. + He became interested in the "Karezza" theory and has tried to + practice it with his wife, but could never entirely control the + emission. + + He has hired a masseur to whip him, as children are whipped, with + a heavy dog whip, which caused pleasurable excitement. During + this time he had relations with his wife generally about once a + week without any great ecstasy. She was cold and sexually slow, + owing to conventional sex repression and to an idea that the + whole thing was "like animals" and to fear of child-bearing, + usually necessitating the use of a cover or withdrawal. It was + only eight years after their marriage that she desired and + obtained a child. During these years he would often stick pins + through his mammæ and tie them together by a string round the + pins drawn so short as to cause great pain and then indulge + himself in the sexual act. He used strong wooden clips with a + tack fixed in them, so as to pierce and pinch the mammæ, and once + he drove a pin entirely through the penis itself, then obtaining + orgasm by friction. He was never able to get an automatic + emission in this way, though he often tried, not even by walking + briskly during an erection. + +In another class of cases a purely ideal symbolism may be present by means +of a fetich which acts as a powerful stimulus without itself being felt to +possess any attraction. A good illustration of this condition is furnished +by a case which has been communicated to me by a medical correspondent in +New Zealand. + + "The patient went out to South Africa as a trooper with the + contingent from New Zealand, throwing up a good position in an + office to do so. He had never had any trouble as regards + connection with women before going out to South Africa. While in + active service at the front he sustained a nasty fall from his + horse, breaking his leg. He was unconscious for four days, and + was then invalided down to Cape Town. Here he rapidly got well, + and his accustomed health returning to him he started having what + he terms 'a good time.' He repeatedly went to brothels, but was + unable to have more than a temporary erection, and no ejaculation + would take place. In one of these places he was in company with a + drunken trooper, who suggested that they should perform the + sexual act with their boots and spurs (only) on. My patient, who + was also drunk, readily assented, and to his surprise was enabled + to perform the act of copulation without any difficulty at all. + He has repeatedly tried since to perform the act without any + spurs, but is quite unable to do so; with the spurs he has no + difficulty at all in obtaining all the gratification he desires. + His general health is good. His mother was an extremely nervous + woman, and so is his sister. His father died when he was quite + young. His only other relation in the colony is a married sister, + who seems to enjoy vigorous health." + +The consideration of the cases here brought forward may suffice to show +that beyond those fetichisms which find their satisfaction in the +contemplation of a part of the body or a garment, there is a more subtle +symbolism. The foot is a center of force, an agent for exerting pressure, +and thus it furnishes a point of departure not alone for the merely static +sexual fetich, but for a dynamic erotic symbolization. The energy of its +movements becomes a substitute for the energy of the sexual organs +themselves in coitus, and exerts the same kind of fascination. The young +girl (page 35) "who seemed to have a passion for treading upon things +which would scrunch or yield under her foot," already possessed the germs +of an erotic symbolism which, under the influence of circumstances in +which she herself took an active part, developed into an adequate method +of sexual gratification.[23] The youth who was her partner learned, in the +same way, to find an erotic symbolism in all the pressure reactions of +attractive feminine feet, the swaying of a carriage beneath their weight, +the crushing of the flowers on which they tread, the slow rising of the +grass which they have pressed. Here we have a symbolism which is +altogether different from that fetichism which adores a definite object; +it is a dynamic symbolism finding its gratification in the spectacle of +movements which ideally recall the fundamental rhythm and pressure +reactions of the sexual process. + +We may trace a very similar erotic symbolism in an absolutely normal form. +The fascination of clothes in the lover's eyes is no doubt a complex +phenomenon, but in part it rests on the aptitudes of a woman's garments to +express vaguely a dynamic symbolism which must always remain indefinite +and elusive, and on that account always possess fascination. No one has so +acutely described this symbolism as Herrick, often an admirable +psychologist in matters of sexual attractiveness. Especially instructive +in this respect are his poems, "Delight in Disorder," "Upon Julia's +Clothes," and notably "Julia's Petticoat." "A sweet disorder in the +dress," he tells us, "kindles in clothes a wantonness;" it is not on the +garment itself, but on the character of its movement that he insists; on +the "erring lace," the "winning wave" of the "tempestuous petticoat;" he +speaks of the "liquefaction" of clothes, their "brave vibration each way +free," and of Julia's petticoat he remarks with a more specific symbolism +still, + + "Sometimes 'twould pant and sigh and heave, + As if to stir it scarce had leave; + But having got it, thereupon, + 'Twould make a brave expansion." + +In the play of the beloved woman's garment, he sees the whole process of +the central act of sex, with its repressions and expansions, and at the +sight is himself ready to "fall into a swoon." + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[13] G. Stanley Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. ii, p. 113. It will be noted +that the hand does not appear among the parts of the body which are +normally of supreme interest. An interest in the hand is by no means +uncommon (it may be noted, for instance, in the course of History XII in +Appendix B to vol. iii of these _Studies_), but the hand does not possess +the mystery which envelops the foot, and hand-fetichism is very much less +frequent than foot-fetichism, while glove-fetichism is remarkably rare. An +interesting case of hand-fetichism, scarcely reaching morbid intensity, is +recorded by Binet, _Etudes de Psychologie Expérimentale_, pp. 13-19; and +see Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, pp. 214 et seq. + +[14] _Mémoires_, vol. i, Chapter VII. + +[15] Among leading English novelists Hardy shows an unusual but by no +means predominant interest in the feet and shoes of his heroines; see, +e.g., the observations of the cobbler in _Under the Greenwood Tree_, +Chapter III. A chapter in Goethe's _Wahlverwandtschaften_ (Part I, Chapter +II) contains an episode involving the charm of the foot and the kissing of +the beloved's shoe. + +[16] Schinz, "Philosophie des Conventions Sociales," _Revue +Philosophique_, June, 1903, p. 626. Mirabeau mentions in his _Erotika +Biblion_ that modern Greek women sometimes use their feet to provoke +orgasm in their lovers. I may add that simultaneous mutual masturbation by +means of the feet is not unknown to-day, and I have been told by an +English shoe-fetichist that he at one time was accustomed to practice this +with a married lady (Brazilian)--she with slippers on and he without--who +derived gratification equal to his own. + +[17] Jacoby (loc. cit. pp. 796-7) gives a large number of references to +Ovid's works bearing on this point. "In reading him," he remarks, "one is +inclined to say that the psychology of the Romans was closely allied to +that of the Chinese." + +[18] R. Kleinpaul, _Sprache ohne Worte_, p. 308. See also Moll, _Konträre +Sexualempfindung_, third edition, pp. 306-308. Bloch brings together many +interesting references bearing on the ancient sexual and religious +symbolism of the shoe, _Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, +Teil II, p. 324. + +[19] Jacoby (loc. cit. p. 797) appears to regard shoe-fetichism as a true +atavism: "The sexual adoration of feminine foot-gear," he concludes, +"perhaps the most enigmatic and certainly the most singular of +degenerative insanities, is thus merely a form of atavism, the return of +the degenerate to the very ancient and primitive psychology which we no +longer understand and are no longer capable of feeling." + +[20] Moll has reported in detail (_Untersuchungen über die Libido +Sexualis_, bd. i, Teil II, pp. 320-324) a case which both he and +Krafft-Ebing regard as illustrative of the connection between +boot-fetichism and masochism. It is essentially a case of masochism, +though manifesting itself almost exclusively in the desire to perform +humiliating acts in connection with the attractive person's boots. + +[21] Krafft-Ebing goes so far as to assert (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, +English translation of tenth edition, p. 174) that "when in cases of +shoe-fetichism the female shoe appears alone as the excitant of sexual +desire one is justified in presuming that masochistic motives have +remained latent.... Latent masochism may always be assumed as the +unconscious motive." In this way he hopelessly misinterprets some of his +own cases. + +[22] Krafft-Ebing goes so far as to assert (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, +English translation, pp. 159 and 174). Yet some of the cases he brings +forward (e.g., Coxe's as quoted by Hammond) show no sign of masochism, +since, according to Krafft-Ebing's own definition (p. 116), the idea of +subjugation by the opposite sex is of the essence of masochism. + +[23] Her actions suggest that there is often a latent sexual consciousness +in regard to the feet in women, atavistic or pseudo-atavistic, and +corresponding to the sexual attraction which the feet formerly aroused, +almost normally, in men. This is also suggested by the case, referred to +by Shufeldt, of an unmarried woman, belonging to a family exhibiting in a +high degree both erotic and neurotic traits, who had "a certain +uncontrollable fascination for shoes. She delights in new shoes, and +changes her shoes all day long at regular intervals of three hours each. +She keeps this row of shoes out in plain sight in her apartment." (R.W. +Shufeldt, "On a Case of Female Impotency," 1896, p. 10.) + + + + +III. + +Scatalogic Symbolism--Urolagnia--Coprolagnia--The Ascetic Attitude Towards +the Flesh--Normal basis of Scatalogic Symbolism--Scatalogic Conceptions +Among Primitive Peoples--Urine as a Primitive Holy Water--Sacredness of +Animal Excreta--Scatalogy in Folk-lore--The Obscene as Derived from the +Mythological--The Immature Sexual Impulse Tends to Manifest Itself in +Scatalogic Forms--The basis of Physiological Connection Between the +Urinary and Genital Spheres--Urinary Fetichism Sometimes Normal in +Animals--The Urolagnia of Masochists--The Scatalogy of Saints--Urolagnia +More Often a Symbolism of Act Than a Symbolism of Object--Only +Occasionally an Olfactory Fetichism--Comparative Rarity of +Coprolagnia--Influence of Nates Fetichism as a Transition to +Coprolagnia--Ideal Coprolagnia--Olfactory Coprolagnia--Urolagnia and +Coprolagnia as Symbols of Coitus. + + +We meet with another group of erotic symbolisms--alike symbolisms of +object and of act--in connection with the two functions adjoining the +anatomical sexual focus: the urinary and alvine excretory functions. These +are sometimes termed the scatalogical group, with the two subdivisions of +urolagnia and Coprolagnia.[24] _Inter fæces et urinam nascimur_ is an +ancient text which has served the ascetic preachers of old for many +discourses on the littleness of man and the meanness of that reproductive +power which plays so large a part in man's life. "The stupid bungle of +Nature," a correspondent writes, "whereby the generative organs serve as a +means of relieving the bladder, is doubtless responsible for much of the +disgust which those organs excite in some minds." + +At the same time, it is necessary to point out, such reflex influence may +act not in one direction only, but also in the reverse direction. From +the standpoint of ascetic contemplation eager to belittle humanity, the +excretory centers may cast dishonor upon the genital center which they +adjoin. From the more ecstatic standpoint of the impassioned lover, eager +to magnify the charm of the woman he worships, it is not impossible for +the excretory centers to take on some charm from the irradiating center of +sex which they enclose. + +Even normally such a process is traceable. The normal lover may not +idealize the excretory functions of his mistress, but the fact that he +finds no repulsion in the most intimate contacts and feels no disgust at +the proximity of the excretory orifices or the existence of their +functions, indicates that the idealization of love has exerted at all +events a neutralizing influence; indeed, the presence of an acute +sensibility to the disturbing influence of this proximity of the excretory +orifices and their functions must be considered abnormal; Swift's +"Strephon and Chloe"--with the conviction underlying it that it is an easy +matter for the excretory functions to drown the possibilities of +love--could only have proceeded from a morbidly sensitive brain.[25] + +A more than mere neutralizing influence, a positively idealizing influence +of the sexual focus on the excretory processes adjoining it, may take +place in the lover's mind without the normal variations of sexual +attraction being over-passed, and even without the creation of an +excretory fetichism. + + Reflections of this attitude may be found in the poets. In the + _Song of Songs_ the lover says of his mistress, "Thy navel is + like a round goblet, wherein no mingled wine is wanting;" in his + lyric "To Dianeme," Herrick says with clear reference to the + mons veneris:-- + + "Show me that hill where smiling love doth sit, + Having a living fountain under it;" + + and in the very numerous poems in various languages which have + more or less obscurely dealt with the rose as the emblem of the + feminine pudenda there are occasional references to the stream + which guards or presides over the rose. It may, indeed, be + recalled that even in the name _nymphæ_ anatomists commonly apply + to the _labia minora_ there is generally believed to be a poetic + allusion to the Nymphs who presided over streams, since the + _labia minora_ exert an influence on the direction of the urinary + stream. + + In _Wilhelm Meister_ (Part I, Chapter XV), Goethe, on the basis + of his own personal experiences, describes his hero's emotions in + the humble surroundings of Marianne's little room as compared + with the stateliness and order of his own home. "It seemed to him + when he had here to remove her stays in order to reach the + harpsichord, there to lay her skirt on the bed before he could + seat himself, when she herself with unembarrassed frankness would + make no attempt to conceal from him many natural acts which + people are accustomed to hide from others out of decency--it + seemed to him, I say, that he became bound to her by invisible + bands." We are told of Wordsworth (Findlay's _Recollections of De + Quincey_, p. 36) that he read _Wilhelm Meister_ till "he came to + the scene where the hero, in his mistress's bedroom, becomes + sentimental over her dirty towels, etc., which struck him with + such disgust that he flung the book out of his hand, would never + look at it again, and declared that surely no English lady would + ever read such a work." I have, however, heard a woman of high + intellectual distinction refer to the peculiar truth and beauty + of this very passage. + + In one of his latest novels, _Les Rencontres de M. de Bréot_, + Henri de Régnier, one of the most notable of recent French + novelists, narrates an episode bearing on the matter before us. A + personage of the story is sitting for a moment in a dark grotto + during a night fête in a nobleman's park, when two ladies enter + and laughingly proceed to raise their garments and accomplish a + natural necessity. The man in the background, suddenly overcome + by a sexual impulse, starts forward; one lady runs away, the + other, whom he detains, offers little resistance to his advances. + To M. de Bréot, whom he shortly after encounters, he exclaims, + abashed at his own actions: "Why did I not flee? But could I + imagine that the spectacle of so disgusting a function would have + any other effect than to give me a humble opinion of human + nature?" M. de Bréot, however, in proceeding to reproach his + interlocutor for his inconsiderate temerity, observes: "What you + tell me, sir, does not entirely surprise me. Nature has placed + very various instincts within us, and the impulse that led you to + what you have just now done is not so peculiar as you think. One + may be a very estimable man and yet love women even in what is + lowliest in their bodies." In harmony with this passage from + Régnier's novel are the remarks of a correspondent who writes to + me of the function of urination that it "appeals sexually to most + normal individuals. My own observations and inquiries prove this. + Women themselves instinctively feel it. The secrecy surrounding + the matter lends, too, I think, a sexual interest." + + The fact that scatalogic processes may in some degree exert an + attraction even in normal love has been especially emphasized by + Bloch (_Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil + II, pp. 222, et seq.): "The man whose intellect and æsthetic + sense has been 'clouded by the sexual impulse' sees these things + in an entirely different light from him who has not been overcome + by the intoxication of love. For him they are idealized (sit + venia verbo) since they are a part of the beloved person, and in + consequence associated with love." Bloch quotes the _Memoiren + einer Sängerin_ (a book which is said to be, though this seems + doubtful, genuinely autobiographical) in the same sense: "A man + who falls in love with a girl is not dragged out of his poetic + sphere by the thought that his beloved must relieve certain + natural necessities every day. It seems, indeed, to him to be + just the opposite. If one loves a person one finds nothing + obscene or disgusting in the object that pleases me." The + opposite attitude is probably in extreme cases due to the + influence of a neurotic or morbidly sensitive temperament. Swift + possessed such a temperament. The possession of a similar + temperament is doubtless responsible for the little prose poem, + "L'Extase," in which Huysmans in his first book, _Le Drageloir á + Epices_, has written an attenuated version of "Strephon and + Chloe" to express the disillusionment of love; the lover lies in + a wood clasping the hand of the beloved with rapturous emotion; + "suddenly she rose, disengaged her hand, disappeared in the + bushes, and I heard as it were the rustling of rain on the + leaves." His dream has fled. + +In estimating the significance of the lover's attitude in this matter, it +is important to realize the position which scatologic conceptions took in +primitive belief. At certain stages of early culture, when all the +emanations of the body are liable to possess mysterious magic properties +and become apt for sacred uses, the excretions, and especially the urine, +are found to form part of religious ritual and ceremonial function. Even +among savages the excreta are frequently regarded as disgusting, but under +the influence of these conceptions such disgust is inhibited, and those +emanations of the body which are usually least honored become religious +symbols. + + Urine has been regarded as the original holy water, and many + customs which still survive in Italy and various parts of Europe, + involving the use of a fluid which must often be yellow and + sometimes salt, possibly indicate the earlier use of urine. (The + Greek water of aspersion, according to Theocritus, was mixed + with salt, as is sometimes the modern Italian holy water. J.J. + Blunt, _Vestiges of Ancient Manners and Customs_, p. 173.) Among + the Hottentots, as Kolbein and others have recorded, the medicine + man urinated alternately on bride and bridegroom, and a + successful young warrior was sprinkled in the same way. Mungo + Park mentions that in Africa on one occasion a bride sent a bowl + of her urine which was thrown over him as a special mark of honor + to a distinguished guest. Pennant remarked that the Highlanders + sprinkled their cattle with urine, as a kind of holy water, on + the first Monday in every quarter. (Bourke, _Scatalogic Rites_, + pp. 228, 239; Brand, _Popular Antiquities_, "Bride-Ales.") + + Even the excreta of animals have sometimes been counted sacred. + This is notably so in the case of the cow, of all animals the + most venerated by primitive peoples, and especially in India. + Jules Bois (_Visions de l'Inde_, p. 86) describes the spectacle + presented in the temple of the cows at Benares: "I put my head + into the opening of the holy stables. It was the largest of + temples, a splendor of precious stones and marble, where the + venerated heifers passed backwards and forwards. A whole people + adored them. They take no notice, plunged in their divine and + obscure unconsciousness. And they fulfil with serenity their + animal functions; they chew the offerings, drink water from + copper vessels, and when they are filled they relieve themselves. + Then a stercoraceous and religious insanity overcomes these + starry-faced women and venerable men; they fall on their knees, + prostrate themselves, eat the droppings, greedily drink the + liquid, which for them is miraculous and sacred." (Cf. Bourke, + _Scatalogic Rites_, Chapter XVII.) + + Among the Chevsurs of the Caucasus, perhaps an Iranian people, a + woman after her confinement, for which she lives apart, purifies + herself by washing in the urine of a cow and then returns home. + This mode of purification is recommended in the Avesta, and is + said to be used by the few remaining followers of this creed. + +We have not only to take into account the frequency with which among +primitive peoples the excretions possess a religious significance. It is +further to be noted that in the folk-lore of modern Europe we everywhere +find plentiful evidence of the earlier prevalence of legends and practices +of a scatalogical character. It is significant that in the majority of +cases it is easy to see a sexual reference in these stories and customs. +The legends have lost their earlier and often mythical significance, and +frequently take on a suggestion of obscenity, while the scatalogical +practices have become the magical devices of lovelorn maidens or forsaken +wives practiced in secrecy. It has happened to scatalogical rites to be +regarded as we may gather from the _Clouds_ of Aristophanes, that the +sacred leathern phallus borne by the women in the Bacchanalia was becoming +in his time, an object to arouse the amusement of little boys. + + Among many primitive peoples throughout the world, and among the + lower social classes of civilized peoples, urine possesses magic + properties, more especially, it would seem, the urine of women + and that of people who stand, or wish to stand, in sexual + relationship to each other. In a legend of the Indians of the + northwest coast of America, recorded by Boas, a woman gives her + lover some of her urine and says: "You can wake the dead if you + drop some of my urine in their ears and nose." (_Zeitschrift für + Ethnologie_, 1894, Heft IV, p. 293.) Among the same Indians there + is a legend of a woman with a beautiful white skin who found on + bathing every morning in the river that the fish were attracted + to her skin and could not be driven off even by magical + solutions. At last she said to herself: "I will make water on + them and then they will leave me alone." She did so, and + henceforth the fish left her. But shortly after fire came from + Heaven and killed her. (Ib., 1891, Heft V, p. 640.) Among both + Christians and Mohammedans a wife can attach an unfaithful + husband by privately putting some of her urine in his drink. (B. + Stern, _Medizin in der Türkei_, vol. ii, p. 11.) This practice is + world-wide; thus among the aborigines of Brazil, according to + Martius, the urine and other excretions and secretions are potent + for aphrodisiacal objects. (Bourke's _Scatalogic Rites of All + Nations_ contains many references to the folk-lore practices in + this matter; a study of popular beliefs in the magic power of + urine, published in Bombay by Professor Eugen Wilhelm in 1889, I + have not seen.) + + The legends which narrate scatalogic exploits are numerous in the + literature of all countries. Among primitive peoples they often + have a purely theological character, for in the popular + mythologies of all countries (even, as we learn from + Aristophanes, among the Greeks) natural phenomena such as the + rain, are apt to be regarded as divine excretions, but in course + of time the legends take on a more erotic or a more obscene + character. In the Irish _Book of Leinster_ (written down + somewhere about the twelfth century, but containing material of + very much older date) we are told how a number of princesses in + Emain Macha, the seat of the Ulster Kings, resolved to find out + which of them could by urinating on it melt a snow pillar which + the men had made, the woman who succeeded to be regarded as the + best among them. None of them succeeded, and they sent for + Derbforgaill, who was in love with Cuchullain, and she was able + to melt the pillar; whereupon the other women, jealous of the + superiority she had thus shown, tore out her eyes. (Zimmer, + "Keltische Beiträge," _Zeitschrift für Deutsche Alterthum_, vol. + xxxii, Heft II, pp. 216-219.) Rhys considers that Derbforgaill + was really a goddess of dawn and dusk, "the drop glistening in + the sun's rays," as indicated by her name, which means a drop or + tear. (J. Rhys, _Lectures on the Origin and Growth of Religion as + Illustrated by Celtic Heathendom_, p. 466.) It is interesting to + compare the legend of Derbforgaill with a somewhat more modern + Picardy folk-lore _conte_ which is clearly analogous but no + longer seems to show any mythologic element, "La Princesse qui + pisse par dessus les Meules." This princess had a habit of + urinating over hay-cocks; the king, her father, in order to break + her of the habit, offered her in marriage to anyone who could + make a hay-cock so high that she could not urinate over it. The + young men came, but the princess would merely laugh and at once + achieve the task. At last there came a young man who argued with + himself that she would not be able to perform this feat after she + had lost her virginity. He therefore seduced her first and she + then failed ignobly, merely wetting her stockings. Accordingly, + she became his bride. (Kryptadia, vol. i. p. 333.) Such legends, + which have lost any mythologic elements they may originally have + possessed and have become merely _contes_, are not uncommon in + the folk-lore of many countries. But in their earlier more + religious forms and in their later more obscene forms, they alike + bear witness to the large place which scatalogic conceptions play + in the primitive mind. + +It is a notable fact in evidence of the close and seemingly normal +association with the sexual impulse of the scatalogic processes, that an +interest in them, arising naturally and spontaneously, is one of the most +frequent channels by which the sexual impulse first manifests itself in +young boys and girls. + + Stanley Hall, who has made special inquiries into the matter, + remarks that in childhood the products of excretion by bladder + and bowels are often objects of interest hardly less intense for + a time than eating and drinking. ("Early Sense of Self," + _American Journal of Psychology_, April, 1898, p. 361.) + "Micturitional obscenities," the same writer observes again, + "which our returns show to be so common before adolescence, + culminate at 10 or 12, and seem to retreat into the background as + sex phenomena appear." They are, he remarks, of two classes: + "Fouling persons or things, secretly from adults, but openly with + each other," and less often "ceremonial acts connected with the + act or the product that almost suggest the scatalogical rites of + savages, unfit for description here, but of great interest and + importance." (G. Stanley Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. i, p. 116.) + The nature of such scatalogical phenomena in childhood--which are + often clearly the instinctive manifestations of an erotic + symbolism--and their wide prevalence among both boys and girls, + are very well illustrated in a narrative which I include in + Appendix B, History II. + +In boys as they approach the age of puberty, this attraction to the +scatalogic, when it exists, tends to die out, giving place to more normal +sexual conceptions, or at all events it takes a subordinate and less +serious place in the mind. In girls, on the other hand, it often tends to +persist. Edmond de Goncourt, a minute observer of the feminine mind, +refers in _Chérie_ to "those innocent and triumphant gaieties which +scatalogic stories have the privilege of arousing in women who have +remained still children, even the most distinguished women." The extent to +which innocent young women, who would frequently be uninterested or +repelled in presence of the sexually obscene are sometimes attracted by +the scatalogically obscene, becomes intelligible, however, if we realize +that a symbolism comes here into play. In women the more specifically +sexual knowledge and experience of life frequently develop much later than +in men or even remains in abeyance, and the specifically sexual phenomena +cannot therefore easily lend themselves to wit, or humor, or imagination. +But the scatalogic sphere, by the very fact that in women it is a +specially intimate and secret region which is yet always liable to be +unexpectedly protruded into consciousness, furnishes an inexhaustible +field for situations which have the same character as those furnished by +the sexually obscene. It thus happens that the sexually obscene which in +men tends to overshadow the scatalogically obscene, in women--partly from +inexperience and partly, it is probable, from their almost physiological +modesty--plays a part subordinate to the scatalogical. In a somewhat +analogous way scatalogical wit and humor play a considerable part in the +work of various eminent authors who were clergymen or priests. + +In addition to the anatomical and psychological associations which +contribute to furnish a basis on which erotic symbolisms may spring up, +there are also physiological connections between the genital and urinary +spheres which directly favor such symbolisms. In discussing the analysis +of the sexual impulse in a previous volume of these _Studies_, I have +pointed out the remarkable relationship--sometimes of transference, +sometimes of compensation--which exists between genital tension and +vesical tension, both in men and women. In the histories of normal sexual +development brought together at the end of that and subsequent volumes the +relationship may frequently be traced, as also in the case of C.P. in the +present study (p. 37). Vesical power is also commonly believed to be in +relation with sexual potency, and the inability to project the urinary +stream in a normal manner is one of the accepted signs of sexual +impotency.[26] Féré, again, has recorded the history of a man with +periodic crises of sexual desire, and subsequently sexual obsession +without desire, which were always accompanied by the impulse to urinate +and by increased urination.[27] In the case, recorded by Pitres and Régis, +of a young girl who, having once at the sight of a young man she liked in +a theater been overcome by sexual feeling accompanied by a strong desire +to urinate, was afterward tormented by a groundless fear of experiencing +an irresistible desire to urinate at inconvenient times,[28] we have an +example of what may be called a physiological scatalogic symbolism of sex, +an emotion which was primarily erotic becoming transferred to the bladder +and then remaining persistent. From such a physiological symbolism it is +but a step to the psychological symbolisms of scatalogic fetichism. + + It is worthy of note, as an indication that such phenomena are + scarcely abnormal, that a urinary symbolism, and even a strictly + sexual fetichism, are normal among many animals. + + The most familiar example of this kind is furnished by the dog, + who is sexually excited in this manner by traces of the bitch and + himself takes every opportunity of making his own path + recognizable. "This custom," Espinas remarks (_Des Sociétés + Animales_, p. 228), "has no other aim than to spread along the + road recognizable traces of their presence for the benefit of + individuals of the other sex, the odor of these traces doubtless + causing excitement." + + It is noteworthy, also, that in animals as well as in man, sexual + excitement may manifest itself in the bladder. Thus Daumas states + (_Chevaux de Sahara_, p. 49) that if the mare urinates when she + hears the stallion neigh it is a sign that she is ready for + connection. + +It is in masochism, or passive algolagnia, that we may most frequently +find scatalogic symbolism in its fully developed form. The man whose +predominant impulse is to subjugate himself to his mistress and to receive +at her hands the utmost humiliation, frequently finds the climax of his +gratification in being urinated on by her, whether in actual fact or only +in imagination. + +In many such cases, however, it is evident that we have a mixed +phenomenon; the symbolism is double. The act becomes desirable because it +is the outward and visible sign of an inwardly experienced abject slavery +to an adored person. But it is also desirable because of intimately sexual +associations in the act itself, as a symbolical detumescence, a simulacrum +of the sexual act, and one which proceeds from the sexual focus itself. + + Krafft-Ebing records various cases of masochism in which the + emission of urine on to the body or into the mouth formed the + climax of sexual gratification, as, for instance (_Psychopathia + Sexualis_, English translation, p. 183) in the case of a Russian + official who as a boy had fancies of being bound between the + thighs of a woman, compelled to sleep beneath her nates and to + drink her urine, and in later life experienced the greatest + excitement when practicing the last part of this early + imagination. + + In another case, recorded by Krafft-Ebing and by him termed + "ideal masochism" (_Op. cit._, pp. 127-130), the subject from + childhood indulged in voluptuous day-dreams in which he was the + slave of a beautiful mistress who would compel him to obey all + her caprices, stand over him with one foot on his breast, sit on + his face and body, make him wait on her in her bath, or when she + urinated, and sometimes insist on doing this on his face; though + a highly intellectual man, he was always too timid to attempt to + carry any of his ideas into execution; he had been troubled by + nocturnal enuresis up to the age of 20. + + Neri, again (_Archivio delle Psicopatie Sessuali_, vol. i, fasc. + 7 and 8, 1896), records the case of an Italian masochist who + experienced the greatest pleasure when both urination and + defecation were practiced in this manner by the woman he was + attached to. + + In a previous volume of these _Studies_ ("Sexual Inversion," + History XXVI) I have recorded the masochistic day-dreams of a boy + whose impulses were at the same time inverted; in his reveries + "the central fact," he states, "became the discharge of urine + from my lover over my body and limbs, or, if I were very fond of + him, I let it be in my face." In actual life the act of urination + casually witnessed in childhood became the symbol, even the + reality, of the central secret of sex: "I stood rooted and + flushing with downcast eyes till the act was over, and was + conscious for a considerable time of stammering speech and + bewildered faculties.... I was overwhelmed with emotion and could + barely drag my feet from the spot or my eyes from the damp + herbage where he had deposited the waters of secrecy. Even to-day + I cannot dissociate myself from the shuddering charm that moment + had for me." + +It is not only the urine and the fæces which may thus acquire a symbolic +fascination and attractiveness under the influence of masochistic +deviations of sexual idealization. In some cases extreme rapture has been +experienced in licking sweating feet. There is, indeed, no excretion or +product of the body which has not been a source of ecstasy: the sweat from +every part of the body, the saliva and menstrual fluid, even the wax from +the ears. + + Krafft-Ebing very truly points out (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, + English translation, p. 178) that this sexual scatalogic + symbolism is precisely paralleled by a religious scatalogic + symbolism. In the excesses of devout enthusiasm the ascetic + performs exactly the same acts as are performed in these excesses + of erotic enthusiasm. To mix excreta with the food, to lick up + excrement, to suck festering sores--all these and the like are + acts which holy and venerated women have performed. + + Not only the saint, but also the prophet and medicine-man have + been frequently eaters of human excrement; it is only necessary + to refer to the instance of the prophet Ezekiel, who declared + that he was commanded to bake his bread with human dung, and to + the practices of medicine-men at Torres Straits, in whose + training the eating of human excrement takes a recognized part. + (Deities, notably Baal-Phegor, were sometimes supposed to eat + excrement, so that it was natural that their messengers and + representatives among men should do so. As regards Baal-Phegor, + see Dulaure, _Des Divinités Génératrices_, Chapter IV, and J.G. + Bourke, _Scatalogic Rites of All Nations_, p. 241. See also + Ezekiel, Chapter IV, v. 12, and _Reports Anthropological + Expedition to Torres Straits_, vol. v, p. 321.) + + It must be added, however, that while the masochist is overcome + by sexual rapture, so that he sees nothing disgusting in his act, + the medicine-man and the ascetic are not so invariably overcome + by religious rapture, and several ascetic writers have referred + to the horror and disgust they experienced, at all events at + first, in accomplishing such acts, while the medicine-men when + novices sometimes find the ordeal too severe and have to abandon + their career. Brénier de Montmorand, while remarking, not without + some exaggeration, that "the Christian ascetics are almost all + eaters of excrement" ("Ascétisme et Mysticisme," _Revue + Philosophique_, March, 1904, p. 245), quotes the testimonies of + Marguerite-Marie and Madame Guyon as to the extreme repugnance + which they had to overcome. They were impelled by a merely + intellectual symbolism of self-mortification rather than by the + profoundly felt emotional symbolism which moves the masochist. + + Coprophagic acts, whether under the influences of religious + exaltation or of sexual rapture, inevitably excite our disgust. + We regard them as almost insane, fortified in that belief by the + undoubted fact that coprophagia is not uncommon among the insane. + It may, therefore, be proper to point out that it is not so very + long since the ingestion of human excrement was carried out by + our own forefathers in the most sane and deliberate manner. It + was administered by medical practitioners for a great number of + ailments, apparently with entirely satisfactory results. Less + than two centuries ago, Schurig, who so admirably gathered + together and arranged the medical lore of his own and the + immediately preceding ages, wrote a very long and detailed + chapter, "De Stercoris Humani Usu Medico" (_Chylologia_, 1725, + cap. XIII; in the Paris _Journal de Médecine_ for February 19, + 1905, there appeared an article, which I have not seen, entitled + "Médicaments oubliées: l'urine et la fiente humaine.") The + classes of cases in which the drug was found beneficial would + seem to have been extremely various. It must not be supposed that + it was usually ingested in the crude form. A common method was to + take the fæces of boys, dry them, mix them with the best honey, + and administer an electuary. (At an earlier period such drugs + appear to have met with some opposition from the Church, which + seems to have seen in them only an application of magic; thus I + note that in Burchard's remarkable Penitential of the fourteenth + century, as reproduced by Wasserschleben, 40 days' penance is + prescribed for the use of human urine or excrement as a medicine. + Wasserschleben _Die Bussordnungen der Abendländlichen Kirche_, p. + 651.) + +The urolagnia of masochism is not a simple phenomenon; it embodies a +double symbolism: on the one hand a symbolism of self-abnegation, such as +the ascetic feels, on the other hand a symbolism of transferred sexual +emotion. Krafft-Ebing was disposed to regard all cases in which a +scatalogical sexual attraction existed as due to "latent masochism." Such +a point of view is quite untenable. Certainly the connection is common, +but in the majority of cases of slightly marked scatalogical fetichism no +masochism is evident. And when we bear in mind the various considerations, +already brought forward, which show how widespread and clearly realized is +the natural and normal basis furnished for such symbolism, it becomes +quite unnecessary to invoke any aid from masochism. There is ample +evidence to show that, either as a habitual or more usually an occasional +act, the impulse to bestow a symbolic value on the act of urination in a +beloved person, is not extremely uncommon; it has been noted of men of +high intellectual distinction; it occurs in women as well as men; when +existing in only a slight degree, it must be regarded as within the normal +limits of variation of sexual emotion. + + The occasional cases in which the urine is drunk may possibly + suggest that the motive lies in the properties of the fluid + acting on the system. Support for this supposition might be found + in the fact that urine actually does possess, apart altogether + from its magic virtues embodied in folk-lore, the properties of a + general stimulant. In composition (as Masterman first pointed + out) "beef-tea differs little from healthy urine," containing + exactly the same constituents, except that in beef-tea there is + less urea and uric acid. Fresh urine--more especially that of + children and young women--is taken as a medicine in nearly all + parts of the world for various disorders, such as epistaxis, + malaria and hysteria, with benefit, this benefit being almost + certainly due to its qualities as a general stimulant and + restorative. William Salmon's _Dispensatory_, 1678 (quoted in + _British Medical Journal_, April 21, 1900, p. 974), shows that in + the seventeenth century urine still occupied an important place + as a medicine, and it frequently entered largely into the + composition of Aqua Divina. + + Its use has been known even in England in the nineteenth century. + (Masterman, _Lancet_, October 2, 1880; R. Neale, "Urine as a + Medicine," _Practitioner_, November, 1881; Bourke brings together + a great deal of evidence as to the therapeutic uses of urine in + his _Scatalogic Rites_, especially pp. 331-335; Lusini has shown + that normal urine invariably increases the frequency of the heart + beats, _Archivio di Farmacologia_, fascs. 19-21, 1893.) + + But it is an error to suppose that these facts account for the + urolagnic drinking of urine. As in the gratification of a normal + sexual impulse, the intense excitement of gratifying a scatalogic + sexual impulse itself produces a degree of emotional stimulation + far greater than the ingestion of a small amount of animal + extractives would be adequate to effect. In such cases, as much + as in normal sexuality, the stimulation is clearly psychic. + +When, as is most commonly the case, it is the process of urination and not +the urine itself which is attractive, we are clearly concerned with a +symbolism of act and not with the fetichistic attraction of an excretion. +When the excretion, apart from the act, provides the attraction, we seem +usually to be in the presence of an olfactory fetichism. These fetichisms +connected with the excreta appear to be experienced chiefly by individuals +who are somewhat weak-minded, which is not necessarily the case in regard +to those persons for whom the act, rather than its product apart from the +beloved person, is the attractive symbol. + + The sexually symbolic nature of the act of urination for many + people is indicated by the existence, according to Bloch, who + enumerates various kinds of indecent photographs, of a group + which he terms "the notorious _pisseuses_." It is further + indicated by several of the reproductions in Fuch's _Erotsiche + Element in der Karikatur_, such as Delorme's "La Necessitê n'a + point de Loi." (It should be added that such a scene by no means + necessarily possesses any erotic symbolism, as we may see in + Rembrandt's etching commonly called "Le Femme qui Pisse," in + which the reflected lights on the partly shadowed stream furnish + an artistic motive which is obviously free from any trace of + obscenity.) In the case which Krafft-Ebing quotes from Maschka of + a young man who would induce young girls to dance naked in his + room, to leap, and to urinate in his presence, whereupon seminal + ejaculation would take place, we have a typical example of + urolagnic symbolism in a form adequate to produce complete + gratification. A case in which the urolagnic form of scatalogic + symbolism reached its fullest development as a sexual perversion + has been described in Russia by Sukhanoff (summarized in + _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, November, 1900, and + _Annales Medico-psychologiques_, February, 1901), that of a young + man of 27, of neuropathic temperament, who when he once chanced + to witness a woman urinating experienced voluptuous sensations. + From that moment he sought close contact with women urinating, + the maximum of gratification being reached when he could place + himself in such a position that a woman, in all innocence, would + urinate into his mouth. All his amorous adventures were concerned + with the search for opportunities for procuring this difficult + gratification. Closets in which he was able to hide, winter + weather and dull days he found most favorable to success. (A + somewhat similar case is recorded in the _Archives de + Neurologie_, 1902, p. 462.) + + In the case of a robust man of neuropathic heredity recorded by + Pelanda some light is shed on the psychic attitude in these + manifestations; there was masturbation up to the age of 16, when + he abandoned the practice, and up to the age of 30 found complete + satisfaction in drinking the still hot urine of women. When a + lady or girl in the house went to her room to satisfy a need of + this kind, she had hardly left it but he hastened in, overcome by + extreme excitement, culminating in spontaneous ejaculation. The + younger the woman the greater the transport he experienced. It is + noteworthy that in this, as possibly in all similar cases, there + was no sensory perversion and no morbid attraction of taste or + smell; he stated that the action of his senses was suspended by + his excitement, and that he was quite unable to perceive the odor + or taste of the fluid. (Pelanda, "Pornopatice," _Archivio di + Psichiatria_, facs. iii-iv, 1889, p. 356.) It is in the emotional + symbolism that the fascination lies and not in any sensory + perversion. + + Magnan records the spontaneous development of this sexual + symbolism in a girl of 11, of good intellectual development but + alcoholic heredity, who seduced a boy younger than herself to + mutual masturbation, and on one occasion, lying on the ground and + raising her clothes, asked him to urinate on her. (_International + Congress of Criminal Anthropology_, 1889.) This case (except for + the early age of the subject) illustrates sporadically occurring + urolagnic symbolism in a woman, to whom such symbolism is fairly + obvious on account of the close resemblance between the emission + of urine and the ejaculation of semen in the man, and the fact + that the same conduit serves for both fluids. (A urolagnic + day-dream of this kind is recorded in the history of a lady + contained in the third volume of these _Studies_, Appendix B, + History VIII.) The natural and inevitable character of this + symbolism is shown by the fact that among primitive peoples urine + is sometimes supposed to possess the fertilizing virtues of + semen. J.G. Frazer in his edition of Pausanias (vol. iv, p. 139) + brings together various stories of women impregnated by urine. + Hartland also (_Legend of Perseus_, vol. i, pp. 76, 92) records + legends of women who were impregnated by accidentally or + intentionally drinking urine. + + The symbolic sexual significance of urolagnia has hitherto + usually been confused with the fetichistic and mainly olfactory + perversion by which the excretion itself becomes a source of + sexual excitement. Long since Tardieu referred, under the name of + "renifleurs," to persons who were said to haunt the neighborhood + of quiet passages, more especially in the neighborhood of + theatres, and who when they perceived a woman emerge after + urination, would hasten to excite themselves by the odor of the + excretion. Possibly a fetichism of this kind existed in a case + recorded by Belletrud and Mercier (_Annales d'Hygiène Publique_, + June, 1904, p. 48). A weak-minded, timid youth, who was very + sexual but not attractive to women, would watch for women who + were about to urinate and immediately they had passed on would go + and lick the spot they had moistened, at the same time + masturbating. Such a fetichistic perversion is strictly analogous + to the fetichism by which women's handkerchiefs, aprons or + underlinen become capable of affording sexual gratification. A + very complete case of such urolagnic fetichism--complete because + separated from association with the person accomplishing the act + of urination--has been recorded by Moraglia in a woman. It is the + case of a beautiful and attractive young woman of 18, with thick + black hair, and expressive vivacious eyes, but sallow complexion. + Married a year previously, but childless, she experienced a + certain amount of pleasure in coitus, but she preferred + masturbation, and frankly acknowledged that she was highly + excited by the odor of fermented urine. So strong was this + fetichism that when, for instance, she passed a street urinal she + was often obliged to go aside and masturbate; once she went for + this purpose into the urinal itself and was almost discovered in + the act, and on another occasion into a church. Her perversion + caused her much worry because of the fear of detection. She + preferred, when she could, to obtain a bottle of urine--which + must be stale and a man's (this, she said, she could detect by + the smell)--and to shut herself up in her own room, holding the + bottle in one hand and repeatedly masturbating with the other. + (Moraglia, "Psicopatie Sessuali," _Archivio di Psichiatria_, vol. + xiii, fasc. 6, p. 267, 1892.) This case is of especial interest + because of the great rarity of fully developed fetichism in + women. In a slight and germinal degree I believe that cases of + fetichism are not uncommon in women, but they are certainly rare + in a well-marked form, and Krafft-Ebing declared, even in the + late editions of his _Psychopathia Sexualis_, that he knew of no + cases in women. + +So far we have been concerned with the urolagnic rather than the +coprolagnic variety of scatalogical symbolism. Although the two are +sometimes associated there is no necessary connection, and most usually +there is no tendency for the one to involve the other. Urolagnia is +certainly much the more frequently found; the act of urination is far more +apt to suggest erotically symbolical ideas than the idea of defecation. +It is not difficult to understand why this should be so. The act of +urination lends itself more easily to sexual symbolism; it is more +intimately associated with the genital function; its repetition is +necessary at more frequent intervals so that it is more in evidence; +moreover, its product, unlike that of the act of defecation, is not +offensive to the senses. Still coprolagnia occurs and not so very +infrequently. Burton remarked that even the normal lover is affected by +this feeling: "immo nec ipsum amicæ stercus foctet."[29] + +Of Caligula who, however, was scarcely sane, it was said "et quidem +stercus uxoris degustavit."[30] In Parisian brothels (according to Taxil +and others) provision is made for those who are sexually excited by the +spectacle of the act of defecation (without reference to contact or odor) +by means of a "tabouret de verre," from under the glass floor of which the +spectacle of the defecating women may be closely observed. It may be added +that the erotic nature of such a spectacle is referred to in the Marquis +de Sade's novels. + +There is one motive for the existence of coprolagnia which must not be +passed over, because it has doubtless frequently served as a mode of +transition to what, taken by itself, may well seem the least æsthetically +attractive of erotic symbols. I refer to the tendency of the nates to +become a sexual fetich. The nates have in all ages and in all parts of the +world been frequently regarded as one of the most æsthetically beautiful +parts of the feminine body.[31] It is probable that on the basis of this +entirely normal attraction more than one form of erotic symbolism is at +all events in part supported. Dühren and others have considered that the +æsthetic charm of the nates is one of the motives which prompt the desire +to inflict flagellation on women. In the same way--certainly in some and +probably in many cases--the sexual charm of the nates progressively +extends to the anal region, to the act of defecation, and finally to the +feces. + + In a case of Krafft-Ebing's (_Op. cit._, p. 183) the subject, + when a child of 6, accidentally placed his hand in contact with + the nates of the little girl who sat next to him in school, and + experienced so great a pleasure in this contact that he + frequently repeated it; when he was 10 a nursery governess, to + gratify her own desires, placed his finger in her vagina; in + adult life he developed urolagnic tendencies. + + In a case of Moll's the development of a youthful admiration for + the nates in a coprolagnic direction may be clearly traced. In + this case a young man, a merchant, in a good position, sought to + come in contact with women defecating; and with this object would + seek to conceal himself in closets; the excretal odor was + pleasurable to him, but was not essential to gratification, and + the sight of the nates was also exciting and at the same time not + essential to gratification; the act of defecation appears, + however, to have been regarded as essential. He never sought to + witness prostitutes in this situation; he was only attracted to + young, pretty and innocent women. The coprolagnia here, however, + had its source in a childish impression of admiration for the + nates. When 5 or 6 years old he crawled under the clothes of a + servant girl, his face coming in contact with her nates, an + impression that remained associated in his mind with pleasure. + Three or four years later he used to experience much pleasure + when a young girl cousin sat on his face; thus was strengthened + an association which developed naturally into coprolagnia. (Moll, + _Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 837.) + + It is scarcely necessary to remark that an admiration for the + nates, even when reaching a fetichistic degree, by no means + necessarily involves, even after many years, any attraction to + the excreta. A correspondent for whom the nates have constituted + a fetich for many years writes: "I find my craving for women with + profuse pelvic or posterior development is growing and I wish to + copulate from behind; but I would feel a sickening feeling if any + part of my person came in contact with the female anus. It is + more pleasing to me to see the nates than the mons, yet I loathe + everything associated with the anal region." + +Moll has recorded in detail a case of what may be described as "ideal +coprolagnia"--that is to say, where the symbolism, though fully developed +in imagination, was not carried into real life--which is of great interest +because it shows how, in a very intelligent subject, the deviated +symbolism may become highly developed and irradiate all the views of life +in the same way as the normal impulse. (The subject's desires were also +inverted, but from the present point of view the psychological interest of +the case is not thereby impaired.) Moll's case was one of symbolism of +act, the excreta offering no attraction apart from the process of +defecation. In a case which has been communicated to me there was, on the +other hand, an olfactory fetichistic attraction to the excreta even in the +absence of the person. + + In Moll's case, the patient, X., 23 years of age, belongs to a + family which he himself describes as nervous. His mother, who is + anæmic, has long suffered from almost periodical attacks of + excitement, weakness, syncope and palpitation. A brother of the + mother died in a lunatic asylum, and several other brothers + complain much of their nerves. The mother's sisters are very + good-natured, but liable to break out in furious passions; this + they inherit from their father. There appears to be no nervous + disease on the patient's father's side. X.'s sisters are also + healthy. + + X. himself is of powerful undersized build and enjoys good + health, injured by no excesses. He considers himself nervous. He + worked hard at school and was always the first in his class; he + adds, however, that this is due less to his own abilities than + the laziness of his school-fellows. He is, as he remarks, very + religious and prays frequently, but seldom goes to church. + + In regard to his psychic characters he says that he has no + specially prominent talent, but is much interested in languages, + mathematics, physics and philosophy, in fact, in abstract + subjects generally. "While I take a lively interest in every kind + of intellectual work," he says, "it is only recently that I have + been attracted to real life and its requirements. I have never + had much skill in physical exercises. For external things until + recently I have only had contempt. I have a delicately + constituted nature, loving solitude, and only associating with a + few select persons. I have a decided taste for fiction, poetry + and music; my temperament is idealistic and religious, with + strict conceptions of duty and morality, and aspirations towards + the good and beautiful. I detest all that is common and coarse, + and yet I can think and act in the way you will learn from the + following pages." + + Regarding his sexual life, X. made the following communication: + "During the last two years I have become convinced of the + perversion of my sexual instinct. I had often previously thought + that in me the impulse was not quite normal, but it is only + lately that I have become convinced of my complete perversion. I + have never read or heard of any case in which the sexual feelings + were of the same kind. Although I can feel a lively inclination + towards superior representatives of the female sex, and have + twice felt something like love, the sight or the recollection + even of a beautiful woman have never caused sexual excitement." + In the two exceptional instances mentioned it appears that X. had + an inclination to kiss the women in question, but that the + thought of coitus had no attraction. "In my voluptuous dreams, + connected with the emission of semen, women in seductive + situations have never appeared. I have never had any desire to + visit a _puella publica_. The love-stories of my fellow-students + seemed very silly, dances and balls were a horror to me, and only + on very rare occasions could I be persuaded to go into society. + It will be easy to guess the diagnosis in my case: I suffer from + the sexual attraction of my own sex, I am a lover of boys. + + "You cannot imagine what a world of thoughts, wishes, feelings + and impulses the words 'knabe,' 'pais,' 'garcon,' 'boy,' + 'ragazzo' have for me; one of these words, even in an unmeaning + clause of a translation-book, calls before me the whole sum of + associations which in course of time have become bound up with + this idea, and it is only with an effort that I can scare away + the wild band. This group of thoughts shows a wonderful mixture + of warm sensuality and ideal love, it unites my lowest and + highest impulses, the strength and the weakness of my nature, my + curse and my blessing. My inclination is especially towards boys + of the age of 12 to 15; though they may be rather younger or + older. That I should prefer beautiful and intelligent boys is + comprehensible. I do not want a prostitute, but a friend or a + son, whose soul I love, whom I can help to become a more perfect + man, such as I myself would willingly be. + + "When I myself belonged to that happy age (i.e., below 15) I had + no dearer wish than to possess a friend of similar tastes. I have + sought, hoped, waited, grieved, and been at last disillusioned, + overcome by desire and despair, and have not found that friend. + Even later the hope often reappeared, but always in vain, and I + cannot boast of that sure recognition which one reads of in the + autobiographies of Urnings. I do not know personally a single + fellow-sufferer. It is also doubtful whether such an + acquaintanceship would greatly help me, for I have a very + peculiar conception of homosexuality. As you will see, I have + little more in common with what are called pæderasts than sexual + indifference to the female sex, and I often ask myself: 'Does any + other man in the whole world feel like you? Are you alone in the + earth with your morbid desires? Are you a pariah of pariahs, or + is there, perhaps, another soul with similar longings living near + you? How often in summer have I gone to the lakes and streams + outside cities to seek boys bathing; but I always came back + unsatisfied, whether I found any or not. And in winter I have + been irresistibly impelled to return to the same spots, as if it + were sanctified by the boys, but my darlings had vanished and + cold winds blew over the icy floods, so that I would return + feeling as though I had buried all my happiness. + + "It must be borne in mind, therefore, that what I have to say + regarding my sexual impulses only refers to fancies and never to + their practical realization. My sensual impulses are not + connected with the sexual organs; all my voluptuous ideas are not + in the least connected with these parts. For this reason I have + never practiced onanism and _immissio membri in anum_ is as + repulsive to me as to a normal man. Even every imitation of + coitus is, for me, without attraction. In a boy's body two things + specially excite me: _his belly and his nates_, the first as + containing the digestive tract, the second as holding the opening + of the bowels. Of the vegetable processes of life in the boy none + interest me nearly so much as the progress of his digestion and + the process of defecation. It is incredible to what an extent + this part of physiology has occupied me from youth. If as a boy I + wanted to read something of a piquantly exciting character I + sought in my father's encyclopædia for articles like: + Obstruction, Constipation, Hæmorrhoids, Fæces, etc. No function + of the body seemed to be so significant as this, and I regarded + its disturbances as the most important in the whole mechanism of + life. The description of other disorders I could read in cold + blood, but intussusception of the bowels makes me ill even + to-day. I am always extremely pleased to hear that the digestion + of the people around me is in good condition. A man who did not + sufficiently watch over his digestion aroused distrust in me, and + I imagined that wicked men must be horribly indifferent regarding + this weighty matter. Even more than in ordinary persons was I + interested in the digestion of more mysterious beings, like + magicians in legends, or men of other nations. I would willingly + have made an anthropological study of my favorite subject, only + to my annoyance books nearly always pass over the matter in + silence. In history and fiction I regretted the absence of + information concerning the state of my heroes' digestion when + they languished in prison or in some unaccustomed or unhealthy + spot. For this reason I held no book more precious than one which + describes how a young man after being shipwrecked lived for a + long time in a narrow snow-hut, and it was conscientiously stated + that he became aware of digestive disturbances. No immorality + angers me more than the foolish practice of ladies who in society + neglect the satisfaction of their natural needs from misplaced + motives of modesty. On a railway journey I suffer horribly from + the thought that one of my fellow-travelers may be prevented from + fulfilling some imperative natural necessity. + + "I naturally devote the greatest attention to my own digestion. + With painful conscientiousness I go to stool every day at the + same hour; if the operation does not come off to my satisfaction + I feel not so much physical as mental discomfort. To this quite + useful hygienic interest became associated at puberty a sensual + interest. Since my fourteenth year I have had no greater + enjoyment than to defecate undressed (I do not do so now) after + having first carefully examined the distension of my abdomen. In + summer I would go into the woods, undress myself in a secluded + spot and indulge in the voluptuous pleasures of defecation. I + would sometimes combine with this a bath in a stream. I would + exhaust my imagination in the effort to invent specially + enjoyable variations, longed for a desert island where I could go + about naked, fill my body with much nourishing food, hold in the + excrement as long as possible and then discharge it in some + subtly-thought-out spot. These practices and ideas often caused + erections and later on emissions, but the genitals played no part + in my conceptions; their movements were uncomfortable and gave no + pleasure. + + "I soon longed to be associated in these orgies with some boy of + the same age, but I wanted not only a companion in my passion, + but also a real friend. Since there could be no question of + masturbation or pæderasty, our love would have been limited to + kisses, embraces, and--as a compensation for coitus--defecation + together. That would have been perfect bliss to me. I will spare + you the unæsthetic contents of my voluptuous dreams. But I + remained without a companion, and, therefore, without real + enjoyment. [He has, however, on various occasions experienced + erections, and even emissions, on seeing, by chance, men or boys + defecate.] Hinc illæ lacrimæ; the excitement over my own + defecation only took place _faute de mieux_. + + "I knew very well that my thoughts and practices were impure and + contemptible. Ah! how often, when the intoxication was over, have + I thrown myself remorsefully on my knees, praying to God for + pardon! For some weeks I repressed my longing; but at last it was + too strong for me, I tried to justify myself and fell into my + vice anew. That I was guilty of licentiousness and loved boys + sexually first became clear to me later on, when I knew the + significance of erection as a sign of sexual excitement. + + "No one can imagine with what demoniacal joy I am possessed at + the thought of a beautiful naked boy whose abdomen is filled as + the result of long abstinence from stool. The thought powerfully + excites me, a flood of passion goes through my blood and my limbs + tremble. I would never grow tired of feeling that belly and + looking at it. My passion would express itself in tempestuous + caresses, and the boy would have to assume various positions in + order to show off the beauty of his form, i.e., to bring the + parts in question into better view. To observe defecation would + still further increase this peculiar enjoyment. If the boy's + bowels were not sufficiently filled I would feed him with all + sorts of food which produces much excrement, such as potatoes, + coarse bread, etc. If possible I would seek to delay defecation + for two or three days, so that it might be as copious as + possible. When at last it occurred it would be an unspeakable joy + for me to watch the fæces--which would have to be fairly + firm--emerging from the anus." + + X. would like to be a teacher and thinks he could exert a + beneficial influence on boys. In spite of the pain he has + suffered he does not think he would like to be cured of his + perverse inclinations, for they have given him joy as well as + pain, and the pain has chiefly been owing to the fact that he + could not gratify his inclinations. X. smokes and drinks in + moderation, and has no feminine habits. (The foregoing is a + condensed summary of the case which is fully reported by Moll, + _Konträre Sexualempfindung_, third edition, pp. 295-305.) + + The case of coprolagnia communicated to me is that of a married + man, normal in all other respects, intellectually brilliant and + filling successfully a very responsible position. When a child + the women of his household were always indifferent as to his + presence in their bedrooms, and would satisfy all natural calls + without reserve before him. He would dream of this with + erections. His sexual interests became slowly centered in the act + of defecation, and this fetich throughout life never appealed to + him so powerfully as when associated with the particular type of + household furniture which was used for this purpose in his own + house. The act of defecation in the opposite sex or anything + pertaining to or suggesting the same caused uncontrollable sexual + excitement; the nates also exerted a great attraction. The alvine + excreta exerted this influence even in the absence of the woman; + it was, however, necessary that she should be a sexually + desirable person. The perversion in this case was not complete; + that is to say, that the excitement produced by the act of + defecation or the excretion itself was not actually preferred to + coitus; the sexual idea was normal coitus in the normal manner, + but preceded by the visual and olfactory enjoyment of the + exciting fetich. When coitus was not possible the enjoyment of + the fetich was accompanied by masturbation (as in the analogous + case of urolagnia in a woman summarized on p. 62.) On one + occasion he was discovered by a friend in a bedroom belonging to + a woman, engaged in the act of masturbation over a vessel + containing the desired fetich. In an agony of shame he begged the + mercy of silence concerning this episode, at the same time + revealing his life-history. He has constantly been haunted by the + dread of detection, as well as by remorse and the consciousness + of degradation, also by the fear that his unconquerable obsession + may lead him to the asylum. + +The scatalogic groups of sexual perversions, urolagnia and coprolagnia, as +may be sufficiently seen in this brief summary, are not merely olfactory +fetiches. They are, in a larger proportion of cases, dynamic symbols, a +preoccupation with physiological acts which, by associations of contiguity +and still more of resemblance, have gained the virtue of stimulating in +slight cases, and replacing in more extreme cases, the normal +preoccupation with the central physiological act itself. We have seen that +there are various considerations which amply suffice to furnish a basis +for such associations. And when we reflect that in the popular mind, and +to some extent in actual fact, the sexual act itself is, like urination +and defecation, an excretory act, we can understand that the true +excretory acts may easily become symbols of the pseudo-excretory act. It +is, indeed, in the muscular release of accumulated pressures and tensions, +involved by the act of liberating the stored-up excretion, that we have +the closest simulacrum of the tumescence and detumescence of the sexual +process.[32] + +In this way the erotic symbolism of urolagnia and coprolagnia is +completely analogous with that dynamic symbolism of the clinging and +swinging garments which Herrick has so accurately described, with the +complex symbolism of flagellation and its play of the rod against the +blushing and trembling nates, with the symbols of sexual strain and stress +which are embodied in the foot and the act of treading. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[24] Fuchs (_Das Erotische Element In der Karikatur_, p. 26), +distinguishing sharply between the "erotic" and the "obscene," reserves +the latter term exclusively for the representation of excretory organs and +acts. He considers that this is etymologically the most exact usage. +However that may be, it seems to me that, in any case, "obscene" has +become so vague a term that it is now impracticable to give it a +restricted and precise sense. + +[25] In this connection we may profitably contemplate the hand and recall +the vast gamut of functions, sacred and profane, which that organ +exercises. Many savages strictly reserve the left hand to the lowlier +purposes of life; but in civilization that is not considered necessary, +and it may be wholesome for some of us to meditate on the more humble uses +of the same hand which is raised in the supreme gesture of benediction and +which men have often counted it a privilege to kiss. + +[26] See, e.g., Morselli, _Una Causa di Nullità del Matrimonio_, 1902, p. +39. + +[27] Féré, _Comptes-Rendus Société de Biologie_, July 23, 1904. + +[28] Transactions of the International Medical Congress, Moscow, vol. iv, +p. 19. A similar symbolism may be traced in many of the cases in which the +focus of modesty becomes in modest women centered in the excretory sphere +and sometimes exaggerated to the extent of obsession. It must not be +supposed, however, that every obsession in this sphere has a symbolical +value of an erotic kind. In the case, for instance, which has been +recorded by Raymond and Janet (_Les Obsessions_, vol. ii, p. 306) of a +woman who spent much of her time in the endeavor to urinate perfectly, +always feeling that she failed in some respect, the obsession seems to +have risen fortuitously on a somewhat neurotic basis without reference to +the sexual life. + +[29] _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. III, Subs. I. + +[30] It may be remarked here that while the eating of excrement (apart +from its former use as a magic charm and as a therapeutic agent) is in +civilization now confined to sexual perverts and the insane, among some +animals it is normal as a measure of hygiene in relation to their young. +Thus, as, e.g., the Rev. Arthur East writes, the mistle thrush swallows +the droppings of its young. (_Knowledge_, June 1, 1899, p. 133.) In the +dog I have observed that the bitch licks her puppies shortly after birth +as they urinate, absorbing the fluid. + +[31] See, e.g., the previous volume of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection +in Man," pp. 165 et seq., and Dühren, _Geschlechtsleben in England_, bd. +ii, pp. 258, et seq. + +[32] In the study of _Love and Pain_ in a previous volume (p. 130) I have +quoted the remarks of a lady who refers to the analogy between sexual +tension and vesical tension--"Cette volupté que ressentent les bords de la +mer, d'être toujours pleins sans jamais déborder"--and its erotic +significance. + + + + +IV. + +Animals as Sources of Erotic Symbolism--Mixoscopic Zoophilia--The +Stuff-fetichisms--Hair-fetichism--The Stuff-fetichisms Mainly on a Tactile +Base--Erotic Zoophilia--Zooerastia--Bestiality--The Conditions that Favor +Bestiality--Its Wide Prevalence Among Primitive Peoples and Among +Peasants--The Primitive Conception of Animals--The Goat--The Influence of +Familiarity with Animals--Congress Between Women and Animals--The Social +Reaction Against Bestiality. + + +The erotic symbols with which we have so far been concerned have in every +case been portions of the body, or its physiological processes, or at +least the garments which it has endowed with life. The association on +which the symbol has arisen has in every case been in large measure, +although not entirely, an association of contiguity. It is now necessary +to touch on a group of sexual symbols in which the association of +contiguity with the human body is absent: the various methods by which +animals or animal products or the sight of animal copulation may arouse +sexual desire in human persons. Here we encounter a symbolism mainly +founded on association by resemblance; the animal sexual act recalls the +human sexual act; the animal becomes the symbol of the human being. + +The group of phenomena we are here concerned with includes several +subdivisions. There is first the more or less sexual pleasure sometimes +experienced, especially by young persons, in the sight of copulating +animals. This I would propose to call Mixoscopic Zoophilia; it falls +within the range of normal variation. Then we have the cases in which the +contact of animals, stroking, etc., produces sexual excitement or +gratification; this is a sexual fetichism in the narrow sense, and is by +Krafft-Ebing termed _Zoophilia Erotica_. We have, further, the class of +cases in which a real or simulated sexual intercourse with animals is +desired. Such cases are not regarded as fetichism by Krafft-Ebing,[33] +but they come within the phenomena of erotic symbolism as here understood. +This class falls into two divisions: one in which the individual is fairly +normal, but belongs to a low grade of culture; the other in which he may +belong to a more refined social class, but is affected by a deep degree of +degeneration. In the first case we may properly apply the term bestiality; +in the second case it may perhaps be better to use the term _zooerastia_, +proposed by Krafft-Ebing.[34] + +Among children, both boys and girls, it is common to find that the +copulation of animals is a mysteriously fascinating spectacle. It is +inevitable that this should be so, for the spectacle is more or less +clearly felt to be the revelation of a secret which has been concealed +from them. It is, moreover, a secret of which they feel intimate +reverberations within themselves, and even in perfectly innocent and +ignorant children the sight may produce an obscure sexual excitement.[35] +It would seem that this occurs more frequently in girls than in boys. Even +in adult age, it may be added, women are liable to experience the same +kind of emotion in the presence of such spectacles. One lady recalls, as a +girl, that on several occasions an element of physical excitement entered +into the feelings with which she watched the coquetry of cats. Another +lady mentions that at the age of about 25, and when still quite ignorant +of sexual matters, she saw from a window some boys tickling a dog and +inducing sexual excitement in the animal; she vaguely divined what they +were doing, and though feeling disgust at their conduct she at the same +time experienced in a strong degree what she now knows was sexual +excitement. The coupling of the larger animals is often an impressive and +splendid spectacle which is far, indeed, from being obscene, and has +commended itself to persons of intellectual distinction;[36] but in young +or ill-balanced minds such sights tend to become both prurient and morbid. +I have already referred to the curious case of a sexually hyperæsthetic +nun who was always powerfully excited by the sight or even the +recollection of flies in sexual connection, so that she was compelled to +masturbate; this dated from childhood. After becoming a nun she recorded +having had this experience, followed by masturbation, more than four +hundred times.[37] Animal spectacles sometimes produce a sexual effect on +children even when not specifically sexual; thus a correspondent, a +clergyman, informs me that when a young and impressionable boy, he was +much affected by seeing a veterinary surgeon insert his hand and arm into +a horse's rectum, and dreamed of this several times afterward with +emissions. + +While the contemplation of animal coitus is an easily intelligible and in +early life, perhaps, an almost normal symbol of sexual emotion, there is +another subdivision of this group of animal fetichisms which forms a more +natural transition from the fetichisms which have their center in the +human body: the stuff-fetichisms, or the sexual attraction exerted by +various tissues, perhaps always of animal origin. Here we are in the +presence of a somewhat complicated phenomenon. In part we have, in a +considerable number of such cases, the sexual attraction of feminine +garments, for all such tissues are liable to enter into the dress. In +part, also, we have a sexual perversion of tactile sensibility, for in a +considerable proportion of these cases it is the touch sensations which +are potent in arousing the erotic sensations. But in part, also, it would +seem, we have here the conscious or subconscious presence of an animal +fetich, and it is notable that perhaps all these stuffs, and especially +fur, which is by far the commonest of the groups, are distinctively animal +products. We may perhaps regard the fetich of feminine hair--a much more +important and common fetich, indeed, than any of the stuff fetichisms--as +a link of transition. Hair is at once an animal and a human product, while +it may be separated from the body and possesses the qualities of a stuff. +Krafft-Ebing remarks that the senses of touch, smell, and hearing, as well +as sight, seem to enter into the attraction exerted by hair. + + The natural fascination of hair, on which hair-fetichism is + founded, begins at a very early age. "The hair is a special + object of interest with infants," Stanley Hall concludes, "which + begins often in the latter part of the first year.... The hair, + no doubt, gives quite unique tactile sensations, both in its own + roots and to hands, and is plastic and yielding to the motor + sense, so that the earliest interest may be akin to that in fur, + which is a marked object in infant experience. Some children + develop an almost fetichistic propensity to pull or later to + stroke the hair or beard of every one with whom they come in + contact." (G. Stanley Hall, "The Early Sense of Self," _American + Journal of Psychology_, April, 1898, p. 359.) + + It should be added that the fascination of hair for the infantile + and childish mind is not necessarily one of attraction, but may + be of repulsion. It happens here, as in the case of so many + characteristics which are of sexual significance, that we are in + the presence of an object which may exert a dynamic emotional + force, a force which is capable of repelling with the same energy + that it attracts. Féré records the instructive case of a child of + 3, of psychopathic heredity, who when he could not sleep was + sometimes taken by his mother into her bed. One night his hand + came in contact with a hairy portion of his mother's body, and + this, arousing the idea of an animal, caused him to leap out of + the bed in terror. He became curious as to the cause of his + terror and in time was able to observe "the animal," but the + train of feelings which had been set up led to a life-long + indifference to women and a tendency to homosexuality. It is + noteworthy that he was attracted to men in whom the hair and + other secondary sexual characters were well developed. (Féré, + _L'Instinct Sexuel_, second edition, pp. 262-267.) + + As a sexual fetich hair strictly belongs to the group of parts of + the body; but since it can be removed from the body and is + sexually effective as a fetich in the absence of the person to + whom it belongs, it is on a level with the garments which may + serve in a similar way, with shoes or handkerchiefs or gloves. + Psychologically, hair-fetichism presents no special problem, but + the wide attraction of hair--it is sexually the most generally + noted part of the feminine body after the eyes--and the peculiar + facility with which when plaited it may be removed, render + hair-fetichism a sexual perversion of specially great + medico-legal interest. + + The frequency of hair-fetichism, as well as of the natural + admiration on which it rests, is indicated by a case recorded by + Laurent. "A few years ago," he states, "one constantly saw at the + Bal Bullier, in Paris, a tall girl whose face was lean and bony, + but whose black hair was of truly remarkable length. She wore it + flowing down her shoulders and loins. Men often followed her in + the street to touch or kiss the hair. Others would accompany her + home and pay her for the mere pleasure of touching and kissing + the long black tresses. One, in consideration of a relatively + considerable sum, desired to pollute the silky hair. She was + obliged to be always on her guard, and to take all sorts of + precautions to prevent any one cutting off this ornament, which + constituted her only beauty as well as her livelihood." (E. + Laurent, _L'Amour Morbide_, 1891, p. 164; also the same author's + _Fétichistes et Erotomanes_, p. 23.) + + The hair despoiler (_Coupeur des Nattes_ or _Zopfabschneider_) + may be found in any civilized country, though the most carefully + studied cases have occurred in Paris. (Several medico-legal + histories of hair-despoilers are summarized by Krafft-Ebing, _Op. + cit._, pp. 329-334). Such persons are usually of nervous + temperament and bad heredity; the attraction to hair occasionally + develops in early life; sometimes the morbid impulse only appears + in later life after fever. The fetich may be either flowing hair + or braided hair, but is usually one or the other, and not both. + Sexual excitement and ejaculation may be produced in the act of + touching or cutting off the hair, which is subsequently, in many + cases, used for masturbation. As a rule the hair-despoiler is a + pure fetichist, no element of sadistic pleasure entering into his + feelings. In the case of a "capillary kleptomaniac" in Chicago--a + highly intelligent and athletic married young man of good + family--the impulse to cut off girls' braids appeared after + recovery from a severe fever. He would gaze admiringly at the + long tresses and then clip them off with great rapidity; he did + this in some fifty cases before he was caught and imprisoned. He + usually threw the braids away before he reached home. (_Alienist + and Neurologist_, April, 1889, p. 325.) In this case there is no + history of sexual excitement, probably because no proper + medico-legal examination was made. (It may be added that + hair-despoilers have been specially studied by Motet, "Les + Coupeurs de Nattes," _Annales d'Hygiène_, 1890.) + +The stuff-fetiches are most usually fur and velvet; feathers, silk, and +leathers also sometimes exert this influence; they are all, it will be +noted, animal substances.[38] The most interesting is probably fur, the +attraction of which is not uncommon in association with passive +algolagnia. As Stanley Hall has shown, the fear of fur, as well as the +love of it, is by no means uncommon in childhood; it may appear even in +infancy and in children who have never come in contact with animals.[39] +It is noteworthy that in most cases of uncomplicated stuff-fetichism the +attraction apparently arises on a congenital basis, as it appears in +persons of nervous or sensitive temperament at an early age and without +being attached to any definite causative incident. The sexual excitation +is nearly always produced by the touch rather than by the sight. As we +found, when dealing with the sense of touch in the previous volume, the +specific sexual sensations may be regarded as a special modification of +ticklishness. The erotic symbolism in the case of these stuff-fetichisms +would seem to be a more or less congenital perversion of ticklishness in +relation to specific animal contacts. + +A further degree of perversion in this direction is reached in a case of +erotic _zoophilia_, recorded by Krafft-Ebing.[40] In this case a +congenital neuropath, of good intelligence but delicate and anæmic, with +feeble sexual powers, had a great love of domestic animals, especially +dogs and cats, from an early age; when petting them he experienced sexual +emotions, although he was innocent in sexual matters. At puberty he +realized the nature of his feelings and tried to break himself of his +habits. He succeeded, but then began erotic dreams accompanied by images +of animals, and these led to masturbation associated with ideas of a +similar kind. At the same time he had no wish for any sort of sexual +intercourse with animals, and was indifferent as to the sex of the animals +which attracted him; his sexual ideals were normal. Such a case seems to +be fundamentally one of fetichism on a tactile basis, and thus forms a +transition between the stuff-fetichisms and the complete perversions of +sexual attraction toward animals. + + In some cases sexually hyperæsthetic women have informed me that + sexual feeling has been produced by casual contact with pet dogs + and cats. In such cases there is usually no real perversion, but + it seems probable that we may here have an occasional foundation + for the somewhat morbid but scarcely vicious excesses of + affection which women are apt to display towards their pet dogs + or cats. In most cases of this affection there is certainly no + sexual element; in the case of childless women, it may rather be + regarded as a maternal than as an erotic symbolism. (The excesses + of this non-erotic zoophilia have been discussed by Féré, + _L'Instinct Sexuel_, second edition, pp. 166-171.) + +Krafft-Ebing considers that complete perversion of sexual attraction +toward animals is radically distinct from erotic _zoophilia_. This view +cannot be accepted. Bestiality and _zooerastia_ merely present in a more +marked and profoundly perverted form a further degree of the same +phenomenon which we meet with in erotic _zoophilia_; the difference is +that they occur either in more insensitive or in more markedly degenerate +persons. + +A fairly typical case of _zooerastia_ has been recorded in America by +Howard, of Baltimore. This was the case of a boy of 16, precociously +mature and fairly bright. He was, however, indifferent to the opposite +sex, though he had ample opportunity for gratifying normal passions. His +parents lived in the city, but the youth had an inordinate desire for the +country and was therefore sent to school in a village. On the second day +after his arrival at school a farmer missed a sow which was found secreted +in an outhouse on the school grounds. This was the first of many similar +incidents in which a sow always took part. So strong was his passion that +on one occasion force had to be used to take him away from the sow he was +caressing. He did not masturbate, and even when restrained from +approaching sows he had no sexual inclination for other animals. His +nocturnal pollutions, which were frequent, were always accompanied by +images of wallowing swine. Notwithstanding careful treatment no cure was +effected; mental and physical vigor failed, and he died at the age of +23.[41] + +It is, however, somewhat doubtful whether we can always or even usually +distinguish between zooerastia and bestiality. Dr. G.F. Lydston, of +Chicago, has communicated to me a case (in which he was consulted) which +seems fairly typical and is instructive in this respect. The subject was a +young man of 21, a farmer's son, not very bright intellectually, but very +healthy and strong, of great assistance on the farm, very capable and +industrious, such a good farm hand that his father was unwilling to send +him away and to lose his services. There was no history of insanity or +neurosis in the family, and no injury or illness in his own history. He +had spells of moroseness and irritability, however, and had also been a +masturbator. Women had no attraction for him, but he would copulate with +the mares upon his father's farm, and this without regard to time, place, +or spectators. Such a case would seem to stand midway between ordinary +bestiality and pathological zooerastia as defined by Krafft-Ebing, yet it +seems probable that in most cases of ordinary bestiality some slight +traces of mental anomaly might be found, if such cases always were, as +they should be, properly investigated.[42] + +We have here reached the grossest and most frequent perversion in this +group; bestiality, or the impulse to attain sexual gratification by +intercourse, or other close contact, with animals. In seeking to +comprehend this perversion it is necessary to divest ourselves of the +attitude toward animals which is the inevitable outcome of refined +civilization and urban life. Most sexual perversions, if not in large +measure the actual outcome of civilized life, easily adjust themselves to +it. Bestiality (except in one form to be noted later) is, on the other +hand, the sexual perversion of dull, insensitive and unfastidious persons. +It flourishes among primitive peoples and among peasants. It is the vice +of the clodhopper, unattractive to women or inapt to court them. + +Three conditions have favored the extreme prevalence of bestiality: (1) +primitive conceptions of life which built up no great barrier between man +and the other animals; (2) the extreme familiarity which necessarily +exists between the peasant and his beasts, often combined with separation +from women; (3) various folk-lore beliefs such as the efficacy of +intercourse with animals as a cure for venereal disease, etc.[43] + +The beliefs and customs of primitive peoples, as well as their mythology +and legends, bring before us a community of man and animals altogether +unlike anything we know in civilization. Men may become animals and +animals may become men; animals and men may communicate with each other +and live on terms of equality; animals may be the ancestors of human +tribes; the sacred totems of savages are most usually animals. There is no +shame or degradation in the notion of a sexual relationship between men +and animals, because in primitive conceptions animals are not inferior +beings separated from man by a great gulf. They are much more like men in +disguise, and in some respects possess powers which make them superior to +men. This is recognized in those plays, festivals, and religious dances, +so common among primitive peoples, in which animal disguises are worn.[44] +When men admire and emulate the qualities of animals and are proud to +believe that they descend from them, it is not surprising that they should +sometimes see nothing derogatory in sexual intercourse with them.[45] + +A significant relic of primitive conceptions in this matter may perhaps be +found in the religious rites connected with the sacred goat of Mendes +described by Herodotus. After telling how the Mendesians reverence the +goat, especially the he-goat, out of their veneration for Pan, whom they +represent as a goat ("the real motive which they assign for this custom I +do not choose to relate"), he adds: "It happened in this country, and +within my remembrance, and was indeed universally notorious, that a goat +had indecent and public communication with a woman."[46] The meaning of +the passage evidently is that in the ordinary intercourse of women with +the sacred goat, connection was only simulated or incomplete on account of +the natural indifference of the goat to the human female, but that in rare +cases the goat proved sexually excitable with the woman and capable of +connection.[47] The goat has always been a kind of sacred emblem of lust. +In the middle ages it became associated with the Devil as one of the +favorite forms he assumed. It is significant of a primitively religious +sexual association between men and animals, that witches constantly +confessed, or were made to confess, that they had had intercourse with the +Devil in the shape of an animal, very frequently a dog. The figures of +human beings and animals in conjunction carved on temples in India, also +seem to indicate the religious significance which this phenomenon +sometimes presents. There is, indeed, no need to go beyond Europe even in +her moments of highest culture to find a religious sanction for sexual +union between human beings, or gods in human shape, and animals. The +legends of Io and the bull, of Leda and the swan, are among the most +familiar in Greek mythology, and in a later pictorial form they constitute +some of the most cherished works of the painters of the Renaissance. + +As regards the prevalence of occasional sexual intercourse between men or +women and animals among primitive peoples at the present time, it is +possible to find many scattered references by travelers in all parts of +the world. Such references by no means indicate that such practices are, +as a rule, common, but they usually show that they are accepted with a +good-humored indifference.[48] + +Bestiality is very rarely found in towns. In the country this vice of the +clodhopper is far from infrequent. For the peasant, whose sensibilities +are uncultivated and who makes but the most elementary demands from a +woman, the difference between an animal and a human being in this respect +scarcely seems to be very great. "My wife was away too long," a German +peasant explained to the magistrate, "and so I went with my sow." It is +certainly an explanation that to the uncultivated peasant, ignorant of +theological and juridical conceptions, must often seem natural and +sufficient. + + Bestiality thus resembles masturbation and other abnormal + manifestations of the sexual impulse which may be practiced + merely _faute de mieux_ and not as, in the strict sense, + perversions of the impulse. Even necrophily may be thus + practiced. A young man who when assisting the grave-digger + conceived and carried out the idea of digging up the bodies of + young girls to satisfy his passions with, and whose case has + been recorded by Belletrud and Mercier, said: "I could find no + young girl who would agree to yield to my desires; that is why I + have done this. I should have preferred to have relations with + living persons. I found it quite natural to do what I did: I saw + no harm in it, and I did not think that any one else could. As + living women felt nothing but repulsion for me, it was quite + natural I should turn to the dead, who have never repulsed me. I + used to say tender things to them like 'my beautiful, my love, I + love you.'" (Belletrud and Mercier "Perversion de l'Instinct + Genésique," _Annales d'Hygiène Publique_, June, 1903.) But when + so highly abnormal an act is felt as natural we are dealing with + a person who is congenitally defective so far as the finer + developments of intelligence are concerned. It was so in this + case of necrophily; he was the son of a weak-minded woman of + unrestrainable sexual inclinations, and was himself somewhat + feeble-minded; he was also, it is instructive to observe, + anosmic. + +But it is by no means only their dulled sensibility or the absence of +women, which accounts for the frequency of bestiality among peasants. A +highly important factor is their constant familiarity with animals. The +peasant lives with animals, tends them, learns to know all their +individual characters; he understands them far better than he understands +men and women; they are his constant companions, his friends. He knows, +moreover, the details of their sexual lives, he witnesses the often highly +impressive spectacle of their coupling. It is scarcely surprising that +peasants should sometimes regard animals as being not only as near to them +as their fellow human beings, but even nearer. + +The significance of the factor of familiarity is indicated by the great +frequency of bestiality among shepherds, goatherds, and others whose +occupation is exclusively the care of animals. Mirabeau, in the eighteenth +century, stated, on the evidence of Basque priests, that all the shepherds +in the Pyrenees practice bestiality. It is apparently much the same in +Italy.[49] In South Italy and Sicily, especially, bestiality among +goatherds and peasants is said to be almost a national custom.[50] In the +extreme north of Europe, it is reported, the reindeer, in this respect, +takes the place of the goat. + +The importance of the same factor is also shown by the fact that when +among women in civilization animal perversions appear, the animal is +nearly always a pet dog. Usually in these cases the animal is taught to +give gratification by _cunnilinctus_. In some cases, however, there is +really sexual intercourse between the animal and the woman. + + Moll mentions that in a case of _cunnilinctus_ by a dog in + Germany there was a difficulty as to whether the matter should be + considered an unnatural offence or simply an offence against + decency; the lower court considered it in the former light, while + the higher court took the more merciful view. (Moll, + _Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 697.) In a + case reported by Pfaff and mentioned by Moll, a country girl was + accused of having sexual intercourse with a large dog. On + examination Pfaff found in the girl's thick pubic hair a loose + hair which under the microscope proved to belong to the dog. + (_Loc. cit._, p. 698.) In such a case it must be noted that while + this evidence may be held to show sexual contact with the dog, it + scarcely suffices to show sexual intercourse. This has, however, + undoubtedly occurred from time to time, even more or less openly. + Bloch (_Op. cit._, pp. 277 and 282) remarks that this is not an + infrequent exhibition given by prostitutes in certain brothels. + Maschka has referred to such an exhibition between a woman and a + bull-dog, which was given to select circles in Paris. Rosse + refers to a case in which a young unmarried woman in Washington + was surprised during intercourse with a large English mastiff, + who in his efforts to get loose caused such severe injuries that + the woman died from hæmorrhage in about an hour. Rosse also + mentions that some years ago a performance of this kind between a + prostitute and a Newfoundland dog could be witnessed in San + Francisco by paying a small sum; the woman declared that a woman + who had once copulated with a dog would ever afterwards prefer + this animal to a man. Rosse adds that he was acquainted with a + similar performance between a woman and a donkey, which used to + take place in Europe (Irving Rosse, "Sexual Hypochondriasis and + Perversion of the Genesic Instinct," _Virginia Medical Monthly_, + October, 1892, p. 379). Juvenal mentions such relations between + the donkey and woman (vi, 332). Krauss (quoted by Bloch, + _Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil II, p. + 276) states that in Bosnia women sometimes carry on these + practices with dogs and also--as he would not have believed had + he not on one occasion observed it--with cats. "It seems to me," + writes Dr. Kiernan, of Chicago, (private letter) "that what Rosse + says of the animal exhibitions in San Francisco is true of all + great cities. The animal employed in such exhibitions here has + usually been a donkey, and in one instance death occurred from + the animal trampling the girl partner. The practice described + occurs in country regions quite frequently. Thus in a case + reported in the suburbs of Omaha, Nebraska, a sixteen-year-old + boy engaged in rectal coitus with a large dog. In attempting to + extricate his swollen penis from the boy's rectum the dog tore + through the _sphincter ani_ an inch into the gluteus muscles. + (_Omaha Clinic_, March, 1893.) In a Missouri case, which I + verified, a smart, pretty, well-educated country girl was found + with a profuse offensive vaginal discharge which had been present + for about a week, coming on suddenly. After washing the external + genitals and opening the labia three rents were discovered, one + through the fourchette and two through the left nymphæ. The + vagina was excessively congested and covered with points bleeding + on the slightest irritation. The patient confessed that one day + while playing with the genitals of a large dog she became excited + and thought she would have slight coitus. After the dog had made + an entrance she was unable to free herself from him, as he + clasped her so firmly with his fore legs. The penis became so + swollen that the dog could not free himself, although for more + than an hour she made persistent efforts to do so. (_Medical + Standard_, June, 1903, p. 184). In an Indiana case, concerning + which I was consulted, the girl was a hebephreniac who had + resorted to this procedure with a Newfoundland dog at the + instance of another girl, seemingly normal as regards mentality, + and had been badly injured; a discharge resulted which resembled + gonorrhoea, but contained no gonococci. These cases are probably + more frequent than is usually assumed." + + Women are known to have had intercourse with various other + animals, occasionally or habitually, in various parts of the + world. Monkeys have been mentioned in this connection. Moll + remarks that it seems to be an indication of an abnormal interest + in monkeys that some women are observed by the attendants in the + monkey-house of zoölogical gardens to be very frequent visitors. + Near the Amazon the traveler Castelnau saw an enormous Coati + monkey belonging to an Indian woman and tried to purchase it; + though he offered a large sum, the woman only laughed. "Your + efforts are useless," remarked an Indian in the same cabin, "he + is her husband." (So far as the early literature of this subject + is concerned, a number of facts and fables regarding the congress + of women with dogs, goats and other animals was brought together + at the beginning of the eighteenth century by Schurig in his + _Gynæcologia_, Section II, cap. VII; I have not drawn on this + collection.) + + In some cases women, and also men, find gratification in the + sexual manipulation of animals without any kind of congress. This + may be illustrated by an observation communicated to me by a + correspondent, a clergyman. "In Ireland, my father's house + adjoined the residence of an archdeacon of the established + church. I was then about 20 and was still kept in religious awe + of evil ways. The archdeacon had two daughters, both of whom he + brought up in great strictness, resolved that they should grow up + examples of virtue and piety. Our stables adjoined, and were + separated only by a thin wall in which was a doorway closed up by + some boards, as the two stables had formerly been one. One night + I had occasion to go to our stable to search for a garden tool I + had missed, and I heard a door open on the other side, and saw a + light glimmer through the cracks of the boards. I looked through + to ascertain who could be there at that late hour, and soon + recognized the stately figure of one of the daughters, F.F. was + tall, dark and handsome, but had never made any advances to me, + nor had I to her. She was making love to her father's mare after + a singular fashion. Stripping her right arm, she formed her + fingers into a cone, and pressed on the mare's vulva. I was + astonished to see the beast stretching her hind legs as if to + accommodate the hand of her mistress, which she pushed in + gradually and with seeming ease to the elbow. At the same time + she seemed to experience the most voluptuous sensation, crisis + after crisis arriving." My correspondent adds that, being + exceedingly curious in the matter, he tried a somewhat similar + experiment himself with one of his father's mares and experienced + what he describes as "a most powerful sexual battery" which + produced very exciting and exhausting effects. Näcke + (_Psychiatrische en Neurologische Bladen_, 1899, No. 2) refers to + an idiot who thus manipulated the vulva of mares in his charge. + The case has been recorded by Guillereau (_Journal de Médicine + Véterinaire et de Zootechnie_, January, 1899) of a youth who was + accustomed to introduce his hand into the vulva of cows in order + to obtain sexual excitement. + + The possibility of sexual excitement between women and animals + involves a certain degree of sexual excitability in animals from + contact with women. Darwin stated that there could be no doubt + that various quadrumanous animals could distinguish women from + men--in the first place probably by smell and secondarily by + sight--and be thus liable to sexual excitement. He quotes the + opinions on this point of Youatt, Brehm, Sir Andrew Smith and + Cuvier (_Descent of Man_, second edition, p. 8). Moll quotes the + opinion of an experienced observer to the same effect + (_Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, Bd. i, p. 429). + Hufeland reported the case of a little girl of three who was + playing, seated on a stool, with a dog placed between her thighs + and locked against her. Seemingly excited by this contact the + animal attempted a sort of copulation, causing the genital parts + of the child to become inflamed. Bloch (_Op. cit._, p. 280, _et + seq._) discusses the same point; he does not consider that + animals will of their own motion sexually cohabit with women, but + that they may be easily trained to it. There can be no doubt that + dogs at all events are sometimes sexually excited by the presence + of women, perhaps especially during menstruation, and many women + are able to bear testimony to the embarrassing attentions they + have sometimes received from strange dogs. There can be no + difficulty in believing that, so far as _cunnilinctus_ is + concerned dogs would require no training. In a case recorded by + Moll (_Konträre Sexualempfindung_, third edition, p. 560) a lady + states that this was done to her when a child, as also to other + children, by dogs who, she said, showed signs of sexual + excitement. In this case there was also sexual excitement thus + produced in the child, and after puberty mutual _cunnilinctus_ + was practiced with girl friends. Guttceit (_Dreissig Jahre + Praxis_, Theil I, p. 310) remarks that some Russian officers who + were in the Turkish campaign of 1828 told him that from fear of + veneral infection in Wallachia they refrained from women and + often used female asses which appeared to show signs of sexual + pleasure. + +A very large number of animals have been recorded as having been employed +in the gratification of sexual desire at some period or in some country, +by men and sometimes by women. Domestic animals are naturally those which +most frequently come into question, and there are few if any of these +which can altogether be excepted. The sow is one of the animals most +frequently abused in this manner.[51] Cases in which mares, cows, and +donkeys figure constantly occur, as well as goats and sheep. Dogs, cats, +and rabbits are heard of from time to time. Hens, ducks, and, especially +in China, geese, are not uncommonly employed. The Roman ladies were said +to have had an abnormal affection for snakes. The bear and even the +crocodile are also mentioned.[52] + +The social and legal attitude toward bestiality has reflected in part the +frequency with which it has been practiced, and in part the disgust mixed +with mystical and sacrilegious horror which it has aroused. It has +sometimes been met merely by a fine, and sometimes the offender and his +innocent partner have been burnt together. In the middle ages and later +its frequency is attested by the fact that it formed a favorite topic with +preachers of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. It is significant that +in the Penitentials,--which were criminal codes, half secular and half +spiritual, in use before the thirteenth century, when penance was +relegated to the judgment of the confessor,--it was thought necessary to +fix the periods of penance which should be undergone respectively by +bishops, priests and deacons who should be guilty of bestiality. + + In Egbert's Penitential, a document of the ninth and tenth + centuries, we read (V. 22): "Item Episcopus cum quadrupede + fornicans VII annos, consuetudinem X, presbyter V, diaconus III, + clerus II." There was a great range in the penances for + bestiality, from ten years to (in the case of boys) one hundred + days. The mare is specially mentioned (Haddon and Stubbs, + _Councils and Ecclesiastical Documents_, vol. iii, p. 422). In + Theodore's Penitential, another Anglo-Saxon document of about the + same age, those who habitually fornicate with animals are + adjudged ten years of penance. It would appear from the + _Penitentiale Pseudo-Romanum_ (which is earlier than the eleventh + century) that one year's penance was adequate for fornication + with a mare when committed by a layman (exactly the same as for + simple fornication with a widow or virgin), and this was + mercifully reduced to half a year if he had no wife. + (Wasserschleben, _Die Bussordnungen der Abendländlichen Kirche_, + p. 366). The _Penitentiale Hubertense_ (emanating from the + monastery of St. Hubert in the Ardennes) fixes ten years' penance + for sodomy, while Fulbert's Penitential (about the eleventh + century) fixes seven years for either sodomy or bestiality. + Burchard's Penitential, which is always detailed and precise, + specially mentions the mare, the cow and the ass, and assigns + forty days bread and water and seven years penance, raised to ten + years in the case of married men. A woman having intercourse with + a horse is assigned seven years penance in Burchard's + Penitential. (Wasserschleben, ib. pp. 651, 659.) + +The extreme severity which was frequently exercised toward those guilty of +this offense, was doubtless in large measure due to the fact that +bestiality was regarded as a kind of sodomy, an offense which was +frequently viewed with a mystical horror apart altogether from any actual +social or personal injury it caused. The Jews seem to have felt this +horror; it was ordered that the sinner and his victim should both be put +to death (Exodus, Ch. 22, v. 19; Leviticus, Ch. 20, v. 15). In the middle +ages, especially in France, the same rule often prevailed. Men and sows, +men and cows, men and donkeys were burnt together. At Toulouse a woman was +burnt for having intercourse with a dog. Even in the seventeenth century a +learned French lawyer, Claude Lebrun de la Rochette, justified such +sentences.[53] It seems probable that even to-day, in the social and legal +attitude toward bestiality, sufficient regard is not paid to the fact that +this offense is usually committed either by persons who are morbidly +abnormal or who are of so low a degree of intelligence that they border on +feeble-mindedness. To what extent, and on what grounds, it ought to be +punished is a question calling for serious reconsideration. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[33] For Krafft-Ebing's discussion of the subject see _Op. cit._, pp. +530-539. + +[34] In England it is not uncommon to use the term "unnatural offence;" +this is an awkward and possibly misleading practice which should not be +followed. In Germany a similar confusion is caused by applying the term +"sodomy" to these cases as well as to pederasty. Krafft-Ebing considers +that this error is due to the jurists, while the theologians have always +distinguished correctly. In this matter, he adds, science must be _ancilla +theologiæ_ and return to the correct usage of words. + +[35] This childish interest, with later abnormal developments, may be seen +in History I of the Appendix to this volume. + +[36] The Countess of Pembroke, Sir Philip Sidney's sister, appears to have +found sexual enjoyment in the contemplation of the sexual prowess of +stallions. Aubrey writes that she "was very salacious and she had a +contrivance that in the spring of the year ... the stallions ... were to +be brought before such a part of the house where she had a vidette to look +on them." (_Short Lives_, 1898, vol. i, p. 311.) Although the modern +editor's modesty has caused the disappearance of several lines from this +passage, the general sense is clear. In the same century Burchard, the +faithful secretary of Pope Alexander VI, describes in his invaluable diary +how four race horses were brought to two mares in a court of the Vatican, +the horses clamorously fighting for the possession of the mares and +eventually mounting them, while the Pope and his daughter Lucrezia looked +on from a window "cum magno risu et delectatione." (_Diarium_, ed Thuasne, +vol. III, p. 169.) + +[37] _Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1902, fasc. ii-iii, p. 338. In the case of +pathological sexuality in a boy of 15, reported by A. MacDonald, and +already summarized, the sight of copulating flies is also mentioned among +many other causes of sexual excitation. + +[38] Krafft-Ebing presents or quotes typical cases of all these fetiches, +_Op. cit._, pp. 255-266. + +[39] G. Stanley Hall, "A study of Fears," _American Journal of +Psychology_, 1897, pp. 213-215. + +[40] _Op. cit._, p. 268. + +[41] W. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," _Alienist and Neurologist_, January, +1896. Krafft-Ebing (op. cit., p. 532) quotes from Boeteau the somewhat +similar case of a gardener's boy of 16--an illegitimate child of +neuropathic heredity and markedly degenerate--who had a passion, of +irresistible and impulsive character, for rabbits. He was declared +irresponsible. Moll (_Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, pp. +431-433) presents the case of a neurotic man who from the age of 15 had +been sexually excited by the sight of animals or by contact with them. He +had repeatedly had connection with cows and mares; he was also sexually +excited by sheep, donkeys, and dogs, whether female or male; the normal +sexual instinct was weak and he experienced very slight attraction to +women. + +[42] Moll also remarks ("Perverse Sexualempfindung," in Senator's and +Kaminer's _Krankheiten und Ehe_) that in this matter it is often hardly +possible to draw a sharp line between vice and disease. + +[43] Instances of this widespread belief--found among the Tamils of Ceylon +as well as in Europe--are quoted from various authors by Bloch, _Beiträge +zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil II, p. 278, and Moll, +_Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 700. On the frequency +of bestiality, from one cause or another, in the East, see, e.g., Stern, +_Medizin und Geschlechtsleben in der Türkei_, bd. ii, p. 219. + +[44] Sometimes (as among the Aleuts) the animal pantomime dances of +savages may represent the transformation of a captive bird into a lovely +woman who falls exhausted into the arms of the hunter. (H.H. Bancroft, +_Native Races of the Pacific_, vol. i, p. 93.) A system of beliefs which +accepts the possibility that a human being may be latent in an animal +obviously favors the practice of bestiality. + +[45] For an example of the primitive confusion between the intercourse of +women with animals and with men see, e.g., Boas, "Sagen aus +British-Columbia," _Zeitschrift für Ethnologie_, heft V, p. 558. + +[46] Herodotus, Book II, Chapter 46. + +[47] Dulare (_Des Divinités Génératrices_, Chapter II) brings together the +evidence showing that in Egypt women had connection with the sacred goat, +apparently in order to secure fertility. + +[48] Various facts and references bearing on this subject are brought +together by Blumenbach, _Anthropological Memoirs_, translated by Bendyshe, +p. 80; Block, _Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil II, +pp. 276-283; also Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, seventh edition, p. 520. + +[49] Mantegazza mentions (_Gli Amori degli Uomini_, cap V) that at Rimini +a young goatherd of the Apennines, troubled with dyspepsia and nervous +symptoms, told him this was due to excesses with the goats in his care. A +finely executed marble group of a satyr having connection with a goat, +found at Herculaneum and now in the Naples Museum (reproduced in Fuchs's +_Erotische Element in der Karikatur_), perhaps symbolizes a traditional +and primitive practice of the goatherd. + +[50] Bayle (_Dictionary_, Art, Bathyllus) quotes various authorities +concerning the Italian auxiliaries in the south of France in the sixteenth +century and their custom of bringing and using goats for this purpose. +Warton in the eighteenth century was informed that in Sicily priests in +confession habitually inquired of herdsmen if they had anything to do with +their sows. In Normandy priests are advised to ask similar questions. + +[51] It is worth noting that in Greek the work choiros means both a sow +and a woman's pudenda; in the _Acharnians_ Aristophanes plays on this +association at some length. The Romans also (as may be gathered from +Varro's _De Re Rustica_) called the feminine pudenda _porcus_. + +[52] Schurig, _Gynæcologia_, pp. 280-387; Bloch, op. cit., 270-277. The +Arabs, according to Kocher, chiefly practice bestiality with goats, sheep +and mares. The Annamites, according to Mondière, commonly employ sows and +(more especially the young women) dogs. Among the Tamils of Ceylon +bestiality with goats and cows is said to be very prevalent. + +[53] Mantegazza (_Gli Amori degli Uomini_, cap. V) brings together some +facts bearing on this matter. + + + + +V. + +Exhibitionism--Illustrative Cases--A Symbolic Perversion of Courtship--The +Impulse to Defile--The Exhibitionist's Psychic Attitude--The Sexual Organs +as Fetichs--Phallus Worship--Adolescent Pride in Sexual +Development--Exhibitionism of the Nates--The Classification of the Forms +of Exhibitionism--Nature of the Relationship of Exhibitionism to Epilepsy. + + +There is a remarkable form of erotic symbolism--very definite and standing +clearly apart from all other forms--in which sexual gratification is +experienced in the simple act of exhibiting the sexual organ to persons of +the opposite sex, usually by preference to young and presumably innocent +persons, very often children. This is termed exhibitionism.[54] It would +appear to be a not very infrequent phenomenon, and most women, once or +more in their lives, especially when young, have encountered a man who has +thus deliberately exposed himself before them. + +The exhibitionist, though often a young and apparently vigorous man, is +always satisfied with the mere act of self-exhibition and the emotional +reaction which that act produces; he makes no demands on the woman to whom +he exposes himself; he seldom speaks, he makes no effort to approach her; +as a rule, he fails even to display the signs of sexual excitation. His +desires are completely gratified by the act of exhibition and by the +emotional reaction it arouses in the woman. He departs satisfied and +relieved. + + A case recorded by Schrenck-Notzing very well represents both the + nature of the impulse felt by the exhibitionist and the way in + which it may originate. It is the case of a business man of 49, + of neurotic heredity, an affectionate husband and father of a + family, who, to his own grief and shame, is compelled from time + to time to exhibit his sexual organs to women in the street. As a + boy of 10 a girl of 12 tried to induce him to coitus; both had + their sexual parts exposed. From that time sexual contacts, as of + his own naked nates against those of a girl, became attractive, + as well as games in which the boys and girls in turn marched + before each other with their sexual parts exposed, and also + imitation of the copulation of animals. Coitus was first + practiced about the age of 20, but sight and touch of the woman's + sexual parts were always necessary to produce sexual excitement. + It was also necessary--and this consideration is highly important + as regards the development of the tendency to exhibition--that + the woman should be excited by the sight of his organs. Even when + he saw or touched a woman's parts orgasm often occurred. It was + the naked sexual organs in an otherwise clothed body which + chiefly excited him. He was not possessed of a high degree of + potency. Girls between the ages of 10 and 17 chiefly excited him, + and especially if he felt that they were quite ignorant of sexual + matters. His self-exhibition was a sort of psychic defloration, + and it was accompanied by the idea that other people felt as he + did about the sexual effects of the naked organs, that he was + shocking but at the same time sexually exciting a young girl. He + was thus gratifying himself through the belief that he was + causing sexual gratification to an innocent girl. This man was + convicted several times, and was finally declared to be suffering + from impulsive insanity. (Schrenck-Notzing, + _Kriminal-psychologische und Psycho-pathologische Studien_, 1902, + pp. 50-57.) In another case of Schrenck-Notzing's, an actor and + portrait painter, aged 31, in youth masturbated and was fond of + contemplating the images of the sexual organs of both sexes, + finding little pleasure in coitus. At the age of 24, at a bathing + establishment, he happened to occupy a compartment next to that + occupied by a lady, and when naked he became aware that his + neighbor was watching him through a chink in the partition. This + caused him powerful excitement and he was obliged to masturbate. + Ever since he has had an impulse to exhibit his organs and to + masturbate in the presence of women. He believes that the sight + of his organs excites the woman (Ib., pp. 57-68). The presence of + masturbation in this case renders it untypical as a case of + exhibitionism. Moll at one time went so far as to assert that + when masturbation takes place we are not entitled to admit + exhibitionism, (_Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, + p. 661), but now accepts exhibitionism with masturbation + ("Perverse Sexualempfindung," _Krankheiten und Ehe_). The act of + exhibition itself gratifies the sexual impulse, and usually it + suffices to replace both tumescence and detumescence. + + A fairly typical case, recorded by Krafft-Ebing, is that of a + German factory worker of 37, a good, sober and intelligent + workman. His parents were healthy, but one of his mother's and + also one of his father's sisters were insane; some of his + relatives are eccentric in religion. He has a languishing + expression and a smile of self-complacency. He never had any + severe illness, but has always been eccentric and imaginative, + much absorbed in romances (such as Dumas's novels) and fond of + identifying himself with their heroes. No signs of epilepsy. In + youth moderate masturbation, later moderate coitus. He lives a + retired life, but is fond of elegant dress and of ornament. + Though not a drinker, he sometimes makes himself a kind of punch + which has a sexually exciting effect on him. The impulse to + exhibitionism has only developed in recent years. When the + impulse is upon him he becomes hot, his heart beats violently, + the blood rushes to his head, and he is oblivious of everything + around him that is not connected with his own act. Afterwards he + regards himself as a fool and makes vain resolutions never to + repeat the act. In exhibition the penis is only half erect and + ejaculation never occurs. (He is only capable of coitus with a + woman who shows great attraction to him.) He is satisfied with + self-exhibition, and believes that he thus gives pleasure to the + woman, since he himself receives pleasure in contemplating a + woman's sexual parts. His erotic dreams are of self-exhibition to + young and voluptuous women. He had been previously punished for + an offense of this kind; medico-legal opinion now recognized the + incriminated man's psychopathic condition. (Krafft-Ebing, _Op. + cit._, pp. 492-494.) + + Trochon has reported the case of a married man of 33, a worker in + a factory, who for several years had exhibited himself at + intervals to shop-girls, etc., in a state of erection, but + without speaking or making other advances. He was a hard-working, + honest, sober man of quiet habits, a good father to his family + and happy at home. He showed not the slightest sign of insanity. + But he was taciturn, melancholic and nervous; a sister was an + idiot. He was arrested, but on the report of the experts that he + committed these acts from a morbid impulse he could not control + he was released. (Trochon, _Archives de l'Anthropologie + Criminelle_, 1888, p. 256.) + + In a case of Freyer's (_Zeitschrift für Medizinalbeamte_, third + year, No. 8) the occasional connection of exhibitionism with + epilepsy is well illustrated by a barber's assistant, aged 35, + whose father suffered from chronic alcoholism and was also said + to have committed the same kind of offense as his son. The mother + and a sister suffered nervously. From ages of 7 to 18 the subject + had epileptic convulsions. From 16 to 21 he indulged in normal + sexual intercourse. At about that time he had often to pass a + playground and at times would urinate there; it happened that the + children watched him with curiosity. He noticed that when thus + watched sexual excitement was caused, inducing erection and even + ejaculation. He gradually found pleasure in this kind of sexual + gratification; finally he became indifferent to coitus. His + erotic dreams, though still usually about normal coitus, were now + sometimes concerned with exhibition before little girls. When + overcome by the impulse he could see and hear nothing around him, + though he did not lose consciousness. After the act was over he + was troubled by his deed. In all other respects he was entirely + reasonable. He was imprisoned many times for exhibiting himself + to young schoolgirls, sometimes vaunting the beauty of his organs + and inviting inspection. On one occasion he underwent mental + examination, but was considered to be mentally sound. He was + finally held to be a hereditarily tainted individual with + neuropathic constitution. The head was abnormally broad, penis + small, patellar reflex absent, and there were many signs of + neurasthenia. (Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, pp. 490-492.) + + The prevalence of epilepsy among exhibitionists is shown by the + observations of Pelanda in Verona. He has recorded six cases of + this perversion, all of which eventually reached the asylum and + were either epileptics or with epileptic relations. One had a + brother who was also an exhibitionist. In some cases the penis + was abnormally large, in others abnormally small. Several had + very weak sexual impulse; one, at the age of 62, had never + effected coitus, and was proud of the fact that he was still a + virgin, considering, he would say, the epoch of demoralization in + which we live. (Pelanda, "Pornopatici," _Archivio di + Psichiatria_, fasc. ii-iv, 1889.) + + In a very typical case of exhibitionism which Garnier has + recorded, a certain X., a gentleman engaged in business in Paris, + had a predilection for exhibiting himself in churches, more + especially in Saint-Roch. He was arrested several times for + exposing his sexual organs here before ladies in prayer. In this + way he finally ruined his commercial position in Paris and was + obliged to establish himself in a small provincial town. Here + again he soon exposed himself in a church and was again sent to + prison, but on his liberation immediately performed the same act + in the same church in what was described as a most imperturbable + manner. Compelled to leave the town, he returned to Paris, and in + a few weeks' time was again arrested for repeating his old + offense in Saint Roch. When examined by Garnier, the information + he supplied was vague and incomplete, and he was very embarrassed + in the attempt to explain himself. He was unable to say why he + chose a church, but he felt that it was to a church that he must + go. He had, however, no thought of profanation and no wish to + give offense. "Quite the contrary!" he declared. He had the sad + and tired air of a man who is dominated by a force stronger than + his will. "I know," he added, "what repulsion my conduct must + inspire. Why am I made thus? Who will cure me?" (P. Garnier, + "Perversions Sexuelles," _Comptes Rendus_, International Congress + of Medicine at Paris in 1900, _Section de Psychiatrie_, pp. + 433-435.) + + In some cases, it would appear, the impulse to exhibitionism may + be overcome or may pass away. This result is the more likely to + come about in those cases in which exhibitionism has been largely + conditioned by chronic alcoholism or other influences tending to + destroy the inhibiting and restraining action of the higher + centers, which may be overcome by hygiene and treatment. In this + connection I may bring forward a case which has been communicated + to me by a medical correspondent in London. It is that of an + actor, of high standing in his profession and extremely + intelligent, 49 years of age, married and father of a large + family. He is sexually vigorous and of erotic temperament. His + general health has always been good, but he is a high-strung, + neurotic man, with quick mental reactions. His habits had for a + long time been decidedly alcoholic, but two years ago, a small + quantity of albumen being found in the urine, he was persuaded to + leave off alcohol, and has since been a teetotaller. Though + ordinarily very reticent about sexual matters, he began four or + five years ago to commit acts of exhibitionism, exposing himself + to servants in the house and occasionally to women in the + country. This continued after the alcohol had been abandoned and + lasted for several years, though the attention of the police was + never attracted to the matter, and so far as possible he was + quietly supervised by his friends. Nine months after, the acts of + exhibitionism ceased, apparently in a spontaneous manner, and + there has so far been no relapse. + +Exhibitionism is an act which, on the face of it, seems nonsensical and +meaningless, and as such, as an inexplicable act of madness, it has +frequently been treated both by writers on insanity and on sexual +perversion. "These acts are so lacking in common sense and intelligent +reflection that no other reason than insanity can be offered for the +patient," Ball concluded.[55] Moll, also, who defines exhibitionism +somewhat too narrowly as a condition in which "the charm of the exhibition +lies for the subject in the display itself," not sufficiently taking into +consideration the imagined effect on the spectator, concludes that "the +psychological basis of exhibitionism is at present by no means cleared +up."[56] + +We may probably best approach exhibitionism by regarding it as +fundamentally a symbolic act based on a perversion of courtship. The +exhibitionist displays the organ of sex to a feminine witness, and in the +shock of modest sexual shame by which she reacts to that spectacle, he +finds a gratifying similitude of the normal emotions of coitus.[57] He +feels that he has effected a psychic defloration. + + Exhibitionism is thus analogous, and, indeed, related, to the + impulse felt by many persons to perform indecorous acts or tell + indecent stories before young and innocent persons of the + opposite sex. This is a kind of psychic exhibitionism, the + gratification it causes lying exactly, as in physical + exhibitionism, in the emotional confusion which it is felt to + arouse. The two kinds of exhibitionism may be combined in the + same person: Thus, in a case reported by Hoche (p. 97), the + exhibitionist an intellectual and highly educated man, with a + doctor's degree, also found pleasure in sending indecent poems + and pictures to women, whom, however, he made no attempt to + seduce; he was content with the thought of the emotions he + aroused or believed that he aroused. + + It is possible that within this group should come the agent in + the following incident which was lately observed by a lady, a + friend of my own. An elderly man in an overcoat was seen standing + outside a large and well-known draper's shop in the outskirts of + London; when able to attract the attention of any of the + shop-girls or of any girl in the street he would fling back his + coat and reveal that he was wearing over his own clothes a + woman's chemise (or possibly bodice) and a woman's drawers; there + was no exposure. The only intelligible explanation of this action + would seem to be that pleasure was experienced in the mild shock + of interested surprise and injured modesty which this vision was + imagined to cause to a young girl. It would thus be a + comparatively innocent form of psychic defloration. + +It is of interest to point out that the sexual symbolism of active +flagellation is very closely analogous to this symbolism of exhibitionism. +The flagellant approaches a woman with the rod (itself a symbol of the +penis and in some countries bearing names which are also applied to that +organ) and inflicts on an intimate part of her body the signs of blushing +and the spasmodic movements which are associated with sexual excitement, +while at the same time she feels, or the flagellant imagines that she +feels, the corresponding emotions of delicious shame.[58] This is an even +closer mimicry of the sexual act than the exhibitionist attains, for the +latter fails to secure the consent of the woman nor does he enjoy any +intimate contact with her naked body. The difference is connected with the +fact that the active flagellant is usually a more virile and normal person +than the exhibitionist. In the majority of cases the exhibitionist's +sexual impulse is very feeble, and as a rule he is either to some degree a +degenerate, or else a person who is suffering from an early stage of +general paralysis, dementia, or some other highly enfeebling cause of +mental disorganization, such as chronic alcoholism. Sexual feebleness is +further indicated by the fact that the individuals selected as witnesses +are frequently mere children. + + It seems probable that a form of erotic symbolism somewhat + similar to exhibitionism is to be found in the rare cases in + which sexual gratification is derived from throwing ink, acid or + other defiling liquids on women's dresses. Thoinot has recorded a + case of this kind (_Attentats aux Moeurs_, 1898, pp. 484, _et + seq._). An instructive case has been presented by Moll. In this + case a young man of somewhat neuropathic heredity had as a youth + of 16 or 17, when romping with his young sister's playfellows, + experienced sexual sensations on chancing to see their white + underlinen. From that time white underlinen and white dresses + became to him a fetich and he was only attracted to women so + attired. One day, at the age of 25, when crossing the street in + wet weather with a young lady in a white dress, a passing vehicle + splashed the dress with mud. This incident caused him strong + sexual excitement, and from that time he had the impulse to throw + ink, perchloride of iron, etc., on to ladies' white dresses, and + sometimes to cut and tear them, sexual excitement and ejaculation + taking place every time he effected this. (Moll, "Gutachten über + einem Sexual Perversen [Besudelungstrieb]," _Zeitschrift für + Medizinalbeamte_, Heft XIII, 1900). Such a case is of + considerable psychological interest. Thoinot considers that in + these cases the fleck is a fetich. That is an incorrect account + of the matter. In this case the white garments constituted the + primary fetich, but that fetich becomes more acutely realized, + and at the same time both parties are thrown into an emotional + state which to the fetichist becomes a mimicry of coitus, by the + act of defilement. We may perhaps connect with this phenomenon + the attraction which muddy shoes often exert over the + shoe-fetichist, and the curious way in which, as we have seen (p. + 18), Restif de la Bretonne associates his love of neatness in + women with his attraction to the feet, the part, he remarks, + least easy to keep clean. + + Garnier applied the term _sadi-fetichism_ to active flagellation + and many similar manifestations such as we are here concerned + with, on the grounds that they are hybrids which combine the + morbid adoration for a definite object with the impulse to + exercise a more or less degree of violence. From the standpoint + of the conception of erotic symbolism I have adopted there is no + need for this term. There is here no hybrid combination of two + unlike mental states. We are simply concerned with states of + erotic symbolism, more or less complete, more or less complex. + +The conception of exhibitionism as a process of erotic symbolism, involves +a conscious or unconscious attitude of attention in the exhibitionist's +mind to the psychic reaction of the woman toward whom his display is +directed. He seeks to cause an emotion which, probably in most cases, he +desires should be pleasurable. But from one cause or another his finer +sensibilities are always inhibited or in abeyance, and he is unable to +estimate accurately either the impression he is likely to produce or the +general results of his action, or else he is moved by a strong impulsive +obsession which overpowers his judgment. In many cases he has good reason +for believing that his act will be pleasurable, and frequently he finds +complacent witnesses among the low-class servant girls, etc. + + It may be pointed out here that we are quite justified in + speaking of a penis-fetichism and also of a vulva-fetichism. This + might be questioned. We are obviously justified in recognizing a + fetichism which attaches itself to the pubic hair, or, as in a + case with which I am acquainted, to the clitoris, but it may seem + that we cannot regard the central sexual organs as symbols of + sex, symbols, as it were, of themselves. Properly regarded, + however, it is the sexual act rather than the sexual organ which + is craved in normal sexual desire; the organ is regarded merely + as the means and not as the end. Regarded as a means the organ is + indeed an object of desire, but it only becomes a fetich when it + arrests and fixes the attention. An attention thus pleasurably + fixed, a vulva-fetichism or a penis-fetichism, is within the + normal range of sexual emotion (this point has been mentioned in + the previous volume when discussing the part played by the + primary sexual organs in sexual selection), and in coarse-grained + natures of either sex it is a normal allurement in its + generalized shape, apart from any attraction to the person to + whom the organs belong. In some morbid cases, however, this + penis-fetichism may become a fully developed sexual perversion. A + typical case of this kind has been recorded by Howard in the + United States. Mrs. W., aged 39, was married at 20 to a strong, + healthy man, but derived no pleasure from coitus, though she + received great pleasure from masturbation practiced immediately + after coitus, and nine years after marriage she ceased actual + coitus, compelling her husband to adopt mutual masturbation. She + would introduce men into the house at all times of the day or + night, and after persuading them to expose their persons would + retire to her room to masturbate. The same man never aroused + desire more than once. This desire became so violent and + persistent that she would seek out men in all sorts of public + places and, having induced them to expose themselves, rapidly + retreat to the nearest convenient spot for self-gratification. + She once abstracted a pair of trousers she had seen a man wear + and after fondling them experienced the orgasm. Her husband + finally left her, after vainly attempting to have her confined in + an asylum. She was often arrested for her actions, but through + the intervention of friends set free again. She was a highly + intelligent woman, and apart from this perversion entirely + normal. (W.L. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," _Alienist and + Neurologist_, January, 1896.) It is on the existence of a more or + less developed penis-fetichism of this kind that the + exhibitionist, mostly by an ignorant instinct, relies for the + effects he desires to produce. + +The exhibitionist is not usually content to produce a mere titillated +amusement; he seeks to produce a more powerful effect which must be +emotional whether or not it is pleasurable. A professional man in +Strassburg (in a case reported by Hoche[59]) would walk about in the +evening in a long cloak, and when he met ladies would suddenly throw his +cloak back under a street lamp, or igniting a red-fire match, and thus +exhibit his organs. There was an evident effort--on the part of a weak, +vain, and effeminate man--to produce a maximum of emotional effect. The +attempt to heighten the emotional shock is also seen in the fact that the +exhibitionist frequently chooses a church as the scene of his exploits, +not during service, for he always avoids a concourse of people, but +perhaps toward evening when there are only a few kneeling women scattered +through the edifice. The church is chosen, often instinctively rather than +deliberately, from no impulse to commit a sacrilegious outrage--which, as +a rule, the exhibitionist does not feel his act to be--but because it +really presents the conditions most favorable to the act and the effects +desired. The exhibitionist's attitude of mind is well illustrated by one +of Garnier's patients who declared that he never wished to be seen by more +than two women at once, "just what is necessary," he added, "for an +exchange of impressions." After each exhibition he would ask himself +anxiously: "Did they see me? What are they thinking? What do they say to +each other about me? Oh! how I should like to know!" Another patient of +Garnier's, who haunted churches for this purpose, made this very +significant statement: "Why do I like going to churches? I can scarcely +say. _But I know that it is only there that my act has its full +importance_. The woman is in a devout frame of mind, and she must see that +such an act in such a place is not a joke in bad taste or a disgusting +obscenity; _that if I go there it is not to amuse myself; it is more +serious than that!_ I watch the effect produced on the faces of the ladies +to whom I show my organs. I wish to see them express a profound joy. I +wish, in fact, that they may be forced to say to themselves: _How +impressive Nature is when thus seen!_" + + Here we trace the presence of a feeling which recalls the + phenomena of the ancient and world-wide phallic worship, still + liable to reappear sporadically. Women sometimes took part in + these rites, and the osculation of the male sexual organ or its + emblematic representation by women is easily traceable in the + phallic rites of India and many other lands, not excluding Europe + even in comparatively recent times. (Dulaure in his _Divinités + Génératices_ brings together much bearing on these points; cf.: + Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter XVII, and Bloch, + _Beiträge zur Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil I, pp. 115-117. Colin + Scott has some interesting remarks on phallic worship and the + part it has played in aiding human evolution, "Sex and Art," + _American Journal of Psychology_, vol. vii, No. 2, pp. 191-197. + Irving Rosse describes some modern phallic rites in which both + men and women took part, similar to those practiced in vaudouism, + "Sexual Hypochondriasis," _Virginia Medical Monthly_, October, + 1892.) + + Putting aside any question of phallic worship, a certain pride + and more or less private feeling of ostentation in the new + expansion and development of the organs of virility seems to be + almost normal at adolescence. "We have much reason to assume," + Stanley Hall remarks, "that in a state of nature there is a + certain instinctive pride and ostentation that accompanies the + new local development. I think it will be found that + exhibitionists are usually those who have excessive growth here, + and that much that modern society stigmatizes as obscene is at + bottom more or less spontaneous and perhaps in some cases not + abnormal. Dr. Seerley tells me he has never examined a young man + largely developed who had the usual strong instinctive tendency + of modesty to cover himself with his hands, but he finds this + instinct general with those whose development is less than the + average." (G. Stanley Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. ii, p. 97.) This + instinct of ostentation, however, so far as it is normal, is held + in check by other considerations, and is not, in the strict + sense, exhibitionism. I have observed a full-grown telegraph boy + walking across Hampstead Heath with his sexual organs exposed, + but immediately he realized that he was seen he concealed them. + The solemnity of exhibitionism at this age finds expression in + the climax of the sonnet, "Oraison du Soir," written at 16 by + Rimbaud, whose verse generally is a splendid and insolent + manifestation of rank adolescence:-- + + "Doux comme le Seigneur du cèdre et des hysopes, + Je pisse vers les cieux bruns très haut et très loin, + Avec l'assentiment des grands héliotropes." + + (J.A. Rimbaud, _Oeuvres_, p. 68.) + + In women, also, there would appear to be traceable a somewhat + similar ostentation, though in them it is complicated and largely + inhibited by modesty, and at the same time diffused over the body + owing to the absence of external sexual organs. "Primitive + woman," remarks Madame Renooz, "proud of her womanhood, for a + long time defended her nakedness which ancient art has always + represented. And in the actual life of the young girl to-day + there is a moment when by a secret atavism she feels the pride of + her sex, the intuition of her moral superiority, and cannot + understand why she must hide its cause. At this moment, wavering + between the laws of Nature and social conventions, she scarcely + knows if nakedness should or should not affright her. A sort of + confused atavistic memory recalls to her a period before clothing + was known, and reveals to her as a paradisaical ideal the customs + of that human epoch." (Céline Renooz, _Psychologie Comparée de + l'Homme et de la Femme_, p. 85.) It may be added that among + primitive peoples, and even among some remote European + populations to-day, the exhibition of feminine nudity has + sometimes been regarded as a spectacle with religious or magic + operation. (Ploss, _Das Weib_, seventh edition, vol. ii, pp. + 663-680; Havelock Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, p. + 304.) It is stated by Gopcevic that in the long struggle between + the Albanians and the Montenegrians the women of the former + people would stand in the front rank and expose themselves by + raising their skirts, believing that they would thus insure + victory. As, however, they were shot down, and as, moreover, + victory usually fell to the Montenegrians, this custom became + discredited. (Quoted by Bloch, _Op. cit._, Teil II, p. 307.) + + With regard to the association, suggested by Stanley Hall, + between exhibitionism and an unusual degree of development of the + sexual organs, it must be remarked that both extremes--a very + large and a very small penis--are specially common in + exhibitionists. The prevalence of the small organ is due to an + association of exhibitionism with sexual feebleness. The + prevalence of the large organ may be due to the cause suggested + by Hall. Among Mahommedans the sexual organs are sometimes + habitually exposed by religious penitents, and I note that + Bernhard Stern, in his book on the medical and sexual aspects of + life in Turkey, referring to a penitent of this sort whom he saw + on the Stamboul bridge at Constantinople, remarks that the organ + was very largely developed. It may well be in such a case that + the penitent's religious attitude is reinforced by some lingering + relic of a more fleshly ostentation. + +It is by a pseudo-atavism that this phallicism is evoked in the +exhibitionist. There is no true emergence of an ancestrally inherited +instinct, but by the paralysis or inhibition of the finer and higher +feelings current in civilization, the exhibitionist is placed on the same +mental level as the man of a more primitive age, and he thus presents the +basis on which the impulses belonging to a higher culture may naturally +take root and develop. + + Reference may here be made to a form of primitive exhibitionism, + almost confined to women, which, although certainly symbolic, is + absolutely non-sexual, and must not, therefore, be confused with + the phenomena we are here occupied with. I refer to the + exhibition of the buttocks as a mark of contempt. In its most + primitive form, no doubt, this exhibitionism is a kind of + exorcism, a method of putting evil spirits, primarily, and + secondarily evil-disposed persons, to flight. It is the most + effective way for a woman to display sexual centers, and it + shares in the magical virtues which all unveiling of the sexual + centers is believed by primitive peoples to possess. It is + recorded that the women of some peoples in the Balkan peninsula + formerly used this gesture against enemies in battle. In the + sixteenth century so distinguished a theologian as Luther when + assailed by the Evil One at night was able to put the adversary + to flight by protruding his uncovered buttocks from the bed. But + the spiritual significance of this attitude is lost with the + decay of primitive beliefs. It survives, but merely as a gesture + of insult. The symbolism comes to have reference to the nates as + the excretory focus, the seat of the anus. In any case it ignores + any sexual attractiveness in this part of the body. Exhibitionism + of this kind, therefore, can scarcely arise in persons of any + sensitiveness or æsthetic perception, even putting aside the + question of modesty, and there seems to be little trace of it in + classic antiquity when the nates were regarded as objects of + beauty. Among the Egyptians, however, we gather from Herodotus + (Bk. II, Chapter LX) that at a certain popular religious festival + men and women would go in boats on the Nile, singing and playing, + and when they approached a town the women on the boats would + insult the women of the town by injurious language and by + exposing themselves. Among the Arabs, however, the specific + gesture we are concerned with is noted, and a man to whom + vengeance is forbidden would express his feelings by exposing his + posterior and strewing earth on his head (Wellhausen, _Rests + Arabischen Heidentums_, 1897, p. 195). It is in Europe and in + mediæval and later times that this emphatic gesture seems to have + flourished as a violent method of expressing contempt. It was by + no means confined to the lower classes, and Kleinpaul, in + discussing this form of "speech without words," quotes examples + of various noble persons, even princesses, who are recorded thus + to have expressed their feelings. (Kleinpaul, _Sprache ohne + Worte_, pp. 271-273.) In more recent times the gesture has become + merely a rare and extreme expression of unrestrained feeling in + coarse-grained peasants. Zola, in the figure of Mouquette in + _Germinal_, may be said to have given a kind of classic + expression to the gesture. In the more remote parts of Europe it + appears to be still not altogether uncommon. This seems to be + notably the case among the South Slavs, and Krauss states that + "when a South Slav woman wishes to express her deepest contempt + for anyone she bends forward, with left hand raising her skirts, + and with the right slapping her posterior, at the same time + exclaiming: 'This for you!'" (Kryptadia, vol. vi, p. 200.) + + A verbal survival of this gesture, consisting in the contemptuous + invitation to kiss this region, still exists among us in remote + parts of the country, especially as an insult offered by an angry + woman who forgets herself. It is said to be commonly used in + Wales. ("Welsh Ædoelogy," Kryptadia, vol. ii, pp. 358, et seq.) + In Cornwall, when addressed by a woman to a man it is sometimes + regarded as a deadly insult, even if the woman is young and + attractive, and may cause a life-long enmity between related + families. From this point of view the nates are a symbol of + contempt, and any sexual significance is excluded. (The + distinction is brought out by Diderot in _Le Neveu de Rameau:_ + "_Lui:_--Il y a d'autres jours ou il ne m'en coûterait rien pour + être vil tant qu'on voudrait; ces jours-là, pour un liard, je + baiserais le cul à la petite Hus. _Moi:_--Eh! mais, l'ami, elle + est blanche, jolie, douce, potelée, et c'est un acte d'humilité + auquel un plus delicat que vous pourrait quelquefois s'abaisser. + _Lui:_--Entendons-nous; c'est qu'il y a baiser le cul au simple, + et baiser le cul au figuré.") + + It must be added that a sexual form of exhibitionism of the nates + must still be recognized. It occurs in masochism and expresses + the desire for passive flagellation. Rousseau, whose emotional + life was profoundly affected by the castigations which as a child + he received from Mlle Lambercier, has in his _Confessions_ told + us how, when a youth, he would sometimes expose himself in this + way in the presence of young women. Such masochistic + exhibitionism seems, however, to be rare. + +While the manifestations of exhibitionism are substantially the same in +all cases, there are many degrees and varieties of the condition. We may +find among exhibitionists, as Garnier remarks, dementia, states of +unconsciousness, epilepsy, general paralysis, alcoholism, but the most +typical cases, he adds, if not indeed the cases to which the term properly +belongs, are those in which it is an impulsive obsession. Krafft-Ebing[60] +divides exhibitionists into four clinical groups: (1) acquired states of +mental weakness, with cerebral or spinal disease clouding consciousness +and at the same time causing impotence; (2) epileptics, in whom the act is +an abnormal organic impulse performed in a state of imperfect +consciousness; (3) a somewhat allied group of neurasthenic cases; (4) +periodical impulsive cases with deep hereditary taint. This classification +is not altogether satisfactory. Garnier's classification, placing the +group of obsessional cases in the foreground and leaving the other more +vaguely defined groups in the background, is probably better. I am +inclined to consider that most of the cases fall into one or other of two +mixed groups. The first class includes cases in which there is more or +less congenital abnormality, but otherwise a fair or even complete degree +of mental integrity; they are usually young adults, they are more or less +precisely conscious of the end they wish to attain, and it is often only +with a severe struggle that they yield to their impulses. In the second +class the beginnings of mental or nervous disease have diminished the +sensibility of the higher centers; the subjects are usually old men whose +lives have been absolutely correct; they are often only vaguely aware of +the nature of the satisfaction they are seeking, and frequently no +struggle precedes the manifestation; such was the case of the overworked +clergyman described by Hughes,[61] who, after much study, became morose +and absent-minded, and committed acts of exhibitionism which he could not +explain but made no attempt to deny; with rest and restorative treatment +his health improved and the acts ceased. It is in the first class of cases +alone that there is a developed sexual perversion. In the cases of the +second class there is a more or less definite sexual intention, but it is +only just conscious, and the emergence of the impulse is due not to its +strength but to the weakness, temporary or permanent, of the higher +inhibiting centers. + +Epileptic cases, with loss of consciousness during the act, can only be +regarded as presenting a pseudo-exhibitionism. They should be excluded +altogether. It is undoubtedly true that many cases of real or apparent +exhibitionism occur in epileptics.[62] We must not, however, too hastily +conclude that because these acts occur in epileptics they are necessarily +unconscious acts. Epilepsy frequently occurs on a basis of hereditary +degeneration, and the exhibitionism may be, and not infrequently is, a +stigma of the degeneracy and not an indication of the occurrence of a +minor epileptic fit. When the act of pseudo-exhibitionism is truly +epileptic, it will usually have no psychic sexual content, and it will +certainly be liable to occur under all sorts of circumstances, when the +patient is alone or in a miscellaneous concourse of people. It will be on +a level with the acts of the highly respectable young woman who, at the +conclusion of an attack of _petit mal_, consisting chiefly of a sudden +desire to pass urine, on one occasion lifted up her clothes and urinated +at a public entertainment, so that it was with difficulty her friends +prevented her from being handed over to the police.[63] Such an act is +automatic, unconscious, and involuntary; the spectators are not even +perceived; it cannot be an act of exhibitionism. Whenever, on the other +hand, the place and the time are evidently chosen deliberately,--a quiet +spot, the presence of only one or two young women or children,--it is +difficult to admit that we are in the presence of a fit of epileptic +unconsciousness, even when the subject is known to be epileptic. + +Even, however, when we exclude those epileptic pseudo-exhibitionists who, +from the legal point of view, are clearly irresponsible, it must still be +remembered that in every case of exhibitionism there is a high degree of +either mental abnormality on a neuropathic basis, or else of actual +disease. This is true to a greater extent in exhibitionism than in almost +any other form of sexual perversion. No subject of exhibitionism should be +sent to prison without expert medical examination. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[54] Lasège first drew attention to this sexual perversion and gave it its +generally accepted name, "Les Exhibitionistes," _L'Union Médicale_, May, +1877. Magnan, on various occasions (for example, "Les Exhibitionistes," +_Archives de l'Anthropologie Criminelle_, vol. v, 1890, p. 456), has given +further development and precision to the clinical picture of the +exhibitionist. + +[55] B. Ball. _La Folie Erotique_, p. 86. + +[56] Moll, _Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 661. + +[57] "Exhibitionism in its most typical form is," Garnier truly says, "a +_systematic act_, manifesting itself as the _strange equivalent of a +sexual connection_, or its _substitution_." The brief account of +exhibitionism (pp. 433-437) in Garnier's discussion of "Perversions +Sexuelles" at the International Medical Congress at Paris in 1900 +(_Section de Psychiatrie: Comptes-Rendus_) is the most satisfactory +statement of the psychological aspects of this perversion with which I am +acquainted. Garnier's unrivalled clinical knowledge of these +manifestations, due to his position during many years as physician at the +Depôt of the Prefecture of Police in Paris, adds great weight to his +conclusions. + +[58] The symbolism of coitus involved in flagellation has been touched on +by Eulenburg (_Sexuale Neuropathie_, p. 121), and is more fully developed +by Dühren (_Geschlechtsleben in England_, bd. ii, pp. 366, _et seq._). + +[59] A. Hoche, _Neurologische Centralblatt_, 1896, No. 2. + +[60] _Op. cit._, pp. 478, et seq. + +[61] C.H. Hughes, "Morbid Exhibitionism," _Alienist and Neurologist_, +August, 1904. Another somewhat similar American case, also preceded by +overwork, and eventually adjudged insane by the courts, is recorded by +D.S. Booth, _Alienist and Neurologist_, February, 1905. + +[62] Exhibitionism in epilepsy is briefly discussed by Féré, _L'Instinct +Sexuel_, second edition, pp. 194-195. + +[63] W.S. Colman, "Post-Epileptic Unconscious Automatic Actions," +_Lancet_, July 5, 1890. + + + + +VI. + +The Forms of Erotic Symbolism are Simulacra of Coitus--Wide +Extension of Erotic Symbolism--Fetichism Not Covering the Whole +Ground of Sexual Selection--It is Based on the Individual Factor in +Selection--Crystallization--The Lover and the Artist--The Key to Erotic +Symbolism to be Found in the Emotional Sphere--The Passage to Pathological +Extremes. + + +We have now examined several very various and yet very typical +manifestations in all of which it is not difficult to see how, in some +strange and eccentric form--on a basis of association through resemblance +or contiguity or both combined--there arises a definite mimicry of the +normal sexual act together with the normal emotions which accompany that +act. It has become clear in what sense we are justified in recognizing +erotic symbolism. + + The symbolic and, as it were, abstracted nature of these + manifestations is shown by the remarkable way in which they are + sometimes capable of transference from the object to the subject. + That is to say that the fetichist may show a tendency to + cultivate his fetich in his own person. A foot-fetichist may like + to go barefoot himself; a man who admired lame women liked to + halt himself; a man who was attracted by small waists in women + found sexual gratification in tight-lacing himself; a man who was + fascinated by fine white skin and wished to cut it found + satisfaction in cutting his own skin; Moll's coprolagnic + fetichist found a voluptuous pleasure in his own acts of + defecation. (See, e.g., Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, p. 221, 224, + 226; Hammond, _Sexual Impotence_, p. 74; cf. _ante_, p. 68.) Such + symbolic transference seems to have a profoundly natural basis, + for we may see a somewhat similar phenomenon in the well-known + tendency of cows to mount a cow in heat. This would appear to be, + not so much a homosexual impulse, as the dynamic psychic action + of an olfactory sexual symbol in a transformed form. + + We seem to have here a psychic process which is a curious + reversal of that process of _Einfühlung_--the projection of one's + own activities into the object contemplated--which Lipps has so + fruitfully developed as the essence of every æsthetic condition. + (T. Lipps, _Æsthetik_, Teil I, 1903.) By _Einfühlung_ our own + interior activity becomes the activity of the object perceived, + a thing being beautiful in proportion as it lends itself to our + _Einfühlung_. But by this action of erotic symbolism, on the + other hand, we transfer the activity of the object into + ourselves. + +When the idea of erotic symbolism as manifested in such definite and +typical forms becomes realized, it further becomes clear that the vaguer +manifestations of such symbolism are exceedingly widespread. When in a +previous volume we were discussing and drawing together the various +threads which unite "Love and Pain," it will now be understood that we +were standing throughout on the threshold of erotic symbolism. Pain +itself, in the sense in which we slowly learned to define it in this +relationship--as a state of intense emotional excitement--may, under a +great variety of special circumstances, become an erotic symbol and afford +the same relief as the emotions normally accompanying the sexual act. +Active algolagnia or sadism is thus a form of erotic symbolism; passive +algolagnia or masochism is (in a man) an inverted form of erotic +symbolism. Active flagellation or passive flagellation are, in exactly the +same way, manifestations of erotic symbolism, the imaginative mimicry of +coitus. + +Binet and also Krafft-Ebing[64] have argued in effect that the whole of +sexual selection is a matter of fetichism, that is to say, of erotic +symbolism of object. "Normal love," Binet states, "appears as the result +of a complicated fetichism." Tarde also seems to have regarded love as +normally a kind of fetichism. "We are a long time before we fall in love +with a woman," he remarks; "we must wait to see the detail which strikes +and delights us, and causes us to overlook what displeases us. Only in +normal love the details are many and always changing. Constancy in love is +rarely anything else but a voyage around the beloved person, a voyage of +exploration and ever new discoveries. The most faithful lover does not +love the same woman in the same way for two days in succession."[65] + +From that point of view normal sexual love is the sway of a fetich--more +or less arbitrary, more or less (as Binet terms it) polytheistic--and it +can have little objective basis. But, as we saw when considering "Sexual +Selection in Man" in the previous volume, more especially when analyzing +the notion of beauty, we are justified in believing that beauty has to a +large extent an objective basis, and that love by no means depends simply +on the capricious selection of some individual fetich. The individual +factor, as we saw, is but one of many factors which constitute beauty. In +the study of sexual selection that individual factor was passed over very +lightly. We now see that it is often a factor of great importance, for in +it are rooted all these outgrowths--normal in their germs, highly abnormal +in their more extreme developments--which make up erotic symbolism. + +Erotic symbolism is therefore concerned with all that is least generic, +least specific, all that is most intimately personal and individual, in +sexual selection. It is the final point in which the decreasing circle of +sexual attractiveness is fixed. In the widest and most abstract form +sexual selection in man is merely human, and we are attracted to that +which bears most fully the marks of humanity; in a less abstract form it +is sexual, and we are attracted to that which most vigorously presents the +secondary sexual characteristics; still narrowing, it is the type of our +own nation and people that appeals most strongly to us in matters of love; +and still further concentrating we are affected by the ideal--in +civilization most often the somewhat exotic ideal--of our own day, the +fashion of our own city. But the individual factor still remains, and amid +the infinite possibilities of erotic symbolism the individual may evolve +an ideal which is often, as far as he knows and perhaps in actuality, an +absolutely unique event in the history of the human soul. + +Erotic symbolism works in its finer manifestations by means of the +idealizing aptitudes; it is the field of sexual psychology in which that +faculty of crystallization, on which Stendhal loved to dwell, achieves its +most brilliant results. In the solitary passage in which we seem to see a +smile on the face of the austere poet of the _De Rerum Naturâ_, Lucretius +tells us how every lover, however he may be amused by the amorous +extravagances of other men, is himself blinded by passion: if his mistress +is black she is a fascinating brunette, if she squints she is the rival of +Pallas, if too tall she is majestic, if too short she is one of the +Graces, _tota merum sal_; if too lean it is her delicate refinement, if +too fat then a Ceres, dirty and she disdains adornment, a chatterer and +brilliantly vivacious, silent and it is her exquisite modesty.[66] Sixteen +hundred years later Robert Burton, when describing the symptoms of love, +made out a long and appalling list of the physical defects which the lover +is prepared to admire.[67] + +Yet we must not be too certain that the lover is wrong in this matter. We +too hastily assume that the casual and hasty judgment of the world is +necessarily more reliable, more conformed to what we call "truth," than +the judgment of the lover which is founded on absorbed and patient study. +In some cases where there is lack of intelligence in the lover and +dissimulation in the object of his love, it may be so. But even a poem or +a picture will often not reveal its beauty except by the expenditure of +time and study. It is foolish to expect that the secret beauty of a human +person will reveal itself more easily. The lover is an artist, an artist +who constructs an image, it is true, but only by patient and concentrated +attention to nature; he knows the defects of his image, probably better +than anyone, but he knows also that art lies, not in the avoidance of +defects, but in the realization of those traits which swallow up defects +and so render them non-existent. A great artist, Rodin, after a life spent +in the study of Nature, has declared that for art there is no ugliness in +Nature. "I have arrived at this belief by the study of Nature," he said; +"I can only grasp the beauty of the soul by the beauty of the body, but +some day one will come who will explain what I only catch a glimpse of and +will declare how the whole earth is beautiful, and all human beings +beautiful. I have never been able to say this in sculpture so well as I +wish and as I feel it affirmed within me. For poets Beauty has always +been some particular landscape, some particular woman; but it should be +all women, all landscapes. A negro or a Mongol has his beauty, however +remote from ours, and it must be the same with their characters. There is +no ugliness. When I was young I made that mistake, as others do; I could +not undertake a woman's bust unless I thought her pretty, according to my +particular idea of beauty; to-day I should do the bust of any woman, and +it would be just as beautiful. And however ugly a woman may look, when she +is with her lover she becomes beautiful; there is beauty in her character, +in her passions, and beauty exists as soon as character or passion becomes +visible, for the body is a casting on which passions are imprinted. And +even without that, there is always the blood that flows in the veins and +the air that fills the lungs."[68] + +The saint, also, is here at one with the lover and the artist. The man who +has so profoundly realized the worth of his fellow men that he is ready +even to die in order to save them, feels that he has discovered a great +secret. Cyples traces the "secret delights" that have thus risen in the +hearts of holy men to the same source as the feelings generated between +lovers, friends, parents, and children. "A few have at intervals walked in +the world," he remarks, "who have, each in his own original way, found out +this marvel.... Straightway man in general has become to them so sweet a +thing that the infatuation has seemed to the rest of their fellows to be a +celestial madness. Beggars' rags to their unhesitating lips grew fit for +kissing, because humanity had touched the garb; there were no longer any +menial acts, but only welcome services.... Remember by how much man is the +subtlest circumstance in the world; at how many points he can attach +relationships; how manifold and perennial he is in his results. All other +things are dull, meager, tame beside him."[69] + +It may be added that even if we still believe that lover and artist and +saint are drawing the main elements of their conceptions from the depths +of their own consciousness, there is a sense in which they are coming +nearer to the truth of things than those for whom their conceptions are +mere illusions. The aptitude for realizing beauty has involved an +adjustment of the nerves and the associated brain centers through +countless ages that began before man was. When the vision of supreme +beauty is slowly or suddenly realized by anyone, with a reverberation that +extends throughout his organism, he has attained to something which for +his species, and for far more than his species, is truth, and can only be +illusion to one who has artificially placed himself outside the stream of +life. + + In an essay on "The Gods as Apparitions of the Race-Life," Edward + Carpenter, though in somewhat Platonic phraseology, thus well + states the matter: "The youth sees the girl; it may be a chance + face, a chance outline, amid the most banal surroundings. But it + gives the cue. There is a memory, a confused reminiscence. The + mortal figure without penetrates to the immortal figure within, + and there rises into consciousness a shining form, glorious, not + belonging to this world, but vibrating with the agelong life of + humanity, and the memory of a thousand love-dreams. The waking of + this vision intoxicates the man; it glows and burns within him; a + goddess (it may be Venus herself) stands in the sacred place of + his temple; a sense of awe-struck splendor fills him, and the + world is changed." "He sees something" (the same writer continues + in a subsequent essay, "Beauty and Duty") "which, in a sense, is + more real than the figures in the street, for he sees something + that has lived and moved for hundreds of years in the heart of + the race; something which has been one of the great formative + influences of his own life, and which has done as much to create + those very figures in the street as qualities in the circulation + of the blood may do to form a finger or other limb. He comes into + touch with a very real Presence or Power--one of those organic + centers of growth in the life of humanity--and feels this larger + life within himself, subjective, if you like, and yet intensely + objective. And more. For is it not also evident that the woman, + the mortal woman who excites his Vision, _has_ some closest + relation to it, and is, indeed, far more than a mere mask or + empty formula which reminds him of it? For she indeed has within + her, just as much as the man has, deep subconscious Powers + working; and the ideal which has dawned so entrancingly on the + man is in all probability closely related to that which has been + working most powerfully in the heredity of the woman, and which + has most contributed to mold _her_ form and outline. No wonder, + then, that her form should remind him of it. Indeed, when he + looks into her eyes he sees _through_ to a far deeper life even + than she herself may be aware of, and yet which is truly hers--a + life perennial and wonderful. The more than mortal in him beholds + the more than mortal in her; and the gods descend to meet." + (Edward Carpenter, _The Art of Creation_, pp. 137, 186.) + +It is this mighty force which lies behind and beneath the aberrations we +have been concerned with, a great reservoir from which they draw the +life-blood that vivifies even their most fantastic shapes. Fetichism and +the other forms of erotic symbolism are but the development and the +isolation of the crystallizations which normally arise on the basis of +sexual selection. Normal in their basis, in their extreme forms they +present the utmost pathological aberrations of the sexual instinct which +can be attained or conceived. In the intermediate space all degrees are +possible. In the slightest degree the symbol is merely a specially +fascinating and beloved feature in a person who is, in all other respects, +felt to be lovable; as such its recognition is a legitimate part of +courtship, an effective aid to tumescence. In a further degree the symbol +is the one arresting and attracting character of a person who must, +however, still be felt as a sexually attractive individual. In a still +further degree of perversion the symbol is effective, even though the +person with whom it is associated is altogether unattractive. In the final +stage the person and even all association with a person disappear +altogether from the field of sexual consciousness; the abstract symbol +rules supreme. + +Long, however, before the symbol has reached that final climax of morbid +intensity we may be said to have passed beyond the sphere of sexual love. +A person, not an abstracted quality, must be the goal of love. So long as +the fetich is subordinated to the person it serves to heighten love. But +love must be based on a complexus of attractive qualities, or it has no +stability.[70] As soon as the fetich becomes isolated and omnipotent, so +that the person sinks into the background as an unimportant appendage of +the fetich, all stability is lost. The fetichist now follows an impersonal +and abstract symbol withersoever it may lead him. + +It has been seen that there are an extraordinary number of forms in which +erotic symbolism may be felt. It must be remembered, and it cannot be too +distinctly emphasized, that the links that bind together the forms of +erotic symbolism are not to be found in objects or even in acts, but in +the underlying emotion. A feeling is the first condition of the symbol, a +feeling which recalls, by a subtle and unconscious automatic association +of resemblance or of contiguity, some former feeling. It is the similarity +of emotion, instinctively apprehended, which links on a symbol only +partially sexual, or even apparently not sexual at all, to the great +central focus of sexual emotion, the great dominating force which brings +the symbol its life-blood.[71] + +The cases of sexual hyperæsthesia, quoted at the beginning of this study, +do but present in a morbidly comprehensive and sensitive form those +possibilities of erotic symbolism which, in some degree, or at some +period, are latent in most persons. They are genuinely instinctive and +automatic, and have nothing in common with that fanciful and deliberate +play of the intelligence around sexual imagery--not infrequently seen in +abnormal and insane persons--which has no significance for sexual +psychology. + +It is to the extreme individualization involved by the developments of +erotic symbolism that the fetichist owes his morbid and perilous +isolation. The lover who is influenced by all the elements of sexual +selection is always supported by the fellow-feeling of a larger body of +other human beings; he has behind him his species, his sex, his nation, or +at the very least a fashion. Even the inverted lover in most cases is soon +able to create around him an atmosphere constituted by persons whose +ideals resemble his own. But it is not so with the erotic symbolist. He is +nearly always alone. He is predisposed to isolation from the outset, for +it would seem to be on a basis of excessive shyness and timidity that the +manifestations of erotic symbolism are most likely to develop. When at +length the symbolist realizes his own aspirations--which seem to him for +the most part an altogether new phenomenon in the world--and at the same +time realizes the wide degree in which they deviate from those of the rest +of mankind, his natural secretiveness is still further reinforced. He +stands alone. His most sacred ideals are for all those around him a +childish absurdity, or a disgusting obscenity, possibly a matter calling +for the intervention of the policeman. We have forgotten that all these +impulses which to us seem so unnatural--this adoration of the foot and +other despised parts of the body, this reverence for the excretory acts +and products, the acceptance of congress with animals, the solemnity of +self-exhibition--were all beliefs and practices which, to our remote +forefathers, were bound up with the highest conceptions of life and the +deepest ardors of religion. + +A man cannot, however, deviate at once so widely and so spontaneously in +his impulses from the rest of the world in which he himself lives without +possessing an aboriginally abnormal temperament. At the very least he +exhibits a neuropathic sensitiveness to abnormal impressions. Not +infrequently there is more than this, the distinct stigmata of +degeneration, sometimes a certain degree of congenital feeble-mindedness +or a tendency to insanity. + +Yet, regarded as a whole, and notwithstanding the frequency with which +they witness to congenital morbidity, the phenomena of erotic symbolism +can scarcely fail to be profoundly impressive to the patient and impartial +student of the human soul. They often seem absurd, sometimes disgusting, +occasionally criminal; they are always, when carried to an extreme degree, +abnormal. But of all the manifestations of sexual psychology, normal and +abnormal, they are the most specifically human. More than any others they +involve the potently plastic force of the imagination. They bring before +us the individual man, not only apart from his fellows, but in opposition, +himself creating his own paradise. They constitute the supreme triumph of +human idealism. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[64] Binet, _Etudes de Psychologie Expérimentale_, esp., p. 84; +Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, p. 18. + +[65] G. Tarde, "L'Amour Morbide," _Archives de l'Anthropologie +Criminelle_, 1890, p. 585. + +[66] Lucretius, Lib. IV, vv. 1150-1163. + +[67] Burton, _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. III, +Subs. I. + +[68] Judith Cladel, _Auguste Rodin Pris sur la Vie_, 1903, pp. 103-104. +Some slight modifications have been made in the translation of this +passage on account of the conversational form of the original. + +[69] W. Cyples, _The Process of Human Experience_, p. 462. Even if (as we +have already seen, _ante_, p. 58) the saint cannot always feel actual +physical pleasure in the intimate contact of humanity, the ardor of +devoted service which his vision of humanity arouses remains unaffected. + +[70] "To love," as Stendhal defined it (_De l'Amour_, Chapter II), "is to +have pleasure in seeing, touching, and feeling by all the senses, and as +near as possible, a beloved object by whom one is oneself loved." + +[71] Pillon's study of "La Mémoire Affective" (_Revue Philosophique_, +February, 1901) helps to explain the psychic mechanism of the process. + + + + +THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE. + +I. + +The Psychological Significance of Detumescence--The Testis and the +Ovary--Sperm Cell and Germ Cell--Development of the Embryo--The External +Sexual Organs--Their Wide Range of Variation--Their Nervous Supply--The +Penis--Its Racial Variations--The Influence of Exercise--The Scrotum and +Testicles--The Mons Veneris--The Vulva--The Labia Majora and their +Varieties--The Pubic Hair and Its Characters--The Clitoris and Its +Functions--The Anus as an Erogenous Zone--The Nymphæ and their +Function--The Vagina--The Hymen--Virginity--The Biological Significance of +the Hymen. + + +In analyzing the sexual impulse we have seen that the process whereby the +conjunction of the sexes is achieved falls naturally into two phases: the +first phase, of tumescence, during which force is generated in the +organism, and the second phase, of detumescence, in which that force is +discharged during conjugation.[72] Hitherto we have been occupied mainly +with the first phase, that of tumescence, and with its associated psychic +phenomena. It was inevitable that this should be so, for it is during the +slow process of tumescence that sexual selection is decided, the +crystallizations of love elaborated, and, to a large extent, the +individual erotic symbols determined. But we can by no means altogether +pass over the final phase of detumescence. Its consideration, it is true, +brings us directly into the field of anatomy and physiology; while +tumescence is largely under control of the will, when the moment of +detumescence arrives the reins slip from the control of the will; the more +fundamental and uncontrollable impulses of the organism gallop on +unchecked; the chariot of Phaëthon dashes blindly down into a sea of +emotion. + +Yet detumescence is the end and climax of the whole drama; it is an +anatomico-physiological process, certainly, but one that inevitably +touches psychology at every point.[73] It is, indeed, the very key to the +process of tumescence, and unless we understand and realize very precisely +what it is that happens during detumescence, our psychological analysis of +the sexual impulse must remain vague and inadequate. + +From the point of view we now occupy, a man and a woman are no longer two +highly sensitive organisms vibrating, voluptuously it may indeed be, but +vaguely and indefinitely, to all kinds of influences and with fluctuating +impulses capable of being directed into any channel, even in the highest +degree divergent from the proper ends of procreation. They are now two +genital organisms who exist to propagate the race, and whatever else they +may be, they must be adequately constituted to effect the act by which the +future of the race is ensured. We have to consider what are the material +conditions which ensure the most satisfactory and complete fulfillment of +this act, and how those conditions may be correlated with other +circumstances in the organism. In thus approaching the subject we shall +find that we have not really abandoned the study of the psychic aspects of +sex. + +The two most primary sexual organs are the testis and the ovary; it is the +object of conjugation to bring into contact the sperm from the testis with +the germ from the ovary. There is no reason to suppose that the germ-cell +and the sperm-cell are essentially different from each other. Sexual +conjugation thus remains a process which is radically the same as the +non-sexual mode of propagation which preceded it. The fusion of the nuclei +of the two cells was regarded by Van Beneden, who in 1875 first accurately +described it, as a process of conjugation comparable to that of the +protozoa and the protophyta. Boveri, who has further extended our +knowledge of the process, considers that the spermatozoon removes an +inhibitory influence preventing the commencement of development in the +ovum; the spermatozoon replaces a portion of the ovum which has already +undergone degeneration, so that the object of conjugation is chiefly to +effect the union of the properties of two cells in one, sexual +fertilization achieving a division of labor with reciprocal inhibition; +the two cells have renounced their original faculty of separate +development in order to attain a fusion of qualities and thus render +possible that production of new forms and qualities which has involved the +progress of the organized world.[74] + +While in fishes this conjugation of the male and female elements is +usually ensured by the female casting her spawn into an artificial nest +outside the body, on to which the male sheds his milt, in all animals +(and, to some extent, birds, who occupy an intermediate position) there is +an organic nest, or incubation chamber as Bland Sutton terms it, the womb, +in the female body, wherein the fertilized egg may develop to a high +degree of maturity sheltered from those manifold risks of the external +world which make it necessary for the spawn of fishes to be so enormous in +amount. Since, however, men and women have descended from remote ancestors +who, in the manner of aquatic creatures, exercised functions of +sperm-extrusion and germ-extrusion that were exactly analogous in the two +sexes, without any specialized female uterine organization, the early +stages of human male and female foetal development still display the +comparatively undifferentiated sexual organization of those remote +ancestors, and during the first months of foetal life it is practically +impossible to tell by the inspection of the genital regions whether the +embryo would have developed into a man or into a woman. If we examine the +embryo at an early stage of development we see that the hind end is the +body stalk, this stalk in later stages becoming part of the umbilical +cord. The urogenital region, formed by the rapid extension of the hind +end beyond its original limit, which corresponds to what is later the +umbilicus, develops mainly by the gradual differentiation of structures +(the Wolffian and Müllerian bodies) which originally exist identically in +both sexes. This process of sexual differentiation is highly complex, so +that it cannot yet be said that there is complete agreement among +investigators as to its details. When some irregularity or arrest of +development occurs in the process we have one or other of the numerous +malformations which may affect this region. If the arrest occurs at a very +early stage we may even find a condition of things which seems to +approximate to that which normally exists in the adult reptilia.[75] Owing +to the fact that both male and female organs develop from more primitive +structures which were sexually undifferentiated, a fundamental analogy in +the sexual organs of the sexes always remains; the developed organs of one +sex exist as rudiments in the other sex; the testicles correspond to the +ovaries; the female clitoris is the homologue of the male penis; the +scrotum of one sex is the labia majora in the other sex, and so +throughout, although it is not always possible at present to be quite +certain in regard to these homologics. + +Since the object to be attained by the sexual organs in the human species +is identical with that which they subserve in their pre-human ancestors, +it is not surprising to find that these structures have a clear +resemblance to the corresponding structures in the apes, although on the +whole there would appear to be in man a higher degree of sexual +differentiation. Thus the uterus of various species of _semnopithecus_ +seems to show a noteworthy correspondence with the same organ in +woman.[76] The somewhat less degree of sexual differentiation is well +shown in the gorilla; in the male the external organs are in the passive +state covered by the wrinkled skin of the abdomen, while in the female, +on the contrary, they are very apparent, and in sexual excitement the +large clitoris and nymphæ become markedly prominent. The penis of the +gorilla, however, more nearly resembles that of man, according to +Hartmann, than does that of the other anthropoid apes, which diverge from +the human type in this respect more than do the cynocephalic apes and some +species of baboon. + +From the psychological point of view we are less interested in the +internal sexual organs, which are most fundamentally concerned with the +production and reception of the sexual elements, than with the more +external parts of the genital apparatus which serve as the instruments of +sexual excitation, and the channels for the intromission and passage of +the seminal fluid. It is these only which can play any part at all in +sexual selection; they are the only part of the sexual apparatus which can +enter into the formation of either normal or abnormal erotic conceptions; +they are the organs most prominently concerned with detumescence; they +alone enter normally into the conscious process of sex at any time. It +seems desirable, therefore, to discuss them briefly at this point. + + Our knowledge of the individual and racial variations of the + external sexual organs is still extremely imperfect. A few + monographs and collections of data on isolated points may be + found in more or less inaccessible publications. As regards + women, Ploss and Bartels have devoted a chapter to the sexual + organs of women which extends to a hundred pages, but remains + scanty and fragmentary. (_Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter VI.) The + most systematic series of observations have been made in the case + of the various kinds of degenerates--idiots, the insane, + criminals, etc.--but it would be obviously unsafe to rely too + absolutely on such investigations for our knowledge of the sexual + organs of the ordinary population. + + There can be no doubt, however, that the external sexual organs + in normal men and women exhibit a peculiarly wide range of + variation. This is indicated not only by the unsystematic results + attained by experienced observers, but also by more systematic + studies. Thus Herman has shown by detailed measurements that + there are great normal variations in the conformation of the + parts that form the floor of the female pelvis. He found that the + projection of the pelvic floor varied from nothing to as much as + two inches, and that in healthy women who had borne no children + the distance between the coccyx and anus, the length of the + perineum, the distance between the fourchette and the symphysis + pubis, and the length of the vagina are subject to wide + variations. (_Lancet_, October 12, 1889.) Even the female + urethral opening varies very greatly, as has been shown by Bergh, + who investigated it in nearly 700 women and reproduces the + various shapes found; while most usually (in about a third of the + cases observed), a longitudinal slit, it may be cross-shaped, + star-shaped, crescentic, etc.; and while sometimes very small, in + about 6 per cent. of the cases it admitted the tip of the little + finger. (Bergh, _Monatsheft für Praktische Dermatologie_, 15 + Sept., 1897.) + + As regards both sexes, Stanley Hall states that "Dr. F.N. + Seerley, who has examined over 2000 normal young men as well as + many young women, tells me that in his opinion individual + variations in these parts are much greater even than those of + face and form, and that the range of adult and apparently normal + size and proportion, as well as function, and of both the age and + order of development, not only of each of the several parts + themselves, but of all their immediate annexes, and in females as + well as males, is far greater than has been recognized by any + writer. This fact is the basis of the anxieties and fears of + morphological abnormality so frequent during adolescence." (G.S. + Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. i, p. 414). + +In accordance with the supreme importance of the part they play, and the +intimately psychic nature of that part, the sexual organs, both internal +and external, are very richly supplied with nerves. While the internal +organs are very abundantly furnished with sympathetic nerves and ganglia, +the external organs show the highest possible degree of specialization of +the various peripheral nervous devices which the organism has developed +for receiving, accumulating, and transmitting stimuli to the brain.[77] + + "The number of conducting cords which attach the genitals to the + nervous centers is simply enormous," writes Bryan Robinson; "the + pudic nerve is composed of nearly all the third sacral and + branches from the second and fourth sacral. As one examines this + nerve he is forced to the conclusion that it is an enormous + supply for a small organ. The periphery of the pudic nerve + spreads itself like a fan over the genitals." The lesser sciatic + nerve supplies only one muscle--the gluteus maximus--and then + sends the large pudendal branch to the side of the penis, and + hence the friction of coitus induces active contraction of the + gluteus maximus, "the main muscle of coition." The large pudic + and the pudendal constitute the main supply of the external + genitals. In women the pudic nerve is equally large, but the + pudendal much smaller, possibly, Bryan Robinson suggests, because + women take a less active part in coitus. The nerve supply of the + clitoris, however, is three or four times as large as that of the + penis in proportion to size. (F.B. Robinson, "The Intimate + Nervous Connection of the Genito-Urinary Organs With the + Cerebro-Spinal and Sympathetic Systems," _New York Medical + Journal_, March 11, 1893; id., _The Abdominal Brain_, 1899.) + +Of all the sexual organs the penis is without doubt that which has most +powerfully impressed the human imagination. It is the very emblem of +generation, and everywhere men have contemplated it with a mixture of +reverence and shuddering awe that has sometimes, even among civilized +peoples, amounted to horror and disgust. Its image is worn as an amulet to +ward off evil and invoked as a charm to call forth blessing. The sexual +organs were once the most sacred object on which a man could place his +hands to swear an inviolate oath, just as now he takes up the Testament. +Even in the traditions of the great classic civilization which we inherit +the penis is _fascinus_, the symbol of all fascination. In the history of +human culture it has had far more than a merely human significance; it has +been the symbol of all the generative force of Nature, the embodiment of +creative energy in the animal and vegetable worlds alike, an image to be +held aloft for worship, the sign of all unconscious ecstasy. As a symbol, +the sacred phallus, it has been woven in and out of all the highest and +deepest human conceptions, so intimately that it is possible to see it +everywhere, that it is possible to fail to see it anywhere. + +In correspondence with the importance of the penis is the large number of +names which men have everywhere bestowed upon it. In French literature +many hundred synonyms may be found. They were also numerous in Latin. In +English the literary terms for the penis seem to be comparatively few, but +a large number of non-literary synonyms exist in colloquial and perhaps +merely local usage. The Latin term penis, which has established itself +among us as the most correct designation, is generally considered to be +associated with _pendere_ and to be connected therefore with the usually +pendent position of the organ. In the middle ages the general literary +term throughout Europe was _coles_ (or _colis_) from _caulis_, a stalk, +and _virga_, a rod. The only serious English literary term, yard (exactly +equivalent to _virga_), as used by Chaucer--almost the last great English +writer whose vocabulary was adequate to the central facts of life--has now +fallen out of literary and even colloquial usage. + + Pierer and Chaulant, in their anatomical and physiological + _Real-Lexicon_ (vol. vi, p. 134), give nearly a hundred synonyms + for the penis. Hyrtl (_Topographisches Anatomie_, seventh + edition, vol. ii, pp. 67-69), adds others. Schurig, in his + _Spermatologia_ (1720, pp. 89-91), also presents a number of + names for the penis; in Chapter III (pp. 189-192) of the same + book he discusses the penis generally with more fullness than + most authors. Louis de Landes, in his _Glossaire Erotique_ of the + French language (pp. 239-242), enumerates several hundred + literary synonyms for the penis, though many of them probably + only occur once. + + There is no thorough and comprehensive modern study of the penis + on an anthropological basis (though I should mention a valuable + and fully illustrated study of anthropological and pathological + variations of the penis in a series of articles by Marandon de + Montyel, "Des Anomalies des Organs Génitaux Externes Chez les + Aliénées," etc., _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, 1895), + and it would be out of place here to attempt to collect the + scattered notices regarding racial and other variations. It may + suffice to note some of the evidence showing that such variations + seem to be numerous and important. The Arab penis (according to + Kocher) is slender and long (a third longer than the average + European penis) and with a club-shaped glans. It undergoes little + change when it enters the erect state. The clothes leaves it + quite free, and the Arab practices manual excitement at an early + age to favor its development. + + Among the Fuegians, also, according to Hyades and Deniker (_Cap + Horn_, vol. vii, p. 153), the average length of the penis is 77 + millimeters, which is longer than in Europeans. + + In men of black race, also, the penis is decidedly large. Thus + Sir H.H. Johnston (_British Central Africa_, p. 399) states this + to be a universal rule. Among the Wankenda of Northern Nyassa, + for instance, he remarks that, while the body is of medium size, + the penis is generally large. He gives the usual length as about + six inches, reaching nine or ten in erection. The prepuce, it is + added, is often very long, and circumcision is practiced by many + tribes. + + Among the American negroes Hrdlicka has found, also (_Proceedings + American Association for the Advancement of Science_, vol. xlvii, + p. 475), that the penis in black boys is larger than in white + boys. + + The passages cited above suggest the question whether the penis + becomes larger by exercise of its generative functions. Most old + authors assert that frequent erection makes the penis large and + long (Schurig, _Spermatologia_, p. 107). Galen noted that in + singers and athletes, who were chaste in order to preserve their + strength, the sexual parts were small and rugrose, like those of + old men, and that exercise of the organs from youth develops + them; Roubaud, quoting this observation (_Traité de + l'Impuissance_, p. 373), agrees with the statement. It seems + probable that there is an element of truth in this ancient + belief. At the same time it must be remembered that the penis is + only to small extent a muscular organ, and that the increase of + size produced by frequent congestion of erectile tissues cannot + be either rapid or pronounced. Variations in the size of the + sexual organs are probably on the whole mainly inherited, though + it is impossible to speak decisively on this point until more + systematic observations become customary. + +The scrotum has usually, in the human imagination, been regarded merely as +an appendage of the penis, of secondary importance, although it is the +garment of the primary and essential organs of sex, and the fact that it +is not the seat of any voluptuous sensation has doubtless helped to +confirm this position. Even the name is merely a mediæval perversion of +_scortum_, skin or hide. In classic times it was usually called the pouch +or purse. The importance of the testicles has not, however, been +altogether ignored, as the very word _testis_ itself shows, for the +_testis_ is simply the _witness_ of virility.[78] + +It is easy to understand why the penis should occupy this special place in +man's thoughts as the supreme sexual organ. It is the one conspicuous and +prominent portion of the sexual apparatus, while its aptitude for swelling +and erecting itself involuntarily, under the influence of sexual emotion, +gives it a peculiar and almost unique position in the body. At the same +time it is the point at which, in the male body, all voluptuous sensation +is concentrated, the only normal masculine center of sex.[79] + +It is not easy to find any correspondingly conspicuous symbol of sex in +the sexual region of women. In the normal position nothing is visible but +the peculiarly human cushion of fat picturesquely termed the Mons Veneris +(because, as Palfyn said, all those who enroll themselves under the banner +of Venus must necessarily scale it), and even that is veiled from view in +the adult by the more or less bushy plantation of hair which grows upon +it. A triangle of varyingly precise definition is thus formed at the lower +apex of the trunk, and this would sometimes appear to have been regarded +as a feminine symbol.[80] But the more usual and typical symbol of +femininity is the idealized ring (by some savages drawn as a lozenge) of +the vulvar opening--the _yoni_ corresponding to the masculine +_lingam_--which is normally closed from view by the larger lips arising +from beneath the shadow of the _mons_. It is a symbol that, like the +masculine phallus, has a double meaning among primitive peoples and is +sometimes used to call down a blessing and sometimes to invoke a +curse.[81] + +This external opening of the feminine genital passage with its two +enclosing lips is now generally called the vulva. It would appear that +originally (as by Celsus and Pliny) this term included the womb, also, but +when the term "uterus" came into use "vulva" was confined (as its sense of +folding doors suggests that it should be) to the external entrance. The +classic term _cunnus_ for the external genitals was chiefly used by the +poets; it has been the etymological source of various European names for +this region, such as the old French _con_, which has now, however, +disappeared from literature while even in popular usage it has given place +to _lapin_ and similar terms. But there is always a tendency, marked in +most parts of the world, for the names of the external female parts to +become indecorous. Even in classic antiquity this part was the _pudendum_, +the part to be ashamed of, and among ourselves the mass of the +population, still preserving the traditions of primitive times, continue +to cherish the same notion. + + The anatomy, anthropology, folk-lore, and terminology of the + external and to some extent the internal feminine sexual region + may be studied in the following publications, among others: + Ploss, _Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter VI; Hyrtl, _Topographisches + Anatomie_, vol. ii, and other publications by the same scholarly + anatomist; W.J. Stewart Mackay, _History of Ancient Gynæcology_, + especially pp. 244-250; R. Bergh, "Symbolæ ad Cognitionem + Genitalium Externorum Foeminearum" (in Danish), + _Hospitalstidende_, August, 1894; and also in _Monatshefte für + Praktische Dermatologie_, 1897. D.S. Lamb, "The Female External + Genital Organs," _New York Journal of Gynæcology_, August, 1894; + R.L. Dickinson, "Hypertrophies of the Labia Minora and Their + Significance," _American Gynecology_, September, 1902; Kryptadia + (in various languages), vol. viii, pp. 3-11, 11-13, and many + other passages. Several of Schurig's works (especially + _Gynæcologia_, _Muliebria_, and _Parthenologia_) contain full + summaries of the statements of the early writers. + +The external or larger lips, like the mons veneris, are specifically human +in their full development, for in the anthropoid apes they are small as is +the mons, and in the lower apes absent altogether; they are, moreover, +larger in the white than in the other human races. Thus in the negro, and +to a less degree in the Japanese (Wernich) and the Javanese (Scherzer) +they are less developed than in women of white race. The greater lips +develop in the foetus later than the lesser lips, which are thus at first +uncovered; this condition thus constitutes an infantile state which +occasionally (in less than 2 per cent. of cases, according to Bergh) +persists in the adult. Their generally accepted name, labia majora, is +comparatively modern.[82] + + The outer sides of the labia majora are covered with hair, and on + the inner sides, which are smooth and moist, but are not true + mucous membrane, there are a few sweat glands and numerous large + sebaceous glands. Bergh considers that there is little or no hair + on the inner sides of the labia majora, but Lamb states that + careful examination shows that from one- to two-thirds of the + inner surface in adult women show hairs like those of the + external surface. In brunettes and women of dark races this + surface is pigmented; in dark races it is usually a slate gray. + From an examination of 2200 young Danish prostitutes Bergh has + found that there are two main varieties in the shape of the labia + majora, with transitional forms. In the first and most frequent + form the labia tend to be less marked and more effaced and + separated at the upper and anterior part, often being lost in the + sides of the mons and presenting a fissure which is broader in + its upper part and showing the inner lips more or less bare. In + the second form the labia are thicker and more outstanding and + the inner edges lie in contact throughout their whole length, + showing the _rima pudendi_ as a long narrow fissure. Whatever the + form, the labia close more tightly together in virgins and in + young individuals generally than in the deflowered and the + elderly. In children, as Martineau pointed out, the vulva appears + to look directly forward and the clitoris and urinary meatus + easily appear, while in adult women, and especially after + attempts at coitus have been made, the vulva appears directed + more below and behind, and the clitoris and meatus more covered + by the labia majora; so that the child urinates forward, while + the adult woman is usually able to urinate almost directly + downwards in the erect position, though in some cases (as may + occasionally be observed in the street) she can only do so when + bending slightly forwards. This difference in the direction of + the stream formerly furnished one of the methods of diagnosing + virginity, an uncertain one, since the difference is largely due + to age and individual variation. The main factor in the position + and aspect of the vulva is pelvic inclination. (See Havelock + Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, p. 64; Stratz, _Die + Schönheit des Weiblichen Körpers_, Chapter XII.) In the European + woman, according to Stratz, a considerable degree of pelvic + inclination is essential to beauty, concealing all but the + anterior third of the vulva. In negresses and other women of + lower race the vulva, however, usually lies further back, being + more conspicuous from behind than in European women; in this + respect lower races resemble the apes. Those women of dark race, + therefore, whose modesty is focused behind rather than in front + thus have sound anatomical considerations on their side. + + As Ploss and Bartels remark, a very common variation among + European women consists in an unusually posterior position of the + vulva and vaginal entrance, so that unless a cushion is placed + under the buttocks it is difficult for the man to effect coitus + in the usual position without giving much pain to the woman. They + add that another anomaly, less easy to remedy, consists in an + abnormally anterior position of the vaginal entrance close + beneath the pelvic bone, so that, although intromission is easy, + the spasmodic contraction of the vagina at the culmination of + orgasm presses the penis against the bone and causes intolerable + pain to the man. + +The mons veneris and the labia majora are, after the age of puberty, +always normally covered by a more or less profuse growth of hair. It is +notable that the apes, notwithstanding their general tendency to +hairiness, show no such special development of hair in this region. We +thus see that all the external and more conspicuous portions of the sexual +sphere in woman--the mons veneris, the labia majora, and the +hair--represent not so much an animal inheritance, such as we commonly +misrepresent them to be, but a higher and genuinely human development. As +none of these structures subserve any clear practical use, it would appear +that they must have developed by sexual selection to satisfy the æsthetic +demands of the eye.[83] + + The character and arrangement of the pubic hair, investigated by + Eschricht and Voigt more than half a century ago, have been more + recently studied by Bergh. As these observers have pointed out, + there are various converging hair streams from above and below, + the clitoris seeming to be the center towards which they are + directed. The hair-covering thus formed is usually ample and, as + a rule, is more so in brunettes than in blondes. It is nearly + always bent, curly and more or less spirally twisted.[84] There + are frequently one or two curls at the commencement of the + fissure, rolled outwards, and occasionally a well marked tuft in + the middle line. In abundance the pubic hair corresponds with the + axillary hair; when one region is defective in hair the other is + usually so also. Strong eyebrows also usually indicate a strong + development of pubic hair. But the hair of the head usually + varies independently, and Bergh found that of 154 women with + spare pubic hair 72 had good and often profuse hair on the head. + Complete or almost complete absence of pubic hair is in Bergh's + experience only found in about 3 per cent. of women; these were + all young and blonde. + +Rothe, in his investigation of the pubic hair of 1000 Berlin women, found +that no two women were really alike in this respect, but there was a +tendency to two main types of arrangement, with minor subdivisions, +according as the hair tended to grow chiefly in the middle line extending +laterally from that line, or to grow equally over the whole extent of the +pubic region; these two groups included half the cases investigated. + + In men the pubic hair normally ascends anteriorly in a faint line + up to the navel, with tendency to form a triangle with the apex + above, and posteriorly extends backwards to the anus. In women + these anterior and posterior extensions are comparatively rare, + or at all events are only represented by a few stray hairs. Rothe + found this variation in 4 per cent. of North German women, though + a triangle of hair was only found in 2 per cent.; Lombroso found + it in 5 per cent, of Italian women; Bergh found it in only 1.6 + per cent. among 1000 Danish prostitutes, all sixteen of whom with + three exceptions were brunettes. In Vienna, among 600 women, Coe + found only 1 per cent, with this distribution of hair, and states + that they were women of decidedly masculine type, though Ploss + and Bartels, as well as Rothe, find, however, that heterogeny, as + they term the masculine distribution, is more common in blondes. + The anterior extension of hair is usually accompanied by the + posterior extension around the anus, usually very slight, but + occasionally as pronounce as in men. (According to Rothe, + however, anterior heterogeny comparatively rare.) These masculine + variations in the extension of the pubic hair appear to be not + uncommonly associated with other physical and psychic anomalies; + it is on this account that they have sometimes been regarded as + indications of a vicious or a criminal temperament; they are, + however, found in quite normal women. + + The pubic hair of women is usually shorter than that of men, but + thick, and the individual hairs stronger and larger in diameter + than those of men, as Pfaff first showed; dark hair is usually + stronger than light. In both length and size the individual + variations are considerable. The usual length is about 2 inches, + or 3-5 centimeters, occasionally reaching about 4 inches, or 9-10 + centimeters, in the larger curls. In a series of 100 women + attended during confinement in London and the north of England I + have only once (in a rather blonde Lancashire woman) found the + hair on labia reaching a conspicuous length of several inches and + forming an obstruction to the manipulations involved in delivery. + But Jahn delivered a woman whose pubic hair was longer than that + of her head, reaching below her knee; Paulini also knew a woman + whose pubic hair nearly reached her knees and was sold to make + wigs; Bartholin mentions a soldier's wife who plaited her pubic + hair behind her back; while Brantôme has several references to + abnormally long hair in ladies of the French court during the + sixteenth century. In 8 cases out of 2200 Bergh found the pubic + hair forming a large curly wig extending to the iliac spines. The + individual hairs have occasionally been found so stiff and + brush-like as to render coitus difficult. + + In color the pubic hair, while generally approximating to that of + the head, is sometimes (according to Rothe, in Germany, in + one-third cases) lighter, and sometimes somewhat darker, as is + found to be the case by Coe, especially in brunettes, and also by + Bergh, in Denmark. Bergh remarks that it is generally + intermediate in color between the eyebrows and the axillary hair, + the latter being more or less decolorized by sweat, and that, + owing to the influence of the urine and vaginal discharges, the + labial hair is paler than that on the mons; blondes with dark + eyebrows usually have dark hair on the mons. The hair on this + spot, as Aristotle observed, is usually the last to turn gray. + +The key to the genital apparatus in women from the psychic point of view, +and, indeed, to some extent, its anatomical center, is to be found in the +clitoris. Anatomically and developmentally the clitoris is the rudimentary +analogue of the masculine penis. Functionally, however, its scope is very +much smaller. While the penis both receives and imparts specific +voluptuous sensations, and is at the same time both the intromittent organ +for the semen and the conduit for the urine, the sole function of the +clitoris is to enter into erection under the stress of sexual emotion and +receive and transmit the stimulatory voluptuous sensations imparted to it +by friction with the masculine genital apparatus. It is so insignificant +an organ that it is only within recent times that its homology with the +penis has been realized. In 1844 Kobelt wrote in his important book, _Die +Mannlichen und Weiblichen Wollust-Organe_, that in his attempt to show +that the female organs are exactly analogous to the male the reader will +probably be unable to follow him, while even Johannes Müller, the father +of scientific physiology, declared at about the same period that the +clitoris is essentially different from the penis. It is indeed but three +centuries since the clitoris was so little known that (in 1593) Realdus +Columbus actually claimed the honor of discovering it. Columbus was not +its discoverer, for Fallopius speedily showed that Avicenna and Albucasis +had referred to it.[85] The Arabs appear to have been very familiar with +it, and, from the various names they gave it, clearly understood the +important part it plays in generating voluptuous emotion.[86] But it was +known in classic antiquity; the Greeks called it myrton, the myrtle-berry; +Galen and Soranus called it nymphê because it is covered as a bride is +veiled, while the old Latin name was _tentigo_, from its power of entering +into erection, and _columella_, the little pillar, from its shape. The +modern term, which is Greek and refers to the sensitiveness of the part to +voluptuous titillation, is said to have originated with Suidas and +Pollux.[87] It was mentioned, though not adopted, by Rufus. + +"The clitoris," declared Haller, "is a part extremely sensible and +wonderfully prurient." It is certainly the chief though by no means the +only point through which the immediate call to detumescence is conveyed to +the female organism. It is, indeed, as Bryan Robinson remarks, "a +veritable electrical bell button which, being pressed or irritated, rings +up the whole nervous system." + + The nervous supply of this little organ is very large, and the + dorsal nerve of the clitoris is relatively three or four times + larger than that of the penis. Yet the sensitive point of this + organ is only 5 to 7 millimeters in extent. The length of the + clitoris is usually rather over 2 centimeters (or about an inch) + and 3 centimeters when erect; a length of 4 centimeters or more + was regarded by Martineau as within the normal range of + variation. It is not usual to find the clitoris longer than this + in Europe (for among some races like the negro the clitoris is + generally large), but all degrees of magnitude may be found as + rare exceptions. (See, e.g., Sir J.Y. Simpson, "Hermaphrodites," + _Obstetric Memoirs and Contributions_, vol. ii, pp. 217-226; also + Dickinson, loc. cit.) It was formerly thought that the clitoris + is easily enlarged by masturbation, and Martineau believed that + in this way it might be doubled in length. It is probable that + slight enlargement of the clitoris may be caused by very + frequent masturbation, but only to an insignificant extent, and + it is impossible to diagnose masturbation from the size of the + clitoris. Among the women of Lake Nyassa, as well as in the + Caroline Islands, special methods are practiced for elongating + the clitoris, but in Europe, at all events, it is probable that + the variations in the size of the organ are mainly congenital. It + may well be that a congenitally large clitoris is associated with + an abnormally developed excitability of the sexual apparatus. + Tilt stated (_On Uterine and Ovarian Inflammation_, p. 37) that + in his experience there was a frequent though not invariable + connection between a large clitoris and sexual proclivity. + (Schurig referred to a case of intense and life-long sexual + obsession associated with an extremely large clitoris, + _Gynæcologia_, pp. 16-17.) Of recent years considerable + importance has been attached by some gynecologists (e.g., R.T. + Morris, "Is Evolution Trying to Do Away With the Clitoris?" + _Transactions American Association of Obstetricians and + Gynecologists_, vol. v, 1893) to preputial adhesions around the + clitoris as a source of nervous disturbance and invalidism in + young women. + +While the clitoris is anatomically analogous to the penis, its actual +mechanism under the stress of sexual excitement is somewhat different. As +Liétaud long since pointed out, it cannot rise freely in erection as the +penis can; it is apparently bound down by its prepuce and its frenulum. +Waldeyer, in his book on the pelvis, states more precisely that, unlike +the penis, when erect it retains its angle, only this becomes somewhat +rounded so that the organ is to some slight extent lifted and protruded. +Waldeyer considered that the clitoris was thus perfectly fitted to fulfill +its part as the recipient of erotic stimulation from friction by the +penis. Adler, however, has pointed out with considerable justice, that +this is not altogether the case. The clitoris was developed in mammals who +practiced the posterior mode of coitus; in this position the clitoris was +beneath the penis, which was thus easily able in coitus to press it +against the pubic bone close beneath which it is situated, and thus impart +the compression and friction which the feminine organ craves. But in the +human anterior mode of coitus it is not necessarily brought into close +contact with the penis during the act of coitus, and thus fails to receive +powerful stimulation. Its restricted position, which is an advantage in +posterior coitus, is a disadvantage in anterior coitus. Adler observes +that it thus comes about that the human method of coitus, while by +bringing breast to breast and face to face it has added a new dignity and +refinement, a fresh source of enjoyment, to the embrace of the sexes, has +not been an unmixed advantage to woman, for while man has lost nothing by +the change, woman has now to contend with an increased difficulty in +attaining an adequate amount of pressure on that "electric button" which +normally sets the whole mechanism in operation.[88] + +We may well bring into connection with the changed conditions brought +about by anterior coitus the interesting fact that while the clitoris +remains the most exquisitely sensitive of the sexual centers in woman, +voluptuous sensitivity is much more widely diffused in woman than in man. +Over the whole body, indeed, it is apt to be more distinctly marked than +is usually the case in man. But even if we confine ourselves to the +genital region, while in man that portion of the penis which enters the +vagina, and especially the glans, is normally the only portion which, even +during turgescence, is sensitive to voluptuous contacts, in woman the +whole of the region comprised within the larger lips, including even the +anus and internally the vagina and the vaginal portion of the womb,[89] +become sensitive to voluptuous contacts. Deprived of the penis the ability +of a man to experience specifically sexual sensations becomes very limited +indeed. But the loss of the clitoris or of any other structure involves no +correspondingly serious disability on women. Ablation of the clitoris for +sexual hyperæsthesia has for this reason been abandoned, except under +special circumstances. The members of the Russian Skoptzy sect habitually +amputate the clitoris, nymphæ, and breasts, yet many young Skoptzy women +told the Russian physician, Guttceit, that they were perfectly well able +to enjoy coitus. + + Freud believes that in very young girls the clitoris is the + exclusive seat of sexual sensation, masturbation at this age + being directed to the clitoris alone, and spontaneous sexual + excitement being confined to twitchings and erection of this + organ, so that young girls are able, from their own experience, + to recognize without instruction the signs of sexual excitement + in boys. At a later age sexual excitability spreads from the + clitoris to other regions--just as the easy inflammability of + wood sets light to coal--though in the male the penis remains + from first to last normally the almost exclusive seat of specific + excitability. (S. Freud, _Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie_, + p. 62.) + + The anus would, however, seem to be sometimes an erogenous zone + even at an early age. Titillation of the anus appears to be + frequently pleasurable in women; and this is not surprising + considering the high degree of erotic sensitivity which is easily + developed at the body orifices where skin meets mucous membrane. + (Thus the meatus of the urethra is a highly erogenous zone, as is + sufficiently shown by the frequency with which hair-pins and + other articles used in masturbation find their way into the + bladder.) It is in this germinal sensitivity, undoubtedly, that + we find a chief key to the practice of _pedicatio_. Freud + attaches great importance to the anus as a sexually erogenous + zone at a very early age, and considers that it very frequently + makes its influence felt in this respect. He believes that + intestinal catarrhs in very early life and hæmorrhoids later tend + to develop sensibility in the anus. He finds an indication that + the anus has become a sexually erogenous zone when children wish + to allow the contents of the rectum to accumulate so that + defecation may by its increased difficulty involve voluptuous + sensations, and adds that masturbatory excitation of the anus + with the fingers is by no means rare in older children. (S. + Freud, _Op. cit._, pp. 40-42.) A medical correspondent in India + tells me of a European lady who derived, she said, "quite as + much, indeed more," pleasure from digitally titillating her + rectum as from vulvo-vaginal titillation; she had several times + submitted to _pedicatio_ and enjoyed it, though it was painful + during penetration. The anus may retain this erogenous + irritability even in old age, and Routh mentions the case of a + lady of over 70, the reverse of lustful, who was so excited by + the act of defecation that she was invariably compelled to + masturbate, although this state of things was a source of great + mental misery to her. (C.H.F. Routh, _British Gynæcological + Journal_, February, 1887, p. 48.) + + Bölsche has sought the explanation of the erogenous nature of the + anus, and the key to _pedicatio_, in an atavistic return to the + very remote amphibian days when the anus was combined with the + sexual parts in a common cloaca. But it is unnecessary to invoke + any vestigial inheritance from a vastly remote past when we bear + in mind that the innervation of these two adjoining regions is + inevitably very closely related. The presence of a body exit with + its marked and special sensitivity at a point where it can + scarcely fail to receive the nervous overflow from an immensely + active center of nervous energy quite adequately accounts for the + phenomenon in question. + +The inner lips, the nymphæ or labia minora, running parallel with the +greater lips which enclose them, embrace the clitoris anteriorly and +extend backward, enclosing the urethral exit between them as well as the +vaginal entrance. They form little wings whence their old Latin name, +_alæ_, and from their resemblance to the cock's comb were by Spigelius +termed crista galli. The red and (especially in brunettes) dark appearance +of the nymphæ suggests that they are mucous membrane and not +integumentary; it is, however, now considered that even on the inner +surface they are covered by skin and separated from the mucous membrane by +a line.[90] In structure, as described by Waldeyer, they consist of fine +connective tissue rich in elastic fibers as well as some muscular tissue, +and full of large veins, so that they are capable of a considerable degree +of turgescence resembling erection during sexual excitement, while +Ballantyne finds that the nymphæ are supplied to a notable extent with +nervous end-organs. + +More than any other part of the sexual apparatus in either sex, the lesser +lips, on account of their shape, their position, and their structure, are +capable of acquired modifications, more especially hypertrophy and +elongation. By stretching, it is stated, a labium can be doubled in its +dimensions. The "Hottentot apron," or elongated nymphæ, commonly found +among some peoples in South Africa, has long been a familiar phenomenon. +In such cases a length or transverse diameter of 3 to 5 centimeters is +commonly found. But such elongated nymphæ are by no means confined to one +part of the world or to one race; they are quite common among women of +European race, and reach a size equal to most of the more reliably +recorded Hottentot cases. Dickinson, who has very carefully studied this +question in New York, finds that in 1000 consecutive gynæcological cases +the labia showed some form of hypertrophy in 36 per cent., or more than 1 +in 3; while among 150 of these cases who were neurasthenic, the proportion +reached 56 per cent., even when minor or doubtful enlargements were +disregarded. Bergh, in about 16 per cent. cases, found very enlarged +nymphæ, the height reached in about 5 per cent. of the cases of +enlargement being nearly six centimeters. Ploss and Bartels, in a full +discussion: of the "Hottentot apron," come to the conclusion that this +condition is perhaps in most cases artificially produced. It is known that +among the Basutos it is the custom for the elder girls to manipulate the +nymphæ of younger children, when alone with them, almost from birth, and +on account of the elastic nature of these structures such manipulation +quite adequately accounts for the elongation. It is not necessary to +suppose that the custom is practiced for the sake of producing sexual +stimulation--though this may frequently occur--since there are numerous +similar primitive customs involving deformation of the sexual organs +without the production of sexual excitement. Dickinson has come to a +similar conclusion as regards the corresponding elongation of the nymphæ +in civilized European women. In 361 out of 1000 women of good social class +he found elongation or thickening, often with a notable degree of +wrinkling and pigmentation, and believes that this is always the result of +frequently repeated masturbation practiced with the separation of the +nymphæ; in 30 per cent. of the cases admission of masturbation was +made.[91] While this conclusion is probably correct in the main, it +requires some qualification. To assert that whenever in women who have +not been pregnant the marked protrusion of the inner lips beyond the outer +lips means that at some period manipulation has been practiced with or +without the production of sexual excitement is to make too absolute a +statement. It is highly probable that the nymphæ, like the clitoris, are +congenitally more prominent in some of the lower human races, as they are +also in the apes; among the Fuegians, for instance, according to Hyades +and Deniker, the labia minora descend lower than in Europeans, although +there is not the slightest reason to suppose that these women practice any +manipulations. Among European women, again, the nymphæ sometimes protrude +very prominently beyond the labia majora in women who are organically of +somewhat infantile type; this occurs in cases in which we may be convinced +that no manipulations have ever been practiced.[92] + +It is difficult to speak very decisively as to the function of the labia +minora. They doubtless exert some amount of protective influence over the +entrance to the vagina, and in this way correspond to the lips of the +mouth after which they are called. They fulfill, however, one very +definite though not obviously important function which is indicated by the +mythologic name they have received. There is, indeed, some obscurity in +the origin of this term, nymphæ, which has not, I believe, been +satisfactorily cleared up. It has been stated that the Greek name nymphê +has been transferred from the clitoris to the labia minora. Any such +transfer could only have taken place when the meaning of the word had been +forgotten, and nymphê had become the totally different word _nymphæ_, the +goddesses who presided over streams. The old anatomists were much +exercised in their minds as to the meaning of the name, but on the whole +were inclined to believe that it referred to the action of the labia +minora in directing the urinary stream. The term nymphæ was first applied +in the modern sense, according to Bergh, in 1599, by Pinæus, mainly from +the influence of these structures on the urinary stream, and he dilated in +his _De Virginitate_ on the suitability of the term to designate so poetic +a spot.[93] In more modern times Luschka and Sir Charles Bell considered +that it is one of the uses of the nymphæ to direct the stream of urine, +and Lamb from his own observation thinks the same conclusion probable. In +reality there cannot be the slightest doubt about the function of the +nymphæ, as, in Hyrtl's phrase, "the naiads of the urinary source," and it +can be demonstrated by the simplest experiment.[94] + +The nymphæ form the intermediate portal of the vagina, as the canal which +conducts to the womb was in anatomy first termed (according to Hyrtl) by +De Graaf.[95] It is a secreting, erectile, more or less sensitive canal +lined by what is usually considered mucous membrane, though some have +regarded it as integument of the same character as that of the external +genitals; it certainly resembles such integument more than, for instance, +the mucous membrane of the rectum. In the woman who has never had sexual +intercourse and has been subjected to no manipulations or accidents +affecting this region, the vagina is closed by a last and final gate of +delicate membrane--scarcely admitting more than a slender finger--called +the hymen. + + The poets called the hymen "fios virginitatis," the flower of + virginity, whence the medico-legal term _defloratio_. + Notwithstanding the great significance which has long been + attached to the phenomena connected with it, the hymen was not + accurately known until Vesalius, Fallopius, and Spigelius + described and named it. It was, however, recognized by the Arab + authors, Avicenna and Averroes. The early literature concerning + it is summarized by Schurig, _Muliebria_, 1729, Section II, cap. + V. The same author's _Parthenologia_ is devoted to the various + ancient problems connected with the question of virginity. + +To say that this delicate piece of membrane is from the non-physical point +of view a more important structure than any other part of the body is to +convey but a feeble idea of the immense importance of the hymen in the +eyes of the men of many past ages and even of our own times and among our +own people.[96] For the uses of the feminine body, or for its beauty, +there is no part which is more absolutely insignificant. But in human +estimation it has acquired a spiritual value which has made it far more +than a part of the body. It has taken the place of the soul, that whose +presence gives all her worth and dignity, even her name, to the unmarried +woman, her purity, her sexual desirability, her market value. Without +it--though in all physical and mental respects she might remain the same +person--she has sometimes been a mark for contempt, a worthless +outcast.[97] + + So fragile a membrane scarcely possesses the reliability which + should be possessed by a structure whose presence or absence has + often meant so much. Its absence by no means necessarily + signifies that a woman has had intercourse with a man. Its + presence by no means signifies that she has never had such + intercourse. + + There are many ways in which the hymen may be destroyed apart + from coitus. Among the Chinese (and also, it would appear, in + India and some other parts of the East) the female parts are from + infancy kept so scrupulously clean by daily washing, the finger + being introduced into the vagina, that the hymen rapidly + disappears, and its existence is unknown even to Chinese doctors. + Among some Brazilian Indians a similar practice exists among + mothers as regards their young children, less, however, for the + sake of cleanliness than in order to facilitate sexual + intercourse in future years. (Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. + i, Chapter VI.) The manipulations of vaginal masturbation will, + of course, similarly destroy the hymen. It is also quite possible + for the hymen to be ruptured by falls and other accidents. (See, + e.g., a lengthy study by Nina-Rodrigues, "Des Ruptures de l'Hymen + dans les Chutes," _Annales d'Hygiène Publique_, September, 1903.) + + On the other hand, integrity of the hymen is no proof of + virginity, apart from the obvious fact that there may be + intercourse without penetration. (The case has even been recorded + of a prostitute with syphilitic condylomata, a somewhat masculine + type of pubic arch, and vulva rather posteriorly placed, whose + hymen had never been penetrated.) The hymen may be of a yielding + or folding type, so that complete penetration may take place and + yet the hymen be afterwards found unruptured. It occasionally + happens that the hymen is found intact at the end of pregnancy. + In some, though not all, of these cases there has been conception + without intromission of the penis. This has occurred even when + the entrance was very minute. The possibility of such conception + has long been recognized, and Schurig (_Syllepsilogia_, 1731, + Section I, cap. VIII, p. 2) quotes ancient authors who have + recorded cases. For some typical modern cases see Guérard + (_Centralblatt für Gynäkologie_, No. 15, 1895), in one of whose + cases the hymen of the pregnant woman scarcely admitted a hair; + also Braun (ib., No. 23, 1895). + +The hymen has played a very definite and pronounced part in the social and +moral life of humanity. Until recently it has been more difficult to +decide what precise biological function it has exercised to ensure its +development and preservation. Sexual selection, no doubt, has worked in +its favor, but that influence has been very limited and comparatively very +recent. Virginity is not usually of any value among peoples who are +entirely primitive. Indeed, even in the classic civilization which we +inherit, it is easy to show that the virgin and the admiration for +virginity are of late growth; the virgin goddesses were not originally +virgins in our modern sense. Diana was the many-breasted patroness of +childbirth before she became the chaste and solitary huntress, for the +earliest distinction would appear to have been simply between the woman +who was attached to a man and the woman who followed an earlier rule of +freedom and independence; it was a later notion to suppose that the latter +woman was debarred from sexual intercourse. We certainly must not seek the +origin of the hymen in sexual selection; we must find it in natural +selection. And here it might seem at first sight that we come upon a +contradiction in Nature, for Nature is always devising contrivances to +secure the maximum amount of fertilization. "Increase and multiply" is so +obviously the command of Nature that the Hebrews, with their usual +insight, unhesitatingly dared to place it in the mouth of Jehovah. But the +hymen is a barrier to fertilization. It has, however, always to be +remembered that as we rise in the zoölogical scale, and as the period of +gestation lengthens and the possible number of offspring is fewer, it +becomes constantly more essential that fertilization shall be effective +rather than easy; the fewer the progeny the more necessary it is that they +shall be vigorous enough to survive. There can be little doubt that, as +one or two writers have already suggested, the hymen owes its development +to the fact that its influence is on the side of effective fertilization. +It is an obstacle to the impregnation of the young female by immature, +aged, or feeble males. The hymen is thus an anatomical expression of that +admiration of force which marks the female in her choice of a mate. So +regarded, it is an interesting example of the intimate manner in which +sexual selection is really based on natural selection. Sexual selection is +but the translation into psychic terms of a process which has already +found expression in the physical texture of the body. + + It may be added that this interpretation of the biological + function of the hymen is supported by the facts of its evolution. + It is unknown among the lower mammals, with whom fertilization is + easy, gestation short and offspring numerous. It only begins to + appear among the higher mammals in whom reproduction is already + beginning to take on the characters which become fully developed + in man. Various authors have found traces of a rudimentary hymen, + not only in apes, but in elephants, horses, donkeys, bitches, + bears, pigs, hyenas, and giraffes. (Hyrtl, _Op. cit._, vol. ii, + p. 189; G. Gellhoen, "Anatomy and Development of the Hymen," + _American Journal Obstetrics_, August, 1904.) It is in the human + species that the tendency to limitation of offspring is most + marked, combined at the same time with a greater aptitude for + impregnation than exists among any lower mammals. It is here, + therefore, that a physical check is of most value, and + accordingly we find that in woman alone, of all animals, is the + hymen fully developed. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[72] "Analysis of the Sexual Impulse," in vol. iii of these _Studies_. + +[73] "The accomplishment of no other function," Hyrtl remarks, "is so +intimately connected with the mind and yet so independent of it." + +[74] The process is still, however, but imperfectly understood; see Art. +"Fécondation," by Ed. Retterer, in Richet's _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_, +vol. vi, 1905. + +[75] Thus a male foetus showing reptilian characters in sexual ducts was +exhibited by Shattock at the Pathological Society of London, February 19, +1895. + +[76] J. Kohlbrugge, "Die Umgestaltung des Uterus der Affen nach den +Geburt," _Zeitschrift für Morphologie_, bd. iv, p. 1, 1901. + +[77] There are, however, no special nerve endings (Krause corpuscles), as +was formerly supposed. The nerve endings in the genital region are the +same as elsewhere. The difference lies in the abundance of superposed +arboreal ramifications. See, e.g., Ed. Retterer, Art. "Ejaculation," +Richet's _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_, vol. v. + +[78] Hyrtl, _Op. cit._, vol. ii, p. 39. + +[79] Sensations of pleasure without those of touch appear to be normal at +the tip of the penis, as pointed out by Scripture, quoted in _Alienist and +Neurologist_, January, 1898. + +[80] See the previous volume of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection in +Man," p. 161. + +[81] See, e.g., Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, beginning of +chapter VI. + +[82] Hyrtl states that the name _labia_ was first used by Haller in the +middle of the eighteenth century in his _Elements of Physiology_, being +adopted by him from the Greek poet Erotion, who gave these structures the +very obvious name cheilea, lips. But this seems to be a mistake, for the +seventeenth century anatomists certainly used the name "labia" for these +parts. + +[83] Bergh tentatively suggests, as regards the pubic hair, that its +appearance may be due to the upright walk in man and the human position +during coitus, the hair preventing irritation of the genitals from the +sweat pouring down from the body and protecting the skin from direct +friction in coitus. (In both these suggestions he was, however, long +previously anticipated by Fabricius ab Aquapendente.) The fanciful +suggestion of Louis Robinson that the pubic hair has developed in order to +enable the human infant to cling securely to his mother is very poorly +supported by facts, and has not met with acceptance. It may be mentioned +that (as stated by Ploss and Bartels) the women of the Bismarck +Archipelago, whose pubic hair is very abundant, use it as a kind of +handkerchief on which to clean their hands. + +[84] Routh and Heywood Smith have noted that the pubic hair tends to lose +its curliness and become straight in women who masturbate. (_British +Gynæcological Journal_, February, 1887, p. 505.) + +[85] Schurig, _Muliebria_, p. 75. Plazzon in 1621 said that in Italian it +had a popular name, _il besneegio_. + +[86] Schurig brought together in his _Gynæcologia_ (pp. 2-4) various early +opinions concerning the clitoris as the seat of voluptuous feeling. + +[87] Hyrtl, _Op. cit._, vol. ii, p. 193. + +[88] Adler, _Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, 1904, pp. +117-119. + +[89] The voluptuous sensations caused by sexual contacts producing +movements of the womb are probably normal and usual. They may even occur +under circumstances unconnected with sexual emotion, and Mundé +(_International Journal of Surgery_, March, 1893) mentions incidentally +that in one case while titillating the cervix with a sound the woman very +plainly showed voluptuous manifestations. + +[90] Henle stated that fine hairs are frequently visible on the nymphæ; +Stieda (_Zeitschrift für Morphologie_, 1902, p. 458) remarks that he has +never been able to see them with the naked eye. + +[91] R.L. Dickinson, "Hypertrophies of the Labia Minora and Their +Significance," _American Gynæcologist_, September, 1902. It is perhaps +noteworthy that Bergh found that in 302 cases in which the nymphæ were of +unequal length, in all but 24 the left was longer. + +[92] It may be remarked that Bergh believes that the nymphæ, and indeed +the external genitals generally, are congenitally more strongly developed +in libidinous persons, and at the same time in brunettes, while in public +prostitutes this is not usually the case, which confirms the belief that +exalted sexual sensibility does not usually lead to prostitution. He adds +that prostitution, unless carried on for many years, has little effect on +the shape of the external genitals. + +[93] Schurig (_Muliebria_, 1729, Section II, cap. II) gives numerous +quotations on this point; thus De Graaf wrote in his book on the sexual +organs of women: "Tales protuberantiæ nymphæ appellantur ea propter quod +aquis e vesica prosilientibus proxime adstare reperiantur, quandoquidem +inter illas, tanquam duos parietes, urina magno impetu cum sibilo sæpe et +absque labiorum irrigatione erumpit, vel quod sint castitatis præsides, +aut sponsam primo intromittant." + +[94] Havelock Ellis, "The Bladder as a Dynamometer," _American Journal of +Dermatology_, May, 1902. If a woman who has never been pregnant, standing +in the erect position before commencing the act of urination presses apart +the labia minora with index and middle fingers the stream will be +projected forward so as to fall usually at a considerable distance in +front of a vertical line from the meatus; if when the act is half +completed the fingers are removed, the labia close together and the +stream, though maintained at a constant pressure, at once changes its +character and direction. + +[95] In poetry this term was employed by Plautus, _Pseudolus_, Act IV, Sc. +7. The Greek aidoion sometimes meant vagina and sometimes the external +sexual parts; kolpos was used for the vagina alone. + +[96] It is curious, however, that the European physicians of the +seventeenth and even eighteenth centuries were doubtful of its value as a +sign of virginity and considered it often absent. + +[97] For a summary of the beliefs and practices of various peoples with +regard to the hymen and virginity see Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. +i, Chapter XVI. + + + + +II + +The Object of Detumescence--Erogenous Zones--The Lips--The Vascular +Characters of Detumescence--Erectile Tissue--Erection in Woman--Mucous +Emission in Women--Sexual Connection--The Human Mode of +Intercourse--Normal Variations--The Motor Characters of +Detumescence--Ejaculation--The Virile Reflex--The General Phenomena of +Detumescence--The Circulatory and Respiratory Phenomena--Blood +Pressure--Cardiac Disturbance--Glandular Activity--Distillatio--The +Essentially Motor Character of Detumescence--Involuntary Muscular +Irradiation to Bladder, etc.--Erotic Intoxication--Analogy of Sexual +Detumescence and Vesical Tension--The Specifically Sexual Movements of +Detumescence in Man--In Woman--The Spontaneous Movements of the Genital +Canal in Woman--Their Function in Conception--Part Played by Active +Movement of the Spermatozoa--The Artificial Injection of Semen--The Facial +Expression During Detumescence--The Expression of Joy--The Occasional +Serious Effects of Coitus. + + +We have seen what the object of detumescence is, and we have briefly +considered the organs and structures which are chiefly concerned in the +process. We have now to inquire what are the actual phenomena which take +place during the act of detumescence. + +Detumescence is normally linked closely to tumescence. Tumescence is the +piling on of the fuel; detumescence is the leaping out of the devouring +flame whence is lighted the torch of life to be handed on from generation +to generation. The whole process is double and yet single; it is exactly +analogous to that by which a pile is driven into the earth by the raising +and then the letting go of a heavy weight which falls on to the head of +the pile. In tumescence the organism is slowly wound up and force +accumulated; in the act of detumescence the accumulated force is let go +and by its liberation the sperm-bearing instrument is driven home. +Courtship, as we commonly term the process of tumescence which takes place +when a woman is first sexually approached by a man, is usually a highly +prolonged process. But it is always necessary to remember that every +repetition of the act of coitus, to be normally and effectively carried +out on both sides, demands a similar double process; detumescence must be +preceded by an abbreviated courtship. + +This abbreviated courtship by which tumescence is secured or heightened in +the repetition of acts of coitus which have become familiar, is mainly +tactile.[98] Since the part of the man in coitus is more active and that +of the woman more passive, the sexual sensitivity of the skin seems to be +more pronounced in women. There are, moreover, regions of the surface of a +woman's body where contact, when sympathetic, seems specially liable to +arouse erotic excitement. Such erogenous zones are often specially marked +in the breasts, occasionally in the palm of the hand, the nape of the +neck, the lobule of the ear, the little finger; there is, indeed, perhaps +no part of the surface of the body which may not, in some individuals at +some time, become normally an erogenous zone. In hysteria the erotic +excitability of these zones is sometimes very intense. The lips are, +however, without doubt, the most persistently and poignantly sensitive +region of the whole body outside the sphere of the sexual organs +themselves. Hence the significance of the kiss as a preliminary of +detumescence.[99] + + The importance of the lips as a normal erogenous zone is shown by + the experiments of Gualino. He applied a thread, folded on itself + several times, to the lips, thus stimulating them in a simple + mechanical manner. Of 20 women, between the ages of 18 and 35, + only 8 felt this as a merely mechanical operation, 4 felt a + vaguely erotic element in the proceeding, 3 experienced a desire + for coitus and in 5 there was actual sexual excitement with + emission of mucus. Of 25 men, between the ages of 20 and 30, in + 15 all sexual feeling was absent, in 7 erotic ideas were + suggested with congestion of the sexual organs without erection, + and in 3 there was the beginning of erection. It should be added + that both the women and the men in whom this sexual reflex was + more especially marked were of somewhat nervous temperament; in + such persons erotic reactions of all kinds generally occur most + easily. (Gualino, "Il Rifflesso Sessuale nell' eccitamento alle + labbre," _Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1904, p. 341.) + +As tumescence, under the influence of sensory stimulation, proceeds toward +the climax when it gives place to detumescence, the physical phenomena +become more and more acutely localized in the sexual organs. The process +which was at first predominantly nervous and psychic now becomes more +prominently vascular. The ancient sexual relationship of the skin asserts +itself; there is marked surface congestion showing itself in various ways. +The face tends to become red, and exactly the same phenomenon is taking +place in the genital organs; "an erection," it has been said, "is a +blushing of the penis." The difference is that in the genital organs this +heightened vascularity has a definite and specific function to +accomplish--the erection of the male organ which fits it to enter the +female parts--and that consequently there has been developed in the penis +that special kind of vascular mechanism, consisting of veins in connective +tissue with unstriped muscular fibers, termed erectile tissue.[100] + +It is not only the man who is supplied with erectile tissue which in the +process of tumescence becomes congested and swollen. The woman also, in +the corresponding external genital region, is likewise supplied with +erectile tissue now also charged with blood, and exhibits the same changes +as have taken place in her partner, though less conspicuously visible. In +the anthropoid apes, as the gorilla, the large clitoris and the nymphæ +become prominent in sexual excitement, but the less development of the +clitoris in women, together with the specifically human evolution of the +mons veneris and larger lips, renders this sexual turgescence practically +invisible, though it is perceptible to touch in an increased degree of +spongy and elastic tension. The whole feminine genital canal, including +the uterus, indeed, is richly supplied with blood-vessels, and is capable +during sexual excitement of a very high degree of turgescence, a kind of +erection. + +The process of erection in woman is accompanied by the pouring out of +fluid which copiously bathes all parts of the vulva around the entrance to +the vagina. This is a bland, more or less odorless mucus which, under +ordinary circumstances, slowly and imperceptibly suffuses the parts. When, +however, the entrance to the vagina is exposed and extended, as during a +gynæcological examination which occasionally produces sexual excitement, +there may be seen a real ejaculation of the fluid which, as usually +described, comes largely from the glands of Bartholin, situated at the +mouth of the vagina. Under these circumstances it is sometimes described +as being emitted in a jet which is thrown to a distance.[101] This mucous +ejaculation was in former days regarded as analogous to the seminal +ejaculation in man, and hence essential to conception. Although this +belief was erroneous the fluid poured out in this manner whenever a high +degree of tumescence is attained, and before the onset of detumescence, +certainly performs an important function in lubricating the entrance to +the genital canal and so facilitating the intromission of the male +organ.[102] Menstruation has a similar influence in facilitating coitus, +as Schurig long since pointed out.[103] A like process takes place during +parturition when the same parts are being lubricated and stretched in +preparation for the protrusion of the foetal head. The occurrence of the +mucous flow in tumescence always indicates that that process is actively +affecting the central sexual organs, and that voluptuous emotions are +present.[104] + + The secretions of the genital canal and outlet in women are + somewhat numerous. We have the odoriferous glands of sebaceous + origin, and with them the prepuce of the clitoris which has been + described as a kind of gigantic sebaceous follicle with the + clitoris occupying its interior. (Hyrtl.) There is the secretion + from the glands of Bartholin. There is again the vaginal + secretion, opaque and albuminous, which appears to be alkaline + when secreted, but becomes acid under the decomposing influence + of bacteria, which are, however, harmless and not pathogenic. + (Gow, _Obstetrical Society of London_, January 3, 1894.) There + is, finally, the mucous uterine secretion, which is alkaline, + and, being poured out during orgasm, is believed to protect the + spermatozoa from destruction by the acid vaginal secretion. + + The belief that the mucus poured out in women during sexual + excitement is feminine semen and therefore essential to + conception had many remarkable consequences and was widespread + until the seventeenth century. Thus, in the chapter "De Modo + coeundi et de regimine eorum qui coeunt" of _De Secretis + Mulierum_, there is insistence on the importance of the proper + mixture of the male semen with the female semen and of arranging + that it shall not escape from the vagina. The woman must lie + quiet for several hours at least, not rising even to urinate, and + when she gets up, be very temperate in eating and drinking, and + not run or jump, pretending that she has a headache. It was the + belief in feminine semen which led some theologians to lay down + that a woman might masturbate if she had not experienced orgasm + in coitus. Schurig in his _Muliebria_ (1729, pp. 159, et seq.) + discusses the opinions of old authors regarding the nature, + source, and uses of the female genital secretions, and quotes + authorities against the old view that it was female semen. In a + subsequent work (_Syllepsilogia_, 1731, pp. 3, et seq.) he + returns to the same question, quotes authors who accept a + feminine semen, shows that Harvey denied it any significance, and + himself decides against it. It has not seriously been brought + forward since. + +When erection is completed in both the man and the woman the conditions +necessary for conjugation have at last been fulfilled. In all animals, +even those most nearly allied to man, coitus is effected by the male +approaching the female posteriorly. In man the normal method of male +approach is anteriorly, face to face. Leonardo da Vinci, in a well-known +drawing representing a sagittal section of a man and a woman connected in +this position of so-called Venus obversa; has shown how well adapted the +position is to the normal position of the organs in the human +species.[105] + + Among monkeys, it is stated, congress is sometimes performed when + the female is on all fours; at other times the male brings the + female between his thighs when he is sitting, holding her with + his forepaws. Froriep informed Lawrence that the male sometimes + supported his feet on the female's calves. (Sir W. Lawrence, + _Lectures on Physiology_, 1823, p. 186.) A summary of the methods + of congress practiced by the various animals below mammals will + be found in the article "Copulation" by H. de Varigny in Richet's + _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_, vol. iv. + + The anterior position in coitus, with the female partner lying + supine, is so widespread throughout the world that it may fairly + be termed the most typically human attitude in sexual congress. + It is found represented in Egyptian graves at Benihassan, + belonging to the Twelfth Dynasty; it is regarded by Mohammedans + as the normal position, although other positions are permitted by + the Prophet: "Your wives are your tillage: go in unto your + tillage in what manner soever you will;" it is that adopted in + Malacca; it appears, from Peruvian antiquities, to have been the + position generally, though not exclusively, adopted in ancient + Peru; it is found in many parts of Africa, and seems also to have + been the most usual position among the American aborigines. + + Various modifications of this position are, however, found. Thus, + in some parts of the world, as among the Suahelis in Zanzibar, + the male partner adopts the supine position. In Loango, according + to Pechuel-Loesche, coitus is performed lying on the side. + Sometimes, as on the west coast of Africa, the woman is supine + and the man more or less erect; or, as among the Queenslanders + (as described by Roth) the woman is supine and the man squats on + his heels with her thighs clasping his flanks, while he raises + her buttocks with his hands. + + The position of coitus in which the man is supine is without + doubt a natural and frequent variation of the specifically human + obverse method of coitus. It was evidently familiar to the + Romans. Ovid mentions it (_Ars Amatoria_, III, 777-8), + recommending it to little women, and saying that Andromache was + too tall to practice it with Hector. Aristophanes refers to it, + and there are Greek epigrams in which women boast of their skill + in riding their lovers. It has sometimes been viewed with a + certain disfavor because it seems to confer a superiority on the + woman. "Cursed be he," according to a Mohammedan saying, "who + maketh woman heaven and man earth." + + Of special interest is the wide prevalence of an attitude in + coitus recalling that which prevails among quadrupeds. The + frequency with which on the walls of Pompeii coitus is + represented with the woman bending forward and her partner + approaching her posteriorly has led to the belief that this + attitude was formerly very common in Southern Italy. However that + may be, it is certainly normal at the present day among various + more or less primitive peoples in whom the vulva is often placed + somewhat posteriorly. It is thus among the Soudanese, as also, in + an altogether different part of the world, among the Eskimo + Innuit and Koniags. The New Caledonians, according to Foley, + cohabit in the quadrupedal manner, and so also the Papuans of New + Guinea (Bongu), according to Vahness. The same custom is also + found in Australia, where, however other postures are also + adopted. In Europe the quadrupedal posture would seem to prevail + among some of the South Slavs, notably the Dalmatians. (The + different methods of coitus practiced by the South Slavs are + described in Kryptadia vol. vi, pp. 220, et seq.) + + This method of coitus was recommended by Lucretius (lib. iv) and + also advised by Paulus Æginetus as favorable to conception. (The + opinions of various early physicians are quoted by Schurig, + _Spermatologia_, 1720, pp. 232, et seq.). It seems to be a + position that is not infrequently agreeable to women, a fact + which may be brought into connection with the remarks of Adler + already quoted (p. 131) concerning the comparative lack of + adjustment of the feminine organs to the obverse position. It is + noteworthy that in the days of witchcraft hysterical women + constantly believed that they had had intercourse with the Devil + in this manner. This circumstance, indeed, probably aided in the + very marked disfavor in which coitus _a posteriori_ fell after + the decay of classic influences. The mediæval physicians + described it as _mos diabolicus_ and mistakenly supposed that it + produced abortion (Hyrtl, op. cit., vol. ii, p. 87). The + theologians, needless to say, were opposed to the _mos + diabolicus_, and already in the Anglo-Saxon Penitential of + Theodore, at the end of the seventh century, 40 days' penance is + prescribed for this method of coitus. + + From the frequency with which they have been adopted by various + peoples as national customs, most of the postures in coitus here + referred to must be said to come within the normal range of + variation. It is a mistake to regard them as vicious perversions. + +Up to the point to which we have so far considered it, the process of +detumescence has been mainly nervous and vascular in character; it has, in +fact, been but the more acute stage of a process which has been going on +throughout tumescence. But now we reach the point at which a new element +comes in: muscular action. With the onset of muscular action, which is +mainly involuntary, even when it affects the voluntary muscles, +detumescence proper begins to take place. Henceforward purposeful psychic +action, except by an effort, is virtually abolished. The individual, as a +separate person, tends to disappear. He has become one with another +person, as nearly one as the conditions of existence ever permit; he and +she are now merely an instrument in the hands of a higher power--by +whatever name we may choose to call that Power--which is using them for an +end not themselves. + +The decisive moment in the production of the instinctive and involuntary +orgasm occurs when, under the influence of the stimulus applied to the +penis by friction with the vagina, the tension of the seminal fluid poured +into the urethra arouses the ejaculatory center in the spinal cord and the +bulbo-cavernosus muscle surrounding the urethra responsively contracts in +rhythmic spasms. Then it is that ejaculation occurs.[106] + +"The circulation quickens, the arteries beat strongly," wrote Roubaud in a +description of the physical state during coitus which may almost be termed +classic; "the venous blood, arrested by muscular contraction, increases +the general heat, and this stagnation, more pronounced in the brain by the +contraction of the muscles of the neck and the throwing of the head +backward, causes a momentary cerebral congestion, during which +intelligence is lost and the faculties abolished. The eyes, violently +injected, become haggard, and the look uncertain, or, in the majority of +cases, the eyes are closed spasmodically to avoid the contact of the +light. The respiration is hurried, sometimes interrupted, and may be +suspended by the spasmodic contraction of the larynx, and the air, for a +time compressed, is at last emitted in broken and meaningless words. The +congested nervous centers only communicate confused sensations and +volitions; mobility and sensation show extreme disorder; the limbs are +seized by convulsions and sometimes by cramps, or are thrown wildly about +or become stiff like iron bars. The jaws, tightly pressed, grind the +teeth, and in some persons the delirium is carried so far that they bite +to bleeding the shoulders their companions have imprudently abandoned to +them. This frantic state of epilepsy lasts but a short time, but it +suffices to exhaust the forces of the organism, especially in man. It is, +I believe, Galen, who said: 'Omne animal post coitum triste præter +mulierem gallumque.'"[107] Most of the elements that make up this typical +picture of the state of coitus are not absolutely essential to that state, +but they all come within the normal range of variation. There can be no +doubt that this range is considerable. There would appear to be not only +individual, but also racial, differences; there is a remarkable passage in +Vatsyayana's _Kama Sutra_ describing the varying behavior of the women of +different races in India under the stress of sexual excitement--Dravidian +women with difficulty attaining erethism, women of the Punjaub fond of +being caressed with the tongue, women of Oude with impetuous desire and +profuse flow of mucus, etc.--and it is highly probable, Ploss and Bartels +remark, that these characterizations are founded on exact +observations.[108] + +The various phenomena included in Roubaud's description of the condition +during coitus may all be directly or indirectly reduced to two groups: the +first circulatory and respiratory, the second motor. It is necessary to +consider both these aspects of the process of detumescence in somewhat +greater detail, although while it is most convenient to discuss them +separately, it must be borne in mind that they are not really separable; +the circulatory phenomena are in large measure a by-product of the +involuntary motor process. + +With the approach of detumescence the respiration becomes shallow, rapid, +and to some extent arrested. This characteristic of the breathing during +sexual excitement is well recognized; so that in, for instance, the +_Arabian Nights_, it is commonly noted of women when gazing at beautiful +youths whose love they desired, that they ceased breathing.[109] It may be +added that exactly the same tendency to superficial and arrested +respiration takes place whenever there is any intense mental +concentration, as in severe intellectual work.[110] + +The arrest of respiration tends to render the blood venous, and thus aids +in stimulating the vasomotor centers, raising the blood-pressure in the +body generally, and especially in the erectile tissues. High +blood-pressure is one of the most marked features of the state of +detumescence. The heart beats are stronger and quicker, the surface +arteries are more visible, the conjunctivæ become red. The precise degree +of blood-pressure attained during coitus has been most accurately +ascertained in the dog. In Bechterew's laboratory in St. Petersburg a +manometer was introduced into the central end of the carotid artery of a +bitch; a male dog was then introduced, and during coitus observations were +made on the blood-pressure at the peripheral and central ends of the +artery. It was found that there was a great general elevation of +blood-pressure, intense hyperæmia of the brain, rapid alternations, during +the act, of vasoconstriction and vasodilatation of the brain, with +increase and diminution of the general arterial tension in relation with +the various phases of the act, the greatest cerebral vasodilatation and +hyperæmia coinciding with the moment following the intromission of the +penis; the end of the act is followed by a considerable fall in the +blood-pressure.[111] I am not acquainted with any precise observations on +the blood-pressure in human subjects during detumescence, and there are +obvious difficulties in the way of such observations. It is probable, +however, that the conditions found would be substantially the same. This +is indicated, so far as the very marked increase of blood-pressure is +concerned, by some observations made by Vaschide and Vurpas with the +sphygmanometer on a lady under the influence of sexual excitement. In this +case there was a relationship of sympathy and friendly tenderness between +the experimenter and the subject, Madame X, aged 25. Experimenter and +subject talked sympathetically, and finally, we are told, while the latter +still had her hands in the sphygmanometer, the former almost made a +declaration of love. Madame X was greatly impressed, and afterward +admitted that her emotions had been genuine and strong. The +blood-pressure, which was in this subject habitually 65 millimeters, rose +to 150 and even 160, indicating a very high pressure, which rarely occurs; +at the same time Madame X looked very emotional and troubled.[112] + + Some authorities are of opinion that irregularities in the + accomplishment of the sexual act are specially liable to cause + disturbances in the circulation. Thus Kisch, of Prague, refers to + the case of a couple practising coitus interruptus--the husband + withdrawing before ejaculation--in which the wife, a vigorous + woman, became liable after some years to attacks termed by Kisch + _neurasthenia cordis vasomotoria_, in which there was at daily or + longer intervals palpitation, with feelings of anxiety, headache, + dizziness, muscular weakness and tendency to faint. He regards + coitus as a cause of various heart troubles in women: (1) Attacks + of tachycardia in very excitable and sexually inclined women; (2) + attacks of tachycardia with dyspnoea in young women, with + vaginismus; (3) cardiac symptoms with lowered vascular tone in + women who for a long time have practised coitus interruptus + without complete sexual gratification (Kisch, "Herzbeschwerden + der Frauen verursacht durch den Cohabitationsact," _Münchener + Medizinisches Wochenschrift_, 1897, p. 617). In this connection, + also, reference may probably be made to those attacks of anxiety + which Freud associates with psychic sexual lesions of an + emotional character. + +Associated with this vascular activity in detumescence we find a general +tendency to glandular activity. Various secretions are formed abundantly. +Perspiration is copious, and the ancient relationship between the +cutaneous and sexual systems seems to evoke a general activity of the skin +and its odoriferous secretions. Salivation, which also occurs, is very +conspicuous in many lower animals, as for instance in the donkey, notably +the female, who just before coitus stands with mouth open, jaws moving, +and saliva dribbling. In men, corresponding to the more copious secretion +in women, there is, during the latter stages of tumescence, a slight +secretion of mucus--Fürbringer's _urethrorrhoea ex libidine_--which +appears in drops at the urethral orifice. It comes from the small glands +of Littré and Cowper which open into the urethra. This phenomenon was well +known to the old theologians, who called it _distillatio_, and realized +its significance as at once distinct from semen and an indication that the +mind was dwelling on voluptuous images; it was also known in classic +times[113]; more recently it has often been confused with semen and has +thus sometimes caused needless anxiety to nervous persons. There is also +an increased secretion of urine, and it is probable that if the viscera +were more accessible to observation we might be able to demonstrate that +the glands throughout the body share in this increased activity. + +The phenomena of detumescence culminate, however, and have their most +obvious manifestation in motor activity. The genital act, as Vaschide and +Vurpas remark, consists essentially in "a more and more marked tension of +the motor state which, reaching its maximum, presents a short tonic phase, +followed by a clonic phase, and terminates in a period of adynamia and +repose." This motor activity is of the essence of the impulse of +detumescence, because without it the sperm cells could not be brought into +the neighborhood of the germ cell and be propelled into the organic nest +which is assigned for their conjunction and incubation. + +The motor activity is general as well as specifically sexual. There is a +general tendency to more or less involuntary movement, without any +increase of voluntary muscular power, which is, indeed, decreased, and +Vaschide and Vurpas state that dynamometric results are somewhat lower +than normal during sexual excitement, and the variations greater.[114] The +tendency to diffused activity of involuntary muscle is well illustrated by +the contraction of the bladder associated with detumescence. While this +occurs in both sexes, in men erection produces a mechanical impediment to +any evacuation of the bladder. In women there is not only a desire to +urinate but, occasionally, actual urination. Many quite healthy and normal +women have, as a rare accident supervening on the coincidence of an +unusually full bladder with an unusual degree of sexual excitement, +experienced a powerful and quite involuntary evacuation of the bladder at +the moment of orgasm. In women with less normal nervous systems this has, +more rarely, been almost habitual. Brantôme has perhaps recorded the +earliest case of this kind in referring to a lady he knew who "quand on +lui faisait cela elle se compissait à bon escient."[115] The tendency to +trembling, constriction of throat, sneezing, emission of internal gas, and +the other similar phenomena occasionally associated with detumescence, are +likewise due to diffusion of the motor disturbance. Even in infancy the +motor signs of sexual excitement are the most obvious indications of +orgasm; thus West, describing masturbation in a child of six or nine +months who practiced thigh-rubbing, states that when sitting in her high +chair she would grasp the handles, stiffen herself, and stare, rubbing her +thighs quickly together several times, and then come to herself with a +sigh, tired, relaxed, and sweating, these seizures, which lasted one or +two minutes, being mistaken by the relations for epileptic fits.[116] + + The essentially motor character of detumescence is well shown by + the extreme forms of erotic intoxication which sometimes appear + as the result of sexual excitement. Féré, who has especially + called attention to the various manifestations of this condition, + presents an instructive case of a man of neurotic heredity and + antecedents, in whom it occasionally happened that sexual + excitement, instead of culminating in the normal orgasm, attained + its climax in a fit of uncontrollable muscular excitement. He + would then sing, dance, gesticulate, roughly treat his partner, + break the objects around him, and finally sink down exhausted and + stupefied. (Féré, _L'Instinct Sexuel_, Chapter X.) In such a case + a diffused and general detumescence has taken the place of the + normal detumescence which has its main focus in the sexual + sphere. + + The same relationship is shown in a case of impotence accompanied + by cramps in the calves and elsewhere, which has been recorded by + Brügelmann ("Zur Lehre vom Perversen Sexualismus," _Zeitschrift + für Hypnotismus_, 1900, Heft I). These muscular conditions ceased + for several days whenever coitus was effected. + + An instructive analogy to the motor irradiations preceding the + moment of sexual detumescence may be found in the somewhat + similar motor irradiations which follow the delayed expulsion of + a highly distended bladder. These sometimes become very marked in + a child or young woman unable to control the motor system + absolutely. The legs are crossed, the foot swung, the thighs + tightly pressed together, the toes curled. The fingers are flexed + in rhythmic succession. The whole body slowly twists as though + the seat had become uncomfortable. It is difficult to concentrate + the mind; the same remark may be automatically repeated; the eyes + search restlessly, and there is a tendency to count surrounding + objects or patterns. When the extreme degree of tension is + reached it is only by executing a kind of dance that the + explosive contraction of the bladder is restrained. + + The picture of muscular irradiation presented under these + circumstances differs but slightly from that of the onset of + detumescence. In one case the explosion is sought, in the other + case it is dreaded; but in both cases there is a retarded + muscular tension,--in the one case involuntary, in the other case + voluntary--maintained at a point of acute intensity, and in both + cases the muscular irradiations of this tension spread over the + whole body. + + The increased motor irritability of the state of detumescence + somewhat resembles the conditions produced by a weak anæsthetic + and there is some interest in noting the sexual excitement liable + to occur in anæsthesia. I am indebted to Dr. J.F.W. Silk for some + remarks on this point:-- + + "I. Sexual emotions may apparently be aroused during the stage of + excitement preceding or following the administration of any + anæsthetic; these emotions may take the form of mere delirious + utterances, or may be associated with what is apparently a sexual + orgasm. Or reflex phenomena connected with the sexual organs may + occasionally be observed under special circumstances; or, to put + it in another way, such reflex possibilities are not always + abolished by the condition of narcosis or anæsthesia. + + "II. Of the particular anæsthetics employed I am inclined to + think that the possibility of such conditions arising is + inversely proportionate to their strength, e.g., they are more + frequently observed with a weak anæsthetic like nitrous oxide + than with chloroform. + + "III. Sexual emotions I believe to be rarely observable in men, + and this is remarkable, or, I should say, particularly + noticeable, for the presence of nurses, female students, etc., + might almost have led one to expect that the contrary would have + been the case. On the other hand, it is among men that I have + frequently observed a reflex phenomenon which has usually taken + the shape of an erection of the penis when the structures in the + neighborhood of the spermatic cord have been handled. + + "IV. Among females the emotional sexual phenomena most frequently + obtrude themselves, and I believe that if it were possible to + induce people to relate their dreams they would very often be + found to be of a sexual character." + +Much more important than the general motor phenomena, more purposive +though involuntary, are the specifically sexual muscular movements. From +the very beginning of detumescence, indeed, muscular activity makes itself +felt, and the peripheral muscles of sex act, according to Kobelt's +expression, as a peripheral sexual heart. In the male these movements are +fairly obvious and fairly simple. It is required that the semen should be +expressed from the vesiculæ seminales, propelled along the urethra, in +combination with the prostatic fluid which is equally essential, and +finally ejected with a certain amount of force from the urethral orifice. +Under the influence of the stimulation furnished by the contact and +friction of the vagina, this process is effectively carried out, mainly by +the rhythmic contractions of the bulbo-cavernosus muscle, and the semen is +emitted in a jet which may be ejaculated to a distance varying from a few +centimeters to a meter or more. + + With regard to the details of the psychic sides of this process a + correspondent, a psychologist, writes as follows:-- + + "I have never noticed in my reading any attempt to analyze the + sensations which accompany the orgasm, and, as I have made a good + many attempts to make such an analysis myself, I will append the + results on the chance that they may be of some value. I have + checked my results so far as possible by comparing them with the + experience of such of my friends as had coitus frequently and + were willing to tell me as much as they could of the psychology + of the process. + + "The first fact that I hit upon was the importance of pressure. + As one of my informants picturesquely phrases it--'the tighter + the fit the greater the pleasure.' This agrees, too, with their + unanimous testimony that the pleasurable sensations were much + greater when the orgasm occurred simultaneously in the man and + woman. Their analysis seldom went further than this, but a few + remarked that the distinctive sensations accompanying the orgasm + seem to begin near the root of the penis or in the testes, and + that they are qualitatively different from the tickling + sensations which precede them. + + "These tickling sensations are caused, I think, by the friction + of the glands against the vaginal walls, and are supplemented by + other sensations from the urethra, whose nerves are stimulated by + pressure of the vaginal walls and sphincter. The specific + sensation of the orgasm begins, I believe, with a strong + contraction of the muscles of the urethral walls along the entire + length of the canal, and is felt as a peculiar ache starting + from the base of the penis and quickly becoming diffused through + the whole organ. This sensation reaches its climax with the + expulsion of the semen into the urethra and the consequent + feeling of distention, which is instantly followed by the + rhythmic peristaltic contractions of the urethral muscles which + mark the climax of the orgasm. + + "The most careful introspection possible under the circumstances + seems to show that these sensations arise almost wholly from the + urethra and in a far less degree from the corona. During periods + of great sexual excitement the nerves of the urethra and corona + seem to possess a peculiar sensitivity and are powerfully + stimulated by the violent peristaltic contractions of the muscles + in the urethral walls during ejaculation. It seems possible that + the intensity and volume of sensation felt at the glans may be + due in part to the greater area of sensitive surface presented in + the fossa as well as to the sensitivity of the corona, and in + part to the fact that during the orgasm the glans is more highly + congested than at any other time, and the nerve endings thus + subjected to additional pressure. + + "If the foregoing statements are true, it is easy to see why the + pleasure of the man is much increased when the orgasm occurs at + the same time in his partner and himself, for the contractions of + the vagina upon the penis would increase the stimulation of all + the nerve endings in that organ for which a mechanical stimulus + is adequate, and the prominence of the corpus spongiosum and + corona would ensure them the greatest stimulation. It seems not + improbable that the specific sensation of orgasm rises from the + stimulation of the peculiar form of nerve end-bulbs which Krause + found in the corpus spongiosum and in the glans. + + "The characteristic massiveness of the experience is probably due + largely to the great number of sensations of strain and pressure + caused by the powerful reflex contraction of so many of the + voluntary muscles. + + "Of course, the foregoing analysis is purely tentative, and I + offer it only on the chance that it may suggest some line of + inquiry which may lead to results of value to the student of + sexual psychology." + + In man the whole process of detumescence, when it has once really + begun, only occupies a few moments. It is so likewise in many + animals; in the genera Bos, Ovis, etc., it is very short, almost + instantaneous, and rather short also in the Equidæ (in a vigorous + stallion, according to Colin, ten to twelve seconds). As + Disselhorst has pointed out, this is dependent on the fact that + these animals, like man, possess a vas deferens which broadens + into an ampulla serving as a receptacle which holds the semen + ready for instant emission when required. On the other hand, in + the dog, cat, boar, and the Canidæ, Felidæ, and Suidæ generally, + there is no receptacle of this kind, and coitus is slow, since a + longer time is required for the peristaltic action of the vas to + bring the semen to the urogenital sinus. (R. Disselhorst, _Die + Accessorischen Geschlechtsdrusen der Wirbelthiere_, 1897, p. + 212.) + + In man there can be little doubt that detumescence is more + rapidly accomplished in the European than in the East, in India, + among the yellow races, or in Polynesia. This is probably in part + due to a deliberate attempt to prolong the act in the East, and + in part to a greater nervous erethism among Westerns. + +In the woman the specifically sexual muscular process is less visible, +more obscure, more complex, and uncertain. Before detumescence actually +begins there are at intervals involuntary rhythmic contractions of the +walls of the vagina, seeming to have the object of at once stimulating and +harmonizing with those that are about to begin in the male organ. It would +appear that these rhythmic contractions are the exaggeration of a +phenomenon which is normal, just as slight contraction is normal and +constant in the bladder. Jastreboff has shown, in the rabbit, that the +vagina is in constant spontaneous rhythmic contraction from above +downward, not peristaltic, but in segments, the intensity of the +contractions increasing with age and especially with sexual development. +This vaginal contraction which in women only becomes well marked just +before detumescence, and is due mainly to the action of the sphincter +cunni (analogous to the bulbo-cavernosus in the male), is only a part of +the localized muscular process. At first there would appear to be a reflex +peristaltic movement of the Fallopian tubes and uterus. Dembo observed +that in animals stimulation of the upper anterior wall of the vagina +caused gradual contraction of the uterus, which is erected by powerful +contraction of its muscular fiber and round ligaments while at the same +time it descends toward the vagina, its cavity becoming more and more +diminished and mucus being forced out. In relaxing, Aristotle long ago +remarked, it aspirates the seminal fluid. + +Although the active participation of the sexual organs in woman, to the +end of directing the semen into the womb at the moment of detumescence, is +thus a very ancient belief, and harmonizes with the Greek view of the womb +as an animal in the body endowed with a considerable amount of +activity,[117] precise observation in modern times has offered but little +confirmation of the reality of this participation. Such observations as +have been made have usually been the accidental result of sexual +excitement and orgasm occurring during a gynæcological examination. As, +however, such a result is liable to occur in erotic subjects, a certain +number of precise observations have accumulated during the past century. +So far as the evidence goes, it would seem that in women, as in mares, +bitches, and other animals, the uterus becomes shorter, broader, and +softer during the orgasm, at the same time descending lower into the +pelvis, with its mouth open intermittently, so that, as one writer +remarks, spontaneously recurring to the simile which commended itself to +the Greeks, "the uterus might be likened to an animal gasping for +breath."[118] This sensitive, responsive mobility of the uterus is, +indeed, not confined to the moment of detumescence, but may occur at other +times under the influence of sexual emotion. + +It would seem probable that in this erection, contraction, and descent of +the uterus, and its simultaneous expulsion of mucus, we have the decisive +moment in the completion of detumescence in woman, and it is probable that +the thick mucus, unlike the earlier more limpid secretion, which women are +sometimes aware of after orgasm, is emitted from the womb at this time. +This is, however, not absolutely certain. Some authorities regard +detumescence in women as accomplished in the pouring out of secretions, +others in the rhythmic genital contractions; the sexual parts may, +however, be copiously bathed in mucus for an indefinitely long period +before the final stage of detumescence is achieved, and the rhythmic +contractions are also taking place at a somewhat early period; in neither +respect is there any obvious increase at the final moment of orgasm. In +women this would seem to be more conspicuously a nervous manifestation +than in men. On the subjective side it is very pronounced, with its +feeling of relieved tension and agreeable repose--a moment when, as one +woman expresses it, together with intense pleasure, there is, as it were, +a floating up into a higher sphere, like the beginning of chloroform +narcosis--but on the objective side this culminating moment is less easy +to define. + + Various observations and remarks made during the past two or + three centuries by Bond, Valisneri, Dionis, Haller, Günther, and + Bischoff, tending to show a sucking action of the uterus in both + women and other female animals, have been brought together by + Litzmann in R. Wagner's _Handwörterbuch der Physiologie_ (1846, + vol. iii, p. 53). Litzmann added an experience of his own: "I had + an opportunity lately, while examining a young and very erethic + woman, to observe how suddenly the uterus assumed a more erect + position, and descended deeper in the pelvis; the lips of the + womb became equal in length, the cervix rounded, softer, and more + easily reached by the finger, and at the same time a high state + of sexual excitement was revealed by the respiration and voice." + + The general belief still remained, however, that the woman's part + in conjugation is passive, and that it is entirely by the energy + of the male organ and of the male sexual elements, the + spermatozoa, that conjunction with the germ cell is attained. + According to this theory, it was believed that the spermatozoa + were, as Wilkinson expresses it, in a history of opinion on this + question, "endowed with some sort of intuition or instinct; that + they would turn in the direction of the os uteri, wading through + the acid mucus of the vagina; travel patiently upward and around + the vaginal portion of the uterus; enter the uterus and proceed + onward in search of the waiting ovum." (A.D. Wilkinson, + "Sterility in the Female," _Transactions of the Lincoln Medical + Society_, Nebraska, 1896.) + + About the year 1859 Fichstedt seems to have done something to + overthrow this theory by declaring his belief that the uterus was + not, as commonly supposed, a passive organ in coitus, but was + capable of sucking in the semen during the brief period of + detumescence. Various authorities then began to bring forward + arguments and observations in the same sense. Wernich, + especially, directed attention to this point in 1872 in a paper + on the erectile properties of the lower segment of the uterus + ("Die Erectionsfahigkeit des untern Uterus-Abschnitts," _Beiträge + zur Geburtshülfe und Gynäkologie_, vol. i, p. 296). He made + precise observations and came to the conclusion that owing to + erectile properties in the neck of the uterus, this part of the + womb elongates during congress and reaches down into the pelvis + with an aspiratory movement, as if to meet the glans of the male. + A little later, in a case of partial prolapse, Beck, in ignorance + of Wernich's theory, was enabled to make a very precise + observation of the action of the uterus during excitement. In + this case the woman was sexually very excitable even under + ordinary examination, and Beck carefully noted the phenomena that + took place during the orgasm. "The os and cervix uteri," he + states, "had been about as firm as usual, moderately hard and, + generally speaking, in a natural and normal condition, with the + external os closed to such an extent as to admit of the uterine + probe with difficulty; but the instant that the height of + excitement was at hand, the os opened itself to the extent of + fully an inch, as nearly as my eye can judge, made five or six + successive gasps as if it were drawing the external os into the + cervix, each time powerfully, and, it seemed to me, with a + regular rhythmical action, at the same time losing its former + density and hardness and becoming quite soft to the touch. Upon + the cessation of the action, as related, the os suddenly closed, + the cervix again hardened itself, and the intense congestion was + dissipated." (J.R. Beck, "How do the Spermatozoa Enter the + Uterus?" _American Journal of Obstetrics_, 1874.) It would appear + that in the early part of this final process of detumescence the + action of the uterus is mainly one of contraction and ejaculation + of any mucus that may be contained; Dr. Paul Mundé has described + "the gushing, almost in jets," of this mucus which he has + observed in an erotic woman under a rather long digital and + specular examination. (_American Journal of Obstetrics_, 1893.) + It is during the latter part of detumescence, it would seem, and + perhaps for a short time after the orgasm is over, that the + action of the uterus is mainly aspiratory. + +While the active part played by the womb in detumescence can no longer be +questioned, it need not too hastily be assumed that the belief in the +active movements of the spermatozoa must therefore be denied. The vigorous +motility of the tadpole-like organisms is obvious to anyone who has ever +seen fresh semen under the microscope; and if it is correct, as Clifton +Edgar states, that the spermatozoa may retain their full activity in the +female organs for at least seventeen days, they have ample time to exert +their energies. The fact that impregnation sometimes occurs without +rupture of the hymen is not decisive evidence that there has been no +penetration, as the hymen may dilate without rupturing; but there seems no +reason to doubt that conception has sometimes taken place when ejaculation +has occurred without penetration; this is indicated in a fairly objective +manner when, as has been occasionally observed, conception has occurred in +women whose vaginas were so narrow as scarcely to admit the entrance of a +goose-quill; such was the condition in the case of a pregnant woman +brought forward by Roubaud. The stories, repeated in various books, of +women who have conceived after homosexual relations with partners who had +just left their husbands' beds are not therefore inherently +impossible.[119] Janke quotes numerous cases in which there has been +impregnation in virgins who have merely allowed the penis to be placed in +contact with the vulva, the hymen remaining unruptured until +delivery.[120] + +It must be added, however, that even if the semen is effused merely at the +mouth of the vagina, without actual penetration, the spermatozoa are still +not entirely without any resource save their own motility in the task of +reaching the ovum. As we have seen, it is not only the uterus which takes +an active part in detumescence; the vagina also is in active movement, and +it seems highly probable that, at all events in some women and under some +circumstances, such movement favoring aspiration toward the womb may be +communicated to the external mouth of the vagina. + + Riolan (_Anthropographia_, 1626, p. 294) referred to the + constriction and dilation of the vulva under the influence of + sexual excitement. It is said that in Abyssinia women can, when + adopting the straddling posture of coitus, by the movements of + their own vaginal muscles alone, grasp the male organ and cause + ejaculation, although the man remains passive. According to + Lorion the Annamites, adopting the normal posture of coitus, + introduce the penis when flaccid or only half erect, the + contraction of the vaginal walls completing the process; the + penis is very small in this people. It is recognized by + gynæcologists that the condition of vaginismus, in which there is + spasmodic contraction of the vagina, making intercourse painful + or impossible, is but a morbid exaggeration of the normal + contraction which occurs in sexual excitement. Even in the + absence of sexual excitement there is a vague affection, + occurring in both married and unmarried women, and not, it would + seem, necessarily hysterical, characterized by quivering or + twitching of the vulva; I am told that this is popularly termed + "flackering of the shape" in Yorkshire and "taittering of the + lips" in Ireland. It may be added that quivering of the gluteal + muscles also takes place during detumescence, and that in Indian + medicine this is likewise regarded as a sign of sexual desire in + women, apart from coitus. + + A non-medical correspondent in Australia, W.J. Chidley, from whom + I have received many communications on this subject, is strongly + of opinion from his own observations that not only does the + uterus take an active part in coitus, but that under natural + conditions the vagina also plays an active part in the process. + He was led to suspect such an action many years ago, as well by + an experience of his own, as also by hearing from a young woman + who met her lover after a long absence that by the excitement + thus aroused a tape attached to the underclothes had been drawn + into the vagina. Since then the confidences of various friends, + together with observations of animals, have confirmed him in the + view that the general belief that coitus must be effected by + forcible entry of the male organ into a passive vagina is + incorrect. He considers that under normal circumstances coitus + should take place but rarely, and then only under the most + favorable circumstances, perhaps exclusively in spring, and, most + especially, only when the woman is ready for it. Then, when in + the arms of the man she loves, the vagina, in sympathy with the + active movements of the womb, becomes distended at the touch of + the turgescent, but not fully erect, penis, "flashes open and + draws in the male organ." "All animals," he adds, "have sexual + intercourse by the male organ being _drawn_, not forced, into the + female. I have been borne out in this by friends who have seen + horses, camels, mules and other large animals in the coupling + season. What is more absurd, for instance, than to say that an + entire _penetrates_ the mare? His penis is a sensitive, beautiful + piece of mechanism, which brings its light head here and there + till it touches the right spot, when the mare, _if ready_, takes + it in. An entire's penis could not penetrate anything; it is a + curve, a beautiful curve which would easily bend. A bull's, + again, is turned down at the end and, more palpably still, would + fold on itself if pressed with force. The womb and vagina of a + beautiful and healthy woman constitute a living, vital, moving + organ, sensitive to a look, a word, a thought, a hand on the + waist." + + A well-known American author thus writes in confirmation of the + foregoing view: "In nature the woman wooes. When impassioned her + vagina becomes erect and dilated, and so lubricated with abundant + mucus to the lips that entrance is easy. This dilatation and + erectile expansion of vagina withdraws the hymen so close to the + walls that penetration need not tear it or cause pain. The more + muscular, primitive and healthy the woman the tougher and less + sensitive the hymen, and the less likely to break or bleed. I + think one great function of the foreskin also is to moisten the + glans, so that it can be lubricated for entrance, and then to + retract, moist side out, to make entrance still easier. I think + that in nature the glans penetrates within the labia, is + withstood a moment, vibrating, and then all resistance is + withdrawn by a sudden 'flashing open' of the gates, permitting + easy entrance, and that the sudden giving up of resistance, and + substitution of welcome, with its instantaneous deep entrance, + causes an almost immediate male orgasm (the thrill being + irresistibly exciting). Certainly this is the process as observed + in horses, cattle, goats, etc., and it seems likely something + analogous is natural in man." + + While it is easily possible to carry to excess a view which would + make the woman rather than the man the active agent in coitus + (and it may be recalled that in the Cebidæ the penis, as also the + clitoris, is furnished with a bone), there is probably an element + of truth in the belief that the vagina shares in the active part + which, there can now be little doubt, is played by the uterus in + detumescence. Such a view certainly enables us to understand how + it is that semen effused on the exterior sexual organs can be + conveyed to the uterus. + + It was indeed the failure to understand the vital activity of the + semen and the feminine genital canal, co-operating together + towards the junction of sperm cell and germ cell, which for so + long stood in the way of the proper understanding of conception. + Even the genius of Harvey, which had grappled successfully with + the problem of the circulation, failed in the attempt to + comprehend the problem of generation. Mainly on account of this + difficulty, he was unable to see how the male element could + possibly enter the uterus, although he devoted much observation + and study to the question. Writing of the uterus of the doe after + copulation, he says: "I began to doubt, to ask myself whether the + semen of the male could by any possibility make its way by + attraction or injection to the seat of conception, and repeated + examination led me to the conclusion that none of the semen + reached this seat." (_De-Generatione Animalium_, Exercise lxvii.) + "The woman," he finally concluded, "after contact with the + spermatic fluid _in coitu_, seems to receive an influence and + become fecundated without the co-operation of any sensible + corporeal agent, in the same way as iron touched by the magnet is + endowed with its powers." + +Although the specifically sexual muscular process of detumescence in +women--as distinguished from the general muscular phenomena of sexual +excitement which may be fairly obvious--is thus seen to be somewhat +complex and obscure, in women as well as in men detumescence is a +convulsion which discharges a slowly accumulated store of nervous force. +In women also, as in men, the motor discharge is directed to a specific +end--the intromission of the semen in the one sex, its reception in the +other. In both sexes the sexual orgasm and the pleasure and satisfaction +associated with it, involve, as their most essential element, the motor +activity of the sexual sphere.[121] + + The active co-operation of the female organs in detumescence is + probably indicated by the difficulty which is experienced in + achieving conception by the artificial injection of semen. Marion + Sims stated in 1866, in _Clinical Notes on Uterine Surgery_, that + in 55 injections in six women he had only once been successful; + he believed that that was the only case at that time on record. + Jacobi had, however, practiced artificial fecundation in animals + (in 1700) and John Hunter in man. See Gould and Pyle, _Anomalies + and Curiosities of Medicine_, p. 43; also Janke (_Die + Willkürliche Hervorbringen des Geschlechts_, pp. 230 et seq.) who + discusses the question of artificial fecundation and brings + together a mass of data. + +The facial expression when tumescence is completed is marked by a high +degree of energy in men and of loveliness in women. At this moment, when +the culminating act of life is about to be accomplished, the individual +thus reaches his supreme state of radiant beauty. The color is heightened, +the eyes are larger and brighter, the facial muscles are more tense, so +that in mature individuals any wrinkles disappear and youthfulness +returns. + +At the beginning of detumescence the features are frequently more +discomposed. There is a general expression of eager receptivity to sensory +impressions. The dilatation of the pupils, the expansion of the nostrils, +the tendency to salivation and to movements of the tongue, all go to make +up a picture which indicates an approaching gratification of sensory +desires; it is significant that in some animals there is at this moment +erection of the ears.[122] There is sometimes a tendency to utter broken +and meaningless words, and it is noted that sometimes women have called +out on their mothers.[123] The dilatation of the pupils produces +photophobia, and in the course of detumescence the eyes are frequently +closed from this cause. At the beginning of sexual excitement, Vaschide +and Vurpas have observed, tonicity of the eye-muscles seems to increase; +the elevators of the upper lids contract, so that the eyes look larger and +their mobility and brightness are heightened; with the increase of +muscular tonicity strabismus occurs, owing to the greater strength of the +muscles that carry the eyes inward.[124] + + The facial expression which marks the culmination of tumescence, + and the approach of detumescence is that which is generally + expressive of joy. In an interesting psycho-physical study of the + emotion of joy, Dearborn thus summarizes its characteristics: + "The eyes are brighter and the upper eyelid elevated, as also are + the brows, the skin over the glabella, the upper lip and the + corners of the mouth, while the skin at the outer canthi of the + eye is puckered. The nostrils are moderately dilated, the tongue + slightly extended and the cheeks somewhat expanded, while in + persons with largely developed pinnal muscles the ears tend + somewhat to incline forwards. The whole arterial system is + dilated, with consequent blushing from this effect on the dermal + capillaries of the face, neck, scalp and hands, and sometimes + more extensively even; from the same cause the eyes slightly + bulge. The whole glandular system likewise is stimulated, causing + the secretions,--gastric, salivary, lachrymal, sudoral, mammary, + genital, etc.--to be increased, with the resulting rise of + temperature and increase in the katobolism generally. Volubility + is almost regularly increased, and is, indeed, one of the most + sensitive and constant of the correlations in emotional + delight.... Pleasantness is correlated in living organisms by + vascular, muscular and glandular extension or expansion, both + literal and figurative." (G. Dearborn, "The Emotion of Joy," + _Psychological Review Monograph Supplements_, vol. ii, No. 5, p. + 62.) All these signs of joy appear to occur at some stage of the + process of sexual excitement. + + In some monkeys it would seem that the muscular movement which in + man has become the smile is the characteristic facial expression + of sexual tumescence or courtship. Discussing the facial + expression of pleasure in children, S.S. Buckman has the + following remarks: "There is one point in such expression which + has not received due consideration, namely, the raising of lumps + of flesh each side of the nose as an indication of pleasure. + Accompanying this may be seen small furrows, both in children and + adults, running from the eyes somewhat obliquely towards the + nose. What these characters indicate may be learned from the male + mandril, whose face, particularly in the breeding season, shows + colored fleshy prominences each side of the nose, with + conspicuous furrows and ridges. In the male mandril these + characters have been developed because, being an unmistakable + sign of sexual ardor, they gave the female particular evidence of + sexual feelings. Thus such characters would come to be recognized + as habitually symptomatic of pleasurable feelings. Finding + similar features in human beings, and particularly in children, + though not developed in the same degree, we may assume that in + our monkey-like ancestors facial characters similar to those of + the mandril were developed, though to a less extent, and that + they were symptomatic of pleasure, because connected with the + period of courtship. Then they became conventionalized as + pleasurable symptoms." (S.S. Buckmann, "Human Babies: What They + Teach," _Nature_, July 5, 1900.) If this view is accepted, it may + be said that the smile, having in man become a generalized sign + of amiability, has no longer any special sexual significance. It + is true that a faint and involuntary smile is often associated + with the later stages of tumescence, but this is usually lost + during detumescence, and may even give place to an expression of + ferocity. + +When we have realized how profound is the organic convulsion involved by +the process of detumescence, and how great the general motor excitement +involved, we can understand how it is that very serious effects may follow +coitus. Even in animals this is sometimes the case. Young bulls and +stallions have fallen in a faint after the first congress; boars may be +seriously affected in a similar way; mares have been known even to fall +dead.[125] In the human species, and especially in men--probably, as Bryan +Robinson remarks, because women are protected by the greater slowness with +which detumescence occurs in them--not only death itself, but innumerable +disorders and accidents have been known to follow immediately after +coitus, these results being mainly due to the vascular and muscular +excitement involved by the processes of detumescence. Fainting, vomiting, +urination, defæcation have been noted as occurring in young men after a +first coitus. Epilepsy has been not infrequently recorded. Lesions of +various organs, even rupture of the spleen, have sometimes taken place. In +men of mature age the arteries have at times been unable to resist the +high blood-pressure, and cerebral hæmorrhage with paralysis has occurred. +In elderly men the excitement of intercourse with strange women has +sometimes caused death, and various cases are known of eminent persons who +have thus died in the arms of young wives or of prostitutes.[126] + +These morbid results, are, however, very exceptional. They usually occur +in persons who are abnormally sensitive, or who have imprudently +transgressed the obvious rules of sexual hygiene. Detumescence is so +profoundly natural a process; it is so deeply and intimately a function of +the organism, that it is frequently harmless even when the bodily +condition is far from absolutely sound. Its usual results, under favorable +circumstances, are entirely beneficial. In men there normally supervenes, +together with the relief from the prolonged tension of tumescence, with +the muscular repose and falling blood-pressure,[127] a sense of profound +satisfaction, a glow of diffused well-being,[128] perhaps an agreeable +lassitude, occasionally also a sense of mental liberation from an +overmastering obsession. Under reasonably happy circumstances there is no +pain, or exhaustion, or sadness, or emotional revulsion. The happy lover's +attitude toward his partner is not expressed by the well-known Sonnet +(CXXIX) of Shakespeare:-- + + "Past reason hunted, and no sooner had + Past reason hated." + +He feels rather with Boccaccio that the kissed mouth loses not its charm, + + "Bocca baciata non perde ventura." + +In women the results of detumescence are the same, except that the +tendency to lassitude is not marked unless the act has been several times +repeated; there is a sensation of repose and self-assurance, and often an +accession of free and joyous energy. After completely satisfactory +detumescence she may experience a feeling as of intoxication, lasting for +several hours, an intoxication that is followed by no evil reaction. + +Such, so far as our present vague and imperfect knowledge extends, are the +main features in the process of detumescence. In the future, without +doubt, we shall learn to know more precisely a process which has been so +supremely important in the life of man and of his ancestors. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[98] The elements furnished by the sense of touch in sexual selection have +been discussed in the first section of the previous volume of these +_Studies_. + +[99] See Appendix A. "The Origins of the Kiss," in the previous volume. + +[100] See, e.g., Art. "Erection," by Retterer, in Richet's _Dictionnaire +de Physiologie_, vol. v. + +[101] Guibaut, _Traité Clinique des Maladies des Femmes_, p. 242. Adler +discusses the sexual secretions in women and their significance, _Die +Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, pp. 19-26. + +[102] In some parts of the world this is further aided by artificial +means. Thus it is stated by Riedel (as quoted by Ploss and Bartels) that +in the Gorong Archipelago the bridegroom, before the first coitus, anoints +the bride's pudenda with an ointment containing opium, musk, etc. I have +been told of an English bride who was instructed by her mother to use a +candle for the same purpose. + +[103] _Parthenologia_, pp. 302, et seq. + +[104] The connection of this mucous flow with sexual emotion was discussed +early in the eighteenth century by Schurig in his _Gynæcologia_, pp. 8-11; +it is frequently passed over by more modern writers. + +[105] The drawing is reproduced by Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, +Chapter XVII; many facts bearing on the ethnography of coitus are brought +together in this chapter. + +[106] Onanoff (Paris Société de Biologie, May 3, 1890) proposed the name +of bulbo-cavernous reflex for the smart contraction of the ischio-and +bulbo-cavernosus muscles (erector penis and accelerator urinæ) produced by +mechanical excitation of the glans. This reflex is clinically elicited by +placing the index-finger of the left hand on the region of the bulb while +the right hand rapidly rubs the dorsal surface of the glands with the edge +of a piece of paper or lightly pinches the mucous membrane; a twitching of +the region of the bulb is then perceived. This reflex is always present in +healthy adult subjects and indicates the integrity of the physical +mechanism of detumescence. It has been described by Hughes. (C.H. Hughes, +"The Virile or Bulbo-cavernous Reflex," _Alienist and Neurologist_, +January, 1898.) + +[107] Roubaud, _Traité de l'Impuissance_, 1855, p. 39. + +[108] _Das Weib_, seventh edition, vol. i, p. 510. + +[109] The influence of impeded respiration in exciting more or less +perverted forms of sexual gratification has been discussed in a section of +"Love and Pain" in the third volume of these _Studies_. + +[110] See, e.g., the experiments of Obici on this point, _Revista +Sperimentale di Freniatria_, 1903, pp. 689, et seq. + +[111] Summarized in _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, March, 1903, p. +188. The tendency to closure of the eyes noted by Roubaud, to avoid +contact of the light, indicates dilatation of the pupils, for which we +need not seek other explanation than the general tendency of all +peripheral stimulation, according to Schiff's law, to produce such +dilatation. + +[112] Vaschide and Vurpas, "Du Coefficient Sexuel de l'Impulsion +Musicale," _Archives de Neurologie_, May, 1904. + +[113] In the _Priapeia_ is an inscription which has thus been +translated:-- + + "You see this organ, after which I'm called + And which is my certificate, is humid; + This moisture is not dew nor drops of rain, + It is the outcome of sweet memory, + Recalling thoughts of a complacent maid." + +The translator supposes that semen is referred to, but without doubt the +allusion is to the theologians' _distillatio_. + +[114] A woman of 30, normal and intelligent, after conversing on love and +passion, and then listening to the music of Grieg and Schumann, felt real +and strong sexual excitement, increased by memories recalled by the +presence of a sympathetic person. When then tested by the dynamometer the +average of ten efforts with the right hand was found to be 28.2 (her +normal average being 31.1) and with the left hand 28.0 (the normal being +30.0). There was, however, great variability in the individual pressures +which sometimes equaled and even exceeded the subject's normal efforts. +The voluntary muscles are thus in harmony with the approaching general +sexual avalanche. (Vaschide and Vurpas, "Quelques Données Expérimentales +sur l'Influence de l'Excitation Sexuelle," _Archivio di Psichiatria_, +1903, fasc. v-vi.) + +[115] Cf. MacGillicuddy, _Functional Disorders of the Nervous System in +Women_, p. 110; Féré, _L'Instinct Sexuel_, second edition, p. 238; id., +"Note sur une Anomalie de l'instinct Sexuel," _Belgique Médicale_, 1905; +also "Analysis of the Sexual Impulse," in an earlier volume of these +_Studies_. + +[116] J.P. West, "Masturbation in Early Childhood," _Medical Standard_, +November, 1895. + +[117] Cf. the discussion of hysteria in "Auto-Erotism," vol. i of these +_Studies_. + +[118] Hirst, _Text-Book of Obstetrics_, 1899, p. 67. + +[119] The earliest story of the kind with which I am acquainted, that of a +widow who was thus impregnated by a married friend, is quoted in Schurig's +_Spermatologia_ (p. 224) from Amatus Lusitanus, _Curationum Centuriæ +Septum_, 1629. + +[120] Janke, _Die Willkürliche Hervorbringen des Geschlechts_, p. 238. + +[121] Cf. Adler, _Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, pp. +29-38. + +[122] Féré, _Pathologie des Emotions_, p. 51. + +[123] This is an instinctive impulse under all strong emotion in primitive +persons. "The Australian Dieri," says A.W. Howitt (_Journal +Anthropological Institute_, August, 1890), "when in pain or grief cry out +for their father or mother." + +[124] Vaschide and Vurpas, _Archives de Neurologie_, May, 1904. + +[125] F.B. Robinson, _New York Medical Journal_, March 11, 1893. + +[126] Féré deals fully with the various morbid results which may follow +coitus, _L' Instinct Sexuel_, Chapter X; id., _Pathologie des Emotions_, +p. 99. + +[127] With regard to the relationship of detumescence to the +blood-pressure Haig remarks: "I think that as the sexual act produces low +and falling blood-pressure, it will of necessity relieve conditions which +are due to high and rising blood-pressure, such, for instance, as mental +depression and bad temper; and, unless my observation deceives me, we have +here a connection between conditions of high blood-pressure, with mental +and bodily depression, and the act of masturbation, for this act will +relieve those conditions, and will tend to be practiced for this purpose." +(A. Haig, _Uric Acid_, sixth edition, p. 154.) + +[128] A medical correspondent speaks of subjective feelings of temperature +coming over the body from 20 to 24 hours after congress, and marked by +sensations of cooling of body and glow of cheeks. In another case, though +lassitude appears on the second day after congress, the first day after is +marked by a notable increase in mental and physical activity. + + + + +III. + +The Constituents of Semen--Function of the Prostate--The Properties of +Semen--Aphrodisiacs--Alcohol, Opium, etc.--Anaphrodisiacs--The Stimulant +Influence of Semen in Coitus--The Internal Effects of Testicular +Secretions--The Influence of Ovarian Secretion. + + +The germ cell never comes into the sphere of consciousness and cannot +therefore concern us in the psychological study of the phenomena of the +sexual instinct. But it is otherwise with the sperm cell, and the seminal +fluid has a relationship, both direct and indirect, to psychic phenomena +which it is now necessary to discuss. + +While the spermatozoa are formed in the glandular tissue of the testes, +the seminal fluid as finally emitted in detumescence is not a purely +testicular product, but is formed by mixture with the fluids poured out at +or before detumescence by various glands which open into the urethra, and +notably the prostate.[129] This is a purely sexual gland, which in animals +only becomes large and active during the breeding season, and may even be +hardly distinguishable at other times; moreover, if the testes are removed +in infancy, the prostate remains rudimentary, so that during recent years +removal of the testes has been widely advocated and practiced for that +hypertrophy of the prostate which is sometimes a distressing ailment of +old age. It is the prostatic fluid, according to Fürbringer, which imparts +its characteristic odor to semen. It appears, however, to be the main +function of the prostatic fluid to arouse and maintain the motility of the +spermatozoa; before meeting the prostatic fluid the spermatozoa are +motionless; that fluid seems to furnish a thinner medium in which they +for the first time gain their full vitality.[130] + +When at length the semen is ejaculated, it contains various substances +which may be separated from it,[131] and possesses various qualities, some +of which have only lately been investigated, while others have evidently +been known to mankind from a very early period. "When held for some time +in the mouth," remarked John Hunter, "it produces a warmth similar to +spices, which lasts some time."[132] Possibly this fact first suggested +that semen might, when ingested, possess valuable stimulant qualities, a +discovery which has been made by various savages, notably by the +Australian aborigines, who, in many parts of Australia, administer a +potion of semen to dying or feeble members of the tribe.[133] It is +perhaps noteworthy that in Central Africa the testes of the goat are +consumed as an aphrodisiac.[134] In eighteenth century Europe, Schurig, in +his _Spermatologia_, still found it necessary to discuss at considerable +length the possible medical properties of human semen, giving many +prescriptions which contained it.[135] The stimulation produced by the +ingestion of semen would appear to form in some cases a part of the +attraction exerted by _fellatio_; De Sade emphasized this point; and in a +case recorded by Howard semen appears to have acted as a stimulant for +which the craving was as irresistible as is that for alcohol in +dipsomania.[136] + + It must be remembered that the early history of this subject is + more or less inextricably commingled with folk-lore practices of + magical origin, not necessarily founded on actual observation of + the physiological effects of consuming the semen or testes. Thus, + according to W.H. Pearse (_Scalpel_, December, 1897), it is the + custom in Cornwall for country maids to eat the testicles of the + young male lambs when they are castrated in the spring, the + survival, probably, of a very ancient religious cult. (I have not + myself been able to hear of this custom in Cornwall.) In + Burchard's Penitential (Cap. CLIV, Wasserschleben, op. cit., p. + 660) seven years' penance is assigned to the woman who swallows + her husband's semen to make him love her more. In the seventeenth + century (as shown in William Salmon's _London Dispensatory_, + 1678) semen was still considered to be good against witchcraft + and also valuable as a love-philter, in which latter capacity its + use still survives. (Bourke, _Scatalogic Rites_, pp. 343, 355.) + In an earlier age (Picart, quoted by Crawley, _The Mystic Rose_, + p. 109) the Manichæans, it is said, sprinkled their eucharistic + bread with human semen, a custom followed by the Albigenses. + + The belief, perhaps founded in experience, that semen possesses + medical and stimulant virtues was doubtless fortified by the + ancient opinion that the spinal cord is the source of this fluid. + This was not only held by the highest medical authorities in + Greece, but also in India and Persia. + + The semen is thus a natural stimulant, a physiological + aphrodisiac, the type of a class of drugs which have been known + and cultivated in all parts of the world from time immemorial. + (Dufour has discussed the aphrodisiacs used in ancient Rome, + _Histoire de la Prostitution_, vol. II, ch. 21.) It would be vain + to attempt to enumerate all the foods and medicaments to which + has been ascribed an influence in heightening the sexual impulse. + (Thus, in the sixteenth century, aphrodisiacal virtues were + attributed to an immense variety of foods by Liébault in his + _Thresor des Remèdes Secrets pour les Maladies des Femmes_, 1585, + pp. 104, et seq.) A large number of them certainly have no such + effect at all, but have obtained this credit either on some + magical ground or from a mistaken association. Thus the potato, + when first introduced from America, had the reputation of being a + powerful aphrodisiac, and the Elizabethan dramatists contain many + references to this supposed virtue. As we know, potatoes, even + when taken in the largest doses, have not the slightest + aphrodisiac effect, and the Irish peasantry, whose diet consists + very largely of potatoes, are even regarded as possessing an + unusually small measure of sexual feeling. It is probable that + the mistake arose from the fact that potatoes were originally a + luxury, and luxuries frequently tend to be regarded as + aphrodisiacs, since they are consumed under circumstances which + tend to arouse the sexual desires. It is possible also that, as + has been plausibly suggested, the misunderstanding may have been + due to sailors--the first to be familiar with the potato--who + attributed to this particular element of their diet ashore the + generally stimulating qualities of their life in port. The eryngo + (_Eryngium maritimum_), or sea holly, which also had an erotic + reputation in Elizabethan times, may well have acquired it in the + same way. Many other vegetables have a similar reputation, which + they still retain. Thus onions are regarded as aphrodisiacal, and + were so regarded by the Greeks, as we learn from Aristophanes. It + is noteworthy that Marro, a reliable observer, has found that in + Italy, both in prisons and asylums, lascivious people are fond of + onions (_La Pubertà_, p. 297), and it may perhaps be worth while + to recall the observation of Sérieux that in a woman in whom the + sexual instinct only awoke in middle age there was a horror of + leeks. In some countries, and especially in Belgium, celery is + popularly looked upon as a sexual stimulant. Various condiments, + again, have the same reputation, perhaps because they are hot and + because sexual desire is regarded, rightly enough, as a kind of + heat. Fish--skate, for instance, and notably oysters and other + shellfish--are very widely regarded as aphrodisiacs, and Kisch + attributes this property to caviar. It is probable that all these + and other foods which have obtained this reputation, in so far as + they have any action whatever on the sexual appetite, only + possess it by virtue of their generally nutritious and + stimulating qualities, and not by the presence of any special + principle having a selective action on the sexual sphere. A + beefsteak is probably as powerful a sexual stimulant as any food; + a nutritious food, however, which is at the same time easily + digestible, and thus requiring less expenditure of energy for its + absorption, may well exert a specially rapid and conspicuous + stimulant effect. But it is not possible to draw a line, and, as + Aquinas long since said, if we wish to maintain ourselves in a + state of purity we shall fear even an immoderate use of bread and + water. + + More definitely aphrodisiacal effects are produced by drugs, and + especially by drugs which in large doses are poisons. The + aphrodisiac with the widest popular reputation is cantharides, + but its sexually exciting effects are merely an accidental result + of its action in causing inflammation of the genito-urinary + passage, and it is both an uncertain and a dangerous result, + except in skillful hands and when administered in small doses. + Nux vomica (with its alkaloid strychnia), by virtue of its + special action on the spinal cord, has a notably pronounced + effect in heightening the irritability of the spinal ejaculatory + center, though it by no means necessarily exerts any + strengthening influence. Alcohol exerts a sexually exciting + effect, but in a different manner; it produces little stimulation + of the cord and, indeed, even paralyzes the lumbar sexual center + in large doses, but it has an influence on the peripheral + nerve-endings and on the skin, and also on the cerebral centers, + tending to arouse desire and to diminish inhibition. In this + latter way, as Adler remarks, it may, in small doses, under some + circumstances, be beneficial in men with an excessive + nervousness or dread of coitus, and women, in whom orgasm has + been difficult to reach, have frequently found this facilitated + by some previous indulgence in alcohol. The aphrodisiac effect of + alcohol seems specially marked on women. But against the use of + alcohol as an aphrodisiac it must be remembered that it is far + from being a tonic to detumescence, at all events in men, and + that there is much evidence tending to show that not only chronic + alcoholism, but even procreation during intoxication is perilous + to the offspring (see, e.g., Andriezen, _Journal of Mental + Science_, January, 1905, and cf. W.C. Sullivan, "Alcoholism and + Suicidal Impulses," ib., April, 1898, p. 268); it may be added + that Bunge has found a very high proportion of cases of + immoderate use of alcohol in the fathers of women unable to + suckle their infants (G. von Bunge, _Die Zunehmende Unfähigkeit + der Frauen ihre Kinder zu Stillen_, 1903) while even an + approximation to the drunken state is far from being a desirable + prelude to the creation of a new human being. It is obvious that + those who wish, for any reason, to cultivate a strict chastity of + thought and feeling would do well to avoid alcohol altogether, or + only in its lightest forms and in moderation. The aphrodisiacal + effects of wine have long been known; Ovid refers to them (e.g., + _Ars Am._, Bk. III, 765). Clement of Alexandria, who was + something of a man of science as well as a Christian moralist, + points out the influence of wine in producing lasciviousness and + sexual precocity. (_Pædagogus_, Bk. II, Chapter II). Chaucer + makes the Wife of Bath say in the Wife of Bath's Prologue:-- + + "And, after wyn, on Venus moste [needs] I thinke: + For al so siken as cold engendreth hayl, + A likerous mouth moste have a likerous tayl, + In womman vinolent is no defense, + This knowen lechours by experience." + + Alcohol, as Chaucer pointed out, comes to the aid of the man, who + is unscrupulous in his efforts to overcome a woman, and this not + merely by virtue of its aphrodisiacal effects, and the apparently + special influence which it seems to exert on women, but also + because it lulls the mental and emotional characteristics which + are the guardians of personality. A correspondent who has + questioned on this point a number of prostitutes he has known, + writes: "Their accounts of the first fall were nearly always the + same. They got to know a 'gentleman,' and on one occasion they + drank too much; before they quite realized what was happening + they were no longer virgins." "In the mental areas, under the + influence of alcohol," Schmiedeberg remarks (in his _Elements of + Pharmacology_), "the finer degrees of observation, judgment, and + reflection are the first to disappear, while the remaining mental + functions remain in a normal condition. The soldier acts more + boldly because he notices dangers less and reflects over them + less; the orator does not allow himself to be influenced by any + disturbing side-considerations as to his audience, hence he + speaks more freely and spiritedly; self-consciousness is lost to + a very great extent, and many are astounded at the ease with + which they can express their thoughts, and at the acuteness of + their judgment in matters which, when they are perfectly sober, + with difficulty reach their minds; and then afterwards they are + ashamed at their mistakes." + + The action of opium in small doses is also to some extent + aphrodisiacal; it slightly stimulates both the brain and the + spinal cord, and has sensory effects on the skin like alcohol; + these effects are favored by the state of agreeable dreaminess it + produces. In the seventeenth century Venette (_La Génération de + l'Homme_, Part II, Chapter V) strongly recommended small doses of + opium, then little known, for this purpose; he had himself, he + says, in illness experienced its joys, "a shadow of those of + heaven." In India opium (as well as cannabis indica) has long + been a not uncommon aphrodisiac; it is specially used to diminish + local sensibility, delaying the orgasm and thus prolonging the + sexual act. (W.D. Sutherland, "De Impotentia," _Indian Medical + Gazette_, January, 1900). Its more direct and stimulating + influence on the sexual emotions seems indicated by the statement + that prostitutes are found standing outside the opium-smoking + dens of Bombay, but not outside the neighboring liquor shops. + (G.C. Lucas, _Lancet_, February 2, 1884.) Like alcohol, opium + seems to have a marked aphrodisiacal effect on women. The case is + recorded of a mentally deranged girl, with no nymphomania though + she masturbated, who on taking small doses of opium at once + showed signs of nymphomania, following men about, etc. (_American + Journal Obstetrics_, May, 1901, p. 74.) It may well be believed + that opium acts beneficially in men when the ejaculatory centers + are weak but irritable; but its actions are too widespread over + the organism to make it in any degree a valuable aphrodisiac. + Various other drugs have more or less reputation as aphrodisiacs; + thus bromide of gold, a nervous and glandular stimulant, is said + to have as one of its effects a heightening of sexual feeling. + Yohimbin, an alkaloid derived from the West African Yohimbehe + tree, has obtained considerable repute during recent years in the + treatment of impotence; in some cases (see, e.g., Toff's results, + summarized in _British Medical Journal_, February 18, 1905) it + has produced good results, apparently by increasing the blood + supply to the sexual organs, but has not been successful in all + cases or in all hands. It must always be remembered that in cases + of psychical impotence suggestion necessarily exerts a beneficial + influence, and this may work through any drug or merely with the + aid of bread pills. All exercise, often even walking, may be a + sexual stimulant, and it is scarcely necessary to add that + powerful stimulation of the skin in the sexual sphere, and more + especially of the nates, is often a more effective aphrodisiac + than any drug, whether the irritation is purely mechanical, as by + flogging, or mechanico-chemical, as by urtication or the + application of nettles. Among the Malays (with whom both men and + women often use a variety of plants as aphrodisiacs, according to + Vaughan Stevens) Breitenstein states (_21 Jahre in India_, Theil + I, p. 228) that both massage and gymnastics are used to increase + sexual powers. The local application of electricity is one of the + most powerful of aphrodisiacs, and McMordie found on applying one + pole to a uterine sound in the uterus and the other to the + abdominal wall that in the majority of healthy women the orgasm + occurred. + + Among anaphrodisiacs, or sexual sedatives, bromide of potassium, + by virtue of its antidotal relationship to strychnia, is one of + the drugs whose action is most definite, though, while it dulls + sexual desire, it also dulls all the nervous and cerebral + activities. Camphor has an ancient reputation as an + anaphrodisiac, and its use in this respect was known to the Arabs + (as may be seen by a reference to it in the _Perfumed Garden_), + while, as Hyrtl mentions (loc. cit. ii, p. 94), rue (_Ruta + graveolens_) was considered a sexual sedative by the monks of + old, who on this account assiduously cultivated it in their + cloister gardens to make _vinum rutæ_. Recently heroin in large + doses (see, e.g., Becker, _Berliner Klinische Wochenschrift_, + November 23, 1903) has been found to have a useful effect in this + direction. It may be doubted, however, whether there is any + satisfactory and reliable anaphrodisiac. Charcot, indeed, it is + said, used to declare that the only anaphrodisiac in which he had + any confidence was that used by the uncle of Heloïse in the case + of Abelard. "_Cela_ (he would add with a grim smile) _tranche la + difficulte_." + +If semen is a stimulant when ingested, it is easy to suppose that it may +exert a similar action on the woman who receives it into the vagina in +normal sexual congress. It is by no means improbable that, as Mattei +argued in 1878, this is actually the case. It is known that the vagina +possesses considerable absorptive power. Thus Coen and Levi, among others, +have shown that if a tampon soaked in a solution of iodine is introduced +into the vagina, iodine will be found in the urine within an hour. And the +same is true of various other substances.[137] If the vagina absorbs drugs +it probably absorbs semen. Toff, of Braila (Roumania), who attaches much +importance to such absorption, considers that it must be analogous to the +ingestion of organic extractives. It is due to this influence, he +believes, that weak and anæmic girls so often become full-blooded and +robust after marriage, and lose their nervous tendencies and shyness.[138] + +It is, however, most certainly a mistake to suppose that the beneficial +influence of coitus on women is exclusively, or even mainly, dependent +upon the absorption of semen. This is conclusively demonstrated by the +fact that such beneficial influence is exerted, and in full measure, even +when all precautions have been taken to avoid any contact with the semen. +In so far as _coitus reservatus_ or _interruptus_ may lead to haste or +discomfort which prevents satisfactory orgasm on the part of the woman, it +is without doubt a cause of defective detumescence and incomplete +satisfaction. But if orgasm is complete the beneficial effects of coitus +follow even if there has been no possibility of the absorption of semen. +Even after _coitus interruptus_, if it can be prolonged for a period long +enough for the woman to attain full and complete satisfaction, she is +enabled to experience what she may describe as a feeling of intoxication, +lasting for several hours. It is in the action of the orgasm itself, and +the vascular, secretory, and metabolic activities set up by the psychic +and nervous influence of coitus with a beloved person, that we must seek +the chief key to the effects produced by coitus on women, however these +effects may possibly be still further heightened by the actual absorption +of semen.[139] + +The positive action of semen, or rather of the testicular products, has +been much investigated during recent years, and appears on the whole to be +demonstrated. The notable discovery by Brown-Séquard, a quarter of a +century ago, that the ingestion of the testicular juices in states of +debility and senility acted as a beneficial stimulant and tonic, opened +the way to a new field of therapeutics. Many investigators in various +countries have found that testicular extracts, and more especially the +spermin as studied by Poehl,[140] and by him regarded as a positive +katalysator or accelerator of metabolic processes, exert a real influence +in giving tone to the heart and other muscles, and in improving the +metabolism of the tissues even when all influences of mental suggestion +have been excluded.[141] + + As the ovaries are strictly analogous to the testes, it was + surmised that ovarian extract might prove a drug equally valuable + with testicular products. As a matter of fact, ovarian extract, + in the form of ovarin, etc., would seem to have proved beneficial + in various disorders, more especially in anæmia and in troubles + due to the artificial menopause. In most conditions, however, in + which it has been employed the results are doubtful or uncertain, + and some authorities believe that the influence of suggestion + plays a considerable part here. + +There is, however, another use which is subserved by the testicular +products, a use which may indeed be said to be implied in those uses to +which reference has already been made, but is yet historically the latest +to be realized and studied. It was not until 1869 that Brown-Séquard first +suggested that an important secretion was elaborated by the ductless +glands and received into the circulation, but that suggestion proved to be +epoch-making. If these glandular secretions are so valuable when +administered as drugs to other persons, must they not be of far greater +value when naturally secreted and poured out into the circulation in the +living body? It is now generally believed, on the basis of a large and +various body of evidence, that this is undoubtedly so. In a very crude +form, indeed, this belief is by no means modern. In opposition to the old +writers who were inclined to regard the semen as an excretion which it was +beneficial to expel, there were other ancient authorities who argued that +it was beneficial to retain it as being a vital fluid which, if +reabsorbed, served to invigorate the body. The great physiologist, Haller, +in the middle of the eighteenth century, came very near to the modern +doctrine when he stated in his _Elements of Physiology_ that the sperm +accumulated in the seminical vesicles is pumped back into the blood, and +thus produces the beard and the hair together with the other surprising +changes of puberty which are absent in the eunuch. The reabsorption of +semen can scarcely be said to be a part of the modern physiological +doctrine, but it is at least now generally held that the testes secrete +substances which pass into the circulation and are of immense importance +in the development of the organism. + +The experiments of Shattock and Seligmann indicate that the semen and its +reabsorption in the seminal vesicles, or the nervous reactions produced by +its presence, can have no part in the formation of secondary sexual +characters. These investigators occluded the vas deferens in sheep by +ligature, at an early age, rendering them later sterile though not +impotent. The secondary sexual characters appeared as in ordinary sheep. +Spermatogenesis, these inquirers conclude, may be the initial factor, but +the results must be attributed to the elaboration by the testicles of an +internal secretion and its absorption into the general circulation.[142] + +When animals are castrated there is enlargement of the ductless glands in +the body, notably the thyroid and the suprarenal capsules.[143] It is +evident, therefore, that the secretions of these ductless glands are in +some degree compensatory to those of the testes. But this compensatory +action is inadequate to produce any sexual development in the absence of +the testes. + +We see, therefore, how extremely important is the function of the testis. +Its significance is not alone for the race, it is not simply concerned +with the formation of the spermatozoa which share equally with the ova the +honor of making the mankind of the future. It also has a separate and +distinct function which has reference to the individual. It elaborates +those internal secretions which stimulate and maintain the physical and +mental characters, constituting all that is most masculine in the male +animal, all that makes the man in distinction from the eunuch. Among +various primitive peoples, including those of the European race whence we +ourselves spring, the most solemn form of oath was sworn by placing the +hand on the testes, dimly recognized as the most sacred part of the body. +A crude and passing phase of civilization has ignorantly cast ignominy +upon the sexual organs; the more primitive belief is now justified by our +advancing knowledge. + + In these as in other respects the ovaries are precisely analogous + to the testes. They not only form the ova, but they elaborate for + internal use a secretion which develops and maintains the special + physical and mental qualities of womanhood, as the testicular + secretion those of manhood. Moreover, as Cecca and Zappi found, + removal of the ovaries has exactly the same effect on the + abnormal development of the other ductless glands as has removal + of the testes. It is of interest to point out that the internal + secretion of the ovaries and its important functions seem to have + been suggested before any other secretion than the sperm was + attributed to the testes. Early in the nineteenth century Cabanis + argued ("De l'Influence des Sexes sur le Caractère des Idées et + des Affections Morales," _Rapport du Physique et du Moral de + l'Homme_, 1824, vol. ii, p. 18) that the ovaries are secreting + glands, forming a "particular humor" which is reabsorbed into the + blood and imparts excitations which are felt by the whole system + and all its organs. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[129] The composite character of the semen was recognized by various old +authors, some of whom said, (e.g., Wharton) that it had three +constituents, which they usually considered to be: (1) The noblest and +most essential part, from the testicles; (2) a watery element from the +vesiculæ; (3) an oily element from the prostate. Schurig, _Spermatologia_, +1720, p. 17. + +[130] See, e.g., C. Mansell Moulin, "A Contribution to the Morphology of +the Prostate," _Journal of Anatomy and Physiology_, January, 1895; G. +Walker, "A Contribution to the Anatomy and Physiology of the Prostate +Gland, and a Few Observations on Ejaculation," _Johns Hopkins Hospital +Bulletin_, October, 1900. + +[131] For a study of the semen and its constituents, see Florence, "Du +Sperme," _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, 1895. + +[132] J. Hunter, _Essays and Observations_, vol. i, p. 189. + +[133] As regards one part of Australia, Walter Roth, _Ethnological Studies +Among the Queensland Aborigines_, p. 174. + +[134] Sir H.H. Johnston, _British Central Africa_, p. 438. + +[135] Cap. VII, pp. 327-357, "De Spermaticis virilis usu Medico," + +[136] W.L. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," _Alienist and Neurologist_, +January, 1896. + +[137] _Zentralblatt für Gynäkologie_, 1894, No. 49. + +[138] E. Toff, "Uber Imprägnierung," _Zentralblatt für Gynäkologie_, +April, 1903. In a similar but somewhat more precise manner Dufougère has +argued ("La Chlorose, ses rapports avec le marriage, son traitement par le +liquide orchitique," Thèse de Bordeaux, 1902) that semen when absorbed by +the vagina stimulates the secretion of the ovaries and thus exerts an +influence over the blood in anæmia; in this way he seeks to explain why it +is that coitus is the best treatment for chlorosis. + +[139] In this connection I may refer to an interesting and suggestive +paper by Harry Campbell on "The Craving for Stimulants" (_Lancet_, October +21, 1899). No reference is made to coitus, but the author discusses +stimulants as normal and beneficial products of the organism, and deals +with the nature of the "physiological intoxication" they produce. + +[140] Spermin was first discovered in the sperm by Schreiner in 1878; it +has also been found in the thyroid, ovaries and various other glands. "The +spermin secreting and elaborating organs," Howard Kelly remarks (_British +Medical Journal_, January 29, 1898), "may be called the apothecaries' of +the body, secreting many important medicaments, much more active and more +accurately representing its true wants than artificially administered +drugs." + +[141] See, e.g., a summary of Buschan's comprehensive discussion of the +subject of organotherapy (Eulenburg's _Real-Encyclopædie der Gesammten +Heilkunde_) in _Journal of Mental Science_, April, 1899, p. 355. + +[142] "Observations Upon the Acquirement of Secondary Sexual Characters, +Indicating the Formation of an Internal Secretion by the Testicles," +_Proceedings Royal Society_, vol. lxxiii, p. 49. + +[143] See, e.g., the experiments of Cecca and Zappi, summarized in +_British Medical Journal_, July 2, 1904. + + + + +IV. + +The Aptitude for Detumescence--Is There an Erotic Temperament?--The +Available Standards of Comparison--Characteristics of the +Castrated--Characteristics of Puberty--Characteristics of the State of +Detumescence--Shortness of Stature--Development of the Secondary Sexual +Characters--Deep Voice--Bright Eyes--Glandular Activity--Everted +Lips--Pigmentation--Profuse Hair--Dubious Significance of Many of These +Characters. + + +What, if any, are the indications which the body generally may furnish as +to the individual's aptitude and vigor for the orgasm of detumescence? Is +there an erotic temperament outwardly and visibly displayed? That is a +question which has often occupied those who have sought to penetrate the +more intimate mysteries of human nature, and since we are here concerned +with human beings in their relationship to the process of detumescence, we +cannot altogether pass over this question, difficult as it is to discuss +it with precision. + + The old physiognomists showed much confidence in dealing with the + matter. Possibly they had more opportunities for observation than + we have, since they often wrote in days when life was lived more + nakedly than among ourselves, but their descriptions, while + sometimes showing much insight, are inextricably mixed up with + false science and superstition. + + In the _De Secretis Mulierum_, wrongly attributed to Albertus + Magnus, we find a chapter entitled "Signa mulieris calidæ naturæ + et quæ coit libenter," which may be summarized here. "The signs," + we are told, "of a woman of warm temperament, and one who + willingly cohabits are these: youth, an age of over 12, or + younger, if she has been seduced, small, high breasts, full and + hard, hair in the usual positions; she is bold of speech, with a + delicate and high voice, haughty and even cruel of disposition, + of good complexion, lean rather than stout, inclined to like + drinking. Such a woman always desires coitus, and receives + satisfaction in the act. The menstrual flow is not abundant nor + always regular. If she becomes pregnant the milk is not abundant. + Her perspiration is less odorous than that of the woman of + opposite temperament; she is fond of singing, and of moving + about, and delights in adornments if she has any." + + Polemon, in his _Sulla Physionomia_, has given among the signs of + libidinous impulse: knees turned inwards, abundance of hairs on + the legs, squint, bright eyes, a high and strident voice, and in + women length of leg below the knee. Aristotle had mentioned among + the signs of wantonness: paleness, abundance of hair on the body, + thick and black hair, hairs covering the temples, and thick + eyelids. + + In the seventeenth century Bouchet, in his _Serées_ (Troisième + Serée), gave as the signs of virility which indicated that a man + could have children: a great voice, a thick rough black beard, a + large thick nose. + + G. Tourdes (Art. "Aphrodisie," _Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des + Sciences Médicales_) thus summarized the ancient beliefs on this + subject: "The erotic temperament has been described as marked by + a lean figure, white and well-ranged teeth, a developed hairy + system, a characteristic voice, air, and expression, and even a + special odor." + +In approaching the question of the general physical indications of a +special aptitude to the manifestation of vigorous detumescence, the most +obvious preliminary would seem to be a study of the castrated. If we know +the special peculiarities of those who by removal of the sexual glands at +a very early age have been deprived of all ability to present the +manifestations of detumescence, we shall probably be in possession of a +type which is the reverse of that which we may expect in persons of a +vigorously erotic temperament. + +The most general characteristics of eunuchs would appear to be an unusual +tendency to put on fat, a notably greater length of the legs, absence of +hair in the sexual and secondary sexual regions, a less degree of +pigmentation, as noted both in the castrated negro and the white man, a +puerile larynx and puerile voice. In character they are usually described +as gentle, conciliatory, and charitable. + + There can be little doubt that castration in man tends to lead to + lengthening of the legs (tibia and fibula) at puberty, from + delayed ossification of the epiphyses. The hands and feet are + also frequently longer and sometimes the forearms. At the same + time the bones are more slender. The pelvis also is narrower. The + eunuchs of Cairo are said to be easily seen in a crowd from their + tall stature. (Collineau, quoting Lortet, _Revue Mensuelle de + l'Ecole d'Anthropologie_, May, 1896.) The castrated Skoptzy show + increased stature, and, it seems, large ears, with decreased + chest and head (L. Pittard, _Revue Scientifique_, June 20, 1903.) + Féré shows that in most of these respects the eunuch resembles + beardless and infantile subjects. ("Les Proportions des Membres + et les Caractères Sexuels," _Journal de l'Anatomie et de la + Physiologie_, November-December, 1897.) Similar phenomena are + found in animals generally. Sellheim, carefully investigating + castrated horses, swine, oxen and fowls, found retardation of + ossification, long and slender extremities, long, broad, but low + skull, relatively smaller pelvis and small thorax. ("Zur Lehre + von den Sekundären Geschlechtscharakteren," _Beiträge zur + Geburtshülfe und Gynäkologie_, 1898, summarized in _Centralblatt + für Anthropologie_, 1900, Heft IV.) + + As regards the mental qualities and moral character of the + castrated, Griffiths considers that there is an undue prejudice + against eunuchs, and refers to Narses, who was not only one of + the first generals of the Roman Empire, but a man of highly + estimable character. (_Lancet_, March 30, 1895.) Matignon, who + has carefully studied Chinese eunuchs, points out that they + occupy positions of much responsibility, and, though regarded in + many respects as social outcasts, possess very excellent and + amiable moral qualities (_Archives Cliniques de Bordeaux_, May, + 1896.) In America Everett Flood finds that epileptics and + feeble-minded boys are mentally and morally benefited by + castration. ("Notes on the Castration of Idiot Children," + _American Journal of Psychology_, January, 1899.) It is often + forgotten that the physical and psychic qualities associated with + and largely dependent on the ability to experience the impulse of + detumescence, while essential to the perfect man, involve many + egoistic, aggressive and acquisitive characteristics which are of + little intellectual value, and at the same time inimical to many + moral virtues. + +We have a further standard--positive this time rather than negative--to +aid us in determining the erotic temperament: the phenomena of puberty. +The efflorescence of puberty is essentially the manifestation of the +ability to experience detumescence. It is therefore reasonable to suppose +that the individuals in whom the special phenomena of puberty develop most +markedly are those in whom detumescence is likely to be most vigorous. If +such is the case we should expect to find the erotic temperament marked by +developed larynx and deep voice, a considerable degree of pigmentary +development in hair and skin, and a marked tendency to hairiness; while +in women there should be a pronounced growth of the breasts and +pelvis.[144] + +There is yet another standard by which we may measure the individual's +aptitude for detumescence: the presence of those activities which are most +prominently brought into play during the process of detumescence. The +individual, that is to say, who is organically most apt to manifest the +physiological activities which mainly make up the process of detumescence, +is most likely to be of pronounced erotic temperament. + +"Erotic persons are of motor type," remark Vaschide and Vurpas, "and we +may say generally that nearly all persons of motor type are erotic." The +state of detumescence is one of motor and muscular energy and of great +vascular activity, so that habitual energy of motor response and an active +circulation may reasonably be taken to indicate an aptitude for the +manifestation of detumescence. + +These three types may be said, therefore, to furnish us valuable though +somewhat general indications. The individual who is farthest removed from +the castrated type, who presents in fullest degree the characters which +begin to emerge at the period of puberty, and who reveals a physiological +aptitude for the vigorous manifestation of those activities which are +called into action during detumescence, is most likely to be of erotic +temperament. The most cautious description of the characteristics of this +temperament given by modern scientific writers, unlike the more detailed +and hazardous descriptions of the early physiognomists, will be found to +be fairly true to the standards thus presented to us. + + The man of sexual type, according to Biérent (_La Puberté_, p. + 148), is hairy, dark and deep-voiced. + + "The men most liable to satyriasis," Bouchereau states (art. + "Satyriasis," _Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des Sciences + Médicales_), "are those with vigorous nervous system, developed + muscles, abundant hair on body, dark complexion, and white + teeth." + + Mantegazza, in his _Fisiologia del Piacere_, thus describes the + sexual temperament: "Individuals of nervous temperament, those + with fine and brown skins, rounded forms, large lips and very + prominent larynx enjoy in general much more than those with + opposite characteristics. A universal tradition," he adds, + "describes as lascivious humpbacks, dwarfs, and in general + persons of short stature and with long noses." + + In a case of nymphomania in a young woman, described by Alibert + (and quoted by Laycock, _Nervous Diseases of Women_, p. 28) the + hips, thighs and legs were remarkably plump, while the chest and + arms were completely emaciated. In a somewhat similar case + described by Marc in his _De la Folie_ a peasant woman, who from + an early age had experienced sexual hyperæsthesia, so that she + felt spasmodic voluptuous feelings at the sight of a man, and was + thus the victim of solitary excesses and of spasmodic movements + which she could not repress, the upper part of the body was very + thin, the hips, legs and thighs highly developed. + + In his work on _Uterine and Ovarian Inflammation_ (1862, p. 37) + Tilt observes: "The restless, bashful eye, and changing + complexion, in presence of a person of the opposite sex, and a + nervous restlessness of body, ever on the move, turning and + twisting on sofa or chair, are the best indications of sexual + temperament." + + An extremely sensual little girl of 8, who was constantly + masturbating when not watched, although brought up by nuns, was + described by Busdraghi (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, fas. i, 1888, + p. 53) as having chestnut hair, bright black eyes, an elevated + nose, small mouth, pleasant round face, full colored cheeks, and + plump and healthy aspect. + + A highly intelligent young Italian woman with strong and somewhat + perverted sexual impulses is described as of attractive + appearance, with olive complexion, small black almond-shaped + eyes, dilated pupils, oblique thin eyebrows, very thick black + hair, rather prominent cheek-bones, largely developed jaw, and + with abundant down on lower part of cheeks and on upper lip. + (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1899, fasc. v-vi.) + + As the type of the sensual woman in word and act, led by her + passions to commit various sexual offenses, Ottolenghi describes + (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, vol. xii, fasc. v-vi, p. 496) a woman + of 32 who attempted to kill her lover. The daughter of parents + who were neurotic and themselves very erotic, she was a highly + intelligent and vivacious woman, with a pleasing and open face, + very thick dark chestnut hair, large cheek-bones, adipose + buttocks almost resembling those of a Hottentot, and very thick + pubic hair. She was very fond of salt things. Sexual inclination + began at the age of 7. + +Adler and Moll remark, very truly, that, so far at least as women are +concerned, sexual anæsthesia or sexual proclivity cannot be unfailingly +read on the features. Every woman desires to please, and coquetry is the +sign of a cold, rather than of an erotic temperament.[145] It may be added +that a considerable degree of congenital sexual anæsthesia by no means +prevents a woman from being beautiful and attractive, though it must +probably still always be said that, as Roubaud points out,[146] the woman +of cold and intellectual temperament, the "femme de tête," however +beautiful and skillful she may be, cannot compete in the struggle for love +with the woman whose qualities are of the heart and of the emotions. But +it seems sufficiently clear that the practical observations of skilled and +experienced observers agree in attributing to persons of erotic type +certain general characteristics which accord with those negative and +positive standards we may frame on the basis of castration, of puberty, +and of detumescence. It may be worth while to note a few of these +characteristics briefly. + +The abnormal lengthening of the long bones at the age of puberty in the +castrated is, as we have seen, very pronounced. There is little tendency +to associate length of limb with an erotic temperament, and a certain +amount of data as well as of more vague opinion points in the opposite +direction. The Arabs would appear to believe that it is short rather than +tall people in whom the sexual instinct is strongly developed, and we read +in the _Perfumed Garden_: "Under all circumstances little women love +coitus more and evince a stronger affection for the virile member than +women of a large size." In his elaborate investigation of criminals Marro +found that prostitutes and women guilty of sexual offenses, as also male +sexual offenders, tend to be short and thick set.[147] In European +folk-lore the thick, bull neck is regarded as a sign of strong +sexuality.[148] Mantegazza refers to a strong sexual temperament as being +associated with arrest or disorder of bony development, and Marro suggests +that the proverbial salacity of rachitic individuals may be due to an +increased activity of the sexual organs.[149] It may be added that +acromegaly, with its excessive bony growths, tends to be associated with +premature sexual involution. + +A further point which is frequently mentioned in the case of women is the +development of the chief secondary sexual regions: the pelvis and the +breasts. It is, indeed, almost inevitable that there should be some degree +of correlation between the aptitude for bearing children and the aptitude +for experiencing detumescence. The reality of such a connection is not +only evidenced by medical observations, but receives further testimony in +popular beliefs. In Italy women with large buttocks are considered wanton, +and among the South Slavs they are regarded as especially fruitful.[150] +Blumenbach asserted that precocious venery will enlarge the breasts, and +believed that he had found evidence of this among young London +prostitutes.[151] + +The association of the aptitude for detumescence with a tendency to a deep +rather than to a high voice, both in men and women, has frequently been +noted and has seldom been denied. The onset of puberty always affects the +voice; in general, Biérent states, the more bass the voice is the more +marked is the development of the sexual apparatus; "a very robust man, +with very developed sexual organs, and very dark and abundant hairy +system, a man of strong puberty in a word, is nearly always a bass."[152] +The influence of sexual excitement in deepening the voice is shown by the +rules of sexual hygiene prescribed to tenors, while a bass has less need +to observe similar precautions. In women every phase of sexual +life--puberty, menstruation, coitus, pregnancy--tends to affect the voice +and always by giving it a deeper character. The deepening of the voice by +sexual intercourse was an ancient Greek observation, and Martial refers to +a woman's good or bad singing as an index to her recent sexual habits. +Prostitutes tend to have a deep voice. Venturi points out that married +women preserve a fresh voice to a more advanced age than spinsters, this +being due to the precocious senility in the latter of an unused function. +Such a phenomenon indicates that the relationship of detumescence to the +deepening of the voice is not quite simple. This is further indicated by +the fact that in robust men abstinence still further deepens the voice +(the monk of melodrama always has a bass voice), while excessive or +precocious sexual indulgence tends to be associated with the same kind of +puerile voice as is found in those persons in whom pubertal development +has not been carried very far, or who are of what Griffiths terms +eunuchoid type. Idiot boys, who are often sexually undeveloped, tend to +have a high voice, while idiot girls (who often manifest marked sexual +proclivities) not infrequently have a deep voice.[153] + +Bright dilated eyes are among the phenomena of detumescence, and are very +frequently noted in persons of a pronounced erotic temperament. This is, +indeed, an ancient observation, and Burton says of people with a black, +lively, and sparkling eye, "without question they are most amorous," +drawing his illustrations mostly from classic literature.[154] Tardieu +described the erotic woman as having bright eyes, and Heywood Smith states +that the eyes of lascivious women resemble, though in a less degree, those +of the insane.[155] Sexual excitement is one among many +causes--intellectual excitement, pain, a loud noise, even any sensory +irritation--which produce dilatation of the pupils and enlargement of the +palpebral fissure, with some protrusion of the eyeball. The influence of +the sexual system upon the eye appears to be far less potent in men than +in women.[156] Sexual desire is, however, by no means the only irritant +within the sexual sphere which may thus influence the eye; morbid +irritations may produce the same effect. Milner Fothergill, in his book on +_Indigestion_, vividly describes the appearance of the eyes sometimes +seen in ovarian disorder: "The glittering flash which glances out from +some female irides is the external indication of ovarian irritation, and +'the ovarian gleam' has features quite its own. The most marked instance +which ever came under my notice was due to irritation in the ovaries, +which had been forced down in front of the uterus and been fixed there by +adhesions. Here there was little sexual proclivity, but the eyes were very +remarkable. They flashed and glittered unceasingly, and at times perfect +lightning bolts shot from them. Usually there is a bright glittering sheen +in them which contrasts with the dead look in the irides of sexual excess +or profuse uterine discharges." + +The activity of the glandular secretions, and especially those of the +skin, during detumescence, would lead us to expect that such secretory +activity is an index to an aptitude for detumescence. As a matter of fact +it is occasionally, though not frequently, noted by medical observers. It +is stated that the erotic temperament is characterized by a special +odor.[157] The activity of the sweat-glands is seldom referred to by +medical observers in describing persons of erotic temperament, although +the descriptions of novelists not infrequently contain allusions to this +point, and the literature of an earlier age shows that the tendency to +perspiration, especially the moist hand, was regarded as a sure sign of a +sensual temperament. "The moist-handed Madonna Imperia, a most rare and +divine creature," remarks Lazarillo in Middleton's comedy _Blurt, +Master-Constable_, to quote one of many allusions to this point in the +Elizabethan drama. + +The lips are sometimes noted as red and everted, perhaps thick[158]; +Tardieu remarked that the typically erotic woman has thick red lips. This +corresponds with the characteristic type of the satyr in classic statues +as in later paintings; his lips are always thick and everted. Fullness, +redness, and eversion of the lips are correlated with good breathing, the +absence of anæmia, laughter, a well-fleshed face. + + This kind of mouth indicates, perhaps, not so much a congenitally + erotic temperament, as an abandonment to impulse. The opposite + type of mouth--with inverted, thin, and retracted lips--would + appear to be found with especial frequency in persons who + habitually repress their impulses on moral grounds. Any kind of + effort to restrain involuntary muscular action may lead to + retraction of the lips: the effort to overcome anger or fear, or + even the resistance to a strong desire to urinate or defecate. In + religious young men, however, it becomes habitual and fixed. I + recall a small band of medical students, gathered together from a + large medical school, who were accustomed to meet together for + prayer and Bible-reading; the majority showed this type of mouth + to a very marked degree: pale faces, with drawn, retracted lips. + It may be termed the Christian or pious _facies_. It is much less + frequently seen in religious women (unless of masculine type), + doubtless because religion for women is in a much less degree + than for men a moral discipline. + + It may be added that an interesting form of this contraction of + the lips, and one that is not purely repressive, is that which + indicates the state of muscular tension associated with the + impulse to guard and protect. In this form the contracted mouth + is the index of tenderness, and is characteristic of the mother + who is watching over the infant she is suckling at her breast. I + have observed precisely the same expression in the face of a boy + of 14 with a large congenital scrotal hernia; when the tumor was + being examined his lower lip became retracted, well marked lines + appearing from the angles downwards, though the upper lip + retained its normal expression It was precisely the tender look + we may see in the faces of mothers who are watching anxiously + over their offspring, and the emotion is evidently the same in + both cases: solicitude for a sensitive and tenderly guarded + object. + +The degree of pigmentation is clearly correlated with sexual vigor. "In +general," Heusinger laid down, in 1823, "the quantity of pigment is +proportional to the functional effectiveness of the genital organs." This +connection is so profound that it may be traced very widely throughout the +organic world. + +The connection between pigmentation and sexual activity is very ancient. +Even leaving out of account the wedding apparel of animals, nearly always +gorgeous in scales and plumage and hair, the sexual orifice shows a more +or less marked tendency to pigmentation during the breeding season from +fishes upward, while in mammals the darker pigmentation of this region is +a constant phenomenon in sexually mature individuals.[159] + +In the human species both the negative standard of castration and the +positive standard of puberty alike indicate a correlation of this kind. +Those individuals in whom puberty never fully develops and who are +consequently said to be affected by infantilism, reveal a relative absence +of pigment in the sexual centers which are normally pigmented to a high +degree.[160] Among those Asiatic races who extirpate the ovaries in young +girls the skin remains white in the perineum, round the anus, and in the +armpits.[161] Even in mature women who undergo ovariotomy, as Kepler +found, the pigmentation of the nipples and areola disappears, as well as +of the perineum and anus, the skin taking on a remarkable whiteness. + +Normally the sexual centers, and in a high degree the genital orifice, +represent the maximum of pigmentation, and under some circumstances this +is clearly visible even in infancy. Thus babies of mixed black and white +blood may show no traces of negro ancestry at birth, but there will always +be increased pigmentation about the external genitalia.[162] The linea +fusca, which reaches from the pubes to the navel and occasionally to the +ensiform cartilage, is a line of sexual pigmentation sometimes regarded as +characteristic of pregnancy, but as Andersen, of Copenhagen, has found by +the examination of several hundred children of both sexes, it exists in a +slight form in about 75 per cent. of young girls, and in almost as large a +proportion of boys. But there is no doubt that it tends to increase with +age as well as to become marked at pregnancy. At puberty there is a +general tendency to changes in pigmentation; thus Godin found that in 28 +per cent, adolescent changes occurred in the eyes and hair at this period, +the hair becoming darker, though the eyes sometimes become lighter. Ammon, +in his investigation of conscripts at the age of 20 (_post_, p. 196), +discovered the significant fact that the eyes and hair darken _pari passu_ +with sexual development. In women, during menstruation, there is a general +tendency to pigmentation; this is especially obvious around the eyes, and +in some cases black rings of true pigment form in this position. Even the +skin of the negro women of Loango sometimes becomes a few shades darker +during menstruation.[163] During pregnancy this tendency to pigmentation +reaches its climax. Pregnancy constantly gives rise to pigmentation of the +face, the neck, the nipples, the abdomen, and this is especially marked in +brunettes. + +This association of pigmentation and sexual aptitudes has been recognized +in the popular lore of some peoples. Thus the Sicilians, who admire brown +skin and have no liking either for a fair skin or light hair, believe that +a white woman is incapable of responding to love. It is the brown woman +who feels love; as it is said in Sicilian dialect: "Fimmina scura, fimmina +amurusa."[164] + + The dependence of pigmentation upon the sexual system is shown by + the fact that irritation of the genital organs by disease will + frequently suffice to produce a high degree of pigmentation. This + may the neck, the trunk, the hands. Simpson long since noted that + uterine irritation apart from pregnancy may produce pigmentation + of the areolæ of the nipples (_Obstetric Works_, vol. i, p. 345). + Engelmann discussed the subject and gave cases, "The + Hystero-Neuroses," pp. 124-139, in _Gynæcological Transactions_, + vol. xii, 1887; and a summary of a memoir by Fouquet on this + subject in _La Gynécologie_, February, 1903, will be found in + _British Medical Journal_, March 28, 1903, + +Of all physical traits vigor of the hairy system has most frequently +perhaps been regarded as the index of vigorous sexuality. In this matter +modern medical observations are at one with popular belief and ancient +physiognomical assertions.[165] The negative test of castration and the +positive test of puberty point in the same direction. + +It is at puberty that all the hair on the body, except that on the head, +begins to develop; indeed, the very word "puberty" has reference to this +growth as the most obvious sign of the whole process. When castration +takes place at an early age all this development of pubescent hair is +arrested. When the primary sexual organs are undeveloped the sexual hair +is also undeveloped, as in a case, recorded by Plant,[166] of a girl with +rudimentary uterus and ovaries who had little or no axillary and pubic +hair, although the hair of the head was long and strong.[167] + + The pseudo-Michael Scot among the _Signa mulieris calidæ naturæ + et quæ coit libenter_ stated that her hair, both on the head and + body, is thick and coarse and crisp, and Della Porta, the + greatest of the physiognomists, said that thickness of hair in + women meant wantonness. Venette, in his _Generation de l'Homme_, + remarked that men who have much hair on the body are most + amorous. At a more recent period Roubaud has said that pubic hair + in its quantity, color and curliness is an index of genital + energy. A poor pilous system, on the other hand, Roubaud regarded + as a probable though not an irrefragable proof of sexual + frigidity in women. "In the cold woman the pilous system is + remarkable for the languor of its vitality; the hairs are fair, + delicate, scarce and smooth, while in ardent natures there are + little curly tufts about the temples." (_Traité de + l'Impuissance_, pp. 124, 523.) Martineau declared (_Leçons sur + les Déformations Vulvaires_, p. 40) that "the more developed the + genital organs the more abundant the hair covering them; + abundance of hair appears to be in relation to the perfect + development of the organs." Tardieu described the typically + erotic woman as very hairy. + + Bergh found that among 2200 young Danish prostitutes those who + showed an unusual extension and amount of pubic hair included + several women who were believed to be libidinous in a very high + degree. (Bergh, "Symbolæ," etc., _Hospitalstidende_, August, + 1894.) Moraglia, again, in Italy, in describing various women, + mostly prostitutes, of unusually strong sexual proclivities, + repeatedly notes very thick hair, with down on the face. + (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, vol. xvi, fasc. iv-v.) + + Marro, also, in Italy found that abundance of hair and down is + especially marked in women who are guilty of infanticide (as also + Pasini has found), though criminal women generally, in his + experience, tend to have abnormally abundant hair. (_Caratteri + del Delinquenti_, cap. XXII.) Lombroso finds that prostitutes + generally tend to be hairy (_Donna Delinquente_, p. 320.) + + A lad of 14, guilty of numerous crimes of violence having a + sexual source, is described by Arthur Macdonald in America as + having hair on the chest as well as all over the pubes. (A. + Macdonald, _Archives de L'Anthropologie Criminelle_, January, + 1893, p. 55.) The association of hairiness with abnormal + sexuality in the weak-minded has been noted at Bicêtre + (_Recherches Cliniques sur l'Epilepsie_, vol. xix, pp. 69, 77.) + + Hypertrichosis universalis, a general hairiness of body, has been + described by Cascella in a woman with very strong sexual desires, + who eventually became insane. (_Revista Mensile di Psichiatria_, + 1903, p. 408.) Bucknill and Tuke give the case of a religiously + minded girl, with very strong and repressed sexual desires, who + became insane; the only abnormal feature in her physical + development was the marked growth of hair over the body. + + Brantôme refers to a great lady known to him whose body was very + hairy, and quotes a saying to the effect that hairy people are + either rich or wanton; the lady in question, he adds, was both. + (Brantôme, _Vie des Dames Galantes_, Discours II.) + + De Sade, whose writings are now regarded as a treasure house of + true observations in the domain of sexual psychology, makes the + Rodin of _Justine_ dark, with much hair and thick eyebrows, while + his very sexual sister is described as dark, thin and very hairy. + (Dühren, _Der Marquis de Sade_, third edition, p. 440.) + + A correspondent who has always taken a special interest in the + condition as regards hairiness of the women to whom he has been + attracted, has sent me notes concerning a series of 12 women. It + may be gathered from these notes that 5 women were neither + markedly sexual nor markedly hairy (either as regards head or + pubes), 6 cases both hairy and sexual, 1 was sexual and not + hairy, none were hairy and not sexual. My correspondent remarks: + "There may be women with scanty pubic hair possessing very strong + sexual emotions. My own experience is quite the opposite." He has + also independently reached the conclusion, arrived at by many + medical observers and clearly suggested by some of the facts here + brought together, that profuse hair frequently denotes a neurotic + temperament. + + It may be added that Mirabeau, as we learn from an anecdote told + by an eyewitness and recorded by Legouvé, had a very hairy chest, + while the same is recorded of Restif de la Bretonne. + +It is a very ancient and popular belief that if a hairy man is not sensual +he is strong: _vir pilosus aut libidinosus aut fortis_. The Greeks +insisted on the hairy nates of Hercules, and Ninon de l'Enclos, when the +great Condé shared her bed without touching her, remarked, on seeing his +hairy body: "Ah, Monseigneur, que vous devez être fort!" It may be doubted +whether there is any exact parallelism between muscular strength and +hairiness, for strength is largely a matter of training, but there can be +no doubt that hairiness really tends to be associated with a generally +vigorous development of the body. + +Although the observations concerning hairiness of body as an index of +vigor, whether sexual or only generally physical, are so ancient, until +recent years no attempts have been made to demonstrate on a large scale +whether there is actually a correlation between hairiness and sexual or +general development of the body. Some importance, therefore, attaches to +Ammon's careful observations of many thousand conscripts in Baden. These +observations fully justify this ancient belief, since they show that on +the one hand the size of the testicles, and on the other hand girth of +chest and stature, are correlated with hairiness of body. + + Ammon's observations were made on nearly 4000 conscripts of the + age of 20. From the point of view of the hairy system he divided + them, into four classes:-- + + I. To which 6.1 per cent, of the men belonged, with smooth + bodies. + + II. Including 25.3 per cent., only slight hairiness. + + III. 53.8 per cent., more developed hairy system, but belly, + breast and back smooth. + + IV. 14.7 per cent., hair all over body. + + V. 0.1 per cent., extreme cases of hairiness. + + The beardless were 12.1 per cent., those with no axillary hair 9 + per cent., those with no hair on pubis 0.4 per cent. This + corresponds with the fact that hair appears first on the pubis + and last on the chin. + + In the first class 69 per cent, were beardless, 54 per cent, + without any axillary hair and 6 per cent, without pubic hair. In + the second class 24 per cent, were beardless, 17 per cent, + without axillary hair. In the third class 3 per cent, were + beardless and 3 per cent without axillary hair. + + Below puberty the diameter of testicles is below 14 millimeters. + There were 13 conscripts having a testicular diameter of less + than 14 millimeters. These infantile individuals all belonged to + the first three classes and mostly to the first. The average + testicular diameter in the first class was nearly 24 millimeters, + and progressively rose in the succeeding classes to over 26 + millimeters in the fourth. + + While there was not much difference in height, the first class + was the shortest, the fourth the tallest. The fourth class also + showed the greatest chest perimeter. The cephalic index of all + classes was 84. (O. Ammon, "L'Infantilisme et le Feminisme au + Conseil de Révision," _L'Anthropologie_, May-June, 1896.) + +We thus see that it is quite justifiable to admit a type of person who +possesses a more than average aptitude for detumescence. Such persons are +more likely to be short than tall; they will show a full development of +the secondary sexual characters; the voice will tend to be deep and the +eyes bright; the glandular activity of the skin will probably be marked, +the lips everted; there is a tendency to a more than average degree of +pigmentation, and there is frequently an abnormal prevalence of hair on +some parts of the body. While none of these signs, taken separately, can +be said to have any necessary connection with the sexual impulse, taken +altogether they indicate an organism that responds to the instinct of +detumescence with special aptitude or with marked energy. In these +respects observation, both scientific and popular, concords with the +probabilities suggested by the three standards in this matter which have +already been set forth. + +No generalization, however, can here be set down in an absolute and +unqualified manner. There are definite reasons why this should be so. +There is, for instance, the highly important consideration that the sexual +impulse of the individual may be conspicuous in two quite distinct ways. +It may assume prominence because the individual possesses a highly +vigorous and well-nourished organism, or its prominence may be due to +mental irritation in a very morbid individual. In the latter +case--although occasionally the two sets of conditions are combined--most +of the signs we might expect in the former case may be absent. Indeed, the +sexual impulses which proceed from a morbid psychic irritability do not in +most cases indicate any special aptitude for detumescence at all; in that +largely lies their morbid character. + +Again, just in the same way that the exaggerated impulse itself may either +be healthy or morbid, so the various characters which we have found to +possess some value as signs of the impulse may themselves either be +healthy or morbid. This is notably the case as regards an abnormal growth +of hair on the body, more especially when it appears on regions where +normally there is little or no hair. Such hypertrichosis is frequently +degenerative in character, though still often associated with the sexual +system. When, however, it is thus a degenerative character of sexual +nature, having its origin in some abnormal foetal condition or later +atrophy of the ovaries, it is no necessary indication of any aptitude for +detumescence. + + Idiots, more especially it would seem idiot girls, tend to show a + highly developed hairy system. Thus Voisin, when investigating + 150 idiot and imbecile girls, found the hair long and thick and + tending to occupy a large surface; one girl had hair on the + areolæ of the mamma. (J. Voisin, "Conformation des organes + génitaux chez les Idiots," _Annales d'Hygiène Publique_, June, + 1894.) It should be said that in idiot boys puberty is late, and + the sexual organs as well as the sexual instinct frequently + undeveloped, while in idiot girls there is no delay in puberty, + and the sexual organs and instinct are frequently fully and even + abnormally developed. + + Hegar has described an interesting case showing an association, + of foetal origin, between sexual anomaly and abnormal hairness. + In this case a girl of 16 had a uterus duplex, an infantile + pelvis, very slight menstruation and undeveloped breasts. She was + very hairy on the face, the anterior aspects of the chest and + abdomen, the sexual regions, and the thighs, but not specially so + on the rest of the body. The hairs were of lanugo-like character, + but dark in color. (A. Hegar, _Beiträge zur Geburtshülfe und + Gynäkologie_, vol. i, p. III, 1898.) Sometimes hiruties of the + face and abdomen begin to appear during pregnancy, apparently + from disease or degeneration of the ovaries. (A case is noted in + _British Medical Journal_, August 2 and 16, pp. 375 and 436, + 1902.) Laycock many years ago referred to the popular belief that + women who have hair on the upper lip seldom bear children, and + regarded this opinion as "questionless founded on fact." + (Laycock, _Nervous Diseases of Women_, p. 22.) When this is so, + we may suppose that the abnormal hairy growth is associated with + degeneration of the ovaries. + +There is another factor which enters into this question and renders the +definition of a physical sexual type less precise than it would otherwise +be. The sexual instinct is common to all persons, and while it seems +probable that there is a type of person in whom sexual energies are +predominant, it would also appear that the people who otherwise show a +very high level of energy in life usually exhibit a more than average +degree of energy in matters of love. The predominantly sexual type, as we +have seen, tends to be associated with a high degree of pigmentation; the +person specially apt for detumescence inclines to belong to the dark +rather than to the purely fair group of the population. On the other hand, +the active, energetic, practical man, the man who is most apt for the +achievement of success in life, tends to belong to the fair rather than to +the dark type.[168] Thus we have a certain conflict of tendencies, and it +becomes possible to assert that while persons with pronounced aptitude for +sexual detumescence tend to be dark, persons whose pronounced energy in +sexual matters tends to ensure success are most likely to be fair. + + The tendency of the fair energetic type, the type of the northern + European man, to sexuality may be connected with the fact that + the violent and criminal man who commits sexual crimes tends to + be fair even amid a dark population. Criminals on the whole would + appear to tend to be dark rather than fair; but Marro found in + Italy that the group of sexual offenders differed from all other + groups of criminals in that their hair was predominantly fair. + (_Caratteri del Delinquenti_, p. 374.) Ottolenghi, in the same + way, in examining 100 sexual offenders, found that they showed 17 + per cent., of fair hair, though criminals generally (on a basis + of nearly 2000) showed only 6 per cent., and normal persons + (nearly 1000) 9 per cent. Similarly while the normal persons + showed only 20 per cent. of blue eyes and criminals generally 36 + per cent., the sexual offenders showed 50 per cent. of blue eyes. + (Ottolenghi, _Archivio di Psichiatria_, fasc. vi, 1888, p. 573.) + Burton remarked (_Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, + Mem. II, Subs. II) that in all ages most amorous young men have + been yellow-haired, adding, "Synesius holds every effeminate + fellow or adulterer is fair-haired." In folk-lore, it has been + noted (Kryptadia, vol. ii, p. 258), red or yellow hair is + sometimes regarded as a mark of sexuality. + + In harmony with this fairness, sexual offenders would appear to + be more dolichocephalic than other criminals. In Italy Marro + found the foreheads of sexual offenders to be narrow, and in + California Drähms found that while murderers had an average + cephalic index of 83.5, and thieves of 80.5, that of sexual + offenders was 79. + + On the other hand, high cheek-bones and broad faces--a condition + most usually found associated with brachycephaly--have sometimes + been noted as associated with undue or violent sexuality. Marro + noted the excess of prominent cheek-bones in sexual offenders, + and in America it has been found that unchaste girls tend to have + broad faces. (_Pedagogical Seminary_, December, 1896, pp. 231, + 235.) + +It will be seen that, when we take a comprehensive view of the facts and +considerations involved, it is possible to obtain a more definite and +coherent picture of the physical signs of a marked aptitude for +detumescence than has hitherto been usually supposed possible. But we also +see that while the _ensemble_ of these signs is probably fairly reliable +as an index of marked sexuality, the separate signs have no such definite +significance, and under some circumstances their significance may even be +reversed. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[144] See Biérent, _La Puberté_; Marro, _La Pubertà_ (and enlarged French +translation, _La Puberté_), and portions of G.S. Hall's _Adolescence_; +also Havelock Ellis, _Man and Woman_ (fourth edition, revised and +enlarged). + +[145] Adler, _Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, p. 174; +Moll, "Perverse Sexualempfindung, Psychische Impotenz und Ehe" (Section +II), in Senator and Kaminer, _Krankheiten und Ehe_. + +[146] Roubaud, _Traité de l'Impuissance_, p. 524. + +[147] Marro, _Caratteri del Delinquenti_, p. 374. + +[148] Kryptadia, vol. ii, p. 258. + +[149] Marro, _La Pubertà_, p. 196. In Italy, the sensuality of the lame is +the subject of proverbs. + +[150] _Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1896, p. 515; Kryptadia, vol. vi, p. 212. + +[151] Blumenbach, _Anthropological Treatises_, p. 248. + +[152] Biérent, _La Puberté_, p. 148. + +[153] Venturi, _Degenerazioni Psico-sessuali_, pp. 408-410. + +[154] _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. II, Sub. II. + +[155] _British Gynæcological Journal_, February, 1887, p. 505. + +[156] Power, _Lancet_, November 26, 1887. + +[157] With regard to the sexual relationships of personal odor, see the +previous volume of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection in Man," section on +Smell. + +[158] In European folk-lore thick lips in a woman are sometimes regarded +as a sign of sensuality, Kryptadia, vol. ii, p, 258. + +[159] The direct dependence of sexual pigmentation on the primary sexual +glands is well illustrated by a true hermaphroditic adult finch exhibited +at the Academy of Sciences of Amsterdam (May 31, 1890); this bird had a +testis on the right side and an ovary on the left, and on the right side +its plumage was of the male's colors, on the left of the female's color. + +[160] See. e.g., Papillault, _Bulletin Société d'Anthropologie_, 1899, p. +446. + +[161] Guinard, Art. "Castration," Richet's _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_. + +[162] J. Whitridge Williams, _Obstetrics_, 1903, p. 132. + +[163] _Zeitschrift für Ethnologie_, 1878, p. 19. + +[164] C. Pitre, _Medicina Populare Siciliana_, p. 47. In England, from +notes sent to me by one correspondent, it would appear that the proportion +of dark and sexually apt women to fair and sexually apt women is as 3 to +1. The experience of others would doubtless give varying results, and in +any case the fallacies are numerous. See, in the previous volume of these +_Studies_, "Sexual Selection in Man," Section IV. + +[165] In Japan the same belief would appear to be held. In a nude figure +representing the typical voluptuous woman by the Japanese painter Marugama +Okio (reproduced in Ploss's _Das Weib_) the pubic and axillary hair is +profuse, though usually sparse in Japan. + +[166] _Centralblatt für Gynäkologie_, No. 9, 1896. + +[167] It is important to remember that there is little correlation in this +matter between the hair of the head and the sexual hair, if not a certain +opposition. (See _ante_, p. 127.) According to one of the aphorisms of +Hippocrates, repeated by Buffon, eunuchs do not become bald, and Aristotle +seems to have believed that sexual intercourse is a cause of baldness in +men. (Laycock, _Nervous Diseases of Women_, p. 23.) + +[168] For some of the evidence on this point, see Havelock Ellis, "The +Comparative Abilities of the Fair and the Dark," _Monthly Review_, August, +1901; cf. id., _A Study of British Genius_, Chapter X. + + + + +THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY. + +The Relationship of Maternal and Sexual Emotion--Conception and Loss of +Virginity--The Anciently Accepted Signs of This Condition--The Pervading +Effects of Pregnancy on the Organism--Pigmentation--The Blood and +Circulation--The Thyroid--Changes in the Nervous System--The Vomiting of +Pregnancy--The Longings of Pregnant Women--Maternal Impressions--Evidence +for and Against Their Validity--The Question Still Open--Imperfection of +Our Knowledge--The Significance of Pregnancy. + + +In analyzing the sexual impulse I have so far deliberately kept out of +view the maternal instinct. This is necessary, for the maternal instinct +is specific and distinct; it is directed to an aim which, however +intimately associated it may be with that of the sexual impulse proper, +can by no means be confounded with it. Yet the emotion of love, as it has +finally developed in the world, is not purely of sexual origin; it is +partly sexual, but it is also partly parental.[169] + +In so far as it is parental it is certainly mainly maternal. There is a +drawing by Bronzino in the Louvre of a woman's head gazing tenderly down +at some invisible object; is it her child or her lover? Doubtless her +child, yet the expression is equally adequate to the emotion evoked by a +lover. If we were here specifically dealing with the emotion of love as a +complex whole, and not with the psychology of the sexual impulse, it would +certainly be necessary to discuss the maternal instinct and its associated +emotions. In any case it seems desirable to touch on the psychic state of +pregnancy, for we are here concerned not only with emotions very closely +connected with the sexual emotions in the narrower sense, but we here at +last approach that state which it is the object of the whole sexual +process to achieve. + +In civilized life a period of weeks, months, even years, may elapse +between the establishment of sexual relations and the occurrence of +conception. Under primitive conditions the loss of the virginal condition +practically involves the pregnant condition, so that under primitive +conditions very little allowance is made for the state, so common among +civilized peoples, of the woman who is no longer a virgin, yet not about +to become a mother. + + There is some interest in noting the signs of loss of virginity + chiefly relied upon by ancient authors. In doing this it is + convenient to follow mainly the full summary of authorities given + by Schurig in his _Barthenologia_ early in the eighteenth + century. The ancient custom, known in classic times, of measuring + the neck the day after marriage was frequently practiced to + ascertain if a girl was or was not a virgin. There were various + ways of doing this. One was to measure with a thread the + circumference of the bride's neck before she went to bed on the + bridal night. If in the morning the same thread would not go + around her neck it was a sure sign that she had lost her + virginity during the night; if not, she was still a virgin or had + been deflowered at an earlier period. Catullus alluded to this + custom, which still exists, or existed until lately, in the south + of France. It is perfectly sound, for it rests on the intimate + response by congestion of the thyroid gland to sexual excitement. + (_Parthenologia_, p. 283; Biérent, _La Puberté_, p. 150; Havelock + Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, p. 267.) + + Some say, Schurig tells us, that the voice, which in the virgin + is shrill, becomes rougher and deeper after the first coitus. He + quotes Riolan's statement that it is certain that the voice of + those who indulge in venery is changed. On that account the + ancients bound down the penis of their singers, and Martial said + that those who wish to preserve their voices should avoid coitus. + Democritus who one day had greeted a girl as "maiden" on the + following day addressed her as "woman," while in the same way it + is said that Albertus Magnus, observing from his study a girl + going for wine for her master, knew that she had had sexual + intercourse by the way because on her return her voice had become + deeper. Here, again, the ancient belief has a solid basis, for + the voice and the larynx are really affected by sexual + conditions. (_Parthenologia_, p. 286; Marro, _La Puberté_, p. + 303; Havelock Ellis, op. cit., pp. 271, 289.) + + Others, again, Schurig proceeds, have judged that the goaty smell + given out in the armpits during the venereal act is also no + uncertain sign of defloration, such odor being perceptible in + those who use much venery, and not seldom in harlots and the + newly married, while, as Hippocrates said, it is not perceived in + boys and girls. (_Parthenologia_, p. 286; cf. the previous volume + of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection in Man," p. 64.) + + In virgins, Schurig remarks, the pubic hair is said to be long + and not twisted, while in women accustomed to coitus it is + crisper. But it is only after long and repeated coitus, some + authors add, that the pubic hairs become crisp. Some recent + observers, it may be remarked, have noted a connection between + sexual excitation and the condition of the pubic hair in women. + (Cf. the present volume, _ante_ p. 127.) + + A sign to which the old authors often attached much importance + was furnished by the urinary stream. In the _De Secretis + Mulierum_, wrongly attributed to Albertus Magnus, it is laid down + that "the virgin urinates higher than the woman." Riolan, in his + _Anthropographia_, discussing the ability of virgins to ejaculate + urine to a height, states that Scaliger had observed women who + were virgins emit urine in a high jet against a wall, but that + married women could seldom do this. Bouaciolus also stated that + the urine of virgins is emitted in a small stream to a distance + with an acute hissing sound. (_Parthenologia_, p. 281.) A + folk-lore belief in the reality of this influence is evidenced by + the Picardy _conte_ referred to already (_ante_, p. 53), "La + Princesse qui pisse au dessus les Meules." There is no doubt a + tendency for the various stresses of sexual life to produce an + influence in this direction, though they act far too slowly and + uncertainly to be a reliable index to the presence or the absence + of virginity. + + Another common ancient test of virginity by urination rests on a + psychic basis, and appears in a variety of forms which are really + all reducible to the same principle. Thus we are told in _De + Secretis Mulierum_ that to ascertain if a girl is seduced she + should be given to eat of powdered crocus flowers, and if she has + been seduced she immediately urinates. We are here concerned with + auto-suggestion, and it may well be believed that with nervous + and credulous girls this test often revealed the truth. + + A further test of virginity discussed by Schurig is the presence + of modesty of countenance. If a woman blushes her virtue is safe. + In this way girls who have themselves had experience of the + marriage bed are said to detect the virgin. The virgin's eyes are + cast down and almost motionless, while she who has known a man + has eyes that are bright and quick. But this sign is equivocal, + says Schurig, for girls are different, and can simulate the + modesty they do not feel. Yet this indication also rests on a + fundamentally sound psychological basis. (See "The Evolution of + Modesty," in the first volume of these _Studies_.) + + In his _Syllepsilogia_ (Section V, cap. I-II), published in 1731, + Schurig discusses further the anciently recognized signs of + pregnancy. The real or imaginary signs of pregnancy sought by + various primitive peoples of the past and present are brought + together by Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, bd. i, Chapter XXVII. + +Both physically and psychically the occurrence of pregnancy is, however, a +distinct event. It marks the beginning of a continuous physical process, +which cannot fail to manifest psychic reactions. A great center of vital +activity--practically a new center, for only the germinal form of it in +menstruation had previously existed--has appeared and affects the whole +organism. "From the moment that the embryo takes possession of the woman," +Robert Barnes puts it, "every drop of blood, every fiber, every organ, is +affected."[170] + +A woman artist once observed to Dr. Stratz, that as the final aim of a +woman is to become a mother and pregnancy is thus her blossoming time, a +beautiful woman ought to be most beautiful when she is pregnant. That is +so, Stratz replied, if her moment of greatest physical perfection +corresponds with the early months of pregnancy, for with the beginning of +pregnancy metabolism is increased, the color of the skin becomes more +lively and delicate, the breasts firmer.[171] Pregnancy may, indeed, often +become visible soon after conception by the brighter eye, the livelier +glance, resulting from greater vascular activity, though later, with the +increase of strain, the face may tend to become somewhat thin and +distorted. The hair, Barnes states, assumes a new vigor, even though it +may have been falling out before. The temperature rises; the weight +increases, even apart from the growth of the foetus. The efflorescence of +pregnancy shows itself, as in the blossoming and fecundated flower, by +increased pigmentation.[172] The nipples with their areolæ, and the +mid-line of the belly, become darker; brown flecks (lentigo) tend to +appear on the forehead, neck, arms, and body; while striæ--at first +blue-red, then a brilliant white--appear on the belly and thighs, though +these are scarcely normal, for they are not seen in women with very +elastic skins and are rare among peasants and savages.[173] The whole +carriage of the woman tends to become changed with the development of the +mighty seed of man planted within her; it simulates the carriage of pride +with the arched back and protruded abdomen.[174] The pregnant woman has +been lifted above the level of ordinary humanity to become the casket of +an inestimable jewel. + +It is in the blood and the circulation that the earliest of the most +prominent symptoms of pregnancy are to be found. The ever increasing +development of this new focus of vascular activity involves an increased +vascular activity in the whole organism. This activity is present almost +from the first--a few days after the impregnation of the ovum--in the +breasts, and quickly becomes obvious to inspection and palpation. Before a +quite passive organ, the breast now rapidly increases in activity of +circulation and in size, while certain characteristic changes begin to +take place around the nipples.[175] As a result of the additional work +imposed upon it the heart tends to become slightly hypertrophied in order +to meet the additional strain; there may be some dilatation also.[176] + + The recent investigations of Stengel and Stanton tend to show + that the increase of the heart's work during pregnancy is less + considerable than has generally been supposed, and that beyond + some enlargement and dilatation of the right ventricle there is + not usually any hypertrophy of the heart. + +The total quantity of blood is raised. While increased in quantity, the +blood appears on the whole to be somewhat depreciated in quality, though +on this point there are considerable differences of opinion. Thus, as +regards hæmoglobin, some investigators have found that the old idea as to +the poverty of hæmoglobin in pregnancy is quite unfounded; a few have even +found that the hæmoglobin is increased. Most authorities have found the +red cells diminished, though some only slightly, while the white cells, +and also the fibrin, are increased. But toward the end of pregnancy there +is a tendency, perhaps due to the establishment of compensation, for the +blood to revert to the normal condition.[177] + +It would appear probable, however, that the vascular phenomena of +pregnancy are not altogether so simple as the above statement would imply. +The activity of various glands at this time--well illustrated by the +marked salivation which sometimes occurs--indicates that other modifying +forces are at work, and it has been suggested that the changes in the +maternal circulation during pregnancy may best be explained by the theory +that there are two opposing kinds of secretion poured into the blood in +unusual degree during pregnancy: one contracting the vessels, the other +dilating them, one or the other sometimes gaining the upper hand. +Suprarenal extract, when administered, has a vaso-constricting influence, +and thyroid extract a vasodilating influence; it may be surmised that +within the body these glands perform similar functions.[178] + +The important part played by the thyroid gland is indicated by its marked +activity at the very beginning of pregnancy. We may probably associate the +general tendency to vasodilatation during early pregnancy with the +tendency to goitre; Freund found an increase of the thyroid in 45 per +cent. of 50 cases. The thyroid belongs to the same class of ductless +glands as the ovary, and, as Bland Sutton and others have insisted, the +analogies between the thyroid and the ovary are very numerous and +significant. It may be added that in recent years Armand Gautier has noted +the importance of the thyroid in elaborating nucleo-proteids containing +arsenic and iodine, which are poured into the circulation during +menstruation and pregnancy. The whole metabolism of the body is indeed +affected, and during the latter part of pregnancy study of the ingesta and +egesta has shown that a storage of nitrogen and even of water is taking +place.[179] The woman, as Pinard puts it, forms the child out of her own +flesh, not merely out of her food; the individual is being sacrificed to +the species. + +The changes in the nervous system of the pregnant woman correspond to +those in the vascular system. There is the same increase of activity, a +heightening of tension. Bruno Wolff, from experiments on bitches, +concluded that the central nervous system in women is probably more easily +excited in the pregnant than in the non-pregnant state, though he was not +prepared to call this cerebral excitability "specific."[180] Direct +observations on pregnant women have shown, without doubt, a heightened +nervous irritability. Reflex action generally is increased. Neumann +investigated the knee-jerk in 500 women during pregnancy, labor, and the +puerperium, and in a large number found that there was a progressive +exaggeration with the advance of pregnancy, little or no change being +observed in the early months; sometimes when no change was observed during +pregnancy the knee-jerk still increased during labor, reaching its maximum +at the moment of the expulsion of the foetus; the return to the normal +condition took place gradually during the puerperium. Tridandani found in +pregnant women that though the superficial reflexes, with the exception of +the abdominal, were diminished, the deep and tendon reflexes were markedly +increased, especially that of the knee, these changes being more marked in +primiparæ than in multiparæ, and more pronounced as pregnancy advanced, +the normal condition returning with ten days after labor. Electrical +excitability was sensibly diminished.[181] + +One of the first signs of high nervous tension is vomiting. As is well +known, this phenomenon commonly appears early in pregnancy, and it is by +many considered entirely physiological. Barnes regards it as a kind of +safety valve, a regulating function, letting off excessive tension and +maintaining equilibrium.[182] Vomiting is, however, a convulsion, and is +thus the simplest form of a kind of manifestation--to which the heightened +nervous tension of pregnancy easily lends itself--that finds its extreme +pathological form in eclampsia. In this connection it is of interest to +point out that the pregnant woman here manifests in the highest degree a +tendency which is marked in women generally, for the female sex, apart +altogether from pregnancy, is specially liable to convulsive +phenomena.[183] + + There is some slight difference of opinion among authorities as + to the precise nature and causation of the sickness of pregnancy. + Barnes, Horrocks and others regard it as physiological; but many + consider it pathological; this is, for instance, the opinion of + Giles. Graily Hewitt attributed it to flexion of the gravid + uterus, Kaltenbach to hysteria, and Zaborsky terms it a neurosis. + Whitridge Williams considers that it may be (1) reflex, or (2) + neurotic (when it is allied to hysteria and amenable to + suggestion), or (3) toxæmic. It really appears to lie on the + borderland between healthy and diseased manifestations. It is + said to be unknown to farmers and veterinary surgeons. It appears + to be little known among savages; it is comparatively infrequent + among women of the lower social classes, and, as Giles has found, + women who habitually menstruate in a painless and normal manner + suffer comparatively little from the sickness of pregnancy. + + We owe a valuable study of the sickness of pregnancy to Giles, + who analyzed the records of 300 cases. He concluded that about + one-third of the pregnant women were free from sickness + throughout pregnancy, 45 per cent. were free during the first + three months. When sickness occurred it began in 70 per cent. of + cases in the first month, and was most frequent during the second + month. The duration varied from a few days to all through. + Between the ages of 20 and 25 sickness was least frequent, and + there was less sickness in the third than in any other pregnancy. + (This corresponds with the conclusion of Matthews Duncan that 25 + is the most favorable age for pregnancy.) To some extent in + agreement with Guéniot, Giles believes that the vomiting of + pregnancy is "one form of manifestation of the high nervous + irritability of pregnancy." This high nervous tension may + overflow into other channels, into the vascular and excretory + system, causing eclampsia; into the muscular system, causing + chorea, or, expending itself in the brain, give rise to hysteria + when mild or insanity when severe. But the vagi form a very ready + channel for such overflow, and hence the frequency of sickness in + pregnancy. There are thus three main factors in the causation of + this phenomenon: (1) An increased nervous irritability; (2) a + local source of irritation; (3) a ready efferent channel for + nervous energy. (Arthur Giles, "Observations on the Etiology of + the Sickness of Pregnancy," _Transactions Obstetrical Society of + London_, vol. xxv, 1894.) + + Martin, who regards the phenomenon as normal, points out that + when nausea and vomiting are absent or suddenly cease there is + often reason to suspect something wrong, especially the death of + the embryo. He also remarks that women who suffer from large + varicose veins are seldom troubled by the nausea of pregnancy. + (J.M.H. Martin, "The Vomiting of Pregnancy," _British Medical + Journal_, December 10, 1904.) These observations may be connected + with those of Evans (_American Gynæcological and Obstetrical + Journal_, January, 1900), who attributes primary importance to + the undoubtedly active factor of the irritation set up by the + uterus, more especially the rhythmic uterine contractions; + stimulation of the breasts produces active uterine contractions, + and Evans found that examination of the breasts sufficed to bring + on a severe attack of vomiting, while on another occasion this + was produced by a vaginal examination. Evans believes that the + purpose of these contractions is to facilitate the circulation of + the blood through the large venous sinuses, the surcharging of + the relatively stagnant pools with effete blood producing the + irritation which leads to rhythmic contractions. + +It is on the basis of the increased vascular and glandular activity and +the heightened nervous tension that the special psychic phenomena of +pregnancy develop. The best known, and perhaps the most characteristic of +these manifestations, is that known as "longings." By this term is meant +more or less irresistible desires for some special food or drink, which +may be digestible or indigestible, sometimes a substance which the woman +ordinarily likes, such as fruit, and occasionally one which, under +ordinary circumstances, she dislikes, as in one case known to me of a +young country woman who, when bearing her child, was always longing for +tobacco and never happy except when she could get a pipe to smoke, +although under ordinary circumstances, like other young women of her +class, she was without any desire to smoke. Occasionally the longings lead +to actions which are more unscrupulous than is common in the case of the +same person at other times; thus in one case known to me a young woman, +pregnant with her first child, insisted to her sister's horror on entering +a strawberry field and eating a quantity of fruit. These "longings" in +their extreme form may properly be considered as neurasthenic obsessions, +but in their simple and less pronounced forms they may well be normal and +healthy. + + The old medical authors abound in narratives describing the + longings of pregnant women for natural and unnatural foods. This + affection was commonly called _pica_, sometimes _citra_ or + _malatia_. Schurig, whose works are a comprehensive treasure + house of ancient medical lore, devotes a long chapter (cap. II) + of his _Chylologia_, published in 1725, to pica as manifested + mainly, though not exclusively, in pregnant women. Some women, he + tells us, have been compelled to eat all sorts of earthy + substances, of which sand seems the most common, and one Italian + woman when pregnant ate several pounds of sand with much + satisfaction, following it up with a draught of her own urine. + Lime, mud, chalk, charcoal, cinders, pitch are also the desired + substances in other cases detailed. One pregnant woman must eat + bread fresh from the oven in very large quantities, and a certain + noble matron ate 140 sweet cakes in one day and night. Wheat and + various kinds of corn as well as of vegetables were the foods + desired by many longing women. One woman was responsible for 20 + pounds of pepper, another ate ginger in large quantities, a third + kept mace under her pillow; cinnamon, salt, emulsion of almonds, + treacle, mushrooms were desired by others. Cherries were longed + for by one, and another ate 30 or 40 lemons in one night. Various + kinds of fish--mullet, oysters, crabs, live eels, etc.--are + mentioned, while other women have found delectation in lizards, + frogs, spiders and flies, even scorpions, lice and fleas. A + pregnant woman, aged 33, of sanguine temperament, ate a live fowl + completely with intense satisfaction. Skin, wool, cotton, thread, + linen, blotting paper have been desired, as well as more + repulsive substances, such as nasal mucus and feces (eaten with + bread). Vinegar, ice, and snow occur in other cases. One woman + stilled a desire for human flesh by biting the nates of children + or the arms of men. Metals are also swallowed, such as iron, + silver, etc. One pregnant woman wished to throw eggs in her + husband's face, and another to have her husband throw eggs in her + face. + + In the next chapter of the same work Schurig describes cases of + acute antipathy which may arise under the same circumstances + (cap. III, "De Nausea seu Antipathia certorum ciborum"). The list + includes bread, meat, fowls, fish, eels (a very common + repulsion), crabs, milk, butter (very often), cheese (often), + honey, sugar, salt, eggs, caviar, sulphur, apples (especially + their odor), strawberries, mulberries, cinnamon, mace, capers, + pepper, onions, mustard, beetroot, rice, mint, absinthe, roses + (many pages are devoted to this antipathy), lilies, elder + flowers, musk (which sometimes caused vomiting), amber, coffee, + opiates, olive oil, vinegar, cats, frogs, spiders, wasps, swords. + + More recently Gould and Pyle (_Anomalies and Curiosities of + Medicine_, p. 80) have briefly summarized some of the ancient and + modern records concerning the longings of pregnant women. + +Various theories are put forward concerning the causation of the longings +of pregnant women, but none of these seems to furnish by itself a complete +and adequate explanation of all cases. Thus it is said that the craving is +the expression of a natural instinct, the system of the pregnant woman +really requiring the food she longs for. It is quite probable that this is +so in many cases, but it is obviously not so in the majority of cases, +even when we confine ourselves to the longings for fairly natural foods, +while we know so little of the special needs of the organism during +pregnancy that the theory in any case is insusceptible of clear +demonstration. + +Allied to this theory is the explanation that the longings are for things +that counteract the tendency to nausea and sickness. Giles, however, in +his valuable statistical study of the longings of a series of 300 pregnant +women, has shown that the percentage of women with longings is exactly the +same (33 per cent.) among women who had suffered at some time during +pregnancy from sickness as among the women who had not so suffered. +Moreover, Giles found that the period of sickness frequently bore no +relation to the time when there were cravings, and the patient often had +cravings after the sickness had ceased. + +According to another theory these longings are mainly a matter of +auto-suggestion. The pregnant woman has received the tradition of such +longings, persuades herself that she has such a longing, and then becomes +convinced that, according to a popular belief, it will be bad for the +child if the longing is not gratified. Giles considers that this process +of auto-suggestion takes place "in a certain number, perhaps even in the +majority of cases."[184] + + The Duchess d'Abrantès, the wife of Marshal Junot, in her + _Mémoires_ gives an amusing account of how in her first pregnancy + a longing was apparently imposed upon her by the anxious + solicitude of her own and her husband's relations. Though + suffering from constant nausea and sickness, she had no longings. + One day at dinner after the pregnancy had gone on for some months + her mother suddenly put down her fork, exclaiming: "I have never + asked you what longing you have!" She replied with truth that she + had none, her days and her nights being occupied with suffering. + "No _envie!_" said the mother, "such a thing was never heard of. + I must speak to your mother-in-law." The two old ladies consulted + anxiously and explained to the young mother how an unsatisfied + longing might produce a monstrous child, and the husband also now + began to ask her every day what she longed for. Her + sister-in-law, moreover, brought her all sorts of stories of + children born with appalling mother's marks due to this cause. + She became frightened and began to wonder what she most wanted, + but could think of nothing. At last, when eating a pastille + flavored with pineapple, it occurred to her that pineapple is an + excellent fruit, and one, moreover, which she had never seen, for + at that time it was extremely rare. Thereupon she began to long + for pineapple, and all the more when she was told that at that + season they could not be obtained. She now began to feel that she + must have pineapple or die, and her husband ran all over Paris, + vainly offering twenty louis for a pineapple. At last he + succeeded in obtaining one through the kindness of Mme. + Bonaparte, and drove home furiously just as his wife, always + talking of pineapples, had gone to bed. He entered the room with + the pineapple, to the great satisfaction of the Duchess's mother. + (In one of her own pregnancies, it appears, she longed in vain + for cherries in January, and the child was born with a mark on + her body resembling a cherry--in scientific terminology, a + _nævus_.) The Duchess effusively thanked her husband and wished + to eat of the fruit immediately, but her husband stopped her and + said that Corvisart, the famous physician, had told him that she + must on no account touch it at night, as it was extremely + indigestible. She promised not to do so, and spent the night in + caressing the pineapple. In the morning the husband came and cut + up the fruit, presenting it to her in a porcelain bowl. Suddenly, + however, there was a revulsion of feeling; she felt that she + could not possibly eat pineapple; persuasion was useless; the + fruit had to be taken away and the windows opened, for the very + smell of it had become odious. The Duchess adds that henceforth, + throughout her life, though still liking the flavor, she was only + able to eat pineapple by doing a sort of violence to herself. + (_Mémories de la Duchesse d'Abrantès_, vol. iii, Chapter VIII.) + It should be added that, in old age, the Duchess d'Abrantès + appears to have become insane. + +The influence of suggestion must certainly be accepted as, at all events, +increasing and emphasizing the tendency to longings. It can scarcely, +however, be regarded as a radical and adequate explanation of the +phenomenon generally. If it is a matter of auto-suggestion due to a +tradition, then we should expect to find longings most frequent and most +pronounced in multiparous women, who are best acquainted with the +tradition and best able to experience all that is expected of a pregnant +woman. But, as a matter of fact, the women who have borne most children +are precisely those who are least likely to be affected by the longings +which tradition demands they should manifest. Giles has shown that +longings occur much more frequently in the first than in any subsequent +pregnancy; there is a regular decrease with the increase in number of +pregnancies until in women with ten or more children the longings scarcely +occur at all. + +We must probably regard longings as based on a physiological and psychic +tendency which is of universal extension and almost or quite normal. They +are known throughout Europe and were known to the medical writers of +antiquity. Old Indian as well as old Jewish physicians recognized them. +They have been noted among many savage races to-day: among the Indians of +North and South America, among the peoples of the Nile and the Soudan, in +the Malay archipelago.[185] In Europe they are most common among the +women of the people, living simple and natural lives.[186] + +The true normal relationship of the longings of pregnancy is with the +impulsive and often irresistible longings for food delicacies which are +apt to overcome children, and in girls often persist or revive through +adolescence and even beyond. Such sudden fits of greediness belong to +those kind of normal psychic manifestations which are on the verge of the +abnormal into which they occasionally pass. They may occur, however, in +healthy, well-bred, and well-behaved children who, under the stress of the +sudden craving, will, without compunction and apparently without +reflection, steal the food they long for or even steal from their parents +the money to buy it. The food thus seized by a well-nigh irresistible +craving is nearly always a fruit. Fruit is usually doled out to children +in small quantities as a luxury, but we are descended from primitive human +peoples and still more remote ape-like ancestors, by whom fruit was in its +season eaten copiously, and it is not surprising that when that season +comes round the child, more sensitive than the adult to primitive +influences, should sometimes experience the impulse of its ancestors with +overwhelming intensity, all the more so if, as is probable, the craving is +to some extent the expression of a physiological need. + + Sanford Bell, who has investigated the food impulses of children + in America, finds that girls have a greater number of likes and + dislikes in foods than boys of the same age, though at the same + time they have less dislikes to some foods than boys. The + proclivity for sweets and fruits shows itself as soon as a child + begins to eat solids. The chief fruits liked are oranges, + bananas, apples, peaches, and pears. This strong preference for + fruits lasts till the age of 13 or 14, though relatively weaker + from 10 to 13. In girls, however, Bell notes the significant fact + from our present point of view that at mid-adolescence there is a + revived taste for sweets and fruits. He believes that the growth + of children in taste in foods recapitulates the experience of the + race. (S. Bell, "An Introductory Study of the Psychology of + Foods." _Pedagogical Seminary_, March, 1904.) + +The heightened nervous impressionability of pregnancy would appear to +arouse into activity those primitive impulses which are liable to occur in +childhood and in the unmarried girl continue to the nubile age. It is a +significant fact that the longings of pregnant women are mainly for fruit, +and notably for so wholesome a fruit as the apple, which may very well +have a beneficial effect on the system of the pregnant woman. Giles, in +his tabulation of the foods longed for by 300 pregnant women, found that +the fruit group was by far the largest, furnishing 79 cases; apples were +far away at the head, occurring in 34 cases out of the 99 who had +longings, while oranges followed at a distance (with 13 cases), and in the +vegetable group tomatoes came first (with 6 cases). Several women declared +"I could have lived on apples," "I was eating apples all day," "I used to +sit up in bed eating apples."[187] Pregnant women appear seldom to long +for the possession of objects outside the edible class, and it seems +doubtful whether they have any special tendency to kleptomania. Pinard has +pointed out that neither Lasègue nor Lunier, in their studies of +kleptomania, have mentioned a single shop robbery committed by a pregnant +woman.[188] Brouardel has indeed found such cases, but the object stolen +was usually a food. + +A further significant fact connecting the longings of pregnant women with +the longings of children is to be found in the fact that they occur mainly +in young women. We have, indeed, no tabulation of the ages of pregnant +women who have manifested longings, but Giles has clearly shown that these +chiefly occur in primiparæ, and steadily and rapidly decrease in each +successive pregnancy. This fact, otherwise somewhat difficult of +explanation, is natural if we look upon the longings of pregnancy as a +revival of those of childhood. It certainly indicates also that we can by +no means regard these longings as exclusively the expression of a +physiological craving, for in that case they would be liable to occur in +any pregnancy unless, indeed, it is argued that with each successive +pregnancy the woman becomes less sensitive to her own physiological state. + + There has been a frequent tendency, more especially among + primitive peoples, to regard a pregnant woman's longings as + something sacred and to be indulged, all the more, no doubt, as + they are usually of a simple and harmless character. In the Black + Forest, according to Ploss and Bartels, a pregnant woman may go + freely into other people's gardens and take fruit, provided she + eats it on the spot, and very similar privileges are accorded to + her elsewhere. Old English opinion, as reflected, for instance, + in Ben Jonson's plays (as Dr. Harriet C.B. Alexander has pointed + out), regards the pregnant woman as not responsible for her + longings, and Kiernan remarks ("Kleptomania and Collectivism," + _Alienist and Neurologist_, November, 1902) that this is in "a + most natural and just view." In France at the Revolution a law of + the 28th Germinal, in the year III, to some extent admitted the + irresponsibility of the pregnant woman generally,--following the + classic precedent, by which a woman could not be brought before a + court of justice so long as she was pregnant,--but the Napoleonic + code, never tender to women, abrogated this. Pinard does not + consider that the longings of pregnant women are irresistible, + and, consequently, regards the pregnant woman as responsible. + This is probably the view most widely held. In any case these + longings seldom come up for medico-legal consideration. + +The phenomena of the longings of pregnancy are linked to the much more +obscure and dubious phenomena of the influence of maternal impressions on +the child within the womb. It is true, indeed, that there is no real +connection whatever between these two groups of manifestations, but they +have been so widely and for so long closely associated in the popular mind +that it is convenient to pass directly from one to the other. The same +name is sometimes given to the two manifestations; thus in France a +pregnant longing is an _envie_, while a mother's mark on the child is also +called an _envie_, because it is supposed to be due to the mother's +unsatisfied longing. + +The conception of a "maternal impression" (the German _Versehen_) rests on +the belief that a powerful mental influence working on the mother's mind +may produce an impression, either general or definite, on the child she is +carrying. It makes a great deal of difference whether the effect of the +impression on the child is general, or definite and circumscribed. It is +not difficult to believe that a general effect--even, as Sir Arthur +Mitchell first gave good reason for believing, idiocy--may be produced on +the child by strong and prolonged emotional influence working on the +mother, because such general influence may be transmitted through a +deteriorated blood-stream. But it is impossible at present to understand +how a definite and limited influence working on the mother could produce a +definite and limited effect on the child, for there are no channels of +nervous communications for the passage of such influences. Our difficulty +in conceiving of the process must, however, be put aside if the fact +itself can be demonstrated by convincing evidence. + + In order to illustrate the nature of maternal impressions, I will + summarize a few cases which I have collected from the best + medical periodical literature during the past fifteen years. I + have exercised no selection and in no way guarantee the + authenticity of the alleged facts or the alleged explanation. + They are merely examples to illustrate a class of cases published + from time to time by medical observers in medical journals of + high repute. + + Early in pregnancy a woman found her pet rabbit killed by a cat + which had gnawed off the two forepaws, leaving ragged stumps; she + was for a long time constantly thinking of this. Her child was + born with deformed feet, one foot with only two toes, the other + three, the os calcis in both feet being either absent or little + developed. (G.B. Beale, Tottenham, _Lancet_, May 4, 1889). + + Three months and a half before birth of the child the father, a + glazier, fell through the roof of a hothouse, severely cutting + his right arm, so that he was lying in the infirmary for a long + time, and it was doubtful whether the hand could be saved. The + child was healthy, but on the flexor surface of the radial side + of the right forearm just above the wrist--the same spot as the + father's injury--there was a nævus the size of a sixpence. (W. + Russell, Paisley, _Lancet_, May 11, 1889.) + + At the beginning of pregnancy a woman was greatly scared by being + kicked over by a frightened cow she was milking; she hung on to + the animal's teats, but thought she would be trampled to death, + and was ill and nervous for weeks afterwards. The child was a + monster, with a fleshy substance--seeming to be prolonged from + the spinal cord and to represent the brain--projecting from the + floor of the skull. Both doctor and nurse were struck by the + resemblance to a cow's teats before they knew the woman's story, + and this was told by the woman immediately after delivery and + before she knew to what she had given birth. (A. Ross Paterson, + Reversby, Lincolnshire, _Lancet_, September 29, 1889.) + + During the second month of pregnancy the mother was terrified by + a bullock as she was returning from market. The child reached + full term and was a well-developed male, stillborn. Its head + "exactly resembled a miniature cow's head;" the occipital bone + was absent, the parietals only slightly developed, the eyes were + placed at the top of the frontal bone, which was quite flat, with + each of its superior angles twisted into a rudimentary horn. + (J.T. Hislop, Tavistock, Devon, _Lancet_, November 1, 1890.) + + When four months pregnant the mother, a multipara of 30, was + startled by a black and white collie dog suddenly pushing against + her and rushing out when she opened the door. This preyed on her + mind, and she felt sure her child would be marked. The whole of + the child's right thigh was encircled by a shining black mole, + studded with white hairs; there was another mole on the spine of + the left scapula. (C.F. Williamson, Horley, Surrey, _Lancet_, + October 11, 1890.) + + A lady in comfortable circumstances, aged 24, not markedly + emotional, with one child, in all respects healthy, early in her + pregnancy saw a man begging whose arms and legs were "all doubled + up." This gave her a shock, but she hoped no ill effects would + follow. The child was an encephalous monster, with the + extremities rigidly flexed and the fingers clenched, the feet + almost sole to sole. In the next pregnancy she frequently passed + a man who was a partial cripple, but she was not unduly + depressed; the child was a counterpart of the last, except that + the head was normal. The next child was strong and well formed. + (C.W. Chapman, London, _Lancet_, October 18, 1890.) + + When the pregnant mother was working in a hayfield her husband + threw at her a young hare he had found in the hay; it struck her + on the cheek and neck. Her daughter has on the left cheek an + oblong patch of soft dark hair, in color and character clearly + resembling the fur of a very young hare. (A. Mackay, Port Appin, + N.B., _Lancet_, December 19, 1891. The writer records also four + other cases which have happened in his experience.) + + When the mother was pregnant her husband had to attend to a sow + who could not give birth to her pigs; he bled her freely, cutting + a notch out of both ears. His wife insisted on seeing the sow. + The helix of each ear of her child at birth was gone, for nearly + or quite half an inch, as if cut purposely. (R.P. Roons, _Medical + World_, 1894.) + + A lady when pregnant was much interested in a story in which one + of the characters had a supernumerary digit, and this often + recurred to her mind. Her baby had a supernumerary digit on one + hand. (J. Jenkyns, Aberdeen, _British Medical Journal_, March 2, + 1895. The writer also records another case.) + + When pregnant the mother saw in the forest a new-born fawn which + was a double monstrosity. Her child was a similar double + monstrosity (_cephalothora copagus_). (Hartmann, _Münchener + Medicinisches Wochenschrift_, No. 9, 1895.) + + A well developed woman of 30, who had ten children in twelve + years, in the third month of her tenth pregnancy saw a child run + over by a street car, which crushed the upper and back part of + its head. Her own child was anencephalic and acranial, with + entire absence of vault of skull. (F.A. Stahl, _American Journal + of Obstetrics_, April, 1896.) + + A healthy woman with no skin blemish had during her third + pregnancy a violent appetite for sunfish. During or after the + fourth month her husband, as a surprise, brought her some sunfish + alive, placing them in a pail of water in the porch. She stumbled + against the pail and the shock caused the fish to flap over the + pail and come in violent contact with her leg. The cold wriggling + fish produced a nervous shock, but she attached no importance to + this. The child (a girl) had at birth a mark of bronze pigment + resembling a fish with the head uppermost (photograph given) on + the corresponding part of the same leg. Daughter's health good; + throughout life she has had a strong craving for sunfish, which + she has sometimes eaten till she has vomited from repletion. + (C.F. Gardiner, Colorado Springs, _American Journal Obstetrics_, + February, 1898.) + + The next case occurred in a bitch. A thoroughbred fox terrier + bitch strayed and was discovered a day or two later with her + right foreleg broken. The limb was set under chloroform with the + help of Röntgen rays, and the dog made a good recovery. Several + weeks later she gave birth to a puppy with a right foreleg that + was ill-developed and minus the paw. (J. Booth, Cork, _British + Medical Journal_, September 16, 1899.) + + Four months before the birth of her child a woman with four + healthy children and no history of deformity in the family fell + and cut her left wrist severely against a broken bowl; she had a + great fright and shock. Her child, otherwise perfect, was born + without left hand and wrist, the stump of arm terminating at + lower end of radius and ulna. (G. Ainslie Johnston, Ambleside, + _British Medical Journal_, April 18, 1903.) + +The belief in the reality of the transference of strong mental or physical +impressions on the mother into physical changes in the child she is +bearing is very ancient and widespread. Most writers on the subject begin +with the book of Genesis and the astute device of Jacob in influencing the +color of his lambs by mental impressions on his ewes. But the belief +exists among even more primitive people than the early Hebrews, and in all +parts of the world.[189] Among the Greeks there is a trace of the belief +in Hippocrates, the first of the world's great physicians, while Soranus, +the most famous of ancient gynæcologists, states the matter in the most +precise manner, with instances in proof. The belief continued to persist +unquestioned throughout the Middle Ages. The first author who denied the +influence of maternal impressions altogether appears to have been the +famous anatomist, Realdus Columbus, who was a professor at Padua, Pisa, +and Rome at the beginning of the sixteenth century. In the same century, +however, another and not less famous Neapolitan, Della Porta, for the +first time formulated a definite theory of maternal impressions. A little +later, early in the seventeenth century, a philosophic physician at Padua, +Fortunatus Licetus, took up an intermediate position which still finds, +perhaps reasonably, a great many adherents. He recognized that a very +frequent cause of malformation in the child is to be found in morbid +antenatal conditions, but at the same time was not prepared to deny +absolutely and in every case the influence of maternal impression on such +conditions. Malebranche, the Platonic philosopher, allowed the greatest +extension to the power of the maternal imagination. In the eighteenth +century, however, the new spirit of free inquiry, of radical criticism, +and unfettered logic, led to a sceptical attitude toward this ancient +belief then flourishing vigorously.[190] In 1727, a few years after +Malebranche's death, James Blondel, a physician of extreme acuteness, who +had been born in Paris, was educated at Leyden, and practiced in London, +published the first methodical and thorough attack on the doctrine of +maternal impressions, _The Strength of Imagination of Pregnant Women +Examined_, and exercised his great ability in ridiculing it. Haller, +Roederer, and Sömmering followed in the steps of Blondel, and were either +sceptical or hostile to the ancient belief. Blumenbach, however, admitted +the influence of maternal impressions. Erasmus Darwin, as well as Goethe +in his _Wahlverwandtschaften_, even accepted the influence of paternal +impressions on the child. By the beginning of the nineteenth century the +majority of physicians were inclined to relegate maternal impressions to +the region of superstition. Yet the exceptions were of notable importance. +Burdach, when all deductions were made, still found it necessary to retain +the belief in maternal impressions, and Von Baer, the founder of +embryology, also accepted it, supported by a case, occurring in his own +sister, which he was able to investigate before the child's birth. L.W.T. +Bischoff, also, while submitting the doctrine to acute criticism, found it +impossible to reject maternal impressions absolutely, and he remarked that +the number of adherents to the doctrine was showing a tendency to increase +rather than diminish. Johannes Müller, the founder of modern physiology in +Germany, declared himself against it, and his influence long prevailed; +Valentin, Rudolf Wagner, and Emil du Bois-Reymond were on the same side. +On the other hand various eminent gynæcologists--Litzmann, Roth, Hennig, +etc.--have argued in favor of the reality of maternal impressions.[191] + +The long conflict of opinion which has taken place over this opinion has +still left the matter unsettled. The acutest critics of the ancient +belief constantly conclude the discussion with an expression of doubt and +uncertainty. Even if the majority of authorities are inclined to reject +maternal impressions, the scientific eminence of those who accept them +makes a decisive opinion difficult. The arguments against such influence +are perfectly sound: (1) it is a primitive belief of unscientific origin; +(2) it is impossible to conceive how such influence can operate since +there is no nervous connection between mother and child; (3) comparatively +few cases have been submitted to severe critical investigation; (4) it is +absurd to ascribe developmental defects to influences which arise long +after the foetus had assumed its definite shape[192]; (5) in any case the +phenomenon must be rare, for William Hunter could not find a coincidence +between maternal impressions and foetal marks through a period of several +years, and Bischoff found no case in 11,000 deliveries. These statements +embody the whole of the argument against maternal impressions, yet it is +clear that they do not settle the matter. Edgar, in a manual of obstetrics +which is widely regarded as a standard work, states that this is "yet a +mooted question."[193] Ballantyne, again, in a discussion of this +influence at the Edinburgh Obstetrical Society, summarizing the result of +a year's inquiry, concluded that it is still "_sub judice_."[194] In a +subsequent discussion of the question he has somewhat modified his +opinion, and is inclined to deny that definite impressions on the pregnant +woman's mind can cause similar defects in the foetus; they are "accidental +coincidences," but he adds that a few of the cases are difficult to +explain away. At the same time he fully believes that prolonged and +strongly marked mental states of the mother may affect the development of +the foetus in her uterus, causing vascular and nutritive disturbances, +irregularities of development, and idiocy.[195] + + Whether and in how far mental impressions on the mother can + produce definite mental and emotional disposition in the child is + a special aspect of the question to which scarcely any inquiry + has been devoted. So distinguished a biologist as Mr. A.W. + Wallace has, however, called attention to this point, bringing + forward evidence on the question and emphasizing the need of + further investigation. "Such transmission of mental influence," + he remarks, "will hardly be held to be impossible or even very + improbable," (A.W. Wallace, "Prenatal Influences on Character," + _Nature_, August 24, 1893.) + +It has already been pointed out that a large number of cases of foetal +deformities, supposed to be due to maternal impressions, cannot possibly +be so caused because the impression took place at a period when the +development of the foetus must already have been decided. In this +connection, however, it must be noted that Dabney has observed a +relationship between the time of supposed mental impressions and the +nature of the actual defect which is of considerable significance as an +argument in favor of the influence of mental impressions. He tabulated 90 +carefully reported cases from recent medical literature, and found that 21 +of them were concerned with defects of structure of the lips and palate. +In all but 2 of these 21 the defect was referred to an impression +occurring within the first three months of pregnancy. This is an important +point as showing that the assigned cause really falls within a period when +a defect of development actually could produce the observed result, +although the person reporting the cases was in many instances manifestly +ignorant of the details of embryology and teratology. There was no such +preponderance of early impressions among the defects of skin and hair +which might well, so far as development is concerned, have been caused at +a later period; here, in 7 out of 15 cases, it was distinctly stated that +the impression was made later than the fourth month.[196] + +It would seem, on the whole, that while the influence of maternal +impressions in producing definite effects on the child within the womb has +by no means been positively demonstrated, we are not entitled to reject it +with any positive assurance. Even if we accept it, however, it must +remain, for the present, an inexplicable fact; the _modus operandi_ we can +scarcely even guess at. General influences from the mother on the child we +can easily conceive of as conveyed by the mother's blood; we can even +suppose that the modified blood might act specifically on one particular +kind of tissue. We can, again, as suggested by Féré, very well believe +that the maternal emotions act upon the womb and produce various kinds and +degrees of pressure on the child within, so that the apparently active +movements of the foetus may be really consecutive on unconscious maternal +excitations.[197] We may also believe that, as suggested by John Thomson, +there are slight incoördinations _in utero_, a kind of developmental +neurosis, produced by some slight lack of harmony of whatever origin, and +leading to the production of malformations.[198] We know, finally, that, +as Féré and others have repeatedly demonstrated during recent years by +experiments on chickens, etc., very subtle agents, even odors, may +profoundly affect embryonic development and produce deformity. But how the +mother's psychic disposition can, apart from heredity, affect specifically +the physical conformation or even the psychic disposition of the child +within her womb must remain for the present an insoluble mystery, even if +we feel disposed to conclude that in some cases such action seems to be +indicated. + + In comprehending such a connection, however at present + undemonstrated, it may well be borne in mind that the + relationship of the mother to the child within her womb is of a + uniquely intimate character. It is of interest in this + connection to quote some remarks by an able psychologist, Dr. + Henry Rutgers Marshall; the remarks are not less interesting for + being brought forward without any connection with the question of + maternal impressions: "It is true that, so far as we know, the + nervous system of the embryo never has a direct connection with + the nervous system of the mother: nevertheless, as there is a + reciprocity of reaction between the physical body of the mother + and its embryonic parasite, the relation of the embryonic nervous + system to the nervous system of the mother is not very far + removed from the relation of the pre-eminent part of the nervous + system of a man to some minor nervous system within his body + which is to a marked extent dissociated from the whole neural + mass. + + "Correspondingly, then, and within the consciousness of the + mother, there develops a new little minor consciousness which, + although but lightly integrated with the mass of her + consciousness, nevertheless has its part in her consciousness + taken as a whole, much as the psychic correspondents of the + action of the nerve which govern the secretions of the glands of + the body have their part in her consciousness taken as a whole. + + "It is very much as if the optic ganglia developed fully in + themselves, without any closer connection with the rest of the + brain than existed at their first appearance. They would form a + little complex nervous system almost but not quite apart from the + brain system; and it would be difficult to deny them a + consciousness of their own; which would indeed form part of the + whole consciousness of the individual, but which would be in a + manner self-dependent." It must, if this is so, be said that + before birth, on the psychic side, the embryo's activities "form + part of a complex consciousness which is that of the mother and + embryo together." "Without subscribing to the strange stories of + telepathy, of the solemn apparition of a person somewhere at the + moment of his death a thousand miles away, of the unquiet ghost + haunting the scenes of its bygone hopes and endeavors, one may + ask" (with the author of the address in medicine at the Leicester + gathering of the British Medical Association, _British Medical + Journal_, July 29, 1905) "whether two brains cannot be so tuned + in sympathy as to transmit and receive a subtile transfusion of + mind without mediation of sense. Considering what is implied by + the human brain with its countless millions of cells, its + complexities of minute structure, its innumerable chemical + compositions, and the condensed forces in its microscopic and + ultramicroscopic elements--the whole a sort of microcosm of + cosmic forces to which no conceivable compound of electric + batteries is comparable; considering, again, that from an + electric station waves of energy radiate through the viewless air + to be caught up by a fit receiver a thousand miles distant, it is + not inconceivable that the human brain may send off still more + subtile waves to be accepted and interpreted by the fitly tuned + receiving brain. Is it, after all, mere fancy that a mental + atmosphere or effluence emanates from one person to affect + another, either soothing sympathetically or irritating + antipathically?" These remarks (like Dr. Marshall's) were made + without reference to maternal impressions, but it may be pointed + out that under no conceivable circumstance could we find a brain + in so virginal and receptive a state as is the child's in the + womb. + +On the whole we see that pregnancy induces a psychic state which is at +once, in healthy persons, one of full development and vigor, and at the +same time one which, especially in individuals who are slightly abnormal, +is apt to involve a state of strained or overstrained nervous tension and +to evoke various manifestations which are in many respects still +imperfectly understood. Even the specifically sexual emotions tend to be +heightened, more especially during the earlier period of pregnancy. In 24 +cases of pregnancy in which the point was investigated by Harry Campbell, +sexual feeling was decidedly increased in 8, in one case (of a woman aged +31 who had had four children) being indeed only present during pregnancy, +when it was considerable; in only 7 cases was there diminution or +disappearance of sexual feeling.[199] Pregnancy may produce mental +depression;[200] but on the other hand it frequently leads to a change of +the most favorable character in the mental and general well-being. Some +women indeed are only well during pregnancy. It is remarkable that some +women who habitually suffer from various nervous troubles--neuralgias, +gastralgia, headache, insomnia--are only free from them at this moment. +This "paradox of gestation," as Vinay has termed it, is specially marked +in the hysterical and those suffering from slight nervous disorders, but +it is by no means universal, so that although it is possible, Vinay +states, to confirm the opinion of the ancients as to the beneficial +action of marriage on hysteria, that is only true of slight cases and +scarcely enables us to counsel marriage in hysteria.[201] Even a woman's +intelligence is sometimes heightened by pregnancy, and Tarnier, as quoted +by Vinay, knew many women whose intelligence, habitually somewhat obtuse, +has only risen to the normal level during pregnancy.[202] The pregnant +woman has reached the climax of womanhood; she has attained to that state +toward which the periodically recurring menstrual wave has been drifting +her at regular intervals throughout her sexual life[203]; she has achieved +that function for which her body has been constructed, and her mental and +emotional disposition adapted, through countless ages. + +And yet, as we have seen, our ignorance of the changes effected by the +occurrence of this supremely important event--even on the physical +side--still remains profound. Pregnancy, even for us, the critical and +unprejudiced children of a civilized age, still remains, as for the +children of more primitive ages, a mystery. Conception itself is a mystery +for the primitive man, and may be produced by all sorts of subtle ways +apart from sexual connection, even by smelling a flower.[204] The pregnant +woman was surrounded by ceremonies, by reverence and fear, often shut up +in a place apart.[205] Her presence, her exhalations, were of extreme +potency; even in some parts of Europe to-day, as in the Walloon districts +of Belgium, a pregnant woman must not kiss a child for her breath is +dangerous, or urinate on plants for she will kill them.[206] The mystery +has somewhat changed its form; it still remains. The future of the race is +bound up with our efforts to fathom the mystery of pregnancy. "The early +days of human life," it has been truly said, "are entirely one with the +mother. On her manner of life--eating, drinking, sleeping, and +thinking--what greatness may not hang?"[207] Schopenhauer observed, with +misapplied horror, that there is nothing a woman is less modest about than +the state of pregnancy, while Weininger exclaims: "Never yet has a +pregnant woman given expression in any form--poem, memoirs, or +gynæcological monograph--to her sensations or feelings."[208] Yet when we +contemplate the mystery of pregnancy and all that it involves, how trivial +all such considerations become! We are here lifted into a region where our +highest intelligence can only lead us to adoration, for we are gazing at a +process in which the operations of Nature become one with the divine task +of Creation. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[169] See, e.g., Groos, _Æsthetische Genuss_, p. 249. "We have to admit," +Groos observes, "the entrance of another instinct, the impulse to tend and +foster, so closely connected with the sexual life. It is seemingly due to +the co-operation of this impulse that the little female bird during +courtship is so often fed by the male like a young fledgling. In man +'love' from the biological standpoint is also an amalgamation of two +needs; when the tender need to protect and foster and serve is lacking the +emotion is not quite perfect. Heine's expression, 'With my mantle I +protect you from the storm,' has always seemed to me very characteristic." +Sometimes the sexual impulse may undergo a complete transformation in this +direction. "I believe there is really a tendency in women," a lady writes +in a letter, "to allow maternal feeling to take the place of sexual +feeling. Very often a woman's feeling for her husband becomes this (though +he may be twenty years older than herself); sometimes it does not, +remaining purely sex feeling. Sometimes it is for some other man she has +this curious self-obliterating maternal feeling. It is not necessarily +connected with sex intercourse. A prostitute, who has relations with +dozens of men, may have it for some feeble drunken fool, who perhaps goes +after other women. I once saw the change from sex feeling to mother +feeling, as I call it, come almost suddenly over a woman after she had +lived about four years with a man who was unfaithful to her. Then, when +all real sex feeling, the hatred of the woman he followed, the desire he +should give her love and tenderness, had all gone, came the other feeling, +and she said to me, 'You don't understand at all; he's only my little +baby; nothing he does can make any difference to me now.' As I grow older +and understand women's natures better, I can see almost at once which +relation it is a woman has to her husband, or any given man. It is this +feeling, and not sex passion, that keeps woman from being free." Not only +is there a sexual association in the impulse to foster and protect, there +would appear to be a similar element also in the response to that impulse. +Freud has especially insisted on the partly sexual character of the +child's feelings for those who care for it and tend it and satisfy its +needs. It is begun in earliest infancy; "whoever has seen the sated infant +sink back from the breast, to fall asleep with flushed cheeks and happy +smile, must say that the picture is adequate to the expression of the +sexual satisfaction of later life." The lips, moreover, are the earliest +erogenous zone. "There will, perhaps, be some opposition," Freud remarks +(_Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie_, pp. 36, 64), "to the +identification of the child's feelings of tenderness and appreciation for +those who tend it with sexual love, but I believe that exact psychological +analysis will place the identity beyond doubt. The relationship of the +child with the person who tends it is for it a continual source of sexual +excitement and satisfaction flowing from the erogenous zones, especially +since the fostering person--as a rule the mother--regards the child with +emotions which proceed from her sexual life; strokes it, kisses it, rocks +it, and very plainly treats it as a compensation for a fully valid sexual +object." Freud remarks that girls who retain the childish character of +their love for their parents to adult age are apt to make cold wives and +to be sexually anæsthetic. + +[170] Esbach (in his _Thèse de Paris_, published in 1876) showed that even +the finger nails are affected in pregnancy and become measurably thinner. + +[171] C.H. Stratz, _Die Schönheit des Weiblichen Körpers_, Chapter VI. + +[172] Iron appears to be liberated in the maternal organism during +pregnancy, and Wychgel has shown (_Zeitschrift für Geburtshülfe und +Gynäkologie_, bd. xlvii, Heft II) that the pigment of pregnant women +contains iron, and that the amount of iron in the urine is increased. + +[173] Vinay, _Maladies de la Grossesse_, Chapter VIII; K. Hennig, +"Exploratio Externa," _Comptes-rendus du XIIe. Congrès International de +Médècine_, vol. vi, Section XIII, pp. 144-166. A bibliography of the +literature concerning the physiology of pregnancy, extending to ten pages, +is appended by Pinard to his article "Grossesse," _Dictionnaire +Encyclopédique des Sciences Médicales_. + +[174] Stratz, op. cit., Chapter XII. + +[175] W.S.A. Griffith, "The Diagnosis of Pregnancy," _British Medical +Journal_, April 11, 1903. + +[176] J. Mackenzie and H.O. Nicholson, "The Heart in Pregnancy," _British +Medical Journal_, October 8, 1904; Stengel and Stanton, "The Condition of +the Heart in Pregnancy," _Medical Record_, May 10, 1902 and _University +Pennsylvania Medical Bulletin_, Sept., 1904 (summarized in _British +Medical Journal_, August 16, 1902, and Sept. 23, 1905.) + +[177] J. Henderson, "Maternal Blood at Term," _Journal of Obstetrics and +Gynæcology_, February, 1902; C. Douglas, "The Blood in Pregnant Women," +_British Medical Journal_, March 26, 1904; W.L. Thompson, "The Blood in +Pregnancy," _Johns Hopkins Hospital Bulletin_, June, 1904. + +[178] H.O. Nicholson, "Some Remarks on the Maternal Circulation in +Pregnancy," _British Medical Journal_, October 3, 1903. + +[179] J. Morris Slemans, "Metabolism During Pregnancy," _Johns Hopkins +Hospital Reports_, vol. xii, 1904. + +[180] B. Wolff, _Zentralblatt für Gynäkologie_, 1904, No. 26. + +[181] Tridandani, _Annali di Ostetrica_, March, 1900. + +[182] R. Barnes, "The Induction of Labor," _British Medical Journal_, +December 22, 1894. + +[183] See, e.g., Havelock Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, pp. 344, +et seq. + +[184] Arthur Giles, "The Longings of Pregnant Women," _Transactions +Obstetrical Society of London_, vol. xxxv, 1893. + +[185] Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, Chapter XXX. + +[186] Thus, in Cornwall, "to be in the longing way" is a popular synonym +for pregnancy. + +[187] The apple, wherever it is known, has nearly always been a sacred or +magic fruit (as J.F. Campbell shows, _Popular Tales of West Highlands_, +vol. I, p. lxxv. et seq.), and the fruit of the forbidden tree which +tempted Eve is always popularly imagined to be an apple. One may perhaps +refer in this connection to the fact that at Rome and elsewhere the +testicles have been called apples. I may add that we find a curious proof +of the recognition of the feminine love of apples in an old Portuguese +ballad, "Donna Guimar," in which a damsel puts on armour and goes to the +wars; her sex is suspected and as a test, she is taken into an orchard, +but Donna Guimar is too wary to fall into the trap, and turning away from +the apples plucks a citron. + +[188] A. Pinard, Art. "Grossesse," _Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des +Sciences Médicales_, p. 138. On the subject of violent, criminal and +abnormal impulses during pregnancy, see Cumston, "Pregnancy and Crime," +_American Journal Obstetrics_, December, 1903. + +[189] See especially Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter XXXI. +Ballantyne in his work on the pathology of the foetus adds Loango negroes, +the Eskimo and the ancient Japanese. + +[190] In 1731 Schurig, in his _Syllepsilogia_, devoted more than a hundred +pages (cap. IX) to summarizing a vast number of curious cases of maternal +impressions leading to birth-marks of all kinds. + +[191] J.W. Ballantyne has written an excellent history of the doctrine of +maternal impressions, reprinted in his _Manual of Antenatal Pathology: The +Embryo_, 1904, Chapter IX; he gives a bibliography of 381 items. In +Germany the history of the question has been written by Dr. Iwan Bloch +(under the pseudonym of Gerhard von Welsenburg), _Das Versehen der +Frauen_, 1899. Cf., in French, G. Variot, "Origine des Préjugés Populaires +sur les Envies," _Bulletin Société d'Anthropologie_, Paris, June 18, 1891. +Variot rejects the doctrine absolutely, Bloch accepts it, Ballantyne +speaks cautiously. + +[192] J.G. Kiernan has shown how many of the alleged cases are negatived +by the failure to take this fact into consideration. (_Journal of American +Medical Association_, December 9, 1899.) + +[193] J. Clifton Edgar, _The Practice of Obstetrics_, second edition, +1904, p. 296. In an important discussion of the question at the American +Gynæcological Society in 1886, introduced by Fordyce Barker, various +eminent gynæcologists declared in favor of the doctrine, more or less +cautiously. (_Transactions of the American Gynæcological Society_, vol. +xi, 1886, pp. 152-196.) Gould and Pyle, bringing forward some of the data +on the question (_Anomalies and Curiosities of Medicine_, pp. 81, _et +seq._) state that the reality of the influence of maternal impressions +seems fully established. On the other side, see G.W. Cook, _American +Journal of Obstetrics_, September, 1889, and H.F. Lewis, ib., July, 1899. + +[194] _Transactions Edinburgh Obstetrical Society_, vol. xvii, 1892. + +[195] J.W. Ballantyne, _Manual of Antenatal Pathology: The Embryo_, p. 45. + +[196] W.C. Dabney, "Maternal Impressions," Keating's _Cyclopædia of +Diseases of Children_, vol. i, 1889, pp. 191-216. + +[197] Féré, _Sensation et Mouvement_, Chapter XIV, "Sur la Psychologie du +Foetus." + +[198] J. Thomson, "Defective Co-ordination in Utero," _British Medical +Journal_, September 6, 1902. + +[199] H. Campbell, _Nervous Organization of Man and Woman_, p. 206; cf. +Moll, _Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 264. Many +authorities, from Soranus of Ephesus onward, consider, however, that +sexual relations should cease during pregnancy, and certainly during the +later months. Cf. Brénot, _De l'influence de la copulation pendant la +grosseisse_, 1903. + +[200] Bianchi terms this fairly common condition the neurasthenia of +pregnancy. + +[201] Vinay, _Traité des Maladies de la Grossesse_, 1894, pp. 51, 577; +Mongeri, "Nervenkrankungen und Schwangerschaft." _Allegemeine Zeitschrift +für Psychiatrie_, bd. LVIII, Heft 5. Haig remarks (_Uric Acid_, sixth +edition, p. 151) that during normal pregnancy diseases with excess of uric +acid in the blood (headaches, fits, mental depression, dyspepsia, asthma) +are absent, and considers that the common idea that women do not easily +take colds, fevers, etc., at this time is well founded. + +[202] Founding his remarks on certain anatomical changes and on a +suggestion of Engel's, Donaldson observes: "It is impossible to escape the +conclusion that in women natural education is complete only with +maternity, which we know to effect some slight changes in the sympathetic +system and possibly the spinal cord, and which may be fairly laid under +suspicion of causing more structural modifications than are at present +recognized." H.H. Donaldson, _The Growth of the Brain_, p. 352. + +[203] The state of menstruation is in many respects an approximation to +that of pregnancy; see, e.g., Edgar's _Practice of Obstetrics_, plates 6 6 +and 7, showing the resemblance of the menstrual changes in the breasts and +the external sexual parts to the changes of pregnancy; cf. Havelock Ellis, +_Man and Woman_, fourth edition, Chapter XI, "The Functional Periodicity +of Woman." + +[204] Thus the gypsies say of an unmarried woman who becomes pregnant, +"She has smelt the moon-flower"--a flower believed to grow on the +so-called moon-mountain and to possess the property of impregnating by its +smell. Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, bd. I, Chapter XXVII. + +[205] This was a sound instinct, for it is now recognized as an extremely +important part of puericulture that a woman should rest at all events +during the latter part of pregnancy; see, e.g., Pinard, _Gazette des +Hôpitaux_, November 28, 1895, and _Annales de Gynécologie_, August, 1898. + +[206] Ploss and Bartels, op. cit., Chapter XXIX; Kryptadia, vol. viii, p. +143. + +[207] Griffith Wilkin, _British Medical Journal_, April 8, 1905. + +[208] Weininger, _Geschlecht und Charakter_, p. 107. I may remark that a +recent book, Ellis Meredith's _Heart of My Heart_, is devoted to a +seemingly autobiographical account of a pregnant woman's emotions and +ideas. The relations of maternity to intellectual work have been carefully +and impartially investigated by Adele Gerhard and Helena Simon, who seem +to conclude that the conflict between the inevitable claims of maternity +and the scarcely less inevitable claims of the intellectual life cannot be +avoided. + + + + +APPENDIX. + +HISTORIES OF SEXUAL DEVELOPMENT. + + HISTORY I.--The following narrative has been written by a + university man trained in psychology:-- + + So far as I have been able to learn, none of my ancestors for at + least three generations have suffered from any nervous or mental + disease; and of those more remote I can learn nothing at all. It + appears probable, then, that any peculiarities of my own sexual + development must be explained by reference to the somewhat + peculiar environment. + + I was the first child and was, naturally, somewhat spoiled--a + process which tended to increase my natural tendency to + sentimentality. On the other hand, I was shy and undemonstrative + with all except my nearest relatives, and with them as well after + my seventh or eighth year. And here it may be well to describe my + "mental type," as this is probably the most important factor in + determining the direction of one's mental development. Of mental + types the "visual" is, of course, by far the most common, but in + my own case visual imagery was never strong or vivid, and has + constantly grown weaker. The dominant part has been played by + tactual, muscular and organic sensations, placing me as one of + the "tactual motor" type, with strong "verbal motor" and + "organic" tendencies. In reading a novel I seldom have a mental + picture of the character or situation, but easily imagine the + sensations (except the visual) and feel something of the emotions + described. When telling of any event I have a strong impulse to + make the movements described and to gesticulate. I remember + events in terms of movements and the words to be used in giving + an account of them; and in thinking of any subject I can feel the + movements of the larynx and, in a less degree, of the lips and + tongue that would be involved in putting my thoughts into words. + I am easily moved to emotion, even to sentimentality, but am + seldom if ever deeply affected and am so averse to any display of + my feelings that I have the reputation among my acquaintances of + being cold, unfeeling and unemotional. I am naturally quiet and + bashful to a degree, which has rendered all forms of social + intercourse painful through much of my life, and this in spite of + a real longing to associate with people on terms of intimacy. As + a child I was sensitive and solitary; later I became morbid as + well. In a character so constituted the feelings and impulses of + the moment are likely to rule, and such has been my constant + experience, though a large element of obstinacy in my character + has kept me from appearing impulsive, and slight influences will + bring about reactions which seem out of all proportion to their + cause. For instance, I cannot, even now, read the more erotic of + Boccaccio's stories without a good deal of sexual excitement and + restlessness, which can be relieved only by vigorous exercise or + masturbation. + + The first ten years of my life were passed on a farm, most of the + time without playmates or companions of my own age. + + As far back as I can remember I indulged in elaborate day-dreams + in which I figured as the chief character along with a few others + who were chiefly creatures of my imagination, but at times + borrowed from reality. These others were always boys until I + learned the proper function of the sexual organs, when girls + usurped the whole stage in numbers beyond the limits of a Turkish + harem. Even at school my day-dreams were scarcely interrupted, + for my shyness and timidity made me very unpopular among my + schoolmates, who tormented me after the fashion of small boys or + neglected me, as the spirit moved them. To make matters worse, I + was brought up under the "sheltered life system," kept carefully + away from the "bad boys," which category included nearly all the + youngsters of the community, and deluged with moral homilies and + tirades on things religious until I was thoroughly convinced that + goodness and discomfort, the right and the unpleasant, were + strictly synonymous; and I was kept through much of the time + facing the prospect of an early death, to be followed by the good + old orthodox hell or the equal miseries of its gorgeous + alternative. I may say in all seriousness that this is a + conservative and unexaggerated account of one phase of my early + life--the one, I think, that tended most strongly to make me + introspective and morbid. Later on, when I was trying to abandon + the habit of masturbation, this early training greatly increased + the despair I felt at each successive failure. + + The first traces of sexual excitement that I can now recall + occurred when I was about 4 years old. I had erections quite + frequently and found a mild pleasure in fondling my genitals when + these occurred, especially just after waking in the morning. I + had no notion of an orgasm, and never succeeded in producing one + until I was 13 years of age. In the summer of my sixth year I + experienced pleasurable sensations in daubing my genitals with + oil and then fondling or rubbing them, but I abandoned this + amusement after getting some irritating substance into the + meatus. A year later my mother warned me that playing with my + penis would "make me very sick," but since experience had taught + me that this was not true, my conviction that what was forbidden + must necessarily be pleasant, sent me directly to my favorite + retreat in the barn loft to experiment. Since, however, I failed, + in spite of persistent effort, to produce any such pleasant + results as I had expected, I soon gave up my attempts for other + kinds of amusement. + + A few months after this, in midsummer, a very sensual servant + girl began a series of attempts to satisfy herself sexually with + my help. She came nearly every day into the loft where I was + playing and did her best to initiate me into the mysteries of + sexual relationships, but I proved a sorry pupil. She would rub + my penis until it became erect and then, placing me upon her, + would insert the penis in her vulva and make movements of her + thighs and hips calculated to cause friction. At times she varied + the program by lying upon me and embracing me passionately. I can + remember distinctly her quick, gasping breath and convulsive + movements. She generally ended the seance by persuading me to + perform cunnilingus upon her. None of these performances were + intelligible to me and I invariably protested against being + compelled to leave my play to amuse her. Even her fondling of my + genitals annoyed me; and, stranger still, I preferred satisfying + her by cunnilingus to the attempts at coitus. + + It was nearly a year later that I experienced the first + unmistakable manifestations of the sexual impulse--erections + accompanied by lustful feeling and vague desires of whose proper + satisfaction I had no notion whatever. It never occurred to me to + associate my experiences with the servant girl with these new + sensations. The peculiar fact about them was that they were + generally occasioned by the infliction of pain upon animals. I do + not remember how I first discovered that they could be evoked in + this way, but I can clearly recollect many of my efforts to + arouse this pleasurable excitement by abusing the dog or the + cats, or by prodding the calves with a nail set in the end of a + broom handle. I seldom manipulated my genitals at this time, and + when I did it was for the purpose of causing sexual excitement + rather than allaying it. + + During this same year I got my first idea of sexual intercourse + by watching animals copulate; but my powers of observation must + have been limited, for I supposed that the penis of the male + entered the anus of the female. In watching the coitus of animals + I experienced lively sexual excitement and lustful sensations, + located not only in the genitals, but apparently in the anus as + well. I often excited, myself by imagining myself playing the + part of the female animal--a peculiar combination of passive + pederasty and bestiality. A servant girl put me to right on the + error of observation just mentioned, but neglected to apply the + principle to human animals, and I remained for another year in + complete ignorance of the structure of woman's sexual organs and + of the intercourse between man and woman. In the meantime I + cultivated my fancies of intercourse with animals, often still + perversely imagining myself taking the part of the female; and + the notion of such relationships gradually became so familiar as + to seem possible and desirable. This is especially significant in + view of later developments. + + Up to my eleventh or twelfth year the erotic element in my + daydreaming varied with the seasons. In the summer it played a + dominant part, while in the winter it was almost entirely absent, + owing, it may be, to the fact that most of my time was spent + indoors or on long, tiresome tramps to and from school, and the + further fact that during the winter I saw but little of the + animals which had acted as a stimulus to sexual excitement. So + little was I troubled in winter and so ignorant was I of normal + intercourse that sleeping with a cousin, a girl of about my own + age (7 or 8 years), resulted in no addition to my knowledge of + things sexual. + + It was early in my ninth year that I first learned something of + the anatomical difference between man and woman and of the + functions of the sexual organs in coitus. These were explained to + me by a young male servant, who, however, told me nothing of + conception or pregnancy. At first I was very little interested, + as it did not immediately occur to me to associate my own erotic + experiences with the matter of these revelations; but under the + faithful tuition of my new instructor I soon began to desire + normal coitus, and my interest in the sexual affairs of animals + weakened accordingly. His teachings went still further, for he + masturbated before me, then persuaded me to masturbate him, and + finally practiced coitus inter femora upon me. He also tried to + masturbate me, but was unable to produce an orgasm, though I + found the experiment mildly pleasurable. + + Early in my eleventh year we left the farm and lived in the city + for several months. In the meantime there had been no + developments in my sexual life beyond what has already been + indicated. In the city I found so much to interest and amuse me + that I almost entirely forgot my erotic day-dreams and desires. + Though my chief playmates were two girls of about my own age I + never thought of attempting sexual intercourse with them, as I + might easily have done, for they were much wiser and more + experienced in these things than myself. Shortly before the end + of our stay in town an older schoolmate explained to me as much + of the process of reproduction as is usually known by a + precocious youngster of 12 years, but I firmly refused to credit + his statements. He adduced the fact of lactation in proof of the + correctness of his views, but I had been too thoroughly steeped + in supernaturalism to be very amenable to naturalistic evidence + of this sort and remained obdurate. But the suggestion stayed + with me and perplexed me not a little; when we returned to the + farm I began to watch the reproductive process in animals. + + The following two years were decidedly unpleasant. I was growing + rapidly and was sluggish, awkward and stupid. At school I was + more unpopular than ever and seemed to have a positive genius + for doing the wrong thing. On the rare occasions when my + companions admitted me to their counsels I was a willing dupe and + catspaw, with the result that I was much in trouble with my + teachers. Being morbidly sensitive I suffered keenly under these + circumstances and, as my health was not at all good, I often made + of my frequent headaches excuses to stay at home, where I would + lie abed brooding over my small troubles or, more often, dreaming + erotic day-dreams and making repeated attempts to produce an + orgasm. But though these efforts were accompanied by the most + lustful thoughts and my imagination created situations of + oriental extravagance, I was 13 years old when they first met + with success. I remember the occasion very distinctly, the more + so because I thought of it much and bitterly when shortly + afterwards I tried to abandon a habit which the family "doctor + book" assured me must result in every variety of damnation. At + the moment, however, I was greatly surprised and gratified and + tried at once to repeat the delightful sensation, but was unable + to do so until the following day. From that time to the present I + think I have masturbated an average of ten times per week, and + this is certainly a very conservative estimate; for though up to + my sixteenth year I could seldom produce an orgasm more than once + a day I have often, during the last four or five years, produced + it from four to seven times per day without difficulty and this + for days and even weeks in succession. During these periods of + excessive masturbation very little liquid was ejaculated and the + pleasurable sensations were slight or entirely lacking. + + From the time when I began masturbating regularly practically my + whole interest centered in things pertaining to sex. I read the + chapters of the family "doctor book" which treated of sexual + matters; my day-dreams were almost exclusively erotic; I sought + opportunities to talk about sex-relationships with my + schoolmates, with whom I was now slowly getting on better terms; + I collected pictures of nude women, learned a great number of + obscene stories, read such obscene books as I could obtain and + even searched the dictionary for words having a sexual + connotation. Up to my fifteenth year, when ejaculation of semen + began, there was a strong sadistic coloring to my day-dreams. + Through this period, too, my bashfulness in the presence of the + opposite sex increased until it reached the point of absurdity. + + When fifteen years old I began to practice coitus inter femora on + my brother and continued it intermittently for about two years. + The experience was disappointing, for I had confidently expected + a great increase of pleasure over masturbation in this act; and + in casting about for some stronger stimulus I recurred to the + forgotten idea of intercourse with animals. I promptly tried to + put the idea to a test, but failed several times, and finally + succeeded, only to find that the result fell far short of my + expectations. Nevertheless I continued the practice irregularly + for about three years--or rather through that part of the three + years that I spent at home, for while I was at school opportunity + for such indulgence was lacking. Long familiarity with the idea + of intercourse with animals had made it impossible for me to feel + the disgust with the practice which it inspires in most people; + and even the perusal of Exodus xxii: 19 failed to make me abandon + it. Firmly as I believed in the Mosaic law the supremacy of the + sexual impulse was complete. + + As early as my sixteenth year I tried to abandon "self-abuse" in + all its forms and have repeatedly made the same effort since that + time but never with more than very partial success. On two or + three occasions I have stopped for periods of several weeks, but + only to begin again and indulge more recklessly than before. The + deep depression which followed each failure, and often each act + of masturbation, I attributed solely to the loss of semen, + leaving out of account the fact that I expected to feel depressed + and the utter discouragement and self-contempt which accompanied + the sense of failure and weakness when, in the face of my + resolution, I repeatedly gave way and yielded to the temptation + to an act whose consequences I firmly believed must be ruinous. I + am now convinced that by far the greater part of this depression + was due to suggestion and the humiliating sense of defeat. And + this feeling of moral impotence, this seeming helplessness + against an overpowering impulse which, on the other hand, seemed + so trivial when viewed without passion, eventually weakened my + self-control to a degree guessed by no one but myself and sapped + the foundations of my moral life in a way which I have constant + occasion to deplore. + + The foregoing paragraphs give, I think, a fair idea of my + condition when I left home for a boarding school at the beginning + of my seventeenth year. From this time my experiences may be said + to have run on in two distinct cycles--that of the summer months + when I was at home, and that of the remainder of the year when I + was at school. This fact will make some confusion and apparent + inconsistency in the rest of this "history" unavoidable. When I + left home I was shy, retiring, totally ignorant of social usage, + without self-confidence, unambitious, dreamy, and subject to fits + of melancholy. I masturbated at least once a day, though I was in + almost constant rebellion against the habit. In my more idle + moments I elaborated erotic day dreams in which there was a + peculiar mixture of the purely sensual and the purely ideal + element; which never fused in my experience, but held the field + alternately or mingled somewhat in the manner of air and water. + One person usually served as the object of my ideal attachment, + another as the center round which I grouped my sensual dreams and + desires. + + At school I found more congenial companions than I had fallen in + with elsewhere, and the necessary contact with people of both + sexes gradually wore off some of the rougher corners and brought + a measure of self-confidence. I had two or three incipient love + affairs which my backwardness kept from growing serious. Out of + this change of environment came a sense of expansion, of escape + from self, which was distinctly pleasant. I still masturbated + regularly, but no longer experienced the former depression except + when at home during vacation. Relatively to the past, life was + now so varied and interesting that I had less and less time for + melancholy; and the discovery that I could lead my classes and + hold my own in athletic sports seemed to indicate that my past + fears had been exaggerated. Nevertheless I was never reconciled + to the habit and often rebelled at the weakness that kept me its + slave. + + When I entered the university the effects of my useless struggle + with the practice of masturbation were pretty well developed. I + could no longer fix my attention steadily upon my work and found + that only by "cribbing" and "bluffing" could I keep my place at + the head of my classes. I was troubled not a little by the + shoddiness of my work, and tried again and again during the + course of the two years spent at this college to shake off the + habit. At the university I was introduced gradually to a wider + social circle and so far outgrew my bashfulness that I began to + seek the society of the opposite sex assiduously. As I gained + self-confidence I became reckless, getting at one time into + serious trouble with the authorities which came near resulting in + my expulsion. I became one of the more popular members of the + clique to which I belonged--much to my surprise and even more to + that of my acquaintances. The physical culture craze attacked me + at this time and my pet ambition was the attainment of strength + and agility. My bump of vanity also grew apace, but an unmeasured + hatred of all kinds of foppishness kept me on the safe side of + moderation in my dress and behavior. + + During my second year of university life I had two love affairs + in the course of which I found that my interest in any particular + member of the fair sex disappeared as soon as it was returned. + The pursuit was fascinating enough, but I cared nothing at all + for the prize when once it was within reach. I may add that the + interest I had in the girls was purely ideal. While at this + school I do not think I masturbated half as often as while at the + preparatory school. + + When I left this college for ---- University I took with me a + formidable catalogue of good resolutions, first among which was + the determination to abandon all kinds of "self-abuse." I think I + kept this one about a month. As I had gone from a comparatively + small school to one of the largest of American universities the + change was great and the revelations it brought me frequently + humiliating. I was lonesome, home-sick, and my bump of + self-esteem was woefully bruised; and not unnaturally I soon + began to seek a partial solace in day-dreams and masturbation. + After I had become somewhat adapted to my new environment I + indulged less frequently in either, and from that time to the + present I have masturbated very irregularly, sometimes but little + and again to excess. + + Not long after I came to this place I met a young lady with whom + I soon became quite intimate. For over a year our friendship was + strictly platonic and then swung suddenly around to a sexual + basis. We were ardent lovers for a few weeks, after which I tired + of the game as I had before in other cases, and broke off all + relations with her as abruptly as was possible. Since then I have + almost wholly withdrawn from the society and companionship of + women and have almost entirely lost whatever tact and assurance I + once possessed in their company. Things pertaining to sexual life + have interested me rather more than less, but have occupied my + attention much less exclusively than before this episode. Though + I have never intended to marry, my breaking off relations with + this girl affected me much. At any rate it marked an abrupt + change in the character of my sexual experiences. The sexual + impulse seems to have lost its power to rouse me to action. + Hitherto I had practiced masturbation always under protest, as it + were--as the only available form of sexual satisfaction; while + now I resigned myself to it as all that there was to hope for in + that field. Of course I knew that a little effort or a little + money would procure natural satisfaction of my sexual needs, but + I also knew that I would never, under any ordinary circumstances, + put forth the necessary effort, and fear of venereal disease has + been more than enough to keep me away from houses of + prostitution. + + Some months ago I refrained from masturbation for a period of + about six weeks and watched carefully for any change in my health + or spirits, but noticed none at all. The only impulse to + masturbate was occasioned by fits of restlessness accompanied by + erections and a mildly pleasurable feeling of fullness in the + penis and scrotum. I think that over 75 per cent, of my acts of + masturbation are provoked by these fits of restlessness and are + unaccompanied by fancy images, erotic thoughts, lustful desires, + or marked pleasure. At other times the act is occasioned by + erotic thoughts and images, and is accompanied by a considerable + degree of lustful pleasure which, however, is never so intense as + in my earlier experiences and has steadily decreased from the + first. Usually the orgasm is accompanied by a strong contraction + of all the voluntary muscles, particularly the extensors, + followed by a slight giddiness and slight feeling of exhaustion. + If repeated several times in the course of a single day the acts + are followed by dullness and lassitude; otherwise the feeling of + exhaustion passes away quickly and a sense of relief and quiet + takes its place. So natural or rather habitual has this resort + to masturbation as a means of relief from nervousness and + restlessness become that the act is almost instinctive in its + unconsciousness. + + I am extremely sensitive to all kinds of sexual influences, and + have an insatiable curiosity regarding everything that pertains + to the sexual life of men or women. I am not, however, excited + sexually by conversation about sexual facts and relationships, no + matter what its nature, though in reading erotic literature my + excitement is often intense. + + The tendency to day dream has never left me, but there are no + longer any elaborate scenes or long-continued "stories," these + having been replaced by vaguely imagined incidents which are + usually broken off before they reach a satisfactory climax. They + are always interrupted by the intrusion of other matters, usually + of more practical interest; and the long-continued habit of + satisfying myself by masturbation has made erotic dreams rather + tantalizing than pleasurable. I dream very seldom at night--at + least I can scarcely ever remember any dreams upon waking--and + practically never of sexual relations. I have not had a nocturnal + emission for over three years, and probably not more than + twenty-five in my life. + + In my "love passages" with girls there has been no serious + thought of coitus on my part, and I have never had intercourse + with a woman--unless my early experiences with the servant girl + be called such. Like all masturbators I always idealized "love" + to the utter exclusion of all sensual cravings; and the notion + that the physical act of coitus was something degrading and + destructive of real love rather than its consummation was, of all + prejudices I have ever formed, the most difficult to escape--a + circumstance due, I suppose, to the fact that all I had ever been + taught on the subject tended to the complete divorce of what was + called "love" from what was stigmatized as a "base sensual + desire." Judging from my own experience and observation I should + say that "ideal love" is a mere surface feeling, bound to + disappear as soon as it has gained its object by arousing a + reciprocal interest on the part of the one to whom it is + directed. So little did I "materialize" the objects of my "love" + that I have never cared for kissing or the warm embraces in which + lovers usually indulge. I have never kissed but one girl, and her + with far too little enthusiasm to satisfy her. My last sweetheart + was a very passionate girl, the warmth of whose embraces was + somewhat torrid and, to me, both puzzling and annoying. The + intensity of feeling which demanded such strenuous expression was + beyond my knowledge of human nature. A somewhat peculiar + circumstance in connection with these experiences is the fact + that I often found myself trying to analyze my emotions with a + purely psychological interest while playing the part of the + intoxicated lover in his mistress's arms. + + There is but little left to say on the subject of my sexual + development. During the last two or three years my knowledge of + the facts of the sexual life has been very greatly increased, + and I have become acquainted with phases of human nature which + were wholly unknown to me before. The part played by things + sexual in my life is still, I suppose, abnormally large; it is + undoubtedly the largest single interest, though my outer life is + determined almost wholly by other considerations. + + Of course I know nothing of the effect which long-continued + masturbation may have had on my ability to perform normal coitus. + I do not think I am subject to any kind of sexual perversion, for + all my indulgence has been _faute de mieux_ and, at least since I + began masturbation, all my desires and erotic day-dreams have had + to do only with normal coitus. The mystery which surrounds the + sexual act seems at times to be regaining its former influence + and power of fascination. I have no doubt, however, but that I + should be greatly disillusioned should I ever perform coitus; and + I greatly regret that I have not been able to test this + conviction and so round out and complete this "history." + + It may be worth while to say a word about my religious + experiences, as, in many cases, they are closely bound up with + the sexual impulse. I was never "converted," but on a dozen or + more occasions approached the crisis more or less closely. The + dominant emotion in these experiences was always fear, sometimes + with anger and despair intermixed in varying proportions. A + complete analysis of these experiences is, of course, impossible, + but the various pleasurable feelings of which converts spoke in + the revivals which I attended were a closed book to me. Following + my revival-meeting experiences came a few days spent in a sort of + moral exaltation during which I eschewed all my habits of which + conventional morality disapproved, save masturbation, and felt no + small satisfaction with my moral conditions. I became a + first-rate Pharisee. Toward the women who had figured in my day + dreams I suddenly conceived the chastest affection, resolutely + smothering every sensual thought and fancy when thinking of them, + and putting in place of these elements ideal love, + self-sacrifice, knightly devotion--Sunday-school Garden-of-Eden + pictures with a mediæval, romantic coloring. These day-dreams + were always sexual, involving situations of extreme complexity + and monumental silliness. Masturbation was always continued and + usually with increased frequency. The end of these periods was + always abrupt and much like awaking from a dream in which the + dreamer has been behaving in a manner to arouse his own disgust. + They were followed by feelings of sheepishness and self-contempt + mingled with anger and a dislike of all things having to do with + religion. My inability to pass the conversion crisis and a + growing contempt for empty enthusiasm finally led me to a saner + attitude toward religion, from which I passed easily into + religious scepticism; and later the study of philosophy and + science, and particularly of psychology, banished the last + lingering remnant of faith in a supernatural agency and led me + to the passion for facts and indifference to values which have + caused me to be often called "dead to all morality." + + + HISTORY II.--C.A., aged 25, unmarried; tutor, preparing to take + Holy Orders:-- + + My paternal ancestry (which is largely Huguenot) is noteworthy + for its patriotism and its large families. My father, who died + when I was a year old, is remembered for the singular uprightness + and purity of his life from his earliest childhood. The + photograph which I have shows him as possessed of a rare classic + beauty of features. He was an ideal husband and father. At the + time of his death he was a Master of Arts and a school principal. + My mother is an extraordinarily neurotic woman, yet famed among + her friends for her great domesticity, attachment to her + husbands, and an almost abnormal love of babies. She has nobly + borne the ill-treatment of her second husband, who for several + years has been in a state of melancholia. My mother has been + "highly-wrought" all her life, and has suffered intensely from + fears of all kinds. As a young girl she was somnambulistic, and + once fell down a stairhead during sleep. In spite of her bodily + sufferings with indigestion, eye-strain, and depression she + retains her youthfulness. She has slight powers of reasoning. She + has had times of unconsciousness and rigidity, I have never heard + any mention of epilepsy. She has a horror of showing prudishness + in regard to the healthful manifestations of sex life, and is + always praising examples of what she terms "a natural woman." + + I have heard that during my first year my mother detected my + nurse in the act of putting a morphine powder on my tongue for + the purpose of keeping me quiet. I was subject to convulsions at + this period, and narrowly escaped a permanent hernia. My family + tell me that from the beginning I was a well-developed and boyish + boy, full of mischief, impulsive, good to look upon, unusually + affectionate, beloved by all. + + In my third year I took pleasure in crawling under the bed with + my boy-cousin who was nine months my senior, and after we had + taken down our drawers, in kissing each other's nates. I do not + remember which of us first thought of this pastime. + + At the age of 4 I gave myself a treat by gazing upward through a + cellar window at the nates of a woman who was defecating from + several feet above into a cesspool that lay beneath. It was + during this summer also that I frightened myself by pulling back + my prepuce far enough to disclose the purple glans, which I had + never seen before. But this act gave me no desire to masturbate. + + When 5 years old, and living in a great city, I drew indecent + pictures in company with a little girl and her younger brother. + These pictures represented men in the act of urinating. The + penes were drawn large, and the streams of urine plainly + indicated. One afternoon I induced the boy to go to the + bath-room, lie on his back, and allow me to perform _fellatio_ on + him. I did not ask him to return the favor. I remember the + curious tar-like smell of his clothing and the region about his + genitals. It is possible that I gained my knowledge of _fellatio_ + from an unknown boy of 10, who had induced me, during the + preceding summer to enter a sandy lot with him, watch him + urinate, and then, kneeling before him, commit _fellatio_. A year + later, as I was walking home in the rain to our summer cottage, + with an open umbrella over my shoulder, a boy of 15, who was + leaning against our fence, exhibited a large, erect penis, and + when I had passed him urinated upon me and my umbrella. I never + saw the boy again. I felt peculiarly insulted by his act. Back of + the house there lived a 12-year-old boy who invited me to watch + him defecate in the outdoor privy, and during the act told me a + number of indecent stories and words which I cannot remember. + + About this time I fell in love with a little Jewish boy next + door. Often I cried myself to sleep over the thought that perhaps + he was lying on a sofa alone and crying with a stomach-ache. I + longed to embrace him; and yet I saw little of him, and made + little of him when I was with him. + + Living in a Western city a few months later, some girls of 12 and + 14 led me to their barn, where they dressed themselves in boys' + clothing and made believe that they were cowboys. One of them + told me to "shut my eyes, open my mouth, and get a surprise." + When I opened my eyes once more a piece of hen-dung lay in my + mouth. I have a vague remembrance of one of the girls asking me + to enter a water-closet with her. She uttered some indelicate + phrase, but I performed no act with her. In the house where I + lived I once entered the bedroom of a half-grown girl while she + was dressing. She knelt to kiss me innocently enough, and I, by a + sudden impulse, ran my hand between her bare neck and her corset + as far as I could reach. Apparently she took no notice of my + movement. Although I did not masturbate, yet during this winter I + experienced a tickling sensation about my genitals when I placed + my hand beneath them as I lay on my stomach in bed. One evening I + pulled up my night-dress and, holding my penis in my hand, I + danced to and fro on the carpet. I imagined that I was one of a + line of naked men and women who were advancing toward another + similar line that faced them. I imagined myself as pleasurably + coming in contact with my female partner who possessed male + genitals. + + The following summer I lived in the woods. My next-door playmate + was a little girl of my own age--6 years. She sat down before me + in the barn and exposed her genitals. This was the first time I + had seen female organs, or had thought for a moment that they + differed from my own. In great perplexity I asked the little + girl: "Has it been cut off?" She and I defecated in peach baskets + that we found in the upper part of the barn. + + When I was 7 years old and back in the Eastern city I lived in + the house of a physician. Alone with his 3-year-old daughter one + day, I showed her my erect organ, and felt a delicious + gratification when she stroked it with the words: "Nice! Nice!" I + confessed my fault to my guardian that night after I had said my + prayers. I had complained to my mother a year before of the + inconvenience I found in my penis being "so long sometimes." She + said that she would "see about having the end taken off." But I + was never circumcised. Her words gave me the doubly unpleasant + impression that my _glans_ was to be cut off. + + There came occasionally to the kitchen of Dr. W.'s house a + foul-mouthed Irish laundress who used coarse language to me + concerning urination. I loathed the woman, and yet one night I + dreamed that I was embracing her naked form and rolling over and + over with her on the bed; and in spite of my sight of female + genitals a few months before, I thought of her as having organs + of my own kind and size. At my first school I watched a + red-haired boy of 12 expose the penis of a 7-year-old boy as he + lay on his back in the bath-room. I do not remember that the + sight gave me sexual pleasure. + + I spent the summer before I was 8 in a double house. The adopted + daughter of our neighbor (a neurotic, retired physician) was a + girl of 13 who had been taken from a poor laboring family. She + got me to show her my parts, touched them, and asked whether I + urinated from my scrotum. She also induced me to play with her + genitals as we sat on a sofa in the twilight, and to spank her + naked nates with the back of a hair-brush as she lay on a bed; + but from none of these performances did I derive physical + satisfaction. The girl E. and I took delight in "talking dirty + secrets," as she expressed it. Her young cousin H. (nephew of her + adopted mother) never heard me use the word "thing" without + suggestively smiling. E. recalled the pleasant hours that she had + spent with her cousin when they were in their night-gowns. She + did not particularize these sexual relations. Under the + board-walk the boy H. and I once defecated in bottles. Some + little girls who lived opposite us pulled up their dresses one + night and "dared" each other to dance out beyond the end of the + house, in full view of the road. We boys merely looked on. + + I now fell passionately in love with a remarkably handsome little + boy of my own age. I longed to kiss and hug him, but I did not + dare to do so, for he was haughty and intolerant of my + attentions. I even allowed him to stand with one foot on me and + remark in a loud tone: "I am Conqueror!" I endured no end of + petty insults and much ill-treatment from this boy. I reached the + height of my passion on the night that he appeared at our + cottage in a tight-fitting suit of pepper-and-salt. I gloried in + his perfect legs and besought my guardian that she would buy me a + similar suit of clothes. + + For the summer after I was 8 years old I lived in a cottage in a + country town. The servant maid M. was a young girl of 16 who + listened eagerly to my accounts of the "secrets" and actions in + which the girl E. and I had taken delight a year before. I think + that M. arranged a meeting between a little black-haired girl and + me in order that we might take a walk and play sexually with each + other. Just as we were starting on our walk one of my relatives + said that I must not leave the yard. + + The little girl and I had see-sawed together and I had been + interested in her legs as she rose in the air. (When I was 13 + years old and see-sawing at a picnic with a stout girl, the + motion of the board and the sight of her straddled form filled me + with longing to embrace her sexually.) One afternoon M. took me + to the house of an acquaintance of hers. M's brother was in the + room and made a number of unremembered remarks which struck me as + being rather "free," and M. told me later that she and the girl + once dressed as ballet dancers and danced before M.'s brother. I + felt that he was lascivious. I was always remarkably intuitive. + + I fell in love with a handsome, stout, black-haired boy who lived + on a farm; but he was not a "farmer's son" in the common sense of + the word. I visited him for two or three days, and we slept with + each other, to my boundless joy. For his freckled girl cousin I + did not care the turn of my wrist, although she was a nice enough + little thing. One night when we three lay on a bed in the dark, + and neither of us boys had eyes or words for her, she silently + left us. He and I never committed the slightest sexual fault. I + left him with tears at the summer-end, and I often kissed his + photograph during the following winter. + + In the flat-house where I began to live when I was 8 years old, I + once practiced mutual tickling of a very slight character with a + boy of my own age. We sat on chairs placed opposite to each other + and we inserted our fingers through the openings in our trousers. + Just as we were beginning to enjoy the titillation we were + interrupted by the approach of one of my family who, however, was + not quick enough to discover us. Down cellar I often saw the + genitals of the janitor's little girls--they were fond of lifting + their skirts and they did not wear drawers--but I had no desire + to attempt conjunction. I once caught an older friend of mine (he + was 13) in the act of leaving one of the girls. The pair had been + in a coal-compartment. The boy was buttoning his trousers and I + guessed what he had been doing. When I began to sleep alone in my + tenth year I had no desire to masturbate, and was loath to do so + by reason of ample warnings given me by my guardian and by the + family physician. One afternoon a stunted friend of mine sat down + in the back yard and astonished me by tying a piece of string to + his penis. At a large private school which I now attended I made + the acquaintance of the principal's son, and wondered why he had + such a fancy for dressing his 5-year-old sister in boy's clothes. + He closed the door on me while he was thus engaged. At my house + we went to the bath-room together, and he showed me his + circumcised and much-ridged penis. Neither of us made any mention + of masturbating. + + At this period I fell slightly in love with a 5-year-old boy with + intensely black eyes. I would kiss him whenever we were alone, + but I had no wish to seduce him. I was always interested in + watching the urination of younger children. When I was 5 years + old I went on my knees to a strange little boy in order to + whisper in his ear an inquiry as to whether he wanted to urinate. + I experienced a pleasurable thrill when I was 10 years old in + leading a small girl cousin to the outdoor privy, in helping her + on and off the open seat, in buttoning and unbuttoning her + drawers, and in gazing at her vulva. + + The summer before I was 10 I lived a wild life in the mountains. + My companions were a negro girl, the two daughters of a + clergyman, the two sons of a questionable woman hotel-keeper, and + the daughter of the Irish scavenger. All of these children were + extraordinarily sensual. Their leading pastime, from morning + until night, was varying forms of indecency, with the supreme + caress--which they termed "raising dickie"--as the most frequent + enjoyment. The 5-year-old daughter of the scavenger explained to + us how she had seen her father approaching her stout mother with + an erect penis, the pair standing up before the lamplight during + the act. This curly-headed, rosy-cheeked child handled her + genitals so much that they were inflamed. I once saw her sitting + in the road and rubbing dust against her vulva. I saw little of + the elder daughter of the minister (she was 12 years old). She + persuaded me to expose myself before her in the cellar of a + partially-built house. In return for my favor she allowed me to + look at her genitals. She did not ask for _conjunctio_. The two + younger daughters were my intimates. With the middle one I was + forever performing a weak conjunction that consisted in the + laying of my member against her vulva. Notwithstanding all the + entreaties of my little friend, I could not be persuaded to + protrude my penis against her vagina; and not on one occasion can + I remember obtaining an erection or extreme pleasure. Up in the + garret she straddled slanting beams with her genitals exposed, + and I followed her example. The negro girl and my little friend + both urinated on a tent floor at my request. I did not fancy the + odor of a girl's genitals, nor the appearance of the vulva when + the labia were held apart. + + The following summer, when I was almost 11, I took a long walk + one day with my old friend, the girl E. We entered a patch of + woods and ate our lunch, but no sense of sexual drawing toward + the girl came over me and she did not offer to entice me. I + slept with her boy-cousin one night, and her neuropathic aunt, a + retired lady physician, bothered us by repeatedly creeping into + our room. I felt intuitively that she was watching to see whether + we would commit mutual masturbation--which we had no thought of + doing. Three years before I had opened the door of her bedroom + suddenly and saw E.'s naked form. The physician had been + examining her, E. told me later. My guardian also annoyed me by + repeated warnings not to play with myself. + + Just before I turned 11 I was sent to a small and so-called + "home" boarding-school. Eight of us lived in the smaller + dormitory. The matron roomed downstairs. There was no resident + master--a serious error. We small boys were told to strip one + evening. We were then tied neck-to-neck and made to dance a + "slave-dance," which was marked by no sexuality. A boy of 15, R., + one afternoon gave me the astonishing information that my father + had taken a part in my procreation. Up to this moment I had known + only of the maternal offices, information of which had been + beautifully supplied to me by my guardian when I was 7 years old. + At that time I talked freely about the coming of a baby brother + in a distant city; I watched the construction of baby clothes; I + named the newcomer, and I was momentarily disappointed when he + proved to be a girl. This same R., a strong boy with a large + penis, got into the custom of lying in bed with me just before + lights were put out. He would read to himself and occasionally + pause to pump his penis and make with his lips the sound of a + laboring locomotive. I felt impelled to handle his organ, for I + was fascinated by its size, and stiffness, and warmth. Rarely he + would titillate my then small and unerect penis. R. never + ejaculated when he was with me; hence not until my third year was + I acquainted with the appearance of a flow of semen. Sometimes R. + would stop during his dressing to manipulate his penis, but was + such a picture of rosy health that I doubt whether he brought + himself often to ejaculation. R. told me that he had been to a + brothel where his genitals were examined to determine whether + they were large enough and not diseased. He also related how he + "played cow" with a girl of his own age, she consenting to + perform _fellatio_ upon him. A dark-skinned, unwashed, pimpled + but fairly vigorous boy of 16, with an irritable domineering + manner, told me the delights of coitus with a girl in a + bath-house, and I overheard his conversation with another "old" + boy concerning the purchase of a girl in a big city for the sum + of five dollars. No details were given. + + I will now pass to my third year, when I was 13 years old. A + large, well-set-up boy of 16, A., became my idol. His toleration + of my presence in his room filled me with endless love. When I + lied about a matter in which he was concerned, his denunciation + of me brought me to a state of shuddering and weeping + unspeakable. When our relations were established again A. + allowed me to creep into his bed after the lights were out, and + there I passionately embraced him, but without performing any + definite act. When I turned over on my side with my back to him + he drew my prepuce back and forth until I experienced orgasm, but + not ejaculation. I would return his favor by pumping his erect + penis, but with no ejaculation on his part. He did not propose + _fellatio_, and I did not think of it. One night when he was in + my bed I began to masturbate very slightly, whereupon he laughed, + saying: "So that is the way you amuse yourself!" As a matter of + fact the habit was not fastened upon me. He always laughed when + the rubbing of his finger on my exposed glans caused me to + shrink. Another boy, H., now began to show me his erect penis and + we practiced mutual manipulations. A. laughingly told me how me + had caught H. in the act of masturbating as he stood in the + bath-tub. A. told me a number of sexual stories--how he enjoyed + coitus in the bushes with a girl on the way home from + entertainments; how half a dozen boys and girls stripped in the + basement of a church and performed coitus on the velvet chairs + which stood behind the pulpit; and how he and a younger boy, who + camped out together, played with each other's genitals. F., a boy + of 11, was highly nervous, subject to timidity and tears on the + slightest provocation, often morose, and under treatment for + kidney trouble. His penis was erect whenever I saw him undress. + He told me that a partially idiotic man taught F. and his + companion how to masturbate. The man invited the boys to his tent + and there pumped his organ until "some white stuff came out of + it." F. also told me that an Indian princess in his part of the + country would permit coitus for fifty cents. A. sometimes slept + with F., and I could imagine their embraces. S., a secretive, + handsome boy of 13, wetted his bed with urine every night. The + only sign that he gave of an interest in sexuality was his + laughing remark concerning the coupling of rose-bugs. Of his + chum, my beloved C., I will speak later. My small room-mate + handled himself only slightly. I never had a desire to lie with + him, since I disliked him, nor with my first room-mate, a + "chunky," fiery boy of 10, whose penis interested me merely + because it was circumcised and almost always erect. His + masturbation was also so slight as not to attract any particular + attention. A lusty German boy, B., showed no signs of sexuality + until his third year, when he laughed about his newly-appearing + pubic hair, and told several of us openly of how he enjoyed to + play "a drum-beat" on his penis before going to sleep. "I don't + do it too much, though," he explained. He showed a mild curiosity + when I gave him the resumé of a book on cohabitation which + contained illustrations of the erect penis and the female organs. + I had found this book in the woods and I read it eagerly during + my third year. + + I came to the point of agreeing with A., who said: "Everyone is + smutty." Indeed I lived in a lustful world, and yet my mind was + bent also on books, and writing, and the outdoor world. I was + overgrown and splendidly developed, with a medium-sized penis and + a scant growth of pubic hair. My face wore a somewhat infantile + expression. My mouth was a perfect "Cupid's bow," my hair thin + and light. I was troubled about my snub-nose, which gave the boys + a great deal of amusement. As a matter of fact I exaggerated its + upward tendency out of my morbid self-consciousness and + cowardice. My imagination was extraordinarily intense, as it had + always been. I was sensitive to smells and sounds and colors and + personalities, and to the subtle influence of the night. I was + timid and easily moved to tears, but not from any physical + weakness until after. At the lower house there was the boy Z., + famed for his large penis; and the older G., a boy of 15, who was + the leader in sexuality at his dormitory. Z. showed me his penis + and exposed his glans often enough, but we did not manipulate + each other. G. told us to notice how large a space his penis + occupied in his trousers, and laughed over Z.'s custom of + masturbating by means of a narrow vase. G.'s special lover was a + nervous boy of ten. It is remarkable that none of us mentioned + _fellatio_ or _pædicatio_. These acts may have occurred at + school, but not to my knowledge. We did not have much to say + sexually about the girls. We heard rumors of a 16-year-old, V., + who had been sent away from school for coitus; and my first + room-mate was said to have obtained _conjunctio_ with a girl + under cover of the chapel shed. Once A. and I pointed a telescope + at the open windows of the girls' dormitory, but we saw nothing + to interest us. A day-scholar, J., a pale, nervous, bright boy of + 13, took me into the study of his uncle-physician and together we + gloated over pictures of the sexual organs. A. was with us on one + occasion. J. told me how he liked to roll over and over in bed + with his hand placed under his scrotum. This act, he said, made + him imagine that he was obtaining coitus. He advised me to slide + my penis back and forth in the vagina whenever I should actually + obtain coitus. In my room at school J. once drew an imaginary map + of a bagnio, in which the water-closet was carefully displayed + _en suite_ with the bedrooms. J. and I never masturbated + together. Indeed, I cannot remember seeing his organ. A hulking + boy of 16, who lived opposite the school-grounds, became intimate + with J., and we three went on a walk up the railroad track. The + big boy, W., tried to inflame my passions by telling me how he + and J. had had coitus with a handsome black-haired widow in town, + but I remained cold. + + During this year I fell in love with C., a popular, talkative, + witty boy of my own age, or perhaps a year younger. He fancied me + and we slept together one night under the most innocent + circumstances. I never dreamed of having sexual relations with + him, and yet I fairly burned with love for him. My stay at his + beautiful home over Sunday while his parents were away was one + long delight. We slept in each other's arms, but there was no + sexuality. En route to C.'s home he pointed with a glove to a + little working-girl, saying he would like to have intercourse + with her, but this was the only remark of the kind that ever + passed his lips in my presence. When undressed save for his + undershirt, he laughingly held his unerect organ in his hand and + made the motions of obtaining conjunction with an imaginary + partner. Once we spoke of masturbation (I could recite the + information of my good physician with a marvelous show of + virtue), and C. remarked: "Yes, doing that makes boys crazy." C. + finally grew tired of my deceptive, babyish nature and + ultra-interest in books and puzzles, but I cherished an + undiminished affection for him, and when he was detained at home + for a fortnight with a broken arm, I wrote him a passionate + letter, which I sobbed over and actually wetted with my tears. + But the fervor of my passion died at the close of the year. I + consider this unsullied friendship to be the only redeeming + feature of my sensual days at school. + + Versed as I was in the warnings against masturbation, I found + pleasure one afternoon when I was alone in slipping my penis + through the open handle of a pair of scissors and in violently + flapping my partially erect organ until a strange, sweet thrill + crept over me from top to toe and a drop of clear liquid oozed + from my member. But I gave up the manipulation with scissors, + finding a greater satisfaction in masturbating while I was + defecating or just after it. I either pumped my organ by slipping + the prepuce back and forth, or I grasped the organ at its root + and violently jerked it back and forth. I soon began to + masturbate not only every time that I defecated, but also at + night just before I went to sleep, and sometimes early in the + morning. On the whole I preferred the jerking just described. I + always brought about ejaculation after perhaps five minutes of + violent exertion. + + My penis became chafed at the root, but I did not especially + care. I remember the afternoon that I masturbated for the first + time while I was defecating in the school water-closet. I cannot + recall that at first I thought of coitus while I masturbated. On + one occasion I masturbated over the _vase de nuit_ after a + delightful afternoon of tobogganing exploration up and down the + mountain. + + During this first year of abuse, I felt no ill effects + whatsoever, although I realized, in an unthinking way, that I was + doing wrong. But sexuality had assumed the proportion of a + regular feature of our school life. It was difficult for me to + place a "universal" view in its true perspective. I used to smile + at the glazed, dull morning eye of poor H., who was a stunted boy + of 15, and thus could not endure his losses so well as I could + endure them. The qualms of conscience which I suffered were lost + in my delight in my dawning sexual life. Sometimes I lay on my + stomach in bed, and by placing my hand under my scrotum, + according to the directions of J., brought up a pretty girl to + mind. Just before Sunday school G., our chief reprobate, and the + rest of us would hunt out what we considered to be nasty texts of + Scripture. The chapter concerning the whoredoms of Aholah and + Aholibah gave me an especial pleasure. T. mentioned the giggling + that occurred at prayers in the lower dormitory when the details + of Esau's birth were read out. A few days before G. was + expelled--for exactly what cause I do not know--he told me of how + greatly he enjoyed coitus on his grandmother's sofa with a girl + of fifteen. When I went home on the boat for holidays I noted the + large, black-haired penis of the strong boy of our school. He + occupied a state-room with me, but made no sexual overtures. + + Since my twelfth year I had been wrapped up all summer long in a + boy who was six months my senior. We slept together constantly, + but not once did we think of obtaining mutual gratification. On + the contrary, we held up high ideals to each other and frowned on + masturbation. I took delight in saying that I never had handled + myself, and never would do so. Even at the height of my + "auto-erotic" period, I skillfully concealed my habits from all + my boy friends. A neurotic solo choir boy friend once spoke of + obtaining ejaculation, whereupon I expressed utter ignorance of + such an act, little hypocrite that I was. This boy told how the + house servants joked with him about coitus and made laughing + lunges at his organs. + + But much as I loved my chum, my most passionate regard went out + in my thirteenth year to N., a chubby, blue-eyed, choir-boy of + 12. He was a pretty boy to any eye. He was not gifted, except in + water-sports, and anything but popular either with girls or with + boys; yet I grew warm at the mention of his name. He did not care + a fig for me. From first to last I had no consciousness of the + sexual nature of my passion, and the thought of doing more than + embrace and kiss him in an innocent manner never crossed my mind. + For two summers I had nights of tossing on my bed (although I + almost never was sleepless for any cause) when I would see his + dear face and form, in and out of the swimming pool, or engaged + perhaps in singing or in showing his beautiful teeth. I seldom + was smitten with little girls, and I found myself embarrassed in + their company after my ninth year; yet I thought well enough of + their looks and ways to enjoy their company at dances. The girls + liked me in a platonic way, for I was accounted a good, big, + kind, blundering boy with a helping hand for the smallest fry. + + During the summer after I was 13, I imagined myself in the early + morning, when I was half awake, as persuading my wife to have + coitus with me. In the course of my spoken words I kept my hand + under my scrotum. + + A plump girl-cousin of my own age was visiting at my uncle's + during the summer after I was 13. With her I greatly desired to + satisfy myself, but I could not be sure that my boy cousin (5 + years old) might not find us out, even though she should consent. + Once when we three were in the hay-loft a wave of lust rolled + over me, but I made no proposal. Night and gaslight greatly + increased my _libido_. On one occasion my aunt had gone to the + village for ice-cream, and L. and I were left alone in the + dining-room. I took her on my lap and had a powerful erection. I + almost asked her to play sexually with me in the barn, but + instead I spoke of an imaginary girl, the first letters of whose + successive names spelled an indecent word for coitus--a word + known to almost every Anglo-Saxon child, I fear. L. laughed, but + gave no sign of assent. For a neighboring girl of 15 I felt such + a drawing that early in the morning I would roll on the floor + with my erect organ in my hand in riotous imagining of coitus + with her. I walked with her in the woods and sat at her feet, but + although I felt instinctively that she would satisfy me without + much persuasion, yet I _could not_ ask her. One night I started + to church in order to walk home with her, and lead her (if + possible) to a field where we might gratify ourselves (I picked + out the exact grassy spot where we might lie); but when I was + almost at the church door my "moral sense" (if that is what it + was) rose and dragged me home again. + + During the swimming hour I watched the genitals of the boys, + comparing them carefully in the most minute details. Circumcised + organs affected me as being disagreeable, and men's hairy, coarse + genitals I abhorred. + + When 13 I became acquainted with the new mail-boy at the inn. He + was a city "street-boy," and got me into smoking cigarettes + occasionally. I did not definitely take up smoking until I was + 16. He told me that a mason once offered him ten cents if he + would masturbate the man in a cellar. The boy said that he + refused. I slept a few times with an ill-favored boy of fine + parentage. He was of my own age, and I had played with him in a + natural way for several years, but my increasing sexual desires + led me to mutually masturbate with him, and even unsuccessfully + to attempt with him mutual pædicatio. On the morning after our + nights of sensuality I felt "gone" and miserable, but not + repentant. By afternoon I was myself again. My relations with G. + were purely animal, for I disliked his jealous disposition, his + horse-laugh, his features, his form, his withdrawn scrotum and + his undersized penis. At home in the evening I often found myself + inflamed with a mental picture of active _fellatio_ with him, but + I never performed this act, so far as I remember. + + One of my great sexual desires was to walk along a fence on which + a girl was seated. In order that I might feast my eyes on her + pudenda she must not wear drawers. + + When I turned 14 I had been, from my unusual size, in long + trousers for several months. I entered a private day-school and + progressed brilliantly in my studies. I kept up masturbation + almost daily, sometimes twice a day, both in the water closet and + in bed. I can remember ejaculating before urination in the school + _cabinet_. At night I often found myself longing for the return + of my sister, seven years my junior, in order that I might + embrace her in bed and fondle her genitals. I had done these + things during my Christmas vacation of the year before. I mildly + reproached myself for such incestuous desires, but they recurred + continually. I dreamed little. And I cannot remember the + character of my dreams. My waking _libido_ spent itself mostly in + longings to embrace (without lustful acts) the forms of little + boys of exquisite blonde beauty and thick hair. Narcissism may + have been present, for in my twelfth year I had been told that at + the age of 5 and 6 I was an extraordinarily beautiful little + creature with long, lint-white hair. The preferable age was from + 6 to 9. My eye was alert on the streets for boys answering to + this description, and a street boy with long, white hair so won + my passion that I followed him to his home and asked his mother + if he might call on me and "play some games." As I did not even + know the boy's name and had never seen him before, I was + wonderingly refused. I sought in vain to find the whereabouts of + another long-haired street boy whom I burned to embrace and load + with benefits. I had a boundless desire for such a boy as this to + idolize me--to look into my face out of big eyes and lose himself + in love for me--to call me by endearing pet names--of his own + accord to throw his arms around my neck. This second actual boy + disappeared from my horizon by presumably moving away from the + vast city neighborhood. I took a fancy to a small boy at school, + who possessed the requisite delicacy, timidity, and sweetness, if + not the physical requisites, of my beau ideal. I walked with him + in the park and planned to have him at the house; but the matter + was not arranged. At boarding-school I had associated much with + younger and weaker boys, and had been ridiculed much for my + cowardice in sports, but at the city school I moved with my + equals and won their recognition. Our gymnasium director was + middle-aged and of an indolent disposition. He liked to recall + his youthful erections and to answer my sexual queries too fully, + and cheerfully volunteered information on brothels. Yet I doubt + whether he had an evil purpose in conversing with me. I thought I + should never dare or want to enter one. I always conjured up the + picture of a row of naked women from whom I could take my pick, + and the smell of the women I imagined to be identical with the + smell of my big friend A. at boarding-school. When I was + traveling down town on an elevated train one afternoon the + brakeman asked me whether I had ever been in a brothel, and told + me that disorderly houses abounded in my neighborhood. "I have + had connection with women," said this red-haired young man, + waving his hand in greeting to a woman who nodded at him from a + window, "since I was 15 years old. Not long ago a fine-looking, + young woman in black offered to pay all my expenses if I would + live with her and connect with her." + + When a girl of perhaps 7, a distant cousin of mine, visited us + for a few days, I gratified my lust by placing my hand under her + genitals and swinging her to and fro. She giggled with pleasure. + That summer I began to experience the evil effects of the + masturbation which I had practiced daily for a year and a half. + Pimples began to break out on my chin (my complexion up to this + time had been white and delicate). The family ascribed my + condition to digestive difficulties. In playing with the boys and + girls I found myself seized with a terrible shyness and a + tendency to look down and weep. I had lost all the courage I + had--it had never been great--in the presence of a crowd of + children. I was fairly at ease with a single companion. My + self-consciousness was something more painful to me than I can + convey in words. At home I wept in my room and cursed myself for + a baby. I little realized the cause of my nervous collapse. Yet I + had too robust a frame not to be able to sleep and to play hard. + The sympathetic pleasure which I had found in swinging my + girl-cousin to and fro I now doubled by letting a 7-year-old boy + ride cock-horse on my feet. I experienced an erection during the + process, and I almost induced ejaculation when I tickled the boy + with my feet in the region of his genitals. To see his shrinking, + giggling joy gave me an exquisite sexual thrill. I longed to + sleep with the boy, but I was afraid of causing comment. At the + new and large boarding school which I entered in the fall my most + lustful dreams and ejaculations were concerned with standing this + little boy on the footboard of a bed, taking down his + knickerbockers, and performing _fellatio_ on him. But I dreamed + also of natural coitus. I fell in love with the handsome, + 12-year-old son of the aged headmaster. The boy, O., sat next me + at the table, and I never tired of gazing at him. It gave me a + special sense of pleasure to look at him when he wore a certain + flowing, scarlet, four-in-hand necktie. But O. was not attracted + to me--for one thing I was in a disagreeably pimpled + condition--and I could not induce him to linger in my room nor to + sleep with me. My passion for O. did not diminish, and it rose to + its supremacy on the evening when he appeared in our hallway (he + roomed on the girls' side of the house and hinted at the sexual + sights that he saw) in a costume of white satin, lace, and wings. + He was ready for a costume party. + + I now masturbated less frequently, for I was beginning to + appreciate the horrible consequences of my indulgence. I had + frequent pollutions, with dreams. My day was one long agony of + fear. How I dreaded to go to sleep in the same bed with my older + chum, who never made any advances beyond embracing me passively + _cum erectione_ while he was asleep. My day was one long agony of + fear. At meal time my feet constantly writhed in agony for fear + that the headmaster's grown up young ladies should make fun of + me, or that my lack of facial composure and my inability to look + people in the eye might be commented upon. I tingled with + apprehension, especially in the region of my stomach. Every nerve + was taut in the effort I made to appear composed. I masturbated + with erections over nothing. Greek recitations were for me an + _auto da fe_. My heart beat like a trip-hammer at the thought of + getting up to recite, and once on my feet my voice shook and my + mind wandered. I hated the thought of people behind me looking at + me. I rarely summoned the courage to turn my head either one way + or the other. I vastly admired the "bravery" of the small, + 15-year-old boy who recited so calmly and so well. I was too + cowardly to play foot-ball and base-ball, and I dreaded even my + favorite tennis because the spectators put me in a state of + scared self-consciousness. Knowing my own condition, I was yet so + blind to it most of the time, and such a Jekyll-and-Hyde, that I + actually pitied a boy of 19 who was an eccentric and a scared + victim of masturbation. But in spite of my neuropathic condition + I developed intellectually. I do not touch upon this aspect of my + life, however, because I am trying to limit myself strictly to + sexual manifestations. At the present time I have not the courage + to continue the narrative. + + + HISTORY III.--The following narrative is written by a clergyman, + age 40, unmarried:-- + + My childhood and early boyhood were unmarked by sexual phenomena, + beyond occasional erections, which commenced when about 5 years + of age, without any exciting causes. These were accompanied by + some degree of excitement, of the same nature as that which I + experienced in later years. I was absolutely ignorant of sexual + matters, but always had an idea that the essential difference + between man and woman was to be found in the genital organs. This + was sometimes a matter for thought and curiosity. + + Being for many years an only child I saw little of other + children, and formed the habit of amusing myself with making + things--boats, houses, etc.--and acquired a taste for science. + When I could read I preferred biography, history, and poetry to + anything else. + + When I was 13 years old and at a large school I heard for the + first time of coitus, but very imperfectly. For a few days it + filled my thoughts and mind, but feeling it was too engrossing a + subject and one which took me off better things, I put it out of + my mind. Later, another boy gave me a fuller description of the + matter, and I began to have a great desire to know more and to be + old enough to practice it. I also discovered that boys + masturbated, and about a year after tried the experiment for + myself. This vice was largely indulged in by my school-fellows. + It never occurred to me that it was sinful, until I was nearly + 16, when I came across a passage in Kenns's _Manual of + Schoolboys_, in which it was hinted such things were wrong + morally and spiritually. Previously I had felt it was an + indelicate and shameful thing, and bad for health. This last idea + was held as a solemn fact by all my boy friends. Gradually + religion began to exert an influence over my sexual nature, + obtaining as years passed a greater and greater restraining + power. It is simply impossible for me to write a history of my + sexual development without also describing the action which + Christianity has had in determining its growth. The two have been + so intimately bound together that my life history would not be a + faithful record of facts if I left religion out of it. + + At school I took part, with great keenness, in cricket and + foot-ball, and was very ambitious to excel in everything in which + I took an interest, but I always had other tastes as well, which + were more precious to me, for example, the love for science, + history, and poetry. Until I was past 16 years my desire was + simply for coitus, girls and women attracted me only as affording + the means of gratifying this desire; but when I was nearly 17 I + began to regard girls as beautiful objects, apart from this, and + to desire their love and companionship. At the same time it + dawned upon me that life held much of joy in the love of women + and in domestic life--so henceforth I regarded them in a higher + and purer light, and apart from sexual gratification. In fact, + from this period till I was over 20, this idea so dominated my + whole being that the lower side of my nature was entirely held in + subjection and abeyance by it. It was rather repulsive to think + of girls as objects of lust. This state of mind was not brought + about by any romantic attachment or through any acquaintance or + through circumstances. I was living in great seclusion and had no + girl friends. After this period the lower side of my nature woke + up as a giant refreshed with wine, and I underwent for many years + a constant struggle with my nature, in which religion always + triumphed in the end. I never fell into fornication, though + sometimes into the vice of masturbation. These outbursts of + desire were periodic, about ten or fourteen days apart, and would + last several days. I must record also the fact that from the time + this awakening took place my ideal views of woman no longer + seemed incompatible with sexual relations. I noticed that at + about 27 there was a lessening of the desire, but that may have + been due to overwork and consequent nervous exhaustion. I had a + good deal of worry and studied daily for about eight hours. In + any case the impulse was strongest during the years above + mentioned. A little later in life, for a time, I became attached + to a girl, and eventually engaged. I then observed, greatly to my + sorrow and annoyance, that whenever I met this lady, or even + thought of her, erections took place. This was particularly + painful to me, as my thoughts were not of a lustful or impure + character. Sometimes sitting by her at a religious service this + would occur, when certainly my mind was far away from anything of + the kind. That was the first woman ever kissed by me, except of + course members of my immediate family circle. Later on my + thoughts turned to marriage, and there was a great longing at + times for this event to take place. However, as this attachment + afterward became the great sorrow of my life for years, it needs + no more comment. This closes one chapter of my history, and at + present I do not propose to add another, as in a great measure it + is only partly written. It may be well here to state that there + has never been in me the slightest homosexual desire; in fact it + has always appeared as a thing utterly inconceivable and + disgustingly loathsome. I am fond of the society of both men and + women, but on the whole prefer the latter. I have had several + warm and intimate though platonic friendships, and get on + exceedingly well with the other sex, although not a good-looking + man. I have always been attracted to women by their spiritual or + mental qualities, rather than by physical beauty, and feel + strongly that the latter alone would never cause me to desire + coitus. Unless there was an attraction other than that of the + flesh, I should feel that I was following simply a brute + instinct, and it would jar with my higher nature and cause + revulsion. This was not the case in my earlier years to the same + extent. I have often wondered whether the sexual impulse was + strong in me or not, but if not, there is nothing in my physical + state or family history to account for it. I am fairly cognizant + with the lives of my ancestors, being descended from two old + families. The sexual instinct was certainly not weak or abnormal + in them. Personally, I am tall and healthy, well built, but + sensitive and highly strung. Smell has never played any part in + my life as a stimulant of sexual desire, and the mere thought of + body odors would have a very decided effect in the opposite + direction. Touch and sight appeal to me strongly, and of the two + the former most. + + I am convinced, after many years careful thought, that sexual + vice and perversion could be greatly reduced if the young were + instructed in the elements of physiology as they bear on this + question. Personally, had I been thus enlightened much sin would + have been avoided in my schoolboy days, and a perverted view of + sexual matters would never have arisen in my mind. It took years + to overcome the feeling that all such things were unclean and + defiling. Eventually light came to me through reading a passage + in a tractate on the Creed by Rufinus. He was defending the + doctrine, of the Incarnation against the pagan objection that it + was an unclean and disgusting idea that God should enter the + world through the womb of the Blessed Virgin Mary, and he meets + it by showing that God created the sexual organs, therefore the + objection is invalid--otherwise God would not be clean or pure, + having Himself designed them and their functions. This passage is + slight in itself, but gave birth to a line of thought which has + influenced me profoundly. I no longer regard sexual matters as + disgusting and unholy, but as intensely sacred, being the outcome + of the Divine Mind. Further, the Incarnation of the Saviour has + not only sanctioned motherhood and all that is implied by it, but + has eternally sanctified it as the means chosen for the + manifestation of God to the world. I should not obtrude my + theological conceptions, but for the fact that they have + determined my life-history in that aspect. + + + HISTORY IV.--When I was 9 years old a boy at the preparatory + school, which I attended, showed me the act of masturbation, + which he said he had practiced for a long time, and which he + urged me to imitate, if I wished to become a father when I grew + up, and married! Boy-like I believed him and tried, but the + sensation obtained was not a pleasant one (I suppose that I was + too rough with myself) and I desisted. + + When I was about 12 years old, a schoolfellow told me that he had + seen his nurse copulating with the groom, and he and I used to + haunt the woods in the hope that we might see an amorous couple + so engaged, but without success. We often talked of the act, as + to how it was done. Neither he nor I had any clear ideas on the + subject, save as to the organs involved. I was about 15 when a + maidservant of the house in which I was a boarder, came to my + bedroom one night and taught me how to masturbate her. She said + that this was a good thing for me to do, and warned me never to + "play with myself" as it would kill me, or drive me mad. I told + her that I had tried it, but could not bring on a pleasurable + feeling, so she did it to me, and although I did not have an + emission, I derived great pleasure from the act. She told me that + it never did a boy any harm to let a girl play with his parts, + and promised that if I would keep the secret, she would often do + this for me. Naturally I promised to say nothing, and she often + came up to my room. Later on she used to insert my penis into her + vulva, while she was rubbing it, at the same time giving me a + pigeon kiss. This _modus operandi_ was much appreciated by me. + One night, after we had been together thus, I dreamt of her and + her maneuvers and had my first emission. I was very proud of + this, as I considered that I had at last attained to man's + estate, and told her of it. She never allowed me to insert my + penis into her vulva after that, alleging that she did not want + to have a baby. + + I was about 16½ years old when I had my first real coitus, my + partner in the act being a girl some two years older than I, who + lived near us. I enjoyed the act very much, as she permitted, nay + insisted on, emission _intra vaginam_, and told her that this was + much nicer than my amours with the maidservant which of course I + had confided to her. She laughed, and said: "Of course." We often + copulated, as long as I was at home, and then I lost sight of + her. Of all the women with whom I have had to do, save one, she + had the most copious secretion of mucus, which in those days I + believed was the woman's semen. Her thighs used to be wet with + it. + + At the University I had regular relations with women of all + sorts, rarely missing a week. Two of them were married women, one + the wife of a solicitor, the other of a doctor. How proud I felt + of my first intrigue with a married woman! I felt that I was + really a man of the world now! + + But though my friends used to tell me all about their love + affairs, and I longed to confide in them, I did not do so. This + was because when I went up to the University, my uncle said that + he would give me a word of advice and hoped that I would follow + it--never to give away a woman, and never to refuse to respond to + a woman's advances, whoever she were. To neglect this advice + would, he said, be foolish, and to break the rules "damned + ungentlemanly." I wish I had always followed advice proffered, as + closely as I have followed this. One night, when I was somewhat + disguised in liquor, as our grandfathers would have put it, I + picked up a girl, who was a private prostitute, if the phrase be + permissible. She declined copulation, and proposed other means of + satisfaction. I insisted, being stubborn in my cups. Had I been + sober I should have done as she suggested, for I have always made + it a point to allow the woman to choose the method of + gratification, and not to demand, or even suggest, anything + myself. I like to please women, and I have always been curious as + to their wants and desires, as revealed, without outside + influence, by themselves. The result of my refusing all methods + of gratification save the most ordinary was that the girl, who + must have known that she was not all right, but shrank from + saying so in so many words, gave me a gonorrhoea, which lasted + nine weeks and much interfered with my amours, as I naturally + declined to run the risk of infecting my partner, a risk which to + my certain knowledge many a young fellow has run, with disastrous + consequence to the confiding woman. As it was due to my tipsy + obstinacy, I could not blame the girl, but resolved never to + drink too much again, a resolve which I have kept, save once, + unbroken. In those days we youngsters thought that it was manly + to be able to carry one's liquor well, and did all in our power + to attain to the seasoned head; but I considered that the risks + entailed were too serious to be neglected. + + I was well on in my 26th year when I met a widow with whom I fell + in love, with the result that I married her. She is a most + sensible woman, and it was her intellectual gifts which were the + attraction to me. In my amours intellect has never played a part. + She has all along been cognizant of, and lenient to, my + polygamous tendencies; for she recognizes the fact that whatever + _fredaine_ I may have on hand makes not the slightest difference + in my love and respect for her. Were she a more sensual woman, + perhaps things would be different. + + In all I have had to do with 81 other women, of whose special + characteristics I kept a careful note at the time. Twenty-six + were normal women with whom my _liasons_ have lasted long, so I + know more about them than I do about the other fifty-five, who + were prostitutes, and with some of whom my dealings were but for + an afternoon. + + The races represented have been these, for I have seen a bit of + the world: English, Scotch, Irish, Welsh, French, German, + Italian, Greek, Danish, Hungarian, Roumanian, Indian, and + Japanese. Taking them all round, the only difference that I found + between old and young women is that the older ones are less + selfish, and more complaisant, and less inclined to resent one's + being unable to attain to the height of their desire, for from + time to time I have been unable to "come up to the scratch" after + a heavy night's labor, or when I was afraid of being caught in + the act of coition, a fear which, in my experience, acts as a + stimulus to desire in women, unlike its action in men. Of all the + women with whom I have had to do the nicest in every way have + been the French women. The English women of the town drink too + much, and are far too keen on getting as much money as they can + for as little as they can, to please me. Were the London girls to + recognize that men do not like a tipsy woman, and that where + there is so much competition the person who is most skillful and + most polite gets the most custom, the alien invasion in Regent + street would soon come to an end. + + Of the fifty-five prostitutes: eighteen informed me that they + were in the habit of masturbating; eight of their own free will, + without asking for reward, did _fellatio_; six asked me to do + _cunnilingus_, which I naturally declined to do; three proposed + anal coitus. Of those who did _fellatio_, two (one French and one + German) told me that they had taken to it because they had heard + that human semen was an excellent remedy against consumption, + which disease had carried off some of their relatives, and that + they had gradually come to like doing it. All who told me that + they masturbated, asked me whether I did so too, and two desired + me to show them the act, one alleging that she liked to see a man + do it; she had been married late in life, after a "stormy youth" + and had had, she said, a large experience of the male sex. They + all seemed to think that however much the practice of + self-excitement might hurt a man, and all thought that it would + hurt him, a woman might masturbate as often as she liked, failing + better means of satisfaction, as she had no such loss of + substance as a man. + + Of the twenty-six normal women, whom I knew more intimately than + I did the fifty-five prostitutes, thirteen, without being + questioned by me, blurted out the fact that they were habitual + masturbators, apparently all required to think of the loved + person to obtain full satisfaction. _Fellatio_ was proposed, and + fully performed, by nine, of whom three experienced the orgasm as + soon as they perceived that I had attained to it. All were more + or less excited while doing it. One proposed anal coitus, "just + to see what it was like;" and three proposed _cunnilingus_, one + having been initiated by a girl friend, and one by her husband. + The third had, I believe, evolved the act out of her own inner + consciousness in her desire to experience pleasure with me. My + relations with one of the twenty-six were confined to my + masturbation of her, the while she did _fellatio_, as she said + that she "had no feeling inside down there." + + With two exceptions my partings from these normal women have not + been tragic and all whom I have met in after life (seven) have + been very ready to resume relations with me, four of them having + made the proposal themselves. + + One thing has struck me, and that is the, often great, difference + that exists between what a woman's looks lead one to think she + is, and what she is when one becomes her lover; the most sensual + woman that I have met might have sat for her portrait as the + Madonna, and she was the only one who took pleasure in hearing + and relating "smoking-room stories," a form of amusement which, + perhaps from their want of appreciation of humor and wit, women + do not indulge in--at least in my experience. + + + HISTORY V.--(A continuation of History III in Appendix B to the + previous volume.) + + As I became better I commenced to dream of true love. I wondered, + too, if my horrible past really could be lived down and a young + woman come to love _me_. I took pleasure in reading love poems, + especially Browning's, and illustrated some with little + water-colors.... + + I was sitting in the stalls one night seeing a performance by a + company of English actors when one of them played so badly that I + thought to myself: "Why, hang it, I could play it better myself!" + The next minute another thought followed: "Why not try?" I came + out of the stalls the proverbial stage-struck youth. I was + sitting in the same place another night when the young man next + to me entered into conversation. By a strange coincidence he knew + a few young men, amateurs, who were going to form a company, give + up their situations and travel, if they could induce a few more + to join them and put a little money in. I made an appointment for + the following evening.... + + There were lots of meetings in bedrooms and rehearsals between + the beds, but ultimately I was told a school-room had been + engaged and a professional actress, A.F. I went to the + school-room and found all the boys there, and a young woman with + a pale, rice-powder complexion. On introduction she gazed at me + as if struck dumb. If she had been better-looking (I thought her + vulgar and puffy) I would have been flattered. I was + disappointed, but rather frightened (she had a stage presence) of + her professional ability, especially when we commenced to + rehearse. I had to make love to her, too, which embarrassed me. + She had a good profile, I noticed, and would have been better + looking, I thought, if she were in better condition, for she was + young, about my own age, twenty-three or four. We were all + young--enjoyed our rehearsals, and had lots of fun--but I did not + respond to the advances A. was evidently making to me. Finally we + started on our tour. As the weeks went on A.F., like the others, + improved wonderfully in health and appearance. If we had had + anything like houses it would have been a pleasant trip. My + strangeness did not escape the notice of the boys altogether, for + I was still a bit strange in mind and nerves--and deeply + religious, bowing my head before each meal and reading my little + Bible and prayer-book at odd times. I drank no alcohol. I spent a + good deal of time by myself of with my faithful companion A., who + was nearly always at my side, she and her appealing eyes. I was + surprised to see how quickly she had improved; she looked quite + attractive and ladylike some evenings at meals, but I only + tolerated her. I was selfish and conceited. + + Things had been going on like this for a week--always playing to + empty houses and our money lower and lower--when A. said to our + other lady, Mrs. T., on a train in my presence: "I shall have to + give him up, I suppose; he will have nothing to do with me." Mrs. + T. said: "You give him up, do you?" and looked at me as if she + were going to try her hand. A. said "Yes," and looked at me, + smiling sadly. I don't know what motive prompted me--whether my + vanity was alarmed at her threatened desertion or that she had + really made some impression on me by her love, probably a little + of both--but I said: "No, don't; come and sit down here," making + way for her, and she joyfully came and nestled against me. From + that time I ceased to treat her with ridicule, and kissed her at + other times than when on the stage. I was subject still to black + moods, and would not speak to her for hours sometimes, but she + seemed content to walk with me and was infinitely patient. I had + heard she was living with--if not married to--an actor. I asked + her about him once, and she said she did not love him; she loved + me and had never loved before. Her face had a touching sadness; + her life had been unhappy and stormy, with no love and little + rest in it. Her face, when she had lost her dissipated look and + unhealthy pallor, was exquisite, delicate as a cameo. Love had + improved her manners, too; she was more gentle and refined. I let + things drift without thinking of the future, when one night + after the performance--I was lying on the sofa and A. was sitting + at my side, as usual--I suddenly thought, with the brutality that + characterized me in these matters--"I will ask her to let me + sleep with her." I still fought against any premonitory thought + of self-abuse, but here, I thought to myself, is a chance of + something better that will do me no harm and perhaps good. When + she understood me she turned very red and walked away, shaking + her head. But I let her understand that was the only way of + retaining me, and finally, when they had all gone to bed, she + gave herself to me, reluctantly and sadly; for she, too, had been + drifting on without thinking of anything of this sort (she hated + it at this time), but just living for her love of me, her first + true love. + + Before this occurred, I must tell you, I had been so much better + that I sometimes felt capable of doing anything, a sense of power + and grasp of intellect which was combined with delicacy of + feeling and sensitiveness to beauty, to skies and clouds and + flowers. I seemed to be awakening to true manhood, to my true + self. And at meals, it is worth recording, I commenced to have a + distaste for meat. + + These glimpses of a better state of things left me on cohabiting + with A., and for a time my gloom and black religious mania came + on me once more. I now thought of my promise at confirmation, and + it seemed to me I had offended beyond pardon. When we came to the + next town, however, I openly slept with A. all night, leaving my + own bed untouched. When we returned to Adelaide one of our party + remarked: "The only man who had any success with the women on the + tour was a Bible-reading, praying, and good, pious, confirmed + Christian." + + A.'s nascent beauty and delicacy and improvement were gradually + impaired, too. My own conduct became so morose at times that, + besides increasing her misery, I offended the others, and + bickerings ensued. I heard the other actress say "He's mad; that + what's the matter." And I was so wrapped up in myself and my + religious mania that I did not mind their thinking so. + + After the tour was over A. asked me to come and see her at her + home, and as I missed her very much I went one night to tea. She + had a room in her father's house to herself. A. was dressed in + her best and we had an affectionate meeting. After tea I asked + her if she were married to E. She said "No." Then I said: "Who + are you married to?" She commenced to cry then, and told me + something of her life, the saddest I ever heard. When only 17 she + had been courted by a young man she did not care for, but who + prevailed on her parents by pretending he had seduced her, but + wished to marry her. Strange as it may seem, A. did not know what + marriage meant, her mother being one of those silly women who + don't like talking of these things and let their daughters grow + up in ignorance, expecting they will learn from some one. In nine + cases out of ten this happens, but A. was an exception. It was + this, and the fact that she had not a particle of love for her + husband, that gave her such a hatred of coition. When her mother + saw the sheets the morning after the marriage she burst out + crying; she did not like the young man and saw she had been + deceived. + + A.'s husband soon showed his true character; he was in reality a + gaol-bird. He beat her, drank, and even wanted her to go on the + streets to earn money for him. She left him and went home; it was + then she began her theatrical career by entering the ballet. At + intervals her husband, drunk and desperate, would waylay and + threaten her in the street. One day after a rehearsal he + attempted to stab her. She got on in spite of all, being a born + actress, and played small parts in traveling companies. Then E., + who had also gone on the stage, courted her and she listened to + him, not because she cared for him, but he protected her and + offered her a home. She joined him; but his drunkenness and + sensuality were so gross that he ruined his health and he + attempted to maltreat A. in a nameless way. And whenever she was + in the family way he would leave her alone and half-conscious in + the cellar for days. To add to her misery she had epileptic fits. + Then sometimes they would be out of an engagement and starving. + They had been so hungry as to steal raw potatoes out of a sack + and eat them thus, having no fire. She would often have had + engagements, but E. was jealous and would not let her act without + him. And he beat her as her husband had done, and her health + became undermined. It was just after one of the forced + miscarriages that she joined our traveling company, and that + accounted for her yellow and puffy appearance. E. was now away + up-country with a circus, but was expected down any time. A. told + me a good deal of all this, between her tears, while sitting at + my feet, and her tone carried conviction. When I ought to have + gone home I persuaded her to let me stay all night. We had been + in bed some time when her mother knocked at the door and wanted + to come in for something in a chest of drawers there. "Why don't + you open the door, A.? Who have you got there? Hasn't that fellow + gone?" A. was confused and told me to get under the bed, but I + refused, and she covered me up with the bed clothes as well as + she could and opened the door. She had hid my clothes, but missed + one of my shoes, and her mother saw it. "Oh, A.," was all she + said; "you've got that fellow in bed," and went out crying. + "Well, Fred" (my stage name), "you've got me into a nice row," A. + said. She gave me my breakfast in the morning and I walked out of + the front door without being molested. Another night I entered + her window by a ladder and stayed all night. In the middle of the + night E. came home drunk. She would not let him in and told him + she would have nothing more to do with him. He attempted to break + in the door, when A. called to me, and hearing a man in the room + he went away, saying, as he went downstairs: "Oh, A.! Oh, A.!" + as if he thought she would not have done such a thing. He never + molested us after that night. + + I think it was my intention, at first, to break off with A. + gradually. I found, however, I could not keep away from her, and + it commenced to be evident to me that a bachelor's life in + lodgings again would be dreary and lonely. And all this time the + fear that I had offended God troubled me more than I have said, + and it occurred to me (there may have been a touch of sophistry + in this, or not) that if I were a true husband to her for the + future--stuck to her and worked for her for the rest of my + days--perhaps it would find favor in God's sight and be an + atonement for my sin. Had she been free I would have married her, + I believe. But she began to be harassed by her mother and + bothered about my incessantly coming there and staying all night. + It ended in my telling her I would be a husband to her, and she + came and lived with me at my lodgings. We had one room and our + meals cost us sixpence each. Cheap as it was, it was a struggle + for me to earn money at all. I remember feeling ill and anxious + once, and sustaining myself by the thought of my father wheeling + the heavy truck up the street when he married my mother. And I + decided to wheel my truck, too. + + A. seemed happy and her love increased, if possible; at first, + though, she must have found me a trying lover, for I made her + kneel and pray with me two or three times a day, which she did + with such a queer expression of face. Sometimes her feelings got + the better of her, and she would say: "Oh, damn it, Fred, you are + always praying." And then I would be shocked and she would be + sorry.... Coitus was frequent; she commenced to like it now.... + + A. was not looking well one evening when she came in, and lay + down on the bed. Presently she commenced to make a strange noise, + and I saw her eyes were closed and her hands clenched. "Ah," said + the landlady, who came in to help me; "she has epileptic fits." + When her convulsions were over she looked blankly at us, knitting + her brows and evidently puzzling her poor brain to remember who + we were. For many years it was my fate to see her looking at me + thus, at first stony and estranged, like a dweller in another + star, then half-recalling with extended hand, then forgetting + again with hand to mouth, then the gradual dawn of memory and + love, and final full recognition. "It's Fred, my Fred!" I never + got used to it; it always moved me to tears.... It was not to be + thought that we had no quarrels. I still had fits of bad temper, + and sometimes they came into collision with A.'s temper. It hurt + my vanity considerably to see how soon she relinquished the + respectful, patient, spaniel-bearing she had when we were + traveling. I said some cruel things to her and she retorted. One + would have thought, to hear us, that all affection was over. But + when the mood of rage wore itself out we would both be sorry and + make it up with tears, and be very happy in spite of our poverty. + + I think it was lust that prevented me from striving to fulfill my + ambitions. A. let me do anything I liked, at all times of day or + night, although she seemed surprised at my proceedings sometimes, + for it was becoming a fever of lubricity with me. She still + thought only of her love. I remember her coming in one day, + tired, pale, perspiring, and worried--we had hardly anything in + the house and she had been to the theater ineffectually--and when + her eyes lighted on me the whole expression of her face changed, + softened and brightened at once, and she came and kissed me and + said: "It is so strange, I was thinking all sorts of nasty things + coming along, but as soon as I see my pet's face I feel happy--I + don't care for anything--I would sooner share a crust with him + than have all the money in the world!" + + I commenced to feel libidinous curiosity to examine her--this was + mostly on Sundays--and she let me, blushing at first, but + laughing. Then I would try new positions in coitus I had heard + of. Still she did not enter into my mood. + + She was engaged at this time to play in a pantomime and I + commenced to lead a miserable, jealous existence. I heard scandal + about her, baseless enough, but in the diseased, nervous, anxious + state I had brought myself to it nearly drove me mad. I would go + with her sometimes to visit her mother, whom I began to like. Her + brother I still saluted coldly. It caused me horror and jealousy + to see A. kissing him and letting him tickle her. In my rage, + when we came home, I even said that perhaps she would let him do + something else, naming it brutally and coarsely. I remember her + shame, astonishment, indignation and tears. If ever a man tried a + woman's love I did. But she forgave me, even that. + + We went to live in a little cottage. It was in this cottage that + A. first showed signs of lust, and in the diseased state of my + mind, instead of regretting it, I encouraged her. She told me one + day that the orgasm very often did not occur at the same time + with her as with me, and that it would not unless I put my little + finger into the anus. This her husband taught her, and she would + rather have died than confess it to me when we first met. We + would often devote our Sundays to having a picnic as we termed + our lustful bouts, stimulating ourselves with wine. Her temper + was not improved thereby (though her fits entirely stopped for a + twelvemonth)--we had wordy warfares, but we made it up again + always with tears. Nor did I allow myself to deteriorate without + reactions and excursions into better things. I was always reading + Emerson; it was he who rescued me from orthodox Christianity and + taught me to trust in myself and in Nature. I have never ceased + this struggle towards better things to this day. There, in a + nutshell, is my life; I have always been defeated when + temptation came, but I have never ceased to struggle. I + determined to be more abstemious in sexual indulgence and asked + her to help me. She agreed willingly, for she was easily led. + Whenever we fell back again into excess it was my fault. + + At a theatrical performance we first met a Miss T., a young + German who sang. She was about 25, with modest, quiet and + engaging manners. A. and she became very friendly. I liked her; + she was tall, dark and lithe, but had bad teeth. + + I had been ill and at this time A. and I had a quarrel, my temper + suddenly breaking out in murderous frenzy. I called her names and + finally put her outside the house, telling her to go to her + mother. I suffered a very hell of remorse and misery. Everything + in the quiet, lonely house reminded me of her, seemed fragrant of + her; my anguish became so keen I could not stop in the house, + though I was just as wretched walking about. I kept this up for + two days, when I met her coming to look for me. One look was + enough--"A.!" "Pet!" in broken sobs--and in tears we kissed and + made it up. Miss T. was with her, and I greeted her, too, with + happy tears in my eyes. Another time, when A. was giving way to + _her_ temper, and one would have thought all love was dead, I + said "Don't you love me then?" and the word alone was a talisman, + her face changed, she held out her arms and began to sob + quietly.... She accepted an offer to travel with a small + theatrical company who were going up-country. She was not looking + well when I left and after a time I received a telegram telling + me to come to her at once as she was ill. Dreading all sorts of + things I borrowed my fare and went to her. I knew nothing of + women, of their point of view and different code of honor, and + was very far from the attitude of Guy de Maupassant who said he + liked women all the better for their charmingly deceitful ways. + A. wanted to see me and had taken the surest means to ensure my + coming. I was angry at first, but she looked so well and was so + loving that I could not be angry long. + + One day when I was working the landlady came in and began talking + about A. and her conduct before I came. She had gone into the + actors' rooms at all hours, the woman said, and drank and been as + bad as the rest in her conversation. It was the second time a + married woman had run her down to me, and I commenced to think + there might be something in it, and suffered all my mad jealousy + over again. Not knowing the freedom actors and actresses allow + themselves on tour, without there being necessarily anything in + it, I worried till I thought I had nothing to do but die. And + then one of the great struggles of my life occurred. Walking the + country roads, I asked myself: "If it _is_ true, if she has been + unfaithful, will you forgive her and help her to arrive at her + best?" For a long time the answer was "No!" But perhaps my + striving for unity with myself had done some good, and the final + resolution was for forgiveness. I felt more peace of mind then, + and when I told a dying consumptive lodger in the house what the + landlady had said, he replied, "Don't you believe a word of it. I + know she loves you!".... + + After an absence I found myself one evening in a town where A. + was performing. I went round to the back and they told me she had + gone to a room in the hotel to change for another part. I + followed and entered the room, with a glass of spirits I found + that an effeminate young actor was bringing to her. She was half + undressed, her beautiful arms and shoulders bare. My arrival was + unexpected and she looked at me surprised, I thought coldly, as I + reproached her for not keeping a promise she had made to me to + touch no alcohol during the tour, but soon her arms were round my + neck. She cried like a child. She was bigger and handsomer and + healthier. There was not only an increased strength and size, but + an increased delicacy and sweetness; her eyes and brows were + lovely; there was an indescribable bloom and fragrance on her, + such as the sun leaves on a peach; the traveling, country air, + and freedom from coitus (had I known it) had enabled her to + arrive at her true self, not only a beautiful woman, but a woman + of fascination, of wit, vivacity and universal _camaraderie_. Her + face was like the dawn; all my fears and jealousy left me like a + cloud that melts before the sun. I remember the look on her face + as she embraced me in bed that night. It had just the very + smallest touch of sensuality, but was more like some beautiful + child's who is being caressed by one she loves; this divine, + drowsy-eyed, adorable look I had never seen on her face + before--nor have I since. + + We fell back into our old lustful ways. Later on A. became ill + and the black devil of epilepsy returned. I became gloomy.... A + restlessness and selfish brutality came over me; our love and + peace were gone. I persuaded A. to go to Melbourne and look out + for an engagement. The day before she was to sail we went to + Glenelg for a trip. The sea air, as often happened, precipitated + A.'s fits. We had gone down to the pier and A. said she felt bad. + I just managed to support her to the hotel before she became + stiff, and I made some impatient remark (for she nearly dragged + me down) which she heard, not being quite unconscious and said + half incoherently and very pitiably: "Be kind, oh, be kind!" + repeating it after consciousness left her. Her heart had been + breaking all day at the prospect of parting, and also, I expect, + because I was so ready to part with her. That moment was a crisis + in my life. I was in a murderous humor, but she looked so + unutterably wretched that it seemed impossible to be anything but + kind. I made myself speak lovingly to her, in moments of partial + consciousness, hired a room, carried her up, and nursed her and + petted her all night. The act of self-control, and forcing + myself to be kind whatever I felt, became a habit in time, a sort + of second nature. + + In a few days she sailed. When she had gone I was remorseful and + mad with myself. How could I let her go by herself? I resolved to + follow her as speedily as possible, and did so. + + If I remember rightly I came to the conclusion about this time + that we ought not to have coition unless we felt great love for + each other. It seemed to corroborate this to a certain extent + that A. always seemed more electric and pleasant to the touch + when we had connection for love and not for lust. Leave it to + Nature, I would say to myself. I began to feel how much my + struggles, efforts and temperate living had improved me. I had + more self-respect, though something of the old self-consciousness + was still left. I did not get better continuously, but in an + up-and-down zigzag. I still had moods of rage approaching madness + and periods of neurotic depression. Long walks decidedly helped + to cure me, and the sea, sun, wind, clouds and trees colored my + dreams at night very sweetly. I frequently dreamed I was walking + in orchards or forests, and a deeper, slightly melancholy but + potent savor, as of a diviner destiny, was on my soul. + + After a long absence, during which she had frequently been ill, + A. joined me. I could see she was recovering from fits, which I + began to realize that she had more frequently in absence from me, + and also from drinking, perhaps. She was small and thin, but + fresh and sweet as honey, and all signs of fits and tempers + passed away from her face, so wonderful in its changes. I had + become so healthy through my abstinence, temperance and long + walks that our meeting was a new revelation to me of how + delicate, fragrant and divine a convalescent woman may be. She + was glad and surprised to see me looking so well, and if she put + her hand on my arm I felt a joyous thrill. I was certainly a + better man for abstaining and she a better woman and I determined + not to have connection unless we were carried away by our love. + As a matter of fact we did not give way to excess, though we were + very loving. I tried to persuade myself that we had not gone back + to our old ways, but I could not do so long. + + Miss T. put in an appearance every day. She did not look so + innocent, but as it was no business of mine I did not trouble. + She seemed more attached to A. than ever.... A. was still very + loving with me, but it was an effort to me to keep up to her + pitch, and when A. proposed to go to Melbourne with Miss T, to + sell off the furniture before settling in Adelaide, I was rather + glad of the opportunity of abstaining from coitus and of watching + myself to see if I again improved. When A. and Miss T. came to + see me before going down to the steamer, A. was nearly crying and + Miss T., changed from the old welcome friend, was not only pale + and anxious, but looked guilty as if she had some treachery in + her mind; she could not meet my eye. I thought less of it then + than afterwards. And once more I took long walks at night and + rose early to catch the freshness of the mornings. + + Some time before this I had read a book advocating a vegetarian + diet, and at this time I chanced to read Pater's beautiful "Denys + L'Auxerrois," the imaginary portrait of a young vine-dresser, who + was attractive beyond ordinary mortals and lived, until his fall + and deterioration, on fruit and water. The words, "a natural + simplicity in living" remained in my memory. I resolved to read + more carefully the book on scientific diet. Who can say, I + thought, what changes for the better may come to me if I live on + a strictly scientific and natural diet? + + I fasted one whole day, and then had a breakfast of cherries, in + the middle of the day a meal of fruit, and walking in the + afternoon--a gray, rainy day--I felt so light, so different, and + the gray sky looked so sweet and familiar, that I was reminded of + the luminous visions of my boyhood. It was a distinct revelation. + This Pan-like, almost Bacchic feeling, did not last, however, nor + was I always able to maintain my new method of diet, though I + tried to do so. I made the attempt, however, but I imagine I was + more than usually run down. I would walk miles in the hope of + feeling less restless. One holiday I walked down to Glenelg, + having only had grapes for my dinner, and lying on the beach I + looked through a strong binocular glass I had borrowed at the + girls bathing. And the beauty of their faces in their frames of + hair, of their arms, of their figures, seen through their wet + clinging dresses, satisfied me and filled me with joy, gave me + for a short time that peace and content--in harmony with the + strong sunlight on the waves and the rhythmic surf on the + shore--I was seeking. The summer evenings on the pier or along + the beach had a peculiar savor; one felt the youth and beauty + there even on dark nights, the air was fragrant with them, white + dresses and summer hats disappearing down the beach or over the + sand hills. It was easy--doubtless justifiable sometimes--to put + a lewd construction on these disappearances; but I felt it need + not have been so; that it was not necessary that youth and + beauty, even the sexual act itself if led up to by love, should + be a subject of giggling and sniggering. I always left the beach + and its flitting summer dresses with a sigh. + + A., after writing once, ceased writing at all and once more her + mother and I were left in a state of anxiety and suspense. At + last I determined to go to Melbourne to look for her, the only + clue I had being a remark in her letter that a certain actor was + giving her an engagement. In Melbourne I could not find any + traces of her for some days and what traces I did find of her + were not calculated to allay my anxious fears. One hotel-keeper + told me that some one of A's name had stayed there with another + hussy (giving Miss T's stage name): "There were nice carryings on + with the pair of them." I thought of Miss T's strange looks, but + could not imagine what hold she had on A., for A. loved me, I + knew. I seemed to be in an inextricable maze. I could settle to + nothing and was thinking of applying to the police when I heard + that the actor A. had mentioned had taken his company to the + Gippsland lakes. I followed to Sale, found the actor and was told + that A. was not there. "She slipped me at the last moment," he + said, "and remained in Melbourne." I returned to my lodgings, + with my anxiety and nervous restlessness increased tenfold. But + suddenly my fear and restlessness left me like a cloud. I felt + quiet, young, peaceful, able to enjoy the country, A. was + doubtless all right and would be able to explain her silence. I + undressed leisurely and happily, thinking of the stars. + + The next day, Sunday, I awoke refreshed and still at peace. After + breakfast, hearing children's voices, I went out into the garden + and there was a collision of souls who somehow were affinities. A + young girl about twelve or younger with a fine presence and + handsome face fixed her eyes on me for half a minute and then + came and sat on my knee. She was one of those children I am + accustomed to call "love-children," because they are so much + brighter, healthier, larger and more loving than others. I always + imagine more love went to their making. We fell in love and she + said, stroking my beard, "Oh, you are pretty!" and I said, "And + so are you!" We were so affectionate that the servant called the + child away and I went for a walk, finding my little sweetheart + waiting for me on my return. The touch of her hand was electric + and her voice fresh and musical. I kissed her, but had become + more self-conscious since the morning and wondered if her mother + or the servant were looking, or even of they would appear. I was + not so frank and natural as my little chum. I have often thought + of her since. She had the breadth of forehead, the strength and + yet lightness of limb, together with the hands and feet, not too + small, that I always imagine the dwellers in Paradise will have. + + I returned to Melbourne and continued trying to find A. At the + same time I commenced in earnest to live on fruit and brown bread + only, and enjoyed better tone and health every day, so that it + was a joy to walk down the street in the sun and exchange glances + with passengers à la old Walt. One day in the Botanical Gardens + veils seemed to be lifted off my eyes. I could look straight at + the sun and taking my note of color from that golden light I + turned my eyes on the flowers, the mown grass, the trees, and for + the first time perceived what a heavenly color green is, what + divine companions flowers are, and what a blue sky really means. + For half an hour I was in Paradise, and to complete my joy Nature + revealed to me a new and unexpected secret. + + I was lying on a bench, basking, and my silk shirt coming open + the strong sun made its way to my breast and presently I felt a + totally new sensation there. I had discovered the last joy of the + skin. My skin, fed by healthy fruit-made blood, must have + functioned normally under the excitation of the sun just then + (for a brief space only, alas!). I cannot describe the joy, any + more than I could describe the taste of a peach to one who has + only eaten apples: it was satisfying, divine. I opened my shirt + wider, but the feeling only spread faintly, and indeed this + halcyon sunny hour terminated in a restlessness that sent me + walking into town to look for A. + + At last I heard, not of A., but of Miss T. She was in a ballet. I + went round during rehearsal and while waiting entered into + conversation with a little chorus girl with a good face, who was + sewing. On my telling her whom I was seeking she stopped sewing + and looked at me quickly: "Oh, are you her husband? I know her. + _I have seen them together_." She looked as if she were going to + tell me something, but merely shook her old-fashioned head in a + mournful, indescribable way, saying "Why don't you keep your wife + with you?" I went to the door and presently saw Miss T. She tried + to avoid me, I thought, and looked more vicious than ever, but + after a minute's thought reluctantly told me where she and A. + were staying. To hide my fears and suspicions I had assumed a + careless demeanor, but I think I should have strangled her had + she refused to tell me. I hastily went to the place indicated and + going up the stairs (to the astonishment of the people) opened + the door and found myself face to face with A.--but how changed! + She had the hard, harlot, loveless look I detested. I felt for a + few minutes that I did not love her, and she regarded me coldly + too, but presently old habits reinstated themselves. She put out + her hands, very pitiably, and then was sobbing in my arms. I + could get nothing out of her but sobs, and to this day do not + know where she spent all these weeks nor why she did not write. + Miss T. came in after rehearsal, pale and hard-faced. I greeted + her politely, but was watching her, trying to puzzle out why A. + did not look as she usually did after long absence from coition. + Miss T. took another room in the same house and was soon joined + by another ballet girl, young and very pretty, who soon began to + have fits. A. was always crying until Miss T. went away with her + pretty friend. I knew nothing, could hardly be said to suspect + anything definite, and yet I pitied that pretty girl whose eyes + looked so helpless and appealing. + + I set to work again. But I continued to live on fruit and bread, + and taking off my clothes I would stand up at the window in the + sun. A lot of prostitutes, however, who lived at the back saw me + and were scandalized or shocked or thought me mad. The landlady + heard of it and spoke to A. So I had to desist from my glorious + sun-baths. + + We slept on a single bed, and though I did my best to avoid + coitus (I wanted to wait and think out some theory of it), A., + who knew nothing of this, wanted to resume our old habits, and + finally I surrendered. But my sufferings next day were intense, + and I had the sense of having fallen from some high estate. My + thoughts were divided between two theories: one that our misery + was caused by our diet, more or less; the other that we had + fallen into some error as regards coitus, and this was becoming + almost a certainty with me. + + There is one incident I think worthy of note which happened + before the "fall" just mentioned and when I was living on fruit + and in splendid health. At a performance I saw a girl on the + stage with handsome legs in tights, and once as she straightened + her leg the knee-cap going into position gave me such a strange + and keen joy--of that quality I call divine or musical--that I + was like one suddenly awakened to the divinity and beauty of the + female form. The joy was so keen and yet peaceful, familiar, and + subjective that I could not help comparing it to a happy chemical + change in the tissues of my own brain. Like the unexpected + functioning of my skin in the sun it was a sign of a partial + return to a normal condition, another glimpse of Paradise. + + I stuck to my new diet and gained a fresh elation and joy in + life. Gradually clothes became insupportable, and I went down to + the beach as often as possible to take them off, and at nights, + beside the patient and astonished A., I would lie naked. One + evening, passing some grass, I looked over the fence like a gipsy + and felt a longing to take off my clothes and sleep in the grass + all night. It was of course impossible. And A. looked unhappily + in my face; she began to think her mother, who now thought I was + mad, must be right. + + That night I woke up and found myself having coition. I was angry + and felt I had been put back in my progress, but a fever of lust + now came over me. I would sit under the tap and let the cold + water run over me to conquer the fever, but at the end of a week + my hopes were frustrated and I even turned against my natural + diet, on which I had made flesh. A., as I expected, went through + her usual fits, and slowly recovered. (If we had connection only + once she in about three weeks had a mild attack of fits; if we + had coition more than once the fits were more severe.) I relapsed + more than once and as a means of impressing my resolution for + future abstinence I would walk for miles in the middle of + pitch-black nights.... + + Miss T. came over to Adelaide and as I knew nothing definite + against her and heard that she was engaged, I thought perhaps my + suspicions were unfounded and was friendly. But one day in town I + saw her and A. on a tram going out to our cottage. Even then my + suspicions might not have been awakened, but I saw Miss T. say + something rapidly to A., and A. called out to me, "Will you be + coming home soon?" And I answered "No." When the tram had gone on + I found myself vaguely wondering what Miss T. wanted to know that + for, for my perceptions were becoming acute enough to understand + women's ways. In another minute I was walking rapidly home. When + I came to the door it was locked. I knocked and knocked and no + one came. I called out and threatened to kick in the door. Still + no one came. Mad with rage I commenced to put my threat into + execution, when the door was opened by Miss T., half-naked, in + her petticoats, and pale as death, but no longer defiant. "So + I've caught you, have I?" I _looked_, but could not trust myself + to speak. Wondering why A. did not appear I went into the + bedroom. She was lying on the bed, just as Miss T. had left her, + on the verge of a fit, and on seeing me she held out her hands + piteously, and when I stooped over her she whispered, "Send her + away, send her away." Then she became unconscious and going into + the next room I ordered Miss T. (who had managed to scramble on + her dress) out of the house. I spoke scornfully as if addressing + a dog, and she slinked out with a malignant but cowed look I hope + never to see on a woman's face again. What they had been doing + with their clothes off I do not know; women will rather die than + confess. When A. had recovered from her fit she denied that there + had been anything between them, and stuck to it doggedly, but + with such a forlorn look I had not the heart to prosecute my + inquiries. + + For my part, all the efforts I had been making for so long seemed + for a time to be in vain; for some weeks I sank into a sort of + satyriasis, and even my anger against Miss T. turned to a + prurient curiosity. At the same time I was not always able to + adhere to my diet. But both as regards coition and diet I was + still fighting, and on the whole successfully. My fits of temper, + however, were excessive and my ennui became gloomy despair. One + day I blasphemed on crossing the Park and spoke contemptuously of + "God and his twopenny ha'penny revolving balls," referring to the + planetary system. But for long walks I should have gone mad. A. + was drinking in the intervals of her fits. I found half-empty + bottles of wine hidden away. This did not improve my temper, and + one day--this was when she was well and up--I struck her a heavy + blow on the face, and she aimed a glass decanter at me. She went + home to her mother and I lived alone in the cottage. I heard soon + afterwards that her husband had come back and that they had made + it up. Our parting was not, however, destined to be final. + + Even out of that month's sufferings I made capital. I was better + after my tendency to lubricity, my gloom, rage, restlessness and + degradation. They had been but the irritations of convalescence. + + + +INDEX OF AUTHORS. + +Abrantès, duchesse d' +Adler +Albucasis +Alexander, H.C.B. +Amatus Lusitanus +Ammon +Andersen +Andriezen +Aquinas +Aristophanes +Aristotle +Averroes +Avicenna +Aubrey +Aulnoy, Madame d' + +Baer +Ball +Ballantyne, J.W. +Bancroft, H.H. +Barker, Fordyce +Barnes, R. +Bartholin +Bayle +Beale, G.B. +Bechterew +Beck, J.R. +Becker +Bell, Sir C. +Bell, Sanford +Belletrud +Beneden +Bergh +Bianchi +Biérent +Binet +Bischoff, T.L.W. +Bloch, J. +Blondel +Blumenbach +Blunt, J.J. +Boas +Boccaccio +Boeteau +Bois, J. +Bois-Reymond, E. du +Bölsche +Booth, D.S. +Booth, J. +Bouchereau +Bouchet +Bourke, J.G. +Boveri +Brand +Braun +Brantôme +Brehm +Breitenstein +Brénier de Montmorand +Brénot +Brouardel +Brown-Séquard +Brügelmann +Buckman, S.S. +Bucknill +Bunge +Burchard +Burdach +Burton, Robert +Buschan +Busdraghi + +Cabanis +Campbell, J.F. +Campbell, H. +Carpenter, E. +Casanova +Cascella +Castelnau +Catullus +Cecca +Celsus +Chapman, C.W. +Charcot +Chaucer +Chaulant +Chevalier +Chidley, W. +Cladel, J. +Clement, of Alexandria +Coe +Coen +Collineau +Colman, W.S. +Columbus, R. +Cook, G.W. +Crawley +Cumston +Cuvier +Cyples + +Dabney +Darwin, C. +Darwin, E. +Daumas +Dearborn, G. +Dembo +Deniker +Dessoir, Max +Dickinson, R.L. +Diderot +Disselhorst +Donaldson, H.H. +Douglas, C. +Drähms +Dühren, E. +Dufougère +Dufour +Dulaure +Duncan, Matthews + +East, A. +Edgar, Clifton +Ellis, Havelock +Engelmann +Erotion +Esbach +Eschricht +Espinas +Eulenburg +Evans +Ezekiel + +Fabricius +Fallopius +Féré +Fichstedt +Flood, E. +Florence +Fothergill, Milner +Frazer, J.G. +Freud +Freyer +Froriep +Fuchs +Fürbringer + +Galen +Gardiner, C.F. +Garnier +Gautier, A. +Gautier, T. +Gellhoen +Gerhard, A. +Giles, A. +Godin +Goethe +Goncourt, E. de +Gopcevic +Goron +Gould +Gow +Graaf, de +Griffiths +Groos, K. +Gualino +Guéniot +Guibaut +Guillereau +Guinard +Guttceit + +Hack +Haddon +Haig +Hall, G. Stanley +Haller +Hamilton, A. +Hammond +Hardy, Thomas +Hartland, E.S. +Harvey +Hegar +Henderson, J. +Henle +Hennig +Herman +Herodotus +Herrick +Heusinger +Hewitt, Graily +Hippocrates +Hirst +Hislop, J.T. +Hoche +Horrocks +Howard, W.L. +Howell +Howitt, A.W. +Hrdlicka +Hughes, C.H. +Hunter, John +Hunter, William +Huysmans +Hyades +Hyrtl + +Jacobi +Jacoby, P. +Jahn +Janet +Janke +Jastreboff +Jenkyns, J. +Johnston, G.A. +Johnston, Sir H.H. +Jonson, Ben +Juvenal + +Kaltenbach +Kelly, H. +Kepler +Kiernan, J.G. +Kisch +Kleinpaul +Kobelt +Kocher +Kohlbrugge +Kolbein +Krafft-Ebing +Krauss + +Lamb, D.S. +Landes, L. de +Lane +Lasègue +Laurent, E. +Lawrence, Sir W. +Laycock +Levi +Licetus +Liébault +Liétaud +Lipps +Litzmann +Lombroso +Lorion +Lortet +Lucas, J.C. +Lucretius +Lunier +Luschka +Lusini +Lydston + +Macdonald, A. +MacGillicuddy +McKay, A. +Mackay, W.J.S. +Mackenzie, J. +Magnan +Malebranche +Mantegazza +Marandon de Montyel +Marc +Marro +Marshall, H.R. +Martial +Martin, J.M.H. +Martineau +Maschka +Masterman +Matignon +Mattel +McMordie +Mercier +Meredith, Ellis +Middleton, T. +Mirabeau +Mitchell, Sir A. +Moll +Mongeri +Morache +Moraglia +Morris, R.T. +Morselli +Motet +Moulin, J. Mansell +Müller, J. +Mundé, P. + +Näcke +Neale, R. +Neri +Nicholson, H.O. +Nina Rodrigues + +Obici +Onanoff +Ottolenghi +Ovid + +Pacheco +Palfyn +Park, Mungo +Papillault +Pasini +Paterson, A.R. +Paulini +Paulus Æginetus +Pearse, W.H. +Pearson, Karl +Pechuel-Loesche +Pelanda +Pennant +Penta +Pfaff +Pierer +Pillon +Pinæus +Pinard +Pitre, C. +Pitres +Pittard +Plant +Plautus +Pliny +Ploss +Poehl +Polemon +Pollux +Porta, Della +Power +Pyle + +Raymond +Régis +Régnier, H. de +Reinach, S. +Renooz, Céline +Restif de la Bretonne +Retterer, E. +Reynolds, A.R. +Rhys, J. +Ribot +Riedel +Rimbaud +Riolan +Robinson, Bryan +Robinson, Louis +Rodin +Roederer +Roons, R.P. +Rosse, Irving +Roth, W. +Rothe +Roubaud +Rousseau +Routh, C.H.F. +Rufus +Russell, W. + +Sade, de +Salmon, W. +Scherzer +Schinz +Schmiedeberg +Schreiner +Schrenck-Notzing +Schurig +Scott, Colin +Scripture, E.W. +Seerley +Seligmann +Sellheim +Shakespeare +Shattock +Shufeldt +Silk, J.F.W. +Simon, H. +Simpson, Sir J. +Sims, Marion +Smith, Sir A. +Smith, Haywood +Sömmering +Soranus +Spigelius +Stahl, F.A. +Stanton +Stendhal +Stengel +Stern, B. +Stevens, Vaughan +Stieda +Stratz +Stubbs +Suidas +Sukhanoff +Sullivan, W.C. +Sutherland, W.D. +Sutton, Bland +Swift + +Tarde +Tardieu +Tarnier +Taxil +Theocritus +Thoinot +Thompson, W.L. +Thomson, J. +Tilt +Toff +Tourdes, G. +Tridandani +Trochon + +Vahness +Valentin +Varigny, H de +Variot, G. +Varro +Vaschide +Vatsyayana +Venette +Venturi +Vesalius +Vinay +Vinci, L. da +Voigt +Voisin, J. +Vurpas + +Wagner, R. +Waldeyer +Walker, G. +Wallace, A.W. +Warton +Wasserschleben +Weininger, O. +Wellhausen +Werner +Wernich +West, J.P. +Wharton +Wilhelm, Eugen +Wilkin, G. +Wilkinson, A.D. +Williams, J.W. Whitridge +Williamson, C.F. +Wolff, B. +Wollstonecraft, Mary +Wordsworth +Wychgel + +Youatt + +Zaborsky +Zoppi +Zimmer +Zola + + + + +INDEX OF SUBJECTS. + +Abyssinians, + coitus among +Acquired element in erotic symbolism +Acromegaly and sexual development +Alcohol, + aphrodisiac effects of +Algolagnia, + in relation to scatologic symbolism + as a form of erotic symbolism +Anæsthesia, + sexual +Anæsthetics in relation to sexual excitement +Anaphrodisiacs +Animal copulation, + attraction of +Animals, + detumescence in +Annamites, + coitus among +Antipathies of pregnant women +Anus in relation to pubic hair + as an erogenous zone +Apes, + sexual organs of + sexual congress in +Aphrodisiacs +Apples, + longings of women for +Arabs, + penis in +Artist, + compared to lover +Associations of contiguity and resemblance in erotic symbolism +Australian method of sexual congress +Auto-suggestions, + longings of pregnancy as + +Bartholin, + glands of +Beard in relation to sexual development +Beauty, + the objective element in +Bestiality +Bladder in relation to sexual excitement +Blood during pregnancy +Blood-pressure during detumescence +Breasts, + and erotic temperament + during pregnancy +Bromide as an anaphrodisiac +Bulbo-cavernous reflex + +Camphor as an anaphrodisiac +Cantharides, + effects of +Castration, + results of +Celery as an aphrodisiac +Children, + attracted to foot + to scatology + to copulation of animals + to hair + food impulses of +Chinese, + foot-fetichism of +Circulatory conditions during coitus + during pregnancy +Clitoris +Clothes, + erotic fascination of +Coitus, + the phenomena of + the methods of + ethnic variations in methods of + respiratory and circulatory conditions during + interruptus as a cause of vasomotor disturbance + glandular activity during + motor activity during + psychic state during + serious effects of +Congenital element in erotic symbolism +Contiguity in erotic symbolism, + associations of +Coprolagnia +Coprophagia, + religious and sexual +Courtship +Crystallization, + Stendhal's + +Defile, + the impulse to +Distillatio +Dog, + human sexual intercourse with +Dynamometric experiments during sexual excitement + +Ejaculation, the mechanism of +Embryo +Epilepsy and exhibitionism + compared to coitus + as a result of coitus +Erectility during coitus +Erogenous zone, + anus as + lips as +Erotic intoxication +Erotic temperament +Eryngo as an aphrodisiac +Ethnic variations in coitus +Etruscans, + sexual significance of foot among +Eunuchs, + characteristics of +Exercise on sexual organs, + influence of +Exhibitionism +Eyes during detumescence + in relation to erotic temperament + darker at puberty + +Face during detumescence, + expression of +Fæces as a drug +Fecundation, + the phenomena of + artificial +Feet as a sexual symbol, + uncovering +Fellatio +Fetichism, + erotic +Flagellation +Foot-fetichism, + _see_ Shoe-fetichism. +Fuegians, + penis in +Fur as a fetich + +Garments as fetiches +Genital organs as fetiches +Goat as a human sexual fetich +Greeks, + sexual significance of foot among + +Hair as a fetich + despoilers of + pubic + darkens at puberty + in relation to erotic temperament + in pregnancy +Hand as fetich +Heart during pregnancy +Homosexuality as a form of erotic symbolism +Hottentot apron +Hymen +Hyperæsthesia, sexual +Hypertrichosis universalis +Hysteria + +Ideal coprolagnia +Idiocy as result of maternal impressions +Idiots, + sexual development of +Impregnation without rupture of hymen + without conjunctions + artificial +Impressions, + maternal +Intellectual work, + relation of pregnancy to +Intoxication, + erotic + +Japanese, + labia majora in +Joy, + the expression of + +Kiss, the +Kleptomania and pregnancy +Knee-jerk in pregnancy + +Labia majora +Labia minora +Larynx in relation to sexual state +Linea fusca +Lips, + as an erogenous zone + in relation to erotic temperament +Longings of pregnancy + theories of + as auto-suggestions + physiological basis of + relation to the longings of childhood + +Masochism, + in relation to shoe-fetichism + in relation to scatalogic symbolism + in relation to exhibitionism of nates + as a form of erotic symbolism +Masturbation and pubic hair + hypertrophy of clitoris ascribed to + part played by clitoris in + why some theologians permitted + phenomena during +Maternal element in sexual love +Maternal impressions +Menstruation in relation to coitus + metabolism during + in relation to sickness of pregnancy + compared to pregnancy +Mental state during pregnancy +Metabolism during pregnancy +Mixoscopic zoophilia +Modesty a supposed sign of virginity +Mohammedan method of sexual congress +Mole as a fetich +Mongol peoples, + foot fetichism among various +Mons veneris +Mordvins, + foot-fetichism among +Motor activity during coitus +Mouth in relation to erotic temperament +Muscular movements during coitus + +Nates in relation to coprolagnia + in relation to exhibitionism + in relation to erotic temperament +Necrophilia +Negative fetich +Negro, + penis in + labia majora in + clitoris in + labia minora in + method of sexual congress among +Nervous system during pregnancy +Neurasthenia cordis vasomotoria +Nipples, + pigmentation of +Nudity, + religious +Nutrition, + symbolism of +Nymphæ +Nymphomania + +Obsessions of scruple + longings of pregnancy as +Obsessional exhibitionism +Odor an alleged sign of defloration +Onion as an aphrodisiac +Opium as an aphrodisiac +Organs, + sexual +Ova and spermatozoa, + union of +Ovarian extract, effects of +Ovaries, + function of + analogy of with thyroid + +Paidophilia +Pain and erotic symbolism +Pedicatio +Pelvic development and erotic temperament +Pelvic floor, variability of +Pelvic inclination +Penis +Penis-fetichism +Phallic worship +Physiognomists and the erotic temperament +Pica +Pigmentation in relation to erotic temperament + in pregnancy +Potatoes, + the supposed aphrodisiac effects of +Precocity, + influence of +Pregnancy and pigmentation + psychic state in + sexual desire during + relation of to intellectual work +Presbyophilia +Prostate +Prostitutes, + external genitals of + stature of +Psychic exhibitionism +Psychic condition during coitus +Puberty, + the phenomena of + pigmentary changes at +Pubic hair +Puericulture +Pygmalionism + +Quadrupedal method of coitus in man + +Rachitic, + sexual tendencies of the +Reflex, bulbo-cavernous +Reflexes during pregnancy +Religious scatalogic symbolism +Resemblance in erotic symbolism, + associations of +Respiration during coitus +Responsibility of pregnant women +Restif de la Bretonne's shoe-fetichism +Romans, + sexual significance of foot among + methods of coitus among +Rousseau +Rue as an anaphrodisiac + +Sadism +Saint compared to lover +Salivation during coitus +Satyriasis +Scatalogic symbolism +Scrotum +Scruple, obsessions of +Secretions of genital canal +Semen, + alleged female + in coitus + in female genital canal + vital activity of + artificial injection of + constituents of + as a stimulant +Sexual anæsthesia +Sexual conjugation +Sexual desire during pregnancy +Sexual organs +Sexual selection in relation to erotic symbolism + in relation to external sexual organs + the probable cause of the hymen +Shadow as a fetich +Shoe, + sexual significance of +Shoe-fetichism frequency of + normal basis of + illustrated by Restif de la Bretonne + prevalence of among Chinese, etc. + former prevalence in Europe + congenital basis of + acquired element in + favored by precocity + relation to masochism + illustrative cases of + dynamic element in +Sickness of pregnancy +Skin, + sexual significance of + condition of during coitus + in relation to erotic temperament + sexual pigmentation of +Slipper as a sexual symbol +Smile, + origin of the +Sodomy, + the term +Spain, + sexual attractiveness of foot in +Spermatozoa reach ova, + how the +Spermin +Sphygmanometer experiments during sexual excitement +Stature and erotic temperament +Stimulants +Stuff-fetichisms +Strychnine, + aphrodisiac effects of +Suggestion in relation to longings of pregnancy +Symbols, + nature of + of sex in language + +Temperament, + alleged erotic +Testicular juices, + effects of +Testes +Thyroid, + condition during sexual excitement + during pregnancy +Ticklishness in relation to stuff-fetichisms +Tumescence in relation to detumescence + +Unnatural offence, + the term +Urethra, + variability of female + an erogenous zone +Urethrorrhoea ex libidine +Urinary stream, + in relation to nymphæ + an alleged index to virginity +Urine in religious rites + possesses magical virtues + in legends + in medicine + during coitus +Urolagnia +Uterus + +Vagina +Vaginismus +Vasomotor conditions during coitus +Vaudonism +Virginity, + ancient diagnosis of +Virile reflex +Voice, + in relation to erotic temperament + in relation to virginity +Vomiting of pregnancy +Vulva +Vulva-fetichism + +Waist, + origin of admiration for small + +Yohimbin as an aphrodisiac + +Zooerastia +Zoophilia erotica +Zoophilia non-erotic + + + +***END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK STUDIES IN THE PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX, +VOLUME 5 (OF 6)*** + + +******* This file should be named 13614-8.txt or 13614-8.zip ******* + + +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: +https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/1/3/6/1/13614 + + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +https://gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS', WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, is critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at https://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/pglaf. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at https://www.gutenberg.org/about/contact + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit https://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/donate + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including including checks, online payments and credit card +donations. To donate, please visit: +https://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + https://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. + diff --git a/old/13614-8.zip b/old/13614-8.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..63222e9 --- /dev/null +++ b/old/13614-8.zip diff --git a/old/13614-h.zip b/old/13614-h.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..13d03f4 --- /dev/null +++ b/old/13614-h.zip diff --git a/old/13614-h/13614-h.htm b/old/13614-h/13614-h.htm new file mode 100644 index 0000000..960febb --- /dev/null +++ b/old/13614-h/13614-h.htm @@ -0,0 +1,13703 @@ +<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01 Transitional//EN"> +<html> +<head> +<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=ISO-8859-1"> +<title>The Project Gutenberg eBook of Studies in the Psychology of Sex, Volume 5 (of 6), by Havelock Ellis</title> + <style type="text/css"> +/*<![CDATA[ XML blockout */ +<!-- + P { margin-top: .75em; + text-align: justify; + margin-bottom: .75em; + } + H1,H2,H3,H4,H5,H6 { + text-align: center; /* all headings centered */ + } + hr {text-align: center; width: 50%;} + html>body hr {margin-right: 25%; margin-left: 25%; width: 50%;} + hr.full {width: 100%;} + html>body hr.full {margin-right: 0%; margin-left: 0%; width: 100%;} + hr.short {text-align: center; width: 20%;} + html>body hr.short {margin-right: 40%; margin-left: 40%; width: 20%;} + + BODY{margin-left: 10%; + margin-right: 10%; + } + img {border: none;} + .ctr {text-align: center;} + .linenum {position: absolute; top: auto; left: 4%;} /* poetry number */ + .note {margin-left: 2em; margin-right: 2em; margin-bottom: 1em;} /* footnote */ + .blkquot {margin-left: 4em; margin-right: 4em;} /* block indent */ + .pagenum {position: absolute; left: 92%; font-size: smaller; text-align: right;} /* page numbers */ + .sidenote {width: 20%; margin-bottom: 1em; margin-top: 1em; padding-left: 1em; font-size: smaller; float: right; clear: right;} + + .poem {margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align: left;} + .poem br {display: none;} + .poem .stanza {margin: 1em 0em 1em 0em;} + .poem span {display: block; margin: 0; padding-left: 3em; text-indent: -3em;} + .poem span.i2 {display: block; margin-left: 2em;} + .poem span.i4 {display: block; margin-left: 4em;} + .poem span.i1 {display: block; margin-left: 1em;} + .poem .caesura {vertical-align: -200%;} + hr.pg { width: 100%; + height: 5px; } + a:link {color:#0000ff; + text-decoration:none} + link {color:#0000ff; + text-decoration:none} + a:visited {color:#0000ff; + text-decoration:none} + a:hover {color:#ff0000} + pre {font-size: 8pt;} + // --> + /* XML end ]]>*/ + </style> +</head> +<body> +<h1>The Project Gutenberg eBook, Studies in the Psychology of Sex, Volume 5 +(of 6), by Havelock Ellis</h1> +<pre> +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at <a href = "https://www.gutenberg.org">www.gutenberg.org</a></pre> +<p>Title: Studies in the Psychology of Sex, Volume 5 (of 6)</p> +<p>Author: Havelock Ellis</p> +<p>Release Date: October 8, 2004 [eBook #13614]</p> +<p>Language: English</p> +<p>Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1</p> +<p>***START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK STUDIES IN THE PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX, VOLUME 5 (OF 6)***</p> +<br><br><h3>E-text prepared by Juliet Sutherland<br> + and the Project Gutenberg Online Distributed Proofreading Team<br> + (https://www.pgdp.net)</h3><br><br> +<hr class="pg" noshade> +<br> +<br> +<br> +<a name='5_Page_iii'></a> + +<h1>STUDIES<br /> +<br /> +IN THE<br /> +<br /> +PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX</h1> +<br /> +<h2>VOLUME V</h2> +<br /> +<h3>EROTIC SYMBOLISM<br /> +THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE<br /> +THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY</h3><br /> +<br /> +<h3>BY</h3> +<br /> +<h2>HAVELOCK ELLIS</h2> +<br /> +<h5>1927</h5><br /> +<hr class="full" /> +<br> +<a name='5_PREFACE'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_v'></a>PREFACE.</h2> +<br /> + +<p>In this volume the terminal phenomena of the sexual process are discussed, +before an attempt is finally made, in the concluding volume, to consider +the bearings of the psychology of sex on that part of morals which may be +called "social hygiene."</p> + +<p>Under "Erotic Symbolism" I include practically all the aberrations of the +sexual instinct, although some of these have seemed of sufficient +importance for separate discussion in previous volumes. It is highly +probable that many readers will consider that the name scarcely suffices +to cover manifestations so numerous and so varied. The term "sexual +equivalents" will seem preferable to some. While, however, it may be fully +admitted that these perversions are "sexual equivalents"—or at all events +equivalents of the normal sexual impulse—that term is merely a +descriptive label which tells us nothing of the phenomena. "Sexual +Symbolism" gives us the key to the process, the key that makes all these +perversions intelligible. In all of them—very clearly in some, as in +shoe-fetichism; more obscurely in others, as in exhibitionism—it has come +about by causes congenital, acquired, or both, that some object or class +of objects, some act or group of acts, has acquired a dynamic power over +the psycho-physical mechanism of the sexual process, deflecting it from +its normal adjustment to the whole of a beloved person of the opposite +sex. There has been a transmutation of values, and certain objects, +certain acts, have acquired an emotional value which for the normal person +they do not possess. Such objects and acts are properly, it seems to me, +termed symbols, and that term embodies the only justification that in most +cases these manifestations can legitimately claim.</p> + +<p>"The Mechanism of Detumescence" brings us at last to the final climax for +which the earlier and more prolonged stage <a name='5_Page_vi'></a>of tumescence, which has +occupied us so often in these <i>Studies</i>, is the elaborate preliminary. +"The art of love," a clever woman novelist has written, "is the art of +preparation." That "preparation" is, on the physiological side, the +production of tumescence, and all courtship is concerned in building up +tumescence. But the final conjugation of two individuals in an explosion +of detumescence, thus slowly brought about, though it is largely an +involuntary act, is still not without its psychological implications and +consequences; and it is therefore a matter for regret that so little is +yet known about it. The one physiological act in which two individuals are +lifted out of all ends that center in self and become the instrument of +those higher forces which fashion the species, can never be an act to be +slurred over as trivial or unworthy of study.</p> + +<p>In the brief study of "The Psychic State in Pregnancy" we at last touch +the point at which the whole complex process of sex reaches its goal. A +woman with a child in her womb is the everlasting miracle which all the +romance of love, all the cunning devices of tumescence and detumescence, +have been invented to make manifest. The psychic state of the woman who +thus occupies the supreme position which life has to offer cannot fail to +be of exceeding interest from many points of view, and not least because +the maternal instinct is one of the elements even of love between the +sexes. But the psychology of pregnancy is full of involved problems, and +here again, as so often in the wide field we have traversed, we stand at +the threshold of a door it is not yet given us to pass.</p> + +<p>HAVELOCK ELLIS.</p> + +<p>Carbis Water, Lelant, Cornwall.</p> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_CONTENTS'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_vii'></a>CONTENTS.</h2> +<h4><a href='#5_PREFACE'>PREFACE.</a></h4> +<br /> +<h4><a href='#5_EROTIC_SYMBOLISM'>EROTIC SYMBOLISM.</a></h4> +<h5><a href='#5_E_I'>I.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Definition of Erotic Symbolism. Symbolism of Act and Symbolism of +Object. Erotic Fetichism. Wide Extension of the Symbols of Sex. The +Immense Variety of Possible Erotic Fetiches. The Normal Foundations of +Erotic Symbolism. Classification of the Phenomena. The Tendency to +Idealize the Defects of a Beloved Person. Stendhal's "Crystallization"</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_E_II'>II.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>Foot-fetichism and Shoe-fetichism. Wide Prevalence and Normal Basis. +Restif de la Bretonne. The Foot a Normal Focus of Sexual Attraction Among +Some Peoples. The Chinese, Greeks, Romans, Spaniards, etc. The Congenital +Predisposition in Erotic Symbolism. The Influence of Early Association and +Emotional Shock. Shoe-fetichism in Relation to Masochism. The Two +Phenomena Independent Though Allied. The Desire to be Trodden On. The +Fascination of Physical Constraint. The Symbolism of Self-inflicted Pain. +The Dynamic Element in Erotic Symbolism. The Symbolism of Garments.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_E_III'>III.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>Scatalogic Symbolism. Urolagnia. Coprolagnia. The Ascetic Attitude Towards +the Flesh. Normal Basis of Scatalogic Symbolism. Scatalogic Conceptions +Among Primitive Peoples. Urine as a Primitive Holy Water. Sacredness of +Animal Excreta. Scatalogy in Folk-lore. The Obscene as Derived from the +Mythological. The Immature Sexual Impulse Tends to Manifest Itself in +Scatalogic Forms. The Basis of Physiological Connection Between the +Urinary and Genital Spheres. Urinary Fetichism Sometimes Normal in +Animals. The Urolagnia of Masochists. The Scatalogy of Saints. Urolagnia +More Often a Symbolism of Act Than a Symbolism of Object. Only +Occasionally an Olfactory Fetichism. Comparative Rarity of Coprolagnia. +Influence of Nates Fetichism as a Transition to Coprolagnia, Ideal +Coprolagnia.<a name='5_Page_viii'></a> Olfactory Coprolagnia. Urolagnia and Coprolagnia as Symbols +of Coitus.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_E_IV'>IV.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>Animals as Sources of Erotic Symbolism. Mixoscopic Zoophilia. The +Stuff-fetichisms. Hair-fetichism. The Stuff-fetichisms Mainly on a Tactile +Base. Erotic Zoophilia. Zooerastia. Bestiality. The Conditions that Favor +Bestiality. Its Wide Prevalence Among Primitive Peoples and Among +Peasants. The Primitive Conception of Animals. The Goat. The Influence of +Familiarity With Animals. Congress Between Women and Animals. The Social +Reaction Against Bestiality.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_E_V'>V.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>Exhibitionism. Illustrative Cases. A Symbolic Perversion of Courtship. The +Impulse to Defile. The Exhibitionist's Psychic Attitude. The Sexual Organs +as Fetiches. Phallus Worship. Adolescent Pride in Sexual Development. +Exhibitionism of the Nates. The Classification of the Forms of +Exhibitionism. Nature of the Relationship of Exhibitionism to Epilepsy.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_E_VI'>VI.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Forms of Erotic Symbolism are Simulacra of Coitus. Wide Extension of +Erotic Symbolism. Fetichism Not Covering the Whole Ground of Sexual +Selection. It is Based on the Individual Factor in Selection. +Crystallization. The Lover and the Artist. The Key to Erotic Symbolism is +to be Found in the Emotional Sphere. The Passage to Pathological Extremes.</p></div> +<br /> +<h4><a href='#5_THE_MECHANISM_OF_DETUMESCENCE'>THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE.</a></h4> +<h5><a href='#5_M_I'>I.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Psychological Significance of Detumescence. The Testis and the Ovary. +Sperm Cell and Germ Cell. Development of the Embryo. The External Sexual +Organs. Their Wide Range of Variation. Their Nervous Supply. The Penis. +Its Racial Variations. The Influence of Exercise. The Scrotum and +Testicles. The Mons Veneris. The Vulva. The Labia Majora and their +Varieties. The Public Hair and Its Characters. The Clitoris and Its +Functions. The Anus as an Erogenous Zone. The Nymphæ and their Function. +The Vagina. The Hymen. Virginity. The Biological Significance of the +Hymen.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_M_II'>II</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Object of Detumescence. Erogenous Zones. The Lips. The Vascular +Characters of Detumescence. Erectile Tissue. Erection in Woman. Mucous +Emission in Women. Sexual Connection. The Human Mode of Intercourse. +Normal Variations. The Motor Characters of Detumescence. Ejaculation. The +Virile Reflex. The General Phenomena of Detumescence. The Circulatory and +Respiratory Phenomena. Blood Pressure. Cardiac Disturbance. Glandular +Activity. Distillatio. The Essentially Motor Character of Detumescence. +Involuntary Muscular Irradiation to Bladder, etc. Erotic Intoxication. +Analogy of Sexual Detumescence and Vesical Tension. The Specifically +Sexual Movements of Detumescence in Man. In Woman. The Spontaneous +Movements of the Genital Canal in Woman. Their Function in Conception. +Part Played by Active Movement of the Spermatozoa. The Artificial +Injection of Semen. The Facial Expression During Detumescence. The +Expression of Joy. The Occasional Serious Effects of Coitus.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_M_III'>III.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Constituents of Semen. Function of the Prostate. The Properties of +Semen. Aphrodisiacs. Alcohol, Opium, etc. Anaphrodisiacs. The Stimulant +Influence of Semen in Coitus. The Internal Effects of Testicular +Secretions. The Influence of Ovarian Secretion.</p></div> +<h5><a href='#5_M_IV'>IV.</a></h5> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Aptitude for Detumescence. Is There an Erotic Temperament? The +Available Standards of Comparison. Characteristics of the Castrated. +Characteristics of Puberty. Characteristics of the State of Detumescence. +Shortness of Stature. Development of the Secondary Sexual Characters. Deep +Voice. Bright Eyes. Glandular Activity. Everted Lips. Pigmentation. +Profuse Hair. Dubious Significance of Many of These Characters.</p></div> + +<br /> + +<h4><a href='#5_THE_PSYCHIC_STATE_IN_PREGNANCY'>THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY.</a></h4> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Relationship of Maternal and Sexual Emotion. Conception and Loss of +Virginity. The Anciently Accepted Signs of This Condition. The Pervading +Effects of Pregnancy on the Organism. Pigmentation. The Blood and +Circulation. The Thyroid. Changes in the Nervous System. The Vomiting of +Pregnancy.<a name='5_Page_x'></a> The Longings of Pregnant Women. Mental Impressions. Evidence +for and Against Their Validity. The Question Still Open. Imperfection of +Our Knowledge. The Significance of Pregnancy.</p></div> +<br /> + +<h4><a href='#5_APPENDIX'>APPENDIX.</a></h4> +<center>Histories of Sexual Development.</center> +<br /> +<h4><a href='#5_INDEX_OF_AUTHORS'>INDEX OF AUTHORS.</a></h4> +<h4><a href='#5_INDEX_OF_SUBJECTS'>INDEX OF SUBJECTS.</a></h4> + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_EROTIC_SYMBOLISM'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_1'></a>EROTIC SYMBOLISM.</h2> + +<a name='5_E_I'></a><h3>I.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Definition of Erotic Symbolism—Symbolism of Act and Symbolism of +Object—Erotic Fetichism—Wide extension of the symbols of Sex—The +Immense Variety of Possible Erotic Fetiches—The Normal Foundations of +Erotic Symbolism—Classification of the Phenomena—The Tendency to +Idealize the Defects of a Beloved Person—Stendhal's "Crystallization."</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>By "erotic symbolism" I mean that tendency whereby the lover's attention +is diverted from the central focus of sexual attraction to some object or +process which is on the periphery of that focus, or is even outside of it +altogether, though recalling it by association of contiguity or of +similarity. It thus happens that tumescence, or even in extreme cases +detumescence, may be provoked by the contemplation of acts or objects +which are away from the end of sexual conjugation.<a name='5_FNanchor_1'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_1'><sup>[1]</sup></a></p> + +<p>In considering the phenomena of sexual selection in a previous volume,<a name='5_FNanchor_2'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_2'><sup>[2]</sup></a> +it was found that there are four or five main factors in the constitution +of beauty in so far as beauty determines sexual selection. Erotic +symbolism is founded on the factor of individual taste in beauty; it +arises as a specialized development of that factor, but it is, +nevertheless, incorrect to merge it in sexual selection. The attractive +characteristics of a beloved woman or man, from the point of view of +sexual selection, are a complex but harmonious whole leading up to a +desire for the complete possession of the person who displays them.<a name='5_Page_2'></a> There +is no tendency to isolate and dissociate any single character from the +individual and to concentrate attention upon that character at the expense +of the attention bestowed upon the individual generally. As soon as such a +tendency begins to show itself, even though only in a slight or temporary +form, we may say that there is erotic symbolism.</p> + +<p>Erotic symbolism is, however, by no means confined to the individualizing +tendency to concentrate amorous attention upon some single characteristic +of the adult woman or man who is normally the object of sexual love. The +adult human being may not be concerned at all, the attractive object or +act may not even be human, not even animal, and we may still be concerned +with a symbol which has parasitically rooted itself on the fruitful site +of sexual emotion and absorbed to itself the energy which normally goes +into the channels of healthy human love having for its final end the +procreation of the species. Thus understood in its widest sense, it may be +said that every sexual perversion, even homosexuality, is a form of erotic +symbolism, for we shall find that in every case some object or act that +for the normal human being has little or no erotic value, has assumed such +value in a supreme degree; that is to say, it has become a symbol of the +normal object of love. Certain perversions are, however, of such great +importance on account of their wide relationships, that they cannot be +adequately discussed merely as forms of erotic symbolism. This is notably +the case as regards homosexuality, auto-erotism, and algolagnia, all of +which phenomena have therefore been separately discussed in previous +studies. We are now mainly concerned with manifestations which are more +narrowly and exclusively symbolical.</p> + +<p>A portion of the field of erotic symbolism is covered by what Binet +(followed by Lombroso, Krafft-Ebing, and others) has termed "erotic +fetichism," or the tendency whereby sexual attraction is unduly exerted by +some special part or peculiarity of the body, or by some inanimate object +which has become associated with it. Such erotic symbolism of object +cannot, however, be dissociated from the even more important erotic +symbolism <a name='5_Page_3'></a>of process, and the two are so closely bound together that we +cannot attain a truly scientific view of them until we regard them broadly +as related parts of a common psychic tendency. If, as Groos asserts,<a name='5_FNanchor_3'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_3'><sup>[3]</sup></a> a +symbol has two chief meanings, one in which it indicates a physical +process which stands for a psychic process, and another in which it +indicates a part which represents the whole, erotic symbolism of act +corresponds to the first of these chief meanings, and erotic symbolism of +object to the other.</p> + +<p>Although it is not impossible to find some germs of erotic symbolism in +animals, in its more pronounced manifestations it is only found in the +human species. It could not be otherwise, for such symbolism involves not +only the play of fancy and imagination, the idealizing aptitude, but also +a certain amount of power of concentrating the attention on a point +outside the natural path of instinct and the ability to form new mental +constructions around that point. There are, indeed, as we shall see, +elementary forms of erotic symbolism which are not uncommonly associated +with feeble-mindedness, but even these are still peculiarly human, and in +its less crude manifestations erotic symbolism easily lends itself to +every degree of human refinement and intelligence.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>"It depends primarily upon an increase of the psychological + process of representation," Colin Scott remarks of sexual + symbolism generally, "involving greater powers of comparison and + analysis as compared with the lower animals. The outer + impressions come to be clearly distinguished as such, but at the + same time are often treated as symbols of inner experiences, and + a meaning read into them which they would not otherwise possess. + Symbolism or fetichism is, indeed, just the capacity to see + meaning, to emphasize something for the sake of other things + which do not appear. In brain terms it indicates an activity of + the higher centers, a sort of side-tracking or long-circuiting of + the primitive energy; ... Rosetti's poem, 'The Woodspurge,'<a name='5_Page_4'></a> + gives a concrete example of the formation of such a symbol. Here + the otherwise insignificant presentation of the three-cupped + woodspurge, representing originally a mere side-current of the + stream of consciousness, becomes the intellectual symbol or + fetich of the whole psychosis forever after. It seems, indeed, as + if the stronger the emotion the more likely will become the + formation of an overlying symbolism, which serves to focus and + stand in the place of something greater than itself; nowhere at + least is symbolism a more characteristic feature than as an + expression of the sexual instinct. The passion of sex, with its + immense hereditary background, in early man became centered often + upon the most trivial and unimportant features.... This + symbolism, now become fetichistic, or symbolic in a bad sense, is + at least an exercise of the increasing representative power of + man, upon which so much of his advancement has depended, while it + also served to express and help to purify his most perennial + emotion." (Colin Scott, "Sex and Art," <i>American Journal of + Psychology</i>, vol. vii, No. 2, p. 189.)</p></div> + +<p>In the study of "Love and Pain" in a previous volume, the analysis of the +large and complex mass of sexual phenomena which are associated with pain, +gradually resolved them to a considerable extent into a special case of +erotic symbolism; pain or restraint, whether inflicted on or by the loved +person, becomes, by a psychic process that is usually unconscious, the +symbol of the sexual mechanism, and hence arouses the same emotions as +that mechanism normally arouses. We may now attempt to deal more broadly +and comprehensively with the normal and abnormal aspects of erotic +symbolism in some of their most typical and least mixed forms.</p> + +<p>"When our human imagination seeks to animate artificial things," Huysmans +writes in <i>Là-bas</i>, "it is compelled to reproduce the movements of animals +in the act of propagation. Look at machines, at the play of pistons in the +cylinders; they are Romeos of steel in Juliets of cast-iron." And not only +in the work of man's hands but throughout Nature we find sexual symbols +which are the less deniable since, for the most part, they make not the +slightest appeal to even the most morbid human imagination. Language is +full of metaphorical symbols of sex which constantly tend to lose their +poetic symbolism and to become commonplace. Semen is but seed, and for the +Latins especially the whole process of human sex, as well as the male <a name='5_Page_5'></a>and +female organs, constantly presented itself in symbols derived from +agricultural and horticultural life. The testicles were beans (<i>fabæ</i>) and +fruit or apples (<i>poma</i> and <i>mala</i>); the penis was a tree (<i>arbor</i>), or a +stalk (<i>thyrsus</i>), or a root (<i>radix</i>), or a sickle (<i>falx</i>), or a +ploughshare (<i>vomer</i>). The semen, again, was dew (<i>ros</i>). The labia majora +or minora were wings (<i>alæ</i>); the vulva and vagina were a field (<i>ager</i> +and <i>campus</i>), or a ploughed furrow (<i>sulcus</i>), or a vineyard (<i>vinea</i>), +or a fountain (<i>fons</i>), while the pudendal hair was herbage +(<i>plantaria</i>).<a name='5_FNanchor_4'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_4'><sup>[4]</sup></a> In other languages it is not difficult to trace similar +and even identical imagery applied to sexual organs and sexual acts. Thus +it is noteworthy that Shakespeare more than once applies the term +"ploughed" to a woman who has had sexual intercourse. The Talmud calls the +labia minora the doors, the labia majora hinges, and the clitoris the key. +The Greeks appear not only to have found in the myrtle-berry, the fruit of +a plant sacred to Venus, the image of the clitoris, but also in the rose +an image of the feminine labia; in the poetic literature of many +countries, indeed, this imagery of the rose may be traced in a more or +less veiled manner.<a name='5_FNanchor_5'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_5'><sup>[5]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The widespread symbolism of sex arose in the theories and conceptions of +primitive peoples concerning the function of generation and its nearest +analogies in Nature; it was continued for the sake of the vigorous and +expressive terminology which it furnished both for daily life and for +literature; its final survivals were cultivated because they furnished a +delicately æsthetic method of approaching matters which a growing +refinement of sentiment made it difficult for lovers and poets to approach +in a more crude and direct manner. Its existence is of interest to us now +because it shows the objective validity of the basis on <a name='5_Page_6'></a>which erotic +symbolism, as we have here to understand it, develops. But from first to +last it is a distinct phenomenon, having a more or less reasoned and +intellectual basis, and it scarcely serves in any degree to feed the +sexual impulse. Erotic symbolism is not intellectual but emotional in its +origin; it starts into being, obscurely, with but a dim consciousness or +for the most part none at all, either suddenly from the shock of some +usually youthful experience, or more gradually through an instinctive +brooding on those things which are most intimately associated with a +sexually desirable person.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The kind of soil on which the germs of erotic symbolism may + develop is well seen in cases of sexual hyperæsthesia. In such + cases all the emotionally sexual analogies and resemblances, + which in erotic symbolism are fixed and organized, may be traced + in vague and passing forms, a single hyperæsthetic individual + perhaps presenting a great variety of germinal symbolisms.</p> + +<p> Thus it has been recorded of an Italian nun (whose sister became + a prostitute) that from the age of 8 she had desire for coitus, + from the age of 10 masturbated, and later had homosexual + feelings, that the same feelings and practices continued after + she had taken the veil, though from time to time they assumed + religious equivalents. The mere contact, indeed, of a priest's + hand, the news of the presentation of an ecclesiastic she had + known to a bishopric, the sight of an ape, the contemplation of + the crucified Christ, the figure of a toy, the picture of a + demon, the act of defecation in the children entrusted to her + care (whom, on this account, and against the regulations, she + would accompany to the closets), especially the sight and the + mere recollection of flies in sexual connection—all these things + sufficed to produce in her a powerful orgasm. (<i>Archivio di + Psichiatria</i>, 1902, fasc. II-III, p. 338.)</p> + +<p> A boy of 15 (given to masturbation), studied by Macdonald in + America, was similarly hyperæsthetic to the symbols of sexual + emotion. "I like amusing myself with my comrades," he told + Macdonald, "rolling ourselves into a ball, which gives one a + funny kind of warmth. I have a special pleasure in talking about + some things. It is the same when the governess kisses me on + saying good night or when I lean against her breast. I have that + sensation, too, when I see some of the pictures in the comic + papers, but only in those representing a woman, as when a young + man skating trips up a girl so that her clothes are raised a + little. When I read how a man saved a young girl from drowning, + so that they swam together, I had the same sensation. Looking at + the statues of women in the museum produces the same effect, or + when I <a name='5_Page_7'></a>see naked babies, or when a mother suckles a child. I + have often had that sensation when reading novels I ought not to + read, or when looking at a new-born calf, or seeing dogs and cows + and horses mounting on each other. When I see a girl flirting + with a boy, or leaning on his shoulder or with his arm round her + waist, I have an erection. It is the same when I see women and + little girls in bathing costume, or when boys talk of what their + fathers and mothers do together. In the Natural History Museum I + often see things which give me that sensation. One day when I + read how a man killed a young girl and carried her into a wood + and undressed her I had a feeling of enjoyment. When I read of + men who were bastards the idea of a woman having a child in that + way gives me this sensation. Some dances, and seeing young girls + astride a horse, excited me, too, and so in a circus when a woman + was shot out of a cannon and her skirts flew in the air. It has + no effect on me when I see men naked. Sometimes I enjoy seeing + women's underclothes in a shop, or when I see a lady or a girl + buying them, especially if they are drawers. When I saw a lady in + a dress which buttoned from top to bottom it had more effect on + me than seeing underclothes. Seeing dogs coupling gives me more + pleasure than looking at pretty women, but less than looking at + pretty little girls." In order of increasing intensity he placed + the phenomena that affected him thus: The coupling of flies, then + of horses, then the sight of women's undergarments, then a boy + and a girl flirting, then cows mounting on each other, the + statues of women with naked breasts, then contact with the + governess's body and breasts, finally coitus. (Arthur Macdonald, + <i>Le Criminel-Type</i>, pp. 126 <i>et seq.</i>)</p> + +<p> It is worthy of remark that the instinct of nutrition, when + restrained, may exhibit something of an analogous symbolism, + though in a minor degree, to that of sex. The ways in which a + hyperæsthetic hunger may seek its symbols are illustrated in the + case of a young woman called Nadia, who during several years was + carefully studied by Janet. It is a case of obsession ("maladie + du scrupule"), simulating hysterical anorexia, in which the + patient, for fear of getting fat, reduced her nourishment to the + smallest possible amount. "Nadia is generally hungry, even very + hungry. One can tell this by her actions; from time to time she + forgets herself to such an extent as to devour greedily anything + she can put her hands on. At other times, when she cannot resist + the desire to eat, she secretly takes a biscuit. She feels + horrible remorse for the action, but, all the same, she does it + again. Her confidences are very curious. She recognizes that a + great effort is needed to avoid eating, and considers she is a + heroine to resist so long. 'Sometimes I spent whole hours in + thinking about food, I was so hungry; I swallowed my saliva, I + bit my handkerchief, I rolled on the floor, I wanted to eat so + badly. I would look in books for descriptions of meals <a name='5_Page_8'></a>and + feasts, and tried to deceive my hunger by imagining that I was + sharing all these good things,'" (P. Janet, "La Maladie du + Scrupule," <i>Revue Philosophique</i>, May, 1901, p. 502.) The + deviations of the instinct of nutrition are, however, confined + within narrow limits, and, in the nature of things, hunger, + unlike sexual desire, cannot easily accept a fetich.</p></div> + +<p>"There is almost no feature, article of dress, attitude, act," Stanley +Hall declares, "or even animal or perhaps object in nature, that may not +have to some morbid soul specialized erogenic and erethic power."<a name='5_FNanchor_6'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_6'><sup>[6]</sup></a> Even +a mere shadow may become a fetich. Goron tells of a merchant in Paris—a +man with a reputation for ability, happily married and the father of a +family, altogether irreproachable in his private life—who was returning +home one evening after a game of billiards with a friend, when, on +chancing to raise his eyes, he saw against a lighted window the shadow of +a woman changing her chemise. He fell in love with that shadow and +returned to the spot every evening for many months to gaze at the window. +Yet—and herein lies the fetichism—he made no attempt to see the woman or +to find out who she was; the shadow sufficed; he had no need of the +realty.<a name='5_FNanchor_7'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_7'><sup>[7]</sup></a> It is even possible to have a negative fetich, the absence of +some character being alone demanded, and the case has been recorded in +Chicago of an American gentleman of average intelligence, education, and +good habits who, having as a boy cherished a pure affection for a girl +whose leg had been amputated, throughout life was relatively impotent with +normal women, but experienced passion and affection for women who had lost +a leg; he was found by his wife to be in extensive correspondence with +one-legged women all over the country, expending no little money on the +purchase of artificial legs for his various protegées.<a name='5_FNanchor_8'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_8'><sup>[8]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is important to remember, however, that while erotic symbolism becomes +fantastic and abnormal in its extreme manifestations, <a name='5_Page_9'></a>it is in its +essence absolutely normal. It is only in the very grossest forms of sexual +desire that it is altogether absent. Stendhal described the mental side of +the process of tumescence as a crystallization, a process whereby certain +features of the beloved person present points around which the emotions +held in solution in the lover's mind may concentrate and deposit +themselves in dazzling brilliance. This process inevitably tends to take +place around all those features and objects associated with the beloved +person which have most deeply impressed the lover's mind, and the more +sensitive and imaginative and emotional he is the more certainly will such +features and objects crystallize into erotic symbols. "Devotion and love," +wrote Mary Wollstonecraft, "may be allowed to hallow the garments as well +as the person, for the lover must want fancy who has not a sort of sacred +respect for the glove or slipper of his mistress. He would not confound +them with vulgar things of the same kind." And nearly two centuries +earlier Burton, who had gathered together so much of the ancient lore of +love, clearly asserted the entirely normal character of erotic symbolism. +"Not one of a thousand falls in love," he declares, "but there is some +peculiar part or other which pleaseth most, and inflames him above the +rest.... If he gets any remnant of hers, a busk-point, a feather of her +fan, a shoe-tie, a lace, a ring, a bracelet of hair, he wears it for a +favor on his arm, in his hat, finger, or next his heart; as Laodamia did +by Protesilaus, when he went to war, sit at home with his picture before +her: a garter or a bracelet of hers is more precious than any Saint's +Relique, he lays it up in his casket (O blessed Relique) and every day +will kiss it: if in her presence his eye is never off her, and drink he +will where she drank, if it be possible, in that very place," etc.<a name='5_FNanchor_9'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_9'><sup>[9]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Burton's accuracy in describing the ways of lovers in his century + is shown by a passage in Hamilton's <i>Mémoires de Gramont</i>. Miss + Price, one of the beauties of Charles II's court, and Dongan were + tenderly <a name='5_Page_10'></a>attached to each other; when the latter died he left + behind a casket full of all possible sorts of love-tokens + pertaining to his mistress, including, among other things, "all + kinds of hair." And as regards France, Burton's contemporary, + Howell, wrote in 1627 in his <i>Familiar Letters</i> concerning the + repulse of the English at Rhé: "A captain told me that when they + were rifling the dead bodies of the French gentlemen after the + first invasion they found that many of them had their mistresses' + favors tied about their genitories."</p> + +<p> Schurig (<i>Spermatologia</i>, p. 357) at the beginning of the + eighteenth century knew a Belgian lady who, when her dearly loved + husband died, secretly cut off his penis and treasured it as a + sacred relic in a silver casket. She eventually powdered it, he + adds, and found it an efficacious medicine for herself and + others. An earlier example, of a lady at the French court who + embalmed and perfumed the genital organs of her dead husband, + always preserving them in a gold casket, is mentioned by + Brantôme. Mantegazza knew a man who kept for many years on his + desk the skull of his dead mistress, making it his dearest + companion. "Some," he remarks, "have slept for months and years + with a book, a garment, a trifle. I once had a friend who would + spend long hours of joy and emotion kissing a thread of silk + which <i>she</i> had held between her fingers, now the only relic of + love." (Mantegazza, <i>Fisiologia dell' Amore</i>, cap. X.) In the + same way I knew a lady who in old age still treasured in her + desk, as the one relic of the only man she had ever been + attracted to, a fragment of paper he had casually twisted up in a + conversation with her half a century before.</p></div> + +<p>The tendency to treasure the relics of a beloved person, more especially +the garments, is the simplest and commonest foundation of erotic +symbolism. It is without doubt absolutely normal. It is inevitable that +those objects which have been in close contact with the beloved person's +body, and are intimately associated with that person in the lover's mind, +should possess a little of the same virtue, the same emotional potency. It +is a phenomenon closely analogous to that by which the relics of saints +are held to possess a singular virtue. But it becomes somewhat less normal +when the garment is regarded as essential even in the presence of the +beloved person.<a name='5_FNanchor_10'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_10'><sup>[10]</sup></a></p> + +<p>While an extremely large number of objects and acts may be found to +possess occasionally the value of erotic symbols, such <a name='5_Page_11'></a>symbols most +frequently fall into certain well-defined groups. A vast number of +isolated objects or acts may be exceptionally the focus of erotic +contemplation, but the objects and acts which frequently become thus +symbolic are comparatively few.</p> + +<p>It seems to me that the phenomena of erotic symbolism may be most +conveniently grouped in three great classes, on the basis of the objects +or acts which arouse them.</p> +<br /> +<p><b>I. PARTS OF THE BODY.—</b></p> + +<p><i>A. Normal:</i> Hand, foot, breasts, nates, hair, +secretions and excretions, etc.</p> + +<p><i>B. Abnormal:</i> Lameness, squinting, pitting of smallpox, etc. Paidophilia +or the love of children, presbyophilia or the love of the aged, and +necrophilia or the attraction for corpses, may be included under this +head, as well as the excitement caused by various animals.</p> +<br /> + +<p><b>II. INANIMATE OBJECTS.<a name='5_FNanchor_11'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_11'><sup>[11]</sup></a>—</b></p> + +<p><i>A. Garments:</i> Gloves, shoes and stockings and +garters, caps, aprons, handkerchiefs, underlinen.</p> + +<p><i>B. Impersonal Objects:</i> Here may be included all the various objects that +may accidentally acquire the power of exciting sexual feeling in +auto-erotism. Pygmalionism may also be included.</p> +<br /> + +<p><b>III. ACTS AND ATTITUDES.—</b></p> + +<p><i>A. Active:</i> Whipping, cruelty, exhibitionism.</p> + +<p><i>B. Passive:</i> Being whipped, experiencing cruelty. Personal odors and the +sound of the voice may be included under this head. </p> + +<p><i>C. Mixoscopic:</i> The +vision of climbing, swinging, etc. The acts of urination and defecation. +The coitus of animals.</p> + +<p>Although the three main groups into which the phenomena of erotic +symbolism are here divided may seem fairly distinct, they are yet very +closely allied, and indeed overlap, so that it <a name='5_Page_12'></a>is possible, as we shall +see, for a single complex symbol to fall into all three groups.</p> + +<p>A very complete kind of erotic symbolism is furnished by Pygmalionism or +the love of statues.<a name='5_FNanchor_12'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_12'><sup>[12]</sup></a> It is exactly analogous to the child's love of a +doll, which is also a form of sexual (though not erotic) symbolism. In a +somewhat less abnormal form, erotic symbolism probably shows itself in its +simplest shape in the tendency to idealize unbeautiful peculiarities in a +beloved person, so that such peculiarities are ever afterward almost or +quite essential in order to arouse sexual attraction. In this way men have +become attracted to limping women. Even the most normal man may idealize a +trifling defect in a beloved woman. The attention is inevitably +concentrated on any such slight deviation from regular beauty, and the +natural result of such concentration is that a complexus of associated +thoughts and emotions becomes attached to something that in itself is +unbeautiful. A defect becomes an admired focus of attention, the embodied +symbol of the lover's emotion.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Thus a mole is not in itself beautiful, but by the tendency to + erotic symbolism it becomes so. Persian poets especially have + lavished the richest imagery on moles (<i>Anis El-Ochchâq</i> in + <i>Bibliothèque des Hautes Etudes</i>, fasc, 25, 1875); the Arabs, as + Lane remarks (<i>Arabian Society in the Middle Ages</i>, p. 214), are + equally extravagant in their admiration of a mole.</p> + +<p> Stendhal long since well described the process by which a defect + becomes a sexual symbol. "Even little defects in a woman's face," + he remarked, "such as a smallpox pit, may arouse the tenderness + of a man who loves her, and throw him into deep reverie when he + sees them in another woman. It is because he has experienced a + thousand feelings in the presence of that smallpox mark, that + these feelings have been for the most part delicious, all of the + highest interest, and that, whatever they may have been, they are + renewed with incredible vivacity on the sight of this sign, even + when perceived on the face of another woman. If in such a case we + come to prefer and love <i>ugliness</i>, it is only because in such a + case ugliness is beauty. A man loved a woman who <a name='5_Page_13'></a>was very thin + and marked by smallpox; he lost her by death. Three years later, + in Rome, he became acquainted with two women, one very beautiful, + the other thin and marked by smallpox, on that account, if you + will, rather ugly. I saw him in love with this plain one at the + end of a week, which he had employed in effacing her plainness by + his memories." (<i>De l'Amour</i>, Chapter XVII.)</p></div> + +<p>In the tendency to idealize the unbeautiful features of a beloved person +erotic symbolism shows itself in a simple and normal form. In a less +simple and more morbid form it appears in persons in whom the normal paths +of sexual gratification are for some reasons inhibited, and who are thus +led to find the symbols of natural love in unnatural perversions. It is +for this reason that so many erotic symbolisms take root in childhood and +puberty, before the sexual instincts have reached full development. It is +for the same reason also, that, at the other end of life, when the sexual +energies are failing, erotic symbols sometimes tend to be substituted for +the normal pleasures of sex. It is for this reason, again, that both men +and women whose normal energies are inhibited sometimes find the symbols +of sexual gratification in the caresses of children.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The case of a schoolmistress recorded by Penta instructively + shows how an erotic symbolism of this last kind may develop by no + means as a refinement of vice, but as the one form in which + sexual gratification becomes possible when normal gratification + has been pathologically inhibited. F. R., aged 48, schoolmistress; + she was some years ago in an asylum with religious mania, but + came out well in a few months. At the age of 12 she had first + experienced sexual excitement in a railway train from the jolting + of the carriage. Soon after she fell in love with a youth who + represented her ideal and who returned her affection. When, + however, she gave herself to him, great was her disillusion and + surprise to find that the sexual act which she had looked forward + to could not be accomplished, for at the first contact there was + great pain and spasmodic resistance of the vagina. There was a + condition of vaginismus. After repeated attempts on subsequent + occasions her lover desisted. Her desire for intercourse + increased, however, rather than diminished, and at last she was + able to tolerate coitus, but the pain was so great that she + acquired a horror of the sexual embrace and no longer sought it. + Having much will power, she restrained all erotic impulses during + many years. It was not until the period of the menopause that the + long repressed desires broke out, and at last found a <a name='5_Page_14'></a>symbolical + outlet that was no longer normal, but was felt to supply a + complete gratification. She sought the close physical contact of + the young children in her care. She would lie on her bed naked, + with two or three naked children, make them suck her breasts and + press them to every part of her body. Her conduct was discovered + by means of other children who peeped through the keyhole, and + she was placed under Penta for treatment. In this case the loss + of moral and mental inhibition, due probably to troubles of the + climacteric, led to indulgence, under abnormal conditions, in + those primitive contacts which are normally the beginning of + love, and these, supported by the ideal image of the early lover, + constituted a complete and adequate symbol of natural love in a + morbidly perverted individual. (P. Penta, <i>Archivio delle + Psicopatie Sessuali</i>, January, 1896.)</p></div> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_1'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_1'>[1]</a><div class='note'><p> The term "erotic symbolism" has already been employed by +Eulenburg (<i>Sexuale Neuropathie</i>, 1895, p. 101). It must be borne in mind +that this term, implying the specific emotion, is much narrower than the +term "sexual symbolism," which may be used to designate a great variety of +ritual and social practices which have played a part in the evolution of +civilization.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_2'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_2'>[2]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Sexual Selection in Man</i>, iv, "Vision."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_3'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_3'>[3]</a><div class='note'><p> K. Groos, <i>Der Æsthetische Genuss</i>, p. 122. The psychology of +the associations of contiguity and resemblance through which erotic +symbolism operates its transference is briefly discussed by Ribot in the +<i>Psychology of the Emotions</i>, Part 1, Chapter XII; the early chapters of +the same author's <i>Logique des Sentiments</i> may also be said to deal with +the emotional basis on which erotic symbolism arises.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_4'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_4'>[4]</a><div class='note'><p> A number of synonyms for the female pudenda are brought +together by Schurig—cunnus, hortus, concha, navis, fovea, larva, canis, +annulus, focus, cymba, antrum, delta, myrtus, etc.—and he discusses many +of them. (<i>Muliebria</i>, Section I, cap. I.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_5'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_5'>[5]</a><div class='note'><p> Kleinpaul, <i>Sprache Ohne Worte</i>, pp. 24-29; <i>cf.</i> K. Pearson, +on the general and special words for sex, <i>Chances of Death</i>, vol. ii, pp. +112-245; a selection of the literature of the rose will be found in a +volume of translations entitled <i>Ros Rosarum</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_6'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_6'>[6]</a><div class='note'><p> G. S. Hall, <i>Adolescence</i>, vol. i, p. 470.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_7'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_7'>[7]</a><div class='note'><p> Goron, <i>Les Parias de l'Amour</i>, p. 45.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_8'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_8'>[8]</a><div class='note'><p> A. R. Reynolds, <i>Medical Standard</i>, vol. x, cited by Kiernan, +"Responsibility in Sexual Perversion," <i>American Journal of Neurology and +Psychiatry</i>, 1882.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_9'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_9'>[9]</a><div class='note'><p> R. Burton, <i>Anatomy of Melancholy</i>, Part III, Section II, +Mem. II, Subs. II, and Mem. III, Subs. I.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_10'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_10'>[10]</a><div class='note'><p> Numerous examples are given by Moll, <i>Konträre +Sexualempfindung</i>, third edition, pp. 265-268.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_11'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_11'>[11]</a><div class='note'><p> Chevalier (<i>De l'Inversion</i>, 1885; <i>id.</i>, <i>L'Inversion +Sexuelle</i>, 1892, p. 52), followed by E. Laurent (<i>L'Amour Morbide</i>, 1891, +Chapter X), separates this group from other fetichistic perversions, under +the head of "azoöphilie." I see no adequate ground for this step. The +various forms of fetichism are too intimately associated to permit of any +group of them being violently separated from the others.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_12'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_12'>[12]</a><div class='note'><p> This has already been considered as a perversion founded on +vision, in discussing <i>Sexual Selection in Man</i>. IV.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_E_II'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_15'></a>II.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Foot-fetichism and Shoe-fetichism—Wide Prevalence and Normal +Basis—Restif de la Bretonne—The Foot a Normal Focus of Sexual Attraction +Among Some Peoples—The Chinese, Greeks, Romans, Spaniards, etc.—The +Congenital Predisposition in Erotic Symbolism—The Influence of Early +Association and Emotional Shock—Shoe-fetichism in Relation to +Masochism—The Two Phenomena Independent Though Allied—The Desire to be +Trodden On—The Fascination of Physical Constraint—The Symbolism of +Self-inflicted Pain—The Dynamic Element in Erotic Symbolism—The +Symbolism of Garments.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>Of all forms of erotic symbolism the most frequent is that which idealizes +the foot and the shoe. The phenomena we here encounter are sometimes so +complex and raise so many interesting questions that it is necessary to +discuss them somewhat fully.</p> + +<p>It would seem that even for the normal lover the foot is one of the most +attractive parts of the body. Stanley Hall found that among the parts +specified as most admired in the other sex by young men and women who +answered a <i>questionnaire</i> the feet came fourth (after the eyes, hair, +stature and size).<a name='5_FNanchor_13'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_13'><sup>[13]</sup></a> Casanova, an acute student and lover of women who +was in no degree a foot fetichist, remarks that all men who share his +interest in women are attracted by their feet; they offer <a name='5_Page_16'></a>the same +interest, he considers, as the question of the particular edition offers +to the book-lover.<a name='5_FNanchor_14'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_14'><sup>[14]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In a report of the results of a <i>questionnaire</i> concerning + children's sense of self, to which over 500 replies were + received, Stanley Hall thus summarizes the main facts ascertained + with reference to the feet: "A special period of noticing the + feet comes somewhat later than that in which the hands are + discovered to consciousness. Our records afford nearly twice as + many cases for feet as for hands. The former are more remote from + the primary psychic focus or position, and are also more often + covered, so that the sight of them is a more marked and + exceptional event. Some children become greatly excited whenever + their feet are exposed. Some infants show signs of fear at the + movement of their own knees and feet covered, and still more + often fright is the first sensation which signalizes the child's + discovery of its feet.... Many are described as playing with them + as if fascinated by strange, newly-discovered toys. They pick + them up and try to throw them away, or out of the cradle, or + bring them to the mouth, where all things tend to go.... Children + often handle their feet, pat and stroke them, offer them toys and + the bottle, as if they, too, had an independent hunger to + gratify, an <i>ego</i> of their own.... Children often develop [later] + a special interest in the feet of others, and examine, feel them, + etc., sometimes expressing surprise that the pinch of the + mother's toe hurts her and not the child, or comparing their own + and the feet of others point by point. Curious, too, are the + intensifications of foot-consciousness throughout the early years + of childhood, whenever children have the exceptional privilege of + going barefoot, or have new shoes. The feet are often + apostrophized, punished, beaten sometimes to the point of pain + for breaking things, throwing the child down, etc. Several + children have habits, which reach great intensity, and then + vanish, of touching or tickling the feet, with gales of laughter, + and a few are described as showing an almost morbid reluctance to + wear anything upon the feet, or even to having them touched by + others.... Several almost fall in love with the great toe or the + little one, especially admiring some crease or dimple in it, + dressing it in some rag of silk or bit of ribbon, or cut-off + glove fingers, winding it with string, prolonging it by tying on + bits of wood. Stroking the feet of others, especially if they are + shapely, often becomes almost a passion with young children, and + several adults confess a survival of the same impulse which it is + an exquisite pleasure to gratify. The interest of some mothers in + babies' toes, the expressions of which are ecstatic and almost + incredible, is a factor of great importance." (G. Stanley Hall, + "Some Aspects of the<a name='5_Page_17'></a> Early Sense of Self," <i>American Journal of + Psychology</i>, April, 1898.) In childhood, Stanley Hall remarks + elsewhere (<i>Adolescence</i>, vol. ii, p. 104), "a form of courtship + may consist solely in touching feet under the desk." It would + seem that even animals have a certain amount of sexual + consciousness in the feet; I have noticed a male donkey, just + before coitus, bite the feet of his partner.</p></div> + +<p>At the same time it is scarcely usual for the normal lover, in most +civilized countries to-day, to attach primary importance to the foot, such +as he very frequently attaches to the eyes, though the feet play a very +conspicuous part in the work of certain novelists.<a name='5_FNanchor_15'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_15'><sup>[15]</sup></a></p> + +<p>In a small but not inconsiderable minority of persons, however, the foot +or the boot becomes the most attractive part of a woman, and in some +morbid cases the woman herself is regarded as a comparatively unimportant +appendage to her feet or her boots. The boots under civilized conditions +much more frequently constitute the sexual symbol than do the feet +themselves; this is not surprising since in ordinary life the feet are not +often seen.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It is usually only under exceptionally favoring conditions that + foot-fetichism occurs, as in the case recorded by Marandon de + Montyel of a doctor who had been brought up in the West Indies. + His mother had been insane and he himself was subject to + obsessions, especially of being incapable of urinating; he had + had nocturnal incontinence of urine in childhood. All the women + of the people in the West Indies go about with naked feet, which + are often beautiful. His puberty evolved under this influence, + and foot-fetichism developed. He especially admired large, fat, + arched feet, with delicate skin and large, regular toes. He + masturbated with images of feet. At 15 he had relations with a + colored chambermaid, but feared to mention his fetichism, though + it was the touch of her feet that chiefly excited him. He now + gave up masturbation, and had a succession of mistresses, but was + always ashamed to confess his fancies until, at the age of 33, in + Paris, a very intelligent woman who had become his mistress + discovered his <a name='5_Page_18'></a>mania and skillfully enabled him to yield to it + without shock to his modesty. He was devoted to this mistress, + who had very beautiful feet (he had been horrified by the feet of + Europeans generally), until she finally left him. (<i>Archives de + Neurologie</i>, October, 1904.)</p> + +<p> Probably the first case of shoe-fetichism ever recorded in any + detail is that of Restif de la Bretonne (1734-1806), publicist + and novelist, one of the most remarkable literary figures of the + later eighteenth century in France. Restif was a neurotic + subject, though not to an extreme degree, and his shoe-fetichism, + though distinctly pronounced, was not pathological; that is to + say, that the shoe was not itself an adequate gratification of + the sexual impulse, but simply a highly important aid to + tumescence, a prelude to the natural climax of detumescence; only + occasionally, and <i>faute de mieux</i>, in the absence of the beloved + person, was the shoe used as an adjunct to masturbation. In + Restif's stories and elsewhere the attraction of the shoe is + frequently discussed or used as a motive. His first decided + literary success, <i>Le Pied de Fanchette</i>, was suggested by a + vision of a girl with a charming foot, casually seen in the + street. While all such passages in his books are really founded + on his own personal feelings and experiences, in his elaborate + autobiography, <i>Monsieur Nicolas</i>, he has frankly set forth the + gradual evolution and cause of his idiosyncrasy. The first + remembered trace dated from the age of 4, when he was able to + recall having remarked the feet of a young girl in his native + place. Restif was a sexually precocious youth, and at the age of + 9, though both delicate in health and shy in manners, his + thoughts were already absorbed in the girls around him. "While + little Monsieur Nicolas," he tells us, "passed for a Narcissus, + his thoughts, as soon as he was alone, by night or by day, had no + other object than that sex he seemed to flee from. The girls most + careful of their persons were naturally those who pleased him + most, and as the part least easy to keep clean is that which + touches the earth it was to the foot-gear that he mechanically + gave his chief attention. Agathe, Reine, and especially + Madeleine, were the most elegant of the girls at that time; their + carefully selected and kept shoes, instead of laces or buckles, + which were not yet worn at Sacy, had blue or rose ribbon, + according to the color of the skirt. I thought of these girls + with emotion; I desired—I knew not what; but I desired + something, if it were only to subdue them." The origin Restif + here assigns to his shoe-fetichism may seem paradoxical; he + admired the girls who were most clean and neat in their dress, he + tells us, and, therefore, paid most attention to that part of + their clothing which was least clean and neat. But, however + paradoxical the remark may seem, it is psychologically sound. All + fetichism is a kind of not necessarily morbid obsession, and as + the careful work of Janet and others in that field has shown, an + obsession is a fascinated attraction to some object or idea + <a name='5_Page_19'></a>which gives the subject a kind of emotional shock by its + contrast to his habitual moods or ideas. The ordinary morbid + obsession cannot usually be harmoniously co-ordinated with the + other experiences of the subject's daily life, and shows, + therefore, no tendency to become pleasurable. Sexual fetichisms, + on the other hand, have a reservoir of agreeable emotion to draw + on, and are thus able to acquire both stability and harmony. It + will also be seen that no element of masochism is involved in + Restif's fetichism, though the mistake has been frequently made + of supposing that these two manifestations are usually or even + necessarily allied. Restif wishes to subject the girl who + attracts him, he has no wish to be subjected by her. He was + especially dazzled by a young girl from another town, whose shoes + were of a fashionable cut, with buckles, "and who was a charming + person besides." She was delicate as a fairy, and rendered his + thoughts unfaithful to the robust beauties of his native Sacy. + "No doubt," he remarks, "because, being frail and weak myself, it + seemed to me that it would be easier to subdue her." "This taste + for the beauty of the feet," he continues, "was so powerful in me + that it unfailingly aroused desire and would have made me + overlook ugliness. It is excessive in all those who have it." He + admired the foot as well as the shoe: "The factitious taste for + the shoe is only a reflection of that for pretty feet. When I + entered a house and saw the boots arranged in a row, as is the + custom, I would tremble with pleasure; I blushed and lowered my + eyes as if in the presence of the girls themselves. With this + vivacity of feeling and a voluptuousness of ideas inconceivable + at the age of 10 I still fled, with an involuntary impulse of + modesty, from the girls I adored."</p> + +<p> We may clearly see how this combination of sensitive and + precocious sexual ardor with extreme shyness, furnished the soil + on which the germ of shoe-fetichism was able to gain a firm root + and persist in some degree throughout a long life very largely + given up to a pursuit of women, abnormal rather by its + excessiveness than its perversity. A few years later, he tells + us, he happened to see a pretty pair of shoes in a bootmaker's + shop, and on hearing that they belonged to a girl whom at that + time he reverently adored at a distance he blushed and nearly + fainted.</p> + +<p> In 1749 he was for a time attracted to a young woman very much + older than himself; he secretly carried away one of her slippers + and kept it for a day; a little later he again took away a shoe + of the same woman which had fascinated him when on her foot, and, + he seems to imply, he used it to masturbate with.</p> + +<p> Perhaps the chief passion of Restif's life was his love for + Colette Parangon. He was still a boy (1752), she was the young + and virtuous wife of the printer whose apprentice Restif was and + in whose house he lived. Madame Parangon, a charming woman, as + she is described, <a name='5_Page_20'></a>was not happily married, and she evidently + felt a tender affection for the boy whose excessive love and + reverence for her were not always successfully concealed. + "Madonna Parangon," he tells us, "possessed a charm which I could + never resist, a pretty little foot; it is a charm which arouses + more than tenderness. Her shoes, made in Paris, had that + voluptuous elegance which seems to communicate soul and life. + Sometimes Colette wore shoes of simple white drugget or with + silver flowers; sometimes rose-colored slippers with green heels, + or green with rose heels; her supple feet, far from deforming her + shoes, increased their grace and rendered the form more + exciting." One day, on entering the house, he saw Madame Parangon + elegantly dressed and wearing rose-colored shoes with tongues, + and with green heels and a pretty rosette. They were new and she + took them off to put on green slippers with rose heels and + borders which he thought equally exciting. As soon as she had + left the room, he continues, "carried away by the most impetuous + passion and idolizing Colette, I seemed to see her and touch her + in handling what she had just worn; my lips pressed one of these + jewels, while the other, deceiving the sacred end of nature, from + excess of exaltation replaced the object of sex (I cannot express + myself more clearly). The warmth which she had communicated to + the insensible object which had touched her still remained and + gave a soul to it; a voluptuous cloud covered my eyes." He adds + that he would kiss with rage and transport whatever had come in + close contact with the woman he adored, and on one occasion + eagerly pressed his lips to her cast-off underlinen, <i>vela + secretiora penetralium</i>.</p> + +<p> At this period Restif's foot-fetichism reached its highest point + of development. It was the aberration of a highly sensitive and + very precocious boy. While the preoccupation with feet and shoes + persisted throughout life, it never became a complete perversion + and never replaced the normal end of sexual desire. His love for + Madam Parangon, one of the deepest emotions in his whole life, + was also the climax of his shoe-fetichism. She represented his + ideal woman, an ethereal sylph with wasp-waist and a child's + feet; it was always his highest praise for a woman that she + resembled Madame Parangon, and he desired that her slipper should + be buried with him. (Restif de la Bretonne, <i>Monsieur Nicolas</i>, + vols. i-iv, vol. xiii, p. 5; <i>id.</i>, <i>Mes Inscriptions</i>, pp. + ci-cv.)</p> + +<p> Shoe-fetichism, more especially if we include under this term all + the cases of real or pseudo-masochism in which an attraction to + the boots or slippers is the chief feature, is a not infrequent + phenomenon, and is certainly the most frequently occurring form + of fetichism. Many cases are brought together by Krafft-Ebing in + his <i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>. Every prostitute of any experience + has known men who merely desire to gaze at her shoes, or possibly + to lick them, and who are quite willing to pay for this + privilege. In London such a person is known as a "bootman," in + Germany as a "Stiefelfrier."</p></div><a name='5_Page_21'></a> + +<p>The predominance of the foot as a focus of sexual attraction, while among +us to-day it is a not uncommon phenomenon, is still not sufficiently +common to be called normal; the majority of even ardent lovers do not +experience this attraction in any marked degree. But these manifestations +of foot-fetichism which with us to-day are abnormal, even when they are +not so extreme as to be morbid, may perhaps become more intelligible to us +when we realize that in earlier periods of civilization, and even to-day +in some parts of the world, the foot is generally recognized as a focus of +sexual attraction, so that some degree of foot-fetichism becomes a normal +phenomenon.</p> + +<p>The most pronounced and the best known example of such normal +foot-fetichism at the present day is certainly to be found among the +Southern Chinese. For a Chinese husband his wife's foot is more +interesting than her face. A Chinese woman is as shy of showing her feet +to a man as a European woman her breasts; they are reserved for her +husband's eyes alone, and to look at a woman's feet in the street is +highly improper and indelicate. Chinese foot-fetichism is connected with +the custom of compressing the feet. This custom appears to rest on the +fact that Chinese women naturally possess a very small foot and is thus an +example of the universal tendency in the search for beauty to accentuate, +even by deformation, the racial characteristics. But there is more than +this. Beauty is largely a name for sexual attractiveness, and the energy +expended in the effort to make the Chinese woman's small foot still +smaller is a measure of the sexual fascination which it exerts. The +practice arose on the basis of the sexual attractiveness of the foot, +though it has doubtless served to heighten that attractiveness, just as +the small waist, which (if we may follow Stratz) is a characteristic +beauty of the European woman, becomes to the average European man still +more attractive when accentuated, even to the extent of deformity, by the +compression of the corset.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Referring to the sexual fascination exerted by the foot in China, + Matignon writes: "My attention has been drawn to this point by a + large number of pornographic engravings, of which the Chinese are + very fond. In all these lascivious scenes we see the male + voluptuously fondling <a name='5_Page_22'></a>the woman's foot. When a Celestial takes + into his hand a woman's foot, especially if it is very small, the + effect upon him is precisely the same as is provoked in a + European by the palpation of a young and firm bosom. All the + Celestials whom I have interrogated on this point have replied + unanimously: 'Oh, a little foot! You Europeans cannot understand + how exquisite, how sweet, how exciting it is!' The contact of the + genital organ with the little foot produces in the male an + indescribable degree of voluptuous feeling, and women skilled in + love know that to arouse the ardor of their lovers a better + method than all Chinese aphrodisiacs—including 'giusen' and + swallows' nests—is to take the penis between their feet. It is + not rare to find Chinese Christians accusing themselves at + confession of having had 'evil thoughts on looking at a woman's + foot.'" (Dr. J. Matignon, "A propos d'un Pied de Chinoise," + <i>Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, 1898.)</p> + +<p> It is said that a Chinese Empress, noted for her vice and having + a congenital club foot, about the year 1100 B.C., desired all + women to resemble her, and that the practice of compressing the + foot thus arose. But this is only tradition, since, in 300 B.C., + Chinese books were destroyed (Morache, Art. "Chine," + <i>Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des Sciences Médicales</i>, p. 191). It + is also said that the practice owes its origin to the wish to + keep women indoors. But women are not secluded in China, nor does + foot compression usually render a woman unable to walk. Many + intelligent Chinese are of opinion that its object is to promote + the development of the sexual parts and of the thighs, and so to + aid both intercourse and parturition. There is no ground for + believing that it has any such influence, though Morache found + that the mons veneris and labia are largely developed in Chinese + women, and not in Tartar women living in Pekin (who do not + compress the foot). If there is any correlation between the feet + and the pelvic regions, it is more probably congenital than due + to the artificial compression of the feet. The ancients seem to + have believed that a small foot indicated a small vagina. Restif + de la Bretonne, who had ample opportunities for forming an + opinion on a matter in which he took so great an interest, + believed that a small foot, round and short, indicated a large + vagina (<i>Monsieur Nicolas</i>, vol. i, reprint of 1883, p. 92). + Even, however, if we admit that there is a real correlation + between the foot and the vagina, that would by no means suffice + to render the foot a focus of sexual attraction.</p> + +<p> It remains the most reasonable view that the foot bandage must be + regarded as strictly analogous to the waist bandage or corset + which also tends to produce deformity of the constricted region. + Stratz has ingeniously remarked (<i>Frauenkleidung</i>, third edition, + p. 101) that the success of the Chinese in dwarfing trees may + have suggested a similar attempt in regard to women's feet, and + adds that in any case both dwarfed trees and bound feet bear + witness in the Mongolian to the same <a name='5_Page_23'></a>love for small and elegant, + not to say deformed, things. For a Chinaman the deformed foot is + a "golden water-lily."</p> + +<p> Many facts (together with illustrations) bearing on Chinese + deformation of the foot will be found in Ploss, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. + i, Section IV.</p></div> + +<p>The significance of the sexual emotion aroused by the female foot in China +and the origin of its compression begin to become clear when we realize +that this foot-fetichism is merely an extreme development of a tendency +which is fairly well marked among nearly all the peoples of yellow race. +Jacoby, who has brought together a number of interesting facts bearing on +the sexual significance of the foot, states that a similar tendency is to +be found among the Mongol and Turk peoples of Siberia, and in the east and +central parts of European Russia, among the Permiaks, the Wotiaks, etc. +Here the woman, at all events when young, has always her feet, as well as +head, covered, however little clothing she may otherwise wear.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>"On hot nights or on baking days," Jacoby states, "you may see + these women with uncovered breasts, or even entirely naked + without embarrassment, but you will never see them with bare + feet, and no male relations, except the husband, will ever see + the feet and lower part of the legs of the women in the house. + These women have their modesty in their feet, and also their + coquetry; to unbind the feet of a woman is for a man a voluptuous + act, and the touch of the bands produces the same effect as a + corset still warm from a woman's body on a European man. A + woman's beauty, that which attracts and excites a man, lies in + her foot; in Mordvin love poems celebrating the beauty of women + there is much about her attire, especially her embroidered + chemise, but as regards the charms of her person the poet is + content to state that 'her feet are beautiful;' with that + everything is said. The young peasant woman of the central + provinces as part of her holiday raiment puts on great woolen + stockings which come up to the groin and are then folded over to + below the knee. To uncover the feet of a person of the opposite + sex is a sexual act, and has thus become the symbol of sexual + possession, so that the stocking or foot-gear became the emblem + of marriage, as later the ring. (It was so among the Jews, as we + see in the book of <i>Ruth</i>, Chapter III, v. 4, and Chapter IV, vv. + 7 and 8). St. Vladimir the Great asked in marriage the daughter + of Prince Rogvold; as Vladimir's mother had been a serf, the + princess proudly replied that she 'would not uncover the feet of + a slave.' At the present time in the <a name='5_Page_24'></a>east of Russia when a young + girl tries to find out by divination whom she will have as a + husband the traditional formula is 'Come and take my stockings + off.' Among the populations of the north and east, it is + sometimes the bride who must do this for her husband on the + wedding night, and sometimes the bridegroom for his wife, not as + a token of love, but as a nuptial ceremony. Among the + professional classes and small nobility in Russia parents place + money in the stocking of their child at marriage as a present for + the other partner, it being supposed that the couple mutually + remove each other's foot raiment, as an act of sexual possession, + the emblem of coitus." (Paul Jacoby, <i>Archives d'Anthropologie + Criminelle</i>, December, 1903, p. 793.) The practice among + ourselves of children hanging up their stockings at night for + presents would seem to be a relic of the last-mentioned custom.</p></div> + +<p>While we may witness the sexual symbolism of the foot, with or without an +associated foot-fetichism, most highly developed in Asia and Eastern +Europe, it has by no means been altogether unknown in some stages of +western civilization, and traces of it may be found here and there even +yet. Schinz refers to the connection between the feet and sexual pleasure +as existing not only among the Egyptians and the Arabs, but among the +ancient Germans and the modern Spaniards,<a name='5_FNanchor_16'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_16'><sup>[16]</sup></a> while Jacoby points out that +among the Greeks, the Romans, and especially the Etruscans, it was usual +to represent chaste and virgin goddesses with their feet covered, even +though they might be otherwise nude. Ovid, again, is never weary of +dwelling on the sexual charm of the feminine foot. He represents the +chaste matron as wearing a weighted <i>stola</i> which always fell so as to +cover her feet; it was only the courtesan, or the nymph who is taking part +in an erotic festival, who appears with raised robes, revealing her +feet.<a name='5_FNanchor_17'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_17'><sup>[17]</sup></a> So grave a historian as Strabo, as well as Ælian, <a name='5_Page_25'></a>refers to the +story of the courtesan Rhodope whose sandal was carried off by an eagle +and dropped in the King of Egypt's lap as he was administering justice, so +that he could not rest until he had discovered to whom this delicately +small sandal belonged, and finally made her his queen. Kleinpaul, who +repeats this story, has collected many European sayings and customs +(including Turkish), indicating that the slipper is a very ancient symbol +of a woman's sexual parts.<a name='5_FNanchor_18'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_18'><sup>[18]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In Rome, Dufour remarks, "Matrons having appropriated the use of + the shoe (<i>soccus</i>) prostitutes were not allowed to use it, and + were obliged to have their feet always naked in sandals or + slippers (<i>crepida</i> and <i>solea</i>), which they fastened over the + instep with gilt bands. Tibullus delights to describe his + mistress's little foot, compressed by the band that imprisoned + it: <i>Ansaque compressos colligat arcta pedes</i>. Nudity of the foot + in woman was a sign of prostitution, and their brilliant + whiteness acted afar as a pimp to attract looks and desires." + (Dufour, <i>Histoire de la Prostitution</i>, vol. II., ch. xviii.)</p> + +<p> This feeling seems to have survived in a more or less vague and + unconscious form in mediæval Europe. "In the tenth century," + according to Dufour (<i>Histoire de la Prostitution</i>, vol. VI., p. + 11), "shoes <i>a la poulaine</i>, with a claw or beak, pursued for + more than four centuries by the anathemas of popes and the + invectives of preachers, were always regarded by mediæval + casuists as the most abominable emblems of immodesty. At a first + glance it is not easy to see why these shoes—terminating in a + lion's claw, an eagle's beak, the prow of a ship, or other metal + appendage—should be so scandalous. The excommunication inflicted + on this kind of foot-gear preceded the impudent invention of some + libertine, who wore <i>poulaines</i> in the shape of the phallus, a + custom adopted also by women. This kind of <i>poulaine</i> was + denounced as <i>mandite de Dicu</i> (Ducange's Glossary, at the word + Poulainia) and prohibited by royal ordinances (see letter of + Charles V., 17 October, 1367, regarding the garments of the women + of Montpellier). Great lords and ladies continued, however, to + wear <i>poulaines</i>." In Louis XL's court they were still worn of a + quarter of an ell in length.</p> + +<p> Spain, ever tenacious of ancient ideas, appears to have preserved + <a name='5_Page_26'></a>longer than other countries the ancient classic traditions in + regard to the foot as a focus of modesty and an object of sexual + attraction. In Spanish religious pictures it was always necessary + that the Virgin's feet should be concealed, the clergy ordaining + that her robe should be long and flowing, so that the feet might + be covered with decent folds. Pacheco, the master and + father-in-law of Velasquez, writes in 1649 in his <i>Arte de la + Pintura</i>: "What can be more foreign from the respect which we owe + to the purity of Our Lady the Virgin than to paint her sitting + down with one of her knees placed over the other, and often with + her sacred feet uncovered and naked. Let thanks be given to the + Holy Inquisition which commands that this liberty should be + corrected!" It was Pacheco's duty in Seville to see that these + commands were obeyed. At the court of Philip IV. at this time the + princesses never showed their feet, as we may see in the pictures + of Velasquez. When a local manufacturer desired to present that + monarch's second bride, Mariana of Austria, with some silk + stockings the offer was indignantly rejected by the Court + Chamberlain: "The Queen of Spain has no legs!" Philip V.'s, queen + was thrown from her horse and dragged by the feet; no one + ventured to interfere until two gentlemen bravely rescued her and + then fled, dreading punishment by the king: they were, however, + graciously pardoned. Reinach ("Pieds Pudiques," <i>Cultes, Mythes + et Religions</i>, pp. 105-110) brings together several passages from + the Countess D'Aulnoy's account of the Madrid Court in the + seventeenth century and from other sources, showing how careful + Spanish ladies were as regards their feet, and how jealous + Spanish husbands were in this matter. At this time, when Spanish + influence was considerable, the fashion of Spain seems to have + spread to other countries. One may note that in Vandyck's + pictures of English beauties the feet are not visible, though in + the more characteristically English painters of a somewhat later + age it became usual to display them conspicuously, while the + French custom in this matter is the farthest removed from the + Spanish. At the present day a well-bred Spanish woman shows as + little as possible of her feet in walking, and even in some of + the most characteristic Spanish dances there is little or no + kicking, and the feet may even be invisible throughout. It is + noteworthy that in numerous figures of Spanish women (probably + artists' models) reproduced in Ploss's <i>Das Weib</i> the stockings + are worn, although the women are otherwise, in most cases, quite + naked. Max Dessoir mentions ("Psychologie der Vita Sexualis," + <i>Zeitschrift für Psychiatrie</i>, 1894, p. 954) that in Spanish + pornographic photographs women always have their shoes on, and he + considers this an indication of perversity. I have seen the + statement (attributed to Gautier's <i>Voyage en Espagne</i>, where, + however, it does not occur) that Spanish prostitutes uncover + their feet in sign of assent, and Madame d'Aulnoy stated that in + her time to show her lover her feet was a Spanish woman's final + favor.</p></div><a name='5_Page_27'></a> + +<p>The tendency, which we thus find to be normal at some earlier periods of +civilization, to insist on the sexual symbolism of the feminine foot or +its coverings, and to regard them as a special sexual fascination, is not +without significance for the interpretation of the sporadic manifestations +of foot-fetichism among ourselves. Eccentric as foot-fetichism may appear +to us, it is simply the re-emergence, by a pseudo-atavism or arrest of +development, of a mental or emotional impulse which was probably +experienced by our forefathers, and is often traceable among young +children to-day.<a name='5_FNanchor_19'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_19'><sup>[19]</sup></a> The occasional reappearance of this bygone impulse +and the stability which it may acquire are thus conditioned by the +sensitive reaction of an abnormally nervous and usually precocious +organism to influences which, among the average and ordinary population of +Europe to-day, are either never felt, or quickly outgrown, or very +strictly subordinated in the highly complex crystallizations which the +course of love and the process of tumescence create within us.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It may be added that this is by no means true of foot-fetichism + only. In some other fetichisms a seemingly congenital + predisposition is even more marked. This is not only the case as + regards hair-fetichism and fur-fetichism (see, <i>e.g.</i>, + Krafft-Ebing, <i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, English translation of + tenth edition, pp. 233, 255, 262). In many cases of fetichisms of + all kinds not only is there no record of any commencement in a + definite episode (an absence which may be accounted for by the + supposition that the original incident has been forgotten), but + it would seem in some cases that the fetichism developed very + slowly.</p></div> + +<p>In this sense, it will be seen, although it is hazardous to speak of +foot-fetichism as strictly an atavism, it may certainly be said to arise +on a congenital basis. It represents the rare development of an inborn +germ, usually latent among ourselves, which in earlier stages of +civilization frequently reached a normal and general fruition.</p> +<a name='5_Page_28'></a> +<p>It is of interest to emphasize this congenital element of foot symbolism, +because more than any other forms of sexual perversion the fetichisms are +those which are most vaguely conditioned by inborn states of the organism +and most definitely aroused by seemingly accidental associations or shocks +in early life. Inversion is sometimes so fundamentally ingrained in the +individual's constitution that it arises and develops in spite of the very +strongest influence in a contrary direction. But a fetichism, while it +tends to occur in sensitive, nervous, timid, precocious individuals—that +is to say, individuals of more or less neuropathic heredity—can usually, +though not always, be traced to a definite starting point in the shock of +some sexually emotional episode in early life.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>A few examples of the influences of such association may here be + given, referring miscellaneously to various forms of erotic + symbolism. Magnan has recorded the case of a hair-fetichist, + living in a district where the women wore their hair done up, who + at the age of 15 experienced pleasurable feelings with erection + at the sight of a village beauty combing her hair; from that time + flowing hair became his fetich, and he could not resist the + temptation to touch it and if possible sever it, thus becoming a + hair-despoiler, for which he was arrested but not sentenced. + (<i>Archives de l'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, vol. v, No. 28.)</p> + +<p> I have elsewhere recorded the history of a boy of 14, having + already had imperfect connection with a grown-up woman, who + associated much with a young married lady; he had no sexual + relations with her, but one day she urinated in his presence, and + he saw that her mons veneris was covered by very thick hair; from + that time he worshiped this woman in secret and acquired a + life-long fetichistic attraction to women whose pubic hair was + similarly abundant (<i>Studies in the Psychology of Sex</i>, vol. iii, + Appendix B, History V).</p> + +<p> Roubaud reported the case of a general's son, sexually initiated + at the age of 14 by a blonde young lady of 21 who, in order to + avoid detection, always retained her clothing: gaiters, a corset + and a silk dress; when the boy's studies were completed and he + was sent to a garrison where he could enjoy freedom he found that + his sexual desires could only be aroused by blonde women dressed + like the lady who had first aroused his sexual desires; + consequently he gave up all thoughts of matrimony, as a woman in + nightclothes produced impotence (<i>Traité de l'Impuissance</i>, p. + 439). Krafft-Ebing records the somewhat similar case of a nervous + Polish boy of old family seduced at the age of 17 by a French + governess, who during several months practiced mutual + masturbation <a name='5_Page_29'></a>with him; in this way his attention became + attracted by her very elegant boots, and in the end he became a + confirmed boot-fetichist (<i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, English + translation, p. 249).</p> + +<p> A boy of 7, of bad heredity, was taught to masturbate by a + servant girl; on one occasion she practiced this on him with her + foot without taking off her shoe; it was the first time the + manœuvre gave him any pleasure, and an association was + thus established which led to shoe-fetichism (Hammond, <i>Sexual + Impotence</i>, p. 44). A government official whose first coitus in + youth took place on a staircase; the sound of his partner's + creaking shoes against the stairs, produced by her efforts to + accelerate orgasm, formed an association which developed into an + auditory shoe-fetichism; in the streets he was compelled to + follow ladies whose shoes creaked, ejaculation being thus + produced, while to obtain complete satisfaction he would make a + prostitute, otherwise naked, sit in front of him in her shoes, + moving her feet so that the shoes creaked. (Moraglia, <i>Archivio + di Psichiatria</i>, vol. xiii, p. 568.)</p> + +<p> Bechterew, in St. Petersburg, has recorded the case of a man who + when a child used to fall asleep at the knees of his nurse with + his head buried in the folds of her apron; in this position he + first experienced erection and voluptuous sensations; when a + youth he had no attraction to naked women, and in real life and + in dreams was only excited sexually under conditions recalling + his early experience; in his relations with women he preferred + them dressed, and was excited by the rustling sound of their + skirts; in this case there was no traceable neuropathic taint nor + any other personal peculiarity. (Summarized in <i>Journal de + Psychologie Normale et Pathologique</i>, January-February, 1904, p. + 72.)</p> + +<p> In a curious case recorded in detail by Moll, a philologist of + sensitive temperament but sound heredity, who had always been + fond of flowers, at the age of 21 became engaged to a young lady + who wore large roses fastened in her jacket; from this time roses + became to him a sexual fetich, to kiss them caused erection, and + his erotic dreams were accompanied by visions of roses and the + hallucination of their odor; the engagement was finally broken + off and the rose-fetichism disappeared (<i>Untersuchungen über + Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. 540).</p></div> + +<p>Such associations may naturally occur in the early experiences of even the +most normal persons. The degree to which they will influence the +subsequent life and thought and feeling depends on the degree of the +individual's morbid emotional receptivity, on the extent to which he is +hereditarily susceptible of abnormal deviation. Precocity is undoubtedly a +condition which favors such deviation; a child who is precociously and +<a name='5_Page_30'></a>abnormally sensitive to persons of the opposite sex before puberty has +established the normal channels of sexual desire, is peculiarly liable to +become the prey of a chance symbolism. All degrees of such symbolism are +possible. While the average insensitive person may fail to perceive them +at all, for the more alert and imaginative lover they are a fascinating +part of the highly charged crystallization of passion. A more nervously +exceptional person, when once such a symbolism has become firmly +implanted, may find it an absolutely essential element in the charm of a +beloved and charming person. Finally, for the individual who is thoroughly +unsound the symbol becomes generalized; a person is no longer desired at +all, being merely regarded as an appendage of the symbol, or being +dispensed with altogether; the symbol is alone desired, and is fully +adequate to impart by itself complete sexual gratification. While it must +be considered a morbid state to demand a symbol as an almost essential +part of the charm of a desired person, it is only in the final condition, +in which the symbol becomes all-sufficing, that we have a true and +complete perversion. In the less complete forms of symbolism it is still +the woman who is desired, and the ends of procreation may be served; when +the woman is ignored and the mere symbol is an adequate and even preferred +stimulus to detumescence the pathological condition becomes complete.</p> + +<p>Krafft-Ebing regarded shoe-fetichism as, in large measure, a more or less +latent form of masochism, the foot or the shoe being the symbol of the +subjection and humiliation which the masochist feels in the presence of +the beloved object. Moll is also inclined to accept such a connection.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>"The very numerous class of boot-and-shoe-fetichists," + Krafft-Ebing wrote, "forms the transition to the manifestations + of another independent perversion, <i>i.e.</i>, fetichism itself; but + it stands in closer relationship to the former.... It is highly + probable, and shown by a correct classification of the observed + cases, that the majority, and perhaps all of the cases of + shoe-fetichism, rest upon a basis of more or less conscious + masochistic desire for self-humiliation.... The majority <a name='5_Page_31'></a>or all + may be looked upon as instances of latent masochism (the motive + remaining unconscious) in which the <i>female foot or shoe, as the + masochist's fetich</i>, has acquired an independent significance." + (<i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, English translation of tenth edition, + pp. 159, <i>et seq.</i>) "Though Krafft-Ebing may not have cleared up + the whole matter," Moll remarks, "I regard his deductions + concerning the connection of foot-and-shoe fetichism to masochism + as the most important progress that has been made in the + theoretic study of sexual perversions.... In any case, the + connection is very frequent." (<i>Konträre Sexualempfindung</i>, third + edition, p. 306.)</p></div> + +<p>It is quite easy to see that this supposed identity of masochism and +foot-fetichism forms a seductive theory. It is also undoubtedly true that +a masochist may very easily be inclined to find in his mistress's foot an +aid to the ecstatic self-abnegation which he desires to attain.<a name='5_FNanchor_20'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_20'><sup>[20]</sup></a> But +only confusion is attained by any general attempt to amalgamate masochism +and foot-fetichism. In the broad sense in which erotic symbolism is here +understood, both masochism and foot-fetichism may be coördinated as +symbolisms; for the masochist his self-humiliating impulses are the symbol +of ecstatic adoration; for the foot-fetichist his mistress's foot or shoe +is the concentrated symbol of all that is most beautiful and elegant and +feminine in her personality. But if in this sense they are coördinated, +they remain entirely distinct and have not even any necessary tendency to +become merged. Masochism merely simulates foot-fetichism; for the +masochist the boot is not strictly a symbol, it is only an instrument +which enables him to carry out his impulse; the true sexual symbol for him +is not the boot, but the emotion of self-subjection. For the +foot-fetichist, on the other hand, the foot or the shoe is not a mere +instrument, but a true symbol; the focus of his worship, an idealized +object which he is content to contemplate or reverently touch. He has no +necessary impulse to any self-degrading action, nor any constant emotion +of subjection.<a name='5_Page_32'></a> It may be noted that in the very typical case of +foot-fetichism which is presented to us in the person of Restif de la +Bretonne (<i>ante</i>, p. 18), he repeatedly speaks of "subjecting" the woman +for whom he feels this fetichistic adoration, and mentions that even when +still a child he especially admired a delicate and fairy-like girl in this +respect because she seemed to him easier to subjugate. Throughout life +Restif's attitude toward women was active and masculine, without the +slightest trace of masochism.<a name='5_FNanchor_21'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_21'><sup>[21]</sup></a></p> + +<p>To suppose that a fetichistic admiration of his mistress's foot is due to +a lover's latent desire to be kicked, is as unreasonable as it would be to +suppose that a fetichistic admiration for her hand indicated a latent +desire to have his ears boxed. In determining whether we are concerned +with a case of foot-fetichism or of masochism we must take into +consideration the whole of the subject's mental and emotional attitude. An +act, however definite, will not suffice as a criterion, for the same act +in different persons may have altogether different implications. To +amalgamate the two is the result of inadequate psychological analysis and +only leads to confusion.</p> + +<p>It is, however, often very difficult to decide whether we are dealing with +a case which is predominantly one of masochism or of foot-fetichism. The +nature of the action desired, as we have seen, will not suffice to +determine the psychological character of the perversion. Krafft-Ebing +believed that the desire to be trodden on, very frequently experienced by +masochists, is absolutely symptomatic of masochism.<a name='5_FNanchor_22'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_22'><sup>[22]</sup></a> This is scarcely +the case. The desire to be trodden on may be fundamentally an <a name='5_Page_33'></a>erotic +symbolism, closely approaching foot-fetichism, and such slight indications +of masochism as appear may be merely a parasitic growth on the symbolism, +a growth perhaps more suggested by the circumstances involved in the +gratification of the abnormal desire than inherent in the innate impulse +of the subject. This may be illustrated by the interesting case of a very +intelligent man with whom I am well acquainted.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>C. P., aged 38. Heredity good. Parents both healthy and normal. + Several children of the marriage, all sexually normal so far as + is known. C. P. is the youngest of the family and separated from + the others by an interval of many years. He was a seven-months' + child. He has always enjoyed good health and is active and + vigorous, both mentally and physically.</p> + +<p> From the age of 9 or 10 to 14 he masturbated occasionally for the + sake of physical relief, having discovered the act for himself. + He was, however, quite innocent and knew nothing of sexual + matters, never having been initiated either by servants or by + other boys.</p> + +<p> "When I encounter a woman who very strongly attracts me and whom + I very greatly admire," he writes, "my desire is never that I may + have sexual connection with her in the ordinary sense, but that I + may lie down upon the floor on my back and be trampled upon by + her. This curious desire is seldom present unless the object of + my admiration is really a lady, and of fine proportions. She must + be richly dressed—preferably in an evening gown, and wear dainty + high-heeled slippers, either quite open so as to show the curve + of the instep, or with only one strap or 'bar' across. The skirts + should be raised sufficiently to afford me the pleasure of seeing + her feet and a liberal amount of ankle, but in no case above the + knee, or the effect is greatly reduced. Although I often greatly + admire a woman's intellect and even person, sexually no other + part of her has any serious attraction for me except the leg, + from the knee downwards, and the foot, and these must be + exquisitely clothed. Given this condition, my desire amounts to a + wish to gratify my sexual sense by contact with the (to me) + attractive part of the woman. Comparatively few women have a leg + or foot sufficiently beautiful to my mind to excite any serious + or compelling desire, but when this is so, or I suspect it, I am + willing to spend any time or trouble to get her to tread upon me + and am anxious to be trampled on with the greatest severity.</p> + +<p> "The treading should be inflicted for a few minutes all over the + chest, abdomen and groin, and lastly on the penis, which is, of + course, lying along the belly in a violent state of erection, and + consequently too hard for the treading to damage it. I also enjoy + being nearly strangled by a woman's foot.</p><a name='5_Page_34'></a> + +<p> "If the lady finally stands facing my head and places her slipper + upon my penis so that the high heel falls about where the penis + leaves the scrotum, the sole covering most of the rest of it and + with the other foot upon the abdomen, into which I can <i>see</i> as + well as feel it sink as she shifts her weight from one foot to + the other, orgasm takes place almost at once. Emission under + these conditions is to me an agony of delight, during which + practically the lady's whole weight should rest upon the penis.</p> + +<p> "One reason for my special pleasure in this method seems to be + that first the heel and afterwards the sole of the slipper as it + treads upon the penis greatly check the passage of the semen and + consequently the pleasure is considerably prolonged. There is + also a curious mental side to the affair. I love to imagine that + the lady who is treading upon me is my mistress and I her slave, + and that she is doing it to punish me for some fault, or to give + <i>herself</i> (not me) pleasure.</p> + +<p> "It follows that the greater the contempt and severity with which + I am 'punished,' the greater becomes my pleasure. The idea of + 'punishment' or 'slavery' is seldom aroused except when I have + great difficulty in accomplishing my desire and the treader is + more than usually handsome and heavy and the trampling + mercilessly inflicted. I have been trampled so long and so + mercilessly several times, that I have flinched each time the + slipper pressed its way into my aching body and have been black + and blue for days afterwards. I take the greatest interest in + leading ladies on to do this for me where I think I will not + offend, and have been surprisingly successful. I must have lain + beneath the feet of quite a hundred women, many of them of good + social position, who would never dream of permitting any ordinary + sexual intercourse, but who have been so interested or amused by + the idea as to do it for me—many of them over and over again. It + is perhaps needless to say that none of my own or the ladies' + clothing is ever removed, or disarranged, for the accomplishment + of orgasm in this manner. After a long and varied experience, I + may say that my favorite weight is 10 to 11 stone, and that + black, very high-heeled slippers, in combination with tan silk + stockings, seem to give me the greatest pleasure and create in me + the strongest desires.</p> + +<p> "Boots, or outdoor shoes, do not attract me to anything like the + same degree, although I have, upon several occasions, enjoyed + myself fairly well by their use. Nude women repel me, and I find + no pleasure in seeing a woman in tights. I am not averse to + normal sexual connection and occasionally employ it. To me, + however, the pleasure is far inferior to that of being trampled + upon. I also derive keen pleasure—and usually have a strong + erection—from seeing a woman, dressed as I have described, tread + upon anything which yields under her foot—such as the seat of a + carriage, the cushions of a punt, a footstool, etc., and I enjoy + seeing her crush flowers by treading upon them. I have often + <a name='5_Page_35'></a>strolled along in the wake of some handsome lady at a picnic or + garden party, for the pleasure of seeing the grass upon which she + has trodden rise slowly again after her foot has pressed it. I + delight also to see a carriage sway as a woman leaves or enters + it—anything which needs the pressure of the foot.</p> + +<p> "To pass now to the origin of this direction of my feelings.</p> + +<p> "Even in early childhood I admired pretty feminine foot-gear, and + in the contemplation of it experienced vague sensations which I + now recognize as sexual. When a lad of 14 or so, I stayed a good + deal at the house of some intimate friends of my parents, the + daughter of the house—an only child—a beautiful and powerful + girl, about six years my senior, being my special chum. This girl + was always daintily dressed, and having most lovely feet and + ankles not unnaturally knew it. Whenever possible she dressed so + as to show off their beauty to the best advantage—rather short + skirts and usually little high-heeled slippers—and was not + averse to showing them in a most distractingly coquettish manner. + She seemed to have a passion for treading upon things which would + scrunch or yield under her foot, such as flowers, little + windfallen apples and pears, acorns, etc., or heaps of hay, straw + or cut grass. As we wandered about the gardens—for we were left + to do exactly as we liked—I got quite accustomed to seeing her + hunt out and tread upon such things, and used to chaff her about + it. At that time I was—as I am still—fond of lying at full + length on a thick hearthrug before a good fire. One evening as I + was lying in this way and we were alone, A. crossed the room to + reach a bangle from the mantelpiece. Instead of reaching over me, + she playfully stepped upon my body, saying that she would show me + how the hay and straw felt. Naturally I fell in with the joke and + laughed. After standing upon me a few moments she raised her + skirt slightly and, holding on to the mantelpiece for support, + stretched out one dainty foot in its brown silk stocking and + high-heeled slipper to the blaze to warm, while looking down and + laughing at my scarlet, excited face. She was a perfectly frank + and charming girl, and I feel pretty certain that, although she + evidently enjoyed my excitement and the feeling of my body + yielding under her feet, she did not on this first occasion + clearly understand my condition; nor can I remember that, though + the desire for sexual gratification drove me nearly mad, it + appeared to awaken in her any reciprocal feeling. I took hold of + her raised foot and, after kissing it, guided it by an absolutely + irresistible impulse on to my penis, which was as hard as wood + and seemed almost bursting. Almost at the moment that her weight + was thrown upon it, orgasm took place for the first time in my + life thoroughly and effectively. No description can give any idea + of what I felt—I only know that from that moment my distorted + sexual focus was fixed forever. Numberless times, after that + evening, I felt the weight of her dainty slippers, and nothing + will ever <a name='5_Page_36'></a>cause the memory of the pleasure she thus gave me to + fade. I know that A. came to enjoy treading upon me, as much as I + enjoyed having her do it. She had a liberal dress allowance and, + seeing the pleasure they gave me, she was always buying pretty + stockings and ravishing slippers with the highest and most + slender Louis heels she could find and would show them to me with + the greatest glee, urging me to lie down that she might try them + on me. She confessed that she loved to see and feel them sink + into my body as she trod upon me and enjoyed the crunch of the + muscles under her heel as she moved about. After some minutes of + this, I always guided her slipper on to my penis, and she would + tread carefully, but with her whole weight—probably about 9 + stone—and watch me with flashing eyes, flushed cheeks, and + quivering lips, as she felt—as she must have done plainly—the + throbbing and swelling of my penis under her foot as emission + took place. I have not the smallest doubt that orgasm took place + simultaneously with her, though we never at any time spoke openly + of it. This went on for several years on almost every favorable + opportunity we had, and after a month or two of separation + sometimes four or five times during a single day. Several times + during A.'s absence I masturbated by getting her slipper and + pressing it with all my strength against the penis while + imagining that she was treading upon me. The pleasure was, of + course, very inferior to her attentions. There was never at any + time between us any question of normal sexual intercourse, and we + were both well content to let things drift as they were.</p> + +<p> "A little after 20 I went abroad, and on my return about three + years later I found her married. Although we met often, the + subject was never alluded to, though we remained firm friends. I + confess I often, when I could do so without being seen, looked + longingly at her feet and would have gladly accepted the pleasure + she could have given me by an occasional resumption of our + strange practice—but it never came.</p> + +<p> "I went abroad again, and now neither she nor her husband are + alive and leave no issue. From time to time I have had occasional + relations with prostitutes, but always in this manner, though I + much prefer to find some lady of or above my own social position + who will do the treading for me. This is, however, interestingly + difficult.</p> + +<p> "Out of say a hundred women (which at home and abroad is what I + should estimate must have stood upon my body) I should say quite + 80 or 85 were <i>not</i> prostitutes. Certainly not more than 10 to 12 + shared any <i>sexual</i> excitement, but while they were evidently + excited they were not gratified. A. alone, so far as I know, had + complete sexual satisfaction of it. I have never asked a woman in + so many words to tread upon me for the purpose of gratifying my + sexual desires (prostitutes excepted), but have always tempted + them to do it in a jocular or teasing manner, and it is very + doubtful if more than a few (married) women <a name='5_Page_37'></a>really understood, + even after they had given me the extreme pleasure, that they had + done so, because any flushing and movement on my part under their + feet was not unnaturally put down to the trampling to which they + were subjecting me, and it was easy for me to guide the foot as + often as was necessary on to the penis till orgasm took place, + and even to keep it there by laying hold of the other one to kiss + it or on some other pretext during emission. Of course many + understood after once doing it (most have done it only once) what + I was at, and, although they did not ever discuss it nor did I, + they were not unwilling to give me as many treadings as I cared + to playfully suggest. I don't think they got any pleasure + sexually out of it themselves, though they could see plainly that + I did, and they did not object to give it me. I have spent as + long as twelve months with some women working gradually nearer + and nearer to my desire—often getting what I want in the end, + but more often failing. I <i>never</i> risk it till I am certain it + would be safe to ask it, and have never had a serious rebuff. In + very many cases I should say the doing of what I want has simply + been regarded by the woman as gratifying a silly and perhaps + amusing whim, in which, beyond the novelty of treading on a man's + body, she has taken but little interest.</p> + +<p> "As in normal seduction, the endeavor to win the woman over to do + what I want without arousing her antagonism is a great part of + the charm to me, and naturally the better her social position the + more difficult this becomes—and the more attractive. I have + found that in three instances prostitutes have performed the same + office for other men and knew all about it. It is not + uninteresting to note that these three women were all of fine, + massive build—one standing about 5 feet 10 inches and weighing + nearly 14 stone—but with comparatively uninteresting faces. The + weight, build and clothing count for a good deal in exciting me. + I find that a sudden check to a man at the supreme moment of + sexual pleasure tends to heighten and prolong the pleasure. My + physical satisfaction is due to the fact that by getting the lady + to stand with all her weight upon my penis (as it lies between + her foot and the soft bed of my own body into which it is deeply + pressed) the act of emission is enormously prolonged, with + corresponding enjoyment. For this reason also I prefer a very + high-heeled slipper. The seminal fluid has to be forced past two + separate obstacles—the pressure of the heel close at the root of + the penis and afterwards the ball of the foot which compresses + the outer half, leaving a free portion between them under the + arched sole of the slipper. I may add that the pleasure is + greatly increased by the retention of the urine, and I always try + to retain as much water as I dare. I have an unconquerable + aversion to red in slippers or stockings; it will even cause + impotence. Why, I know not. Strange as it may seem, although pain + and bruising are often inflicted <a name='5_Page_38'></a>by a severe treading, I have + never been in any way injured by the practice, and my pleasure in + it seems not to diminish by constant repetition. The comparative + difficulty of obtaining the pleasure from just the woman I want + has a never-ending, if inexplicable, charm for me."</p> + +<p> It will be observed that in this case special importance is + attached to shoes with high heels, and the subject considers that + the pressure of such shoes is for mechanical reasons most + favorable for procuring ejaculation. Nearly all heterosexual + shoe-fetichists seem, however, to be equally attracted by high + heels. Restif de la Bretonne frequently referred to this point, + and he gave a number of reasons for the attractiveness of high + heels: (1) They are unlike men's boots and, therefore, have a + sexual fascination; (2) they make the leg and foot look more + charming; (3) they give a less bold and more sylph-like character + to the walk; (4) they keep the feet clean. (Restif de la + Bretonne, <i>Nuits de Paris</i>, vol. v, quoted in Preface to his <i>Mes + Inscriptions</i>, p. ciii.) It is doubtless the first reason—the + fact that high heels are a kind of secondary sexual + character—which is most generally potent in this attraction.</p></div> + +<p>The foregoing history, while it very distinctly brings before us a case of +erotic symbolism, is not strictly an example of shoe-fetichism. The +symbolism is more complex. The focus of beauty in a desirable woman is +transferred and concentrated in the region below the knee; in that sense +we have foot-fetichism. But the act of coitus itself is also symbolically +transferred. Not only has the foot become the symbol of the vulva, but +trampling has become the symbol of coitus; intercourse takes place +symbolically <i>per pedem</i>. It is a result of this symbolization of the foot +and of trampling that all acts of treading take on a new and symbolical +sexual charm. The element of masochism—of pleasure in being a woman's +slave—is a parasitic growth; that is to say, it is not founded in the +subject's constitution, but chances to have found a favorable soil in the +special circumstances under which his sexual life developed. It is not +primary, but secondary, and remains an unimportant and merely occasional +element.</p> + +<p>It may be instructive to bring forward for comparison a case in which also +we have a symbolism involving boot-fetichism, but extending beyond it. In +this case there is a basis of inversion (as is not infrequent in erotic +symbolisms), but from the present point of view the psychological +significance of the case remains the same.</p><a name='5_Page_39'></a> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>A. N., aged 29, unmarried, healthy, though not robust, and without + any known hereditary taint. Has followed various avocations + without taking great interest in them, but has shown some + literary ability.</p> + +<p> "I am an Englishman," his own narrative runs, "the third of three + children. At my birth my father was 41 and my mother 34. My + mother died of cancer when I was 15. My father is still alive, a + reserved man, who still nurses his sorrow for his wife's death. I + have no reason to believe my parents anything but normal and + useful members of society. My sister is normal and happily + married. My brother I have reason to believe to be an invert.</p> + +<p> "A horoscope cast for me describes me in a way I think correct, + and so do my friends: 'A mild, obliging, gentle, amiable person, + with many fine traits of character; timid in nature, fond of + society, loving peace and quietude, delighting in warm and close + friendships. There is much that is firm, steadfast and + industrious, some self-love, a good deal of diplomacy, a little + that is subtle, or what is called finesse. You are reserved with + those you dislike. There is a serious and sad side to your + character; you are very thoughtful and contemplative when in + these moods. But you are not pessimistic. You have superior + abilities, for they are intuitively intellectual. There is a cold + reticence which restrains generous impulses and which inclines to + acquisitiveness; it will make you deliberate, inventive, adding + self-esteem, some vanity.'</p> + +<p> "At an early age I was left much alone in the nursery and there + contracted the habit of masturbation long before the age of + puberty. I use the word 'masturbation' for want of a better, + though it may not quite describe my case. I have never used my + hand to the penis. As far back as I can remember I have had what + a Frenchman has described as 'le fetichisme de la chaussure,' and + in those early days, before I was 6 years old, I would put on my + father's boots, taken from a cupboard at hand, and then tying or + strapping my legs together would produce an erection, and all the + pleasurable feelings experienced, I suppose, by means of + masturbation. I always did this secretly, but couldn't tell why. + I continued this practice on and off all my boyhood and youth. + When I discovered the first emission I was much surprised. I + always did this thing without loosening my trousers. As to how + these feelings arose I am totally unable to say. I can't remember + being without such feelings, and they seem to me perfectly + normal. The sight, or even thought, of high boots, or leggings, + especially if well polished or in patent leather, would set all + my sexual passions aflame, and does yet. As a boy my great desire + was to wear these things. A soldier in boots and spurs, a groom + in tops, or even an errand-boy in patent leather leggings, + fascinated me, and to this day, despite reason and everything + else. The sight of such things produced an erection. An emission + I could always produce by tightly tying my legs together, but + only when wearing boots, and preferably leggings, which when I + had pocket money<a name='5_Page_40'></a> I bought for this purpose. (At the present + moment I have five pairs in the house and two pairs of high + boots, quite unjustified by ordinary use.) This habit I lapse + into yet at times. The smell of leather affects me, but I never + know how far this may be due to association with boots; the smell + suggests the image. Restraint by a leather strap is more exciting + than by cords. Erotic dreams always take the form of restraint on + the limbs when booted.</p> + +<p> "Uniforms and liveries have a great temptation for me, but only + when of a tight-fitting nature and smart, as soldiers', grooms', + etc., but not sailors'; most powerfully when the person is in + boots or leggings and breeches.</p> + +<p> "I was a quiet, sensitive boy, taking no part in games or sports. + Have always been indifferent to them. I made few friends, but + didn't want them. The craving for friendship came much later, + after I was 21. I was a day boy at a private school, and never + had any conversation with any boy on sexual matters, though I was + dimly aware of much 'nastiness' about the school. I knew nothing + of sodomy. But all these things were repulsive to me, + notwithstanding my secret practices. I was a 'good boy.'</p> + +<p> "Up to the age of 21 I was perfectly satisfied with my own + society, something of a prig, fond of books and reading, etc. I + was and ever have been absolutely insensible to the influence of + the other sex. I am not a woman hater, and take intellectual + pleasure in the society of certain ladies, but they are nearly + all much older than myself. I have a strong repulsion from sexual + relations with women. I should not mind being married for the + sake of companionship and for the sake of having boys of my own. + But the sexual act would frighten me. I could not in my present + frame of mind go to bed with a woman. Yet I feel an immense envy + of my married friends in that they are able to give out, and find + satisfaction for, their affection in a way that is quite + impossible for me. I picture certain boys in the place of the + wife.</p> + +<p> "I am now only happy in the society of men younger than myself, + age 17 to (say) 23 or 24, youths with smooth faces, or first sign + of hair on lip, well groomed, slightly effeminate in feature, of + sympathetic, perhaps weak nature. I feel I want to help them, do + something for them, devote myself entirely to their welfare.</p> + +<p> "With such there is no fixed line between friendship and love. I + yearn for intimacy with particular friends, but never dare + express it. I find so many people object to any strong expression + of feeling that I dare not run the risk of appearing ridiculous + in the eyes of these desired intimates.</p> + +<p> "I have no desire for <i>pædicatio</i>, but the idea itself does not + repulse me or seem unnatural, though personally it repels me a + little. But I think this to be mere prejudice on my part, which + might be broken <a name='5_Page_41'></a>down if the loved person showed a willingness to + act a passive part. I should never dare to make an advance, + however.</p> + +<p> "I am restrained by moral and religious considerations from + making my real feelings known, and I feel I should sink in my own + estimation if I gave way, though my natural desire is to do so. + In the face of opportunities (not I mean of <i>pædicatio</i>, but of + expression of excessive affection, etc.), or what might be such, + I always fail to speak lest I should forfeit the esteem of the + other person. I have a feeling of surprise when any one I like + evinces a liking for me. I feel that those I love are + immeasurably my superiors, though my reason may tell me it is not + so. I would grovel at their feet, do anything to win a smile from + them, or to make them give me their company.</p> + +<p> "Ordinary bodily contact with the boy I love gives me most + exquisite pleasure, and I never lose an opportunity of bringing + such contact about when it can be done naturally. I feel an + immense desire to embrace, kiss, squeeze, etc., the person, to + generally maul him, and say nice things—the kind of things a man + usually says to a woman. A handshake, the mere presence of the + person, makes me happy and content.</p> + +<p> "I can say with the Albanian: 'If I find myself in the presence + of the beloved, I rest absorbed in gazing on him. Absent, I think + of nought but him. If the beloved unexpectedly appears I fall + into confusion. My heart beats faster. I have eyes and ears only + for the beloved.'</p> + +<p> "I feel that my capacity of affection is finer and more spiritual + than that which commonly subsists between persons of different + sexes. And so, while trying to fight my instincts by religion, I + find my natural feeling to be part of my religion, and its + highest expression. In this sense I can speak from experience in + my own case, and more especially in that of my brother, that what + you have said about philanthropic activity resulting from + repressed homosexuality is very true indeed. I can say with one + of your female cases: 'Love is to me a religion. The very nature + of my affection for my friends precludes the possibility of any + element entering into it which is not absolutely pure and + sacred.' I am, however, madly jealous. I want entire possession, + and I can't bear for a moment that any one I do not care for + should know the person I love.</p> + +<p> "I am never attracted by men older than myself. The youths who + attract me may be of any class, though preferably, I think, of a + class a little lower than myself. I am not quite sure of this, + however, as circumstances may have contributed more than + deliberate choice to bring certain youths under my notice. Those + who have exercised the most powerful influence on me have been an + Oxford undergraduate, a barber's assistant, and a plumber's + apprentice. Though naturally fond of intellectual society, I do + not ask for intellect in those I love. It goes for nothing. I + always prefer their company to that of the most educated persons. + This preference has alienated me to some extent from more refined + and educated circles that formerly I was intimate with.</p><a name='5_Page_42'></a> + +<p> "I have been led entirely out of my old habits by association + with younger friends, and now do things which before I should + never have dreamed of doing. My thoughts now are always with + certain youths, and if they speak of leaving the town, or in any + way talk of a future that I cannot share, I suffer horrid + sinkings of the heart and depression of spirits."</p></div> + +<p>This case, while it concerns a person of quite different temperament, with +a more innate predisposition to specific perversions, is yet in many +respects analogous to the previous case. There is boot-fetichism; nothing +is felt to be so attractive as the foot-gear, and there is also at the +same time more than this; there is the attraction of repression and +constraint developed into a sexual symbol. In C. P.'s case that symbolism +arises from the experience of an abnormal heterosexual relationship; in +A. N.'s case it is founded on auto-erotic experiences associated with +inversion; in both alike the entire symbolism has become diffused and +generalized.</p> + +<p>In the two cases just brought forward we have an erotic symbolism of act +founded on, and closely associated with, an erotic symbolism of object. It +may be instructive to bring forward another case in which no fetichistic +feeling toward an object can be traced, but an erotic symbolism still +clearly exists. In this case pain, even when self-inflicted, has acquired +a symbolic value as a stimulus to tumescence, without any element of +masochism. Such a case serves to indicate how the sexual attraction of +pain is really a special case of the erotic symbolism with which we are +here concerned.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>A. W., aged 50, a writer and lecturer, physically and mentally + energetic and enjoying good health. He is, however, very + emotional and of nervous temperament, but self-controlled. Though + physically well developed, the sexual organs are small. He is + married to an attractive woman, to whom he is much attached, and + has two healthy children.</p> + +<p> At 10 or 12 years of age he had a frequent desire to be whipped, + his parents never having struck him, and on one occasion he asked + a brother to go with him to the closet to get him to whip him on + the posterior; but on arrival he was too shy to make the request. + He did not recognize the cause of these desires, knowing nothing + of such things <a name='5_Page_43'></a>except from the misinformation of his + school-fellows' talk. As far as he can remember, he was an + entirely normal, healthy boy up to the age of about 15, when his + attention was arrested by an advertisement of a quack medicine + for the results of "youthful excesses."</p> + +<p> Being a city boy, he was unfamiliar with the coupling even of + animals, had never had a conscious erection and did not know of + frictional excitement. Experiment, however, resulted in an + orgasm, and, though believing that it was wicked or at least weak + and degrading, he indulged in masturbation at intervals, usually + about six times a month, and has continued even up to the + present.</p> + +<p> He had an abnormally small opening in the prepuce, making the + uncovering of the glans almost impossible. (At the age of about + 37, he himself slit the prepuce by three or four cuts of a + scissors at intervals of about ten days. This was followed by a + marked decrease in desire, especially as he shortly afterwards + learned the importance of local cleanliness.) While in college at + about the age of 19 he began to have nocturnal emissions + occasionally and once or twice a week when at stool. Alarmed by + these, he consulted a physician, who warned him of the danger, + gave him bromide and prescribed cold bathing of the parts, with a + hard, cool bed. These stopped the emissions.</p> + +<p> He never had connection with women until the age of about 25, and + then only three times until his marriage at 30 years of age, + being deterred partly by conscientious scruples, but more by + shyness and convention, and deriving very little pleasure from + these instances. Even since marriage he has derived more pleasure + from sexual excitement than from coitus, and can maintain + erection for as long as two hours.</p> + +<p> He has always been accustomed to torture himself in various + ingenious ways, nearly always connected with sex. He would burn + his skin deeply with red hot wire in inconspicuous places. These + and similar acts were generally followed by manual excitation + nearly always brought to a climax.</p> + +<p> He considers that he is attracted to refined and intellectual + women. But he is without very ardent desires, having several + times gone to bed with attractive women who stripped themselves + naked, but without attempting any sexual intercourse with them. + He became interested in the "Karezza" theory and has tried to + practice it with his wife, but could never entirely control the + emission.</p> + +<p> He has hired a masseur to whip him, as children are whipped, with + a heavy dog whip, which caused pleasurable excitement. During + this time he had relations with his wife generally about once a + week without any great ecstasy. She was cold and sexually slow, + owing to conventional sex repression and to an idea that the + whole thing was "like animals" and to fear of child-bearing, + usually necessitating the use of a cover or withdrawal. It was + only eight years after their marriage that she desired and + obtained a child. During these years he would often stick <a name='5_Page_44'></a>pins + through his mammæ and tie them together by a string round the + pins drawn so short as to cause great pain and then indulge + himself in the sexual act. He used strong wooden clips with a + tack fixed in them, so as to pierce and pinch the mammæ, and once + he drove a pin entirely through the penis itself, then obtaining + orgasm by friction. He was never able to get an automatic + emission in this way, though he often tried, not even by walking + briskly during an erection.</p></div> + +<p>In another class of cases a purely ideal symbolism may be present by means +of a fetich which acts as a powerful stimulus without itself being felt to +possess any attraction. A good illustration of this condition is furnished +by a case which has been communicated to me by a medical correspondent in +New Zealand.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>"The patient went out to South Africa as a trooper with the + contingent from New Zealand, throwing up a good position in an + office to do so. He had never had any trouble as regards + connection with women before going out to South Africa. While in + active service at the front he sustained a nasty fall from his + horse, breaking his leg. He was unconscious for four days, and + was then invalided down to Cape Town. Here he rapidly got well, + and his accustomed health returning to him he started having what + he terms 'a good time.' He repeatedly went to brothels, but was + unable to have more than a temporary erection, and no ejaculation + would take place. In one of these places he was in company with a + drunken trooper, who suggested that they should perform the + sexual act with their boots and spurs (only) on. My patient, who + was also drunk, readily assented, and to his surprise was enabled + to perform the act of copulation without any difficulty at all. + He has repeatedly tried since to perform the act without any + spurs, but is quite unable to do so; with the spurs he has no + difficulty at all in obtaining all the gratification he desires. + His general health is good. His mother was an extremely nervous + woman, and so is his sister. His father died when he was quite + young. His only other relation in the colony is a married sister, + who seems to enjoy vigorous health."</p></div> + +<p>The consideration of the cases here brought forward may suffice to show +that beyond those fetichisms which find their satisfaction in the +contemplation of a part of the body or a garment, there is a more subtle +symbolism. The foot is a center of force, an agent for exerting pressure, +and thus it furnishes a point of departure not alone for the merely static +sexual fetich, but for a dynamic erotic symbolization. The energy of its +movements <a name='5_Page_45'></a>becomes a substitute for the energy of the sexual organs +themselves in coitus, and exerts the same kind of fascination. The young +girl (page 35) "who seemed to have a passion for treading upon things +which would scrunch or yield under her foot," already possessed the germs +of an erotic symbolism which, under the influence of circumstances in +which she herself took an active part, developed into an adequate method +of sexual gratification.<a name='5_FNanchor_23'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_23'><sup>[23]</sup></a> The youth who was her partner learned, in the +same way, to find an erotic symbolism in all the pressure reactions of +attractive feminine feet, the swaying of a carriage beneath their weight, +the crushing of the flowers on which they tread, the slow rising of the +grass which they have pressed. Here we have a symbolism which is +altogether different from that fetichism which adores a definite object; +it is a dynamic symbolism finding its gratification in the spectacle of +movements which ideally recall the fundamental rhythm and pressure +reactions of the sexual process.</p> + +<p>We may trace a very similar erotic symbolism in an absolutely normal form. +The fascination of clothes in the lover's eyes is no doubt a complex +phenomenon, but in part it rests on the aptitudes of a woman's garments to +express vaguely a dynamic symbolism which must always remain indefinite +and elusive, and on that account always possess fascination. No one has so +acutely described this symbolism as Herrick, often an admirable +psychologist in matters of sexual attractiveness. Especially instructive +in this respect are his poems, "Delight in Disorder," "Upon Julia's +Clothes," and notably "Julia's Petticoat." "A sweet disorder in the +dress," he tells us, "kindles in clothes a wantonness;" it is not on the +garment itself, but on the <a name='5_Page_46'></a>character of its movement that he insists; on +the "erring lace," the "winning wave" of the "tempestuous petticoat;" he +speaks of the "liquefaction" of clothes, their "brave vibration each way +free," and of Julia's petticoat he remarks with a more specific symbolism +still,</p> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span>"Sometimes 'twould pant and sigh and heave,<br /></span> +<span class='i1'>As if to stir it scarce had leave;<br /></span> +<span class='i1'>But having got it, thereupon,<br /></span> +<span class='i1'>'Twould make a brave expansion."<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<p>In the play of the beloved woman's garment, he sees the whole process of +the central act of sex, with its repressions and expansions, and at the +sight is himself ready to "fall into a swoon."</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_13'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_13'>[13]</a><div class='note'><p> G. Stanley Hall, <i>Adolescence</i>, vol. ii, p. 113. It will be +noted that the hand does not appear among the parts of the body which are +normally of supreme interest. An interest in the hand is by no means +uncommon (it may be noted, for instance, in the course of History XII in +Appendix B to vol. iii of these <i>Studies</i>), but the hand does not possess +the mystery which envelops the foot, and hand-fetichism is very much less +frequent than foot-fetichism, while glove-fetichism is remarkably rare. An +interesting case of hand-fetichism, scarcely reaching morbid intensity, is +recorded by Binet, <i>Etudes de Psychologie Expérimentale</i>, pp. 13-19; and +see Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 214 <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_14'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_14'>[14]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Mémoires</i>, vol. i, Chapter VII.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_15'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_15'>[15]</a><div class='note'><p> Among leading English novelists Hardy shows an unusual but +by no means predominant interest in the feet and shoes of his heroines; +see, <i>e.g.</i>, the observations of the cobbler in <i>Under the Greenwood +Tree</i>, Chapter III. A chapter in Goethe's <i>Wahlverwandtschaften</i> (Part I, +Chapter II) contains an episode involving the charm of the foot and the +kissing of the beloved's shoe.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_16'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_16'>[16]</a><div class='note'><p> Schinz, "Philosophie des Conventions Sociales," <i>Revue +Philosophique</i>, June, 1903, p. 626. Mirabeau mentions in his <i>Erotika +Biblion</i> that modern Greek women sometimes use their feet to provoke +orgasm in their lovers. I may add that simultaneous mutual masturbation by +means of the feet is not unknown to-day, and I have been told by an +English shoe-fetichist that he at one time was accustomed to practice this +with a married lady (Brazilian)—she with slippers on and he without—who +derived gratification equal to his own.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_17'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_17'>[17]</a><div class='note'><p> Jacoby (<i>loc. cit.</i> pp. 796-7) gives a large number of +references to Ovid's works bearing on this point. "In reading him," he +remarks, "one is inclined to say that the psychology of the Romans was +closely allied to that of the Chinese."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_18'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_18'>[18]</a><div class='note'><p> R. Kleinpaul, <i>Sprache ohne Worte</i>, p. 308. See also Moll, +<i>Konträre Sexualempfindung</i>, third edition, pp. 306-308. Bloch brings +together many interesting references bearing on the ancient sexual and +religious symbolism of the shoe, <i>Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia +Sexualis</i>, Teil II, p. 324.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_19'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_19'>[19]</a><div class='note'><p> Jacoby (<i>loc. cit.</i> p. 797) appears to regard shoe-fetichism +as a true atavism: "The sexual adoration of feminine foot-gear," he +concludes, "perhaps the most enigmatic and certainly the most singular of +degenerative insanities, is thus merely a form of atavism, the return of +the degenerate to the very ancient and primitive psychology which we no +longer understand and are no longer capable of feeling."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_20'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_20'>[20]</a><div class='note'><p> Moll has reported in detail (<i>Untersuchungen über die Libido +Sexualis</i>, bd. i, Teil II, pp. 320-324) a case which both he and +Krafft-Ebing regard as illustrative of the connection between +boot-fetichism and masochism. It is essentially a case of masochism, +though manifesting itself almost exclusively in the desire to perform +humiliating acts in connection with the attractive person's boots.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_21'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_21'>[21]</a><div class='note'><p> Krafft-Ebing goes so far as to assert (<i>Psychopathia +Sexualis</i>, English translation of tenth edition, p. 174) that "when in +cases of shoe-fetichism the female shoe appears alone as the excitant of +sexual desire one is justified in presuming that masochistic motives have +remained latent.... Latent masochism may always be assumed as the +unconscious motive." In this way he hopelessly misinterprets some of his +own cases.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_22'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_22'>[22]</a><div class='note'><p> Krafft-Ebing goes so far as to assert (<i>Psychopathia +Sexualis</i>, English translation, pp. 159 and 174). Yet some of the cases he +brings forward (<i>e.g.</i>, Coxe's as quoted by Hammond) show no sign of +masochism, since, according to Krafft-Ebing's own definition (p. 116), the +idea of subjugation by the opposite sex is of the essence of masochism.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_23'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_23'>[23]</a><div class='note'><p> Her actions suggest that there is often a latent sexual +consciousness in regard to the feet in women, atavistic or +pseudo-atavistic, and corresponding to the sexual attraction which the +feet formerly aroused, almost normally, in men. This is also suggested by +the case, referred to by Shufeldt, of an unmarried woman, belonging to a +family exhibiting in a high degree both erotic and neurotic traits, who +had "a certain uncontrollable fascination for shoes. She delights in new +shoes, and changes her shoes all day long at regular intervals of three +hours each. She keeps this row of shoes out in plain sight in her +apartment." (R. W. Shufeldt, "On a Case of Female Impotency," 1896, p. +10.)</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_E_III'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_47'></a>III.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Scatalogic Symbolism—Urolagnia—Coprolagnia—The Ascetic Attitude Towards +the Flesh—Normal basis of Scatalogic Symbolism—Scatalogic Conceptions +Among Primitive Peoples—Urine as a Primitive Holy Water—Sacredness of +Animal Excreta—Scatalogy in Folk-lore—The Obscene as Derived from the +Mythological—The Immature Sexual Impulse Tends to Manifest Itself in +Scatalogic Forms—The basis of Physiological Connection Between the +Urinary and Genital Spheres—Urinary Fetichism Sometimes Normal in +Animals—The Urolagnia of Masochists—The Scatalogy of Saints—Urolagnia +More Often a Symbolism of Act Than a Symbolism of Object—Only +Occasionally an Olfactory Fetichism—Comparative Rarity of +Coprolagnia—Influence of Nates Fetichism as a Transition to +Coprolagnia—Ideal Coprolagnia—Olfactory Coprolagnia—Urolagnia and +Coprolagnia as Symbols of Coitus.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>We meet with another group of erotic symbolisms—alike symbolisms of +object and of act—in connection with the two functions adjoining the +anatomical sexual focus: the urinary and alvine excretory functions. These +are sometimes termed the scatalogical group, with the two subdivisions of +urolagnia and Coprolagnia.<a name='5_FNanchor_24'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_24'><sup>[24]</sup></a> <i>Inter fæces et urinam nascimur</i> is an +ancient text which has served the ascetic preachers of old for many +discourses on the littleness of man and the meanness of that reproductive +power which plays so large a part in man's life. "The stupid bungle of +Nature," a correspondent writes, "whereby the generative organs serve as a +means of relieving the bladder, is doubtless responsible for much of the +disgust which those organs excite in some minds."</p> + +<p>At the same time, it is necessary to point out, such reflex influence may +act not in one direction only, but also in the reverse <a name='5_Page_48'></a>direction. From +the standpoint of ascetic contemplation eager to belittle humanity, the +excretory centers may cast dishonor upon the genital center which they +adjoin. From the more ecstatic standpoint of the impassioned lover, eager +to magnify the charm of the woman he worships, it is not impossible for +the excretory centers to take on some charm from the irradiating center of +sex which they enclose.</p> + +<p>Even normally such a process is traceable. The normal lover may not +idealize the excretory functions of his mistress, but the fact that he +finds no repulsion in the most intimate contacts and feels no disgust at +the proximity of the excretory orifices or the existence of their +functions, indicates that the idealization of love has exerted at all +events a neutralizing influence; indeed, the presence of an acute +sensibility to the disturbing influence of this proximity of the excretory +orifices and their functions must be considered abnormal; Swift's +"Strephon and Chloe"—with the conviction underlying it that it is an easy +matter for the excretory functions to drown the possibilities of +love—could only have proceeded from a morbidly sensitive brain.<a name='5_FNanchor_25'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_25'><sup>[25]</sup></a></p> + +<p>A more than mere neutralizing influence, a positively idealizing influence +of the sexual focus on the excretory processes adjoining it, may take +place in the lover's mind without the normal variations of sexual +attraction being over-passed, and even without the creation of an +excretory fetichism.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Reflections of this attitude may be found in the poets. In the + <i>Song of Songs</i> the lover says of his mistress, "Thy navel is + like a round goblet, wherein no mingled wine is wanting;" in his + lyric "To Dianeme," Herrick says with clear reference to the mons veneris:—</p></div> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span class='i4'>"Show me that hill where smiling love doth sit,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>Having a living fountain under it;"<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>and in the very numerous poems in various languages which have + more <a name='5_Page_49'></a>or less obscurely dealt with the rose as the emblem of the + feminine pudenda there are occasional references to the stream + which guards or presides over the rose. It may, indeed, be + recalled that even in the name <i>nymphæ</i> anatomists commonly apply + to the <i>labia minora</i> there is generally believed to be a poetic + allusion to the Nymphs who presided over streams, since the + <i>labia minora</i> exert an influence on the direction of the urinary + stream.</p> + +<p> In <i>Wilhelm Meister</i> (Part I, Chapter XV), Goethe, on the basis + of his own personal experiences, describes his hero's emotions in + the humble surroundings of Marianne's little room as compared + with the stateliness and order of his own home. "It seemed to him + when he had here to remove her stays in order to reach the + harpsichord, there to lay her skirt on the bed before he could + seat himself, when she herself with unembarrassed frankness would + make no attempt to conceal from him many natural acts which + people are accustomed to hide from others out of decency—it + seemed to him, I say, that he became bound to her by invisible + bands." We are told of Wordsworth (Findlay's <i>Recollections of De + Quincey</i>, p. 36) that he read <i>Wilhelm Meister</i> till "he came to + the scene where the hero, in his mistress's bedroom, becomes + sentimental over her dirty towels, etc., which struck him with + such disgust that he flung the book out of his hand, would never + look at it again, and declared that surely no English lady would + ever read such a work." I have, however, heard a woman of high + intellectual distinction refer to the peculiar truth and beauty + of this very passage.</p> + +<p> In one of his latest novels, <i>Les Rencontres de M. de Bréot</i>, + Henri de Régnier, one of the most notable of recent French + novelists, narrates an episode bearing on the matter before us. A + personage of the story is sitting for a moment in a dark grotto + during a night fête in a nobleman's park, when two ladies enter + and laughingly proceed to raise their garments and accomplish a + natural necessity. The man in the background, suddenly overcome + by a sexual impulse, starts forward; one lady runs away, the + other, whom he detains, offers little resistance to his advances. + To M. de Bréot, whom he shortly after encounters, he exclaims, + abashed at his own actions: "Why did I not flee? But could I + imagine that the spectacle of so disgusting a function would have + any other effect than to give me a humble opinion of human + nature?" M. de Bréot, however, in proceeding to reproach his + interlocutor for his inconsiderate temerity, observes: "What you + tell me, sir, does not entirely surprise me. Nature has placed + very various instincts within us, and the impulse that led you to + what you have just now done is not so peculiar as you think. One + may be a very estimable man and yet love women even in what is + lowliest in their bodies." In harmony with this passage from + Régnier's novel are the remarks of a correspondent who writes to + me of the function of urination that it "appeals sexually to most + normal individuals. My own observations and inquiries prove this. + Women <a name='5_Page_50'></a>themselves instinctively feel it. The secrecy surrounding + the matter lends, too, I think, a sexual interest."</p> + +<p> The fact that scatalogic processes may in some degree exert an + attraction even in normal love has been especially emphasized by + Bloch (<i>Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, Teil + II, pp. 222, <i>et seq.</i>): "The man whose intellect and æsthetic + sense has been 'clouded by the sexual impulse' sees these things + in an entirely different light from him who has not been overcome + by the intoxication of love. For him they are idealized (sit + venia verbo) since they are a part of the beloved person, and in + consequence associated with love." Bloch quotes the <i>Memoiren + einer Sängerin</i> (a book which is said to be, though this seems + doubtful, genuinely autobiographical) in the same sense: "A man + who falls in love with a girl is not dragged out of his poetic + sphere by the thought that his beloved must relieve certain + natural necessities every day. It seems, indeed, to him to be + just the opposite. If one loves a person one finds nothing + obscene or disgusting in the object that pleases me." The + opposite attitude is probably in extreme cases due to the + influence of a neurotic or morbidly sensitive temperament. Swift + possessed such a temperament. The possession of a similar + temperament is doubtless responsible for the little prose poem, + "L'Extase," in which Huysmans in his first book, <i>Le Drageloir á + Epices</i>, has written an attenuated version of "Strephon and + Chloe" to express the disillusionment of love; the lover lies in + a wood clasping the hand of the beloved with rapturous emotion; + "suddenly she rose, disengaged her hand, disappeared in the + bushes, and I heard as it were the rustling of rain on the + leaves." His dream has fled.</p></div> + +<p>In estimating the significance of the lover's attitude in this matter, it +is important to realize the position which scatologic conceptions took in +primitive belief. At certain stages of early culture, when all the +emanations of the body are liable to possess mysterious magic properties +and become apt for sacred uses, the excretions, and especially the urine, +are found to form part of religious ritual and ceremonial function. Even +among savages the excreta are frequently regarded as disgusting, but under +the influence of these conceptions such disgust is inhibited, and those +emanations of the body which are usually least honored become religious +symbols.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Urine has been regarded as the original holy water, and many + customs which still survive in Italy and various parts of Europe, + involving the use of a fluid which must often be yellow and + sometimes salt, possibly indicate the earlier use of urine. (The + Greek water of aspersion, <a name='5_Page_51'></a>according to Theocritus, was mixed + with salt, as is sometimes the modern Italian holy water. J. J. + Blunt, <i>Vestiges of Ancient Manners and Customs</i>, p. 173.) Among + the Hottentots, as Kolbein and others have recorded, the medicine + man urinated alternately on bride and bridegroom, and a + successful young warrior was sprinkled in the same way. Mungo + Park mentions that in Africa on one occasion a bride sent a bowl + of her urine which was thrown over him as a special mark of honor + to a distinguished guest. Pennant remarked that the Highlanders + sprinkled their cattle with urine, as a kind of holy water, on + the first Monday in every quarter. (Bourke, <i>Scatalogic Rites</i>, + pp. 228, 239; Brand, <i>Popular Antiquities</i>, "Bride-Ales.")</p> + +<p> Even the excreta of animals have sometimes been counted sacred. + This is notably so in the case of the cow, of all animals the + most venerated by primitive peoples, and especially in India. + Jules Bois (<i>Visions de l'Inde</i>, p. 86) describes the spectacle + presented in the temple of the cows at Benares: "I put my head + into the opening of the holy stables. It was the largest of + temples, a splendor of precious stones and marble, where the + venerated heifers passed backwards and forwards. A whole people + adored them. They take no notice, plunged in their divine and + obscure unconsciousness. And they fulfil with serenity their + animal functions; they chew the offerings, drink water from + copper vessels, and when they are filled they relieve themselves. + Then a stercoraceous and religious insanity overcomes these + starry-faced women and venerable men; they fall on their knees, + prostrate themselves, eat the droppings, greedily drink the + liquid, which for them is miraculous and sacred." (<i>Cf.</i> Bourke, + <i>Scatalogic Rites</i>, Chapter XVII.)</p> + +<p> Among the Chevsurs of the Caucasus, perhaps an Iranian people, a + woman after her confinement, for which she lives apart, purifies + herself by washing in the urine of a cow and then returns home. + This mode of purification is recommended in the Avesta, and is + said to be used by the few remaining followers of this creed.</p></div> + +<p>We have not only to take into account the frequency with which among +primitive peoples the excretions possess a religious significance. It is +further to be noted that in the folk-lore of modern Europe we everywhere +find plentiful evidence of the earlier prevalence of legends and practices +of a scatalogical character. It is significant that in the majority of +cases it is easy to see a sexual reference in these stories and customs. +The legends have lost their earlier and often mythical significance, and +frequently take on a suggestion of obscenity, while the scatalogical +practices have become the magical devices of lovelorn maidens or forsaken +wives practiced in secrecy. It has happened <a name='5_Page_52'></a>to scatalogical rites to be +regarded as we may gather from the <i>Clouds</i> of Aristophanes, that the +sacred leathern phallus borne by the women in the Bacchanalia was becoming +in his time, an object to arouse the amusement of little boys.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Among many primitive peoples throughout the world, and among the + lower social classes of civilized peoples, urine possesses magic + properties, more especially, it would seem, the urine of women + and that of people who stand, or wish to stand, in sexual + relationship to each other. In a legend of the Indians of the + northwest coast of America, recorded by Boas, a woman gives her + lover some of her urine and says: "You can wake the dead if you + drop some of my urine in their ears and nose." (<i>Zeitschrift für + Ethnologie</i>, 1894, Heft IV, p. 293.) Among the same Indians there + is a legend of a woman with a beautiful white skin who found on + bathing every morning in the river that the fish were attracted + to her skin and could not be driven off even by magical + solutions. At last she said to herself: "I will make water on + them and then they will leave me alone." She did so, and + henceforth the fish left her. But shortly after fire came from + Heaven and killed her. (<i>Ib.</i>, 1891, Heft V, p. 640.) Among both + Christians and Mohammedans a wife can attach an unfaithful + husband by privately putting some of her urine in his drink. (B. + Stern, <i>Medizin in der Türkei</i>, vol. ii, p. 11.) This practice is + world-wide; thus among the aborigines of Brazil, according to + Martius, the urine and other excretions and secretions are potent + for aphrodisiacal objects. (Bourke's <i>Scatalogic Rites of All + Nations</i> contains many references to the folk-lore practices in + this matter; a study of popular beliefs in the magic power of + urine, published in Bombay by Professor Eugen Wilhelm in 1889, I + have not seen.)</p> + +<p> The legends which narrate scatalogic exploits are numerous in the + literature of all countries. Among primitive peoples they often + have a purely theological character, for in the popular + mythologies of all countries (even, as we learn from + Aristophanes, among the Greeks) natural phenomena such as the + rain, are apt to be regarded as divine excretions, but in course + of time the legends take on a more erotic or a more obscene + character. In the Irish <i>Book of Leinster</i> (written down + somewhere about the twelfth century, but containing material of + very much older date) we are told how a number of princesses in + Emain Macha, the seat of the Ulster Kings, resolved to find out + which of them could by urinating on it melt a snow pillar which + the men had made, the woman who succeeded to be regarded as the + best among them. None of them succeeded, and they sent for + Derbforgaill, who was in love with Cuchullain, and she was able + to melt the pillar; whereupon the other women, jealous of the + superiority she had thus shown, tore out her eyes. (Zimmer, + "Keltische Beiträge," <i>Zeitschrift für Deutsche Alterthum</i>, vol.<a name='5_Page_53'></a> + xxxii, Heft II, pp. 216-219.) Rhys considers that Derbforgaill + was really a goddess of dawn and dusk, "the drop glistening in + the sun's rays," as indicated by her name, which means a drop or + tear. (J. Rhys, <i>Lectures on the Origin and Growth of Religion as + Illustrated by Celtic Heathendom</i>, p. 466.) It is interesting to + compare the legend of Derbforgaill with a somewhat more modern + Picardy folk-lore <i>conte</i> which is clearly analogous but no + longer seems to show any mythologic element, "La Princesse qui + pisse par dessus les Meules." This princess had a habit of + urinating over hay-cocks; the king, her father, in order to break + her of the habit, offered her in marriage to anyone who could + make a hay-cock so high that she could not urinate over it. The + young men came, but the princess would merely laugh and at once + achieve the task. At last there came a young man who argued with + himself that she would not be able to perform this feat after she + had lost her virginity. He therefore seduced her first and she + then failed ignobly, merely wetting her stockings. Accordingly, + she became his bride. (Κρυπτάδια, vol. i. p. 333.) Such + legends, which have lost any mythologic elements they may + originally have possessed and have become merely <i>contes</i>, are + not uncommon in the folk-lore of many countries. But in their + earlier more religious forms and in their later more obscene + forms, they alike bear witness to the large place which + scatalogic conceptions play in the primitive mind.</p></div> + +<p>It is a notable fact in evidence of the close and seemingly normal +association with the sexual impulse of the scatalogic processes, that an +interest in them, arising naturally and spontaneously, is one of the most +frequent channels by which the sexual impulse first manifests itself in +young boys and girls.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Stanley Hall, who has made special inquiries into the matter, + remarks that in childhood the products of excretion by bladder + and bowels are often objects of interest hardly less intense for + a time than eating and drinking. ("Early Sense of Self," + <i>American Journal of Psychology</i>, April, 1898, p. 361.) + "Micturitional obscenities," the same writer observes again, + "which our returns show to be so common before adolescence, + culminate at 10 or 12, and seem to retreat into the background as + sex phenomena appear." They are, he remarks, of two classes: + "Fouling persons or things, secretly from adults, but openly with + each other," and less often "ceremonial acts connected with the + act or the product that almost suggest the scatalogical rites of + savages, unfit for description here, but of great interest and + importance." (G. Stanley Hall, <i>Adolescence</i>, vol. i, p. 116.) + The nature of such scatalogical phenomena in childhood—which are + often clearly the instinctive <a name='5_Page_54'></a>manifestations of an erotic + symbolism—and their wide prevalence among both boys and girls, + are very well illustrated in a narrative which I include in + Appendix B, History II.</p></div> + +<p>In boys as they approach the age of puberty, this attraction to the +scatalogic, when it exists, tends to die out, giving place to more normal +sexual conceptions, or at all events it takes a subordinate and less +serious place in the mind. In girls, on the other hand, it often tends to +persist. Edmond de Goncourt, a minute observer of the feminine mind, +refers in <i>Chérie</i> to "those innocent and triumphant gaieties which +scatalogic stories have the privilege of arousing in women who have +remained still children, even the most distinguished women." The extent to +which innocent young women, who would frequently be uninterested or +repelled in presence of the sexually obscene are sometimes attracted by +the scatalogically obscene, becomes intelligible, however, if we realize +that a symbolism comes here into play. In women the more specifically +sexual knowledge and experience of life frequently develop much later than +in men or even remains in abeyance, and the specifically sexual phenomena +cannot therefore easily lend themselves to wit, or humor, or imagination. +But the scatalogic sphere, by the very fact that in women it is a +specially intimate and secret region which is yet always liable to be +unexpectedly protruded into consciousness, furnishes an inexhaustible +field for situations which have the same character as those furnished by +the sexually obscene. It thus happens that the sexually obscene which in +men tends to overshadow the scatalogically obscene, in women—partly from +inexperience and partly, it is probable, from their almost physiological +modesty—plays a part subordinate to the scatalogical. In a somewhat +analogous way scatalogical wit and humor play a considerable part in the +work of various eminent authors who were clergymen or priests.</p> + +<p>In addition to the anatomical and psychological associations which +contribute to furnish a basis on which erotic symbolisms may spring up, +there are also physiological connections between the genital and urinary +spheres which directly favor such symbolisms. In discussing the analysis +of the sexual impulse <a name='5_Page_55'></a>in a previous volume of these <i>Studies</i>, I have +pointed out the remarkable relationship—sometimes of transference, +sometimes of compensation—which exists between genital tension and +vesical tension, both in men and women. In the histories of normal sexual +development brought together at the end of that and subsequent volumes the +relationship may frequently be traced, as also in the case of C. P. in the +present study (p. 37). Vesical power is also commonly believed to be in +relation with sexual potency, and the inability to project the urinary +stream in a normal manner is one of the accepted signs of sexual +impotency.<a name='5_FNanchor_26'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_26'><sup>[26]</sup></a> Féré, again, has recorded the history of a man with +periodic crises of sexual desire, and subsequently sexual obsession +without desire, which were always accompanied by the impulse to urinate +and by increased urination.<a name='5_FNanchor_27'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_27'><sup>[27]</sup></a> In the case, recorded by Pitres and Régis, +of a young girl who, having once at the sight of a young man she liked in +a theater been overcome by sexual feeling accompanied by a strong desire +to urinate, was afterward tormented by a groundless fear of experiencing +an irresistible desire to urinate at inconvenient times,<a name='5_FNanchor_28'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_28'><sup>[28]</sup></a> we have an +example of what may be called a physiological scatalogic symbolism of sex, +an emotion which was primarily erotic becoming transferred to the bladder +and then remaining persistent. From such a physiological symbolism it is +but a step to the psychological symbolisms of scatalogic fetichism.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It is worthy of note, as an indication that such phenomena are + scarcely abnormal, that a urinary symbolism, and even a strictly + sexual fetichism, are normal among many animals.</p><a name='5_Page_56'></a> + +<p> The most familiar example of this kind is furnished by the dog, + who is sexually excited in this manner by traces of the bitch and + himself takes every opportunity of making his own path + recognizable. "This custom," Espinas remarks (<i>Des Sociétés + Animales</i>, p. 228), "has no other aim than to spread along the + road recognizable traces of their presence for the benefit of + individuals of the other sex, the odor of these traces doubtless + causing excitement."</p> + +<p> It is noteworthy, also, that in animals as well as in man, sexual + excitement may manifest itself in the bladder. Thus Daumas states + (<i>Chevaux de Sahara</i>, p. 49) that if the mare urinates when she + hears the stallion neigh it is a sign that she is ready for + connection.</p></div> + +<p>It is in masochism, or passive algolagnia, that we may most frequently +find scatalogic symbolism in its fully developed form. The man whose +predominant impulse is to subjugate himself to his mistress and to receive +at her hands the utmost humiliation, frequently finds the climax of his +gratification in being urinated on by her, whether in actual fact or only +in imagination.</p> + +<p>In many such cases, however, it is evident that we have a mixed +phenomenon; the symbolism is double. The act becomes desirable because it +is the outward and visible sign of an inwardly experienced abject slavery +to an adored person. But it is also desirable because of intimately sexual +associations in the act itself, as a symbolical detumescence, a simulacrum +of the sexual act, and one which proceeds from the sexual focus itself.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Krafft-Ebing records various cases of masochism in which the + emission of urine on to the body or into the mouth formed the + climax of sexual gratification, as, for instance (<i>Psychopathia + Sexualis</i>, English translation, p. 183) in the case of a Russian + official who as a boy had fancies of being bound between the + thighs of a woman, compelled to sleep beneath her nates and to + drink her urine, and in later life experienced the greatest + excitement when practicing the last part of this early + imagination.</p> + +<p> In another case, recorded by Krafft-Ebing and by him termed + "ideal masochism" (<i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 127-130), the subject from + childhood indulged in voluptuous day-dreams in which he was the + slave of a beautiful mistress who would compel him to obey all + her caprices, stand over him with one foot on his breast, sit on + his face and body, make him <a name='5_Page_57'></a>wait on her in her bath, or when she + urinated, and sometimes insist on doing this on his face; though + a highly intellectual man, he was always too timid to attempt to + carry any of his ideas into execution; he had been troubled by + nocturnal enuresis up to the age of 20.</p> + +<p> Neri, again (<i>Archivio delle Psicopatie Sessuali</i>, vol. i, fasc. + 7 and 8, 1896), records the case of an Italian masochist who + experienced the greatest pleasure when both urination and + defecation were practiced in this manner by the woman he was + attached to.</p> + +<p> In a previous volume of these <i>Studies</i> ("Sexual Inversion," + History XXVI) I have recorded the masochistic day-dreams of a boy + whose impulses were at the same time inverted; in his reveries + "the central fact," he states, "became the discharge of urine + from my lover over my body and limbs, or, if I were very fond of + him, I let it be in my face." In actual life the act of urination + casually witnessed in childhood became the symbol, even the + reality, of the central secret of sex: "I stood rooted and + flushing with downcast eyes till the act was over, and was + conscious for a considerable time of stammering speech and + bewildered faculties.... I was overwhelmed with emotion and could + barely drag my feet from the spot or my eyes from the damp + herbage where he had deposited the waters of secrecy. Even to-day + I cannot dissociate myself from the shuddering charm that moment + had for me."</p></div> + +<p>It is not only the urine and the fæces which may thus acquire a symbolic +fascination and attractiveness under the influence of masochistic +deviations of sexual idealization. In some cases extreme rapture has been +experienced in licking sweating feet. There is, indeed, no excretion or +product of the body which has not been a source of ecstasy: the sweat from +every part of the body, the saliva and menstrual fluid, even the wax from +the ears.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Krafft-Ebing very truly points out (<i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, + English translation, p. 178) that this sexual scatalogic + symbolism is precisely paralleled by a religious scatalogic + symbolism. In the excesses of devout enthusiasm the ascetic + performs exactly the same acts as are performed in these excesses + of erotic enthusiasm. To mix excreta with the food, to lick up + excrement, to suck festering sores—all these and the like are + acts which holy and venerated women have performed.</p> + +<p> Not only the saint, but also the prophet and medicine-man have + been frequently eaters of human excrement; it is only necessary + to refer to the instance of the prophet Ezekiel, who declared + that he was commanded to bake his bread with human dung, and to + the practices of medicine-men at Torres Straits, in whose + training the eating of human excrement takes a recognized part. + (Deities, notably Baal-Phegor, were <a name='5_Page_58'></a>sometimes supposed to eat + excrement, so that it was natural that their messengers and + representatives among men should do so. As regards Baal-Phegor, + see Dulaure, <i>Des Divinités Génératrices</i>, Chapter IV, and J. G. + Bourke, <i>Scatalogic Rites of All Nations</i>, p. 241. See also + Ezekiel, Chapter IV, v. 12, and <i>Reports Anthropological + Expedition to Torres Straits</i>, vol. v, p. 321.)</p> + +<p> It must be added, however, that while the masochist is overcome + by sexual rapture, so that he sees nothing disgusting in his act, + the medicine-man and the ascetic are not so invariably overcome + by religious rapture, and several ascetic writers have referred + to the horror and disgust they experienced, at all events at + first, in accomplishing such acts, while the medicine-men when + novices sometimes find the ordeal too severe and have to abandon + their career. Brénier de Montmorand, while remarking, not without + some exaggeration, that "the Christian ascetics are almost all + eaters of excrement" ("Ascétisme et Mysticisme," <i>Revue + Philosophique</i>, March, 1904, p. 245), quotes the testimonies of + Marguerite-Marie and Madame Guyon as to the extreme repugnance + which they had to overcome. They were impelled by a merely + intellectual symbolism of self-mortification rather than by the + profoundly felt emotional symbolism which moves the masochist.</p> + +<p> Coprophagic acts, whether under the influences of religious + exaltation or of sexual rapture, inevitably excite our disgust. + We regard them as almost insane, fortified in that belief by the + undoubted fact that coprophagia is not uncommon among the insane. + It may, therefore, be proper to point out that it is not so very + long since the ingestion of human excrement was carried out by + our own forefathers in the most sane and deliberate manner. It + was administered by medical practitioners for a great number of + ailments, apparently with entirely satisfactory results. Less + than two centuries ago, Schurig, who so admirably gathered + together and arranged the medical lore of his own and the + immediately preceding ages, wrote a very long and detailed + chapter, "De Stercoris Humani Usu Medico" (<i>Chylologia</i>, 1725, + cap. XIII; in the Paris <i>Journal de Médecine</i> for February 19, + 1905, there appeared an article, which I have not seen, entitled + "Médicaments oubliées: l'urine et la fiente humaine.") The + classes of cases in which the drug was found beneficial would + seem to have been extremely various. It must not be supposed that + it was usually ingested in the crude form. A common method was to + take the fæces of boys, dry them, mix them with the best honey, + and administer an electuary. (At an earlier period such drugs + appear to have met with some opposition from the Church, which + seems to have seen in them only an application of magic; thus I + note that in Burchard's remarkable Penitential of the fourteenth + century, as reproduced by Wasserschleben, 40 days' penance is + prescribed for the use of human urine or excrement as a medicine. + Wasserschleben <i>Die Bussordnungen der Abendländlichen Kirche</i>, p. + 651.)</p></div><a name='5_Page_59'></a> + +<p>The urolagnia of masochism is not a simple phenomenon; it embodies a +double symbolism: on the one hand a symbolism of self-abnegation, such as +the ascetic feels, on the other hand a symbolism of transferred sexual +emotion. Krafft-Ebing was disposed to regard all cases in which a +scatalogical sexual attraction existed as due to "latent masochism." Such +a point of view is quite untenable. Certainly the connection is common, +but in the majority of cases of slightly marked scatalogical fetichism no +masochism is evident. And when we bear in mind the various considerations, +already brought forward, which show how widespread and clearly realized is +the natural and normal basis furnished for such symbolism, it becomes +quite unnecessary to invoke any aid from masochism. There is ample +evidence to show that, either as a habitual or more usually an occasional +act, the impulse to bestow a symbolic value on the act of urination in a +beloved person, is not extremely uncommon; it has been noted of men of +high intellectual distinction; it occurs in women as well as men; when +existing in only a slight degree, it must be regarded as within the normal +limits of variation of sexual emotion.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The occasional cases in which the urine is drunk may possibly + suggest that the motive lies in the properties of the fluid + acting on the system. Support for this supposition might be found + in the fact that urine actually does possess, apart altogether + from its magic virtues embodied in folk-lore, the properties of a + general stimulant. In composition (as Masterman first pointed + out) "beef-tea differs little from healthy urine," containing + exactly the same constituents, except that in beef-tea there is + less urea and uric acid. Fresh urine—more especially that of + children and young women—is taken as a medicine in nearly all + parts of the world for various disorders, such as epistaxis, + malaria and hysteria, with benefit, this benefit being almost + certainly due to its qualities as a general stimulant and + restorative. William Salmon's <i>Dispensatory</i>, 1678 (quoted in + <i>British Medical Journal</i>, April 21, 1900, p. 974), shows that in + the seventeenth century urine still occupied an important place + as a medicine, and it frequently entered largely into the + composition of Aqua Divina.</p> + +<p> Its use has been known even in England in the nineteenth century. + (Masterman, <i>Lancet</i>, October 2, 1880; R. Neale, "Urine as a + Medicine," <i>Practitioner</i>, November, 1881; Bourke brings together + a great deal of evidence as to the therapeutic uses of urine in + his <i>Scatalogic Rites</i>, <a name='5_Page_60'></a>especially pp. 331-335; Lusini has shown + that normal urine invariably increases the frequency of the heart + beats, <i>Archivio di Farmacologia</i>, fascs. 19-21, 1893.)</p> + +<p> But it is an error to suppose that these facts account for the + urolagnic drinking of urine. As in the gratification of a normal + sexual impulse, the intense excitement of gratifying a scatalogic + sexual impulse itself produces a degree of emotional stimulation + far greater than the ingestion of a small amount of animal + extractives would be adequate to effect. In such cases, as much + as in normal sexuality, the stimulation is clearly psychic.</p></div> + +<p>When, as is most commonly the case, it is the process of urination and not +the urine itself which is attractive, we are clearly concerned with a +symbolism of act and not with the fetichistic attraction of an excretion. +When the excretion, apart from the act, provides the attraction, we seem +usually to be in the presence of an olfactory fetichism. These fetichisms +connected with the excreta appear to be experienced chiefly by individuals +who are somewhat weak-minded, which is not necessarily the case in regard +to those persons for whom the act, rather than its product apart from the +beloved person, is the attractive symbol.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The sexually symbolic nature of the act of urination for many + people is indicated by the existence, according to Bloch, who + enumerates various kinds of indecent photographs, of a group + which he terms "the notorious <i>pisseuses</i>." It is further + indicated by several of the reproductions in Fuch's <i>Erotsiche + Element in der Karikatur</i>, such as Delorme's "La Necessitê n'a + point de Loi." (It should be added that such a scene by no means + necessarily possesses any erotic symbolism, as we may see in + Rembrandt's etching commonly called "Le Femme qui Pisse," in + which the reflected lights on the partly shadowed stream furnish + an artistic motive which is obviously free from any trace of + obscenity.) In the case which Krafft-Ebing quotes from Maschka of + a young man who would induce young girls to dance naked in his + room, to leap, and to urinate in his presence, whereupon seminal + ejaculation would take place, we have a typical example of + urolagnic symbolism in a form adequate to produce complete + gratification. A case in which the urolagnic form of scatalogic + symbolism reached its fullest development as a sexual perversion + has been described in Russia by Sukhanoff (summarized in + <i>Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, November, 1900, and + <i>Annales Medico-psychologiques</i>, February, 1901), that of a young + man of 27, of neuropathic temperament, who when he once chanced + to witness a <a name='5_Page_61'></a>woman urinating experienced voluptuous sensations. + From that moment he sought close contact with women urinating, + the maximum of gratification being reached when he could place + himself in such a position that a woman, in all innocence, would + urinate into his mouth. All his amorous adventures were concerned + with the search for opportunities for procuring this difficult + gratification. Closets in which he was able to hide, winter + weather and dull days he found most favorable to success. (A + somewhat similar case is recorded in the <i>Archives de + Neurologie</i>, 1902, p. 462.)</p> + +<p> In the case of a robust man of neuropathic heredity recorded by + Pelanda some light is shed on the psychic attitude in these + manifestations; there was masturbation up to the age of 16, when + he abandoned the practice, and up to the age of 30 found complete + satisfaction in drinking the still hot urine of women. When a + lady or girl in the house went to her room to satisfy a need of + this kind, she had hardly left it but he hastened in, overcome by + extreme excitement, culminating in spontaneous ejaculation. The + younger the woman the greater the transport he experienced. It is + noteworthy that in this, as possibly in all similar cases, there + was no sensory perversion and no morbid attraction of taste or + smell; he stated that the action of his senses was suspended by + his excitement, and that he was quite unable to perceive the odor + or taste of the fluid. (Pelanda, "Pornopatice," <i>Archivio di + Psichiatria</i>, facs. iii-iv, 1889, p. 356.) It is in the emotional + symbolism that the fascination lies and not in any sensory + perversion.</p> + +<p> Magnan records the spontaneous development of this sexual + symbolism in a girl of 11, of good intellectual development but + alcoholic heredity, who seduced a boy younger than herself to + mutual masturbation, and on one occasion, lying on the ground and + raising her clothes, asked him to urinate on her. (<i>International + Congress of Criminal Anthropology</i>, 1889.) This case (except for + the early age of the subject) illustrates sporadically occurring + urolagnic symbolism in a woman, to whom such symbolism is fairly + obvious on account of the close resemblance between the emission + of urine and the ejaculation of semen in the man, and the fact + that the same conduit serves for both fluids. (A urolagnic + day-dream of this kind is recorded in the history of a lady + contained in the third volume of these <i>Studies</i>, Appendix B, + History VIII.) The natural and inevitable character of this + symbolism is shown by the fact that among primitive peoples urine + is sometimes supposed to possess the fertilizing virtues of + semen. J. G. Frazer in his edition of Pausanias (vol. iv, p. 139) + brings together various stories of women impregnated by urine. + Hartland also (<i>Legend of Perseus</i>, vol. i, pp. 76, 92) records + legends of women who were impregnated by accidentally or + intentionally drinking urine.</p> + +<p> The symbolic sexual significance of urolagnia has hitherto + usually been confused with the fetichistic and mainly olfactory + perversion by <a name='5_Page_62'></a>which the excretion itself becomes a source of + sexual excitement. Long since Tardieu referred, under the name of + "renifleurs," to persons who were said to haunt the neighborhood + of quiet passages, more especially in the neighborhood of + theatres, and who when they perceived a woman emerge after + urination, would hasten to excite themselves by the odor of the + excretion. Possibly a fetichism of this kind existed in a case + recorded by Belletrud and Mercier (<i>Annales d'Hygiène Publique</i>, + June, 1904, p. 48). A weak-minded, timid youth, who was very + sexual but not attractive to women, would watch for women who + were about to urinate and immediately they had passed on would go + and lick the spot they had moistened, at the same time + masturbating. Such a fetichistic perversion is strictly analogous + to the fetichism by which women's handkerchiefs, aprons or + underlinen become capable of affording sexual gratification. A + very complete case of such urolagnic fetichism—complete because + separated from association with the person accomplishing the act + of urination—has been recorded by Moraglia in a woman. It is the + case of a beautiful and attractive young woman of 18, with thick + black hair, and expressive vivacious eyes, but sallow complexion. + Married a year previously, but childless, she experienced a + certain amount of pleasure in coitus, but she preferred + masturbation, and frankly acknowledged that she was highly + excited by the odor of fermented urine. So strong was this + fetichism that when, for instance, she passed a street urinal she + was often obliged to go aside and masturbate; once she went for + this purpose into the urinal itself and was almost discovered in + the act, and on another occasion into a church. Her perversion + caused her much worry because of the fear of detection. She + preferred, when she could, to obtain a bottle of urine—which + must be stale and a man's (this, she said, she could detect by + the smell)—and to shut herself up in her own room, holding the + bottle in one hand and repeatedly masturbating with the other. + (Moraglia, "Psicopatie Sessuali," <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, vol. + xiii, fasc. 6, p. 267, 1892.) This case is of especial interest + because of the great rarity of fully developed fetichism in + women. In a slight and germinal degree I believe that cases of + fetichism are not uncommon in women, but they are certainly rare + in a well-marked form, and Krafft-Ebing declared, even in the + late editions of his <i>Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, that he knew of no + cases in women.</p></div> + +<p>So far we have been concerned with the urolagnic rather than the +coprolagnic variety of scatalogical symbolism. Although the two are +sometimes associated there is no necessary connection, and most usually +there is no tendency for the one to involve the other. Urolagnia is +certainly much the more frequently found; the act of urination is far more +apt to suggest <a name='5_Page_63'></a>erotically symbolical ideas than the idea of defecation. +It is not difficult to understand why this should be so. The act of +urination lends itself more easily to sexual symbolism; it is more +intimately associated with the genital function; its repetition is +necessary at more frequent intervals so that it is more in evidence; +moreover, its product, unlike that of the act of defecation, is not +offensive to the senses. Still coprolagnia occurs and not so very +infrequently. Burton remarked that even the normal lover is affected by +this feeling: "immo nec ipsum amicæ stercus foctet."<a name='5_FNanchor_29'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_29'><sup>[29]</sup></a></p> + +<p>Of Caligula who, however, was scarcely sane, it was said "et quidem +stercus uxoris degustavit."<a name='5_FNanchor_30'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_30'><sup>[30]</sup></a> In Parisian brothels (according to Taxil +and others) provision is made for those who are sexually excited by the +spectacle of the act of defecation (without reference to contact or odor) +by means of a "tabouret de verre," from under the glass floor of which the +spectacle of the defecating women may be closely observed. It may be added +that the erotic nature of such a spectacle is referred to in the Marquis +de Sade's novels.</p> + +<p>There is one motive for the existence of coprolagnia which must not be +passed over, because it has doubtless frequently served as a mode of +transition to what, taken by itself, may well seem the least æsthetically +attractive of erotic symbols. I refer to the tendency of the nates to +become a sexual fetich. The nates have in all ages and in all parts of the +world been frequently regarded as one of the most æsthetically beautiful +parts of the feminine body.<a name='5_FNanchor_31'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_31'><sup>[31]</sup></a> It is probable that on the basis of this +entirely normal attraction more than one form of erotic symbolism <a name='5_Page_64'></a>is at +all events in part supported. Dühren and others have considered that the +æsthetic charm of the nates is one of the motives which prompt the desire +to inflict flagellation on women. In the same way—certainly in some and +probably in many cases—the sexual charm of the nates progressively +extends to the anal region, to the act of defecation, and finally to the +feces.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In a case of Krafft-Ebing's (<i>Op. cit.</i>, p. 183) the subject, + when a child of 6, accidentally placed his hand in contact with + the nates of the little girl who sat next to him in school, and + experienced so great a pleasure in this contact that he + frequently repeated it; when he was 10 a nursery governess, to + gratify her own desires, placed his finger in her vagina; in + adult life he developed urolagnic tendencies.</p> + +<p> In a case of Moll's the development of a youthful admiration for + the nates in a coprolagnic direction may be clearly traced. In + this case a young man, a merchant, in a good position, sought to + come in contact with women defecating; and with this object would + seek to conceal himself in closets; the excretal odor was + pleasurable to him, but was not essential to gratification, and + the sight of the nates was also exciting and at the same time not + essential to gratification; the act of defecation appears, + however, to have been regarded as essential. He never sought to + witness prostitutes in this situation; he was only attracted to + young, pretty and innocent women. The coprolagnia here, however, + had its source in a childish impression of admiration for the + nates. When 5 or 6 years old he crawled under the clothes of a + servant girl, his face coming in contact with her nates, an + impression that remained associated in his mind with pleasure. + Three or four years later he used to experience much pleasure + when a young girl cousin sat on his face; thus was strengthened + an association which developed naturally into coprolagnia. (Moll, + <i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. 837.)</p> + +<p> It is scarcely necessary to remark that an admiration for the + nates, even when reaching a fetichistic degree, by no means + necessarily involves, even after many years, any attraction to + the excreta. A correspondent for whom the nates have constituted + a fetich for many years writes: "I find my craving for women with + profuse pelvic or posterior development is growing and I wish to + copulate from behind; but I would feel a sickening feeling if any + part of my person came in contact with the female anus. It is + more pleasing to me to see the nates than the mons, yet I loathe + everything associated with the anal region."</p></div> + +<p>Moll has recorded in detail a case of what may be described as "ideal +coprolagnia"—that is to say, where the symbolism, <a name='5_Page_65'></a>though fully developed +in imagination, was not carried into real life—which is of great interest +because it shows how, in a very intelligent subject, the deviated +symbolism may become highly developed and irradiate all the views of life +in the same way as the normal impulse. (The subject's desires were also +inverted, but from the present point of view the psychological interest of +the case is not thereby impaired.) Moll's case was one of symbolism of +act, the excreta offering no attraction apart from the process of +defecation. In a case which has been communicated to me there was, on the +other hand, an olfactory fetichistic attraction to the excreta even in the +absence of the person.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In Moll's case, the patient, X., 23 years of age, belongs to a + family which he himself describes as nervous. His mother, who is + anæmic, has long suffered from almost periodical attacks of + excitement, weakness, syncope and palpitation. A brother of the + mother died in a lunatic asylum, and several other brothers + complain much of their nerves. The mother's sisters are very + good-natured, but liable to break out in furious passions; this + they inherit from their father. There appears to be no nervous + disease on the patient's father's side. X.'s sisters are also + healthy.</p> + +<p> X. himself is of powerful undersized build and enjoys good + health, injured by no excesses. He considers himself nervous. He + worked hard at school and was always the first in his class; he + adds, however, that this is due less to his own abilities than + the laziness of his school-fellows. He is, as he remarks, very + religious and prays frequently, but seldom goes to church.</p> + +<p> In regard to his psychic characters he says that he has no + specially prominent talent, but is much interested in languages, + mathematics, physics and philosophy, in fact, in abstract + subjects generally. "While I take a lively interest in every kind + of intellectual work," he says, "it is only recently that I have + been attracted to real life and its requirements. I have never + had much skill in physical exercises. For external things until + recently I have only had contempt. I have a delicately + constituted nature, loving solitude, and only associating with a + few select persons. I have a decided taste for fiction, poetry + and music; my temperament is idealistic and religious, with + strict conceptions of duty and morality, and aspirations towards + the good and beautiful. I detest all that is common and coarse, + and yet I can think and act in the way you will learn from the + following pages."</p> + +<p> Regarding his sexual life, X. made the following communication: + "During the last two years I have become convinced of the + perversion of my sexual instinct. I had often previously thought + that in <a name='5_Page_66'></a>me the impulse was not quite normal, but it is only + lately that I have become convinced of my complete perversion. I + have never read or heard of any case in which the sexual feelings + were of the same kind. Although I can feel a lively inclination + towards superior representatives of the female sex, and have + twice felt something like love, the sight or the recollection + even of a beautiful woman have never caused sexual excitement." + In the two exceptional instances mentioned it appears that X. had + an inclination to kiss the women in question, but that the + thought of coitus had no attraction. "In my voluptuous dreams, + connected with the emission of semen, women in seductive + situations have never appeared. I have never had any desire to + visit a <i>puella publica</i>. The love-stories of my fellow-students + seemed very silly, dances and balls were a horror to me, and only + on very rare occasions could I be persuaded to go into society. + It will be easy to guess the diagnosis in my case: I suffer from + the sexual attraction of my own sex, I am a lover of boys.</p> + +<p> "You cannot imagine what a world of thoughts, wishes, feelings + and impulses the words 'knabe,' 'παις,' 'garcon,' 'boy,' + 'ragazzo' have for me; one of these words, even in an unmeaning + clause of a translation-book, calls before me the whole sum of + associations which in course of time have become bound up with + this idea, and it is only with an effort that I can scare away + the wild band. This group of thoughts shows a wonderful mixture + of warm sensuality and ideal love, it unites my lowest and + highest impulses, the strength and the weakness of my nature, my + curse and my blessing. My inclination is especially towards boys + of the age of 12 to 15; though they may be rather younger or + older. That I should prefer beautiful and intelligent boys is + comprehensible. I do not want a prostitute, but a friend or a + son, whose soul I love, whom I can help to become a more perfect + man, such as I myself would willingly be.</p> + +<p> "When I myself belonged to that happy age (<i>i.e.</i>, below 15) I + had no dearer wish than to possess a friend of similar tastes. I + have sought, hoped, waited, grieved, and been at last + disillusioned, overcome by desire and despair, and have not found + that friend. Even later the hope often reappeared, but always in + vain, and I cannot boast of that sure recognition which one reads + of in the autobiographies of Urnings. I do not know personally a + single fellow-sufferer. It is also doubtful whether such an + acquaintanceship would greatly help me, for I have a very + peculiar conception of homosexuality. As you will see, I have + little more in common with what are called pæderasts than sexual + indifference to the female sex, and I often ask myself: 'Does any + other man in the whole world feel like you? Are you alone in the + earth with your morbid desires? Are you a pariah of pariahs, or + is there, perhaps, another soul with similar longings living near + you? How often in summer have I gone to the lakes and streams + outside cities to seek boys bathing; but I always came back + unsatisfied, whether I found any or not. And <a name='5_Page_67'></a>in winter I have + been irresistibly impelled to return to the same spots, as if it + were sanctified by the boys, but my darlings had vanished and + cold winds blew over the icy floods, so that I would return + feeling as though I had buried all my happiness.</p> + +<p> "It must be borne in mind, therefore, that what I have to say + regarding my sexual impulses only refers to fancies and never to + their practical realization. My sensual impulses are not + connected with the sexual organs; all my voluptuous ideas are not + in the least connected with these parts. For this reason I have + never practiced onanism and <i>immissio membri in anum</i> is as + repulsive to me as to a normal man. Even every imitation of + coitus is, for me, without attraction. In a boy's body two things + specially excite me: <i>his belly and his nates</i>, the first as + containing the digestive tract, the second as holding the opening + of the bowels. Of the vegetable processes of life in the boy none + interest me nearly so much as the progress of his digestion and + the process of defecation. It is incredible to what an extent + this part of physiology has occupied me from youth. If as a boy I + wanted to read something of a piquantly exciting character I + sought in my father's encyclopædia for articles like: + Obstruction, Constipation, Hæmorrhoids, Fæces, etc. No function + of the body seemed to be so significant as this, and I regarded + its disturbances as the most important in the whole mechanism of + life. The description of other disorders I could read in cold + blood, but intussusception of the bowels makes me ill even + to-day. I am always extremely pleased to hear that the digestion + of the people around me is in good condition. A man who did not + sufficiently watch over his digestion aroused distrust in me, and + I imagined that wicked men must be horribly indifferent regarding + this weighty matter. Even more than in ordinary persons was I + interested in the digestion of more mysterious beings, like + magicians in legends, or men of other nations. I would willingly + have made an anthropological study of my favorite subject, only + to my annoyance books nearly always pass over the matter in + silence. In history and fiction I regretted the absence of + information concerning the state of my heroes' digestion when + they languished in prison or in some unaccustomed or unhealthy + spot. For this reason I held no book more precious than one which + describes how a young man after being shipwrecked lived for a + long time in a narrow snow-hut, and it was conscientiously stated + that he became aware of digestive disturbances. No immorality + angers me more than the foolish practice of ladies who in society + neglect the satisfaction of their natural needs from misplaced + motives of modesty. On a railway journey I suffer horribly from + the thought that one of my fellow-travelers may be prevented from + fulfilling some imperative natural necessity.</p> + +<p> "I naturally devote the greatest attention to my own digestion. + With painful conscientiousness I go to stool every day at the + same <a name='5_Page_68'></a>hour; if the operation does not come off to my satisfaction + I feel not so much physical as mental discomfort. To this quite + useful hygienic interest became associated at puberty a sensual + interest. Since my fourteenth year I have had no greater + enjoyment than to defecate undressed (I do not do so now) after + having first carefully examined the distension of my abdomen. In + summer I would go into the woods, undress myself in a secluded + spot and indulge in the voluptuous pleasures of defecation. I + would sometimes combine with this a bath in a stream. I would + exhaust my imagination in the effort to invent specially + enjoyable variations, longed for a desert island where I could go + about naked, fill my body with much nourishing food, hold in the + excrement as long as possible and then discharge it in some + subtly-thought-out spot. These practices and ideas often caused + erections and later on emissions, but the genitals played no part + in my conceptions; their movements were uncomfortable and gave no + pleasure.</p> + +<p> "I soon longed to be associated in these orgies with some boy of + the same age, but I wanted not only a companion in my passion, + but also a real friend. Since there could be no question of + masturbation or pæderasty, our love would have been limited to + kisses, embraces, and—as a compensation for coitus—defecation + together. That would have been perfect bliss to me. I will spare + you the unæsthetic contents of my voluptuous dreams. But I + remained without a companion, and, therefore, without real + enjoyment. [He has, however, on various occasions experienced + erections, and even emissions, on seeing, by chance, men or boys + defecate.] Hinc illæ lacrimæ; the excitement over my own + defecation only took place <i>faute de mieux</i>.</p> + +<p> "I knew very well that my thoughts and practices were impure and + contemptible. Ah! how often, when the intoxication was over, have + I thrown myself remorsefully on my knees, praying to God for + pardon! For some weeks I repressed my longing; but at last it was + too strong for me, I tried to justify myself and fell into my + vice anew. That I was guilty of licentiousness and loved boys + sexually first became clear to me later on, when I knew the + significance of erection as a sign of sexual excitement.</p> + +<p> "No one can imagine with what demoniacal joy I am possessed at + the thought of a beautiful naked boy whose abdomen is filled as + the result of long abstinence from stool. The thought powerfully + excites me, a flood of passion goes through my blood and my limbs + tremble. I would never grow tired of feeling that belly and + looking at it. My passion would express itself in tempestuous + caresses, and the boy would have to assume various positions in + order to show off the beauty of his form, <i>i.e.</i>, to bring the + parts in question into better view. To observe defecation would + still further increase this peculiar enjoyment. If the boy's + bowels were not sufficiently filled I would feed him with all + sorts <a name='5_Page_69'></a>of food which produces much excrement, such as potatoes, + coarse bread, etc. If possible I would seek to delay defecation + for two or three days, so that it might be as copious as + possible. When at last it occurred it would be an unspeakable joy + for me to watch the fæces—which would have to be fairly + firm—emerging from the anus."</p> + +<p> X. would like to be a teacher and thinks he could exert a + beneficial influence on boys. In spite of the pain he has + suffered he does not think he would like to be cured of his + perverse inclinations, for they have given him joy as well as + pain, and the pain has chiefly been owing to the fact that he + could not gratify his inclinations. X. smokes and drinks in + moderation, and has no feminine habits. (The foregoing is a + condensed summary of the case which is fully reported by Moll, + <i>Konträre Sexualempfindung</i>, third edition, pp. 295-305.)</p> + +<p> The case of coprolagnia communicated to me is that of a married + man, normal in all other respects, intellectually brilliant and + filling successfully a very responsible position. When a child + the women of his household were always indifferent as to his + presence in their bedrooms, and would satisfy all natural calls + without reserve before him. He would dream of this with + erections. His sexual interests became slowly centered in the act + of defecation, and this fetich throughout life never appealed to + him so powerfully as when associated with the particular type of + household furniture which was used for this purpose in his own + house. The act of defecation in the opposite sex or anything + pertaining to or suggesting the same caused uncontrollable sexual + excitement; the nates also exerted a great attraction. The alvine + excreta exerted this influence even in the absence of the woman; + it was, however, necessary that she should be a sexually + desirable person. The perversion in this case was not complete; + that is to say, that the excitement produced by the act of + defecation or the excretion itself was not actually preferred to + coitus; the sexual idea was normal coitus in the normal manner, + but preceded by the visual and olfactory enjoyment of the + exciting fetich. When coitus was not possible the enjoyment of + the fetich was accompanied by masturbation (as in the analogous + case of urolagnia in a woman summarized on p. 62.) On one + occasion he was discovered by a friend in a bedroom belonging to + a woman, engaged in the act of masturbation over a vessel + containing the desired fetich. In an agony of shame he begged the + mercy of silence concerning this episode, at the same time + revealing his life-history. He has constantly been haunted by the + dread of detection, as well as by remorse and the consciousness + of degradation, also by the fear that his unconquerable obsession + may lead him to the asylum.</p></div> + +<p>The scatalogic groups of sexual perversions, urolagnia and coprolagnia, as +may be sufficiently seen in this brief summary, <a name='5_Page_70'></a>are not merely olfactory +fetiches. They are, in a larger proportion of cases, dynamic symbols, a +preoccupation with physiological acts which, by associations of contiguity +and still more of resemblance, have gained the virtue of stimulating in +slight cases, and replacing in more extreme cases, the normal +preoccupation with the central physiological act itself. We have seen that +there are various considerations which amply suffice to furnish a basis +for such associations. And when we reflect that in the popular mind, and +to some extent in actual fact, the sexual act itself is, like urination +and defecation, an excretory act, we can understand that the true +excretory acts may easily become symbols of the pseudo-excretory act. It +is, indeed, in the muscular release of accumulated pressures and tensions, +involved by the act of liberating the stored-up excretion, that we have +the closest simulacrum of the tumescence and detumescence of the sexual +process.<a name='5_FNanchor_32'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_32'><sup>[32]</sup></a></p> + +<p>In this way the erotic symbolism of urolagnia and coprolagnia is +completely analogous with that dynamic symbolism of the clinging and +swinging garments which Herrick has so accurately described, with the +complex symbolism of flagellation and its play of the rod against the +blushing and trembling nates, with the symbols of sexual strain and stress +which are embodied in the foot and the act of treading.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_24'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_24'>[24]</a><div class='note'><p> Fuchs (<i>Das Erotische Element In der Karikatur</i>, p. 26), +distinguishing sharply between the "erotic" and the "obscene," reserves +the latter term exclusively for the representation of excretory organs and +acts. He considers that this is etymologically the most exact usage. +However that may be, it seems to me that, in any case, "obscene" has +become so vague a term that it is now impracticable to give it a +restricted and precise sense.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_25'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_25'>[25]</a><div class='note'><p> In this connection we may profitably contemplate the hand +and recall the vast gamut of functions, sacred and profane, which that +organ exercises. Many savages strictly reserve the left hand to the +lowlier purposes of life; but in civilization that is not considered +necessary, and it may be wholesome for some of us to meditate on the more +humble uses of the same hand which is raised in the supreme gesture of +benediction and which men have often counted it a privilege to kiss.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_26'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_26'>[26]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, Morselli, <i>Una Causa di Nullità del +Matrimonio</i>, 1902, p. 39.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_27'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_27'>[27]</a><div class='note'><p> Féré, <i>Comptes-Rendus Société de Biologie</i>, July 23, 1904.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_28'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_28'>[28]</a><div class='note'><p> Transactions of the International Medical Congress, Moscow, +vol. iv, p. 19. A similar symbolism may be traced in many of the cases in +which the focus of modesty becomes in modest women centered in the +excretory sphere and sometimes exaggerated to the extent of obsession. It +must not be supposed, however, that every obsession in this sphere has a +symbolical value of an erotic kind. In the case, for instance, which has +been recorded by Raymond and Janet (<i>Les Obsessions</i>, vol. ii, p. 306) of +a woman who spent much of her time in the endeavor to urinate perfectly, +always feeling that she failed in some respect, the obsession seems to +have risen fortuitously on a somewhat neurotic basis without reference to +the sexual life.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_29'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_29'>[29]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Anatomy of Melancholy</i>, Part III, Section II, Mem. III, +Subs. I.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_30'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_30'>[30]</a><div class='note'><p> It may be remarked here that while the eating of excrement +(apart from its former use as a magic charm and as a therapeutic agent) is +in civilization now confined to sexual perverts and the insane, among some +animals it is normal as a measure of hygiene in relation to their young. +Thus, as, <i>e.g.</i>, the Rev. Arthur East writes, the mistle thrush swallows +the droppings of its young. (<i>Knowledge</i>, June 1, 1899, p. 133.) In the +dog I have observed that the bitch licks her puppies shortly after birth +as they urinate, absorbing the fluid.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_31'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_31'>[31]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, the previous volume of these <i>Studies</i>, "Sexual +Selection in Man," pp. 165 <i>et seq.</i>, and Dühren, <i>Geschlechtsleben in +England</i>, bd. ii, pp. 258, <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_32'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_32'>[32]</a><div class='note'><p> In the study of <i>Love and Pain</i> in a previous volume (p. +130) I have quoted the remarks of a lady who refers to the analogy between +sexual tension and vesical tension—"Cette volupté que ressentent les +bords de la mer, d'être toujours pleins sans jamais déborder"—and its +erotic significance.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_E_IV'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_71'></a>IV.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Animals as Sources of Erotic Symbolism—Mixoscopic Zoophilia—The +Stuff-fetichisms—Hair-fetichism—The Stuff-fetichisms Mainly on a Tactile +Base—Erotic Zoophilia—Zooerastia—Bestiality—The Conditions that Favor +Bestiality—Its Wide Prevalence Among Primitive Peoples and Among +Peasants—The Primitive Conception of Animals—The Goat—The Influence of +Familiarity with Animals—Congress Between Women and Animals—The Social +Reaction Against Bestiality.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>The erotic symbols with which we have so far been concerned have in every +case been portions of the body, or its physiological processes, or at +least the garments which it has endowed with life. The association on +which the symbol has arisen has in every case been in large measure, +although not entirely, an association of contiguity. It is now necessary +to touch on a group of sexual symbols in which the association of +contiguity with the human body is absent: the various methods by which +animals or animal products or the sight of animal copulation may arouse +sexual desire in human persons. Here we encounter a symbolism mainly +founded on association by resemblance; the animal sexual act recalls the +human sexual act; the animal becomes the symbol of the human being.</p> + +<p>The group of phenomena we are here concerned with includes several +subdivisions. There is first the more or less sexual pleasure sometimes +experienced, especially by young persons, in the sight of copulating +animals. This I would propose to call Mixoscopic Zoophilia; it falls +within the range of normal variation. Then we have the cases in which the +contact of animals, stroking, etc., produces sexual excitement or +gratification; this is a sexual fetichism in the narrow sense, and is by +Krafft-Ebing termed <i>Zoophilia Erotica</i>. We have, further, the class of +cases in which a real or simulated sexual intercourse with animals is +desired. Such cases are not regarded as fetichism by<a name='5_Page_72'></a> Krafft-Ebing,<a name='5_FNanchor_33'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_33'><sup>[33]</sup></a> +but they come within the phenomena of erotic symbolism as here understood. +This class falls into two divisions: one in which the individual is fairly +normal, but belongs to a low grade of culture; the other in which he may +belong to a more refined social class, but is affected by a deep degree of +degeneration. In the first case we may properly apply the term bestiality; +in the second case it may perhaps be better to use the term <i>zooerastia</i>, +proposed by Krafft-Ebing.<a name='5_FNanchor_34'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_34'><sup>[34]</sup></a></p> + +<p>Among children, both boys and girls, it is common to find that the +copulation of animals is a mysteriously fascinating spectacle. It is +inevitable that this should be so, for the spectacle is more or less +clearly felt to be the revelation of a secret which has been concealed +from them. It is, moreover, a secret of which they feel intimate +reverberations within themselves, and even in perfectly innocent and +ignorant children the sight may produce an obscure sexual excitement.<a name='5_FNanchor_35'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_35'><sup>[35]</sup></a> +It would seem that this occurs more frequently in girls than in boys. Even +in adult age, it may be added, women are liable to experience the same +kind of emotion in the presence of such spectacles. One lady recalls, as a +girl, that on several occasions an element of physical excitement entered +into the feelings with which she watched the coquetry of cats. Another +lady mentions that at the age of about 25, and when still quite ignorant +of sexual matters, she saw from a window some boys tickling a dog and +inducing sexual excitement in the animal; she vaguely divined what they +were doing, and though feeling disgust at their conduct she at the same +time experienced in a strong degree what she now knows was sexual +excitement. The coupling of the larger animals is <a name='5_Page_73'></a>often an impressive and +splendid spectacle which is far, indeed, from being obscene, and has +commended itself to persons of intellectual distinction;<a name='5_FNanchor_36'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_36'><sup>[36]</sup></a> but in young +or ill-balanced minds such sights tend to become both prurient and morbid. +I have already referred to the curious case of a sexually hyperæsthetic +nun who was always powerfully excited by the sight or even the +recollection of flies in sexual connection, so that she was compelled to +masturbate; this dated from childhood. After becoming a nun she recorded +having had this experience, followed by masturbation, more than four +hundred times.<a name='5_FNanchor_37'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_37'><sup>[37]</sup></a> Animal spectacles sometimes produce a sexual effect on +children even when not specifically sexual; thus a correspondent, a +clergyman, informs me that when a young and impressionable boy, he was +much affected by seeing a veterinary surgeon insert his hand and arm into +a horse's rectum, and dreamed of this several times afterward with +emissions.</p> + +<p>While the contemplation of animal coitus is an easily intelligible and in +early life, perhaps, an almost normal symbol of sexual emotion, there is +another subdivision of this group of animal fetichisms which forms a more +natural transition from the fetichisms which have their center in the +human body: the stuff-fetichisms, or the sexual attraction exerted by +various tissues, perhaps always of animal origin. Here we are in the +presence of a somewhat complicated phenomenon. In part we have, <a name='5_Page_74'></a>in a +considerable number of such cases, the sexual attraction of feminine +garments, for all such tissues are liable to enter into the dress. In +part, also, we have a sexual perversion of tactile sensibility, for in a +considerable proportion of these cases it is the touch sensations which +are potent in arousing the erotic sensations. But in part, also, it would +seem, we have here the conscious or subconscious presence of an animal +fetich, and it is notable that perhaps all these stuffs, and especially +fur, which is by far the commonest of the groups, are distinctively animal +products. We may perhaps regard the fetich of feminine hair—a much more +important and common fetich, indeed, than any of the stuff fetichisms—as +a link of transition. Hair is at once an animal and a human product, while +it may be separated from the body and possesses the qualities of a stuff. +Krafft-Ebing remarks that the senses of touch, smell, and hearing, as well +as sight, seem to enter into the attraction exerted by hair.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The natural fascination of hair, on which hair-fetichism is + founded, begins at a very early age. "The hair is a special + object of interest with infants," Stanley Hall concludes, "which + begins often in the latter part of the first year.... The hair, + no doubt, gives quite unique tactile sensations, both in its own + roots and to hands, and is plastic and yielding to the motor + sense, so that the earliest interest may be akin to that in fur, + which is a marked object in infant experience. Some children + develop an almost fetichistic propensity to pull or later to + stroke the hair or beard of every one with whom they come in + contact." (G. Stanley Hall, "The Early Sense of Self," <i>American + Journal of Psychology</i>, April, 1898, p. 359.)</p> + +<p> It should be added that the fascination of hair for the infantile + and childish mind is not necessarily one of attraction, but may + be of repulsion. It happens here, as in the case of so many + characteristics which are of sexual significance, that we are in + the presence of an object which may exert a dynamic emotional + force, a force which is capable of repelling with the same energy + that it attracts. Féré records the instructive case of a child of + 3, of psychopathic heredity, who when he could not sleep was + sometimes taken by his mother into her bed. One night his hand + came in contact with a hairy portion of his mother's body, and + this, arousing the idea of an animal, caused him to leap out of + the bed in terror. He became curious as to the cause of his + terror and in time was able to observe "the animal," but the + train of feelings which had been set up led to a life-long + indifference to women and a tendency to homosexuality. It is + noteworthy that he was attracted to <a name='5_Page_75'></a>men in whom the hair and + other secondary sexual characters were well developed. (Féré, + <i>L'Instinct Sexuel</i>, second edition, pp. 262-267.)</p> + +<p> As a sexual fetich hair strictly belongs to the group of parts of + the body; but since it can be removed from the body and is + sexually effective as a fetich in the absence of the person to + whom it belongs, it is on a level with the garments which may + serve in a similar way, with shoes or handkerchiefs or gloves. + Psychologically, hair-fetichism presents no special problem, but + the wide attraction of hair—it is sexually the most generally + noted part of the feminine body after the eyes—and the peculiar + facility with which when plaited it may be removed, render + hair-fetichism a sexual perversion of specially great + medico-legal interest.</p> + +<p> The frequency of hair-fetichism, as well as of the natural + admiration on which it rests, is indicated by a case recorded by + Laurent. "A few years ago," he states, "one constantly saw at the + Bal Bullier, in Paris, a tall girl whose face was lean and bony, + but whose black hair was of truly remarkable length. She wore it + flowing down her shoulders and loins. Men often followed her in + the street to touch or kiss the hair. Others would accompany her + home and pay her for the mere pleasure of touching and kissing + the long black tresses. One, in consideration of a relatively + considerable sum, desired to pollute the silky hair. She was + obliged to be always on her guard, and to take all sorts of + precautions to prevent any one cutting off this ornament, which + constituted her only beauty as well as her livelihood." (E. + Laurent, <i>L'Amour Morbide</i>, 1891, p. 164; also the same author's + <i>Fétichistes et Erotomanes</i>, p. 23.)</p> + +<p> The hair despoiler (<i>Coupeur des Nattes</i> or <i>Zopfabschneider</i>) + may be found in any civilized country, though the most carefully + studied cases have occurred in Paris. (Several medico-legal + histories of hair-despoilers are summarized by Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. + cit.</i>, pp. 329-334). Such persons are usually of nervous + temperament and bad heredity; the attraction to hair occasionally + develops in early life; sometimes the morbid impulse only appears + in later life after fever. The fetich may be either flowing hair + or braided hair, but is usually one or the other, and not both. + Sexual excitement and ejaculation may be produced in the act of + touching or cutting off the hair, which is subsequently, in many + cases, used for masturbation. As a rule the hair-despoiler is a + pure fetichist, no element of sadistic pleasure entering into his + feelings. In the case of a "capillary kleptomaniac" in Chicago—a + highly intelligent and athletic married young man of good + family—the impulse to cut off girls' braids appeared after + recovery from a severe fever. He would gaze admiringly at the + long tresses and then clip them off with great rapidity; he did + this in some fifty cases before he was caught and imprisoned. He + usually threw the braids away before he reached home. (<i>Alienist + and Neurologist</i>, April, 1889, p. 325.) In this case there <a name='5_Page_76'></a>is no + history of sexual excitement, probably because no proper + medico-legal examination was made. (It may be added that + hair-despoilers have been specially studied by Motet, "Les + Coupeurs de Nattes," <i>Annales d'Hygiène</i>, 1890.)</p></div> + +<p>The stuff-fetiches are most usually fur and velvet; feathers, silk, and +leathers also sometimes exert this influence; they are all, it will be +noted, animal substances.<a name='5_FNanchor_38'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_38'><sup>[38]</sup></a> The most interesting is probably fur, the +attraction of which is not uncommon in association with passive +algolagnia. As Stanley Hall has shown, the fear of fur, as well as the +love of it, is by no means uncommon in childhood; it may appear even in +infancy and in children who have never come in contact with animals.<a name='5_FNanchor_39'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_39'><sup>[39]</sup></a> +It is noteworthy that in most cases of uncomplicated stuff-fetichism the +attraction apparently arises on a congenital basis, as it appears in +persons of nervous or sensitive temperament at an early age and without +being attached to any definite causative incident. The sexual excitation +is nearly always produced by the touch rather than by the sight. As we +found, when dealing with the sense of touch in the previous volume, the +specific sexual sensations may be regarded as a special modification of +ticklishness. The erotic symbolism in the case of these stuff-fetichisms +would seem to be a more or less congenital perversion of ticklishness in +relation to specific animal contacts.</p> + +<p>A further degree of perversion in this direction is reached in a case of +erotic <i>zoophilia</i>, recorded by Krafft-Ebing.<a name='5_FNanchor_40'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_40'><sup>[40]</sup></a> In this case a +congenital neuropath, of good intelligence but delicate and anæmic, with +feeble sexual powers, had a great love of domestic animals, especially +dogs and cats, from an early age; when petting them he experienced sexual +emotions, although he was innocent in sexual matters. At puberty he +realized the nature of his feelings and tried to break himself of his +habits. He succeeded, but then began erotic dreams accompanied by images +of <a name='5_Page_77'></a>animals, and these led to masturbation associated with ideas of a +similar kind. At the same time he had no wish for any sort of sexual +intercourse with animals, and was indifferent as to the sex of the animals +which attracted him; his sexual ideals were normal. Such a case seems to +be fundamentally one of fetichism on a tactile basis, and thus forms a +transition between the stuff-fetichisms and the complete perversions of +sexual attraction toward animals.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In some cases sexually hyperæsthetic women have informed me that + sexual feeling has been produced by casual contact with pet dogs + and cats. In such cases there is usually no real perversion, but + it seems probable that we may here have an occasional foundation + for the somewhat morbid but scarcely vicious excesses of + affection which women are apt to display towards their pet dogs + or cats. In most cases of this affection there is certainly no + sexual element; in the case of childless women, it may rather be + regarded as a maternal than as an erotic symbolism. (The excesses + of this non-erotic zoophilia have been discussed by Féré, + <i>L'Instinct Sexuel</i>, second edition, pp. 166-171.)</p></div> + +<p>Krafft-Ebing considers that complete perversion of sexual attraction +toward animals is radically distinct from erotic <i>zoophilia</i>. This view +cannot be accepted. Bestiality and <i>zooerastia</i> merely present in a more +marked and profoundly perverted form a further degree of the same +phenomenon which we meet with in erotic <i>zoophilia</i>; the difference is +that they occur either in more insensitive or in more markedly degenerate +persons.</p> + +<p>A fairly typical case of <i>zooerastia</i> has been recorded in America by +Howard, of Baltimore. This was the case of a boy of 16, precociously +mature and fairly bright. He was, however, indifferent to the opposite +sex, though he had ample opportunity for gratifying normal passions. His +parents lived in the city, but the youth had an inordinate desire for the +country and was therefore sent to school in a village. On the second day +after his arrival at school a farmer missed a sow which was found secreted +in an outhouse on the school grounds. This was the first of many similar +incidents in which a sow always took part. So strong was his passion that +on one occasion force had to be used to take him away from the sow he was +caressing. He did <a name='5_Page_78'></a>not masturbate, and even when restrained from +approaching sows he had no sexual inclination for other animals. His +nocturnal pollutions, which were frequent, were always accompanied by +images of wallowing swine. Notwithstanding careful treatment no cure was +effected; mental and physical vigor failed, and he died at the age of +23.<a name='5_FNanchor_41'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_41'><sup>[41]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is, however, somewhat doubtful whether we can always or even usually +distinguish between zooerastia and bestiality. Dr. G. F. Lydston, of +Chicago, has communicated to me a case (in which he was consulted) which +seems fairly typical and is instructive in this respect. The subject was a +young man of 21, a farmer's son, not very bright intellectually, but very +healthy and strong, of great assistance on the farm, very capable and +industrious, such a good farm hand that his father was unwilling to send +him away and to lose his services. There was no history of insanity or +neurosis in the family, and no injury or illness in his own history. He +had spells of moroseness and irritability, however, and had also been a +masturbator. Women had no attraction for him, but he would copulate with +the mares upon his father's farm, and this without regard to time, place, +or spectators. Such a case would seem to stand midway between ordinary +bestiality and pathological zooerastia as defined by Krafft-Ebing, yet it +seems probable that in most cases of ordinary bestiality some slight +traces of mental anomaly might be found, if such cases always were, as +they should be, properly investigated.<a name='5_FNanchor_42'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_42'><sup>[42]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_79'></a> +<p>We have here reached the grossest and most frequent perversion in this +group; bestiality, or the impulse to attain sexual gratification by +intercourse, or other close contact, with animals. In seeking to +comprehend this perversion it is necessary to divest ourselves of the +attitude toward animals which is the inevitable outcome of refined +civilization and urban life. Most sexual perversions, if not in large +measure the actual outcome of civilized life, easily adjust themselves to +it. Bestiality (except in one form to be noted later) is, on the other +hand, the sexual perversion of dull, insensitive and unfastidious persons. +It flourishes among primitive peoples and among peasants. It is the vice +of the clodhopper, unattractive to women or inapt to court them.</p> + +<p>Three conditions have favored the extreme prevalence of bestiality: (1) +primitive conceptions of life which built up no great barrier between man +and the other animals; (2) the extreme familiarity which necessarily +exists between the peasant and his beasts, often combined with separation +from women; (3) various folk-lore beliefs such as the efficacy of +intercourse with animals as a cure for venereal disease, etc.<a name='5_FNanchor_43'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_43'><sup>[43]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The beliefs and customs of primitive peoples, as well as their mythology +and legends, bring before us a community of man and animals altogether +unlike anything we know in civilization. Men may become animals and +animals may become men; animals and men may communicate with each other +and live on terms of equality; animals may be the ancestors of human +tribes; the sacred totems of savages are most usually animals. There is no +shame or degradation in the notion of a sexual relationship between men +and animals, because in primitive conceptions animals are not inferior +beings separated from man by a great gulf. They are much more like men in +disguise, and in some respects possess powers which make them superior to +men.<a name='5_Page_80'></a> This is recognized in those plays, festivals, and religious dances, +so common among primitive peoples, in which animal disguises are worn.<a name='5_FNanchor_44'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_44'><sup>[44]</sup></a> +When men admire and emulate the qualities of animals and are proud to +believe that they descend from them, it is not surprising that they should +sometimes see nothing derogatory in sexual intercourse with them.<a name='5_FNanchor_45'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_45'><sup>[45]</sup></a></p> + +<p>A significant relic of primitive conceptions in this matter may perhaps be +found in the religious rites connected with the sacred goat of Mendes +described by Herodotus. After telling how the Mendesians reverence the +goat, especially the he-goat, out of their veneration for Pan, whom they +represent as a goat ("the real motive which they assign for this custom I +do not choose to relate"), he adds: "It happened in this country, and +within my remembrance, and was indeed universally notorious, that a goat +had indecent and public communication with a woman."<a name='5_FNanchor_46'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_46'><sup>[46]</sup></a> The meaning of +the passage evidently is that in the ordinary intercourse of women with +the sacred goat, connection was only simulated or incomplete on account of +the natural indifference of the goat to the human female, but that in rare +cases the goat proved sexually excitable with the woman and capable of +connection.<a name='5_FNanchor_47'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_47'><sup>[47]</sup></a> The goat has always been a kind of sacred emblem of lust. +In the middle ages it became associated with the Devil as one of the +favorite forms he assumed. It is significant of a primitively religious +sexual association between men and animals, that witches constantly +confessed, or were made to confess, that they had had intercourse with the +Devil in the shape of an animal, very frequently a dog. The figures <a name='5_Page_81'></a>of +human beings and animals in conjunction carved on temples in India, also +seem to indicate the religious significance which this phenomenon +sometimes presents. There is, indeed, no need to go beyond Europe even in +her moments of highest culture to find a religious sanction for sexual +union between human beings, or gods in human shape, and animals. The +legends of Io and the bull, of Leda and the swan, are among the most +familiar in Greek mythology, and in a later pictorial form they constitute +some of the most cherished works of the painters of the Renaissance.</p> + +<p>As regards the prevalence of occasional sexual intercourse between men or +women and animals among primitive peoples at the present time, it is +possible to find many scattered references by travelers in all parts of +the world. Such references by no means indicate that such practices are, +as a rule, common, but they usually show that they are accepted with a +good-humored indifference.<a name='5_FNanchor_48'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_48'><sup>[48]</sup></a></p> + +<p>Bestiality is very rarely found in towns. In the country this vice of the +clodhopper is far from infrequent. For the peasant, whose sensibilities +are uncultivated and who makes but the most elementary demands from a +woman, the difference between an animal and a human being in this respect +scarcely seems to be very great. "My wife was away too long," a German +peasant explained to the magistrate, "and so I went with my sow." It is +certainly an explanation that to the uncultivated peasant, ignorant of +theological and juridical conceptions, must often seem natural and +sufficient.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Bestiality thus resembles masturbation and other abnormal + manifestations of the sexual impulse which may be practiced + merely <i>faute de mieux</i> and not as, in the strict sense, + perversions of the impulse. Even necrophily may be thus + practiced. A young man who when assisting the grave-digger + conceived and carried out the idea of digging up the bodies of + young girls to satisfy his passions with, and whose case <a name='5_Page_82'></a>has + been recorded by Belletrud and Mercier, said: "I could find no + young girl who would agree to yield to my desires; that is why I + have done this. I should have preferred to have relations with + living persons. I found it quite natural to do what I did: I saw + no harm in it, and I did not think that any one else could. As + living women felt nothing but repulsion for me, it was quite + natural I should turn to the dead, who have never repulsed me. I + used to say tender things to them like 'my beautiful, my love, I + love you.'" (Belletrud and Mercier "Perversion de l'Instinct + Genésique," <i>Annales d'Hygiène Publique</i>, June, 1903.) But when + so highly abnormal an act is felt as natural we are dealing with + a person who is congenitally defective so far as the finer + developments of intelligence are concerned. It was so in this + case of necrophily; he was the son of a weak-minded woman of + unrestrainable sexual inclinations, and was himself somewhat + feeble-minded; he was also, it is instructive to observe, + anosmic.</p></div> + +<p>But it is by no means only their dulled sensibility or the absence of +women, which accounts for the frequency of bestiality among peasants. A +highly important factor is their constant familiarity with animals. The +peasant lives with animals, tends them, learns to know all their +individual characters; he understands them far better than he understands +men and women; they are his constant companions, his friends. He knows, +moreover, the details of their sexual lives, he witnesses the often highly +impressive spectacle of their coupling. It is scarcely surprising that +peasants should sometimes regard animals as being not only as near to them +as their fellow human beings, but even nearer.</p> + +<p>The significance of the factor of familiarity is indicated by the great +frequency of bestiality among shepherds, goatherds, and others whose +occupation is exclusively the care of animals. Mirabeau, in the eighteenth +century, stated, on the evidence of Basque priests, that all the shepherds +in the Pyrenees practice bestiality. It is apparently much the same in +Italy.<a name='5_FNanchor_49'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_49'><sup>[49]</sup></a> In South<a name='5_Page_83'></a> Italy and Sicily, especially, bestiality among +goatherds and peasants is said to be almost a national custom.<a name='5_FNanchor_50'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_50'><sup>[50]</sup></a> In the +extreme north of Europe, it is reported, the reindeer, in this respect, +takes the place of the goat.</p> + +<p>The importance of the same factor is also shown by the fact that when +among women in civilization animal perversions appear, the animal is +nearly always a pet dog. Usually in these cases the animal is taught to +give gratification by <i>cunnilinctus</i>. In some cases, however, there is +really sexual intercourse between the animal and the woman.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Moll mentions that in a case of <i>cunnilinctus</i> by a dog in + Germany there was a difficulty as to whether the matter should be + considered an unnatural offence or simply an offence against + decency; the lower court considered it in the former light, while + the higher court took the more merciful view. (Moll, + <i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. 697.) In a + case reported by Pfaff and mentioned by Moll, a country girl was + accused of having sexual intercourse with a large dog. On + examination Pfaff found in the girl's thick pubic hair a loose + hair which under the microscope proved to belong to the dog. + (<i>Loc. cit.</i>, p. 698.) In such a case it must be noted that while + this evidence may be held to show sexual contact with the dog, it + scarcely suffices to show sexual intercourse. This has, however, + undoubtedly occurred from time to time, even more or less openly. + Bloch (<i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 277 and 282) remarks that this is not an + infrequent exhibition given by prostitutes in certain brothels. + Maschka has referred to such an exhibition between a woman and a + bull-dog, which was given to select circles in Paris. Rosse + refers to a case in which a young unmarried woman in Washington + was surprised during intercourse with a large English mastiff, + who in his efforts to get loose caused such severe injuries that + the woman died from hæmorrhage in about an hour. Rosse also + mentions that some years ago a performance of this kind between a + prostitute and a Newfoundland dog could be witnessed in San + Francisco by paying a small sum; the woman declared that a woman + who had once copulated with a dog would ever afterwards prefer + this animal to a man. Rosse adds that he was acquainted with a + similar performance between a woman <a name='5_Page_84'></a>and a donkey, which used to + take place in Europe (Irving Rosse, "Sexual Hypochondriasis and + Perversion of the Genesic Instinct," <i>Virginia Medical Monthly</i>, + October, 1892, p. 379). Juvenal mentions such relations between + the donkey and woman (vi, 332). Krauss (quoted by Bloch, + <i>Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, Teil II, p. + 276) states that in Bosnia women sometimes carry on these + practices with dogs and also—as he would not have believed had + he not on one occasion observed it—with cats. "It seems to me," + writes Dr. Kiernan, of Chicago, (private letter) "that what Rosse + says of the animal exhibitions in San Francisco is true of all + great cities. The animal employed in such exhibitions here has + usually been a donkey, and in one instance death occurred from + the animal trampling the girl partner. The practice described + occurs in country regions quite frequently. Thus in a case + reported in the suburbs of Omaha, Nebraska, a sixteen-year-old + boy engaged in rectal coitus with a large dog. In attempting to + extricate his swollen penis from the boy's rectum the dog tore + through the <i>sphincter ani</i> an inch into the gluteus muscles. + (<i>Omaha Clinic</i>, March, 1893.) In a Missouri case, which I + verified, a smart, pretty, well-educated country girl was found + with a profuse offensive vaginal discharge which had been present + for about a week, coming on suddenly. After washing the external + genitals and opening the labia three rents were discovered, one + through the fourchette and two through the left nymphæ. The + vagina was excessively congested and covered with points bleeding + on the slightest irritation. The patient confessed that one day + while playing with the genitals of a large dog she became excited + and thought she would have slight coitus. After the dog had made + an entrance she was unable to free herself from him, as he + clasped her so firmly with his fore legs. The penis became so + swollen that the dog could not free himself, although for more + than an hour she made persistent efforts to do so. (<i>Medical + Standard</i>, June, 1903, p. 184). In an Indiana case, concerning + which I was consulted, the girl was a hebephreniac who had + resorted to this procedure with a Newfoundland dog at the + instance of another girl, seemingly normal as regards mentality, + and had been badly injured; a discharge resulted which resembled + gonorrhœa, but contained no gonococci. These cases are + probably more frequent than is usually assumed."</p> + +<p> Women are known to have had intercourse with various other + animals, occasionally or habitually, in various parts of the + world. Monkeys have been mentioned in this connection. Moll + remarks that it seems to be an indication of an abnormal interest + in monkeys that some women are observed by the attendants in the + monkey-house of zoölogical gardens to be very frequent visitors. + Near the Amazon the traveler Castelnau saw an enormous Coati + monkey belonging to an Indian woman and tried to purchase it; + though he offered a large sum, the woman only laughed. "Your + efforts are useless," remarked an<a name='5_Page_85'></a> Indian in the same cabin, "he + is her husband." (So far as the early literature of this subject + is concerned, a number of facts and fables regarding the congress + of women with dogs, goats and other animals was brought together + at the beginning of the eighteenth century by Schurig in his + <i>Gynæcologia</i>, Section II, cap. VII; I have not drawn on this + collection.)</p> + +<p> In some cases women, and also men, find gratification in the + sexual manipulation of animals without any kind of congress. This + may be illustrated by an observation communicated to me by a + correspondent, a clergyman. "In Ireland, my father's house + adjoined the residence of an archdeacon of the established + church. I was then about 20 and was still kept in religious awe + of evil ways. The archdeacon had two daughters, both of whom he + brought up in great strictness, resolved that they should grow up + examples of virtue and piety. Our stables adjoined, and were + separated only by a thin wall in which was a doorway closed up by + some boards, as the two stables had formerly been one. One night + I had occasion to go to our stable to search for a garden tool I + had missed, and I heard a door open on the other side, and saw a + light glimmer through the cracks of the boards. I looked through + to ascertain who could be there at that late hour, and soon + recognized the stately figure of one of the daughters, F. F. was + tall, dark and handsome, but had never made any advances to me, + nor had I to her. She was making love to her father's mare after + a singular fashion. Stripping her right arm, she formed her + fingers into a cone, and pressed on the mare's vulva. I was + astonished to see the beast stretching her hind legs as if to + accommodate the hand of her mistress, which she pushed in + gradually and with seeming ease to the elbow. At the same time + she seemed to experience the most voluptuous sensation, crisis + after crisis arriving." My correspondent adds that, being + exceedingly curious in the matter, he tried a somewhat similar + experiment himself with one of his father's mares and experienced + what he describes as "a most powerful sexual battery" which + produced very exciting and exhausting effects. Näcke + (<i>Psychiatrische en Neurologische Bladen</i>, 1899, No. 2) refers to + an idiot who thus manipulated the vulva of mares in his charge. + The case has been recorded by Guillereau (<i>Journal de Médicine + Véterinaire et de Zootechnie</i>, January, 1899) of a youth who was + accustomed to introduce his hand into the vulva of cows in order + to obtain sexual excitement.</p> + +<p> The possibility of sexual excitement between women and animals + involves a certain degree of sexual excitability in animals from + contact with women. Darwin stated that there could be no doubt + that various quadrumanous animals could distinguish women from + men—in the first place probably by smell and secondarily by + sight—and be thus liable to sexual excitement. He quotes the + opinions on this point of Youatt,<a name='5_Page_86'></a> Brehm, Sir Andrew Smith and + Cuvier (<i>Descent of Man</i>, second edition, p. 8). Moll quotes the + opinion of an experienced observer to the same effect + (<i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, Bd. i, p. 429). + Hufeland reported the case of a little girl of three who was + playing, seated on a stool, with a dog placed between her thighs + and locked against her. Seemingly excited by this contact the + animal attempted a sort of copulation, causing the genital parts + of the child to become inflamed. Bloch (<i>Op. cit.</i>, p. 280, <i>et + seq.</i>) discusses the same point; he does not consider that + animals will of their own motion sexually cohabit with women, but + that they may be easily trained to it. There can be no doubt that + dogs at all events are sometimes sexually excited by the presence + of women, perhaps especially during menstruation, and many women + are able to bear testimony to the embarrassing attentions they + have sometimes received from strange dogs. There can be no + difficulty in believing that, so far as <i>cunnilinctus</i> is + concerned dogs would require no training. In a case recorded by + Moll (<i>Konträre Sexualempfindung</i>, third edition, p. 560) a lady + states that this was done to her when a child, as also to other + children, by dogs who, she said, showed signs of sexual + excitement. In this case there was also sexual excitement thus + produced in the child, and after puberty mutual <i>cunnilinctus</i> + was practiced with girl friends. Guttceit (<i>Dreissig Jahre + Praxis</i>, Theil I, p. 310) remarks that some Russian officers who + were in the Turkish campaign of 1828 told him that from fear of + veneral infection in Wallachia they refrained from women and + often used female asses which appeared to show signs of sexual + pleasure.</p></div> + +<p>A very large number of animals have been recorded as having been employed +in the gratification of sexual desire at some period or in some country, +by men and sometimes by women. Domestic animals are naturally those which +most frequently come into question, and there are few if any of these +which can altogether be excepted. The sow is one of the animals most +frequently abused in this manner.<a name='5_FNanchor_51'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_51'><sup>[51]</sup></a> Cases in which mares, cows, and +donkeys figure constantly occur, as well as goats and sheep. Dogs, cats, +and rabbits are heard of from time to time. Hens, ducks, and, especially +in China, geese, are not uncommonly employed. The Roman ladies were said +to have had an abnormal <a name='5_Page_87'></a>affection for snakes. The bear and even the +crocodile are also mentioned.<a name='5_FNanchor_52'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_52'><sup>[52]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The social and legal attitude toward bestiality has reflected in part the +frequency with which it has been practiced, and in part the disgust mixed +with mystical and sacrilegious horror which it has aroused. It has +sometimes been met merely by a fine, and sometimes the offender and his +innocent partner have been burnt together. In the middle ages and later +its frequency is attested by the fact that it formed a favorite topic with +preachers of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. It is significant that +in the Penitentials,—which were criminal codes, half secular and half +spiritual, in use before the thirteenth century, when penance was +relegated to the judgment of the confessor,—it was thought necessary to +fix the periods of penance which should be undergone respectively by +bishops, priests and deacons who should be guilty of bestiality.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In Egbert's Penitential, a document of the ninth and tenth + centuries, we read (V. 22): "Item Episcopus cum quadrupede + fornicans VII annos, consuetudinem X, presbyter V, diaconus III, + clerus II." There was a great range in the penances for + bestiality, from ten years to (in the case of boys) one hundred + days. The mare is specially mentioned (Haddon and Stubbs, + <i>Councils and Ecclesiastical Documents</i>, vol. iii, p. 422). In + Theodore's Penitential, another Anglo-Saxon document of about the + same age, those who habitually fornicate with animals are + adjudged ten years of penance. It would appear from the + <i>Penitentiale Pseudo-Romanum</i> (which is earlier than the eleventh + century) that one year's penance was adequate for fornication + with a mare when committed by a layman (exactly the same as for + simple fornication with a widow or virgin), and this was + mercifully reduced to half a year if he had no wife. + (Wasserschleben, <i>Die Bussordnungen der Abendländlichen Kirche</i>, + p. 366). The <i>Penitentiale Hubertense</i> (emanating from the + monastery of St. Hubert in the Ardennes) fixes ten years' penance + for sodomy, while Fulbert's Penitential (about the eleventh + century) fixes seven years for either sodomy or bestiality. + Burchard's Penitential, <a name='5_Page_88'></a>which is always detailed and precise, + specially mentions the mare, the cow and the ass, and assigns + forty days bread and water and seven years penance, raised to ten + years in the case of married men. A woman having intercourse with + a horse is assigned seven years penance in Burchard's + Penitential. (Wasserschleben, <i>ib.</i> pp. 651, 659.)</p></div> + +<p>The extreme severity which was frequently exercised toward those guilty of +this offense, was doubtless in large measure due to the fact that +bestiality was regarded as a kind of sodomy, an offense which was +frequently viewed with a mystical horror apart altogether from any actual +social or personal injury it caused. The Jews seem to have felt this +horror; it was ordered that the sinner and his victim should both be put +to death (Exodus, Ch. 22, v. 19; Leviticus, Ch. 20, v. 15). In the middle +ages, especially in France, the same rule often prevailed. Men and sows, +men and cows, men and donkeys were burnt together. At Toulouse a woman was +burnt for having intercourse with a dog. Even in the seventeenth century a +learned French lawyer, Claude Lebrun de la Rochette, justified such +sentences.<a name='5_FNanchor_53'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_53'><sup>[53]</sup></a> It seems probable that even to-day, in the social and legal +attitude toward bestiality, sufficient regard is not paid to the fact that +this offense is usually committed either by persons who are morbidly +abnormal or who are of so low a degree of intelligence that they border on +feeble-mindedness. To what extent, and on what grounds, it ought to be +punished is a question calling for serious reconsideration.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_33'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_33'>[33]</a><div class='note'><p> For Krafft-Ebing's discussion of the subject see <i>Op. cit.</i>, +pp. 530-539.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_34'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_34'>[34]</a><div class='note'><p> In England it is not uncommon to use the term "unnatural +offence;" this is an awkward and possibly misleading practice which should +not be followed. In Germany a similar confusion is caused by applying the +term "sodomy" to these cases as well as to pederasty. Krafft-Ebing +considers that this error is due to the jurists, while the theologians +have always distinguished correctly. In this matter, he adds, science must +be <i>ancilla theologiæ</i> and return to the correct usage of words.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_35'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_35'>[35]</a><div class='note'><p> This childish interest, with later abnormal developments, +may be seen in History I of the Appendix to this volume.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_36'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_36'>[36]</a><div class='note'><p> The Countess of Pembroke, Sir Philip Sidney's sister, +appears to have found sexual enjoyment in the contemplation of the sexual +prowess of stallions. Aubrey writes that she "was very salacious and she +had a contrivance that in the spring of the year ... the stallions ... +were to be brought before such a part of the house where she had a vidette +to look on them." (<i>Short Lives</i>, 1898, vol. i, p. 311.) Although the +modern editor's modesty has caused the disappearance of several lines from +this passage, the general sense is clear. In the same century Burchard, +the faithful secretary of Pope Alexander VI, describes in his invaluable +diary how four race horses were brought to two mares in a court of the +Vatican, the horses clamorously fighting for the possession of the mares +and eventually mounting them, while the Pope and his daughter Lucrezia +looked on from a window "cum magno risu et delectatione." (<i>Diarium</i>, ed +Thuasne, vol. III, p. 169.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_37'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_37'>[37]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, 1902, fasc. ii-iii, p. 338. In +the case of pathological sexuality in a boy of 15, reported by A. +MacDonald, and already summarized, the sight of copulating flies is also +mentioned among many other causes of sexual excitation.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_38'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_38'>[38]</a><div class='note'><p> Krafft-Ebing presents or quotes typical cases of all these +fetiches, <i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 255-266.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_39'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_39'>[39]</a><div class='note'><p> G. Stanley Hall, "A study of Fears," <i>American Journal of +Psychology</i>, 1897, pp. 213-215.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_40'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_40'>[40]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Op. cit.</i>, p. 268.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_41'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_41'>[41]</a><div class='note'><p> W. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," <i>Alienist and Neurologist</i>, +January, 1896. Krafft-Ebing (<i>op. cit.</i>, p. 532) quotes from Boeteau the +somewhat similar case of a gardener's boy of 16—an illegitimate child of +neuropathic heredity and markedly degenerate—who had a passion, of +irresistible and impulsive character, for rabbits. He was declared +irresponsible. Moll (<i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, pp. +431-433) presents the case of a neurotic man who from the age of 15 had +been sexually excited by the sight of animals or by contact with them. He +had repeatedly had connection with cows and mares; he was also sexually +excited by sheep, donkeys, and dogs, whether female or male; the normal +sexual instinct was weak and he experienced very slight attraction to +women.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_42'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_42'>[42]</a><div class='note'><p> Moll also remarks ("Perverse Sexualempfindung," in Senator's +and Kaminer's <i>Krankheiten und Ehe</i>) that in this matter it is often +hardly possible to draw a sharp line between vice and disease.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_43'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_43'>[43]</a><div class='note'><p> Instances of this widespread belief—found among the Tamils +of Ceylon as well as in Europe—are quoted from various authors by Bloch, +<i>Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, Teil II, p. 278, and +Moll, <i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. 700. On the +frequency of bestiality, from one cause or another, in the East, see, +<i>e.g.</i>, Stern, <i>Medizin und Geschlechtsleben in der Türkei</i>, bd. ii, p. +219.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_44'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_44'>[44]</a><div class='note'><p> Sometimes (as among the Aleuts) the animal pantomime dances +of savages may represent the transformation of a captive bird into a +lovely woman who falls exhausted into the arms of the hunter. (H. H. +Bancroft, <i>Native Races of the Pacific</i>, vol. i, p. 93.) A system of +beliefs which accepts the possibility that a human being may be latent in +an animal obviously favors the practice of bestiality.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_45'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_45'>[45]</a><div class='note'><p> For an example of the primitive confusion between the +intercourse of women with animals and with men see, <i>e.g.</i>, Boas, "Sagen +aus British-Columbia," <i>Zeitschrift für Ethnologie</i>, heft V, p. 558.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_46'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_46'>[46]</a><div class='note'><p> Herodotus, Book II, Chapter 46.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_47'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_47'>[47]</a><div class='note'><p> Dulare (<i>Des Divinités Génératrices</i>, Chapter II) brings +together the evidence showing that in Egypt women had connection with the +sacred goat, apparently in order to secure fertility.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_48'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_48'>[48]</a><div class='note'><p> Various facts and references bearing on this subject are +brought together by Blumenbach, <i>Anthropological Memoirs</i>, translated by +Bendyshe, p. 80; Block, <i>Beiträge zur Ætiologie der Psychopathia +Sexualis</i>, Teil II, pp. 276-283; also Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, +seventh edition, p. 520.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_49'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_49'>[49]</a><div class='note'><p> Mantegazza mentions (<i>Gli Amori degli Uomini</i>, cap V) that +at Rimini a young goatherd of the Apennines, troubled with dyspepsia and +nervous symptoms, told him this was due to excesses with the goats in his +care. A finely executed marble group of a satyr having connection with a +goat, found at Herculaneum and now in the Naples Museum (reproduced in +Fuchs's <i>Erotische Element in der Karikatur</i>), perhaps symbolizes a +traditional and primitive practice of the goatherd.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_50'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_50'>[50]</a><div class='note'><p> Bayle (<i>Dictionary</i>, Art, Bathyllus) quotes various +authorities concerning the Italian auxiliaries in the south of France in +the sixteenth century and their custom of bringing and using goats for +this purpose. Warton in the eighteenth century was informed that in Sicily +priests in confession habitually inquired of herdsmen if they had anything +to do with their sows. In Normandy priests are advised to ask similar +questions.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_51'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_51'>[51]</a><div class='note'><p> It is worth noting that in Greek the work χοιρος +means both a sow and a woman's pudenda; in the <i>Acharnians</i> Aristophanes +plays on this association at some length. The Romans also (as may be +gathered from Varro's <i>De Re Rustica</i>) called the feminine pudenda +<i>porcus</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_52'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_52'>[52]</a><div class='note'><p> Schurig, <i>Gynæcologia</i>, pp. 280-387; Bloch, <i>op. cit.</i>, +270-277. The Arabs, according to Kocher, chiefly practice bestiality with +goats, sheep and mares. The Annamites, according to Mondière, commonly +employ sows and (more especially the young women) dogs. Among the Tamils +of Ceylon bestiality with goats and cows is said to be very prevalent.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_53'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_53'>[53]</a><div class='note'><p> Mantegazza (<i>Gli Amori degli Uomini</i>, cap. V) brings +together some facts bearing on this matter.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_E_V'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_89'></a>V.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Exhibitionism—Illustrative Cases—A Symbolic Perversion of Courtship—The +Impulse to Defile—The Exhibitionist's Psychic Attitude—The Sexual Organs +as Fetichs—Phallus Worship—Adolescent Pride in Sexual +Development—Exhibitionism of the Nates—The Classification of the Forms +of Exhibitionism—Nature of the Relationship of Exhibitionism to Epilepsy.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>There is a remarkable form of erotic symbolism—very definite and standing +clearly apart from all other forms—in which sexual gratification is +experienced in the simple act of exhibiting the sexual organ to persons of +the opposite sex, usually by preference to young and presumably innocent +persons, very often children. This is termed exhibitionism.<a name='5_FNanchor_54'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_54'><sup>[54]</sup></a> It would +appear to be a not very infrequent phenomenon, and most women, once or +more in their lives, especially when young, have encountered a man who has +thus deliberately exposed himself before them.</p> + +<p>The exhibitionist, though often a young and apparently vigorous man, is +always satisfied with the mere act of self-exhibition and the emotional +reaction which that act produces; he makes no demands on the woman to whom +he exposes himself; he seldom speaks, he makes no effort to approach her; +as a rule, he fails even to display the signs of sexual excitation. His +desires are completely gratified by the act of exhibition and by the +emotional reaction it arouses in the woman. He departs satisfied and +relieved.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>A case recorded by Schrenck-Notzing very well represents both the + nature of the impulse felt by the exhibitionist and the way in + which it may originate. It is the case of a business man of 49, + of neurotic <a name='5_Page_90'></a>heredity, an affectionate husband and father of a + family, who, to his own grief and shame, is compelled from time + to time to exhibit his sexual organs to women in the street. As a + boy of 10 a girl of 12 tried to induce him to coitus; both had + their sexual parts exposed. From that time sexual contacts, as of + his own naked nates against those of a girl, became attractive, + as well as games in which the boys and girls in turn marched + before each other with their sexual parts exposed, and also + imitation of the copulation of animals. Coitus was first + practiced about the age of 20, but sight and touch of the woman's + sexual parts were always necessary to produce sexual excitement. + It was also necessary—and this consideration is highly important + as regards the development of the tendency to exhibition—that + the woman should be excited by the sight of his organs. Even when + he saw or touched a woman's parts orgasm often occurred. It was + the naked sexual organs in an otherwise clothed body which + chiefly excited him. He was not possessed of a high degree of + potency. Girls between the ages of 10 and 17 chiefly excited him, + and especially if he felt that they were quite ignorant of sexual + matters. His self-exhibition was a sort of psychic defloration, + and it was accompanied by the idea that other people felt as he + did about the sexual effects of the naked organs, that he was + shocking but at the same time sexually exciting a young girl. He + was thus gratifying himself through the belief that he was + causing sexual gratification to an innocent girl. This man was + convicted several times, and was finally declared to be suffering + from impulsive insanity. (Schrenck-Notzing, + <i>Kriminal-psychologische und Psycho-pathologische Studien</i>, 1902, + pp. 50-57.) In another case of Schrenck-Notzing's, an actor and + portrait painter, aged 31, in youth masturbated and was fond of + contemplating the images of the sexual organs of both sexes, + finding little pleasure in coitus. At the age of 24, at a bathing + establishment, he happened to occupy a compartment next to that + occupied by a lady, and when naked he became aware that his + neighbor was watching him through a chink in the partition. This + caused him powerful excitement and he was obliged to masturbate. + Ever since he has had an impulse to exhibit his organs and to + masturbate in the presence of women. He believes that the sight + of his organs excites the woman (<i>Ib.</i>, pp. 57-68). The presence + of masturbation in this case renders it untypical as a case of + exhibitionism. Moll at one time went so far as to assert that + when masturbation takes place we are not entitled to admit + exhibitionism, (<i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, + p. 661), but now accepts exhibitionism with masturbation + ("Perverse Sexualempfindung," <i>Krankheiten und Ehe</i>). The act of + exhibition itself gratifies the sexual impulse, and usually it + suffices to replace both tumescence and detumescence.</p> + +<p> A fairly typical case, recorded by Krafft-Ebing, is that of a + German factory worker of 37, a good, sober and intelligent + workman. His <a name='5_Page_91'></a>parents were healthy, but one of his mother's and + also one of his father's sisters were insane; some of his + relatives are eccentric in religion. He has a languishing + expression and a smile of self-complacency. He never had any + severe illness, but has always been eccentric and imaginative, + much absorbed in romances (such as Dumas's novels) and fond of + identifying himself with their heroes. No signs of epilepsy. In + youth moderate masturbation, later moderate coitus. He lives a + retired life, but is fond of elegant dress and of ornament. + Though not a drinker, he sometimes makes himself a kind of punch + which has a sexually exciting effect on him. The impulse to + exhibitionism has only developed in recent years. When the + impulse is upon him he becomes hot, his heart beats violently, + the blood rushes to his head, and he is oblivious of everything + around him that is not connected with his own act. Afterwards he + regards himself as a fool and makes vain resolutions never to + repeat the act. In exhibition the penis is only half erect and + ejaculation never occurs. (He is only capable of coitus with a + woman who shows great attraction to him.) He is satisfied with + self-exhibition, and believes that he thus gives pleasure to the + woman, since he himself receives pleasure in contemplating a + woman's sexual parts. His erotic dreams are of self-exhibition to + young and voluptuous women. He had been previously punished for + an offense of this kind; medico-legal opinion now recognized the + incriminated man's psychopathic condition. (Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. + cit.</i>, pp. 492-494.)</p> + +<p> Trochon has reported the case of a married man of 33, a worker in + a factory, who for several years had exhibited himself at + intervals to shop-girls, etc., in a state of erection, but + without speaking or making other advances. He was a hard-working, + honest, sober man of quiet habits, a good father to his family + and happy at home. He showed not the slightest sign of insanity. + But he was taciturn, melancholic and nervous; a sister was an + idiot. He was arrested, but on the report of the experts that he + committed these acts from a morbid impulse he could not control + he was released. (Trochon, <i>Archives de l'Anthropologie + Criminelle</i>, 1888, p. 256.)</p> + +<p> In a case of Freyer's (<i>Zeitschrift für Medizinalbeamte</i>, third + year, No. 8) the occasional connection of exhibitionism with + epilepsy is well illustrated by a barber's assistant, aged 35, + whose father suffered from chronic alcoholism and was also said + to have committed the same kind of offense as his son. The mother + and a sister suffered nervously. From ages of 7 to 18 the subject + had epileptic convulsions. From 16 to 21 he indulged in normal + sexual intercourse. At about that time he had often to pass a + playground and at times would urinate there; it happened that the + children watched him with curiosity. He noticed that when thus + watched sexual excitement was caused, inducing erection and even + ejaculation. He gradually found pleasure in this kind of <a name='5_Page_92'></a>sexual + gratification; finally he became indifferent to coitus. His + erotic dreams, though still usually about normal coitus, were now + sometimes concerned with exhibition before little girls. When + overcome by the impulse he could see and hear nothing around him, + though he did not lose consciousness. After the act was over he + was troubled by his deed. In all other respects he was entirely + reasonable. He was imprisoned many times for exhibiting himself + to young schoolgirls, sometimes vaunting the beauty of his organs + and inviting inspection. On one occasion he underwent mental + examination, but was considered to be mentally sound. He was + finally held to be a hereditarily tainted individual with + neuropathic constitution. The head was abnormally broad, penis + small, patellar reflex absent, and there were many signs of + neurasthenia. (Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 490-492.)</p> + +<p> The prevalence of epilepsy among exhibitionists is shown by the + observations of Pelanda in Verona. He has recorded six cases of + this perversion, all of which eventually reached the asylum and + were either epileptics or with epileptic relations. One had a + brother who was also an exhibitionist. In some cases the penis + was abnormally large, in others abnormally small. Several had + very weak sexual impulse; one, at the age of 62, had never + effected coitus, and was proud of the fact that he was still a + virgin, considering, he would say, the epoch of demoralization in + which we live. (Pelanda, "Pornopatici," <i>Archivio di + Psichiatria</i>, fasc. ii-iv, 1889.)</p> + +<p> In a very typical case of exhibitionism which Garnier has + recorded, a certain X., a gentleman engaged in business in Paris, + had a predilection for exhibiting himself in churches, more + especially in Saint-Roch. He was arrested several times for + exposing his sexual organs here before ladies in prayer. In this + way he finally ruined his commercial position in Paris and was + obliged to establish himself in a small provincial town. Here + again he soon exposed himself in a church and was again sent to + prison, but on his liberation immediately performed the same act + in the same church in what was described as a most imperturbable + manner. Compelled to leave the town, he returned to Paris, and in + a few weeks' time was again arrested for repeating his old + offense in Saint Roch. When examined by Garnier, the information + he supplied was vague and incomplete, and he was very embarrassed + in the attempt to explain himself. He was unable to say why he + chose a church, but he felt that it was to a church that he must + go. He had, however, no thought of profanation and no wish to + give offense. "Quite the contrary!" he declared. He had the sad + and tired air of a man who is dominated by a force stronger than + his will. "I know," he added, "what repulsion my conduct must + inspire. Why am I made thus? Who will cure me?" (P. Garnier, + "Perversions Sexuelles," <i>Comptes Rendus</i>, International Congress + of Medicine at Paris in 1900, <i>Section de Psychiatrie</i>, pp. + 433-435.)</p><a name='5_Page_93'></a> + +<p> In some cases, it would appear, the impulse to exhibitionism may + be overcome or may pass away. This result is the more likely to + come about in those cases in which exhibitionism has been largely + conditioned by chronic alcoholism or other influences tending to + destroy the inhibiting and restraining action of the higher + centers, which may be overcome by hygiene and treatment. In this + connection I may bring forward a case which has been communicated + to me by a medical correspondent in London. It is that of an + actor, of high standing in his profession and extremely + intelligent, 49 years of age, married and father of a large + family. He is sexually vigorous and of erotic temperament. His + general health has always been good, but he is a high-strung, + neurotic man, with quick mental reactions. His habits had for a + long time been decidedly alcoholic, but two years ago, a small + quantity of albumen being found in the urine, he was persuaded to + leave off alcohol, and has since been a teetotaller. Though + ordinarily very reticent about sexual matters, he began four or + five years ago to commit acts of exhibitionism, exposing himself + to servants in the house and occasionally to women in the + country. This continued after the alcohol had been abandoned and + lasted for several years, though the attention of the police was + never attracted to the matter, and so far as possible he was + quietly supervised by his friends. Nine months after, the acts of + exhibitionism ceased, apparently in a spontaneous manner, and + there has so far been no relapse.</p></div> + +<p>Exhibitionism is an act which, on the face of it, seems nonsensical and +meaningless, and as such, as an inexplicable act of madness, it has +frequently been treated both by writers on insanity and on sexual +perversion. "These acts are so lacking in common sense and intelligent +reflection that no other reason than insanity can be offered for the +patient," Ball concluded.<a name='5_FNanchor_55'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_55'><sup>[55]</sup></a> Moll, also, who defines exhibitionism +somewhat too narrowly as a condition in which "the charm of the exhibition +lies for the subject in the display itself," not sufficiently taking into +consideration the imagined effect on the spectator, concludes that "the +psychological basis of exhibitionism is at present by no means cleared +up."<a name='5_FNanchor_56'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_56'><sup>[56]</sup></a></p> + +<p>We may probably best approach exhibitionism by regarding it as +fundamentally a symbolic act based on a perversion of courtship. The +exhibitionist displays the organ of sex to a <a name='5_Page_94'></a>feminine witness, and in the +shock of modest sexual shame by which she reacts to that spectacle, he +finds a gratifying similitude of the normal emotions of coitus.<a name='5_FNanchor_57'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_57'><sup>[57]</sup></a> He +feels that he has effected a psychic defloration.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Exhibitionism is thus analogous, and, indeed, related, to the + impulse felt by many persons to perform indecorous acts or tell + indecent stories before young and innocent persons of the + opposite sex. This is a kind of psychic exhibitionism, the + gratification it causes lying exactly, as in physical + exhibitionism, in the emotional confusion which it is felt to + arouse. The two kinds of exhibitionism may be combined in the + same person: Thus, in a case reported by Hoche (p. 97), the + exhibitionist an intellectual and highly educated man, with a + doctor's degree, also found pleasure in sending indecent poems + and pictures to women, whom, however, he made no attempt to + seduce; he was content with the thought of the emotions he + aroused or believed that he aroused.</p> + +<p> It is possible that within this group should come the agent in + the following incident which was lately observed by a lady, a + friend of my own. An elderly man in an overcoat was seen standing + outside a large and well-known draper's shop in the outskirts of + London; when able to attract the attention of any of the + shop-girls or of any girl in the street he would fling back his + coat and reveal that he was wearing over his own clothes a + woman's chemise (or possibly bodice) and a woman's drawers; there + was no exposure. The only intelligible explanation of this action + would seem to be that pleasure was experienced in the mild shock + of interested surprise and injured modesty which this vision was + imagined to cause to a young girl. It would thus be a + comparatively innocent form of psychic defloration.</p></div> + +<p>It is of interest to point out that the sexual symbolism of active +flagellation is very closely analogous to this symbolism of exhibitionism. +The flagellant approaches a woman with the rod (itself a symbol of the +penis and in some countries bearing names which are also applied to that +organ) and inflicts on an <a name='5_Page_95'></a>intimate part of her body the signs of blushing +and the spasmodic movements which are associated with sexual excitement, +while at the same time she feels, or the flagellant imagines that she +feels, the corresponding emotions of delicious shame.<a name='5_FNanchor_58'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_58'><sup>[58]</sup></a> This is an even +closer mimicry of the sexual act than the exhibitionist attains, for the +latter fails to secure the consent of the woman nor does he enjoy any +intimate contact with her naked body. The difference is connected with the +fact that the active flagellant is usually a more virile and normal person +than the exhibitionist. In the majority of cases the exhibitionist's +sexual impulse is very feeble, and as a rule he is either to some degree a +degenerate, or else a person who is suffering from an early stage of +general paralysis, dementia, or some other highly enfeebling cause of +mental disorganization, such as chronic alcoholism. Sexual feebleness is +further indicated by the fact that the individuals selected as witnesses +are frequently mere children.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It seems probable that a form of erotic symbolism somewhat + similar to exhibitionism is to be found in the rare cases in + which sexual gratification is derived from throwing ink, acid or + other defiling liquids on women's dresses. Thoinot has recorded a + case of this kind (<i>Attentats aux Moeurs</i>, 1898, pp. 484, <i>et + seq.</i>). An instructive case has been presented by Moll. In this + case a young man of somewhat neuropathic heredity had as a youth + of 16 or 17, when romping with his young sister's playfellows, + experienced sexual sensations on chancing to see their white + underlinen. From that time white underlinen and white dresses + became to him a fetich and he was only attracted to women so + attired. One day, at the age of 25, when crossing the street in + wet weather with a young lady in a white dress, a passing vehicle + splashed the dress with mud. This incident caused him strong + sexual excitement, and from that time he had the impulse to throw + ink, perchloride of iron, etc., on to ladies' white dresses, and + sometimes to cut and tear them, sexual excitement and ejaculation + taking place every time he effected this. (Moll, "Gutachten über + einem Sexual Perversen [Besudelungstrieb]," <i>Zeitschrift für + Medizinalbeamte</i>, Heft XIII, 1900). Such a case is of + considerable psychological interest. Thoinot considers that in + these cases the fleck is a fetich. That is an incorrect account + of the matter. In this case the <a name='5_Page_96'></a>white garments constituted the + primary fetich, but that fetich becomes more acutely realized, + and at the same time both parties are thrown into an emotional + state which to the fetichist becomes a mimicry of coitus, by the + act of defilement. We may perhaps connect with this phenomenon + the attraction which muddy shoes often exert over the + shoe-fetichist, and the curious way in which, as we have seen (p. + 18), Restif de la Bretonne associates his love of neatness in + women with his attraction to the feet, the part, he remarks, + least easy to keep clean.</p> + +<p> Garnier applied the term <i>sadi-fetichism</i> to active flagellation + and many similar manifestations such as we are here concerned + with, on the grounds that they are hybrids which combine the + morbid adoration for a definite object with the impulse to + exercise a more or less degree of violence. From the standpoint + of the conception of erotic symbolism I have adopted there is no + need for this term. There is here no hybrid combination of two + unlike mental states. We are simply concerned with states of + erotic symbolism, more or less complete, more or less complex.</p></div> + +<p>The conception of exhibitionism as a process of erotic symbolism, involves +a conscious or unconscious attitude of attention in the exhibitionist's +mind to the psychic reaction of the woman toward whom his display is +directed. He seeks to cause an emotion which, probably in most cases, he +desires should be pleasurable. But from one cause or another his finer +sensibilities are always inhibited or in abeyance, and he is unable to +estimate accurately either the impression he is likely to produce or the +general results of his action, or else he is moved by a strong impulsive +obsession which overpowers his judgment. In many cases he has good reason +for believing that his act will be pleasurable, and frequently he finds +complacent witnesses among the low-class servant girls, etc.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It may be pointed out here that we are quite justified in + speaking of a penis-fetichism and also of a vulva-fetichism. This + might be questioned. We are obviously justified in recognizing a + fetichism which attaches itself to the pubic hair, or, as in a + case with which I am acquainted, to the clitoris, but it may seem + that we cannot regard the central sexual organs as symbols of + sex, symbols, as it were, of themselves. Properly regarded, + however, it is the sexual act rather than the sexual organ which + is craved in normal sexual desire; the organ is regarded merely + as the means and not as the end. Regarded as a means the organ is + indeed an object of desire, but it only becomes a fetich when it + arrests and fixes the attention. An attention thus pleasurably + fixed, a vulva-fetichism or a penis-fetichism, is within the + normal range <a name='5_Page_97'></a>of sexual emotion (this point has been mentioned in + the previous volume when discussing the part played by the + primary sexual organs in sexual selection), and in coarse-grained + natures of either sex it is a normal allurement in its + generalized shape, apart from any attraction to the person to + whom the organs belong. In some morbid cases, however, this + penis-fetichism may become a fully developed sexual perversion. A + typical case of this kind has been recorded by Howard in the + United States. Mrs. W., aged 39, was married at 20 to a strong, + healthy man, but derived no pleasure from coitus, though she + received great pleasure from masturbation practiced immediately + after coitus, and nine years after marriage she ceased actual + coitus, compelling her husband to adopt mutual masturbation. She + would introduce men into the house at all times of the day or + night, and after persuading them to expose their persons would + retire to her room to masturbate. The same man never aroused + desire more than once. This desire became so violent and + persistent that she would seek out men in all sorts of public + places and, having induced them to expose themselves, rapidly + retreat to the nearest convenient spot for self-gratification. + She once abstracted a pair of trousers she had seen a man wear + and after fondling them experienced the orgasm. Her husband + finally left her, after vainly attempting to have her confined in + an asylum. She was often arrested for her actions, but through + the intervention of friends set free again. She was a highly + intelligent woman, and apart from this perversion entirely + normal. (W. L. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," <i>Alienist and + Neurologist</i>, January, 1896.) It is on the existence of a more or + less developed penis-fetichism of this kind that the + exhibitionist, mostly by an ignorant instinct, relies for the + effects he desires to produce.</p></div> + +<p>The exhibitionist is not usually content to produce a mere titillated +amusement; he seeks to produce a more powerful effect which must be +emotional whether or not it is pleasurable. A professional man in +Strassburg (in a case reported by Hoche<a name='5_FNanchor_59'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_59'><sup>[59]</sup></a>) would walk about in the +evening in a long cloak, and when he met ladies would suddenly throw his +cloak back under a street lamp, or igniting a red-fire match, and thus +exhibit his organs. There was an evident effort—on the part of a weak, +vain, and effeminate man—to produce a maximum of emotional effect. The +attempt to heighten the emotional shock is also seen in the fact that the +exhibitionist frequently chooses a church as the scene of his exploits, +not during service, for he <a name='5_Page_98'></a>always avoids a concourse of people, but +perhaps toward evening when there are only a few kneeling women scattered +through the edifice. The church is chosen, often instinctively rather than +deliberately, from no impulse to commit a sacrilegious outrage—which, as +a rule, the exhibitionist does not feel his act to be—but because it +really presents the conditions most favorable to the act and the effects +desired. The exhibitionist's attitude of mind is well illustrated by one +of Garnier's patients who declared that he never wished to be seen by more +than two women at once, "just what is necessary," he added, "for an +exchange of impressions." After each exhibition he would ask himself +anxiously: "Did they see me? What are they thinking? What do they say to +each other about me? Oh! how I should like to know!" Another patient of +Garnier's, who haunted churches for this purpose, made this very +significant statement: "Why do I like going to churches? I can scarcely +say. <i>But I know that it is only there that my act has its full +importance</i>. The woman is in a devout frame of mind, and she must see that +such an act in such a place is not a joke in bad taste or a disgusting +obscenity; <i>that if I go there it is not to amuse myself; it is more +serious than that!</i> I watch the effect produced on the faces of the ladies +to whom I show my organs. I wish to see them express a profound joy. I +wish, in fact, that they may be forced to say to themselves: <i>How +impressive Nature is when thus seen!</i>"</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Here we trace the presence of a feeling which recalls the + phenomena of the ancient and world-wide phallic worship, still + liable to reappear sporadically. Women sometimes took part in + these rites, and the osculation of the male sexual organ or its + emblematic representation by women is easily traceable in the + phallic rites of India and many other lands, not excluding Europe + even in comparatively recent times. (Dulaure in his <i>Divinités + Génératices</i> brings together much bearing on these points; <i>cf.</i>: + Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. i, Chapter XVII, and Bloch, + <i>Beiträge zur Psychopathia Sexualis</i>, Teil I, pp. 115-117. Colin + Scott has some interesting remarks on phallic worship and the + part it has played in aiding human evolution, "Sex and Art," + <i>American Journal of Psychology</i>, vol. vii, No. 2, pp. 191-197. + Irving Rosse describes some modern phallic rites in which both + men and women took part, similar to those practiced in vaudouism, + "Sexual Hypochondriasis," <i>Virginia Medical Monthly</i>, October, + 1892.)</p><a name='5_Page_99'></a> + +<p> Putting aside any question of phallic worship, a certain pride + and more or less private feeling of ostentation in the new + expansion and development of the organs of virility seems to be + almost normal at adolescence. "We have much reason to assume," + Stanley Hall remarks, "that in a state of nature there is a + certain instinctive pride and ostentation that accompanies the + new local development. I think it will be found that + exhibitionists are usually those who have excessive growth here, + and that much that modern society stigmatizes as obscene is at + bottom more or less spontaneous and perhaps in some cases not + abnormal. Dr. Seerley tells me he has never examined a young man + largely developed who had the usual strong instinctive tendency + of modesty to cover himself with his hands, but he finds this + instinct general with those whose development is less than the + average." (G. Stanley Hall, <i>Adolescence</i>, vol. ii, p. 97.) This + instinct of ostentation, however, so far as it is normal, is held + in check by other considerations, and is not, in the strict + sense, exhibitionism. I have observed a full-grown telegraph boy + walking across Hampstead Heath with his sexual organs exposed, + but immediately he realized that he was seen he concealed them. + The solemnity of exhibitionism at this age finds expression in + the climax of the sonnet, "Oraison du Soir," written at 16 by + Rimbaud, whose verse generally is a splendid and insolent + manifestation of rank adolescence:—</p></div> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span class='i4'>"Doux comme le Seigneur du cèdre et des hysopes,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>Je pisse vers les cieux bruns très haut et très loin,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>Avec l'assentiment des grands héliotropes."<br /></span> +</div><div class='stanza'> +<span class='i4'>(J. A. Rimbaud, <i>Œuvres</i>, p. 68.)<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In women, also, there would appear to be traceable a somewhat + similar ostentation, though in them it is complicated and largely + inhibited by modesty, and at the same time diffused over the body + owing to the absence of external sexual organs. "Primitive + woman," remarks Madame Renooz, "proud of her womanhood, for a + long time defended her nakedness which ancient art has always + represented. And in the actual life of the young girl to-day + there is a moment when by a secret atavism she feels the pride of + her sex, the intuition of her moral superiority, and cannot + understand why she must hide its cause. At this moment, wavering + between the laws of Nature and social conventions, she scarcely + knows if nakedness should or should not affright her. A sort of + confused atavistic memory recalls to her a period before clothing + was known, and reveals to her as a paradisaical ideal the customs + of that human epoch." (Céline Renooz, <i>Psychologie Comparée de + l'Homme et de la Femme</i>, p. 85.) It may be added that among + primitive peoples, and even among some remote European + populations to-day, the exhibition of feminine nudity has + sometimes been regarded as a spectacle with religious or magic + operation. (Ploss, <i>Das Weib</i>, seventh edition, vol. ii, <a name='5_Page_100'></a>pp. + 663-680; Havelock Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i>, fourth edition, p. + 304.) It is stated by Gopcevic that in the long struggle between + the Albanians and the Montenegrians the women of the former + people would stand in the front rank and expose themselves by + raising their skirts, believing that they would thus insure + victory. As, however, they were shot down, and as, moreover, + victory usually fell to the Montenegrians, this custom became + discredited. (Quoted by Bloch, <i>Op. cit.</i>, Teil II, p. 307.)</p> + +<p> With regard to the association, suggested by Stanley Hall, + between exhibitionism and an unusual degree of development of the + sexual organs, it must be remarked that both extremes—a very + large and a very small penis—are specially common in + exhibitionists. The prevalence of the small organ is due to an + association of exhibitionism with sexual feebleness. The + prevalence of the large organ may be due to the cause suggested + by Hall. Among Mahommedans the sexual organs are sometimes + habitually exposed by religious penitents, and I note that + Bernhard Stern, in his book on the medical and sexual aspects of + life in Turkey, referring to a penitent of this sort whom he saw + on the Stamboul bridge at Constantinople, remarks that the organ + was very largely developed. It may well be in such a case that + the penitent's religious attitude is reinforced by some lingering + relic of a more fleshly ostentation.</p></div> + +<p>It is by a pseudo-atavism that this phallicism is evoked in the +exhibitionist. There is no true emergence of an ancestrally inherited +instinct, but by the paralysis or inhibition of the finer and higher +feelings current in civilization, the exhibitionist is placed on the same +mental level as the man of a more primitive age, and he thus presents the +basis on which the impulses belonging to a higher culture may naturally +take root and develop.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Reference may here be made to a form of primitive exhibitionism, + almost confined to women, which, although certainly symbolic, is + absolutely non-sexual, and must not, therefore, be confused with + the phenomena we are here occupied with. I refer to the + exhibition of the buttocks as a mark of contempt. In its most + primitive form, no doubt, this exhibitionism is a kind of + exorcism, a method of putting evil spirits, primarily, and + secondarily evil-disposed persons, to flight. It is the most + effective way for a woman to display sexual centers, and it + shares in the magical virtues which all unveiling of the sexual + centers is believed by primitive peoples to possess. It is + recorded that the women of some peoples in the Balkan peninsula + formerly used this gesture against enemies in battle. In the + sixteenth century so distinguished a theologian as Luther when + assailed by the Evil One at night was able to put the adversary + to flight by protruding his uncovered buttocks <a name='5_Page_101'></a>from the bed. But + the spiritual significance of this attitude is lost with the + decay of primitive beliefs. It survives, but merely as a gesture + of insult. The symbolism comes to have reference to the nates as + the excretory focus, the seat of the anus. In any case it ignores + any sexual attractiveness in this part of the body. Exhibitionism + of this kind, therefore, can scarcely arise in persons of any + sensitiveness or æsthetic perception, even putting aside the + question of modesty, and there seems to be little trace of it in + classic antiquity when the nates were regarded as objects of + beauty. Among the Egyptians, however, we gather from Herodotus + (Bk. II, Chapter LX) that at a certain popular religious festival + men and women would go in boats on the Nile, singing and playing, + and when they approached a town the women on the boats would + insult the women of the town by injurious language and by + exposing themselves. Among the Arabs, however, the specific + gesture we are concerned with is noted, and a man to whom + vengeance is forbidden would express his feelings by exposing his + posterior and strewing earth on his head (Wellhausen, <i>Rests + Arabischen Heidentums</i>, 1897, p. 195). It is in Europe and in + mediæval and later times that this emphatic gesture seems to have + flourished as a violent method of expressing contempt. It was by + no means confined to the lower classes, and Kleinpaul, in + discussing this form of "speech without words," quotes examples + of various noble persons, even princesses, who are recorded thus + to have expressed their feelings. (Kleinpaul, <i>Sprache ohne + Worte</i>, pp. 271-273.) In more recent times the gesture has become + merely a rare and extreme expression of unrestrained feeling in + coarse-grained peasants. Zola, in the figure of Mouquette in + <i>Germinal</i>, may be said to have given a kind of classic + expression to the gesture. In the more remote parts of Europe it + appears to be still not altogether uncommon. This seems to be + notably the case among the South Slavs, and Krauss states that + "when a South Slav woman wishes to express her deepest contempt + for anyone she bends forward, with left hand raising her skirts, + and with the right slapping her posterior, at the same time + exclaiming: 'This for you!'" (Κρυπτάδια, vol. vi, p. + 200.)</p> + +<p> A verbal survival of this gesture, consisting in the contemptuous + invitation to kiss this region, still exists among us in remote + parts of the country, especially as an insult offered by an angry + woman who forgets herself. It is said to be commonly used in + Wales. ("Welsh Ædœlogy," Κρυπτάδια, vol. ii, + pp. 358, <i>et seq.</i>) In Cornwall, when addressed by a woman to a + man it is sometimes regarded as a deadly insult, even if the + woman is young and attractive, and may cause a life-long enmity + between related families. From this point of view the nates are a + symbol of contempt, and any sexual significance is excluded. (The + distinction is brought out by Diderot in <i>Le Neveu de Rameau:</i> + "<i>Lui:</i>—Il y a d'autres jours ou il ne m'en coûterait rien pour + être vil tant <a name='5_Page_102'></a>qu'on voudrait; ces jours-là, pour un liard, je + baiserais le cul à la petite Hus. <i>Moi:</i>—Eh! mais, l'ami, elle + est blanche, jolie, douce, potelée, et c'est un acte d'humilité + auquel un plus delicat que vous pourrait quelquefois s'abaisser. + <i>Lui:</i>—Entendons-nous; c'est qu'il y a baiser le cul au simple, + et baiser le cul au figuré.")</p> + +<p> It must be added that a sexual form of exhibitionism of the nates + must still be recognized. It occurs in masochism and expresses + the desire for passive flagellation. Rousseau, whose emotional + life was profoundly affected by the castigations which as a child + he received from Mlle Lambercier, has in his <i>Confessions</i> told + us how, when a youth, he would sometimes expose himself in this + way in the presence of young women. Such masochistic + exhibitionism seems, however, to be rare.</p></div> + +<p>While the manifestations of exhibitionism are substantially the same in +all cases, there are many degrees and varieties of the condition. We may +find among exhibitionists, as Garnier remarks, dementia, states of +unconsciousness, epilepsy, general paralysis, alcoholism, but the most +typical cases, he adds, if not indeed the cases to which the term properly +belongs, are those in which it is an impulsive obsession. Krafft-Ebing<a name='5_FNanchor_60'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_60'><sup>[60]</sup></a> +divides exhibitionists into four clinical groups: (1) acquired states of +mental weakness, with cerebral or spinal disease clouding consciousness +and at the same time causing impotence; (2) epileptics, in whom the act is +an abnormal organic impulse performed in a state of imperfect +consciousness; (3) a somewhat allied group of neurasthenic cases; (4) +periodical impulsive cases with deep hereditary taint. This classification +is not altogether satisfactory. Garnier's classification, placing the +group of obsessional cases in the foreground and leaving the other more +vaguely defined groups in the background, is probably better. I am +inclined to consider that most of the cases fall into one or other of two +mixed groups. The first class includes cases in which there is more or +less congenital abnormality, but otherwise a fair or even complete degree +of mental integrity; they are usually young adults, they are more or less +precisely conscious of the end they wish to attain, and it is often only +with a severe struggle that they yield to their impulses. In the second +class the <a name='5_Page_103'></a>beginnings of mental or nervous disease have diminished the +sensibility of the higher centers; the subjects are usually old men whose +lives have been absolutely correct; they are often only vaguely aware of +the nature of the satisfaction they are seeking, and frequently no +struggle precedes the manifestation; such was the case of the overworked +clergyman described by Hughes,<a name='5_FNanchor_61'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_61'><sup>[61]</sup></a> who, after much study, became morose +and absent-minded, and committed acts of exhibitionism which he could not +explain but made no attempt to deny; with rest and restorative treatment +his health improved and the acts ceased. It is in the first class of cases +alone that there is a developed sexual perversion. In the cases of the +second class there is a more or less definite sexual intention, but it is +only just conscious, and the emergence of the impulse is due not to its +strength but to the weakness, temporary or permanent, of the higher +inhibiting centers.</p> + +<p>Epileptic cases, with loss of consciousness during the act, can only be +regarded as presenting a pseudo-exhibitionism. They should be excluded +altogether. It is undoubtedly true that many cases of real or apparent +exhibitionism occur in epileptics.<a name='5_FNanchor_62'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_62'><sup>[62]</sup></a> We must not, however, too hastily +conclude that because these acts occur in epileptics they are necessarily +unconscious acts. Epilepsy frequently occurs on a basis of hereditary +degeneration, and the exhibitionism may be, and not infrequently is, a +stigma of the degeneracy and not an indication of the occurrence of a +minor epileptic fit. When the act of pseudo-exhibitionism is truly +epileptic, it will usually have no psychic sexual content, and it will +certainly be liable to occur under all sorts of circumstances, when the +patient is alone or in a miscellaneous concourse of people. It will be on +a level with the acts of the highly respectable young woman who, at the +conclusion of an attack of <i>petit mal</i>, consisting chiefly of a sudden +desire to pass urine, on <a name='5_Page_104'></a>one occasion lifted up her clothes and urinated +at a public entertainment, so that it was with difficulty her friends +prevented her from being handed over to the police.<a name='5_FNanchor_63'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_63'><sup>[63]</sup></a> Such an act is +automatic, unconscious, and involuntary; the spectators are not even +perceived; it cannot be an act of exhibitionism. Whenever, on the other +hand, the place and the time are evidently chosen deliberately,—a quiet +spot, the presence of only one or two young women or children,—it is +difficult to admit that we are in the presence of a fit of epileptic +unconsciousness, even when the subject is known to be epileptic.</p> + +<p>Even, however, when we exclude those epileptic pseudo-exhibitionists who, +from the legal point of view, are clearly irresponsible, it must still be +remembered that in every case of exhibitionism there is a high degree of +either mental abnormality on a neuropathic basis, or else of actual +disease. This is true to a greater extent in exhibitionism than in almost +any other form of sexual perversion. No subject of exhibitionism should be +sent to prison without expert medical examination.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_54'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_54'>[54]</a><div class='note'><p> Lasège first drew attention to this sexual perversion and +gave it its generally accepted name, "Les Exhibitionistes," <i>L'Union +Médicale</i>, May, 1877. Magnan, on various occasions (for example, "Les +Exhibitionistes," <i>Archives de l'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, vol. v, 1890, +p. 456), has given further development and precision to the clinical +picture of the exhibitionist.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_55'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_55'>[55]</a><div class='note'><p> B. Ball. <i>La Folie Erotique</i>, p. 86.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_56'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_56'>[56]</a><div class='note'><p> Moll, <i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. +661.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_57'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_57'>[57]</a><div class='note'><p> "Exhibitionism in its most typical form is," Garnier truly +says, "a <i>systematic act</i>, manifesting itself as the <i>strange equivalent +of a sexual connection</i>, or its <i>substitution</i>." The brief account of +exhibitionism (pp. 433-437) in Garnier's discussion of "Perversions +Sexuelles" at the International Medical Congress at Paris in 1900 +(<i>Section de Psychiatrie: Comptes-Rendus</i>) is the most satisfactory +statement of the psychological aspects of this perversion with which I am +acquainted. Garnier's unrivalled clinical knowledge of these +manifestations, due to his position during many years as physician at the +Depôt of the Prefecture of Police in Paris, adds great weight to his +conclusions.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_58'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_58'>[58]</a><div class='note'><p> The symbolism of coitus involved in flagellation has been +touched on by Eulenburg (<i>Sexuale Neuropathie</i>, p. 121), and is more fully +developed by Dühren (<i>Geschlechtsleben in England</i>, bd. ii, pp. 366, <i>et +seq.</i>).</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_59'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_59'>[59]</a><div class='note'><p> A. Hoche, <i>Neurologische Centralblatt</i>, 1896, No. 2.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_60'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_60'>[60]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 478, <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_61'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_61'>[61]</a><div class='note'><p> C. H. Hughes, "Morbid Exhibitionism," <i>Alienist and +Neurologist</i>, August, 1904. Another somewhat similar American case, also +preceded by overwork, and eventually adjudged insane by the courts, is +recorded by D. S. Booth, <i>Alienist and Neurologist</i>, February, 1905.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_62'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_62'>[62]</a><div class='note'><p> Exhibitionism in epilepsy is briefly discussed by Féré, +<i>L'Instinct Sexuel</i>, second edition, pp. 194-195.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_63'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_63'>[63]</a><div class='note'><p> W. S. Colman, "Post-Epileptic Unconscious Automatic Actions," +<i>Lancet</i>, July 5, 1890.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_E_VI'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_105'></a>VI.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Forms of Erotic Symbolism are Simulacra of Coitus—Wide Extension of +Erotic Symbolism—Fetichism Not Covering the Whole Ground of Sexual +Selection—It is Based on the Individual Factor in +Selection—Crystallization—The Lover and the Artist—The Key to Erotic +Symbolism to be Found in the Emotional Sphere—The Passage to Pathological +Extremes.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>We have now examined several very various and yet very typical +manifestations in all of which it is not difficult to see how, in some +strange and eccentric form—on a basis of association through resemblance +or contiguity or both combined—there arises a definite mimicry of the +normal sexual act together with the normal emotions which accompany that +act. It has become clear in what sense we are justified in recognizing +erotic symbolism.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The symbolic and, as it were, abstracted nature of these + manifestations is shown by the remarkable way in which they are + sometimes capable of transference from the object to the subject. + That is to say that the fetichist may show a tendency to + cultivate his fetich in his own person. A foot-fetichist may like + to go barefoot himself; a man who admired lame women liked to + halt himself; a man who was attracted by small waists in women + found sexual gratification in tight-lacing himself; a man who was + fascinated by fine white skin and wished to cut it found + satisfaction in cutting his own skin; Moll's coprolagnic + fetichist found a voluptuous pleasure in his own acts of + defecation. (See, <i>e.g.</i>, Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. cit.</i>, p. 221, 224, + 226; Hammond, <i>Sexual Impotence</i>, p. 74; <i>cf.</i> <i>ante</i>, p. 68.) + Such symbolic transference seems to have a profoundly natural + basis, for we may see a somewhat similar phenomenon in the + well-known tendency of cows to mount a cow in heat. This would + appear to be, not so much a homosexual impulse, as the dynamic + psychic action of an olfactory sexual symbol in a transformed + form.</p> + +<p> We seem to have here a psychic process which is a curious + reversal of that process of <i>Einfühlung</i>—the projection of one's + own activities into the object contemplated—which Lipps has so + fruitfully developed as the essence of every æsthetic condition. + (T. Lipps, <i>Æsthetik</i>, Teil I, 1903.) By <i>Einfühlung</i> our own + interior activity becomes the activity <a name='5_Page_106'></a>of the object perceived, + a thing being beautiful in proportion as it lends itself to our + <i>Einfühlung</i>. But by this action of erotic symbolism, on the + other hand, we transfer the activity of the object into + ourselves.</p></div> + +<p>When the idea of erotic symbolism as manifested in such definite and +typical forms becomes realized, it further becomes clear that the vaguer +manifestations of such symbolism are exceedingly widespread. When in a +previous volume we were discussing and drawing together the various +threads which unite "Love and Pain," it will now be understood that we +were standing throughout on the threshold of erotic symbolism. Pain +itself, in the sense in which we slowly learned to define it in this +relationship—as a state of intense emotional excitement—may, under a +great variety of special circumstances, become an erotic symbol and afford +the same relief as the emotions normally accompanying the sexual act. +Active algolagnia or sadism is thus a form of erotic symbolism; passive +algolagnia or masochism is (in a man) an inverted form of erotic +symbolism. Active flagellation or passive flagellation are, in exactly the +same way, manifestations of erotic symbolism, the imaginative mimicry of +coitus.</p> + +<p>Binet and also Krafft-Ebing<a name='5_FNanchor_64'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_64'><sup>[64]</sup></a> have argued in effect that the whole of +sexual selection is a matter of fetichism, that is to say, of erotic +symbolism of object. "Normal love," Binet states, "appears as the result +of a complicated fetichism." Tarde also seems to have regarded love as +normally a kind of fetichism. "We are a long time before we fall in love +with a woman," he remarks; "we must wait to see the detail which strikes +and delights us, and causes us to overlook what displeases us. Only in +normal love the details are many and always changing. Constancy in love is +rarely anything else but a voyage around the beloved person, a voyage of +exploration and ever new discoveries. The most faithful lover does not +love the same woman in the same way for two days in succession."<a name='5_FNanchor_65'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_65'><sup>[65]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_107'></a> +<p>From that point of view normal sexual love is the sway of a fetich—more +or less arbitrary, more or less (as Binet terms it) polytheistic—and it +can have little objective basis. But, as we saw when considering "Sexual +Selection in Man" in the previous volume, more especially when analyzing +the notion of beauty, we are justified in believing that beauty has to a +large extent an objective basis, and that love by no means depends simply +on the capricious selection of some individual fetich. The individual +factor, as we saw, is but one of many factors which constitute beauty. In +the study of sexual selection that individual factor was passed over very +lightly. We now see that it is often a factor of great importance, for in +it are rooted all these outgrowths—normal in their germs, highly abnormal +in their more extreme developments—which make up erotic symbolism.</p> + +<p>Erotic symbolism is therefore concerned with all that is least generic, +least specific, all that is most intimately personal and individual, in +sexual selection. It is the final point in which the decreasing circle of +sexual attractiveness is fixed. In the widest and most abstract form +sexual selection in man is merely human, and we are attracted to that +which bears most fully the marks of humanity; in a less abstract form it +is sexual, and we are attracted to that which most vigorously presents the +secondary sexual characteristics; still narrowing, it is the type of our +own nation and people that appeals most strongly to us in matters of love; +and still further concentrating we are affected by the ideal—in +civilization most often the somewhat exotic ideal—of our own day, the +fashion of our own city. But the individual factor still remains, and amid +the infinite possibilities of erotic symbolism the individual may evolve +an ideal which is often, as far as he knows and perhaps in actuality, an +absolutely unique event in the history of the human soul.</p> + +<p>Erotic symbolism works in its finer manifestations by means of the +idealizing aptitudes; it is the field of sexual psychology in which that +faculty of crystallization, on which Stendhal loved to dwell, achieves its +most brilliant results. In the solitary passage in which we seem to see a +smile on the face of the austere <a name='5_Page_108'></a>poet of the <i>De Rerum Naturâ</i>, Lucretius +tells us how every lover, however he may be amused by the amorous +extravagances of other men, is himself blinded by passion: if his mistress +is black she is a fascinating brunette, if she squints she is the rival of +Pallas, if too tall she is majestic, if too short she is one of the +Graces, <i>tota merum sal</i>; if too lean it is her delicate refinement, if +too fat then a Ceres, dirty and she disdains adornment, a chatterer and +brilliantly vivacious, silent and it is her exquisite modesty.<a name='5_FNanchor_66'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_66'><sup>[66]</sup></a> Sixteen +hundred years later Robert Burton, when describing the symptoms of love, +made out a long and appalling list of the physical defects which the lover +is prepared to admire.<a name='5_FNanchor_67'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_67'><sup>[67]</sup></a></p> + +<p>Yet we must not be too certain that the lover is wrong in this matter. We +too hastily assume that the casual and hasty judgment of the world is +necessarily more reliable, more conformed to what we call "truth," than +the judgment of the lover which is founded on absorbed and patient study. +In some cases where there is lack of intelligence in the lover and +dissimulation in the object of his love, it may be so. But even a poem or +a picture will often not reveal its beauty except by the expenditure of +time and study. It is foolish to expect that the secret beauty of a human +person will reveal itself more easily. The lover is an artist, an artist +who constructs an image, it is true, but only by patient and concentrated +attention to nature; he knows the defects of his image, probably better +than anyone, but he knows also that art lies, not in the avoidance of +defects, but in the realization of those traits which swallow up defects +and so render them non-existent. A great artist, Rodin, after a life spent +in the study of Nature, has declared that for art there is no ugliness in +Nature. "I have arrived at this belief by the study of Nature," he said; +"I can only grasp the beauty of the soul by the beauty of the body, but +some day one will come who will explain what I only catch a glimpse of and +will declare how the whole earth is beautiful, and all human beings +beautiful. I have never been able to say this in sculpture so well as I +wish <a name='5_Page_109'></a>and as I feel it affirmed within me. For poets Beauty has always +been some particular landscape, some particular woman; but it should be +all women, all landscapes. A negro or a Mongol has his beauty, however +remote from ours, and it must be the same with their characters. There is +no ugliness. When I was young I made that mistake, as others do; I could +not undertake a woman's bust unless I thought her pretty, according to my +particular idea of beauty; to-day I should do the bust of any woman, and +it would be just as beautiful. And however ugly a woman may look, when she +is with her lover she becomes beautiful; there is beauty in her character, +in her passions, and beauty exists as soon as character or passion becomes +visible, for the body is a casting on which passions are imprinted. And +even without that, there is always the blood that flows in the veins and +the air that fills the lungs."<a name='5_FNanchor_68'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_68'><sup>[68]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The saint, also, is here at one with the lover and the artist. The man who +has so profoundly realized the worth of his fellow men that he is ready +even to die in order to save them, feels that he has discovered a great +secret. Cyples traces the "secret delights" that have thus risen in the +hearts of holy men to the same source as the feelings generated between +lovers, friends, parents, and children. "A few have at intervals walked in +the world," he remarks, "who have, each in his own original way, found out +this marvel.... Straightway man in general has become to them so sweet a +thing that the infatuation has seemed to the rest of their fellows to be a +celestial madness. Beggars' rags to their unhesitating lips grew fit for +kissing, because humanity had touched the garb; there were no longer any +menial acts, but only welcome services.... Remember by how much man is the +subtlest circumstance in the world; at how many points he can attach +relationships; how manifold and perennial he is in his results. All other +things are dull, meager, tame beside him."<a name='5_FNanchor_69'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_69'><sup>[69]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_110'></a> +<p>It may be added that even if we still believe that lover and artist and +saint are drawing the main elements of their conceptions from the depths +of their own consciousness, there is a sense in which they are coming +nearer to the truth of things than those for whom their conceptions are +mere illusions. The aptitude for realizing beauty has involved an +adjustment of the nerves and the associated brain centers through +countless ages that began before man was. When the vision of supreme +beauty is slowly or suddenly realized by anyone, with a reverberation that +extends throughout his organism, he has attained to something which for +his species, and for far more than his species, is truth, and can only be +illusion to one who has artificially placed himself outside the stream of +life.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In an essay on "The Gods as Apparitions of the Race-Life," Edward + Carpenter, though in somewhat Platonic phraseology, thus well + states the matter: "The youth sees the girl; it may be a chance + face, a chance outline, amid the most banal surroundings. But it + gives the cue. There is a memory, a confused reminiscence. The + mortal figure without penetrates to the immortal figure within, + and there rises into consciousness a shining form, glorious, not + belonging to this world, but vibrating with the agelong life of + humanity, and the memory of a thousand love-dreams. The waking of + this vision intoxicates the man; it glows and burns within him; a + goddess (it may be Venus herself) stands in the sacred place of + his temple; a sense of awe-struck splendor fills him, and the + world is changed." "He sees something" (the same writer continues + in a subsequent essay, "Beauty and Duty") "which, in a sense, is + more real than the figures in the street, for he sees something + that has lived and moved for hundreds of years in the heart of + the race; something which has been one of the great formative + influences of his own life, and which has done as much to create + those very figures in the street as qualities in the circulation + of the blood may do to form a finger or other limb. He comes into + touch with a very real Presence or Power—one of those organic + centers of growth in the life of humanity—and feels this larger + life within himself, subjective, if you like, and yet intensely + objective. And more. For is it not also evident that the woman, + the mortal woman who excites his Vision, <i>has</i> some closest + relation to it, and is, indeed, far more than a mere mask or + empty formula which reminds him of it? For she indeed has within + her, just as much as the <a name='5_Page_111'></a>man has, deep subconscious Powers + working; and the ideal which has dawned so entrancingly on the + man is in all probability closely related to that which has been + working most powerfully in the heredity of the woman, and which + has most contributed to mold <i>her</i> form and outline. No wonder, + then, that her form should remind him of it. Indeed, when he + looks into her eyes he sees <i>through</i> to a far deeper life even + than she herself may be aware of, and yet which is truly hers—a + life perennial and wonderful. The more than mortal in him beholds + the more than mortal in her; and the gods descend to meet." + (Edward Carpenter, <i>The Art of Creation</i>, pp. 137, 186.)</p></div> + +<p>It is this mighty force which lies behind and beneath the aberrations we +have been concerned with, a great reservoir from which they draw the +life-blood that vivifies even their most fantastic shapes. Fetichism and +the other forms of erotic symbolism are but the development and the +isolation of the crystallizations which normally arise on the basis of +sexual selection. Normal in their basis, in their extreme forms they +present the utmost pathological aberrations of the sexual instinct which +can be attained or conceived. In the intermediate space all degrees are +possible. In the slightest degree the symbol is merely a specially +fascinating and beloved feature in a person who is, in all other respects, +felt to be lovable; as such its recognition is a legitimate part of +courtship, an effective aid to tumescence. In a further degree the symbol +is the one arresting and attracting character of a person who must, +however, still be felt as a sexually attractive individual. In a still +further degree of perversion the symbol is effective, even though the +person with whom it is associated is altogether unattractive. In the final +stage the person and even all association with a person disappear +altogether from the field of sexual consciousness; the abstract symbol +rules supreme.</p> + +<p>Long, however, before the symbol has reached that final climax of morbid +intensity we may be said to have passed beyond the sphere of sexual love. +A person, not an abstracted quality, must be the goal of love. So long as +the fetich is subordinated to the person it serves to heighten love. But +love must be based on a complexus of attractive qualities, or it has no +<a name='5_Page_112'></a>stability.<a name='5_FNanchor_70'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_70'><sup>[70]</sup></a> As soon as the fetich becomes isolated and omnipotent, so +that the person sinks into the background as an unimportant appendage of +the fetich, all stability is lost. The fetichist now follows an impersonal +and abstract symbol withersoever it may lead him.</p> + +<p>It has been seen that there are an extraordinary number of forms in which +erotic symbolism may be felt. It must be remembered, and it cannot be too +distinctly emphasized, that the links that bind together the forms of +erotic symbolism are not to be found in objects or even in acts, but in +the underlying emotion. A feeling is the first condition of the symbol, a +feeling which recalls, by a subtle and unconscious automatic association +of resemblance or of contiguity, some former feeling. It is the similarity +of emotion, instinctively apprehended, which links on a symbol only +partially sexual, or even apparently not sexual at all, to the great +central focus of sexual emotion, the great dominating force which brings +the symbol its life-blood.<a name='5_FNanchor_71'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_71'><sup>[71]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The cases of sexual hyperæsthesia, quoted at the beginning of this study, +do but present in a morbidly comprehensive and sensitive form those +possibilities of erotic symbolism which, in some degree, or at some +period, are latent in most persons. They are genuinely instinctive and +automatic, and have nothing in common with that fanciful and deliberate +play of the intelligence around sexual imagery—not infrequently seen in +abnormal and insane persons—which has no significance for sexual +psychology.</p> + +<p>It is to the extreme individualization involved by the developments of +erotic symbolism that the fetichist owes his morbid and perilous +isolation. The lover who is influenced by all the elements of sexual +selection is always supported by the fellow-feeling of a larger body of +other human beings; he has behind him his species, his sex, his nation, or +at the very least a fashion. Even the inverted lover in most cases is soon +able to create <a name='5_Page_113'></a>around him an atmosphere constituted by persons whose +ideals resemble his own. But it is not so with the erotic symbolist. He is +nearly always alone. He is predisposed to isolation from the outset, for +it would seem to be on a basis of excessive shyness and timidity that the +manifestations of erotic symbolism are most likely to develop. When at +length the symbolist realizes his own aspirations—which seem to him for +the most part an altogether new phenomenon in the world—and at the same +time realizes the wide degree in which they deviate from those of the rest +of mankind, his natural secretiveness is still further reinforced. He +stands alone. His most sacred ideals are for all those around him a +childish absurdity, or a disgusting obscenity, possibly a matter calling +for the intervention of the policeman. We have forgotten that all these +impulses which to us seem so unnatural—this adoration of the foot and +other despised parts of the body, this reverence for the excretory acts +and products, the acceptance of congress with animals, the solemnity of +self-exhibition—were all beliefs and practices which, to our remote +forefathers, were bound up with the highest conceptions of life and the +deepest ardors of religion.</p> + +<p>A man cannot, however, deviate at once so widely and so spontaneously in +his impulses from the rest of the world in which he himself lives without +possessing an aboriginally abnormal temperament. At the very least he +exhibits a neuropathic sensitiveness to abnormal impressions. Not +infrequently there is more than this, the distinct stigmata of +degeneration, sometimes a certain degree of congenital feeble-mindedness +or a tendency to insanity.</p> + +<p>Yet, regarded as a whole, and notwithstanding the frequency with which +they witness to congenital morbidity, the phenomena of erotic symbolism +can scarcely fail to be profoundly impressive to the patient and impartial +student of the human soul. They often seem absurd, sometimes disgusting, +occasionally criminal; they are always, when carried to an extreme degree, +abnormal. But of all the manifestations of sexual psychology, normal and +abnormal, they are the most specifically human. More than any others they +involve the <a name='5_Page_114'></a>potently plastic force of the imagination. They bring before +us the individual man, not only apart from his fellows, but in opposition, +himself creating his own paradise. They constitute the supreme triumph of +human idealism.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_64'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_64'>[64]</a><div class='note'><p> Binet, <i>Etudes de Psychologie Expérimentale</i>, esp., p. 84; +Krafft-Ebing, <i>Op. cit.</i>, p. 18.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_65'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_65'>[65]</a><div class='note'><p> G. Tarde, "L'Amour Morbide," <i>Archives de l'Anthropologie +Criminelle</i>, 1890, p. 585.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_66'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_66'>[66]</a><div class='note'><p> Lucretius, Lib. IV, vv. 1150-1163.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_67'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_67'>[67]</a><div class='note'><p> Burton, <i>Anatomy of Melancholy</i>, Part III, Section II, Mem. +III, Subs. I.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_68'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_68'>[68]</a><div class='note'><p> Judith Cladel, <i>Auguste Rodin Pris sur la Vie</i>, 1903, pp. +103-104. Some slight modifications have been made in the translation of +this passage on account of the conversational form of the original.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_69'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_69'>[69]</a><div class='note'><p> W. Cyples, <i>The Process of Human Experience</i>, p. 462. Even +if (as we have already seen, <i>ante</i>, p. 58) the saint cannot always feel +actual physical pleasure in the intimate contact of humanity, the ardor of +devoted service which his vision of humanity arouses remains unaffected.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_70'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_70'>[70]</a><div class='note'><p> "To love," as Stendhal defined it (<i>De l'Amour</i>, Chapter +II), "is to have pleasure in seeing, touching, and feeling by all the +senses, and as near as possible, a beloved object by whom one is oneself +loved."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_71'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_71'>[71]</a><div class='note'><p> Pillon's study of "La Mémoire Affective" (<i>Revue +Philosophique</i>, February, 1901) helps to explain the psychic mechanism of +the process.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_THE_MECHANISM_OF_DETUMESCENCE'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_115'></a>THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE.</h2> + +<a name='5_M_I'></a><h3>I.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Psychological Significance of Detumescence—The Testis and the +Ovary—Sperm Cell and Germ Cell—Development of the Embryo—The External +Sexual Organs—Their Wide Range of Variation—Their Nervous Supply—The +Penis—Its Racial Variations—The Influence of Exercise—The Scrotum and +Testicles—The Mons Veneris—The Vulva—The Labia Majora and their +Varieties—The Pubic Hair and Its Characters—The Clitoris and Its +Functions—The Anus as an Erogenous Zone—The Nymphæ and their +Function—The Vagina—The Hymen—Virginity—The Biological Significance of +the Hymen.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>In analyzing the sexual impulse we have seen that the process whereby the +conjunction of the sexes is achieved falls naturally into two phases: the +first phase, of tumescence, during which force is generated in the +organism, and the second phase, of detumescence, in which that force is +discharged during conjugation.<a name='5_FNanchor_72'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_72'><sup>[72]</sup></a> Hitherto we have been occupied mainly +with the first phase, that of tumescence, and with its associated psychic +phenomena. It was inevitable that this should be so, for it is during the +slow process of tumescence that sexual selection is decided, the +crystallizations of love elaborated, and, to a large extent, the +individual erotic symbols determined. But we can by no means altogether +pass over the final phase of detumescence. Its consideration, it is true, +brings us directly into the field of anatomy and physiology; while +tumescence is largely under control of the will, when the moment of +detumescence arrives the reins slip from the control of the will; the more +fundamental and uncontrollable impulses of the organism <a name='5_Page_116'></a>gallop on +unchecked; the chariot of Phaëthon dashes blindly down into a sea of +emotion.</p> + +<p>Yet detumescence is the end and climax of the whole drama; it is an +anatomico-physiological process, certainly, but one that inevitably +touches psychology at every point.<a name='5_FNanchor_73'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_73'><sup>[73]</sup></a> It is, indeed, the very key to the +process of tumescence, and unless we understand and realize very precisely +what it is that happens during detumescence, our psychological analysis of +the sexual impulse must remain vague and inadequate.</p> + +<p>From the point of view we now occupy, a man and a woman are no longer two +highly sensitive organisms vibrating, voluptuously it may indeed be, but +vaguely and indefinitely, to all kinds of influences and with fluctuating +impulses capable of being directed into any channel, even in the highest +degree divergent from the proper ends of procreation. They are now two +genital organisms who exist to propagate the race, and whatever else they +may be, they must be adequately constituted to effect the act by which the +future of the race is ensured. We have to consider what are the material +conditions which ensure the most satisfactory and complete fulfillment of +this act, and how those conditions may be correlated with other +circumstances in the organism. In thus approaching the subject we shall +find that we have not really abandoned the study of the psychic aspects of +sex.</p> + +<p>The two most primary sexual organs are the testis and the ovary; it is the +object of conjugation to bring into contact the sperm from the testis with +the germ from the ovary. There is no reason to suppose that the germ-cell +and the sperm-cell are essentially different from each other. Sexual +conjugation thus remains a process which is radically the same as the +non-sexual mode of propagation which preceded it. The fusion of the nuclei +of the two cells was regarded by Van Beneden, who in 1875 first accurately +described it, as a process of conjugation comparable to that of the +protozoa and the protophyta. Boveri, <a name='5_Page_117'></a>who has further extended our +knowledge of the process, considers that the spermatozoon removes an +inhibitory influence preventing the commencement of development in the +ovum; the spermatozoon replaces a portion of the ovum which has already +undergone degeneration, so that the object of conjugation is chiefly to +effect the union of the properties of two cells in one, sexual +fertilization achieving a division of labor with reciprocal inhibition; +the two cells have renounced their original faculty of separate +development in order to attain a fusion of qualities and thus render +possible that production of new forms and qualities which has involved the +progress of the organized world.<a name='5_FNanchor_74'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_74'><sup>[74]</sup></a></p> + +<p>While in fishes this conjugation of the male and female elements is +usually ensured by the female casting her spawn into an artificial nest +outside the body, on to which the male sheds his milt, in all animals +(and, to some extent, birds, who occupy an intermediate position) there is +an organic nest, or incubation chamber as Bland Sutton terms it, the womb, +in the female body, wherein the fertilized egg may develop to a high +degree of maturity sheltered from those manifold risks of the external +world which make it necessary for the spawn of fishes to be so enormous in +amount. Since, however, men and women have descended from remote ancestors +who, in the manner of aquatic creatures, exercised functions of +sperm-extrusion and germ-extrusion that were exactly analogous in the two +sexes, without any specialized female uterine organization, the early +stages of human male and female fœtal development still display +the comparatively undifferentiated sexual organization of those remote +ancestors, and during the first months of fœtal life it is +practically impossible to tell by the inspection of the genital regions +whether the embryo would have developed into a man or into a woman. If we +examine the embryo at an early stage of development we see that the hind +end is the body stalk, this stalk in later stages becoming part of the +umbilical cord.<a name='5_Page_118'></a> The urogenital region, formed by the rapid extension of +the hind end beyond its original limit, which corresponds to what is later +the umbilicus, develops mainly by the gradual differentiation of +structures (the Wolffian and Müllerian bodies) which originally exist +identically in both sexes. This process of sexual differentiation is +highly complex, so that it cannot yet be said that there is complete +agreement among investigators as to its details. When some irregularity or +arrest of development occurs in the process we have one or other of the +numerous malformations which may affect this region. If the arrest occurs +at a very early stage we may even find a condition of things which seems +to approximate to that which normally exists in the adult reptilia.<a name='5_FNanchor_75'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_75'><sup>[75]</sup></a> +Owing to the fact that both male and female organs develop from more +primitive structures which were sexually undifferentiated, a fundamental +analogy in the sexual organs of the sexes always remains; the developed +organs of one sex exist as rudiments in the other sex; the testicles +correspond to the ovaries; the female clitoris is the homologue of the +male penis; the scrotum of one sex is the labia majora in the other sex, +and so throughout, although it is not always possible at present to be +quite certain in regard to these homologics.</p> + +<p>Since the object to be attained by the sexual organs in the human species +is identical with that which they subserve in their pre-human ancestors, +it is not surprising to find that these structures have a clear +resemblance to the corresponding structures in the apes, although on the +whole there would appear to be in man a higher degree of sexual +differentiation. Thus the uterus of various species of <i>semnopithecus</i> +seems to show a noteworthy correspondence with the same organ in +woman.<a name='5_FNanchor_76'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_76'><sup>[76]</sup></a> The somewhat less degree of sexual differentiation is well +shown in the gorilla; in the male the external organs are in the passive +state covered by the wrinkled skin of the abdomen, while in the <a name='5_Page_119'></a>female, +on the contrary, they are very apparent, and in sexual excitement the +large clitoris and nymphæ become markedly prominent. The penis of the +gorilla, however, more nearly resembles that of man, according to +Hartmann, than does that of the other anthropoid apes, which diverge from +the human type in this respect more than do the cynocephalic apes and some +species of baboon.</p> + +<p>From the psychological point of view we are less interested in the +internal sexual organs, which are most fundamentally concerned with the +production and reception of the sexual elements, than with the more +external parts of the genital apparatus which serve as the instruments of +sexual excitation, and the channels for the intromission and passage of +the seminal fluid. It is these only which can play any part at all in +sexual selection; they are the only part of the sexual apparatus which can +enter into the formation of either normal or abnormal erotic conceptions; +they are the organs most prominently concerned with detumescence; they +alone enter normally into the conscious process of sex at any time. It +seems desirable, therefore, to discuss them briefly at this point.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Our knowledge of the individual and racial variations of the + external sexual organs is still extremely imperfect. A few + monographs and collections of data on isolated points may be + found in more or less inaccessible publications. As regards + women, Ploss and Bartels have devoted a chapter to the sexual + organs of women which extends to a hundred pages, but remains + scanty and fragmentary. (<i>Das Weib</i>, vol. i, Chapter VI.) The + most systematic series of observations have been made in the case + of the various kinds of degenerates—idiots, the insane, + criminals, etc.—but it would be obviously unsafe to rely too + absolutely on such investigations for our knowledge of the sexual + organs of the ordinary population.</p> + +<p> There can be no doubt, however, that the external sexual organs + in normal men and women exhibit a peculiarly wide range of + variation. This is indicated not only by the unsystematic results + attained by experienced observers, but also by more systematic + studies. Thus Herman has shown by detailed measurements that + there are great normal variations in the conformation of the + parts that form the floor of the female pelvis. He found that the + projection of the pelvic floor varied from nothing to as much as + two inches, and that in healthy women who had borne no children + the distance between the coccyx and anus, the length <a name='5_Page_120'></a>of the + perineum, the distance between the fourchette and the symphysis + pubis, and the length of the vagina are subject to wide + variations. (<i>Lancet</i>, October 12, 1889.) Even the female + urethral opening varies very greatly, as has been shown by Bergh, + who investigated it in nearly 700 women and reproduces the + various shapes found; while most usually (in about a third of the + cases observed), a longitudinal slit, it may be cross-shaped, + star-shaped, crescentic, etc.; and while sometimes very small, in + about 6 per cent. of the cases it admitted the tip of the little + finger. (Bergh, <i>Monatsheft für Praktische Dermatologie</i>, 15 + Sept., 1897.)</p> + +<p> As regards both sexes, Stanley Hall states that "Dr. F. N. + Seerley, who has examined over 2000 normal young men as well as + many young women, tells me that in his opinion individual + variations in these parts are much greater even than those of + face and form, and that the range of adult and apparently normal + size and proportion, as well as function, and of both the age and + order of development, not only of each of the several parts + themselves, but of all their immediate annexes, and in females as + well as males, is far greater than has been recognized by any + writer. This fact is the basis of the anxieties and fears of + morphological abnormality so frequent during adolescence." (G. S. + Hall, <i>Adolescence</i>, vol. i, p. 414).</p></div> + +<p>In accordance with the supreme importance of the part they play, and the +intimately psychic nature of that part, the sexual organs, both internal +and external, are very richly supplied with nerves. While the internal +organs are very abundantly furnished with sympathetic nerves and ganglia, +the external organs show the highest possible degree of specialization of +the various peripheral nervous devices which the organism has developed +for receiving, accumulating, and transmitting stimuli to the brain.<a name='5_FNanchor_77'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_77'><sup>[77]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>"The number of conducting cords which attach the genitals to the + nervous centers is simply enormous," writes Bryan Robinson; "the + pudic nerve is composed of nearly all the third sacral and + branches from the second and fourth sacral. As one examines this + nerve he is forced to the conclusion that it is an enormous + supply for a small organ. The periphery of the pudic nerve + spreads itself like a fan over the genitals." The lesser sciatic + nerve supplies only one muscle—the gluteus maximus—and <a name='5_Page_121'></a>then + sends the large pudendal branch to the side of the penis, and + hence the friction of coitus induces active contraction of the + gluteus maximus, "the main muscle of coition." The large pudic + and the pudendal constitute the main supply of the external + genitals. In women the pudic nerve is equally large, but the + pudendal much smaller, possibly, Bryan Robinson suggests, because + women take a less active part in coitus. The nerve supply of the + clitoris, however, is three or four times as large as that of the + penis in proportion to size. (F. B. Robinson, "The Intimate + Nervous Connection of the Genito-Urinary Organs With the + Cerebro-Spinal and Sympathetic Systems," <i>New York Medical + Journal</i>, March 11, 1893; <i>id.</i>, <i>The Abdominal Brain</i>, 1899.)</p></div> + +<p>Of all the sexual organs the penis is without doubt that which has most +powerfully impressed the human imagination. It is the very emblem of +generation, and everywhere men have contemplated it with a mixture of +reverence and shuddering awe that has sometimes, even among civilized +peoples, amounted to horror and disgust. Its image is worn as an amulet to +ward off evil and invoked as a charm to call forth blessing. The sexual +organs were once the most sacred object on which a man could place his +hands to swear an inviolate oath, just as now he takes up the Testament. +Even in the traditions of the great classic civilization which we inherit +the penis is <i>fascinus</i>, the symbol of all fascination. In the history of +human culture it has had far more than a merely human significance; it has +been the symbol of all the generative force of Nature, the embodiment of +creative energy in the animal and vegetable worlds alike, an image to be +held aloft for worship, the sign of all unconscious ecstasy. As a symbol, +the sacred phallus, it has been woven in and out of all the highest and +deepest human conceptions, so intimately that it is possible to see it +everywhere, that it is possible to fail to see it anywhere.</p> + +<p>In correspondence with the importance of the penis is the large number of +names which men have everywhere bestowed upon it. In French literature +many hundred synonyms may be found. They were also numerous in Latin. In +English the literary terms for the penis seem to be comparatively few, but +a large number of non-literary synonyms exist in colloquial and perhaps +merely local usage. The Latin term penis, which has <a name='5_Page_122'></a>established itself +among us as the most correct designation, is generally considered to be +associated with <i>pendere</i> and to be connected therefore with the usually +pendent position of the organ. In the middle ages the general literary +term throughout Europe was <i>coles</i> (or <i>colis</i>) from <i>caulis</i>, a stalk, +and <i>virga</i>, a rod. The only serious English literary term, yard (exactly +equivalent to <i>virga</i>), as used by Chaucer—almost the last great English +writer whose vocabulary was adequate to the central facts of life—has now +fallen out of literary and even colloquial usage.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Pierer and Chaulant, in their anatomical and physiological + <i>Real-Lexicon</i> (vol. vi, p. 134), give nearly a hundred synonyms + for the penis. Hyrtl (<i>Topographisches Anatomie</i>, seventh + edition, vol. ii, pp. 67-69), adds others. Schurig, in his + <i>Spermatologia</i> (1720, pp. 89-91), also presents a number of + names for the penis; in Chapter III (pp. 189-192) of the same + book he discusses the penis generally with more fullness than + most authors. Louis de Landes, in his <i>Glossaire Erotique</i> of the + French language (pp. 239-242), enumerates several hundred + literary synonyms for the penis, though many of them probably + only occur once.</p> + +<p> There is no thorough and comprehensive modern study of the penis + on an anthropological basis (though I should mention a valuable + and fully illustrated study of anthropological and pathological + variations of the penis in a series of articles by Marandon de + Montyel, "Des Anomalies des Organs Génitaux Externes Chez les + Aliénées," etc., <i>Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, 1895), + and it would be out of place here to attempt to collect the + scattered notices regarding racial and other variations. It may + suffice to note some of the evidence showing that such variations + seem to be numerous and important. The Arab penis (according to + Kocher) is slender and long (a third longer than the average + European penis) and with a club-shaped glans. It undergoes little + change when it enters the erect state. The clothes leaves it + quite free, and the Arab practices manual excitement at an early + age to favor its development.</p> + +<p> Among the Fuegians, also, according to Hyades and Deniker (<i>Cap + Horn</i>, vol. vii, p. 153), the average length of the penis is 77 + millimeters, which is longer than in Europeans.</p> + +<p> In men of black race, also, the penis is decidedly large. Thus + Sir H. H. Johnston (<i>British Central Africa</i>, p. 399) states this + to be a universal rule. Among the Wankenda of Northern Nyassa, + for instance, he remarks that, while the body is of medium size, + the penis is generally large. He gives the usual length as about + six inches, reaching nine or ten in erection. The prepuce, it is + added, is often very long, and circumcision is practiced by many + tribes.</p><a name='5_Page_123'></a> + +<p> Among the American negroes Hrdlicka has found, also (<i>Proceedings + American Association for the Advancement of Science</i>, vol. xlvii, + p. 475), that the penis in black boys is larger than in white + boys.</p> + +<p> The passages cited above suggest the question whether the penis + becomes larger by exercise of its generative functions. Most old + authors assert that frequent erection makes the penis large and + long (Schurig, <i>Spermatologia</i>, p. 107). Galen noted that in + singers and athletes, who were chaste in order to preserve their + strength, the sexual parts were small and rugrose, like those of + old men, and that exercise of the organs from youth develops + them; Roubaud, quoting this observation (<i>Traité de + l'Impuissance</i>, p. 373), agrees with the statement. It seems + probable that there is an element of truth in this ancient + belief. At the same time it must be remembered that the penis is + only to small extent a muscular organ, and that the increase of + size produced by frequent congestion of erectile tissues cannot + be either rapid or pronounced. Variations in the size of the + sexual organs are probably on the whole mainly inherited, though + it is impossible to speak decisively on this point until more + systematic observations become customary.</p></div> + +<p>The scrotum has usually, in the human imagination, been regarded merely as +an appendage of the penis, of secondary importance, although it is the +garment of the primary and essential organs of sex, and the fact that it +is not the seat of any voluptuous sensation has doubtless helped to +confirm this position. Even the name is merely a mediæval perversion of +<i>scortum</i>, skin or hide. In classic times it was usually called the pouch +or purse. The importance of the testicles has not, however, been +altogether ignored, as the very word <i>testis</i> itself shows, for the +<i>testis</i> is simply the <i>witness</i> of virility.<a name='5_FNanchor_78'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_78'><sup>[78]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is easy to understand why the penis should occupy this special place in +man's thoughts as the supreme sexual organ. It is the one conspicuous and +prominent portion of the sexual apparatus, while its aptitude for swelling +and erecting itself involuntarily, under the influence of sexual emotion, +gives it a peculiar and almost unique position in the body. At the same +time it is the point at which, in the male body, all voluptuous sensation +is concentrated, the only normal masculine center of sex.<a name='5_FNanchor_79'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_79'><sup>[79]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_124'></a> +<p>It is not easy to find any correspondingly conspicuous symbol of sex in +the sexual region of women. In the normal position nothing is visible but +the peculiarly human cushion of fat picturesquely termed the Mons Veneris +(because, as Palfyn said, all those who enroll themselves under the banner +of Venus must necessarily scale it), and even that is veiled from view in +the adult by the more or less bushy plantation of hair which grows upon +it. A triangle of varyingly precise definition is thus formed at the lower +apex of the trunk, and this would sometimes appear to have been regarded +as a feminine symbol.<a name='5_FNanchor_80'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_80'><sup>[80]</sup></a> But the more usual and typical symbol of +femininity is the idealized ring (by some savages drawn as a lozenge) of +the vulvar opening—the <i>yoni</i> corresponding to the masculine +<i>lingam</i>—which is normally closed from view by the larger lips arising +from beneath the shadow of the <i>mons</i>. It is a symbol that, like the +masculine phallus, has a double meaning among primitive peoples and is +sometimes used to call down a blessing and sometimes to invoke a +curse.<a name='5_FNanchor_81'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_81'><sup>[81]</sup></a></p> + +<p>This external opening of the feminine genital passage with its two +enclosing lips is now generally called the vulva. It would appear that +originally (as by Celsus and Pliny) this term included the womb, also, but +when the term "uterus" came into use "vulva" was confined (as its sense of +folding doors suggests that it should be) to the external entrance. The +classic term <i>cunnus</i> for the external genitals was chiefly used by the +poets; it has been the etymological source of various European names for +this region, such as the old French <i>con</i>, which has now, however, +disappeared from literature while even in popular usage it has given place +to <i>lapin</i> and similar terms. But there is always a tendency, marked in +most parts of the world, for the names of the external female parts to +become indecorous. Even in classic antiquity this part was the <i>pudendum</i>, +the part <a name='5_Page_125'></a>to be ashamed of, and among ourselves the mass of the +population, still preserving the traditions of primitive times, continue +to cherish the same notion.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The anatomy, anthropology, folk-lore, and terminology of the + external and to some extent the internal feminine sexual region + may be studied in the following publications, among others: + Ploss, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. i, Chapter VI; Hyrtl, <i>Topographisches + Anatomie</i>, vol. ii, and other publications by the same scholarly + anatomist; W. J. Stewart Mackay, <i>History of Ancient Gynæcology</i>, + especially pp. 244-250; R. Bergh, "Symbolæ ad Cognitionem + Genitalium Externorum Fœminearum" (in Danish), + <i>Hospitalstidende</i>, August, 1894; and also in <i>Monatshefte für + Praktische Dermatologie</i>, 1897. D. S. Lamb, "The Female External + Genital Organs," <i>New York Journal of Gynæcology</i>, August, 1894; + R. L. Dickinson, "Hypertrophies of the Labia Minora and Their + Significance," <i>American Gynecology</i>, September, 1902; Κρυπτάδια + (in various languages), vol. viii, pp. 3-11, 11-13, + and many other passages. Several of Schurig's works (especially + <i>Gynæcologia</i>, <i>Muliebria</i>, and <i>Parthenologia</i>) contain full + summaries of the statements of the early writers.</p></div> + +<p>The external or larger lips, like the mons veneris, are specifically human +in their full development, for in the anthropoid apes they are small as is +the mons, and in the lower apes absent altogether; they are, moreover, +larger in the white than in the other human races. Thus in the negro, and +to a less degree in the Japanese (Wernich) and the Javanese (Scherzer) +they are less developed than in women of white race. The greater lips +develop in the fœtus later than the lesser lips, which are thus +at first uncovered; this condition thus constitutes an infantile state +which occasionally (in less than 2 per cent. of cases, according to Bergh) +persists in the adult. Their generally accepted name, labia majora, is +comparatively modern.<a name='5_FNanchor_82'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_82'><sup>[82]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The outer sides of the labia majora are covered with hair, and on + the inner sides, which are smooth and moist, but are not true + mucous membrane, there are a few sweat glands and numerous large + sebaceous glands. Bergh considers that there is little or no hair + on the inner sides of the labia majora, but Lamb states that + careful examination shows that from one- to two-thirds of the + inner surface in adult women <a name='5_Page_126'></a>show hairs like those of the + external surface. In brunettes and women of dark races this + surface is pigmented; in dark races it is usually a slate gray. + From an examination of 2200 young Danish prostitutes Bergh has + found that there are two main varieties in the shape of the labia + majora, with transitional forms. In the first and most frequent + form the labia tend to be less marked and more effaced and + separated at the upper and anterior part, often being lost in the + sides of the mons and presenting a fissure which is broader in + its upper part and showing the inner lips more or less bare. In + the second form the labia are thicker and more outstanding and + the inner edges lie in contact throughout their whole length, + showing the <i>rima pudendi</i> as a long narrow fissure. Whatever the + form, the labia close more tightly together in virgins and in + young individuals generally than in the deflowered and the + elderly. In children, as Martineau pointed out, the vulva appears + to look directly forward and the clitoris and urinary meatus + easily appear, while in adult women, and especially after + attempts at coitus have been made, the vulva appears directed + more below and behind, and the clitoris and meatus more covered + by the labia majora; so that the child urinates forward, while + the adult woman is usually able to urinate almost directly + downwards in the erect position, though in some cases (as may + occasionally be observed in the street) she can only do so when + bending slightly forwards. This difference in the direction of + the stream formerly furnished one of the methods of diagnosing + virginity, an uncertain one, since the difference is largely due + to age and individual variation. The main factor in the position + and aspect of the vulva is pelvic inclination. (See Havelock + Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i>, fourth edition, p. 64; Stratz, <i>Die + Schönheit des Weiblichen Körpers</i>, Chapter XII.) In the European + woman, according to Stratz, a considerable degree of pelvic + inclination is essential to beauty, concealing all but the + anterior third of the vulva. In negresses and other women of + lower race the vulva, however, usually lies further back, being + more conspicuous from behind than in European women; in this + respect lower races resemble the apes. Those women of dark race, + therefore, whose modesty is focused behind rather than in front + thus have sound anatomical considerations on their side.</p> + +<p> As Ploss and Bartels remark, a very common variation among + European women consists in an unusually posterior position of the + vulva and vaginal entrance, so that unless a cushion is placed + under the buttocks it is difficult for the man to effect coitus + in the usual position without giving much pain to the woman. They + add that another anomaly, less easy to remedy, consists in an + abnormally anterior position of the vaginal entrance close + beneath the pelvic bone, so that, although intromission is easy, + the spasmodic contraction of the vagina at the culmination of + orgasm presses the penis against the bone and causes intolerable + pain to the man.</p></div><a name='5_Page_127'></a> + +<p>The mons veneris and the labia majora are, after the age of puberty, +always normally covered by a more or less profuse growth of hair. It is +notable that the apes, notwithstanding their general tendency to +hairiness, show no such special development of hair in this region. We +thus see that all the external and more conspicuous portions of the sexual +sphere in woman—the mons veneris, the labia majora, and the +hair—represent not so much an animal inheritance, such as we commonly +misrepresent them to be, but a higher and genuinely human development. As +none of these structures subserve any clear practical use, it would appear +that they must have developed by sexual selection to satisfy the æsthetic +demands of the eye.<a name='5_FNanchor_83'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_83'><sup>[83]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The character and arrangement of the pubic hair, investigated by + Eschricht and Voigt more than half a century ago, have been more + recently studied by Bergh. As these observers have pointed out, + there are various converging hair streams from above and below, + the clitoris seeming to be the center towards which they are + directed. The hair-covering thus formed is usually ample and, as + a rule, is more so in brunettes than in blondes. It is nearly + always bent, curly and more or less spirally twisted.<a name='5_FNanchor_84'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_84'><sup>[84]</sup></a> There + are frequently one or two curls at the commencement of the + fissure, rolled outwards, and occasionally a well marked tuft in + the middle line. In abundance the pubic hair corresponds with the + axillary hair; when one region is defective in hair the other is + usually so also. Strong eyebrows also usually indicate a strong + development of pubic hair. But the hair of the head usually + varies independently, and Bergh found that of 154 women with + spare pubic hair 72 had good and often profuse hair on the head. + Complete or almost <a name='5_Page_128'></a>complete absence of pubic hair is in Bergh's + experience only found in about 3 per cent. of women; these were + all young and blonde.</p></div> + +<p>Rothe, in his investigation of the pubic hair of 1000 Berlin women, found +that no two women were really alike in this respect, but there was a +tendency to two main types of arrangement, with minor subdivisions, +according as the hair tended to grow chiefly in the middle line extending +laterally from that line, or to grow equally over the whole extent of the +pubic region; these two groups included half the cases investigated.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In men the pubic hair normally ascends anteriorly in a faint line + up to the navel, with tendency to form a triangle with the apex + above, and posteriorly extends backwards to the anus. In women + these anterior and posterior extensions are comparatively rare, + or at all events are only represented by a few stray hairs. Rothe + found this variation in 4 per cent. of North German women, though + a triangle of hair was only found in 2 per cent.; Lombroso found + it in 5 per cent, of Italian women; Bergh found it in only 1.6 + per cent. among 1000 Danish prostitutes, all sixteen of whom with + three exceptions were brunettes. In Vienna, among 600 women, Coe + found only 1 per cent, with this distribution of hair, and states + that they were women of decidedly masculine type, though Ploss + and Bartels, as well as Rothe, find, however, that heterogeny, as + they term the masculine distribution, is more common in blondes. + The anterior extension of hair is usually accompanied by the + posterior extension around the anus, usually very slight, but + occasionally as pronounce as in men. (According to Rothe, + however, anterior heterogeny comparatively rare.) These masculine + variations in the extension of the pubic hair appear to be not + uncommonly associated with other physical and psychic anomalies; + it is on this account that they have sometimes been regarded as + indications of a vicious or a criminal temperament; they are, + however, found in quite normal women.</p> + +<p> The pubic hair of women is usually shorter than that of men, but + thick, and the individual hairs stronger and larger in diameter + than those of men, as Pfaff first showed; dark hair is usually + stronger than light. In both length and size the individual + variations are considerable. The usual length is about 2 inches, + or 3-5 centimeters, occasionally reaching about 4 inches, or 9-10 + centimeters, in the larger curls. In a series of 100 women + attended during confinement in London and the north of England I + have only once (in a rather blonde Lancashire woman) found the + hair on labia reaching a conspicuous length of several inches and + forming an obstruction to the manipulations involved in delivery. + But Jahn delivered a woman whose pubic hair was longer than that + of her head, reaching below her knee; Paulini also knew a woman + whose <a name='5_Page_129'></a>pubic hair nearly reached her knees and was sold to make + wigs; Bartholin mentions a soldier's wife who plaited her pubic + hair behind her back; while Brantôme has several references to + abnormally long hair in ladies of the French court during the + sixteenth century. In 8 cases out of 2200 Bergh found the pubic + hair forming a large curly wig extending to the iliac spines. The + individual hairs have occasionally been found so stiff and + brush-like as to render coitus difficult.</p> + +<p> In color the pubic hair, while generally approximating to that of + the head, is sometimes (according to Rothe, in Germany, in + one-third cases) lighter, and sometimes somewhat darker, as is + found to be the case by Coe, especially in brunettes, and also by + Bergh, in Denmark. Bergh remarks that it is generally + intermediate in color between the eyebrows and the axillary hair, + the latter being more or less decolorized by sweat, and that, + owing to the influence of the urine and vaginal discharges, the + labial hair is paler than that on the mons; blondes with dark + eyebrows usually have dark hair on the mons. The hair on this + spot, as Aristotle observed, is usually the last to turn gray.</p></div> + +<p>The key to the genital apparatus in women from the psychic point of view, +and, indeed, to some extent, its anatomical center, is to be found in the +clitoris. Anatomically and developmentally the clitoris is the rudimentary +analogue of the masculine penis. Functionally, however, its scope is very +much smaller. While the penis both receives and imparts specific +voluptuous sensations, and is at the same time both the intromittent organ +for the semen and the conduit for the urine, the sole function of the +clitoris is to enter into erection under the stress of sexual emotion and +receive and transmit the stimulatory voluptuous sensations imparted to it +by friction with the masculine genital apparatus. It is so insignificant +an organ that it is only within recent times that its homology with the +penis has been realized. In 1844 Kobelt wrote in his important book, <i>Die +Mannlichen und Weiblichen Wollust-Organe</i>, that in his attempt to show +that the female organs are exactly analogous to the male the reader will +probably be unable to follow him, while even Johannes Müller, the father +of scientific physiology, declared at about the same period that the +clitoris is essentially different from the penis. It is indeed but three +centuries since the clitoris was so little known that (in 1593) Realdus +Columbus actually claimed the honor of discovering it.<a name='5_Page_130'></a> Columbus was not +its discoverer, for Fallopius speedily showed that Avicenna and Albucasis +had referred to it.<a name='5_FNanchor_85'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_85'><sup>[85]</sup></a> The Arabs appear to have been very familiar with +it, and, from the various names they gave it, clearly understood the +important part it plays in generating voluptuous emotion.<a name='5_FNanchor_86'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_86'><sup>[86]</sup></a> But it was +known in classic antiquity; the Greeks called it μύρτον, the +myrtle-berry; Galen and Soranus called it νύμφη because it is +covered as a bride is veiled, while the old Latin name was <i>tentigo</i>, from +its power of entering into erection, and <i>columella</i>, the little pillar, +from its shape. The modern term, which is Greek and refers to the +sensitiveness of the part to voluptuous titillation, is said to have +originated with Suidas and Pollux.<a name='5_FNanchor_87'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_87'><sup>[87]</sup></a> It was mentioned, though not +adopted, by Rufus.</p> + +<p>"The clitoris," declared Haller, "is a part extremely sensible and +wonderfully prurient." It is certainly the chief though by no means the +only point through which the immediate call to detumescence is conveyed to +the female organism. It is, indeed, as Bryan Robinson remarks, "a +veritable electrical bell button which, being pressed or irritated, rings +up the whole nervous system."</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The nervous supply of this little organ is very large, and the + dorsal nerve of the clitoris is relatively three or four times + larger than that of the penis. Yet the sensitive point of this + organ is only 5 to 7 millimeters in extent. The length of the + clitoris is usually rather over 2 centimeters (or about an inch) + and 3 centimeters when erect; a length of 4 centimeters or more + was regarded by Martineau as within the normal range of + variation. It is not usual to find the clitoris longer than this + in Europe (for among some races like the negro the clitoris is + generally large), but all degrees of magnitude may be found as + rare exceptions. (See, <i>e.g.</i>, Sir J. Y. Simpson, + "Hermaphrodites," <i>Obstetric Memoirs and Contributions</i>, vol. ii, + pp. 217-226; also Dickinson, <i>loc. cit.</i>) It was formerly thought + that the clitoris is easily enlarged by masturbation, and + Martineau believed that in this way it might be doubled in + length. It is probable that slight enlargement of the clitoris + may be <a name='5_Page_131'></a>caused by very frequent masturbation, but only to an + insignificant extent, and it is impossible to diagnose + masturbation from the size of the clitoris. Among the women of + Lake Nyassa, as well as in the Caroline Islands, special methods + are practiced for elongating the clitoris, but in Europe, at all + events, it is probable that the variations in the size of the + organ are mainly congenital. It may well be that a congenitally + large clitoris is associated with an abnormally developed + excitability of the sexual apparatus. Tilt stated (<i>On Uterine + and Ovarian Inflammation</i>, p. 37) that in his experience there + was a frequent though not invariable connection between a large + clitoris and sexual proclivity. (Schurig referred to a case of + intense and life-long sexual obsession associated with an + extremely large clitoris, <i>Gynæcologia</i>, pp. 16-17.) Of recent + years considerable importance has been attached by some + gynecologists (<i>e.g.</i>, R. T. Morris, "Is Evolution Trying to Do + Away With the Clitoris?" <i>Transactions American Association of + Obstetricians and Gynecologists</i>, vol. v, 1893) to preputial + adhesions around the clitoris as a source of nervous disturbance + and invalidism in young women.</p></div> + +<p>While the clitoris is anatomically analogous to the penis, its actual +mechanism under the stress of sexual excitement is somewhat different. As +Liétaud long since pointed out, it cannot rise freely in erection as the +penis can; it is apparently bound down by its prepuce and its frenulum. +Waldeyer, in his book on the pelvis, states more precisely that, unlike +the penis, when erect it retains its angle, only this becomes somewhat +rounded so that the organ is to some slight extent lifted and protruded. +Waldeyer considered that the clitoris was thus perfectly fitted to fulfill +its part as the recipient of erotic stimulation from friction by the +penis. Adler, however, has pointed out with considerable justice, that +this is not altogether the case. The clitoris was developed in mammals who +practiced the posterior mode of coitus; in this position the clitoris was +beneath the penis, which was thus easily able in coitus to press it +against the pubic bone close beneath which it is situated, and thus impart +the compression and friction which the feminine organ craves. But in the +human anterior mode of coitus it is not necessarily brought into close +contact with the penis during the act of coitus, and thus fails to receive +powerful stimulation. Its restricted position, <a name='5_Page_132'></a>which is an advantage in +posterior coitus, is a disadvantage in anterior coitus. Adler observes +that it thus comes about that the human method of coitus, while by +bringing breast to breast and face to face it has added a new dignity and +refinement, a fresh source of enjoyment, to the embrace of the sexes, has +not been an unmixed advantage to woman, for while man has lost nothing by +the change, woman has now to contend with an increased difficulty in +attaining an adequate amount of pressure on that "electric button" which +normally sets the whole mechanism in operation.<a name='5_FNanchor_88'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_88'><sup>[88]</sup></a></p> + +<p>We may well bring into connection with the changed conditions brought +about by anterior coitus the interesting fact that while the clitoris +remains the most exquisitely sensitive of the sexual centers in woman, +voluptuous sensitivity is much more widely diffused in woman than in man. +Over the whole body, indeed, it is apt to be more distinctly marked than +is usually the case in man. But even if we confine ourselves to the +genital region, while in man that portion of the penis which enters the +vagina, and especially the glans, is normally the only portion which, even +during turgescence, is sensitive to voluptuous contacts, in woman the +whole of the region comprised within the larger lips, including even the +anus and internally the vagina and the vaginal portion of the womb,<a name='5_FNanchor_89'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_89'><sup>[89]</sup></a> +become sensitive to voluptuous contacts. Deprived of the penis the ability +of a man to experience specifically sexual sensations becomes very limited +indeed. But the loss of the clitoris or of any other structure involves no +correspondingly serious disability on women. Ablation of the clitoris for +sexual hyperæsthesia has for this reason been abandoned, except under +special circumstances. The members of the Russian Skoptzy sect habitually +amputate <a name='5_Page_133'></a>the clitoris, nymphæ, and breasts, yet many young Skoptzy women +told the Russian physician, Guttceit, that they were perfectly well able +to enjoy coitus.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Freud believes that in very young girls the clitoris is the + exclusive seat of sexual sensation, masturbation at this age + being directed to the clitoris alone, and spontaneous sexual + excitement being confined to twitchings and erection of this + organ, so that young girls are able, from their own experience, + to recognize without instruction the signs of sexual excitement + in boys. At a later age sexual excitability spreads from the + clitoris to other regions—just as the easy inflammability of + wood sets light to coal—though in the male the penis remains + from first to last normally the almost exclusive seat of specific + excitability. (S. Freud, <i>Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie</i>, + p. 62.)</p> + +<p> The anus would, however, seem to be sometimes an erogenous zone + even at an early age. Titillation of the anus appears to be + frequently pleasurable in women; and this is not surprising + considering the high degree of erotic sensitivity which is easily + developed at the body orifices where skin meets mucous membrane. + (Thus the meatus of the urethra is a highly erogenous zone, as is + sufficiently shown by the frequency with which hair-pins and + other articles used in masturbation find their way into the + bladder.) It is in this germinal sensitivity, undoubtedly, that + we find a chief key to the practice of <i>pedicatio</i>. Freud + attaches great importance to the anus as a sexually erogenous + zone at a very early age, and considers that it very frequently + makes its influence felt in this respect. He believes that + intestinal catarrhs in very early life and hæmorrhoids later tend + to develop sensibility in the anus. He finds an indication that + the anus has become a sexually erogenous zone when children wish + to allow the contents of the rectum to accumulate so that + defecation may by its increased difficulty involve voluptuous + sensations, and adds that masturbatory excitation of the anus + with the fingers is by no means rare in older children. (S. + Freud, <i>Op. cit.</i>, pp. 40-42.) A medical correspondent in India + tells me of a European lady who derived, she said, "quite as + much, indeed more," pleasure from digitally titillating her + rectum as from vulvo-vaginal titillation; she had several times + submitted to <i>pedicatio</i> and enjoyed it, though it was painful + during penetration. The anus may retain this erogenous + irritability even in old age, and Routh mentions the case of a + lady of over 70, the reverse of lustful, who was so excited by + the act of defecation that she was invariably compelled to + masturbate, although this state of things was a source of great + mental misery to her. (C. H. F. Routh, <i>British Gynæcological + Journal</i>, February, 1887, p. 48.)</p> + +<p> Bölsche has sought the explanation of the erogenous nature of the + anus, and the key to <i>pedicatio</i>, in an atavistic return to the + very <a name='5_Page_134'></a>remote amphibian days when the anus was combined with the + sexual parts in a common cloaca. But it is unnecessary to invoke + any vestigial inheritance from a vastly remote past when we bear + in mind that the innervation of these two adjoining regions is + inevitably very closely related. The presence of a body exit with + its marked and special sensitivity at a point where it can + scarcely fail to receive the nervous overflow from an immensely + active center of nervous energy quite adequately accounts for the + phenomenon in question.</p></div> + +<p>The inner lips, the nymphæ or labia minora, running parallel with the +greater lips which enclose them, embrace the clitoris anteriorly and +extend backward, enclosing the urethral exit between them as well as the +vaginal entrance. They form little wings whence their old Latin name, +<i>alæ</i>, and from their resemblance to the cock's comb were by Spigelius +termed crista galli. The red and (especially in brunettes) dark appearance +of the nymphæ suggests that they are mucous membrane and not +integumentary; it is, however, now considered that even on the inner +surface they are covered by skin and separated from the mucous membrane by +a line.<a name='5_FNanchor_90'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_90'><sup>[90]</sup></a> In structure, as described by Waldeyer, they consist of fine +connective tissue rich in elastic fibers as well as some muscular tissue, +and full of large veins, so that they are capable of a considerable degree +of turgescence resembling erection during sexual excitement, while +Ballantyne finds that the nymphæ are supplied to a notable extent with +nervous end-organs.</p> + +<p>More than any other part of the sexual apparatus in either sex, the lesser +lips, on account of their shape, their position, and their structure, are +capable of acquired modifications, more especially hypertrophy and +elongation. By stretching, it is stated, a labium can be doubled in its +dimensions. The "Hottentot apron," or elongated nymphæ, commonly found +among some peoples in South Africa, has long been a familiar phenomenon. +In such cases a length or transverse diameter of 3 to 5 centimeters is +commonly found. But such elongated <a name='5_Page_135'></a>nymphæ are by no means confined to one +part of the world or to one race; they are quite common among women of +European race, and reach a size equal to most of the more reliably +recorded Hottentot cases. Dickinson, who has very carefully studied this +question in New York, finds that in 1000 consecutive gynæcological cases +the labia showed some form of hypertrophy in 36 per cent., or more than 1 +in 3; while among 150 of these cases who were neurasthenic, the proportion +reached 56 per cent., even when minor or doubtful enlargements were +disregarded. Bergh, in about 16 per cent. cases, found very enlarged +nymphæ, the height reached in about 5 per cent. of the cases of +enlargement being nearly six centimeters. Ploss and Bartels, in a full +discussion: of the "Hottentot apron," come to the conclusion that this +condition is perhaps in most cases artificially produced. It is known that +among the Basutos it is the custom for the elder girls to manipulate the +nymphæ of younger children, when alone with them, almost from birth, and +on account of the elastic nature of these structures such manipulation +quite adequately accounts for the elongation. It is not necessary to +suppose that the custom is practiced for the sake of producing sexual +stimulation—though this may frequently occur—since there are numerous +similar primitive customs involving deformation of the sexual organs +without the production of sexual excitement. Dickinson has come to a +similar conclusion as regards the corresponding elongation of the nymphæ +in civilized European women. In 361 out of 1000 women of good social class +he found elongation or thickening, often with a notable degree of +wrinkling and pigmentation, and believes that this is always the result of +frequently repeated masturbation practiced with the separation of the +nymphæ; in 30 per cent. of the cases admission of masturbation was +made.<a name='5_FNanchor_91'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_91'><sup>[91]</sup></a> While this conclusion is probably correct in the main, it +requires some qualification. To assert <a name='5_Page_136'></a>that whenever in women who have +not been pregnant the marked protrusion of the inner lips beyond the outer +lips means that at some period manipulation has been practiced with or +without the production of sexual excitement is to make too absolute a +statement. It is highly probable that the nymphæ, like the clitoris, are +congenitally more prominent in some of the lower human races, as they are +also in the apes; among the Fuegians, for instance, according to Hyades +and Deniker, the labia minora descend lower than in Europeans, although +there is not the slightest reason to suppose that these women practice any +manipulations. Among European women, again, the nymphæ sometimes protrude +very prominently beyond the labia majora in women who are organically of +somewhat infantile type; this occurs in cases in which we may be convinced +that no manipulations have ever been practiced.<a name='5_FNanchor_92'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_92'><sup>[92]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is difficult to speak very decisively as to the function of the labia +minora. They doubtless exert some amount of protective influence over the +entrance to the vagina, and in this way correspond to the lips of the +mouth after which they are called. They fulfill, however, one very +definite though not obviously important function which is indicated by the +mythologic name they have received. There is, indeed, some obscurity in +the origin of this term, nymphæ, which has not, I believe, been +satisfactorily cleared up. It has been stated that the Greek name νύμφη has been transferred from the clitoris to the labia minora. Any +such transfer could only have taken place when the meaning of the word had +been forgotten, and νύμφη had become the totally different +word <i>nymphæ</i>, the goddesses who presided over streams. The old anatomists +were much exercised in their minds as to the meaning of the name, but on +the whole were inclined to believe that it referred to the <a name='5_Page_137'></a>action of the +labia minora in directing the urinary stream. The term nymphæ was first +applied in the modern sense, according to Bergh, in 1599, by Pinæus, +mainly from the influence of these structures on the urinary stream, and +he dilated in his <i>De Virginitate</i> on the suitability of the term to +designate so poetic a spot.<a name='5_FNanchor_93'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_93'><sup>[93]</sup></a> In more modern times Luschka and Sir +Charles Bell considered that it is one of the uses of the nymphæ to direct +the stream of urine, and Lamb from his own observation thinks the same +conclusion probable. In reality there cannot be the slightest doubt about +the function of the nymphæ, as, in Hyrtl's phrase, "the naiads of the +urinary source," and it can be demonstrated by the simplest +experiment.<a name='5_FNanchor_94'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_94'><sup>[94]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The nymphæ form the intermediate portal of the vagina, as the canal which +conducts to the womb was in anatomy first termed (according to Hyrtl) by +De Graaf.<a name='5_FNanchor_95'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_95'><sup>[95]</sup></a> It is a secreting, erectile, more or less sensitive canal +lined by what is usually considered mucous membrane, though some have +regarded it as integument of the same character as that of the external +genitals; it certainly resembles such integument more than, for instance, +the mucous membrane of the rectum. In the woman who has never had sexual +intercourse and has been subjected to no manipulations or accidents +affecting this region, the vagina <a name='5_Page_138'></a>is closed by a last and final gate of +delicate membrane—scarcely admitting more than a slender finger—called +the hymen.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The poets called the hymen "fios virginitatis," the flower of + virginity, whence the medico-legal term <i>defloratio</i>. + Notwithstanding the great significance which has long been + attached to the phenomena connected with it, the hymen was not + accurately known until Vesalius, Fallopius, and Spigelius + described and named it. It was, however, recognized by the Arab + authors, Avicenna and Averroes. The early literature concerning + it is summarized by Schurig, <i>Muliebria</i>, 1729, Section II, cap. + V. The same author's <i>Parthenologia</i> is devoted to the various + ancient problems connected with the question of virginity.</p></div> + +<p>To say that this delicate piece of membrane is from the non-physical point +of view a more important structure than any other part of the body is to +convey but a feeble idea of the immense importance of the hymen in the +eyes of the men of many past ages and even of our own times and among our +own people.<a name='5_FNanchor_96'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_96'><sup>[96]</sup></a> For the uses of the feminine body, or for its beauty, +there is no part which is more absolutely insignificant. But in human +estimation it has acquired a spiritual value which has made it far more +than a part of the body. It has taken the place of the soul, that whose +presence gives all her worth and dignity, even her name, to the unmarried +woman, her purity, her sexual desirability, her market value. Without +it—though in all physical and mental respects she might remain the same +person—she has sometimes been a mark for contempt, a worthless +outcast.<a name='5_FNanchor_97'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_97'><sup>[97]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>So fragile a membrane scarcely possesses the reliability which + should be possessed by a structure whose presence or absence has + often meant so much. Its absence by no means necessarily + signifies that a woman has had intercourse with a man. Its + presence by no means signifies that she has never had such + intercourse.</p> + +<p> There are many ways in which the hymen may be destroyed apart + from coitus. Among the Chinese (and also, it would appear, in + India and some other parts of the East) the female parts are from + infancy <a name='5_Page_139'></a>kept so scrupulously clean by daily washing, the finger + being introduced into the vagina, that the hymen rapidly + disappears, and its existence is unknown even to Chinese doctors. + Among some Brazilian Indians a similar practice exists among + mothers as regards their young children, less, however, for the + sake of cleanliness than in order to facilitate sexual + intercourse in future years. (Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. + i, Chapter VI.) The manipulations of vaginal masturbation will, + of course, similarly destroy the hymen. It is also quite possible + for the hymen to be ruptured by falls and other accidents. (See, + <i>e.g.</i>, a lengthy study by Nina-Rodrigues, "Des Ruptures de + l'Hymen dans les Chutes," <i>Annales d'Hygiène Publique</i>, + September, 1903.)</p> + +<p> On the other hand, integrity of the hymen is no proof of + virginity, apart from the obvious fact that there may be + intercourse without penetration. (The case has even been recorded + of a prostitute with syphilitic condylomata, a somewhat masculine + type of pubic arch, and vulva rather posteriorly placed, whose + hymen had never been penetrated.) The hymen may be of a yielding + or folding type, so that complete penetration may take place and + yet the hymen be afterwards found unruptured. It occasionally + happens that the hymen is found intact at the end of pregnancy. + In some, though not all, of these cases there has been conception + without intromission of the penis. This has occurred even when + the entrance was very minute. The possibility of such conception + has long been recognized, and Schurig (<i>Syllepsilogia</i>, 1731, + Section I, cap. VIII, p. 2) quotes ancient authors who have + recorded cases. For some typical modern cases see Guérard + (<i>Centralblatt für Gynäkologie</i>, No. 15, 1895), in one of whose + cases the hymen of the pregnant woman scarcely admitted a hair; + also Braun (<i>ib.</i>, No. 23, 1895).</p></div> + +<p>The hymen has played a very definite and pronounced part in the social and +moral life of humanity. Until recently it has been more difficult to +decide what precise biological function it has exercised to ensure its +development and preservation. Sexual selection, no doubt, has worked in +its favor, but that influence has been very limited and comparatively very +recent. Virginity is not usually of any value among peoples who are +entirely primitive. Indeed, even in the classic civilization which we +inherit, it is easy to show that the virgin and the admiration for +virginity are of late growth; the virgin goddesses were not originally +virgins in our modern sense. Diana was the many-breasted patroness of +childbirth before she became the chaste and solitary huntress, for the +earliest distinction would appear <a name='5_Page_140'></a>to have been simply between the woman +who was attached to a man and the woman who followed an earlier rule of +freedom and independence; it was a later notion to suppose that the latter +woman was debarred from sexual intercourse. We certainly must not seek the +origin of the hymen in sexual selection; we must find it in natural +selection. And here it might seem at first sight that we come upon a +contradiction in Nature, for Nature is always devising contrivances to +secure the maximum amount of fertilization. "Increase and multiply" is so +obviously the command of Nature that the Hebrews, with their usual +insight, unhesitatingly dared to place it in the mouth of Jehovah. But the +hymen is a barrier to fertilization. It has, however, always to be +remembered that as we rise in the zoölogical scale, and as the period of +gestation lengthens and the possible number of offspring is fewer, it +becomes constantly more essential that fertilization shall be effective +rather than easy; the fewer the progeny the more necessary it is that they +shall be vigorous enough to survive. There can be little doubt that, as +one or two writers have already suggested, the hymen owes its development +to the fact that its influence is on the side of effective fertilization. +It is an obstacle to the impregnation of the young female by immature, +aged, or feeble males. The hymen is thus an anatomical expression of that +admiration of force which marks the female in her choice of a mate. So +regarded, it is an interesting example of the intimate manner in which +sexual selection is really based on natural selection. Sexual selection is +but the translation into psychic terms of a process which has already +found expression in the physical texture of the body.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It may be added that this interpretation of the biological + function of the hymen is supported by the facts of its evolution. + It is unknown among the lower mammals, with whom fertilization is + easy, gestation short and offspring numerous. It only begins to + appear among the higher mammals in whom reproduction is already + beginning to take on the characters which become fully developed + in man. Various authors have found traces of a rudimentary hymen, + not only in apes, but in elephants, horses, donkeys, bitches, + bears, pigs, hyenas, and giraffes. (Hyrtl, <i>Op. cit.</i>, vol. ii, + p. 189; G. Gellhoen, "Anatomy and Development<a name='5_Page_141'></a> of the Hymen," + <i>American Journal Obstetrics</i>, August, 1904.) It is in the human + species that the tendency to limitation of offspring is most + marked, combined at the same time with a greater aptitude for + impregnation than exists among any lower mammals. It is here, + therefore, that a physical check is of most value, and + accordingly we find that in woman alone, of all animals, is the + hymen fully developed.</p></div> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_72'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_72'>[72]</a><div class='note'><p> "Analysis of the Sexual Impulse," in vol. iii of these +<i>Studies</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_73'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_73'>[73]</a><div class='note'><p> "The accomplishment of no other function," Hyrtl remarks, +"is so intimately connected with the mind and yet so independent of it."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_74'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_74'>[74]</a><div class='note'><p> The process is still, however, but imperfectly understood; +see Art. "Fécondation," by Ed. Retterer, in Richet's <i>Dictionnaire de +Physiologie</i>, vol. vi, 1905.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_75'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_75'>[75]</a><div class='note'><p> Thus a male fœtus showing reptilian characters in +sexual ducts was exhibited by Shattock at the Pathological Society of +London, February 19, 1895.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_76'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_76'>[76]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Kohlbrugge, "Die Umgestaltung des Uterus der Affen nach +den Geburt," <i>Zeitschrift für Morphologie</i>, bd. iv, p. 1, 1901.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_77'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_77'>[77]</a><div class='note'><p> There are, however, no special nerve endings (Krause +corpuscles), as was formerly supposed. The nerve endings in the genital +region are the same as elsewhere. The difference lies in the abundance of +superposed arboreal ramifications. See, <i>e.g.</i>, Ed. Retterer, Art. +"Ejaculation," Richet's <i>Dictionnaire de Physiologie</i>, vol. v.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_78'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_78'>[78]</a><div class='note'><p> Hyrtl, <i>Op. cit.</i>, vol. ii, p. 39.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_79'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_79'>[79]</a><div class='note'><p> Sensations of pleasure without those of touch appear to be +normal at the tip of the penis, as pointed out by Scripture, quoted in +<i>Alienist and Neurologist</i>, January, 1898.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_80'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_80'>[80]</a><div class='note'><p> See the previous volume of these <i>Studies</i>, "Sexual +Selection in Man," p. 161.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_81'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_81'>[81]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. i, +beginning of chapter VI.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_82'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_82'>[82]</a><div class='note'><p> Hyrtl states that the name <i>labia</i> was first used by Haller +in the middle of the eighteenth century in his <i>Elements of Physiology</i>, +being adopted by him from the Greek poet Erotion, who gave these +structures the very obvious name χειλεα, lips. But this seems to +be a mistake, for the seventeenth century anatomists certainly used the +name "labia" for these parts.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_83'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_83'>[83]</a><div class='note'><p> Bergh tentatively suggests, as regards the pubic hair, that +its appearance may be due to the upright walk in man and the human +position during coitus, the hair preventing irritation of the genitals +from the sweat pouring down from the body and protecting the skin from +direct friction in coitus. (In both these suggestions he was, however, +long previously anticipated by Fabricius ab Aquapendente.) The fanciful +suggestion of Louis Robinson that the pubic hair has developed in order to +enable the human infant to cling securely to his mother is very poorly +supported by facts, and has not met with acceptance. It may be mentioned +that (as stated by Ploss and Bartels) the women of the Bismarck +Archipelago, whose pubic hair is very abundant, use it as a kind of +handkerchief on which to clean their hands.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_84'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_84'>[84]</a><div class='note'><p> Routh and Heywood Smith have noted that the pubic hair tends +to lose its curliness and become straight in women who masturbate. +(<i>British Gynæcological Journal</i>, February, 1887, p. 505.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_85'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_85'>[85]</a><div class='note'><p> Schurig, <i>Muliebria</i>, p. 75. Plazzon in 1621 said that in +Italian it had a popular name, <i>il besneegio</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_86'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_86'>[86]</a><div class='note'><p> Schurig brought together in his <i>Gynæcologia</i> (pp. 2-4) +various early opinions concerning the clitoris as the seat of voluptuous +feeling.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_87'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_87'>[87]</a><div class='note'><p> Hyrtl, <i>Op. cit.</i>, vol. ii, p. 193.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_88'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_88'>[88]</a><div class='note'><p> Adler, <i>Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes</i>, +1904, pp. 117-119.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_89'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_89'>[89]</a><div class='note'><p> The voluptuous sensations caused by sexual contacts +producing movements of the womb are probably normal and usual. They may +even occur under circumstances unconnected with sexual emotion, and Mundé +(<i>International Journal of Surgery</i>, March, 1893) mentions incidentally +that in one case while titillating the cervix with a sound the woman very +plainly showed voluptuous manifestations.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_90'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_90'>[90]</a><div class='note'><p> Henle stated that fine hairs are frequently visible on the +nymphæ; Stieda (<i>Zeitschrift für Morphologie</i>, 1902, p. 458) remarks that +he has never been able to see them with the naked eye.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_91'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_91'>[91]</a><div class='note'><p> R. L. Dickinson, "Hypertrophies of the Labia Minora and Their +Significance," <i>American Gynæcologist</i>, September, 1902. It is perhaps +noteworthy that Bergh found that in 302 cases in which the nymphæ were of +unequal length, in all but 24 the left was longer.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_92'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_92'>[92]</a><div class='note'><p> It may be remarked that Bergh believes that the nymphæ, and +indeed the external genitals generally, are congenitally more strongly +developed in libidinous persons, and at the same time in brunettes, while +in public prostitutes this is not usually the case, which confirms the +belief that exalted sexual sensibility does not usually lead to +prostitution. He adds that prostitution, unless carried on for many years, +has little effect on the shape of the external genitals.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_93'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_93'>[93]</a><div class='note'><p> Schurig (<i>Muliebria</i>, 1729, Section II, cap. II) gives +numerous quotations on this point; thus De Graaf wrote in his book on the +sexual organs of women: "Tales protuberantiæ nymphæ appellantur ea propter +quod aquis e vesica prosilientibus proxime adstare reperiantur, +quandoquidem inter illas, tanquam duos parietes, urina magno impetu cum +sibilo sæpe et absque labiorum irrigatione erumpit, vel quod sint +castitatis præsides, aut sponsam primo intromittant."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_94'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_94'>[94]</a><div class='note'><p> Havelock Ellis, "The Bladder as a Dynamometer," <i>American +Journal of Dermatology</i>, May, 1902. If a woman who has never been +pregnant, standing in the erect position before commencing the act of +urination presses apart the labia minora with index and middle fingers the +stream will be projected forward so as to fall usually at a considerable +distance in front of a vertical line from the meatus; if when the act is +half completed the fingers are removed, the labia close together and the +stream, though maintained at a constant pressure, at once changes its +character and direction.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_95'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_95'>[95]</a><div class='note'><p> In poetry this term was employed by Plautus, <i>Pseudolus</i>, +Act IV, Sc. 7. The Greek αιδοιον sometimes meant vagina and +sometimes the external sexual parts; κολπος was used for the +vagina alone.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_96'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_96'>[96]</a><div class='note'><p> It is curious, however, that the European physicians of the +seventeenth and even eighteenth centuries were doubtful of its value as a +sign of virginity and considered it often absent.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_97'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_97'>[97]</a><div class='note'><p> For a summary of the beliefs and practices of various +peoples with regard to the hymen and virginity see Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das +Weib</i>, vol. i, Chapter XVI.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_M_II'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_142'></a>II</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Object of Detumescence—Erogenous Zones—The Lips—The Vascular +Characters of Detumescence—Erectile Tissue—Erection in Woman—Mucous +Emission in Women—Sexual Connection—The Human Mode of +Intercourse—Normal Variations—The Motor Characters of +Detumescence—Ejaculation—The Virile Reflex—The General Phenomena of +Detumescence—The Circulatory and Respiratory Phenomena—Blood +Pressure—Cardiac Disturbance—Glandular Activity—Distillatio—The +Essentially Motor Character of Detumescence—Involuntary Muscular +Irradiation to Bladder, etc.—Erotic Intoxication—Analogy of Sexual +Detumescence and Vesical Tension—The Specifically Sexual Movements of +Detumescence in Man—In Woman—The Spontaneous Movements of the Genital +Canal in Woman—Their Function in Conception—Part Played by Active +Movement of the Spermatozoa—The Artificial Injection of Semen—The Facial +Expression During Detumescence—The Expression of Joy—The Occasional +Serious Effects of Coitus.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>We have seen what the object of detumescence is, and we have briefly +considered the organs and structures which are chiefly concerned in the +process. We have now to inquire what are the actual phenomena which take +place during the act of detumescence.</p> + +<p>Detumescence is normally linked closely to tumescence. Tumescence is the +piling on of the fuel; detumescence is the leaping out of the devouring +flame whence is lighted the torch of life to be handed on from generation +to generation. The whole process is double and yet single; it is exactly +analogous to that by which a pile is driven into the earth by the raising +and then the letting go of a heavy weight which falls on to the head of +the pile. In tumescence the organism is slowly wound up and force +accumulated; in the act of detumescence the accumulated force is let go +and by its liberation the sperm-bearing instrument is driven home. +Courtship, as we commonly term the process of tumescence which takes place +when a woman is first sexually approached by a man, is usually a highly +prolonged <a name='5_Page_143'></a>process. But it is always necessary to remember that every +repetition of the act of coitus, to be normally and effectively carried +out on both sides, demands a similar double process; detumescence must be +preceded by an abbreviated courtship.</p> + +<p>This abbreviated courtship by which tumescence is secured or heightened in +the repetition of acts of coitus which have become familiar, is mainly +tactile.<a name='5_FNanchor_98'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_98'><sup>[98]</sup></a> Since the part of the man in coitus is more active and that +of the woman more passive, the sexual sensitivity of the skin seems to be +more pronounced in women. There are, moreover, regions of the surface of a +woman's body where contact, when sympathetic, seems specially liable to +arouse erotic excitement. Such erogenous zones are often specially marked +in the breasts, occasionally in the palm of the hand, the nape of the +neck, the lobule of the ear, the little finger; there is, indeed, perhaps +no part of the surface of the body which may not, in some individuals at +some time, become normally an erogenous zone. In hysteria the erotic +excitability of these zones is sometimes very intense. The lips are, +however, without doubt, the most persistently and poignantly sensitive +region of the whole body outside the sphere of the sexual organs +themselves. Hence the significance of the kiss as a preliminary of +detumescence.<a name='5_FNanchor_99'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_99'><sup>[99]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The importance of the lips as a normal erogenous zone is shown by + the experiments of Gualino. He applied a thread, folded on itself + several times, to the lips, thus stimulating them in a simple + mechanical manner. Of 20 women, between the ages of 18 and 35, + only 8 felt this as a merely mechanical operation, 4 felt a + vaguely erotic element in the proceeding, 3 experienced a desire + for coitus and in 5 there was actual sexual excitement with + emission of mucus. Of 25 men, between the ages of 20 and 30, in + 15 all sexual feeling was absent, in 7 erotic ideas were + suggested with congestion of the sexual organs without erection, + and in 3 there was the beginning of erection. It should be added + that both the women and the men in whom this sexual reflex was + more especially <a name='5_Page_144'></a>marked were of somewhat nervous temperament; in + such persons erotic reactions of all kinds generally occur most + easily. (Gualino, "Il Rifflesso Sessuale nell' eccitamento alle + labbre," <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, 1904, p. 341.)</p></div> + +<p>As tumescence, under the influence of sensory stimulation, proceeds toward +the climax when it gives place to detumescence, the physical phenomena +become more and more acutely localized in the sexual organs. The process +which was at first predominantly nervous and psychic now becomes more +prominently vascular. The ancient sexual relationship of the skin asserts +itself; there is marked surface congestion showing itself in various ways. +The face tends to become red, and exactly the same phenomenon is taking +place in the genital organs; "an erection," it has been said, "is a +blushing of the penis." The difference is that in the genital organs this +heightened vascularity has a definite and specific function to +accomplish—the erection of the male organ which fits it to enter the +female parts—and that consequently there has been developed in the penis +that special kind of vascular mechanism, consisting of veins in connective +tissue with unstriped muscular fibers, termed erectile tissue.<a name='5_FNanchor_100'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_100'><sup>[100]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is not only the man who is supplied with erectile tissue which in the +process of tumescence becomes congested and swollen. The woman also, in +the corresponding external genital region, is likewise supplied with +erectile tissue now also charged with blood, and exhibits the same changes +as have taken place in her partner, though less conspicuously visible. In +the anthropoid apes, as the gorilla, the large clitoris and the nymphæ +become prominent in sexual excitement, but the less development of the +clitoris in women, together with the specifically human evolution of the +mons veneris and larger lips, renders this sexual turgescence practically +invisible, though it is perceptible to touch in an increased degree of +spongy and elastic tension. The whole feminine genital canal, including +the uterus, indeed, is richly supplied with blood-vessels, and is capable +<a name='5_Page_145'></a>during sexual excitement of a very high degree of turgescence, a kind of +erection.</p> + +<p>The process of erection in woman is accompanied by the pouring out of +fluid which copiously bathes all parts of the vulva around the entrance to +the vagina. This is a bland, more or less odorless mucus which, under +ordinary circumstances, slowly and imperceptibly suffuses the parts. When, +however, the entrance to the vagina is exposed and extended, as during a +gynæcological examination which occasionally produces sexual excitement, +there may be seen a real ejaculation of the fluid which, as usually +described, comes largely from the glands of Bartholin, situated at the +mouth of the vagina. Under these circumstances it is sometimes described +as being emitted in a jet which is thrown to a distance.<a name='5_FNanchor_101'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_101'><sup>[101]</sup></a> This mucous +ejaculation was in former days regarded as analogous to the seminal +ejaculation in man, and hence essential to conception. Although this +belief was erroneous the fluid poured out in this manner whenever a high +degree of tumescence is attained, and before the onset of detumescence, +certainly performs an important function in lubricating the entrance to +the genital canal and so facilitating the intromission of the male +organ.<a name='5_FNanchor_102'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_102'><sup>[102]</sup></a> Menstruation has a similar influence in facilitating coitus, +as Schurig long since pointed out.<a name='5_FNanchor_103'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_103'><sup>[103]</sup></a> A like process takes place during +parturition when the same parts are being lubricated and stretched in +preparation for the protrusion of the fœtal head. The occurrence +of the mucous flow in tumescence always indicates that that process is +actively affecting the central sexual organs, and that voluptuous emotions +are present.<a name='5_FNanchor_104'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_104'><sup>[104]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_146'></a> +<div class='blkquot'><p>The secretions of the genital canal and outlet in women are + somewhat numerous. We have the odoriferous glands of sebaceous + origin, and with them the prepuce of the clitoris which has been + described as a kind of gigantic sebaceous follicle with the + clitoris occupying its interior. (Hyrtl.) There is the secretion + from the glands of Bartholin. There is again the vaginal + secretion, opaque and albuminous, which appears to be alkaline + when secreted, but becomes acid under the decomposing influence + of bacteria, which are, however, harmless and not pathogenic. + (Gow, <i>Obstetrical Society of London</i>, January 3, 1894.) There + is, finally, the mucous uterine secretion, which is alkaline, + and, being poured out during orgasm, is believed to protect the + spermatozoa from destruction by the acid vaginal secretion.</p> + +<p> The belief that the mucus poured out in women during sexual + excitement is feminine semen and therefore essential to + conception had many remarkable consequences and was widespread + until the seventeenth century. Thus, in the chapter "De Modo + coeundi et de regimine eorum qui coeunt" of <i>De Secretis + Mulierum</i>, there is insistence on the importance of the proper + mixture of the male semen with the female semen and of arranging + that it shall not escape from the vagina. The woman must lie + quiet for several hours at least, not rising even to urinate, and + when she gets up, be very temperate in eating and drinking, and + not run or jump, pretending that she has a headache. It was the + belief in feminine semen which led some theologians to lay down + that a woman might masturbate if she had not experienced orgasm + in coitus. Schurig in his <i>Muliebria</i> (1729, pp. 159, <i>et seq.</i>) + discusses the opinions of old authors regarding the nature, + source, and uses of the female genital secretions, and quotes + authorities against the old view that it was female semen. In a + subsequent work (<i>Syllepsilogia</i>, 1731, pp. 3, <i>et seq.</i>) he + returns to the same question, quotes authors who accept a + feminine semen, shows that Harvey denied it any significance, and + himself decides against it. It has not seriously been brought + forward since.</p></div> + +<p>When erection is completed in both the man and the woman the conditions +necessary for conjugation have at last been fulfilled. In all animals, +even those most nearly allied to man, coitus is effected by the male +approaching the female posteriorly. In man the normal method of male +approach is anteriorly, face to face. Leonardo da Vinci, in a well-known +drawing representing a sagittal section of a man and a woman connected in +this position of so-called Venus obversa; has shown how well <a name='5_Page_147'></a>adapted the +position is to the normal position of the organs in the human +species.<a name='5_FNanchor_105'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_105'><sup>[105]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Among monkeys, it is stated, congress is sometimes performed when + the female is on all fours; at other times the male brings the + female between his thighs when he is sitting, holding her with + his forepaws. Froriep informed Lawrence that the male sometimes + supported his feet on the female's calves. (Sir W. Lawrence, + <i>Lectures on Physiology</i>, 1823, p. 186.) A summary of the methods + of congress practiced by the various animals below mammals will + be found in the article "Copulation" by H. de Varigny in Richet's + <i>Dictionnaire de Physiologie</i>, vol. iv.</p> + +<p> The anterior position in coitus, with the female partner lying + supine, is so widespread throughout the world that it may fairly + be termed the most typically human attitude in sexual congress. + It is found represented in Egyptian graves at Benihassan, + belonging to the Twelfth Dynasty; it is regarded by Mohammedans + as the normal position, although other positions are permitted by + the Prophet: "Your wives are your tillage: go in unto your + tillage in what manner soever you will;" it is that adopted in + Malacca; it appears, from Peruvian antiquities, to have been the + position generally, though not exclusively, adopted in ancient + Peru; it is found in many parts of Africa, and seems also to have + been the most usual position among the American aborigines.</p> + +<p> Various modifications of this position are, however, found. Thus, + in some parts of the world, as among the Suahelis in Zanzibar, + the male partner adopts the supine position. In Loango, according + to Pechuel-Loesche, coitus is performed lying on the side. + Sometimes, as on the west coast of Africa, the woman is supine + and the man more or less erect; or, as among the Queenslanders + (as described by Roth) the woman is supine and the man squats on + his heels with her thighs clasping his flanks, while he raises + her buttocks with his hands.</p> + +<p> The position of coitus in which the man is supine is without + doubt a natural and frequent variation of the specifically human + obverse method of coitus. It was evidently familiar to the + Romans. Ovid mentions it (<i>Ars Amatoria</i>, III, 777-8), + recommending it to little women, and saying that Andromache was + too tall to practice it with Hector. Aristophanes refers to it, + and there are Greek epigrams in which women boast of their skill + in riding their lovers. It has sometimes been viewed with a + certain disfavor because it seems to confer a superiority on the + woman. "Cursed be he," according to a Mohammedan saying, "who + maketh woman heaven and man earth."</p><a name='5_Page_148'></a> + +<p> Of special interest is the wide prevalence of an attitude in + coitus recalling that which prevails among quadrupeds. The + frequency with which on the walls of Pompeii coitus is + represented with the woman bending forward and her partner + approaching her posteriorly has led to the belief that this + attitude was formerly very common in Southern Italy. However that + may be, it is certainly normal at the present day among various + more or less primitive peoples in whom the vulva is often placed + somewhat posteriorly. It is thus among the Soudanese, as also, in + an altogether different part of the world, among the Eskimo + Innuit and Koniags. The New Caledonians, according to Foley, + cohabit in the quadrupedal manner, and so also the Papuans of New + Guinea (Bongu), according to Vahness. The same custom is also + found in Australia, where, however other postures are also + adopted. In Europe the quadrupedal posture would seem to prevail + among some of the South Slavs, notably the Dalmatians. (The + different methods of coitus practiced by the South Slavs are + described in Κρυπτάδια vol. vi, pp. 220, <i>et seq.</i>)</p> + +<p> This method of coitus was recommended by Lucretius (lib. iv) and + also advised by Paulus Æginetus as favorable to conception. (The + opinions of various early physicians are quoted by Schurig, + <i>Spermatologia</i>, 1720, pp. 232, <i>et seq.</i>). It seems to be a + position that is not infrequently agreeable to women, a fact + which may be brought into connection with the remarks of Adler + already quoted (p. 131) concerning the comparative lack of + adjustment of the feminine organs to the obverse position. It is + noteworthy that in the days of witchcraft hysterical women + constantly believed that they had had intercourse with the Devil + in this manner. This circumstance, indeed, probably aided in the + very marked disfavor in which coitus <i>a posteriori</i> fell after + the decay of classic influences. The mediæval physicians + described it as <i>mos diabolicus</i> and mistakenly supposed that it + produced abortion (Hyrtl, <i>op. cit.</i>, vol. ii, p. 87). The + theologians, needless to say, were opposed to the <i>mos + diabolicus</i>, and already in the Anglo-Saxon Penitential of + Theodore, at the end of the seventh century, 40 days' penance is + prescribed for this method of coitus.</p> + +<p> From the frequency with which they have been adopted by various + peoples as national customs, most of the postures in coitus here + referred to must be said to come within the normal range of + variation. It is a mistake to regard them as vicious perversions.</p></div> + +<p>Up to the point to which we have so far considered it, the process of +detumescence has been mainly nervous and vascular in character; it has, in +fact, been but the more acute stage of a process which has been going on +throughout tumescence.<a name='5_Page_149'></a> But now we reach the point at which a new element +comes in: muscular action. With the onset of muscular action, which is +mainly involuntary, even when it affects the voluntary muscles, +detumescence proper begins to take place. Henceforward purposeful psychic +action, except by an effort, is virtually abolished. The individual, as a +separate person, tends to disappear. He has become one with another +person, as nearly one as the conditions of existence ever permit; he and +she are now merely an instrument in the hands of a higher power—by +whatever name we may choose to call that Power—which is using them for an +end not themselves.</p> + +<p>The decisive moment in the production of the instinctive and involuntary +orgasm occurs when, under the influence of the stimulus applied to the +penis by friction with the vagina, the tension of the seminal fluid poured +into the urethra arouses the ejaculatory center in the spinal cord and the +bulbo-cavernosus muscle surrounding the urethra responsively contracts in +rhythmic spasms. Then it is that ejaculation occurs.<a name='5_FNanchor_106'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_106'><sup>[106]</sup></a></p> + +<p>"The circulation quickens, the arteries beat strongly," wrote Roubaud in a +description of the physical state during coitus which may almost be termed +classic; "the venous blood, arrested by muscular contraction, increases +the general heat, and this stagnation, more pronounced in the brain by the +contraction of the muscles of the neck and the throwing of the head +backward, causes a momentary cerebral congestion, during which +intelligence is lost and the faculties abolished. The eyes, violently +injected, become haggard, and the look uncertain, or, in the majority of +cases, the eyes are closed spasmodically to <a name='5_Page_150'></a>avoid the contact of the +light. The respiration is hurried, sometimes interrupted, and may be +suspended by the spasmodic contraction of the larynx, and the air, for a +time compressed, is at last emitted in broken and meaningless words. The +congested nervous centers only communicate confused sensations and +volitions; mobility and sensation show extreme disorder; the limbs are +seized by convulsions and sometimes by cramps, or are thrown wildly about +or become stiff like iron bars. The jaws, tightly pressed, grind the +teeth, and in some persons the delirium is carried so far that they bite +to bleeding the shoulders their companions have imprudently abandoned to +them. This frantic state of epilepsy lasts but a short time, but it +suffices to exhaust the forces of the organism, especially in man. It is, +I believe, Galen, who said: 'Omne animal post coitum triste præter +mulierem gallumque.'"<a name='5_FNanchor_107'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_107'><sup>[107]</sup></a> Most of the elements that make up this typical +picture of the state of coitus are not absolutely essential to that state, +but they all come within the normal range of variation. There can be no +doubt that this range is considerable. There would appear to be not only +individual, but also racial, differences; there is a remarkable passage in +Vatsyayana's <i>Kama Sutra</i> describing the varying behavior of the women of +different races in India under the stress of sexual excitement—Dravidian +women with difficulty attaining erethism, women of the Punjaub fond of +being caressed with the tongue, women of Oude with impetuous desire and +profuse flow of mucus, etc.—and it is highly probable, Ploss and Bartels +remark, that these characterizations are founded on exact +observations.<a name='5_FNanchor_108'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_108'><sup>[108]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The various phenomena included in Roubaud's description of the condition +during coitus may all be directly or indirectly reduced to two groups: the +first circulatory and respiratory, the second motor. It is necessary to +consider both these aspects of the process of detumescence in somewhat +greater detail, although while it is most convenient to discuss them +separately, <a name='5_Page_151'></a>it must be borne in mind that they are not really separable; +the circulatory phenomena are in large measure a by-product of the +involuntary motor process.</p> + +<p>With the approach of detumescence the respiration becomes shallow, rapid, +and to some extent arrested. This characteristic of the breathing during +sexual excitement is well recognized; so that in, for instance, the +<i>Arabian Nights</i>, it is commonly noted of women when gazing at beautiful +youths whose love they desired, that they ceased breathing.<a name='5_FNanchor_109'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_109'><sup>[109]</sup></a> It may be +added that exactly the same tendency to superficial and arrested +respiration takes place whenever there is any intense mental +concentration, as in severe intellectual work.<a name='5_FNanchor_110'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_110'><sup>[110]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The arrest of respiration tends to render the blood venous, and thus aids +in stimulating the vasomotor centers, raising the blood-pressure in the +body generally, and especially in the erectile tissues. High +blood-pressure is one of the most marked features of the state of +detumescence. The heart beats are stronger and quicker, the surface +arteries are more visible, the conjunctivæ become red. The precise degree +of blood-pressure attained during coitus has been most accurately +ascertained in the dog. In Bechterew's laboratory in St. Petersburg a +manometer was introduced into the central end of the carotid artery of a +bitch; a male dog was then introduced, and during coitus observations were +made on the blood-pressure at the peripheral and central ends of the +artery. It was found that there was a great general elevation of +blood-pressure, intense hyperæmia of the brain, rapid alternations, during +the act, of vasoconstriction and vasodilatation of the brain, with +increase and diminution of the general arterial tension in relation with +the various phases of the act, the greatest cerebral vasodilatation and +hyperæmia coinciding with the moment following the intromission of the +penis; the end of the act is followed by a considerable <a name='5_Page_152'></a>fall in the +blood-pressure.<a name='5_FNanchor_111'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_111'><sup>[111]</sup></a> I am not acquainted with any precise observations on +the blood-pressure in human subjects during detumescence, and there are +obvious difficulties in the way of such observations. It is probable, +however, that the conditions found would be substantially the same. This +is indicated, so far as the very marked increase of blood-pressure is +concerned, by some observations made by Vaschide and Vurpas with the +sphygmanometer on a lady under the influence of sexual excitement. In this +case there was a relationship of sympathy and friendly tenderness between +the experimenter and the subject, Madame X, aged 25. Experimenter and +subject talked sympathetically, and finally, we are told, while the latter +still had her hands in the sphygmanometer, the former almost made a +declaration of love. Madame X was greatly impressed, and afterward +admitted that her emotions had been genuine and strong. The +blood-pressure, which was in this subject habitually 65 millimeters, rose +to 150 and even 160, indicating a very high pressure, which rarely occurs; +at the same time Madame X looked very emotional and troubled.<a name='5_FNanchor_112'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_112'><sup>[112]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Some authorities are of opinion that irregularities in the + accomplishment of the sexual act are specially liable to cause + disturbances in the circulation. Thus Kisch, of Prague, refers to + the case of a couple practising coitus interruptus—the husband + withdrawing before ejaculation—in which the wife, a vigorous + woman, became liable after some years to attacks termed by Kisch + <i>neurasthenia cordis vasomotoria</i>, in which there was at daily or + longer intervals palpitation, with feelings of anxiety, headache, + dizziness, muscular weakness and tendency to faint. He regards + coitus as a cause of various heart troubles in women: (1) Attacks + of tachycardia in very excitable and sexually inclined women; (2) + attacks of tachycardia with dyspnœa in young women, with + vaginismus; (3) cardiac symptoms with lowered vascular tone in + women who for a long time have practised coitus interruptus + without complete sexual gratification (Kisch, "Herzbeschwerden + der Frauen verursacht <a name='5_Page_153'></a>durch den Cohabitationsact," <i>Münchener + Medizinisches Wochenschrift</i>, 1897, p. 617). In this connection, + also, reference may probably be made to those attacks of anxiety + which Freud associates with psychic sexual lesions of an + emotional character.</p></div> + +<p>Associated with this vascular activity in detumescence we find a general +tendency to glandular activity. Various secretions are formed abundantly. +Perspiration is copious, and the ancient relationship between the +cutaneous and sexual systems seems to evoke a general activity of the skin +and its odoriferous secretions. Salivation, which also occurs, is very +conspicuous in many lower animals, as for instance in the donkey, notably +the female, who just before coitus stands with mouth open, jaws moving, +and saliva dribbling. In men, corresponding to the more copious secretion +in women, there is, during the latter stages of tumescence, a slight +secretion of mucus—Fürbringer's <i>urethrorrhœa ex +libidine</i>—which appears in drops at the urethral orifice. It comes from +the small glands of Littré and Cowper which open into the urethra. This +phenomenon was well known to the old theologians, who called it +<i>distillatio</i>, and realized its significance as at once distinct from +semen and an indication that the mind was dwelling on voluptuous images; +it was also known in classic times<a name='5_FNanchor_113'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_113'><sup>[113]</sup></a>; more recently it has often been +confused with semen and has thus sometimes caused needless anxiety to +nervous persons. There is also an increased secretion of urine, and it is +probable that if the viscera were more accessible to observation we might +be able to demonstrate that the glands throughout the body share in this +increased activity.</p> + +<p>The phenomena of detumescence culminate, however, and have their most +obvious manifestation in motor activity. The genital act, as Vaschide and +Vurpas remark, consists essentially <a name='5_Page_154'></a>in "a more and more marked tension of +the motor state which, reaching its maximum, presents a short tonic phase, +followed by a clonic phase, and terminates in a period of adynamia and +repose." This motor activity is of the essence of the impulse of +detumescence, because without it the sperm cells could not be brought into +the neighborhood of the germ cell and be propelled into the organic nest +which is assigned for their conjunction and incubation.</p> + +<p>The motor activity is general as well as specifically sexual. There is a +general tendency to more or less involuntary movement, without any +increase of voluntary muscular power, which is, indeed, decreased, and +Vaschide and Vurpas state that dynamometric results are somewhat lower +than normal during sexual excitement, and the variations greater.<a name='5_FNanchor_114'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_114'><sup>[114]</sup></a> The +tendency to diffused activity of involuntary muscle is well illustrated by +the contraction of the bladder associated with detumescence. While this +occurs in both sexes, in men erection produces a mechanical impediment to +any evacuation of the bladder. In women there is not only a desire to +urinate but, occasionally, actual urination. Many quite healthy and normal +women have, as a rare accident supervening on the coincidence of an +unusually full bladder with an unusual degree of sexual excitement, +experienced a powerful and quite involuntary evacuation of the bladder at +the moment of orgasm. In women with less normal nervous systems this has, +more rarely, been almost habitual. Brantôme has perhaps recorded the +earliest case of this kind in referring to a lady he knew who "quand on +lui faisait cela <a name='5_Page_155'></a>elle se compissait à bon escient."<a name='5_FNanchor_115'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_115'><sup>[115]</sup></a> The tendency to +trembling, constriction of throat, sneezing, emission of internal gas, and +the other similar phenomena occasionally associated with detumescence, are +likewise due to diffusion of the motor disturbance. Even in infancy the +motor signs of sexual excitement are the most obvious indications of +orgasm; thus West, describing masturbation in a child of six or nine +months who practiced thigh-rubbing, states that when sitting in her high +chair she would grasp the handles, stiffen herself, and stare, rubbing her +thighs quickly together several times, and then come to herself with a +sigh, tired, relaxed, and sweating, these seizures, which lasted one or +two minutes, being mistaken by the relations for epileptic fits.<a name='5_FNanchor_116'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_116'><sup>[116]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The essentially motor character of detumescence is well shown by + the extreme forms of erotic intoxication which sometimes appear + as the result of sexual excitement. Féré, who has especially + called attention to the various manifestations of this condition, + presents an instructive case of a man of neurotic heredity and + antecedents, in whom it occasionally happened that sexual + excitement, instead of culminating in the normal orgasm, attained + its climax in a fit of uncontrollable muscular excitement. He + would then sing, dance, gesticulate, roughly treat his partner, + break the objects around him, and finally sink down exhausted and + stupefied. (Féré, <i>L'Instinct Sexuel</i>, Chapter X.) In such a case + a diffused and general detumescence has taken the place of the + normal detumescence which has its main focus in the sexual + sphere.</p> + +<p> The same relationship is shown in a case of impotence accompanied + by cramps in the calves and elsewhere, which has been recorded by + Brügelmann ("Zur Lehre vom Perversen Sexualismus," <i>Zeitschrift + für Hypnotismus</i>, 1900, Heft I). These muscular conditions ceased + for several days whenever coitus was effected.</p> + +<p> An instructive analogy to the motor irradiations preceding the + moment of sexual detumescence may be found in the somewhat + similar motor irradiations which follow the delayed expulsion of + a highly distended bladder. These sometimes become very marked in + a child or <a name='5_Page_156'></a>young woman unable to control the motor system + absolutely. The legs are crossed, the foot swung, the thighs + tightly pressed together, the toes curled. The fingers are flexed + in rhythmic succession. The whole body slowly twists as though + the seat had become uncomfortable. It is difficult to concentrate + the mind; the same remark may be automatically repeated; the eyes + search restlessly, and there is a tendency to count surrounding + objects or patterns. When the extreme degree of tension is + reached it is only by executing a kind of dance that the + explosive contraction of the bladder is restrained.</p> + +<p> The picture of muscular irradiation presented under these + circumstances differs but slightly from that of the onset of + detumescence. In one case the explosion is sought, in the other + case it is dreaded; but in both cases there is a retarded + muscular tension,—in the one case involuntary, in the other case + voluntary—maintained at a point of acute intensity, and in both + cases the muscular irradiations of this tension spread over the + whole body.</p> + +<p> The increased motor irritability of the state of detumescence + somewhat resembles the conditions produced by a weak anæsthetic + and there is some interest in noting the sexual excitement liable + to occur in anæsthesia. I am indebted to Dr. J. F. W. Silk for some + remarks on this point:—</p> + +<p> "I. Sexual emotions may apparently be aroused during the stage of + excitement preceding or following the administration of any + anæsthetic; these emotions may take the form of mere delirious + utterances, or may be associated with what is apparently a sexual + orgasm. Or reflex phenomena connected with the sexual organs may + occasionally be observed under special circumstances; or, to put + it in another way, such reflex possibilities are not always + abolished by the condition of narcosis or anæsthesia.</p> + +<p> "II. Of the particular anæsthetics employed I am inclined to + think that the possibility of such conditions arising is + inversely proportionate to their strength, <i>e.g.</i>, they are more + frequently observed with a weak anæsthetic like nitrous oxide + than with chloroform.</p> + +<p> "III. Sexual emotions I believe to be rarely observable in men, + and this is remarkable, or, I should say, particularly + noticeable, for the presence of nurses, female students, etc., + might almost have led one to expect that the contrary would have + been the case. On the other hand, it is among men that I have + frequently observed a reflex phenomenon which has usually taken + the shape of an erection of the penis when the structures in the + neighborhood of the spermatic cord have been handled.</p> + +<p> "IV. Among females the emotional sexual phenomena most frequently + obtrude themselves, and I believe that if it were possible to + induce people to relate their dreams they would very often be + found to be of a sexual character."</p></div><a name='5_Page_157'></a> + +<p>Much more important than the general motor phenomena, more purposive +though involuntary, are the specifically sexual muscular movements. From +the very beginning of detumescence, indeed, muscular activity makes itself +felt, and the peripheral muscles of sex act, according to Kobelt's +expression, as a peripheral sexual heart. In the male these movements are +fairly obvious and fairly simple. It is required that the semen should be +expressed from the vesiculæ seminales, propelled along the urethra, in +combination with the prostatic fluid which is equally essential, and +finally ejected with a certain amount of force from the urethral orifice. +Under the influence of the stimulation furnished by the contact and +friction of the vagina, this process is effectively carried out, mainly by +the rhythmic contractions of the bulbo-cavernosus muscle, and the semen is +emitted in a jet which may be ejaculated to a distance varying from a few +centimeters to a meter or more.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>With regard to the details of the psychic sides of this process a + correspondent, a psychologist, writes as follows:—</p> + +<p> "I have never noticed in my reading any attempt to analyze the + sensations which accompany the orgasm, and, as I have made a good + many attempts to make such an analysis myself, I will append the + results on the chance that they may be of some value. I have + checked my results so far as possible by comparing them with the + experience of such of my friends as had coitus frequently and + were willing to tell me as much as they could of the psychology + of the process.</p> + +<p> "The first fact that I hit upon was the importance of pressure. + As one of my informants picturesquely phrases it—'the tighter + the fit the greater the pleasure.' This agrees, too, with their + unanimous testimony that the pleasurable sensations were much + greater when the orgasm occurred simultaneously in the man and + woman. Their analysis seldom went further than this, but a few + remarked that the distinctive sensations accompanying the orgasm + seem to begin near the root of the penis or in the testes, and + that they are qualitatively different from the tickling + sensations which precede them.</p> + +<p> "These tickling sensations are caused, I think, by the friction + of the glands against the vaginal walls, and are supplemented by + other sensations from the urethra, whose nerves are stimulated by + pressure of the vaginal walls and sphincter. The specific + sensation of the orgasm begins, I believe, with a strong + contraction of the muscles of the urethral walls along the entire + length of the canal, and is felt as a peculiar <a name='5_Page_158'></a>ache starting + from the base of the penis and quickly becoming diffused through + the whole organ. This sensation reaches its climax with the + expulsion of the semen into the urethra and the consequent + feeling of distention, which is instantly followed by the + rhythmic peristaltic contractions of the urethral muscles which + mark the climax of the orgasm.</p> + +<p> "The most careful introspection possible under the circumstances + seems to show that these sensations arise almost wholly from the + urethra and in a far less degree from the corona. During periods + of great sexual excitement the nerves of the urethra and corona + seem to possess a peculiar sensitivity and are powerfully + stimulated by the violent peristaltic contractions of the muscles + in the urethral walls during ejaculation. It seems possible that + the intensity and volume of sensation felt at the glans may be + due in part to the greater area of sensitive surface presented in + the fossa as well as to the sensitivity of the corona, and in + part to the fact that during the orgasm the glans is more highly + congested than at any other time, and the nerve endings thus + subjected to additional pressure.</p> + +<p> "If the foregoing statements are true, it is easy to see why the + pleasure of the man is much increased when the orgasm occurs at + the same time in his partner and himself, for the contractions of + the vagina upon the penis would increase the stimulation of all + the nerve endings in that organ for which a mechanical stimulus + is adequate, and the prominence of the corpus spongiosum and + corona would ensure them the greatest stimulation. It seems not + improbable that the specific sensation of orgasm rises from the + stimulation of the peculiar form of nerve end-bulbs which Krause + found in the corpus spongiosum and in the glans.</p> + +<p> "The characteristic massiveness of the experience is probably due + largely to the great number of sensations of strain and pressure + caused by the powerful reflex contraction of so many of the + voluntary muscles.</p> + +<p> "Of course, the foregoing analysis is purely tentative, and I + offer it only on the chance that it may suggest some line of + inquiry which may lead to results of value to the student of + sexual psychology."</p> + +<p> In man the whole process of detumescence, when it has once really + begun, only occupies a few moments. It is so likewise in many + animals; in the genera Bos, Ovis, etc., it is very short, almost + instantaneous, and rather short also in the Equidæ (in a vigorous + stallion, according to Colin, ten to twelve seconds). As + Disselhorst has pointed out, this is dependent on the fact that + these animals, like man, possess a vas deferens which broadens + into an ampulla serving as a receptacle which holds the semen + ready for instant emission when required. On the other hand, in + the dog, cat, boar, and the Canidæ, Felidæ, and Suidæ generally, + there is no receptacle of this kind, and coitus is slow, since a + longer time is required for the peristaltic action of the vas to + bring the semen <a name='5_Page_159'></a>to the urogenital sinus. (R. Disselhorst, <i>Die + Accessorischen Geschlechtsdrusen der Wirbelthiere</i>, 1897, p. + 212.)</p> + +<p> In man there can be little doubt that detumescence is more + rapidly accomplished in the European than in the East, in India, + among the yellow races, or in Polynesia. This is probably in part + due to a deliberate attempt to prolong the act in the East, and + in part to a greater nervous erethism among Westerns.</p></div> + +<p>In the woman the specifically sexual muscular process is less visible, +more obscure, more complex, and uncertain. Before detumescence actually +begins there are at intervals involuntary rhythmic contractions of the +walls of the vagina, seeming to have the object of at once stimulating and +harmonizing with those that are about to begin in the male organ. It would +appear that these rhythmic contractions are the exaggeration of a +phenomenon which is normal, just as slight contraction is normal and +constant in the bladder. Jastreboff has shown, in the rabbit, that the +vagina is in constant spontaneous rhythmic contraction from above +downward, not peristaltic, but in segments, the intensity of the +contractions increasing with age and especially with sexual development. +This vaginal contraction which in women only becomes well marked just +before detumescence, and is due mainly to the action of the sphincter +cunni (analogous to the bulbo-cavernosus in the male), is only a part of +the localized muscular process. At first there would appear to be a reflex +peristaltic movement of the Fallopian tubes and uterus. Dembo observed +that in animals stimulation of the upper anterior wall of the vagina +caused gradual contraction of the uterus, which is erected by powerful +contraction of its muscular fiber and round ligaments while at the same +time it descends toward the vagina, its cavity becoming more and more +diminished and mucus being forced out. In relaxing, Aristotle long ago +remarked, it aspirates the seminal fluid.</p> + +<p>Although the active participation of the sexual organs in woman, to the +end of directing the semen into the womb at the moment of detumescence, is +thus a very ancient belief, and harmonizes with the Greek view of the womb +as an animal in <a name='5_Page_160'></a>the body endowed with a considerable amount of +activity,<a name='5_FNanchor_117'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_117'><sup>[117]</sup></a> precise observation in modern times has offered but little +confirmation of the reality of this participation. Such observations as +have been made have usually been the accidental result of sexual +excitement and orgasm occurring during a gynæcological examination. As, +however, such a result is liable to occur in erotic subjects, a certain +number of precise observations have accumulated during the past century. +So far as the evidence goes, it would seem that in women, as in mares, +bitches, and other animals, the uterus becomes shorter, broader, and +softer during the orgasm, at the same time descending lower into the +pelvis, with its mouth open intermittently, so that, as one writer +remarks, spontaneously recurring to the simile which commended itself to +the Greeks, "the uterus might be likened to an animal gasping for +breath."<a name='5_FNanchor_118'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_118'><sup>[118]</sup></a> This sensitive, responsive mobility of the uterus is, +indeed, not confined to the moment of detumescence, but may occur at other +times under the influence of sexual emotion.</p> + +<p>It would seem probable that in this erection, contraction, and descent of +the uterus, and its simultaneous expulsion of mucus, we have the decisive +moment in the completion of detumescence in woman, and it is probable that +the thick mucus, unlike the earlier more limpid secretion, which women are +sometimes aware of after orgasm, is emitted from the womb at this time. +This is, however, not absolutely certain. Some authorities regard +detumescence in women as accomplished in the pouring out of secretions, +others in the rhythmic genital contractions; the sexual parts may, +however, be copiously bathed in mucus for an indefinitely long period +before the final stage of detumescence is achieved, and the rhythmic +contractions are also taking place at a somewhat early period; in neither +respect is there any obvious increase at the final moment of orgasm. In +women this would seem to be more conspicuously a nervous manifestation +than in men. On the subjective side it is very <a name='5_Page_161'></a>pronounced, with its +feeling of relieved tension and agreeable repose—a moment when, as one +woman expresses it, together with intense pleasure, there is, as it were, +a floating up into a higher sphere, like the beginning of chloroform +narcosis—but on the objective side this culminating moment is less easy +to define.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Various observations and remarks made during the past two or + three centuries by Bond, Valisneri, Dionis, Haller, Günther, and + Bischoff, tending to show a sucking action of the uterus in both + women and other female animals, have been brought together by + Litzmann in R. Wagner's <i>Handwörterbuch der Physiologie</i> (1846, + vol. iii, p. 53). Litzmann added an experience of his own: "I had + an opportunity lately, while examining a young and very erethic + woman, to observe how suddenly the uterus assumed a more erect + position, and descended deeper in the pelvis; the lips of the + womb became equal in length, the cervix rounded, softer, and more + easily reached by the finger, and at the same time a high state + of sexual excitement was revealed by the respiration and voice."</p> + +<p> The general belief still remained, however, that the woman's part + in conjugation is passive, and that it is entirely by the energy + of the male organ and of the male sexual elements, the + spermatozoa, that conjunction with the germ cell is attained. + According to this theory, it was believed that the spermatozoa + were, as Wilkinson expresses it, in a history of opinion on this + question, "endowed with some sort of intuition or instinct; that + they would turn in the direction of the os uteri, wading through + the acid mucus of the vagina; travel patiently upward and around + the vaginal portion of the uterus; enter the uterus and proceed + onward in search of the waiting ovum." (A. D. Wilkinson, + "Sterility in the Female," <i>Transactions of the Lincoln Medical + Society</i>, Nebraska, 1896.)</p> + +<p> About the year 1859 Fichstedt seems to have done something to + overthrow this theory by declaring his belief that the uterus was + not, as commonly supposed, a passive organ in coitus, but was + capable of sucking in the semen during the brief period of + detumescence. Various authorities then began to bring forward + arguments and observations in the same sense. Wernich, + especially, directed attention to this point in 1872 in a paper + on the erectile properties of the lower segment of the uterus + ("Die Erectionsfahigkeit des untern Uterus-Abschnitts," <i>Beiträge + zur Geburtshülfe und Gynäkologie</i>, vol. i, p. 296). He made + precise observations and came to the conclusion that owing to + erectile properties in the neck of the uterus, this part of the + womb elongates during congress and reaches down into the pelvis + with an aspiratory movement, as if to meet the glans of the male. + A little later, in a case of partial prolapse, Beck, in ignorance + of Wernich's theory, was enabled to make <a name='5_Page_162'></a>a very precise + observation of the action of the uterus during excitement. In + this case the woman was sexually very excitable even under + ordinary examination, and Beck carefully noted the phenomena that + took place during the orgasm. "The os and cervix uteri," he + states, "had been about as firm as usual, moderately hard and, + generally speaking, in a natural and normal condition, with the + external os closed to such an extent as to admit of the uterine + probe with difficulty; but the instant that the height of + excitement was at hand, the os opened itself to the extent of + fully an inch, as nearly as my eye can judge, made five or six + successive gasps as if it were drawing the external os into the + cervix, each time powerfully, and, it seemed to me, with a + regular rhythmical action, at the same time losing its former + density and hardness and becoming quite soft to the touch. Upon + the cessation of the action, as related, the os suddenly closed, + the cervix again hardened itself, and the intense congestion was + dissipated." (J. R. Beck, "How do the Spermatozoa Enter the + Uterus?" <i>American Journal of Obstetrics</i>, 1874.) It would appear + that in the early part of this final process of detumescence the + action of the uterus is mainly one of contraction and ejaculation + of any mucus that may be contained; Dr. Paul Mundé has described + "the gushing, almost in jets," of this mucus which he has + observed in an erotic woman under a rather long digital and + specular examination. (<i>American Journal of Obstetrics</i>, 1893.) + It is during the latter part of detumescence, it would seem, and + perhaps for a short time after the orgasm is over, that the + action of the uterus is mainly aspiratory.</p></div> + +<p>While the active part played by the womb in detumescence can no longer be +questioned, it need not too hastily be assumed that the belief in the +active movements of the spermatozoa must therefore be denied. The vigorous +motility of the tadpole-like organisms is obvious to anyone who has ever +seen fresh semen under the microscope; and if it is correct, as Clifton +Edgar states, that the spermatozoa may retain their full activity in the +female organs for at least seventeen days, they have ample time to exert +their energies. The fact that impregnation sometimes occurs without +rupture of the hymen is not decisive evidence that there has been no +penetration, as the hymen may dilate without rupturing; but there seems no +reason to doubt that conception has sometimes taken place when ejaculation +has occurred without penetration; this is indicated in a fairly objective +manner when, as has been occasionally observed, conception has occurred in +<a name='5_Page_163'></a>women whose vaginas were so narrow as scarcely to admit the entrance of a +goose-quill; such was the condition in the case of a pregnant woman +brought forward by Roubaud. The stories, repeated in various books, of +women who have conceived after homosexual relations with partners who had +just left their husbands' beds are not therefore inherently +impossible.<a name='5_FNanchor_119'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_119'><sup>[119]</sup></a> Janke quotes numerous cases in which there has been +impregnation in virgins who have merely allowed the penis to be placed in +contact with the vulva, the hymen remaining unruptured until +delivery.<a name='5_FNanchor_120'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_120'><sup>[120]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It must be added, however, that even if the semen is effused merely at the +mouth of the vagina, without actual penetration, the spermatozoa are still +not entirely without any resource save their own motility in the task of +reaching the ovum. As we have seen, it is not only the uterus which takes +an active part in detumescence; the vagina also is in active movement, and +it seems highly probable that, at all events in some women and under some +circumstances, such movement favoring aspiration toward the womb may be +communicated to the external mouth of the vagina.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Riolan (<i>Anthropographia</i>, 1626, p. 294) referred to the + constriction and dilation of the vulva under the influence of + sexual excitement. It is said that in Abyssinia women can, when + adopting the straddling posture of coitus, by the movements of + their own vaginal muscles alone, grasp the male organ and cause + ejaculation, although the man remains passive. According to + Lorion the Annamites, adopting the normal posture of coitus, + introduce the penis when flaccid or only half erect, the + contraction of the vaginal walls completing the process; the + penis is very small in this people. It is recognized by + gynæcologists that the condition of vaginismus, in which there is + spasmodic contraction of the vagina, making intercourse painful + or impossible, is but a morbid exaggeration of the normal + contraction which occurs in sexual excitement. Even in the + absence of sexual excitement there is a vague affection, + occurring in both married and unmarried women, and not, it would + seem, <a name='5_Page_164'></a>necessarily hysterical, characterized by quivering or + twitching of the vulva; I am told that this is popularly termed + "flackering of the shape" in Yorkshire and "taittering of the + lips" in Ireland. It may be added that quivering of the gluteal + muscles also takes place during detumescence, and that in Indian + medicine this is likewise regarded as a sign of sexual desire in + women, apart from coitus.</p> + +<p> A non-medical correspondent in Australia, W. J. Chidley, from whom + I have received many communications on this subject, is strongly + of opinion from his own observations that not only does the + uterus take an active part in coitus, but that under natural + conditions the vagina also plays an active part in the process. + He was led to suspect such an action many years ago, as well by + an experience of his own, as also by hearing from a young woman + who met her lover after a long absence that by the excitement + thus aroused a tape attached to the underclothes had been drawn + into the vagina. Since then the confidences of various friends, + together with observations of animals, have confirmed him in the + view that the general belief that coitus must be effected by + forcible entry of the male organ into a passive vagina is + incorrect. He considers that under normal circumstances coitus + should take place but rarely, and then only under the most + favorable circumstances, perhaps exclusively in spring, and, most + especially, only when the woman is ready for it. Then, when in + the arms of the man she loves, the vagina, in sympathy with the + active movements of the womb, becomes distended at the touch of + the turgescent, but not fully erect, penis, "flashes open and + draws in the male organ." "All animals," he adds, "have sexual + intercourse by the male organ being <i>drawn</i>, not forced, into the + female. I have been borne out in this by friends who have seen + horses, camels, mules and other large animals in the coupling + season. What is more absurd, for instance, than to say that an + entire <i>penetrates</i> the mare? His penis is a sensitive, beautiful + piece of mechanism, which brings its light head here and there + till it touches the right spot, when the mare, <i>if ready</i>, takes + it in. An entire's penis could not penetrate anything; it is a + curve, a beautiful curve which would easily bend. A bull's, + again, is turned down at the end and, more palpably still, would + fold on itself if pressed with force. The womb and vagina of a + beautiful and healthy woman constitute a living, vital, moving + organ, sensitive to a look, a word, a thought, a hand on the + waist."</p> + +<p> A well-known American author thus writes in confirmation of the + foregoing view: "In nature the woman wooes. When impassioned her + vagina becomes erect and dilated, and so lubricated with abundant + mucus to the lips that entrance is easy. This dilatation and + erectile expansion of vagina withdraws the hymen so close to the + walls that penetration need not tear it or cause pain. The more + muscular, primitive and healthy the woman the tougher and less + sensitive the hymen, <a name='5_Page_165'></a>and the less likely to break or bleed. I + think one great function of the foreskin also is to moisten the + glans, so that it can be lubricated for entrance, and then to + retract, moist side out, to make entrance still easier. I think + that in nature the glans penetrates within the labia, is + withstood a moment, vibrating, and then all resistance is + withdrawn by a sudden 'flashing open' of the gates, permitting + easy entrance, and that the sudden giving up of resistance, and + substitution of welcome, with its instantaneous deep entrance, + causes an almost immediate male orgasm (the thrill being + irresistibly exciting). Certainly this is the process as observed + in horses, cattle, goats, etc., and it seems likely something + analogous is natural in man."</p> + +<p> While it is easily possible to carry to excess a view which would + make the woman rather than the man the active agent in coitus + (and it may be recalled that in the Cebidæ the penis, as also the + clitoris, is furnished with a bone), there is probably an element + of truth in the belief that the vagina shares in the active part + which, there can now be little doubt, is played by the uterus in + detumescence. Such a view certainly enables us to understand how + it is that semen effused on the exterior sexual organs can be + conveyed to the uterus.</p> + +<p> It was indeed the failure to understand the vital activity of the + semen and the feminine genital canal, co-operating together + towards the junction of sperm cell and germ cell, which for so + long stood in the way of the proper understanding of conception. + Even the genius of Harvey, which had grappled successfully with + the problem of the circulation, failed in the attempt to + comprehend the problem of generation. Mainly on account of this + difficulty, he was unable to see how the male element could + possibly enter the uterus, although he devoted much observation + and study to the question. Writing of the uterus of the doe after + copulation, he says: "I began to doubt, to ask myself whether the + semen of the male could by any possibility make its way by + attraction or injection to the seat of conception, and repeated + examination led me to the conclusion that none of the semen + reached this seat." (<i>De-Generatione Animalium</i>, Exercise lxvii.) + "The woman," he finally concluded, "after contact with the + spermatic fluid <i>in coitu</i>, seems to receive an influence and + become fecundated without the co-operation of any sensible + corporeal agent, in the same way as iron touched by the magnet is + endowed with its powers."</p></div> + +<p>Although the specifically sexual muscular process of detumescence in +women—as distinguished from the general muscular phenomena of sexual +excitement which may be fairly obvious—is thus seen to be somewhat +complex and obscure, in women as well as in men detumescence is a +convulsion which <a name='5_Page_166'></a>discharges a slowly accumulated store of nervous force. +In women also, as in men, the motor discharge is directed to a specific +end—the intromission of the semen in the one sex, its reception in the +other. In both sexes the sexual orgasm and the pleasure and satisfaction +associated with it, involve, as their most essential element, the motor +activity of the sexual sphere.<a name='5_FNanchor_121'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_121'><sup>[121]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The active co-operation of the female organs in detumescence is + probably indicated by the difficulty which is experienced in + achieving conception by the artificial injection of semen. Marion + Sims stated in 1866, in <i>Clinical Notes on Uterine Surgery</i>, that + in 55 injections in six women he had only once been successful; + he believed that that was the only case at that time on record. + Jacobi had, however, practiced artificial fecundation in animals + (in 1700) and John Hunter in man. See Gould and Pyle, <i>Anomalies + and Curiosities of Medicine</i>, p. 43; also Janke (<i>Die + Willkürliche Hervorbringen des Geschlechts</i>, pp. 230 <i>et seq.</i>) + who discusses the question of artificial fecundation and brings + together a mass of data.</p></div> + +<p>The facial expression when tumescence is completed is marked by a high +degree of energy in men and of loveliness in women. At this moment, when +the culminating act of life is about to be accomplished, the individual +thus reaches his supreme state of radiant beauty. The color is heightened, +the eyes are larger and brighter, the facial muscles are more tense, so +that in mature individuals any wrinkles disappear and youthfulness +returns.</p> + +<p>At the beginning of detumescence the features are frequently more +discomposed. There is a general expression of eager receptivity to sensory +impressions. The dilatation of the pupils, the expansion of the nostrils, +the tendency to salivation and to movements of the tongue, all go to make +up a picture which indicates an approaching gratification of sensory +desires; it is significant that in some animals there is at this moment +erection of the ears.<a name='5_FNanchor_122'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_122'><sup>[122]</sup></a> There is sometimes a tendency to utter broken +and meaningless words, and it is noted that sometimes <a name='5_Page_167'></a>women have called +out on their mothers.<a name='5_FNanchor_123'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_123'><sup>[123]</sup></a> The dilatation of the pupils produces +photophobia, and in the course of detumescence the eyes are frequently +closed from this cause. At the beginning of sexual excitement, Vaschide +and Vurpas have observed, tonicity of the eye-muscles seems to increase; +the elevators of the upper lids contract, so that the eyes look larger and +their mobility and brightness are heightened; with the increase of +muscular tonicity strabismus occurs, owing to the greater strength of the +muscles that carry the eyes inward.<a name='5_FNanchor_124'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_124'><sup>[124]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The facial expression which marks the culmination of tumescence, + and the approach of detumescence is that which is generally + expressive of joy. In an interesting psycho-physical study of the + emotion of joy, Dearborn thus summarizes its characteristics: + "The eyes are brighter and the upper eyelid elevated, as also are + the brows, the skin over the glabella, the upper lip and the + corners of the mouth, while the skin at the outer canthi of the + eye is puckered. The nostrils are moderately dilated, the tongue + slightly extended and the cheeks somewhat expanded, while in + persons with largely developed pinnal muscles the ears tend + somewhat to incline forwards. The whole arterial system is + dilated, with consequent blushing from this effect on the dermal + capillaries of the face, neck, scalp and hands, and sometimes + more extensively even; from the same cause the eyes slightly + bulge. The whole glandular system likewise is stimulated, causing + the secretions,—gastric, salivary, lachrymal, sudoral, mammary, + genital, etc.—to be increased, with the resulting rise of + temperature and increase in the katobolism generally. Volubility + is almost regularly increased, and is, indeed, one of the most + sensitive and constant of the correlations in emotional + delight.... Pleasantness is correlated in living organisms by + vascular, muscular and glandular extension or expansion, both + literal and figurative." (G. Dearborn, "The Emotion of Joy," + <i>Psychological Review Monograph Supplements</i>, vol. ii, No. 5, p. + 62.) All these signs of joy appear to occur at some stage of the + process of sexual excitement.</p> + +<p> In some monkeys it would seem that the muscular movement which in + man has become the smile is the characteristic facial expression + of sexual tumescence or courtship. Discussing the facial + expression of pleasure in children, S. S. Buckman has the + following remarks: "There <a name='5_Page_168'></a>is one point in such expression which + has not received due consideration, namely, the raising of lumps + of flesh each side of the nose as an indication of pleasure. + Accompanying this may be seen small furrows, both in children and + adults, running from the eyes somewhat obliquely towards the + nose. What these characters indicate may be learned from the male + mandril, whose face, particularly in the breeding season, shows + colored fleshy prominences each side of the nose, with + conspicuous furrows and ridges. In the male mandril these + characters have been developed because, being an unmistakable + sign of sexual ardor, they gave the female particular evidence of + sexual feelings. Thus such characters would come to be recognized + as habitually symptomatic of pleasurable feelings. Finding + similar features in human beings, and particularly in children, + though not developed in the same degree, we may assume that in + our monkey-like ancestors facial characters similar to those of + the mandril were developed, though to a less extent, and that + they were symptomatic of pleasure, because connected with the + period of courtship. Then they became conventionalized as + pleasurable symptoms." (S. S. Buckmann, "Human Babies: What They + Teach," <i>Nature</i>, July 5, 1900.) If this view is accepted, it may + be said that the smile, having in man become a generalized sign + of amiability, has no longer any special sexual significance. It + is true that a faint and involuntary smile is often associated + with the later stages of tumescence, but this is usually lost + during detumescence, and may even give place to an expression of + ferocity.</p></div> + +<p>When we have realized how profound is the organic convulsion involved by +the process of detumescence, and how great the general motor excitement +involved, we can understand how it is that very serious effects may follow +coitus. Even in animals this is sometimes the case. Young bulls and +stallions have fallen in a faint after the first congress; boars may be +seriously affected in a similar way; mares have been known even to fall +dead.<a name='5_FNanchor_125'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_125'><sup>[125]</sup></a> In the human species, and especially in men—probably, as Bryan +Robinson remarks, because women are protected by the greater slowness with +which detumescence occurs in them—not only death itself, but innumerable +disorders and accidents have been known to follow immediately after +coitus, these results being mainly due to the vascular and muscular +excitement involved by the processes of detumescence. Fainting, vomiting, +<a name='5_Page_169'></a>urination, defæcation have been noted as occurring in young men after a +first coitus. Epilepsy has been not infrequently recorded. Lesions of +various organs, even rupture of the spleen, have sometimes taken place. In +men of mature age the arteries have at times been unable to resist the +high blood-pressure, and cerebral hæmorrhage with paralysis has occurred. +In elderly men the excitement of intercourse with strange women has +sometimes caused death, and various cases are known of eminent persons who +have thus died in the arms of young wives or of prostitutes.<a name='5_FNanchor_126'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_126'><sup>[126]</sup></a></p> + +<p>These morbid results, are, however, very exceptional. They usually occur +in persons who are abnormally sensitive, or who have imprudently +transgressed the obvious rules of sexual hygiene. Detumescence is so +profoundly natural a process; it is so deeply and intimately a function of +the organism, that it is frequently harmless even when the bodily +condition is far from absolutely sound. Its usual results, under favorable +circumstances, are entirely beneficial. In men there normally supervenes, +together with the relief from the prolonged tension of tumescence, with +the muscular repose and falling blood-pressure,<a name='5_FNanchor_127'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_127'><sup>[127]</sup></a> a sense of profound +satisfaction, a glow of diffused well-being,<a name='5_FNanchor_128'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_128'><sup>[128]</sup></a> perhaps an agreeable +lassitude, occasionally also a sense of mental liberation from an +overmastering obsession. Under reasonably <a name='5_Page_170'></a>happy circumstances there is no +pain, or exhaustion, or sadness, or emotional revulsion. The happy lover's +attitude toward his partner is not expressed by the well-known Sonnet +(CXXIX) of Shakespeare:—</p> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span>"Past reason hunted, and no sooner had<br /></span> +<span>Past reason hated."<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<p>He feels rather with Boccaccio that the kissed mouth loses not its charm,</p> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span>"Bocca baciata non perde ventura."<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<p>In women the results of detumescence are the same, except that the +tendency to lassitude is not marked unless the act has been several times +repeated; there is a sensation of repose and self-assurance, and often an +accession of free and joyous energy. After completely satisfactory +detumescence she may experience a feeling as of intoxication, lasting for +several hours, an intoxication that is followed by no evil reaction.</p> + +<p>Such, so far as our present vague and imperfect knowledge extends, are the +main features in the process of detumescence. In the future, without +doubt, we shall learn to know more precisely a process which has been so +supremely important in the life of man and of his ancestors.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_98'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_98'>[98]</a><div class='note'><p> The elements furnished by the sense of touch in sexual +selection have been discussed in the first section of the previous volume +of these <i>Studies</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_99'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_99'>[99]</a><div class='note'><p> See Appendix A. "The Origins of the Kiss," in the previous +volume.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_100'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_100'>[100]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, Art. "Erection," by Retterer, in Richet's +<i>Dictionnaire de Physiologie</i>, vol. v.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_101'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_101'>[101]</a><div class='note'><p> Guibaut, <i>Traité Clinique des Maladies des Femmes</i>, p. 242. +Adler discusses the sexual secretions in women and their significance, +<i>Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes</i>, pp. 19-26.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_102'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_102'>[102]</a><div class='note'><p> In some parts of the world this is further aided by +artificial means. Thus it is stated by Riedel (as quoted by Ploss and +Bartels) that in the Gorong Archipelago the bridegroom, before the first +coitus, anoints the bride's pudenda with an ointment containing opium, +musk, etc. I have been told of an English bride who was instructed by her +mother to use a candle for the same purpose.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_103'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_103'>[103]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Parthenologia</i>, pp. 302, <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_104'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_104'>[104]</a><div class='note'><p> The connection of this mucous flow with sexual emotion was +discussed early in the eighteenth century by Schurig in his <i>Gynæcologia</i>, +pp. 8-11; it is frequently passed over by more modern writers.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_105'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_105'>[105]</a><div class='note'><p> The drawing is reproduced by Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, +vol. i, Chapter XVII; many facts bearing on the ethnography of coitus are +brought together in this chapter.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_106'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_106'>[106]</a><div class='note'><p> Onanoff (Paris Société de Biologie, May 3, 1890) proposed +the name of bulbo-cavernous reflex for the smart contraction of the +ischio-and bulbo-cavernosus muscles (erector penis and accelerator urinæ) +produced by mechanical excitation of the glans. This reflex is clinically +elicited by placing the index-finger of the left hand on the region of the +bulb while the right hand rapidly rubs the dorsal surface of the glands +with the edge of a piece of paper or lightly pinches the mucous membrane; +a twitching of the region of the bulb is then perceived. This reflex is +always present in healthy adult subjects and indicates the integrity of +the physical mechanism of detumescence. It has been described by Hughes. +(C. H. Hughes, "The Virile or Bulbo-cavernous Reflex," <i>Alienist and +Neurologist</i>, January, 1898.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_107'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_107'>[107]</a><div class='note'><p> Roubaud, <i>Traité de l'Impuissance</i>, 1855, p. 39.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_108'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_108'>[108]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Das Weib</i>, seventh edition, vol. i, p. 510.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_109'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_109'>[109]</a><div class='note'><p> The influence of impeded respiration in exciting more or +less perverted forms of sexual gratification has been discussed in a +section of "Love and Pain" in the third volume of these <i>Studies</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_110'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_110'>[110]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, the experiments of Obici on this point, +<i>Revista Sperimentale di Freniatria</i>, 1903, pp. 689, <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_111'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_111'>[111]</a><div class='note'><p> Summarized in <i>Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, March, +1903, p. 188. The tendency to closure of the eyes noted by Roubaud, to +avoid contact of the light, indicates dilatation of the pupils, for which +we need not seek other explanation than the general tendency of all +peripheral stimulation, according to Schiff's law, to produce such +dilatation.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_112'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_112'>[112]</a><div class='note'><p> Vaschide and Vurpas, "Du Coefficient Sexuel de l'Impulsion +Musicale," <i>Archives de Neurologie</i>, May, 1904.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_113'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_113'>[113]</a><div class='note'><p> In the <i>Priapeia</i> is an inscription which has thus been +translated:—</p> +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span>"You see this organ, after which I'm called<br /></span> +<span>And which is my certificate, is humid;<br /></span> +<span>This moisture is not dew nor drops of rain,<br /></span> +<span>It is the outcome of sweet memory,<br /></span> +<span>Recalling thoughts of a complacent maid."<br /></span> +</div></div> +<p>The translator supposes that semen is referred to, but without doubt the +allusion is to the theologians' <i>distillatio</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_114'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_114'>[114]</a><div class='note'><p> A woman of 30, normal and intelligent, after conversing on +love and passion, and then listening to the music of Grieg and Schumann, +felt real and strong sexual excitement, increased by memories recalled by +the presence of a sympathetic person. When then tested by the dynamometer +the average of ten efforts with the right hand was found to be 28.2 (her +normal average being 31.1) and with the left hand 28.0 (the normal being +30.0). There was, however, great variability in the individual pressures +which sometimes equaled and even exceeded the subject's normal efforts. +The voluntary muscles are thus in harmony with the approaching general +sexual avalanche. (Vaschide and Vurpas, "Quelques Données Expérimentales +sur l'Influence de l'Excitation Sexuelle," <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, +1903, fasc. v-vi.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_115'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_115'>[115]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Cf.</i> MacGillicuddy, <i>Functional Disorders of the Nervous +System in Women</i>, p. 110; Féré, <i>L'Instinct Sexuel</i>, second edition, p. +238; <i>id.</i>, "Note sur une Anomalie de l'instinct Sexuel," <i>Belgique +Médicale</i>, 1905; also "Analysis of the Sexual Impulse," in an earlier +volume of these <i>Studies</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_116'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_116'>[116]</a><div class='note'><p> J. P. West, "Masturbation in Early Childhood," <i>Medical +Standard</i>, November, 1895.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_117'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_117'>[117]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Cf.</i> the discussion of hysteria in "Auto-Erotism," vol. i +of these <i>Studies</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_118'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_118'>[118]</a><div class='note'><p> Hirst, <i>Text-Book of Obstetrics</i>, 1899, p. 67.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_119'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_119'>[119]</a><div class='note'><p> The earliest story of the kind with which I am acquainted, +that of a widow who was thus impregnated by a married friend, is quoted in +Schurig's <i>Spermatologia</i> (p. 224) from Amatus Lusitanus, <i>Curationum +Centuriæ Septum</i>, 1629.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_120'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_120'>[120]</a><div class='note'><p> Janke, <i>Die Willkürliche Hervorbringen des Geschlechts</i>, p. +238.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_121'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_121'>[121]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Cf.</i> Adler, <i>Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des +Weibes</i>, pp. 29-38.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_122'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_122'>[122]</a><div class='note'><p> Féré, <i>Pathologie des Emotions</i>, p. 51.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_123'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_123'>[123]</a><div class='note'><p> This is an instinctive impulse under all strong emotion in +primitive persons. "The Australian Dieri," says A. W. Howitt (<i>Journal +Anthropological Institute</i>, August, 1890), "when in pain or grief cry out +for their father or mother."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_124'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_124'>[124]</a><div class='note'><p> Vaschide and Vurpas, <i>Archives de Neurologie</i>, May, 1904.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_125'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_125'>[125]</a><div class='note'><p> F. B. Robinson, <i>New York Medical Journal</i>, March 11, 1893.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_126'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_126'>[126]</a><div class='note'><p> Féré deals fully with the various morbid results which may +follow coitus, <i>L' Instinct Sexuel</i>, Chapter X; <i>id.</i>, <i>Pathologie des +Emotions</i>, p. 99.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_127'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_127'>[127]</a><div class='note'><p> With regard to the relationship of detumescence to the +blood-pressure Haig remarks: "I think that as the sexual act produces low +and falling blood-pressure, it will of necessity relieve conditions which +are due to high and rising blood-pressure, such, for instance, as mental +depression and bad temper; and, unless my observation deceives me, we have +here a connection between conditions of high blood-pressure, with mental +and bodily depression, and the act of masturbation, for this act will +relieve those conditions, and will tend to be practiced for this purpose." +(A. Haig, <i>Uric Acid</i>, sixth edition, p. 154.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_128'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_128'>[128]</a><div class='note'><p> A medical correspondent speaks of subjective feelings of +temperature coming over the body from 20 to 24 hours after congress, and +marked by sensations of cooling of body and glow of cheeks. In another +case, though lassitude appears on the second day after congress, the first +day after is marked by a notable increase in mental and physical +activity.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_M_III'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_171'></a>III.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Constituents of Semen—Function of the Prostate—The Properties of +Semen—Aphrodisiacs—Alcohol, Opium, etc.—Anaphrodisiacs—The Stimulant +Influence of Semen in Coitus—The Internal Effects of Testicular +Secretions—The Influence of Ovarian Secretion.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>The germ cell never comes into the sphere of consciousness and cannot +therefore concern us in the psychological study of the phenomena of the +sexual instinct. But it is otherwise with the sperm cell, and the seminal +fluid has a relationship, both direct and indirect, to psychic phenomena +which it is now necessary to discuss.</p> + +<p>While the spermatozoa are formed in the glandular tissue of the testes, +the seminal fluid as finally emitted in detumescence is not a purely +testicular product, but is formed by mixture with the fluids poured out at +or before detumescence by various glands which open into the urethra, and +notably the prostate.<a name='5_FNanchor_129'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_129'><sup>[129]</sup></a> This is a purely sexual gland, which in animals +only becomes large and active during the breeding season, and may even be +hardly distinguishable at other times; moreover, if the testes are removed +in infancy, the prostate remains rudimentary, so that during recent years +removal of the testes has been widely advocated and practiced for that +hypertrophy of the prostate which is sometimes a distressing ailment of +old age. It is the prostatic fluid, according to Fürbringer, which imparts +its characteristic odor to semen. It appears, however, to be the main +function of the prostatic fluid to arouse and maintain the motility of the +spermatozoa; before meeting the prostatic fluid the spermatozoa are +motionless; that fluid seems to furnish <a name='5_Page_172'></a>a thinner medium in which they +for the first time gain their full vitality.<a name='5_FNanchor_130'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_130'><sup>[130]</sup></a></p> + +<p>When at length the semen is ejaculated, it contains various substances +which may be separated from it,<a name='5_FNanchor_131'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_131'><sup>[131]</sup></a> and possesses various qualities, some +of which have only lately been investigated, while others have evidently +been known to mankind from a very early period. "When held for some time +in the mouth," remarked John Hunter, "it produces a warmth similar to +spices, which lasts some time."<a name='5_FNanchor_132'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_132'><sup>[132]</sup></a> Possibly this fact first suggested +that semen might, when ingested, possess valuable stimulant qualities, a +discovery which has been made by various savages, notably by the +Australian aborigines, who, in many parts of Australia, administer a +potion of semen to dying or feeble members of the tribe.<a name='5_FNanchor_133'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_133'><sup>[133]</sup></a> It is +perhaps noteworthy that in Central Africa the testes of the goat are +consumed as an aphrodisiac.<a name='5_FNanchor_134'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_134'><sup>[134]</sup></a> In eighteenth century Europe, Schurig, in +his <i>Spermatologia</i>, still found it necessary to discuss at considerable +length the possible medical properties of human semen, giving many +prescriptions which contained it.<a name='5_FNanchor_135'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_135'><sup>[135]</sup></a> The stimulation produced by the +ingestion of semen would appear to form in some cases a part of the +attraction exerted by <i>fellatio</i>; De Sade emphasized this point; and in a +case recorded by Howard semen appears to have acted as a stimulant for +which the craving was as irresistible as is that for alcohol in +dipsomania.<a name='5_FNanchor_136'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_136'><sup>[136]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>It must be remembered that the early history of this subject is + more or less inextricably commingled with folk-lore practices of + magical <a name='5_Page_173'></a>origin, not necessarily founded on actual observation of + the physiological effects of consuming the semen or testes. Thus, + according to W. H. Pearse (<i>Scalpel</i>, December, 1897), it is the + custom in Cornwall for country maids to eat the testicles of the + young male lambs when they are castrated in the spring, the + survival, probably, of a very ancient religious cult. (I have not + myself been able to hear of this custom in Cornwall.) In + Burchard's Penitential (Cap. CLIV, Wasserschleben, <i>op. cit.</i>, p. + 660) seven years' penance is assigned to the woman who swallows + her husband's semen to make him love her more. In the seventeenth + century (as shown in William Salmon's <i>London Dispensatory</i>, + 1678) semen was still considered to be good against witchcraft + and also valuable as a love-philter, in which latter capacity its + use still survives. (Bourke, <i>Scatalogic Rites</i>, pp. 343, 355.) + In an earlier age (Picart, quoted by Crawley, <i>The Mystic Rose</i>, + p. 109) the Manichæans, it is said, sprinkled their eucharistic + bread with human semen, a custom followed by the Albigenses.</p> + +<p> The belief, perhaps founded in experience, that semen possesses + medical and stimulant virtues was doubtless fortified by the + ancient opinion that the spinal cord is the source of this fluid. + This was not only held by the highest medical authorities in + Greece, but also in India and Persia.</p> + +<p> The semen is thus a natural stimulant, a physiological + aphrodisiac, the type of a class of drugs which have been known + and cultivated in all parts of the world from time immemorial. + (Dufour has discussed the aphrodisiacs used in ancient Rome, + <i>Histoire de la Prostitution</i>, vol. II, ch. 21.) It would be vain + to attempt to enumerate all the foods and medicaments to which + has been ascribed an influence in heightening the sexual impulse. + (Thus, in the sixteenth century, aphrodisiacal virtues were + attributed to an immense variety of foods by Liébault in his + <i>Thresor des Remèdes Secrets pour les Maladies des Femmes</i>, 1585, + pp. 104, <i>et seq.</i>) A large number of them certainly have no such + effect at all, but have obtained this credit either on some + magical ground or from a mistaken association. Thus the potato, + when first introduced from America, had the reputation of being a + powerful aphrodisiac, and the Elizabethan dramatists contain many + references to this supposed virtue. As we know, potatoes, even + when taken in the largest doses, have not the slightest + aphrodisiac effect, and the Irish peasantry, whose diet consists + very largely of potatoes, are even regarded as possessing an + unusually small measure of sexual feeling. It is probable that + the mistake arose from the fact that potatoes were originally a + luxury, and luxuries frequently tend to be regarded as + aphrodisiacs, since they are consumed under circumstances which + tend to arouse the sexual desires. It is possible also that, as + has been plausibly suggested, the misunderstanding may have been + due to sailors—the first to be familiar with the potato—who + <a name='5_Page_174'></a>attributed to this particular element of their diet ashore the + generally stimulating qualities of their life in port. The eryngo + (<i>Eryngium maritimum</i>), or sea holly, which also had an erotic + reputation in Elizabethan times, may well have acquired it in the + same way. Many other vegetables have a similar reputation, which + they still retain. Thus onions are regarded as aphrodisiacal, and + were so regarded by the Greeks, as we learn from Aristophanes. It + is noteworthy that Marro, a reliable observer, has found that in + Italy, both in prisons and asylums, lascivious people are fond of + onions (<i>La Pubertà</i>, p. 297), and it may perhaps be worth while + to recall the observation of Sérieux that in a woman in whom the + sexual instinct only awoke in middle age there was a horror of + leeks. In some countries, and especially in Belgium, celery is + popularly looked upon as a sexual stimulant. Various condiments, + again, have the same reputation, perhaps because they are hot and + because sexual desire is regarded, rightly enough, as a kind of + heat. Fish—skate, for instance, and notably oysters and other + shellfish—are very widely regarded as aphrodisiacs, and Kisch + attributes this property to caviar. It is probable that all these + and other foods which have obtained this reputation, in so far as + they have any action whatever on the sexual appetite, only + possess it by virtue of their generally nutritious and + stimulating qualities, and not by the presence of any special + principle having a selective action on the sexual sphere. A + beefsteak is probably as powerful a sexual stimulant as any food; + a nutritious food, however, which is at the same time easily + digestible, and thus requiring less expenditure of energy for its + absorption, may well exert a specially rapid and conspicuous + stimulant effect. But it is not possible to draw a line, and, as + Aquinas long since said, if we wish to maintain ourselves in a + state of purity we shall fear even an immoderate use of bread and + water.</p> + +<p> More definitely aphrodisiacal effects are produced by drugs, and + especially by drugs which in large doses are poisons. The + aphrodisiac with the widest popular reputation is cantharides, + but its sexually exciting effects are merely an accidental result + of its action in causing inflammation of the genito-urinary + passage, and it is both an uncertain and a dangerous result, + except in skillful hands and when administered in small doses. + Nux vomica (with its alkaloid strychnia), by virtue of its + special action on the spinal cord, has a notably pronounced + effect in heightening the irritability of the spinal ejaculatory + center, though it by no means necessarily exerts any + strengthening influence. Alcohol exerts a sexually exciting + effect, but in a different manner; it produces little stimulation + of the cord and, indeed, even paralyzes the lumbar sexual center + in large doses, but it has an influence on the peripheral + nerve-endings and on the skin, and also on the cerebral centers, + tending to arouse desire and to diminish inhibition. In this + latter way, as Adler remarks, it may, in small doses, under some + circumstances, be <a name='5_Page_175'></a>beneficial in men with an excessive + nervousness or dread of coitus, and women, in whom orgasm has + been difficult to reach, have frequently found this facilitated + by some previous indulgence in alcohol. The aphrodisiac effect of + alcohol seems specially marked on women. But against the use of + alcohol as an aphrodisiac it must be remembered that it is far + from being a tonic to detumescence, at all events in men, and + that there is much evidence tending to show that not only chronic + alcoholism, but even procreation during intoxication is perilous + to the offspring (see, <i>e.g.</i>, Andriezen, <i>Journal of Mental + Science</i>, January, 1905, and <i>cf.</i> W. C. Sullivan, "Alcoholism and + Suicidal Impulses," <i>ib.</i>, April, 1898, p. 268); it may be added + that Bunge has found a very high proportion of cases of + immoderate use of alcohol in the fathers of women unable to + suckle their infants (G. von Bunge, <i>Die Zunehmende Unfähigkeit + der Frauen ihre Kinder zu Stillen</i>, 1903) while even an + approximation to the drunken state is far from being a desirable + prelude to the creation of a new human being. It is obvious that + those who wish, for any reason, to cultivate a strict chastity of + thought and feeling would do well to avoid alcohol altogether, or + only in its lightest forms and in moderation. The aphrodisiacal + effects of wine have long been known; Ovid refers to them + (<i>e.g.</i>, <i>Ars Am.</i>, Bk. III, 765). Clement of Alexandria, who was + something of a man of science as well as a Christian moralist, + points out the influence of wine in producing lasciviousness and + sexual precocity. (<i>Pædagogus</i>, Bk. II, Chapter II). Chaucer + makes the Wife of Bath say in the Wife of Bath's Prologue:—</p></div> + +<div class='poem'><div class='stanza'> +<span class='i4'>"And, after wyn, on Venus moste [needs] I thinke:<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>For al so siken as cold engendreth hayl,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>A likerous mouth moste have a likerous tayl,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>In womman vinolent is no defense,<br /></span> +<span class='i4'>This knowen lechours by experience."<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Alcohol, as Chaucer pointed out, comes to the aid of the man, who + is unscrupulous in his efforts to overcome a woman, and this not + merely by virtue of its aphrodisiacal effects, and the apparently + special influence which it seems to exert on women, but also + because it lulls the mental and emotional characteristics which + are the guardians of personality. A correspondent who has + questioned on this point a number of prostitutes he has known, + writes: "Their accounts of the first fall were nearly always the + same. They got to know a 'gentleman,' and on one occasion they + drank too much; before they quite realized what was happening + they were no longer virgins." "In the mental areas, under the + influence of alcohol," Schmiedeberg remarks (in his <i>Elements of + Pharmacology</i>), "the finer degrees of observation, judgment, and + reflection are the first to disappear, while the remaining mental + functions remain in a normal condition. The soldier acts more + boldly because he notices <a name='5_Page_176'></a>dangers less and reflects over them + less; the orator does not allow himself to be influenced by any + disturbing side-considerations as to his audience, hence he + speaks more freely and spiritedly; self-consciousness is lost to + a very great extent, and many are astounded at the ease with + which they can express their thoughts, and at the acuteness of + their judgment in matters which, when they are perfectly sober, + with difficulty reach their minds; and then afterwards they are + ashamed at their mistakes."</p> + +<p> The action of opium in small doses is also to some extent + aphrodisiacal; it slightly stimulates both the brain and the + spinal cord, and has sensory effects on the skin like alcohol; + these effects are favored by the state of agreeable dreaminess it + produces. In the seventeenth century Venette (<i>La Génération de + l'Homme</i>, Part II, Chapter V) strongly recommended small doses of + opium, then little known, for this purpose; he had himself, he + says, in illness experienced its joys, "a shadow of those of + heaven." In India opium (as well as cannabis indica) has long + been a not uncommon aphrodisiac; it is specially used to diminish + local sensibility, delaying the orgasm and thus prolonging the + sexual act. (W. D. Sutherland, "De Impotentia," <i>Indian Medical + Gazette</i>, January, 1900). Its more direct and stimulating + influence on the sexual emotions seems indicated by the statement + that prostitutes are found standing outside the opium-smoking + dens of Bombay, but not outside the neighboring liquor shops. + (G. C. Lucas, <i>Lancet</i>, February 2, 1884.) Like alcohol, opium + seems to have a marked aphrodisiacal effect on women. The case is + recorded of a mentally deranged girl, with no nymphomania though + she masturbated, who on taking small doses of opium at once + showed signs of nymphomania, following men about, etc. (<i>American + Journal Obstetrics</i>, May, 1901, p. 74.) It may well be believed + that opium acts beneficially in men when the ejaculatory centers + are weak but irritable; but its actions are too widespread over + the organism to make it in any degree a valuable aphrodisiac. + Various other drugs have more or less reputation as aphrodisiacs; + thus bromide of gold, a nervous and glandular stimulant, is said + to have as one of its effects a heightening of sexual feeling. + Yohimbin, an alkaloid derived from the West African Yohimbehe + tree, has obtained considerable repute during recent years in the + treatment of impotence; in some cases (see, <i>e.g.</i>, Toff's + results, summarized in <i>British Medical Journal</i>, February 18, + 1905) it has produced good results, apparently by increasing the + blood supply to the sexual organs, but has not been successful in + all cases or in all hands. It must always be remembered that in + cases of psychical impotence suggestion necessarily exerts a + beneficial influence, and this may work through any drug or + merely with the aid of bread pills. All exercise, often even + walking, may be a sexual stimulant, and it is scarcely necessary + to add that powerful stimulation of the skin in the sexual + sphere, <a name='5_Page_177'></a>and more especially of the nates, is often a more + effective aphrodisiac than any drug, whether the irritation is + purely mechanical, as by flogging, or mechanico-chemical, as by + urtication or the application of nettles. Among the Malays (with + whom both men and women often use a variety of plants as + aphrodisiacs, according to Vaughan Stevens) Breitenstein states + (<i>21 Jahre in India</i>, Theil I, p. 228) that both massage and + gymnastics are used to increase sexual powers. The local + application of electricity is one of the most powerful of + aphrodisiacs, and McMordie found on applying one pole to a + uterine sound in the uterus and the other to the abdominal wall + that in the majority of healthy women the orgasm occurred.</p> + +<p> Among anaphrodisiacs, or sexual sedatives, bromide of potassium, + by virtue of its antidotal relationship to strychnia, is one of + the drugs whose action is most definite, though, while it dulls + sexual desire, it also dulls all the nervous and cerebral + activities. Camphor has an ancient reputation as an + anaphrodisiac, and its use in this respect was known to the Arabs + (as may be seen by a reference to it in the <i>Perfumed Garden</i>), + while, as Hyrtl mentions (<i>loc. cit.</i> ii, p. 94), rue (<i>Ruta + graveolens</i>) was considered a sexual sedative by the monks of + old, who on this account assiduously cultivated it in their + cloister gardens to make <i>vinum rutæ</i>. Recently heroin in large + doses (see, <i>e.g.</i>, Becker, <i>Berliner Klinische Wochenschrift</i>, + November 23, 1903) has been found to have a useful effect in this + direction. It may be doubted, however, whether there is any + satisfactory and reliable anaphrodisiac. Charcot, indeed, it is + said, used to declare that the only anaphrodisiac in which he had + any confidence was that used by the uncle of Heloïse in the case + of Abelard. "<i>Cela</i> (he would add with a grim smile) <i>tranche la + difficulte</i>."</p></div> + +<p>If semen is a stimulant when ingested, it is easy to suppose that it may +exert a similar action on the woman who receives it into the vagina in +normal sexual congress. It is by no means improbable that, as Mattei +argued in 1878, this is actually the case. It is known that the vagina +possesses considerable absorptive power. Thus Coen and Levi, among others, +have shown that if a tampon soaked in a solution of iodine is introduced +into the vagina, iodine will be found in the urine within an hour. And the +same is true of various other substances.<a name='5_FNanchor_137'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_137'><sup>[137]</sup></a> If the vagina absorbs drugs +it probably absorbs semen. Toff, of Braila (Roumania), who attaches much +importance to such absorption, considers that it must be analogous to the +ingestion of organic extractives. It is due to this influence, he +believes, <a name='5_Page_178'></a>that weak and anæmic girls so often become full-blooded and +robust after marriage, and lose their nervous tendencies and shyness.<a name='5_FNanchor_138'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_138'><sup>[138]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It is, however, most certainly a mistake to suppose that the beneficial +influence of coitus on women is exclusively, or even mainly, dependent +upon the absorption of semen. This is conclusively demonstrated by the +fact that such beneficial influence is exerted, and in full measure, even +when all precautions have been taken to avoid any contact with the semen. +In so far as <i>coitus reservatus</i> or <i>interruptus</i> may lead to haste or +discomfort which prevents satisfactory orgasm on the part of the woman, it +is without doubt a cause of defective detumescence and incomplete +satisfaction. But if orgasm is complete the beneficial effects of coitus +follow even if there has been no possibility of the absorption of semen. +Even after <i>coitus interruptus</i>, if it can be prolonged for a period long +enough for the woman to attain full and complete satisfaction, she is +enabled to experience what she may describe as a feeling of intoxication, +lasting for several hours. It is in the action of the orgasm itself, and +the vascular, secretory, and metabolic activities set up by the psychic +and nervous influence of coitus with a beloved person, that we must seek +the chief key to the effects produced by coitus on women, however these +effects may possibly be still further heightened by the actual absorption +of semen.<a name='5_FNanchor_139'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_139'><sup>[139]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The positive action of semen, or rather of the testicular products, has +been much investigated during recent years, and appears on the whole to be +demonstrated. The notable discovery <a name='5_Page_179'></a>by Brown-Séquard, a quarter of a +century ago, that the ingestion of the testicular juices in states of +debility and senility acted as a beneficial stimulant and tonic, opened +the way to a new field of therapeutics. Many investigators in various +countries have found that testicular extracts, and more especially the +spermin as studied by Poehl,<a name='5_FNanchor_140'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_140'><sup>[140]</sup></a> and by him regarded as a positive +katalysator or accelerator of metabolic processes, exert a real influence +in giving tone to the heart and other muscles, and in improving the +metabolism of the tissues even when all influences of mental suggestion +have been excluded.<a name='5_FNanchor_141'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_141'><sup>[141]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>As the ovaries are strictly analogous to the testes, it was + surmised that ovarian extract might prove a drug equally valuable + with testicular products. As a matter of fact, ovarian extract, + in the form of ovarin, etc., would seem to have proved beneficial + in various disorders, more especially in anæmia and in troubles + due to the artificial menopause. In most conditions, however, in + which it has been employed the results are doubtful or uncertain, + and some authorities believe that the influence of suggestion + plays a considerable part here.</p></div> + +<p>There is, however, another use which is subserved by the testicular +products, a use which may indeed be said to be implied in those uses to +which reference has already been made, but is yet historically the latest +to be realized and studied. It was not until 1869 that Brown-Séquard first +suggested that an important secretion was elaborated by the ductless +glands and received into the circulation, but that suggestion proved to be +epoch-making. If these glandular secretions are so valuable when +administered as drugs to other persons, must they not be of far greater +value when naturally secreted and poured out into the circulation in the +living body? It is now generally <a name='5_Page_180'></a>believed, on the basis of a large and +various body of evidence, that this is undoubtedly so. In a very crude +form, indeed, this belief is by no means modern. In opposition to the old +writers who were inclined to regard the semen as an excretion which it was +beneficial to expel, there were other ancient authorities who argued that +it was beneficial to retain it as being a vital fluid which, if +reabsorbed, served to invigorate the body. The great physiologist, Haller, +in the middle of the eighteenth century, came very near to the modern +doctrine when he stated in his <i>Elements of Physiology</i> that the sperm +accumulated in the seminical vesicles is pumped back into the blood, and +thus produces the beard and the hair together with the other surprising +changes of puberty which are absent in the eunuch. The reabsorption of +semen can scarcely be said to be a part of the modern physiological +doctrine, but it is at least now generally held that the testes secrete +substances which pass into the circulation and are of immense importance +in the development of the organism.</p> + +<p>The experiments of Shattock and Seligmann indicate that the semen and its +reabsorption in the seminal vesicles, or the nervous reactions produced by +its presence, can have no part in the formation of secondary sexual +characters. These investigators occluded the vas deferens in sheep by +ligature, at an early age, rendering them later sterile though not +impotent. The secondary sexual characters appeared as in ordinary sheep. +Spermatogenesis, these inquirers conclude, may be the initial factor, but +the results must be attributed to the elaboration by the testicles of an +internal secretion and its absorption into the general circulation.<a name='5_FNanchor_142'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_142'><sup>[142]</sup></a></p> + +<p>When animals are castrated there is enlargement of the ductless glands in +the body, notably the thyroid and the suprarenal capsules.<a name='5_FNanchor_143'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_143'><sup>[143]</sup></a> It is +evident, therefore, that the secretions of <a name='5_Page_181'></a>these ductless glands are in +some degree compensatory to those of the testes. But this compensatory +action is inadequate to produce any sexual development in the absence of +the testes.</p> + +<p>We see, therefore, how extremely important is the function of the testis. +Its significance is not alone for the race, it is not simply concerned +with the formation of the spermatozoa which share equally with the ova the +honor of making the mankind of the future. It also has a separate and +distinct function which has reference to the individual. It elaborates +those internal secretions which stimulate and maintain the physical and +mental characters, constituting all that is most masculine in the male +animal, all that makes the man in distinction from the eunuch. Among +various primitive peoples, including those of the European race whence we +ourselves spring, the most solemn form of oath was sworn by placing the +hand on the testes, dimly recognized as the most sacred part of the body. +A crude and passing phase of civilization has ignorantly cast ignominy +upon the sexual organs; the more primitive belief is now justified by our +advancing knowledge.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In these as in other respects the ovaries are precisely analogous + to the testes. They not only form the ova, but they elaborate for + internal use a secretion which develops and maintains the special + physical and mental qualities of womanhood, as the testicular + secretion those of manhood. Moreover, as Cecca and Zappi found, + removal of the ovaries has exactly the same effect on the + abnormal development of the other ductless glands as has removal + of the testes. It is of interest to point out that the internal + secretion of the ovaries and its important functions seem to have + been suggested before any other secretion than the sperm was + attributed to the testes. Early in the nineteenth century Cabanis + argued ("De l'Influence des Sexes sur le Caractère des Idées et + des Affections Morales," <i>Rapport du Physique et du Moral de + l'Homme</i>, 1824, vol. ii, p. 18) that the ovaries are secreting + glands, forming a "particular humor" which is reabsorbed into the + blood and imparts excitations which are felt by the whole system + and all its organs.</p></div> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_129'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_129'>[129]</a><div class='note'><p> The composite character of the semen was recognized by +various old authors, some of whom said, (<i>e.g.</i>, Wharton) that it had +three constituents, which they usually considered to be: (1) The noblest +and most essential part, from the testicles; (2) a watery element from the +vesiculæ; (3) an oily element from the prostate. Schurig, <i>Spermatologia</i>, +1720, p. 17.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_130'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_130'>[130]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, C. Mansell Moulin, "A Contribution to the +Morphology of the Prostate," <i>Journal of Anatomy and Physiology</i>, January, +1895; G. Walker, "A Contribution to the Anatomy and Physiology of the +Prostate Gland, and a Few Observations on Ejaculation," <i>Johns Hopkins +Hospital Bulletin</i>, October, 1900.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_131'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_131'>[131]</a><div class='note'><p> For a study of the semen and its constituents, see +Florence, "Du Sperme," <i>Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, 1895.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_132'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_132'>[132]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Hunter, <i>Essays and Observations</i>, vol. i, p. 189.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_133'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_133'>[133]</a><div class='note'><p> As regards one part of Australia, Walter Roth, +<i>Ethnological Studies Among the Queensland Aborigines</i>, p. 174.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_134'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_134'>[134]</a><div class='note'><p> Sir H. H. Johnston, <i>British Central Africa</i>, p. 438.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_135'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_135'>[135]</a><div class='note'><p> Cap. VII, pp. 327-357, "De Spermaticis virilis usu +Medico,"</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_136'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_136'>[136]</a><div class='note'><p> W. L. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," <i>Alienist and +Neurologist</i>, January, 1896.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_137'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_137'>[137]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Zentralblatt für Gynäkologie</i>, 1894, No. 49.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_138'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_138'>[138]</a><div class='note'><p> E. Toff, "Uber Imprägnierung," <i>Zentralblatt für +Gynäkologie</i>, April, 1903. In a similar but somewhat more precise manner +Dufougère has argued ("La Chlorose, ses rapports avec le marriage, son +traitement par le liquide orchitique," Thèse de Bordeaux, 1902) that semen +when absorbed by the vagina stimulates the secretion of the ovaries and +thus exerts an influence over the blood in anæmia; in this way he seeks to +explain why it is that coitus is the best treatment for chlorosis.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_139'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_139'>[139]</a><div class='note'><p> In this connection I may refer to an interesting and +suggestive paper by Harry Campbell on "The Craving for Stimulants" +(<i>Lancet</i>, October 21, 1899). No reference is made to coitus, but the +author discusses stimulants as normal and beneficial products of the +organism, and deals with the nature of the "physiological intoxication" +they produce.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_140'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_140'>[140]</a><div class='note'><p> Spermin was first discovered in the sperm by Schreiner in +1878; it has also been found in the thyroid, ovaries and various other +glands. "The spermin secreting and elaborating organs," Howard Kelly +remarks (<i>British Medical Journal</i>, January 29, 1898), "may be called the +apothecaries' of the body, secreting many important medicaments, much more +active and more accurately representing its true wants than artificially +administered drugs."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_141'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_141'>[141]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, a summary of Buschan's comprehensive +discussion of the subject of organotherapy (Eulenburg's <i>Real-Encyclopædie +der Gesammten Heilkunde</i>) in <i>Journal of Mental Science</i>, April, 1899, p. +355.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_142'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_142'>[142]</a><div class='note'><p> "Observations Upon the Acquirement of Secondary Sexual +Characters, Indicating the Formation of an Internal Secretion by the +Testicles," <i>Proceedings Royal Society</i>, vol. lxxiii, p. 49.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_143'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_143'>[143]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, the experiments of Cecca and Zappi, summarized +in <i>British Medical Journal</i>, July 2, 1904.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_M_IV'></a><h3><a name='5_Page_182'></a>IV.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Aptitude for Detumescence—Is There an Erotic Temperament?—The +Available Standards of Comparison—Characteristics of the +Castrated—Characteristics of Puberty—Characteristics of the State of +Detumescence—Shortness of Stature—Development of the Secondary Sexual +Characters—Deep Voice—Bright Eyes—Glandular Activity—Everted +Lips—Pigmentation—Profuse Hair—Dubious Significance of Many of These +Characters.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>What, if any, are the indications which the body generally may furnish as +to the individual's aptitude and vigor for the orgasm of detumescence? Is +there an erotic temperament outwardly and visibly displayed? That is a +question which has often occupied those who have sought to penetrate the +more intimate mysteries of human nature, and since we are here concerned +with human beings in their relationship to the process of detumescence, we +cannot altogether pass over this question, difficult as it is to discuss +it with precision.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The old physiognomists showed much confidence in dealing with the + matter. Possibly they had more opportunities for observation than + we have, since they often wrote in days when life was lived more + nakedly than among ourselves, but their descriptions, while + sometimes showing much insight, are inextricably mixed up with + false science and superstition.</p> + +<p> In the <i>De Secretis Mulierum</i>, wrongly attributed to Albertus + Magnus, we find a chapter entitled "Signa mulieris calidæ naturæ + et quæ coit libenter," which may be summarized here. "The signs," + we are told, "of a woman of warm temperament, and one who + willingly cohabits are these: youth, an age of over 12, or + younger, if she has been seduced, small, high breasts, full and + hard, hair in the usual positions; she is bold of speech, with a + delicate and high voice, haughty and even cruel of disposition, + of good complexion, lean rather than stout, inclined to like + drinking. Such a woman always desires coitus, and receives + satisfaction in the act. The menstrual flow is not abundant nor + always regular. If she becomes pregnant the milk is not abundant. + Her perspiration is less odorous than that of the woman of + opposite <a name='5_Page_183'></a>temperament; she is fond of singing, and of moving + about, and delights in adornments if she has any."</p> + +<p> Polemon, in his <i>Sulla Physionomia</i>, has given among the signs of + libidinous impulse: knees turned inwards, abundance of hairs on + the legs, squint, bright eyes, a high and strident voice, and in + women length of leg below the knee. Aristotle had mentioned among + the signs of wantonness: paleness, abundance of hair on the body, + thick and black hair, hairs covering the temples, and thick + eyelids.</p> + +<p> In the seventeenth century Bouchet, in his <i>Serées</i> (Troisième + Serée), gave as the signs of virility which indicated that a man + could have children: a great voice, a thick rough black beard, a + large thick nose.</p> + +<p> G. Tourdes (Art. "Aphrodisie," <i>Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des + Sciences Médicales</i>) thus summarized the ancient beliefs on this + subject: "The erotic temperament has been described as marked by + a lean figure, white and well-ranged teeth, a developed hairy + system, a characteristic voice, air, and expression, and even a + special odor."</p></div> + +<p>In approaching the question of the general physical indications of a +special aptitude to the manifestation of vigorous detumescence, the most +obvious preliminary would seem to be a study of the castrated. If we know +the special peculiarities of those who by removal of the sexual glands at +a very early age have been deprived of all ability to present the +manifestations of detumescence, we shall probably be in possession of a +type which is the reverse of that which we may expect in persons of a +vigorously erotic temperament.</p> + +<p>The most general characteristics of eunuchs would appear to be an unusual +tendency to put on fat, a notably greater length of the legs, absence of +hair in the sexual and secondary sexual regions, a less degree of +pigmentation, as noted both in the castrated negro and the white man, a +puerile larynx and puerile voice. In character they are usually described +as gentle, conciliatory, and charitable.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>There can be little doubt that castration in man tends to lead to + lengthening of the legs (tibia and fibula) at puberty, from + delayed ossification of the epiphyses. The hands and feet are + also frequently longer and sometimes the forearms. At the same + time the bones are more slender. The pelvis also is narrower. The + eunuchs of Cairo are said to be easily seen in a crowd from their + tall stature. (Collineau, quoting Lortet, <i>Revue Mensuelle de + l'Ecole d'Anthropologie</i>, May, 1896.) The <a name='5_Page_184'></a>castrated Skoptzy show + increased stature, and, it seems, large ears, with decreased + chest and head (L. Pittard, <i>Revue Scientifique</i>, June 20, 1903.) + Féré shows that in most of these respects the eunuch resembles + beardless and infantile subjects. ("Les Proportions des Membres + et les Caractères Sexuels," <i>Journal de l'Anatomie et de la + Physiologie</i>, November-December, 1897.) Similar phenomena are + found in animals generally. Sellheim, carefully investigating + castrated horses, swine, oxen and fowls, found retardation of + ossification, long and slender extremities, long, broad, but low + skull, relatively smaller pelvis and small thorax. ("Zur Lehre + von den Sekundären Geschlechtscharakteren," <i>Beiträge zur + Geburtshülfe und Gynäkologie</i>, 1898, summarized in <i>Centralblatt + für Anthropologie</i>, 1900, Heft IV.)</p> + +<p> As regards the mental qualities and moral character of the + castrated, Griffiths considers that there is an undue prejudice + against eunuchs, and refers to Narses, who was not only one of + the first generals of the Roman Empire, but a man of highly + estimable character. (<i>Lancet</i>, March 30, 1895.) Matignon, who + has carefully studied Chinese eunuchs, points out that they + occupy positions of much responsibility, and, though regarded in + many respects as social outcasts, possess very excellent and + amiable moral qualities (<i>Archives Cliniques de Bordeaux</i>, May, + 1896.) In America Everett Flood finds that epileptics and + feeble-minded boys are mentally and morally benefited by + castration. ("Notes on the Castration of Idiot Children," + <i>American Journal of Psychology</i>, January, 1899.) It is often + forgotten that the physical and psychic qualities associated with + and largely dependent on the ability to experience the impulse of + detumescence, while essential to the perfect man, involve many + egoistic, aggressive and acquisitive characteristics which are of + little intellectual value, and at the same time inimical to many + moral virtues.</p></div> + +<p>We have a further standard—positive this time rather than negative—to +aid us in determining the erotic temperament: the phenomena of puberty. +The efflorescence of puberty is essentially the manifestation of the +ability to experience detumescence. It is therefore reasonable to suppose +that the individuals in whom the special phenomena of puberty develop most +markedly are those in whom detumescence is likely to be most vigorous. If +such is the case we should expect to find the erotic temperament marked by +developed larynx and deep voice, a considerable degree of pigmentary +development in hair and skin, <a name='5_Page_185'></a>and a marked tendency to hairiness; while +in women there should be a pronounced growth of the breasts and +pelvis.<a name='5_FNanchor_144'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_144'><sup>[144]</sup></a></p> + +<p>There is yet another standard by which we may measure the individual's +aptitude for detumescence: the presence of those activities which are most +prominently brought into play during the process of detumescence. The +individual, that is to say, who is organically most apt to manifest the +physiological activities which mainly make up the process of detumescence, +is most likely to be of pronounced erotic temperament.</p> + +<p>"Erotic persons are of motor type," remark Vaschide and Vurpas, "and we +may say generally that nearly all persons of motor type are erotic." The +state of detumescence is one of motor and muscular energy and of great +vascular activity, so that habitual energy of motor response and an active +circulation may reasonably be taken to indicate an aptitude for the +manifestation of detumescence.</p> + +<p>These three types may be said, therefore, to furnish us valuable though +somewhat general indications. The individual who is farthest removed from +the castrated type, who presents in fullest degree the characters which +begin to emerge at the period of puberty, and who reveals a physiological +aptitude for the vigorous manifestation of those activities which are +called into action during detumescence, is most likely to be of erotic +temperament. The most cautious description of the characteristics of this +temperament given by modern scientific writers, unlike the more detailed +and hazardous descriptions of the early physiognomists, will be found to +be fairly true to the standards thus presented to us.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The man of sexual type, according to Biérent (<i>La Puberté</i>, p. + 148), is hairy, dark and deep-voiced.</p> + +<p> "The men most liable to satyriasis," Bouchereau states (art. + "Satyriasis," <i>Dictionnaire Encyclopédique des Sciences + Médicales</i>), "are those with vigorous nervous system, developed + muscles, abundant hair on body, dark complexion, and white + teeth."</p><a name='5_Page_186'></a> + +<p> Mantegazza, in his <i>Fisiologia del Piacere</i>, thus describes the + sexual temperament: "Individuals of nervous temperament, those + with fine and brown skins, rounded forms, large lips and very + prominent larynx enjoy in general much more than those with + opposite characteristics. A universal tradition," he adds, + "describes as lascivious humpbacks, dwarfs, and in general + persons of short stature and with long noses."</p> + +<p> In a case of nymphomania in a young woman, described by Alibert + (and quoted by Laycock, <i>Nervous Diseases of Women</i>, p. 28) the + hips, thighs and legs were remarkably plump, while the chest and + arms were completely emaciated. In a somewhat similar case + described by Marc in his <i>De la Folie</i> a peasant woman, who from + an early age had experienced sexual hyperæsthesia, so that she + felt spasmodic voluptuous feelings at the sight of a man, and was + thus the victim of solitary excesses and of spasmodic movements + which she could not repress, the upper part of the body was very + thin, the hips, legs and thighs highly developed.</p> + +<p> In his work on <i>Uterine and Ovarian Inflammation</i> (1862, p. 37) + Tilt observes: "The restless, bashful eye, and changing + complexion, in presence of a person of the opposite sex, and a + nervous restlessness of body, ever on the move, turning and + twisting on sofa or chair, are the best indications of sexual + temperament."</p> + +<p> An extremely sensual little girl of 8, who was constantly + masturbating when not watched, although brought up by nuns, was + described by Busdraghi (<i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, fas. i, 1888, + p. 53) as having chestnut hair, bright black eyes, an elevated + nose, small mouth, pleasant round face, full colored cheeks, and + plump and healthy aspect.</p> + +<p> A highly intelligent young Italian woman with strong and somewhat + perverted sexual impulses is described as of attractive + appearance, with olive complexion, small black almond-shaped + eyes, dilated pupils, oblique thin eyebrows, very thick black + hair, rather prominent cheek-bones, largely developed jaw, and + with abundant down on lower part of cheeks and on upper lip. + (<i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, 1899, fasc. v-vi.)</p> + +<p> As the type of the sensual woman in word and act, led by her + passions to commit various sexual offenses, Ottolenghi describes + (<i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, vol. xii, fasc. v-vi, p. 496) a woman + of 32 who attempted to kill her lover. The daughter of parents + who were neurotic and themselves very erotic, she was a highly + intelligent and vivacious woman, with a pleasing and open face, + very thick dark chestnut hair, large cheek-bones, adipose + buttocks almost resembling those of a Hottentot, and very thick + pubic hair. She was very fond of salt things. Sexual inclination + began at the age of 7.</p></div> + +<p>Adler and Moll remark, very truly, that, so far at least as women are +concerned, sexual anæsthesia or sexual proclivity <a name='5_Page_187'></a>cannot be unfailingly +read on the features. Every woman desires to please, and coquetry is the +sign of a cold, rather than of an erotic temperament.<a name='5_FNanchor_145'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_145'><sup>[145]</sup></a> It may be added +that a considerable degree of congenital sexual anæsthesia by no means +prevents a woman from being beautiful and attractive, though it must +probably still always be said that, as Roubaud points out,<a name='5_FNanchor_146'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_146'><sup>[146]</sup></a> the woman +of cold and intellectual temperament, the "femme de tête," however +beautiful and skillful she may be, cannot compete in the struggle for love +with the woman whose qualities are of the heart and of the emotions. But +it seems sufficiently clear that the practical observations of skilled and +experienced observers agree in attributing to persons of erotic type +certain general characteristics which accord with those negative and +positive standards we may frame on the basis of castration, of puberty, +and of detumescence. It may be worth while to note a few of these +characteristics briefly.</p> + +<p>The abnormal lengthening of the long bones at the age of puberty in the +castrated is, as we have seen, very pronounced. There is little tendency +to associate length of limb with an erotic temperament, and a certain +amount of data as well as of more vague opinion points in the opposite +direction. The Arabs would appear to believe that it is short rather than +tall people in whom the sexual instinct is strongly developed, and we read +in the <i>Perfumed Garden</i>: "Under all circumstances little women love +coitus more and evince a stronger affection for the virile member than +women of a large size." In his elaborate investigation of criminals Marro +found that prostitutes and women guilty of sexual offenses, as also male +sexual offenders, tend to be short and thick set.<a name='5_FNanchor_147'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_147'><sup>[147]</sup></a> In European +folk-lore the thick, bull neck is regarded as a sign of strong +sexuality.<a name='5_FNanchor_148'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_148'><sup>[148]</sup></a> Mantegazza refers to a strong sexual temperament as being +associated with arrest or disorder of bony development, and Marro suggests +that <a name='5_Page_188'></a>the proverbial salacity of rachitic individuals may be due to an +increased activity of the sexual organs.<a name='5_FNanchor_149'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_149'><sup>[149]</sup></a> It may be added that +acromegaly, with its excessive bony growths, tends to be associated with +premature sexual involution.</p> + +<p>A further point which is frequently mentioned in the case of women is the +development of the chief secondary sexual regions: the pelvis and the +breasts. It is, indeed, almost inevitable that there should be some degree +of correlation between the aptitude for bearing children and the aptitude +for experiencing detumescence. The reality of such a connection is not +only evidenced by medical observations, but receives further testimony in +popular beliefs. In Italy women with large buttocks are considered wanton, +and among the South Slavs they are regarded as especially fruitful.<a name='5_FNanchor_150'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_150'><sup>[150]</sup></a> +Blumenbach asserted that precocious venery will enlarge the breasts, and +believed that he had found evidence of this among young London +prostitutes.<a name='5_FNanchor_151'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_151'><sup>[151]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The association of the aptitude for detumescence with a tendency to a deep +rather than to a high voice, both in men and women, has frequently been +noted and has seldom been denied. The onset of puberty always affects the +voice; in general, Biérent states, the more bass the voice is the more +marked is the development of the sexual apparatus; "a very robust man, +with very developed sexual organs, and very dark and abundant hairy +system, a man of strong puberty in a word, is nearly always a bass."<a name='5_FNanchor_152'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_152'><sup>[152]</sup></a> +The influence of sexual excitement in deepening the voice is shown by the +rules of sexual hygiene prescribed to tenors, while a bass has less need +to observe similar precautions. In women every phase of sexual +life—puberty, menstruation, coitus, pregnancy—tends to affect the voice +and always by giving it a deeper character. The deepening of the voice by +sexual intercourse was an ancient Greek observation, and Martial refers to +a woman's good or bad singing as an index to her recent <a name='5_Page_189'></a>sexual habits. +Prostitutes tend to have a deep voice. Venturi points out that married +women preserve a fresh voice to a more advanced age than spinsters, this +being due to the precocious senility in the latter of an unused function. +Such a phenomenon indicates that the relationship of detumescence to the +deepening of the voice is not quite simple. This is further indicated by +the fact that in robust men abstinence still further deepens the voice +(the monk of melodrama always has a bass voice), while excessive or +precocious sexual indulgence tends to be associated with the same kind of +puerile voice as is found in those persons in whom pubertal development +has not been carried very far, or who are of what Griffiths terms +eunuchoid type. Idiot boys, who are often sexually undeveloped, tend to +have a high voice, while idiot girls (who often manifest marked sexual +proclivities) not infrequently have a deep voice.<a name='5_FNanchor_153'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_153'><sup>[153]</sup></a></p> + +<p>Bright dilated eyes are among the phenomena of detumescence, and are very +frequently noted in persons of a pronounced erotic temperament. This is, +indeed, an ancient observation, and Burton says of people with a black, +lively, and sparkling eye, "without question they are most amorous," +drawing his illustrations mostly from classic literature.<a name='5_FNanchor_154'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_154'><sup>[154]</sup></a> Tardieu +described the erotic woman as having bright eyes, and Heywood Smith states +that the eyes of lascivious women resemble, though in a less degree, those +of the insane.<a name='5_FNanchor_155'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_155'><sup>[155]</sup></a> Sexual excitement is one among many +causes—intellectual excitement, pain, a loud noise, even any sensory +irritation—which produce dilatation of the pupils and enlargement of the +palpebral fissure, with some protrusion of the eyeball. The influence of +the sexual system upon the eye appears to be far less potent in men than +in women.<a name='5_FNanchor_156'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_156'><sup>[156]</sup></a> Sexual desire is, however, by no means the only irritant +within the sexual sphere which may thus influence the eye; morbid +irritations may produce the same effect. Milner Fothergill, in his book on +<i>Indigestion</i>, vividly describes the appearance of the <a name='5_Page_190'></a>eyes sometimes +seen in ovarian disorder: "The glittering flash which glances out from +some female irides is the external indication of ovarian irritation, and +'the ovarian gleam' has features quite its own. The most marked instance +which ever came under my notice was due to irritation in the ovaries, +which had been forced down in front of the uterus and been fixed there by +adhesions. Here there was little sexual proclivity, but the eyes were very +remarkable. They flashed and glittered unceasingly, and at times perfect +lightning bolts shot from them. Usually there is a bright glittering sheen +in them which contrasts with the dead look in the irides of sexual excess +or profuse uterine discharges."</p> + +<p>The activity of the glandular secretions, and especially those of the +skin, during detumescence, would lead us to expect that such secretory +activity is an index to an aptitude for detumescence. As a matter of fact +it is occasionally, though not frequently, noted by medical observers. It +is stated that the erotic temperament is characterized by a special +odor.<a name='5_FNanchor_157'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_157'><sup>[157]</sup></a> The activity of the sweat-glands is seldom referred to by +medical observers in describing persons of erotic temperament, although +the descriptions of novelists not infrequently contain allusions to this +point, and the literature of an earlier age shows that the tendency to +perspiration, especially the moist hand, was regarded as a sure sign of a +sensual temperament. "The moist-handed Madonna Imperia, a most rare and +divine creature," remarks Lazarillo in Middleton's comedy <i>Blurt, +Master-Constable</i>, to quote one of many allusions to this point in the +Elizabethan drama.</p> + +<p>The lips are sometimes noted as red and everted, perhaps thick<a name='5_FNanchor_158'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_158'><sup>[158]</sup></a>; +Tardieu remarked that the typically erotic woman has thick red lips. This +corresponds with the characteristic type of the satyr in classic statues +as in later paintings; his lips are <a name='5_Page_191'></a>always thick and everted. Fullness, +redness, and eversion of the lips are correlated with good breathing, the +absence of anæmia, laughter, a well-fleshed face.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>This kind of mouth indicates, perhaps, not so much a congenitally + erotic temperament, as an abandonment to impulse. The opposite + type of mouth—with inverted, thin, and retracted lips—would + appear to be found with especial frequency in persons who + habitually repress their impulses on moral grounds. Any kind of + effort to restrain involuntary muscular action may lead to + retraction of the lips: the effort to overcome anger or fear, or + even the resistance to a strong desire to urinate or defecate. In + religious young men, however, it becomes habitual and fixed. I + recall a small band of medical students, gathered together from a + large medical school, who were accustomed to meet together for + prayer and Bible-reading; the majority showed this type of mouth + to a very marked degree: pale faces, with drawn, retracted lips. + It may be termed the Christian or pious <i>facies</i>. It is much less + frequently seen in religious women (unless of masculine type), + doubtless because religion for women is in a much less degree + than for men a moral discipline.</p> + +<p> It may be added that an interesting form of this contraction of + the lips, and one that is not purely repressive, is that which + indicates the state of muscular tension associated with the + impulse to guard and protect. In this form the contracted mouth + is the index of tenderness, and is characteristic of the mother + who is watching over the infant she is suckling at her breast. I + have observed precisely the same expression in the face of a boy + of 14 with a large congenital scrotal hernia; when the tumor was + being examined his lower lip became retracted, well marked lines + appearing from the angles downwards, though the upper lip + retained its normal expression It was precisely the tender look + we may see in the faces of mothers who are watching anxiously + over their offspring, and the emotion is evidently the same in + both cases: solicitude for a sensitive and tenderly guarded + object.</p></div> + +<p>The degree of pigmentation is clearly correlated with sexual vigor. "In +general," Heusinger laid down, in 1823, "the quantity of pigment is +proportional to the functional effectiveness of the genital organs." This +connection is so profound that it may be traced very widely throughout the +organic world.</p> + +<p>The connection between pigmentation and sexual activity is very ancient. +Even leaving out of account the wedding apparel of animals, nearly always +gorgeous in scales and plumage and hair, the sexual orifice shows a more +or less marked tendency <a name='5_Page_192'></a>to pigmentation during the breeding season from +fishes upward, while in mammals the darker pigmentation of this region is +a constant phenomenon in sexually mature individuals.<a name='5_FNanchor_159'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_159'><sup>[159]</sup></a></p> + +<p>In the human species both the negative standard of castration and the +positive standard of puberty alike indicate a correlation of this kind. +Those individuals in whom puberty never fully develops and who are +consequently said to be affected by infantilism, reveal a relative absence +of pigment in the sexual centers which are normally pigmented to a high +degree.<a name='5_FNanchor_160'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_160'><sup>[160]</sup></a> Among those Asiatic races who extirpate the ovaries in young +girls the skin remains white in the perineum, round the anus, and in the +armpits.<a name='5_FNanchor_161'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_161'><sup>[161]</sup></a> Even in mature women who undergo ovariotomy, as Kepler +found, the pigmentation of the nipples and areola disappears, as well as +of the perineum and anus, the skin taking on a remarkable whiteness.</p> + +<p>Normally the sexual centers, and in a high degree the genital orifice, +represent the maximum of pigmentation, and under some circumstances this +is clearly visible even in infancy. Thus babies of mixed black and white +blood may show no traces of negro ancestry at birth, but there will always +be increased pigmentation about the external genitalia.<a name='5_FNanchor_162'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_162'><sup>[162]</sup></a> The linea +fusca, which reaches from the pubes to the navel and occasionally to the +ensiform cartilage, is a line of sexual pigmentation sometimes regarded as +characteristic of pregnancy, but as Andersen, of Copenhagen, has found by +the examination of several hundred children of both sexes, it exists in a +slight form in about 75 per cent. of young girls, and in almost as large a +proportion of boys. But there is no doubt that it tends to increase with +age as well as to become marked at pregnancy. At puberty there is a +general tendency to changes in pigmentation; thus Godin found <a name='5_Page_193'></a>that in 28 +per cent, adolescent changes occurred in the eyes and hair at this period, +the hair becoming darker, though the eyes sometimes become lighter. Ammon, +in his investigation of conscripts at the age of 20 (<i>post</i>, p. 196), +discovered the significant fact that the eyes and hair darken <i>pari passu</i> +with sexual development. In women, during menstruation, there is a general +tendency to pigmentation; this is especially obvious around the eyes, and +in some cases black rings of true pigment form in this position. Even the +skin of the negro women of Loango sometimes becomes a few shades darker +during menstruation.<a name='5_FNanchor_163'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_163'><sup>[163]</sup></a> During pregnancy this tendency to pigmentation +reaches its climax. Pregnancy constantly gives rise to pigmentation of the +face, the neck, the nipples, the abdomen, and this is especially marked in +brunettes.</p> + +<p>This association of pigmentation and sexual aptitudes has been recognized +in the popular lore of some peoples. Thus the Sicilians, who admire brown +skin and have no liking either for a fair skin or light hair, believe that +a white woman is incapable of responding to love. It is the brown woman +who feels love; as it is said in Sicilian dialect: "Fimmina scura, fimmina +amurusa."<a name='5_FNanchor_164'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_164'><sup>[164]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The dependence of pigmentation upon the sexual system is shown by + the fact that irritation of the genital organs by disease will + frequently suffice to produce a high degree of pigmentation. This + may the neck, the trunk, the hands. Simpson long since noted that + uterine irritation apart from pregnancy may produce pigmentation + of the areolæ of the nipples (<i>Obstetric Works</i>, vol. i, p. 345). + Engelmann discussed the subject and gave cases, "The + Hystero-Neuroses," pp. 124-139, in <i>Gynæcological Transactions</i>, + vol. xii, 1887; and a summary of a memoir by Fouquet on this + subject in <i>La Gynécologie</i>, February, 1903, will be found in + <i>British Medical Journal</i>, March 28, 1903,</p></div><a name='5_Page_194'></a> + +<p>Of all physical traits vigor of the hairy system has most frequently +perhaps been regarded as the index of vigorous sexuality. In this matter +modern medical observations are at one with popular belief and ancient +physiognomical assertions.<a name='5_FNanchor_165'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_165'><sup>[165]</sup></a> The negative test of castration and the +positive test of puberty point in the same direction.</p> + +<p>It is at puberty that all the hair on the body, except that on the head, +begins to develop; indeed, the very word "puberty" has reference to this +growth as the most obvious sign of the whole process. When castration +takes place at an early age all this development of pubescent hair is +arrested. When the primary sexual organs are undeveloped the sexual hair +is also undeveloped, as in a case, recorded by Plant,<a name='5_FNanchor_166'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_166'><sup>[166]</sup></a> of a girl with +rudimentary uterus and ovaries who had little or no axillary and pubic +hair, although the hair of the head was long and strong.<a name='5_FNanchor_167'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_167'><sup>[167]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The pseudo-Michael Scot among the <i>Signa mulieris calidæ naturæ + et quæ coit libenter</i> stated that her hair, both on the head and + body, is thick and coarse and crisp, and Della Porta, the + greatest of the physiognomists, said that thickness of hair in + women meant wantonness. Venette, in his <i>Generation de l'Homme</i>, + remarked that men who have much hair on the body are most + amorous. At a more recent period Roubaud has said that pubic hair + in its quantity, color and curliness is an index of genital + energy. A poor pilous system, on the other hand, Roubaud regarded + as a probable though not an irrefragable proof of sexual + frigidity in women. "In the cold woman the pilous system is + remarkable for the languor of its vitality; the hairs are fair, + delicate, scarce and smooth, while in ardent natures there are + little curly tufts about the temples." (<i>Traité de + l'Impuissance</i>, pp. 124, 523.) Martineau declared (<i>Leçons sur + les Déformations Vulvaires</i>, p. 40) that "the more developed the + genital organs the more abundant the hair covering them; + <a name='5_Page_195'></a>abundance of hair appears to be in relation to the perfect + development of the organs." Tardieu described the typically + erotic woman as very hairy.</p> + +<p> Bergh found that among 2200 young Danish prostitutes those who + showed an unusual extension and amount of pubic hair included + several women who were believed to be libidinous in a very high + degree. (Bergh, "Symbolæ," etc., <i>Hospitalstidende</i>, August, + 1894.) Moraglia, again, in Italy, in describing various women, + mostly prostitutes, of unusually strong sexual proclivities, + repeatedly notes very thick hair, with down on the face. + (<i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, vol. xvi, fasc. iv-v.)</p> + +<p> Marro, also, in Italy found that abundance of hair and down is + especially marked in women who are guilty of infanticide (as also + Pasini has found), though criminal women generally, in his + experience, tend to have abnormally abundant hair. (<i>Caratteri + del Delinquenti</i>, cap. XXII.) Lombroso finds that prostitutes + generally tend to be hairy (<i>Donna Delinquente</i>, p. 320.)</p> + +<p> A lad of 14, guilty of numerous crimes of violence having a + sexual source, is described by Arthur Macdonald in America as + having hair on the chest as well as all over the pubes. (A. + Macdonald, <i>Archives de L'Anthropologie Criminelle</i>, January, + 1893, p. 55.) The association of hairiness with abnormal + sexuality in the weak-minded has been noted at Bicêtre + (<i>Recherches Cliniques sur l'Epilepsie</i>, vol. xix, pp. 69, 77.)</p> + +<p> Hypertrichosis universalis, a general hairiness of body, has been + described by Cascella in a woman with very strong sexual desires, + who eventually became insane. (<i>Revista Mensile di Psichiatria</i>, + 1903, p. 408.) Bucknill and Tuke give the case of a religiously + minded girl, with very strong and repressed sexual desires, who + became insane; the only abnormal feature in her physical + development was the marked growth of hair over the body.</p> + +<p> Brantôme refers to a great lady known to him whose body was very + hairy, and quotes a saying to the effect that hairy people are + either rich or wanton; the lady in question, he adds, was both. + (Brantôme, <i>Vie des Dames Galantes</i>, Discours II.)</p> + +<p> De Sade, whose writings are now regarded as a treasure house of + true observations in the domain of sexual psychology, makes the + Rodin of <i>Justine</i> dark, with much hair and thick eyebrows, while + his very sexual sister is described as dark, thin and very hairy. + (Dühren, <i>Der Marquis de Sade</i>, third edition, p. 440.)</p> + +<p> A correspondent who has always taken a special interest in the + condition as regards hairiness of the women to whom he has been + attracted, has sent me notes concerning a series of 12 women. It + may be gathered from these notes that 5 women were neither + markedly sexual nor markedly hairy (either as regards head or + pubes), 6 cases both hairy and sexual, 1 was sexual and not + hairy, none were hairy <a name='5_Page_196'></a>and not sexual. My correspondent remarks: + "There may be women with scanty pubic hair possessing very strong + sexual emotions. My own experience is quite the opposite." He has + also independently reached the conclusion, arrived at by many + medical observers and clearly suggested by some of the facts here + brought together, that profuse hair frequently denotes a neurotic + temperament.</p> + +<p> It may be added that Mirabeau, as we learn from an anecdote told + by an eyewitness and recorded by Legouvé, had a very hairy chest, + while the same is recorded of Restif de la Bretonne.</p></div> + +<p>It is a very ancient and popular belief that if a hairy man is not sensual +he is strong: <i>vir pilosus aut libidinosus aut fortis</i>. The Greeks +insisted on the hairy nates of Hercules, and Ninon de l'Enclos, when the +great Condé shared her bed without touching her, remarked, on seeing his +hairy body: "Ah, Monseigneur, que vous devez être fort!" It may be doubted +whether there is any exact parallelism between muscular strength and +hairiness, for strength is largely a matter of training, but there can be +no doubt that hairiness really tends to be associated with a generally +vigorous development of the body.</p> + +<p>Although the observations concerning hairiness of body as an index of +vigor, whether sexual or only generally physical, are so ancient, until +recent years no attempts have been made to demonstrate on a large scale +whether there is actually a correlation between hairiness and sexual or +general development of the body. Some importance, therefore, attaches to +Ammon's careful observations of many thousand conscripts in Baden. These +observations fully justify this ancient belief, since they show that on +the one hand the size of the testicles, and on the other hand girth of +chest and stature, are correlated with hairiness of body.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Ammon's observations were made on nearly 4000 conscripts of the + age of 20. From the point of view of the hairy system he divided + them, into four classes:—</p> + +<ul><li> I. To which 6.1 per cent, of the men belonged, with smooth + bodies.</li> + +<li> II. Including 25.3 per cent., only slight hairiness.</li> + +<li> III. 53.8 per cent., more developed hairy system, but belly, + breast and back smooth.</li> + +<li> IV. 14.7 per cent., hair all over body.</li> + +<li> V. 0.1 per cent., extreme cases of hairiness.</li></ul><a name='5_Page_197'></a> + +<p> The beardless were 12.1 per cent., those with no axillary hair 9 + per cent., those with no hair on pubis 0.4 per cent. This + corresponds with the fact that hair appears first on the pubis + and last on the chin.</p> + +<p> In the first class 69 per cent, were beardless, 54 per cent, + without any axillary hair and 6 per cent, without pubic hair. In + the second class 24 per cent, were beardless, 17 per cent, + without axillary hair. In the third class 3 per cent, were + beardless and 3 per cent without axillary hair.</p> + +<p> Below puberty the diameter of testicles is below 14 millimeters. + There were 13 conscripts having a testicular diameter of less + than 14 millimeters. These infantile individuals all belonged to + the first three classes and mostly to the first. The average + testicular diameter in the first class was nearly 24 millimeters, + and progressively rose in the succeeding classes to over 26 + millimeters in the fourth.</p> + +<p> While there was not much difference in height, the first class + was the shortest, the fourth the tallest. The fourth class also + showed the greatest chest perimeter. The cephalic index of all + classes was 84. (O. Ammon, "L'Infantilisme et le Feminisme au + Conseil de Révision," <i>L'Anthropologie</i>, May-June, 1896.)</p></div> + +<p>We thus see that it is quite justifiable to admit a type of person who +possesses a more than average aptitude for detumescence. Such persons are +more likely to be short than tall; they will show a full development of +the secondary sexual characters; the voice will tend to be deep and the +eyes bright; the glandular activity of the skin will probably be marked, +the lips everted; there is a tendency to a more than average degree of +pigmentation, and there is frequently an abnormal prevalence of hair on +some parts of the body. While none of these signs, taken separately, can +be said to have any necessary connection with the sexual impulse, taken +altogether they indicate an organism that responds to the instinct of +detumescence with special aptitude or with marked energy. In these +respects observation, both scientific and popular, concords with the +probabilities suggested by the three standards in this matter which have +already been set forth.</p> + +<p>No generalization, however, can here be set down in an absolute and +unqualified manner. There are definite reasons why this should be so. +There is, for instance, the highly important consideration that the sexual +impulse of the individual <a name='5_Page_198'></a>may be conspicuous in two quite distinct ways. +It may assume prominence because the individual possesses a highly +vigorous and well-nourished organism, or its prominence may be due to +mental irritation in a very morbid individual. In the latter +case—although occasionally the two sets of conditions are combined—most +of the signs we might expect in the former case may be absent. Indeed, the +sexual impulses which proceed from a morbid psychic irritability do not in +most cases indicate any special aptitude for detumescence at all; in that +largely lies their morbid character.</p> + +<p>Again, just in the same way that the exaggerated impulse itself may either +be healthy or morbid, so the various characters which we have found to +possess some value as signs of the impulse may themselves either be +healthy or morbid. This is notably the case as regards an abnormal growth +of hair on the body, more especially when it appears on regions where +normally there is little or no hair. Such hypertrichosis is frequently +degenerative in character, though still often associated with the sexual +system. When, however, it is thus a degenerative character of sexual +nature, having its origin in some abnormal fœtal condition or +later atrophy of the ovaries, it is no necessary indication of any +aptitude for detumescence.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Idiots, more especially it would seem idiot girls, tend to show a + highly developed hairy system. Thus Voisin, when investigating + 150 idiot and imbecile girls, found the hair long and thick and + tending to occupy a large surface; one girl had hair on the + areolæ of the mamma. (J. Voisin, "Conformation des organes + génitaux chez les Idiots," <i>Annales d'Hygiène Publique</i>, June, + 1894.) It should be said that in idiot boys puberty is late, and + the sexual organs as well as the sexual instinct frequently + undeveloped, while in idiot girls there is no delay in puberty, + and the sexual organs and instinct are frequently fully and even + abnormally developed.</p> + +<p> Hegar has described an interesting case showing an association, + of fœtal origin, between sexual anomaly and abnormal + hairness. In this case a girl of 16 had a uterus duplex, an + infantile pelvis, very slight menstruation and undeveloped + breasts. She was very hairy on the face, the anterior aspects of + the chest and abdomen, the sexual regions, and the thighs, but + not specially so on the rest of the body. The hairs were of + lanugo-like character, but dark in color. (A. Hegar, <i>Beiträge + zur<a name='5_Page_199'></a> Geburtshülfe und Gynäkologie</i>, vol. i, p. III, 1898.) + Sometimes hiruties of the face and abdomen begin to appear during + pregnancy, apparently from disease or degeneration of the + ovaries. (A case is noted in <i>British Medical Journal</i>, August 2 + and 16, pp. 375 and 436, 1902.) Laycock many years ago referred + to the popular belief that women who have hair on the upper lip + seldom bear children, and regarded this opinion as "questionless + founded on fact." (Laycock, <i>Nervous Diseases of Women</i>, p. 22.) + When this is so, we may suppose that the abnormal hairy growth is + associated with degeneration of the ovaries.</p></div> + +<p>There is another factor which enters into this question and renders the +definition of a physical sexual type less precise than it would otherwise +be. The sexual instinct is common to all persons, and while it seems +probable that there is a type of person in whom sexual energies are +predominant, it would also appear that the people who otherwise show a +very high level of energy in life usually exhibit a more than average +degree of energy in matters of love. The predominantly sexual type, as we +have seen, tends to be associated with a high degree of pigmentation; the +person specially apt for detumescence inclines to belong to the dark +rather than to the purely fair group of the population. On the other hand, +the active, energetic, practical man, the man who is most apt for the +achievement of success in life, tends to belong to the fair rather than to +the dark type.<a name='5_FNanchor_168'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_168'><sup>[168]</sup></a> Thus we have a certain conflict of tendencies, and it +becomes possible to assert that while persons with pronounced aptitude for +sexual detumescence tend to be dark, persons whose pronounced energy in +sexual matters tends to ensure success are most likely to be fair.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The tendency of the fair energetic type, the type of the northern + European man, to sexuality may be connected with the fact that + the violent and criminal man who commits sexual crimes tends to + be fair even amid a dark population. Criminals on the whole would + appear to tend to be dark rather than fair; but Marro found in + Italy that the group of sexual offenders differed from all other + groups of criminals in that their hair was predominantly fair. + (<i>Caratteri del Delinquenti</i>, <a name='5_Page_200'></a>p. 374.) Ottolenghi, in the same + way, in examining 100 sexual offenders, found that they showed 17 + per cent., of fair hair, though criminals generally (on a basis + of nearly 2000) showed only 6 per cent., and normal persons + (nearly 1000) 9 per cent. Similarly while the normal persons + showed only 20 per cent. of blue eyes and criminals generally 36 + per cent., the sexual offenders showed 50 per cent. of blue eyes. + (Ottolenghi, <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, fasc. vi, 1888, p. 573.) + Burton remarked (<i>Anatomy of Melancholy</i>, Part III, Section II, + Mem. II, Subs. II) that in all ages most amorous young men have + been yellow-haired, adding, "Synesius holds every effeminate + fellow or adulterer is fair-haired." In folk-lore, it has been + noted (Κρυπτάδια, vol. ii, p. 258), red or yellow hair + is sometimes regarded as a mark of sexuality.</p> + +<p> In harmony with this fairness, sexual offenders would appear to + be more dolichocephalic than other criminals. In Italy Marro + found the foreheads of sexual offenders to be narrow, and in + California Drähms found that while murderers had an average + cephalic index of 83.5, and thieves of 80.5, that of sexual + offenders was 79.</p> + +<p> On the other hand, high cheek-bones and broad faces—a condition + most usually found associated with brachycephaly—have sometimes + been noted as associated with undue or violent sexuality. Marro + noted the excess of prominent cheek-bones in sexual offenders, + and in America it has been found that unchaste girls tend to have + broad faces. (<i>Pedagogical Seminary</i>, December, 1896, pp. 231, + 235.)</p></div> + +<p>It will be seen that, when we take a comprehensive view of the facts and +considerations involved, it is possible to obtain a more definite and +coherent picture of the physical signs of a marked aptitude for +detumescence than has hitherto been usually supposed possible. But we also +see that while the <i>ensemble</i> of these signs is probably fairly reliable +as an index of marked sexuality, the separate signs have no such definite +significance, and under some circumstances their significance may even be +reversed.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_144'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_144'>[144]</a><div class='note'><p> See Biérent, <i>La Puberté</i>; Marro, <i>La Pubertà</i> (and +enlarged French translation, <i>La Puberté</i>), and portions of G. S. Hall's +<i>Adolescence</i>; also Havelock Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i> (fourth edition, +revised and enlarged).</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_145'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_145'>[145]</a><div class='note'><p> Adler, <i>Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes</i>, +p. 174; Moll, "Perverse Sexualempfindung, Psychische Impotenz und Ehe" +(Section II), in Senator and Kaminer, <i>Krankheiten und Ehe</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_146'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_146'>[146]</a><div class='note'><p> Roubaud, <i>Traité de l'Impuissance</i>, p. 524.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_147'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_147'>[147]</a><div class='note'><p> Marro, <i>Caratteri del Delinquenti</i>, p. 374.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_148'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_148'>[148]</a><div class='note'><p> Κρυπτάδια, vol. ii, p. 258.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_149'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_149'>[149]</a><div class='note'><p> Marro, <i>La Pubertà</i>, p. 196. In Italy, the sensuality of +the lame is the subject of proverbs.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_150'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_150'>[150]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Archivio di Psichiatria</i>, 1896, p. 515; +Κρυπτάδια, vol. vi, p. 212.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_151'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_151'>[151]</a><div class='note'><p> Blumenbach, <i>Anthropological Treatises</i>, p. 248.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_152'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_152'>[152]</a><div class='note'><p> Biérent, <i>La Puberté</i>, p. 148.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_153'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_153'>[153]</a><div class='note'><p> Venturi, <i>Degenerazioni Psico-sessuali</i>, pp. 408-410.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_154'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_154'>[154]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Anatomy of Melancholy</i>, Part III, Section II, Mem. II, +Sub. II.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_155'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_155'>[155]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>British Gynæcological Journal</i>, February, 1887, p. 505.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_156'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_156'>[156]</a><div class='note'><p> Power, <i>Lancet</i>, November 26, 1887.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_157'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_157'>[157]</a><div class='note'><p> With regard to the sexual relationships of personal odor, +see the previous volume of these <i>Studies</i>, "Sexual Selection in Man," +section on Smell.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_158'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_158'>[158]</a><div class='note'><p> In European folk-lore thick lips in a woman are sometimes +regarded as a sign of sensuality, Κρυπτάδια, vol. ii, p, 258.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_159'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_159'>[159]</a><div class='note'><p> The direct dependence of sexual pigmentation on the primary +sexual glands is well illustrated by a true hermaphroditic adult finch +exhibited at the Academy of Sciences of Amsterdam (May 31, 1890); this +bird had a testis on the right side and an ovary on the left, and on the +right side its plumage was of the male's colors, on the left of the +female's color.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_160'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_160'>[160]</a><div class='note'><p> See. <i>e.g.</i>, Papillault, <i>Bulletin Société +d'Anthropologie</i>, 1899, p. 446.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_161'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_161'>[161]</a><div class='note'><p> Guinard, Art. "Castration," Richet's <i>Dictionnaire de +Physiologie</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_162'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_162'>[162]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Whitridge Williams, <i>Obstetrics</i>, 1903, p. 132.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_163'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_163'>[163]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Zeitschrift für Ethnologie</i>, 1878, p. 19.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_164'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_164'>[164]</a><div class='note'><p> C. Pitre, <i>Medicina Populare Siciliana</i>, p. 47. In England, +from notes sent to me by one correspondent, it would appear that the +proportion of dark and sexually apt women to fair and sexually apt women +is as 3 to 1. The experience of others would doubtless give varying +results, and in any case the fallacies are numerous. See, in the previous +volume of these <i>Studies</i>, "Sexual Selection in Man," Section IV.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_165'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_165'>[165]</a><div class='note'><p> In Japan the same belief would appear to be held. In a nude +figure representing the typical voluptuous woman by the Japanese painter +Marugama Okio (reproduced in Ploss's <i>Das Weib</i>) the pubic and axillary +hair is profuse, though usually sparse in Japan.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_166'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_166'>[166]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Centralblatt für Gynäkologie</i>, No. 9, 1896.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_167'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_167'>[167]</a><div class='note'><p> It is important to remember that there is little +correlation in this matter between the hair of the head and the sexual +hair, if not a certain opposition. (See <i>ante</i>, p. 127.) According to one +of the aphorisms of Hippocrates, repeated by Buffon, eunuchs do not become +bald, and Aristotle seems to have believed that sexual intercourse is a +cause of baldness in men. (Laycock, <i>Nervous Diseases of Women</i>, p. 23.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_168'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_168'>[168]</a><div class='note'><p> For some of the evidence on this point, see Havelock Ellis, +"The Comparative Abilities of the Fair and the Dark," <i>Monthly Review</i>, +August, 1901; <i>cf.</i> <i>id.</i>, <i>A Study of British Genius</i>, Chapter X.</p></div> + + + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_THE_PSYCHIC_STATE_IN_PREGNANCY'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_201'></a>THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY.</h2> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Relationship of Maternal and Sexual Emotion—Conception and Loss of +Virginity—The Anciently Accepted Signs of This Condition—The Pervading +Effects of Pregnancy on the Organism—Pigmentation—The Blood and +Circulation—The Thyroid—Changes in the Nervous System—The Vomiting of +Pregnancy—The Longings of Pregnant Women—Maternal Impressions—Evidence +for and Against Their Validity—The Question Still Open—Imperfection of +Our Knowledge—The Significance of Pregnancy.</p></div> +<br /> + +<p>In analyzing the sexual impulse I have so far deliberately kept out of +view the maternal instinct. This is necessary, for the maternal instinct +is specific and distinct; it is directed to an aim which, however +intimately associated it may be with that of the sexual impulse proper, +can by no means be confounded with it. Yet the emotion of love, as it has +finally developed in the world, is not purely of sexual origin; it is +partly sexual, but it is also partly parental.<a name='5_FNanchor_169'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_169'><sup>[169]</sup></a></p> +<a name='5_Page_202'></a> +<p>In so far as it is parental it is certainly mainly maternal. There is a +drawing by Bronzino in the Louvre of a woman's head gazing tenderly down +at some invisible object; is it her child or her lover? Doubtless her +child, yet the expression is equally adequate to the emotion evoked by a +lover. If we were here specifically dealing with the emotion of love as a +complex whole, and not with the psychology of the sexual impulse, it would +certainly be necessary to discuss the maternal instinct and its associated +emotions. In any case it seems desirable to touch on the psychic state of +pregnancy, for we are here concerned not only with emotions very closely +connected with the sexual emotions in the narrower sense, but we here at +last approach that state which it is the object of the whole sexual +process to achieve.</p> + +<p>In civilized life a period of weeks, months, even years, may elapse +between the establishment of sexual relations and the occurrence <a name='5_Page_203'></a>of +conception. Under primitive conditions the loss of the virginal condition +practically involves the pregnant condition, so that under primitive +conditions very little allowance is made for the state, so common among +civilized peoples, of the woman who is no longer a virgin, yet not about +to become a mother.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>There is some interest in noting the signs of loss of virginity + chiefly relied upon by ancient authors. In doing this it is + convenient to follow mainly the full summary of authorities given + by Schurig in his <i>Barthenologia</i> early in the eighteenth + century. The ancient custom, known in classic times, of measuring + the neck the day after marriage was frequently practiced to + ascertain if a girl was or was not a virgin. There were various + ways of doing this. One was to measure with a thread the + circumference of the bride's neck before she went to bed on the + bridal night. If in the morning the same thread would not go + around her neck it was a sure sign that she had lost her + virginity during the night; if not, she was still a virgin or had + been deflowered at an earlier period. Catullus alluded to this + custom, which still exists, or existed until lately, in the south + of France. It is perfectly sound, for it rests on the intimate + response by congestion of the thyroid gland to sexual excitement. + (<i>Parthenologia</i>, p. 283; Biérent, <i>La Puberté</i>, p. 150; Havelock + Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i>, fourth edition, p. 267.)</p> + +<p> Some say, Schurig tells us, that the voice, which in the virgin + is shrill, becomes rougher and deeper after the first coitus. He + quotes Riolan's statement that it is certain that the voice of + those who indulge in venery is changed. On that account the + ancients bound down the penis of their singers, and Martial said + that those who wish to preserve their voices should avoid coitus. + Democritus who one day had greeted a girl as "maiden" on the + following day addressed her as "woman," while in the same way it + is said that Albertus Magnus, observing from his study a girl + going for wine for her master, knew that she had had sexual + intercourse by the way because on her return her voice had become + deeper. Here, again, the ancient belief has a solid basis, for + the voice and the larynx are really affected by sexual + conditions. (<i>Parthenologia</i>, p. 286; Marro, <i>La Puberté</i>, p. + 303; Havelock Ellis, <i>op. cit.</i>, pp. 271, 289.)</p> + +<p> Others, again, Schurig proceeds, have judged that the goaty smell + given out in the armpits during the venereal act is also no + uncertain sign of defloration, such odor being perceptible in + those who use much venery, and not seldom in harlots and the + newly married, while, as Hippocrates said, it is not perceived in + boys and girls. (<i>Parthenologia</i>, p. 286; <i>cf.</i> the previous + volume of these <i>Studies</i>, "Sexual Selection in Man," p. 64.)</p><a name='5_Page_204'></a> + +<p> In virgins, Schurig remarks, the pubic hair is said to be long + and not twisted, while in women accustomed to coitus it is + crisper. But it is only after long and repeated coitus, some + authors add, that the pubic hairs become crisp. Some recent + observers, it may be remarked, have noted a connection between + sexual excitation and the condition of the pubic hair in women. + (<i>Cf.</i> the present volume, <i>ante</i> p. 127.)</p> + +<p> A sign to which the old authors often attached much importance + was furnished by the urinary stream. In the <i>De Secretis + Mulierum</i>, wrongly attributed to Albertus Magnus, it is laid down + that "the virgin urinates higher than the woman." Riolan, in his + <i>Anthropographia</i>, discussing the ability of virgins to ejaculate + urine to a height, states that Scaliger had observed women who + were virgins emit urine in a high jet against a wall, but that + married women could seldom do this. Bouaciolus also stated that + the urine of virgins is emitted in a small stream to a distance + with an acute hissing sound. (<i>Parthenologia</i>, p. 281.) A + folk-lore belief in the reality of this influence is evidenced by + the Picardy <i>conte</i> referred to already (<i>ante</i>, p. 53), "La + Princesse qui pisse au dessus les Meules." There is no doubt a + tendency for the various stresses of sexual life to produce an + influence in this direction, though they act far too slowly and + uncertainly to be a reliable index to the presence or the absence + of virginity.</p> + +<p> Another common ancient test of virginity by urination rests on a + psychic basis, and appears in a variety of forms which are really + all reducible to the same principle. Thus we are told in <i>De + Secretis Mulierum</i> that to ascertain if a girl is seduced she + should be given to eat of powdered crocus flowers, and if she has + been seduced she immediately urinates. We are here concerned with + auto-suggestion, and it may well be believed that with nervous + and credulous girls this test often revealed the truth.</p> + +<p> A further test of virginity discussed by Schurig is the presence + of modesty of countenance. If a woman blushes her virtue is safe. + In this way girls who have themselves had experience of the + marriage bed are said to detect the virgin. The virgin's eyes are + cast down and almost motionless, while she who has known a man + has eyes that are bright and quick. But this sign is equivocal, + says Schurig, for girls are different, and can simulate the + modesty they do not feel. Yet this indication also rests on a + fundamentally sound psychological basis. (See "The Evolution of + Modesty," in the first volume of these <i>Studies</i>.)</p> + +<p> In his <i>Syllepsilogia</i> (Section V, cap. I-II), published in 1731, + Schurig discusses further the anciently recognized signs of + pregnancy. The real or imaginary signs of pregnancy sought by + various primitive peoples of the past and present are brought + together by Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, bd. i, Chapter XXVII.</p></div><a name='5_Page_205'></a> + +<p>Both physically and psychically the occurrence of pregnancy is, however, a +distinct event. It marks the beginning of a continuous physical process, +which cannot fail to manifest psychic reactions. A great center of vital +activity—practically a new center, for only the germinal form of it in +menstruation had previously existed—has appeared and affects the whole +organism. "From the moment that the embryo takes possession of the woman," +Robert Barnes puts it, "every drop of blood, every fiber, every organ, is +affected."<a name='5_FNanchor_170'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_170'><sup>[170]</sup></a></p> + +<p>A woman artist once observed to Dr. Stratz, that as the final aim of a +woman is to become a mother and pregnancy is thus her blossoming time, a +beautiful woman ought to be most beautiful when she is pregnant. That is +so, Stratz replied, if her moment of greatest physical perfection +corresponds with the early months of pregnancy, for with the beginning of +pregnancy metabolism is increased, the color of the skin becomes more +lively and delicate, the breasts firmer.<a name='5_FNanchor_171'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_171'><sup>[171]</sup></a> Pregnancy may, indeed, often +become visible soon after conception by the brighter eye, the livelier +glance, resulting from greater vascular activity, though later, with the +increase of strain, the face may tend to become somewhat thin and +distorted. The hair, Barnes states, assumes a new vigor, even though it +may have been falling out before. The temperature rises; the weight +increases, even apart from the growth of the fœtus. The +efflorescence of pregnancy shows itself, as in the blossoming and +fecundated flower, by increased pigmentation.<a name='5_FNanchor_172'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_172'><sup>[172]</sup></a> The nipples with their +areolæ, and the mid-line of the belly, become darker; brown flecks +(lentigo) tend to appear on the forehead, neck, arms, and body; while +striæ—at first blue-red, then a brilliant white—appear on the belly and +thighs, <a name='5_Page_206'></a>though these are scarcely normal, for they are not seen in women +with very elastic skins and are rare among peasants and savages.<a name='5_FNanchor_173'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_173'><sup>[173]</sup></a> The +whole carriage of the woman tends to become changed with the development +of the mighty seed of man planted within her; it simulates the carriage of +pride with the arched back and protruded abdomen.<a name='5_FNanchor_174'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_174'><sup>[174]</sup></a> The pregnant woman +has been lifted above the level of ordinary humanity to become the casket +of an inestimable jewel.</p> + +<p>It is in the blood and the circulation that the earliest of the most +prominent symptoms of pregnancy are to be found. The ever increasing +development of this new focus of vascular activity involves an increased +vascular activity in the whole organism. This activity is present almost +from the first—a few days after the impregnation of the ovum—in the +breasts, and quickly becomes obvious to inspection and palpation. Before a +quite passive organ, the breast now rapidly increases in activity of +circulation and in size, while certain characteristic changes begin to +take place around the nipples.<a name='5_FNanchor_175'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_175'><sup>[175]</sup></a> As a result of the additional work +imposed upon it the heart tends to become slightly hypertrophied in order +to meet the additional strain; there may be some dilatation also.<a name='5_FNanchor_176'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_176'><sup>[176]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The recent investigations of Stengel and Stanton tend to show + that the increase of the heart's work during pregnancy is less + considerable than has generally been supposed, and that beyond + some enlargement and dilatation of the right ventricle there is + not usually any hypertrophy of the heart.</p></div><a name='5_Page_207'></a> + +<p>The total quantity of blood is raised. While increased in quantity, the +blood appears on the whole to be somewhat depreciated in quality, though +on this point there are considerable differences of opinion. Thus, as +regards hæmoglobin, some investigators have found that the old idea as to +the poverty of hæmoglobin in pregnancy is quite unfounded; a few have even +found that the hæmoglobin is increased. Most authorities have found the +red cells diminished, though some only slightly, while the white cells, +and also the fibrin, are increased. But toward the end of pregnancy there +is a tendency, perhaps due to the establishment of compensation, for the +blood to revert to the normal condition.<a name='5_FNanchor_177'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_177'><sup>[177]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It would appear probable, however, that the vascular phenomena of +pregnancy are not altogether so simple as the above statement would imply. +The activity of various glands at this time—well illustrated by the +marked salivation which sometimes occurs—indicates that other modifying +forces are at work, and it has been suggested that the changes in the +maternal circulation during pregnancy may best be explained by the theory +that there are two opposing kinds of secretion poured into the blood in +unusual degree during pregnancy: one contracting the vessels, the other +dilating them, one or the other sometimes gaining the upper hand. +Suprarenal extract, when administered, has a vaso-constricting influence, +and thyroid extract a vasodilating influence; it may be surmised that +within the body these glands perform similar functions.<a name='5_FNanchor_178'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_178'><sup>[178]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The important part played by the thyroid gland is indicated by its marked +activity at the very beginning of pregnancy. We may probably associate the +general tendency to vasodilatation during early pregnancy with the +tendency to goitre; Freund found an increase of the thyroid in 45 per +cent. of 50 cases. The thyroid belongs to the same class of ductless +glands as the <a name='5_Page_208'></a>ovary, and, as Bland Sutton and others have insisted, the +analogies between the thyroid and the ovary are very numerous and +significant. It may be added that in recent years Armand Gautier has noted +the importance of the thyroid in elaborating nucleo-proteids containing +arsenic and iodine, which are poured into the circulation during +menstruation and pregnancy. The whole metabolism of the body is indeed +affected, and during the latter part of pregnancy study of the ingesta and +egesta has shown that a storage of nitrogen and even of water is taking +place.<a name='5_FNanchor_179'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_179'><sup>[179]</sup></a> The woman, as Pinard puts it, forms the child out of her own +flesh, not merely out of her food; the individual is being sacrificed to +the species.</p> + +<p>The changes in the nervous system of the pregnant woman correspond to +those in the vascular system. There is the same increase of activity, a +heightening of tension. Bruno Wolff, from experiments on bitches, +concluded that the central nervous system in women is probably more easily +excited in the pregnant than in the non-pregnant state, though he was not +prepared to call this cerebral excitability "specific."<a name='5_FNanchor_180'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_180'><sup>[180]</sup></a> Direct +observations on pregnant women have shown, without doubt, a heightened +nervous irritability. Reflex action generally is increased. Neumann +investigated the knee-jerk in 500 women during pregnancy, labor, and the +puerperium, and in a large number found that there was a progressive +exaggeration with the advance of pregnancy, little or no change being +observed in the early months; sometimes when no change was observed during +pregnancy the knee-jerk still increased during labor, reaching its maximum +at the moment of the expulsion of the fœtus; the return to the +normal condition took place gradually during the puerperium. Tridandani +found in pregnant women that though the superficial reflexes, with the +exception of the abdominal, were diminished, the deep and tendon reflexes +were markedly increased, especially that of the knee, these changes being +more marked in primiparæ than in multiparæ, and more pronounced as +pregnancy advanced, the normal condition returning with <a name='5_Page_209'></a>ten days after +labor. Electrical excitability was sensibly diminished.<a name='5_FNanchor_181'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_181'><sup>[181]</sup></a></p> + +<p>One of the first signs of high nervous tension is vomiting. As is well +known, this phenomenon commonly appears early in pregnancy, and it is by +many considered entirely physiological. Barnes regards it as a kind of +safety valve, a regulating function, letting off excessive tension and +maintaining equilibrium.<a name='5_FNanchor_182'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_182'><sup>[182]</sup></a> Vomiting is, however, a convulsion, and is +thus the simplest form of a kind of manifestation—to which the heightened +nervous tension of pregnancy easily lends itself—that finds its extreme +pathological form in eclampsia. In this connection it is of interest to +point out that the pregnant woman here manifests in the highest degree a +tendency which is marked in women generally, for the female sex, apart +altogether from pregnancy, is specially liable to convulsive +phenomena.<a name='5_FNanchor_183'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_183'><sup>[183]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>There is some slight difference of opinion among authorities as + to the precise nature and causation of the sickness of pregnancy. + Barnes, Horrocks and others regard it as physiological; but many + consider it pathological; this is, for instance, the opinion of + Giles. Graily Hewitt attributed it to flexion of the gravid + uterus, Kaltenbach to hysteria, and Zaborsky terms it a neurosis. + Whitridge Williams considers that it may be (1) reflex, or (2) + neurotic (when it is allied to hysteria and amenable to + suggestion), or (3) toxæmic. It really appears to lie on the + borderland between healthy and diseased manifestations. It is + said to be unknown to farmers and veterinary surgeons. It appears + to be little known among savages; it is comparatively infrequent + among women of the lower social classes, and, as Giles has found, + women who habitually menstruate in a painless and normal manner + suffer comparatively little from the sickness of pregnancy.</p> + +<p> We owe a valuable study of the sickness of pregnancy to Giles, + who analyzed the records of 300 cases. He concluded that about + one-third of the pregnant women were free from sickness + throughout pregnancy, 45 per cent. were free during the first + three months. When sickness occurred it began in 70 per cent. of + cases in the first month, and was most frequent during the second + month. The duration varied from <a name='5_Page_210'></a>a few days to all through. + Between the ages of 20 and 25 sickness was least frequent, and + there was less sickness in the third than in any other pregnancy. + (This corresponds with the conclusion of Matthews Duncan that 25 + is the most favorable age for pregnancy.) To some extent in + agreement with Guéniot, Giles believes that the vomiting of + pregnancy is "one form of manifestation of the high nervous + irritability of pregnancy." This high nervous tension may + overflow into other channels, into the vascular and excretory + system, causing eclampsia; into the muscular system, causing + chorea, or, expending itself in the brain, give rise to hysteria + when mild or insanity when severe. But the vagi form a very ready + channel for such overflow, and hence the frequency of sickness in + pregnancy. There are thus three main factors in the causation of + this phenomenon: (1) An increased nervous irritability; (2) a + local source of irritation; (3) a ready efferent channel for + nervous energy. (Arthur Giles, "Observations on the Etiology of + the Sickness of Pregnancy," <i>Transactions Obstetrical Society of + London</i>, vol. xxv, 1894.)</p> + +<p> Martin, who regards the phenomenon as normal, points out that + when nausea and vomiting are absent or suddenly cease there is + often reason to suspect something wrong, especially the death of + the embryo. He also remarks that women who suffer from large + varicose veins are seldom troubled by the nausea of pregnancy. + (J. M. H. Martin, "The Vomiting of Pregnancy," <i>British Medical + Journal</i>, December 10, 1904.) These observations may be connected + with those of Evans (<i>American Gynæcological and Obstetrical + Journal</i>, January, 1900), who attributes primary importance to + the undoubtedly active factor of the irritation set up by the + uterus, more especially the rhythmic uterine contractions; + stimulation of the breasts produces active uterine contractions, + and Evans found that examination of the breasts sufficed to bring + on a severe attack of vomiting, while on another occasion this + was produced by a vaginal examination. Evans believes that the + purpose of these contractions is to facilitate the circulation of + the blood through the large venous sinuses, the surcharging of + the relatively stagnant pools with effete blood producing the + irritation which leads to rhythmic contractions.</p></div> + +<p>It is on the basis of the increased vascular and glandular activity and +the heightened nervous tension that the special psychic phenomena of +pregnancy develop. The best known, and perhaps the most characteristic of +these manifestations, is that known as "longings." By this term is meant +more or less irresistible desires for some special food or drink, which +may be digestible or indigestible, sometimes a substance which the <a name='5_Page_211'></a>woman +ordinarily likes, such as fruit, and occasionally one which, under +ordinary circumstances, she dislikes, as in one case known to me of a +young country woman who, when bearing her child, was always longing for +tobacco and never happy except when she could get a pipe to smoke, +although under ordinary circumstances, like other young women of her +class, she was without any desire to smoke. Occasionally the longings lead +to actions which are more unscrupulous than is common in the case of the +same person at other times; thus in one case known to me a young woman, +pregnant with her first child, insisted to her sister's horror on entering +a strawberry field and eating a quantity of fruit. These "longings" in +their extreme form may properly be considered as neurasthenic obsessions, +but in their simple and less pronounced forms they may well be normal and +healthy.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The old medical authors abound in narratives describing the + longings of pregnant women for natural and unnatural foods. This + affection was commonly called <i>pica</i>, sometimes <i>citra</i> or + <i>malatia</i>. Schurig, whose works are a comprehensive treasure + house of ancient medical lore, devotes a long chapter (cap. II) + of his <i>Chylologia</i>, published in 1725, to pica as manifested + mainly, though not exclusively, in pregnant women. Some women, he + tells us, have been compelled to eat all sorts of earthy + substances, of which sand seems the most common, and one Italian + woman when pregnant ate several pounds of sand with much + satisfaction, following it up with a draught of her own urine. + Lime, mud, chalk, charcoal, cinders, pitch are also the desired + substances in other cases detailed. One pregnant woman must eat + bread fresh from the oven in very large quantities, and a certain + noble matron ate 140 sweet cakes in one day and night. Wheat and + various kinds of corn as well as of vegetables were the foods + desired by many longing women. One woman was responsible for 20 + pounds of pepper, another ate ginger in large quantities, a third + kept mace under her pillow; cinnamon, salt, emulsion of almonds, + treacle, mushrooms were desired by others. Cherries were longed + for by one, and another ate 30 or 40 lemons in one night. Various + kinds of fish—mullet, oysters, crabs, live eels, etc.—are + mentioned, while other women have found delectation in lizards, + frogs, spiders and flies, even scorpions, lice and fleas. A + pregnant woman, aged 33, of sanguine temperament, ate a live fowl + completely with intense satisfaction. Skin, wool, cotton, thread, + linen, blotting paper have been desired, as well as more + repulsive substances, such as nasal mucus and feces (eaten with + bread). Vinegar, ice, and snow occur in <a name='5_Page_212'></a>other cases. One woman + stilled a desire for human flesh by biting the nates of children + or the arms of men. Metals are also swallowed, such as iron, + silver, etc. One pregnant woman wished to throw eggs in her + husband's face, and another to have her husband throw eggs in her + face.</p> + +<p> In the next chapter of the same work Schurig describes cases of + acute antipathy which may arise under the same circumstances + (cap. III, "De Nausea seu Antipathia certorum ciborum"). The list + includes bread, meat, fowls, fish, eels (a very common + repulsion), crabs, milk, butter (very often), cheese (often), + honey, sugar, salt, eggs, caviar, sulphur, apples (especially + their odor), strawberries, mulberries, cinnamon, mace, capers, + pepper, onions, mustard, beetroot, rice, mint, absinthe, roses + (many pages are devoted to this antipathy), lilies, elder + flowers, musk (which sometimes caused vomiting), amber, coffee, + opiates, olive oil, vinegar, cats, frogs, spiders, wasps, swords.</p> + +<p> More recently Gould and Pyle (<i>Anomalies and Curiosities of + Medicine</i>, p. 80) have briefly summarized some of the ancient and + modern records concerning the longings of pregnant women.</p></div> + +<p>Various theories are put forward concerning the causation of the longings +of pregnant women, but none of these seems to furnish by itself a complete +and adequate explanation of all cases. Thus it is said that the craving is +the expression of a natural instinct, the system of the pregnant woman +really requiring the food she longs for. It is quite probable that this is +so in many cases, but it is obviously not so in the majority of cases, +even when we confine ourselves to the longings for fairly natural foods, +while we know so little of the special needs of the organism during +pregnancy that the theory in any case is insusceptible of clear +demonstration.</p> + +<p>Allied to this theory is the explanation that the longings are for things +that counteract the tendency to nausea and sickness. Giles, however, in +his valuable statistical study of the longings of a series of 300 pregnant +women, has shown that the percentage of women with longings is exactly the +same (33 per cent.) among women who had suffered at some time during +pregnancy from sickness as among the women who had not so suffered. +Moreover, Giles found that the period of sickness frequently bore no +relation to the time when there were cravings, and the patient often had +cravings after the sickness had ceased.</p> + +<p>According to another theory these longings are mainly a <a name='5_Page_213'></a>matter of +auto-suggestion. The pregnant woman has received the tradition of such +longings, persuades herself that she has such a longing, and then becomes +convinced that, according to a popular belief, it will be bad for the +child if the longing is not gratified. Giles considers that this process +of auto-suggestion takes place "in a certain number, perhaps even in the +majority of cases."<a name='5_FNanchor_184'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_184'><sup>[184]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>The Duchess d'Abrantès, the wife of Marshal Junot, in her + <i>Mémoires</i> gives an amusing account of how in her first pregnancy + a longing was apparently imposed upon her by the anxious + solicitude of her own and her husband's relations. Though + suffering from constant nausea and sickness, she had no longings. + One day at dinner after the pregnancy had gone on for some months + her mother suddenly put down her fork, exclaiming: "I have never + asked you what longing you have!" She replied with truth that she + had none, her days and her nights being occupied with suffering. + "No <i>envie!</i>" said the mother, "such a thing was never heard of. + I must speak to your mother-in-law." The two old ladies consulted + anxiously and explained to the young mother how an unsatisfied + longing might produce a monstrous child, and the husband also now + began to ask her every day what she longed for. Her + sister-in-law, moreover, brought her all sorts of stories of + children born with appalling mother's marks due to this cause. + She became frightened and began to wonder what she most wanted, + but could think of nothing. At last, when eating a pastille + flavored with pineapple, it occurred to her that pineapple is an + excellent fruit, and one, moreover, which she had never seen, for + at that time it was extremely rare. Thereupon she began to long + for pineapple, and all the more when she was told that at that + season they could not be obtained. She now began to feel that she + must have pineapple or die, and her husband ran all over Paris, + vainly offering twenty louis for a pineapple. At last he + succeeded in obtaining one through the kindness of Mme. + Bonaparte, and drove home furiously just as his wife, always + talking of pineapples, had gone to bed. He entered the room with + the pineapple, to the great satisfaction of the Duchess's mother. + (In one of her own pregnancies, it appears, she longed in vain + for cherries in January, and the child was born with a mark on + her body resembling a cherry—in scientific terminology, a + <i>nævus</i>.) The Duchess effusively thanked her husband and wished + to eat of the fruit immediately, but her husband stopped her and + said that Corvisart, the famous physician, had told him that she + must on no <a name='5_Page_214'></a>account touch it at night, as it was extremely + indigestible. She promised not to do so, and spent the night in + caressing the pineapple. In the morning the husband came and cut + up the fruit, presenting it to her in a porcelain bowl. Suddenly, + however, there was a revulsion of feeling; she felt that she + could not possibly eat pineapple; persuasion was useless; the + fruit had to be taken away and the windows opened, for the very + smell of it had become odious. The Duchess adds that henceforth, + throughout her life, though still liking the flavor, she was only + able to eat pineapple by doing a sort of violence to herself. + (<i>Mémories de la Duchesse d'Abrantès</i>, vol. iii, Chapter VIII.) + It should be added that, in old age, the Duchess d'Abrantès + appears to have become insane.</p></div> + +<p>The influence of suggestion must certainly be accepted as, at all events, +increasing and emphasizing the tendency to longings. It can scarcely, +however, be regarded as a radical and adequate explanation of the +phenomenon generally. If it is a matter of auto-suggestion due to a +tradition, then we should expect to find longings most frequent and most +pronounced in multiparous women, who are best acquainted with the +tradition and best able to experience all that is expected of a pregnant +woman. But, as a matter of fact, the women who have borne most children +are precisely those who are least likely to be affected by the longings +which tradition demands they should manifest. Giles has shown that +longings occur much more frequently in the first than in any subsequent +pregnancy; there is a regular decrease with the increase in number of +pregnancies until in women with ten or more children the longings scarcely +occur at all.</p> + +<p>We must probably regard longings as based on a physiological and psychic +tendency which is of universal extension and almost or quite normal. They +are known throughout Europe and were known to the medical writers of +antiquity. Old Indian as well as old Jewish physicians recognized them. +They have been noted among many savage races to-day: among the Indians of +North and South America, among the peoples of the Nile and the Soudan, in +the Malay archipelago.<a name='5_FNanchor_185'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_185'><sup>[185]</sup></a> In Europe they are most <a name='5_Page_215'></a>common among the +women of the people, living simple and natural lives.<a name='5_FNanchor_186'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_186'><sup>[186]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The true normal relationship of the longings of pregnancy is with the +impulsive and often irresistible longings for food delicacies which are +apt to overcome children, and in girls often persist or revive through +adolescence and even beyond. Such sudden fits of greediness belong to +those kind of normal psychic manifestations which are on the verge of the +abnormal into which they occasionally pass. They may occur, however, in +healthy, well-bred, and well-behaved children who, under the stress of the +sudden craving, will, without compunction and apparently without +reflection, steal the food they long for or even steal from their parents +the money to buy it. The food thus seized by a well-nigh irresistible +craving is nearly always a fruit. Fruit is usually doled out to children +in small quantities as a luxury, but we are descended from primitive human +peoples and still more remote ape-like ancestors, by whom fruit was in its +season eaten copiously, and it is not surprising that when that season +comes round the child, more sensitive than the adult to primitive +influences, should sometimes experience the impulse of its ancestors with +overwhelming intensity, all the more so if, as is probable, the craving is +to some extent the expression of a physiological need.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Sanford Bell, who has investigated the food impulses of children + in America, finds that girls have a greater number of likes and + dislikes in foods than boys of the same age, though at the same + time they have less dislikes to some foods than boys. The + proclivity for sweets and fruits shows itself as soon as a child + begins to eat solids. The chief fruits liked are oranges, + bananas, apples, peaches, and pears. This strong preference for + fruits lasts till the age of 13 or 14, though relatively weaker + from 10 to 13. In girls, however, Bell notes the significant fact + from our present point of view that at mid-adolescence there is a + revived taste for sweets and fruits. He believes that the growth + of children in taste in foods recapitulates the experience of the + race. (S. Bell, "An Introductory Study of the Psychology of + Foods." <i>Pedagogical Seminary</i>, March, 1904.)</p></div><a name='5_Page_216'></a> + +<p>The heightened nervous impressionability of pregnancy would appear to +arouse into activity those primitive impulses which are liable to occur in +childhood and in the unmarried girl continue to the nubile age. It is a +significant fact that the longings of pregnant women are mainly for fruit, +and notably for so wholesome a fruit as the apple, which may very well +have a beneficial effect on the system of the pregnant woman. Giles, in +his tabulation of the foods longed for by 300 pregnant women, found that +the fruit group was by far the largest, furnishing 79 cases; apples were +far away at the head, occurring in 34 cases out of the 99 who had +longings, while oranges followed at a distance (with 13 cases), and in the +vegetable group tomatoes came first (with 6 cases). Several women declared +"I could have lived on apples," "I was eating apples all day," "I used to +sit up in bed eating apples."<a name='5_FNanchor_187'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_187'><sup>[187]</sup></a> Pregnant women appear seldom to long +for the possession of objects outside the edible class, and it seems +doubtful whether they have any special tendency to kleptomania. Pinard has +pointed out that neither Lasègue nor Lunier, in their studies of +kleptomania, have mentioned a single shop robbery committed by a pregnant +woman.<a name='5_FNanchor_188'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_188'><sup>[188]</sup></a> Brouardel has indeed found such cases, but the object stolen +was usually a food.</p> + +<p>A further significant fact connecting the longings of pregnant women with +the longings of children is to be found in the fact that they occur mainly +in young women. We have, indeed, no tabulation of the ages of pregnant +women who have manifested longings, but Giles has clearly shown that these +chiefly <a name='5_Page_217'></a>occur in primiparæ, and steadily and rapidly decrease in each +successive pregnancy. This fact, otherwise somewhat difficult of +explanation, is natural if we look upon the longings of pregnancy as a +revival of those of childhood. It certainly indicates also that we can by +no means regard these longings as exclusively the expression of a +physiological craving, for in that case they would be liable to occur in +any pregnancy unless, indeed, it is argued that with each successive +pregnancy the woman becomes less sensitive to her own physiological state.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>There has been a frequent tendency, more especially among + primitive peoples, to regard a pregnant woman's longings as + something sacred and to be indulged, all the more, no doubt, as + they are usually of a simple and harmless character. In the Black + Forest, according to Ploss and Bartels, a pregnant woman may go + freely into other people's gardens and take fruit, provided she + eats it on the spot, and very similar privileges are accorded to + her elsewhere. Old English opinion, as reflected, for instance, + in Ben Jonson's plays (as Dr. Harriet C. B. Alexander has pointed + out), regards the pregnant woman as not responsible for her + longings, and Kiernan remarks ("Kleptomania and Collectivism," + <i>Alienist and Neurologist</i>, November, 1902) that this is in "a + most natural and just view." In France at the Revolution a law of + the 28th Germinal, in the year III, to some extent admitted the + irresponsibility of the pregnant woman generally,—following the + classic precedent, by which a woman could not be brought before a + court of justice so long as she was pregnant,—but the Napoleonic + code, never tender to women, abrogated this. Pinard does not + consider that the longings of pregnant women are irresistible, + and, consequently, regards the pregnant woman as responsible. + This is probably the view most widely held. In any case these + longings seldom come up for medico-legal consideration.</p></div> + +<p>The phenomena of the longings of pregnancy are linked to the much more +obscure and dubious phenomena of the influence of maternal impressions on +the child within the womb. It is true, indeed, that there is no real +connection whatever between these two groups of manifestations, but they +have been so widely and for so long closely associated in the popular mind +that it is convenient to pass directly from one to the other. The same +name is sometimes given to the two manifestations; thus in France a +pregnant longing is an <i>envie</i>, while a mother's mark on the child is also +called an <i>envie</i>, because it is supposed to be due to the mother's +unsatisfied longing.</p><a name='5_Page_218'></a> + +<p>The conception of a "maternal impression" (the German <i>Versehen</i>) rests on +the belief that a powerful mental influence working on the mother's mind +may produce an impression, either general or definite, on the child she is +carrying. It makes a great deal of difference whether the effect of the +impression on the child is general, or definite and circumscribed. It is +not difficult to believe that a general effect—even, as Sir Arthur +Mitchell first gave good reason for believing, idiocy—may be produced on +the child by strong and prolonged emotional influence working on the +mother, because such general influence may be transmitted through a +deteriorated blood-stream. But it is impossible at present to understand +how a definite and limited influence working on the mother could produce a +definite and limited effect on the child, for there are no channels of +nervous communications for the passage of such influences. Our difficulty +in conceiving of the process must, however, be put aside if the fact +itself can be demonstrated by convincing evidence.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In order to illustrate the nature of maternal impressions, I will + summarize a few cases which I have collected from the best + medical periodical literature during the past fifteen years. I + have exercised no selection and in no way guarantee the + authenticity of the alleged facts or the alleged explanation. + They are merely examples to illustrate a class of cases published + from time to time by medical observers in medical journals of + high repute.</p> + +<p> Early in pregnancy a woman found her pet rabbit killed by a cat + which had gnawed off the two forepaws, leaving ragged stumps; she + was for a long time constantly thinking of this. Her child was + born with deformed feet, one foot with only two toes, the other + three, the os calcis in both feet being either absent or little + developed. (G. B. Beale, Tottenham, <i>Lancet</i>, May 4, 1889).</p> + +<p> Three months and a half before birth of the child the father, a + glazier, fell through the roof of a hothouse, severely cutting + his right arm, so that he was lying in the infirmary for a long + time, and it was doubtful whether the hand could be saved. The + child was healthy, but on the flexor surface of the radial side + of the right forearm just above the wrist—the same spot as the + father's injury—there was a nævus the size of a sixpence. (W. + Russell, Paisley, <i>Lancet</i>, May 11, 1889.)</p> + +<p> At the beginning of pregnancy a woman was greatly scared by being + kicked over by a frightened cow she was milking; she hung on to + the animal's teats, but thought she would be trampled to death, + and <a name='5_Page_219'></a>was ill and nervous for weeks afterwards. The child was a + monster, with a fleshy substance—seeming to be prolonged from + the spinal cord and to represent the brain—projecting from the + floor of the skull. Both doctor and nurse were struck by the + resemblance to a cow's teats before they knew the woman's story, + and this was told by the woman immediately after delivery and + before she knew to what she had given birth. (A. Ross Paterson, + Reversby, Lincolnshire, <i>Lancet</i>, September 29, 1889.)</p> + +<p> During the second month of pregnancy the mother was terrified by + a bullock as she was returning from market. The child reached + full term and was a well-developed male, stillborn. Its head + "exactly resembled a miniature cow's head;" the occipital bone + was absent, the parietals only slightly developed, the eyes were + placed at the top of the frontal bone, which was quite flat, with + each of its superior angles twisted into a rudimentary horn. + (J. T. Hislop, Tavistock, Devon, <i>Lancet</i>, November 1, 1890.)</p> + +<p> When four months pregnant the mother, a multipara of 30, was + startled by a black and white collie dog suddenly pushing against + her and rushing out when she opened the door. This preyed on her + mind, and she felt sure her child would be marked. The whole of + the child's right thigh was encircled by a shining black mole, + studded with white hairs; there was another mole on the spine of + the left scapula. (C. F. Williamson, Horley, Surrey, <i>Lancet</i>, + October 11, 1890.)</p> + +<p> A lady in comfortable circumstances, aged 24, not markedly + emotional, with one child, in all respects healthy, early in her + pregnancy saw a man begging whose arms and legs were "all doubled + up." This gave her a shock, but she hoped no ill effects would + follow. The child was an encephalous monster, with the + extremities rigidly flexed and the fingers clenched, the feet + almost sole to sole. In the next pregnancy she frequently passed + a man who was a partial cripple, but she was not unduly + depressed; the child was a counterpart of the last, except that + the head was normal. The next child was strong and well formed. + (C. W. Chapman, London, <i>Lancet</i>, October 18, 1890.)</p> + +<p> When the pregnant mother was working in a hayfield her husband + threw at her a young hare he had found in the hay; it struck her + on the cheek and neck. Her daughter has on the left cheek an + oblong patch of soft dark hair, in color and character clearly + resembling the fur of a very young hare. (A. Mackay, Port Appin, + N. B., <i>Lancet</i>, December 19, 1891. The writer records also four + other cases which have happened in his experience.)</p> + +<p> When the mother was pregnant her husband had to attend to a sow + who could not give birth to her pigs; he bled her freely, cutting + a notch out of both ears. His wife insisted on seeing the sow. + The helix of each ear of her child at birth was gone, for nearly + or quite half an inch, as if cut purposely. (R. P. Roons, <i>Medical + World</i>, 1894.)</p><a name='5_Page_220'></a> + +<p> A lady when pregnant was much interested in a story in which one + of the characters had a supernumerary digit, and this often + recurred to her mind. Her baby had a supernumerary digit on one + hand. (J. Jenkyns, Aberdeen, <i>British Medical Journal</i>, March 2, + 1895. The writer also records another case.)</p> + +<p> When pregnant the mother saw in the forest a new-born fawn which + was a double monstrosity. Her child was a similar double + monstrosity (<i>cephalothora copagus</i>). (Hartmann, <i>Münchener + Medicinisches Wochenschrift</i>, No. 9, 1895.)</p> + +<p> A well developed woman of 30, who had ten children in twelve + years, in the third month of her tenth pregnancy saw a child run + over by a street car, which crushed the upper and back part of + its head. Her own child was anencephalic and acranial, with + entire absence of vault of skull. (F. A. Stahl, <i>American Journal + of Obstetrics</i>, April, 1896.)</p> + +<p> A healthy woman with no skin blemish had during her third + pregnancy a violent appetite for sunfish. During or after the + fourth month her husband, as a surprise, brought her some sunfish + alive, placing them in a pail of water in the porch. She stumbled + against the pail and the shock caused the fish to flap over the + pail and come in violent contact with her leg. The cold wriggling + fish produced a nervous shock, but she attached no importance to + this. The child (a girl) had at birth a mark of bronze pigment + resembling a fish with the head uppermost (photograph given) on + the corresponding part of the same leg. Daughter's health good; + throughout life she has had a strong craving for sunfish, which + she has sometimes eaten till she has vomited from repletion. + (C. F. Gardiner, Colorado Springs, <i>American Journal Obstetrics</i>, + February, 1898.)</p> + +<p> The next case occurred in a bitch. A thoroughbred fox terrier + bitch strayed and was discovered a day or two later with her + right foreleg broken. The limb was set under chloroform with the + help of Röntgen rays, and the dog made a good recovery. Several + weeks later she gave birth to a puppy with a right foreleg that + was ill-developed and minus the paw. (J. Booth, Cork, <i>British + Medical Journal</i>, September 16, 1899.)</p> + +<p> Four months before the birth of her child a woman with four + healthy children and no history of deformity in the family fell + and cut her left wrist severely against a broken bowl; she had a + great fright and shock. Her child, otherwise perfect, was born + without left hand and wrist, the stump of arm terminating at + lower end of radius and ulna. (G. Ainslie Johnston, Ambleside, + <i>British Medical Journal</i>, April 18, 1903.)</p></div> + +<p>The belief in the reality of the transference of strong mental or physical +impressions on the mother into physical <a name='5_Page_221'></a>changes in the child she is +bearing is very ancient and widespread. Most writers on the subject begin +with the book of Genesis and the astute device of Jacob in influencing the +color of his lambs by mental impressions on his ewes. But the belief +exists among even more primitive people than the early Hebrews, and in all +parts of the world.<a name='5_FNanchor_189'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_189'><sup>[189]</sup></a> Among the Greeks there is a trace of the belief +in Hippocrates, the first of the world's great physicians, while Soranus, +the most famous of ancient gynæcologists, states the matter in the most +precise manner, with instances in proof. The belief continued to persist +unquestioned throughout the Middle Ages. The first author who denied the +influence of maternal impressions altogether appears to have been the +famous anatomist, Realdus Columbus, who was a professor at Padua, Pisa, +and Rome at the beginning of the sixteenth century. In the same century, +however, another and not less famous Neapolitan, Della Porta, for the +first time formulated a definite theory of maternal impressions. A little +later, early in the seventeenth century, a philosophic physician at Padua, +Fortunatus Licetus, took up an intermediate position which still finds, +perhaps reasonably, a great many adherents. He recognized that a very +frequent cause of malformation in the child is to be found in morbid +antenatal conditions, but at the same time was not prepared to deny +absolutely and in every case the influence of maternal impression on such +conditions. Malebranche, the Platonic philosopher, allowed the greatest +extension to the power of the maternal imagination. In the eighteenth +century, however, the new spirit of free inquiry, of radical criticism, +and unfettered logic, led to a sceptical attitude toward this ancient +belief then flourishing vigorously.<a name='5_FNanchor_190'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_190'><sup>[190]</sup></a> In 1727, a few years after +Malebranche's death, James Blondel, a physician of extreme acuteness, who +had <a name='5_Page_222'></a>been born in Paris, was educated at Leyden, and practiced in London, +published the first methodical and thorough attack on the doctrine of +maternal impressions, <i>The Strength of Imagination of Pregnant Women +Examined</i>, and exercised his great ability in ridiculing it. Haller, +Roederer, and Sömmering followed in the steps of Blondel, and were either +sceptical or hostile to the ancient belief. Blumenbach, however, admitted +the influence of maternal impressions. Erasmus Darwin, as well as Goethe +in his <i>Wahlverwandtschaften</i>, even accepted the influence of paternal +impressions on the child. By the beginning of the nineteenth century the +majority of physicians were inclined to relegate maternal impressions to +the region of superstition. Yet the exceptions were of notable importance. +Burdach, when all deductions were made, still found it necessary to retain +the belief in maternal impressions, and Von Baer, the founder of +embryology, also accepted it, supported by a case, occurring in his own +sister, which he was able to investigate before the child's birth. L. W. T. +Bischoff, also, while submitting the doctrine to acute criticism, found it +impossible to reject maternal impressions absolutely, and he remarked that +the number of adherents to the doctrine was showing a tendency to increase +rather than diminish. Johannes Müller, the founder of modern physiology in +Germany, declared himself against it, and his influence long prevailed; +Valentin, Rudolf Wagner, and Emil du Bois-Reymond were on the same side. +On the other hand various eminent gynæcologists—Litzmann, Roth, Hennig, +etc.—have argued in favor of the reality of maternal impressions.<a name='5_FNanchor_191'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_191'><sup>[191]</sup></a></p> + +<p>The long conflict of opinion which has taken place over this opinion has +still left the matter unsettled. The acutest critics <a name='5_Page_223'></a>of the ancient +belief constantly conclude the discussion with an expression of doubt and +uncertainty. Even if the majority of authorities are inclined to reject +maternal impressions, the scientific eminence of those who accept them +makes a decisive opinion difficult. The arguments against such influence +are perfectly sound: (1) it is a primitive belief of unscientific origin; +(2) it is impossible to conceive how such influence can operate since +there is no nervous connection between mother and child; (3) comparatively +few cases have been submitted to severe critical investigation; (4) it is +absurd to ascribe developmental defects to influences which arise long +after the fœtus had assumed its definite shape<a name='5_FNanchor_192'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_192'><sup>[192]</sup></a>; (5) in any +case the phenomenon must be rare, for William Hunter could not find a +coincidence between maternal impressions and fœtal marks through +a period of several years, and Bischoff found no case in 11,000 +deliveries. These statements embody the whole of the argument against +maternal impressions, yet it is clear that they do not settle the matter. +Edgar, in a manual of obstetrics which is widely regarded as a standard +work, states that this is "yet a mooted question."<a name='5_FNanchor_193'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_193'><sup>[193]</sup></a> Ballantyne, again, +in a discussion of this influence at the Edinburgh Obstetrical Society, +summarizing the result of a year's inquiry, concluded that it is still +"<i>sub judice</i>."<a name='5_FNanchor_194'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_194'><sup>[194]</sup></a> In a subsequent discussion of the question he has +somewhat modified his opinion, and is inclined to deny that definite +impressions on the pregnant woman's mind can cause similar defects in the +fœtus; they are "accidental coincidences," but he adds that a few +of the <a name='5_Page_224'></a>cases are difficult to explain away. At the same time he fully +believes that prolonged and strongly marked mental states of the mother +may affect the development of the fœtus in her uterus, causing +vascular and nutritive disturbances, irregularities of development, and +idiocy.<a name='5_FNanchor_195'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_195'><sup>[195]</sup></a></p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>Whether and in how far mental impressions on the mother can + produce definite mental and emotional disposition in the child is + a special aspect of the question to which scarcely any inquiry + has been devoted. So distinguished a biologist as Mr. A. W. + Wallace has, however, called attention to this point, bringing + forward evidence on the question and emphasizing the need of + further investigation. "Such transmission of mental influence," + he remarks, "will hardly be held to be impossible or even very + improbable," (A. W. Wallace, "Prenatal Influences on Character," + <i>Nature</i>, August 24, 1893.)</p></div> + +<p>It has already been pointed out that a large number of cases of fœtal +deformities, supposed to be due to maternal impressions, cannot +possibly be so caused because the impression took place at a period when +the development of the fœtus must already have been decided. In +this connection, however, it must be noted that Dabney has observed a +relationship between the time of supposed mental impressions and the +nature of the actual defect which is of considerable significance as an +argument in favor of the influence of mental impressions. He tabulated 90 +carefully reported cases from recent medical literature, and found that 21 +of them were concerned with defects of structure of the lips and palate. +In all but 2 of these 21 the defect was referred to an impression +occurring within the first three months of pregnancy. This is an important +point as showing that the assigned cause really falls within a period when +a defect of development actually could produce the observed result, +although the person reporting the cases was in many instances manifestly +ignorant of the details of embryology and teratology. There was no such +preponderance of early impressions among the defects of skin and hair +which might well, so far as development is concerned, have been caused at +a later period; here, in 7 out <a name='5_Page_225'></a>of 15 cases, it was distinctly stated that +the impression was made later than the fourth month.<a name='5_FNanchor_196'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_196'><sup>[196]</sup></a></p> + +<p>It would seem, on the whole, that while the influence of maternal +impressions in producing definite effects on the child within the womb has +by no means been positively demonstrated, we are not entitled to reject it +with any positive assurance. Even if we accept it, however, it must +remain, for the present, an inexplicable fact; the <i>modus operandi</i> we can +scarcely even guess at. General influences from the mother on the child we +can easily conceive of as conveyed by the mother's blood; we can even +suppose that the modified blood might act specifically on one particular +kind of tissue. We can, again, as suggested by Féré, very well believe +that the maternal emotions act upon the womb and produce various kinds and +degrees of pressure on the child within, so that the apparently active +movements of the fœtus may be really consecutive on unconscious +maternal excitations.<a name='5_FNanchor_197'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_197'><sup>[197]</sup></a> We may also believe that, as suggested by John +Thomson, there are slight incoördinations <i>in utero</i>, a kind of +developmental neurosis, produced by some slight lack of harmony of +whatever origin, and leading to the production of malformations.<a name='5_FNanchor_198'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_198'><sup>[198]</sup></a> We +know, finally, that, as Féré and others have repeatedly demonstrated +during recent years by experiments on chickens, etc., very subtle agents, +even odors, may profoundly affect embryonic development and produce +deformity. But how the mother's psychic disposition can, apart from +heredity, affect specifically the physical conformation or even the +psychic disposition of the child within her womb must remain for the +present an insoluble mystery, even if we feel disposed to conclude that in +some cases such action seems to be indicated.</p> + +<div class='blkquot'><p>In comprehending such a connection, however at present + undemonstrated, it may well be borne in mind that the + relationship of the mother to the child within her womb is of a + uniquely intimate character. It is <a name='5_Page_226'></a>of interest in this + connection to quote some remarks by an able psychologist, Dr. + Henry Rutgers Marshall; the remarks are not less interesting for + being brought forward without any connection with the question of + maternal impressions: "It is true that, so far as we know, the + nervous system of the embryo never has a direct connection with + the nervous system of the mother: nevertheless, as there is a + reciprocity of reaction between the physical body of the mother + and its embryonic parasite, the relation of the embryonic nervous + system to the nervous system of the mother is not very far + removed from the relation of the pre-eminent part of the nervous + system of a man to some minor nervous system within his body + which is to a marked extent dissociated from the whole neural + mass.</p> + +<p> "Correspondingly, then, and within the consciousness of the + mother, there develops a new little minor consciousness which, + although but lightly integrated with the mass of her + consciousness, nevertheless has its part in her consciousness + taken as a whole, much as the psychic correspondents of the + action of the nerve which govern the secretions of the glands of + the body have their part in her consciousness taken as a whole.</p> + +<p> "It is very much as if the optic ganglia developed fully in + themselves, without any closer connection with the rest of the + brain than existed at their first appearance. They would form a + little complex nervous system almost but not quite apart from the + brain system; and it would be difficult to deny them a + consciousness of their own; which would indeed form part of the + whole consciousness of the individual, but which would be in a + manner self-dependent." It must, if this is so, be said that + before birth, on the psychic side, the embryo's activities "form + part of a complex consciousness which is that of the mother and + embryo together." "Without subscribing to the strange stories of + telepathy, of the solemn apparition of a person somewhere at the + moment of his death a thousand miles away, of the unquiet ghost + haunting the scenes of its bygone hopes and endeavors, one may + ask" (with the author of the address in medicine at the Leicester + gathering of the British Medical Association, <i>British Medical + Journal</i>, July 29, 1905) "whether two brains cannot be so tuned + in sympathy as to transmit and receive a subtile transfusion of + mind without mediation of sense. Considering what is implied by + the human brain with its countless millions of cells, its + complexities of minute structure, its innumerable chemical + compositions, and the condensed forces in its microscopic and + ultramicroscopic elements—the whole a sort of microcosm of + cosmic forces to which no conceivable compound of electric + batteries is comparable; considering, again, that from an + electric station waves of energy radiate through the viewless air + to be caught up by a fit receiver a thousand miles distant, it is + not inconceivable that the human brain may send off still more + subtile <a name='5_Page_227'></a>waves to be accepted and interpreted by the fitly tuned + receiving brain. Is it, after all, mere fancy that a mental + atmosphere or effluence emanates from one person to affect + another, either soothing sympathetically or irritating + antipathically?" These remarks (like Dr. Marshall's) were made + without reference to maternal impressions, but it may be pointed + out that under no conceivable circumstance could we find a brain + in so virginal and receptive a state as is the child's in the + womb.</p></div> + +<p>On the whole we see that pregnancy induces a psychic state which is at +once, in healthy persons, one of full development and vigor, and at the +same time one which, especially in individuals who are slightly abnormal, +is apt to involve a state of strained or overstrained nervous tension and +to evoke various manifestations which are in many respects still +imperfectly understood. Even the specifically sexual emotions tend to be +heightened, more especially during the earlier period of pregnancy. In 24 +cases of pregnancy in which the point was investigated by Harry Campbell, +sexual feeling was decidedly increased in 8, in one case (of a woman aged +31 who had had four children) being indeed only present during pregnancy, +when it was considerable; in only 7 cases was there diminution or +disappearance of sexual feeling.<a name='5_FNanchor_199'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_199'><sup>[199]</sup></a> Pregnancy may produce mental +depression;<a name='5_FNanchor_200'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_200'><sup>[200]</sup></a> but on the other hand it frequently leads to a change of +the most favorable character in the mental and general well-being. Some +women indeed are only well during pregnancy. It is remarkable that some +women who habitually suffer from various nervous troubles—neuralgias, +gastralgia, headache, insomnia—are only free from them at this moment. +This "paradox of gestation," as Vinay has termed it, is specially marked +in the hysterical and those suffering from slight nervous disorders, but +it is by no means universal, so that although it is possible, Vinay +states, to confirm the opinion of the ancients as <a name='5_Page_228'></a>to the beneficial +action of marriage on hysteria, that is only true of slight cases and +scarcely enables us to counsel marriage in hysteria.<a name='5_FNanchor_201'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_201'><sup>[201]</sup></a> Even a woman's +intelligence is sometimes heightened by pregnancy, and Tarnier, as quoted +by Vinay, knew many women whose intelligence, habitually somewhat obtuse, +has only risen to the normal level during pregnancy.<a name='5_FNanchor_202'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_202'><sup>[202]</sup></a> The pregnant +woman has reached the climax of womanhood; she has attained to that state +toward which the periodically recurring menstrual wave has been drifting +her at regular intervals throughout her sexual life<a name='5_FNanchor_203'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_203'><sup>[203]</sup></a>; she has achieved +that function for which her body has been constructed, and her mental and +emotional disposition adapted, through countless ages.</p> + +<p>And yet, as we have seen, our ignorance of the changes effected by the +occurrence of this supremely important event—even on the physical +side—still remains profound. Pregnancy, even for us, the critical and +unprejudiced children of a civilized age, still remains, as for the +children of more primitive ages, a mystery. Conception itself is a mystery +for the primitive man, and may be produced by all sorts of subtle ways +apart from sexual connection, even by smelling a flower.<a name='5_FNanchor_204'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_204'><sup>[204]</sup></a> The pregnant +woman <a name='5_Page_229'></a>was surrounded by ceremonies, by reverence and fear, often shut up +in a place apart.<a name='5_FNanchor_205'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_205'><sup>[205]</sup></a> Her presence, her exhalations, were of extreme +potency; even in some parts of Europe to-day, as in the Walloon districts +of Belgium, a pregnant woman must not kiss a child for her breath is +dangerous, or urinate on plants for she will kill them.<a name='5_FNanchor_206'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_206'><sup>[206]</sup></a> The mystery +has somewhat changed its form; it still remains. The future of the race is +bound up with our efforts to fathom the mystery of pregnancy. "The early +days of human life," it has been truly said, "are entirely one with the +mother. On her manner of life—eating, drinking, sleeping, and +thinking—what greatness may not hang?"<a name='5_FNanchor_207'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_207'><sup>[207]</sup></a> Schopenhauer observed, with +misapplied horror, that there is nothing a woman is less modest about than +the state of pregnancy, while Weininger exclaims: "Never yet has a +pregnant woman given expression in any form—poem, memoirs, or +gynæcological monograph—to her sensations or feelings."<a name='5_FNanchor_208'></a><a href='#5_Footnote_208'><sup>[208]</sup></a> Yet when we +contemplate the mystery of pregnancy and all that it involves, how trivial +all such considerations become! We are here lifted into a region where our +highest intelligence can only lead us to adoration, for we are gazing at a +process in which the operations of Nature become one with the divine task +of Creation.</p> + +<hr /> + +<a name='5_Footnote_169'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_169'>[169]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, Groos, <i>Æsthetische Genuss</i>, p. 249. "We have +to admit," Groos observes, "the entrance of another instinct, the impulse +to tend and foster, so closely connected with the sexual life. It is +seemingly due to the co-operation of this impulse that the little female +bird during courtship is so often fed by the male like a young fledgling. +In man 'love' from the biological standpoint is also an amalgamation of +two needs; when the tender need to protect and foster and serve is lacking +the emotion is not quite perfect. Heine's expression, 'With my mantle I +protect you from the storm,' has always seemed to me very characteristic." +Sometimes the sexual impulse may undergo a complete transformation in this +direction. "I believe there is really a tendency in women," a lady writes +in a letter, "to allow maternal feeling to take the place of sexual +feeling. Very often a woman's feeling for her husband becomes this (though +he may be twenty years older than herself); sometimes it does not, +remaining purely sex feeling. Sometimes it is for some other man she has +this curious self-obliterating maternal feeling. It is not necessarily +connected with sex intercourse. A prostitute, who has relations with +dozens of men, may have it for some feeble drunken fool, who perhaps goes +after other women. I once saw the change from sex feeling to mother +feeling, as I call it, come almost suddenly over a woman after she had +lived about four years with a man who was unfaithful to her. Then, when +all real sex feeling, the hatred of the woman he followed, the desire he +should give her love and tenderness, had all gone, came the other feeling, +and she said to me, 'You don't understand at all; he's only my little +baby; nothing he does can make any difference to me now.' As I grow older +and understand women's natures better, I can see almost at once which +relation it is a woman has to her husband, or any given man. It is this +feeling, and not sex passion, that keeps woman from being free." Not only +is there a sexual association in the impulse to foster and protect, there +would appear to be a similar element also in the response to that impulse. +Freud has especially insisted on the partly sexual character of the +child's feelings for those who care for it and tend it and satisfy its +needs. It is begun in earliest infancy; "whoever has seen the sated infant +sink back from the breast, to fall asleep with flushed cheeks and happy +smile, must say that the picture is adequate to the expression of the +sexual satisfaction of later life." The lips, moreover, are the earliest +erogenous zone. "There will, perhaps, be some opposition," Freud remarks +(<i>Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie</i>, pp. 36, 64), "to the +identification of the child's feelings of tenderness and appreciation for +those who tend it with sexual love, but I believe that exact psychological +analysis will place the identity beyond doubt. The relationship of the +child with the person who tends it is for it a continual source of sexual +excitement and satisfaction flowing from the erogenous zones, especially +since the fostering person—as a rule the mother—regards the child with +emotions which proceed from her sexual life; strokes it, kisses it, rocks +it, and very plainly treats it as a compensation for a fully valid sexual +object." Freud remarks that girls who retain the childish character of +their love for their parents to adult age are apt to make cold wives and +to be sexually anæsthetic.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_170'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_170'>[170]</a><div class='note'><p> Esbach (in his <i>Thèse de Paris</i>, published in 1876) showed +that even the finger nails are affected in pregnancy and become measurably +thinner.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_171'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_171'>[171]</a><div class='note'><p> C. H. Stratz, <i>Die Schönheit des Weiblichen Körpers</i>, +Chapter VI.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_172'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_172'>[172]</a><div class='note'><p> Iron appears to be liberated in the maternal organism +during pregnancy, and Wychgel has shown (<i>Zeitschrift für Geburtshülfe und +Gynäkologie</i>, bd. xlvii, Heft II) that the pigment of pregnant women +contains iron, and that the amount of iron in the urine is increased.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_173'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_173'>[173]</a><div class='note'><p> Vinay, <i>Maladies de la Grossesse</i>, Chapter VIII; K. Hennig, +"Exploratio Externa," <i>Comptes-rendus du XIIe. Congrès International de +Médècine</i>, vol. vi, Section XIII, pp. 144-166. A bibliography of the +literature concerning the physiology of pregnancy, extending to ten pages, +is appended by Pinard to his article "Grossesse," <i>Dictionnaire +Encyclopédique des Sciences Médicales</i>.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_174'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_174'>[174]</a><div class='note'><p> Stratz, <i>op. cit.</i>, Chapter XII.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_175'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_175'>[175]</a><div class='note'><p> W. S. A. Griffith, "The Diagnosis of Pregnancy," <i>British +Medical Journal</i>, April 11, 1903.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_176'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_176'>[176]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Mackenzie and H. O. Nicholson, "The Heart in Pregnancy," +<i>British Medical Journal</i>, October 8, 1904; Stengel and Stanton, "The +Condition of the Heart in Pregnancy," <i>Medical Record</i>, May 10, 1902 and +<i>University Pennsylvania Medical Bulletin</i>, Sept., 1904 (summarized in +<i>British Medical Journal</i>, August 16, 1902, and Sept. 23, 1905.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_177'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_177'>[177]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Henderson, "Maternal Blood at Term," <i>Journal of +Obstetrics and Gynæcology</i>, February, 1902; C. Douglas, "The Blood in +Pregnant Women," <i>British Medical Journal</i>, March 26, 1904; W. L. Thompson, +"The Blood in Pregnancy," <i>Johns Hopkins Hospital Bulletin</i>, June, 1904.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_178'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_178'>[178]</a><div class='note'><p> H. O. Nicholson, "Some Remarks on the Maternal Circulation +in Pregnancy," <i>British Medical Journal</i>, October 3, 1903.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_179'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_179'>[179]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Morris Slemans, "Metabolism During Pregnancy," <i>Johns +Hopkins Hospital Reports</i>, vol. xii, 1904.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_180'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_180'>[180]</a><div class='note'><p> B. Wolff, <i>Zentralblatt für Gynäkologie</i>, 1904, No. 26.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_181'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_181'>[181]</a><div class='note'><p> Tridandani, <i>Annali di Ostetrica</i>, March, 1900.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_182'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_182'>[182]</a><div class='note'><p> R. Barnes, "The Induction of Labor," <i>British Medical +Journal</i>, December 22, 1894.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_183'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_183'>[183]</a><div class='note'><p> See, <i>e.g.</i>, Havelock Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i>, fourth +edition, pp. 344, <i>et seq.</i></p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_184'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_184'>[184]</a><div class='note'><p> Arthur Giles, "The Longings of Pregnant Women," +<i>Transactions Obstetrical Society of London</i>, vol. xxxv, 1893.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_185'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_185'>[185]</a><div class='note'><p> Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, Chapter XXX.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_186'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_186'>[186]</a><div class='note'><p> Thus, in Cornwall, "to be in the longing way" is a popular +synonym for pregnancy.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_187'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_187'>[187]</a><div class='note'><p> The apple, wherever it is known, has nearly always been a +sacred or magic fruit (as J. F. Campbell shows, <i>Popular Tales of West +Highlands</i>, vol. I, p. lxxv. <i>et seq.</i>), and the fruit of the forbidden +tree which tempted Eve is always popularly imagined to be an apple. One +may perhaps refer in this connection to the fact that at Rome and +elsewhere the testicles have been called apples. I may add that we find a +curious proof of the recognition of the feminine love of apples in an old +Portuguese ballad, "Donna Guimar," in which a damsel puts on armour and +goes to the wars; her sex is suspected and as a test, she is taken into an +orchard, but Donna Guimar is too wary to fall into the trap, and turning +away from the apples plucks a citron.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_188'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_188'>[188]</a><div class='note'><p> A. Pinard, Art. "Grossesse," <i>Dictionnaire Encyclopédique +des Sciences Médicales</i>, p. 138. On the subject of violent, criminal and +abnormal impulses during pregnancy, see Cumston, "Pregnancy and Crime," +<i>American Journal Obstetrics</i>, December, 1903.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_189'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_189'>[189]</a><div class='note'><p> See especially Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, vol. i, +Chapter XXXI. Ballantyne in his work on the pathology of the fœtus +adds Loango negroes, the Eskimo and the ancient Japanese.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_190'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_190'>[190]</a><div class='note'><p> In 1731 Schurig, in his <i>Syllepsilogia</i>, devoted more than +a hundred pages (cap. IX) to summarizing a vast number of curious cases of +maternal impressions leading to birth-marks of all kinds.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_191'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_191'>[191]</a><div class='note'><p> J. W. Ballantyne has written an excellent history of the +doctrine of maternal impressions, reprinted in his <i>Manual of Antenatal +Pathology: The Embryo</i>, 1904, Chapter IX; he gives a bibliography of 381 +items. In Germany the history of the question has been written by Dr. Iwan +Bloch (under the pseudonym of Gerhard von Welsenburg), <i>Das Versehen der +Frauen</i>, 1899. <i>Cf.</i>, in French, G. Variot, "Origine des Préjugés +Populaires sur les Envies," <i>Bulletin Société d'Anthropologie</i>, Paris, +June 18, 1891. Variot rejects the doctrine absolutely, Bloch accepts it, +Ballantyne speaks cautiously.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_192'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_192'>[192]</a><div class='note'><p> J. G. Kiernan has shown how many of the alleged cases are +negatived by the failure to take this fact into consideration. (<i>Journal +of American Medical Association</i>, December 9, 1899.)</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_193'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_193'>[193]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Clifton Edgar, <i>The Practice of Obstetrics</i>, second +edition, 1904, p. 296. In an important discussion of the question at the +American Gynæcological Society in 1886, introduced by Fordyce Barker, +various eminent gynæcologists declared in favor of the doctrine, more or +less cautiously. (<i>Transactions of the American Gynæcological Society</i>, +vol. xi, 1886, pp. 152-196.) Gould and Pyle, bringing forward some of the +data on the question (<i>Anomalies and Curiosities of Medicine</i>, pp. 81, <i>et +seq.</i>) state that the reality of the influence of maternal impressions +seems fully established. On the other side, see G. W. Cook, <i>American +Journal of Obstetrics</i>, September, 1889, and H. F. Lewis, <i>ib.</i>, July, +1899.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_194'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_194'>[194]</a><div class='note'><p> <i>Transactions Edinburgh Obstetrical Society</i>, vol. xvii, +1892.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_195'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_195'>[195]</a><div class='note'><p> J. W. Ballantyne, <i>Manual of Antenatal Pathology: The +Embryo</i>, p. 45.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_196'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_196'>[196]</a><div class='note'><p> W. C. Dabney, "Maternal Impressions," Keating's <i>Cyclopædia +of Diseases of Children</i>, vol. i, 1889, pp. 191-216.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_197'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_197'>[197]</a><div class='note'><p> Féré, <i>Sensation et Mouvement</i>, Chapter XIV, "Sur la +Psychologie du Fœtus."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_198'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_198'>[198]</a><div class='note'><p> J. Thomson, "Defective Co-ordination in Utero," <i>British +Medical Journal</i>, September 6, 1902.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_199'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_199'>[199]</a><div class='note'><p> H. Campbell, <i>Nervous Organization of Man and Woman</i>, p. +206; <i>cf.</i> Moll, <i>Untersuchungen über die Libido Sexualis</i>, bd. i, p. 264. +Many authorities, from Soranus of Ephesus onward, consider, however, that +sexual relations should cease during pregnancy, and certainly during the +later months. <i>Cf.</i> Brénot, <i>De l'influence de la copulation pendant la +grosseisse</i>, 1903.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_200'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_200'>[200]</a><div class='note'><p> Bianchi terms this fairly common condition the neurasthenia +of pregnancy.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_201'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_201'>[201]</a><div class='note'><p> Vinay, <i>Traité des Maladies de la Grossesse</i>, 1894, pp. 51, +577; Mongeri, "Nervenkrankungen und Schwangerschaft." <i>Allegemeine +Zeitschrift für Psychiatrie</i>, bd. LVIII, Heft 5. Haig remarks (<i>Uric +Acid</i>, sixth edition, p. 151) that during normal pregnancy diseases with +excess of uric acid in the blood (headaches, fits, mental depression, +dyspepsia, asthma) are absent, and considers that the common idea that +women do not easily take colds, fevers, etc., at this time is well +founded.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_202'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_202'>[202]</a><div class='note'><p> Founding his remarks on certain anatomical changes and on a +suggestion of Engel's, Donaldson observes: "It is impossible to escape the +conclusion that in women natural education is complete only with +maternity, which we know to effect some slight changes in the sympathetic +system and possibly the spinal cord, and which may be fairly laid under +suspicion of causing more structural modifications than are at present +recognized." H. H. Donaldson, <i>The Growth of the Brain</i>, p. 352.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_203'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_203'>[203]</a><div class='note'><p> The state of menstruation is in many respects an +approximation to that of pregnancy; see, <i>e.g.</i>, Edgar's <i>Practice of +Obstetrics</i>, plates 6 6 and 7, showing the resemblance of the menstrual +changes in the breasts and the external sexual parts to the changes of +pregnancy; <i>cf.</i> Havelock Ellis, <i>Man and Woman</i>, fourth edition, Chapter +XI, "The Functional Periodicity of Woman."</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_204'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_204'>[204]</a><div class='note'><p> Thus the gypsies say of an unmarried woman who becomes +pregnant, "She has smelt the moon-flower"—a flower believed to grow on +the so-called moon-mountain and to possess the property of impregnating by +its smell. Ploss and Bartels, <i>Das Weib</i>, bd. I, Chapter XXVII.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_205'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_205'>[205]</a><div class='note'><p> This was a sound instinct, for it is now recognized as an +extremely important part of puericulture that a woman should rest at all +events during the latter part of pregnancy; see, <i>e.g.</i>, Pinard, <i>Gazette +des Hôpitaux</i>, November 28, 1895, and <i>Annales de Gynécologie</i>, August, +1898.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_206'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_206'>[206]</a><div class='note'><p> Ploss and Bartels, <i>op. cit.</i>, Chapter XXIX; +Κρυπτάδια, vol. viii, p. 143.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_207'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_207'>[207]</a><div class='note'><p> Griffith Wilkin, <i>British Medical Journal</i>, April 8, 1905.</p></div> + +<a name='5_Footnote_208'></a><a href='#5_FNanchor_208'>[208]</a><div class='note'><p> Weininger, <i>Geschlecht und Charakter</i>, p. 107. I may remark +that a recent book, Ellis Meredith's <i>Heart of My Heart</i>, is devoted to a +seemingly autobiographical account of a pregnant woman's emotions and +ideas. The relations of maternity to intellectual work have been carefully +and impartially investigated by Adele Gerhard and Helena Simon, who seem +to conclude that the conflict between the inevitable claims of maternity +and the scarcely less inevitable claims of the intellectual life cannot be +avoided.</p></div> + + + + +<a name='5_Page_230'></a> +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_APPENDIX'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_231'></a>APPENDIX.</h2> + +<h3>HISTORIES OF SEXUAL DEVELOPMENT.</h3> + +<div class='blkquot'><p><b>HISTORY I.—</b>The following narrative has been written by a + university man trained in psychology:—</p> + +<p> So far as I have been able to learn, none of my ancestors for at + least three generations have suffered from any nervous or mental + disease; and of those more remote I can learn nothing at all. It + appears probable, then, that any peculiarities of my own sexual + development must be explained by reference to the somewhat + peculiar environment.</p> + +<p> I was the first child and was, naturally, somewhat spoiled—a + process which tended to increase my natural tendency to + sentimentality. On the other hand, I was shy and undemonstrative + with all except my nearest relatives, and with them as well after + my seventh or eighth year. And here it may be well to describe my + "mental type," as this is probably the most important factor in + determining the direction of one's mental development. Of mental + types the "visual" is, of course, by far the most common, but in + my own case visual imagery was never strong or vivid, and has + constantly grown weaker. The dominant part has been played by + tactual, muscular and organic sensations, placing me as one of + the "tactual motor" type, with strong "verbal motor" and + "organic" tendencies. In reading a novel I seldom have a mental + picture of the character or situation, but easily imagine the + sensations (except the visual) and feel something of the emotions + described. When telling of any event I have a strong impulse to + make the movements described and to gesticulate. I remember + events in terms of movements and the words to be used in giving + an account of them; and in thinking of any subject I can feel the + movements of the larynx and, in a less degree, of the lips and + tongue that would be involved in putting my thoughts into words. + I am easily moved to emotion, even to sentimentality, but am + seldom if ever deeply affected and am so averse to any display of + my feelings that I have the reputation among my acquaintances of + being cold, unfeeling and unemotional. I am naturally quiet and + bashful to a degree, which has rendered all forms of social + intercourse painful through much of my life, and this in spite of + a real longing to associate with people on terms of intimacy. As + a child I was sensitive and solitary; later I became morbid as + well. In a character so constituted the feelings and impulses <a name='5_Page_232'></a>of + the moment are likely to rule, and such has been my constant + experience, though a large element of obstinacy in my character + has kept me from appearing impulsive, and slight influences will + bring about reactions which seem out of all proportion to their + cause. For instance, I cannot, even now, read the more erotic of + Boccaccio's stories without a good deal of sexual excitement and + restlessness, which can be relieved only by vigorous exercise or + masturbation.</p> + +<p> The first ten years of my life were passed on a farm, most of the + time without playmates or companions of my own age.</p> + +<p> As far back as I can remember I indulged in elaborate day-dreams + in which I figured as the chief character along with a few others + who were chiefly creatures of my imagination, but at times + borrowed from reality. These others were always boys until I + learned the proper function of the sexual organs, when girls + usurped the whole stage in numbers beyond the limits of a Turkish + harem. Even at school my day-dreams were scarcely interrupted, + for my shyness and timidity made me very unpopular among my + schoolmates, who tormented me after the fashion of small boys or + neglected me, as the spirit moved them. To make matters worse, I + was brought up under the "sheltered life system," kept carefully + away from the "bad boys," which category included nearly all the + youngsters of the community, and deluged with moral homilies and + tirades on things religious until I was thoroughly convinced that + goodness and discomfort, the right and the unpleasant, were + strictly synonymous; and I was kept through much of the time + facing the prospect of an early death, to be followed by the good + old orthodox hell or the equal miseries of its gorgeous + alternative. I may say in all seriousness that this is a + conservative and unexaggerated account of one phase of my early + life—the one, I think, that tended most strongly to make me + introspective and morbid. Later on, when I was trying to abandon + the habit of masturbation, this early training greatly increased + the despair I felt at each successive failure.</p> + +<p> The first traces of sexual excitement that I can now recall + occurred when I was about 4 years old. I had erections quite + frequently and found a mild pleasure in fondling my genitals when + these occurred, especially just after waking in the morning. I + had no notion of an orgasm, and never succeeded in producing one + until I was 13 years of age. In the summer of my sixth year I + experienced pleasurable sensations in daubing my genitals with + oil and then fondling or rubbing them, but I abandoned this + amusement after getting some irritating substance into the + meatus. A year later my mother warned me that playing with my + penis would "make me very sick," but since experience had taught + me that this was not true, my conviction that what was forbidden + must necessarily be pleasant, sent me directly to my favorite + retreat in the barn loft to experiment. Since, however, I failed, + in spite of persistent <a name='5_Page_233'></a>effort, to produce any such pleasant + results as I had expected, I soon gave up my attempts for other + kinds of amusement.</p> + +<p> A few months after this, in midsummer, a very sensual servant + girl began a series of attempts to satisfy herself sexually with + my help. She came nearly every day into the loft where I was + playing and did her best to initiate me into the mysteries of + sexual relationships, but I proved a sorry pupil. She would rub + my penis until it became erect and then, placing me upon her, + would insert the penis in her vulva and make movements of her + thighs and hips calculated to cause friction. At times she varied + the program by lying upon me and embracing me passionately. I can + remember distinctly her quick, gasping breath and convulsive + movements. She generally ended the seance by persuading me to + perform cunnilingus upon her. None of these performances were + intelligible to me and I invariably protested against being + compelled to leave my play to amuse her. Even her fondling of my + genitals annoyed me; and, stranger still, I preferred satisfying + her by cunnilingus to the attempts at coitus.</p> + +<p> It was nearly a year later that I experienced the first + unmistakable manifestations of the sexual impulse—erections + accompanied by lustful feeling and vague desires of whose proper + satisfaction I had no notion whatever. It never occurred to me to + associate my experiences with the servant girl with these new + sensations. The peculiar fact about them was that they were + generally occasioned by the infliction of pain upon animals. I do + not remember how I first discovered that they could be evoked in + this way, but I can clearly recollect many of my efforts to + arouse this pleasurable excitement by abusing the dog or the + cats, or by prodding the calves with a nail set in the end of a + broom handle. I seldom manipulated my genitals at this time, and + when I did it was for the purpose of causing sexual excitement + rather than allaying it.</p> + +<p> During this same year I got my first idea of sexual intercourse + by watching animals copulate; but my powers of observation must + have been limited, for I supposed that the penis of the male + entered the anus of the female. In watching the coitus of animals + I experienced lively sexual excitement and lustful sensations, + located not only in the genitals, but apparently in the anus as + well. I often excited, myself by imagining myself playing the + part of the female animal—a peculiar combination of passive + pederasty and bestiality. A servant girl put me to right on the + error of observation just mentioned, but neglected to apply the + principle to human animals, and I remained for another year in + complete ignorance of the structure of woman's sexual organs and + of the intercourse between man and woman. In the meantime I + cultivated my fancies of intercourse with animals, often still + perversely imagining myself taking the part of the female; and + the notion of such <a name='5_Page_234'></a>relationships gradually became so familiar as + to seem possible and desirable. This is especially significant in + view of later developments.</p> + +<p> Up to my eleventh or twelfth year the erotic element in my + daydreaming varied with the seasons. In the summer it played a + dominant part, while in the winter it was almost entirely absent, + owing, it may be, to the fact that most of my time was spent + indoors or on long, tiresome tramps to and from school, and the + further fact that during the winter I saw but little of the + animals which had acted as a stimulus to sexual excitement. So + little was I troubled in winter and so ignorant was I of normal + intercourse that sleeping with a cousin, a girl of about my own + age (7 or 8 years), resulted in no addition to my knowledge of + things sexual.</p> + +<p> It was early in my ninth year that I first learned something of + the anatomical difference between man and woman and of the + functions of the sexual organs in coitus. These were explained to + me by a young male servant, who, however, told me nothing of + conception or pregnancy. At first I was very little interested, + as it did not immediately occur to me to associate my own erotic + experiences with the matter of these revelations; but under the + faithful tuition of my new instructor I soon began to desire + normal coitus, and my interest in the sexual affairs of animals + weakened accordingly. His teachings went still further, for he + masturbated before me, then persuaded me to masturbate him, and + finally practiced coitus inter femora upon me. He also tried to + masturbate me, but was unable to produce an orgasm, though I + found the experiment mildly pleasurable.</p> + +<p> Early in my eleventh year we left the farm and lived in the city + for several months. In the meantime there had been no + developments in my sexual life beyond what has already been + indicated. In the city I found so much to interest and amuse me + that I almost entirely forgot my erotic day-dreams and desires. + Though my chief playmates were two girls of about my own age I + never thought of attempting sexual intercourse with them, as I + might easily have done, for they were much wiser and more + experienced in these things than myself. Shortly before the end + of our stay in town an older schoolmate explained to me as much + of the process of reproduction as is usually known by a + precocious youngster of 12 years, but I firmly refused to credit + his statements. He adduced the fact of lactation in proof of the + correctness of his views, but I had been too thoroughly steeped + in supernaturalism to be very amenable to naturalistic evidence + of this sort and remained obdurate. But the suggestion stayed + with me and perplexed me not a little; when we returned to the + farm I began to watch the reproductive process in animals.</p> + +<p> The following two years were decidedly unpleasant. I was growing + rapidly and was sluggish, awkward and stupid. At school I was + more <a name='5_Page_235'></a>unpopular than ever and seemed to have a positive genius + for doing the wrong thing. On the rare occasions when my + companions admitted me to their counsels I was a willing dupe and + catspaw, with the result that I was much in trouble with my + teachers. Being morbidly sensitive I suffered keenly under these + circumstances and, as my health was not at all good, I often made + of my frequent headaches excuses to stay at home, where I would + lie abed brooding over my small troubles or, more often, dreaming + erotic day-dreams and making repeated attempts to produce an + orgasm. But though these efforts were accompanied by the most + lustful thoughts and my imagination created situations of + oriental extravagance, I was 13 years old when they first met + with success. I remember the occasion very distinctly, the more + so because I thought of it much and bitterly when shortly + afterwards I tried to abandon a habit which the family "doctor + book" assured me must result in every variety of damnation. At + the moment, however, I was greatly surprised and gratified and + tried at once to repeat the delightful sensation, but was unable + to do so until the following day. From that time to the present I + think I have masturbated an average of ten times per week, and + this is certainly a very conservative estimate; for though up to + my sixteenth year I could seldom produce an orgasm more than once + a day I have often, during the last four or five years, produced + it from four to seven times per day without difficulty and this + for days and even weeks in succession. During these periods of + excessive masturbation very little liquid was ejaculated and the + pleasurable sensations were slight or entirely lacking.</p> + +<p> From the time when I began masturbating regularly practically my + whole interest centered in things pertaining to sex. I read the + chapters of the family "doctor book" which treated of sexual + matters; my day-dreams were almost exclusively erotic; I sought + opportunities to talk about sex-relationships with my + schoolmates, with whom I was now slowly getting on better terms; + I collected pictures of nude women, learned a great number of + obscene stories, read such obscene books as I could obtain and + even searched the dictionary for words having a sexual + connotation. Up to my fifteenth year, when ejaculation of semen + began, there was a strong sadistic coloring to my day-dreams. + Through this period, too, my bashfulness in the presence of the + opposite sex increased until it reached the point of absurdity.</p> + +<p> When fifteen years old I began to practice coitus inter femora on + my brother and continued it intermittently for about two years. + The experience was disappointing, for I had confidently expected + a great increase of pleasure over masturbation in this act; and + in casting about for some stronger stimulus I recurred to the + forgotten idea of intercourse with animals. I promptly tried to + put the idea to a test, but failed several times, and finally + succeeded, only to find that the result <a name='5_Page_236'></a>fell far short of my + expectations. Nevertheless I continued the practice irregularly + for about three years—or rather through that part of the three + years that I spent at home, for while I was at school opportunity + for such indulgence was lacking. Long familiarity with the idea + of intercourse with animals had made it impossible for me to feel + the disgust with the practice which it inspires in most people; + and even the perusal of Exodus xxii: 19 failed to make me abandon + it. Firmly as I believed in the Mosaic law the supremacy of the + sexual impulse was complete.</p> + +<p> As early as my sixteenth year I tried to abandon "self-abuse" in + all its forms and have repeatedly made the same effort since that + time but never with more than very partial success. On two or + three occasions I have stopped for periods of several weeks, but + only to begin again and indulge more recklessly than before. The + deep depression which followed each failure, and often each act + of masturbation, I attributed solely to the loss of semen, + leaving out of account the fact that I expected to feel depressed + and the utter discouragement and self-contempt which accompanied + the sense of failure and weakness when, in the face of my + resolution, I repeatedly gave way and yielded to the temptation + to an act whose consequences I firmly believed must be ruinous. I + am now convinced that by far the greater part of this depression + was due to suggestion and the humiliating sense of defeat. And + this feeling of moral impotence, this seeming helplessness + against an overpowering impulse which, on the other hand, seemed + so trivial when viewed without passion, eventually weakened my + self-control to a degree guessed by no one but myself and sapped + the foundations of my moral life in a way which I have constant + occasion to deplore.</p> + +<p> The foregoing paragraphs give, I think, a fair idea of my + condition when I left home for a boarding school at the beginning + of my seventeenth year. From this time my experiences may be said + to have run on in two distinct cycles—that of the summer months + when I was at home, and that of the remainder of the year when I + was at school. This fact will make some confusion and apparent + inconsistency in the rest of this "history" unavoidable. When I + left home I was shy, retiring, totally ignorant of social usage, + without self-confidence, unambitious, dreamy, and subject to fits + of melancholy. I masturbated at least once a day, though I was in + almost constant rebellion against the habit. In my more idle + moments I elaborated erotic day dreams in which there was a + peculiar mixture of the purely sensual and the purely ideal + element; which never fused in my experience, but held the field + alternately or mingled somewhat in the manner of air and water. + One person usually served as the object of my ideal attachment, + another as the center round which I grouped my sensual dreams and + desires.</p> + +<p> At school I found more congenial companions than I had fallen in + with <a name='5_Page_237'></a>elsewhere, and the necessary contact with people of both + sexes gradually wore off some of the rougher corners and brought + a measure of self-confidence. I had two or three incipient love + affairs which my backwardness kept from growing serious. Out of + this change of environment came a sense of expansion, of escape + from self, which was distinctly pleasant. I still masturbated + regularly, but no longer experienced the former depression except + when at home during vacation. Relatively to the past, life was + now so varied and interesting that I had less and less time for + melancholy; and the discovery that I could lead my classes and + hold my own in athletic sports seemed to indicate that my past + fears had been exaggerated. Nevertheless I was never reconciled + to the habit and often rebelled at the weakness that kept me its + slave.</p> + +<p> When I entered the university the effects of my useless struggle + with the practice of masturbation were pretty well developed. I + could no longer fix my attention steadily upon my work and found + that only by "cribbing" and "bluffing" could I keep my place at + the head of my classes. I was troubled not a little by the + shoddiness of my work, and tried again and again during the + course of the two years spent at this college to shake off the + habit. At the university I was introduced gradually to a wider + social circle and so far outgrew my bashfulness that I began to + seek the society of the opposite sex assiduously. As I gained + self-confidence I became reckless, getting at one time into + serious trouble with the authorities which came near resulting in + my expulsion. I became one of the more popular members of the + clique to which I belonged—much to my surprise and even more to + that of my acquaintances. The physical culture craze attacked me + at this time and my pet ambition was the attainment of strength + and agility. My bump of vanity also grew apace, but an unmeasured + hatred of all kinds of foppishness kept me on the safe side of + moderation in my dress and behavior.</p> + +<p> During my second year of university life I had two love affairs + in the course of which I found that my interest in any particular + member of the fair sex disappeared as soon as it was returned. + The pursuit was fascinating enough, but I cared nothing at all + for the prize when once it was within reach. I may add that the + interest I had in the girls was purely ideal. While at this + school I do not think I masturbated half as often as while at the + preparatory school.</p> + +<p> When I left this college for —— University I took with me a + formidable catalogue of good resolutions, first among which was + the determination to abandon all kinds of "self-abuse." I think I + kept this one about a month. As I had gone from a comparatively + small school to one of the largest of American universities the + change was great and the revelations it brought me frequently + humiliating. I was lonesome, home-sick, and my bump of + self-esteem was woefully bruised; and not <a name='5_Page_238'></a>unnaturally I soon + began to seek a partial solace in day-dreams and masturbation. + After I had become somewhat adapted to my new environment I + indulged less frequently in either, and from that time to the + present I have masturbated very irregularly, sometimes but little + and again to excess.</p> + +<p> Not long after I came to this place I met a young lady with whom + I soon became quite intimate. For over a year our friendship was + strictly platonic and then swung suddenly around to a sexual + basis. We were ardent lovers for a few weeks, after which I tired + of the game as I had before in other cases, and broke off all + relations with her as abruptly as was possible. Since then I have + almost wholly withdrawn from the society and companionship of + women and have almost entirely lost whatever tact and assurance I + once possessed in their company. Things pertaining to sexual life + have interested me rather more than less, but have occupied my + attention much less exclusively than before this episode. Though + I have never intended to marry, my breaking off relations with + this girl affected me much. At any rate it marked an abrupt + change in the character of my sexual experiences. The sexual + impulse seems to have lost its power to rouse me to action. + Hitherto I had practiced masturbation always under protest, as it + were—as the only available form of sexual satisfaction; while + now I resigned myself to it as all that there was to hope for in + that field. Of course I knew that a little effort or a little + money would procure natural satisfaction of my sexual needs, but + I also knew that I would never, under any ordinary circumstances, + put forth the necessary effort, and fear of venereal disease has + been more than enough to keep me away from houses of + prostitution.</p> + +<p> Some months ago I refrained from masturbation for a period of + about six weeks and watched carefully for any change in my health + or spirits, but noticed none at all. The only impulse to + masturbate was occasioned by fits of restlessness accompanied by + erections and a mildly pleasurable feeling of fullness in the + penis and scrotum. I think that over 75 per cent, of my acts of + masturbation are provoked by these fits of restlessness and are + unaccompanied by fancy images, erotic thoughts, lustful desires, + or marked pleasure. At other times the act is occasioned by + erotic thoughts and images, and is accompanied by a considerable + degree of lustful pleasure which, however, is never so intense as + in my earlier experiences and has steadily decreased from the + first. Usually the orgasm is accompanied by a strong contraction + of all the voluntary muscles, particularly the extensors, + followed by a slight giddiness and slight feeling of exhaustion. + If repeated several times in the course of a single day the acts + are followed by dullness and lassitude; otherwise the feeling of + exhaustion passes away quickly and a sense of relief and quiet + takes its place. So natural or rather habitual has this resort + <a name='5_Page_239'></a>to masturbation as a means of relief from nervousness and + restlessness become that the act is almost instinctive in its + unconsciousness.</p> + +<p> I am extremely sensitive to all kinds of sexual influences, and + have an insatiable curiosity regarding everything that pertains + to the sexual life of men or women. I am not, however, excited + sexually by conversation about sexual facts and relationships, no + matter what its nature, though in reading erotic literature my + excitement is often intense.</p> + +<p> The tendency to day dream has never left me, but there are no + longer any elaborate scenes or long-continued "stories," these + having been replaced by vaguely imagined incidents which are + usually broken off before they reach a satisfactory climax. They + are always interrupted by the intrusion of other matters, usually + of more practical interest; and the long-continued habit of + satisfying myself by masturbation has made erotic dreams rather + tantalizing than pleasurable. I dream very seldom at night—at + least I can scarcely ever remember any dreams upon waking—and + practically never of sexual relations. I have not had a nocturnal + emission for over three years, and probably not more than + twenty-five in my life.</p> + +<p> In my "love passages" with girls there has been no serious + thought of coitus on my part, and I have never had intercourse + with a woman—unless my early experiences with the servant girl + be called such. Like all masturbators I always idealized "love" + to the utter exclusion of all sensual cravings; and the notion + that the physical act of coitus was something degrading and + destructive of real love rather than its consummation was, of all + prejudices I have ever formed, the most difficult to escape—a + circumstance due, I suppose, to the fact that all I had ever been + taught on the subject tended to the complete divorce of what was + called "love" from what was stigmatized as a "base sensual + desire." Judging from my own experience and observation I should + say that "ideal love" is a mere surface feeling, bound to + disappear as soon as it has gained its object by arousing a + reciprocal interest on the part of the one to whom it is + directed. So little did I "materialize" the objects of my "love" + that I have never cared for kissing or the warm embraces in which + lovers usually indulge. I have never kissed but one girl, and her + with far too little enthusiasm to satisfy her. My last sweetheart + was a very passionate girl, the warmth of whose embraces was + somewhat torrid and, to me, both puzzling and annoying. The + intensity of feeling which demanded such strenuous expression was + beyond my knowledge of human nature. A somewhat peculiar + circumstance in connection with these experiences is the fact + that I often found myself trying to analyze my emotions with a + purely psychological interest while playing the part of the + intoxicated lover in his mistress's arms.</p> + +<p> There is but little left to say on the subject of my sexual + development. During the last two or three years my knowledge of + the facts of <a name='5_Page_240'></a>the sexual life has been very greatly increased, + and I have become acquainted with phases of human nature which + were wholly unknown to me before. The part played by things + sexual in my life is still, I suppose, abnormally large; it is + undoubtedly the largest single interest, though my outer life is + determined almost wholly by other considerations.</p> + +<p> Of course I know nothing of the effect which long-continued + masturbation may have had on my ability to perform normal coitus. + I do not think I am subject to any kind of sexual perversion, for + all my indulgence has been <i>faute de mieux</i> and, at least since I + began masturbation, all my desires and erotic day-dreams have had + to do only with normal coitus. The mystery which surrounds the + sexual act seems at times to be regaining its former influence + and power of fascination. I have no doubt, however, but that I + should be greatly disillusioned should I ever perform coitus; and + I greatly regret that I have not been able to test this + conviction and so round out and complete this "history."</p> + +<p> It may be worth while to say a word about my religious + experiences, as, in many cases, they are closely bound up with + the sexual impulse. I was never "converted," but on a dozen or + more occasions approached the crisis more or less closely. The + dominant emotion in these experiences was always fear, sometimes + with anger and despair intermixed in varying proportions. A + complete analysis of these experiences is, of course, impossible, + but the various pleasurable feelings of which converts spoke in + the revivals which I attended were a closed book to me. Following + my revival-meeting experiences came a few days spent in a sort of + moral exaltation during which I eschewed all my habits of which + conventional morality disapproved, save masturbation, and felt no + small satisfaction with my moral conditions. I became a + first-rate Pharisee. Toward the women who had figured in my day + dreams I suddenly conceived the chastest affection, resolutely + smothering every sensual thought and fancy when thinking of them, + and putting in place of these elements ideal love, + self-sacrifice, knightly devotion—Sunday-school Garden-of-Eden + pictures with a mediæval, romantic coloring. These day-dreams + were always sexual, involving situations of extreme complexity + and monumental silliness. Masturbation was always continued and + usually with increased frequency. The end of these periods was + always abrupt and much like awaking from a dream in which the + dreamer has been behaving in a manner to arouse his own disgust. + They were followed by feelings of sheepishness and self-contempt + mingled with anger and a dislike of all things having to do with + religion. My inability to pass the conversion crisis and a + growing contempt for empty enthusiasm finally led me to a saner + attitude toward religion, from which I passed easily into + religious scepticism; and later the study of philosophy and + science, and particularly of psychology, banished the last + lingering remnant <a name='5_Page_241'></a>of faith in a supernatural agency and led me + to the passion for facts and indifference to values which have + caused me to be often called "dead to all morality."</p> +<br /> + +<p> <b>HISTORY II.—</b>C. A., aged 25, unmarried; tutor, preparing to take + Holy Orders:—</p> + +<p> My paternal ancestry (which is largely Huguenot) is noteworthy + for its patriotism and its large families. My father, who died + when I was a year old, is remembered for the singular uprightness + and purity of his life from his earliest childhood. The + photograph which I have shows him as possessed of a rare classic + beauty of features. He was an ideal husband and father. At the + time of his death he was a Master of Arts and a school principal. + My mother is an extraordinarily neurotic woman, yet famed among + her friends for her great domesticity, attachment to her + husbands, and an almost abnormal love of babies. She has nobly + borne the ill-treatment of her second husband, who for several + years has been in a state of melancholia. My mother has been + "highly-wrought" all her life, and has suffered intensely from + fears of all kinds. As a young girl she was somnambulistic, and + once fell down a stairhead during sleep. In spite of her bodily + sufferings with indigestion, eye-strain, and depression she + retains her youthfulness. She has slight powers of reasoning. She + has had times of unconsciousness and rigidity, I have never heard + any mention of epilepsy. She has a horror of showing prudishness + in regard to the healthful manifestations of sex life, and is + always praising examples of what she terms "a natural woman."</p> + +<p> I have heard that during my first year my mother detected my + nurse in the act of putting a morphine powder on my tongue for + the purpose of keeping me quiet. I was subject to convulsions at + this period, and narrowly escaped a permanent hernia. My family + tell me that from the beginning I was a well-developed and boyish + boy, full of mischief, impulsive, good to look upon, unusually + affectionate, beloved by all.</p> + +<p> In my third year I took pleasure in crawling under the bed with + my boy-cousin who was nine months my senior, and after we had + taken down our drawers, in kissing each other's nates. I do not + remember which of us first thought of this pastime.</p> + +<p> At the age of 4 I gave myself a treat by gazing upward through a + cellar window at the nates of a woman who was defecating from + several feet above into a cesspool that lay beneath. It was + during this summer also that I frightened myself by pulling back + my prepuce far enough to disclose the purple glans, which I had + never seen before. But this act gave me no desire to masturbate.</p> + +<p> When 5 years old, and living in a great city, I drew indecent + pictures in company with a little girl and her younger brother. + These pictures <a name='5_Page_242'></a>represented men in the act of urinating. The + penes were drawn large, and the streams of urine plainly + indicated. One afternoon I induced the boy to go to the + bath-room, lie on his back, and allow me to perform <i>fellatio</i> on + him. I did not ask him to return the favor. I remember the + curious tar-like smell of his clothing and the region about his + genitals. It is possible that I gained my knowledge of <i>fellatio</i> + from an unknown boy of 10, who had induced me, during the + preceding summer to enter a sandy lot with him, watch him + urinate, and then, kneeling before him, commit <i>fellatio</i>. A year + later, as I was walking home in the rain to our summer cottage, + with an open umbrella over my shoulder, a boy of 15, who was + leaning against our fence, exhibited a large, erect penis, and + when I had passed him urinated upon me and my umbrella. I never + saw the boy again. I felt peculiarly insulted by his act. Back of + the house there lived a 12-year-old boy who invited me to watch + him defecate in the outdoor privy, and during the act told me a + number of indecent stories and words which I cannot remember.</p> + +<p> About this time I fell in love with a little Jewish boy next + door. Often I cried myself to sleep over the thought that perhaps + he was lying on a sofa alone and crying with a stomach-ache. I + longed to embrace him; and yet I saw little of him, and made + little of him when I was with him.</p> + +<p> Living in a Western city a few months later, some girls of 12 and + 14 led me to their barn, where they dressed themselves in boys' + clothing and made believe that they were cowboys. One of them + told me to "shut my eyes, open my mouth, and get a surprise." + When I opened my eyes once more a piece of hen-dung lay in my + mouth. I have a vague remembrance of one of the girls asking me + to enter a water-closet with her. She uttered some indelicate + phrase, but I performed no act with her. In the house where I + lived I once entered the bedroom of a half-grown girl while she + was dressing. She knelt to kiss me innocently enough, and I, by a + sudden impulse, ran my hand between her bare neck and her corset + as far as I could reach. Apparently she took no notice of my + movement. Although I did not masturbate, yet during this winter I + experienced a tickling sensation about my genitals when I placed + my hand beneath them as I lay on my stomach in bed. One evening I + pulled up my night-dress and, holding my penis in my hand, I + danced to and fro on the carpet. I imagined that I was one of a + line of naked men and women who were advancing toward another + similar line that faced them. I imagined myself as pleasurably + coming in contact with my female partner who possessed male + genitals.</p> + +<p> The following summer I lived in the woods. My next-door playmate + was a little girl of my own age—6 years. She sat down before me + in the barn and exposed her genitals. This was the first time I + had seen female organs, or had thought for a moment that they + differed from <a name='5_Page_243'></a>my own. In great perplexity I asked the little + girl: "Has it been cut off?" She and I defecated in peach baskets + that we found in the upper part of the barn.</p> + +<p> When I was 7 years old and back in the Eastern city I lived in + the house of a physician. Alone with his 3-year-old daughter one + day, I showed her my erect organ, and felt a delicious + gratification when she stroked it with the words: "Nice! Nice!" I + confessed my fault to my guardian that night after I had said my + prayers. I had complained to my mother a year before of the + inconvenience I found in my penis being "so long sometimes." She + said that she would "see about having the end taken off." But I + was never circumcised. Her words gave me the doubly unpleasant + impression that my <i>glans</i> was to be cut off.</p> + +<p> There came occasionally to the kitchen of Dr. W.'s house a + foul-mouthed Irish laundress who used coarse language to me + concerning urination. I loathed the woman, and yet one night I + dreamed that I was embracing her naked form and rolling over and + over with her on the bed; and in spite of my sight of female + genitals a few months before, I thought of her as having organs + of my own kind and size. At my first school I watched a + red-haired boy of 12 expose the penis of a 7-year-old boy as he + lay on his back in the bath-room. I do not remember that the + sight gave me sexual pleasure.</p> + +<p> I spent the summer before I was 8 in a double house. The adopted + daughter of our neighbor (a neurotic, retired physician) was a + girl of 13 who had been taken from a poor laboring family. She + got me to show her my parts, touched them, and asked whether I + urinated from my scrotum. She also induced me to play with her + genitals as we sat on a sofa in the twilight, and to spank her + naked nates with the back of a hair-brush as she lay on a bed; + but from none of these performances did I derive physical + satisfaction. The girl E. and I took delight in "talking dirty + secrets," as she expressed it. Her young cousin H. (nephew of her + adopted mother) never heard me use the word "thing" without + suggestively smiling. E. recalled the pleasant hours that she had + spent with her cousin when they were in their night-gowns. She + did not particularize these sexual relations. Under the + board-walk the boy H. and I once defecated in bottles. Some + little girls who lived opposite us pulled up their dresses one + night and "dared" each other to dance out beyond the end of the + house, in full view of the road. We boys merely looked on.</p> + +<p> I now fell passionately in love with a remarkably handsome little + boy of my own age. I longed to kiss and hug him, but I did not + dare to do so, for he was haughty and intolerant of my + attentions. I even allowed him to stand with one foot on me and + remark in a loud tone: "I am Conqueror!" I endured no end of + petty insults and much ill-treatment from this boy. I reached the + height of my passion on the <a name='5_Page_244'></a>night that he appeared at our + cottage in a tight-fitting suit of pepper-and-salt. I gloried in + his perfect legs and besought my guardian that she would buy me a + similar suit of clothes.</p> + +<p> For the summer after I was 8 years old I lived in a cottage in a + country town. The servant maid M. was a young girl of 16 who + listened eagerly to my accounts of the "secrets" and actions in + which the girl E. and I had taken delight a year before. I think + that M. arranged a meeting between a little black-haired girl and + me in order that we might take a walk and play sexually with each + other. Just as we were starting on our walk one of my relatives + said that I must not leave the yard.</p> + +<p> The little girl and I had see-sawed together and I had been + interested in her legs as she rose in the air. (When I was 13 + years old and see-sawing at a picnic with a stout girl, the + motion of the board and the sight of her straddled form filled me + with longing to embrace her sexually.) One afternoon M. took me + to the house of an acquaintance of hers. M's brother was in the + room and made a number of unremembered remarks which struck me as + being rather "free," and M. told me later that she and the girl + once dressed as ballet dancers and danced before M.'s brother. I + felt that he was lascivious. I was always remarkably intuitive.</p> + +<p> I fell in love with a handsome, stout, black-haired boy who lived + on a farm; but he was not a "farmer's son" in the common sense of + the word. I visited him for two or three days, and we slept with + each other, to my boundless joy. For his freckled girl cousin I + did not care the turn of my wrist, although she was a nice enough + little thing. One night when we three lay on a bed in the dark, + and neither of us boys had eyes or words for her, she silently + left us. He and I never committed the slightest sexual fault. I + left him with tears at the summer-end, and I often kissed his + photograph during the following winter.</p> + +<p> In the flat-house where I began to live when I was 8 years old, I + once practiced mutual tickling of a very slight character with a + boy of my own age. We sat on chairs placed opposite to each other + and we inserted our fingers through the openings in our trousers. + Just as we were beginning to enjoy the titillation we were + interrupted by the approach of one of my family who, however, was + not quick enough to discover us. Down cellar I often saw the + genitals of the janitor's little girls—they were fond of lifting + their skirts and they did not wear drawers—but I had no desire + to attempt conjunction. I once caught an older friend of mine (he + was 13) in the act of leaving one of the girls. The pair had been + in a coal-compartment. The boy was buttoning his trousers and I + guessed what he had been doing. When I began to sleep alone in my + tenth year I had no desire to masturbate, and was loath to do so + by reason of ample warnings given me by my guardian and by the + family physician. One afternoon a stunted friend of mine sat down + in <a name='5_Page_245'></a>the back yard and astonished me by tying a piece of string to + his penis. At a large private school which I now attended I made + the acquaintance of the principal's son, and wondered why he had + such a fancy for dressing his 5-year-old sister in boy's clothes. + He closed the door on me while he was thus engaged. At my house + we went to the bath-room together, and he showed me his + circumcised and much-ridged penis. Neither of us made any mention + of masturbating.</p> + +<p> At this period I fell slightly in love with a 5-year-old boy with + intensely black eyes. I would kiss him whenever we were alone, + but I had no wish to seduce him. I was always interested in + watching the urination of younger children. When I was 5 years + old I went on my knees to a strange little boy in order to + whisper in his ear an inquiry as to whether he wanted to urinate. + I experienced a pleasurable thrill when I was 10 years old in + leading a small girl cousin to the outdoor privy, in helping her + on and off the open seat, in buttoning and unbuttoning her + drawers, and in gazing at her vulva.</p> + +<p> The summer before I was 10 I lived a wild life in the mountains. + My companions were a negro girl, the two daughters of a + clergyman, the two sons of a questionable woman hotel-keeper, and + the daughter of the Irish scavenger. All of these children were + extraordinarily sensual. Their leading pastime, from morning + until night, was varying forms of indecency, with the supreme + caress—which they termed "raising dickie"—as the most frequent + enjoyment. The 5-year-old daughter of the scavenger explained to + us how she had seen her father approaching her stout mother with + an erect penis, the pair standing up before the lamplight during + the act. This curly-headed, rosy-cheeked child handled her + genitals so much that they were inflamed. I once saw her sitting + in the road and rubbing dust against her vulva. I saw little of + the elder daughter of the minister (she was 12 years old). She + persuaded me to expose myself before her in the cellar of a + partially-built house. In return for my favor she allowed me to + look at her genitals. She did not ask for <i>conjunctio</i>. The two + younger daughters were my intimates. With the middle one I was + forever performing a weak conjunction that consisted in the + laying of my member against her vulva. Notwithstanding all the + entreaties of my little friend, I could not be persuaded to + protrude my penis against her vagina; and not on one occasion can + I remember obtaining an erection or extreme pleasure. Up in the + garret she straddled slanting beams with her genitals exposed, + and I followed her example. The negro girl and my little friend + both urinated on a tent floor at my request. I did not fancy the + odor of a girl's genitals, nor the appearance of the vulva when + the labia were held apart.</p> + +<p> The following summer, when I was almost 11, I took a long walk + one day with my old friend, the girl E. We entered a patch of + woods and ate our lunch, but no sense of sexual drawing toward + the girl came <a name='5_Page_246'></a>over me and she did not offer to entice me. I + slept with her boy-cousin one night, and her neuropathic aunt, a + retired lady physician, bothered us by repeatedly creeping into + our room. I felt intuitively that she was watching to see whether + we would commit mutual masturbation—which we had no thought of + doing. Three years before I had opened the door of her bedroom + suddenly and saw E.'s naked form. The physician had been + examining her, E. told me later. My guardian also annoyed me by + repeated warnings not to play with myself.</p> + +<p> Just before I turned 11 I was sent to a small and so-called + "home" boarding-school. Eight of us lived in the smaller + dormitory. The matron roomed downstairs. There was no resident + master—a serious error. We small boys were told to strip one + evening. We were then tied neck-to-neck and made to dance a + "slave-dance," which was marked by no sexuality. A boy of 15, R., + one afternoon gave me the astonishing information that my father + had taken a part in my procreation. Up to this moment I had known + only of the maternal offices, information of which had been + beautifully supplied to me by my guardian when I was 7 years old. + At that time I talked freely about the coming of a baby brother + in a distant city; I watched the construction of baby clothes; I + named the newcomer, and I was momentarily disappointed when he + proved to be a girl. This same R., a strong boy with a large + penis, got into the custom of lying in bed with me just before + lights were put out. He would read to himself and occasionally + pause to pump his penis and make with his lips the sound of a + laboring locomotive. I felt impelled to handle his organ, for I + was fascinated by its size, and stiffness, and warmth. Rarely he + would titillate my then small and unerect penis. R. never + ejaculated when he was with me; hence not until my third year was + I acquainted with the appearance of a flow of semen. Sometimes R. + would stop during his dressing to manipulate his penis, but was + such a picture of rosy health that I doubt whether he brought + himself often to ejaculation. R. told me that he had been to a + brothel where his genitals were examined to determine whether + they were large enough and not diseased. He also related how he + "played cow" with a girl of his own age, she consenting to + perform <i>fellatio</i> upon him. A dark-skinned, unwashed, pimpled + but fairly vigorous boy of 16, with an irritable domineering + manner, told me the delights of coitus with a girl in a + bath-house, and I overheard his conversation with another "old" + boy concerning the purchase of a girl in a big city for the sum + of five dollars. No details were given.</p> + +<p> I will now pass to my third year, when I was 13 years old. A + large, well-set-up boy of 16, A., became my idol. His toleration + of my presence in his room filled me with endless love. When I + lied about a matter in which he was concerned, his denunciation + of me brought me to a state of shuddering and weeping + unspeakable. When our relations <a name='5_Page_247'></a>were established again A. + allowed me to creep into his bed after the lights were out, and + there I passionately embraced him, but without performing any + definite act. When I turned over on my side with my back to him + he drew my prepuce back and forth until I experienced orgasm, but + not ejaculation. I would return his favor by pumping his erect + penis, but with no ejaculation on his part. He did not propose + <i>fellatio</i>, and I did not think of it. One night when he was in + my bed I began to masturbate very slightly, whereupon he laughed, + saying: "So that is the way you amuse yourself!" As a matter of + fact the habit was not fastened upon me. He always laughed when + the rubbing of his finger on my exposed glans caused me to + shrink. Another boy, H., now began to show me his erect penis and + we practiced mutual manipulations. A. laughingly told me how me + had caught H. in the act of masturbating as he stood in the + bath-tub. A. told me a number of sexual stories—how he enjoyed + coitus in the bushes with a girl on the way home from + entertainments; how half a dozen boys and girls stripped in the + basement of a church and performed coitus on the velvet chairs + which stood behind the pulpit; and how he and a younger boy, who + camped out together, played with each other's genitals. F., a boy + of 11, was highly nervous, subject to timidity and tears on the + slightest provocation, often morose, and under treatment for + kidney trouble. His penis was erect whenever I saw him undress. + He told me that a partially idiotic man taught F. and his + companion how to masturbate. The man invited the boys to his tent + and there pumped his organ until "some white stuff came out of + it." F. also told me that an Indian princess in his part of the + country would permit coitus for fifty cents. A. sometimes slept + with F., and I could imagine their embraces. S., a secretive, + handsome boy of 13, wetted his bed with urine every night. The + only sign that he gave of an interest in sexuality was his + laughing remark concerning the coupling of rose-bugs. Of his + chum, my beloved C., I will speak later. My small room-mate + handled himself only slightly. I never had a desire to lie with + him, since I disliked him, nor with my first room-mate, a + "chunky," fiery boy of 10, whose penis interested me merely + because it was circumcised and almost always erect. His + masturbation was also so slight as not to attract any particular + attention. A lusty German boy, B., showed no signs of sexuality + until his third year, when he laughed about his newly-appearing + pubic hair, and told several of us openly of how he enjoyed to + play "a drum-beat" on his penis before going to sleep. "I don't + do it too much, though," he explained. He showed a mild curiosity + when I gave him the resumé of a book on cohabitation which + contained illustrations of the erect penis and the female organs. + I had found this book in the woods and I read it eagerly during + my third year.</p> + +<p> I came to the point of agreeing with A., who said: "Everyone is + <a name='5_Page_248'></a>smutty." Indeed I lived in a lustful world, and yet my mind was + bent also on books, and writing, and the outdoor world. I was + overgrown and splendidly developed, with a medium-sized penis and + a scant growth of pubic hair. My face wore a somewhat infantile + expression. My mouth was a perfect "Cupid's bow," my hair thin + and light. I was troubled about my snub-nose, which gave the boys + a great deal of amusement. As a matter of fact I exaggerated its + upward tendency out of my morbid self-consciousness and + cowardice. My imagination was extraordinarily intense, as it had + always been. I was sensitive to smells and sounds and colors and + personalities, and to the subtle influence of the night. I was + timid and easily moved to tears, but not from any physical + weakness until after. At the lower house there was the boy Z., + famed for his large penis; and the older G., a boy of 15, who was + the leader in sexuality at his dormitory. Z. showed me his penis + and exposed his glans often enough, but we did not manipulate + each other. G. told us to notice how large a space his penis + occupied in his trousers, and laughed over Z.'s custom of + masturbating by means of a narrow vase. G.'s special lover was a + nervous boy of ten. It is remarkable that none of us mentioned + <i>fellatio</i> or <i>pædicatio</i>. These acts may have occurred at + school, but not to my knowledge. We did not have much to say + sexually about the girls. We heard rumors of a 16-year-old, V., + who had been sent away from school for coitus; and my first + room-mate was said to have obtained <i>conjunctio</i> with a girl + under cover of the chapel shed. Once A. and I pointed a telescope + at the open windows of the girls' dormitory, but we saw nothing + to interest us. A day-scholar, J., a pale, nervous, bright boy of + 13, took me into the study of his uncle-physician and together we + gloated over pictures of the sexual organs. A. was with us on one + occasion. J. told me how he liked to roll over and over in bed + with his hand placed under his scrotum. This act, he said, made + him imagine that he was obtaining coitus. He advised me to slide + my penis back and forth in the vagina whenever I should actually + obtain coitus. In my room at school J. once drew an imaginary map + of a bagnio, in which the water-closet was carefully displayed + <i>en suite</i> with the bedrooms. J. and I never masturbated + together. Indeed, I cannot remember seeing his organ. A hulking + boy of 16, who lived opposite the school-grounds, became intimate + with J., and we three went on a walk up the railroad track. The + big boy, W., tried to inflame my passions by telling me how he + and J. had had coitus with a handsome black-haired widow in town, + but I remained cold.</p> + +<p> During this year I fell in love with C., a popular, talkative, + witty boy of my own age, or perhaps a year younger. He fancied me + and we slept together one night under the most innocent + circumstances. I never dreamed of having sexual relations with + him, and yet I fairly burned with love for him. My stay at his + beautiful home over Sunday while his <a name='5_Page_249'></a>parents were away was one + long delight. We slept in each other's arms, but there was no + sexuality. En route to C.'s home he pointed with a glove to a + little working-girl, saying he would like to have intercourse + with her, but this was the only remark of the kind that ever + passed his lips in my presence. When undressed save for his + undershirt, he laughingly held his unerect organ in his hand and + made the motions of obtaining conjunction with an imaginary + partner. Once we spoke of masturbation (I could recite the + information of my good physician with a marvelous show of + virtue), and C. remarked: "Yes, doing that makes boys crazy." C. + finally grew tired of my deceptive, babyish nature and + ultra-interest in books and puzzles, but I cherished an + undiminished affection for him, and when he was detained at home + for a fortnight with a broken arm, I wrote him a passionate + letter, which I sobbed over and actually wetted with my tears. + But the fervor of my passion died at the close of the year. I + consider this unsullied friendship to be the only redeeming + feature of my sensual days at school.</p> + +<p> Versed as I was in the warnings against masturbation, I found + pleasure one afternoon when I was alone in slipping my penis + through the open handle of a pair of scissors and in violently + flapping my partially erect organ until a strange, sweet thrill + crept over me from top to toe and a drop of clear liquid oozed + from my member. But I gave up the manipulation with scissors, + finding a greater satisfaction in masturbating while I was + defecating or just after it. I either pumped my organ by slipping + the prepuce back and forth, or I grasped the organ at its root + and violently jerked it back and forth. I soon began to + masturbate not only every time that I defecated, but also at + night just before I went to sleep, and sometimes early in the + morning. On the whole I preferred the jerking just described. I + always brought about ejaculation after perhaps five minutes of + violent exertion.</p> + +<p> My penis became chafed at the root, but I did not especially + care. I remember the afternoon that I masturbated for the first + time while I was defecating in the school water-closet. I cannot + recall that at first I thought of coitus while I masturbated. On + one occasion I masturbated over the <i>vase de nuit</i> after a + delightful afternoon of tobogganing exploration up and down the + mountain.</p> + +<p> During this first year of abuse, I felt no ill effects + whatsoever, although I realized, in an unthinking way, that I was + doing wrong. But sexuality had assumed the proportion of a + regular feature of our school life. It was difficult for me to + place a "universal" view in its true perspective. I used to smile + at the glazed, dull morning eye of poor H., who was a stunted boy + of 15, and thus could not endure his losses so well as I could + endure them. The qualms of conscience which I suffered were lost + in my delight in my dawning sexual life. Sometimes I lay on my + stomach in bed, and by placing my hand under my scrotum, + according to <a name='5_Page_250'></a>the directions of J., brought up a pretty girl to + mind. Just before Sunday school G., our chief reprobate, and the + rest of us would hunt out what we considered to be nasty texts of + Scripture. The chapter concerning the whoredoms of Aholah and + Aholibah gave me an especial pleasure. T. mentioned the giggling + that occurred at prayers in the lower dormitory when the details + of Esau's birth were read out. A few days before G. was + expelled—for exactly what cause I do not know—he told me of how + greatly he enjoyed coitus on his grandmother's sofa with a girl + of fifteen. When I went home on the boat for holidays I noted the + large, black-haired penis of the strong boy of our school. He + occupied a state-room with me, but made no sexual overtures.</p> + +<p> Since my twelfth year I had been wrapped up all summer long in a + boy who was six months my senior. We slept together constantly, + but not once did we think of obtaining mutual gratification. On + the contrary, we held up high ideals to each other and frowned on + masturbation. I took delight in saying that I never had handled + myself, and never would do so. Even at the height of my + "auto-erotic" period, I skillfully concealed my habits from all + my boy friends. A neurotic solo choir boy friend once spoke of + obtaining ejaculation, whereupon I expressed utter ignorance of + such an act, little hypocrite that I was. This boy told how the + house servants joked with him about coitus and made laughing + lunges at his organs.</p> + +<p> But much as I loved my chum, my most passionate regard went out + in my thirteenth year to N., a chubby, blue-eyed, choir-boy of + 12. He was a pretty boy to any eye. He was not gifted, except in + water-sports, and anything but popular either with girls or with + boys; yet I grew warm at the mention of his name. He did not care + a fig for me. From first to last I had no consciousness of the + sexual nature of my passion, and the thought of doing more than + embrace and kiss him in an innocent manner never crossed my mind. + For two summers I had nights of tossing on my bed (although I + almost never was sleepless for any cause) when I would see his + dear face and form, in and out of the swimming pool, or engaged + perhaps in singing or in showing his beautiful teeth. I seldom + was smitten with little girls, and I found myself embarrassed in + their company after my ninth year; yet I thought well enough of + their looks and ways to enjoy their company at dances. The girls + liked me in a platonic way, for I was accounted a good, big, + kind, blundering boy with a helping hand for the smallest fry.</p> + +<p> During the summer after I was 13, I imagined myself in the early + morning, when I was half awake, as persuading my wife to have + coitus with me. In the course of my spoken words I kept my hand + under my scrotum.</p> + +<p> A plump girl-cousin of my own age was visiting at my uncle's + during the summer after I was 13. With her I greatly desired to + <a name='5_Page_251'></a>satisfy myself, but I could not be sure that my boy cousin (5 + years old) might not find us out, even though she should consent. + Once when we three were in the hay-loft a wave of lust rolled + over me, but I made no proposal. Night and gaslight greatly + increased my <i>libido</i>. On one occasion my aunt had gone to the + village for ice-cream, and L. and I were left alone in the + dining-room. I took her on my lap and had a powerful erection. I + almost asked her to play sexually with me in the barn, but + instead I spoke of an imaginary girl, the first letters of whose + successive names spelled an indecent word for coitus—a word + known to almost every Anglo-Saxon child, I fear. L. laughed, but + gave no sign of assent. For a neighboring girl of 15 I felt such + a drawing that early in the morning I would roll on the floor + with my erect organ in my hand in riotous imagining of coitus + with her. I walked with her in the woods and sat at her feet, but + although I felt instinctively that she would satisfy me without + much persuasion, yet I <i>could not</i> ask her. One night I started + to church in order to walk home with her, and lead her (if + possible) to a field where we might gratify ourselves (I picked + out the exact grassy spot where we might lie); but when I was + almost at the church door my "moral sense" (if that is what it + was) rose and dragged me home again.</p> + +<p> During the swimming hour I watched the genitals of the boys, + comparing them carefully in the most minute details. Circumcised + organs affected me as being disagreeable, and men's hairy, coarse + genitals I abhorred.</p> + +<p> When 13 I became acquainted with the new mail-boy at the inn. He + was a city "street-boy," and got me into smoking cigarettes + occasionally. I did not definitely take up smoking until I was + 16. He told me that a mason once offered him ten cents if he + would masturbate the man in a cellar. The boy said that he + refused. I slept a few times with an ill-favored boy of fine + parentage. He was of my own age, and I had played with him in a + natural way for several years, but my increasing sexual desires + led me to mutually masturbate with him, and even unsuccessfully + to attempt with him mutual pædicatio. On the morning after our + nights of sensuality I felt "gone" and miserable, but not + repentant. By afternoon I was myself again. My relations with G. + were purely animal, for I disliked his jealous disposition, his + horse-laugh, his features, his form, his withdrawn scrotum and + his undersized penis. At home in the evening I often found myself + inflamed with a mental picture of active <i>fellatio</i> with him, but + I never performed this act, so far as I remember.</p> + +<p> One of my great sexual desires was to walk along a fence on which + a girl was seated. In order that I might feast my eyes on her + pudenda she must not wear drawers.</p> + +<p> When I turned 14 I had been, from my unusual size, in long + trousers <a name='5_Page_252'></a>for several months. I entered a private day-school and + progressed brilliantly in my studies. I kept up masturbation + almost daily, sometimes twice a day, both in the water closet and + in bed. I can remember ejaculating before urination in the school + <i>cabinet</i>. At night I often found myself longing for the return + of my sister, seven years my junior, in order that I might + embrace her in bed and fondle her genitals. I had done these + things during my Christmas vacation of the year before. I mildly + reproached myself for such incestuous desires, but they recurred + continually. I dreamed little. And I cannot remember the + character of my dreams. My waking <i>libido</i> spent itself mostly in + longings to embrace (without lustful acts) the forms of little + boys of exquisite blonde beauty and thick hair. Narcissism may + have been present, for in my twelfth year I had been told that at + the age of 5 and 6 I was an extraordinarily beautiful little + creature with long, lint-white hair. The preferable age was from + 6 to 9. My eye was alert on the streets for boys answering to + this description, and a street boy with long, white hair so won + my passion that I followed him to his home and asked his mother + if he might call on me and "play some games." As I did not even + know the boy's name and had never seen him before, I was + wonderingly refused. I sought in vain to find the whereabouts of + another long-haired street boy whom I burned to embrace and load + with benefits. I had a boundless desire for such a boy as this to + idolize me—to look into my face out of big eyes and lose himself + in love for me—to call me by endearing pet names—of his own + accord to throw his arms around my neck. This second actual boy + disappeared from my horizon by presumably moving away from the + vast city neighborhood. I took a fancy to a small boy at school, + who possessed the requisite delicacy, timidity, and sweetness, if + not the physical requisites, of my beau ideal. I walked with him + in the park and planned to have him at the house; but the matter + was not arranged. At boarding-school I had associated much with + younger and weaker boys, and had been ridiculed much for my + cowardice in sports, but at the city school I moved with my + equals and won their recognition. Our gymnasium director was + middle-aged and of an indolent disposition. He liked to recall + his youthful erections and to answer my sexual queries too fully, + and cheerfully volunteered information on brothels. Yet I doubt + whether he had an evil purpose in conversing with me. I thought I + should never dare or want to enter one. I always conjured up the + picture of a row of naked women from whom I could take my pick, + and the smell of the women I imagined to be identical with the + smell of my big friend A. at boarding-school. When I was + traveling down town on an elevated train one afternoon the + brakeman asked me whether I had ever been in a brothel, and told + me that disorderly houses abounded in my neighborhood. "I have + had connection with women," said this red-haired young man, + waving his hand <a name='5_Page_253'></a>in greeting to a woman who nodded at him from a + window, "since I was 15 years old. Not long ago a fine-looking, + young woman in black offered to pay all my expenses if I would + live with her and connect with her."</p> + +<p> When a girl of perhaps 7, a distant cousin of mine, visited us + for a few days, I gratified my lust by placing my hand under her + genitals and swinging her to and fro. She giggled with pleasure. + That summer I began to experience the evil effects of the + masturbation which I had practiced daily for a year and a half. + Pimples began to break out on my chin (my complexion up to this + time had been white and delicate). The family ascribed my + condition to digestive difficulties. In playing with the boys and + girls I found myself seized with a terrible shyness and a + tendency to look down and weep. I had lost all the courage I + had—it had never been great—in the presence of a crowd of + children. I was fairly at ease with a single companion. My + self-consciousness was something more painful to me than I can + convey in words. At home I wept in my room and cursed myself for + a baby. I little realized the cause of my nervous collapse. Yet I + had too robust a frame not to be able to sleep and to play hard. + The sympathetic pleasure which I had found in swinging my + girl-cousin to and fro I now doubled by letting a 7-year-old boy + ride cock-horse on my feet. I experienced an erection during the + process, and I almost induced ejaculation when I tickled the boy + with my feet in the region of his genitals. To see his shrinking, + giggling joy gave me an exquisite sexual thrill. I longed to + sleep with the boy, but I was afraid of causing comment. At the + new and large boarding school which I entered in the fall my most + lustful dreams and ejaculations were concerned with standing this + little boy on the footboard of a bed, taking down his + knickerbockers, and performing <i>fellatio</i> on him. But I dreamed + also of natural coitus. I fell in love with the handsome, + 12-year-old son of the aged headmaster. The boy, O., sat next me + at the table, and I never tired of gazing at him. It gave me a + special sense of pleasure to look at him when he wore a certain + flowing, scarlet, four-in-hand necktie. But O. was not attracted + to me—for one thing I was in a disagreeably pimpled + condition—and I could not induce him to linger in my room nor to + sleep with me. My passion for O. did not diminish, and it rose to + its supremacy on the evening when he appeared in our hallway (he + roomed on the girls' side of the house and hinted at the sexual + sights that he saw) in a costume of white satin, lace, and wings. + He was ready for a costume party.</p> + +<p> I now masturbated less frequently, for I was beginning to + appreciate the horrible consequences of my indulgence. I had + frequent pollutions, with dreams. My day was one long agony of + fear. How I dreaded to go to sleep in the same bed with my older + chum, who never made any advances beyond embracing me passively + <i>cum erectione</i> while he was asleep. My day was one long agony of + fear. At meal time my feet <a name='5_Page_254'></a>constantly writhed in agony for fear + that the headmaster's grown up young ladies should make fun of + me, or that my lack of facial composure and my inability to look + people in the eye might be commented upon. I tingled with + apprehension, especially in the region of my stomach. Every nerve + was taut in the effort I made to appear composed. I masturbated + with erections over nothing. Greek recitations were for me an + <i>auto da fe</i>. My heart beat like a trip-hammer at the thought of + getting up to recite, and once on my feet my voice shook and my + mind wandered. I hated the thought of people behind me looking at + me. I rarely summoned the courage to turn my head either one way + or the other. I vastly admired the "bravery" of the small, + 15-year-old boy who recited so calmly and so well. I was too + cowardly to play foot-ball and base-ball, and I dreaded even my + favorite tennis because the spectators put me in a state of + scared self-consciousness. Knowing my own condition, I was yet so + blind to it most of the time, and such a Jekyll-and-Hyde, that I + actually pitied a boy of 19 who was an eccentric and a scared + victim of masturbation. But in spite of my neuropathic condition + I developed intellectually. I do not touch upon this aspect of my + life, however, because I am trying to limit myself strictly to + sexual manifestations. At the present time I have not the courage + to continue the narrative.</p> +<br /> + +<p> <b>HISTORY III.—</b>The following narrative is written by a clergyman, + age 40, unmarried:—</p> + +<p> My childhood and early boyhood were unmarked by sexual phenomena, + beyond occasional erections, which commenced when about 5 years + of age, without any exciting causes. These were accompanied by + some degree of excitement, of the same nature as that which I + experienced in later years. I was absolutely ignorant of sexual + matters, but always had an idea that the essential difference + between man and woman was to be found in the genital organs. This + was sometimes a matter for thought and curiosity.</p> + +<p> Being for many years an only child I saw little of other + children, and formed the habit of amusing myself with making + things—boats, houses, etc.—and acquired a taste for science. + When I could read I preferred biography, history, and poetry to + anything else.</p> + +<p> When I was 13 years old and at a large school I heard for the + first time of coitus, but very imperfectly. For a few days it + filled my thoughts and mind, but feeling it was too engrossing a + subject and one which took me off better things, I put it out of + my mind. Later, another boy gave me a fuller description of the + matter, and I began to have a great desire to know more and to be + old enough to practice it. I also discovered that boys + masturbated, and about a year after tried <a name='5_Page_255'></a>the experiment for + myself. This vice was largely indulged in by my school-fellows. + It never occurred to me that it was sinful, until I was nearly + 16, when I came across a passage in Kenns's <i>Manual of + Schoolboys</i>, in which it was hinted such things were wrong + morally and spiritually. Previously I had felt it was an + indelicate and shameful thing, and bad for health. This last idea + was held as a solemn fact by all my boy friends. Gradually + religion began to exert an influence over my sexual nature, + obtaining as years passed a greater and greater restraining + power. It is simply impossible for me to write a history of my + sexual development without also describing the action which + Christianity has had in determining its growth. The two have been + so intimately bound together that my life history would not be a + faithful record of facts if I left religion out of it.</p> + +<p> At school I took part, with great keenness, in cricket and + foot-ball, and was very ambitious to excel in everything in which + I took an interest, but I always had other tastes as well, which + were more precious to me, for example, the love for science, + history, and poetry. Until I was past 16 years my desire was + simply for coitus, girls and women attracted me only as affording + the means of gratifying this desire; but when I was nearly 17 I + began to regard girls as beautiful objects, apart from this, and + to desire their love and companionship. At the same time it + dawned upon me that life held much of joy in the love of women + and in domestic life—so henceforth I regarded them in a higher + and purer light, and apart from sexual gratification. In fact, + from this period till I was over 20, this idea so dominated my + whole being that the lower side of my nature was entirely held in + subjection and abeyance by it. It was rather repulsive to think + of girls as objects of lust. This state of mind was not brought + about by any romantic attachment or through any acquaintance or + through circumstances. I was living in great seclusion and had no + girl friends. After this period the lower side of my nature woke + up as a giant refreshed with wine, and I underwent for many years + a constant struggle with my nature, in which religion always + triumphed in the end. I never fell into fornication, though + sometimes into the vice of masturbation. These outbursts of + desire were periodic, about ten or fourteen days apart, and would + last several days. I must record also the fact that from the time + this awakening took place my ideal views of woman no longer + seemed incompatible with sexual relations. I noticed that at + about 27 there was a lessening of the desire, but that may have + been due to overwork and consequent nervous exhaustion. I had a + good deal of worry and studied daily for about eight hours. In + any case the impulse was strongest during the years above + mentioned. A little later in life, for a time, I became attached + to a girl, and eventually engaged. I then observed, greatly to my + sorrow and annoyance, that whenever I met this lady, or even + thought of her, <a name='5_Page_256'></a>erections took place. This was particularly + painful to me, as my thoughts were not of a lustful or impure + character. Sometimes sitting by her at a religious service this + would occur, when certainly my mind was far away from anything of + the kind. That was the first woman ever kissed by me, except of + course members of my immediate family circle. Later on my + thoughts turned to marriage, and there was a great longing at + times for this event to take place. However, as this attachment + afterward became the great sorrow of my life for years, it needs + no more comment. This closes one chapter of my history, and at + present I do not propose to add another, as in a great measure it + is only partly written. It may be well here to state that there + has never been in me the slightest homosexual desire; in fact it + has always appeared as a thing utterly inconceivable and + disgustingly loathsome. I am fond of the society of both men and + women, but on the whole prefer the latter. I have had several + warm and intimate though platonic friendships, and get on + exceedingly well with the other sex, although not a good-looking + man. I have always been attracted to women by their spiritual or + mental qualities, rather than by physical beauty, and feel + strongly that the latter alone would never cause me to desire + coitus. Unless there was an attraction other than that of the + flesh, I should feel that I was following simply a brute + instinct, and it would jar with my higher nature and cause + revulsion. This was not the case in my earlier years to the same + extent. I have often wondered whether the sexual impulse was + strong in me or not, but if not, there is nothing in my physical + state or family history to account for it. I am fairly cognizant + with the lives of my ancestors, being descended from two old + families. The sexual instinct was certainly not weak or abnormal + in them. Personally, I am tall and healthy, well built, but + sensitive and highly strung. Smell has never played any part in + my life as a stimulant of sexual desire, and the mere thought of + body odors would have a very decided effect in the opposite + direction. Touch and sight appeal to me strongly, and of the two + the former most.</p> + +<p> I am convinced, after many years careful thought, that sexual + vice and perversion could be greatly reduced if the young were + instructed in the elements of physiology as they bear on this + question. Personally, had I been thus enlightened much sin would + have been avoided in my schoolboy days, and a perverted view of + sexual matters would never have arisen in my mind. It took years + to overcome the feeling that all such things were unclean and + defiling. Eventually light came to me through reading a passage + in a tractate on the Creed by Rufinus. He was defending the + doctrine, of the Incarnation against the pagan objection that it + was an unclean and disgusting idea that God should enter the + world through the womb of the Blessed Virgin Mary, and he meets + it by showing that God created the sexual organs, therefore the + objection <a name='5_Page_257'></a>is invalid—otherwise God would not be clean or pure, + having Himself designed them and their functions. This passage is + slight in itself, but gave birth to a line of thought which has + influenced me profoundly. I no longer regard sexual matters as + disgusting and unholy, but as intensely sacred, being the outcome + of the Divine Mind. Further, the Incarnation of the Saviour has + not only sanctioned motherhood and all that is implied by it, but + has eternally sanctified it as the means chosen for the + manifestation of God to the world. I should not obtrude my + theological conceptions, but for the fact that they have + determined my life-history in that aspect.</p> +<br /> + +<p> <b>HISTORY IV.—</b>When I was 9 years old a boy at the preparatory + school, which I attended, showed me the act of masturbation, + which he said he had practiced for a long time, and which he + urged me to imitate, if I wished to become a father when I grew + up, and married! Boy-like I believed him and tried, but the + sensation obtained was not a pleasant one (I suppose that I was + too rough with myself) and I desisted.</p> + +<p> When I was about 12 years old, a schoolfellow told me that he had + seen his nurse copulating with the groom, and he and I used to + haunt the woods in the hope that we might see an amorous couple + so engaged, but without success. We often talked of the act, as + to how it was done. Neither he nor I had any clear ideas on the + subject, save as to the organs involved. I was about 15 when a + maidservant of the house in which I was a boarder, came to my + bedroom one night and taught me how to masturbate her. She said + that this was a good thing for me to do, and warned me never to + "play with myself" as it would kill me, or drive me mad. I told + her that I had tried it, but could not bring on a pleasurable + feeling, so she did it to me, and although I did not have an + emission, I derived great pleasure from the act. She told me that + it never did a boy any harm to let a girl play with his parts, + and promised that if I would keep the secret, she would often do + this for me. Naturally I promised to say nothing, and she often + came up to my room. Later on she used to insert my penis into her + vulva, while she was rubbing it, at the same time giving me a + pigeon kiss. This <i>modus operandi</i> was much appreciated by me. + One night, after we had been together thus, I dreamt of her and + her maneuvers and had my first emission. I was very proud of + this, as I considered that I had at last attained to man's + estate, and told her of it. She never allowed me to insert my + penis into her vulva after that, alleging that she did not want + to have a baby.</p> + +<p> I was about 16½ years old when I had my first real coitus, my + partner in the act being a girl some two years older than I, who + lived near us. I enjoyed the act very much, as she permitted, nay + insisted on, emission <i>intra vaginam</i>, and told her that this was + much nicer than my <a name='5_Page_258'></a>amours with the maidservant which of course I + had confided to her. She laughed, and said: "Of course." We often + copulated, as long as I was at home, and then I lost sight of + her. Of all the women with whom I have had to do, save one, she + had the most copious secretion of mucus, which in those days I + believed was the woman's semen. Her thighs used to be wet with + it.</p> + +<p> At the University I had regular relations with women of all + sorts, rarely missing a week. Two of them were married women, one + the wife of a solicitor, the other of a doctor. How proud I felt + of my first intrigue with a married woman! I felt that I was + really a man of the world now!</p> + +<p> But though my friends used to tell me all about their love + affairs, and I longed to confide in them, I did not do so. This + was because when I went up to the University, my uncle said that + he would give me a word of advice and hoped that I would follow + it—never to give away a woman, and never to refuse to respond to + a woman's advances, whoever she were. To neglect this advice + would, he said, be foolish, and to break the rules "damned + ungentlemanly." I wish I had always followed advice proffered, as + closely as I have followed this. One night, when I was somewhat + disguised in liquor, as our grandfathers would have put it, I + picked up a girl, who was a private prostitute, if the phrase be + permissible. She declined copulation, and proposed other means of + satisfaction. I insisted, being stubborn in my cups. Had I been + sober I should have done as she suggested, for I have always made + it a point to allow the woman to choose the method of + gratification, and not to demand, or even suggest, anything + myself. I like to please women, and I have always been curious as + to their wants and desires, as revealed, without outside + influence, by themselves. The result of my refusing all methods + of gratification save the most ordinary was that the girl, who + must have known that she was not all right, but shrank from + saying so in so many words, gave me a gonorrhœa, which + lasted nine weeks and much interfered with my amours, as I + naturally declined to run the risk of infecting my partner, a + risk which to my certain knowledge many a young fellow has run, + with disastrous consequence to the confiding woman. As it was due + to my tipsy obstinacy, I could not blame the girl, but resolved + never to drink too much again, a resolve which I have kept, save + once, unbroken. In those days we youngsters thought that it was + manly to be able to carry one's liquor well, and did all in our + power to attain to the seasoned head; but I considered that the + risks entailed were too serious to be neglected.</p> + +<p> I was well on in my 26th year when I met a widow with whom I fell + in love, with the result that I married her. She is a most + sensible woman, and it was her intellectual gifts which were the + attraction to me. In my amours intellect has never played a part. + She has all along been <a name='5_Page_259'></a>cognizant of, and lenient to, my + polygamous tendencies; for she recognizes the fact that whatever + <i>fredaine</i> I may have on hand makes not the slightest difference + in my love and respect for her. Were she a more sensual woman, + perhaps things would be different.</p> + +<p> In all I have had to do with 81 other women, of whose special + characteristics I kept a careful note at the time. Twenty-six + were normal women with whom my <i>liasons</i> have lasted long, so I + know more about them than I do about the other fifty-five, who + were prostitutes, and with some of whom my dealings were but for + an afternoon.</p> + +<p> The races represented have been these, for I have seen a bit of + the world: English, Scotch, Irish, Welsh, French, German, + Italian, Greek, Danish, Hungarian, Roumanian, Indian, and + Japanese. Taking them all round, the only difference that I found + between old and young women is that the older ones are less + selfish, and more complaisant, and less inclined to resent one's + being unable to attain to the height of their desire, for from + time to time I have been unable to "come up to the scratch" after + a heavy night's labor, or when I was afraid of being caught in + the act of coition, a fear which, in my experience, acts as a + stimulus to desire in women, unlike its action in men. Of all the + women with whom I have had to do the nicest in every way have + been the French women. The English women of the town drink too + much, and are far too keen on getting as much money as they can + for as little as they can, to please me. Were the London girls to + recognize that men do not like a tipsy woman, and that where + there is so much competition the person who is most skillful and + most polite gets the most custom, the alien invasion in Regent + street would soon come to an end.</p> + +<p> Of the fifty-five prostitutes: eighteen informed me that they + were in the habit of masturbating; eight of their own free will, + without asking for reward, did <i>fellatio</i>; six asked me to do + <i>cunnilingus</i>, which I naturally declined to do; three proposed + anal coitus. Of those who did <i>fellatio</i>, two (one French and one + German) told me that they had taken to it because they had heard + that human semen was an excellent remedy against consumption, + which disease had carried off some of their relatives, and that + they had gradually come to like doing it. All who told me that + they masturbated, asked me whether I did so too, and two desired + me to show them the act, one alleging that she liked to see a man + do it; she had been married late in life, after a "stormy youth" + and had had, she said, a large experience of the male sex. They + all seemed to think that however much the practice of + self-excitement might hurt a man, and all thought that it would + hurt him, a woman might masturbate as often as she liked, failing + better means of satisfaction, as she had no such loss of + substance as a man.</p> + +<p> Of the twenty-six normal women, whom I knew more intimately than + I did the fifty-five prostitutes, thirteen, without being + questioned <a name='5_Page_260'></a>by me, blurted out the fact that they were habitual + masturbators, apparently all required to think of the loved + person to obtain full satisfaction. <i>Fellatio</i> was proposed, and + fully performed, by nine, of whom three experienced the orgasm as + soon as they perceived that I had attained to it. All were more + or less excited while doing it. One proposed anal coitus, "just + to see what it was like;" and three proposed <i>cunnilingus</i>, one + having been initiated by a girl friend, and one by her husband. + The third had, I believe, evolved the act out of her own inner + consciousness in her desire to experience pleasure with me. My + relations with one of the twenty-six were confined to my + masturbation of her, the while she did <i>fellatio</i>, as she said + that she "had no feeling inside down there."</p> + +<p> With two exceptions my partings from these normal women have not + been tragic and all whom I have met in after life (seven) have + been very ready to resume relations with me, four of them having + made the proposal themselves.</p> + +<p> One thing has struck me, and that is the, often great, difference + that exists between what a woman's looks lead one to think she + is, and what she is when one becomes her lover; the most sensual + woman that I have met might have sat for her portrait as the + Madonna, and she was the only one who took pleasure in hearing + and relating "smoking-room stories," a form of amusement which, + perhaps from their want of appreciation of humor and wit, women + do not indulge in—at least in my experience.</p> +<br /> + +<p> <b>HISTORY V.—</b>(A continuation of History III in Appendix B to the + previous volume.)</p> + +<p> As I became better I commenced to dream of true love. I wondered, + too, if my horrible past really could be lived down and a young + woman come to love <i>me</i>. I took pleasure in reading love poems, + especially Browning's, and illustrated some with little + water-colors....</p> + +<p> I was sitting in the stalls one night seeing a performance by a + company of English actors when one of them played so badly that I + thought to myself: "Why, hang it, I could play it better myself!" + The next minute another thought followed: "Why not try?" I came + out of the stalls the proverbial stage-struck youth. I was + sitting in the same place another night when the young man next + to me entered into conversation. By a strange coincidence he knew + a few young men, amateurs, who were going to form a company, give + up their situations and travel, if they could induce a few more + to join them and put a little money in. I made an appointment for + the following evening....</p> + +<p> There were lots of meetings in bedrooms and rehearsals between + the beds, but ultimately I was told a school-room had been + engaged and <a name='5_Page_261'></a>a professional actress, A. F. I went to the + school-room and found all the boys there, and a young woman with + a pale, rice-powder complexion. On introduction she gazed at me + as if struck dumb. If she had been better-looking (I thought her + vulgar and puffy) I would have been flattered. I was + disappointed, but rather frightened (she had a stage presence) of + her professional ability, especially when we commenced to + rehearse. I had to make love to her, too, which embarrassed me. + She had a good profile, I noticed, and would have been better + looking, I thought, if she were in better condition, for she was + young, about my own age, twenty-three or four. We were all + young—enjoyed our rehearsals, and had lots of fun—but I did not + respond to the advances A. was evidently making to me. Finally we + started on our tour. As the weeks went on A. F., like the others, + improved wonderfully in health and appearance. If we had had + anything like houses it would have been a pleasant trip. My + strangeness did not escape the notice of the boys altogether, for + I was still a bit strange in mind and nerves—and deeply + religious, bowing my head before each meal and reading my little + Bible and prayer-book at odd times. I drank no alcohol. I spent a + good deal of time by myself of with my faithful companion A., who + was nearly always at my side, she and her appealing eyes. I was + surprised to see how quickly she had improved; she looked quite + attractive and ladylike some evenings at meals, but I only + tolerated her. I was selfish and conceited.</p> + +<p> Things had been going on like this for a week—always playing to + empty houses and our money lower and lower—when A. said to our + other lady, Mrs. T., on a train in my presence: "I shall have to + give him up, I suppose; he will have nothing to do with me." Mrs. + T. said: "You give him up, do you?" and looked at me as if she + were going to try her hand. A. said "Yes," and looked at me, + smiling sadly. I don't know what motive prompted me—whether my + vanity was alarmed at her threatened desertion or that she had + really made some impression on me by her love, probably a little + of both—but I said: "No, don't; come and sit down here," making + way for her, and she joyfully came and nestled against me. From + that time I ceased to treat her with ridicule, and kissed her at + other times than when on the stage. I was subject still to black + moods, and would not speak to her for hours sometimes, but she + seemed content to walk with me and was infinitely patient. I had + heard she was living with—if not married to—an actor. I asked + her about him once, and she said she did not love him; she loved + me and had never loved before. Her face had a touching sadness; + her life had been unhappy and stormy, with no love and little + rest in it. Her face, when she had lost her dissipated look and + unhealthy pallor, was exquisite, delicate as a cameo. Love had + improved her manners, too; she was more gentle and refined. I let + things drift without thinking <a name='5_Page_262'></a>of the future, when one night + after the performance—I was lying on the sofa and A. was sitting + at my side, as usual—I suddenly thought, with the brutality that + characterized me in these matters—"I will ask her to let me + sleep with her." I still fought against any premonitory thought + of self-abuse, but here, I thought to myself, is a chance of + something better that will do me no harm and perhaps good. When + she understood me she turned very red and walked away, shaking + her head. But I let her understand that was the only way of + retaining me, and finally, when they had all gone to bed, she + gave herself to me, reluctantly and sadly; for she, too, had been + drifting on without thinking of anything of this sort (she hated + it at this time), but just living for her love of me, her first + true love.</p> + +<p> Before this occurred, I must tell you, I had been so much better + that I sometimes felt capable of doing anything, a sense of power + and grasp of intellect which was combined with delicacy of + feeling and sensitiveness to beauty, to skies and clouds and + flowers. I seemed to be awakening to true manhood, to my true + self. And at meals, it is worth recording, I commenced to have a + distaste for meat.</p> + +<p> These glimpses of a better state of things left me on cohabiting + with A., and for a time my gloom and black religious mania came + on me once more. I now thought of my promise at confirmation, and + it seemed to me I had offended beyond pardon. When we came to the + next town, however, I openly slept with A. all night, leaving my + own bed untouched. When we returned to Adelaide one of our party + remarked: "The only man who had any success with the women on the + tour was a Bible-reading, praying, and good, pious, confirmed + Christian."</p> + +<p> A.'s nascent beauty and delicacy and improvement were gradually + impaired, too. My own conduct became so morose at times that, + besides increasing her misery, I offended the others, and + bickerings ensued. I heard the other actress say "He's mad; that + what's the matter." And I was so wrapped up in myself and my + religious mania that I did not mind their thinking so.</p> + +<p> After the tour was over A. asked me to come and see her at her + home, and as I missed her very much I went one night to tea. She + had a room in her father's house to herself. A. was dressed in + her best and we had an affectionate meeting. After tea I asked + her if she were married to E. She said "No." Then I said: "Who + are you married to?" She commenced to cry then, and told me + something of her life, the saddest I ever heard. When only 17 she + had been courted by a young man she did not care for, but who + prevailed on her parents by pretending he had seduced her, but + wished to marry her. Strange as it may seem, A. did not know what + marriage meant, her mother being one of those silly women who + don't like talking of these things and let their daughters grow + up in ignorance, expecting they will learn from some one. In nine + <a name='5_Page_263'></a>cases out of ten this happens, but A. was an exception. It was + this, and the fact that she had not a particle of love for her + husband, that gave her such a hatred of coition. When her mother + saw the sheets the morning after the marriage she burst out + crying; she did not like the young man and saw she had been + deceived.</p> + +<p> A.'s husband soon showed his true character; he was in reality a + gaol-bird. He beat her, drank, and even wanted her to go on the + streets to earn money for him. She left him and went home; it was + then she began her theatrical career by entering the ballet. At + intervals her husband, drunk and desperate, would waylay and + threaten her in the street. One day after a rehearsal he + attempted to stab her. She got on in spite of all, being a born + actress, and played small parts in traveling companies. Then E., + who had also gone on the stage, courted her and she listened to + him, not because she cared for him, but he protected her and + offered her a home. She joined him; but his drunkenness and + sensuality were so gross that he ruined his health and he + attempted to maltreat A. in a nameless way. And whenever she was + in the family way he would leave her alone and half-conscious in + the cellar for days. To add to her misery she had epileptic fits. + Then sometimes they would be out of an engagement and starving. + They had been so hungry as to steal raw potatoes out of a sack + and eat them thus, having no fire. She would often have had + engagements, but E. was jealous and would not let her act without + him. And he beat her as her husband had done, and her health + became undermined. It was just after one of the forced + miscarriages that she joined our traveling company, and that + accounted for her yellow and puffy appearance. E. was now away + up-country with a circus, but was expected down any time. A. told + me a good deal of all this, between her tears, while sitting at + my feet, and her tone carried conviction. When I ought to have + gone home I persuaded her to let me stay all night. We had been + in bed some time when her mother knocked at the door and wanted + to come in for something in a chest of drawers there. "Why don't + you open the door, A.? Who have you got there? Hasn't that fellow + gone?" A. was confused and told me to get under the bed, but I + refused, and she covered me up with the bed clothes as well as + she could and opened the door. She had hid my clothes, but missed + one of my shoes, and her mother saw it. "Oh, A.," was all she + said; "you've got that fellow in bed," and went out crying. + "Well, Fred" (my stage name), "you've got me into a nice row," A. + said. She gave me my breakfast in the morning and I walked out of + the front door without being molested. Another night I entered + her window by a ladder and stayed all night. In the middle of the + night E. came home drunk. She would not let him in and told him + she would have nothing more to do with him. He attempted to break + in the door, when A. called to me, and hearing a man in the room + he went away, saying, as he <a name='5_Page_264'></a>went downstairs: "Oh, A.! Oh, A.!" + as if he thought she would not have done such a thing. He never + molested us after that night.</p> + +<p> I think it was my intention, at first, to break off with A. + gradually. I found, however, I could not keep away from her, and + it commenced to be evident to me that a bachelor's life in + lodgings again would be dreary and lonely. And all this time the + fear that I had offended God troubled me more than I have said, + and it occurred to me (there may have been a touch of sophistry + in this, or not) that if I were a true husband to her for the + future—stuck to her and worked for her for the rest of my + days—perhaps it would find favor in God's sight and be an + atonement for my sin. Had she been free I would have married her, + I believe. But she began to be harassed by her mother and + bothered about my incessantly coming there and staying all night. + It ended in my telling her I would be a husband to her, and she + came and lived with me at my lodgings. We had one room and our + meals cost us sixpence each. Cheap as it was, it was a struggle + for me to earn money at all. I remember feeling ill and anxious + once, and sustaining myself by the thought of my father wheeling + the heavy truck up the street when he married my mother. And I + decided to wheel my truck, too.</p> + +<p> A. seemed happy and her love increased, if possible; at first, + though, she must have found me a trying lover, for I made her + kneel and pray with me two or three times a day, which she did + with such a queer expression of face. Sometimes her feelings got + the better of her, and she would say: "Oh, damn it, Fred, you are + always praying." And then I would be shocked and she would be + sorry.... Coitus was frequent; she commenced to like it now....</p> + +<p> A. was not looking well one evening when she came in, and lay + down on the bed. Presently she commenced to make a strange noise, + and I saw her eyes were closed and her hands clenched. "Ah," said + the landlady, who came in to help me; "she has epileptic fits." + When her convulsions were over she looked blankly at us, knitting + her brows and evidently puzzling her poor brain to remember who + we were. For many years it was my fate to see her looking at me + thus, at first stony and estranged, like a dweller in another + star, then half-recalling with extended hand, then forgetting + again with hand to mouth, then the gradual dawn of memory and + love, and final full recognition. "It's Fred, my Fred!" I never + got used to it; it always moved me to tears.... It was not to be + thought that we had no quarrels. I still had fits of bad temper, + and sometimes they came into collision with A.'s temper. It hurt + my vanity considerably to see how soon she relinquished the + respectful, patient, spaniel-bearing she had when we were + traveling. I said some cruel things to her and she retorted. One + would have thought, to hear us, that all affection was over. But + when the mood of rage wore <a name='5_Page_265'></a>itself out we would both be sorry and + make it up with tears, and be very happy in spite of our poverty.</p> + +<p> I think it was lust that prevented me from striving to fulfill my + ambitions. A. let me do anything I liked, at all times of day or + night, although she seemed surprised at my proceedings sometimes, + for it was becoming a fever of lubricity with me. She still + thought only of her love. I remember her coming in one day, + tired, pale, perspiring, and worried—we had hardly anything in + the house and she had been to the theater ineffectually—and when + her eyes lighted on me the whole expression of her face changed, + softened and brightened at once, and she came and kissed me and + said: "It is so strange, I was thinking all sorts of nasty things + coming along, but as soon as I see my pet's face I feel happy—I + don't care for anything—I would sooner share a crust with him + than have all the money in the world!"</p> + +<p> I commenced to feel libidinous curiosity to examine her—this was + mostly on Sundays—and she let me, blushing at first, but + laughing. Then I would try new positions in coitus I had heard + of. Still she did not enter into my mood.</p> + +<p> She was engaged at this time to play in a pantomime and I + commenced to lead a miserable, jealous existence. I heard scandal + about her, baseless enough, but in the diseased, nervous, anxious + state I had brought myself to it nearly drove me mad. I would go + with her sometimes to visit her mother, whom I began to like. Her + brother I still saluted coldly. It caused me horror and jealousy + to see A. kissing him and letting him tickle her. In my rage, + when we came home, I even said that perhaps she would let him do + something else, naming it brutally and coarsely. I remember her + shame, astonishment, indignation and tears. If ever a man tried a + woman's love I did. But she forgave me, even that.</p> + +<p> We went to live in a little cottage. It was in this cottage that + A. first showed signs of lust, and in the diseased state of my + mind, instead of regretting it, I encouraged her. She told me one + day that the orgasm very often did not occur at the same time + with her as with me, and that it would not unless I put my little + finger into the anus. This her husband taught her, and she would + rather have died than confess it to me when we first met. We + would often devote our Sundays to having a picnic as we termed + our lustful bouts, stimulating ourselves with wine. Her temper + was not improved thereby (though her fits entirely stopped for a + twelvemonth)—we had wordy warfares, but we made it up again + always with tears. Nor did I allow myself to deteriorate without + reactions and excursions into better things. I was always reading + Emerson; it was he who rescued me from orthodox Christianity and + taught me to trust in myself and in Nature. I have never ceased + this struggle towards better things to this day. There, in a + nutshell, is <a name='5_Page_266'></a>my life; I have always been defeated when + temptation came, but I have never ceased to struggle. I + determined to be more abstemious in sexual indulgence and asked + her to help me. She agreed willingly, for she was easily led. + Whenever we fell back again into excess it was my fault.</p> + +<p> At a theatrical performance we first met a Miss T., a young + German who sang. She was about 25, with modest, quiet and + engaging manners. A. and she became very friendly. I liked her; + she was tall, dark and lithe, but had bad teeth.</p> + +<p> I had been ill and at this time A. and I had a quarrel, my temper + suddenly breaking out in murderous frenzy. I called her names and + finally put her outside the house, telling her to go to her + mother. I suffered a very hell of remorse and misery. Everything + in the quiet, lonely house reminded me of her, seemed fragrant of + her; my anguish became so keen I could not stop in the house, + though I was just as wretched walking about. I kept this up for + two days, when I met her coming to look for me. One look was + enough—"A.!" "Pet!" in broken sobs—and in tears we kissed and + made it up. Miss T. was with her, and I greeted her, too, with + happy tears in my eyes. Another time, when A. was giving way to + <i>her</i> temper, and one would have thought all love was dead, I + said "Don't you love me then?" and the word alone was a talisman, + her face changed, she held out her arms and began to sob + quietly.... She accepted an offer to travel with a small + theatrical company who were going up-country. She was not looking + well when I left and after a time I received a telegram telling + me to come to her at once as she was ill. Dreading all sorts of + things I borrowed my fare and went to her. I knew nothing of + women, of their point of view and different code of honor, and + was very far from the attitude of Guy de Maupassant who said he + liked women all the better for their charmingly deceitful ways. + A. wanted to see me and had taken the surest means to ensure my + coming. I was angry at first, but she looked so well and was so + loving that I could not be angry long.</p> + +<p> One day when I was working the landlady came in and began talking + about A. and her conduct before I came. She had gone into the + actors' rooms at all hours, the woman said, and drank and been as + bad as the rest in her conversation. It was the second time a + married woman had run her down to me, and I commenced to think + there might be something in it, and suffered all my mad jealousy + over again. Not knowing the freedom actors and actresses allow + themselves on tour, without there being necessarily anything in + it, I worried till I thought I had nothing to do but die. And + then one of the great struggles of my life occurred. Walking the + country roads, I asked myself: "If it <i>is</i> true, if she has been + unfaithful, will you forgive her and help her to arrive at her + best?" For a long time the answer was "No!" But perhaps my + striving for unity with myself had done some good, and the <a name='5_Page_267'></a>final + resolution was for forgiveness. I felt more peace of mind then, + and when I told a dying consumptive lodger in the house what the + landlady had said, he replied, "Don't you believe a word of it. I + know she loves you!"....</p> + +<p> After an absence I found myself one evening in a town where A. + was performing. I went round to the back and they told me she had + gone to a room in the hotel to change for another part. I + followed and entered the room, with a glass of spirits I found + that an effeminate young actor was bringing to her. She was half + undressed, her beautiful arms and shoulders bare. My arrival was + unexpected and she looked at me surprised, I thought coldly, as I + reproached her for not keeping a promise she had made to me to + touch no alcohol during the tour, but soon her arms were round my + neck. She cried like a child. She was bigger and handsomer and + healthier. There was not only an increased strength and size, but + an increased delicacy and sweetness; her eyes and brows were + lovely; there was an indescribable bloom and fragrance on her, + such as the sun leaves on a peach; the traveling, country air, + and freedom from coitus (had I known it) had enabled her to + arrive at her true self, not only a beautiful woman, but a woman + of fascination, of wit, vivacity and universal <i>camaraderie</i>. Her + face was like the dawn; all my fears and jealousy left me like a + cloud that melts before the sun. I remember the look on her face + as she embraced me in bed that night. It had just the very + smallest touch of sensuality, but was more like some beautiful + child's who is being caressed by one she loves; this divine, + drowsy-eyed, adorable look I had never seen on her face + before—nor have I since.</p> + +<p> We fell back into our old lustful ways. Later on A. became ill + and the black devil of epilepsy returned. I became gloomy.... A + restlessness and selfish brutality came over me; our love and + peace were gone. I persuaded A. to go to Melbourne and look out + for an engagement. The day before she was to sail we went to + Glenelg for a trip. The sea air, as often happened, precipitated + A.'s fits. We had gone down to the pier and A. said she felt bad. + I just managed to support her to the hotel before she became + stiff, and I made some impatient remark (for she nearly dragged + me down) which she heard, not being quite unconscious and said + half incoherently and very pitiably: "Be kind, oh, be kind!" + repeating it after consciousness left her. Her heart had been + breaking all day at the prospect of parting, and also, I expect, + because I was so ready to part with her. That moment was a crisis + in my life. I was in a murderous humor, but she looked so + unutterably wretched that it seemed impossible to be anything but + kind. I made myself speak lovingly to her, in moments of partial + consciousness, hired a room, carried her up, and nursed her and + petted her all night. The act of self-control, <a name='5_Page_268'></a>and forcing + myself to be kind whatever I felt, became a habit in time, a sort + of second nature.</p> + +<p> In a few days she sailed. When she had gone I was remorseful and + mad with myself. How could I let her go by herself? I resolved to + follow her as speedily as possible, and did so.</p> + +<p> If I remember rightly I came to the conclusion about this time + that we ought not to have coition unless we felt great love for + each other. It seemed to corroborate this to a certain extent + that A. always seemed more electric and pleasant to the touch + when we had connection for love and not for lust. Leave it to + Nature, I would say to myself. I began to feel how much my + struggles, efforts and temperate living had improved me. I had + more self-respect, though something of the old self-consciousness + was still left. I did not get better continuously, but in an + up-and-down zigzag. I still had moods of rage approaching madness + and periods of neurotic depression. Long walks decidedly helped + to cure me, and the sea, sun, wind, clouds and trees colored my + dreams at night very sweetly. I frequently dreamed I was walking + in orchards or forests, and a deeper, slightly melancholy but + potent savor, as of a diviner destiny, was on my soul.</p> + +<p> After a long absence, during which she had frequently been ill, + A. joined me. I could see she was recovering from fits, which I + began to realize that she had more frequently in absence from me, + and also from drinking, perhaps. She was small and thin, but + fresh and sweet as honey, and all signs of fits and tempers + passed away from her face, so wonderful in its changes. I had + become so healthy through my abstinence, temperance and long + walks that our meeting was a new revelation to me of how + delicate, fragrant and divine a convalescent woman may be. She + was glad and surprised to see me looking so well, and if she put + her hand on my arm I felt a joyous thrill. I was certainly a + better man for abstaining and she a better woman and I determined + not to have connection unless we were carried away by our love. + As a matter of fact we did not give way to excess, though we were + very loving. I tried to persuade myself that we had not gone back + to our old ways, but I could not do so long.</p> + +<p> Miss T. put in an appearance every day. She did not look so + innocent, but as it was no business of mine I did not trouble. + She seemed more attached to A. than ever.... A. was still very + loving with me, but it was an effort to me to keep up to her + pitch, and when A. proposed to go to Melbourne with Miss T, to + sell off the furniture before settling in Adelaide, I was rather + glad of the opportunity of abstaining from coitus and of watching + myself to see if I again improved. When A. and Miss T. came to + see me before going down to the steamer, A. was nearly crying and + Miss T., changed from the old welcome friend, was not only pale + and anxious, but looked guilty as if she had some <a name='5_Page_269'></a>treachery in + her mind; she could not meet my eye. I thought less of it then + than afterwards. And once more I took long walks at night and + rose early to catch the freshness of the mornings.</p> + +<p> Some time before this I had read a book advocating a vegetarian + diet, and at this time I chanced to read Pater's beautiful "Denys + L'Auxerrois," the imaginary portrait of a young vine-dresser, who + was attractive beyond ordinary mortals and lived, until his fall + and deterioration, on fruit and water. The words, "a natural + simplicity in living" remained in my memory. I resolved to read + more carefully the book on scientific diet. Who can say, I + thought, what changes for the better may come to me if I live on + a strictly scientific and natural diet?</p> + +<p> I fasted one whole day, and then had a breakfast of cherries, in + the middle of the day a meal of fruit, and walking in the + afternoon—a gray, rainy day—I felt so light, so different, and + the gray sky looked so sweet and familiar, that I was reminded of + the luminous visions of my boyhood. It was a distinct revelation. + This Pan-like, almost Bacchic feeling, did not last, however, nor + was I always able to maintain my new method of diet, though I + tried to do so. I made the attempt, however, but I imagine I was + more than usually run down. I would walk miles in the hope of + feeling less restless. One holiday I walked down to Glenelg, + having only had grapes for my dinner, and lying on the beach I + looked through a strong binocular glass I had borrowed at the + girls bathing. And the beauty of their faces in their frames of + hair, of their arms, of their figures, seen through their wet + clinging dresses, satisfied me and filled me with joy, gave me + for a short time that peace and content—in harmony with the + strong sunlight on the waves and the rhythmic surf on the + shore—I was seeking. The summer evenings on the pier or along + the beach had a peculiar savor; one felt the youth and beauty + there even on dark nights, the air was fragrant with them, white + dresses and summer hats disappearing down the beach or over the + sand hills. It was easy—doubtless justifiable sometimes—to put + a lewd construction on these disappearances; but I felt it need + not have been so; that it was not necessary that youth and + beauty, even the sexual act itself if led up to by love, should + be a subject of giggling and sniggering. I always left the beach + and its flitting summer dresses with a sigh.</p> + +<p> A., after writing once, ceased writing at all and once more her + mother and I were left in a state of anxiety and suspense. At + last I determined to go to Melbourne to look for her, the only + clue I had being a remark in her letter that a certain actor was + giving her an engagement. In Melbourne I could not find any + traces of her for some days and what traces I did find of her + were not calculated to allay my anxious fears. One hotel-keeper + told me that some one of A's name had stayed there with another + hussy (giving Miss T's stage name): "There were nice carryings on + with the pair of them." I thought of Miss T's strange <a name='5_Page_270'></a>looks, but + could not imagine what hold she had on A., for A. loved me, I + knew. I seemed to be in an inextricable maze. I could settle to + nothing and was thinking of applying to the police when I heard + that the actor A. had mentioned had taken his company to the + Gippsland lakes. I followed to Sale, found the actor and was told + that A. was not there. "She slipped me at the last moment," he + said, "and remained in Melbourne." I returned to my lodgings, + with my anxiety and nervous restlessness increased tenfold. But + suddenly my fear and restlessness left me like a cloud. I felt + quiet, young, peaceful, able to enjoy the country, A. was + doubtless all right and would be able to explain her silence. I + undressed leisurely and happily, thinking of the stars.</p> + +<p> The next day, Sunday, I awoke refreshed and still at peace. After + breakfast, hearing children's voices, I went out into the garden + and there was a collision of souls who somehow were affinities. A + young girl about twelve or younger with a fine presence and + handsome face fixed her eyes on me for half a minute and then + came and sat on my knee. She was one of those children I am + accustomed to call "love-children," because they are so much + brighter, healthier, larger and more loving than others. I always + imagine more love went to their making. We fell in love and she + said, stroking my beard, "Oh, you are pretty!" and I said, "And + so are you!" We were so affectionate that the servant called the + child away and I went for a walk, finding my little sweetheart + waiting for me on my return. The touch of her hand was electric + and her voice fresh and musical. I kissed her, but had become + more self-conscious since the morning and wondered if her mother + or the servant were looking, or even of they would appear. I was + not so frank and natural as my little chum. I have often thought + of her since. She had the breadth of forehead, the strength and + yet lightness of limb, together with the hands and feet, not too + small, that I always imagine the dwellers in Paradise will have.</p> + +<p> I returned to Melbourne and continued trying to find A. At the + same time I commenced in earnest to live on fruit and brown bread + only, and enjoyed better tone and health every day, so that it + was a joy to walk down the street in the sun and exchange glances + with passengers à la old Walt. One day in the Botanical Gardens + veils seemed to be lifted off my eyes. I could look straight at + the sun and taking my note of color from that golden light I + turned my eyes on the flowers, the mown grass, the trees, and for + the first time perceived what a heavenly color green is, what + divine companions flowers are, and what a blue sky really means. + For half an hour I was in Paradise, and to complete my joy Nature + revealed to me a new and unexpected secret.</p> + +<p> I was lying on a bench, basking, and my silk shirt coming open + the strong sun made its way to my breast and presently I felt a + totally new sensation there. I had discovered the last joy of the + skin. My <a name='5_Page_271'></a>skin, fed by healthy fruit-made blood, must have + functioned normally under the excitation of the sun just then + (for a brief space only, alas!). I cannot describe the joy, any + more than I could describe the taste of a peach to one who has + only eaten apples: it was satisfying, divine. I opened my shirt + wider, but the feeling only spread faintly, and indeed this + halcyon sunny hour terminated in a restlessness that sent me + walking into town to look for A.</p> + +<p> At last I heard, not of A., but of Miss T. She was in a ballet. I + went round during rehearsal and while waiting entered into + conversation with a little chorus girl with a good face, who was + sewing. On my telling her whom I was seeking she stopped sewing + and looked at me quickly: "Oh, are you her husband? I know her. + <i>I have seen them together</i>." She looked as if she were going to + tell me something, but merely shook her old-fashioned head in a + mournful, indescribable way, saying "Why don't you keep your wife + with you?" I went to the door and presently saw Miss T. She tried + to avoid me, I thought, and looked more vicious than ever, but + after a minute's thought reluctantly told me where she and A. + were staying. To hide my fears and suspicions I had assumed a + careless demeanor, but I think I should have strangled her had + she refused to tell me. I hastily went to the place indicated and + going up the stairs (to the astonishment of the people) opened + the door and found myself face to face with A.—but how changed! + She had the hard, harlot, loveless look I detested. I felt for a + few minutes that I did not love her, and she regarded me coldly + too, but presently old habits reinstated themselves. She put out + her hands, very pitiably, and then was sobbing in my arms. I + could get nothing out of her but sobs, and to this day do not + know where she spent all these weeks nor why she did not write. + Miss T. came in after rehearsal, pale and hard-faced. I greeted + her politely, but was watching her, trying to puzzle out why A. + did not look as she usually did after long absence from coition. + Miss T. took another room in the same house and was soon joined + by another ballet girl, young and very pretty, who soon began to + have fits. A. was always crying until Miss T. went away with her + pretty friend. I knew nothing, could hardly be said to suspect + anything definite, and yet I pitied that pretty girl whose eyes + looked so helpless and appealing.</p> + +<p> I set to work again. But I continued to live on fruit and bread, + and taking off my clothes I would stand up at the window in the + sun. A lot of prostitutes, however, who lived at the back saw me + and were scandalized or shocked or thought me mad. The landlady + heard of it and spoke to A. So I had to desist from my glorious + sun-baths.</p> + +<p> We slept on a single bed, and though I did my best to avoid + coitus (I wanted to wait and think out some theory of it), A., + who knew nothing of this, wanted to resume our old habits, and + finally I surrendered. But my sufferings next day were intense, + and I had the sense <a name='5_Page_272'></a>of having fallen from some high estate. My + thoughts were divided between two theories: one that our misery + was caused by our diet, more or less; the other that we had + fallen into some error as regards coitus, and this was becoming + almost a certainty with me.</p> + +<p> There is one incident I think worthy of note which happened + before the "fall" just mentioned and when I was living on fruit + and in splendid health. At a performance I saw a girl on the + stage with handsome legs in tights, and once as she straightened + her leg the knee-cap going into position gave me such a strange + and keen joy—of that quality I call divine or musical—that I + was like one suddenly awakened to the divinity and beauty of the + female form. The joy was so keen and yet peaceful, familiar, and + subjective that I could not help comparing it to a happy chemical + change in the tissues of my own brain. Like the unexpected + functioning of my skin in the sun it was a sign of a partial + return to a normal condition, another glimpse of Paradise.</p> + +<p> I stuck to my new diet and gained a fresh elation and joy in + life. Gradually clothes became insupportable, and I went down to + the beach as often as possible to take them off, and at nights, + beside the patient and astonished A., I would lie naked. One + evening, passing some grass, I looked over the fence like a gipsy + and felt a longing to take off my clothes and sleep in the grass + all night. It was of course impossible. And A. looked unhappily + in my face; she began to think her mother, who now thought I was + mad, must be right.</p> + +<p> That night I woke up and found myself having coition. I was angry + and felt I had been put back in my progress, but a fever of lust + now came over me. I would sit under the tap and let the cold + water run over me to conquer the fever, but at the end of a week + my hopes were frustrated and I even turned against my natural + diet, on which I had made flesh. A., as I expected, went through + her usual fits, and slowly recovered. (If we had connection only + once she in about three weeks had a mild attack of fits; if we + had coition more than once the fits were more severe.) I relapsed + more than once and as a means of impressing my resolution for + future abstinence I would walk for miles in the middle of + pitch-black nights....</p> + +<p> Miss T. came over to Adelaide and as I knew nothing definite + against her and heard that she was engaged, I thought perhaps my + suspicions were unfounded and was friendly. But one day in town I + saw her and A. on a tram going out to our cottage. Even then my + suspicions might not have been awakened, but I saw Miss T. say + something rapidly to A., and A. called out to me, "Will you be + coming home soon?" And I answered "No." When the tram had gone on + I found myself vaguely wondering what Miss T. wanted to know that + for, for my perceptions were becoming acute enough to understand + women's ways. In another minute I was walking rapidly home. When + I came to the door <a name='5_Page_273'></a>it was locked. I knocked and knocked and no + one came. I called out and threatened to kick in the door. Still + no one came. Mad with rage I commenced to put my threat into + execution, when the door was opened by Miss T., half-naked, in + her petticoats, and pale as death, but no longer defiant. "So + I've caught you, have I?" I <i>looked</i>, but could not trust myself + to speak. Wondering why A. did not appear I went into the + bedroom. She was lying on the bed, just as Miss T. had left her, + on the verge of a fit, and on seeing me she held out her hands + piteously, and when I stooped over her she whispered, "Send her + away, send her away." Then she became unconscious and going into + the next room I ordered Miss T. (who had managed to scramble on + her dress) out of the house. I spoke scornfully as if addressing + a dog, and she slinked out with a malignant but cowed look I hope + never to see on a woman's face again. What they had been doing + with their clothes off I do not know; women will rather die than + confess. When A. had recovered from her fit she denied that there + had been anything between them, and stuck to it doggedly, but + with such a forlorn look I had not the heart to prosecute my + inquiries.</p> + +<p> For my part, all the efforts I had been making for so long seemed + for a time to be in vain; for some weeks I sank into a sort of + satyriasis, and even my anger against Miss T. turned to a + prurient curiosity. At the same time I was not always able to + adhere to my diet. But both as regards coition and diet I was + still fighting, and on the whole successfully. My fits of temper, + however, were excessive and my ennui became gloomy despair. One + day I blasphemed on crossing the Park and spoke contemptuously of + "God and his twopenny ha'penny revolving balls," referring to the + planetary system. But for long walks I should have gone mad. A. + was drinking in the intervals of her fits. I found half-empty + bottles of wine hidden away. This did not improve my temper, and + one day—this was when she was well and up—I struck her a heavy + blow on the face, and she aimed a glass decanter at me. She went + home to her mother and I lived alone in the cottage. I heard soon + afterwards that her husband had come back and that they had made + it up. Our parting was not, however, destined to be final.</p> + +<p> Even out of that month's sufferings I made capital. I was better + after my tendency to lubricity, my gloom, rage, restlessness and + degradation. They had been but the irritations of convalescence.</p></div> + + + +<a name='5_Page_274'></a> +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_INDEX_OF_AUTHORS'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_275'></a>INDEX OF AUTHORS.</h2> + + +<ul><li>Abrantès, duchesse d', <a href='#5_Page_213'>213</a>.</li> +<li>Adler, <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Albucasis, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>.</li> +<li>Alexander, H. C. B., <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a>.</li> +<li>Amatus Lusitanus, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li> +<li>Ammon, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>, <a href='#5_Page_196'>196</a>.</li> +<li>Andersen, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Andriezen, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Aquinas, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Aristophanes, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Aristotle, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>.</li> +<li>Averroes, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a></li> +<li>Avicenna, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>.</li> +<li>Aubrey, <a href='#5_Page_93'>93</a>.</li> +<li>Aulnoy, Madame d', <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Baer, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Ball, <a href='#5_Page_93'>93</a>.</li> +<li>Ballantyne, J. W., <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Bancroft, H. H., <a href='#5_Page_80'>80</a>.</li> +<li>Barker, Fordyce, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Barnes, R., <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Bartholin, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>.</li> +<li>Bayle, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>.</li> +<li>Beale, G. B., <a href='#5_Page_218'>218</a>.</li> +<li>Bechterew, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>.</li> +<li>Beck, J. R., <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a>.</li> +<li>Becker, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Bell, Sir C., <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Bell, Sanford, <a href='#5_Page_215'>215</a>.</li> +<li>Belletrud, <a href='#5_Page_62'>62</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>.</li> +<li>Beneden, <a href='#5_Page_116'>116</a>.</li> +<li>Bergh, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>, <a href='#5_Page_135'>135</a>, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Bianchi, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Biérent, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>, <a href='#5_Page_188'>188</a>, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li> +<li>Binet, <a href='#5_Page_2'>2</a>, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li> +<li>Bischoff, T. L. W., <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Bloch, J., <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>, <a href='#5_Page_50'>50</a>, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>, <a href='#5_Page_78'>78</a>, <a href='#5_Page_81'>81</a>, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Blondel, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li> +<li>Blumenbach, <a href='#5_Page_81'>81</a>, <a href='#5_Page_188'>188</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Blunt, J. J., <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Boas, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>, <a href='#5_Page_80'>80</a>.</li> +<li>Boccaccio, <a href='#5_Page_170'>170</a>.</li> +<li>Boeteau, <a href='#5_Page_78'>78</a>.</li> +<li>Bois, J., <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Bois-Reymond, E. du, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Bölsche, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li> +<li>Booth, D. S., <a href='#5_Page_103'>103</a>.</li> +<li>Booth, J., <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Bouchereau, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>.</li> +<li>Bouchet, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li> +<li>Bourke, J. G., <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>, <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Boveri, <a href='#5_Page_116'>116</a>.</li> +<li>Brand, <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Braun, <a href='#5_Page_139'>139</a>.</li> +<li>Brantôme, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Brehm, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>.</li> +<li>Breitenstein, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Brénier de Montmorand, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>.</li> +<li>Brénot, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Brouardel, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Brown-Séquard, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Brügelmann, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li> +<li>Buckman, S. S., <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>.</li> +<li>Bucknill, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Bunge, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Burchard, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Burdach, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Burton, Robert, <a href='#5_Page_9'>9</a>, <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>, <a href='#5_Page_108'>108</a>, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>, <a href='#5_Page_200'>200</a>.</li> +<li>Buschan, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Busdraghi, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Cabanis, <a href='#5_Page_181'>181</a>.</li> +<li>Campbell, J. F., <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Campbell, H., <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Carpenter, E., <a href='#5_Page_110'>110</a>.</li> +<li>Casanova, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>.</li> +<li>Cascella, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Castelnau, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>.</li> +<li>Catullus, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li> +<li>Cecca, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>.</li> +<li>Celsus, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>.</li> +<li>Chapman, C. W., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Charcot, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Chaucer, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Chaulant, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li> +<li>Chevalier, <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>.</li> +<li>Chidley, W., <a href='#5_Page_164'>164</a>.</li> +<li>Cladel, J., <a href='#5_Page_109'>109</a>.</li> +<li>Clement, of Alexandria, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Coe, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>.</li> +<li>Coen, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Collineau, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li> +<li>Colman, W. S., <a href='#5_Page_104'>104</a>.</li> +<li>Columbus, R., <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li> +<li>Cook, G. W., <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.<a name='5_Page_276'></a></li> +<li>Crawley, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Cumston, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Cuvier, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>.</li> +<li>Cyples, <a href='#5_Page_109'>109</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Dabney, <a href='#5_Page_224'>224</a>.</li> +<li>Darwin, C., <a href='#5_Page_85'>85</a>.</li> +<li>Darwin, E., <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Daumas, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>.</li> +<li>Dearborn, G., <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>.</li> +<li>Dembo, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>.</li> +<li>Deniker, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>.</li> +<li>Dessoir, Max, <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li> +<li>Dickinson, R. L., <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_135'>135</a>.</li> +<li>Diderot, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +<li>Disselhorst, <a href='#5_Page_158'>158</a>.</li> +<li>Donaldson, H. H., <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Douglas, C., <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li> +<li>Drähms, <a href='#5_Page_200'>200</a>.</li> +<li>Dühren, E., <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>, <a href='#5_Page_64'>64</a>, <a href='#5_Page_95'>95</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a> (and see Bloch, J.).</li> +<li>Dufougère, <a href='#5_Page_178'>178</a>.</li> +<li>Dufour, <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Dulaure, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>, <a href='#5_Page_80'>80</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>.</li> +<li>Duncan, Matthews, <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>East, A., <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>.</li> +<li>Edgar, Clifton, <a href='#5_Page_162'>162</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Ellis, Havelock, <a href='#5_Page_1'>1</a>, <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>, <a href='#5_Page_199'>199</a>, <a href='#5_Page_200'>200</a>, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Engelmann, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li> +<li>Erotion, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>.</li> +<li>Esbach, <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>.</li> +<li>Eschricht, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>.</li> +<li>Espinas, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>.</li> +<li>Eulenburg, <a href='#5_Page_1'>1</a>, <a href='#5_Page_95'>95</a>.</li> +<li>Evans, <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>.</li> +<li>Ezekiel, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Fabricius, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>.</li> +<li>Fallopius, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>.</li> +<li>Féré, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>, <a href='#5_Page_74'>74</a>, <a href='#5_Page_77'>77</a>, <a href='#5_Page_103'>103</a>, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>, <a href='#5_Page_169'>169</a>, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>, <a href='#5_Page_225'>225</a>.</li> +<li>Fichstedt, <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a>.</li> +<li>Flood, E., <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>.</li> +<li>Florence, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Fothergill, Milner, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>.</li> +<li>Frazer, J. G., <a href='#5_Page_61'>61</a>.</li> +<li>Freud, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>, <a href='#5_Page_202'>202</a>.</li> +<li>Freyer, <a href='#5_Page_91'>91</a>.</li> +<li>Froriep, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li> +<li>Fuchs, <a href='#5_Page_47'>47</a>, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>.</li> +<li>Fürbringer, <a href='#5_Page_171'>171</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Galen, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>.</li> +<li>Gardiner, C. F., <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Garnier, <a href='#5_Page_92'>92</a>, <a href='#5_Page_94'>94</a>, <a href='#5_Page_96'>96</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>.</li> +<li>Gautier, A., <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Gautier, T., <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li> +<li>Gellhoen, <a href='#5_Page_140'>140</a>.</li> +<li>Gerhard, A., <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Giles, A., <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>, <a href='#5_Page_212'>212</a>, <a href='#5_Page_214'>214</a>, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Godin, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Goethe, <a href='#5_Page_17'>17</a>, <a href='#5_Page_49'>49</a>.</li> +<li>Goncourt, E. de, <a href='#5_Page_54'>54</a>.</li> +<li>Gopcevic, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>.</li> +<li>Goron, <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>.</li> +<li>Gould, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>, <a href='#5_Page_212'>212</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Gow, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>.</li> +<li>Graaf, de, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Griffiths, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>.</li> +<li>Groos, K., <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>, <a href='#5_Page_201'>201</a>.</li> +<li>Gualino, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>.</li> +<li>Guéniot, <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>.</li> +<li>Guibaut, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>.</li> +<li>Guillereau, <a href='#5_Page_85'>85</a>.</li> +<li>Guinard, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Guttceit, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Hack, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Haddon, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>.</li> +<li>Haig, <a href='#5_Page_169'>169</a>, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Hall, G. Stanley, <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>, <a href='#5_Page_16'>16</a>, <a href='#5_Page_53'>53</a>, <a href='#5_Page_74'>74</a>, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>, <a href='#5_Page_99'>99</a>, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>.</li> +<li>Haller, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Hamilton, A., <a href='#5_Page_9'>9</a>.</li> +<li>Hammond, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>.</li> +<li>Hardy, Thomas, <a href='#5_Page_17'>17</a>.</li> +<li>Hartland, E. S., <a href='#5_Page_61'>61</a>.</li> +<li>Harvey, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>, <a href='#5_Page_165'>165</a>.</li> +<li>Hegar, <a href='#5_Page_198'>198</a>.</li> +<li>Henderson, J., <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li> +<li>Henle, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a>.</li> +<li>Hennig, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Herman, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>.</li> +<li>Herodotus, <a href='#5_Page_80'>80</a>, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +<li>Herrick, <a href='#5_Page_45'>45</a>, <a href='#5_Page_48'>48</a>, <a href='#5_Page_70'>70</a>.</li> +<li>Heusinger, <a href='#5_Page_191'>191</a>.</li> +<li>Hewitt, Graily, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Hippocrates, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>, <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Hirst, <a href='#5_Page_160'>160</a>.</li> +<li>Hislop, J. T., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Hoche, <a href='#5_Page_97'>97</a>.</li> +<li>Horrocks, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Howard, W. L., <a href='#5_Page_77'>77</a>, <a href='#5_Page_97'>97</a>, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Howell, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>.</li> +<li>Howitt, A. W., <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>.</li> +<li>Hrdlicka, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>.</li> +<li>Hughes, C. H., <a href='#5_Page_103'>103</a>, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>.</li> +<li>Hunter, John, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Hunter, William, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Huysmans, <a href='#5_Page_4'>4</a>, <a href='#5_Page_50'>50</a>.</li> +<li>Hyades, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>.</li> +<li>Hyrtl, <a href='#5_Page_116'>116</a>, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>, <a href='#5_Page_140'>140</a>, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.<a name='5_Page_277'></a></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Jacobi, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li> +<li>Jacoby, P., <a href='#5_Page_23'>23</a>, <a href='#5_Page_27'>27</a>.</li> +<li>Jahn, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>.</li> +<li>Janet, <a href='#5_Page_7'>7</a>, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>.</li> +<li>Janke, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li> +<li>Jastreboff, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>.</li> +<li>Jenkyns, J., <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Johnston, G. A., <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Johnston, Sir H. H., <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Jonson, Ben, <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a>.</li> +<li>Juvenal, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Kaltenbach, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Kelly, H., <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Kepler, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Kiernan, J. G., <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>, <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +<li>Kisch, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Kleinpaul, <a href='#5_Page_5'>5</a>, <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +<li>Kobelt, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>.</li> +<li>Kocher, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li> +<li>Kohlbrugge, <a href='#5_Page_118'>118</a>.</li> +<li>Kolbein, <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Krafft-Ebing, + <ul><li> <a href='#5_Page_2'>2</a>, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>, <a href='#5_Page_20'>20</a>, <a href='#5_Page_27'>27</a>, <a href='#5_Page_28'>28</a>, <a href='#5_Page_30'>30</a>, <a href='#5_Page_32'>32</a>, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>, <a href='#5_Page_57'>57</a>, <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>, <a href='#5_Page_62'>62</a>,</li> +<li> <a href='#5_Page_64'>64</a>, <a href='#5_Page_71'>71</a>, <a href='#5_Page_72'>72</a>, <a href='#5_Page_75'>75</a>, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>, <a href='#5_Page_78'>78</a>, <a href='#5_Page_90'>90</a>, <a href='#5_Page_92'>92</a>, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>, <a href='#5_Page_105'>105</a>, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Krauss, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Lamb, D. S., <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Landes, L. de, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li> +<li>Lane, <a href='#5_Page_12'>12</a>.</li> +<li>Lasègue, <a href='#5_Page_89'>89</a>, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Laurent, E., <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>, <a href='#5_Page_75'>75</a>.</li> +<li>Lawrence, Sir W., <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li> +<li>Laycock, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>, <a href='#5_Page_199'>199</a>.</li> +<li>Levi, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Licetus, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li> +<li>Liébault, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Liétaud, <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>.</li> +<li>Lipps, <a href='#5_Page_105'>105</a>.</li> +<li>Litzmann, <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Lombroso, <a href='#5_Page_2'>2</a>, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Lorion, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li> +<li>Lortet, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li> +<li>Lucas, J. C., <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>.</li> +<li>Lucretius, <a href='#5_Page_108'>108</a>, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li> +<li>Lunier, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Luschka, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Lusini, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>.</li> +<li>Lydston, <a href='#5_Page_78'>78</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Macdonald, A., <a href='#5_Page_6'>6</a>, <a href='#5_Page_73'>73</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>MacGillicuddy, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li> +<li>McKay, A., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Mackay, W. J. S., <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>.</li> +<li>Mackenzie, J., <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li> +<li>Magnan, <a href='#5_Page_28'>28</a>, <a href='#5_Page_61'>61</a>, <a href='#5_Page_89'>89</a>.</li> +<li>Malebranche, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li> +<li>Mantegazza, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>, <a href='#5_Page_88'>88</a>, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>, <a href='#5_Page_187'>187</a>.</li> +<li>Marandon de Montyel, <a href='#5_Page_17'>17</a>, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li> +<li>Marc, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Marro, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>, <a href='#5_Page_187'>187</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>, <a href='#5_Page_199'>199</a>, <a href='#5_Page_200'>200</a>.</li> +<li>Marshall, H. R., <a href='#5_Page_225'>225</a>.</li> +<li>Martial, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li> +<li>Martin, J. M. H., <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>.</li> +<li>Martineau, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>.</li> +<li>Maschka, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>.</li> +<li>Masterman, <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>.</li> +<li>Matignon, <a href='#5_Page_21'>21</a>, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>.</li> +<li>Mattel, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>McMordie, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Mercier, <a href='#5_Page_62'>62</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>.</li> +<li>Meredith, Ellis, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Middleton, T., <a href='#5_Page_190'>190</a>.</li> +<li>Mirabeau, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>.</li> +<li>Mitchell, Sir A., <a href='#5_Page_218'>218</a>.</li> +<li>Moll, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>, <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>, <a href='#5_Page_30'>30</a>, <a href='#5_Page_31'>31</a>, <a href='#5_Page_64'>64</a>, <a href='#5_Page_78'>78</a>, <a href='#5_Page_79'>79</a>, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>, <a href='#5_Page_84'>84</a>, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>, <a href='#5_Page_90'>90</a>, <a href='#5_Page_93'>93</a>, <a href='#5_Page_95'>95</a>, <a href='#5_Page_105'>105</a>, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Mongeri, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Morache, <a href='#5_Page_22'>22</a>.</li> +<li>Moraglia, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>, <a href='#5_Page_62'>62</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Morris, R. T., <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>.</li> +<li>Morselli, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>.</li> +<li>Motet, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>.</li> +<li>Moulin, J. Mansell, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Müller, J., <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Mundé, P., <a href='#5_Page_132'>132</a>, <a href='#5_Page_162'>162</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Näcke, <a href='#5_Page_85'>85</a>.</li> +<li>Neale, R., <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>.</li> +<li>Neri, <a href='#5_Page_57'>57</a>.</li> +<li>Nicholson, H. O., <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>, <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li> +<li>Nina Rodrigues, <a href='#5_Page_139'>139</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Obici, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>.</li> +<li>Onanoff, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>.</li> +<li>Ottolenghi, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>, <a href='#5_Page_200'>200</a>.</li> +<li>Ovid, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Pacheco, <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li> +<li>Palfyn, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>.</li> +<li>Park, Mungo, <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Papillault, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Pasini, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Paterson, A. R., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Paulini, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>.</li> +<li>Paulus Æginetus, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li> +<li>Pearse, W. H., <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Pearson, Karl, <a href='#5_Page_5'>5</a>.<a name='5_Page_278'></a></li> +<li>Pechuel-Loesche, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li> +<li>Pelanda, <a href='#5_Page_61'>61</a>, <a href='#5_Page_92'>92</a>.</li> +<li>Pennant, <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Penta, <a href='#5_Page_13'>13</a>.</li> +<li>Pfaff, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>.</li> +<li>Pierer, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li> +<li>Pillon, <a href='#5_Page_112'>112</a>.</li> +<li>Pinæus, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Pinard, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Pitre, C., <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li> +<li>Pitres, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>.</li> +<li>Pittard, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>.</li> +<li>Plant, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>.</li> +<li>Plautus, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>.</li> +<li>Pliny, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>.</li> +<li>Ploss, + <ul><li> <a href='#5_Page_23'>23</a>, <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>, <a href='#5_Page_81'>81</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>, <a href='#5_Page_99'>99</a>, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>, </li> +<li> <a href='#5_Page_135'>135</a>, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_150'>150</a>, <a href='#5_Page_204'>204</a>, <a href='#5_Page_214'>214</a>, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Poehl, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Polemon, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li> +<li>Pollux, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>.</li> +<li>Porta, Della, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li> +<li>Power, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>.</li> +<li>Pyle, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>, <a href='#5_Page_212'>212</a>, <a href='#5_Page_223'>223</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Raymond, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>.</li> +<li>Régis, <a href='#5_Page_55'>55</a>.</li> +<li>Régnier, H. de, <a href='#5_Page_49'>49</a>.</li> +<li>Reinach, S., <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li> +<li>Renooz, Céline, <a href='#5_Page_99'>99</a>.</li> +<li>Restif de la Bretonne, <a href='#5_Page_18'>18</a>, <a href='#5_Page_22'>22</a>.</li> +<li>Retterer, E., <a href='#5_Page_117'>117</a>, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>, <a href='#5_Page_144'>144</a>.</li> +<li>Reynolds, A. R., <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>.</li> +<li>Rhys, J., <a href='#5_Page_53'>53</a>.</li> +<li>Ribot, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>.</li> +<li>Riedel, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>.</li> +<li>Rimbaud, <a href='#5_Page_99'>99</a>.</li> +<li>Riolan, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>, <a href='#5_Page_204'>204</a>.</li> +<li>Robinson, Bryan, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_168'>168</a>.</li> +<li>Robinson, Louis, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>.</li> +<li>Rodin, <a href='#5_Page_108'>108</a>.</li> +<li>Roederer, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Roons, R. P., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Rosse, Irving, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>.</li> +<li>Roth, W., <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Rothe, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>.</li> +<li>Roubaud, <a href='#5_Page_28'>28</a>, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>, <a href='#5_Page_187'>187</a>, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>.</li> +<li>Rousseau, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>.</li> +<li>Routh, C. H. F., <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li> +<li>Rufus, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>.</li> +<li>Russell, W., <a href='#5_Page_218'>218</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Sade, de, <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Salmon, W., <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Scherzer, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>.</li> +<li>Schinz, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>.</li> +<li>Schmiedeberg, <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Schreiner, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Schrenck-Notzing, <a href='#5_Page_89'>89</a>.</li> +<li>Schurig, + <ul><li> <a href='#5_Page_5'>5</a>, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>, <a href='#5_Page_85'>85</a>, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>,</li> +<li> <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>, <a href='#5_Page_139'>139</a>, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>, <a href='#5_Page_211'>211</a>, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Scott, Colin, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>.</li> +<li>Scripture, E. W., <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>.</li> +<li>Seerley, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>.</li> +<li>Seligmann, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>.</li> +<li>Sellheim, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>.</li> +<li>Shakespeare, <a href='#5_Page_170'>170</a>.</li> +<li>Shattock, <a href='#5_Page_118'>118</a>, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>.</li> +<li>Shufeldt, <a href='#5_Page_45'>45</a>.</li> +<li>Silk, J. F. W., <a href='#5_Page_156'>156</a>.</li> +<li>Simon, H., <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Simpson, Sir J., <a href='#5_Page_7'>7</a>, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li> +<li>Sims, Marion, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li> +<li>Smith, Sir A., <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>.</li> +<li>Smith, Haywood, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>.</li> +<li>Sömmering, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Soranus, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>, <a href='#5_Page_221'>221</a>, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Spigelius, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a>, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>.</li> +<li>Stahl, F. A., <a href='#5_Page_220'>220</a>.</li> +<li>Stanton, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li> +<li>Stendhal, <a href='#5_Page_9'>9</a>, <a href='#5_Page_12'>12</a>, <a href='#5_Page_107'>107</a>, <a href='#5_Page_112'>112</a>.</li> +<li>Stengel, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li> +<li>Stern, B., <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>, <a href='#5_Page_79'>79</a>, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>.</li> +<li>Stevens, Vaughan, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Stieda, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a>.</li> +<li>Stratz, <a href='#5_Page_21'>21</a>, <a href='#5_Page_22'>22</a>, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>.</li> +<li>Stubbs, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>.</li> +<li>Suidas, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>.</li> +<li>Sukhanoff, <a href='#5_Page_60'>60</a>.</li> +<li>Sullivan, W. C., <a href='#5_Page_175'>175</a>.</li> +<li>Sutherland, W. D., <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>.</li> +<li>Sutton, Bland, <a href='#5_Page_117'>117</a>, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Swift, <a href='#5_Page_48'>48</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Tarde, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li> +<li>Tardieu, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>, <a href='#5_Page_190'>190</a>, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Tarnier, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li> +<li>Taxil, <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>.</li> +<li>Theocritus, <a href='#5_Page_51'>51</a>.</li> +<li>Thoinot, <a href='#5_Page_95'>95</a>.</li> +<li>Thompson, W. L., <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li> +<li>Thomson, J., <a href='#5_Page_225'>225</a>.</li> +<li>Tilt, <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Toff, <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Tourdes, G., <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li> +<li>Tridandani, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Trochon, <a href='#5_Page_91'>91</a>.<a name='5_Page_279'></a></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Vahness, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li> +<li>Valentin, <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Varigny, H de, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li> +<li>Variot, G., <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Varro, <a href='#5_Page_86'>86</a>.</li> +<li>Vaschide, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>, <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>.</li> +<li>Vatsyayana, <a href='#5_Page_150'>150</a>.</li> +<li>Venette, <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>.</li> +<li>Venturi, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>.</li> +<li>Vesalius, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>.</li> +<li>Vinay, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +<li>Vinci, L. da, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>.</li> +<li>Voigt, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>.</li> +<li>Voisin, J., <a href='#5_Page_198'>198</a>.</li> +<li>Vurpas, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>, <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Wagner, R., <a href='#5_Page_222'>222</a>.</li> +<li>Waldeyer, <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>.</li> +<li>Walker, G., <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Wallace, A. W., <a href='#5_Page_224'>224</a>.</li> +<li>Warton, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>.</li> +<li>Wasserschleben, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>, <a href='#5_Page_87'>87</a>, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li> +<li>Weininger, O., <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Wellhausen, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +<li>Werner, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>.</li> +<li>Wernich, <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a>.</li> +<li>West, J. P., <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li> +<li>Wharton, <a href='#5_Page_171'>171</a>.</li> +<li>Wilhelm, Eugen, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>.</li> +<li>Wilkin, G., <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Wilkinson, A. D., <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a>.</li> +<li>Williams, J. W. Whitridge, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Williamson, C. F., <a href='#5_Page_219'>219</a>.</li> +<li>Wolff, B., <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Wollstonecraft, Mary, <a href='#5_Page_9'>9</a>.</li> +<li>Wordsworth, <a href='#5_Page_49'>49</a>.</li> +<li>Wychgel, <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Youatt, <a href='#5_Page_85'>85</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Zaborsky, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>.</li> +<li>Zoppi, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>.</li> +<li>Zimmer, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>.</li> +<li>Zola, <a href='#5_Page_101'>101</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<a name='5_Page_280'></a> + +<hr class="full" /> +<a name='5_INDEX_OF_SUBJECTS'></a><h2><a name='5_Page_281'></a>INDEX OF SUBJECTS.</h2> + + +<ul><li>Abyssinians, + <ul><li>coitus among, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Acquired element in erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_28'>28</a>.</li> +<li>Acromegaly and sexual development, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Alcohol, + <ul><li>aphrodisiac effects of, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Algolagnia, + <ul><li>in relation to scatologic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>;</li> +<li> as a form of erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Anæsthesia, + <ul><li>sexual, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Anæsthetics in relation to sexual excitement, <a href='#5_Page_156'>156</a>.</li> +<li>Anaphrodisiacs, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Animal copulation, + <ul><li>attraction of, <a href='#5_Page_72'>72</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Animals, + <ul><li>detumescence in, <a href='#5_Page_158'>158</a>, <a href='#5_Page_160'>160</a>, <a href='#5_Page_168'>168</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Annamites, + <ul><li>coitus among, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Antipathies of pregnant women, <a href='#5_Page_212'>212</a>.</li> +<li>Anus in relation to pubic hair, <a href='#5_Page_128'>128</a>; + <ul><li>as an erogenous zone, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Apes, + <ul><li>sexual organs of, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>, <a href='#5_Page_165'>165</a>;</li> +<li> sexual congress in, <a href='#5_Page_144'>144</a>, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Aphrodisiacs, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Apples, + <ul><li>longings of women for, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Arabs, + <ul><li>penis in, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Artist, + <ul><li>compared to lover, <a href='#5_Page_108'>108</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Associations of contiguity and resemblance in erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>.</li> +<li>Australian method of sexual congress, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li> +<li>Auto-suggestions, + <ul><li>longings of pregnancy as, <a href='#5_Page_213'>213</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Bartholin, + <ul><li>glands of, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Beard in relation to sexual development, <a href='#5_Page_197'>197</a>.</li> +<li>Beauty, + <ul><li>the objective element in, <a href='#5_Page_107'>107</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Bestiality, <a href='#5_Page_77'>77</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Bladder in relation to sexual excitement, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li> +<li>Blood during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li> +<li>Blood-pressure during detumescence, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>, <a href='#5_Page_169'>169</a>.</li> +<li>Breasts, + <ul><li>and erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_188'>188</a>;</li> +<li> during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Bromide as an anaphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Bulbo-cavernous reflex, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>, <a href='#5_Page_157'>157</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Camphor as an anaphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Cantharides, + <ul><li>effects of, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Castration, + <ul><li>results of, <a href='#5_Page_180'>180</a>, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Celery as an aphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Children, + <ul><li>attracted to foot, <a href='#5_Page_16'>16</a>;</li> +<li> to scatology, <a href='#5_Page_53'>53</a>;</li> +<li> to copulation of animals, <a href='#5_Page_72'>72</a>;</li> +<li> to hair, <a href='#5_Page_74'>74</a>;</li> +<li> food impulses of, <a href='#5_Page_215'>215</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Chinese, + <ul><li>foot-fetichism of, <a href='#5_Page_21'>21</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Circulatory conditions during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>; + <ul><li>during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Clitoris, <a href='#5_Page_118'>118</a>, <a href='#5_Page_121'>121</a>, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>.</li> +<li>Clothes, + <ul><li>erotic fascination of, <a href='#5_Page_45'>45</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Coitus, + <ul><li>the phenomena of, <a href='#5_Page_111'>111</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> the methods of, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> ethnic variations in methods of, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>;</li> +<li> respiratory and circulatory conditions during, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>;</li> +<li> interruptus as a cause of vasomotor disturbance, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>, <a href='#5_Page_178'>178</a>;</li> +<li> glandular activity during, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>;</li> +<li> motor activity during, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> psychic state during, <a href='#5_Page_157'>157</a>;</li> +<li> serious effects of, <a href='#5_Page_168'>168</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Congenital element in erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_27'>27</a>.</li> +<li>Contiguity in erotic symbolism, + <ul><li>associations of, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Coprolagnia, <a href='#5_Page_47'>47</a>, <a href='#5_Page_62'>62</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Coprophagia, + <ul><li>religious and sexual, <a href='#5_Page_57'>57</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Courtship, <a href='#5_Page_142'>142</a>.</li> +<li>Crystallization, + <ul><li>Stendhal's, <a href='#5_Page_9'>9</a>, <a href='#5_Page_107'>107</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Defile, + <ul><li>the impulse to, <a href='#5_Page_95'>95</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Distillatio, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>.</li> +<li>Dog, + <ul><li>human sexual intercourse with, <a href='#5_Page_83'>83</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Dynamometric experiments during sexual excitement, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>.<a name='5_Page_282'></a></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Ejaculation, the mechanism of, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>.</li> +<li>Embryo, <a href='#5_Page_117'>117</a>.</li> +<li>Epilepsy and exhibitionism, <a href='#5_Page_91'>91</a>, <a href='#5_Page_103'>103</a>; + <ul><li>compared to coitus, <a href='#5_Page_150'>150</a>;</li> +<li> as a result of coitus, <a href='#5_Page_169'>169</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Erectility during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_144'>144</a>.</li> +<li>Erogenous zone, + <ul><li>anus as, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>;</li> +<li> lips as, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>, <a href='#5_Page_202'>202</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Erotic intoxication, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li> +<li>Erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_182'>182</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Eryngo as an aphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Ethnic variations in coitus, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_150'>150</a>, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li> +<li>Etruscans, + <ul><li>sexual significance of foot among, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Eunuchs, + <ul><li>characteristics of, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Exercise on sexual organs, + <ul><li>influence of, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Exhibitionism, <a href='#5_Page_89'>89</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Eyes during detumescence, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>; + <ul><li>in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_189'>189</a>;</li> +<li> darker at puberty, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Face during detumescence, + <ul><li>expression of, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Fæces as a drug, <a href='#5_Page_58'>58</a>.</li> +<li>Fecundation, + <ul><li>the phenomena of, <a href='#5_Page_117'>117</a>;</li> +<li> artificial, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Feet as a sexual symbol, + <ul><li>uncovering, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Fellatio, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li> +<li>Fetichism, + <ul><li>erotic, <a href='#5_Page_2'>2</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Flagellation, <a href='#5_Page_64'>64</a>, <a href='#5_Page_94'>94</a>, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li> +<li>Foot-fetichism, + <ul><li><i>see</i> Shoe-fetichism.</li></ul></li> +<li>Fuegians, + <ul><li>penis in, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Fur as a fetich, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Garments as fetiches, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>, <a href='#5_Page_74'>74</a></li> +<li>Genital organs as fetiches, <a href='#5_Page_10'>10</a>.</li> +<li>Goat as a human sexual fetich, <a href='#5_Page_80'>80</a>, <a href='#5_Page_82'>82</a>.</li> +<li>Greeks, + <ul><li>sexual significance of foot among, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Hair as a fetich, <a href='#5_Page_74'>74</a>; + <ul><li>despoilers of, <a href='#5_Page_75'>75</a>;</li> +<li> pubic, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> darkens at puberty, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> in pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Hand as fetich, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>.</li> +<li>Heart during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_206'>206</a>.</li> +<li>Homosexuality as a form of erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_2'>2</a>.</li> +<li>Hottentot apron, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a>.</li> +<li>Hymen, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_162'>162</a>.</li> +<li>Hyperæsthesia, sexual, <a href='#5_Page_6'>6</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Hypertrichosis universalis, <a href='#5_Page_195'>195</a>.</li> +<li>Hysteria, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Ideal coprolagnia, <a href='#5_Page_64'>64</a>.</li> +<li>Idiocy as result of maternal impressions, <a href='#5_Page_218'>218</a>, <a href='#5_Page_224'>224</a>.</li> +<li>Idiots, + <ul><li>sexual development of, <a href='#5_Page_198'>198</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Impregnation without rupture of hymen, <a href='#5_Page_162'>162</a>; + <ul><li>without conjunctions, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>;</li> +<li> artificial, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Impressions, + <ul><li>maternal, <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Intellectual work, + <ul><li>relation of pregnancy to, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Intoxication, + <ul><li>erotic, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Japanese, + <ul><li>labia majora in, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Joy, + <ul><li>the expression of, <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Kiss, the, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>.</li> +<li>Kleptomania and pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_216'>216</a>.</li> +<li>Knee-jerk in pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Labia majora, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Labia minora, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Larynx in relation to sexual state, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li> +<li>Linea fusca, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li> +<li>Lips, + <ul><li>as an erogenous zone, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>, <a href='#5_Page_202'>202</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_190'>190</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Longings of pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>; + <ul><li>theories of, <a href='#5_Page_212'>212</a>;</li> +<li> as auto-suggestions, <a href='#5_Page_213'>213</a>;</li> +<li> physiological basis of, <a href='#5_Page_214'>214</a>;</li> +<li> relation to the longings of childhood, <a href='#5_Page_215'>215</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Masochism, + <ul><li>in relation to shoe-fetichism, <a href='#5_Page_31'>31</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to scatalogic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_56'>56</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to exhibitionism of nates, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>;</li> +<li> as a form of erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Masturbation and pubic hair, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>; + <ul><li>hypertrophy of clitoris ascribed to, <a href='#5_Page_131'>131</a>;</li> +<li> part played by clitoris in, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>;</li> +<li> why some theologians permitted, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>;</li> +<li> phenomena during, <a href='#5_Page_155'>155</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Maternal element in sexual love, <a href='#5_Page_201'>201</a>.</li> +<li>Maternal impressions, <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a> <i>et seq.</i><a name='5_Page_283'></a></li> +<li>Menstruation in relation to coitus, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>; + <ul><li>metabolism during, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to sickness of pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a>;</li> +<li> compared to pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_228'>228</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Mental state during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Metabolism during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Mixoscopic zoophilia, <a href='#5_Page_71'>71</a>.</li> +<li>Modesty a supposed sign of virginity, <a href='#5_Page_204'>204</a>.</li> +<li>Mohammedan method of sexual congress, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li> +<li>Mole as a fetich, <a href='#5_Page_12'>12</a>.</li> +<li>Mongol peoples, + <ul><li>foot fetichism among various, <a href='#5_Page_23'>23</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Mons veneris, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a>.</li> +<li>Mordvins, + <ul><li>foot-fetichism among, <a href='#5_Page_23'>23</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Motor activity during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_183'>183</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Mouth in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_191'>191</a>.</li> +<li>Muscular movements during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Nates in relation to coprolagnia, <a href='#5_Page_63'>63</a>; + <ul><li>in relation to exhibitionism, <a href='#5_Page_100'>100</a>, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Necrophilia, <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>, <a href='#5_Page_81'>81</a>.</li> +<li>Negative fetich, <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>.</li> +<li>Negro, + <ul><li>penis in, <a href='#5_Page_122'>122</a>;</li> +<li> labia majora in, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a>;</li> +<li> clitoris in, <a href='#5_Page_130'>130</a>;</li> +<li> labia minora in, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a>;</li> +<li> method of sexual congress among, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Nervous system during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Neurasthenia cordis vasomotoria, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>.</li> +<li>Nipples, + <ul><li>pigmentation of, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Nudity, + <ul><li>religious, <a href='#5_Page_99'>99</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Nutrition, + <ul><li>symbolism of, <a href='#5_Page_7'>7</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Nymphæ, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>, <a href='#5_Page_134'>134</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Nymphomania, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Obsessions of scruple, <a href='#5_Page_7'>7</a>; + <ul><li>longings of pregnancy as, <a href='#5_Page_211'>211</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Obsessional exhibitionism, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>.</li> +<li>Odor an alleged sign of defloration, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li> +<li>Onion as an aphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li> +<li>Opium as an aphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>.</li> +<li>Organs, + <ul><li>sexual, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Ova and spermatozoa, + <ul><li>union of, <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Ovarian extract, effects of, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Ovaries, + <ul><li>function of, <a href='#5_Page_181'>181</a>;</li> +<li> analogy of with thyroid, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Paidophilia, <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>, <a href='#5_Page_13'>13</a>.</li> +<li>Pain and erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li> +<li>Pedicatio, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li> +<li>Pelvic development and erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Pelvic floor, variability of, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>.</li> +<li>Pelvic inclination, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>.</li> +<li>Penis, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a>, <a href='#5_Page_121'>121</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_129'>129</a>.</li> +<li>Penis-fetichism, <a href='#5_Page_96'>96</a>.</li> +<li>Phallic worship, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>.</li> +<li>Physiognomists and the erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_182'>182</a>.</li> +<li>Pica, <a href='#5_Page_211'>211</a>.</li> +<li>Pigmentation in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_191'>191</a>; + <ul><li>in pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_205'>205</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Potatoes, + <ul><li>the supposed aphrodisiac effects of, <a href='#5_Page_173'>173</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Precocity, + <ul><li>influence of, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Pregnancy and pigmentation, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>; + <ul><li>psychic state in, <a href='#5_Page_201'>201</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> sexual desire during, <a href='#5_Page_227'>227</a>;</li> +<li> relation of to intellectual work, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Presbyophilia, <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>.</li> +<li>Prostate, <a href='#5_Page_171'>171</a>.</li> +<li>Prostitutes, + <ul><li>external genitals of, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>;</li> +<li> stature of, <a href='#5_Page_187'>187</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Psychic exhibitionism, <a href='#5_Page_94'>94</a>.</li> +<li>Psychic condition during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_157'>157</a>.</li> +<li>Puberty, + <ul><li>the phenomena of, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>;</li> +<li> pigmentary changes at, <a href='#5_Page_192'>192</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Pubic hair, <a href='#5_Page_125'>125</a> <i>et seq.</i>; <a href='#5_Page_204'>204</a>.</li> +<li>Puericulture, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Pygmalionism, <a href='#5_Page_11'>11</a>, <a href='#5_Page_12'>12</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Quadrupedal method of coitus in man, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Rachitic, + <ul><li>sexual tendencies of the, <a href='#5_Page_184'>184</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Reflex, bulbo-cavernous, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>.</li> +<li>Reflexes during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_208'>208</a>.</li> +<li>Religious scatalogic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_57'>57</a>.</li> +<li>Resemblance in erotic symbolism, + <ul><li>associations of, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Respiration during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>.</li> +<li>Responsibility of pregnant women, <a href='#5_Page_217'>217</a>.<a name='5_Page_284'></a></li> +<li>Restif de la Bretonne's shoe-fetichism, <a href='#5_Page_18'>18</a>.</li> +<li>Romans, + <ul><li>sexual significance of foot among, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>;</li> +<li> methods of coitus among, <a href='#5_Page_147'>147</a>, <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Rousseau, <a href='#5_Page_102'>102</a>.</li> +<li>Rue as an anaphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Sadism, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>.</li> +<li>Saint compared to lover, <a href='#5_Page_109'>109</a>.</li> +<li>Salivation during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>.</li> +<li>Satyriasis, <a href='#5_Page_185'>185</a>.</li> +<li>Scatalogic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_47'>47</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Scrotum, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>.</li> +<li>Scruple, obsessions of, <a href='#5_Page_7'>7</a>.</li> +<li>Secretions of genital canal, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>.</li> +<li>Semen, + <ul><li>alleged female, <a href='#5_Page_146'>146</a>;</li> +<li> in coitus, <a href='#5_Page_157'>157</a>;</li> +<li> in female genital canal, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>;</li> +<li> vital activity of, <a href='#5_Page_165'>165</a>;</li> +<li> artificial injection of, <a href='#5_Page_166'>166</a>;</li> +<li> constituents of, <a href='#5_Page_171'>171</a>;</li> +<li> as a stimulant, <a href='#5_Page_172'>172</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Sexual anæsthesia, <a href='#5_Page_186'>186</a>.</li> +<li>Sexual conjugation, <a href='#5_Page_116'>116</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Sexual desire during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_229'>229</a>.</li> +<li>Sexual organs, <a href='#5_Page_119'>119</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Sexual selection in relation to erotic symbolism, <a href='#5_Page_106'>106</a>; + <ul><li>in relation to external sexual organs, <a href='#5_Page_127'>127</a>;</li> +<li> the probable cause of the hymen, <a href='#5_Page_140'>140</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Shadow as a fetich, <a href='#5_Page_8'>8</a>.</li> +<li>Shoe, + <ul><li>sexual significance of, <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Shoe-fetichism frequency of, <a href='#5_Page_15'>15</a>; + <ul><li>normal basis of, <a href='#5_Page_16'>16</a>, <a href='#5_Page_27'>27</a>;</li> +<li> illustrated by Restif de la Bretonne, <a href='#5_Page_18'>18</a>;</li> +<li> prevalence of among Chinese, etc., <a href='#5_Page_21'>21</a>;</li> +<li> former prevalence in Europe, <a href='#5_Page_24'>24</a>;</li> +<li> congenital basis of, <a href='#5_Page_27'>27</a>;</li> +<li> acquired element in, <a href='#5_Page_28'>28</a>;</li> +<li> favored by precocity, <a href='#5_Page_29'>29</a>;</li> +<li> relation to masochism, <a href='#5_Page_30'>30</a>;</li> +<li> illustrative cases of, <a href='#5_Page_33'>33</a> <i>et seq.</i>;</li> +<li> dynamic element in, <a href='#5_Page_45'>45</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Sickness of pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Skin, + <ul><li>sexual significance of, <a href='#5_Page_143'>143</a>, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>;</li> +<li> condition of during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_144'>144</a>, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_190'>190</a>;</li> +<li> sexual pigmentation of, <a href='#5_Page_193'>193</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Slipper as a sexual symbol, <a href='#5_Page_25'>25</a>.</li> +<li>Smile, + <ul><li>origin of the, <a href='#5_Page_167'>167</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Sodomy, + <ul><li>the term, <a href='#5_Page_72'>72</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Spain, + <ul><li>sexual attractiveness of foot in, <a href='#5_Page_26'>26</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Spermatozoa reach ova, + <ul><li>how the, <a href='#5_Page_161'>161</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_171'>171</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Spermin, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li> +<li>Sphygmanometer experiments during sexual excitement, <a href='#5_Page_152'>152</a>.</li> +<li>Stature and erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_187'>187</a>.</li> +<li>Stimulants, <a href='#5_Page_178'>178</a>.</li> +<li>Stuff-fetichisms, <a href='#5_Page_73'>73</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Strychnine, + <ul><li>aphrodisiac effects of, <a href='#5_Page_174'>174</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Suggestion in relation to longings of pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_214'>214</a>.</li> +<li>Symbols, + <ul><li>nature of, <a href='#5_Page_3'>3</a>;</li> +<li> of sex in language, <a href='#5_Page_4'>4</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Temperament, + <ul><li>alleged erotic, <a href='#5_Page_182'>182</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Testicular juices, + <ul><li>effects of, <a href='#5_Page_179'>179</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Testes, <a href='#5_Page_123'>123</a>, <a href='#5_Page_181'>181</a>, <a href='#5_Page_197'>197</a>.</li> +<li>Thyroid, + <ul><li>condition during sexual excitement, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>;</li> +<li> during pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_207'>207</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Ticklishness in relation to stuff-fetichisms, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>.</li> +<li>Tumescence in relation to detumescence, <a href='#5_Page_115'>115</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_142'>142</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Unnatural offence, + <ul><li>the term, <a href='#5_Page_72'>72</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Urethra, + <ul><li>variability of female, <a href='#5_Page_120'>120</a>;</li> +<li> an erogenous zone, <a href='#5_Page_133'>133</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Urethrorrhœa ex libidine, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>.</li> +<li>Urinary stream, + <ul><li>in relation to nymphæ, <a href='#5_Page_136'>136</a>;</li> +<li> an alleged index to virginity, <a href='#5_Page_204'>204</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Urine in religious rites, <a href='#5_Page_50'>50</a>; + <ul><li>possesses magical virtues, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>;</li> +<li> in legends, <a href='#5_Page_52'>52</a>;</li> +<li> in medicine, <a href='#5_Page_59'>59</a>;</li> +<li> during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_153'>153</a>, <a href='#5_Page_154'>154</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Urolagnia, <a href='#5_Page_47'>47</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Uterus, <a href='#5_Page_118'>118</a>, <a href='#5_Page_132'>132</a>, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a> <i>et seq.</i>, <a href='#5_Page_194'>194</a>, <a href='#5_Page_210'>210</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Vagina, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_137'>137</a>, <a href='#5_Page_145'>145</a>, <a href='#5_Page_159'>159</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>, <a href='#5_Page_177'>177</a>.</li> +<li>Vaginismus, <a href='#5_Page_13'>13</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li> +<li>Vasomotor conditions during coitus, <a href='#5_Page_151'>151</a>.</li> +<li>Vaudonism, <a href='#5_Page_98'>98</a>.</li> +<li>Virginity, + <ul><li>ancient diagnosis of, <a href='#5_Page_126'>126</a>, <a href='#5_Page_138'>138</a>, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a> <i>et seq.</i></li></ul></li> +<li>Virile reflex, <a href='#5_Page_149'>149</a>.<a name='5_Page_285'></a></li> +<li>Voice, + <ul><li>in relation to erotic temperament, <a href='#5_Page_188'>188</a>;</li> +<li> in relation to virginity, <a href='#5_Page_203'>203</a>.</li></ul></li> +<li>Vomiting of pregnancy, <a href='#5_Page_209'>209</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Vulva, <a href='#5_Page_124'>124</a> <i>et seq.</i> <a href='#5_Page_148'>148</a>, <a href='#5_Page_163'>163</a>.</li> +<li>Vulva-fetichism, <a href='#5_Page_96'>96</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Waist, + <ul><li>origin of admiration for small, <a href='#5_Page_21'>21</a>.</li></ul></li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Yohimbin as an aphrodisiac, <a href='#5_Page_176'>176</a>.</li> +</ul> + + +<ul><li>Zooerastia, <a href='#5_Page_77'>77</a> <i>et seq.</i></li> +<li>Zoophilia erotica, <a href='#5_Page_71'>71</a>, <a href='#5_Page_76'>76</a>.</li> +<li>Zoophilia non-erotic, <a href='#5_Page_77'>77</a>.</li> +</ul> +<br> +<br> +<hr class="pg" noshade> +<p>***END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK STUDIES IN THE PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX, VOLUME 5 (OF 6)***</p> +<p>******* This file should be named 13614-h.txt or 13614-h.zip *******</p> +<p>This and all associated files of various formats will be found in:<br /> +<a href="https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/1/3/6/1/13614">https://www.gutenberg.org/1/3/6/1/13614</a></p> +<p>Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed.</p> + +<p>Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution.</p> + + + +<pre> +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +<a href="https://gutenberg.org/license">https://gutenberg.org/license)</a>. + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS,' WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, is critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at https://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/pglaf. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at https://www.gutenberg.org/about/contact + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit https://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/pglaf + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including including checks, online payments and credit card +donations. To donate, please visit: +https://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +Each eBook is in a subdirectory of the same number as the eBook's +eBook number, often in several formats including plain vanilla ASCII, +compressed (zipped), HTML and others. + +Corrected EDITIONS of our eBooks replace the old file and take over +the old filename and etext number. The replaced older file is renamed. +VERSIONS based on separate sources are treated as new eBooks receiving +new filenames and etext numbers. + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + +<a href="https://www.gutenberg.org">https://www.gutenberg.org</a> + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. + +EBooks posted prior to November 2003, with eBook numbers BELOW #10000, +are filed in directories based on their release date. If you want to +download any of these eBooks directly, rather than using the regular +search system you may utilize the following addresses and just +download by the etext year. + +<a href="https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/etext06/">https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/etext06/</a> + + (Or /etext 05, 04, 03, 02, 01, 00, 99, + 98, 97, 96, 95, 94, 93, 92, 92, 91 or 90) + +EBooks posted since November 2003, with etext numbers OVER #10000, are +filed in a different way. The year of a release date is no longer part +of the directory path. The path is based on the etext number (which is +identical to the filename). The path to the file is made up of single +digits corresponding to all but the last digit in the filename. For +example an eBook of filename 10234 would be found at: + +https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/1/0/2/3/10234 + +or filename 24689 would be found at: +https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/2/4/6/8/24689 + +An alternative method of locating eBooks: +<a href="https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/GUTINDEX.ALL">https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/GUTINDEX.ALL</a> + +*** END: FULL LICENSE *** +</pre> +</body> +</html> diff --git a/old/13614.txt b/old/13614.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b388a4e --- /dev/null +++ b/old/13614.txt @@ -0,0 +1,13501 @@ +The Project Gutenberg eBook, Studies in the Psychology of Sex, Volume 5 +(of 6), by Havelock Ellis + + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + + + + +Title: Studies in the Psychology of Sex, Volume 5 (of 6) + +Author: Havelock Ellis + +Release Date: October 8, 2004 [eBook #13614] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ISO-646-US (US-ASCII) + + +***START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK STUDIES IN THE PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX, +VOLUME 5 (OF 6)*** + + +E-text prepared by Juliet Sutherland and the Project Gutenberg Online +Distributed Proofreading Team (https://www.pgdp.net) + + + +STUDIES IN THE PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX, VOLUME V + + Erotic Symbolism + The Mechanism of Detumescence + The Psychic State in Pregnancy + +by + +HAVELOCK ELLIS + +1927 + + + + + + + +PREFACE. + + +In this volume the terminal phenomena of the sexual process are discussed, +before an attempt is finally made, in the concluding volume, to consider +the bearings of the psychology of sex on that part of morals which may be +called "social hygiene." + +Under "Erotic Symbolism" I include practically all the aberrations of the +sexual instinct, although some of these have seemed of sufficient +importance for separate discussion in previous volumes. It is highly +probable that many readers will consider that the name scarcely suffices +to cover manifestations so numerous and so varied. The term "sexual +equivalents" will seem preferable to some. While, however, it may be fully +admitted that these perversions are "sexual equivalents"--or at all events +equivalents of the normal sexual impulse--that term is merely a +descriptive label which tells us nothing of the phenomena. "Sexual +Symbolism" gives us the key to the process, the key that makes all these +perversions intelligible. In all of them--very clearly in some, as in +shoe-fetichism; more obscurely in others, as in exhibitionism--it has come +about by causes congenital, acquired, or both, that some object or class +of objects, some act or group of acts, has acquired a dynamic power over +the psycho-physical mechanism of the sexual process, deflecting it from +its normal adjustment to the whole of a beloved person of the opposite +sex. There has been a transmutation of values, and certain objects, +certain acts, have acquired an emotional value which for the normal person +they do not possess. Such objects and acts are properly, it seems to me, +termed symbols, and that term embodies the only justification that in most +cases these manifestations can legitimately claim. + +"The Mechanism of Detumescence" brings us at last to the final climax for +which the earlier and more prolonged stage of tumescence, which has +occupied us so often in these _Studies_, is the elaborate preliminary. +"The art of love," a clever woman novelist has written, "is the art of +preparation." That "preparation" is, on the physiological side, the +production of tumescence, and all courtship is concerned in building up +tumescence. But the final conjugation of two individuals in an explosion +of detumescence, thus slowly brought about, though it is largely an +involuntary act, is still not without its psychological implications and +consequences; and it is therefore a matter for regret that so little is +yet known about it. The one physiological act in which two individuals are +lifted out of all ends that center in self and become the instrument of +those higher forces which fashion the species, can never be an act to be +slurred over as trivial or unworthy of study. + +In the brief study of "The Psychic State in Pregnancy" we at last touch +the point at which the whole complex process of sex reaches its goal. A +woman with a child in her womb is the everlasting miracle which all the +romance of love, all the cunning devices of tumescence and detumescence, +have been invented to make manifest. The psychic state of the woman who +thus occupies the supreme position which life has to offer cannot fail to +be of exceeding interest from many points of view, and not least because +the maternal instinct is one of the elements even of love between the +sexes. But the psychology of pregnancy is full of involved problems, and +here again, as so often in the wide field we have traversed, we stand at +the threshold of a door it is not yet given us to pass. + +HAVELOCK ELLIS. + +Carbis Water, Lelant, Cornwall. + + + + +CONTENTS. + + +EROTIC SYMBOLISM. + +I. + +The Definition of Erotic Symbolism. Symbolism of Act and Symbolism of +Object. Erotic Fetichism. Wide Extension of the Symbols of Sex. The +Immense Variety of Possible Erotic Fetiches. The Normal Foundations of +Erotic Symbolism. Classification of the Phenomena. The Tendency to +Idealize the Defects of a Beloved Person. Stendhal's "Crystallization". + +II. + +Foot-fetichism and Shoe-fetichism. Wide Prevalence and Normal Basis. +Restif de la Bretonne. The Foot a Normal Focus of Sexual Attraction Among +Some Peoples. The Chinese, Greeks, Romans, Spaniards, etc. The Congenital +Predisposition in Erotic Symbolism. The Influence of Early Association and +Emotional Shock. Shoe-fetichism in Relation to Masochism. The Two +Phenomena Independent Though Allied. The Desire to be Trodden On. The +Fascination of Physical Constraint. The Symbolism of Self-inflicted Pain. +The Dynamic Element in Erotic Symbolism. The Symbolism of Garments. + +III. + +Scatalogic Symbolism. Urolagnia. Coprolagnia. The Ascetic Attitude Towards +the Flesh. Normal Basis of Scatalogic Symbolism. Scatalogic Conceptions +Among Primitive Peoples. Urine as a Primitive Holy Water. Sacredness of +Animal Excreta. Scatalogy in Folk-lore. The Obscene as Derived from the +Mythological. The Immature Sexual Impulse Tends to Manifest Itself in +Scatalogic Forms. The Basis of Physiological Connection Between the +Urinary and Genital Spheres. Urinary Fetichism Sometimes Normal in +Animals. The Urolagnia of Masochists. The Scatalogy of Saints. Urolagnia +More Often a Symbolism of Act Than a Symbolism of Object. Only +Occasionally an Olfactory Fetichism. Comparative Rarity of Coprolagnia. +Influence of Nates Fetichism as a Transition to Coprolagnia, Ideal +Coprolagnia. Olfactory Coprolagnia. Urolagnia and Coprolagnia as Symbols +of Coitus. + +IV. + +Animals as Sources of Erotic Symbolism. Mixoscopic Zoophilia. The +Stuff-fetichisms. Hair-fetichism. The Stuff-fetichisms Mainly on a Tactile +Base. Erotic Zoophilia. Zooerastia. Bestiality. The Conditions that Favor +Bestiality. Its Wide Prevalence Among Primitive Peoples and Among +Peasants. The Primitive Conception of Animals. The Goat. The Influence of +Familiarity With Animals. Congress Between Women and Animals. The Social +Reaction Against Bestiality. + +V. + +Exhibitionism. Illustrative Cases. A Symbolic Perversion of Courtship. The +Impulse to Defile. The Exhibitionist's Psychic Attitude. The Sexual Organs +as Fetiches. Phallus Worship. Adolescent Pride in Sexual Development. +Exhibitionism of the Nates. The Classification of the Forms of +Exhibitionism. Nature of the Relationship of Exhibitionism to Epilepsy. + +VI. + +The Forms of Erotic Symbolism are Simulacra of Coitus. Wide Extension of +Erotic Symbolism. Fetichism Not Covering the Whole Ground of Sexual +Selection. It is Based on the Individual Factor in Selection. +Crystallization. The Lover and the Artist. The Key to Erotic Symbolism is +to be Found in the Emotional Sphere. The Passage to Pathological Extremes. + + + +THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE. + +I. + +The Psychological Significance of Detumescence. The Testis and the Ovary. +Sperm Cell and Germ Cell. Development of the Embryo. The External Sexual +Organs. Their Wide Range of Variation. Their Nervous Supply. The Penis. +Its Racial Variations. The Influence of Exercise. The Scrotum and +Testicles. The Mons Veneris. The Vulva. The Labia Majora and their +Varieties. The Public Hair and Its Characters. The Clitoris and Its +Functions. The Anus as an Erogenous Zone. The Nymphae and their Function. +The Vagina. The Hymen. Virginity. The Biological Significance of the +Hymen. + +II. + +The Object of Detumescence. Erogenous Zones. The Lips. The Vascular +Characters of Detumescence. Erectile Tissue. Erection in Woman. Mucous +Emission in Women. Sexual Connection. The Human Mode of Intercourse. +Normal Variations. The Motor Characters of Detumescence. Ejaculation. The +Virile Reflex. The General Phenomena of Detumescence. The Circulatory and +Respiratory Phenomena. Blood Pressure. Cardiac Disturbance. Glandular +Activity. Distillatio. The Essentially Motor Character of Detumescence. +Involuntary Muscular Irradiation to Bladder, etc. Erotic Intoxication. +Analogy of Sexual Detumescence and Vesical Tension. The Specifically +Sexual Movements of Detumescence in Man. In Woman. The Spontaneous +Movements of the Genital Canal in Woman. Their Function in Conception. +Part Played by Active Movement of the Spermatozoa. The Artificial +Injection of Semen. The Facial Expression During Detumescence. The +Expression of Joy. The Occasional Serious Effects of Coitus. + +III. + +The Constituents of Semen. Function of the Prostate. The Properties of +Semen. Aphrodisiacs. Alcohol, Opium, etc. Anaphrodisiacs. The Stimulant +Influence of Semen in Coitus. The Internal Effects of Testicular +Secretions. The Influence of Ovarian Secretion. + +IV. + +The Aptitude for Detumescence. Is There an Erotic Temperament? The +Available Standards of Comparison. Characteristics of the Castrated. +Characteristics of Puberty. Characteristics of the State of Detumescence. +Shortness of Stature. Development of the Secondary Sexual Characters. Deep +Voice. Bright Eyes. Glandular Activity. Everted Lips. Pigmentation. +Profuse Hair. Dubious Significance of Many of These Characters. + + +THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY. + +The Relationship of Maternal and Sexual Emotion. Conception and Loss of +Virginity. The Anciently Accepted Signs of This Condition. The Pervading +Effects of Pregnancy on the Organism. Pigmentation. The Blood and +Circulation. The Thyroid. Changes in the Nervous System. The Vomiting of +Pregnancy. The Longings of Pregnant Women. Mental Impressions. Evidence +for and Against Their Validity. The Question Still Open. Imperfection of +Our Knowledge. The Significance of Pregnancy. + + +APPENDIX. + +Histories of Sexual Development. + + +INDEX OF AUTHORS. + + +INDEX OF SUBJECTS. + + + + +EROTIC SYMBOLISM. + +I. + +The Definition of Erotic Symbolism--Symbolism of Act and Symbolism of +Object--Erotic Fetichism--Wide extension of the symbols of Sex--The +Immense Variety of Possible Erotic Fetiches--The Normal Foundations of +Erotic Symbolism--Classification of the Phenomena--The Tendency to +Idealize the Defects of a Beloved Person--Stendhal's "Crystallization." + + +By "erotic symbolism" I mean that tendency whereby the lover's attention +is diverted from the central focus of sexual attraction to some object or +process which is on the periphery of that focus, or is even outside of it +altogether, though recalling it by association of contiguity or of +similarity. It thus happens that tumescence, or even in extreme cases +detumescence, may be provoked by the contemplation of acts or objects +which are away from the end of sexual conjugation.[1] + +In considering the phenomena of sexual selection in a previous volume,[2] +it was found that there are four or five main factors in the constitution +of beauty in so far as beauty determines sexual selection. Erotic +symbolism is founded on the factor of individual taste in beauty; it +arises as a specialized development of that factor, but it is, +nevertheless, incorrect to merge it in sexual selection. The attractive +characteristics of a beloved woman or man, from the point of view of +sexual selection, are a complex but harmonious whole leading up to a +desire for the complete possession of the person who displays them. There +is no tendency to isolate and dissociate any single character from the +individual and to concentrate attention upon that character at the expense +of the attention bestowed upon the individual generally. As soon as such a +tendency begins to show itself, even though only in a slight or temporary +form, we may say that there is erotic symbolism. + +Erotic symbolism is, however, by no means confined to the individualizing +tendency to concentrate amorous attention upon some single characteristic +of the adult woman or man who is normally the object of sexual love. The +adult human being may not be concerned at all, the attractive object or +act may not even be human, not even animal, and we may still be concerned +with a symbol which has parasitically rooted itself on the fruitful site +of sexual emotion and absorbed to itself the energy which normally goes +into the channels of healthy human love having for its final end the +procreation of the species. Thus understood in its widest sense, it may be +said that every sexual perversion, even homosexuality, is a form of erotic +symbolism, for we shall find that in every case some object or act that +for the normal human being has little or no erotic value, has assumed such +value in a supreme degree; that is to say, it has become a symbol of the +normal object of love. Certain perversions are, however, of such great +importance on account of their wide relationships, that they cannot be +adequately discussed merely as forms of erotic symbolism. This is notably +the case as regards homosexuality, auto-erotism, and algolagnia, all of +which phenomena have therefore been separately discussed in previous +studies. We are now mainly concerned with manifestations which are more +narrowly and exclusively symbolical. + +A portion of the field of erotic symbolism is covered by what Binet +(followed by Lombroso, Krafft-Ebing, and others) has termed "erotic +fetichism," or the tendency whereby sexual attraction is unduly exerted by +some special part or peculiarity of the body, or by some inanimate object +which has become associated with it. Such erotic symbolism of object +cannot, however, be dissociated from the even more important erotic +symbolism of process, and the two are so closely bound together that we +cannot attain a truly scientific view of them until we regard them broadly +as related parts of a common psychic tendency. If, as Groos asserts,[3] a +symbol has two chief meanings, one in which it indicates a physical +process which stands for a psychic process, and another in which it +indicates a part which represents the whole, erotic symbolism of act +corresponds to the first of these chief meanings, and erotic symbolism of +object to the other. + +Although it is not impossible to find some germs of erotic symbolism in +animals, in its more pronounced manifestations it is only found in the +human species. It could not be otherwise, for such symbolism involves not +only the play of fancy and imagination, the idealizing aptitude, but also +a certain amount of power of concentrating the attention on a point +outside the natural path of instinct and the ability to form new mental +constructions around that point. There are, indeed, as we shall see, +elementary forms of erotic symbolism which are not uncommonly associated +with feeble-mindedness, but even these are still peculiarly human, and in +its less crude manifestations erotic symbolism easily lends itself to +every degree of human refinement and intelligence. + + "It depends primarily upon an increase of the psychological + process of representation," Colin Scott remarks of sexual + symbolism generally, "involving greater powers of comparison and + analysis as compared with the lower animals. The outer + impressions come to be clearly distinguished as such, but at the + same time are often treated as symbols of inner experiences, and + a meaning read into them which they would not otherwise possess. + Symbolism or fetichism is, indeed, just the capacity to see + meaning, to emphasize something for the sake of other things + which do not appear. In brain terms it indicates an activity of + the higher centers, a sort of side-tracking or long-circuiting of + the primitive energy; ... Rosetti's poem, 'The Woodspurge,' + gives a concrete example of the formation of such a symbol. Here + the otherwise insignificant presentation of the three-cupped + woodspurge, representing originally a mere side-current of the + stream of consciousness, becomes the intellectual symbol or + fetich of the whole psychosis forever after. It seems, indeed, as + if the stronger the emotion the more likely will become the + formation of an overlying symbolism, which serves to focus and + stand in the place of something greater than itself; nowhere at + least is symbolism a more characteristic feature than as an + expression of the sexual instinct. The passion of sex, with its + immense hereditary background, in early man became centered often + upon the most trivial and unimportant features.... This + symbolism, now become fetichistic, or symbolic in a bad sense, is + at least an exercise of the increasing representative power of + man, upon which so much of his advancement has depended, while it + also served to express and help to purify his most perennial + emotion." (Colin Scott, "Sex and Art," _American Journal of + Psychology_, vol. vii, No. 2, p. 189.) + +In the study of "Love and Pain" in a previous volume, the analysis of the +large and complex mass of sexual phenomena which are associated with pain, +gradually resolved them to a considerable extent into a special case of +erotic symbolism; pain or restraint, whether inflicted on or by the loved +person, becomes, by a psychic process that is usually unconscious, the +symbol of the sexual mechanism, and hence arouses the same emotions as +that mechanism normally arouses. We may now attempt to deal more broadly +and comprehensively with the normal and abnormal aspects of erotic +symbolism in some of their most typical and least mixed forms. + +"When our human imagination seeks to animate artificial things," Huysmans +writes in _La-bas_, "it is compelled to reproduce the movements of animals +in the act of propagation. Look at machines, at the play of pistons in the +cylinders; they are Romeos of steel in Juliets of cast-iron." And not only +in the work of man's hands but throughout Nature we find sexual symbols +which are the less deniable since, for the most part, they make not the +slightest appeal to even the most morbid human imagination. Language is +full of metaphorical symbols of sex which constantly tend to lose their +poetic symbolism and to become commonplace. Semen is but seed, and for the +Latins especially the whole process of human sex, as well as the male and +female organs, constantly presented itself in symbols derived from +agricultural and horticultural life. The testicles were beans (_fabae_) and +fruit or apples (_poma_ and _mala_); the penis was a tree (_arbor_), or a +stalk (_thyrsus_), or a root (_radix_), or a sickle (_falx_), or a +ploughshare (_vomer_). The semen, again, was dew (_ros_). The labia majora +or minora were wings (_alae_); the vulva and vagina were a field (_ager_ +and _campus_), or a ploughed furrow (_sulcus_), or a vineyard (_vinea_), +or a fountain (_fons_), while the pudendal hair was herbage +(_plantaria_).[4] In other languages it is not difficult to trace similar +and even identical imagery applied to sexual organs and sexual acts. Thus +it is noteworthy that Shakespeare more than once applies the term +"ploughed" to a woman who has had sexual intercourse. The Talmud calls the +labia minora the doors, the labia majora hinges, and the clitoris the key. +The Greeks appear not only to have found in the myrtle-berry, the fruit of +a plant sacred to Venus, the image of the clitoris, but also in the rose +an image of the feminine labia; in the poetic literature of many +countries, indeed, this imagery of the rose may be traced in a more or +less veiled manner.[5] + +The widespread symbolism of sex arose in the theories and conceptions of +primitive peoples concerning the function of generation and its nearest +analogies in Nature; it was continued for the sake of the vigorous and +expressive terminology which it furnished both for daily life and for +literature; its final survivals were cultivated because they furnished a +delicately aesthetic method of approaching matters which a growing +refinement of sentiment made it difficult for lovers and poets to approach +in a more crude and direct manner. Its existence is of interest to us now +because it shows the objective validity of the basis on which erotic +symbolism, as we have here to understand it, develops. But from first to +last it is a distinct phenomenon, having a more or less reasoned and +intellectual basis, and it scarcely serves in any degree to feed the +sexual impulse. Erotic symbolism is not intellectual but emotional in its +origin; it starts into being, obscurely, with but a dim consciousness or +for the most part none at all, either suddenly from the shock of some +usually youthful experience, or more gradually through an instinctive +brooding on those things which are most intimately associated with a +sexually desirable person. + + The kind of soil on which the germs of erotic symbolism may + develop is well seen in cases of sexual hyperaesthesia. In such + cases all the emotionally sexual analogies and resemblances, + which in erotic symbolism are fixed and organized, may be traced + in vague and passing forms, a single hyperaesthetic individual + perhaps presenting a great variety of germinal symbolisms. + + Thus it has been recorded of an Italian nun (whose sister became + a prostitute) that from the age of 8 she had desire for coitus, + from the age of 10 masturbated, and later had homosexual + feelings, that the same feelings and practices continued after + she had taken the veil, though from time to time they assumed + religious equivalents. The mere contact, indeed, of a priest's + hand, the news of the presentation of an ecclesiastic she had + known to a bishopric, the sight of an ape, the contemplation of + the crucified Christ, the figure of a toy, the picture of a + demon, the act of defecation in the children entrusted to her + care (whom, on this account, and against the regulations, she + would accompany to the closets), especially the sight and the + mere recollection of flies in sexual connection--all these things + sufficed to produce in her a powerful orgasm. (_Archivio di + Psichiatria_, 1902, fasc. II-III, p. 338.) + + A boy of 15 (given to masturbation), studied by Macdonald in + America, was similarly hyperaesthetic to the symbols of sexual + emotion. "I like amusing myself with my comrades," he told + Macdonald, "rolling ourselves into a ball, which gives one a + funny kind of warmth. I have a special pleasure in talking about + some things. It is the same when the governess kisses me on + saying good night or when I lean against her breast. I have that + sensation, too, when I see some of the pictures in the comic + papers, but only in those representing a woman, as when a young + man skating trips up a girl so that her clothes are raised a + little. When I read how a man saved a young girl from drowning, + so that they swam together, I had the same sensation. Looking at + the statues of women in the museum produces the same effect, or + when I see naked babies, or when a mother suckles a child. I + have often had that sensation when reading novels I ought not to + read, or when looking at a new-born calf, or seeing dogs and cows + and horses mounting on each other. When I see a girl flirting + with a boy, or leaning on his shoulder or with his arm round her + waist, I have an erection. It is the same when I see women and + little girls in bathing costume, or when boys talk of what their + fathers and mothers do together. In the Natural History Museum I + often see things which give me that sensation. One day when I + read how a man killed a young girl and carried her into a wood + and undressed her I had a feeling of enjoyment. When I read of + men who were bastards the idea of a woman having a child in that + way gives me this sensation. Some dances, and seeing young girls + astride a horse, excited me, too, and so in a circus when a woman + was shot out of a cannon and her skirts flew in the air. It has + no effect on me when I see men naked. Sometimes I enjoy seeing + women's underclothes in a shop, or when I see a lady or a girl + buying them, especially if they are drawers. When I saw a lady in + a dress which buttoned from top to bottom it had more effect on + me than seeing underclothes. Seeing dogs coupling gives me more + pleasure than looking at pretty women, but less than looking at + pretty little girls." In order of increasing intensity he placed + the phenomena that affected him thus: The coupling of flies, then + of horses, then the sight of women's undergarments, then a boy + and a girl flirting, then cows mounting on each other, the + statues of women with naked breasts, then contact with the + governess's body and breasts, finally coitus. (Arthur Macdonald, + _Le Criminel-Type_, pp. 126 et seq.) + + It is worthy of remark that the instinct of nutrition, when + restrained, may exhibit something of an analogous symbolism, + though in a minor degree, to that of sex. The ways in which a + hyperaesthetic hunger may seek its symbols are illustrated in the + case of a young woman called Nadia, who during several years was + carefully studied by Janet. It is a case of obsession ("maladie + du scrupule"), simulating hysterical anorexia, in which the + patient, for fear of getting fat, reduced her nourishment to the + smallest possible amount. "Nadia is generally hungry, even very + hungry. One can tell this by her actions; from time to time she + forgets herself to such an extent as to devour greedily anything + she can put her hands on. At other times, when she cannot resist + the desire to eat, she secretly takes a biscuit. She feels + horrible remorse for the action, but, all the same, she does it + again. Her confidences are very curious. She recognizes that a + great effort is needed to avoid eating, and considers she is a + heroine to resist so long. 'Sometimes I spent whole hours in + thinking about food, I was so hungry; I swallowed my saliva, I + bit my handkerchief, I rolled on the floor, I wanted to eat so + badly. I would look in books for descriptions of meals and + feasts, and tried to deceive my hunger by imagining that I was + sharing all these good things,'" (P. Janet, "La Maladie du + Scrupule," _Revue Philosophique_, May, 1901, p. 502.) The + deviations of the instinct of nutrition are, however, confined + within narrow limits, and, in the nature of things, hunger, + unlike sexual desire, cannot easily accept a fetich. + +"There is almost no feature, article of dress, attitude, act," Stanley +Hall declares, "or even animal or perhaps object in nature, that may not +have to some morbid soul specialized erogenic and erethic power."[6] Even +a mere shadow may become a fetich. Goron tells of a merchant in Paris--a +man with a reputation for ability, happily married and the father of a +family, altogether irreproachable in his private life--who was returning +home one evening after a game of billiards with a friend, when, on +chancing to raise his eyes, he saw against a lighted window the shadow of +a woman changing her chemise. He fell in love with that shadow and +returned to the spot every evening for many months to gaze at the window. +Yet--and herein lies the fetichism--he made no attempt to see the woman or +to find out who she was; the shadow sufficed; he had no need of the +realty.[7] It is even possible to have a negative fetich, the absence of +some character being alone demanded, and the case has been recorded in +Chicago of an American gentleman of average intelligence, education, and +good habits who, having as a boy cherished a pure affection for a girl +whose leg had been amputated, throughout life was relatively impotent with +normal women, but experienced passion and affection for women who had lost +a leg; he was found by his wife to be in extensive correspondence with +one-legged women all over the country, expending no little money on the +purchase of artificial legs for his various protegees.[8] + +It is important to remember, however, that while erotic symbolism becomes +fantastic and abnormal in its extreme manifestations, it is in its +essence absolutely normal. It is only in the very grossest forms of sexual +desire that it is altogether absent. Stendhal described the mental side of +the process of tumescence as a crystallization, a process whereby certain +features of the beloved person present points around which the emotions +held in solution in the lover's mind may concentrate and deposit +themselves in dazzling brilliance. This process inevitably tends to take +place around all those features and objects associated with the beloved +person which have most deeply impressed the lover's mind, and the more +sensitive and imaginative and emotional he is the more certainly will such +features and objects crystallize into erotic symbols. "Devotion and love," +wrote Mary Wollstonecraft, "may be allowed to hallow the garments as well +as the person, for the lover must want fancy who has not a sort of sacred +respect for the glove or slipper of his mistress. He would not confound +them with vulgar things of the same kind." And nearly two centuries +earlier Burton, who had gathered together so much of the ancient lore of +love, clearly asserted the entirely normal character of erotic symbolism. +"Not one of a thousand falls in love," he declares, "but there is some +peculiar part or other which pleaseth most, and inflames him above the +rest.... If he gets any remnant of hers, a busk-point, a feather of her +fan, a shoe-tie, a lace, a ring, a bracelet of hair, he wears it for a +favor on his arm, in his hat, finger, or next his heart; as Laodamia did +by Protesilaus, when he went to war, sit at home with his picture before +her: a garter or a bracelet of hers is more precious than any Saint's +Relique, he lays it up in his casket (O blessed Relique) and every day +will kiss it: if in her presence his eye is never off her, and drink he +will where she drank, if it be possible, in that very place," etc.[9] + + Burton's accuracy in describing the ways of lovers in his century + is shown by a passage in Hamilton's _Memoires de Gramont_. Miss + Price, one of the beauties of Charles II's court, and Dongan were + tenderly attached to each other; when the latter died he left + behind a casket full of all possible sorts of love-tokens + pertaining to his mistress, including, among other things, "all + kinds of hair." And as regards France, Burton's contemporary, + Howell, wrote in 1627 in his _Familiar Letters_ concerning the + repulse of the English at Rhe: "A captain told me that when they + were rifling the dead bodies of the French gentlemen after the + first invasion they found that many of them had their mistresses' + favors tied about their genitories." + + Schurig (_Spermatologia_, p. 357) at the beginning of the + eighteenth century knew a Belgian lady who, when her dearly loved + husband died, secretly cut off his penis and treasured it as a + sacred relic in a silver casket. She eventually powdered it, he + adds, and found it an efficacious medicine for herself and + others. An earlier example, of a lady at the French court who + embalmed and perfumed the genital organs of her dead husband, + always preserving them in a gold casket, is mentioned by + Brantome. Mantegazza knew a man who kept for many years on his + desk the skull of his dead mistress, making it his dearest + companion. "Some," he remarks, "have slept for months and years + with a book, a garment, a trifle. I once had a friend who would + spend long hours of joy and emotion kissing a thread of silk + which _she_ had held between her fingers, now the only relic of + love." (Mantegazza, _Fisiologia dell' Amore_, cap. X.) In the + same way I knew a lady who in old age still treasured in her + desk, as the one relic of the only man she had ever been + attracted to, a fragment of paper he had casually twisted up in a + conversation with her half a century before. + +The tendency to treasure the relics of a beloved person, more especially +the garments, is the simplest and commonest foundation of erotic +symbolism. It is without doubt absolutely normal. It is inevitable that +those objects which have been in close contact with the beloved person's +body, and are intimately associated with that person in the lover's mind, +should possess a little of the same virtue, the same emotional potency. It +is a phenomenon closely analogous to that by which the relics of saints +are held to possess a singular virtue. But it becomes somewhat less normal +when the garment is regarded as essential even in the presence of the +beloved person.[10] + +While an extremely large number of objects and acts may be found to +possess occasionally the value of erotic symbols, such symbols most +frequently fall into certain well-defined groups. A vast number of +isolated objects or acts may be exceptionally the focus of erotic +contemplation, but the objects and acts which frequently become thus +symbolic are comparatively few. + +It seems to me that the phenomena of erotic symbolism may be most +conveniently grouped in three great classes, on the basis of the objects +or acts which arouse them. + +I. PARTS OF THE BODY.--_A. Normal:_ Hand, foot, breasts, nates, hair, +secretions and excretions, etc. + +_B. Abnormal:_ Lameness, squinting, pitting of smallpox, etc. Paidophilia +or the love of children, presbyophilia or the love of the aged, and +necrophilia or the attraction for corpses, may be included under this +head, as well as the excitement caused by various animals. + + +II. INANIMATE OBJECTS.[11]--_A. Garments:_ Gloves, shoes and stockings and +garters, caps, aprons, handkerchiefs, underlinen. + +_B. Impersonal Objects:_ Here may be included all the various objects that +may accidentally acquire the power of exciting sexual feeling in +auto-erotism. Pygmalionism may also be included. + + +III. ACTS AND ATTITUDES.--_A. Active:_ Whipping, cruelty, exhibitionism. +_B. Passive:_ Being whipped, experiencing cruelty. Personal odors and the +sound of the voice may be included under this head. _C. Mixoscopic:_ The +vision of climbing, swinging, etc. The acts of urination and defecation. +The coitus of animals. + +Although the three main groups into which the phenomena of erotic +symbolism are here divided may seem fairly distinct, they are yet very +closely allied, and indeed overlap, so that it is possible, as we shall +see, for a single complex symbol to fall into all three groups. + +A very complete kind of erotic symbolism is furnished by Pygmalionism or +the love of statues.[12] It is exactly analogous to the child's love of a +doll, which is also a form of sexual (though not erotic) symbolism. In a +somewhat less abnormal form, erotic symbolism probably shows itself in its +simplest shape in the tendency to idealize unbeautiful peculiarities in a +beloved person, so that such peculiarities are ever afterward almost or +quite essential in order to arouse sexual attraction. In this way men have +become attracted to limping women. Even the most normal man may idealize a +trifling defect in a beloved woman. The attention is inevitably +concentrated on any such slight deviation from regular beauty, and the +natural result of such concentration is that a complexus of associated +thoughts and emotions becomes attached to something that in itself is +unbeautiful. A defect becomes an admired focus of attention, the embodied +symbol of the lover's emotion. + + Thus a mole is not in itself beautiful, but by the tendency to + erotic symbolism it becomes so. Persian poets especially have + lavished the richest imagery on moles (_Anis El-Ochchaq_ in + _Bibliotheque des Hautes Etudes_, fasc, 25, 1875); the Arabs, as + Lane remarks (_Arabian Society in the Middle Ages_, p. 214), are + equally extravagant in their admiration of a mole. + + Stendhal long since well described the process by which a defect + becomes a sexual symbol. "Even little defects in a woman's face," + he remarked, "such as a smallpox pit, may arouse the tenderness + of a man who loves her, and throw him into deep reverie when he + sees them in another woman. It is because he has experienced a + thousand feelings in the presence of that smallpox mark, that + these feelings have been for the most part delicious, all of the + highest interest, and that, whatever they may have been, they are + renewed with incredible vivacity on the sight of this sign, even + when perceived on the face of another woman. If in such a case we + come to prefer and love _ugliness_, it is only because in such a + case ugliness is beauty. A man loved a woman who was very thin + and marked by smallpox; he lost her by death. Three years later, + in Rome, he became acquainted with two women, one very beautiful, + the other thin and marked by smallpox, on that account, if you + will, rather ugly. I saw him in love with this plain one at the + end of a week, which he had employed in effacing her plainness by + his memories." (_De l'Amour_, Chapter XVII.) + +In the tendency to idealize the unbeautiful features of a beloved person +erotic symbolism shows itself in a simple and normal form. In a less +simple and more morbid form it appears in persons in whom the normal paths +of sexual gratification are for some reasons inhibited, and who are thus +led to find the symbols of natural love in unnatural perversions. It is +for this reason that so many erotic symbolisms take root in childhood and +puberty, before the sexual instincts have reached full development. It is +for the same reason also, that, at the other end of life, when the sexual +energies are failing, erotic symbols sometimes tend to be substituted for +the normal pleasures of sex. It is for this reason, again, that both men +and women whose normal energies are inhibited sometimes find the symbols +of sexual gratification in the caresses of children. + + The case of a schoolmistress recorded by Penta instructively + shows how an erotic symbolism of this last kind may develop by no + means as a refinement of vice, but as the one form in which + sexual gratification becomes possible when normal gratification + has been pathologically inhibited. F.R., aged 48, schoolmistress; + she was some years ago in an asylum with religious mania, but + came out well in a few months. At the age of 12 she had first + experienced sexual excitement in a railway train from the jolting + of the carriage. Soon after she fell in love with a youth who + represented her ideal and who returned her affection. When, + however, she gave herself to him, great was her disillusion and + surprise to find that the sexual act which she had looked forward + to could not be accomplished, for at the first contact there was + great pain and spasmodic resistance of the vagina. There was a + condition of vaginismus. After repeated attempts on subsequent + occasions her lover desisted. Her desire for intercourse + increased, however, rather than diminished, and at last she was + able to tolerate coitus, but the pain was so great that she + acquired a horror of the sexual embrace and no longer sought it. + Having much will power, she restrained all erotic impulses during + many years. It was not until the period of the menopause that the + long repressed desires broke out, and at last found a symbolical + outlet that was no longer normal, but was felt to supply a + complete gratification. She sought the close physical contact of + the young children in her care. She would lie on her bed naked, + with two or three naked children, make them suck her breasts and + press them to every part of her body. Her conduct was discovered + by means of other children who peeped through the keyhole, and + she was placed under Penta for treatment. In this case the loss + of moral and mental inhibition, due probably to troubles of the + climacteric, led to indulgence, under abnormal conditions, in + those primitive contacts which are normally the beginning of + love, and these, supported by the ideal image of the early lover, + constituted a complete and adequate symbol of natural love in a + morbidly perverted individual. (P. Penta, _Archivio delle + Psicopatie Sessuali_, January, 1896.) + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[1] The term "erotic symbolism" has already been employed by Eulenburg +(_Sexuale Neuropathie_, 1895, p. 101). It must be borne in mind that this +term, implying the specific emotion, is much narrower than the term +"sexual symbolism," which may be used to designate a great variety of +ritual and social practices which have played a part in the evolution of +civilization. + +[2] _Sexual Selection in Man_, iv, "Vision." + +[3] K. Groos, _Der AEsthetische Genuss_, p. 122. The psychology of the +associations of contiguity and resemblance through which erotic symbolism +operates its transference is briefly discussed by Ribot in the _Psychology +of the Emotions_, Part 1, Chapter XII; the early chapters of the same +author's _Logique des Sentiments_ may also be said to deal with the +emotional basis on which erotic symbolism arises. + +[4] A number of synonyms for the female pudenda are brought together by +Schurig--cunnus, hortus, concha, navis, fovea, larva, canis, annulus, +focus, cymba, antrum, delta, myrtus, etc.--and he discusses many of them. +(_Muliebria_, Section I, cap. I.) + +[5] Kleinpaul, _Sprache Ohne Worte_, pp. 24-29; cf. K. Pearson, on the +general and special words for sex, _Chances of Death_, vol. ii, pp. +112-245; a selection of the literature of the rose will be found in a +volume of translations entitled _Ros Rosarum_. + +[6] G.S. Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. i, p. 470. + +[7] Goron, _Les Parias de l'Amour_, p. 45. + +[8] A.R. Reynolds, _Medical Standard_, vol. x, cited by Kiernan, +"Responsibility in Sexual Perversion," _American Journal of Neurology and +Psychiatry_, 1882. + +[9] R. Burton, _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. II, +Subs. II, and Mem. III, Subs. I. + +[10] Numerous examples are given by Moll, _Kontraere Sexualempfindung_, +third edition, pp. 265-268. + +[11] Chevalier (_De l'Inversion_, 1885; id., _L'Inversion Sexuelle_, 1892, +p. 52), followed by E. Laurent (_L'Amour Morbide_, 1891, Chapter X), +separates this group from other fetichistic perversions, under the head of +"azooephilie." I see no adequate ground for this step. The various forms of +fetichism are too intimately associated to permit of any group of them +being violently separated from the others. + +[12] This has already been considered as a perversion founded on vision, +in discussing _Sexual Selection in Man_. IV. + + + + +II. + +Foot-fetichism and Shoe-fetichism--Wide Prevalence and Normal +Basis--Restif de la Bretonne--The Foot a Normal Focus of Sexual Attraction +Among Some Peoples--The Chinese, Greeks, Romans, Spaniards, etc.--The +Congenital Predisposition in Erotic Symbolism--The Influence of Early +Association and Emotional Shock--Shoe-fetichism in Relation to +Masochism--The Two Phenomena Independent Though Allied--The Desire to be +Trodden On--The Fascination of Physical Constraint--The Symbolism of +Self-inflicted Pain--The Dynamic Element in Erotic Symbolism--The +Symbolism of Garments. + + +Of all forms of erotic symbolism the most frequent is that which idealizes +the foot and the shoe. The phenomena we here encounter are sometimes so +complex and raise so many interesting questions that it is necessary to +discuss them somewhat fully. + +It would seem that even for the normal lover the foot is one of the most +attractive parts of the body. Stanley Hall found that among the parts +specified as most admired in the other sex by young men and women who +answered a _questionnaire_ the feet came fourth (after the eyes, hair, +stature and size).[13] Casanova, an acute student and lover of women who +was in no degree a foot fetichist, remarks that all men who share his +interest in women are attracted by their feet; they offer the same +interest, he considers, as the question of the particular edition offers +to the book-lover.[14] + + In a report of the results of a _questionnaire_ concerning + children's sense of self, to which over 500 replies were + received, Stanley Hall thus summarizes the main facts ascertained + with reference to the feet: "A special period of noticing the + feet comes somewhat later than that in which the hands are + discovered to consciousness. Our records afford nearly twice as + many cases for feet as for hands. The former are more remote from + the primary psychic focus or position, and are also more often + covered, so that the sight of them is a more marked and + exceptional event. Some children become greatly excited whenever + their feet are exposed. Some infants show signs of fear at the + movement of their own knees and feet covered, and still more + often fright is the first sensation which signalizes the child's + discovery of its feet.... Many are described as playing with them + as if fascinated by strange, newly-discovered toys. They pick + them up and try to throw them away, or out of the cradle, or + bring them to the mouth, where all things tend to go.... Children + often handle their feet, pat and stroke them, offer them toys and + the bottle, as if they, too, had an independent hunger to + gratify, an _ego_ of their own.... Children often develop [later] + a special interest in the feet of others, and examine, feel them, + etc., sometimes expressing surprise that the pinch of the + mother's toe hurts her and not the child, or comparing their own + and the feet of others point by point. Curious, too, are the + intensifications of foot-consciousness throughout the early years + of childhood, whenever children have the exceptional privilege of + going barefoot, or have new shoes. The feet are often + apostrophized, punished, beaten sometimes to the point of pain + for breaking things, throwing the child down, etc. Several + children have habits, which reach great intensity, and then + vanish, of touching or tickling the feet, with gales of laughter, + and a few are described as showing an almost morbid reluctance to + wear anything upon the feet, or even to having them touched by + others.... Several almost fall in love with the great toe or the + little one, especially admiring some crease or dimple in it, + dressing it in some rag of silk or bit of ribbon, or cut-off + glove fingers, winding it with string, prolonging it by tying on + bits of wood. Stroking the feet of others, especially if they are + shapely, often becomes almost a passion with young children, and + several adults confess a survival of the same impulse which it is + an exquisite pleasure to gratify. The interest of some mothers in + babies' toes, the expressions of which are ecstatic and almost + incredible, is a factor of great importance." (G. Stanley Hall, + "Some Aspects of the Early Sense of Self," _American Journal of + Psychology_, April, 1898.) In childhood, Stanley Hall remarks + elsewhere (_Adolescence_, vol. ii, p. 104), "a form of courtship + may consist solely in touching feet under the desk." It would + seem that even animals have a certain amount of sexual + consciousness in the feet; I have noticed a male donkey, just + before coitus, bite the feet of his partner. + +At the same time it is scarcely usual for the normal lover, in most +civilized countries to-day, to attach primary importance to the foot, such +as he very frequently attaches to the eyes, though the feet play a very +conspicuous part in the work of certain novelists.[15] + +In a small but not inconsiderable minority of persons, however, the foot +or the boot becomes the most attractive part of a woman, and in some +morbid cases the woman herself is regarded as a comparatively unimportant +appendage to her feet or her boots. The boots under civilized conditions +much more frequently constitute the sexual symbol than do the feet +themselves; this is not surprising since in ordinary life the feet are not +often seen. + + It is usually only under exceptionally favoring conditions that + foot-fetichism occurs, as in the case recorded by Marandon de + Montyel of a doctor who had been brought up in the West Indies. + His mother had been insane and he himself was subject to + obsessions, especially of being incapable of urinating; he had + had nocturnal incontinence of urine in childhood. All the women + of the people in the West Indies go about with naked feet, which + are often beautiful. His puberty evolved under this influence, + and foot-fetichism developed. He especially admired large, fat, + arched feet, with delicate skin and large, regular toes. He + masturbated with images of feet. At 15 he had relations with a + colored chambermaid, but feared to mention his fetichism, though + it was the touch of her feet that chiefly excited him. He now + gave up masturbation, and had a succession of mistresses, but was + always ashamed to confess his fancies until, at the age of 33, in + Paris, a very intelligent woman who had become his mistress + discovered his mania and skillfully enabled him to yield to it + without shock to his modesty. He was devoted to this mistress, + who had very beautiful feet (he had been horrified by the feet of + Europeans generally), until she finally left him. (_Archives de + Neurologie_, October, 1904.) + + Probably the first case of shoe-fetichism ever recorded in any + detail is that of Restif de la Bretonne (1734-1806), publicist + and novelist, one of the most remarkable literary figures of the + later eighteenth century in France. Restif was a neurotic + subject, though not to an extreme degree, and his shoe-fetichism, + though distinctly pronounced, was not pathological; that is to + say, that the shoe was not itself an adequate gratification of + the sexual impulse, but simply a highly important aid to + tumescence, a prelude to the natural climax of detumescence; only + occasionally, and _faute de mieux_, in the absence of the beloved + person, was the shoe used as an adjunct to masturbation. In + Restif's stories and elsewhere the attraction of the shoe is + frequently discussed or used as a motive. His first decided + literary success, _Le Pied de Fanchette_, was suggested by a + vision of a girl with a charming foot, casually seen in the + street. While all such passages in his books are really founded + on his own personal feelings and experiences, in his elaborate + autobiography, _Monsieur Nicolas_, he has frankly set forth the + gradual evolution and cause of his idiosyncrasy. The first + remembered trace dated from the age of 4, when he was able to + recall having remarked the feet of a young girl in his native + place. Restif was a sexually precocious youth, and at the age of + 9, though both delicate in health and shy in manners, his + thoughts were already absorbed in the girls around him. "While + little Monsieur Nicolas," he tells us, "passed for a Narcissus, + his thoughts, as soon as he was alone, by night or by day, had no + other object than that sex he seemed to flee from. The girls most + careful of their persons were naturally those who pleased him + most, and as the part least easy to keep clean is that which + touches the earth it was to the foot-gear that he mechanically + gave his chief attention. Agathe, Reine, and especially + Madeleine, were the most elegant of the girls at that time; their + carefully selected and kept shoes, instead of laces or buckles, + which were not yet worn at Sacy, had blue or rose ribbon, + according to the color of the skirt. I thought of these girls + with emotion; I desired--I knew not what; but I desired + something, if it were only to subdue them." The origin Restif + here assigns to his shoe-fetichism may seem paradoxical; he + admired the girls who were most clean and neat in their dress, he + tells us, and, therefore, paid most attention to that part of + their clothing which was least clean and neat. But, however + paradoxical the remark may seem, it is psychologically sound. All + fetichism is a kind of not necessarily morbid obsession, and as + the careful work of Janet and others in that field has shown, an + obsession is a fascinated attraction to some object or idea + which gives the subject a kind of emotional shock by its + contrast to his habitual moods or ideas. The ordinary morbid + obsession cannot usually be harmoniously co-ordinated with the + other experiences of the subject's daily life, and shows, + therefore, no tendency to become pleasurable. Sexual fetichisms, + on the other hand, have a reservoir of agreeable emotion to draw + on, and are thus able to acquire both stability and harmony. It + will also be seen that no element of masochism is involved in + Restif's fetichism, though the mistake has been frequently made + of supposing that these two manifestations are usually or even + necessarily allied. Restif wishes to subject the girl who + attracts him, he has no wish to be subjected by her. He was + especially dazzled by a young girl from another town, whose shoes + were of a fashionable cut, with buckles, "and who was a charming + person besides." She was delicate as a fairy, and rendered his + thoughts unfaithful to the robust beauties of his native Sacy. + "No doubt," he remarks, "because, being frail and weak myself, it + seemed to me that it would be easier to subdue her." "This taste + for the beauty of the feet," he continues, "was so powerful in me + that it unfailingly aroused desire and would have made me + overlook ugliness. It is excessive in all those who have it." He + admired the foot as well as the shoe: "The factitious taste for + the shoe is only a reflection of that for pretty feet. When I + entered a house and saw the boots arranged in a row, as is the + custom, I would tremble with pleasure; I blushed and lowered my + eyes as if in the presence of the girls themselves. With this + vivacity of feeling and a voluptuousness of ideas inconceivable + at the age of 10 I still fled, with an involuntary impulse of + modesty, from the girls I adored." + + We may clearly see how this combination of sensitive and + precocious sexual ardor with extreme shyness, furnished the soil + on which the germ of shoe-fetichism was able to gain a firm root + and persist in some degree throughout a long life very largely + given up to a pursuit of women, abnormal rather by its + excessiveness than its perversity. A few years later, he tells + us, he happened to see a pretty pair of shoes in a bootmaker's + shop, and on hearing that they belonged to a girl whom at that + time he reverently adored at a distance he blushed and nearly + fainted. + + In 1749 he was for a time attracted to a young woman very much + older than himself; he secretly carried away one of her slippers + and kept it for a day; a little later he again took away a shoe + of the same woman which had fascinated him when on her foot, and, + he seems to imply, he used it to masturbate with. + + Perhaps the chief passion of Restif's life was his love for + Colette Parangon. He was still a boy (1752), she was the young + and virtuous wife of the printer whose apprentice Restif was and + in whose house he lived. Madame Parangon, a charming woman, as + she is described, was not happily married, and she evidently + felt a tender affection for the boy whose excessive love and + reverence for her were not always successfully concealed. + "Madonna Parangon," he tells us, "possessed a charm which I could + never resist, a pretty little foot; it is a charm which arouses + more than tenderness. Her shoes, made in Paris, had that + voluptuous elegance which seems to communicate soul and life. + Sometimes Colette wore shoes of simple white drugget or with + silver flowers; sometimes rose-colored slippers with green heels, + or green with rose heels; her supple feet, far from deforming her + shoes, increased their grace and rendered the form more + exciting." One day, on entering the house, he saw Madame Parangon + elegantly dressed and wearing rose-colored shoes with tongues, + and with green heels and a pretty rosette. They were new and she + took them off to put on green slippers with rose heels and + borders which he thought equally exciting. As soon as she had + left the room, he continues, "carried away by the most impetuous + passion and idolizing Colette, I seemed to see her and touch her + in handling what she had just worn; my lips pressed one of these + jewels, while the other, deceiving the sacred end of nature, from + excess of exaltation replaced the object of sex (I cannot express + myself more clearly). The warmth which she had communicated to + the insensible object which had touched her still remained and + gave a soul to it; a voluptuous cloud covered my eyes." He adds + that he would kiss with rage and transport whatever had come in + close contact with the woman he adored, and on one occasion + eagerly pressed his lips to her cast-off underlinen, _vela + secretiora penetralium_. + + At this period Restif's foot-fetichism reached its highest point + of development. It was the aberration of a highly sensitive and + very precocious boy. While the preoccupation with feet and shoes + persisted throughout life, it never became a complete perversion + and never replaced the normal end of sexual desire. His love for + Madam Parangon, one of the deepest emotions in his whole life, + was also the climax of his shoe-fetichism. She represented his + ideal woman, an ethereal sylph with wasp-waist and a child's + feet; it was always his highest praise for a woman that she + resembled Madame Parangon, and he desired that her slipper should + be buried with him. (Restif de la Bretonne, _Monsieur Nicolas_, + vols. i-iv, vol. xiii, p. 5; id., _Mes Inscriptions_, pp. ci-cv.) + + Shoe-fetichism, more especially if we include under this term all + the cases of real or pseudo-masochism in which an attraction to + the boots or slippers is the chief feature, is a not infrequent + phenomenon, and is certainly the most frequently occurring form + of fetichism. Many cases are brought together by Krafft-Ebing in + his _Psychopathia Sexualis_. Every prostitute of any experience + has known men who merely desire to gaze at her shoes, or possibly + to lick them, and who are quite willing to pay for this + privilege. In London such a person is known as a "bootman," in + Germany as a "Stiefelfrier." + +The predominance of the foot as a focus of sexual attraction, while among +us to-day it is a not uncommon phenomenon, is still not sufficiently +common to be called normal; the majority of even ardent lovers do not +experience this attraction in any marked degree. But these manifestations +of foot-fetichism which with us to-day are abnormal, even when they are +not so extreme as to be morbid, may perhaps become more intelligible to us +when we realize that in earlier periods of civilization, and even to-day +in some parts of the world, the foot is generally recognized as a focus of +sexual attraction, so that some degree of foot-fetichism becomes a normal +phenomenon. + +The most pronounced and the best known example of such normal +foot-fetichism at the present day is certainly to be found among the +Southern Chinese. For a Chinese husband his wife's foot is more +interesting than her face. A Chinese woman is as shy of showing her feet +to a man as a European woman her breasts; they are reserved for her +husband's eyes alone, and to look at a woman's feet in the street is +highly improper and indelicate. Chinese foot-fetichism is connected with +the custom of compressing the feet. This custom appears to rest on the +fact that Chinese women naturally possess a very small foot and is thus an +example of the universal tendency in the search for beauty to accentuate, +even by deformation, the racial characteristics. But there is more than +this. Beauty is largely a name for sexual attractiveness, and the energy +expended in the effort to make the Chinese woman's small foot still +smaller is a measure of the sexual fascination which it exerts. The +practice arose on the basis of the sexual attractiveness of the foot, +though it has doubtless served to heighten that attractiveness, just as +the small waist, which (if we may follow Stratz) is a characteristic +beauty of the European woman, becomes to the average European man still +more attractive when accentuated, even to the extent of deformity, by the +compression of the corset. + + Referring to the sexual fascination exerted by the foot in China, + Matignon writes: "My attention has been drawn to this point by a + large number of pornographic engravings, of which the Chinese are + very fond. In all these lascivious scenes we see the male + voluptuously fondling the woman's foot. When a Celestial takes + into his hand a woman's foot, especially if it is very small, the + effect upon him is precisely the same as is provoked in a + European by the palpation of a young and firm bosom. All the + Celestials whom I have interrogated on this point have replied + unanimously: 'Oh, a little foot! You Europeans cannot understand + how exquisite, how sweet, how exciting it is!' The contact of the + genital organ with the little foot produces in the male an + indescribable degree of voluptuous feeling, and women skilled in + love know that to arouse the ardor of their lovers a better + method than all Chinese aphrodisiacs--including 'giusen' and + swallows' nests--is to take the penis between their feet. It is + not rare to find Chinese Christians accusing themselves at + confession of having had 'evil thoughts on looking at a woman's + foot.'" (Dr. J. Matignon, "A propos d'un Pied de Chinoise," + _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, 1898.) + + It is said that a Chinese Empress, noted for her vice and having + a congenital club foot, about the year 1100 B.C., desired all + women to resemble her, and that the practice of compressing the + foot thus arose. But this is only tradition, since, in 300 B.C., + Chinese books were destroyed (Morache, Art. "Chine," + _Dictionnaire Encyclopedique des Sciences Medicales_, p. 191). It + is also said that the practice owes its origin to the wish to + keep women indoors. But women are not secluded in China, nor does + foot compression usually render a woman unable to walk. Many + intelligent Chinese are of opinion that its object is to promote + the development of the sexual parts and of the thighs, and so to + aid both intercourse and parturition. There is no ground for + believing that it has any such influence, though Morache found + that the mons veneris and labia are largely developed in Chinese + women, and not in Tartar women living in Pekin (who do not + compress the foot). If there is any correlation between the feet + and the pelvic regions, it is more probably congenital than due + to the artificial compression of the feet. The ancients seem to + have believed that a small foot indicated a small vagina. Restif + de la Bretonne, who had ample opportunities for forming an + opinion on a matter in which he took so great an interest, + believed that a small foot, round and short, indicated a large + vagina (_Monsieur Nicolas_, vol. i, reprint of 1883, p. 92). + Even, however, if we admit that there is a real correlation + between the foot and the vagina, that would by no means suffice + to render the foot a focus of sexual attraction. + + It remains the most reasonable view that the foot bandage must be + regarded as strictly analogous to the waist bandage or corset + which also tends to produce deformity of the constricted region. + Stratz has ingeniously remarked (_Frauenkleidung_, third edition, + p. 101) that the success of the Chinese in dwarfing trees may + have suggested a similar attempt in regard to women's feet, and + adds that in any case both dwarfed trees and bound feet bear + witness in the Mongolian to the same love for small and elegant, + not to say deformed, things. For a Chinaman the deformed foot is + a "golden water-lily." + + Many facts (together with illustrations) bearing on Chinese + deformation of the foot will be found in Ploss, _Das Weib_, vol. + i, Section IV. + +The significance of the sexual emotion aroused by the female foot in China +and the origin of its compression begin to become clear when we realize +that this foot-fetichism is merely an extreme development of a tendency +which is fairly well marked among nearly all the peoples of yellow race. +Jacoby, who has brought together a number of interesting facts bearing on +the sexual significance of the foot, states that a similar tendency is to +be found among the Mongol and Turk peoples of Siberia, and in the east and +central parts of European Russia, among the Permiaks, the Wotiaks, etc. +Here the woman, at all events when young, has always her feet, as well as +head, covered, however little clothing she may otherwise wear. + + "On hot nights or on baking days," Jacoby states, "you may see + these women with uncovered breasts, or even entirely naked + without embarrassment, but you will never see them with bare + feet, and no male relations, except the husband, will ever see + the feet and lower part of the legs of the women in the house. + These women have their modesty in their feet, and also their + coquetry; to unbind the feet of a woman is for a man a voluptuous + act, and the touch of the bands produces the same effect as a + corset still warm from a woman's body on a European man. A + woman's beauty, that which attracts and excites a man, lies in + her foot; in Mordvin love poems celebrating the beauty of women + there is much about her attire, especially her embroidered + chemise, but as regards the charms of her person the poet is + content to state that 'her feet are beautiful;' with that + everything is said. The young peasant woman of the central + provinces as part of her holiday raiment puts on great woolen + stockings which come up to the groin and are then folded over to + below the knee. To uncover the feet of a person of the opposite + sex is a sexual act, and has thus become the symbol of sexual + possession, so that the stocking or foot-gear became the emblem + of marriage, as later the ring. (It was so among the Jews, as we + see in the book of _Ruth_, Chapter III, v. 4, and Chapter IV, vv. + 7 and 8). St. Vladimir the Great asked in marriage the daughter + of Prince Rogvold; as Vladimir's mother had been a serf, the + princess proudly replied that she 'would not uncover the feet of + a slave.' At the present time in the east of Russia when a young + girl tries to find out by divination whom she will have as a + husband the traditional formula is 'Come and take my stockings + off.' Among the populations of the north and east, it is + sometimes the bride who must do this for her husband on the + wedding night, and sometimes the bridegroom for his wife, not as + a token of love, but as a nuptial ceremony. Among the + professional classes and small nobility in Russia parents place + money in the stocking of their child at marriage as a present for + the other partner, it being supposed that the couple mutually + remove each other's foot raiment, as an act of sexual possession, + the emblem of coitus." (Paul Jacoby, _Archives d'Anthropologie + Criminelle_, December, 1903, p. 793.) The practice among + ourselves of children hanging up their stockings at night for + presents would seem to be a relic of the last-mentioned custom. + +While we may witness the sexual symbolism of the foot, with or without an +associated foot-fetichism, most highly developed in Asia and Eastern +Europe, it has by no means been altogether unknown in some stages of +western civilization, and traces of it may be found here and there even +yet. Schinz refers to the connection between the feet and sexual pleasure +as existing not only among the Egyptians and the Arabs, but among the +ancient Germans and the modern Spaniards,[16] while Jacoby points out that +among the Greeks, the Romans, and especially the Etruscans, it was usual +to represent chaste and virgin goddesses with their feet covered, even +though they might be otherwise nude. Ovid, again, is never weary of +dwelling on the sexual charm of the feminine foot. He represents the +chaste matron as wearing a weighted _stola_ which always fell so as to +cover her feet; it was only the courtesan, or the nymph who is taking part +in an erotic festival, who appears with raised robes, revealing her +feet.[17] So grave a historian as Strabo, as well as AElian, refers to the +story of the courtesan Rhodope whose sandal was carried off by an eagle +and dropped in the King of Egypt's lap as he was administering justice, so +that he could not rest until he had discovered to whom this delicately +small sandal belonged, and finally made her his queen. Kleinpaul, who +repeats this story, has collected many European sayings and customs +(including Turkish), indicating that the slipper is a very ancient symbol +of a woman's sexual parts.[18] + + In Rome, Dufour remarks, "Matrons having appropriated the use of + the shoe (_soccus_) prostitutes were not allowed to use it, and + were obliged to have their feet always naked in sandals or + slippers (_crepida_ and _solea_), which they fastened over the + instep with gilt bands. Tibullus delights to describe his + mistress's little foot, compressed by the band that imprisoned + it: _Ansaque compressos colligat arcta pedes_. Nudity of the foot + in woman was a sign of prostitution, and their brilliant + whiteness acted afar as a pimp to attract looks and desires." + (Dufour, _Histoire de la Prostitution_, vol. II., ch. xviii.) + + This feeling seems to have survived in a more or less vague and + unconscious form in mediaeval Europe. "In the tenth century," + according to Dufour (_Histoire de la Prostitution_, vol. VI., p. + 11), "shoes _a la poulaine_, with a claw or beak, pursued for + more than four centuries by the anathemas of popes and the + invectives of preachers, were always regarded by mediaeval + casuists as the most abominable emblems of immodesty. At a first + glance it is not easy to see why these shoes--terminating in a + lion's claw, an eagle's beak, the prow of a ship, or other metal + appendage--should be so scandalous. The excommunication inflicted + on this kind of foot-gear preceded the impudent invention of some + libertine, who wore _poulaines_ in the shape of the phallus, a + custom adopted also by women. This kind of _poulaine_ was + denounced as _mandite de Dicu_ (Ducange's Glossary, at the word + Poulainia) and prohibited by royal ordinances (see letter of + Charles V., 17 October, 1367, regarding the garments of the women + of Montpellier). Great lords and ladies continued, however, to + wear _poulaines_." In Louis XL's court they were still worn of a + quarter of an ell in length. + + Spain, ever tenacious of ancient ideas, appears to have preserved + longer than other countries the ancient classic traditions in + regard to the foot as a focus of modesty and an object of sexual + attraction. In Spanish religious pictures it was always necessary + that the Virgin's feet should be concealed, the clergy ordaining + that her robe should be long and flowing, so that the feet might + be covered with decent folds. Pacheco, the master and + father-in-law of Velasquez, writes in 1649 in his _Arte de la + Pintura_: "What can be more foreign from the respect which we owe + to the purity of Our Lady the Virgin than to paint her sitting + down with one of her knees placed over the other, and often with + her sacred feet uncovered and naked. Let thanks be given to the + Holy Inquisition which commands that this liberty should be + corrected!" It was Pacheco's duty in Seville to see that these + commands were obeyed. At the court of Philip IV. at this time the + princesses never showed their feet, as we may see in the pictures + of Velasquez. When a local manufacturer desired to present that + monarch's second bride, Mariana of Austria, with some silk + stockings the offer was indignantly rejected by the Court + Chamberlain: "The Queen of Spain has no legs!" Philip V.'s, queen + was thrown from her horse and dragged by the feet; no one + ventured to interfere until two gentlemen bravely rescued her and + then fled, dreading punishment by the king: they were, however, + graciously pardoned. Reinach ("Pieds Pudiques," _Cultes, Mythes + et Religions_, pp. 105-110) brings together several passages from + the Countess D'Aulnoy's account of the Madrid Court in the + seventeenth century and from other sources, showing how careful + Spanish ladies were as regards their feet, and how jealous + Spanish husbands were in this matter. At this time, when Spanish + influence was considerable, the fashion of Spain seems to have + spread to other countries. One may note that in Vandyck's + pictures of English beauties the feet are not visible, though in + the more characteristically English painters of a somewhat later + age it became usual to display them conspicuously, while the + French custom in this matter is the farthest removed from the + Spanish. At the present day a well-bred Spanish woman shows as + little as possible of her feet in walking, and even in some of + the most characteristic Spanish dances there is little or no + kicking, and the feet may even be invisible throughout. It is + noteworthy that in numerous figures of Spanish women (probably + artists' models) reproduced in Ploss's _Das Weib_ the stockings + are worn, although the women are otherwise, in most cases, quite + naked. Max Dessoir mentions ("Psychologie der Vita Sexualis," + _Zeitschrift fuer Psychiatrie_, 1894, p. 954) that in Spanish + pornographic photographs women always have their shoes on, and he + considers this an indication of perversity. I have seen the + statement (attributed to Gautier's _Voyage en Espagne_, where, + however, it does not occur) that Spanish prostitutes uncover + their feet in sign of assent, and Madame d'Aulnoy stated that in + her time to show her lover her feet was a Spanish woman's final + favor. + +The tendency, which we thus find to be normal at some earlier periods of +civilization, to insist on the sexual symbolism of the feminine foot or +its coverings, and to regard them as a special sexual fascination, is not +without significance for the interpretation of the sporadic manifestations +of foot-fetichism among ourselves. Eccentric as foot-fetichism may appear +to us, it is simply the re-emergence, by a pseudo-atavism or arrest of +development, of a mental or emotional impulse which was probably +experienced by our forefathers, and is often traceable among young +children to-day.[19] The occasional reappearance of this bygone impulse +and the stability which it may acquire are thus conditioned by the +sensitive reaction of an abnormally nervous and usually precocious +organism to influences which, among the average and ordinary population of +Europe to-day, are either never felt, or quickly outgrown, or very +strictly subordinated in the highly complex crystallizations which the +course of love and the process of tumescence create within us. + + It may be added that this is by no means true of foot-fetichism + only. In some other fetichisms a seemingly congenital + predisposition is even more marked. This is not only the case as + regards hair-fetichism and fur-fetichism (see, e.g., + Krafft-Ebing, _Psychopathia Sexualis_, English translation of + tenth edition, pp. 233, 255, 262). In many cases of fetichisms of + all kinds not only is there no record of any commencement in a + definite episode (an absence which may be accounted for by the + supposition that the original incident has been forgotten), but + it would seem in some cases that the fetichism developed very + slowly. + +In this sense, it will be seen, although it is hazardous to speak of +foot-fetichism as strictly an atavism, it may certainly be said to arise +on a congenital basis. It represents the rare development of an inborn +germ, usually latent among ourselves, which in earlier stages of +civilization frequently reached a normal and general fruition. + +It is of interest to emphasize this congenital element of foot symbolism, +because more than any other forms of sexual perversion the fetichisms are +those which are most vaguely conditioned by inborn states of the organism +and most definitely aroused by seemingly accidental associations or shocks +in early life. Inversion is sometimes so fundamentally ingrained in the +individual's constitution that it arises and develops in spite of the very +strongest influence in a contrary direction. But a fetichism, while it +tends to occur in sensitive, nervous, timid, precocious individuals--that +is to say, individuals of more or less neuropathic heredity--can usually, +though not always, be traced to a definite starting point in the shock of +some sexually emotional episode in early life. + + A few examples of the influences of such association may here be + given, referring miscellaneously to various forms of erotic + symbolism. Magnan has recorded the case of a hair-fetichist, + living in a district where the women wore their hair done up, who + at the age of 15 experienced pleasurable feelings with erection + at the sight of a village beauty combing her hair; from that time + flowing hair became his fetich, and he could not resist the + temptation to touch it and if possible sever it, thus becoming a + hair-despoiler, for which he was arrested but not sentenced. + (_Archives de l'Anthropologie Criminelle_, vol. v, No. 28.) + + I have elsewhere recorded the history of a boy of 14, having + already had imperfect connection with a grown-up woman, who + associated much with a young married lady; he had no sexual + relations with her, but one day she urinated in his presence, and + he saw that her mons veneris was covered by very thick hair; from + that time he worshiped this woman in secret and acquired a + life-long fetichistic attraction to women whose pubic hair was + similarly abundant (_Studies in the Psychology of Sex_, vol. iii, + Appendix B, History V). + + Roubaud reported the case of a general's son, sexually initiated + at the age of 14 by a blonde young lady of 21 who, in order to + avoid detection, always retained her clothing: gaiters, a corset + and a silk dress; when the boy's studies were completed and he + was sent to a garrison where he could enjoy freedom he found that + his sexual desires could only be aroused by blonde women dressed + like the lady who had first aroused his sexual desires; + consequently he gave up all thoughts of matrimony, as a woman in + nightclothes produced impotence (_Traite de l'Impuissance_, p. + 439). Krafft-Ebing records the somewhat similar case of a nervous + Polish boy of old family seduced at the age of 17 by a French + governess, who during several months practiced mutual + masturbation with him; in this way his attention became + attracted by her very elegant boots, and in the end he became a + confirmed boot-fetichist (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, English + translation, p. 249). + + A boy of 7, of bad heredity, was taught to masturbate by a + servant girl; on one occasion she practiced this on him with her + foot without taking off her shoe; it was the first time the + manoeuvre gave him any pleasure, and an association was thus + established which led to shoe-fetichism (Hammond, _Sexual + Impotence_, p. 44). A government official whose first coitus in + youth took place on a staircase; the sound of his partner's + creaking shoes against the stairs, produced by her efforts to + accelerate orgasm, formed an association which developed into an + auditory shoe-fetichism; in the streets he was compelled to + follow ladies whose shoes creaked, ejaculation being thus + produced, while to obtain complete satisfaction he would make a + prostitute, otherwise naked, sit in front of him in her shoes, + moving her feet so that the shoes creaked. (Moraglia, _Archivio + di Psichiatria_, vol. xiii, p. 568.) + + Bechterew, in St. Petersburg, has recorded the case of a man who + when a child used to fall asleep at the knees of his nurse with + his head buried in the folds of her apron; in this position he + first experienced erection and voluptuous sensations; when a + youth he had no attraction to naked women, and in real life and + in dreams was only excited sexually under conditions recalling + his early experience; in his relations with women he preferred + them dressed, and was excited by the rustling sound of their + skirts; in this case there was no traceable neuropathic taint nor + any other personal peculiarity. (Summarized in _Journal de + Psychologie Normale et Pathologique_, January-February, 1904, p. + 72.) + + In a curious case recorded in detail by Moll, a philologist of + sensitive temperament but sound heredity, who had always been + fond of flowers, at the age of 21 became engaged to a young lady + who wore large roses fastened in her jacket; from this time roses + became to him a sexual fetich, to kiss them caused erection, and + his erotic dreams were accompanied by visions of roses and the + hallucination of their odor; the engagement was finally broken + off and the rose-fetichism disappeared (_Untersuchungen ueber + Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 540). + +Such associations may naturally occur in the early experiences of even the +most normal persons. The degree to which they will influence the +subsequent life and thought and feeling depends on the degree of the +individual's morbid emotional receptivity, on the extent to which he is +hereditarily susceptible of abnormal deviation. Precocity is undoubtedly a +condition which favors such deviation; a child who is precociously and +abnormally sensitive to persons of the opposite sex before puberty has +established the normal channels of sexual desire, is peculiarly liable to +become the prey of a chance symbolism. All degrees of such symbolism are +possible. While the average insensitive person may fail to perceive them +at all, for the more alert and imaginative lover they are a fascinating +part of the highly charged crystallization of passion. A more nervously +exceptional person, when once such a symbolism has become firmly +implanted, may find it an absolutely essential element in the charm of a +beloved and charming person. Finally, for the individual who is thoroughly +unsound the symbol becomes generalized; a person is no longer desired at +all, being merely regarded as an appendage of the symbol, or being +dispensed with altogether; the symbol is alone desired, and is fully +adequate to impart by itself complete sexual gratification. While it must +be considered a morbid state to demand a symbol as an almost essential +part of the charm of a desired person, it is only in the final condition, +in which the symbol becomes all-sufficing, that we have a true and +complete perversion. In the less complete forms of symbolism it is still +the woman who is desired, and the ends of procreation may be served; when +the woman is ignored and the mere symbol is an adequate and even preferred +stimulus to detumescence the pathological condition becomes complete. + +Krafft-Ebing regarded shoe-fetichism as, in large measure, a more or less +latent form of masochism, the foot or the shoe being the symbol of the +subjection and humiliation which the masochist feels in the presence of +the beloved object. Moll is also inclined to accept such a connection. + + "The very numerous class of boot-and-shoe-fetichists," + Krafft-Ebing wrote, "forms the transition to the manifestations + of another independent perversion, i.e., fetichism itself; but it + stands in closer relationship to the former.... It is highly + probable, and shown by a correct classification of the observed + cases, that the majority, and perhaps all of the cases of + shoe-fetichism, rest upon a basis of more or less conscious + masochistic desire for self-humiliation.... The majority or all + may be looked upon as instances of latent masochism (the motive + remaining unconscious) in which the _female foot or shoe, as the + masochist's fetich_, has acquired an independent significance." + (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, English translation of tenth edition, + pp. 159, et seq.) "Though Krafft-Ebing may not have cleared up + the whole matter," Moll remarks, "I regard his deductions + concerning the connection of foot-and-shoe fetichism to masochism + as the most important progress that has been made in the + theoretic study of sexual perversions.... In any case, the + connection is very frequent." (_Kontraere Sexualempfindung_, third + edition, p. 306.) + +It is quite easy to see that this supposed identity of masochism and +foot-fetichism forms a seductive theory. It is also undoubtedly true that +a masochist may very easily be inclined to find in his mistress's foot an +aid to the ecstatic self-abnegation which he desires to attain.[20] But +only confusion is attained by any general attempt to amalgamate masochism +and foot-fetichism. In the broad sense in which erotic symbolism is here +understood, both masochism and foot-fetichism may be cooerdinated as +symbolisms; for the masochist his self-humiliating impulses are the symbol +of ecstatic adoration; for the foot-fetichist his mistress's foot or shoe +is the concentrated symbol of all that is most beautiful and elegant and +feminine in her personality. But if in this sense they are cooerdinated, +they remain entirely distinct and have not even any necessary tendency to +become merged. Masochism merely simulates foot-fetichism; for the +masochist the boot is not strictly a symbol, it is only an instrument +which enables him to carry out his impulse; the true sexual symbol for him +is not the boot, but the emotion of self-subjection. For the +foot-fetichist, on the other hand, the foot or the shoe is not a mere +instrument, but a true symbol; the focus of his worship, an idealized +object which he is content to contemplate or reverently touch. He has no +necessary impulse to any self-degrading action, nor any constant emotion +of subjection. It may be noted that in the very typical case of +foot-fetichism which is presented to us in the person of Restif de la +Bretonne (_ante_, p. 18), he repeatedly speaks of "subjecting" the woman +for whom he feels this fetichistic adoration, and mentions that even when +still a child he especially admired a delicate and fairy-like girl in this +respect because she seemed to him easier to subjugate. Throughout life +Restif's attitude toward women was active and masculine, without the +slightest trace of masochism.[21] + +To suppose that a fetichistic admiration of his mistress's foot is due to +a lover's latent desire to be kicked, is as unreasonable as it would be to +suppose that a fetichistic admiration for her hand indicated a latent +desire to have his ears boxed. In determining whether we are concerned +with a case of foot-fetichism or of masochism we must take into +consideration the whole of the subject's mental and emotional attitude. An +act, however definite, will not suffice as a criterion, for the same act +in different persons may have altogether different implications. To +amalgamate the two is the result of inadequate psychological analysis and +only leads to confusion. + +It is, however, often very difficult to decide whether we are dealing with +a case which is predominantly one of masochism or of foot-fetichism. The +nature of the action desired, as we have seen, will not suffice to +determine the psychological character of the perversion. Krafft-Ebing +believed that the desire to be trodden on, very frequently experienced by +masochists, is absolutely symptomatic of masochism.[22] This is scarcely +the case. The desire to be trodden on may be fundamentally an erotic +symbolism, closely approaching foot-fetichism, and such slight indications +of masochism as appear may be merely a parasitic growth on the symbolism, +a growth perhaps more suggested by the circumstances involved in the +gratification of the abnormal desire than inherent in the innate impulse +of the subject. This may be illustrated by the interesting case of a very +intelligent man with whom I am well acquainted. + + C.P., aged 38. Heredity good. Parents both healthy and normal. + Several children of the marriage, all sexually normal so far as + is known. C.P. is the youngest of the family and separated from + the others by an interval of many years. He was a seven-months' + child. He has always enjoyed good health and is active and + vigorous, both mentally and physically. + + From the age of 9 or 10 to 14 he masturbated occasionally for the + sake of physical relief, having discovered the act for himself. + He was, however, quite innocent and knew nothing of sexual + matters, never having been initiated either by servants or by + other boys. + + "When I encounter a woman who very strongly attracts me and whom + I very greatly admire," he writes, "my desire is never that I may + have sexual connection with her in the ordinary sense, but that I + may lie down upon the floor on my back and be trampled upon by + her. This curious desire is seldom present unless the object of + my admiration is really a lady, and of fine proportions. She must + be richly dressed--preferably in an evening gown, and wear dainty + high-heeled slippers, either quite open so as to show the curve + of the instep, or with only one strap or 'bar' across. The skirts + should be raised sufficiently to afford me the pleasure of seeing + her feet and a liberal amount of ankle, but in no case above the + knee, or the effect is greatly reduced. Although I often greatly + admire a woman's intellect and even person, sexually no other + part of her has any serious attraction for me except the leg, + from the knee downwards, and the foot, and these must be + exquisitely clothed. Given this condition, my desire amounts to a + wish to gratify my sexual sense by contact with the (to me) + attractive part of the woman. Comparatively few women have a leg + or foot sufficiently beautiful to my mind to excite any serious + or compelling desire, but when this is so, or I suspect it, I am + willing to spend any time or trouble to get her to tread upon me + and am anxious to be trampled on with the greatest severity. + + "The treading should be inflicted for a few minutes all over the + chest, abdomen and groin, and lastly on the penis, which is, of + course, lying along the belly in a violent state of erection, and + consequently too hard for the treading to damage it. I also enjoy + being nearly strangled by a woman's foot. + + "If the lady finally stands facing my head and places her slipper + upon my penis so that the high heel falls about where the penis + leaves the scrotum, the sole covering most of the rest of it and + with the other foot upon the abdomen, into which I can _see_ as + well as feel it sink as she shifts her weight from one foot to + the other, orgasm takes place almost at once. Emission under + these conditions is to me an agony of delight, during which + practically the lady's whole weight should rest upon the penis. + + "One reason for my special pleasure in this method seems to be + that first the heel and afterwards the sole of the slipper as it + treads upon the penis greatly check the passage of the semen and + consequently the pleasure is considerably prolonged. There is + also a curious mental side to the affair. I love to imagine that + the lady who is treading upon me is my mistress and I her slave, + and that she is doing it to punish me for some fault, or to give + _herself_ (not me) pleasure. + + "It follows that the greater the contempt and severity with which + I am 'punished,' the greater becomes my pleasure. The idea of + 'punishment' or 'slavery' is seldom aroused except when I have + great difficulty in accomplishing my desire and the treader is + more than usually handsome and heavy and the trampling + mercilessly inflicted. I have been trampled so long and so + mercilessly several times, that I have flinched each time the + slipper pressed its way into my aching body and have been black + and blue for days afterwards. I take the greatest interest in + leading ladies on to do this for me where I think I will not + offend, and have been surprisingly successful. I must have lain + beneath the feet of quite a hundred women, many of them of good + social position, who would never dream of permitting any ordinary + sexual intercourse, but who have been so interested or amused by + the idea as to do it for me--many of them over and over again. It + is perhaps needless to say that none of my own or the ladies' + clothing is ever removed, or disarranged, for the accomplishment + of orgasm in this manner. After a long and varied experience, I + may say that my favorite weight is 10 to 11 stone, and that + black, very high-heeled slippers, in combination with tan silk + stockings, seem to give me the greatest pleasure and create in me + the strongest desires. + + "Boots, or outdoor shoes, do not attract me to anything like the + same degree, although I have, upon several occasions, enjoyed + myself fairly well by their use. Nude women repel me, and I find + no pleasure in seeing a woman in tights. I am not averse to + normal sexual connection and occasionally employ it. To me, + however, the pleasure is far inferior to that of being trampled + upon. I also derive keen pleasure--and usually have a strong + erection--from seeing a woman, dressed as I have described, tread + upon anything which yields under her foot--such as the seat of a + carriage, the cushions of a punt, a footstool, etc., and I enjoy + seeing her crush flowers by treading upon them. I have often + strolled along in the wake of some handsome lady at a picnic or + garden party, for the pleasure of seeing the grass upon which she + has trodden rise slowly again after her foot has pressed it. I + delight also to see a carriage sway as a woman leaves or enters + it--anything which needs the pressure of the foot. + + "To pass now to the origin of this direction of my feelings. + + "Even in early childhood I admired pretty feminine foot-gear, and + in the contemplation of it experienced vague sensations which I + now recognize as sexual. When a lad of 14 or so, I stayed a good + deal at the house of some intimate friends of my parents, the + daughter of the house--an only child--a beautiful and powerful + girl, about six years my senior, being my special chum. This girl + was always daintily dressed, and having most lovely feet and + ankles not unnaturally knew it. Whenever possible she dressed so + as to show off their beauty to the best advantage--rather short + skirts and usually little high-heeled slippers--and was not + averse to showing them in a most distractingly coquettish manner. + She seemed to have a passion for treading upon things which would + scrunch or yield under her foot, such as flowers, little + windfallen apples and pears, acorns, etc., or heaps of hay, straw + or cut grass. As we wandered about the gardens--for we were left + to do exactly as we liked--I got quite accustomed to seeing her + hunt out and tread upon such things, and used to chaff her about + it. At that time I was--as I am still--fond of lying at full + length on a thick hearthrug before a good fire. One evening as I + was lying in this way and we were alone, A. crossed the room to + reach a bangle from the mantelpiece. Instead of reaching over me, + she playfully stepped upon my body, saying that she would show me + how the hay and straw felt. Naturally I fell in with the joke and + laughed. After standing upon me a few moments she raised her + skirt slightly and, holding on to the mantelpiece for support, + stretched out one dainty foot in its brown silk stocking and + high-heeled slipper to the blaze to warm, while looking down and + laughing at my scarlet, excited face. She was a perfectly frank + and charming girl, and I feel pretty certain that, although she + evidently enjoyed my excitement and the feeling of my body + yielding under her feet, she did not on this first occasion + clearly understand my condition; nor can I remember that, though + the desire for sexual gratification drove me nearly mad, it + appeared to awaken in her any reciprocal feeling. I took hold of + her raised foot and, after kissing it, guided it by an absolutely + irresistible impulse on to my penis, which was as hard as wood + and seemed almost bursting. Almost at the moment that her weight + was thrown upon it, orgasm took place for the first time in my + life thoroughly and effectively. No description can give any idea + of what I felt--I only know that from that moment my distorted + sexual focus was fixed forever. Numberless times, after that + evening, I felt the weight of her dainty slippers, and nothing + will ever cause the memory of the pleasure she thus gave me to + fade. I know that A. came to enjoy treading upon me, as much as I + enjoyed having her do it. She had a liberal dress allowance and, + seeing the pleasure they gave me, she was always buying pretty + stockings and ravishing slippers with the highest and most + slender Louis heels she could find and would show them to me with + the greatest glee, urging me to lie down that she might try them + on me. She confessed that she loved to see and feel them sink + into my body as she trod upon me and enjoyed the crunch of the + muscles under her heel as she moved about. After some minutes of + this, I always guided her slipper on to my penis, and she would + tread carefully, but with her whole weight--probably about 9 + stone--and watch me with flashing eyes, flushed cheeks, and + quivering lips, as she felt--as she must have done plainly--the + throbbing and swelling of my penis under her foot as emission + took place. I have not the smallest doubt that orgasm took place + simultaneously with her, though we never at any time spoke openly + of it. This went on for several years on almost every favorable + opportunity we had, and after a month or two of separation + sometimes four or five times during a single day. Several times + during A.'s absence I masturbated by getting her slipper and + pressing it with all my strength against the penis while + imagining that she was treading upon me. The pleasure was, of + course, very inferior to her attentions. There was never at any + time between us any question of normal sexual intercourse, and we + were both well content to let things drift as they were. + + "A little after 20 I went abroad, and on my return about three + years later I found her married. Although we met often, the + subject was never alluded to, though we remained firm friends. I + confess I often, when I could do so without being seen, looked + longingly at her feet and would have gladly accepted the pleasure + she could have given me by an occasional resumption of our + strange practice--but it never came. + + "I went abroad again, and now neither she nor her husband are + alive and leave no issue. From time to time I have had occasional + relations with prostitutes, but always in this manner, though I + much prefer to find some lady of or above my own social position + who will do the treading for me. This is, however, interestingly + difficult. + + "Out of say a hundred women (which at home and abroad is what I + should estimate must have stood upon my body) I should say quite + 80 or 85 were _not_ prostitutes. Certainly not more than 10 to 12 + shared any _sexual_ excitement, but while they were evidently + excited they were not gratified. A. alone, so far as I know, had + complete sexual satisfaction of it. I have never asked a woman in + so many words to tread upon me for the purpose of gratifying my + sexual desires (prostitutes excepted), but have always tempted + them to do it in a jocular or teasing manner, and it is very + doubtful if more than a few (married) women really understood, + even after they had given me the extreme pleasure, that they had + done so, because any flushing and movement on my part under their + feet was not unnaturally put down to the trampling to which they + were subjecting me, and it was easy for me to guide the foot as + often as was necessary on to the penis till orgasm took place, + and even to keep it there by laying hold of the other one to kiss + it or on some other pretext during emission. Of course many + understood after once doing it (most have done it only once) what + I was at, and, although they did not ever discuss it nor did I, + they were not unwilling to give me as many treadings as I cared + to playfully suggest. I don't think they got any pleasure + sexually out of it themselves, though they could see plainly that + I did, and they did not object to give it me. I have spent as + long as twelve months with some women working gradually nearer + and nearer to my desire--often getting what I want in the end, + but more often failing. I _never_ risk it till I am certain it + would be safe to ask it, and have never had a serious rebuff. In + very many cases I should say the doing of what I want has simply + been regarded by the woman as gratifying a silly and perhaps + amusing whim, in which, beyond the novelty of treading on a man's + body, she has taken but little interest. + + "As in normal seduction, the endeavor to win the woman over to do + what I want without arousing her antagonism is a great part of + the charm to me, and naturally the better her social position the + more difficult this becomes--and the more attractive. I have + found that in three instances prostitutes have performed the same + office for other men and knew all about it. It is not + uninteresting to note that these three women were all of fine, + massive build--one standing about 5 feet 10 inches and weighing + nearly 14 stone--but with comparatively uninteresting faces. The + weight, build and clothing count for a good deal in exciting me. + I find that a sudden check to a man at the supreme moment of + sexual pleasure tends to heighten and prolong the pleasure. My + physical satisfaction is due to the fact that by getting the lady + to stand with all her weight upon my penis (as it lies between + her foot and the soft bed of my own body into which it is deeply + pressed) the act of emission is enormously prolonged, with + corresponding enjoyment. For this reason also I prefer a very + high-heeled slipper. The seminal fluid has to be forced past two + separate obstacles--the pressure of the heel close at the root of + the penis and afterwards the ball of the foot which compresses + the outer half, leaving a free portion between them under the + arched sole of the slipper. I may add that the pleasure is + greatly increased by the retention of the urine, and I always try + to retain as much water as I dare. I have an unconquerable + aversion to red in slippers or stockings; it will even cause + impotence. Why, I know not. Strange as it may seem, although pain + and bruising are often inflicted by a severe treading, I have + never been in any way injured by the practice, and my pleasure in + it seems not to diminish by constant repetition. The comparative + difficulty of obtaining the pleasure from just the woman I want + has a never-ending, if inexplicable, charm for me." + + It will be observed that in this case special importance is + attached to shoes with high heels, and the subject considers that + the pressure of such shoes is for mechanical reasons most + favorable for procuring ejaculation. Nearly all heterosexual + shoe-fetichists seem, however, to be equally attracted by high + heels. Restif de la Bretonne frequently referred to this point, + and he gave a number of reasons for the attractiveness of high + heels: (1) They are unlike men's boots and, therefore, have a + sexual fascination; (2) they make the leg and foot look more + charming; (3) they give a less bold and more sylph-like character + to the walk; (4) they keep the feet clean. (Restif de la + Bretonne, _Nuits de Paris_, vol. v, quoted in Preface to his _Mes + Inscriptions_, p. ciii.) It is doubtless the first reason--the + fact that high heels are a kind of secondary sexual + character--which is most generally potent in this attraction. + +The foregoing history, while it very distinctly brings before us a case of +erotic symbolism, is not strictly an example of shoe-fetichism. The +symbolism is more complex. The focus of beauty in a desirable woman is +transferred and concentrated in the region below the knee; in that sense +we have foot-fetichism. But the act of coitus itself is also symbolically +transferred. Not only has the foot become the symbol of the vulva, but +trampling has become the symbol of coitus; intercourse takes place +symbolically _per pedem_. It is a result of this symbolization of the foot +and of trampling that all acts of treading take on a new and symbolical +sexual charm. The element of masochism--of pleasure in being a woman's +slave--is a parasitic growth; that is to say, it is not founded in the +subject's constitution, but chances to have found a favorable soil in the +special circumstances under which his sexual life developed. It is not +primary, but secondary, and remains an unimportant and merely occasional +element. + +It may be instructive to bring forward for comparison a case in which also +we have a symbolism involving boot-fetichism, but extending beyond it. In +this case there is a basis of inversion (as is not infrequent in erotic +symbolisms), but from the present point of view the psychological +significance of the case remains the same. + + A.N., aged 29, unmarried, healthy, though not robust, and without + any known hereditary taint. Has followed various avocations + without taking great interest in them, but has shown some + literary ability. + + "I am an Englishman," his own narrative runs, "the third of three + children. At my birth my father was 41 and my mother 34. My + mother died of cancer when I was 15. My father is still alive, a + reserved man, who still nurses his sorrow for his wife's death. I + have no reason to believe my parents anything but normal and + useful members of society. My sister is normal and happily + married. My brother I have reason to believe to be an invert. + + "A horoscope cast for me describes me in a way I think correct, + and so do my friends: 'A mild, obliging, gentle, amiable person, + with many fine traits of character; timid in nature, fond of + society, loving peace and quietude, delighting in warm and close + friendships. There is much that is firm, steadfast and + industrious, some self-love, a good deal of diplomacy, a little + that is subtle, or what is called finesse. You are reserved with + those you dislike. There is a serious and sad side to your + character; you are very thoughtful and contemplative when in + these moods. But you are not pessimistic. You have superior + abilities, for they are intuitively intellectual. There is a cold + reticence which restrains generous impulses and which inclines to + acquisitiveness; it will make you deliberate, inventive, adding + self-esteem, some vanity.' + + "At an early age I was left much alone in the nursery and there + contracted the habit of masturbation long before the age of + puberty. I use the word 'masturbation' for want of a better, + though it may not quite describe my case. I have never used my + hand to the penis. As far back as I can remember I have had what + a Frenchman has described as 'le fetichisme de la chaussure,' and + in those early days, before I was 6 years old, I would put on my + father's boots, taken from a cupboard at hand, and then tying or + strapping my legs together would produce an erection, and all the + pleasurable feelings experienced, I suppose, by means of + masturbation. I always did this secretly, but couldn't tell why. + I continued this practice on and off all my boyhood and youth. + When I discovered the first emission I was much surprised. I + always did this thing without loosening my trousers. As to how + these feelings arose I am totally unable to say. I can't remember + being without such feelings, and they seem to me perfectly + normal. The sight, or even thought, of high boots, or leggings, + especially if well polished or in patent leather, would set all + my sexual passions aflame, and does yet. As a boy my great desire + was to wear these things. A soldier in boots and spurs, a groom + in tops, or even an errand-boy in patent leather leggings, + fascinated me, and to this day, despite reason and everything + else. The sight of such things produced an erection. An emission + I could always produce by tightly tying my legs together, but + only when wearing boots, and preferably leggings, which when I + had pocket money I bought for this purpose. (At the present + moment I have five pairs in the house and two pairs of high + boots, quite unjustified by ordinary use.) This habit I lapse + into yet at times. The smell of leather affects me, but I never + know how far this may be due to association with boots; the smell + suggests the image. Restraint by a leather strap is more exciting + than by cords. Erotic dreams always take the form of restraint on + the limbs when booted. + + "Uniforms and liveries have a great temptation for me, but only + when of a tight-fitting nature and smart, as soldiers', grooms', + etc., but not sailors'; most powerfully when the person is in + boots or leggings and breeches. + + "I was a quiet, sensitive boy, taking no part in games or sports. + Have always been indifferent to them. I made few friends, but + didn't want them. The craving for friendship came much later, + after I was 21. I was a day boy at a private school, and never + had any conversation with any boy on sexual matters, though I was + dimly aware of much 'nastiness' about the school. I knew nothing + of sodomy. But all these things were repulsive to me, + notwithstanding my secret practices. I was a 'good boy.' + + "Up to the age of 21 I was perfectly satisfied with my own + society, something of a prig, fond of books and reading, etc. I + was and ever have been absolutely insensible to the influence of + the other sex. I am not a woman hater, and take intellectual + pleasure in the society of certain ladies, but they are nearly + all much older than myself. I have a strong repulsion from sexual + relations with women. I should not mind being married for the + sake of companionship and for the sake of having boys of my own. + But the sexual act would frighten me. I could not in my present + frame of mind go to bed with a woman. Yet I feel an immense envy + of my married friends in that they are able to give out, and find + satisfaction for, their affection in a way that is quite + impossible for me. I picture certain boys in the place of the + wife. + + "I am now only happy in the society of men younger than myself, + age 17 to (say) 23 or 24, youths with smooth faces, or first sign + of hair on lip, well groomed, slightly effeminate in feature, of + sympathetic, perhaps weak nature. I feel I want to help them, do + something for them, devote myself entirely to their welfare. + + "With such there is no fixed line between friendship and love. I + yearn for intimacy with particular friends, but never dare + express it. I find so many people object to any strong expression + of feeling that I dare not run the risk of appearing ridiculous + in the eyes of these desired intimates. + + "I have no desire for _paedicatio_, but the idea itself does not + repulse me or seem unnatural, though personally it repels me a + little. But I think this to be mere prejudice on my part, which + might be broken down if the loved person showed a willingness to + act a passive part. I should never dare to make an advance, + however. + + "I am restrained by moral and religious considerations from + making my real feelings known, and I feel I should sink in my own + estimation if I gave way, though my natural desire is to do so. + In the face of opportunities (not I mean of _paedicatio_, but of + expression of excessive affection, etc.), or what might be such, + I always fail to speak lest I should forfeit the esteem of the + other person. I have a feeling of surprise when any one I like + evinces a liking for me. I feel that those I love are + immeasurably my superiors, though my reason may tell me it is not + so. I would grovel at their feet, do anything to win a smile from + them, or to make them give me their company. + + "Ordinary bodily contact with the boy I love gives me most + exquisite pleasure, and I never lose an opportunity of bringing + such contact about when it can be done naturally. I feel an + immense desire to embrace, kiss, squeeze, etc., the person, to + generally maul him, and say nice things--the kind of things a man + usually says to a woman. A handshake, the mere presence of the + person, makes me happy and content. + + "I can say with the Albanian: 'If I find myself in the presence + of the beloved, I rest absorbed in gazing on him. Absent, I think + of nought but him. If the beloved unexpectedly appears I fall + into confusion. My heart beats faster. I have eyes and ears only + for the beloved.' + + "I feel that my capacity of affection is finer and more spiritual + than that which commonly subsists between persons of different + sexes. And so, while trying to fight my instincts by religion, I + find my natural feeling to be part of my religion, and its + highest expression. In this sense I can speak from experience in + my own case, and more especially in that of my brother, that what + you have said about philanthropic activity resulting from + repressed homosexuality is very true indeed. I can say with one + of your female cases: 'Love is to me a religion. The very nature + of my affection for my friends precludes the possibility of any + element entering into it which is not absolutely pure and + sacred.' I am, however, madly jealous. I want entire possession, + and I can't bear for a moment that any one I do not care for + should know the person I love. + + "I am never attracted by men older than myself. The youths who + attract me may be of any class, though preferably, I think, of a + class a little lower than myself. I am not quite sure of this, + however, as circumstances may have contributed more than + deliberate choice to bring certain youths under my notice. Those + who have exercised the most powerful influence on me have been an + Oxford undergraduate, a barber's assistant, and a plumber's + apprentice. Though naturally fond of intellectual society, I do + not ask for intellect in those I love. It goes for nothing. I + always prefer their company to that of the most educated persons. + This preference has alienated me to some extent from more refined + and educated circles that formerly I was intimate with. + + "I have been led entirely out of my old habits by association + with younger friends, and now do things which before I should + never have dreamed of doing. My thoughts now are always with + certain youths, and if they speak of leaving the town, or in any + way talk of a future that I cannot share, I suffer horrid + sinkings of the heart and depression of spirits." + +This case, while it concerns a person of quite different temperament, with +a more innate predisposition to specific perversions, is yet in many +respects analogous to the previous case. There is boot-fetichism; nothing +is felt to be so attractive as the foot-gear, and there is also at the +same time more than this; there is the attraction of repression and +constraint developed into a sexual symbol. In C.P.'s case that symbolism +arises from the experience of an abnormal heterosexual relationship; in +A.N.'s case it is founded on auto-erotic experiences associated with +inversion; in both alike the entire symbolism has become diffused and +generalized. + +In the two cases just brought forward we have an erotic symbolism of act +founded on, and closely associated with, an erotic symbolism of object. It +may be instructive to bring forward another case in which no fetichistic +feeling toward an object can be traced, but an erotic symbolism still +clearly exists. In this case pain, even when self-inflicted, has acquired +a symbolic value as a stimulus to tumescence, without any element of +masochism. Such a case serves to indicate how the sexual attraction of +pain is really a special case of the erotic symbolism with which we are +here concerned. + + A.W., aged 50, a writer and lecturer, physically and mentally + energetic and enjoying good health. He is, however, very + emotional and of nervous temperament, but self-controlled. Though + physically well developed, the sexual organs are small. He is + married to an attractive woman, to whom he is much attached, and + has two healthy children. + + At 10 or 12 years of age he had a frequent desire to be whipped, + his parents never having struck him, and on one occasion he asked + a brother to go with him to the closet to get him to whip him on + the posterior; but on arrival he was too shy to make the request. + He did not recognize the cause of these desires, knowing nothing + of such things except from the misinformation of his + school-fellows' talk. As far as he can remember, he was an + entirely normal, healthy boy up to the age of about 15, when his + attention was arrested by an advertisement of a quack medicine + for the results of "youthful excesses." + + Being a city boy, he was unfamiliar with the coupling even of + animals, had never had a conscious erection and did not know of + frictional excitement. Experiment, however, resulted in an + orgasm, and, though believing that it was wicked or at least weak + and degrading, he indulged in masturbation at intervals, usually + about six times a month, and has continued even up to the + present. + + He had an abnormally small opening in the prepuce, making the + uncovering of the glans almost impossible. (At the age of about + 37, he himself slit the prepuce by three or four cuts of a + scissors at intervals of about ten days. This was followed by a + marked decrease in desire, especially as he shortly afterwards + learned the importance of local cleanliness.) While in college at + about the age of 19 he began to have nocturnal emissions + occasionally and once or twice a week when at stool. Alarmed by + these, he consulted a physician, who warned him of the danger, + gave him bromide and prescribed cold bathing of the parts, with a + hard, cool bed. These stopped the emissions. + + He never had connection with women until the age of about 25, and + then only three times until his marriage at 30 years of age, + being deterred partly by conscientious scruples, but more by + shyness and convention, and deriving very little pleasure from + these instances. Even since marriage he has derived more pleasure + from sexual excitement than from coitus, and can maintain + erection for as long as two hours. + + He has always been accustomed to torture himself in various + ingenious ways, nearly always connected with sex. He would burn + his skin deeply with red hot wire in inconspicuous places. These + and similar acts were generally followed by manual excitation + nearly always brought to a climax. + + He considers that he is attracted to refined and intellectual + women. But he is without very ardent desires, having several + times gone to bed with attractive women who stripped themselves + naked, but without attempting any sexual intercourse with them. + He became interested in the "Karezza" theory and has tried to + practice it with his wife, but could never entirely control the + emission. + + He has hired a masseur to whip him, as children are whipped, with + a heavy dog whip, which caused pleasurable excitement. During + this time he had relations with his wife generally about once a + week without any great ecstasy. She was cold and sexually slow, + owing to conventional sex repression and to an idea that the + whole thing was "like animals" and to fear of child-bearing, + usually necessitating the use of a cover or withdrawal. It was + only eight years after their marriage that she desired and + obtained a child. During these years he would often stick pins + through his mammae and tie them together by a string round the + pins drawn so short as to cause great pain and then indulge + himself in the sexual act. He used strong wooden clips with a + tack fixed in them, so as to pierce and pinch the mammae, and once + he drove a pin entirely through the penis itself, then obtaining + orgasm by friction. He was never able to get an automatic + emission in this way, though he often tried, not even by walking + briskly during an erection. + +In another class of cases a purely ideal symbolism may be present by means +of a fetich which acts as a powerful stimulus without itself being felt to +possess any attraction. A good illustration of this condition is furnished +by a case which has been communicated to me by a medical correspondent in +New Zealand. + + "The patient went out to South Africa as a trooper with the + contingent from New Zealand, throwing up a good position in an + office to do so. He had never had any trouble as regards + connection with women before going out to South Africa. While in + active service at the front he sustained a nasty fall from his + horse, breaking his leg. He was unconscious for four days, and + was then invalided down to Cape Town. Here he rapidly got well, + and his accustomed health returning to him he started having what + he terms 'a good time.' He repeatedly went to brothels, but was + unable to have more than a temporary erection, and no ejaculation + would take place. In one of these places he was in company with a + drunken trooper, who suggested that they should perform the + sexual act with their boots and spurs (only) on. My patient, who + was also drunk, readily assented, and to his surprise was enabled + to perform the act of copulation without any difficulty at all. + He has repeatedly tried since to perform the act without any + spurs, but is quite unable to do so; with the spurs he has no + difficulty at all in obtaining all the gratification he desires. + His general health is good. His mother was an extremely nervous + woman, and so is his sister. His father died when he was quite + young. His only other relation in the colony is a married sister, + who seems to enjoy vigorous health." + +The consideration of the cases here brought forward may suffice to show +that beyond those fetichisms which find their satisfaction in the +contemplation of a part of the body or a garment, there is a more subtle +symbolism. The foot is a center of force, an agent for exerting pressure, +and thus it furnishes a point of departure not alone for the merely static +sexual fetich, but for a dynamic erotic symbolization. The energy of its +movements becomes a substitute for the energy of the sexual organs +themselves in coitus, and exerts the same kind of fascination. The young +girl (page 35) "who seemed to have a passion for treading upon things +which would scrunch or yield under her foot," already possessed the germs +of an erotic symbolism which, under the influence of circumstances in +which she herself took an active part, developed into an adequate method +of sexual gratification.[23] The youth who was her partner learned, in the +same way, to find an erotic symbolism in all the pressure reactions of +attractive feminine feet, the swaying of a carriage beneath their weight, +the crushing of the flowers on which they tread, the slow rising of the +grass which they have pressed. Here we have a symbolism which is +altogether different from that fetichism which adores a definite object; +it is a dynamic symbolism finding its gratification in the spectacle of +movements which ideally recall the fundamental rhythm and pressure +reactions of the sexual process. + +We may trace a very similar erotic symbolism in an absolutely normal form. +The fascination of clothes in the lover's eyes is no doubt a complex +phenomenon, but in part it rests on the aptitudes of a woman's garments to +express vaguely a dynamic symbolism which must always remain indefinite +and elusive, and on that account always possess fascination. No one has so +acutely described this symbolism as Herrick, often an admirable +psychologist in matters of sexual attractiveness. Especially instructive +in this respect are his poems, "Delight in Disorder," "Upon Julia's +Clothes," and notably "Julia's Petticoat." "A sweet disorder in the +dress," he tells us, "kindles in clothes a wantonness;" it is not on the +garment itself, but on the character of its movement that he insists; on +the "erring lace," the "winning wave" of the "tempestuous petticoat;" he +speaks of the "liquefaction" of clothes, their "brave vibration each way +free," and of Julia's petticoat he remarks with a more specific symbolism +still, + + "Sometimes 'twould pant and sigh and heave, + As if to stir it scarce had leave; + But having got it, thereupon, + 'Twould make a brave expansion." + +In the play of the beloved woman's garment, he sees the whole process of +the central act of sex, with its repressions and expansions, and at the +sight is himself ready to "fall into a swoon." + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[13] G. Stanley Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. ii, p. 113. It will be noted +that the hand does not appear among the parts of the body which are +normally of supreme interest. An interest in the hand is by no means +uncommon (it may be noted, for instance, in the course of History XII in +Appendix B to vol. iii of these _Studies_), but the hand does not possess +the mystery which envelops the foot, and hand-fetichism is very much less +frequent than foot-fetichism, while glove-fetichism is remarkably rare. An +interesting case of hand-fetichism, scarcely reaching morbid intensity, is +recorded by Binet, _Etudes de Psychologie Experimentale_, pp. 13-19; and +see Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, pp. 214 et seq. + +[14] _Memoires_, vol. i, Chapter VII. + +[15] Among leading English novelists Hardy shows an unusual but by no +means predominant interest in the feet and shoes of his heroines; see, +e.g., the observations of the cobbler in _Under the Greenwood Tree_, +Chapter III. A chapter in Goethe's _Wahlverwandtschaften_ (Part I, Chapter +II) contains an episode involving the charm of the foot and the kissing of +the beloved's shoe. + +[16] Schinz, "Philosophie des Conventions Sociales," _Revue +Philosophique_, June, 1903, p. 626. Mirabeau mentions in his _Erotika +Biblion_ that modern Greek women sometimes use their feet to provoke +orgasm in their lovers. I may add that simultaneous mutual masturbation by +means of the feet is not unknown to-day, and I have been told by an +English shoe-fetichist that he at one time was accustomed to practice this +with a married lady (Brazilian)--she with slippers on and he without--who +derived gratification equal to his own. + +[17] Jacoby (loc. cit. pp. 796-7) gives a large number of references to +Ovid's works bearing on this point. "In reading him," he remarks, "one is +inclined to say that the psychology of the Romans was closely allied to +that of the Chinese." + +[18] R. Kleinpaul, _Sprache ohne Worte_, p. 308. See also Moll, _Kontraere +Sexualempfindung_, third edition, pp. 306-308. Bloch brings together many +interesting references bearing on the ancient sexual and religious +symbolism of the shoe, _Beitraege zur AEtiologie der Psychopathia, +Sexualis_, Teil II, p. 324. + +[19] Jacoby (loc. cit. p. 797) appears to regard shoe-fetichism as a true +atavism: "The sexual adoration of feminine foot-gear," he concludes, +"perhaps the most enigmatic and certainly the most singular of +degenerative insanities, is thus merely a form of atavism, the return of +the degenerate to the very ancient and primitive psychology which we no +longer understand and are no longer capable of feeling." + +[20] Moll has reported in detail (_Untersuchungen ueber die Libido +Sexualis_, bd. i, Teil II, pp. 320-324) a case which both he and +Krafft-Ebing regard as illustrative of the connection between +boot-fetichism and masochism. It is essentially a case of masochism, +though manifesting itself almost exclusively in the desire to perform +humiliating acts in connection with the attractive person's boots. + +[21] Krafft-Ebing goes so far as to assert (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, +English translation of tenth edition, p. 174) that "when in cases of +shoe-fetichism the female shoe appears alone as the excitant of sexual +desire one is justified in presuming that masochistic motives have +remained latent.... Latent masochism may always be assumed as the +unconscious motive." In this way he hopelessly misinterprets some of his +own cases. + +[22] Krafft-Ebing goes so far as to assert (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, +English translation, pp. 159 and 174). Yet some of the cases he brings +forward (e.g., Coxe's as quoted by Hammond) show no sign of masochism, +since, according to Krafft-Ebing's own definition (p. 116), the idea of +subjugation by the opposite sex is of the essence of masochism. + +[23] Her actions suggest that there is often a latent sexual consciousness +in regard to the feet in women, atavistic or pseudo-atavistic, and +corresponding to the sexual attraction which the feet formerly aroused, +almost normally, in men. This is also suggested by the case, referred to +by Shufeldt, of an unmarried woman, belonging to a family exhibiting in a +high degree both erotic and neurotic traits, who had "a certain +uncontrollable fascination for shoes. She delights in new shoes, and +changes her shoes all day long at regular intervals of three hours each. +She keeps this row of shoes out in plain sight in her apartment." (R.W. +Shufeldt, "On a Case of Female Impotency," 1896, p. 10.) + + + + +III. + +Scatalogic Symbolism--Urolagnia--Coprolagnia--The Ascetic Attitude Towards +the Flesh--Normal basis of Scatalogic Symbolism--Scatalogic Conceptions +Among Primitive Peoples--Urine as a Primitive Holy Water--Sacredness of +Animal Excreta--Scatalogy in Folk-lore--The Obscene as Derived from the +Mythological--The Immature Sexual Impulse Tends to Manifest Itself in +Scatalogic Forms--The basis of Physiological Connection Between the +Urinary and Genital Spheres--Urinary Fetichism Sometimes Normal in +Animals--The Urolagnia of Masochists--The Scatalogy of Saints--Urolagnia +More Often a Symbolism of Act Than a Symbolism of Object--Only +Occasionally an Olfactory Fetichism--Comparative Rarity of +Coprolagnia--Influence of Nates Fetichism as a Transition to +Coprolagnia--Ideal Coprolagnia--Olfactory Coprolagnia--Urolagnia and +Coprolagnia as Symbols of Coitus. + + +We meet with another group of erotic symbolisms--alike symbolisms of +object and of act--in connection with the two functions adjoining the +anatomical sexual focus: the urinary and alvine excretory functions. These +are sometimes termed the scatalogical group, with the two subdivisions of +urolagnia and Coprolagnia.[24] _Inter faeces et urinam nascimur_ is an +ancient text which has served the ascetic preachers of old for many +discourses on the littleness of man and the meanness of that reproductive +power which plays so large a part in man's life. "The stupid bungle of +Nature," a correspondent writes, "whereby the generative organs serve as a +means of relieving the bladder, is doubtless responsible for much of the +disgust which those organs excite in some minds." + +At the same time, it is necessary to point out, such reflex influence may +act not in one direction only, but also in the reverse direction. From +the standpoint of ascetic contemplation eager to belittle humanity, the +excretory centers may cast dishonor upon the genital center which they +adjoin. From the more ecstatic standpoint of the impassioned lover, eager +to magnify the charm of the woman he worships, it is not impossible for +the excretory centers to take on some charm from the irradiating center of +sex which they enclose. + +Even normally such a process is traceable. The normal lover may not +idealize the excretory functions of his mistress, but the fact that he +finds no repulsion in the most intimate contacts and feels no disgust at +the proximity of the excretory orifices or the existence of their +functions, indicates that the idealization of love has exerted at all +events a neutralizing influence; indeed, the presence of an acute +sensibility to the disturbing influence of this proximity of the excretory +orifices and their functions must be considered abnormal; Swift's +"Strephon and Chloe"--with the conviction underlying it that it is an easy +matter for the excretory functions to drown the possibilities of +love--could only have proceeded from a morbidly sensitive brain.[25] + +A more than mere neutralizing influence, a positively idealizing influence +of the sexual focus on the excretory processes adjoining it, may take +place in the lover's mind without the normal variations of sexual +attraction being over-passed, and even without the creation of an +excretory fetichism. + + Reflections of this attitude may be found in the poets. In the + _Song of Songs_ the lover says of his mistress, "Thy navel is + like a round goblet, wherein no mingled wine is wanting;" in his + lyric "To Dianeme," Herrick says with clear reference to the + mons veneris:-- + + "Show me that hill where smiling love doth sit, + Having a living fountain under it;" + + and in the very numerous poems in various languages which have + more or less obscurely dealt with the rose as the emblem of the + feminine pudenda there are occasional references to the stream + which guards or presides over the rose. It may, indeed, be + recalled that even in the name _nymphae_ anatomists commonly apply + to the _labia minora_ there is generally believed to be a poetic + allusion to the Nymphs who presided over streams, since the + _labia minora_ exert an influence on the direction of the urinary + stream. + + In _Wilhelm Meister_ (Part I, Chapter XV), Goethe, on the basis + of his own personal experiences, describes his hero's emotions in + the humble surroundings of Marianne's little room as compared + with the stateliness and order of his own home. "It seemed to him + when he had here to remove her stays in order to reach the + harpsichord, there to lay her skirt on the bed before he could + seat himself, when she herself with unembarrassed frankness would + make no attempt to conceal from him many natural acts which + people are accustomed to hide from others out of decency--it + seemed to him, I say, that he became bound to her by invisible + bands." We are told of Wordsworth (Findlay's _Recollections of De + Quincey_, p. 36) that he read _Wilhelm Meister_ till "he came to + the scene where the hero, in his mistress's bedroom, becomes + sentimental over her dirty towels, etc., which struck him with + such disgust that he flung the book out of his hand, would never + look at it again, and declared that surely no English lady would + ever read such a work." I have, however, heard a woman of high + intellectual distinction refer to the peculiar truth and beauty + of this very passage. + + In one of his latest novels, _Les Rencontres de M. de Breot_, + Henri de Regnier, one of the most notable of recent French + novelists, narrates an episode bearing on the matter before us. A + personage of the story is sitting for a moment in a dark grotto + during a night fete in a nobleman's park, when two ladies enter + and laughingly proceed to raise their garments and accomplish a + natural necessity. The man in the background, suddenly overcome + by a sexual impulse, starts forward; one lady runs away, the + other, whom he detains, offers little resistance to his advances. + To M. de Breot, whom he shortly after encounters, he exclaims, + abashed at his own actions: "Why did I not flee? But could I + imagine that the spectacle of so disgusting a function would have + any other effect than to give me a humble opinion of human + nature?" M. de Breot, however, in proceeding to reproach his + interlocutor for his inconsiderate temerity, observes: "What you + tell me, sir, does not entirely surprise me. Nature has placed + very various instincts within us, and the impulse that led you to + what you have just now done is not so peculiar as you think. One + may be a very estimable man and yet love women even in what is + lowliest in their bodies." In harmony with this passage from + Regnier's novel are the remarks of a correspondent who writes to + me of the function of urination that it "appeals sexually to most + normal individuals. My own observations and inquiries prove this. + Women themselves instinctively feel it. The secrecy surrounding + the matter lends, too, I think, a sexual interest." + + The fact that scatalogic processes may in some degree exert an + attraction even in normal love has been especially emphasized by + Bloch (_Beitraege zur AEtiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil + II, pp. 222, et seq.): "The man whose intellect and aesthetic + sense has been 'clouded by the sexual impulse' sees these things + in an entirely different light from him who has not been overcome + by the intoxication of love. For him they are idealized (sit + venia verbo) since they are a part of the beloved person, and in + consequence associated with love." Bloch quotes the _Memoiren + einer Saengerin_ (a book which is said to be, though this seems + doubtful, genuinely autobiographical) in the same sense: "A man + who falls in love with a girl is not dragged out of his poetic + sphere by the thought that his beloved must relieve certain + natural necessities every day. It seems, indeed, to him to be + just the opposite. If one loves a person one finds nothing + obscene or disgusting in the object that pleases me." The + opposite attitude is probably in extreme cases due to the + influence of a neurotic or morbidly sensitive temperament. Swift + possessed such a temperament. The possession of a similar + temperament is doubtless responsible for the little prose poem, + "L'Extase," in which Huysmans in his first book, _Le Drageloir a + Epices_, has written an attenuated version of "Strephon and + Chloe" to express the disillusionment of love; the lover lies in + a wood clasping the hand of the beloved with rapturous emotion; + "suddenly she rose, disengaged her hand, disappeared in the + bushes, and I heard as it were the rustling of rain on the + leaves." His dream has fled. + +In estimating the significance of the lover's attitude in this matter, it +is important to realize the position which scatologic conceptions took in +primitive belief. At certain stages of early culture, when all the +emanations of the body are liable to possess mysterious magic properties +and become apt for sacred uses, the excretions, and especially the urine, +are found to form part of religious ritual and ceremonial function. Even +among savages the excreta are frequently regarded as disgusting, but under +the influence of these conceptions such disgust is inhibited, and those +emanations of the body which are usually least honored become religious +symbols. + + Urine has been regarded as the original holy water, and many + customs which still survive in Italy and various parts of Europe, + involving the use of a fluid which must often be yellow and + sometimes salt, possibly indicate the earlier use of urine. (The + Greek water of aspersion, according to Theocritus, was mixed + with salt, as is sometimes the modern Italian holy water. J.J. + Blunt, _Vestiges of Ancient Manners and Customs_, p. 173.) Among + the Hottentots, as Kolbein and others have recorded, the medicine + man urinated alternately on bride and bridegroom, and a + successful young warrior was sprinkled in the same way. Mungo + Park mentions that in Africa on one occasion a bride sent a bowl + of her urine which was thrown over him as a special mark of honor + to a distinguished guest. Pennant remarked that the Highlanders + sprinkled their cattle with urine, as a kind of holy water, on + the first Monday in every quarter. (Bourke, _Scatalogic Rites_, + pp. 228, 239; Brand, _Popular Antiquities_, "Bride-Ales.") + + Even the excreta of animals have sometimes been counted sacred. + This is notably so in the case of the cow, of all animals the + most venerated by primitive peoples, and especially in India. + Jules Bois (_Visions de l'Inde_, p. 86) describes the spectacle + presented in the temple of the cows at Benares: "I put my head + into the opening of the holy stables. It was the largest of + temples, a splendor of precious stones and marble, where the + venerated heifers passed backwards and forwards. A whole people + adored them. They take no notice, plunged in their divine and + obscure unconsciousness. And they fulfil with serenity their + animal functions; they chew the offerings, drink water from + copper vessels, and when they are filled they relieve themselves. + Then a stercoraceous and religious insanity overcomes these + starry-faced women and venerable men; they fall on their knees, + prostrate themselves, eat the droppings, greedily drink the + liquid, which for them is miraculous and sacred." (Cf. Bourke, + _Scatalogic Rites_, Chapter XVII.) + + Among the Chevsurs of the Caucasus, perhaps an Iranian people, a + woman after her confinement, for which she lives apart, purifies + herself by washing in the urine of a cow and then returns home. + This mode of purification is recommended in the Avesta, and is + said to be used by the few remaining followers of this creed. + +We have not only to take into account the frequency with which among +primitive peoples the excretions possess a religious significance. It is +further to be noted that in the folk-lore of modern Europe we everywhere +find plentiful evidence of the earlier prevalence of legends and practices +of a scatalogical character. It is significant that in the majority of +cases it is easy to see a sexual reference in these stories and customs. +The legends have lost their earlier and often mythical significance, and +frequently take on a suggestion of obscenity, while the scatalogical +practices have become the magical devices of lovelorn maidens or forsaken +wives practiced in secrecy. It has happened to scatalogical rites to be +regarded as we may gather from the _Clouds_ of Aristophanes, that the +sacred leathern phallus borne by the women in the Bacchanalia was becoming +in his time, an object to arouse the amusement of little boys. + + Among many primitive peoples throughout the world, and among the + lower social classes of civilized peoples, urine possesses magic + properties, more especially, it would seem, the urine of women + and that of people who stand, or wish to stand, in sexual + relationship to each other. In a legend of the Indians of the + northwest coast of America, recorded by Boas, a woman gives her + lover some of her urine and says: "You can wake the dead if you + drop some of my urine in their ears and nose." (_Zeitschrift fuer + Ethnologie_, 1894, Heft IV, p. 293.) Among the same Indians there + is a legend of a woman with a beautiful white skin who found on + bathing every morning in the river that the fish were attracted + to her skin and could not be driven off even by magical + solutions. At last she said to herself: "I will make water on + them and then they will leave me alone." She did so, and + henceforth the fish left her. But shortly after fire came from + Heaven and killed her. (Ib., 1891, Heft V, p. 640.) Among both + Christians and Mohammedans a wife can attach an unfaithful + husband by privately putting some of her urine in his drink. (B. + Stern, _Medizin in der Tuerkei_, vol. ii, p. 11.) This practice is + world-wide; thus among the aborigines of Brazil, according to + Martius, the urine and other excretions and secretions are potent + for aphrodisiacal objects. (Bourke's _Scatalogic Rites of All + Nations_ contains many references to the folk-lore practices in + this matter; a study of popular beliefs in the magic power of + urine, published in Bombay by Professor Eugen Wilhelm in 1889, I + have not seen.) + + The legends which narrate scatalogic exploits are numerous in the + literature of all countries. Among primitive peoples they often + have a purely theological character, for in the popular + mythologies of all countries (even, as we learn from + Aristophanes, among the Greeks) natural phenomena such as the + rain, are apt to be regarded as divine excretions, but in course + of time the legends take on a more erotic or a more obscene + character. In the Irish _Book of Leinster_ (written down + somewhere about the twelfth century, but containing material of + very much older date) we are told how a number of princesses in + Emain Macha, the seat of the Ulster Kings, resolved to find out + which of them could by urinating on it melt a snow pillar which + the men had made, the woman who succeeded to be regarded as the + best among them. None of them succeeded, and they sent for + Derbforgaill, who was in love with Cuchullain, and she was able + to melt the pillar; whereupon the other women, jealous of the + superiority she had thus shown, tore out her eyes. (Zimmer, + "Keltische Beitraege," _Zeitschrift fuer Deutsche Alterthum_, vol. + xxxii, Heft II, pp. 216-219.) Rhys considers that Derbforgaill + was really a goddess of dawn and dusk, "the drop glistening in + the sun's rays," as indicated by her name, which means a drop or + tear. (J. Rhys, _Lectures on the Origin and Growth of Religion as + Illustrated by Celtic Heathendom_, p. 466.) It is interesting to + compare the legend of Derbforgaill with a somewhat more modern + Picardy folk-lore _conte_ which is clearly analogous but no + longer seems to show any mythologic element, "La Princesse qui + pisse par dessus les Meules." This princess had a habit of + urinating over hay-cocks; the king, her father, in order to break + her of the habit, offered her in marriage to anyone who could + make a hay-cock so high that she could not urinate over it. The + young men came, but the princess would merely laugh and at once + achieve the task. At last there came a young man who argued with + himself that she would not be able to perform this feat after she + had lost her virginity. He therefore seduced her first and she + then failed ignobly, merely wetting her stockings. Accordingly, + she became his bride. (Kryptadia, vol. i. p. 333.) Such legends, + which have lost any mythologic elements they may originally have + possessed and have become merely _contes_, are not uncommon in + the folk-lore of many countries. But in their earlier more + religious forms and in their later more obscene forms, they alike + bear witness to the large place which scatalogic conceptions play + in the primitive mind. + +It is a notable fact in evidence of the close and seemingly normal +association with the sexual impulse of the scatalogic processes, that an +interest in them, arising naturally and spontaneously, is one of the most +frequent channels by which the sexual impulse first manifests itself in +young boys and girls. + + Stanley Hall, who has made special inquiries into the matter, + remarks that in childhood the products of excretion by bladder + and bowels are often objects of interest hardly less intense for + a time than eating and drinking. ("Early Sense of Self," + _American Journal of Psychology_, April, 1898, p. 361.) + "Micturitional obscenities," the same writer observes again, + "which our returns show to be so common before adolescence, + culminate at 10 or 12, and seem to retreat into the background as + sex phenomena appear." They are, he remarks, of two classes: + "Fouling persons or things, secretly from adults, but openly with + each other," and less often "ceremonial acts connected with the + act or the product that almost suggest the scatalogical rites of + savages, unfit for description here, but of great interest and + importance." (G. Stanley Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. i, p. 116.) + The nature of such scatalogical phenomena in childhood--which are + often clearly the instinctive manifestations of an erotic + symbolism--and their wide prevalence among both boys and girls, + are very well illustrated in a narrative which I include in + Appendix B, History II. + +In boys as they approach the age of puberty, this attraction to the +scatalogic, when it exists, tends to die out, giving place to more normal +sexual conceptions, or at all events it takes a subordinate and less +serious place in the mind. In girls, on the other hand, it often tends to +persist. Edmond de Goncourt, a minute observer of the feminine mind, +refers in _Cherie_ to "those innocent and triumphant gaieties which +scatalogic stories have the privilege of arousing in women who have +remained still children, even the most distinguished women." The extent to +which innocent young women, who would frequently be uninterested or +repelled in presence of the sexually obscene are sometimes attracted by +the scatalogically obscene, becomes intelligible, however, if we realize +that a symbolism comes here into play. In women the more specifically +sexual knowledge and experience of life frequently develop much later than +in men or even remains in abeyance, and the specifically sexual phenomena +cannot therefore easily lend themselves to wit, or humor, or imagination. +But the scatalogic sphere, by the very fact that in women it is a +specially intimate and secret region which is yet always liable to be +unexpectedly protruded into consciousness, furnishes an inexhaustible +field for situations which have the same character as those furnished by +the sexually obscene. It thus happens that the sexually obscene which in +men tends to overshadow the scatalogically obscene, in women--partly from +inexperience and partly, it is probable, from their almost physiological +modesty--plays a part subordinate to the scatalogical. In a somewhat +analogous way scatalogical wit and humor play a considerable part in the +work of various eminent authors who were clergymen or priests. + +In addition to the anatomical and psychological associations which +contribute to furnish a basis on which erotic symbolisms may spring up, +there are also physiological connections between the genital and urinary +spheres which directly favor such symbolisms. In discussing the analysis +of the sexual impulse in a previous volume of these _Studies_, I have +pointed out the remarkable relationship--sometimes of transference, +sometimes of compensation--which exists between genital tension and +vesical tension, both in men and women. In the histories of normal sexual +development brought together at the end of that and subsequent volumes the +relationship may frequently be traced, as also in the case of C.P. in the +present study (p. 37). Vesical power is also commonly believed to be in +relation with sexual potency, and the inability to project the urinary +stream in a normal manner is one of the accepted signs of sexual +impotency.[26] Fere, again, has recorded the history of a man with +periodic crises of sexual desire, and subsequently sexual obsession +without desire, which were always accompanied by the impulse to urinate +and by increased urination.[27] In the case, recorded by Pitres and Regis, +of a young girl who, having once at the sight of a young man she liked in +a theater been overcome by sexual feeling accompanied by a strong desire +to urinate, was afterward tormented by a groundless fear of experiencing +an irresistible desire to urinate at inconvenient times,[28] we have an +example of what may be called a physiological scatalogic symbolism of sex, +an emotion which was primarily erotic becoming transferred to the bladder +and then remaining persistent. From such a physiological symbolism it is +but a step to the psychological symbolisms of scatalogic fetichism. + + It is worthy of note, as an indication that such phenomena are + scarcely abnormal, that a urinary symbolism, and even a strictly + sexual fetichism, are normal among many animals. + + The most familiar example of this kind is furnished by the dog, + who is sexually excited in this manner by traces of the bitch and + himself takes every opportunity of making his own path + recognizable. "This custom," Espinas remarks (_Des Societes + Animales_, p. 228), "has no other aim than to spread along the + road recognizable traces of their presence for the benefit of + individuals of the other sex, the odor of these traces doubtless + causing excitement." + + It is noteworthy, also, that in animals as well as in man, sexual + excitement may manifest itself in the bladder. Thus Daumas states + (_Chevaux de Sahara_, p. 49) that if the mare urinates when she + hears the stallion neigh it is a sign that she is ready for + connection. + +It is in masochism, or passive algolagnia, that we may most frequently +find scatalogic symbolism in its fully developed form. The man whose +predominant impulse is to subjugate himself to his mistress and to receive +at her hands the utmost humiliation, frequently finds the climax of his +gratification in being urinated on by her, whether in actual fact or only +in imagination. + +In many such cases, however, it is evident that we have a mixed +phenomenon; the symbolism is double. The act becomes desirable because it +is the outward and visible sign of an inwardly experienced abject slavery +to an adored person. But it is also desirable because of intimately sexual +associations in the act itself, as a symbolical detumescence, a simulacrum +of the sexual act, and one which proceeds from the sexual focus itself. + + Krafft-Ebing records various cases of masochism in which the + emission of urine on to the body or into the mouth formed the + climax of sexual gratification, as, for instance (_Psychopathia + Sexualis_, English translation, p. 183) in the case of a Russian + official who as a boy had fancies of being bound between the + thighs of a woman, compelled to sleep beneath her nates and to + drink her urine, and in later life experienced the greatest + excitement when practicing the last part of this early + imagination. + + In another case, recorded by Krafft-Ebing and by him termed + "ideal masochism" (_Op. cit._, pp. 127-130), the subject from + childhood indulged in voluptuous day-dreams in which he was the + slave of a beautiful mistress who would compel him to obey all + her caprices, stand over him with one foot on his breast, sit on + his face and body, make him wait on her in her bath, or when she + urinated, and sometimes insist on doing this on his face; though + a highly intellectual man, he was always too timid to attempt to + carry any of his ideas into execution; he had been troubled by + nocturnal enuresis up to the age of 20. + + Neri, again (_Archivio delle Psicopatie Sessuali_, vol. i, fasc. + 7 and 8, 1896), records the case of an Italian masochist who + experienced the greatest pleasure when both urination and + defecation were practiced in this manner by the woman he was + attached to. + + In a previous volume of these _Studies_ ("Sexual Inversion," + History XXVI) I have recorded the masochistic day-dreams of a boy + whose impulses were at the same time inverted; in his reveries + "the central fact," he states, "became the discharge of urine + from my lover over my body and limbs, or, if I were very fond of + him, I let it be in my face." In actual life the act of urination + casually witnessed in childhood became the symbol, even the + reality, of the central secret of sex: "I stood rooted and + flushing with downcast eyes till the act was over, and was + conscious for a considerable time of stammering speech and + bewildered faculties.... I was overwhelmed with emotion and could + barely drag my feet from the spot or my eyes from the damp + herbage where he had deposited the waters of secrecy. Even to-day + I cannot dissociate myself from the shuddering charm that moment + had for me." + +It is not only the urine and the faeces which may thus acquire a symbolic +fascination and attractiveness under the influence of masochistic +deviations of sexual idealization. In some cases extreme rapture has been +experienced in licking sweating feet. There is, indeed, no excretion or +product of the body which has not been a source of ecstasy: the sweat from +every part of the body, the saliva and menstrual fluid, even the wax from +the ears. + + Krafft-Ebing very truly points out (_Psychopathia Sexualis_, + English translation, p. 178) that this sexual scatalogic + symbolism is precisely paralleled by a religious scatalogic + symbolism. In the excesses of devout enthusiasm the ascetic + performs exactly the same acts as are performed in these excesses + of erotic enthusiasm. To mix excreta with the food, to lick up + excrement, to suck festering sores--all these and the like are + acts which holy and venerated women have performed. + + Not only the saint, but also the prophet and medicine-man have + been frequently eaters of human excrement; it is only necessary + to refer to the instance of the prophet Ezekiel, who declared + that he was commanded to bake his bread with human dung, and to + the practices of medicine-men at Torres Straits, in whose + training the eating of human excrement takes a recognized part. + (Deities, notably Baal-Phegor, were sometimes supposed to eat + excrement, so that it was natural that their messengers and + representatives among men should do so. As regards Baal-Phegor, + see Dulaure, _Des Divinites Generatrices_, Chapter IV, and J.G. + Bourke, _Scatalogic Rites of All Nations_, p. 241. See also + Ezekiel, Chapter IV, v. 12, and _Reports Anthropological + Expedition to Torres Straits_, vol. v, p. 321.) + + It must be added, however, that while the masochist is overcome + by sexual rapture, so that he sees nothing disgusting in his act, + the medicine-man and the ascetic are not so invariably overcome + by religious rapture, and several ascetic writers have referred + to the horror and disgust they experienced, at all events at + first, in accomplishing such acts, while the medicine-men when + novices sometimes find the ordeal too severe and have to abandon + their career. Brenier de Montmorand, while remarking, not without + some exaggeration, that "the Christian ascetics are almost all + eaters of excrement" ("Ascetisme et Mysticisme," _Revue + Philosophique_, March, 1904, p. 245), quotes the testimonies of + Marguerite-Marie and Madame Guyon as to the extreme repugnance + which they had to overcome. They were impelled by a merely + intellectual symbolism of self-mortification rather than by the + profoundly felt emotional symbolism which moves the masochist. + + Coprophagic acts, whether under the influences of religious + exaltation or of sexual rapture, inevitably excite our disgust. + We regard them as almost insane, fortified in that belief by the + undoubted fact that coprophagia is not uncommon among the insane. + It may, therefore, be proper to point out that it is not so very + long since the ingestion of human excrement was carried out by + our own forefathers in the most sane and deliberate manner. It + was administered by medical practitioners for a great number of + ailments, apparently with entirely satisfactory results. Less + than two centuries ago, Schurig, who so admirably gathered + together and arranged the medical lore of his own and the + immediately preceding ages, wrote a very long and detailed + chapter, "De Stercoris Humani Usu Medico" (_Chylologia_, 1725, + cap. XIII; in the Paris _Journal de Medecine_ for February 19, + 1905, there appeared an article, which I have not seen, entitled + "Medicaments oubliees: l'urine et la fiente humaine.") The + classes of cases in which the drug was found beneficial would + seem to have been extremely various. It must not be supposed that + it was usually ingested in the crude form. A common method was to + take the faeces of boys, dry them, mix them with the best honey, + and administer an electuary. (At an earlier period such drugs + appear to have met with some opposition from the Church, which + seems to have seen in them only an application of magic; thus I + note that in Burchard's remarkable Penitential of the fourteenth + century, as reproduced by Wasserschleben, 40 days' penance is + prescribed for the use of human urine or excrement as a medicine. + Wasserschleben _Die Bussordnungen der Abendlaendlichen Kirche_, p. + 651.) + +The urolagnia of masochism is not a simple phenomenon; it embodies a +double symbolism: on the one hand a symbolism of self-abnegation, such as +the ascetic feels, on the other hand a symbolism of transferred sexual +emotion. Krafft-Ebing was disposed to regard all cases in which a +scatalogical sexual attraction existed as due to "latent masochism." Such +a point of view is quite untenable. Certainly the connection is common, +but in the majority of cases of slightly marked scatalogical fetichism no +masochism is evident. And when we bear in mind the various considerations, +already brought forward, which show how widespread and clearly realized is +the natural and normal basis furnished for such symbolism, it becomes +quite unnecessary to invoke any aid from masochism. There is ample +evidence to show that, either as a habitual or more usually an occasional +act, the impulse to bestow a symbolic value on the act of urination in a +beloved person, is not extremely uncommon; it has been noted of men of +high intellectual distinction; it occurs in women as well as men; when +existing in only a slight degree, it must be regarded as within the normal +limits of variation of sexual emotion. + + The occasional cases in which the urine is drunk may possibly + suggest that the motive lies in the properties of the fluid + acting on the system. Support for this supposition might be found + in the fact that urine actually does possess, apart altogether + from its magic virtues embodied in folk-lore, the properties of a + general stimulant. In composition (as Masterman first pointed + out) "beef-tea differs little from healthy urine," containing + exactly the same constituents, except that in beef-tea there is + less urea and uric acid. Fresh urine--more especially that of + children and young women--is taken as a medicine in nearly all + parts of the world for various disorders, such as epistaxis, + malaria and hysteria, with benefit, this benefit being almost + certainly due to its qualities as a general stimulant and + restorative. William Salmon's _Dispensatory_, 1678 (quoted in + _British Medical Journal_, April 21, 1900, p. 974), shows that in + the seventeenth century urine still occupied an important place + as a medicine, and it frequently entered largely into the + composition of Aqua Divina. + + Its use has been known even in England in the nineteenth century. + (Masterman, _Lancet_, October 2, 1880; R. Neale, "Urine as a + Medicine," _Practitioner_, November, 1881; Bourke brings together + a great deal of evidence as to the therapeutic uses of urine in + his _Scatalogic Rites_, especially pp. 331-335; Lusini has shown + that normal urine invariably increases the frequency of the heart + beats, _Archivio di Farmacologia_, fascs. 19-21, 1893.) + + But it is an error to suppose that these facts account for the + urolagnic drinking of urine. As in the gratification of a normal + sexual impulse, the intense excitement of gratifying a scatalogic + sexual impulse itself produces a degree of emotional stimulation + far greater than the ingestion of a small amount of animal + extractives would be adequate to effect. In such cases, as much + as in normal sexuality, the stimulation is clearly psychic. + +When, as is most commonly the case, it is the process of urination and not +the urine itself which is attractive, we are clearly concerned with a +symbolism of act and not with the fetichistic attraction of an excretion. +When the excretion, apart from the act, provides the attraction, we seem +usually to be in the presence of an olfactory fetichism. These fetichisms +connected with the excreta appear to be experienced chiefly by individuals +who are somewhat weak-minded, which is not necessarily the case in regard +to those persons for whom the act, rather than its product apart from the +beloved person, is the attractive symbol. + + The sexually symbolic nature of the act of urination for many + people is indicated by the existence, according to Bloch, who + enumerates various kinds of indecent photographs, of a group + which he terms "the notorious _pisseuses_." It is further + indicated by several of the reproductions in Fuch's _Erotsiche + Element in der Karikatur_, such as Delorme's "La Necessite n'a + point de Loi." (It should be added that such a scene by no means + necessarily possesses any erotic symbolism, as we may see in + Rembrandt's etching commonly called "Le Femme qui Pisse," in + which the reflected lights on the partly shadowed stream furnish + an artistic motive which is obviously free from any trace of + obscenity.) In the case which Krafft-Ebing quotes from Maschka of + a young man who would induce young girls to dance naked in his + room, to leap, and to urinate in his presence, whereupon seminal + ejaculation would take place, we have a typical example of + urolagnic symbolism in a form adequate to produce complete + gratification. A case in which the urolagnic form of scatalogic + symbolism reached its fullest development as a sexual perversion + has been described in Russia by Sukhanoff (summarized in + _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, November, 1900, and + _Annales Medico-psychologiques_, February, 1901), that of a young + man of 27, of neuropathic temperament, who when he once chanced + to witness a woman urinating experienced voluptuous sensations. + From that moment he sought close contact with women urinating, + the maximum of gratification being reached when he could place + himself in such a position that a woman, in all innocence, would + urinate into his mouth. All his amorous adventures were concerned + with the search for opportunities for procuring this difficult + gratification. Closets in which he was able to hide, winter + weather and dull days he found most favorable to success. (A + somewhat similar case is recorded in the _Archives de + Neurologie_, 1902, p. 462.) + + In the case of a robust man of neuropathic heredity recorded by + Pelanda some light is shed on the psychic attitude in these + manifestations; there was masturbation up to the age of 16, when + he abandoned the practice, and up to the age of 30 found complete + satisfaction in drinking the still hot urine of women. When a + lady or girl in the house went to her room to satisfy a need of + this kind, she had hardly left it but he hastened in, overcome by + extreme excitement, culminating in spontaneous ejaculation. The + younger the woman the greater the transport he experienced. It is + noteworthy that in this, as possibly in all similar cases, there + was no sensory perversion and no morbid attraction of taste or + smell; he stated that the action of his senses was suspended by + his excitement, and that he was quite unable to perceive the odor + or taste of the fluid. (Pelanda, "Pornopatice," _Archivio di + Psichiatria_, facs. iii-iv, 1889, p. 356.) It is in the emotional + symbolism that the fascination lies and not in any sensory + perversion. + + Magnan records the spontaneous development of this sexual + symbolism in a girl of 11, of good intellectual development but + alcoholic heredity, who seduced a boy younger than herself to + mutual masturbation, and on one occasion, lying on the ground and + raising her clothes, asked him to urinate on her. (_International + Congress of Criminal Anthropology_, 1889.) This case (except for + the early age of the subject) illustrates sporadically occurring + urolagnic symbolism in a woman, to whom such symbolism is fairly + obvious on account of the close resemblance between the emission + of urine and the ejaculation of semen in the man, and the fact + that the same conduit serves for both fluids. (A urolagnic + day-dream of this kind is recorded in the history of a lady + contained in the third volume of these _Studies_, Appendix B, + History VIII.) The natural and inevitable character of this + symbolism is shown by the fact that among primitive peoples urine + is sometimes supposed to possess the fertilizing virtues of + semen. J.G. Frazer in his edition of Pausanias (vol. iv, p. 139) + brings together various stories of women impregnated by urine. + Hartland also (_Legend of Perseus_, vol. i, pp. 76, 92) records + legends of women who were impregnated by accidentally or + intentionally drinking urine. + + The symbolic sexual significance of urolagnia has hitherto + usually been confused with the fetichistic and mainly olfactory + perversion by which the excretion itself becomes a source of + sexual excitement. Long since Tardieu referred, under the name of + "renifleurs," to persons who were said to haunt the neighborhood + of quiet passages, more especially in the neighborhood of + theatres, and who when they perceived a woman emerge after + urination, would hasten to excite themselves by the odor of the + excretion. Possibly a fetichism of this kind existed in a case + recorded by Belletrud and Mercier (_Annales d'Hygiene Publique_, + June, 1904, p. 48). A weak-minded, timid youth, who was very + sexual but not attractive to women, would watch for women who + were about to urinate and immediately they had passed on would go + and lick the spot they had moistened, at the same time + masturbating. Such a fetichistic perversion is strictly analogous + to the fetichism by which women's handkerchiefs, aprons or + underlinen become capable of affording sexual gratification. A + very complete case of such urolagnic fetichism--complete because + separated from association with the person accomplishing the act + of urination--has been recorded by Moraglia in a woman. It is the + case of a beautiful and attractive young woman of 18, with thick + black hair, and expressive vivacious eyes, but sallow complexion. + Married a year previously, but childless, she experienced a + certain amount of pleasure in coitus, but she preferred + masturbation, and frankly acknowledged that she was highly + excited by the odor of fermented urine. So strong was this + fetichism that when, for instance, she passed a street urinal she + was often obliged to go aside and masturbate; once she went for + this purpose into the urinal itself and was almost discovered in + the act, and on another occasion into a church. Her perversion + caused her much worry because of the fear of detection. She + preferred, when she could, to obtain a bottle of urine--which + must be stale and a man's (this, she said, she could detect by + the smell)--and to shut herself up in her own room, holding the + bottle in one hand and repeatedly masturbating with the other. + (Moraglia, "Psicopatie Sessuali," _Archivio di Psichiatria_, vol. + xiii, fasc. 6, p. 267, 1892.) This case is of especial interest + because of the great rarity of fully developed fetichism in + women. In a slight and germinal degree I believe that cases of + fetichism are not uncommon in women, but they are certainly rare + in a well-marked form, and Krafft-Ebing declared, even in the + late editions of his _Psychopathia Sexualis_, that he knew of no + cases in women. + +So far we have been concerned with the urolagnic rather than the +coprolagnic variety of scatalogical symbolism. Although the two are +sometimes associated there is no necessary connection, and most usually +there is no tendency for the one to involve the other. Urolagnia is +certainly much the more frequently found; the act of urination is far more +apt to suggest erotically symbolical ideas than the idea of defecation. +It is not difficult to understand why this should be so. The act of +urination lends itself more easily to sexual symbolism; it is more +intimately associated with the genital function; its repetition is +necessary at more frequent intervals so that it is more in evidence; +moreover, its product, unlike that of the act of defecation, is not +offensive to the senses. Still coprolagnia occurs and not so very +infrequently. Burton remarked that even the normal lover is affected by +this feeling: "immo nec ipsum amicae stercus foctet."[29] + +Of Caligula who, however, was scarcely sane, it was said "et quidem +stercus uxoris degustavit."[30] In Parisian brothels (according to Taxil +and others) provision is made for those who are sexually excited by the +spectacle of the act of defecation (without reference to contact or odor) +by means of a "tabouret de verre," from under the glass floor of which the +spectacle of the defecating women may be closely observed. It may be added +that the erotic nature of such a spectacle is referred to in the Marquis +de Sade's novels. + +There is one motive for the existence of coprolagnia which must not be +passed over, because it has doubtless frequently served as a mode of +transition to what, taken by itself, may well seem the least aesthetically +attractive of erotic symbols. I refer to the tendency of the nates to +become a sexual fetich. The nates have in all ages and in all parts of the +world been frequently regarded as one of the most aesthetically beautiful +parts of the feminine body.[31] It is probable that on the basis of this +entirely normal attraction more than one form of erotic symbolism is at +all events in part supported. Duehren and others have considered that the +aesthetic charm of the nates is one of the motives which prompt the desire +to inflict flagellation on women. In the same way--certainly in some and +probably in many cases--the sexual charm of the nates progressively +extends to the anal region, to the act of defecation, and finally to the +feces. + + In a case of Krafft-Ebing's (_Op. cit._, p. 183) the subject, + when a child of 6, accidentally placed his hand in contact with + the nates of the little girl who sat next to him in school, and + experienced so great a pleasure in this contact that he + frequently repeated it; when he was 10 a nursery governess, to + gratify her own desires, placed his finger in her vagina; in + adult life he developed urolagnic tendencies. + + In a case of Moll's the development of a youthful admiration for + the nates in a coprolagnic direction may be clearly traced. In + this case a young man, a merchant, in a good position, sought to + come in contact with women defecating; and with this object would + seek to conceal himself in closets; the excretal odor was + pleasurable to him, but was not essential to gratification, and + the sight of the nates was also exciting and at the same time not + essential to gratification; the act of defecation appears, + however, to have been regarded as essential. He never sought to + witness prostitutes in this situation; he was only attracted to + young, pretty and innocent women. The coprolagnia here, however, + had its source in a childish impression of admiration for the + nates. When 5 or 6 years old he crawled under the clothes of a + servant girl, his face coming in contact with her nates, an + impression that remained associated in his mind with pleasure. + Three or four years later he used to experience much pleasure + when a young girl cousin sat on his face; thus was strengthened + an association which developed naturally into coprolagnia. (Moll, + _Untersuchungen ueber die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 837.) + + It is scarcely necessary to remark that an admiration for the + nates, even when reaching a fetichistic degree, by no means + necessarily involves, even after many years, any attraction to + the excreta. A correspondent for whom the nates have constituted + a fetich for many years writes: "I find my craving for women with + profuse pelvic or posterior development is growing and I wish to + copulate from behind; but I would feel a sickening feeling if any + part of my person came in contact with the female anus. It is + more pleasing to me to see the nates than the mons, yet I loathe + everything associated with the anal region." + +Moll has recorded in detail a case of what may be described as "ideal +coprolagnia"--that is to say, where the symbolism, though fully developed +in imagination, was not carried into real life--which is of great interest +because it shows how, in a very intelligent subject, the deviated +symbolism may become highly developed and irradiate all the views of life +in the same way as the normal impulse. (The subject's desires were also +inverted, but from the present point of view the psychological interest of +the case is not thereby impaired.) Moll's case was one of symbolism of +act, the excreta offering no attraction apart from the process of +defecation. In a case which has been communicated to me there was, on the +other hand, an olfactory fetichistic attraction to the excreta even in the +absence of the person. + + In Moll's case, the patient, X., 23 years of age, belongs to a + family which he himself describes as nervous. His mother, who is + anaemic, has long suffered from almost periodical attacks of + excitement, weakness, syncope and palpitation. A brother of the + mother died in a lunatic asylum, and several other brothers + complain much of their nerves. The mother's sisters are very + good-natured, but liable to break out in furious passions; this + they inherit from their father. There appears to be no nervous + disease on the patient's father's side. X.'s sisters are also + healthy. + + X. himself is of powerful undersized build and enjoys good + health, injured by no excesses. He considers himself nervous. He + worked hard at school and was always the first in his class; he + adds, however, that this is due less to his own abilities than + the laziness of his school-fellows. He is, as he remarks, very + religious and prays frequently, but seldom goes to church. + + In regard to his psychic characters he says that he has no + specially prominent talent, but is much interested in languages, + mathematics, physics and philosophy, in fact, in abstract + subjects generally. "While I take a lively interest in every kind + of intellectual work," he says, "it is only recently that I have + been attracted to real life and its requirements. I have never + had much skill in physical exercises. For external things until + recently I have only had contempt. I have a delicately + constituted nature, loving solitude, and only associating with a + few select persons. I have a decided taste for fiction, poetry + and music; my temperament is idealistic and religious, with + strict conceptions of duty and morality, and aspirations towards + the good and beautiful. I detest all that is common and coarse, + and yet I can think and act in the way you will learn from the + following pages." + + Regarding his sexual life, X. made the following communication: + "During the last two years I have become convinced of the + perversion of my sexual instinct. I had often previously thought + that in me the impulse was not quite normal, but it is only + lately that I have become convinced of my complete perversion. I + have never read or heard of any case in which the sexual feelings + were of the same kind. Although I can feel a lively inclination + towards superior representatives of the female sex, and have + twice felt something like love, the sight or the recollection + even of a beautiful woman have never caused sexual excitement." + In the two exceptional instances mentioned it appears that X. had + an inclination to kiss the women in question, but that the + thought of coitus had no attraction. "In my voluptuous dreams, + connected with the emission of semen, women in seductive + situations have never appeared. I have never had any desire to + visit a _puella publica_. The love-stories of my fellow-students + seemed very silly, dances and balls were a horror to me, and only + on very rare occasions could I be persuaded to go into society. + It will be easy to guess the diagnosis in my case: I suffer from + the sexual attraction of my own sex, I am a lover of boys. + + "You cannot imagine what a world of thoughts, wishes, feelings + and impulses the words 'knabe,' 'pais,' 'garcon,' 'boy,' + 'ragazzo' have for me; one of these words, even in an unmeaning + clause of a translation-book, calls before me the whole sum of + associations which in course of time have become bound up with + this idea, and it is only with an effort that I can scare away + the wild band. This group of thoughts shows a wonderful mixture + of warm sensuality and ideal love, it unites my lowest and + highest impulses, the strength and the weakness of my nature, my + curse and my blessing. My inclination is especially towards boys + of the age of 12 to 15; though they may be rather younger or + older. That I should prefer beautiful and intelligent boys is + comprehensible. I do not want a prostitute, but a friend or a + son, whose soul I love, whom I can help to become a more perfect + man, such as I myself would willingly be. + + "When I myself belonged to that happy age (i.e., below 15) I had + no dearer wish than to possess a friend of similar tastes. I have + sought, hoped, waited, grieved, and been at last disillusioned, + overcome by desire and despair, and have not found that friend. + Even later the hope often reappeared, but always in vain, and I + cannot boast of that sure recognition which one reads of in the + autobiographies of Urnings. I do not know personally a single + fellow-sufferer. It is also doubtful whether such an + acquaintanceship would greatly help me, for I have a very + peculiar conception of homosexuality. As you will see, I have + little more in common with what are called paederasts than sexual + indifference to the female sex, and I often ask myself: 'Does any + other man in the whole world feel like you? Are you alone in the + earth with your morbid desires? Are you a pariah of pariahs, or + is there, perhaps, another soul with similar longings living near + you? How often in summer have I gone to the lakes and streams + outside cities to seek boys bathing; but I always came back + unsatisfied, whether I found any or not. And in winter I have + been irresistibly impelled to return to the same spots, as if it + were sanctified by the boys, but my darlings had vanished and + cold winds blew over the icy floods, so that I would return + feeling as though I had buried all my happiness. + + "It must be borne in mind, therefore, that what I have to say + regarding my sexual impulses only refers to fancies and never to + their practical realization. My sensual impulses are not + connected with the sexual organs; all my voluptuous ideas are not + in the least connected with these parts. For this reason I have + never practiced onanism and _immissio membri in anum_ is as + repulsive to me as to a normal man. Even every imitation of + coitus is, for me, without attraction. In a boy's body two things + specially excite me: _his belly and his nates_, the first as + containing the digestive tract, the second as holding the opening + of the bowels. Of the vegetable processes of life in the boy none + interest me nearly so much as the progress of his digestion and + the process of defecation. It is incredible to what an extent + this part of physiology has occupied me from youth. If as a boy I + wanted to read something of a piquantly exciting character I + sought in my father's encyclopaedia for articles like: + Obstruction, Constipation, Haemorrhoids, Faeces, etc. No function + of the body seemed to be so significant as this, and I regarded + its disturbances as the most important in the whole mechanism of + life. The description of other disorders I could read in cold + blood, but intussusception of the bowels makes me ill even + to-day. I am always extremely pleased to hear that the digestion + of the people around me is in good condition. A man who did not + sufficiently watch over his digestion aroused distrust in me, and + I imagined that wicked men must be horribly indifferent regarding + this weighty matter. Even more than in ordinary persons was I + interested in the digestion of more mysterious beings, like + magicians in legends, or men of other nations. I would willingly + have made an anthropological study of my favorite subject, only + to my annoyance books nearly always pass over the matter in + silence. In history and fiction I regretted the absence of + information concerning the state of my heroes' digestion when + they languished in prison or in some unaccustomed or unhealthy + spot. For this reason I held no book more precious than one which + describes how a young man after being shipwrecked lived for a + long time in a narrow snow-hut, and it was conscientiously stated + that he became aware of digestive disturbances. No immorality + angers me more than the foolish practice of ladies who in society + neglect the satisfaction of their natural needs from misplaced + motives of modesty. On a railway journey I suffer horribly from + the thought that one of my fellow-travelers may be prevented from + fulfilling some imperative natural necessity. + + "I naturally devote the greatest attention to my own digestion. + With painful conscientiousness I go to stool every day at the + same hour; if the operation does not come off to my satisfaction + I feel not so much physical as mental discomfort. To this quite + useful hygienic interest became associated at puberty a sensual + interest. Since my fourteenth year I have had no greater + enjoyment than to defecate undressed (I do not do so now) after + having first carefully examined the distension of my abdomen. In + summer I would go into the woods, undress myself in a secluded + spot and indulge in the voluptuous pleasures of defecation. I + would sometimes combine with this a bath in a stream. I would + exhaust my imagination in the effort to invent specially + enjoyable variations, longed for a desert island where I could go + about naked, fill my body with much nourishing food, hold in the + excrement as long as possible and then discharge it in some + subtly-thought-out spot. These practices and ideas often caused + erections and later on emissions, but the genitals played no part + in my conceptions; their movements were uncomfortable and gave no + pleasure. + + "I soon longed to be associated in these orgies with some boy of + the same age, but I wanted not only a companion in my passion, + but also a real friend. Since there could be no question of + masturbation or paederasty, our love would have been limited to + kisses, embraces, and--as a compensation for coitus--defecation + together. That would have been perfect bliss to me. I will spare + you the unaesthetic contents of my voluptuous dreams. But I + remained without a companion, and, therefore, without real + enjoyment. [He has, however, on various occasions experienced + erections, and even emissions, on seeing, by chance, men or boys + defecate.] Hinc illae lacrimae; the excitement over my own + defecation only took place _faute de mieux_. + + "I knew very well that my thoughts and practices were impure and + contemptible. Ah! how often, when the intoxication was over, have + I thrown myself remorsefully on my knees, praying to God for + pardon! For some weeks I repressed my longing; but at last it was + too strong for me, I tried to justify myself and fell into my + vice anew. That I was guilty of licentiousness and loved boys + sexually first became clear to me later on, when I knew the + significance of erection as a sign of sexual excitement. + + "No one can imagine with what demoniacal joy I am possessed at + the thought of a beautiful naked boy whose abdomen is filled as + the result of long abstinence from stool. The thought powerfully + excites me, a flood of passion goes through my blood and my limbs + tremble. I would never grow tired of feeling that belly and + looking at it. My passion would express itself in tempestuous + caresses, and the boy would have to assume various positions in + order to show off the beauty of his form, i.e., to bring the + parts in question into better view. To observe defecation would + still further increase this peculiar enjoyment. If the boy's + bowels were not sufficiently filled I would feed him with all + sorts of food which produces much excrement, such as potatoes, + coarse bread, etc. If possible I would seek to delay defecation + for two or three days, so that it might be as copious as + possible. When at last it occurred it would be an unspeakable joy + for me to watch the faeces--which would have to be fairly + firm--emerging from the anus." + + X. would like to be a teacher and thinks he could exert a + beneficial influence on boys. In spite of the pain he has + suffered he does not think he would like to be cured of his + perverse inclinations, for they have given him joy as well as + pain, and the pain has chiefly been owing to the fact that he + could not gratify his inclinations. X. smokes and drinks in + moderation, and has no feminine habits. (The foregoing is a + condensed summary of the case which is fully reported by Moll, + _Kontraere Sexualempfindung_, third edition, pp. 295-305.) + + The case of coprolagnia communicated to me is that of a married + man, normal in all other respects, intellectually brilliant and + filling successfully a very responsible position. When a child + the women of his household were always indifferent as to his + presence in their bedrooms, and would satisfy all natural calls + without reserve before him. He would dream of this with + erections. His sexual interests became slowly centered in the act + of defecation, and this fetich throughout life never appealed to + him so powerfully as when associated with the particular type of + household furniture which was used for this purpose in his own + house. The act of defecation in the opposite sex or anything + pertaining to or suggesting the same caused uncontrollable sexual + excitement; the nates also exerted a great attraction. The alvine + excreta exerted this influence even in the absence of the woman; + it was, however, necessary that she should be a sexually + desirable person. The perversion in this case was not complete; + that is to say, that the excitement produced by the act of + defecation or the excretion itself was not actually preferred to + coitus; the sexual idea was normal coitus in the normal manner, + but preceded by the visual and olfactory enjoyment of the + exciting fetich. When coitus was not possible the enjoyment of + the fetich was accompanied by masturbation (as in the analogous + case of urolagnia in a woman summarized on p. 62.) On one + occasion he was discovered by a friend in a bedroom belonging to + a woman, engaged in the act of masturbation over a vessel + containing the desired fetich. In an agony of shame he begged the + mercy of silence concerning this episode, at the same time + revealing his life-history. He has constantly been haunted by the + dread of detection, as well as by remorse and the consciousness + of degradation, also by the fear that his unconquerable obsession + may lead him to the asylum. + +The scatalogic groups of sexual perversions, urolagnia and coprolagnia, as +may be sufficiently seen in this brief summary, are not merely olfactory +fetiches. They are, in a larger proportion of cases, dynamic symbols, a +preoccupation with physiological acts which, by associations of contiguity +and still more of resemblance, have gained the virtue of stimulating in +slight cases, and replacing in more extreme cases, the normal +preoccupation with the central physiological act itself. We have seen that +there are various considerations which amply suffice to furnish a basis +for such associations. And when we reflect that in the popular mind, and +to some extent in actual fact, the sexual act itself is, like urination +and defecation, an excretory act, we can understand that the true +excretory acts may easily become symbols of the pseudo-excretory act. It +is, indeed, in the muscular release of accumulated pressures and tensions, +involved by the act of liberating the stored-up excretion, that we have +the closest simulacrum of the tumescence and detumescence of the sexual +process.[32] + +In this way the erotic symbolism of urolagnia and coprolagnia is +completely analogous with that dynamic symbolism of the clinging and +swinging garments which Herrick has so accurately described, with the +complex symbolism of flagellation and its play of the rod against the +blushing and trembling nates, with the symbols of sexual strain and stress +which are embodied in the foot and the act of treading. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[24] Fuchs (_Das Erotische Element In der Karikatur_, p. 26), +distinguishing sharply between the "erotic" and the "obscene," reserves +the latter term exclusively for the representation of excretory organs and +acts. He considers that this is etymologically the most exact usage. +However that may be, it seems to me that, in any case, "obscene" has +become so vague a term that it is now impracticable to give it a +restricted and precise sense. + +[25] In this connection we may profitably contemplate the hand and recall +the vast gamut of functions, sacred and profane, which that organ +exercises. Many savages strictly reserve the left hand to the lowlier +purposes of life; but in civilization that is not considered necessary, +and it may be wholesome for some of us to meditate on the more humble uses +of the same hand which is raised in the supreme gesture of benediction and +which men have often counted it a privilege to kiss. + +[26] See, e.g., Morselli, _Una Causa di Nullita del Matrimonio_, 1902, p. +39. + +[27] Fere, _Comptes-Rendus Societe de Biologie_, July 23, 1904. + +[28] Transactions of the International Medical Congress, Moscow, vol. iv, +p. 19. A similar symbolism may be traced in many of the cases in which the +focus of modesty becomes in modest women centered in the excretory sphere +and sometimes exaggerated to the extent of obsession. It must not be +supposed, however, that every obsession in this sphere has a symbolical +value of an erotic kind. In the case, for instance, which has been +recorded by Raymond and Janet (_Les Obsessions_, vol. ii, p. 306) of a +woman who spent much of her time in the endeavor to urinate perfectly, +always feeling that she failed in some respect, the obsession seems to +have risen fortuitously on a somewhat neurotic basis without reference to +the sexual life. + +[29] _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. III, Subs. I. + +[30] It may be remarked here that while the eating of excrement (apart +from its former use as a magic charm and as a therapeutic agent) is in +civilization now confined to sexual perverts and the insane, among some +animals it is normal as a measure of hygiene in relation to their young. +Thus, as, e.g., the Rev. Arthur East writes, the mistle thrush swallows +the droppings of its young. (_Knowledge_, June 1, 1899, p. 133.) In the +dog I have observed that the bitch licks her puppies shortly after birth +as they urinate, absorbing the fluid. + +[31] See, e.g., the previous volume of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection +in Man," pp. 165 et seq., and Duehren, _Geschlechtsleben in England_, bd. +ii, pp. 258, et seq. + +[32] In the study of _Love and Pain_ in a previous volume (p. 130) I have +quoted the remarks of a lady who refers to the analogy between sexual +tension and vesical tension--"Cette volupte que ressentent les bords de la +mer, d'etre toujours pleins sans jamais deborder"--and its erotic +significance. + + + + +IV. + +Animals as Sources of Erotic Symbolism--Mixoscopic Zoophilia--The +Stuff-fetichisms--Hair-fetichism--The Stuff-fetichisms Mainly on a Tactile +Base--Erotic Zoophilia--Zooerastia--Bestiality--The Conditions that Favor +Bestiality--Its Wide Prevalence Among Primitive Peoples and Among +Peasants--The Primitive Conception of Animals--The Goat--The Influence of +Familiarity with Animals--Congress Between Women and Animals--The Social +Reaction Against Bestiality. + + +The erotic symbols with which we have so far been concerned have in every +case been portions of the body, or its physiological processes, or at +least the garments which it has endowed with life. The association on +which the symbol has arisen has in every case been in large measure, +although not entirely, an association of contiguity. It is now necessary +to touch on a group of sexual symbols in which the association of +contiguity with the human body is absent: the various methods by which +animals or animal products or the sight of animal copulation may arouse +sexual desire in human persons. Here we encounter a symbolism mainly +founded on association by resemblance; the animal sexual act recalls the +human sexual act; the animal becomes the symbol of the human being. + +The group of phenomena we are here concerned with includes several +subdivisions. There is first the more or less sexual pleasure sometimes +experienced, especially by young persons, in the sight of copulating +animals. This I would propose to call Mixoscopic Zoophilia; it falls +within the range of normal variation. Then we have the cases in which the +contact of animals, stroking, etc., produces sexual excitement or +gratification; this is a sexual fetichism in the narrow sense, and is by +Krafft-Ebing termed _Zoophilia Erotica_. We have, further, the class of +cases in which a real or simulated sexual intercourse with animals is +desired. Such cases are not regarded as fetichism by Krafft-Ebing,[33] +but they come within the phenomena of erotic symbolism as here understood. +This class falls into two divisions: one in which the individual is fairly +normal, but belongs to a low grade of culture; the other in which he may +belong to a more refined social class, but is affected by a deep degree of +degeneration. In the first case we may properly apply the term bestiality; +in the second case it may perhaps be better to use the term _zooerastia_, +proposed by Krafft-Ebing.[34] + +Among children, both boys and girls, it is common to find that the +copulation of animals is a mysteriously fascinating spectacle. It is +inevitable that this should be so, for the spectacle is more or less +clearly felt to be the revelation of a secret which has been concealed +from them. It is, moreover, a secret of which they feel intimate +reverberations within themselves, and even in perfectly innocent and +ignorant children the sight may produce an obscure sexual excitement.[35] +It would seem that this occurs more frequently in girls than in boys. Even +in adult age, it may be added, women are liable to experience the same +kind of emotion in the presence of such spectacles. One lady recalls, as a +girl, that on several occasions an element of physical excitement entered +into the feelings with which she watched the coquetry of cats. Another +lady mentions that at the age of about 25, and when still quite ignorant +of sexual matters, she saw from a window some boys tickling a dog and +inducing sexual excitement in the animal; she vaguely divined what they +were doing, and though feeling disgust at their conduct she at the same +time experienced in a strong degree what she now knows was sexual +excitement. The coupling of the larger animals is often an impressive and +splendid spectacle which is far, indeed, from being obscene, and has +commended itself to persons of intellectual distinction;[36] but in young +or ill-balanced minds such sights tend to become both prurient and morbid. +I have already referred to the curious case of a sexually hyperaesthetic +nun who was always powerfully excited by the sight or even the +recollection of flies in sexual connection, so that she was compelled to +masturbate; this dated from childhood. After becoming a nun she recorded +having had this experience, followed by masturbation, more than four +hundred times.[37] Animal spectacles sometimes produce a sexual effect on +children even when not specifically sexual; thus a correspondent, a +clergyman, informs me that when a young and impressionable boy, he was +much affected by seeing a veterinary surgeon insert his hand and arm into +a horse's rectum, and dreamed of this several times afterward with +emissions. + +While the contemplation of animal coitus is an easily intelligible and in +early life, perhaps, an almost normal symbol of sexual emotion, there is +another subdivision of this group of animal fetichisms which forms a more +natural transition from the fetichisms which have their center in the +human body: the stuff-fetichisms, or the sexual attraction exerted by +various tissues, perhaps always of animal origin. Here we are in the +presence of a somewhat complicated phenomenon. In part we have, in a +considerable number of such cases, the sexual attraction of feminine +garments, for all such tissues are liable to enter into the dress. In +part, also, we have a sexual perversion of tactile sensibility, for in a +considerable proportion of these cases it is the touch sensations which +are potent in arousing the erotic sensations. But in part, also, it would +seem, we have here the conscious or subconscious presence of an animal +fetich, and it is notable that perhaps all these stuffs, and especially +fur, which is by far the commonest of the groups, are distinctively animal +products. We may perhaps regard the fetich of feminine hair--a much more +important and common fetich, indeed, than any of the stuff fetichisms--as +a link of transition. Hair is at once an animal and a human product, while +it may be separated from the body and possesses the qualities of a stuff. +Krafft-Ebing remarks that the senses of touch, smell, and hearing, as well +as sight, seem to enter into the attraction exerted by hair. + + The natural fascination of hair, on which hair-fetichism is + founded, begins at a very early age. "The hair is a special + object of interest with infants," Stanley Hall concludes, "which + begins often in the latter part of the first year.... The hair, + no doubt, gives quite unique tactile sensations, both in its own + roots and to hands, and is plastic and yielding to the motor + sense, so that the earliest interest may be akin to that in fur, + which is a marked object in infant experience. Some children + develop an almost fetichistic propensity to pull or later to + stroke the hair or beard of every one with whom they come in + contact." (G. Stanley Hall, "The Early Sense of Self," _American + Journal of Psychology_, April, 1898, p. 359.) + + It should be added that the fascination of hair for the infantile + and childish mind is not necessarily one of attraction, but may + be of repulsion. It happens here, as in the case of so many + characteristics which are of sexual significance, that we are in + the presence of an object which may exert a dynamic emotional + force, a force which is capable of repelling with the same energy + that it attracts. Fere records the instructive case of a child of + 3, of psychopathic heredity, who when he could not sleep was + sometimes taken by his mother into her bed. One night his hand + came in contact with a hairy portion of his mother's body, and + this, arousing the idea of an animal, caused him to leap out of + the bed in terror. He became curious as to the cause of his + terror and in time was able to observe "the animal," but the + train of feelings which had been set up led to a life-long + indifference to women and a tendency to homosexuality. It is + noteworthy that he was attracted to men in whom the hair and + other secondary sexual characters were well developed. (Fere, + _L'Instinct Sexuel_, second edition, pp. 262-267.) + + As a sexual fetich hair strictly belongs to the group of parts of + the body; but since it can be removed from the body and is + sexually effective as a fetich in the absence of the person to + whom it belongs, it is on a level with the garments which may + serve in a similar way, with shoes or handkerchiefs or gloves. + Psychologically, hair-fetichism presents no special problem, but + the wide attraction of hair--it is sexually the most generally + noted part of the feminine body after the eyes--and the peculiar + facility with which when plaited it may be removed, render + hair-fetichism a sexual perversion of specially great + medico-legal interest. + + The frequency of hair-fetichism, as well as of the natural + admiration on which it rests, is indicated by a case recorded by + Laurent. "A few years ago," he states, "one constantly saw at the + Bal Bullier, in Paris, a tall girl whose face was lean and bony, + but whose black hair was of truly remarkable length. She wore it + flowing down her shoulders and loins. Men often followed her in + the street to touch or kiss the hair. Others would accompany her + home and pay her for the mere pleasure of touching and kissing + the long black tresses. One, in consideration of a relatively + considerable sum, desired to pollute the silky hair. She was + obliged to be always on her guard, and to take all sorts of + precautions to prevent any one cutting off this ornament, which + constituted her only beauty as well as her livelihood." (E. + Laurent, _L'Amour Morbide_, 1891, p. 164; also the same author's + _Fetichistes et Erotomanes_, p. 23.) + + The hair despoiler (_Coupeur des Nattes_ or _Zopfabschneider_) + may be found in any civilized country, though the most carefully + studied cases have occurred in Paris. (Several medico-legal + histories of hair-despoilers are summarized by Krafft-Ebing, _Op. + cit._, pp. 329-334). Such persons are usually of nervous + temperament and bad heredity; the attraction to hair occasionally + develops in early life; sometimes the morbid impulse only appears + in later life after fever. The fetich may be either flowing hair + or braided hair, but is usually one or the other, and not both. + Sexual excitement and ejaculation may be produced in the act of + touching or cutting off the hair, which is subsequently, in many + cases, used for masturbation. As a rule the hair-despoiler is a + pure fetichist, no element of sadistic pleasure entering into his + feelings. In the case of a "capillary kleptomaniac" in Chicago--a + highly intelligent and athletic married young man of good + family--the impulse to cut off girls' braids appeared after + recovery from a severe fever. He would gaze admiringly at the + long tresses and then clip them off with great rapidity; he did + this in some fifty cases before he was caught and imprisoned. He + usually threw the braids away before he reached home. (_Alienist + and Neurologist_, April, 1889, p. 325.) In this case there is no + history of sexual excitement, probably because no proper + medico-legal examination was made. (It may be added that + hair-despoilers have been specially studied by Motet, "Les + Coupeurs de Nattes," _Annales d'Hygiene_, 1890.) + +The stuff-fetiches are most usually fur and velvet; feathers, silk, and +leathers also sometimes exert this influence; they are all, it will be +noted, animal substances.[38] The most interesting is probably fur, the +attraction of which is not uncommon in association with passive +algolagnia. As Stanley Hall has shown, the fear of fur, as well as the +love of it, is by no means uncommon in childhood; it may appear even in +infancy and in children who have never come in contact with animals.[39] +It is noteworthy that in most cases of uncomplicated stuff-fetichism the +attraction apparently arises on a congenital basis, as it appears in +persons of nervous or sensitive temperament at an early age and without +being attached to any definite causative incident. The sexual excitation +is nearly always produced by the touch rather than by the sight. As we +found, when dealing with the sense of touch in the previous volume, the +specific sexual sensations may be regarded as a special modification of +ticklishness. The erotic symbolism in the case of these stuff-fetichisms +would seem to be a more or less congenital perversion of ticklishness in +relation to specific animal contacts. + +A further degree of perversion in this direction is reached in a case of +erotic _zoophilia_, recorded by Krafft-Ebing.[40] In this case a +congenital neuropath, of good intelligence but delicate and anaemic, with +feeble sexual powers, had a great love of domestic animals, especially +dogs and cats, from an early age; when petting them he experienced sexual +emotions, although he was innocent in sexual matters. At puberty he +realized the nature of his feelings and tried to break himself of his +habits. He succeeded, but then began erotic dreams accompanied by images +of animals, and these led to masturbation associated with ideas of a +similar kind. At the same time he had no wish for any sort of sexual +intercourse with animals, and was indifferent as to the sex of the animals +which attracted him; his sexual ideals were normal. Such a case seems to +be fundamentally one of fetichism on a tactile basis, and thus forms a +transition between the stuff-fetichisms and the complete perversions of +sexual attraction toward animals. + + In some cases sexually hyperaesthetic women have informed me that + sexual feeling has been produced by casual contact with pet dogs + and cats. In such cases there is usually no real perversion, but + it seems probable that we may here have an occasional foundation + for the somewhat morbid but scarcely vicious excesses of + affection which women are apt to display towards their pet dogs + or cats. In most cases of this affection there is certainly no + sexual element; in the case of childless women, it may rather be + regarded as a maternal than as an erotic symbolism. (The excesses + of this non-erotic zoophilia have been discussed by Fere, + _L'Instinct Sexuel_, second edition, pp. 166-171.) + +Krafft-Ebing considers that complete perversion of sexual attraction +toward animals is radically distinct from erotic _zoophilia_. This view +cannot be accepted. Bestiality and _zooerastia_ merely present in a more +marked and profoundly perverted form a further degree of the same +phenomenon which we meet with in erotic _zoophilia_; the difference is +that they occur either in more insensitive or in more markedly degenerate +persons. + +A fairly typical case of _zooerastia_ has been recorded in America by +Howard, of Baltimore. This was the case of a boy of 16, precociously +mature and fairly bright. He was, however, indifferent to the opposite +sex, though he had ample opportunity for gratifying normal passions. His +parents lived in the city, but the youth had an inordinate desire for the +country and was therefore sent to school in a village. On the second day +after his arrival at school a farmer missed a sow which was found secreted +in an outhouse on the school grounds. This was the first of many similar +incidents in which a sow always took part. So strong was his passion that +on one occasion force had to be used to take him away from the sow he was +caressing. He did not masturbate, and even when restrained from +approaching sows he had no sexual inclination for other animals. His +nocturnal pollutions, which were frequent, were always accompanied by +images of wallowing swine. Notwithstanding careful treatment no cure was +effected; mental and physical vigor failed, and he died at the age of +23.[41] + +It is, however, somewhat doubtful whether we can always or even usually +distinguish between zooerastia and bestiality. Dr. G.F. Lydston, of +Chicago, has communicated to me a case (in which he was consulted) which +seems fairly typical and is instructive in this respect. The subject was a +young man of 21, a farmer's son, not very bright intellectually, but very +healthy and strong, of great assistance on the farm, very capable and +industrious, such a good farm hand that his father was unwilling to send +him away and to lose his services. There was no history of insanity or +neurosis in the family, and no injury or illness in his own history. He +had spells of moroseness and irritability, however, and had also been a +masturbator. Women had no attraction for him, but he would copulate with +the mares upon his father's farm, and this without regard to time, place, +or spectators. Such a case would seem to stand midway between ordinary +bestiality and pathological zooerastia as defined by Krafft-Ebing, yet it +seems probable that in most cases of ordinary bestiality some slight +traces of mental anomaly might be found, if such cases always were, as +they should be, properly investigated.[42] + +We have here reached the grossest and most frequent perversion in this +group; bestiality, or the impulse to attain sexual gratification by +intercourse, or other close contact, with animals. In seeking to +comprehend this perversion it is necessary to divest ourselves of the +attitude toward animals which is the inevitable outcome of refined +civilization and urban life. Most sexual perversions, if not in large +measure the actual outcome of civilized life, easily adjust themselves to +it. Bestiality (except in one form to be noted later) is, on the other +hand, the sexual perversion of dull, insensitive and unfastidious persons. +It flourishes among primitive peoples and among peasants. It is the vice +of the clodhopper, unattractive to women or inapt to court them. + +Three conditions have favored the extreme prevalence of bestiality: (1) +primitive conceptions of life which built up no great barrier between man +and the other animals; (2) the extreme familiarity which necessarily +exists between the peasant and his beasts, often combined with separation +from women; (3) various folk-lore beliefs such as the efficacy of +intercourse with animals as a cure for venereal disease, etc.[43] + +The beliefs and customs of primitive peoples, as well as their mythology +and legends, bring before us a community of man and animals altogether +unlike anything we know in civilization. Men may become animals and +animals may become men; animals and men may communicate with each other +and live on terms of equality; animals may be the ancestors of human +tribes; the sacred totems of savages are most usually animals. There is no +shame or degradation in the notion of a sexual relationship between men +and animals, because in primitive conceptions animals are not inferior +beings separated from man by a great gulf. They are much more like men in +disguise, and in some respects possess powers which make them superior to +men. This is recognized in those plays, festivals, and religious dances, +so common among primitive peoples, in which animal disguises are worn.[44] +When men admire and emulate the qualities of animals and are proud to +believe that they descend from them, it is not surprising that they should +sometimes see nothing derogatory in sexual intercourse with them.[45] + +A significant relic of primitive conceptions in this matter may perhaps be +found in the religious rites connected with the sacred goat of Mendes +described by Herodotus. After telling how the Mendesians reverence the +goat, especially the he-goat, out of their veneration for Pan, whom they +represent as a goat ("the real motive which they assign for this custom I +do not choose to relate"), he adds: "It happened in this country, and +within my remembrance, and was indeed universally notorious, that a goat +had indecent and public communication with a woman."[46] The meaning of +the passage evidently is that in the ordinary intercourse of women with +the sacred goat, connection was only simulated or incomplete on account of +the natural indifference of the goat to the human female, but that in rare +cases the goat proved sexually excitable with the woman and capable of +connection.[47] The goat has always been a kind of sacred emblem of lust. +In the middle ages it became associated with the Devil as one of the +favorite forms he assumed. It is significant of a primitively religious +sexual association between men and animals, that witches constantly +confessed, or were made to confess, that they had had intercourse with the +Devil in the shape of an animal, very frequently a dog. The figures of +human beings and animals in conjunction carved on temples in India, also +seem to indicate the religious significance which this phenomenon +sometimes presents. There is, indeed, no need to go beyond Europe even in +her moments of highest culture to find a religious sanction for sexual +union between human beings, or gods in human shape, and animals. The +legends of Io and the bull, of Leda and the swan, are among the most +familiar in Greek mythology, and in a later pictorial form they constitute +some of the most cherished works of the painters of the Renaissance. + +As regards the prevalence of occasional sexual intercourse between men or +women and animals among primitive peoples at the present time, it is +possible to find many scattered references by travelers in all parts of +the world. Such references by no means indicate that such practices are, +as a rule, common, but they usually show that they are accepted with a +good-humored indifference.[48] + +Bestiality is very rarely found in towns. In the country this vice of the +clodhopper is far from infrequent. For the peasant, whose sensibilities +are uncultivated and who makes but the most elementary demands from a +woman, the difference between an animal and a human being in this respect +scarcely seems to be very great. "My wife was away too long," a German +peasant explained to the magistrate, "and so I went with my sow." It is +certainly an explanation that to the uncultivated peasant, ignorant of +theological and juridical conceptions, must often seem natural and +sufficient. + + Bestiality thus resembles masturbation and other abnormal + manifestations of the sexual impulse which may be practiced + merely _faute de mieux_ and not as, in the strict sense, + perversions of the impulse. Even necrophily may be thus + practiced. A young man who when assisting the grave-digger + conceived and carried out the idea of digging up the bodies of + young girls to satisfy his passions with, and whose case has + been recorded by Belletrud and Mercier, said: "I could find no + young girl who would agree to yield to my desires; that is why I + have done this. I should have preferred to have relations with + living persons. I found it quite natural to do what I did: I saw + no harm in it, and I did not think that any one else could. As + living women felt nothing but repulsion for me, it was quite + natural I should turn to the dead, who have never repulsed me. I + used to say tender things to them like 'my beautiful, my love, I + love you.'" (Belletrud and Mercier "Perversion de l'Instinct + Genesique," _Annales d'Hygiene Publique_, June, 1903.) But when + so highly abnormal an act is felt as natural we are dealing with + a person who is congenitally defective so far as the finer + developments of intelligence are concerned. It was so in this + case of necrophily; he was the son of a weak-minded woman of + unrestrainable sexual inclinations, and was himself somewhat + feeble-minded; he was also, it is instructive to observe, + anosmic. + +But it is by no means only their dulled sensibility or the absence of +women, which accounts for the frequency of bestiality among peasants. A +highly important factor is their constant familiarity with animals. The +peasant lives with animals, tends them, learns to know all their +individual characters; he understands them far better than he understands +men and women; they are his constant companions, his friends. He knows, +moreover, the details of their sexual lives, he witnesses the often highly +impressive spectacle of their coupling. It is scarcely surprising that +peasants should sometimes regard animals as being not only as near to them +as their fellow human beings, but even nearer. + +The significance of the factor of familiarity is indicated by the great +frequency of bestiality among shepherds, goatherds, and others whose +occupation is exclusively the care of animals. Mirabeau, in the eighteenth +century, stated, on the evidence of Basque priests, that all the shepherds +in the Pyrenees practice bestiality. It is apparently much the same in +Italy.[49] In South Italy and Sicily, especially, bestiality among +goatherds and peasants is said to be almost a national custom.[50] In the +extreme north of Europe, it is reported, the reindeer, in this respect, +takes the place of the goat. + +The importance of the same factor is also shown by the fact that when +among women in civilization animal perversions appear, the animal is +nearly always a pet dog. Usually in these cases the animal is taught to +give gratification by _cunnilinctus_. In some cases, however, there is +really sexual intercourse between the animal and the woman. + + Moll mentions that in a case of _cunnilinctus_ by a dog in + Germany there was a difficulty as to whether the matter should be + considered an unnatural offence or simply an offence against + decency; the lower court considered it in the former light, while + the higher court took the more merciful view. (Moll, + _Untersuchungen ueber die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 697.) In a + case reported by Pfaff and mentioned by Moll, a country girl was + accused of having sexual intercourse with a large dog. On + examination Pfaff found in the girl's thick pubic hair a loose + hair which under the microscope proved to belong to the dog. + (_Loc. cit._, p. 698.) In such a case it must be noted that while + this evidence may be held to show sexual contact with the dog, it + scarcely suffices to show sexual intercourse. This has, however, + undoubtedly occurred from time to time, even more or less openly. + Bloch (_Op. cit._, pp. 277 and 282) remarks that this is not an + infrequent exhibition given by prostitutes in certain brothels. + Maschka has referred to such an exhibition between a woman and a + bull-dog, which was given to select circles in Paris. Rosse + refers to a case in which a young unmarried woman in Washington + was surprised during intercourse with a large English mastiff, + who in his efforts to get loose caused such severe injuries that + the woman died from haemorrhage in about an hour. Rosse also + mentions that some years ago a performance of this kind between a + prostitute and a Newfoundland dog could be witnessed in San + Francisco by paying a small sum; the woman declared that a woman + who had once copulated with a dog would ever afterwards prefer + this animal to a man. Rosse adds that he was acquainted with a + similar performance between a woman and a donkey, which used to + take place in Europe (Irving Rosse, "Sexual Hypochondriasis and + Perversion of the Genesic Instinct," _Virginia Medical Monthly_, + October, 1892, p. 379). Juvenal mentions such relations between + the donkey and woman (vi, 332). Krauss (quoted by Bloch, + _Beitraege zur AEtiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil II, p. + 276) states that in Bosnia women sometimes carry on these + practices with dogs and also--as he would not have believed had + he not on one occasion observed it--with cats. "It seems to me," + writes Dr. Kiernan, of Chicago, (private letter) "that what Rosse + says of the animal exhibitions in San Francisco is true of all + great cities. The animal employed in such exhibitions here has + usually been a donkey, and in one instance death occurred from + the animal trampling the girl partner. The practice described + occurs in country regions quite frequently. Thus in a case + reported in the suburbs of Omaha, Nebraska, a sixteen-year-old + boy engaged in rectal coitus with a large dog. In attempting to + extricate his swollen penis from the boy's rectum the dog tore + through the _sphincter ani_ an inch into the gluteus muscles. + (_Omaha Clinic_, March, 1893.) In a Missouri case, which I + verified, a smart, pretty, well-educated country girl was found + with a profuse offensive vaginal discharge which had been present + for about a week, coming on suddenly. After washing the external + genitals and opening the labia three rents were discovered, one + through the fourchette and two through the left nymphae. The + vagina was excessively congested and covered with points bleeding + on the slightest irritation. The patient confessed that one day + while playing with the genitals of a large dog she became excited + and thought she would have slight coitus. After the dog had made + an entrance she was unable to free herself from him, as he + clasped her so firmly with his fore legs. The penis became so + swollen that the dog could not free himself, although for more + than an hour she made persistent efforts to do so. (_Medical + Standard_, June, 1903, p. 184). In an Indiana case, concerning + which I was consulted, the girl was a hebephreniac who had + resorted to this procedure with a Newfoundland dog at the + instance of another girl, seemingly normal as regards mentality, + and had been badly injured; a discharge resulted which resembled + gonorrhoea, but contained no gonococci. These cases are probably + more frequent than is usually assumed." + + Women are known to have had intercourse with various other + animals, occasionally or habitually, in various parts of the + world. Monkeys have been mentioned in this connection. Moll + remarks that it seems to be an indication of an abnormal interest + in monkeys that some women are observed by the attendants in the + monkey-house of zooelogical gardens to be very frequent visitors. + Near the Amazon the traveler Castelnau saw an enormous Coati + monkey belonging to an Indian woman and tried to purchase it; + though he offered a large sum, the woman only laughed. "Your + efforts are useless," remarked an Indian in the same cabin, "he + is her husband." (So far as the early literature of this subject + is concerned, a number of facts and fables regarding the congress + of women with dogs, goats and other animals was brought together + at the beginning of the eighteenth century by Schurig in his + _Gynaecologia_, Section II, cap. VII; I have not drawn on this + collection.) + + In some cases women, and also men, find gratification in the + sexual manipulation of animals without any kind of congress. This + may be illustrated by an observation communicated to me by a + correspondent, a clergyman. "In Ireland, my father's house + adjoined the residence of an archdeacon of the established + church. I was then about 20 and was still kept in religious awe + of evil ways. The archdeacon had two daughters, both of whom he + brought up in great strictness, resolved that they should grow up + examples of virtue and piety. Our stables adjoined, and were + separated only by a thin wall in which was a doorway closed up by + some boards, as the two stables had formerly been one. One night + I had occasion to go to our stable to search for a garden tool I + had missed, and I heard a door open on the other side, and saw a + light glimmer through the cracks of the boards. I looked through + to ascertain who could be there at that late hour, and soon + recognized the stately figure of one of the daughters, F.F. was + tall, dark and handsome, but had never made any advances to me, + nor had I to her. She was making love to her father's mare after + a singular fashion. Stripping her right arm, she formed her + fingers into a cone, and pressed on the mare's vulva. I was + astonished to see the beast stretching her hind legs as if to + accommodate the hand of her mistress, which she pushed in + gradually and with seeming ease to the elbow. At the same time + she seemed to experience the most voluptuous sensation, crisis + after crisis arriving." My correspondent adds that, being + exceedingly curious in the matter, he tried a somewhat similar + experiment himself with one of his father's mares and experienced + what he describes as "a most powerful sexual battery" which + produced very exciting and exhausting effects. Naecke + (_Psychiatrische en Neurologische Bladen_, 1899, No. 2) refers to + an idiot who thus manipulated the vulva of mares in his charge. + The case has been recorded by Guillereau (_Journal de Medicine + Veterinaire et de Zootechnie_, January, 1899) of a youth who was + accustomed to introduce his hand into the vulva of cows in order + to obtain sexual excitement. + + The possibility of sexual excitement between women and animals + involves a certain degree of sexual excitability in animals from + contact with women. Darwin stated that there could be no doubt + that various quadrumanous animals could distinguish women from + men--in the first place probably by smell and secondarily by + sight--and be thus liable to sexual excitement. He quotes the + opinions on this point of Youatt, Brehm, Sir Andrew Smith and + Cuvier (_Descent of Man_, second edition, p. 8). Moll quotes the + opinion of an experienced observer to the same effect + (_Untersuchungen ueber die Libido Sexualis_, Bd. i, p. 429). + Hufeland reported the case of a little girl of three who was + playing, seated on a stool, with a dog placed between her thighs + and locked against her. Seemingly excited by this contact the + animal attempted a sort of copulation, causing the genital parts + of the child to become inflamed. Bloch (_Op. cit._, p. 280, _et + seq._) discusses the same point; he does not consider that + animals will of their own motion sexually cohabit with women, but + that they may be easily trained to it. There can be no doubt that + dogs at all events are sometimes sexually excited by the presence + of women, perhaps especially during menstruation, and many women + are able to bear testimony to the embarrassing attentions they + have sometimes received from strange dogs. There can be no + difficulty in believing that, so far as _cunnilinctus_ is + concerned dogs would require no training. In a case recorded by + Moll (_Kontraere Sexualempfindung_, third edition, p. 560) a lady + states that this was done to her when a child, as also to other + children, by dogs who, she said, showed signs of sexual + excitement. In this case there was also sexual excitement thus + produced in the child, and after puberty mutual _cunnilinctus_ + was practiced with girl friends. Guttceit (_Dreissig Jahre + Praxis_, Theil I, p. 310) remarks that some Russian officers who + were in the Turkish campaign of 1828 told him that from fear of + veneral infection in Wallachia they refrained from women and + often used female asses which appeared to show signs of sexual + pleasure. + +A very large number of animals have been recorded as having been employed +in the gratification of sexual desire at some period or in some country, +by men and sometimes by women. Domestic animals are naturally those which +most frequently come into question, and there are few if any of these +which can altogether be excepted. The sow is one of the animals most +frequently abused in this manner.[51] Cases in which mares, cows, and +donkeys figure constantly occur, as well as goats and sheep. Dogs, cats, +and rabbits are heard of from time to time. Hens, ducks, and, especially +in China, geese, are not uncommonly employed. The Roman ladies were said +to have had an abnormal affection for snakes. The bear and even the +crocodile are also mentioned.[52] + +The social and legal attitude toward bestiality has reflected in part the +frequency with which it has been practiced, and in part the disgust mixed +with mystical and sacrilegious horror which it has aroused. It has +sometimes been met merely by a fine, and sometimes the offender and his +innocent partner have been burnt together. In the middle ages and later +its frequency is attested by the fact that it formed a favorite topic with +preachers of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. It is significant that +in the Penitentials,--which were criminal codes, half secular and half +spiritual, in use before the thirteenth century, when penance was +relegated to the judgment of the confessor,--it was thought necessary to +fix the periods of penance which should be undergone respectively by +bishops, priests and deacons who should be guilty of bestiality. + + In Egbert's Penitential, a document of the ninth and tenth + centuries, we read (V. 22): "Item Episcopus cum quadrupede + fornicans VII annos, consuetudinem X, presbyter V, diaconus III, + clerus II." There was a great range in the penances for + bestiality, from ten years to (in the case of boys) one hundred + days. The mare is specially mentioned (Haddon and Stubbs, + _Councils and Ecclesiastical Documents_, vol. iii, p. 422). In + Theodore's Penitential, another Anglo-Saxon document of about the + same age, those who habitually fornicate with animals are + adjudged ten years of penance. It would appear from the + _Penitentiale Pseudo-Romanum_ (which is earlier than the eleventh + century) that one year's penance was adequate for fornication + with a mare when committed by a layman (exactly the same as for + simple fornication with a widow or virgin), and this was + mercifully reduced to half a year if he had no wife. + (Wasserschleben, _Die Bussordnungen der Abendlaendlichen Kirche_, + p. 366). The _Penitentiale Hubertense_ (emanating from the + monastery of St. Hubert in the Ardennes) fixes ten years' penance + for sodomy, while Fulbert's Penitential (about the eleventh + century) fixes seven years for either sodomy or bestiality. + Burchard's Penitential, which is always detailed and precise, + specially mentions the mare, the cow and the ass, and assigns + forty days bread and water and seven years penance, raised to ten + years in the case of married men. A woman having intercourse with + a horse is assigned seven years penance in Burchard's + Penitential. (Wasserschleben, ib. pp. 651, 659.) + +The extreme severity which was frequently exercised toward those guilty of +this offense, was doubtless in large measure due to the fact that +bestiality was regarded as a kind of sodomy, an offense which was +frequently viewed with a mystical horror apart altogether from any actual +social or personal injury it caused. The Jews seem to have felt this +horror; it was ordered that the sinner and his victim should both be put +to death (Exodus, Ch. 22, v. 19; Leviticus, Ch. 20, v. 15). In the middle +ages, especially in France, the same rule often prevailed. Men and sows, +men and cows, men and donkeys were burnt together. At Toulouse a woman was +burnt for having intercourse with a dog. Even in the seventeenth century a +learned French lawyer, Claude Lebrun de la Rochette, justified such +sentences.[53] It seems probable that even to-day, in the social and legal +attitude toward bestiality, sufficient regard is not paid to the fact that +this offense is usually committed either by persons who are morbidly +abnormal or who are of so low a degree of intelligence that they border on +feeble-mindedness. To what extent, and on what grounds, it ought to be +punished is a question calling for serious reconsideration. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[33] For Krafft-Ebing's discussion of the subject see _Op. cit._, pp. +530-539. + +[34] In England it is not uncommon to use the term "unnatural offence;" +this is an awkward and possibly misleading practice which should not be +followed. In Germany a similar confusion is caused by applying the term +"sodomy" to these cases as well as to pederasty. Krafft-Ebing considers +that this error is due to the jurists, while the theologians have always +distinguished correctly. In this matter, he adds, science must be _ancilla +theologiae_ and return to the correct usage of words. + +[35] This childish interest, with later abnormal developments, may be seen +in History I of the Appendix to this volume. + +[36] The Countess of Pembroke, Sir Philip Sidney's sister, appears to have +found sexual enjoyment in the contemplation of the sexual prowess of +stallions. Aubrey writes that she "was very salacious and she had a +contrivance that in the spring of the year ... the stallions ... were to +be brought before such a part of the house where she had a vidette to look +on them." (_Short Lives_, 1898, vol. i, p. 311.) Although the modern +editor's modesty has caused the disappearance of several lines from this +passage, the general sense is clear. In the same century Burchard, the +faithful secretary of Pope Alexander VI, describes in his invaluable diary +how four race horses were brought to two mares in a court of the Vatican, +the horses clamorously fighting for the possession of the mares and +eventually mounting them, while the Pope and his daughter Lucrezia looked +on from a window "cum magno risu et delectatione." (_Diarium_, ed Thuasne, +vol. III, p. 169.) + +[37] _Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1902, fasc. ii-iii, p. 338. In the case of +pathological sexuality in a boy of 15, reported by A. MacDonald, and +already summarized, the sight of copulating flies is also mentioned among +many other causes of sexual excitation. + +[38] Krafft-Ebing presents or quotes typical cases of all these fetiches, +_Op. cit._, pp. 255-266. + +[39] G. Stanley Hall, "A study of Fears," _American Journal of +Psychology_, 1897, pp. 213-215. + +[40] _Op. cit._, p. 268. + +[41] W. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," _Alienist and Neurologist_, January, +1896. Krafft-Ebing (op. cit., p. 532) quotes from Boeteau the somewhat +similar case of a gardener's boy of 16--an illegitimate child of +neuropathic heredity and markedly degenerate--who had a passion, of +irresistible and impulsive character, for rabbits. He was declared +irresponsible. Moll (_Untersuchungen ueber die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, pp. +431-433) presents the case of a neurotic man who from the age of 15 had +been sexually excited by the sight of animals or by contact with them. He +had repeatedly had connection with cows and mares; he was also sexually +excited by sheep, donkeys, and dogs, whether female or male; the normal +sexual instinct was weak and he experienced very slight attraction to +women. + +[42] Moll also remarks ("Perverse Sexualempfindung," in Senator's and +Kaminer's _Krankheiten und Ehe_) that in this matter it is often hardly +possible to draw a sharp line between vice and disease. + +[43] Instances of this widespread belief--found among the Tamils of Ceylon +as well as in Europe--are quoted from various authors by Bloch, _Beitraege +zur AEtiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil II, p. 278, and Moll, +_Untersuchungen ueber die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 700. On the frequency +of bestiality, from one cause or another, in the East, see, e.g., Stern, +_Medizin und Geschlechtsleben in der Tuerkei_, bd. ii, p. 219. + +[44] Sometimes (as among the Aleuts) the animal pantomime dances of +savages may represent the transformation of a captive bird into a lovely +woman who falls exhausted into the arms of the hunter. (H.H. Bancroft, +_Native Races of the Pacific_, vol. i, p. 93.) A system of beliefs which +accepts the possibility that a human being may be latent in an animal +obviously favors the practice of bestiality. + +[45] For an example of the primitive confusion between the intercourse of +women with animals and with men see, e.g., Boas, "Sagen aus +British-Columbia," _Zeitschrift fuer Ethnologie_, heft V, p. 558. + +[46] Herodotus, Book II, Chapter 46. + +[47] Dulare (_Des Divinites Generatrices_, Chapter II) brings together the +evidence showing that in Egypt women had connection with the sacred goat, +apparently in order to secure fertility. + +[48] Various facts and references bearing on this subject are brought +together by Blumenbach, _Anthropological Memoirs_, translated by Bendyshe, +p. 80; Block, _Beitraege zur AEtiologie der Psychopathia Sexualis_, +Teil II, pp. 276-283; also Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, seventh edition, +p. 520. + +[49] Mantegazza mentions (_Gli Amori degli Uomini_, cap V) that at Rimini +a young goatherd of the Apennines, troubled with dyspepsia and nervous +symptoms, told him this was due to excesses with the goats in his care. A +finely executed marble group of a satyr having connection with a goat, +found at Herculaneum and now in the Naples Museum (reproduced in Fuchs's +_Erotische Element in der Karikatur_), perhaps symbolizes a traditional +and primitive practice of the goatherd. + +[50] Bayle (_Dictionary_, Art, Bathyllus) quotes various authorities +concerning the Italian auxiliaries in the south of France in the sixteenth +century and their custom of bringing and using goats for this purpose. +Warton in the eighteenth century was informed that in Sicily priests in +confession habitually inquired of herdsmen if they had anything to do with +their sows. In Normandy priests are advised to ask similar questions. + +[51] It is worth noting that in Greek the work choiros means both a sow +and a woman's pudenda; in the _Acharnians_ Aristophanes plays on this +association at some length. The Romans also (as may be gathered from +Varro's _De Re Rustica_) called the feminine pudenda _porcus_. + +[52] Schurig, _Gynaecologia_, pp. 280-387; Bloch, op. cit., 270-277. The +Arabs, according to Kocher, chiefly practice bestiality with goats, sheep +and mares. The Annamites, according to Mondiere, commonly employ sows and +(more especially the young women) dogs. Among the Tamils of Ceylon +bestiality with goats and cows is said to be very prevalent. + +[53] Mantegazza (_Gli Amori degli Uomini_, cap. V) brings together some +facts bearing on this matter. + + + + +V. + +Exhibitionism--Illustrative Cases--A Symbolic Perversion of Courtship--The +Impulse to Defile--The Exhibitionist's Psychic Attitude--The Sexual Organs +as Fetichs--Phallus Worship--Adolescent Pride in Sexual +Development--Exhibitionism of the Nates--The Classification of the Forms +of Exhibitionism--Nature of the Relationship of Exhibitionism to Epilepsy. + + +There is a remarkable form of erotic symbolism--very definite and standing +clearly apart from all other forms--in which sexual gratification is +experienced in the simple act of exhibiting the sexual organ to persons of +the opposite sex, usually by preference to young and presumably innocent +persons, very often children. This is termed exhibitionism.[54] It would +appear to be a not very infrequent phenomenon, and most women, once or +more in their lives, especially when young, have encountered a man who has +thus deliberately exposed himself before them. + +The exhibitionist, though often a young and apparently vigorous man, is +always satisfied with the mere act of self-exhibition and the emotional +reaction which that act produces; he makes no demands on the woman to whom +he exposes himself; he seldom speaks, he makes no effort to approach her; +as a rule, he fails even to display the signs of sexual excitation. His +desires are completely gratified by the act of exhibition and by the +emotional reaction it arouses in the woman. He departs satisfied and +relieved. + + A case recorded by Schrenck-Notzing very well represents both the + nature of the impulse felt by the exhibitionist and the way in + which it may originate. It is the case of a business man of 49, + of neurotic heredity, an affectionate husband and father of a + family, who, to his own grief and shame, is compelled from time + to time to exhibit his sexual organs to women in the street. As a + boy of 10 a girl of 12 tried to induce him to coitus; both had + their sexual parts exposed. From that time sexual contacts, as of + his own naked nates against those of a girl, became attractive, + as well as games in which the boys and girls in turn marched + before each other with their sexual parts exposed, and also + imitation of the copulation of animals. Coitus was first + practiced about the age of 20, but sight and touch of the woman's + sexual parts were always necessary to produce sexual excitement. + It was also necessary--and this consideration is highly important + as regards the development of the tendency to exhibition--that + the woman should be excited by the sight of his organs. Even when + he saw or touched a woman's parts orgasm often occurred. It was + the naked sexual organs in an otherwise clothed body which + chiefly excited him. He was not possessed of a high degree of + potency. Girls between the ages of 10 and 17 chiefly excited him, + and especially if he felt that they were quite ignorant of sexual + matters. His self-exhibition was a sort of psychic defloration, + and it was accompanied by the idea that other people felt as he + did about the sexual effects of the naked organs, that he was + shocking but at the same time sexually exciting a young girl. He + was thus gratifying himself through the belief that he was + causing sexual gratification to an innocent girl. This man was + convicted several times, and was finally declared to be suffering + from impulsive insanity. (Schrenck-Notzing, + _Kriminal-psychologische und Psycho-pathologische Studien_, 1902, + pp. 50-57.) In another case of Schrenck-Notzing's, an actor and + portrait painter, aged 31, in youth masturbated and was fond of + contemplating the images of the sexual organs of both sexes, + finding little pleasure in coitus. At the age of 24, at a bathing + establishment, he happened to occupy a compartment next to that + occupied by a lady, and when naked he became aware that his + neighbor was watching him through a chink in the partition. This + caused him powerful excitement and he was obliged to masturbate. + Ever since he has had an impulse to exhibit his organs and to + masturbate in the presence of women. He believes that the sight + of his organs excites the woman (Ib., pp. 57-68). The presence of + masturbation in this case renders it untypical as a case of + exhibitionism. Moll at one time went so far as to assert that + when masturbation takes place we are not entitled to admit + exhibitionism, (_Untersuchungen ueber die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, + p. 661), but now accepts exhibitionism with masturbation + ("Perverse Sexualempfindung," _Krankheiten und Ehe_). The act of + exhibition itself gratifies the sexual impulse, and usually it + suffices to replace both tumescence and detumescence. + + A fairly typical case, recorded by Krafft-Ebing, is that of a + German factory worker of 37, a good, sober and intelligent + workman. His parents were healthy, but one of his mother's and + also one of his father's sisters were insane; some of his + relatives are eccentric in religion. He has a languishing + expression and a smile of self-complacency. He never had any + severe illness, but has always been eccentric and imaginative, + much absorbed in romances (such as Dumas's novels) and fond of + identifying himself with their heroes. No signs of epilepsy. In + youth moderate masturbation, later moderate coitus. He lives a + retired life, but is fond of elegant dress and of ornament. + Though not a drinker, he sometimes makes himself a kind of punch + which has a sexually exciting effect on him. The impulse to + exhibitionism has only developed in recent years. When the + impulse is upon him he becomes hot, his heart beats violently, + the blood rushes to his head, and he is oblivious of everything + around him that is not connected with his own act. Afterwards he + regards himself as a fool and makes vain resolutions never to + repeat the act. In exhibition the penis is only half erect and + ejaculation never occurs. (He is only capable of coitus with a + woman who shows great attraction to him.) He is satisfied with + self-exhibition, and believes that he thus gives pleasure to the + woman, since he himself receives pleasure in contemplating a + woman's sexual parts. His erotic dreams are of self-exhibition to + young and voluptuous women. He had been previously punished for + an offense of this kind; medico-legal opinion now recognized the + incriminated man's psychopathic condition. (Krafft-Ebing, _Op. + cit._, pp. 492-494.) + + Trochon has reported the case of a married man of 33, a worker in + a factory, who for several years had exhibited himself at + intervals to shop-girls, etc., in a state of erection, but + without speaking or making other advances. He was a hard-working, + honest, sober man of quiet habits, a good father to his family + and happy at home. He showed not the slightest sign of insanity. + But he was taciturn, melancholic and nervous; a sister was an + idiot. He was arrested, but on the report of the experts that he + committed these acts from a morbid impulse he could not control + he was released. (Trochon, _Archives de l'Anthropologie + Criminelle_, 1888, p. 256.) + + In a case of Freyer's (_Zeitschrift fuer Medizinalbeamte_, third + year, No. 8) the occasional connection of exhibitionism with + epilepsy is well illustrated by a barber's assistant, aged 35, + whose father suffered from chronic alcoholism and was also said + to have committed the same kind of offense as his son. The mother + and a sister suffered nervously. From ages of 7 to 18 the subject + had epileptic convulsions. From 16 to 21 he indulged in normal + sexual intercourse. At about that time he had often to pass a + playground and at times would urinate there; it happened that the + children watched him with curiosity. He noticed that when thus + watched sexual excitement was caused, inducing erection and even + ejaculation. He gradually found pleasure in this kind of sexual + gratification; finally he became indifferent to coitus. His + erotic dreams, though still usually about normal coitus, were now + sometimes concerned with exhibition before little girls. When + overcome by the impulse he could see and hear nothing around him, + though he did not lose consciousness. After the act was over he + was troubled by his deed. In all other respects he was entirely + reasonable. He was imprisoned many times for exhibiting himself + to young schoolgirls, sometimes vaunting the beauty of his organs + and inviting inspection. On one occasion he underwent mental + examination, but was considered to be mentally sound. He was + finally held to be a hereditarily tainted individual with + neuropathic constitution. The head was abnormally broad, penis + small, patellar reflex absent, and there were many signs of + neurasthenia. (Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, pp. 490-492.) + + The prevalence of epilepsy among exhibitionists is shown by the + observations of Pelanda in Verona. He has recorded six cases of + this perversion, all of which eventually reached the asylum and + were either epileptics or with epileptic relations. One had a + brother who was also an exhibitionist. In some cases the penis + was abnormally large, in others abnormally small. Several had + very weak sexual impulse; one, at the age of 62, had never + effected coitus, and was proud of the fact that he was still a + virgin, considering, he would say, the epoch of demoralization in + which we live. (Pelanda, "Pornopatici," _Archivio di + Psichiatria_, fasc. ii-iv, 1889.) + + In a very typical case of exhibitionism which Garnier has + recorded, a certain X., a gentleman engaged in business in Paris, + had a predilection for exhibiting himself in churches, more + especially in Saint-Roch. He was arrested several times for + exposing his sexual organs here before ladies in prayer. In this + way he finally ruined his commercial position in Paris and was + obliged to establish himself in a small provincial town. Here + again he soon exposed himself in a church and was again sent to + prison, but on his liberation immediately performed the same act + in the same church in what was described as a most imperturbable + manner. Compelled to leave the town, he returned to Paris, and in + a few weeks' time was again arrested for repeating his old + offense in Saint Roch. When examined by Garnier, the information + he supplied was vague and incomplete, and he was very embarrassed + in the attempt to explain himself. He was unable to say why he + chose a church, but he felt that it was to a church that he must + go. He had, however, no thought of profanation and no wish to + give offense. "Quite the contrary!" he declared. He had the sad + and tired air of a man who is dominated by a force stronger than + his will. "I know," he added, "what repulsion my conduct must + inspire. Why am I made thus? Who will cure me?" (P. Garnier, + "Perversions Sexuelles," _Comptes Rendus_, International Congress + of Medicine at Paris in 1900, _Section de Psychiatrie_, pp. + 433-435.) + + In some cases, it would appear, the impulse to exhibitionism may + be overcome or may pass away. This result is the more likely to + come about in those cases in which exhibitionism has been largely + conditioned by chronic alcoholism or other influences tending to + destroy the inhibiting and restraining action of the higher + centers, which may be overcome by hygiene and treatment. In this + connection I may bring forward a case which has been communicated + to me by a medical correspondent in London. It is that of an + actor, of high standing in his profession and extremely + intelligent, 49 years of age, married and father of a large + family. He is sexually vigorous and of erotic temperament. His + general health has always been good, but he is a high-strung, + neurotic man, with quick mental reactions. His habits had for a + long time been decidedly alcoholic, but two years ago, a small + quantity of albumen being found in the urine, he was persuaded to + leave off alcohol, and has since been a teetotaller. Though + ordinarily very reticent about sexual matters, he began four or + five years ago to commit acts of exhibitionism, exposing himself + to servants in the house and occasionally to women in the + country. This continued after the alcohol had been abandoned and + lasted for several years, though the attention of the police was + never attracted to the matter, and so far as possible he was + quietly supervised by his friends. Nine months after, the acts of + exhibitionism ceased, apparently in a spontaneous manner, and + there has so far been no relapse. + +Exhibitionism is an act which, on the face of it, seems nonsensical and +meaningless, and as such, as an inexplicable act of madness, it has +frequently been treated both by writers on insanity and on sexual +perversion. "These acts are so lacking in common sense and intelligent +reflection that no other reason than insanity can be offered for the +patient," Ball concluded.[55] Moll, also, who defines exhibitionism +somewhat too narrowly as a condition in which "the charm of the exhibition +lies for the subject in the display itself," not sufficiently taking into +consideration the imagined effect on the spectator, concludes that "the +psychological basis of exhibitionism is at present by no means cleared +up."[56] + +We may probably best approach exhibitionism by regarding it as +fundamentally a symbolic act based on a perversion of courtship. The +exhibitionist displays the organ of sex to a feminine witness, and in the +shock of modest sexual shame by which she reacts to that spectacle, he +finds a gratifying similitude of the normal emotions of coitus.[57] He +feels that he has effected a psychic defloration. + + Exhibitionism is thus analogous, and, indeed, related, to the + impulse felt by many persons to perform indecorous acts or tell + indecent stories before young and innocent persons of the + opposite sex. This is a kind of psychic exhibitionism, the + gratification it causes lying exactly, as in physical + exhibitionism, in the emotional confusion which it is felt to + arouse. The two kinds of exhibitionism may be combined in the + same person: Thus, in a case reported by Hoche (p. 97), the + exhibitionist an intellectual and highly educated man, with a + doctor's degree, also found pleasure in sending indecent poems + and pictures to women, whom, however, he made no attempt to + seduce; he was content with the thought of the emotions he + aroused or believed that he aroused. + + It is possible that within this group should come the agent in + the following incident which was lately observed by a lady, a + friend of my own. An elderly man in an overcoat was seen standing + outside a large and well-known draper's shop in the outskirts of + London; when able to attract the attention of any of the + shop-girls or of any girl in the street he would fling back his + coat and reveal that he was wearing over his own clothes a + woman's chemise (or possibly bodice) and a woman's drawers; there + was no exposure. The only intelligible explanation of this action + would seem to be that pleasure was experienced in the mild shock + of interested surprise and injured modesty which this vision was + imagined to cause to a young girl. It would thus be a + comparatively innocent form of psychic defloration. + +It is of interest to point out that the sexual symbolism of active +flagellation is very closely analogous to this symbolism of exhibitionism. +The flagellant approaches a woman with the rod (itself a symbol of the +penis and in some countries bearing names which are also applied to that +organ) and inflicts on an intimate part of her body the signs of blushing +and the spasmodic movements which are associated with sexual excitement, +while at the same time she feels, or the flagellant imagines that she +feels, the corresponding emotions of delicious shame.[58] This is an even +closer mimicry of the sexual act than the exhibitionist attains, for the +latter fails to secure the consent of the woman nor does he enjoy any +intimate contact with her naked body. The difference is connected with the +fact that the active flagellant is usually a more virile and normal person +than the exhibitionist. In the majority of cases the exhibitionist's +sexual impulse is very feeble, and as a rule he is either to some degree a +degenerate, or else a person who is suffering from an early stage of +general paralysis, dementia, or some other highly enfeebling cause of +mental disorganization, such as chronic alcoholism. Sexual feebleness is +further indicated by the fact that the individuals selected as witnesses +are frequently mere children. + + It seems probable that a form of erotic symbolism somewhat + similar to exhibitionism is to be found in the rare cases in + which sexual gratification is derived from throwing ink, acid or + other defiling liquids on women's dresses. Thoinot has recorded a + case of this kind (_Attentats aux Moeurs_, 1898, pp. 484, _et + seq._). An instructive case has been presented by Moll. In this + case a young man of somewhat neuropathic heredity had as a youth + of 16 or 17, when romping with his young sister's playfellows, + experienced sexual sensations on chancing to see their white + underlinen. From that time white underlinen and white dresses + became to him a fetich and he was only attracted to women so + attired. One day, at the age of 25, when crossing the street in + wet weather with a young lady in a white dress, a passing vehicle + splashed the dress with mud. This incident caused him strong + sexual excitement, and from that time he had the impulse to throw + ink, perchloride of iron, etc., on to ladies' white dresses, and + sometimes to cut and tear them, sexual excitement and ejaculation + taking place every time he effected this. (Moll, "Gutachten ueber + einem Sexual Perversen [Besudelungstrieb]," _Zeitschrift fuer + Medizinalbeamte_, Heft XIII, 1900). Such a case is of + considerable psychological interest. Thoinot considers that in + these cases the fleck is a fetich. That is an incorrect account + of the matter. In this case the white garments constituted the + primary fetich, but that fetich becomes more acutely realized, + and at the same time both parties are thrown into an emotional + state which to the fetichist becomes a mimicry of coitus, by the + act of defilement. We may perhaps connect with this phenomenon + the attraction which muddy shoes often exert over the + shoe-fetichist, and the curious way in which, as we have seen (p. + 18), Restif de la Bretonne associates his love of neatness in + women with his attraction to the feet, the part, he remarks, + least easy to keep clean. + + Garnier applied the term _sadi-fetichism_ to active flagellation + and many similar manifestations such as we are here concerned + with, on the grounds that they are hybrids which combine the + morbid adoration for a definite object with the impulse to + exercise a more or less degree of violence. From the standpoint + of the conception of erotic symbolism I have adopted there is no + need for this term. There is here no hybrid combination of two + unlike mental states. We are simply concerned with states of + erotic symbolism, more or less complete, more or less complex. + +The conception of exhibitionism as a process of erotic symbolism, involves +a conscious or unconscious attitude of attention in the exhibitionist's +mind to the psychic reaction of the woman toward whom his display is +directed. He seeks to cause an emotion which, probably in most cases, he +desires should be pleasurable. But from one cause or another his finer +sensibilities are always inhibited or in abeyance, and he is unable to +estimate accurately either the impression he is likely to produce or the +general results of his action, or else he is moved by a strong impulsive +obsession which overpowers his judgment. In many cases he has good reason +for believing that his act will be pleasurable, and frequently he finds +complacent witnesses among the low-class servant girls, etc. + + It may be pointed out here that we are quite justified in + speaking of a penis-fetichism and also of a vulva-fetichism. This + might be questioned. We are obviously justified in recognizing a + fetichism which attaches itself to the pubic hair, or, as in a + case with which I am acquainted, to the clitoris, but it may seem + that we cannot regard the central sexual organs as symbols of + sex, symbols, as it were, of themselves. Properly regarded, + however, it is the sexual act rather than the sexual organ which + is craved in normal sexual desire; the organ is regarded merely + as the means and not as the end. Regarded as a means the organ is + indeed an object of desire, but it only becomes a fetich when it + arrests and fixes the attention. An attention thus pleasurably + fixed, a vulva-fetichism or a penis-fetichism, is within the + normal range of sexual emotion (this point has been mentioned in + the previous volume when discussing the part played by the + primary sexual organs in sexual selection), and in coarse-grained + natures of either sex it is a normal allurement in its + generalized shape, apart from any attraction to the person to + whom the organs belong. In some morbid cases, however, this + penis-fetichism may become a fully developed sexual perversion. A + typical case of this kind has been recorded by Howard in the + United States. Mrs. W., aged 39, was married at 20 to a strong, + healthy man, but derived no pleasure from coitus, though she + received great pleasure from masturbation practiced immediately + after coitus, and nine years after marriage she ceased actual + coitus, compelling her husband to adopt mutual masturbation. She + would introduce men into the house at all times of the day or + night, and after persuading them to expose their persons would + retire to her room to masturbate. The same man never aroused + desire more than once. This desire became so violent and + persistent that she would seek out men in all sorts of public + places and, having induced them to expose themselves, rapidly + retreat to the nearest convenient spot for self-gratification. + She once abstracted a pair of trousers she had seen a man wear + and after fondling them experienced the orgasm. Her husband + finally left her, after vainly attempting to have her confined in + an asylum. She was often arrested for her actions, but through + the intervention of friends set free again. She was a highly + intelligent woman, and apart from this perversion entirely + normal. (W.L. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," _Alienist and + Neurologist_, January, 1896.) It is on the existence of a more or + less developed penis-fetichism of this kind that the + exhibitionist, mostly by an ignorant instinct, relies for the + effects he desires to produce. + +The exhibitionist is not usually content to produce a mere titillated +amusement; he seeks to produce a more powerful effect which must be +emotional whether or not it is pleasurable. A professional man in +Strassburg (in a case reported by Hoche[59]) would walk about in the +evening in a long cloak, and when he met ladies would suddenly throw his +cloak back under a street lamp, or igniting a red-fire match, and thus +exhibit his organs. There was an evident effort--on the part of a weak, +vain, and effeminate man--to produce a maximum of emotional effect. The +attempt to heighten the emotional shock is also seen in the fact that the +exhibitionist frequently chooses a church as the scene of his exploits, +not during service, for he always avoids a concourse of people, but +perhaps toward evening when there are only a few kneeling women scattered +through the edifice. The church is chosen, often instinctively rather than +deliberately, from no impulse to commit a sacrilegious outrage--which, as +a rule, the exhibitionist does not feel his act to be--but because it +really presents the conditions most favorable to the act and the effects +desired. The exhibitionist's attitude of mind is well illustrated by one +of Garnier's patients who declared that he never wished to be seen by more +than two women at once, "just what is necessary," he added, "for an +exchange of impressions." After each exhibition he would ask himself +anxiously: "Did they see me? What are they thinking? What do they say to +each other about me? Oh! how I should like to know!" Another patient of +Garnier's, who haunted churches for this purpose, made this very +significant statement: "Why do I like going to churches? I can scarcely +say. _But I know that it is only there that my act has its full +importance_. The woman is in a devout frame of mind, and she must see that +such an act in such a place is not a joke in bad taste or a disgusting +obscenity; _that if I go there it is not to amuse myself; it is more +serious than that!_ I watch the effect produced on the faces of the ladies +to whom I show my organs. I wish to see them express a profound joy. I +wish, in fact, that they may be forced to say to themselves: _How +impressive Nature is when thus seen!_" + + Here we trace the presence of a feeling which recalls the + phenomena of the ancient and world-wide phallic worship, still + liable to reappear sporadically. Women sometimes took part in + these rites, and the osculation of the male sexual organ or its + emblematic representation by women is easily traceable in the + phallic rites of India and many other lands, not excluding Europe + even in comparatively recent times. (Dulaure in his _Divinites + Generatices_ brings together much bearing on these points; cf.: + Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter XVII, and Bloch, + _Beitraege zur Psychopathia Sexualis_, Teil I, pp. 115-117. Colin + Scott has some interesting remarks on phallic worship and the + part it has played in aiding human evolution, "Sex and Art," + _American Journal of Psychology_, vol. vii, No. 2, pp. 191-197. + Irving Rosse describes some modern phallic rites in which both + men and women took part, similar to those practiced in vaudouism, + "Sexual Hypochondriasis," _Virginia Medical Monthly_, October, + 1892.) + + Putting aside any question of phallic worship, a certain pride + and more or less private feeling of ostentation in the new + expansion and development of the organs of virility seems to be + almost normal at adolescence. "We have much reason to assume," + Stanley Hall remarks, "that in a state of nature there is a + certain instinctive pride and ostentation that accompanies the + new local development. I think it will be found that + exhibitionists are usually those who have excessive growth here, + and that much that modern society stigmatizes as obscene is at + bottom more or less spontaneous and perhaps in some cases not + abnormal. Dr. Seerley tells me he has never examined a young man + largely developed who had the usual strong instinctive tendency + of modesty to cover himself with his hands, but he finds this + instinct general with those whose development is less than the + average." (G. Stanley Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. ii, p. 97.) This + instinct of ostentation, however, so far as it is normal, is held + in check by other considerations, and is not, in the strict + sense, exhibitionism. I have observed a full-grown telegraph boy + walking across Hampstead Heath with his sexual organs exposed, + but immediately he realized that he was seen he concealed them. + The solemnity of exhibitionism at this age finds expression in + the climax of the sonnet, "Oraison du Soir," written at 16 by + Rimbaud, whose verse generally is a splendid and insolent + manifestation of rank adolescence:-- + + "Doux comme le Seigneur du cedre et des hysopes, + Je pisse vers les cieux bruns tres haut et tres loin, + Avec l'assentiment des grands heliotropes." + + (J.A. Rimbaud, _Oeuvres_, p. 68.) + + In women, also, there would appear to be traceable a somewhat + similar ostentation, though in them it is complicated and largely + inhibited by modesty, and at the same time diffused over the body + owing to the absence of external sexual organs. "Primitive + woman," remarks Madame Renooz, "proud of her womanhood, for a + long time defended her nakedness which ancient art has always + represented. And in the actual life of the young girl to-day + there is a moment when by a secret atavism she feels the pride of + her sex, the intuition of her moral superiority, and cannot + understand why she must hide its cause. At this moment, wavering + between the laws of Nature and social conventions, she scarcely + knows if nakedness should or should not affright her. A sort of + confused atavistic memory recalls to her a period before clothing + was known, and reveals to her as a paradisaical ideal the customs + of that human epoch." (Celine Renooz, _Psychologie Comparee de + l'Homme et de la Femme_, p. 85.) It may be added that among + primitive peoples, and even among some remote European + populations to-day, the exhibition of feminine nudity has + sometimes been regarded as a spectacle with religious or magic + operation. (Ploss, _Das Weib_, seventh edition, vol. ii, pp. + 663-680; Havelock Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, p. + 304.) It is stated by Gopcevic that in the long struggle between + the Albanians and the Montenegrians the women of the former + people would stand in the front rank and expose themselves by + raising their skirts, believing that they would thus insure + victory. As, however, they were shot down, and as, moreover, + victory usually fell to the Montenegrians, this custom became + discredited. (Quoted by Bloch, _Op. cit._, Teil II, p. 307.) + + With regard to the association, suggested by Stanley Hall, + between exhibitionism and an unusual degree of development of the + sexual organs, it must be remarked that both extremes--a very + large and a very small penis--are specially common in + exhibitionists. The prevalence of the small organ is due to an + association of exhibitionism with sexual feebleness. The + prevalence of the large organ may be due to the cause suggested + by Hall. Among Mahommedans the sexual organs are sometimes + habitually exposed by religious penitents, and I note that + Bernhard Stern, in his book on the medical and sexual aspects of + life in Turkey, referring to a penitent of this sort whom he saw + on the Stamboul bridge at Constantinople, remarks that the organ + was very largely developed. It may well be in such a case that + the penitent's religious attitude is reinforced by some lingering + relic of a more fleshly ostentation. + +It is by a pseudo-atavism that this phallicism is evoked in the +exhibitionist. There is no true emergence of an ancestrally inherited +instinct, but by the paralysis or inhibition of the finer and higher +feelings current in civilization, the exhibitionist is placed on the same +mental level as the man of a more primitive age, and he thus presents the +basis on which the impulses belonging to a higher culture may naturally +take root and develop. + + Reference may here be made to a form of primitive exhibitionism, + almost confined to women, which, although certainly symbolic, is + absolutely non-sexual, and must not, therefore, be confused with + the phenomena we are here occupied with. I refer to the + exhibition of the buttocks as a mark of contempt. In its most + primitive form, no doubt, this exhibitionism is a kind of + exorcism, a method of putting evil spirits, primarily, and + secondarily evil-disposed persons, to flight. It is the most + effective way for a woman to display sexual centers, and it + shares in the magical virtues which all unveiling of the sexual + centers is believed by primitive peoples to possess. It is + recorded that the women of some peoples in the Balkan peninsula + formerly used this gesture against enemies in battle. In the + sixteenth century so distinguished a theologian as Luther when + assailed by the Evil One at night was able to put the adversary + to flight by protruding his uncovered buttocks from the bed. But + the spiritual significance of this attitude is lost with the + decay of primitive beliefs. It survives, but merely as a gesture + of insult. The symbolism comes to have reference to the nates as + the excretory focus, the seat of the anus. In any case it ignores + any sexual attractiveness in this part of the body. Exhibitionism + of this kind, therefore, can scarcely arise in persons of any + sensitiveness or aesthetic perception, even putting aside the + question of modesty, and there seems to be little trace of it in + classic antiquity when the nates were regarded as objects of + beauty. Among the Egyptians, however, we gather from Herodotus + (Bk. II, Chapter LX) that at a certain popular religious festival + men and women would go in boats on the Nile, singing and playing, + and when they approached a town the women on the boats would + insult the women of the town by injurious language and by + exposing themselves. Among the Arabs, however, the specific + gesture we are concerned with is noted, and a man to whom + vengeance is forbidden would express his feelings by exposing his + posterior and strewing earth on his head (Wellhausen, _Rests + Arabischen Heidentums_, 1897, p. 195). It is in Europe and in + mediaeval and later times that this emphatic gesture seems to have + flourished as a violent method of expressing contempt. It was by + no means confined to the lower classes, and Kleinpaul, in + discussing this form of "speech without words," quotes examples + of various noble persons, even princesses, who are recorded thus + to have expressed their feelings. (Kleinpaul, _Sprache ohne + Worte_, pp. 271-273.) In more recent times the gesture has become + merely a rare and extreme expression of unrestrained feeling in + coarse-grained peasants. Zola, in the figure of Mouquette in + _Germinal_, may be said to have given a kind of classic + expression to the gesture. In the more remote parts of Europe it + appears to be still not altogether uncommon. This seems to be + notably the case among the South Slavs, and Krauss states that + "when a South Slav woman wishes to express her deepest contempt + for anyone she bends forward, with left hand raising her skirts, + and with the right slapping her posterior, at the same time + exclaiming: 'This for you!'" (Kryptadia, vol. vi, p. 200.) + + A verbal survival of this gesture, consisting in the contemptuous + invitation to kiss this region, still exists among us in remote + parts of the country, especially as an insult offered by an angry + woman who forgets herself. It is said to be commonly used in + Wales. ("Welsh AEdoelogy," Kryptadia, vol. ii, pp. 358, et seq.) + In Cornwall, when addressed by a woman to a man it is sometimes + regarded as a deadly insult, even if the woman is young and + attractive, and may cause a life-long enmity between related + families. From this point of view the nates are a symbol of + contempt, and any sexual significance is excluded. (The + distinction is brought out by Diderot in _Le Neveu de Rameau:_ + "_Lui:_--Il y a d'autres jours ou il ne m'en couterait rien pour + etre vil tant qu'on voudrait; ces jours-la, pour un liard, je + baiserais le cul a la petite Hus. _Moi:_--Eh! mais, l'ami, elle + est blanche, jolie, douce, potelee, et c'est un acte d'humilite + auquel un plus delicat que vous pourrait quelquefois s'abaisser. + _Lui:_--Entendons-nous; c'est qu'il y a baiser le cul au simple, + et baiser le cul au figure.") + + It must be added that a sexual form of exhibitionism of the nates + must still be recognized. It occurs in masochism and expresses + the desire for passive flagellation. Rousseau, whose emotional + life was profoundly affected by the castigations which as a child + he received from Mlle Lambercier, has in his _Confessions_ told + us how, when a youth, he would sometimes expose himself in this + way in the presence of young women. Such masochistic + exhibitionism seems, however, to be rare. + +While the manifestations of exhibitionism are substantially the same in +all cases, there are many degrees and varieties of the condition. We may +find among exhibitionists, as Garnier remarks, dementia, states of +unconsciousness, epilepsy, general paralysis, alcoholism, but the most +typical cases, he adds, if not indeed the cases to which the term properly +belongs, are those in which it is an impulsive obsession. Krafft-Ebing[60] +divides exhibitionists into four clinical groups: (1) acquired states of +mental weakness, with cerebral or spinal disease clouding consciousness +and at the same time causing impotence; (2) epileptics, in whom the act is +an abnormal organic impulse performed in a state of imperfect +consciousness; (3) a somewhat allied group of neurasthenic cases; (4) +periodical impulsive cases with deep hereditary taint. This classification +is not altogether satisfactory. Garnier's classification, placing the +group of obsessional cases in the foreground and leaving the other more +vaguely defined groups in the background, is probably better. I am +inclined to consider that most of the cases fall into one or other of two +mixed groups. The first class includes cases in which there is more or +less congenital abnormality, but otherwise a fair or even complete degree +of mental integrity; they are usually young adults, they are more or less +precisely conscious of the end they wish to attain, and it is often only +with a severe struggle that they yield to their impulses. In the second +class the beginnings of mental or nervous disease have diminished the +sensibility of the higher centers; the subjects are usually old men whose +lives have been absolutely correct; they are often only vaguely aware of +the nature of the satisfaction they are seeking, and frequently no +struggle precedes the manifestation; such was the case of the overworked +clergyman described by Hughes,[61] who, after much study, became morose +and absent-minded, and committed acts of exhibitionism which he could not +explain but made no attempt to deny; with rest and restorative treatment +his health improved and the acts ceased. It is in the first class of cases +alone that there is a developed sexual perversion. In the cases of the +second class there is a more or less definite sexual intention, but it is +only just conscious, and the emergence of the impulse is due not to its +strength but to the weakness, temporary or permanent, of the higher +inhibiting centers. + +Epileptic cases, with loss of consciousness during the act, can only be +regarded as presenting a pseudo-exhibitionism. They should be excluded +altogether. It is undoubtedly true that many cases of real or apparent +exhibitionism occur in epileptics.[62] We must not, however, too hastily +conclude that because these acts occur in epileptics they are necessarily +unconscious acts. Epilepsy frequently occurs on a basis of hereditary +degeneration, and the exhibitionism may be, and not infrequently is, a +stigma of the degeneracy and not an indication of the occurrence of a +minor epileptic fit. When the act of pseudo-exhibitionism is truly +epileptic, it will usually have no psychic sexual content, and it will +certainly be liable to occur under all sorts of circumstances, when the +patient is alone or in a miscellaneous concourse of people. It will be on +a level with the acts of the highly respectable young woman who, at the +conclusion of an attack of _petit mal_, consisting chiefly of a sudden +desire to pass urine, on one occasion lifted up her clothes and urinated +at a public entertainment, so that it was with difficulty her friends +prevented her from being handed over to the police.[63] Such an act is +automatic, unconscious, and involuntary; the spectators are not even +perceived; it cannot be an act of exhibitionism. Whenever, on the other +hand, the place and the time are evidently chosen deliberately,--a quiet +spot, the presence of only one or two young women or children,--it is +difficult to admit that we are in the presence of a fit of epileptic +unconsciousness, even when the subject is known to be epileptic. + +Even, however, when we exclude those epileptic pseudo-exhibitionists who, +from the legal point of view, are clearly irresponsible, it must still be +remembered that in every case of exhibitionism there is a high degree of +either mental abnormality on a neuropathic basis, or else of actual +disease. This is true to a greater extent in exhibitionism than in almost +any other form of sexual perversion. No subject of exhibitionism should be +sent to prison without expert medical examination. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[54] Lasege first drew attention to this sexual perversion and gave it its +generally accepted name, "Les Exhibitionistes," _L'Union Medicale_, May, +1877. Magnan, on various occasions (for example, "Les Exhibitionistes," +_Archives de l'Anthropologie Criminelle_, vol. v, 1890, p. 456), has given +further development and precision to the clinical picture of the +exhibitionist. + +[55] B. Ball. _La Folie Erotique_, p. 86. + +[56] Moll, _Untersuchungen ueber die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 661. + +[57] "Exhibitionism in its most typical form is," Garnier truly says, "a +_systematic act_, manifesting itself as the _strange equivalent of a +sexual connection_, or its _substitution_." The brief account of +exhibitionism (pp. 433-437) in Garnier's discussion of "Perversions +Sexuelles" at the International Medical Congress at Paris in 1900 +(_Section de Psychiatrie: Comptes-Rendus_) is the most satisfactory +statement of the psychological aspects of this perversion with which I am +acquainted. Garnier's unrivalled clinical knowledge of these +manifestations, due to his position during many years as physician at the +Depot of the Prefecture of Police in Paris, adds great weight to his +conclusions. + +[58] The symbolism of coitus involved in flagellation has been touched on +by Eulenburg (_Sexuale Neuropathie_, p. 121), and is more fully developed +by Duehren (_Geschlechtsleben in England_, bd. ii, pp. 366, _et seq._). + +[59] A. Hoche, _Neurologische Centralblatt_, 1896, No. 2. + +[60] _Op. cit._, pp. 478, et seq. + +[61] C.H. Hughes, "Morbid Exhibitionism," _Alienist and Neurologist_, +August, 1904. Another somewhat similar American case, also preceded by +overwork, and eventually adjudged insane by the courts, is recorded by +D.S. Booth, _Alienist and Neurologist_, February, 1905. + +[62] Exhibitionism in epilepsy is briefly discussed by Fere, _L'Instinct +Sexuel_, second edition, pp. 194-195. + +[63] W.S. Colman, "Post-Epileptic Unconscious Automatic Actions," +_Lancet_, July 5, 1890. + + + + +VI. + +The Forms of Erotic Symbolism are Simulacra of Coitus--Wide +Extension of Erotic Symbolism--Fetichism Not Covering the Whole +Ground of Sexual Selection--It is Based on the Individual Factor in +Selection--Crystallization--The Lover and the Artist--The Key to Erotic +Symbolism to be Found in the Emotional Sphere--The Passage to Pathological +Extremes. + + +We have now examined several very various and yet very typical +manifestations in all of which it is not difficult to see how, in some +strange and eccentric form--on a basis of association through resemblance +or contiguity or both combined--there arises a definite mimicry of the +normal sexual act together with the normal emotions which accompany that +act. It has become clear in what sense we are justified in recognizing +erotic symbolism. + + The symbolic and, as it were, abstracted nature of these + manifestations is shown by the remarkable way in which they are + sometimes capable of transference from the object to the subject. + That is to say that the fetichist may show a tendency to + cultivate his fetich in his own person. A foot-fetichist may like + to go barefoot himself; a man who admired lame women liked to + halt himself; a man who was attracted by small waists in women + found sexual gratification in tight-lacing himself; a man who was + fascinated by fine white skin and wished to cut it found + satisfaction in cutting his own skin; Moll's coprolagnic + fetichist found a voluptuous pleasure in his own acts of + defecation. (See, e.g., Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, p. 221, 224, + 226; Hammond, _Sexual Impotence_, p. 74; cf. _ante_, p. 68.) Such + symbolic transference seems to have a profoundly natural basis, + for we may see a somewhat similar phenomenon in the well-known + tendency of cows to mount a cow in heat. This would appear to be, + not so much a homosexual impulse, as the dynamic psychic action + of an olfactory sexual symbol in a transformed form. + + We seem to have here a psychic process which is a curious + reversal of that process of _Einfuehlung_--the projection of one's + own activities into the object contemplated--which Lipps has so + fruitfully developed as the essence of every aesthetic condition. + (T. Lipps, _AEsthetik_, Teil I, 1903.) By _Einfuehlung_ our own + interior activity becomes the activity of the object perceived, + a thing being beautiful in proportion as it lends itself to our + _Einfuehlung_. But by this action of erotic symbolism, on the + other hand, we transfer the activity of the object into + ourselves. + +When the idea of erotic symbolism as manifested in such definite and +typical forms becomes realized, it further becomes clear that the vaguer +manifestations of such symbolism are exceedingly widespread. When in a +previous volume we were discussing and drawing together the various +threads which unite "Love and Pain," it will now be understood that we +were standing throughout on the threshold of erotic symbolism. Pain +itself, in the sense in which we slowly learned to define it in this +relationship--as a state of intense emotional excitement--may, under a +great variety of special circumstances, become an erotic symbol and afford +the same relief as the emotions normally accompanying the sexual act. +Active algolagnia or sadism is thus a form of erotic symbolism; passive +algolagnia or masochism is (in a man) an inverted form of erotic +symbolism. Active flagellation or passive flagellation are, in exactly the +same way, manifestations of erotic symbolism, the imaginative mimicry of +coitus. + +Binet and also Krafft-Ebing[64] have argued in effect that the whole of +sexual selection is a matter of fetichism, that is to say, of erotic +symbolism of object. "Normal love," Binet states, "appears as the result +of a complicated fetichism." Tarde also seems to have regarded love as +normally a kind of fetichism. "We are a long time before we fall in love +with a woman," he remarks; "we must wait to see the detail which strikes +and delights us, and causes us to overlook what displeases us. Only in +normal love the details are many and always changing. Constancy in love is +rarely anything else but a voyage around the beloved person, a voyage of +exploration and ever new discoveries. The most faithful lover does not +love the same woman in the same way for two days in succession."[65] + +From that point of view normal sexual love is the sway of a fetich--more +or less arbitrary, more or less (as Binet terms it) polytheistic--and it +can have little objective basis. But, as we saw when considering "Sexual +Selection in Man" in the previous volume, more especially when analyzing +the notion of beauty, we are justified in believing that beauty has to a +large extent an objective basis, and that love by no means depends simply +on the capricious selection of some individual fetich. The individual +factor, as we saw, is but one of many factors which constitute beauty. In +the study of sexual selection that individual factor was passed over very +lightly. We now see that it is often a factor of great importance, for in +it are rooted all these outgrowths--normal in their germs, highly abnormal +in their more extreme developments--which make up erotic symbolism. + +Erotic symbolism is therefore concerned with all that is least generic, +least specific, all that is most intimately personal and individual, in +sexual selection. It is the final point in which the decreasing circle of +sexual attractiveness is fixed. In the widest and most abstract form +sexual selection in man is merely human, and we are attracted to that +which bears most fully the marks of humanity; in a less abstract form it +is sexual, and we are attracted to that which most vigorously presents the +secondary sexual characteristics; still narrowing, it is the type of our +own nation and people that appeals most strongly to us in matters of love; +and still further concentrating we are affected by the ideal--in +civilization most often the somewhat exotic ideal--of our own day, the +fashion of our own city. But the individual factor still remains, and amid +the infinite possibilities of erotic symbolism the individual may evolve +an ideal which is often, as far as he knows and perhaps in actuality, an +absolutely unique event in the history of the human soul. + +Erotic symbolism works in its finer manifestations by means of the +idealizing aptitudes; it is the field of sexual psychology in which that +faculty of crystallization, on which Stendhal loved to dwell, achieves its +most brilliant results. In the solitary passage in which we seem to see a +smile on the face of the austere poet of the _De Rerum Natura_, Lucretius +tells us how every lover, however he may be amused by the amorous +extravagances of other men, is himself blinded by passion: if his mistress +is black she is a fascinating brunette, if she squints she is the rival of +Pallas, if too tall she is majestic, if too short she is one of the +Graces, _tota merum sal_; if too lean it is her delicate refinement, if +too fat then a Ceres, dirty and she disdains adornment, a chatterer and +brilliantly vivacious, silent and it is her exquisite modesty.[66] Sixteen +hundred years later Robert Burton, when describing the symptoms of love, +made out a long and appalling list of the physical defects which the lover +is prepared to admire.[67] + +Yet we must not be too certain that the lover is wrong in this matter. We +too hastily assume that the casual and hasty judgment of the world is +necessarily more reliable, more conformed to what we call "truth," than +the judgment of the lover which is founded on absorbed and patient study. +In some cases where there is lack of intelligence in the lover and +dissimulation in the object of his love, it may be so. But even a poem or +a picture will often not reveal its beauty except by the expenditure of +time and study. It is foolish to expect that the secret beauty of a human +person will reveal itself more easily. The lover is an artist, an artist +who constructs an image, it is true, but only by patient and concentrated +attention to nature; he knows the defects of his image, probably better +than anyone, but he knows also that art lies, not in the avoidance of +defects, but in the realization of those traits which swallow up defects +and so render them non-existent. A great artist, Rodin, after a life spent +in the study of Nature, has declared that for art there is no ugliness in +Nature. "I have arrived at this belief by the study of Nature," he said; +"I can only grasp the beauty of the soul by the beauty of the body, but +some day one will come who will explain what I only catch a glimpse of and +will declare how the whole earth is beautiful, and all human beings +beautiful. I have never been able to say this in sculpture so well as I +wish and as I feel it affirmed within me. For poets Beauty has always +been some particular landscape, some particular woman; but it should be +all women, all landscapes. A negro or a Mongol has his beauty, however +remote from ours, and it must be the same with their characters. There is +no ugliness. When I was young I made that mistake, as others do; I could +not undertake a woman's bust unless I thought her pretty, according to my +particular idea of beauty; to-day I should do the bust of any woman, and +it would be just as beautiful. And however ugly a woman may look, when she +is with her lover she becomes beautiful; there is beauty in her character, +in her passions, and beauty exists as soon as character or passion becomes +visible, for the body is a casting on which passions are imprinted. And +even without that, there is always the blood that flows in the veins and +the air that fills the lungs."[68] + +The saint, also, is here at one with the lover and the artist. The man who +has so profoundly realized the worth of his fellow men that he is ready +even to die in order to save them, feels that he has discovered a great +secret. Cyples traces the "secret delights" that have thus risen in the +hearts of holy men to the same source as the feelings generated between +lovers, friends, parents, and children. "A few have at intervals walked in +the world," he remarks, "who have, each in his own original way, found out +this marvel.... Straightway man in general has become to them so sweet a +thing that the infatuation has seemed to the rest of their fellows to be a +celestial madness. Beggars' rags to their unhesitating lips grew fit for +kissing, because humanity had touched the garb; there were no longer any +menial acts, but only welcome services.... Remember by how much man is the +subtlest circumstance in the world; at how many points he can attach +relationships; how manifold and perennial he is in his results. All other +things are dull, meager, tame beside him."[69] + +It may be added that even if we still believe that lover and artist and +saint are drawing the main elements of their conceptions from the depths +of their own consciousness, there is a sense in which they are coming +nearer to the truth of things than those for whom their conceptions are +mere illusions. The aptitude for realizing beauty has involved an +adjustment of the nerves and the associated brain centers through +countless ages that began before man was. When the vision of supreme +beauty is slowly or suddenly realized by anyone, with a reverberation that +extends throughout his organism, he has attained to something which for +his species, and for far more than his species, is truth, and can only be +illusion to one who has artificially placed himself outside the stream of +life. + + In an essay on "The Gods as Apparitions of the Race-Life," Edward + Carpenter, though in somewhat Platonic phraseology, thus well + states the matter: "The youth sees the girl; it may be a chance + face, a chance outline, amid the most banal surroundings. But it + gives the cue. There is a memory, a confused reminiscence. The + mortal figure without penetrates to the immortal figure within, + and there rises into consciousness a shining form, glorious, not + belonging to this world, but vibrating with the agelong life of + humanity, and the memory of a thousand love-dreams. The waking of + this vision intoxicates the man; it glows and burns within him; a + goddess (it may be Venus herself) stands in the sacred place of + his temple; a sense of awe-struck splendor fills him, and the + world is changed." "He sees something" (the same writer continues + in a subsequent essay, "Beauty and Duty") "which, in a sense, is + more real than the figures in the street, for he sees something + that has lived and moved for hundreds of years in the heart of + the race; something which has been one of the great formative + influences of his own life, and which has done as much to create + those very figures in the street as qualities in the circulation + of the blood may do to form a finger or other limb. He comes into + touch with a very real Presence or Power--one of those organic + centers of growth in the life of humanity--and feels this larger + life within himself, subjective, if you like, and yet intensely + objective. And more. For is it not also evident that the woman, + the mortal woman who excites his Vision, _has_ some closest + relation to it, and is, indeed, far more than a mere mask or + empty formula which reminds him of it? For she indeed has within + her, just as much as the man has, deep subconscious Powers + working; and the ideal which has dawned so entrancingly on the + man is in all probability closely related to that which has been + working most powerfully in the heredity of the woman, and which + has most contributed to mold _her_ form and outline. No wonder, + then, that her form should remind him of it. Indeed, when he + looks into her eyes he sees _through_ to a far deeper life even + than she herself may be aware of, and yet which is truly hers--a + life perennial and wonderful. The more than mortal in him beholds + the more than mortal in her; and the gods descend to meet." + (Edward Carpenter, _The Art of Creation_, pp. 137, 186.) + +It is this mighty force which lies behind and beneath the aberrations we +have been concerned with, a great reservoir from which they draw the +life-blood that vivifies even their most fantastic shapes. Fetichism and +the other forms of erotic symbolism are but the development and the +isolation of the crystallizations which normally arise on the basis of +sexual selection. Normal in their basis, in their extreme forms they +present the utmost pathological aberrations of the sexual instinct which +can be attained or conceived. In the intermediate space all degrees are +possible. In the slightest degree the symbol is merely a specially +fascinating and beloved feature in a person who is, in all other respects, +felt to be lovable; as such its recognition is a legitimate part of +courtship, an effective aid to tumescence. In a further degree the symbol +is the one arresting and attracting character of a person who must, +however, still be felt as a sexually attractive individual. In a still +further degree of perversion the symbol is effective, even though the +person with whom it is associated is altogether unattractive. In the final +stage the person and even all association with a person disappear +altogether from the field of sexual consciousness; the abstract symbol +rules supreme. + +Long, however, before the symbol has reached that final climax of morbid +intensity we may be said to have passed beyond the sphere of sexual love. +A person, not an abstracted quality, must be the goal of love. So long as +the fetich is subordinated to the person it serves to heighten love. But +love must be based on a complexus of attractive qualities, or it has no +stability.[70] As soon as the fetich becomes isolated and omnipotent, so +that the person sinks into the background as an unimportant appendage of +the fetich, all stability is lost. The fetichist now follows an impersonal +and abstract symbol withersoever it may lead him. + +It has been seen that there are an extraordinary number of forms in which +erotic symbolism may be felt. It must be remembered, and it cannot be too +distinctly emphasized, that the links that bind together the forms of +erotic symbolism are not to be found in objects or even in acts, but in +the underlying emotion. A feeling is the first condition of the symbol, a +feeling which recalls, by a subtle and unconscious automatic association +of resemblance or of contiguity, some former feeling. It is the similarity +of emotion, instinctively apprehended, which links on a symbol only +partially sexual, or even apparently not sexual at all, to the great +central focus of sexual emotion, the great dominating force which brings +the symbol its life-blood.[71] + +The cases of sexual hyperaesthesia, quoted at the beginning of this study, +do but present in a morbidly comprehensive and sensitive form those +possibilities of erotic symbolism which, in some degree, or at some +period, are latent in most persons. They are genuinely instinctive and +automatic, and have nothing in common with that fanciful and deliberate +play of the intelligence around sexual imagery--not infrequently seen in +abnormal and insane persons--which has no significance for sexual +psychology. + +It is to the extreme individualization involved by the developments of +erotic symbolism that the fetichist owes his morbid and perilous +isolation. The lover who is influenced by all the elements of sexual +selection is always supported by the fellow-feeling of a larger body of +other human beings; he has behind him his species, his sex, his nation, or +at the very least a fashion. Even the inverted lover in most cases is soon +able to create around him an atmosphere constituted by persons whose +ideals resemble his own. But it is not so with the erotic symbolist. He is +nearly always alone. He is predisposed to isolation from the outset, for +it would seem to be on a basis of excessive shyness and timidity that the +manifestations of erotic symbolism are most likely to develop. When at +length the symbolist realizes his own aspirations--which seem to him for +the most part an altogether new phenomenon in the world--and at the same +time realizes the wide degree in which they deviate from those of the rest +of mankind, his natural secretiveness is still further reinforced. He +stands alone. His most sacred ideals are for all those around him a +childish absurdity, or a disgusting obscenity, possibly a matter calling +for the intervention of the policeman. We have forgotten that all these +impulses which to us seem so unnatural--this adoration of the foot and +other despised parts of the body, this reverence for the excretory acts +and products, the acceptance of congress with animals, the solemnity of +self-exhibition--were all beliefs and practices which, to our remote +forefathers, were bound up with the highest conceptions of life and the +deepest ardors of religion. + +A man cannot, however, deviate at once so widely and so spontaneously in +his impulses from the rest of the world in which he himself lives without +possessing an aboriginally abnormal temperament. At the very least he +exhibits a neuropathic sensitiveness to abnormal impressions. Not +infrequently there is more than this, the distinct stigmata of +degeneration, sometimes a certain degree of congenital feeble-mindedness +or a tendency to insanity. + +Yet, regarded as a whole, and notwithstanding the frequency with which +they witness to congenital morbidity, the phenomena of erotic symbolism +can scarcely fail to be profoundly impressive to the patient and impartial +student of the human soul. They often seem absurd, sometimes disgusting, +occasionally criminal; they are always, when carried to an extreme degree, +abnormal. But of all the manifestations of sexual psychology, normal and +abnormal, they are the most specifically human. More than any others they +involve the potently plastic force of the imagination. They bring before +us the individual man, not only apart from his fellows, but in opposition, +himself creating his own paradise. They constitute the supreme triumph of +human idealism. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[64] Binet, _Etudes de Psychologie Experimentale_, esp., p. 84; +Krafft-Ebing, _Op. cit._, p. 18. + +[65] G. Tarde, "L'Amour Morbide," _Archives de l'Anthropologie +Criminelle_, 1890, p. 585. + +[66] Lucretius, Lib. IV, vv. 1150-1163. + +[67] Burton, _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. III, +Subs. I. + +[68] Judith Cladel, _Auguste Rodin Pris sur la Vie_, 1903, pp. 103-104. +Some slight modifications have been made in the translation of this +passage on account of the conversational form of the original. + +[69] W. Cyples, _The Process of Human Experience_, p. 462. Even if (as we +have already seen, _ante_, p. 58) the saint cannot always feel actual +physical pleasure in the intimate contact of humanity, the ardor of +devoted service which his vision of humanity arouses remains unaffected. + +[70] "To love," as Stendhal defined it (_De l'Amour_, Chapter II), "is to +have pleasure in seeing, touching, and feeling by all the senses, and as +near as possible, a beloved object by whom one is oneself loved." + +[71] Pillon's study of "La Memoire Affective" (_Revue Philosophique_, +February, 1901) helps to explain the psychic mechanism of the process. + + + + +THE MECHANISM OF DETUMESCENCE. + +I. + +The Psychological Significance of Detumescence--The Testis and the +Ovary--Sperm Cell and Germ Cell--Development of the Embryo--The External +Sexual Organs--Their Wide Range of Variation--Their Nervous Supply--The +Penis--Its Racial Variations--The Influence of Exercise--The Scrotum and +Testicles--The Mons Veneris--The Vulva--The Labia Majora and their +Varieties--The Pubic Hair and Its Characters--The Clitoris and Its +Functions--The Anus as an Erogenous Zone--The Nymphae and their +Function--The Vagina--The Hymen--Virginity--The Biological Significance of +the Hymen. + + +In analyzing the sexual impulse we have seen that the process whereby the +conjunction of the sexes is achieved falls naturally into two phases: the +first phase, of tumescence, during which force is generated in the +organism, and the second phase, of detumescence, in which that force is +discharged during conjugation.[72] Hitherto we have been occupied mainly +with the first phase, that of tumescence, and with its associated psychic +phenomena. It was inevitable that this should be so, for it is during the +slow process of tumescence that sexual selection is decided, the +crystallizations of love elaborated, and, to a large extent, the +individual erotic symbols determined. But we can by no means altogether +pass over the final phase of detumescence. Its consideration, it is true, +brings us directly into the field of anatomy and physiology; while +tumescence is largely under control of the will, when the moment of +detumescence arrives the reins slip from the control of the will; the more +fundamental and uncontrollable impulses of the organism gallop on +unchecked; the chariot of Phaethon dashes blindly down into a sea of +emotion. + +Yet detumescence is the end and climax of the whole drama; it is an +anatomico-physiological process, certainly, but one that inevitably +touches psychology at every point.[73] It is, indeed, the very key to the +process of tumescence, and unless we understand and realize very precisely +what it is that happens during detumescence, our psychological analysis of +the sexual impulse must remain vague and inadequate. + +From the point of view we now occupy, a man and a woman are no longer two +highly sensitive organisms vibrating, voluptuously it may indeed be, but +vaguely and indefinitely, to all kinds of influences and with fluctuating +impulses capable of being directed into any channel, even in the highest +degree divergent from the proper ends of procreation. They are now two +genital organisms who exist to propagate the race, and whatever else they +may be, they must be adequately constituted to effect the act by which the +future of the race is ensured. We have to consider what are the material +conditions which ensure the most satisfactory and complete fulfillment of +this act, and how those conditions may be correlated with other +circumstances in the organism. In thus approaching the subject we shall +find that we have not really abandoned the study of the psychic aspects of +sex. + +The two most primary sexual organs are the testis and the ovary; it is the +object of conjugation to bring into contact the sperm from the testis with +the germ from the ovary. There is no reason to suppose that the germ-cell +and the sperm-cell are essentially different from each other. Sexual +conjugation thus remains a process which is radically the same as the +non-sexual mode of propagation which preceded it. The fusion of the nuclei +of the two cells was regarded by Van Beneden, who in 1875 first accurately +described it, as a process of conjugation comparable to that of the +protozoa and the protophyta. Boveri, who has further extended our +knowledge of the process, considers that the spermatozoon removes an +inhibitory influence preventing the commencement of development in the +ovum; the spermatozoon replaces a portion of the ovum which has already +undergone degeneration, so that the object of conjugation is chiefly to +effect the union of the properties of two cells in one, sexual +fertilization achieving a division of labor with reciprocal inhibition; +the two cells have renounced their original faculty of separate +development in order to attain a fusion of qualities and thus render +possible that production of new forms and qualities which has involved the +progress of the organized world.[74] + +While in fishes this conjugation of the male and female elements is +usually ensured by the female casting her spawn into an artificial nest +outside the body, on to which the male sheds his milt, in all animals +(and, to some extent, birds, who occupy an intermediate position) there is +an organic nest, or incubation chamber as Bland Sutton terms it, the womb, +in the female body, wherein the fertilized egg may develop to a high +degree of maturity sheltered from those manifold risks of the external +world which make it necessary for the spawn of fishes to be so enormous in +amount. Since, however, men and women have descended from remote ancestors +who, in the manner of aquatic creatures, exercised functions of +sperm-extrusion and germ-extrusion that were exactly analogous in the two +sexes, without any specialized female uterine organization, the early +stages of human male and female foetal development still display the +comparatively undifferentiated sexual organization of those remote +ancestors, and during the first months of foetal life it is practically +impossible to tell by the inspection of the genital regions whether the +embryo would have developed into a man or into a woman. If we examine the +embryo at an early stage of development we see that the hind end is the +body stalk, this stalk in later stages becoming part of the umbilical +cord. The urogenital region, formed by the rapid extension of the hind +end beyond its original limit, which corresponds to what is later the +umbilicus, develops mainly by the gradual differentiation of structures +(the Wolffian and Muellerian bodies) which originally exist identically in +both sexes. This process of sexual differentiation is highly complex, so +that it cannot yet be said that there is complete agreement among +investigators as to its details. When some irregularity or arrest of +development occurs in the process we have one or other of the numerous +malformations which may affect this region. If the arrest occurs at a very +early stage we may even find a condition of things which seems to +approximate to that which normally exists in the adult reptilia.[75] Owing +to the fact that both male and female organs develop from more primitive +structures which were sexually undifferentiated, a fundamental analogy in +the sexual organs of the sexes always remains; the developed organs of one +sex exist as rudiments in the other sex; the testicles correspond to the +ovaries; the female clitoris is the homologue of the male penis; the +scrotum of one sex is the labia majora in the other sex, and so +throughout, although it is not always possible at present to be quite +certain in regard to these homologics. + +Since the object to be attained by the sexual organs in the human species +is identical with that which they subserve in their pre-human ancestors, +it is not surprising to find that these structures have a clear +resemblance to the corresponding structures in the apes, although on the +whole there would appear to be in man a higher degree of sexual +differentiation. Thus the uterus of various species of _semnopithecus_ +seems to show a noteworthy correspondence with the same organ in +woman.[76] The somewhat less degree of sexual differentiation is well +shown in the gorilla; in the male the external organs are in the passive +state covered by the wrinkled skin of the abdomen, while in the female, +on the contrary, they are very apparent, and in sexual excitement the +large clitoris and nymphae become markedly prominent. The penis of the +gorilla, however, more nearly resembles that of man, according to +Hartmann, than does that of the other anthropoid apes, which diverge from +the human type in this respect more than do the cynocephalic apes and some +species of baboon. + +From the psychological point of view we are less interested in the +internal sexual organs, which are most fundamentally concerned with the +production and reception of the sexual elements, than with the more +external parts of the genital apparatus which serve as the instruments of +sexual excitation, and the channels for the intromission and passage of +the seminal fluid. It is these only which can play any part at all in +sexual selection; they are the only part of the sexual apparatus which can +enter into the formation of either normal or abnormal erotic conceptions; +they are the organs most prominently concerned with detumescence; they +alone enter normally into the conscious process of sex at any time. It +seems desirable, therefore, to discuss them briefly at this point. + + Our knowledge of the individual and racial variations of the + external sexual organs is still extremely imperfect. A few + monographs and collections of data on isolated points may be + found in more or less inaccessible publications. As regards + women, Ploss and Bartels have devoted a chapter to the sexual + organs of women which extends to a hundred pages, but remains + scanty and fragmentary. (_Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter VI.) The + most systematic series of observations have been made in the case + of the various kinds of degenerates--idiots, the insane, + criminals, etc.--but it would be obviously unsafe to rely too + absolutely on such investigations for our knowledge of the sexual + organs of the ordinary population. + + There can be no doubt, however, that the external sexual organs + in normal men and women exhibit a peculiarly wide range of + variation. This is indicated not only by the unsystematic results + attained by experienced observers, but also by more systematic + studies. Thus Herman has shown by detailed measurements that + there are great normal variations in the conformation of the + parts that form the floor of the female pelvis. He found that the + projection of the pelvic floor varied from nothing to as much as + two inches, and that in healthy women who had borne no children + the distance between the coccyx and anus, the length of the + perineum, the distance between the fourchette and the symphysis + pubis, and the length of the vagina are subject to wide + variations. (_Lancet_, October 12, 1889.) Even the female + urethral opening varies very greatly, as has been shown by Bergh, + who investigated it in nearly 700 women and reproduces the + various shapes found; while most usually (in about a third of the + cases observed), a longitudinal slit, it may be cross-shaped, + star-shaped, crescentic, etc.; and while sometimes very small, in + about 6 per cent. of the cases it admitted the tip of the little + finger. (Bergh, _Monatsheft fuer Praktische Dermatologie_, 15 + Sept., 1897.) + + As regards both sexes, Stanley Hall states that "Dr. F.N. + Seerley, who has examined over 2000 normal young men as well as + many young women, tells me that in his opinion individual + variations in these parts are much greater even than those of + face and form, and that the range of adult and apparently normal + size and proportion, as well as function, and of both the age and + order of development, not only of each of the several parts + themselves, but of all their immediate annexes, and in females as + well as males, is far greater than has been recognized by any + writer. This fact is the basis of the anxieties and fears of + morphological abnormality so frequent during adolescence." (G.S. + Hall, _Adolescence_, vol. i, p. 414). + +In accordance with the supreme importance of the part they play, and the +intimately psychic nature of that part, the sexual organs, both internal +and external, are very richly supplied with nerves. While the internal +organs are very abundantly furnished with sympathetic nerves and ganglia, +the external organs show the highest possible degree of specialization of +the various peripheral nervous devices which the organism has developed +for receiving, accumulating, and transmitting stimuli to the brain.[77] + + "The number of conducting cords which attach the genitals to the + nervous centers is simply enormous," writes Bryan Robinson; "the + pudic nerve is composed of nearly all the third sacral and + branches from the second and fourth sacral. As one examines this + nerve he is forced to the conclusion that it is an enormous + supply for a small organ. The periphery of the pudic nerve + spreads itself like a fan over the genitals." The lesser sciatic + nerve supplies only one muscle--the gluteus maximus--and then + sends the large pudendal branch to the side of the penis, and + hence the friction of coitus induces active contraction of the + gluteus maximus, "the main muscle of coition." The large pudic + and the pudendal constitute the main supply of the external + genitals. In women the pudic nerve is equally large, but the + pudendal much smaller, possibly, Bryan Robinson suggests, because + women take a less active part in coitus. The nerve supply of the + clitoris, however, is three or four times as large as that of the + penis in proportion to size. (F.B. Robinson, "The Intimate + Nervous Connection of the Genito-Urinary Organs With the + Cerebro-Spinal and Sympathetic Systems," _New York Medical + Journal_, March 11, 1893; id., _The Abdominal Brain_, 1899.) + +Of all the sexual organs the penis is without doubt that which has most +powerfully impressed the human imagination. It is the very emblem of +generation, and everywhere men have contemplated it with a mixture of +reverence and shuddering awe that has sometimes, even among civilized +peoples, amounted to horror and disgust. Its image is worn as an amulet to +ward off evil and invoked as a charm to call forth blessing. The sexual +organs were once the most sacred object on which a man could place his +hands to swear an inviolate oath, just as now he takes up the Testament. +Even in the traditions of the great classic civilization which we inherit +the penis is _fascinus_, the symbol of all fascination. In the history of +human culture it has had far more than a merely human significance; it has +been the symbol of all the generative force of Nature, the embodiment of +creative energy in the animal and vegetable worlds alike, an image to be +held aloft for worship, the sign of all unconscious ecstasy. As a symbol, +the sacred phallus, it has been woven in and out of all the highest and +deepest human conceptions, so intimately that it is possible to see it +everywhere, that it is possible to fail to see it anywhere. + +In correspondence with the importance of the penis is the large number of +names which men have everywhere bestowed upon it. In French literature +many hundred synonyms may be found. They were also numerous in Latin. In +English the literary terms for the penis seem to be comparatively few, but +a large number of non-literary synonyms exist in colloquial and perhaps +merely local usage. The Latin term penis, which has established itself +among us as the most correct designation, is generally considered to be +associated with _pendere_ and to be connected therefore with the usually +pendent position of the organ. In the middle ages the general literary +term throughout Europe was _coles_ (or _colis_) from _caulis_, a stalk, +and _virga_, a rod. The only serious English literary term, yard (exactly +equivalent to _virga_), as used by Chaucer--almost the last great English +writer whose vocabulary was adequate to the central facts of life--has now +fallen out of literary and even colloquial usage. + + Pierer and Chaulant, in their anatomical and physiological + _Real-Lexicon_ (vol. vi, p. 134), give nearly a hundred synonyms + for the penis. Hyrtl (_Topographisches Anatomie_, seventh + edition, vol. ii, pp. 67-69), adds others. Schurig, in his + _Spermatologia_ (1720, pp. 89-91), also presents a number of + names for the penis; in Chapter III (pp. 189-192) of the same + book he discusses the penis generally with more fullness than + most authors. Louis de Landes, in his _Glossaire Erotique_ of the + French language (pp. 239-242), enumerates several hundred + literary synonyms for the penis, though many of them probably + only occur once. + + There is no thorough and comprehensive modern study of the penis + on an anthropological basis (though I should mention a valuable + and fully illustrated study of anthropological and pathological + variations of the penis in a series of articles by Marandon de + Montyel, "Des Anomalies des Organs Genitaux Externes Chez les + Alienees," etc., _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, 1895), + and it would be out of place here to attempt to collect the + scattered notices regarding racial and other variations. It may + suffice to note some of the evidence showing that such variations + seem to be numerous and important. The Arab penis (according to + Kocher) is slender and long (a third longer than the average + European penis) and with a club-shaped glans. It undergoes little + change when it enters the erect state. The clothes leaves it + quite free, and the Arab practices manual excitement at an early + age to favor its development. + + Among the Fuegians, also, according to Hyades and Deniker (_Cap + Horn_, vol. vii, p. 153), the average length of the penis is 77 + millimeters, which is longer than in Europeans. + + In men of black race, also, the penis is decidedly large. Thus + Sir H.H. Johnston (_British Central Africa_, p. 399) states this + to be a universal rule. Among the Wankenda of Northern Nyassa, + for instance, he remarks that, while the body is of medium size, + the penis is generally large. He gives the usual length as about + six inches, reaching nine or ten in erection. The prepuce, it is + added, is often very long, and circumcision is practiced by many + tribes. + + Among the American negroes Hrdlicka has found, also (_Proceedings + American Association for the Advancement of Science_, vol. xlvii, + p. 475), that the penis in black boys is larger than in white + boys. + + The passages cited above suggest the question whether the penis + becomes larger by exercise of its generative functions. Most old + authors assert that frequent erection makes the penis large and + long (Schurig, _Spermatologia_, p. 107). Galen noted that in + singers and athletes, who were chaste in order to preserve their + strength, the sexual parts were small and rugrose, like those of + old men, and that exercise of the organs from youth develops + them; Roubaud, quoting this observation (_Traite de + l'Impuissance_, p. 373), agrees with the statement. It seems + probable that there is an element of truth in this ancient + belief. At the same time it must be remembered that the penis is + only to small extent a muscular organ, and that the increase of + size produced by frequent congestion of erectile tissues cannot + be either rapid or pronounced. Variations in the size of the + sexual organs are probably on the whole mainly inherited, though + it is impossible to speak decisively on this point until more + systematic observations become customary. + +The scrotum has usually, in the human imagination, been regarded merely as +an appendage of the penis, of secondary importance, although it is the +garment of the primary and essential organs of sex, and the fact that it +is not the seat of any voluptuous sensation has doubtless helped to +confirm this position. Even the name is merely a mediaeval perversion of +_scortum_, skin or hide. In classic times it was usually called the pouch +or purse. The importance of the testicles has not, however, been +altogether ignored, as the very word _testis_ itself shows, for the +_testis_ is simply the _witness_ of virility.[78] + +It is easy to understand why the penis should occupy this special place in +man's thoughts as the supreme sexual organ. It is the one conspicuous and +prominent portion of the sexual apparatus, while its aptitude for swelling +and erecting itself involuntarily, under the influence of sexual emotion, +gives it a peculiar and almost unique position in the body. At the same +time it is the point at which, in the male body, all voluptuous sensation +is concentrated, the only normal masculine center of sex.[79] + +It is not easy to find any correspondingly conspicuous symbol of sex in +the sexual region of women. In the normal position nothing is visible but +the peculiarly human cushion of fat picturesquely termed the Mons Veneris +(because, as Palfyn said, all those who enroll themselves under the banner +of Venus must necessarily scale it), and even that is veiled from view in +the adult by the more or less bushy plantation of hair which grows upon +it. A triangle of varyingly precise definition is thus formed at the lower +apex of the trunk, and this would sometimes appear to have been regarded +as a feminine symbol.[80] But the more usual and typical symbol of +femininity is the idealized ring (by some savages drawn as a lozenge) of +the vulvar opening--the _yoni_ corresponding to the masculine +_lingam_--which is normally closed from view by the larger lips arising +from beneath the shadow of the _mons_. It is a symbol that, like the +masculine phallus, has a double meaning among primitive peoples and is +sometimes used to call down a blessing and sometimes to invoke a +curse.[81] + +This external opening of the feminine genital passage with its two +enclosing lips is now generally called the vulva. It would appear that +originally (as by Celsus and Pliny) this term included the womb, also, but +when the term "uterus" came into use "vulva" was confined (as its sense of +folding doors suggests that it should be) to the external entrance. The +classic term _cunnus_ for the external genitals was chiefly used by the +poets; it has been the etymological source of various European names for +this region, such as the old French _con_, which has now, however, +disappeared from literature while even in popular usage it has given place +to _lapin_ and similar terms. But there is always a tendency, marked in +most parts of the world, for the names of the external female parts to +become indecorous. Even in classic antiquity this part was the _pudendum_, +the part to be ashamed of, and among ourselves the mass of the +population, still preserving the traditions of primitive times, continue +to cherish the same notion. + + The anatomy, anthropology, folk-lore, and terminology of the + external and to some extent the internal feminine sexual region + may be studied in the following publications, among others: + Ploss, _Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter VI; Hyrtl, _Topographisches + Anatomie_, vol. ii, and other publications by the same scholarly + anatomist; W.J. Stewart Mackay, _History of Ancient Gynaecology_, + especially pp. 244-250; R. Bergh, "Symbolae ad Cognitionem + Genitalium Externorum Foeminearum" (in Danish), + _Hospitalstidende_, August, 1894; and also in _Monatshefte fuer + Praktische Dermatologie_, 1897. D.S. Lamb, "The Female External + Genital Organs," _New York Journal of Gynaecology_, August, 1894; + R.L. Dickinson, "Hypertrophies of the Labia Minora and Their + Significance," _American Gynecology_, September, 1902; Kryptadia + (in various languages), vol. viii, pp. 3-11, 11-13, and many + other passages. Several of Schurig's works (especially + _Gynaecologia_, _Muliebria_, and _Parthenologia_) contain full + summaries of the statements of the early writers. + +The external or larger lips, like the mons veneris, are specifically human +in their full development, for in the anthropoid apes they are small as is +the mons, and in the lower apes absent altogether; they are, moreover, +larger in the white than in the other human races. Thus in the negro, and +to a less degree in the Japanese (Wernich) and the Javanese (Scherzer) +they are less developed than in women of white race. The greater lips +develop in the foetus later than the lesser lips, which are thus at first +uncovered; this condition thus constitutes an infantile state which +occasionally (in less than 2 per cent. of cases, according to Bergh) +persists in the adult. Their generally accepted name, labia majora, is +comparatively modern.[82] + + The outer sides of the labia majora are covered with hair, and on + the inner sides, which are smooth and moist, but are not true + mucous membrane, there are a few sweat glands and numerous large + sebaceous glands. Bergh considers that there is little or no hair + on the inner sides of the labia majora, but Lamb states that + careful examination shows that from one- to two-thirds of the + inner surface in adult women show hairs like those of the + external surface. In brunettes and women of dark races this + surface is pigmented; in dark races it is usually a slate gray. + From an examination of 2200 young Danish prostitutes Bergh has + found that there are two main varieties in the shape of the labia + majora, with transitional forms. In the first and most frequent + form the labia tend to be less marked and more effaced and + separated at the upper and anterior part, often being lost in the + sides of the mons and presenting a fissure which is broader in + its upper part and showing the inner lips more or less bare. In + the second form the labia are thicker and more outstanding and + the inner edges lie in contact throughout their whole length, + showing the _rima pudendi_ as a long narrow fissure. Whatever the + form, the labia close more tightly together in virgins and in + young individuals generally than in the deflowered and the + elderly. In children, as Martineau pointed out, the vulva appears + to look directly forward and the clitoris and urinary meatus + easily appear, while in adult women, and especially after + attempts at coitus have been made, the vulva appears directed + more below and behind, and the clitoris and meatus more covered + by the labia majora; so that the child urinates forward, while + the adult woman is usually able to urinate almost directly + downwards in the erect position, though in some cases (as may + occasionally be observed in the street) she can only do so when + bending slightly forwards. This difference in the direction of + the stream formerly furnished one of the methods of diagnosing + virginity, an uncertain one, since the difference is largely due + to age and individual variation. The main factor in the position + and aspect of the vulva is pelvic inclination. (See Havelock + Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, p. 64; Stratz, _Die + Schoenheit des Weiblichen Koerpers_, Chapter XII.) In the European + woman, according to Stratz, a considerable degree of pelvic + inclination is essential to beauty, concealing all but the + anterior third of the vulva. In negresses and other women of + lower race the vulva, however, usually lies further back, being + more conspicuous from behind than in European women; in this + respect lower races resemble the apes. Those women of dark race, + therefore, whose modesty is focused behind rather than in front + thus have sound anatomical considerations on their side. + + As Ploss and Bartels remark, a very common variation among + European women consists in an unusually posterior position of the + vulva and vaginal entrance, so that unless a cushion is placed + under the buttocks it is difficult for the man to effect coitus + in the usual position without giving much pain to the woman. They + add that another anomaly, less easy to remedy, consists in an + abnormally anterior position of the vaginal entrance close + beneath the pelvic bone, so that, although intromission is easy, + the spasmodic contraction of the vagina at the culmination of + orgasm presses the penis against the bone and causes intolerable + pain to the man. + +The mons veneris and the labia majora are, after the age of puberty, +always normally covered by a more or less profuse growth of hair. It is +notable that the apes, notwithstanding their general tendency to +hairiness, show no such special development of hair in this region. We +thus see that all the external and more conspicuous portions of the sexual +sphere in woman--the mons veneris, the labia majora, and the +hair--represent not so much an animal inheritance, such as we commonly +misrepresent them to be, but a higher and genuinely human development. As +none of these structures subserve any clear practical use, it would appear +that they must have developed by sexual selection to satisfy the aesthetic +demands of the eye.[83] + + The character and arrangement of the pubic hair, investigated by + Eschricht and Voigt more than half a century ago, have been more + recently studied by Bergh. As these observers have pointed out, + there are various converging hair streams from above and below, + the clitoris seeming to be the center towards which they are + directed. The hair-covering thus formed is usually ample and, as + a rule, is more so in brunettes than in blondes. It is nearly + always bent, curly and more or less spirally twisted.[84] There + are frequently one or two curls at the commencement of the + fissure, rolled outwards, and occasionally a well marked tuft in + the middle line. In abundance the pubic hair corresponds with the + axillary hair; when one region is defective in hair the other is + usually so also. Strong eyebrows also usually indicate a strong + development of pubic hair. But the hair of the head usually + varies independently, and Bergh found that of 154 women with + spare pubic hair 72 had good and often profuse hair on the head. + Complete or almost complete absence of pubic hair is in Bergh's + experience only found in about 3 per cent. of women; these were + all young and blonde. + +Rothe, in his investigation of the pubic hair of 1000 Berlin women, found +that no two women were really alike in this respect, but there was a +tendency to two main types of arrangement, with minor subdivisions, +according as the hair tended to grow chiefly in the middle line extending +laterally from that line, or to grow equally over the whole extent of the +pubic region; these two groups included half the cases investigated. + + In men the pubic hair normally ascends anteriorly in a faint line + up to the navel, with tendency to form a triangle with the apex + above, and posteriorly extends backwards to the anus. In women + these anterior and posterior extensions are comparatively rare, + or at all events are only represented by a few stray hairs. Rothe + found this variation in 4 per cent. of North German women, though + a triangle of hair was only found in 2 per cent.; Lombroso found + it in 5 per cent, of Italian women; Bergh found it in only 1.6 + per cent. among 1000 Danish prostitutes, all sixteen of whom with + three exceptions were brunettes. In Vienna, among 600 women, Coe + found only 1 per cent, with this distribution of hair, and states + that they were women of decidedly masculine type, though Ploss + and Bartels, as well as Rothe, find, however, that heterogeny, as + they term the masculine distribution, is more common in blondes. + The anterior extension of hair is usually accompanied by the + posterior extension around the anus, usually very slight, but + occasionally as pronounce as in men. (According to Rothe, + however, anterior heterogeny comparatively rare.) These masculine + variations in the extension of the pubic hair appear to be not + uncommonly associated with other physical and psychic anomalies; + it is on this account that they have sometimes been regarded as + indications of a vicious or a criminal temperament; they are, + however, found in quite normal women. + + The pubic hair of women is usually shorter than that of men, but + thick, and the individual hairs stronger and larger in diameter + than those of men, as Pfaff first showed; dark hair is usually + stronger than light. In both length and size the individual + variations are considerable. The usual length is about 2 inches, + or 3-5 centimeters, occasionally reaching about 4 inches, or 9-10 + centimeters, in the larger curls. In a series of 100 women + attended during confinement in London and the north of England I + have only once (in a rather blonde Lancashire woman) found the + hair on labia reaching a conspicuous length of several inches and + forming an obstruction to the manipulations involved in delivery. + But Jahn delivered a woman whose pubic hair was longer than that + of her head, reaching below her knee; Paulini also knew a woman + whose pubic hair nearly reached her knees and was sold to make + wigs; Bartholin mentions a soldier's wife who plaited her pubic + hair behind her back; while Brantome has several references to + abnormally long hair in ladies of the French court during the + sixteenth century. In 8 cases out of 2200 Bergh found the pubic + hair forming a large curly wig extending to the iliac spines. The + individual hairs have occasionally been found so stiff and + brush-like as to render coitus difficult. + + In color the pubic hair, while generally approximating to that of + the head, is sometimes (according to Rothe, in Germany, in + one-third cases) lighter, and sometimes somewhat darker, as is + found to be the case by Coe, especially in brunettes, and also by + Bergh, in Denmark. Bergh remarks that it is generally + intermediate in color between the eyebrows and the axillary hair, + the latter being more or less decolorized by sweat, and that, + owing to the influence of the urine and vaginal discharges, the + labial hair is paler than that on the mons; blondes with dark + eyebrows usually have dark hair on the mons. The hair on this + spot, as Aristotle observed, is usually the last to turn gray. + +The key to the genital apparatus in women from the psychic point of view, +and, indeed, to some extent, its anatomical center, is to be found in the +clitoris. Anatomically and developmentally the clitoris is the rudimentary +analogue of the masculine penis. Functionally, however, its scope is very +much smaller. While the penis both receives and imparts specific +voluptuous sensations, and is at the same time both the intromittent organ +for the semen and the conduit for the urine, the sole function of the +clitoris is to enter into erection under the stress of sexual emotion and +receive and transmit the stimulatory voluptuous sensations imparted to it +by friction with the masculine genital apparatus. It is so insignificant +an organ that it is only within recent times that its homology with the +penis has been realized. In 1844 Kobelt wrote in his important book, _Die +Mannlichen und Weiblichen Wollust-Organe_, that in his attempt to show +that the female organs are exactly analogous to the male the reader will +probably be unable to follow him, while even Johannes Mueller, the father +of scientific physiology, declared at about the same period that the +clitoris is essentially different from the penis. It is indeed but three +centuries since the clitoris was so little known that (in 1593) Realdus +Columbus actually claimed the honor of discovering it. Columbus was not +its discoverer, for Fallopius speedily showed that Avicenna and Albucasis +had referred to it.[85] The Arabs appear to have been very familiar with +it, and, from the various names they gave it, clearly understood the +important part it plays in generating voluptuous emotion.[86] But it was +known in classic antiquity; the Greeks called it myrton, the myrtle-berry; +Galen and Soranus called it nymphe because it is covered as a bride is +veiled, while the old Latin name was _tentigo_, from its power of entering +into erection, and _columella_, the little pillar, from its shape. The +modern term, which is Greek and refers to the sensitiveness of the part to +voluptuous titillation, is said to have originated with Suidas and +Pollux.[87] It was mentioned, though not adopted, by Rufus. + +"The clitoris," declared Haller, "is a part extremely sensible and +wonderfully prurient." It is certainly the chief though by no means the +only point through which the immediate call to detumescence is conveyed to +the female organism. It is, indeed, as Bryan Robinson remarks, "a +veritable electrical bell button which, being pressed or irritated, rings +up the whole nervous system." + + The nervous supply of this little organ is very large, and the + dorsal nerve of the clitoris is relatively three or four times + larger than that of the penis. Yet the sensitive point of this + organ is only 5 to 7 millimeters in extent. The length of the + clitoris is usually rather over 2 centimeters (or about an inch) + and 3 centimeters when erect; a length of 4 centimeters or more + was regarded by Martineau as within the normal range of + variation. It is not usual to find the clitoris longer than this + in Europe (for among some races like the negro the clitoris is + generally large), but all degrees of magnitude may be found as + rare exceptions. (See, e.g., Sir J.Y. Simpson, "Hermaphrodites," + _Obstetric Memoirs and Contributions_, vol. ii, pp. 217-226; also + Dickinson, loc. cit.) It was formerly thought that the clitoris + is easily enlarged by masturbation, and Martineau believed that + in this way it might be doubled in length. It is probable that + slight enlargement of the clitoris may be caused by very + frequent masturbation, but only to an insignificant extent, and + it is impossible to diagnose masturbation from the size of the + clitoris. Among the women of Lake Nyassa, as well as in the + Caroline Islands, special methods are practiced for elongating + the clitoris, but in Europe, at all events, it is probable that + the variations in the size of the organ are mainly congenital. It + may well be that a congenitally large clitoris is associated with + an abnormally developed excitability of the sexual apparatus. + Tilt stated (_On Uterine and Ovarian Inflammation_, p. 37) that + in his experience there was a frequent though not invariable + connection between a large clitoris and sexual proclivity. + (Schurig referred to a case of intense and life-long sexual + obsession associated with an extremely large clitoris, + _Gynaecologia_, pp. 16-17.) Of recent years considerable + importance has been attached by some gynecologists (e.g., R.T. + Morris, "Is Evolution Trying to Do Away With the Clitoris?" + _Transactions American Association of Obstetricians and + Gynecologists_, vol. v, 1893) to preputial adhesions around the + clitoris as a source of nervous disturbance and invalidism in + young women. + +While the clitoris is anatomically analogous to the penis, its actual +mechanism under the stress of sexual excitement is somewhat different. As +Lietaud long since pointed out, it cannot rise freely in erection as the +penis can; it is apparently bound down by its prepuce and its frenulum. +Waldeyer, in his book on the pelvis, states more precisely that, unlike +the penis, when erect it retains its angle, only this becomes somewhat +rounded so that the organ is to some slight extent lifted and protruded. +Waldeyer considered that the clitoris was thus perfectly fitted to fulfill +its part as the recipient of erotic stimulation from friction by the +penis. Adler, however, has pointed out with considerable justice, that +this is not altogether the case. The clitoris was developed in mammals who +practiced the posterior mode of coitus; in this position the clitoris was +beneath the penis, which was thus easily able in coitus to press it +against the pubic bone close beneath which it is situated, and thus impart +the compression and friction which the feminine organ craves. But in the +human anterior mode of coitus it is not necessarily brought into close +contact with the penis during the act of coitus, and thus fails to receive +powerful stimulation. Its restricted position, which is an advantage in +posterior coitus, is a disadvantage in anterior coitus. Adler observes +that it thus comes about that the human method of coitus, while by +bringing breast to breast and face to face it has added a new dignity and +refinement, a fresh source of enjoyment, to the embrace of the sexes, has +not been an unmixed advantage to woman, for while man has lost nothing by +the change, woman has now to contend with an increased difficulty in +attaining an adequate amount of pressure on that "electric button" which +normally sets the whole mechanism in operation.[88] + +We may well bring into connection with the changed conditions brought +about by anterior coitus the interesting fact that while the clitoris +remains the most exquisitely sensitive of the sexual centers in woman, +voluptuous sensitivity is much more widely diffused in woman than in man. +Over the whole body, indeed, it is apt to be more distinctly marked than +is usually the case in man. But even if we confine ourselves to the +genital region, while in man that portion of the penis which enters the +vagina, and especially the glans, is normally the only portion which, even +during turgescence, is sensitive to voluptuous contacts, in woman the +whole of the region comprised within the larger lips, including even the +anus and internally the vagina and the vaginal portion of the womb,[89] +become sensitive to voluptuous contacts. Deprived of the penis the ability +of a man to experience specifically sexual sensations becomes very limited +indeed. But the loss of the clitoris or of any other structure involves no +correspondingly serious disability on women. Ablation of the clitoris for +sexual hyperaesthesia has for this reason been abandoned, except under +special circumstances. The members of the Russian Skoptzy sect habitually +amputate the clitoris, nymphae, and breasts, yet many young Skoptzy women +told the Russian physician, Guttceit, that they were perfectly well able +to enjoy coitus. + + Freud believes that in very young girls the clitoris is the + exclusive seat of sexual sensation, masturbation at this age + being directed to the clitoris alone, and spontaneous sexual + excitement being confined to twitchings and erection of this + organ, so that young girls are able, from their own experience, + to recognize without instruction the signs of sexual excitement + in boys. At a later age sexual excitability spreads from the + clitoris to other regions--just as the easy inflammability of + wood sets light to coal--though in the male the penis remains + from first to last normally the almost exclusive seat of specific + excitability. (S. Freud, _Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie_, + p. 62.) + + The anus would, however, seem to be sometimes an erogenous zone + even at an early age. Titillation of the anus appears to be + frequently pleasurable in women; and this is not surprising + considering the high degree of erotic sensitivity which is easily + developed at the body orifices where skin meets mucous membrane. + (Thus the meatus of the urethra is a highly erogenous zone, as is + sufficiently shown by the frequency with which hair-pins and + other articles used in masturbation find their way into the + bladder.) It is in this germinal sensitivity, undoubtedly, that + we find a chief key to the practice of _pedicatio_. Freud + attaches great importance to the anus as a sexually erogenous + zone at a very early age, and considers that it very frequently + makes its influence felt in this respect. He believes that + intestinal catarrhs in very early life and haemorrhoids later tend + to develop sensibility in the anus. He finds an indication that + the anus has become a sexually erogenous zone when children wish + to allow the contents of the rectum to accumulate so that + defecation may by its increased difficulty involve voluptuous + sensations, and adds that masturbatory excitation of the anus + with the fingers is by no means rare in older children. (S. + Freud, _Op. cit._, pp. 40-42.) A medical correspondent in India + tells me of a European lady who derived, she said, "quite as + much, indeed more," pleasure from digitally titillating her + rectum as from vulvo-vaginal titillation; she had several times + submitted to _pedicatio_ and enjoyed it, though it was painful + during penetration. The anus may retain this erogenous + irritability even in old age, and Routh mentions the case of a + lady of over 70, the reverse of lustful, who was so excited by + the act of defecation that she was invariably compelled to + masturbate, although this state of things was a source of great + mental misery to her. (C.H.F. Routh, _British Gynaecological + Journal_, February, 1887, p. 48.) + + Boelsche has sought the explanation of the erogenous nature of the + anus, and the key to _pedicatio_, in an atavistic return to the + very remote amphibian days when the anus was combined with the + sexual parts in a common cloaca. But it is unnecessary to invoke + any vestigial inheritance from a vastly remote past when we bear + in mind that the innervation of these two adjoining regions is + inevitably very closely related. The presence of a body exit with + its marked and special sensitivity at a point where it can + scarcely fail to receive the nervous overflow from an immensely + active center of nervous energy quite adequately accounts for the + phenomenon in question. + +The inner lips, the nymphae or labia minora, running parallel with the +greater lips which enclose them, embrace the clitoris anteriorly and +extend backward, enclosing the urethral exit between them as well as the +vaginal entrance. They form little wings whence their old Latin name, +_alae_, and from their resemblance to the cock's comb were by Spigelius +termed crista galli. The red and (especially in brunettes) dark appearance +of the nymphae suggests that they are mucous membrane and not +integumentary; it is, however, now considered that even on the inner +surface they are covered by skin and separated from the mucous membrane by +a line.[90] In structure, as described by Waldeyer, they consist of fine +connective tissue rich in elastic fibers as well as some muscular tissue, +and full of large veins, so that they are capable of a considerable degree +of turgescence resembling erection during sexual excitement, while +Ballantyne finds that the nymphae are supplied to a notable extent with +nervous end-organs. + +More than any other part of the sexual apparatus in either sex, the lesser +lips, on account of their shape, their position, and their structure, are +capable of acquired modifications, more especially hypertrophy and +elongation. By stretching, it is stated, a labium can be doubled in its +dimensions. The "Hottentot apron," or elongated nymphae, commonly found +among some peoples in South Africa, has long been a familiar phenomenon. +In such cases a length or transverse diameter of 3 to 5 centimeters is +commonly found. But such elongated nymphae are by no means confined to one +part of the world or to one race; they are quite common among women of +European race, and reach a size equal to most of the more reliably +recorded Hottentot cases. Dickinson, who has very carefully studied this +question in New York, finds that in 1000 consecutive gynaecological cases +the labia showed some form of hypertrophy in 36 per cent., or more than 1 +in 3; while among 150 of these cases who were neurasthenic, the proportion +reached 56 per cent., even when minor or doubtful enlargements were +disregarded. Bergh, in about 16 per cent. cases, found very enlarged +nymphae, the height reached in about 5 per cent. of the cases of +enlargement being nearly six centimeters. Ploss and Bartels, in a full +discussion: of the "Hottentot apron," come to the conclusion that this +condition is perhaps in most cases artificially produced. It is known that +among the Basutos it is the custom for the elder girls to manipulate the +nymphae of younger children, when alone with them, almost from birth, and +on account of the elastic nature of these structures such manipulation +quite adequately accounts for the elongation. It is not necessary to +suppose that the custom is practiced for the sake of producing sexual +stimulation--though this may frequently occur--since there are numerous +similar primitive customs involving deformation of the sexual organs +without the production of sexual excitement. Dickinson has come to a +similar conclusion as regards the corresponding elongation of the nymphae +in civilized European women. In 361 out of 1000 women of good social class +he found elongation or thickening, often with a notable degree of +wrinkling and pigmentation, and believes that this is always the result of +frequently repeated masturbation practiced with the separation of the +nymphae; in 30 per cent. of the cases admission of masturbation was +made.[91] While this conclusion is probably correct in the main, it +requires some qualification. To assert that whenever in women who have +not been pregnant the marked protrusion of the inner lips beyond the outer +lips means that at some period manipulation has been practiced with or +without the production of sexual excitement is to make too absolute a +statement. It is highly probable that the nymphae, like the clitoris, are +congenitally more prominent in some of the lower human races, as they are +also in the apes; among the Fuegians, for instance, according to Hyades +and Deniker, the labia minora descend lower than in Europeans, although +there is not the slightest reason to suppose that these women practice any +manipulations. Among European women, again, the nymphae sometimes protrude +very prominently beyond the labia majora in women who are organically of +somewhat infantile type; this occurs in cases in which we may be convinced +that no manipulations have ever been practiced.[92] + +It is difficult to speak very decisively as to the function of the labia +minora. They doubtless exert some amount of protective influence over the +entrance to the vagina, and in this way correspond to the lips of the +mouth after which they are called. They fulfill, however, one very +definite though not obviously important function which is indicated by the +mythologic name they have received. There is, indeed, some obscurity in +the origin of this term, nymphae, which has not, I believe, been +satisfactorily cleared up. It has been stated that the Greek name nymphe +has been transferred from the clitoris to the labia minora. Any such +transfer could only have taken place when the meaning of the word had been +forgotten, and nymphe had become the totally different word _nymphae_, the +goddesses who presided over streams. The old anatomists were much +exercised in their minds as to the meaning of the name, but on the whole +were inclined to believe that it referred to the action of the labia +minora in directing the urinary stream. The term nymphae was first applied +in the modern sense, according to Bergh, in 1599, by Pinaeus, mainly from +the influence of these structures on the urinary stream, and he dilated in +his _De Virginitate_ on the suitability of the term to designate so poetic +a spot.[93] In more modern times Luschka and Sir Charles Bell considered +that it is one of the uses of the nymphae to direct the stream of urine, +and Lamb from his own observation thinks the same conclusion probable. In +reality there cannot be the slightest doubt about the function of the +nymphae, as, in Hyrtl's phrase, "the naiads of the urinary source," and it +can be demonstrated by the simplest experiment.[94] + +The nymphae form the intermediate portal of the vagina, as the canal which +conducts to the womb was in anatomy first termed (according to Hyrtl) by +De Graaf.[95] It is a secreting, erectile, more or less sensitive canal +lined by what is usually considered mucous membrane, though some have +regarded it as integument of the same character as that of the external +genitals; it certainly resembles such integument more than, for instance, +the mucous membrane of the rectum. In the woman who has never had sexual +intercourse and has been subjected to no manipulations or accidents +affecting this region, the vagina is closed by a last and final gate of +delicate membrane--scarcely admitting more than a slender finger--called +the hymen. + + The poets called the hymen "fios virginitatis," the flower of + virginity, whence the medico-legal term _defloratio_. + Notwithstanding the great significance which has long been + attached to the phenomena connected with it, the hymen was not + accurately known until Vesalius, Fallopius, and Spigelius + described and named it. It was, however, recognized by the Arab + authors, Avicenna and Averroes. The early literature concerning + it is summarized by Schurig, _Muliebria_, 1729, Section II, cap. + V. The same author's _Parthenologia_ is devoted to the various + ancient problems connected with the question of virginity. + +To say that this delicate piece of membrane is from the non-physical point +of view a more important structure than any other part of the body is to +convey but a feeble idea of the immense importance of the hymen in the +eyes of the men of many past ages and even of our own times and among our +own people.[96] For the uses of the feminine body, or for its beauty, +there is no part which is more absolutely insignificant. But in human +estimation it has acquired a spiritual value which has made it far more +than a part of the body. It has taken the place of the soul, that whose +presence gives all her worth and dignity, even her name, to the unmarried +woman, her purity, her sexual desirability, her market value. Without +it--though in all physical and mental respects she might remain the same +person--she has sometimes been a mark for contempt, a worthless +outcast.[97] + + So fragile a membrane scarcely possesses the reliability which + should be possessed by a structure whose presence or absence has + often meant so much. Its absence by no means necessarily + signifies that a woman has had intercourse with a man. Its + presence by no means signifies that she has never had such + intercourse. + + There are many ways in which the hymen may be destroyed apart + from coitus. Among the Chinese (and also, it would appear, in + India and some other parts of the East) the female parts are from + infancy kept so scrupulously clean by daily washing, the finger + being introduced into the vagina, that the hymen rapidly + disappears, and its existence is unknown even to Chinese doctors. + Among some Brazilian Indians a similar practice exists among + mothers as regards their young children, less, however, for the + sake of cleanliness than in order to facilitate sexual + intercourse in future years. (Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. + i, Chapter VI.) The manipulations of vaginal masturbation will, + of course, similarly destroy the hymen. It is also quite possible + for the hymen to be ruptured by falls and other accidents. (See, + e.g., a lengthy study by Nina-Rodrigues, "Des Ruptures de l'Hymen + dans les Chutes," _Annales d'Hygiene Publique_, September, 1903.) + + On the other hand, integrity of the hymen is no proof of + virginity, apart from the obvious fact that there may be + intercourse without penetration. (The case has even been recorded + of a prostitute with syphilitic condylomata, a somewhat masculine + type of pubic arch, and vulva rather posteriorly placed, whose + hymen had never been penetrated.) The hymen may be of a yielding + or folding type, so that complete penetration may take place and + yet the hymen be afterwards found unruptured. It occasionally + happens that the hymen is found intact at the end of pregnancy. + In some, though not all, of these cases there has been conception + without intromission of the penis. This has occurred even when + the entrance was very minute. The possibility of such conception + has long been recognized, and Schurig (_Syllepsilogia_, 1731, + Section I, cap. VIII, p. 2) quotes ancient authors who have + recorded cases. For some typical modern cases see Guerard + (_Centralblatt fuer Gynaekologie_, No. 15, 1895), in one of whose + cases the hymen of the pregnant woman scarcely admitted a hair; + also Braun (ib., No. 23, 1895). + +The hymen has played a very definite and pronounced part in the social and +moral life of humanity. Until recently it has been more difficult to +decide what precise biological function it has exercised to ensure its +development and preservation. Sexual selection, no doubt, has worked in +its favor, but that influence has been very limited and comparatively very +recent. Virginity is not usually of any value among peoples who are +entirely primitive. Indeed, even in the classic civilization which we +inherit, it is easy to show that the virgin and the admiration for +virginity are of late growth; the virgin goddesses were not originally +virgins in our modern sense. Diana was the many-breasted patroness of +childbirth before she became the chaste and solitary huntress, for the +earliest distinction would appear to have been simply between the woman +who was attached to a man and the woman who followed an earlier rule of +freedom and independence; it was a later notion to suppose that the latter +woman was debarred from sexual intercourse. We certainly must not seek the +origin of the hymen in sexual selection; we must find it in natural +selection. And here it might seem at first sight that we come upon a +contradiction in Nature, for Nature is always devising contrivances to +secure the maximum amount of fertilization. "Increase and multiply" is so +obviously the command of Nature that the Hebrews, with their usual +insight, unhesitatingly dared to place it in the mouth of Jehovah. But the +hymen is a barrier to fertilization. It has, however, always to be +remembered that as we rise in the zooelogical scale, and as the period of +gestation lengthens and the possible number of offspring is fewer, it +becomes constantly more essential that fertilization shall be effective +rather than easy; the fewer the progeny the more necessary it is that they +shall be vigorous enough to survive. There can be little doubt that, as +one or two writers have already suggested, the hymen owes its development +to the fact that its influence is on the side of effective fertilization. +It is an obstacle to the impregnation of the young female by immature, +aged, or feeble males. The hymen is thus an anatomical expression of that +admiration of force which marks the female in her choice of a mate. So +regarded, it is an interesting example of the intimate manner in which +sexual selection is really based on natural selection. Sexual selection is +but the translation into psychic terms of a process which has already +found expression in the physical texture of the body. + + It may be added that this interpretation of the biological + function of the hymen is supported by the facts of its evolution. + It is unknown among the lower mammals, with whom fertilization is + easy, gestation short and offspring numerous. It only begins to + appear among the higher mammals in whom reproduction is already + beginning to take on the characters which become fully developed + in man. Various authors have found traces of a rudimentary hymen, + not only in apes, but in elephants, horses, donkeys, bitches, + bears, pigs, hyenas, and giraffes. (Hyrtl, _Op. cit._, vol. ii, + p. 189; G. Gellhoen, "Anatomy and Development of the Hymen," + _American Journal Obstetrics_, August, 1904.) It is in the human + species that the tendency to limitation of offspring is most + marked, combined at the same time with a greater aptitude for + impregnation than exists among any lower mammals. It is here, + therefore, that a physical check is of most value, and + accordingly we find that in woman alone, of all animals, is the + hymen fully developed. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[72] "Analysis of the Sexual Impulse," in vol. iii of these _Studies_. + +[73] "The accomplishment of no other function," Hyrtl remarks, "is so +intimately connected with the mind and yet so independent of it." + +[74] The process is still, however, but imperfectly understood; see Art. +"Fecondation," by Ed. Retterer, in Richet's _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_, +vol. vi, 1905. + +[75] Thus a male foetus showing reptilian characters in sexual ducts was +exhibited by Shattock at the Pathological Society of London, February 19, +1895. + +[76] J. Kohlbrugge, "Die Umgestaltung des Uterus der Affen nach den +Geburt," _Zeitschrift fuer Morphologie_, bd. iv, p. 1, 1901. + +[77] There are, however, no special nerve endings (Krause corpuscles), as +was formerly supposed. The nerve endings in the genital region are the +same as elsewhere. The difference lies in the abundance of superposed +arboreal ramifications. See, e.g., Ed. Retterer, Art. "Ejaculation," +Richet's _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_, vol. v. + +[78] Hyrtl, _Op. cit._, vol. ii, p. 39. + +[79] Sensations of pleasure without those of touch appear to be normal at +the tip of the penis, as pointed out by Scripture, quoted in _Alienist and +Neurologist_, January, 1898. + +[80] See the previous volume of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection in +Man," p. 161. + +[81] See, e.g., Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, beginning of +chapter VI. + +[82] Hyrtl states that the name _labia_ was first used by Haller in the +middle of the eighteenth century in his _Elements of Physiology_, being +adopted by him from the Greek poet Erotion, who gave these structures the +very obvious name cheilea, lips. But this seems to be a mistake, for the +seventeenth century anatomists certainly used the name "labia" for these +parts. + +[83] Bergh tentatively suggests, as regards the pubic hair, that its +appearance may be due to the upright walk in man and the human position +during coitus, the hair preventing irritation of the genitals from the +sweat pouring down from the body and protecting the skin from direct +friction in coitus. (In both these suggestions he was, however, long +previously anticipated by Fabricius ab Aquapendente.) The fanciful +suggestion of Louis Robinson that the pubic hair has developed in order to +enable the human infant to cling securely to his mother is very poorly +supported by facts, and has not met with acceptance. It may be mentioned +that (as stated by Ploss and Bartels) the women of the Bismarck +Archipelago, whose pubic hair is very abundant, use it as a kind of +handkerchief on which to clean their hands. + +[84] Routh and Heywood Smith have noted that the pubic hair tends to lose +its curliness and become straight in women who masturbate. (_British +Gynaecological Journal_, February, 1887, p. 505.) + +[85] Schurig, _Muliebria_, p. 75. Plazzon in 1621 said that in Italian it +had a popular name, _il besneegio_. + +[86] Schurig brought together in his _Gynaecologia_ (pp. 2-4) various early +opinions concerning the clitoris as the seat of voluptuous feeling. + +[87] Hyrtl, _Op. cit._, vol. ii, p. 193. + +[88] Adler, _Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, 1904, pp. +117-119. + +[89] The voluptuous sensations caused by sexual contacts producing +movements of the womb are probably normal and usual. They may even occur +under circumstances unconnected with sexual emotion, and Munde +(_International Journal of Surgery_, March, 1893) mentions incidentally +that in one case while titillating the cervix with a sound the woman very +plainly showed voluptuous manifestations. + +[90] Henle stated that fine hairs are frequently visible on the nymphae; +Stieda (_Zeitschrift fuer Morphologie_, 1902, p. 458) remarks that he has +never been able to see them with the naked eye. + +[91] R.L. Dickinson, "Hypertrophies of the Labia Minora and Their +Significance," _American Gynaecologist_, September, 1902. It is perhaps +noteworthy that Bergh found that in 302 cases in which the nymphae were of +unequal length, in all but 24 the left was longer. + +[92] It may be remarked that Bergh believes that the nymphae, and indeed +the external genitals generally, are congenitally more strongly developed +in libidinous persons, and at the same time in brunettes, while in public +prostitutes this is not usually the case, which confirms the belief that +exalted sexual sensibility does not usually lead to prostitution. He adds +that prostitution, unless carried on for many years, has little effect on +the shape of the external genitals. + +[93] Schurig (_Muliebria_, 1729, Section II, cap. II) gives numerous +quotations on this point; thus De Graaf wrote in his book on the sexual +organs of women: "Tales protuberantiae nymphae appellantur ea propter quod +aquis e vesica prosilientibus proxime adstare reperiantur, quandoquidem +inter illas, tanquam duos parietes, urina magno impetu cum sibilo saepe et +absque labiorum irrigatione erumpit, vel quod sint castitatis praesides, +aut sponsam primo intromittant." + +[94] Havelock Ellis, "The Bladder as a Dynamometer," _American Journal of +Dermatology_, May, 1902. If a woman who has never been pregnant, standing +in the erect position before commencing the act of urination presses apart +the labia minora with index and middle fingers the stream will be +projected forward so as to fall usually at a considerable distance in +front of a vertical line from the meatus; if when the act is half +completed the fingers are removed, the labia close together and the +stream, though maintained at a constant pressure, at once changes its +character and direction. + +[95] In poetry this term was employed by Plautus, _Pseudolus_, Act IV, Sc. +7. The Greek aidoion sometimes meant vagina and sometimes the external +sexual parts; kolpos was used for the vagina alone. + +[96] It is curious, however, that the European physicians of the +seventeenth and even eighteenth centuries were doubtful of its value as a +sign of virginity and considered it often absent. + +[97] For a summary of the beliefs and practices of various peoples with +regard to the hymen and virginity see Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. +i, Chapter XVI. + + + + +II + +The Object of Detumescence--Erogenous Zones--The Lips--The Vascular +Characters of Detumescence--Erectile Tissue--Erection in Woman--Mucous +Emission in Women--Sexual Connection--The Human Mode of +Intercourse--Normal Variations--The Motor Characters of +Detumescence--Ejaculation--The Virile Reflex--The General Phenomena of +Detumescence--The Circulatory and Respiratory Phenomena--Blood +Pressure--Cardiac Disturbance--Glandular Activity--Distillatio--The +Essentially Motor Character of Detumescence--Involuntary Muscular +Irradiation to Bladder, etc.--Erotic Intoxication--Analogy of Sexual +Detumescence and Vesical Tension--The Specifically Sexual Movements of +Detumescence in Man--In Woman--The Spontaneous Movements of the Genital +Canal in Woman--Their Function in Conception--Part Played by Active +Movement of the Spermatozoa--The Artificial Injection of Semen--The Facial +Expression During Detumescence--The Expression of Joy--The Occasional +Serious Effects of Coitus. + + +We have seen what the object of detumescence is, and we have briefly +considered the organs and structures which are chiefly concerned in the +process. We have now to inquire what are the actual phenomena which take +place during the act of detumescence. + +Detumescence is normally linked closely to tumescence. Tumescence is the +piling on of the fuel; detumescence is the leaping out of the devouring +flame whence is lighted the torch of life to be handed on from generation +to generation. The whole process is double and yet single; it is exactly +analogous to that by which a pile is driven into the earth by the raising +and then the letting go of a heavy weight which falls on to the head of +the pile. In tumescence the organism is slowly wound up and force +accumulated; in the act of detumescence the accumulated force is let go +and by its liberation the sperm-bearing instrument is driven home. +Courtship, as we commonly term the process of tumescence which takes place +when a woman is first sexually approached by a man, is usually a highly +prolonged process. But it is always necessary to remember that every +repetition of the act of coitus, to be normally and effectively carried +out on both sides, demands a similar double process; detumescence must be +preceded by an abbreviated courtship. + +This abbreviated courtship by which tumescence is secured or heightened in +the repetition of acts of coitus which have become familiar, is mainly +tactile.[98] Since the part of the man in coitus is more active and that +of the woman more passive, the sexual sensitivity of the skin seems to be +more pronounced in women. There are, moreover, regions of the surface of a +woman's body where contact, when sympathetic, seems specially liable to +arouse erotic excitement. Such erogenous zones are often specially marked +in the breasts, occasionally in the palm of the hand, the nape of the +neck, the lobule of the ear, the little finger; there is, indeed, perhaps +no part of the surface of the body which may not, in some individuals at +some time, become normally an erogenous zone. In hysteria the erotic +excitability of these zones is sometimes very intense. The lips are, +however, without doubt, the most persistently and poignantly sensitive +region of the whole body outside the sphere of the sexual organs +themselves. Hence the significance of the kiss as a preliminary of +detumescence.[99] + + The importance of the lips as a normal erogenous zone is shown by + the experiments of Gualino. He applied a thread, folded on itself + several times, to the lips, thus stimulating them in a simple + mechanical manner. Of 20 women, between the ages of 18 and 35, + only 8 felt this as a merely mechanical operation, 4 felt a + vaguely erotic element in the proceeding, 3 experienced a desire + for coitus and in 5 there was actual sexual excitement with + emission of mucus. Of 25 men, between the ages of 20 and 30, in + 15 all sexual feeling was absent, in 7 erotic ideas were + suggested with congestion of the sexual organs without erection, + and in 3 there was the beginning of erection. It should be added + that both the women and the men in whom this sexual reflex was + more especially marked were of somewhat nervous temperament; in + such persons erotic reactions of all kinds generally occur most + easily. (Gualino, "Il Rifflesso Sessuale nell' eccitamento alle + labbre," _Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1904, p. 341.) + +As tumescence, under the influence of sensory stimulation, proceeds toward +the climax when it gives place to detumescence, the physical phenomena +become more and more acutely localized in the sexual organs. The process +which was at first predominantly nervous and psychic now becomes more +prominently vascular. The ancient sexual relationship of the skin asserts +itself; there is marked surface congestion showing itself in various ways. +The face tends to become red, and exactly the same phenomenon is taking +place in the genital organs; "an erection," it has been said, "is a +blushing of the penis." The difference is that in the genital organs this +heightened vascularity has a definite and specific function to +accomplish--the erection of the male organ which fits it to enter the +female parts--and that consequently there has been developed in the penis +that special kind of vascular mechanism, consisting of veins in connective +tissue with unstriped muscular fibers, termed erectile tissue.[100] + +It is not only the man who is supplied with erectile tissue which in the +process of tumescence becomes congested and swollen. The woman also, in +the corresponding external genital region, is likewise supplied with +erectile tissue now also charged with blood, and exhibits the same changes +as have taken place in her partner, though less conspicuously visible. In +the anthropoid apes, as the gorilla, the large clitoris and the nymphae +become prominent in sexual excitement, but the less development of the +clitoris in women, together with the specifically human evolution of the +mons veneris and larger lips, renders this sexual turgescence practically +invisible, though it is perceptible to touch in an increased degree of +spongy and elastic tension. The whole feminine genital canal, including +the uterus, indeed, is richly supplied with blood-vessels, and is capable +during sexual excitement of a very high degree of turgescence, a kind of +erection. + +The process of erection in woman is accompanied by the pouring out of +fluid which copiously bathes all parts of the vulva around the entrance to +the vagina. This is a bland, more or less odorless mucus which, under +ordinary circumstances, slowly and imperceptibly suffuses the parts. When, +however, the entrance to the vagina is exposed and extended, as during a +gynaecological examination which occasionally produces sexual excitement, +there may be seen a real ejaculation of the fluid which, as usually +described, comes largely from the glands of Bartholin, situated at the +mouth of the vagina. Under these circumstances it is sometimes described +as being emitted in a jet which is thrown to a distance.[101] This mucous +ejaculation was in former days regarded as analogous to the seminal +ejaculation in man, and hence essential to conception. Although this +belief was erroneous the fluid poured out in this manner whenever a high +degree of tumescence is attained, and before the onset of detumescence, +certainly performs an important function in lubricating the entrance to +the genital canal and so facilitating the intromission of the male +organ.[102] Menstruation has a similar influence in facilitating coitus, +as Schurig long since pointed out.[103] A like process takes place during +parturition when the same parts are being lubricated and stretched in +preparation for the protrusion of the foetal head. The occurrence of the +mucous flow in tumescence always indicates that that process is actively +affecting the central sexual organs, and that voluptuous emotions are +present.[104] + + The secretions of the genital canal and outlet in women are + somewhat numerous. We have the odoriferous glands of sebaceous + origin, and with them the prepuce of the clitoris which has been + described as a kind of gigantic sebaceous follicle with the + clitoris occupying its interior. (Hyrtl.) There is the secretion + from the glands of Bartholin. There is again the vaginal + secretion, opaque and albuminous, which appears to be alkaline + when secreted, but becomes acid under the decomposing influence + of bacteria, which are, however, harmless and not pathogenic. + (Gow, _Obstetrical Society of London_, January 3, 1894.) There + is, finally, the mucous uterine secretion, which is alkaline, + and, being poured out during orgasm, is believed to protect the + spermatozoa from destruction by the acid vaginal secretion. + + The belief that the mucus poured out in women during sexual + excitement is feminine semen and therefore essential to + conception had many remarkable consequences and was widespread + until the seventeenth century. Thus, in the chapter "De Modo + coeundi et de regimine eorum qui coeunt" of _De Secretis + Mulierum_, there is insistence on the importance of the proper + mixture of the male semen with the female semen and of arranging + that it shall not escape from the vagina. The woman must lie + quiet for several hours at least, not rising even to urinate, and + when she gets up, be very temperate in eating and drinking, and + not run or jump, pretending that she has a headache. It was the + belief in feminine semen which led some theologians to lay down + that a woman might masturbate if she had not experienced orgasm + in coitus. Schurig in his _Muliebria_ (1729, pp. 159, et seq.) + discusses the opinions of old authors regarding the nature, + source, and uses of the female genital secretions, and quotes + authorities against the old view that it was female semen. In a + subsequent work (_Syllepsilogia_, 1731, pp. 3, et seq.) he + returns to the same question, quotes authors who accept a + feminine semen, shows that Harvey denied it any significance, and + himself decides against it. It has not seriously been brought + forward since. + +When erection is completed in both the man and the woman the conditions +necessary for conjugation have at last been fulfilled. In all animals, +even those most nearly allied to man, coitus is effected by the male +approaching the female posteriorly. In man the normal method of male +approach is anteriorly, face to face. Leonardo da Vinci, in a well-known +drawing representing a sagittal section of a man and a woman connected in +this position of so-called Venus obversa; has shown how well adapted the +position is to the normal position of the organs in the human +species.[105] + + Among monkeys, it is stated, congress is sometimes performed when + the female is on all fours; at other times the male brings the + female between his thighs when he is sitting, holding her with + his forepaws. Froriep informed Lawrence that the male sometimes + supported his feet on the female's calves. (Sir W. Lawrence, + _Lectures on Physiology_, 1823, p. 186.) A summary of the methods + of congress practiced by the various animals below mammals will + be found in the article "Copulation" by H. de Varigny in Richet's + _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_, vol. iv. + + The anterior position in coitus, with the female partner lying + supine, is so widespread throughout the world that it may fairly + be termed the most typically human attitude in sexual congress. + It is found represented in Egyptian graves at Benihassan, + belonging to the Twelfth Dynasty; it is regarded by Mohammedans + as the normal position, although other positions are permitted by + the Prophet: "Your wives are your tillage: go in unto your + tillage in what manner soever you will;" it is that adopted in + Malacca; it appears, from Peruvian antiquities, to have been the + position generally, though not exclusively, adopted in ancient + Peru; it is found in many parts of Africa, and seems also to have + been the most usual position among the American aborigines. + + Various modifications of this position are, however, found. Thus, + in some parts of the world, as among the Suahelis in Zanzibar, + the male partner adopts the supine position. In Loango, according + to Pechuel-Loesche, coitus is performed lying on the side. + Sometimes, as on the west coast of Africa, the woman is supine + and the man more or less erect; or, as among the Queenslanders + (as described by Roth) the woman is supine and the man squats on + his heels with her thighs clasping his flanks, while he raises + her buttocks with his hands. + + The position of coitus in which the man is supine is without + doubt a natural and frequent variation of the specifically human + obverse method of coitus. It was evidently familiar to the + Romans. Ovid mentions it (_Ars Amatoria_, III, 777-8), + recommending it to little women, and saying that Andromache was + too tall to practice it with Hector. Aristophanes refers to it, + and there are Greek epigrams in which women boast of their skill + in riding their lovers. It has sometimes been viewed with a + certain disfavor because it seems to confer a superiority on the + woman. "Cursed be he," according to a Mohammedan saying, "who + maketh woman heaven and man earth." + + Of special interest is the wide prevalence of an attitude in + coitus recalling that which prevails among quadrupeds. The + frequency with which on the walls of Pompeii coitus is + represented with the woman bending forward and her partner + approaching her posteriorly has led to the belief that this + attitude was formerly very common in Southern Italy. However that + may be, it is certainly normal at the present day among various + more or less primitive peoples in whom the vulva is often placed + somewhat posteriorly. It is thus among the Soudanese, as also, in + an altogether different part of the world, among the Eskimo + Innuit and Koniags. The New Caledonians, according to Foley, + cohabit in the quadrupedal manner, and so also the Papuans of New + Guinea (Bongu), according to Vahness. The same custom is also + found in Australia, where, however other postures are also + adopted. In Europe the quadrupedal posture would seem to prevail + among some of the South Slavs, notably the Dalmatians. (The + different methods of coitus practiced by the South Slavs are + described in Kryptadia vol. vi, pp. 220, et seq.) + + This method of coitus was recommended by Lucretius (lib. iv) and + also advised by Paulus AEginetus as favorable to conception. (The + opinions of various early physicians are quoted by Schurig, + _Spermatologia_, 1720, pp. 232, et seq.). It seems to be a + position that is not infrequently agreeable to women, a fact + which may be brought into connection with the remarks of Adler + already quoted (p. 131) concerning the comparative lack of + adjustment of the feminine organs to the obverse position. It is + noteworthy that in the days of witchcraft hysterical women + constantly believed that they had had intercourse with the Devil + in this manner. This circumstance, indeed, probably aided in the + very marked disfavor in which coitus _a posteriori_ fell after + the decay of classic influences. The mediaeval physicians + described it as _mos diabolicus_ and mistakenly supposed that it + produced abortion (Hyrtl, op. cit., vol. ii, p. 87). The + theologians, needless to say, were opposed to the _mos + diabolicus_, and already in the Anglo-Saxon Penitential of + Theodore, at the end of the seventh century, 40 days' penance is + prescribed for this method of coitus. + + From the frequency with which they have been adopted by various + peoples as national customs, most of the postures in coitus here + referred to must be said to come within the normal range of + variation. It is a mistake to regard them as vicious perversions. + +Up to the point to which we have so far considered it, the process of +detumescence has been mainly nervous and vascular in character; it has, in +fact, been but the more acute stage of a process which has been going on +throughout tumescence. But now we reach the point at which a new element +comes in: muscular action. With the onset of muscular action, which is +mainly involuntary, even when it affects the voluntary muscles, +detumescence proper begins to take place. Henceforward purposeful psychic +action, except by an effort, is virtually abolished. The individual, as a +separate person, tends to disappear. He has become one with another +person, as nearly one as the conditions of existence ever permit; he and +she are now merely an instrument in the hands of a higher power--by +whatever name we may choose to call that Power--which is using them for an +end not themselves. + +The decisive moment in the production of the instinctive and involuntary +orgasm occurs when, under the influence of the stimulus applied to the +penis by friction with the vagina, the tension of the seminal fluid poured +into the urethra arouses the ejaculatory center in the spinal cord and the +bulbo-cavernosus muscle surrounding the urethra responsively contracts in +rhythmic spasms. Then it is that ejaculation occurs.[106] + +"The circulation quickens, the arteries beat strongly," wrote Roubaud in a +description of the physical state during coitus which may almost be termed +classic; "the venous blood, arrested by muscular contraction, increases +the general heat, and this stagnation, more pronounced in the brain by the +contraction of the muscles of the neck and the throwing of the head +backward, causes a momentary cerebral congestion, during which +intelligence is lost and the faculties abolished. The eyes, violently +injected, become haggard, and the look uncertain, or, in the majority of +cases, the eyes are closed spasmodically to avoid the contact of the +light. The respiration is hurried, sometimes interrupted, and may be +suspended by the spasmodic contraction of the larynx, and the air, for a +time compressed, is at last emitted in broken and meaningless words. The +congested nervous centers only communicate confused sensations and +volitions; mobility and sensation show extreme disorder; the limbs are +seized by convulsions and sometimes by cramps, or are thrown wildly about +or become stiff like iron bars. The jaws, tightly pressed, grind the +teeth, and in some persons the delirium is carried so far that they bite +to bleeding the shoulders their companions have imprudently abandoned to +them. This frantic state of epilepsy lasts but a short time, but it +suffices to exhaust the forces of the organism, especially in man. It is, +I believe, Galen, who said: 'Omne animal post coitum triste praeter +mulierem gallumque.'"[107] Most of the elements that make up this typical +picture of the state of coitus are not absolutely essential to that state, +but they all come within the normal range of variation. There can be no +doubt that this range is considerable. There would appear to be not only +individual, but also racial, differences; there is a remarkable passage in +Vatsyayana's _Kama Sutra_ describing the varying behavior of the women of +different races in India under the stress of sexual excitement--Dravidian +women with difficulty attaining erethism, women of the Punjaub fond of +being caressed with the tongue, women of Oude with impetuous desire and +profuse flow of mucus, etc.--and it is highly probable, Ploss and Bartels +remark, that these characterizations are founded on exact +observations.[108] + +The various phenomena included in Roubaud's description of the condition +during coitus may all be directly or indirectly reduced to two groups: the +first circulatory and respiratory, the second motor. It is necessary to +consider both these aspects of the process of detumescence in somewhat +greater detail, although while it is most convenient to discuss them +separately, it must be borne in mind that they are not really separable; +the circulatory phenomena are in large measure a by-product of the +involuntary motor process. + +With the approach of detumescence the respiration becomes shallow, rapid, +and to some extent arrested. This characteristic of the breathing during +sexual excitement is well recognized; so that in, for instance, the +_Arabian Nights_, it is commonly noted of women when gazing at beautiful +youths whose love they desired, that they ceased breathing.[109] It may be +added that exactly the same tendency to superficial and arrested +respiration takes place whenever there is any intense mental +concentration, as in severe intellectual work.[110] + +The arrest of respiration tends to render the blood venous, and thus aids +in stimulating the vasomotor centers, raising the blood-pressure in the +body generally, and especially in the erectile tissues. High +blood-pressure is one of the most marked features of the state of +detumescence. The heart beats are stronger and quicker, the surface +arteries are more visible, the conjunctivae become red. The precise degree +of blood-pressure attained during coitus has been most accurately +ascertained in the dog. In Bechterew's laboratory in St. Petersburg a +manometer was introduced into the central end of the carotid artery of a +bitch; a male dog was then introduced, and during coitus observations were +made on the blood-pressure at the peripheral and central ends of the +artery. It was found that there was a great general elevation of +blood-pressure, intense hyperaemia of the brain, rapid alternations, during +the act, of vasoconstriction and vasodilatation of the brain, with +increase and diminution of the general arterial tension in relation with +the various phases of the act, the greatest cerebral vasodilatation and +hyperaemia coinciding with the moment following the intromission of the +penis; the end of the act is followed by a considerable fall in the +blood-pressure.[111] I am not acquainted with any precise observations on +the blood-pressure in human subjects during detumescence, and there are +obvious difficulties in the way of such observations. It is probable, +however, that the conditions found would be substantially the same. This +is indicated, so far as the very marked increase of blood-pressure is +concerned, by some observations made by Vaschide and Vurpas with the +sphygmanometer on a lady under the influence of sexual excitement. In this +case there was a relationship of sympathy and friendly tenderness between +the experimenter and the subject, Madame X, aged 25. Experimenter and +subject talked sympathetically, and finally, we are told, while the latter +still had her hands in the sphygmanometer, the former almost made a +declaration of love. Madame X was greatly impressed, and afterward +admitted that her emotions had been genuine and strong. The +blood-pressure, which was in this subject habitually 65 millimeters, rose +to 150 and even 160, indicating a very high pressure, which rarely occurs; +at the same time Madame X looked very emotional and troubled.[112] + + Some authorities are of opinion that irregularities in the + accomplishment of the sexual act are specially liable to cause + disturbances in the circulation. Thus Kisch, of Prague, refers to + the case of a couple practising coitus interruptus--the husband + withdrawing before ejaculation--in which the wife, a vigorous + woman, became liable after some years to attacks termed by Kisch + _neurasthenia cordis vasomotoria_, in which there was at daily or + longer intervals palpitation, with feelings of anxiety, headache, + dizziness, muscular weakness and tendency to faint. He regards + coitus as a cause of various heart troubles in women: (1) Attacks + of tachycardia in very excitable and sexually inclined women; (2) + attacks of tachycardia with dyspnoea in young women, with + vaginismus; (3) cardiac symptoms with lowered vascular tone in + women who for a long time have practised coitus interruptus + without complete sexual gratification (Kisch, "Herzbeschwerden + der Frauen verursacht durch den Cohabitationsact," _Muenchener + Medizinisches Wochenschrift_, 1897, p. 617). In this connection, + also, reference may probably be made to those attacks of anxiety + which Freud associates with psychic sexual lesions of an + emotional character. + +Associated with this vascular activity in detumescence we find a general +tendency to glandular activity. Various secretions are formed abundantly. +Perspiration is copious, and the ancient relationship between the +cutaneous and sexual systems seems to evoke a general activity of the skin +and its odoriferous secretions. Salivation, which also occurs, is very +conspicuous in many lower animals, as for instance in the donkey, notably +the female, who just before coitus stands with mouth open, jaws moving, +and saliva dribbling. In men, corresponding to the more copious secretion +in women, there is, during the latter stages of tumescence, a slight +secretion of mucus--Fuerbringer's _urethrorrhoea ex libidine_--which +appears in drops at the urethral orifice. It comes from the small glands +of Littre and Cowper which open into the urethra. This phenomenon was well +known to the old theologians, who called it _distillatio_, and realized +its significance as at once distinct from semen and an indication that the +mind was dwelling on voluptuous images; it was also known in classic +times[113]; more recently it has often been confused with semen and has +thus sometimes caused needless anxiety to nervous persons. There is also +an increased secretion of urine, and it is probable that if the viscera +were more accessible to observation we might be able to demonstrate that +the glands throughout the body share in this increased activity. + +The phenomena of detumescence culminate, however, and have their most +obvious manifestation in motor activity. The genital act, as Vaschide and +Vurpas remark, consists essentially in "a more and more marked tension of +the motor state which, reaching its maximum, presents a short tonic phase, +followed by a clonic phase, and terminates in a period of adynamia and +repose." This motor activity is of the essence of the impulse of +detumescence, because without it the sperm cells could not be brought into +the neighborhood of the germ cell and be propelled into the organic nest +which is assigned for their conjunction and incubation. + +The motor activity is general as well as specifically sexual. There is a +general tendency to more or less involuntary movement, without any +increase of voluntary muscular power, which is, indeed, decreased, and +Vaschide and Vurpas state that dynamometric results are somewhat lower +than normal during sexual excitement, and the variations greater.[114] The +tendency to diffused activity of involuntary muscle is well illustrated by +the contraction of the bladder associated with detumescence. While this +occurs in both sexes, in men erection produces a mechanical impediment to +any evacuation of the bladder. In women there is not only a desire to +urinate but, occasionally, actual urination. Many quite healthy and normal +women have, as a rare accident supervening on the coincidence of an +unusually full bladder with an unusual degree of sexual excitement, +experienced a powerful and quite involuntary evacuation of the bladder at +the moment of orgasm. In women with less normal nervous systems this has, +more rarely, been almost habitual. Brantome has perhaps recorded the +earliest case of this kind in referring to a lady he knew who "quand on +lui faisait cela elle se compissait a bon escient."[115] The tendency to +trembling, constriction of throat, sneezing, emission of internal gas, and +the other similar phenomena occasionally associated with detumescence, are +likewise due to diffusion of the motor disturbance. Even in infancy the +motor signs of sexual excitement are the most obvious indications of +orgasm; thus West, describing masturbation in a child of six or nine +months who practiced thigh-rubbing, states that when sitting in her high +chair she would grasp the handles, stiffen herself, and stare, rubbing her +thighs quickly together several times, and then come to herself with a +sigh, tired, relaxed, and sweating, these seizures, which lasted one or +two minutes, being mistaken by the relations for epileptic fits.[116] + + The essentially motor character of detumescence is well shown by + the extreme forms of erotic intoxication which sometimes appear + as the result of sexual excitement. Fere, who has especially + called attention to the various manifestations of this condition, + presents an instructive case of a man of neurotic heredity and + antecedents, in whom it occasionally happened that sexual + excitement, instead of culminating in the normal orgasm, attained + its climax in a fit of uncontrollable muscular excitement. He + would then sing, dance, gesticulate, roughly treat his partner, + break the objects around him, and finally sink down exhausted and + stupefied. (Fere, _L'Instinct Sexuel_, Chapter X.) In such a case + a diffused and general detumescence has taken the place of the + normal detumescence which has its main focus in the sexual + sphere. + + The same relationship is shown in a case of impotence accompanied + by cramps in the calves and elsewhere, which has been recorded by + Bruegelmann ("Zur Lehre vom Perversen Sexualismus," _Zeitschrift + fuer Hypnotismus_, 1900, Heft I). These muscular conditions ceased + for several days whenever coitus was effected. + + An instructive analogy to the motor irradiations preceding the + moment of sexual detumescence may be found in the somewhat + similar motor irradiations which follow the delayed expulsion of + a highly distended bladder. These sometimes become very marked in + a child or young woman unable to control the motor system + absolutely. The legs are crossed, the foot swung, the thighs + tightly pressed together, the toes curled. The fingers are flexed + in rhythmic succession. The whole body slowly twists as though + the seat had become uncomfortable. It is difficult to concentrate + the mind; the same remark may be automatically repeated; the eyes + search restlessly, and there is a tendency to count surrounding + objects or patterns. When the extreme degree of tension is + reached it is only by executing a kind of dance that the + explosive contraction of the bladder is restrained. + + The picture of muscular irradiation presented under these + circumstances differs but slightly from that of the onset of + detumescence. In one case the explosion is sought, in the other + case it is dreaded; but in both cases there is a retarded + muscular tension,--in the one case involuntary, in the other case + voluntary--maintained at a point of acute intensity, and in both + cases the muscular irradiations of this tension spread over the + whole body. + + The increased motor irritability of the state of detumescence + somewhat resembles the conditions produced by a weak anaesthetic + and there is some interest in noting the sexual excitement liable + to occur in anaesthesia. I am indebted to Dr. J.F.W. Silk for some + remarks on this point:-- + + "I. Sexual emotions may apparently be aroused during the stage of + excitement preceding or following the administration of any + anaesthetic; these emotions may take the form of mere delirious + utterances, or may be associated with what is apparently a sexual + orgasm. Or reflex phenomena connected with the sexual organs may + occasionally be observed under special circumstances; or, to put + it in another way, such reflex possibilities are not always + abolished by the condition of narcosis or anaesthesia. + + "II. Of the particular anaesthetics employed I am inclined to + think that the possibility of such conditions arising is + inversely proportionate to their strength, e.g., they are more + frequently observed with a weak anaesthetic like nitrous oxide + than with chloroform. + + "III. Sexual emotions I believe to be rarely observable in men, + and this is remarkable, or, I should say, particularly + noticeable, for the presence of nurses, female students, etc., + might almost have led one to expect that the contrary would have + been the case. On the other hand, it is among men that I have + frequently observed a reflex phenomenon which has usually taken + the shape of an erection of the penis when the structures in the + neighborhood of the spermatic cord have been handled. + + "IV. Among females the emotional sexual phenomena most frequently + obtrude themselves, and I believe that if it were possible to + induce people to relate their dreams they would very often be + found to be of a sexual character." + +Much more important than the general motor phenomena, more purposive +though involuntary, are the specifically sexual muscular movements. From +the very beginning of detumescence, indeed, muscular activity makes itself +felt, and the peripheral muscles of sex act, according to Kobelt's +expression, as a peripheral sexual heart. In the male these movements are +fairly obvious and fairly simple. It is required that the semen should be +expressed from the vesiculae seminales, propelled along the urethra, in +combination with the prostatic fluid which is equally essential, and +finally ejected with a certain amount of force from the urethral orifice. +Under the influence of the stimulation furnished by the contact and +friction of the vagina, this process is effectively carried out, mainly by +the rhythmic contractions of the bulbo-cavernosus muscle, and the semen is +emitted in a jet which may be ejaculated to a distance varying from a few +centimeters to a meter or more. + + With regard to the details of the psychic sides of this process a + correspondent, a psychologist, writes as follows:-- + + "I have never noticed in my reading any attempt to analyze the + sensations which accompany the orgasm, and, as I have made a good + many attempts to make such an analysis myself, I will append the + results on the chance that they may be of some value. I have + checked my results so far as possible by comparing them with the + experience of such of my friends as had coitus frequently and + were willing to tell me as much as they could of the psychology + of the process. + + "The first fact that I hit upon was the importance of pressure. + As one of my informants picturesquely phrases it--'the tighter + the fit the greater the pleasure.' This agrees, too, with their + unanimous testimony that the pleasurable sensations were much + greater when the orgasm occurred simultaneously in the man and + woman. Their analysis seldom went further than this, but a few + remarked that the distinctive sensations accompanying the orgasm + seem to begin near the root of the penis or in the testes, and + that they are qualitatively different from the tickling + sensations which precede them. + + "These tickling sensations are caused, I think, by the friction + of the glands against the vaginal walls, and are supplemented by + other sensations from the urethra, whose nerves are stimulated by + pressure of the vaginal walls and sphincter. The specific + sensation of the orgasm begins, I believe, with a strong + contraction of the muscles of the urethral walls along the entire + length of the canal, and is felt as a peculiar ache starting + from the base of the penis and quickly becoming diffused through + the whole organ. This sensation reaches its climax with the + expulsion of the semen into the urethra and the consequent + feeling of distention, which is instantly followed by the + rhythmic peristaltic contractions of the urethral muscles which + mark the climax of the orgasm. + + "The most careful introspection possible under the circumstances + seems to show that these sensations arise almost wholly from the + urethra and in a far less degree from the corona. During periods + of great sexual excitement the nerves of the urethra and corona + seem to possess a peculiar sensitivity and are powerfully + stimulated by the violent peristaltic contractions of the muscles + in the urethral walls during ejaculation. It seems possible that + the intensity and volume of sensation felt at the glans may be + due in part to the greater area of sensitive surface presented in + the fossa as well as to the sensitivity of the corona, and in + part to the fact that during the orgasm the glans is more highly + congested than at any other time, and the nerve endings thus + subjected to additional pressure. + + "If the foregoing statements are true, it is easy to see why the + pleasure of the man is much increased when the orgasm occurs at + the same time in his partner and himself, for the contractions of + the vagina upon the penis would increase the stimulation of all + the nerve endings in that organ for which a mechanical stimulus + is adequate, and the prominence of the corpus spongiosum and + corona would ensure them the greatest stimulation. It seems not + improbable that the specific sensation of orgasm rises from the + stimulation of the peculiar form of nerve end-bulbs which Krause + found in the corpus spongiosum and in the glans. + + "The characteristic massiveness of the experience is probably due + largely to the great number of sensations of strain and pressure + caused by the powerful reflex contraction of so many of the + voluntary muscles. + + "Of course, the foregoing analysis is purely tentative, and I + offer it only on the chance that it may suggest some line of + inquiry which may lead to results of value to the student of + sexual psychology." + + In man the whole process of detumescence, when it has once really + begun, only occupies a few moments. It is so likewise in many + animals; in the genera Bos, Ovis, etc., it is very short, almost + instantaneous, and rather short also in the Equidae (in a vigorous + stallion, according to Colin, ten to twelve seconds). As + Disselhorst has pointed out, this is dependent on the fact that + these animals, like man, possess a vas deferens which broadens + into an ampulla serving as a receptacle which holds the semen + ready for instant emission when required. On the other hand, in + the dog, cat, boar, and the Canidae, Felidae, and Suidae generally, + there is no receptacle of this kind, and coitus is slow, since a + longer time is required for the peristaltic action of the vas to + bring the semen to the urogenital sinus. (R. Disselhorst, _Die + Accessorischen Geschlechtsdrusen der Wirbelthiere_, 1897, p. + 212.) + + In man there can be little doubt that detumescence is more + rapidly accomplished in the European than in the East, in India, + among the yellow races, or in Polynesia. This is probably in part + due to a deliberate attempt to prolong the act in the East, and + in part to a greater nervous erethism among Westerns. + +In the woman the specifically sexual muscular process is less visible, +more obscure, more complex, and uncertain. Before detumescence actually +begins there are at intervals involuntary rhythmic contractions of the +walls of the vagina, seeming to have the object of at once stimulating and +harmonizing with those that are about to begin in the male organ. It would +appear that these rhythmic contractions are the exaggeration of a +phenomenon which is normal, just as slight contraction is normal and +constant in the bladder. Jastreboff has shown, in the rabbit, that the +vagina is in constant spontaneous rhythmic contraction from above +downward, not peristaltic, but in segments, the intensity of the +contractions increasing with age and especially with sexual development. +This vaginal contraction which in women only becomes well marked just +before detumescence, and is due mainly to the action of the sphincter +cunni (analogous to the bulbo-cavernosus in the male), is only a part of +the localized muscular process. At first there would appear to be a reflex +peristaltic movement of the Fallopian tubes and uterus. Dembo observed +that in animals stimulation of the upper anterior wall of the vagina +caused gradual contraction of the uterus, which is erected by powerful +contraction of its muscular fiber and round ligaments while at the same +time it descends toward the vagina, its cavity becoming more and more +diminished and mucus being forced out. In relaxing, Aristotle long ago +remarked, it aspirates the seminal fluid. + +Although the active participation of the sexual organs in woman, to the +end of directing the semen into the womb at the moment of detumescence, is +thus a very ancient belief, and harmonizes with the Greek view of the womb +as an animal in the body endowed with a considerable amount of +activity,[117] precise observation in modern times has offered but little +confirmation of the reality of this participation. Such observations as +have been made have usually been the accidental result of sexual +excitement and orgasm occurring during a gynaecological examination. As, +however, such a result is liable to occur in erotic subjects, a certain +number of precise observations have accumulated during the past century. +So far as the evidence goes, it would seem that in women, as in mares, +bitches, and other animals, the uterus becomes shorter, broader, and +softer during the orgasm, at the same time descending lower into the +pelvis, with its mouth open intermittently, so that, as one writer +remarks, spontaneously recurring to the simile which commended itself to +the Greeks, "the uterus might be likened to an animal gasping for +breath."[118] This sensitive, responsive mobility of the uterus is, +indeed, not confined to the moment of detumescence, but may occur at other +times under the influence of sexual emotion. + +It would seem probable that in this erection, contraction, and descent of +the uterus, and its simultaneous expulsion of mucus, we have the decisive +moment in the completion of detumescence in woman, and it is probable that +the thick mucus, unlike the earlier more limpid secretion, which women are +sometimes aware of after orgasm, is emitted from the womb at this time. +This is, however, not absolutely certain. Some authorities regard +detumescence in women as accomplished in the pouring out of secretions, +others in the rhythmic genital contractions; the sexual parts may, +however, be copiously bathed in mucus for an indefinitely long period +before the final stage of detumescence is achieved, and the rhythmic +contractions are also taking place at a somewhat early period; in neither +respect is there any obvious increase at the final moment of orgasm. In +women this would seem to be more conspicuously a nervous manifestation +than in men. On the subjective side it is very pronounced, with its +feeling of relieved tension and agreeable repose--a moment when, as one +woman expresses it, together with intense pleasure, there is, as it were, +a floating up into a higher sphere, like the beginning of chloroform +narcosis--but on the objective side this culminating moment is less easy +to define. + + Various observations and remarks made during the past two or + three centuries by Bond, Valisneri, Dionis, Haller, Guenther, and + Bischoff, tending to show a sucking action of the uterus in both + women and other female animals, have been brought together by + Litzmann in R. Wagner's _Handwoerterbuch der Physiologie_ (1846, + vol. iii, p. 53). Litzmann added an experience of his own: "I had + an opportunity lately, while examining a young and very erethic + woman, to observe how suddenly the uterus assumed a more erect + position, and descended deeper in the pelvis; the lips of the + womb became equal in length, the cervix rounded, softer, and more + easily reached by the finger, and at the same time a high state + of sexual excitement was revealed by the respiration and voice." + + The general belief still remained, however, that the woman's part + in conjugation is passive, and that it is entirely by the energy + of the male organ and of the male sexual elements, the + spermatozoa, that conjunction with the germ cell is attained. + According to this theory, it was believed that the spermatozoa + were, as Wilkinson expresses it, in a history of opinion on this + question, "endowed with some sort of intuition or instinct; that + they would turn in the direction of the os uteri, wading through + the acid mucus of the vagina; travel patiently upward and around + the vaginal portion of the uterus; enter the uterus and proceed + onward in search of the waiting ovum." (A.D. Wilkinson, + "Sterility in the Female," _Transactions of the Lincoln Medical + Society_, Nebraska, 1896.) + + About the year 1859 Fichstedt seems to have done something to + overthrow this theory by declaring his belief that the uterus was + not, as commonly supposed, a passive organ in coitus, but was + capable of sucking in the semen during the brief period of + detumescence. Various authorities then began to bring forward + arguments and observations in the same sense. Wernich, + especially, directed attention to this point in 1872 in a paper + on the erectile properties of the lower segment of the uterus + ("Die Erectionsfahigkeit des untern Uterus-Abschnitts," _Beitraege + zur Geburtshuelfe und Gynaekologie_, vol. i, p. 296). He made + precise observations and came to the conclusion that owing to + erectile properties in the neck of the uterus, this part of the + womb elongates during congress and reaches down into the pelvis + with an aspiratory movement, as if to meet the glans of the male. + A little later, in a case of partial prolapse, Beck, in ignorance + of Wernich's theory, was enabled to make a very precise + observation of the action of the uterus during excitement. In + this case the woman was sexually very excitable even under + ordinary examination, and Beck carefully noted the phenomena that + took place during the orgasm. "The os and cervix uteri," he + states, "had been about as firm as usual, moderately hard and, + generally speaking, in a natural and normal condition, with the + external os closed to such an extent as to admit of the uterine + probe with difficulty; but the instant that the height of + excitement was at hand, the os opened itself to the extent of + fully an inch, as nearly as my eye can judge, made five or six + successive gasps as if it were drawing the external os into the + cervix, each time powerfully, and, it seemed to me, with a + regular rhythmical action, at the same time losing its former + density and hardness and becoming quite soft to the touch. Upon + the cessation of the action, as related, the os suddenly closed, + the cervix again hardened itself, and the intense congestion was + dissipated." (J.R. Beck, "How do the Spermatozoa Enter the + Uterus?" _American Journal of Obstetrics_, 1874.) It would appear + that in the early part of this final process of detumescence the + action of the uterus is mainly one of contraction and ejaculation + of any mucus that may be contained; Dr. Paul Munde has described + "the gushing, almost in jets," of this mucus which he has + observed in an erotic woman under a rather long digital and + specular examination. (_American Journal of Obstetrics_, 1893.) + It is during the latter part of detumescence, it would seem, and + perhaps for a short time after the orgasm is over, that the + action of the uterus is mainly aspiratory. + +While the active part played by the womb in detumescence can no longer be +questioned, it need not too hastily be assumed that the belief in the +active movements of the spermatozoa must therefore be denied. The vigorous +motility of the tadpole-like organisms is obvious to anyone who has ever +seen fresh semen under the microscope; and if it is correct, as Clifton +Edgar states, that the spermatozoa may retain their full activity in the +female organs for at least seventeen days, they have ample time to exert +their energies. The fact that impregnation sometimes occurs without +rupture of the hymen is not decisive evidence that there has been no +penetration, as the hymen may dilate without rupturing; but there seems no +reason to doubt that conception has sometimes taken place when ejaculation +has occurred without penetration; this is indicated in a fairly objective +manner when, as has been occasionally observed, conception has occurred in +women whose vaginas were so narrow as scarcely to admit the entrance of a +goose-quill; such was the condition in the case of a pregnant woman +brought forward by Roubaud. The stories, repeated in various books, of +women who have conceived after homosexual relations with partners who had +just left their husbands' beds are not therefore inherently +impossible.[119] Janke quotes numerous cases in which there has been +impregnation in virgins who have merely allowed the penis to be placed in +contact with the vulva, the hymen remaining unruptured until +delivery.[120] + +It must be added, however, that even if the semen is effused merely at the +mouth of the vagina, without actual penetration, the spermatozoa are still +not entirely without any resource save their own motility in the task of +reaching the ovum. As we have seen, it is not only the uterus which takes +an active part in detumescence; the vagina also is in active movement, and +it seems highly probable that, at all events in some women and under some +circumstances, such movement favoring aspiration toward the womb may be +communicated to the external mouth of the vagina. + + Riolan (_Anthropographia_, 1626, p. 294) referred to the + constriction and dilation of the vulva under the influence of + sexual excitement. It is said that in Abyssinia women can, when + adopting the straddling posture of coitus, by the movements of + their own vaginal muscles alone, grasp the male organ and cause + ejaculation, although the man remains passive. According to + Lorion the Annamites, adopting the normal posture of coitus, + introduce the penis when flaccid or only half erect, the + contraction of the vaginal walls completing the process; the + penis is very small in this people. It is recognized by + gynaecologists that the condition of vaginismus, in which there is + spasmodic contraction of the vagina, making intercourse painful + or impossible, is but a morbid exaggeration of the normal + contraction which occurs in sexual excitement. Even in the + absence of sexual excitement there is a vague affection, + occurring in both married and unmarried women, and not, it would + seem, necessarily hysterical, characterized by quivering or + twitching of the vulva; I am told that this is popularly termed + "flackering of the shape" in Yorkshire and "taittering of the + lips" in Ireland. It may be added that quivering of the gluteal + muscles also takes place during detumescence, and that in Indian + medicine this is likewise regarded as a sign of sexual desire in + women, apart from coitus. + + A non-medical correspondent in Australia, W.J. Chidley, from whom + I have received many communications on this subject, is strongly + of opinion from his own observations that not only does the + uterus take an active part in coitus, but that under natural + conditions the vagina also plays an active part in the process. + He was led to suspect such an action many years ago, as well by + an experience of his own, as also by hearing from a young woman + who met her lover after a long absence that by the excitement + thus aroused a tape attached to the underclothes had been drawn + into the vagina. Since then the confidences of various friends, + together with observations of animals, have confirmed him in the + view that the general belief that coitus must be effected by + forcible entry of the male organ into a passive vagina is + incorrect. He considers that under normal circumstances coitus + should take place but rarely, and then only under the most + favorable circumstances, perhaps exclusively in spring, and, most + especially, only when the woman is ready for it. Then, when in + the arms of the man she loves, the vagina, in sympathy with the + active movements of the womb, becomes distended at the touch of + the turgescent, but not fully erect, penis, "flashes open and + draws in the male organ." "All animals," he adds, "have sexual + intercourse by the male organ being _drawn_, not forced, into the + female. I have been borne out in this by friends who have seen + horses, camels, mules and other large animals in the coupling + season. What is more absurd, for instance, than to say that an + entire _penetrates_ the mare? His penis is a sensitive, beautiful + piece of mechanism, which brings its light head here and there + till it touches the right spot, when the mare, _if ready_, takes + it in. An entire's penis could not penetrate anything; it is a + curve, a beautiful curve which would easily bend. A bull's, + again, is turned down at the end and, more palpably still, would + fold on itself if pressed with force. The womb and vagina of a + beautiful and healthy woman constitute a living, vital, moving + organ, sensitive to a look, a word, a thought, a hand on the + waist." + + A well-known American author thus writes in confirmation of the + foregoing view: "In nature the woman wooes. When impassioned her + vagina becomes erect and dilated, and so lubricated with abundant + mucus to the lips that entrance is easy. This dilatation and + erectile expansion of vagina withdraws the hymen so close to the + walls that penetration need not tear it or cause pain. The more + muscular, primitive and healthy the woman the tougher and less + sensitive the hymen, and the less likely to break or bleed. I + think one great function of the foreskin also is to moisten the + glans, so that it can be lubricated for entrance, and then to + retract, moist side out, to make entrance still easier. I think + that in nature the glans penetrates within the labia, is + withstood a moment, vibrating, and then all resistance is + withdrawn by a sudden 'flashing open' of the gates, permitting + easy entrance, and that the sudden giving up of resistance, and + substitution of welcome, with its instantaneous deep entrance, + causes an almost immediate male orgasm (the thrill being + irresistibly exciting). Certainly this is the process as observed + in horses, cattle, goats, etc., and it seems likely something + analogous is natural in man." + + While it is easily possible to carry to excess a view which would + make the woman rather than the man the active agent in coitus + (and it may be recalled that in the Cebidae the penis, as also the + clitoris, is furnished with a bone), there is probably an element + of truth in the belief that the vagina shares in the active part + which, there can now be little doubt, is played by the uterus in + detumescence. Such a view certainly enables us to understand how + it is that semen effused on the exterior sexual organs can be + conveyed to the uterus. + + It was indeed the failure to understand the vital activity of the + semen and the feminine genital canal, co-operating together + towards the junction of sperm cell and germ cell, which for so + long stood in the way of the proper understanding of conception. + Even the genius of Harvey, which had grappled successfully with + the problem of the circulation, failed in the attempt to + comprehend the problem of generation. Mainly on account of this + difficulty, he was unable to see how the male element could + possibly enter the uterus, although he devoted much observation + and study to the question. Writing of the uterus of the doe after + copulation, he says: "I began to doubt, to ask myself whether the + semen of the male could by any possibility make its way by + attraction or injection to the seat of conception, and repeated + examination led me to the conclusion that none of the semen + reached this seat." (_De-Generatione Animalium_, Exercise lxvii.) + "The woman," he finally concluded, "after contact with the + spermatic fluid _in coitu_, seems to receive an influence and + become fecundated without the co-operation of any sensible + corporeal agent, in the same way as iron touched by the magnet is + endowed with its powers." + +Although the specifically sexual muscular process of detumescence in +women--as distinguished from the general muscular phenomena of sexual +excitement which may be fairly obvious--is thus seen to be somewhat +complex and obscure, in women as well as in men detumescence is a +convulsion which discharges a slowly accumulated store of nervous force. +In women also, as in men, the motor discharge is directed to a specific +end--the intromission of the semen in the one sex, its reception in the +other. In both sexes the sexual orgasm and the pleasure and satisfaction +associated with it, involve, as their most essential element, the motor +activity of the sexual sphere.[121] + + The active co-operation of the female organs in detumescence is + probably indicated by the difficulty which is experienced in + achieving conception by the artificial injection of semen. Marion + Sims stated in 1866, in _Clinical Notes on Uterine Surgery_, that + in 55 injections in six women he had only once been successful; + he believed that that was the only case at that time on record. + Jacobi had, however, practiced artificial fecundation in animals + (in 1700) and John Hunter in man. See Gould and Pyle, _Anomalies + and Curiosities of Medicine_, p. 43; also Janke (_Die + Willkuerliche Hervorbringen des Geschlechts_, pp. 230 et seq.) who + discusses the question of artificial fecundation and brings + together a mass of data. + +The facial expression when tumescence is completed is marked by a high +degree of energy in men and of loveliness in women. At this moment, when +the culminating act of life is about to be accomplished, the individual +thus reaches his supreme state of radiant beauty. The color is heightened, +the eyes are larger and brighter, the facial muscles are more tense, so +that in mature individuals any wrinkles disappear and youthfulness +returns. + +At the beginning of detumescence the features are frequently more +discomposed. There is a general expression of eager receptivity to sensory +impressions. The dilatation of the pupils, the expansion of the nostrils, +the tendency to salivation and to movements of the tongue, all go to make +up a picture which indicates an approaching gratification of sensory +desires; it is significant that in some animals there is at this moment +erection of the ears.[122] There is sometimes a tendency to utter broken +and meaningless words, and it is noted that sometimes women have called +out on their mothers.[123] The dilatation of the pupils produces +photophobia, and in the course of detumescence the eyes are frequently +closed from this cause. At the beginning of sexual excitement, Vaschide +and Vurpas have observed, tonicity of the eye-muscles seems to increase; +the elevators of the upper lids contract, so that the eyes look larger and +their mobility and brightness are heightened; with the increase of +muscular tonicity strabismus occurs, owing to the greater strength of the +muscles that carry the eyes inward.[124] + + The facial expression which marks the culmination of tumescence, + and the approach of detumescence is that which is generally + expressive of joy. In an interesting psycho-physical study of the + emotion of joy, Dearborn thus summarizes its characteristics: + "The eyes are brighter and the upper eyelid elevated, as also are + the brows, the skin over the glabella, the upper lip and the + corners of the mouth, while the skin at the outer canthi of the + eye is puckered. The nostrils are moderately dilated, the tongue + slightly extended and the cheeks somewhat expanded, while in + persons with largely developed pinnal muscles the ears tend + somewhat to incline forwards. The whole arterial system is + dilated, with consequent blushing from this effect on the dermal + capillaries of the face, neck, scalp and hands, and sometimes + more extensively even; from the same cause the eyes slightly + bulge. The whole glandular system likewise is stimulated, causing + the secretions,--gastric, salivary, lachrymal, sudoral, mammary, + genital, etc.--to be increased, with the resulting rise of + temperature and increase in the katobolism generally. Volubility + is almost regularly increased, and is, indeed, one of the most + sensitive and constant of the correlations in emotional + delight.... Pleasantness is correlated in living organisms by + vascular, muscular and glandular extension or expansion, both + literal and figurative." (G. Dearborn, "The Emotion of Joy," + _Psychological Review Monograph Supplements_, vol. ii, No. 5, p. + 62.) All these signs of joy appear to occur at some stage of the + process of sexual excitement. + + In some monkeys it would seem that the muscular movement which in + man has become the smile is the characteristic facial expression + of sexual tumescence or courtship. Discussing the facial + expression of pleasure in children, S.S. Buckman has the + following remarks: "There is one point in such expression which + has not received due consideration, namely, the raising of lumps + of flesh each side of the nose as an indication of pleasure. + Accompanying this may be seen small furrows, both in children and + adults, running from the eyes somewhat obliquely towards the + nose. What these characters indicate may be learned from the male + mandril, whose face, particularly in the breeding season, shows + colored fleshy prominences each side of the nose, with + conspicuous furrows and ridges. In the male mandril these + characters have been developed because, being an unmistakable + sign of sexual ardor, they gave the female particular evidence of + sexual feelings. Thus such characters would come to be recognized + as habitually symptomatic of pleasurable feelings. Finding + similar features in human beings, and particularly in children, + though not developed in the same degree, we may assume that in + our monkey-like ancestors facial characters similar to those of + the mandril were developed, though to a less extent, and that + they were symptomatic of pleasure, because connected with the + period of courtship. Then they became conventionalized as + pleasurable symptoms." (S.S. Buckmann, "Human Babies: What They + Teach," _Nature_, July 5, 1900.) If this view is accepted, it may + be said that the smile, having in man become a generalized sign + of amiability, has no longer any special sexual significance. It + is true that a faint and involuntary smile is often associated + with the later stages of tumescence, but this is usually lost + during detumescence, and may even give place to an expression of + ferocity. + +When we have realized how profound is the organic convulsion involved by +the process of detumescence, and how great the general motor excitement +involved, we can understand how it is that very serious effects may follow +coitus. Even in animals this is sometimes the case. Young bulls and +stallions have fallen in a faint after the first congress; boars may be +seriously affected in a similar way; mares have been known even to fall +dead.[125] In the human species, and especially in men--probably, as Bryan +Robinson remarks, because women are protected by the greater slowness with +which detumescence occurs in them--not only death itself, but innumerable +disorders and accidents have been known to follow immediately after +coitus, these results being mainly due to the vascular and muscular +excitement involved by the processes of detumescence. Fainting, vomiting, +urination, defaecation have been noted as occurring in young men after a +first coitus. Epilepsy has been not infrequently recorded. Lesions of +various organs, even rupture of the spleen, have sometimes taken place. In +men of mature age the arteries have at times been unable to resist the +high blood-pressure, and cerebral haemorrhage with paralysis has occurred. +In elderly men the excitement of intercourse with strange women has +sometimes caused death, and various cases are known of eminent persons who +have thus died in the arms of young wives or of prostitutes.[126] + +These morbid results, are, however, very exceptional. They usually occur +in persons who are abnormally sensitive, or who have imprudently +transgressed the obvious rules of sexual hygiene. Detumescence is so +profoundly natural a process; it is so deeply and intimately a function of +the organism, that it is frequently harmless even when the bodily +condition is far from absolutely sound. Its usual results, under favorable +circumstances, are entirely beneficial. In men there normally supervenes, +together with the relief from the prolonged tension of tumescence, with +the muscular repose and falling blood-pressure,[127] a sense of profound +satisfaction, a glow of diffused well-being,[128] perhaps an agreeable +lassitude, occasionally also a sense of mental liberation from an +overmastering obsession. Under reasonably happy circumstances there is no +pain, or exhaustion, or sadness, or emotional revulsion. The happy lover's +attitude toward his partner is not expressed by the well-known Sonnet +(CXXIX) of Shakespeare:-- + + "Past reason hunted, and no sooner had + Past reason hated." + +He feels rather with Boccaccio that the kissed mouth loses not its charm, + + "Bocca baciata non perde ventura." + +In women the results of detumescence are the same, except that the +tendency to lassitude is not marked unless the act has been several times +repeated; there is a sensation of repose and self-assurance, and often an +accession of free and joyous energy. After completely satisfactory +detumescence she may experience a feeling as of intoxication, lasting for +several hours, an intoxication that is followed by no evil reaction. + +Such, so far as our present vague and imperfect knowledge extends, are the +main features in the process of detumescence. In the future, without +doubt, we shall learn to know more precisely a process which has been so +supremely important in the life of man and of his ancestors. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[98] The elements furnished by the sense of touch in sexual selection have +been discussed in the first section of the previous volume of these +_Studies_. + +[99] See Appendix A. "The Origins of the Kiss," in the previous volume. + +[100] See, e.g., Art. "Erection," by Retterer, in Richet's _Dictionnaire +de Physiologie_, vol. v. + +[101] Guibaut, _Traite Clinique des Maladies des Femmes_, p. 242. Adler +discusses the sexual secretions in women and their significance, _Die +Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, pp. 19-26. + +[102] In some parts of the world this is further aided by artificial +means. Thus it is stated by Riedel (as quoted by Ploss and Bartels) that +in the Gorong Archipelago the bridegroom, before the first coitus, anoints +the bride's pudenda with an ointment containing opium, musk, etc. I have +been told of an English bride who was instructed by her mother to use a +candle for the same purpose. + +[103] _Parthenologia_, pp. 302, et seq. + +[104] The connection of this mucous flow with sexual emotion was discussed +early in the eighteenth century by Schurig in his _Gynaecologia_, pp. 8-11; +it is frequently passed over by more modern writers. + +[105] The drawing is reproduced by Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, +Chapter XVII; many facts bearing on the ethnography of coitus are brought +together in this chapter. + +[106] Onanoff (Paris Societe de Biologie, May 3, 1890) proposed the name +of bulbo-cavernous reflex for the smart contraction of the ischio-and +bulbo-cavernosus muscles (erector penis and accelerator urinae) produced by +mechanical excitation of the glans. This reflex is clinically elicited by +placing the index-finger of the left hand on the region of the bulb while +the right hand rapidly rubs the dorsal surface of the glands with the edge +of a piece of paper or lightly pinches the mucous membrane; a twitching of +the region of the bulb is then perceived. This reflex is always present in +healthy adult subjects and indicates the integrity of the physical +mechanism of detumescence. It has been described by Hughes. (C.H. Hughes, +"The Virile or Bulbo-cavernous Reflex," _Alienist and Neurologist_, +January, 1898.) + +[107] Roubaud, _Traite de l'Impuissance_, 1855, p. 39. + +[108] _Das Weib_, seventh edition, vol. i, p. 510. + +[109] The influence of impeded respiration in exciting more or less +perverted forms of sexual gratification has been discussed in a section of +"Love and Pain" in the third volume of these _Studies_. + +[110] See, e.g., the experiments of Obici on this point, _Revista +Sperimentale di Freniatria_, 1903, pp. 689, et seq. + +[111] Summarized in _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, March, 1903, p. +188. The tendency to closure of the eyes noted by Roubaud, to avoid +contact of the light, indicates dilatation of the pupils, for which we +need not seek other explanation than the general tendency of all +peripheral stimulation, according to Schiff's law, to produce such +dilatation. + +[112] Vaschide and Vurpas, "Du Coefficient Sexuel de l'Impulsion +Musicale," _Archives de Neurologie_, May, 1904. + +[113] In the _Priapeia_ is an inscription which has thus been +translated:-- + + "You see this organ, after which I'm called + And which is my certificate, is humid; + This moisture is not dew nor drops of rain, + It is the outcome of sweet memory, + Recalling thoughts of a complacent maid." + +The translator supposes that semen is referred to, but without doubt the +allusion is to the theologians' _distillatio_. + +[114] A woman of 30, normal and intelligent, after conversing on love and +passion, and then listening to the music of Grieg and Schumann, felt real +and strong sexual excitement, increased by memories recalled by the +presence of a sympathetic person. When then tested by the dynamometer the +average of ten efforts with the right hand was found to be 28.2 (her +normal average being 31.1) and with the left hand 28.0 (the normal being +30.0). There was, however, great variability in the individual pressures +which sometimes equaled and even exceeded the subject's normal efforts. +The voluntary muscles are thus in harmony with the approaching general +sexual avalanche. (Vaschide and Vurpas, "Quelques Donnees Experimentales +sur l'Influence de l'Excitation Sexuelle," _Archivio di Psichiatria_, +1903, fasc. v-vi.) + +[115] Cf. MacGillicuddy, _Functional Disorders of the Nervous System in +Women_, p. 110; Fere, _L'Instinct Sexuel_, second edition, p. 238; id., +"Note sur une Anomalie de l'instinct Sexuel," _Belgique Medicale_, 1905; +also "Analysis of the Sexual Impulse," in an earlier volume of these +_Studies_. + +[116] J.P. West, "Masturbation in Early Childhood," _Medical Standard_, +November, 1895. + +[117] Cf. the discussion of hysteria in "Auto-Erotism," vol. i of these +_Studies_. + +[118] Hirst, _Text-Book of Obstetrics_, 1899, p. 67. + +[119] The earliest story of the kind with which I am acquainted, that of a +widow who was thus impregnated by a married friend, is quoted in Schurig's +_Spermatologia_ (p. 224) from Amatus Lusitanus, _Curationum Centuriae +Septum_, 1629. + +[120] Janke, _Die Willkuerliche Hervorbringen des Geschlechts_, p. 238. + +[121] Cf. Adler, _Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, pp. +29-38. + +[122] Fere, _Pathologie des Emotions_, p. 51. + +[123] This is an instinctive impulse under all strong emotion in primitive +persons. "The Australian Dieri," says A.W. Howitt (_Journal +Anthropological Institute_, August, 1890), "when in pain or grief cry out +for their father or mother." + +[124] Vaschide and Vurpas, _Archives de Neurologie_, May, 1904. + +[125] F.B. Robinson, _New York Medical Journal_, March 11, 1893. + +[126] Fere deals fully with the various morbid results which may follow +coitus, _L' Instinct Sexuel_, Chapter X; id., _Pathologie des Emotions_, +p. 99. + +[127] With regard to the relationship of detumescence to the +blood-pressure Haig remarks: "I think that as the sexual act produces low +and falling blood-pressure, it will of necessity relieve conditions which +are due to high and rising blood-pressure, such, for instance, as mental +depression and bad temper; and, unless my observation deceives me, we have +here a connection between conditions of high blood-pressure, with mental +and bodily depression, and the act of masturbation, for this act will +relieve those conditions, and will tend to be practiced for this purpose." +(A. Haig, _Uric Acid_, sixth edition, p. 154.) + +[128] A medical correspondent speaks of subjective feelings of temperature +coming over the body from 20 to 24 hours after congress, and marked by +sensations of cooling of body and glow of cheeks. In another case, though +lassitude appears on the second day after congress, the first day after is +marked by a notable increase in mental and physical activity. + + + + +III. + +The Constituents of Semen--Function of the Prostate--The Properties of +Semen--Aphrodisiacs--Alcohol, Opium, etc.--Anaphrodisiacs--The Stimulant +Influence of Semen in Coitus--The Internal Effects of Testicular +Secretions--The Influence of Ovarian Secretion. + + +The germ cell never comes into the sphere of consciousness and cannot +therefore concern us in the psychological study of the phenomena of the +sexual instinct. But it is otherwise with the sperm cell, and the seminal +fluid has a relationship, both direct and indirect, to psychic phenomena +which it is now necessary to discuss. + +While the spermatozoa are formed in the glandular tissue of the testes, +the seminal fluid as finally emitted in detumescence is not a purely +testicular product, but is formed by mixture with the fluids poured out at +or before detumescence by various glands which open into the urethra, and +notably the prostate.[129] This is a purely sexual gland, which in animals +only becomes large and active during the breeding season, and may even be +hardly distinguishable at other times; moreover, if the testes are removed +in infancy, the prostate remains rudimentary, so that during recent years +removal of the testes has been widely advocated and practiced for that +hypertrophy of the prostate which is sometimes a distressing ailment of +old age. It is the prostatic fluid, according to Fuerbringer, which imparts +its characteristic odor to semen. It appears, however, to be the main +function of the prostatic fluid to arouse and maintain the motility of the +spermatozoa; before meeting the prostatic fluid the spermatozoa are +motionless; that fluid seems to furnish a thinner medium in which they +for the first time gain their full vitality.[130] + +When at length the semen is ejaculated, it contains various substances +which may be separated from it,[131] and possesses various qualities, some +of which have only lately been investigated, while others have evidently +been known to mankind from a very early period. "When held for some time +in the mouth," remarked John Hunter, "it produces a warmth similar to +spices, which lasts some time."[132] Possibly this fact first suggested +that semen might, when ingested, possess valuable stimulant qualities, a +discovery which has been made by various savages, notably by the +Australian aborigines, who, in many parts of Australia, administer a +potion of semen to dying or feeble members of the tribe.[133] It is +perhaps noteworthy that in Central Africa the testes of the goat are +consumed as an aphrodisiac.[134] In eighteenth century Europe, Schurig, in +his _Spermatologia_, still found it necessary to discuss at considerable +length the possible medical properties of human semen, giving many +prescriptions which contained it.[135] The stimulation produced by the +ingestion of semen would appear to form in some cases a part of the +attraction exerted by _fellatio_; De Sade emphasized this point; and in a +case recorded by Howard semen appears to have acted as a stimulant for +which the craving was as irresistible as is that for alcohol in +dipsomania.[136] + + It must be remembered that the early history of this subject is + more or less inextricably commingled with folk-lore practices of + magical origin, not necessarily founded on actual observation of + the physiological effects of consuming the semen or testes. Thus, + according to W.H. Pearse (_Scalpel_, December, 1897), it is the + custom in Cornwall for country maids to eat the testicles of the + young male lambs when they are castrated in the spring, the + survival, probably, of a very ancient religious cult. (I have not + myself been able to hear of this custom in Cornwall.) In + Burchard's Penitential (Cap. CLIV, Wasserschleben, op. cit., p. + 660) seven years' penance is assigned to the woman who swallows + her husband's semen to make him love her more. In the seventeenth + century (as shown in William Salmon's _London Dispensatory_, + 1678) semen was still considered to be good against witchcraft + and also valuable as a love-philter, in which latter capacity its + use still survives. (Bourke, _Scatalogic Rites_, pp. 343, 355.) + In an earlier age (Picart, quoted by Crawley, _The Mystic Rose_, + p. 109) the Manichaeans, it is said, sprinkled their eucharistic + bread with human semen, a custom followed by the Albigenses. + + The belief, perhaps founded in experience, that semen possesses + medical and stimulant virtues was doubtless fortified by the + ancient opinion that the spinal cord is the source of this fluid. + This was not only held by the highest medical authorities in + Greece, but also in India and Persia. + + The semen is thus a natural stimulant, a physiological + aphrodisiac, the type of a class of drugs which have been known + and cultivated in all parts of the world from time immemorial. + (Dufour has discussed the aphrodisiacs used in ancient Rome, + _Histoire de la Prostitution_, vol. II, ch. 21.) It would be vain + to attempt to enumerate all the foods and medicaments to which + has been ascribed an influence in heightening the sexual impulse. + (Thus, in the sixteenth century, aphrodisiacal virtues were + attributed to an immense variety of foods by Liebault in his + _Thresor des Remedes Secrets pour les Maladies des Femmes_, 1585, + pp. 104, et seq.) A large number of them certainly have no such + effect at all, but have obtained this credit either on some + magical ground or from a mistaken association. Thus the potato, + when first introduced from America, had the reputation of being a + powerful aphrodisiac, and the Elizabethan dramatists contain many + references to this supposed virtue. As we know, potatoes, even + when taken in the largest doses, have not the slightest + aphrodisiac effect, and the Irish peasantry, whose diet consists + very largely of potatoes, are even regarded as possessing an + unusually small measure of sexual feeling. It is probable that + the mistake arose from the fact that potatoes were originally a + luxury, and luxuries frequently tend to be regarded as + aphrodisiacs, since they are consumed under circumstances which + tend to arouse the sexual desires. It is possible also that, as + has been plausibly suggested, the misunderstanding may have been + due to sailors--the first to be familiar with the potato--who + attributed to this particular element of their diet ashore the + generally stimulating qualities of their life in port. The eryngo + (_Eryngium maritimum_), or sea holly, which also had an erotic + reputation in Elizabethan times, may well have acquired it in the + same way. Many other vegetables have a similar reputation, which + they still retain. Thus onions are regarded as aphrodisiacal, and + were so regarded by the Greeks, as we learn from Aristophanes. It + is noteworthy that Marro, a reliable observer, has found that in + Italy, both in prisons and asylums, lascivious people are fond of + onions (_La Puberta_, p. 297), and it may perhaps be worth while + to recall the observation of Serieux that in a woman in whom the + sexual instinct only awoke in middle age there was a horror of + leeks. In some countries, and especially in Belgium, celery is + popularly looked upon as a sexual stimulant. Various condiments, + again, have the same reputation, perhaps because they are hot and + because sexual desire is regarded, rightly enough, as a kind of + heat. Fish--skate, for instance, and notably oysters and other + shellfish--are very widely regarded as aphrodisiacs, and Kisch + attributes this property to caviar. It is probable that all these + and other foods which have obtained this reputation, in so far as + they have any action whatever on the sexual appetite, only + possess it by virtue of their generally nutritious and + stimulating qualities, and not by the presence of any special + principle having a selective action on the sexual sphere. A + beefsteak is probably as powerful a sexual stimulant as any food; + a nutritious food, however, which is at the same time easily + digestible, and thus requiring less expenditure of energy for its + absorption, may well exert a specially rapid and conspicuous + stimulant effect. But it is not possible to draw a line, and, as + Aquinas long since said, if we wish to maintain ourselves in a + state of purity we shall fear even an immoderate use of bread and + water. + + More definitely aphrodisiacal effects are produced by drugs, and + especially by drugs which in large doses are poisons. The + aphrodisiac with the widest popular reputation is cantharides, + but its sexually exciting effects are merely an accidental result + of its action in causing inflammation of the genito-urinary + passage, and it is both an uncertain and a dangerous result, + except in skillful hands and when administered in small doses. + Nux vomica (with its alkaloid strychnia), by virtue of its + special action on the spinal cord, has a notably pronounced + effect in heightening the irritability of the spinal ejaculatory + center, though it by no means necessarily exerts any + strengthening influence. Alcohol exerts a sexually exciting + effect, but in a different manner; it produces little stimulation + of the cord and, indeed, even paralyzes the lumbar sexual center + in large doses, but it has an influence on the peripheral + nerve-endings and on the skin, and also on the cerebral centers, + tending to arouse desire and to diminish inhibition. In this + latter way, as Adler remarks, it may, in small doses, under some + circumstances, be beneficial in men with an excessive + nervousness or dread of coitus, and women, in whom orgasm has + been difficult to reach, have frequently found this facilitated + by some previous indulgence in alcohol. The aphrodisiac effect of + alcohol seems specially marked on women. But against the use of + alcohol as an aphrodisiac it must be remembered that it is far + from being a tonic to detumescence, at all events in men, and + that there is much evidence tending to show that not only chronic + alcoholism, but even procreation during intoxication is perilous + to the offspring (see, e.g., Andriezen, _Journal of Mental + Science_, January, 1905, and cf. W.C. Sullivan, "Alcoholism and + Suicidal Impulses," ib., April, 1898, p. 268); it may be added + that Bunge has found a very high proportion of cases of + immoderate use of alcohol in the fathers of women unable to + suckle their infants (G. von Bunge, _Die Zunehmende Unfaehigkeit + der Frauen ihre Kinder zu Stillen_, 1903) while even an + approximation to the drunken state is far from being a desirable + prelude to the creation of a new human being. It is obvious that + those who wish, for any reason, to cultivate a strict chastity of + thought and feeling would do well to avoid alcohol altogether, or + only in its lightest forms and in moderation. The aphrodisiacal + effects of wine have long been known; Ovid refers to them (e.g., + _Ars Am._, Bk. III, 765). Clement of Alexandria, who was + something of a man of science as well as a Christian moralist, + points out the influence of wine in producing lasciviousness and + sexual precocity. (_Paedagogus_, Bk. II, Chapter II). Chaucer + makes the Wife of Bath say in the Wife of Bath's Prologue:-- + + "And, after wyn, on Venus moste [needs] I thinke: + For al so siken as cold engendreth hayl, + A likerous mouth moste have a likerous tayl, + In womman vinolent is no defense, + This knowen lechours by experience." + + Alcohol, as Chaucer pointed out, comes to the aid of the man, who + is unscrupulous in his efforts to overcome a woman, and this not + merely by virtue of its aphrodisiacal effects, and the apparently + special influence which it seems to exert on women, but also + because it lulls the mental and emotional characteristics which + are the guardians of personality. A correspondent who has + questioned on this point a number of prostitutes he has known, + writes: "Their accounts of the first fall were nearly always the + same. They got to know a 'gentleman,' and on one occasion they + drank too much; before they quite realized what was happening + they were no longer virgins." "In the mental areas, under the + influence of alcohol," Schmiedeberg remarks (in his _Elements of + Pharmacology_), "the finer degrees of observation, judgment, and + reflection are the first to disappear, while the remaining mental + functions remain in a normal condition. The soldier acts more + boldly because he notices dangers less and reflects over them + less; the orator does not allow himself to be influenced by any + disturbing side-considerations as to his audience, hence he + speaks more freely and spiritedly; self-consciousness is lost to + a very great extent, and many are astounded at the ease with + which they can express their thoughts, and at the acuteness of + their judgment in matters which, when they are perfectly sober, + with difficulty reach their minds; and then afterwards they are + ashamed at their mistakes." + + The action of opium in small doses is also to some extent + aphrodisiacal; it slightly stimulates both the brain and the + spinal cord, and has sensory effects on the skin like alcohol; + these effects are favored by the state of agreeable dreaminess it + produces. In the seventeenth century Venette (_La Generation de + l'Homme_, Part II, Chapter V) strongly recommended small doses of + opium, then little known, for this purpose; he had himself, he + says, in illness experienced its joys, "a shadow of those of + heaven." In India opium (as well as cannabis indica) has long + been a not uncommon aphrodisiac; it is specially used to diminish + local sensibility, delaying the orgasm and thus prolonging the + sexual act. (W.D. Sutherland, "De Impotentia," _Indian Medical + Gazette_, January, 1900). Its more direct and stimulating + influence on the sexual emotions seems indicated by the statement + that prostitutes are found standing outside the opium-smoking + dens of Bombay, but not outside the neighboring liquor shops. + (G.C. Lucas, _Lancet_, February 2, 1884.) Like alcohol, opium + seems to have a marked aphrodisiacal effect on women. The case is + recorded of a mentally deranged girl, with no nymphomania though + she masturbated, who on taking small doses of opium at once + showed signs of nymphomania, following men about, etc. (_American + Journal Obstetrics_, May, 1901, p. 74.) It may well be believed + that opium acts beneficially in men when the ejaculatory centers + are weak but irritable; but its actions are too widespread over + the organism to make it in any degree a valuable aphrodisiac. + Various other drugs have more or less reputation as aphrodisiacs; + thus bromide of gold, a nervous and glandular stimulant, is said + to have as one of its effects a heightening of sexual feeling. + Yohimbin, an alkaloid derived from the West African Yohimbehe + tree, has obtained considerable repute during recent years in the + treatment of impotence; in some cases (see, e.g., Toff's results, + summarized in _British Medical Journal_, February 18, 1905) it + has produced good results, apparently by increasing the blood + supply to the sexual organs, but has not been successful in all + cases or in all hands. It must always be remembered that in cases + of psychical impotence suggestion necessarily exerts a beneficial + influence, and this may work through any drug or merely with the + aid of bread pills. All exercise, often even walking, may be a + sexual stimulant, and it is scarcely necessary to add that + powerful stimulation of the skin in the sexual sphere, and more + especially of the nates, is often a more effective aphrodisiac + than any drug, whether the irritation is purely mechanical, as by + flogging, or mechanico-chemical, as by urtication or the + application of nettles. Among the Malays (with whom both men and + women often use a variety of plants as aphrodisiacs, according to + Vaughan Stevens) Breitenstein states (_21 Jahre in India_, Theil + I, p. 228) that both massage and gymnastics are used to increase + sexual powers. The local application of electricity is one of the + most powerful of aphrodisiacs, and McMordie found on applying one + pole to a uterine sound in the uterus and the other to the + abdominal wall that in the majority of healthy women the orgasm + occurred. + + Among anaphrodisiacs, or sexual sedatives, bromide of potassium, + by virtue of its antidotal relationship to strychnia, is one of + the drugs whose action is most definite, though, while it dulls + sexual desire, it also dulls all the nervous and cerebral + activities. Camphor has an ancient reputation as an + anaphrodisiac, and its use in this respect was known to the Arabs + (as may be seen by a reference to it in the _Perfumed Garden_), + while, as Hyrtl mentions (loc. cit. ii, p. 94), rue (_Ruta + graveolens_) was considered a sexual sedative by the monks of + old, who on this account assiduously cultivated it in their + cloister gardens to make _vinum rutae_. Recently heroin in large + doses (see, e.g., Becker, _Berliner Klinische Wochenschrift_, + November 23, 1903) has been found to have a useful effect in this + direction. It may be doubted, however, whether there is any + satisfactory and reliable anaphrodisiac. Charcot, indeed, it is + said, used to declare that the only anaphrodisiac in which he had + any confidence was that used by the uncle of Heloise in the case + of Abelard. "_Cela_ (he would add with a grim smile) _tranche la + difficulte_." + +If semen is a stimulant when ingested, it is easy to suppose that it may +exert a similar action on the woman who receives it into the vagina in +normal sexual congress. It is by no means improbable that, as Mattei +argued in 1878, this is actually the case. It is known that the vagina +possesses considerable absorptive power. Thus Coen and Levi, among others, +have shown that if a tampon soaked in a solution of iodine is introduced +into the vagina, iodine will be found in the urine within an hour. And the +same is true of various other substances.[137] If the vagina absorbs drugs +it probably absorbs semen. Toff, of Braila (Roumania), who attaches much +importance to such absorption, considers that it must be analogous to the +ingestion of organic extractives. It is due to this influence, he +believes, that weak and anaemic girls so often become full-blooded and +robust after marriage, and lose their nervous tendencies and shyness.[138] + +It is, however, most certainly a mistake to suppose that the beneficial +influence of coitus on women is exclusively, or even mainly, dependent +upon the absorption of semen. This is conclusively demonstrated by the +fact that such beneficial influence is exerted, and in full measure, even +when all precautions have been taken to avoid any contact with the semen. +In so far as _coitus reservatus_ or _interruptus_ may lead to haste or +discomfort which prevents satisfactory orgasm on the part of the woman, it +is without doubt a cause of defective detumescence and incomplete +satisfaction. But if orgasm is complete the beneficial effects of coitus +follow even if there has been no possibility of the absorption of semen. +Even after _coitus interruptus_, if it can be prolonged for a period long +enough for the woman to attain full and complete satisfaction, she is +enabled to experience what she may describe as a feeling of intoxication, +lasting for several hours. It is in the action of the orgasm itself, and +the vascular, secretory, and metabolic activities set up by the psychic +and nervous influence of coitus with a beloved person, that we must seek +the chief key to the effects produced by coitus on women, however these +effects may possibly be still further heightened by the actual absorption +of semen.[139] + +The positive action of semen, or rather of the testicular products, has +been much investigated during recent years, and appears on the whole to be +demonstrated. The notable discovery by Brown-Sequard, a quarter of a +century ago, that the ingestion of the testicular juices in states of +debility and senility acted as a beneficial stimulant and tonic, opened +the way to a new field of therapeutics. Many investigators in various +countries have found that testicular extracts, and more especially the +spermin as studied by Poehl,[140] and by him regarded as a positive +katalysator or accelerator of metabolic processes, exert a real influence +in giving tone to the heart and other muscles, and in improving the +metabolism of the tissues even when all influences of mental suggestion +have been excluded.[141] + + As the ovaries are strictly analogous to the testes, it was + surmised that ovarian extract might prove a drug equally valuable + with testicular products. As a matter of fact, ovarian extract, + in the form of ovarin, etc., would seem to have proved beneficial + in various disorders, more especially in anaemia and in troubles + due to the artificial menopause. In most conditions, however, in + which it has been employed the results are doubtful or uncertain, + and some authorities believe that the influence of suggestion + plays a considerable part here. + +There is, however, another use which is subserved by the testicular +products, a use which may indeed be said to be implied in those uses to +which reference has already been made, but is yet historically the latest +to be realized and studied. It was not until 1869 that Brown-Sequard first +suggested that an important secretion was elaborated by the ductless +glands and received into the circulation, but that suggestion proved to be +epoch-making. If these glandular secretions are so valuable when +administered as drugs to other persons, must they not be of far greater +value when naturally secreted and poured out into the circulation in the +living body? It is now generally believed, on the basis of a large and +various body of evidence, that this is undoubtedly so. In a very crude +form, indeed, this belief is by no means modern. In opposition to the old +writers who were inclined to regard the semen as an excretion which it was +beneficial to expel, there were other ancient authorities who argued that +it was beneficial to retain it as being a vital fluid which, if +reabsorbed, served to invigorate the body. The great physiologist, Haller, +in the middle of the eighteenth century, came very near to the modern +doctrine when he stated in his _Elements of Physiology_ that the sperm +accumulated in the seminical vesicles is pumped back into the blood, and +thus produces the beard and the hair together with the other surprising +changes of puberty which are absent in the eunuch. The reabsorption of +semen can scarcely be said to be a part of the modern physiological +doctrine, but it is at least now generally held that the testes secrete +substances which pass into the circulation and are of immense importance +in the development of the organism. + +The experiments of Shattock and Seligmann indicate that the semen and its +reabsorption in the seminal vesicles, or the nervous reactions produced by +its presence, can have no part in the formation of secondary sexual +characters. These investigators occluded the vas deferens in sheep by +ligature, at an early age, rendering them later sterile though not +impotent. The secondary sexual characters appeared as in ordinary sheep. +Spermatogenesis, these inquirers conclude, may be the initial factor, but +the results must be attributed to the elaboration by the testicles of an +internal secretion and its absorption into the general circulation.[142] + +When animals are castrated there is enlargement of the ductless glands in +the body, notably the thyroid and the suprarenal capsules.[143] It is +evident, therefore, that the secretions of these ductless glands are in +some degree compensatory to those of the testes. But this compensatory +action is inadequate to produce any sexual development in the absence of +the testes. + +We see, therefore, how extremely important is the function of the testis. +Its significance is not alone for the race, it is not simply concerned +with the formation of the spermatozoa which share equally with the ova the +honor of making the mankind of the future. It also has a separate and +distinct function which has reference to the individual. It elaborates +those internal secretions which stimulate and maintain the physical and +mental characters, constituting all that is most masculine in the male +animal, all that makes the man in distinction from the eunuch. Among +various primitive peoples, including those of the European race whence we +ourselves spring, the most solemn form of oath was sworn by placing the +hand on the testes, dimly recognized as the most sacred part of the body. +A crude and passing phase of civilization has ignorantly cast ignominy +upon the sexual organs; the more primitive belief is now justified by our +advancing knowledge. + + In these as in other respects the ovaries are precisely analogous + to the testes. They not only form the ova, but they elaborate for + internal use a secretion which develops and maintains the special + physical and mental qualities of womanhood, as the testicular + secretion those of manhood. Moreover, as Cecca and Zappi found, + removal of the ovaries has exactly the same effect on the + abnormal development of the other ductless glands as has removal + of the testes. It is of interest to point out that the internal + secretion of the ovaries and its important functions seem to have + been suggested before any other secretion than the sperm was + attributed to the testes. Early in the nineteenth century Cabanis + argued ("De l'Influence des Sexes sur le Caractere des Idees et + des Affections Morales," _Rapport du Physique et du Moral de + l'Homme_, 1824, vol. ii, p. 18) that the ovaries are secreting + glands, forming a "particular humor" which is reabsorbed into the + blood and imparts excitations which are felt by the whole system + and all its organs. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[129] The composite character of the semen was recognized by various old +authors, some of whom said, (e.g., Wharton) that it had three +constituents, which they usually considered to be: (1) The noblest and +most essential part, from the testicles; (2) a watery element from the +vesiculae; (3) an oily element from the prostate. Schurig, _Spermatologia_, +1720, p. 17. + +[130] See, e.g., C. Mansell Moulin, "A Contribution to the Morphology of +the Prostate," _Journal of Anatomy and Physiology_, January, 1895; G. +Walker, "A Contribution to the Anatomy and Physiology of the Prostate +Gland, and a Few Observations on Ejaculation," _Johns Hopkins Hospital +Bulletin_, October, 1900. + +[131] For a study of the semen and its constituents, see Florence, "Du +Sperme," _Archives d'Anthropologie Criminelle_, 1895. + +[132] J. Hunter, _Essays and Observations_, vol. i, p. 189. + +[133] As regards one part of Australia, Walter Roth, _Ethnological Studies +Among the Queensland Aborigines_, p. 174. + +[134] Sir H.H. Johnston, _British Central Africa_, p. 438. + +[135] Cap. VII, pp. 327-357, "De Spermaticis virilis usu Medico," + +[136] W.L. Howard, "Sexual Perversion," _Alienist and Neurologist_, +January, 1896. + +[137] _Zentralblatt fuer Gynaekologie_, 1894, No. 49. + +[138] E. Toff, "Uber Impraegnierung," _Zentralblatt fuer Gynaekologie_, +April, 1903. In a similar but somewhat more precise manner Dufougere has +argued ("La Chlorose, ses rapports avec le marriage, son traitement par le +liquide orchitique," These de Bordeaux, 1902) that semen when absorbed by +the vagina stimulates the secretion of the ovaries and thus exerts an +influence over the blood in anaemia; in this way he seeks to explain why it +is that coitus is the best treatment for chlorosis. + +[139] In this connection I may refer to an interesting and suggestive +paper by Harry Campbell on "The Craving for Stimulants" (_Lancet_, October +21, 1899). No reference is made to coitus, but the author discusses +stimulants as normal and beneficial products of the organism, and deals +with the nature of the "physiological intoxication" they produce. + +[140] Spermin was first discovered in the sperm by Schreiner in 1878; it +has also been found in the thyroid, ovaries and various other glands. "The +spermin secreting and elaborating organs," Howard Kelly remarks (_British +Medical Journal_, January 29, 1898), "may be called the apothecaries' of +the body, secreting many important medicaments, much more active and more +accurately representing its true wants than artificially administered +drugs." + +[141] See, e.g., a summary of Buschan's comprehensive discussion of the +subject of organotherapy (Eulenburg's _Real-Encyclopaedie der Gesammten +Heilkunde_) in _Journal of Mental Science_, April, 1899, p. 355. + +[142] "Observations Upon the Acquirement of Secondary Sexual Characters, +Indicating the Formation of an Internal Secretion by the Testicles," +_Proceedings Royal Society_, vol. lxxiii, p. 49. + +[143] See, e.g., the experiments of Cecca and Zappi, summarized in +_British Medical Journal_, July 2, 1904. + + + + +IV. + +The Aptitude for Detumescence--Is There an Erotic Temperament?--The +Available Standards of Comparison--Characteristics of the +Castrated--Characteristics of Puberty--Characteristics of the State of +Detumescence--Shortness of Stature--Development of the Secondary Sexual +Characters--Deep Voice--Bright Eyes--Glandular Activity--Everted +Lips--Pigmentation--Profuse Hair--Dubious Significance of Many of These +Characters. + + +What, if any, are the indications which the body generally may furnish as +to the individual's aptitude and vigor for the orgasm of detumescence? Is +there an erotic temperament outwardly and visibly displayed? That is a +question which has often occupied those who have sought to penetrate the +more intimate mysteries of human nature, and since we are here concerned +with human beings in their relationship to the process of detumescence, we +cannot altogether pass over this question, difficult as it is to discuss +it with precision. + + The old physiognomists showed much confidence in dealing with the + matter. Possibly they had more opportunities for observation than + we have, since they often wrote in days when life was lived more + nakedly than among ourselves, but their descriptions, while + sometimes showing much insight, are inextricably mixed up with + false science and superstition. + + In the _De Secretis Mulierum_, wrongly attributed to Albertus + Magnus, we find a chapter entitled "Signa mulieris calidae naturae + et quae coit libenter," which may be summarized here. "The signs," + we are told, "of a woman of warm temperament, and one who + willingly cohabits are these: youth, an age of over 12, or + younger, if she has been seduced, small, high breasts, full and + hard, hair in the usual positions; she is bold of speech, with a + delicate and high voice, haughty and even cruel of disposition, + of good complexion, lean rather than stout, inclined to like + drinking. Such a woman always desires coitus, and receives + satisfaction in the act. The menstrual flow is not abundant nor + always regular. If she becomes pregnant the milk is not abundant. + Her perspiration is less odorous than that of the woman of + opposite temperament; she is fond of singing, and of moving + about, and delights in adornments if she has any." + + Polemon, in his _Sulla Physionomia_, has given among the signs of + libidinous impulse: knees turned inwards, abundance of hairs on + the legs, squint, bright eyes, a high and strident voice, and in + women length of leg below the knee. Aristotle had mentioned among + the signs of wantonness: paleness, abundance of hair on the body, + thick and black hair, hairs covering the temples, and thick + eyelids. + + In the seventeenth century Bouchet, in his _Serees_ (Troisieme + Seree), gave as the signs of virility which indicated that a man + could have children: a great voice, a thick rough black beard, a + large thick nose. + + G. Tourdes (Art. "Aphrodisie," _Dictionnaire Encyclopedique des + Sciences Medicales_) thus summarized the ancient beliefs on this + subject: "The erotic temperament has been described as marked by + a lean figure, white and well-ranged teeth, a developed hairy + system, a characteristic voice, air, and expression, and even a + special odor." + +In approaching the question of the general physical indications of a +special aptitude to the manifestation of vigorous detumescence, the most +obvious preliminary would seem to be a study of the castrated. If we know +the special peculiarities of those who by removal of the sexual glands at +a very early age have been deprived of all ability to present the +manifestations of detumescence, we shall probably be in possession of a +type which is the reverse of that which we may expect in persons of a +vigorously erotic temperament. + +The most general characteristics of eunuchs would appear to be an unusual +tendency to put on fat, a notably greater length of the legs, absence of +hair in the sexual and secondary sexual regions, a less degree of +pigmentation, as noted both in the castrated negro and the white man, a +puerile larynx and puerile voice. In character they are usually described +as gentle, conciliatory, and charitable. + + There can be little doubt that castration in man tends to lead to + lengthening of the legs (tibia and fibula) at puberty, from + delayed ossification of the epiphyses. The hands and feet are + also frequently longer and sometimes the forearms. At the same + time the bones are more slender. The pelvis also is narrower. The + eunuchs of Cairo are said to be easily seen in a crowd from their + tall stature. (Collineau, quoting Lortet, _Revue Mensuelle de + l'Ecole d'Anthropologie_, May, 1896.) The castrated Skoptzy show + increased stature, and, it seems, large ears, with decreased + chest and head (L. Pittard, _Revue Scientifique_, June 20, 1903.) + Fere shows that in most of these respects the eunuch resembles + beardless and infantile subjects. ("Les Proportions des Membres + et les Caracteres Sexuels," _Journal de l'Anatomie et de la + Physiologie_, November-December, 1897.) Similar phenomena are + found in animals generally. Sellheim, carefully investigating + castrated horses, swine, oxen and fowls, found retardation of + ossification, long and slender extremities, long, broad, but low + skull, relatively smaller pelvis and small thorax. ("Zur Lehre + von den Sekundaeren Geschlechtscharakteren," _Beitraege zur + Geburtshuelfe und Gynaekologie_, 1898, summarized in _Centralblatt + fuer Anthropologie_, 1900, Heft IV.) + + As regards the mental qualities and moral character of the + castrated, Griffiths considers that there is an undue prejudice + against eunuchs, and refers to Narses, who was not only one of + the first generals of the Roman Empire, but a man of highly + estimable character. (_Lancet_, March 30, 1895.) Matignon, who + has carefully studied Chinese eunuchs, points out that they + occupy positions of much responsibility, and, though regarded in + many respects as social outcasts, possess very excellent and + amiable moral qualities (_Archives Cliniques de Bordeaux_, May, + 1896.) In America Everett Flood finds that epileptics and + feeble-minded boys are mentally and morally benefited by + castration. ("Notes on the Castration of Idiot Children," + _American Journal of Psychology_, January, 1899.) It is often + forgotten that the physical and psychic qualities associated with + and largely dependent on the ability to experience the impulse of + detumescence, while essential to the perfect man, involve many + egoistic, aggressive and acquisitive characteristics which are of + little intellectual value, and at the same time inimical to many + moral virtues. + +We have a further standard--positive this time rather than negative--to +aid us in determining the erotic temperament: the phenomena of puberty. +The efflorescence of puberty is essentially the manifestation of the +ability to experience detumescence. It is therefore reasonable to suppose +that the individuals in whom the special phenomena of puberty develop most +markedly are those in whom detumescence is likely to be most vigorous. If +such is the case we should expect to find the erotic temperament marked by +developed larynx and deep voice, a considerable degree of pigmentary +development in hair and skin, and a marked tendency to hairiness; while +in women there should be a pronounced growth of the breasts and +pelvis.[144] + +There is yet another standard by which we may measure the individual's +aptitude for detumescence: the presence of those activities which are most +prominently brought into play during the process of detumescence. The +individual, that is to say, who is organically most apt to manifest the +physiological activities which mainly make up the process of detumescence, +is most likely to be of pronounced erotic temperament. + +"Erotic persons are of motor type," remark Vaschide and Vurpas, "and we +may say generally that nearly all persons of motor type are erotic." The +state of detumescence is one of motor and muscular energy and of great +vascular activity, so that habitual energy of motor response and an active +circulation may reasonably be taken to indicate an aptitude for the +manifestation of detumescence. + +These three types may be said, therefore, to furnish us valuable though +somewhat general indications. The individual who is farthest removed from +the castrated type, who presents in fullest degree the characters which +begin to emerge at the period of puberty, and who reveals a physiological +aptitude for the vigorous manifestation of those activities which are +called into action during detumescence, is most likely to be of erotic +temperament. The most cautious description of the characteristics of this +temperament given by modern scientific writers, unlike the more detailed +and hazardous descriptions of the early physiognomists, will be found to +be fairly true to the standards thus presented to us. + + The man of sexual type, according to Bierent (_La Puberte_, p. + 148), is hairy, dark and deep-voiced. + + "The men most liable to satyriasis," Bouchereau states (art. + "Satyriasis," _Dictionnaire Encyclopedique des Sciences + Medicales_), "are those with vigorous nervous system, developed + muscles, abundant hair on body, dark complexion, and white + teeth." + + Mantegazza, in his _Fisiologia del Piacere_, thus describes the + sexual temperament: "Individuals of nervous temperament, those + with fine and brown skins, rounded forms, large lips and very + prominent larynx enjoy in general much more than those with + opposite characteristics. A universal tradition," he adds, + "describes as lascivious humpbacks, dwarfs, and in general + persons of short stature and with long noses." + + In a case of nymphomania in a young woman, described by Alibert + (and quoted by Laycock, _Nervous Diseases of Women_, p. 28) the + hips, thighs and legs were remarkably plump, while the chest and + arms were completely emaciated. In a somewhat similar case + described by Marc in his _De la Folie_ a peasant woman, who from + an early age had experienced sexual hyperaesthesia, so that she + felt spasmodic voluptuous feelings at the sight of a man, and was + thus the victim of solitary excesses and of spasmodic movements + which she could not repress, the upper part of the body was very + thin, the hips, legs and thighs highly developed. + + In his work on _Uterine and Ovarian Inflammation_ (1862, p. 37) + Tilt observes: "The restless, bashful eye, and changing + complexion, in presence of a person of the opposite sex, and a + nervous restlessness of body, ever on the move, turning and + twisting on sofa or chair, are the best indications of sexual + temperament." + + An extremely sensual little girl of 8, who was constantly + masturbating when not watched, although brought up by nuns, was + described by Busdraghi (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, fas. i, 1888, + p. 53) as having chestnut hair, bright black eyes, an elevated + nose, small mouth, pleasant round face, full colored cheeks, and + plump and healthy aspect. + + A highly intelligent young Italian woman with strong and somewhat + perverted sexual impulses is described as of attractive + appearance, with olive complexion, small black almond-shaped + eyes, dilated pupils, oblique thin eyebrows, very thick black + hair, rather prominent cheek-bones, largely developed jaw, and + with abundant down on lower part of cheeks and on upper lip. + (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1899, fasc. v-vi.) + + As the type of the sensual woman in word and act, led by her + passions to commit various sexual offenses, Ottolenghi describes + (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, vol. xii, fasc. v-vi, p. 496) a woman + of 32 who attempted to kill her lover. The daughter of parents + who were neurotic and themselves very erotic, she was a highly + intelligent and vivacious woman, with a pleasing and open face, + very thick dark chestnut hair, large cheek-bones, adipose + buttocks almost resembling those of a Hottentot, and very thick + pubic hair. She was very fond of salt things. Sexual inclination + began at the age of 7. + +Adler and Moll remark, very truly, that, so far at least as women are +concerned, sexual anaesthesia or sexual proclivity cannot be unfailingly +read on the features. Every woman desires to please, and coquetry is the +sign of a cold, rather than of an erotic temperament.[145] It may be added +that a considerable degree of congenital sexual anaesthesia by no means +prevents a woman from being beautiful and attractive, though it must +probably still always be said that, as Roubaud points out,[146] the woman +of cold and intellectual temperament, the "femme de tete," however +beautiful and skillful she may be, cannot compete in the struggle for love +with the woman whose qualities are of the heart and of the emotions. But +it seems sufficiently clear that the practical observations of skilled and +experienced observers agree in attributing to persons of erotic type +certain general characteristics which accord with those negative and +positive standards we may frame on the basis of castration, of puberty, +and of detumescence. It may be worth while to note a few of these +characteristics briefly. + +The abnormal lengthening of the long bones at the age of puberty in the +castrated is, as we have seen, very pronounced. There is little tendency +to associate length of limb with an erotic temperament, and a certain +amount of data as well as of more vague opinion points in the opposite +direction. The Arabs would appear to believe that it is short rather than +tall people in whom the sexual instinct is strongly developed, and we read +in the _Perfumed Garden_: "Under all circumstances little women love +coitus more and evince a stronger affection for the virile member than +women of a large size." In his elaborate investigation of criminals Marro +found that prostitutes and women guilty of sexual offenses, as also male +sexual offenders, tend to be short and thick set.[147] In European +folk-lore the thick, bull neck is regarded as a sign of strong +sexuality.[148] Mantegazza refers to a strong sexual temperament as being +associated with arrest or disorder of bony development, and Marro suggests +that the proverbial salacity of rachitic individuals may be due to an +increased activity of the sexual organs.[149] It may be added that +acromegaly, with its excessive bony growths, tends to be associated with +premature sexual involution. + +A further point which is frequently mentioned in the case of women is the +development of the chief secondary sexual regions: the pelvis and the +breasts. It is, indeed, almost inevitable that there should be some degree +of correlation between the aptitude for bearing children and the aptitude +for experiencing detumescence. The reality of such a connection is not +only evidenced by medical observations, but receives further testimony in +popular beliefs. In Italy women with large buttocks are considered wanton, +and among the South Slavs they are regarded as especially fruitful.[150] +Blumenbach asserted that precocious venery will enlarge the breasts, and +believed that he had found evidence of this among young London +prostitutes.[151] + +The association of the aptitude for detumescence with a tendency to a deep +rather than to a high voice, both in men and women, has frequently been +noted and has seldom been denied. The onset of puberty always affects the +voice; in general, Bierent states, the more bass the voice is the more +marked is the development of the sexual apparatus; "a very robust man, +with very developed sexual organs, and very dark and abundant hairy +system, a man of strong puberty in a word, is nearly always a bass."[152] +The influence of sexual excitement in deepening the voice is shown by the +rules of sexual hygiene prescribed to tenors, while a bass has less need +to observe similar precautions. In women every phase of sexual +life--puberty, menstruation, coitus, pregnancy--tends to affect the voice +and always by giving it a deeper character. The deepening of the voice by +sexual intercourse was an ancient Greek observation, and Martial refers to +a woman's good or bad singing as an index to her recent sexual habits. +Prostitutes tend to have a deep voice. Venturi points out that married +women preserve a fresh voice to a more advanced age than spinsters, this +being due to the precocious senility in the latter of an unused function. +Such a phenomenon indicates that the relationship of detumescence to the +deepening of the voice is not quite simple. This is further indicated by +the fact that in robust men abstinence still further deepens the voice +(the monk of melodrama always has a bass voice), while excessive or +precocious sexual indulgence tends to be associated with the same kind of +puerile voice as is found in those persons in whom pubertal development +has not been carried very far, or who are of what Griffiths terms +eunuchoid type. Idiot boys, who are often sexually undeveloped, tend to +have a high voice, while idiot girls (who often manifest marked sexual +proclivities) not infrequently have a deep voice.[153] + +Bright dilated eyes are among the phenomena of detumescence, and are very +frequently noted in persons of a pronounced erotic temperament. This is, +indeed, an ancient observation, and Burton says of people with a black, +lively, and sparkling eye, "without question they are most amorous," +drawing his illustrations mostly from classic literature.[154] Tardieu +described the erotic woman as having bright eyes, and Heywood Smith states +that the eyes of lascivious women resemble, though in a less degree, those +of the insane.[155] Sexual excitement is one among many +causes--intellectual excitement, pain, a loud noise, even any sensory +irritation--which produce dilatation of the pupils and enlargement of the +palpebral fissure, with some protrusion of the eyeball. The influence of +the sexual system upon the eye appears to be far less potent in men than +in women.[156] Sexual desire is, however, by no means the only irritant +within the sexual sphere which may thus influence the eye; morbid +irritations may produce the same effect. Milner Fothergill, in his book on +_Indigestion_, vividly describes the appearance of the eyes sometimes +seen in ovarian disorder: "The glittering flash which glances out from +some female irides is the external indication of ovarian irritation, and +'the ovarian gleam' has features quite its own. The most marked instance +which ever came under my notice was due to irritation in the ovaries, +which had been forced down in front of the uterus and been fixed there by +adhesions. Here there was little sexual proclivity, but the eyes were very +remarkable. They flashed and glittered unceasingly, and at times perfect +lightning bolts shot from them. Usually there is a bright glittering sheen +in them which contrasts with the dead look in the irides of sexual excess +or profuse uterine discharges." + +The activity of the glandular secretions, and especially those of the +skin, during detumescence, would lead us to expect that such secretory +activity is an index to an aptitude for detumescence. As a matter of fact +it is occasionally, though not frequently, noted by medical observers. It +is stated that the erotic temperament is characterized by a special +odor.[157] The activity of the sweat-glands is seldom referred to by +medical observers in describing persons of erotic temperament, although +the descriptions of novelists not infrequently contain allusions to this +point, and the literature of an earlier age shows that the tendency to +perspiration, especially the moist hand, was regarded as a sure sign of a +sensual temperament. "The moist-handed Madonna Imperia, a most rare and +divine creature," remarks Lazarillo in Middleton's comedy _Blurt, +Master-Constable_, to quote one of many allusions to this point in the +Elizabethan drama. + +The lips are sometimes noted as red and everted, perhaps thick[158]; +Tardieu remarked that the typically erotic woman has thick red lips. This +corresponds with the characteristic type of the satyr in classic statues +as in later paintings; his lips are always thick and everted. Fullness, +redness, and eversion of the lips are correlated with good breathing, the +absence of anaemia, laughter, a well-fleshed face. + + This kind of mouth indicates, perhaps, not so much a congenitally + erotic temperament, as an abandonment to impulse. The opposite + type of mouth--with inverted, thin, and retracted lips--would + appear to be found with especial frequency in persons who + habitually repress their impulses on moral grounds. Any kind of + effort to restrain involuntary muscular action may lead to + retraction of the lips: the effort to overcome anger or fear, or + even the resistance to a strong desire to urinate or defecate. In + religious young men, however, it becomes habitual and fixed. I + recall a small band of medical students, gathered together from a + large medical school, who were accustomed to meet together for + prayer and Bible-reading; the majority showed this type of mouth + to a very marked degree: pale faces, with drawn, retracted lips. + It may be termed the Christian or pious _facies_. It is much less + frequently seen in religious women (unless of masculine type), + doubtless because religion for women is in a much less degree + than for men a moral discipline. + + It may be added that an interesting form of this contraction of + the lips, and one that is not purely repressive, is that which + indicates the state of muscular tension associated with the + impulse to guard and protect. In this form the contracted mouth + is the index of tenderness, and is characteristic of the mother + who is watching over the infant she is suckling at her breast. I + have observed precisely the same expression in the face of a boy + of 14 with a large congenital scrotal hernia; when the tumor was + being examined his lower lip became retracted, well marked lines + appearing from the angles downwards, though the upper lip + retained its normal expression It was precisely the tender look + we may see in the faces of mothers who are watching anxiously + over their offspring, and the emotion is evidently the same in + both cases: solicitude for a sensitive and tenderly guarded + object. + +The degree of pigmentation is clearly correlated with sexual vigor. "In +general," Heusinger laid down, in 1823, "the quantity of pigment is +proportional to the functional effectiveness of the genital organs." This +connection is so profound that it may be traced very widely throughout the +organic world. + +The connection between pigmentation and sexual activity is very ancient. +Even leaving out of account the wedding apparel of animals, nearly always +gorgeous in scales and plumage and hair, the sexual orifice shows a more +or less marked tendency to pigmentation during the breeding season from +fishes upward, while in mammals the darker pigmentation of this region is +a constant phenomenon in sexually mature individuals.[159] + +In the human species both the negative standard of castration and the +positive standard of puberty alike indicate a correlation of this kind. +Those individuals in whom puberty never fully develops and who are +consequently said to be affected by infantilism, reveal a relative absence +of pigment in the sexual centers which are normally pigmented to a high +degree.[160] Among those Asiatic races who extirpate the ovaries in young +girls the skin remains white in the perineum, round the anus, and in the +armpits.[161] Even in mature women who undergo ovariotomy, as Kepler +found, the pigmentation of the nipples and areola disappears, as well as +of the perineum and anus, the skin taking on a remarkable whiteness. + +Normally the sexual centers, and in a high degree the genital orifice, +represent the maximum of pigmentation, and under some circumstances this +is clearly visible even in infancy. Thus babies of mixed black and white +blood may show no traces of negro ancestry at birth, but there will always +be increased pigmentation about the external genitalia.[162] The linea +fusca, which reaches from the pubes to the navel and occasionally to the +ensiform cartilage, is a line of sexual pigmentation sometimes regarded as +characteristic of pregnancy, but as Andersen, of Copenhagen, has found by +the examination of several hundred children of both sexes, it exists in a +slight form in about 75 per cent. of young girls, and in almost as large a +proportion of boys. But there is no doubt that it tends to increase with +age as well as to become marked at pregnancy. At puberty there is a +general tendency to changes in pigmentation; thus Godin found that in 28 +per cent, adolescent changes occurred in the eyes and hair at this period, +the hair becoming darker, though the eyes sometimes become lighter. Ammon, +in his investigation of conscripts at the age of 20 (_post_, p. 196), +discovered the significant fact that the eyes and hair darken _pari passu_ +with sexual development. In women, during menstruation, there is a general +tendency to pigmentation; this is especially obvious around the eyes, and +in some cases black rings of true pigment form in this position. Even the +skin of the negro women of Loango sometimes becomes a few shades darker +during menstruation.[163] During pregnancy this tendency to pigmentation +reaches its climax. Pregnancy constantly gives rise to pigmentation of the +face, the neck, the nipples, the abdomen, and this is especially marked in +brunettes. + +This association of pigmentation and sexual aptitudes has been recognized +in the popular lore of some peoples. Thus the Sicilians, who admire brown +skin and have no liking either for a fair skin or light hair, believe that +a white woman is incapable of responding to love. It is the brown woman +who feels love; as it is said in Sicilian dialect: "Fimmina scura, fimmina +amurusa."[164] + + The dependence of pigmentation upon the sexual system is shown by + the fact that irritation of the genital organs by disease will + frequently suffice to produce a high degree of pigmentation. This + may the neck, the trunk, the hands. Simpson long since noted that + uterine irritation apart from pregnancy may produce pigmentation + of the areolae of the nipples (_Obstetric Works_, vol. i, p. 345). + Engelmann discussed the subject and gave cases, "The + Hystero-Neuroses," pp. 124-139, in _Gynaecological Transactions_, + vol. xii, 1887; and a summary of a memoir by Fouquet on this + subject in _La Gynecologie_, February, 1903, will be found in + _British Medical Journal_, March 28, 1903, + +Of all physical traits vigor of the hairy system has most frequently +perhaps been regarded as the index of vigorous sexuality. In this matter +modern medical observations are at one with popular belief and ancient +physiognomical assertions.[165] The negative test of castration and the +positive test of puberty point in the same direction. + +It is at puberty that all the hair on the body, except that on the head, +begins to develop; indeed, the very word "puberty" has reference to this +growth as the most obvious sign of the whole process. When castration +takes place at an early age all this development of pubescent hair is +arrested. When the primary sexual organs are undeveloped the sexual hair +is also undeveloped, as in a case, recorded by Plant,[166] of a girl with +rudimentary uterus and ovaries who had little or no axillary and pubic +hair, although the hair of the head was long and strong.[167] + + The pseudo-Michael Scot among the _Signa mulieris calidae naturae + et quae coit libenter_ stated that her hair, both on the head and + body, is thick and coarse and crisp, and Della Porta, the + greatest of the physiognomists, said that thickness of hair in + women meant wantonness. Venette, in his _Generation de l'Homme_, + remarked that men who have much hair on the body are most + amorous. At a more recent period Roubaud has said that pubic hair + in its quantity, color and curliness is an index of genital + energy. A poor pilous system, on the other hand, Roubaud regarded + as a probable though not an irrefragable proof of sexual + frigidity in women. "In the cold woman the pilous system is + remarkable for the languor of its vitality; the hairs are fair, + delicate, scarce and smooth, while in ardent natures there are + little curly tufts about the temples." (_Traite de + l'Impuissance_, pp. 124, 523.) Martineau declared (_Lecons sur + les Deformations Vulvaires_, p. 40) that "the more developed the + genital organs the more abundant the hair covering them; + abundance of hair appears to be in relation to the perfect + development of the organs." Tardieu described the typically + erotic woman as very hairy. + + Bergh found that among 2200 young Danish prostitutes those who + showed an unusual extension and amount of pubic hair included + several women who were believed to be libidinous in a very high + degree. (Bergh, "Symbolae," etc., _Hospitalstidende_, August, + 1894.) Moraglia, again, in Italy, in describing various women, + mostly prostitutes, of unusually strong sexual proclivities, + repeatedly notes very thick hair, with down on the face. + (_Archivio di Psichiatria_, vol. xvi, fasc. iv-v.) + + Marro, also, in Italy found that abundance of hair and down is + especially marked in women who are guilty of infanticide (as also + Pasini has found), though criminal women generally, in his + experience, tend to have abnormally abundant hair. (_Caratteri + del Delinquenti_, cap. XXII.) Lombroso finds that prostitutes + generally tend to be hairy (_Donna Delinquente_, p. 320.) + + A lad of 14, guilty of numerous crimes of violence having a + sexual source, is described by Arthur Macdonald in America as + having hair on the chest as well as all over the pubes. (A. + Macdonald, _Archives de L'Anthropologie Criminelle_, January, + 1893, p. 55.) The association of hairiness with abnormal + sexuality in the weak-minded has been noted at Bicetre + (_Recherches Cliniques sur l'Epilepsie_, vol. xix, pp. 69, 77.) + + Hypertrichosis universalis, a general hairiness of body, has been + described by Cascella in a woman with very strong sexual desires, + who eventually became insane. (_Revista Mensile di Psichiatria_, + 1903, p. 408.) Bucknill and Tuke give the case of a religiously + minded girl, with very strong and repressed sexual desires, who + became insane; the only abnormal feature in her physical + development was the marked growth of hair over the body. + + Brantome refers to a great lady known to him whose body was very + hairy, and quotes a saying to the effect that hairy people are + either rich or wanton; the lady in question, he adds, was both. + (Brantome, _Vie des Dames Galantes_, Discours II.) + + De Sade, whose writings are now regarded as a treasure house of + true observations in the domain of sexual psychology, makes the + Rodin of _Justine_ dark, with much hair and thick eyebrows, while + his very sexual sister is described as dark, thin and very hairy. + (Duehren, _Der Marquis de Sade_, third edition, p. 440.) + + A correspondent who has always taken a special interest in the + condition as regards hairiness of the women to whom he has been + attracted, has sent me notes concerning a series of 12 women. It + may be gathered from these notes that 5 women were neither + markedly sexual nor markedly hairy (either as regards head or + pubes), 6 cases both hairy and sexual, 1 was sexual and not + hairy, none were hairy and not sexual. My correspondent remarks: + "There may be women with scanty pubic hair possessing very strong + sexual emotions. My own experience is quite the opposite." He has + also independently reached the conclusion, arrived at by many + medical observers and clearly suggested by some of the facts here + brought together, that profuse hair frequently denotes a neurotic + temperament. + + It may be added that Mirabeau, as we learn from an anecdote told + by an eyewitness and recorded by Legouve, had a very hairy chest, + while the same is recorded of Restif de la Bretonne. + +It is a very ancient and popular belief that if a hairy man is not sensual +he is strong: _vir pilosus aut libidinosus aut fortis_. The Greeks +insisted on the hairy nates of Hercules, and Ninon de l'Enclos, when the +great Conde shared her bed without touching her, remarked, on seeing his +hairy body: "Ah, Monseigneur, que vous devez etre fort!" It may be doubted +whether there is any exact parallelism between muscular strength and +hairiness, for strength is largely a matter of training, but there can be +no doubt that hairiness really tends to be associated with a generally +vigorous development of the body. + +Although the observations concerning hairiness of body as an index of +vigor, whether sexual or only generally physical, are so ancient, until +recent years no attempts have been made to demonstrate on a large scale +whether there is actually a correlation between hairiness and sexual or +general development of the body. Some importance, therefore, attaches to +Ammon's careful observations of many thousand conscripts in Baden. These +observations fully justify this ancient belief, since they show that on +the one hand the size of the testicles, and on the other hand girth of +chest and stature, are correlated with hairiness of body. + + Ammon's observations were made on nearly 4000 conscripts of the + age of 20. From the point of view of the hairy system he divided + them, into four classes:-- + + I. To which 6.1 per cent, of the men belonged, with smooth + bodies. + + II. Including 25.3 per cent., only slight hairiness. + + III. 53.8 per cent., more developed hairy system, but belly, + breast and back smooth. + + IV. 14.7 per cent., hair all over body. + + V. 0.1 per cent., extreme cases of hairiness. + + The beardless were 12.1 per cent., those with no axillary hair 9 + per cent., those with no hair on pubis 0.4 per cent. This + corresponds with the fact that hair appears first on the pubis + and last on the chin. + + In the first class 69 per cent, were beardless, 54 per cent, + without any axillary hair and 6 per cent, without pubic hair. In + the second class 24 per cent, were beardless, 17 per cent, + without axillary hair. In the third class 3 per cent, were + beardless and 3 per cent without axillary hair. + + Below puberty the diameter of testicles is below 14 millimeters. + There were 13 conscripts having a testicular diameter of less + than 14 millimeters. These infantile individuals all belonged to + the first three classes and mostly to the first. The average + testicular diameter in the first class was nearly 24 millimeters, + and progressively rose in the succeeding classes to over 26 + millimeters in the fourth. + + While there was not much difference in height, the first class + was the shortest, the fourth the tallest. The fourth class also + showed the greatest chest perimeter. The cephalic index of all + classes was 84. (O. Ammon, "L'Infantilisme et le Feminisme au + Conseil de Revision," _L'Anthropologie_, May-June, 1896.) + +We thus see that it is quite justifiable to admit a type of person who +possesses a more than average aptitude for detumescence. Such persons are +more likely to be short than tall; they will show a full development of +the secondary sexual characters; the voice will tend to be deep and the +eyes bright; the glandular activity of the skin will probably be marked, +the lips everted; there is a tendency to a more than average degree of +pigmentation, and there is frequently an abnormal prevalence of hair on +some parts of the body. While none of these signs, taken separately, can +be said to have any necessary connection with the sexual impulse, taken +altogether they indicate an organism that responds to the instinct of +detumescence with special aptitude or with marked energy. In these +respects observation, both scientific and popular, concords with the +probabilities suggested by the three standards in this matter which have +already been set forth. + +No generalization, however, can here be set down in an absolute and +unqualified manner. There are definite reasons why this should be so. +There is, for instance, the highly important consideration that the sexual +impulse of the individual may be conspicuous in two quite distinct ways. +It may assume prominence because the individual possesses a highly +vigorous and well-nourished organism, or its prominence may be due to +mental irritation in a very morbid individual. In the latter +case--although occasionally the two sets of conditions are combined--most +of the signs we might expect in the former case may be absent. Indeed, the +sexual impulses which proceed from a morbid psychic irritability do not in +most cases indicate any special aptitude for detumescence at all; in that +largely lies their morbid character. + +Again, just in the same way that the exaggerated impulse itself may either +be healthy or morbid, so the various characters which we have found to +possess some value as signs of the impulse may themselves either be +healthy or morbid. This is notably the case as regards an abnormal growth +of hair on the body, more especially when it appears on regions where +normally there is little or no hair. Such hypertrichosis is frequently +degenerative in character, though still often associated with the sexual +system. When, however, it is thus a degenerative character of sexual +nature, having its origin in some abnormal foetal condition or later +atrophy of the ovaries, it is no necessary indication of any aptitude for +detumescence. + + Idiots, more especially it would seem idiot girls, tend to show a + highly developed hairy system. Thus Voisin, when investigating + 150 idiot and imbecile girls, found the hair long and thick and + tending to occupy a large surface; one girl had hair on the + areolae of the mamma. (J. Voisin, "Conformation des organes + genitaux chez les Idiots," _Annales d'Hygiene Publique_, June, + 1894.) It should be said that in idiot boys puberty is late, and + the sexual organs as well as the sexual instinct frequently + undeveloped, while in idiot girls there is no delay in puberty, + and the sexual organs and instinct are frequently fully and even + abnormally developed. + + Hegar has described an interesting case showing an association, + of foetal origin, between sexual anomaly and abnormal hairness. + In this case a girl of 16 had a uterus duplex, an infantile + pelvis, very slight menstruation and undeveloped breasts. She was + very hairy on the face, the anterior aspects of the chest and + abdomen, the sexual regions, and the thighs, but not specially so + on the rest of the body. The hairs were of lanugo-like character, + but dark in color. (A. Hegar, _Beitraege zur Geburtshuelfe und + Gynaekologie_, vol. i, p. III, 1898.) Sometimes hiruties of the + face and abdomen begin to appear during pregnancy, apparently + from disease or degeneration of the ovaries. (A case is noted in + _British Medical Journal_, August 2 and 16, pp. 375 and 436, + 1902.) Laycock many years ago referred to the popular belief that + women who have hair on the upper lip seldom bear children, and + regarded this opinion as "questionless founded on fact." + (Laycock, _Nervous Diseases of Women_, p. 22.) When this is so, + we may suppose that the abnormal hairy growth is associated with + degeneration of the ovaries. + +There is another factor which enters into this question and renders the +definition of a physical sexual type less precise than it would otherwise +be. The sexual instinct is common to all persons, and while it seems +probable that there is a type of person in whom sexual energies are +predominant, it would also appear that the people who otherwise show a +very high level of energy in life usually exhibit a more than average +degree of energy in matters of love. The predominantly sexual type, as we +have seen, tends to be associated with a high degree of pigmentation; the +person specially apt for detumescence inclines to belong to the dark +rather than to the purely fair group of the population. On the other hand, +the active, energetic, practical man, the man who is most apt for the +achievement of success in life, tends to belong to the fair rather than to +the dark type.[168] Thus we have a certain conflict of tendencies, and it +becomes possible to assert that while persons with pronounced aptitude for +sexual detumescence tend to be dark, persons whose pronounced energy in +sexual matters tends to ensure success are most likely to be fair. + + The tendency of the fair energetic type, the type of the northern + European man, to sexuality may be connected with the fact that + the violent and criminal man who commits sexual crimes tends to + be fair even amid a dark population. Criminals on the whole would + appear to tend to be dark rather than fair; but Marro found in + Italy that the group of sexual offenders differed from all other + groups of criminals in that their hair was predominantly fair. + (_Caratteri del Delinquenti_, p. 374.) Ottolenghi, in the same + way, in examining 100 sexual offenders, found that they showed 17 + per cent., of fair hair, though criminals generally (on a basis + of nearly 2000) showed only 6 per cent., and normal persons + (nearly 1000) 9 per cent. Similarly while the normal persons + showed only 20 per cent. of blue eyes and criminals generally 36 + per cent., the sexual offenders showed 50 per cent. of blue eyes. + (Ottolenghi, _Archivio di Psichiatria_, fasc. vi, 1888, p. 573.) + Burton remarked (_Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, + Mem. II, Subs. II) that in all ages most amorous young men have + been yellow-haired, adding, "Synesius holds every effeminate + fellow or adulterer is fair-haired." In folk-lore, it has been + noted (Kryptadia, vol. ii, p. 258), red or yellow hair is + sometimes regarded as a mark of sexuality. + + In harmony with this fairness, sexual offenders would appear to + be more dolichocephalic than other criminals. In Italy Marro + found the foreheads of sexual offenders to be narrow, and in + California Draehms found that while murderers had an average + cephalic index of 83.5, and thieves of 80.5, that of sexual + offenders was 79. + + On the other hand, high cheek-bones and broad faces--a condition + most usually found associated with brachycephaly--have sometimes + been noted as associated with undue or violent sexuality. Marro + noted the excess of prominent cheek-bones in sexual offenders, + and in America it has been found that unchaste girls tend to have + broad faces. (_Pedagogical Seminary_, December, 1896, pp. 231, + 235.) + +It will be seen that, when we take a comprehensive view of the facts and +considerations involved, it is possible to obtain a more definite and +coherent picture of the physical signs of a marked aptitude for +detumescence than has hitherto been usually supposed possible. But we also +see that while the _ensemble_ of these signs is probably fairly reliable +as an index of marked sexuality, the separate signs have no such definite +significance, and under some circumstances their significance may even be +reversed. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[144] See Bierent, _La Puberte_; Marro, _La Puberta_ (and enlarged French +translation, _La Puberte_), and portions of G.S. Hall's _Adolescence_; +also Havelock Ellis, _Man and Woman_ (fourth edition, revised and +enlarged). + +[145] Adler, _Die Mangelhafte Geschlechtsempfindung des Weibes_, p. 174; +Moll, "Perverse Sexualempfindung, Psychische Impotenz und Ehe" (Section +II), in Senator and Kaminer, _Krankheiten und Ehe_. + +[146] Roubaud, _Traite de l'Impuissance_, p. 524. + +[147] Marro, _Caratteri del Delinquenti_, p. 374. + +[148] Kryptadia, vol. ii, p. 258. + +[149] Marro, _La Puberta_, p. 196. In Italy, the sensuality of the lame is +the subject of proverbs. + +[150] _Archivio di Psichiatria_, 1896, p. 515; Kryptadia, vol. vi, p. 212. + +[151] Blumenbach, _Anthropological Treatises_, p. 248. + +[152] Bierent, _La Puberte_, p. 148. + +[153] Venturi, _Degenerazioni Psico-sessuali_, pp. 408-410. + +[154] _Anatomy of Melancholy_, Part III, Section II, Mem. II, Sub. II. + +[155] _British Gynaecological Journal_, February, 1887, p. 505. + +[156] Power, _Lancet_, November 26, 1887. + +[157] With regard to the sexual relationships of personal odor, see the +previous volume of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection in Man," section on +Smell. + +[158] In European folk-lore thick lips in a woman are sometimes regarded +as a sign of sensuality, Kryptadia, vol. ii, p, 258. + +[159] The direct dependence of sexual pigmentation on the primary sexual +glands is well illustrated by a true hermaphroditic adult finch exhibited +at the Academy of Sciences of Amsterdam (May 31, 1890); this bird had a +testis on the right side and an ovary on the left, and on the right side +its plumage was of the male's colors, on the left of the female's color. + +[160] See. e.g., Papillault, _Bulletin Societe d'Anthropologie_, 1899, p. +446. + +[161] Guinard, Art. "Castration," Richet's _Dictionnaire de Physiologie_. + +[162] J. Whitridge Williams, _Obstetrics_, 1903, p. 132. + +[163] _Zeitschrift fuer Ethnologie_, 1878, p. 19. + +[164] C. Pitre, _Medicina Populare Siciliana_, p. 47. In England, from +notes sent to me by one correspondent, it would appear that the proportion +of dark and sexually apt women to fair and sexually apt women is as 3 to +1. The experience of others would doubtless give varying results, and in +any case the fallacies are numerous. See, in the previous volume of these +_Studies_, "Sexual Selection in Man," Section IV. + +[165] In Japan the same belief would appear to be held. In a nude figure +representing the typical voluptuous woman by the Japanese painter Marugama +Okio (reproduced in Ploss's _Das Weib_) the pubic and axillary hair is +profuse, though usually sparse in Japan. + +[166] _Centralblatt fuer Gynaekologie_, No. 9, 1896. + +[167] It is important to remember that there is little correlation in this +matter between the hair of the head and the sexual hair, if not a certain +opposition. (See _ante_, p. 127.) According to one of the aphorisms of +Hippocrates, repeated by Buffon, eunuchs do not become bald, and Aristotle +seems to have believed that sexual intercourse is a cause of baldness in +men. (Laycock, _Nervous Diseases of Women_, p. 23.) + +[168] For some of the evidence on this point, see Havelock Ellis, "The +Comparative Abilities of the Fair and the Dark," _Monthly Review_, August, +1901; cf. id., _A Study of British Genius_, Chapter X. + + + + +THE PSYCHIC STATE IN PREGNANCY. + +The Relationship of Maternal and Sexual Emotion--Conception and Loss of +Virginity--The Anciently Accepted Signs of This Condition--The Pervading +Effects of Pregnancy on the Organism--Pigmentation--The Blood and +Circulation--The Thyroid--Changes in the Nervous System--The Vomiting of +Pregnancy--The Longings of Pregnant Women--Maternal Impressions--Evidence +for and Against Their Validity--The Question Still Open--Imperfection of +Our Knowledge--The Significance of Pregnancy. + + +In analyzing the sexual impulse I have so far deliberately kept out of +view the maternal instinct. This is necessary, for the maternal instinct +is specific and distinct; it is directed to an aim which, however +intimately associated it may be with that of the sexual impulse proper, +can by no means be confounded with it. Yet the emotion of love, as it has +finally developed in the world, is not purely of sexual origin; it is +partly sexual, but it is also partly parental.[169] + +In so far as it is parental it is certainly mainly maternal. There is a +drawing by Bronzino in the Louvre of a woman's head gazing tenderly down +at some invisible object; is it her child or her lover? Doubtless her +child, yet the expression is equally adequate to the emotion evoked by a +lover. If we were here specifically dealing with the emotion of love as a +complex whole, and not with the psychology of the sexual impulse, it would +certainly be necessary to discuss the maternal instinct and its associated +emotions. In any case it seems desirable to touch on the psychic state of +pregnancy, for we are here concerned not only with emotions very closely +connected with the sexual emotions in the narrower sense, but we here at +last approach that state which it is the object of the whole sexual +process to achieve. + +In civilized life a period of weeks, months, even years, may elapse +between the establishment of sexual relations and the occurrence of +conception. Under primitive conditions the loss of the virginal condition +practically involves the pregnant condition, so that under primitive +conditions very little allowance is made for the state, so common among +civilized peoples, of the woman who is no longer a virgin, yet not about +to become a mother. + + There is some interest in noting the signs of loss of virginity + chiefly relied upon by ancient authors. In doing this it is + convenient to follow mainly the full summary of authorities given + by Schurig in his _Barthenologia_ early in the eighteenth + century. The ancient custom, known in classic times, of measuring + the neck the day after marriage was frequently practiced to + ascertain if a girl was or was not a virgin. There were various + ways of doing this. One was to measure with a thread the + circumference of the bride's neck before she went to bed on the + bridal night. If in the morning the same thread would not go + around her neck it was a sure sign that she had lost her + virginity during the night; if not, she was still a virgin or had + been deflowered at an earlier period. Catullus alluded to this + custom, which still exists, or existed until lately, in the south + of France. It is perfectly sound, for it rests on the intimate + response by congestion of the thyroid gland to sexual excitement. + (_Parthenologia_, p. 283; Bierent, _La Puberte_, p. 150; Havelock + Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, p. 267.) + + Some say, Schurig tells us, that the voice, which in the virgin + is shrill, becomes rougher and deeper after the first coitus. He + quotes Riolan's statement that it is certain that the voice of + those who indulge in venery is changed. On that account the + ancients bound down the penis of their singers, and Martial said + that those who wish to preserve their voices should avoid coitus. + Democritus who one day had greeted a girl as "maiden" on the + following day addressed her as "woman," while in the same way it + is said that Albertus Magnus, observing from his study a girl + going for wine for her master, knew that she had had sexual + intercourse by the way because on her return her voice had become + deeper. Here, again, the ancient belief has a solid basis, for + the voice and the larynx are really affected by sexual + conditions. (_Parthenologia_, p. 286; Marro, _La Puberte_, p. + 303; Havelock Ellis, op. cit., pp. 271, 289.) + + Others, again, Schurig proceeds, have judged that the goaty smell + given out in the armpits during the venereal act is also no + uncertain sign of defloration, such odor being perceptible in + those who use much venery, and not seldom in harlots and the + newly married, while, as Hippocrates said, it is not perceived in + boys and girls. (_Parthenologia_, p. 286; cf. the previous volume + of these _Studies_, "Sexual Selection in Man," p. 64.) + + In virgins, Schurig remarks, the pubic hair is said to be long + and not twisted, while in women accustomed to coitus it is + crisper. But it is only after long and repeated coitus, some + authors add, that the pubic hairs become crisp. Some recent + observers, it may be remarked, have noted a connection between + sexual excitation and the condition of the pubic hair in women. + (Cf. the present volume, _ante_ p. 127.) + + A sign to which the old authors often attached much importance + was furnished by the urinary stream. In the _De Secretis + Mulierum_, wrongly attributed to Albertus Magnus, it is laid down + that "the virgin urinates higher than the woman." Riolan, in his + _Anthropographia_, discussing the ability of virgins to ejaculate + urine to a height, states that Scaliger had observed women who + were virgins emit urine in a high jet against a wall, but that + married women could seldom do this. Bouaciolus also stated that + the urine of virgins is emitted in a small stream to a distance + with an acute hissing sound. (_Parthenologia_, p. 281.) A + folk-lore belief in the reality of this influence is evidenced by + the Picardy _conte_ referred to already (_ante_, p. 53), "La + Princesse qui pisse au dessus les Meules." There is no doubt a + tendency for the various stresses of sexual life to produce an + influence in this direction, though they act far too slowly and + uncertainly to be a reliable index to the presence or the absence + of virginity. + + Another common ancient test of virginity by urination rests on a + psychic basis, and appears in a variety of forms which are really + all reducible to the same principle. Thus we are told in _De + Secretis Mulierum_ that to ascertain if a girl is seduced she + should be given to eat of powdered crocus flowers, and if she has + been seduced she immediately urinates. We are here concerned with + auto-suggestion, and it may well be believed that with nervous + and credulous girls this test often revealed the truth. + + A further test of virginity discussed by Schurig is the presence + of modesty of countenance. If a woman blushes her virtue is safe. + In this way girls who have themselves had experience of the + marriage bed are said to detect the virgin. The virgin's eyes are + cast down and almost motionless, while she who has known a man + has eyes that are bright and quick. But this sign is equivocal, + says Schurig, for girls are different, and can simulate the + modesty they do not feel. Yet this indication also rests on a + fundamentally sound psychological basis. (See "The Evolution of + Modesty," in the first volume of these _Studies_.) + + In his _Syllepsilogia_ (Section V, cap. I-II), published in 1731, + Schurig discusses further the anciently recognized signs of + pregnancy. The real or imaginary signs of pregnancy sought by + various primitive peoples of the past and present are brought + together by Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, bd. i, Chapter XXVII. + +Both physically and psychically the occurrence of pregnancy is, however, a +distinct event. It marks the beginning of a continuous physical process, +which cannot fail to manifest psychic reactions. A great center of vital +activity--practically a new center, for only the germinal form of it in +menstruation had previously existed--has appeared and affects the whole +organism. "From the moment that the embryo takes possession of the woman," +Robert Barnes puts it, "every drop of blood, every fiber, every organ, is +affected."[170] + +A woman artist once observed to Dr. Stratz, that as the final aim of a +woman is to become a mother and pregnancy is thus her blossoming time, a +beautiful woman ought to be most beautiful when she is pregnant. That is +so, Stratz replied, if her moment of greatest physical perfection +corresponds with the early months of pregnancy, for with the beginning of +pregnancy metabolism is increased, the color of the skin becomes more +lively and delicate, the breasts firmer.[171] Pregnancy may, indeed, often +become visible soon after conception by the brighter eye, the livelier +glance, resulting from greater vascular activity, though later, with the +increase of strain, the face may tend to become somewhat thin and +distorted. The hair, Barnes states, assumes a new vigor, even though it +may have been falling out before. The temperature rises; the weight +increases, even apart from the growth of the foetus. The efflorescence of +pregnancy shows itself, as in the blossoming and fecundated flower, by +increased pigmentation.[172] The nipples with their areolae, and the +mid-line of the belly, become darker; brown flecks (lentigo) tend to +appear on the forehead, neck, arms, and body; while striae--at first +blue-red, then a brilliant white--appear on the belly and thighs, though +these are scarcely normal, for they are not seen in women with very +elastic skins and are rare among peasants and savages.[173] The whole +carriage of the woman tends to become changed with the development of the +mighty seed of man planted within her; it simulates the carriage of pride +with the arched back and protruded abdomen.[174] The pregnant woman has +been lifted above the level of ordinary humanity to become the casket of +an inestimable jewel. + +It is in the blood and the circulation that the earliest of the most +prominent symptoms of pregnancy are to be found. The ever increasing +development of this new focus of vascular activity involves an increased +vascular activity in the whole organism. This activity is present almost +from the first--a few days after the impregnation of the ovum--in the +breasts, and quickly becomes obvious to inspection and palpation. Before a +quite passive organ, the breast now rapidly increases in activity of +circulation and in size, while certain characteristic changes begin to +take place around the nipples.[175] As a result of the additional work +imposed upon it the heart tends to become slightly hypertrophied in order +to meet the additional strain; there may be some dilatation also.[176] + + The recent investigations of Stengel and Stanton tend to show + that the increase of the heart's work during pregnancy is less + considerable than has generally been supposed, and that beyond + some enlargement and dilatation of the right ventricle there is + not usually any hypertrophy of the heart. + +The total quantity of blood is raised. While increased in quantity, the +blood appears on the whole to be somewhat depreciated in quality, though +on this point there are considerable differences of opinion. Thus, as +regards haemoglobin, some investigators have found that the old idea as to +the poverty of haemoglobin in pregnancy is quite unfounded; a few have even +found that the haemoglobin is increased. Most authorities have found the +red cells diminished, though some only slightly, while the white cells, +and also the fibrin, are increased. But toward the end of pregnancy there +is a tendency, perhaps due to the establishment of compensation, for the +blood to revert to the normal condition.[177] + +It would appear probable, however, that the vascular phenomena of +pregnancy are not altogether so simple as the above statement would imply. +The activity of various glands at this time--well illustrated by the +marked salivation which sometimes occurs--indicates that other modifying +forces are at work, and it has been suggested that the changes in the +maternal circulation during pregnancy may best be explained by the theory +that there are two opposing kinds of secretion poured into the blood in +unusual degree during pregnancy: one contracting the vessels, the other +dilating them, one or the other sometimes gaining the upper hand. +Suprarenal extract, when administered, has a vaso-constricting influence, +and thyroid extract a vasodilating influence; it may be surmised that +within the body these glands perform similar functions.[178] + +The important part played by the thyroid gland is indicated by its marked +activity at the very beginning of pregnancy. We may probably associate the +general tendency to vasodilatation during early pregnancy with the +tendency to goitre; Freund found an increase of the thyroid in 45 per +cent. of 50 cases. The thyroid belongs to the same class of ductless +glands as the ovary, and, as Bland Sutton and others have insisted, the +analogies between the thyroid and the ovary are very numerous and +significant. It may be added that in recent years Armand Gautier has noted +the importance of the thyroid in elaborating nucleo-proteids containing +arsenic and iodine, which are poured into the circulation during +menstruation and pregnancy. The whole metabolism of the body is indeed +affected, and during the latter part of pregnancy study of the ingesta and +egesta has shown that a storage of nitrogen and even of water is taking +place.[179] The woman, as Pinard puts it, forms the child out of her own +flesh, not merely out of her food; the individual is being sacrificed to +the species. + +The changes in the nervous system of the pregnant woman correspond to +those in the vascular system. There is the same increase of activity, a +heightening of tension. Bruno Wolff, from experiments on bitches, +concluded that the central nervous system in women is probably more easily +excited in the pregnant than in the non-pregnant state, though he was not +prepared to call this cerebral excitability "specific."[180] Direct +observations on pregnant women have shown, without doubt, a heightened +nervous irritability. Reflex action generally is increased. Neumann +investigated the knee-jerk in 500 women during pregnancy, labor, and the +puerperium, and in a large number found that there was a progressive +exaggeration with the advance of pregnancy, little or no change being +observed in the early months; sometimes when no change was observed during +pregnancy the knee-jerk still increased during labor, reaching its maximum +at the moment of the expulsion of the foetus; the return to the normal +condition took place gradually during the puerperium. Tridandani found in +pregnant women that though the superficial reflexes, with the exception of +the abdominal, were diminished, the deep and tendon reflexes were markedly +increased, especially that of the knee, these changes being more marked in +primiparae than in multiparae, and more pronounced as pregnancy advanced, +the normal condition returning with ten days after labor. Electrical +excitability was sensibly diminished.[181] + +One of the first signs of high nervous tension is vomiting. As is well +known, this phenomenon commonly appears early in pregnancy, and it is by +many considered entirely physiological. Barnes regards it as a kind of +safety valve, a regulating function, letting off excessive tension and +maintaining equilibrium.[182] Vomiting is, however, a convulsion, and is +thus the simplest form of a kind of manifestation--to which the heightened +nervous tension of pregnancy easily lends itself--that finds its extreme +pathological form in eclampsia. In this connection it is of interest to +point out that the pregnant woman here manifests in the highest degree a +tendency which is marked in women generally, for the female sex, apart +altogether from pregnancy, is specially liable to convulsive +phenomena.[183] + + There is some slight difference of opinion among authorities as + to the precise nature and causation of the sickness of pregnancy. + Barnes, Horrocks and others regard it as physiological; but many + consider it pathological; this is, for instance, the opinion of + Giles. Graily Hewitt attributed it to flexion of the gravid + uterus, Kaltenbach to hysteria, and Zaborsky terms it a neurosis. + Whitridge Williams considers that it may be (1) reflex, or (2) + neurotic (when it is allied to hysteria and amenable to + suggestion), or (3) toxaemic. It really appears to lie on the + borderland between healthy and diseased manifestations. It is + said to be unknown to farmers and veterinary surgeons. It appears + to be little known among savages; it is comparatively infrequent + among women of the lower social classes, and, as Giles has found, + women who habitually menstruate in a painless and normal manner + suffer comparatively little from the sickness of pregnancy. + + We owe a valuable study of the sickness of pregnancy to Giles, + who analyzed the records of 300 cases. He concluded that about + one-third of the pregnant women were free from sickness + throughout pregnancy, 45 per cent. were free during the first + three months. When sickness occurred it began in 70 per cent. of + cases in the first month, and was most frequent during the second + month. The duration varied from a few days to all through. + Between the ages of 20 and 25 sickness was least frequent, and + there was less sickness in the third than in any other pregnancy. + (This corresponds with the conclusion of Matthews Duncan that 25 + is the most favorable age for pregnancy.) To some extent in + agreement with Gueniot, Giles believes that the vomiting of + pregnancy is "one form of manifestation of the high nervous + irritability of pregnancy." This high nervous tension may + overflow into other channels, into the vascular and excretory + system, causing eclampsia; into the muscular system, causing + chorea, or, expending itself in the brain, give rise to hysteria + when mild or insanity when severe. But the vagi form a very ready + channel for such overflow, and hence the frequency of sickness in + pregnancy. There are thus three main factors in the causation of + this phenomenon: (1) An increased nervous irritability; (2) a + local source of irritation; (3) a ready efferent channel for + nervous energy. (Arthur Giles, "Observations on the Etiology of + the Sickness of Pregnancy," _Transactions Obstetrical Society of + London_, vol. xxv, 1894.) + + Martin, who regards the phenomenon as normal, points out that + when nausea and vomiting are absent or suddenly cease there is + often reason to suspect something wrong, especially the death of + the embryo. He also remarks that women who suffer from large + varicose veins are seldom troubled by the nausea of pregnancy. + (J.M.H. Martin, "The Vomiting of Pregnancy," _British Medical + Journal_, December 10, 1904.) These observations may be connected + with those of Evans (_American Gynaecological and Obstetrical + Journal_, January, 1900), who attributes primary importance to + the undoubtedly active factor of the irritation set up by the + uterus, more especially the rhythmic uterine contractions; + stimulation of the breasts produces active uterine contractions, + and Evans found that examination of the breasts sufficed to bring + on a severe attack of vomiting, while on another occasion this + was produced by a vaginal examination. Evans believes that the + purpose of these contractions is to facilitate the circulation of + the blood through the large venous sinuses, the surcharging of + the relatively stagnant pools with effete blood producing the + irritation which leads to rhythmic contractions. + +It is on the basis of the increased vascular and glandular activity and +the heightened nervous tension that the special psychic phenomena of +pregnancy develop. The best known, and perhaps the most characteristic of +these manifestations, is that known as "longings." By this term is meant +more or less irresistible desires for some special food or drink, which +may be digestible or indigestible, sometimes a substance which the woman +ordinarily likes, such as fruit, and occasionally one which, under +ordinary circumstances, she dislikes, as in one case known to me of a +young country woman who, when bearing her child, was always longing for +tobacco and never happy except when she could get a pipe to smoke, +although under ordinary circumstances, like other young women of her +class, she was without any desire to smoke. Occasionally the longings lead +to actions which are more unscrupulous than is common in the case of the +same person at other times; thus in one case known to me a young woman, +pregnant with her first child, insisted to her sister's horror on entering +a strawberry field and eating a quantity of fruit. These "longings" in +their extreme form may properly be considered as neurasthenic obsessions, +but in their simple and less pronounced forms they may well be normal and +healthy. + + The old medical authors abound in narratives describing the + longings of pregnant women for natural and unnatural foods. This + affection was commonly called _pica_, sometimes _citra_ or + _malatia_. Schurig, whose works are a comprehensive treasure + house of ancient medical lore, devotes a long chapter (cap. II) + of his _Chylologia_, published in 1725, to pica as manifested + mainly, though not exclusively, in pregnant women. Some women, he + tells us, have been compelled to eat all sorts of earthy + substances, of which sand seems the most common, and one Italian + woman when pregnant ate several pounds of sand with much + satisfaction, following it up with a draught of her own urine. + Lime, mud, chalk, charcoal, cinders, pitch are also the desired + substances in other cases detailed. One pregnant woman must eat + bread fresh from the oven in very large quantities, and a certain + noble matron ate 140 sweet cakes in one day and night. Wheat and + various kinds of corn as well as of vegetables were the foods + desired by many longing women. One woman was responsible for 20 + pounds of pepper, another ate ginger in large quantities, a third + kept mace under her pillow; cinnamon, salt, emulsion of almonds, + treacle, mushrooms were desired by others. Cherries were longed + for by one, and another ate 30 or 40 lemons in one night. Various + kinds of fish--mullet, oysters, crabs, live eels, etc.--are + mentioned, while other women have found delectation in lizards, + frogs, spiders and flies, even scorpions, lice and fleas. A + pregnant woman, aged 33, of sanguine temperament, ate a live fowl + completely with intense satisfaction. Skin, wool, cotton, thread, + linen, blotting paper have been desired, as well as more + repulsive substances, such as nasal mucus and feces (eaten with + bread). Vinegar, ice, and snow occur in other cases. One woman + stilled a desire for human flesh by biting the nates of children + or the arms of men. Metals are also swallowed, such as iron, + silver, etc. One pregnant woman wished to throw eggs in her + husband's face, and another to have her husband throw eggs in her + face. + + In the next chapter of the same work Schurig describes cases of + acute antipathy which may arise under the same circumstances + (cap. III, "De Nausea seu Antipathia certorum ciborum"). The list + includes bread, meat, fowls, fish, eels (a very common + repulsion), crabs, milk, butter (very often), cheese (often), + honey, sugar, salt, eggs, caviar, sulphur, apples (especially + their odor), strawberries, mulberries, cinnamon, mace, capers, + pepper, onions, mustard, beetroot, rice, mint, absinthe, roses + (many pages are devoted to this antipathy), lilies, elder + flowers, musk (which sometimes caused vomiting), amber, coffee, + opiates, olive oil, vinegar, cats, frogs, spiders, wasps, swords. + + More recently Gould and Pyle (_Anomalies and Curiosities of + Medicine_, p. 80) have briefly summarized some of the ancient and + modern records concerning the longings of pregnant women. + +Various theories are put forward concerning the causation of the longings +of pregnant women, but none of these seems to furnish by itself a complete +and adequate explanation of all cases. Thus it is said that the craving is +the expression of a natural instinct, the system of the pregnant woman +really requiring the food she longs for. It is quite probable that this is +so in many cases, but it is obviously not so in the majority of cases, +even when we confine ourselves to the longings for fairly natural foods, +while we know so little of the special needs of the organism during +pregnancy that the theory in any case is insusceptible of clear +demonstration. + +Allied to this theory is the explanation that the longings are for things +that counteract the tendency to nausea and sickness. Giles, however, in +his valuable statistical study of the longings of a series of 300 pregnant +women, has shown that the percentage of women with longings is exactly the +same (33 per cent.) among women who had suffered at some time during +pregnancy from sickness as among the women who had not so suffered. +Moreover, Giles found that the period of sickness frequently bore no +relation to the time when there were cravings, and the patient often had +cravings after the sickness had ceased. + +According to another theory these longings are mainly a matter of +auto-suggestion. The pregnant woman has received the tradition of such +longings, persuades herself that she has such a longing, and then becomes +convinced that, according to a popular belief, it will be bad for the +child if the longing is not gratified. Giles considers that this process +of auto-suggestion takes place "in a certain number, perhaps even in the +majority of cases."[184] + + The Duchess d'Abrantes, the wife of Marshal Junot, in her + _Memoires_ gives an amusing account of how in her first pregnancy + a longing was apparently imposed upon her by the anxious + solicitude of her own and her husband's relations. Though + suffering from constant nausea and sickness, she had no longings. + One day at dinner after the pregnancy had gone on for some months + her mother suddenly put down her fork, exclaiming: "I have never + asked you what longing you have!" She replied with truth that she + had none, her days and her nights being occupied with suffering. + "No _envie!_" said the mother, "such a thing was never heard of. + I must speak to your mother-in-law." The two old ladies consulted + anxiously and explained to the young mother how an unsatisfied + longing might produce a monstrous child, and the husband also now + began to ask her every day what she longed for. Her + sister-in-law, moreover, brought her all sorts of stories of + children born with appalling mother's marks due to this cause. + She became frightened and began to wonder what she most wanted, + but could think of nothing. At last, when eating a pastille + flavored with pineapple, it occurred to her that pineapple is an + excellent fruit, and one, moreover, which she had never seen, for + at that time it was extremely rare. Thereupon she began to long + for pineapple, and all the more when she was told that at that + season they could not be obtained. She now began to feel that she + must have pineapple or die, and her husband ran all over Paris, + vainly offering twenty louis for a pineapple. At last he + succeeded in obtaining one through the kindness of Mme. + Bonaparte, and drove home furiously just as his wife, always + talking of pineapples, had gone to bed. He entered the room with + the pineapple, to the great satisfaction of the Duchess's mother. + (In one of her own pregnancies, it appears, she longed in vain + for cherries in January, and the child was born with a mark on + her body resembling a cherry--in scientific terminology, a + _naevus_.) The Duchess effusively thanked her husband and wished + to eat of the fruit immediately, but her husband stopped her and + said that Corvisart, the famous physician, had told him that she + must on no account touch it at night, as it was extremely + indigestible. She promised not to do so, and spent the night in + caressing the pineapple. In the morning the husband came and cut + up the fruit, presenting it to her in a porcelain bowl. Suddenly, + however, there was a revulsion of feeling; she felt that she + could not possibly eat pineapple; persuasion was useless; the + fruit had to be taken away and the windows opened, for the very + smell of it had become odious. The Duchess adds that henceforth, + throughout her life, though still liking the flavor, she was only + able to eat pineapple by doing a sort of violence to herself. + (_Memories de la Duchesse d'Abrantes_, vol. iii, Chapter VIII.) + It should be added that, in old age, the Duchess d'Abrantes + appears to have become insane. + +The influence of suggestion must certainly be accepted as, at all events, +increasing and emphasizing the tendency to longings. It can scarcely, +however, be regarded as a radical and adequate explanation of the +phenomenon generally. If it is a matter of auto-suggestion due to a +tradition, then we should expect to find longings most frequent and most +pronounced in multiparous women, who are best acquainted with the +tradition and best able to experience all that is expected of a pregnant +woman. But, as a matter of fact, the women who have borne most children +are precisely those who are least likely to be affected by the longings +which tradition demands they should manifest. Giles has shown that +longings occur much more frequently in the first than in any subsequent +pregnancy; there is a regular decrease with the increase in number of +pregnancies until in women with ten or more children the longings scarcely +occur at all. + +We must probably regard longings as based on a physiological and psychic +tendency which is of universal extension and almost or quite normal. They +are known throughout Europe and were known to the medical writers of +antiquity. Old Indian as well as old Jewish physicians recognized them. +They have been noted among many savage races to-day: among the Indians of +North and South America, among the peoples of the Nile and the Soudan, in +the Malay archipelago.[185] In Europe they are most common among the +women of the people, living simple and natural lives.[186] + +The true normal relationship of the longings of pregnancy is with the +impulsive and often irresistible longings for food delicacies which are +apt to overcome children, and in girls often persist or revive through +adolescence and even beyond. Such sudden fits of greediness belong to +those kind of normal psychic manifestations which are on the verge of the +abnormal into which they occasionally pass. They may occur, however, in +healthy, well-bred, and well-behaved children who, under the stress of the +sudden craving, will, without compunction and apparently without +reflection, steal the food they long for or even steal from their parents +the money to buy it. The food thus seized by a well-nigh irresistible +craving is nearly always a fruit. Fruit is usually doled out to children +in small quantities as a luxury, but we are descended from primitive human +peoples and still more remote ape-like ancestors, by whom fruit was in its +season eaten copiously, and it is not surprising that when that season +comes round the child, more sensitive than the adult to primitive +influences, should sometimes experience the impulse of its ancestors with +overwhelming intensity, all the more so if, as is probable, the craving is +to some extent the expression of a physiological need. + + Sanford Bell, who has investigated the food impulses of children + in America, finds that girls have a greater number of likes and + dislikes in foods than boys of the same age, though at the same + time they have less dislikes to some foods than boys. The + proclivity for sweets and fruits shows itself as soon as a child + begins to eat solids. The chief fruits liked are oranges, + bananas, apples, peaches, and pears. This strong preference for + fruits lasts till the age of 13 or 14, though relatively weaker + from 10 to 13. In girls, however, Bell notes the significant fact + from our present point of view that at mid-adolescence there is a + revived taste for sweets and fruits. He believes that the growth + of children in taste in foods recapitulates the experience of the + race. (S. Bell, "An Introductory Study of the Psychology of + Foods." _Pedagogical Seminary_, March, 1904.) + +The heightened nervous impressionability of pregnancy would appear to +arouse into activity those primitive impulses which are liable to occur in +childhood and in the unmarried girl continue to the nubile age. It is a +significant fact that the longings of pregnant women are mainly for fruit, +and notably for so wholesome a fruit as the apple, which may very well +have a beneficial effect on the system of the pregnant woman. Giles, in +his tabulation of the foods longed for by 300 pregnant women, found that +the fruit group was by far the largest, furnishing 79 cases; apples were +far away at the head, occurring in 34 cases out of the 99 who had +longings, while oranges followed at a distance (with 13 cases), and in the +vegetable group tomatoes came first (with 6 cases). Several women declared +"I could have lived on apples," "I was eating apples all day," "I used to +sit up in bed eating apples."[187] Pregnant women appear seldom to long +for the possession of objects outside the edible class, and it seems +doubtful whether they have any special tendency to kleptomania. Pinard has +pointed out that neither Lasegue nor Lunier, in their studies of +kleptomania, have mentioned a single shop robbery committed by a pregnant +woman.[188] Brouardel has indeed found such cases, but the object stolen +was usually a food. + +A further significant fact connecting the longings of pregnant women with +the longings of children is to be found in the fact that they occur mainly +in young women. We have, indeed, no tabulation of the ages of pregnant +women who have manifested longings, but Giles has clearly shown that these +chiefly occur in primiparae, and steadily and rapidly decrease in each +successive pregnancy. This fact, otherwise somewhat difficult of +explanation, is natural if we look upon the longings of pregnancy as a +revival of those of childhood. It certainly indicates also that we can by +no means regard these longings as exclusively the expression of a +physiological craving, for in that case they would be liable to occur in +any pregnancy unless, indeed, it is argued that with each successive +pregnancy the woman becomes less sensitive to her own physiological state. + + There has been a frequent tendency, more especially among + primitive peoples, to regard a pregnant woman's longings as + something sacred and to be indulged, all the more, no doubt, as + they are usually of a simple and harmless character. In the Black + Forest, according to Ploss and Bartels, a pregnant woman may go + freely into other people's gardens and take fruit, provided she + eats it on the spot, and very similar privileges are accorded to + her elsewhere. Old English opinion, as reflected, for instance, + in Ben Jonson's plays (as Dr. Harriet C.B. Alexander has pointed + out), regards the pregnant woman as not responsible for her + longings, and Kiernan remarks ("Kleptomania and Collectivism," + _Alienist and Neurologist_, November, 1902) that this is in "a + most natural and just view." In France at the Revolution a law of + the 28th Germinal, in the year III, to some extent admitted the + irresponsibility of the pregnant woman generally,--following the + classic precedent, by which a woman could not be brought before a + court of justice so long as she was pregnant,--but the Napoleonic + code, never tender to women, abrogated this. Pinard does not + consider that the longings of pregnant women are irresistible, + and, consequently, regards the pregnant woman as responsible. + This is probably the view most widely held. In any case these + longings seldom come up for medico-legal consideration. + +The phenomena of the longings of pregnancy are linked to the much more +obscure and dubious phenomena of the influence of maternal impressions on +the child within the womb. It is true, indeed, that there is no real +connection whatever between these two groups of manifestations, but they +have been so widely and for so long closely associated in the popular mind +that it is convenient to pass directly from one to the other. The same +name is sometimes given to the two manifestations; thus in France a +pregnant longing is an _envie_, while a mother's mark on the child is also +called an _envie_, because it is supposed to be due to the mother's +unsatisfied longing. + +The conception of a "maternal impression" (the German _Versehen_) rests on +the belief that a powerful mental influence working on the mother's mind +may produce an impression, either general or definite, on the child she is +carrying. It makes a great deal of difference whether the effect of the +impression on the child is general, or definite and circumscribed. It is +not difficult to believe that a general effect--even, as Sir Arthur +Mitchell first gave good reason for believing, idiocy--may be produced on +the child by strong and prolonged emotional influence working on the +mother, because such general influence may be transmitted through a +deteriorated blood-stream. But it is impossible at present to understand +how a definite and limited influence working on the mother could produce a +definite and limited effect on the child, for there are no channels of +nervous communications for the passage of such influences. Our difficulty +in conceiving of the process must, however, be put aside if the fact +itself can be demonstrated by convincing evidence. + + In order to illustrate the nature of maternal impressions, I will + summarize a few cases which I have collected from the best + medical periodical literature during the past fifteen years. I + have exercised no selection and in no way guarantee the + authenticity of the alleged facts or the alleged explanation. + They are merely examples to illustrate a class of cases published + from time to time by medical observers in medical journals of + high repute. + + Early in pregnancy a woman found her pet rabbit killed by a cat + which had gnawed off the two forepaws, leaving ragged stumps; she + was for a long time constantly thinking of this. Her child was + born with deformed feet, one foot with only two toes, the other + three, the os calcis in both feet being either absent or little + developed. (G.B. Beale, Tottenham, _Lancet_, May 4, 1889). + + Three months and a half before birth of the child the father, a + glazier, fell through the roof of a hothouse, severely cutting + his right arm, so that he was lying in the infirmary for a long + time, and it was doubtful whether the hand could be saved. The + child was healthy, but on the flexor surface of the radial side + of the right forearm just above the wrist--the same spot as the + father's injury--there was a naevus the size of a sixpence. (W. + Russell, Paisley, _Lancet_, May 11, 1889.) + + At the beginning of pregnancy a woman was greatly scared by being + kicked over by a frightened cow she was milking; she hung on to + the animal's teats, but thought she would be trampled to death, + and was ill and nervous for weeks afterwards. The child was a + monster, with a fleshy substance--seeming to be prolonged from + the spinal cord and to represent the brain--projecting from the + floor of the skull. Both doctor and nurse were struck by the + resemblance to a cow's teats before they knew the woman's story, + and this was told by the woman immediately after delivery and + before she knew to what she had given birth. (A. Ross Paterson, + Reversby, Lincolnshire, _Lancet_, September 29, 1889.) + + During the second month of pregnancy the mother was terrified by + a bullock as she was returning from market. The child reached + full term and was a well-developed male, stillborn. Its head + "exactly resembled a miniature cow's head;" the occipital bone + was absent, the parietals only slightly developed, the eyes were + placed at the top of the frontal bone, which was quite flat, with + each of its superior angles twisted into a rudimentary horn. + (J.T. Hislop, Tavistock, Devon, _Lancet_, November 1, 1890.) + + When four months pregnant the mother, a multipara of 30, was + startled by a black and white collie dog suddenly pushing against + her and rushing out when she opened the door. This preyed on her + mind, and she felt sure her child would be marked. The whole of + the child's right thigh was encircled by a shining black mole, + studded with white hairs; there was another mole on the spine of + the left scapula. (C.F. Williamson, Horley, Surrey, _Lancet_, + October 11, 1890.) + + A lady in comfortable circumstances, aged 24, not markedly + emotional, with one child, in all respects healthy, early in her + pregnancy saw a man begging whose arms and legs were "all doubled + up." This gave her a shock, but she hoped no ill effects would + follow. The child was an encephalous monster, with the + extremities rigidly flexed and the fingers clenched, the feet + almost sole to sole. In the next pregnancy she frequently passed + a man who was a partial cripple, but she was not unduly + depressed; the child was a counterpart of the last, except that + the head was normal. The next child was strong and well formed. + (C.W. Chapman, London, _Lancet_, October 18, 1890.) + + When the pregnant mother was working in a hayfield her husband + threw at her a young hare he had found in the hay; it struck her + on the cheek and neck. Her daughter has on the left cheek an + oblong patch of soft dark hair, in color and character clearly + resembling the fur of a very young hare. (A. Mackay, Port Appin, + N.B., _Lancet_, December 19, 1891. The writer records also four + other cases which have happened in his experience.) + + When the mother was pregnant her husband had to attend to a sow + who could not give birth to her pigs; he bled her freely, cutting + a notch out of both ears. His wife insisted on seeing the sow. + The helix of each ear of her child at birth was gone, for nearly + or quite half an inch, as if cut purposely. (R.P. Roons, _Medical + World_, 1894.) + + A lady when pregnant was much interested in a story in which one + of the characters had a supernumerary digit, and this often + recurred to her mind. Her baby had a supernumerary digit on one + hand. (J. Jenkyns, Aberdeen, _British Medical Journal_, March 2, + 1895. The writer also records another case.) + + When pregnant the mother saw in the forest a new-born fawn which + was a double monstrosity. Her child was a similar double + monstrosity (_cephalothora copagus_). (Hartmann, _Muenchener + Medicinisches Wochenschrift_, No. 9, 1895.) + + A well developed woman of 30, who had ten children in twelve + years, in the third month of her tenth pregnancy saw a child run + over by a street car, which crushed the upper and back part of + its head. Her own child was anencephalic and acranial, with + entire absence of vault of skull. (F.A. Stahl, _American Journal + of Obstetrics_, April, 1896.) + + A healthy woman with no skin blemish had during her third + pregnancy a violent appetite for sunfish. During or after the + fourth month her husband, as a surprise, brought her some sunfish + alive, placing them in a pail of water in the porch. She stumbled + against the pail and the shock caused the fish to flap over the + pail and come in violent contact with her leg. The cold wriggling + fish produced a nervous shock, but she attached no importance to + this. The child (a girl) had at birth a mark of bronze pigment + resembling a fish with the head uppermost (photograph given) on + the corresponding part of the same leg. Daughter's health good; + throughout life she has had a strong craving for sunfish, which + she has sometimes eaten till she has vomited from repletion. + (C.F. Gardiner, Colorado Springs, _American Journal Obstetrics_, + February, 1898.) + + The next case occurred in a bitch. A thoroughbred fox terrier + bitch strayed and was discovered a day or two later with her + right foreleg broken. The limb was set under chloroform with the + help of Roentgen rays, and the dog made a good recovery. Several + weeks later she gave birth to a puppy with a right foreleg that + was ill-developed and minus the paw. (J. Booth, Cork, _British + Medical Journal_, September 16, 1899.) + + Four months before the birth of her child a woman with four + healthy children and no history of deformity in the family fell + and cut her left wrist severely against a broken bowl; she had a + great fright and shock. Her child, otherwise perfect, was born + without left hand and wrist, the stump of arm terminating at + lower end of radius and ulna. (G. Ainslie Johnston, Ambleside, + _British Medical Journal_, April 18, 1903.) + +The belief in the reality of the transference of strong mental or physical +impressions on the mother into physical changes in the child she is +bearing is very ancient and widespread. Most writers on the subject begin +with the book of Genesis and the astute device of Jacob in influencing the +color of his lambs by mental impressions on his ewes. But the belief +exists among even more primitive people than the early Hebrews, and in all +parts of the world.[189] Among the Greeks there is a trace of the belief +in Hippocrates, the first of the world's great physicians, while Soranus, +the most famous of ancient gynaecologists, states the matter in the most +precise manner, with instances in proof. The belief continued to persist +unquestioned throughout the Middle Ages. The first author who denied the +influence of maternal impressions altogether appears to have been the +famous anatomist, Realdus Columbus, who was a professor at Padua, Pisa, +and Rome at the beginning of the sixteenth century. In the same century, +however, another and not less famous Neapolitan, Della Porta, for the +first time formulated a definite theory of maternal impressions. A little +later, early in the seventeenth century, a philosophic physician at Padua, +Fortunatus Licetus, took up an intermediate position which still finds, +perhaps reasonably, a great many adherents. He recognized that a very +frequent cause of malformation in the child is to be found in morbid +antenatal conditions, but at the same time was not prepared to deny +absolutely and in every case the influence of maternal impression on such +conditions. Malebranche, the Platonic philosopher, allowed the greatest +extension to the power of the maternal imagination. In the eighteenth +century, however, the new spirit of free inquiry, of radical criticism, +and unfettered logic, led to a sceptical attitude toward this ancient +belief then flourishing vigorously.[190] In 1727, a few years after +Malebranche's death, James Blondel, a physician of extreme acuteness, who +had been born in Paris, was educated at Leyden, and practiced in London, +published the first methodical and thorough attack on the doctrine of +maternal impressions, _The Strength of Imagination of Pregnant Women +Examined_, and exercised his great ability in ridiculing it. Haller, +Roederer, and Soemmering followed in the steps of Blondel, and were either +sceptical or hostile to the ancient belief. Blumenbach, however, admitted +the influence of maternal impressions. Erasmus Darwin, as well as Goethe +in his _Wahlverwandtschaften_, even accepted the influence of paternal +impressions on the child. By the beginning of the nineteenth century the +majority of physicians were inclined to relegate maternal impressions to +the region of superstition. Yet the exceptions were of notable importance. +Burdach, when all deductions were made, still found it necessary to retain +the belief in maternal impressions, and Von Baer, the founder of +embryology, also accepted it, supported by a case, occurring in his own +sister, which he was able to investigate before the child's birth. L.W.T. +Bischoff, also, while submitting the doctrine to acute criticism, found it +impossible to reject maternal impressions absolutely, and he remarked that +the number of adherents to the doctrine was showing a tendency to increase +rather than diminish. Johannes Mueller, the founder of modern physiology in +Germany, declared himself against it, and his influence long prevailed; +Valentin, Rudolf Wagner, and Emil du Bois-Reymond were on the same side. +On the other hand various eminent gynaecologists--Litzmann, Roth, Hennig, +etc.--have argued in favor of the reality of maternal impressions.[191] + +The long conflict of opinion which has taken place over this opinion has +still left the matter unsettled. The acutest critics of the ancient +belief constantly conclude the discussion with an expression of doubt and +uncertainty. Even if the majority of authorities are inclined to reject +maternal impressions, the scientific eminence of those who accept them +makes a decisive opinion difficult. The arguments against such influence +are perfectly sound: (1) it is a primitive belief of unscientific origin; +(2) it is impossible to conceive how such influence can operate since +there is no nervous connection between mother and child; (3) comparatively +few cases have been submitted to severe critical investigation; (4) it is +absurd to ascribe developmental defects to influences which arise long +after the foetus had assumed its definite shape[192]; (5) in any case the +phenomenon must be rare, for William Hunter could not find a coincidence +between maternal impressions and foetal marks through a period of several +years, and Bischoff found no case in 11,000 deliveries. These statements +embody the whole of the argument against maternal impressions, yet it is +clear that they do not settle the matter. Edgar, in a manual of obstetrics +which is widely regarded as a standard work, states that this is "yet a +mooted question."[193] Ballantyne, again, in a discussion of this +influence at the Edinburgh Obstetrical Society, summarizing the result of +a year's inquiry, concluded that it is still "_sub judice_."[194] In a +subsequent discussion of the question he has somewhat modified his +opinion, and is inclined to deny that definite impressions on the pregnant +woman's mind can cause similar defects in the foetus; they are "accidental +coincidences," but he adds that a few of the cases are difficult to +explain away. At the same time he fully believes that prolonged and +strongly marked mental states of the mother may affect the development of +the foetus in her uterus, causing vascular and nutritive disturbances, +irregularities of development, and idiocy.[195] + + Whether and in how far mental impressions on the mother can + produce definite mental and emotional disposition in the child is + a special aspect of the question to which scarcely any inquiry + has been devoted. So distinguished a biologist as Mr. A.W. + Wallace has, however, called attention to this point, bringing + forward evidence on the question and emphasizing the need of + further investigation. "Such transmission of mental influence," + he remarks, "will hardly be held to be impossible or even very + improbable," (A.W. Wallace, "Prenatal Influences on Character," + _Nature_, August 24, 1893.) + +It has already been pointed out that a large number of cases of foetal +deformities, supposed to be due to maternal impressions, cannot possibly +be so caused because the impression took place at a period when the +development of the foetus must already have been decided. In this +connection, however, it must be noted that Dabney has observed a +relationship between the time of supposed mental impressions and the +nature of the actual defect which is of considerable significance as an +argument in favor of the influence of mental impressions. He tabulated 90 +carefully reported cases from recent medical literature, and found that 21 +of them were concerned with defects of structure of the lips and palate. +In all but 2 of these 21 the defect was referred to an impression +occurring within the first three months of pregnancy. This is an important +point as showing that the assigned cause really falls within a period when +a defect of development actually could produce the observed result, +although the person reporting the cases was in many instances manifestly +ignorant of the details of embryology and teratology. There was no such +preponderance of early impressions among the defects of skin and hair +which might well, so far as development is concerned, have been caused at +a later period; here, in 7 out of 15 cases, it was distinctly stated that +the impression was made later than the fourth month.[196] + +It would seem, on the whole, that while the influence of maternal +impressions in producing definite effects on the child within the womb has +by no means been positively demonstrated, we are not entitled to reject it +with any positive assurance. Even if we accept it, however, it must +remain, for the present, an inexplicable fact; the _modus operandi_ we can +scarcely even guess at. General influences from the mother on the child we +can easily conceive of as conveyed by the mother's blood; we can even +suppose that the modified blood might act specifically on one particular +kind of tissue. We can, again, as suggested by Fere, very well believe +that the maternal emotions act upon the womb and produce various kinds and +degrees of pressure on the child within, so that the apparently active +movements of the foetus may be really consecutive on unconscious maternal +excitations.[197] We may also believe that, as suggested by John Thomson, +there are slight incooerdinations _in utero_, a kind of developmental +neurosis, produced by some slight lack of harmony of whatever origin, and +leading to the production of malformations.[198] We know, finally, that, +as Fere and others have repeatedly demonstrated during recent years by +experiments on chickens, etc., very subtle agents, even odors, may +profoundly affect embryonic development and produce deformity. But how the +mother's psychic disposition can, apart from heredity, affect specifically +the physical conformation or even the psychic disposition of the child +within her womb must remain for the present an insoluble mystery, even if +we feel disposed to conclude that in some cases such action seems to be +indicated. + + In comprehending such a connection, however at present + undemonstrated, it may well be borne in mind that the + relationship of the mother to the child within her womb is of a + uniquely intimate character. It is of interest in this + connection to quote some remarks by an able psychologist, Dr. + Henry Rutgers Marshall; the remarks are not less interesting for + being brought forward without any connection with the question of + maternal impressions: "It is true that, so far as we know, the + nervous system of the embryo never has a direct connection with + the nervous system of the mother: nevertheless, as there is a + reciprocity of reaction between the physical body of the mother + and its embryonic parasite, the relation of the embryonic nervous + system to the nervous system of the mother is not very far + removed from the relation of the pre-eminent part of the nervous + system of a man to some minor nervous system within his body + which is to a marked extent dissociated from the whole neural + mass. + + "Correspondingly, then, and within the consciousness of the + mother, there develops a new little minor consciousness which, + although but lightly integrated with the mass of her + consciousness, nevertheless has its part in her consciousness + taken as a whole, much as the psychic correspondents of the + action of the nerve which govern the secretions of the glands of + the body have their part in her consciousness taken as a whole. + + "It is very much as if the optic ganglia developed fully in + themselves, without any closer connection with the rest of the + brain than existed at their first appearance. They would form a + little complex nervous system almost but not quite apart from the + brain system; and it would be difficult to deny them a + consciousness of their own; which would indeed form part of the + whole consciousness of the individual, but which would be in a + manner self-dependent." It must, if this is so, be said that + before birth, on the psychic side, the embryo's activities "form + part of a complex consciousness which is that of the mother and + embryo together." "Without subscribing to the strange stories of + telepathy, of the solemn apparition of a person somewhere at the + moment of his death a thousand miles away, of the unquiet ghost + haunting the scenes of its bygone hopes and endeavors, one may + ask" (with the author of the address in medicine at the Leicester + gathering of the British Medical Association, _British Medical + Journal_, July 29, 1905) "whether two brains cannot be so tuned + in sympathy as to transmit and receive a subtile transfusion of + mind without mediation of sense. Considering what is implied by + the human brain with its countless millions of cells, its + complexities of minute structure, its innumerable chemical + compositions, and the condensed forces in its microscopic and + ultramicroscopic elements--the whole a sort of microcosm of + cosmic forces to which no conceivable compound of electric + batteries is comparable; considering, again, that from an + electric station waves of energy radiate through the viewless air + to be caught up by a fit receiver a thousand miles distant, it is + not inconceivable that the human brain may send off still more + subtile waves to be accepted and interpreted by the fitly tuned + receiving brain. Is it, after all, mere fancy that a mental + atmosphere or effluence emanates from one person to affect + another, either soothing sympathetically or irritating + antipathically?" These remarks (like Dr. Marshall's) were made + without reference to maternal impressions, but it may be pointed + out that under no conceivable circumstance could we find a brain + in so virginal and receptive a state as is the child's in the + womb. + +On the whole we see that pregnancy induces a psychic state which is at +once, in healthy persons, one of full development and vigor, and at the +same time one which, especially in individuals who are slightly abnormal, +is apt to involve a state of strained or overstrained nervous tension and +to evoke various manifestations which are in many respects still +imperfectly understood. Even the specifically sexual emotions tend to be +heightened, more especially during the earlier period of pregnancy. In 24 +cases of pregnancy in which the point was investigated by Harry Campbell, +sexual feeling was decidedly increased in 8, in one case (of a woman aged +31 who had had four children) being indeed only present during pregnancy, +when it was considerable; in only 7 cases was there diminution or +disappearance of sexual feeling.[199] Pregnancy may produce mental +depression;[200] but on the other hand it frequently leads to a change of +the most favorable character in the mental and general well-being. Some +women indeed are only well during pregnancy. It is remarkable that some +women who habitually suffer from various nervous troubles--neuralgias, +gastralgia, headache, insomnia--are only free from them at this moment. +This "paradox of gestation," as Vinay has termed it, is specially marked +in the hysterical and those suffering from slight nervous disorders, but +it is by no means universal, so that although it is possible, Vinay +states, to confirm the opinion of the ancients as to the beneficial +action of marriage on hysteria, that is only true of slight cases and +scarcely enables us to counsel marriage in hysteria.[201] Even a woman's +intelligence is sometimes heightened by pregnancy, and Tarnier, as quoted +by Vinay, knew many women whose intelligence, habitually somewhat obtuse, +has only risen to the normal level during pregnancy.[202] The pregnant +woman has reached the climax of womanhood; she has attained to that state +toward which the periodically recurring menstrual wave has been drifting +her at regular intervals throughout her sexual life[203]; she has achieved +that function for which her body has been constructed, and her mental and +emotional disposition adapted, through countless ages. + +And yet, as we have seen, our ignorance of the changes effected by the +occurrence of this supremely important event--even on the physical +side--still remains profound. Pregnancy, even for us, the critical and +unprejudiced children of a civilized age, still remains, as for the +children of more primitive ages, a mystery. Conception itself is a mystery +for the primitive man, and may be produced by all sorts of subtle ways +apart from sexual connection, even by smelling a flower.[204] The pregnant +woman was surrounded by ceremonies, by reverence and fear, often shut up +in a place apart.[205] Her presence, her exhalations, were of extreme +potency; even in some parts of Europe to-day, as in the Walloon districts +of Belgium, a pregnant woman must not kiss a child for her breath is +dangerous, or urinate on plants for she will kill them.[206] The mystery +has somewhat changed its form; it still remains. The future of the race is +bound up with our efforts to fathom the mystery of pregnancy. "The early +days of human life," it has been truly said, "are entirely one with the +mother. On her manner of life--eating, drinking, sleeping, and +thinking--what greatness may not hang?"[207] Schopenhauer observed, with +misapplied horror, that there is nothing a woman is less modest about than +the state of pregnancy, while Weininger exclaims: "Never yet has a +pregnant woman given expression in any form--poem, memoirs, or +gynaecological monograph--to her sensations or feelings."[208] Yet when we +contemplate the mystery of pregnancy and all that it involves, how trivial +all such considerations become! We are here lifted into a region where our +highest intelligence can only lead us to adoration, for we are gazing at a +process in which the operations of Nature become one with the divine task +of Creation. + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[169] See, e.g., Groos, _AEsthetische Genuss_, p. 249. "We have to admit," +Groos observes, "the entrance of another instinct, the impulse to tend and +foster, so closely connected with the sexual life. It is seemingly due to +the co-operation of this impulse that the little female bird during +courtship is so often fed by the male like a young fledgling. In man +'love' from the biological standpoint is also an amalgamation of two +needs; when the tender need to protect and foster and serve is lacking the +emotion is not quite perfect. Heine's expression, 'With my mantle I +protect you from the storm,' has always seemed to me very characteristic." +Sometimes the sexual impulse may undergo a complete transformation in this +direction. "I believe there is really a tendency in women," a lady writes +in a letter, "to allow maternal feeling to take the place of sexual +feeling. Very often a woman's feeling for her husband becomes this (though +he may be twenty years older than herself); sometimes it does not, +remaining purely sex feeling. Sometimes it is for some other man she has +this curious self-obliterating maternal feeling. It is not necessarily +connected with sex intercourse. A prostitute, who has relations with +dozens of men, may have it for some feeble drunken fool, who perhaps goes +after other women. I once saw the change from sex feeling to mother +feeling, as I call it, come almost suddenly over a woman after she had +lived about four years with a man who was unfaithful to her. Then, when +all real sex feeling, the hatred of the woman he followed, the desire he +should give her love and tenderness, had all gone, came the other feeling, +and she said to me, 'You don't understand at all; he's only my little +baby; nothing he does can make any difference to me now.' As I grow older +and understand women's natures better, I can see almost at once which +relation it is a woman has to her husband, or any given man. It is this +feeling, and not sex passion, that keeps woman from being free." Not only +is there a sexual association in the impulse to foster and protect, there +would appear to be a similar element also in the response to that impulse. +Freud has especially insisted on the partly sexual character of the +child's feelings for those who care for it and tend it and satisfy its +needs. It is begun in earliest infancy; "whoever has seen the sated infant +sink back from the breast, to fall asleep with flushed cheeks and happy +smile, must say that the picture is adequate to the expression of the +sexual satisfaction of later life." The lips, moreover, are the earliest +erogenous zone. "There will, perhaps, be some opposition," Freud remarks +(_Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie_, pp. 36, 64), "to the +identification of the child's feelings of tenderness and appreciation for +those who tend it with sexual love, but I believe that exact psychological +analysis will place the identity beyond doubt. The relationship of the +child with the person who tends it is for it a continual source of sexual +excitement and satisfaction flowing from the erogenous zones, especially +since the fostering person--as a rule the mother--regards the child with +emotions which proceed from her sexual life; strokes it, kisses it, rocks +it, and very plainly treats it as a compensation for a fully valid sexual +object." Freud remarks that girls who retain the childish character of +their love for their parents to adult age are apt to make cold wives and +to be sexually anaesthetic. + +[170] Esbach (in his _These de Paris_, published in 1876) showed that even +the finger nails are affected in pregnancy and become measurably thinner. + +[171] C.H. Stratz, _Die Schoenheit des Weiblichen Koerpers_, Chapter VI. + +[172] Iron appears to be liberated in the maternal organism during +pregnancy, and Wychgel has shown (_Zeitschrift fuer Geburtshuelfe und +Gynaekologie_, bd. xlvii, Heft II) that the pigment of pregnant women +contains iron, and that the amount of iron in the urine is increased. + +[173] Vinay, _Maladies de la Grossesse_, Chapter VIII; K. Hennig, +"Exploratio Externa," _Comptes-rendus du XIIe. Congres International de +Medecine_, vol. vi, Section XIII, pp. 144-166. A bibliography of the +literature concerning the physiology of pregnancy, extending to ten pages, +is appended by Pinard to his article "Grossesse," _Dictionnaire +Encyclopedique des Sciences Medicales_. + +[174] Stratz, op. cit., Chapter XII. + +[175] W.S.A. Griffith, "The Diagnosis of Pregnancy," _British Medical +Journal_, April 11, 1903. + +[176] J. Mackenzie and H.O. Nicholson, "The Heart in Pregnancy," _British +Medical Journal_, October 8, 1904; Stengel and Stanton, "The Condition of +the Heart in Pregnancy," _Medical Record_, May 10, 1902 and _University +Pennsylvania Medical Bulletin_, Sept., 1904 (summarized in _British +Medical Journal_, August 16, 1902, and Sept. 23, 1905.) + +[177] J. Henderson, "Maternal Blood at Term," _Journal of Obstetrics and +Gynaecology_, February, 1902; C. Douglas, "The Blood in Pregnant Women," +_British Medical Journal_, March 26, 1904; W.L. Thompson, "The Blood in +Pregnancy," _Johns Hopkins Hospital Bulletin_, June, 1904. + +[178] H.O. Nicholson, "Some Remarks on the Maternal Circulation in +Pregnancy," _British Medical Journal_, October 3, 1903. + +[179] J. Morris Slemans, "Metabolism During Pregnancy," _Johns Hopkins +Hospital Reports_, vol. xii, 1904. + +[180] B. Wolff, _Zentralblatt fuer Gynaekologie_, 1904, No. 26. + +[181] Tridandani, _Annali di Ostetrica_, March, 1900. + +[182] R. Barnes, "The Induction of Labor," _British Medical Journal_, +December 22, 1894. + +[183] See, e.g., Havelock Ellis, _Man and Woman_, fourth edition, pp. 344, +et seq. + +[184] Arthur Giles, "The Longings of Pregnant Women," _Transactions +Obstetrical Society of London_, vol. xxxv, 1893. + +[185] Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, Chapter XXX. + +[186] Thus, in Cornwall, "to be in the longing way" is a popular synonym +for pregnancy. + +[187] The apple, wherever it is known, has nearly always been a sacred or +magic fruit (as J.F. Campbell shows, _Popular Tales of West Highlands_, +vol. I, p. lxxv. et seq.), and the fruit of the forbidden tree which +tempted Eve is always popularly imagined to be an apple. One may perhaps +refer in this connection to the fact that at Rome and elsewhere the +testicles have been called apples. I may add that we find a curious proof +of the recognition of the feminine love of apples in an old Portuguese +ballad, "Donna Guimar," in which a damsel puts on armour and goes to the +wars; her sex is suspected and as a test, she is taken into an orchard, +but Donna Guimar is too wary to fall into the trap, and turning away from +the apples plucks a citron. + +[188] A. Pinard, Art. "Grossesse," _Dictionnaire Encyclopedique des +Sciences Medicales_, p. 138. On the subject of violent, criminal and +abnormal impulses during pregnancy, see Cumston, "Pregnancy and Crime," +_American Journal Obstetrics_, December, 1903. + +[189] See especially Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, vol. i, Chapter XXXI. +Ballantyne in his work on the pathology of the foetus adds Loango negroes, +the Eskimo and the ancient Japanese. + +[190] In 1731 Schurig, in his _Syllepsilogia_, devoted more than a hundred +pages (cap. IX) to summarizing a vast number of curious cases of maternal +impressions leading to birth-marks of all kinds. + +[191] J.W. Ballantyne has written an excellent history of the doctrine of +maternal impressions, reprinted in his _Manual of Antenatal Pathology: The +Embryo_, 1904, Chapter IX; he gives a bibliography of 381 items. In +Germany the history of the question has been written by Dr. Iwan Bloch +(under the pseudonym of Gerhard von Welsenburg), _Das Versehen der +Frauen_, 1899. Cf., in French, G. Variot, "Origine des Prejuges Populaires +sur les Envies," _Bulletin Societe d'Anthropologie_, Paris, June 18, 1891. +Variot rejects the doctrine absolutely, Bloch accepts it, Ballantyne +speaks cautiously. + +[192] J.G. Kiernan has shown how many of the alleged cases are negatived +by the failure to take this fact into consideration. (_Journal of American +Medical Association_, December 9, 1899.) + +[193] J. Clifton Edgar, _The Practice of Obstetrics_, second edition, +1904, p. 296. In an important discussion of the question at the American +Gynaecological Society in 1886, introduced by Fordyce Barker, various +eminent gynaecologists declared in favor of the doctrine, more or less +cautiously. (_Transactions of the American Gynaecological Society_, vol. +xi, 1886, pp. 152-196.) Gould and Pyle, bringing forward some of the data +on the question (_Anomalies and Curiosities of Medicine_, pp. 81, _et +seq._) state that the reality of the influence of maternal impressions +seems fully established. On the other side, see G.W. Cook, _American +Journal of Obstetrics_, September, 1889, and H.F. Lewis, ib., July, 1899. + +[194] _Transactions Edinburgh Obstetrical Society_, vol. xvii, 1892. + +[195] J.W. Ballantyne, _Manual of Antenatal Pathology: The Embryo_, p. 45. + +[196] W.C. Dabney, "Maternal Impressions," Keating's _Cyclopaedia of +Diseases of Children_, vol. i, 1889, pp. 191-216. + +[197] Fere, _Sensation et Mouvement_, Chapter XIV, "Sur la Psychologie du +Foetus." + +[198] J. Thomson, "Defective Co-ordination in Utero," _British Medical +Journal_, September 6, 1902. + +[199] H. Campbell, _Nervous Organization of Man and Woman_, p. 206; cf. +Moll, _Untersuchungen ueber die Libido Sexualis_, bd. i, p. 264. Many +authorities, from Soranus of Ephesus onward, consider, however, that +sexual relations should cease during pregnancy, and certainly during the +later months. Cf. Brenot, _De l'influence de la copulation pendant la +grosseisse_, 1903. + +[200] Bianchi terms this fairly common condition the neurasthenia of +pregnancy. + +[201] Vinay, _Traite des Maladies de la Grossesse_, 1894, pp. 51, 577; +Mongeri, "Nervenkrankungen und Schwangerschaft." _Allegemeine Zeitschrift +fuer Psychiatrie_, bd. LVIII, Heft 5. Haig remarks (_Uric Acid_, sixth +edition, p. 151) that during normal pregnancy diseases with excess of uric +acid in the blood (headaches, fits, mental depression, dyspepsia, asthma) +are absent, and considers that the common idea that women do not easily +take colds, fevers, etc., at this time is well founded. + +[202] Founding his remarks on certain anatomical changes and on a +suggestion of Engel's, Donaldson observes: "It is impossible to escape the +conclusion that in women natural education is complete only with +maternity, which we know to effect some slight changes in the sympathetic +system and possibly the spinal cord, and which may be fairly laid under +suspicion of causing more structural modifications than are at present +recognized." H.H. Donaldson, _The Growth of the Brain_, p. 352. + +[203] The state of menstruation is in many respects an approximation to +that of pregnancy; see, e.g., Edgar's _Practice of Obstetrics_, plates 6 6 +and 7, showing the resemblance of the menstrual changes in the breasts and +the external sexual parts to the changes of pregnancy; cf. Havelock Ellis, +_Man and Woman_, fourth edition, Chapter XI, "The Functional Periodicity +of Woman." + +[204] Thus the gypsies say of an unmarried woman who becomes pregnant, +"She has smelt the moon-flower"--a flower believed to grow on the +so-called moon-mountain and to possess the property of impregnating by its +smell. Ploss and Bartels, _Das Weib_, bd. I, Chapter XXVII. + +[205] This was a sound instinct, for it is now recognized as an extremely +important part of puericulture that a woman should rest at all events +during the latter part of pregnancy; see, e.g., Pinard, _Gazette des +Hopitaux_, November 28, 1895, and _Annales de Gynecologie_, August, 1898. + +[206] Ploss and Bartels, op. cit., Chapter XXIX; Kryptadia, vol. viii, p. +143. + +[207] Griffith Wilkin, _British Medical Journal_, April 8, 1905. + +[208] Weininger, _Geschlecht und Charakter_, p. 107. I may remark that a +recent book, Ellis Meredith's _Heart of My Heart_, is devoted to a +seemingly autobiographical account of a pregnant woman's emotions and +ideas. The relations of maternity to intellectual work have been carefully +and impartially investigated by Adele Gerhard and Helena Simon, who seem +to conclude that the conflict between the inevitable claims of maternity +and the scarcely less inevitable claims of the intellectual life cannot be +avoided. + + + + +APPENDIX. + +HISTORIES OF SEXUAL DEVELOPMENT. + + HISTORY I.--The following narrative has been written by a + university man trained in psychology:-- + + So far as I have been able to learn, none of my ancestors for at + least three generations have suffered from any nervous or mental + disease; and of those more remote I can learn nothing at all. It + appears probable, then, that any peculiarities of my own sexual + development must be explained by reference to the somewhat + peculiar environment. + + I was the first child and was, naturally, somewhat spoiled--a + process which tended to increase my natural tendency to + sentimentality. On the other hand, I was shy and undemonstrative + with all except my nearest relatives, and with them as well after + my seventh or eighth year. And here it may be well to describe my + "mental type," as this is probably the most important factor in + determining the direction of one's mental development. Of mental + types the "visual" is, of course, by far the most common, but in + my own case visual imagery was never strong or vivid, and has + constantly grown weaker. The dominant part has been played by + tactual, muscular and organic sensations, placing me as one of + the "tactual motor" type, with strong "verbal motor" and + "organic" tendencies. In reading a novel I seldom have a mental + picture of the character or situation, but easily imagine the + sensations (except the visual) and feel something of the emotions + described. When telling of any event I have a strong impulse to + make the movements described and to gesticulate. I remember + events in terms of movements and the words to be used in giving + an account of them; and in thinking of any subject I can feel the + movements of the larynx and, in a less degree, of the lips and + tongue that would be involved in putting my thoughts into words. + I am easily moved to emotion, even to sentimentality, but am + seldom if ever deeply affected and am so averse to any display of + my feelings that I have the reputation among my acquaintances of + being cold, unfeeling and unemotional. I am naturally quiet and + bashful to a degree, which has rendered all forms of social + intercourse painful through much of my life, and this in spite of + a real longing to associate with people on terms of intimacy. As + a child I was sensitive and solitary; later I became morbid as + well. In a character so constituted the feelings and impulses of + the moment are likely to rule, and such has been my constant + experience, though a large element of obstinacy in my character + has kept me from appearing impulsive, and slight influences will + bring about reactions which seem out of all proportion to their + cause. For instance, I cannot, even now, read the more erotic of + Boccaccio's stories without a good deal of sexual excitement and + restlessness, which can be relieved only by vigorous exercise or + masturbation. + + The first ten years of my life were passed on a farm, most of the + time without playmates or companions of my own age. + + As far back as I can remember I indulged in elaborate day-dreams + in which I figured as the chief character along with a few others + who were chiefly creatures of my imagination, but at times + borrowed from reality. These others were always boys until I + learned the proper function of the sexual organs, when girls + usurped the whole stage in numbers beyond the limits of a Turkish + harem. Even at school my day-dreams were scarcely interrupted, + for my shyness and timidity made me very unpopular among my + schoolmates, who tormented me after the fashion of small boys or + neglected me, as the spirit moved them. To make matters worse, I + was brought up under the "sheltered life system," kept carefully + away from the "bad boys," which category included nearly all the + youngsters of the community, and deluged with moral homilies and + tirades on things religious until I was thoroughly convinced that + goodness and discomfort, the right and the unpleasant, were + strictly synonymous; and I was kept through much of the time + facing the prospect of an early death, to be followed by the good + old orthodox hell or the equal miseries of its gorgeous + alternative. I may say in all seriousness that this is a + conservative and unexaggerated account of one phase of my early + life--the one, I think, that tended most strongly to make me + introspective and morbid. Later on, when I was trying to abandon + the habit of masturbation, this early training greatly increased + the despair I felt at each successive failure. + + The first traces of sexual excitement that I can now recall + occurred when I was about 4 years old. I had erections quite + frequently and found a mild pleasure in fondling my genitals when + these occurred, especially just after waking in the morning. I + had no notion of an orgasm, and never succeeded in producing one + until I was 13 years of age. In the summer of my sixth year I + experienced pleasurable sensations in daubing my genitals with + oil and then fondling or rubbing them, but I abandoned this + amusement after getting some irritating substance into the + meatus. A year later my mother warned me that playing with my + penis would "make me very sick," but since experience had taught + me that this was not true, my conviction that what was forbidden + must necessarily be pleasant, sent me directly to my favorite + retreat in the barn loft to experiment. Since, however, I failed, + in spite of persistent effort, to produce any such pleasant + results as I had expected, I soon gave up my attempts for other + kinds of amusement. + + A few months after this, in midsummer, a very sensual servant + girl began a series of attempts to satisfy herself sexually with + my help. She came nearly every day into the loft where I was + playing and did her best to initiate me into the mysteries of + sexual relationships, but I proved a sorry pupil. She would rub + my penis until it became erect and then, placing me upon her, + would insert the penis in her vulva and make movements of her + thighs and hips calculated to cause friction. At times she varied + the program by lying upon me and embracing me passionately. I can + remember distinctly her quick, gasping breath and convulsive + movements. She generally ended the seance by persuading me to + perform cunnilingus upon her. None of these performances were + intelligible to me and I invariably protested against being + compelled to leave my play to amuse her. Even her fondling of my + genitals annoyed me; and, stranger still, I preferred satisfying + her by cunnilingus to the attempts at coitus. + + It was nearly a year later that I experienced the first + unmistakable manifestations of the sexual impulse--erections + accompanied by lustful feeling and vague desires of whose proper + satisfaction I had no notion whatever. It never occurred to me to + associate my experiences with the servant girl with these new + sensations. The peculiar fact about them was that they were + generally occasioned by the infliction of pain upon animals. I do + not remember how I first discovered that they could be evoked in + this way, but I can clearly recollect many of my efforts to + arouse this pleasurable excitement by abusing the dog or the + cats, or by prodding the calves with a nail set in the end of a + broom handle. I seldom manipulated my genitals at this time, and + when I did it was for the purpose of causing sexual excitement + rather than allaying it. + + During this same year I got my first idea of sexual intercourse + by watching animals copulate; but my powers of observation must + have been limited, for I supposed that the penis of the male + entered the anus of the female. In watching the coitus of animals + I experienced lively sexual excitement and lustful sensations, + located not only in the genitals, but apparently in the anus as + well. I often excited, myself by imagining myself playing the + part of the female animal--a peculiar combination of passive + pederasty and bestiality. A servant girl put me to right on the + error of observation just mentioned, but neglected to apply the + principle to human animals, and I remained for another year in + complete ignorance of the structure of woman's sexual organs and + of the intercourse between man and woman. In the meantime I + cultivated my fancies of intercourse with animals, often still + perversely imagining myself taking the part of the female; and + the notion of such relationships gradually became so familiar as + to seem possible and desirable. This is especially significant in + view of later developments. + + Up to my eleventh or twelfth year the erotic element in my + daydreaming varied with the seasons. In the summer it played a + dominant part, while in the winter it was almost entirely absent, + owing, it may be, to the fact that most of my time was spent + indoors or on long, tiresome tramps to and from school, and the + further fact that during the winter I saw but little of the + animals which had acted as a stimulus to sexual excitement. So + little was I troubled in winter and so ignorant was I of normal + intercourse that sleeping with a cousin, a girl of about my own + age (7 or 8 years), resulted in no addition to my knowledge of + things sexual. + + It was early in my ninth year that I first learned something of + the anatomical difference between man and woman and of the + functions of the sexual organs in coitus. These were explained to + me by a young male servant, who, however, told me nothing of + conception or pregnancy. At first I was very little interested, + as it did not immediately occur to me to associate my own erotic + experiences with the matter of these revelations; but under the + faithful tuition of my new instructor I soon began to desire + normal coitus, and my interest in the sexual affairs of animals + weakened accordingly. His teachings went still further, for he + masturbated before me, then persuaded me to masturbate him, and + finally practiced coitus inter femora upon me. He also tried to + masturbate me, but was unable to produce an orgasm, though I + found the experiment mildly pleasurable. + + Early in my eleventh year we left the farm and lived in the city + for several months. In the meantime there had been no + developments in my sexual life beyond what has already been + indicated. In the city I found so much to interest and amuse me + that I almost entirely forgot my erotic day-dreams and desires. + Though my chief playmates were two girls of about my own age I + never thought of attempting sexual intercourse with them, as I + might easily have done, for they were much wiser and more + experienced in these things than myself. Shortly before the end + of our stay in town an older schoolmate explained to me as much + of the process of reproduction as is usually known by a + precocious youngster of 12 years, but I firmly refused to credit + his statements. He adduced the fact of lactation in proof of the + correctness of his views, but I had been too thoroughly steeped + in supernaturalism to be very amenable to naturalistic evidence + of this sort and remained obdurate. But the suggestion stayed + with me and perplexed me not a little; when we returned to the + farm I began to watch the reproductive process in animals. + + The following two years were decidedly unpleasant. I was growing + rapidly and was sluggish, awkward and stupid. At school I was + more unpopular than ever and seemed to have a positive genius + for doing the wrong thing. On the rare occasions when my + companions admitted me to their counsels I was a willing dupe and + catspaw, with the result that I was much in trouble with my + teachers. Being morbidly sensitive I suffered keenly under these + circumstances and, as my health was not at all good, I often made + of my frequent headaches excuses to stay at home, where I would + lie abed brooding over my small troubles or, more often, dreaming + erotic day-dreams and making repeated attempts to produce an + orgasm. But though these efforts were accompanied by the most + lustful thoughts and my imagination created situations of + oriental extravagance, I was 13 years old when they first met + with success. I remember the occasion very distinctly, the more + so because I thought of it much and bitterly when shortly + afterwards I tried to abandon a habit which the family "doctor + book" assured me must result in every variety of damnation. At + the moment, however, I was greatly surprised and gratified and + tried at once to repeat the delightful sensation, but was unable + to do so until the following day. From that time to the present I + think I have masturbated an average of ten times per week, and + this is certainly a very conservative estimate; for though up to + my sixteenth year I could seldom produce an orgasm more than once + a day I have often, during the last four or five years, produced + it from four to seven times per day without difficulty and this + for days and even weeks in succession. During these periods of + excessive masturbation very little liquid was ejaculated and the + pleasurable sensations were slight or entirely lacking. + + From the time when I began masturbating regularly practically my + whole interest centered in things pertaining to sex. I read the + chapters of the family "doctor book" which treated of sexual + matters; my day-dreams were almost exclusively erotic; I sought + opportunities to talk about sex-relationships with my + schoolmates, with whom I was now slowly getting on better terms; + I collected pictures of nude women, learned a great number of + obscene stories, read such obscene books as I could obtain and + even searched the dictionary for words having a sexual + connotation. Up to my fifteenth year, when ejaculation of semen + began, there was a strong sadistic coloring to my day-dreams. + Through this period, too, my bashfulness in the presence of the + opposite sex increased until it reached the point of absurdity. + + When fifteen years old I began to practice coitus inter femora on + my brother and continued it intermittently for about two years. + The experience was disappointing, for I had confidently expected + a great increase of pleasure over masturbation in this act; and + in casting about for some stronger stimulus I recurred to the + forgotten idea of intercourse with animals. I promptly tried to + put the idea to a test, but failed several times, and finally + succeeded, only to find that the result fell far short of my + expectations. Nevertheless I continued the practice irregularly + for about three years--or rather through that part of the three + years that I spent at home, for while I was at school opportunity + for such indulgence was lacking. Long familiarity with the idea + of intercourse with animals had made it impossible for me to feel + the disgust with the practice which it inspires in most people; + and even the perusal of Exodus xxii: 19 failed to make me abandon + it. Firmly as I believed in the Mosaic law the supremacy of the + sexual impulse was complete. + + As early as my sixteenth year I tried to abandon "self-abuse" in + all its forms and have repeatedly made the same effort since that + time but never with more than very partial success. On two or + three occasions I have stopped for periods of several weeks, but + only to begin again and indulge more recklessly than before. The + deep depression which followed each failure, and often each act + of masturbation, I attributed solely to the loss of semen, + leaving out of account the fact that I expected to feel depressed + and the utter discouragement and self-contempt which accompanied + the sense of failure and weakness when, in the face of my + resolution, I repeatedly gave way and yielded to the temptation + to an act whose consequences I firmly believed must be ruinous. I + am now convinced that by far the greater part of this depression + was due to suggestion and the humiliating sense of defeat. And + this feeling of moral impotence, this seeming helplessness + against an overpowering impulse which, on the other hand, seemed + so trivial when viewed without passion, eventually weakened my + self-control to a degree guessed by no one but myself and sapped + the foundations of my moral life in a way which I have constant + occasion to deplore. + + The foregoing paragraphs give, I think, a fair idea of my + condition when I left home for a boarding school at the beginning + of my seventeenth year. From this time my experiences may be said + to have run on in two distinct cycles--that of the summer months + when I was at home, and that of the remainder of the year when I + was at school. This fact will make some confusion and apparent + inconsistency in the rest of this "history" unavoidable. When I + left home I was shy, retiring, totally ignorant of social usage, + without self-confidence, unambitious, dreamy, and subject to fits + of melancholy. I masturbated at least once a day, though I was in + almost constant rebellion against the habit. In my more idle + moments I elaborated erotic day dreams in which there was a + peculiar mixture of the purely sensual and the purely ideal + element; which never fused in my experience, but held the field + alternately or mingled somewhat in the manner of air and water. + One person usually served as the object of my ideal attachment, + another as the center round which I grouped my sensual dreams and + desires. + + At school I found more congenial companions than I had fallen in + with elsewhere, and the necessary contact with people of both + sexes gradually wore off some of the rougher corners and brought + a measure of self-confidence. I had two or three incipient love + affairs which my backwardness kept from growing serious. Out of + this change of environment came a sense of expansion, of escape + from self, which was distinctly pleasant. I still masturbated + regularly, but no longer experienced the former depression except + when at home during vacation. Relatively to the past, life was + now so varied and interesting that I had less and less time for + melancholy; and the discovery that I could lead my classes and + hold my own in athletic sports seemed to indicate that my past + fears had been exaggerated. Nevertheless I was never reconciled + to the habit and often rebelled at the weakness that kept me its + slave. + + When I entered the university the effects of my useless struggle + with the practice of masturbation were pretty well developed. I + could no longer fix my attention steadily upon my work and found + that only by "cribbing" and "bluffing" could I keep my place at + the head of my classes. I was troubled not a little by the + shoddiness of my work, and tried again and again during the + course of the two years spent at this college to shake off the + habit. At the university I was introduced gradually to a wider + social circle and so far outgrew my bashfulness that I began to + seek the society of the opposite sex assiduously. As I gained + self-confidence I became reckless, getting at one time into + serious trouble with the authorities which came near resulting in + my expulsion. I became one of the more popular members of the + clique to which I belonged--much to my surprise and even more to + that of my acquaintances. The physical culture craze attacked me + at this time and my pet ambition was the attainment of strength + and agility. My bump of vanity also grew apace, but an unmeasured + hatred of all kinds of foppishness kept me on the safe side of + moderation in my dress and behavior. + + During my second year of university life I had two love affairs + in the course of which I found that my interest in any particular + member of the fair sex disappeared as soon as it was returned. + The pursuit was fascinating enough, but I cared nothing at all + for the prize when once it was within reach. I may add that the + interest I had in the girls was purely ideal. While at this + school I do not think I masturbated half as often as while at the + preparatory school. + + When I left this college for ---- University I took with me a + formidable catalogue of good resolutions, first among which was + the determination to abandon all kinds of "self-abuse." I think I + kept this one about a month. As I had gone from a comparatively + small school to one of the largest of American universities the + change was great and the revelations it brought me frequently + humiliating. I was lonesome, home-sick, and my bump of + self-esteem was woefully bruised; and not unnaturally I soon + began to seek a partial solace in day-dreams and masturbation. + After I had become somewhat adapted to my new environment I + indulged less frequently in either, and from that time to the + present I have masturbated very irregularly, sometimes but little + and again to excess. + + Not long after I came to this place I met a young lady with whom + I soon became quite intimate. For over a year our friendship was + strictly platonic and then swung suddenly around to a sexual + basis. We were ardent lovers for a few weeks, after which I tired + of the game as I had before in other cases, and broke off all + relations with her as abruptly as was possible. Since then I have + almost wholly withdrawn from the society and companionship of + women and have almost entirely lost whatever tact and assurance I + once possessed in their company. Things pertaining to sexual life + have interested me rather more than less, but have occupied my + attention much less exclusively than before this episode. Though + I have never intended to marry, my breaking off relations with + this girl affected me much. At any rate it marked an abrupt + change in the character of my sexual experiences. The sexual + impulse seems to have lost its power to rouse me to action. + Hitherto I had practiced masturbation always under protest, as it + were--as the only available form of sexual satisfaction; while + now I resigned myself to it as all that there was to hope for in + that field. Of course I knew that a little effort or a little + money would procure natural satisfaction of my sexual needs, but + I also knew that I would never, under any ordinary circumstances, + put forth the necessary effort, and fear of venereal disease has + been more than enough to keep me away from houses of + prostitution. + + Some months ago I refrained from masturbation for a period of + about six weeks and watched carefully for any change in my health + or spirits, but noticed none at all. The only impulse to + masturbate was occasioned by fits of restlessness accompanied by + erections and a mildly pleasurable feeling of fullness in the + penis and scrotum. I think that over 75 per cent, of my acts of + masturbation are provoked by these fits of restlessness and are + unaccompanied by fancy images, erotic thoughts, lustful desires, + or marked pleasure. At other times the act is occasioned by + erotic thoughts and images, and is accompanied by a considerable + degree of lustful pleasure which, however, is never so intense as + in my earlier experiences and has steadily decreased from the + first. Usually the orgasm is accompanied by a strong contraction + of all the voluntary muscles, particularly the extensors, + followed by a slight giddiness and slight feeling of exhaustion. + If repeated several times in the course of a single day the acts + are followed by dullness and lassitude; otherwise the feeling of + exhaustion passes away quickly and a sense of relief and quiet + takes its place. So natural or rather habitual has this resort + to masturbation as a means of relief from nervousness and + restlessness become that the act is almost instinctive in its + unconsciousness. + + I am extremely sensitive to all kinds of sexual influences, and + have an insatiable curiosity regarding everything that pertains + to the sexual life of men or women. I am not, however, excited + sexually by conversation about sexual facts and relationships, no + matter what its nature, though in reading erotic literature my + excitement is often intense. + + The tendency to day dream has never left me, but there are no + longer any elaborate scenes or long-continued "stories," these + having been replaced by vaguely imagined incidents which are + usually broken off before they reach a satisfactory climax. They + are always interrupted by the intrusion of other matters, usually + of more practical interest; and the long-continued habit of + satisfying myself by masturbation has made erotic dreams rather + tantalizing than pleasurable. I dream very seldom at night--at + least I can scarcely ever remember any dreams upon waking--and + practically never of sexual relations. I have not had a nocturnal + emission for over three years, and probably not more than + twenty-five in my life. + + In my "love passages" with girls there has been no serious + thought of coitus on my part, and I have never had intercourse + with a woman--unless my early experiences with the servant girl + be called such. Like all masturbators I always idealized "love" + to the utter exclusion of all sensual cravings; and the notion + that the physical act of coitus was something degrading and + destructive of real love rather than its consummation was, of all + prejudices I have ever formed, the most difficult to escape--a + circumstance due, I suppose, to the fact that all I had ever been + taught on the subject tended to the complete divorce of what was + called "love" from what was stigmatized as a "base sensual + desire." Judging from my own experience and observation I should + say that "ideal love" is a mere surface feeling, bound to + disappear as soon as it has gained its object by arousing a + reciprocal interest on the part of the one to whom it is + directed. So little did I "materialize" the objects of my "love" + that I have never cared for kissing or the warm embraces in which + lovers usually indulge. I have never kissed but one girl, and her + with far too little enthusiasm to satisfy her. My last sweetheart + was a very passionate girl, the warmth of whose embraces was + somewhat torrid and, to me, both puzzling and annoying. The + intensity of feeling which demanded such strenuous expression was + beyond my knowledge of human nature. A somewhat peculiar + circumstance in connection with these experiences is the fact + that I often found myself trying to analyze my emotions with a + purely psychological interest while playing the part of the + intoxicated lover in his mistress's arms. + + There is but little left to say on the subject of my sexual + development. During the last two or three years my knowledge of + the facts of the sexual life has been very greatly increased, + and I have become acquainted with phases of human nature which + were wholly unknown to me before. The part played by things + sexual in my life is still, I suppose, abnormally large; it is + undoubtedly the largest single interest, though my outer life is + determined almost wholly by other considerations. + + Of course I know nothing of the effect which long-continued + masturbation may have had on my ability to perform normal coitus. + I do not think I am subject to any kind of sexual perversion, for + all my indulgence has been _faute de mieux_ and, at least since I + began masturbation, all my desires and erotic day-dreams have had + to do only with normal coitus. The mystery which surrounds the + sexual act seems at times to be regaining its former influence + and power of fascination. I have no doubt, however, but that I + should be greatly disillusioned should I ever perform coitus; and + I greatly regret that I have not been able to test this + conviction and so round out and complete this "history." + + It may be worth while to say a word about my religious + experiences, as, in many cases, they are closely bound up with + the sexual impulse. I was never "converted," but on a dozen or + more occasions approached the crisis more or less closely. The + dominant emotion in these experiences was always fear, sometimes + with anger and despair intermixed in varying proportions. A + complete analysis of these experiences is, of course, impossible, + but the various pleasurable feelings of which converts spoke in + the revivals which I attended were a closed book to me. Following + my revival-meeting experiences came a few days spent in a sort of + moral exaltation during which I eschewed all my habits of which + conventional morality disapproved, save masturbation, and felt no + small satisfaction with my moral conditions. I became a + first-rate Pharisee. Toward the women who had figured in my day + dreams I suddenly conceived the chastest affection, resolutely + smothering every sensual thought and fancy when thinking of them, + and putting in place of these elements ideal love, + self-sacrifice, knightly devotion--Sunday-school Garden-of-Eden + pictures with a mediaeval, romantic coloring. These day-dreams + were always sexual, involving situations of extreme complexity + and monumental silliness. Masturbation was always continued and + usually with increased frequency. The end of these periods was + always abrupt and much like awaking from a dream in which the + dreamer has been behaving in a manner to arouse his own disgust. + They were followed by feelings of sheepishness and self-contempt + mingled with anger and a dislike of all things having to do with + religion. My inability to pass the conversion crisis and a + growing contempt for empty enthusiasm finally led me to a saner + attitude toward religion, from which I passed easily into + religious scepticism; and later the study of philosophy and + science, and particularly of psychology, banished the last + lingering remnant of faith in a supernatural agency and led me + to the passion for facts and indifference to values which have + caused me to be often called "dead to all morality." + + + HISTORY II.--C.A., aged 25, unmarried; tutor, preparing to take + Holy Orders:-- + + My paternal ancestry (which is largely Huguenot) is noteworthy + for its patriotism and its large families. My father, who died + when I was a year old, is remembered for the singular uprightness + and purity of his life from his earliest childhood. The + photograph which I have shows him as possessed of a rare classic + beauty of features. He was an ideal husband and father. At the + time of his death he was a Master of Arts and a school principal. + My mother is an extraordinarily neurotic woman, yet famed among + her friends for her great domesticity, attachment to her + husbands, and an almost abnormal love of babies. She has nobly + borne the ill-treatment of her second husband, who for several + years has been in a state of melancholia. My mother has been + "highly-wrought" all her life, and has suffered intensely from + fears of all kinds. As a young girl she was somnambulistic, and + once fell down a stairhead during sleep. In spite of her bodily + sufferings with indigestion, eye-strain, and depression she + retains her youthfulness. She has slight powers of reasoning. She + has had times of unconsciousness and rigidity, I have never heard + any mention of epilepsy. She has a horror of showing prudishness + in regard to the healthful manifestations of sex life, and is + always praising examples of what she terms "a natural woman." + + I have heard that during my first year my mother detected my + nurse in the act of putting a morphine powder on my tongue for + the purpose of keeping me quiet. I was subject to convulsions at + this period, and narrowly escaped a permanent hernia. My family + tell me that from the beginning I was a well-developed and boyish + boy, full of mischief, impulsive, good to look upon, unusually + affectionate, beloved by all. + + In my third year I took pleasure in crawling under the bed with + my boy-cousin who was nine months my senior, and after we had + taken down our drawers, in kissing each other's nates. I do not + remember which of us first thought of this pastime. + + At the age of 4 I gave myself a treat by gazing upward through a + cellar window at the nates of a woman who was defecating from + several feet above into a cesspool that lay beneath. It was + during this summer also that I frightened myself by pulling back + my prepuce far enough to disclose the purple glans, which I had + never seen before. But this act gave me no desire to masturbate. + + When 5 years old, and living in a great city, I drew indecent + pictures in company with a little girl and her younger brother. + These pictures represented men in the act of urinating. The + penes were drawn large, and the streams of urine plainly + indicated. One afternoon I induced the boy to go to the + bath-room, lie on his back, and allow me to perform _fellatio_ on + him. I did not ask him to return the favor. I remember the + curious tar-like smell of his clothing and the region about his + genitals. It is possible that I gained my knowledge of _fellatio_ + from an unknown boy of 10, who had induced me, during the + preceding summer to enter a sandy lot with him, watch him + urinate, and then, kneeling before him, commit _fellatio_. A year + later, as I was walking home in the rain to our summer cottage, + with an open umbrella over my shoulder, a boy of 15, who was + leaning against our fence, exhibited a large, erect penis, and + when I had passed him urinated upon me and my umbrella. I never + saw the boy again. I felt peculiarly insulted by his act. Back of + the house there lived a 12-year-old boy who invited me to watch + him defecate in the outdoor privy, and during the act told me a + number of indecent stories and words which I cannot remember. + + About this time I fell in love with a little Jewish boy next + door. Often I cried myself to sleep over the thought that perhaps + he was lying on a sofa alone and crying with a stomach-ache. I + longed to embrace him; and yet I saw little of him, and made + little of him when I was with him. + + Living in a Western city a few months later, some girls of 12 and + 14 led me to their barn, where they dressed themselves in boys' + clothing and made believe that they were cowboys. One of them + told me to "shut my eyes, open my mouth, and get a surprise." + When I opened my eyes once more a piece of hen-dung lay in my + mouth. I have a vague remembrance of one of the girls asking me + to enter a water-closet with her. She uttered some indelicate + phrase, but I performed no act with her. In the house where I + lived I once entered the bedroom of a half-grown girl while she + was dressing. She knelt to kiss me innocently enough, and I, by a + sudden impulse, ran my hand between her bare neck and her corset + as far as I could reach. Apparently she took no notice of my + movement. Although I did not masturbate, yet during this winter I + experienced a tickling sensation about my genitals when I placed + my hand beneath them as I lay on my stomach in bed. One evening I + pulled up my night-dress and, holding my penis in my hand, I + danced to and fro on the carpet. I imagined that I was one of a + line of naked men and women who were advancing toward another + similar line that faced them. I imagined myself as pleasurably + coming in contact with my female partner who possessed male + genitals. + + The following summer I lived in the woods. My next-door playmate + was a little girl of my own age--6 years. She sat down before me + in the barn and exposed her genitals. This was the first time I + had seen female organs, or had thought for a moment that they + differed from my own. In great perplexity I asked the little + girl: "Has it been cut off?" She and I defecated in peach baskets + that we found in the upper part of the barn. + + When I was 7 years old and back in the Eastern city I lived in + the house of a physician. Alone with his 3-year-old daughter one + day, I showed her my erect organ, and felt a delicious + gratification when she stroked it with the words: "Nice! Nice!" I + confessed my fault to my guardian that night after I had said my + prayers. I had complained to my mother a year before of the + inconvenience I found in my penis being "so long sometimes." She + said that she would "see about having the end taken off." But I + was never circumcised. Her words gave me the doubly unpleasant + impression that my _glans_ was to be cut off. + + There came occasionally to the kitchen of Dr. W.'s house a + foul-mouthed Irish laundress who used coarse language to me + concerning urination. I loathed the woman, and yet one night I + dreamed that I was embracing her naked form and rolling over and + over with her on the bed; and in spite of my sight of female + genitals a few months before, I thought of her as having organs + of my own kind and size. At my first school I watched a + red-haired boy of 12 expose the penis of a 7-year-old boy as he + lay on his back in the bath-room. I do not remember that the + sight gave me sexual pleasure. + + I spent the summer before I was 8 in a double house. The adopted + daughter of our neighbor (a neurotic, retired physician) was a + girl of 13 who had been taken from a poor laboring family. She + got me to show her my parts, touched them, and asked whether I + urinated from my scrotum. She also induced me to play with her + genitals as we sat on a sofa in the twilight, and to spank her + naked nates with the back of a hair-brush as she lay on a bed; + but from none of these performances did I derive physical + satisfaction. The girl E. and I took delight in "talking dirty + secrets," as she expressed it. Her young cousin H. (nephew of her + adopted mother) never heard me use the word "thing" without + suggestively smiling. E. recalled the pleasant hours that she had + spent with her cousin when they were in their night-gowns. She + did not particularize these sexual relations. Under the + board-walk the boy H. and I once defecated in bottles. Some + little girls who lived opposite us pulled up their dresses one + night and "dared" each other to dance out beyond the end of the + house, in full view of the road. We boys merely looked on. + + I now fell passionately in love with a remarkably handsome little + boy of my own age. I longed to kiss and hug him, but I did not + dare to do so, for he was haughty and intolerant of my + attentions. I even allowed him to stand with one foot on me and + remark in a loud tone: "I am Conqueror!" I endured no end of + petty insults and much ill-treatment from this boy. I reached the + height of my passion on the night that he appeared at our + cottage in a tight-fitting suit of pepper-and-salt. I gloried in + his perfect legs and besought my guardian that she would buy me a + similar suit of clothes. + + For the summer after I was 8 years old I lived in a cottage in a + country town. The servant maid M. was a young girl of 16 who + listened eagerly to my accounts of the "secrets" and actions in + which the girl E. and I had taken delight a year before. I think + that M. arranged a meeting between a little black-haired girl and + me in order that we might take a walk and play sexually with each + other. Just as we were starting on our walk one of my relatives + said that I must not leave the yard. + + The little girl and I had see-sawed together and I had been + interested in her legs as she rose in the air. (When I was 13 + years old and see-sawing at a picnic with a stout girl, the + motion of the board and the sight of her straddled form filled me + with longing to embrace her sexually.) One afternoon M. took me + to the house of an acquaintance of hers. M's brother was in the + room and made a number of unremembered remarks which struck me as + being rather "free," and M. told me later that she and the girl + once dressed as ballet dancers and danced before M.'s brother. I + felt that he was lascivious. I was always remarkably intuitive. + + I fell in love with a handsome, stout, black-haired boy who lived + on a farm; but he was not a "farmer's son" in the common sense of + the word. I visited him for two or three days, and we slept with + each other, to my boundless joy. For his freckled girl cousin I + did not care the turn of my wrist, although she was a nice enough + little thing. One night when we three lay on a bed in the dark, + and neither of us boys had eyes or words for her, she silently + left us. He and I never committed the slightest sexual fault. I + left him with tears at the summer-end, and I often kissed his + photograph during the following winter. + + In the flat-house where I began to live when I was 8 years old, I + once practiced mutual tickling of a very slight character with a + boy of my own age. We sat on chairs placed opposite to each other + and we inserted our fingers through the openings in our trousers. + Just as we were beginning to enjoy the titillation we were + interrupted by the approach of one of my family who, however, was + not quick enough to discover us. Down cellar I often saw the + genitals of the janitor's little girls--they were fond of lifting + their skirts and they did not wear drawers--but I had no desire + to attempt conjunction. I once caught an older friend of mine (he + was 13) in the act of leaving one of the girls. The pair had been + in a coal-compartment. The boy was buttoning his trousers and I + guessed what he had been doing. When I began to sleep alone in my + tenth year I had no desire to masturbate, and was loath to do so + by reason of ample warnings given me by my guardian and by the + family physician. One afternoon a stunted friend of mine sat down + in the back yard and astonished me by tying a piece of string to + his penis. At a large private school which I now attended I made + the acquaintance of the principal's son, and wondered why he had + such a fancy for dressing his 5-year-old sister in boy's clothes. + He closed the door on me while he was thus engaged. At my house + we went to the bath-room together, and he showed me his + circumcised and much-ridged penis. Neither of us made any mention + of masturbating. + + At this period I fell slightly in love with a 5-year-old boy with + intensely black eyes. I would kiss him whenever we were alone, + but I had no wish to seduce him. I was always interested in + watching the urination of younger children. When I was 5 years + old I went on my knees to a strange little boy in order to + whisper in his ear an inquiry as to whether he wanted to urinate. + I experienced a pleasurable thrill when I was 10 years old in + leading a small girl cousin to the outdoor privy, in helping her + on and off the open seat, in buttoning and unbuttoning her + drawers, and in gazing at her vulva. + + The summer before I was 10 I lived a wild life in the mountains. + My companions were a negro girl, the two daughters of a + clergyman, the two sons of a questionable woman hotel-keeper, and + the daughter of the Irish scavenger. All of these children were + extraordinarily sensual. Their leading pastime, from morning + until night, was varying forms of indecency, with the supreme + caress--which they termed "raising dickie"--as the most frequent + enjoyment. The 5-year-old daughter of the scavenger explained to + us how she had seen her father approaching her stout mother with + an erect penis, the pair standing up before the lamplight during + the act. This curly-headed, rosy-cheeked child handled her + genitals so much that they were inflamed. I once saw her sitting + in the road and rubbing dust against her vulva. I saw little of + the elder daughter of the minister (she was 12 years old). She + persuaded me to expose myself before her in the cellar of a + partially-built house. In return for my favor she allowed me to + look at her genitals. She did not ask for _conjunctio_. The two + younger daughters were my intimates. With the middle one I was + forever performing a weak conjunction that consisted in the + laying of my member against her vulva. Notwithstanding all the + entreaties of my little friend, I could not be persuaded to + protrude my penis against her vagina; and not on one occasion can + I remember obtaining an erection or extreme pleasure. Up in the + garret she straddled slanting beams with her genitals exposed, + and I followed her example. The negro girl and my little friend + both urinated on a tent floor at my request. I did not fancy the + odor of a girl's genitals, nor the appearance of the vulva when + the labia were held apart. + + The following summer, when I was almost 11, I took a long walk + one day with my old friend, the girl E. We entered a patch of + woods and ate our lunch, but no sense of sexual drawing toward + the girl came over me and she did not offer to entice me. I + slept with her boy-cousin one night, and her neuropathic aunt, a + retired lady physician, bothered us by repeatedly creeping into + our room. I felt intuitively that she was watching to see whether + we would commit mutual masturbation--which we had no thought of + doing. Three years before I had opened the door of her bedroom + suddenly and saw E.'s naked form. The physician had been + examining her, E. told me later. My guardian also annoyed me by + repeated warnings not to play with myself. + + Just before I turned 11 I was sent to a small and so-called + "home" boarding-school. Eight of us lived in the smaller + dormitory. The matron roomed downstairs. There was no resident + master--a serious error. We small boys were told to strip one + evening. We were then tied neck-to-neck and made to dance a + "slave-dance," which was marked by no sexuality. A boy of 15, R., + one afternoon gave me the astonishing information that my father + had taken a part in my procreation. Up to this moment I had known + only of the maternal offices, information of which had been + beautifully supplied to me by my guardian when I was 7 years old. + At that time I talked freely about the coming of a baby brother + in a distant city; I watched the construction of baby clothes; I + named the newcomer, and I was momentarily disappointed when he + proved to be a girl. This same R., a strong boy with a large + penis, got into the custom of lying in bed with me just before + lights were put out. He would read to himself and occasionally + pause to pump his penis and make with his lips the sound of a + laboring locomotive. I felt impelled to handle his organ, for I + was fascinated by its size, and stiffness, and warmth. Rarely he + would titillate my then small and unerect penis. R. never + ejaculated when he was with me; hence not until my third year was + I acquainted with the appearance of a flow of semen. Sometimes R. + would stop during his dressing to manipulate his penis, but was + such a picture of rosy health that I doubt whether he brought + himself often to ejaculation. R. told me that he had been to a + brothel where his genitals were examined to determine whether + they were large enough and not diseased. He also related how he + "played cow" with a girl of his own age, she consenting to + perform _fellatio_ upon him. A dark-skinned, unwashed, pimpled + but fairly vigorous boy of 16, with an irritable domineering + manner, told me the delights of coitus with a girl in a + bath-house, and I overheard his conversation with another "old" + boy concerning the purchase of a girl in a big city for the sum + of five dollars. No details were given. + + I will now pass to my third year, when I was 13 years old. A + large, well-set-up boy of 16, A., became my idol. His toleration + of my presence in his room filled me with endless love. When I + lied about a matter in which he was concerned, his denunciation + of me brought me to a state of shuddering and weeping + unspeakable. When our relations were established again A. + allowed me to creep into his bed after the lights were out, and + there I passionately embraced him, but without performing any + definite act. When I turned over on my side with my back to him + he drew my prepuce back and forth until I experienced orgasm, but + not ejaculation. I would return his favor by pumping his erect + penis, but with no ejaculation on his part. He did not propose + _fellatio_, and I did not think of it. One night when he was in + my bed I began to masturbate very slightly, whereupon he laughed, + saying: "So that is the way you amuse yourself!" As a matter of + fact the habit was not fastened upon me. He always laughed when + the rubbing of his finger on my exposed glans caused me to + shrink. Another boy, H., now began to show me his erect penis and + we practiced mutual manipulations. A. laughingly told me how me + had caught H. in the act of masturbating as he stood in the + bath-tub. A. told me a number of sexual stories--how he enjoyed + coitus in the bushes with a girl on the way home from + entertainments; how half a dozen boys and girls stripped in the + basement of a church and performed coitus on the velvet chairs + which stood behind the pulpit; and how he and a younger boy, who + camped out together, played with each other's genitals. F., a boy + of 11, was highly nervous, subject to timidity and tears on the + slightest provocation, often morose, and under treatment for + kidney trouble. His penis was erect whenever I saw him undress. + He told me that a partially idiotic man taught F. and his + companion how to masturbate. The man invited the boys to his tent + and there pumped his organ until "some white stuff came out of + it." F. also told me that an Indian princess in his part of the + country would permit coitus for fifty cents. A. sometimes slept + with F., and I could imagine their embraces. S., a secretive, + handsome boy of 13, wetted his bed with urine every night. The + only sign that he gave of an interest in sexuality was his + laughing remark concerning the coupling of rose-bugs. Of his + chum, my beloved C., I will speak later. My small room-mate + handled himself only slightly. I never had a desire to lie with + him, since I disliked him, nor with my first room-mate, a + "chunky," fiery boy of 10, whose penis interested me merely + because it was circumcised and almost always erect. His + masturbation was also so slight as not to attract any particular + attention. A lusty German boy, B., showed no signs of sexuality + until his third year, when he laughed about his newly-appearing + pubic hair, and told several of us openly of how he enjoyed to + play "a drum-beat" on his penis before going to sleep. "I don't + do it too much, though," he explained. He showed a mild curiosity + when I gave him the resume of a book on cohabitation which + contained illustrations of the erect penis and the female organs. + I had found this book in the woods and I read it eagerly during + my third year. + + I came to the point of agreeing with A., who said: "Everyone is + smutty." Indeed I lived in a lustful world, and yet my mind was + bent also on books, and writing, and the outdoor world. I was + overgrown and splendidly developed, with a medium-sized penis and + a scant growth of pubic hair. My face wore a somewhat infantile + expression. My mouth was a perfect "Cupid's bow," my hair thin + and light. I was troubled about my snub-nose, which gave the boys + a great deal of amusement. As a matter of fact I exaggerated its + upward tendency out of my morbid self-consciousness and + cowardice. My imagination was extraordinarily intense, as it had + always been. I was sensitive to smells and sounds and colors and + personalities, and to the subtle influence of the night. I was + timid and easily moved to tears, but not from any physical + weakness until after. At the lower house there was the boy Z., + famed for his large penis; and the older G., a boy of 15, who was + the leader in sexuality at his dormitory. Z. showed me his penis + and exposed his glans often enough, but we did not manipulate + each other. G. told us to notice how large a space his penis + occupied in his trousers, and laughed over Z.'s custom of + masturbating by means of a narrow vase. G.'s special lover was a + nervous boy of ten. It is remarkable that none of us mentioned + _fellatio_ or _paedicatio_. These acts may have occurred at + school, but not to my knowledge. We did not have much to say + sexually about the girls. We heard rumors of a 16-year-old, V., + who had been sent away from school for coitus; and my first + room-mate was said to have obtained _conjunctio_ with a girl + under cover of the chapel shed. Once A. and I pointed a telescope + at the open windows of the girls' dormitory, but we saw nothing + to interest us. A day-scholar, J., a pale, nervous, bright boy of + 13, took me into the study of his uncle-physician and together we + gloated over pictures of the sexual organs. A. was with us on one + occasion. J. told me how he liked to roll over and over in bed + with his hand placed under his scrotum. This act, he said, made + him imagine that he was obtaining coitus. He advised me to slide + my penis back and forth in the vagina whenever I should actually + obtain coitus. In my room at school J. once drew an imaginary map + of a bagnio, in which the water-closet was carefully displayed + _en suite_ with the bedrooms. J. and I never masturbated + together. Indeed, I cannot remember seeing his organ. A hulking + boy of 16, who lived opposite the school-grounds, became intimate + with J., and we three went on a walk up the railroad track. The + big boy, W., tried to inflame my passions by telling me how he + and J. had had coitus with a handsome black-haired widow in town, + but I remained cold. + + During this year I fell in love with C., a popular, talkative, + witty boy of my own age, or perhaps a year younger. He fancied me + and we slept together one night under the most innocent + circumstances. I never dreamed of having sexual relations with + him, and yet I fairly burned with love for him. My stay at his + beautiful home over Sunday while his parents were away was one + long delight. We slept in each other's arms, but there was no + sexuality. En route to C.'s home he pointed with a glove to a + little working-girl, saying he would like to have intercourse + with her, but this was the only remark of the kind that ever + passed his lips in my presence. When undressed save for his + undershirt, he laughingly held his unerect organ in his hand and + made the motions of obtaining conjunction with an imaginary + partner. Once we spoke of masturbation (I could recite the + information of my good physician with a marvelous show of + virtue), and C. remarked: "Yes, doing that makes boys crazy." C. + finally grew tired of my deceptive, babyish nature and + ultra-interest in books and puzzles, but I cherished an + undiminished affection for him, and when he was detained at home + for a fortnight with a broken arm, I wrote him a passionate + letter, which I sobbed over and actually wetted with my tears. + But the fervor of my passion died at the close of the year. I + consider this unsullied friendship to be the only redeeming + feature of my sensual days at school. + + Versed as I was in the warnings against masturbation, I found + pleasure one afternoon when I was alone in slipping my penis + through the open handle of a pair of scissors and in violently + flapping my partially erect organ until a strange, sweet thrill + crept over me from top to toe and a drop of clear liquid oozed + from my member. But I gave up the manipulation with scissors, + finding a greater satisfaction in masturbating while I was + defecating or just after it. I either pumped my organ by slipping + the prepuce back and forth, or I grasped the organ at its root + and violently jerked it back and forth. I soon began to + masturbate not only every time that I defecated, but also at + night just before I went to sleep, and sometimes early in the + morning. On the whole I preferred the jerking just described. I + always brought about ejaculation after perhaps five minutes of + violent exertion. + + My penis became chafed at the root, but I did not especially + care. I remember the afternoon that I masturbated for the first + time while I was defecating in the school water-closet. I cannot + recall that at first I thought of coitus while I masturbated. On + one occasion I masturbated over the _vase de nuit_ after a + delightful afternoon of tobogganing exploration up and down the + mountain. + + During this first year of abuse, I felt no ill effects + whatsoever, although I realized, in an unthinking way, that I was + doing wrong. But sexuality had assumed the proportion of a + regular feature of our school life. It was difficult for me to + place a "universal" view in its true perspective. I used to smile + at the glazed, dull morning eye of poor H., who was a stunted boy + of 15, and thus could not endure his losses so well as I could + endure them. The qualms of conscience which I suffered were lost + in my delight in my dawning sexual life. Sometimes I lay on my + stomach in bed, and by placing my hand under my scrotum, + according to the directions of J., brought up a pretty girl to + mind. Just before Sunday school G., our chief reprobate, and the + rest of us would hunt out what we considered to be nasty texts of + Scripture. The chapter concerning the whoredoms of Aholah and + Aholibah gave me an especial pleasure. T. mentioned the giggling + that occurred at prayers in the lower dormitory when the details + of Esau's birth were read out. A few days before G. was + expelled--for exactly what cause I do not know--he told me of how + greatly he enjoyed coitus on his grandmother's sofa with a girl + of fifteen. When I went home on the boat for holidays I noted the + large, black-haired penis of the strong boy of our school. He + occupied a state-room with me, but made no sexual overtures. + + Since my twelfth year I had been wrapped up all summer long in a + boy who was six months my senior. We slept together constantly, + but not once did we think of obtaining mutual gratification. On + the contrary, we held up high ideals to each other and frowned on + masturbation. I took delight in saying that I never had handled + myself, and never would do so. Even at the height of my + "auto-erotic" period, I skillfully concealed my habits from all + my boy friends. A neurotic solo choir boy friend once spoke of + obtaining ejaculation, whereupon I expressed utter ignorance of + such an act, little hypocrite that I was. This boy told how the + house servants joked with him about coitus and made laughing + lunges at his organs. + + But much as I loved my chum, my most passionate regard went out + in my thirteenth year to N., a chubby, blue-eyed, choir-boy of + 12. He was a pretty boy to any eye. He was not gifted, except in + water-sports, and anything but popular either with girls or with + boys; yet I grew warm at the mention of his name. He did not care + a fig for me. From first to last I had no consciousness of the + sexual nature of my passion, and the thought of doing more than + embrace and kiss him in an innocent manner never crossed my mind. + For two summers I had nights of tossing on my bed (although I + almost never was sleepless for any cause) when I would see his + dear face and form, in and out of the swimming pool, or engaged + perhaps in singing or in showing his beautiful teeth. I seldom + was smitten with little girls, and I found myself embarrassed in + their company after my ninth year; yet I thought well enough of + their looks and ways to enjoy their company at dances. The girls + liked me in a platonic way, for I was accounted a good, big, + kind, blundering boy with a helping hand for the smallest fry. + + During the summer after I was 13, I imagined myself in the early + morning, when I was half awake, as persuading my wife to have + coitus with me. In the course of my spoken words I kept my hand + under my scrotum. + + A plump girl-cousin of my own age was visiting at my uncle's + during the summer after I was 13. With her I greatly desired to + satisfy myself, but I could not be sure that my boy cousin (5 + years old) might not find us out, even though she should consent. + Once when we three were in the hay-loft a wave of lust rolled + over me, but I made no proposal. Night and gaslight greatly + increased my _libido_. On one occasion my aunt had gone to the + village for ice-cream, and L. and I were left alone in the + dining-room. I took her on my lap and had a powerful erection. I + almost asked her to play sexually with me in the barn, but + instead I spoke of an imaginary girl, the first letters of whose + successive names spelled an indecent word for coitus--a word + known to almost every Anglo-Saxon child, I fear. L. laughed, but + gave no sign of assent. For a neighboring girl of 15 I felt such + a drawing that early in the morning I would roll on the floor + with my erect organ in my hand in riotous imagining of coitus + with her. I walked with her in the woods and sat at her feet, but + although I felt instinctively that she would satisfy me without + much persuasion, yet I _could not_ ask her. One night I started + to church in order to walk home with her, and lead her (if + possible) to a field where we might gratify ourselves (I picked + out the exact grassy spot where we might lie); but when I was + almost at the church door my "moral sense" (if that is what it + was) rose and dragged me home again. + + During the swimming hour I watched the genitals of the boys, + comparing them carefully in the most minute details. Circumcised + organs affected me as being disagreeable, and men's hairy, coarse + genitals I abhorred. + + When 13 I became acquainted with the new mail-boy at the inn. He + was a city "street-boy," and got me into smoking cigarettes + occasionally. I did not definitely take up smoking until I was + 16. He told me that a mason once offered him ten cents if he + would masturbate the man in a cellar. The boy said that he + refused. I slept a few times with an ill-favored boy of fine + parentage. He was of my own age, and I had played with him in a + natural way for several years, but my increasing sexual desires + led me to mutually masturbate with him, and even unsuccessfully + to attempt with him mutual paedicatio. On the morning after our + nights of sensuality I felt "gone" and miserable, but not + repentant. By afternoon I was myself again. My relations with G. + were purely animal, for I disliked his jealous disposition, his + horse-laugh, his features, his form, his withdrawn scrotum and + his undersized penis. At home in the evening I often found myself + inflamed with a mental picture of active _fellatio_ with him, but + I never performed this act, so far as I remember. + + One of my great sexual desires was to walk along a fence on which + a girl was seated. In order that I might feast my eyes on her + pudenda she must not wear drawers. + + When I turned 14 I had been, from my unusual size, in long + trousers for several months. I entered a private day-school and + progressed brilliantly in my studies. I kept up masturbation + almost daily, sometimes twice a day, both in the water closet and + in bed. I can remember ejaculating before urination in the school + _cabinet_. At night I often found myself longing for the return + of my sister, seven years my junior, in order that I might + embrace her in bed and fondle her genitals. I had done these + things during my Christmas vacation of the year before. I mildly + reproached myself for such incestuous desires, but they recurred + continually. I dreamed little. And I cannot remember the + character of my dreams. My waking _libido_ spent itself mostly in + longings to embrace (without lustful acts) the forms of little + boys of exquisite blonde beauty and thick hair. Narcissism may + have been present, for in my twelfth year I had been told that at + the age of 5 and 6 I was an extraordinarily beautiful little + creature with long, lint-white hair. The preferable age was from + 6 to 9. My eye was alert on the streets for boys answering to + this description, and a street boy with long, white hair so won + my passion that I followed him to his home and asked his mother + if he might call on me and "play some games." As I did not even + know the boy's name and had never seen him before, I was + wonderingly refused. I sought in vain to find the whereabouts of + another long-haired street boy whom I burned to embrace and load + with benefits. I had a boundless desire for such a boy as this to + idolize me--to look into my face out of big eyes and lose himself + in love for me--to call me by endearing pet names--of his own + accord to throw his arms around my neck. This second actual boy + disappeared from my horizon by presumably moving away from the + vast city neighborhood. I took a fancy to a small boy at school, + who possessed the requisite delicacy, timidity, and sweetness, if + not the physical requisites, of my beau ideal. I walked with him + in the park and planned to have him at the house; but the matter + was not arranged. At boarding-school I had associated much with + younger and weaker boys, and had been ridiculed much for my + cowardice in sports, but at the city school I moved with my + equals and won their recognition. Our gymnasium director was + middle-aged and of an indolent disposition. He liked to recall + his youthful erections and to answer my sexual queries too fully, + and cheerfully volunteered information on brothels. Yet I doubt + whether he had an evil purpose in conversing with me. I thought I + should never dare or want to enter one. I always conjured up the + picture of a row of naked women from whom I could take my pick, + and the smell of the women I imagined to be identical with the + smell of my big friend A. at boarding-school. When I was + traveling down town on an elevated train one afternoon the + brakeman asked me whether I had ever been in a brothel, and told + me that disorderly houses abounded in my neighborhood. "I have + had connection with women," said this red-haired young man, + waving his hand in greeting to a woman who nodded at him from a + window, "since I was 15 years old. Not long ago a fine-looking, + young woman in black offered to pay all my expenses if I would + live with her and connect with her." + + When a girl of perhaps 7, a distant cousin of mine, visited us + for a few days, I gratified my lust by placing my hand under her + genitals and swinging her to and fro. She giggled with pleasure. + That summer I began to experience the evil effects of the + masturbation which I had practiced daily for a year and a half. + Pimples began to break out on my chin (my complexion up to this + time had been white and delicate). The family ascribed my + condition to digestive difficulties. In playing with the boys and + girls I found myself seized with a terrible shyness and a + tendency to look down and weep. I had lost all the courage I + had--it had never been great--in the presence of a crowd of + children. I was fairly at ease with a single companion. My + self-consciousness was something more painful to me than I can + convey in words. At home I wept in my room and cursed myself for + a baby. I little realized the cause of my nervous collapse. Yet I + had too robust a frame not to be able to sleep and to play hard. + The sympathetic pleasure which I had found in swinging my + girl-cousin to and fro I now doubled by letting a 7-year-old boy + ride cock-horse on my feet. I experienced an erection during the + process, and I almost induced ejaculation when I tickled the boy + with my feet in the region of his genitals. To see his shrinking, + giggling joy gave me an exquisite sexual thrill. I longed to + sleep with the boy, but I was afraid of causing comment. At the + new and large boarding school which I entered in the fall my most + lustful dreams and ejaculations were concerned with standing this + little boy on the footboard of a bed, taking down his + knickerbockers, and performing _fellatio_ on him. But I dreamed + also of natural coitus. I fell in love with the handsome, + 12-year-old son of the aged headmaster. The boy, O., sat next me + at the table, and I never tired of gazing at him. It gave me a + special sense of pleasure to look at him when he wore a certain + flowing, scarlet, four-in-hand necktie. But O. was not attracted + to me--for one thing I was in a disagreeably pimpled + condition--and I could not induce him to linger in my room nor to + sleep with me. My passion for O. did not diminish, and it rose to + its supremacy on the evening when he appeared in our hallway (he + roomed on the girls' side of the house and hinted at the sexual + sights that he saw) in a costume of white satin, lace, and wings. + He was ready for a costume party. + + I now masturbated less frequently, for I was beginning to + appreciate the horrible consequences of my indulgence. I had + frequent pollutions, with dreams. My day was one long agony of + fear. How I dreaded to go to sleep in the same bed with my older + chum, who never made any advances beyond embracing me passively + _cum erectione_ while he was asleep. My day was one long agony of + fear. At meal time my feet constantly writhed in agony for fear + that the headmaster's grown up young ladies should make fun of + me, or that my lack of facial composure and my inability to look + people in the eye might be commented upon. I tingled with + apprehension, especially in the region of my stomach. Every nerve + was taut in the effort I made to appear composed. I masturbated + with erections over nothing. Greek recitations were for me an + _auto da fe_. My heart beat like a trip-hammer at the thought of + getting up to recite, and once on my feet my voice shook and my + mind wandered. I hated the thought of people behind me looking at + me. I rarely summoned the courage to turn my head either one way + or the other. I vastly admired the "bravery" of the small, + 15-year-old boy who recited so calmly and so well. I was too + cowardly to play foot-ball and base-ball, and I dreaded even my + favorite tennis because the spectators put me in a state of + scared self-consciousness. Knowing my own condition, I was yet so + blind to it most of the time, and such a Jekyll-and-Hyde, that I + actually pitied a boy of 19 who was an eccentric and a scared + victim of masturbation. But in spite of my neuropathic condition + I developed intellectually. I do not touch upon this aspect of my + life, however, because I am trying to limit myself strictly to + sexual manifestations. At the present time I have not the courage + to continue the narrative. + + + HISTORY III.--The following narrative is written by a clergyman, + age 40, unmarried:-- + + My childhood and early boyhood were unmarked by sexual phenomena, + beyond occasional erections, which commenced when about 5 years + of age, without any exciting causes. These were accompanied by + some degree of excitement, of the same nature as that which I + experienced in later years. I was absolutely ignorant of sexual + matters, but always had an idea that the essential difference + between man and woman was to be found in the genital organs. This + was sometimes a matter for thought and curiosity. + + Being for many years an only child I saw little of other + children, and formed the habit of amusing myself with making + things--boats, houses, etc.--and acquired a taste for science. + When I could read I preferred biography, history, and poetry to + anything else. + + When I was 13 years old and at a large school I heard for the + first time of coitus, but very imperfectly. For a few days it + filled my thoughts and mind, but feeling it was too engrossing a + subject and one which took me off better things, I put it out of + my mind. Later, another boy gave me a fuller description of the + matter, and I began to have a great desire to know more and to be + old enough to practice it. I also discovered that boys + masturbated, and about a year after tried the experiment for + myself. This vice was largely indulged in by my school-fellows. + It never occurred to me that it was sinful, until I was nearly + 16, when I came across a passage in Kenns's _Manual of + Schoolboys_, in which it was hinted such things were wrong + morally and spiritually. Previously I had felt it was an + indelicate and shameful thing, and bad for health. This last idea + was held as a solemn fact by all my boy friends. Gradually + religion began to exert an influence over my sexual nature, + obtaining as years passed a greater and greater restraining + power. It is simply impossible for me to write a history of my + sexual development without also describing the action which + Christianity has had in determining its growth. The two have been + so intimately bound together that my life history would not be a + faithful record of facts if I left religion out of it. + + At school I took part, with great keenness, in cricket and + foot-ball, and was very ambitious to excel in everything in which + I took an interest, but I always had other tastes as well, which + were more precious to me, for example, the love for science, + history, and poetry. Until I was past 16 years my desire was + simply for coitus, girls and women attracted me only as affording + the means of gratifying this desire; but when I was nearly 17 I + began to regard girls as beautiful objects, apart from this, and + to desire their love and companionship. At the same time it + dawned upon me that life held much of joy in the love of women + and in domestic life--so henceforth I regarded them in a higher + and purer light, and apart from sexual gratification. In fact, + from this period till I was over 20, this idea so dominated my + whole being that the lower side of my nature was entirely held in + subjection and abeyance by it. It was rather repulsive to think + of girls as objects of lust. This state of mind was not brought + about by any romantic attachment or through any acquaintance or + through circumstances. I was living in great seclusion and had no + girl friends. After this period the lower side of my nature woke + up as a giant refreshed with wine, and I underwent for many years + a constant struggle with my nature, in which religion always + triumphed in the end. I never fell into fornication, though + sometimes into the vice of masturbation. These outbursts of + desire were periodic, about ten or fourteen days apart, and would + last several days. I must record also the fact that from the time + this awakening took place my ideal views of woman no longer + seemed incompatible with sexual relations. I noticed that at + about 27 there was a lessening of the desire, but that may have + been due to overwork and consequent nervous exhaustion. I had a + good deal of worry and studied daily for about eight hours. In + any case the impulse was strongest during the years above + mentioned. A little later in life, for a time, I became attached + to a girl, and eventually engaged. I then observed, greatly to my + sorrow and annoyance, that whenever I met this lady, or even + thought of her, erections took place. This was particularly + painful to me, as my thoughts were not of a lustful or impure + character. Sometimes sitting by her at a religious service this + would occur, when certainly my mind was far away from anything of + the kind. That was the first woman ever kissed by me, except of + course members of my immediate family circle. Later on my + thoughts turned to marriage, and there was a great longing at + times for this event to take place. However, as this attachment + afterward became the great sorrow of my life for years, it needs + no more comment. This closes one chapter of my history, and at + present I do not propose to add another, as in a great measure it + is only partly written. It may be well here to state that there + has never been in me the slightest homosexual desire; in fact it + has always appeared as a thing utterly inconceivable and + disgustingly loathsome. I am fond of the society of both men and + women, but on the whole prefer the latter. I have had several + warm and intimate though platonic friendships, and get on + exceedingly well with the other sex, although not a good-looking + man. I have always been attracted to women by their spiritual or + mental qualities, rather than by physical beauty, and feel + strongly that the latter alone would never cause me to desire + coitus. Unless there was an attraction other than that of the + flesh, I should feel that I was following simply a brute + instinct, and it would jar with my higher nature and cause + revulsion. This was not the case in my earlier years to the same + extent. I have often wondered whether the sexual impulse was + strong in me or not, but if not, there is nothing in my physical + state or family history to account for it. I am fairly cognizant + with the lives of my ancestors, being descended from two old + families. The sexual instinct was certainly not weak or abnormal + in them. Personally, I am tall and healthy, well built, but + sensitive and highly strung. Smell has never played any part in + my life as a stimulant of sexual desire, and the mere thought of + body odors would have a very decided effect in the opposite + direction. Touch and sight appeal to me strongly, and of the two + the former most. + + I am convinced, after many years careful thought, that sexual + vice and perversion could be greatly reduced if the young were + instructed in the elements of physiology as they bear on this + question. Personally, had I been thus enlightened much sin would + have been avoided in my schoolboy days, and a perverted view of + sexual matters would never have arisen in my mind. It took years + to overcome the feeling that all such things were unclean and + defiling. Eventually light came to me through reading a passage + in a tractate on the Creed by Rufinus. He was defending the + doctrine, of the Incarnation against the pagan objection that it + was an unclean and disgusting idea that God should enter the + world through the womb of the Blessed Virgin Mary, and he meets + it by showing that God created the sexual organs, therefore the + objection is invalid--otherwise God would not be clean or pure, + having Himself designed them and their functions. This passage is + slight in itself, but gave birth to a line of thought which has + influenced me profoundly. I no longer regard sexual matters as + disgusting and unholy, but as intensely sacred, being the outcome + of the Divine Mind. Further, the Incarnation of the Saviour has + not only sanctioned motherhood and all that is implied by it, but + has eternally sanctified it as the means chosen for the + manifestation of God to the world. I should not obtrude my + theological conceptions, but for the fact that they have + determined my life-history in that aspect. + + + HISTORY IV.--When I was 9 years old a boy at the preparatory + school, which I attended, showed me the act of masturbation, + which he said he had practiced for a long time, and which he + urged me to imitate, if I wished to become a father when I grew + up, and married! Boy-like I believed him and tried, but the + sensation obtained was not a pleasant one (I suppose that I was + too rough with myself) and I desisted. + + When I was about 12 years old, a schoolfellow told me that he had + seen his nurse copulating with the groom, and he and I used to + haunt the woods in the hope that we might see an amorous couple + so engaged, but without success. We often talked of the act, as + to how it was done. Neither he nor I had any clear ideas on the + subject, save as to the organs involved. I was about 15 when a + maidservant of the house in which I was a boarder, came to my + bedroom one night and taught me how to masturbate her. She said + that this was a good thing for me to do, and warned me never to + "play with myself" as it would kill me, or drive me mad. I told + her that I had tried it, but could not bring on a pleasurable + feeling, so she did it to me, and although I did not have an + emission, I derived great pleasure from the act. She told me that + it never did a boy any harm to let a girl play with his parts, + and promised that if I would keep the secret, she would often do + this for me. Naturally I promised to say nothing, and she often + came up to my room. Later on she used to insert my penis into her + vulva, while she was rubbing it, at the same time giving me a + pigeon kiss. This _modus operandi_ was much appreciated by me. + One night, after we had been together thus, I dreamt of her and + her maneuvers and had my first emission. I was very proud of + this, as I considered that I had at last attained to man's + estate, and told her of it. She never allowed me to insert my + penis into her vulva after that, alleging that she did not want + to have a baby. + + I was about 161/2 years old when I had my first real coitus, my + partner in the act being a girl some two years older than I, who + lived near us. I enjoyed the act very much, as she permitted, nay + insisted on, emission _intra vaginam_, and told her that this was + much nicer than my amours with the maidservant which of course I + had confided to her. She laughed, and said: "Of course." We often + copulated, as long as I was at home, and then I lost sight of + her. Of all the women with whom I have had to do, save one, she + had the most copious secretion of mucus, which in those days I + believed was the woman's semen. Her thighs used to be wet with + it. + + At the University I had regular relations with women of all + sorts, rarely missing a week. Two of them were married women, one + the wife of a solicitor, the other of a doctor. How proud I felt + of my first intrigue with a married woman! I felt that I was + really a man of the world now! + + But though my friends used to tell me all about their love + affairs, and I longed to confide in them, I did not do so. This + was because when I went up to the University, my uncle said that + he would give me a word of advice and hoped that I would follow + it--never to give away a woman, and never to refuse to respond to + a woman's advances, whoever she were. To neglect this advice + would, he said, be foolish, and to break the rules "damned + ungentlemanly." I wish I had always followed advice proffered, as + closely as I have followed this. One night, when I was somewhat + disguised in liquor, as our grandfathers would have put it, I + picked up a girl, who was a private prostitute, if the phrase be + permissible. She declined copulation, and proposed other means of + satisfaction. I insisted, being stubborn in my cups. Had I been + sober I should have done as she suggested, for I have always made + it a point to allow the woman to choose the method of + gratification, and not to demand, or even suggest, anything + myself. I like to please women, and I have always been curious as + to their wants and desires, as revealed, without outside + influence, by themselves. The result of my refusing all methods + of gratification save the most ordinary was that the girl, who + must have known that she was not all right, but shrank from + saying so in so many words, gave me a gonorrhoea, which lasted + nine weeks and much interfered with my amours, as I naturally + declined to run the risk of infecting my partner, a risk which to + my certain knowledge many a young fellow has run, with disastrous + consequence to the confiding woman. As it was due to my tipsy + obstinacy, I could not blame the girl, but resolved never to + drink too much again, a resolve which I have kept, save once, + unbroken. In those days we youngsters thought that it was manly + to be able to carry one's liquor well, and did all in our power + to attain to the seasoned head; but I considered that the risks + entailed were too serious to be neglected. + + I was well on in my 26th year when I met a widow with whom I fell + in love, with the result that I married her. She is a most + sensible woman, and it was her intellectual gifts which were the + attraction to me. In my amours intellect has never played a part. + She has all along been cognizant of, and lenient to, my + polygamous tendencies; for she recognizes the fact that whatever + _fredaine_ I may have on hand makes not the slightest difference + in my love and respect for her. Were she a more sensual woman, + perhaps things would be different. + + In all I have had to do with 81 other women, of whose special + characteristics I kept a careful note at the time. Twenty-six + were normal women with whom my _liasons_ have lasted long, so I + know more about them than I do about the other fifty-five, who + were prostitutes, and with some of whom my dealings were but for + an afternoon. + + The races represented have been these, for I have seen a bit of + the world: English, Scotch, Irish, Welsh, French, German, + Italian, Greek, Danish, Hungarian, Roumanian, Indian, and + Japanese. Taking them all round, the only difference that I found + between old and young women is that the older ones are less + selfish, and more complaisant, and less inclined to resent one's + being unable to attain to the height of their desire, for from + time to time I have been unable to "come up to the scratch" after + a heavy night's labor, or when I was afraid of being caught in + the act of coition, a fear which, in my experience, acts as a + stimulus to desire in women, unlike its action in men. Of all the + women with whom I have had to do the nicest in every way have + been the French women. The English women of the town drink too + much, and are far too keen on getting as much money as they can + for as little as they can, to please me. Were the London girls to + recognize that men do not like a tipsy woman, and that where + there is so much competition the person who is most skillful and + most polite gets the most custom, the alien invasion in Regent + street would soon come to an end. + + Of the fifty-five prostitutes: eighteen informed me that they + were in the habit of masturbating; eight of their own free will, + without asking for reward, did _fellatio_; six asked me to do + _cunnilingus_, which I naturally declined to do; three proposed + anal coitus. Of those who did _fellatio_, two (one French and one + German) told me that they had taken to it because they had heard + that human semen was an excellent remedy against consumption, + which disease had carried off some of their relatives, and that + they had gradually come to like doing it. All who told me that + they masturbated, asked me whether I did so too, and two desired + me to show them the act, one alleging that she liked to see a man + do it; she had been married late in life, after a "stormy youth" + and had had, she said, a large experience of the male sex. They + all seemed to think that however much the practice of + self-excitement might hurt a man, and all thought that it would + hurt him, a woman might masturbate as often as she liked, failing + better means of satisfaction, as she had no such loss of + substance as a man. + + Of the twenty-six normal women, whom I knew more intimately than + I did the fifty-five prostitutes, thirteen, without being + questioned by me, blurted out the fact that they were habitual + masturbators, apparently all required to think of the loved + person to obtain full satisfaction. _Fellatio_ was proposed, and + fully performed, by nine, of whom three experienced the orgasm as + soon as they perceived that I had attained to it. All were more + or less excited while doing it. One proposed anal coitus, "just + to see what it was like;" and three proposed _cunnilingus_, one + having been initiated by a girl friend, and one by her husband. + The third had, I believe, evolved the act out of her own inner + consciousness in her desire to experience pleasure with me. My + relations with one of the twenty-six were confined to my + masturbation of her, the while she did _fellatio_, as she said + that she "had no feeling inside down there." + + With two exceptions my partings from these normal women have not + been tragic and all whom I have met in after life (seven) have + been very ready to resume relations with me, four of them having + made the proposal themselves. + + One thing has struck me, and that is the, often great, difference + that exists between what a woman's looks lead one to think she + is, and what she is when one becomes her lover; the most sensual + woman that I have met might have sat for her portrait as the + Madonna, and she was the only one who took pleasure in hearing + and relating "smoking-room stories," a form of amusement which, + perhaps from their want of appreciation of humor and wit, women + do not indulge in--at least in my experience. + + + HISTORY V.--(A continuation of History III in Appendix B to the + previous volume.) + + As I became better I commenced to dream of true love. I wondered, + too, if my horrible past really could be lived down and a young + woman come to love _me_. I took pleasure in reading love poems, + especially Browning's, and illustrated some with little + water-colors.... + + I was sitting in the stalls one night seeing a performance by a + company of English actors when one of them played so badly that I + thought to myself: "Why, hang it, I could play it better myself!" + The next minute another thought followed: "Why not try?" I came + out of the stalls the proverbial stage-struck youth. I was + sitting in the same place another night when the young man next + to me entered into conversation. By a strange coincidence he knew + a few young men, amateurs, who were going to form a company, give + up their situations and travel, if they could induce a few more + to join them and put a little money in. I made an appointment for + the following evening.... + + There were lots of meetings in bedrooms and rehearsals between + the beds, but ultimately I was told a school-room had been + engaged and a professional actress, A.F. I went to the + school-room and found all the boys there, and a young woman with + a pale, rice-powder complexion. On introduction she gazed at me + as if struck dumb. If she had been better-looking (I thought her + vulgar and puffy) I would have been flattered. I was + disappointed, but rather frightened (she had a stage presence) of + her professional ability, especially when we commenced to + rehearse. I had to make love to her, too, which embarrassed me. + She had a good profile, I noticed, and would have been better + looking, I thought, if she were in better condition, for she was + young, about my own age, twenty-three or four. We were all + young--enjoyed our rehearsals, and had lots of fun--but I did not + respond to the advances A. was evidently making to me. Finally we + started on our tour. As the weeks went on A.F., like the others, + improved wonderfully in health and appearance. If we had had + anything like houses it would have been a pleasant trip. My + strangeness did not escape the notice of the boys altogether, for + I was still a bit strange in mind and nerves--and deeply + religious, bowing my head before each meal and reading my little + Bible and prayer-book at odd times. I drank no alcohol. I spent a + good deal of time by myself of with my faithful companion A., who + was nearly always at my side, she and her appealing eyes. I was + surprised to see how quickly she had improved; she looked quite + attractive and ladylike some evenings at meals, but I only + tolerated her. I was selfish and conceited. + + Things had been going on like this for a week--always playing to + empty houses and our money lower and lower--when A. said to our + other lady, Mrs. T., on a train in my presence: "I shall have to + give him up, I suppose; he will have nothing to do with me." Mrs. + T. said: "You give him up, do you?" and looked at me as if she + were going to try her hand. A. said "Yes," and looked at me, + smiling sadly. I don't know what motive prompted me--whether my + vanity was alarmed at her threatened desertion or that she had + really made some impression on me by her love, probably a little + of both--but I said: "No, don't; come and sit down here," making + way for her, and she joyfully came and nestled against me. From + that time I ceased to treat her with ridicule, and kissed her at + other times than when on the stage. I was subject still to black + moods, and would not speak to her for hours sometimes, but she + seemed content to walk with me and was infinitely patient. I had + heard she was living with--if not married to--an actor. I asked + her about him once, and she said she did not love him; she loved + me and had never loved before. Her face had a touching sadness; + her life had been unhappy and stormy, with no love and little + rest in it. Her face, when she had lost her dissipated look and + unhealthy pallor, was exquisite, delicate as a cameo. Love had + improved her manners, too; she was more gentle and refined. I let + things drift without thinking of the future, when one night + after the performance--I was lying on the sofa and A. was sitting + at my side, as usual--I suddenly thought, with the brutality that + characterized me in these matters--"I will ask her to let me + sleep with her." I still fought against any premonitory thought + of self-abuse, but here, I thought to myself, is a chance of + something better that will do me no harm and perhaps good. When + she understood me she turned very red and walked away, shaking + her head. But I let her understand that was the only way of + retaining me, and finally, when they had all gone to bed, she + gave herself to me, reluctantly and sadly; for she, too, had been + drifting on without thinking of anything of this sort (she hated + it at this time), but just living for her love of me, her first + true love. + + Before this occurred, I must tell you, I had been so much better + that I sometimes felt capable of doing anything, a sense of power + and grasp of intellect which was combined with delicacy of + feeling and sensitiveness to beauty, to skies and clouds and + flowers. I seemed to be awakening to true manhood, to my true + self. And at meals, it is worth recording, I commenced to have a + distaste for meat. + + These glimpses of a better state of things left me on cohabiting + with A., and for a time my gloom and black religious mania came + on me once more. I now thought of my promise at confirmation, and + it seemed to me I had offended beyond pardon. When we came to the + next town, however, I openly slept with A. all night, leaving my + own bed untouched. When we returned to Adelaide one of our party + remarked: "The only man who had any success with the women on the + tour was a Bible-reading, praying, and good, pious, confirmed + Christian." + + A.'s nascent beauty and delicacy and improvement were gradually + impaired, too. My own conduct became so morose at times that, + besides increasing her misery, I offended the others, and + bickerings ensued. I heard the other actress say "He's mad; that + what's the matter." And I was so wrapped up in myself and my + religious mania that I did not mind their thinking so. + + After the tour was over A. asked me to come and see her at her + home, and as I missed her very much I went one night to tea. She + had a room in her father's house to herself. A. was dressed in + her best and we had an affectionate meeting. After tea I asked + her if she were married to E. She said "No." Then I said: "Who + are you married to?" She commenced to cry then, and told me + something of her life, the saddest I ever heard. When only 17 she + had been courted by a young man she did not care for, but who + prevailed on her parents by pretending he had seduced her, but + wished to marry her. Strange as it may seem, A. did not know what + marriage meant, her mother being one of those silly women who + don't like talking of these things and let their daughters grow + up in ignorance, expecting they will learn from some one. In nine + cases out of ten this happens, but A. was an exception. It was + this, and the fact that she had not a particle of love for her + husband, that gave her such a hatred of coition. When her mother + saw the sheets the morning after the marriage she burst out + crying; she did not like the young man and saw she had been + deceived. + + A.'s husband soon showed his true character; he was in reality a + gaol-bird. He beat her, drank, and even wanted her to go on the + streets to earn money for him. She left him and went home; it was + then she began her theatrical career by entering the ballet. At + intervals her husband, drunk and desperate, would waylay and + threaten her in the street. One day after a rehearsal he + attempted to stab her. She got on in spite of all, being a born + actress, and played small parts in traveling companies. Then E., + who had also gone on the stage, courted her and she listened to + him, not because she cared for him, but he protected her and + offered her a home. She joined him; but his drunkenness and + sensuality were so gross that he ruined his health and he + attempted to maltreat A. in a nameless way. And whenever she was + in the family way he would leave her alone and half-conscious in + the cellar for days. To add to her misery she had epileptic fits. + Then sometimes they would be out of an engagement and starving. + They had been so hungry as to steal raw potatoes out of a sack + and eat them thus, having no fire. She would often have had + engagements, but E. was jealous and would not let her act without + him. And he beat her as her husband had done, and her health + became undermined. It was just after one of the forced + miscarriages that she joined our traveling company, and that + accounted for her yellow and puffy appearance. E. was now away + up-country with a circus, but was expected down any time. A. told + me a good deal of all this, between her tears, while sitting at + my feet, and her tone carried conviction. When I ought to have + gone home I persuaded her to let me stay all night. We had been + in bed some time when her mother knocked at the door and wanted + to come in for something in a chest of drawers there. "Why don't + you open the door, A.? Who have you got there? Hasn't that fellow + gone?" A. was confused and told me to get under the bed, but I + refused, and she covered me up with the bed clothes as well as + she could and opened the door. She had hid my clothes, but missed + one of my shoes, and her mother saw it. "Oh, A.," was all she + said; "you've got that fellow in bed," and went out crying. + "Well, Fred" (my stage name), "you've got me into a nice row," A. + said. She gave me my breakfast in the morning and I walked out of + the front door without being molested. Another night I entered + her window by a ladder and stayed all night. In the middle of the + night E. came home drunk. She would not let him in and told him + she would have nothing more to do with him. He attempted to break + in the door, when A. called to me, and hearing a man in the room + he went away, saying, as he went downstairs: "Oh, A.! Oh, A.!" + as if he thought she would not have done such a thing. He never + molested us after that night. + + I think it was my intention, at first, to break off with A. + gradually. I found, however, I could not keep away from her, and + it commenced to be evident to me that a bachelor's life in + lodgings again would be dreary and lonely. And all this time the + fear that I had offended God troubled me more than I have said, + and it occurred to me (there may have been a touch of sophistry + in this, or not) that if I were a true husband to her for the + future--stuck to her and worked for her for the rest of my + days--perhaps it would find favor in God's sight and be an + atonement for my sin. Had she been free I would have married her, + I believe. But she began to be harassed by her mother and + bothered about my incessantly coming there and staying all night. + It ended in my telling her I would be a husband to her, and she + came and lived with me at my lodgings. We had one room and our + meals cost us sixpence each. Cheap as it was, it was a struggle + for me to earn money at all. I remember feeling ill and anxious + once, and sustaining myself by the thought of my father wheeling + the heavy truck up the street when he married my mother. And I + decided to wheel my truck, too. + + A. seemed happy and her love increased, if possible; at first, + though, she must have found me a trying lover, for I made her + kneel and pray with me two or three times a day, which she did + with such a queer expression of face. Sometimes her feelings got + the better of her, and she would say: "Oh, damn it, Fred, you are + always praying." And then I would be shocked and she would be + sorry.... Coitus was frequent; she commenced to like it now.... + + A. was not looking well one evening when she came in, and lay + down on the bed. Presently she commenced to make a strange noise, + and I saw her eyes were closed and her hands clenched. "Ah," said + the landlady, who came in to help me; "she has epileptic fits." + When her convulsions were over she looked blankly at us, knitting + her brows and evidently puzzling her poor brain to remember who + we were. For many years it was my fate to see her looking at me + thus, at first stony and estranged, like a dweller in another + star, then half-recalling with extended hand, then forgetting + again with hand to mouth, then the gradual dawn of memory and + love, and final full recognition. "It's Fred, my Fred!" I never + got used to it; it always moved me to tears.... It was not to be + thought that we had no quarrels. I still had fits of bad temper, + and sometimes they came into collision with A.'s temper. It hurt + my vanity considerably to see how soon she relinquished the + respectful, patient, spaniel-bearing she had when we were + traveling. I said some cruel things to her and she retorted. One + would have thought, to hear us, that all affection was over. But + when the mood of rage wore itself out we would both be sorry and + make it up with tears, and be very happy in spite of our poverty. + + I think it was lust that prevented me from striving to fulfill my + ambitions. A. let me do anything I liked, at all times of day or + night, although she seemed surprised at my proceedings sometimes, + for it was becoming a fever of lubricity with me. She still + thought only of her love. I remember her coming in one day, + tired, pale, perspiring, and worried--we had hardly anything in + the house and she had been to the theater ineffectually--and when + her eyes lighted on me the whole expression of her face changed, + softened and brightened at once, and she came and kissed me and + said: "It is so strange, I was thinking all sorts of nasty things + coming along, but as soon as I see my pet's face I feel happy--I + don't care for anything--I would sooner share a crust with him + than have all the money in the world!" + + I commenced to feel libidinous curiosity to examine her--this was + mostly on Sundays--and she let me, blushing at first, but + laughing. Then I would try new positions in coitus I had heard + of. Still she did not enter into my mood. + + She was engaged at this time to play in a pantomime and I + commenced to lead a miserable, jealous existence. I heard scandal + about her, baseless enough, but in the diseased, nervous, anxious + state I had brought myself to it nearly drove me mad. I would go + with her sometimes to visit her mother, whom I began to like. Her + brother I still saluted coldly. It caused me horror and jealousy + to see A. kissing him and letting him tickle her. In my rage, + when we came home, I even said that perhaps she would let him do + something else, naming it brutally and coarsely. I remember her + shame, astonishment, indignation and tears. If ever a man tried a + woman's love I did. But she forgave me, even that. + + We went to live in a little cottage. It was in this cottage that + A. first showed signs of lust, and in the diseased state of my + mind, instead of regretting it, I encouraged her. She told me one + day that the orgasm very often did not occur at the same time + with her as with me, and that it would not unless I put my little + finger into the anus. This her husband taught her, and she would + rather have died than confess it to me when we first met. We + would often devote our Sundays to having a picnic as we termed + our lustful bouts, stimulating ourselves with wine. Her temper + was not improved thereby (though her fits entirely stopped for a + twelvemonth)--we had wordy warfares, but we made it up again + always with tears. Nor did I allow myself to deteriorate without + reactions and excursions into better things. I was always reading + Emerson; it was he who rescued me from orthodox Christianity and + taught me to trust in myself and in Nature. I have never ceased + this struggle towards better things to this day. There, in a + nutshell, is my life; I have always been defeated when + temptation came, but I have never ceased to struggle. I + determined to be more abstemious in sexual indulgence and asked + her to help me. She agreed willingly, for she was easily led. + Whenever we fell back again into excess it was my fault. + + At a theatrical performance we first met a Miss T., a young + German who sang. She was about 25, with modest, quiet and + engaging manners. A. and she became very friendly. I liked her; + she was tall, dark and lithe, but had bad teeth. + + I had been ill and at this time A. and I had a quarrel, my temper + suddenly breaking out in murderous frenzy. I called her names and + finally put her outside the house, telling her to go to her + mother. I suffered a very hell of remorse and misery. Everything + in the quiet, lonely house reminded me of her, seemed fragrant of + her; my anguish became so keen I could not stop in the house, + though I was just as wretched walking about. I kept this up for + two days, when I met her coming to look for me. One look was + enough--"A.!" "Pet!" in broken sobs--and in tears we kissed and + made it up. Miss T. was with her, and I greeted her, too, with + happy tears in my eyes. Another time, when A. was giving way to + _her_ temper, and one would have thought all love was dead, I + said "Don't you love me then?" and the word alone was a talisman, + her face changed, she held out her arms and began to sob + quietly.... She accepted an offer to travel with a small + theatrical company who were going up-country. She was not looking + well when I left and after a time I received a telegram telling + me to come to her at once as she was ill. Dreading all sorts of + things I borrowed my fare and went to her. I knew nothing of + women, of their point of view and different code of honor, and + was very far from the attitude of Guy de Maupassant who said he + liked women all the better for their charmingly deceitful ways. + A. wanted to see me and had taken the surest means to ensure my + coming. I was angry at first, but she looked so well and was so + loving that I could not be angry long. + + One day when I was working the landlady came in and began talking + about A. and her conduct before I came. She had gone into the + actors' rooms at all hours, the woman said, and drank and been as + bad as the rest in her conversation. It was the second time a + married woman had run her down to me, and I commenced to think + there might be something in it, and suffered all my mad jealousy + over again. Not knowing the freedom actors and actresses allow + themselves on tour, without there being necessarily anything in + it, I worried till I thought I had nothing to do but die. And + then one of the great struggles of my life occurred. Walking the + country roads, I asked myself: "If it _is_ true, if she has been + unfaithful, will you forgive her and help her to arrive at her + best?" For a long time the answer was "No!" But perhaps my + striving for unity with myself had done some good, and the final + resolution was for forgiveness. I felt more peace of mind then, + and when I told a dying consumptive lodger in the house what the + landlady had said, he replied, "Don't you believe a word of it. I + know she loves you!".... + + After an absence I found myself one evening in a town where A. + was performing. I went round to the back and they told me she had + gone to a room in the hotel to change for another part. I + followed and entered the room, with a glass of spirits I found + that an effeminate young actor was bringing to her. She was half + undressed, her beautiful arms and shoulders bare. My arrival was + unexpected and she looked at me surprised, I thought coldly, as I + reproached her for not keeping a promise she had made to me to + touch no alcohol during the tour, but soon her arms were round my + neck. She cried like a child. She was bigger and handsomer and + healthier. There was not only an increased strength and size, but + an increased delicacy and sweetness; her eyes and brows were + lovely; there was an indescribable bloom and fragrance on her, + such as the sun leaves on a peach; the traveling, country air, + and freedom from coitus (had I known it) had enabled her to + arrive at her true self, not only a beautiful woman, but a woman + of fascination, of wit, vivacity and universal _camaraderie_. Her + face was like the dawn; all my fears and jealousy left me like a + cloud that melts before the sun. I remember the look on her face + as she embraced me in bed that night. It had just the very + smallest touch of sensuality, but was more like some beautiful + child's who is being caressed by one she loves; this divine, + drowsy-eyed, adorable look I had never seen on her face + before--nor have I since. + + We fell back into our old lustful ways. Later on A. became ill + and the black devil of epilepsy returned. I became gloomy.... A + restlessness and selfish brutality came over me; our love and + peace were gone. I persuaded A. to go to Melbourne and look out + for an engagement. The day before she was to sail we went to + Glenelg for a trip. The sea air, as often happened, precipitated + A.'s fits. We had gone down to the pier and A. said she felt bad. + I just managed to support her to the hotel before she became + stiff, and I made some impatient remark (for she nearly dragged + me down) which she heard, not being quite unconscious and said + half incoherently and very pitiably: "Be kind, oh, be kind!" + repeating it after consciousness left her. Her heart had been + breaking all day at the prospect of parting, and also, I expect, + because I was so ready to part with her. That moment was a crisis + in my life. I was in a murderous humor, but she looked so + unutterably wretched that it seemed impossible to be anything but + kind. I made myself speak lovingly to her, in moments of partial + consciousness, hired a room, carried her up, and nursed her and + petted her all night. The act of self-control, and forcing + myself to be kind whatever I felt, became a habit in time, a sort + of second nature. + + In a few days she sailed. When she had gone I was remorseful and + mad with myself. How could I let her go by herself? I resolved to + follow her as speedily as possible, and did so. + + If I remember rightly I came to the conclusion about this time + that we ought not to have coition unless we felt great love for + each other. It seemed to corroborate this to a certain extent + that A. always seemed more electric and pleasant to the touch + when we had connection for love and not for lust. Leave it to + Nature, I would say to myself. I began to feel how much my + struggles, efforts and temperate living had improved me. I had + more self-respect, though something of the old self-consciousness + was still left. I did not get better continuously, but in an + up-and-down zigzag. I still had moods of rage approaching madness + and periods of neurotic depression. Long walks decidedly helped + to cure me, and the sea, sun, wind, clouds and trees colored my + dreams at night very sweetly. I frequently dreamed I was walking + in orchards or forests, and a deeper, slightly melancholy but + potent savor, as of a diviner destiny, was on my soul. + + After a long absence, during which she had frequently been ill, + A. joined me. I could see she was recovering from fits, which I + began to realize that she had more frequently in absence from me, + and also from drinking, perhaps. She was small and thin, but + fresh and sweet as honey, and all signs of fits and tempers + passed away from her face, so wonderful in its changes. I had + become so healthy through my abstinence, temperance and long + walks that our meeting was a new revelation to me of how + delicate, fragrant and divine a convalescent woman may be. She + was glad and surprised to see me looking so well, and if she put + her hand on my arm I felt a joyous thrill. I was certainly a + better man for abstaining and she a better woman and I determined + not to have connection unless we were carried away by our love. + As a matter of fact we did not give way to excess, though we were + very loving. I tried to persuade myself that we had not gone back + to our old ways, but I could not do so long. + + Miss T. put in an appearance every day. She did not look so + innocent, but as it was no business of mine I did not trouble. + She seemed more attached to A. than ever.... A. was still very + loving with me, but it was an effort to me to keep up to her + pitch, and when A. proposed to go to Melbourne with Miss T, to + sell off the furniture before settling in Adelaide, I was rather + glad of the opportunity of abstaining from coitus and of watching + myself to see if I again improved. When A. and Miss T. came to + see me before going down to the steamer, A. was nearly crying and + Miss T., changed from the old welcome friend, was not only pale + and anxious, but looked guilty as if she had some treachery in + her mind; she could not meet my eye. I thought less of it then + than afterwards. And once more I took long walks at night and + rose early to catch the freshness of the mornings. + + Some time before this I had read a book advocating a vegetarian + diet, and at this time I chanced to read Pater's beautiful "Denys + L'Auxerrois," the imaginary portrait of a young vine-dresser, who + was attractive beyond ordinary mortals and lived, until his fall + and deterioration, on fruit and water. The words, "a natural + simplicity in living" remained in my memory. I resolved to read + more carefully the book on scientific diet. Who can say, I + thought, what changes for the better may come to me if I live on + a strictly scientific and natural diet? + + I fasted one whole day, and then had a breakfast of cherries, in + the middle of the day a meal of fruit, and walking in the + afternoon--a gray, rainy day--I felt so light, so different, and + the gray sky looked so sweet and familiar, that I was reminded of + the luminous visions of my boyhood. It was a distinct revelation. + This Pan-like, almost Bacchic feeling, did not last, however, nor + was I always able to maintain my new method of diet, though I + tried to do so. I made the attempt, however, but I imagine I was + more than usually run down. I would walk miles in the hope of + feeling less restless. One holiday I walked down to Glenelg, + having only had grapes for my dinner, and lying on the beach I + looked through a strong binocular glass I had borrowed at the + girls bathing. And the beauty of their faces in their frames of + hair, of their arms, of their figures, seen through their wet + clinging dresses, satisfied me and filled me with joy, gave me + for a short time that peace and content--in harmony with the + strong sunlight on the waves and the rhythmic surf on the + shore--I was seeking. The summer evenings on the pier or along + the beach had a peculiar savor; one felt the youth and beauty + there even on dark nights, the air was fragrant with them, white + dresses and summer hats disappearing down the beach or over the + sand hills. It was easy--doubtless justifiable sometimes--to put + a lewd construction on these disappearances; but I felt it need + not have been so; that it was not necessary that youth and + beauty, even the sexual act itself if led up to by love, should + be a subject of giggling and sniggering. I always left the beach + and its flitting summer dresses with a sigh. + + A., after writing once, ceased writing at all and once more her + mother and I were left in a state of anxiety and suspense. At + last I determined to go to Melbourne to look for her, the only + clue I had being a remark in her letter that a certain actor was + giving her an engagement. In Melbourne I could not find any + traces of her for some days and what traces I did find of her + were not calculated to allay my anxious fears. One hotel-keeper + told me that some one of A's name had stayed there with another + hussy (giving Miss T's stage name): "There were nice carryings on + with the pair of them." I thought of Miss T's strange looks, but + could not imagine what hold she had on A., for A. loved me, I + knew. I seemed to be in an inextricable maze. I could settle to + nothing and was thinking of applying to the police when I heard + that the actor A. had mentioned had taken his company to the + Gippsland lakes. I followed to Sale, found the actor and was told + that A. was not there. "She slipped me at the last moment," he + said, "and remained in Melbourne." I returned to my lodgings, + with my anxiety and nervous restlessness increased tenfold. But + suddenly my fear and restlessness left me like a cloud. I felt + quiet, young, peaceful, able to enjoy the country, A. was + doubtless all right and would be able to explain her silence. I + undressed leisurely and happily, thinking of the stars. + + The next day, Sunday, I awoke refreshed and still at peace. After + breakfast, hearing children's voices, I went out into the garden + and there was a collision of souls who somehow were affinities. A + young girl about twelve or younger with a fine presence and + handsome face fixed her eyes on me for half a minute and then + came and sat on my knee. She was one of those children I am + accustomed to call "love-children," because they are so much + brighter, healthier, larger and more loving than others. I always + imagine more love went to their making. We fell in love and she + said, stroking my beard, "Oh, you are pretty!" and I said, "And + so are you!" We were so affectionate that the servant called the + child away and I went for a walk, finding my little sweetheart + waiting for me on my return. The touch of her hand was electric + and her voice fresh and musical. I kissed her, but had become + more self-conscious since the morning and wondered if her mother + or the servant were looking, or even of they would appear. I was + not so frank and natural as my little chum. I have often thought + of her since. She had the breadth of forehead, the strength and + yet lightness of limb, together with the hands and feet, not too + small, that I always imagine the dwellers in Paradise will have. + + I returned to Melbourne and continued trying to find A. At the + same time I commenced in earnest to live on fruit and brown bread + only, and enjoyed better tone and health every day, so that it + was a joy to walk down the street in the sun and exchange glances + with passengers a la old Walt. One day in the Botanical Gardens + veils seemed to be lifted off my eyes. I could look straight at + the sun and taking my note of color from that golden light I + turned my eyes on the flowers, the mown grass, the trees, and for + the first time perceived what a heavenly color green is, what + divine companions flowers are, and what a blue sky really means. + For half an hour I was in Paradise, and to complete my joy Nature + revealed to me a new and unexpected secret. + + I was lying on a bench, basking, and my silk shirt coming open + the strong sun made its way to my breast and presently I felt a + totally new sensation there. I had discovered the last joy of the + skin. My skin, fed by healthy fruit-made blood, must have + functioned normally under the excitation of the sun just then + (for a brief space only, alas!). I cannot describe the joy, any + more than I could describe the taste of a peach to one who has + only eaten apples: it was satisfying, divine. I opened my shirt + wider, but the feeling only spread faintly, and indeed this + halcyon sunny hour terminated in a restlessness that sent me + walking into town to look for A. + + At last I heard, not of A., but of Miss T. She was in a ballet. I + went round during rehearsal and while waiting entered into + conversation with a little chorus girl with a good face, who was + sewing. On my telling her whom I was seeking she stopped sewing + and looked at me quickly: "Oh, are you her husband? I know her. + _I have seen them together_." She looked as if she were going to + tell me something, but merely shook her old-fashioned head in a + mournful, indescribable way, saying "Why don't you keep your wife + with you?" I went to the door and presently saw Miss T. She tried + to avoid me, I thought, and looked more vicious than ever, but + after a minute's thought reluctantly told me where she and A. + were staying. To hide my fears and suspicions I had assumed a + careless demeanor, but I think I should have strangled her had + she refused to tell me. I hastily went to the place indicated and + going up the stairs (to the astonishment of the people) opened + the door and found myself face to face with A.--but how changed! + She had the hard, harlot, loveless look I detested. I felt for a + few minutes that I did not love her, and she regarded me coldly + too, but presently old habits reinstated themselves. She put out + her hands, very pitiably, and then was sobbing in my arms. I + could get nothing out of her but sobs, and to this day do not + know where she spent all these weeks nor why she did not write. + Miss T. came in after rehearsal, pale and hard-faced. I greeted + her politely, but was watching her, trying to puzzle out why A. + did not look as she usually did after long absence from coition. + Miss T. took another room in the same house and was soon joined + by another ballet girl, young and very pretty, who soon began to + have fits. A. was always crying until Miss T. went away with her + pretty friend. I knew nothing, could hardly be said to suspect + anything definite, and yet I pitied that pretty girl whose eyes + looked so helpless and appealing. + + I set to work again. But I continued to live on fruit and bread, + and taking off my clothes I would stand up at the window in the + sun. A lot of prostitutes, however, who lived at the back saw me + and were scandalized or shocked or thought me mad. The landlady + heard of it and spoke to A. So I had to desist from my glorious + sun-baths. + + We slept on a single bed, and though I did my best to avoid + coitus (I wanted to wait and think out some theory of it), A., + who knew nothing of this, wanted to resume our old habits, and + finally I surrendered. But my sufferings next day were intense, + and I had the sense of having fallen from some high estate. My + thoughts were divided between two theories: one that our misery + was caused by our diet, more or less; the other that we had + fallen into some error as regards coitus, and this was becoming + almost a certainty with me. + + There is one incident I think worthy of note which happened + before the "fall" just mentioned and when I was living on fruit + and in splendid health. At a performance I saw a girl on the + stage with handsome legs in tights, and once as she straightened + her leg the knee-cap going into position gave me such a strange + and keen joy--of that quality I call divine or musical--that I + was like one suddenly awakened to the divinity and beauty of the + female form. The joy was so keen and yet peaceful, familiar, and + subjective that I could not help comparing it to a happy chemical + change in the tissues of my own brain. Like the unexpected + functioning of my skin in the sun it was a sign of a partial + return to a normal condition, another glimpse of Paradise. + + I stuck to my new diet and gained a fresh elation and joy in + life. Gradually clothes became insupportable, and I went down to + the beach as often as possible to take them off, and at nights, + beside the patient and astonished A., I would lie naked. One + evening, passing some grass, I looked over the fence like a gipsy + and felt a longing to take off my clothes and sleep in the grass + all night. It was of course impossible. And A. looked unhappily + in my face; she began to think her mother, who now thought I was + mad, must be right. + + That night I woke up and found myself having coition. I was angry + and felt I had been put back in my progress, but a fever of lust + now came over me. I would sit under the tap and let the cold + water run over me to conquer the fever, but at the end of a week + my hopes were frustrated and I even turned against my natural + diet, on which I had made flesh. A., as I expected, went through + her usual fits, and slowly recovered. (If we had connection only + once she in about three weeks had a mild attack of fits; if we + had coition more than once the fits were more severe.) I relapsed + more than once and as a means of impressing my resolution for + future abstinence I would walk for miles in the middle of + pitch-black nights.... + + Miss T. came over to Adelaide and as I knew nothing definite + against her and heard that she was engaged, I thought perhaps my + suspicions were unfounded and was friendly. But one day in town I + saw her and A. on a tram going out to our cottage. Even then my + suspicions might not have been awakened, but I saw Miss T. say + something rapidly to A., and A. called out to me, "Will you be + coming home soon?" And I answered "No." When the tram had gone on + I found myself vaguely wondering what Miss T. wanted to know that + for, for my perceptions were becoming acute enough to understand + women's ways. In another minute I was walking rapidly home. When + I came to the door it was locked. I knocked and knocked and no + one came. I called out and threatened to kick in the door. Still + no one came. Mad with rage I commenced to put my threat into + execution, when the door was opened by Miss T., half-naked, in + her petticoats, and pale as death, but no longer defiant. "So + I've caught you, have I?" I _looked_, but could not trust myself + to speak. Wondering why A. did not appear I went into the + bedroom. She was lying on the bed, just as Miss T. had left her, + on the verge of a fit, and on seeing me she held out her hands + piteously, and when I stooped over her she whispered, "Send her + away, send her away." Then she became unconscious and going into + the next room I ordered Miss T. (who had managed to scramble on + her dress) out of the house. I spoke scornfully as if addressing + a dog, and she slinked out with a malignant but cowed look I hope + never to see on a woman's face again. What they had been doing + with their clothes off I do not know; women will rather die than + confess. When A. had recovered from her fit she denied that there + had been anything between them, and stuck to it doggedly, but + with such a forlorn look I had not the heart to prosecute my + inquiries. + + For my part, all the efforts I had been making for so long seemed + for a time to be in vain; for some weeks I sank into a sort of + satyriasis, and even my anger against Miss T. turned to a + prurient curiosity. At the same time I was not always able to + adhere to my diet. But both as regards coition and diet I was + still fighting, and on the whole successfully. My fits of temper, + however, were excessive and my ennui became gloomy despair. One + day I blasphemed on crossing the Park and spoke contemptuously of + "God and his twopenny ha'penny revolving balls," referring to the + planetary system. But for long walks I should have gone mad. A. + was drinking in the intervals of her fits. I found half-empty + bottles of wine hidden away. This did not improve my temper, and + one day--this was when she was well and up--I struck her a heavy + blow on the face, and she aimed a glass decanter at me. She went + home to her mother and I lived alone in the cottage. I heard soon + afterwards that her husband had come back and that they had made + it up. Our parting was not, however, destined to be final. + + Even out of that month's sufferings I made capital. I was better + after my tendency to lubricity, my gloom, rage, restlessness and + degradation. They had been but the irritations of convalescence. + + + +INDEX OF AUTHORS. + +Abrantes, duchesse d' +Adler +Albucasis +Alexander, H.C.B. +Amatus Lusitanus +Ammon +Andersen +Andriezen +Aquinas +Aristophanes +Aristotle +Averroes +Avicenna +Aubrey +Aulnoy, Madame d' + +Baer +Ball +Ballantyne, J.W. +Bancroft, H.H. +Barker, Fordyce +Barnes, R. +Bartholin +Bayle +Beale, G.B. +Bechterew +Beck, J.R. +Becker +Bell, Sir C. +Bell, Sanford +Belletrud +Beneden +Bergh +Bianchi +Bierent +Binet +Bischoff, T.L.W. +Bloch, J. +Blondel +Blumenbach +Blunt, J.J. +Boas +Boccaccio +Boeteau +Bois, J. +Bois-Reymond, E. du +Boelsche +Booth, D.S. +Booth, J. +Bouchereau +Bouchet +Bourke, J.G. +Boveri +Brand +Braun +Brantome +Brehm +Breitenstein +Brenier de Montmorand +Brenot +Brouardel +Brown-Sequard +Bruegelmann +Buckman, S.S. +Bucknill +Bunge +Burchard +Burdach +Burton, Robert +Buschan +Busdraghi + +Cabanis +Campbell, J.F. +Campbell, H. +Carpenter, E. +Casanova +Cascella +Castelnau +Catullus +Cecca +Celsus +Chapman, C.W. +Charcot +Chaucer +Chaulant +Chevalier +Chidley, W. +Cladel, J. +Clement, of Alexandria +Coe +Coen +Collineau +Colman, W.S. +Columbus, R. +Cook, G.W. +Crawley +Cumston +Cuvier +Cyples + +Dabney +Darwin, C. +Darwin, E. +Daumas +Dearborn, G. +Dembo +Deniker +Dessoir, Max +Dickinson, R.L. +Diderot +Disselhorst +Donaldson, H.H. +Douglas, C. +Draehms +Duehren, E. +Dufougere +Dufour +Dulaure +Duncan, Matthews + +East, A. +Edgar, Clifton +Ellis, Havelock +Engelmann +Erotion +Esbach +Eschricht +Espinas +Eulenburg +Evans +Ezekiel + +Fabricius +Fallopius +Fere +Fichstedt +Flood, E. +Florence +Fothergill, Milner +Frazer, J.G. +Freud +Freyer +Froriep +Fuchs +Fuerbringer + +Galen +Gardiner, C.F. +Garnier +Gautier, A. +Gautier, T. +Gellhoen +Gerhard, A. +Giles, A. +Godin +Goethe +Goncourt, E. de +Gopcevic +Goron +Gould +Gow +Graaf, de +Griffiths +Groos, K. +Gualino +Gueniot +Guibaut +Guillereau +Guinard +Guttceit + +Hack +Haddon +Haig +Hall, G. Stanley +Haller +Hamilton, A. +Hammond +Hardy, Thomas +Hartland, E.S. +Harvey +Hegar +Henderson, J. +Henle +Hennig +Herman +Herodotus +Herrick +Heusinger +Hewitt, Graily +Hippocrates +Hirst +Hislop, J.T. +Hoche +Horrocks +Howard, W.L. +Howell +Howitt, A.W. +Hrdlicka +Hughes, C.H. +Hunter, John +Hunter, William +Huysmans +Hyades +Hyrtl + +Jacobi +Jacoby, P. +Jahn +Janet +Janke +Jastreboff +Jenkyns, J. +Johnston, G.A. +Johnston, Sir H.H. +Jonson, Ben +Juvenal + +Kaltenbach +Kelly, H. +Kepler +Kiernan, J.G. +Kisch +Kleinpaul +Kobelt +Kocher +Kohlbrugge +Kolbein +Krafft-Ebing +Krauss + +Lamb, D.S. +Landes, L. de +Lane +Lasegue +Laurent, E. +Lawrence, Sir W. +Laycock +Levi +Licetus +Liebault +Lietaud +Lipps +Litzmann +Lombroso +Lorion +Lortet +Lucas, J.C. +Lucretius +Lunier +Luschka +Lusini +Lydston + +Macdonald, A. +MacGillicuddy +McKay, A. +Mackay, W.J.S. +Mackenzie, J. +Magnan +Malebranche +Mantegazza +Marandon de Montyel +Marc +Marro +Marshall, H.R. +Martial +Martin, J.M.H. +Martineau +Maschka +Masterman +Matignon +Mattel +McMordie +Mercier +Meredith, Ellis +Middleton, T. +Mirabeau +Mitchell, Sir A. +Moll +Mongeri +Morache +Moraglia +Morris, R.T. +Morselli +Motet +Moulin, J. Mansell +Mueller, J. +Munde, P. + +Naecke +Neale, R. +Neri +Nicholson, H.O. +Nina Rodrigues + +Obici +Onanoff +Ottolenghi +Ovid + +Pacheco +Palfyn +Park, Mungo +Papillault +Pasini +Paterson, A.R. +Paulini +Paulus AEginetus +Pearse, W.H. +Pearson, Karl +Pechuel-Loesche +Pelanda +Pennant +Penta +Pfaff +Pierer +Pillon +Pinaeus +Pinard +Pitre, C. +Pitres +Pittard +Plant +Plautus +Pliny +Ploss +Poehl +Polemon +Pollux +Porta, Della +Power +Pyle + +Raymond +Regis +Regnier, H. de +Reinach, S. +Renooz, Celine +Restif de la Bretonne +Retterer, E. +Reynolds, A.R. +Rhys, J. +Ribot +Riedel +Rimbaud +Riolan +Robinson, Bryan +Robinson, Louis +Rodin +Roederer +Roons, R.P. +Rosse, Irving +Roth, W. +Rothe +Roubaud +Rousseau +Routh, C.H.F. +Rufus +Russell, W. + +Sade, de +Salmon, W. +Scherzer +Schinz +Schmiedeberg +Schreiner +Schrenck-Notzing +Schurig +Scott, Colin +Scripture, E.W. +Seerley +Seligmann +Sellheim +Shakespeare +Shattock +Shufeldt +Silk, J.F.W. +Simon, H. +Simpson, Sir J. +Sims, Marion +Smith, Sir A. +Smith, Haywood +Soemmering +Soranus +Spigelius +Stahl, F.A. +Stanton +Stendhal +Stengel +Stern, B. +Stevens, Vaughan +Stieda +Stratz +Stubbs +Suidas +Sukhanoff +Sullivan, W.C. +Sutherland, W.D. +Sutton, Bland +Swift + +Tarde +Tardieu +Tarnier +Taxil +Theocritus +Thoinot +Thompson, W.L. +Thomson, J. +Tilt +Toff +Tourdes, G. +Tridandani +Trochon + +Vahness +Valentin +Varigny, H de +Variot, G. +Varro +Vaschide +Vatsyayana +Venette +Venturi +Vesalius +Vinay +Vinci, L. da +Voigt +Voisin, J. +Vurpas + +Wagner, R. +Waldeyer +Walker, G. +Wallace, A.W. +Warton +Wasserschleben +Weininger, O. +Wellhausen +Werner +Wernich +West, J.P. +Wharton +Wilhelm, Eugen +Wilkin, G. +Wilkinson, A.D. +Williams, J.W. Whitridge +Williamson, C.F. +Wolff, B. +Wollstonecraft, Mary +Wordsworth +Wychgel + +Youatt + +Zaborsky +Zoppi +Zimmer +Zola + + + + +INDEX OF SUBJECTS. + +Abyssinians, + coitus among +Acquired element in erotic symbolism +Acromegaly and sexual development +Alcohol, + aphrodisiac effects of +Algolagnia, + in relation to scatologic symbolism + as a form of erotic symbolism +Anaesthesia, + sexual +Anaesthetics in relation to sexual excitement +Anaphrodisiacs +Animal copulation, + attraction of +Animals, + detumescence in +Annamites, + coitus among +Antipathies of pregnant women +Anus in relation to pubic hair + as an erogenous zone +Apes, + sexual organs of + sexual congress in +Aphrodisiacs +Apples, + longings of women for +Arabs, + penis in +Artist, + compared to lover +Associations of contiguity and resemblance in erotic symbolism +Australian method of sexual congress +Auto-suggestions, + longings of pregnancy as + +Bartholin, + glands of +Beard in relation to sexual development +Beauty, + the objective element in +Bestiality +Bladder in relation to sexual excitement +Blood during pregnancy +Blood-pressure during detumescence +Breasts, + and erotic temperament + during pregnancy +Bromide as an anaphrodisiac +Bulbo-cavernous reflex + +Camphor as an anaphrodisiac +Cantharides, + effects of +Castration, + results of +Celery as an aphrodisiac +Children, + attracted to foot + to scatology + to copulation of animals + to hair + food impulses of +Chinese, + foot-fetichism of +Circulatory conditions during coitus + during pregnancy +Clitoris +Clothes, + erotic fascination of +Coitus, + the phenomena of + the methods of + ethnic variations in methods of + respiratory and circulatory conditions during + interruptus as a cause of vasomotor disturbance + glandular activity during + motor activity during + psychic state during + serious effects of +Congenital element in erotic symbolism +Contiguity in erotic symbolism, + associations of +Coprolagnia +Coprophagia, + religious and sexual +Courtship +Crystallization, + Stendhal's + +Defile, + the impulse to +Distillatio +Dog, + human sexual intercourse with +Dynamometric experiments during sexual excitement + +Ejaculation, the mechanism of +Embryo +Epilepsy and exhibitionism + compared to coitus + as a result of coitus +Erectility during coitus +Erogenous zone, + anus as + lips as +Erotic intoxication +Erotic temperament +Eryngo as an aphrodisiac +Ethnic variations in coitus +Etruscans, + sexual significance of foot among +Eunuchs, + characteristics of +Exercise on sexual organs, + influence of +Exhibitionism +Eyes during detumescence + in relation to erotic temperament + darker at puberty + +Face during detumescence, + expression of +Faeces as a drug +Fecundation, + the phenomena of + artificial +Feet as a sexual symbol, + uncovering +Fellatio +Fetichism, + erotic +Flagellation +Foot-fetichism, + _see_ Shoe-fetichism. +Fuegians, + penis in +Fur as a fetich + +Garments as fetiches +Genital organs as fetiches +Goat as a human sexual fetich +Greeks, + sexual significance of foot among + +Hair as a fetich + despoilers of + pubic + darkens at puberty + in relation to erotic temperament + in pregnancy +Hand as fetich +Heart during pregnancy +Homosexuality as a form of erotic symbolism +Hottentot apron +Hymen +Hyperaesthesia, sexual +Hypertrichosis universalis +Hysteria + +Ideal coprolagnia +Idiocy as result of maternal impressions +Idiots, + sexual development of +Impregnation without rupture of hymen + without conjunctions + artificial +Impressions, + maternal +Intellectual work, + relation of pregnancy to +Intoxication, + erotic + +Japanese, + labia majora in +Joy, + the expression of + +Kiss, the +Kleptomania and pregnancy +Knee-jerk in pregnancy + +Labia majora +Labia minora +Larynx in relation to sexual state +Linea fusca +Lips, + as an erogenous zone + in relation to erotic temperament +Longings of pregnancy + theories of + as auto-suggestions + physiological basis of + relation to the longings of childhood + +Masochism, + in relation to shoe-fetichism + in relation to scatalogic symbolism + in relation to exhibitionism of nates + as a form of erotic symbolism +Masturbation and pubic hair + hypertrophy of clitoris ascribed to + part played by clitoris in + why some theologians permitted + phenomena during +Maternal element in sexual love +Maternal impressions +Menstruation in relation to coitus + metabolism during + in relation to sickness of pregnancy + compared to pregnancy +Mental state during pregnancy +Metabolism during pregnancy +Mixoscopic zoophilia +Modesty a supposed sign of virginity +Mohammedan method of sexual congress +Mole as a fetich +Mongol peoples, + foot fetichism among various +Mons veneris +Mordvins, + foot-fetichism among +Motor activity during coitus +Mouth in relation to erotic temperament +Muscular movements during coitus + +Nates in relation to coprolagnia + in relation to exhibitionism + in relation to erotic temperament +Necrophilia +Negative fetich +Negro, + penis in + labia majora in + clitoris in + labia minora in + method of sexual congress among +Nervous system during pregnancy +Neurasthenia cordis vasomotoria +Nipples, + pigmentation of +Nudity, + religious +Nutrition, + symbolism of +Nymphae +Nymphomania + +Obsessions of scruple + longings of pregnancy as +Obsessional exhibitionism +Odor an alleged sign of defloration +Onion as an aphrodisiac +Opium as an aphrodisiac +Organs, + sexual +Ova and spermatozoa, + union of +Ovarian extract, effects of +Ovaries, + function of + analogy of with thyroid + +Paidophilia +Pain and erotic symbolism +Pedicatio +Pelvic development and erotic temperament +Pelvic floor, variability of +Pelvic inclination +Penis +Penis-fetichism +Phallic worship +Physiognomists and the erotic temperament +Pica +Pigmentation in relation to erotic temperament + in pregnancy +Potatoes, + the supposed aphrodisiac effects of +Precocity, + influence of +Pregnancy and pigmentation + psychic state in + sexual desire during + relation of to intellectual work +Presbyophilia +Prostate +Prostitutes, + external genitals of + stature of +Psychic exhibitionism +Psychic condition during coitus +Puberty, + the phenomena of + pigmentary changes at +Pubic hair +Puericulture +Pygmalionism + +Quadrupedal method of coitus in man + +Rachitic, + sexual tendencies of the +Reflex, bulbo-cavernous +Reflexes during pregnancy +Religious scatalogic symbolism +Resemblance in erotic symbolism, + associations of +Respiration during coitus +Responsibility of pregnant women +Restif de la Bretonne's shoe-fetichism +Romans, + sexual significance of foot among + methods of coitus among +Rousseau +Rue as an anaphrodisiac + +Sadism +Saint compared to lover +Salivation during coitus +Satyriasis +Scatalogic symbolism +Scrotum +Scruple, obsessions of +Secretions of genital canal +Semen, + alleged female + in coitus + in female genital canal + vital activity of + artificial injection of + constituents of + as a stimulant +Sexual anaesthesia +Sexual conjugation +Sexual desire during pregnancy +Sexual organs +Sexual selection in relation to erotic symbolism + in relation to external sexual organs + the probable cause of the hymen +Shadow as a fetich +Shoe, + sexual significance of +Shoe-fetichism frequency of + normal basis of + illustrated by Restif de la Bretonne + prevalence of among Chinese, etc. + former prevalence in Europe + congenital basis of + acquired element in + favored by precocity + relation to masochism + illustrative cases of + dynamic element in +Sickness of pregnancy +Skin, + sexual significance of + condition of during coitus + in relation to erotic temperament + sexual pigmentation of +Slipper as a sexual symbol +Smile, + origin of the +Sodomy, + the term +Spain, + sexual attractiveness of foot in +Spermatozoa reach ova, + how the +Spermin +Sphygmanometer experiments during sexual excitement +Stature and erotic temperament +Stimulants +Stuff-fetichisms +Strychnine, + aphrodisiac effects of +Suggestion in relation to longings of pregnancy +Symbols, + nature of + of sex in language + +Temperament, + alleged erotic +Testicular juices, + effects of +Testes +Thyroid, + condition during sexual excitement + during pregnancy +Ticklishness in relation to stuff-fetichisms +Tumescence in relation to detumescence + +Unnatural offence, + the term +Urethra, + variability of female + an erogenous zone +Urethrorrhoea ex libidine +Urinary stream, + in relation to nymphae + an alleged index to virginity +Urine in religious rites + possesses magical virtues + in legends + in medicine + during coitus +Urolagnia +Uterus + +Vagina +Vaginismus +Vasomotor conditions during coitus +Vaudonism +Virginity, + ancient diagnosis of +Virile reflex +Voice, + in relation to erotic temperament + in relation to virginity +Vomiting of pregnancy +Vulva +Vulva-fetichism + +Waist, + origin of admiration for small + +Yohimbin as an aphrodisiac + +Zooerastia +Zoophilia erotica +Zoophilia non-erotic + + + +***END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK STUDIES IN THE PSYCHOLOGY OF SEX, +VOLUME 5 (OF 6)*** + + +******* This file should be named 13614.txt or 13614.zip ******* + + +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: +https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/1/3/6/1/13614 + + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +https://gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS', WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, is critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at https://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/pglaf. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at https://www.gutenberg.org/about/contact + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit https://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/donate + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including including checks, online payments and credit card +donations. To donate, please visit: +https://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + https://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. + diff --git a/old/13614.zip b/old/13614.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..63a9cad --- /dev/null +++ b/old/13614.zip |
