diff options
| author | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 04:45:46 -0700 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 04:45:46 -0700 |
| commit | decd13f51fe9933858e0679ca79257dd3b0896d2 (patch) | |
| tree | b221568bf9f2b0f61da4fa7260ff2c65da9087ee | |
| -rw-r--r-- | .gitattributes | 3 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 14980-8.txt | 10991 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 14980-8.zip | bin | 0 -> 213323 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | 14980-h.zip | bin | 0 -> 230378 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | 14980-h/14980-h.htm | 11956 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 14980.txt | 10991 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 14980.zip | bin | 0 -> 213263 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | LICENSE.txt | 11 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | README.md | 2 |
9 files changed, 33954 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/.gitattributes b/.gitattributes new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6833f05 --- /dev/null +++ b/.gitattributes @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +* text=auto +*.txt text +*.md text diff --git a/14980-8.txt b/14980-8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..877ebe8 --- /dev/null +++ b/14980-8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,10991 @@ +The Project Gutenberg EBook of Outwitting Our Nerves +by Josephine A. Jackson and Helen M. Salisbury + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: Outwitting Our Nerves + A Primer of Psychotherapy + +Author: Josephine A. Jackson and Helen M. Salisbury + +Release Date: February 8, 2005 [EBook #14980] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK OUTWITTING OUR NERVES *** + + + + +Produced by Rick Niles, Ronald Holder and the PG Online Distributed +Proofreading Team. + + + + + + + +OUTWITTING OUR +NERVES + +A PRIMER OF PSYCHOTHERAPY + +BY + +JOSEPHINE A. JACKSON, M.D. +HELEN M. SALISBURY + +[Illustration] + +NEW YORK +THE CENTURY CO. +1922 + +1921, by +THE CENTURY CO. + +PRINTED IN U.S.A. + + + + +TO + +MARY PATTERSON MANLY + +A LOVER OF TRUTH + + + + +FOREWORD + + +"Your trouble is nervous. There is nothing we can cut out and there is +nothing we can give medicine for." With these words a young college +student was dismissed from one of our great diagnostic clinics. + +The physician was right. In a nervous disorder there is nothing to cut +out and there is nothing to give medicine for. Nevertheless there is +something to be done,--something which is as definite and scientific +as a prescription or a surgical operation. + +Psychotherapy, which is treatment by the mental measures of +psycho-analysis and re-education, is an established procedure in the +scientific world to-day. Nervous disorders are now curable, as has +been proved by the clinical results in scores of cases from civil +life, under treatment by Freud, Janet, Prince, Sidis, DuBois, and +others; and in thousands of cases of war neuroses as reported by Smith +and Pear, Eder, MacCurdy, and other military observers. These army +experts have shown that shell-shock in war is the same as nervousness +in civil life and that both may be cured by psycho-analysis and +re-education. + +For more than a decade, in handling nervous cases, I have made use of +the findings of recognized authorities on psychopathology. Truths have +been applied in a special way, with the features of re-education so +emphasized that my home has been called a psychological +boarding-school. As the alumni have gone back to the game of life +with no haunting memories of usual sanatorium methods, but with the +equipment of a fuller self-knowledge and sense of power, they have +sent back a call for some word that shall extend this helpful message +to a larger circle. + +There has come, too, a demand for a book which shall give accurate and +up-to-date information to those physicians who are eager for light on +the subject of nervous disorders, and especially for knowledge of the +significant contributions of Sigmund Freud, but who are too busy to +devote time to highly technical volumes outside their own specialties. + +This need for a simple, comprehensive presentation of the Freudian +principles I have attempted to meet in this primer of psychotherapy, +providing enough of biological and psychological background to make +them intelligible, and enough application and illustration to make +them useful to the general practitioner or the average layman. + +JOSEPHINE A. JACKSON. + +Pasadena, California, 1921. + + + + +CONTENTS + +PART I: THE STRANGE WAYS OF NERVES + +CHAPTER I + PAGE + +In which most of us plead guilty to the charge of "nerves." + +NERVOUS FOLK 3 + +CHAPTER II + +In which we learn what "nerves" are not and get a hint of +what they are. + +THE DRAMA OF NERVES 10 + + +PART II: "HOW THE WHEELS GO ROUND" + +CHAPTER III + +In which we find a goodly inheritance. + +THE STORY OF THE INSTINCTS 33 + +CHAPTER IV + +In which we learn more about ourselves. + +THE STORY OF THE INSTINCTS (Continued) 51 + +CHAPTER V + +In which we look below the surface and discover a veritable +wonderland. + +THE SUBCONSCIOUS MIND 77 + +CHAPTER VI + +In which we learn why it pays to be cheerful. + +BODY AND MIND 118 + +CHAPTER VII + +In which we go to the root of the matter. + +THE REAL TROUBLE 141 + + +PART III: THE MASTERY OF "NERVES" + +CHAPTER VIII + +In which we pick up the clue. + +THE WAY OUT 183 + +CHAPTER IX + +In which we discover new stores of energy and relearn the +truth about fatigue. + +THAT TIRED FEELING 219 + +CHAPTER X + +In which the ban is lifted. + +DIETARY TABOOS 250 + +CHAPTER XI + +In which we learn an old trick. + +THE BUGABOO OF CONSTIPATION 278 + +CHAPTER XII + +In which handicaps are dropped. + +A WOMAN'S ILLS 300 + +CHAPTER XIII + +In which we lose our dread of night. + +THAT INTERESTING INSOMNIA 322 + +CHAPTER XIV + +In which we raise our thresholds. + +FEELING OUR FEELINGS 333 + +CHAPTER XV + +In which we learn discrimination. + +CHOOSING OUR EMOTIONS 359 + +CHAPTER XVI + +In which we find new use for our steam. + +FINDING VENT IN SUBLIMATION 379 + +GLOSSARY 386 + +BIBLIOGRAPHY 390 + +INDEX 393 + + + + +OUTWITTING OUR NERVES + + + + +CHAPTER I + +_In Which Most of Us Plead Guilty to the Charge of "Nerves."_ + +NERVOUS FOLK + +WHO'S WHO + + +Whenever the subject of "nerves" is mentioned most people begin trying +to prove an alibi. The man who is nervous and knows that he is +nervous, realizes that he needs help, but the man who has as yet felt +no lack of stability in himself is quite likely to be impatient with +that whole class of people who are liable to nervous breakdown. It is +therefore well to remind ourselves at once that the line between the +so-called "normal" and the nervous is an exceedingly fine one. +"Nervous invalids and well people are indistinguishable both in theory +and in practice,"[1] and "after all we are most of us more or less +neurasthenic."[2] The fact is that everybody is a possible neurotic. + +[Footnote 1: Putnam: _Human Motives_, p. 117.] + +[Footnote 2: DuBois: _Physic Treatment of Nervous Disorders_, p. 172.] + +So, as we think about nervous folk and begin to recognize our friends +and relatives in this class, it may be that some of us will +unexpectedly find ourselves looking in the mirror. Some of our +lifelong habits may turn out to be nervous tricks. At any rate, it +behooves us to be careful about throwing stones, for most of us live +in houses that are at least part glass. + + +THE EARMARKS + +=Am I "Like Folks"?= Before we begin to talk about the real sufferer +from "nerves," the nervous invalid, let us look for some of the +earmarks that are often found on the supposedly well person. All of +these signs are deviations from the normal and are sure indications of +nervousness. The test question for each individual is this: "Am I +'like folks'?" To be normal and to be well is to be "like folks." Can +the average man stand this or that? If he can, then you are not normal +if you cannot. Do the people around you eat the thing that upsets you? +If they do, ten chances to one your trouble is not a physical +idiosyncrasy, but a nervous habit. In bodily matters, at least, it is +a good thing to be one of the crowd. + +Many people who would resent being called anything but normal--in +general--are not at all loth to be thought "different," when it comes +to particulars. Are there not many of us who are at small pains to +hide the fact that we "didn't sleep a wink last night," or that we +"can't stand" a ticking clock or a crowing rooster? We sometimes +consider it a mark of distinction to have a delicate appetite and to +have to choose our food with care. If we are frank with ourselves, +some of us will have to admit that our own ailments seem interesting, +while the other person's ills are "merely nervous" or imaginary or +abnormal. After all, a good many of us will have to plead guilty to +the charge of nervousness. + +We have only to read the endless advertisements of cathartics and +"internal baths," or to check up the quantity of laxatives sold at any +drug store, to realize the wide-spread bondage to that great bugaboo +constipation. He who is constipated can hardly prove an alibi to +"nerves." Then there are the school-teachers and others who are worn +out at the end of each year's work, hardly able to hold on until +vacation; and the people who can't manage their tempers; and those who +are upset over trifles; and those who are dissatisfied with life. To a +certain degree, at least, all of these are nervous persons. The list +grows. + +=Half-Power Engines.= These people are all supposed to be well. They +keep going--by fits and starts--and as they are used to running on +three cylinders, with frequent stops for repairs, they accept this +rate of living as a matter of course, never realizing that they might +be sixty horse-power engines, instead of their little thirty or forty. +For this large and neglected class of people psychotherapy has a +stimulating message, and for them many of the following pages have +been written. + +=The Real Sufferers.= These so-called normal people are merely on the +fringe of nervousness, on the border line between normality and +disease. Beyond them there exists a great company of those whose lives +have been literally wrecked by "nerves." Their work interrupted or +given up for good, their minds harassed by doubts and fears, their +bodies incapacitated, they crowd the sanatoria and the health resorts +in a vain search for health. From New England to Florida they seek, +and on to Colorado and California, and perhaps to Hawaii and the +Orient, thinking by rest and change to pull themselves together and +become whole again. There are thousands of these people--lawyers, +preachers, teachers, mothers, social workers, business and +professional folk of all sorts, the kind of persons the world needs +most--laid off for months or years of treatment, on account of some +kind of nervous disorder. + +=Various Types of Nervousness.= The psychoneuroses are of many +forms.[3] To some people "nerves" means nervous prostration, +breakdown, fatigue, weakness, insomnia, the blues, upset stomach, or +unsteady heart,--all signs of so-called neurasthenia or +nerve-weakness. To others the word "nerves" calls up memories of +strange, emotional storms that seem to rise out of nowhere, to sweep +the sky clear of everything else, and to pass as they came, leaving +the victim and the family equally mystified as to their meaning. These +strange alterations of personality are but one manifestation of +hysteria, that myriad-faced disorder which is able to mimic so +successfully the symptoms of almost every known disease, from tumors +and fevers to paralysis and blindness. + +[Footnote 3: The technical term for nervousness is +_psycho-neurosis_--disease of the psyche. There are certain "real +neuroses" such as paralysis and spinal-cord disease, which involve an +organic impairment of nerve-tissue. However, as this book deals only +with psychic disturbance, we shall, throughout, use the term +_neuroses_ and _psycho-neuroses_ indiscriminately, to denote nervous +or functional disorders.] + +To still other people nervous trouble means fear,--just terrible fear +without object or meaning or reason (anxiety neuroses); or a definite +fear of some harmless object (phobia); or a strange, persistent, +recurrent idea, quite foreign to the personality and beyond the reach +of reason (obsession); or an insistent desire to perform some absurd +act (compulsion); or perhaps, a deadly and pall-like depression (the +blues). + +As a matter of fact, the neuroses include all these varieties, and +various shades and combinations of each. There are, however, certain +mental characteristics which recur with surprising regularity in most +of the various phases--dissatisfaction, lack of confidence, a sense of +being alone and shut in to oneself, doubt, anxiety, fear, worry, +self-depreciation, lack of interest in outside affairs, pessimism, +fixed belief in one's powerlessness, along whatever line it may be. + +Underneath all these differing forms of nervousness are the same +mechanisms and the same kind of difficulty. To understand one is to +understand all, and to understand normal people as well; for in the +last analysis we are one and all built on the same lines and governed +by the same laws. The only difference is, that, as Jung says, "the +nervous person falls ill of the conflicts with which the well person +battles successfully." + + +SUMMARY + +Since at least seventy-five per cent. of all the people who apply to +physicians for help are nervous patients; and since these thousands of +patients are not among the mental incompetents, but are as a rule +among the highly organized, conscientious folk who have most to +contribute to the leadership of the world, it is obviously of vital +importance to society that its citizens should be taught how to solve +their inner conflicts and keep well. In this strategic period of +reconstruction, the world that is being remodeled cannot afford to +lose one leader because of an unnecessary breakdown. + +There is greater need than ever for people who can keep at their tasks +without long enforced rests; people who can think deeply and +continuously without brain-fag; people who can concentrate all their +powers on the work in hand without wasting time or energy on +unnecessary aches and pains; people whose bodies are kept up to the +top notch of vitality by well-digested food, well-slept sleep, +well-forgotten fatigue, and well-used reserve energy. That such a +state of affairs is no Utopian dream, but is merely a matter of +knowing how, will appear more clearly in later chapters. + + + + +CHAPTER II + +_In which we learn what "nerves" are not, and get a hint of what they +are_ + +THE DRAMA OF NERVES + +AN EXPLODED THEORY + + +="Nerves" not Nerves.= Pick up any newspaper, turn over a few pages, +and you will be sure to come to an advertisement something like this: + + Tired man, your nerves are sick! + They need rest and a tonic to restore + their worn-out depleted cells! + +No wonder people have believed this kind of thing. It has been dinned +into their ears for many years. They have read it with their breakfast +coffee and gazed at it in the street cars and even heard it from their +family physicians, until it has become part and parcel of their +thinking; yet all the time the fundamental idea has been false, and +now, at last, the theory is exploded. + +So far as the modern laboratory can discover, the nerves of the most +confirmed neurotic are perfectly healthy. They are not starved, nor +depleted, nor exhausted; the fat-sheath is not wanting, there is no +inflammation, there is nothing lacking in the cell itself, and there +is no accumulation of fatigue products. Paradoxical as it may sound, +there is nothing the matter with a nervous person's nerves. The +faithful messengers have borne the blame for so long that their name +has gotten itself woven into the very language as symbolic of disease. +When we speak of nervous prostration, neurasthenia, neuroses, +nervousness, and "nerves" we mean that body and mind are behaving +badly because of functional disorder. These terms are good enough as +figures of speech, so long as we are not fooled by them; but accepting +them in their literal sense has been a costly procedure. + +Thanks to the investigations of physiologist and psychologist, usually +combined in the person of a physician, "nervousness" has been found to +be not an organic disease but a functional one. This is a very +important distinction, for an organic disease implies impairment of +the tissues of the organ, while a functional disorder means only a +disturbance of its action. In a purely nervous disorder there seems to +be no trouble with what the nerves and organs are, but only with what +they do; it is behavior and not tissue that is at fault. Of course, in +real life, things are seldom as clear-cut as they are in books, and +so it happens that often there is a combination of organic and +functional disease that is puzzling even to a skilled diagnostician. +The first essential is a diagnosis as to whether it be an organic +disease, with accompanying nervous symptoms, or a functional +disturbance complicated by some minor organic trouble. If the main +cause is organic, only physical means can cure it, but if the trouble +is functional, no amount of medicine or surgery, diet or rest, will +touch it; yet the symptoms are so similar and the dividing line is so +elusive, that great skill is sometimes required to determine whether a +given symptom points to a disturbance of physical tissue or only to +behavior. + +If the physician is sometimes fooled, how much more the sufferer +himself! Nausea from a healthy stomach is just as sickening as nausea +from a diseased one. A fainting-spell is equally uncomfortable, +whether it come from an impaired heart or simply from one that is +behaving badly for the moment. It must be remembered that in +functional nervousness the trouble is very real. The organs are really +"acting up." Sometimes it is the brain that misbehaves instead of the +stomach or heart. In that case it often reports all kinds of pains +that have no origin outside of the brain. Pain, of course, is +perceived only by the brain. Cut the telegraph wire, the nerve, and no +amount of injury to the finger can cause pain. It is equally true that +a misbehaving brain can report sensations that have no external +cause, that have not come in through the regular channel along the +nerve. The pain feels just the same, is every bit as uncomfortable as +though its cause were external. + +Sometimes, instead of reporting false pains, the brain misbehaves in +other ways. It seems to lose its power to decide, to concentrate, or +to remember. Then the patient is almost sure to fancy himself going +insane. But insanity is a physical disease, implying changes or toxins +in the brain cells. Functional disorders tell another story. Their +cause is different, even though the picture they present is often a +close copy of an organic disease. + +=Distorted Pictures.= It should not be thought, however, that the +symptoms of functional and organic troubles are identical. Hysteria +and neurasthenia closely simulate every imaginable physical disease, +but they do not exactly parallel any one of them. It may take a +skilled eye to discover the differences, but differences there are. +Functional troubles usually show a near-picture of organic disease, +with just enough contradictory or inconsistent features to furnish a +clue as to their real nature. For this reason it is important that the +treatment of the disease be solely the province of the physician; for +only the carefully trained in all the requirements of diagnosis can +differentiate the pseudo from the real, the innocuous from the +disastrous. + +False or nervous neuritis may feel like real neuritis (the result of +poisons in the blood), but it gives itself away when it localizes +itself in parts of the body where there is no nerve trunk. The +exhaustion of neurasthenia sometimes seems extreme enough to be the +result of a dangerous physical condition; but when this exhaustion +disappears as if by magic under the proper kind of treatment, we know +that the trouble cannot be in the body. Let it be said, then, with all +the emphasis we can command, "nerves" are not physical. Laboratory +investigation, contradictory symptoms, and response to treatment all +bear witness to this fact. Whatever symptoms of disturbance there may +be in pure nervousness, the nerves and organs can in no way be shown +to be diseased. + + +THE POSITIVE SIDE + +="Nerves" not Imaginary.= "But," some one says, "how can healthy +organs misbehave in this way? Something must be wrong. There must be +some cause. If 'nerves' are not physical, what are they? They surely +can't be imaginary." Most emphatically, they are real; nothing could +be more maddening than to have some one suggest that our troubles are +"mere imagination." No wonder such theories have been more popular +with the patient's family than with the patient himself. Many years +ago a physician put the whole truth into a few words: "The patient +says, 'I cannot'; his friends say, 'He will not'; the doctor says, 'He +cannot will.'" He tries, but in the circumstances he really cannot. + +=The Man behind the Body.= The trouble is real; the organs do "act +up"; the nerves do carry the wrong messages. But the nerves are merely +telegraph wires. They are not responsible for the messages that are +given them to carry. Behind the wires is the operator, the man higher +up, and upon him the responsibility falls. In functional troubles the +body is working in a perfectly normal way, considering the perverted +conditions. It is doing its work well, doing just what it is told, +obeying its master. The troubles are not with the bodily machine but +with the master. The man behind the body is in trouble and he really +has no way of showing his pain except through his body. The trouble in +nervous disorders is in the personality, the soul, the realm of ideas, +and that is not your body, but _you_. Loss of appetite may mean either +that the powers of the physical organism are busily engaged in +combating some poison circulating in the blood, or that the ego is "up +against" conditions for which it has "no stomach." Paralysis may be +due to a hemorrhage into the brain tissues from a diseased blood +vessel, or it may symbolize a sense of inadequacy and defeat. +Exaggerated exhaustion, halting feet, stammering tongue, may give +evidence of a disturbed ego rather than of a diseased brain. + +=All Body and no Mind.= At last we have begun to realize what we ought +to have known all along,--that the body is not the whole man. The +medical world for a long time has been in danger of forgetting or +ignoring psychic suffering, while it has devoted itself to the +treatment of physical disease. + +By way of condoning this fault it must be recognized that the five +years of medical school have been all too short to learn what is +needed of physiology and anatomy, histology, bacteriology, and the +various other physical sciences. But at last the medical schools are +realizing that they have been sending their graduates out only +half-prepared--conversant with only one half of a patient, leaving +them to fend for themselves in discovering the ways of the other half. +Many an M.D. has gone a long way in this exploration. Native common +sense, intuition, and careful study have enabled him to go beyond what +he had learned in his text-books. But in the best universities the +present-day student of medicine is now being given an insight into the +ways of man as a whole--mind as well as body. The movement can hardly +proceed too rapidly, and when it has had time to reach its goal, the +day of the long-term sentence to nervousness will be past. + +In the meanwhile most physicians, lacking such knowledge and with the +eye fixed largely on the body, have been pumping out the stomach, +prescribing lengthy rest-cures, trying massage, diet, electricity, and +surgical operations, in a vain attempt to cure a disease of the +personality. Physical measures have been given a good trial, but few +would contend that they have succeeded. Sometimes the patient has +recovered--in time--but often, apparently, despite the treatment +rather than because of it. Sometimes, in the hands of a man like Dr. +S. Weir Mitchell, results seem good, until we realize that the same +measures are ineffective when tried by other men, and that, after all, +what has counted most has been the personality of the physician rather +than his physical treatment. + +No wonder that most doctors have disliked nervous cases. To a man +trained in all the exactness of the physical sciences, the apparent +lawlessness and irresponsibility of the psychic side of the +personality is especially repugnant. He is impatient of what he fails +to comprehend. + +=All Mind and no Body.= This unsympathetic attitude, often only half +conscious on the part of the regular practitioners, has led many +thousands of people to follow will-o'-the-wisp cults, which pay no +attention to the findings of science, but which emphasize a +realization of man's spiritual nature. Many of these cults, founded +largely on untruth or half-falsehood, have succeeded in cases where +careful science has failed. Despite fearful blunders and execrable +lack of discrimination in attempting to cure all the ills that flesh +is heir to by methods that apply only to functional troubles, ignorant +enthusiasts and quacks have sometimes cured nervous troubles where the +conscientious medical man has had to acknowledge defeat. + +=The Whole Man.= But thinking people are not willing to desert science +for cults that ignore the existence of these physical bodies. If they +have found it unsatisfactory to be treated as if they were all body, +they have also been unwilling to be treated as if they were all mind. +They have been in a dilemma between two half-truths, even if they have +not realized the dilemma. It has remained for modern psychotherapy to +strike the balance--to treat the whole man. Solidly planted on the +rock of the physical sciences, with its laboratories, physiological +and psychological, and with a long record of investigation and +treatment of pathological cases, it resembles the mind cure of earlier +days or the assertions of Christian Science about as much as modern +medicine resembles the old bloodletting, leeching practices of our +forefathers. + +For the last quarter-century there have been scattered groups of +physicians,--brilliant, patient pioneers,--who, recognizing man as +spirit inhabiting body, have explored the realm of man's mind and +charted its paths. These pioneers, beginning with Charcot, have been +men of acknowledged scientific training and spirit, whose word must be +respected and whose success in treating functional troubles stands out +in sharp contrast to the fumblings of the average practitioner in this +field. The results of their work have been positive, not negative. +They have not merely asserted that nervous disorders are not physical; +they have discovered what the trouble is and have found it to be +discoverable and removable in almost every case, provided only that +the right method is used. + +=Ourselves and Our Bodies.= If the statement that "nervous troubles +are neither physical nor imaginary but a disease of the personality," +sounds rather mystifying to the average person, it is only because the +average person is not very conversant with his own inner life. We +shall hope, later on, to find some definite guide-posts and landmarks +which will help us feel more at home in this fascinating realm. At +present, we are not attempting anything more than a suggestion of the +itinerary which we shall follow. A book on physical hygiene can +presuppose at least a rudimentary knowledge of heart and lungs and +circulation, but a book on mental hygiene must begin at the beginning, +and even before the beginning must clear away misconceptions and make +clear certain fundamental principles. But the gist of the whole matter +is this: in a neurosis, certain forces of the personality--instincts +and their accompanying emotions--which ought to work harmoniously, +having become tangled up with some erroneous ideas, have lost their +power of coöperation and are working at cross purposes, leaving the +individual mis-adapted to his environment, the prey of all sorts of +mental and physical disturbances. + +The fact that the cause is mental while the result is often physical, +should cause no surprise. In the physiological realm we are used to +the idea that cause and effect are often widely separated. A headache +may be caused by faulty eyes, or it may result from trouble in the +intestines. In the same way, we should not be too much surprised if +the cause of nervous troubles is found to be even more remote, +provided there is some connecting link between cause and effect. The +difficulty in this case is the apparent gulf between the realm of the +spirit and the realm of the body. It is hard to see how an intangible +thing like a thought can produce a pain in the arm or nausea in the +stomach. Philosophers are still arguing concerning the nature of the +relation between mind and body, but no one denies that the closest +relation does exist. Every year science is learning that ideas count +and that they count physically, as well as spiritually. + +=Such Stuff as "Nerves" are Made Of.= Dr. Tom A. Williams in the +little composite volume "Psychotherapeutics" says that the neuroses +are based not on inherently weak nervous constitutions but on +ignorance and on false ideas. What, then, are some of these erroneous +ideas, these misconceptions, that cause so much trouble? We shall want +to examine them more carefully in later chapters, but we might glance +now at a few examples of these popular bugaboos that need to be slain +by the sword of cold, hard fact. + +=Popular Misconceptions about the Body.= + +1 "Eight hours' sleep is essential to health. All insomnia is +dangerous and is incompatible with health. Nervous insomnia leads to +shattered nerves and ultimately to insanity." + +2 "Overwork leads to nervous breakdown. Fatigue accumulates from day +to day and necessitates a long rest for recuperation." + +3 "A carefully planned diet is essential to health, especially for the +nervous person. A variety of food, eaten at the same time, is harmful. +Acid and milk--for example, oranges and milk--are difficult to digest. +Sour stomach is a sign of indigestion." + +4 "Modern life is so strenuous that our nerves cannot stand the +strain." + +5 "Brain work is very fatiguing. It causes brain-fag and exhaustion." + +6 "Constipation is at the root of most physical ailments and is +caused by eating the wrong kind of food." + +Some of these misconceptions are household words and are so all but +universally believed that the thought that they can be challenged is +enough to bewilder one. However, it is ideas like this that furnish +the material out of which many a nervous trouble is made. Based on a +half-knowledge of the human body, on logical conclusions from faulty +premises, on hastily swallowed notions passed on from one person to +another, they tend by the very power of an idea to work themselves out +to fulfilment. + + +THE POWER BEHIND IDEAS + +=Ideas Count.= Ideas are not the lifeless things they may appear. They +are not merely intellectual property that can be locked up and ignored +at will, nor are they playthings that can be taken up or discarded +according to the caprice of the moment. Ideas work themselves into the +very fiber of our being. They are part of us and they _do_ things. If +they are true, in line with things as they are, they do things that +are for our good, but if they are false, we often discover that they +have an altogether unsuspected power for harm and are capable of +astonishing results, results which have no apparent relation to the +ideas responsible for them and which are, therefore, laid to physical +causes. Thinking straight, then, becomes a hygienic as well as a +moral duty. + +=Ideas and Emotions.= Ideas do not depend upon themselves for their +driving-power. Life is not a cold intellectual process; it is a vivid +experience, vibrant with feeling and emotion. It therefore happens +that the experiences of life tend to bring ideas and emotions together +and when an idea and an emotion get linked up together, they tend to +stay together, especially if the emotion be intense or the experience +is often repeated. + +The word emotion means outgoing motion, discharging force. This force +is like live steam. An emotion is the driving part of an instinct. It +is the dynamic force, the electric current which supplies the power +for every thought and every action of a human life. + +Man is not a passive creature. The words that describe him are not +passive words. Indeed, it is almost impossible to think about man at +all except in terms of desire, impulse, purpose, action, energy. There +are three things that may be done with energy: First, it may be +frittered away, allowed to leak, to escape. Secondly, it may be locked +up; this results usually in an explosion, a finding of destructive +outlets. Finally, it may be harnessed, controlled, used in beneficent +ways. Health and happiness depend upon which one of the three courses +is taken. + + +CHARACTER AND HEALTH + +Evidently, it is highly important to have a working knowledge of these +emotions and instincts; important to know enough about them and their +purpose to handle them rightly if they do not spontaneously work +together for our best character and health. The problems of character +and the problems of health so overlap that it is impossible to write a +book about nervous disorders which does not at the same time deal with +the principles of character-formation. The laws and mechanisms which +govern the everyday life of the normal person are the same laws and +mechanisms which make the nervous person ill. As Boris Sidis puts it, +"The pathological is the normal out of place." The person who is +master of himself, working together as a harmonious whole, is stronger +in every way than the person whose forces are divided. Given a little +self-knowledge, the nervous invalid often becomes one of the most +successful members of society,--to use the word successful in the best +sense. + +=It Pays to Know.= To be educated is to have the right idea and the +right emotion in the right place. To be sure, some people have so well +learned the secret of poise that they do not have to study the why nor +the how. Intuition often far outruns knowledge. It would be foolish +indeed to suggest that only the person versed in psychological lore is +skilled in the art of living. Psychology is not life; it can make no +claim to furnish the motive nor the power for successful living, for +it is not faith, nor hope, nor love; but it tries to point the way and +to help us fulfil conditions. There is no more reason why the average +man should be unaware of the instincts or the subconscious mind, than +that he should be ignorant of germs or of the need of fresh air. + +If it be argued that character and health are both inherently +by-products of self-forgetful service, rather than of painstaking +thought, we answer that this is true, but that there can be no +self-forgetting when things have gone too far wrong. At such times it +pays to look in, if we can do it intelligently, in order that we may +the sooner get our eyes off ourselves and look out. The pursuit of +self-knowledge is not a pleasurable pastime but simply a valuable +means to an end. + + +KNOWING OUR MACHINE + +=Counting on Ourselves.= Knowing our machine makes us better able to +handle it. For, after all, each of us is, in many ways, very like a +piece of marvelous and complicated machinery. For one thing, our +minds, as well as our bodies, are subject to uniform laws upon which +we can depend. We are not creatures of chaos; under certain conditions +we can count on ourselves. Freedom does not mean freedom from the +reign of law. It means that, to a certain extent, we can make use of +the laws. Psychic laws are as susceptible to investigation, +verification, and use as are any laws in the physical world. Each +person is so much the center of his own life that it is very easy for +him to fall into the way of thinking that he is different from all the +rest of the world. It is a healthful experience for him to realize +that every person he meets is made on the same principles, impelled by +the same forces, and fighting much the same fight. Since the laws of +the mental world are uniform, we can count on them as aids toward +understanding other people and understanding ourselves. + +="Intelligent Scrutiny versus Morbid Introspection."= It helps +wonderfully to be able to look at ourselves in an objective, +impersonal way. We are likely to be overcome by emotion, or swept by +vague longings which seem to have no meaning and which, just because +they are bound up so closely with our own ego, are not looked at but +are merely felt. Unknown forces are within us, pulling us this way and +that, until sometimes we who should be masters are helpless slaves. +One great help toward mastery and one long step toward serenity is a +working-knowledge of the causes and an impersonal interest in the +phenomena going on within. Introspection is a morbid, emotional +fixation on self, until it takes on this quality of objectivity. What +Cabot calls the "sin of impersonality" is a grievous sin when +directed toward another person, but most of us could stand a good deal +of ingrowing impersonality without any harm. + +The fact that the human machine can run itself without a hitch in the +majority of cases is witness to its inherent tendency toward health. +People were living and living well through all the centuries before +the science of psychology was formulated. But not with all people do +things run so smoothly. There were demoniacs in Bible times and +neurotics in the Middle Ages, as there are nervous invalids and +half-well people to-day. Psychology has a real contribution to make, +and in recent years its lessons have been put into language which the +average man can understand. + +Psychology is not merely interested in abstract terms with long names. +It is no longer absorbed merely in states of consciousness taken +separately and analyzed abstractly. The newer functional psychology is +increasingly interested in the study of real persons, their purposes +and interests, what they feel and value, and how they may learn to +realize their highest aspirations. It is about ordinary people, as +they think and act, in the kitchen, on the street cars, at the +bargain-counter, people in crowds and alone, mothers and their babies, +little children at play, young girls with their lovers, and all the +rest of human life. It is the science of _you_, and as such it can +hardly help being interesting. + +While psychology deals with such topics as the subconscious mind, the +instincts, the laws of habit, and association of ideas and suggestion, +it is after all not so much an academic as a practical question. These +forces govern the thought you are thinking at this moment, the way you +will feel a half-hour from now, the mood you will be in to-morrow, the +friends you will make and the profession you will choose, besides +having a large share in the health or ill-health of your body in the +meantime. + + +SUMMARY + +Perhaps it would be well before going farther to summarize what we +have been saying. Here in a nutshell is the kernel of the subject: + +Disease may be caused by physical or by psychic forces. A "nervous" +disorder is not a physical but a psychic disease. It is caused not by +lack of energy but by misdirected energy; not by overwork or +nerve-depletion, but by misconception, emotional conflict, repressed +instincts, and buried memories. Seventy-five per cent. of all cases of +ill-health are due to psychic causes, to disjointed thinking rather +than to a disjointed spine. Wherefore, let us learn to think right. + +In outline form, the trouble in a neurosis may be stated something +like this: + +Lack of adaptation to the social environment--caused by + Lack of harmony within the personality--caused by + Misdirected energy--caused by + Inappropriate emotions--caused by + Wrong ideas or ignorance. + +Working backward, the cure naturally would be: + +Right ideas--resulting in + Appropriate emotions--resulting in + Redirected energy--resulting in + Harmony--resulting in + Readjustment to the environment. + +If the reader is beginning to feel somewhat bewildered by these +general statements, let him take heart. So far we have tried merely to +suggest the outline of the whole problem, but we shall in the future +be more specific. Nervous troubles, which seem so simple, are really +involved with the whole mechanism of mental life and can in no way be +understood except as these mechanisms are understood. We have hinted +at some of the causes of "nerves," but we cannot give a real +explanation until we explain the forces behind them. These forces may +at first seem a bit abstract, or a bit remote from the main theme, but +each is essential to the story of nerves and to the understanding of +the more practical chapters in Part III. + +As in a Bernard Shaw play, the preface may be the most important part +of this "drama of nerves." Nor is the figure too far-fetched, +because, strange as it may seem, every neurosis is in essence a drama. +It has its conflict, its villain, and its victim, its love-story, its +practical joke, its climax, and its denouement. Sometimes the play +goes on forever with no solution, but sometimes psychotherapy steps in +as the fairy god-mother, to release the victim, outwit the villain, +and bring about the live-happily-ever-after ending. + + + + +PART II: "HOW THE WHEELS GO ROUND" + + + + +CHAPTER III + +_In which we find a goodly inheritance_ + +THE STORY OF THE INSTINCTS + +EACH IN HIS OWN TONGUE + + A fire mist and a planet, + A crystal and a cell, + A jelly-fish and a saurian, + And caves where cavemen dwell; + Then a sense of law and beauty, + And a face turned from the clod; + Some call it evolution + And others call it God.[4] + + +If we begin at the beginning, we have to go back a long way to get our +start, for the roots of our family tree reach back over millions of +years. "In the beginning--God." These first words of the book of +Genesis must be, in spirit at least, the first words of any discussion +of life. We know now, however, that when God made man, He did not +complete His masterpiece at one sitting, but instead devised a plan by +which the onward urge within and the environment without should act +and interact until from countless adaptations a human being was made. + +[Footnote 4: William Herbert Carruth.] + +As the late Dr. Putnam of Harvard University says, "We stand as the +representative of a Creative Energy that expressed itself first in far +simpler forms of life and finally in the form of human instincts."[5] +And again: "The choices and decisions of the organisms whose lives +prepared the way through eons of time for ours, present themselves to +us as instincts."[6] + +[Footnote 5: Putnam: _Human Motives_, p. 32.] + +[Footnote 6: Putnam: _Human Motives_, p. 18.] + + +INTRODUCING THE INSTINCTS + +=Back of Our Dispositions.= What is it that makes the baby jump at a +noise? What energizes a man when you tell him he is a liar? What makes +a young girl blush when you look at her, or a youth begin to take +pains with his necktie? What makes men go to war or build tunnels or +found hospitals or make love or save for a home? What makes a woman +slave for her children, or give her life for them if need be? +"Instinct" you say, and rightly. Back of every one of these well-known +human tendencies is a specific instinct or group of instincts. The +story of the life of man and the story of the mind of man must begin +with the instincts. Indeed, any intelligent approach to human life, +whether it be that of the mother, the teacher, the preacher, the +social worker or the neurologist, leads back inevitably to the +instincts as the starting-point of understanding. But what is +instinct? + +We are apt to be a bit hazy on that point, as we are on any +fundamental thing with which we intimately live. We reckon on these +instinctive tendencies every hour of the day, but as we are not used +to labeling them, it may help in the very beginning of our discussion +to have a list before our eyes. Here, then, is a list of the +fundamental tendencies of the human race and the emotions which drive +them to fulfilment. + +THE SPECIFIC INSTINCTS AND THEIR EMOTIONS (AFTER MCDOUGALL) + +_Instinct_ _Emotion_ + +Nutritive Instinct Hunger +Flight Fear +Repulsion Disgust +Curiosity Wonder +Self-assertion Positive Self-feeling (Elation) +Self-abasement Negative Self-feeling (Subjection) +Gregariousness Emotion unnamed +Acquisition Love of Possession +Construction Emotion unnamed +Pugnacity Anger +Reproductive Instinct Emotion unnamed +Parental Instinct Tender Emotion + +These are the fundamental tendencies or dispositions with which every +human being is endowed as he comes into the world. Differing in degree +in different individuals, they unite in varying proportions to form +various kinds of dispositions, but are in greater or less degree the +common property of us all. + +There flows through the life of every creature a steady stream of +energy. Scientists have not been able to decide on a descriptive term +for this all-important life-force. It has been variously called +"libido," "vital impulse" or "élan vital," "the spirit of life," +"hormé," and "creative energy." The chief business of this life-force +seems to be the preservation and development of the individual and the +preservation and development of the race. In the service of these two +needs have grown up these habit-reactions which we call instincts. The +first ten of our list belong under the heading of self-preservation +and the last two under that of race-preservation. As hunger is the +most urgent representative of the self-preservative group, and as +reproduction and parental care make up the race-preservative group, +some scientists refer all impulses to the two great instincts of +nutrition and sex, using these words in the widest sense. However, it +will be useful for our purpose to follow McDougall's classification +and to examine individually the various tendencies of the two groups. + +=In Debt to Our Ancestors.= An instinct is the result of the +experience of the race, laid in brain and nerve-cells ready for use. +It is a gift from our ancestors, an inheritance from the education of +the age-long line of beings who have gone before. In the struggle for +existence, it has been necessary for the members of the race to feed +themselves, to run away from danger, to fight, to herd together, to +reproduce themselves, to care for their young, and to do various other +things which make for the well-being or preservation of the race. The +individuals that did these things at the right time survived and +passed on to their offspring an inherited tendency to this kind of +reaction. McDougall defines an instinct as "an inherited or innate +psycho-physical disposition which determines its possessor to perceive +or pay attention to objects of a certain class, to experience an +emotional excitement of a particular quality upon perceiving such an +object, and to act in regard to it in a particular manner, or at least +to experience an impulse to such action." This is just what an +instinct is,--an inherited disposition to notice, to feel, and to want +to act in certain ways in certain situations. It is the something +which makes us act when we cannot explain why, the something that goes +deeper than reason, and that links us to all other human +beings,--those who live to-day and those who have gone before. + +It is true that East is East and West is West, but the two do meet in +the common foundation of our human nature. The likeness between men +and between races is far greater and far more fundamental than the +differences can ever be. + +=Firing Up the Engine.= Purpose is writ large across the face of an +instinct, and that purpose is always toward action. Whenever a +situation arises which demands instantaneous action, the instinct is +the means of securing it. Planted within the creature is a tendency +which makes it perceive and feel and act in the appropriate way. It +will be noticed that there are three distinct parts to the process, +corresponding to intellect, emotion, will. The initial intellectual +part makes us sensitive to certain situations, makes us recognize an +object as meaningful and significant, and waves the flag for the +emotion; the emotion fires up the engine, pulls the levers all over +the body that release its energy and get it ready for action, and +pushes the button that calls into the mind an intense, almost +irresistible desire or impulse to act. Once aroused, the emotion and +the impulse are not to be changed. In man or beast, in savage or +savant, the intense feeling, the marked bodily changes, and the +yearning for action are identical and unchangeable. The brakes can be +put on and the action suppressed, but in that case the end of the +whole process is defeated. Could anything be plainer than that an +instinct and its emotion were never intended to be aroused except in +situations in which their characteristic action is to be desired? An +emotion is the hot part of an instinct and exists solely for securing +action. If all signs of the emotion are to be suppressed, all +expression denied, why the emotion? + +But although the emotion and the impulse, once aroused, are beyond +control, there is yet one part of the instinct that is meant to be +controlled. The initial or receptive portion, that which notices a +situation, recognizes it as significant, and sends in the signal for +action, can be trained to discrimination. This is where reason comes +in. If the situation calls for flight, fear is in order; if it calls +for fight, anger is in order; if it calls for examination, wonder is +in order; but if it calls for none of these things, reason should show +some discrimination and refuse to call up the emotion. + +=The Right of Way.= There is a law that comes to the aid of reason in +this dilemma and that is the "law of the common path."[7] By this is +meant that man is capable of but one intense emotion at a time. No one +can imagine himself strenuously making love while he is shaken by an +agony of fear, or ravenously eating while he is in a passion of rage. +The stronger emotion gets the right of way, obtains control of mental +and bodily machinery, and leaves no room for opposite states. If the +two emotions are not antagonistic, they may blend together to form a +compound emotion, but if in the nature of the case such a blending is +impossible, the weaker is for the time being forgotten in the +intensity of the stronger. "The expulsive power of a new affection" is +not merely a happy phrase; it is a fact in every day life. The +problem, then, resolves itself into ways of making the desirable +emotion the stronger, of learning how to form the habit of giving it +the head start and the right of way. In our chapter on "Choosing the +Emotions," we shall find that much depends on building up the right +kind of sentiments, or the permanent organization of instincts around +ideas. However, we must first look more closely at the separate +instincts to acquaint ourselves with the purpose and the ways of each, +and to discover the nature of the forces with which we have to deal. + +[Footnote 7: Sherrington: _Integrative Action of the Nervous System_.] + + +I THE SELF-PRESERVATIVE INSTINCTS + +=Hunger.= Hunger is the most pressing desire of the egoistic or +self-preserving impulse. The yearning for food and the impulse to seek +and eat it are aroused organically within the body and are behind much +of the activity of every type of life. As the impulse is so familiar, +and its promptings are so little subject to psychic control, it seems +unnecessary to do more than mention its importance. + +=Flight and Fear.= All through the ages the race has been subject to +injury. Species has been pitted against species, individual against +individual. He who could fight hardest or run fastest has survived and +passed his abilities on to his offspring. Not all could be strongest +for fight, and many species have owed their existence to their ability +to run and to know when to run. Thus it is that one of the strongest +and most universal tendencies is the instinct for flight, and its +emotion, fear. "Fear is the representation of injury and is born of +the innumerable injuries which have been inflicted in the course of +evolution."[8] Some babies are frightened if they are held too +loosely, even though they have never known a fall. Some persons have +an instinctive fear of cats, a left-over from the time when the race +needed to flee from the tiger and others of the cat family. Almost +every one, no matter in what state of culture, fears the unknown +because the race before him has had to be afraid of that which was not +familiar. + +[Footnote 8: Crile: _Origin and Nature of the Emotions_.] + +The emotion of fear is well known, but its purpose is not so often +recognized. An emotion brings about internal changes, visceral changes +they are called, which enable the organism to act on the emotion,--to +accomplish its object. There is only so much energy available at a +given moment, stored up in the brain cells, ready for use. In such an +emergency as flight every ounce of energy is needed. The large muscles +used in running must have a great supply of extra energy. The heart +and lungs must be speeded up in order to provide oxygen and take care +of extra waste products. The special senses of sight and hearing must +be sensitized. Digestion and intestinal peristalsis must be stopped in +order to save energy. No person could by conscious thought accomplish +all these things. How, then, are they brought about? + +=Internal Laboratories.= In the wonderful internal laboratory of the +body there are little glands whose business it is to secrete chemicals +for just these emergencies. When an object is sighted which arouses +fear, the brain cells flash instantaneous messages over the body, +among others to the supra-renal glands or adrenals, just over the +kidneys, and to the thyroid gland in the neck. Instantly these glands +pour forth adrenalin and thyroid secretion into the blood, and the +body responds. Blood pressure rises; brain cells speed up; the liver +pours forth glycogen, its ready-to-burn fuel; sweat-glands send forth +cold perspiration in order to regulate temperature; blood is pumped +out from stomach and intestines to the external muscles. As we have +seen, the body as a whole can respond to just one stimulus at a time. +The response to this stimulus has the right of way. The whole body is +integrated, set for this one thing. When fear holds the switchboard no +other messages are allowed on the line, and the creature is ready for +flight. + +But after flight comes concealment with the opposite bodily need, the +need for absolute silence. This is why we sometimes get the opposite +result. The heart seems to stop beating, the breath ceases, the limbs +refuse to move, all because our ancestors needed to hide after they +had run, and because we are in a very real way a part of them. + +=Old-Fashioned Fear.= There is one passage from Dr. Crile's book which +so admirably sums up these points that it seems worth while to insert +it at length. + + We fear not in our hearts alone, not in our brains alone, not in + our viscera alone--fear influences every organ and tissue. Each + organ or tissue is stimulated or inhibited according to its use + or hindrance in the physical struggle for existence. By thus + concentrating all or most of the nerve force on the + nerve-muscular mechanism for defense, a greater physical power is + developed. Hence it is that under the stimulus of fear animals + are able to perform preternatural feats of strength. For the same + reason, the exhaustion following fear will be increased as the + powerful stimulus of fear drains the cup of nervous energy even + though no visible action may result.... Perhaps the most striking + difference between man and animals lies in the greater control + which man has gained over his primitive instinctive reactions. As + compared with the entire duration of organic evolution, man came + down from his arboreal abode and assumed his new rôle of + increased domination over the physical world but a moment ago. + And now, though sitting at his desk in command of the complicated + machinery of civilization, when he fears a business catastrophe + his fear is manifested in the terms of his ancestral physical + battle in the struggle for existence. He cannot fear + intellectually, he cannot fear dispassionately, he fears with all + his organs, and the same + organs are stimulated and inhibited as if, instead of its being a + battle of credit, or position, or of honor, it were a physical + battle with teeth and claws.... Nature has but one means of + response to fear, and whatever its cause the phenomena are always + the same--always physical.[9] + +[Footnote 9: Crile: _Origin and Nature of the Emotions_, p. 60 ff.] + + * * * * * + +The moral is as plain as day: Learn to call up fear only when speedy +legs are needed, not a cool head or a comfortable digestion. Fear is a +costly proceeding, an emergency measure like a fire-alarm, to be used +only when the occasion is urgent enough to demand it. How often it is +misused and how large a part it plays in nervous symptoms, both mental +and physical, will appear more clearly in later chapters. + +=Repulsion and Disgust.= Akin to the instinct of flight is that of +repulsion, which impels us, instead of fleeing, to thrust the object +away. It leads us to reject from the mouth noxious and disgusting +objects and to shrink from slimy, creepy creatures, and has of course +been highly useful in protecting the race from poisons and snakes. It +still operates in the tendency to put away from us those things, +mental or physical, toward which we feel aversion or disgust. Recent +psychological discoveries have revealed how largely a neurosis +consists in putting away from us--out of consciousness,--whatever we +do not wish to recognize, and so it happens that disgust plays an +unexpected part in nervous disorders. + +=Curiosity and Wonder.= Fortunately for the race, it has not had to +wait until different features of the environment prove to be helpful +or harmful. There is an instinct which urges forward to exploration +and discovery and which enables the creature not only to adapt itself +to the environment but to learn how to adapt the environment to +itself. This is the instinct of curiosity. It is the impulse back of +all advance in science, religion, and intellectual achievement of +every kind, and is sometimes called "intellectual feeling." + +=Self-Assertion.= It goes almost without saying that one of the +strongest and most important impulses of mankind is the instinct of +self-assertion; it often gets us into trouble, but it is also behind +every effort toward developed character. At its lowest level +self-assertion manifests itself in the strutting of the peacock, the +prancing of the horse, and the "See how big I am," of the small boy. +At its highest level, when combined with self-consciousness and the +moral sentiments acquired from society and developed into the +self-regarding sentiment, it is responsible for most of our ideas of +right, our conception of what is and what is not compatible with our +self-respect. + +=Self-Abasement.= Self-assertion is aroused primarily by the presence +of others and especially of those to whom we feel in any way +superior, but when the presence of others makes us feel small, when we +want to hide or keep in the background, we are being moved by the +opposite instinct of self-abasement and negative self-feeling. It may +be either the real or the fancied superiority of the spectators that +arouses this feeling,--their wisdom or strength, beauty or good +clothes. Sometimes, as in stage-fright, it is their numerical +superiority. Bashfulness is the struggle between the two +self-instincts, assertion and abasement. Our impulse for self-display +urges us on to make a good impression, while our feeling of +inferiority impels us to get away unnoticed. Hence the struggle and +the painful emotion. + +=Gregariousness.= Man has been called a gregarious animal. That is, +like the animals, he likes to run with his kind, and feels a +pronounced aversion to prolonged isolation. It is this +"herd-instinct," too, which makes man so extremely sensitive to the +opinions of the society in which he lives. Because of this impulse to +go with the crowd, ideas received through education are accepted as +imperative and are backed up by all the force of the instinct of +self-regard. When the teachings of society happen to run counter to +the laws of our being, the possibilities of conflict are indeed +great.[10] + +[Footnote 10: For a thorough discussion of the importance of this +instinct, see Trotter's _Instincts of the Herd in Peace and War_.] + +=Acquisition.= Another fundamental disposition in both animals and +men is the instinct for possession, the instinct whose function it is +to provide for future needs. Squirrels and birds lay up nuts for the +winter; the dog hides his bone where only he can find it. Children +love to have things for their "very own," and almost invariably go +through the hoarding stage in which stamps or samples or bits of +string are hoarded for the sake of possession, quite apart from their +usefulness or value. Much of the training of children consists in +learning what is "mine" and what is "thine," and respect for the +property of others can develop only out of a sense of one's own +property rights. + +=Construction.= There is an innate satisfaction in making +something,--from a doll-dress to a poem,--and this satisfaction rests +on the impulse to construct, to fashion something with our own hands +or our own brain. The emotion accompanying this instinct is too +indefinite to have a name but it is nevertheless a real one and plays +a large part in the sense of power which results from the satisfaction +of good work well done. Later it will be seen how closely related is +this impulse to the creative instinct of reproduction and how useful +it can be in drawing off the surplus energy of that much denied +instinct. + +=Pugnacity and Anger.= What is it that makes us angry? A little +thought will convince us that the thing which arouses our fury is not +the sight of any special object, but the blocking of any one of the +other instincts. Watch any animal at bay when its chance for flight +has gone. The timidest one will turn and fight with every sign of +fury. Watch a mother when her young are threatened,--bear, or cat or +lion or human. Fear has no place then. It is entirely displaced by +anger over the balking of the maternal instinct of protection. +Strictly speaking, pugnacity belongs among the instincts neither of +self-preservation nor of race-preservation, but is a special device +for reinforcing both groups. + +As fear supplies the energy for running, so anger fits us for +fight,--and for nothing but fight. The mechanism is almost identical +with that of fear. Brain and liver, adrenals and thyroid are the +means, but the emotion presses the button and releases the energy, +stopping all digestion and energizing all combat-muscles. The blood is +flooded with fuel and with substances which, if not used, are harmful +to the body. We were never meant to be angry without fighting. The +habit of self-control has its distinct advantages, but it is hard on +the body, which was patterned before self-control came into fashion. +The wise man, once he is aroused, lets off steam at the woodpile or on +a long, vigorous walk. He probably does not say to himself that he is +a motor animal integrated for fight and that he must get rid of +glycogen and adrenalin and thyroid secretion. He only knows that he +feels better "on the move." + +The wiser man does not let himself get angry in the first place unless +the situation calls for fight. However, the fight need not be a +hand-to-hand combat with one's fellow man. William James has pointed +out that there is a "moral equivalent for war," and that the energy of +this instinct may be used to reinforce other impulses and help +overcome obstacles of all sorts. A good deal of the business man's +zest, the engineer's determination, and the reformer's zeal spring +from the fight-instinct used in the right way. As James, Cannon, and +others have pointed out, the way to end war may be to employ man's +instinct of pugnacity in fighting the universal enemies of the +race--fire, flood, famine, disease, and the various social +evils--rather than let it spend its force in war between nations. Even +our sports may be offshoots of the fight-instinct, for McDougall holds +that the play-tendency has its root in the instinct of rivalry, a +modified form of pugnacity. Evidently fighting-blood is a useful +inheritance, even to-day, and rightly directed is a necessary part of +a complete and forceful personality. + +This, then, completes the list of self-preservative instincts, those +which are commonly called egoistic and which have been given us for +the maintenance of our own individual personal lives. But our +endowment includes another set of impulses which are no less important +and which must be reckoned with if human conduct is to be understood. + + + + +CHAPTER IV + +_In which we learn more about ourselves_ + +THE STORY OF THE INSTINCTS (Continued) + +II. THE RACE-PRESERVATIVE INSTINCTS + + +=Looking beyond Ourselves.= We sometimes speak of self-preservation as +though it were the only law of life, while as a matter of fact it is +but half the story. Nature has seen to it that there shall be planted +in every living creature an innate urge toward the larger life of the +race. Although the creature may never give a conscious thought to the +welfare of the race, he still bears within himself a set of instincts +which have as their end and aim, not the individual at all, but +society as a whole, and the life of generations that are to come. He +is bigger than he knows. Although he may have no notion why he feels +and acts as he does, and although he may pervert the purpose for his +own selfish end, he is continually being moved by the mighty impulse +of the race-life, an impulse which often outrivals the desire I or his +own personal existence. The craving to reproduce ourselves and the +craving to cherish and protect our young are among the most dynamic +forces in life. The two desires are so closely bound together that +they are often spoken of as one under the name of the sex-instinct, or +the family instincts. Let us look first at that part of the yearning +which urges toward perpetuating our own life in offspring. + +=Watching Nature Work.= It is wonderful, indeed, to watch Nature in +the long process of Evolution, as she adapts her methods to the +growing complexity of the organism. With a variety and ingenuity of +means, but always with the same steady purpose, she works from the +lowest levels,--where there is no true reproduction, only +multiplication by division,--on through the beginning of reproduction +proper, where a single parent produces the offspring; then on to the +level where it takes two parents of different structure to produce a +new organism, and sex-life begins. At first Nature does not even +demand that father and mother shall come near each other. In the +water, the female of this type lays an egg, and the male, guided by +his instinct, swims to it and deposits his fertilizing fluid. In plant +life, bird and bee, attracted by wonderfully planned perfumes and +color and honey, are called in to carry the pollen from male to female +cell. + +But it is when we come to the highest level that we find even more +subtle ways planned to accomplish the desired end. Here we enter the +realm of individual initiative, for it is not now enough to leave to +external forces the joining of the two life-elements. In order to make +a new individual, father and mother must be drawn together, and so +there enters into the situation a personal relationship with all that +that implies. Because Nature has had to provide ways of drawing +individuals to one another, she has put into the higher types of life +the power of mutual attraction,--a power which in man, the highest of +all types, is responsible for many outgrowths that seem far removed +from the original purpose. + +=The Love-Motif.= On the one hand, there is the persistent desire to +be attractive, which manifests itself in the subtlest ways. How many +of the yearnings and activities of human life have their roots in this +ancient and honorable desire! The love of pretty clothes,--however it +may seem to be motivated and however it may be complicated by other +motives,-draws its energy, fundamentally, from the same need that +provides the gay plumage and limpid song of the bird or the painted +wings of the butterfly. + +On the other hand, there is the capability of being attracted, with +all the personal relationships which spring from the power of admiring +and loving another person. The interest in others does not expend its +whole force on its primary objects,--mate and children. It flows out +into all human relationships, developing all the possibilities of +loving which mean so much in human life; the love of man for man and +woman for woman, as well as mutual love of man and woman. A force like +this, once planted, especially in the higher types of life, does not +spend all its energies in its main trunk. It sends out branches in +many directions, bearing by-products which are rich in value for all +of life. + +Many of our richest relationships, our best impulses, and our most +firmly fixed social habits spring from the family instincts of +reproduction and parental care. The social life of our young people, +so well calculated to bring young men and women together; all the +beauty of family life and, as we shall later see, all the broader +benevolent activities for society in general, are energized by the +same love-instincts which form so large a part of human nature. + + +LEARNING TO LOVE + +=A Four-Grade School.= It is impossible to watch the growth of the +love-life of a human being, to trace its development from babyhood up +to its culmination in mating and parenthood, without a sense of wonder +at the steady purpose behind it all. We used to believe that the love +for the young girl that suddenly blooms forth in the callow youth was +an entirely new affair, something suddenly planted in him as he +developed into manhood; but now we know, thanks to the uncovering of +human nature by the painstaking investigations of the psycho-analytic +school of psychologists, that the seeds of the love-life are planted, +not in puberty, but with the beginning of life itself. Looked at in +one way, all infancy and childhood are a preparation, a training of +the love-instinct which is to be ready at the proper time to find its +mate and play its part in the perpetuation of the race. Nature begins +early. As she plants in the tiny baby all the organs that shall be +needed during its lifetime, so she plants the rudiments of all the +impulses and tendencies that shall later be developed into the +full-grown instincts. There have been found to be four periods in the +love-life of the growing child, three of them preparatory steps +leading up to maturity; periods in which the main current of love is +directed respectively toward self, parents, comrades, and finally +toward lover or mate. + +=Like Narcissus.= In the first stage, the baby's interest is in his +own body. He is getting acquainted with himself, and he soon finds +that his body contains possibilities of pleasurable sensations which +may be repeated by the proper stimulation. Besides the +hunger-satisfaction that it brings, the act of sucking is pleasurable +in itself, and so the baby begins to suck his thumb or his quilts or +his rattle. Later, this impulse to stimulate the nerves about the +mouth finds its satisfaction in kissing, and still later it plays a +definite part in the wooing process; but at first the child is +self-sufficient and finds his pleasure entirely within himself. Other +regions of the body yield similar pleasure. We often find a tiny child +rubbing his genital organs or his thighs or taking exaggerated +pleasure in riding on someone's foot in order to stimulate these +nerves, which he has discovered at first merely by chance. When he +begins to run around, he loves to exhibit his own body, to go about +naked. None of this is naughtiness or perversion; it is only Nature's +preparation of trends that she will later need to use. The child is +normally and naturally in love with himself.[11] But he must not +linger too long in this stage. None of the channels which his +life-force is cutting must be dug too deep, else in later life they +will offer lines of least resistance which may, on occasion, invite +illness or perversion. + +[Footnote 11: This is the stage which is technically known as +auto-eroticism or self-love.] + +=In Love with His Family.= Presently Nature pries the child loose from +love of himself and directs part of his interests to people outside +himself. Before he is a year old, part of his love is turned to +others. In this stage it is natural that at first his affection should +center on those who make up his home circle,--his parents and other +members of the household. Even in this early choice we see a +foreshadowing of his future need. The normal little boy is especially +fond of his mother, and the normal little girl of her father. Not all +the love goes to the parent of the opposite sex, but if the child be +normal, a noticeably larger part finds its way in that direction. +Observing parents can often see unmistakable signs of jealousy: toward +the parent of the same sex, or the brother or sister of the same sex. +The little boy who sleeps with his mother while his father is away, or +who on these occasions gets all the attention and all the petting he +craves, is naturally eager to perpetuate this state of affairs. Many a +small boy has been heard to say that he wished his father would go +away and stay all the time,--to the horror of the parents who do not +understand. All this is natural enough, but it is not to be +encouraged. The pattern of the father or the mother must not be +stamped too deep in the impressionable child-mind. Too little love and +sympathy are bad, leading to repression and a morbid turning in of the +love-force; but too much petting, too many caresses are just as bad. +Sentimental self-indulgence on the part of the parents has been +repeatedly proved to be the cause of many a later illness for the +child. As the right kind of family love and comradeship, the kind that +leads to freedom and self-dependence, is among the highest forces in +life, so the wrong kind is among the worst. Parents and their +substitutes--nurses, sisters, and brothers--are but temporary +stopping-places for the growing love, stepping-stones to later +attachments which are biologically more necessary. The small boy who +lets himself be coddled and petted too long by his adoring relatives, +who does not shake off their caresses and run away to the other boys, +is doomed to failure, and, as we shall later see, probably to +illness.[12] + +[Footnote 12: One of the best discussions of this theme is found in +the chapter "The Only or Favorite Child," by A.A. Brill, in +_Psychoanalysis_.] + +In the later infantile period, the child, besides wanting to exhibit +his own body, shows marked interest in looking at the bodies of +others, and marked curiosity on sex-questions in general. He +particularly wants to know "where babies come from." If his questions +are unfortunately met by embarrassment or laughing evasion, or by +obvious lying about the stork or the doctor or the angels, his +curiosity is only whetted, and he comes to the very natural conclusion +that all matters of sex are sinful, disgusting, and indecent, and to +be investigated only on the sly. This conception cannot be brought +into harmony with the unconscious mental processes arising from his +race-instincts nor with his instinctive sense that "whatever is is +right." The resulting conflict in some four-year-old children is +surprisingly intense. Astonished indeed would many parents be if they +knew what was going on inside the heads of their "innocent" little +children; not "bad" things, but pathetic things which a little candor +would have avoided. + +Alongside the rudimentary impulses of showing and looking, there is +developed another set of trends which Nature needs to use later on, +the so-called sadistic and masochistic impulses, the desire to +dominate and master and even to inflict pain, and its opposite impulse +which takes pleasure in yielding and submitting to mastery. These +traits, harking back to the time when the male needed to capture by +force, are of course much more evident in adolescence and especially +in love-making, but have their beginning in childhood, as many a +mother of cruel children knows to her sorrow. In adolescence, when +sex-differentiation is much more marked, the dominating impulse is +stronger in the boy and the yielding impulse in the girl; but in +little children the differentiation has not yet begun. + +=Gang and Chum.= At about four or five years the child leaves the +infantile stage of development, with its self-love and its intense +devotion to parents and their substitutes. He begins to be especially +interested in playmates of his own sex, to care more for the opinions +of the gang--or if it be a little girl, of the chum--than for those of +the parents. The life-force is leading him on to the next step in his +education, freeing him little by little from a too-hampering +attachment to his family. This does not mean that he does not love +his father and mother. It means only that some of his love is being +turned toward the rest of the world, that he may be an independent, +socially useful man. + +This period between infancy and puberty is known as the latency +period. All interest in sex disappears, repressed by the spontaneously +developing sense of shame and modesty and by the impact of education +and social disapproval. The child forgets that he was ever curious on +sex-matters and lets his curiosity turn into other, more acceptable +channels. + +=The Mating-Time.= We are familiar with the changes that take place at +puberty. We laugh at the girl who, throwing off her tom-boy ways, +suddenly wants her skirts let down and her hair done up. We laugh at +the boy who suddenly leaves off being a rowdy, and turns into a +would-be dandy. We scold because this same boy and girl who have +always been so "sweet and tractable" become, almost overnight, surly +and cantankerous, restive under authority and impatient of family +restraint. We should neither laugh nor scold, if we understood. Nature +is succeeding in her purpose. She has led the young life on from self +to parents, from parents to gang or chum, and now she is trying to +lead it away from all its earlier attachments, to set it free for its +final adventure in loving. The process is painful, so painful that it +sometimes fails of accomplishment. In any case, the strain is +tremendous, needing all the wisdom and understanding which the family +has to offer. It is no easy task for any person to free himself from +the sense of dependence and protection, and the shielding love that +have always been his; to weigh anchors that are holding him to the +past and to start out on the voyage alone. + +At this time of change, the chemistry of the body plays an important +part in the development of the mental traits; all half-developed +tendencies are given power through the maturing of the sex-glands, +which bind them into an organization ready for their ultimate purpose. +The current is now turned on, and the machinery, which has been +furnished from the beginning, is ready for its task. After a few false +starts in the shape of "puppy love," the mature instinct, if it be +successful, seeks until from among the crowd it finds its mate. It has +graduated from the training-school and is ready for life. + + +CIVILIZATION'S PROBLEM + +=When Nature's Plans Fall Through.= We have been describing the normal +course of affairs. We know that all too often the normal is not +achieved. Inner forces or outer circumstances too often conspire to +keep the young man or the young woman from the culmination toward +which everything has been moving. If the life-force cannot liberate +itself from the old family grooves to forge ahead into new channels, +or if economic demands or other conditions make postponement +necessary, then marriage is not possible. All the glandular secretions +and internal stimuli have been urging on to the final consummation, +developing physical and emotional life for an end that does not come; +or if it does come, is not sufficient to satisfy the demands of the +age-old instinct which for millions of years knew no restraint. In any +case, man finds himself, and woman herself, face to face with a +pressing problem, none the less pressing because it is in most cases +entirely unrecognized. + +=Blundering Instincts.= The older a person is, the more fixed are his +habits. Now, an instinct is a race-habit and represents the +crystallized reactions of a past that is old. Whatever has been done +over and over again, millions of times, naturally becomes fixed, +automatic, tending to conserve itself in its old ways, to resist any +change and to act as it has always acted. This conserves energy and +works well so long as conditions remain the same. But if for any +reason there comes a change, things are likely to go wrong. By just so +far as things are different, an automatic habit becomes a handicap +instead of a help. + +This having to act under changed conditions is exactly the trouble +with the reproductive instinct. Under civilization, conditions have +changed but the instinct has not. It is trying to act as it always +has acted, but civilized man wills otherwise. The change that has come +is not in the physical, external environment, but in man himself and +in the social environment which he has created. There is in man an +onward urge toward new and better things. Side by side with the desire +to live as he always has lived, there is a desire to make new +adaptations which are for the advancement of the whole race-life. +Besides the natural wish to take his desires as he finds them, there +is also the wish to modify them and use them for higher and more +socially useful ends. + +As the race has found through long experience that monogamy is to be +preferred to promiscuous mating; that the highest interests of life +are fostered by loyalty to the institution of the family; that the +careful rearing of several children rather than the mere production of +many is in the long run to be desired; and that a single standard of +morality is practicable; so society has established for its members a +standard which is in direct opposition to the immeasurable urge of the +past. To make matters worse, there have at the same time grown up in +many communities a standard of living and an economic competition +which still further limit the size of the family and the satisfaction +of the reproductive impulse. + +=The Perpetual Feud.= There thus arises the strategic struggle +between that which the race has found good in the past and that which +the race finds good in the present. As the older race-experience is +laid in they body and built into the very fiber of the individual, +inherited as an innate impulse, it has become an integral part of +himself, an individual need rather than a social one. On the other +hand, man has, as another innate part of his being, the desire to go +with the herd, to conform to the standards of his fellows, to be what +he has learned society wants him to be. Hence the struggle, insistent, +ever more pressing, between two sets of desires within the man +himself; the feud between the past and the present, between the +natural and the social, between the selfish and the ideal. On one +side, there is the demand for instinctive satisfaction; on the other, +for moral control; on one side the demand for pleasure; on the other, +the demands of reality.[13] + +[Footnote 13: "All the burdens of men or society are caused by the +inadequacies in the association of primal animal emotions with those +mental powers which have been so rapidly developed in +man-kind."--Shaler quoted by Hinkle: Introduction to Jung's +_Psychology of the Unconscious_.] + +Two factors intensify the conflict. In the first place, the older +habits have the head start. Compared with the almost limitless extent +of our past history, our desire for the control of the instincts is +very new indeed. It requires the long look and the right perspective +to understand how very lately we have entered into our new conditions +and how old a habit we are trying to break. In the second place, the +larger part of the stimulus comes from within the body itself. When +studying the other instincts, we saw that the best way to control was +to refuse to stimulate when the situation was not suitable for +discharge. But with the organically aroused sex-instinct there is no +such power of choice. We may fan the flame by the thoughts we think or +the environment we seek, or we may smother the flame until it is out +of sight, but we cannot extinguish it by any act of ours. The issue +has always been too important to be left to the individual. The +stimulation comes, primarily, not by way of the mind but by way of the +body. With this instinct we cannot "stop before we begin," because +Nature has taken the matter out of our hands and begins for us. + + +THE BULWARK WE HAVE BUILT + +With the competing forces so strong and the issues so great, it is not +to be wondered at that society has had to build up a massive bulwark +of public opinion, to establish regulations and fix penalties that are +more stringent than those imposed in any other direction. Nor is it +remarkable that in its effort to protect itself, society has sometimes +made mistakes. + +These blunders seem to lie in two directions. Assuming that it is +nearly impossible for the male to control his instincts, and that, +after all, it does not matter so much whether he does or not, society +has blinked at license in men, and thus has fostered a demoralizing, +anti-social double standard which has broken up countless homes, has +been responsible for the spread of venereal diseases, and has been +among the greatest curses of modern civilization. At the same time +society, in its efforts to maintain its standards for woman, has +taught its children, especially its girls, that anything savoring of +the word "sexual" is sinful, disgusting, and impure. To be sure, very +many women have modified their childish views, but an astonishingly +large number conserve, even in maturity, their warped ideas about the +whole subject of sex. Many a mature woman secretly believes that she, +at least, is not guilty of harboring anything so "vulgar" as a +reproductive instinct, not realizing that if this were so, she would +be, in very truth, a freak of nature. + +Of course, woman is by nature as fully endowed with sex instincts as +is man. Kipling portrays the female of the species as "deadlier than +the male" in that the very framework of her constitution outlines the +one issue for which it was launched,--stanch against any attack which +might endanger the carrying on of life. Feeling the force of this +instinctive urge, she braces herself against precipitancy in response +by what seems almost a negation. + +Just as we lean well in when riding around a corner, in order to keep +ourselves from falling out, so by an "over-compensation" for what is +unconsciously felt to be danger woman increases her feeling of safety +by setting up a taboo on the whole subject of sex. It is time that we +freed our minds from the artificial and perverted attitude toward this +dominant impulse; time to rescue the word "sex" from its implications +of grossness and sensuousness, and to recognize the instinct in its +true light as one of the necessary and holy forces of life, a force +capable of causing great damage, but also holding infinite +possibilities for good if wisely directed. + +Society only gets its members into trouble when, even by implication, +it attempts to deny its natural make-up, and allows little children to +grow up with the false idea that one of their strongest impulses is to +be shunned by them as a thing of shame. We cannot dam back the flood +by building a bulwark of untruth, and then expect the bulwark to hold. + +=Adaptable Energy.= We neither have to give in to our over-insistent +desires nor to deny that they exist. Man has a power of adaptation. +Just when we seem to run up against a dead wall, to face an +irreconcilable conflict, we find a wonderful power of indirect +expression that affords satisfaction to all the innate forces without +doing violence to the ethical standards which have proved so necessary +for the development of character. + +Hunger, which, like the reproductive instinct, is stimulated by the +changing chemistry of the body, can be satisfied only by achieving its +primary purpose, the taking of material food; but the creative impulse +to reproduce oneself possesses a unique ability to spiritualize itself +and expend its energy in other lines of creative endeavor. There seems +to be some sort of close connection between the especially intense +energy of the reproductive instinct and the modes of expression of the +instinct for construction; a connection which makes possible the +utilization of threatening destructive energy by directing it toward +socially valuable work. Just as we harness the mountain stream and use +its wild force to light our cities, or catch the lightning to run our +trolley cars, so we find man and woman--under the right +conditions--easily and naturally switching over the power of their +surplus sex-energy to ends which seem at first only slightly related +to its original aim, but which resemble it in that they too are +self-expressive and creative. If a person is able to express himself +in some real way, to give himself to socially needed work; if he can +reproduce himself intellectually and spiritually in artistic +production, in invention, in literature, in social betterment, he is +drawing on an age-old reservoir of creative energy, and by so doing is +relieving himself of inner tension which would otherwise seek less +beneficent ways of expression. + +The world knew all this intuitively for a long time before it knew it +theoretically. The novelists, who are unconsciously among the best +psychologists, have thoroughly worked the vein. The average man knows +it. "He was disappointed in love," we say, "and we thought he would go +to pieces, but now he has found himself in his work"; or, "She will go +mad if she doesn't find some one who needs her." It is only lately +that science has caught up with intuition, but now the physicians and +psychologists who have had the most intimate and first-hand +acquaintance with the human heart are recognizing, to a man, this +unique power of the love-instinct and its possibilities for creative +work of every sort.[14] + +[Footnote 14: Among those who have shown this connection between the +love-force and creative work are Freud, Jung, Jelliffe, White, Brill, +Jones, Wright, Frink, and the late Dr. Putnam of Harvard University, +who writes: "Freud has never asserted it as his opinion and it +certainly is not mine, that this is the only root from which artistic +expression springs. On the other hand, it is probable that all +artistic productions are partly referable to this source. A close +examination of many of them would enable any one to justify the +opinion that it is a source largely drawn upon."--_Human Motives_. p. +87.] + + +=Higher Levels.= Freud has called this spiritualization of natural +forces by a term borrowed from chemistry. As a solid is "sublimated" +when transformed into a gas, so a primal impulse is said to be +"sublimated" when it is diverted from its original object and made to +serve other ends. By this power of sublimation the little +exhibitionist, who loved to show himself, may become an actor; the +"cruel" boy who loved to dissect animals may become a surgeon; the +sexually curious child may turn his curiosity to other things and +become a scholar; the "born mother," if denied children of her own or +having finished with their upbringing, may take to herself the +children of the city, working for better laws and better care for +needy little ones; the man or woman whose sex-instinct is too strong +to find expression in legitimate, direct ways, may find it a valuable +resource, an increment of energy for creative work, along whatever +line his talent may lie. + +There is no more marvelous provision in all life than this power of +sublimation of one form of energy into another, a provision shadowing +forth almost limitless possibilities for higher adaptations and for +growth in character. As we think of the distance we have already +traveled and the endless possibilities of ever higher excursions of +the life-force, we feel like echoing Paul's words: "He who began a +good work in you will perfect it unto the end." The history of the +past holds great promise for the future. + +=When Sublimation Fails.= But in the meantime we cannot congratulate +ourselves too heartily. Sublimation too often fails. There are too +many nervous wrecks by the way, too many weak indulgers of original +desires, too many repressed, starved lives with no outlet for their +misunderstood yearnings; and, as we shall see, too many people who, in +spite of a big lifework, fail to find satisfaction because of +unnecessary handicaps carried over from their childhood days. +"Society's great task is, therefore, the understanding of the +life-force, its manifold efforts at expression and the way of +attaining this, and to provide as free and expansive ways as possible +for the creative energy which is to work marvelous things for the +future." + +If "the understanding of the life force" is to be available for use, +it must be the property of the average man and woman, the fathers and +mothers of our children, the teachers and physicians who act as their +advisers and friends.[15] This chapter is intended to do its bit +toward such a general understanding. + +[Footnote 15: "Appropriate educational processes might perhaps guide +this enormous impulsive energy toward the maintenance instead of the +destruction of marriage and the family. But up to the present time, +education with respect to this moral issue has commonly lacked any +such constructive method. The social standard and the individual +impulse have simply collided, and the individual has been left to +resolve the conflict, for the most part by his own resources."--G.A. +Coe: _Psychology of Religion_, p. 150.] + + +PARENTAL INSTINCT AND TENDER EMOTION + +=Until They Can Fly.= Only half of Nature's need is met by the +reproductive instinct. Her carefulness in this direction would be +largely wasted without that other impulse which she has planted, the +impulse to protect the new lives until they are old enough to fend for +themselves. The higher the type of life and the greater the future +demands, the longer is the period of preparation and consequent period +of parental care. This fact, coupled with man's power for lasting +relationships through the organization of permanent sentiments, has +made the, bond between parent and child an enduring one. Needless to +say, this relationship is among the most beautiful on earth, the +source of an incalculable amount of joy and gain. However, as we have +already suggested, there lurks here, as in every beneficent force, a +danger. If parents forget what they are for, and try to foster a more +than ordinary tie, they make themselves a menace to those whom they +most love. Any exaggeration is abnormal. If the childhood bond is +over-strong, or the childhood dependence too long cultivated, then the +relationship has overstepped its purpose, and, as we shall later see, +has laid the foundation for a future neurosis. + +=Mothering the World.= Probably no instinct has so many ways of +indirect expression as this mothering impulse of protection. Aroused +by the cry of a child in distress, or by the thought of the weakness, +or need, or ill-treatment of any defenseless creature, this +mother-father impulse is at the root of altruism, gratitude, love, +pity, benevolence, and all unselfish actions. + +There is still a great difference of opinion as to how man's spiritual +nature came into being; still discussion as to whether it developed +out of crude beginnings as the rest of his physical and mental +endowment has developed, or whether it was added from the outside as +something entirely new. Be that as it may, the fact remains that man +has as an innate part of his being an altruistic tendency, an +unselfish care for the welfare of others, a relationship to society as +a whole,--a relationship which is the only foundation of health and +happiness and which brings sure disaster if ignored. The egoistic +tendencies are only a part of human nature. Part of us is naturally +socially minded, unselfish, spiritual, capable of responding to the +call to lose our lives in order that others may find theirs. + + +SUMMARY + +Civilized man as he is to-day is a product of the past and can be +understood only as that past is understood. The conflicts with which +he is confronted are the direct outcome of the evolutional history of +the race and of its attempt to adapt its primitive instincts to +present-day ideals. + +Character is what we do with our instincts. According to Freud, all +of a man's traits are the result of his unchanged original impulses, +or of his reactions against those impulses, or of his sublimation of +them. In other words, there are three things we may do with our +instincts. We may follow our primal desires, we may deny their +existence, or we may use them for ends which are in harmony with our +lives as we want them to be. As the first course leads to degeneracy, +the second to nervous illness, and the third to happy usefulness, it +is obviously important to learn the way of sublimation. Sometimes this +is accomplished unconsciously by the life-force, but sometimes +sublimation fails, and is reestablished only when the conscious mind +gains an understanding of the great forces of life. This method of +reeducation of the personality as a means of treatment in nervousness +is called psycho-therapy. + +=Religion's Contribution.= If it be asked why, amid all this +discussion of instincts and motives we have made no mention of that +great energizer religion, we answer that we have by no means forgotten +it, but that we have been dealing solely with those primary tendencies +out of which all of the compound emotions are made. Man has been +described as instinctively and incurably religious, but there seems no +doubt that religion is a compound reaction, made up of +love,--sympathetic response to the parental love of God,--fear, +negative self-feeling, and positive self-feeling in the shape of +aspiration for the desired ideal of character; all woven into several +compound emotions such as awe, gratitude, and reverence. + +It goes almost without saying that religion, if it be vital, is one of +the greatest sources of moral energy and spiritual dynamic, and that +it is and always has been one of the greatest aids to sublimation that +man has found. A force like the Christian religion, which sets the +highest ideal of character and makes man want to live up to it, and +which at the same time says, "You can. Here is strength to help you"; +which unifies life and fills it with purpose; which furnishes the +highest love-object and turns the thought outward to the good of +mankind--such a force could hardly fail to be a dynamic factor in the +effort toward sublimation. This book, however, deals primarily with +those cases for which religion has had, to call science to her aid in +order to find the cause of failure, to flood the whole subject with +light, and to help cut the cords which, binding us to the past, make +it impossible to utilize the great resources that are at hand for all +the children of men. + +=Where We Keep Our Instincts.= It must have been impossible to read +through these two chapters on instinct without feeling that, after +all, we are not very well acquainted with ourselves. The more we look +into human nature, the more evident it becomes that there is much in +each one of us of which we are only dimly aware. It is now time for us +to look a little deeper,--to find where we keep these instinctive +tendencies with which it is possible to live so intimately without +even suspecting their existence. We shall find that they occupy a +realm of their own, and that this realm, while quite out of sight, is +yet open to exploration. + + + + +CHAPTER V + +_In which we look below the surface and discover a veritable +wonderland_ + +THE SUBCONSCIOUS MIND + +STRANGERS TO OURSELVES + + +=Hidden Strings.= A collie dog lies on the hearthrug. A small boy with +mischievous intent ties a fine thread to a bone, hides himself behind +a chair, and pulls the bone slowly across the floor. The dog is thrown +into a fit of terror because he does not know about the hidden string. + +A Chinese in the early days of San Francisco stands spell-bound at the +sight of a cable car. "No pushee. No pullee. Go allee samee like +hellee!" He does not know about the hidden string. + +A woman of refinement and culture thinks a thought that horrifies her +sensitive soul. It is entirely out of keeping with her character as +she knows it. In her misunderstanding she considers it wicked and +thrusts it from her, wondering how it ever could have been hers. She +does not know about the hidden string. + +In the last two chapters we thought together about some of these +strings, examining the fibers of which they are made and learning in +what directions they pull. We found them to be more powerful than we +should have supposed, more insistent and less visible. We found that +instinctive desire is the string, the cable that energizes our every +act, but that our desires are neither single nor simple, and are but +rarely on the surface. Many of us live with them a long time, feeling +the tug, but not recognizing the string. + +=There's a Reason.= We take our thoughts and feelings and actions for +granted, without stopping very often to wonder where they come from. +But there is always a reason. When the law of cause and effect reaches +the doorsill of our minds, it does not stop short to give way to the +law of chance. We wake up in the morning with a certain thought on +top. We say it "just happens." But nothing ever just happens. No +thought that ever comes into our heads has been without its +history,--its ancestors and its determining causes. But what about +dreams? They, at least, you say, have no connections, no past and no +future, only a weird, fantastic present. Strange to say, dreams have +been found to be as closely related to our real selves, as interwoven +with the warp and woof of our lives as are any of our waking thoughts. +Even dreams have a reason. + +We find ourselves holding certain beliefs and prejudices, interested +in certain things and indifferent to others, liking some foods, some +colors and disliking others. Search our minds as we will, we find no +clue to many of these inner trends. Why? + +The answer is simple. The cause is hidden below the surface. If we try +to explain ourselves on the basis of the open-to-inspection part of +our minds, we must come to the conclusion that we are queer creatures +indeed. Only by assuming that there is more to us than we know, can we +find any rational basis for the way we think and feel and act. + +=A Real Mind.= We learn of our internal machinery by what it does. We +must infer a part of our minds which introspection does not reveal, a +mind within the mind, able to work for us even while we are unaware of +its existence. This inner mind is usually known as the subconscious, +the mind under the level of consciousness.[16] We forget a name, but +we know that it will come to us if we think about something else. +Presently, out of somewhere, there flashes the word we want. Where was +it in the meanwhile, and what hunted it out from among all our other +memories and sent it up into consciousness? The something which did +that must be capable of conserving memories, of recognizing the right +one and of communicating it,--surely a real mind. + +[Footnote 16: Writers of the psycho-analytic school use the word +"unconscious" to denote the lower layers of this region, and +"fore-conscious" to denote its upper layers. Morton Prince uses the +terms "unconscious" and "conscious" to denote the different strata. As +there is still a good deal of confusion in the use of terms, it has +seemed to us simpler to use throughout only the general term +"subconscious."] + +One evening my collaborator fumbled unsuccessfully for the name of a +certain well-known journalist and educator. It was on the tip of her +tongue, but it simply would not come, not even the initial letter. In +a whimsical mood she said to herself just as she went to sleep, +"Little subconscious mind, you find that name to-night." In the middle +of the night she awoke, saying, "Williams--Talcott Williams." The +subconscious, which has charge of her memories, had been at work while +she slept. + +The history of literature abounds in stories of under-the-surface +work. The man of genius usually waits until the mood is on, until the +muse speaks; then all his lifeless material is lighted by new +radiance. He feels that some one outside himself is dictating. Often +he merely holds the pen while the finished work pours itself out +spontaneously as if from a higher source. + +But it is not only the man of genius who makes use of these unseen +powers. He may have readier access to his subconscious than the rest +of us, but he has no monopoly. The most matter-of-fact man often says +that he will "sleep over" a knotty problem. He puts it into his mind +and then goes about his business, or goes to sleep while this unseen +judge weighs and balances, collects related facts, looks first at one +side of the question and then at the other, and finally sends up into +consciousness a decision full of conviction, a decision that has been +formulated so far from the focus of attention that it seems to be +something altogether new, a veritable inspiration. + +We must infer the subconscious from what it does. Things +happen,--there must be a cause. Some of the things that happen +presuppose imagination, reason, intelligence, will, emotion, desire, +all the elements of mind. We cannot see this mind, but we can see its +products. To deny the subconscious is to deny the artist while looking +at his picture, to disbelieve in the poet while reading his poem, and +to doubt the existence of the explosive while listening to the report. +The subconscious is an artist, a poet, and an explosive by turns. If +we deny its existence, a good portion of man's doings are +unintelligible. If we admit it, many of his actions and his +afflictions which have seemed absurd stand out in a new light as +purposeful efforts with a real and adequate cause. + +=The Submerged Nine Tenths.= The more deeply psychologists and +physicians have studied into these things, the more certainly have +they been forced to the conclusion that the conscious mind of man, the +part that he can explore at will, is by far the smaller part of his +personality. Since this is to some people a rather startling +proposition, we can do no better than quote the following statement +from White on the relation of consciousness to the rest of the psychic +life: + + Consciousness includes only that of which we are _aware_, while + outside of this somewhat restricted area there lies a much wider + area in which lie the deeper motives for conduct, and which not + only operates to control conduct, but also dictates what may and + what may not become conscious. Stanley Hall has very forcibly put + the matter by using the illustration of the iceberg. Only + one-tenth of the iceberg is visible above water; nine-tenths is + beneath the surface. It may appear in a given instance that the + iceberg is being carried along by the prevailing winds and + surface currents, but if we keep our eyes open we shall sooner or + later see a berg going in the face of the wind, and, so, + apparently putting to naught all the laws of aerodynamics. We can + understand this only when we come to realize that much the + greater portion of the berg is beneath the surface and that it is + moving in response to invisible forces addressed against this + submerged portion. + + Consciousness only arises late in the course of evolution and + only in connection with adjustments that are relatively complex. + When the same or similar conditions in the environment are + repeatedly presented to the organism so that it is called upon to + react in a similar and almost + identical way each time, there tends to be organized a mechanism + of reaction which becomes more and more automatic and is + accompanied by a state of mind of less and less awareness.[17] + +[Footnote 17: White: _Mechanisms of Character Formation_.] + +It is easy to see the economy of this arrangement which provides +ready-made patterns of reaction for habitual situations and leaves +consciousness free for new decisions. Since an automatic action, +traveling along well-worn brain paths, consumes little energy and +causes the minimum of fatigue, the plan not only frees consciousness +from a confusing number of details, but also works for the +conservation of energy. While consciousness is busy lighting up the +special problems of the moment, the vast mass of life's demands are +taken care of by the subconscious, which constitutes the bulk of the +mind. "Properly speaking, the unconscious is the real psyche."[18] + +[Footnote 18: Freud: _Interpretation of Dreams_, p. 486.] + +=The Heart of Psychology.= In the face of all this, it is not to be +wondered at that the problem of the subconscious has been called not +one problem of psychology but the problem. It cannot be denied that +the discoveries which have already been made as to its activities have +been of immense practical importance in the understanding of normal +conduct and in the treatment of the psycho-neuroses. + +If some of the methods--such as hypnosis, automatic writing, and +interpretation of dreams--which are used to investigate its activities +seem to savor of the charlatan and the mountebank, it is because they +have occasionally been appropriated by the ignorant and the +unscrupulous. Their real setting is the psychological laboratory and +the physician's office. In the hands of men like Sigmund Freud, Boris +Sidis, and Morton Prince, they are as scientific as the apparatus of +any other laboratory and their findings are as susceptible of proof. +We may, then, go forward with the conviction that we are walking on +solid ground and that the main paths, at least, will turn into beaten +highways. + + +ANCESTRAL MEMORIES + +=Race-Memories.= An individual as he stands at any moment is the +product of his past,--the past which he has inherited and the past +which he has lived. In other words, he is a bundle of memories +accumulated through the experience of the race, and through his own +experience as a person. Some of these memories are conscious, and +these he calls his, while others fail to reach consciousness and are +not recognized as part of his assets. + +The instincts form the starting-point of mind, conscious and +subconscious, and are the foundation upon which the rest is built. +They often show themselves as part of our conscious lives, but their +roots are laid deep in the subconscious from which they can never be +eradicated. This deepest-laid instinctive layer of the subconscious is +little subject to change. It represents the earlier adjustments of the +race, crystallized into habit. It takes no account of the differences +between the present and the past. It knows no culture, no reason, no +lately acquired prudence. It is all energy and can only wish, or urge +toward action. But since only those race-memories became instincts +which had proved needful to the race in the long run, they are on the +whole beneficent forces, working for the good of the race and the good +of the individual, if he learns how to handle them aright and to adapt +them to present conditions. + +This instinctive urge toward action arouses in the individual an +organic response that is felt as a tension or craving and is mainly +dependent upon its own chemical constitution at the moment. Hunger is +the sensation caused by the little muscular contractions in the +stomach when the body is low in its food supply. Sudden fright is felt +as an all-gone sensation "at the pit of the stomach." What really +happens is a tightening up of the circular muscles of the +blood-vessels lying in the network of the solar plexus, and a spasm of +the muscles of the digestive tract. The hungry stomach impels to +action until satisfied; the physical discomfort in fear impels toward +measures of safety. The apparatus that is made use of by the +subconscious in carrying out this instinctive urge is called the +autonomic nervous system.[19] It regulates all the functions of +living, not only under the stress of emotion, but during every moment +of waking or sleeping. + +[Footnote 19: Kempf: "The Tonus of Automatic Segments as a Cause of +Abnormal Behavior," _Journal of Nervous and Mental Diseases_, January, +1921.] + +=A Capable Manager.= The conscious mind could not possibly send +messages to the numerous glands that fit the body for action, nor +attend to all the delicate adjustments that enter into the process. +The conscious mind in most of us does not even know of the existence +of the organs and secretions involved, but something sends the +messages and it is something that has a remarkable likeness to mind as +we usually think of mind,--something which takes advantage of the past +and gages means to an end with a nicety that excites our wonder. + +=Take no Anxious Thought.= We take food into our stomachs and forget +about it, if we are wise; and this subconscious overseer who through +millions of years of experience has learned how to digest food does +the rest. As with digestion, so with our heart-action; we lie down at +night fairly sure that there will be no break in the regular rhythm of +its beat. The subconscious overseer is "on the job" and he never +rests. No matter how hard we sleep, he never lets us forget to take a +breath; and if we trust him, he is very likely to wake us up at the +appointed time in the morning. Also, if we trust him, he carries us +off to sleep as though we were babies. Has he not had long practice in +the days before insomnia was invented? + +=First Aid to the Injured.= In times of infection or injury, this +subconscious manager is better than any doctor. The doctors say with +truth that they only assist nature. If the infection is internal, +antitoxins are produced within the body. If the injury is external, +like a cut, the messages fly, and white blood-corpuscles are marshaled +to take care of poisons and build up the tissue. If the injury is of +the kind that needs rest, the subconscious doctor knows it. He +therefore causes pain and rigidity, in order to induce us to hold the +injured part still until it is restored. + +Crile reminds us of a fact that is often noticed by surgeons. If +patients under ether are handled roughly, especially in the intestinal +region, respiration quickens and there are tremors and even convulsive +efforts which interfere with the surgeon's work. The conscious mind +cannot feel. It is asleep. But the subconscious mind, whose business +it is to protect the body, is trying to get away from injury. The body +uses up as much energy as though it had run for miles, and when the +patient wakes up, we say that he is suffering from shock. The +subconscious mind which is not affected by ether, has been exhausting +itself in a vain attempt to get the body away from harm. + +=A Tireless Servant.= When the conscious mind undertakes a job, it is +always more or less subject to fatigue. But the subconscious after its +long practice seems never to tire. We say that its activities have +become automatic. With all its inherited skill, the subconscious, if +left to itself, can be depended upon to run the bodily machinery +without effort and without hitch. The only things that can interfere +with its work are the wrong kind of emotions and the wrong kind of +suggestions from the conscious mind. Barring these, it goes its way +like a trusty servant, looking after details and leaving its master's +mind free for other things. Having been "in the family" for +generations, it knows its business and resents any interference with +its duties or any infringement of its rights. + +No man, then, comes into this world without inheritance: he receives +from his ancestors two goodly sets of heirlooms, the instincts and the +mechanism which carries on bodily functions. This is the capital with +which man starts life; but immediately he begins increasing this +capital, adding memories from his own experience to the accumulated +race-records. + + +PERSONAL MEMORIES + +No more startling secret has been unearthed by science than the +discovery of the length and minuteness of our memories. No matter how +much one may think he has forgotten, the tablets of his mind are +closely written with records of infinitesimal experiences, shadowy +sensations, old happenings which the conscious self has lost entirely +and would scarcely recognize as its own. Many of these brain records, +or neurograms, as Prince calls them, are never aroused from their +dormant conditions. But others, aroused by emotion or association of +ideas, may after years of inactivity, come forth again either as +conscious memories or as subconscious forces, or even as physiological +memories,--bodily repetitions of the pains, palpitations, and tremors +of old emotional experiences. + +=Irresistible Childhood.= An experience that is forgotten is not +necessarily lost. Although the first few years of childhood are lost +to conscious memory, these years outweigh all others in their +influence on character. The Jesuit priest was right when he said, +"Give me a child until he is six years old, and he will be a Catholic +all his life." As Frink has so ably shown, the determining factors +that enter into any adult choice, such as the choice of the Catholic +or the Protestant faith, are in a large measure made up of +subconscious memories from early childhood, forgotten memories of +Sunday-school and church, of lessons at home or passages in +books,--experiences which no voluntary effort could recall, but which +still live unrecognized in our mature judgments and beliefs. Naturally +we do not acknowledge these subconscious motives. We like to believe +that all our decisions are based on reason, and so we invent plausible +arguments for our attitudes and our actions, arguments which we +ourselves implicitly believe. This process of substituting a plausible +reason for a subconscious one is known as rationalization, a process +which every one of us engages in many times a day. + +It is indeed true that the child is father to the man. Those first +impressionable years, when we believed implicitly whatever any one +told us and when through ignorance we reacted emotionally to ordinary +experiences, are molding us still, making us the men and women we are +to-day, coloring with childish ideas many of the attitudes of our +supposedly reasoning life. Bergson says: + + The unconscious is our historical past. In reality the past is + preserved automatically. In its entirety probably it follows us + at every instant; all that we have felt, thought and willed from + our earliest infancy is there, leaning over the present which is + about to join it, pressing against the portals of consciousness + that would fain leave it outside. + +=Spontaneous Outbursts.= "How do we know all this?" some one says. +"What is the evidence for these sweeping statements? If we cannot +remember, how can we discover these strange memories that are so +powerful but so elusive? If they are below the level of consciousness, +are they not, in the very nature of the case, forever hidden from +view, in the sphere of the occult rather than that of science?" + +The answer to these questions is determined by one important fact; the +line between the conscious and subconscious minds does not always +remain in the same place; the "threshold of consciousness" is +sometimes displaced, automatically allowing these buried memories to +come to the surface. In sleep and delirium, in trance and +hallucination, in hysteria and intoxication, the tables are turned; +the restraining hand of the conscious mind is loosened and the +submerged self comes forth with all its ancient memories. + +It is a common experience to have a patient in delirium repeat +long-forgotten verses or descriptions of events that the "real man" +has lost entirely. The renowned servant-girl, quoted by Hudson, who in +delirium recited passage after passage of Hebrew, Latin, and Greek, +which she had heard her one-time master repeat in his study, is +typical of many such instances.[20] + +[Footnote 20: Hudson: _The Law of Psychic Phenomena_, p. 44. Quoted +from _Coleridge's Biographia Literaria_, Vol. I, p. 117 (edit. 1847).] + +A young girl of nineteen, a patient of mine, lapsed for several weeks +into a dissociated state in which she forgot all the memories and +ideas of her adult life, and returned to the period of her childhood. +She used to say that she saw things inside her head and would +accurately describe events that took place before she was two years of +age,--scenes which she had completely forgotten in her normal life. +One day when I asked her to tell me what she was seeing, she began to +talk about "little sister" (herself) and "little brother." "Little +sister and brother were the two little folks that lived with their +mother and their daddy and they were playing on the sand-pile. You +know there was only one sand-pile, not like all the ones they have +down here (at the seaside), and they had a bucket that they would put +sand in and they would dump it out again and they would make nice +things, you know; they would play with their little dog Ponto and he +was white with black and brown spots on him. Little brother had white +hair and he was bigger than little sister and he had a little waist +with ruffles down the front and around the collar and a black coat +that came down to his knees and it had two little white bands around +it. Some of the waists he wore had blue specks and some had red and +black specks in it. + +"Little sister had yellow curls and she had a blue coat with jiggly +streaks of white in it, and she had a little white bonnet that was +crocheted, and she had little blue mittens on that were tied to a +string that went around her neck and down the other arm. It got pretty +cold where they lived. Little sister and little brother would go out +to the pile of leaves and jump on them and bounce and they would +crackle. The leaves came down from the trees all of a sudden when they +got tired, and they were different colors, brown and red. Little +sister could walk then but she could not walk one other time before +then; she could stand up by holding to a chair, but she could not go +herself. One morning Big Tom said 'Run to Daddy' and she went to her +daddy, and after that she always walked; they were glad and she was +glad. She walked all day long. Big Tom was a man who used to help +Daddy and little sister always liked him. He was a nice man." + +The mother verified this scene of the first walking, saying that it +had occurred on her own wedding-anniversary when the child was +twenty-three months old. + +One night I heard the same patient talk in her sleep in the slow and +hesitating manner of a child reading phonetically from a printed page. +I soon recognized the words as those of a poem of Tagore's, called "My +Prayer," and remembered that a magazine containing the poem had been +lying on the bed during the day. When she had finished I wakened her, +saying, "Now tell me what you have been dreaming." She answered in +her childish way, "I think I do not dream." She went to sleep +immediately and again repeated the poem, word for word, without a +single mistake. Again I awakened her with the words, "Now tell me what +you have been dreaming." And again she answered, "I think I do not +dream." I said: "But yes; don't you remember you were just saying, +'When the time comes for me to go'?" (the last line of the poem). "Oh, +yes," she said, "I was seeing it, and I think I'll not go to sleep +again. It tires me so to see it." + +While she was awake she had no recollection of having seen the poem +and was indeed in her dissociated state quite incapable of +understanding its meaning. Asleep, she saw every word as plainly as if +the page had been before her eyes. + +The distorted pictures of dreams are always made of the material which +past experiences have furnished and which have in many cases been +dropped out of consciousness for years only to rise out of their long +oblivion when the conscious mind has been put to sleep. + +=Unearthing Old Experiences.= However, psychology does not have to +wait for buried memories to come forth of their own free will. It has +a number of successful ways of summoning them from their hiding-place +and helping them across the line into consciousness. In the hands of +skilled investigators and therapeutists, hypnosis, hypnoidization, +automatic writing, crystal-gazing, abstraction, free association, +word-association, and interpretation of dreams have all been +repeatedly successful in bringing to light memories which apparently +have been for many years completely blotted out of mind. As we become +better acquainted with these technical devices we shall find that +there are four kinds of experiences whose records are carefully stored +away in our minds. Some were always so far from the center of our +attention that we could swear they never had been ours; others, +although once present in consciousness, were so trivial and +unimportant that it seems ridiculous to suppose them conserved; others +never came into our waking minds at all and entered our lives only in +special states, such as sleep or delirium or dreams. All these we +should expect to forget; the astonishing thing is that they ever were +conserved. But there is a fourth class that is different. It is made +up of experiences that were so vital, so emotional, so closely woven +into the fiber of our being that it seems impossible that they ever +could be forgotten. Let us look at a few examples of records of all +these four kinds of experiences, examples chosen from hundreds of +their kind as illustrations of the all-embracing character of buried +memories.[21] + +[Footnote 21: For further examples see Prince, _The Unconscious_; +Prince, _The Dissociation of a Personality_, and Hudson, _The Law of +Psychic Phenomena_.] + +=Out of the Corners of Our Eyes.= In the first place, we are much +more observing than we imagine. We may be so interested in our own +thoughts that details of our environment are entirely lost on the +conscious mind, but the subconscious has its eyes open, and its ears. +People in hypnosis have been known to repeat verbatim whole passages +from newspapers which they had never consciously read. While they were +busy with one column, their wide-awake subconscious was devouring the +next one, and remembering it. Prince relates the story of a young +woman who unconsciously "took in" the details of a friend's +appearance: + + I asked B.C.A. (without warning and after having covered her + eyes) to describe the dress of a friend who was present and with + whom she had been conversing perhaps some twenty minutes. She was + unable to do so beyond saying that he wore dark clothes. I then + found that I myself was unable to give a more detailed + description of his dress, although we had lunched and been + together about two hours. B.C.A. was then asked to write a + description automatically. Her hand wrote as follows (she was + unaware that her hand was writing): + + "He has on a dark greenish gray suit, a stripe in it--little + rough stripe; black bow cravat; shirt with three little stripes + in it; black laced shoes; false teeth; one finger gone; three + buttons on his coat." + + The written description was absolutely correct. The stripes in + the coat were almost invisible. I had not noticed + his teeth or the loss of a finger and we had to count the buttons + to make sure of their number owing to their partial concealment + by the folds of the unbuttoned coat. The shoe-strings I am sure + under the conditions would have escaped nearly every one's + notice.[22] + +[Footnote 22: Prince: _The Unconscious_, p. 53.] + +Automatic writing, the method used to uncover this subconscious +perception, is a favorite method with some investigators and is often +used by Morton Prince. The hand writes without the direction of the +personal consciousness and usually without the person's being aware +that it is writing. A dissociated person does this very easily; other +people can cultivate the ability, and perhaps most of us approach it +when we are at the telephone, busily writing or drawing remarkable +pictures while the rest of us is engaged in conversation. + +The present epidemic of the Ouija board shows how many persons there +are who are able to switch off the conscious mind and let the +subconscious control the muscles that are used in writing. The fact +that the writer has no understanding of what he is doing and believes +himself directed by some outside power, in no way interferes with the +subconscious phenomenon. + +=Everyday Doings.= Besides perceptions which were originally so far +from the focus of attention that the conscious mind never caught them +at all, there are the little experiences of everyday life, fleeting +thoughts and impressions which occupy us for a minute and then +disappear. Every experience is a dynamic fact and no matter how +trivial the experience may be or how completely forgotten, it still +exists as a part of the personality. + +An amusing example of the everyday kind of forgotten experience +occurred during the writing of this chapter. I wrote a sentence which +pleased me very well. This is the sentence: "In the esthetic processes +of evolution they [man's desires] have sunk below the surface as soon +as formed, and have been covered over by an elastic and snug-fitting +consciousness as the skin covers in the tissues and organs of the +body." After showing this passage to my collaborator and remarking +that this figure had never been used before, I was partly chagrined +and partly amused to have her bring me the following sentence from +White and Jelliffe: "Consciousness covered over and obscured the inner +organs of the psyche just as the skin hides the inner organs of the +body from vision." My originality had vanished and I was close to +plagiarism. Indeed, if a history of plagiarism could be written, it +would probably abound in just such stories. I had read the article +containing this sentence only once, about three years before, and had +never quoted it or consciously thought of it. It had lain buried for +three years, only to come forth as an original idea of my own. Who +knows how many times we all do just this thing without catching +ourselves in the trick? + +=Back-Door Memories.= There are other kinds of memories which hide in +the subconscious, memories of experiences which have not come in by +the front door, but have entered the mind during special states, such +as sleep, delirium, intoxication, or hypnosis. What is known as +post-hypnotic suggestion is the functioning of a suggestion received +during hypnosis and emerging later as an impulse without being +recognized as a memory. A man in a hypnotic state is told that at five +o'clock he will take off his clothes and go to bed, without +remembering that such a suggestion has been given him. He awakens with +no recollection of the suggestion, but at five o'clock he suddenly +feels impelled to go to bed, even though his unreasonable desire puts +him into a highly embarrassing position. The suggestion, to be thus +effective, must have been conserved somewhere in his mind outside of +consciousness. + +Suggestions that enter the mind during the normal sleep are also +recorded,--a fact that carries a warning to people who are in the +habit of talking of all sorts of matters while in the room with +sleeping children. I have sometimes suggested to sleeping patients +that on waking they will remember and tell me the cause of their +symptoms. The following example shows not only the conservation of +impressions gained in sleep, but also the sway of forgotten ideas of +childhood, still strong in mature years. This young woman, a trained +nurse, with many marked symptoms of hysteria, had been asked casually +to bring a book from the Public Library. She cried out in +consternation, "Oh, no, I am afraid!" After a good deal of urging she +finally brought the book, although at the cost of considerable effort. +Later, while she was taking a nap, I said to her, "You will not +remember that I have talked to you. You will stay asleep while I am +talking and while you are asleep there will come to your mind the +reasons why you are afraid to go to the Public Library. When you +waken, you will tell me all about it." Upon awakening, she said: "Oh, +do you know, I can tell you why I have always been afraid to go to the +Public Library. While I was in Parochial School, Father ---- used to +come in and tell us children to use the books out of the school +library and never to go to the Public Library." I questioned her +concerning her idea of the reason for such an injunction and what she +thought was in the books which she was told not to read. She +hesitatingly stated that it was her idea, even in childhood, that the +books dealt with topics concerning the tabooed subject of the birth of +children and kindred matters. + +=Smoldering Volcanoes.= Let us now consider those emotional +experiences which seem far too compelling to be forgotten, but which +may live within us for years without giving any evidence of their +existence. Memories like these are apt to be anything but a dead past. + +Many of my own patients have uncovered emotional memories through +simply talking out to me whatever came into their minds, laying aside +their critical faculty and letting their minds wander on into whatever +paths association led them. This is known as the free-association +method, and simple as it seems, is one of the most effective in +uncovering memories which have been forgotten for years. One of my +patients, a refined, highly educated woman of middle age, had suffered +for two years with almost constant nausea. One day, after a long talk, +with no suggestion on my part, only an occasional, "What does that +remind you of?" she told with great emotion an experience which she +had had at eighteen years of age, in which she had for a moment been +sexually attracted to a boy friend, but had recoiled as soon as she +realized where her impulse was leading her. She had been so horrified +at the idea of her degradation, so nauseated at what she considered +her sin, that she had put it out of her mind, denied that such a +thought had ever been hers, repressed the desire into the +subconscious, where it had continued to function unsatisfied, +unassimilated with her mature judgments. Her nausea was the symbol of +a moral disgust. Physical nausea she was willing to acknowledge, but +not this other thing. Upon reciting this old experience, with every +sign of the original shame, she cried: "Oh, Doctor! why did you bring +this up? I had forgotten it. I haven't thought of it in thirty years." +I reminded her that I couldn't bring it up,--I had never known +anything about it. With the emotional incoming of this memory and the +saner attitude toward it which the mature woman's mind was able to +take, the nausea disappeared for good. This case is typical of the +psycho-neuroses and we shall have occasion to refer to it again. The +present emphasis is on the fact that an emotional memory may be buried +for many years while it still retains the power of reappearing in more +or less disguised manifestation. + +=Repressed Memories.= If we ask how so burning a memory could escape +from the consciousness of a grown woman, we are driven to the +conclusion that this forgetting can be the result of no mere quiet +fading away, but that there must have been some active force at work +which kept the memory from coming into awareness. It was not lost. It +was not passive. Out of sight was not out of mind. There must have +been a reason for its expulsion from the personal consciousness. In +fact, we find that there is a reason. We find that whenever a vital +emotional experience disappears from view, it is because it is too +painful to be endured in consciousness. Nor is it ever the pain of an +impersonal experience or even the thought of what some one else has +done to us that drives a memory out of mind. As a matter of fact, we +never expel a memory except when it bears directly on ourselves and on +our own opinion of ourselves. We can stand almost anything else, but +we cannot stand an idea that does not fit in with our ideal for +ourselves. This is not the pious ideal that we should like to live up +to and that we hope to attain some day, not the ideal that we think we +ought to have--like never speaking ill of others or never being +selfish--but the secret picture that each of us has, locked away +within him, the specifications of ourselves reduced to their lowest +terms, below which we cannot go. Energized by the instinct of positive +self-feeling, and organized with the moral sentiments which we have +acquired from education and the ideals of society, especially those +acquired in early childhood, this ideal of ourselves becomes +incorporated into our conscience and is an absolute necessity for our +happiness. + +We have found that when two emotions clash, one drives out the other. +So in this case, the woman's positive self-feeling of self-respect, +combined with disgust, drove from the field that other emotion of the +reproductive instinct which was trying to get expression. Speaking +technically, one repressed the other. The woman said to herself, "No, +I never could have had such a thought," and promptly forgot it. +Needless to say, this kind of handling did not kill the impulse. +Buried in the depths of her soul, it continued to live like a live +coal, until in later years, fanned by the wind of some new experience, +it burst into flame. + +In this case the wish had originally flashed into awareness for an +instant, but very often the impulse never gets into consciousness at +all. The upper layers of the subconscious, where the acquired ideals +live, automatically work to keep down any desires which are thought to +be out of keeping with the person as he knows himself. He then would +emphatically deny that such desires had ever had any place in his +life. + +Freud has called this repressing force the psychic censor. To get into +consciousness, any idea from the subconscious must be able to pass +this censor. This force seems to be a combination of the +self-regarding and herd-instincts, which dispute with the instinct for +reproduction the right to "the common path" for expression. + +A considerable part of any person's subconscious is made up of +memories, wishes, impulses, which are repressed in this way. Of course +any instinctive desire may be repressed, but it is easy to understand +why the most frequently denied impulse, the instinct of reproduction, +against whose urgency society has cultivated so strong a feeling, +should be repressed more frequently than any other.[23] + +[Footnote 23: See foot-note, p. 145, Chap. VII.] + +=Past and Present.= It matters not, then, in what state experiences +come to us, whether in sleep or delirium, intoxication or hypnosis, or +in the normal waking condition. They are conserved and may exert great +influence on our normal lives. It matters not whether the experiences +be full of meaning and emotion or whether they be so slight as to pass +unnoticed, they are conserved. It matters not whether these +experiences be mere sense-impressions, or inner thoughts, whether they +be unacknowledged hopes or fears, undesirable moods and unworthy +desires or fine aspirations and lofty ideals. They are conserved and +they may at a later day rise up to bless or to curse us long after we +had thought them buried in the past. The present is the product of the +past. It is the past plus an element of choice which keeps us from +settling down in the despair of fatalism and enables us to do +something toward making the present that is, a help and not a +stumbling-block to the present that is to be. + + +SOME HABITS OF THE SUBCONSCIOUS + +=The Association of Ideas.= It is only by something akin to poetic +license that we can speak of lower and higher strata of mind. When we +carry over the language of material things into the less easily +pictured psychic realm, it is sometimes well to remind ourselves that +figures of speech, if taken too literally, are more misleading than +illuminating. When we speak of the deep-laid instinctive lower levels +of mind and the higher acquired levels, we must not imagine that these +strata are really laid in neat, mutually exclusive layers, one on top +of the other in the chambers of the mind. Nor must we imagine the +mental elements of instinct, idea, and memory as jumbled together in +chaotic confusion, or in scattered isolated units. As a matter of +fact, the best word to picture the inside of our minds is the word +"group." We do not know just how ideas and instincts can group +themselves together, but we do know that by some arrangement of brain +paths and nerve-connections, the laws of association of ideas and of +habit take our mental experiences and organize them into more or less +permanent systems. Instinctive emotions tend to organize themselves +around ideas to form sentiments; ideas or sentiments, which through +repetition or emotion are associated together, tend to stay together +in groups or complexes which act as a whole; complexes which pertain +to the same interests tend to bind themselves into larger systems or +constellations, forming moods, or sides to one's character. It is not +highly important to differentiate in every case a sentiment from a +complex, or a complex from a constellation, especially as many writers +use "complex" as the generic term for all sorts of groups; but a +general understanding of the much-used word "complex" is necessary +for a comprehension of modern literature on psychology, psychotherapy +or general education. + +"=What Is a Complex=?" Reduced to its lowest terms, a complex is a +group. It may be simply a group of associated movements, like lacing +one's shoes or knitting; it may be a group of movements and ideas, +like typewriting or piano-playing, which through repetition have +become automatic or subconscious; it may be merely a group of ideas, +such as the days of the week, the alphabet or the multiplication +table. In all these types it is repetition working through the law of +habit that ties the ideas and movements together into an organic +whole. Usually, however, the word complex is reserved for psychic +elements that are bound together by emotion. In this sense, a complex +is an emotional thought-habit. Frink's definition, which is one of the +simplest, recognizes only this emotional type: "A complex is a system +of connected ideas, having a strong emotional tone, and displaying a +tendency to produce or influence conscious thought and action in a +definite and predetermined direction."[24] + +[Footnote 24: Frink: "What Is a Complex?" _Journal American Medical +Assoc_., Vol. LXII, No. 12, Mar. 21, 1914.] + +Emotion and repetition are the great welders of complexes. Emotion is +the strongest cement in the world. A single emotional experience +suffices to bind together ideas that were originally as far apart as +the poles. + +Sometimes a complex includes not only ideas, movements, and emotions, +but physiological disturbances and sensations. Some people cannot go +aboard a stationary ship without vomiting, nor see a rose, even though +it prove to be a wax one, without the sneezing and watery eyes of +hay-fever. This is what is known as a "conditioned reflex." Past +associations plus fear have so welded together idea and bodily +manifestation that one follows the other as a matter of course, long +after the real cause is removed. In such ways innumerable nervous +symptoms arise. The same laws which form healthy complexes, and, +indeed, which make all education possible, may thus be responsible for +the unhealthy mal-adaptive association-habits which lie back of a +neurosis. Fortunately, a knowledge of this fact furnishes the clue to +the re-education that brings recovery. + +A complex may be either conscious or unconscious, but as it usually +happens that either all or part of its elements are below the surface, +the word is oftenest used to mean those buried systems of the +subconscious mind that influence thought or behavior without +themselves being open to scrutiny. It is these buried complexes, +memory groups, gathered through the years of experience, that +determine action in uniform and easily prophesied directions. Every +individual has a definite complex about religion, about politics, +about patriotism, about business, and it is the sum of these buried +complexes which makes up his total personality. + +=Displacement.= Association or grouping is, then, an intrinsic power +of mind; but as all life seems to be built on opposites--light and +darkness, heat and cold, love and hate--so mind, which is capable of +association, is capable also of displacement or the splitting apart of +elements which belong together. There is such a thing as the simple +breaking up of complexes, when education or experience or neglect +separate ideas and emotions which had been previously welded together; +but displacement is another matter. Here there is still a path between +idea and emotion; they still belong to the same complex, but the +connection is lost sight of. The impulse or emotion attaches itself to +another substitute idea which is related to the first but which is +more acceptable to the personality. Sometimes the original idea is +forgotten; repressed, or dissociated into the subconscious, as in +anxiety neurosis; and sometimes it is merely shorn of its emotional +interest and remembered as an unrelated or insignificant idea, as in +compulsion neurosis. + +=Transference.= Another kind of displacement which seems hard to +believe possible until it is repeatedly encountered in intelligent +human beings is the process called transference, by which everybody at +some time or other acts toward the people he meets, not according to +rational standards but according to old unconscious attitudes toward +other people. Each of us carries, within, subconscious pictures of the +people who surrounded us when we were children; and now when we meet a +new person we are likely unconsciously to say to ourselves--not, "This +person has eyebrows like my mother, or a voice like my nurse," or, +"This person bosses me around as my father used to do," but, "This is +my mother, this is my nurse, this is my father." Whereupon we may +proceed to act toward that person very much as we did toward the +original person in childhood. + +Transference is subconsciously identifying one person with another and +behaving toward the one as if he were that other. Analysis has +discovered that many a man's hostile attitude toward the state or +religion or authority in general, is nothing more than this kind of +displacement of his childhood's attitude toward authority in the +person of his perhaps too-domineering father. Many a woman has married +a husband, not for what he was in himself, but because she +unconsciously identified him with her childish image of her father. + +Students of human nature have always recognized the kind of +displacement which transfers the sense of guilt from some major act or +attitude to a minor one which is more easily faced, just as _Lady +Macbeth_ felt that by washing her hands she might free herself from +her deeper stain. This is a frequent mechanism in the +psychoneuroses--not that neurotics are likely to have committed any +great crime, but that they feel subconsciously that some of their +wishes or thoughts are wicked. + +=The Phenomena of Dissociation.= When an idea or a complex, a +perception or a memory is either temporarily or permanently shoved out +of consciousness into the subconscious, it is said to be dissociated. +When we are asleep, the part of us that is usually conscious is +dissociated and the submerged part takes the stage. When we forget our +surroundings in concentration or absent-mindedness, a part of us is +dissociated and our friends say that we are "not all there," or as +popular slang has it, "Nobody home." When a mood or system of +complexes drives out all other moods, one becomes "a different +person." But if this normal dissociation is carried a step farther, we +may lose the power to put ourselves together again, and then we may +truly be said to be dissociated. Almost any part of us is subject to +this kind of apparent loss. In neurasthenia the happy, healthy +complexes which have hitherto dominated our lives may be split off and +left lying dormant in the subconscious; or the power of will or +concentration may seem to be gone. In hysteria we may seem to lose the +ability to see or feel or walk, or we may lose for the time all +recollection of certain past events, or of whole periods of our lives, +or of everything but one system of ideas which monopolizes the field +of attention. Sometimes great systems of memories, instincts, and +complexes are alternately shifted in and out of gear, leaving first +one kind of person on top and then another.[25] Stevenson's _Dr. +Jekyll_ and _Mr. Hyde_ is not so fantastic a character as he seems. +Any one who doubts the ability of the mind to split itself up into two +or more distinct personalities, entertaining totally different +conceptions of life, disliking each other, playing tricks on each +other, writing notes to each other, and carrying on a perpetual feud +as each tries to get the upper hand, should read Morton Prince's +"Dissociation of a Personality," a fascinating account of his famous +case, Miss Beauchamp. + +[Footnote 25: When a memory or system of memories is suddenly lost +from consciousness the person is said to be suffering from amnesia or +pathological loss of memory.] + +=Internal Warfare.= Conflict, often accentuated by shock or fatigue, +represses or drives down certain ideas, perceptions, wishes, memories, +or complexes into the subconscious, where they remain, sometimes +dormant and passive but often dynamic, emotional, carrying on an +over-excited, automatic activity, freed from the control of reason and +the modifying influence of other ideas, and able to cause almost any +kind of disturbance. So long as there is team-work between the +various parts of our personality we are able to act as a unit; but +just as soon as we break up into factions with no communication +between the warring camps, so soon do we become quite incapable of +coördination or adjustment, like a nation torn by civil war. Many of +the seemingly fantastic and bizarre mental phenomena of which a human +being is capable are the result of this kind of disintegration. + +However, nature has a remarkable power for righting herself, and it is +only under an accumulation of unfortunate circumstances that there +appears a neurosis, which is nothing more than a functioning of +certain parts of the personality with all the rest dissociated. We +shall later inquire more fully into the causes that lead up to such a +result and shall find that the mechanisms involved are these processes +of organization and disorganization by which mind is wont to group +together or separate the various elements within its borders. + + +SUMMARY + +Gathering up our impressions, we find a number of outstanding +qualities which we may summarize in the following way: + +The Subconscious is: + +_1 Vast yet Explorable_ + +The fraction that could accurately show the relation of the conscious +to the unconscious part of ourselves would have such a small numerator +and such a huge denominator that we might well wonder where +consciousness came in at all.[26] Some one has likened the +subconscious to the great far-reaching depths of the Mammoth Cave, and +consciousness to the tiny, flickering lamp which we carry to light our +way in the darkness. However, ever the subconscious mind is becoming +explorable, and it may be that science is giving the tiny lamp the +revealing power of a great searchlight. + +[Footnote 26: "The entire active life of the individual may be +represented by a fraction, the numerator of which is any particular +moment, the denominator is the rich inheritance of the +past."--Jelliffe: "The Technique of Psychoanalysis," _Psychoanalytic +Review,_ Vol. III, No. 2, p. 164.] + +_2 Ancient yet Modern_ + +The lowest layers of the subconscious, represented by the instincts, +are as old as life itself, with their lineage reaching back in direct +and unbroken line to the first living things on the ooze of the ocean +floor. The higher strata are more modern, full, and accurate records +of our own lifetime, beginning with our first cry and ending with +to-day's thoughts. + +_3 Primitive yet Refined_ + +The lowest level, representing the past of the race, is primitive like +a savage, and infantile, like a child; it is instinctive, unalterable, +and universal; it knows no restraint, no culture, and no prudence. The +higher level, the storehouse of individual experience, bears the +marks of acquired ideals, of cultivated refinement, and represents +among other things the precepts and prudence of civilized society. + +_4 Emotional yet Intellectual_ + +Our records of the past are not dead archives, but living +forces--persistent, urging, dynamic and emotional. They give meaning +to new experiences, color our judgments, shape our beliefs, determine +our interests, and, if wrongly handled, make their way into +consciousness as neurotic symptoms. + +However, the subconscious is not all emotion. It is a mind capable of +elaborate thought, able to calculate, to scheme, to answer doubts, to +solve problems, to fabricate the purposeful, fantastic allegories of +dreams and to create from mere knowledge the inspired works of genius. + +But the subconscious has one great limitation, it cannot reason +inductively. Given a premise, this mind can reason as unerringly as +the most skilful logician; that is, it can reason deductively, but it +cannot arrive at a general conclusion from a number of particular +facts. However, except for inductive reasoning and awareness, the +subconscious seems to possess all the attributes of conscious mind and +is in fact an intellectual force to be reckoned with. + +_5 Organized yet Disorganizable_ + +The subconscious mind is a highly organized institution, but like all +such institutions it is liable to disorganization when rent by +internal dissension. Ordinarily it keeps its ideas and emotions, its +complexes and moods in fairly accurate order, but when upset by +emotional warfare, it gets its records confused and falls into a +chaotic state which makes regular business impossible. + +_6 Masterful yet Obedient_ + +The subconscious, which is master of the body, is in normal life the +servant of consciousness. One of its outstanding qualities is +suggestibility. Since it cannot reason from particulars to a general +conclusion it takes any statement given it by consciousness, believes +it implicitly and acts accordingly. + +The pilot wheel of the ship is, after all, the conscious mind, +insignificant in size when compared with the great mass of the vessel, +but all-powerful in its ability to direct the course of the voyage. + +Nervous persons are people who are too much under the sway of the +subconscious; so, too, are some geniuses, who narrowly escape a +neurosis by finding a more useful outlet for their subconscious +energies. While the poet, the inventor, and the neurotic are likely to +be too largely controlled by the subconscious, the average man is to a +greater extent ruled by the conscious mind; and the highest type of +genius is the man whose conscious and subconscious minds work together +in perfect harmony, each up to its full power. + +If, as many believe, the next great strides of science are to be in +this direction, it may pay some of us to be pioneers in learning how +to make use of these undeveloped riches of memory, organization, and +surplus energy. The subconscious, which can on occasion behave like a +very devil within us, is, when rightly used, our greatest asset, the +source of powers whose appearance in the occasional individual has +been considered almost superhuman, but which prove to be +characteristically human, the common inheritance of the race of man. + + + + +CHAPTER VI + +_In which we learn why it pays to be cheerful_ + +BODY AND MIND + +THE MISSING LINK + + +=Ancient Knowledge.= People have always known that mind in some +strange way carries its moods over into the body. The writer of the +Book of Proverbs tells us, from that far-off day, that "A merry heart +doeth good like a medicine, but a broken spirit drieth the bones." +Jesus in His healing ministry always emphasized the place of faith in +the cure of the body. "Thy faith hath made thee whole," is a frequent +word on His lips, and ever since His day people have been +rediscovering the truth that faith, even in the absence of a worthy +object, does often make whole. Faith in the doctor, the medicine, the +charm, the mineral waters, the shrine, and in the good God, has +brought health to many thousands of sufferers. People have always +reckoned on this bodily result from a mental state. They have +intuitively known better than to tell a sick person that he is looking +worse, but they have not always known why. They have known that a fit +of anger is apt to bring on a headache, but they have not stopped to +look for the reason, or if they have, they have often gotten +themselves into a tangle. This is because there has always been, until +recently, a missing link. Now the link has been found. After the last +chapter, it will not be hard to understand that this connecting link, +this go-between of body and mind, is nothing else than the +subconscious mind. When we remember that it has the double power of +knowing our thoughts and of controlling our bodies, it is not hard to +see how an idea can translate itself into a pain, nor to realize with +new vividness the truth of the statement that healthy mental states +make for health, and unhealthy mental states for illness. + +=Suggestion and Emotion.= There are still many gaps in our knowledge +of the ways of the subconscious, but investigation has thrown a good +deal of light on the problem. Two of the principles already discussed +are sufficient to explain most of the phenomena. These are, first, +that the subconscious is amenable to control by suggestion, and +secondly, that it is greatly influenced by emotion. Tracing back the +principles behind any example of the power of mind over body, one +finds at the root of the matter either a suggestion or an emotion, or +both. If, then, the stimulating and depressing effects of mental +states are to be understood, the first Step must be a fuller +understanding of the laws governing suggestion and emotion. + + +THE CONTAGION OF IDEAS + +One of the most important points about the subconscious mind is its +openness to suggestion. It likes to believe what it is told and to act +accordingly. The conscious mind, too,--proud seat of reason though it +may be,--shares this habit of accepting ideas without demanding too +much proof of their truth. Even at his best, man is extremely +susceptible to the contagion of ideas. Most of us are even less immune +to this mental contagion than we are to colds or influenza; for ideas +are catching. They are such subtle, insinuating things that they creep +into our minds without our knowing it at all; and once there, they are +as powerful as most germs. + +Let a person faint in a crowded room, and a good per cent. of the +women present will begin to fan themselves. The room has suddenly +become insufferably close. After we have read half a hundred times +that Ivory soap floats, a fair proportion of the population is likely +to be seized with desire for a soap that floats,--not because they +have any good reason for doing so, but simply because the suggestion +has "taken." As for the harbingers of spring, they are neither the +birds nor the wild flowers, but the blooming windows of the +milliners, which successfully suggest in wintry February that summer +is coming, and that felt and fur are out of season. It is evident that +all advertising is suggestion. + +The training of children, also, if it is done in the right way, is +largely a matter of suggestion. The little child who falls down and +bumps his head is very likely to cry if met with a sympathetic show of +concern, while the same child will often take his mishaps as a joke if +his elders meet them with a laugh or a diverting remark. Unlucky is +the child whose mother does not know, either consciously or +intuitively, that example and contagion are more powerful--and more +pleasant--than command and prohibition. + +=Everything Suggestive.= Human beings are constantly communicating, +one to another. Sometimes they "get over" an idea by means of words, +but often they do it in more subtle ways,--by the elevation of an +eyelid, the gesture of a hand, composure of manner in a crisis, or a +laugh in a delicate situation. A suggestion is merely an idea passed +from one person to another, an idea that is accepted with conviction +and acted upon, even though there may be no logic, no reason, no proof +of its truth. It is an influence that takes hold of the mind and works +itself out to fulfilment, quite apart from its worth or +reasonableness. Of course, logical persuasion and argument have their +place in the communication of ideas; an idea may be conveyed by other +ways than suggestion. But while suggestion is not everything, it is +equally true that there is suggestion in everything. The doctor may +give a patient a very rational explanation of his case, but the +doubtful shake of the head or the encouraging look of his eye is quite +likely to color the patient's general impression. The eyes of our +subconscious are always open, and they are constantly getting +impressions, subtle suggestions that are implied rather than +expressed. + +=Abnormal Suggestibility.= While everybody is suggestible, nervous +people are abnormally so. It may be, as McDougall suggests, that they +have so large an amount of submission or negative self-feeling in +their make-up that they believe anything, just because some one else +says it is true. Sometimes it is lack of knowledge that makes us +gullible, and at other times the cause of our suggestibility is +failure to use the knowledge that we have. Sometimes our ideas are +locked away in air-tight compartments with no interaction between +them. The psychologists tell us that suggestion is greatly favored by +a narrowing of the attention, a "contraction of the field of +consciousness," a dissociation of other ideas through concentration. +This all simply means that we forget to let our common sense bring to +bear counter ideas that might challenge a false one; or that worry--a +veritable "spasm of the attention"--has fixed upon an idea to the +exclusion of all others; or that through fatigue or the dissociation +of sleep or hypnosis or hysteria, our reasoning powers have been +locked out and for the time being are unable to act. + +It was through experiments on hypnotized subjects that scientists +first learned of the suggestibility of the subconscious mind. In +hypnosis a person can be made to believe almost anything and to do +almost anything compatible with the safety and the moral sense of the +individual. The instinct of self-preservation will not allow the most +deeply hypnotized person to do anything dangerous to himself; and the +moral complexes, laid in the subconscious, never permit a person to +perform in earnest an act of which the waking moral sense would +disapprove. Within these limits, a person in the dissociated hypnotic +state can be made to accept almost any suggestion. We found in the +last chapter how open to suggestion is a person in normal sleep. Of +the dissociation of hysteria we shall have occasion to speak in later +chapters. Although all these special states heighten suggestibility, +we must not forget how susceptible each of us is in his normal waking +state. + +=Living Its Faith.= All this gathers meaning only when we realize that +ideas are dynamic. They always tend to work themselves out to +fulfilment. The subconscious no sooner gets a conviction than it tries +to act it out. Of course it can succeed only up to a certain limit. +If it believes the stomach to have cancer, it cannot make cancer, but +it can make the stomach misbehave. One of my patients, on hearing of a +case of brain-tumor immediately imagined this to be her trouble, and +developed a pain in her head. She could not manufacture a tumor, but +she could manufacture what she believed to be the symptoms. + +There was another patient who was supposed to have brain-tumor. This +young woman seemed to have lost almost entirely the power to keep her +equilibrium in walking. Her center of gravity was never over her feet, +but away out in space, so that she was continually banging from one +side of the room to the other, only saving herself from injury by +catching at the wall or the furniture with her hands. Several +physicians who had been interested in the case had found the symptoms +strongly suggestive of brain-tumor. There were, however, certain +unmistakable earmarks of hysteria, such as childlike bland +indifference to the awkwardness of the gait which was a grotesque +caricature of several brain and spinal-cord diseases, with no accurate +picture of any single one. This was evidently a case, not of actual +loss of power but a dissociation of the memory-picture of walking. The +patient was a trained nurse and knew in a general way the symptoms of +brain-tumor. When the suggestion of brain-tumor had fixed itself in +her mind she was able subconsciously to manufacture what she believed +to be the symptoms of that disease. + +By injecting a keen sense of disapprobation and skepticism into the +hitherto placidly accepted state of disability, by flashing a mirror +on the physical and moral attitudes which she was assuming, I was able +to rob the pathological complex of its (altogether unconscious) +pleasurable feeling-tone, and to restore to its former strength and +poise a personality of exceptional native worth and beauty. After a +few weeks at my house she was able to walk like a normal person and +went back to her work, for good. + +We have already learned enough about the inner self to see in a faint +way how it works out its ideas. Since the subconscious mind runs the +bodily machinery, since it regulates digestion, the building up of +tissue, circulation, respiration, glandular secretion, muscular tonus, +and every other process pertaining to nutrition and growth, it is not +difficult to see how an idea about any of these matters can work +itself out into a fact. A thought can furnish the mental machinery +needed to fulfil the thought. Some one catches the suggestion: +"Concentration is hard on the brain. It soon brings on brain-fag and +headache." Not knowing facts to the contrary, the suggestible mind +accepts the proposition. Then one day, after a little concentration, +the idea begins to work. Whereupon the autonomic nervous system +tightens up the blood-vessels that regulate the local blood supply, +too much blood stays in the head, and lo, it aches! The next time, the +suggestion comes with greater force, and soon the habit is +formed,--all the result of an idea. It is a good thing to remember +that constant thought about any part of the body never fails to send +an over-supply of blood to that part; of course that means congestion +and pain. + +=Hands Off!= By sending messages directly to an organ through the +nerve-centers or by changing circulation, the subconscious director of +our bodies can make any part of us misbehave in a number of ways. All +it needs is a suggestion of an interfering thought about an organ. As +we have insisted before, the subconscious cannot stand interference. +Sadler well says: "Man can live at the equator or exist at the poles. +He can eat almost anything and everything, but he cannot long stand +self-contemplation. The human mind can accomplish wonders in the way +of work, but it is soon wrecked when directed into the channels of +worry."[27] In other words, hands off!--or rather, minds off! Don't +get ideas that make you think about your body. The surest way to +disarrange any function is to think about it. It is a stout heart that +will not change its beat with a frequent finger on the pulse, and a +hearty stomach that will not "act up" under attention. "Judicious +neglect" is a good motto for most occasions. Take no anxious thought +if you would be well. Know enough about your body to counteract false +suggestions; fulfil the common-sense laws of hygiene,--eight hours in +bed, plenty of exercise and fresh air, and three square meals a day. +Then forget all about it. "A mental representation is already a +sensation,"[28] and we have enough legitimate sensations without +manufacturing others. + +[Footnote 27: Sadler: _Physiology of Faith and Fear_.] + +[Footnote 28: DuBois: _Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders_.] + +=From Real Life.= Startling indeed are the tricks that we can play on +ourselves by disregarding these laws. A patient who was unnecessarily +concerned about his stomach once came to me in great alarm, exhibiting +a distinct, well-defined swelling about the size of a match-box in the +region of his stomach. I looked at it, laughed, and told him to forget +it. Whereupon it promptly disappeared. The first segment of the rectus +muscle had tied itself up into a knot, under the stimulus of anxious +attention. + +Another patient appeared at my door one day saying, "Look here!" +Examination showed that her abdomen was swollen to the size of more +than a six-months pregnancy. As it happened, this woman had a friend +who a short time before had developed a pseudo, or hysterical +pregnancy which continued for several months. My patient, accepting +the suggestion, was prepared to imitate her. I gave her a punch or +two and told her to go and dress for luncheon. In the afternoon she +had returned to her normal size. + +Another woman, suffering from chronic constipation, was firmly +convinced that her bowels could not move without a cathartic, which I +refused to give. However, I did give her some strychnine pills, +carefully explaining that they were not for her intestines and that +they would have no effect there. She did not believe me, and promptly +began to have an evacuation every day. It seems that sometimes two +wrong ideas are equal to a right one. + +If doctors fully realized the power of suggestion, they would be more +careful than they sometimes are about suggesting symptoms by the +questions they ask their patients. + +A patient of mine with locomotor-ataxia suffered from the usual train +of symptoms incident to that disease. It turned out, however, that +many of the symptoms had been suggested by the questions of former +physicians who had asked him whether he had certain symptoms and +certain disabilities. The patient had answered in the negative and +then promptly developed the suggested symptoms. When I told him what +had happened, these false symptoms disappeared leaving only those +which had a real physical foundation. + +Another patient, a young girl, complained of a definite localized +pain in her arm, and told me that she was suffering from angina +pectoris. As we do not expect to find this disease in a young person, +I asked her where she got such an idea. "Dr. ---- told me so last +May." "Did you feel the pain in this same place before that time?" I +asked. She thought a minute and then answered: "Why no, I had a pain +around my heart but I did not notice it in my arm until after that +consultation." The wise physician lets his patients describe their own +symptoms without suggesting others by the implication of his +questions. + +=Autosuggestion.= Of course we must remember that an idea cannot +always work itself out immediately. Conditions are not always ripe. It +often lies fallow a long time, buried in the subconscious, only to +come up again as an autosuggestion, a suggestion from the self to the +self. If some one tells us that nervous insomnia is disastrous, and we +believe it, we shall probably store up the idea until the next time +that chance conditions keep us awake. Then the autosuggestion "bobs +up," common sense is side-tracked, we toss and worry--and of course +stay awake. An autosuggestion often repeated becomes the strongest of +suggestions, successfully opposing most outside ideas that would +counteract it,--reason enough for seeing to it that our +autosuggestions are of the healthful variety. + +At the base of every psycho-neurosis is an unhealthful suggestion. +This is never the ultimate cause. There are other forces at work. But +the suggestion is the material out of which those other forces weave +the neurosis. Suggestibility is one of the earmarks of nervousness. A +sensible and sturdy spirit, stable enough to maintain its equilibrium, +is a fairly good antidote to attack. "As a man thinketh in his heart, +so is he." + + +WHY FEELINGS COUNT + +=The Emotions Again.= It seems impossible to discuss any psychological +principle without finally coming back to the subject of emotions. It +truly seems that all roads lead to the instincts and to the emotions +which drive them. And so, as we follow the trail of suggestion, we +suddenly turn a corner and find ourselves back at our +starting-point--the emotional life. Like all other ideas, suggestions +get tied up with emotions to form complexes, of which the +driving-power is the emotion. + +If we look into our emotional life, we find, besides the true +emotions, with which we have become familiar in Chapter III, a great +number of feelings or feeling-tones which color either pleasurably or +painfully our emotions and our ideas. On the one hand there are +pleasure, joy, exaltation, courage, cheer, confidence, satisfaction; +and on the other, pain, sorrow, depression, apprehension, gloom, +distrust, and dissatisfaction. Every complex which is laid away in +our subconscious is tinted, either slightly or intensely, with its +specific feeling-tone. + +=Emotions--Tonic and Poisonous.= All this is most important because of +one vital fact; joyful emotions invigorate, and sorrowful emotions +depress; pleasurable emotions stimulate, and painful emotions burden; +satisfying emotions revitalize, and unsatisfying emotions sap the +strength. In other words, our bodies are made for courage, confidence, +and cheer. Any other atmosphere puts them out of their element, +handicapped by abnormal conditions for which they were never +fashioned. We were written in a major key, and when we try to change +over into minor tones we get sadly out of tune. + +There is another factor; painful emotions make us fall to pieces, +while pleasant emotions bind us together. We can see why this is so +when we remember that powerful emotions like fear and anger tend to +dissociate all but themselves, to split up the mind into separate +parts and to force out of consciousness everything but their own +impulse. Morton Prince in his elaborate studies of the cases of +multiple personality, Miss Beauchamp and B.C.A., found repeatedly that +he had only to hypnotize the patient and replace painful, depressing +complexes by healthy, happy ones to change her from a weak, worn-out +person, complaining of fatigue, insomnia, and innumerable aches and +pains, into a vigorous woman, for the time being completely well. On +this point he says: + + Exalting emotions have an intense synthesizing effect, while + depressing emotions have a disintegrating effect. With the + inrushing of depressive memories or ideas ... there is suddenly + developed a condition of fatigue, ill-being and disintegration, + followed after waking by a return or accentuation of all the + neurasthenic symptoms. If on the other hand, exalting ideas and + memories are introduced and brought into the limelight of + attention, there is almost a magical reversal of processes. The + patient feels strong and energetic, the neurasthenic symptoms + disappear and he exhibits a capacity for sustained effort. He + becomes re-vitalized, so to speak.[29] + +[Footnote 29: Prince: _Psycho-therapeutics_, Chap. I.] + +In cases like this the needed strength and energy are not lost; they +are merely side-tracked, but the person feels as weak as though he +were physically ill. + + +BODILY RESPONSE TO EMOTIONAL STATES + +=Secretions.= Let us look more carefully into some of the +physiological processes involved in emotional changes. Among the most +apparent of bodily responses are the various external secretions. +Tears, the secretion of the lachrymal glands in response to an +emotion, are too common a phenomenon to arouse comment. It is common +knowledge that clammy hands and a dry mouth betray emotion. Every +nursing mother knows that she dares not become too disturbed lest her +milk should dry up or change in character. Most people have +experienced an increase in urine in times of excitement; recently +physiologists have discovered the presence of sugar in the urine of +students at the time of athletic contests and difficult +examinations.[30] We have seen what an important role the various +internal secretions, such as the adrenal and thyroid secretions play +in fitting the body for flight and combat, and how large a part fear +and anger have in their production. Constant over-production of these +secretions through chronic states of worry is responsible for many a +distressing symptom. + +[Footnote 30: Cannon.] + +Most graphic evidence of the disturbance of secretions by emotion is +found in the response of the salivary and gastric glands to painful or +pleasurable thinking. As these are the secretions which play the +largest part in the digestive processes, they lead us naturally to our +next heading. + +=Digestion.= Everybody knows that appetizing food makes the mouth +water, but not everybody realizes that it makes the stomach water +also. Nor do we often realize the vital place that this watering has +in taking care of our food. "Well begun is half-done," is literally +true of digestion. A good flow of saliva brings the food into contact +with the taste-buds in the tongue. Taste sends messages to the +nerve-centers in the medulla oblongata; these centers in turn flash +signals to the stomach glands, which immediately "get busy" preparing +the all-important gastric juice. It takes about five minutes for this +juice to be made ready, and so it happens that in five minutes after +the first taste, or even in some cases after the first smell, the +stomach is pouring forth its "appetite juice" which determines all the +rest of the digestive process, in intestines as well as in stomach. +Experiments on dogs and cats by Pawlow, Cannon, and others have shown +what fear and anger and even mildly unpleasant emotions do to the +whole digestive process. Cannon tells of a dog who produced 66.7 cubic +centimeters of pure gastric juice in the twenty minutes following five +minutes of sham feeding (feeding in which food is swallowed and then +dropped out of an opening in the esophagus into a bucket instead of +into the stomach). Although there was no food in the stomach, the +juice was produced by the enjoyment of the taste and the thought of +it. On another day, after this dog had been infuriated by a cat, and +then pacified, the sham feeding was given again. This time, although +the dog ate eagerly, he produced only 9 cubic centimeters of gastric +juice, and this rich in mucus. Evidently a good appetite and +attractively served food are not more important than a cheerful mind. +Spicy table talk, well mixed with laughter, is better than all the +digestive tablets in the world. What is true of stomach secretions is +equally true of stomach contractions. "The pleasurable taking of food" +is a necessity if the required contractions of stomach and intestines +are to go forward on schedule time. A little extra dose of adrenalin +from a mild case of depression or worry is enough to stop all +movements for many minutes. What a revelation on many a case of +nervous dyspepsia! The person who dubbed it "Emotional Dyspepsia" had +facts on his side. + +=Circulation.= It is not the heart only that pumps the blood through +the body. The tiny muscles of the smallest blood-vessels, by their +elasticity are of the greatest importance in maintaining an even flow, +and this is especially influenced by fear and depression. Blushing, +pallor, cold hands and feet, are circulatory disturbances based +largely on emotions. Better than a hot-water bottle or electric pads +are courage and optimism. A patient of mine laughingly tells of an +incident which she says happened a number of years ago, but which I +have forgotten. She says that she asked me one night as she carried +her hot-water bottle to bed, "Doctor, what makes cold feet?" and that +I lightly answered "Cowardice!" Whereupon she threw away her beloved +water-bag and has never needed it since. + +There is a disturbance of the circulation which results in very +marked swelling and redness of the affected part. This is known as +angio-neurotic edema, or nervous swelling. I do not have to go farther +than my own person for an example of this phenomenon. When I was a +young woman I taught school and went home every day for luncheon. One +day at luncheon, some one of the family criticized me severely. I went +back to school very angry. Before I entered the school-room, the +principal handed me some books which she had ordered for me. They were +not at all the books I wanted, and that upset me still more. As I went +into the schoolroom, I found that my face was swollen until my eyes +were almost shut; it was a bright red and covered with purplish +blotches. My fingers were swollen so that I could not bend the joints +in the slightest degree. It was a day or two before the disturbance +disappeared, and the whole of it was the result of anger. + +We hear much to-day about high blood pressure. They say that a man is +as old as his arteries, and now it is known that the health of the +arteries depends largely on blood pressure. Since this is a matter +that can be definitely measured at any minute, we have an easy way of +noting the remarkable effect of shifting emotions. Sadler tells of an +ex-convict with a blood pressure of 190 millimeters. It seems that he +was worrying over possible rearrest. On being reassured on this +point, his blood pressure began to drop within a few minutes, falling +20 mm. in three hours, and 35 mm. by the following day. + +=Muscular Tone.= A force that affects circulation, blood pressure, +respiration, nutrition of cells, secretion, and digestion, can hardly +fail to have a marked effect on the tone of the muscles, internal as +well as external. When we remember that heart, stomach, and intestines +are made of muscular tissue, to say nothing of the skeletal muscles, +we begin to realize how important is muscular tone for bodily health. +Over and over again have I demonstrated that a courageous mind is the +best tonic. Perhaps an example from my "flat-footed" patients will be +to the point. One woman, the young mother of a family, came to me for +a nervous trouble. Besides this, she had suffered for seven or eight +years from severe pains in her feet and had been compelled to wear +specially made shoes prescribed by a Chicago orthopedist. The shoes, +however, did not seem to lessen the pain. After an ordinary day's +occupation, she could not even walk across the floor at dinner-time. A +walk of two blocks would incapacitate her for many days. She was +convinced that her feet could never be cured and came to me only on +account of nervous trouble. On the day of her arrival she flung +herself down on the couch, saying that she would like to go away from +everybody, where the children would never bother her again. She was +sure nobody loved her and she wanted to die. Within three weeks, in +ordinary shoes, this woman tramped nine miles up Mount Wilson and the +next day tramped down again. Her attitude had changed from that of +irritable fretfulness to one of buoyant joy, and with the moral change +had come new strength in the muscles. The death of her husband has +since made it necessary for her to support the family, and she is now +on her feet from eight to fourteen hours a day, a constant source of +inspiration to all about her, and no more weary than the average +person. + +Flabbiness in the muscles often causes this trouble with the feet. +"The arches of the foot are maintained by ligaments between the bones, +supported by muscle tendons which prevent undue stretching of the +ligaments and are a protection against flat-foot."[31] Muscle tissue +has an abundant blood supply, while ligaments have very little and +soon lose their resiliency if unsupported. Any lack of tone in the +calf-muscles throws the weight on the less resistant ligaments and on +the cartilages placed as cushions between the bony structures of the +arch. This is what causes the pain.[32] + +[Footnote 31: Grey's Anatomy--"The Articulations."] + +[Footnote 32: Actual loss of the arch by downward displacement of the +bones cannot be overcome by restoring muscle-tone. The majority of +so-called cases of flatfoot are, however, in the stage amenable to +psychic measures.] + +Flat-footedness is only one result of weak muscles. Eye-strain is +another; ptosis, or falling of the organs, is another. In a majority +of cases the best treatment for any of these troubles is an +understanding attempt to go to the root of the matter by bracing up +the whole mental tone. The most scientific oculists do not try to +correct eye trouble due to muscular insufficiency by any special +prisms or glasses. They know that the eyes will right themselves when +the general health and the general spirits improve. I have found by +repeated experience with nervous patients that it takes only a short +time for people who have been unable to read for months or years to +regain their old faculty. So remarkable is the power of mind. + + +SUMMARY + +We have found that the gap between the body and the mind is not so +wide as it seems, and that it is bridged by the subconscious mind, +which is at once the master of the body and the servant of +consciousness. In recording the physical effects of suggestion and +emotion, we have not taken time to describe the galvanometers, the +weighing-machines and all the other apparatus used in the various +laboratory tests; but enough has been said to show that when doctors +and psychologists speak of the effect of mind on body, they are +dealing with definite facts and with laws capable of scientific +proof. + +We have emphasized the fact that downcast and fearful moods have an +immediate effect on the body; but after all, most people know this +already. What they do not know is the real cause of the mood. When a +nervous person finds out why he worries, he is well on the way toward +recovery. An understanding of the cause is among the most vital +discoveries of modern science. + +The discussion, so far, has merely prepared us to plunge into the +heart of the question: What is it that in the last analysis makes a +person nervous, and how may he find his way out? This question the +next two chapters will try to answer. + + + + +CHAPTER VII + +_In which we go to the root of the matter_ + +THE REAL TROUBLE + + +PIONEERS + +=Following the Gleam.= Kipling's Elephant-child with the "'satiable +curiosity" finally asked a question which seemed simple enough but +which sent him on a long journey into unknown parts. In the same way +man's modest and simple question, "What makes people nervous?" has +sent him far-adventuring to find the answer. For centuries he has +followed false trails, ending in blind alleys, and only lately does he +seem to have found the road that shall lead him to his journey's end. + +We may be thankful that we are following a band of pioneers whose +fearless courage and passion for truth would not let them turn back +even when the trail led through fields hitherto forbidden. The leader +of this band of pioneers was a young doctor named Freud. + + +THE SEARCH FOR TRUTH + +=Early Beginnings.= In 1882, when Freud was the assistant to Dr. +Breuer of Vienna, there was brought to them for treatment a young +woman afflicted with various hysterical pains and paralyses. This +young woman's case marked an epoch in medical history; for out of the +effort to cure her came some surprising discoveries of great +significance to the open-minded young student. + +It was found that each of this girl's symptoms was related to some +forgotten experience, and that in every case the forgetting seemed to +be the result of the painfulness of the experience. In other words, +the symptoms were not visitations from without, but expressions from +within; they were a part of the mental life of the patient; they had a +history and a meaning, and the meaning seemed in some way to be +connected with the patient's previous attitude of mind which made the +experience too painful to be tolerated in consciousness. These +previous ideas were largely subconscious and had been acquired during +early childhood. When by means of hypnosis a great mass of forgotten +material was brought to the surface and later made plain to her +consciousness, the symptoms disappeared as if by magic. + +=A Startling Discovery.= For a time Breuer and Freud worked together, +finding that their investigations with other patients served to +corroborate their former conclusions. When it became apparent that in +every case the painful experience bore some relation to the love-life +of the patient, both doctors were startled. Along with most of the +rest of the world, they had been taught to look askance at the +reproductive instinct and to shrink from realizing the vital place +which sex holds in human life. + +Breuer dropped the work, and after an interval Freud went on alone. He +was resolved to know the truth, and to tell what he saw. When he +reported to the world that out of all his hundreds of patients, he had +been unable, after the most careful analysis, to find one whose +illness did not grow from some lack of adjustment of the sex-life, he +was met by a storm of protest from all quarters. No amount of evidence +seemed to make any difference. People were determined that no such +libel should be heaped on human nature. Sex-urge was not respectable +and nervous people were to be respected. + +Despite public disapproval, the scorn of other scientists, and the +resistance of his own inner prejudices, Freud kept on. He was forced +to acknowledge the validity of the facts which invariably presented +themselves to view. Like Luther under equal duress, he cried: "Here I +stand. I can do no other." + +=Freudian Principles.= Gradually, as he worked, he gathered together a +number of outstanding facts about man's mental life and about the +psycho-neuroses. These facts he formulated into certain principles, +which may be summed up in the following way. + +1 There is no _chance_ in mental life; every mental phenomenon--hence +every nervous phenomenon--has a cause and meaning. + +2 Infantile mental life is of tremendous importance in the direction +of adult processes. + +3 Much of what is called forgetting is rather a repression into the +subconscious, of impulses which were painful to the personality as a +whole. + +4 Mental processes are dynamic, insisting on discharge, either in +reality or in phantasy. + +5 An emotion may become detached from the idea to which it belongs and +be displaced on other ideas. + +6 Sex-interests dominate much of the mental life where their influence +is unrecognized. The disturbance in a psycho-neurosis is always in +this domain of sex-life. "In a normal sexual life, no neurosis." If a +shock is the precipitating cause of the trouble, it is only because +the ground was already prepared by the sex-disturbance. + +Freud was perhaps unfortunate in his choice of the word "sex," which +has so many evil connotations; but as he found no other word to cover +the field, he chose the old one and stretched its meaning to include +all the psychic and physical phenomena which spring directly and +indirectly from the great processes of reproduction and parental care, +and which ultimately include all and more than our word "love."[33] + +[Footnote 33: Freud and his followers have always said that they saw +no theoretical reason why any other repressed instinct should not form +the basis of a neurosis, but that, as a matter of fact, they never had +found this to be the case, probably because no other instinct comes +into such bitter and persistent conflict with the dictates of society. +Now, however, the Great War seems to have changed conditions. Under +the strain and danger of life at the front there has developed a kind +of nervous breakdown called shellshock or war-neurosis, which seems in +some cases to be based not on the repression of the instinct of +race-preservation but on the unusual necessity for repression of the +instinct of self-preservation. Army surgeons report that wounded men +almost never suffer from shell-shock. The wound is enough to secure +the unconsciously desired removal to the rear. But in the absence of +wounds, a desire for safety may at the same time be so intense and so +severely repressed that it seizes upon the neurosis as the only +possible means of escape from the unbearable situation. In time of +peace, however, the instinct of reproduction seems to be the only +impulse which is severely enough repressed to be responsible for a +nervous breakdown.] + +=Later Developments.= Little by little, the scientific world came to +see that this wild theorizer had facts on his side; that not only had +he formulated a theory, but he had discovered a cure, and that he was +able to free people from obsessions, fears, and physical symptoms +before which other methods were powerless. One by one the open-minded +men of science were converted by the overpowering logic of the +evidence, until to-day we find not only a "Freudian school," counting +among its members many of the eminent scientists of the day, but we +find in medical schools and universities courses based on Freudian +principles, with text-books by acknowledged authorities in medicine +and psychology. We find magazines devoted entirely to psycho-analytic +subjects,[34] besides articles in medical journals and even numerous +articles in popular magazines. Not only is the treatment of nervous +disorders revolutionized by these principles but floods of light are +thrown on such widely different fields of study as ancient myths and +folk lore, the theory of wit, methods of child training, and the +little slips of the tongue and everyday "breaks" that have until +recently been considered the meaningless results of chance. + +[Footnote 34: _The Psychoanalytic Review_ and the _International +Journal of Psychoanalysis._] + +=A Searching Question.= We find, then, that when we ask, "What makes +people nervous?" we are really asking: "What is man like, inside and +out, up and down? What makes him think, feel, and act as he does every +hour of every day?" We are asking for the source of human motives, the +science of human behavior, the charting of the human mind. It is hard +to-day to understand how so much reproach and ridicule could have been +aroused by the statement that the ultimate cause of nervousness is a +disturbance of the sex-life. There has already been a change in the +public attitude toward things sexual. + +Training-courses for mothers and teachers, elementary teaching in the +schools, lectures and magazine articles have done much to show the +fallacy of our old hypersensitive attitude. Since the war, some of us +know, too, with what success the army has used the Freudian principles +in treating war-neurosis, which was mistakenly called shell-shock by +the first observers. We know, too, more about the constitution of +man's mind than the public knew ten years ago. When we remember the +insistent character of the instincts and the repressive method used by +society in restraining the most obstreperous impulse, when we remember +the pain of such conflict and the depressing physical effects of +painful emotions, we cannot wonder that this most sharply repressed +instinct should cause mental and physical trouble. + +=What about Sublimation?= On the other hand, it has been stated in +Chapter IV that although this universal urge cannot be repressed, it +can be sublimated or diverted to useful ends which bring happiness, +not disaster, to the individual. We have a right, then, to ask why +this happy issue is not always attained, why sublimation ever fails. +If a psycho-neurosis is caused by a failure of an insistent instinct +to find adequate expression, by a blocking of the libido or the +love-force, what are the conditions which bring about this blocking? +The sex-instinct of every respectable person is subject to restraint. +Some people are able to adjust themselves; why not all? The question, +"What makes people nervous?" then turns out to mean: What keeps people +from a satisfactory outlet for their love-instincts? What is it that +holds them back from satisfaction in direct expression, and prevents +indirect outlet in sublimation? Whatever does this must be the real +cause of "nerves." + + +THE CAUSES OF "NERVES" + +=Plural, not Singular.= The first thing to learn about the cause is +that it is not a cause at all, but several causes. We are so well made +that it takes a combination of circumstances to upset our equilibrium. +In other words, a neurosis must be "over-determined." Heredity, faulty +education, emotional shock, physical fatigue, have each at various +times been blamed for a breakdown. As a matter of fact, it seems to +take a number of ingredients to make a neurosis,--a little unstable +inheritance plus a considerable amount of faulty upbringing, plus a +later series of emotional experiences bearing just the right +relationship to the earlier factors. Heredity, childhood reactions, +and later experiences, are the three legs on which a neurosis usually +stands. An occasional breakdown seems to stand on the single leg of +childhood experiences but in the majority of cases each of the three +factors contributes its quota to the final disaster. + +=Born or Made?= It used to be thought that neurotics, like poets, were +born, not made. Heredity was considered wholly responsible, and there +seemed very little to do about it. But to-day the emphasis on heredity +is steadily giving way to stress on early environment. There are, no +doubt, such factors as a certain innate sensitiveness, a natural +suggestibility, an intensity of emotion, a little tendency to nervous +instability, which predispose a person to nerves, but unless the +inborn tendency is reinforced by the reactions and training of early +childhood, it is likely to die a natural death. + + +CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCES + +=Early Reactions.= Freud found that a neurotic is made before he is +six years old. When by repeated explorations into the minds of his +patients, he made this important discovery, he at first believed that +the disturbing factor was always some single emotional experience or +shock in childhood,--usually of a sexual nature. But Freud and later +investigators have since found that the trouble is not so often a +single experience as a long series of exaggerated emotional reactions, +a too intense emotional life, a precocity in feeling tending toward +fixation of childhood habits, which are thus carried over into adult +life. + +=Fixation of Habits.= Fixation is the word that expresses all +this,--fixation of childish habits. A neurotic is a person who made +such strong habits in childhood that he cannot abandon them in +maturity. He is too much ruled by the past. His unconscious emotional +thought-habits are the complexes which were made in childhood and +therefore lack the power of adaptation to mature life. + +We saw in Chapter IV that Nature takes great pains to develop in the +child the psychic and physical trends which he will need later on in +his mature love-life, and that this training is accomplished in a +number of well-defined periods which lead from one to the other. If, +however, the child reacts too intensely, lingers too long in any one +of these phases, he lays for himself action lines of least resistance +which he may never leave or to which he may return during the strain +and stress of adult life. + +In either case, the neurotic is a grown-up child. He may be a very +learned, very charming person, but he is nevertheless dragging behind +him a part of his childhood which he should have outgrown long ago. +Part of him is suffering from an arrest of development,--not a leg or +an arm but an impulse. + +=Precocious Emotions.= The habits which tend to become fixed too soon +seem to be of four kinds; the habit of loving, the habit of rebelling, +the habit of repressing normal instincts, and the habit of dreaming. +In each case it is the excess of feeling which causes the +trouble,--too much love, too much hate, too much disgust, or too much +pleasure in imagination. Exaggeration is always a danger-signal. An +overdeveloped child is likely to be an underdeveloped man. Especially +in the emotions is precocity to be deplored. A premature alphabet or +multiplication table is not nearly so serious as premature intensity +of feeling, nor so likely to lead later to trouble. Of course fixation +in these emotional habits does not always lead to a serious breakdown. +If the fixation is not too extreme, and if later events do not happen +to accentuate the trouble, the arrest of development may merely show +itself in certain weaknesses of character or in isolated symptoms +without developing a real neurosis. + +Let us examine each of these arrested habits and the excess emotion +which sets the mold before it is ready for maturity. + +=Too Much Self-Love.= In the chapter on the reproductive instinct, we +found that the natural way to learn to love is by successively loving +oneself, one's parents and family, one's fellows, and one's mate. If +the love-force gets too much pleasure in any one of these phases, it +finds it hard to give up its old love and to pass on to the next +phase. Thus some children take too much pleasure in their own bodies +or, a little later, in their own personalities. If they are too much +interested in their own physical sensations and the pleasure they get +by stimulating certain zones of the body, then in later life they +cannot free themselves from the desire for this kind of satisfaction. +Try as they may, they cannot be satisfied with normal adult relations, +but sink back into some form of so-called sex-perversion. + +Perhaps it is another phase of self-love which holds the child too +much. If, like Narcissus, he becomes too fond of looking at himself, +is too eager to show off, too desirous of winning praise, then forever +after he is likely to be self-conscious, self-centered, thinking +always of the impression he is making, unable ever to be at leisure +from himself. He is fixed in the Narcissistic stage of his life, and +is unadapted to the world of social relations. + +=Too Much Family-love.= We have already spoken of the danger of +fixation in the second period, that of object-love--the period of +family relationships. The danger is here again one of degree and may +be avoided by a little knowledge and self-control on the part of the +parents. The little girl who is permitted to lavish too much love on +her father, who does not see anybody else, who cannot learn to like +the boys is a misfit. The wise mother will see that her love for her +boy does not express itself too much by means of hugs and kisses. The +mother who shows very plainly that she loves her little boy better +than she loves her husband and the mother who boasts that her +adolescent boy tells her all his secrets and takes her out in +preference to any girl--that deluded mother is trying to take +something that is not hers, and is thereby courting trouble. When her +son grows up, he may not know why, but no girl will suit him, and he +will either remain a bachelor or marry some older woman who reminds +him subconsciously of his mother. His love-requirements will be too +strict; he will be forever trying either in phantasy or in real life +to duplicate his earlier love-experiences. This, of course, cannot +satisfy the demands of a mature man. He will be torn between +conflicting desires, unhappy without knowing why, unable either to +remain a child or to become a man, and impelled to gain +self-expression in indirect and unsatisfactory ways. + +Since it is not possible in this space to recite specific cases which +show how often a nervous trouble points back to the father-mother +complex,[35] it may help to cite the opinions of a few of our best +authorities. Freud says of the family complex, "This is the root +complex of the neurosis." Jelliffe: "It is the foot-rule of +measurement of success in life": by which he means that just so far as +we are able at the right time to free ourselves from dependence on +parents are we able to adjust ourselves to the world at large. +Pfister: "The attitude toward parents very often determines for a +life-time the attitude toward people in general and toward life +itself." Hinkle: "The entire direction of lives is determined by +parental relationships." + +[Footnote 35: This is technically known as the Oedipus Complex.] + +=Too Much Hate.= Besides loving too hard, there is the danger of +hating too hard. If it sounds strange to talk of the hatreds of +childhood, we must remember that we are thinking of real life as it is +when the conventions of adult life are removed and the subconscious +gives up its secrets. + +Several references have been made to the jealousy of the small child +when he has to share his love with the parent of the same sex. For +every little boy the father gets in the way. For every little girl the +mother gets in the way. At one time or other there is likely to be a +period when this is resented with all the violence of a child's +emotions. It is likely to be very soon repressed and succeeded by a +real affection which lasts through life. But underneath, unmodified by +time, there may exist simultaneously the old childish image and the +old unconscious reaction to it, unconscious but still active in +indirect ways. + +Jealousy is very often united with the natural rebellion of a child +against authority. The rebellion may, of course, be directed against +either parent who is final in authority in the home. In most cases +this is the father. As the impulse of self-assertion is usually +stronger in boys than in girls, and as the boy's impulse in this +direction is reinforced by any existing jealousy toward his father, we +find a strong spirit of rebellion more often playing a subconscious +part in the life of men than of women. The novelist's favorite theme +of the conflict between the young man and "the old man" represents the +conscious, unrepressed complex. More often, however, there is true +affection for the father, while the rebellion which really belongs to +the childish father-image is displaced or transferred to other symbols +of authority,--the state, the law, the king, the school, the teacher, +the church, or perhaps to religion and authority in general. +Anarchists and atheists naturally rationalize their reasons for +dissent, but, for all that, they are not so much intellectual pioneers +as rebellious little boys who have forgotten to grow up. + +=Liking to be "Bossed."= There is a worse danger, however, than too +much rebellion, and that is too little rebellion. Sometimes this +yielding spirit is the result of an overdose of negative self-feeling +and an under-dose of positive self-feeling; but sometimes it is +over-compensation for the repressed spirit of rebellion which the +child considers wicked. Consciously he becomes over-meek, because he +has to summon all his powers to fight his subconscious insurrection. +Whether he be meek by nature or by training, he is likely to be a +failure. Everybody knows that the child who is too good never amounts +to anything. He who has never disobeyed is a weakling. Naturally +resenting all authority, the normal individual, if he be well trained, +soon learns that some authority is necessary. He rebels, but he learns +to acquiesce, to a certain degree. If he acquiesces too easily, +represses too severely his rebellious spirit, swings to the other +extreme of wanting to be "bossed," he is very likely to end as a +nervous invalid, unfitted for the battles of life. The neurotic in the +majority of cases likes authority, clings to it too long, wants the +teacher to tell him what to do, wants the doctor to order him around, +is generally over-conscientious, and afraid he will offend the "boss" +or some one else who reminds him of the father-image. All this carries +a warning to parents who cannot manage their children without +dominating their lives, even when the domination is a kindly one. +Perhaps the modern child is in more danger of being spoiled than +bullied, but analysis of nervous patients shows that both kinds of +danger still exist. + +=Too Much Disgust.= The third form of excessive emotion is disgust. +The love-force, besides being blocked by a fixation of childish love +and of childish reactions toward authority, is very often kept from +free mature self-expression by a perpetuation of a childish reaction +against sex. We hardly need dwell longer on the folly of teaching +children to be ashamed of so inevitable a part of their own nature. +Disgust is a very strong emotion, and when it is turned against a part +of ourselves, united with that other strong impulse of self-regard and +incorporated into the conscience, it makes a Chinese wall of exclusion +against the baffled, misunderstood reproductive instinct, which is +thrust aside as alien. + +=Restraint versus Denial.= Repression is not merely restraint. It is +restraint plus denial. To the clamoring instinct we say not merely, +"No, you _may_ not," but "No, you _are_ not. You do not exist. Nothing +like you could belong to me." The woman with nausea (Chapter V) did +not say to herself: "You are a normal, healthy woman, possessed of a +normal woman's desires. But wait a while until the proper time comes." +Controlled by an immature feeling of disgust, she had said: "I never +thought it. It cannot be." + +The difference is just this. When an ungratifiable desire is honestly +faced and squarely answered, it is modified by other desires, chooses +another way of discharge, and ceases to be desire. When a desire is +repressed, it is still desire, unsatisfied, insistent, unmodifiable by +mature points of view, untouched by time, automatic, and capable of +almost any subterfuge in order to get satisfaction. A repressed desire +is buried, shut away from the disintegrating effects of sunlight and +air. While the rest of the personality is constantly changing under +the influence of new ideas, the buried complex lives on in its +immaturity, absolutely untouched by time. + +=Childish Birth-theories.= When a child's questions about where babies +come from are met by evasions, he is forced to manufacture his own +theories. His elders would laugh if they knew some of these theories, +but they would not laugh if they knew how often the childish ideas, +wide of the truth, furnish the material for future neuroses. Frink +tells the story of a young woman who had a compulsion for taking +drugs. Although not a drug-fiend in the usual sense, she was +constantly impelled to take any kind of drug she could obtain. It was +finally revealed that during her childhood she had tried hard to +discover how babies were made, and had at last concluded that they +grew in the mother as a result of some medicine furnished by the +doctor. The idea had long been forgotten, only to reappear as a +compulsion. The natural desire for a child was strong in her, but was +repressed as unholy in an unmarried woman. The associated childish +idea of drug-taking was not repellent to her moral sense and was used +as a substitute for the real desire to bear a child. + +Many of my patients have suffered from the effect of some such +birth-theories. One young girl, twenty years old, was greatly +afflicted with myso-phobia, or the fear of contamination. She spent +most of her time in washing her hands and keeping her hands and +clothing free from contamination by contact with innumerable harmless +objects. When cleaning her shoes on the grass, she would kneel so that +the hem of her skirt would touch the grass, lest some dust should fly +up under her clothes. After eating luncheon in the park with a girl +who had tuberculosis, she said that she was not afraid of tuberculosis +in the lungs, but asked if something like tuberculosis might not get +in and begin to grow somewhere else. Her life was full to overflowing +of such compulsive fears. + +As opportunity offered itself from day to day, I would catch her +compulsive ideas in the very act of expressing themselves, and would +pin her down as to the association and the source of her fear, always +taking care not to make suggestions or ask leading questions. She was +finally convinced out of her own mouth that her real fear was the idea +of something getting into her body and growing there. Then she told +how she had questioned her mother about the reproductive life and had +been put off with signs of embarrassment. For a long time she had been +afraid to walk or talk with a boy, because, not knowing how conception +might occur, she feared grave consequences. + +Very soon after the beginning of her conversations with me, the girl +realized that her fear was really a disguised desire that something +might be planted within and grow. With her new understanding of +herself, her compulsions promptly slipped away. She began to eat and +sleep, and to live a happy, natural life. + +=Chronic Repression.= It takes first-hand acquaintance with nervous +patients to realize how common are stories like these. Unnecessary +repressions based on false training are the cause of many a physical +symptom and mental distress which a little parental frankness might +have forestalled.[36] + +[Footnote 36: Parents who are eager to handle this subject in the +right way are often sincerely puzzled as to how to go about it. No +matter how complete their education, it is very likely to fail them at +this critical point. For the benefit of such parents, let it be said +with all possible emphasis that the first and most important step must +be a change in their own mental attitude. If there is left within them +the shadow of embarrassment on the subject of sex, their children will +not fail to sense the situation at once. A feeling of hesitation or a +tendency to apologize for nature makes a far deeper impression on the +child-mind than do the most beautiful of half-believed words on the +subject. And this impression, subtle and elusive as it may seem, is a +real and vital experience which is quite likely to color the whole of +the child's life. If you would give your children a fair start, you +must first get rid of your own inner resistances. After that, all will +be clear sailing. + +In the second place, take the earliest opportunity to bring up the +subject in a natural way. A young father told me recently that his +little daughter had asked her mother why she didn't have any lap any +more. "And of course your wife took that chance to tell her about the +baby that is coming," I said. "Oh, no," he answered, "she did nothing +of the kind. Mary is far too young to know about such things." There +are always chances if we are on the look out for them--and the earlier +the better. It has been noticed that children are never repelled by +the idea of any natural process unless the new idea runs counter to +some notion which has already been formed. The wise parent is the one +who gets in the right impression before some other child has had a +chance to plant the wrong one. + +Then, too, we elders are judged quite as much by what we do not say as +by what we do. Happy is the child who is not left to draw his own +conclusions from the silence and evasiveness of his parents. The +sex-instruction which children are getting in the schools is often +good, but it usually comes too late--the damage is always done before +the sixth year. + +When it comes to the exact words in which to explain the phenomena of +generation and birth each parent must naturally find his own way. The +main point is that we must tell the truth and not try to improve on +nature. If we say that the baby grows under the mother's heart and +later the child learns that this is not true, he inevitably gets the +idea that there is something not nice about the part of the body in +which the baby does grow. What could be wrong with the simple truth +that the father plants a tiny seed in the mother's body and that this +seed joins with another little seed already there and grows until it +is a real baby ready to come into the world? The question as to how +the father plants the seed need cause no alarm. If brothers and +sisters are brought up together with no artificial sense of false +modesty, they very early learn the difference between the male and the +female body. It is simple enough to tell the little child the function +of the male structure. And it is easy to explain that the seeds do not +grow until the little boy and girl have grown to be man and woman and +that the way to be well and to have fine strong children is to leave +the generative organs alone until that time. A sense of the dignity +and high purpose of these organs is far more likely to prevent +perversions--to say nothing of nervousness--than is an attitude of +taboo and silence.] + +A certain amount of repression is inevitable and useful, but a +neurotic is merely an exaggerated represser. He represses so much of +himself that it will not stay down.[37] He builds up a permanent +resistance which automatically acts as a dam to his normal sex +instinct and forces it into undesirable outlets. + +[Footnote 37: "A neurosis is a partial failure of repression." Frink: +_Morbid Fears and Compulsions_.] + +A resistance is a chronic repression, repression that has become fixed +and subconscious, a habit that has lost its flexibility and outlives +its usefulness. It is a fixation of repression, and is built out of an +over-strong complex or emotional thought habit, acquired during +childhood, incorporated into the conscience and carried over into +maturity, where it warps judgment and interferes with normal +development because it is fundamentally untrue and at variance with +the laws of nature. + +=Too Much Day-Dreaming.= The fourth habit which holds back the adult +from maturity and predisposes toward "nerves" is the habit of +imagination. It need hardly be said that a certain kind of imagination +is a good thing and one of man's greatest assets. But the essence of +day-dreaming is the exact opposite; it is the desire to see things as +they are not, but as we should like them to be,--not in order that we +may bring them to pass, but for the mere pleasure of dreaming. Instead +of turning a microscope or a telescope on the world of reality, as +positive imagination does, this negative variety refuses even to look +with the naked eye. To dream is easier than to do; to build up +phantasies is easier than to build up a reputation or a fortune; to +think a forbidden pleasure is easier than to sublimate. +"Pleasure-thinking" is not only easier than "reality-thinking,"--it is +the _older_ way. + +Children gratify many of their desires simply by imagining them +gratified. Much of the difficulty of later life might be avoided if +the little child could be taught to work for the accomplishment of his +pleasures rather than to dream of them. The normal child gradually +abandons this "pleasure-thinking" for the more purposeful thinking of +the actual world, but the child who loiters too long in the realm of +fancy may ever after find it hard to keep away from its borders. His +natural interest in sex, if artificially repressed, is especially +prone to satisfy itself by way of phantasy. + +=Turning back to Phantasy.= In later life, when the love-force for one +reason or another becomes too strong to be handled either directly or +indirectly in the real world, there comes the almost irresistible +impulse to regress to the infantile way and to find expression by +means of phantasy. After long experience Freud concluded that phantasy +lies at the root of every neurosis. Jung says that a sex-phantasy is +always at least one determiner of a nervous illness, and Jelliffe +writes that the essence of the neurosis is a special activity of the +imagination. + +Such a statement need not shock the most sensitive conscience. The +very fact that a neurosis breaks out is proof that the phantasies are +repellent to the owners of them and are thrust down into the +subconscious as unworthy. In fact, every neurosis is witness to the +strength of the human conscience. No phantasy could cause illness. It +is the phantasy plus the repression of it that makes the trouble, or +rather it is the conflict between the forces back of the phantasy and +the repression. The neurosis, then, turns out to be a "flight from the +real," the result of a desire to run away from a difficulty. When a +problem presses or a disagreeable situation is to be faced, it is +easier to give up and fall ill than to see the thing through to the +end. Here again, we find that nervousness is a regression to the +irresponsible reactions of childhood. + +=Maturity versus Immaturity.= We have been thinking of the main causes +of "nerves" and have found them to be infantile habits of loving, +rebelling, repressing, and dreaming. We have tried to show that these +habits are able to cause trouble because of their bearing on that +inevitable conflict between the ancient urge of the reproductive +instinct and the later ideals which society has acquired. If this +conflict be met in the light of the present, free from the backward +pull, of outgrown habits, an adjustment is possible which satisfies +both the individual and society. We call this adjustment sublimation. +This is rather a synthesis than a compromise, a union of the opposing +forces, a happy utilization of energy by displacement on more useful +ideas. But if the conflict has to be met with the mind hampered by +immature thinking and immature feeling; if the demands of the +here-and-now are met as if it were long ago; if unhealthy and untrue +complexes, old loves and hates complicate the situation; if to the +necessary conflict is added an unnecessary one; then something else +happens. Compromise of some kind must be made, but instead of a happy +union of the two forces a poor compromise is effected, gaining a +partial satisfaction for both sides, but a real one for neither. The +neurosis is this compromise. + + +LATER EXPERIENCES + +=The Last Straw.= The precipitating cause may be one of a number of +things. It may be entirely within, or it may be external. Perhaps it +is only a quickening of the maturing instincts at the time of +adolescence, making the love-force too strong to be held by the old +repressions. Perhaps the husband, wife, or lover dies, or the +life-work is taken away, depriving the vital energy of its usual +outlets. Perhaps the trigger is pulled by an emotional shock which +bears a faint resemblance to old emotional experiences, and which +stimulates both the repressing and repressed trends and makes the +person at the same time say both "Yes," and "No."[38] Perhaps +physical fatigue lets down the mental and moral tension and makes the +conflict too strong to be controlled. Perhaps an external problem +presses and arouses the old habit of fleeing from disagreeable +reality. Any or all these factors may cooperate, but not one of them +is anything more than a last straw on an overburdened back. No +calamity, deprivation, fatigue, or emotion has been able to bring +about a neurosis unless the ground was prepared for it by the earlier +reactions of childhood. + +[Footnote 38: "The external world can only cause repression when there +was already present beforehand a strong initial tension reaching back +even to childhood."--Pfister: _Psychoanalytic Method_, p. 94.] + + +THE BREAKDOWN ITSELF + +="Two Persons under One Hat."= We can understand now why a neurotic +can be described in so many ways. We often hear him called an +especially moral, especially ethical person, with a very active +conscience; an intensely social being, unable to be satisfied with +anything but a social standard; a person with "finer intellectual +insight and greater sensitiveness than the rest of mankind." At the +same time we are told that a neurosis is a partial triumph of +anti-social, non-moral factors, and that it is a cowardly flight from +reality; we hear a nervous invalid called selfish, unsocial, shut in, +primitive, childish, self-deceived. Both these descriptions are true +to life. A neurosis is an ethical struggle between these two sets of +forces. If the lower set had triumphed, the man would have been merely +weak; if the higher set had been victorious, he would have been +strong. As it is, he is neither one nor the other,--only nervous. The +neurosis is the only solution of the struggle which he is able to +find, and serves the purpose of a sort of armed armistice between the +two camps. + + +SERVING A PURPOSE + +If a neurosis is a compromise, if it is the easiest way out, if it +serves a purpose, it must be that the individual himself has a hand in +shaping that purpose. Can it be that a breakdown which seems such an +unmitigated disaster is really welcomed by a part of our own selves? +Nothing is more intensely resented by the nervous invalid than the +accusation that he likes his symptoms,--and no wonder. The conscious +part of him hates the pain, the inconvenience, and the disability with +a real hatred. It is not pleasant to be ill. And yet, as it turns out, +it is pleasanter to be ill than it is to bear the tension of +unsatisfied desire or to be undeceived about oneself. Every symptom is +a means of expression for repressed and forgotten impulses and is a +relief to the personality. It tends to the preservation of the +individual, rather than to his destruction. The nervous invalid is not +short-lived, but his family may be! It has been said that a neurosis +is not so much a disease as a dilemma. Rather might it be said that +the neurosis is a way out of the dilemma. It is a harbor after a +stormy sea, not always a quiet harbor, but at least a usable one. +Unpleasant as it is, every nervous symptom is a form of compensation +which has been deliberately though unconsciously chosen by its owner. + +=Rationalizing Our Distress.= Among other things, a nervous symptom +furnishes a seemingly reasonable excuse for the sense of distress +which is behind every breakdown. Something troubles us. We are not +willing to acknowledge what it is. On the other hand, we must appear +reasonable to ourselves, so we manufacture a reason. Perhaps at the +time when the person first feels distress, he is on a railroad train. +So he says to himself, "It is the train. I must not go near the +railway"; and he develops a phobia for cars. Perhaps at the onset of +the fear he happens to have a slight pain in the arm. He makes use of +the pain to explain his distress. He thinks about it and holds on to +it. It serves a purpose, and is on the whole less painful than the +feeling of unexplained impending disaster which is attached to no +particular idea. Perhaps he happens to be tired when the conflict +first gets beyond control. So he seizes the idea of fatigue to explain +his illness. He develops chronic fatigue and talks proudly of +overwork. In every case the symptom serves a real purpose, and is, +despite its discomfort, a relief to the distressed personality. + +A neurosis is a subconscious effort at adjustment. Like a physical +symptom, it is Nature's way of trying to cure herself. It is an +attempt to get equilibrium, but it is an awkward attempt and hardly +the kind that we would choose when we see what we are doing. + +=Securing an Audience.= Besides furnishing relief from too intense +strain, a nervous breakdown brings secondary advantages that are at +most only dimly recognized by the individual. One of the most intense +cravings of the primitive part of the subconscious is for an audience; +a nervous symptom always secures that audience. The invalid is the +object of the solicitous care of the family, friends, physician, and +specialist. Pomp and ceremony, so dear to the child-mind, make their +appeal to the dissociated part of the personality. The repressed +instincts, hungry for love and attention, delight in the petting and +special care which an illness is sure to bring. Secretly and +unconsciously, the neurotic takes a certain pleasure in all the +various changes that are made for his benefit,--the dismantling of +striking clocks, the muffling of household noises, the banishing of +crowing roosters, and the changes in menu which must be carefully +planned for his stomach. + +This characteristic of finding pleasure in personal ministrations is +plainly a regression to the infantile phase of life. The baby demands +and obtains the center of the stage. Later he has to learn to give it +up, but the neurotic gets the center again and is often very loth to +leave it for a more inconspicuous place. + +=Capitalizing an Illness.= Then, too, a neurosis provides a way of +escape from all sorts of disagreeable duties. It can be capitalized in +innumerable ways,--ways that would horrify the invalid if he realized +the truth. Much of the resentment manifested against the suggestion +that the neurosis is psychic in origin is simply a resistance against +giving up the unconsciously enjoyed advantages of the illness. An +honest desire to get well is a long step toward cure. + +The purposive character of a nervous illness is well illustrated by +two cases reported by Thaddeus Hoyt Ames.[39] A young woman, the +drudge of the family, suddenly became hysterically blind, that is, she +became blind despite the fact that her eyes and optic nerves proved to +be unimpaired. She remained blind until it was proved to her that a +part of her welcomed the blindness and had really produced it for the +purpose of getting away from the monotony of her unappreciated life at +home. She naturally resented the charge but finally accepted it and +"turned on" her eyesight in an instant. The other patient, a man, +became blind in order to avoid seeing his wife who had turned out to +be not at all what he had hoped. When he realized what he was doing, +he decided that there might be better ways of adjusting himself to his +wife. He then switched on his seeing power, which had never been +really lost, but only disconnected and dissociated from the rest of +his mind. + +[Footnote 39: Thaddeus Hoyt Ames: _Archives of Ophthalmology_, Vol. +XLIII, No. 4, 1914.] + +That the conscious mind has no part in the subterfuge is shown by the +fact that both patients gave up their artificial haven as soon as they +saw how they had been fooling themselves. The fact remains that every +neurosis is the fulfilment of a wish,--a distorted, unrecognized, +unsatisfactory fulfilment to be sure, but still an effort to satisfy +desire. As Frink remarks, "A neurosis is a kind of behaviour." We +always choose the conduct we like. It is a matter of choice. Does not +this answer our question as to why some people always take unhealthy +suggestions? If we take the bad one, it is because it serves the need +of a part of our being. + + +SIGN LANGUAGE + +=Talking in Symbols.= We have several times suggested that a nervous +symptom is a disguised, indirect expression of subconscious impulses. +It is the completeness of the disguise which makes it so hard for us +to realize its true meaning. It takes a stretch of the imagination to +believe that a pain in the body can mean a pain in the soul, or that +a fear of contamination can signify a desire to bear a child. But in +all this we must not forget the primitive, childlike nature of the +instinctive life. + +The savage and the child do not think as civilized man thinks. Savage +or child thinks in pictures; he acts his feelings; he groups things +according to superficial resemblances, he expresses an idea by its +opposite; he talks in symbols. We still use these devices in poetic +speech and in everyday thought. A wedding-ring stands for the marriage +bond; the flag for a nation; a greyhound for fleetness; a wild beast +for ferocity; sunrise for youth; and sunset for old age. "The essence +of language consists in the statement of resemblance. The expression +of human thought is an expression of association."[40] + +[Footnote 40: Trigant Burrow: _Journal of American Medical +Association_, Vol. LXVI, No. II, 1916.] + +The association may be so accidental and superficial as to seem absurd +to another person, or it may be so fundamental as to express the +universal thought of man from the beginning of time. Many of the signs +and symbols which crop out in neurotic symptoms and in normal dreams +are the same as those which appear in myths, fairy tales and folk-lore +and in the art of the earlier races. + +=A Secret Code.= When the denied instincts of a man's repressed life +insist on expression, and when the shocked proprieties of his +repressing life demand conformity to social standards, the +subconscious, held back from free speech, strikes a compromise by +making use of figurative language. As Trigant Burrow says, if the +moral repugnance is very strong, the disguise must be more elaborate, +the symbols more far-fetched. The symbols of nervous symptoms and of +dreams are a "secret code," understood by the sender but meaningless +to the censoring conscience, which passes them as harmless. + +=The Right Kind of Symbolism.= Sublimation itself is merely a symbolic +expression of basic impulses. It follows the line of our make-up, +which naturally and fundamentally is wont to let one thing stand for +another and to express itself in indirect ways. Sublimation says: "If +I cannot recreate myself in the person of a child, I will recreate +myself in making a bridge, or a picture, or a social settlement,--or a +pudding." It says: "If I cannot have my own child to love, I will +adopt an orphan-asylum, or I will work for a child-labor law." It +merely lets one thing stand for another and transfers all the passions +that belong to the one on to the other, which is the same thing as +saying that it gives vent to its original desire by means of symbolic +expression. + +=The Wrong Kind of Symbolism.= A nervous disorder is an unfortunate +choice of symbols. Instead of spiritualizing an innate impulse, it +merely disguises it. The disguise takes a number of forms. One of the +commonest ways is to act out in the body what is taking place in the +soul. The woman with nausea converted her moral disgust into a +physical nausea, which expressed her distress while it hid its +meaning. The girl who was tired of seeing her work, and the man who +wanted to avoid seeing his wife chose a way out which physically +symbolized their real desire. A dentist once came to me with a +paralyzed right arm. He had given up his office and believed that he +would never work again. It turned out that his only son had just died +and that he was dramatizing his soul-pain by means of his body. His +subconscious mind was saying, "My good right arm is gone," and saying +it in its own way. Within a week the arm was playing tennis, and ever +since it has been busy filling teeth. There were, of course, other +factors leading up to the trouble, but the factor which determined its +form was the sense of loss which acted itself out through the body. + +Sometimes, as we have seen, the disguise takes another form. Instead +of conversion into a physical symptom, it lets one idea stand for +another and displaces the impulse or the emotion to the substitute +idea. The girl with the impulse to take drugs fooled her conscience by +letting the drug-taking idea stand for the idea of conception. The +girl with the fear of contamination carried the disguise still +farther by changing the desire into fear,--a very common subterfuge. + +=The Case of Mrs. Y.= There came to me a short time ago a little woman +whose face showed intense fright. For several months she had spent +much of the time walking the floor and wringing her hands in an agony +of terror. In the night she would waken from her sleep, shaking with +fear; soon she would be retching and vomiting, although she herself +recognized the fact that there was nothing the matter with her +stomach. + +Part of the time her fear was a general terror of some unknown thing, +and part of the time it was a specialized fear of great intensity. She +was afraid she would choke her son, to whom she was passionately +devoted. During the course of the treatment, which followed the lines +of psycho-analysis to be described in the next chapter, I found that +this fear had arisen one evening when she was lying reading by the +side of her sleeping child. Suddenly, without warning, she had a sort +of mental picture of her own hands reaching out and choking the boy. +Naturally she was terrified. She jumped out of bed, decided that she +was losing her mind and went into a hysterical state which her husband +had great trouble in dispelling. After that she was afraid to be left +alone with her children lest she should kill them. + +During the analysis it was discovered that what she had been reading +on that first night was the thirteenth verse of the ninety-first +Psalm. "Thou shalt tread upon the lion and the adder. The young lion +and the dragon thou shalt trample under foot." To her the adder meant +the snake, the tempter in the Garden of Eden, and hence sex. What she +wanted to choke was her own insistent sex urge of which the child was +the symbol and the result. On later occasions she had the same sort of +hallucinations in connection with another child and on sight of a +brutish kind of man who symbolized to the subconscious mind the +sex-urge, of which she was afraid. Not so much by what her mother had +said as by what she had avoided saying, and by her expression whenever +the subject was mentioned, had she given her little daughter a +fundamentally wrong idea of the reproductive instinct. Later when the +girl was woman grown she still clung to the old conception, deploring +the sex-part of the marriage relation and feeling herself too refined +to be moved by any such sensual urge. But the strong sex-instinct +within her would not be downed. It was so insistent as to be an object +of terror to her repressing instinct, which could not bring itself to +acknowledge its presence. The fear that came to the surface was merely +a disguised and symbolic representation of this real fear which was +turning her life into a nightmare. + +The nausea and vomiting in this woman seemed to be symbolic of the +disgust which she felt subconsciously at the thought of her own +sex-desires, but sometimes the physical disturbances which accompany +such phobias are the natural physical reactions to the constant fear +state. Indigestion, palpitation, and tremors are not in themselves +symbolic of the inner trouble but may be the result of an overdose of +the adrenal and thyroid secretions and the other accompaniments of +fear. In such cases the real symptom is the fear, and the physical +disturbance an incidental by-product of the emotional state. In any +case a nervous symptom is always the sign of something else--a +hieroglyph which must be deciphered before its real meaning can be +discovered. + + +SUMMARY + +=Three Kinds of People.= Absurd as it sounds, "nerves" turn out to be +a question of morals; a neurosis, an affair of conscience; a nervous +symptom an unsettled ethical struggle. The ethical struggle is not +unusual; it is a normal part of man's life, the natural result of his +desire to change into a more civilized being. The people in the world +may be divided into three classes, according to the way they decide +the conflict. + +=The Primitive.= The first class merely capitulate to their primitive +desires. They may not be nervous, but it is safe to say that they are +rarely happy. The voice of conscience is hard to drown, even when it +is not strong enough to control conduct. Happily it often succeeds in +making us miserable, when we desert the ways that have proved best for +our kind. The "immoral" person has not yet "arrived"; he simply +disregards the collective wisdom of society and gives the victory to +the primitive forces which try to keep man back on his old level. We +cannot break the ideals by which man lives, and still be happy. + +=The Salt of the Earth.= The second class of people decide the +conflict in a way that satisfies both themselves and society. They +give the victory to the higher trends and at the same time make a +lasting peace by winning over the energy of the undesirable impulses. +By sublimation they divert the threatening force to useful work and +turn it out into real life, using its steam to make the world's wheels +go round. Their love-force, unhampered by childish habits, is free to +give itself to adult relationships or to express itself symbolically +in socially helpful ways. + +=Nervous People.= To the third class belong the people who have not +finished the fight. These are the folk with "nerves," the people in +whom the conflict is fiercest because both sides are too strong. The +victory goes to neither side; the tug of war ends in a tie. Since the +energy of the nervous person is divided between the effort to repress +and the effort to gain expression, there is little left for the +external world. There is plenty of energy wasted on emotion, physical +symptoms, phantasy, or useless acts symbolizing the struggle. + +A neurotic is a normal person, "only more so." His impulses are the +same impulses as those of every other person; his complexes are the +same kind of complexes, only more intense. He is an exaggerated human +being. He may be only slightly exaggerated, showing merely a little +character-weakness or a slight physical symptom, or he may be so +intensified as to make life miserable for himself and everybody near +him. It is quantity, not quality, that ails him, for he differs from +his steady-going neighbor not in kind but in degree. More of him is +repressed and a larger part of him is fixed in a childish mold. + +=Tricking Ourselves.= A neurosis is a confidence game that we play on +ourselves. It is an attempt to get stolen fruit and to look pious at +the same time,--not in order to fool somebody else but to fool +ourselves. + +No nervous symptom is what it seems to be. It is an arch pretender. It +pretends to be afraid of something it does not fear at all, or to +ignore something that interests it intensely. It pretends to be a +physical disease, when primarily it has nothing to do with the body; +and the person most deluded is the one who "owns" the symptom. Its +purpose is to avoid the pain of disillusionment and to furnish relief +to a distracted soul which dares not face itself. + +Although the true meaning of a symptom is hidden, there is fortunately +a clue by which it can be traced. Sometimes it takes the art of a +psychic detective to follow the clues down, down through the different +layers of the subconscious mind, until the troublesome impulses and +complexes are found and dragged forth,--not to be punished for +breaking the peace but to be led toward reconciliation. But "that is +another story," and belongs to another chapter. We are approaching THE +WAY OUT. + +PART III--THE MASTERY OF "NERVES" + + + + +CHAPTER VIII + +_In which we pick up the clue_ + +THE WAY OUT + +THE SCIENCE OF RE-EDUCATION + + +There is a story of an Irishman at the World's Fair in Chicago. +Although his funds were getting low, he made up his mind that he would +not go home without a ride on a camel. For several minutes he stood +before a sign reading: "First ride 25¢, second ride 15¢, third ride +10¢." Then, scratching his head, he exclaimed, "Faith, and I'll take +the third ride!" Should there by any chance be a reader who, eager to +find the way out without paying the price of knowledge, is tempted to +say to himself "Faith, and I'll begin with Part III," we give him fair +warning that if he does so, he will in all probability end by putting +down the book in a confused and skeptical frame of mind. + +It is difficult to find our way out of a maze without some faint idea +of the path by which we got in. He who brings to this chapter the +popular notion that nervousness is the result of worn-out +nerve-cells, can hardly be expected to understand how it can be cured +by a process of mental adjustment. Suggestion to that effect can +scarcely fail to appear to him faddish and unpractical. But once a +person has grasped the idea that "nerves" are merely a slip in the cog +of hidden mental machinery, and has acquired at least a +working-knowledge of "the way the wheels go round," he can scarcely +fail to understand that the only logical cure must consist in some +kind of readjustment of this underground machinery. If "nerves" were +physical, then only physical measures could cure, but as they are +psychic, the only effective measures must be psychic. + +=Gross Misconceptions.= Nervousness is caused by a lack of adjustment +to the world as it is; therefore the only possible cure must be some +sort of readjustment between the person's inner forces and the demands +of the social world. As this lack of adjustment is concerned chiefly +with the repressed instinct of reproduction, it is only natural that +there should be people who believe that "the way out" lies in some +form of physical satisfaction of the sex-impulse--in marriage, in +changing or ignoring the social code, in homo-sexual relations or in +the practice of masturbation. But we have only to look about us to see +that this prescription does not cure. Freud naïvely asks whether he +would be likely to take three years to uncover and loosen the psychic +resistances of his patients, if the simple prescription of sex-license +would give relief. + +Since there are as many married neurotics as single, it is evident +that even marriage is not a sure preventive of nervousness. License, +on the other hand, can satisfy only a part of the individual's +craving. Freud insists that the sex-instinct has a psychic component +as well as a physical one, and that it is this psychic part which is +most often repressed. He maintains that for complete satisfaction +there must be psychic union between mates, and that gratification of +the physical component of sex when dissociated from psychic +satisfaction, results in an accumulation of tension that reacts badly +on the whole organism. + +The psychic tension accumulating in adult sex-relations has its +inception in the mistaken attitude on the part of the wife, who +remains true to her childhood training that any pleasure in sex is +vulgar; or on the part of the man, who reacts to the mood of the wife, +or is held by his own unbroken mother-son complex; or on the part of +both the tension piles up because of society's taboo upon rearing +large families. As the first two factors in this lack of adjustment +grew largely out of some kind of faulty education or from faulty +reaction to early experiences, the only effective way to secure a +better adaptation must be through a re-education which reaches down +to that part of the personality that bears the stamp of the +unfortunate early factors. + +=Remaking Ourselves.= As a matter of fact, the science of +psychotherapy or mental treatment is simply the science of +re-education,--a process designed to break up old unhealthy complexes +which disrupt the forces of the individual, and to build up healthy +complexes which adjust him to the social world and enable him to use +his energy in useful ways. + +Fortunately, minds can be changed. It is easier to make over an +unhealthy complex than to make over a weak heart, to straighten out a +warped idea than to straighten a bent back. Remarkable indeed have +been some of the transformations in people who are supposed to have +passed the plastic period in life. While it is true that some persons +become "set" in middle life, and almost impervious to new ideas, it is +also true that a person at fifty has more richness of experience upon +which to draw, more appreciation of the value of the good, than has a +person at twenty. If he really wants to change himself, he can do +wonderful things by re-education. + +The first step in this re-education is a grasp of the facts. If you +want to pull yourself out of a nervous disorder, first of all learn as +much as you can about the causes of "nerves," about the general laws +of mind and body, and about your own mental quirks. If this is not +sufficient, go to a specialist trained in psychotherapy and let him +help you uncover those trouble-making parts of your personality which +you cannot find for yourself. It is the purpose of this book to +summarize the facts which most need to be known. Let us now consider +those methods which the psychopathologist finds most useful in helping +his patients to self-knowledge and readjustment. + +=Various Methods.= As there are a number of schools of medicine, so +there are a number of distinct methods of psychotherapy, each with its +own theories and methods of procedure, and each with its ardent +supporters. These methods may be classified into two groups. The first +group includes those methods, hypnosis and psycho-analysis, which make +a thorough search through the subconscious mind for the buried +complexes causing the trouble, and might, therefore, be called +"re-education with subconscious exploration." The other group, +includes so-called explanation and suggestion, or methods of +"re-education without subconscious exploration," which content +themselves with making a general survey and building up new complexes +without going to the trouble of uncovering the buried past. Although +the theory and the technique vary greatly, the aim of all these +methods is the same,--the readjustment of the individual to life. + +RE-EDUCATION WITH SUBCONSCIOUS EXPLORATION + +=Hypnosis.= The method by which most of the important early +discoveries were made is hypnosis, or artificial sleep, a method by +which the conscious mind is dissociated and the subconscious brought +to the fore. It was through hypnosis that Freud, Janet, Prince, and +Sidis made their first investigations into the nature of nervousness +and worked their first cures. With the conscious mind asleep and its +inhibitions out of the way, a hypnotized patient is often able to +remember and to disclose to the physician hidden complexes of which he +is unaware when awake. Hypnosis may thus be a valuable aid to +diagnosis, enabling the physician to determine the cause of +troublesome symptoms. He may then begin to make suggestions calculated +to break up the old complexes and to build new ones, made up of more +healthful ideas, desirable emotions and happy feeling-tones. As we +have seen, a hypnotized subject is highly suggestible. His +counter-suggestions inactivated, he believes almost anything told him +and is extremely susceptible to the doctor's influence. + +The dangers of hypnosis have been much exaggerated. Indeed, as an +instrument in the hands of a competent physician, it is not to be +feared at all. It has, however, its limitations. Many times the very +memories which need to be unearthed refuse to come to the surface. +Stubborn resistances are more likely to be subconscious than +conscious, and may prove too strong to be overcome in this way. +Moreover, the road to superficial success is very inviting. It is easy +to cure the symptom, leaving the ultimate cause untouched and ready to +break out in new manifestations. The drug and drink habits may be +broken up without making any attempt to discover the unsatisfied +longings which were responsible for the habit. A pain may be cured +without finding the mental cause of the pain or initiating any +measures to guard against its return, and without giving the patient +any insight into the inner forces with which he still has to deal. + +Since nervousness is a state of exaggerated suggestibility and +abnormal dissociation, many psychologists believe that it is unwise to +employ a method which heightens the state of suggestibility and +encourages the habit of dissociation. They feel that it is wiser to +use less artificial methods which rest on the rational control of the +conscious mind and make the patient better acquainted with his own +inner forces and more permanently able to cope with new manifestations +of those forces. They believe that the character of the patient is +strengthened and his morale raised by methods which increase the +sovereignty of reason and decrease the role of unreasoning +suggestibility. + +=Psycho-Analysis.= Freud's contribution has been not only a discovery +of the general causes of nervousness, but a special means of locating +the cause in any particular case. Abandoning hypnosis, he developed +another method which he called psycho-analysis. What chemical analysis +is to chemistry, psycho-analysis is to the science of the mind. It +splits up the mental content into its component parts, the better to +be examined and modified by the conscious mind. Psycho-analysis is +merely a technical process for discovering repressed complexes and +bringing them into consciousness, where they may be recognized for +what they are and altered to meet the demands of real life. It is a +device for finding and removing the cause of nervousness,--for +bringing to light hidden desires which may be honestly faced and +efficiently directed instead of being left to seethe in dangerous +insurrection. In order permanently to break up a real neurosis, a man +must first know himself and then change himself. He must gain insight +into his own mental processes and then systematically set to work to +change those processes that unfit him for life. + +We shall later find that a detailed self-discovery through +psycho-analysis is not always necessary, and that a more general +understanding of oneself is sufficient for the milder kinds of +nervousness. But because of the promise which psycho-analysis holds +out to those stubborn cases before which other methods are powerless; +because of the invaluable understanding of human nature which it +places at the disposal of all nervous people, who may profit by its +findings without undergoing an analysis; and because of the flood of +light which it sheds on the motives, conduct, and character of every +human being, no educated person can afford to be without a general +knowledge of psycho-analysis.[41] + +[Footnote 41: It is unfortunate that the records of an analysis are +too voluminous for use in so brief an account as this. Since the +report of one case would fill a book, and a condensed summary would +require a chapter, we must refer to some of the volumes which deal +exclusively with the psychoanalytic principles. For a list of these +books, see Bibliography.] + +=A Chain of Associations.= Psycho-analysis is not, like hypnosis, +based on dissociation; it is based on the association of ideas. Its +main feature is a process of uncritical thinking called "free +association." To understand it, one must realize how intricately woven +together are the thoughts of a human being and how trivial are the +bonds of association between these ideas. One person reminds us of +another because his hair is the same color or because he handles his +fork in the same way. Two words are associated because they sound +alike. Two ideas are connected because they once occurred to us at the +same time. A subtle odor or a stray breeze serves to remind us of some +old experience. Connections that seem far-fetched to other people may +be quite strong enough to bind together in our minds ideas and +emotions which have once been associated, even unconsciously, in past +experience. + +In this way, thoughts in consciousness and in the upper layers of the +subconscious are connected by a series of associations, forming links +in invisible chains that lead to the deepest, most repressed ideas. +Even a dissociated complex has some connection with the rest of the +mind, if we only have the patience to discover it. Therefore, by +adopting a passive attitude, by simply letting his thoughts wander, by +talking out to the physician everything that comes to his mind without +criticizing or calling any thought irrelevant or far-fetched, and +without rejecting any thought because of its painful character, the +patient is helped to trace down and unearth the troublesome complex +which may have been absolutely forgotten for many years. He is helped +to relive the childhood experiences back of the over-strong habits +which lasted into maturity. + +=Resisting the Probe.= Naturally, it is not all fair sailing. The +subconscious impulses which repressed the painful complex in the first +place still shrink from uncovering it. In many cases the resistance is +very strong. It, therefore, often happens that after a time the +patient becomes restive; he begins to criticize the doctor and to +ridicule the method. His mind goes blank and no thought will come; or +he refuses to tell what does come. The nearer the probe comes to the +sore spot, the greater the pain of the repressing impulses and the +stronger the resistance. Usually a strange thing happens; the patient, +instead of consciously remembering the forgotten experiences, begins +to relive them with his original emotions transferred on to the +doctor. Depending upon what person of his childhood he identifies with +him, the patient develops either a strong affection or an intense +antagonism to the physician, attitudes called in technical terms +positive and negative transference. If the analyst is skilful, he is +able to circumvent all the subterfuges of the resisting forces and to +uncover and modify the troublesome complexes. Sometimes this can be +accomplished at one sitting, but more often it requires long hours of +conversation. Freud has spent three years on a single difficult case, +and very frequently the analysis drags out through weeks or months. +The amount of mental material is so great, especially in a person who +is no longer young, that every analysis would probably be an +interminable affair if it were not for three valuable ways of finding +the clue and picking up the scent somewhere near the end of the trail. +The first of these clues is nothing else than so despised a phenomenon +as the patient's own night-dreams, which turn out to be not +meaningless jargon, as we have supposed, but significant utterances of +the inner man. + +=The Message of the Dream.= When Freud rescued dreams from the mental +scrap-basket and learned how to piece them together so that their +message to man about himself became for the first time intelligible, +he furnished the human race with what will probably be considered its +most valuable key to the hidden mysteries of the mind. Freeing the +dream from the superstition of olden times and from the neglect of +later days, Freud was the first to discover that it is part and parcel +of man's mental life, that it has a purpose and a meaning and that the +meaning may be scientifically deciphered. It then invariably reveals +itself to be not a prophecy for the future but an interpretation of +the present and of the past, an invaluable synopsis of the drama which +is being staged within the personality of the dreamer. + +As modern man has swung away from the idea of the dream as a warning +or a prophecy, he has accepted the even more untrue conception of +dreaming as the mere sport of sleep,--the "babble of the mind," the +fantastic and insignificant freak-play of undirected mental processes, +or the result of physical sensations without relation to the rest of +mental life. No wonder, then, that Freud's startling dictum, "A dream +is a disguised fulfilment of a repressed wish," should be met with +astonishment and incredulity. When a person is confronted for the +first time with this statement, he invariably begins to cite dreams in +which he is pursued by wild beasts, or in which his loved ones are +seen lying dead. He then triumphantly asserts that no such dream +could be the fulfilment of a wish. + +The trouble is that he has overlooked the word "disguised." Like wit +and some figures of speech, a dream says something different from what +it means. It deals in symbols. Its "manifest content" may be merely a +fantastic and impossible scene without apparent rhyme or reason, but +the "latent content," the hidden meaning, always expresses some urgent +personal problem. Although the dream may seem to be impersonal and +unemotional, it nevertheless deals in every case with some matter of +vital concern to the dreamer himself. It is a condensed and composite +picture of some present problem and of some related childish repressed +wish which the experiences of the preceding day have aroused. + +As Frink says, a dream is like a cartoon with the labels +omitted--absolutely unintelligible until its symbols are interpreted. +Although some dreams whose symbolism is that which man has always +used, can be easily understood by a person who knows, many dreams are +meaningless, even to an experienced analyst, until the patient himself +furnishes the labels by telling what each bit of the picture brings to +his mind. The dream, as a rule, merely furnishes the starting-point +for free association. + +Each symbol is an arrow pointing the way to forbidden impulses which +are repressed in waking life but which find partial expression during +sleep. The subconscious part of the conscience is still on the job, so +the repressed desires can express themselves only in distorted ways +which will not arouse the censor and disturb sleep. The purpose of the +dream is thus two-fold,--to relieve the tensions of unsatisfied +desire, and to do this in such a subtle way as to keep the dreamer +asleep. Sometimes it fails of its purpose, but when there is danger of +our discovering too much about ourselves, we immediately wake up, +saying that we have had a bad dream. + +It is at first difficult to believe that we are capable of this +elaborate mental work while we are fast asleep. However, a little +investigation shows us to be more clever than we realize. The +subconscious mind, in its effort to satisfy both the repressing and +the repressed impulses, carries on very complicated processes, +disguises material by allowing one person to stand for another, two +persons to stand for one, or one person to stand for two; it shifts +emotion from important to trivial matters, dramatizes, condenses, and +elaborates, with a skill that is amazing. We are all of us very clever +playwrights and makers of allegories--in our sleep. Also, we are all +very clever at getting what we want, and the dream secures for us, in +a way, something which we want very much indeed and which the world +of social restraint or our own warped childish notion denies us. + +Not every one can become an interpreter of dreams. It takes a skilled +and patient specialist thoroughly to understand the process. But it is +fortunate indeed that we possess such a valuable means of diagnosis +when extraordinary conditions make it necessary to explore the +subconscious in the search for trouble-making complexes.[42] + +[Footnote 42: For further study of the dream, see Freud: +_Interpretation of Dreams_; and _General Introduction to +Psycho-Analysis_.] + +=The Word-Test.= Although dreams furnish the main clues to buried +complexes, they are by no means the only instrument of the +psycho-analyst. Another device, called the association word-test, has +been developed by Dr. Carl Jung of Switzerland. The analyst prepares a +list of perhaps one hundred words, which he reads one by one to the +patient, hoping in this way to strike some of the emotional reactions +of which the patient himself is unaware. The latter responds with the +first word that comes into his mind, no matter how absurd it may seem. +The responses themselves are often significant, but the time that +elapses is even more so. It usually happens that it takes very much +longer for some responses than for others. If a patient's average time +is one or two seconds, some responses may take five or ten or twenty +seconds. Sometimes no word comes at all and the patient says that his +mind is a blank. He coughs or blushes, grows pale or trembles, showing +all the signs of emotion even when he himself has no notion of the +cause. The significant word has hit upon a subconscious association +with some emotional complex. The blocking of the mind is an effort of +the resistance to keep the painful ideas out of consciousness. The +telltale word then furnishes a starting point for further +associations. + +One of my patients blocked on the word "long." Instead of saying +"short" or "pencil" or "road" or "day" or any other word which might +naturally be associated with "long," she laughed and said that no word +would come. Finally an emotional memory came to light. It seems that +this woman had been courted by a man whom she unconsciously loved, but +whom she had "turned down" because she was ambitious for a career. +After the man had moved to another town, my patient heard that he was +engaged to another girl. She then realized that she loved him and +began to long for him with her whole heart. The meaningful word "long" +thus led us to one of the emotional memories for which we were +seeking. + +="Chance" Signs.= There are other clues to hidden inner processes, +other sign-posts pointing to the cause of a neurosis. Not only through +dreams and through emotional reactions to certain words does the +subconscious reveal its desires, but also through the little slips of +the tongue and of the pen, the "chance" acts and unconscious +mannerisms which are usually ignored as entirely insignificant. When +we "make a break" and say what we secretly mean but wish to hide from +ourselves or others; when we forget an appointment which part of us +really wishes to avoid, or forget a name with which we are perfectly +familiar; when we lose the pen so that we cannot write or the desk key +so that we cannot work; when we blunder and drop things and do what we +did not mean to do; then we may know--the normal as well as the +nervous person--that our subconscious minds with their repressed +desires are trying to get the reins and are partially succeeding. + +An example from my own life may illustrate the point. In building a +number of houses, I had occasion often to use the word studding, but +on every occasion, I forgot the word and always had to end lamely by +saying "those pieces of timber that go up and down." Each time the +builder supplied the word, but the next time it was no more +accessible. Finally, the reason came to me. One day when I was a +little child I looked out of the window and cried, "Oh, see that great +big beautiful horse." My grandmother exclaimed, "Sh! sh! that is a +stud horse." Over-reaction to that impression repressed the word stud +so successfully that as a grown woman I could not recall another word +which happened to contain the same syllable. + +During an analysis a patient of mine who had a mother-in-law situation +on her hands told me a dream of the night before. "I dreamed that my +mother-in-law, who has really been very ill, was taken with a +sinking-spell. I rushed to the telephone to call the doctor, but found +to my terror that I could not remember his number." "What is his +number?" I asked, knowing that she ought to know it perfectly. +"Two-eight-nine-six," she answered at once. The number really was +2876. Asleep and awake, her repressed desire for release from the +mother-in-law's querulous presence was attempting to have its way. In +the dream, she avoided calling the doctor by forgetting his number +entirely. Awake, she evaded the issue by remembering a wrong number. +In the dream she thinly disguised her desire by displacing the anxious +emotion from the sense of her own guilty wishes to the idea of the +mother-in-law's death. When confronted with this interpretation, the +woman readily acknowledged its truth. + +Even stammering, which has always been considered a physical disorder, +has been proved, by psycho-analysis, to be the sign of an emotional +disturbance. H. Addington Bruce reports the case of one of Dr. Brill's +patients, a young man who had been stammering for several years. +Observation revealed the fact that his chief difficulty was with +words beginning with K and although at first he firmly denied any +significance to the letter, he later confessed that his sweetheart +whose name began with K had eloped with his best friend and that he +had vowed never to mention her name again. Upon Dr. Brill's suggestion +he tried to think of the unfaithful lover as Miss W., but soon +returned, saying that he was stammering worse than ever. Investigation +showed that the additional unpronounceable words contained the letter +W. When he was induced to renounce his oath never to call the girl's +name again, he found that he had no more difficulty with his +speech.[43] + +[Footnote 43: H. Addington Bruce; "Stammering and Its Cure," +_McClure's_, February, 1913.] + +Thus we see that even the halting tongue of a stammerer may point the +way to the buried complex for which search is being made. + +Since there is no accident in mental life, and since there is behind +every action a force or group of forces, no smallest action is +insignificant to the person trained to understand. + +If this at first seems disturbing, it is only because we do not +realize that there is nothing within of which we need be ashamed. +People are very much alike, especially in the deeper layers of their +being. What belongs to the whole human race does not need to be +hidden away in darkness. There is nothing to lose and everything to +gain by an increasing understanding of the chance signals which reveal +the forces at work within the depths of the mind. To the analyst every +little unconscious act is a valuable clue pointing toward the end of +his quest.[44] + +[Footnote 44: For further discussion of this subject, see Freud's +_Psycho-pathology of Everyday Life_, translated by A.A. Brill.] + +=The Aim of Psycho-Analysis.= As we have seen, the object of all this +technique is the discovery and the removal of the resistances which +have been keeping the emotional conflicts in the dark. It is a long +step just to learn that there are resistances; and by reliving, bit by +bit, the earlier experiences responsible for unfortunate habits, we +find that the habits themselves lose much of their old power. They can +be seen for what they are, and changed to suit present conditions. A +wish is incomparably stronger when unconscious than when conscious; +and the old stereotyped, automatic reactions tend to cease when once +they have been seen for what they are. They become assimilated with +the rest of the personality and modified by the mature attitudes of +the conscious mind. The person then re-educates himself by the very +act of discovering himself. In other cases, the uncovering is merely +the first step in the process of re-education. The analyst then +assumes the rôle of educator, cutting away old shackles, breaking down +false standards, building up new complexes, showing the patient the +naturalness of his desires, inducing him to look at them as biologic +facts, and showing him how to sublimate those which may not find +direct expression; in fact, leading him out into the self-expression +of a free, unhampered life.[45] + +[Footnote 45: "It will be readily understood that in the +reconstruction of the shattered purposes, the frustrated hopes and the +outraged instincts which are found to lie at the source of those human +woes we call 'nervous disorders,' there takes place a gradual +transposition of values, a total recasting of ideas, and that through +the whole process, education in the deepest meaning of the word, +enters at last into its full sovereign rights."--Trigant Burrow.] + +Among my patients at one time was a woman subject to terrible fits of +despondency. She was happily married and enjoyed the marriage +relationship, but could not free herself from a terrible sense of +guilt and degradation, a sense which was so acute that she wanted to +end her life. Although she was an active member of a church, she was +starving for the real message of the church, continually bound by a +feeling of aloofness which made her a stranger in the midst of +friends. Psycho-analysis revealed an experience of her childhood which +she had kept a secret all these years. It seems that when she was +seven years of age an old minister had driven her into town and had +made some sort of sex-approach on the way. Although ignorant of its +significance, the child was badly frightened and overcome with a sense +of guilt. She had already inferred that such subjects were not to be +mentioned and she hesitated long before telling even her mother. +Smoldering within her through the years had been this emotional +complex about the sex-life and about people connected with a church, +so that even as a grown woman the relationships of her mature years +were completely ruined by her old childish reaction. With insight as +to the cause of her trouble, she was able to modify her attitudes and +to live a free and happy life. + +Several years ago there came to me a man of exceptional intellectual +ability, who for years had been totally incapacitated because of blind +resistances built up in childhood. Although married to a woman whom he +thoroughly liked and admired, he was absolutely miserable in his +married life. He had, in fact, a deep-rooted complex against marriage, +and had only allowed himself to be captured because the woman, with +whom he had been good friends, had cried when he refused to marry her. +During analysis it transpired that as a little boy of four he had +often seen his silly young mother cry because she could not have a new +dress. He had taken her side and bitterly felt that she was abused by +his father. Later, at six, he had heard some coarse stories about sex +to which he had over-reacted. Still later he had heard the workmen on +the farm say that they could not go to the gold-fields because they +had wives and were held back by marriage. "There are no idle words +where children are," and this little boy had built up such a strong +complex against marriage that he could not possibly be happy as a +grown man. He was as much crippled by the old scar as is an arm which +is bent and stunted from a deep scar in the flesh. After the analysis +had broken up the adhesions, he found himself free, able to give +mature expression to his repressed and dissatisfied love-instincts. + +Psycho-analysis is not a process of addition, but one of subtraction. +Like a surgical operation, it undoes the results of old injuries, +removes foreign material, and gives nature a chance to develop freely +in her own satisfactory way. + + +RE-EDUCATION WITHOUT SUBCONSCIOUS EXPLORATION + +=Simple Explanation.= So far, "the way out" sounds rather involved. It +seems to require a special kind of doctor and a complicated, lengthy +process before the exact trouble can be determined. But, fortunately +for the average nervous patient, this lengthy process of analysis is +by no means always necessary. People with troublesome nervous +symptoms, and even those who have had a serious breakdown, are +constantly being cured by a kind of re-education which breaks up +subconscious complexes without trying to bring them to the surface. If +the dead past can be let alone, so much the better. Sometimes a +bullet buried in the flesh sends up a constant stream of discomfort +until it is dug out and removed; but if it has carried in no infection +and the body can adjust itself, it is usually considered better to let +it remain. + +The subconscious makes its own deductions. If resistances are not too +strong it is often possible to introduce healthy ideas by way of the +conscious reason, to break up old habits, and make over the mentality +without going to the trouble of uncovering some of the reactions which +are responsible for the difficulty. + +=Moral Hygiene.= Because this is true, there has grown up a kind of +psychotherapy which is known as simple explanation, or persuasion. As +usually practised, this kind of re-education pays very little +attention to the ultimate cause of "nerves." It has little to say +about repressed instincts or the real reasons for fearful emotions and +physical symptoms. Instead, it attacks the symptom itself, contenting +itself with teaching the patient that his trouble is psychic in +origin; that it is based on exaggerated suggestibility and +uncontrolled emotionalism; that it is made out of false ideas about +the body, illogical conclusions, and unhealthy feeling-tones; and that +it may be cured by a kind of moral hygiene, which breaks up these old +habits and replaces them with new and better ones. It tries to +inculcate the cheerful attitude of mind; to give the patient the +conviction of power; to correct his false ideas about his stomach, his +heart, or his head; to train him out of his emotionalism; to lead him +into a state of mind more largely controlled by reason; and to make +him find some useful and absorbing work. + +This kind of mental and moral treatment has been sufficient to cure +many neuroses of long standing. In cases that are helped by this +method, the patient's love-force, robbed of the material out of which +it has woven its disguise, and trained out of its bad habits by +re-education, automatically makes its own readjustments and forces new +channels for itself out into more useful activities. Very many nervous +persons seem to need nothing more than this simple kind of help. + +=When Simple Explanation Does not Explain.= For very many cases, +however, this procedure, good as it is, does not go deep enough. +Although it gives a sound objective education about the facts of one's +body, it furnishes only the most superficial subjective knowledge of +one's inner life. If the inner struggle be bitter, the competing +forces will hold on to their poor refuge in the symptom, despite any +number of explanations that the symptom can have no physical cause. +Sometimes it is enough for a person to be shown that he is too +suggestible, but often it is far more helpful for him to get an +inkling as to why he likes unhealthy suggestions, and to understand +something of his starved instincts which he may learn to satisfy in +better ways. + + +PSYCHOLOGICAL EXPLANATION + +Between the two extremes of the cases which need a real analysis and +those which are cured by simple explanation, I have found the great +bulk of nervous cases. To simple explanation with its highly useful +information, I therefore add what might be called psychological +explanation, a re-education which makes use of all that illuminating +material unearthed by the explorations of hypnosis and especially of +psycho-analysis. Along with correct ideas about such matters as +digestion, sleep, and fatigue, I give, so far as the patient is able +to understand, a comprehension of the rights of the denied instincts, +the ways of the subconscious, the fettering hold of unfortunate +childish habits, the various mental mechanisms by which we fool +ourselves, and the ways by which we may make better adaptations. + +=According to the Patient.= The treatment varies according to the +nature of the trouble, and is somewhat dependent on the mentality of +the patient. There are many people who would only be confused by being +forced into a study of mental phenomena. Not being students, they +would be more bewildered than helped by the details of their inner +mechanisms. Others, of studious habits and inquiring minds, are +encouraged to browse at will in a library of psychotherapy and to +learn all that they can from the best authorities. + +In any case, I give the patients as much as they are able to take of +my own understanding of the subject. There are no secrets in this +method. The patient is treated as a rational human being who has +nothing to lose and everything to gain by the fullest knowledge that +he is able to acquire. Without forcing him to plunge in over his +depth, I encourage him to understand himself to the fullest possible +extent. Besides individual private conferences, we have twice a day an +informal gathering of all the patients in my household--"the family" +as we like to call ourselves--for a reading or talk on the various +ways of the body and the mind, which need to be understood for normal +living and for the cure of nerves. Very often people of only average +education, long without the opportunity of study, gain in a +surprisingly short time enough insight to make new adaptations and +cure themselves. For this, a college education is not nearly so +important as an open mind. It is because of the success of this method +that I have been encouraged to reach a larger number of people by +means of a book, based on the same plan of re-education. + +=Explanation vs. Suggestion.= Re-education through this kind of +explanation is simply a matter of learning the truth and acting upon +it. It is a process of real enlightenment, and is very different from +suggestion which trades upon the patient's credulity, increasing his +already exaggerated suggestibility. + +Freud illustrates the difference between suggestion and +psycho-analysis by saying that suggestion is like painting and +psycho-analysis like sculpture. Painting adds something from the +outside, plastering over the canvas with extraneous matter, while +sculpture cuts away the unnecessary material and reveals the angel in +the marble. So suggestion covers over the real trouble by crying, +"Peace, peace, when there is no peace." Without attempting to remove +the cause, it says to the patient: "You have no pain. You are not +tired. You will sleep to-night. You will be cheerful." Sometimes the +suggestion works and sometimes it does not, but at best the relief is +likely to be a mere temporary makeshift. The symptom may be relieved, +but the character is not changed and therefore no permanent relief is +assured. It is far better for a nervous person to say to himself, +"There is something wrong and I am going to find it," than to keep +repeating over and over, "There is nothing wrong," and so on through a +list of half-believed autosuggestions. + +On the other hand, psycho-analysis, and this kind of re-education +based on psycho-analytic principles, do not pay a great deal of +attention to the individual symptom. Instead of adding from without +they try to take away whatever has proved a hindrance to normal +growth and development, and to remove unnecessary resistances which +are responsible for the symptom, and which have been holding the +patient back from the fullest self-expression. + +=Incantation vs. Knowledge.= There came to me one day a well-known +public woman who had suffered from nervous indigestion for many years. +As she was able to be with me for only one night, we had time for just +one conversation, but in that time she discovered what she was doing +and lost her indigestion. In the course of the conversation she turned +to me, saying: "Doctor, I know what a force suggestion is. I believe +in its power. Will you tell me why I have not been able to cure myself +of this trouble? Every night after I go to bed I repeat over and over +these Bible verses," naming a number of passages relating to God's +goodness and care for His children. My answer was something like this: +"You are too intelligent a woman to be cured by an incantation. When +you feel surging up within you the sense of God's goodness, or when +you actually want to realize His loving kindness, then by all means +repeat the verses. But don't prostitute those wonderful words by +making them into a charm and then expect them to cure your +indigestion. It is a desecration of the words and a denial of your own +intelligence. Autosuggestion is a powerful force, but real +psychotherapy is based not on the mechanical repetition of any set of +words, but on a knowledge of the truth." + +=The "Bullying Method."= Sometimes, to be sure, explanation is not +enough. The brain paths between the associated ideas are so deeply +worn that no amount of persuasion avails. It is easy for the doubter +to say: "Well, that sounds very well, but my case is different. I have +tried over and over again and I know." With people of this sort, an +ounce of demonstration is worth a pound of argument. + +By way of illustration we might mention the man who couldn't eat eggs. +To be sure, he had tried many times but always had suffered the most +intense cramps in his stomach, and no amount of talk could make him +believe that an egg was not poison to him. I took the straight road of +simply proving to him that he was mistaken, and had him eat an egg. +After a time of apprehension and retching, he vomited the egg, +thinking, of course, that he had proved his point. To his +astonishment, I said, "Now, let's go and eat another." With great +consternation, he finally complied, evidently expecting to die on the +spot; but as I immediately prescribed a game of tennis, he scarcely +had time to think of the pain, which in fact failed to appear. +However, as he thereafter insisted on eating four eggs a day,--with +eggs at top-notch price I decided that the joke was on the doctor! + +=Enjoying the Right Things.= In substituting healthful complexes for +unhealthful ones, psychotherapy not only changes ideas and emotions, +but alters the feelings of pleasure or pain that are bound up with the +ideas. Dr. Tom A. Williams writes: "The essence of psychotherapy and +education is to associate useful activities with agreeable +feeling-tones and to dissociate from injurious acts the agreeable +feeling-tones that may have been acquired." Right character consists +not so much in enjoying things as in enjoying the right things. + +Some people enjoy being martyrs. They love to tell about the terrible +strain they have been under, the amount of work they have done, or the +number of times they have collapsed. One of my patients gave every +evidence of satisfaction as he told about his various breakdowns. "The +last time I was ill," or "That time when I was in the sanatorium," +were frequent phrases on his lips. Finally, after I had asked him if +he would boast about the number of times he had awkwardly fallen down +in the street, and had shown him that a neurosis is not really a +matter to be proud of, he saw the point and stopped taking pleasure in +his mistakes. + +Such signs of pleasure in the wrong things are evidence of suppressed +wishes which we do not acknowledge but try to gratify in indirect +ways.[46] The pleasure which ought to be associated with the idea of +good work well done has somehow been switched over to the idea of +being an invalid. The satisfaction which ought to go with a sense of +power and ability to do things has attached itself to the idea of +weakness and inability. The pleasurable feeling-tone which normally +belongs to ministering to others, regresses in the nervous invalid to +the infantile satisfaction of being ministered unto. + +[Footnote 46: For a further elaboration of this theme, see Holt: _The +Freudian Wish_.] + +But these things are only a habit. A good look in the mirror soon +makes one right about face and start in the other direction. Once +started, a good habit is built up with surprising ease. It is really +much more satisfying to cook a good dinner for the family's comfort +than to think about one's ills; much pleasanter to enjoy a good meal +than to insist on hot water and toast. Once we have satisfied our +suppressed longings in more desirable ways, or by a process of +self-training have initiated a new set of habits, we feel again the +old zest in normal affairs, the old interest and pleasure in +activities which add to the joy of life. Thus does re-education fit a +man to take his place in the world's work as a socially useful being, +no longer a burden, but a contributor to the sum total of human +happiness. + + +SUMMARY + +=Knowing and Doing.= Having set out to learn how to outwit our +nerves, we are now ready to sum up conclusions and in the following +chapters to apply them to the more common nervous symptoms. It has +been shown that a nervous person is in great need of change,--not, +indeed, a change in climate or in scene, in work or in diet, but a +change in the hidden recesses of his own being. Outwitting nerves +means first and foremost changing one's mind, an inner and spiritual +process very different from the kind of change which used to be +prescribed for the nervous invalid. + +As Putnam says, the slogan of the suggestion-school of psychotherapy +has always been, "You can do better if you try"; while that of the +psycho-analytic school is, "You can do better when you know." Refuting +the old adage, "Where ignorance is bliss 'tis folly to be wise," the +best methods of psychotherapy insist that the first step in any +thorough-going attempt to change oneself must be the great step of +self-knowledge. As the conflicts which result in "nerves" are always +far beyond those mental regions which are open to scrutiny, a real +self-knowledge requires an examination of the half-conscious or wholly +unconscious longings which are usually ignored. A real understanding +of self comes only when one is willing, to analyze his motives until +he sees the connection between them and his nervous symptoms, which +are but the symbolic gratification of desires he dares not +acknowledge. + +Although these deeply buried complexes are the real force behind a +nervous illness, the material out of which the symptoms are +manufactured is taken largely from superficial misconceptions +concerning the bodily functions. It is therefore a great help, also, +to possess a fund of information,--not technical nor detailed but +accurate as far as it goes,--about the more important workings of the +bodily machinery. A little knowledge about the actual chemistry of +fatigue and the way it is automatically cared for by the body is +likely to do away with the idea of nervous exhaustion as resulting +from accumulation of fatigue. A simple understanding of the biological +and physiological facts concerning the assimilation of food and the +elimination of waste material leaves the intelligent person less ready +to convert his psychic discomfort into indigestion and constipation. +Chapters IX to XIII in this book, which at first glance may seem to +belong to a work on physiology rather than on psychology are designed +to give just such needed insight. + +But knowing the truth is only the first half of the way out. Every +neurosis is a deliberate choice by a part of the personality. +Self-discovery is helpful only when it leads to better ways of +self-expression. The final aim of psychotherapy is the happy +adjustment of the individual to the demands of society and the +establishment of useful outlets for his energy. This phase of the +subject will be discussed more fully in Chapter XVI. + +=The Future Hope.= Much has been said about the cure of a neurosis. +There are enough people already in the maze of nervousness to warrant +the setting up of numerous signs reading, "This way out." But after +all, is not a blocking of the way in of vastly more importance? As it +is always easier to prevent than to cure, so it is easier to train +than to reform. If re-education is the cure, why is not education the +ounce of prevention which shall settle the problem for all time? + +If the general public understood what "nerves" are, it is hardly +conceivable that there could be so many breakdowns as there are at +present. If a man's family and friends, to say nothing of himself, +understood what he is doing when he suddenly collapses and has to quit +work, it is not likely that he would choose that way out of his +difficulties. + +Most important of all, when parents know that the foundation of +nervousness is laid in childhood, they will see to it that their +children are started right on the road to health. When fathers and +mothers realize that an over-strong bond between parents and children +is responsible for a large proportion of nervous troubles, most of +them will make sure that such exaggeration is not allowed to develop. + +And, finally, when parents are freed from their "conspiracy of +silence" by a reverent attitude toward the whole of life, their very +saneness will impart to their children a wholesome respect for the +reproductive instinct. There will then be found in the next generation +fewer half-starved men and women carrying the burden of unnecessary +repressions and the pain of unsatisfied yearnings. + +Not that such a day will usher in the millennium. We are not +suggesting a panacea for all the social ills. There is an inevitable +conflict between the instinctive urge of the life-force and the +demands of society, a conflict which makes men and women either finer +or baser, according to the way they handle it. What is claimed is that +the right kind of education--using the word in its largest, deepest +sense--will remove the most fruitful cause of nervousness by taking +away the extra burden of misconception and making it easier for people +to be "content with being moral."[47] + +[Footnote 47: Frink: _Morbid Fears and Compulsions._] + + + + +CHAPTER IX + +_In which we discover new stores of energy and learn the truth about +fatigue_ + +THAT TIRED FEELING + +UNFAILING RESOURCES + + +"They that wait upon the Lord shall renew their strength. They shall +mount up with wings as eagles. They shall run and not be weary. They +shall walk and not faint." + +It is safe to say that many a person loves this promise of the prophet +Isaiah without taking it in anything like a literal sense. The words +are considered to be so figurative and so highly spiritualized that +they seem scarcely to relate at all to this earthly life, much less to +the possibilities of these physical bodies. + +Besides the nervous folk who feel themselves so weary that they +scarcely have strength to live, there are thousands upon thousands of +men and women who are called normal but who have lost much of the joy +of life because they feel their bodies inadequate to meet the demands +of everyday living. + +To such men and women the Biblical promise, "As thy day, so shall thy +strength be," comes now as the message of modern science. Nature is +not stingy. She has not given the human race a meager inheritance. She +did not blunder when she made the human body, nor did she allow the +spirit of man to develop a civilization to whose demand his body is +not equal. After its long process of development through the survival +of the fittest, the human body, unless definitely diseased, is a +perfectly adequate instrument, as abundantly able to cope with the +complex demands of modern society as with the simpler but more +strenuous life of the stone age. The body has stored within its cells +enough energy in the shape of protein, carbohydrate and fat to meet +and more than meet any drains that are likely to be made upon it, +either through the monotony of the daily grind or the excitement of +sudden emergency. Nature never runs on a narrow margin. Her motto +seems everywhere to be, "Provide for the emergency, enough and to +spare, good measure, pressed down, running over." She does not start +her engines out with insufficient steam to complete the journey. On +the contrary, she has in most instances reserve boilers which are +almost never touched. As a rule the trouble is not so much a lack of +steam as the ignorance of the engineer who is unacquainted with his +engine and afraid to "let her out." + +="The Energies of Men."= Perhaps nothing has done so much to reveal +the hidden powers of mankind as that remarkable essay of Professor +William James, "The Energies of Men."[48] Listen to his introductory +paragraph as he opens up to us new "levels of energy" which are +usually "untapped": + +[Footnote 48: James: _On Vital Reserves_.] + + Every one knows what it is to start a piece of work, either + intellectual or muscular, feeling stale--or _cold_, as an + Adirondack guide once put it to me. And everybody knows what it + is to "warm up to his job." The process of warming up gets + particularly striking in the phenomenon known as the "second + wind." On usual occasions we make a practice of stopping an + occupation as soon as we meet the first effective layer (so to + call it) of fatigue. We have then walked, played or worked + "enough," so we desist. That amount of fatigue is an efficacious + obstruction on this side of which our usual life is cast. But if + an unusual necessity forces us to press onward, a surprising + thing occurs. The fatigue gets worse up to a certain critical + point, when gradually or suddenly it passes away, and we are + fresher than before. We have evidently tapped a level of new + energy, masked until then by the fatigue-obstacle usually obeyed. + There may be layer after layer of this experience. A third and + fourth "wind" may supervene. Mental activity shows the phenomenon + as well as physical, and in exceptional cases we + may find, beyond the very extremity of fatigue-distress, amounts + of ease and power that we never dreamed ourselves to own, sources + of strength habitually not taxed at all, because habitually we + never push through the obstruction, never pass those early + critical points. + +Again Professor James says: + + Of course there are limits; the trees don't grow into the sky. + But the plain fact remains that men the world over possess + amounts of resource which only very exceptional individuals push + to their extremes of use. But the very same individual, pushing + his energies to their extreme, may in a vast number of cases keep + the pace up day after day, and find no "reaction" of a bad sort, + so long as decent hygienic conditions are preserved. His more + active rate of energizing does not wreck him; for the organism + adapts itself, and as the rate of waste augments, augments + correspondingly the rate of repair.[49] + +[Footnote 49: Ibid., pp. 6-7.] + +Another psychologist, Boris Sidis, writes: "But a very small fraction +of the total amount of energy possessed by the organism is used in its +relation with the ordinary stimuli of its environment."[50] These +men--Professor James and Dr. Sidis--represent not young enthusiasts +who ignorantly fancy that every one shares their own abundant +strength, but careful men of science who have repeatedly been able to +unearth unsuspected supplies of energy in "worn out" men and women, +supposed to be at the end of their resources. Every successful +physician and every leader of men knows the truth of these statements. +What would have happened in the great war if Marshal Foch had not +known that his men possessed powers far beyond their ken, and had not +had sublime faith in the "second wind"? + +[Footnote 50: Sidis: P. 112 of the composite volume +_Pychotherapeutics_.] + +=What about Being Tired?= If all these things are true, why do people +need to be told? If man's equipment is so adequate and his reserves +are so ample, why after all these centuries of living does the human +race need to learn from science the truth about its own powers? The +average man is very likely to say that it is all very well for a +scientist sitting in his laboratory to tell him about hidden +resources, but that he knows what it is to be tired. Is not the crux +of the whole question summed up in that word "tired"? If we do not +need to rest, why should fatigue exist? If the purpose of fatigue +seems to be to slow down our efforts, why should we disregard it or +seek to evade its warnings? The whole question resolves itself into +this: What is fatigue? In view of the hampering effect of +misconception on this point, it is evident that the question is not +academic, but intensely practical. We shall find that fatigue is of +two kinds,--true and false, or physical and moral, or physiological +and nervous,--and that while the two kinds feel very much alike, +their origin and behavior are quite different. + + +PHYSIOLOGICAL FATIGUE + +=Fatigue, not Exhaustion.= In the first place, then, fatigue very +seldom means a lack of strength or an exhaustion of energy. The +average man in the course of a lifetime probably never knows what it +is to be truly exhausted. If he should become so tired that he could +in no circumstances run for his life, no matter how many wild beasts +were after him, then it might seem that he had drained himself of all +his store of energy. But even in that case, a large part of his +fatigue would be the result of another cause. + +=A Matter of Chemistry.= True fatigue is a chemical affair. It is the +result of recent effort,--physical, mental, or emotional,--and is the +sum of sensations arising from the presence of waste material in the +muscles and the blood. The whole picture becomes clear if we think of +the body as a factory whose fires continuously burn, yielding heat and +energy, together with certain waste material,--carbon dioxide and ash. +Within man's body the fuel, instead of being the carbon of coal is the +carbon of glycogen or animal starch, taken in as food and stored away +within the cells of the muscles and the liver. The oxygen for +combustion is continuously supplied by the lungs. So far the factory +is well equipped to maintain its fires. Nor does it fail when it comes +to carrying away waste products. Like all factories, the body has its +endless chain arrangement, the blood stream, which automatically picks +up the debris in its tiny buckets--the blood-cells and serum--and +carries it away to the several dumping-grounds in lungs, kidneys, +intestines, and skin. + +Besides the products of combustion, there are always to be washed away +some broken-down particles from the tissues themselves, which, like +all machinery, are being continuously worn out and repaired. By +chemical tests in the laboratory, the physiologist finds that a muscle +which has recently been in violent exercise contains among other +things carbon dioxid, urea, creatin, and sarco-lactic acid, none of +which are found in a rested muscle. Since all this debris is acid in +reaction and since we are "marine animals," at home only in salt water +or alkaline solution, the cells must be quickly washed of the fatigue +products, which, if allowed to accumulate, would very soon poison the +body and put out the fires. + +=No Back Debts.= The human machine is regulated to carry away its +fatigue products as fast as they are made, with but slight lagging +behind that is made good in the hours of sleep, when bodily activities +are lessened and time is allowed for repair. Unless the body is +definitely diseased, it virtually never carries over its fatigue from +one day to another. In the matter of fatigue, there are no old debts +to pay. Nature renews herself in cycles, and her cycle is twenty-four +hours,--not nine or ten months as many school-teachers seem to +imagine, or eleven months as some business men suppose. In order to +make assurance doubly sure, many set apart every seventh day for a +rest day, for change of occupation and thought, and for catching up +any slight arrears which might exist. But the point is that a healthy +body never gets far behind. + +If through some flaw in the machine, waste products do pile up, they +destroy the machine. If the heart leaks or the blood-cells fail in +their carrying-power, or if lungs, kidneys or skin are out of repair, +there is sometimes an accumulation of fatigue products which poisons +the whole system and ends in death. But the person with tuberculosis +or heart trouble does not usually allow this to happen. The body +incapacitated by disease limits its activities as closely as possible +within the range of its power to take care of waste matter. Even the +sick body does not carry about its old toxins. The man who had not +eliminated the poisons of a month-old effort would not be a tired man. +He would be a dead man. + +=A Sliding Scale.= If all this be true, real fatigue can only be the +result of recent effort. If one is still alive, the results of earlier +effort must long since have disappeared. The tissue-cells retain not +the slightest trace of its effects. Fatigue cannot possibly last, +because it either kills us or cures itself. Up to a certain point, far +beyond our usual high-water mark, the more a person does the more he +can do. As Professor James has pointed out, the rate of repair +increases with the rate of combustion. Under unusual stress, the rate +of the whole machine is increased: the heart-pump speeds up, +respirations deepen and quicken, the blood flows faster, the endless +chain of filling and emptying buckets hurries the interchange of +oxygen and carbon dioxid, until the extreme capacity is reached and +the organism refuses to do more without a period of rest. + +The whole arrangement illustrates the wonderful provisions of Nature. +Although each individual is continuously manufacturing enough +carbonic-acid gas to kill himself in a very few minutes, he need not +be alarmed for fear that he may forget to expel his own poisons. +Nobody can hold his breath for more than a few minutes. The naughty +baby sometimes tries, but when he begins to get black in the face, he +takes a breath in spite of himself. The presence of carbonic-acid gas +in the circulation automatically regulates breathing, and the greater +the amount of gas the deeper the breath. The faster we burn the faster +we blow. As with breathing, so with all the rest of elimination and +repair. The body dares not get behind. + +="Second Wind."= A city man frequently sets out on a mountain tramp +without any muscular preparation for the trip. He walks ten or fifteen +miles when his average is not over one or two. Sometimes after a few +hours he feels himself exhausted, but a glorious view opens out before +him and he goes on with new zest. He has merely increased his rate of +repair and drawn on a new stock of energy. That night he is tired, and +the next day he is likely to be stiff and sore. There is a little +fatigue left in him, but it takes only a day or two for the body to be +wholly refreshed, especially if he hastens the process by another good +walk. Up to a certain point, far beyond our usual limit, the more we +do, the more we can do. + +One day after a long walk my little daughter said that she could go no +farther and waited to be carried. But she soon spied a dog on ahead +and ran off after him with new zest. She followed the dog back and +forth, running more than a mile before she reached home, and then in +the exuberance of her spirits, ran around the house three times. + +=The Emotions Again.= What is the key that unlocks new stores of +energy and drives away fatigue? What is it in the amateur +mountain-climbers that helps the body maintain its new standard? What +keeps indefatigable workers on the job long after the ordinary man has +tired? Is it not always an invigorating emotion,--the zest of +pursuit, the joy of battle, intense interest in work, or a new +enthusiasm? All great military commanders know the importance of +morale. They know that troops can stand more while they are going +forward than while running away, that the more contented and hopeful +they are, the better fighters they make; discouragement, lack of +interest, the fighting of a losing game, dearth of appreciation, +futility of effort, monotony of task, all conspire in soldier or +civilian to use up and to lock up energy which might have been +available for real work. Approaching the matter from a new angle, we +find once more that the difference between strength and weakness is in +many cases merely a difference in the emotions and feeling-tones which +habitually control. + +Fatigue is a safety-device of nature to keep us within safe limits, +but it is a device toward which we must not become too sensitive. As a +rule it makes us stop long before the danger point is reached. If we +fall into the habit of watching its first signals, they may easily +become so insistent that they monopolize attention. Attention +increases any sensation, especially if colored by fear. Fear adds to +the waste matter of fatigue little driblets of adrenalin and other +secretions which must somehow be eliminated before equilibrium is +reestablished. This creates a vicious circle. We are tired, hence we +are discouraged. We are discouraged, hence we are more tired. This +kind of "tire" is a chemical condition, but it is produced not by work +but by an emotion. He who learns to take his fatigue philosophically, +as a natural and harmless phenomenon which will soon disappear if +ignored, is likely to find himself possessed of exceptional strength. +We can stand almost any amount of work, provided we do not multiply it +by worry. We can even stand a good deal of real anxiety provided it is +not turned in on ourselves and directed toward our own health. + +="Decent Hygienic Conditions."= If fatigue products cannot pile up, +why is extra rest ever needed? Because there is a limit to the supply +of fuel. If the fat-supply stored away for such emergencies finally +becomes low, we may need an extra dose of sleeping and eating in order +to let the reservoirs fill again. But this never takes very long. The +body soon fills in its reserves if it has anything like common-sense +care. The doctrine of reserve energy does not warrant a careless +burning of the candle at both ends. It presupposes "decent hygienic +conditions,"--eight hours in bed, three square meals a day, and a fair +amount of fresh air and exercise. + +="Over There."= On the other hand, the stories that floated back to us +from the war zone illustrate in the most powerful way what the human +body can do when necessity forbids the slightest attention to its +needs. One of the best of these stories is Dorothy Canfield's account +of Dr. Girard-Mangin, "France's Fighting Woman Doctor." Better than +any abstract discussion of human endurance is this vibrant narrative +of that little woman, "not very strong, slightly built, with some +serious constitutional weakness," who lived through hardships and +accomplished feats of daring which would have been considered beyond +the range of possibility--before the war. + +Think of her out there in her leaky makeshift hospital with her twenty +crude helpers and her hundreds of mortally sick typhoid patients; four +hundred and seventy days of continuous service with no place to +sleep--when there was a chance--except a freezing, wind-swept attic in +a deserted village. Think of her in the midst of that terrible Battle +of Verdun, during four black nights without a light, among those +delirious men, and then during the long, long ride with her dying +patients over the shell-swept roads. Listen to her as she speaks of +herself at the end of that ride, without a place to lay her head: "Oh, +then I did feel tired! That morning for the first time I knew how +tired I was, as I went dragging myself from door to door begging for a +room and a bed. It was because I was no longer working, you see. As +long as you have work to do you can go on." Then listen to her as she +receives her orders to rush to a new post, before she has had time to +lay herself on the bed she has finally found. "Then at once my +tiredness went away. It only lasted while I thought of getting to bed. +When I knew we were going into action once more, I was myself again." +Watch her as she rides on through the afternoon and the long dangerous +night; as she swallows her coffee and plum-cake, and operates for five +hours without stopping; as she sleeps in the only place there is--a +"quite comfortable chair" in a corner; and as she keeps up this life +for twenty days before she is sent--not on a vacation, mind you, but +to another strenuous post.[51] + +[Footnote 51: Dorothy Canfield: _The Day of Glory._] + +This brave little woman is not an isolated example of extraordinary +powers. The human race in the great war tapped new reservoirs of power +and discovered itself to be greater than it knew. Professor James's +assertions are completely proved,--that "as a rule men habitually use +only a small part of the powers which they actually possess," and that +"most of us may learn to push the barrier (of fatigue) further off, +and to live in perfect comfort on much higher levels of power." + +=How?= The practical question is: how may we--the men and women of +ordinary powers, away from the extraordinary stimulus of a crisis like +the great war--attain our maximum and drop off the dreary mantle of +fatigue which so often holds us back from our best efforts? It may be +that the first step is simply getting a true conception of physical +fatigue as something which needs to be feared only in case of a +diseased body, and which is quite likely to disappear under a little +judicious neglect. + +In the second place, fatigue shows itself to be closely bound up with +emotions and instincts. The great releasers of energy are the +instincts. What but the mothering instinct and the love of country +could uncover all those unsuspected reserves of Dr. Girard-Mangin and +others of her kind? What is it but the enthusiasm for work which +explains the indefatigable energy of Edison and Roosevelt? If the +wrong kind of emotion locks up energy, the right kind just as surely +unlocks great stores which have hitherto lain dormant. If most people +live below their possibilities, it is either because they have not +learned how to utilize the energy of their instinctive emotions in the +work they find to do, or because some of their strongest instincts +which are meant to supply motive power to the rest of life are locked +away by false ideas and unnecessary repressions, and so fail to feed +in the energy which they control. In such a case, the "spring tonic" +that is needed is a self-knowledge which shall release us from +hampering inhibitions and set us free for enthusiastic +self-expression. + + +NERVOUS FATIGUE + +_What of the Nervous Invalid?_ If the normal man lives constantly +below his maximum, what shall we say of the nervous invalid? +Fatigability is the very earmark of his condition. In many instances +he seems scarcely able to raise his hand to his head. Sometimes he can +scarcely speak for weariness. Frequently to walk a block sends him to +bed for a week. I once had a patient who felt that she had to raise +her eyelids very slowly for fear of over-exertion. She could speak +only about two or three words a day, the rest of the time talking in +whispers. She could not raise a glass to her lips if it were full of +water, but could manage it if only half full. A person nearly dead +with some fatal disease does not appear more powerless than a typical +neurasthenic. + +If it he true that accumulation of fatigue is promptly fatal, what +shall we say of the woman who says that she is still exhausted from +the labor of a year ago,--or of ten years ago? What of the business +man who travels from sanatorium to sanatorium because five years ago +he went through a strenuous year? What of the college student who is +broken down because he studied too hard, or the teacher who is worn +out because of ten hard years of teaching? There can be but one +answer. No matter what their feelings, they can be suffering from no +true physiological fatigue. Something very real has happened to them, +but only through ignorance and the power of suggestion can it be +called fatigue and attributed to overwork. + +=Stories of Real People.= Perhaps if we look over the stories of a few +people who have been members of my household, we may work our way to +an understanding of the truth. We give only the barest outline of the +facts, thinking that the cumulative effect of a number of cases will +outweigh a more detailed description of one or two. The most casual +survey shows that whatever it was that burdened these fine men and +women, it was not lack of energy. No matter how extreme had been their +exhaustion, they were able at once, without rest or any other physical +treatment, to summon strength for exertions quite up to those of a +normal person. + +The second point that stands out clearly to any one acquainted with +these inner histories is the conviction that in each case the trouble +was related in some way to the unsatisfied love-life, to the insistent +and thwarted instinct of reproduction. In some cases no search was +made for the cause. The simple explanation that there was no lack of +power was sufficient to release inhibited energy. But in every case +where the cause was sought, it was found to be some outer lack of +satisfaction, or some inner repression of the love-force. + +=From Prostration to Tennis.= One young woman, Miss A., had suffered +for ten years from the extremest kind of fatigue. She could not walk a +block without support and without the feeling of great exhaustion. +Before her illness she had had a sweetheart. Not understanding her +normal physical sensations when he was near, she had felt them +extremely wicked and had repressed them with all her strength. Later, +she broke off the engagement, and a little while after developed the +neurosis. Within a week after coming to my house, she was playing +tennis, walking three miles to church, and generally living the life +of a normal person. + +=Making Her Own Discoveries.= Then there was Miss B. who for four +years had been "exhausted." She had such severe pains in her legs that +she was almost helpless. If she sewed for half an hour on the sewing +machine, she would be in bed for two weeks. Although she was engaged +to be married, she could not possibly shop for her trousseau. Two +years before, a very able surgeon had been of the opinion that the +pain in the legs was caused by an ovarian tumor. He removed the tumor, +assuring the patient that she would be cured. However, despite the +operation and the force of the suggestion, the pains persisted. + +After she had been with me for a few days, she sewed for an hour on +the machine. In a day or so she took a four-mile walk in a cañon near +the house and, on returning in the afternoon, walked two and a half +miles down town to do some shopping. I did not make an analysis in +her case because she recovered so quickly,--going home well within two +weeks. But she declared that she had found the cause while reading in +one of the books on psychology. I had my suspicions that the +long-drawn-out engagement had something to do with the trouble, but I +did not confirm my opinion. A long engagement, by continually +stimulating desire without satisfying it, only too often leads to +nervous illness. + +=Afraid of Heat.= Professor X., of a large Eastern college, had been +incapacitated for four years with a severe fatigue neurosis and an +intense fear of heat. Constantly watching the weather reports, he was +in the habit of fleeing to the Maine coast whenever the +weather-prophet predicted warm weather. After a short reëducation, he +discovered that his fatigue was symbolic of an inner feeling of +inadequacy, and that it bore no relation to his body. Discarding his +weariness and throwing all his energies into the Liberty Loan +Campaign, he found himself speaking almost continuously throughout one +of the hottest days in the history of California, with the thermometer +standing at 107 degrees. After that he had no doubt as to his cure. + +=In Bed from Fear.= Miss C. was carried into my house rolled in a +blanket. She had been confined to her bed except for fifteen minutes a +day, during which time she was able to lie in a hammock! It seems +that her illness was the result of fear, an over-reaction to early +teaching about self-abuse. Her mother had frightened her terribly by +giving her the false idea that this practice often leads to insanity. +Having indulged in self-abuse, she believed herself going insane, and +very naturally succumbed to the effects of such a fear. After a few +days of re-education, she was as strong as any average person. Having +no clothing but for a sick-room, she borrowed hat, skirt, and shoes, +and walked to church, a three-mile walk. + +=Empty Hands.= Miss Y., a fine woman of middle age, suffering from +extreme fatigue could neither sleep nor eat. She could only weep. She +had spent her life taking care of an invalid girl who had recently +died. Now her hands were empty. Like many a mother whose family has +grown up, she had no outlet for her mothering instinct, and her sense +of impotency expressed itself in the only way it knew how,--through +her body. As there is never any lack of unselfish work to be done, or +of people who need mothering, she soon found herself and learned how +to sublimate her energy in useful activities. + +=Defying Nature.= One young man from Wyoming had felt himself obliged +to give up his business because he could neither work nor eat. It soon +cropped out that he and his wife had decided that they must not have +any children. With a better understanding of the great forces which +they were defying, his strength and his appetite came back and he went +back to work, rejoicing. + +=Left-over Habits.= Often a state of fatigue is the result of a +carried-over habit. One of my patients, a young girl, had several +years before been operated on for exophthalmic goiter. This is a +disease of the thyroid gland, and is characterized by rapid heart, +extreme fatigue, and numerous other symptoms. Although this girl's +goiter had been removed, the symptoms still persisted. She could not +walk nor do even a little work, like wiping a few dishes. I took her +down on the beach, let her feel her own pulse and mine and then ran +with her on the sand. Again I let her feel our pulses and discover for +herself that hers had quickened no more than was normal and had slowed +down as soon as mine. After a few such lessons, she was convinced that +her symptoms were reverberations for which there was no longer any +physical cause. + +Another young girl, Miss L., had had a similar operation for goiter +six years before. Since that time she had been virtually bedridden. +During the first meal she had at my house her sister sat by her couch +because she must not be left alone. By the second meal the sister had +gone, and Miss L. ate at the table with the other guests. That night +she managed to crawl upstairs, with a good deal of assistance and +with great terror at the probable results of such an effort. After +that, she walked up-stairs alone whenever she had occasion to go to +her room. Her heart will always be a little rapid and her body will +never be very strong, but she now lives a helpful happy life at home +and among her friends. + +In cases like this the exaggeration proves the counterfeit. Nobody +could have been so down and out _physically_ without dying. The +exaggeration secures attention and gives the little satisfaction to +the natural desires which are denied expression, and which gain an +outlet through habit along the lines previously worn by the real +disease. Many a person is still suffering from an old pain or an old +disability whose cause has long since disappeared, but which is +stamped on the mind and believed in as a present reality. Since the +sensation is as real as ever, it is sometimes very hard to believe +that it is not legitimate, but if the person is intelligent, a little +explanation and re-education usually suffices. + +=Twenty Years an Invalid.= Mr. S., from Ohio, had spent much of his +time for twenty years going from one sanatorium to another. There was +scarcely a health resort in the country with which he was not +familiar. The day he came to me he felt himself completely exhausted +by the two-block walk from the car. He explained that he could +scarcely listen to what I was saying because his brain was so fagged +that concentration was impossible. When asked to read a book, he +dramatically exclaimed, "Books and I have parted company!" I set him +to work reading "Dear Enemy" but it was not a week before he was +devouring the deeper books on psychology, in complete forgetfulness of +the pains in his head. Playing golf and walking at least six miles +every day, he rejoiced in a new sense of strength in his body, which +for twenty years he had considered "used up." He is now doing a +man-sized job in the business and philanthropic life of his home city. + +=Brain-fag.= This feeling of brain-fag is one of the commonest nervous +symptoms; and almost always it is supposed to be the result of +intellectual overwork. Some people who easily accept the idea that +physical work cannot cause nervous breakdown can scarcely give up the +deep-rooted notion that intense mental work is harmful. Intellectual +effort does give rise to fatigue in exactly the same way as does +physical exertion, but the body takes care of the waste products of +the one just as it does those of the other. Du Bois says that out of +all his nervous cases he has not found one which can be traced to +intellectual overwork. I can say the same thing, and I know no case in +all the literature of the subject whose symptoms I can believe to be +the result of mental labor. + +The college students who break down are not wrecked by intellectual +work. In some cases, one strong factor in their undoing is the strain +and readjustment necessary because of the discrepancies between some +of their deepest religious beliefs and the truth as they learn it in +the class-room. The other factors are merely those which play their +part in any neurosis. + +=Re-educating the Teacher.= School-teachers are prone to believe +themselves worn out from the mental work and the strain of the +strenuous life of teaching. Many a fine, conscientious teacher has +come to me with this story of overwork. But the school-teacher is as +easily re-educated as is any one else. I usually begin the process by +stating that I taught school myself for ten years and can speak from +experience. After I explain that there is no physical reason why the +teachers of some cities are fagged out at the end of nine months while +those in other cities whose session is longer can hold on for ten +months, and stenographers who lead just as strenuous a life manage to +exist with only a two-weeks' vacation, they begin to see that perhaps +after all they have been fooling themselves by a suggestion, "setting" +themselves for just so long and expecting to be done up at the end of +the term. Many of these same teachers have gone back to their work +with a new sense of "enough and to spare" and some of them have +written back that they have passed triumphantly through especially +trying years with no sense of depletion. + +In any work, it is the feeling of strain which tells, the emotionalism +and feeling sorry for oneself because one has a hard job. It is +wonderful what a sense of power comes from the simple idea that we are +equal to our tasks. + +=Sudden Relief.= The story of Mr. V. illustrates Professor James's +statement that often the fatigue gets worse up to a certain critical +point, and then suddenly passes away. Mr. V. was another patient who +was "physically exhausted." When the rest of "the family" went +clamming on the beach, he felt himself too weak for such exertions, so +I left him on the sand to hold the bag while the rest of us dug for +clams. The minute I turned my back he disappeared. I found him lying +flat on his back, resting, behind the bulk-head. I decided that he +needed the two-mile walk home and we all set out to walk. "Doctor, +this is cruel. It is dangerous. My knees can never stand this. I shall +be ill!" ran the constant refrain for the first mile. Then things went +a bit better. Toward the last he found, to his absolute astonishment, +that the fatigue had entirely rolled away. The last half-mile he +accomplished with perfect ease. Needless to say, he never again +complained of physical exhaustion. + +=False Neuritis.= Miss T. was suffering from fatigue and very severe +pains in her arms, pains which were supposed to be the result of real +neuritis, but which did not correspond to the physiological picture of +that disease. A consultation revealed the fact that her love-instinct +had been repeatedly stimulated, and then at the last, when it had +expected satisfaction, had been disappointed. A discussion of her +life, its inner forces, and her future aims helped to pull her +together again and give her instinct new outlets. The pains and the +fatigue disappeared at once. + +=Something Wrong.= These cases are chosen at random and are typical of +scores of others. In no single case was the trouble feigned or +imaginary or unreal. But in every case it was a mistake. _The sense of +loss of muscular power was really a sense of loss of power on the part +of the soul._ Some inner force was reaching out, reaching out after +something which it could never quite attain. As it happened, in every +case that I analyzed, the force which felt itself defeated and +inadequate was the thwarted instinct of reproduction. Like a man +pinned to the ground by a stronger force, it felt itself most helpless +while struggling the hardest. Just as we feel a thrill of fright when +we step up in the dark and find no step there, so this instinct had +gotten itself ready for a step which was not there. Inner repressions +or outer circumstances had denied satisfaction and left only an +undefined sense that something was wrong. The life-force, feeling +itself helpless, limp, tired, had no way of expressing itself except +in terms of the body. Since expression is itself a relief and an +outlet for feeling, the denied desire had seized on suggestions of +overwork to explain its sense of weariness, and had symbolized its +soul-pain by converting it into a physical pain. The feeling of +inadequacy was very real, but it was simply displaced from one part of +the personality to another,--from an unknown, inarticulate part to one +which was more familiar and which had its own means of expression. + +=Locked-up Energy.= We do not know just how the soul can make its pain +so intensely real to the body, but we do know that any conviction on +the part of the subconscious mind is quickly expressed in the physical +machine. A conviction of pain or of powerlessness is very soon +converted into a feeling which can scarcely be denied. The mere +suggestion that the body is overworked is enough to make it tired. + +We know, too, that the instincts are the great releasers of energy. So +it happens that when our most dynamic instinct--that for the +reproduction of the race--is repressed, we lack one of the greatest +sources of usable energy. The energy is there, but it is not +accessible. Inhibited and locked away, it is not fed into the engine, +and we feel exactly as though it were _nil_. Despite its name, the +disease neurasthenia does not signify a real asthenia or weakness. +Rather, it is a disorder in which there is plenty of energy that has +somehow been temporarily misplaced. Then, too, we must remember that +under the depressing influence of chronic fear, not quite so much +energy is stored away as would otherwise be. All the bodily functions +are slowed down; food is not so completely assimilated, the heart-beat +is weakened, the breathing is more shallow, and fatigue products are +more slowly eliminated. As Du Bois says, "An emotion tires the +organism more than the most intense physical or intellectual work." + +=Avoid the Rest-Cure.= It is a healthful sign that the rest-cure is +fast going out of style. Wherever it has helped a nervous patient, the +real curative agent has been the personality of the doctor and the +patient's faith in him. The whole theory was based on ignorance of the +cause of nerves. People suffering from "nervous exhaustion" are likely +to be just as "tired" after a month in bed as they were before. Why +not? Physical fatigue is quickly remedied, and what can rest do after +that? What possible effect can rest have on the fatigue of a +discouraged instinct? Since the best releaser of energy is enthusiasm, +don't try to get that by lying around in bed or playing checkers at a +health resort. + + +SUMMARY + +If you are chronically and perpetually fatigued, or if you tire more +easily than the other people you know, consult a competent physician +and let him look you over. If he tells you that you have neither +tuberculosis, heart trouble, Bright's disease, nor any other +demonstrable disease, that you are physically fit and "merely +nervous," give yourself a good shake and commit the following +paragraphs to memory. + + + A CATECHISM FOR THE WEARY ONE + + WHAT? + + Q. What is fatigue? + + A. It is a chemical condition resulting from effort that is very + recent. + + Q. What else creates fatigue? + + A. Worry, fear, resentment, discontent, and other depressing + emotions. + + Q. What magnifies fatigue? + + A. Attention to the feeling. + + Q. What makes us weary long after the cause is removed? + + A. Habit. + + WHY? + + Q. Why do many people believe themselves over-worked? + + A. Because of the power of suggestion. + + Q. Why do they take the suggestion? + + A. Because it serves their need and expresses their inner feelings. + + Q. Why are they willing to choose such an uncomfortable mode of + expression? + + A. Because they don't know what they are doing, and the + subconscious is very insistent. + + WHO? + + Q. Who gets up tired every morning? + + A. The neurotic. + + Q. Who fancies his brain so exhausted that a little concentration + is impossible? + + A. The neurotic. + + Q. Who still believes himself exhausted as the result of work that + is now ancient history? + + A. The neurotic. + + Q. Who lays all his woes to overwork? + + A. The neurotic. + + Q. Who complains of fatigue before he has well begun? + + A. The neurotic. + + Q. Who may drop his fatigue as soon as he "gets the idea?" + + A. The neurotic. + + HOW? + + Q. How can he get the idea? + + A. By understanding himself. + + Q. How may he express his inner feelings? + + A. By choosing a better way. + + Q. How can he forget his fatigue? + + A. By ignoring it. + + Q. How can he ignore it? + + A. By finding a good stiff job. + + If he wants advice in a nutshell, here it is: Get understanding! + Get courage! Get busy! + + + + +CHAPTER X + +_In which the ban is lifted_ + +DIETARY TABOOS + +MISUNDERSTOOD STOMACHS + + +=Modern Improvements.= Most people have heard the story of the little +girl who wanted to know what made her hair snap. After she had been +informed that there was probably electricity in her hair, she sat +quiet for a few minutes and then exclaimed: "Our family has all the +modern improvements! I have electricity in my hair and Grandma has gas +on her stomach!" Judged by this standard many American families are +well abreast of the times; and if we include among the modern +improvements not only gas on the stomach but also nervous dyspepsia, +acid stomach, indigestion, sick-headache, and biliousness, we must +conclude that a good proportion of the population is both modern and +improved. + +Despite all this the stomach is one of the best-equipped mechanisms in +the world. It, at least, is not modern. After their age-long +development the organs of the body are remarkably standardized and +adapted to the work required of them. It is safe to say that ninety +per cent. of all so-called "stomach trouble" is due not to any +inherent weakness of the organ itself but to a misunderstanding +between the stomach and its owner. + +=Organic Trouble.= Unfortunately, there are a few real organic causes +for trouble. There are a few cancers of the stomach and a certain +number of ulcers. But if the patients whom I have seen are in any way +typical, the ulcers that really are cannot compare in number with the +ulcers that are supposed to be. Patients go to physicians with so many +tales of digestive distress that even the best doctors are fooled +unless they are especially alert to the ways of "nerves." They must +find some explanation for all the various functional disturbances +which the patients report, and as they are in the habit of taking only +the body into account, they find the diagnosis of stomach ulcer as +satisfactory as any. + +There is, of course, such a thing as an enlarged or sagging stomach. +But it is only in the rarest of cases that such a condition leads to +any functional disturbances unless complicated by suggestion. In most +cases a person can go about his business as happily as ever unless he +gets the idea that ptosis must inevitably lead to pain and discomfort. + +Confusion sometimes arises when the stomach is blamed for +disturbances which originate elsewhere. One day a very sick-looking +girl came to me with eager expectation written all over her face. Her +stomach was misbehaving and she had heard that I could cure nervous +indigestion. It needed little more than a glance to know that she was +suffering from organic heart trouble. A boy of sixteen had been taking +a stomach-tonic for three months, but the thin, wiry pulse pointed to +a different ailment. His digestive disturbances were merely the echo +of an organic disease of the kidneys. When the body is burdened by +disease, it may have little energy left for digesting food, but in +that case the trouble must be sought in other quarters than the +stomach. + +Aside from a few organic difficulties, there is almost no real disease +of the stomach. Its misdoings are not matters of food and chemistry, +muscle-power and nerve supply, but are the end results of slips in the +mental and emotional life of its owner. + +=Fads Dynamogenic.= What is it that gives the impetus to fads about +eating, or about religious belief? Are they advocated by the +individual whose libido is finding abundant expression in the natural +channels of business and family life, or by his less fortunate brother +who can gain a sense of power only by means of some unaccustomed idea? +William James says: + + This leads me to say a word about ideas considered as dynamogenic + agents or stimuli for unlocking what would otherwise be unused + reservoirs of individual power.... In general, whether a given + idea shall be a live idea depends more on the person into whose + mind it is injected than on the idea itself. Which is the + suggestive idea for this person and which for that one? Mr. + Fletcher's disciples regenerate themselves by the idea (and the + fact) that they are chewing and re-chewing and super-chewing + their food. Dr. Dewey's pupils regenerate themselves by going + without their breakfast--a fact, but also an ascetic idea. Not + every one can use these ideas with the same success. + +Because it is so adaptable and sturdy, the stomach lends itself +readily to these devices for gaining self-expression; but the danger +lies in bringing the process of digestion into conscious attention +which interferes with automatic functioning. Still further, the +disregard of physiological chemistry is likely to deprive the body of +food-stuffs which it requires. + +The average person is too sensible to be carried off his feet by the +enthusiasm of the health-crank, but as most of us are likely to pick +up a few false notions, it may be well to be armed with the simple +principles of food chemistry in order to combat the fads which so +easily beset us and to know why we are right when we insist on eating +three regular meals of the mixed and varied diet which has proved +best for the race through so many years of trial and experience. + + +WHAT WE NEED TO EAT + +=The Essence of Dietetics.= To the layman the average discussion of +food principles is, to say the least, confusing. Dealing largely, as +it does, with unfamiliar terms like carbohydrate and hydrocarbon and +calories, it is hard to translate into the terms of the potatoes left +over from dinner and the vegetables we can afford to buy. But the +practical deductions are not at all difficult to understand. Boiled +down to their simplest terms, the essential principles may be stated +in a few sentences. The body must secure from the food that we eat, +tissue for its cells, energy for immediate use or to be stored for +emergency, mineral salts, vitamins, water and a certain bulk from +fruits and vegetables,--this latter to aid in the elimination of waste +matter. + +Food for repairing bodily tissue is called protein and is secured from +meat, eggs, milk, and certain vegetables, notably peas. Fuel for heat +and energy is in two forms--carbohydrate (starch and sugar) and fat. +We get sugar from sugar-cane and beets, and from syrups, fruit, and +honey. Starch is furnished from flour products--mainly bread--from +rice, potatoes, macaroni, tapioca, and many vegetables. Fats come from +milk and butter, from nuts, from meat-fat--bacon, lard and suet--and +from vegetable oils. The mineral salts are obtained mainly from fruit +and vegetables, which also provide certain mysterious vitamins +necessary for health, but as yet not well understood. + +=What the Market Affords.= The moral from all this is plain. The human +body needs all the foods which are ordinarily served on the table. +Whenever, through fad or through fear, we leave out of our diet any +standard food, we are running a risk of cutting the body down on some +element which it needs. They say that variety is the spice of life. In +the matter of food it is more than that, it is the essence of life. +Eat everything that the market affords and you will be sure to be well +nourished. If you leave out meat you will make your body work overtime +to secure enough tissue material from other foods. If you leave out +white bread, you will lose one of the greatest sources of energy. If +you leave out tomatoes and cucumbers and strawberries, you deprive +your body of the salts and vitamins which are essential. + +=A Simple Rule.= There is one point that is good to remember. The +average person needs twice as much starch as he needs of protein and +fat together. That is, if he needs four parts of protein and three of +fat, he ought to eat about fourteen parts of starch. This does not +mean that we need to bother ourselves with troublesome tables of what +to eat, but only to keep in mind in a general way that we need more +bread and potatoes than we do meat and eggs. The body does not have +to rebuild itself every day. It is probable that a good many people +eat too much protein food. If a man is doing hearty work he must have +a good supply of meat, but the average person needs only a moderate +amount. Here again, the habits of the more intelligent families are +likely to come pretty near the dictates of science. + +=For the Children.= The mother of a family ought to know that the +children need plenty of bread, butter, and milk. Despite all the +notions to the contrary, good well-baked white bread is neither +indigestible nor constipating. It is indeed the staff of life. Two +large slices should form the background of every meal, unless there is +an extraordinary amount of other starchy food or unless the person is +too fat. Milk-fat (from whole milk, cream, and butter) is by far the +best fat for children. Besides fat, it furnishes a certain +growth-principle necessary for development. As the dairyman cannot +raise good calves on skimmed milk, so we cannot raise robust children +without plenty of butter and milk. The pity of it is that poor people +are forced to try! Milk is also the best protein for children, whose +kidneys may be overstrained by trying to care for the waste matter +from an excessive quantity of eggs and meat. Bread and butter, milk, +fruit, vegetables, and sugar in ample quantities and meat and eggs in +moderate quantities are pretty sure to make the kind of children we +want. Above all things, let us train them not to be afraid of normal +amounts of any regular food or of any combination of foods. + +=The Fear of Mixtures.= There are many people who can without +flinching face almost any single food, but who quail before mixtures. +Perhaps there is no notion which is more firmly entrenched in the +popular mind than this fear of certain food-combinations, acquired +largely from the advertisements of certain so-called "food +specialists." + +The most persistent idea is the fear of acid and milk. It is +interesting to watch the new people when they first come to my table. +Confronted with grape-fruit and cream at the same meal, or oranges and +milk, or cucumbers and milk, they eat under protest, in consternation +over the disastrous results that are sure to follow. Out of all these +scores of people, many of whom are supposed to have weak stomachs, I +have never had one case of indigestion from such a combination. When a +person knows that the stomach juices themselves include hydrochloric +acid which is far more acid than any orange or grapefruit, that the +milk curdles as soon as it reaches the stomach, and that it must +curdle if it is to be digested, he has to be very "set" indeed if he +is to cling to any remnant of fear. + +Of course to say that the stomach is well prepared chemically, +muscularly, and by its nerve supply to handle any combination of +ordinary food in ordinary amounts is not the same thing as saying that +we may devour with impunity any amount of anything. It is a good thing +for every one to know when he has reached his limit, and a person with +organic heart disease should avoid eating large quantities at one +time, or when he is extraordinarily fatigued or emotionally disturbed, +lest at such a time he may put a fatal strain on the pneumogastric +nerve that controls both stomach and heart. + + +THE FEAR OF CERTAIN FOODS + +=Physical Idiosyncrasies.= Most of our false fears on food subjects +come from some tradition--either a social tradition or a little +private, pet tradition of one's own. Some one once was ill after +eating strawberries and cream. What more natural than to look back to +those little curdles in the dish and to start the tradition that such +mixtures are dangerous? The worst of it is that the taboo habit is +very likely to grow. One after another, innocent foods are thrown out +until one wonders what is left. A patient of mine, Mr. G., told me +that he had a short time before gone to a physician with a tale of woe +about his sour stomach. "What are you eating?" asked the doctor. "Bran +crackers and prunes." "Then," said the learned doctor, "you will have +to cut out the prunes!" Needless to say, this man ate everything at my +table, and flourished accordingly. + +There may be such a thing as physical idiosyncrasies for certain +foods. I have often heard of them, but I have never seen one. I have +often challenged my patients to show me some of the "spells" which +they say invariably follow the eating of certain foods, but I have +almost never been given an exhibition. The man who couldn't eat eggs +did throw up once, but he couldn't do it a second time. Many people +have threatened to break out with hives after strawberries. One woman +triumphantly brought me what looked like a nice eruption, but which +proved to be the after-results of a hungry flea! After that she ate +strawberries,--without the flea and without the hives. + +=Not Miracles but Ideas.= Conversions on food subjects are so common +at my table that I should have difficulty in remembering the +individual stories. Scores of them run together in my mind and make a +sort of composite narrative something like this: "Oh, no, thank you, I +don't eat this. You really must excuse me. I have tried many times and +it is invariably disastrous." Then a reluctant yielding and a day or +two later some talk about miracles. "It really is wonderful. I don't +understand," etc. Experiences like these only go to show the power of +the subconscious mind, both in building up wrong habit-reactions and +in quickly substituting healthy ones, once the false idea is removed. + +Among my stomach-patients there were two men, brothers-in-law, +immigrants from the Austrian Tyrol, and now resident in one of the +cow-boy states. Leonardo spoke little English, and though Giovanni +understood a very little, he spoke only Italian. + +Several years before I knew them, Giovanni had developed a severe case +of stomach trouble and had finally gone to a medical center for +operation. The disturbance, however, was not relieved by the operation +and before long his brother-in-law fell into the same kind of trouble. +For several years the two had spent much of their time dieting, +vomiting, and worrying over their sour stomachs. Giovanni finally +became so ill that his sick-benefit society had actually assessed its +members to pay for his funeral expenses. About this time a business +man of their town, impressed by the cure of a former patient who had +made a quick recovery after seven years of invalidism, persuaded the +two men to take their little savings and come to California to be +under my care. The evening meal and breakfast went smoothly enough, +although the menu included articles which they had been taught to +avoid. However, as I left the house on a necessary absence soon after +breakfast, I saw Leonardo weeping in the garden and Giovanni spitting +up his breakfast, out at the entrance gate. On my return, I found one +of "the family" literally sitting on the coat-tails of Leonardo, while +Giovanni hovered at a distance, safe from capture. Leonardo upbraided +me bitterly for having undone all the gain they had made in the long +months of rigid dieting, for now the vomiting had returned, because +they had eaten sugar on their oatmeal at breakfast! I made Leonardo +drink an egg-nog, took him into the consultation-room and held my hand +on his knee to keep him in his chair, while explaining to him as best +I could the physiologic action of the hydrochloric acid on the +digestive juice, which he feared as a sour stomach, the sign of +indigestion. + +During the conversation I said, "I suppose Giovanni imitated you in +this mistaken fear about your health." The reply was, "No, I got it +off him!" Nearly two hours later he exclaimed in astonishment: "Why, +that milk hasn't come up! Maybe I am cured!" "Of course you are +cured," I answered; "there never was anything really the matter with +your stomach, so you are cured as soon as you think you are." + +Later Giovanni was inveigled into the house by the promise that he +would have to eat nothing more than milk soup. All was smooth sailing +after this. For my own part I feared for the permanency of the cure, +for they were returning to the old environment. But more than three +years have passed, and grateful letters still come telling of their +continued health. + +Another patient, a teacher of domestic science in a big Eastern +university, had lived on skimmed milk and lime-water from Easter to +Thanksgiving. Several attempts to enlarge the dietary by adding cream +or white of egg had only served to increase the sense of discomfort. +Finding nothing in the history of the case to warrant a diagnosis of +organic disease of the stomach, I served her plate with the regular +dinner, bidding her have no hesitancy even over the pork chops and +potato chips. She gained nine pounds in weight the first week, and in +two and a half months was forty pounds to the good. + +=When Re-education Failed.= But there is one patient who has had to +have his lesson repeated at intervals. This man laughingly calls +himself a disgrace to his doctor because he is a "repeater." His story +illustrates the power of an autosuggestion and the disastrous effect +of attention to a physiological function. When Mr. T. came first to me +he weighed only 120 pounds, although he is over six feet tall and of +large frame. From the age of sixteen he had followed fads in eating +and thought he had a weak stomach. I treated his "weak stomach" to +everything there was in the market, including mince-pies, cabbage, +cheese, and all the other so-called indigestibles. He gained 16-1/2 +pounds the first week and 31 pounds in five weeks. One would think +that the idea about the weak stomach would have died a natural death, +but it did not. Again and again he came back to me like a living +skeleton, the last time weighing only 105 pounds, and again and again +he has gone back to his home in the Middle West plump and well. Twice +while he was at home he underwent unnecessary operations, once for an +ulcer that was not there and once for supposed chronic spasm of the +pylorus. Needless to say, the operations did not help. You cannot cut +out an idea with a knife. Neither can you wash it out with a +stomach-pump; else would Mr. T. long ago have been cured! This +particular idea of his seems to be proof against all my best efforts +at re-education. Psycho-analysis is impracticable, partly because of +the duration of the habit of repression, but the history, and certain +symbolic symptoms, indicate the Freudian mechanisms at work. All I can +do is to feed him up, bully him along, and keep him from starving to +death. Just now he is doing very well at home, although he has moved +to California so as not to be too far away from "the miracle-worker." + +If Mr. T.'s case had been typical, I should long ago have lost my +faith in psychotherapy. Keeping people from starving is worth while, +but is less satisfactory than curing them of what ails them. The +nervous patient who has a relapse is no credit to his doctor. It is +only when the origin of his trouble is not removed that the bond of +transference tends to become permanent. The neurotic who is well only +while under the influence of his physician is still a neurotic. +However, as most people's complexes are neither so deeply buried nor +so obstinate as this, a simple explanation or a single demonstration +is usually enough to loose the fettering hold of old misconceptions. + + +COMMON AILMENTS + +="Gas on the Stomach."= We all know people who suffer from "gas." +Indeed, very few of us escape an occasional desire to belch after a +hearty meal. But the person with nervous indigestion rolls out the +"gas" with such force that the noise can sometimes be heard all over +the house. He may keep this up for hours at a time, under the +conviction that he is freeing himself from the products of fermenting +food. He may exhibit a well-bloated stomach as proof of the disastrous +effect of certain articles of diet. The gas and the bloating are +supposed to be the sign and the seal of indigestion, a positive +evidence that undigested food is fermenting in the stomach. + +But what is fermentation? It is, necessarily, a question of the growth +of bacteria and is a process which we may easily watch in our own +kitchens. Bread rises when the yeast-cells have multiplied and acted +on the starch of the flour, producing enough gas to raise the whole +mass. Potatoes ferment because bacteria have multiplied within them. +Canned fruit blows up because enough bacteria have developed inside to +produce sufficient gas to blow open the can. Every housewife knows +that it takes time for each of these processes. Bread has to stand +several hours before it will rise; potatoes do not ferment under +twelve hours, and canned fruit is not considered safe from the +fermenting process under three days. Evidently there is some mistake +when a person begins to belch forth "gas" within an hour or two after +a meal. As a matter of fact, it is not gas at all but merely air that +is swallowed with the food or that was present in the empty stomach. + +When the food enters the stomach it necessarily displaces air, which +normally comes out automatically and noiselessly. But if, through fear +or attention, a certain set of muscles contract, the pent-up air may +come forth awkwardly and noisily or it may stay imprisoned until we +take measures to let it out. A hearty laugh is as good as anything, +but if that cannot be managed, we may have to resort to a cup of hot +water which gives the stomach a slap and makes it let go. Two belches +are enough to relieve the pressure. After that we merely go on +swallowing air and letting it out again, a habit both awkward and +useless. + +If the emotion which ties the muscle-knot is very intense, and the +stomach refuses to let go under ordinary measures, the pain may be +severe. But a quantity of hot water or a dose of ipecac is sure to +relieve the situation. If the person is able to give himself a good +moral slap and relax his unruly muscles, he reaches the same end by a +much pleasanter road. + +Some people are fond of the popular remedy of hot water and soda. +Their faith in its efficacy is likely to be increased by the good +display of gas which is sure to follow. As any cook knows, soda and +acid always fizz. The soda is broken up by the hydrochloric acid of +the stomach and forms salt and carbon dioxid, a gas. However, as the +avowed aim of the remedy is the relief of gas rather than its +manufacture, and as the soda uses up the hydrochloric acid needed in +digestion, the practice cannot be recommended as reasonable. + +=Gastritis.= I once knew a woman who went to a big city to consult a +fashionable doctor. When she returned she told with great satisfaction +that the doctor had pronounced her case gastritis. "It must be true," +she added, "because I have so much gas on my stomach!" The diagnosis +of gastritis used to be very common. The ending _itis_ means +inflammation,--gastritis, enteritis, colitis, each meaning +inflammation of the corresponding organ. An inflammation implies an +irritant. There can be no kind of _itis_ without the presence of +something which irritates the membrane of the affected part. If we +get unusual and irritating bacteria in some spoiled food, we are +likely to have an acute inflammation until the offending bacteria are +expelled. But an inflammation of this kind never lasts. People who +have had ptomaine poisoning sometimes assert that they are afterwards +susceptible to poisoning by the kind of food which first made them +ill. Such a susceptibility is not so much a hold-over effect from the +poison as a hold-over fear which tends to repeat the physical reaction +whenever that food is eaten. I, myself, have had ptomaine poisoning +from canned salmon, but I have never since had any trouble about +eating salmon. + +=Sour Stomach.= Sometimes when a person lies down an hour or so after +a meal, some of the contents of his stomach comes up in his throat. +Then if he be ignorant of physiology, he may be very much alarmed +because his stomach is "sour." Not knowing that he would have far +greater cause for alarm if his stomach were _not_ sour, he may, if the +idea is interesting to him, begin to restrict his diet, to take +digestive tablets, and to develop a regular case of nervous dyspepsia. +Sometimes when the specialists measure the amount of hydrochloric acid +in the stomach, they do find too much or too little acid; but this +merely means that an emotion has made the glands work overtime or has +stopped their action for a little while. The functions of the body +are so very, very old that there is little likelihood of permanent +disturbance. + +=Biliousness.= The stomach is not the only part of the body concerning +which we lack proper confidence. Next to it the liver is the most +maligned organ in the whole body. Although the liver is about as +likely to be upset in its process of secreting bile as the ocean is +likely to be lacking in salt, many an intelligent person labels every +little disturbance "biliousness" and lays it at the door of his +faithful, dependable liver. + +As a matter of fact, the liver is liable to injury from virtually but +three sources--alcohol, bacterial infection, and cancer--and even a +liver hardened by alcohol goes on secreting bile as usual. The patient +dies of dropsy but not of "liver complaint." + +Some people act as if they thought bile were a poison. On the +contrary, it is a very useful digestant; it aids in keeping down the +number of harmful bacteria and helps to carry the food from intestines +to blood. Every day the liver manufactures at least a pint of this +important fluid. The body uses what it needs and stores the surplus +for reserve in the gall-bladder. The flow is continuous and, despite +all appearances to the contrary, there is no such thing as a torpid or +an over-active liver. + +It is true that after a "bilious" person has vomited for a few minutes +he is likely to throw up a certain amount of bile, which is supposed +to have been lying in his stomach and causing the nausea. In fact, +however, this bile is merely a part of the usual supply stored away in +the gall-bladder. By the very act of retching, the bile is forced out +of the bile channels into the stomach and thence up into the mouth. +Anybody can throw up bile at any time if he only tries hard enough. + +One of the favorite habits of certain people is the taking of calomel +and salts. After such a dose they view with satisfaction the green +character of the stools and conclude that they have rid themselves of +a great amount of harmful matter. As a matter of fact, the greater +part of the coloring in the stools is from the calomel itself, changed +in the intestines from one salt of mercury to another. Any excess bile +is the result of the irritating action of the calomel on the +intestinal wall, an irritation which makes the bowel hurry to cast out +this foreign substance without waiting for the bile to be absorbed as +usual. + +A patient once told me that he had bought medicine from a street fakir +and by his direction had followed it with a dose of salts. He saved +the bowel movement, washed it in a sieve, and discovered a great +number of "gall-stones," which the medicine had so effectively washed +from his system. He was much astonished when I told him that his +gall-stones were merely pieces of soap. He did not know that +everybody manufactures soap in his body every day, and that by taking +an extra quantity of oil in the shape of the fakir's medicine and an +extra quantity of potash in the salts, he had merely augmented a +normal physiological process. The supposed action of calomel belongs +to the same class of phenomena, and has no slightest effect on the +liver or on real gall-stones, which are the precipitate of bile-salts +in the gall-bladder, and which cannot be reached by any medicine. + +If the popular notions about biliousness are ill founded, what then +causes the disturbances which undoubtedly do occur and which show +themselves in attacks of nausea or sick headache? The answer can be +given in a word of four letters; a coated tongue, a bilious attack and +a sick headache are all the outcome of a mood. Stocks have gone down +or the wife is cranky or the neighbors are hateful. Adrenalin and +thyroid secretions are poured out as the result of emotion; digestion +is stopped, circulation disturbed, and the whole apparatus thrown out +of gear. + +=Sick-Headache.= Sick-headache is primarily a circulatory disturbance; +and although the disturbance may have been inaugurated by some +chemical unbalance, the sum total of the force that makes a +sick-headache is emotional. The emotion, of course, need not be +conscious in order to be effective. If we picture the arteries all +over the body as being supplied with, among other things, a wall of +circular muscles, and then imagine messages of emotion being flashed +to the nerves controlling this muscle wall, we may get an idea of what +happens just before a sick-headache. Some parts of the arteries +contract too much and other parts relax. The arteries to the head +tighten up at the extremities and become loose lower down. The force +of the blood-stream against the constricted portion can hardly fail to +cause pain. The sick part of the headache is merely a sympathetic +strike of the nerves which control circulation and stomach. + +The moral of all this is plain. If a sick-headache is the result of an +emotional spasm of the blood-vessels, the obvious cure is a change of +the emotion. Some people manage it by going to a party or a picnic, +others by ignoring the symptoms and keeping on with their work. A +woman physician whom I know was in the midst of a violent headache +when called out on an obstetrical case. She felt sorry for herself, +but went on the case. In the strenuous work which followed, she quite +forgot the headache, which disappeared as if by magic. + +Sometimes it happens that a headache recurs periodically or at regular +intervals. It is easy to see that in such cases the exciting cause is +fear and expectation. At some time in the past, headaches have +occurred at an interval of, say, fourteen days; as the next +fourteenth day approaches the sufferer says to himself: "It is about +time for another headache. I am afraid it will come to-morrow," and of +course it comes. One man told me that if he ate Sunday-night supper he +inevitably had a headache on Monday morning. We were about to sit down +to a simple Sunday supper and he refused very positively to join us. I +told him he could stay all night and that I would take care of him if +the Monday sickness appeared. He accepted my challenge but was unable +to produce a headache. In fact, he felt so unusually flourishing the +next morning that he insisted on frying the bacon for my entire +family. That was the end of the Monday headaches. + +=A Few Examples.= As sick-headache has always been considered a rather +stubborn difficulty, not amenable to most forms of treatment, it may +be well to cite a few cases which were helped by educational methods. +A patient came home from a walk one day and announced that he was +going to bed. When questioned, be said: "I am tired and I have a +sick-headache. Isn't it logical to go to bed?" To which I answered +that it would be far more logical to put some food into his stomach +and change the circulation than to lie in bed and think about his +pain. This man was completely cured. I have had patients throw up one +meal, and very rarely two, but I have never had to supply more than +three meals at a time. The waste of food I consider amply justified by +the benefit to the patient. + +There once came to me an elderly woman, the wife of a poor minister. +She was suffering from attacks of nausea, which recurred every five to +ten days with intense pain through the eyes, and with photo-phobia or +fear of light. I found that she had by dint of heroic efforts raised a +large and promising family on the salary of an itinerant +minister--from four hundred to six hundred a year! All the time she +had been feeling sorry for herself because her husband did not +appreciate her. One day, after reading one of his letters which seemed +to show an utter lack of appreciation of all that she was doing, she +fell down in the field beside her plow, paralyzed. From that time on +she had been more or less of an invalid, continually nursing her +grudge and complaining that she ought not to have been made to bear so +many children. + +After I had heard this plaint over and over for about a week, I said: +"Perhaps you ought not to have had that little daughter, the little +ewe-lamb. Maybe she was one too many." "Oh, no," came the quick +response. "I couldn't have spared _her_." Then I went down the line of +the fine stalwart sons. Perhaps she could have spared John or Tom or +Fred? Finally she saw the whole matter in a different light,--saw +herself as a queen among women, the mother of such a family. + +As to the husband, I tried to show her that she was not very clever +to live with a man all those years without discovering that he was not +likely to change. "You can't change him but you can change your +reaction to him. If something keeps hurting your hand, you don't keep +on being sore. You grow callous. Isn't it about time you grew a moral +callous, too?" + +I put her on the roof to sleep, on account of her fear of light. Only +once did she start a headache, which I quickly nipped in the bud by +making her get up and dress. She had come to stay "three months or +four,--if I get along well." At the end of four weeks she left, an +apparently well woman. The last I heard of her she was stumping the +state for temperance, the oldest of an automobile party of speakers, +and the sturdiest physically. With the emotional grievance, +disappeared also the physical effects in stomach and head. + +Miss S., a very brilliant woman, ambitious to make the most of her +life, had been shelved for twenty-five years because of violent +sick-headaches which made it impossible for her to undertake any kind +of work. She had not been able to read a half-hour a day without +bringing on a terrible headache. I insisted on her reading, and very +soon she was so deep in psychological literature that I had difficulty +in making her go to bed at all. After learning the cause of her +headaches and gaining greater emotional control, she succeeded so +well in freeing herself from the old habit, that she now leads the +busiest kind of useful life with only an occasional headache, perhaps +once in six months. + +A certain minister suffered constantly from a dull pain in his head, +besides having violent headaches every few days. He started in to have +a bad spell the day after his arrival at my house. As I was going out +of the door, he caught my sleeve. "Doctor," he said, "would it be bad +manners to run away?" "Manners?" I answered. "They don't count, but +morals, yes." He stayed--and that was his last bad headache. Both +chronic and periodic pains disappeared for good. + +One woman who had suffered from bad headaches for eighteen years lost +them completely under a process of re-education. On the other hand, I +have had patients who were not helped at all. The principles held good +in their cases, but they were simply not able to lose the old habit of +tightening up the body under emotion. + +=Hysterical Nausea.= Sometimes nausea is merely the physical symbol of +a subconscious moral disgust. We have already told the stories of "the +woman with the nausea" (Chapter V) and of Mrs. Y. (Chapter VII). These +cases are typical of many others. Their bodies were perfectly normal, +and when, through psycho-analysis and re-education, they were helped +to make over their childish attitudes toward the sex-life, the nausea +disappeared. + +=Loss of Appetite.= A nervous patient with a good appetite is "the +exception that proves the rule." The neurotic is usually under weight +and often complains that he feels satiated almost as soon as he begins +to eat. Loss of appetite may, of course, mean that the body is busy +combating toxins in the blood, but in a nervous person it usually +means a symbolic loss of appetite for something in life, a struggle of +the personality against something for which he has "no stomach." +Psycho-analysis often reveals the source of the trouble, and a little +bullying helps along the good work. By simply taking away a harmful +means of expression, we may often force the subconscious mind to find +a better language. + + +SUMMARY + +Since the stomach seems to be an organ which is much better fitted to +care for food than to care for a depressing emotion or a false idea, +it seems far more sensible to change our minds than to keep enlarging +our list of eatables which are taboo. + +And since most indigestion is in very truth nothing more nor less than +an emotional disturbance, worked up by fear, anger, discontent, worry, +ignorance, suggestion, attention to bodily functions which are meant +to be ignored, love of notice and the conversion of moral distress +into physical distress, the best diet list which can be furnished to +Mr. Everyman in search of health must read something like this: + + MENU + + Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, + Sunday + + A Calm Spirit Plenty of Good Cheer + A Varied Diet Commonsense + Good Cooking + Judicious Neglect of Symptoms + Forgetfulness of the Digestive Process + A Little Accurate Knowledge + A Determination to + BE LIKE FOLKS + + + + +CHAPTER XI + +_In which we relearn an old trick_ + +THE BUGABOO OF CONSTIPATION + +POPULAR SUPERSTITIONS + + +In line with the taboos connected with the taking of food are the +ceremonials attendant upon its elimination. Taking anxious thought +about functions well established by nature is a feature of +conversion-hysteria, the displacement of emotional desire from its +psychic realm into symbolic physical expression. Whatever other +symptoms nervous people may manifest, they are almost sure to be +troubled with chronic constipation. It is true that there are many +constipated people who do not seem to be nervous and who resent being +classed among the neurotics. Everybody knows that the occasional +individual who has difficulty in swallowing his food is nervous and +that the, trouble lies not in the muscles of his throat but in the +ideas of his mind. But very few people seem to realize that the more +common individual who makes hard work of that other simple +process--elimination of his intestinal waste matter--is suffering +from the same kind of disturbance and giving way to a nervous trick. +When all the facts are in, the constipated person will have hard work +to clear himself of at least one count on the charge of nerves. + +=An Oft-told Tale.= Sooner or later, then, the neurotic, whether he +calls himself a neurotic or not, is very likely to begin worrying over +his diet or his sedentary occupation. He imagines himself the victim +of autointoxication, afflicted with paralysis of the colon or dearth +of intestinal secretions. He leaves off eating white bread, berries, +cheese, chocolate, and many another innocent food, and insists on a +diet of bran-biscuit, flaxseed breakfast-foods, prunes, spinach, +cream, and olive-oil with doses of mineral oil between meals. In all +probability, he begins a course of massage or he starts to take extra +long walks and to exercise night and morning, pulling his knees up to +his chin and touching his fingers to his toes. When all these measures +fail, he gives in to the morning enema or the nightly pill, in +imminent danger of succumbing to a life-long habit. + + +THE TRUTH ABOUT CONSTIPATION + +=What the Colon Is For.= It is well, then to have a fair understanding +of the structure and purpose of our intestinal machinery. Contrary to +general opinion, the intestines are not a dumping-ground but a +digestive organ. After the food is partly digested in the stomach, it +passes through a twenty-two foot tube (the small intestine) into a +five-foot tube (the large intestine or colon) where digestion is +completed, the nutriment is absorbed, and the waste matter is passed +on and out through the rectum. As the food passes along the colon, +pushed slowly ahead by the peristaltic wave, or rhythmic muscular +contractions of the intestinal wall, it is seized upon by the four +hundred varieties of friendly bacteria which inhabit the intestines of +every healthy person, and is changed into a form which the body can +assimilate. Digestion in the stomach and small intestine is carried on +by means of certain digestive juices, but in the large intestine it is +the bacteria which do the work. Without them we could not live. + +Around the colon is a thick network of little blood vessels, all of +which lead straight to the liver, the storehouse of the body. After +the food is fully digested, it is passed through the thin intestinal +wall into these tiny vessels and carried away to liver and muscles for +storage or for immediate use. + +This process of absorption is carried on throughout the whole length +of the colon. Not until the very end of the intestine is reached is +all the nutrition abstracted. The bowel-content can properly be called +waste matter only after it has reached the rectum or pouch at the +lower end of the colon. Even then, this waste matter is not poison, +but merely indigestible material which the body cannot handle. + +=Food, not Poison.= The colon is not a cesspool but a digestive and +assimilating organ. Its content is not poison but food. Active +elimination is important not so much because delay causes +autointoxication or poisoning as because too large a mass is hard to +manage and irritates the intestinal wall. The problem is not so much +one of toxicology as of simple mechanics. If Nature had put within the +body five feet of tubing which could easily become a cesspool and a +breeder of poison, it is not at all likely that she would have laid +alongside an elaborate system of blood vessels leading not out to the +kidneys but into the storehouse of the liver; and if civilized man's +changed manner of living had so upset Nature's plans as easily to +transform his internal machinery into a chronic source of danger, we +may be sure that he would long ago have gone the way of the unfit and +succumbed to his own poisons. + +=Possible Invasions.= It is true that the intestinal tract, like the +rest of the body, is open to attack by harmful bacteria. But in a +great majority of cases, these enemy bacteria are either quickly +destroyed by the beneficent microbes within or are immediately cast +out as unfit. Any germs irritating to the intestinal wall cause the +mucous membrane to produce an unusual flow of mucus which washes away +the offending bacteria in what we call a diarrhea.[52] + +[Footnote 52: If the invading army proves obstinate and the diarrhea +continues a day or so, it is wise to assist Nature by a dose of +castor-oil, which gives an additional insult to the intestinal wall, +spurs it on to a desperate effort, and hastens the cleansing process. +In severe cases the more promptly the castor-oil is administered the +better. Such emergency measures are very different from the habitual +use of insulting drugs.] + +Sometimes the wrong kind of bacteria do persist, causing anemia, +rheumatism, sciatica, or neuritis. When these disorders are not the +result of infection from teeth, tonsils, or other sources of poison, +but are really caused by intestinal bacteria, I have found that a diet +of buttermilk (lactic acid bacteria), with turnip-tops or spinach to +supply the necessary mineral salts, often succeeds in planting the +right bacteria and driving out the disturbing ones. These disorders +are invasions from without, like tuberculosis or malaria, and are as +likely to attack the person with easy bowel movements as the one with +the most chronic constipation. + +=Autointoxication.= A good deal of the talk about autointoxication is +just talk. It sounds well and affords an easy explanation for all +sorts of ills, but in a large majority of cases the diagnosis can +hardly be substantiated. Uninformed writers of newspaper articles on +the care of the body, or purveyors of purgatives or apparatus for +internal baths are fond of dilating on the "foulness of the colon" as +a leading cause of disease. As a rule, they advise either a strict +diet, some kind of cathartic, or an elaborate process of washing out +the colon to clear the body of its terrible accumulation of poisons. + +=Cathartics and Enemas.= He who makes a practice of flushing out his +intestinal tract with high enemas and internal baths is like a person +who eats a good dinner and then proceeds to wash out his stomach. In +the mistaken idea that he is making himself clean, he is washing what +was never intended to be washed and robbing the body of the nutrition +which it needs. And the man who persists in the pill habit is making a +worse mistake, adding insult to injury and forcing the mucous membrane +to toughen itself against such malicious attacks. + +=Cathartics and Operations.= Even in emergencies, the use of +purgatives as a routine measure is happily decreasing year by year. +For many years I have deplored the use of purgatives before and after +operations. That other practitioners are coming to the same conclusion +is witnessed by a number of papers recently read in medical societies +condemning purgation at the time of operation. + +Among the most favorably received papers of the California Medical +Societies have been one by Emmet L. Rixford, surgeon of the Stanford +University Medical College, read before the Southern California +Medical Society at Los Angeles December 8, 1916, and one by W.D. +Alvarez at the California Medical Society, Del Monte, 1918,--both +condemning the use of purgatives as a routine measure before +operations. An article entitled the "Use and Abuse of Cathartics" in +the "Journal of the American Medical Association" admirably summarizes +the disadvantages of purgation at such a time.[53] + +[Footnote 53: "1 Danger of dissemination of infection throughout the +peritoneal cavity, in case localized infection exists. + +"2 Increased absorption of toxins and greater bacterial activity by +reason of the fact that undigested food has been carried down into the +colon to serve as pabulum for bacteria, and that liquid feces form a +better culture medium than solid feces. + +"3 Increased distention of the intestine with gas and fluid, when it +should be empty.... + +"4 Psychic and physical weakness produced by dehydration of the body, +disturbance in the salt balance of the system, and the loss of sleep +occasioned by the frequent purging during the night preceding the +operation. As Oliver Wendell Holmes says: 'If it were known that a +prize fighter were to have a drastic purgative administered two or +three days before a contest, no one will question that it would affect +the betting on his side unfavorably. If this be true for a powerful +man in perfect health, how much more true must it be of the sick man +battling for life.' + +"5 Increase in postoperative distress and danger: thirst, gas pains, +and even ileus...."--_Journal of American Medical Association_, Vol. +73, No. 17, p. 1285, Oct. 25. 1919.] + +Four years ago I was called to a near-by city to see a former patient +who two days before had had a minor operation,--removal of a cyst of +the breast. She was dazed, almost in a state of surgical shock and +very near collapse. I found that she had been put through the usual +course of purgation before operation and starvation afterward, and I +diagnosed her condition as a state bordering on acidosis, or lowering +of the alkaline salts of the body. I ordered food at once. She rallied +and recovered. + +A few months later this same woman had to undergo a much more serious +operation for multiple fibroids of the uterus and removal of the +appendix. This time I advised the surgeon against the use of any +purgative, and he took my remarks so seriously that he did not even +allow an enema to be given. This time the patient showed no signs of +exhaustion and had very few gas pains. I firmly believe that the day +will soon come when a patient under operation, or a patient after +childbirth, will no longer be depleted by a weakening and dehydrating +cathartic and by a period of starvation, at a time when he needs all +the energy he can summon. + +=Cathartics and Childbirth.= The article referred to in the "Journal +of the American Medical Association" cites the experiences of Dr. R. +McPherson of the Lying-in Hospital of New York, "who showed that the +routine purgation after confinement is not only useless but harmful. +Of 322 women who were not purged, only three had fever (and one of +them a mammary abscess); most of them had normal bowel movements and +those who did not were given an enema every third day. Of 322 women +who were delivered by the same technique and the same operators but +were purged in the usual routine manner, twenty-eight had some fever." +This experience of one physician is corroborated by that of others who +find that the more we tamper with the natural functions in time of +stress the harder do we make the recuperative process. There are +certainly times when catharsis is necessary but "one thing is certain, +the day for routine purgation is past."[54] Even in emergencies we +need to know why we administer cathartics and in chronic cases we may +be sure that they are always a mistake. + +[Footnote 54: Ibid, p. 1286.] + +="An Old Trick."= Before we make a practice of interfering with +Nature's processes, it is well to remember how old and stable those +processes are. As long as there has been the taking in of food, there +has been also the casting out of waste matter. The sea-anemone closes +in on the little mollusk that floats against its waving petals, +assimilates what it can and rejects the rest. In the long line from +sea-anemone to man, this automatic process of elimination has gone on +without a hitch, adapting itself with perfect success to the changing +habits of the varying types of life. So old a process is not easily +upset. And, be it noted, in the human body this automatic, involuntary +process still goes on with very little trouble until it reaches a +point in the body where man, the thinking animal, tries to control it +by conscious thought. + +=A Question of Evacuation.= Much of the misconception about +constipation arises from the mistaken idea that this is a disorder of +the whole intestine or at least of the whole colon. As a matter of +fact, the trouble is almost wholly in the rectum. There is no trouble +with the general traffic movement, but only with the unloading at the +terminus. In my experience, the patient reports that he feels the +fecal mass in the lower part of the rectum, but that he is unable to +expel it. Examination by finger or by X-ray reveals a mass in the +rectal pouch. If there is a piling up of freight further back on the +line, it is only because the unloading process has been delayed at the +terminus. + +So long as the bowel-content is in the region of automatic control, +there is very little likelihood of trouble. An occasional case of +organic trouble--appendicitis, lead-colic, mechanical obstruction, new +growths or spinal-cord disease--may cause a real blockade, but in +ninety-nine cases out of every hundred there is little trouble so long +as the involuntary muscles, working automatically under the direction +of the subconscious mind, are in control. By slow or rapid stages, on +time or behind time, the bowel-content reaches the upper part of the +rectum and passes through a little valve into the lower pouch. Here is +where the trouble begins. + +=Meddlesome Interference.= In the natural state the little human, like +the other animals, empties his bowel whenever the fecal mass enters +the lower portion of the rectum. The presence of the mass in the +rectum constitutes a call to stool which is responded to as +unthinkingly as is the desire for air in the taking of a breath. But +the tiny child soon has to learn to control some of his natural +functions. At the lower end of the rectum there is a purse-string +muscle called the _Sphincter-ani_, an involuntary muscle which may +with training be brought partly under voluntary control. Under the +demands of civilization, the baby learns to tighten up this muscle +until the proper time for evacuation. Then, if he be normal, he lets +go, the muscles higher up contract and the bowel empties itself +automatically, as it always did before civilization began. + +There is, however, a possibility of trouble whenever the conscious +mind tries to assume control of functions which are meant to be +automatic. Under certain conditions necessary control becomes +meddlesome interference. If the child for one reason or another takes +too much interest in the function of elimination; if he likes too much +the sense-gratification from stimulation of the rectal nerves and +learns to increase this gratification by holding back the fecal mass; +if he gets the idea that the function is "not nice" and takes the +interest that one naturally feels in subjects that are taboo; or if he +catches from his elders the suggestion that the bowel movement is a +highly important process and that something disastrous is likely to +happen unless it is successfully performed every day; then his very +interest in the matter tends to interfere with automatic regulation, +and to cause trouble. + +Just as people often find it hard to let go the bladder muscle and +urinate when in a hurry or under observation, and just as an +apprehensive woman in childbirth tightens up the purse-string muscle +of the womb, so the little child, or the grown up who catches the +suggestion of difficulty in the bowel movement, loses the trick of +letting go. Instead of merely exercising control by temporarily +inhibiting the function, he tries to carry through the process itself +by voluntary control--and fails. Constipation is a perfect example of +the power of suggestion, and of the troublesome effect of a fear-idea +in the realm of automatic functions. + + +FOOD AND CONSTIPATION + +Since the waste matter from all foods finally reaches the rectum, and +since constipation is merely a difficulty in the forces of expulsion, +it is hard to see how any normal food in the quantities usually eaten +could have the slightest effect on the problem. When we remember that +it takes food from twelve to twenty-four hours to reach the rectum, +and that it has during all that time been subjected to the action of +the powerful chemicals of the digestive tract, it is hard to imagine a +piece of cheese, of whatever variety, strong enough to stop the +contraction of the muscles of the upper rectum or to tie the +sphincter-muscle into a knot. It would be difficult to find a food +which could pass without effect through twenty-seven feet of +intestinal tubing only to become suddenly effective on the wall of the +rectum. If the wrong kind of food is the cause of constipation, why +does the rectum prove to be the most refractory portion of the tube? +On what principle could a piece of chocolate inhibit the call to stool +or contract the sphincter muscle? On the other hand, even if it should +be conceded that constipation were the result of lack of lubricating +secretions in the colon, how could two tablespoonfuls of mineral oil +be a sufficient lubricant after being mixed with liquid and solid food +through many feet of the intestinal tract? + +=An Adaptable Apparatus.= The lining of the intestines has plenty of +secretions to take care of its function. It is as well adapted to the +vicissitudes of life as are the other parts of the body. The muscular +coat is no more liable to paralysis or spasm than are the voluntary +muscles. As the skin adapts itself to all waters and all weathers, +and as the lungs adjust themselves to varying air-pressures, so the +intestinal wall makes ready adaptation to any common-sense demands, +adjusting itself with ease to an athletic or a sedentary life, and to +the normal variations of diet. What man has eaten throughout the +centuries man may eat to-day. If you will but believe it, your +intestines will make no more objection to white bread, blackberries, +and cheese, along with all other ordinary articles of food, than the +skin makes to varying kinds of water. Naturally, the suggested idea +that a food will constipate tends to carry itself out to fulfilment +and to prevent the call to stool from rising to the level of +consciousness; but the real force lies not in the food but in the +suggestion. + +=The Bran Fad.= It is when we try to improve on the normal human diet +that we really insult the body. He who leaves off eating nourishing +white bread and takes to bran muffins is simply cheating his body. +Bran has a small food value, but the human body is not made to extract +it. Not only does bran fail to give us any nourishment itself, but it +lessens the power of the intestines to care for other food.[55] The +fad for bran is based on the well-known fact that we need a certain +quantity of bulk in order to stimulate the intestinal wall to normal +peristalsis. We do need bulk, but not more than we naturally get from +a normal and varied diet including a reasonable amount of fruit and +vegetables. + +[Footnote 55: See an article entitled "Bread and Bran," _Journal of +American Medical Association_, July 5, 1919, p. 36.] + +It is true that the suggestion of the efficacy of bran, dates, +spinach, or any other food is frequently quite sufficient to give +relief, temporarily, just as massage, manipulation of the vertebrae, +the surgeon's knife, or mineral oil may be enough to carry the +conviction of power to a suggestible individual. But who wants to take +his suggestions in such inconvenient forms as these? + +=Change of Water.= Another popular superstition centers around +drinking-waters. There are people who cannot move from one town to +another, much less take an extensive trip, without a fit of +constipation--or a box of pills. If they only knew it, there is no +water on earth which could make a person constipated. A new water, +full of unusual minerals, might hasten the bowel movement, but on what +possible principle could it retard it? Constipation has nothing to do +with food or with water, but solicitous care about either can hardly +fail to create the trouble which it tries to avoid. + + +THE CURE + +=Taking off the Brakes.= Since constipation is wholly due to the +acceptance of a false suggestion, the only logical cure must be +release from the power of that suggestion. "He is able as soon as he +thinks he is able"; not that thought gives the power, but that the +right thought releases the inhibition of the mistaken thought. As soon +as the brakes are taken off, the internal machinery is quite able to +make the wheels go round. The bowel will empty itself if we let it. +The function of elimination is not a new trick learned with difficulty +by the aged, but a trick as old and as elemental as life itself. Like +balancing on a bicycle, it may not be done by any voluntary muscular +effort, but it just does itself when one learns how. + +Once the sense of power comes, once the mind forgets to be doubtful or +afraid, then the old automatic habit invariably reasserts itself. +Meddlesome interference may throw the mechanism out of gear, but +fortunately it cannot strip the gears. Constipation is an inhibition +or restraint of function, but is never a loss of function. No one is +too old, no one is too fixed in the bad habit to relearn the old +trick. I have had a good many patients with chronic constipation, but +I have never had one who failed to learn. Real conviction speedily +brings success, and in many cases success seems to outrun conviction. +So efficient is Nature if she has only half a chance! + +=Some People Who Learned.= Unless you are over ninety-two, do not +despair. One old lady of that age, a sort of patient by proxy, was +able to cure herself without even one consultation. Her daughter had +been a patient of mine and had been cured of the constipation with +which she had been busy for many years. The mother, who believed her +own bowel paralyzed, had been in the habit of lying on the bed and +taking a copious enema every second day of her life. When, however, +she heard of her daughter's cure, the bright old woman gave up her +enemas and let her bowels do their own functioning. She stayed cured +until her death at ninety-five. + +=A Fifty-year Habit.= Another old lady was not quite so easily +convinced. She ridiculed the idea that her son of fifty, who had been +"constipated in his cradle" could be cured of his lifelong habit, but +he was cured. As long as there is life and the light of reason, so +long may Nature's functions be reëstablished. + +=The Whole Family.= Nor is any one too young to learn. A tiny baby is +easily taught. There came to me for two consultations a mother and her +two babies, all three constipated. The four-year-old child, mentally +deficient, had been fed on milk of magnesia from his infancy, and the +four-months-old baby had been started on the same path. I explained to +the mother the mechanism of elimination, told her to give up +cathartics, and to set a regular time for herself and the baby, but +was a little dubious about the mentally deficient four-year-old. +However she soon reported that they had all three promptly acquired +the new habit. Four years later she told me that they had never had +any more trouble. + +=A Record History.= When Miss H. first came to my house, she told a +story that was almost incredible. She said that for many months she +had been taking eight tablespoonfuls of mineral oil three times a day +besides a cathartic at night, and an enema in the morning. No wonder +she was a little dubious over such mild treatment as mine seemed to +be! + +Constipation was only one of this young woman's troubles. She could +not sleep and was so fatigued that she believed herself at the end of +her physical capital. When she first came to me she had tears in her +eyes most of the time and used to confide to various people that she +was sure she was a patient that I could not cure,--a very common +belief among nervous invalids! She was sure that I did not understand +her case, and that she could not get anything out of this kind of +treatment. + +It was only a very short time, however, before her bowels were +functioning like those of a normal person. She lost her insomnia and +her fatigue and went away as well as ever. When she got back to her +office, she found that her old position, which she had believed secure +to her, had been given to another. She had to go out and hunt a new +job and face conditions harder than she had had before, but she came +through with flying colors. A short time ago Miss H. came back to see +me,--a happy, robust young woman, very different from the person I had +first known. She assured me that she had never had any return of her +old symptoms and that she was as well as a person could be. + +=Living up to a Suggestion.= Mrs. T. had not had a natural movement of +the bowels in twenty-five years. After the birth of a child, +twenty-five years before, her physician had told her that her muscles +had been so badly torn in labor that they could not carry through a +natural movement. After that she had never gone a day without a pill +or an enema. I explained to her that when any muscle of the rectum is +injured in childbirth, it is the sphincter-ani, and that since this is +the muscle whose contraction holds back the bowel content, its injury +would tend to over-free evacuation rather than to constipation. She +saw the point and within two or three days regained her old power of +spontaneous evacuation. + +=Practical Steps.= The first step, then, in acquiring normal habits is +the conviction of the integrity of our physical machines and a +determination not to interfere by thought, or by physical meddling, +with the elemental functions of our bodies. After this all-important +step, there are a few practical suggestions which it is well to +follow. Most of them are nothing more than the common-sense habits of +personal hygiene which are so obvious as to be almost axiomatic, but +which are nevertheless often neglected: + +1 Eat three square meals a day. + +2 Drink when thirsty, having conveniently at hand the facilities for +drinking. + +3 Heed the call to stool as you heed the call of hunger. When the +stool passes the little valve between the upper and lower portions of +the rectum, it gives the signal that the time for evacuation has come. +If this signal is always heeded, it will automatically start the +machinery that leads to evacuation. If it is persistently ignored +because one is too busy, or because the mind is filled with the idea +of disability, the call very soon fails to rise to the level of +consciousness. The feces remain in the rectum, and the bad habit is +begun. + +4 Choose a regular time and keep that appointment with yourself as +regularly as possible. In all the activities of Nature, there is a +rhythm which it is well to observe. + +5 Take time to acquire the habit. Do not be in a hurry. Do not strain. +No amount of effort will start the movement. Just let it come of +itself. + +6 Finally, should the unconscious suggestion of lack of power +stubbornly remain in force, take a small enema on the third day. If +the waste matter accumulates for three or more days, the bulk becomes +so great that the circular muscles of the rectum are unable to handle +it, just as the fingers cannot squeeze down to expel water from too +large a mass of wet blankets. Take only a small enema--never over a +quart at a time--and expel the water immediately. One or two such +measures will bring away the mass in the rectum. The material farther +up still contains food elements and is not yet ready for expulsion. +Lessen the amount of water each time until no outside help is needed. +Once you get the right idea, all enemas will be superfluous. + + +SUMMARY + +If you would have in a nutshell an epitome of the truth about +constipation, indigestion, insomnia, and the other functional +disturbances common to nervous folk, you can do, no better than to +commit to memory and store away for future reference that choice +limerick of the centipede, which so admirably sums up the whole matter +of meddlesome interference: + + A centipede was happy quite + Until a frog in fun + Said, "Pray, which leg comes after which?" + This raised her mind to such a pitch, + She lay distracted in the ditch, + Considering how to run. + +Whoever tries to consider "which leg comes after which" in any line +of physiological activity, is pretty sure to find himself in the ditch +considering how to run. Wherefore, remember the centipede! + + + + +CHAPTER XII + +_In which handicaps are dropped_ + +A WOMAN'S ILLS + +"THE FEMALE OF THE SPECIES" + + +If ever there was a man who wished himself a woman, he has hidden away +the desire within the recesses of his own heart. But one does not have +to wait long to hear a member of the female sex exclaim with evident +emotion, "Oh, dear, I wish I had been born a man!" It is probable that +if these same women were given the chance to transform themselves +overnight, they would hesitate long when it actually came to the +point. The joys of being a woman are real joys. However, in too many +cases these joys seem hardly to compensate for the discomforts of the +feminine organism. It is the body that drags. Painful menstrual +periods, the dreaded "change of life," various "female troubles" with +a number of pregnancies scattered along between, make some of the +daughters of Eve feel that they spend a good deal of their lives +paying a penalty merely for being women. Brought up to believe +themselves heirs to a curse laid on the first woman, they accept their +discomforts with resignation and try to make the best of a bad +business. + +="Since the War."= Nothing is quite the same since the war. Among +other things we have learned that many of our so-called handicaps were +nothing but illusions,--base libels on the female body. Under the +stern necessity of war the women of the world discovered that they +could stand up under jobs which have until now been considered quite +beyond their powers. Society girls, who were used to coddling +themselves, found a new joy in hard and continuous work; middle-aged +women, who were supposed to be at the time of life when little could +be expected of them, quite forgot themselves in service. Ambulance +drivers, nurses, welfare workers, farmerettes, Red-Cross workers, +street-car conductors and "bell-boys," revealed to themselves and to +the world unsuspected powers of endurance in a woman's body. Although +some of the heavier occupations still seem to be "man's work," better +fitted for a man's sturdier body, we know now that many of these +disabilities were merely a matter of tradition and of faulty training. + +There still remains, however, a goodly number of women who are +continuously or periodically below par because of some form of +feminine disability. Some of these women are suffering from real +physical handicaps, but many of them need to be told that they are +disabled not by reason of being women but by reason of being nervous +women. + +="Nerves" Again.= Despite the organic disturbances which may beset the +reproductive organs, and despite the havoc wrought by venereal +diseases, it may be said with absolute assurance that the majority of +feminine ills are the result neither of the natural frailty of the +female body, nor even of man's infringement of the social law, but are +the direct result of false suggestion and of false attitudes toward +the facts of the reproductive life. The trouble is less a difficulty +with the reproductive organs than a difficulty with the reproductive +instinct. "Something wrong" with the instinct is translated by the +subconscious mind into "something wrong" with the related generative +organs, and converted into a physical pain. + +That this relation has always been dimly felt is shown by the fact +that the early Greeks called nervous disorders _hysteria_, from the +Greek word for womb. It is only lately, however, that the blame has +been put in the right place and the trouble traced to the _instinct_ +rather than to the _organs_ of reproduction. + +=Why Women Are Nervous.= Although women hold no monopoly, it must be +conceded that they are particularly prone to "nerves." The reason is +not hard to find. Since the leading factor in a neurosis is a +disturbance of the insistent instinct of reproduction, a disturbance +usually based on repression, then any class of persons in whom the +instinct is particularly repressed would, in the very nature of the +case, be particularly liable to nervousness. + +No one who thoroughly knows human nature would attempt to deny that +woman is as strongly endowed as man with the great urge toward the +perpetuation of the race, or that she has had to repress the instinct +more severely than has man. The man insists on knowing that the +children he provides for are his own children. Whatever the degree of +his own fidelity, he must be sure that his wife is true to him. Thus +has grown up the insistence that, no matter what man does, woman, if +she is to be counted respectable, shall control the urge of the +instinct and live up to the requirements of continence set for her by +society. + +Unfortunately, however, there is more often blind repression than +rational control. The measures taken to prevent a girl's becoming a +tom-boy are measures of sex-repression quite as much as of +sex-differentiation. Over-reaction of sensitive little souls to +lessons in modesty often causes distortion of normal sex-development. +Ignorance concerning the phenomena of life is commended as innocence, +while it really implies a sex-curiosity which has been too severely +repressed. The young woman blushes at thoughts of love, while the +young man is filled with a sense of dignity. We smile at the picture +of "Miss Philura's" confusion as she hesitatingly sends up to her +Creator a petition for the much-desired boon of a husband. But really, +why shouldn't she want one? Many a young woman, in order to deaden her +senses to the unsuspected lure of the reproductive instinct by what is +really an awkward attempt at _sublimation_, makes a fetish of dress +and social position and considers only the marriage of convenience; +or, on the other hand, she scorns men altogether and throws herself +into a "career." + +Young men are not so often taught to repress, but neither are they +taught to swing their vital energies into altruistic channels through +sublimation. Since the woman of his class will not marry him until he +has money, the young man too often satisfies his undirected instincts +in a commercial way. The statistics of venereal diseases prove that +here, as elsewhere, goods subject to barter are subject to +contamination. In a late marriage, too often a contaminated body +accompanies the material possessions which the standards of society +have demanded of a husband. + +But the woman pays in still other coin for the repressions arising +from faulty childhood training. Unable to find expression for herself +either in marriage or in devotion to work, because some old childish +repression is still denying all outlet to her legitimate desire, she +frequently falls into a neurosis; or if she escapes a real breakdown, +she gives expression to unsatisfied longings in some isolated nervous +symptoms which in many cases center about the organs of generation. +There then results any one of the various functional disturbances +which are only too often mistaken for organic disease. What is needed +in cases like this is not a gynecologist nor a surgeon, but a +psycho-pathologist--or perhaps only a grasp of the facts. Let us look +at the more common of these disturbances in order to gain an +understanding of the situation. + + +THE MENSTRUAL PERIOD + +=Potential Motherhood.= Among the normal phenomena of a woman's life +is the recurring cycle of potential motherhood. Every three or four +weeks a new ovum or egg matures in the ovary and undergoes certain +chemical changes, which send into the blood a substance called a +hormone. This hormone is a messenger, stimulating the mucous membrane +of the womb into making its velvet pile longer and softer, and its +nutrient juices more abundant in readiness for the ovum. + +The same stimulus causes the whole organism to make ready for a new +life. As in hunger, the chemistry of the body produces the +muscle-tension that is felt as a craving for food, so this recurring +chemical stimulus produces a definite craving in body and mind. This +craving brings about an increased irritability or sensitiveness to +stimuli which may result either in a joyous or a fretful mood. + +During sleep the social inhibitions are felt less distinctly and the +sleeper dreams love-dreams woven from messages coming up from all the +minute nerve-endings in the expectant reproductive organs. But if no +germ-cell travels up the womb-canal and tube to meet and impregnate +the ovum, the womb-lining rejects the egg as chemically unfit. All the +furbishings are loosened from the walls and slowly cast out, +constituting the menstrual flow. The phenomenon as a whole is a +physiological function and should be accompanied by a sense of +well-being and comfort as is the exercise of any other function, such +as digestion or muscular activity. Only too often, however, it is +dreaded as an unmitigated disaster, a time for giving up work or fun +and going to bed with a hot-water bottle until "the worst is over." +Let us see how this perversion comes about. + +=Why Menstruation Is Painful.= What sort of atmosphere is created for +the young girl as she attains puberty? Most girls get their first +inkling of the menstrual period from the periodic "sick spells" of +mother or sister. This knowledge comes without conscious thought and +is a direct observation of the subconscious mind, which records +impressions with the accuracy and completeness of a photographic +plate. Hearing the talk about a "sick-time" and observing the signs of +"cramps" among older friends, the young girl's subconscious mind plays +up to the suggestion and recoils with fear from the newly experienced +sensations in the maturing organs of reproduction. + +This recoil of fear interferes with the circulation in the functioning +organs, just as fear blanches the face or hinders digestion. There is +several times as much blood in the stomach when it is full of food as +there is between meals, but we do not for this reason fancy that we +have a pain after each meal. There is more blood in the generative +organs during their functioning, but this means pain only when fear +ties up the circulation and causes undue congestion. Fear acts further +on the sturdy muscle of the womb, tying it up into just such knots as +we feel in the esophagus when we say that we have a lump in the +throat. It is safe to say that ninety-five cases of painful +menstruation out of every hundred are caused by fear and by the +expectation of pain. The cysts and tumors responsible for pain are so +rare as to be fairly negligible, when compared with these other +causes. + +Dr. Clelia Duel Mosher of Stanford University has for many years +carried on careful investigations among the students of the +university. After describing in detail certain physical exercises +which she has found of value, she continues: + + But more important even than this is an alteration of the morbid + attitude of women themselves toward this function; and almost + equally essential is a fundamental change in the habit of mind on + our part as physicians; for do we not tend to translate too much, + the whole of a woman's life into terms of menstruation? If every + young girl were taught that menstruation is not normally a "bad + time" and that pain or incapacity at that period is as + discreditable and unnecessary as bad breath due to decaying + teeth, we might almost look for a revolution in the physical life + of women.... In my experience the traditional treatment of rest + in bed, directing the attention solely to the sex-zone of the + body, and the accepted theory that it is an inevitable illness + while at the same time the mind is without occupation, produces a + morbid attitude and favors the development and exaggeration of + whatever symptoms there may be.[56] + +[Footnote 56: Clelia Duel Mosher: _Health and the Woman Movement_, pp. +25, 26, 19.] + +=Pre-Menstrual Discomfort.= If it be objected that women often feel +badly for a day or two before the period begins, before they know that +it is due, and that this feeling of discomfort could not be caused by +fear and expectation, it is easy to reply that the subconscious mind +knows perfectly what is happening within the body. The emotion of +fear, working within the subconscious, is able to translate all the +varying bodily sensations into feelings of distress without any +knowledge on the part of the conscious mind. + +Sometimes before the period begins, a girl feels blue and upset for a +day or two, a sign that the instinct is getting discouraged. The whole +body is saying, "Get ready, get ready," but it has gotten ready many +times before, and to no purpose. Unsatisfied striving brings +discouragement. What reaches consciousness is a feeling of pessimism +and a general dissatisfaction with life as a whole. If, instead of +giving in to the blues or going to bed and predicting a pain, the girl +finds other outlets for her energy, she finds that after all, her +instinct may be satisfied in indirect ways and that she has strangely +come into a new supply of _vim_. + +=The Purpose of the Pain.= Although suggestion is behind all nervous +symptoms, there is a deeper reason for the disturbance. When an +unhealthy suggestion is seized and acted upon, it is because some +unsatisfied part of the personality sees in it a chance for +accomplishing its own ends. The pre-menstrual period is the +blooming-time, the mating-time, the springtime of the organism. That +means eminently a time for coming into notice, that one's charms may +attract the desired complement. But if the rightfully insistent +instinctive desires are held in check by unnatural repressions and +misapplied social restrictions, the starved instinct can obtain +expression only by a concealment of purpose. The disguise assumed is +often one of indifference or positive distaste for the allurements of +the other sex. But, as we know, an instinctive desire will not be +denied. In this case, the misguided instinct which has been given the +suggestion that menstruation means illness, fits this conception into +the scheme of things and obtains notice in a roundabout way by the +attention given to the invalid. + +=The Treatment.= To find that the symptom has a purpose rather than a +cause gives the indication for the treatment. Judicious neglect causes +the symptom to cease by defeating its very purpose,--that of drawing +attention to itself. The person who never mentions her discomfort, +thinks about it as little as possible, and goes about her business as +usual, is likely to find her trouble gone before she realizes it.[57] + +[Footnote 57: Violent exercise at this time is unwise, but continuing +one's usual activity helps the circulation and keeps the mind from +centering on the affected part. The physiological congestion is unduly +intensified by standing; therefore all employments should afford +facilities for the woman to sit at least part of the time while +continuing work.] + +A little explanation gives the patient insight into the workings of +her own mind, and usually causes the pain to disappear in short order. +Astonished, indeed, and filled with gratitude have been some of my +young-women patients who had all their lives been unable to plan any +work or social engagements for the time of this functioning. Many of +them were the worst kind of doubters when they were told that to go to +bed and center their attention on the generative organs only made the +muscles tighten up and the circulation congest. They could not +conceive themselves up and around, pursuing their normal life during +such a time. However, as they have found by experience that this point +of view is not an optimistic dream, they have broken up the +confidence-game which their subconscious had been playing on them, and +have gone on their way rejoicing. + +There was one young girl, a doctor's daughter, who suffered +continuously from pain in the abdomen, and from back-pain which +increased so greatly at the time of the menses that she was in the +habit of going to bed for several days, to be waited on with +solicitous care by her family. In an attempt to cure the trouble she +had undergone an operation to suspend the uterus, but the pain had +continued as before. When she came to me, I explained to her that +there was no physical difficulty and that her trouble was wholly +nervous. I made her play tennis every day and she had just finished a +game when her period came on. She stayed up for luncheon, went for a +walk in the afternoon, ate her dinner with the family, and behaved +like other people. Her mother telephoned that evening and when I told +her what her daughter had been doing, she gasped in astonishment. She +had difficulty in believing that the new order was not miracle but +simply the working out of natural law. Since that time her daughter +has had no more trouble. + +=The Ounce of Prevention.= If young girls had wiser counselors in +their mothers and physicians, the misconception would never occur, and +such an indirect outlet would not be needed; the organic sensations +incident to puberty and the recurring menstrual period would have +something of the significance of the annunciation to Mary, bringing +wonder and a sense of well-being. + +When your little daughter arrives at maturity, give her a joyous +initiation into the noble order of women. She will welcome the new +function as a badge of womanhood and as a harbinger of wonderful +things to come. + +A girl of fifteen came under my care to be helped out of a mood of +increasing depression and uneasiness. Her glance was furtive, yet +anxiously expectant. Tears came unbidden as she sat alone or fingered +the keys of the piano. Tactful questioning elicited no response as to +reasons for her unhappiness. Opportunities for giving confidence were +not accepted. At a chance moment our talk drifted to the subject of +menstruation. "Your periods are regular and easy; and do you know what +they are for?" Then I painted for her a picture of the preparations +that are made throughout the whole organism, for the germ-cell that +comes each month and has in it all the possibilities of a new little +life. + +The result of this confidential talk may seem fanciful to any one but +an eye-witness. We had only a week's association, but the depression +ceased, the furtive look and deprecatory manner were replaced by a +joyous buoyancy. In a few weeks the thin neck and awkward body rounded +out into the symmetry which usually precedes the establishment of +puberty, but which was delayed in this case until the unconscious +conflict resolved itself. + +=In the Large.= Looked at from any angle, this subject is an important +one. There are involved not only the physical comfort and convenience +of the sufferers themselves, but also the economic prospects of women +as a whole. If women are to demand equal opportunity and equal pay, +they must be able to do equal work without periodic times of illness. +When employers of women tell us that they regularly have to hire extra +help because some of their workers lose time each month, we realize +how great is the aggregate of economic waste, a waste which would +assuredly be justified if the health of the country's womanhood were +really involved, but which is inefficient and unnecessary when caused +merely by ignorant tradition. "Up to standard every day of every +week," is a slogan quite within the range of possibility for all but +the seriously ill. When reduced to their lowest terms, the +inconveniences of this function are not great and are not too dear a +price to pay for the possibilities of motherhood. + + +THE "CHANGE OF LIFE" + +=Another Phantom Peril.= As the young girl is taught to fear the +menstrual period, so the older woman is taught to dread the time when +the periods shall cease. Despite the general enlightenment of this day +and age, the menopause or "change of life" is all too frequently +feared as a "critical period" in a woman's life, a time of distressing +physical sensations and even of danger to mental balance. + +As a matter of fact, the menopause is a physiological process which +should be accomplished with as little mental and physical disturbance +as accompanies the establishment of puberty. The same internal +secretion is concerned in both. When the function of ovulation ceases +the body has to find a new way to dispose of the internal secretion of +the ovary. Its presence in the blood is the cause of the sudden +dilatation of the blood-vessels that is known as the "hot flash." + +The matter is altogether a problem of chemistry, with the necessity +for a new adjustment among the glands of internal secretion. The body +easily manages this if left to itself, but is greatly interfered with +by the wrong suggestion and emotion. We have already seen how quickly +emotion affects all secretions and how easily the adrenal and thyroid +glands are influenced by fear. This is the root of the trouble in many +cases of difficult "change." If an occasional body is not quite able +to regulate the chemical readjustment, we may have to administer the +glands of some other animal, but in the majority of cases, the body, +unhampered by an extra burden of fear, is quite able to make its own +adjustments. The hot flash passes in a moment, if not prolonged by +emotion or if not converted into a habit by attention. + +One source of trouble in the menopause is that it comes at a time in a +woman's life when she is likely to have too much leisure. In no way +can a woman so easily handicap her body at this time as by stopping +work and being afraid. Those women who have to go on as usual find +themselves past the change almost before they know it,--unless they +consider themselves abused, and worry over the necessity for working +through such a "critical time." + +=Three Rules.= Here are a few pointers which have have been of help to +a number of women: + +1 Remember that this is a physiological process and therefore +abundantly safeguarded by Nature. If you don't expect trouble you will +not be likely to find it. + +2 Remember that the sweating and flushing are made worse by notice. + +3 Do everything in your power to keep from the public the knowledge +that you are no longer a potential mother. If you are past forty, do +not mop your face or gasp for breath or carry a fan to the theater! +Shun attention and fear, and you will be surprised at the ease with +which the "change" is effected. + +=Nature's Last Chance.= While we are on the subject of the middle-aged +woman, it may be well to mention a phenomenon sometimes noticed in the +early forties. Often an "old maid" who has considered herself settled +for life in her bachelor estate, suddenly takes to herself a husband. +(I use the verb advisedly!) Mothers who have thought their +child-bearing days long past sometimes find themselves pregnant. "The +child of her old age" is not an uncommon occurrence. Unmarried women +who have "kept straight" all their lives sometimes go down before +temptation at this late time. There is a reason. It is as though +Nature were making a last desperate attempt to produce another life +before it is too late, speeding up all the internal secretions and +flashing insistent messages throughout the whole organism. + +It may help some woman who feels herself inexplicably impelled toward +the male sex to know that she is not being "tempted by the devil" but +merely driven by the insistent chemicals within her body. She is +likely to rationalize and tell herself that it is too bad for a +worth-while person like herself to leave no progeny behind her; or she +may say, as one of my patients did when contemplating running away +with another woman's husband,--that she could make that man so much +happier than his wife did, and that she really owed it to him as well +as to herself. When a woman knows what is the matter with her, it +makes it easier to bide her time and wait for the demands of Nature to +subside. Chemicals may not be so romantic as love, but neither are +they so melodramatic! + + +OTHER TROUBLES + +="Speaking of Operations."= Physicians are often called upon to +diagnose some such vague symptom as pain in the abdomen, back and +head; ache in the legs; constipation, or loss of appetite. Since the +patient is very insistent that something shall be done, the physician +may be driven to operate, even when he has an uneasy feeling that the +trouble is "merely nervous." Sixty per cent. of the operations on +women are necessitated by the results of gonorrheal infection. Next in +frequency up to recent date, have been operations for nervous symptoms +which could in no way be reached by the knife. Only too often a +nerve-specialist hears the tale of an operation which was supposed to +cure a certain pain but which left it worse rather than better. It is +a pleasure to see some of these pains disappear under a little +re-education, but one cannot help wishing that the re-education had +come before the knife instead of after it. + +A skilled surgeon can cut almost anything out of a person's body, but +he cannot cut out an instinct. It sometimes takes great skill to +determine whether the trouble is an organic affection or a functional +disturbance caused by the misdirected instinct of reproduction. Often, +however, the clinical pictures are so different as to leave no room +for doubt, provided the diagnostician has his eyes open and is not +over-persuaded by the importunity of the poor neurotic, who insists +that the surgeon shall remove her appendix, her gall-bladder, her +genital organs, and her tonsils, and who finally comes back that he +may have a whack at the operation scar. + +=The Bearing of Children.= A number of years ago I became acquainted +with a charming young married woman who had all her life recoiled with +fear from the phenomena of sex. She had been afraid of menstruation +and of marriage, and had at this time almost a phobia for pregnancy +and childbirth. Before long she came to me in terror, telling me that +she had become pregnant. I explained to her that pregnancy is the time +when most women are at their best, that the nausea which is often +troublesome in the beginning is caused merely by a mixing of messages +from the autonomic nerves, which refer new sensations in the womb to +the more usual center of activity in the stomach; and that after the +body has become accustomed to these sensations, most women experience +a greater sense of well-being and peace than at any other time in +life. We had a conversation or two on the subject and everything +seemed to go well for a while. + +As it happened, this young woman and her husband came to call on me +one afternoon just before the baby was expected. During the visit she +began to show signs of being in labor. Again she was in terror. Again +I explained the phenomena of labor, telling her that the +womb-contractions are caused by the presence in the blood of a +chemical secretion (hormone) which continues its good work as long as +there is a state of confidence, but which sometimes stops under fear +or apprehension. I explained that these womb-efforts are a peristaltic +movement, a contraction of the upper muscles and a letting go of the +purse-string muscle at the mouth of the womb, and that fear only tends +to tie up this purse-string muscle, making a difficult process out of +one which was intended by Nature to be much more simple. She seemed to +understand and to lose a good deal of her fright. + +About six o'clock the couple went home on the street car from the +upper end of Pasadena to the far end of Los Angeles. The next morning +I had a jubilant telephone message from the happy father, announcing +that the boy-baby had arrived at midnight and that, wonderful to +relate, he had come without the mother's experiencing any pain +whatever. + +I give this account for what it is worth, without of course contending +that labor could always be as easy as this. It happened that this girl +was a normal, healthy woman and that there were no complications of +any kind in the process of childbirth. A right attitude of mind could +not have corrected any physical difficulty, but it did seem to help +her let go of her fear, which would of itself have caused long and +painful labor. + +A patient once told me that when her first baby came, she happened to +be out in the country where she had to call in a doctor whom she did +not know. He was an uncouth sort of fellow who inspired fear rather +than confidence. She soon found that labor stopped whenever he came +into the room, and started again when he went out. She had the good +sense to send him out and complete her labor with only the help of her +mother. Unfortunate is the obstetrician who does not know how to +inspire a feeling of confidence in his patients. Even childbirth may +be mightily helped or hindered by the mother's state of mind. + + +SUMMARY + +A woman's body has more stability than she knows. It is sometimes out +of order, but it is more often misunderstood; usually it is an +unobtrusive and satisfactory instrument, quite fit for its daily +tasks. The average woman is really well put together. We hear about +the ones who have difficulty, but not about the great majority who do +not. We notice the few who are upset during the menopause, and forget +all the others. To be comfortable and efficient most of the time is, +after all, merely to be "like folks." + +The special functions which Nature has been perfecting in a woman's +body are as a rule, easily carried through unless complicated by false +ideas or by fear. + +If the woman who has no organic difficulty but who still finds herself +handicapped by her body, will cease being either resigned to her +languishing lot or envious of her stalwart brothers; if instead she +will set out to learn how to be efficient as a woman, she will find +that many of her ills are not the blunders of an inefficient Creator, +but are home-made products, which quickly vanish in the light of +understanding. + + + + +CHAPTER XIII + +_In which we lose our dread of night._ + +THAT INTERESTING INSOMNIA + +THE FEAR OF STAYING AWAKE + + +To sleep or not to sleep! That is the question. In all the world there +is nothing to equal it in importance,--to the man with insomnia. His +days are mere interludes between troubled nights spent in restless +tossing to and fro and feverish worry over the weary day to come. His +mind filled with ideas about the disastrous effects of insomnia, he +imagines himself fast sliding down hill toward the grave or the +insane-asylum. It is true that his conversation very often politely +begins something like this: "Good morning. Did you sleep well last +night?" but if we fail to respond by an equally polite "and I hope you +had a good night?" he seems restless until he has somehow +disillusioned us by stating the exact number of hours and minutes +during which he was able to lose himself in slumber. + +We must not ridicule the man who doesn't sleep. We are all very much +alike. If any one of us happens to lie awake for a night or two, he is +likely to get into a panic, and if the spell should last a week, he +begins looking up steamship agents and talking of voyages to Southern +seas. The fact is that most people are dreadfully afraid of insomnia. +Knowing the effects of a few nights of enforced wakefulness, and +having had a little experience with the fagged feeling after a +restless night, they believe themselves only logical when they fall +into a panic over the prospect of persistent insomnia. + +=Two Kinds of Wakefulness.= As a matter of fact, insomnia is a phantom +peril. There is not the slightest danger from lying awake nights, +provided one is not kept awake by some irritating physical stimulus. +All fear of insomnia is based on ignorance of the difference between +enforced wakefulness and deliberate wakefulness, or insomnia. The man +who has acquired the habit may stay awake almost indefinitely without +appreciable harm, but the one who is kept awake for a week by a pain, +by a chemical poison from infection, or by the necessity for staying +up on his job, may easily be in a state of exhaustion. Even in cases +of prolonged pain or over-exertion, the body tends to maintain its +equilibrium by hastening its rate of repair and by falling asleep +before the danger point is reached. It is almost impossible to impair +permanently the tissue of the brain except in the presence of a +chemical irritant. In case of infection we often have to give medicine +to neutralize the effect of the poison or to resort to narcotics which +make the brain cells less susceptible to irritation. But nervous +insomnia is another story. + + +A HARMLESS HABIT + +=Long-Lived Insomniacs.= A man of my acquaintance once said in all +seriousness and with evident alarm: "I am following in the footsteps +of my mother. She lived to be seventy years old and she had insomnia +all her life." If this man had been preaching a sermon on the +harmlessness of chronic insomnia, he could not have chosen a better +text, but he seemed just as much concerned about himself as if his +mother had died from the effects of three months' wakefulness. People +can live healthy lives during twenty or thirty years of insomnia +because chronic insomnia is nothing more or less than a habit, and +"habit spells ease." The brain cells are not irritated by either +internal or external stimuli; there is no effort to keep awake; +virtually no energy is expended,--except in restless tossing and +worry. If the body is kept still and emotion eliminated, fatigue +products are washed away and the reserves are filled in with perfect +ease. + +=Thinking in Circles.= Habit means automatic, subconscious activity, +with the least expenditure of energy and the least amount of fatigue. +We have already noted the ease with which heart and diaphragm muscles +carry on their work from the beginning of life to its end. Anything +relegated to the subconscious mind can be kept up almost indefinitely +without tire, and to this subconscious type of activity belong the +thoughts of a chronic insomniac. Despite all assertions to the +contrary, his conscious mind is not really awake. If he is questioned +about the happenings of the night, he is likely to have been unaware +of the most audible noises. The thoughts that run through his brain +are not new, constructive, energy-consuming thoughts, but the same old +thoughts that have been going around in circles for days and weeks at +a time. + +It is true that a person sometimes chooses to wake up and do his +constructive planning in the night. This kind of thought does bring +fatigue, up to a certain point. After that the body hastens its rate +of repair or automatically goes to sleep. Activity of this kind is +always a matter of choice. He who really prefers sleep will shut the +drawers containing the day's business and leave them shut until +morning. + +=Day-Dreaming at Night.= However, the man who makes a practice of +staying awake rarely does much real thinking. He lets the thoughts run +through his mind as they will, builds air-castles of things he would +like to do and can't, or other kinds of air-castles about the +disastrous effects of his insomnia on the day that is to come; he +worries over his health, or his finances, and grieves over his +sorrows. He is really indulging himself, thinking the thoughts he +likes most to think, and these consume but little energy. Like a horse +that knows the rounds, they can go jogging on indefinitely without +guidance from the driver. + + +WHAT CAUSES THE FATIGUE + +=Tossing and Fretting.= The thing that tires is not the insomnia but +the emotion over the insomnia. If people who fail to sleep are +perpetually fagged out, it is not from loss of sleep, but from worry +and tossing. Often they spend a good deal of the night feeling sorry +for themselves. They turn and toss, exclaiming with each turn: "Why +don't I sleep? How badly I shall feel to-morrow! What a night! What a +night!" Such a spree of emotionalism can hardly fail to tire, but it +is not fair to blame the insomnia. + +He who makes up his mind to it can rest almost as well without sleep +as with it, provided he keeps his mind calm and his body relaxed. +"Decent hygienic conditions" demand not necessarily eight hours of +sleep but eight hours of quiet rest in bed. Tossing about drives away +sleep and uses up energy. I make it a rule that my patients shall not +turn over more than four times during the night. This is more +important than that they should sleep. To be sure, I do not stay awake +to enforce the rule, but most people catch the idea very quickly and +before they know it they are sleeping. + + +HOW TO GO TO SLEEP + +=Ceasing to Care.= The best way to learn to sleep is not to care +whether you do or not. Nothing could be better than DuBois's advice: +"Don't look for sleep; it flies away like a pigeon when one pursues +it."[58] Attention to anything keeps the mind awake, and most of all, +attention to sleep. More than one person has waked up to see whether +or not he was going to sleep. We cannot, however, fool ourselves by +merely pretending indifference. The only sensible way is to get the +facts firmly fixed in our minds so that we actually realize that we do +not need more sleep than our bodies take. As soon as it is realized +that insomnia is really of no importance, it tends to disappear. + +[Footnote 58: DuBois: _Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders_, p. +339.] + +=Catching the Idea.= There came one day for consultation a very +healthy-looking woman, a deaconess of the Lutheran Church. "Doctor," +she said, "I came to get relief from insomnia. For twenty years I have +not slept more than one or two hours a night." "Why do you want more?" +I asked. "Why, isn't it very unhealthy not to sleep?" she exclaimed +in astonishment. "Evidently not," I answered. + +This woman had tried every doctor she could think of, including the +splendid S. Weir Mitchell. Her insomnia had become a preoccupation +with her, her chief thought in life. All I did was to explain to her +that her body had been getting all the sleep it needed, and that +neither body nor mind was in the least run down after twenty years of +sleeplessness. "When you cease being interested in your insomnia, it +will go away, although from a health standpoint it matters very little +whether it does or not." We had two conversations on the subject, and +a week later she came back to tell me that she was sleeping eight +hours a night. + +One woman had had insomnia for thirty years. After I had explained to +her that her body had adjusted itself to this way of living and that +she need not try to get more sleep, she snored so loud all night and +every night that the rest of the family began to complain! + +A certain banker proved very quick at catching the idea. He had been +so troubled with insomnia and intense weakness that his doctors +prescribed a six-months voyage in Southern waters. Knowing that my +prescriptions involved a change in point of view rather than in scene, +he came to me. Although he had been getting only about half an hour's +sleep a night, he went to sleep in his chair the first evening, and +then went upstairs and slept all night. He resumed his duties at the +bank, walking a mile and a half the first day and three miles the +second. During the months following, he reported, "No more insomnia." + +=Keeping Account.= A bright young college graduate came to me for a +number of ailments, chief among them being sleeplessness. She was also +overcome by fatigue, having spent four months in bed. A four-mile walk +in the cañon and a few other such outings soon dispelled the fatigue, +but the insomnia proved more obstinate. After she had been with me for +a week or two, I took her aside one day for a little talk. "Well?" I +said as we sat down. Then she began: "Sunday night I was awake from +half-past one to four, Monday from twelve to one, Tuesday from one to +three, Wednesday from two to four, Thursday--" By this time she became +aware of the quizzical expression on my face and began to be +embarrassed. Then she stopped and laughed. "Well," she said, "I did +not know that I was paying so much attention to my sleep." She was +bright enough to see the point at once, gave up her preoccupation in +the all-absorbing topic and promptly forgot to have any trouble with +so natural a function as sleep. + +=Making New Associations.= Examples like this show how natural is +childlike slumber when once we take away the inhibitions of a +hampering idea. Age-old habits like sleep are not lost, but they may +easily be interfered with by a little too much attention. When a +person who can scarcely keep his eyes open all the evening is +instantly wide awake as soon as his head touches the pillow, we may be +sure that a part of his trouble comes from the wrong associations +which he has built up with the thought of night. When a dear little +old lady told me of her constant state of apprehension about going to +bed, I said to her: "When I go to my room, the darkness says sleep. +When I take off my clothes, the very act says sleep. When I put my +head on the pillow, the pillow says sleep." She liked that and found +herself able to sleep all night. The next evening she wanted another +"sleeping-potion" but as I did not want her to become dependent on +anybody's suggestion, I put my mouth up close to her ear and +whispered, "Abra ca dabra, dum, dum, dum." She laughed, but saw the +point. After that she slept very well. She merely broke the habit by +making a new kind of association with the thought of bed. Nature did +the rest. + +It seems hardly necessary to remark that drug-taking is the most +inefficient way of handling the situation. Everybody knows that +narcotics are harmful to the delicate cells of the brain and that the +dose has to be continuously increased in cases of chronic insomnia. +If a person realizes that the drug is far more harmful than the +insomnia itself, he is weak indeed to yield to temptation for the sake +of a few nights of sleep. As the cause of insomnia is psychic, so the +only logical cure is a new idea and a new attitude of mind. + + +THE PURPOSE OF INSOMNIA + +Like all nervous symptoms, insomnia is not an affliction but an +indulgence. Somehow, and in ways unknown to the conscious mind, it +brings a certain amount of satisfaction to a part of the personality. +No matter how unpleasant it may be, no matter how much we consciously +fear it, something inside chooses to stay awake. + +Started, as a rule, through suggestion or imitation, insomnia is +sometimes kept up as a means of making ourselves seem important,--to +ourselves and to others. It at least provides an excuse for thinking +and talking about ourselves, and furnishes a certain feeling of +distinction. If something within us craves attention, even staying +awake may not be too dear a price to pay for that attention. Strange +to say, there are other times when the insomnia is chosen by the +primitive subconscious mind with the idea of doing penance for +supposed sins whose evil effects might possibly be avoided by this +kind of expiation. Analysis shows that motives like this are not so +uncommon as might be supposed. In other cases insomnia is chosen for +the chance it gives for phantasy-building. A person denied the right +kind of outlet for his instincts may so enjoy the day-dreaming habit +that he prolongs it into the night, really preferring it to sleep. +Such a state of affairs is not at all incompatible with an intense +conscious desire to sleep and a real fear of insomnia. So strange may +be the motives hidden away within the depths of the most prosaic +individual! + + +SUMMARY + +Nervous insomnia is something which a part of us makes use of and +another part fears. It is a mistake on both sides. Although not in the +least dangerous, the habit can hardly be considered a satisfactory +form of amusement. Nature has provided a better way to spend the +night, a way to which she speedily brings us when we choose to let her +do it. + +We do not have to ask for sleep as for a special boon which may be +denied. We simply have to lie down in trust, expecting to be carried +away like a child. If our expectation is not at once realized we can +still trust, as with relaxed mind and body we lie in calm content, +knowing that Nature is, minute by minute, restoring us for another +day. + + + + +CHAPTER XIV + +_In which we raise our thresholds_ + +FEELING OUR FEELINGS + +FINELY STRUNG VIOLINS + + +The young girl had been telling me about her symptoms. "You know, +Doctor," she said. "I am a very sensitive person. In fact, I have +always been told that I am like a finely strung violin." There was +pride in every tone of her voice,--pride and satisfaction over +possessing an organization so superior to the common clay of the +average person. It was a typical remark, and showed clearly that this +girl belonged among the nervous folk. For the nervous person is not +only over-sensitive, but he accepts his condition with a secret and +half-conscious pride as a token of superiority. + +It seems that there are a good many kinds of sensitiveness. Whether it +is a good or bad possession depends entirely on what kind of things a +person is sensitive to. If he is quick to take in a situation, easily +impressed with the needs of others, open-doored to beauty and to the +appeal of the spiritual, keenly alive to the humorous, even when the +joke is on himself and the situation uncomfortable, then surely he has +a right to be glad of his sensitiveness. But too often the word means +something else. It means feeling, intensely, physical sensations of +which most people are unaware, or reacting emotionally to situations +which call for no such response. It means, in short, feeling our +feelings and liking to feel them. There seems to be nothing +particularly praiseworthy or desirable about this kind of +sensitiveness. If this is what it means to be a "finely-wrought +violin," it might even be better to be a bass drum which can stand a +few poundings without ruin to its constitution. + +"But," says the sensitive person, "are we not born either violins or +drums? Is not heredity rather than choice to blame? And what can a +person do about it?" These questions are so closely bound up with the +problems of nervous symptoms of indigestion, fatigue, a woman's ills, +hysterical pains and sensations, and with all the problems of +emotional control, that we shall do well to look more carefully into +this question of sensibility, which is really the question of the +relation of the individual to his environment. + + +SELECTING OUR SENSATIONS + +=Reaction and Over-Reaction.= Every organism, if it is to live, must +be normally sensitive to its environment. It must possess the power +of response to stimuli. As the sea-anemone curls up at touch, and as +the tiny baby blinks at the light, so must every living thing be able +to sense and to react to the presence of a dangerous or a friendly +force. Only by a certain degree of irritability can it survive in the +struggle for existence. The five senses are simply different phases of +the apparatus for receiving communications from the outside world. +Other parts of the machinery catch the manifold messages continually +pouring into the brain from within our bodies themselves. These +communications cannot be stopped nor can we prevent their impress on +the cells of the brain and spinal cord, but we do have a good deal to +say as to which ones shall be brought into the focus of attention and +receive enough notice to become real, conscious sensations. + +=Paying Attention.= If a human being had to give conscious attention +to every stimulus from the outer world and from his own body, to every +signal which flashes itself along his sensory nerves to his brain, he +would need a different kind of mind from his present efficient but +limited apparatus. As it is, there is an admirable provision for +taking care of the messages without overburdening consciousness. The +stream of messages never stops, not even in sleep. But the conscious +mind has its private secretary, the subconscious, to receive the +messages and to answer them. + +During any five minutes of a walk down a city street a man has +hundreds of visual images flashed upon the retina of the eye. His eye +sees every little line in the faces of the passers-by, every detail of +their clothing, the decorations on the buildings, the street signs +overhead, the articles in the shop-windows, the paving of the +sidewalks, the curbings and tracks which he crosses, and scores of +other objects to most of which the man himself is oblivious. His ear +hears every sound within hearing distance,--the honk of every horn, +the clang of every bell, the voices of the people and the shuffle of +feet. Some part of his mind feels the press of his foot on the +pavement, the rubbing of his heel on his stocking, the touch of his +clothing all over his body, and all those so-called kinesthetic +sensations,--sensations of motion and balance which keep him in +equilibrium and on the move, to say nothing of the never-ending stream +of messages from every cell of every muscle and tissue of his body. + +Out of this constant rush of stimuli our man gives attention to only +the smallest fraction. Whatever is interesting to him, that he sees +and hears and feels. All other sensations he passes by as indifferent. +Unless they come with extraordinary intensity, they do not get over +into his consciousness at all. + +="Listening-in" on the Subconscious.= The subconscious mind knows and +needs to know what is happening in the farthermost cell of the body. +It needs to know at any moment where the knees are, and the feet; +otherwise the individual would fall in a heap whenever he forgot to +watch his step. It needs to know just how much light is entering the +eye, and how much blood is in the stomach. To this end it has a system +of communication from every point in the body and this system is in +constant operation. Its messages never cease. But these messages were +never meant to be in the focus of attention. They are meant only for +the subconscious mind and are generally so low-toned as to be easily +ignored unless one falls into the habit of listening for them. Unless +they are invested with a significance which does not belong to them, +they will not emerge into consciousness as real sensations. + +=Psychic Thresholds.= Boris Sidis has given us a word which has proved +very useful in this connection. The limit of sensitivity of a +cell--the degree of irritability--he calls the stimulus-threshold.[59] +As the wind must come in gusts to drive the rain in over a high +doorsill, so must any stimulus--an idea or a sensation--come with +sufficient force to get over the obstructions at the doorway of +consciousness. These psychic thresholds do not maintain a constant +level. They are raised or lowered at will by a hidden and automatic +machinery, which is dependent entirely on the ideas already in +consciousness, by the interest bestowed upon the newcomer. The +intensity of the stimuli cannot be controlled, but the interest we +feel in them and the welcome given them are very largely a matter of +choice. + +[Footnote 59: Sidis: _Foundations of Normal and Abnormal Psychology_, +Chap. XXX.] + +Each organism has a wide field of choice as to which ideas and which +physical stimuli it shall welcome and which it shall shut out. We may +raise our thresholds, build up a bulwark of indifference to a whole +class of excitations, shut our mental doors, and pull down the shades; +or we may lower the thresholds so that the slightest flicker of an +idea or the smallest pin-prick of a sensation finds ready access to +the center of attention. + +=Thresholds and Character.= There are certain thresholds made to shift +frequently and easily. When one is hungry any food tastes good, for +the threshold is low; but the food must be most tempting to be +acceptable just after a hearty meal. On the other hand, a fairly +constant threshold is maintained for many different kinds of stimuli. +These stimuli are always bound together in groups, and make appeal +depending upon the predominating interest. As anything pertaining to +agriculture is noticed by a farmer, or any article of dress by a +fashionable woman, so any stimulus coming from a "warm" group is +welcomed, while any from a "cold" group is met by a high threshold. +The kind of person one is depends on what kind of things are "warm" +to him and what kind are "cold." The superman is one who has gained +such conscious control of his psychic thresholds that he can raise and +lower them at will in the interests of the social good. + +=Thresholds and Sensations.= The importance of these principles is +obvious. The next chapter will show more of their influence on ideas +and emotions; but for the present we will consider their lessons in +the sphere of the physical. Psychology speaks here in no uncertain +terms to physiology. Whoever becomes fascinated by the processes of +his own body is bound to magnify the sensations from those processes, +until the most insignificant message from the subconscious becomes a +distressing and alarming symptom. The person whose mental ear is +strained to catch every little creaking of his internal machinery can +always hear some kind of rumble. If he deliberately lowers his +thresholds to the whole class of stimuli pertaining to himself, there +is small wonder that they sweep over the boundaries into consciousness +with irresistible force. + +=The Motives for Sensitiveness.= Sensitiveness is largely a matter of +choice, but what determines choice? Why is it that one person chooses +altruism as the master threshold that determines the level of all the +others, while another person who ought to be equally fine lowers his +thresholds only to himself? What makes a person too interested in his +own sensations and feelings? As usual there is a cause. + +The real cause back of most cases of chronic sensitiveness is an +abnormal desire for attention. Sometimes this love of attention arises +from an under-developed instinct of self-assertion, or "inferiority +complex." If there is a sense of inadequacy, a feeling of not being so +important as other people, a person is quite likely to over-compensate +by making himself seem important to himself and to others in the only +way he knows. All unconsciously he develops an extreme sensitiveness +which somehow heightens his self-regard by making him believe himself +finely and delicately organized, and by securing the notice of his +associates. + +Or, again, the love of attention may be simply a sign of arrested +development, a fixation of the Narcissistic period of childhood which +loves to look at itself and make the world look. Or there may be lack +of satisfaction of the normal adult love-life, a lack of the love and +attention which the love-instinct naturally craves. If this instinct +is not getting normal outlet, either directly through personal +relationships or indirectly through a sublimated activity, what is +more natural than that it should turn in on itself, dissociate its +interest in other things and occupy itself with its own feelings, and +at the same time secure the coveted attention through physical +disability, with its necessity for special ministration? + +In any case there is likely to develop a general overreaction to all +outside stimulation, a hypersensitiveness to some particular kind of +stimulus, or a chronic hysterical pain which somehow serves the +personality in ways unknown to itself. No one "feels his feelings" +unless, despite all discomfort, he really enjoys them. A hard +statement to accept perhaps, but one that is repeatedly proved by a +specialist in "nerves"! + + +DETERMINING CAUSES + +=Accidental Association.= In many cases, the form which the +sensitiveness takes is merely a matter of accident. Often it is based +on some small physical disability, as when a slight tendency to take +cold is magnified into an intense fear of fresh air. + +Sometimes a past fleeting pain which has become associated with the +stream of thought of an emotional moment--what Boris Sidis calls the +moment-consciousness--is perpetuated in consciousness in place of the +repressed emotion. "In the determination of the pathology of hysteria, +the accidental moment plays a much greater part than is generally +recognized; if a painful affect--emotion--originates while eating but +is repressed, it may produce nausea and vomiting and continue for +months as an hysterical symptom."[60] + +[Footnote 60: Freud: _Selected Papers_, p. 2.] + +One of Freud's patients, Miss Rosalie H----, found while taking +singing-lessons that she often choked over notes of the middle +register, although she took with ease notes higher and lower in the +scale. It was revealed that this girl, who had a most unhappy home +life, had, during a former period, often experienced this choking +sensation from a painful emotion just before she went for her music +lesson. Some of the left-over sensations had remained during the +singing, and as the middle notes happen to involve the same muscles as +does a lump in one's throat, she had often found herself choking over +these notes. Later on, while living in a different city and in a +wholly different environment, the physical sensations from her throat +muscles, as they took these middle notes, brought back the associated +sensations of choking,--without, however, uncovering the buried +emotion.[61] Many a painful hysterical affliction is based on just +such mechanisms as these. As Freud remarks, "The hysteric suffers +mostly from reminiscences."[62] + +[Footnote 61: Ibid, p. 43.] + +[Footnote 62: Ibid, p. 5.] + +=Subconscious Symbolism.= Sometimes, as we have seen, the form which +a hypersensitiveness assumes is not determined by any physical +sensation, either past or symbolism which acts out in the body the +drama of the soul. + +=Facing the Facts.= Whatever the motives and whatever the determining +causes, hypersensibility is in any case a feeling of feelings which is +not warranted by the present situation. Hypersensitiveness is never +anything but a makeshift kind of satisfaction. Despite certain +subconscious reasoning, it does not make one more important nor more +beloved. Neither does it furnish a real expression for that great +creative love-instinct whose outlet, if it is to bring satisfaction, +must be a real outlet into the external world. An understanding of the +motives is helpful only when it makes clear that they are +short-sighted motives and that the real desires back of them may be +satisfied in better ways. + + +SOME LOWERED THRESHOLDS + +As the public appetite for specific cases appears to be insatiable, we +will give from real life some examples of low thresholds which were +raised through re-education. One hesitates to write down these +examples because when they are on paper they sound like advertisements +of patent medicines. However, there is no magic in any of these cures, +but only the working out of definite laws which may be used by other +sufferers, if they only know. Re-education through a knowledge of +oneself and the laws at work really does remarkable things when it has +a chance. + +="Danger-Signals" without the Danger.= There was the man who had queer +feelings all over his body, especially in his head and stomach, and +who considered these sensations as danger-signals warning him to stop. +This man had worked up from messenger boy to a position next to the +president in one of the transcontinental railroad systems. On the +appearance of these "danger-signals" he had tried to resign but had +been given a year's leave of absence instead. Half the year had gone +in rest-cure, but he was still afraid to eat or work, and believed +himself "done for." After three weeks of re-education he saw that +instead of having overdrawn his capital, he had in another sense +overdrawn his sensations. He went away as fit as ever, finished his +leave of absence doing hard labor on his farm, and then went back to +even harder tasks, working for the Government in the administration of +the railroads during the war. He is still at work. + +=Enjoying Poor Health.= There was the woman who had been an invalid +for twenty years, doing little else during all that time than to feel +her own feelings. Because of the distressing sensations in her +stomach, she had for a year taken nothing but liquid nourishment. She +had queer feelings in her solar-plexus and indeed a general luxury of +over-feeling. She could not leave her room nor have any visitors. She +was the star invalid of the family, waited on by her two hard-working +sisters who earned the living for them all. + +Her sisters had inveigled her to my house under false pretenses, +calling it a boarding-house and omitting to mention that I was a +doctor, because "she guessed she knew more about her case than any +doctor." For the first week I got in only one sentence a day,--just +before I slipped out of the door after taking in her "liquid +nourishment." But at the end of the week I announced that thereafter +her meals would be served in the dining-room. When she found that +there was to be no more liquid nourishment, she had to appear at the +family table. After that it was only a short time before she was at +home, cooking for her sisters. When she saw the role she had been +unconsciously playing, she could hardly wish to go on with it. + +=Feeling His Legs.= Mr. R. suffered from such severe and distressing +pains in his legs that he believed himself on the verge of paralysis. +He was also bothered by a chronic emotional state which made him look +like a "weepy" woman. His eyes were always full of tears and his chin +a-quiver, and he had, as he said, a perpetual lump in his throat. +Under re-education both lump and paralysis disappeared completely and +Mr. R. took his wife across the continent, driving his machine with +his own hands--and feet. + +=A Subconscious Association.= Mr. D.'s case admirably illustrates the +return of symptoms through an unconscious association. He was a +lawyer, prominent in public affairs of the Middle West, who had been +my patient for several weeks and who had gone home cured of many +striking disabilities. Before he came to me, he had given up his +public work and was believed by all his associates to be afflicted +with softening of the brain, and "out of the game" for good. From +being one of the ablest men of his State, he had fallen into such a +condition that he could neither read a letter nor write one. He could +not stand the least sunshine on his head, and to walk half a mile was +an impossibility. He was completely "down and out" and expected to be +an invalid for the rest of his life. + +But these symptoms had one by one disappeared during his five-weeks +stay with me. He had done good stiff work in the garden, carried a +heavy sack of grapefruit a mile in the hot sun, and was generally his +old self again. Now he was back in the harness, hard at work as of +old. Suddenly, as he sat reading in his home one evening, all his old +symptoms swept over him,--the pains in his head and legs, the pounding +of the heart, the "all-gone" sensations as though he were going to die +on the spot. He became almost completely dissociated, but through it +all he clung to the idea which he had learned,--namely that this +experience was not really physical as it seemed but was the result of +some idea, and would pass. He did not tell any one of the attack, +ignored it as much as possible, and waited. In a few minutes he was +himself again. Then he looked for the cause and realized that the +article he was reading was one he had read several months previous, +when suffering most severely from the whole train of symptoms. When +the familiar words had again gone into his mind, they had pressed the +button for the whole physiological experience which had once before +been associated with them. This is the same mechanism as that involved +in Prince's case, Miss Beauchamp, who became completely dissociated at +one time when a breeze swept across her face. When Dr. Prince looked +for the cause, he found that once before she had experienced certain +distressing emotions while a breeze was fanning her cheek. The +recurrence of the physical stimulation had been sufficient to bring +back in its entirety the former emotional complex. + +=Another Kind of Association.= One of my women patients illustrates +another kind of association-mechanism, based not on proximity in time +but proximity of position in the body. This woman had complained for +years of "bladder trouble" although no physical examination had been +able to reveal any organic difficulty. She referred to a constant +distress in the region of the bladder and was never without a certain +red blanket which she wrapped around her every time she sat down. +During psycho-analysis she recounted an experience of years before +which she had never mentioned to anybody. During a professional +consultation her physician, a married man, had suddenly seized her and +exclaimed, "I love you! I love you!" In spite of herself, the woman +felt a certain appeal, followed by a great sense of guilt. In the +conflict between the physiological reflex and her moral repugnance, +she had shunted out of consciousness the real sex-sensation and had +replaced it with a sensation which had become associated in her +subconscious mind with the original temptation. Since the nerves from +the genital region and from the bladder connect with the same segment +of the spinal cord, she had unconsciously chosen to mix her messages, +and to cling to the substitute sensation without being in the least +Conscious of the cause. As soon as she had described the scene to me +and had discerned its connection with her symptoms, the bladder +trouble disappeared. + +=Afraid of the Cold.= Patients who are sensitive to cold are very +numerous. Mr. G.--he of the prunes and bran biscuits--was so afraid of +a draft that he could detect the air current if a window was opened a +few inches anywhere in a two-story house. He always wore two suits of +underwear, but despite his precautions he had a swollen red throat +much of the time. His prescription was a cold bath every morning, a +source of delight to the other men patients, who made him stay in the +water while they counted five. He was required to dress and live like +other folks and of course his sensitiveness and his sore throat +disappeared. + +Dr. B----, when he came to me, was the most wrapped-up man I had ever +met. He had on two suits of underwear, a sweater, a vest and suit +coat, an overcoat, a bear-skin coat and a Jaeger scarf--all in +Pasadena in May! + +Besides this fear of cold, he was suffering from a hypersensitiveness +of several other varieties. So sensitive was his skin that he had his +clothes all made several sizes too big for him so that they would not +make pressure. He was so aware of the muscles of the neck that he +believed himself unable to hold up his head, and either propped it +with his hands or leaned it against the back of a chair. + +He had been working on the eighth edition of his book, a scientific +treatise of nation-wide importance, but his eyes were so sensitive +that he could not possibly use them and had to keep them shaded from +the glare. He was so conscious of the messages of fatigue that he was +unable to walk at all, and he suffered from the usual trouble with +constipation. All these symptoms of course belonged together and were +the direct result of a wrong state of mind. When he had changed his +mind, he took off his extra clothes, walked a mile and a half at the +first try, gave up his constipation, and went back to work. Later on I +had a letter from him saying that his favorite seat was an overturned +nail-keg in the garden and that he was thinking of sawing the backs +off his chairs. + +Miss Y---- had worn cotton in her ears for a year or two because she +had once had an inflammation of the middle ear, and believed the +membrane still sensitive to cold. There was Miss E----, whose +underwear always reached to her throat and wrists and who spent her +time following the sun; and Dr. I----, who never forgot her heavy +sweater or her shawl over her knees, even in front of the fire. The +procession of "cold ones" is almost endless, but always they find that +their sensitiveness is of their own making and that it disappears when +they choose to ignore it. + +=Fear of Light.= Fear of cold is no more common than fear of light. +Nervous folk with half-shut eyes are very frequent indeed. From one +woman I took at least seven pairs of dark glasses before she learned +that her eye was made for light. A good example is furnished by a +woman who was not a patient of mine at all, but merely the sister of a +patient. After my patient had been cured of a number of distressing +symptoms--pain in the spine, sore heels, a severe nervous cough, +indigestion and other typical complaints,--she began to scheme to get +her sister to come to me. + +This sister, the wife of a minister in the Middle West, had a constant +pain in her eyes, compelling her to hold them half-shut all the time. +When she was approached about coming to me, she said indignantly, "If +that doctor thinks that my trouble is nervous, she is much mistaken," +and then proceeded to get well. Once the subconscious mind gets the +idea that its game is recognized, it is very apt to give it up, and it +can do this without loss of time if it really wants to. + +=Pain at the Base of the Brain.= Of all nervous pains, that in the +back of the neck is by all odds the most common. It is rare indeed to +find a nervous patient without this complaint, and among supposedly +well folk it is only too frequent. Indeed, it almost seems that in +some quarters such a pain stands as a badge of the fervor and zeal of +one's work. + +But work is never responsible for this sense of discomfort. Only an +over-sensitiveness to feelings or a false emotionalism can produce a +pain of this kind, unless it should happen to be caused by some poison +circulating in the blood. The trouble is not with the nerves or with +the spine, despite the fad about misplaced vertebræ. When a doctor +examines a sensitive spine, marking the sore spots with a blue pencil, +and a few minutes later repeats the process, he finds almost +invariably that the spots have shifted. They are not true physical +pains and they rarely remain long in the same place. + +Pain in the spine and neck is an example of exaggerated sensibility or +over-awareness. Since all messages from every part of trunk and limb +must go through the spinal cord, and since very many of them enter the +cord in the region of the neck and shoulder blades, it is only natural +that an over-feeling of these messages should be especially noticed in +this zone. + +Sometimes a false emotionalism adds to the discomfort by tensing the +whole muscular system and making the messages more intense. When a +social worker or a business man gets tense over his work or ties +himself into knots over a committee meeting, he not only foolishly +wastes his energy but makes his nerves carry messages that are more +urgent than usual. Then if he is on the look-out for sensations, he +all the more easily becomes aware of the central station in the spine +where the messages are received. By centering his attention on this +station and tightening up his back-muscles, he increases this +over-awareness and easily gets himself into the clutch of a vicious +habit. + +Sometimes a tenseness of the body is the result, not of a false +attitude toward one's work, but of a lack of satisfaction in other +directions. If the love-force is not getting what it wants, it may +keep the body in a state of tension, with all the undesirable results +of such tension. The person who keeps himself tense, whether because +of his work or because of tension in other directions, has not really +learned how to throw himself into his job and to forget himself, his +emotions, and his body. + +=Various Pains.= Tender spots may appear in almost any part of the +body. There was the girl with the sore scalp, who was frequently so +sensitive that she could not bear to have a single hair touched at its +farthermost end, and who could not think of brushing her hair at such +a time. There was the man whose wrists and ankles were so painful that +the slightest touch was excruciating; the woman with the false +sciatica; the man with the so-called appendicitis pains; and the man +with the false neuritis, who always wore jersey coats several sizes +too large. Each one of these false pains was removed by the process of +re-education. + +=Low Thresholds to Fatigue.= Mr. H. was habitually so overcome by +fatigue that he could not make himself carry through the slightest +piece of work, even when necessity demanded it. On Sunday night, when +there was no one else to milk the cow, he had had to stop in the +middle of the process and go into the house to lie down. To carry the +milk was impossible, so low were his thresholds to the slightest +message of fatigue. It turned out that things were not going right in +the reproductive life. His threshold was low in this direction, and it +carried down with it all other thresholds. After a general revaluation +of values, he found himself able to keep his thresholds at the normal +level. + +A fine, efficient missionary from the Orient had been so overcome with +fatigue that he was forced to give up all work and return to this +country. He had been with me for a while and was again ready to go to +work. He came one day with a radiant face to bid me good-by. "Why are +you so joyous?" I asked. "Because," he answered, "before I came home I +was so fatigued that it used me up completely just to see the native +servants pack our luggage. Now we are taking back twice as much, and I +not only packed it all myself but made the boxes with my own hands. No +more fatigue for me!" + +A charming young girl who in many ways was an inspiration to all her +associates fell into the habit of over-feeling her fatigue. "You know, +Doctor," she said, "that I give out too much of myself; everybody +tells me so." That was just the trouble. Everybody had told her so, +and the suggestion had worked. It did not take her long to learn that +in scattering abroad she was enriching herself, and that her "giving +out" was not exhausting to her but rather the truest kind of +self-expression. It is only when a "giving out" is accompanied by a +"looking in" that it can ever deplete. The "See how much I am +giving," and "How tired I shall be," attitude could hardly fail to +exhaust, but a real self-expression and the fulfilment of a real +desire to give are never anything else than exhilarating. There is +something wrong with the minister who is used up after his Sunday +sermons. If his message and not himself is his real concern, he will +have only a normal amount of fatigue, accompanied by a general sense +of accomplishment and well-being, after he has fed his flock. To be +sure, I have never been a minister, but I have had a goodly number +among my patients and I speak from a fairly close acquaintance with +their problems. + +=Stopping Our Ears.= Roosters seem to be a perpetual source of +annoyance to the folk whose thresholds are not under proper control. +But as roosters seem to be necessary to an egg-eating nation, it seems +simpler to change the threshold than to abolish the roosters. There +was one woman who complained especially about being disturbed by +early-morning Chanticleers. I explained that the crowing called for no +action on her part, and that therefore she should not allow it to come +into consciousness. "Do you mean," she said, "that I could keep from +hearing them?" As it happened, she was sitting under the clock, which +had just struck seven. "Did you hear the clock strike?" I asked. "No," +she said; "did it strike?" + +This poor little woman, who suffered from a very painful back and +other distressing symptoms, had been married at sixteen to a roué of +forty; and, without experiencing any of the psychic feelings of sex, +had been immediately plunged into the physical sex-relations. Since +sex is psycho-physical and since any attempt to separate the two +elements is both desecrating and unsatisfactory; it is not surprising +that misery, and finally divorce, had been her portion. Another +equally unpleasant experience had followed, and the poor woman in the +strain and disappointment of her love-life, and in the lowering of the +thresholds pertaining to this thwarted instinct, had unconsciously +lowered the thresholds to all physical stimuli, until she was no +longer master of herself in any line. When she saw the reason for her +exaggerated reactions, she was able to gain control of herself, and to +find outlet in other ways. + +Too many persons fall into the way of being disturbed by noises which +are no concern of theirs. As nurses learn to sleep through all sounds +but the call of their own patients, so any one may learn to ignore all +sounds but those which he needs to hear. Connection with the outside +world can be severed by a mental attitude in much the same way as this +is accomplished by the physical effect of an anaesthetic. Then the +usual noises, those which the subconscious recognizes as without +significance, will be without power to disturb. The well-known New +York publisher who spent his last days on his private yacht, on which +everything was rubber-heeled and velvet-cushioned, thought that he +couldn't stand noises; but how much more fun he would have had, if +some one had only told him about thresholds! + + +SUMMARY + +There are two kinds of people in the world,--masters and puppets. +There is the man in control of his thresholds, at leisure from himself +and master of circumstance, free to use his energy in fruitful ways; +and there is the over-sensitive soul, wondering where the barometer +stands and whether people are going to be quiet, feeling his feelings +and worrying because no one else feels them, forever wasting his +energy in exaggerated reactions to normal situations. + +This "ticklish" person is not better equipped than his neighbor, but +more poorly equipped. True adjustment to the environment requires the +faculty of putting out from consciousness all stimuli that do not +require conscious attention. The nervous person is lacking in this +faculty, but he usually fails to realize that this lack places him in +the class of defectives. A paralyzed man is a cripple because he +cannot run with the crowd; a nervous individual is a cripple, but only +because he thinks that to run with the crowd lacks distinction. +Something depends on the accident of birth, but far more depends on +his own choice. Understanding, judicious neglect of symptoms, +whole-souled absorption in other interests, and a good look in the +mirror, are sure to put him back in the running with a wholesome +delight in being once more "like folks." + + + + +CHAPTER XV + +_In which we learn discrimination_ + +CHOOSING OUR EMOTIONS + +LIKING THE TASTE + + +It was a summer evening by the seaside, and a group of us were sitting +on the porch, having a sort of heart-to-heart talk about +psychology,--which means, of course, that we were talking about +ourselves. One by one the different members of the family spoke out +the questions that had been troubling them, or brought up their +various problems of character or of health. At length a splendid Red +Cross nurse who had won medals for distinguished service in the early +days of the war, broke out with the question: "Doctor, how can I get +rid of my terrible temper? Sometimes it is very bad, and always it has +been one of the trials of my life." She spoke earnestly and sincerely, +but this was my answer: "You like your temper. Something in you enjoys +it, else you would give it up." Her face was a study in astonishment. +"I don't like it," she stammered; "always after I have had an +outburst of anger I am in the depths of remorse. Many a time I have +cried my eyes out over this very thing." "And you like that, too," I +answered. "You are having an emotional spree, indulging yourself first +in one kind of emotion and then in another. If you really hated it as +much as you say you do, you would never allow yourself the indulgence, +much less speak of it afterward." Her astonishment was still further +increased when several of the group said they, too, had sensed her +satisfaction with her moods. + +Hard as it is to believe, we do choose our emotions. We like emotion +as we do salt in our food, and too often we choose it because +something in us likes the savor, and not because it leads to the +character or the conduct that we know to be good. + + +THE POWER OF CHOICE + +Whether we believe it or not, and whether we like it or not, the fact +remains that we ourselves decide which of all the possible emotions we +shall choose, or we decide not to press the button for any emotion at +all. + +To a very large extent man, if he knows how and really wishes, may +select the emotion which is suitable in that it leads to the right +conduct, has a beneficial effect on the body, adapts him to his social +environment, and makes him the kind of man he wants to be. + +=The Test of Feeling.= The psychologist to-day has a sure test of +character. He says in substance: "Tell me what you feel and I will +tell you what you are. Tell me what things you love, what things you +fear, and what makes you angry and I will describe with a fair degree +of accuracy your character, your conduct, and a good deal about the +state of your physical health." + +Since this test of emotion is fundamentally sound, it is not +surprising that the nervous man is in a state of distress. +Indigestion, fatigue, over-sensibility, sound like problems in +physiology, but we cannot go far in the discussion of any of them +without coming face to face with the emotions as the real factors in +the case. When we turn to the mental characteristics of nervous folk, +we even more quickly find ourselves in the midst of an emotional +disturbance. Worried, fearful, anxious, self-pitying, excitable, or +melancholy, the nervous person proves that whatever else a neurosis +may be, it is, in essence, a riot of the emotions. + +There is small wonder that a riot at the heart of the empire should +lead to insurrection in every province of the personality. It is only +for the purpose of discussion that we can separate feeling from +thinking and doing. Every thought and every act has in it something of +all three elements. An emotion is not an isolated phenomenon; it is +bound up on the one hand with ideas and on the other with bodily +states and conduct. Whoever runs amuck in his emotions runs amuck in +his whole being. The nervous invalid with his exhausted and sensitive +body, his upset mind and irrational conduct is a living illustration +of the central place of the emotions in the realm of the personality. + +But it is not the nervous person only who needs a better understanding +of his emotional life. The well man also gets angry for childish +reasons; he is prejudiced and envious, unhappy and suspicious for the +very same reason as is the nervous man. Since the working-capital of +energy is limited to a definite amount, the control of the emotions +becomes a central problem in any life,--a deciding factor in the +output and the outcome, as well as in comfort and happiness by the +way. + +Nothing is harder for the average man to believe than this fact that +he really has the power to choose his emotions. He has been +dissatisfied with himself in his past reactions, and yet he has not +known how to change them. His anger or his depression has appeared so +undesirable to his best judgment and to his conscious reason that it +has seemed to be not a part of himself at all but an invasion from +without which has swept over him without his consent and quite beyond +control. + + +A HOUSE DIVIDED AGAINST ITSELF + +Most of the confusion comes from the fact that we know only a part of +ourselves. What we do not consciously enjoy we believe we do not enjoy +at all. What we do not consciously choose we believe to be beyond our +power of choice,--the work of the evil one, or the natural depravity +of human nature, perhaps; but certainly not anything of our choosing. + +The point is that a human being is so constituted that he can, without +knowing it, entertain at the same time two diametrically opposite +desires. The average person is not so unified as he believes, but is, +in fact, "a house divided against itself." + +The words of the apostle Paul express for most of us the truth about +ourselves: "For what I would, that I do not; but what I hate that I +do." What Paul calls the law of his members warring against the law of +his mind is simply what we call to-day the instinctive desires coming +into conflict with our conscious ideal. + +=Hidden Desires.= Although we choose our emotions, we choose in many +cases in response to a buried part of ourselves of which we are wholly +unaware, or only half-aware. When we do not like what we have chosen, +it is because the conscious part of us is out of harmony with another +part and that part is doing the choosing. If the emotions which we +choose are not those that the whole of us--or at least the +conscious--would desire, it is because we are choosing in response to +hidden desires, and giving satisfaction to cravings which we have not +recognized. Repeated indulgence of such desires is responsible for the +emotional habits which we are too likely to consider an inevitable +part of our personality, inherited from ancestors who are not on hand +to defend themselves. When we form the habit of being afraid of things +that other people do not fear, or of being irritated or depressed, or +of giving way to fits of temper, it is because these habit-reactions +satisfy the inner cravings that in the circumstances can get +satisfaction in no better way. + +These hidden desires are of several different kinds, when squarely +looked at. Some of the cravings are found to be childish, and so out +of keeping with our real characters that we could not possibly hold on +to them as conscious desires. Others turn out to be so natural and so +inevitable that we wonder how we could ever have imagined that they +ought to be repressed. Still others, legitimate in themselves, but +denied because of outer circumstances, are found to be easily +satisfied in indirect ways which bear no resemblance to their old +unfortunate forms of outlet. + + +WHEN KNOWLEDGE HELPS + +The way to get rid of an undesirable emotion is not by working at the +emotion itself, but by realizing that this is merely an offshoot of a +deeper root, hidden below the surface. The great point is to recognize +this deeper root. + +=Childish Anger.= It helps to know that uncalled-for anger is a +defense reaction--a sort of camouflage or smoke cloud which we throw +out to hide from ourselves and others the fact that we are being +worsted in an argument, or being shown up in an undesirable light. +Better than any amount of weeping over a hot temper is an +understanding of the fact that when we fly into unseemly rage we are +usually giving indulgence to a childhood desire to run away from +unpleasant facts and to cover up our own faults. + +=Enjoying the Blues.= It helps to know that the easiest way to fight +the blues is by realizing that they are a deliberate, if unconscious, +attempt to gain the pity of ourselves and others. There seems to be in +undeveloped human nature something that really enjoys being pitied, +and if we cannot get the commiseration of other people, we can, +without much trouble, work up a case of self-pity. Most of us would +have to acknowledge that we seldom find tears in our eyes except when +our own woes are under consideration. "Whatever else the blues +accomplish, they certainly afford us a chance to submerge ourselves +in a sea of self-engrossment."[63] + +[Footnote 63: Putnam: _Human Motives_.] + +=The Chip on the Shoulder.= It helps to know that irritability and +over-sensitiveness are usually the result of tension from unsatisfied +desires which must find some kind of outlet. If a person is secretly +restive under the fact that he cannot have the kind of clothes he +wants, cannot shine in society, or secure a college education or a +large fortune,--all of which minister to our insistent and rarely +satisfied instinct of self-assertion,--or if he is secretly yearning +for the satisfaction of the marriage relation, or for the sense of +completion in parenthood; then the tension from these unsatisfied +desires shows itself in a hundred little everyday instances of lack of +self-control. These mystify him and his friends, but they are +understandable when the whole truth is known. + +=Anxiety and Fear.= Nowhere is understanding more valuable than when +we approach the subject of anxiety and fear. Whenever a person falls +into a state of abnormal fear, his friends and his physician spend a +good deal of time in attempting to prove to him that there is no cause +for apprehension, and in exhorting him to use his reason and give up +his fear. But how can a person help himself when he is fighting in the +dark? How can he free himself when the thing he thinks he fears is +merely a symbol of what he really fears? The woman who was afraid she +would choke her child had been several months in the hands of +Christian Scientists, and had earnestly tried to replace fear with +courage. But in the circumstances, and without further knowledge, this +was as impossible as it is for a man to lift himself by his own +boot-straps. She had no point of contact with her real fear, as the +man has no leverage contact with the earth from which he wishes to +lift himself. + +To be sure there are many cases in which an assumed cheerfulness and +courage do have a mighty effect on the inner man. The forces of the +personality are not set, but plastic, and are constantly acting and +interacting upon one another. Surface habits do influence the forces +below the surface. William James's advice, "Square your shoulders, +speak in a major key, smile, and turn a compliment," is good for most +occasions, but sometimes even a little understanding of the cause is +far more effective. + +It helps to know that persistent anxiety, lacking obvious cause, is +found to be the anxiety of the thwarted instinct of reproduction. When +the sex-instinct is repeatedly stimulated and then checked it sets in +motion some of the same glands that are activated in fear. What comes +up into consciousness is therefore very naturally a fear or dread of +impending disaster, very like the poignant anxiety that one feels +when stepping up in the dark to a step that is not there. + +Simultaneous with the fear lest these repressed desires should not be +satisfied, there is an intense fear lest they should. The more +insistent the repressed desire, and the more it seems likely to break +through into consciousness, the keener the anguish of the ethical +impulses. Abnormal fear, however it may seem to be externalized, +always implies at the bottom a fear of something within. There is no +truth which is harder to believe on first hearing but which grows more +compelling with further knowledge, than this truth that an exaggerated +fear always implies a desire which somehow offends the total +personality. When we observe the various distressing phobias, such as +the common fear of contamination, a woman's fear to undress at night, +a fear that the gas was not turned off, or that one's clothing is out +of order; fear lest the exact truth has not been told, or that the +uttermost farthing of one's obligations has not been met,--then we may +know that there is something in the fear situation which either +directly or symbolically refers to some hidden desire; a desire which +the individual would not for the world acknowledge to himself, but +which is too keen to be altogether repressed. + +The close connection between fear and desire is often shown in the +unfounded fear of having committed a crime. Both doctors and lawyers +in their professional work occasionally come upon individuals who +believe that they have committed some heinous crime of which they are +really innocent, and who insist upon their guilt despite all evidence +to the contrary. A quiet, gentle youth who at the age of twenty was +under my medical care, is still not sure in his own whether he, at +twelve years of age, was the burglar who broke into the village store +and killed the owner. It is difficult for the normally self-satisfied +individual to understand the appeal of heroics to a person whose +starved instinct of self-assertion makes him choose to be known as a +villain rather than not to be known at all. + +=Breaking the Spell.= When once we bring up into consciousness these +hidden desires that manifest themselves in such troublesome ways, we +find that we have robbed them of much of their power over our lives. +Sometimes, it is true, a detailed and thorough exploration by +psycho-analysis is necessary, but in many cases it is sufficient just +to know that there are underlying causes. To know these things is far +from excusing ourselves because of them. Even though emotions are +determined by forces that are deep in the subconscious, we may still +choose in opposition to those forces, if we but know that we can do +so. The fact that some of the roots of our bad habits reach down into +the subconscious is no excuse for not digging them up. As Dr. Putnam +says, "It is the whole of us that acts, and we are as responsible for +the supervision of the unseen as for the obvious factors that are at +work. The moon may be only half illumined and half visible, but the +invisible half goes on, none the less, exerting its full share of +influence on the motion of the tides and earth."[64] + +[Footnote 64: Putnam: _Freud's Psychoanalytic Method and Its +Evolution_, p. 34.] + + +THE HIGHEST KIND OF CHOICE + +There is no easier way to enliven any conversation than by dropping +the remark that a human being always does what he wants to do. Simple +as the statement seems, it is quite enough to quicken the dullest +table-talk and loosen the most reticent tongue. + +"I don't do what I want to do," says the college student. "I want to +play tennis every afternoon; but what I do is to sit in a stuffy room +and study." + +"I don't do what I want to do," says the mother of a family. "At night +I want to sit down and read the latest magazine, but what I do is to +darn stockings by the hour." + +Nevertheless we shall see that, even in cases like these, each of us +is acting in accordance with his strongest desire. There may be--there +often is--a bitter conflict, but in the end the desire that is really +stronger always conquers and works itself out into action. + +It is possible to imagine a situation in which a man would be +physically unable to do what he wanted to do. Bound by physical cords, +held by prison walls, or weakened by illness, he might be actually +unable to carry out his desires. But apart from physical restraint, it +is hard to imagine a situation in real life in which a person does not +actually do what he wants to do; that is, what _in the circumstances +he wants to do_. This is simply saying in another way that we act in +accordance with the emotion which is at the moment strongest. + +=Will Is Choice.= Just here we can imagine an earnest protest: "But +why do you ignore the human will? Why do you try to make man the +creature of feeling? A high-grade man does--not what he wants to do +but what he thinks he ought to do. In any person worthy of the +adjective 'civilized' it is conscience, not desire, which is the +motive power of his life." + +It is true: in the better kind of man the will is of central +importance; but what is "will"? Let us imagine a raw soldier in the +trenches just before a charge into No-Man's Land. He is afraid, but +the word of command comes, and instantly he is a new creature. His +fear drops away and, energized by the lust of battle, he rushes +forward, obviously driven by the stronger emotion. He goes ahead +because he really wants to, and we say that he does not have to use +his will. + +Imagine another soldier in the same situation; with him fear seems +uppermost. His knees shake and his legs want to carry him in the wrong +direction, but he still goes forward. And he goes forward, not so much +because there is no other possibility as because, in the +circumstances, he really wants to. All his life, and especially during +his military training, he has been filled with ideals of loyalty and +courage. More than he fears the guns of the enemy or of his +firing-squad does he fear the loss of his own self-respect and the +respect of his comrades. Greater than his "will to live" is his desire +to play the man. There is conflict, and the desire which seems at the +moment weaker is given the victory because it is reinforced by that +other permanent desire to be a worthy man, brave, and dependable in a +crisis. He goes forward, because in the circumstances, he really wants +to, but in this case we say that he had to use his will. + +Is it not apparent that will itself is choice,--the selection by the +whole personality of the emotion and the action which best fit into +its ideals? Will is choice by the part of us which has ideals. +McDougall points out that will is the reinforcement of the weaker +desire by the master desire to be a certain kind of a character.[65] + +[Footnote 65: "The essential mark of volition is that the personality +as a whole, or the central feature or nucleus of the personality, the +man himself, is thrown upon the side of the weaker +motive."--McDougall: _Introduction to Social Psychology_, p. 240.] + +Each human being as he goes through life acquires a number of moral +ideals and sentiments which he adopts as his own. They become linked +with the instinct of self-assertion, which henceforth acts as the +motive power behind them, and attempts to drive from the field any +emotion which happens to conflict. + +Men, like the lower animals, are ruled by desire, but, as G.A. Coe +says, "Men mold themselves. They form desires not merely to have this +or that object, but to be this or that kind of a man."[66] + +[Footnote 66: Coe: _Psychology of Religion_.] + +If a man be worthy of the name, he is not swayed by the emotion which +happens for the moment to be strongest. He has the power to reinforce +and make dominant those impulses which fit into the ideal he has built +for himself. In other words, he has the power to choose between his +desires, and this power depends largely upon the ideals which he has +incorporated into his life by the complexes and sentiments which +compose his personality. + +_Ideas and Ideals_. If emotion is the heart of humanity, ideas are its +head. In our emphasis on emotion, we must not forget that as emotion +controls action, so ideas control emotion. But ideas, of themselves, +are not enough. Everybody has seen weaklings who were full of pious +platitudes. Ideas do control life, but only when linked up with some +strong emotion. No moral sentiment is strong enough to withstand an +intense instinctive desire. If ideas are to be dynamic factors in a +life, they must become ideals and be really desired. They must be +backed up by the impulse of self-assertion, incorporated with the +sentiment of self-regard, and so made a permanent part of the central +personality. + +Parents and teachers who try to "break a child's will" and to punish +every evidence of independence and self-assertion little know that +they are undermining the foundations of morality itself, and doing +their utmost to leave the child at the mercy of his chance whims and +emotions. There can be no strength of character without self-regard, +and self-regard is built on the instinctive desire of self-assertion. + +=Education and Religion.= It is easy to see how important education is +in this process of giving the right content to the self-regarding +sentiment. The child trained to regard "temper" as a disgrace, +self-pity as a vice, over-sensitiveness as a sign of selfishness, and +all forms of exaggerated emotionalism as a token of weakness, has +acquired a powerful weapon against temptation in later life. +Indulgence in any of these forms of gratification he will regard as +unworthy and out of keeping with his personality. + +It is easy, too, to see how central a place a vital religious faith +has in enriching and ennobling the ego-ideal, and in giving it +driving-power. A force which makes a high ideal seem both imperative +and possible of achievement could hardly fail to be a deciding factor. +Every student of human nature knows in how many countless lives the +Christian religion has made all the difference between mere good +intentions and the power to realize those intentions; how many times +it has furnished the motive power which nothing else seemed able to +supply. Moral sentiments which have been merely sentiments become, +through the magic of a new faith, incorporated into conscience and +endowed with new power. + +Just here lies the value of any great love, or any intense devotion to +a cause. As Royce says: "To have a conscience, then, is to have a +cause; to unify your life by means of an ideal determined by this +cause, and to compare this ideal and the life."[67] + +[Footnote 67: Royce: _Philosophy of Loyalty_, p. 175.] + +=Avoiding the Strain.= It seems that a human being is to a large +extent controlled by will, and that will is in itself the highest kind +of choice. But too often will is crippled because it does not speak +for the whole personality. Knowledge helps a person to relate +conscience with hitherto hidden parts of himself, to assert his will, +and to choose only those emotions and outlets which the connected-up, +the unified personality wants. Sometimes, indeed, a little knowledge +makes the exercise of the will power unnecessary. Using will power +is, after all, likely to be a strenuous business. It implies the +presence of conflict, and the strain of defeating the desire which has +to be denied.[68] Why struggle to subdue emotional bad habits when a +little insight dispels the desire back of them, and makes them melt +away as if by magic? For example, why use our will to keep down fear +or anger when a little understanding dissipates these emotions without +effort? + +[Footnote 68: Freud: _Introduction to Psychoanalysis_, p. 42.] + +Whatever we do with difficulty we are not doing well. When it requires +effort to do our duty this means that a great part of us does not want +to do it. When we get rid of our hidden resistances we work with ease. +As a strong wind, applied in the right way, drives the ship without +effort, just so the forces in our lives, if they are adjusted to one +another, will without strain or stress easily and naturally work +together to carry us in the direction we have chosen. When we get rid +of blind conflicts, even the business of ruling our spirits becomes +feasible. + + +SUMMARY + +=Various "Sprees."= The human animal has a constitutional dislike for +dullness and will seize upon almost any device which promises to lift +him out of what he considers the monotony of daily grind. An elaborate +essay might be written on the means which human beings have taken to +create the sense of _aliveness_ which they so much crave. Some of +them--we call them savages--have found satisfactory certain wild +orgies in primitive war-dances; others--we shall soon call them "out +of date"--have found simpler a bottle of whisky or a glass of +champagne; still others find a cold shower more invigorating, or a +brisk walk or a good stiff job which sets them aglow with the sense of +accomplishment. But there are always those who, for one reason or +another, find most satisfactory of all a chronic emotional tippling, +or a good old-fashioned emotional spree. Persons who would be shocked +at the idea of whisky or champagne allow themselves this other kind of +indulgence without in the least knowing why. + +Nor is the connection between alcoholism and emotionalism so +far-fetched as it seems. Psycho-analytic investigations have +repeatedly revealed the fact that both are indulged in because they +remove inhibitions, give vent to repressed desires, and bring a sense +of life and power which has somehow been lost in the normal living. +Both kinds of spree are followed by the inevitable "morning after" +with its proverbial headache, remorse, and vows of repentance but +despite all this, both are clung to because the satisfaction they +bring is too deep to be easily relinquished. + +Whenever an emotion quite out of keeping with conscious desire is +allowed to become habitual, we may know that it is being chosen by a +part of the personality which needs to be uncovered and squarely +faced. Nervous symptoms and exaggerated emotionalism are alike +evidence of the fact that the wrong part of us is doing the choosing +and that the will needs to be enlightened on what is taking place in +the outer edge of its domain. In the choice between emotionalism and +equanimity, the selection of the former can only be in response to +unrecognized desire. + +A nervous person is invariably an emotional person, and as a rule lays +the blame for his condition upon past experiences. But experience is +what happens to us _plus_ the way we take it. We cannot always ward +off the blow, but we can decide upon our reaction. "Even if the +conduct of others has been the cause of our emotion, it is really we +ourselves who have created it by the way in which we have +reacted."[69] + +[Footnote 69: DuBois: _Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders_, p. +155.] + + One ship drives east, another drives west, + While the self-same breezes blow; + 'Tis the set of the sail, and not the gale + That bids them where to go. + Like the winds of the sea are the ways of fate, + As we journey along through life; + 'Tis the set of the soul that decides the goal, + And not the calm or the strife. + REBECCA R. WILLIAMS. + + + + +CHAPTER XVI + +_In which we find new use for our steam_ + +FINDING VENT IN SUBLIMATION + +THE RE-DIRECTION OF ENERGY + + +A child pent up on a rainy day is a troublesome child. His energy +keeps piling up, but there is no opportunity for him to expend it. The +nervous person is just such a pent-up child. A portion of his +personality is developing steam which goes astray in its search for +vent; this portion is found to be the psychic side of his sex-life. +Something has blocked the satisfactory achievement of instinctive ends +and turned his interest in on himself. + +Perhaps he does not come into complete psychic satisfaction of his +love-life because his wife is out of sympathy or is held back by her +own childish repressions. Perhaps his love-instinct is baffled by +finding itself thwarted in its purpose of creating children, +restrained by the social ban and the desire for a luxurious standard +of living. Perhaps he is jealous of his chief, or of an older +relative whose business stride he cannot equal. + +Jung has pointed out how frequently introversion or turning in of the +life-force is brought about by the painfulness of present reality and +by the lack of the power of adaptation to things as they are. But this +lack always has its roots in childhood. The woman who is shocked at +the thought of sex is the little girl who reacted too strongly to +early impressions. The man of forty who is disgruntled because he is +not made manager of a business created by others is the little boy who +was jealous of his father and wanted to usurp his place of power. The +man who suffers from a sense of inferiority because his friend has a +handsomer or more intellectual wife is the same little boy who strove +with his father for possession of the mother, the most desired object +in his childish environment. The measure of escape from these childish +attitudes means the measure of success in life. + +Fortunately for society, the average person achieves this success. The +normal person in his childhood learned how to switch the energy of his +primitive desires into channels approved by society. Stored away in +his subconscious, this acquired faculty carries him without conscious +effort through all the necessary adjustments in maturity. The nervous +person, less well equipped in childhood, may fortunately acquire the +faculty in all its completeness, although at the cost of genuine +effort and patient self-study. + +=Sublimation the Key Word.= In the prevention and in the cure of +nervous disorders there is one factor of central importance, and that +factor is sublimation--or the freeing of sex-energy for socially +useful, non-sexual ends. To sublimate is to find vent for oneself and +to serve society as well; for sublimation opens up new channels for +pent-up energy, utilizing all the surplus of the sex-instinct in +substitute activities. When the dynamic of this impulse is turned +outward, not inward, it proves to be one of man's greatest +possessions, a valuable contribution of energy to creative activities +and personal relationships of every kind. + +=The Failure to Sublimate.= A neurosis is nonconstructive use of one's +surplus steam. The trouble with a nervous person is that his +love-force is turned in on himself instead of out into the world of +reality. This is what his friends mean when they say that he is +self-absorbed; and this is what the psychologists mean when they say +that a neurotic is introverted. A person, in so far as he is nervous, +does not see other people at all--that is, he does not see them as +real persons, but only as auditors who may be made to listen to the +tale of his woes. His own problems loom so large that he becomes +especially afflicted with what Cabot calls "the sin of impersonality"; +or to use President King's words, he lacks that "reverence for +personality" which enables one to see people vividly as real persons +and not as street-car conductors or servants or merely as members of +one's family. To be sure, many a so-called normal individual is +afflicted with this same kind of blindness; here as elsewhere the +neurotic simply exaggerates. Engrossed in his own mental conflicts and +physical symptoms, he is likely to find his interest withdrawing more +and more from other people and centering upon himself. + +=Sublimation and Religion.= We do not need psychology to tell us that +engrossment in self is a disastrous condition. When the psycho-analyst +says that the life-force must be turned out, not in, he is approaching +from a new angle the truth as it is found in the gospel,--"Thou shalt +love the Lord thy God with all thy heart," and "thy neighbor as +thyself." Religion provides the love-object in the Creator; altruism +provides it in the "neighbor." Christianity and psychology agree that +as soon as love ceases to be an outgoing force, just so soon does the +individual become an incomplete and disrupted personality.[70] + +[Footnote 70: For emphasis on religion as a means to sublimation, see +Freud, Putnam, Pfister, James, and DuBois.] + +=Carlyle's Doctrine of Work.= "Produce! produce! produce!" Life for a +social being involves not only rich personal relationships, but +absorbing, creative work. No nervous person is cured until he is +willing to take and to keep a "man-size job." A good piece of work is +not only the sign of a cure; it is the final step without which no +cure is complete. + +=Along Nature's Lines.= If the psychologist is asked what kind of task +this is to be, he answers that each person must decide for himself his +own life-work. An individual may not know why, but he does know that +there are certain things which he most likes to do. Sublimation is +more readily accomplished if his energy is directed toward self-chosen +interests. Parents or teachers or physicians who try to force another +person into any definite plan of action are making a grievous blunder. +Help may be given toward self-knowledge and the understanding of +general principles, but advice should never be specific. + +Taken in the large, it is found that men and women choose different +ways of sublimation. Man and woman differ in the psychic components of +the sex-life even as they differ in the physical. Sublimation to be +successful must follow the lines laid down by nature. The urge of the +average man is toward construction, domination, mastery. The urge of +the average woman is toward mothering, protection, nurture. The +masculine characteristics find ready sublimation in a career; the man +builds bridges, digs canals, harnesses mountain streams, conquers +pests, overcomes gravity, brings the ends of the earth together by +"wireless" or by rail; he provides for the weak and the helpless--his +own progeny--or, incarnated in the body of a Hoover, he gives life to +the children of the world. + +In woman, the dominant force is the nurturing instinct. Child and man +of her own come first, but when these are lacking, to paraphrase +Kipling, in default of closer ties, she is wedded to convictions; +Heaven help him who denies! Only as a career opens up full vent for +this nurturing instinct, will it provide satisfactory substitute in +sublimation. Its natural trend can be seen in the recent tidal wave of +social legislation--for prohibition, child-labor laws, sanitation, +recognition and control of venereal disease, acknowledgment of +paternity to the illegitimate child. + +Since the women of the day, in numbers up to the million, have been +compelled to sacrifice both man and unformed babe to the grim +Juggernaut of war, this nurturing urge may press hard against many of +the social and business barriers now impeding its flow. But if society +understands and readjusts these barriers, making it possible for its +citizens--women as well as men--to approximate the natural instinctive +bent, it will not only save itself much unrest but will also go far +toward preventing the spread of nervous invalidism. + + +SUMMARY + +That which a nervous invalid most needs is a redirection of energy. +Since, in spite of appearances, there is never any real lack of +energy, no time is needed for the making of strength, and a cure can +take place just as soon as the inner forces allow the energy to flow +out in the right direction. Sometimes, indeed, an outer change may +start the inner process. Often the "work cure" does cure; occasionally +the sudden necessity to earn one's living or to mother a little child +frees the life-force from its old preoccupation and forces it into +other channels. In most cases, however, the nervous invalid is +suffering not from lack of opportunities for outside interest but from +an inner inability to meet the opportunities which present themselves. +The great change that has to be made is not in external conditions and +habits but in the hidden corners of the mind; a change that can be +accomplished only by self-knowledge and re-education. + +But if self-knowledge is the first step in any cure, so self-giving +must be the final step. Sooner or later in the life of every nervous +invalid there comes a time when nothing will serve to unify his +disorganized forces but steady and unswerving responsibility for a +good stiff piece of work. Happy for him that this is so and that he is +living in a day when science no longer tells him to fold his hands and +wait. + + + + +GLOSSARY + + +_Autonomic nervous system:_ The vegetative nervous system which +controls vital functions,--as digestion, respiration, circulation. + +_Censor:_ A hypothetical faculty of the fore-conscious mind which +resists the emergence into consciousness of questionable desires. + +_Common path:_ In physiology, the final route over which response is +made to physical stimulation; similarly in psychology, the one outlet +for the finally dominant impulse. + +_Compensation:_ Exaggerated manifestation of one character-trend as a +defense against its opposite which is painfully repressed; relief in +substitute symptom formation. + +_Complex:_ A group of ideas held together by emotion (usually +referring to a group which is wholly or in part unconscious). + +_Compulsion:_ A persistent compelling impulse to perform some +seemingly unreasonable (but really substitute or symbolic) act, or to +hold some irrational fear or idea; an emotional force which has been +separated from the original idea. + +_Conflict:_ (Special) Struggle between instincts (unconscious). + +_Conversion:_ (Special) The process by which a repressed mental +complex expresses itself through a physical symptom. + +_Displacement:_ 1. Transposition of an emotion from its original idea +to one more acceptable to the personality. 2. The shifting of +emphasis, in dreams, from essential to less significant elements. + +_Dissociation:_ 1. The state of being shut out from taking active part +(applied to a group of ideas), as in normal forgetfulness. 2. +(Abnormal) An exaggerated degree of separation of groups of ideas, +with loss to the personality of the forces or memories which these +groups contain, as in double personality. + +_Fixation:_ Establishment in childhood of over-strong habit-reactions. + +_Free Association:_ A device for uncovering buried complexes by +letting the mind wander without conscious direction. + +_Homo-sexual:_ The quality of being more attracted by an individual of +the same sex (abnormal) than by one of the opposite sex +(hetero-sexual, normal). + +_Hysteria:_ That form of functional nervous disorder which manifests +itself in physical symptoms; an attempt to dramatize unconscious +repressed desires. + +_Inhibition:_ Restraint (Special) limitation of function, physical or +ideational, due to unconscious emotional attitudes. + +_Libido:_ Life-force, élan vital, or (restricted) the energy of the +sex-instinct. + +_Neurosis:_ Used loosely for psycho-neurosis or nervous disorder. + +_Obsession:_ A compulsive idea inaccessible to reason. + +_Oedipus Complex:_ Over-strong bond between mother and son, or (more +loosely) between father and daughter. + +_Over-determined:_ Used of an impulse made over-strong by lack of +discharge, with accumulation of emotional tension from added factors. + +_Phobia:_ A persistent, unreasoning fear of some object or situation. + +_Psycho-neurosis:_ "A perversion of normal (psychic) reactions," +(Prince); a general term for functional dissociation of the +personality, resulting in: psychasthenia--disturbed ideation; +neurasthenia--disturbed emotions; hysteria--disturbed motor or sensory +activity. + +_Psychotherapy:_ Treatment by psychic or mental measures. + +_Rationalization:_ The process of substituting a plausible, false +explanation for a repressed, unconscious desire. + +_Repression:_ Expulsion from consciousness of a pain-provoking mental +process. + +_Resistance:_ The force which impedes the return of a repressed +complex to consciousness. + +_Subconscious:_ That part of the mind of which one is unaware; the +storehouse of memories ancestral and personal. + +_Sublimation:_ The act of freeing sex-energy from definitely sexual +aims; utilization of sex-energy for nonsexual ends. + +_Suggestion:_ The process by which any idea, true or false, takes hold +of one; the idea may enter the mind consciously or unconsciously, +through reason or through impulse. + +_Symbol:_ An object or an attitude which stands for an ides or a +quality; (Special) that which stands for or represents some +unconscious mental process. + +_Threshold_ (door-sill): A figure which represents the level of the +barrier erected by the mind against the perception of an idea or +sensation. + +_Transference:_ Unconscious identification of a present personal +relationship with an earlier one, with conveyance of the earlier +emotional attitudes (hostile or affectionate) to the present +relationship. + + + + +BIBLIOGRAPHY + + +BOOKS ON THE GENERAL LAWS OF BODY AND MIND + +Cannon, Walter B: Bodily Changes in Pain, Hunger, +Fear and Rage. + +Crile, George W.: The Origin and Nature of the Emotions. + +Coe, George Albert: The Psychology of Religion. + +Hudson, Thomas Jay: The Law of Psychic Phenomena. + +Janet, Pierre: The Major Symptoms of Hysteria; The +Mental State of Hystericals. + +James, William: Psychology; Talks to Teachers on Psychology; +Varieties of Religious Experience. + +Jastrow, Joseph: The Subconscious. + +Kempf, Edward J.: The Tonus of Autonomic Segments +in Psychopathology. + +Long, Constance: Psychology of Fantasy. + +McDougall, William: Social Psychology. + +Mosher, Clelia Duel: Health and the Woman Movement. + +Phillips, D. E.: Elementary Psychology. + +Prince, Morton: The Unconscious; The Dissociation of +a Personality; My Life as a Dissociated Personality. + +Sherrington, Charles L.: The Integrative Action of the +Nervous System. + +Sidis, Boris: The Foundations of Normal and Abnormal +Psychology; Psychopathological Researches. + +Tansley, A. G.: The New Psychology. + +Thomson, William Hanna: Brain and Personality. + +White, William A.: Principles of Mental Hygiene; + The Mental Hygiene of Childhood. + +Proceedings of the International Conference of Women Physicians. +(National Board, Y.W.C.A., 600 Lexington Avenue, New York City.) + + +BOOKS ON MENTAL HYGIENE + +Brown, Charles R.: Faith and Health. + +Bruce, H. Addington: Scientific Mental Healing. + +Cabot, Richard: What Men Live By; + Social Service and the Art of Healing. + +DuBois, Paul: The Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders. + +Huckel, Oliver: Mental Medicine. + +James, William: Vital Reserves. + +Prince, Morton, and others: Psychotherapeutics. + +Sadler, William S.: The Physiology of Faith and Fear. + +Worcester, Elwood } +McComb, Samuel } Religion and Medicine. +Coriat, Isador H. } + + +BOOKS ON PSYCHO-ANALYSIS + +Brill, A. A.: Fundamentals of Psychoanalysis. + +Emerson, L. E.: Nervousness. + +Freud, Sigmund: The Interpretation of Dreams; + The Psychopathology of Everyday Life; + Wit and the Unconscious; + Selected Papers and Sexual Theory; + A General Introduction to Psychoanalysis. + +Frink, H. W.: Morbid Fears and Compulsions. + +Hitschmann, E.: Freud's Theories of the Neuroses. + +Holt, E. B.: The Freudian Wish. + +Jung, Carl G.: The Psychology of the Unconscious; Analytical +Psychology. + +Jones, Ernest: Psycho-analysis; Treatment of the Neuroses, Including +Psychoneuroses--in Modern Treatment of Nervous and Mental +Diseases--White and Jelliffe. + +Pfister, Oskar: The Psychoanalytic Method. + +Putnam, James Jackson: Addresses on Psychoanalysis--Human +Motives. + +Tridon, André: Psychoanalysis. + +White, William A.: The Mechanisms of Character +Formation. + + +JOURNALS DEVOTED TO THE SUBJECT OF NERVOUS DISORDERS + +Journal of Abnormal Psychology, published in Boston. + +Psychoanalytic Review, published in Washington, D.C. + +International Journal of Psychoanalysis, published in +London. + + + + +INDEX + + +A + +Acid and Milk, 21, 257 + +Acidosis, 285 + +Adjustment + a neurosis an effort at, 169 + to new conditions causes consciousness, 82 + of the race, in subconscious, 78 + to the social whole, 164, 216, 380 + +Adolescence, 59 + +Adrenal Secretion, 42, 48, 133, 229, 270 + +Alcoholism, relation to unconscious desires, 377 + +Alvarez, W.D., 284 + +Ames, Thaddeus Hoyt, 170 + +Amnesia, 113 + +Anaemia, buttermilk in, 282 + +Anger, 47 ff. + +Anxiety and Fear, 366, 367, 368 + +Anxiety Neurosis, 7, 109 + +Anxious thought in conversion hysteria, 277 + +Appetite, symbolic loss of, 276 + +Association + accidental, 341 + a chain of, 191 + free, 101, 191 + making new, 329, 330 + of ideas, 106 + subconscious, 346 + word test, 197, 198 + +Audience, secured in a neurosis, 169 + +Auto-eroticism, 57 + +Auto-intoxication, 279, 282 + +Automatic writing, 96, 97 + +Autonomic nervous system, 86, 126, 319 + +Auto-suggestion, 129, 210 + + +B + +Bacteria, in anaemia, sciatica, rheumatism, 281 + +Bashfulness, 46 + +Bergson, 90 + +Biliousness, 268 + +Birth-Theories, 158, 160, 161 + +Blocking, in word association, 198 + +Bodily Response to Emotional States, 134 + +Brain, + diseased in insanity, sound in neurosis, 13 + fag, 125, 241 + records, 89 + +Bran fad, 291 + +Breuer, Joseph, 142 + +Brill, A.A., 58, 69, 201, 202 + +Bruce, H. Addington, 200, 201 + +Burrow, Trigant, 173, 203 + +Buttermilk in anaemia, 282 + + +C + +Cabot, Richard, 27, 381 + +Canfield, Dorothy, 231 + +Cannon, Walter B., 49, 134 + +Capitalizing an Illness, 170 + +Catechism, 247 + +Cathartics, 283 + and acidosis, 286 + and bacterial infection, 282 + and child birth, 285, 286 + and operations, 284 + +Causes of Nerves, 146, 164 + +Censor, psychic, 104, 195 + +Change of life, 314 + +Character and health, 24, 25, 362 + +Chemistry, 61, 190, 224, 225, 230, 247, 306, 315, 317, 324 + +Child, + birth-theories of, 158 + father to the man, 90 + habit-fixation of, 150 + love-life, four periods 54, 55 + questions, 158 + too much bossing of, 154 + too much petting of, 57 + training, 160 + +Childhood, + bonds too strong, 72 + determines future character, 91, 148 + experiences, 149 + reactions, 148 + +Choosing our Emotions, 360 + a neurosis, 122, 169, 216 + our Sensations, 339 + +Christian religion, 74, 374 + +Coe, George A., 71, 373 + +Colon, function of, 279, 280 + +Common Path, 52 + +Compensation, 168, 340 + +Complex, + against marriage, 204 + and conditioned reflex, 108 + and personality, 105 + breaking up of, 109, 186 + buried, 187, 192, 197, 201, 202, 215 + chance signs of, 198 + definition, 107 + dissociated, 111 + emotional, 198, 345 + father-mother, 152 + feeling-tone of, 130 + formation of, 129 + forming a resistance, 159 + making over, 187, 190 + mother-son, 185 + physiological, 108 + repressed, 112, 157, 190 + unconscious, 108 + +Compromise, 163, 164, 165 + +Compulsion neuroses, 7, 109, 156 + +Conditioned reflex, 108 + +Conduct, kind of, 168, 191, 360 + +Conflict, 59, 64, 112, 145, 154, 164, 178, 200, 218, 313, 372, 376 + +Conscience, 164, 173, 177, 196, 376 + +Consciousness, + displaced threshold of, 91 +relation to the subconscious, 82 + rise of, 82 + +Constipation, 277 ff. + and food, 289, 290 + cure of, 294 + due to suggestion, 294 + purpose of, 288 + +Conversion-hysteria, 174, 236, 237, 238, 245, 277, 302 + +Crile, George W., 41, 44 + +Curiosity, + child's concerning sex, 58 + displacement over to scientific investigation, 45 + + +D + +Day-dreaming, 162, 325, 326 + +Defence-reaction, 365 + +Desire + energy of, 78 + in dreams, 194 + in emotional habits, 364 + in nervous disorders, 167 + instinctive, 38 + instinctive and ideals, 363 + tensions of, 196 + +Diarrhoea, bacterial, 281 + +Dietetics, essence of, 254 + +Digestion, 86, 133, 250, 251 + +Disease, + of the ego, 15 + physical, 12, 13, 28 + psychic, 12, 13, 14, 28 + +Disorders, functional and organic, 13 + +Displacement, 109, 110, 165, 174 + +Dissociation, 111 + abnormal, 189 + an example of, 92, 347 + in hypnosis, 123 + in hysteria, 111, 123 + in neurasthenia, 111 + increases suggestibility, 122 + normal, 111 + of a "Personality," 113 + of memory picture of walking, 125 + of power of sight, 170 + +Dreams, 193 ff. + Freud's dictum, 193 + latent content, 195 + manifest content, 195 + purpose of, 195 + work of, 196 + +DuBois, Paul, 4, 127, 246, 327, 382 + + +E + +Education, 202, 218 + in Emotional Control, 374 + +Emotion, 35, 360 ff. + and complexes, 108 + and fatigue, 229, 247 + and instincts, 40 ff. + and muscle tone, 137 + blood-pressure in, 136 + bodily response to, 133 + feeling tones in, 130 + precocious, 150 + repressed (see repression) + secretions in, 132 + the strongest cement, 107 + tonic and poisonous, 131 + unrecognized desire in, 364 + +Energy, + adaptable, 67 + creative, 34, 69, 71 + inhibited, 235 + libido, 36, 252 + misdirected, 28, 379 + new level of, 221 + physiological reserve, 117 + redirection of, 385 + releasers of, 245 + three uses of, 23 + utilization of, 68, 165 + +"Energies of Men", 221 + +Environment, 33, 96, 149, 334 + +Evolution, 73 + +Exhaustion, nervous, 216, 224, 243, 246 + +Explanation vs Suggestion, 206 ff. + + +F + +Fads-dynamogenic, 252 + +Faith, 118 + +Family complex, 153 + +Fatigue, 219 ff. + a Matter of Chemistry, 225 + and insomnia, 326, 327 + and moral tension, 166 + and sex-repression, 235, 244 + true and false, 223 + +Fear, 40 ff. + exaggerated, 368 + externalized, 368 + of cold, 348 + of fatigue, 219, 354 + of food, 133, 251 + of heat, 237 + of noise, 355 + physical effects of, 41 + purpose of, 41 + symbolic of desire, 368 + +Feeling our Feelings, 333 ff. + +Feeling-tones, 130, 206, 213, 229 + +Fermentation, 264 + +Finding New Vents, 379 + +Fixation of Habits, 150, 151, 162 + +Flat-foot, 138 + +Food, 254 ff. + and constipation, 289, 290 + for the children, 256 + idiosyncrasies, 258 + mixtures, 255 + variety essential, 255 + +Foreconscious, 79 + +Free Association, 101, 191, 195 + +Freud, Sigmund, 69, 74, 83, 84, 104, 142, 149, 153, 163, 185, 188, 193, + 210, 342, 376, 382 + +Freudian principles, 143, 144, 147 + misconceptions concerning, 184, 185 + +Frink, H.W., 89, 107, 158, 162, 171, 195, 218 + + +G + +Gall-stones, 269 + +Gas on the stomach, 264 + +Gastric juice, 86, 134 + +Gastritis, 266 + +Genius, 116 + +Girard-Mangin, Dr., 231 + +Goitre, 239 + + +H + +Habit, + defined, 150 + dissociation, 189 + dreaming, 162 + fixation of, 150, 152 + of insomnia, 322 + of loving, 150, 164 + of rebelling, 150, 164 + of repressing normal instincts, 151 + reactions, 364 + +Heredity, 148 + +Hidden desires, 363, 368 + +Hinkle, Bertha M., 154 + +Holt, E.B., 213 + +Homosexuality, 184 + +Hoover, Herbert A., 384 + +Hormone, 305, 319 + +Hudson, J.W., 91, 95 + +Hydrochloric Acid, 267 + +Hygiene, + laws of, 127 + moral, 206 + +Hygienic conditions, 222, 230 + +Hypersensitiveness, 342 + +Hypnosis, 84 ff. + aid to diagnosis, 187 + its drawbacks, 188 + suggestibility in, 189 + +Hysteria, 7, 111 + +Hysterical pains, 353 + +Hysterical pregnancy, (case), 127 + + +I + +Ideas, + and emotions, 23 + ascetic, 253 + contagion of, 120 + dynamogenic, 253 + not surgical, 262 + +Idiosyncrasies, physical, 258 + +Identification, 110 + +Imagination, 162 + +Incantation, 211 + +Indigestion; 211, 250 + +Inferiority complex, 340, 380 + +Inhibition, 188, 245, 293, 306, 330, 377 + +Insomnia, 322 ff. + +Instincts and their Emotions, 33 ff., 51 ff. + +Instincts, + beneficent, 85 + energy releasers, 233 + race-inheritance, 85 + repressed, 28, 103, 147, 169, 172 + sex (see under sex) + thwarted, 235, 244, 340, 356, 367, 379 + +Internal Secretion, + of ovary, 316, 317 + (see Adrenal) + (see Thyroid) + +Introspection, 26 + +Introversion, 380, 381 + + +J + +James, William, 49, 221, 227, 243, 253, 347, 382 + +Janet, Pierre, 188 + +Jealousy, 154, 380 + +Jelliffe, Smith Ely, 98, 114, 153, 163 + +Jones, Ernest, 69 + +Judicious neglect, 127 + +Jung, C.G., 8, 64, 69, 163, 197, 380 + + +K + +Kempf, Edward J., 86 + +Kinaesthetic sensations, 336 + + +L + +Latency period, 60 + +Libido, 36, 147, 252 + +Liver trouble, 268 + + +M + +Masturbation, 184 + +McDougall, Wm., 49, 122, 372 + +Memories, 84 ff. + +Menopause, 314 + +Menstruation, 306 + +Mind (see Consciousness and Subconscious) + +Misconceptions, + about the body, 21, 22 + about theory of sex, 184 + +Mixtures, fear of, 257 + +Monogamy, 63 + +Moral hygiene, 206 + +Mosher, Clelia Duel, 308 + +Muscle-tone, 137, 244 + +Myth, 146 + + +N + +Narcissus, 55, 152, 340 + +Nausea, 101, 177, 275 + of pregnancy, 319 + +Nerves, + attitude toward, 3 + causes of, 28, 148 + drama of, 10, 29 + medical schools and, 16 + not physical, 14 + prevention of, 385 + +Neurasthenia, 111, 246 + +Neuritis, 14, 244 + +Neurosis, + a compromise, 167 + a confidence game, 179 + a failure of sublimation, 381 + a flight from reality, 170 + an ethical struggle, 177 + an introversion, 381 + and shell-shock, 147 + and suggestion, 129 + anxiety, 7, 109 + awkwardness of, 213 + compulsion, 109 + caused by buried complexes, 108, 190 + definition 112 + origin in childhood, 149, 157, 217 + purpose of, 167 + root-complex of, 153 + + +O + +Obsession, 7, 204 + +Oedipus Complex, 154 + +Organic trouble, 11, 12, 251 + +Ouija Board, 97 + +Over-awareness, 352 + +Over-compensation, 67 + +Over-determined, 148 + + +P + +Pain, + at base of the brain, 351 + chronic hysterical, 341 + menstrual, 306 + +Personality, + alterations of, 7, 15, 20 + and emotions, 362, 369 + and will, 372 + choice by, 216 + complexes and, 107 + disrupted, 382 + multiple, 111, 131 + nervousness a disorder of, 15 + reverence for, 383 + unified, 375 + +Persuasion, 206 + +Pfister, Oskar, 153, 166, 382 + +Phantasy, 153, 163 + +Phobia, 7, 368 + +Plagiarism, 98 + +Popular Misconceptions, 21 + +Prince, Morton, 79, 84, 89, 95, 97, 112, 132, 188, 347 + +Psycho-analysis, 189 ff. + +Psychological explanation, 208 + +Psychology, 25, 27, 94 + +Psycho-neurosis, 144, 147, 163, 169 (see also neurosis) + +Psycho-therapy, 74, 187, 216 + +Ptosis, 139, 251 + +Putnam, James J., 3, 34, 69, 215, 366, 370, 382 + + +R + +Race-memories, 84 + +Rationalization, 90, 155, 168, 317 + +Reaction and over-reaction, 149, 198, 202, 238, 335 + +Reality, flight from, 164, 379 + +Re-education, 183 ff. + +Reflex, + conditioned, 108 + physiological, 349 + +Regression to infantile state, 163, 164 + case of, 92 + +Religion, 74, 89, 374, 382 + +Reminiscences, hysteric suffers from, 7 + +Repression, 104, 156, 160, 162, 235, 245, 304 + +Resistance, 160, 188, 192, 202, 211 + +Rest-cure, 246 + +Rheumatism, buttermilk treatment of, 282 + +Rixford, Emmet L., 283 + +Royce, Josiah, 375 + + +S + +Sadler, Wm., 126, 136 + +School, four grade, 54 + +Second wind, 221 + +Self-abuse, 184, 238 + +Self-pity, 365 + +Self-regard, 45, 103, 157, 374 + +Sensations, lowered threshold to, 333 ff. + +Sensitiveness, 333, 340 + +Sex, + and artistic creation, 379 + and "Nerves," 141 ff. + glands, secretion of, 305, 314, 316 +instinct organically aroused, 65 + instinct thwarted, 161, 367, 379 + instruction, 160 + license, 184 + life, 143, 146, 157 + perversion, 152 + phantasy, 163 + psychic component of, 185, 356, 379, 383 + repressed, 104 + sublimation of, 233, 379 + +Shell-shock, (see foreword) + also 145, 147 + +Sherrington, Chas., 39 + +Sick-headache, 270 + +Sidis, Boris, 24, 84, 188, 222, 337, 341 + +Slips of tongue, etc., 199 + +Slogan, + of psychoanalytic school, 215 + woman's, 314 + +Social code, 184 + +Soda, misuse of, 266 + +"Sour-stomach," 260, 266 + +Sprees, 376 + +Stammering, 200 + +Standard, + double, 66 + single, 62 + +Stomach, 133 + and conversion hysteria, 250 ff. + fads, 252 + gas on, 252 + +Subconscious mind, 77 ff. + amenable to control by suggestion, emotion, 119 + functions of, 85, 335, 337 + habits of, 105, 259 + physical expression of, 245 + playing confidence game, 311 + store-house of memories, 84, 89 + tireless, 325 + +Sublimation, 379 ff. + a synthesis, 164 + and religion, 74, 382 + definition (Freud), 69, 70 + failure of, 71, 147, 381 + in a career, 385 + in artistic creation, 68 + natural trends of, 383 + of energy, 178, 238, 309 + +Success, measure of, 380 + +Sugar in urine, 133 + +Suggestion, + a method of psychotherapy, 208 + constipation the result of, 289, 298 + definition, 121 + false, 302 + in child training, 121 + in hypnosis, 99, 188 + in sleep, 99 + inconvenient forms of, 296 + power of, 45 + unhealthy, 310 + +Suggestibility, 122, 189, 206 + +Superman, 339 + +Symbolism, 171, 176, 275, 342 + +Symptoms, purpose of, 168 + + +T + +Taboos, + dietary, 250 ff. + interest in, 289 + +Tensions, psychic, 69, 85, 353, 366 + +Thresholds, psychic, 337 ff. + +Thyroid secretion, 42, 133, 185, 270 + +Transference, 109, 193, 264 + +Trotter, W., 46 + + +U + +Unconscious, (see subconscious) + + +V + +Venereal disease, 304, 317 + +Vitamins, 255 + + +W + +White, Wm. A., 69, 82, 83, 98 + +Will, 371 + +Williams, Tom A., 21, 213 + +Wish fulfilment, 171, 194, 200, 214 + +Word-association test, 197 + +Work-cure, 385 + + + + +ILLUSTRATIONS FROM CASES + + +A + +Adolescence and depression, 312, 313 + +Anger and circulation, 136 + +Angina pectoris, false, 129 + +Anxiety-neurosis, 175 + + +B + +Bearing children, 318 + +Brain fag, 241 + +Bran crackers and prunes, 258 + + +C + +Cathartics, abuse of, 284 + +Childhood sex-reactions, 203 + +Constipation and lacerations in labor, 296 + +Constipation and Mineral Oil, 295 + +Constipation, recovery from, (some cases), 294 + +Contamination, fear of, 159 + +Conversion of moral distress to physical, 348 + + +D + +Danger-signals and the railroad man, 344 + +Dissociated state, memories in, 92 + + +E + +Emotion and sick-headache, 273 + +"Enjoying" poor health, 213, 345 + +"Exhaustion," 243 + +Eye-strain, twenty-five years, 274 + + +F + +Fatigue, 228, 234, (two cases), 239 + +Fatigue and emotion, (three cases), 354 + +Fear, 237, + of heat, 237 + +Fear of air, 348, 349 + +Fear of cold, (three cases), 348, 349 + +Fear of light, (two cases), 350 + +Fear complicating labor, 320 + +"Flat-foot," 137 + +Forgetting and repressed wish, 200 + +Free-love, chemical cause of, 317 + + +G + +Gall-stones, 269 + + +I + +Idiosyncrasy for eggs, 212 + +Insomnia and attention, 329 + +Insomnia and point of view, 328 + +Insomnia and wrong associations, 330 + +Insomnia, chronic, 328 + + +L + +Library, child fear of, 100 + +Locomotor Ataxia, exaggeration of symptoms, 128 + + +M + +Menstrual pain, unnecessary, 220 + +Muscle-tumors, phantom, 127, 128 + + +N + +Nausea, in sex-repression, 101, 177 + +Nervous indigestion, 211 + +"Neuritis," 174, + false, 244 + +Noise, fear of, 355 + + +O + +Obsession against marriage, 204 + + +P + +Paralysis, fear of, 345, 346 + +Physical illness mistaken for functional, 252 + +Plagiarism, 98 + + +R + +Recovering lost word, 80 + +Repression and disgust, 199 + + +S + +Sick-headache, 271, 274 + +Skim-milk diet, 262 + +"Sour stomach" and two Tyrolese, 260 + +T + +Temper, an indulgence, 359 + +The "Repeater" gains in weight, 263 + +Thyroid disturbance, fatigue in, 239, 240 + + +U + +Unconscious Association and symptoms, 346 + + +W + +Walking, lost power of, 124 + +Word Association test, 198 + + +Transcriber's Notes + +The following typographical errors were noted and corrected: + +On page 146 of the book: Heading changed from "A Searching Queston" + to "A Searching Question". +On page 152, "Narcisstic" changed to "Narcissistic". +On page 276, "..the nausea disappearaed." changed to "disappeared". +On page 294, "...Nature's functions re reëstablished" changed to "be". +On page 302, "...nor even of man's infringment..." changed to + "infringement". +On page 330, "I put my mouth up close to to her ear...", removed the + duplicate "to". +On page 346, for the paragraph starting "But these symptoms...", + "disappeaared" changed to "disappeared". +In the Index, page 401, "Thesholds" changed to "Thresholds". + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Outwitting Our Nerves +by Josephine A. Jackson and Helen M. Salisbury + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK OUTWITTING OUR NERVES *** + +***** This file should be named 14980-8.txt or 14980-8.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + https://www.gutenberg.org/1/4/9/8/14980/ + +Produced by Rick Niles, Ronald Holder and the PG Online Distributed +Proofreading Team. + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +https://gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS' WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, is critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at https://www.pglaf.org. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Its 501(c)(3) letter is posted at +https://pglaf.org/fundraising. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at https://pglaf.org + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit https://pglaf.org + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including including checks, online payments and credit card +donations. To donate, please visit: https://pglaf.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + https://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. diff --git a/14980-8.zip b/14980-8.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..70c3d81 --- /dev/null +++ b/14980-8.zip diff --git a/14980-h.zip b/14980-h.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..d5a8d32 --- /dev/null +++ b/14980-h.zip diff --git a/14980-h/14980-h.htm b/14980-h/14980-h.htm new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7b37e48 --- /dev/null +++ b/14980-h/14980-h.htm @@ -0,0 +1,11956 @@ +<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1"?> +<!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Strict//EN" + "http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/DTD/xhtml1-strict.dtd"> + +<html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"> + <head> + <title> + The Project Gutenberg eBook of Outwitting Our Nerves, by Josephine A. Jackson, M.D.. + </title> + <style type="text/css"> +/*<![CDATA[ XML blockout */ +<!-- + p { margin-top: .75em; + text-align: justify; + text-indent: 1em; + margin-bottom: .75em; + } + h1,h2,h3,h4,h5,h6 { + text-align: center; /* all headings centered */ + clear: both; + } + hr { width: 50%; + margin-top: 2em; + margin-bottom: 2em; + margin-left: auto; + margin-right: auto; + clear: both; + } + + table {margin-left: 10%;} + table.la{margin-left: 0em;} + body{margin-left: 10%; + margin-right: 10%; + } + + .linenum {position: absolute; top: auto; left: 4%;} /* poetry number */ + .blockquot{margin-left: 5%; margin-right: 10%;} + .pagenum {position: absolute; left: 92%; font-size: smaller; text-align: right;} /* page numbers */ + .sidenote {width: 20%; padding-bottom: .5em; padding-top: .5em; + padding-left: .5em; padding-right: .5em; margin-left: 1em; + float: right; clear: right; margin-top: 1em; + font-size: smaller; background: #eeeeee; border: dashed 1px;} + + .bb {border-bottom: solid 2px;} + .bl {border-left: solid 2px;} + .bt {border-top: solid 2px;} + .br {border-right: solid 2px;} + .bbox {border: solid 2px;} + .hov { border-bottom: dotted 1px black } + + .center {text-align: center;} + .smcap {font-variant: small-caps;} + + .figcenter {margin: auto; text-align: center;} + + .figleft {float: left; clear: left; margin-left: 0; margin-bottom: 1em; margin-top: + 1em; margin-right: 1em; padding: 0; text-align: center;} + + .figright {float: right; clear: right; margin-left: 1em; margin-bottom: 1em; + margin-top: 1em; margin-right: 0; padding: 0; text-align: center;} + + .textrite {margin-right: 4%; text-align: right;} + + .heading {margin-top: 1em; margin-bottom: 1em; + text-align: center; font-size: 120%;} + .scheading {margin-top: 1em; margin-bottom: 1em; + text-align: center; font-size: 120%; font-variant: small-caps;} + .hangind {margin-left: 1.25em; + text-indent: -1.25em;} + .noind {text-indent: 0em;} + .ind1{margin-left: 1em;} + .ind2{margin-left: 2em;} + .footnotes {border: dashed 1px;} + .footnote {margin-left: 10%; margin-right: 10%; font-size: 0.9em;} + .footnote .label {position: absolute; right: 84%; text-align: right;} + .fnanchor {vertical-align: super; font-size: .8em; text-decoration: none;} + + .poem {margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align: left;} + .poem br {display: none;} + .poem .stanza {margin: 1em 0em 1em 0em;} + .poem span {display: block; margin: 0; padding-left: 3em; text-indent: -3em;} + .poem span.i2 {display: block; margin-left: 2em;} + .poem span.i4 {display: block; margin-left: 4em;} + // --> + /* XML end ]]>*/ + </style> + </head> +<body> + + +<pre> + +The Project Gutenberg EBook of Outwitting Our Nerves +by Josephine A. Jackson and Helen M. Salisbury + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: Outwitting Our Nerves + A Primer of Psychotherapy + +Author: Josephine A. Jackson and Helen M. Salisbury + +Release Date: February 8, 2005 [EBook #14980] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK OUTWITTING OUR NERVES *** + + + + +Produced by Rick Niles, Ronald Holder and the PG Online Distributed +Proofreading Team. + + + + + + +</pre> + + + + +<h1>OUTWITTING OUR</h1> +<h1>NERVES</h1> + +<h3>A PRIMER OF PSYCHOTHERAPY</h3> + +<h3>BY</h3> + +<h2>JOSEPHINE A. JACKSON, M.D.</h2> +<h2>HELEN M. SALISBURY</h2> + +<p> </p> + +<h3>NEW YORK</h3> +<h3>THE CENTURY CO.</h3> +<h3>1922</h3> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + + +<h6>1921, by</h6> +<h6>THE CENTURY CO.</h6> +<h6>PRINTED IN U.S.A.</h6> + +<p> </p> + +<hr /> + +<p> </p> + +<h3>TO</h3> + +<h3>MARY PATTERSON MANLY</h3> + +<h3>A LOVER OF TRUTH</h3> + +<p> </p> + +<hr /> + +<p> </p> + +<h2>FOREWORD</h2> + + +<p>"Your trouble is nervous. There is nothing we can cut out and there is +nothing we can give medicine for." With these words a young college +student was dismissed from one of our great diagnostic clinics.</p> + +<p>The physician was right. In a nervous disorder there is nothing to cut +out and there is nothing to give medicine for. Nevertheless there is +something to be done,—something which is as definite and scientific +as a prescription or a surgical operation.</p> + +<p>Psychotherapy, which is treatment by the mental measures of +psycho-analysis and re-education, is an established procedure in the +scientific world to-day. Nervous disorders are now curable, as has +been proved by the clinical results in scores of cases from civil +life, under treatment by Freud, Janet, Prince, Sidis, DuBois, and +others; and in thousands of cases of war neuroses as reported by Smith +and Pear, Eder, MacCurdy, and other military observers. These army +experts have shown that shell-shock in war is the same as nervousness +in civil life and that both may be cured by psycho-analysis and +re-education.</p> + +<p>For more than a decade, in handling nervous cases, I have made use of +the findings of recognized authorities on psychopathology. Truths have +been applied in a special way, with the features of re-education so +emphasized that my home has been called a psychological +boarding-school. As the alumni have gone back to the game of life +with no haunting memories of usual sanatorium methods, but with the +equipment of a fuller self-knowledge and sense of power, they have +sent back a call for some word that shall extend this helpful message +to a larger circle.</p> + +<p>There has come, too, a demand for a book which shall give accurate and +up-to-date information to those physicians who are eager for light on +the subject of nervous disorders, and especially for knowledge of the +significant contributions of Sigmund Freud, but who are too busy to +devote time to highly technical volumes outside their own specialties.</p> + +<p>This need for a simple, comprehensive presentation of the Freudian +principles I have attempted to meet in this primer of psychotherapy, +providing enough of biological and psychological background to make +them intelligible, and enough application and illustration to make +them useful to the general practitioner or the average layman.</p> + +<p class="textrite">JOSEPHINE A. JACKSON.</p> + +<p>Pasadena, California, 1921.</p> + +<p> </p> + +<hr /> + +<p> </p> + +<h2>CONTENTS</h2> + + +<table cellspacing="0" cellpadding="7" border="0" summary="Table of Contents"> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">PART I: THE STRANGE WAYS OF NERVES</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>CHAPTER I</td> + <td align="right">PAGE</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which most of us plead guilty to the charge of "nerves."</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_I">Nervous Folk</a></span></td> + <td align="right">3</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER II</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we learn what "nerves" are not and get a hint of +what they are.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_II">The Drama of Nerves</a></span></td> + <td align="right">10</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center"> <br />PART II: "HOW THE WHEELS GO ROUND"</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>CHAPTER III</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we find a goodly inheritance.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_III">The Story of the Instincts</a></span></td> + <td align="right">33</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER IV</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we learn more about ourselves.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_IV">The Story of the Instincts</a></span> (Continued)</td> + <td align="right">51</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER V</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we look below the surface and discover a veritable wonderland.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_V">The Subconscious Mind</a></span></td> + <td align="right">77</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER VI</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we learn why it pays to be cheerful.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_VI">Body and Mind</a></span></td> + <td align="right">118</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER VII</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we go to the root of the matter.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_VII">The Real Trouble</a></span></td> + <td align="right">141</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center"> <br />PART III: THE MASTERY OF "NERVES"</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>CHAPTER VIII</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we pick up the clue.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_VIII">The Way Out</a></span></td> + <td align="right">183</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER IX</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we discover new stores of energy and relearn the +truth about fatigue.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_IX">That Tired Feeling</a></span></td> + <td align="right">219</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER X</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which the ban is lifted.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_X">Dietary Taboos</a></span></td> + <td align="right">250</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER XI</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we learn an old trick.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_XI">The Bugaboo of Constipation</a></span></td> + <td align="right">278</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER XII</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which handicaps are dropped.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_XII">A Woman's Ills</a></span></td> + <td align="right">300</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER XIII</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we lose our dread of night.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_XIII">That Interesting Insomnia</a></span></td> + <td align="right">322</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER XIV</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we raise our thresholds.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_XIV">Feeling Our Feelings</a></span></td> + <td align="right">333</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER XV</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we learn discrimination.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_XV">Choosing Our Emotions</a></span></td> + <td align="right">359</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br />CHAPTER XVI</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td colspan="2" align="center">In which we find new use for our steam.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td><span class="smcap"><a href="#CHAPTER_XVI">Finding Vent in Sublimation</a></span></td> + <td align="right">379</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br /><span class="smcap"><a href="#GLOSSARY">Glossary</a></span></td> + <td align="right">386</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br /><span class="smcap"><a href="#BIBLIOGRAPHY">Bibliography</a></span></td> + <td align="right">390</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td> <br /><span class="smcap"><a href="#INDEX">Index</a></span></td> + <td align="right">393</td> +</tr> +</table> + + +<p> +<br /><!-- Page 1 --><a name="Page_1" id="Page_1" /> +<br /><!-- Page 2 --><a name="Page_2" id="Page_2" /> +</p> + + +<p> </p> + +<hr /> + +<p> </p> + +<h2><!-- Page 3 --><a name="Page_3" id="Page_3" />OUTWITTING OUR NERVES</h2> + +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_I" id="CHAPTER_I">CHAPTER I</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In Which Most of Us Plead Guilty to the Charge of "Nerves."</i></p> + +<p class="heading">NERVOUS FOLK</p> + +<p class="scheading">Who's Who</p> + + +<p>Whenever the subject of "nerves" is mentioned most people begin trying +to prove an alibi. The man who is nervous and knows that he is +nervous, realizes that he needs help, but the man who has as yet felt +no lack of stability in himself is quite likely to be impatient with +that whole class of people who are liable to nervous breakdown. It is +therefore well to remind ourselves at once that the line between the +so-called "normal" and the nervous is an exceedingly fine one. +"Nervous invalids and well people are indistinguishable both in theory +and in practice,"<a name="FNanchor_1" id="FNanchor_1"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_1" class="fnanchor">[1]</a> and "after all +we are most of us more or less <!-- Page 4 --><a name="Page_4" id="Page_4" /> +neurasthenic."<a name="FNanchor_2" id="FNanchor_2"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_2" class="fnanchor">[2]</a> The +fact is that everybody is a possible neurotic.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_1" id="Footnote_1"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_1"><span class="label">[1]</span> +</a> Putnam: <i>Human Motives</i>, p. 117.</p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_2" id="Footnote_2"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_2"><span class="label">[2]</span> +</a> DuBois: <i>Physic Treatment of Nervous Disorders</i>, p. 172.</p></div> + +<p>So, as we think about nervous folk and begin to recognize our friends +and relatives in this class, it may be that some of us will +unexpectedly find ourselves looking in the mirror. Some of our +lifelong habits may turn out to be nervous tricks. At any rate, it +behooves us to be careful about throwing stones, for most of us live +in houses that are at least part glass.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Earmarks</p> + +<p><b>Am I "Like Folks"?</b> Before we begin to talk about the real sufferer +from "nerves," the nervous invalid, let us look for some of the +earmarks that are often found on the supposedly well person. All of +these signs are deviations from the normal and are sure indications of +nervousness. The test question for each individual is this: "Am I +'like folks'?" To be normal and to be well is to be "like folks." Can +the average man stand this or that? If he can, then you are not normal +if you cannot. Do the people around you eat the thing that upsets you? +If they do, ten chances to one your trouble is not a physical +idiosyncrasy, but a nervous habit. In bodily matters, at least, it is +a good thing to be one of the crowd.</p> + +<p>Many people who would resent being called anything <!-- Page 5 --> +<a name="Page_5" id="Page_5" />but normal—in +general—are not at all loth to be thought "different," when it comes +to particulars. Are there not many of us who are at small pains to +hide the fact that we "didn't sleep a wink last night," or that we +"can't stand" a ticking clock or a crowing rooster? We sometimes +consider it a mark of distinction to have a delicate appetite and to +have to choose our food with care. If we are frank with ourselves, +some of us will have to admit that our own ailments seem interesting, +while the other person's ills are "merely nervous" or imaginary or +abnormal. After all, a good many of us will have to plead guilty to +the charge of nervousness.</p> + +<p>We have only to read the endless advertisements of cathartics and +"internal baths," or to check up the quantity of laxatives sold at any +drug store, to realize the wide-spread bondage to that great bugaboo +constipation. He who is constipated can hardly prove an alibi to +"nerves." Then there are the school-teachers and others who are worn +out at the end of each year's work, hardly able to hold on until +vacation; and the people who can't manage their tempers; and those who +are upset over trifles; and those who are dissatisfied with life. To a +certain degree, at least, all of these are nervous persons. The list +grows.</p> + +<p><b>Half-Power Engines.</b> These people are all supposed to be well. They +keep going—by fits and <!-- Page 6 --><a name="Page_6" id="Page_6" /> +starts—and as they are used to running on +three cylinders, with frequent stops for repairs, they accept this +rate of living as a matter of course, never realizing that they might +be sixty horse-power engines, instead of their little thirty or forty. +For this large and neglected class of people psychotherapy has a +stimulating message, and for them many of the following pages have +been written.</p> + +<p><b>The Real Sufferers.</b> These so-called normal people are merely on the +fringe of nervousness, on the border line between normality and +disease. Beyond them there exists a great company of those whose lives +have been literally wrecked by "nerves." Their work interrupted or +given up for good, their minds harassed by doubts and fears, their +bodies incapacitated, they crowd the sanatoria and the health resorts +in a vain search for health. From New England to Florida they seek, +and on to Colorado and California, and perhaps to Hawaii and the +Orient, thinking by rest and change to pull themselves together and +become whole again. There are thousands of these people—lawyers, +preachers, teachers, mothers, social workers, business and +professional folk of all sorts, the kind of persons the world needs +most—laid off for months or years of treatment, on account of some +kind of nervous disorder.</p> + +<p><b>Various Types of Nervousness.</b> The psychoneuroses +<!-- Page 7 --><a name="Page_7" id="Page_7" />are of many +forms.<a name="FNanchor_3" id="FNanchor_3"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_3" class="fnanchor">[3]</a> To some +people "nerves" means nervous prostration, +breakdown, fatigue, weakness, insomnia, the blues, upset stomach, or +unsteady heart,—all signs of so-called neurasthenia or +nerve-weakness. To others the word "nerves" calls up memories of +strange, emotional storms that seem to rise out of nowhere, to sweep +the sky clear of everything else, and to pass as they came, leaving +the victim and the family equally mystified as to their meaning. These +strange alterations of personality are but one manifestation of +hysteria, that myriad-faced disorder which is able to mimic so +successfully the symptoms of almost every known disease, from tumors +and fevers to paralysis and blindness.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_3" id="Footnote_3"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_3"><span class="label">[3]</span></a> The technical term for nervousness is +<i>psycho-neurosis</i>—disease of the psyche. There are certain "real +neuroses" such as paralysis and spinal-cord disease, which involve an +organic impairment of nerve-tissue. However, as this book deals only +with psychic disturbance, we shall, throughout, use the term +<i>neuroses</i> and <i>psycho-neuroses</i> indiscriminately, to denote nervous +or functional disorders.</p></div> + +<p>To still other people nervous trouble means fear,—just terrible fear +without object or meaning or reason (anxiety neuroses); or a definite +fear of some harmless object (phobia); or a strange, persistent, +recurrent idea, quite foreign to the personality and beyond the reach +of reason (obsession); or an insistent desire to perform some absurd +act (compulsion); or perhaps, a deadly and pall-like depression (the +blues).</p> + +<p><!-- Page 8 --><a name="Page_8" id="Page_8" /> +As a matter of fact, the neuroses include all these varieties, and +various shades and combinations of each. There are, however, certain +mental characteristics which recur with surprising regularity in most +of the various phases—dissatisfaction, lack of confidence, a sense of +being alone and shut in to oneself, doubt, anxiety, fear, worry, +self-depreciation, lack of interest in outside affairs, pessimism, +fixed belief in one's powerlessness, along whatever line it may be.</p> + +<p>Underneath all these differing forms of nervousness are the same +mechanisms and the same kind of difficulty. To understand one is to +understand all, and to understand normal people as well; for in the +last analysis we are one and all built on the same lines and governed +by the same laws. The only difference is, that, as Jung says, "the +nervous person falls ill of the conflicts with which the well person +battles successfully."</p> + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p>Since at least seventy-five per cent. of all the people who apply to +physicians for help are nervous patients; and since these thousands of +patients are not among the mental incompetents, but are as a rule +among the highly organized, conscientious folk who have most to +contribute to the leadership of the world, it is obviously of vital +importance to society that its citizens should be taught how to solve +their inner conflicts and <!-- Page 9 --><a name="Page_9" id="Page_9" />keep +well. In this strategic period of +reconstruction, the world that is being remodeled cannot afford to +lose one leader because of an unnecessary breakdown.</p> + +<p>There is greater need than ever for people who can keep at their tasks +without long enforced rests; people who can think deeply and +continuously without brain-fag; people who can concentrate all their +powers on the work in hand without wasting time or energy on +unnecessary aches and pains; people whose bodies are kept up to the +top notch of vitality by well-digested food, well-slept sleep, +well-forgotten fatigue, and well-used reserve energy. That such a +state of affairs is no Utopian dream, but is merely a matter of +knowing how, will appear more clearly in later chapters.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> +<!-- Page 10 --><div><a name="Page_10" id="Page_10"></a></div> + +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_II" id="CHAPTER_II">CHAPTER II</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we learn what "nerves" are not, and get a hint of what they +are</i></p> + +<p class="heading">THE DRAMA OF NERVES</p> + +<p class="scheading">An Exploded Theory</p> + + +<p><b>"Nerves" not Nerves.</b> Pick up any newspaper, turn over a few pages, +and you will be sure to come to an advertisement something like this:</p> + +<div class="poem"><div class="stanza"> +<span>Tired man, your nerves are sick!<br /></span> +<span>They need rest and a tonic to restore<br /></span> +<span class="i2">their worn-out depleted cells!<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<p>No wonder people have believed this kind of thing. It has been dinned +into their ears for many years. They have read it with their breakfast +coffee and gazed at it in the street cars and even heard it from their +family physicians, until it has become part and parcel of their +thinking; yet all the time the fundamental idea has been false, and +now, at last, the theory is exploded.</p> + +<p>So far as the modern laboratory can discover, the +<!-- Page 11 --><a name="Page_11" id="Page_11" />nerves of the most +confirmed neurotic are perfectly healthy. They are not starved, nor +depleted, nor exhausted; the fat-sheath is not wanting, there is no +inflammation, there is nothing lacking in the cell itself, and there +is no accumulation of fatigue products. Paradoxical as it may sound, +there is nothing the matter with a nervous person's nerves. The +faithful messengers have borne the blame for so long that their name +has gotten itself woven into the very language as symbolic of disease. +When we speak of nervous prostration, neurasthenia, neuroses, +nervousness, and "nerves" we mean that body and mind are behaving +badly because of functional disorder. These terms are good enough as +figures of speech, so long as we are not fooled by them; but accepting +them in their literal sense has been a costly procedure.</p> + +<p>Thanks to the investigations of physiologist and psychologist, usually +combined in the person of a physician, "nervousness" has been found to +be not an organic disease but a functional one. This is a very +important distinction, for an organic disease implies impairment of +the tissues of the organ, while a functional disorder means only a +disturbance of its action. In a purely nervous disorder there seems to +be no trouble with what the nerves and organs are, but only with what +they do; it is behavior and not tissue that is at fault. Of course, in +real life, things are seldom as <!-- Page 12 --><a name="Page_12" id="Page_12" /> +clear-cut as they are in books, and +so it happens that often there is a combination of organic and +functional disease that is puzzling even to a skilled diagnostician. +The first essential is a diagnosis as to whether it be an organic +disease, with accompanying nervous symptoms, or a functional +disturbance complicated by some minor organic trouble. If the main +cause is organic, only physical means can cure it, but if the trouble +is functional, no amount of medicine or surgery, diet or rest, will +touch it; yet the symptoms are so similar and the dividing line is so +elusive, that great skill is sometimes required to determine whether a +given symptom points to a disturbance of physical tissue or only to +behavior.</p> + +<p>If the physician is sometimes fooled, how much more the sufferer +himself! Nausea from a healthy stomach is just as sickening as nausea +from a diseased one. A fainting-spell is equally uncomfortable, +whether it come from an impaired heart or simply from one that is +behaving badly for the moment. It must be remembered that in +functional nervousness the trouble is very real. The organs are really +"acting up." Sometimes it is the brain that misbehaves instead of the +stomach or heart. In that case it often reports all kinds of pains +that have no origin outside of the brain. Pain, of course, is +perceived only by the brain. Cut the telegraph wire, the nerve, and no +amount of injury to the finger can cause pain. It is equally true that +a <!-- Page 13 --><a name="Page_13" id="Page_13" />misbehaving +brain can report sensations that have no external +cause, that have not come in through the regular channel along the +nerve. The pain feels just the same, is every bit as uncomfortable as +though its cause were external.</p> + +<p>Sometimes, instead of reporting false pains, the brain misbehaves in +other ways. It seems to lose its power to decide, to concentrate, or +to remember. Then the patient is almost sure to fancy himself going +insane. But insanity is a physical disease, implying changes or toxins +in the brain cells. Functional disorders tell another story. Their +cause is different, even though the picture they present is often a +close copy of an organic disease.</p> + +<p><b>Distorted Pictures.</b> It should not be thought, however, that the +symptoms of functional and organic troubles are identical. Hysteria +and neurasthenia closely simulate every imaginable physical disease, +but they do not exactly parallel any one of them. It may take a +skilled eye to discover the differences, but differences there are. +Functional troubles usually show a near-picture of organic disease, +with just enough contradictory or inconsistent features to furnish a +clue as to their real nature. For this reason it is important that the +treatment of the disease be solely the province of the physician; for +only the carefully trained in all the requirements of diagnosis can +differentiate the <!-- Page 14 --><a name="Page_14" id="Page_14" />pseudo +from the real, the innocuous from the disastrous.</p> + +<p>False or nervous neuritis may feel like real neuritis (the result of +poisons in the blood), but it gives itself away when it localizes +itself in parts of the body where there is no nerve trunk. The +exhaustion of neurasthenia sometimes seems extreme enough to be the +result of a dangerous physical condition; but when this exhaustion +disappears as if by magic under the proper kind of treatment, we know +that the trouble cannot be in the body. Let it be said, then, with all +the emphasis we can command, "nerves" are not physical. Laboratory +investigation, contradictory symptoms, and response to treatment all +bear witness to this fact. Whatever symptoms of disturbance there may +be in pure nervousness, the nerves and organs can in no way be shown +to be diseased.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Positive Side</p> + + +<p><b>"Nerves" not Imaginary.</b> "But," some one says, "how can healthy +organs misbehave in this way? Something must be wrong. There must be +some cause. If 'nerves' are not physical, what are they? They surely +can't be imaginary." Most emphatically, they are real; nothing could +be more maddening than to have some one suggest that our troubles are +"mere imagination." No wonder such theories have been +<!-- Page 15 --><a name="Page_15" id="Page_15" />more popular +with the patient's family than with the patient himself. Many years +ago a physician put the whole truth into a few words: "The patient +says, 'I cannot'; his friends say, 'He will not'; the doctor says, 'He +cannot will.'" He tries, but in the circumstances he really cannot.</p> + +<p><b>The Man behind the Body.</b> The trouble is real; the organs do "act +up"; the nerves do carry the wrong messages. But the nerves are merely +telegraph wires. They are not responsible for the messages that are +given them to carry. Behind the wires is the operator, the man higher +up, and upon him the responsibility falls. In functional troubles the +body is working in a perfectly normal way, considering the perverted +conditions. It is doing its work well, doing just what it is told, +obeying its master. The troubles are not with the bodily machine but +with the master. The man behind the body is in trouble and he really +has no way of showing his pain except through his body. The trouble in +nervous disorders is in the personality, the soul, the realm of ideas, +and that is not your body, but <i>you</i>. Loss of appetite may mean either +that the powers of the physical organism are busily engaged in +combating some poison circulating in the blood, or that the ego is "up +against" conditions for which it has "no stomach." Paralysis may be +due to a hemorrhage into the brain tissues from a diseased blood +vessel, or <!-- Page 16 --><a name="Page_16" id="Page_16" />it +may symbolize a sense of inadequacy and defeat. +Exaggerated exhaustion, halting feet, stammering tongue, may give +evidence of a disturbed ego rather than of a diseased brain.</p> + +<p><b>All Body and no Mind.</b> At last we have begun to realize what we ought +to have known all along,—that the body is not the whole man. The +medical world for a long time has been in danger of forgetting or +ignoring psychic suffering, while it has devoted itself to the +treatment of physical disease.</p> + +<p>By way of condoning this fault it must be recognized that the five +years of medical school have been all too short to learn what is +needed of physiology and anatomy, histology, bacteriology, and the +various other physical sciences. But at last the medical schools are +realizing that they have been sending their graduates out only +half-prepared—conversant with only one half of a patient, leaving +them to fend for themselves in discovering the ways of the other half. +Many an M.D. has gone a long way in this exploration. Native common +sense, intuition, and careful study have enabled him to go beyond what +he had learned in his text-books. But in the best universities the +present-day student of medicine is now being given an insight into the +ways of man as a whole—mind as well as body. The movement can hardly +proceed too rapidly, and when it has had time to reach its goal, the +day of the <!-- Page 17 --><a name="Page_17" id="Page_17" />long-term +sentence to nervousness will be past.</p> + +<p>In the meanwhile most physicians, lacking such knowledge and with the +eye fixed largely on the body, have been pumping out the stomach, +prescribing lengthy rest-cures, trying massage, diet, electricity, and +surgical operations, in a vain attempt to cure a disease of the +personality. Physical measures have been given a good trial, but few +would contend that they have succeeded. Sometimes the patient has +recovered—in time—but often, apparently, despite the treatment +rather than because of it. Sometimes, in the hands of a man like Dr. +S. Weir Mitchell, results seem good, until we realize that the same +measures are ineffective when tried by other men, and that, after all, +what has counted most has been the personality of the physician rather +than his physical treatment.</p> + +<p>No wonder that most doctors have disliked nervous cases. To a man +trained in all the exactness of the physical sciences, the apparent +lawlessness and irresponsibility of the psychic side of the +personality is especially repugnant. He is impatient of what he fails +to comprehend.</p> + +<p><b>All Mind and no Body.</b> This unsympathetic attitude, often only half +conscious on the part of the regular practitioners, has led many +thousands of people to follow will-o'-the-wisp cults, which pay no +attention to the findings of science, but which emphasize a +<!-- Page 18 --><a name="Page_18" id="Page_18" />realization of +man's spiritual nature. Many of these cults, founded +largely on untruth or half-falsehood, have succeeded in cases where +careful science has failed. Despite fearful blunders and execrable +lack of discrimination in attempting to cure all the ills that flesh +is heir to by methods that apply only to functional troubles, ignorant +enthusiasts and quacks have sometimes cured nervous troubles where the +conscientious medical man has had to acknowledge defeat.</p> + +<p><b>The Whole Man.</b> But thinking people are not willing to desert science +for cults that ignore the existence of these physical bodies. If they +have found it unsatisfactory to be treated as if they were all body, +they have also been unwilling to be treated as if they were all mind. +They have been in a dilemma between two half-truths, even if they have +not realized the dilemma. It has remained for modern psychotherapy to +strike the balance—to treat the whole man. Solidly planted on the +rock of the physical sciences, with its laboratories, physiological +and psychological, and with a long record of investigation and +treatment of pathological cases, it resembles the mind cure of earlier +days or the assertions of Christian Science about as much as modern +medicine resembles the old bloodletting, leeching practices of our +forefathers.</p> + +<p>For the last quarter-century there have been scattered groups of +physicians,—brilliant, patient pioneers,—who, +<!-- Page 19 --><a name="Page_19" id="Page_19" />recognizing man as +spirit inhabiting body, have explored the realm of man's mind and +charted its paths. These pioneers, beginning with Charcot, have been +men of acknowledged scientific training and spirit, whose word must be +respected and whose success in treating functional troubles stands out +in sharp contrast to the fumblings of the average practitioner in this +field. The results of their work have been positive, not negative. +They have not merely asserted that nervous disorders are not physical; +they have discovered what the trouble is and have found it to be +discoverable and removable in almost every case, provided only that +the right method is used.</p> + +<p><b>Ourselves and Our Bodies.</b> If the statement that "nervous troubles +are neither physical nor imaginary but a disease of the personality," +sounds rather mystifying to the average person, it is only because the +average person is not very conversant with his own inner life. We +shall hope, later on, to find some definite guide-posts and landmarks +which will help us feel more at home in this fascinating realm. At +present, we are not attempting anything more than a suggestion of the +itinerary which we shall follow. A book on physical hygiene can +presuppose at least a rudimentary knowledge of heart and lungs and +circulation, but a book on mental hygiene must begin at the beginning, +and even before the beginning must clear away misconceptions +<!-- Page 20 --><a name="Page_20" id="Page_20" />and make +clear certain fundamental principles. But the gist of the whole matter +is this: in a neurosis, certain forces of the personality—instincts +and their accompanying emotions—which ought to work harmoniously, +having become tangled up with some erroneous ideas, have lost their +power of coöperation and are working at cross purposes, leaving the +individual mis-adapted to his environment, the prey of all sorts of +mental and physical disturbances.</p> + +<p>The fact that the cause is mental while the result is often physical, +should cause no surprise. In the physiological realm we are used to +the idea that cause and effect are often widely separated. A headache +may be caused by faulty eyes, or it may result from trouble in the +intestines. In the same way, we should not be too much surprised if +the cause of nervous troubles is found to be even more remote, +provided there is some connecting link between cause and effect. The +difficulty in this case is the apparent gulf between the realm of the +spirit and the realm of the body. It is hard to see how an intangible +thing like a thought can produce a pain in the arm or nausea in the +stomach. Philosophers are still arguing concerning the nature of the +relation between mind and body, but no one denies that the closest +relation does exist. Every year science is learning that ideas count +and that they count physically, as well as spiritually.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 21 --><a name="Page_21" id="Page_21" /><b>Such +Stuff as "Nerves" are Made Of.</b> Dr. Tom A. Williams in the +little composite volume "Psychotherapeutics" says that the neuroses +are based not on inherently weak nervous constitutions but on +ignorance and on false ideas. What, then, are some of these erroneous +ideas, these misconceptions, that cause so much trouble? We shall want +to examine them more carefully in later chapters, but we might glance +now at a few examples of these popular bugaboos that need to be slain +by the sword of cold, hard fact.</p> + +<p><b>Popular Misconceptions about the Body.</b></p> + +<p>1 "Eight hours' sleep is essential to health. All insomnia is +dangerous and is incompatible with health. Nervous insomnia leads to +shattered nerves and ultimately to insanity."</p> + +<p>2 "Overwork leads to nervous breakdown. Fatigue accumulates from day +to day and necessitates a long rest for recuperation."</p> + +<p>3 "A carefully planned diet is essential to health, especially for the +nervous person. A variety of food, eaten at the same time, is harmful. +Acid and milk—for example, oranges and milk—are difficult to digest. +Sour stomach is a sign of indigestion."</p> + +<p>4 "Modern life is so strenuous that our nerves cannot stand the +strain."</p> + +<p>5 "Brain work is very fatiguing. It causes brain-fag and exhaustion."</p> + +<p><!-- Page 22 --><a name="Page_22" id="Page_22" />6 "Constipation +is at the root of most physical ailments and is +caused by eating the wrong kind of food."</p> + +<p>Some of these misconceptions are household words and are so all but +universally believed that the thought that they can be challenged is +enough to bewilder one. However, it is ideas like this that furnish +the material out of which many a nervous trouble is made. Based on a +half-knowledge of the human body, on logical conclusions from faulty +premises, on hastily swallowed notions passed on from one person to +another, they tend by the very power of an idea to work themselves out +to fulfilment.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Power Behind Ideas</p> + +<p><b>Ideas Count.</b> Ideas are not the lifeless things they may appear. They +are not merely intellectual property that can be locked up and ignored +at will, nor are they playthings that can be taken up or discarded +according to the caprice of the moment. Ideas work themselves into the +very fiber of our being. They are part of us and they <i>do</i> things. If +they are true, in line with things as they are, they do things that +are for our good, but if they are false, we often discover that they +have an altogether unsuspected power for harm and are capable of +astonishing results, results which have no apparent relation to the +ideas responsible for them and which are, therefore, laid to physical +causes. Thinking <!-- Page 23 --><a name="Page_23" id="Page_23" />straight, +then, becomes a hygienic as well as a moral duty.</p> + +<p><b>Ideas and Emotions.</b> Ideas do not depend upon themselves for their +driving-power. Life is not a cold intellectual process; it is a vivid +experience, vibrant with feeling and emotion. It therefore happens +that the experiences of life tend to bring ideas and emotions together +and when an idea and an emotion get linked up together, they tend to +stay together, especially if the emotion be intense or the experience +is often repeated.</p> + +<p>The word emotion means outgoing motion, discharging force. This force +is like live steam. An emotion is the driving part of an instinct. It +is the dynamic force, the electric current which supplies the power +for every thought and every action of a human life.</p> + +<p>Man is not a passive creature. The words that describe him are not +passive words. Indeed, it is almost impossible to think about man at +all except in terms of desire, impulse, purpose, action, energy. There +are three things that may be done with energy: First, it may be +frittered away, allowed to leak, to escape. Secondly, it may be locked +up; this results usually in an explosion, a finding of destructive +outlets. Finally, it may be harnessed, controlled, used in beneficent +ways. Health and happiness depend upon which one of the three courses +is taken.</p> + +<p class="scheading"><!-- Page 24 --><a name="Page_24" id="Page_24" />Character and Health</p> + +<p>Evidently, it is highly important to have a working knowledge of these +emotions and instincts; important to know enough about them and their +purpose to handle them rightly if they do not spontaneously work +together for our best character and health. The problems of character +and the problems of health so overlap that it is impossible to write a +book about nervous disorders which does not at the same time deal with +the principles of character-formation. The laws and mechanisms which +govern the everyday life of the normal person are the same laws and +mechanisms which make the nervous person ill. As Boris Sidis puts it, +"The pathological is the normal out of place." The person who is +master of himself, working together as a harmonious whole, is stronger +in every way than the person whose forces are divided. Given a little +self-knowledge, the nervous invalid often becomes one of the most +successful members of society,—to use the word successful in the best +sense.</p> + +<p><b>It Pays to Know.</b> To be educated is to have the right idea and the +right emotion in the right place. To be sure, some people have so well +learned the secret of poise that they do not have to study the why nor +the how. Intuition often far outruns knowledge. It would be foolish +indeed to suggest that only the person versed in psychological lore is +skilled in the art of living. <!-- Page 25 --><a name="Page_25" id="Page_25" /> +Psychology is not life; it can make no +claim to furnish the motive nor the power for successful living, for +it is not faith, nor hope, nor love; but it tries to point the way and +to help us fulfil conditions. There is no more reason why the average +man should be unaware of the instincts or the subconscious mind, than +that he should be ignorant of germs or of the need of fresh air.</p> + +<p>If it be argued that character and health are both inherently +by-products of self-forgetful service, rather than of painstaking +thought, we answer that this is true, but that there can be no +self-forgetting when things have gone too far wrong. At such times it +pays to look in, if we can do it intelligently, in order that we may +the sooner get our eyes off ourselves and look out. The pursuit of +self-knowledge is not a pleasurable pastime but simply a valuable +means to an end.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Knowing Our Machine</p> + +<p><b>Counting on Ourselves.</b> Knowing our machine makes us better able to +handle it. For, after all, each of us is, in many ways, very like a +piece of marvelous and complicated machinery. For one thing, our +minds, as well as our bodies, are subject to uniform laws upon which +we can depend. We are not creatures of chaos; under certain conditions +we can count on ourselves. Freedom does not mean freedom from the +<!-- Page 26 --><a name="Page_26" id="Page_26" />reign of law. +It means that, to a certain extent, we can make use of +the laws. Psychic laws are as susceptible to investigation, +verification, and use as are any laws in the physical world. Each +person is so much the center of his own life that it is very easy for +him to fall into the way of thinking that he is different from all the +rest of the world. It is a healthful experience for him to realize +that every person he meets is made on the same principles, impelled by +the same forces, and fighting much the same fight. Since the laws of +the mental world are uniform, we can count on them as aids toward +understanding other people and understanding ourselves.</p> + +<p><b>"Intelligent Scrutiny versus Morbid Introspection."</b> It helps +wonderfully to be able to look at ourselves in an objective, +impersonal way. We are likely to be overcome by emotion, or swept by +vague longings which seem to have no meaning and which, just because +they are bound up so closely with our own ego, are not looked at but +are merely felt. Unknown forces are within us, pulling us this way and +that, until sometimes we who should be masters are helpless slaves. +One great help toward mastery and one long step toward serenity is a +working-knowledge of the causes and an impersonal interest in the +phenomena going on within. Introspection is a morbid, emotional +fixation on self, until it takes on this quality of objectivity. What +<!-- Page 27 --><a name="Page_27" id="Page_27" />Cabot calls the +"sin of impersonality" is a grievous sin when +directed toward another person, but most of us could stand a good deal +of ingrowing impersonality without any harm.</p> + +<p>The fact that the human machine can run itself without a hitch in the +majority of cases is witness to its inherent tendency toward health. +People were living and living well through all the centuries before +the science of psychology was formulated. But not with all people do +things run so smoothly. There were demoniacs in Bible times and +neurotics in the Middle Ages, as there are nervous invalids and +half-well people to-day. Psychology has a real contribution to make, +and in recent years its lessons have been put into language which the +average man can understand.</p> + +<p>Psychology is not merely interested in abstract terms with long names. +It is no longer absorbed merely in states of consciousness taken +separately and analyzed abstractly. The newer functional psychology is +increasingly interested in the study of real persons, their purposes +and interests, what they feel and value, and how they may learn to +realize their highest aspirations. It is about ordinary people, as +they think and act, in the kitchen, on the street cars, at the +bargain-counter, people in crowds and alone, mothers and their babies, +little children at play, young girls with their lovers, and all the +rest of human life. It is the science of <i>you</i>, and <!-- Page 28 --> +<a name="Page_28" id="Page_28" />as such it can +hardly help being interesting.</p> + +<p>While psychology deals with such topics as the subconscious mind, the +instincts, the laws of habit, and association of ideas and suggestion, +it is after all not so much an academic as a practical question. These +forces govern the thought you are thinking at this moment, the way you +will feel a half-hour from now, the mood you will be in to-morrow, the +friends you will make and the profession you will choose, besides +having a large share in the health or ill-health of your body in the +meantime.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p>Perhaps it would be well before going farther to summarize what we +have been saying. Here in a nutshell is the kernel of the subject:</p> + +<p>Disease may be caused by physical or by psychic forces. A "nervous" +disorder is not a physical but a psychic disease. It is caused not by +lack of energy but by misdirected energy; not by overwork or +nerve-depletion, but by misconception, emotional conflict, repressed +instincts, and buried memories. Seventy-five per cent. of all cases of +ill-health are due to psychic causes, to disjointed thinking rather +than to a disjointed spine. Wherefore, let us learn to think right.</p> + +<p>In outline form, the trouble in a neurosis may be stated something +like this:</p> + +<p><!-- Page 29 --><a name="Page_29" id="Page_29" /> <br /> +Lack of adaptation to the social environment—caused by<br /> +<span class="ind1">Lack of harmony within the personality—caused by</span><br /> +<span style="margin-left: 2em;">Misdirected energy—caused by</span><br /> +<span style="margin-left: 3em;">Inappropriate emotions—caused by</span><br /> +<span style="margin-left: 4em;">Wrong ideas or ignorance.</span><br /> +</p> + +<p>Working backward, the cure naturally would be:</p> + +<p> <br /> +Right ideas—resulting in<br /> +<span class="ind1">Appropriate emotions—resulting in</span><br /> +<span style="margin-left: 2em;">Redirected energy—resulting in</span><br /> +<span style="margin-left: 3em;">Harmony—resulting in</span><br /> +<span style="margin-left: 4em;">Readjustment to the environment.</span><br /> +</p> + +<p>If the reader is beginning to feel somewhat bewildered by these +general statements, let him take heart. So far we have tried merely to +suggest the outline of the whole problem, but we shall in the future +be more specific. Nervous troubles, which seem so simple, are really +involved with the whole mechanism of mental life and can in no way be +understood except as these mechanisms are understood. We have hinted +at some of the causes of "nerves," but we cannot give a real +explanation until we explain the forces behind them. These forces may +at first seem a bit abstract, or a bit remote from the main theme, but +each is essential to the story of nerves and to the understanding of +the more practical chapters in Part III.</p> + +<p>As in a Bernard Shaw play, the preface may be the most important part +of this "drama of nerves." Nor <!-- Page 30 --> +<a name="Page_30" id="Page_30" />is the figure too far-fetched, +because, strange as it may seem, every neurosis is in essence a drama. +It has its conflict, its villain, and its victim, its love-story, its +practical joke, its climax, and its denouement. Sometimes the play +goes on forever with no solution, but sometimes psychotherapy steps in +as the fairy god-mother, to release the victim, outwit the villain, +and bring about the live-happily-ever-after ending.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> +<hr /> +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<!-- Page 31 --><div><a name="Page_31" id="Page_31"></a></div> + +<p class="heading">PART II: "HOW THE WHEELS GO ROUND"</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> +<hr /> + +<div><!-- Page 32 --><a name="Page_32" id="Page_32" /> +<!-- Page 33 --><a name="Page_33" id="Page_33" /></div> +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_III" id="CHAPTER_III">CHAPTER III</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we find a goodly inheritance</i></p> + +<p class="heading">THE STORY OF THE INSTINCTS</p> + +<p class="scheading">Each in His Own Tongue</p> + +<div class="poem"><div class="stanza"> +<span>A fire mist and a planet,<br /></span> +<span>A crystal and a cell,<br /></span> +<span>A jelly-fish and a saurian,<br /></span> +<span>And caves where cavemen dwell;<br /></span> +<span>Then a sense of law and beauty,<br /></span> +<span>And a face turned from the clod;<br /></span> +<span>Some call it evolution<br /></span> +<span>And others call it God.<a name="FNanchor_4" id="FNanchor_4"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_4" class="fnanchor">[4]</a><br /></span> +</div></div> + + +<p>If we begin at the beginning, we have to go back a long way to get our +start, for the roots of our family tree reach back over millions of +years. "In the beginning—God." These first words of the book of +Genesis must be, in spirit at least, the first words of any discussion +of life. We know now, however, that when God made man, He did not +complete His masterpiece at one sitting, but instead devised a plan by +which the onward urge within and the environment without should act +and interact until from countless adaptations a human being was made.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_4" id="Footnote_4"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_4"><span class="label">[4]</span></a> William Herbert Carruth.</p></div> + +<p><!-- Page 34 --><a name="Page_34" id="Page_34" />As the late +Dr. Putnam of Harvard University says, "We stand as the +representative of a Creative Energy that expressed itself first in far +simpler forms of life and finally in the form of human +instincts."<a name="FNanchor_5" id="FNanchor_5"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_5" class="fnanchor">[5]</a> +And again: "The choices and decisions of the organisms whose lives +prepared the way through eons of time for ours, present themselves to +us as instincts."<a name="FNanchor_6" id="FNanchor_6"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_6" class="fnanchor">[6]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_5" id="Footnote_5"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_5"><span class="label">[5]</span> +</a> Putnam: <i>Human Motives</i>, p. 32.</p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_6" id="Footnote_6"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_6"><span class="label">[6]</span> +</a> Putnam: <i>Human Motives</i>, p. 18.</p></div> + + +<p class="scheading">Introducing the Instincts</p> + +<p><b>Back of Our Dispositions.</b> What is it that makes the baby jump at a +noise? What energizes a man when you tell him he is a liar? What makes +a young girl blush when you look at her, or a youth begin to take +pains with his necktie? What makes men go to war or build tunnels or +found hospitals or make love or save for a home? What makes a woman +slave for her children, or give her life for them if need be? +"Instinct" you say, and rightly. Back of every one of these well-known +human tendencies is a specific instinct or group of instincts. The +story of the life of man and the story of the mind of man must begin +with the instincts. Indeed, any intelligent approach to human life, +whether it be that of the mother, the teacher, the preacher, the +social worker or the neurologist, leads back inevitably to the +instincts as the starting-point of understanding. But what is +instinct?</p> + +<p><!-- Page 35 --><a name="Page_35" id="Page_35" />We are apt +to be a bit hazy on that point, as we are on any +fundamental thing with which we intimately live. We reckon on these +instinctive tendencies every hour of the day, but as we are not used +to labeling them, it may help in the very beginning of our discussion +to have a list before our eyes. Here, then, is a list of the +fundamental tendencies of the human race and the emotions which drive +them to fulfilment.</p> + +<p class="center"> <br />THE SPECIFIC INSTINCTS AND THEIR EMOTIONS (AFTER MCDOUGALL)</p> + +<table cellspacing="0" cellpadding="4" border="0" +summary="Instincts and Emotions (after McDougall)"> +<tr> + <td><i>Instinct</i><br /> </td> + <td><i>Emotion</i><br /> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Nutritive Instinct </td> + <td>Hunger</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Flight </td> + <td>Fear</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Repulsion</td> + <td>Disgust</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Curiosity</td> + <td>Wonder</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Self-assertion</td> + <td>Positive Self-feeling (Elation)</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Self-abasement</td> + <td>Negative Self-feeling (Subjection)</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Gregariousness</td> + <td>Emotion unnamed</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Acquisition</td> + <td>Love of Possession</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Construction</td> + <td>Emotion unnamed</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Pugnacity</td> + <td>Anger</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Reproductive Instinct </td> + <td>Emotion unnamed</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Parental Instinct<br /> </td> + <td>Tender Emotion<br /> </td> +</tr> +</table> + +<p>These are the fundamental tendencies or dispositions with which every +human being is endowed as he comes into the world. Differing in degree +in different individuals, they unite in varying proportions to form +various kinds of dispositions, but are in greater or less degree the +common property of us all.</p> + +<p>There flows through the life of every creature a <!-- Page 36 --> +<a name="Page_36" id="Page_36" />steady stream of +energy. Scientists have not been able to decide on a descriptive term +for this all-important life-force. It has been variously called +"libido," "vital impulse" or "élan vital," "the spirit of life," +"hormé," and "creative energy." The chief business of this life-force +seems to be the preservation and development of the individual and the +preservation and development of the race. In the service of these two +needs have grown up these habit-reactions which we call instincts. The +first ten of our list belong under the heading of self-preservation +and the last two under that of race-preservation. As hunger is the +most urgent representative of the self-preservative group, and as +reproduction and parental care make up the race-preservative group, +some scientists refer all impulses to the two great instincts of +nutrition and sex, using these words in the widest sense. However, it +will be useful for our purpose to follow McDougall's classification +and to examine individually the various tendencies of the two groups.</p> + +<p><b>In Debt to Our Ancestors.</b> An instinct is the result of the +experience of the race, laid in brain and nerve-cells ready for use. +It is a gift from our ancestors, an inheritance from the education of +the age-long line of beings who have gone before. In the struggle for +existence, it has been necessary for the members of the race to feed +themselves, to run away from danger, to <!-- Page 37 --> +<a name="Page_37" id="Page_37" />fight, to herd together, to +reproduce themselves, to care for their young, and to do various other +things which make for the well-being or preservation of the race. The +individuals that did these things at the right time survived and +passed on to their offspring an inherited tendency to this kind of +reaction. McDougall defines an instinct as "an inherited or innate +psycho-physical disposition which determines its possessor to perceive +or pay attention to objects of a certain class, to experience an +emotional excitement of a particular quality upon perceiving such an +object, and to act in regard to it in a particular manner, or at least +to experience an impulse to such action." This is just what an +instinct is,—an inherited disposition to notice, to feel, and to want +to act in certain ways in certain situations. It is the something +which makes us act when we cannot explain why, the something that goes +deeper than reason, and that links us to all other human +beings,—those who live to-day and those who have gone before.</p> + +<p>It is true that East is East and West is West, but the two do meet in +the common foundation of our human nature. The likeness between men +and between races is far greater and far more fundamental than the +differences can ever be.</p> + +<p><b>Firing Up the Engine.</b> Purpose is writ large across the face of an +instinct, and that purpose is always toward action. Whenever a +situation arises which <!-- Page 38 --><a name="Page_38" id="Page_38" /> +demands instantaneous action, the instinct is +the means of securing it. Planted within the creature is a tendency +which makes it perceive and feel and act in the appropriate way. It +will be noticed that there are three distinct parts to the process, +corresponding to intellect, emotion, will. The initial intellectual +part makes us sensitive to certain situations, makes us recognize an +object as meaningful and significant, and waves the flag for the +emotion; the emotion fires up the engine, pulls the levers all over +the body that release its energy and get it ready for action, and +pushes the button that calls into the mind an intense, almost +irresistible desire or impulse to act. Once aroused, the emotion and +the impulse are not to be changed. In man or beast, in savage or +savant, the intense feeling, the marked bodily changes, and the +yearning for action are identical and unchangeable. The brakes can be +put on and the action suppressed, but in that case the end of the +whole process is defeated. Could anything be plainer than that an +instinct and its emotion were never intended to be aroused except in +situations in which their characteristic action is to be desired? An +emotion is the hot part of an instinct and exists solely for securing +action. If all signs of the emotion are to be suppressed, all +expression denied, why the emotion?</p> + +<p>But although the emotion and the impulse, once aroused, are beyond +control, there is yet one part of <!-- Page 39 --><a name="Page_39" id="Page_39" /> +the instinct that is meant to be controlled. The initial or receptive portion, +that which notices a situation, recognizes it as significant, and sends in the signal for +action, can be trained to discrimination. This is where reason comes +in. If the situation calls for flight, fear is in order; if it calls +for fight, anger is in order; if it calls for examination, wonder is +in order; but if it calls for none of these things, reason should show +some discrimination and refuse to call up the emotion.</p> + +<p><b>The Right of Way.</b> There is a law that comes to the aid of reason in +this dilemma and that is the "law of the common +path."<a name="FNanchor_7" id="FNanchor_7"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_7" class="fnanchor">[7]</a> By this is +meant that man is capable of but one intense emotion at a time. No one +can imagine himself strenuously making love while he is shaken by an +agony of fear, or ravenously eating while he is in a passion of rage. +The stronger emotion gets the right of way, obtains control of mental +and bodily machinery, and leaves no room for opposite states. If the +two emotions are not antagonistic, they may blend together to form a +compound emotion, but if in the nature of the case such a blending is +impossible, the weaker is for the time being forgotten in the +intensity of the stronger. "The expulsive power of a new affection" is +not merely a happy phrase; it is a fact in every day life. The +problem, then, resolves itself into ways of making the desirable +emotion the <!-- Page 40 --><a name="Page_40" id="Page_40" />stronger, +of learning how to form the habit of giving it +the head start and the right of way. In our chapter on "Choosing the +Emotions," we shall find that much depends on building up the right +kind of sentiments, or the permanent organization of instincts around +ideas. However, we must first look more closely at the separate +instincts to acquaint ourselves with the purpose and the ways of each, +and to discover the nature of the forces with which we have to deal.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_7" id="Footnote_7"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_7"><span class="label">[7]</span> +</a> Sherrington: <i>Integrative Action of the Nervous System</i>.</p></div> + +<p class="scheading">I The Self-Preservative Instincts</p> + +<p><b>Hunger.</b> Hunger is the most pressing desire of the egoistic or +self-preserving impulse. The yearning for food and the impulse to seek +and eat it are aroused organically within the body and are behind much +of the activity of every type of life. As the impulse is so familiar, +and its promptings are so little subject to psychic control, it seems +unnecessary to do more than mention its importance.</p> + +<p><b>Flight and Fear.</b> All through the ages the race has been subject to +injury. Species has been pitted against species, individual against +individual. He who could fight hardest or run fastest has survived and +passed his abilities on to his offspring. Not all could be strongest +for fight, and many species have owed their existence to their ability +to run and to know when to run. Thus it is that one of the strongest +and most <!-- Page 41 --><a name="Page_41" id="Page_41" />universal +tendencies is the instinct for flight, and its +emotion, fear. "Fear is the representation of injury and is born of +the innumerable injuries which have been inflicted in the course of +evolution."<a name="FNanchor_8" id="FNanchor_8"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_8" class="fnanchor">[8]</a> Some babies are frightened if they are held too +loosely, even though they have never known a fall. Some persons have +an instinctive fear of cats, a left-over from the time when the race +needed to flee from the tiger and others of the cat family. Almost +every one, no matter in what state of culture, fears the unknown +because the race before him has had to be afraid of that which was not +familiar.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_8" id="Footnote_8"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_8"><span class="label">[8]</span> +</a> Crile: <i>Origin and Nature of the Emotions</i>.</p></div> + +<p>The emotion of fear is well known, but its purpose is not so often +recognized. An emotion brings about internal changes, visceral changes +they are called, which enable the organism to act on the emotion,—to +accomplish its object. There is only so much energy available at a +given moment, stored up in the brain cells, ready for use. In such an +emergency as flight every ounce of energy is needed. The large muscles +used in running must have a great supply of extra energy. The heart +and lungs must be speeded up in order to provide oxygen and take care +of extra waste products. The special senses of sight and hearing must +be sensitized. Digestion and intestinal peristalsis must be stopped in +order to save energy. No person could by <!-- Page 42 --> +<a name="Page_42" id="Page_42" />conscious thought accomplish +all these things. How, then, are they brought about?</p> + +<p><b>Internal Laboratories.</b> In the wonderful internal laboratory of the +body there are little glands whose business it is to secrete chemicals +for just these emergencies. When an object is sighted which arouses +fear, the brain cells flash instantaneous messages over the body, +among others to the supra-renal glands or adrenals, just over the +kidneys, and to the thyroid gland in the neck. Instantly these glands +pour forth adrenalin and thyroid secretion into the blood, and the +body responds. Blood pressure rises; brain cells speed up; the liver +pours forth glycogen, its ready-to-burn fuel; sweat-glands send forth +cold perspiration in order to regulate temperature; blood is pumped +out from stomach and intestines to the external muscles. As we have +seen, the body as a whole can respond to just one stimulus at a time. +The response to this stimulus has the right of way. The whole body is +integrated, set for this one thing. When fear holds the switchboard no +other messages are allowed on the line, and the creature is ready for +flight.</p> + +<p>But after flight comes concealment with the opposite bodily need, the +need for absolute silence. This is why we sometimes get the opposite +result. The heart seems to stop beating, the breath ceases, the limbs +refuse to move, all because our ancestors needed to <!-- Page 43 --> +<a name="Page_43" id="Page_43" />hide after they +had run, and because we are in a very real way a part of them.</p> + +<p><b>Old-Fashioned Fear.</b> There is one passage from Dr. Crile's book which +so admirably sums up these points that it seems worth while to insert +it at length.</p> + +<div class="blockquot"><p>We fear not in our hearts alone, not in our brains alone, not in + our viscera alone—fear influences every organ and tissue. Each + organ or tissue is stimulated or inhibited according to its use + or hindrance in the physical struggle for existence. By thus + concentrating all or most of the nerve force on the + nerve-muscular mechanism for defense, a greater physical power is + developed. Hence it is that under the stimulus of fear animals + are able to perform preternatural feats of strength. For the same + reason, the exhaustion following fear will be increased as the + powerful stimulus of fear drains the cup of nervous energy even + though no visible action may result.... Perhaps the most striking + difference between man and animals lies in the greater control + which man has gained over his primitive instinctive reactions. As + compared with the entire duration of organic evolution, man came + down from his arboreal abode and assumed his new rôle of + increased domination over the physical world but a moment ago. + And now, though sitting at his desk in command of the complicated + machinery of civilization, when he fears a business catastrophe + his fear is manifested in the terms of his ancestral physical + battle in the struggle for existence. He cannot fear + intellectually, he cannot fear dispassionately, he fears with all + his organs, and the same<!-- Page 44 --><a name="Page_44" id="Page_44" /> + organs are stimulated and inhibited as if, instead of its being a + battle of credit, or position, or of honor, it were a physical + battle with teeth and claws.... Nature has but one means of + response to fear, and whatever its cause the phenomena are always + the same—always + physical.<a name="FNanchor_9" id="FNanchor_9"></a> + <a href="#Footnote_9" class="fnanchor">[9]</a></p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_9" id="Footnote_9"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_9"><span class="label">[9]</span> +</a> Crile: <i>Origin and Nature of the Emotions</i>, p. 60 ff.</p></div> + +<p>The moral is as plain as day: Learn to call up fear only when speedy +legs are needed, not a cool head or a comfortable digestion. Fear is a +costly proceeding, an emergency measure like a fire-alarm, to be used +only when the occasion is urgent enough to demand it. How often it is +misused and how large a part it plays in nervous symptoms, both mental +and physical, will appear more clearly in later chapters.</p> + +<p><b>Repulsion and Disgust.</b> Akin to the instinct of flight is that of +repulsion, which impels us, instead of fleeing, to thrust the object +away. It leads us to reject from the mouth noxious and disgusting +objects and to shrink from slimy, creepy creatures, and has of course +been highly useful in protecting the race from poisons and snakes. It +still operates in the tendency to put away from us those things, +mental or physical, toward which we feel aversion or disgust. Recent +psychological discoveries have revealed how largely a neurosis +consists in putting away from us—out of consciousness,—whatever we +do not wish to recognize, <!-- Page 45 --><a name="Page_45" id="Page_45" /> +and so it happens that disgust plays an unexpected part in nervous disorders.</p> + +<p><b>Curiosity and Wonder.</b> Fortunately for the race, it has not had to +wait until different features of the environment prove to be helpful +or harmful. There is an instinct which urges forward to exploration +and discovery and which enables the creature not only to adapt itself +to the environment but to learn how to adapt the environment to +itself. This is the instinct of curiosity. It is the impulse back of +all advance in science, religion, and intellectual achievement of +every kind, and is sometimes called "intellectual feeling."</p> + +<p><b>Self-Assertion.</b> It goes almost without saying that one of the +strongest and most important impulses of mankind is the instinct of +self-assertion; it often gets us into trouble, but it is also behind +every effort toward developed character. At its lowest level +self-assertion manifests itself in the strutting of the peacock, the +prancing of the horse, and the "See how big I am," of the small boy. +At its highest level, when combined with self-consciousness and the +moral sentiments acquired from society and developed into the +self-regarding sentiment, it is responsible for most of our ideas of +right, our conception of what is and what is not compatible with our +self-respect.</p> + +<p><b>Self-Abasement.</b> Self-assertion is aroused primarily by the presence +of others and especially of those to <!-- Page 46 --><a name="Page_46" id="Page_46" />whom we feel in any way +superior, but when the presence of others makes us feel small, when we +want to hide or keep in the background, we are being moved by the +opposite instinct of self-abasement and negative self-feeling. It may +be either the real or the fancied superiority of the spectators that +arouses this feeling,—their wisdom or strength, beauty or good +clothes. Sometimes, as in stage-fright, it is their numerical +superiority. Bashfulness is the struggle between the two +self-instincts, assertion and abasement. Our impulse for self-display +urges us on to make a good impression, while our feeling of +inferiority impels us to get away unnoticed. Hence the struggle and +the painful emotion.</p> + +<p><b>Gregariousness.</b> Man has been called a gregarious animal. That is, +like the animals, he likes to run with his kind, and feels a +pronounced aversion to prolonged isolation. It is this +"herd-instinct," too, which makes man so extremely sensitive to the +opinions of the society in which he lives. Because of this impulse to +go with the crowd, ideas received through education are accepted as +imperative and are backed up by all the force of the instinct of +self-regard. When the teachings of society happen to run counter to +the laws of our being, the possibilities of conflict are indeed +great.<a name="FNanchor_10" id="FNanchor_10"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_10" class="fnanchor">[10]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_10" id="Footnote_10"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_10"><span class="label">[10]</span> +</a> For a thorough discussion of the importance of this +instinct, see Trotter's <i>Instincts of the Herd in Peace and War</i>.</p></div> + +<p><!-- Page 47 --><a name="Page_47" id="Page_47" /> +<b>Acquisition.</b> Another fundamental disposition in both animals and +men is the instinct for possession, the instinct whose function it is +to provide for future needs. Squirrels and birds lay up nuts for the +winter; the dog hides his bone where only he can find it. Children +love to have things for their "very own," and almost invariably go +through the hoarding stage in which stamps or samples or bits of +string are hoarded for the sake of possession, quite apart from their +usefulness or value. Much of the training of children consists in +learning what is "mine" and what is "thine," and respect for the +property of others can develop only out of a sense of one's own +property rights.</p> + +<p><b>Construction.</b> There is an innate satisfaction in making +something,—from a doll-dress to a poem,—and this satisfaction rests +on the impulse to construct, to fashion something with our own hands +or our own brain. The emotion accompanying this instinct is too +indefinite to have a name but it is nevertheless a real one and plays +a large part in the sense of power which results from the satisfaction +of good work well done. Later it will be seen how closely related is +this impulse to the creative instinct of reproduction and how useful +it can be in drawing off the surplus energy of that much denied +instinct.</p> + +<p><b>Pugnacity and Anger.</b> What is it that makes us +<!-- Page 48 --><a name="Page_48" id="Page_48" />angry? A little +thought will convince us that the thing which arouses our fury is not +the sight of any special object, but the blocking of any one of the +other instincts. Watch any animal at bay when its chance for flight +has gone. The timidest one will turn and fight with every sign of +fury. Watch a mother when her young are threatened,—bear, or cat or +lion or human. Fear has no place then. It is entirely displaced by +anger over the balking of the maternal instinct of protection. +Strictly speaking, pugnacity belongs among the instincts neither of +self-preservation nor of race-preservation, but is a special device +for reinforcing both groups.</p> + +<p>As fear supplies the energy for running, so anger fits us for +fight,—and for nothing but fight. The mechanism is almost identical +with that of fear. Brain and liver, adrenals and thyroid are the +means, but the emotion presses the button and releases the energy, +stopping all digestion and energizing all combat-muscles. The blood is +flooded with fuel and with substances which, if not used, are harmful +to the body. We were never meant to be angry without fighting. The +habit of self-control has its distinct advantages, but it is hard on +the body, which was patterned before self-control came into fashion. +The wise man, once he is aroused, lets off steam at the woodpile or on +a long, vigorous walk. He probably does not say to himself that he is +<!-- Page 49 --><a name="Page_49" id="Page_49" />a motor animal +integrated for fight and that he must get rid of +glycogen and adrenalin and thyroid secretion. He only knows that he +feels better "on the move."</p> + +<p>The wiser man does not let himself get angry in the first place unless +the situation calls for fight. However, the fight need not be a +hand-to-hand combat with one's fellow man. William James has pointed +out that there is a "moral equivalent for war," and that the energy of +this instinct may be used to reinforce other impulses and help +overcome obstacles of all sorts. A good deal of the business man's +zest, the engineer's determination, and the reformer's zeal spring +from the fight-instinct used in the right way. As James, Cannon, and +others have pointed out, the way to end war may be to employ man's +instinct of pugnacity in fighting the universal enemies of the +race—fire, flood, famine, disease, and the various social +evils—rather than let it spend its force in war between nations. Even +our sports may be offshoots of the fight-instinct, for McDougall holds +that the play-tendency has its root in the instinct of rivalry, a +modified form of pugnacity. Evidently fighting-blood is a useful +inheritance, even to-day, and rightly directed is a necessary part of +a complete and forceful personality.</p> + +<p>This, then, completes the list of self-preservative instincts, those +which are commonly called egoistic <!-- Page 50 --> +<a name="Page_50" id="Page_50" />and which have been given us for +the maintenance of our own individual personal lives. But our +endowment includes another set of impulses which are no less important +and which must be reckoned with if human conduct is to be understood.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<!-- Page 51 --><div><a name="Page_51" id="Page_51"></a></div> + +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_IV" id="CHAPTER_IV">CHAPTER IV</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we learn more about ourselves</i></p> + +<p class="heading">THE STORY OF THE INSTINCTS (Continued)</p> + +<p class="scheading">II. The Race-Preservative Instincts</p> + + +<p><b>Looking beyond Ourselves.</b> We sometimes speak of self-preservation as +though it were the only law of life, while as a matter of fact it is +but half the story. Nature has seen to it that there shall be planted +in every living creature an innate urge toward the larger life of the +race. Although the creature may never give a conscious thought to the +welfare of the race, he still bears within himself a set of instincts +which have as their end and aim, not the individual at all, but +society as a whole, and the life of generations that are to come. He +is bigger than he knows. Although he may have no notion why he feels +and acts as he does, and although he may pervert the purpose for his +own selfish end, he is continually being moved by the mighty impulse +of the race-life, an impulse which often outrivals the desire I or his +own personal existence. The craving to reproduce ourselves and the +craving to cherish and protect +<!-- Page 52 --><a name="Page_52" id="Page_52" />our young are among the most dynamic +forces in life. The two desires are so closely bound together that +they are often spoken of as one under the name of the sex-instinct, or +the family instincts. Let us look first at that part of the yearning +which urges toward perpetuating our own life in offspring.</p> + +<p><b>Watching Nature Work.</b> It is wonderful, indeed, to watch Nature in +the long process of Evolution, as she adapts her methods to the +growing complexity of the organism. With a variety and ingenuity of +means, but always with the same steady purpose, she works from the +lowest levels,—where there is no true reproduction, only +multiplication by division,—on through the beginning of reproduction +proper, where a single parent produces the offspring; then on to the +level where it takes two parents of different structure to produce a +new organism, and sex-life begins. At first Nature does not even +demand that father and mother shall come near each other. In the +water, the female of this type lays an egg, and the male, guided by +his instinct, swims to it and deposits his fertilizing fluid. In plant +life, bird and bee, attracted by wonderfully planned perfumes and +color and honey, are called in to carry the pollen from male to female +cell.</p> + +<p>But it is when we come to the highest level that we find even more +subtle ways planned to accomplish the desired end. Here we enter the +realm of individual <!-- Page 53 --><a name="Page_53" id="Page_53" />initiative, +for it is not now enough to leave to +external forces the joining of the two life-elements. In order to make +a new individual, father and mother must be drawn together, and so +there enters into the situation a personal relationship with all that +that implies. Because Nature has had to provide ways of drawing +individuals to one another, she has put into the higher types of life +the power of mutual attraction,—a power which in man, the highest of +all types, is responsible for many outgrowths that seem far removed +from the original purpose.</p> + +<p><b>The Love-Motif.</b> On the one hand, there is the persistent desire to +be attractive, which manifests itself in the subtlest ways. How many +of the yearnings and activities of human life have their roots in this +ancient and honorable desire! The love of pretty clothes,—however it +may seem to be motivated and however it may be complicated by other +motives,-draws its energy, fundamentally, from the same need that +provides the gay plumage and limpid song of the bird or the painted +wings of the butterfly.</p> + +<p>On the other hand, there is the capability of being attracted, with +all the personal relationships which spring from the power of admiring +and loving another person. The interest in others does not expend its +whole force on its primary objects,—mate and children. It flows out +into all human relationships, developing +<!-- Page 54 --><a name="Page_54" id="Page_54" />all the possibilities of +loving which mean so much in human life; the love of man for man and +woman for woman, as well as mutual love of man and woman. A force like +this, once planted, especially in the higher types of life, does not +spend all its energies in its main trunk. It sends out branches in +many directions, bearing by-products which are rich in value for all +of life.</p> + +<p>Many of our richest relationships, our best impulses, and our most +firmly fixed social habits spring from the family instincts of +reproduction and parental care. The social life of our young people, +so well calculated to bring young men and women together; all the +beauty of family life and, as we shall later see, all the broader +benevolent activities for society in general, are energized by the +same love-instincts which form so large a part of human nature.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Learning to Love</p> + +<p><b>A Four-Grade School.</b> It is impossible to watch the growth of the +love-life of a human being, to trace its development from babyhood up +to its culmination in mating and parenthood, without a sense of wonder +at the steady purpose behind it all. We used to believe that the love +for the young girl that suddenly blooms forth in the callow youth was +an entirely new affair, something suddenly planted in him as he +developed into manhood; but now we know, thanks to the uncovering +<!-- Page 55 --><a name="Page_55" id="Page_55" />of +human nature by the painstaking investigations of the psycho-analytic +school of psychologists, that the seeds of the love-life are planted, +not in puberty, but with the beginning of life itself. Looked at in +one way, all infancy and childhood are a preparation, a training of +the love-instinct which is to be ready at the proper time to find its +mate and play its part in the perpetuation of the race. Nature begins +early. As she plants in the tiny baby all the organs that shall be +needed during its lifetime, so she plants the rudiments of all the +impulses and tendencies that shall later be developed into the +full-grown instincts. There have been found to be four periods in the +love-life of the growing child, three of them preparatory steps +leading up to maturity; periods in which the main current of love is +directed respectively toward self, parents, comrades, and finally +toward lover or mate.</p> + +<p><b>Like Narcissus.</b> In the first stage, the baby's interest is in his +own body. He is getting acquainted with himself, and he soon finds +that his body contains possibilities of pleasurable sensations which +may be repeated by the proper stimulation. Besides the +hunger-satisfaction that it brings, the act of sucking is pleasurable +in itself, and so the baby begins to suck his thumb or his quilts or +his rattle. Later, this impulse to stimulate the nerves about the +mouth finds its satisfaction in kissing, and still later it plays a +definite part in the <!-- Page 56 --><a name="Page_56" id="Page_56" /> +wooing process; but at first the child is +self-sufficient and finds his pleasure entirely within himself. Other +regions of the body yield similar pleasure. We often find a tiny child +rubbing his genital organs or his thighs or taking exaggerated +pleasure in riding on someone's foot in order to stimulate these +nerves, which he has discovered at first merely by chance. When he +begins to run around, he loves to exhibit his own body, to go about +naked. None of this is naughtiness or perversion; it is only Nature's +preparation of trends that she will later need to use. The child is +normally and naturally in love with +himself.<a name="FNanchor_11" id="FNanchor_11"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_11" class="fnanchor">[11]</a> But he must not +linger too long in this stage. None of the channels which his +life-force is cutting must be dug too deep, else in later life they +will offer lines of least resistance which may, on occasion, invite +illness or perversion.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_11" id="Footnote_11"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_11"><span class="label">[11]</span> +</a> This is the stage which is technically known as +auto-eroticism or self-love.</p></div> + +<p><b>In Love with His Family.</b> Presently Nature pries the child loose from +love of himself and directs part of his interests to people outside +himself. Before he is a year old, part of his love is turned to +others. In this stage it is natural that at first his affection should +center on those who make up his home circle,—his parents and other +members of the household. Even in this early choice we see a +foreshadowing of his future need. The normal little boy is especially +fond of his <!-- Page 57 --><a name="Page_57" id="Page_57" />mother, +and the normal little girl of her father. Not all +the love goes to the parent of the opposite sex, but if the child be +normal, a noticeably larger part finds its way in that direction. +Observing parents can often see unmistakable signs of jealousy: toward +the parent of the same sex, or the brother or sister of the same sex. +The little boy who sleeps with his mother while his father is away, or +who on these occasions gets all the attention and all the petting he +craves, is naturally eager to perpetuate this state of affairs. Many a +small boy has been heard to say that he wished his father would go +away and stay all the time,—to the horror of the parents who do not +understand. All this is natural enough, but it is not to be +encouraged. The pattern of the father or the mother must not be +stamped too deep in the impressionable child-mind. Too little love and +sympathy are bad, leading to repression and a morbid turning in of the +love-force; but too much petting, too many caresses are just as bad. +Sentimental self-indulgence on the part of the parents has been +repeatedly proved to be the cause of many a later illness for the +child. As the right kind of family love and comradeship, the kind that +leads to freedom and self-dependence, is among the highest forces in +life, so the wrong kind is among the worst. Parents and their +substitutes—nurses, sisters, and brothers—are but temporary +stopping-places for the growing love, stepping-stones +<!-- Page 58 --><a name="Page_58" id="Page_58" />to later +attachments which are biologically more necessary. The small boy who +lets himself be coddled and petted too long by his adoring relatives, +who does not shake off their caresses and run away to the other boys, +is doomed to failure, and, as we shall later see, probably to +illness.<a name="FNanchor_12" id="FNanchor_12"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_12" class="fnanchor">[12]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_12" id="Footnote_12"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_12"><span class="label">[12]</span> +</a> One of the best discussions of this theme is found in +the chapter "The Only or Favorite Child," by A.A. Brill, in +<i>Psychoanalysis</i>.</p></div> + +<p>In the later infantile period, the child, besides wanting to exhibit +his own body, shows marked interest in looking at the bodies of +others, and marked curiosity on sex-questions in general. He +particularly wants to know "where babies come from." If his questions +are unfortunately met by embarrassment or laughing evasion, or by +obvious lying about the stork or the doctor or the angels, his +curiosity is only whetted, and he comes to the very natural conclusion +that all matters of sex are sinful, disgusting, and indecent, and to +be investigated only on the sly. This conception cannot be brought +into harmony with the unconscious mental processes arising from his +race-instincts nor with his instinctive sense that "whatever is is +right." The resulting conflict in some four-year-old children is +surprisingly intense. Astonished indeed would many parents be if they +knew what was going on inside the heads of their "innocent" little +children; not "bad" <!-- Page 59 --> +<a name="Page_59" id="Page_59" />things, but pathetic things which a little candor +would have avoided.</p> + +<p>Alongside the rudimentary impulses of showing and looking, there is +developed another set of trends which Nature needs to use later on, +the so-called sadistic and masochistic impulses, the desire to +dominate and master and even to inflict pain, and its opposite impulse +which takes pleasure in yielding and submitting to mastery. These +traits, harking back to the time when the male needed to capture by +force, are of course much more evident in adolescence and especially +in love-making, but have their beginning in childhood, as many a +mother of cruel children knows to her sorrow. In adolescence, when +sex-differentiation is much more marked, the dominating impulse is +stronger in the boy and the yielding impulse in the girl; but in +little children the differentiation has not yet begun.</p> + +<p><b>Gang and Chum.</b> At about four or five years the child leaves the +infantile stage of development, with its self-love and its intense +devotion to parents and their substitutes. He begins to be especially +interested in playmates of his own sex, to care more for the opinions +of the gang—or if it be a little girl, of the chum—than for those of +the parents. The life-force is leading him on to the next step in his +education, freeing him little by little from a too-hampering +attachment to his family. This does not mean that he +does <!-- Page 60 --><a name="Page_60" id="Page_60" />not love +his father and mother. It means only that some of his love is being +turned toward the rest of the world, that he may be an independent, +socially useful man.</p> + +<p>This period between infancy and puberty is known as the latency +period. All interest in sex disappears, repressed by the spontaneously +developing sense of shame and modesty and by the impact of education +and social disapproval. The child forgets that he was ever curious on +sex-matters and lets his curiosity turn into other, more acceptable +channels.</p> + +<p><b>The Mating-Time.</b> We are familiar with the changes that take place at +puberty. We laugh at the girl who, throwing off her tom-boy ways, +suddenly wants her skirts let down and her hair done up. We laugh at +the boy who suddenly leaves off being a rowdy, and turns into a +would-be dandy. We scold because this same boy and girl who have +always been so "sweet and tractable" become, almost overnight, surly +and cantankerous, restive under authority and impatient of family +restraint. We should neither laugh nor scold, if we understood. Nature +is succeeding in her purpose. She has led the young life on from self +to parents, from parents to gang or chum, and now she is trying to +lead it away from all its earlier attachments, to set it free for its +final adventure in loving. The process is painful, so painful that it +sometimes fails of accomplishment. In any case, the strain is +tremendous, needing <!-- Page 61 --><a name="Page_61" id="Page_61" />all +the wisdom and understanding which the family +has to offer. It is no easy task for any person to free himself from +the sense of dependence and protection, and the shielding love that +have always been his; to weigh anchors that are holding him to the +past and to start out on the voyage alone.</p> + +<p>At this time of change, the chemistry of the body plays an important +part in the development of the mental traits; all half-developed +tendencies are given power through the maturing of the sex-glands, +which bind them into an organization ready for their ultimate purpose. +The current is now turned on, and the machinery, which has been +furnished from the beginning, is ready for its task. After a few false +starts in the shape of "puppy love," the mature instinct, if it be +successful, seeks until from among the crowd it finds its mate. It has +graduated from the training-school and is ready for life.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Civilization's Problem</p> + +<p><b>When Nature's Plans Fall Through.</b> We have been describing the normal +course of affairs. We know that all too often the normal is not +achieved. Inner forces or outer circumstances too often conspire to +keep the young man or the young woman from the culmination toward +which everything has been moving. If the life-force cannot liberate +itself from the old family <!-- Page 62 --><a name="Page_62" id="Page_62" />grooves +to forge ahead into new channels, +or if economic demands or other conditions make postponement +necessary, then marriage is not possible. All the glandular secretions +and internal stimuli have been urging on to the final consummation, +developing physical and emotional life for an end that does not come; +or if it does come, is not sufficient to satisfy the demands of the +age-old instinct which for millions of years knew no restraint. In any +case, man finds himself, and woman herself, face to face with a +pressing problem, none the less pressing because it is in most cases +entirely unrecognized.</p> + +<p><b>Blundering Instincts.</b> The older a person is, the more fixed are his +habits. Now, an instinct is a race-habit and represents the +crystallized reactions of a past that is old. Whatever has been done +over and over again, millions of times, naturally becomes fixed, +automatic, tending to conserve itself in its old ways, to resist any +change and to act as it has always acted. This conserves energy and +works well so long as conditions remain the same. But if for any +reason there comes a change, things are likely to go wrong. By just so +far as things are different, an automatic habit becomes a handicap +instead of a help.</p> + +<p>This having to act under changed conditions is exactly the trouble +with the reproductive instinct. Under civilization, conditions have +changed but the instinct <!-- Page 63 --><a name="Page_63" id="Page_63" />has +not. It is trying to act as it always +has acted, but civilized man wills otherwise. The change that has come +is not in the physical, external environment, but in man himself and +in the social environment which he has created. There is in man an +onward urge toward new and better things. Side by side with the desire +to live as he always has lived, there is a desire to make new +adaptations which are for the advancement of the whole race-life. +Besides the natural wish to take his desires as he finds them, there +is also the wish to modify them and use them for higher and more +socially useful ends.</p> + +<p>As the race has found through long experience that monogamy is to be +preferred to promiscuous mating; that the highest interests of life +are fostered by loyalty to the institution of the family; that the +careful rearing of several children rather than the mere production of +many is in the long run to be desired; and that a single standard of +morality is practicable; so society has established for its members a +standard which is in direct opposition to the immeasurable urge of the +past. To make matters worse, there have at the same time grown up in +many communities a standard of living and an economic competition +which still further limit the size of the family and the satisfaction +of the reproductive impulse.</p> + +<p><b>The Perpetual Feud.</b> There thus arises the strategic +<!-- Page 64 --><a name="Page_64" id="Page_64" />struggle +between that which the race has found good in the past and that which +the race finds good in the present. As the older race-experience is +laid in they body and built into the very fiber of the individual, +inherited as an innate impulse, it has become an integral part of +himself, an individual need rather than a social one. On the other +hand, man has, as another innate part of his being, the desire to go +with the herd, to conform to the standards of his fellows, to be what +he has learned society wants him to be. Hence the struggle, insistent, +ever more pressing, between two sets of desires within the man +himself; the feud between the past and the present, between the +natural and the social, between the selfish and the ideal. On one +side, there is the demand for instinctive satisfaction; on the other, +for moral control; on one side the demand for pleasure; on the other, +the demands of reality.<a name="FNanchor_13" id="FNanchor_13"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_13" class="fnanchor">[13]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_13" id="Footnote_13" /> +<a href="#FNanchor_13"><span class="label">[13]</span> +</a> "All the burdens of men or society are caused by the +inadequacies in the association of primal animal emotions with those +mental powers which have been so rapidly developed in +man-kind."—Shaler quoted by Hinkle: Introduction to Jung's +<i>Psychology of the Unconscious</i>.</p></div> + +<p>Two factors intensify the conflict. In the first place, the older +habits have the head start. Compared with the almost limitless extent +of our past history, our desire for the control of the instincts is +very new indeed. It requires the long look and the right perspective +<!-- Page 65 --><a name="Page_65" id="Page_65" /> +to understand how very lately we have entered into our new conditions +and how old a habit we are trying to break. In the second place, the +larger part of the stimulus comes from within the body itself. When +studying the other instincts, we saw that the best way to control was +to refuse to stimulate when the situation was not suitable for +discharge. But with the organically aroused sex-instinct there is no +such power of choice. We may fan the flame by the thoughts we think or +the environment we seek, or we may smother the flame until it is out +of sight, but we cannot extinguish it by any act of ours. The issue +has always been too important to be left to the individual. The +stimulation comes, primarily, not by way of the mind but by way of the +body. With this instinct we cannot "stop before we begin," because +Nature has taken the matter out of our hands and begins for us.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Bulwark We Have Built</p> + +<p>With the competing forces so strong and the issues so great, it is not +to be wondered at that society has had to build up a massive bulwark +of public opinion, to establish regulations and fix penalties that are +more stringent than those imposed in any other direction. Nor is it +remarkable that in its effort to protect itself, society has sometimes +made mistakes.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 66 --><a name="Page_66" id="Page_66" />These +blunders seem to lie in two directions. Assuming that it is +nearly impossible for the male to control his instincts, and that, +after all, it does not matter so much whether he does or not, society +has blinked at license in men, and thus has fostered a demoralizing, +anti-social double standard which has broken up countless homes, has +been responsible for the spread of venereal diseases, and has been +among the greatest curses of modern civilization. At the same time +society, in its efforts to maintain its standards for woman, has +taught its children, especially its girls, that anything savoring of +the word "sexual" is sinful, disgusting, and impure. To be sure, very +many women have modified their childish views, but an astonishingly +large number conserve, even in maturity, their warped ideas about the +whole subject of sex. Many a mature woman secretly believes that she, +at least, is not guilty of harboring anything so "vulgar" as a +reproductive instinct, not realizing that if this were so, she would +be, in very truth, a freak of nature.</p> + +<p>Of course, woman is by nature as fully endowed with sex instincts as +is man. Kipling portrays the female of the species as "deadlier than +the male" in that the very framework of her constitution outlines the +one issue for which it was launched,—stanch against any attack which +might endanger the carrying on of life. Feeling the force of this +instinctive urge, she <!-- Page 67 --><a name="Page_67" id="Page_67" />braces +herself against precipitancy in response by what seems almost a negation.</p> + +<p>Just as we lean well in when riding around a corner, in order to keep +ourselves from falling out, so by an "over-compensation" for what is +unconsciously felt to be danger woman increases her feeling of safety +by setting up a taboo on the whole subject of sex. It is time that we +freed our minds from the artificial and perverted attitude toward this +dominant impulse; time to rescue the word "sex" from its implications +of grossness and sensuousness, and to recognize the instinct in its +true light as one of the necessary and holy forces of life, a force +capable of causing great damage, but also holding infinite +possibilities for good if wisely directed.</p> + +<p>Society only gets its members into trouble when, even by implication, +it attempts to deny its natural make-up, and allows little children to +grow up with the false idea that one of their strongest impulses is to +be shunned by them as a thing of shame. We cannot dam back the flood +by building a bulwark of untruth, and then expect the bulwark to hold.</p> + +<p><b>Adaptable Energy.</b> We neither have to give in to our over-insistent +desires nor to deny that they exist. Man has a power of adaptation. +Just when we seem to run up against a dead wall, to face an +irreconcilable conflict, we find a wonderful power of indirect +<!-- Page 68 --><a name="Page_68" id="Page_68" /> +expression that affords satisfaction to all the innate forces without +doing violence to the ethical standards which have proved so necessary +for the development of character.</p> + +<p>Hunger, which, like the reproductive instinct, is stimulated by the +changing chemistry of the body, can be satisfied only by achieving its +primary purpose, the taking of material food; but the creative impulse +to reproduce oneself possesses a unique ability to spiritualize itself +and expend its energy in other lines of creative endeavor. There seems +to be some sort of close connection between the especially intense +energy of the reproductive instinct and the modes of expression of the +instinct for construction; a connection which makes possible the +utilization of threatening destructive energy by directing it toward +socially valuable work. Just as we harness the mountain stream and use +its wild force to light our cities, or catch the lightning to run our +trolley cars, so we find man and woman—under the right +conditions—easily and naturally switching over the power of their +surplus sex-energy to ends which seem at first only slightly related +to its original aim, but which resemble it in that they too are +self-expressive and creative. If a person is able to express himself +in some real way, to give himself to socially needed work; if he can +reproduce himself intellectually and spiritually in artistic +production, in <!-- Page 69 --><a name="Page_69" id="Page_69" />invention, +in literature, in social betterment, he is +drawing on an age-old reservoir of creative energy, and by so doing is +relieving himself of inner tension which would otherwise seek less +beneficent ways of expression.</p> + +<p>The world knew all this intuitively for a long time before it knew it +theoretically. The novelists, who are unconsciously among the best +psychologists, have thoroughly worked the vein. The average man knows +it. "He was disappointed in love," we say, "and we thought he would go +to pieces, but now he has found himself in his work"; or, "She will go +mad if she doesn't find some one who needs her." It is only lately +that science has caught up with intuition, but now the physicians and +psychologists who have had the most intimate and first-hand +acquaintance with the human heart are recognizing, to a man, this +unique power of the love-instinct and its possibilities for creative +work of every sort.<a name="FNanchor_14" id="FNanchor_14"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_14" class="fnanchor">[14]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_14" id="Footnote_14" /> +<a href="#FNanchor_14"><span class="label">[14]</span> +</a> Among those who have shown this connection between the +love-force and creative work are Freud, Jung, Jelliffe, White, Brill, +Jones, Wright, Frink, and the late Dr. Putnam of Harvard University, +who writes: "Freud has never asserted it as his opinion and it +certainly is not mine, that this is the only root from which artistic +expression springs. On the other hand, it is probable that all +artistic productions are partly referable to this source. A close +examination of many of them would enable any one to justify the +opinion that it is a source largely drawn +upon."—<i>Human Motives</i>. p. 87.</p></div> + + +<p><b>Higher Levels.</b> Freud has called this spiritualization +<!-- Page 70 --><a name="Page_70" id="Page_70" />of natural +forces by a term borrowed from chemistry. As a solid is "sublimated" +when transformed into a gas, so a primal impulse is said to be +"sublimated" when it is diverted from its original object and made to +serve other ends. By this power of sublimation the little +exhibitionist, who loved to show himself, may become an actor; the +"cruel" boy who loved to dissect animals may become a surgeon; the +sexually curious child may turn his curiosity to other things and +become a scholar; the "born mother," if denied children of her own or +having finished with their upbringing, may take to herself the +children of the city, working for better laws and better care for +needy little ones; the man or woman whose sex-instinct is too strong +to find expression in legitimate, direct ways, may find it a valuable +resource, an increment of energy for creative work, along whatever +line his talent may lie.</p> + +<p>There is no more marvelous provision in all life than this power of +sublimation of one form of energy into another, a provision shadowing +forth almost limitless possibilities for higher adaptations and for +growth in character. As we think of the distance we have already +traveled and the endless possibilities of ever higher excursions of +the life-force, we feel like echoing Paul's words: "He who began a +good work in you will perfect it unto the end." The history +<!-- Page 71 --><a name="Page_71" id="Page_71" />of the +past holds great promise for the future.</p> + +<p><b>When Sublimation Fails.</b> But in the meantime we cannot congratulate +ourselves too heartily. Sublimation too often fails. There are too +many nervous wrecks by the way, too many weak indulgers of original +desires, too many repressed, starved lives with no outlet for their +misunderstood yearnings; and, as we shall see, too many people who, in +spite of a big lifework, fail to find satisfaction because of +unnecessary handicaps carried over from their childhood days. +"Society's great task is, therefore, the understanding of the +life-force, its manifold efforts at expression and the way of +attaining this, and to provide as free and expansive ways as possible +for the creative energy which is to work marvelous things for the +future."</p> + +<p>If "the understanding of the life force" is to be available for use, +it must be the property of the average man and woman, the fathers and +mothers of our children, the teachers and physicians who act as their +advisers and friends.<a name="FNanchor_15" id="FNanchor_15"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_15" class="fnanchor">[15]</a> This chapter +is intended to do its bit toward such a general understanding.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_15" id="Footnote_15"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_15"><span class="label">[15]</span></a> "Appropriate +educational processes might perhaps guide +this enormous impulsive energy toward the maintenance instead of the +destruction of marriage and the family. But up to the present time, +education with respect to this moral issue has commonly lacked any +such constructive method. The social standard and the individual +impulse have simply collided, and the individual has been left to +resolve the conflict, for the most part by his own resources."—G.A. +Coe: <i>Psychology of Religion</i>, p. 150.</p></div> + +<p class="scheading"><!-- Page 72 --><a name="Page_72" id="Page_72" />Parental Instinct and Tender Emotion</p> + +<p><b>Until They Can Fly.</b> Only half of Nature's need is met by the +reproductive instinct. Her carefulness in this direction would be +largely wasted without that other impulse which she has planted, the +impulse to protect the new lives until they are old enough to fend for +themselves. The higher the type of life and the greater the future +demands, the longer is the period of preparation and consequent period +of parental care. This fact, coupled with man's power for lasting +relationships through the organization of permanent sentiments, has +made the, bond between parent and child an enduring one. Needless to +say, this relationship is among the most beautiful on earth, the +source of an incalculable amount of joy and gain. However, as we have +already suggested, there lurks here, as in every beneficent force, a +danger. If parents forget what they are for, and try to foster a more +than ordinary tie, they make themselves a menace to those whom they +most love. Any exaggeration is abnormal. If the childhood bond is +over-strong, or the childhood dependence too long cultivated, then the +relationship has overstepped its purpose, and, as we shall later see, +has laid the foundation for a future neurosis.</p> + +<p><b>Mothering the World.</b> Probably no instinct has so many ways of +indirect expression as this mothering <!-- Page 73 --> +<a name="Page_73" id="Page_73" />impulse of protection. Aroused +by the cry of a child in distress, or by the thought of the weakness, +or need, or ill-treatment of any defenseless creature, this +mother-father impulse is at the root of altruism, gratitude, love, +pity, benevolence, and all unselfish actions.</p> + +<p>There is still a great difference of opinion as to how man's spiritual +nature came into being; still discussion as to whether it developed +out of crude beginnings as the rest of his physical and mental +endowment has developed, or whether it was added from the outside as +something entirely new. Be that as it may, the fact remains that man +has as an innate part of his being an altruistic tendency, an +unselfish care for the welfare of others, a relationship to society as +a whole,—a relationship which is the only foundation of health and +happiness and which brings sure disaster if ignored. The egoistic +tendencies are only a part of human nature. Part of us is naturally +socially minded, unselfish, spiritual, capable of responding to the +call to lose our lives in order that others may find theirs.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p>Civilized man as he is to-day is a product of the past and can be +understood only as that past is understood. The conflicts with which +he is confronted are the direct outcome of the evolutional history of +the race and of its attempt to adapt its primitive instincts to +present-day ideals.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 74 --><a name="Page_74" id="Page_74" />Character +is what we do with our instincts. According to Freud, all +of a man's traits are the result of his unchanged original impulses, +or of his reactions against those impulses, or of his sublimation of +them. In other words, there are three things we may do with our +instincts. We may follow our primal desires, we may deny their +existence, or we may use them for ends which are in harmony with our +lives as we want them to be. As the first course leads to degeneracy, +the second to nervous illness, and the third to happy usefulness, it +is obviously important to learn the way of sublimation. Sometimes this +is accomplished unconsciously by the life-force, but sometimes +sublimation fails, and is reestablished only when the conscious mind +gains an understanding of the great forces of life. This method of +reeducation of the personality as a means of treatment in nervousness +is called psycho-therapy.</p> + +<p><b>Religion's Contribution.</b> If it be asked why, amid all this +discussion of instincts and motives we have made no mention of that +great energizer religion, we answer that we have by no means forgotten +it, but that we have been dealing solely with those primary tendencies +out of which all of the compound emotions are made. Man has been +described as instinctively and incurably religious, but there seems no +doubt that religion is a compound reaction, made up of +love,—<!-- Page 75 --><a name="Page_75" id="Page_75" />sympathetic +response to the parental love of God,—fear, +negative self-feeling, and positive self-feeling in the shape of +aspiration for the desired ideal of character; all woven into several +compound emotions such as awe, gratitude, and reverence.</p> + +<p>It goes almost without saying that religion, if it be vital, is one of +the greatest sources of moral energy and spiritual dynamic, and that +it is and always has been one of the greatest aids to sublimation that +man has found. A force like the Christian religion, which sets the +highest ideal of character and makes man want to live up to it, and +which at the same time says, "You can. Here is strength to help you"; +which unifies life and fills it with purpose; which furnishes the +highest love-object and turns the thought outward to the good of +mankind—such a force could hardly fail to be a dynamic factor in the +effort toward sublimation. This book, however, deals primarily with +those cases for which religion has had, to call science to her aid in +order to find the cause of failure, to flood the whole subject with +light, and to help cut the cords which, binding us to the past, make +it impossible to utilize the great resources that are at hand for all +the children of men.</p> + +<p><b>Where We Keep Our Instincts.</b> It must have been impossible to read +through these two chapters on instinct without feeling that, after +all, we are not very well acquainted with ourselves. The more we look +<!-- Page 76 --><a name="Page_76" id="Page_76" />into human +nature, the more evident it becomes that there is much in +each one of us of which we are only dimly aware. It is now time for us +to look a little deeper,—to find where we keep these instinctive +tendencies with which it is possible to live so intimately without +even suspecting their existence. We shall find that they occupy a +realm of their own, and that this realm, while quite out of sight, is +yet open to exploration.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<!-- Page 77 --><div><a name="Page_77" id="Page_77"></a></div> + +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_V" id="CHAPTER_V">CHAPTER V</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we look below the surface and discover a veritable +wonderland</i></p> + +<p class="heading">THE SUBCONSCIOUS MIND</p> + +<p class="scheading">Strangers to Ourselves</p> + + +<p><b>Hidden Strings.</b> A collie dog lies on the hearthrug. A small boy with +mischievous intent ties a fine thread to a bone, hides himself behind +a chair, and pulls the bone slowly across the floor. The dog is thrown +into a fit of terror because he does not know about the hidden string.</p> + +<p>A Chinese in the early days of San Francisco stands spell-bound at the +sight of a cable car. "No pushee. No pullee. Go allee samee like +hellee!" He does not know about the hidden string.</p> + +<p>A woman of refinement and culture thinks a thought that horrifies her +sensitive soul. It is entirely out of keeping with her character as +she knows it. In her misunderstanding she considers it wicked and +thrusts it from her, wondering how it ever could have been hers. She +does not know about the hidden string.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 78 --><a name="Page_78" id="Page_78" />In the last +two chapters we thought together about some of these +strings, examining the fibers of which they are made and learning in +what directions they pull. We found them to be more powerful than we +should have supposed, more insistent and less visible. We found that +instinctive desire is the string, the cable that energizes our every +act, but that our desires are neither single nor simple, and are but +rarely on the surface. Many of us live with them a long time, feeling +the tug, but not recognizing the string.</p> + +<p><b>There's a Reason.</b> We take our thoughts and feelings and actions for +granted, without stopping very often to wonder where they come from. +But there is always a reason. When the law of cause and effect reaches +the doorsill of our minds, it does not stop short to give way to the +law of chance. We wake up in the morning with a certain thought on +top. We say it "just happens." But nothing ever just happens. No +thought that ever comes into our heads has been without its +history,—its ancestors and its determining causes. But what about +dreams? They, at least, you say, have no connections, no past and no +future, only a weird, fantastic present. Strange to say, dreams have +been found to be as closely related to our real selves, as interwoven +with the warp and woof of our lives as are any of our waking thoughts. +Even dreams have a reason.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 79 --><a name="Page_79" id="Page_79" />We find ourselves +holding certain beliefs and prejudices, interested +in certain things and indifferent to others, liking some foods, some +colors and disliking others. Search our minds as we will, we find no +clue to many of these inner trends. Why?</p> + +<p>The answer is simple. The cause is hidden below the surface. If we try +to explain ourselves on the basis of the open-to-inspection part of +our minds, we must come to the conclusion that we are queer creatures +indeed. Only by assuming that there is more to us than we know, can we +find any rational basis for the way we think and feel and act.</p> + +<p><b>A Real Mind.</b> We learn of our internal machinery by what it does. We +must infer a part of our minds which introspection does not reveal, a +mind within the mind, able to work for us even while we are unaware of +its existence. This inner mind is usually known as the subconscious, +the mind under the level of consciousness.<a name="FNanchor_16" id="FNanchor_16"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_16" class="fnanchor">[16]</a> We forget a name, but +we know that it will come to us if we think about something else. +Presently, out of somewhere, there flashes the word we want. Where was +it in the meanwhile, and what <!-- Page 80 --><a name="Page_80" id="Page_80" />hunted +it out from among all our other memories and sent it up into consciousness? +The something which did that must be capable of conserving memories, of recognizing +the right one and of communicating it,—surely a real mind.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_16" id="Footnote_16"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_16"><span class="label">[16]</span> +</a> Writers of the psycho-analytic school use the word +"unconscious" to denote the lower layers of this region, and +"fore-conscious" to denote its upper layers. Morton Prince uses the +terms "unconscious" and "conscious" to denote the different strata. +As there is still a good deal of confusion in the use of terms, it has +seemed to us simpler to use throughout only the general term +"subconscious."</p></div> + +<p>One evening my collaborator fumbled unsuccessfully for the name of a +certain well-known journalist and educator. It was on the tip of her +tongue, but it simply would not come, not even the initial letter. In +a whimsical mood she said to herself just as she went to sleep, +"Little subconscious mind, you find that name to-night." In the middle +of the night she awoke, saying, "Williams—Talcott Williams." The +subconscious, which has charge of her memories, had been at work while +she slept.</p> + +<p>The history of literature abounds in stories of under-the-surface +work. The man of genius usually waits until the mood is on, until the +muse speaks; then all his lifeless material is lighted by new +radiance. He feels that some one outside himself is dictating. Often +he merely holds the pen while the finished work pours itself out +spontaneously as if from a higher source.</p> + +<p>But it is not only the man of genius who makes use of these unseen +powers. He may have readier access to his subconscious than the rest +of us, but he has no monopoly. The most matter-of-fact man often says +that he will "sleep over" a knotty problem. He puts +<!-- Page 81 --><a name="Page_81" id="Page_81" />it into his mind +and then goes about his business, or goes to sleep while this unseen +judge weighs and balances, collects related facts, looks first at one +side of the question and then at the other, and finally sends up into +consciousness a decision full of conviction, a decision that has been +formulated so far from the focus of attention that it seems to be +something altogether new, a veritable inspiration.</p> + +<p>We must infer the subconscious from what it does. Things +happen,—there must be a cause. Some of the things that happen +presuppose imagination, reason, intelligence, will, emotion, desire, +all the elements of mind. We cannot see this mind, but we can see its +products. To deny the subconscious is to deny the artist while looking +at his picture, to disbelieve in the poet while reading his poem, and +to doubt the existence of the explosive while listening to the report. +The subconscious is an artist, a poet, and an explosive by turns. If +we deny its existence, a good portion of man's doings are +unintelligible. If we admit it, many of his actions and his +afflictions which have seemed absurd stand out in a new light as +purposeful efforts with a real and adequate cause.</p> + +<p><b>The Submerged Nine Tenths.</b> The more deeply psychologists and +physicians have studied into these things, the more certainly have +they been forced to the conclusion that the conscious mind of man, the +part that <!-- Page 82 --><a name="Page_82" id="Page_82" />he can +explore at will, is by far the smaller part of his +personality. Since this is to some people a rather startling +proposition, we can do no better than quote the following statement +from White on the relation of consciousness to the rest of the psychic life:</p> + +<div class="blockquot"><p>Consciousness includes only that of which we are <i>aware</i>, while + outside of this somewhat restricted area there lies a much wider + area in which lie the deeper motives for conduct, and which not + only operates to control conduct, but also dictates what may and + what may not become conscious. Stanley Hall has very forcibly put + the matter by using the illustration of the iceberg. Only + one-tenth of the iceberg is visible above water; nine-tenths is + beneath the surface. It may appear in a given instance that the + iceberg is being carried along by the prevailing winds and + surface currents, but if we keep our eyes open we shall sooner or + later see a berg going in the face of the wind, and, so, + apparently putting to naught all the laws of aerodynamics. We can + understand this only when we come to realize that much the + greater portion of the berg is beneath the surface and that it is + moving in response to invisible forces addressed against this + submerged portion.</p> + +<p> Consciousness only arises late in the course of evolution and + only in connection with adjustments that are relatively complex. + When the same or similar conditions in the environment are + repeatedly presented to the organism so that it is called upon to + react in a similar and almost +<!-- Page 83 --><a name="Page_83" id="Page_83" /> + identical way each time, there tends to be organized a mechanism + of reaction which becomes more and more automatic and is + accompanied by a state of mind of less and less + awareness.<a name="FNanchor_17" id="FNanchor_17"></a> + <a href="#Footnote_17" class="fnanchor">[17]</a></p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_17" id="Footnote_17"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_17"><span class="label">[17]</span> +</a> White: <i>Mechanisms of Character Formation</i>.</p></div> + +<p>It is easy to see the economy of this arrangement which provides +ready-made patterns of reaction for habitual situations and leaves +consciousness free for new decisions. Since an automatic action, +traveling along well-worn brain paths, consumes little energy and +causes the minimum of fatigue, the plan not only frees consciousness +from a confusing number of details, but also works for the +conservation of energy. While consciousness is busy lighting up the +special problems of the moment, the vast mass of life's demands are +taken care of by the subconscious, which constitutes the bulk of the +mind. "Properly speaking, the unconscious is the real +psyche."<a name="FNanchor_18" id="FNanchor_18"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_18" class="fnanchor">[18]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_18" id="Footnote_18"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_18"><span class="label">[18]</span> +</a> Freud: <i>Interpretation of Dreams</i>, p. 486.</p></div> + +<p><b>The Heart of Psychology.</b> In the face of all this, it is not to be +wondered at that the problem of the subconscious has been called not +one problem of psychology but the problem. It cannot be denied that +the discoveries which have already been made as to its activities have +been of immense practical importance in the understanding of normal +conduct and in the treatment of the psycho-neuroses.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 84 --><a name="Page_84" id="Page_84" />If some +of the methods—such as hypnosis, automatic writing, and +interpretation of dreams—which are used to investigate its activities +seem to savor of the charlatan and the mountebank, it is because they +have occasionally been appropriated by the ignorant and the +unscrupulous. Their real setting is the psychological laboratory and +the physician's office. In the hands of men like Sigmund Freud, Boris +Sidis, and Morton Prince, they are as scientific as the apparatus of +any other laboratory and their findings are as susceptible of proof. +We may, then, go forward with the conviction that we are walking on +solid ground and that the main paths, at least, will turn into beaten +highways.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Ancestral Memories</p> + +<p><b>Race-Memories.</b> An individual as he stands at any moment is the +product of his past,—the past which he has inherited and the past +which he has lived. In other words, he is a bundle of memories +accumulated through the experience of the race, and through his own +experience as a person. Some of these memories are conscious, and +these he calls his, while others fail to reach consciousness and are +not recognized as part of his assets.</p> + +<p>The instincts form the starting-point of mind, conscious and +subconscious, and are the foundation <!-- Page 85 --> +<a name="Page_85" id="Page_85" />upon which the rest is built. +They often show themselves as part of our conscious lives, but their +roots are laid deep in the subconscious from which they can never be +eradicated. This deepest-laid instinctive layer of the subconscious is +little subject to change. It represents the earlier adjustments of the +race, crystallized into habit. It takes no account of the differences +between the present and the past. It knows no culture, no reason, no +lately acquired prudence. It is all energy and can only wish, or urge +toward action. But since only those race-memories became instincts +which had proved needful to the race in the long run, they are on the +whole beneficent forces, working for the good of the race and the good +of the individual, if he learns how to handle them aright and to adapt +them to present conditions.</p> + +<p>This instinctive urge toward action arouses in the individual an +organic response that is felt as a tension or craving and is mainly +dependent upon its own chemical constitution at the moment. Hunger is +the sensation caused by the little muscular contractions in the +stomach when the body is low in its food supply. Sudden fright is felt +as an all-gone sensation "at the pit of the stomach." What really +happens is a tightening up of the circular muscles of the +blood-vessels lying in the network of the solar plexus, and a spasm of +the muscles of the digestive tract. The hungry stomach <!-- Page 86 --> +<a name="Page_86" id="Page_86" />impels to +action until satisfied; the physical discomfort in fear impels toward +measures of safety. The apparatus that is made use of by the +subconscious in carrying out this instinctive urge is called the +autonomic nervous system.<a name="FNanchor_19" id="FNanchor_19"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_19" class="fnanchor">[19]</a> It regulates all the functions of +living, not only under the stress of emotion, but during every moment +of waking or sleeping.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_19" id="Footnote_19"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_19"><span class="label">[19]</span> +</a> Kempf: "The Tonus of Automatic Segments as a Cause of +Abnormal Behavior," <i>Journal of Nervous and Mental Diseases</i>, January, +1921.</p></div> + +<p><b>A Capable Manager.</b> The conscious mind could not possibly send +messages to the numerous glands that fit the body for action, nor +attend to all the delicate adjustments that enter into the process. +The conscious mind in most of us does not even know of the existence +of the organs and secretions involved, but something sends the +messages and it is something that has a remarkable likeness to mind as +we usually think of mind,—something which takes advantage of the past +and gages means to an end with a nicety that excites our wonder.</p> + +<p><b>Take no Anxious Thought.</b> We take food into our stomachs and forget +about it, if we are wise; and this subconscious overseer who through +millions of years of experience has learned how to digest food does +the rest. As with digestion, so with our heart-action; we lie down at +night fairly sure that there will be no break in the regular rhythm of +its beat. The subconscious +<!-- Page 87 --><a name="Page_87" id="Page_87" />overseer is +"on the job" and he never +rests. No matter how hard we sleep, he never lets us forget to take a +breath; and if we trust him, he is very likely to wake us up at the +appointed time in the morning. Also, if we trust him, he carries us +off to sleep as though we were babies. Has he not had long practice in +the days before insomnia was invented?</p> + +<p><b>First Aid to the Injured.</b> In times of infection or injury, this +subconscious manager is better than any doctor. The doctors say with +truth that they only assist nature. If the infection is internal, +antitoxins are produced within the body. If the injury is external, +like a cut, the messages fly, and white blood-corpuscles are marshaled +to take care of poisons and build up the tissue. If the injury is of +the kind that needs rest, the subconscious doctor knows it. He +therefore causes pain and rigidity, in order to induce us to hold the +injured part still until it is restored.</p> + +<p>Crile reminds us of a fact that is often noticed by surgeons. If +patients under ether are handled roughly, especially in the intestinal +region, respiration quickens and there are tremors and even convulsive +efforts which interfere with the surgeon's work. The conscious mind +cannot feel. It is asleep. But the subconscious mind, whose business +it is to protect the body, is trying to get away from injury. The body +uses up as much energy as though it had run for miles, +<!-- Page 88 --><a name="Page_88" id="Page_88" />and when the +patient wakes up, we say that he is suffering from shock. The +subconscious mind which is not affected by ether, has been exhausting +itself in a vain attempt to get the body away from harm.</p> + +<p><b>A Tireless Servant.</b> When the conscious mind undertakes a job, it is +always more or less subject to fatigue. But the subconscious after its +long practice seems never to tire. We say that its activities have +become automatic. With all its inherited skill, the subconscious, if +left to itself, can be depended upon to run the bodily machinery +without effort and without hitch. The only things that can interfere +with its work are the wrong kind of emotions and the wrong kind of +suggestions from the conscious mind. Barring these, it goes its way +like a trusty servant, looking after details and leaving its master's +mind free for other things. Having been "in the family" for +generations, it knows its business and resents any interference with +its duties or any infringement of its rights.</p> + +<p>No man, then, comes into this world without inheritance: he receives +from his ancestors two goodly sets of heirlooms, the instincts and the +mechanism which carries on bodily functions. This is the capital with +which man starts life; but immediately he begins increasing this +capital, adding memories from his own experience to the accumulated +race-records.</p> + +<p class="scheading"><!-- Page 89 --> +<a name="Page_89" id="Page_89" />Personal Memories</p> + +<p>No more startling secret has been unearthed by science than the +discovery of the length and minuteness of our memories. No matter how +much one may think he has forgotten, the tablets of his mind are +closely written with records of infinitesimal experiences, shadowy +sensations, old happenings which the conscious self has lost entirely +and would scarcely recognize as its own. Many of these brain records, +or neurograms, as Prince calls them, are never aroused from their +dormant conditions. But others, aroused by emotion or association of +ideas, may after years of inactivity, come forth again either as +conscious memories or as subconscious forces, or even as physiological +memories,—bodily repetitions of the pains, palpitations, and tremors +of old emotional experiences.</p> + +<p><b>Irresistible Childhood.</b> An experience that is forgotten is not +necessarily lost. Although the first few years of childhood are lost +to conscious memory, these years outweigh all others in their +influence on character. The Jesuit priest was right when he said, +"Give me a child until he is six years old, and he will be a Catholic +all his life." As Frink has so ably shown, the determining factors +that enter into any adult choice, such as the choice of the Catholic +or the Protestant faith, are in a large measure made up of +subconscious memories from early childhood, forgotten memories of +<!-- Page 90 --><a name="Page_90" id="Page_90" />Sunday-school +and church, of lessons at home or passages in +books,—experiences which no voluntary effort could recall, but which +still live unrecognized in our mature judgments and beliefs. Naturally +we do not acknowledge these subconscious motives. We like to believe +that all our decisions are based on reason, and so we invent plausible +arguments for our attitudes and our actions, arguments which we +ourselves implicitly believe. This process of substituting a plausible +reason for a subconscious one is known as rationalization, a process +which every one of us engages in many times a day.</p> + +<p>It is indeed true that the child is father to the man. Those first +impressionable years, when we believed implicitly whatever any one +told us and when through ignorance we reacted emotionally to ordinary +experiences, are molding us still, making us the men and women we are +to-day, coloring with childish ideas many of the attitudes of our +supposedly reasoning life. Bergson says:</p> + +<div class="blockquot"><p>The unconscious is our historical past. In reality the past is + preserved automatically. In its entirety probably it follows us + at every instant; all that we have felt, thought and willed from + our earliest infancy is there, leaning over the present which is + about to join it, pressing against the portals of consciousness + that would fain leave it outside.</p></div> + +<p><!-- Page 91 --><a name="Page_91" id="Page_91" /><b>Spontaneous +Outbursts.</b> "How do we know all this?" some one says. +"What is the evidence for these sweeping statements? If we cannot +remember, how can we discover these strange memories that are so +powerful but so elusive? If they are below the level of consciousness, +are they not, in the very nature of the case, forever hidden from +view, in the sphere of the occult rather than that of science?"</p> + +<p>The answer to these questions is determined by one important fact; the +line between the conscious and subconscious minds does not always +remain in the same place; the "threshold of consciousness" is +sometimes displaced, automatically allowing these buried memories to +come to the surface. In sleep and delirium, in trance and +hallucination, in hysteria and intoxication, the tables are turned; +the restraining hand of the conscious mind is loosened and the +submerged self comes forth with all its ancient memories.</p> + +<p>It is a common experience to have a patient in delirium repeat +long-forgotten verses or descriptions of events that the "real man" +has lost entirely. The renowned servant-girl, quoted by Hudson, who in +delirium recited passage after passage of Hebrew, Latin, and Greek, +which she had heard her one-time master repeat in his study, is +typical of many such instances.<a name="FNanchor_20" id="FNanchor_20"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_20" class="fnanchor">[20]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_20" id="Footnote_20"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_20"><span class="label">[20]</span></a> Hudson: +<i>The Law of Psychic Phenomena</i>, p. 44. Quoted +from <i>Coleridge's Biographia Literaria</i>, Vol. I, p. 117 (edit. 1847).</p></div> + +<p><!-- Page 92 --><a name="Page_92" id="Page_92" />A young girl +of nineteen, a patient of mine, lapsed for several weeks +into a dissociated state in which she forgot all the memories and +ideas of her adult life, and returned to the period of her childhood. +She used to say that she saw things inside her head and would +accurately describe events that took place before she was two years of +age,—scenes which she had completely forgotten in her normal life. +One day when I asked her to tell me what she was seeing, she began to +talk about "little sister" (herself) and "little brother." "Little +sister and brother were the two little folks that lived with their +mother and their daddy and they were playing on the sand-pile. You +know there was only one sand-pile, not like all the ones they have +down here (at the seaside), and they had a bucket that they would put +sand in and they would dump it out again and they would make nice +things, you know; they would play with their little dog Ponto and he +was white with black and brown spots on him. Little brother had white +hair and he was bigger than little sister and he had a little waist +with ruffles down the front and around the collar and a black coat +that came down to his knees and it had two little white bands around +it. Some of the waists he wore had blue specks and some had red and +black specks in it.</p> + +<p>"Little sister had yellow curls and she had a blue coat with jiggly +streaks of white in it, and she had a <!-- Page 93 --> +<a name="Page_93" id="Page_93" />little white bonnet that was +crocheted, and she had little blue mittens on that were tied to a +string that went around her neck and down the other arm. It got pretty +cold where they lived. Little sister and little brother would go out +to the pile of leaves and jump on them and bounce and they would +crackle. The leaves came down from the trees all of a sudden when they +got tired, and they were different colors, brown and red. Little +sister could walk then but she could not walk one other time before +then; she could stand up by holding to a chair, but she could not go +herself. One morning Big Tom said 'Run to Daddy' and she went to her +daddy, and after that she always walked; they were glad and she was +glad. She walked all day long. Big Tom was a man who used to help +Daddy and little sister always liked him. He was a nice man."</p> + +<p>The mother verified this scene of the first walking, saying that it +had occurred on her own wedding-anniversary when the child was +twenty-three months old.</p> + +<p>One night I heard the same patient talk in her sleep in the slow and +hesitating manner of a child reading phonetically from a printed page. +I soon recognized the words as those of a poem of Tagore's, called "My +Prayer," and remembered that a magazine containing the poem had been +lying on the bed during the day. When she had finished I wakened her, +saying, "Now tell me what you have been dreaming." +She answered <!-- Page 94 --><a name="Page_94" id="Page_94" />in +her childish way, "I think I do not dream." She went to sleep +immediately and again repeated the poem, word for word, without a +single mistake. Again I awakened her with the words, "Now tell me what +you have been dreaming." And again she answered, "I think I do not +dream." I said: "But yes; don't you remember you were just saying, +'When the time comes for me to go'?" (the last line of the poem). "Oh, +yes," she said, "I was seeing it, and I think I'll not go to sleep +again. It tires me so to see it."</p> + +<p>While she was awake she had no recollection of having seen the poem +and was indeed in her dissociated state quite incapable of +understanding its meaning. Asleep, she saw every word as plainly as if +the page had been before her eyes.</p> + +<p>The distorted pictures of dreams are always made of the material which +past experiences have furnished and which have in many cases been +dropped out of consciousness for years only to rise out of their long +oblivion when the conscious mind has been put to sleep.</p> + +<p><b>Unearthing Old Experiences.</b> However, psychology does not have to +wait for buried memories to come forth of their own free will. It has +a number of successful ways of summoning them from their hiding-place +and helping them across the line into consciousness. In the hands of +skilled investigators and therapeutists, hypnosis, hypnoidization, +automatic writing, <!-- Page 95 --><a name="Page_95" id="Page_95" />crystal-gazing, +abstraction, free association, word-association, and interpretation of dreams +have all been repeatedly successful in bringing to light memories which apparently +have been for many years completely blotted out of mind. As we become +better acquainted with these technical devices we shall find that +there are four kinds of experiences whose records are carefully stored +away in our minds. Some were always so far from the center of our +attention that we could swear they never had been ours; others, +although once present in consciousness, were so trivial and +unimportant that it seems ridiculous to suppose them conserved; others +never came into our waking minds at all and entered our lives only in +special states, such as sleep or delirium or dreams. All these we +should expect to forget; the astonishing thing is that they ever were +conserved. But there is a fourth class that is different. It is made +up of experiences that were so vital, so emotional, so closely woven +into the fiber of our being that it seems impossible that they ever +could be forgotten. Let us look at a few examples of records of all +these four kinds of experiences, examples chosen from hundreds of +their kind as illustrations of the all-embracing character of buried +memories.<a name="FNanchor_21" id="FNanchor_21"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_21" class="fnanchor">[21]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_21" id="Footnote_21"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_21"><span class="label">[21]</span> +</a> For further examples see Prince, <i>The Unconscious</i>; +Prince, <i>The Dissociation of a Personality</i>, and Hudson, <i>The Law of +Psychic Phenomena</i>.</p></div> + +<p><!-- Page 96 --><a name="Page_96" id="Page_96" /><b>Out of the +Corners of Our Eyes.</b> In the first place, we are much +more observing than we imagine. We may be so interested in our own +thoughts that details of our environment are entirely lost on the +conscious mind, but the subconscious has its eyes open, and its ears. +People in hypnosis have been known to repeat verbatim whole passages +from newspapers which they had never consciously read. While they were +busy with one column, their wide-awake subconscious was devouring the +next one, and remembering it. Prince relates the story of a young +woman who unconsciously "took in" the details of a friend's +appearance:</p> + +<div class="blockquot"><p>I asked B.C.A. (without warning and after having covered her + eyes) to describe the dress of a friend who was present and with + whom she had been conversing perhaps some twenty minutes. She was + unable to do so beyond saying that he wore dark clothes. I then + found that I myself was unable to give a more detailed + description of his dress, although we had lunched and been + together about two hours. B.C.A. was then asked to write a + description automatically. Her hand wrote as follows (she was + unaware that her hand was writing):</p> + +<p> "He has on a dark greenish gray suit, a stripe in it—little + rough stripe; black bow cravat; shirt with three little stripes + in it; black laced shoes; false teeth; one finger gone; three + buttons on his coat."</p> + +<p> The written description was absolutely correct. The stripes in + the coat were almost invisible. I had not noticed + <!-- Page 97 --><a name="Page_97" id="Page_97" /> + his teeth or the loss of a finger and we had to count the buttons + to make sure of their number owing to their partial concealment + by the folds of the unbuttoned coat. The shoe-strings I am sure + under the conditions would have escaped nearly every one's + notice.<a name="FNanchor_22" id="FNanchor_22"></a> + <a href="#Footnote_22" class="fnanchor">[22]</a></p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_22" id="Footnote_22"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_22"><span class="label">[22]</span> +</a> Prince: <i>The Unconscious</i>, p. 53.</p></div> + +<p>Automatic writing, the method used to uncover this subconscious +perception, is a favorite method with some investigators and is often +used by Morton Prince. The hand writes without the direction of the +personal consciousness and usually without the person's being aware +that it is writing. A dissociated person does this very easily; other +people can cultivate the ability, and perhaps most of us approach it +when we are at the telephone, busily writing or drawing remarkable +pictures while the rest of us is engaged in conversation.</p> + +<p>The present epidemic of the Ouija board shows how many persons there +are who are able to switch off the conscious mind and let the +subconscious control the muscles that are used in writing. The fact +that the writer has no understanding of what he is doing and believes +himself directed by some outside power, in no way interferes with the +subconscious phenomenon.</p> + +<p><b>Everyday Doings.</b> Besides perceptions which were originally so far +from the focus of attention that the conscious mind never caught them +at all, there are the little experiences of everyday life, fleeting +thoughts and <!-- Page 98 --><a name="Page_98" id="Page_98" />impressions +which occupy us for a minute and then +disappear. Every experience is a dynamic fact and no matter how +trivial the experience may be or how completely forgotten, it still +exists as a part of the personality.</p> + +<p>An amusing example of the everyday kind of forgotten experience +occurred during the writing of this chapter. I wrote a sentence which +pleased me very well. This is the sentence: "In the esthetic processes +of evolution they [man's desires] have sunk below the surface as soon +as formed, and have been covered over by an elastic and snug-fitting +consciousness as the skin covers in the tissues and organs of the +body." After showing this passage to my collaborator and remarking +that this figure had never been used before, I was partly chagrined +and partly amused to have her bring me the following sentence from +White and Jelliffe: "Consciousness covered over and obscured the inner +organs of the psyche just as the skin hides the inner organs of the +body from vision." My originality had vanished and I was close to +plagiarism. Indeed, if a history of plagiarism could be written, it +would probably abound in just such stories. I had read the article +containing this sentence only once, about three years before, and had +never quoted it or consciously thought of it. It had lain buried for +three years, only to come forth as an original idea of my +<!-- Page 99 --><a name="Page_99" id="Page_99" />own. Who +knows how many times we all do just this thing without catching +ourselves in the trick?</p> + +<p><b>Back-Door Memories.</b> There are other kinds of memories which hide in +the subconscious, memories of experiences which have not come in by +the front door, but have entered the mind during special states, such +as sleep, delirium, intoxication, or hypnosis. What is known as +post-hypnotic suggestion is the functioning of a suggestion received +during hypnosis and emerging later as an impulse without being +recognized as a memory. A man in a hypnotic state is told that at five +o'clock he will take off his clothes and go to bed, without +remembering that such a suggestion has been given him. He awakens with +no recollection of the suggestion, but at five o'clock he suddenly +feels impelled to go to bed, even though his unreasonable desire puts +him into a highly embarrassing position. The suggestion, to be thus +effective, must have been conserved somewhere in his mind outside of +consciousness.</p> + +<p>Suggestions that enter the mind during the normal sleep are also +recorded,—a fact that carries a warning to people who are in the +habit of talking of all sorts of matters while in the room with +sleeping children. I have sometimes suggested to sleeping patients +that on waking they will remember and tell me the cause of their +symptoms. The following example shows not only the conservation of +impressions gained in sleep, <!-- Page 100 --><a name="Page_100" id="Page_100" /> +but also the sway of forgotten ideas of +childhood, still strong in mature years. This young woman, a trained +nurse, with many marked symptoms of hysteria, had been asked casually +to bring a book from the Public Library. She cried out in +consternation, "Oh, no, I am afraid!" After a good deal of urging she +finally brought the book, although at the cost of considerable effort. +Later, while she was taking a nap, I said to her, "You will not +remember that I have talked to you. You will stay asleep while I am +talking and while you are asleep there will come to your mind the +reasons why you are afraid to go to the Public Library. When you +waken, you will tell me all about it." Upon awakening, she said: "Oh, +do you know, I can tell you why I have always been afraid to go to the +Public Library. While I was in Parochial School, Father —— used to +come in and tell us children to use the books out of the school +library and never to go to the Public Library." I questioned her +concerning her idea of the reason for such an injunction and what she +thought was in the books which she was told not to read. She +hesitatingly stated that it was her idea, even in childhood, that the +books dealt with topics concerning the tabooed subject of the birth of +children and kindred matters.</p> + +<p><b>Smoldering Volcanoes.</b> Let us now consider those emotional +experiences which seem far too compelling to be forgotten, but which +may live within us for years <!-- Page 101 --><a name="Page_101" id="Page_101" /> +without giving any evidence of their +existence. Memories like these are apt to be anything but a dead past.</p> + +<p>Many of my own patients have uncovered emotional memories through +simply talking out to me whatever came into their minds, laying aside +their critical faculty and letting their minds wander on into whatever +paths association led them. This is known as the free-association +method, and simple as it seems, is one of the most effective in +uncovering memories which have been forgotten for years. One of my +patients, a refined, highly educated woman of middle age, had suffered +for two years with almost constant nausea. One day, after a long talk, +with no suggestion on my part, only an occasional, "What does that +remind you of?" she told with great emotion an experience which she +had had at eighteen years of age, in which she had for a moment been +sexually attracted to a boy friend, but had recoiled as soon as she +realized where her impulse was leading her. She had been so horrified +at the idea of her degradation, so nauseated at what she considered +her sin, that she had put it out of her mind, denied that such a +thought had ever been hers, repressed the desire into the +subconscious, where it had continued to function unsatisfied, +unassimilated with her mature judgments. Her nausea was the symbol of +a moral disgust. Physical nausea she was willing to acknowledge, but +not this other thing. Upon reciting this old experience, +<!-- Page 102 --><a name="Page_102" id="Page_102" />with every +sign of the original shame, she cried: "Oh, Doctor! why did you bring +this up? I had forgotten it. I haven't thought of it in thirty years." +I reminded her that I couldn't bring it up,—I had never known +anything about it. With the emotional incoming of this memory and the +saner attitude toward it which the mature woman's mind was able to +take, the nausea disappeared for good. This case is typical of the +psycho-neuroses and we shall have occasion to refer to it again. The +present emphasis is on the fact that an emotional memory may be buried +for many years while it still retains the power of reappearing in more +or less disguised manifestation.</p> + +<p><b>Repressed Memories.</b> If we ask how so burning a memory could escape +from the consciousness of a grown woman, we are driven to the +conclusion that this forgetting can be the result of no mere quiet +fading away, but that there must have been some active force at work +which kept the memory from coming into awareness. It was not lost. It +was not passive. Out of sight was not out of mind. There must have +been a reason for its expulsion from the personal consciousness. In +fact, we find that there is a reason. We find that whenever a vital +emotional experience disappears from view, it is because it is too +painful to be endured in consciousness. Nor is it ever the pain of an +impersonal experience or even the thought of what some <!-- Page 103 --> +<a name="Page_103" id="Page_103" />one else has +done to us that drives a memory out of mind. As a matter of fact, we +never expel a memory except when it bears directly on ourselves and on +our own opinion of ourselves. We can stand almost anything else, but +we cannot stand an idea that does not fit in with our ideal for +ourselves. This is not the pious ideal that we should like to live up +to and that we hope to attain some day, not the ideal that we think we +ought to have—like never speaking ill of others or never being +selfish—but the secret picture that each of us has, locked away +within him, the specifications of ourselves reduced to their lowest +terms, below which we cannot go. Energized by the instinct of positive +self-feeling, and organized with the moral sentiments which we have +acquired from education and the ideals of society, especially those +acquired in early childhood, this ideal of ourselves becomes +incorporated into our conscience and is an absolute necessity for our +happiness.</p> + +<p>We have found that when two emotions clash, one drives out the other. +So in this case, the woman's positive self-feeling of self-respect, +combined with disgust, drove from the field that other emotion of the +reproductive instinct which was trying to get expression. Speaking +technically, one repressed the other. The woman said to herself, "No, +I never could have had such a thought," and promptly forgot it. +Needless to say, this kind of handling did not kill the +<!-- Page 104 --><a name="Page_104" id="Page_104" />impulse. +Buried in the depths of her soul, it continued to live like a live +coal, until in later years, fanned by the wind of some new experience, +it burst into flame.</p> + +<p>In this case the wish had originally flashed into awareness for an +instant, but very often the impulse never gets into consciousness at +all. The upper layers of the subconscious, where the acquired ideals +live, automatically work to keep down any desires which are thought to +be out of keeping with the person as he knows himself. He then would +emphatically deny that such desires had ever had any place in his +life.</p> + +<p>Freud has called this repressing force the psychic censor. To get into +consciousness, any idea from the subconscious must be able to pass +this censor. This force seems to be a combination of the +self-regarding and herd-instincts, which dispute with the instinct for +reproduction the right to "the common path" for expression.</p> + +<p>A considerable part of any person's subconscious is made up of +memories, wishes, impulses, which are repressed in this way. Of course +any instinctive desire may be repressed, but it is easy to understand +why the most frequently denied impulse, the instinct of reproduction, +against whose urgency society has cultivated so strong a feeling, +should be repressed more frequently than any +other.<a name="FNanchor_23" id="FNanchor_23"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_23" class="fnanchor">[23]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_23" id="Footnote_23"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_23"><span class="label">[23]</span> +</a> See foot-note, p. 145, Chap. VII.</p></div> + +<p><!-- Page 105 --><a name="Page_105" id="Page_105" /> +<b>Past and Present.</b> It matters not, then, in what state experiences +come to us, whether in sleep or delirium, intoxication or hypnosis, or +in the normal waking condition. They are conserved and may exert great +influence on our normal lives. It matters not whether the experiences +be full of meaning and emotion or whether they be so slight as to pass +unnoticed, they are conserved. It matters not whether these +experiences be mere sense-impressions, or inner thoughts, whether they +be unacknowledged hopes or fears, undesirable moods and unworthy +desires or fine aspirations and lofty ideals. They are conserved and +they may at a later day rise up to bless or to curse us long after we +had thought them buried in the past. The present is the product of the +past. It is the past plus an element of choice which keeps us from +settling down in the despair of fatalism and enables us to do +something toward making the present that is, a help and not a +stumbling-block to the present that is to be.</p> + +<p class="scheading">Some Habits of the Subconscious</p> + +<p><b>The Association of Ideas.</b> It is only by something akin to poetic +license that we can speak of lower and higher strata of mind. When we +carry over the language of material things into the less easily +pictured psychic realm, it is sometimes well to remind ourselves that +figures of speech, if taken too literally, are more +<!-- Page 106 --><a name="Page_106" id="Page_106" />misleading than +illuminating. When we speak of the deep-laid instinctive lower levels +of mind and the higher acquired levels, we must not imagine that these +strata are really laid in neat, mutually exclusive layers, one on top +of the other in the chambers of the mind. Nor must we imagine the +mental elements of instinct, idea, and memory as jumbled together in +chaotic confusion, or in scattered isolated units. As a matter of +fact, the best word to picture the inside of our minds is the word +"group." We do not know just how ideas and instincts can group +themselves together, but we do know that by some arrangement of brain +paths and nerve-connections, the laws of association of ideas and of +habit take our mental experiences and organize them into more or less +permanent systems. Instinctive emotions tend to organize themselves +around ideas to form sentiments; ideas or sentiments, which through +repetition or emotion are associated together, tend to stay together +in groups or complexes which act as a whole; complexes which pertain +to the same interests tend to bind themselves into larger systems or +constellations, forming moods, or sides to one's character. It is not +highly important to differentiate in every case a sentiment from a +complex, or a complex from a constellation, especially as many writers +use "complex" as the generic term for all sorts of groups; but a +general understanding of the much-used word "complex" is +<!-- Page 107 --><a name="Page_107" id="Page_107" />necessary +for a comprehension of modern literature on psychology, psychotherapy +or general education.</p> + +<p>"<b>What Is a Complex</b>?" Reduced to its lowest terms, a complex is a +group. It may be simply a group of associated movements, like lacing +one's shoes or knitting; it may be a group of movements and ideas, +like typewriting or piano-playing, which through repetition have +become automatic or subconscious; it may be merely a group of ideas, +such as the days of the week, the alphabet or the multiplication +table. In all these types it is repetition working through the law of +habit that ties the ideas and movements together into an organic +whole. Usually, however, the word complex is reserved for psychic +elements that are bound together by emotion. In this sense, a complex +is an emotional thought-habit. Frink's definition, which is one of the +simplest, recognizes only this emotional type: "A complex is a system +of connected ideas, having a strong emotional tone, and displaying a +tendency to produce or influence conscious thought and action in a definite and +predetermined direction."<a name="FNanchor_24" id="FNanchor_24"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_24" class="fnanchor">[24]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_24" id="Footnote_24"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_24"><span class="label">[24]</span> +</a> Frink: "What Is a Complex?" <i>Journal American Medical +Assoc</i>., Vol. LXII, No. 12, Mar. 21, 1914.</p></div> + +<p>Emotion and repetition are the great welders of complexes. Emotion is +the strongest cement in the world. A single emotional experience +suffices to bind together ideas that were originally as far apart as +the poles.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 108 --><a name="Page_108" id="Page_108" />Sometimes +a complex includes not only ideas, movements, and emotions, +but physiological disturbances and sensations. Some people cannot go +aboard a stationary ship without vomiting, nor see a rose, even though +it prove to be a wax one, without the sneezing and watery eyes of +hay-fever. This is what is known as a "conditioned reflex." Past +associations plus fear have so welded together idea and bodily +manifestation that one follows the other as a matter of course, long +after the real cause is removed. In such ways innumerable nervous +symptoms arise. The same laws which form healthy complexes, and, +indeed, which make all education possible, may thus be responsible for +the unhealthy mal-adaptive association-habits which lie back of a +neurosis. Fortunately, a knowledge of this fact furnishes the clue to +the re-education that brings recovery.</p> + +<p>A complex may be either conscious or unconscious, but as it usually +happens that either all or part of its elements are below the surface, +the word is oftenest used to mean those buried systems of the +subconscious mind that influence thought or behavior without +themselves being open to scrutiny. It is these buried complexes, +memory groups, gathered through the years of experience, that +determine action in uniform and easily prophesied directions. Every +individual has a definite complex about religion, about politics, +about patriotism, <!-- Page 109 --><a name="Page_109" id="Page_109" />about +business, and it is the sum of these buried +complexes which makes up his total personality.</p> + +<p><b>Displacement.</b> Association or grouping is, then, an intrinsic power +of mind; but as all life seems to be built on opposites—light and +darkness, heat and cold, love and hate—so mind, which is capable of +association, is capable also of displacement or the splitting apart of +elements which belong together. There is such a thing as the simple +breaking up of complexes, when education or experience or neglect +separate ideas and emotions which had been previously welded together; +but displacement is another matter. Here there is still a path between +idea and emotion; they still belong to the same complex, but the +connection is lost sight of. The impulse or emotion attaches itself to +another substitute idea which is related to the first but which is +more acceptable to the personality. Sometimes the original idea is +forgotten; repressed, or dissociated into the subconscious, as in +anxiety neurosis; and sometimes it is merely shorn of its emotional +interest and remembered as an unrelated or insignificant idea, as in +compulsion neurosis.</p> + +<p><b>Transference.</b> Another kind of displacement which seems hard to +believe possible until it is repeatedly encountered in intelligent +human beings is the process called transference, by which everybody at +some time or other acts toward the people he meets, not according +<!-- Page 110 --><a name="Page_110" id="Page_110" />to +rational standards but according to old unconscious attitudes toward +other people. Each of us carries, within, subconscious pictures of the +people who surrounded us when we were children; and now when we meet a +new person we are likely unconsciously to say to ourselves—not, "This +person has eyebrows like my mother, or a voice like my nurse," or, +"This person bosses me around as my father used to do," but, "This is +my mother, this is my nurse, this is my father." Whereupon we may +proceed to act toward that person very much as we did toward the +original person in childhood.</p> + +<p>Transference is subconsciously identifying one person with another and +behaving toward the one as if he were that other. Analysis has +discovered that many a man's hostile attitude toward the state or +religion or authority in general, is nothing more than this kind of +displacement of his childhood's attitude toward authority in the +person of his perhaps too-domineering father. Many a woman has married +a husband, not for what he was in himself, but because she +unconsciously identified him with her childish image of her father.</p> + +<p>Students of human nature have always recognized the kind of +displacement which transfers the sense of guilt from some major act or +attitude to a minor one which is more easily faced, just as <i>Lady +Macbeth</i> felt <!-- Page 111 --><a name="Page_111" id="Page_111" />that +by washing her hands she might free herself from +her deeper stain. This is a frequent mechanism in the +psychoneuroses—not that neurotics are likely to have committed any +great crime, but that they feel subconsciously that some of their +wishes or thoughts are wicked.</p> + +<p><b>The Phenomena of Dissociation.</b> When an idea or a complex, a +perception or a memory is either temporarily or permanently shoved out +of consciousness into the subconscious, it is said to be dissociated. +When we are asleep, the part of us that is usually conscious is +dissociated and the submerged part takes the stage. When we forget our +surroundings in concentration or absent-mindedness, a part of us is +dissociated and our friends say that we are "not all there," or as +popular slang has it, "Nobody home." When a mood or system of +complexes drives out all other moods, one becomes "a different +person." But if this normal dissociation is carried a step farther, we +may lose the power to put ourselves together again, and then we may +truly be said to be dissociated. Almost any part of us is subject to +this kind of apparent loss. In neurasthenia the happy, healthy +complexes which have hitherto dominated our lives may be split off and +left lying dormant in the subconscious; or the power of will or +concentration may seem to be gone. In hysteria we may seem to lose the +ability to see or feel or walk, or we <!-- Page 112 --> +<a name="Page_112" id="Page_112" />may lose for the time all +recollection of certain past events, or of whole periods of our lives, +or of everything but one system of ideas which monopolizes the field +of attention. Sometimes great systems of memories, instincts, and +complexes are alternately shifted in and out of gear, leaving first +one kind of person on top and then +another.<a name="FNanchor_25" id="FNanchor_25"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_25" class="fnanchor">[25]</a> Stevenson's <i>Dr. +Jekyll</i> and <i>Mr. Hyde</i> is not so fantastic a character as he seems. +Any one who doubts the ability of the mind to split itself up into two +or more distinct personalities, entertaining totally different +conceptions of life, disliking each other, playing tricks on each +other, writing notes to each other, and carrying on a perpetual feud +as each tries to get the upper hand, should read Morton Prince's +"Dissociation of a Personality," a fascinating account of his famous +case, Miss Beauchamp.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_25" id="Footnote_25"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_25"><span class="label">[25]</span> +</a> When a memory or system of memories is suddenly lost +from consciousness the person is said to be suffering from amnesia or +pathological loss of memory.</p></div> + +<p><b>Internal Warfare.</b> Conflict, often accentuated by shock or fatigue, +represses or drives down certain ideas, perceptions, wishes, memories, +or complexes into the subconscious, where they remain, sometimes +dormant and passive but often dynamic, emotional, carrying on an +over-excited, automatic activity, freed from the control of reason and +the modifying influence of other ideas, and able to cause almost any +kind of disturbance. So long as there is team-work between the +<!-- Page 113 --><a name="Page_113" id="Page_113" />various +parts of our personality we are able to act as a unit; but +just as soon as we break up into factions with no communication +between the warring camps, so soon do we become quite incapable of +coördination or adjustment, like a nation torn by civil war. Many of +the seemingly fantastic and bizarre mental phenomena of which a human +being is capable are the result of this kind of disintegration.</p> + +<p>However, nature has a remarkable power for righting herself, and it is +only under an accumulation of unfortunate circumstances that there +appears a neurosis, which is nothing more than a functioning of +certain parts of the personality with all the rest dissociated. We +shall later inquire more fully into the causes that lead up to such a +result and shall find that the mechanisms involved are these processes +of organization and disorganization by which mind is wont to group +together or separate the various elements within its borders.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p>Gathering up our impressions, we find a number of outstanding +qualities which we may summarize in the following way:</p> + +<p>The Subconscious is:</p> + +<p class="center"><i>1 Vast yet Explorable</i></p> + +<p>The fraction that could accurately show the relation <!-- Page 114 --> +<a name="Page_114" id="Page_114" />of the conscious +to the unconscious part of ourselves would have such a small numerator +and such a huge denominator that we might well wonder where +consciousness came in at all.<a name="FNanchor_26" id="FNanchor_26"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_26" class="fnanchor">[26]</a> Some one has likened the +subconscious to the great far-reaching depths of the Mammoth Cave, and +consciousness to the tiny, flickering lamp which we carry to light our +way in the darkness. However, ever the subconscious mind is becoming +explorable, and it may be that science is giving the tiny lamp the +revealing power of a great searchlight.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_26" id="Footnote_26"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_26"><span class="label">[26]</span> +</a> "The entire active life of the individual may be +represented by a fraction, the numerator of which is any particular +moment, the denominator is the rich inheritance of the +past."—Jelliffe: "The Technique of Psychoanalysis," +<i>Psychoanalytic Review,</i> Vol. III, No. 2, p. 164.</p></div> + +<p class="center"><i>2 Ancient yet Modern</i></p> + +<p>The lowest layers of the subconscious, represented by the instincts, +are as old as life itself, with their lineage reaching back in direct +and unbroken line to the first living things on the ooze of the ocean +floor. The higher strata are more modern, full, and accurate records +of our own lifetime, beginning with our first cry and ending with +to-day's thoughts.</p> + +<p class="center"><i>3 Primitive yet Refined</i></p> + +<p>The lowest level, representing the past of the race, is primitive like +a savage, and infantile, like a child; it is instinctive, unalterable, +and universal; it knows no restraint, no culture, and no prudence. The +higher <!-- Page 115 --><a name="Page_115" id="Page_115" />level, +the storehouse of individual experience, bears the +marks of acquired ideals, of cultivated refinement, and represents +among other things the precepts and prudence of civilized society.</p> + + +<p class="center"><i>4 Emotional yet Intellectual</i></p> + +<p>Our records of the past are not dead archives, but living +forces—persistent, urging, dynamic and emotional. They give meaning +to new experiences, color our judgments, shape our beliefs, determine +our interests, and, if wrongly handled, make their way into +consciousness as neurotic symptoms.</p> + +<p>However, the subconscious is not all emotion. It is a mind capable of +elaborate thought, able to calculate, to scheme, to answer doubts, to +solve problems, to fabricate the purposeful, fantastic allegories of +dreams and to create from mere knowledge the inspired works of genius.</p> + +<p>But the subconscious has one great limitation, it cannot reason +inductively. Given a premise, this mind can reason as unerringly as +the most skilful logician; that is, it can reason deductively, but it +cannot arrive at a general conclusion from a number of particular +facts. However, except for inductive reasoning and awareness, the +subconscious seems to possess all the attributes of conscious mind and +is in fact an intellectual force to be reckoned with.</p> + +<p class="center"><!-- Page 116 --><a name="Page_116" id="Page_116" /> +<i>5 Organized yet Disorganizable</i></p> + +<p>The subconscious mind is a highly organized institution, but like all +such institutions it is liable to disorganization when rent by +internal dissension. Ordinarily it keeps its ideas and emotions, its +complexes and moods in fairly accurate order, but when upset by +emotional warfare, it gets its records confused and falls into a +chaotic state which makes regular business impossible.</p> + + +<p class="center"><i>6 Masterful yet Obedient</i></p> + +<p>The subconscious, which is master of the body, is in normal life the +servant of consciousness. One of its outstanding qualities is +suggestibility. Since it cannot reason from particulars to a general +conclusion it takes any statement given it by consciousness, believes +it implicitly and acts accordingly.</p> + +<p>The pilot wheel of the ship is, after all, the conscious mind, +insignificant in size when compared with the great mass of the vessel, +but all-powerful in its ability to direct the course of the voyage.</p> + +<p>Nervous persons are people who are too much under the sway of the +subconscious; so, too, are some geniuses, who narrowly escape a +neurosis by finding a more useful outlet for their subconscious +energies. While the poet, the inventor, and the neurotic are likely to +be too largely controlled by the subconscious, the average man is to a +greater extent ruled by the conscious +<!-- Page 117 --><a name="Page_117" id="Page_117" />mind; and the highest type of +genius is the man whose conscious and subconscious minds work together +in perfect harmony, each up to its full power.</p> + +<p>If, as many believe, the next great strides of science are to be in +this direction, it may pay some of us to be pioneers in learning how +to make use of these undeveloped riches of memory, organization, and +surplus energy. The subconscious, which can on occasion behave like a +very devil within us, is, when rightly used, our greatest asset, the +source of powers whose appearance in the occasional individual has +been considered almost superhuman, but which prove to be +characteristically human, the common inheritance of the race of man.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<!-- Page 118 --><div><a name="Page_118" id="Page_118"></a></div> +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_VI" id="CHAPTER_VI">CHAPTER VI</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we learn why it pays to be cheerful</i></p> + +<p class="heading">BODY AND MIND</p> + +<p class="scheading">The Missing Link</p> + + +<p><b>Ancient Knowledge.</b> People have always known that mind in some +strange way carries its moods over into the body. The writer of the +Book of Proverbs tells us, from that far-off day, that "A merry heart +doeth good like a medicine, but a broken spirit drieth the bones." +Jesus in His healing ministry always emphasized the place of faith in +the cure of the body. "Thy faith hath made thee whole," is a frequent +word on His lips, and ever since His day people have been +rediscovering the truth that faith, even in the absence of a worthy +object, does often make whole. Faith in the doctor, the medicine, the +charm, the mineral waters, the shrine, and in the good God, has +brought health to many thousands of sufferers. People have always +reckoned on this bodily result from a mental state. They have +intuitively known better than to tell a sick person that he is looking +worse, but they have not always <!-- Page 119 --> +<a name="Page_119" id="Page_119" />known why. They have known that a fit +of anger is apt to bring on a headache, but they have not stopped to +look for the reason, or if they have, they have often gotten +themselves into a tangle. This is because there has always been, until +recently, a missing link. Now the link has been found. After the last +chapter, it will not be hard to understand that this connecting link, +this go-between of body and mind, is nothing else than the +subconscious mind. When we remember that it has the double power of +knowing our thoughts and of controlling our bodies, it is not hard to +see how an idea can translate itself into a pain, nor to realize with +new vividness the truth of the statement that healthy mental states +make for health, and unhealthy mental states for illness.</p> + +<p><b>Suggestion and Emotion.</b> There are still many gaps in our knowledge +of the ways of the subconscious, but investigation has thrown a good +deal of light on the problem. Two of the principles already discussed +are sufficient to explain most of the phenomena. These are, first, +that the subconscious is amenable to control by suggestion, and +secondly, that it is greatly influenced by emotion. Tracing back the +principles behind any example of the power of mind over body, one +finds at the root of the matter either a suggestion or an emotion, or +both. If, then, the stimulating and depressing effects of mental +states are to be understood, the first <!-- Page 120 --> +<a name="Page_120" id="Page_120" />Step must be a fuller +understanding of the laws governing suggestion and emotion.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Contagion of Ideas</p> + +<p>One of the most important points about the subconscious mind is its +openness to suggestion. It likes to believe what it is told and to act +accordingly. The conscious mind, too,—proud seat of reason though it +may be,—shares this habit of accepting ideas without demanding too +much proof of their truth. Even at his best, man is extremely +susceptible to the contagion of ideas. Most of us are even less immune +to this mental contagion than we are to colds or influenza; for ideas +are catching. They are such subtle, insinuating things that they creep +into our minds without our knowing it at all; and once there, they are +as powerful as most germs.</p> + +<p>Let a person faint in a crowded room, and a good per cent. of the +women present will begin to fan themselves. The room has suddenly +become insufferably close. After we have read half a hundred times +that Ivory soap floats, a fair proportion of the population is likely +to be seized with desire for a soap that floats,—not because they +have any good reason for doing so, but simply because the suggestion +has "taken." As for the harbingers of spring, they are neither the +birds nor the wild flowers, but the blooming windows <!-- Page 121 --><a name="Page_121" id="Page_121" />of the +milliners, which successfully suggest in wintry February that summer +is coming, and that felt and fur are out of season. It is evident that +all advertising is suggestion.</p> + +<p>The training of children, also, if it is done in the right way, is +largely a matter of suggestion. The little child who falls down and +bumps his head is very likely to cry if met with a sympathetic show of +concern, while the same child will often take his mishaps as a joke if +his elders meet them with a laugh or a diverting remark. Unlucky is +the child whose mother does not know, either consciously or +intuitively, that example and contagion are more powerful—and more +pleasant—than command and prohibition.</p> + +<p><b>Everything Suggestive.</b> Human beings are constantly communicating, +one to another. Sometimes they "get over" an idea by means of words, +but often they do it in more subtle ways,—by the elevation of an +eyelid, the gesture of a hand, composure of manner in a crisis, or a +laugh in a delicate situation. A suggestion is merely an idea passed +from one person to another, an idea that is accepted with conviction +and acted upon, even though there may be no logic, no reason, no proof +of its truth. It is an influence that takes hold of the mind and works +itself out to fulfilment, quite apart from its worth or +reasonableness. Of course, logical persuasion and argument have their +place <!-- Page 122 --><a name="Page_122" id="Page_122" />in +the communication of ideas; an idea may be conveyed by other +ways than suggestion. But while suggestion is not everything, it is +equally true that there is suggestion in everything. The doctor may +give a patient a very rational explanation of his case, but the +doubtful shake of the head or the encouraging look of his eye is quite +likely to color the patient's general impression. The eyes of our +subconscious are always open, and they are constantly getting +impressions, subtle suggestions that are implied rather than +expressed.</p> + +<p><b>Abnormal Suggestibility.</b> While everybody is suggestible, nervous +people are abnormally so. It may be, as McDougall suggests, that they +have so large an amount of submission or negative self-feeling in +their make-up that they believe anything, just because some one else +says it is true. Sometimes it is lack of knowledge that makes us +gullible, and at other times the cause of our suggestibility is +failure to use the knowledge that we have. Sometimes our ideas are +locked away in air-tight compartments with no interaction between +them. The psychologists tell us that suggestion is greatly favored by +a narrowing of the attention, a "contraction of the field of +consciousness," a dissociation of other ideas through concentration. +This all simply means that we forget to let our common sense bring to +bear counter ideas that might challenge a false one; or that worry—a +veritable "spasm of the <!-- Page 123 --><a name="Page_123" id="Page_123" /> +attention"—has fixed upon an idea to the +exclusion of all others; or that through fatigue or the dissociation +of sleep or hypnosis or hysteria, our reasoning powers have been +locked out and for the time being are unable to act.</p> + +<p>It was through experiments on hypnotized subjects that scientists +first learned of the suggestibility of the subconscious mind. In +hypnosis a person can be made to believe almost anything and to do +almost anything compatible with the safety and the moral sense of the +individual. The instinct of self-preservation will not allow the most +deeply hypnotized person to do anything dangerous to himself; and the +moral complexes, laid in the subconscious, never permit a person to +perform in earnest an act of which the waking moral sense would +disapprove. Within these limits, a person in the dissociated hypnotic +state can be made to accept almost any suggestion. We found in the +last chapter how open to suggestion is a person in normal sleep. Of +the dissociation of hysteria we shall have occasion to speak in later +chapters. Although all these special states heighten suggestibility, +we must not forget how susceptible each of us is in his normal waking +state.</p> + +<p><b>Living Its Faith.</b> All this gathers meaning only when we realize that +ideas are dynamic. They always tend to work themselves out to +fulfilment. The subconscious no sooner gets a conviction than it tries +<!-- Page 124 --><a name="Page_124" id="Page_124" />to act it out. +Of course it can succeed only up to a certain limit. +If it believes the stomach to have cancer, it cannot make cancer, but +it can make the stomach misbehave. One of my patients, on hearing of a +case of brain-tumor immediately imagined this to be her trouble, and +developed a pain in her head. She could not manufacture a tumor, but +she could manufacture what she believed to be the symptoms.</p> + +<p>There was another patient who was supposed to have brain-tumor. This +young woman seemed to have lost almost entirely the power to keep her +equilibrium in walking. Her center of gravity was never over her feet, +but away out in space, so that she was continually banging from one +side of the room to the other, only saving herself from injury by +catching at the wall or the furniture with her hands. Several +physicians who had been interested in the case had found the symptoms +strongly suggestive of brain-tumor. There were, however, certain +unmistakable earmarks of hysteria, such as childlike bland +indifference to the awkwardness of the gait which was a grotesque +caricature of several brain and spinal-cord diseases, with no accurate +picture of any single one. This was evidently a case, not of actual +loss of power but a dissociation of the memory-picture of walking. The +patient was a trained nurse and knew in a general way the symptoms of +brain-tumor. When the suggestion <!-- Page 125 --> +<a name="Page_125" id="Page_125" />of brain-tumor had fixed itself in +her mind she was able subconsciously to manufacture what she believed +to be the symptoms of that disease.</p> + +<p>By injecting a keen sense of disapprobation and skepticism into the +hitherto placidly accepted state of disability, by flashing a mirror +on the physical and moral attitudes which she was assuming, I was able +to rob the pathological complex of its (altogether unconscious) +pleasurable feeling-tone, and to restore to its former strength and +poise a personality of exceptional native worth and beauty. After a +few weeks at my house she was able to walk like a normal person and +went back to her work, for good.</p> + +<p>We have already learned enough about the inner self to see in a faint +way how it works out its ideas. Since the subconscious mind runs the +bodily machinery, since it regulates digestion, the building up of +tissue, circulation, respiration, glandular secretion, muscular tonus, +and every other process pertaining to nutrition and growth, it is not +difficult to see how an idea about any of these matters can work +itself out into a fact. A thought can furnish the mental machinery +needed to fulfil the thought. Some one catches the suggestion: +"Concentration is hard on the brain. It soon brings on brain-fag and +headache." Not knowing facts to the contrary, the suggestible mind +accepts the proposition. Then one day, after a little concentration, +<!-- Page 126 --><a name="Page_126" id="Page_126" />the idea +begins to work. Whereupon the autonomic nervous system +tightens up the blood-vessels that regulate the local blood supply, +too much blood stays in the head, and lo, it aches! The next time, the +suggestion comes with greater force, and soon the habit is +formed,—all the result of an idea. It is a good thing to remember +that constant thought about any part of the body never fails to send +an over-supply of blood to that part; of course that means congestion +and pain.</p> + +<p><b>Hands Off</b>! By sending messages directly to an organ through the +nerve-centers or by changing circulation, the subconscious director of +our bodies can make any part of us misbehave in a number of ways. All +it needs is a suggestion of an interfering thought about an organ. As +we have insisted before, the subconscious cannot stand interference. +Sadler well says: "Man can live at the equator or exist at the poles. +He can eat almost anything and everything, but he cannot long stand +self-contemplation. The human mind can accomplish wonders in the way +of work, but it is soon wrecked when directed into the channels of +worry."<a name="FNanchor_27" id="FNanchor_27"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_27" class="fnanchor">[27]</a> In other +words, hands off!—or rather, minds off! Don't +get ideas that make you think about your body. The surest way to +disarrange any function is to think about it. It is a stout heart that +will not change its beat with a frequent finger on the pulse, +<!-- Page 127 --><a name="Page_127" id="Page_127" />and a +hearty stomach that will not "act up" under attention. "Judicious +neglect" is a good motto for most occasions. Take no anxious thought +if you would be well. Know enough about your body to counteract false +suggestions; fulfil the common-sense laws of hygiene,—eight hours in +bed, plenty of exercise and fresh air, and three square meals a day. +Then forget all about it. "A mental representation is already a +sensation,"<a name="FNanchor_28" id="FNanchor_28"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_28" class="fnanchor">[28]</a> and we +have enough legitimate sensations without manufacturing others.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_27" id="Footnote_27"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_27"><span class="label">[27]</span> +</a> Sadler: <i>Physiology of Faith and Fear</i>.</p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_28" id="Footnote_28"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_28"><span class="label">[28]</span> +</a> DuBois: <i>Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders</i>.</p></div> + +<p><b>From Real Life.</b> Startling indeed are the tricks that we can play on +ourselves by disregarding these laws. A patient who was unnecessarily +concerned about his stomach once came to me in great alarm, exhibiting +a distinct, well-defined swelling about the size of a match-box in the +region of his stomach. I looked at it, laughed, and told him to forget +it. Whereupon it promptly disappeared. The first segment of the rectus +muscle had tied itself up into a knot, under the stimulus of anxious +attention.</p> + +<p>Another patient appeared at my door one day saying, "Look here!" +Examination showed that her abdomen was swollen to the size of more +than a six-months pregnancy. As it happened, this woman had a friend +who a short time before had developed a pseudo, or hysterical +pregnancy which continued for several months. My patient, accepting +the suggestion, was <!-- Page 128 --><a name="Page_128" id="Page_128" /> +prepared to imitate her. I gave her a punch or +two and told her to go and dress for luncheon. In the afternoon she +had returned to her normal size.</p> + +<p>Another woman, suffering from chronic constipation, was firmly +convinced that her bowels could not move without a cathartic, which I +refused to give. However, I did give her some strychnine pills, +carefully explaining that they were not for her intestines and that +they would have no effect there. She did not believe me, and promptly +began to have an evacuation every day. It seems that sometimes two +wrong ideas are equal to a right one.</p> + +<p>If doctors fully realized the power of suggestion, they would be more +careful than they sometimes are about suggesting symptoms by the +questions they ask their patients.</p> + +<p>A patient of mine with locomotor-ataxia suffered from the usual train +of symptoms incident to that disease. It turned out, however, that +many of the symptoms had been suggested by the questions of former +physicians who had asked him whether he had certain symptoms and +certain disabilities. The patient had answered in the negative and +then promptly developed the suggested symptoms. When I told him what +had happened, these false symptoms disappeared leaving only those +which had a real physical foundation.</p> + +<p>Another patient, a young girl, complained of a definite +<!-- Page 129 --><a name="Page_129" id="Page_129" />localized +pain in her arm, and told me that she was suffering from angina +pectoris. As we do not expect to find this disease in a young person, +I asked her where she got such an idea. "Dr. —— told me so last +May." "Did you feel the pain in this same place before that time?" I +asked. She thought a minute and then answered: "Why no, I had a pain +around my heart but I did not notice it in my arm until after that +consultation." The wise physician lets his patients describe their own +symptoms without suggesting others by the implication of his +questions.</p> + +<p><b>Autosuggestion.</b> Of course we must remember that an idea cannot +always work itself out immediately. Conditions are not always ripe. It +often lies fallow a long time, buried in the subconscious, only to +come up again as an autosuggestion, a suggestion from the self to the +self. If some one tells us that nervous insomnia is disastrous, and we +believe it, we shall probably store up the idea until the next time +that chance conditions keep us awake. Then the autosuggestion "bobs +up," common sense is side-tracked, we toss and worry—and of course +stay awake. An autosuggestion often repeated becomes the strongest of +suggestions, successfully opposing most outside ideas that would +counteract it,—reason enough for seeing to it that our +autosuggestions are of the healthful variety.</p> + +<p>At the base of every psycho-neurosis is an unhealthful +<!-- Page 130 --><a name="Page_130" id="Page_130" />suggestion. +This is never the ultimate cause. There are other forces at work. But +the suggestion is the material out of which those other forces weave +the neurosis. Suggestibility is one of the earmarks of nervousness. A +sensible and sturdy spirit, stable enough to maintain its equilibrium, +is a fairly good antidote to attack. "As a man thinketh in his heart, +so is he."</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Why Feelings Count</p> + +<p><b>The Emotions Again.</b> It seems impossible to discuss any psychological +principle without finally coming back to the subject of emotions. It +truly seems that all roads lead to the instincts and to the emotions +which drive them. And so, as we follow the trail of suggestion, we +suddenly turn a corner and find ourselves back at our +starting-point—the emotional life. Like all other ideas, suggestions +get tied up with emotions to form complexes, of which the +driving-power is the emotion.</p> + +<p>If we look into our emotional life, we find, besides the true +emotions, with which we have become familiar in Chapter III, a great +number of feelings or feeling-tones which color either pleasurably or +painfully our emotions and our ideas. On the one hand there are +pleasure, joy, exaltation, courage, cheer, confidence, satisfaction; +and on the other, pain, sorrow, depression, apprehension, gloom, +distrust, and dissatisfaction. <!-- Page 131 --> +<a name="Page_131" id="Page_131" />Every complex which is laid away in +our subconscious is tinted, either slightly or intensely, with its +specific feeling-tone.</p> + +<p><b>Emotions—Tonic and Poisonous.</b> All this is most important because of +one vital fact; joyful emotions invigorate, and sorrowful emotions +depress; pleasurable emotions stimulate, and painful emotions burden; +satisfying emotions revitalize, and unsatisfying emotions sap the +strength. In other words, our bodies are made for courage, confidence, +and cheer. Any other atmosphere puts them out of their element, +handicapped by abnormal conditions for which they were never +fashioned. We were written in a major key, and when we try to change +over into minor tones we get sadly out of tune.</p> + +<p>There is another factor; painful emotions make us fall to pieces, +while pleasant emotions bind us together. We can see why this is so +when we remember that powerful emotions like fear and anger tend to +dissociate all but themselves, to split up the mind into separate +parts and to force out of consciousness everything but their own +impulse. Morton Prince in his elaborate studies of the cases of +multiple personality, Miss Beauchamp and B.C.A., found repeatedly that +he had only to hypnotize the patient and replace painful, depressing +complexes by healthy, happy ones to change her from a weak, worn-out +person, complaining of <!-- Page 132 --><a name="Page_132" id="Page_132" />fatigue, +insomnia, and innumerable aches and pains, into a vigorous woman, +for the time being completely well. On this point he says:</p> + +<div class="blockquot"><p>Exalting emotions have an intense synthesizing effect, while + depressing emotions have a disintegrating effect. With the + inrushing of depressive memories or ideas ... there is suddenly + developed a condition of fatigue, ill-being and disintegration, + followed after waking by a return or accentuation of all the + neurasthenic symptoms. If on the other hand, exalting ideas and + memories are introduced and brought into the limelight of + attention, there is almost a magical reversal of processes. The + patient feels strong and energetic, the neurasthenic symptoms + disappear and he exhibits a capacity for sustained effort. He + becomes re-vitalized, so to speak.<a name="FNanchor_29" id="FNanchor_29"></a> + <a href="#Footnote_29" class="fnanchor">[29]</a></p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_29" id="Footnote_29"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_29"><span class="label">[29]</span> +</a> Prince: <i>Psycho-therapeutics</i>, Chap. I.</p></div> + +<p>In cases like this the needed strength and energy are not lost; they +are merely side-tracked, but the person feels as weak as though he +were physically ill.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Bodily Response to Emotional States</p> + +<p><b>Secretions.</b> Let us look more carefully into some of the +physiological processes involved in emotional changes. Among the most +apparent of bodily responses are the various external secretions. +Tears, the secretion of the lachrymal glands in response to an +emotion, are too common a phenomenon to arouse comment. It is common +knowledge that clammy hands and <!-- Page 133 --> +<a name="Page_133" id="Page_133" />a dry mouth betray emotion. Every +nursing mother knows that she dares not become too disturbed lest her +milk should dry up or change in character. Most people have +experienced an increase in urine in times of excitement; recently +physiologists have discovered the presence of sugar in the urine of +students at the time of athletic contests and difficult +examinations.<a name="FNanchor_30" id="FNanchor_30"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_30" class="fnanchor">[30]</a> We +have seen what an important role the various +internal secretions, such as the adrenal and thyroid secretions play +in fitting the body for flight and combat, and how large a part fear +and anger have in their production. Constant over-production of these +secretions through chronic states of worry is responsible for many a +distressing symptom.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_30" id="Footnote_30"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_30"><span class="label">[30]</span></a> Cannon.</p></div> + +<p>Most graphic evidence of the disturbance of secretions by emotion is +found in the response of the salivary and gastric glands to painful or +pleasurable thinking. As these are the secretions which play the +largest part in the digestive processes, they lead us naturally to our +next heading.</p> + +<p><b>Digestion.</b> Everybody knows that appetizing food makes the mouth +water, but not everybody realizes that it makes the stomach water +also. Nor do we often realize the vital place that this watering has +in taking care of our food. "Well begun is half-done," is literally +true of digestion. A good flow of saliva brings <!-- Page 134 --> +<a name="Page_134" id="Page_134" />the food into contact +with the taste-buds in the tongue. Taste sends messages to the +nerve-centers in the medulla oblongata; these centers in turn flash +signals to the stomach glands, which immediately "get busy" preparing +the all-important gastric juice. It takes about five minutes for this +juice to be made ready, and so it happens that in five minutes after +the first taste, or even in some cases after the first smell, the +stomach is pouring forth its "appetite juice" which determines all the +rest of the digestive process, in intestines as well as in stomach. +Experiments on dogs and cats by Pawlow, Cannon, and others have shown +what fear and anger and even mildly unpleasant emotions do to the +whole digestive process. Cannon tells of a dog who produced 66.7 cubic +centimeters of pure gastric juice in the twenty minutes following five +minutes of sham feeding (feeding in which food is swallowed and then +dropped out of an opening in the esophagus into a bucket instead of +into the stomach). Although there was no food in the stomach, the +juice was produced by the enjoyment of the taste and the thought of +it. On another day, after this dog had been infuriated by a cat, and +then pacified, the sham feeding was given again. This time, although +the dog ate eagerly, he produced only 9 cubic centimeters of gastric +juice, and this rich in mucus. Evidently a good appetite and +attractively served food are not more important than <!-- Page 135 --> +<a name="Page_135" id="Page_135" />a cheerful mind. +Spicy table talk, well mixed with laughter, is better than all the +digestive tablets in the world. What is true of stomach secretions is +equally true of stomach contractions. "The pleasurable taking of food" +is a necessity if the required contractions of stomach and intestines +are to go forward on schedule time. A little extra dose of adrenalin +from a mild case of depression or worry is enough to stop all +movements for many minutes. What a revelation on many a case of +nervous dyspepsia! The person who dubbed it "Emotional Dyspepsia" had +facts on his side.</p> + +<p><b>Circulation.</b> It is not the heart only that pumps the blood through +the body. The tiny muscles of the smallest blood-vessels, by their +elasticity are of the greatest importance in maintaining an even flow, +and this is especially influenced by fear and depression. Blushing, +pallor, cold hands and feet, are circulatory disturbances based +largely on emotions. Better than a hot-water bottle or electric pads +are courage and optimism. A patient of mine laughingly tells of an +incident which she says happened a number of years ago, but which I +have forgotten. She says that she asked me one night as she carried +her hot-water bottle to bed, "Doctor, what makes cold feet?" and that +I lightly answered "Cowardice!" Whereupon she threw away her beloved +water-bag and has never needed it since.</p> + +<p>There is a disturbance of the circulation which <!-- Page 136 --> +<a name="Page_136" id="Page_136" />results in very +marked swelling and redness of the affected part. This is known as +angio-neurotic edema, or nervous swelling. I do not have to go farther +than my own person for an example of this phenomenon. When I was a +young woman I taught school and went home every day for luncheon. One +day at luncheon, some one of the family criticized me severely. I went +back to school very angry. Before I entered the school-room, the +principal handed me some books which she had ordered for me. They were +not at all the books I wanted, and that upset me still more. As I went +into the schoolroom, I found that my face was swollen until my eyes +were almost shut; it was a bright red and covered with purplish +blotches. My fingers were swollen so that I could not bend the joints +in the slightest degree. It was a day or two before the disturbance +disappeared, and the whole of it was the result of anger.</p> + +<p>We hear much to-day about high blood pressure. They say that a man is +as old as his arteries, and now it is known that the health of the +arteries depends largely on blood pressure. Since this is a matter +that can be definitely measured at any minute, we have an easy way of +noting the remarkable effect of shifting emotions. Sadler tells of an +ex-convict with a blood pressure of 190 millimeters. It seems that he +was worrying over possible rearrest. On being reassured <!-- Page 137 --> +<a name="Page_137" id="Page_137" />on this +point, his blood pressure began to drop within a few minutes, falling +20 mm. in three hours, and 35 mm. by the following day.</p> + +<p><b>Muscular Tone.</b> A force that affects circulation, blood pressure, +respiration, nutrition of cells, secretion, and digestion, can hardly +fail to have a marked effect on the tone of the muscles, internal as +well as external. When we remember that heart, stomach, and intestines +are made of muscular tissue, to say nothing of the skeletal muscles, +we begin to realize how important is muscular tone for bodily health. +Over and over again have I demonstrated that a courageous mind is the +best tonic. Perhaps an example from my "flat-footed" patients will be +to the point. One woman, the young mother of a family, came to me for +a nervous trouble. Besides this, she had suffered for seven or eight +years from severe pains in her feet and had been compelled to wear +specially made shoes prescribed by a Chicago orthopedist. The shoes, +however, did not seem to lessen the pain. After an ordinary day's +occupation, she could not even walk across the floor at dinner-time. A +walk of two blocks would incapacitate her for many days. She was +convinced that her feet could never be cured and came to me only on +account of nervous trouble. On the day of her arrival she flung +herself down on the couch, saying that she would like to go away from +everybody, where the children would <!-- Page 138 --> +<a name="Page_138" id="Page_138" />never bother her again. She was +sure nobody loved her and she wanted to die. Within three weeks, in +ordinary shoes, this woman tramped nine miles up Mount Wilson and the +next day tramped down again. Her attitude had changed from that of +irritable fretfulness to one of buoyant joy, and with the moral change +had come new strength in the muscles. The death of her husband has +since made it necessary for her to support the family, and she is now +on her feet from eight to fourteen hours a day, a constant source of +inspiration to all about her, and no more weary than the average +person.</p> + +<p>Flabbiness in the muscles often causes this trouble with the feet. +"The arches of the foot are maintained by ligaments between the bones, +supported by muscle tendons which prevent undue stretching of the +ligaments and are a protection against +flat-foot."<a name="FNanchor_31" id="FNanchor_31"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_31" class="fnanchor">[31]</a> Muscle tissue +has an abundant blood supply, while ligaments have very little and +soon lose their resiliency if unsupported. Any lack of tone in the +calf-muscles throws the weight on the less resistant ligaments and on +the cartilages placed as cushions between the bony structures of the arch. +This is what causes the pain.<a name="FNanchor_32" id="FNanchor_32"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_32" class="fnanchor">[32]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_31" id="Footnote_31"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_31"><span class="label">[31]</span> +</a> Grey's Anatomy—"The Articulations."</p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_32" id="Footnote_32"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_32"><span class="label">[32]</span> +</a> Actual loss of the arch by downward displacement of the +bones cannot be overcome by restoring muscle-tone. The majority of +so-called cases of flatfoot are, however, in the stage amenable to +psychic measures.</p></div> + +<p><!-- Page 139 --><a name="Page_139" id="Page_139" /> +Flat-footedness is only one result of weak muscles. Eye-strain is +another; ptosis, or falling of the organs, is another. In a majority +of cases the best treatment for any of these troubles is an +understanding attempt to go to the root of the matter by bracing up +the whole mental tone. The most scientific oculists do not try to +correct eye trouble due to muscular insufficiency by any special +prisms or glasses. They know that the eyes will right themselves when +the general health and the general spirits improve. I have found by +repeated experience with nervous patients that it takes only a short +time for people who have been unable to read for months or years to +regain their old faculty. So remarkable is the power of mind.</p> + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p>We have found that the gap between the body and the mind is not so +wide as it seems, and that it is bridged by the subconscious mind, +which is at once the master of the body and the servant of +consciousness. In recording the physical effects of suggestion and +emotion, we have not taken time to describe the galvanometers, the +weighing-machines and all the other apparatus used in the various +laboratory tests; but enough has been said to show that when doctors +and psychologists speak of the effect of mind on body, they are +<!-- Page 140 --><a name="Page_140" id="Page_140" />dealing +with definite facts and with laws capable of scientific proof.</p> + +<p>We have emphasized the fact that downcast and fearful moods have an +immediate effect on the body; but after all, most people know this +already. What they do not know is the real cause of the mood. When a +nervous person finds out why he worries, he is well on the way toward +recovery. An understanding of the cause is among the most vital +discoveries of modern science.</p> + +<p>The discussion, so far, has merely prepared us to plunge into the +heart of the question: What is it that in the last analysis makes a +person nervous, and how may he find his way out? This question the +next two chapters will try to answer.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> +<div><!-- Page 141 --><a name="Page_141" id="Page_141" /></div> + +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_VII" id="CHAPTER_VII">CHAPTER VII</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we go to the root of the matter</i></p> + +<p class="heading">THE REAL TROUBLE</p> + +<p class="scheading">Pioneers</p> + +<p><b>Following the Gleam.</b> Kipling's Elephant-child with the "'satiable +curiosity" finally asked a question which seemed simple enough but +which sent him on a long journey into unknown parts. In the same way +man's modest and simple question, "What makes people nervous?" has +sent him far-adventuring to find the answer. For centuries he has +followed false trails, ending in blind alleys, and only lately does he +seem to have found the road that shall lead him to his journey's end.</p> + +<p>We may be thankful that we are following a band of pioneers whose +fearless courage and passion for truth would not let them turn back +even when the trail led through fields hitherto forbidden. The leader +of this band of pioneers was a young doctor named Freud.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Search for Truth</p> + +<p><b>Early Beginnings.</b> In 1882, when Freud was the <!-- Page 142 --> +<a name="Page_142" id="Page_142" />assistant to Dr. +Breuer of Vienna, there was brought to them for treatment a young +woman afflicted with various hysterical pains and paralyses. This +young woman's case marked an epoch in medical history; for out of the +effort to cure her came some surprising discoveries of great +significance to the open-minded young student.</p> + +<p>It was found that each of this girl's symptoms was related to some +forgotten experience, and that in every case the forgetting seemed to +be the result of the painfulness of the experience. In other words, +the symptoms were not visitations from without, but expressions from +within; they were a part of the mental life of the patient; they had a +history and a meaning, and the meaning seemed in some way to be +connected with the patient's previous attitude of mind which made the +experience too painful to be tolerated in consciousness. These +previous ideas were largely subconscious and had been acquired during +early childhood. When by means of hypnosis a great mass of forgotten +material was brought to the surface and later made plain to her +consciousness, the symptoms disappeared as if by magic.</p> + +<p><b>A Startling Discovery.</b> For a time Breuer and Freud worked together, +finding that their investigations with other patients served to +corroborate their former conclusions. When it became apparent that in +<!-- Page 143 --><a name="Page_143" id="Page_143" />every case +the painful experience bore some relation to the love-life +of the patient, both doctors were startled. Along with most of the +rest of the world, they had been taught to look askance at the +reproductive instinct and to shrink from realizing the vital place +which sex holds in human life.</p> + +<p>Breuer dropped the work, and after an interval Freud went on alone. He +was resolved to know the truth, and to tell what he saw. When he +reported to the world that out of all his hundreds of patients, he had +been unable, after the most careful analysis, to find one whose +illness did not grow from some lack of adjustment of the sex-life, he +was met by a storm of protest from all quarters. No amount of evidence +seemed to make any difference. People were determined that no such +libel should be heaped on human nature. Sex-urge was not respectable +and nervous people were to be respected.</p> + +<p>Despite public disapproval, the scorn of other scientists, and the +resistance of his own inner prejudices, Freud kept on. He was forced +to acknowledge the validity of the facts which invariably presented +themselves to view. Like Luther under equal duress, he cried: "Here I +stand. I can do no other."</p> + +<p><b>Freudian Principles.</b> Gradually, as he worked, he gathered together a +number of outstanding facts about <!-- Page 144 --><a name="Page_144" id="Page_144" />man's +mental life and about the psycho-neuroses. These facts he formulated into certain principles, +which may be summed up in the following way.</p> + +<p>1 There is no <i>chance</i> in mental life; every mental phenomenon—hence +every nervous phenomenon—has a cause and meaning.</p> + +<p>2 Infantile mental life is of tremendous importance in the direction +of adult processes.</p> + +<p>3 Much of what is called forgetting is rather a repression into the +subconscious, of impulses which were painful to the personality as a +whole.</p> + +<p>4 Mental processes are dynamic, insisting on discharge, either in +reality or in phantasy.</p> + +<p>5 An emotion may become detached from the idea to which it belongs and +be displaced on other ideas.</p> + +<p>6 Sex-interests dominate much of the mental life where their influence +is unrecognized. The disturbance in a psycho-neurosis is always in +this domain of sex-life. "In a normal sexual life, no neurosis." If a +shock is the precipitating cause of the trouble, it is only because +the ground was already prepared by the sex-disturbance.</p> + +<p>Freud was perhaps unfortunate in his choice of the word "sex," which +has so many evil connotations; but as he found no other word to cover +the field, he chose the old one and stretched its meaning to include +all the psychic and physical phenomena which spring <!-- Page 145 --> +<a name="Page_145" id="Page_145" />directly and +indirectly from the great processes of reproduction and parental care, +and which ultimately include all and more than our word +"love."<a name="FNanchor_33" id="FNanchor_33"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_33" class="fnanchor">[33]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_33" id="Footnote_33"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_33"><span class="label">[33]</span> +</a> Freud and his followers have always said that they saw +no theoretical reason why any other repressed instinct should not form +the basis of a neurosis, but that, as a matter of fact, they never had +found this to be the case, probably because no other instinct comes +into such bitter and persistent conflict with the dictates of society. +Now, however, the Great War seems to have changed conditions. Under +the strain and danger of life at the front there has developed a kind +of nervous breakdown called shellshock or war-neurosis, which seems in +some cases to be based not on the repression of the instinct of +race-preservation but on the unusual necessity for repression of the +instinct of self-preservation. Army surgeons report that wounded men +almost never suffer from shell-shock. The wound is enough to secure +the unconsciously desired removal to the rear. But in the absence of +wounds, a desire for safety may at the same time be so intense and so +severely repressed that it seizes upon the neurosis as the only +possible means of escape from the unbearable situation. In time of +peace, however, the instinct of reproduction seems to be the only +impulse which is severely enough repressed to be responsible for a +nervous breakdown.</p></div> + +<p><b>Later Developments.</b> Little by little, the scientific world came to +see that this wild theorizer had facts on his side; that not only had +he formulated a theory, but he had discovered a cure, and that he was +able to free people from obsessions, fears, and physical symptoms +before which other methods were powerless. One by one the open-minded +men of science were converted by the overpowering logic of the +evidence, until to-day we find not only a "Freudian school," counting +among its members many of the eminent scientists of <!-- Page 146 --> +<a name="Page_146" id="Page_146" />the day, but we +find in medical schools and universities courses based on Freudian +principles, with text-books by acknowledged authorities in medicine +and psychology. We find magazines devoted entirely to psycho-analytic +subjects,<a name="FNanchor_34" id="FNanchor_34"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_34" class="fnanchor">[34]</a> besides +articles in medical journals and even numerous +articles in popular magazines. Not only is the treatment of nervous +disorders revolutionized by these principles but floods of light are +thrown on such widely different fields of study as ancient myths and +folk lore, the theory of wit, methods of child training, and the +little slips of the tongue and everyday "breaks" that have until +recently been considered the meaningless results of chance.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_34" id="Footnote_34"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_34"><span class="label">[34]</span> +</a> <i>The Psychoanalytic Review</i> and the <i>International +Journal of Psychoanalysis.</i></p></div> + +<p><b>A Searching <span title="Corrected typo: was 'Queston'" class="hov">Question</span>.</b> + We find, then, that when we ask, "What makes +people nervous?" we are really asking: "What is man like, inside and +out, up and down? What makes him think, feel, and act as he does every +hour of every day?" We are asking for the source of human motives, the +science of human behavior, the charting of the human mind. It is hard +to-day to understand how so much reproach and ridicule could have been +aroused by the statement that the ultimate cause of nervousness is a +disturbance of the sex-life. There has already been a change in the +public attitude toward things sexual.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 147 --><a name="Page_147" id="Page_147" />Training-courses +for mothers and teachers, elementary teaching in the +schools, lectures and magazine articles have done much to show the +fallacy of our old hypersensitive attitude. Since the war, some of us +know, too, with what success the army has used the Freudian principles +in treating war-neurosis, which was mistakenly called shell-shock by +the first observers. We know, too, more about the constitution of +man's mind than the public knew ten years ago. When we remember the +insistent character of the instincts and the repressive method used by +society in restraining the most obstreperous impulse, when we remember +the pain of such conflict and the depressing physical effects of +painful emotions, we cannot wonder that this most sharply repressed +instinct should cause mental and physical trouble.</p> + +<p><b>What about Sublimation?</b> On the other hand, it has been stated in +Chapter IV that although this universal urge cannot be repressed, it +can be sublimated or diverted to useful ends which bring happiness, +not disaster, to the individual. We have a right, then, to ask why +this happy issue is not always attained, why sublimation ever fails. +If a psycho-neurosis is caused by a failure of an insistent instinct +to find adequate expression, by a blocking of the libido or the +love-force, what are the conditions which bring about this blocking? +The sex-instinct of every respectable person<!-- Page 148 --> +<a name="Page_148" id="Page_148" /> is subject to restraint. +Some people are able to adjust themselves; why not all? The question, +"What makes people nervous?" then turns out to mean: What keeps people +from a satisfactory outlet for their love-instincts? What is it that +holds them back from satisfaction in direct expression, and prevents +indirect outlet in sublimation? Whatever does this must be the real +cause of "nerves."</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Causes of "Nerves"</p> + +<p><b>Plural, not Singular.</b> The first thing to learn about the cause is +that it is not a cause at all, but several causes. We are so well made +that it takes a combination of circumstances to upset our equilibrium. +In other words, a neurosis must be "over-determined." Heredity, faulty +education, emotional shock, physical fatigue, have each at various +times been blamed for a breakdown. As a matter of fact, it seems to +take a number of ingredients to make a neurosis,—a little unstable +inheritance plus a considerable amount of faulty upbringing, plus a +later series of emotional experiences bearing just the right +relationship to the earlier factors. Heredity, childhood reactions, +and later experiences, are the three legs on which a neurosis usually +stands. An occasional breakdown seems to stand on the single leg of +childhood experiences but in the majority of cases each of the three +<!-- Page 149 --><a name="Page_149" id="Page_149" />factors +contributes its quota to the final disaster.</p> + +<p><b>Born or Made?</b> It used to be thought that neurotics, like poets, were +born, not made. Heredity was considered wholly responsible, and there +seemed very little to do about it. But to-day the emphasis on heredity +is steadily giving way to stress on early environment. There are, no +doubt, such factors as a certain innate sensitiveness, a natural +suggestibility, an intensity of emotion, a little tendency to nervous +instability, which predispose a person to nerves, but unless the +inborn tendency is reinforced by the reactions and training of early +childhood, it is likely to die a natural death.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Childhood Experiences</p> + +<p><b>Early Reactions.</b> Freud found that a neurotic is made before he is +six years old. When by repeated explorations into the minds of his +patients, he made this important discovery, he at first believed that +the disturbing factor was always some single emotional experience or +shock in childhood,—usually of a sexual nature. But Freud and later +investigators have since found that the trouble is not so often a +single experience as a long series of exaggerated emotional reactions, +a too intense emotional life, a precocity in feeling tending toward +fixation of childhood habits, which are thus carried over into adult life.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 150 --><a name="Page_150" id="Page_150" /><b>Fixation +of Habits.</b> Fixation is the word that expresses all +this,—fixation of childish habits. A neurotic is a person who made +such strong habits in childhood that he cannot abandon them in +maturity. He is too much ruled by the past. His unconscious emotional +thought-habits are the complexes which were made in childhood and +therefore lack the power of adaptation to mature life.</p> + +<p>We saw in Chapter IV that Nature takes great pains to develop in the +child the psychic and physical trends which he will need later on in +his mature love-life, and that this training is accomplished in a +number of well-defined periods which lead from one to the other. If, +however, the child reacts too intensely, lingers too long in any one +of these phases, he lays for himself action lines of least resistance +which he may never leave or to which he may return during the strain +and stress of adult life.</p> + +<p>In either case, the neurotic is a grown-up child. He may be a very +learned, very charming person, but he is nevertheless dragging behind +him a part of his childhood which he should have outgrown long ago. +Part of him is suffering from an arrest of development,—not a leg or +an arm but an impulse.</p> + +<p><b>Precocious Emotions.</b> The habits which tend to become fixed too soon +seem to be of four kinds; the habit of loving, the habit of rebelling, +the habit of repressing <!-- Page 151 --><a name="Page_151" id="Page_151" /> +normal instincts, and the habit of dreaming. +In each case it is the excess of feeling which causes the +trouble,—too much love, too much hate, too much disgust, or too much +pleasure in imagination. Exaggeration is always a danger-signal. An +overdeveloped child is likely to be an underdeveloped man. Especially +in the emotions is precocity to be deplored. A premature alphabet or +multiplication table is not nearly so serious as premature intensity +of feeling, nor so likely to lead later to trouble. Of course fixation +in these emotional habits does not always lead to a serious breakdown. +If the fixation is not too extreme, and if later events do not happen +to accentuate the trouble, the arrest of development may merely show +itself in certain weaknesses of character or in isolated symptoms +without developing a real neurosis.</p> + +<p>Let us examine each of these arrested habits and the excess emotion +which sets the mold before it is ready for maturity.</p> + +<p><b>Too Much Self-Love.</b> In the chapter on the reproductive instinct, we +found that the natural way to learn to love is by successively loving +oneself, one's parents and family, one's fellows, and one's mate. If +the love-force gets too much pleasure in any one of these phases, it +finds it hard to give up its old love and to pass on to the next +phase. Thus some children take too much pleasure in their own bodies +or, a little later, in their <!-- Page 152 --> +<a name="Page_152" id="Page_152" />own personalities. If they are too much +interested in their own physical sensations and the pleasure they get +by stimulating certain zones of the body, then in later life they +cannot free themselves from the desire for this kind of satisfaction. +Try as they may, they cannot be satisfied with normal adult relations, +but sink back into some form of so-called sex-perversion.</p> + +<p>Perhaps it is another phase of self-love which holds the child too +much. If, like Narcissus, he becomes too fond of looking at himself, +is too eager to show off, too desirous of winning praise, then forever +after he is likely to be self-conscious, self-centered, thinking +always of the impression he is making, unable ever to be at leisure +from himself. He is fixed in +the <span title="Corrected typo: was 'Narcisstic'" class="hov">Narcissistic</span> stage +of his life, and is unadapted to the world of social relations.</p> + +<p><b>Too Much Family-love.</b> We have already spoken of the danger of +fixation in the second period, that of object-love—the period of +family relationships. The danger is here again one of degree and may +be avoided by a little knowledge and self-control on the part of the +parents. The little girl who is permitted to lavish too much love on +her father, who does not see anybody else, who cannot learn to like +the boys is a misfit. The wise mother will see that her love for her +boy does not express itself too much by means of hugs and kisses. The +mother who shows very plainly that she loves her <!-- Page 153 --> +<a name="Page_153" id="Page_153" />little boy better +than she loves her husband and the mother who boasts that her +adolescent boy tells her all his secrets and takes her out in +preference to any girl—that deluded mother is trying to take +something that is not hers, and is thereby courting trouble. When her +son grows up, he may not know why, but no girl will suit him, and he +will either remain a bachelor or marry some older woman who reminds +him subconsciously of his mother. His love-requirements will be too +strict; he will be forever trying either in phantasy or in real life +to duplicate his earlier love-experiences. This, of course, cannot +satisfy the demands of a mature man. He will be torn between +conflicting desires, unhappy without knowing why, unable either to +remain a child or to become a man, and impelled to gain +self-expression in indirect and unsatisfactory ways.</p> + +<p>Since it is not possible in this space to recite specific cases which +show how often a nervous trouble points back to the father-mother +complex,<a name="FNanchor_35" id="FNanchor_35"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_35" class="fnanchor">[35]</a> it may +help to cite the opinions of a few of our best +authorities. Freud says of the family complex, "This is the root +complex of the neurosis." Jelliffe: "It is the foot-rule of +measurement of success in life": by which he means that just so far as +we are able at the right time to free ourselves from dependence on +parents are we able to adjust ourselves to the world at large. +Pfister: "The <!-- Page 154 --><a name="Page_154" id="Page_154" />attitude +toward parents very often determines for a +life-time the attitude toward people in general and toward life +itself." Hinkle: "The entire direction of lives is determined by +parental relationships."</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_35" id="Footnote_35"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_35"><span class="label">[35]</span> +</a> This is technically known as the Oedipus Complex.</p></div> + +<p><b>Too Much Hate.</b> Besides loving too hard, there is the danger of +hating too hard. If it sounds strange to talk of the hatreds of +childhood, we must remember that we are thinking of real life as it is +when the conventions of adult life are removed and the subconscious +gives up its secrets.</p> + +<p>Several references have been made to the jealousy of the small child +when he has to share his love with the parent of the same sex. For +every little boy the father gets in the way. For every little girl the +mother gets in the way. At one time or other there is likely to be a +period when this is resented with all the violence of a child's +emotions. It is likely to be very soon repressed and succeeded by a +real affection which lasts through life. But underneath, unmodified by +time, there may exist simultaneously the old childish image and the +old unconscious reaction to it, unconscious but still active in +indirect ways.</p> + +<p>Jealousy is very often united with the natural rebellion of a child +against authority. The rebellion may, of course, be directed against +either parent who is final in authority in the home. In most cases +this is the father. As the impulse of self-assertion is usually +<!-- Page 155 --><a name="Page_155" id="Page_155" />stronger +in boys than in girls, and as the boy's impulse in this +direction is reinforced by any existing jealousy toward his father, we +find a strong spirit of rebellion more often playing a subconscious +part in the life of men than of women. The novelist's favorite theme +of the conflict between the young man and "the old man" represents the +conscious, unrepressed complex. More often, however, there is true +affection for the father, while the rebellion which really belongs to +the childish father-image is displaced or transferred to other symbols +of authority,—the state, the law, the king, the school, the teacher, +the church, or perhaps to religion and authority in general. +Anarchists and atheists naturally rationalize their reasons for +dissent, but, for all that, they are not so much intellectual pioneers +as rebellious little boys who have forgotten to grow up.</p> + +<p><b>Liking to be "Bossed."</b> There is a worse danger, however, than too +much rebellion, and that is too little rebellion. Sometimes this +yielding spirit is the result of an overdose of negative self-feeling +and an under-dose of positive self-feeling; but sometimes it is +over-compensation for the repressed spirit of rebellion which the +child considers wicked. Consciously he becomes over-meek, because he +has to summon all his powers to fight his subconscious insurrection. +Whether he be meek by nature or by training, he is likely to be a +<!-- Page 156 --><a name="Page_156" id="Page_156" /> +failure. Everybody knows that the child who is too good never amounts +to anything. He who has never disobeyed is a weakling. Naturally +resenting all authority, the normal individual, if he be well trained, +soon learns that some authority is necessary. He rebels, but he learns +to acquiesce, to a certain degree. If he acquiesces too easily, +represses too severely his rebellious spirit, swings to the other +extreme of wanting to be "bossed," he is very likely to end as a +nervous invalid, unfitted for the battles of life. The neurotic in the +majority of cases likes authority, clings to it too long, wants the +teacher to tell him what to do, wants the doctor to order him around, +is generally over-conscientious, and afraid he will offend the "boss" +or some one else who reminds him of the father-image. All this carries +a warning to parents who cannot manage their children without +dominating their lives, even when the domination is a kindly one. +Perhaps the modern child is in more danger of being spoiled than +bullied, but analysis of nervous patients shows that both kinds of +danger still exist.</p> + +<p><b>Too Much Disgust.</b> The third form of excessive emotion is disgust. +The love-force, besides being blocked by a fixation of childish love +and of childish reactions toward authority, is very often kept from +free mature self-expression by a perpetuation of a childish reaction +against sex. We hardly need dwell longer on <!-- Page 157 --> +<a name="Page_157" id="Page_157" />the folly of teaching +children to be ashamed of so inevitable a part of their own nature. +Disgust is a very strong emotion, and when it is turned against a part +of ourselves, united with that other strong impulse of self-regard and +incorporated into the conscience, it makes a Chinese wall of exclusion +against the baffled, misunderstood reproductive instinct, which is +thrust aside as alien.</p> + +<p><b>Restraint versus Denial.</b> Repression is not merely restraint. It is +restraint plus denial. To the clamoring instinct we say not merely, +"No, you <i>may</i> not," but "No, you <i>are</i> not. You do not exist. Nothing +like you could belong to me." The woman with nausea (Chapter V) did +not say to herself: "You are a normal, healthy woman, possessed of a +normal woman's desires. But wait a while until the proper time comes." +Controlled by an immature feeling of disgust, she had said: "I never +thought it. It cannot be."</p> + +<p>The difference is just this. When an ungratifiable desire is honestly +faced and squarely answered, it is modified by other desires, chooses +another way of discharge, and ceases to be desire. When a desire is +repressed, it is still desire, unsatisfied, insistent, unmodifiable by +mature points of view, untouched by time, automatic, and capable of +almost any subterfuge in order to get satisfaction. A repressed desire +is buried, shut away from the disintegrating effects of sunlight +<!-- Page 158 --><a name="Page_158" id="Page_158" />and +air. While the rest of the personality is constantly changing under +the influence of new ideas, the buried complex lives on in its +immaturity, absolutely untouched by time.</p> + +<p><b>Childish Birth-theories.</b> When a child's questions about where babies +come from are met by evasions, he is forced to manufacture his own +theories. His elders would laugh if they knew some of these theories, +but they would not laugh if they knew how often the childish ideas, +wide of the truth, furnish the material for future neuroses. Frink +tells the story of a young woman who had a compulsion for taking +drugs. Although not a drug-fiend in the usual sense, she was +constantly impelled to take any kind of drug she could obtain. It was +finally revealed that during her childhood she had tried hard to +discover how babies were made, and had at last concluded that they +grew in the mother as a result of some medicine furnished by the +doctor. The idea had long been forgotten, only to reappear as a +compulsion. The natural desire for a child was strong in her, but was +repressed as unholy in an unmarried woman. The associated childish +idea of drug-taking was not repellent to her moral sense and was used +as a substitute for the real desire to bear a child.</p> + +<p>Many of my patients have suffered from the effect of some such +birth-theories. One young girl, twenty <!-- Page 159 --> +<a name="Page_159" id="Page_159" />years old, was greatly +afflicted with myso-phobia, or the fear of contamination. She spent +most of her time in washing her hands and keeping her hands and +clothing free from contamination by contact with innumerable harmless +objects. When cleaning her shoes on the grass, she would kneel so that +the hem of her skirt would touch the grass, lest some dust should fly +up under her clothes. After eating luncheon in the park with a girl +who had tuberculosis, she said that she was not afraid of tuberculosis +in the lungs, but asked if something like tuberculosis might not get +in and begin to grow somewhere else. Her life was full to overflowing +of such compulsive fears.</p> + +<p>As opportunity offered itself from day to day, I would catch her +compulsive ideas in the very act of expressing themselves, and would +pin her down as to the association and the source of her fear, always +taking care not to make suggestions or ask leading questions. She was +finally convinced out of her own mouth that her real fear was the idea +of something getting into her body and growing there. Then she told +how she had questioned her mother about the reproductive life and had +been put off with signs of embarrassment. For a long time she had been +afraid to walk or talk with a boy, because, not knowing how conception +might occur, she feared grave consequences.</p> + +<p>Very soon after the beginning of her conversations <!-- Page 160 --> +<a name="Page_160" id="Page_160" />with me, the girl +realized that her fear was really a disguised desire that something +might be planted within and grow. With her new understanding of +herself, her compulsions promptly slipped away. She began to eat and +sleep, and to live a happy, natural life.</p> + +<p><b>Chronic Repression.</b> It takes first-hand acquaintance with nervous +patients to realize how common are stories like these. Unnecessary +repressions based on false training are the cause of many a physical +symptom and mental distress which a little parental frankness might +have forestalled.<a name="FNanchor_36" id="FNanchor_36"> +</a><a href="#Footnote_36" class="fnanchor">[36]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_36" id="Footnote_36"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_36"><span class="label">[36]</span> +</a> Parents who are eager to handle this subject in the +right way are often sincerely puzzled as to how to go about it. No +matter how complete their education, it is very likely to fail them at +this critical point. For the benefit of such parents, let it be said +with all possible emphasis that the first and most important step must +be a change in their own mental attitude. If there is left within them +the shadow of embarrassment on the subject of sex, their children will +not fail to sense the situation at once. A feeling of hesitation or a +tendency to apologize for nature makes a far deeper impression on the +child-mind than do the most beautiful of half-believed words on the +subject. And this impression, subtle and elusive as it may seem, is a +real and vital experience which is quite likely to color the whole of +the child's life. If you would give your children a fair start, you +must first get rid of your own inner resistances. After that, all will +be clear sailing. +</p><p> +In the second place, take the earliest opportunity to bring up the +subject in a natural way. A young father told me recently that his +little daughter had asked her mother why she didn't have any lap any +more. "And of course your wife took that chance to tell her about the +baby that is coming," I said. "Oh, no," he answered, "she did nothing +of the kind. Mary is far too young to know about such things." There +are always chances if we are on the look out for them—and the earlier +the better. It has been noticed that children are never repelled by +the idea of any natural process unless the new idea runs counter to +some notion which has already been formed. The wise parent is the one +who gets in the right impression before some other child has had a +chance to plant the wrong one. +</p><p> +Then, too, we elders are judged quite as much by what we do not say as +by what we do. Happy is the child who is not left to draw his own +conclusions from the silence and evasiveness of his parents. The +sex-instruction which children are getting in the schools is often +good, but it usually comes too late—the damage is always done before +the sixth year. +</p><p> +When it comes to the exact words in which to explain the phenomena of +generation and birth each parent must naturally find his own way. The +main point is that we must tell the truth and not try to improve on +nature. If we say that the baby grows under the mother's heart and +later the child learns that this is not true, he inevitably gets the +idea that there is something not nice about the part of the body in +which the baby does grow. What could be wrong with the simple truth +that the father plants a tiny seed in the mother's body and that this +seed joins with another little seed already there and grows until it +is a real baby ready to come into the world? The question as to how +the father plants the seed need cause no alarm. If brothers and +sisters are brought up together with no artificial sense of false +modesty, they very early learn the difference between the male and the +female body. It is simple enough to tell the little child the function +of the male structure. And it is easy to explain that the seeds do not +grow until the little boy and girl have grown to be man and woman and +that the way to be well and to have fine strong children is to leave +the generative organs alone until that time. A sense of the dignity +and high purpose of these organs is far more likely to prevent +perversions—to say nothing of nervousness—than is an attitude of +taboo and silence.</p></div> + +<p><!-- Page 161 --><a name="Page_161" id="Page_161" />A +certain amount of repression is inevitable and useful, but a +neurotic is merely an exaggerated represser. He represses so much of +himself that it will not stay <!-- Page 162 --><a name="Page_162" id="Page_162" /> +down.<a name="FNanchor_37" id="FNanchor_37"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_37" class="fnanchor">[37]</a> He builds up a permanent +resistance which automatically acts as a dam to his normal sex +instinct and forces it into undesirable outlets.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_37" id="Footnote_37"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_37"><span class="label">[37]</span> +</a> "A neurosis is a partial failure of repression." Frink: +<i>Morbid Fears and Compulsions</i>.</p></div> + +<p>A resistance is a chronic repression, repression that has become fixed +and subconscious, a habit that has lost its flexibility and outlives +its usefulness. It is a fixation of repression, and is built out of an +over-strong complex or emotional thought habit, acquired during +childhood, incorporated into the conscience and carried over into +maturity, where it warps judgment and interferes with normal +development because it is fundamentally untrue and at variance with +the laws of nature.</p> + +<p><b>Too Much Day-Dreaming.</b> The fourth habit which holds back the adult +from maturity and predisposes toward "nerves" is the habit of +imagination. It need hardly be said that a certain kind of imagination +is a good thing and one of man's greatest assets. But the essence of +day-dreaming is the exact opposite; it is the desire to see things as +they are not, but as we should like them to be,—not in order that we +may bring them to pass, but for the mere pleasure of dreaming. Instead +of turning a microscope or a telescope on the world of reality, as +positive imagination does, this negative variety refuses even to look +with the naked eye. To dream is easier than to do; to build up +phantasies<!-- Page 163 --><a name="Page_163" id="Page_163" /> + is easier than to build up a reputation or a fortune; to +think a forbidden pleasure is easier than to sublimate. +"Pleasure-thinking" is not only easier than "reality-thinking,"—it is +the <i>older</i> way.</p> + +<p>Children gratify many of their desires simply by imagining them +gratified. Much of the difficulty of later life might be avoided if +the little child could be taught to work for the accomplishment of his +pleasures rather than to dream of them. The normal child gradually +abandons this "pleasure-thinking" for the more purposeful thinking of +the actual world, but the child who loiters too long in the realm of +fancy may ever after find it hard to keep away from its borders. His +natural interest in sex, if artificially repressed, is especially +prone to satisfy itself by way of phantasy.</p> + +<p><b>Turning back to Phantasy.</b> In later life, when the love-force for one +reason or another becomes too strong to be handled either directly or +indirectly in the real world, there comes the almost irresistible +impulse to regress to the infantile way and to find expression by +means of phantasy. After long experience Freud concluded that phantasy +lies at the root of every neurosis. Jung says that a sex-phantasy is +always at least one determiner of a nervous illness, and Jelliffe +writes that the essence of the neurosis is a special activity of the +imagination.</p> + +<p>Such a statement need not shock the most sensitive <!-- Page 164 --> +<a name="Page_164" id="Page_164" />conscience. The +very fact that a neurosis breaks out is proof that the phantasies are +repellent to the owners of them and are thrust down into the +subconscious as unworthy. In fact, every neurosis is witness to the +strength of the human conscience. No phantasy could cause illness. It +is the phantasy plus the repression of it that makes the trouble, or +rather it is the conflict between the forces back of the phantasy and +the repression. The neurosis, then, turns out to be a "flight from the +real," the result of a desire to run away from a difficulty. When a +problem presses or a disagreeable situation is to be faced, it is +easier to give up and fall ill than to see the thing through to the +end. Here again, we find that nervousness is a regression to the +irresponsible reactions of childhood.</p> + +<p><b>Maturity versus Immaturity.</b> We have been thinking of the main causes +of "nerves" and have found them to be infantile habits of loving, +rebelling, repressing, and dreaming. We have tried to show that these +habits are able to cause trouble because of their bearing on that +inevitable conflict between the ancient urge of the reproductive +instinct and the later ideals which society has acquired. If this +conflict be met in the light of the present, free from the backward +pull, of outgrown habits, an adjustment is possible which satisfies +both the individual and society. We call this adjustment sublimation. +This is rather a synthesis than a <!-- Page 165 --> +<a name="Page_165" id="Page_165" />compromise, a union of the opposing +forces, a happy utilization of energy by displacement on more useful +ideas. But if the conflict has to be met with the mind hampered by +immature thinking and immature feeling; if the demands of the +here-and-now are met as if it were long ago; if unhealthy and untrue +complexes, old loves and hates complicate the situation; if to the +necessary conflict is added an unnecessary one; then something else +happens. Compromise of some kind must be made, but instead of a happy +union of the two forces a poor compromise is effected, gaining a +partial satisfaction for both sides, but a real one for neither. The +neurosis is this compromise.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Later Experiences</p> + +<p><b>The Last Straw.</b> The precipitating cause may be one of a number of +things. It may be entirely within, or it may be external. Perhaps it +is only a quickening of the maturing instincts at the time of +adolescence, making the love-force too strong to be held by the old +repressions. Perhaps the husband, wife, or lover dies, or the +life-work is taken away, depriving the vital energy of its usual +outlets. Perhaps the trigger is pulled by an emotional shock which +bears a faint resemblance to old emotional experiences, and which +stimulates both the repressing and repressed trends and makes the +person at the same time say both "Yes," <!-- Page 166 --> +<a name="Page_166" id="Page_166" />and +"No."<a name="FNanchor_38" id="FNanchor_38"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_38" class="fnanchor">[38]</a> Perhaps +physical fatigue lets down the mental and moral tension and makes the +conflict too strong to be controlled. Perhaps an external problem +presses and arouses the old habit of fleeing from disagreeable +reality. Any or all these factors may cooperate, but not one of them +is anything more than a last straw on an overburdened back. No +calamity, deprivation, fatigue, or emotion has been able to bring +about a neurosis unless the ground was prepared for it by the earlier +reactions of childhood.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_38" id="Footnote_38"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_38"><span class="label">[38]</span> +</a> "The external world can only cause repression when there +was already present beforehand a strong initial tension reaching back +even to childhood."—Pfister: <i>Psychoanalytic Method</i>, p. 94.</p></div> + + +<p class="scheading">The Breakdown Itself</p> + +<p>"<b>Two Persons under One Hat.</b>" We can understand now why a neurotic +can be described in so many ways. We often hear him called an +especially moral, especially ethical person, with a very active +conscience; an intensely social being, unable to be satisfied with +anything but a social standard; a person with "finer intellectual +insight and greater sensitiveness than the rest of mankind." At the +same time we are told that a neurosis is a partial triumph of +anti-social, non-moral factors, and that it is a cowardly flight from +reality; we hear a nervous invalid called selfish, unsocial, shut in, +primitive, childish, self-deceived. Both these descriptions are true +to life. A neurosis is an ethical struggle +<!-- Page 167 --><a name="Page_167" id="Page_167" />between these two sets of +forces. If the lower set had triumphed, the man would have been merely +weak; if the higher set had been victorious, he would have been +strong. As it is, he is neither one nor the other,—only nervous. The +neurosis is the only solution of the struggle which he is able to find, +and serves the purpose of a sort of armed armistice between the two camps.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Serving a Purpose</p> + +<p>If a neurosis is a compromise, if it is the easiest way out, if it +serves a purpose, it must be that the individual himself has a hand in +shaping that purpose. Can it be that a breakdown which seems such an +unmitigated disaster is really welcomed by a part of our own selves? +Nothing is more intensely resented by the nervous invalid than the +accusation that he likes his symptoms,—and no wonder. The conscious +part of him hates the pain, the inconvenience, and the disability with +a real hatred. It is not pleasant to be ill. And yet, as it turns out, +it is pleasanter to be ill than it is to bear the tension of +unsatisfied desire or to be undeceived about oneself. Every symptom is +a means of expression for repressed and forgotten impulses and is a +relief to the personality. It tends to the preservation of the +individual, rather than to his destruction. The nervous invalid is not +short-lived, but his family may be! It <!-- Page 168 --> +<a name="Page_168" id="Page_168" />has been said that a neurosis +is not so much a disease as a dilemma. Rather might it be said that +the neurosis is a way out of the dilemma. It is a harbor after a +stormy sea, not always a quiet harbor, but at least a usable one. +Unpleasant as it is, every nervous symptom is a form of compensation +which has been deliberately though unconsciously chosen by its owner.</p> + +<p><b>Rationalizing Our Distress.</b> Among other things, a nervous symptom +furnishes a seemingly reasonable excuse for the sense of distress +which is behind every breakdown. Something troubles us. We are not +willing to acknowledge what it is. On the other hand, we must appear +reasonable to ourselves, so we manufacture a reason. Perhaps at the +time when the person first feels distress, he is on a railroad train. +So he says to himself, "It is the train. I must not go near the +railway"; and he develops a phobia for cars. Perhaps at the onset of +the fear he happens to have a slight pain in the arm. He makes use of +the pain to explain his distress. He thinks about it and holds on to +it. It serves a purpose, and is on the whole less painful than the +feeling of unexplained impending disaster which is attached to no +particular idea. Perhaps he happens to be tired when the conflict +first gets beyond control. So he seizes the idea of fatigue to explain +his illness. He develops chronic fatigue and talks proudly of +overwork. In every case the symptom serves a real +<!-- Page 169 --><a name="Page_169" id="Page_169" />purpose, and is, +despite its discomfort, a relief to the distressed personality.</p> + +<p>A neurosis is a subconscious effort at adjustment. Like a physical +symptom, it is Nature's way of trying to cure herself. It is an +attempt to get equilibrium, but it is an awkward attempt and hardly +the kind that we would choose when we see what we are doing.</p> + +<p><b>Securing an Audience.</b> Besides furnishing relief from too intense +strain, a nervous breakdown brings secondary advantages that are at +most only dimly recognized by the individual. One of the most intense +cravings of the primitive part of the subconscious is for an audience; +a nervous symptom always secures that audience. The invalid is the +object of the solicitous care of the family, friends, physician, and +specialist. Pomp and ceremony, so dear to the child-mind, make their +appeal to the dissociated part of the personality. The repressed +instincts, hungry for love and attention, delight in the petting and +special care which an illness is sure to bring. Secretly and +unconsciously, the neurotic takes a certain pleasure in all the +various changes that are made for his benefit,—the dismantling of +striking clocks, the muffling of household noises, the banishing of +crowing roosters, and the changes in menu which must be carefully +planned for his stomach.</p> + +<p>This characteristic of finding pleasure in personal <!-- Page 170 --> +<a name="Page_170" id="Page_170" />ministrations is +plainly a regression to the infantile phase of life. The baby demands +and obtains the center of the stage. Later he has to learn to give it +up, but the neurotic gets the center again and is often very loth to +leave it for a more inconspicuous place.</p> + +<p><b>Capitalizing an Illness.</b> Then, too, a neurosis provides a way of +escape from all sorts of disagreeable duties. It can be capitalized in +innumerable ways,—ways that would horrify the invalid if he realized +the truth. Much of the resentment manifested against the suggestion +that the neurosis is psychic in origin is simply a resistance against +giving up the unconsciously enjoyed advantages of the illness. An +honest desire to get well is a long step toward cure.</p> + +<p>The purposive character of a nervous illness is well illustrated by +two cases reported by Thaddeus Hoyt +Ames.<a name="FNanchor_39" id="FNanchor_39"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_39" class="fnanchor">[39]</a> A young woman, the +drudge of the family, suddenly became hysterically blind, that is, she +became blind despite the fact that her eyes and optic nerves proved to +be unimpaired. She remained blind until it was proved to her that a +part of her welcomed the blindness and had really produced it for the +purpose of getting away from the monotony of her unappreciated life at +home. She naturally resented the charge but finally accepted it and +"turned on" her eyesight in an instant. The other patient, a man, +became blind in <!-- Page 171 --><a name="Page_171" id="Page_171" />order +to avoid seeing his wife who had turned out to +be not at all what he had hoped. When he realized what he was doing, +he decided that there might be better ways of adjusting himself to his +wife. He then switched on his seeing power, which had never been +really lost, but only disconnected and dissociated from the rest of +his mind.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_39" id="Footnote_39"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_39"><span class="label">[39]</span> +</a> Thaddeus Hoyt Ames: <i>Archives of Ophthalmology</i>, Vol. +XLIII, No. 4, 1914.</p></div> + +<p>That the conscious mind has no part in the subterfuge is shown by the +fact that both patients gave up their artificial haven as soon as they +saw how they had been fooling themselves. The fact remains that every +neurosis is the fulfilment of a wish,—a distorted, unrecognized, +unsatisfactory fulfilment to be sure, but still an effort to satisfy +desire. As Frink remarks, "A neurosis is a kind of behaviour." We +always choose the conduct we like. It is a matter of choice. Does not +this answer our question as to why some people always take unhealthy +suggestions? If we take the bad one, it is because it serves the need +of a part of our being.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Sign Language</p> + +<p><b>Talking in Symbols.</b> We have several times suggested that a nervous +symptom is a disguised, indirect expression of subconscious impulses. +It is the completeness of the disguise which makes it so hard for us +to realize its true meaning. It takes a stretch of the imagination to +believe that a pain in the body can <!-- Page 172 --> +<a name="Page_172" id="Page_172" />mean a pain in the soul, or that +a fear of contamination can signify a desire to bear a child. But in +all this we must not forget the primitive, childlike nature of the +instinctive life.</p> + +<p>The savage and the child do not think as civilized man thinks. Savage +or child thinks in pictures; he acts his feelings; he groups things +according to superficial resemblances, he expresses an idea by its +opposite; he talks in symbols. We still use these devices in poetic +speech and in everyday thought. A wedding-ring stands for the marriage +bond; the flag for a nation; a greyhound for fleetness; a wild beast +for ferocity; sunrise for youth; and sunset for old age. "The essence +of language consists in the statement of resemblance. The expression +of human thought is an expression of +association."<a name="FNanchor_40" id="FNanchor_40"> +</a><a href="#Footnote_40" class="fnanchor">[40]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_40" id="Footnote_40"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_40"><span class="label">[40]</span> +</a> Trigant Burrow: <i>Journal of American Medical +Association</i>, Vol. LXVI, No. II, 1916.</p></div> + +<p>The association may be so accidental and superficial as to seem absurd +to another person, or it may be so fundamental as to express the +universal thought of man from the beginning of time. Many of the signs +and symbols which crop out in neurotic symptoms and in normal dreams +are the same as those which appear in myths, fairy tales and folk-lore +and in the art of the earlier races.</p> + +<p><b>A Secret Code.</b> When the denied instincts of a man's repressed life +insist on expression, and when the <!-- Page 173 --> +<a name="Page_173" id="Page_173" />shocked proprieties of his +repressing life demand conformity to social standards, the +subconscious, held back from free speech, strikes a compromise by +making use of figurative language. As Trigant Burrow says, if the +moral repugnance is very strong, the disguise must be more elaborate, +the symbols more far-fetched. The symbols of nervous symptoms and of +dreams are a "secret code," understood by the sender but meaningless +to the censoring conscience, which passes them as harmless.</p> + +<p><b>The Right Kind of Symbolism.</b> Sublimation itself is merely a symbolic +expression of basic impulses. It follows the line of our make-up, +which naturally and fundamentally is wont to let one thing stand for +another and to express itself in indirect ways. Sublimation says: "If +I cannot recreate myself in the person of a child, I will recreate +myself in making a bridge, or a picture, or a social settlement,—or a +pudding." It says: "If I cannot have my own child to love, I will +adopt an orphan-asylum, or I will work for a child-labor law." It +merely lets one thing stand for another and transfers all the passions +that belong to the one on to the other, which is the same thing as +saying that it gives vent to its original desire by means of symbolic +expression.</p> + +<p><b>The Wrong Kind of Symbolism.</b> A nervous disorder is an unfortunate +choice of symbols. Instead of <!-- Page 174 --> +<a name="Page_174" id="Page_174" />spiritualizing an innate impulse, it +merely disguises it. The disguise takes a number of forms. One of the +commonest ways is to act out in the body what is taking place in the +soul. The woman with nausea converted her moral disgust into a +physical nausea, which expressed her distress while it hid its +meaning. The girl who was tired of seeing her work, and the man who +wanted to avoid seeing his wife chose a way out which physically +symbolized their real desire. A dentist once came to me with a +paralyzed right arm. He had given up his office and believed that he +would never work again. It turned out that his only son had just died +and that he was dramatizing his soul-pain by means of his body. His +subconscious mind was saying, "My good right arm is gone," and saying +it in its own way. Within a week the arm was playing tennis, and ever +since it has been busy filling teeth. There were, of course, other +factors leading up to the trouble, but the factor which determined its +form was the sense of loss which acted itself out through the body.</p> + +<p>Sometimes, as we have seen, the disguise takes another form. Instead +of conversion into a physical symptom, it lets one idea stand for +another and displaces the impulse or the emotion to the substitute +idea. The girl with the impulse to take drugs fooled her conscience by +letting the drug-taking idea stand for the idea of conception. The +girl with the fear of contamination +<!-- Page 175 --><a name="Page_175" id="Page_175" />carried the disguise still +farther by changing the desire into fear,—a very common subterfuge.</p> + +<p><b>The Case of Mrs. Y.</b> There came to me a short time ago a little woman +whose face showed intense fright. For several months she had spent +much of the time walking the floor and wringing her hands in an agony +of terror. In the night she would waken from her sleep, shaking with +fear; soon she would be retching and vomiting, although she herself +recognized the fact that there was nothing the matter with her +stomach.</p> + +<p>Part of the time her fear was a general terror of some unknown thing, +and part of the time it was a specialized fear of great intensity. She +was afraid she would choke her son, to whom she was passionately +devoted. During the course of the treatment, which followed the lines +of psycho-analysis to be described in the next chapter, I found that +this fear had arisen one evening when she was lying reading by the +side of her sleeping child. Suddenly, without warning, she had a sort +of mental picture of her own hands reaching out and choking the boy. +Naturally she was terrified. She jumped out of bed, decided that she +was losing her mind and went into a hysterical state which her husband +had great trouble in dispelling. After that she was afraid to be left +alone with her children lest she should kill them.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 176 --><a name="Page_176" id="Page_176" />During +the analysis it was discovered that what she had been reading +on that first night was the thirteenth verse of the ninety-first +Psalm. "Thou shalt tread upon the lion and the adder. The young lion +and the dragon thou shalt trample under foot." To her the adder meant +the snake, the tempter in the Garden of Eden, and hence sex. What she +wanted to choke was her own insistent sex urge of which the child was +the symbol and the result. On later occasions she had the same sort of +hallucinations in connection with another child and on sight of a +brutish kind of man who symbolized to the subconscious mind the +sex-urge, of which she was afraid. Not so much by what her mother had +said as by what she had avoided saying, and by her expression whenever +the subject was mentioned, had she given her little daughter a +fundamentally wrong idea of the reproductive instinct. Later when the +girl was woman grown she still clung to the old conception, deploring +the sex-part of the marriage relation and feeling herself too refined +to be moved by any such sensual urge. But the strong sex-instinct +within her would not be downed. It was so insistent as to be an object +of terror to her repressing instinct, which could not bring itself to +acknowledge its presence. The fear that came to the surface was merely +a disguised and symbolic representation of this real fear which was +turning her life into a nightmare.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 177 --><a name="Page_177" id="Page_177" />The +nausea and vomiting in this woman seemed to be symbolic of the +disgust which she felt subconsciously at the thought of her own +sex-desires, but sometimes the physical disturbances which accompany +such phobias are the natural physical reactions to the constant fear +state. Indigestion, palpitation, and tremors are not in themselves +symbolic of the inner trouble but may be the result of an overdose of +the adrenal and thyroid secretions and the other accompaniments of +fear. In such cases the real symptom is the fear, and the physical +disturbance an incidental by-product of the emotional state. In any +case a nervous symptom is always the sign of something else—a +hieroglyph which must be deciphered before its real meaning can be +discovered.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p><b>Three Kinds of People.</b> Absurd as it sounds, "nerves" turn out to be +a question of morals; a neurosis, an affair of conscience; a nervous +symptom an unsettled ethical struggle. The ethical struggle is not +unusual; it is a normal part of man's life, the natural result of his +desire to change into a more civilized being. The people in the world +may be divided into three classes, according to the way they decide +the conflict.</p> + +<p><b>The Primitive.</b> The first class merely capitulate to <!-- Page 178 --> +<a name="Page_178" id="Page_178" />their primitive +desires. They may not be nervous, but it is safe to say that they are +rarely happy. The voice of conscience is hard to drown, even when it +is not strong enough to control conduct. Happily it often succeeds in +making us miserable, when we desert the ways that have proved best for +our kind. The "immoral" person has not yet "arrived"; he simply +disregards the collective wisdom of society and gives the victory to +the primitive forces which try to keep man back on his old level. We +cannot break the ideals by which man lives, and still be happy.</p> + +<p><b>The Salt of the Earth.</b> The second class of people decide the +conflict in a way that satisfies both themselves and society. They +give the victory to the higher trends and at the same time make a +lasting peace by winning over the energy of the undesirable impulses. +By sublimation they divert the threatening force to useful work and +turn it out into real life, using its steam to make the world's wheels +go round. Their love-force, unhampered by childish habits, is free to +give itself to adult relationships or to express itself symbolically +in socially helpful ways.</p> + +<p><b>Nervous People.</b> To the third class belong the people who have not +finished the fight. These are the folk with "nerves," the people in +whom the conflict is fiercest because both sides are too strong. The +victory goes to neither side; the tug of war ends in a tie. <!-- Page 179 --> +<a name="Page_179" id="Page_179" />Since the +energy of the nervous person is divided between the effort to repress +and the effort to gain expression, there is little left for the +external world. There is plenty of energy wasted on emotion, physical +symptoms, phantasy, or useless acts symbolizing the struggle.</p> + +<p>A neurotic is a normal person, "only more so." His impulses are the +same impulses as those of every other person; his complexes are the +same kind of complexes, only more intense. He is an exaggerated human +being. He may be only slightly exaggerated, showing merely a little +character-weakness or a slight physical symptom, or he may be so +intensified as to make life miserable for himself and everybody near +him. It is quantity, not quality, that ails him, for he differs from +his steady-going neighbor not in kind but in degree. More of him is +repressed and a larger part of him is fixed in a childish mold.</p> + +<p><b>Tricking Ourselves.</b> A neurosis is a confidence game that we play on +ourselves. It is an attempt to get stolen fruit and to look pious at +the same time,—not in order to fool somebody else but to fool +ourselves.</p> + +<p>No nervous symptom is what it seems to be. It is an arch pretender. It +pretends to be afraid of something it does not fear at all, or to +ignore something that interests it intensely. It pretends to be a +physical disease, when primarily it has nothing to do with the +<!-- Page 180 --><a name="Page_180" id="Page_180" />body; +and the person most deluded is the one who "owns" the symptom. Its +purpose is to avoid the pain of disillusionment and to furnish relief +to a distracted soul which dares not face itself.</p> + +<p>Although the true meaning of a symptom is hidden, there is fortunately +a clue by which it can be traced. Sometimes it takes the art of a +psychic detective to follow the clues down, down through the different +layers of the subconscious mind, until the troublesome impulses and +complexes are found and dragged forth,—not to be punished for +breaking the peace but to be led toward reconciliation. But "that is +another story," and belongs to another chapter. We are approaching THE +WAY OUT.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> +<hr /> +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 181 --><a name="Page_181" id="Page_181" /></div> +<p class="heading">PART III—THE MASTERY OF "NERVES"</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> +<hr /> +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 182 --><a name="Page_182" id="Page_182" /> +<!-- Page 183 --><a name="Page_183" id="Page_183" /></div> + +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_VIII" id="CHAPTER_VIII">CHAPTER VIII</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we pick up the clue</i></p> + +<p class="heading">THE WAY OUT</p> + +<p class="scheading">The Science of Re-education</p> + + +<p>There is a story of an Irishman at the World's Fair in Chicago. +Although his funds were getting low, he made up his mind that he would +not go home without a ride on a camel. For several minutes he stood +before a sign reading: "First ride 25¢, second ride 15¢, third ride +10¢." Then, scratching his head, he exclaimed, "Faith, and I'll take +the third ride!" Should there by any chance be a reader who, eager to +find the way out without paying the price of knowledge, is tempted to +say to himself "Faith, and I'll begin with Part III," we give him fair +warning that if he does so, he will in all probability end by putting +down the book in a confused and skeptical frame of mind.</p> + +<p>It is difficult to find our way out of a maze without some faint idea +of the path by which we got in. He who brings to this chapter the +popular notion that nervousness +<!-- Page 184 --><a name="Page_184" id="Page_184" />is the result of worn-out +nerve-cells, can hardly be expected to understand how it can be cured +by a process of mental adjustment. Suggestion to that effect can +scarcely fail to appear to him faddish and unpractical. But once a +person has grasped the idea that "nerves" are merely a slip in the cog +of hidden mental machinery, and has acquired at least a +working-knowledge of "the way the wheels go round," he can scarcely +fail to understand that the only logical cure must consist in some +kind of readjustment of this underground machinery. If "nerves" were +physical, then only physical measures could cure, but as they are +psychic, the only effective measures must be psychic.</p> + +<p><b>Gross Misconceptions.</b> Nervousness is caused by a lack of adjustment +to the world as it is; therefore the only possible cure must be some +sort of readjustment between the person's inner forces and the demands +of the social world. As this lack of adjustment is concerned chiefly +with the repressed instinct of reproduction, it is only natural that +there should be people who believe that "the way out" lies in some +form of physical satisfaction of the sex-impulse—in marriage, in +changing or ignoring the social code, in homo-sexual relations or in +the practice of masturbation. But we have only to look about us to see +that this prescription does not cure. Freud naïvely asks whether he +would <!-- Page 185 --><a name="Page_185" id="Page_185" />be +likely to take three years to uncover and loosen the psychic +resistances of his patients, if the simple prescription of sex-license +would give relief.</p> + +<p>Since there are as many married neurotics as single, it is evident +that even marriage is not a sure preventive of nervousness. License, +on the other hand, can satisfy only a part of the individual's +craving. Freud insists that the sex-instinct has a psychic component +as well as a physical one, and that it is this psychic part which is +most often repressed. He maintains that for complete satisfaction +there must be psychic union between mates, and that gratification of +the physical component of sex when dissociated from psychic +satisfaction, results in an accumulation of tension that reacts badly +on the whole organism.</p> + +<p>The psychic tension accumulating in adult sex-relations has its +inception in the mistaken attitude on the part of the wife, who +remains true to her childhood training that any pleasure in sex is +vulgar; or on the part of the man, who reacts to the mood of the wife, +or is held by his own unbroken mother-son complex; or on the part of +both the tension piles up because of society's taboo upon rearing +large families. As the first two factors in this lack of adjustment +grew largely out of some kind of faulty education or from faulty +reaction to early experiences, the only effective way to secure a +better adaptation must be through a re-education +<!-- Page 186 --><a name="Page_186" id="Page_186" />which reaches down +to that part of the personality that bears the stamp of the unfortunate early factors.</p> + +<p><b>Remaking Ourselves.</b> As a matter of fact, the science of +psychotherapy or mental treatment is simply the science of +re-education,—a process designed to break up old unhealthy complexes +which disrupt the forces of the individual, and to build up healthy +complexes which adjust him to the social world and enable him to use +his energy in useful ways.</p> + +<p>Fortunately, minds can be changed. It is easier to make over an +unhealthy complex than to make over a weak heart, to straighten out a +warped idea than to straighten a bent back. Remarkable indeed have +been some of the transformations in people who are supposed to have +passed the plastic period in life. While it is true that some persons +become "set" in middle life, and almost impervious to new ideas, it is +also true that a person at fifty has more richness of experience upon +which to draw, more appreciation of the value of the good, than has a +person at twenty. If he really wants to change himself, he can do +wonderful things by re-education.</p> + +<p>The first step in this re-education is a grasp of the facts. If you +want to pull yourself out of a nervous disorder, first of all learn as +much as you can about the causes of "nerves," about the general laws +of mind and body, and about your own mental quirks. If this +<!-- Page 187 --><a name="Page_187" id="Page_187" />is not +sufficient, go to a specialist trained in psychotherapy and let him +help you uncover those trouble-making parts of your personality which +you cannot find for yourself. It is the purpose of this book to +summarize the facts which most need to be known. Let us now consider +those methods which the psychopathologist finds most useful in helping +his patients to self-knowledge and readjustment.</p> + +<p><b>Various Methods.</b> As there are a number of schools of medicine, so +there are a number of distinct methods of psychotherapy, each with its +own theories and methods of procedure, and each with its ardent +supporters. These methods may be classified into two groups. The first +group includes those methods, hypnosis and psycho-analysis, which make +a thorough search through the subconscious mind for the buried +complexes causing the trouble, and might, therefore, be called +"re-education with subconscious exploration." The other group, +includes so-called explanation and suggestion, or methods of +"re-education without subconscious exploration," which content +themselves with making a general survey and building up new complexes +without going to the trouble of uncovering the buried past. Although +the theory and the technique vary greatly, the aim of all these +methods is the same,—the readjustment of the individual to life.</p> + +<p class="scheading"><!-- Page 188 --><a name="Page_188" id="Page_188" />Re-education +with Subconscious Exploration</p> + +<p><b>Hypnosis.</b> The method by which most of the important early +discoveries were made is hypnosis, or artificial sleep, a method by +which the conscious mind is dissociated and the subconscious brought +to the fore. It was through hypnosis that Freud, Janet, Prince, and +Sidis made their first investigations into the nature of nervousness +and worked their first cures. With the conscious mind asleep and its +inhibitions out of the way, a hypnotized patient is often able to +remember and to disclose to the physician hidden complexes of which he +is unaware when awake. Hypnosis may thus be a valuable aid to +diagnosis, enabling the physician to determine the cause of +troublesome symptoms. He may then begin to make suggestions calculated +to break up the old complexes and to build new ones, made up of more +healthful ideas, desirable emotions and happy feeling-tones. As we +have seen, a hypnotized subject is highly suggestible. His +counter-suggestions inactivated, he believes almost anything told him +and is extremely susceptible to the doctor's influence.</p> + +<p>The dangers of hypnosis have been much exaggerated. Indeed, as an +instrument in the hands of a competent physician, it is not to be +feared at all. It has, however, its limitations. Many times the very +memories which need to be unearthed refuse to come to the surface. +Stubborn resistances are more likely to be <!-- Page 189 --> +<a name="Page_189" id="Page_189" />subconscious than +conscious, and may prove too strong to be overcome in this way. +Moreover, the road to superficial success is very inviting. It is easy +to cure the symptom, leaving the ultimate cause untouched and ready to +break out in new manifestations. The drug and drink habits may be +broken up without making any attempt to discover the unsatisfied +longings which were responsible for the habit. A pain may be cured +without finding the mental cause of the pain or initiating any +measures to guard against its return, and without giving the patient +any insight into the inner forces with which he still has to deal.</p> + +<p>Since nervousness is a state of exaggerated suggestibility and +abnormal dissociation, many psychologists believe that it is unwise to +employ a method which heightens the state of suggestibility and +encourages the habit of dissociation. They feel that it is wiser to +use less artificial methods which rest on the rational control of the +conscious mind and make the patient better acquainted with his own +inner forces and more permanently able to cope with new manifestations +of those forces. They believe that the character of the patient is +strengthened and his morale raised by methods which increase the +sovereignty of reason and decrease the role of unreasoning +suggestibility.</p> + +<p><b>Psycho-Analysis.</b> Freud's contribution has been not only a discovery +of the general causes of nervousness, but a special means of locating +the cause in any particular +<!-- Page 190 --><a name="Page_190" id="Page_190" />case. Abandoning hypnosis, +he developed another method which he called psycho-analysis. What chemical analysis +is to chemistry, psycho-analysis is to the science of the mind. It +splits up the mental content into its component parts, the better to +be examined and modified by the conscious mind. Psycho-analysis is +merely a technical process for discovering repressed complexes and +bringing them into consciousness, where they may be recognized for +what they are and altered to meet the demands of real life. It is a +device for finding and removing the cause of nervousness,—for +bringing to light hidden desires which may be honestly faced and +efficiently directed instead of being left to seethe in dangerous +insurrection. In order permanently to break up a real neurosis, a man +must first know himself and then change himself. He must gain insight +into his own mental processes and then systematically set to work to +change those processes that unfit him for life.</p> + +<p>We shall later find that a detailed self-discovery through +psycho-analysis is not always necessary, and that a more general +understanding of oneself is sufficient for the milder kinds of +nervousness. But because of the promise which psycho-analysis holds +out to those stubborn cases before which other methods are powerless; +because of the invaluable understanding of human nature which it +places at the disposal of all <!-- Page 191 --> +<a name="Page_191" id="Page_191" />nervous people, who may profit by its +findings without undergoing an analysis; and because of the flood of +light which it sheds on the motives, conduct, and character of every +human being, no educated person can afford to be without a general +knowledge of psycho-analysis.<a name="FNanchor_41" id="FNanchor_41"> +</a><a href="#Footnote_41" class="fnanchor">[41]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_41" id="Footnote_41"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_41"><span class="label">[41]</span> +</a> It is unfortunate that the records of an analysis are +too voluminous for use in so brief an account as this. Since the +report of one case would fill a book, and a condensed summary would +require a chapter, we must refer to some of the volumes which deal +exclusively with the psychoanalytic principles. For a list of these +books, see Bibliography.</p></div> + +<p><b>A Chain of Associations.</b> Psycho-analysis is not, like hypnosis, +based on dissociation; it is based on the association of ideas. Its +main feature is a process of uncritical thinking called "free +association." To understand it, one must realize how intricately woven +together are the thoughts of a human being and how trivial are the +bonds of association between these ideas. One person reminds us of +another because his hair is the same color or because he handles his +fork in the same way. Two words are associated because they sound +alike. Two ideas are connected because they once occurred to us at the +same time. A subtle odor or a stray breeze serves to remind us of some +old experience. Connections that seem far-fetched to other people may +be quite strong enough to bind together in our minds ideas and +emotions which have once been <!-- Page 192 --> +<a name="Page_192" id="Page_192" />associated, even unconsciously, +in past experience.</p> + +<p>In this way, thoughts in consciousness and in the upper layers of the +subconscious are connected by a series of associations, forming links +in invisible chains that lead to the deepest, most repressed ideas. +Even a dissociated complex has some connection with the rest of the +mind, if we only have the patience to discover it. Therefore, by +adopting a passive attitude, by simply letting his thoughts wander, by +talking out to the physician everything that comes to his mind without +criticizing or calling any thought irrelevant or far-fetched, and +without rejecting any thought because of its painful character, the +patient is helped to trace down and unearth the troublesome complex +which may have been absolutely forgotten for many years. He is helped +to relive the childhood experiences back of the over-strong habits +which lasted into maturity.</p> + +<p><b>Resisting the Probe.</b> Naturally, it is not all fair sailing. The +subconscious impulses which repressed the painful complex in the first +place still shrink from uncovering it. In many cases the resistance is +very strong. It, therefore, often happens that after a time the +patient becomes restive; he begins to criticize the doctor and to +ridicule the method. His mind goes blank and no thought will come; or +he refuses to tell what does come. The nearer the probe comes to the +sore spot, the greater the pain of the repressing impulses +<!-- Page 193 --><a name="Page_193" id="Page_193" />and the +stronger the resistance. Usually a strange thing happens; the patient, +instead of consciously remembering the forgotten experiences, begins +to relive them with his original emotions transferred on to the +doctor. Depending upon what person of his childhood he identifies with +him, the patient develops either a strong affection or an intense +antagonism to the physician, attitudes called in technical terms +positive and negative transference. If the analyst is skilful, he is +able to circumvent all the subterfuges of the resisting forces and to +uncover and modify the troublesome complexes. Sometimes this can be +accomplished at one sitting, but more often it requires long hours of +conversation. Freud has spent three years on a single difficult case, +and very frequently the analysis drags out through weeks or months. +The amount of mental material is so great, especially in a person who +is no longer young, that every analysis would probably be an +interminable affair if it were not for three valuable ways of finding +the clue and picking up the scent somewhere near the end of the trail. +The first of these clues is nothing else than so despised a phenomenon +as the patient's own night-dreams, which turn out to be not +meaningless jargon, as we have supposed, but significant utterances of +the inner man.</p> + +<p><b>The Message of the Dream.</b> When Freud rescued dreams from the mental +scrap-basket and learned how <!-- Page 194 --><a name="Page_194" id="Page_194" /> +to piece them together so that their +message to man about himself became for the first time intelligible, +he furnished the human race with what will probably be considered its +most valuable key to the hidden mysteries of the mind. Freeing the +dream from the superstition of olden times and from the neglect of +later days, Freud was the first to discover that it is part and parcel +of man's mental life, that it has a purpose and a meaning and that the +meaning may be scientifically deciphered. It then invariably reveals +itself to be not a prophecy for the future but an interpretation of +the present and of the past, an invaluable synopsis of the drama which +is being staged within the personality of the dreamer.</p> + +<p>As modern man has swung away from the idea of the dream as a warning +or a prophecy, he has accepted the even more untrue conception of +dreaming as the mere sport of sleep,—the "babble of the mind," the +fantastic and insignificant freak-play of undirected mental processes, +or the result of physical sensations without relation to the rest of +mental life. No wonder, then, that Freud's startling dictum, "A dream +is a disguised fulfilment of a repressed wish," should be met with +astonishment and incredulity. When a person is confronted for the +first time with this statement, he invariably begins to cite dreams in +which he is pursued by wild beasts, or in which his loved ones are +seen <!-- Page 195 --><a name="Page_195" id="Page_195" />lying +dead. He then triumphantly asserts that no such dream +could be the fulfilment of a wish.</p> + +<p>The trouble is that he has overlooked the word "disguised." Like wit +and some figures of speech, a dream says something different from what +it means. It deals in symbols. Its "manifest content" may be merely a +fantastic and impossible scene without apparent rhyme or reason, but +the "latent content," the hidden meaning, always expresses some urgent +personal problem. Although the dream may seem to be impersonal and +unemotional, it nevertheless deals in every case with some matter of +vital concern to the dreamer himself. It is a condensed and composite +picture of some present problem and of some related childish repressed +wish which the experiences of the preceding day have aroused.</p> + +<p>As Frink says, a dream is like a cartoon with the labels +omitted—absolutely unintelligible until its symbols are interpreted. +Although some dreams whose symbolism is that which man has always +used, can be easily understood by a person who knows, many dreams are +meaningless, even to an experienced analyst, until the patient himself +furnishes the labels by telling what each bit of the picture brings to +his mind. The dream, as a rule, merely furnishes the starting-point +for free association.</p> + +<p>Each symbol is an arrow pointing the way to <!-- Page 196 --> +<a name="Page_196" id="Page_196" />forbidden impulses which +are repressed in waking life but which find partial expression during +sleep. The subconscious part of the conscience is still on the job, so +the repressed desires can express themselves only in distorted ways +which will not arouse the censor and disturb sleep. The purpose of the +dream is thus two-fold,—to relieve the tensions of unsatisfied +desire, and to do this in such a subtle way as to keep the dreamer +asleep. Sometimes it fails of its purpose, but when there is danger of +our discovering too much about ourselves, we immediately wake up, +saying that we have had a bad dream.</p> + +<p>It is at first difficult to believe that we are capable of this +elaborate mental work while we are fast asleep. However, a little +investigation shows us to be more clever than we realize. The +subconscious mind, in its effort to satisfy both the repressing and +the repressed impulses, carries on very complicated processes, +disguises material by allowing one person to stand for another, two +persons to stand for one, or one person to stand for two; it shifts +emotion from important to trivial matters, dramatizes, condenses, and +elaborates, with a skill that is amazing. We are all of us very clever +playwrights and makers of allegories—in our sleep. Also, we are all +very clever at getting what we want, and the dream secures for us, in +a way, something which we want very much indeed and which the world +<!-- Page 197 --><a name="Page_197" id="Page_197" />of social restraint +or our own warped childish notion denies us.</p> + +<p>Not every one can become an interpreter of dreams. It takes a skilled +and patient specialist thoroughly to understand the process. But it is +fortunate indeed that we possess such a valuable means of diagnosis +when extraordinary conditions make it necessary to explore the +subconscious in the search for trouble-making +complexes.<a name="FNanchor_42" id="FNanchor_42"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_42" class="fnanchor">[42]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_42" id="Footnote_42"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_42"><span class="label">[42]</span></a> For f +urther study of the dream, see Freud: <i>Interpretation of Dreams</i>; +and <i>General Introduction to Psycho-Analysis</i>.</p></div> + +<p><b>The Word-Test.</b> Although dreams furnish the main clues to buried +complexes, they are by no means the only instrument of the +psycho-analyst. Another device, called the association word-test, has +been developed by Dr. Carl Jung of Switzerland. The analyst prepares a +list of perhaps one hundred words, which he reads one by one to the +patient, hoping in this way to strike some of the emotional reactions +of which the patient himself is unaware. The latter responds with the +first word that comes into his mind, no matter how absurd it may seem. +The responses themselves are often significant, but the time that +elapses is even more so. It usually happens that it takes very much +longer for some responses than for others. If a patient's average time +is one or two seconds, some responses may take five or ten or twenty +seconds. Sometimes<!-- Page 198 --><a name="Page_198" id="Page_198" /> + no word comes at all and the patient says that his +mind is a blank. He coughs or blushes, grows pale or trembles, showing +all the signs of emotion even when he himself has no notion of the +cause. The significant word has hit upon a subconscious association +with some emotional complex. The blocking of the mind is an effort of +the resistance to keep the painful ideas out of consciousness. The +telltale word then furnishes a starting point for further +associations.</p> + +<p>One of my patients blocked on the word "long." Instead of saying +"short" or "pencil" or "road" or "day" or any other word which might +naturally be associated with "long," she laughed and said that no word +would come. Finally an emotional memory came to light. It seems that +this woman had been courted by a man whom she unconsciously loved, but +whom she had "turned down" because she was ambitious for a career. +After the man had moved to another town, my patient heard that he was +engaged to another girl. She then realized that she loved him and +began to long for him with her whole heart. The meaningful word "long" +thus led us to one of the emotional memories for which we were +seeking.</p> + +<p><b>"Chance" Signs.</b> There are other clues to hidden inner processes, +other sign-posts pointing to the cause of a neurosis. Not only through +dreams and through emotional reactions to certain words does the +<!-- Page 199 --><a name="Page_199" id="Page_199" /> +subconscious reveal its desires, but also through the little slips of +the tongue and of the pen, the "chance" acts and unconscious +mannerisms which are usually ignored as entirely insignificant. When +we "make a break" and say what we secretly mean but wish to hide from +ourselves or others; when we forget an appointment which part of us +really wishes to avoid, or forget a name with which we are perfectly +familiar; when we lose the pen so that we cannot write or the desk key +so that we cannot work; when we blunder and drop things and do what we +did not mean to do; then we may know—the normal as well as the +nervous person—that our subconscious minds with their repressed +desires are trying to get the reins and are partially succeeding.</p> + +<p>An example from my own life may illustrate the point. In building a +number of houses, I had occasion often to use the word studding, but +on every occasion, I forgot the word and always had to end lamely by +saying "those pieces of timber that go up and down." Each time the +builder supplied the word, but the next time it was no more +accessible. Finally, the reason came to me. One day when I was a +little child I looked out of the window and cried, "Oh, see that great +big beautiful horse." My grandmother exclaimed, "Sh! sh! that is a +stud horse." Over-reaction to that impression repressed the word stud +so successfully that as a grown woman I could not recall another word +<!-- Page 200 --><a name="Page_200" id="Page_200" />which happened to contain the same syllable.</p> + +<p>During an analysis a patient of mine who had a mother-in-law situation +on her hands told me a dream of the night before. "I dreamed that my +mother-in-law, who has really been very ill, was taken with a +sinking-spell. I rushed to the telephone to call the doctor, but found +to my terror that I could not remember his number." "What is his +number?" I asked, knowing that she ought to know it perfectly. +"Two-eight-nine-six," she answered at once. The number really was +2876. Asleep and awake, her repressed desire for release from the +mother-in-law's querulous presence was attempting to have its way. In +the dream, she avoided calling the doctor by forgetting his number +entirely. Awake, she evaded the issue by remembering a wrong number. +In the dream she thinly disguised her desire by displacing the anxious +emotion from the sense of her own guilty wishes to the idea of the +mother-in-law's death. When confronted with this interpretation, the +woman readily acknowledged its truth.</p> + +<p>Even stammering, which has always been considered a physical disorder, +has been proved, by psycho-analysis, to be the sign of an emotional +disturbance. H. Addington Bruce reports the case of one of Dr. Brill's +patients, a young man who had been stammering for several years. +Observation revealed the fact <!-- Page 201 --><a name="Page_201" id="Page_201" />that +his chief difficulty was with words beginning with K and although at first he firmly +denied any significance to the letter, he later confessed that his sweetheart +whose name began with K had eloped with his best friend and that he +had vowed never to mention her name again. Upon Dr. Brill's suggestion +he tried to think of the unfaithful lover as Miss W., but soon +returned, saying that he was stammering worse than ever. Investigation +showed that the additional unpronounceable words contained the letter +W. When he was induced to renounce his oath never to call the girl's +name again, he found that he had no more difficulty with his +speech.<a name="FNanchor_43" id="FNanchor_43"> +</a><a href="#Footnote_43" class="fnanchor">[43]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_43" id="Footnote_43"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_43"><span class="label">[43]</span> +</a> H. Addington Bruce; "Stammering and Its Cure," +<i>McClure's</i>, February, 1913.</p></div> + +<p>Thus we see that even the halting tongue of a stammerer may point the +way to the buried complex for which search is being made.</p> + +<p>Since there is no accident in mental life, and since there is behind +every action a force or group of forces, no smallest action is +insignificant to the person trained to understand.</p> + +<p>If this at first seems disturbing, it is only because we do not +realize that there is nothing within of which we need be ashamed. +People are very much alike, especially in the deeper layers of their +being. What belongs to the whole human race does not need to be +<!-- Page 202 --><a name="Page_202" id="Page_202" />hidden away +in darkness. There is nothing to lose and everything to +gain by an increasing understanding of the chance signals which reveal +the forces at work within the depths of the mind. To the analyst every +little unconscious act is a valuable clue pointing toward the end of +his quest.<a name="FNanchor_44" id="FNanchor_44"> +</a><a href="#Footnote_44" class="fnanchor">[44]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_44" id="Footnote_44"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_44"><span class="label">[44]</span> +</a> For further discussion of this subject, see Freud's +<i>Psycho-pathology of Everyday Life</i>, translated by A.A. Brill.</p></div> + +<p><b>The Aim of Psycho-Analysis.</b> As we have seen, the object of all this +technique is the discovery and the removal of the resistances which +have been keeping the emotional conflicts in the dark. It is a long +step just to learn that there are resistances; and by reliving, bit by +bit, the earlier experiences responsible for unfortunate habits, we +find that the habits themselves lose much of their old power. They can +be seen for what they are, and changed to suit present conditions. A +wish is incomparably stronger when unconscious than when conscious; +and the old stereotyped, automatic reactions tend to cease when once +they have been seen for what they are. They become assimilated with +the rest of the personality and modified by the mature attitudes of +the conscious mind. The person then re-educates himself by the very +act of discovering himself. In other cases, the uncovering is merely +the first step in the process of re-education. The analyst then +assumes the rôle of educator, cutting away old shackles, breaking down +<!-- Page 203 --><a name="Page_203" id="Page_203" />false standards, +building up new complexes, showing the patient the +naturalness of his desires, inducing him to look at them as biologic +facts, and showing him how to sublimate those which may not find +direct expression; in fact, leading him out into the self-expression +of a free, unhampered life.<a name="FNanchor_45" id="FNanchor_45"> +</a><a href="#Footnote_45" class="fnanchor">[45]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_45" id="Footnote_45"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_45"><span class="label">[45]</span> +</a> "It will be readily understood that in the +reconstruction of the shattered purposes, the frustrated hopes and the +outraged instincts which are found to lie at the source of those human +woes we call 'nervous disorders,' there takes place a gradual +transposition of values, a total recasting of ideas, and that through +the whole process, education in the deepest meaning of the word, +enters at last into its full sovereign rights."—Trigant Burrow.</p></div> + +<p>Among my patients at one time was a woman subject to terrible fits of +despondency. She was happily married and enjoyed the marriage +relationship, but could not free herself from a terrible sense of +guilt and degradation, a sense which was so acute that she wanted to +end her life. Although she was an active member of a church, she was +starving for the real message of the church, continually bound by a +feeling of aloofness which made her a stranger in the midst of +friends. Psycho-analysis revealed an experience of her childhood which +she had kept a secret all these years. It seems that when she was +seven years of age an old minister had driven her into town and had +made some sort of sex-approach on the way. Although ignorant of its +significance, the child was badly frightened and overcome with a sense +of guilt. She had already inferred +<!-- Page 204 --><a name="Page_204" id="Page_204" />that such subjects were +not to be mentioned and she hesitated long before telling even her mother. +Smoldering within her through the years had been this emotional +complex about the sex-life and about people connected with a church, +so that even as a grown woman the relationships of her mature years +were completely ruined by her old childish reaction. With insight as +to the cause of her trouble, she was able to modify her attitudes and +to live a free and happy life.</p> + +<p>Several years ago there came to me a man of exceptional intellectual +ability, who for years had been totally incapacitated because of blind +resistances built up in childhood. Although married to a woman whom he +thoroughly liked and admired, he was absolutely miserable in his +married life. He had, in fact, a deep-rooted complex against marriage, +and had only allowed himself to be captured because the woman, with +whom he had been good friends, had cried when he refused to marry her. +During analysis it transpired that as a little boy of four he had +often seen his silly young mother cry because she could not have a new +dress. He had taken her side and bitterly felt that she was abused by +his father. Later, at six, he had heard some coarse stories about sex +to which he had over-reacted. Still later he had heard the workmen on +the farm say that they could not go to the gold-fields because they +had wives and were held back by marriage. +<!-- Page 205 --><a name="Page_205" id="Page_205" />"There are no idle words +where children are," and this little boy had built up such a strong +complex against marriage that he could not possibly be happy as a +grown man. He was as much crippled by the old scar as is an arm which +is bent and stunted from a deep scar in the flesh. After the analysis +had broken up the adhesions, he found himself free, able to give +mature expression to his repressed and dissatisfied love-instincts.</p> + +<p>Psycho-analysis is not a process of addition, but one of subtraction. +Like a surgical operation, it undoes the results of old injuries, +removes foreign material, and gives nature a chance to develop freely +in her own satisfactory way.</p> + +<p class="scheading">Re-education without Subconscious Exploration</p> + +<p><b>Simple Explanation.</b> So far, "the way out" sounds rather involved. It +seems to require a special kind of doctor and a complicated, lengthy +process before the exact trouble can be determined. But, fortunately +for the average nervous patient, this lengthy process of analysis is +by no means always necessary. People with troublesome nervous +symptoms, and even those who have had a serious breakdown, are +constantly being cured by a kind of re-education which breaks up +subconscious complexes without trying to bring them to the surface. If +the dead past can be let alone, so much <!-- Page 206 --> +<a name="Page_206" id="Page_206" />the better. Sometimes a +bullet buried in the flesh sends up a constant stream of discomfort +until it is dug out and removed; but if it has carried in no infection +and the body can adjust itself, it is usually considered better to let it remain.</p> + +<p>The subconscious makes its own deductions. If resistances are not too +strong it is often possible to introduce healthy ideas by way of the +conscious reason, to break up old habits, and make over the mentality +without going to the trouble of uncovering some of the reactions which +are responsible for the difficulty.</p> + +<p><b>Moral Hygiene.</b> Because this is true, there has grown up a kind of +psychotherapy which is known as simple explanation, or persuasion. As +usually practised, this kind of re-education pays very little +attention to the ultimate cause of "nerves." It has little to say +about repressed instincts or the real reasons for fearful emotions and +physical symptoms. Instead, it attacks the symptom itself, contenting +itself with teaching the patient that his trouble is psychic in +origin; that it is based on exaggerated suggestibility and +uncontrolled emotionalism; that it is made out of false ideas about +the body, illogical conclusions, and unhealthy feeling-tones; and that +it may be cured by a kind of moral hygiene, which breaks up these old +habits and replaces them with new and better ones. It tries to +inculcate the cheerful attitude of mind; to give <!-- Page 207 --> +<a name="Page_207" id="Page_207" />the patient the +conviction of power; to correct his false ideas about his stomach, his +heart, or his head; to train him out of his emotionalism; to lead him +into a state of mind more largely controlled by reason; and to make +him find some useful and absorbing work.</p> + +<p>This kind of mental and moral treatment has been sufficient to cure +many neuroses of long standing. In cases that are helped by this +method, the patient's love-force, robbed of the material out of which +it has woven its disguise, and trained out of its bad habits by +re-education, automatically makes its own readjustments and forces new +channels for itself out into more useful activities. Very many nervous +persons seem to need nothing more than this simple kind of help.</p> + +<p><b>When Simple Explanation Does not Explain.</b> For very many cases, +however, this procedure, good as it is, does not go deep enough. +Although it gives a sound objective education about the facts of one's +body, it furnishes only the most superficial subjective knowledge of +one's inner life. If the inner struggle be bitter, the competing +forces will hold on to their poor refuge in the symptom, despite any +number of explanations that the symptom can have no physical cause. +Sometimes it is enough for a person to be shown that he is too +suggestible, but often it is far more helpful for him to get an +inkling as to why he likes unhealthy suggestions, and to understand +something <!-- Page 208 --><a name="Page_208" id="Page_208" /> +of his starved instincts which he may learn to satisfy in better ways.</p> + +<p class="scheading">Psychological Explanation</p> + +<p>Between the two extremes of the cases which need a real analysis and +those which are cured by simple explanation, I have found the great +bulk of nervous cases. To simple explanation with its highly useful +information, I therefore add what might be called psychological +explanation, a re-education which makes use of all that illuminating +material unearthed by the explorations of hypnosis and especially of +psycho-analysis. Along with correct ideas about such matters as +digestion, sleep, and fatigue, I give, so far as the patient is able +to understand, a comprehension of the rights of the denied instincts, +the ways of the subconscious, the fettering hold of unfortunate +childish habits, the various mental mechanisms by which we fool +ourselves, and the ways by which we may make better adaptations.</p> + +<p><b>According to the Patient.</b> The treatment varies according to the +nature of the trouble, and is somewhat dependent on the mentality of +the patient. There are many people who would only be confused by being +forced into a study of mental phenomena. Not being students, they +would be more bewildered than helped by the details of their inner +mechanisms. Others, of studious habits and inquiring minds, are +encouraged to <!-- Page 209 --><a name="Page_209" id="Page_209" /> +browse at will in a library of psychotherapy and to +learn all that they can from the best authorities.</p> + +<p>In any case, I give the patients as much as they are able to take of +my own understanding of the subject. There are no secrets in this +method. The patient is treated as a rational human being who has +nothing to lose and everything to gain by the fullest knowledge that +he is able to acquire. Without forcing him to plunge in over his +depth, I encourage him to understand himself to the fullest possible +extent. Besides individual private conferences, we have twice a day an +informal gathering of all the patients in my household—"the family" +as we like to call ourselves—for a reading or talk on the various +ways of the body and the mind, which need to be understood for normal +living and for the cure of nerves. Very often people of only average +education, long without the opportunity of study, gain in a +surprisingly short time enough insight to make new adaptations and +cure themselves. For this, a college education is not nearly so +important as an open mind. It is because of the success of this method +that I have been encouraged to reach a larger number of people by +means of a book, based on the same plan of re-education.</p> + +<p><b>Explanation vs. Suggestion.</b> Re-education through this kind of +explanation is simply a matter of learning the truth and acting upon +it. It is a process of real enlightenment, +<!-- Page 210 --><a name="Page_210" id="Page_210" />and is very different +from suggestion which trades upon the patient's credulity, increasing his +already exaggerated suggestibility.</p> + +<p>Freud illustrates the difference between suggestion and +psycho-analysis by saying that suggestion is like painting and +psycho-analysis like sculpture. Painting adds something from the +outside, plastering over the canvas with extraneous matter, while +sculpture cuts away the unnecessary material and reveals the angel in +the marble. So suggestion covers over the real trouble by crying, +"Peace, peace, when there is no peace." Without attempting to remove +the cause, it says to the patient: "You have no pain. You are not +tired. You will sleep to-night. You will be cheerful." Sometimes the +suggestion works and sometimes it does not, but at best the relief is +likely to be a mere temporary makeshift. The symptom may be relieved, +but the character is not changed and therefore no permanent relief is +assured. It is far better for a nervous person to say to himself, +"There is something wrong and I am going to find it," than to keep +repeating over and over, "There is nothing wrong," and so on through a +list of half-believed autosuggestions.</p> + +<p>On the other hand, psycho-analysis, and this kind of re-education +based on psycho-analytic principles, do not pay a great deal of +attention to the individual symptom. Instead of adding from without +they try to take <!-- Page 211 --><a name="Page_211" id="Page_211" /> +away whatever has proved a hindrance to normal +growth and development, and to remove unnecessary resistances which +are responsible for the symptom, and which have been holding the +patient back from the fullest self-expression.</p> + +<p><b>Incantation vs. Knowledge.</b> There came to me one day a well-known +public woman who had suffered from nervous indigestion for many years. +As she was able to be with me for only one night, we had time for just +one conversation, but in that time she discovered what she was doing +and lost her indigestion. In the course of the conversation she turned +to me, saying: "Doctor, I know what a force suggestion is. I believe +in its power. Will you tell me why I have not been able to cure myself +of this trouble? Every night after I go to bed I repeat over and over +these Bible verses," naming a number of passages relating to God's +goodness and care for His children. My answer was something like this: +"You are too intelligent a woman to be cured by an incantation. When +you feel surging up within you the sense of God's goodness, or when +you actually want to realize His loving kindness, then by all means +repeat the verses. But don't prostitute those wonderful words by +making them into a charm and then expect them to cure your +indigestion. It is a desecration of the words and a denial of your own +intelligence. Autosuggestion is a powerful force, but real +<!-- Page 212 --><a name="Page_212" id="Page_212" />psychotherapy +is based not on the mechanical repetition of any set of +words, but on a knowledge of the truth."</p> + +<p><b>The "Bullying Method."</b> Sometimes, to be sure, explanation is not +enough. The brain paths between the associated ideas are so deeply +worn that no amount of persuasion avails. It is easy for the doubter +to say: "Well, that sounds very well, but my case is different. I have +tried over and over again and I know." With people of this sort, an +ounce of demonstration is worth a pound of argument.</p> + +<p>By way of illustration we might mention the man who couldn't eat eggs. +To be sure, he had tried many times but always had suffered the most +intense cramps in his stomach, and no amount of talk could make him +believe that an egg was not poison to him. I took the straight road of +simply proving to him that he was mistaken, and had him eat an egg. +After a time of apprehension and retching, he vomited the egg, +thinking, of course, that he had proved his point. To his +astonishment, I said, "Now, let's go and eat another." With great +consternation, he finally complied, evidently expecting to die on the +spot; but as I immediately prescribed a game of tennis, he scarcely +had time to think of the pain, which in fact failed to appear. +However, as he thereafter insisted on eating four eggs a day,—with +eggs at top-notch price I decided that the joke was on the doctor!</p> + +<p><!-- Page 213 --><a name="Page_213" id="Page_213" /><b>Enjoying +the Right Things.</b> In substituting healthful complexes for +unhealthful ones, psychotherapy not only changes ideas and emotions, +but alters the feelings of pleasure or pain that are bound up with the +ideas. Dr. Tom A. Williams writes: "The essence of psychotherapy and +education is to associate useful activities with agreeable +feeling-tones and to dissociate from injurious acts the agreeable +feeling-tones that may have been acquired." Right character consists +not so much in enjoying things as in enjoying the right things.</p> + +<p>Some people enjoy being martyrs. They love to tell about the terrible +strain they have been under, the amount of work they have done, or the +number of times they have collapsed. One of my patients gave every +evidence of satisfaction as he told about his various breakdowns. "The +last time I was ill," or "That time when I was in the sanatorium," +were frequent phrases on his lips. Finally, after I had asked him if +he would boast about the number of times he had awkwardly fallen down +in the street, and had shown him that a neurosis is not really a +matter to be proud of, he saw the point and stopped taking pleasure in +his mistakes.</p> + +<p>Such signs of pleasure in the wrong things are evidence of suppressed +wishes which we do not acknowledge but try to gratify in indirect +ways.<a name="FNanchor_46" id="FNanchor_46"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_46" class="fnanchor">[46]</a> The pleasure +<!-- Page 214 --><a name="Page_214" id="Page_214" /> +which ought to be associated with the idea of +good work well done has somehow been switched over to the idea of +being an invalid. The satisfaction which ought to go with a sense of +power and ability to do things has attached itself to the idea of +weakness and inability. The pleasurable feeling-tone which normally +belongs to ministering to others, regresses in the nervous invalid to +the infantile satisfaction of being ministered unto.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_46" id="Footnote_46"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_46"><span class="label">[46]</span> +</a> For a further elaboration of this theme, see Holt: <i>The +Freudian Wish</i>.</p></div> + +<p>But these things are only a habit. A good look in the mirror soon +makes one right about face and start in the other direction. Once +started, a good habit is built up with surprising ease. It is really +much more satisfying to cook a good dinner for the family's comfort +than to think about one's ills; much pleasanter to enjoy a good meal +than to insist on hot water and toast. Once we have satisfied our +suppressed longings in more desirable ways, or by a process of +self-training have initiated a new set of habits, we feel again the +old zest in normal affairs, the old interest and pleasure in +activities which add to the joy of life. Thus does re-education fit a +man to take his place in the world's work as a socially useful being, +no longer a burden, but a contributor to the sum total of human +happiness.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p><b>Knowing and Doing.</b> Having set out to learn how +<!-- Page 215 --><a name="Page_215" id="Page_215" />to outwit our +nerves, we are now ready to sum up conclusions and in the following +chapters to apply them to the more common nervous symptoms. It has +been shown that a nervous person is in great need of change,—not, +indeed, a change in climate or in scene, in work or in diet, but a +change in the hidden recesses of his own being. Outwitting nerves +means first and foremost changing one's mind, an inner and spiritual +process very different from the kind of change which used to be +prescribed for the nervous invalid.</p> + +<p>As Putnam says, the slogan of the suggestion-school of psychotherapy +has always been, "You can do better if you try"; while that of the +psycho-analytic school is, "You can do better when you know." Refuting +the old adage, "Where ignorance is bliss 'tis folly to be wise," the +best methods of psychotherapy insist that the first step in any +thorough-going attempt to change oneself must be the great step of +self-knowledge. As the conflicts which result in "nerves" are always +far beyond those mental regions which are open to scrutiny, a real +self-knowledge requires an examination of the half-conscious or wholly +unconscious longings which are usually ignored. A real understanding +of self comes only when one is willing, to analyze his motives until +he sees the connection between them and his nervous symptoms, which +are but the symbolic gratification of desires he dares not +acknowledge.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 216 --><a name="Page_216" id="Page_216" />Although +these deeply buried complexes are the real force behind a +nervous illness, the material out of which the symptoms are +manufactured is taken largely from superficial misconceptions +concerning the bodily functions. It is therefore a great help, also, +to possess a fund of information,—not technical nor detailed but +accurate as far as it goes,—about the more important workings of the +bodily machinery. A little knowledge about the actual chemistry of +fatigue and the way it is automatically cared for by the body is +likely to do away with the idea of nervous exhaustion as resulting +from accumulation of fatigue. A simple understanding of the biological +and physiological facts concerning the assimilation of food and the +elimination of waste material leaves the intelligent person less ready +to convert his psychic discomfort into indigestion and constipation. +Chapters IX to XIII in this book, which at first glance may seem to +belong to a work on physiology rather than on psychology are designed +to give just such needed insight.</p> + +<p>But knowing the truth is only the first half of the way out. Every +neurosis is a deliberate choice by a part of the personality. +Self-discovery is helpful only when it leads to better ways of +self-expression. The final aim of psychotherapy is the happy +adjustment of the individual to the demands of society and the +establishment of useful outlets for his energy. This phase of +<!-- Page 217 --><a name="Page_217" id="Page_217" />the +subject will be discussed more fully in Chapter XVI.</p> + +<p><b>The Future Hope.</b> Much has been said about the cure of a neurosis. +There are enough people already in the maze of nervousness to warrant +the setting up of numerous signs reading, "This way out." But after +all, is not a blocking of the way in of vastly more importance? As it +is always easier to prevent than to cure, so it is easier to train +than to reform. If re-education is the cure, why is not education the +ounce of prevention which shall settle the problem for all time?</p> + +<p>If the general public understood what "nerves" are, it is hardly +conceivable that there could be so many breakdowns as there are at +present. If a man's family and friends, to say nothing of himself, +understood what he is doing when he suddenly collapses and has to quit +work, it is not likely that he would choose that way out of his +difficulties.</p> + +<p>Most important of all, when parents know that the foundation of +nervousness is laid in childhood, they will see to it that their +children are started right on the road to health. When fathers and +mothers realize that an over-strong bond between parents and children +is responsible for a large proportion of nervous troubles, most of +them will make sure that such exaggeration is not allowed to develop.</p> + +<p>And, finally, when parents are freed from their "conspiracy +<!-- Page 218 --><a name="Page_218" id="Page_218" />of +silence" by a reverent attitude toward the whole of life, their very +saneness will impart to their children a wholesome respect for the +reproductive instinct. There will then be found in the next generation +fewer half-starved men and women carrying the burden of unnecessary +repressions and the pain of unsatisfied yearnings.</p> + +<p>Not that such a day will usher in the millennium. We are not +suggesting a panacea for all the social ills. There is an inevitable +conflict between the instinctive urge of the life-force and the +demands of society, a conflict which makes men and women either finer +or baser, according to the way they handle it. What is claimed is that +the right kind of education—using the word in its largest, deepest +sense—will remove the most fruitful cause of nervousness by taking +away the extra burden of misconception and making it easier for people +to be "content with being +moral."<a name="FNanchor_47" id="FNanchor_47"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_47" class="fnanchor">[47]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_47" id="Footnote_47"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_47"><span class="label">[47]</span> +</a> Frink: <i>Morbid Fears and Compulsions.</i></p></div> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 219 --><a name="Page_219" id="Page_219" /></div> +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_IX" id="CHAPTER_IX">CHAPTER IX</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we discover new stores of energy and learn the truth about fatigue</i></p> + +<p class="heading">THAT TIRED FEELING</p> + +<p class="scheading">Unfailing Resources</p> + + +<p>"They that wait upon the Lord shall renew their strength. They shall +mount up with wings as eagles. They shall run and not be weary. They +shall walk and not faint."</p> + +<p>It is safe to say that many a person loves this promise of the prophet +Isaiah without taking it in anything like a literal sense. The words +are considered to be so figurative and so highly spiritualized that +they seem scarcely to relate at all to this earthly life, much less to +the possibilities of these physical bodies.</p> + +<p>Besides the nervous folk who feel themselves so weary that they +scarcely have strength to live, there are thousands upon thousands of +men and women who are called normal but who have lost much of the joy +of life because they feel their bodies inadequate to meet the demands +of everyday living.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 220 --><a name="Page_220" id="Page_220" />To such men +and women the Biblical promise, "As thy day, so shall thy +strength be," comes now as the message of modern science. Nature is +not stingy. She has not given the human race a meager inheritance. She +did not blunder when she made the human body, nor did she allow the +spirit of man to develop a civilization to whose demand his body is +not equal. After its long process of development through the survival +of the fittest, the human body, unless definitely diseased, is a +perfectly adequate instrument, as abundantly able to cope with the +complex demands of modern society as with the simpler but more +strenuous life of the stone age. The body has stored within its cells +enough energy in the shape of protein, carbohydrate and fat to meet +and more than meet any drains that are likely to be made upon it, +either through the monotony of the daily grind or the excitement of +sudden emergency. Nature never runs on a narrow margin. Her motto +seems everywhere to be, "Provide for the emergency, enough and to +spare, good measure, pressed down, running over." She does not start +her engines out with insufficient steam to complete the journey. On +the contrary, she has in most instances reserve boilers which are +almost never touched. As a rule the trouble is not so much a lack of +steam as the ignorance of the engineer who is unacquainted with his +engine and afraid to "let her out."</p> + +<p><!-- Page 221 --><a name="Page_221" id="Page_221" /> +<b>"The Energies of Men."</b> Perhaps nothing has done so much to reveal +the hidden powers of mankind as that remarkable essay of Professor +William James, "The Energies of Men."<a name="FNanchor_48" id="FNanchor_48"> +</a><a href="#Footnote_48" class="fnanchor">[48]</a> Listen to his introductory +paragraph as he opens up to us new "levels of energy" which are +usually "untapped":</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_48" id="Footnote_48"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_48"><span class="label">[48]</span> +</a> James: <i>On Vital Reserves</i>.</p></div> + +<div class="blockquot"><p>Every one knows what it is to start a piece of work, either + intellectual or muscular, feeling stale—or <i>cold</i>, as an + Adirondack guide once put it to me. And everybody knows what it + is to "warm up to his job." The process of warming up gets + particularly striking in the phenomenon known as the "second + wind." On usual occasions we make a practice of stopping an + occupation as soon as we meet the first effective layer (so to + call it) of fatigue. We have then walked, played or worked + "enough," so we desist. That amount of fatigue is an efficacious + obstruction on this side of which our usual life is cast. But if + an unusual necessity forces us to press onward, a surprising + thing occurs. The fatigue gets worse up to a certain critical + point, when gradually or suddenly it passes away, and we are + fresher than before. We have evidently tapped a level of new + energy, masked until then by the fatigue-obstacle usually obeyed. + There may be layer after layer of this experience. A third and + fourth "wind" may supervene. Mental activity shows the phenomenon + as well as physical, and in exceptional cases we + <!-- Page 222 --><a name="Page_222" id="Page_222" /> + may find, beyond the very extremity of fatigue-distress, amounts + of ease and power that we never dreamed ourselves to own, sources + of strength habitually not taxed at all, because habitually we + never push through the obstruction, never pass those early + critical points.</p></div> + +<p>Again Professor James says:</p> + +<div class="blockquot"><p>Of course there are limits; the trees don't grow into the sky. + But the plain fact remains that men the world over possess + amounts of resource which only very exceptional individuals push + to their extremes of use. But the very same individual, pushing + his energies to their extreme, may in a vast number of cases keep + the pace up day after day, and find no "reaction" of a bad sort, + so long as decent hygienic conditions are preserved. His more + active rate of energizing does not wreck him; for the organism + adapts itself, and as the rate of waste augments, augments + correspondingly the rate of repair.<a name="FNanchor_49" id="FNanchor_49"></a> + <a href="#Footnote_49" class="fnanchor">[49]</a></p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_49" id="Footnote_49"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_49"><span class="label">[49]</span></a> Ibid., pp. 6-7.</p></div> + +<p>Another psychologist, Boris Sidis, writes: "But a very small fraction +of the total amount of energy possessed by the organism is used in its +relation with the ordinary stimuli of its +environment."<a name="FNanchor_50" id="FNanchor_50"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_50" class="fnanchor">[50]</a> These +men—Professor James and Dr. Sidis—represent not young enthusiasts +who ignorantly fancy that every one shares their own abundant +strength, but careful men of science who have repeatedly been able to +unearth <!-- Page 223 --><a name="Page_223" id="Page_223" /> +unsuspected supplies of energy in "worn out" men and women, +supposed to be at the end of their resources. Every successful +physician and every leader of men knows the truth of these statements. +What would have happened in the great war if Marshal Foch had not +known that his men possessed powers far beyond their ken, and had not +had sublime faith in the "second wind"?</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_50" id="Footnote_50"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_50"><span class="label">[50]</span></a> Sidis: +P. 112 of the composite volume <i>Pychotherapeutics</i>.</p></div> + +<p><b>What about Being Tired?</b> If all these things are true, why do people +need to be told? If man's equipment is so adequate and his reserves +are so ample, why after all these centuries of living does the human +race need to learn from science the truth about its own powers? The +average man is very likely to say that it is all very well for a +scientist sitting in his laboratory to tell him about hidden +resources, but that he knows what it is to be tired. Is not the crux +of the whole question summed up in that word "tired"? If we do not +need to rest, why should fatigue exist? If the purpose of fatigue +seems to be to slow down our efforts, why should we disregard it or +seek to evade its warnings? The whole question resolves itself into +this: What is fatigue? In view of the hampering effect of +misconception on this point, it is evident that the question is not +academic, but intensely practical. We shall find that fatigue is of +two kinds,—true and false, or physical and moral, or physiological +<!-- Page 224 --><a name="Page_224" id="Page_224" /> +and nervous,—and that while the two kinds feel very much alike, +their origin and behavior are quite different.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Physiological Fatigue</p> + +<p><b>Fatigue, not Exhaustion.</b> In the first place, then, fatigue very +seldom means a lack of strength or an exhaustion of energy. The +average man in the course of a lifetime probably never knows what it +is to be truly exhausted. If he should become so tired that he could +in no circumstances run for his life, no matter how many wild beasts +were after him, then it might seem that he had drained himself of all +his store of energy. But even in that case, a large part of his +fatigue would be the result of another cause.</p> + +<p><b>A Matter of Chemistry.</b> True fatigue is a chemical affair. It is the +result of recent effort,—physical, mental, or emotional,—and is the +sum of sensations arising from the presence of waste material in the +muscles and the blood. The whole picture becomes clear if we think of +the body as a factory whose fires continuously burn, yielding heat and +energy, together with certain waste material,—carbon dioxide and ash. +Within man's body the fuel, instead of being the carbon of coal is the +carbon of glycogen or animal starch, taken in as food and stored away +within the cells of the muscles and the liver. The oxygen for +combustion is continuously supplied by the lungs. So +<!-- Page 225 --><a name="Page_225" id="Page_225" />far the factory +is well equipped to maintain its fires. Nor does it fail when it comes +to carrying away waste products. Like all factories, the body has its +endless chain arrangement, the blood stream, which automatically picks +up the debris in its tiny buckets—the blood-cells and serum—and +carries it away to the several dumping-grounds in lungs, kidneys, +intestines, and skin.</p> + +<p>Besides the products of combustion, there are always to be washed away +some broken-down particles from the tissues themselves, which, like +all machinery, are being continuously worn out and repaired. By +chemical tests in the laboratory, the physiologist finds that a muscle +which has recently been in violent exercise contains among other +things carbon dioxid, urea, creatin, and sarco-lactic acid, none of +which are found in a rested muscle. Since all this debris is acid in +reaction and since we are "marine animals," at home only in salt water +or alkaline solution, the cells must be quickly washed of the fatigue +products, which, if allowed to accumulate, would very soon poison the +body and put out the fires.</p> + +<p><b>No Back Debts.</b> The human machine is regulated to carry away its +fatigue products as fast as they are made, with but slight lagging +behind that is made good in the hours of sleep, when bodily activities +are lessened and time is allowed for repair. Unless the body is +definitely diseased, it virtually never carries over its <!-- Page 226 --> +<a name="Page_226" id="Page_226" />fatigue from +one day to another. In the matter of fatigue, there are no old debts +to pay. Nature renews herself in cycles, and her cycle is twenty-four +hours,—not nine or ten months as many school-teachers seem to +imagine, or eleven months as some business men suppose. In order to +make assurance doubly sure, many set apart every seventh day for a +rest day, for change of occupation and thought, and for catching up +any slight arrears which might exist. But the point is that a healthy +body never gets far behind.</p> + +<p>If through some flaw in the machine, waste products do pile up, they +destroy the machine. If the heart leaks or the blood-cells fail in +their carrying-power, or if lungs, kidneys or skin are out of repair, +there is sometimes an accumulation of fatigue products which poisons +the whole system and ends in death. But the person with tuberculosis +or heart trouble does not usually allow this to happen. The body +incapacitated by disease limits its activities as closely as possible +within the range of its power to take care of waste matter. Even the +sick body does not carry about its old toxins. The man who had not +eliminated the poisons of a month-old effort would not be a tired man. +He would be a dead man.</p> + +<p><b>A Sliding Scale.</b> If all this be true, real fatigue can only be the +result of recent effort. If one is still alive, the results of earlier +effort must long since have <!-- Page 227 --> +<a name="Page_227" id="Page_227" />disappeared. The tissue-cells retain not +the slightest trace of its effects. Fatigue cannot possibly last, +because it either kills us or cures itself. Up to a certain point, far +beyond our usual high-water mark, the more a person does the more he +can do. As Professor James has pointed out, the rate of repair +increases with the rate of combustion. Under unusual stress, the rate +of the whole machine is increased: the heart-pump speeds up, +respirations deepen and quicken, the blood flows faster, the endless +chain of filling and emptying buckets hurries the interchange of +oxygen and carbon dioxid, until the extreme capacity is reached and +the organism refuses to do more without a period of rest.</p> + +<p>The whole arrangement illustrates the wonderful provisions of Nature. +Although each individual is continuously manufacturing enough +carbonic-acid gas to kill himself in a very few minutes, he need not +be alarmed for fear that he may forget to expel his own poisons. +Nobody can hold his breath for more than a few minutes. The naughty +baby sometimes tries, but when he begins to get black in the face, he +takes a breath in spite of himself. The presence of carbonic-acid gas +in the circulation automatically regulates breathing, and the greater +the amount of gas the deeper the breath. The faster we burn the faster +we blow. As with breathing, so with all the rest of elimination and +repair. The body dares not get behind.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 228 --><a name="Page_228" id="Page_228" /> +<b>"Second Wind."</b> A city man frequently sets out on a mountain tramp +without any muscular preparation for the trip. He walks ten or fifteen +miles when his average is not over one or two. Sometimes after a few +hours he feels himself exhausted, but a glorious view opens out before +him and he goes on with new zest. He has merely increased his rate of +repair and drawn on a new stock of energy. That night he is tired, and +the next day he is likely to be stiff and sore. There is a little +fatigue left in him, but it takes only a day or two for the body to be +wholly refreshed, especially if he hastens the process by another good +walk. Up to a certain point, far beyond our usual limit, the more we +do, the more we can do.</p> + +<p>One day after a long walk my little daughter said that she could go no +farther and waited to be carried. But she soon spied a dog on ahead +and ran off after him with new zest. She followed the dog back and +forth, running more than a mile before she reached home, and then in +the exuberance of her spirits, ran around the house three times.</p> + +<p><b>The Emotions Again.</b> What is the key that unlocks new stores of +energy and drives away fatigue? What is it in the amateur +mountain-climbers that helps the body maintain its new standard? What +keeps indefatigable workers on the job long after the ordinary man has +tired? Is it not always an invigorating<!-- Page 229 --> +<a name="Page_229" id="Page_229" /> emotion,—the zest of +pursuit, the joy of battle, intense interest in work, or a new +enthusiasm? All great military commanders know the importance of +morale. They know that troops can stand more while they are going +forward than while running away, that the more contented and hopeful +they are, the better fighters they make; discouragement, lack of +interest, the fighting of a losing game, dearth of appreciation, +futility of effort, monotony of task, all conspire in soldier or +civilian to use up and to lock up energy which might have been +available for real work. Approaching the matter from a new angle, we +find once more that the difference between strength and weakness is in +many cases merely a difference in the emotions and feeling-tones which +habitually control.</p> + +<p>Fatigue is a safety-device of nature to keep us within safe limits, +but it is a device toward which we must not become too sensitive. As a +rule it makes us stop long before the danger point is reached. If we +fall into the habit of watching its first signals, they may easily +become so insistent that they monopolize attention. Attention +increases any sensation, especially if colored by fear. Fear adds to +the waste matter of fatigue little driblets of adrenalin and other +secretions which must somehow be eliminated before equilibrium is +reestablished. This creates a vicious circle. We are tired, hence we +are discouraged. We are discouraged, <!-- Page 230 --> +<a name="Page_230" id="Page_230" />hence we are more tired. This +kind of "tire" is a chemical condition, but it is produced not by work +but by an emotion. He who learns to take his fatigue philosophically, +as a natural and harmless phenomenon which will soon disappear if +ignored, is likely to find himself possessed of exceptional strength. +We can stand almost any amount of work, provided we do not multiply it +by worry. We can even stand a good deal of real anxiety provided it is +not turned in on ourselves and directed toward our own health.</p> + +<p><b>"Decent Hygienic Conditions."</b> If fatigue products cannot pile up, +why is extra rest ever needed? Because there is a limit to the supply +of fuel. If the fat-supply stored away for such emergencies finally +becomes low, we may need an extra dose of sleeping and eating in order +to let the reservoirs fill again. But this never takes very long. The +body soon fills in its reserves if it has anything like common-sense +care. The doctrine of reserve energy does not warrant a careless +burning of the candle at both ends. It presupposes "decent hygienic +conditions,"—eight hours in bed, three square meals a day, and a fair +amount of fresh air and exercise.</p> + +<p><b>"Over There."</b> On the other hand, the stories that floated back to us +from the war zone illustrate in the most powerful way what the human +body can do when necessity forbids the slightest attention to its +needs. <!-- Page 231 --><a name="Page_231" id="Page_231" />One +of the best of these stories is Dorothy Canfield's account +of Dr. Girard-Mangin, "France's Fighting Woman Doctor." Better than +any abstract discussion of human endurance is this vibrant narrative +of that little woman, "not very strong, slightly built, with some +serious constitutional weakness," who lived through hardships and +accomplished feats of daring which would have been considered beyond +the range of possibility—before the war.</p> + +<p>Think of her out there in her leaky makeshift hospital with her twenty +crude helpers and her hundreds of mortally sick typhoid patients; four +hundred and seventy days of continuous service with no place to +sleep—when there was a chance—except a freezing, wind-swept attic in +a deserted village. Think of her in the midst of that terrible Battle +of Verdun, during four black nights without a light, among those +delirious men, and then during the long, long ride with her dying +patients over the shell-swept roads. Listen to her as she speaks of +herself at the end of that ride, without a place to lay her head: "Oh, +then I did feel tired! That morning for the first time I knew how +tired I was, as I went dragging myself from door to door begging for a +room and a bed. It was because I was no longer working, you see. As +long as you have work to do you can go on." Then listen to her as she +receives her orders to rush to a new post, before she has had time +<!-- Page 232 --><a name="Page_232" id="Page_232" />to +lay herself on the bed she has finally found. "Then at once my +tiredness went away. It only lasted while I thought of getting to bed. +When I knew we were going into action once more, I was myself again." +Watch her as she rides on through the afternoon and the long dangerous +night; as she swallows her coffee and plum-cake, and operates for five +hours without stopping; as she sleeps in the only place there is—a +"quite comfortable chair" in a corner; and as she keeps up this life +for twenty days before she is sent—not on a vacation, mind you, but +to another strenuous post.<a name="FNanchor_51" id="FNanchor_51"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_51" class="fnanchor">[51]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_51" id="Footnote_51"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_51"><span class="label">[51]</span> +</a> Dorothy Canfield: <i>The Day of Glory.</i></p></div> + +<p>This brave little woman is not an isolated example of extraordinary +powers. The human race in the great war tapped new reservoirs of power +and discovered itself to be greater than it knew. Professor James's +assertions are completely proved,—that "as a rule men habitually use +only a small part of the powers which they actually possess," and that +"most of us may learn to push the barrier (of fatigue) further off, +and to live in perfect comfort on much higher levels of power."</p> + +<p><b>How?</b> The practical question is: how may we—the men and women of +ordinary powers, away from the extraordinary stimulus of a crisis like +the great war—attain our maximum and drop off the dreary mantle of +fatigue which so often holds us back from our best <!-- Page 233 --> +<a name="Page_233" id="Page_233" />efforts? It may be +that the first step is simply getting a true conception of physical +fatigue as something which needs to be feared only in case of a +diseased body, and which is quite likely to disappear under a little +judicious neglect.</p> + +<p>In the second place, fatigue shows itself to be closely bound up with +emotions and instincts. The great releasers of energy are the +instincts. What but the mothering instinct and the love of country +could uncover all those unsuspected reserves of Dr. Girard-Mangin and +others of her kind? What is it but the enthusiasm for work which +explains the indefatigable energy of Edison and Roosevelt? If the +wrong kind of emotion locks up energy, the right kind just as surely +unlocks great stores which have hitherto lain dormant. If most people +live below their possibilities, it is either because they have not +learned how to utilize the energy of their instinctive emotions in the +work they find to do, or because some of their strongest instincts +which are meant to supply motive power to the rest of life are locked +away by false ideas and unnecessary repressions, and so fail to feed +in the energy which they control. In such a case, the "spring tonic" +that is needed is a self-knowledge which shall release us from +hampering inhibitions and set us free for enthusiastic +self-expression.</p> + +<p class="scheading"><!-- Page 234 --> +<a name="Page_234" id="Page_234" />Nervous Fatigue</p> + +<p><i>What of the Nervous Invalid?</i> If the normal man lives constantly +below his maximum, what shall we say of the nervous invalid? +Fatigability is the very earmark of his condition. In many instances +he seems scarcely able to raise his hand to his head. Sometimes he can +scarcely speak for weariness. Frequently to walk a block sends him to +bed for a week. I once had a patient who felt that she had to raise +her eyelids very slowly for fear of over-exertion. She could speak +only about two or three words a day, the rest of the time talking in +whispers. She could not raise a glass to her lips if it were full of +water, but could manage it if only half full. A person nearly dead +with some fatal disease does not appear more powerless than a typical +neurasthenic.</p> + +<p>If it he true that accumulation of fatigue is promptly fatal, what +shall we say of the woman who says that she is still exhausted from +the labor of a year ago,—or of ten years ago? What of the business +man who travels from sanatorium to sanatorium because five years ago +he went through a strenuous year? What of the college student who is +broken down because he studied too hard, or the teacher who is worn +out because of ten hard years of teaching? There can be but one +answer. No matter what their feelings, they can be suffering from no +true physiological fatigue. Something <!-- Page 235 --> +<a name="Page_235" id="Page_235" />very real has happened to them, +but only through ignorance and the power of suggestion can it be +called fatigue and attributed to overwork.</p> + +<p><b>Stories of Real People.</b> Perhaps if we look over the stories of a few +people who have been members of my household, we may work our way to +an understanding of the truth. We give only the barest outline of the +facts, thinking that the cumulative effect of a number of cases will +outweigh a more detailed description of one or two. The most casual +survey shows that whatever it was that burdened these fine men and +women, it was not lack of energy. No matter how extreme had been their +exhaustion, they were able at once, without rest or any other physical +treatment, to summon strength for exertions quite up to those of a +normal person.</p> + +<p>The second point that stands out clearly to any one acquainted with +these inner histories is the conviction that in each case the trouble +was related in some way to the unsatisfied love-life, to the insistent +and thwarted instinct of reproduction. In some cases no search was +made for the cause. The simple explanation that there was no lack of +power was sufficient to release inhibited energy. But in every case +where the cause was sought, it was found to be some outer lack of +satisfaction, or some inner repression of the love-force.</p> + +<p><b>From Prostration to Tennis.</b> One young woman, +<!-- Page 236 --><a name="Page_236" id="Page_236" />Miss A., had suffered +for ten years from the extremest kind of fatigue. She could not walk a +block without support and without the feeling of great exhaustion. +Before her illness she had had a sweetheart. Not understanding her +normal physical sensations when he was near, she had felt them +extremely wicked and had repressed them with all her strength. Later, +she broke off the engagement, and a little while after developed the +neurosis. Within a week after coming to my house, she was playing +tennis, walking three miles to church, and generally living the life +of a normal person.</p> + +<p><b>Making Her Own Discoveries.</b> Then there was Miss B. who for four +years had been "exhausted." She had such severe pains in her legs that +she was almost helpless. If she sewed for half an hour on the sewing +machine, she would be in bed for two weeks. Although she was engaged +to be married, she could not possibly shop for her trousseau. Two +years before, a very able surgeon had been of the opinion that the +pain in the legs was caused by an ovarian tumor. He removed the tumor, +assuring the patient that she would be cured. However, despite the +operation and the force of the suggestion, the pains persisted.</p> + +<p>After she had been with me for a few days, she sewed for an hour on +the machine. In a day or so she took a four-mile walk in a cañon near +the house and, on returning in the afternoon, walked two and a half +<!-- Page 237 --><a name="Page_237" id="Page_237" />miles +down town to do some shopping. I did not make an analysis in +her case because she recovered so quickly,—going home well within two +weeks. But she declared that she had found the cause while reading in +one of the books on psychology. I had my suspicions that the +long-drawn-out engagement had something to do with the trouble, but I +did not confirm my opinion. A long engagement, by continually +stimulating desire without satisfying it, only too often leads to +nervous illness.</p> + +<p><b>Afraid of Heat.</b> Professor X., of a large Eastern college, had been +incapacitated for four years with a severe fatigue neurosis and an +intense fear of heat. Constantly watching the weather reports, he was +in the habit of fleeing to the Maine coast whenever the +weather-prophet predicted warm weather. After a short re.ëducation, he +discovered that his fatigue was symbolic of an inner feeling of +inadequacy, and that it bore no relation to his body. Discarding his +weariness and throwing all his energies into the Liberty Loan +Campaign, he found himself speaking almost continuously throughout one +of the hottest days in the history of California, with the thermometer +standing at 107 degrees. After that he had no doubt as to his cure.</p> + +<p><b>In Bed from Fear.</b> Miss C. was carried into my house rolled in a +blanket. She had been confined to her bed except for fifteen minutes a +day, during which <!-- Page 238 --><a name="Page_238" id="Page_238" />time +she was able to lie in a hammock! It seems +that her illness was the result of fear, an over-reaction to early +teaching about self-abuse. Her mother had frightened her terribly by +giving her the false idea that this practice often leads to insanity. +Having indulged in self-abuse, she believed herself going insane, and +very naturally succumbed to the effects of such a fear. After a few +days of re-education, she was as strong as any average person. Having +no clothing but for a sick-room, she borrowed hat, skirt, and shoes, +and walked to church, a three-mile walk.</p> + +<p><b>Empty Hands.</b> Miss Y., a fine woman of middle age, suffering from +extreme fatigue could neither sleep nor eat. She could only weep. She +had spent her life taking care of an invalid girl who had recently +died. Now her hands were empty. Like many a mother whose family has +grown up, she had no outlet for her mothering instinct, and her sense +of impotency expressed itself in the only way it knew how,—through +her body. As there is never any lack of unselfish work to be done, or +of people who need mothering, she soon found herself and learned how +to sublimate her energy in useful activities.</p> + +<p><b>Defying Nature.</b> One young man from Wyoming had felt himself obliged +to give up his business because he could neither work nor eat. It soon +cropped out that he and his wife had decided that they must not +<!-- Page 239 --><a name="Page_239" id="Page_239" />have +any children. With a better understanding of the great forces which +they were defying, his strength and his appetite came back and he went +back to work, rejoicing.</p> + +<p><b>Left-over Habits.</b> Often a state of fatigue is the result of a +carried-over habit. One of my patients, a young girl, had several +years before been operated on for exophthalmic goiter. This is a +disease of the thyroid gland, and is characterized by rapid heart, +extreme fatigue, and numerous other symptoms. Although this girl's +goiter had been removed, the symptoms still persisted. She could not +walk nor do even a little work, like wiping a few dishes. I took her +down on the beach, let her feel her own pulse and mine and then ran +with her on the sand. Again I let her feel our pulses and discover for +herself that hers had quickened no more than was normal and had slowed +down as soon as mine. After a few such lessons, she was convinced that +her symptoms were reverberations for which there was no longer any +physical cause.</p> + +<p>Another young girl, Miss L., had had a similar operation for goiter +six years before. Since that time she had been virtually bedridden. +During the first meal she had at my house her sister sat by her couch +because she must not be left alone. By the second meal the sister had +gone, and Miss L. ate at the table with the other guests. That night +she managed to crawl upstairs, <!-- Page 240 --> +<a name="Page_240" id="Page_240" />with a good deal of assistance and +with great terror at the probable results of such an effort. After +that, she walked up-stairs alone whenever she had occasion to go to +her room. Her heart will always be a little rapid and her body will +never be very strong, but she now lives a helpful happy life at home +and among her friends.</p> + +<p>In cases like this the exaggeration proves the counterfeit. Nobody +could have been so down and out <i>physically</i> without dying. The +exaggeration secures attention and gives the little satisfaction to +the natural desires which are denied expression, and which gain an +outlet through habit along the lines previously worn by the real +disease. Many a person is still suffering from an old pain or an old +disability whose cause has long since disappeared, but which is +stamped on the mind and believed in as a present reality. Since the +sensation is as real as ever, it is sometimes very hard to believe +that it is not legitimate, but if the person is intelligent, a little +explanation and re-education usually suffices.</p> + +<p><b>Twenty Years an Invalid.</b> Mr. S., from Ohio, had spent much of his +time for twenty years going from one sanatorium to another. There was +scarcely a health resort in the country with which he was not +familiar. The day he came to me he felt himself completely exhausted +by the two-block walk from the car. <!-- Page 241 --> +<a name="Page_241" id="Page_241" />He explained that he could +scarcely listen to what I was saying because his brain was so fagged +that concentration was impossible. When asked to read a book, he +dramatically exclaimed, "Books and I have parted company!" I set him +to work reading "Dear Enemy" but it was not a week before he was +devouring the deeper books on psychology, in complete forgetfulness of +the pains in his head. Playing golf and walking at least six miles +every day, he rejoiced in a new sense of strength in his body, which +for twenty years he had considered "used up." He is now doing a +man-sized job in the business and philanthropic life of his home city.</p> + +<p><b>Brain-fag.</b> This feeling of brain-fag is one of the commonest nervous +symptoms; and almost always it is supposed to be the result of +intellectual overwork. Some people who easily accept the idea that +physical work cannot cause nervous breakdown can scarcely give up the +deep-rooted notion that intense mental work is harmful. Intellectual +effort does give rise to fatigue in exactly the same way as does +physical exertion, but the body takes care of the waste products of +the one just as it does those of the other. Du Bois says that out of +all his nervous cases he has not found one which can be traced to +intellectual overwork. I can say the same thing, and I know no case in +all the literature of the subject whose symptoms I can believe to +<!-- Page 242 --><a name="Page_242" id="Page_242" />be +the result of mental labor.</p> + +<p>The college students who break down are not wrecked by intellectual +work. In some cases, one strong factor in their undoing is the strain +and readjustment necessary because of the discrepancies between some +of their deepest religious beliefs and the truth as they learn it in +the class-room. The other factors are merely those which play their +part in any neurosis.</p> + +<p><b>Re-educating the Teacher.</b> School-teachers are prone to believe +themselves worn out from the mental work and the strain of the +strenuous life of teaching. Many a fine, conscientious teacher has +come to me with this story of overwork. But the school-teacher is as +easily re-educated as is any one else. I usually begin the process by +stating that I taught school myself for ten years and can speak from +experience. After I explain that there is no physical reason why the +teachers of some cities are fagged out at the end of nine months while +those in other cities whose session is longer can hold on for ten +months, and stenographers who lead just as strenuous a life manage to +exist with only a two-weeks' vacation, they begin to see that perhaps +after all they have been fooling themselves by a suggestion, "setting" +themselves for just so long and expecting to be done up at the end of +the term. Many of these same teachers have gone back to their work +<!-- Page 243 --><a name="Page_243" id="Page_243" />with a new sense +of "enough and to spare" and some of them have +written back that they have passed triumphantly through especially +trying years with no sense of depletion.</p> + +<p>In any work, it is the feeling of strain which tells, the emotionalism +and feeling sorry for oneself because one has a hard job. It is +wonderful what a sense of power comes from the simple idea that we are +equal to our tasks.</p> + +<p><b>Sudden Relief.</b> The story of Mr. V. illustrates Professor James's +statement that often the fatigue gets worse up to a certain critical +point, and then suddenly passes away. Mr. V. was another patient who +was "physically exhausted." When the rest of "the family" went +clamming on the beach, he felt himself too weak for such exertions, so +I left him on the sand to hold the bag while the rest of us dug for +clams. The minute I turned my back he disappeared. I found him lying +flat on his back, resting, behind the bulk-head. I decided that he +needed the two-mile walk home and we all set out to walk. "Doctor, +this is cruel. It is dangerous. My knees can never stand this. I shall +be ill!" ran the constant refrain for the first mile. Then things went +a bit better. Toward the last he found, to his absolute astonishment, +that the fatigue had entirely rolled away. The last half-mile he +accomplished with perfect ease. Needless to say, he <!-- Page 244 --> +<a name="Page_244" id="Page_244" />never again +complained of physical exhaustion.</p> + +<p><b>False Neuritis.</b> Miss T. was suffering from fatigue and very severe +pains in her arms, pains which were supposed to be the result of real +neuritis, but which did not correspond to the physiological picture of +that disease. A consultation revealed the fact that her love-instinct +had been repeatedly stimulated, and then at the last, when it had +expected satisfaction, had been disappointed. A discussion of her +life, its inner forces, and her future aims helped to pull her +together again and give her instinct new outlets. The pains and the +fatigue disappeared at once.</p> + +<p><b>Something Wrong.</b> These cases are chosen at random and are typical of +scores of others. In no single case was the trouble feigned or +imaginary or unreal. But in every case it was a mistake. <i>The sense of +loss of muscular power was really a sense of loss of power on the part +of the soul.</i> Some inner force was reaching out, reaching out after +something which it could never quite attain. As it happened, in every +case that I analyzed, the force which felt itself defeated and +inadequate was the thwarted instinct of reproduction. Like a man +pinned to the ground by a stronger force, it felt itself most helpless +while struggling the hardest. Just as we feel a thrill of fright when +we step up in the dark and find no step there, so this instinct had +gotten itself ready for a step which was not there. Inner repressions +<!-- Page 245 --><a name="Page_245" id="Page_245" /> +or outer circumstances had denied satisfaction and left only an +undefined sense that something was wrong. The life-force, feeling +itself helpless, limp, tired, had no way of expressing itself except +in terms of the body. Since expression is itself a relief and an +outlet for feeling, the denied desire had seized on suggestions of +overwork to explain its sense of weariness, and had symbolized its +soul-pain by converting it into a physical pain. The feeling of +inadequacy was very real, but it was simply displaced from one part of +the personality to another,—from an unknown, inarticulate part to one +which was more familiar and which had its own means of expression.</p> + +<p><b>Locked-up Energy.</b> We do not know just how the soul can make its pain +so intensely real to the body, but we do know that any conviction on +the part of the subconscious mind is quickly expressed in the physical +machine. A conviction of pain or of powerlessness is very soon +converted into a feeling which can scarcely be denied. The mere +suggestion that the body is overworked is enough to make it tired.</p> + +<p>We know, too, that the instincts are the great releasers of energy. So +it happens that when our most dynamic instinct—that for the +reproduction of the race—is repressed, we lack one of the greatest +sources of usable energy. The energy is there, but it is not +accessible. Inhibited and locked away, it is not fed <!-- Page 246 --> +<a name="Page_246" id="Page_246" />into the engine, +and we feel exactly as though it were <i>nil</i>. Despite its name, the +disease neurasthenia does not signify a real asthenia or weakness. +Rather, it is a disorder in which there is plenty of energy that has +somehow been temporarily misplaced. Then, too, we must remember that +under the depressing influence of chronic fear, not quite so much +energy is stored away as would otherwise be. All the bodily functions +are slowed down; food is not so completely assimilated, the heart-beat +is weakened, the breathing is more shallow, and fatigue products are +more slowly eliminated. As Du Bois says, "An emotion tires the +organism more than the most intense physical or intellectual work."</p> + +<p><b>Avoid the Rest-Cure.</b> It is a healthful sign that the rest-cure is +fast going out of style. Wherever it has helped a nervous patient, the +real curative agent has been the personality of the doctor and the +patient's faith in him. The whole theory was based on ignorance of the +cause of nerves. People suffering from "nervous exhaustion" are likely +to be just as "tired" after a month in bed as they were before. Why +not? Physical fatigue is quickly remedied, and what can rest do after +that? What possible effect can rest have on the fatigue of a +discouraged instinct? Since the best releaser of energy is enthusiasm, +don't try to get that by lying around in bed or playing checkers at a +health resort.</p> + +<p class="scheading"><!-- Page 247 --><a name="Page_247" id="Page_247" />Summary</p> + +<p>If you are chronically and perpetually fatigued, or if you tire more +easily than the other people you know, consult a competent physician +and let him look you over. If he tells you that you have neither +tuberculosis, heart trouble, Bright's disease, nor any other +demonstrable disease, that you are physically fit and "merely +nervous," give yourself a good shake and commit the following +paragraphs to memory.</p> + + +<p class="center">A CATECHISM FOR THE WEARY ONE</p> + +<div class="blockquot"> +<p> <br /> WHAT?</p> + +<p>Q. What is fatigue?</p> + +<p>A. It is a chemical condition resulting from effort that is very + recent.</p> + +<p>Q. What else creates fatigue?</p> + +<p>A. Worry, fear, resentment, discontent, and other depressing + emotions.</p> + +<p>Q. What magnifies fatigue?</p> + +<p>A. Attention to the feeling.</p> + +<p>Q. What makes us weary long after the cause is removed?</p> + +<p>A. Habit.</p> + +<p> <br />WHY?</p> + +<p>Q. Why do many people believe themselves over-worked?</p> + +<p>A. Because of the power of suggestion.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 248 --><a name="Page_248" id="Page_248" />Q. Why do they take the suggestion?</p> + +<p>A. Because it serves their need and expresses their inner feelings.</p> + +<p>Q. Why are they willing to choose such an uncomfortable mode of +expression?</p> + +<p>A. Because they don't know what they are doing, and the subconscious +is very insistent.</p> + +<p> <br />WHO?</p> + +<p>Q. Who gets up tired every morning?</p> + +<p>A. The neurotic.</p> + +<p>Q. Who fancies his brain so exhausted that a little concentration is +impossible?</p> + +<p>A. The neurotic.</p> + +<p>Q. Who still believes himself exhausted as the result of work that is +now ancient history?</p> + +<p>A. The neurotic.</p> + +<p>Q. Who lays all his woes to overwork?</p> + +<p>A. The neurotic.</p> + +<p>Q. Who complains of fatigue before he has well begun?</p> + +<p>A. The neurotic.</p> + +<p>Q. Who may drop his fatigue as soon as he "gets the idea?"</p> + +<p>A. The neurotic.</p> + +<p> <br />HOW?</p> + +<p>Q. How can he get the idea?</p> + +<p>A. By understanding himself.</p> + +<p>Q. How may he express his inner feelings?<!-- Page 249 --><a name="Page_249" id="Page_249" /></p> + +<p>A. By choosing a better way.</p> + +<p>Q. How can he forget his fatigue?</p> + +<p>A. By ignoring it.</p> + +<p>Q. How can he ignore it?</p> + +<p>A. By finding a good stiff job.</p> + +<p>If he wants advice in a nutshell, here it is: <br />Get understanding! + Get courage! Get busy!</p></div> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 250 --><a name="Page_250" id="Page_250" /></div> +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_X" id="CHAPTER_X">CHAPTER X</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which the ban is lifted</i></p> + +<p class="heading">DIETARY TABOOS</p> + +<p class="scheading">Misunderstood Stomachs</p> + + +<p><b>Modern Improvements.</b> Most people have heard the story of the little +girl who wanted to know what made her hair snap. After she had been +informed that there was probably electricity in her hair, she sat +quiet for a few minutes and then exclaimed: "Our family has all the +modern improvements! I have electricity in my hair and Grandma has gas +on her stomach!" Judged by this standard many American families are +well abreast of the times; and if we include among the modern +improvements not only gas on the stomach but also nervous dyspepsia, +acid stomach, indigestion, sick-headache, and biliousness, we must +conclude that a good proportion of the population is both modern and +improved.</p> + +<p>Despite all this the stomach is one of the best-equipped mechanisms in +the world. It, at least, is not modern. After their age-long +development the organs <!-- Page 251 --><a name="Page_251" id="Page_251" /> +of the body are remarkably standardized and +adapted to the work required of them. It is safe to say that ninety +per cent. of all so-called "stomach trouble" is due not to any +inherent weakness of the organ itself but to a misunderstanding +between the stomach and its owner.</p> + +<p><b>Organic Trouble.</b> Unfortunately, there are a few real organic causes +for trouble. There are a few cancers of the stomach and a certain +number of ulcers. But if the patients whom I have seen are in any way +typical, the ulcers that really are cannot compare in number with the +ulcers that are supposed to be. Patients go to physicians with so many +tales of digestive distress that even the best doctors are fooled +unless they are especially alert to the ways of "nerves." They must +find some explanation for all the various functional disturbances +which the patients report, and as they are in the habit of taking only +the body into account, they find the diagnosis of stomach ulcer as +satisfactory as any.</p> + +<p>There is, of course, such a thing as an enlarged or sagging stomach. +But it is only in the rarest of cases that such a condition leads to +any functional disturbances unless complicated by suggestion. In most +cases a person can go about his business as happily as ever unless he +gets the idea that ptosis must inevitably lead to pain and discomfort.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 252 --><a name="Page_252" id="Page_252" />Confusion +sometimes arises when the stomach is blamed for +disturbances which originate elsewhere. One day a very sick-looking +girl came to me with eager expectation written all over her face. Her +stomach was misbehaving and she had heard that I could cure nervous +indigestion. It needed little more than a glance to know that she was +suffering from organic heart trouble. A boy of sixteen had been taking +a stomach-tonic for three months, but the thin, wiry pulse pointed to +a different ailment. His digestive disturbances were merely the echo +of an organic disease of the kidneys. When the body is burdened by +disease, it may have little energy left for digesting food, but in +that case the trouble must be sought in other quarters than the +stomach.</p> + +<p>Aside from a few organic difficulties, there is almost no real disease +of the stomach. Its misdoings are not matters of food and chemistry, +muscle-power and nerve supply, but are the end results of slips in the +mental and emotional life of its owner.</p> + +<p><b>Fads Dynamogenic.</b> What is it that gives the impetus to fads about +eating, or about religious belief? Are they advocated by the +individual whose libido is finding abundant expression in the natural +channels of business and family life, or by his less fortunate brother +who can gain a sense of power only by means of some unaccustomed idea? +William James says:<!-- Page 253 --><a name="Page_253" id="Page_253" /></p> + +<div class="blockquot"><p>This leads me to say a word about ideas considered as dynamogenic + agents or stimuli for unlocking what would otherwise be unused + reservoirs of individual power.... In general, whether a given + idea shall be a live idea depends more on the person into whose + mind it is injected than on the idea itself. Which is the + suggestive idea for this person and which for that one? Mr. + Fletcher's disciples regenerate themselves by the idea (and the + fact) that they are chewing and re-chewing and super-chewing + their food. Dr. Dewey's pupils regenerate themselves by going + without their breakfast—a fact, but also an ascetic idea. Not + every one can use these ideas with the same success.</p></div> + +<p>Because it is so adaptable and sturdy, the stomach lends itself +readily to these devices for gaining self-expression; but the danger +lies in bringing the process of digestion into conscious attention +which interferes with automatic functioning. Still further, the +disregard of physiological chemistry is likely to deprive the body of +food-stuffs which it requires.</p> + +<p>The average person is too sensible to be carried off his feet by the +enthusiasm of the health-crank, but as most of us are likely to pick +up a few false notions, it may be well to be armed with the simple +principles of food chemistry in order to combat the fads which so +easily beset us and to know why we are right when we insist on eating +three regular meals of the mixed and <!-- Page 254 --> +<a name="Page_254" id="Page_254" />varied diet which has proved +best for the race through so many years of trial and experience.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">What We Need to Eat</p> + +<p><b>The Essence of Dietetics.</b> To the layman the average discussion of +food principles is, to say the least, confusing. Dealing largely, as +it does, with unfamiliar terms like carbohydrate and hydrocarbon and +calories, it is hard to translate into the terms of the potatoes left +over from dinner and the vegetables we can afford to buy. But the +practical deductions are not at all difficult to understand. Boiled +down to their simplest terms, the essential principles may be stated +in a few sentences. The body must secure from the food that we eat, +tissue for its cells, energy for immediate use or to be stored for +emergency, mineral salts, vitamins, water and a certain bulk from +fruits and vegetables,—this latter to aid in the elimination of waste +matter.</p> + +<p>Food for repairing bodily tissue is called protein and is secured from +meat, eggs, milk, and certain vegetables, notably peas. Fuel for heat +and energy is in two forms—carbohydrate (starch and sugar) and fat. +We get sugar from sugar-cane and beets, and from syrups, fruit, and +honey. Starch is furnished from flour products—mainly bread—from +rice, potatoes, macaroni, tapioca, and many vegetables. Fats come from +milk and butter, from nuts, from meat-fat—bacon, lard and suet—and +from vegetable oils. The mineral <!-- Page 255 --><a name="Page_255" id="Page_255" /> +salts are obtained mainly from fruit +and vegetables, which also provide certain mysterious vitamins +necessary for health, but as yet not well understood.</p> + +<p><b>What the Market Affords.</b> The moral from all this is plain. The human +body needs all the foods which are ordinarily served on the table. +Whenever, through fad or through fear, we leave out of our diet any +standard food, we are running a risk of cutting the body down on some +element which it needs. They say that variety is the spice of life. In +the matter of food it is more than that, it is the essence of life. +Eat everything that the market affords and you will be sure to be well +nourished. If you leave out meat you will make your body work overtime +to secure enough tissue material from other foods. If you leave out +white bread, you will lose one of the greatest sources of energy. If +you leave out tomatoes and cucumbers and strawberries, you deprive +your body of the salts and vitamins which are essential.</p> + +<p><b>A Simple Rule.</b> There is one point that is good to remember. The +average person needs twice as much starch as he needs of protein and +fat together. That is, if he needs four parts of protein and three of +fat, he ought to eat about fourteen parts of starch. This does not +mean that we need to bother ourselves with troublesome tables of what +to eat, but only to keep in mind in a general way that we need more +bread and <!-- Page 256 --><a name="Page_256" id="Page_256" /> +potatoes than we do meat and eggs. The body does not have +to rebuild itself every day. It is probable that a good many people +eat too much protein food. If a man is doing hearty work he must have +a good supply of meat, but the average person needs only a moderate +amount. Here again, the habits of the more intelligent families are +likely to come pretty near the dictates of science.</p> + +<p><b>For the Children.</b> The mother of a family ought to know that the +children need plenty of bread, butter, and milk. Despite all the +notions to the contrary, good well-baked white bread is neither +indigestible nor constipating. It is indeed the staff of life. Two +large slices should form the background of every meal, unless there is +an extraordinary amount of other starchy food or unless the person is +too fat. Milk-fat (from whole milk, cream, and butter) is by far the +best fat for children. Besides fat, it furnishes a certain +growth-principle necessary for development. As the dairyman cannot +raise good calves on skimmed milk, so we cannot raise robust children +without plenty of butter and milk. The pity of it is that poor people +are forced to try! Milk is also the best protein for children, whose +kidneys may be overstrained by trying to care for the waste matter +from an excessive quantity of eggs and meat. Bread and butter, milk, +fruit, vegetables, and sugar in ample quantities and meat and eggs in +<!-- Page 257 --><a name="Page_257" id="Page_257" /> +moderate quantities are pretty sure to make the kind of children we +want. Above all things, let us train them not to be afraid of normal +amounts of any regular food or of any combination of foods.</p> + +<p><b>The Fear of Mixtures.</b> There are many people who can without +flinching face almost any single food, but who quail before mixtures. +Perhaps there is no notion which is more firmly entrenched in the +popular mind than this fear of certain food-combinations, acquired +largely from the advertisements of certain so-called "food +specialists."</p> + +<p>The most persistent idea is the fear of acid and milk. It is +interesting to watch the new people when they first come to my table. +Confronted with grape-fruit and cream at the same meal, or oranges and +milk, or cucumbers and milk, they eat under protest, in consternation +over the disastrous results that are sure to follow. Out of all these +scores of people, many of whom are supposed to have weak stomachs, I +have never had one case of indigestion from such a combination. When a +person knows that the stomach juices themselves include hydrochloric +acid which is far more acid than any orange or grapefruit, that the +milk curdles as soon as it reaches the stomach, and that it must +curdle if it is to be digested, he has to be very "set" indeed if he +is to cling to any remnant of fear.</p> + +<p>Of course to say that the stomach is well prepared <!-- Page 258 --> +<a name="Page_258" id="Page_258" />chemically, +muscularly, and by its nerve supply to handle any combination of +ordinary food in ordinary amounts is not the same thing as saying that +we may devour with impunity any amount of anything. It is a good thing +for every one to know when he has reached his limit, and a person with +organic heart disease should avoid eating large quantities at one +time, or when he is extraordinarily fatigued or emotionally disturbed, +lest at such a time he may put a fatal strain on the pneumogastric +nerve that controls both stomach and heart.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Fear of Certain Foods</p> + +<p><b>Physical Idiosyncrasies.</b> Most of our false fears on food subjects +come from some tradition—either a social tradition or a little +private, pet tradition of one's own. Some one once was ill after +eating strawberries and cream. What more natural than to look back to +those little curdles in the dish and to start the tradition that such +mixtures are dangerous? The worst of it is that the taboo habit is +very likely to grow. One after another, innocent foods are thrown out +until one wonders what is left. A patient of mine, Mr. G., told me +that he had a short time before gone to a physician with a tale of woe +about his sour stomach. "What are you eating?" asked the doctor. "Bran +crackers and prunes." "Then," said the learned doctor, +"you will <!-- Page 259 --><a name="Page_259" id="Page_259" />have +to cut out the prunes!" Needless to say, this man ate everything at my +table, and flourished accordingly.</p> + +<p>There may be such a thing as physical idiosyncrasies for certain +foods. I have often heard of them, but I have never seen one. I have +often challenged my patients to show me some of the "spells" which +they say invariably follow the eating of certain foods, but I have +almost never been given an exhibition. The man who couldn't eat eggs +did throw up once, but he couldn't do it a second time. Many people +have threatened to break out with hives after strawberries. One woman +triumphantly brought me what looked like a nice eruption, but which +proved to be the after-results of a hungry flea! After that she ate +strawberries,—without the flea and without the hives.</p> + +<p><b>Not Miracles but Ideas.</b> Conversions on food subjects are so common +at my table that I should have difficulty in remembering the +individual stories. Scores of them run together in my mind and make a +sort of composite narrative something like this: "Oh, no, thank you, I +don't eat this. You really must excuse me. I have tried many times and +it is invariably disastrous." Then a reluctant yielding and a day or +two later some talk about miracles. "It really is wonderful. I don't +understand," etc. Experiences like these only go to show the power of +the subconscious mind, both in <!-- Page 260 --><a name="Page_260" id="Page_260" /> +building up wrong habit-reactions and +in quickly substituting healthy ones, once the false idea is removed.</p> + +<p>Among my stomach-patients there were two men, brothers-in-law, +immigrants from the Austrian Tyrol, and now resident in one of the +cow-boy states. Leonardo spoke little English, and though Giovanni +understood a very little, he spoke only Italian.</p> + +<p>Several years before I knew them, Giovanni had developed a severe case +of stomach trouble and had finally gone to a medical center for +operation. The disturbance, however, was not relieved by the operation +and before long his brother-in-law fell into the same kind of trouble. +For several years the two had spent much of their time dieting, +vomiting, and worrying over their sour stomachs. Giovanni finally +became so ill that his sick-benefit society had actually assessed its +members to pay for his funeral expenses. About this time a business +man of their town, impressed by the cure of a former patient who had +made a quick recovery after seven years of invalidism, persuaded the +two men to take their little savings and come to California to be +under my care. The evening meal and breakfast went smoothly enough, +although the menu included articles which they had been taught to +avoid. However, as I left the house on a necessary absence soon after +breakfast, I saw Leonardo weeping in the garden and Giovanni spitting +up his breakfast, out at <!-- Page 261 --><a name="Page_261" id="Page_261" /> +the entrance gate. On my return, I found one +of "the family" literally sitting on the coat-tails of Leonardo, while +Giovanni hovered at a distance, safe from capture. Leonardo upbraided +me bitterly for having undone all the gain they had made in the long +months of rigid dieting, for now the vomiting had returned, because +they had eaten sugar on their oatmeal at breakfast! I made Leonardo +drink an egg-nog, took him into the consultation-room and held my hand +on his knee to keep him in his chair, while explaining to him as best +I could the physiologic action of the hydrochloric acid on the +digestive juice, which he feared as a sour stomach, the sign of +indigestion.</p> + +<p>During the conversation I said, "I suppose Giovanni imitated you in +this mistaken fear about your health." The reply was, "No, I got it +off him!" Nearly two hours later he exclaimed in astonishment: "Why, +that milk hasn't come up! Maybe I am cured!" "Of course you are +cured," I answered; "there never was anything really the matter with +your stomach, so you are cured as soon as you think you are."</p> + +<p>Later Giovanni was inveigled into the house by the promise that he +would have to eat nothing more than milk soup. All was smooth sailing +after this. For my own part I feared for the permanency of the cure, +for they were returning to the old environment. But more than three +years have passed, and grateful <!-- Page 262 --> +<a name="Page_262" id="Page_262" />letters still come telling of their +continued health.</p> + +<p>Another patient, a teacher of domestic science in a big Eastern +university, had lived on skimmed milk and lime-water from Easter to +Thanksgiving. Several attempts to enlarge the dietary by adding cream +or white of egg had only served to increase the sense of discomfort. +Finding nothing in the history of the case to warrant a diagnosis of +organic disease of the stomach, I served her plate with the regular +dinner, bidding her have no hesitancy even over the pork chops and +potato chips. She gained nine pounds in weight the first week, and in +two and a half months was forty pounds to the good.</p> + +<p><b>When Re-education Failed.</b> But there is one patient who has had to +have his lesson repeated at intervals. This man laughingly calls +himself a disgrace to his doctor because he is a "repeater." His story +illustrates the power of an autosuggestion and the disastrous effect +of attention to a physiological function. When Mr. T. came first to me +he weighed only 120 pounds, although he is over six feet tall and of +large frame. From the age of sixteen he had followed fads in eating +and thought he had a weak stomach. I treated his "weak stomach" to +everything there was in the market, including mince-pies, cabbage, +cheese, and all the other so-called indigestibles. He gained 16-1/2 +pounds the first week and 31 pounds in five weeks. <!-- Page 263 --> +<a name="Page_263" id="Page_263" />One would think +that the idea about the weak stomach would have died a natural death, +but it did not. Again and again he came back to me like a living +skeleton, the last time weighing only 105 pounds, and again and again +he has gone back to his home in the Middle West plump and well. Twice +while he was at home he underwent unnecessary operations, once for an +ulcer that was not there and once for supposed chronic spasm of the +pylorus. Needless to say, the operations did not help. You cannot cut +out an idea with a knife. Neither can you wash it out with a +stomach-pump; else would Mr. T. long ago have been cured! This +particular idea of his seems to be proof against all my best efforts +at re-education. Psycho-analysis is impracticable, partly because of +the duration of the habit of repression, but the history, and certain +symbolic symptoms, indicate the Freudian mechanisms at work. All I can +do is to feed him up, bully him along, and keep him from starving to +death. Just now he is doing very well at home, although he has moved +to California so as not to be too far away from "the miracle-worker."</p> + +<p>If Mr. T.'s case had been typical, I should long ago have lost my +faith in psychotherapy. Keeping people from starving is worth while, +but is less satisfactory than curing them of what ails them. The +nervous patient who has a relapse is no credit to his <!-- Page 264 --> +<a name="Page_264" id="Page_264" />doctor. It is +only when the origin of his trouble is not removed that the bond of +transference tends to become permanent. The neurotic who is well only +while under the influence of his physician is still a neurotic. +However, as most people's complexes are neither so deeply buried nor +so obstinate as this, a simple explanation or a single demonstration +is usually enough to loose the fettering hold of old misconceptions.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Common Ailments</p> + +<p><b>"Gas on the Stomach."</b> We all know people who suffer from "gas." +Indeed, very few of us escape an occasional desire to belch after a +hearty meal. But the person with nervous indigestion rolls out the +"gas" with such force that the noise can sometimes be heard all over +the house. He may keep this up for hours at a time, under the +conviction that he is freeing himself from the products of fermenting +food. He may exhibit a well-bloated stomach as proof of the disastrous +effect of certain articles of diet. The gas and the bloating are +supposed to be the sign and the seal of indigestion, a positive +evidence that undigested food is fermenting in the stomach.</p> + +<p>But what is fermentation? It is, necessarily, a question of the growth +of bacteria and is a process which we may easily watch in our own +kitchens. Bread rises when the yeast-cells have multiplied and acted +on the <!-- Page 265 --><a name="Page_265" id="Page_265" />starch +of the flour, producing enough gas to raise the whole +mass. Potatoes ferment because bacteria have multiplied within them. +Canned fruit blows up because enough bacteria have developed inside to +produce sufficient gas to blow open the can. Every housewife knows +that it takes time for each of these processes. Bread has to stand +several hours before it will rise; potatoes do not ferment under +twelve hours, and canned fruit is not considered safe from the +fermenting process under three days. Evidently there is some mistake +when a person begins to belch forth "gas" within an hour or two after +a meal. As a matter of fact, it is not gas at all but merely air that +is swallowed with the food or that was present in the empty stomach.</p> + +<p>When the food enters the stomach it necessarily displaces air, which +normally comes out automatically and noiselessly. But if, through fear +or attention, a certain set of muscles contract, the pent-up air may +come forth awkwardly and noisily or it may stay imprisoned until we +take measures to let it out. A hearty laugh is as good as anything, +but if that cannot be managed, we may have to resort to a cup of hot +water which gives the stomach a slap and makes it let go. Two belches +are enough to relieve the pressure. After that we merely go on +swallowing air and letting it out again, a habit both awkward and +useless.</p> + +<p>If the emotion which ties the muscle-knot is very <!-- Page 266 --> +<a name="Page_266" id="Page_266" />intense, and the +stomach refuses to let go under ordinary measures, the pain may be +severe. But a quantity of hot water or a dose of ipecac is sure to +relieve the situation. If the person is able to give himself a good +moral slap and relax his unruly muscles, he reaches the same end by a +much pleasanter road.</p> + +<p>Some people are fond of the popular remedy of hot water and soda. +Their faith in its efficacy is likely to be increased by the good +display of gas which is sure to follow. As any cook knows, soda and +acid always fizz. The soda is broken up by the hydrochloric acid of +the stomach and forms salt and carbon dioxid, a gas. However, as the +avowed aim of the remedy is the relief of gas rather than its +manufacture, and as the soda uses up the hydrochloric acid needed in +digestion, the practice cannot be recommended as reasonable.</p> + +<p><b>Gastritis.</b> I once knew a woman who went to a big city to consult a +fashionable doctor. When she returned she told with great satisfaction +that the doctor had pronounced her case gastritis. "It must be true," +she added, "because I have so much gas on my stomach!" The diagnosis +of gastritis used to be very common. The ending <i>itis</i> means +inflammation,—gastritis, enteritis, colitis, each meaning +inflammation of the corresponding organ. An inflammation implies an +irritant. There can be no kind of <i>itis</i> without the presence of +something which irritates the membrane of the <!-- Page 267 --> +<a name="Page_267" id="Page_267" />affected part. If we +get unusual and irritating bacteria in some spoiled food, we are +likely to have an acute inflammation until the offending bacteria are +expelled. But an inflammation of this kind never lasts. People who +have had ptomaine poisoning sometimes assert that they are afterwards +susceptible to poisoning by the kind of food which first made them +ill. Such a susceptibility is not so much a hold-over effect from the +poison as a hold-over fear which tends to repeat the physical reaction +whenever that food is eaten. I, myself, have had ptomaine poisoning +from canned salmon, but I have never since had any trouble about +eating salmon.</p> + +<p><b>Sour Stomach.</b> Sometimes when a person lies down an hour or so after +a meal, some of the contents of his stomach comes up in his throat. +Then if he be ignorant of physiology, he may be very much alarmed +because his stomach is "sour." Not knowing that he would have far +greater cause for alarm if his stomach were <i>not</i> sour, he may, if the +idea is interesting to him, begin to restrict his diet, to take +digestive tablets, and to develop a regular case of nervous dyspepsia. +Sometimes when the specialists measure the amount of hydrochloric acid +in the stomach, they do find too much or too little acid; but this +merely means that an emotion has made the glands work overtime or has +stopped their action for a little while. The functions +<!-- Page 268 --><a name="Page_268" id="Page_268" />of the body +are so very, very old that there is little likelihood of permanent disturbance.</p> + +<p><b>Biliousness.</b> The stomach is not the only part of the body concerning +which we lack proper confidence. Next to it the liver is the most +maligned organ in the whole body. Although the liver is about as +likely to be upset in its process of secreting bile as the ocean is +likely to be lacking in salt, many an intelligent person labels every +little disturbance "biliousness" and lays it at the door of his +faithful, dependable liver.</p> + +<p>As a matter of fact, the liver is liable to injury from virtually but +three sources—alcohol, bacterial infection, and cancer—and even a +liver hardened by alcohol goes on secreting bile as usual. The patient +dies of dropsy but not of "liver complaint."</p> + +<p>Some people act as if they thought bile were a poison. On the +contrary, it is a very useful digestant; it aids in keeping down the +number of harmful bacteria and helps to carry the food from intestines +to blood. Every day the liver manufactures at least a pint of this +important fluid. The body uses what it needs and stores the surplus +for reserve in the gall-bladder. The flow is continuous and, despite +all appearances to the contrary, there is no such thing as a torpid or +an over-active liver.</p> + +<p>It is true that after a "bilious" person has vomited for a few minutes +he is likely to throw up a certain <!-- Page 269 --><a name="Page_269" id="Page_269" /> +amount of bile, which is supposed +to have been lying in his stomach and causing the nausea. In fact, +however, this bile is merely a part of the usual supply stored away in +the gall-bladder. By the very act of retching, the bile is forced out +of the bile channels into the stomach and thence up into the mouth. +Anybody can throw up bile at any time if he only tries hard enough.</p> + +<p>One of the favorite habits of certain people is the taking of calomel +and salts. After such a dose they view with satisfaction the green +character of the stools and conclude that they have rid themselves of +a great amount of harmful matter. As a matter of fact, the greater +part of the coloring in the stools is from the calomel itself, changed +in the intestines from one salt of mercury to another. Any excess bile +is the result of the irritating action of the calomel on the +intestinal wall, an irritation which makes the bowel hurry to cast out +this foreign substance without waiting for the bile to be absorbed as +usual.</p> + +<p>A patient once told me that he had bought medicine from a street fakir +and by his direction had followed it with a dose of salts. He saved +the bowel movement, washed it in a sieve, and discovered a great +number of "gall-stones," which the medicine had so effectively washed +from his system. He was much astonished when I told him that his +gall-stones were merely pieces <!-- Page 270 --> +<a name="Page_270" id="Page_270" />of soap. He did not know that +everybody manufactures soap in his body every day, and that by taking +an extra quantity of oil in the shape of the fakir's medicine and an +extra quantity of potash in the salts, he had merely augmented a +normal physiological process. The supposed action of calomel belongs +to the same class of phenomena, and has no slightest effect on the +liver or on real gall-stones, which are the precipitate of bile-salts +in the gall-bladder, and which cannot be reached by any medicine.</p> + +<p>If the popular notions about biliousness are ill founded, what then +causes the disturbances which undoubtedly do occur and which show +themselves in attacks of nausea or sick headache? The answer can be +given in a word of four letters; a coated tongue, a bilious attack and +a sick headache are all the outcome of a mood. Stocks have gone down +or the wife is cranky or the neighbors are hateful. Adrenalin and +thyroid secretions are poured out as the result of emotion; digestion +is stopped, circulation disturbed, and the whole apparatus thrown out +of gear.</p> + +<p><b>Sick-Headache.</b> Sick-headache is primarily a circulatory disturbance; +and although the disturbance may have been inaugurated by some +chemical unbalance, the sum total of the force that makes a +sick-headache is emotional. The emotion, of course, need not be +conscious in order to be effective. If we picture the <!-- Page 271 --> +<a name="Page_271" id="Page_271" />arteries all +over the body as being supplied with, among other things, a wall of +circular muscles, and then imagine messages of emotion being flashed +to the nerves controlling this muscle wall, we may get an idea of what +happens just before a sick-headache. Some parts of the arteries +contract too much and other parts relax. The arteries to the head +tighten up at the extremities and become loose lower down. The force +of the blood-stream against the constricted portion can hardly fail to +cause pain. The sick part of the headache is merely a sympathetic +strike of the nerves which control circulation and stomach.</p> + +<p>The moral of all this is plain. If a sick-headache is the result of an +emotional spasm of the blood-vessels, the obvious cure is a change of +the emotion. Some people manage it by going to a party or a picnic, +others by ignoring the symptoms and keeping on with their work. A +woman physician whom I know was in the midst of a violent headache +when called out on an obstetrical case. She felt sorry for herself, +but went on the case. In the strenuous work which followed, she quite +forgot the headache, which disappeared as if by magic.</p> + +<p>Sometimes it happens that a headache recurs periodically or at regular +intervals. It is easy to see that in such cases the exciting cause is +fear and expectation. At some time in the past, headaches have +occurred at <!-- Page 272 --><a name="Page_272" id="Page_272" /> +an interval of, say, fourteen days; as the next +fourteenth day approaches the sufferer says to himself: "It is about +time for another headache. I am afraid it will come to-morrow," and of +course it comes. One man told me that if he ate Sunday-night supper he +inevitably had a headache on Monday morning. We were about to sit down +to a simple Sunday supper and he refused very positively to join us. I +told him he could stay all night and that I would take care of him if +the Monday sickness appeared. He accepted my challenge but was unable +to produce a headache. In fact, he felt so unusually flourishing the +next morning that he insisted on frying the bacon for my entire +family. That was the end of the Monday headaches.</p> + +<p><b>A Few Examples.</b> As sick-headache has always been considered a rather +stubborn difficulty, not amenable to most forms of treatment, it may +be well to cite a few cases which were helped by educational methods. +A patient came home from a walk one day and announced that he was +going to bed. When questioned, be said: "I am tired and I have a +sick-headache. Isn't it logical to go to bed?" To which I answered +that it would be far more logical to put some food into his stomach +and change the circulation than to lie in bed and think about his +pain. This man was completely cured. I have had patients throw up one +meal, and very rarely two, but I have never had to supply <!-- Page 273 --> +<a name="Page_273" id="Page_273" />more than +three meals at a time. The waste of food I consider amply justified by +the benefit to the patient.</p> + +<p>There once came to me an elderly woman, the wife of a poor minister. +She was suffering from attacks of nausea, which recurred every five to +ten days with intense pain through the eyes, and with photo-phobia or +fear of light. I found that she had by dint of heroic efforts raised a +large and promising family on the salary of an itinerant +minister—from four hundred to six hundred a year! All the time she +had been feeling sorry for herself because her husband did not +appreciate her. One day, after reading one of his letters which seemed +to show an utter lack of appreciation of all that she was doing, she +fell down in the field beside her plow, paralyzed. From that time on +she had been more or less of an invalid, continually nursing her +grudge and complaining that she ought not to have been made to bear so +many children.</p> + +<p>After I had heard this plaint over and over for about a week, I said: +"Perhaps you ought not to have had that little daughter, the little +ewe-lamb. Maybe she was one too many." "Oh, no," came the quick +response. "I couldn't have spared <i>her</i>." Then I went down the line of +the fine stalwart sons. Perhaps she could have spared John or Tom or +Fred? Finally she saw the whole matter in a different light,—saw +herself as a queen among women, the mother of such a family.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 274 --><a name="Page_274" id="Page_274" />As to +the husband, I tried to show her that she was not very clever +to live with a man all those years without discovering that he was not +likely to change. "You can't change him but you can change your +reaction to him. If something keeps hurting your hand, you don't keep +on being sore. You grow callous. Isn't it about time you grew a moral +callous, too?"</p> + +<p>I put her on the roof to sleep, on account of her fear of light. Only +once did she start a headache, which I quickly nipped in the bud by +making her get up and dress. She had come to stay "three months or +four,—if I get along well." At the end of four weeks she left, an +apparently well woman. The last I heard of her she was stumping the +state for temperance, the oldest of an automobile party of speakers, +and the sturdiest physically. With the emotional grievance, +disappeared also the physical effects in stomach and head.</p> + +<p>Miss S., a very brilliant woman, ambitious to make the most of her +life, had been shelved for twenty-five years because of violent +sick-headaches which made it impossible for her to undertake any kind +of work. She had not been able to read a half-hour a day without +bringing on a terrible headache. I insisted on her reading, and very +soon she was so deep in psychological literature that I had difficulty +in making her go to bed at all. After learning the cause of her +headaches and gaining greater emotional control, she succeeded +<!-- Page 275 --><a name="Page_275" id="Page_275" />so +well in freeing herself from the old habit, that she now leads the +busiest kind of useful life with only an occasional headache, perhaps +once in six months.</p> + +<p>A certain minister suffered constantly from a dull pain in his head, +besides having violent headaches every few days. He started in to have +a bad spell the day after his arrival at my house. As I was going out +of the door, he caught my sleeve. "Doctor," he said, "would it be bad +manners to run away?" "Manners?" I answered. "They don't count, but +morals, yes." He stayed—and that was his last bad headache. Both +chronic and periodic pains disappeared for good.</p> + +<p>One woman who had suffered from bad headaches for eighteen years lost +them completely under a process of re-education. On the other hand, I +have had patients who were not helped at all. The principles held good +in their cases, but they were simply not able to lose the old habit of +tightening up the body under emotion.</p> + +<p><b>Hysterical Nausea.</b> Sometimes nausea is merely the physical symbol of +a subconscious moral disgust. We have already told the stories of "the +woman with the nausea" (Chapter V) and of Mrs. Y. (Chapter VII). These +cases are typical of many others. Their bodies were perfectly normal, +and when, through <!-- Page 276 --><a name="Page_276" id="Page_276" /> +psycho-analysis and re-education, they were helped to make over their childish +attitudes toward the sex-life, the nausea +<span title="Corrected typo: was 'disappearaed'" class="hov">disappeared</span>.</p> + +<p><b>Loss of Appetite.</b> A nervous patient with a good appetite is "the +exception that proves the rule." The neurotic is usually under weight +and often complains that he feels satiated almost as soon as he begins +to eat. Loss of appetite may, of course, mean that the body is busy +combating toxins in the blood, but in a nervous person it usually +means a symbolic loss of appetite for something in life, a struggle of +the personality against something for which he has "no stomach." +Psycho-analysis often reveals the source of the trouble, and a little +bullying helps along the good work. By simply taking away a harmful +means of expression, we may often force the subconscious mind to find +a better language.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p>Since the stomach seems to be an organ which is much better fitted to +care for food than to care for a depressing emotion or a false idea, +it seems far more sensible to change our minds than to keep enlarging +our list of eatables which are taboo.</p> + +<p>And since most indigestion is in very truth nothing more nor less than +an emotional disturbance, worked up by fear, anger, discontent, worry, +ignorance, suggestion, <!-- Page 277 --><a name="Page_277" id="Page_277" /> +attention to bodily functions which are meant +to be ignored, love of notice and the conversion of moral distress +into physical distress, the best diet list which can be furnished to +Mr. Everyman in search of health must read something like this:</p> + + +<p class="heading">MENU</p> + +<p class="center">Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday</p> + +<p class="center">A Calm Spirit Plenty of Good Cheer<br /> +A Varied Diet Commonsense<br /> +Good Cooking<br /> +Judicious Neglect of Symptoms<br /> +Forgetfulness of the Digestive Process<br /> +A Little Accurate Knowledge<br /> +A Determination to<br /> +BE LIKE FOLKS</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 278 --><a name="Page_278" id="Page_278" /></div> + +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_XI" id="CHAPTER_XI">CHAPTER XI</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we relearn an old trick</i></p> + +<p class="heading">THE BUGABOO OF CONSTIPATION</p> + +<p class="scheading">Popular Superstitions</p> + + +<p>In line with the taboos connected with the taking of food are the +ceremonials attendant upon its elimination. Taking anxious thought +about functions well established by nature is a feature of +conversion-hysteria, the displacement of emotional desire from its +psychic realm into symbolic physical expression. Whatever other +symptoms nervous people may manifest, they are almost sure to be +troubled with chronic constipation. It is true that there are many +constipated people who do not seem to be nervous and who resent being +classed among the neurotics. Everybody knows that the occasional +individual who has difficulty in swallowing his food is nervous and +that the, trouble lies not in the muscles of his throat but in the +ideas of his mind. But very few people seem to realize that the more +common individual who makes hard work of that other simple +process—elimination of his intestinal <!-- Page 279 --> +<a name="Page_279" id="Page_279" />waste matter—is suffering +from the same kind of disturbance and giving way to a nervous trick. +When all the facts are in, the constipated person will have hard work +to clear himself of at least one count on the charge of nerves.</p> + +<p><b>An Oft-told Tale.</b> Sooner or later, then, the neurotic, whether he +calls himself a neurotic or not, is very likely to begin worrying over +his diet or his sedentary occupation. He imagines himself the victim +of autointoxication, afflicted with paralysis of the colon or dearth +of intestinal secretions. He leaves off eating white bread, berries, +cheese, chocolate, and many another innocent food, and insists on a +diet of bran-biscuit, flaxseed breakfast-foods, prunes, spinach, +cream, and olive-oil with doses of mineral oil between meals. In all +probability, he begins a course of massage or he starts to take extra +long walks and to exercise night and morning, pulling his knees up to +his chin and touching his fingers to his toes. When all these measures +fail, he gives in to the morning enema or the nightly pill, in +imminent danger of succumbing to a life-long habit.</p> + +<p class="scheading">The Truth About Constipation</p> + +<p><b>What the Colon Is For.</b> It is well, then to have a fair understanding +of the structure and purpose of our intestinal machinery. Contrary to +general opinion, the <!-- Page 280 --><a name="Page_280" id="Page_280" /> +intestines are not a dumping-ground but a +digestive organ. After the food is partly digested in the stomach, it +passes through a twenty-two foot tube (the small intestine) into a +five-foot tube (the large intestine or colon) where digestion is +completed, the nutriment is absorbed, and the waste matter is passed +on and out through the rectum. As the food passes along the colon, +pushed slowly ahead by the peristaltic wave, or rhythmic muscular +contractions of the intestinal wall, it is seized upon by the four +hundred varieties of friendly bacteria which inhabit the intestines of +every healthy person, and is changed into a form which the body can +assimilate. Digestion in the stomach and small intestine is carried on +by means of certain digestive juices, but in the large intestine it is +the bacteria which do the work. Without them we could not live.</p> + +<p>Around the colon is a thick network of little blood vessels, all of +which lead straight to the liver, the storehouse of the body. After +the food is fully digested, it is passed through the thin intestinal +wall into these tiny vessels and carried away to liver and muscles for +storage or for immediate use.</p> + +<p>This process of absorption is carried on throughout the whole length +of the colon. Not until the very end of the intestine is reached is +all the nutrition abstracted. The bowel-content can properly be called +waste matter only after it has reached the rectum or <!-- Page 281 --> +<a name="Page_281" id="Page_281" />pouch at the +lower end of the colon. Even then, this waste matter is not poison, +but merely indigestible material which the body cannot handle.</p> + +<p><b>Food, not Poison.</b> The colon is not a cesspool but a digestive and +assimilating organ. Its content is not poison but food. Active +elimination is important not so much because delay causes +autointoxication or poisoning as because too large a mass is hard to +manage and irritates the intestinal wall. The problem is not so much +one of toxicology as of simple mechanics. If Nature had put within the +body five feet of tubing which could easily become a cesspool and a +breeder of poison, it is not at all likely that she would have laid +alongside an elaborate system of blood vessels leading not out to the +kidneys but into the storehouse of the liver; and if civilized man's +changed manner of living had so upset Nature's plans as easily to +transform his internal machinery into a chronic source of danger, we +may be sure that he would long ago have gone the way of the unfit and +succumbed to his own poisons.</p> + +<p><b>Possible Invasions.</b> It is true that the intestinal tract, like the +rest of the body, is open to attack by harmful bacteria. But in a +great majority of cases, these enemy bacteria are either quickly +destroyed by the beneficent microbes within or are immediately cast +out as unfit. Any germs irritating to the intestinal wall cause the +mucous membrane to produce an unusual flow <!-- Page 282 --> +<a name="Page_282" id="Page_282" />of mucus which washes away +the offending bacteria in what we call a +diarrhea.<a name="FNanchor_52" id="FNanchor_52"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_52" class="fnanchor">[52]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_52" id="Footnote_52"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_52"><span class="label">[52]</span> +</a> If the invading army proves obstinate and the diarrhea +continues a day or so, it is wise to assist Nature by a dose of +castor-oil, which gives an additional insult to the intestinal wall, +spurs it on to a desperate effort, and hastens the cleansing process. +In severe cases the more promptly the castor-oil is administered the +better. Such emergency measures are very different from the habitual +use of insulting drugs.</p></div> + +<p>Sometimes the wrong kind of bacteria do persist, causing anemia, +rheumatism, sciatica, or neuritis. When these disorders are not the +result of infection from teeth, tonsils, or other sources of poison, +but are really caused by intestinal bacteria, I have found that a diet +of buttermilk (lactic acid bacteria), with turnip-tops or spinach to +supply the necessary mineral salts, often succeeds in planting the +right bacteria and driving out the disturbing ones. These disorders +are invasions from without, like tuberculosis or malaria, and are as +likely to attack the person with easy bowel movements as the one with +the most chronic constipation.</p> + +<p><b>Autointoxication.</b> A good deal of the talk about autointoxication is +just talk. It sounds well and affords an easy explanation for all +sorts of ills, but in a large majority of cases the diagnosis can +hardly be substantiated. Uninformed writers of newspaper articles on +the care of the body, or purveyors of purgatives or apparatus for +internal baths are fond of dilating on <!-- Page 283 --> +<a name="Page_283" id="Page_283" />the "foulness of the colon" as +a leading cause of disease. As a rule, they advise either a strict +diet, some kind of cathartic, or an elaborate process of washing out +the colon to clear the body of its terrible accumulation of poisons.</p> + +<p><b>Cathartics and Enemas.</b> He who makes a practice of flushing out his +intestinal tract with high enemas and internal baths is like a person +who eats a good dinner and then proceeds to wash out his stomach. In +the mistaken idea that he is making himself clean, he is washing what +was never intended to be washed and robbing the body of the nutrition +which it needs. And the man who persists in the pill habit is making a +worse mistake, adding insult to injury and forcing the mucous membrane +to toughen itself against such malicious attacks.</p> + +<p><b>Cathartics and Operations.</b> Even in emergencies, the use of +purgatives as a routine measure is happily decreasing year by year. +For many years I have deplored the use of purgatives before and after +operations. That other practitioners are coming to the same conclusion +is witnessed by a number of papers recently read in medical societies +condemning purgation at the time of operation.</p> + +<p>Among the most favorably received papers of the California Medical +Societies have been one by Emmet L. Rixford, surgeon of the Stanford +University <!-- Page 284 --><a name="Page_284" id="Page_284" /> +Medical College, read before the Southern California +Medical Society at Los Angeles December 8, 1916, and one by W.D. +Alvarez at the California Medical Society, Del Monte, 1918,—both +condemning the use of purgatives as a routine measure before +operations. An article entitled the "Use and Abuse of Cathartics" in +the "Journal of the American Medical Association" admirably summarizes +the disadvantages of purgation at such a +time.<a name="FNanchor_53" id="FNanchor_53"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_53" class="fnanchor">[53]</a></p> + + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_53" id="Footnote_53"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_53"><span class="label">[53]</span> +</a> "1 Danger of dissemination of infection throughout the +peritoneal cavity, in case localized infection exists. +</p><p> +"2 Increased absorption of toxins and greater bacterial activity by +reason of the fact that undigested food has been carried down into the +colon to serve as pabulum for bacteria, and that liquid feces form a +better culture medium than solid feces. +</p><p> +"3 Increased distention of the intestine with gas and fluid, when it +should be empty.... +</p><p> +"4 Psychic and physical weakness produced by dehydration of the body, +disturbance in the salt balance of the system, and the loss of sleep +occasioned by the frequent purging during the night preceding the +operation. As Oliver Wendell Holmes says: 'If it were known that a +prize fighter were to have a drastic purgative administered two or +three days before a contest, no one will question that it would affect +the betting on his side unfavorably. If this be true for a powerful +man in perfect health, how much more true must it be of the sick man +battling for life.' +</p><p> +"5 Increase in postoperative distress and danger: thirst, gas pains, +and even ileus...."—<i>Journal of American Medical Association</i>, Vol. +73, No. 17, p. 1285, Oct. 25. 1919.</p></div> + +<p>Four years ago I was called to a near-by city to see a former patient +who two days before had had a minor operation,—removal of a cyst of +the breast. She was dazed, almost in a state of surgical shock and +very near <!-- Page 285 --><a name="Page_285" id="Page_285" />collapse. +I found that she had been put through the usual +course of purgation before operation and starvation afterward, and I +diagnosed her condition as a state bordering on acidosis, or lowering +of the alkaline salts of the body. I ordered food at once. She rallied +and recovered.</p> + +<p>A few months later this same woman had to undergo a much more serious +operation for multiple fibroids of the uterus and removal of the +appendix. This time I advised the surgeon against the use of any +purgative, and he took my remarks so seriously that he did not even +allow an enema to be given. This time the patient showed no signs of +exhaustion and had very few gas pains. I firmly believe that the day +will soon come when a patient under operation, or a patient after +childbirth, will no longer be depleted by a weakening and dehydrating +cathartic and by a period of starvation, at a time when he needs all +the energy he can summon.</p> + +<p><b>Cathartics and Childbirth.</b> The article referred to in the "Journal +of the American Medical Association" cites the experiences of Dr. R. +McPherson of the Lying-in Hospital of New York, "who showed that the +routine purgation after confinement is not only useless but harmful. +Of 322 women who were not purged, only three had fever (and one of +them a mammary abscess); most of them had normal bowel movements and +those who did not were given an enema <!-- Page 286 --> +<a name="Page_286" id="Page_286" />every third day. Of 322 women +who were delivered by the same technique and the same operators but +were purged in the usual routine manner, twenty-eight had some fever." +This experience of one physician is corroborated by that of others who +find that the more we tamper with the natural functions in time of +stress the harder do we make the recuperative process. There are +certainly times when catharsis is necessary but "one thing is certain, +the day for routine purgation is +past."<a name="FNanchor_54" id="FNanchor_54"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_54" class="fnanchor">[54]</a> Even in emergencies we +need to know why we administer cathartics and in chronic cases we may +be sure that they are always a mistake.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_54" id="Footnote_54"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_54"><span class="label">[54]</span></a> Ibid, p. 1286.</p></div> + +<p><b>"An Old Trick."</b> Before we make a practice of interfering with +Nature's processes, it is well to remember how old and stable those +processes are. As long as there has been the taking in of food, there +has been also the casting out of waste matter. The sea-anemone closes +in on the little mollusk that floats against its waving petals, +assimilates what it can and rejects the rest. In the long line from +sea-anemone to man, this automatic process of elimination has gone on +without a hitch, adapting itself with perfect success to the changing +habits of the varying types of life. So old a process is not easily +upset. And, be it noted, in the human body this automatic, involuntary +process still <!-- Page 287 --><a name="Page_287" id="Page_287" /> +goes on with very little trouble until it reaches a point in the body where man, +the thinking animal, tries to control it by conscious thought.</p> + +<p><b>A Question of Evacuation.</b> Much of the misconception about +constipation arises from the mistaken idea that this is a disorder of +the whole intestine or at least of the whole colon. As a matter of +fact, the trouble is almost wholly in the rectum. There is no trouble +with the general traffic movement, but only with the unloading at the +terminus. In my experience, the patient reports that he feels the +fecal mass in the lower part of the rectum, but that he is unable to +expel it. Examination by finger or by X-ray reveals a mass in the +rectal pouch. If there is a piling up of freight further back on the +line, it is only because the unloading process has been delayed at the +terminus.</p> + +<p>So long as the bowel-content is in the region of automatic control, +there is very little likelihood of trouble. An occasional case of +organic trouble—appendicitis, lead-colic, mechanical obstruction, new +growths or spinal-cord disease—may cause a real blockade, but in +ninety-nine cases out of every hundred there is little trouble so long +as the involuntary muscles, working automatically under the direction +of the subconscious mind, are in control. By slow or rapid stages, on +time or behind time, the bowel-content reaches the upper <!-- Page 288 --> +<a name="Page_288" id="Page_288" />part of the +rectum and passes through a little valve into the lower pouch. Here is +where the trouble begins.</p> + +<p><b>Meddlesome Interference.</b> In the natural state the little human, like +the other animals, empties his bowel whenever the fecal mass enters +the lower portion of the rectum. The presence of the mass in the +rectum constitutes a call to stool which is responded to as +unthinkingly as is the desire for air in the taking of a breath. But +the tiny child soon has to learn to control some of his natural +functions. At the lower end of the rectum there is a purse-string +muscle called the <i>Sphincter-ani</i>, an involuntary muscle which may +with training be brought partly under voluntary control. Under the +demands of civilization, the baby learns to tighten up this muscle +until the proper time for evacuation. Then, if he be normal, he lets +go, the muscles higher up contract and the bowel empties itself +automatically, as it always did before civilization began.</p> + +<p>There is, however, a possibility of trouble whenever the conscious +mind tries to assume control of functions which are meant to be +automatic. Under certain conditions necessary control becomes +meddlesome interference. If the child for one reason or another takes +too much interest in the function of elimination; if he likes too much +the sense-gratification from stimulation of the rectal nerves and +learns to increase this gratification <!-- Page 289 --> +<a name="Page_289" id="Page_289" />by holding back the fecal mass; +if he gets the idea that the function is "not nice" and takes the +interest that one naturally feels in subjects that are taboo; or if he +catches from his elders the suggestion that the bowel movement is a +highly important process and that something disastrous is likely to +happen unless it is successfully performed every day; then his very +interest in the matter tends to interfere with automatic regulation, +and to cause trouble.</p> + +<p>Just as people often find it hard to let go the bladder muscle and +urinate when in a hurry or under observation, and just as an +apprehensive woman in childbirth tightens up the purse-string muscle +of the womb, so the little child, or the grown up who catches the +suggestion of difficulty in the bowel movement, loses the trick of +letting go. Instead of merely exercising control by temporarily +inhibiting the function, he tries to carry through the process itself +by voluntary control—and fails. Constipation is a perfect example of +the power of suggestion, and of the troublesome effect of a fear-idea +in the realm of automatic functions.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Food and Constipation</p> + +<p>Since the waste matter from all foods finally reaches the rectum, and +since constipation is merely a difficulty in the forces of expulsion, +it is hard to see how any normal food in the quantities usually eaten +could have <!-- Page 290 --><a name="Page_290" id="Page_290" />the +slightest effect on the problem. When we remember that +it takes food from twelve to twenty-four hours to reach the rectum, +and that it has during all that time been subjected to the action of +the powerful chemicals of the digestive tract, it is hard to imagine a +piece of cheese, of whatever variety, strong enough to stop the +contraction of the muscles of the upper rectum or to tie the +sphincter-muscle into a knot. It would be difficult to find a food +which could pass without effect through twenty-seven feet of +intestinal tubing only to become suddenly effective on the wall of the +rectum. If the wrong kind of food is the cause of constipation, why +does the rectum prove to be the most refractory portion of the tube? +On what principle could a piece of chocolate inhibit the call to stool +or contract the sphincter muscle? On the other hand, even if it should +be conceded that constipation were the result of lack of lubricating +secretions in the colon, how could two tablespoonfuls of mineral oil +be a sufficient lubricant after being mixed with liquid and solid food +through many feet of the intestinal tract?</p> + +<p><b>An Adaptable Apparatus.</b> The lining of the intestines has plenty of +secretions to take care of its function. It is as well adapted to the +vicissitudes of life as are the other parts of the body. The muscular +coat is no more liable to paralysis or spasm than are the voluntary +muscles. As the skin adapts itself to all <!-- Page 291 --> +<a name="Page_291" id="Page_291" />waters and all weathers, +and as the lungs adjust themselves to varying air-pressures, so the +intestinal wall makes ready adaptation to any common-sense demands, +adjusting itself with ease to an athletic or a sedentary life, and to +the normal variations of diet. What man has eaten throughout the +centuries man may eat to-day. If you will but believe it, your +intestines will make no more objection to white bread, blackberries, +and cheese, along with all other ordinary articles of food, than the +skin makes to varying kinds of water. Naturally, the suggested idea +that a food will constipate tends to carry itself out to fulfilment +and to prevent the call to stool from rising to the level of +consciousness; but the real force lies not in the food but in the +suggestion.</p> + +<p><b>The Bran Fad.</b> It is when we try to improve on the normal human diet +that we really insult the body. He who leaves off eating nourishing +white bread and takes to bran muffins is simply cheating his body. +Bran has a small food value, but the human body is not made to extract +it. Not only does bran fail to give us any nourishment itself, but it +lessens the power of the intestines to care for other +food.<a name="FNanchor_55" id="FNanchor_55"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_55" class="fnanchor">[55]</a> The +fad for bran is based on the well-known fact that we need a certain +quantity of bulk in order to stimulate the intestinal wall to normal +peristalsis. We do need bulk, but not more than we naturally get from +a normal and varied <!-- Page 292 --><a name="Page_292" id="Page_292" /> +diet including a reasonable amount of fruit and vegetables.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_55" id="Footnote_55"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_55"><span class="label">[55]</span> +</a> See an article entitled "Bread and Bran," <i>Journal of +American Medical Association</i>, July 5, 1919, p. 36.</p></div> + +<p>It is true that the suggestion of the efficacy of bran, dates, +spinach, or any other food is frequently quite sufficient to give +relief, temporarily, just as massage, manipulation of the vertebrae, +the surgeon's knife, or mineral oil may be enough to carry the +conviction of power to a suggestible individual. But who wants to take +his suggestions in such inconvenient forms as these?</p> + +<p><b>Change of Water.</b> Another popular superstition centers around +drinking-waters. There are people who cannot move from one town to +another, much less take an extensive trip, without a fit of +constipation—or a box of pills. If they only knew it, there is no +water on earth which could make a person constipated. A new water, +full of unusual minerals, might hasten the bowel movement, but on what +possible principle could it retard it? Constipation has nothing to do +with food or with water, but solicitous care about either can hardly +fail to create the trouble which it tries to avoid.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Cure</p> + +<p><b>Taking off the Brakes.</b> Since constipation is wholly due to the +acceptance of a false suggestion, the only logical cure must be +release from the power of <!-- Page 293 --><a name="Page_293" id="Page_293" /> +that suggestion. "He is able as soon as he +thinks he is able"; not that thought gives the power, but that the +right thought releases the inhibition of the mistaken thought. As soon +as the brakes are taken off, the internal machinery is quite able to +make the wheels go round. The bowel will empty itself if we let it. +The function of elimination is not a new trick learned with difficulty +by the aged, but a trick as old and as elemental as life itself. Like +balancing on a bicycle, it may not be done by any voluntary muscular +effort, but it just does itself when one learns how.</p> + +<p>Once the sense of power comes, once the mind forgets to be doubtful or +afraid, then the old automatic habit invariably reasserts itself. +Meddlesome interference may throw the mechanism out of gear, but +fortunately it cannot strip the gears. Constipation is an inhibition +or restraint of function, but is never a loss of function. No one is +too old, no one is too fixed in the bad habit to relearn the old +trick. I have had a good many patients with chronic constipation, but +I have never had one who failed to learn. Real conviction speedily +brings success, and in many cases success seems to outrun conviction. +So efficient is Nature if she has only half a chance!</p> + +<p><b>Some People Who Learned.</b> Unless you are over ninety-two, do not +despair. One old lady of that age, a sort of patient by proxy, was +able to cure herself <!-- Page 294 --><a name="Page_294" id="Page_294" /> +without even one consultation. Her daughter had +been a patient of mine and had been cured of the constipation with +which she had been busy for many years. The mother, who believed her +own bowel paralyzed, had been in the habit of lying on the bed and +taking a copious enema every second day of her life. When, however, +she heard of her daughter's cure, the bright old woman gave up her +enemas and let her bowels do their own functioning. She stayed cured +until her death at ninety-five.</p> + +<p><b>A Fifty-year Habit.</b> Another old lady was not quite so easily +convinced. She ridiculed the idea that her son of fifty, who had been +"constipated in his cradle" could be cured of his lifelong habit, but +he was cured. As long as there is life and the light of reason, so long may Nature's functions +<span title="Corrected typo: was 're'" class="hov">be</span> reëstablished.</p> + +<p><b>The Whole Family.</b> Nor is any one too young to learn. A tiny baby is +easily taught. There came to me for two consultations a mother and her +two babies, all three constipated. The four-year-old child, mentally +deficient, had been fed on milk of magnesia from his infancy, and the +four-months-old baby had been started on the same path. I explained to +the mother the mechanism of elimination, told her to give up +cathartics, and to set a regular time for herself and the baby, but +was a little dubious about the mentally <!-- Page 295 --> +<a name="Page_295" id="Page_295" />deficient four-year-old. +However she soon reported that they had all three promptly acquired +the new habit. Four years later she told me that they had never had +any more trouble.</p> + +<p><b>A Record History.</b> When Miss H. first came to my house, she told a +story that was almost incredible. She said that for many months she +had been taking eight tablespoonfuls of mineral oil three times a day +besides a cathartic at night, and an enema in the morning. No wonder +she was a little dubious over such mild treatment as mine seemed to be!</p> + +<p>Constipation was only one of this young woman's troubles. She could +not sleep and was so fatigued that she believed herself at the end of +her physical capital. When she first came to me she had tears in her +eyes most of the time and used to confide to various people that she +was sure she was a patient that I could not cure,—a very common +belief among nervous invalids! She was sure that I did not understand +her case, and that she could not get anything out of this kind of treatment.</p> + +<p>It was only a very short time, however, before her bowels were +functioning like those of a normal person. She lost her insomnia and +her fatigue and went away as well as ever. When she got back to her +office, she found that her old position, which she had believed secure +to her, had been given to another. She had to <!-- Page 296 --> +<a name="Page_296" id="Page_296" />go out and hunt a new +job and face conditions harder than she had had before, but she came +through with flying colors. A short time ago Miss H. came back to see +me,—a happy, robust young woman, very different from the person I had +first known. She assured me that she had never had any return of her +old symptoms and that she was as well as a person could be.</p> + +<p><b>Living up to a Suggestion.</b> Mrs. T. had not had a natural movement of +the bowels in twenty-five years. After the birth of a child, +twenty-five years before, her physician had told her that her muscles +had been so badly torn in labor that they could not carry through a +natural movement. After that she had never gone a day without a pill +or an enema. I explained to her that when any muscle of the rectum is +injured in childbirth, it is the sphincter-ani, and that since this is +the muscle whose contraction holds back the bowel content, its injury +would tend to over-free evacuation rather than to constipation. She +saw the point and within two or three days regained her old power of +spontaneous evacuation.</p> + +<p><b>Practical Steps.</b> The first step, then, in acquiring normal habits is +the conviction of the integrity of our physical machines and a +determination not to interfere by thought, or by physical meddling, +with the elemental functions of our bodies. After this all-important +step, there are a few practical suggestions which it is well to +<!-- Page 297 --><a name="Page_297" id="Page_297" />follow. Most of +them are nothing more than the common-sense habits of +personal hygiene which are so obvious as to be almost axiomatic, but +which are nevertheless often neglected:</p> + +<p>1 Eat three square meals a day.</p> + +<p>2 Drink when thirsty, having conveniently at hand the facilities for +drinking.</p> + +<p>3 Heed the call to stool as you heed the call of hunger. When the +stool passes the little valve between the upper and lower portions of +the rectum, it gives the signal that the time for evacuation has come. +If this signal is always heeded, it will automatically start the +machinery that leads to evacuation. If it is persistently ignored +because one is too busy, or because the mind is filled with the idea +of disability, the call very soon fails to rise to the level of consciousness. +The feces remain in the rectum, and the bad habit is begun.</p> + +<p>4 Choose a regular time and keep that appointment with yourself as +regularly as possible. In all the activities of Nature, there is a +rhythm which it is well to observe.</p> + +<p>5 Take time to acquire the habit. Do not be in a hurry. Do not strain. +No amount of effort will start the movement. Just let it come of itself.</p> + +<p>6 Finally, should the unconscious suggestion of lack of power +stubbornly remain in force, take a small enema on the third day. If +the waste matter <!-- Page 298 --><a name="Page_298" id="Page_298" /> +accumulates for three or more days, the bulk becomes +so great that the circular muscles of the rectum are unable to handle +it, just as the fingers cannot squeeze down to expel water from too +large a mass of wet blankets. Take only a small enema—never over a +quart at a time—and expel the water immediately. One or two such +measures will bring away the mass in the rectum. The material farther +up still contains food elements and is not yet ready for expulsion. +Lessen the amount of water each time until no outside help is needed. +Once you get the right idea, all enemas will be superfluous.</p> + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p>If you would have in a nutshell an epitome of the truth about +constipation, indigestion, insomnia, and the other functional +disturbances common to nervous folk, you can do, no better than to +commit to memory and store away for future reference that choice +limerick of the centipede, which so admirably sums up the whole matter +of meddlesome interference:</p> + +<div class="poem"><div class="stanza"> +<span>A centipede was happy quite<br /></span> +<span>Until a frog in fun<br /></span> +<span>Said, "Pray, which leg comes after which?"<br /></span> +<span>This raised her mind to such a pitch,<br /></span> +<span>She lay distracted in the ditch,<br /></span> +<span>Considering how to run.<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<p><!-- Page 299 --><a name="Page_299" id="Page_299" />Whoever +tries to consider "which leg comes after which" in any line +of physiological activity, is pretty sure to find himself in the ditch +considering how to run. Wherefore, remember the centipede!</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 300 --><a name="Page_300" id="Page_300" /></div> +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_XII" id="CHAPTER_XII">CHAPTER XII</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which handicaps are dropped</i></p> + +<p class="heading">A WOMAN'S ILLS</p> + +<p class="scheading">"The Female of the Species"</p> + + +<p>If ever there was a man who wished himself a woman, he has hidden away +the desire within the recesses of his own heart. But one does not have +to wait long to hear a member of the female sex exclaim with evident +emotion, "Oh, dear, I wish I had been born a man!" It is probable that +if these same women were given the chance to transform themselves +overnight, they would hesitate long when it actually came to the +point. The joys of being a woman are real joys. However, in too many +cases these joys seem hardly to compensate for the discomforts of the +feminine organism. It is the body that drags. Painful menstrual +periods, the dreaded "change of life," various "female troubles" with +a number of pregnancies scattered along between, make some of the +daughters of Eve feel that they spend a good deal of their lives +paying a penalty merely for being women. Brought <!-- Page 301 --> +<a name="Page_301" id="Page_301" />up to believe +themselves heirs to a curse laid on the first woman, they accept their +discomforts with resignation and try to make the best of a bad business.</p> + +<p><b>"Since the War."</b> Nothing is quite the same since the war. Among +other things we have learned that many of our so-called handicaps were +nothing but illusions,—base libels on the female body. Under the +stern necessity of war the women of the world discovered that they +could stand up under jobs which have until now been considered quite +beyond their powers. Society girls, who were used to coddling +themselves, found a new joy in hard and continuous work; middle-aged +women, who were supposed to be at the time of life when little could +be expected of them, quite forgot themselves in service. Ambulance +drivers, nurses, welfare workers, farmerettes, Red-Cross workers, +street-car conductors and "bell-boys," revealed to themselves and to +the world unsuspected powers of endurance in a woman's body. Although +some of the heavier occupations still seem to be "man's work," better +fitted for a man's sturdier body, we know now that many of these +disabilities were merely a matter of tradition and of faulty training.</p> + +<p>There still remains, however, a goodly number of women who are +continuously or periodically below par because of some form of +feminine disability. Some of these women are suffering from real +physical <!-- Page 302 --><a name="Page_302" id="Page_302" /> +handicaps, but many of them need to be told that they are disabled not +by reason of being women but by reason of being nervous women.</p> + +<p><b>"Nerves" Again.</b> Despite the organic disturbances which may beset the +reproductive organs, and despite the havoc wrought by venereal diseases, +it may be said with absolute assurance that the majority of feminine ills are the result +neither of the natural frailty of the female body, nor even of man's +<span title="Corrected typo: was 'infringment'" class="hov">infringement</span> of the social law, +but are the direct result of false suggestion and of false attitudes toward +the facts of the reproductive life. The trouble is less a difficulty +with the reproductive organs than a difficulty with the reproductive +instinct. "Something wrong" with the instinct is translated by the +subconscious mind into "something wrong" with the related generative +organs, and converted into a physical pain.</p> + +<p>That this relation has always been dimly felt is shown by the fact +that the early Greeks called nervous disorders <i>hysteria</i>, from the +Greek word for womb. It is only lately, however, that the blame has +been put in the right place and the trouble traced to the <i>instinct</i> +rather than to the <i>organs</i> of reproduction.</p> + +<p><b>Why Women Are Nervous.</b> Although women hold no monopoly, it must be +conceded that they are particularly prone to "nerves." The reason is +not hard to find. Since the leading factor in a neurosis is a +<!-- Page 303 --><a name="Page_303" id="Page_303" />disturbance +of the insistent instinct of reproduction, a disturbance +usually based on repression, then any class of persons in whom the +instinct is particularly repressed would, in the very nature of the +case, be particularly liable to nervousness.</p> + +<p>No one who thoroughly knows human nature would attempt to deny that +woman is as strongly endowed as man with the great urge toward the +perpetuation of the race, or that she has had to repress the instinct +more severely than has man. The man insists on knowing that the +children he provides for are his own children. Whatever the degree of +his own fidelity, he must be sure that his wife is true to him. Thus +has grown up the insistence that, no matter what man does, woman, if +she is to be counted respectable, shall control the urge of the +instinct and live up to the requirements of continence set for her by +society.</p> + +<p>Unfortunately, however, there is more often blind repression than +rational control. The measures taken to prevent a girl's becoming a +tom-boy are measures of sex-repression quite as much as of +sex-differentiation. Over-reaction of sensitive little souls to +lessons in modesty often causes distortion of normal sex-development. +Ignorance concerning the phenomena of life is commended as innocence, +while it really implies a sex-curiosity which has been too severely +repressed. The young woman blushes at thoughts of love, while the +<!-- Page 304 --><a name="Page_304" id="Page_304" />young +man is filled with a sense of dignity. We smile at the picture +of "Miss Philura's" confusion as she hesitatingly sends up to her +Creator a petition for the much-desired boon of a husband. But really, +why shouldn't she want one? Many a young woman, in order to deaden her +senses to the unsuspected lure of the reproductive instinct by what is +really an awkward attempt at <i>sublimation</i>, makes a fetish of dress +and social position and considers only the marriage of convenience; +or, on the other hand, she scorns men altogether and throws herself +into a "career."</p> + +<p>Young men are not so often taught to repress, but neither are they +taught to swing their vital energies into altruistic channels through +sublimation. Since the woman of his class will not marry him until he +has money, the young man too often satisfies his undirected instincts +in a commercial way. The statistics of venereal diseases prove that +here, as elsewhere, goods subject to barter are subject to +contamination. In a late marriage, too often a contaminated body +accompanies the material possessions which the standards of society +have demanded of a husband.</p> + +<p>But the woman pays in still other coin for the repressions arising +from faulty childhood training. Unable to find expression for herself +either in marriage or in devotion to work, because some old childish +repression is still denying all outlet to her legitimate desire, +<!-- Page 305 --><a name="Page_305" id="Page_305" />she +frequently falls into a neurosis; or if she escapes a real breakdown, +she gives expression to unsatisfied longings in some isolated nervous +symptoms which in many cases center about the organs of generation. +There then results any one of the various functional disturbances +which are only too often mistaken for organic disease. What is needed +in cases like this is not a gynecologist nor a surgeon, but a +psycho-pathologist—or perhaps only a grasp of the facts. Let us look +at the more common of these disturbances in order to gain an +understanding of the situation.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Menstrual Period</p> + +<p><b>Potential Motherhood.</b> Among the normal phenomena of a woman's life +is the recurring cycle of potential motherhood. Every three or four +weeks a new ovum or egg matures in the ovary and undergoes certain +chemical changes, which send into the blood a substance called a +hormone. This hormone is a messenger, stimulating the mucous membrane +of the womb into making its velvet pile longer and softer, and its +nutrient juices more abundant in readiness for the ovum.</p> + +<p>The same stimulus causes the whole organism to make ready for a new +life. As in hunger, the chemistry of the body produces the +muscle-tension that is felt as a craving for food, so this recurring +chemical <!-- Page 306 --><a name="Page_306" id="Page_306" /> +stimulus produces a definite craving in body and mind. This +craving brings about an increased irritability or sensitiveness to +stimuli which may result either in a joyous or a fretful mood.</p> + +<p>During sleep the social inhibitions are felt less distinctly and the +sleeper dreams love-dreams woven from messages coming up from all the +minute nerve-endings in the expectant reproductive organs. But if no +germ-cell travels up the womb-canal and tube to meet and impregnate +the ovum, the womb-lining rejects the egg as chemically unfit. All the +furbishings are loosened from the walls and slowly cast out, +constituting the menstrual flow. The phenomenon as a whole is a +physiological function and should be accompanied by a sense of +well-being and comfort as is the exercise of any other function, such +as digestion or muscular activity. Only too often, however, it is +dreaded as an unmitigated disaster, a time for giving up work or fun +and going to bed with a hot-water bottle until "the worst is over." +Let us see how this perversion comes about.</p> + +<p><b>Why Menstruation Is Painful.</b> What sort of atmosphere is created for +the young girl as she attains puberty? Most girls get their first +inkling of the menstrual period from the periodic "sick spells" of +mother or sister. This knowledge comes without conscious thought and +is a direct observation of the +<!-- Page 307 --><a name="Page_307" id="Page_307" />subconscious mind, +which records impressions with the accuracy and completeness of a photographic +plate. Hearing the talk about a "sick-time" and observing the signs of +"cramps" among older friends, the young girl's subconscious mind plays +up to the suggestion and recoils with fear from the newly experienced +sensations in the maturing organs of reproduction.</p> + +<p>This recoil of fear interferes with the circulation in the functioning +organs, just as fear blanches the face or hinders digestion. There is +several times as much blood in the stomach when it is full of food as +there is between meals, but we do not for this reason fancy that we +have a pain after each meal. There is more blood in the generative +organs during their functioning, but this means pain only when fear +ties up the circulation and causes undue congestion. Fear acts further +on the sturdy muscle of the womb, tying it up into just such knots as +we feel in the esophagus when we say that we have a lump in the +throat. It is safe to say that ninety-five cases of painful +menstruation out of every hundred are caused by fear and by the +expectation of pain. The cysts and tumors responsible for pain are so +rare as to be fairly negligible, when compared with these other +causes.</p> + +<p>Dr. Clelia Duel Mosher of Stanford University has for many years +carried on careful investigations among the students of the +university. After describing in <!-- Page 308 --> +<a name="Page_308" id="Page_308" />detail certain physical exercises +which she has found of value, she continues:</p> + +<div class="blockquot"><p>But more important even than this is an alteration of the morbid + attitude of women themselves toward this function; and almost + equally essential is a fundamental change in the habit of mind on + our part as physicians; for do we not tend to translate too much, + the whole of a woman's life into terms of menstruation? If every + young girl were taught that menstruation is not normally a "bad + time" and that pain or incapacity at that period is as + discreditable and unnecessary as bad breath due to decaying + teeth, we might almost look for a revolution in the physical life + of women.... In my experience the traditional treatment of rest + in bed, directing the attention solely to the sex-zone of the + body, and the accepted theory that it is an inevitable illness + while at the same time the mind is without occupation, produces a + morbid attitude and favors the development and exaggeration of + whatever symptoms there may + be.<a name="FNanchor_56" id="FNanchor_56"></a> + <a href="#Footnote_56" class="fnanchor">[56]</a></p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_56" id="Footnote_56"> +</a><a href="#FNanchor_56"><span class="label">[56]</span> +</a> Clelia Duel Mosher: <i>Health and the Woman Movement</i>, pp. +25, 26, 19.</p></div> + +<p><b>Pre-Menstrual Discomfort.</b> If it be objected that women often feel +badly for a day or two before the period begins, before they know that +it is due, and that this feeling of discomfort could not be caused by +fear and expectation, it is easy to reply that the subconscious mind +knows perfectly what is happening within the body. The emotion of +fear, working within the <!-- Page 309 --><a name="Page_309" id="Page_309" /> +subconscious, is able to translate all the +varying bodily sensations into feelings of distress without any +knowledge on the part of the conscious mind.</p> + +<p>Sometimes before the period begins, a girl feels blue and upset for a +day or two, a sign that the instinct is getting discouraged. The whole +body is saying, "Get ready, get ready," but it has gotten ready many +times before, and to no purpose. Unsatisfied striving brings +discouragement. What reaches consciousness is a feeling of pessimism +and a general dissatisfaction with life as a whole. If, instead of +giving in to the blues or going to bed and predicting a pain, the girl +finds other outlets for her energy, she finds that after all, her +instinct may be satisfied in indirect ways and that she has strangely +come into a new supply of <i>vim</i>.</p> + +<p><b>The Purpose of the Pain.</b> Although suggestion is behind all nervous +symptoms, there is a deeper reason for the disturbance. When an +unhealthy suggestion is seized and acted upon, it is because some +unsatisfied part of the personality sees in it a chance for +accomplishing its own ends. The pre-menstrual period is the +blooming-time, the mating-time, the springtime of the organism. That +means eminently a time for coming into notice, that one's charms may +attract the desired complement. But if the rightfully insistent +instinctive desires are held in check by unnatural repressions and +misapplied social restrictions, the starved <!-- Page 310 --> +<a name="Page_310" id="Page_310" />instinct can obtain +expression only by a concealment of purpose. The disguise assumed is +often one of indifference or positive distaste for the allurements of +the other sex. But, as we know, an instinctive desire will not be +denied. In this case, the misguided instinct which has been given the +suggestion that menstruation means illness, fits this conception into +the scheme of things and obtains notice in a roundabout way by the +attention given to the invalid.</p> + +<p><b>The Treatment.</b> To find that the symptom has a purpose rather than a +cause gives the indication for the treatment. Judicious neglect causes +the symptom to cease by defeating its very purpose,—that of drawing +attention to itself. The person who never mentions her discomfort, +thinks about it as little as possible, and goes about her business as +usual, is likely to find her trouble gone before she realizes it. +<a name="FNanchor_57" id="FNanchor_57"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_57" class="fnanchor">[57]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_57" id="Footnote_57"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_57"><span class="label">[57]</span> +</a> Violent exercise at this time is unwise, but continuing +one's usual activity helps the circulation and keeps the mind from +centering on the affected part. The physiological congestion is unduly +intensified by standing; therefore all employments should afford +facilities for the woman to sit at least part of the time while +continuing work.</p></div> + +<p>A little explanation gives the patient insight into the workings of +her own mind, and usually causes the pain to disappear in short order. +Astonished, indeed, and filled with gratitude have been some of my +young-women patients who had all their lives been unable to +<!-- Page 311 --><a name="Page_311" id="Page_311" />plan any +work or social engagements for the time of this functioning. Many of +them were the worst kind of doubters when they were told that to go to +bed and center their attention on the generative organs only made the +muscles tighten up and the circulation congest. They could not +conceive themselves up and around, pursuing their normal life during +such a time. However, as they have found by experience that this point +of view is not an optimistic dream, they have broken up the +confidence-game which their subconscious had been playing on them, and +have gone on their way rejoicing.</p> + +<p>There was one young girl, a doctor's daughter, who suffered +continuously from pain in the abdomen, and from back-pain which +increased so greatly at the time of the menses that she was in the +habit of going to bed for several days, to be waited on with +solicitous care by her family. In an attempt to cure the trouble she +had undergone an operation to suspend the uterus, but the pain had +continued as before. When she came to me, I explained to her that +there was no physical difficulty and that her trouble was wholly +nervous. I made her play tennis every day and she had just finished a +game when her period came on. She stayed up for luncheon, went for a +walk in the afternoon, ate her dinner with the family, and behaved +like other people. Her mother telephoned that evening and when I told +her what her <!-- Page 312 --><a name="Page_312" id="Page_312" /> +daughter had been doing, she gasped in astonishment. She +had difficulty in believing that the new order was not miracle but +simply the working out of natural law. Since that time her daughter +has had no more trouble.</p> + +<p><b>The Ounce of Prevention.</b> If young girls had wiser counselors in +their mothers and physicians, the misconception would never occur, and +such an indirect outlet would not be needed; the organic sensations +incident to puberty and the recurring menstrual period would have +something of the significance of the annunciation to Mary, bringing +wonder and a sense of well-being.</p> + +<p>When your little daughter arrives at maturity, give her a joyous +initiation into the noble order of women. She will welcome the new +function as a badge of womanhood and as a harbinger of wonderful +things to come.</p> + +<p>A girl of fifteen came under my care to be helped out of a mood of +increasing depression and uneasiness. Her glance was furtive, yet +anxiously expectant. Tears came unbidden as she sat alone or fingered +the keys of the piano. Tactful questioning elicited no response as to +reasons for her unhappiness. Opportunities for giving confidence were +not accepted. At a chance moment our talk drifted to the subject of +menstruation. "Your periods are regular and easy; and do you know what +they are for?" Then I painted <!-- Page 313 --> +<a name="Page_313" id="Page_313" />for her a picture of the preparations +that are made throughout the whole organism, for the germ-cell that +comes each month and has in it all the possibilities of a new little life.</p> + +<p>The result of this confidential talk may seem fanciful to any one but +an eye-witness. We had only a week's association, but the depression +ceased, the furtive look and deprecatory manner were replaced by a +joyous buoyancy. In a few weeks the thin neck and awkward body rounded +out into the symmetry which usually precedes the establishment of +puberty, but which was delayed in this case until the unconscious +conflict resolved itself.</p> + +<p><b>In the Large.</b> Looked at from any angle, this subject is an important +one. There are involved not only the physical comfort and convenience +of the sufferers themselves, but also the economic prospects of women +as a whole. If women are to demand equal opportunity and equal pay, +they must be able to do equal work without periodic times of illness. +When employers of women tell us that they regularly have to hire extra +help because some of their workers lose time each month, we realize +how great is the aggregate of economic waste, a waste which would +assuredly be justified if the health of the country's womanhood were +really involved, but which is inefficient and unnecessary when caused +merely by ignorant tradition. "Up to <!-- Page 314 --> +<a name="Page_314" id="Page_314" />standard every day of every +week," is a slogan quite within the range of possibility for all but +the seriously ill. When reduced to their lowest terms, the +inconveniences of this function are not great and are not too dear a +price to pay for the possibilities of motherhood.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The "Change of Life"</p> + +<p><b>Another Phantom Peril.</b> As the young girl is taught to fear the +menstrual period, so the older woman is taught to dread the time when +the periods shall cease. Despite the general enlightenment of this day +and age, the menopause or "change of life" is all too frequently +feared as a "critical period" in a woman's life, a time of distressing +physical sensations and even of danger to mental balance.</p> + +<p>As a matter of fact, the menopause is a physiological process which +should be accomplished with as little mental and physical disturbance +as accompanies the establishment of puberty. The same internal +secretion is concerned in both. When the function of ovulation ceases +the body has to find a new way to dispose of the internal secretion of +the ovary. Its presence in the blood is the cause of the sudden +dilatation of the blood-vessels that is known as the "hot flash."</p> + +<p>The matter is altogether a problem of chemistry, with the necessity +for a new adjustment among the glands of internal secretion. The body +easily manages <!-- Page 315 --><a name="Page_315" id="Page_315" /> +this if left to itself, but is greatly interfered with +by the wrong suggestion and emotion. We have already seen how quickly +emotion affects all secretions and how easily the adrenal and thyroid +glands are influenced by fear. This is the root of the trouble in many +cases of difficult "change." If an occasional body is not quite able +to regulate the chemical readjustment, we may have to administer the +glands of some other animal, but in the majority of cases, the body, +unhampered by an extra burden of fear, is quite able to make its own +adjustments. The hot flash passes in a moment, if not prolonged by +emotion or if not converted into a habit by attention.</p> + +<p>One source of trouble in the menopause is that it comes at a time in a +woman's life when she is likely to have too much leisure. In no way +can a woman so easily handicap her body at this time as by stopping +work and being afraid. Those women who have to go on as usual find +themselves past the change almost before they know it,—unless they +consider themselves abused, and worry over the necessity for working +through such a "critical time."</p> + +<p><b>Three Rules.</b> Here are a few pointers which have have been of help to +a number of women:</p> + +<p>1 Remember that this is a physiological process and therefore +abundantly safeguarded by Nature. If you don't expect trouble you will +not be likely to find it.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 316 --><a name="Page_316" id="Page_316" />2 Remember +that the sweating and flushing are made worse by notice.</p> + +<p>3 Do everything in your power to keep from the public the knowledge +that you are no longer a potential mother. If you are past forty, do +not mop your face or gasp for breath or carry a fan to the theater! +Shun attention and fear, and you will be surprised at the ease with +which the "change" is effected.</p> + +<p><b>Nature's Last Chance.</b> While we are on the subject of the middle-aged +woman, it may be well to mention a phenomenon sometimes noticed in the +early forties. Often an "old maid" who has considered herself settled +for life in her bachelor estate, suddenly takes to herself a husband. +(I use the verb advisedly!) Mothers who have thought their +child-bearing days long past sometimes find themselves pregnant. "The +child of her old age" is not an uncommon occurrence. Unmarried women +who have "kept straight" all their lives sometimes go down before +temptation at this late time. There is a reason. It is as though +Nature were making a last desperate attempt to produce another life +before it is too late, speeding up all the internal secretions and +flashing insistent messages throughout the whole organism.</p> + +<p>It may help some woman who feels herself inexplicably impelled toward +the male sex to know that she is not being "tempted by the devil" but +merely driven <!-- Page 317 --><a name="Page_317" id="Page_317" />by +the insistent chemicals within her body. She is +likely to rationalize and tell herself that it is too bad for a +worth-while person like herself to leave no progeny behind her; or she +may say, as one of my patients did when contemplating running away +with another woman's husband,—that she could make that man so much +happier than his wife did, and that she really owed it to him as well +as to herself. When a woman knows what is the matter with her, it +makes it easier to bide her time and wait for the demands of Nature to +subside. Chemicals may not be so romantic as love, but neither are +they so melodramatic!</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Other Troubles</p> + +<p><b>"Speaking of Operations."</b> Physicians are often called upon to +diagnose some such vague symptom as pain in the abdomen, back and +head; ache in the legs; constipation, or loss of appetite. Since the +patient is very insistent that something shall be done, the physician +may be driven to operate, even when he has an uneasy feeling that the +trouble is "merely nervous." Sixty per cent. of the operations on +women are necessitated by the results of gonorrheal infection. Next in +frequency up to recent date, have been operations for nervous symptoms +which could in no way be reached by the knife. Only too often a +nerve-specialist hears the tale of an operation which was supposed to +cure <!-- Page 318 --><a name="Page_318" id="Page_318" />a certain +pain but which left it worse rather than better. It is +a pleasure to see some of these pains disappear under a little +re-education, but one cannot help wishing that the re-education had +come before the knife instead of after it.</p> + +<p>A skilled surgeon can cut almost anything out of a person's body, but +he cannot cut out an instinct. It sometimes takes great skill to +determine whether the trouble is an organic affection or a functional +disturbance caused by the misdirected instinct of reproduction. Often, +however, the clinical pictures are so different as to leave no room +for doubt, provided the diagnostician has his eyes open and is not +over-persuaded by the importunity of the poor neurotic, who insists +that the surgeon shall remove her appendix, her gall-bladder, her +genital organs, and her tonsils, and who finally comes back that he +may have a whack at the operation scar.</p> + +<p><b>The Bearing of Children.</b> A number of years ago I became acquainted +with a charming young married woman who had all her life recoiled with +fear from the phenomena of sex. She had been afraid of menstruation +and of marriage, and had at this time almost a phobia for pregnancy +and childbirth. Before long she came to me in terror, telling me that +she had become pregnant. I explained to her that pregnancy is the time +when most women are at their best, that the <!-- Page 319 --> +<a name="Page_319" id="Page_319" />nausea which is often +troublesome in the beginning is caused merely by a mixing of messages +from the autonomic nerves, which refer new sensations in the womb to +the more usual center of activity in the stomach; and that after the +body has become accustomed to these sensations, most women experience +a greater sense of well-being and peace than at any other time in +life. We had a conversation or two on the subject and everything +seemed to go well for a while.</p> + +<p>As it happened, this young woman and her husband came to call on me +one afternoon just before the baby was expected. During the visit she +began to show signs of being in labor. Again she was in terror. Again +I explained the phenomena of labor, telling her that the +womb-contractions are caused by the presence in the blood of a +chemical secretion (hormone) which continues its good work as long as +there is a state of confidence, but which sometimes stops under fear +or apprehension. I explained that these womb-efforts are a peristaltic +movement, a contraction of the upper muscles and a letting go of the +purse-string muscle at the mouth of the womb, and that fear only tends +to tie up this purse-string muscle, making a difficult process out of +one which was intended by Nature to be much more simple. She seemed to +understand and to lose a good deal of her fright.</p> + +<p>About six o'clock the couple went home on the street <!-- Page 320 --> +<a name="Page_320" id="Page_320" />car from the +upper end of Pasadena to the far end of Los Angeles. The next morning +I had a jubilant telephone message from the happy father, announcing +that the boy-baby had arrived at midnight and that, wonderful to +relate, he had come without the mother's experiencing any pain +whatever.</p> + +<p>I give this account for what it is worth, without of course contending +that labor could always be as easy as this. It happened that this girl +was a normal, healthy woman and that there were no complications of +any kind in the process of childbirth. A right attitude of mind could +not have corrected any physical difficulty, but it did seem to help +her let go of her fear, which would of itself have caused long and +painful labor.</p> + +<p>A patient once told me that when her first baby came, she happened to +be out in the country where she had to call in a doctor whom she did +not know. He was an uncouth sort of fellow who inspired fear rather +than confidence. She soon found that labor stopped whenever he came +into the room, and started again when he went out. She had the good +sense to send him out and complete her labor with only the help of her +mother. Unfortunate is the obstetrician who does not know how to +inspire a feeling of confidence in his patients. Even childbirth may +be mightily helped or hindered by the mother's state of mind.</p> + +<p class="scheading"><!-- Page 321 --><a name="Page_321" id="Page_321" />Summary</p> + +<p>A woman's body has more stability than she knows. It is sometimes out +of order, but it is more often misunderstood; usually it is an +unobtrusive and satisfactory instrument, quite fit for its daily +tasks. The average woman is really well put together. We hear about +the ones who have difficulty, but not about the great majority who do +not. We notice the few who are upset during the menopause, and forget +all the others. To be comfortable and efficient most of the time is, +after all, merely to be "like folks."</p> + +<p>The special functions which Nature has been perfecting in a woman's +body are as a rule, easily carried through unless complicated by false +ideas or by fear.</p> + +<p>If the woman who has no organic difficulty but who still finds herself +handicapped by her body, will cease being either resigned to her +languishing lot or envious of her stalwart brothers; if instead she +will set out to learn how to be efficient as a woman, she will find +that many of her ills are not the blunders of an inefficient Creator, +but are home-made products, which quickly vanish in the light of +understanding.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 322 --><a name="Page_322" id="Page_322" /></div> + +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_XIII" id="CHAPTER_XIII">CHAPTER XIII</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we lose our dread of night.</i></p> + +<p class="heading">THAT INTERESTING INSOMNIA</p> + +<p class="scheading">The Fear of Staying Awake</p> + + +<p>To sleep or not to sleep! That is the question. In all the world there +is nothing to equal it in importance,—to the man with insomnia. His +days are mere interludes between troubled nights spent in restless +tossing to and fro and feverish worry over the weary day to come. His +mind filled with ideas about the disastrous effects of insomnia, he +imagines himself fast sliding down hill toward the grave or the +insane-asylum. It is true that his conversation very often politely +begins something like this: "Good morning. Did you sleep well last +night?" but if we fail to respond by an equally polite "and I hope you +had a good night?" he seems restless until he has somehow +disillusioned us by stating the exact number of hours and minutes +during which he was able to lose himself in slumber.</p> + +<p>We must not ridicule the man who doesn't sleep. <!-- Page 323 --> +<a name="Page_323" id="Page_323" />We are all very much +alike. If any one of us happens to lie awake for a night or two, he is +likely to get into a panic, and if the spell should last a week, he +begins looking up steamship agents and talking of voyages to Southern +seas. The fact is that most people are dreadfully afraid of insomnia. +Knowing the effects of a few nights of enforced wakefulness, and +having had a little experience with the fagged feeling after a +restless night, they believe themselves only logical when they fall +into a panic over the prospect of persistent insomnia.</p> + +<p><b>Two Kinds of Wakefulness.</b> As a matter of fact, insomnia is a phantom +peril. There is not the slightest danger from lying awake nights, +provided one is not kept awake by some irritating physical stimulus. +All fear of insomnia is based on ignorance of the difference between +enforced wakefulness and deliberate wakefulness, or insomnia. The man +who has acquired the habit may stay awake almost indefinitely without +appreciable harm, but the one who is kept awake for a week by a pain, +by a chemical poison from infection, or by the necessity for staying +up on his job, may easily be in a state of exhaustion. Even in cases +of prolonged pain or over-exertion, the body tends to maintain its +equilibrium by hastening its rate of repair and by falling asleep +before the danger point is reached. It is almost impossible to impair +permanently the tissue <!-- Page 324 --> +<a name="Page_324" id="Page_324" />of the brain except in the presence of a +chemical irritant. In case of infection we often have to give medicine +to neutralize the effect of the poison or to resort to narcotics which +make the brain cells less susceptible to irritation. But nervous +insomnia is another story.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">A Harmless Habit</p> + +<p><b>Long-Lived Insomniacs.</b> A man of my acquaintance once said in all +seriousness and with evident alarm: "I am following in the footsteps +of my mother. She lived to be seventy years old and she had insomnia +all her life." If this man had been preaching a sermon on the +harmlessness of chronic insomnia, he could not have chosen a better +text, but he seemed just as much concerned about himself as if his +mother had died from the effects of three months' wakefulness. People +can live healthy lives during twenty or thirty years of insomnia +because chronic insomnia is nothing more or less than a habit, and +"habit spells ease." The brain cells are not irritated by either +internal or external stimuli; there is no effort to keep awake; +virtually no energy is expended,—except in restless tossing and +worry. If the body is kept still and emotion eliminated, fatigue +products are washed away and the reserves are filled in with perfect +ease.</p> + +<p><b>Thinking in Circles.</b> Habit means automatic, +<!-- Page 325 --><a name="Page_325" id="Page_325" />subconscious activity, +with the least expenditure of energy and the least amount of fatigue. +We have already noted the ease with which heart and diaphragm muscles +carry on their work from the beginning of life to its end. Anything +relegated to the subconscious mind can be kept up almost indefinitely +without tire, and to this subconscious type of activity belong the +thoughts of a chronic insomniac. Despite all assertions to the +contrary, his conscious mind is not really awake. If he is questioned +about the happenings of the night, he is likely to have been unaware +of the most audible noises. The thoughts that run through his brain +are not new, constructive, energy-consuming thoughts, but the same old +thoughts that have been going around in circles for days and weeks at +a time.</p> + +<p>It is true that a person sometimes chooses to wake up and do his +constructive planning in the night. This kind of thought does bring +fatigue, up to a certain point. After that the body hastens its rate +of repair or automatically goes to sleep. Activity of this kind is +always a matter of choice. He who really prefers sleep will shut the +drawers containing the day's business and leave them shut until +morning.</p> + +<p><b>Day-Dreaming at Night.</b> However, the man who makes a practice of +staying awake rarely does much real thinking. He lets the thoughts run +through his mind as they will, builds air-castles of things he would +<!-- Page 326 --><a name="Page_326" id="Page_326" />like +to do and can't, or other kinds of air-castles about the +disastrous effects of his insomnia on the day that is to come; he +worries over his health, or his finances, and grieves over his +sorrows. He is really indulging himself, thinking the thoughts he +likes most to think, and these consume but little energy. Like a horse +that knows the rounds, they can go jogging on indefinitely without +guidance from the driver.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">What Causes the Fatigue</p> + +<p><b>Tossing and Fretting.</b> The thing that tires is not the insomnia but +the emotion over the insomnia. If people who fail to sleep are +perpetually fagged out, it is not from loss of sleep, but from worry +and tossing. Often they spend a good deal of the night feeling sorry +for themselves. They turn and toss, exclaiming with each turn: "Why +don't I sleep? How badly I shall feel to-morrow! What a night! What a +night!" Such a spree of emotionalism can hardly fail to tire, but it +is not fair to blame the insomnia.</p> + +<p>He who makes up his mind to it can rest almost as well without sleep +as with it, provided he keeps his mind calm and his body relaxed. +"Decent hygienic conditions" demand not necessarily eight hours of +sleep but eight hours of quiet rest in bed. Tossing about drives away +sleep and uses up energy. I make it a rule that my patients shall not +turn over more than four <!-- Page 327 --> +<a name="Page_327" id="Page_327" />times during the night. This is more +important than that they should sleep. To be sure, I do not stay awake +to enforce the rule, but most people catch the idea very quickly and +before they know it they are sleeping.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">How to Go to Sleep</p> + +<p><b>Ceasing to Care.</b> The best way to learn to sleep is not to care +whether you do or not. Nothing could be better than DuBois's advice: +"Don't look for sleep; it flies away like a pigeon when one pursues +it."<a name="FNanchor_58" id="FNanchor_58"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_58" class="fnanchor">[58]</a> +Attention to anything keeps the mind awake, and most of all, +attention to sleep. More than one person has waked up to see whether +or not he was going to sleep. We cannot, however, fool ourselves by +merely pretending indifference. The only sensible way is to get the +facts firmly fixed in our minds so that we actually realize that we do +not need more sleep than our bodies take. As soon as it is realized +that insomnia is really of no importance, it tends to disappear.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_58" id="Footnote_58"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_58"><span class="label">[58]</span> +</a> DuBois: <i>Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders</i>, p. +339.</p></div> + +<p><b>Catching the Idea.</b> There came one day for consultation a very +healthy-looking woman, a deaconess of the Lutheran Church. "Doctor," +she said, "I came to get relief from insomnia. For twenty years I have +not slept more than one or two hours a night." "Why do you want more?" +I asked. "Why, isn't it <!-- Page 328 --><a name="Page_328" id="Page_328" /> +very unhealthy not to sleep?" she exclaimed +in astonishment. "Evidently not," I answered.</p> + +<p>This woman had tried every doctor she could think of, including the +splendid S. Weir Mitchell. Her insomnia had become a preoccupation +with her, her chief thought in life. All I did was to explain to her +that her body had been getting all the sleep it needed, and that +neither body nor mind was in the least run down after twenty years of +sleeplessness. "When you cease being interested in your insomnia, it +will go away, although from a health standpoint it matters very little +whether it does or not." We had two conversations on the subject, and +a week later she came back to tell me that she was sleeping eight +hours a night.</p> + +<p>One woman had had insomnia for thirty years. After I had explained to +her that her body had adjusted itself to this way of living and that +she need not try to get more sleep, she snored so loud all night and +every night that the rest of the family began to complain!</p> + +<p>A certain banker proved very quick at catching the idea. He had been +so troubled with insomnia and intense weakness that his doctors +prescribed a six-months voyage in Southern waters. Knowing that my +prescriptions involved a change in point of view rather than in scene, +he came to me. Although he had been getting only about half an hour's +sleep a night, he went <!-- Page 329 --><a name="Page_329" id="Page_329" /> +to sleep in his chair the first evening, and +then went upstairs and slept all night. He resumed his duties at the +bank, walking a mile and a half the first day and three miles the +second. During the months following, he reported, "No more insomnia."</p> + +<p><b>Keeping Account.</b> A bright young college graduate came to me for a +number of ailments, chief among them being sleeplessness. She was also +overcome by fatigue, having spent four months in bed. A four-mile walk +in the cañon and a few other such outings soon dispelled the fatigue, +but the insomnia proved more obstinate. After she had been with me for +a week or two, I took her aside one day for a little talk. "Well?" I +said as we sat down. Then she began: "Sunday night I was awake from +half-past one to four, Monday from twelve to one, Tuesday from one to +three, Wednesday from two to four, Thursday—" By this time she became +aware of the quizzical expression on my face and began to be +embarrassed. Then she stopped and laughed. "Well," she said, "I did +not know that I was paying so much attention to my sleep." She was +bright enough to see the point at once, gave up her preoccupation in +the all-absorbing topic and promptly forgot to have any trouble with +so natural a function as sleep.</p> + +<p><b>Making New Associations.</b> Examples like this show how natural is +childlike slumber when once we <!-- Page 330 --> +<a name="Page_330" id="Page_330" />take away the inhibitions of a +hampering idea. Age-old habits like sleep are not lost, but they may +easily be interfered with by a little too much attention. When a +person who can scarcely keep his eyes open all the evening is +instantly wide awake as soon as his head touches the pillow, we may be +sure that a part of his trouble comes from the wrong associations +which he has built up with the thought of night. When a dear little +old lady told me of her constant state of apprehension about going to +bed, I said to her: "When I go to my room, the darkness says sleep. +When I take off my clothes, the very act says sleep. When I put my +head on the pillow, the pillow says sleep." She liked that and found +herself able to sleep all night. The next evening she wanted another +"sleeping-potion" but as I did not want her to become dependent on +anybody's suggestion, I put my mouth up close +<span title="Corrected typo: was 'to to'" class="hov">to</span> her ear and +whispered, "Abra ca dabra, dum, dum, dum." She laughed, but saw the +point. After that she slept very well. She merely broke the habit by +making a new kind of association with the thought of bed. Nature did the rest.</p> + +<p>It seems hardly necessary to remark that drug-taking is the most +inefficient way of handling the situation. Everybody knows that +narcotics are harmful to the delicate cells of the brain and that the +dose has to be continuously increased in cases of chronic insomnia. +<!-- Page 331 --><a name="Page_331" id="Page_331" />If a +person realizes that the drug is far more harmful than the +insomnia itself, he is weak indeed to yield to temptation for the sake +of a few nights of sleep. As the cause of insomnia is psychic, so the +only logical cure is a new idea and a new attitude of mind.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Purpose of Insomnia</p> + +<p>Like all nervous symptoms, insomnia is not an affliction but an +indulgence. Somehow, and in ways unknown to the conscious mind, it +brings a certain amount of satisfaction to a part of the personality. +No matter how unpleasant it may be, no matter how much we consciously +fear it, something inside chooses to stay awake.</p> + +<p>Started, as a rule, through suggestion or imitation, insomnia is +sometimes kept up as a means of making ourselves seem important,—to +ourselves and to others. It at least provides an excuse for thinking +and talking about ourselves, and furnishes a certain feeling of +distinction. If something within us craves attention, even staying +awake may not be too dear a price to pay for that attention. Strange +to say, there are other times when the insomnia is chosen by the +primitive subconscious mind with the idea of doing penance for +supposed sins whose evil effects might possibly be avoided by this +kind of expiation. Analysis shows that motives like this are not so +uncommon as might be supposed. <!-- Page 332 --> +<a name="Page_332" id="Page_332" />In other cases insomnia is chosen for +the chance it gives for phantasy-building. A person denied the right +kind of outlet for his instincts may so enjoy the day-dreaming habit +that he prolongs it into the night, really preferring it to sleep. +Such a state of affairs is not at all incompatible with an intense +conscious desire to sleep and a real fear of insomnia. So strange may +be the motives hidden away within the depths of the most prosaic +individual!</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p>Nervous insomnia is something which a part of us makes use of and +another part fears. It is a mistake on both sides. Although not in the +least dangerous, the habit can hardly be considered a satisfactory +form of amusement. Nature has provided a better way to spend the +night, a way to which she speedily brings us when we choose to let her +do it.</p> + +<p>We do not have to ask for sleep as for a special boon which may be +denied. We simply have to lie down in trust, expecting to be carried +away like a child. If our expectation is not at once realized we can +still trust, as with relaxed mind and body we lie in calm content, +knowing that Nature is, minute by minute, restoring us for another +day.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 333 --><a name="Page_333" id="Page_333" /></div> + +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_XIV" id="CHAPTER_XIV">CHAPTER XIV</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we raise our thresholds</i></p> + +<p class="heading">FEELING OUR FEELINGS</p> + +<p class="scheading">Finely Strung Violins</p> + + +<p>The young girl had been telling me about her symptoms. "You know, +Doctor," she said. "I am a very sensitive person. In fact, I have +always been told that I am like a finely strung violin." There was +pride in every tone of her voice,—pride and satisfaction over +possessing an organization so superior to the common clay of the +average person. It was a typical remark, and showed clearly that this +girl belonged among the nervous folk. For the nervous person is not +only over-sensitive, but he accepts his condition with a secret and +half-conscious pride as a token of superiority.</p> + +<p>It seems that there are a good many kinds of sensitiveness. Whether it +is a good or bad possession depends entirely on what kind of things a +person is sensitive to. If he is quick to take in a situation, easily +impressed with the needs of others, open-doored to beauty and to the +appeal of the spiritual, keenly alive <!-- Page 334 --> +<a name="Page_334" id="Page_334" />to the humorous, even when the +joke is on himself and the situation uncomfortable, then surely he has +a right to be glad of his sensitiveness. But too often the word means +something else. It means feeling, intensely, physical sensations of +which most people are unaware, or reacting emotionally to situations +which call for no such response. It means, in short, feeling our +feelings and liking to feel them. There seems to be nothing +particularly praiseworthy or desirable about this kind of +sensitiveness. If this is what it means to be a "finely-wrought +violin," it might even be better to be a bass drum which can stand a +few poundings without ruin to its constitution.</p> + +<p>"But," says the sensitive person, "are we not born either violins or +drums? Is not heredity rather than choice to blame? And what can a +person do about it?" These questions are so closely bound up with the +problems of nervous symptoms of indigestion, fatigue, a woman's ills, +hysterical pains and sensations, and with all the problems of +emotional control, that we shall do well to look more carefully into +this question of sensibility, which is really the question of the +relation of the individual to his environment.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Selecting Our Sensations</p> + +<p><b>Reaction and Over-Reaction.</b> Every organism, if it is to live, must +be normally sensitive to its environment. <!-- Page 335 --> +<a name="Page_335" id="Page_335" />It must possess the power +of response to stimuli. As the sea-anemone curls up at touch, and as +the tiny baby blinks at the light, so must every living thing be able +to sense and to react to the presence of a dangerous or a friendly +force. Only by a certain degree of irritability can it survive in the +struggle for existence. The five senses are simply different phases of +the apparatus for receiving communications from the outside world. +Other parts of the machinery catch the manifold messages continually +pouring into the brain from within our bodies themselves. These +communications cannot be stopped nor can we prevent their impress on +the cells of the brain and spinal cord, but we do have a good deal to +say as to which ones shall be brought into the focus of attention and +receive enough notice to become real, conscious sensations.</p> + +<p><b>Paying Attention.</b> If a human being had to give conscious attention +to every stimulus from the outer world and from his own body, to every +signal which flashes itself along his sensory nerves to his brain, he +would need a different kind of mind from his present efficient but +limited apparatus. As it is, there is an admirable provision for +taking care of the messages without overburdening consciousness. The +stream of messages never stops, not even in sleep. But the conscious +mind has its private secretary, the subconscious, to receive the +messages and to answer them.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 336 --><a name="Page_336" id="Page_336" /> +During any five minutes of a walk down a city street a man has +hundreds of visual images flashed upon the retina of the eye. His eye +sees every little line in the faces of the passers-by, every detail of +their clothing, the decorations on the buildings, the street signs +overhead, the articles in the shop-windows, the paving of the +sidewalks, the curbings and tracks which he crosses, and scores of +other objects to most of which the man himself is oblivious. His ear +hears every sound within hearing distance,—the honk of every horn, +the clang of every bell, the voices of the people and the shuffle of +feet. Some part of his mind feels the press of his foot on the +pavement, the rubbing of his heel on his stocking, the touch of his +clothing all over his body, and all those so-called kinesthetic +sensations,—sensations of motion and balance which keep him in +equilibrium and on the move, to say nothing of the never-ending stream +of messages from every cell of every muscle and tissue of his body.</p> + +<p>Out of this constant rush of stimuli our man gives attention to only +the smallest fraction. Whatever is interesting to him, that he sees +and hears and feels. All other sensations he passes by as indifferent. +Unless they come with extraordinary intensity, they do not get over +into his consciousness at all.</p> + +<p><b>"Listening-in" on the Subconscious.</b> The +subconscious mind knows and needs to know what is happening +<!-- Page 337 --><a name="Page_337" id="Page_337" />in the farthermost cell of the body. +It needs to know at any moment where the knees are, and the feet; +otherwise the individual would fall in a heap whenever he forgot to +watch his step. It needs to know just how much light is entering the +eye, and how much blood is in the stomach. To this end it has a system +of communication from every point in the body and this system is in +constant operation. Its messages never cease. But these messages were +never meant to be in the focus of attention. They are meant only for +the subconscious mind and are generally so low-toned as to be easily +ignored unless one falls into the habit of listening for them. Unless +they are invested with a significance which does not belong to them, +they will not emerge into consciousness as real sensations.</p> + +<p><b>Psychic Thresholds.</b> Boris Sidis has given us a word which has proved +very useful in this connection. The limit of sensitivity of a +cell—the degree of irritability—he calls the +stimulus-threshold.<a name="FNanchor_59" id="FNanchor_59"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_59" class="fnanchor">[59]</a> +As the wind must come in gusts to drive the rain in over a high +doorsill, so must any stimulus—an idea or a sensation—come with +sufficient force to get over the obstructions at the doorway of +consciousness. These psychic thresholds do not maintain a constant +level. They are raised or lowered at will by a hidden and automatic +<!-- Page 338 --><a name="Page_338" id="Page_338" />machinery, +which is dependent entirely on the ideas already in +consciousness, by the interest bestowed upon the newcomer. The +intensity of the stimuli cannot be controlled, but the interest we +feel in them and the welcome given them are very largely a matter of choice.</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_59" id="Footnote_59"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_59"><span class="label">[59]</span> +</a> Sidis: <i>Foundations of Normal and Abnormal Psychology</i>, +Chap. XXX.</p></div> + +<p>Each organism has a wide field of choice as to which ideas and which +physical stimuli it shall welcome and which it shall shut out. We may +raise our thresholds, build up a bulwark of indifference to a whole +class of excitations, shut our mental doors, and pull down the shades; +or we may lower the thresholds so that the slightest flicker of an +idea or the smallest pin-prick of a sensation finds ready access to +the center of attention.</p> + +<p><b>Thresholds and Character.</b> There are certain thresholds made to shift +frequently and easily. When one is hungry any food tastes good, for +the threshold is low; but the food must be most tempting to be +acceptable just after a hearty meal. On the other hand, a fairly +constant threshold is maintained for many different kinds of stimuli. +These stimuli are always bound together in groups, and make appeal +depending upon the predominating interest. As anything pertaining to +agriculture is noticed by a farmer, or any article of dress by a +fashionable woman, so any stimulus coming from a "warm" group is +welcomed, while any from a "cold" group is met by a high threshold. +The kind <!-- Page 339 --><a name="Page_339" id="Page_339" />of person +one is depends on what kind of things are "warm" +to him and what kind are "cold." The superman is one who has gained +such conscious control of his psychic thresholds that he can raise and +lower them at will in the interests of the social good.</p> + +<p><b>Thresholds and Sensations.</b> The importance of these principles is +obvious. The next chapter will show more of their influence on ideas +and emotions; but for the present we will consider their lessons in +the sphere of the physical. Psychology speaks here in no uncertain +terms to physiology. Whoever becomes fascinated by the processes of +his own body is bound to magnify the sensations from those processes, +until the most insignificant message from the subconscious becomes a +distressing and alarming symptom. The person whose mental ear is +strained to catch every little creaking of his internal machinery can +always hear some kind of rumble. If he deliberately lowers his +thresholds to the whole class of stimuli pertaining to himself, there +is small wonder that they sweep over the boundaries into consciousness +with irresistible force.</p> + +<p><b>The Motives for Sensitiveness.</b> Sensitiveness is largely a matter of +choice, but what determines choice? Why is it that one person chooses +altruism as the master threshold that determines the level of all the +others, while another person who ought to be equally fine lowers +<!-- Page 340 --><a name="Page_340" id="Page_340" />his +thresholds only to himself? What makes a person too interested in his +own sensations and feelings? As usual there is a cause.</p> + +<p>The real cause back of most cases of chronic sensitiveness is an +abnormal desire for attention. Sometimes this love of attention arises +from an under-developed instinct of self-assertion, or "inferiority +complex." If there is a sense of inadequacy, a feeling of not being so +important as other people, a person is quite likely to over-compensate +by making himself seem important to himself and to others in the only +way he knows. All unconsciously he develops an extreme sensitiveness +which somehow heightens his self-regard by making him believe himself +finely and delicately organized, and by securing the notice of his +associates.</p> + +<p>Or, again, the love of attention may be simply a sign of arrested +development, a fixation of the Narcissistic period of childhood which +loves to look at itself and make the world look. Or there may be lack +of satisfaction of the normal adult love-life, a lack of the love and +attention which the love-instinct naturally craves. If this instinct +is not getting normal outlet, either directly through personal +relationships or indirectly through a sublimated activity, what is +more natural than that it should turn in on itself, dissociate its +interest in other things and occupy itself with its own +<!-- Page 341 --><a name="Page_341" id="Page_341" />feelings, and +at the same time secure the coveted attention through physical +disability, with its necessity for special ministration?</p> + +<p>In any case there is likely to develop a general overreaction to all +outside stimulation, a hypersensitiveness to some particular kind of +stimulus, or a chronic hysterical pain which somehow serves the +personality in ways unknown to itself. No one "feels his feelings" +unless, despite all discomfort, he really enjoys them. A hard +statement to accept perhaps, but one that is repeatedly proved by a +specialist in "nerves"!</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Determining Causes</p> + +<p><b>Accidental Association.</b> In many cases, the form which the +sensitiveness takes is merely a matter of accident. Often it is based +on some small physical disability, as when a slight tendency to take +cold is magnified into an intense fear of fresh air.</p> + +<p>Sometimes a past fleeting pain which has become associated with the +stream of thought of an emotional moment—what Boris Sidis calls the +moment-consciousness—is perpetuated in consciousness in place of the +repressed emotion. "In the determination of the pathology of hysteria, +the accidental moment plays a much greater part than is generally +recognized; if a painful affect—emotion—originates while eating but +is repressed, it may produce nausea and vomiting and <!-- Page 342 --> +<a name="Page_342" id="Page_342" />continue for months as an hysterical +symptom."<a name="FNanchor_60" id="FNanchor_60"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_60" class="fnanchor">[60]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_60" id="Footnote_60"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_60"><span class="label">[60]</span> +</a> Freud: <i>Selected Papers</i>, p. 2.</p></div> + +<p>One of Freud's patients, Miss Rosalie H——, found while taking +singing-lessons that she often choked over notes of the middle +register, although she took with ease notes higher and lower in the +scale. It was revealed that this girl, who had a most unhappy home +life, had, during a former period, often experienced this choking +sensation from a painful emotion just before she went for her music +lesson. Some of the left-over sensations had remained during the +singing, and as the middle notes happen to involve the same muscles as +does a lump in one's throat, she had often found herself choking over +these notes. Later on, while living in a different city and in a +wholly different environment, the physical sensations from her throat +muscles, as they took these middle notes, brought back the associated +sensations of choking,—without, however, uncovering the buried +emotion.<a name="FNanchor_61" id="FNanchor_61"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_61" class="fnanchor">[61]</a> Many a +painful hysterical affliction is based on just such mechanisms as these. +As Freud remarks, "The hysteric suffers mostly from +reminiscences."<a name="FNanchor_62" id="FNanchor_62"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_62" class="fnanchor">[62]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_61" id="Footnote_61"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_61"><span class="label">[61]</span></a> Ibid, p. 43.</p></div> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_62" id="Footnote_62"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_62"><span class="label">[62]</span></a> Ibid, p. 5.</p></div> + +<p><!-- Page 343 --><a name="Page_343" id="Page_343" /><b>Subconscious +Symbolism.</b> Sometimes, as we have seen, the form which +a hypersensitiveness assumes is not determined by any physical sensation, +either past or symbolism which acts out in the body the drama of the soul.</p> + +<p><b>Facing the Facts.</b> Whatever the motives and whatever the determining +causes, hypersensibility is in any case a feeling of feelings which is +not warranted by the present situation. Hypersensitiveness is never +anything but a makeshift kind of satisfaction. Despite certain +subconscious reasoning, it does not make one more important nor more +beloved. Neither does it furnish a real expression for that great +creative love-instinct whose outlet, if it is to bring satisfaction, +must be a real outlet into the external world. An understanding of the +motives is helpful only when it makes clear that they are +short-sighted motives and that the real desires back of them may be +satisfied in better ways.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Some Lowered Thresholds</p> + +<p>As the public appetite for specific cases appears to be insatiable, we +will give from real life some examples of low thresholds which were +raised through re-education. One hesitates to write down these +examples because when they are on paper they sound like advertisements +of patent medicines. However, there is no magic in any of these cures, +but only the working out of definite laws which may be used by other +sufferers, if they only <!-- Page 344 --> +<a name="Page_344" id="Page_344" />know. Re-education through a knowledge of +oneself and the laws at work really does remarkable things when it has +a chance.</p> + +<p><b>"Danger-Signals" without the Danger.</b> There was the man who had queer +feelings all over his body, especially in his head and stomach, and +who considered these sensations as danger-signals warning him to stop. +This man had worked up from messenger boy to a position next to the +president in one of the transcontinental railroad systems. On the +appearance of these "danger-signals" he had tried to resign but had +been given a year's leave of absence instead. Half the year had gone +in rest-cure, but he was still afraid to eat or work, and believed +himself "done for." After three weeks of re-education he saw that +instead of having overdrawn his capital, he had in another sense +overdrawn his sensations. He went away as fit as ever, finished his +leave of absence doing hard labor on his farm, and then went back to +even harder tasks, working for the Government in the administration of +the railroads during the war. He is still at work.</p> + +<p><b>Enjoying Poor Health.</b> There was the woman who had been an invalid +for twenty years, doing little else during all that time than to feel +her own feelings. Because of the distressing sensations in her +stomach, she had for a year taken nothing but liquid nourishment. She +had queer feelings in her solar-plexus and <!-- Page 345 --> +<a name="Page_345" id="Page_345" />indeed a general luxury of +over-feeling. She could not leave her room nor have any visitors. She +was the star invalid of the family, waited on by her two hard-working +sisters who earned the living for them all.</p> + +<p>Her sisters had inveigled her to my house under false pretenses, +calling it a boarding-house and omitting to mention that I was a +doctor, because "she guessed she knew more about her case than any +doctor." For the first week I got in only one sentence a day,—just +before I slipped out of the door after taking in her "liquid +nourishment." But at the end of the week I announced that thereafter +her meals would be served in the dining-room. When she found that +there was to be no more liquid nourishment, she had to appear at the +family table. After that it was only a short time before she was at +home, cooking for her sisters. When she saw the role she had been +unconsciously playing, she could hardly wish to go on with it.</p> + +<p><b>Feeling His Legs.</b> Mr. R. suffered from such severe and distressing +pains in his legs that he believed himself on the verge of paralysis. +He was also bothered by a chronic emotional state which made him look +like a "weepy" woman. His eyes were always full of tears and his chin +a-quiver, and he had, as he said, a perpetual lump in his throat. +Under re-education both lump and paralysis disappeared completely and +Mr. R. took his wife across the continent, <!-- Page 346 --> +<a name="Page_346" id="Page_346" />driving his machine with his +own hands—and feet.</p> + +<p><b>A Subconscious Association.</b> Mr. D.'s case admirably illustrates the +return of symptoms through an unconscious association. He was a +lawyer, prominent in public affairs of the Middle West, who had been +my patient for several weeks and who had gone home cured of many +striking disabilities. Before he came to me, he had given up his +public work and was believed by all his associates to be afflicted +with softening of the brain, and "out of the game" for good. From +being one of the ablest men of his State, he had fallen into such a +condition that he could neither read a letter nor write one. He could +not stand the least sunshine on his head, and to walk half a mile was +an impossibility. He was completely "down and out" and expected to be +an invalid for the rest of his life.</p> + +<p>But these symptoms had one by one +<span title="Corrected typo: was 'disappeaared'" class="hov">disappeared</span> +during his five-weeks stay with me. He had done good stiff work in the garden, carried a +heavy sack of grapefruit a mile in the hot sun, and was generally his +old self again. Now he was back in the harness, hard at work as of +old. Suddenly, as he sat reading in his home one evening, all his old +symptoms swept over him,—the pains in his head and legs, the pounding +of the heart, the "all-gone" sensations as though he were going to die +on the spot. He became almost completely dissociated, but through it +all he clung to the idea which <!-- Page 347 --> +<a name="Page_347" id="Page_347" />he had learned,—namely that this +experience was not really physical as it seemed but was the result of +some idea, and would pass. He did not tell any one of the attack, +ignored it as much as possible, and waited. In a few minutes he was +himself again. Then he looked for the cause and realized that the +article he was reading was one he had read several months previous, +when suffering most severely from the whole train of symptoms. When +the familiar words had again gone into his mind, they had pressed the +button for the whole physiological experience which had once before +been associated with them. This is the same mechanism as that involved +in Prince's case, Miss Beauchamp, who became completely dissociated at +one time when a breeze swept across her face. When Dr. Prince looked +for the cause, he found that once before she had experienced certain +distressing emotions while a breeze was fanning her cheek. The +recurrence of the physical stimulation had been sufficient to bring +back in its entirety the former emotional complex.</p> + +<p><b>Another Kind of Association.</b> One of my women patients illustrates +another kind of association-mechanism, based not on proximity in time +but proximity of position in the body. This woman had complained for +years of "bladder trouble" although no physical examination had been +able to reveal any organic difficulty. She referred to a constant +distress in the region of the <!-- Page 348 --> +<a name="Page_348" id="Page_348" />bladder and was never without a certain +red blanket which she wrapped around her every time she sat down. +During psycho-analysis she recounted an experience of years before +which she had never mentioned to anybody. During a professional +consultation her physician, a married man, had suddenly seized her and +exclaimed, "I love you! I love you!" In spite of herself, the woman +felt a certain appeal, followed by a great sense of guilt. In the +conflict between the physiological reflex and her moral repugnance, +she had shunted out of consciousness the real sex-sensation and had +replaced it with a sensation which had become associated in her +subconscious mind with the original temptation. Since the nerves from +the genital region and from the bladder connect with the same segment +of the spinal cord, she had unconsciously chosen to mix her messages, +and to cling to the substitute sensation without being in the least +Conscious of the cause. As soon as she had described the scene to me +and had discerned its connection with her symptoms, the bladder +trouble disappeared.</p> + +<p><b>Afraid of the Cold.</b> Patients who are sensitive to cold are very +numerous. Mr. G.—he of the prunes and bran biscuits—was so afraid of +a draft that he could detect the air current if a window was opened a +few inches anywhere in a two-story house. He always wore two suits of +underwear, but despite his precautions <!-- Page 349 --><a name="Page_349" id="Page_349" /> +he had a swollen red throat +much of the time. His prescription was a cold bath every morning, a +source of delight to the other men patients, who made him stay in the +water while they counted five. He was required to dress and live like +other folks and of course his sensitiveness and his sore throat disappeared.</p> + +<p>Dr. B——, when he came to me, was the most wrapped-up man I had ever +met. He had on two suits of underwear, a sweater, a vest and suit +coat, an overcoat, a bear-skin coat and a Jaeger scarf—all in +Pasadena in May!</p> + +<p>Besides this fear of cold, he was suffering from a hypersensitiveness +of several other varieties. So sensitive was his skin that he had his +clothes all made several sizes too big for him so that they would not +make pressure. He was so aware of the muscles of the neck that he +believed himself unable to hold up his head, and either propped it +with his hands or leaned it against the back of a chair.</p> + +<p>He had been working on the eighth edition of his book, a scientific +treatise of nation-wide importance, but his eyes were so sensitive +that he could not possibly use them and had to keep them shaded from +the glare. He was so conscious of the messages of fatigue that he was +unable to walk at all, and he suffered from the usual trouble with +constipation. All these symptoms of course belonged together and were +the direct result of <!-- Page 350 --><a name="Page_350" id="Page_350" /> +a wrong state of mind. When he had changed his +mind, he took off his extra clothes, walked a mile and a half at the +first try, gave up his constipation, and went back to work. Later on I +had a letter from him saying that his favorite seat was an overturned +nail-keg in the garden and that he was thinking of sawing the backs +off his chairs.</p> + +<p>Miss Y—— had worn cotton in her ears for a year or two because she +had once had an inflammation of the middle ear, and believed the +membrane still sensitive to cold. There was Miss E——, whose +underwear always reached to her throat and wrists and who spent her +time following the sun; and Dr. I——, who never forgot her heavy +sweater or her shawl over her knees, even in front of the fire. The +procession of "cold ones" is almost endless, but always they find that +their sensitiveness is of their own making and that it disappears when +they choose to ignore it.</p> + +<p><b>Fear of Light.</b> Fear of cold is no more common than fear of light. +Nervous folk with half-shut eyes are very frequent indeed. From one +woman I took at least seven pairs of dark glasses before she learned +that her eye was made for light. A good example is furnished by a +woman who was not a patient of mine at all, but merely the sister of a +patient. After my patient had been cured of a number of distressing +symptoms—pain in the spine, sore heels, a severe nervous +<!-- Page 351 --><a name="Page_351" id="Page_351" />cough, +indigestion and other typical complaints,—she began to scheme to get +her sister to come to me.</p> + +<p>This sister, the wife of a minister in the Middle West, had a constant +pain in her eyes, compelling her to hold them half-shut all the time. +When she was approached about coming to me, she said indignantly, "If +that doctor thinks that my trouble is nervous, she is much mistaken," +and then proceeded to get well. Once the subconscious mind gets the +idea that its game is recognized, it is very apt to give it up, and it +can do this without loss of time if it really wants to.</p> + +<p><b>Pain at the Base of the Brain.</b> Of all nervous pains, that in the +back of the neck is by all odds the most common. It is rare indeed to +find a nervous patient without this complaint, and among supposedly +well folk it is only too frequent. Indeed, it almost seems that in +some quarters such a pain stands as a badge of the fervor and zeal of +one's work.</p> + +<p>But work is never responsible for this sense of discomfort. Only an +over-sensitiveness to feelings or a false emotionalism can produce a +pain of this kind, unless it should happen to be caused by some poison +circulating in the blood. The trouble is not with the nerves or with +the spine, despite the fad about misplaced vertebræ. When a doctor +examines a sensitive spine, marking the sore spots with a blue pencil, +and a few minutes later repeats the process, he finds almost +<!-- Page 352 --><a name="Page_352" id="Page_352" />invariably +that the spots have shifted. They are not true physical +pains and they rarely remain long in the same place.</p> + +<p>Pain in the spine and neck is an example of exaggerated sensibility or +over-awareness. Since all messages from every part of trunk and limb +must go through the spinal cord, and since very many of them enter the +cord in the region of the neck and shoulder blades, it is only natural +that an over-feeling of these messages should be especially noticed in +this zone.</p> + +<p>Sometimes a false emotionalism adds to the discomfort by tensing the +whole muscular system and making the messages more intense. When a +social worker or a business man gets tense over his work or ties +himself into knots over a committee meeting, he not only foolishly +wastes his energy but makes his nerves carry messages that are more +urgent than usual. Then if he is on the look-out for sensations, he +all the more easily becomes aware of the central station in the spine +where the messages are received. By centering his attention on this +station and tightening up his back-muscles, he increases this +over-awareness and easily gets himself into the clutch of a vicious +habit.</p> + +<p>Sometimes a tenseness of the body is the result, not of a false +attitude toward one's work, but of a lack of satisfaction in other +directions. If the love-force is not getting what it wants, it may +keep the body in a <!-- Page 353 --><a name="Page_353" id="Page_353" /> +state of tension, with all the undesirable results +of such tension. The person who keeps himself tense, whether because +of his work or because of tension in other directions, has not really +learned how to throw himself into his job and to forget himself, his +emotions, and his body.</p> + +<p><b>Various Pains.</b> Tender spots may appear in almost any part of the +body. There was the girl with the sore scalp, who was frequently so +sensitive that she could not bear to have a single hair touched at its +farthermost end, and who could not think of brushing her hair at such +a time. There was the man whose wrists and ankles were so painful that +the slightest touch was excruciating; the woman with the false +sciatica; the man with the so-called appendicitis pains; and the man +with the false neuritis, who always wore jersey coats several sizes +too large. Each one of these false pains was removed by the process of +re-education.</p> + +<p><b>Low Thresholds to Fatigue.</b> Mr. H. was habitually so overcome by +fatigue that he could not make himself carry through the slightest +piece of work, even when necessity demanded it. On Sunday night, when +there was no one else to milk the cow, he had had to stop in the +middle of the process and go into the house to lie down. To carry the +milk was impossible, so low were his thresholds to the slightest +message of fatigue. It turned out that things were not going right +<!-- Page 354 --><a name="Page_354" id="Page_354" />in +the reproductive life. His threshold was low in this direction, and it +carried down with it all other thresholds. After a general revaluation +of values, he found himself able to keep his thresholds at the normal +level.</p> + +<p>A fine, efficient missionary from the Orient had been so overcome with +fatigue that he was forced to give up all work and return to this +country. He had been with me for a while and was again ready to go to +work. He came one day with a radiant face to bid me good-by. "Why are +you so joyous?" I asked. "Because," he answered, "before I came home I +was so fatigued that it used me up completely just to see the native +servants pack our luggage. Now we are taking back twice as much, and I +not only packed it all myself but made the boxes with my own hands. No +more fatigue for me!"</p> + +<p>A charming young girl who in many ways was an inspiration to all her +associates fell into the habit of over-feeling her fatigue. "You know, +Doctor," she said, "that I give out too much of myself; everybody +tells me so." That was just the trouble. Everybody had told her so, +and the suggestion had worked. It did not take her long to learn that +in scattering abroad she was enriching herself, and that her "giving +out" was not exhausting to her but rather the truest kind of +self-expression. It is only when a "giving out" is accompanied by a +"looking in" that it can ever <!-- Page 355 --> +<a name="Page_355" id="Page_355" />deplete. The "See how much I am +giving," and "How tired I shall be," attitude could hardly fail to +exhaust, but a real self-expression and the fulfilment of a real +desire to give are never anything else than exhilarating. There is +something wrong with the minister who is used up after his Sunday +sermons. If his message and not himself is his real concern, he will +have only a normal amount of fatigue, accompanied by a general sense +of accomplishment and well-being, after he has fed his flock. To be +sure, I have never been a minister, but I have had a goodly number +among my patients and I speak from a fairly close acquaintance with +their problems.</p> + +<p><b>Stopping Our Ears.</b> Roosters seem to be a perpetual source of +annoyance to the folk whose thresholds are not under proper control. +But as roosters seem to be necessary to an egg-eating nation, it seems +simpler to change the threshold than to abolish the roosters. There +was one woman who complained especially about being disturbed by +early-morning Chanticleers. I explained that the crowing called for no +action on her part, and that therefore she should not allow it to come +into consciousness. "Do you mean," she said, "that I could keep from +hearing them?" As it happened, she was sitting under the clock, which +had just struck seven. "Did you hear the clock strike?" I asked. "No," +she said; "did it strike?"</p> + +<p><!-- Page 356 --><a name="Page_356" id="Page_356" /> +This poor little woman, who suffered from a very painful back and +other distressing symptoms, had been married at sixteen to a roué of +forty; and, without experiencing any of the psychic feelings of sex, +had been immediately plunged into the physical sex-relations. Since +sex is psycho-physical and since any attempt to separate the two +elements is both desecrating and unsatisfactory; it is not surprising +that misery, and finally divorce, had been her portion. Another +equally unpleasant experience had followed, and the poor woman in the +strain and disappointment of her love-life, and in the lowering of the +thresholds pertaining to this thwarted instinct, had unconsciously +lowered the thresholds to all physical stimuli, until she was no +longer master of herself in any line. When she saw the reason for her +exaggerated reactions, she was able to gain control of herself, and to +find outlet in other ways.</p> + +<p>Too many persons fall into the way of being disturbed by noises which +are no concern of theirs. As nurses learn to sleep through all sounds +but the call of their own patients, so any one may learn to ignore all +sounds but those which he needs to hear. Connection with the outside +world can be severed by a mental attitude in much the same way as this +is accomplished by the physical effect of an anaesthetic. Then the +usual noises, those which the subconscious recognizes as without +<!-- Page 357 --><a name="Page_357" id="Page_357" /> +significance, will be without power to disturb. The well-known New +York publisher who spent his last days on his private yacht, on which +everything was rubber-heeled and velvet-cushioned, thought that he +couldn't stand noises; but how much more fun he would have had, if +some one had only told him about thresholds!</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p>There are two kinds of people in the world,—masters and puppets. +There is the man in control of his thresholds, at leisure from himself +and master of circumstance, free to use his energy in fruitful ways; +and there is the over-sensitive soul, wondering where the barometer +stands and whether people are going to be quiet, feeling his feelings +and worrying because no one else feels them, forever wasting his +energy in exaggerated reactions to normal situations.</p> + +<p>This "ticklish" person is not better equipped than his neighbor, but +more poorly equipped. True adjustment to the environment requires the +faculty of putting out from consciousness all stimuli that do not +require conscious attention. The nervous person is lacking in this +faculty, but he usually fails to realize that this lack places him in +the class of defectives. A paralyzed man is a cripple because he +cannot run with the crowd; a nervous individual is a cripple, but only +because he <!-- Page 358 --><a name="Page_358" id="Page_358" /> +thinks that to run with the crowd lacks distinction. +Something depends on the accident of birth, but far more depends on +his own choice. Understanding, judicious neglect of symptoms, +whole-souled absorption in other interests, and a good look in the +mirror, are sure to put him back in the running with a wholesome +delight in being once more "like folks."</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 359 --><a name="Page_359" id="Page_359" /></div> +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_XV" id="CHAPTER_XV">CHAPTER XV</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we learn discrimination</i></p> + +<p class="heading">CHOOSING OUR EMOTIONS</p> + +<p class="scheading">Liking the Taste</p> + + +<p>It was a summer evening by the seaside, and a group of us were sitting +on the porch, having a sort of heart-to-heart talk about +psychology,—which means, of course, that we were talking about +ourselves. One by one the different members of the family spoke out +the questions that had been troubling them, or brought up their +various problems of character or of health. At length a splendid Red +Cross nurse who had won medals for distinguished service in the early +days of the war, broke out with the question: "Doctor, how can I get +rid of my terrible temper? Sometimes it is very bad, and always it has +been one of the trials of my life." She spoke earnestly and sincerely, +but this was my answer: "You like your temper. Something in you enjoys +it, else you would give it up." Her face was a study in astonishment. +"I don't like it," she <!-- Page 360 --> +<a name="Page_360" id="Page_360" />stammered; "always after I have had an +outburst of anger I am in the depths of remorse. Many a time I have +cried my eyes out over this very thing." "And you like that, too," I +answered. "You are having an emotional spree, indulging yourself first +in one kind of emotion and then in another. If you really hated it as +much as you say you do, you would never allow yourself the indulgence, +much less speak of it afterward." Her astonishment was still further +increased when several of the group said they, too, had sensed her +satisfaction with her moods.</p> + +<p>Hard as it is to believe, we do choose our emotions. We like emotion +as we do salt in our food, and too often we choose it because +something in us likes the savor, and not because it leads to the +character or the conduct that we know to be good.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">The Power of Choice</p> + +<p>Whether we believe it or not, and whether we like it or not, the fact +remains that we ourselves decide which of all the possible emotions we +shall choose, or we decide not to press the button for any emotion at +all.</p> + +<p>To a very large extent man, if he knows how and really wishes, may +select the emotion which is suitable in that it leads to the right +conduct, has a beneficial effect on the body, adapts him to his social +<!-- Page 361 --><a name="Page_361" id="Page_361" /> +environment, and makes him the kind of man he wants to be.</p> + +<p><b>The Test of Feeling.</b> The psychologist to-day has a sure test of +character. He says in substance: "Tell me what you feel and I will +tell you what you are. Tell me what things you love, what things you +fear, and what makes you angry and I will describe with a fair degree +of accuracy your character, your conduct, and a good deal about the +state of your physical health."</p> + +<p>Since this test of emotion is fundamentally sound, it is not +surprising that the nervous man is in a state of distress. +Indigestion, fatigue, over-sensibility, sound like problems in +physiology, but we cannot go far in the discussion of any of them +without coming face to face with the emotions as the real factors in +the case. When we turn to the mental characteristics of nervous folk, +we even more quickly find ourselves in the midst of an emotional +disturbance. Worried, fearful, anxious, self-pitying, excitable, or +melancholy, the nervous person proves that whatever else a neurosis +may be, it is, in essence, a riot of the emotions.</p> + +<p>There is small wonder that a riot at the heart of the empire should +lead to insurrection in every province of the personality. It is only +for the purpose of discussion that we can separate feeling from +thinking and doing. Every thought and every act has in it something of +all three elements. An emotion is not an isolated phenomenon; it is +bound up on the one hand <!-- Page 362 --><a name="Page_362" id="Page_362" /> +with ideas and on the other with bodily +states and conduct. Whoever runs amuck in his emotions runs amuck in +his whole being. The nervous invalid with his exhausted and sensitive +body, his upset mind and irrational conduct is a living illustration +of the central place of the emotions in the realm of the personality.</p> + +<p>But it is not the nervous person only who needs a better understanding +of his emotional life. The well man also gets angry for childish +reasons; he is prejudiced and envious, unhappy and suspicious for the +very same reason as is the nervous man. Since the working-capital of +energy is limited to a definite amount, the control of the emotions +becomes a central problem in any life,—a deciding factor in the +output and the outcome, as well as in comfort and happiness by the way.</p> + +<p>Nothing is harder for the average man to believe than this fact that +he really has the power to choose his emotions. He has been +dissatisfied with himself in his past reactions, and yet he has not +known how to change them. His anger or his depression has appeared so +undesirable to his best judgment and to his conscious reason that it +has seemed to be not a part of himself at all but an invasion from without +which has swept over him without his consent and quite beyond control.</p> + + <p class="scheading"><!-- Page 363 --> + <a name="Page_363" id="Page_363" />A House Divided Against Itself</p> + +<p>Most of the confusion comes from the fact that we know only a part of +ourselves. What we do not consciously enjoy we believe we do not enjoy +at all. What we do not consciously choose we believe to be beyond our +power of choice,—the work of the evil one, or the natural depravity +of human nature, perhaps; but certainly not anything of our choosing.</p> + +<p>The point is that a human being is so constituted that he can, without +knowing it, entertain at the same time two diametrically opposite +desires. The average person is not so unified as he believes, but is, +in fact, "a house divided against itself."</p> + +<p>The words of the apostle Paul express for most of us the truth about +ourselves: "For what I would, that I do not; but what I hate that I +do." What Paul calls the law of his members warring against the law of +his mind is simply what we call to-day the instinctive desires coming +into conflict with our conscious ideal.</p> + +<p><b>Hidden Desires.</b> Although we choose our emotions, we choose in many +cases in response to a buried part of ourselves of which we are wholly +unaware, or only half-aware. When we do not like what we have chosen, +it is because the conscious part of us is out of harmony with another +part and that part is doing the choosing. If the emotions which we +choose are not <!-- Page 364 --><a name="Page_364" id="Page_364" />those +that the whole of us—or at least the +conscious—would desire, it is because we are choosing in response to +hidden desires, and giving satisfaction to cravings which we have not +recognized. Repeated indulgence of such desires is responsible for the +emotional habits which we are too likely to consider an inevitable +part of our personality, inherited from ancestors who are not on hand +to defend themselves. When we form the habit of being afraid of things +that other people do not fear, or of being irritated or depressed, or +of giving way to fits of temper, it is because these habit-reactions +satisfy the inner cravings that in the circumstances can get +satisfaction in no better way.</p> + +<p>These hidden desires are of several different kinds, when squarely +looked at. Some of the cravings are found to be childish, and so out +of keeping with our real characters that we could not possibly hold on +to them as conscious desires. Others turn out to be so natural and so +inevitable that we wonder how we could ever have imagined that they +ought to be repressed. Still others, legitimate in themselves, but +denied because of outer circumstances, are found to be easily +satisfied in indirect ways which bear no resemblance to their old +unfortunate forms of outlet.</p> + +<p class="scheading"><!-- Page 365 --> +<a name="Page_365" id="Page_365" />When Knowledge Helps</p> + +<p>The way to get rid of an undesirable emotion is not by working at the +emotion itself, but by realizing that this is merely an offshoot of a +deeper root, hidden below the surface. The great point is to recognize +this deeper root.</p> + +<p><b>Childish Anger.</b> It helps to know that uncalled-for anger is a +defense reaction—a sort of camouflage or smoke cloud which we throw +out to hide from ourselves and others the fact that we are being +worsted in an argument, or being shown up in an undesirable light. +Better than any amount of weeping over a hot temper is an +understanding of the fact that when we fly into unseemly rage we are +usually giving indulgence to a childhood desire to run away from +unpleasant facts and to cover up our own faults.</p> + +<p><b>Enjoying the Blues.</b> It helps to know that the easiest way to fight +the blues is by realizing that they are a deliberate, if unconscious, +attempt to gain the pity of ourselves and others. There seems to be in +undeveloped human nature something that really enjoys being pitied, +and if we cannot get the commiseration of other people, we can, +without much trouble, work up a case of self-pity. Most of us would +have to acknowledge that we seldom find tears in our eyes except when +our own woes are under consideration. "Whatever else the blues +accomplish, they certainly afford us a <!-- Page 366 --> +<a name="Page_366" id="Page_366" />chance to submerge ourselves +in a sea of self-engrossment."<a name="FNanchor_63" id="FNanchor_63"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_63" class="fnanchor">[63]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_63" id="Footnote_63"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_63"><span class="label">[63]</span> +</a> Putnam: <i>Human Motives</i>.</p></div> + +<p><b>The Chip on the Shoulder.</b> It helps to know that irritability and +over-sensitiveness are usually the result of tension from unsatisfied +desires which must find some kind of outlet. If a person is secretly +restive under the fact that he cannot have the kind of clothes he +wants, cannot shine in society, or secure a college education or a +large fortune,—all of which minister to our insistent and rarely +satisfied instinct of self-assertion,—or if he is secretly yearning +for the satisfaction of the marriage relation, or for the sense of +completion in parenthood; then the tension from these unsatisfied +desires shows itself in a hundred little everyday instances of lack of +self-control. These mystify him and his friends, but they are +understandable when the whole truth is known.</p> + +<p><b>Anxiety and Fear.</b> Nowhere is understanding more valuable than when +we approach the subject of anxiety and fear. Whenever a person falls +into a state of abnormal fear, his friends and his physician spend a +good deal of time in attempting to prove to him that there is no cause +for apprehension, and in exhorting him to use his reason and give up +his fear. But how can a person help himself when he is fighting in the +dark? How can he free himself when the thing he <!-- Page 367 --> +<a name="Page_367" id="Page_367" />thinks he fears is +merely a symbol of what he really fears? The woman who was afraid she +would choke her child had been several months in the hands of +Christian Scientists, and had earnestly tried to replace fear with +courage. But in the circumstances, and without further knowledge, this +was as impossible as it is for a man to lift himself by his own +boot-straps. She had no point of contact with her real fear, as the +man has no leverage contact with the earth from which he wishes to +lift himself.</p> + +<p>To be sure there are many cases in which an assumed cheerfulness and +courage do have a mighty effect on the inner man. The forces of the +personality are not set, but plastic, and are constantly acting and +interacting upon one another. Surface habits do influence the forces +below the surface. William James's advice, "Square your shoulders, +speak in a major key, smile, and turn a compliment," is good for most +occasions, but sometimes even a little understanding of the cause is +far more effective.</p> + +<p>It helps to know that persistent anxiety, lacking obvious cause, is +found to be the anxiety of the thwarted instinct of reproduction. When +the sex-instinct is repeatedly stimulated and then checked it sets in +motion some of the same glands that are activated in fear. What comes +up into consciousness is therefore very naturally a fear or dread of +impending disaster, very <!-- Page 368 --> +<a name="Page_368" id="Page_368" />like the poignant anxiety that one feels +when stepping up in the dark to a step that is not there.</p> + +<p>Simultaneous with the fear lest these repressed desires should not be +satisfied, there is an intense fear lest they should. The more +insistent the repressed desire, and the more it seems likely to break +through into consciousness, the keener the anguish of the ethical +impulses. Abnormal fear, however it may seem to be externalized, +always implies at the bottom a fear of something within. There is no +truth which is harder to believe on first hearing but which grows more +compelling with further knowledge, than this truth that an exaggerated +fear always implies a desire which somehow offends the total +personality. When we observe the various distressing phobias, such as +the common fear of contamination, a woman's fear to undress at night, +a fear that the gas was not turned off, or that one's clothing is out +of order; fear lest the exact truth has not been told, or that the +uttermost farthing of one's obligations has not been met,—then we may +know that there is something in the fear situation which either +directly or symbolically refers to some hidden desire; a desire which +the individual would not for the world acknowledge to himself, but +which is too keen to be altogether repressed.</p> + +<p>The close connection between fear and desire is often shown in the +unfounded fear of having committed<!-- Page 369 --> +<a name="Page_369" id="Page_369" /> a crime. Both doctors and lawyers +in their professional work occasionally come upon individuals who +believe that they have committed some heinous crime of which they are +really innocent, and who insist upon their guilt despite all evidence +to the contrary. A quiet, gentle youth who at the age of twenty was +under my medical care, is still not sure in his own whether he, at +twelve years of age, was the burglar who broke into the village store +and killed the owner. It is difficult for the normally self-satisfied +individual to understand the appeal of heroics to a person whose +starved instinct of self-assertion makes him choose to be known as a +villain rather than not to be known at all.</p> + +<p><b>Breaking the Spell.</b> When once we bring up into consciousness these +hidden desires that manifest themselves in such troublesome ways, we +find that we have robbed them of much of their power over our lives. +Sometimes, it is true, a detailed and thorough exploration by +psycho-analysis is necessary, but in many cases it is sufficient just +to know that there are underlying causes. To know these things is far +from excusing ourselves because of them. Even though emotions are +determined by forces that are deep in the subconscious, we may still +choose in opposition to those forces, if we but know that we can do +so. The fact that some of the roots of our bad habits reach down into +the <!-- Page 370 --><a name="Page_370" id="Page_370" /> +subconscious is no excuse for not digging them up. As Dr. Putnam +says, "It is the whole of us that acts, and we are as responsible for +the supervision of the unseen as for the obvious factors that are at +work. The moon may be only half illumined and half visible, but the +invisible half goes on, none the less, exerting its full share of +influence on the motion of the tides and +earth."<a name="FNanchor_64" id="FNanchor_64"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_64" class="fnanchor">[64]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_64" id="Footnote_64"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_64"><span class="label">[64]</span> +</a> Putnam: <i>Freud's Psychoanalytic Method and Its Evolution</i>, p. 34.</p></div> + + +<p class="scheading">The Highest Kind of Choice</p> + +<p>There is no easier way to enliven any conversation than by dropping +the remark that a human being always does what he wants to do. Simple +as the statement seems, it is quite enough to quicken the dullest +table-talk and loosen the most reticent tongue.</p> + +<p>"I don't do what I want to do," says the college student. "I want to +play tennis every afternoon; but what I do is to sit in a stuffy room +and study."</p> + +<p>"I don't do what I want to do," says the mother of a family. "At night +I want to sit down and read the latest magazine, but what I do is to +darn stockings by the hour."</p> + +<p>Nevertheless we shall see that, even in cases like these, each of us +is acting in accordance with his strongest desire. There may be—there +often is—a bitter <!-- Page 371 --><a name="Page_371" id="Page_371" /> +conflict, but in the end the desire that is really +stronger always conquers and works itself out into action.</p> + +<p>It is possible to imagine a situation in which a man would be +physically unable to do what he wanted to do. Bound by physical cords, +held by prison walls, or weakened by illness, he might be actually +unable to carry out his desires. But apart from physical restraint, it +is hard to imagine a situation in real life in which a person does not +actually do what he wants to do; that is, what <i>in the circumstances +he wants to do</i>. This is simply saying in another way that we act in +accordance with the emotion which is at the moment strongest.</p> + +<p><b>Will Is Choice.</b> Just here we can imagine an earnest protest: "But +why do you ignore the human will? Why do you try to make man the +creature of feeling? A high-grade man does—not what he wants to do +but what he thinks he ought to do. In any person worthy of the +adjective 'civilized' it is conscience, not desire, which is the +motive power of his life."</p> + +<p>It is true: in the better kind of man the will is of central +importance; but what is "will"? Let us imagine a raw soldier in the +trenches just before a charge into No-Man's Land. He is afraid, but +the word of command comes, and instantly he is a new creature. His +fear drops away and, energized by the lust of battle, he rushes +forward, obviously driven by the stronger emotion. He goes ahead +because he really wants to, <!-- Page 372 --><a name="Page_372" id="Page_372" /> +and we say that he does not have to use his will.</p> + +<p>Imagine another soldier in the same situation; with him fear seems +uppermost. His knees shake and his legs want to carry him in the wrong +direction, but he still goes forward. And he goes forward, not so much +because there is no other possibility as because, in the +circumstances, he really wants to. All his life, and especially during +his military training, he has been filled with ideals of loyalty and +courage. More than he fears the guns of the enemy or of his +firing-squad does he fear the loss of his own self-respect and the +respect of his comrades. Greater than his "will to live" is his desire +to play the man. There is conflict, and the desire which seems at the +moment weaker is given the victory because it is reinforced by that +other permanent desire to be a worthy man, brave, and dependable in a +crisis. He goes forward, because in the circumstances, he really wants +to, but in this case we say that he had to use his will.</p> + +<p>Is it not apparent that will itself is choice,—the selection by the +whole personality of the emotion and the action which best fit into +its ideals? Will is choice by the part of us which has ideals. +McDougall points out that will is the reinforcement of the weaker +desire by the master desire to be a certain kind of a +character.<a name="FNanchor_65" id="FNanchor_65"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_65" class="fnanchor">[65]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_65" id="Footnote_65"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_65"><span class="label">[65]</span> +</a> "The essential mark of volition is that the personality +as a whole, or the central feature or nucleus of the personality, the +man himself, is thrown upon the side of the weaker +motive."—McDougall: <i>Introduction to Social Psychology</i>, p. 240.</p></div> + +<p><!-- Page 373 --><a name="Page_373" id="Page_373" />Each human +being as he goes through life acquires a number of moral +ideals and sentiments which he adopts as his own. They become linked +with the instinct of self-assertion, which henceforth acts as the +motive power behind them, and attempts to drive from the field any +emotion which happens to conflict.</p> + +<p>Men, like the lower animals, are ruled by desire, but, as G.A. Coe +says, "Men mold themselves. They form desires not merely to have this +or that object, but to be this or that kind of a +man."<a name="FNanchor_66" id="FNanchor_66"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_66" class="fnanchor">[66]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_66" id="Footnote_66"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_66"><span class="label">[66]</span> +</a> Coe: <i>Psychology of Religion</i>.</p></div> + +<p>If a man be worthy of the name, he is not swayed by the emotion which +happens for the moment to be strongest. He has the power to reinforce +and make dominant those impulses which fit into the ideal he has built +for himself. In other words, he has the power to choose between his +desires, and this power depends largely upon the ideals which he has +incorporated into his life by the complexes and sentiments which +compose his personality.</p> + +<p><i>Ideas and Ideals</i>. If emotion is the heart of humanity, ideas are its +head. In our emphasis on emotion, we must not forget that as emotion +controls action, so ideas control emotion. But ideas, of themselves, +are not enough. Everybody has seen weaklings who were full of pious +platitudes. Ideas do control life, but only when linked up with some +strong emotion. <!-- Page 374 --><a name="Page_374" id="Page_374" /> +No moral sentiment is strong enough to withstand an +intense instinctive desire. If ideas are to be dynamic factors in a +life, they must become ideals and be really desired. They must be +backed up by the impulse of self-assertion, incorporated with the +sentiment of self-regard, and so made a permanent part of the central +personality.</p> + +<p>Parents and teachers who try to "break a child's will" and to punish +every evidence of independence and self-assertion little know that +they are undermining the foundations of morality itself, and doing +their utmost to leave the child at the mercy of his chance whims and +emotions. There can be no strength of character without self-regard, +and self-regard is built on the instinctive desire of self-assertion.</p> + +<p><b>Education and Religion.</b> It is easy to see how important education is +in this process of giving the right content to the self-regarding +sentiment. The child trained to regard "temper" as a disgrace, +self-pity as a vice, over-sensitiveness as a sign of selfishness, and +all forms of exaggerated emotionalism as a token of weakness, has +acquired a powerful weapon against temptation in later life. +Indulgence in any of these forms of gratification he will regard as +unworthy and out of keeping with his personality.</p> + +<p>It is easy, too, to see how central a place a vital religious faith +has in enriching and ennobling the ego-<!-- Page 375 --> +<a name="Page_375" id="Page_375" />ideal, and in giving it +driving-power. A force which makes a high ideal seem both imperative +and possible of achievement could hardly fail to be a deciding factor. +Every student of human nature knows in how many countless lives the +Christian religion has made all the difference between mere good +intentions and the power to realize those intentions; how many times +it has furnished the motive power which nothing else seemed able to +supply. Moral sentiments which have been merely sentiments become, +through the magic of a new faith, incorporated into conscience and +endowed with new power.</p> + +<p>Just here lies the value of any great love, or any intense devotion to +a cause. As Royce says: "To have a conscience, then, is to have a +cause; to unify your life by means of an ideal determined by this +cause, and to compare this ideal and the +life."<a name="FNanchor_67" id="FNanchor_67"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_67" class="fnanchor">[67]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_67" id="Footnote_67"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_67"><span class="label">[67]</span> +</a> Royce: <i>Philosophy of Loyalty</i>, p. 175.</p></div> + +<p><b>Avoiding the Strain.</b> It seems that a human being is to a large +extent controlled by will, and that will is in itself the highest kind +of choice. But too often will is crippled because it does not speak +for the whole personality. Knowledge helps a person to relate +conscience with hitherto hidden parts of himself, to assert his will, +and to choose only those emotions and outlets which the connected-up, +the unified personality wants. Sometimes, indeed, a little knowledge +makes the exercise <!-- Page 376 --><a name="Page_376" id="Page_376" /> +of the will power unnecessary. Using will power +is, after all, likely to be a strenuous business. It implies the +presence of conflict, and the strain of defeating the desire which has +to be denied.<a name="FNanchor_68" id="FNanchor_68"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_68" class="fnanchor">[68]</a> Why +struggle to subdue emotional bad habits when a +little insight dispels the desire back of them, and makes them melt +away as if by magic? For example, why use our will to keep down fear +or anger when a little understanding dissipates these emotions without effort?</p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_68" id="Footnote_68"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_68"><span class="label">[68]</span> +</a> Freud: <i>Introduction to Psychoanalysis</i>, p. 42.</p></div> + +<p>Whatever we do with difficulty we are not doing well. When it requires +effort to do our duty this means that a great part of us does not want +to do it. When we get rid of our hidden resistances we work with ease. +As a strong wind, applied in the right way, drives the ship without +effort, just so the forces in our lives, if they are adjusted to one +another, will without strain or stress easily and naturally work +together to carry us in the direction we have chosen. When we get rid +of blind conflicts, even the business of ruling our spirits becomes +feasible.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Summary</p> + +<p><b>Various "Sprees."</b> The human animal has a constitutional dislike for +dullness and will seize upon almost any device which promises to lift +him out of what he considers the monotony of daily grind. An elaborate +<!-- Page 377 --><a name="Page_377" id="Page_377" />essay +might be written on the means which human beings have taken to +create the sense of <i>aliveness</i> which they so much crave. Some of +them—we call them savages—have found satisfactory certain wild +orgies in primitive war-dances; others—we shall soon call them "out +of date"—have found simpler a bottle of whisky or a glass of +champagne; still others find a cold shower more invigorating, or a +brisk walk or a good stiff job which sets them aglow with the sense of +accomplishment. But there are always those who, for one reason or +another, find most satisfactory of all a chronic emotional tippling, +or a good old-fashioned emotional spree. Persons who would be shocked +at the idea of whisky or champagne allow themselves this other kind of +indulgence without in the least knowing why.</p> + +<p>Nor is the connection between alcoholism and emotionalism so +far-fetched as it seems. Psycho-analytic investigations have +repeatedly revealed the fact that both are indulged in because they +remove inhibitions, give vent to repressed desires, and bring a sense +of life and power which has somehow been lost in the normal living. +Both kinds of spree are followed by the inevitable "morning after" +with its proverbial headache, remorse, and vows of repentance but +despite all this, both are clung to because the satisfaction they +bring is too deep to be easily relinquished.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 378 --><a name="Page_378" id="Page_378" />Whenever +an emotion quite out of keeping with conscious desire is +allowed to become habitual, we may know that it is being chosen by a +part of the personality which needs to be uncovered and squarely +faced. Nervous symptoms and exaggerated emotionalism are alike +evidence of the fact that the wrong part of us is doing the choosing +and that the will needs to be enlightened on what is taking place in +the outer edge of its domain. In the choice between emotionalism and +equanimity, the selection of the former can only be in response to +unrecognized desire.</p> + +<p>A nervous person is invariably an emotional person, and as a rule lays +the blame for his condition upon past experiences. But experience is +what happens to us <i>plus</i> the way we take it. We cannot always ward +off the blow, but we can decide upon our reaction. "Even if the +conduct of others has been the cause of our emotion, it is really we +ourselves who have created it by the way in which we have +reacted."<a name="FNanchor_69" id="FNanchor_69"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_69" class="fnanchor">[69]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_69" id="Footnote_69"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_69"><span class="label">[69]</span> +</a> DuBois: <i>Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders</i>, p. 155.</p></div> + +<div class="poem"><div class="stanza"> +<span>One ship drives east, another drives west,<br /></span> +<span>While the self-same breezes blow;<br /></span> +<span>'Tis the set of the sail, and not the gale<br /></span> +<span>That bids them where to go.<br /></span> +<span>Like the winds of the sea are the ways of fate,<br /></span> +<span>As we journey along through life;<br /></span> +<span>'Tis the set of the soul that decides the goal,<br /></span> +<span>And not the calm or the strife.<br /></span> +<span>REBECCA R. WILLIAMS.<br /></span> +</div></div> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 379 --><a name="Page_379" id="Page_379" /></div> +<p class="heading"><a name="CHAPTER_XVI" id="CHAPTER_XVI">CHAPTER XVI</a></p> + +<p class="heading"><i>In which we find new use for our steam</i></p> + +<p class="heading">FINDING VENT IN SUBLIMATION</p> + +<p class="scheading">The Re-direction of Energy</p> + + +<p>A child pent up on a rainy day is a troublesome child. His energy +keeps piling up, but there is no opportunity for him to expend it. The +nervous person is just such a pent-up child. A portion of his +personality is developing steam which goes astray in its search for +vent; this portion is found to be the psychic side of his sex-life. +Something has blocked the satisfactory achievement of instinctive ends +and turned his interest in on himself.</p> + +<p>Perhaps he does not come into complete psychic satisfaction of his +love-life because his wife is out of sympathy or is held back by her +own childish repressions. Perhaps his love-instinct is baffled by +finding itself thwarted in its purpose of creating children, +restrained by the social ban and the desire for a luxurious standard +of living. Perhaps he is jealous of his chief, <!-- Page 380 --> +<a name="Page_380" id="Page_380" />or of an older +relative whose business stride he cannot equal.</p> + +<p>Jung has pointed out how frequently introversion or turning in of the +life-force is brought about by the painfulness of present reality and +by the lack of the power of adaptation to things as they are. But this +lack always has its roots in childhood. The woman who is shocked at +the thought of sex is the little girl who reacted too strongly to +early impressions. The man of forty who is disgruntled because he is +not made manager of a business created by others is the little boy who +was jealous of his father and wanted to usurp his place of power. The +man who suffers from a sense of inferiority because his friend has a +handsomer or more intellectual wife is the same little boy who strove +with his father for possession of the mother, the most desired object +in his childish environment. The measure of escape from these childish +attitudes means the measure of success in life.</p> + +<p>Fortunately for society, the average person achieves this success. The +normal person in his childhood learned how to switch the energy of his +primitive desires into channels approved by society. Stored away in +his subconscious, this acquired faculty carries him without conscious +effort through all the necessary adjustments in maturity. The nervous +person, less well equipped in childhood, may fortunately acquire the +<!-- Page 381 --><a name="Page_381" id="Page_381" /> +faculty in all its completeness, although at the cost of genuine +effort and patient self-study.</p> + +<p><b>Sublimation the Key Word.</b> In the prevention and in the cure of +nervous disorders there is one factor of central importance, and that +factor is sublimation—or the freeing of sex-energy for socially +useful, non-sexual ends. To sublimate is to find vent for oneself and +to serve society as well; for sublimation opens up new channels for +pent-up energy, utilizing all the surplus of the sex-instinct in +substitute activities. When the dynamic of this impulse is turned +outward, not inward, it proves to be one of man's greatest +possessions, a valuable contribution of energy to creative activities +and personal relationships of every kind.</p> + +<p><b>The Failure to Sublimate.</b> A neurosis is nonconstructive use of one's +surplus steam. The trouble with a nervous person is that his +love-force is turned in on himself instead of out into the world of +reality. This is what his friends mean when they say that he is +self-absorbed; and this is what the psychologists mean when they say +that a neurotic is introverted. A person, in so far as he is nervous, +does not see other people at all—that is, he does not see them as +real persons, but only as auditors who may be made to listen to the +tale of his woes. His own problems loom so large that he becomes +especially afflicted with what Cabot calls "the sin of impersonality"; +or to use <!-- Page 382 --><a name="Page_382" id="Page_382" />President +King's words, he lacks that "reverence for +personality" which enables one to see people vividly as real persons +and not as street-car conductors or servants or merely as members of +one's family. To be sure, many a so-called normal individual is +afflicted with this same kind of blindness; here as elsewhere the +neurotic simply exaggerates. Engrossed in his own mental conflicts and +physical symptoms, he is likely to find his interest withdrawing more +and more from other people and centering upon himself.</p> + +<p><b>Sublimation and Religion.</b> We do not need psychology to tell us that +engrossment in self is a disastrous condition. When the psycho-analyst +says that the life-force must be turned out, not in, he is approaching +from a new angle the truth as it is found in the gospel,—"Thou shalt +love the Lord thy God with all thy heart," and "thy neighbor as +thyself." Religion provides the love-object in the Creator; altruism +provides it in the "neighbor." Christianity and psychology agree that +as soon as love ceases to be an outgoing force, just so soon does the +individual become an incomplete and disrupted +personality.<a name="FNanchor_70" id="FNanchor_70"></a> +<a href="#Footnote_70" class="fnanchor">[70]</a></p> + +<div class="footnote"><p><a name="Footnote_70" id="Footnote_70"></a> +<a href="#FNanchor_70"><span class="label">[70]</span> +</a> For emphasis on religion as a means to sublimation, see +Freud, Putnam, Pfister, James, and DuBois.</p></div> + +<p><b>Carlyle's Doctrine of Work.</b> "Produce! produce! produce!" Life for a +social being involves not only rich personal relationships, but +absorbing, creative <!-- Page 383 --><a name="Page_383" id="Page_383" />work. +No nervous person is cured until he is +willing to take and to keep a "man-size job." A good piece of work is +not only the sign of a cure; it is the final step without which no +cure is complete.</p> + +<p><b>Along Nature's Lines.</b> If the psychologist is asked what kind of task +this is to be, he answers that each person must decide for himself his +own life-work. An individual may not know why, but he does know that +there are certain things which he most likes to do. Sublimation is +more readily accomplished if his energy is directed toward self-chosen +interests. Parents or teachers or physicians who try to force another +person into any definite plan of action are making a grievous blunder. +Help may be given toward self-knowledge and the understanding of +general principles, but advice should never be specific.</p> + +<p>Taken in the large, it is found that men and women choose different +ways of sublimation. Man and woman differ in the psychic components of +the sex-life even as they differ in the physical. Sublimation to be +successful must follow the lines laid down by nature. The urge of the +average man is toward construction, domination, mastery. The urge of +the average woman is toward mothering, protection, nurture. The +masculine characteristics find ready sublimation in a career; the man +builds bridges, digs canals, harnesses mountain streams, conquers +pests, overcomes <!-- Page 384 --><a name="Page_384" id="Page_384" />gravity, +brings the ends of the earth together by "wireless" or by rail; +he provides for the weak and the helpless—his +own progeny—or, incarnated in the body of a Hoover, he gives life to +the children of the world.</p> + +<p>In woman, the dominant force is the nurturing instinct. Child and man +of her own come first, but when these are lacking, to paraphrase +Kipling, in default of closer ties, she is wedded to convictions; +Heaven help him who denies! Only as a career opens up full vent for +this nurturing instinct, will it provide satisfactory substitute in +sublimation. Its natural trend can be seen in the recent tidal wave of +social legislation—for prohibition, child-labor laws, sanitation, +recognition and control of venereal disease, acknowledgment of +paternity to the illegitimate child.</p> + +<p>Since the women of the day, in numbers up to the million, have been +compelled to sacrifice both man and unformed babe to the grim +Juggernaut of war, this nurturing urge may press hard against many of +the social and business barriers now impeding its flow. But if society +understands and readjusts these barriers, making it possible for its +citizens—women as well as men—to approximate the natural instinctive +bent, it will not only save itself much unrest but will also go far +toward preventing the spread of nervous invalidism.</p> + +<p class="scheading"><!-- Page 385 --> +<a name="Page_385" id="Page_385" />Summary</p> + +<p>That which a nervous invalid most needs is a redirection of energy. +Since, in spite of appearances, there is never any real lack of +energy, no time is needed for the making of strength, and a cure can +take place just as soon as the inner forces allow the energy to flow +out in the right direction. Sometimes, indeed, an outer change may +start the inner process. Often the "work cure" does cure; occasionally +the sudden necessity to earn one's living or to mother a little child +frees the life-force from its old preoccupation and forces it into +other channels. In most cases, however, the nervous invalid is +suffering not from lack of opportunities for outside interest but from +an inner inability to meet the opportunities which present themselves. +The great change that has to be made is not in external conditions and +habits but in the hidden corners of the mind; a change that can be +accomplished only by self-knowledge and re-education.</p> + +<p>But if self-knowledge is the first step in any cure, so self-giving +must be the final step. Sooner or later in the life of every nervous +invalid there comes a time when nothing will serve to unify his +disorganized forces but steady and unswerving responsibility for a +good stiff piece of work. Happy for him that this is so and that he is +living in a day when science no longer tells him to fold his hands and +wait.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<hr /> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 386 --><a name="Page_386" id="Page_386" /></div> +<p class="heading"><a name="GLOSSARY" id="GLOSSARY" />GLOSSARY</p> + + +<p><i>Autonomic nervous system:</i> The vegetative nervous system which +controls vital functions,—as digestion, respiration, circulation.</p> + +<p><i>Censor:</i> A hypothetical faculty of the fore-conscious mind which +resists the emergence into consciousness of questionable desires.</p> + +<p><i>Common path:</i> In physiology, the final route over which response is +made to physical stimulation; similarly in psychology, the one outlet +for the finally dominant impulse.</p> + +<p><i>Compensation:</i> Exaggerated manifestation of one character-trend as a +defense against its opposite which is painfully repressed; relief in +substitute symptom formation.</p> + +<p><i>Complex:</i> A group of ideas held together by emotion (usually +referring to a group which is wholly or in part unconscious).</p> + +<p><i>Compulsion:</i> A persistent compelling impulse to perform some +seemingly unreasonable (but really substitute or symbolic) act, or to +hold some irrational fear or idea; an emotional force which has been +separated from the original idea.</p> + +<p><i>Conflict:</i> (Special) Struggle between instincts (unconscious).</p> + +<p><!-- Page 387 --><a name="Page_387" id="Page_387" /> +<i>Conversion:</i> (Special) The process by which a repressed mental +complex expresses itself through a physical symptom.</p> + +<p><i>Displacement:</i> 1. Transposition of an emotion from its original idea +to one more acceptable to the personality. 2. The shifting of +emphasis, in dreams, from essential to less significant elements.</p> + +<p><i>Dissociation:</i> 1. The state of being shut out from taking active part +(applied to a group of ideas), as in normal forgetfulness. 2. +(Abnormal) An exaggerated degree of separation of groups of ideas, +with loss to the personality of the forces or memories which these +groups contain, as in double personality.</p> + +<p><i>Fixation:</i> Establishment in childhood of over-strong habit-reactions.</p> + +<p><i>Free Association:</i> A device for uncovering buried complexes by +letting the mind wander without conscious direction.</p> + +<p><i>Homo-sexual:</i> The quality of being more attracted by an individual of +the same sex (abnormal) than by one of the opposite sex +(hetero-sexual, normal).</p> + +<p><i>Hysteria:</i> That form of functional nervous disorder which manifests +itself in physical symptoms; an attempt to dramatize unconscious +repressed desires.</p> + +<p><i>Inhibition:</i> Restraint (Special) limitation of function, physical or +ideational, due to unconscious emotional attitudes.</p> + +<p><i>Libido:</i> Life-force, élan vital, or (restricted) the energy of the +sex-instinct.</p> + +<p><!-- Page 388 --><a name="Page_388" id="Page_388" /> +<i>Neurosis:</i> Used loosely for psycho-neurosis or nervous disorder.</p> + +<p><i>Obsession:</i> A compulsive idea inaccessible to reason.</p> + +<p><i>Oedipus Complex:</i> Over-strong bond between mother and son, or (more +loosely) between father and daughter.</p> + +<p><i>Over-determined:</i> Used of an impulse made over-strong by lack of +discharge, with accumulation of emotional tension from added factors.</p> + +<p><i>Phobia:</i> A persistent, unreasoning fear of some object or situation.</p> + +<p><i>Psycho-neurosis:</i> "A perversion of normal (psychic) reactions," +(Prince); a general term for functional dissociation of the +personality, resulting in: psychasthenia—disturbed ideation; +neurasthenia—disturbed emotions; hysteria—disturbed motor or sensory +activity.</p> + +<p><i>Psychotherapy:</i> Treatment by psychic or mental measures.</p> + +<p><i>Rationalization:</i> The process of substituting a plausible, false +explanation for a repressed, unconscious desire.</p> + +<p><i>Repression:</i> Expulsion from consciousness of a pain-provoking mental +process.</p> + +<p><i>Resistance:</i> The force which impedes the return of a repressed +complex to consciousness.</p> + +<p><i>Subconscious:</i> That part of the mind of which one is unaware; the +storehouse of memories ancestral and personal.</p> + +<p><i>Sublimation:</i> The act of freeing sex-energy from +<!-- Page 389 --><a name="Page_389" id="Page_389" />definitely +sexual aims; utilization of sex-energy for nonsexual ends.</p> + +<p><i>Suggestion:</i> The process by which any idea, true or false, takes hold +of one; the idea may enter the mind consciously or unconsciously, +through reason or through impulse.</p> + +<p><i>Symbol:</i> An object or an attitude which stands for an ides or a +quality; (Special) that which stands for or represents some +unconscious mental process.</p> + +<p><i>Threshold</i> (door-sill): A figure which represents the level of the +barrier erected by the mind against the perception of an idea or +sensation.</p> + +<p><i>Transference:</i> Unconscious identification of a present personal +relationship with an earlier one, with conveyance of the earlier +emotional attitudes (hostile or affectionate) to the present +relationship.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<hr /> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<div><!-- Page 390 --><a name="Page_390" id="Page_390" /></div> +<p class="heading"><a name="BIBLIOGRAPHY" id="BIBLIOGRAPHY" />BIBLIOGRAPHY</p> + +<p class="scheading">Books on the General Laws of Body and Mind</p> + +<p class="hangind">Cannon, Walter B: Bodily Changes in Pain, Hunger, Fear and Rage.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Crile, George W.: The Origin and Nature of the Emotions.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Coe, George Albert: The Psychology of Religion.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Hudson, Thomas Jay: The Law of Psychic Phenomena.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Janet, Pierre: The Major Symptoms of Hysteria; The Mental State of Hystericals.</p> + +<p class="hangind">James, William: Psychology; Talks to Teachers on Psychology; +Varieties of Religious Experience.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Jastrow, Joseph: The Subconscious.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Kempf, Edward J.: The Tonus of Autonomic Segments in Psychopathology.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Long, Constance: Psychology of Fantasy.</p> + +<p class="hangind">McDougall, William: Social Psychology.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Mosher, Clelia Duel: Health and the Woman Movement.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Phillips, D.E.: Elementary Psychology.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Prince, Morton: The Unconscious; The Dissociation of a Personality; My Life as a Dissociated Personality.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Sherrington, Charles L.: The Integrative Action of the Nervous System.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Sidis, Boris: The Foundations of Normal and Abnormal Psychology; Psychopathological Researches.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Tansley, A.G.: The New Psychology.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Thomson, William Hanna: Brain and Personality.</p> + +<p class="hangind"><!-- Page 391 --><a name="Page_391" id="Page_391" /> +White, William A.: Principles of Mental Hygiene; +The Mental Hygiene of Childhood.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Proceedings of the International Conference of Women Physicians. +(National Board, Y.W.C.A., 600 Lexington Avenue, New York City.)</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Books on Mental Hygiene</p> + +<p class="hangind">Brown, Charles R.: Faith and Health.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Bruce, H. Addington: Scientific Mental Healing.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Cabot, Richard: What Men Live By; +Social Service and the Art of Healing.</p> + +<p class="hangind">DuBois, Paul: The Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Huckel, Oliver: Mental Medicine.</p> + +<p class="hangind">James, William: Vital Reserves.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Prince, Morton, and others: Psychotherapeutics.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Sadler, William S.: The Physiology of Faith and Fear.</p> + +<table class="la" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="4" border="0" summary="Religion and Medicine"> +<tr> + <td>Worcester, Elwood</td> + <td valign="middle" rowspan="3" style="white-space: nowrap; font-size: 300%">}</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>McComb, Samuel</td> + <td>Religion and Medicine.</td> +</tr> +<tr> + <td>Coriat, Isador H.</td> + <td> </td> +</tr> +</table> + +<p class="scheading">Books on Psycho-Analysis</p> + +<p class="hangind">Brill, A.A.: Fundamentals of Psychoanalysis.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Emerson, L.E.: Nervousness.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Freud, Sigmund: The Interpretation of Dreams; +The Psychopathology of Everyday Life; +Wit and the Unconscious; +Selected Papers and Sexual Theory; +A General Introduction to Psychoanalysis.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Frink, H.W.: Morbid Fears and Compulsions.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Hitschmann, E.: Freud's Theories of the Neuroses.</p> + +<p class="hangind"><!-- Page 392 --><a name="Page_392" id="Page_392" /> +Holt, E.B.: The Freudian Wish.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Jung, Carl G.: The Psychology of the Unconscious; Analytical Psychology.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Jones, Ernest: Psycho-analysis; Treatment of the Neuroses, Including +Psychoneuroses—in Modern Treatment of Nervous and Mental +Diseases—White and Jelliffe.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Pfister, Oskar: The Psychoanalytic Method.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Putnam, James Jackson: Addresses on Psychoanalysis—Human +Motives.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Tridon, André: Psychoanalysis.</p> + +<p class="hangind">White, William A.: The Mechanisms of Character Formation.</p> + + +<p class="scheading">Journals Devoted to the Subject of Nervous Disorders</p> + +<p class="hangind">Journal of Abnormal Psychology, published in Boston.</p> + +<p class="hangind">Psychoanalytic Review, published in Washington, D.C.</p> + +<p class="hangind">International Journal of Psychoanalysis, published in London.</p> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<hr /> + +<p> </p> +<p> </p> + +<h2><a name="INDEX" id="INDEX" /><!-- Page 393 --><a name="Page_393" id="Page_393" />INDEX</h2> + +<p class="heading">A</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Acid and Milk, <a href="#Page_21">21</a>, <a href="#Page_257">257</a><br /> +<br /> +Acidosis, <a href="#Page_285">285</a><br /> +<br /> +Adjustment<br /> +<span class="ind1">a neurosis an effort at, <a href="#Page_169">169</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">to new conditions causes consciousness, <a href="#Page_82">82</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of the race, in subconscious, <a href="#Page_78">78</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">to the social whole, <a href="#Page_164">164</a>, <a href="#Page_216">216</a>, +<a href="#Page_380">380</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Adolescence, <a href="#Page_59">59</a><br /> +<br /> +Adrenal Secretion, <a href="#Page_42">42</a>, <a href="#Page_48">48</a>, <a href="#Page_133">133</a>, + <a href="#Page_229">229</a>, <a href="#Page_270">270</a><br /> +<br /> +Alcoholism, relation to unconscious desires, <a href="#Page_377">377</a><br /> +<br /> +Alvarez, W.D., <a href="#Page_284">284</a><br /> +<br /> +Ames, Thaddeus Hoyt, <a href="#Page_170">170</a><br /> +<br /> +Amnesia, <a href="#Page_113">113</a><br /> +<br /> +Anaemia, buttermilk in, <a href="#Page_282">282</a><br /> +<br /> +Anger, <a href="#Page_47">47</a> ff.<br /> +<br /> +Anxiety and Fear, <a href="#Page_366">366</a>, <a href="#Page_367">367</a>, <a href="#Page_368">368</a><br /> +<br /> +Anxiety Neurosis, <a href="#Page_7">7</a>, <a href="#Page_109">109</a><br /> +<br /> +Anxious thought in conversion hysteria, <a href="#Page_277">277</a><br /> +<br /> +Appetite, symbolic loss of, <a href="#Page_276">276</a><br /> +<br /> +Association<br /> +<span class="ind1">accidental, <a href="#Page_341">341</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">a chain of, <a href="#Page_191">191</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">free, <a href="#Page_101">101</a>, <a href="#Page_191">191</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">making new, <a href="#Page_329">329</a>, <a href="#Page_330">330</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of ideas, <a href="#Page_106">106</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">subconscious, <a href="#Page_346">346</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">word test, <a href="#Page_197">197</a>, <a href="#Page_198">198</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Audience, secured in a neurosis, <a href="#Page_169">169</a><br /> +<br /> +Auto-eroticism, <a href="#Page_57">57</a><br /> +<br /> +Auto-intoxication, <a href="#Page_279">279</a>, <a href="#Page_282">282</a><br /> +<br /> +Automatic writing, <a href="#Page_96">96</a>, <a href="#Page_97">97</a><br /> +<br /> +Autonomic nervous system, <a href="#Page_86">86</a>, +<a href="#Page_126">126</a>, <a href="#Page_319">319</a><br /> +<br /> +Auto-suggestion, <a href="#Page_129">129</a>, <a href="#Page_210">210</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">B</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Bacteria, in anaemia, sciatica, rheumatism, <a href="#Page_281">281</a><br /> +<br /> +Bashfulness, <a href="#Page_46">46</a><br /> +<br /> +Bergson, <a href="#Page_90">90</a><br /> +<br /> +Biliousness, <a href="#Page_268">268</a><br /> +<br /> +Birth-Theories, <a href="#Page_158">158</a>, <a href="#Page_160">160</a>, <a href="#Page_161">161</a><br /> +<br /> +Blocking, in word association, <a href="#Page_198">198</a><br /> +<br /> +Bodily Response to Emotional States, <a href="#Page_134">134</a><br /> +<br /> +Brain,<br /> +<span class="ind1">diseased in insanity, sound in neurosis, <a href="#Page_13">13</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">fag, <a href="#Page_125">125</a>, <a href="#Page_241">241</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">records, <a href="#Page_89">89</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Bran fad, <a href="#Page_291">291</a><br /> +<br /> +Breuer, Joseph, <a href="#Page_142">142</a><br /> +<br /> +Brill, A.A., <a href="#Page_58">58</a>, <a href="#Page_69">69</a>, <a href="#Page_201">201</a>, + <a href="#Page_202">202</a><br /><!-- Page 394 --><a name="Page_394" id="Page_394" /> +<br /> +Bruce, H. Addington, <a href="#Page_200">200</a>, <a href="#Page_201">201</a><br /> +<br /> +Burrow, Trigant, <a href="#Page_173">173</a>, <a href="#Page_203">203</a><br /> +<br /> +Buttermilk in anaemia, <a href="#Page_282">282</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">C</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Cabot, Richard, <a href="#Page_27">27</a>, <a href="#Page_381">381</a><br /> +<br /> +Canfield, Dorothy, <a href="#Page_231">231</a><br /> +<br /> +Cannon, Walter B., <a href="#Page_49">49</a>, <a href="#Page_134">134</a><br /> +<br /> +Capitalizing an Illness, <a href="#Page_170">170</a><br /> +<br /> +Catechism, <a href="#Page_247">247</a><br /> +<br /> +Cathartics, <a href="#Page_283">283</a><br /> +<span class="ind1">and acidosis, <a href="#Page_286">286</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and bacterial infection, <a href="#Page_282">282</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and child birth, <a href="#Page_285">285</a>, <a href="#Page_286">286</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and operations, <a href="#Page_284">284</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Causes of Nerves, <a href="#Page_146">146</a>, <a href="#Page_164">164</a><br /> +<br /> +Censor, psychic, <a href="#Page_104">104</a>, <a href="#Page_195">195</a><br /> +<br /> +Change of life, <a href="#Page_314">314</a><br /> +<br /> +Character and health, <a href="#Page_24">24</a>, <a href="#Page_25">25</a>, <a href="#Page_362">362</a><br /> +<br /> +Chemistry, <a href="#Page_61">61</a>, <a href="#Page_190">190</a>, +<a href="#Page_224">224</a>, <a href="#Page_225">225</a>, <a href="#Page_230">230</a>, +<a href="#Page_247">247</a>, <a href="#Page_306">306</a>, <a href="#Page_315">315</a>, +<a href="#Page_317">317</a>, <a href="#Page_324">324</a><br /> +<br /> +Child,<br /> +<span class="ind1">birth-theories of, <a href="#Page_158">158</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">father to the man, <a href="#Page_90">90</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">habit-fixation of, <a href="#Page_150">150</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">love-life, four periods <a href="#Page_54">54</a>, <a href="#Page_55">55</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">questions, <a href="#Page_158">158</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">too much bossing of, <a href="#Page_154">154</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">too much petting of, <a href="#Page_57">57</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">training, <a href="#Page_160">160</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Childhood,<br /> +<span class="ind1">bonds too strong, <a href="#Page_72">72</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">determines future character, <a href="#Page_91">91</a>, +<a href="#Page_148">148</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">experiences, <a href="#Page_149">149</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">reactions, <a href="#Page_148">148</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Choosing our Emotions, <a href="#Page_360">360</a><br /> +<span class="ind1">a neurosis, <a href="#Page_122">122</a>, <a href="#Page_169">169</a>, +<a href="#Page_216">216</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">our Sensations, <a href="#Page_339">339</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Christian religion, <a href="#Page_74">74</a>, <a href="#Page_374">374</a><br /> +<br /> +Coe, George A., <a href="#Page_71">71</a>, <a href="#Page_373">373</a><br /> +<br /> +Colon, function of, <a href="#Page_279">279</a>, <a href="#Page_280">280</a><br /> +<br /> +Common Path, <a href="#Page_52">52</a><br /> +<br /> +Compensation, <a href="#Page_168">168</a>, <a href="#Page_340">340</a><br /> +<br /> +Complex,<br /> +<span class="ind1">against marriage, <a href="#Page_204">204</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and conditioned reflex, <a href="#Page_108">108</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and personality, <a href="#Page_105">105</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">breaking up of, <a href="#Page_109">109</a>, <a href="#Page_186">186</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">buried, <a href="#Page_187">187</a>, <a href="#Page_192">192</a>, + <a href="#Page_197">197</a>, <a href="#Page_201">201</a>, +<a href="#Page_202">202</a>, <a href="#Page_215">215</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">chance signs of, <a href="#Page_198">198</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">definition, <a href="#Page_107">107</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">dissociated, <a href="#Page_111">111</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">emotional, <a href="#Page_198">198</a>, <a href="#Page_345">345</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">father-mother, <a href="#Page_152">152</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">feeling-tone of, <a href="#Page_130">130</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">formation of, <a href="#Page_129">129</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">forming a resistance, <a href="#Page_159">159</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">making over, <a href="#Page_187">187</a>, <a href="#Page_190">190</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">mother-son, <a href="#Page_185">185</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">physiological, <a href="#Page_108">108</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">repressed, <a href="#Page_112">112</a>, <a href="#Page_157">157</a>, + <a href="#Page_190">190</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">unconscious, <a href="#Page_108">108</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Compromise, <a href="#Page_163">163</a>, <a href="#Page_164">164</a>, <a href="#Page_165">165</a><br /> +<br /> +Compulsion neuroses, <a href="#Page_7">7</a>, <a href="#Page_109">109</a>, <a href="#Page_156">156</a><br /> +<br /> +Conditioned reflex, <a href="#Page_108">108</a><br /> +<br /> +Conduct, kind of, <a href="#Page_168">168</a>, <a href="#Page_191">191</a>, <a href="#Page_360">360</a><br /> +<br /> +Conflict, <a href="#Page_59">59</a>, <a href="#Page_64">64</a>, <a href="#Page_112">112</a>, +<a href="#Page_145">145</a>, <a href="#Page_154">154</a>, <a href="#Page_164">164</a>, +<a href="#Page_178">178</a>, <a href="#Page_200">200</a>, <a href="#Page_218">218</a>, +<a href="#Page_313">313</a>, <a href="#Page_372">372</a>, <a href="#Page_376">376</a><br /> +<br /> +Conscience, <a href="#Page_164">164</a>, <a href="#Page_173">173</a>, <a href="#Page_177">177</a>, + <a href="#Page_196">196</a>, <a href="#Page_376">376</a><br /> +<br /> +Consciousness,<br /> +<span class="ind1">displaced threshold of, <a href="#Page_91">91</a></span><br /> +relation to the subconscious, <a href="#Page_82">82</a><br /> +<!-- Page 395 --><a name="Page_395" id="Page_395" /> +<span class="ind1">rise of, <a href="#Page_82">82</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Constipation, <a href="#Page_277">277</a> ff.<br /> +<span class="ind1">and food, <a href="#Page_289">289</a>, <a href="#Page_290">290</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">cure of, <a href="#Page_294">294</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">due to suggestion, <a href="#Page_294">294</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">purpose of, <a href="#Page_288">288</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Conversion-hysteria, <a href="#Page_174">174</a>, <a href="#Page_236">236</a>, +<a href="#Page_237">237</a>, <a href="#Page_238">238</a>, <a href="#Page_245">245</a>, +<a href="#Page_277">277</a>, <a href="#Page_302">302</a><br /> +<br /> +Crile, George W., <a href="#Page_41">41</a>, <a href="#Page_44">44</a><br /> +<br /> +Curiosity,<br /> +<span class="ind1">child's concerning sex, <a href="#Page_58">58</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">displacement over to scientific investigation, <a href="#Page_45">45</a></span><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">D</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Day-dreaming, <a href="#Page_162">162</a>, <a href="#Page_325">325</a>, <a href="#Page_326">326</a><br /> +<br /> +Defence-reaction, <a href="#Page_365">365</a><br /> +<br /> +Desire<br /> +<span class="ind1">energy of, <a href="#Page_78">78</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in dreams, <a href="#Page_194">194</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in emotional habits, <a href="#Page_364">364</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in nervous disorders, <a href="#Page_167">167</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">instinctive, <a href="#Page_38">38</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">instinctive and ideals, <a href="#Page_363">363</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">tensions of, <a href="#Page_196">196</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Diarrhoea, bacterial, <a href="#Page_281">281</a><br /> +<br /> +Dietetics, essence of, <a href="#Page_254">254</a><br /> +<br /> +Digestion, <a href="#Page_86">86</a>, <a href="#Page_133">133</a>, +<a href="#Page_250">250</a>, <a href="#Page_251">251</a><br /> +<br /> +Disease,<br /> +<span class="ind1">of the ego, <a href="#Page_15">15</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">physical, <a href="#Page_12">12</a>, <a href="#Page_13">13</a>, <a href="#Page_28">28</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">psychic, <a href="#Page_12">12</a>, <a href="#Page_13">13</a>, +<a href="#Page_14">14</a>, <a href="#Page_28">28</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Disorders, functional and organic, <a href="#Page_13">13</a><br /> +<br /> +Displacement, <a href="#Page_109">109</a>, <a href="#Page_110">110</a>, +<a href="#Page_165">165</a>, <a href="#Page_174">174</a><br /> +<br /> +Dissociation, <a href="#Page_111">111</a><br /> +<span class="ind1">abnormal, <a href="#Page_189">189</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">an example of, <a href="#Page_92">92</a>, <a href="#Page_347">347</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in hypnosis, <a href="#Page_123">123</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in hysteria, <a href="#Page_111">111</a>, <a href="#Page_123">123</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in neurasthenia, <a href="#Page_111">111</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">increases suggestibility, <a href="#Page_122">122</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">normal, <a href="#Page_111">111</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of a "Personality," <a href="#Page_113">113</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of memory picture of walking, <a href="#Page_125">125</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of power of sight, <a href="#Page_170">170</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Dreams, <a href="#Page_193">193</a> ff.<br /> +<span class="ind1">Freud's dictum, <a href="#Page_193">193</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">latent content, <a href="#Page_195">195</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">manifest content, <a href="#Page_195">195</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">purpose of, <a href="#Page_195">195</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">work of, <a href="#Page_196">196</a></span><br /> +<br /> +DuBois, Paul, <a href="#Page_4">4</a>, <a href="#Page_127">127</a>, +<a href="#Page_246">246</a>, <a href="#Page_327">327</a>, <a href="#Page_382">382</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">E</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Education, <a href="#Page_202">202</a>, <a href="#Page_218">218</a><br /> +<span class="ind1">in Emotional Control, <a href="#Page_374">374</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Emotion, <a href="#Page_35">35</a>, <a href="#Page_360">360</a> ff.<br /> +<span class="ind1">and complexes, <a href="#Page_108">108</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and fatigue, <a href="#Page_229">229</a>, <a href="#Page_247">247</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and instincts, <a href="#Page_40">40</a> ff.</span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and muscle tone, <a href="#Page_137">137</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">blood-pressure in, <a href="#Page_136">136</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">bodily response to, <a href="#Page_133">133</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">feeling tones in, <a href="#Page_130">130</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">precocious, <a href="#Page_150">150</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">repressed (see repression)</span><br /> +<span class="ind1">secretions in, <a href="#Page_132">132</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">the strongest cement, <a href="#Page_107">107</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">tonic and poisonous, <a href="#Page_131">131</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">unrecognized desire in, <a href="#Page_364">364</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Energy,<br /><!-- Page 396 --><a name="Page_396" id="Page_396" /> +<span class="ind1">adaptable, <a href="#Page_67">67</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">creative, <a href="#Page_34">34</a>, <a href="#Page_69">69</a>, + <a href="#Page_71">71</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">inhibited, <a href="#Page_235">235</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">libido, <a href="#Page_36">36</a>, <a href="#Page_252">252</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">misdirected, <a href="#Page_28">28</a>, <a href="#Page_379">379</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">new level of, <a href="#Page_221">221</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">physiological reserve, <a href="#Page_117">117</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">redirection of, <a href="#Page_385">385</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">releasers of, <a href="#Page_245">245</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">three uses of, <a href="#Page_23">23</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">utilization of, <a href="#Page_68">68</a>, <a href="#Page_165">165</a></span><br /> +<br /> +"Energies of Men", <a href="#Page_221">221</a><br /> +<br /> +Environment, <a href="#Page_33">33</a>, <a href="#Page_96">96</a>, +<a href="#Page_149">149</a>, <a href="#Page_334">334</a><br /> +<br /> +Evolution, <a href="#Page_73">73</a><br /> +<br /> +Exhaustion, nervous, <a href="#Page_216">216</a>, <a href="#Page_224">224</a>, +<a href="#Page_243">243</a>, <a href="#Page_246">246</a><br /> +<br /> +Explanation vs Suggestion, <a href="#Page_206">206</a> ff.<br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">F</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Fads-dynamogenic, <a href="#Page_252">252</a><br /> +<br /> +Faith, <a href="#Page_118">118</a><br /> +<br /> +Family complex, <a href="#Page_153">153</a><br /> +<br /> +Fatigue, <a href="#Page_219">219</a> ff.<br /> +<span class="ind1">a Matter of Chemistry, <a href="#Page_225">225</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and insomnia, <a href="#Page_326">326</a>, <a href="#Page_327">327</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and moral tension, <a href="#Page_166">166</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and sex-repression, <a href="#Page_235">235</a>, <a href="#Page_244">244</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">true and false, <a href="#Page_223">223</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Fear, <a href="#Page_40">40</a> ff.<br /> +<span class="ind1">exaggerated, <a href="#Page_368">368</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">externalized, <a href="#Page_368">368</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of cold, <a href="#Page_348">348</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of fatigue, <a href="#Page_219">219</a>, <a href="#Page_354">354</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of food, <a href="#Page_133">133</a>, <a href="#Page_251">251</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of heat, <a href="#Page_237">237</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of noise, <a href="#Page_355">355</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">physical effects of, <a href="#Page_41">41</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">purpose of, <a href="#Page_41">41</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">symbolic of desire, <a href="#Page_368">368</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Feeling our Feelings, <a href="#Page_333">333</a> ff.<br /> +<br /> +Feeling-tones, <a href="#Page_130">130</a>, <a href="#Page_206">206</a>, +<a href="#Page_213">213</a>, <a href="#Page_229">229</a><br /> +<br /> +Fermentation, <a href="#Page_264">264</a><br /> +<br /> +Finding New Vents, <a href="#Page_379">379</a><br /> +<br /> +Fixation of Habits, <a href="#Page_150">150</a>, <a href="#Page_151">151</a>, <a href="#Page_162">162</a><br /> +<br /> +Flat-foot, <a href="#Page_138">138</a><br /> +<br /> +Food, <a href="#Page_254">254</a> ff.<br /> +<span class="ind1">and constipation, <a href="#Page_289">289</a>, <a href="#Page_290">290</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">for the children, <a href="#Page_256">256</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">idiosyncrasies, <a href="#Page_258">258</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">mixtures, <a href="#Page_255">255</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">variety essential, <a href="#Page_255">255</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Foreconscious, <a href="#Page_79">79</a><br /> +<br /> +Free Association, <a href="#Page_101">101</a>, <a href="#Page_191">191</a>, <a href="#Page_195">195</a><br /> +<br /> +Freud, Sigmund, <a href="#Page_69">69</a>, <a href="#Page_74">74</a>, <a href="#Page_83">83</a>, +<a href="#Page_84">84</a>, <a href="#Page_104">104</a>, <a href="#Page_142">142</a>, +<a href="#Page_149">149</a>, <a href="#Page_153">153</a>, <a href="#Page_163">163</a>, +<a href="#Page_185">185</a>, <a href="#Page_188">188</a>, <a href="#Page_193">193</a>, +<a href="#Page_210">210</a>, <a href="#Page_342">342</a>, <a href="#Page_376">376</a>, <a href="#Page_382">382</a><br /> +<br /> +Freudian principles, <a href="#Page_143">143</a>, <a href="#Page_144">144</a>, <a href="#Page_147">147</a><br /> +<span class="ind1">misconceptions concerning, <a href="#Page_184">184</a>, <a href="#Page_185">185</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Frink, H.W., <a href="#Page_89">89</a>, <a href="#Page_107">107</a>, +<a href="#Page_158">158</a>, <a href="#Page_162">162</a>, <a href="#Page_171">171</a>, +<a href="#Page_195">195</a>, <a href="#Page_218">218</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">G</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Gall-stones, <a href="#Page_269">269</a><br /> +<br /> +Gas on the stomach, <a href="#Page_264">264</a><br /> +<br /> +Gastric juice, <a href="#Page_86">86</a>, <a href="#Page_134">134</a><br /> +<br /> +Gastritis, <a href="#Page_266">266</a><br /> +<br /> +Genius, <a href="#Page_116">116</a><br /> +<br /> +Girard-Mangin, Dr., <a href="#Page_231">231</a><br /> +<br /> +Goitre, <a href="#Page_239">239</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading"><!-- Page 397 --><a name="Page_397" id="Page_397" />H</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Habit,<br /> +<span class="ind1">defined, <a href="#Page_150">150</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">dissociation, <a href="#Page_189">189</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">dreaming, <a href="#Page_162">162</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">fixation of, <a href="#Page_150">150</a>, <a href="#Page_152">152</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of insomnia, <a href="#Page_322">322</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of loving, <a href="#Page_150">150</a>, <a href="#Page_164">164</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of rebelling, <a href="#Page_150">150</a>, <a href="#Page_164">164</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of repressing normal instincts, <a href="#Page_151">151</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">reactions, <a href="#Page_364">364</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Heredity, <a href="#Page_148">148</a><br /> +<br /> +Hidden desires, <a href="#Page_363">363</a>, <a href="#Page_368">368</a><br /> +<br /> +Hinkle, Bertha M., <a href="#Page_154">154</a><br /> +<br /> +Holt, E.B., <a href="#Page_213">213</a><br /> +<br /> +Homosexuality, <a href="#Page_184">184</a><br /> +<br /> +Hoover, Herbert A., <a href="#Page_384">384</a><br /> +<br /> +Hormone, <a href="#Page_305">305</a>, <a href="#Page_319">319</a><br /> +<br /> +Hudson, J.W., <a href="#Page_91">91</a>, <a href="#Page_95">95</a><br /> +<br /> +Hydrochloric Acid, <a href="#Page_267">267</a><br /> +<br /> +Hygiene,<br /> +<span class="ind1">laws of, <a href="#Page_127">127</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">moral, <a href="#Page_206">206</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Hygienic conditions, <a href="#Page_222">222</a>, <a href="#Page_230">230</a><br /> +<br /> +Hypersensitiveness, <a href="#Page_342">342</a><br /> +<br /> +Hypnosis, <a href="#Page_84">84</a> ff.<br /> +<span class="ind1">aid to diagnosis, <a href="#Page_187">187</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">its drawbacks, <a href="#Page_188">188</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">suggestibility in, <a href="#Page_189">189</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Hysteria, <a href="#Page_7">7</a>, <a href="#Page_111">111</a><br /> +<br /> +Hysterical pains, <a href="#Page_353">353</a><br /> +<br /> +Hysterical pregnancy, (case), <a href="#Page_127">127</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">I</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Ideas,<br /> +<span class="ind1">and emotions, <a href="#Page_23">23</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">ascetic, <a href="#Page_253">253</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">contagion of, <a href="#Page_120">120</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">dynamogenic, <a href="#Page_253">253</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">not surgical, <a href="#Page_262">262</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Idiosyncrasies, physical, <a href="#Page_258">258</a><br /> +<br /> +Identification, <a href="#Page_110">110</a><br /> +<br /> +Imagination, <a href="#Page_162">162</a><br /> +<br /> +Incantation, <a href="#Page_211">211</a><br /> +<br /> +Indigestion; <a href="#Page_211">211</a>, <a href="#Page_250">250</a><br /> +<br /> +Inferiority complex, <a href="#Page_340">340</a>, <a href="#Page_380">380</a><br /> +<br /> +Inhibition, <a href="#Page_188">188</a>, <a href="#Page_245">245</a>, +<a href="#Page_293">293</a>, <a href="#Page_306">306</a>, <a href="#Page_330">330</a>, <a href="#Page_377">377</a><br /> +<br /> +Insomnia, <a href="#Page_322">322</a> ff.<br /> +<br /> +Instincts and their Emotions, <a href="#Page_33">33</a> ff., <a href="#Page_51">51</a> ff.<br /> +<br /> +Instincts,<br /> +<span class="ind1">beneficent, <a href="#Page_85">85</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">energy releasers, <a href="#Page_233">233</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">race-inheritance, <a href="#Page_85">85</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">repressed, <a href="#Page_28">28</a>, <a href="#Page_103">103</a>, +<a href="#Page_147">147</a>, <a href="#Page_169">169</a>, <a href="#Page_172">172</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">sex (see under sex)</span><br /> +<span class="ind1">thwarted, <a href="#Page_235">235</a>, <a href="#Page_244">244</a>, <a href="#Page_340">340</a>, +<a href="#Page_356">356</a>, <a href="#Page_367">367</a>, <a href="#Page_379">379</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Internal Secretion,<br /> +<span class="ind1">of ovary, <a href="#Page_316">316</a>, <a href="#Page_317">317</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">(see Adrenal)</span><br /> +<span class="ind1">(see Thyroid)</span><br /> +<br /> +Introspection, <a href="#Page_26">26</a><br /> +<br /> +Introversion, <a href="#Page_380">380</a>, <a href="#Page_381">381</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">J</p> + +<p class="noind"> +James, William, <a href="#Page_49">49</a>, <a href="#Page_221">221</a>, +<a href="#Page_227">227</a>, <a href="#Page_243">243</a>, <a href="#Page_253">253</a>, +<a href="#Page_347">347</a>, <a href="#Page_382">382</a><br /> +<br /> +Janet, Pierre, <a href="#Page_188">188</a><br /> +<br /> +Jealousy, <a href="#Page_154">154</a>, <a href="#Page_380">380</a><br /> +<br /> +Jelliffe, Smith Ely, <a href="#Page_98">98</a>, <a href="#Page_114">114</a>, +<a href="#Page_153">153</a>, <a href="#Page_163">163</a><br /> +<br /> +Jones, Ernest, <a href="#Page_69">69</a><br /><!-- Page 398 --><a name="Page_398" id="Page_398" /> +<br /> +Judicious neglect, <a href="#Page_127">127</a><br /> +<br /> +Jung, C.G., <a href="#Page_8">8</a>, <a href="#Page_64">64</a>, <a href="#Page_69">69</a>, +<a href="#Page_163">163</a>, <a href="#Page_197">197</a>, <a href="#Page_380">380</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">K</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Kempf, Edward J., <a href="#Page_86">86</a><br /> +<br /> +Kinaesthetic sensations, <a href="#Page_336">336</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">L</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Latency period, <a href="#Page_60">60</a><br /> +<br /> +Libido, <a href="#Page_36">36</a>, <a href="#Page_147">147</a>, <a href="#Page_252">252</a><br /> +<br /> +Liver trouble, <a href="#Page_268">268</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">M</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Masturbation, <a href="#Page_184">184</a><br /> +<br /> +McDougall, Wm., <a href="#Page_49">49</a>, <a href="#Page_122">122</a>, <a href="#Page_372">372</a><br /> +<br /> +Memories, <a href="#Page_84">84</a> ff.<br /> +<br /> +Menopause, <a href="#Page_314">314</a><br /> +<br /> +Menstruation, <a href="#Page_306">306</a><br /> +<br /> +Mind (see Consciousness and Subconscious)<br /> +<br /> +Misconceptions,<br /> +<span class="ind1">about the body, <a href="#Page_21">21</a>, <a href="#Page_22">22</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">about theory of sex, <a href="#Page_184">184</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Mixtures, fear of, <a href="#Page_257">257</a><br /> +<br /> +Monogamy, <a href="#Page_63">63</a><br /> +<br /> +Moral hygiene, <a href="#Page_206">206</a><br /> +<br /> +Mosher, Clelia Duel, <a href="#Page_308">308</a><br /> +<br /> +Muscle-tone, <a href="#Page_137">137</a>, <a href="#Page_244">244</a><br /> +<br /> +Myth, <a href="#Page_146">146</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">N</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Narcissus, <a href="#Page_55">55</a>, <a href="#Page_152">152</a>, <a href="#Page_340">340</a><br /> +<br /> +Nausea, <a href="#Page_101">101</a>, <a href="#Page_177">177</a>, <a href="#Page_275">275</a><br /> +<span class="ind1">of pregnancy, <a href="#Page_319">319</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Nerves,<br /> +<span class="ind1">attitude toward, <a href="#Page_3">3</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">causes of, <a href="#Page_28">28</a>, <a href="#Page_148">148</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">drama of, <a href="#Page_10">10</a>, <a href="#Page_29">29</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">medical schools and, <a href="#Page_16">16</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">not physical, <a href="#Page_14">14</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">prevention of, <a href="#Page_385">385</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Neurasthenia, <a href="#Page_111">111</a>, <a href="#Page_246">246</a><br /> +<br /> +Neuritis, <a href="#Page_14">14</a>, <a href="#Page_244">244</a><br /> +<br /> +Neurosis,<br /> +<span class="ind1">a compromise, <a href="#Page_167">167</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">a confidence game, <a href="#Page_179">179</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">a failure of sublimation, <a href="#Page_381">381</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">a flight from reality, <a href="#Page_170">170</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">an ethical struggle, <a href="#Page_177">177</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">an introversion, <a href="#Page_381">381</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and shell-shock, <a href="#Page_147">147</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and suggestion, <a href="#Page_129">129</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">anxiety, <a href="#Page_7">7</a>, <a href="#Page_109">109</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">awkwardness of, <a href="#Page_213">213</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">compulsion, <a href="#Page_109">109</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">caused by buried complexes, <a href="#Page_108">108</a>, <a href="#Page_190">190</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">definition <a href="#Page_112">112</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">origin in childhood, <a href="#Page_149">149</a>, <a href="#Page_157">157</a>, <a href="#Page_217">217</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">purpose of, <a href="#Page_167">167</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">root-complex of, <a href="#Page_153">153</a></span><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">O</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Obsession, <a href="#Page_7">7</a>, <a href="#Page_204">204</a><br /> +<br /> +Oedipus Complex, <a href="#Page_154">154</a><br /> +<br /> +Organic trouble, <a href="#Page_11">11</a>, <a href="#Page_12">12</a>, <a href="#Page_251">251</a><br /> +<br /> +Ouija Board, <a href="#Page_97">97</a><br /> +<br /> +Over-awareness, <a href="#Page_352">352</a><br /> +<br /> +Over-compensation, <a href="#Page_67">67</a><br /> +<br /> +Over-determined, <a href="#Page_148">148</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading"><!-- Page 399 --><a name="Page_399" id="Page_399" />P</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Pain,<br /> +<span class="ind1">at base of the brain, <a href="#Page_351">351</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">chronic hysterical, <a href="#Page_341">341</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">menstrual, <a href="#Page_306">306</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Personality,<br /> +<span class="ind1">alterations of, <a href="#Page_7">7</a>, <a href="#Page_15">15</a>, <a href="#Page_20">20</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and emotions, <a href="#Page_362">362</a>, <a href="#Page_369">369</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and will, <a href="#Page_372">372</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">choice by, <a href="#Page_216">216</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">complexes and, <a href="#Page_107">107</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">disrupted, <a href="#Page_382">382</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">multiple, <a href="#Page_111">111</a>, <a href="#Page_131">131</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">nervousness a disorder of, <a href="#Page_15">15</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">reverence for, <a href="#Page_383">383</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">unified, <a href="#Page_375">375</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Persuasion, <a href="#Page_206">206</a><br /> +<br /> +Pfister, Oskar, <a href="#Page_153">153</a>, <a href="#Page_166">166</a>, <a href="#Page_382">382</a><br /> +<br /> +Phantasy, <a href="#Page_153">153</a>, <a href="#Page_163">163</a><br /> +<br /> +Phobia, <a href="#Page_7">7</a>, <a href="#Page_368">368</a><br /> +<br /> +Plagiarism, <a href="#Page_98">98</a><br /> +<br /> +Popular Misconceptions, <a href="#Page_21">21</a><br /> +<br /> +Prince, Morton, <a href="#Page_79">79</a>, <a href="#Page_84">84</a>, +<a href="#Page_89">89</a>, <a href="#Page_95">95</a>, <a href="#Page_97">97</a>, <a href="#Page_112">112</a>, +<a href="#Page_132">132</a>, <a href="#Page_188">188</a>, <a href="#Page_347">347</a><br /> +<br /> +Psycho-analysis, <a href="#Page_189">189</a> ff.<br /> +<br /> +Psychological explanation, <a href="#Page_208">208</a><br /> +<br /> +Psychology, <a href="#Page_25">25</a>, <a href="#Page_27">27</a>, <a href="#Page_94">94</a><br /> +<br /> +Psycho-neurosis, <a href="#Page_144">144</a>, <a href="#Page_147">147</a>, +<a href="#Page_163">163</a>, <a href="#Page_169">169</a> (see also neurosis)<br /> +<br /> +Psycho-therapy, <a href="#Page_74">74</a>, <a href="#Page_187">187</a>, <a href="#Page_216">216</a><br /> +<br /> +Ptosis, <a href="#Page_139">139</a>, <a href="#Page_251">251</a><br /> +<br /> +Putnam, James J., <a href="#Page_3">3</a>, <a href="#Page_34">34</a>, +<a href="#Page_69">69</a>, <a href="#Page_215">215</a>, <a href="#Page_366">366</a>, +<a href="#Page_370">370</a>, <a href="#Page_382">382</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">R</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Race-memories, <a href="#Page_84">84</a><br /> +<br /> +Rationalization, <a href="#Page_90">90</a>, <a href="#Page_155">155</a>, <a href="#Page_168">168</a>, +<a href="#Page_317">317</a><br /> +<br /> +Reaction and over-reaction, <a href="#Page_149">149</a>, <a href="#Page_198">198</a>, +<a href="#Page_202">202</a>, <a href="#Page_238">238</a>, <a href="#Page_335">335</a><br /> +<br /> +Reality, flight from, <a href="#Page_164">164</a>, <a href="#Page_379">379</a><br /> +<br /> +Re-education, <a href="#Page_183">183</a> ff.<br /> +<br /> +Reflex,<br /> +<span class="ind1">conditioned, <a href="#Page_108">108</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">physiological, <a href="#Page_349">349</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Regression to infantile state, <a href="#Page_163">163</a>, <a href="#Page_164">164</a><br /> +<span class="ind1">case of, <a href="#Page_92">92</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Religion, <a href="#Page_74">74</a>, <a href="#Page_89">89</a>, +<a href="#Page_374">374</a>, <a href="#Page_382">382</a><br /> +<br /> +Reminiscences, hysteric suffers from, <a href="#Page_7">7</a><br /> +<br /> +Repression, <a href="#Page_104">104</a>, <a href="#Page_156">156</a>, +<a href="#Page_160">160</a>, <a href="#Page_162">162</a>, <a href="#Page_235">235</a>, +<a href="#Page_245">245</a>, <a href="#Page_304">304</a><br /> +<br /> +Resistance, <a href="#Page_160">160</a>, <a href="#Page_188">188</a>, +<a href="#Page_192">192</a>, <a href="#Page_202">202</a>, <a href="#Page_211">211</a><br /> +<br /> +Rest-cure, <a href="#Page_246">246</a><br /> +<br /> +Rheumatism, buttermilk treatment of, <a href="#Page_282">282</a><br /> +<br /> +Rixford, Emmet L., <a href="#Page_283">283</a><br /> +<br /> +Royce, Josiah, <a href="#Page_375">375</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">S</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Sadler, Wm., <a href="#Page_126">126</a>, <a href="#Page_136">136</a><br /> +<br /> +School, four grade, <a href="#Page_54">54</a><br /> +<br /> +Second wind, <a href="#Page_221">221</a><br /> +<br /> +Self-abuse, <a href="#Page_184">184</a>, <a href="#Page_238">238</a><br /> +<br /> +Self-pity, <a href="#Page_365">365</a><br /> +<br /> +Self-regard, <a href="#Page_45">45</a>, <a href="#Page_103">103</a>, +<a href="#Page_157">157</a>, <a href="#Page_374">374</a><br /> +<br /> +Sensations, lowered threshold to, <a href="#Page_333">333</a> ff.<br /> +<br /> +Sensitiveness, <a href="#Page_333">333</a>, <a href="#Page_340">340</a><br /> +<br /> +Sex,<br /> +<span class="ind1">and artistic creation, <a href="#Page_379">379</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and "Nerves," <a href="#Page_141">141</a> ff.</span><br /> +<span class="ind1">glands, secretion of, <a href="#Page_305">305</a>, <a href="#Page_314">314</a>, <a href="#Page_316">316</a></span><br /> +instinct organically aroused, <a href="#Page_65">65</a><br /><!-- Page 400 --><a name="Page_400" id="Page_400" /> +<span class="ind1">instinct thwarted, <a href="#Page_161">161</a>, +<a href="#Page_367">367</a>, <a href="#Page_379">379</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">instruction, <a href="#Page_160">160</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">license, <a href="#Page_184">184</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">life, <a href="#Page_143">143</a>, +<a href="#Page_146">146</a>, <a href="#Page_157">157</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">perversion, <a href="#Page_152">152</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">phantasy, <a href="#Page_163">163</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">psychic component of, <a href="#Page_185">185</a>, <a href="#Page_356">356</a>, +<a href="#Page_379">379</a>, <a href="#Page_383">383</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">repressed, <a href="#Page_104">104</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">sublimation of, <a href="#Page_233">233</a>, <a href="#Page_379">379</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Shell-shock, (see foreword)<br /> +<span class="ind1">also <a href="#Page_145">145</a>, <a href="#Page_147">147</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Sherrington, Chas., <a href="#Page_39">39</a><br /> +<br /> +Sick-headache, <a href="#Page_270">270</a><br /> +<br /> +Sidis, Boris, <a href="#Page_24">24</a>, <a href="#Page_84">84</a>, <a href="#Page_188">188</a>, +<a href="#Page_222">222</a>, <a href="#Page_337">337</a>, <a href="#Page_341">341</a><br /> +<br /> +Slips of tongue, etc., <a href="#Page_199">199</a><br /> +<br /> +Slogan,<br /> +<span class="ind1">of psychoanalytic school, <a href="#Page_215">215</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">woman's, <a href="#Page_314">314</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Social code, <a href="#Page_184">184</a><br /> +<br /> +Soda, misuse of, <a href="#Page_266">266</a><br /> +<br /> +"Sour-stomach," <a href="#Page_260">260</a>, <a href="#Page_266">266</a><br /> +<br /> +Sprees, <a href="#Page_376">376</a><br /> +<br /> +Stammering, <a href="#Page_200">200</a><br /> +<br /> +Standard,<br /> +<span class="ind1">double, <a href="#Page_66">66</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">single, <a href="#Page_62">62</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Stomach, <a href="#Page_133">133</a><br /> +<span class="ind1">and conversion hysteria, <a href="#Page_250">250</a> ff.</span><br /> +<span class="ind1">fads, <a href="#Page_252">252</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">gas on, <a href="#Page_252">252</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Subconscious mind, <a href="#Page_77">77</a> ff.<br /> +<span class="ind1">amenable to control by suggestion, emotion, <a href="#Page_119">119</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">functions of, <a href="#Page_85">85</a>, +<a href="#Page_335">335</a>, <a href="#Page_337">337</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">habits of, <a href="#Page_105">105</a>, <a href="#Page_259">259</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">physical expression of, <a href="#Page_245">245</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">playing confidence game, <a href="#Page_311">311</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">store-house of memories, <a href="#Page_84">84</a>, <a href="#Page_89">89</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">tireless, <a href="#Page_325">325</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Sublimation, <a href="#Page_379">379</a> ff.<br /> +<span class="ind1">a synthesis, <a href="#Page_164">164</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">and religion, <a href="#Page_74">74</a>, <a href="#Page_382">382</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">definition (Freud), <a href="#Page_69">69</a>, <a href="#Page_70">70</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">failure of, <a href="#Page_71">71</a>, <a href="#Page_147">147</a>, +<a href="#Page_381">381</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in a career, <a href="#Page_385">385</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in artistic creation, <a href="#Page_68">68</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">natural trends of, <a href="#Page_383">383</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">of energy, <a href="#Page_178">178</a>, <a href="#Page_238">238</a>, +<a href="#Page_309">309</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Success, measure of, <a href="#Page_380">380</a><br /> +<br /> +Sugar in urine, <a href="#Page_133">133</a><br /> +<br /> +Suggestion,<br /> +<span class="ind1">a method of psychotherapy, <a href="#Page_208">208</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">constipation the result of, <a href="#Page_289">289</a>, <a href="#Page_298">298</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">definition, <a href="#Page_121">121</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">false, <a href="#Page_302">302</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in child training, <a href="#Page_121">121</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in hypnosis, <a href="#Page_99">99</a>, <a href="#Page_188">188</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">in sleep, <a href="#Page_99">99</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">inconvenient forms of, <a href="#Page_296">296</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">power of, <a href="#Page_45">45</a></span><br /> +<span class="ind1">unhealthy, <a href="#Page_310">310</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Suggestibility, <a href="#Page_122">122</a>, <a href="#Page_189">189</a>, <a href="#Page_206">206</a><br /> +<br /> +Superman, <a href="#Page_339">339</a><br /> +<br /> +Symbolism, <a href="#Page_171">171</a>, <a href="#Page_176">176</a>, +<a href="#Page_275">275</a>, <a href="#Page_342">342</a><br /> +<br /> +Symptoms, purpose of, <a href="#Page_168">168</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">T</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Taboos,<br /> +<span class="ind1">dietary, <a href="#Page_250">250</a> ff.</span><br /> +<span class="ind1">interest in, <a href="#Page_289">289</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Tensions, psychic, <a href="#Page_69">69</a>, <a href="#Page_85">85</a>, <a href="#Page_353">353</a>, +<a href="#Page_366">366</a><br /><!-- Page 401 --><a name="Page_401" id="Page_401" /> +<br /> +<span title="Corrected typo: was 'Thesholds'" class="hov">Thresholds</span>, psychic, <a href="#Page_337">337</a> ff.<br /> +<br /> +Thyroid secretion, <a href="#Page_42">42</a>, <a href="#Page_133">133</a>, +<a href="#Page_185">185</a>, <a href="#Page_270">270</a><br /> +<br /> +Transference, <a href="#Page_109">109</a>, <a href="#Page_193">193</a>, <a href="#Page_264">264</a><br /> +<br /> +Trotter, W., <a href="#Page_46">46</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">U</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Unconscious, (see subconscious)<br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">V</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Venereal disease, <a href="#Page_304">304</a>, <a href="#Page_317">317</a><br /> +<br /> +Vitamins, <a href="#Page_255">255</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">W</p> + +<p class="noind"> +White, Wm. A., <a href="#Page_69">69</a>, <a href="#Page_82">82</a>, +<a href="#Page_83">83</a>, <a href="#Page_98">98</a><br /> +<br /> +Will, <a href="#Page_371">371</a><br /> +<br /> +Williams, Tom A., <a href="#Page_21">21</a>, <a href="#Page_213">213</a><br /> +<br /> +Wish fulfilment, <a href="#Page_171">171</a>, <a href="#Page_194">194</a>, +<a href="#Page_200">200</a>, <a href="#Page_214">214</a><br /> +<br /> +Word-association test, <a href="#Page_197">197</a><br /> +<br /> +Work-cure, <a href="#Page_385">385</a><br /> + </p> + + + +<p class="heading">ILLUSTRATIONS FROM CASES</p> + + +<p class="heading">A</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Adolescence and depression, <a href="#Page_312">312</a>, <a href="#Page_313">313</a><br /> +<br /> +Anger and circulation, <a href="#Page_136">136</a><br /> +<br /> +Angina pectoris, false, <a href="#Page_129">129</a><br /> +<br /> +Anxiety-neurosis, <a href="#Page_175">175</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">B</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Bearing children, <a href="#Page_318">318</a><br /> +<br /> +Brain fag, <a href="#Page_241">241</a><br /> +<br /> +Bran crackers and prunes, <a href="#Page_258">258</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">C</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Cathartics, abuse of, <a href="#Page_284">284</a><br /> +<br /> +Childhood sex-reactions, <a href="#Page_203">203</a><br /> +<br /> +Constipation and lacerations in labor, <a href="#Page_296">296</a><br /> +<br /> +Constipation and Mineral Oil, <a href="#Page_295">295</a><br /> +<br /> +Constipation, recovery from, (some cases), <a href="#Page_294">294</a><br /> +<br /> +Contamination, fear of, <a href="#Page_159">159</a><br /> +<br /> +Conversion of moral distress to physical, <a href="#Page_348">348</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">D</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Danger-signals and the railroad man, <a href="#Page_344">344</a><br /> +<br /> +Dissociated state, memories in, <a href="#Page_92">92</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">E</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Emotion and sick-headache, <a href="#Page_273">273</a><br /> +<br /> +"Enjoying" poor health, <a href="#Page_213">213</a>, <a href="#Page_345">345</a><br /> +<br /> +"Exhaustion," <a href="#Page_243">243</a><br /> +<br /> +Eye-strain, twenty-five years, <a href="#Page_274">274</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading"><!-- Page 402 --><a name="Page_402" id="Page_402" />F</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Fatigue, <a href="#Page_228">228</a>, <a href="#Page_234">234</a>, (two cases), <a href="#Page_239">239</a><br /> +<br /> +Fatigue and emotion, (three cases), <a href="#Page_354">354</a><br /> +<br /> +Fear, <a href="#Page_237">237</a>,<br /> +<span class="ind1">of heat, <a href="#Page_237">237</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Fear of air, <a href="#Page_348">348</a>, <a href="#Page_349">349</a><br /> +<br /> +Fear of cold, (three cases), <a href="#Page_348">348</a>, <a href="#Page_349">349</a><br /> +<br /> +Fear of light, (two cases), <a href="#Page_350">350</a><br /> +<br /> +Fear complicating labor, <a href="#Page_320">320</a><br /> +<br /> +"Flat-foot," <a href="#Page_137">137</a><br /> +<br /> +Forgetting and repressed wish, <a href="#Page_200">200</a><br /> +<br /> +Free-love, chemical cause of, <a href="#Page_317">317</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">G</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Gall-stones, <a href="#Page_269">269</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">I</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Idiosyncrasy for eggs, <a href="#Page_212">212</a><br /> +<br /> +Insomnia and attention, <a href="#Page_329">329</a><br /> +<br /> +Insomnia and point of view, <a href="#Page_328">328</a><br /> +<br /> +Insomnia and wrong associations, <a href="#Page_330">330</a><br /> +<br /> +Insomnia, chronic, <a href="#Page_328">328</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">L</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Library, child fear of, <a href="#Page_100">100</a><br /> +<br /> +Locomotor Ataxia, exaggeration of symptoms, <a href="#Page_128">128</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">M</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Menstrual pain, unnecessary, <a href="#Page_220">220</a><br /> +<br /> +Muscle-tumors, phantom, <a href="#Page_127">127</a>, <a href="#Page_128">128</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">N</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Nausea, in sex-repression, <a href="#Page_101">101</a>, <a href="#Page_177">177</a><br /> +<br /> +Nervous indigestion, <a href="#Page_211">211</a><br /> +<br /> +"Neuritis," <a href="#Page_174">174</a>,<br /> +<span class="ind1">false, <a href="#Page_244">244</a></span><br /> +<br /> +Noise, fear of, <a href="#Page_355">355</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">O</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Obsession against marriage, <a href="#Page_204">204</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">P</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Paralysis, fear of, <a href="#Page_345">345</a>, <a href="#Page_346">346</a><br /> +<br /> +Physical illness mistaken for functional, <a href="#Page_252">252</a><br /> +<br /> +Plagiarism, <a href="#Page_98">98</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">R</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Recovering lost word, <a href="#Page_80">80</a><br /> +<br /> +Repression and disgust, <a href="#Page_199">199</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">S</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Sick-headache, <a href="#Page_271">271</a>, <a href="#Page_274">274</a><br /> +<br /> +Skim-milk diet, <a href="#Page_262">262</a><br /> +<br /> +"Sour stomach" and two Tyrolese, <a href="#Page_260">260</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading"><!-- Page 403 --><a name="Page_403" id="Page_403" />T</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Temper, an indulgence, <a href="#Page_359">359</a><br /> +<br /> +The "Repeater" gains in weight, <a href="#Page_263">263</a><br /> +<br /> +Thyroid disturbance, fatigue in, <a href="#Page_239">239</a>, <a href="#Page_240">240</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">U</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Unconscious Association and symptoms, <a href="#Page_346">346</a><br /> + </p> + +<p class="heading">W</p> + +<p class="noind"> +Walking, lost power of, <a href="#Page_124">124</a><br /> +<br /> +Word Association test, <a href="#Page_198">198</a><br /> + </p> + + + + + + + + +<pre> + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Outwitting Our Nerves +by Josephine A. Jackson and Helen M. Salisbury + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK OUTWITTING OUR NERVES *** + +***** This file should be named 14980-h.htm or 14980-h.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + https://www.gutenberg.org/1/4/9/8/14980/ + +Produced by Rick Niles, Ronald Holder and the PG Online Distributed +Proofreading Team. + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +https://gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS' WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, is critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at https://www.pglaf.org. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Its 501(c)(3) letter is posted at +https://pglaf.org/fundraising. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at https://pglaf.org + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit https://pglaf.org + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including including checks, online payments and credit card +donations. To donate, please visit: https://pglaf.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + https://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. + + +</pre> + +</body> +</html> diff --git a/14980.txt b/14980.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3a66969 --- /dev/null +++ b/14980.txt @@ -0,0 +1,10991 @@ +The Project Gutenberg EBook of Outwitting Our Nerves +by Josephine A. Jackson and Helen M. Salisbury + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: Outwitting Our Nerves + A Primer of Psychotherapy + +Author: Josephine A. Jackson and Helen M. Salisbury + +Release Date: February 8, 2005 [EBook #14980] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ASCII + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK OUTWITTING OUR NERVES *** + + + + +Produced by Rick Niles, Ronald Holder and the PG Online Distributed +Proofreading Team. + + + + + + + +OUTWITTING OUR +NERVES + +A PRIMER OF PSYCHOTHERAPY + +BY + +JOSEPHINE A. JACKSON, M.D. +HELEN M. SALISBURY + +[Illustration] + +NEW YORK +THE CENTURY CO. +1922 + +1921, by +THE CENTURY CO. + +PRINTED IN U.S.A. + + + + +TO + +MARY PATTERSON MANLY + +A LOVER OF TRUTH + + + + +FOREWORD + + +"Your trouble is nervous. There is nothing we can cut out and there is +nothing we can give medicine for." With these words a young college +student was dismissed from one of our great diagnostic clinics. + +The physician was right. In a nervous disorder there is nothing to cut +out and there is nothing to give medicine for. Nevertheless there is +something to be done,--something which is as definite and scientific +as a prescription or a surgical operation. + +Psychotherapy, which is treatment by the mental measures of +psycho-analysis and re-education, is an established procedure in the +scientific world to-day. Nervous disorders are now curable, as has +been proved by the clinical results in scores of cases from civil +life, under treatment by Freud, Janet, Prince, Sidis, DuBois, and +others; and in thousands of cases of war neuroses as reported by Smith +and Pear, Eder, MacCurdy, and other military observers. These army +experts have shown that shell-shock in war is the same as nervousness +in civil life and that both may be cured by psycho-analysis and +re-education. + +For more than a decade, in handling nervous cases, I have made use of +the findings of recognized authorities on psychopathology. Truths have +been applied in a special way, with the features of re-education so +emphasized that my home has been called a psychological +boarding-school. As the alumni have gone back to the game of life +with no haunting memories of usual sanatorium methods, but with the +equipment of a fuller self-knowledge and sense of power, they have +sent back a call for some word that shall extend this helpful message +to a larger circle. + +There has come, too, a demand for a book which shall give accurate and +up-to-date information to those physicians who are eager for light on +the subject of nervous disorders, and especially for knowledge of the +significant contributions of Sigmund Freud, but who are too busy to +devote time to highly technical volumes outside their own specialties. + +This need for a simple, comprehensive presentation of the Freudian +principles I have attempted to meet in this primer of psychotherapy, +providing enough of biological and psychological background to make +them intelligible, and enough application and illustration to make +them useful to the general practitioner or the average layman. + +JOSEPHINE A. JACKSON. + +Pasadena, California, 1921. + + + + +CONTENTS + +PART I: THE STRANGE WAYS OF NERVES + +CHAPTER I + PAGE + +In which most of us plead guilty to the charge of "nerves." + +NERVOUS FOLK 3 + +CHAPTER II + +In which we learn what "nerves" are not and get a hint of +what they are. + +THE DRAMA OF NERVES 10 + + +PART II: "HOW THE WHEELS GO ROUND" + +CHAPTER III + +In which we find a goodly inheritance. + +THE STORY OF THE INSTINCTS 33 + +CHAPTER IV + +In which we learn more about ourselves. + +THE STORY OF THE INSTINCTS (Continued) 51 + +CHAPTER V + +In which we look below the surface and discover a veritable +wonderland. + +THE SUBCONSCIOUS MIND 77 + +CHAPTER VI + +In which we learn why it pays to be cheerful. + +BODY AND MIND 118 + +CHAPTER VII + +In which we go to the root of the matter. + +THE REAL TROUBLE 141 + + +PART III: THE MASTERY OF "NERVES" + +CHAPTER VIII + +In which we pick up the clue. + +THE WAY OUT 183 + +CHAPTER IX + +In which we discover new stores of energy and relearn the +truth about fatigue. + +THAT TIRED FEELING 219 + +CHAPTER X + +In which the ban is lifted. + +DIETARY TABOOS 250 + +CHAPTER XI + +In which we learn an old trick. + +THE BUGABOO OF CONSTIPATION 278 + +CHAPTER XII + +In which handicaps are dropped. + +A WOMAN'S ILLS 300 + +CHAPTER XIII + +In which we lose our dread of night. + +THAT INTERESTING INSOMNIA 322 + +CHAPTER XIV + +In which we raise our thresholds. + +FEELING OUR FEELINGS 333 + +CHAPTER XV + +In which we learn discrimination. + +CHOOSING OUR EMOTIONS 359 + +CHAPTER XVI + +In which we find new use for our steam. + +FINDING VENT IN SUBLIMATION 379 + +GLOSSARY 386 + +BIBLIOGRAPHY 390 + +INDEX 393 + + + + +OUTWITTING OUR NERVES + + + + +CHAPTER I + +_In Which Most of Us Plead Guilty to the Charge of "Nerves."_ + +NERVOUS FOLK + +WHO'S WHO + + +Whenever the subject of "nerves" is mentioned most people begin trying +to prove an alibi. The man who is nervous and knows that he is +nervous, realizes that he needs help, but the man who has as yet felt +no lack of stability in himself is quite likely to be impatient with +that whole class of people who are liable to nervous breakdown. It is +therefore well to remind ourselves at once that the line between the +so-called "normal" and the nervous is an exceedingly fine one. +"Nervous invalids and well people are indistinguishable both in theory +and in practice,"[1] and "after all we are most of us more or less +neurasthenic."[2] The fact is that everybody is a possible neurotic. + +[Footnote 1: Putnam: _Human Motives_, p. 117.] + +[Footnote 2: DuBois: _Physic Treatment of Nervous Disorders_, p. 172.] + +So, as we think about nervous folk and begin to recognize our friends +and relatives in this class, it may be that some of us will +unexpectedly find ourselves looking in the mirror. Some of our +lifelong habits may turn out to be nervous tricks. At any rate, it +behooves us to be careful about throwing stones, for most of us live +in houses that are at least part glass. + + +THE EARMARKS + +=Am I "Like Folks"?= Before we begin to talk about the real sufferer +from "nerves," the nervous invalid, let us look for some of the +earmarks that are often found on the supposedly well person. All of +these signs are deviations from the normal and are sure indications of +nervousness. The test question for each individual is this: "Am I +'like folks'?" To be normal and to be well is to be "like folks." Can +the average man stand this or that? If he can, then you are not normal +if you cannot. Do the people around you eat the thing that upsets you? +If they do, ten chances to one your trouble is not a physical +idiosyncrasy, but a nervous habit. In bodily matters, at least, it is +a good thing to be one of the crowd. + +Many people who would resent being called anything but normal--in +general--are not at all loth to be thought "different," when it comes +to particulars. Are there not many of us who are at small pains to +hide the fact that we "didn't sleep a wink last night," or that we +"can't stand" a ticking clock or a crowing rooster? We sometimes +consider it a mark of distinction to have a delicate appetite and to +have to choose our food with care. If we are frank with ourselves, +some of us will have to admit that our own ailments seem interesting, +while the other person's ills are "merely nervous" or imaginary or +abnormal. After all, a good many of us will have to plead guilty to +the charge of nervousness. + +We have only to read the endless advertisements of cathartics and +"internal baths," or to check up the quantity of laxatives sold at any +drug store, to realize the wide-spread bondage to that great bugaboo +constipation. He who is constipated can hardly prove an alibi to +"nerves." Then there are the school-teachers and others who are worn +out at the end of each year's work, hardly able to hold on until +vacation; and the people who can't manage their tempers; and those who +are upset over trifles; and those who are dissatisfied with life. To a +certain degree, at least, all of these are nervous persons. The list +grows. + +=Half-Power Engines.= These people are all supposed to be well. They +keep going--by fits and starts--and as they are used to running on +three cylinders, with frequent stops for repairs, they accept this +rate of living as a matter of course, never realizing that they might +be sixty horse-power engines, instead of their little thirty or forty. +For this large and neglected class of people psychotherapy has a +stimulating message, and for them many of the following pages have +been written. + +=The Real Sufferers.= These so-called normal people are merely on the +fringe of nervousness, on the border line between normality and +disease. Beyond them there exists a great company of those whose lives +have been literally wrecked by "nerves." Their work interrupted or +given up for good, their minds harassed by doubts and fears, their +bodies incapacitated, they crowd the sanatoria and the health resorts +in a vain search for health. From New England to Florida they seek, +and on to Colorado and California, and perhaps to Hawaii and the +Orient, thinking by rest and change to pull themselves together and +become whole again. There are thousands of these people--lawyers, +preachers, teachers, mothers, social workers, business and +professional folk of all sorts, the kind of persons the world needs +most--laid off for months or years of treatment, on account of some +kind of nervous disorder. + +=Various Types of Nervousness.= The psychoneuroses are of many +forms.[3] To some people "nerves" means nervous prostration, +breakdown, fatigue, weakness, insomnia, the blues, upset stomach, or +unsteady heart,--all signs of so-called neurasthenia or +nerve-weakness. To others the word "nerves" calls up memories of +strange, emotional storms that seem to rise out of nowhere, to sweep +the sky clear of everything else, and to pass as they came, leaving +the victim and the family equally mystified as to their meaning. These +strange alterations of personality are but one manifestation of +hysteria, that myriad-faced disorder which is able to mimic so +successfully the symptoms of almost every known disease, from tumors +and fevers to paralysis and blindness. + +[Footnote 3: The technical term for nervousness is +_psycho-neurosis_--disease of the psyche. There are certain "real +neuroses" such as paralysis and spinal-cord disease, which involve an +organic impairment of nerve-tissue. However, as this book deals only +with psychic disturbance, we shall, throughout, use the term +_neuroses_ and _psycho-neuroses_ indiscriminately, to denote nervous +or functional disorders.] + +To still other people nervous trouble means fear,--just terrible fear +without object or meaning or reason (anxiety neuroses); or a definite +fear of some harmless object (phobia); or a strange, persistent, +recurrent idea, quite foreign to the personality and beyond the reach +of reason (obsession); or an insistent desire to perform some absurd +act (compulsion); or perhaps, a deadly and pall-like depression (the +blues). + +As a matter of fact, the neuroses include all these varieties, and +various shades and combinations of each. There are, however, certain +mental characteristics which recur with surprising regularity in most +of the various phases--dissatisfaction, lack of confidence, a sense of +being alone and shut in to oneself, doubt, anxiety, fear, worry, +self-depreciation, lack of interest in outside affairs, pessimism, +fixed belief in one's powerlessness, along whatever line it may be. + +Underneath all these differing forms of nervousness are the same +mechanisms and the same kind of difficulty. To understand one is to +understand all, and to understand normal people as well; for in the +last analysis we are one and all built on the same lines and governed +by the same laws. The only difference is, that, as Jung says, "the +nervous person falls ill of the conflicts with which the well person +battles successfully." + + +SUMMARY + +Since at least seventy-five per cent. of all the people who apply to +physicians for help are nervous patients; and since these thousands of +patients are not among the mental incompetents, but are as a rule +among the highly organized, conscientious folk who have most to +contribute to the leadership of the world, it is obviously of vital +importance to society that its citizens should be taught how to solve +their inner conflicts and keep well. In this strategic period of +reconstruction, the world that is being remodeled cannot afford to +lose one leader because of an unnecessary breakdown. + +There is greater need than ever for people who can keep at their tasks +without long enforced rests; people who can think deeply and +continuously without brain-fag; people who can concentrate all their +powers on the work in hand without wasting time or energy on +unnecessary aches and pains; people whose bodies are kept up to the +top notch of vitality by well-digested food, well-slept sleep, +well-forgotten fatigue, and well-used reserve energy. That such a +state of affairs is no Utopian dream, but is merely a matter of +knowing how, will appear more clearly in later chapters. + + + + +CHAPTER II + +_In which we learn what "nerves" are not, and get a hint of what they +are_ + +THE DRAMA OF NERVES + +AN EXPLODED THEORY + + +="Nerves" not Nerves.= Pick up any newspaper, turn over a few pages, +and you will be sure to come to an advertisement something like this: + + Tired man, your nerves are sick! + They need rest and a tonic to restore + their worn-out depleted cells! + +No wonder people have believed this kind of thing. It has been dinned +into their ears for many years. They have read it with their breakfast +coffee and gazed at it in the street cars and even heard it from their +family physicians, until it has become part and parcel of their +thinking; yet all the time the fundamental idea has been false, and +now, at last, the theory is exploded. + +So far as the modern laboratory can discover, the nerves of the most +confirmed neurotic are perfectly healthy. They are not starved, nor +depleted, nor exhausted; the fat-sheath is not wanting, there is no +inflammation, there is nothing lacking in the cell itself, and there +is no accumulation of fatigue products. Paradoxical as it may sound, +there is nothing the matter with a nervous person's nerves. The +faithful messengers have borne the blame for so long that their name +has gotten itself woven into the very language as symbolic of disease. +When we speak of nervous prostration, neurasthenia, neuroses, +nervousness, and "nerves" we mean that body and mind are behaving +badly because of functional disorder. These terms are good enough as +figures of speech, so long as we are not fooled by them; but accepting +them in their literal sense has been a costly procedure. + +Thanks to the investigations of physiologist and psychologist, usually +combined in the person of a physician, "nervousness" has been found to +be not an organic disease but a functional one. This is a very +important distinction, for an organic disease implies impairment of +the tissues of the organ, while a functional disorder means only a +disturbance of its action. In a purely nervous disorder there seems to +be no trouble with what the nerves and organs are, but only with what +they do; it is behavior and not tissue that is at fault. Of course, in +real life, things are seldom as clear-cut as they are in books, and +so it happens that often there is a combination of organic and +functional disease that is puzzling even to a skilled diagnostician. +The first essential is a diagnosis as to whether it be an organic +disease, with accompanying nervous symptoms, or a functional +disturbance complicated by some minor organic trouble. If the main +cause is organic, only physical means can cure it, but if the trouble +is functional, no amount of medicine or surgery, diet or rest, will +touch it; yet the symptoms are so similar and the dividing line is so +elusive, that great skill is sometimes required to determine whether a +given symptom points to a disturbance of physical tissue or only to +behavior. + +If the physician is sometimes fooled, how much more the sufferer +himself! Nausea from a healthy stomach is just as sickening as nausea +from a diseased one. A fainting-spell is equally uncomfortable, +whether it come from an impaired heart or simply from one that is +behaving badly for the moment. It must be remembered that in +functional nervousness the trouble is very real. The organs are really +"acting up." Sometimes it is the brain that misbehaves instead of the +stomach or heart. In that case it often reports all kinds of pains +that have no origin outside of the brain. Pain, of course, is +perceived only by the brain. Cut the telegraph wire, the nerve, and no +amount of injury to the finger can cause pain. It is equally true that +a misbehaving brain can report sensations that have no external +cause, that have not come in through the regular channel along the +nerve. The pain feels just the same, is every bit as uncomfortable as +though its cause were external. + +Sometimes, instead of reporting false pains, the brain misbehaves in +other ways. It seems to lose its power to decide, to concentrate, or +to remember. Then the patient is almost sure to fancy himself going +insane. But insanity is a physical disease, implying changes or toxins +in the brain cells. Functional disorders tell another story. Their +cause is different, even though the picture they present is often a +close copy of an organic disease. + +=Distorted Pictures.= It should not be thought, however, that the +symptoms of functional and organic troubles are identical. Hysteria +and neurasthenia closely simulate every imaginable physical disease, +but they do not exactly parallel any one of them. It may take a +skilled eye to discover the differences, but differences there are. +Functional troubles usually show a near-picture of organic disease, +with just enough contradictory or inconsistent features to furnish a +clue as to their real nature. For this reason it is important that the +treatment of the disease be solely the province of the physician; for +only the carefully trained in all the requirements of diagnosis can +differentiate the pseudo from the real, the innocuous from the +disastrous. + +False or nervous neuritis may feel like real neuritis (the result of +poisons in the blood), but it gives itself away when it localizes +itself in parts of the body where there is no nerve trunk. The +exhaustion of neurasthenia sometimes seems extreme enough to be the +result of a dangerous physical condition; but when this exhaustion +disappears as if by magic under the proper kind of treatment, we know +that the trouble cannot be in the body. Let it be said, then, with all +the emphasis we can command, "nerves" are not physical. Laboratory +investigation, contradictory symptoms, and response to treatment all +bear witness to this fact. Whatever symptoms of disturbance there may +be in pure nervousness, the nerves and organs can in no way be shown +to be diseased. + + +THE POSITIVE SIDE + +="Nerves" not Imaginary.= "But," some one says, "how can healthy +organs misbehave in this way? Something must be wrong. There must be +some cause. If 'nerves' are not physical, what are they? They surely +can't be imaginary." Most emphatically, they are real; nothing could +be more maddening than to have some one suggest that our troubles are +"mere imagination." No wonder such theories have been more popular +with the patient's family than with the patient himself. Many years +ago a physician put the whole truth into a few words: "The patient +says, 'I cannot'; his friends say, 'He will not'; the doctor says, 'He +cannot will.'" He tries, but in the circumstances he really cannot. + +=The Man behind the Body.= The trouble is real; the organs do "act +up"; the nerves do carry the wrong messages. But the nerves are merely +telegraph wires. They are not responsible for the messages that are +given them to carry. Behind the wires is the operator, the man higher +up, and upon him the responsibility falls. In functional troubles the +body is working in a perfectly normal way, considering the perverted +conditions. It is doing its work well, doing just what it is told, +obeying its master. The troubles are not with the bodily machine but +with the master. The man behind the body is in trouble and he really +has no way of showing his pain except through his body. The trouble in +nervous disorders is in the personality, the soul, the realm of ideas, +and that is not your body, but _you_. Loss of appetite may mean either +that the powers of the physical organism are busily engaged in +combating some poison circulating in the blood, or that the ego is "up +against" conditions for which it has "no stomach." Paralysis may be +due to a hemorrhage into the brain tissues from a diseased blood +vessel, or it may symbolize a sense of inadequacy and defeat. +Exaggerated exhaustion, halting feet, stammering tongue, may give +evidence of a disturbed ego rather than of a diseased brain. + +=All Body and no Mind.= At last we have begun to realize what we ought +to have known all along,--that the body is not the whole man. The +medical world for a long time has been in danger of forgetting or +ignoring psychic suffering, while it has devoted itself to the +treatment of physical disease. + +By way of condoning this fault it must be recognized that the five +years of medical school have been all too short to learn what is +needed of physiology and anatomy, histology, bacteriology, and the +various other physical sciences. But at last the medical schools are +realizing that they have been sending their graduates out only +half-prepared--conversant with only one half of a patient, leaving +them to fend for themselves in discovering the ways of the other half. +Many an M.D. has gone a long way in this exploration. Native common +sense, intuition, and careful study have enabled him to go beyond what +he had learned in his text-books. But in the best universities the +present-day student of medicine is now being given an insight into the +ways of man as a whole--mind as well as body. The movement can hardly +proceed too rapidly, and when it has had time to reach its goal, the +day of the long-term sentence to nervousness will be past. + +In the meanwhile most physicians, lacking such knowledge and with the +eye fixed largely on the body, have been pumping out the stomach, +prescribing lengthy rest-cures, trying massage, diet, electricity, and +surgical operations, in a vain attempt to cure a disease of the +personality. Physical measures have been given a good trial, but few +would contend that they have succeeded. Sometimes the patient has +recovered--in time--but often, apparently, despite the treatment +rather than because of it. Sometimes, in the hands of a man like Dr. +S. Weir Mitchell, results seem good, until we realize that the same +measures are ineffective when tried by other men, and that, after all, +what has counted most has been the personality of the physician rather +than his physical treatment. + +No wonder that most doctors have disliked nervous cases. To a man +trained in all the exactness of the physical sciences, the apparent +lawlessness and irresponsibility of the psychic side of the +personality is especially repugnant. He is impatient of what he fails +to comprehend. + +=All Mind and no Body.= This unsympathetic attitude, often only half +conscious on the part of the regular practitioners, has led many +thousands of people to follow will-o'-the-wisp cults, which pay no +attention to the findings of science, but which emphasize a +realization of man's spiritual nature. Many of these cults, founded +largely on untruth or half-falsehood, have succeeded in cases where +careful science has failed. Despite fearful blunders and execrable +lack of discrimination in attempting to cure all the ills that flesh +is heir to by methods that apply only to functional troubles, ignorant +enthusiasts and quacks have sometimes cured nervous troubles where the +conscientious medical man has had to acknowledge defeat. + +=The Whole Man.= But thinking people are not willing to desert science +for cults that ignore the existence of these physical bodies. If they +have found it unsatisfactory to be treated as if they were all body, +they have also been unwilling to be treated as if they were all mind. +They have been in a dilemma between two half-truths, even if they have +not realized the dilemma. It has remained for modern psychotherapy to +strike the balance--to treat the whole man. Solidly planted on the +rock of the physical sciences, with its laboratories, physiological +and psychological, and with a long record of investigation and +treatment of pathological cases, it resembles the mind cure of earlier +days or the assertions of Christian Science about as much as modern +medicine resembles the old bloodletting, leeching practices of our +forefathers. + +For the last quarter-century there have been scattered groups of +physicians,--brilliant, patient pioneers,--who, recognizing man as +spirit inhabiting body, have explored the realm of man's mind and +charted its paths. These pioneers, beginning with Charcot, have been +men of acknowledged scientific training and spirit, whose word must be +respected and whose success in treating functional troubles stands out +in sharp contrast to the fumblings of the average practitioner in this +field. The results of their work have been positive, not negative. +They have not merely asserted that nervous disorders are not physical; +they have discovered what the trouble is and have found it to be +discoverable and removable in almost every case, provided only that +the right method is used. + +=Ourselves and Our Bodies.= If the statement that "nervous troubles +are neither physical nor imaginary but a disease of the personality," +sounds rather mystifying to the average person, it is only because the +average person is not very conversant with his own inner life. We +shall hope, later on, to find some definite guide-posts and landmarks +which will help us feel more at home in this fascinating realm. At +present, we are not attempting anything more than a suggestion of the +itinerary which we shall follow. A book on physical hygiene can +presuppose at least a rudimentary knowledge of heart and lungs and +circulation, but a book on mental hygiene must begin at the beginning, +and even before the beginning must clear away misconceptions and make +clear certain fundamental principles. But the gist of the whole matter +is this: in a neurosis, certain forces of the personality--instincts +and their accompanying emotions--which ought to work harmoniously, +having become tangled up with some erroneous ideas, have lost their +power of cooeperation and are working at cross purposes, leaving the +individual mis-adapted to his environment, the prey of all sorts of +mental and physical disturbances. + +The fact that the cause is mental while the result is often physical, +should cause no surprise. In the physiological realm we are used to +the idea that cause and effect are often widely separated. A headache +may be caused by faulty eyes, or it may result from trouble in the +intestines. In the same way, we should not be too much surprised if +the cause of nervous troubles is found to be even more remote, +provided there is some connecting link between cause and effect. The +difficulty in this case is the apparent gulf between the realm of the +spirit and the realm of the body. It is hard to see how an intangible +thing like a thought can produce a pain in the arm or nausea in the +stomach. Philosophers are still arguing concerning the nature of the +relation between mind and body, but no one denies that the closest +relation does exist. Every year science is learning that ideas count +and that they count physically, as well as spiritually. + +=Such Stuff as "Nerves" are Made Of.= Dr. Tom A. Williams in the +little composite volume "Psychotherapeutics" says that the neuroses +are based not on inherently weak nervous constitutions but on +ignorance and on false ideas. What, then, are some of these erroneous +ideas, these misconceptions, that cause so much trouble? We shall want +to examine them more carefully in later chapters, but we might glance +now at a few examples of these popular bugaboos that need to be slain +by the sword of cold, hard fact. + +=Popular Misconceptions about the Body.= + +1 "Eight hours' sleep is essential to health. All insomnia is +dangerous and is incompatible with health. Nervous insomnia leads to +shattered nerves and ultimately to insanity." + +2 "Overwork leads to nervous breakdown. Fatigue accumulates from day +to day and necessitates a long rest for recuperation." + +3 "A carefully planned diet is essential to health, especially for the +nervous person. A variety of food, eaten at the same time, is harmful. +Acid and milk--for example, oranges and milk--are difficult to digest. +Sour stomach is a sign of indigestion." + +4 "Modern life is so strenuous that our nerves cannot stand the +strain." + +5 "Brain work is very fatiguing. It causes brain-fag and exhaustion." + +6 "Constipation is at the root of most physical ailments and is +caused by eating the wrong kind of food." + +Some of these misconceptions are household words and are so all but +universally believed that the thought that they can be challenged is +enough to bewilder one. However, it is ideas like this that furnish +the material out of which many a nervous trouble is made. Based on a +half-knowledge of the human body, on logical conclusions from faulty +premises, on hastily swallowed notions passed on from one person to +another, they tend by the very power of an idea to work themselves out +to fulfilment. + + +THE POWER BEHIND IDEAS + +=Ideas Count.= Ideas are not the lifeless things they may appear. They +are not merely intellectual property that can be locked up and ignored +at will, nor are they playthings that can be taken up or discarded +according to the caprice of the moment. Ideas work themselves into the +very fiber of our being. They are part of us and they _do_ things. If +they are true, in line with things as they are, they do things that +are for our good, but if they are false, we often discover that they +have an altogether unsuspected power for harm and are capable of +astonishing results, results which have no apparent relation to the +ideas responsible for them and which are, therefore, laid to physical +causes. Thinking straight, then, becomes a hygienic as well as a +moral duty. + +=Ideas and Emotions.= Ideas do not depend upon themselves for their +driving-power. Life is not a cold intellectual process; it is a vivid +experience, vibrant with feeling and emotion. It therefore happens +that the experiences of life tend to bring ideas and emotions together +and when an idea and an emotion get linked up together, they tend to +stay together, especially if the emotion be intense or the experience +is often repeated. + +The word emotion means outgoing motion, discharging force. This force +is like live steam. An emotion is the driving part of an instinct. It +is the dynamic force, the electric current which supplies the power +for every thought and every action of a human life. + +Man is not a passive creature. The words that describe him are not +passive words. Indeed, it is almost impossible to think about man at +all except in terms of desire, impulse, purpose, action, energy. There +are three things that may be done with energy: First, it may be +frittered away, allowed to leak, to escape. Secondly, it may be locked +up; this results usually in an explosion, a finding of destructive +outlets. Finally, it may be harnessed, controlled, used in beneficent +ways. Health and happiness depend upon which one of the three courses +is taken. + + +CHARACTER AND HEALTH + +Evidently, it is highly important to have a working knowledge of these +emotions and instincts; important to know enough about them and their +purpose to handle them rightly if they do not spontaneously work +together for our best character and health. The problems of character +and the problems of health so overlap that it is impossible to write a +book about nervous disorders which does not at the same time deal with +the principles of character-formation. The laws and mechanisms which +govern the everyday life of the normal person are the same laws and +mechanisms which make the nervous person ill. As Boris Sidis puts it, +"The pathological is the normal out of place." The person who is +master of himself, working together as a harmonious whole, is stronger +in every way than the person whose forces are divided. Given a little +self-knowledge, the nervous invalid often becomes one of the most +successful members of society,--to use the word successful in the best +sense. + +=It Pays to Know.= To be educated is to have the right idea and the +right emotion in the right place. To be sure, some people have so well +learned the secret of poise that they do not have to study the why nor +the how. Intuition often far outruns knowledge. It would be foolish +indeed to suggest that only the person versed in psychological lore is +skilled in the art of living. Psychology is not life; it can make no +claim to furnish the motive nor the power for successful living, for +it is not faith, nor hope, nor love; but it tries to point the way and +to help us fulfil conditions. There is no more reason why the average +man should be unaware of the instincts or the subconscious mind, than +that he should be ignorant of germs or of the need of fresh air. + +If it be argued that character and health are both inherently +by-products of self-forgetful service, rather than of painstaking +thought, we answer that this is true, but that there can be no +self-forgetting when things have gone too far wrong. At such times it +pays to look in, if we can do it intelligently, in order that we may +the sooner get our eyes off ourselves and look out. The pursuit of +self-knowledge is not a pleasurable pastime but simply a valuable +means to an end. + + +KNOWING OUR MACHINE + +=Counting on Ourselves.= Knowing our machine makes us better able to +handle it. For, after all, each of us is, in many ways, very like a +piece of marvelous and complicated machinery. For one thing, our +minds, as well as our bodies, are subject to uniform laws upon which +we can depend. We are not creatures of chaos; under certain conditions +we can count on ourselves. Freedom does not mean freedom from the +reign of law. It means that, to a certain extent, we can make use of +the laws. Psychic laws are as susceptible to investigation, +verification, and use as are any laws in the physical world. Each +person is so much the center of his own life that it is very easy for +him to fall into the way of thinking that he is different from all the +rest of the world. It is a healthful experience for him to realize +that every person he meets is made on the same principles, impelled by +the same forces, and fighting much the same fight. Since the laws of +the mental world are uniform, we can count on them as aids toward +understanding other people and understanding ourselves. + +="Intelligent Scrutiny versus Morbid Introspection."= It helps +wonderfully to be able to look at ourselves in an objective, +impersonal way. We are likely to be overcome by emotion, or swept by +vague longings which seem to have no meaning and which, just because +they are bound up so closely with our own ego, are not looked at but +are merely felt. Unknown forces are within us, pulling us this way and +that, until sometimes we who should be masters are helpless slaves. +One great help toward mastery and one long step toward serenity is a +working-knowledge of the causes and an impersonal interest in the +phenomena going on within. Introspection is a morbid, emotional +fixation on self, until it takes on this quality of objectivity. What +Cabot calls the "sin of impersonality" is a grievous sin when +directed toward another person, but most of us could stand a good deal +of ingrowing impersonality without any harm. + +The fact that the human machine can run itself without a hitch in the +majority of cases is witness to its inherent tendency toward health. +People were living and living well through all the centuries before +the science of psychology was formulated. But not with all people do +things run so smoothly. There were demoniacs in Bible times and +neurotics in the Middle Ages, as there are nervous invalids and +half-well people to-day. Psychology has a real contribution to make, +and in recent years its lessons have been put into language which the +average man can understand. + +Psychology is not merely interested in abstract terms with long names. +It is no longer absorbed merely in states of consciousness taken +separately and analyzed abstractly. The newer functional psychology is +increasingly interested in the study of real persons, their purposes +and interests, what they feel and value, and how they may learn to +realize their highest aspirations. It is about ordinary people, as +they think and act, in the kitchen, on the street cars, at the +bargain-counter, people in crowds and alone, mothers and their babies, +little children at play, young girls with their lovers, and all the +rest of human life. It is the science of _you_, and as such it can +hardly help being interesting. + +While psychology deals with such topics as the subconscious mind, the +instincts, the laws of habit, and association of ideas and suggestion, +it is after all not so much an academic as a practical question. These +forces govern the thought you are thinking at this moment, the way you +will feel a half-hour from now, the mood you will be in to-morrow, the +friends you will make and the profession you will choose, besides +having a large share in the health or ill-health of your body in the +meantime. + + +SUMMARY + +Perhaps it would be well before going farther to summarize what we +have been saying. Here in a nutshell is the kernel of the subject: + +Disease may be caused by physical or by psychic forces. A "nervous" +disorder is not a physical but a psychic disease. It is caused not by +lack of energy but by misdirected energy; not by overwork or +nerve-depletion, but by misconception, emotional conflict, repressed +instincts, and buried memories. Seventy-five per cent. of all cases of +ill-health are due to psychic causes, to disjointed thinking rather +than to a disjointed spine. Wherefore, let us learn to think right. + +In outline form, the trouble in a neurosis may be stated something +like this: + +Lack of adaptation to the social environment--caused by + Lack of harmony within the personality--caused by + Misdirected energy--caused by + Inappropriate emotions--caused by + Wrong ideas or ignorance. + +Working backward, the cure naturally would be: + +Right ideas--resulting in + Appropriate emotions--resulting in + Redirected energy--resulting in + Harmony--resulting in + Readjustment to the environment. + +If the reader is beginning to feel somewhat bewildered by these +general statements, let him take heart. So far we have tried merely to +suggest the outline of the whole problem, but we shall in the future +be more specific. Nervous troubles, which seem so simple, are really +involved with the whole mechanism of mental life and can in no way be +understood except as these mechanisms are understood. We have hinted +at some of the causes of "nerves," but we cannot give a real +explanation until we explain the forces behind them. These forces may +at first seem a bit abstract, or a bit remote from the main theme, but +each is essential to the story of nerves and to the understanding of +the more practical chapters in Part III. + +As in a Bernard Shaw play, the preface may be the most important part +of this "drama of nerves." Nor is the figure too far-fetched, +because, strange as it may seem, every neurosis is in essence a drama. +It has its conflict, its villain, and its victim, its love-story, its +practical joke, its climax, and its denouement. Sometimes the play +goes on forever with no solution, but sometimes psychotherapy steps in +as the fairy god-mother, to release the victim, outwit the villain, +and bring about the live-happily-ever-after ending. + + + + +PART II: "HOW THE WHEELS GO ROUND" + + + + +CHAPTER III + +_In which we find a goodly inheritance_ + +THE STORY OF THE INSTINCTS + +EACH IN HIS OWN TONGUE + + A fire mist and a planet, + A crystal and a cell, + A jelly-fish and a saurian, + And caves where cavemen dwell; + Then a sense of law and beauty, + And a face turned from the clod; + Some call it evolution + And others call it God.[4] + + +If we begin at the beginning, we have to go back a long way to get our +start, for the roots of our family tree reach back over millions of +years. "In the beginning--God." These first words of the book of +Genesis must be, in spirit at least, the first words of any discussion +of life. We know now, however, that when God made man, He did not +complete His masterpiece at one sitting, but instead devised a plan by +which the onward urge within and the environment without should act +and interact until from countless adaptations a human being was made. + +[Footnote 4: William Herbert Carruth.] + +As the late Dr. Putnam of Harvard University says, "We stand as the +representative of a Creative Energy that expressed itself first in far +simpler forms of life and finally in the form of human instincts."[5] +And again: "The choices and decisions of the organisms whose lives +prepared the way through eons of time for ours, present themselves to +us as instincts."[6] + +[Footnote 5: Putnam: _Human Motives_, p. 32.] + +[Footnote 6: Putnam: _Human Motives_, p. 18.] + + +INTRODUCING THE INSTINCTS + +=Back of Our Dispositions.= What is it that makes the baby jump at a +noise? What energizes a man when you tell him he is a liar? What makes +a young girl blush when you look at her, or a youth begin to take +pains with his necktie? What makes men go to war or build tunnels or +found hospitals or make love or save for a home? What makes a woman +slave for her children, or give her life for them if need be? +"Instinct" you say, and rightly. Back of every one of these well-known +human tendencies is a specific instinct or group of instincts. The +story of the life of man and the story of the mind of man must begin +with the instincts. Indeed, any intelligent approach to human life, +whether it be that of the mother, the teacher, the preacher, the +social worker or the neurologist, leads back inevitably to the +instincts as the starting-point of understanding. But what is +instinct? + +We are apt to be a bit hazy on that point, as we are on any +fundamental thing with which we intimately live. We reckon on these +instinctive tendencies every hour of the day, but as we are not used +to labeling them, it may help in the very beginning of our discussion +to have a list before our eyes. Here, then, is a list of the +fundamental tendencies of the human race and the emotions which drive +them to fulfilment. + +THE SPECIFIC INSTINCTS AND THEIR EMOTIONS (AFTER MCDOUGALL) + +_Instinct_ _Emotion_ + +Nutritive Instinct Hunger +Flight Fear +Repulsion Disgust +Curiosity Wonder +Self-assertion Positive Self-feeling (Elation) +Self-abasement Negative Self-feeling (Subjection) +Gregariousness Emotion unnamed +Acquisition Love of Possession +Construction Emotion unnamed +Pugnacity Anger +Reproductive Instinct Emotion unnamed +Parental Instinct Tender Emotion + +These are the fundamental tendencies or dispositions with which every +human being is endowed as he comes into the world. Differing in degree +in different individuals, they unite in varying proportions to form +various kinds of dispositions, but are in greater or less degree the +common property of us all. + +There flows through the life of every creature a steady stream of +energy. Scientists have not been able to decide on a descriptive term +for this all-important life-force. It has been variously called +"libido," "vital impulse" or "elan vital," "the spirit of life," +"horme," and "creative energy." The chief business of this life-force +seems to be the preservation and development of the individual and the +preservation and development of the race. In the service of these two +needs have grown up these habit-reactions which we call instincts. The +first ten of our list belong under the heading of self-preservation +and the last two under that of race-preservation. As hunger is the +most urgent representative of the self-preservative group, and as +reproduction and parental care make up the race-preservative group, +some scientists refer all impulses to the two great instincts of +nutrition and sex, using these words in the widest sense. However, it +will be useful for our purpose to follow McDougall's classification +and to examine individually the various tendencies of the two groups. + +=In Debt to Our Ancestors.= An instinct is the result of the +experience of the race, laid in brain and nerve-cells ready for use. +It is a gift from our ancestors, an inheritance from the education of +the age-long line of beings who have gone before. In the struggle for +existence, it has been necessary for the members of the race to feed +themselves, to run away from danger, to fight, to herd together, to +reproduce themselves, to care for their young, and to do various other +things which make for the well-being or preservation of the race. The +individuals that did these things at the right time survived and +passed on to their offspring an inherited tendency to this kind of +reaction. McDougall defines an instinct as "an inherited or innate +psycho-physical disposition which determines its possessor to perceive +or pay attention to objects of a certain class, to experience an +emotional excitement of a particular quality upon perceiving such an +object, and to act in regard to it in a particular manner, or at least +to experience an impulse to such action." This is just what an +instinct is,--an inherited disposition to notice, to feel, and to want +to act in certain ways in certain situations. It is the something +which makes us act when we cannot explain why, the something that goes +deeper than reason, and that links us to all other human +beings,--those who live to-day and those who have gone before. + +It is true that East is East and West is West, but the two do meet in +the common foundation of our human nature. The likeness between men +and between races is far greater and far more fundamental than the +differences can ever be. + +=Firing Up the Engine.= Purpose is writ large across the face of an +instinct, and that purpose is always toward action. Whenever a +situation arises which demands instantaneous action, the instinct is +the means of securing it. Planted within the creature is a tendency +which makes it perceive and feel and act in the appropriate way. It +will be noticed that there are three distinct parts to the process, +corresponding to intellect, emotion, will. The initial intellectual +part makes us sensitive to certain situations, makes us recognize an +object as meaningful and significant, and waves the flag for the +emotion; the emotion fires up the engine, pulls the levers all over +the body that release its energy and get it ready for action, and +pushes the button that calls into the mind an intense, almost +irresistible desire or impulse to act. Once aroused, the emotion and +the impulse are not to be changed. In man or beast, in savage or +savant, the intense feeling, the marked bodily changes, and the +yearning for action are identical and unchangeable. The brakes can be +put on and the action suppressed, but in that case the end of the +whole process is defeated. Could anything be plainer than that an +instinct and its emotion were never intended to be aroused except in +situations in which their characteristic action is to be desired? An +emotion is the hot part of an instinct and exists solely for securing +action. If all signs of the emotion are to be suppressed, all +expression denied, why the emotion? + +But although the emotion and the impulse, once aroused, are beyond +control, there is yet one part of the instinct that is meant to be +controlled. The initial or receptive portion, that which notices a +situation, recognizes it as significant, and sends in the signal for +action, can be trained to discrimination. This is where reason comes +in. If the situation calls for flight, fear is in order; if it calls +for fight, anger is in order; if it calls for examination, wonder is +in order; but if it calls for none of these things, reason should show +some discrimination and refuse to call up the emotion. + +=The Right of Way.= There is a law that comes to the aid of reason in +this dilemma and that is the "law of the common path."[7] By this is +meant that man is capable of but one intense emotion at a time. No one +can imagine himself strenuously making love while he is shaken by an +agony of fear, or ravenously eating while he is in a passion of rage. +The stronger emotion gets the right of way, obtains control of mental +and bodily machinery, and leaves no room for opposite states. If the +two emotions are not antagonistic, they may blend together to form a +compound emotion, but if in the nature of the case such a blending is +impossible, the weaker is for the time being forgotten in the +intensity of the stronger. "The expulsive power of a new affection" is +not merely a happy phrase; it is a fact in every day life. The +problem, then, resolves itself into ways of making the desirable +emotion the stronger, of learning how to form the habit of giving it +the head start and the right of way. In our chapter on "Choosing the +Emotions," we shall find that much depends on building up the right +kind of sentiments, or the permanent organization of instincts around +ideas. However, we must first look more closely at the separate +instincts to acquaint ourselves with the purpose and the ways of each, +and to discover the nature of the forces with which we have to deal. + +[Footnote 7: Sherrington: _Integrative Action of the Nervous System_.] + + +I THE SELF-PRESERVATIVE INSTINCTS + +=Hunger.= Hunger is the most pressing desire of the egoistic or +self-preserving impulse. The yearning for food and the impulse to seek +and eat it are aroused organically within the body and are behind much +of the activity of every type of life. As the impulse is so familiar, +and its promptings are so little subject to psychic control, it seems +unnecessary to do more than mention its importance. + +=Flight and Fear.= All through the ages the race has been subject to +injury. Species has been pitted against species, individual against +individual. He who could fight hardest or run fastest has survived and +passed his abilities on to his offspring. Not all could be strongest +for fight, and many species have owed their existence to their ability +to run and to know when to run. Thus it is that one of the strongest +and most universal tendencies is the instinct for flight, and its +emotion, fear. "Fear is the representation of injury and is born of +the innumerable injuries which have been inflicted in the course of +evolution."[8] Some babies are frightened if they are held too +loosely, even though they have never known a fall. Some persons have +an instinctive fear of cats, a left-over from the time when the race +needed to flee from the tiger and others of the cat family. Almost +every one, no matter in what state of culture, fears the unknown +because the race before him has had to be afraid of that which was not +familiar. + +[Footnote 8: Crile: _Origin and Nature of the Emotions_.] + +The emotion of fear is well known, but its purpose is not so often +recognized. An emotion brings about internal changes, visceral changes +they are called, which enable the organism to act on the emotion,--to +accomplish its object. There is only so much energy available at a +given moment, stored up in the brain cells, ready for use. In such an +emergency as flight every ounce of energy is needed. The large muscles +used in running must have a great supply of extra energy. The heart +and lungs must be speeded up in order to provide oxygen and take care +of extra waste products. The special senses of sight and hearing must +be sensitized. Digestion and intestinal peristalsis must be stopped in +order to save energy. No person could by conscious thought accomplish +all these things. How, then, are they brought about? + +=Internal Laboratories.= In the wonderful internal laboratory of the +body there are little glands whose business it is to secrete chemicals +for just these emergencies. When an object is sighted which arouses +fear, the brain cells flash instantaneous messages over the body, +among others to the supra-renal glands or adrenals, just over the +kidneys, and to the thyroid gland in the neck. Instantly these glands +pour forth adrenalin and thyroid secretion into the blood, and the +body responds. Blood pressure rises; brain cells speed up; the liver +pours forth glycogen, its ready-to-burn fuel; sweat-glands send forth +cold perspiration in order to regulate temperature; blood is pumped +out from stomach and intestines to the external muscles. As we have +seen, the body as a whole can respond to just one stimulus at a time. +The response to this stimulus has the right of way. The whole body is +integrated, set for this one thing. When fear holds the switchboard no +other messages are allowed on the line, and the creature is ready for +flight. + +But after flight comes concealment with the opposite bodily need, the +need for absolute silence. This is why we sometimes get the opposite +result. The heart seems to stop beating, the breath ceases, the limbs +refuse to move, all because our ancestors needed to hide after they +had run, and because we are in a very real way a part of them. + +=Old-Fashioned Fear.= There is one passage from Dr. Crile's book which +so admirably sums up these points that it seems worth while to insert +it at length. + + We fear not in our hearts alone, not in our brains alone, not in + our viscera alone--fear influences every organ and tissue. Each + organ or tissue is stimulated or inhibited according to its use + or hindrance in the physical struggle for existence. By thus + concentrating all or most of the nerve force on the + nerve-muscular mechanism for defense, a greater physical power is + developed. Hence it is that under the stimulus of fear animals + are able to perform preternatural feats of strength. For the same + reason, the exhaustion following fear will be increased as the + powerful stimulus of fear drains the cup of nervous energy even + though no visible action may result.... Perhaps the most striking + difference between man and animals lies in the greater control + which man has gained over his primitive instinctive reactions. As + compared with the entire duration of organic evolution, man came + down from his arboreal abode and assumed his new role of + increased domination over the physical world but a moment ago. + And now, though sitting at his desk in command of the complicated + machinery of civilization, when he fears a business catastrophe + his fear is manifested in the terms of his ancestral physical + battle in the struggle for existence. He cannot fear + intellectually, he cannot fear dispassionately, he fears with all + his organs, and the same + organs are stimulated and inhibited as if, instead of its being a + battle of credit, or position, or of honor, it were a physical + battle with teeth and claws.... Nature has but one means of + response to fear, and whatever its cause the phenomena are always + the same--always physical.[9] + +[Footnote 9: Crile: _Origin and Nature of the Emotions_, p. 60 ff.] + + * * * * * + +The moral is as plain as day: Learn to call up fear only when speedy +legs are needed, not a cool head or a comfortable digestion. Fear is a +costly proceeding, an emergency measure like a fire-alarm, to be used +only when the occasion is urgent enough to demand it. How often it is +misused and how large a part it plays in nervous symptoms, both mental +and physical, will appear more clearly in later chapters. + +=Repulsion and Disgust.= Akin to the instinct of flight is that of +repulsion, which impels us, instead of fleeing, to thrust the object +away. It leads us to reject from the mouth noxious and disgusting +objects and to shrink from slimy, creepy creatures, and has of course +been highly useful in protecting the race from poisons and snakes. It +still operates in the tendency to put away from us those things, +mental or physical, toward which we feel aversion or disgust. Recent +psychological discoveries have revealed how largely a neurosis +consists in putting away from us--out of consciousness,--whatever we +do not wish to recognize, and so it happens that disgust plays an +unexpected part in nervous disorders. + +=Curiosity and Wonder.= Fortunately for the race, it has not had to +wait until different features of the environment prove to be helpful +or harmful. There is an instinct which urges forward to exploration +and discovery and which enables the creature not only to adapt itself +to the environment but to learn how to adapt the environment to +itself. This is the instinct of curiosity. It is the impulse back of +all advance in science, religion, and intellectual achievement of +every kind, and is sometimes called "intellectual feeling." + +=Self-Assertion.= It goes almost without saying that one of the +strongest and most important impulses of mankind is the instinct of +self-assertion; it often gets us into trouble, but it is also behind +every effort toward developed character. At its lowest level +self-assertion manifests itself in the strutting of the peacock, the +prancing of the horse, and the "See how big I am," of the small boy. +At its highest level, when combined with self-consciousness and the +moral sentiments acquired from society and developed into the +self-regarding sentiment, it is responsible for most of our ideas of +right, our conception of what is and what is not compatible with our +self-respect. + +=Self-Abasement.= Self-assertion is aroused primarily by the presence +of others and especially of those to whom we feel in any way +superior, but when the presence of others makes us feel small, when we +want to hide or keep in the background, we are being moved by the +opposite instinct of self-abasement and negative self-feeling. It may +be either the real or the fancied superiority of the spectators that +arouses this feeling,--their wisdom or strength, beauty or good +clothes. Sometimes, as in stage-fright, it is their numerical +superiority. Bashfulness is the struggle between the two +self-instincts, assertion and abasement. Our impulse for self-display +urges us on to make a good impression, while our feeling of +inferiority impels us to get away unnoticed. Hence the struggle and +the painful emotion. + +=Gregariousness.= Man has been called a gregarious animal. That is, +like the animals, he likes to run with his kind, and feels a +pronounced aversion to prolonged isolation. It is this +"herd-instinct," too, which makes man so extremely sensitive to the +opinions of the society in which he lives. Because of this impulse to +go with the crowd, ideas received through education are accepted as +imperative and are backed up by all the force of the instinct of +self-regard. When the teachings of society happen to run counter to +the laws of our being, the possibilities of conflict are indeed +great.[10] + +[Footnote 10: For a thorough discussion of the importance of this +instinct, see Trotter's _Instincts of the Herd in Peace and War_.] + +=Acquisition.= Another fundamental disposition in both animals and +men is the instinct for possession, the instinct whose function it is +to provide for future needs. Squirrels and birds lay up nuts for the +winter; the dog hides his bone where only he can find it. Children +love to have things for their "very own," and almost invariably go +through the hoarding stage in which stamps or samples or bits of +string are hoarded for the sake of possession, quite apart from their +usefulness or value. Much of the training of children consists in +learning what is "mine" and what is "thine," and respect for the +property of others can develop only out of a sense of one's own +property rights. + +=Construction.= There is an innate satisfaction in making +something,--from a doll-dress to a poem,--and this satisfaction rests +on the impulse to construct, to fashion something with our own hands +or our own brain. The emotion accompanying this instinct is too +indefinite to have a name but it is nevertheless a real one and plays +a large part in the sense of power which results from the satisfaction +of good work well done. Later it will be seen how closely related is +this impulse to the creative instinct of reproduction and how useful +it can be in drawing off the surplus energy of that much denied +instinct. + +=Pugnacity and Anger.= What is it that makes us angry? A little +thought will convince us that the thing which arouses our fury is not +the sight of any special object, but the blocking of any one of the +other instincts. Watch any animal at bay when its chance for flight +has gone. The timidest one will turn and fight with every sign of +fury. Watch a mother when her young are threatened,--bear, or cat or +lion or human. Fear has no place then. It is entirely displaced by +anger over the balking of the maternal instinct of protection. +Strictly speaking, pugnacity belongs among the instincts neither of +self-preservation nor of race-preservation, but is a special device +for reinforcing both groups. + +As fear supplies the energy for running, so anger fits us for +fight,--and for nothing but fight. The mechanism is almost identical +with that of fear. Brain and liver, adrenals and thyroid are the +means, but the emotion presses the button and releases the energy, +stopping all digestion and energizing all combat-muscles. The blood is +flooded with fuel and with substances which, if not used, are harmful +to the body. We were never meant to be angry without fighting. The +habit of self-control has its distinct advantages, but it is hard on +the body, which was patterned before self-control came into fashion. +The wise man, once he is aroused, lets off steam at the woodpile or on +a long, vigorous walk. He probably does not say to himself that he is +a motor animal integrated for fight and that he must get rid of +glycogen and adrenalin and thyroid secretion. He only knows that he +feels better "on the move." + +The wiser man does not let himself get angry in the first place unless +the situation calls for fight. However, the fight need not be a +hand-to-hand combat with one's fellow man. William James has pointed +out that there is a "moral equivalent for war," and that the energy of +this instinct may be used to reinforce other impulses and help +overcome obstacles of all sorts. A good deal of the business man's +zest, the engineer's determination, and the reformer's zeal spring +from the fight-instinct used in the right way. As James, Cannon, and +others have pointed out, the way to end war may be to employ man's +instinct of pugnacity in fighting the universal enemies of the +race--fire, flood, famine, disease, and the various social +evils--rather than let it spend its force in war between nations. Even +our sports may be offshoots of the fight-instinct, for McDougall holds +that the play-tendency has its root in the instinct of rivalry, a +modified form of pugnacity. Evidently fighting-blood is a useful +inheritance, even to-day, and rightly directed is a necessary part of +a complete and forceful personality. + +This, then, completes the list of self-preservative instincts, those +which are commonly called egoistic and which have been given us for +the maintenance of our own individual personal lives. But our +endowment includes another set of impulses which are no less important +and which must be reckoned with if human conduct is to be understood. + + + + +CHAPTER IV + +_In which we learn more about ourselves_ + +THE STORY OF THE INSTINCTS (Continued) + +II. THE RACE-PRESERVATIVE INSTINCTS + + +=Looking beyond Ourselves.= We sometimes speak of self-preservation as +though it were the only law of life, while as a matter of fact it is +but half the story. Nature has seen to it that there shall be planted +in every living creature an innate urge toward the larger life of the +race. Although the creature may never give a conscious thought to the +welfare of the race, he still bears within himself a set of instincts +which have as their end and aim, not the individual at all, but +society as a whole, and the life of generations that are to come. He +is bigger than he knows. Although he may have no notion why he feels +and acts as he does, and although he may pervert the purpose for his +own selfish end, he is continually being moved by the mighty impulse +of the race-life, an impulse which often outrivals the desire I or his +own personal existence. The craving to reproduce ourselves and the +craving to cherish and protect our young are among the most dynamic +forces in life. The two desires are so closely bound together that +they are often spoken of as one under the name of the sex-instinct, or +the family instincts. Let us look first at that part of the yearning +which urges toward perpetuating our own life in offspring. + +=Watching Nature Work.= It is wonderful, indeed, to watch Nature in +the long process of Evolution, as she adapts her methods to the +growing complexity of the organism. With a variety and ingenuity of +means, but always with the same steady purpose, she works from the +lowest levels,--where there is no true reproduction, only +multiplication by division,--on through the beginning of reproduction +proper, where a single parent produces the offspring; then on to the +level where it takes two parents of different structure to produce a +new organism, and sex-life begins. At first Nature does not even +demand that father and mother shall come near each other. In the +water, the female of this type lays an egg, and the male, guided by +his instinct, swims to it and deposits his fertilizing fluid. In plant +life, bird and bee, attracted by wonderfully planned perfumes and +color and honey, are called in to carry the pollen from male to female +cell. + +But it is when we come to the highest level that we find even more +subtle ways planned to accomplish the desired end. Here we enter the +realm of individual initiative, for it is not now enough to leave to +external forces the joining of the two life-elements. In order to make +a new individual, father and mother must be drawn together, and so +there enters into the situation a personal relationship with all that +that implies. Because Nature has had to provide ways of drawing +individuals to one another, she has put into the higher types of life +the power of mutual attraction,--a power which in man, the highest of +all types, is responsible for many outgrowths that seem far removed +from the original purpose. + +=The Love-Motif.= On the one hand, there is the persistent desire to +be attractive, which manifests itself in the subtlest ways. How many +of the yearnings and activities of human life have their roots in this +ancient and honorable desire! The love of pretty clothes,--however it +may seem to be motivated and however it may be complicated by other +motives,-draws its energy, fundamentally, from the same need that +provides the gay plumage and limpid song of the bird or the painted +wings of the butterfly. + +On the other hand, there is the capability of being attracted, with +all the personal relationships which spring from the power of admiring +and loving another person. The interest in others does not expend its +whole force on its primary objects,--mate and children. It flows out +into all human relationships, developing all the possibilities of +loving which mean so much in human life; the love of man for man and +woman for woman, as well as mutual love of man and woman. A force like +this, once planted, especially in the higher types of life, does not +spend all its energies in its main trunk. It sends out branches in +many directions, bearing by-products which are rich in value for all +of life. + +Many of our richest relationships, our best impulses, and our most +firmly fixed social habits spring from the family instincts of +reproduction and parental care. The social life of our young people, +so well calculated to bring young men and women together; all the +beauty of family life and, as we shall later see, all the broader +benevolent activities for society in general, are energized by the +same love-instincts which form so large a part of human nature. + + +LEARNING TO LOVE + +=A Four-Grade School.= It is impossible to watch the growth of the +love-life of a human being, to trace its development from babyhood up +to its culmination in mating and parenthood, without a sense of wonder +at the steady purpose behind it all. We used to believe that the love +for the young girl that suddenly blooms forth in the callow youth was +an entirely new affair, something suddenly planted in him as he +developed into manhood; but now we know, thanks to the uncovering of +human nature by the painstaking investigations of the psycho-analytic +school of psychologists, that the seeds of the love-life are planted, +not in puberty, but with the beginning of life itself. Looked at in +one way, all infancy and childhood are a preparation, a training of +the love-instinct which is to be ready at the proper time to find its +mate and play its part in the perpetuation of the race. Nature begins +early. As she plants in the tiny baby all the organs that shall be +needed during its lifetime, so she plants the rudiments of all the +impulses and tendencies that shall later be developed into the +full-grown instincts. There have been found to be four periods in the +love-life of the growing child, three of them preparatory steps +leading up to maturity; periods in which the main current of love is +directed respectively toward self, parents, comrades, and finally +toward lover or mate. + +=Like Narcissus.= In the first stage, the baby's interest is in his +own body. He is getting acquainted with himself, and he soon finds +that his body contains possibilities of pleasurable sensations which +may be repeated by the proper stimulation. Besides the +hunger-satisfaction that it brings, the act of sucking is pleasurable +in itself, and so the baby begins to suck his thumb or his quilts or +his rattle. Later, this impulse to stimulate the nerves about the +mouth finds its satisfaction in kissing, and still later it plays a +definite part in the wooing process; but at first the child is +self-sufficient and finds his pleasure entirely within himself. Other +regions of the body yield similar pleasure. We often find a tiny child +rubbing his genital organs or his thighs or taking exaggerated +pleasure in riding on someone's foot in order to stimulate these +nerves, which he has discovered at first merely by chance. When he +begins to run around, he loves to exhibit his own body, to go about +naked. None of this is naughtiness or perversion; it is only Nature's +preparation of trends that she will later need to use. The child is +normally and naturally in love with himself.[11] But he must not +linger too long in this stage. None of the channels which his +life-force is cutting must be dug too deep, else in later life they +will offer lines of least resistance which may, on occasion, invite +illness or perversion. + +[Footnote 11: This is the stage which is technically known as +auto-eroticism or self-love.] + +=In Love with His Family.= Presently Nature pries the child loose from +love of himself and directs part of his interests to people outside +himself. Before he is a year old, part of his love is turned to +others. In this stage it is natural that at first his affection should +center on those who make up his home circle,--his parents and other +members of the household. Even in this early choice we see a +foreshadowing of his future need. The normal little boy is especially +fond of his mother, and the normal little girl of her father. Not all +the love goes to the parent of the opposite sex, but if the child be +normal, a noticeably larger part finds its way in that direction. +Observing parents can often see unmistakable signs of jealousy: toward +the parent of the same sex, or the brother or sister of the same sex. +The little boy who sleeps with his mother while his father is away, or +who on these occasions gets all the attention and all the petting he +craves, is naturally eager to perpetuate this state of affairs. Many a +small boy has been heard to say that he wished his father would go +away and stay all the time,--to the horror of the parents who do not +understand. All this is natural enough, but it is not to be +encouraged. The pattern of the father or the mother must not be +stamped too deep in the impressionable child-mind. Too little love and +sympathy are bad, leading to repression and a morbid turning in of the +love-force; but too much petting, too many caresses are just as bad. +Sentimental self-indulgence on the part of the parents has been +repeatedly proved to be the cause of many a later illness for the +child. As the right kind of family love and comradeship, the kind that +leads to freedom and self-dependence, is among the highest forces in +life, so the wrong kind is among the worst. Parents and their +substitutes--nurses, sisters, and brothers--are but temporary +stopping-places for the growing love, stepping-stones to later +attachments which are biologically more necessary. The small boy who +lets himself be coddled and petted too long by his adoring relatives, +who does not shake off their caresses and run away to the other boys, +is doomed to failure, and, as we shall later see, probably to +illness.[12] + +[Footnote 12: One of the best discussions of this theme is found in +the chapter "The Only or Favorite Child," by A.A. Brill, in +_Psychoanalysis_.] + +In the later infantile period, the child, besides wanting to exhibit +his own body, shows marked interest in looking at the bodies of +others, and marked curiosity on sex-questions in general. He +particularly wants to know "where babies come from." If his questions +are unfortunately met by embarrassment or laughing evasion, or by +obvious lying about the stork or the doctor or the angels, his +curiosity is only whetted, and he comes to the very natural conclusion +that all matters of sex are sinful, disgusting, and indecent, and to +be investigated only on the sly. This conception cannot be brought +into harmony with the unconscious mental processes arising from his +race-instincts nor with his instinctive sense that "whatever is is +right." The resulting conflict in some four-year-old children is +surprisingly intense. Astonished indeed would many parents be if they +knew what was going on inside the heads of their "innocent" little +children; not "bad" things, but pathetic things which a little candor +would have avoided. + +Alongside the rudimentary impulses of showing and looking, there is +developed another set of trends which Nature needs to use later on, +the so-called sadistic and masochistic impulses, the desire to +dominate and master and even to inflict pain, and its opposite impulse +which takes pleasure in yielding and submitting to mastery. These +traits, harking back to the time when the male needed to capture by +force, are of course much more evident in adolescence and especially +in love-making, but have their beginning in childhood, as many a +mother of cruel children knows to her sorrow. In adolescence, when +sex-differentiation is much more marked, the dominating impulse is +stronger in the boy and the yielding impulse in the girl; but in +little children the differentiation has not yet begun. + +=Gang and Chum.= At about four or five years the child leaves the +infantile stage of development, with its self-love and its intense +devotion to parents and their substitutes. He begins to be especially +interested in playmates of his own sex, to care more for the opinions +of the gang--or if it be a little girl, of the chum--than for those of +the parents. The life-force is leading him on to the next step in his +education, freeing him little by little from a too-hampering +attachment to his family. This does not mean that he does not love +his father and mother. It means only that some of his love is being +turned toward the rest of the world, that he may be an independent, +socially useful man. + +This period between infancy and puberty is known as the latency +period. All interest in sex disappears, repressed by the spontaneously +developing sense of shame and modesty and by the impact of education +and social disapproval. The child forgets that he was ever curious on +sex-matters and lets his curiosity turn into other, more acceptable +channels. + +=The Mating-Time.= We are familiar with the changes that take place at +puberty. We laugh at the girl who, throwing off her tom-boy ways, +suddenly wants her skirts let down and her hair done up. We laugh at +the boy who suddenly leaves off being a rowdy, and turns into a +would-be dandy. We scold because this same boy and girl who have +always been so "sweet and tractable" become, almost overnight, surly +and cantankerous, restive under authority and impatient of family +restraint. We should neither laugh nor scold, if we understood. Nature +is succeeding in her purpose. She has led the young life on from self +to parents, from parents to gang or chum, and now she is trying to +lead it away from all its earlier attachments, to set it free for its +final adventure in loving. The process is painful, so painful that it +sometimes fails of accomplishment. In any case, the strain is +tremendous, needing all the wisdom and understanding which the family +has to offer. It is no easy task for any person to free himself from +the sense of dependence and protection, and the shielding love that +have always been his; to weigh anchors that are holding him to the +past and to start out on the voyage alone. + +At this time of change, the chemistry of the body plays an important +part in the development of the mental traits; all half-developed +tendencies are given power through the maturing of the sex-glands, +which bind them into an organization ready for their ultimate purpose. +The current is now turned on, and the machinery, which has been +furnished from the beginning, is ready for its task. After a few false +starts in the shape of "puppy love," the mature instinct, if it be +successful, seeks until from among the crowd it finds its mate. It has +graduated from the training-school and is ready for life. + + +CIVILIZATION'S PROBLEM + +=When Nature's Plans Fall Through.= We have been describing the normal +course of affairs. We know that all too often the normal is not +achieved. Inner forces or outer circumstances too often conspire to +keep the young man or the young woman from the culmination toward +which everything has been moving. If the life-force cannot liberate +itself from the old family grooves to forge ahead into new channels, +or if economic demands or other conditions make postponement +necessary, then marriage is not possible. All the glandular secretions +and internal stimuli have been urging on to the final consummation, +developing physical and emotional life for an end that does not come; +or if it does come, is not sufficient to satisfy the demands of the +age-old instinct which for millions of years knew no restraint. In any +case, man finds himself, and woman herself, face to face with a +pressing problem, none the less pressing because it is in most cases +entirely unrecognized. + +=Blundering Instincts.= The older a person is, the more fixed are his +habits. Now, an instinct is a race-habit and represents the +crystallized reactions of a past that is old. Whatever has been done +over and over again, millions of times, naturally becomes fixed, +automatic, tending to conserve itself in its old ways, to resist any +change and to act as it has always acted. This conserves energy and +works well so long as conditions remain the same. But if for any +reason there comes a change, things are likely to go wrong. By just so +far as things are different, an automatic habit becomes a handicap +instead of a help. + +This having to act under changed conditions is exactly the trouble +with the reproductive instinct. Under civilization, conditions have +changed but the instinct has not. It is trying to act as it always +has acted, but civilized man wills otherwise. The change that has come +is not in the physical, external environment, but in man himself and +in the social environment which he has created. There is in man an +onward urge toward new and better things. Side by side with the desire +to live as he always has lived, there is a desire to make new +adaptations which are for the advancement of the whole race-life. +Besides the natural wish to take his desires as he finds them, there +is also the wish to modify them and use them for higher and more +socially useful ends. + +As the race has found through long experience that monogamy is to be +preferred to promiscuous mating; that the highest interests of life +are fostered by loyalty to the institution of the family; that the +careful rearing of several children rather than the mere production of +many is in the long run to be desired; and that a single standard of +morality is practicable; so society has established for its members a +standard which is in direct opposition to the immeasurable urge of the +past. To make matters worse, there have at the same time grown up in +many communities a standard of living and an economic competition +which still further limit the size of the family and the satisfaction +of the reproductive impulse. + +=The Perpetual Feud.= There thus arises the strategic struggle +between that which the race has found good in the past and that which +the race finds good in the present. As the older race-experience is +laid in they body and built into the very fiber of the individual, +inherited as an innate impulse, it has become an integral part of +himself, an individual need rather than a social one. On the other +hand, man has, as another innate part of his being, the desire to go +with the herd, to conform to the standards of his fellows, to be what +he has learned society wants him to be. Hence the struggle, insistent, +ever more pressing, between two sets of desires within the man +himself; the feud between the past and the present, between the +natural and the social, between the selfish and the ideal. On one +side, there is the demand for instinctive satisfaction; on the other, +for moral control; on one side the demand for pleasure; on the other, +the demands of reality.[13] + +[Footnote 13: "All the burdens of men or society are caused by the +inadequacies in the association of primal animal emotions with those +mental powers which have been so rapidly developed in +man-kind."--Shaler quoted by Hinkle: Introduction to Jung's +_Psychology of the Unconscious_.] + +Two factors intensify the conflict. In the first place, the older +habits have the head start. Compared with the almost limitless extent +of our past history, our desire for the control of the instincts is +very new indeed. It requires the long look and the right perspective +to understand how very lately we have entered into our new conditions +and how old a habit we are trying to break. In the second place, the +larger part of the stimulus comes from within the body itself. When +studying the other instincts, we saw that the best way to control was +to refuse to stimulate when the situation was not suitable for +discharge. But with the organically aroused sex-instinct there is no +such power of choice. We may fan the flame by the thoughts we think or +the environment we seek, or we may smother the flame until it is out +of sight, but we cannot extinguish it by any act of ours. The issue +has always been too important to be left to the individual. The +stimulation comes, primarily, not by way of the mind but by way of the +body. With this instinct we cannot "stop before we begin," because +Nature has taken the matter out of our hands and begins for us. + + +THE BULWARK WE HAVE BUILT + +With the competing forces so strong and the issues so great, it is not +to be wondered at that society has had to build up a massive bulwark +of public opinion, to establish regulations and fix penalties that are +more stringent than those imposed in any other direction. Nor is it +remarkable that in its effort to protect itself, society has sometimes +made mistakes. + +These blunders seem to lie in two directions. Assuming that it is +nearly impossible for the male to control his instincts, and that, +after all, it does not matter so much whether he does or not, society +has blinked at license in men, and thus has fostered a demoralizing, +anti-social double standard which has broken up countless homes, has +been responsible for the spread of venereal diseases, and has been +among the greatest curses of modern civilization. At the same time +society, in its efforts to maintain its standards for woman, has +taught its children, especially its girls, that anything savoring of +the word "sexual" is sinful, disgusting, and impure. To be sure, very +many women have modified their childish views, but an astonishingly +large number conserve, even in maturity, their warped ideas about the +whole subject of sex. Many a mature woman secretly believes that she, +at least, is not guilty of harboring anything so "vulgar" as a +reproductive instinct, not realizing that if this were so, she would +be, in very truth, a freak of nature. + +Of course, woman is by nature as fully endowed with sex instincts as +is man. Kipling portrays the female of the species as "deadlier than +the male" in that the very framework of her constitution outlines the +one issue for which it was launched,--stanch against any attack which +might endanger the carrying on of life. Feeling the force of this +instinctive urge, she braces herself against precipitancy in response +by what seems almost a negation. + +Just as we lean well in when riding around a corner, in order to keep +ourselves from falling out, so by an "over-compensation" for what is +unconsciously felt to be danger woman increases her feeling of safety +by setting up a taboo on the whole subject of sex. It is time that we +freed our minds from the artificial and perverted attitude toward this +dominant impulse; time to rescue the word "sex" from its implications +of grossness and sensuousness, and to recognize the instinct in its +true light as one of the necessary and holy forces of life, a force +capable of causing great damage, but also holding infinite +possibilities for good if wisely directed. + +Society only gets its members into trouble when, even by implication, +it attempts to deny its natural make-up, and allows little children to +grow up with the false idea that one of their strongest impulses is to +be shunned by them as a thing of shame. We cannot dam back the flood +by building a bulwark of untruth, and then expect the bulwark to hold. + +=Adaptable Energy.= We neither have to give in to our over-insistent +desires nor to deny that they exist. Man has a power of adaptation. +Just when we seem to run up against a dead wall, to face an +irreconcilable conflict, we find a wonderful power of indirect +expression that affords satisfaction to all the innate forces without +doing violence to the ethical standards which have proved so necessary +for the development of character. + +Hunger, which, like the reproductive instinct, is stimulated by the +changing chemistry of the body, can be satisfied only by achieving its +primary purpose, the taking of material food; but the creative impulse +to reproduce oneself possesses a unique ability to spiritualize itself +and expend its energy in other lines of creative endeavor. There seems +to be some sort of close connection between the especially intense +energy of the reproductive instinct and the modes of expression of the +instinct for construction; a connection which makes possible the +utilization of threatening destructive energy by directing it toward +socially valuable work. Just as we harness the mountain stream and use +its wild force to light our cities, or catch the lightning to run our +trolley cars, so we find man and woman--under the right +conditions--easily and naturally switching over the power of their +surplus sex-energy to ends which seem at first only slightly related +to its original aim, but which resemble it in that they too are +self-expressive and creative. If a person is able to express himself +in some real way, to give himself to socially needed work; if he can +reproduce himself intellectually and spiritually in artistic +production, in invention, in literature, in social betterment, he is +drawing on an age-old reservoir of creative energy, and by so doing is +relieving himself of inner tension which would otherwise seek less +beneficent ways of expression. + +The world knew all this intuitively for a long time before it knew it +theoretically. The novelists, who are unconsciously among the best +psychologists, have thoroughly worked the vein. The average man knows +it. "He was disappointed in love," we say, "and we thought he would go +to pieces, but now he has found himself in his work"; or, "She will go +mad if she doesn't find some one who needs her." It is only lately +that science has caught up with intuition, but now the physicians and +psychologists who have had the most intimate and first-hand +acquaintance with the human heart are recognizing, to a man, this +unique power of the love-instinct and its possibilities for creative +work of every sort.[14] + +[Footnote 14: Among those who have shown this connection between the +love-force and creative work are Freud, Jung, Jelliffe, White, Brill, +Jones, Wright, Frink, and the late Dr. Putnam of Harvard University, +who writes: "Freud has never asserted it as his opinion and it +certainly is not mine, that this is the only root from which artistic +expression springs. On the other hand, it is probable that all +artistic productions are partly referable to this source. A close +examination of many of them would enable any one to justify the +opinion that it is a source largely drawn upon."--_Human Motives_. p. +87.] + + +=Higher Levels.= Freud has called this spiritualization of natural +forces by a term borrowed from chemistry. As a solid is "sublimated" +when transformed into a gas, so a primal impulse is said to be +"sublimated" when it is diverted from its original object and made to +serve other ends. By this power of sublimation the little +exhibitionist, who loved to show himself, may become an actor; the +"cruel" boy who loved to dissect animals may become a surgeon; the +sexually curious child may turn his curiosity to other things and +become a scholar; the "born mother," if denied children of her own or +having finished with their upbringing, may take to herself the +children of the city, working for better laws and better care for +needy little ones; the man or woman whose sex-instinct is too strong +to find expression in legitimate, direct ways, may find it a valuable +resource, an increment of energy for creative work, along whatever +line his talent may lie. + +There is no more marvelous provision in all life than this power of +sublimation of one form of energy into another, a provision shadowing +forth almost limitless possibilities for higher adaptations and for +growth in character. As we think of the distance we have already +traveled and the endless possibilities of ever higher excursions of +the life-force, we feel like echoing Paul's words: "He who began a +good work in you will perfect it unto the end." The history of the +past holds great promise for the future. + +=When Sublimation Fails.= But in the meantime we cannot congratulate +ourselves too heartily. Sublimation too often fails. There are too +many nervous wrecks by the way, too many weak indulgers of original +desires, too many repressed, starved lives with no outlet for their +misunderstood yearnings; and, as we shall see, too many people who, in +spite of a big lifework, fail to find satisfaction because of +unnecessary handicaps carried over from their childhood days. +"Society's great task is, therefore, the understanding of the +life-force, its manifold efforts at expression and the way of +attaining this, and to provide as free and expansive ways as possible +for the creative energy which is to work marvelous things for the +future." + +If "the understanding of the life force" is to be available for use, +it must be the property of the average man and woman, the fathers and +mothers of our children, the teachers and physicians who act as their +advisers and friends.[15] This chapter is intended to do its bit +toward such a general understanding. + +[Footnote 15: "Appropriate educational processes might perhaps guide +this enormous impulsive energy toward the maintenance instead of the +destruction of marriage and the family. But up to the present time, +education with respect to this moral issue has commonly lacked any +such constructive method. The social standard and the individual +impulse have simply collided, and the individual has been left to +resolve the conflict, for the most part by his own resources."--G.A. +Coe: _Psychology of Religion_, p. 150.] + + +PARENTAL INSTINCT AND TENDER EMOTION + +=Until They Can Fly.= Only half of Nature's need is met by the +reproductive instinct. Her carefulness in this direction would be +largely wasted without that other impulse which she has planted, the +impulse to protect the new lives until they are old enough to fend for +themselves. The higher the type of life and the greater the future +demands, the longer is the period of preparation and consequent period +of parental care. This fact, coupled with man's power for lasting +relationships through the organization of permanent sentiments, has +made the, bond between parent and child an enduring one. Needless to +say, this relationship is among the most beautiful on earth, the +source of an incalculable amount of joy and gain. However, as we have +already suggested, there lurks here, as in every beneficent force, a +danger. If parents forget what they are for, and try to foster a more +than ordinary tie, they make themselves a menace to those whom they +most love. Any exaggeration is abnormal. If the childhood bond is +over-strong, or the childhood dependence too long cultivated, then the +relationship has overstepped its purpose, and, as we shall later see, +has laid the foundation for a future neurosis. + +=Mothering the World.= Probably no instinct has so many ways of +indirect expression as this mothering impulse of protection. Aroused +by the cry of a child in distress, or by the thought of the weakness, +or need, or ill-treatment of any defenseless creature, this +mother-father impulse is at the root of altruism, gratitude, love, +pity, benevolence, and all unselfish actions. + +There is still a great difference of opinion as to how man's spiritual +nature came into being; still discussion as to whether it developed +out of crude beginnings as the rest of his physical and mental +endowment has developed, or whether it was added from the outside as +something entirely new. Be that as it may, the fact remains that man +has as an innate part of his being an altruistic tendency, an +unselfish care for the welfare of others, a relationship to society as +a whole,--a relationship which is the only foundation of health and +happiness and which brings sure disaster if ignored. The egoistic +tendencies are only a part of human nature. Part of us is naturally +socially minded, unselfish, spiritual, capable of responding to the +call to lose our lives in order that others may find theirs. + + +SUMMARY + +Civilized man as he is to-day is a product of the past and can be +understood only as that past is understood. The conflicts with which +he is confronted are the direct outcome of the evolutional history of +the race and of its attempt to adapt its primitive instincts to +present-day ideals. + +Character is what we do with our instincts. According to Freud, all +of a man's traits are the result of his unchanged original impulses, +or of his reactions against those impulses, or of his sublimation of +them. In other words, there are three things we may do with our +instincts. We may follow our primal desires, we may deny their +existence, or we may use them for ends which are in harmony with our +lives as we want them to be. As the first course leads to degeneracy, +the second to nervous illness, and the third to happy usefulness, it +is obviously important to learn the way of sublimation. Sometimes this +is accomplished unconsciously by the life-force, but sometimes +sublimation fails, and is reestablished only when the conscious mind +gains an understanding of the great forces of life. This method of +reeducation of the personality as a means of treatment in nervousness +is called psycho-therapy. + +=Religion's Contribution.= If it be asked why, amid all this +discussion of instincts and motives we have made no mention of that +great energizer religion, we answer that we have by no means forgotten +it, but that we have been dealing solely with those primary tendencies +out of which all of the compound emotions are made. Man has been +described as instinctively and incurably religious, but there seems no +doubt that religion is a compound reaction, made up of +love,--sympathetic response to the parental love of God,--fear, +negative self-feeling, and positive self-feeling in the shape of +aspiration for the desired ideal of character; all woven into several +compound emotions such as awe, gratitude, and reverence. + +It goes almost without saying that religion, if it be vital, is one of +the greatest sources of moral energy and spiritual dynamic, and that +it is and always has been one of the greatest aids to sublimation that +man has found. A force like the Christian religion, which sets the +highest ideal of character and makes man want to live up to it, and +which at the same time says, "You can. Here is strength to help you"; +which unifies life and fills it with purpose; which furnishes the +highest love-object and turns the thought outward to the good of +mankind--such a force could hardly fail to be a dynamic factor in the +effort toward sublimation. This book, however, deals primarily with +those cases for which religion has had, to call science to her aid in +order to find the cause of failure, to flood the whole subject with +light, and to help cut the cords which, binding us to the past, make +it impossible to utilize the great resources that are at hand for all +the children of men. + +=Where We Keep Our Instincts.= It must have been impossible to read +through these two chapters on instinct without feeling that, after +all, we are not very well acquainted with ourselves. The more we look +into human nature, the more evident it becomes that there is much in +each one of us of which we are only dimly aware. It is now time for us +to look a little deeper,--to find where we keep these instinctive +tendencies with which it is possible to live so intimately without +even suspecting their existence. We shall find that they occupy a +realm of their own, and that this realm, while quite out of sight, is +yet open to exploration. + + + + +CHAPTER V + +_In which we look below the surface and discover a veritable +wonderland_ + +THE SUBCONSCIOUS MIND + +STRANGERS TO OURSELVES + + +=Hidden Strings.= A collie dog lies on the hearthrug. A small boy with +mischievous intent ties a fine thread to a bone, hides himself behind +a chair, and pulls the bone slowly across the floor. The dog is thrown +into a fit of terror because he does not know about the hidden string. + +A Chinese in the early days of San Francisco stands spell-bound at the +sight of a cable car. "No pushee. No pullee. Go allee samee like +hellee!" He does not know about the hidden string. + +A woman of refinement and culture thinks a thought that horrifies her +sensitive soul. It is entirely out of keeping with her character as +she knows it. In her misunderstanding she considers it wicked and +thrusts it from her, wondering how it ever could have been hers. She +does not know about the hidden string. + +In the last two chapters we thought together about some of these +strings, examining the fibers of which they are made and learning in +what directions they pull. We found them to be more powerful than we +should have supposed, more insistent and less visible. We found that +instinctive desire is the string, the cable that energizes our every +act, but that our desires are neither single nor simple, and are but +rarely on the surface. Many of us live with them a long time, feeling +the tug, but not recognizing the string. + +=There's a Reason.= We take our thoughts and feelings and actions for +granted, without stopping very often to wonder where they come from. +But there is always a reason. When the law of cause and effect reaches +the doorsill of our minds, it does not stop short to give way to the +law of chance. We wake up in the morning with a certain thought on +top. We say it "just happens." But nothing ever just happens. No +thought that ever comes into our heads has been without its +history,--its ancestors and its determining causes. But what about +dreams? They, at least, you say, have no connections, no past and no +future, only a weird, fantastic present. Strange to say, dreams have +been found to be as closely related to our real selves, as interwoven +with the warp and woof of our lives as are any of our waking thoughts. +Even dreams have a reason. + +We find ourselves holding certain beliefs and prejudices, interested +in certain things and indifferent to others, liking some foods, some +colors and disliking others. Search our minds as we will, we find no +clue to many of these inner trends. Why? + +The answer is simple. The cause is hidden below the surface. If we try +to explain ourselves on the basis of the open-to-inspection part of +our minds, we must come to the conclusion that we are queer creatures +indeed. Only by assuming that there is more to us than we know, can we +find any rational basis for the way we think and feel and act. + +=A Real Mind.= We learn of our internal machinery by what it does. We +must infer a part of our minds which introspection does not reveal, a +mind within the mind, able to work for us even while we are unaware of +its existence. This inner mind is usually known as the subconscious, +the mind under the level of consciousness.[16] We forget a name, but +we know that it will come to us if we think about something else. +Presently, out of somewhere, there flashes the word we want. Where was +it in the meanwhile, and what hunted it out from among all our other +memories and sent it up into consciousness? The something which did +that must be capable of conserving memories, of recognizing the right +one and of communicating it,--surely a real mind. + +[Footnote 16: Writers of the psycho-analytic school use the word +"unconscious" to denote the lower layers of this region, and +"fore-conscious" to denote its upper layers. Morton Prince uses the +terms "unconscious" and "conscious" to denote the different strata. As +there is still a good deal of confusion in the use of terms, it has +seemed to us simpler to use throughout only the general term +"subconscious."] + +One evening my collaborator fumbled unsuccessfully for the name of a +certain well-known journalist and educator. It was on the tip of her +tongue, but it simply would not come, not even the initial letter. In +a whimsical mood she said to herself just as she went to sleep, +"Little subconscious mind, you find that name to-night." In the middle +of the night she awoke, saying, "Williams--Talcott Williams." The +subconscious, which has charge of her memories, had been at work while +she slept. + +The history of literature abounds in stories of under-the-surface +work. The man of genius usually waits until the mood is on, until the +muse speaks; then all his lifeless material is lighted by new +radiance. He feels that some one outside himself is dictating. Often +he merely holds the pen while the finished work pours itself out +spontaneously as if from a higher source. + +But it is not only the man of genius who makes use of these unseen +powers. He may have readier access to his subconscious than the rest +of us, but he has no monopoly. The most matter-of-fact man often says +that he will "sleep over" a knotty problem. He puts it into his mind +and then goes about his business, or goes to sleep while this unseen +judge weighs and balances, collects related facts, looks first at one +side of the question and then at the other, and finally sends up into +consciousness a decision full of conviction, a decision that has been +formulated so far from the focus of attention that it seems to be +something altogether new, a veritable inspiration. + +We must infer the subconscious from what it does. Things +happen,--there must be a cause. Some of the things that happen +presuppose imagination, reason, intelligence, will, emotion, desire, +all the elements of mind. We cannot see this mind, but we can see its +products. To deny the subconscious is to deny the artist while looking +at his picture, to disbelieve in the poet while reading his poem, and +to doubt the existence of the explosive while listening to the report. +The subconscious is an artist, a poet, and an explosive by turns. If +we deny its existence, a good portion of man's doings are +unintelligible. If we admit it, many of his actions and his +afflictions which have seemed absurd stand out in a new light as +purposeful efforts with a real and adequate cause. + +=The Submerged Nine Tenths.= The more deeply psychologists and +physicians have studied into these things, the more certainly have +they been forced to the conclusion that the conscious mind of man, the +part that he can explore at will, is by far the smaller part of his +personality. Since this is to some people a rather startling +proposition, we can do no better than quote the following statement +from White on the relation of consciousness to the rest of the psychic +life: + + Consciousness includes only that of which we are _aware_, while + outside of this somewhat restricted area there lies a much wider + area in which lie the deeper motives for conduct, and which not + only operates to control conduct, but also dictates what may and + what may not become conscious. Stanley Hall has very forcibly put + the matter by using the illustration of the iceberg. Only + one-tenth of the iceberg is visible above water; nine-tenths is + beneath the surface. It may appear in a given instance that the + iceberg is being carried along by the prevailing winds and + surface currents, but if we keep our eyes open we shall sooner or + later see a berg going in the face of the wind, and, so, + apparently putting to naught all the laws of aerodynamics. We can + understand this only when we come to realize that much the + greater portion of the berg is beneath the surface and that it is + moving in response to invisible forces addressed against this + submerged portion. + + Consciousness only arises late in the course of evolution and + only in connection with adjustments that are relatively complex. + When the same or similar conditions in the environment are + repeatedly presented to the organism so that it is called upon to + react in a similar and almost + identical way each time, there tends to be organized a mechanism + of reaction which becomes more and more automatic and is + accompanied by a state of mind of less and less awareness.[17] + +[Footnote 17: White: _Mechanisms of Character Formation_.] + +It is easy to see the economy of this arrangement which provides +ready-made patterns of reaction for habitual situations and leaves +consciousness free for new decisions. Since an automatic action, +traveling along well-worn brain paths, consumes little energy and +causes the minimum of fatigue, the plan not only frees consciousness +from a confusing number of details, but also works for the +conservation of energy. While consciousness is busy lighting up the +special problems of the moment, the vast mass of life's demands are +taken care of by the subconscious, which constitutes the bulk of the +mind. "Properly speaking, the unconscious is the real psyche."[18] + +[Footnote 18: Freud: _Interpretation of Dreams_, p. 486.] + +=The Heart of Psychology.= In the face of all this, it is not to be +wondered at that the problem of the subconscious has been called not +one problem of psychology but the problem. It cannot be denied that +the discoveries which have already been made as to its activities have +been of immense practical importance in the understanding of normal +conduct and in the treatment of the psycho-neuroses. + +If some of the methods--such as hypnosis, automatic writing, and +interpretation of dreams--which are used to investigate its activities +seem to savor of the charlatan and the mountebank, it is because they +have occasionally been appropriated by the ignorant and the +unscrupulous. Their real setting is the psychological laboratory and +the physician's office. In the hands of men like Sigmund Freud, Boris +Sidis, and Morton Prince, they are as scientific as the apparatus of +any other laboratory and their findings are as susceptible of proof. +We may, then, go forward with the conviction that we are walking on +solid ground and that the main paths, at least, will turn into beaten +highways. + + +ANCESTRAL MEMORIES + +=Race-Memories.= An individual as he stands at any moment is the +product of his past,--the past which he has inherited and the past +which he has lived. In other words, he is a bundle of memories +accumulated through the experience of the race, and through his own +experience as a person. Some of these memories are conscious, and +these he calls his, while others fail to reach consciousness and are +not recognized as part of his assets. + +The instincts form the starting-point of mind, conscious and +subconscious, and are the foundation upon which the rest is built. +They often show themselves as part of our conscious lives, but their +roots are laid deep in the subconscious from which they can never be +eradicated. This deepest-laid instinctive layer of the subconscious is +little subject to change. It represents the earlier adjustments of the +race, crystallized into habit. It takes no account of the differences +between the present and the past. It knows no culture, no reason, no +lately acquired prudence. It is all energy and can only wish, or urge +toward action. But since only those race-memories became instincts +which had proved needful to the race in the long run, they are on the +whole beneficent forces, working for the good of the race and the good +of the individual, if he learns how to handle them aright and to adapt +them to present conditions. + +This instinctive urge toward action arouses in the individual an +organic response that is felt as a tension or craving and is mainly +dependent upon its own chemical constitution at the moment. Hunger is +the sensation caused by the little muscular contractions in the +stomach when the body is low in its food supply. Sudden fright is felt +as an all-gone sensation "at the pit of the stomach." What really +happens is a tightening up of the circular muscles of the +blood-vessels lying in the network of the solar plexus, and a spasm of +the muscles of the digestive tract. The hungry stomach impels to +action until satisfied; the physical discomfort in fear impels toward +measures of safety. The apparatus that is made use of by the +subconscious in carrying out this instinctive urge is called the +autonomic nervous system.[19] It regulates all the functions of +living, not only under the stress of emotion, but during every moment +of waking or sleeping. + +[Footnote 19: Kempf: "The Tonus of Automatic Segments as a Cause of +Abnormal Behavior," _Journal of Nervous and Mental Diseases_, January, +1921.] + +=A Capable Manager.= The conscious mind could not possibly send +messages to the numerous glands that fit the body for action, nor +attend to all the delicate adjustments that enter into the process. +The conscious mind in most of us does not even know of the existence +of the organs and secretions involved, but something sends the +messages and it is something that has a remarkable likeness to mind as +we usually think of mind,--something which takes advantage of the past +and gages means to an end with a nicety that excites our wonder. + +=Take no Anxious Thought.= We take food into our stomachs and forget +about it, if we are wise; and this subconscious overseer who through +millions of years of experience has learned how to digest food does +the rest. As with digestion, so with our heart-action; we lie down at +night fairly sure that there will be no break in the regular rhythm of +its beat. The subconscious overseer is "on the job" and he never +rests. No matter how hard we sleep, he never lets us forget to take a +breath; and if we trust him, he is very likely to wake us up at the +appointed time in the morning. Also, if we trust him, he carries us +off to sleep as though we were babies. Has he not had long practice in +the days before insomnia was invented? + +=First Aid to the Injured.= In times of infection or injury, this +subconscious manager is better than any doctor. The doctors say with +truth that they only assist nature. If the infection is internal, +antitoxins are produced within the body. If the injury is external, +like a cut, the messages fly, and white blood-corpuscles are marshaled +to take care of poisons and build up the tissue. If the injury is of +the kind that needs rest, the subconscious doctor knows it. He +therefore causes pain and rigidity, in order to induce us to hold the +injured part still until it is restored. + +Crile reminds us of a fact that is often noticed by surgeons. If +patients under ether are handled roughly, especially in the intestinal +region, respiration quickens and there are tremors and even convulsive +efforts which interfere with the surgeon's work. The conscious mind +cannot feel. It is asleep. But the subconscious mind, whose business +it is to protect the body, is trying to get away from injury. The body +uses up as much energy as though it had run for miles, and when the +patient wakes up, we say that he is suffering from shock. The +subconscious mind which is not affected by ether, has been exhausting +itself in a vain attempt to get the body away from harm. + +=A Tireless Servant.= When the conscious mind undertakes a job, it is +always more or less subject to fatigue. But the subconscious after its +long practice seems never to tire. We say that its activities have +become automatic. With all its inherited skill, the subconscious, if +left to itself, can be depended upon to run the bodily machinery +without effort and without hitch. The only things that can interfere +with its work are the wrong kind of emotions and the wrong kind of +suggestions from the conscious mind. Barring these, it goes its way +like a trusty servant, looking after details and leaving its master's +mind free for other things. Having been "in the family" for +generations, it knows its business and resents any interference with +its duties or any infringement of its rights. + +No man, then, comes into this world without inheritance: he receives +from his ancestors two goodly sets of heirlooms, the instincts and the +mechanism which carries on bodily functions. This is the capital with +which man starts life; but immediately he begins increasing this +capital, adding memories from his own experience to the accumulated +race-records. + + +PERSONAL MEMORIES + +No more startling secret has been unearthed by science than the +discovery of the length and minuteness of our memories. No matter how +much one may think he has forgotten, the tablets of his mind are +closely written with records of infinitesimal experiences, shadowy +sensations, old happenings which the conscious self has lost entirely +and would scarcely recognize as its own. Many of these brain records, +or neurograms, as Prince calls them, are never aroused from their +dormant conditions. But others, aroused by emotion or association of +ideas, may after years of inactivity, come forth again either as +conscious memories or as subconscious forces, or even as physiological +memories,--bodily repetitions of the pains, palpitations, and tremors +of old emotional experiences. + +=Irresistible Childhood.= An experience that is forgotten is not +necessarily lost. Although the first few years of childhood are lost +to conscious memory, these years outweigh all others in their +influence on character. The Jesuit priest was right when he said, +"Give me a child until he is six years old, and he will be a Catholic +all his life." As Frink has so ably shown, the determining factors +that enter into any adult choice, such as the choice of the Catholic +or the Protestant faith, are in a large measure made up of +subconscious memories from early childhood, forgotten memories of +Sunday-school and church, of lessons at home or passages in +books,--experiences which no voluntary effort could recall, but which +still live unrecognized in our mature judgments and beliefs. Naturally +we do not acknowledge these subconscious motives. We like to believe +that all our decisions are based on reason, and so we invent plausible +arguments for our attitudes and our actions, arguments which we +ourselves implicitly believe. This process of substituting a plausible +reason for a subconscious one is known as rationalization, a process +which every one of us engages in many times a day. + +It is indeed true that the child is father to the man. Those first +impressionable years, when we believed implicitly whatever any one +told us and when through ignorance we reacted emotionally to ordinary +experiences, are molding us still, making us the men and women we are +to-day, coloring with childish ideas many of the attitudes of our +supposedly reasoning life. Bergson says: + + The unconscious is our historical past. In reality the past is + preserved automatically. In its entirety probably it follows us + at every instant; all that we have felt, thought and willed from + our earliest infancy is there, leaning over the present which is + about to join it, pressing against the portals of consciousness + that would fain leave it outside. + +=Spontaneous Outbursts.= "How do we know all this?" some one says. +"What is the evidence for these sweeping statements? If we cannot +remember, how can we discover these strange memories that are so +powerful but so elusive? If they are below the level of consciousness, +are they not, in the very nature of the case, forever hidden from +view, in the sphere of the occult rather than that of science?" + +The answer to these questions is determined by one important fact; the +line between the conscious and subconscious minds does not always +remain in the same place; the "threshold of consciousness" is +sometimes displaced, automatically allowing these buried memories to +come to the surface. In sleep and delirium, in trance and +hallucination, in hysteria and intoxication, the tables are turned; +the restraining hand of the conscious mind is loosened and the +submerged self comes forth with all its ancient memories. + +It is a common experience to have a patient in delirium repeat +long-forgotten verses or descriptions of events that the "real man" +has lost entirely. The renowned servant-girl, quoted by Hudson, who in +delirium recited passage after passage of Hebrew, Latin, and Greek, +which she had heard her one-time master repeat in his study, is +typical of many such instances.[20] + +[Footnote 20: Hudson: _The Law of Psychic Phenomena_, p. 44. Quoted +from _Coleridge's Biographia Literaria_, Vol. I, p. 117 (edit. 1847).] + +A young girl of nineteen, a patient of mine, lapsed for several weeks +into a dissociated state in which she forgot all the memories and +ideas of her adult life, and returned to the period of her childhood. +She used to say that she saw things inside her head and would +accurately describe events that took place before she was two years of +age,--scenes which she had completely forgotten in her normal life. +One day when I asked her to tell me what she was seeing, she began to +talk about "little sister" (herself) and "little brother." "Little +sister and brother were the two little folks that lived with their +mother and their daddy and they were playing on the sand-pile. You +know there was only one sand-pile, not like all the ones they have +down here (at the seaside), and they had a bucket that they would put +sand in and they would dump it out again and they would make nice +things, you know; they would play with their little dog Ponto and he +was white with black and brown spots on him. Little brother had white +hair and he was bigger than little sister and he had a little waist +with ruffles down the front and around the collar and a black coat +that came down to his knees and it had two little white bands around +it. Some of the waists he wore had blue specks and some had red and +black specks in it. + +"Little sister had yellow curls and she had a blue coat with jiggly +streaks of white in it, and she had a little white bonnet that was +crocheted, and she had little blue mittens on that were tied to a +string that went around her neck and down the other arm. It got pretty +cold where they lived. Little sister and little brother would go out +to the pile of leaves and jump on them and bounce and they would +crackle. The leaves came down from the trees all of a sudden when they +got tired, and they were different colors, brown and red. Little +sister could walk then but she could not walk one other time before +then; she could stand up by holding to a chair, but she could not go +herself. One morning Big Tom said 'Run to Daddy' and she went to her +daddy, and after that she always walked; they were glad and she was +glad. She walked all day long. Big Tom was a man who used to help +Daddy and little sister always liked him. He was a nice man." + +The mother verified this scene of the first walking, saying that it +had occurred on her own wedding-anniversary when the child was +twenty-three months old. + +One night I heard the same patient talk in her sleep in the slow and +hesitating manner of a child reading phonetically from a printed page. +I soon recognized the words as those of a poem of Tagore's, called "My +Prayer," and remembered that a magazine containing the poem had been +lying on the bed during the day. When she had finished I wakened her, +saying, "Now tell me what you have been dreaming." She answered in +her childish way, "I think I do not dream." She went to sleep +immediately and again repeated the poem, word for word, without a +single mistake. Again I awakened her with the words, "Now tell me what +you have been dreaming." And again she answered, "I think I do not +dream." I said: "But yes; don't you remember you were just saying, +'When the time comes for me to go'?" (the last line of the poem). "Oh, +yes," she said, "I was seeing it, and I think I'll not go to sleep +again. It tires me so to see it." + +While she was awake she had no recollection of having seen the poem +and was indeed in her dissociated state quite incapable of +understanding its meaning. Asleep, she saw every word as plainly as if +the page had been before her eyes. + +The distorted pictures of dreams are always made of the material which +past experiences have furnished and which have in many cases been +dropped out of consciousness for years only to rise out of their long +oblivion when the conscious mind has been put to sleep. + +=Unearthing Old Experiences.= However, psychology does not have to +wait for buried memories to come forth of their own free will. It has +a number of successful ways of summoning them from their hiding-place +and helping them across the line into consciousness. In the hands of +skilled investigators and therapeutists, hypnosis, hypnoidization, +automatic writing, crystal-gazing, abstraction, free association, +word-association, and interpretation of dreams have all been +repeatedly successful in bringing to light memories which apparently +have been for many years completely blotted out of mind. As we become +better acquainted with these technical devices we shall find that +there are four kinds of experiences whose records are carefully stored +away in our minds. Some were always so far from the center of our +attention that we could swear they never had been ours; others, +although once present in consciousness, were so trivial and +unimportant that it seems ridiculous to suppose them conserved; others +never came into our waking minds at all and entered our lives only in +special states, such as sleep or delirium or dreams. All these we +should expect to forget; the astonishing thing is that they ever were +conserved. But there is a fourth class that is different. It is made +up of experiences that were so vital, so emotional, so closely woven +into the fiber of our being that it seems impossible that they ever +could be forgotten. Let us look at a few examples of records of all +these four kinds of experiences, examples chosen from hundreds of +their kind as illustrations of the all-embracing character of buried +memories.[21] + +[Footnote 21: For further examples see Prince, _The Unconscious_; +Prince, _The Dissociation of a Personality_, and Hudson, _The Law of +Psychic Phenomena_.] + +=Out of the Corners of Our Eyes.= In the first place, we are much +more observing than we imagine. We may be so interested in our own +thoughts that details of our environment are entirely lost on the +conscious mind, but the subconscious has its eyes open, and its ears. +People in hypnosis have been known to repeat verbatim whole passages +from newspapers which they had never consciously read. While they were +busy with one column, their wide-awake subconscious was devouring the +next one, and remembering it. Prince relates the story of a young +woman who unconsciously "took in" the details of a friend's +appearance: + + I asked B.C.A. (without warning and after having covered her + eyes) to describe the dress of a friend who was present and with + whom she had been conversing perhaps some twenty minutes. She was + unable to do so beyond saying that he wore dark clothes. I then + found that I myself was unable to give a more detailed + description of his dress, although we had lunched and been + together about two hours. B.C.A. was then asked to write a + description automatically. Her hand wrote as follows (she was + unaware that her hand was writing): + + "He has on a dark greenish gray suit, a stripe in it--little + rough stripe; black bow cravat; shirt with three little stripes + in it; black laced shoes; false teeth; one finger gone; three + buttons on his coat." + + The written description was absolutely correct. The stripes in + the coat were almost invisible. I had not noticed + his teeth or the loss of a finger and we had to count the buttons + to make sure of their number owing to their partial concealment + by the folds of the unbuttoned coat. The shoe-strings I am sure + under the conditions would have escaped nearly every one's + notice.[22] + +[Footnote 22: Prince: _The Unconscious_, p. 53.] + +Automatic writing, the method used to uncover this subconscious +perception, is a favorite method with some investigators and is often +used by Morton Prince. The hand writes without the direction of the +personal consciousness and usually without the person's being aware +that it is writing. A dissociated person does this very easily; other +people can cultivate the ability, and perhaps most of us approach it +when we are at the telephone, busily writing or drawing remarkable +pictures while the rest of us is engaged in conversation. + +The present epidemic of the Ouija board shows how many persons there +are who are able to switch off the conscious mind and let the +subconscious control the muscles that are used in writing. The fact +that the writer has no understanding of what he is doing and believes +himself directed by some outside power, in no way interferes with the +subconscious phenomenon. + +=Everyday Doings.= Besides perceptions which were originally so far +from the focus of attention that the conscious mind never caught them +at all, there are the little experiences of everyday life, fleeting +thoughts and impressions which occupy us for a minute and then +disappear. Every experience is a dynamic fact and no matter how +trivial the experience may be or how completely forgotten, it still +exists as a part of the personality. + +An amusing example of the everyday kind of forgotten experience +occurred during the writing of this chapter. I wrote a sentence which +pleased me very well. This is the sentence: "In the esthetic processes +of evolution they [man's desires] have sunk below the surface as soon +as formed, and have been covered over by an elastic and snug-fitting +consciousness as the skin covers in the tissues and organs of the +body." After showing this passage to my collaborator and remarking +that this figure had never been used before, I was partly chagrined +and partly amused to have her bring me the following sentence from +White and Jelliffe: "Consciousness covered over and obscured the inner +organs of the psyche just as the skin hides the inner organs of the +body from vision." My originality had vanished and I was close to +plagiarism. Indeed, if a history of plagiarism could be written, it +would probably abound in just such stories. I had read the article +containing this sentence only once, about three years before, and had +never quoted it or consciously thought of it. It had lain buried for +three years, only to come forth as an original idea of my own. Who +knows how many times we all do just this thing without catching +ourselves in the trick? + +=Back-Door Memories.= There are other kinds of memories which hide in +the subconscious, memories of experiences which have not come in by +the front door, but have entered the mind during special states, such +as sleep, delirium, intoxication, or hypnosis. What is known as +post-hypnotic suggestion is the functioning of a suggestion received +during hypnosis and emerging later as an impulse without being +recognized as a memory. A man in a hypnotic state is told that at five +o'clock he will take off his clothes and go to bed, without +remembering that such a suggestion has been given him. He awakens with +no recollection of the suggestion, but at five o'clock he suddenly +feels impelled to go to bed, even though his unreasonable desire puts +him into a highly embarrassing position. The suggestion, to be thus +effective, must have been conserved somewhere in his mind outside of +consciousness. + +Suggestions that enter the mind during the normal sleep are also +recorded,--a fact that carries a warning to people who are in the +habit of talking of all sorts of matters while in the room with +sleeping children. I have sometimes suggested to sleeping patients +that on waking they will remember and tell me the cause of their +symptoms. The following example shows not only the conservation of +impressions gained in sleep, but also the sway of forgotten ideas of +childhood, still strong in mature years. This young woman, a trained +nurse, with many marked symptoms of hysteria, had been asked casually +to bring a book from the Public Library. She cried out in +consternation, "Oh, no, I am afraid!" After a good deal of urging she +finally brought the book, although at the cost of considerable effort. +Later, while she was taking a nap, I said to her, "You will not +remember that I have talked to you. You will stay asleep while I am +talking and while you are asleep there will come to your mind the +reasons why you are afraid to go to the Public Library. When you +waken, you will tell me all about it." Upon awakening, she said: "Oh, +do you know, I can tell you why I have always been afraid to go to the +Public Library. While I was in Parochial School, Father ---- used to +come in and tell us children to use the books out of the school +library and never to go to the Public Library." I questioned her +concerning her idea of the reason for such an injunction and what she +thought was in the books which she was told not to read. She +hesitatingly stated that it was her idea, even in childhood, that the +books dealt with topics concerning the tabooed subject of the birth of +children and kindred matters. + +=Smoldering Volcanoes.= Let us now consider those emotional +experiences which seem far too compelling to be forgotten, but which +may live within us for years without giving any evidence of their +existence. Memories like these are apt to be anything but a dead past. + +Many of my own patients have uncovered emotional memories through +simply talking out to me whatever came into their minds, laying aside +their critical faculty and letting their minds wander on into whatever +paths association led them. This is known as the free-association +method, and simple as it seems, is one of the most effective in +uncovering memories which have been forgotten for years. One of my +patients, a refined, highly educated woman of middle age, had suffered +for two years with almost constant nausea. One day, after a long talk, +with no suggestion on my part, only an occasional, "What does that +remind you of?" she told with great emotion an experience which she +had had at eighteen years of age, in which she had for a moment been +sexually attracted to a boy friend, but had recoiled as soon as she +realized where her impulse was leading her. She had been so horrified +at the idea of her degradation, so nauseated at what she considered +her sin, that she had put it out of her mind, denied that such a +thought had ever been hers, repressed the desire into the +subconscious, where it had continued to function unsatisfied, +unassimilated with her mature judgments. Her nausea was the symbol of +a moral disgust. Physical nausea she was willing to acknowledge, but +not this other thing. Upon reciting this old experience, with every +sign of the original shame, she cried: "Oh, Doctor! why did you bring +this up? I had forgotten it. I haven't thought of it in thirty years." +I reminded her that I couldn't bring it up,--I had never known +anything about it. With the emotional incoming of this memory and the +saner attitude toward it which the mature woman's mind was able to +take, the nausea disappeared for good. This case is typical of the +psycho-neuroses and we shall have occasion to refer to it again. The +present emphasis is on the fact that an emotional memory may be buried +for many years while it still retains the power of reappearing in more +or less disguised manifestation. + +=Repressed Memories.= If we ask how so burning a memory could escape +from the consciousness of a grown woman, we are driven to the +conclusion that this forgetting can be the result of no mere quiet +fading away, but that there must have been some active force at work +which kept the memory from coming into awareness. It was not lost. It +was not passive. Out of sight was not out of mind. There must have +been a reason for its expulsion from the personal consciousness. In +fact, we find that there is a reason. We find that whenever a vital +emotional experience disappears from view, it is because it is too +painful to be endured in consciousness. Nor is it ever the pain of an +impersonal experience or even the thought of what some one else has +done to us that drives a memory out of mind. As a matter of fact, we +never expel a memory except when it bears directly on ourselves and on +our own opinion of ourselves. We can stand almost anything else, but +we cannot stand an idea that does not fit in with our ideal for +ourselves. This is not the pious ideal that we should like to live up +to and that we hope to attain some day, not the ideal that we think we +ought to have--like never speaking ill of others or never being +selfish--but the secret picture that each of us has, locked away +within him, the specifications of ourselves reduced to their lowest +terms, below which we cannot go. Energized by the instinct of positive +self-feeling, and organized with the moral sentiments which we have +acquired from education and the ideals of society, especially those +acquired in early childhood, this ideal of ourselves becomes +incorporated into our conscience and is an absolute necessity for our +happiness. + +We have found that when two emotions clash, one drives out the other. +So in this case, the woman's positive self-feeling of self-respect, +combined with disgust, drove from the field that other emotion of the +reproductive instinct which was trying to get expression. Speaking +technically, one repressed the other. The woman said to herself, "No, +I never could have had such a thought," and promptly forgot it. +Needless to say, this kind of handling did not kill the impulse. +Buried in the depths of her soul, it continued to live like a live +coal, until in later years, fanned by the wind of some new experience, +it burst into flame. + +In this case the wish had originally flashed into awareness for an +instant, but very often the impulse never gets into consciousness at +all. The upper layers of the subconscious, where the acquired ideals +live, automatically work to keep down any desires which are thought to +be out of keeping with the person as he knows himself. He then would +emphatically deny that such desires had ever had any place in his +life. + +Freud has called this repressing force the psychic censor. To get into +consciousness, any idea from the subconscious must be able to pass +this censor. This force seems to be a combination of the +self-regarding and herd-instincts, which dispute with the instinct for +reproduction the right to "the common path" for expression. + +A considerable part of any person's subconscious is made up of +memories, wishes, impulses, which are repressed in this way. Of course +any instinctive desire may be repressed, but it is easy to understand +why the most frequently denied impulse, the instinct of reproduction, +against whose urgency society has cultivated so strong a feeling, +should be repressed more frequently than any other.[23] + +[Footnote 23: See foot-note, p. 145, Chap. VII.] + +=Past and Present.= It matters not, then, in what state experiences +come to us, whether in sleep or delirium, intoxication or hypnosis, or +in the normal waking condition. They are conserved and may exert great +influence on our normal lives. It matters not whether the experiences +be full of meaning and emotion or whether they be so slight as to pass +unnoticed, they are conserved. It matters not whether these +experiences be mere sense-impressions, or inner thoughts, whether they +be unacknowledged hopes or fears, undesirable moods and unworthy +desires or fine aspirations and lofty ideals. They are conserved and +they may at a later day rise up to bless or to curse us long after we +had thought them buried in the past. The present is the product of the +past. It is the past plus an element of choice which keeps us from +settling down in the despair of fatalism and enables us to do +something toward making the present that is, a help and not a +stumbling-block to the present that is to be. + + +SOME HABITS OF THE SUBCONSCIOUS + +=The Association of Ideas.= It is only by something akin to poetic +license that we can speak of lower and higher strata of mind. When we +carry over the language of material things into the less easily +pictured psychic realm, it is sometimes well to remind ourselves that +figures of speech, if taken too literally, are more misleading than +illuminating. When we speak of the deep-laid instinctive lower levels +of mind and the higher acquired levels, we must not imagine that these +strata are really laid in neat, mutually exclusive layers, one on top +of the other in the chambers of the mind. Nor must we imagine the +mental elements of instinct, idea, and memory as jumbled together in +chaotic confusion, or in scattered isolated units. As a matter of +fact, the best word to picture the inside of our minds is the word +"group." We do not know just how ideas and instincts can group +themselves together, but we do know that by some arrangement of brain +paths and nerve-connections, the laws of association of ideas and of +habit take our mental experiences and organize them into more or less +permanent systems. Instinctive emotions tend to organize themselves +around ideas to form sentiments; ideas or sentiments, which through +repetition or emotion are associated together, tend to stay together +in groups or complexes which act as a whole; complexes which pertain +to the same interests tend to bind themselves into larger systems or +constellations, forming moods, or sides to one's character. It is not +highly important to differentiate in every case a sentiment from a +complex, or a complex from a constellation, especially as many writers +use "complex" as the generic term for all sorts of groups; but a +general understanding of the much-used word "complex" is necessary +for a comprehension of modern literature on psychology, psychotherapy +or general education. + +"=What Is a Complex=?" Reduced to its lowest terms, a complex is a +group. It may be simply a group of associated movements, like lacing +one's shoes or knitting; it may be a group of movements and ideas, +like typewriting or piano-playing, which through repetition have +become automatic or subconscious; it may be merely a group of ideas, +such as the days of the week, the alphabet or the multiplication +table. In all these types it is repetition working through the law of +habit that ties the ideas and movements together into an organic +whole. Usually, however, the word complex is reserved for psychic +elements that are bound together by emotion. In this sense, a complex +is an emotional thought-habit. Frink's definition, which is one of the +simplest, recognizes only this emotional type: "A complex is a system +of connected ideas, having a strong emotional tone, and displaying a +tendency to produce or influence conscious thought and action in a +definite and predetermined direction."[24] + +[Footnote 24: Frink: "What Is a Complex?" _Journal American Medical +Assoc_., Vol. LXII, No. 12, Mar. 21, 1914.] + +Emotion and repetition are the great welders of complexes. Emotion is +the strongest cement in the world. A single emotional experience +suffices to bind together ideas that were originally as far apart as +the poles. + +Sometimes a complex includes not only ideas, movements, and emotions, +but physiological disturbances and sensations. Some people cannot go +aboard a stationary ship without vomiting, nor see a rose, even though +it prove to be a wax one, without the sneezing and watery eyes of +hay-fever. This is what is known as a "conditioned reflex." Past +associations plus fear have so welded together idea and bodily +manifestation that one follows the other as a matter of course, long +after the real cause is removed. In such ways innumerable nervous +symptoms arise. The same laws which form healthy complexes, and, +indeed, which make all education possible, may thus be responsible for +the unhealthy mal-adaptive association-habits which lie back of a +neurosis. Fortunately, a knowledge of this fact furnishes the clue to +the re-education that brings recovery. + +A complex may be either conscious or unconscious, but as it usually +happens that either all or part of its elements are below the surface, +the word is oftenest used to mean those buried systems of the +subconscious mind that influence thought or behavior without +themselves being open to scrutiny. It is these buried complexes, +memory groups, gathered through the years of experience, that +determine action in uniform and easily prophesied directions. Every +individual has a definite complex about religion, about politics, +about patriotism, about business, and it is the sum of these buried +complexes which makes up his total personality. + +=Displacement.= Association or grouping is, then, an intrinsic power +of mind; but as all life seems to be built on opposites--light and +darkness, heat and cold, love and hate--so mind, which is capable of +association, is capable also of displacement or the splitting apart of +elements which belong together. There is such a thing as the simple +breaking up of complexes, when education or experience or neglect +separate ideas and emotions which had been previously welded together; +but displacement is another matter. Here there is still a path between +idea and emotion; they still belong to the same complex, but the +connection is lost sight of. The impulse or emotion attaches itself to +another substitute idea which is related to the first but which is +more acceptable to the personality. Sometimes the original idea is +forgotten; repressed, or dissociated into the subconscious, as in +anxiety neurosis; and sometimes it is merely shorn of its emotional +interest and remembered as an unrelated or insignificant idea, as in +compulsion neurosis. + +=Transference.= Another kind of displacement which seems hard to +believe possible until it is repeatedly encountered in intelligent +human beings is the process called transference, by which everybody at +some time or other acts toward the people he meets, not according to +rational standards but according to old unconscious attitudes toward +other people. Each of us carries, within, subconscious pictures of the +people who surrounded us when we were children; and now when we meet a +new person we are likely unconsciously to say to ourselves--not, "This +person has eyebrows like my mother, or a voice like my nurse," or, +"This person bosses me around as my father used to do," but, "This is +my mother, this is my nurse, this is my father." Whereupon we may +proceed to act toward that person very much as we did toward the +original person in childhood. + +Transference is subconsciously identifying one person with another and +behaving toward the one as if he were that other. Analysis has +discovered that many a man's hostile attitude toward the state or +religion or authority in general, is nothing more than this kind of +displacement of his childhood's attitude toward authority in the +person of his perhaps too-domineering father. Many a woman has married +a husband, not for what he was in himself, but because she +unconsciously identified him with her childish image of her father. + +Students of human nature have always recognized the kind of +displacement which transfers the sense of guilt from some major act or +attitude to a minor one which is more easily faced, just as _Lady +Macbeth_ felt that by washing her hands she might free herself from +her deeper stain. This is a frequent mechanism in the +psychoneuroses--not that neurotics are likely to have committed any +great crime, but that they feel subconsciously that some of their +wishes or thoughts are wicked. + +=The Phenomena of Dissociation.= When an idea or a complex, a +perception or a memory is either temporarily or permanently shoved out +of consciousness into the subconscious, it is said to be dissociated. +When we are asleep, the part of us that is usually conscious is +dissociated and the submerged part takes the stage. When we forget our +surroundings in concentration or absent-mindedness, a part of us is +dissociated and our friends say that we are "not all there," or as +popular slang has it, "Nobody home." When a mood or system of +complexes drives out all other moods, one becomes "a different +person." But if this normal dissociation is carried a step farther, we +may lose the power to put ourselves together again, and then we may +truly be said to be dissociated. Almost any part of us is subject to +this kind of apparent loss. In neurasthenia the happy, healthy +complexes which have hitherto dominated our lives may be split off and +left lying dormant in the subconscious; or the power of will or +concentration may seem to be gone. In hysteria we may seem to lose the +ability to see or feel or walk, or we may lose for the time all +recollection of certain past events, or of whole periods of our lives, +or of everything but one system of ideas which monopolizes the field +of attention. Sometimes great systems of memories, instincts, and +complexes are alternately shifted in and out of gear, leaving first +one kind of person on top and then another.[25] Stevenson's _Dr. +Jekyll_ and _Mr. Hyde_ is not so fantastic a character as he seems. +Any one who doubts the ability of the mind to split itself up into two +or more distinct personalities, entertaining totally different +conceptions of life, disliking each other, playing tricks on each +other, writing notes to each other, and carrying on a perpetual feud +as each tries to get the upper hand, should read Morton Prince's +"Dissociation of a Personality," a fascinating account of his famous +case, Miss Beauchamp. + +[Footnote 25: When a memory or system of memories is suddenly lost +from consciousness the person is said to be suffering from amnesia or +pathological loss of memory.] + +=Internal Warfare.= Conflict, often accentuated by shock or fatigue, +represses or drives down certain ideas, perceptions, wishes, memories, +or complexes into the subconscious, where they remain, sometimes +dormant and passive but often dynamic, emotional, carrying on an +over-excited, automatic activity, freed from the control of reason and +the modifying influence of other ideas, and able to cause almost any +kind of disturbance. So long as there is team-work between the +various parts of our personality we are able to act as a unit; but +just as soon as we break up into factions with no communication +between the warring camps, so soon do we become quite incapable of +cooerdination or adjustment, like a nation torn by civil war. Many of +the seemingly fantastic and bizarre mental phenomena of which a human +being is capable are the result of this kind of disintegration. + +However, nature has a remarkable power for righting herself, and it is +only under an accumulation of unfortunate circumstances that there +appears a neurosis, which is nothing more than a functioning of +certain parts of the personality with all the rest dissociated. We +shall later inquire more fully into the causes that lead up to such a +result and shall find that the mechanisms involved are these processes +of organization and disorganization by which mind is wont to group +together or separate the various elements within its borders. + + +SUMMARY + +Gathering up our impressions, we find a number of outstanding +qualities which we may summarize in the following way: + +The Subconscious is: + +_1 Vast yet Explorable_ + +The fraction that could accurately show the relation of the conscious +to the unconscious part of ourselves would have such a small numerator +and such a huge denominator that we might well wonder where +consciousness came in at all.[26] Some one has likened the +subconscious to the great far-reaching depths of the Mammoth Cave, and +consciousness to the tiny, flickering lamp which we carry to light our +way in the darkness. However, ever the subconscious mind is becoming +explorable, and it may be that science is giving the tiny lamp the +revealing power of a great searchlight. + +[Footnote 26: "The entire active life of the individual may be +represented by a fraction, the numerator of which is any particular +moment, the denominator is the rich inheritance of the +past."--Jelliffe: "The Technique of Psychoanalysis," _Psychoanalytic +Review,_ Vol. III, No. 2, p. 164.] + +_2 Ancient yet Modern_ + +The lowest layers of the subconscious, represented by the instincts, +are as old as life itself, with their lineage reaching back in direct +and unbroken line to the first living things on the ooze of the ocean +floor. The higher strata are more modern, full, and accurate records +of our own lifetime, beginning with our first cry and ending with +to-day's thoughts. + +_3 Primitive yet Refined_ + +The lowest level, representing the past of the race, is primitive like +a savage, and infantile, like a child; it is instinctive, unalterable, +and universal; it knows no restraint, no culture, and no prudence. The +higher level, the storehouse of individual experience, bears the +marks of acquired ideals, of cultivated refinement, and represents +among other things the precepts and prudence of civilized society. + +_4 Emotional yet Intellectual_ + +Our records of the past are not dead archives, but living +forces--persistent, urging, dynamic and emotional. They give meaning +to new experiences, color our judgments, shape our beliefs, determine +our interests, and, if wrongly handled, make their way into +consciousness as neurotic symptoms. + +However, the subconscious is not all emotion. It is a mind capable of +elaborate thought, able to calculate, to scheme, to answer doubts, to +solve problems, to fabricate the purposeful, fantastic allegories of +dreams and to create from mere knowledge the inspired works of genius. + +But the subconscious has one great limitation, it cannot reason +inductively. Given a premise, this mind can reason as unerringly as +the most skilful logician; that is, it can reason deductively, but it +cannot arrive at a general conclusion from a number of particular +facts. However, except for inductive reasoning and awareness, the +subconscious seems to possess all the attributes of conscious mind and +is in fact an intellectual force to be reckoned with. + +_5 Organized yet Disorganizable_ + +The subconscious mind is a highly organized institution, but like all +such institutions it is liable to disorganization when rent by +internal dissension. Ordinarily it keeps its ideas and emotions, its +complexes and moods in fairly accurate order, but when upset by +emotional warfare, it gets its records confused and falls into a +chaotic state which makes regular business impossible. + +_6 Masterful yet Obedient_ + +The subconscious, which is master of the body, is in normal life the +servant of consciousness. One of its outstanding qualities is +suggestibility. Since it cannot reason from particulars to a general +conclusion it takes any statement given it by consciousness, believes +it implicitly and acts accordingly. + +The pilot wheel of the ship is, after all, the conscious mind, +insignificant in size when compared with the great mass of the vessel, +but all-powerful in its ability to direct the course of the voyage. + +Nervous persons are people who are too much under the sway of the +subconscious; so, too, are some geniuses, who narrowly escape a +neurosis by finding a more useful outlet for their subconscious +energies. While the poet, the inventor, and the neurotic are likely to +be too largely controlled by the subconscious, the average man is to a +greater extent ruled by the conscious mind; and the highest type of +genius is the man whose conscious and subconscious minds work together +in perfect harmony, each up to its full power. + +If, as many believe, the next great strides of science are to be in +this direction, it may pay some of us to be pioneers in learning how +to make use of these undeveloped riches of memory, organization, and +surplus energy. The subconscious, which can on occasion behave like a +very devil within us, is, when rightly used, our greatest asset, the +source of powers whose appearance in the occasional individual has +been considered almost superhuman, but which prove to be +characteristically human, the common inheritance of the race of man. + + + + +CHAPTER VI + +_In which we learn why it pays to be cheerful_ + +BODY AND MIND + +THE MISSING LINK + + +=Ancient Knowledge.= People have always known that mind in some +strange way carries its moods over into the body. The writer of the +Book of Proverbs tells us, from that far-off day, that "A merry heart +doeth good like a medicine, but a broken spirit drieth the bones." +Jesus in His healing ministry always emphasized the place of faith in +the cure of the body. "Thy faith hath made thee whole," is a frequent +word on His lips, and ever since His day people have been +rediscovering the truth that faith, even in the absence of a worthy +object, does often make whole. Faith in the doctor, the medicine, the +charm, the mineral waters, the shrine, and in the good God, has +brought health to many thousands of sufferers. People have always +reckoned on this bodily result from a mental state. They have +intuitively known better than to tell a sick person that he is looking +worse, but they have not always known why. They have known that a fit +of anger is apt to bring on a headache, but they have not stopped to +look for the reason, or if they have, they have often gotten +themselves into a tangle. This is because there has always been, until +recently, a missing link. Now the link has been found. After the last +chapter, it will not be hard to understand that this connecting link, +this go-between of body and mind, is nothing else than the +subconscious mind. When we remember that it has the double power of +knowing our thoughts and of controlling our bodies, it is not hard to +see how an idea can translate itself into a pain, nor to realize with +new vividness the truth of the statement that healthy mental states +make for health, and unhealthy mental states for illness. + +=Suggestion and Emotion.= There are still many gaps in our knowledge +of the ways of the subconscious, but investigation has thrown a good +deal of light on the problem. Two of the principles already discussed +are sufficient to explain most of the phenomena. These are, first, +that the subconscious is amenable to control by suggestion, and +secondly, that it is greatly influenced by emotion. Tracing back the +principles behind any example of the power of mind over body, one +finds at the root of the matter either a suggestion or an emotion, or +both. If, then, the stimulating and depressing effects of mental +states are to be understood, the first Step must be a fuller +understanding of the laws governing suggestion and emotion. + + +THE CONTAGION OF IDEAS + +One of the most important points about the subconscious mind is its +openness to suggestion. It likes to believe what it is told and to act +accordingly. The conscious mind, too,--proud seat of reason though it +may be,--shares this habit of accepting ideas without demanding too +much proof of their truth. Even at his best, man is extremely +susceptible to the contagion of ideas. Most of us are even less immune +to this mental contagion than we are to colds or influenza; for ideas +are catching. They are such subtle, insinuating things that they creep +into our minds without our knowing it at all; and once there, they are +as powerful as most germs. + +Let a person faint in a crowded room, and a good per cent. of the +women present will begin to fan themselves. The room has suddenly +become insufferably close. After we have read half a hundred times +that Ivory soap floats, a fair proportion of the population is likely +to be seized with desire for a soap that floats,--not because they +have any good reason for doing so, but simply because the suggestion +has "taken." As for the harbingers of spring, they are neither the +birds nor the wild flowers, but the blooming windows of the +milliners, which successfully suggest in wintry February that summer +is coming, and that felt and fur are out of season. It is evident that +all advertising is suggestion. + +The training of children, also, if it is done in the right way, is +largely a matter of suggestion. The little child who falls down and +bumps his head is very likely to cry if met with a sympathetic show of +concern, while the same child will often take his mishaps as a joke if +his elders meet them with a laugh or a diverting remark. Unlucky is +the child whose mother does not know, either consciously or +intuitively, that example and contagion are more powerful--and more +pleasant--than command and prohibition. + +=Everything Suggestive.= Human beings are constantly communicating, +one to another. Sometimes they "get over" an idea by means of words, +but often they do it in more subtle ways,--by the elevation of an +eyelid, the gesture of a hand, composure of manner in a crisis, or a +laugh in a delicate situation. A suggestion is merely an idea passed +from one person to another, an idea that is accepted with conviction +and acted upon, even though there may be no logic, no reason, no proof +of its truth. It is an influence that takes hold of the mind and works +itself out to fulfilment, quite apart from its worth or +reasonableness. Of course, logical persuasion and argument have their +place in the communication of ideas; an idea may be conveyed by other +ways than suggestion. But while suggestion is not everything, it is +equally true that there is suggestion in everything. The doctor may +give a patient a very rational explanation of his case, but the +doubtful shake of the head or the encouraging look of his eye is quite +likely to color the patient's general impression. The eyes of our +subconscious are always open, and they are constantly getting +impressions, subtle suggestions that are implied rather than +expressed. + +=Abnormal Suggestibility.= While everybody is suggestible, nervous +people are abnormally so. It may be, as McDougall suggests, that they +have so large an amount of submission or negative self-feeling in +their make-up that they believe anything, just because some one else +says it is true. Sometimes it is lack of knowledge that makes us +gullible, and at other times the cause of our suggestibility is +failure to use the knowledge that we have. Sometimes our ideas are +locked away in air-tight compartments with no interaction between +them. The psychologists tell us that suggestion is greatly favored by +a narrowing of the attention, a "contraction of the field of +consciousness," a dissociation of other ideas through concentration. +This all simply means that we forget to let our common sense bring to +bear counter ideas that might challenge a false one; or that worry--a +veritable "spasm of the attention"--has fixed upon an idea to the +exclusion of all others; or that through fatigue or the dissociation +of sleep or hypnosis or hysteria, our reasoning powers have been +locked out and for the time being are unable to act. + +It was through experiments on hypnotized subjects that scientists +first learned of the suggestibility of the subconscious mind. In +hypnosis a person can be made to believe almost anything and to do +almost anything compatible with the safety and the moral sense of the +individual. The instinct of self-preservation will not allow the most +deeply hypnotized person to do anything dangerous to himself; and the +moral complexes, laid in the subconscious, never permit a person to +perform in earnest an act of which the waking moral sense would +disapprove. Within these limits, a person in the dissociated hypnotic +state can be made to accept almost any suggestion. We found in the +last chapter how open to suggestion is a person in normal sleep. Of +the dissociation of hysteria we shall have occasion to speak in later +chapters. Although all these special states heighten suggestibility, +we must not forget how susceptible each of us is in his normal waking +state. + +=Living Its Faith.= All this gathers meaning only when we realize that +ideas are dynamic. They always tend to work themselves out to +fulfilment. The subconscious no sooner gets a conviction than it tries +to act it out. Of course it can succeed only up to a certain limit. +If it believes the stomach to have cancer, it cannot make cancer, but +it can make the stomach misbehave. One of my patients, on hearing of a +case of brain-tumor immediately imagined this to be her trouble, and +developed a pain in her head. She could not manufacture a tumor, but +she could manufacture what she believed to be the symptoms. + +There was another patient who was supposed to have brain-tumor. This +young woman seemed to have lost almost entirely the power to keep her +equilibrium in walking. Her center of gravity was never over her feet, +but away out in space, so that she was continually banging from one +side of the room to the other, only saving herself from injury by +catching at the wall or the furniture with her hands. Several +physicians who had been interested in the case had found the symptoms +strongly suggestive of brain-tumor. There were, however, certain +unmistakable earmarks of hysteria, such as childlike bland +indifference to the awkwardness of the gait which was a grotesque +caricature of several brain and spinal-cord diseases, with no accurate +picture of any single one. This was evidently a case, not of actual +loss of power but a dissociation of the memory-picture of walking. The +patient was a trained nurse and knew in a general way the symptoms of +brain-tumor. When the suggestion of brain-tumor had fixed itself in +her mind she was able subconsciously to manufacture what she believed +to be the symptoms of that disease. + +By injecting a keen sense of disapprobation and skepticism into the +hitherto placidly accepted state of disability, by flashing a mirror +on the physical and moral attitudes which she was assuming, I was able +to rob the pathological complex of its (altogether unconscious) +pleasurable feeling-tone, and to restore to its former strength and +poise a personality of exceptional native worth and beauty. After a +few weeks at my house she was able to walk like a normal person and +went back to her work, for good. + +We have already learned enough about the inner self to see in a faint +way how it works out its ideas. Since the subconscious mind runs the +bodily machinery, since it regulates digestion, the building up of +tissue, circulation, respiration, glandular secretion, muscular tonus, +and every other process pertaining to nutrition and growth, it is not +difficult to see how an idea about any of these matters can work +itself out into a fact. A thought can furnish the mental machinery +needed to fulfil the thought. Some one catches the suggestion: +"Concentration is hard on the brain. It soon brings on brain-fag and +headache." Not knowing facts to the contrary, the suggestible mind +accepts the proposition. Then one day, after a little concentration, +the idea begins to work. Whereupon the autonomic nervous system +tightens up the blood-vessels that regulate the local blood supply, +too much blood stays in the head, and lo, it aches! The next time, the +suggestion comes with greater force, and soon the habit is +formed,--all the result of an idea. It is a good thing to remember +that constant thought about any part of the body never fails to send +an over-supply of blood to that part; of course that means congestion +and pain. + +=Hands Off!= By sending messages directly to an organ through the +nerve-centers or by changing circulation, the subconscious director of +our bodies can make any part of us misbehave in a number of ways. All +it needs is a suggestion of an interfering thought about an organ. As +we have insisted before, the subconscious cannot stand interference. +Sadler well says: "Man can live at the equator or exist at the poles. +He can eat almost anything and everything, but he cannot long stand +self-contemplation. The human mind can accomplish wonders in the way +of work, but it is soon wrecked when directed into the channels of +worry."[27] In other words, hands off!--or rather, minds off! Don't +get ideas that make you think about your body. The surest way to +disarrange any function is to think about it. It is a stout heart that +will not change its beat with a frequent finger on the pulse, and a +hearty stomach that will not "act up" under attention. "Judicious +neglect" is a good motto for most occasions. Take no anxious thought +if you would be well. Know enough about your body to counteract false +suggestions; fulfil the common-sense laws of hygiene,--eight hours in +bed, plenty of exercise and fresh air, and three square meals a day. +Then forget all about it. "A mental representation is already a +sensation,"[28] and we have enough legitimate sensations without +manufacturing others. + +[Footnote 27: Sadler: _Physiology of Faith and Fear_.] + +[Footnote 28: DuBois: _Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders_.] + +=From Real Life.= Startling indeed are the tricks that we can play on +ourselves by disregarding these laws. A patient who was unnecessarily +concerned about his stomach once came to me in great alarm, exhibiting +a distinct, well-defined swelling about the size of a match-box in the +region of his stomach. I looked at it, laughed, and told him to forget +it. Whereupon it promptly disappeared. The first segment of the rectus +muscle had tied itself up into a knot, under the stimulus of anxious +attention. + +Another patient appeared at my door one day saying, "Look here!" +Examination showed that her abdomen was swollen to the size of more +than a six-months pregnancy. As it happened, this woman had a friend +who a short time before had developed a pseudo, or hysterical +pregnancy which continued for several months. My patient, accepting +the suggestion, was prepared to imitate her. I gave her a punch or +two and told her to go and dress for luncheon. In the afternoon she +had returned to her normal size. + +Another woman, suffering from chronic constipation, was firmly +convinced that her bowels could not move without a cathartic, which I +refused to give. However, I did give her some strychnine pills, +carefully explaining that they were not for her intestines and that +they would have no effect there. She did not believe me, and promptly +began to have an evacuation every day. It seems that sometimes two +wrong ideas are equal to a right one. + +If doctors fully realized the power of suggestion, they would be more +careful than they sometimes are about suggesting symptoms by the +questions they ask their patients. + +A patient of mine with locomotor-ataxia suffered from the usual train +of symptoms incident to that disease. It turned out, however, that +many of the symptoms had been suggested by the questions of former +physicians who had asked him whether he had certain symptoms and +certain disabilities. The patient had answered in the negative and +then promptly developed the suggested symptoms. When I told him what +had happened, these false symptoms disappeared leaving only those +which had a real physical foundation. + +Another patient, a young girl, complained of a definite localized +pain in her arm, and told me that she was suffering from angina +pectoris. As we do not expect to find this disease in a young person, +I asked her where she got such an idea. "Dr. ---- told me so last +May." "Did you feel the pain in this same place before that time?" I +asked. She thought a minute and then answered: "Why no, I had a pain +around my heart but I did not notice it in my arm until after that +consultation." The wise physician lets his patients describe their own +symptoms without suggesting others by the implication of his +questions. + +=Autosuggestion.= Of course we must remember that an idea cannot +always work itself out immediately. Conditions are not always ripe. It +often lies fallow a long time, buried in the subconscious, only to +come up again as an autosuggestion, a suggestion from the self to the +self. If some one tells us that nervous insomnia is disastrous, and we +believe it, we shall probably store up the idea until the next time +that chance conditions keep us awake. Then the autosuggestion "bobs +up," common sense is side-tracked, we toss and worry--and of course +stay awake. An autosuggestion often repeated becomes the strongest of +suggestions, successfully opposing most outside ideas that would +counteract it,--reason enough for seeing to it that our +autosuggestions are of the healthful variety. + +At the base of every psycho-neurosis is an unhealthful suggestion. +This is never the ultimate cause. There are other forces at work. But +the suggestion is the material out of which those other forces weave +the neurosis. Suggestibility is one of the earmarks of nervousness. A +sensible and sturdy spirit, stable enough to maintain its equilibrium, +is a fairly good antidote to attack. "As a man thinketh in his heart, +so is he." + + +WHY FEELINGS COUNT + +=The Emotions Again.= It seems impossible to discuss any psychological +principle without finally coming back to the subject of emotions. It +truly seems that all roads lead to the instincts and to the emotions +which drive them. And so, as we follow the trail of suggestion, we +suddenly turn a corner and find ourselves back at our +starting-point--the emotional life. Like all other ideas, suggestions +get tied up with emotions to form complexes, of which the +driving-power is the emotion. + +If we look into our emotional life, we find, besides the true +emotions, with which we have become familiar in Chapter III, a great +number of feelings or feeling-tones which color either pleasurably or +painfully our emotions and our ideas. On the one hand there are +pleasure, joy, exaltation, courage, cheer, confidence, satisfaction; +and on the other, pain, sorrow, depression, apprehension, gloom, +distrust, and dissatisfaction. Every complex which is laid away in +our subconscious is tinted, either slightly or intensely, with its +specific feeling-tone. + +=Emotions--Tonic and Poisonous.= All this is most important because of +one vital fact; joyful emotions invigorate, and sorrowful emotions +depress; pleasurable emotions stimulate, and painful emotions burden; +satisfying emotions revitalize, and unsatisfying emotions sap the +strength. In other words, our bodies are made for courage, confidence, +and cheer. Any other atmosphere puts them out of their element, +handicapped by abnormal conditions for which they were never +fashioned. We were written in a major key, and when we try to change +over into minor tones we get sadly out of tune. + +There is another factor; painful emotions make us fall to pieces, +while pleasant emotions bind us together. We can see why this is so +when we remember that powerful emotions like fear and anger tend to +dissociate all but themselves, to split up the mind into separate +parts and to force out of consciousness everything but their own +impulse. Morton Prince in his elaborate studies of the cases of +multiple personality, Miss Beauchamp and B.C.A., found repeatedly that +he had only to hypnotize the patient and replace painful, depressing +complexes by healthy, happy ones to change her from a weak, worn-out +person, complaining of fatigue, insomnia, and innumerable aches and +pains, into a vigorous woman, for the time being completely well. On +this point he says: + + Exalting emotions have an intense synthesizing effect, while + depressing emotions have a disintegrating effect. With the + inrushing of depressive memories or ideas ... there is suddenly + developed a condition of fatigue, ill-being and disintegration, + followed after waking by a return or accentuation of all the + neurasthenic symptoms. If on the other hand, exalting ideas and + memories are introduced and brought into the limelight of + attention, there is almost a magical reversal of processes. The + patient feels strong and energetic, the neurasthenic symptoms + disappear and he exhibits a capacity for sustained effort. He + becomes re-vitalized, so to speak.[29] + +[Footnote 29: Prince: _Psycho-therapeutics_, Chap. I.] + +In cases like this the needed strength and energy are not lost; they +are merely side-tracked, but the person feels as weak as though he +were physically ill. + + +BODILY RESPONSE TO EMOTIONAL STATES + +=Secretions.= Let us look more carefully into some of the +physiological processes involved in emotional changes. Among the most +apparent of bodily responses are the various external secretions. +Tears, the secretion of the lachrymal glands in response to an +emotion, are too common a phenomenon to arouse comment. It is common +knowledge that clammy hands and a dry mouth betray emotion. Every +nursing mother knows that she dares not become too disturbed lest her +milk should dry up or change in character. Most people have +experienced an increase in urine in times of excitement; recently +physiologists have discovered the presence of sugar in the urine of +students at the time of athletic contests and difficult +examinations.[30] We have seen what an important role the various +internal secretions, such as the adrenal and thyroid secretions play +in fitting the body for flight and combat, and how large a part fear +and anger have in their production. Constant over-production of these +secretions through chronic states of worry is responsible for many a +distressing symptom. + +[Footnote 30: Cannon.] + +Most graphic evidence of the disturbance of secretions by emotion is +found in the response of the salivary and gastric glands to painful or +pleasurable thinking. As these are the secretions which play the +largest part in the digestive processes, they lead us naturally to our +next heading. + +=Digestion.= Everybody knows that appetizing food makes the mouth +water, but not everybody realizes that it makes the stomach water +also. Nor do we often realize the vital place that this watering has +in taking care of our food. "Well begun is half-done," is literally +true of digestion. A good flow of saliva brings the food into contact +with the taste-buds in the tongue. Taste sends messages to the +nerve-centers in the medulla oblongata; these centers in turn flash +signals to the stomach glands, which immediately "get busy" preparing +the all-important gastric juice. It takes about five minutes for this +juice to be made ready, and so it happens that in five minutes after +the first taste, or even in some cases after the first smell, the +stomach is pouring forth its "appetite juice" which determines all the +rest of the digestive process, in intestines as well as in stomach. +Experiments on dogs and cats by Pawlow, Cannon, and others have shown +what fear and anger and even mildly unpleasant emotions do to the +whole digestive process. Cannon tells of a dog who produced 66.7 cubic +centimeters of pure gastric juice in the twenty minutes following five +minutes of sham feeding (feeding in which food is swallowed and then +dropped out of an opening in the esophagus into a bucket instead of +into the stomach). Although there was no food in the stomach, the +juice was produced by the enjoyment of the taste and the thought of +it. On another day, after this dog had been infuriated by a cat, and +then pacified, the sham feeding was given again. This time, although +the dog ate eagerly, he produced only 9 cubic centimeters of gastric +juice, and this rich in mucus. Evidently a good appetite and +attractively served food are not more important than a cheerful mind. +Spicy table talk, well mixed with laughter, is better than all the +digestive tablets in the world. What is true of stomach secretions is +equally true of stomach contractions. "The pleasurable taking of food" +is a necessity if the required contractions of stomach and intestines +are to go forward on schedule time. A little extra dose of adrenalin +from a mild case of depression or worry is enough to stop all +movements for many minutes. What a revelation on many a case of +nervous dyspepsia! The person who dubbed it "Emotional Dyspepsia" had +facts on his side. + +=Circulation.= It is not the heart only that pumps the blood through +the body. The tiny muscles of the smallest blood-vessels, by their +elasticity are of the greatest importance in maintaining an even flow, +and this is especially influenced by fear and depression. Blushing, +pallor, cold hands and feet, are circulatory disturbances based +largely on emotions. Better than a hot-water bottle or electric pads +are courage and optimism. A patient of mine laughingly tells of an +incident which she says happened a number of years ago, but which I +have forgotten. She says that she asked me one night as she carried +her hot-water bottle to bed, "Doctor, what makes cold feet?" and that +I lightly answered "Cowardice!" Whereupon she threw away her beloved +water-bag and has never needed it since. + +There is a disturbance of the circulation which results in very +marked swelling and redness of the affected part. This is known as +angio-neurotic edema, or nervous swelling. I do not have to go farther +than my own person for an example of this phenomenon. When I was a +young woman I taught school and went home every day for luncheon. One +day at luncheon, some one of the family criticized me severely. I went +back to school very angry. Before I entered the school-room, the +principal handed me some books which she had ordered for me. They were +not at all the books I wanted, and that upset me still more. As I went +into the schoolroom, I found that my face was swollen until my eyes +were almost shut; it was a bright red and covered with purplish +blotches. My fingers were swollen so that I could not bend the joints +in the slightest degree. It was a day or two before the disturbance +disappeared, and the whole of it was the result of anger. + +We hear much to-day about high blood pressure. They say that a man is +as old as his arteries, and now it is known that the health of the +arteries depends largely on blood pressure. Since this is a matter +that can be definitely measured at any minute, we have an easy way of +noting the remarkable effect of shifting emotions. Sadler tells of an +ex-convict with a blood pressure of 190 millimeters. It seems that he +was worrying over possible rearrest. On being reassured on this +point, his blood pressure began to drop within a few minutes, falling +20 mm. in three hours, and 35 mm. by the following day. + +=Muscular Tone.= A force that affects circulation, blood pressure, +respiration, nutrition of cells, secretion, and digestion, can hardly +fail to have a marked effect on the tone of the muscles, internal as +well as external. When we remember that heart, stomach, and intestines +are made of muscular tissue, to say nothing of the skeletal muscles, +we begin to realize how important is muscular tone for bodily health. +Over and over again have I demonstrated that a courageous mind is the +best tonic. Perhaps an example from my "flat-footed" patients will be +to the point. One woman, the young mother of a family, came to me for +a nervous trouble. Besides this, she had suffered for seven or eight +years from severe pains in her feet and had been compelled to wear +specially made shoes prescribed by a Chicago orthopedist. The shoes, +however, did not seem to lessen the pain. After an ordinary day's +occupation, she could not even walk across the floor at dinner-time. A +walk of two blocks would incapacitate her for many days. She was +convinced that her feet could never be cured and came to me only on +account of nervous trouble. On the day of her arrival she flung +herself down on the couch, saying that she would like to go away from +everybody, where the children would never bother her again. She was +sure nobody loved her and she wanted to die. Within three weeks, in +ordinary shoes, this woman tramped nine miles up Mount Wilson and the +next day tramped down again. Her attitude had changed from that of +irritable fretfulness to one of buoyant joy, and with the moral change +had come new strength in the muscles. The death of her husband has +since made it necessary for her to support the family, and she is now +on her feet from eight to fourteen hours a day, a constant source of +inspiration to all about her, and no more weary than the average +person. + +Flabbiness in the muscles often causes this trouble with the feet. +"The arches of the foot are maintained by ligaments between the bones, +supported by muscle tendons which prevent undue stretching of the +ligaments and are a protection against flat-foot."[31] Muscle tissue +has an abundant blood supply, while ligaments have very little and +soon lose their resiliency if unsupported. Any lack of tone in the +calf-muscles throws the weight on the less resistant ligaments and on +the cartilages placed as cushions between the bony structures of the +arch. This is what causes the pain.[32] + +[Footnote 31: Grey's Anatomy--"The Articulations."] + +[Footnote 32: Actual loss of the arch by downward displacement of the +bones cannot be overcome by restoring muscle-tone. The majority of +so-called cases of flatfoot are, however, in the stage amenable to +psychic measures.] + +Flat-footedness is only one result of weak muscles. Eye-strain is +another; ptosis, or falling of the organs, is another. In a majority +of cases the best treatment for any of these troubles is an +understanding attempt to go to the root of the matter by bracing up +the whole mental tone. The most scientific oculists do not try to +correct eye trouble due to muscular insufficiency by any special +prisms or glasses. They know that the eyes will right themselves when +the general health and the general spirits improve. I have found by +repeated experience with nervous patients that it takes only a short +time for people who have been unable to read for months or years to +regain their old faculty. So remarkable is the power of mind. + + +SUMMARY + +We have found that the gap between the body and the mind is not so +wide as it seems, and that it is bridged by the subconscious mind, +which is at once the master of the body and the servant of +consciousness. In recording the physical effects of suggestion and +emotion, we have not taken time to describe the galvanometers, the +weighing-machines and all the other apparatus used in the various +laboratory tests; but enough has been said to show that when doctors +and psychologists speak of the effect of mind on body, they are +dealing with definite facts and with laws capable of scientific +proof. + +We have emphasized the fact that downcast and fearful moods have an +immediate effect on the body; but after all, most people know this +already. What they do not know is the real cause of the mood. When a +nervous person finds out why he worries, he is well on the way toward +recovery. An understanding of the cause is among the most vital +discoveries of modern science. + +The discussion, so far, has merely prepared us to plunge into the +heart of the question: What is it that in the last analysis makes a +person nervous, and how may he find his way out? This question the +next two chapters will try to answer. + + + + +CHAPTER VII + +_In which we go to the root of the matter_ + +THE REAL TROUBLE + + +PIONEERS + +=Following the Gleam.= Kipling's Elephant-child with the "'satiable +curiosity" finally asked a question which seemed simple enough but +which sent him on a long journey into unknown parts. In the same way +man's modest and simple question, "What makes people nervous?" has +sent him far-adventuring to find the answer. For centuries he has +followed false trails, ending in blind alleys, and only lately does he +seem to have found the road that shall lead him to his journey's end. + +We may be thankful that we are following a band of pioneers whose +fearless courage and passion for truth would not let them turn back +even when the trail led through fields hitherto forbidden. The leader +of this band of pioneers was a young doctor named Freud. + + +THE SEARCH FOR TRUTH + +=Early Beginnings.= In 1882, when Freud was the assistant to Dr. +Breuer of Vienna, there was brought to them for treatment a young +woman afflicted with various hysterical pains and paralyses. This +young woman's case marked an epoch in medical history; for out of the +effort to cure her came some surprising discoveries of great +significance to the open-minded young student. + +It was found that each of this girl's symptoms was related to some +forgotten experience, and that in every case the forgetting seemed to +be the result of the painfulness of the experience. In other words, +the symptoms were not visitations from without, but expressions from +within; they were a part of the mental life of the patient; they had a +history and a meaning, and the meaning seemed in some way to be +connected with the patient's previous attitude of mind which made the +experience too painful to be tolerated in consciousness. These +previous ideas were largely subconscious and had been acquired during +early childhood. When by means of hypnosis a great mass of forgotten +material was brought to the surface and later made plain to her +consciousness, the symptoms disappeared as if by magic. + +=A Startling Discovery.= For a time Breuer and Freud worked together, +finding that their investigations with other patients served to +corroborate their former conclusions. When it became apparent that in +every case the painful experience bore some relation to the love-life +of the patient, both doctors were startled. Along with most of the +rest of the world, they had been taught to look askance at the +reproductive instinct and to shrink from realizing the vital place +which sex holds in human life. + +Breuer dropped the work, and after an interval Freud went on alone. He +was resolved to know the truth, and to tell what he saw. When he +reported to the world that out of all his hundreds of patients, he had +been unable, after the most careful analysis, to find one whose +illness did not grow from some lack of adjustment of the sex-life, he +was met by a storm of protest from all quarters. No amount of evidence +seemed to make any difference. People were determined that no such +libel should be heaped on human nature. Sex-urge was not respectable +and nervous people were to be respected. + +Despite public disapproval, the scorn of other scientists, and the +resistance of his own inner prejudices, Freud kept on. He was forced +to acknowledge the validity of the facts which invariably presented +themselves to view. Like Luther under equal duress, he cried: "Here I +stand. I can do no other." + +=Freudian Principles.= Gradually, as he worked, he gathered together a +number of outstanding facts about man's mental life and about the +psycho-neuroses. These facts he formulated into certain principles, +which may be summed up in the following way. + +1 There is no _chance_ in mental life; every mental phenomenon--hence +every nervous phenomenon--has a cause and meaning. + +2 Infantile mental life is of tremendous importance in the direction +of adult processes. + +3 Much of what is called forgetting is rather a repression into the +subconscious, of impulses which were painful to the personality as a +whole. + +4 Mental processes are dynamic, insisting on discharge, either in +reality or in phantasy. + +5 An emotion may become detached from the idea to which it belongs and +be displaced on other ideas. + +6 Sex-interests dominate much of the mental life where their influence +is unrecognized. The disturbance in a psycho-neurosis is always in +this domain of sex-life. "In a normal sexual life, no neurosis." If a +shock is the precipitating cause of the trouble, it is only because +the ground was already prepared by the sex-disturbance. + +Freud was perhaps unfortunate in his choice of the word "sex," which +has so many evil connotations; but as he found no other word to cover +the field, he chose the old one and stretched its meaning to include +all the psychic and physical phenomena which spring directly and +indirectly from the great processes of reproduction and parental care, +and which ultimately include all and more than our word "love."[33] + +[Footnote 33: Freud and his followers have always said that they saw +no theoretical reason why any other repressed instinct should not form +the basis of a neurosis, but that, as a matter of fact, they never had +found this to be the case, probably because no other instinct comes +into such bitter and persistent conflict with the dictates of society. +Now, however, the Great War seems to have changed conditions. Under +the strain and danger of life at the front there has developed a kind +of nervous breakdown called shellshock or war-neurosis, which seems in +some cases to be based not on the repression of the instinct of +race-preservation but on the unusual necessity for repression of the +instinct of self-preservation. Army surgeons report that wounded men +almost never suffer from shell-shock. The wound is enough to secure +the unconsciously desired removal to the rear. But in the absence of +wounds, a desire for safety may at the same time be so intense and so +severely repressed that it seizes upon the neurosis as the only +possible means of escape from the unbearable situation. In time of +peace, however, the instinct of reproduction seems to be the only +impulse which is severely enough repressed to be responsible for a +nervous breakdown.] + +=Later Developments.= Little by little, the scientific world came to +see that this wild theorizer had facts on his side; that not only had +he formulated a theory, but he had discovered a cure, and that he was +able to free people from obsessions, fears, and physical symptoms +before which other methods were powerless. One by one the open-minded +men of science were converted by the overpowering logic of the +evidence, until to-day we find not only a "Freudian school," counting +among its members many of the eminent scientists of the day, but we +find in medical schools and universities courses based on Freudian +principles, with text-books by acknowledged authorities in medicine +and psychology. We find magazines devoted entirely to psycho-analytic +subjects,[34] besides articles in medical journals and even numerous +articles in popular magazines. Not only is the treatment of nervous +disorders revolutionized by these principles but floods of light are +thrown on such widely different fields of study as ancient myths and +folk lore, the theory of wit, methods of child training, and the +little slips of the tongue and everyday "breaks" that have until +recently been considered the meaningless results of chance. + +[Footnote 34: _The Psychoanalytic Review_ and the _International +Journal of Psychoanalysis._] + +=A Searching Question.= We find, then, that when we ask, "What makes +people nervous?" we are really asking: "What is man like, inside and +out, up and down? What makes him think, feel, and act as he does every +hour of every day?" We are asking for the source of human motives, the +science of human behavior, the charting of the human mind. It is hard +to-day to understand how so much reproach and ridicule could have been +aroused by the statement that the ultimate cause of nervousness is a +disturbance of the sex-life. There has already been a change in the +public attitude toward things sexual. + +Training-courses for mothers and teachers, elementary teaching in the +schools, lectures and magazine articles have done much to show the +fallacy of our old hypersensitive attitude. Since the war, some of us +know, too, with what success the army has used the Freudian principles +in treating war-neurosis, which was mistakenly called shell-shock by +the first observers. We know, too, more about the constitution of +man's mind than the public knew ten years ago. When we remember the +insistent character of the instincts and the repressive method used by +society in restraining the most obstreperous impulse, when we remember +the pain of such conflict and the depressing physical effects of +painful emotions, we cannot wonder that this most sharply repressed +instinct should cause mental and physical trouble. + +=What about Sublimation?= On the other hand, it has been stated in +Chapter IV that although this universal urge cannot be repressed, it +can be sublimated or diverted to useful ends which bring happiness, +not disaster, to the individual. We have a right, then, to ask why +this happy issue is not always attained, why sublimation ever fails. +If a psycho-neurosis is caused by a failure of an insistent instinct +to find adequate expression, by a blocking of the libido or the +love-force, what are the conditions which bring about this blocking? +The sex-instinct of every respectable person is subject to restraint. +Some people are able to adjust themselves; why not all? The question, +"What makes people nervous?" then turns out to mean: What keeps people +from a satisfactory outlet for their love-instincts? What is it that +holds them back from satisfaction in direct expression, and prevents +indirect outlet in sublimation? Whatever does this must be the real +cause of "nerves." + + +THE CAUSES OF "NERVES" + +=Plural, not Singular.= The first thing to learn about the cause is +that it is not a cause at all, but several causes. We are so well made +that it takes a combination of circumstances to upset our equilibrium. +In other words, a neurosis must be "over-determined." Heredity, faulty +education, emotional shock, physical fatigue, have each at various +times been blamed for a breakdown. As a matter of fact, it seems to +take a number of ingredients to make a neurosis,--a little unstable +inheritance plus a considerable amount of faulty upbringing, plus a +later series of emotional experiences bearing just the right +relationship to the earlier factors. Heredity, childhood reactions, +and later experiences, are the three legs on which a neurosis usually +stands. An occasional breakdown seems to stand on the single leg of +childhood experiences but in the majority of cases each of the three +factors contributes its quota to the final disaster. + +=Born or Made?= It used to be thought that neurotics, like poets, were +born, not made. Heredity was considered wholly responsible, and there +seemed very little to do about it. But to-day the emphasis on heredity +is steadily giving way to stress on early environment. There are, no +doubt, such factors as a certain innate sensitiveness, a natural +suggestibility, an intensity of emotion, a little tendency to nervous +instability, which predispose a person to nerves, but unless the +inborn tendency is reinforced by the reactions and training of early +childhood, it is likely to die a natural death. + + +CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCES + +=Early Reactions.= Freud found that a neurotic is made before he is +six years old. When by repeated explorations into the minds of his +patients, he made this important discovery, he at first believed that +the disturbing factor was always some single emotional experience or +shock in childhood,--usually of a sexual nature. But Freud and later +investigators have since found that the trouble is not so often a +single experience as a long series of exaggerated emotional reactions, +a too intense emotional life, a precocity in feeling tending toward +fixation of childhood habits, which are thus carried over into adult +life. + +=Fixation of Habits.= Fixation is the word that expresses all +this,--fixation of childish habits. A neurotic is a person who made +such strong habits in childhood that he cannot abandon them in +maturity. He is too much ruled by the past. His unconscious emotional +thought-habits are the complexes which were made in childhood and +therefore lack the power of adaptation to mature life. + +We saw in Chapter IV that Nature takes great pains to develop in the +child the psychic and physical trends which he will need later on in +his mature love-life, and that this training is accomplished in a +number of well-defined periods which lead from one to the other. If, +however, the child reacts too intensely, lingers too long in any one +of these phases, he lays for himself action lines of least resistance +which he may never leave or to which he may return during the strain +and stress of adult life. + +In either case, the neurotic is a grown-up child. He may be a very +learned, very charming person, but he is nevertheless dragging behind +him a part of his childhood which he should have outgrown long ago. +Part of him is suffering from an arrest of development,--not a leg or +an arm but an impulse. + +=Precocious Emotions.= The habits which tend to become fixed too soon +seem to be of four kinds; the habit of loving, the habit of rebelling, +the habit of repressing normal instincts, and the habit of dreaming. +In each case it is the excess of feeling which causes the +trouble,--too much love, too much hate, too much disgust, or too much +pleasure in imagination. Exaggeration is always a danger-signal. An +overdeveloped child is likely to be an underdeveloped man. Especially +in the emotions is precocity to be deplored. A premature alphabet or +multiplication table is not nearly so serious as premature intensity +of feeling, nor so likely to lead later to trouble. Of course fixation +in these emotional habits does not always lead to a serious breakdown. +If the fixation is not too extreme, and if later events do not happen +to accentuate the trouble, the arrest of development may merely show +itself in certain weaknesses of character or in isolated symptoms +without developing a real neurosis. + +Let us examine each of these arrested habits and the excess emotion +which sets the mold before it is ready for maturity. + +=Too Much Self-Love.= In the chapter on the reproductive instinct, we +found that the natural way to learn to love is by successively loving +oneself, one's parents and family, one's fellows, and one's mate. If +the love-force gets too much pleasure in any one of these phases, it +finds it hard to give up its old love and to pass on to the next +phase. Thus some children take too much pleasure in their own bodies +or, a little later, in their own personalities. If they are too much +interested in their own physical sensations and the pleasure they get +by stimulating certain zones of the body, then in later life they +cannot free themselves from the desire for this kind of satisfaction. +Try as they may, they cannot be satisfied with normal adult relations, +but sink back into some form of so-called sex-perversion. + +Perhaps it is another phase of self-love which holds the child too +much. If, like Narcissus, he becomes too fond of looking at himself, +is too eager to show off, too desirous of winning praise, then forever +after he is likely to be self-conscious, self-centered, thinking +always of the impression he is making, unable ever to be at leisure +from himself. He is fixed in the Narcissistic stage of his life, and +is unadapted to the world of social relations. + +=Too Much Family-love.= We have already spoken of the danger of +fixation in the second period, that of object-love--the period of +family relationships. The danger is here again one of degree and may +be avoided by a little knowledge and self-control on the part of the +parents. The little girl who is permitted to lavish too much love on +her father, who does not see anybody else, who cannot learn to like +the boys is a misfit. The wise mother will see that her love for her +boy does not express itself too much by means of hugs and kisses. The +mother who shows very plainly that she loves her little boy better +than she loves her husband and the mother who boasts that her +adolescent boy tells her all his secrets and takes her out in +preference to any girl--that deluded mother is trying to take +something that is not hers, and is thereby courting trouble. When her +son grows up, he may not know why, but no girl will suit him, and he +will either remain a bachelor or marry some older woman who reminds +him subconsciously of his mother. His love-requirements will be too +strict; he will be forever trying either in phantasy or in real life +to duplicate his earlier love-experiences. This, of course, cannot +satisfy the demands of a mature man. He will be torn between +conflicting desires, unhappy without knowing why, unable either to +remain a child or to become a man, and impelled to gain +self-expression in indirect and unsatisfactory ways. + +Since it is not possible in this space to recite specific cases which +show how often a nervous trouble points back to the father-mother +complex,[35] it may help to cite the opinions of a few of our best +authorities. Freud says of the family complex, "This is the root +complex of the neurosis." Jelliffe: "It is the foot-rule of +measurement of success in life": by which he means that just so far as +we are able at the right time to free ourselves from dependence on +parents are we able to adjust ourselves to the world at large. +Pfister: "The attitude toward parents very often determines for a +life-time the attitude toward people in general and toward life +itself." Hinkle: "The entire direction of lives is determined by +parental relationships." + +[Footnote 35: This is technically known as the Oedipus Complex.] + +=Too Much Hate.= Besides loving too hard, there is the danger of +hating too hard. If it sounds strange to talk of the hatreds of +childhood, we must remember that we are thinking of real life as it is +when the conventions of adult life are removed and the subconscious +gives up its secrets. + +Several references have been made to the jealousy of the small child +when he has to share his love with the parent of the same sex. For +every little boy the father gets in the way. For every little girl the +mother gets in the way. At one time or other there is likely to be a +period when this is resented with all the violence of a child's +emotions. It is likely to be very soon repressed and succeeded by a +real affection which lasts through life. But underneath, unmodified by +time, there may exist simultaneously the old childish image and the +old unconscious reaction to it, unconscious but still active in +indirect ways. + +Jealousy is very often united with the natural rebellion of a child +against authority. The rebellion may, of course, be directed against +either parent who is final in authority in the home. In most cases +this is the father. As the impulse of self-assertion is usually +stronger in boys than in girls, and as the boy's impulse in this +direction is reinforced by any existing jealousy toward his father, we +find a strong spirit of rebellion more often playing a subconscious +part in the life of men than of women. The novelist's favorite theme +of the conflict between the young man and "the old man" represents the +conscious, unrepressed complex. More often, however, there is true +affection for the father, while the rebellion which really belongs to +the childish father-image is displaced or transferred to other symbols +of authority,--the state, the law, the king, the school, the teacher, +the church, or perhaps to religion and authority in general. +Anarchists and atheists naturally rationalize their reasons for +dissent, but, for all that, they are not so much intellectual pioneers +as rebellious little boys who have forgotten to grow up. + +=Liking to be "Bossed."= There is a worse danger, however, than too +much rebellion, and that is too little rebellion. Sometimes this +yielding spirit is the result of an overdose of negative self-feeling +and an under-dose of positive self-feeling; but sometimes it is +over-compensation for the repressed spirit of rebellion which the +child considers wicked. Consciously he becomes over-meek, because he +has to summon all his powers to fight his subconscious insurrection. +Whether he be meek by nature or by training, he is likely to be a +failure. Everybody knows that the child who is too good never amounts +to anything. He who has never disobeyed is a weakling. Naturally +resenting all authority, the normal individual, if he be well trained, +soon learns that some authority is necessary. He rebels, but he learns +to acquiesce, to a certain degree. If he acquiesces too easily, +represses too severely his rebellious spirit, swings to the other +extreme of wanting to be "bossed," he is very likely to end as a +nervous invalid, unfitted for the battles of life. The neurotic in the +majority of cases likes authority, clings to it too long, wants the +teacher to tell him what to do, wants the doctor to order him around, +is generally over-conscientious, and afraid he will offend the "boss" +or some one else who reminds him of the father-image. All this carries +a warning to parents who cannot manage their children without +dominating their lives, even when the domination is a kindly one. +Perhaps the modern child is in more danger of being spoiled than +bullied, but analysis of nervous patients shows that both kinds of +danger still exist. + +=Too Much Disgust.= The third form of excessive emotion is disgust. +The love-force, besides being blocked by a fixation of childish love +and of childish reactions toward authority, is very often kept from +free mature self-expression by a perpetuation of a childish reaction +against sex. We hardly need dwell longer on the folly of teaching +children to be ashamed of so inevitable a part of their own nature. +Disgust is a very strong emotion, and when it is turned against a part +of ourselves, united with that other strong impulse of self-regard and +incorporated into the conscience, it makes a Chinese wall of exclusion +against the baffled, misunderstood reproductive instinct, which is +thrust aside as alien. + +=Restraint versus Denial.= Repression is not merely restraint. It is +restraint plus denial. To the clamoring instinct we say not merely, +"No, you _may_ not," but "No, you _are_ not. You do not exist. Nothing +like you could belong to me." The woman with nausea (Chapter V) did +not say to herself: "You are a normal, healthy woman, possessed of a +normal woman's desires. But wait a while until the proper time comes." +Controlled by an immature feeling of disgust, she had said: "I never +thought it. It cannot be." + +The difference is just this. When an ungratifiable desire is honestly +faced and squarely answered, it is modified by other desires, chooses +another way of discharge, and ceases to be desire. When a desire is +repressed, it is still desire, unsatisfied, insistent, unmodifiable by +mature points of view, untouched by time, automatic, and capable of +almost any subterfuge in order to get satisfaction. A repressed desire +is buried, shut away from the disintegrating effects of sunlight and +air. While the rest of the personality is constantly changing under +the influence of new ideas, the buried complex lives on in its +immaturity, absolutely untouched by time. + +=Childish Birth-theories.= When a child's questions about where babies +come from are met by evasions, he is forced to manufacture his own +theories. His elders would laugh if they knew some of these theories, +but they would not laugh if they knew how often the childish ideas, +wide of the truth, furnish the material for future neuroses. Frink +tells the story of a young woman who had a compulsion for taking +drugs. Although not a drug-fiend in the usual sense, she was +constantly impelled to take any kind of drug she could obtain. It was +finally revealed that during her childhood she had tried hard to +discover how babies were made, and had at last concluded that they +grew in the mother as a result of some medicine furnished by the +doctor. The idea had long been forgotten, only to reappear as a +compulsion. The natural desire for a child was strong in her, but was +repressed as unholy in an unmarried woman. The associated childish +idea of drug-taking was not repellent to her moral sense and was used +as a substitute for the real desire to bear a child. + +Many of my patients have suffered from the effect of some such +birth-theories. One young girl, twenty years old, was greatly +afflicted with myso-phobia, or the fear of contamination. She spent +most of her time in washing her hands and keeping her hands and +clothing free from contamination by contact with innumerable harmless +objects. When cleaning her shoes on the grass, she would kneel so that +the hem of her skirt would touch the grass, lest some dust should fly +up under her clothes. After eating luncheon in the park with a girl +who had tuberculosis, she said that she was not afraid of tuberculosis +in the lungs, but asked if something like tuberculosis might not get +in and begin to grow somewhere else. Her life was full to overflowing +of such compulsive fears. + +As opportunity offered itself from day to day, I would catch her +compulsive ideas in the very act of expressing themselves, and would +pin her down as to the association and the source of her fear, always +taking care not to make suggestions or ask leading questions. She was +finally convinced out of her own mouth that her real fear was the idea +of something getting into her body and growing there. Then she told +how she had questioned her mother about the reproductive life and had +been put off with signs of embarrassment. For a long time she had been +afraid to walk or talk with a boy, because, not knowing how conception +might occur, she feared grave consequences. + +Very soon after the beginning of her conversations with me, the girl +realized that her fear was really a disguised desire that something +might be planted within and grow. With her new understanding of +herself, her compulsions promptly slipped away. She began to eat and +sleep, and to live a happy, natural life. + +=Chronic Repression.= It takes first-hand acquaintance with nervous +patients to realize how common are stories like these. Unnecessary +repressions based on false training are the cause of many a physical +symptom and mental distress which a little parental frankness might +have forestalled.[36] + +[Footnote 36: Parents who are eager to handle this subject in the +right way are often sincerely puzzled as to how to go about it. No +matter how complete their education, it is very likely to fail them at +this critical point. For the benefit of such parents, let it be said +with all possible emphasis that the first and most important step must +be a change in their own mental attitude. If there is left within them +the shadow of embarrassment on the subject of sex, their children will +not fail to sense the situation at once. A feeling of hesitation or a +tendency to apologize for nature makes a far deeper impression on the +child-mind than do the most beautiful of half-believed words on the +subject. And this impression, subtle and elusive as it may seem, is a +real and vital experience which is quite likely to color the whole of +the child's life. If you would give your children a fair start, you +must first get rid of your own inner resistances. After that, all will +be clear sailing. + +In the second place, take the earliest opportunity to bring up the +subject in a natural way. A young father told me recently that his +little daughter had asked her mother why she didn't have any lap any +more. "And of course your wife took that chance to tell her about the +baby that is coming," I said. "Oh, no," he answered, "she did nothing +of the kind. Mary is far too young to know about such things." There +are always chances if we are on the look out for them--and the earlier +the better. It has been noticed that children are never repelled by +the idea of any natural process unless the new idea runs counter to +some notion which has already been formed. The wise parent is the one +who gets in the right impression before some other child has had a +chance to plant the wrong one. + +Then, too, we elders are judged quite as much by what we do not say as +by what we do. Happy is the child who is not left to draw his own +conclusions from the silence and evasiveness of his parents. The +sex-instruction which children are getting in the schools is often +good, but it usually comes too late--the damage is always done before +the sixth year. + +When it comes to the exact words in which to explain the phenomena of +generation and birth each parent must naturally find his own way. The +main point is that we must tell the truth and not try to improve on +nature. If we say that the baby grows under the mother's heart and +later the child learns that this is not true, he inevitably gets the +idea that there is something not nice about the part of the body in +which the baby does grow. What could be wrong with the simple truth +that the father plants a tiny seed in the mother's body and that this +seed joins with another little seed already there and grows until it +is a real baby ready to come into the world? The question as to how +the father plants the seed need cause no alarm. If brothers and +sisters are brought up together with no artificial sense of false +modesty, they very early learn the difference between the male and the +female body. It is simple enough to tell the little child the function +of the male structure. And it is easy to explain that the seeds do not +grow until the little boy and girl have grown to be man and woman and +that the way to be well and to have fine strong children is to leave +the generative organs alone until that time. A sense of the dignity +and high purpose of these organs is far more likely to prevent +perversions--to say nothing of nervousness--than is an attitude of +taboo and silence.] + +A certain amount of repression is inevitable and useful, but a +neurotic is merely an exaggerated represser. He represses so much of +himself that it will not stay down.[37] He builds up a permanent +resistance which automatically acts as a dam to his normal sex +instinct and forces it into undesirable outlets. + +[Footnote 37: "A neurosis is a partial failure of repression." Frink: +_Morbid Fears and Compulsions_.] + +A resistance is a chronic repression, repression that has become fixed +and subconscious, a habit that has lost its flexibility and outlives +its usefulness. It is a fixation of repression, and is built out of an +over-strong complex or emotional thought habit, acquired during +childhood, incorporated into the conscience and carried over into +maturity, where it warps judgment and interferes with normal +development because it is fundamentally untrue and at variance with +the laws of nature. + +=Too Much Day-Dreaming.= The fourth habit which holds back the adult +from maturity and predisposes toward "nerves" is the habit of +imagination. It need hardly be said that a certain kind of imagination +is a good thing and one of man's greatest assets. But the essence of +day-dreaming is the exact opposite; it is the desire to see things as +they are not, but as we should like them to be,--not in order that we +may bring them to pass, but for the mere pleasure of dreaming. Instead +of turning a microscope or a telescope on the world of reality, as +positive imagination does, this negative variety refuses even to look +with the naked eye. To dream is easier than to do; to build up +phantasies is easier than to build up a reputation or a fortune; to +think a forbidden pleasure is easier than to sublimate. +"Pleasure-thinking" is not only easier than "reality-thinking,"--it is +the _older_ way. + +Children gratify many of their desires simply by imagining them +gratified. Much of the difficulty of later life might be avoided if +the little child could be taught to work for the accomplishment of his +pleasures rather than to dream of them. The normal child gradually +abandons this "pleasure-thinking" for the more purposeful thinking of +the actual world, but the child who loiters too long in the realm of +fancy may ever after find it hard to keep away from its borders. His +natural interest in sex, if artificially repressed, is especially +prone to satisfy itself by way of phantasy. + +=Turning back to Phantasy.= In later life, when the love-force for one +reason or another becomes too strong to be handled either directly or +indirectly in the real world, there comes the almost irresistible +impulse to regress to the infantile way and to find expression by +means of phantasy. After long experience Freud concluded that phantasy +lies at the root of every neurosis. Jung says that a sex-phantasy is +always at least one determiner of a nervous illness, and Jelliffe +writes that the essence of the neurosis is a special activity of the +imagination. + +Such a statement need not shock the most sensitive conscience. The +very fact that a neurosis breaks out is proof that the phantasies are +repellent to the owners of them and are thrust down into the +subconscious as unworthy. In fact, every neurosis is witness to the +strength of the human conscience. No phantasy could cause illness. It +is the phantasy plus the repression of it that makes the trouble, or +rather it is the conflict between the forces back of the phantasy and +the repression. The neurosis, then, turns out to be a "flight from the +real," the result of a desire to run away from a difficulty. When a +problem presses or a disagreeable situation is to be faced, it is +easier to give up and fall ill than to see the thing through to the +end. Here again, we find that nervousness is a regression to the +irresponsible reactions of childhood. + +=Maturity versus Immaturity.= We have been thinking of the main causes +of "nerves" and have found them to be infantile habits of loving, +rebelling, repressing, and dreaming. We have tried to show that these +habits are able to cause trouble because of their bearing on that +inevitable conflict between the ancient urge of the reproductive +instinct and the later ideals which society has acquired. If this +conflict be met in the light of the present, free from the backward +pull, of outgrown habits, an adjustment is possible which satisfies +both the individual and society. We call this adjustment sublimation. +This is rather a synthesis than a compromise, a union of the opposing +forces, a happy utilization of energy by displacement on more useful +ideas. But if the conflict has to be met with the mind hampered by +immature thinking and immature feeling; if the demands of the +here-and-now are met as if it were long ago; if unhealthy and untrue +complexes, old loves and hates complicate the situation; if to the +necessary conflict is added an unnecessary one; then something else +happens. Compromise of some kind must be made, but instead of a happy +union of the two forces a poor compromise is effected, gaining a +partial satisfaction for both sides, but a real one for neither. The +neurosis is this compromise. + + +LATER EXPERIENCES + +=The Last Straw.= The precipitating cause may be one of a number of +things. It may be entirely within, or it may be external. Perhaps it +is only a quickening of the maturing instincts at the time of +adolescence, making the love-force too strong to be held by the old +repressions. Perhaps the husband, wife, or lover dies, or the +life-work is taken away, depriving the vital energy of its usual +outlets. Perhaps the trigger is pulled by an emotional shock which +bears a faint resemblance to old emotional experiences, and which +stimulates both the repressing and repressed trends and makes the +person at the same time say both "Yes," and "No."[38] Perhaps +physical fatigue lets down the mental and moral tension and makes the +conflict too strong to be controlled. Perhaps an external problem +presses and arouses the old habit of fleeing from disagreeable +reality. Any or all these factors may cooperate, but not one of them +is anything more than a last straw on an overburdened back. No +calamity, deprivation, fatigue, or emotion has been able to bring +about a neurosis unless the ground was prepared for it by the earlier +reactions of childhood. + +[Footnote 38: "The external world can only cause repression when there +was already present beforehand a strong initial tension reaching back +even to childhood."--Pfister: _Psychoanalytic Method_, p. 94.] + + +THE BREAKDOWN ITSELF + +="Two Persons under One Hat."= We can understand now why a neurotic +can be described in so many ways. We often hear him called an +especially moral, especially ethical person, with a very active +conscience; an intensely social being, unable to be satisfied with +anything but a social standard; a person with "finer intellectual +insight and greater sensitiveness than the rest of mankind." At the +same time we are told that a neurosis is a partial triumph of +anti-social, non-moral factors, and that it is a cowardly flight from +reality; we hear a nervous invalid called selfish, unsocial, shut in, +primitive, childish, self-deceived. Both these descriptions are true +to life. A neurosis is an ethical struggle between these two sets of +forces. If the lower set had triumphed, the man would have been merely +weak; if the higher set had been victorious, he would have been +strong. As it is, he is neither one nor the other,--only nervous. The +neurosis is the only solution of the struggle which he is able to +find, and serves the purpose of a sort of armed armistice between the +two camps. + + +SERVING A PURPOSE + +If a neurosis is a compromise, if it is the easiest way out, if it +serves a purpose, it must be that the individual himself has a hand in +shaping that purpose. Can it be that a breakdown which seems such an +unmitigated disaster is really welcomed by a part of our own selves? +Nothing is more intensely resented by the nervous invalid than the +accusation that he likes his symptoms,--and no wonder. The conscious +part of him hates the pain, the inconvenience, and the disability with +a real hatred. It is not pleasant to be ill. And yet, as it turns out, +it is pleasanter to be ill than it is to bear the tension of +unsatisfied desire or to be undeceived about oneself. Every symptom is +a means of expression for repressed and forgotten impulses and is a +relief to the personality. It tends to the preservation of the +individual, rather than to his destruction. The nervous invalid is not +short-lived, but his family may be! It has been said that a neurosis +is not so much a disease as a dilemma. Rather might it be said that +the neurosis is a way out of the dilemma. It is a harbor after a +stormy sea, not always a quiet harbor, but at least a usable one. +Unpleasant as it is, every nervous symptom is a form of compensation +which has been deliberately though unconsciously chosen by its owner. + +=Rationalizing Our Distress.= Among other things, a nervous symptom +furnishes a seemingly reasonable excuse for the sense of distress +which is behind every breakdown. Something troubles us. We are not +willing to acknowledge what it is. On the other hand, we must appear +reasonable to ourselves, so we manufacture a reason. Perhaps at the +time when the person first feels distress, he is on a railroad train. +So he says to himself, "It is the train. I must not go near the +railway"; and he develops a phobia for cars. Perhaps at the onset of +the fear he happens to have a slight pain in the arm. He makes use of +the pain to explain his distress. He thinks about it and holds on to +it. It serves a purpose, and is on the whole less painful than the +feeling of unexplained impending disaster which is attached to no +particular idea. Perhaps he happens to be tired when the conflict +first gets beyond control. So he seizes the idea of fatigue to explain +his illness. He develops chronic fatigue and talks proudly of +overwork. In every case the symptom serves a real purpose, and is, +despite its discomfort, a relief to the distressed personality. + +A neurosis is a subconscious effort at adjustment. Like a physical +symptom, it is Nature's way of trying to cure herself. It is an +attempt to get equilibrium, but it is an awkward attempt and hardly +the kind that we would choose when we see what we are doing. + +=Securing an Audience.= Besides furnishing relief from too intense +strain, a nervous breakdown brings secondary advantages that are at +most only dimly recognized by the individual. One of the most intense +cravings of the primitive part of the subconscious is for an audience; +a nervous symptom always secures that audience. The invalid is the +object of the solicitous care of the family, friends, physician, and +specialist. Pomp and ceremony, so dear to the child-mind, make their +appeal to the dissociated part of the personality. The repressed +instincts, hungry for love and attention, delight in the petting and +special care which an illness is sure to bring. Secretly and +unconsciously, the neurotic takes a certain pleasure in all the +various changes that are made for his benefit,--the dismantling of +striking clocks, the muffling of household noises, the banishing of +crowing roosters, and the changes in menu which must be carefully +planned for his stomach. + +This characteristic of finding pleasure in personal ministrations is +plainly a regression to the infantile phase of life. The baby demands +and obtains the center of the stage. Later he has to learn to give it +up, but the neurotic gets the center again and is often very loth to +leave it for a more inconspicuous place. + +=Capitalizing an Illness.= Then, too, a neurosis provides a way of +escape from all sorts of disagreeable duties. It can be capitalized in +innumerable ways,--ways that would horrify the invalid if he realized +the truth. Much of the resentment manifested against the suggestion +that the neurosis is psychic in origin is simply a resistance against +giving up the unconsciously enjoyed advantages of the illness. An +honest desire to get well is a long step toward cure. + +The purposive character of a nervous illness is well illustrated by +two cases reported by Thaddeus Hoyt Ames.[39] A young woman, the +drudge of the family, suddenly became hysterically blind, that is, she +became blind despite the fact that her eyes and optic nerves proved to +be unimpaired. She remained blind until it was proved to her that a +part of her welcomed the blindness and had really produced it for the +purpose of getting away from the monotony of her unappreciated life at +home. She naturally resented the charge but finally accepted it and +"turned on" her eyesight in an instant. The other patient, a man, +became blind in order to avoid seeing his wife who had turned out to +be not at all what he had hoped. When he realized what he was doing, +he decided that there might be better ways of adjusting himself to his +wife. He then switched on his seeing power, which had never been +really lost, but only disconnected and dissociated from the rest of +his mind. + +[Footnote 39: Thaddeus Hoyt Ames: _Archives of Ophthalmology_, Vol. +XLIII, No. 4, 1914.] + +That the conscious mind has no part in the subterfuge is shown by the +fact that both patients gave up their artificial haven as soon as they +saw how they had been fooling themselves. The fact remains that every +neurosis is the fulfilment of a wish,--a distorted, unrecognized, +unsatisfactory fulfilment to be sure, but still an effort to satisfy +desire. As Frink remarks, "A neurosis is a kind of behaviour." We +always choose the conduct we like. It is a matter of choice. Does not +this answer our question as to why some people always take unhealthy +suggestions? If we take the bad one, it is because it serves the need +of a part of our being. + + +SIGN LANGUAGE + +=Talking in Symbols.= We have several times suggested that a nervous +symptom is a disguised, indirect expression of subconscious impulses. +It is the completeness of the disguise which makes it so hard for us +to realize its true meaning. It takes a stretch of the imagination to +believe that a pain in the body can mean a pain in the soul, or that +a fear of contamination can signify a desire to bear a child. But in +all this we must not forget the primitive, childlike nature of the +instinctive life. + +The savage and the child do not think as civilized man thinks. Savage +or child thinks in pictures; he acts his feelings; he groups things +according to superficial resemblances, he expresses an idea by its +opposite; he talks in symbols. We still use these devices in poetic +speech and in everyday thought. A wedding-ring stands for the marriage +bond; the flag for a nation; a greyhound for fleetness; a wild beast +for ferocity; sunrise for youth; and sunset for old age. "The essence +of language consists in the statement of resemblance. The expression +of human thought is an expression of association."[40] + +[Footnote 40: Trigant Burrow: _Journal of American Medical +Association_, Vol. LXVI, No. II, 1916.] + +The association may be so accidental and superficial as to seem absurd +to another person, or it may be so fundamental as to express the +universal thought of man from the beginning of time. Many of the signs +and symbols which crop out in neurotic symptoms and in normal dreams +are the same as those which appear in myths, fairy tales and folk-lore +and in the art of the earlier races. + +=A Secret Code.= When the denied instincts of a man's repressed life +insist on expression, and when the shocked proprieties of his +repressing life demand conformity to social standards, the +subconscious, held back from free speech, strikes a compromise by +making use of figurative language. As Trigant Burrow says, if the +moral repugnance is very strong, the disguise must be more elaborate, +the symbols more far-fetched. The symbols of nervous symptoms and of +dreams are a "secret code," understood by the sender but meaningless +to the censoring conscience, which passes them as harmless. + +=The Right Kind of Symbolism.= Sublimation itself is merely a symbolic +expression of basic impulses. It follows the line of our make-up, +which naturally and fundamentally is wont to let one thing stand for +another and to express itself in indirect ways. Sublimation says: "If +I cannot recreate myself in the person of a child, I will recreate +myself in making a bridge, or a picture, or a social settlement,--or a +pudding." It says: "If I cannot have my own child to love, I will +adopt an orphan-asylum, or I will work for a child-labor law." It +merely lets one thing stand for another and transfers all the passions +that belong to the one on to the other, which is the same thing as +saying that it gives vent to its original desire by means of symbolic +expression. + +=The Wrong Kind of Symbolism.= A nervous disorder is an unfortunate +choice of symbols. Instead of spiritualizing an innate impulse, it +merely disguises it. The disguise takes a number of forms. One of the +commonest ways is to act out in the body what is taking place in the +soul. The woman with nausea converted her moral disgust into a +physical nausea, which expressed her distress while it hid its +meaning. The girl who was tired of seeing her work, and the man who +wanted to avoid seeing his wife chose a way out which physically +symbolized their real desire. A dentist once came to me with a +paralyzed right arm. He had given up his office and believed that he +would never work again. It turned out that his only son had just died +and that he was dramatizing his soul-pain by means of his body. His +subconscious mind was saying, "My good right arm is gone," and saying +it in its own way. Within a week the arm was playing tennis, and ever +since it has been busy filling teeth. There were, of course, other +factors leading up to the trouble, but the factor which determined its +form was the sense of loss which acted itself out through the body. + +Sometimes, as we have seen, the disguise takes another form. Instead +of conversion into a physical symptom, it lets one idea stand for +another and displaces the impulse or the emotion to the substitute +idea. The girl with the impulse to take drugs fooled her conscience by +letting the drug-taking idea stand for the idea of conception. The +girl with the fear of contamination carried the disguise still +farther by changing the desire into fear,--a very common subterfuge. + +=The Case of Mrs. Y.= There came to me a short time ago a little woman +whose face showed intense fright. For several months she had spent +much of the time walking the floor and wringing her hands in an agony +of terror. In the night she would waken from her sleep, shaking with +fear; soon she would be retching and vomiting, although she herself +recognized the fact that there was nothing the matter with her +stomach. + +Part of the time her fear was a general terror of some unknown thing, +and part of the time it was a specialized fear of great intensity. She +was afraid she would choke her son, to whom she was passionately +devoted. During the course of the treatment, which followed the lines +of psycho-analysis to be described in the next chapter, I found that +this fear had arisen one evening when she was lying reading by the +side of her sleeping child. Suddenly, without warning, she had a sort +of mental picture of her own hands reaching out and choking the boy. +Naturally she was terrified. She jumped out of bed, decided that she +was losing her mind and went into a hysterical state which her husband +had great trouble in dispelling. After that she was afraid to be left +alone with her children lest she should kill them. + +During the analysis it was discovered that what she had been reading +on that first night was the thirteenth verse of the ninety-first +Psalm. "Thou shalt tread upon the lion and the adder. The young lion +and the dragon thou shalt trample under foot." To her the adder meant +the snake, the tempter in the Garden of Eden, and hence sex. What she +wanted to choke was her own insistent sex urge of which the child was +the symbol and the result. On later occasions she had the same sort of +hallucinations in connection with another child and on sight of a +brutish kind of man who symbolized to the subconscious mind the +sex-urge, of which she was afraid. Not so much by what her mother had +said as by what she had avoided saying, and by her expression whenever +the subject was mentioned, had she given her little daughter a +fundamentally wrong idea of the reproductive instinct. Later when the +girl was woman grown she still clung to the old conception, deploring +the sex-part of the marriage relation and feeling herself too refined +to be moved by any such sensual urge. But the strong sex-instinct +within her would not be downed. It was so insistent as to be an object +of terror to her repressing instinct, which could not bring itself to +acknowledge its presence. The fear that came to the surface was merely +a disguised and symbolic representation of this real fear which was +turning her life into a nightmare. + +The nausea and vomiting in this woman seemed to be symbolic of the +disgust which she felt subconsciously at the thought of her own +sex-desires, but sometimes the physical disturbances which accompany +such phobias are the natural physical reactions to the constant fear +state. Indigestion, palpitation, and tremors are not in themselves +symbolic of the inner trouble but may be the result of an overdose of +the adrenal and thyroid secretions and the other accompaniments of +fear. In such cases the real symptom is the fear, and the physical +disturbance an incidental by-product of the emotional state. In any +case a nervous symptom is always the sign of something else--a +hieroglyph which must be deciphered before its real meaning can be +discovered. + + +SUMMARY + +=Three Kinds of People.= Absurd as it sounds, "nerves" turn out to be +a question of morals; a neurosis, an affair of conscience; a nervous +symptom an unsettled ethical struggle. The ethical struggle is not +unusual; it is a normal part of man's life, the natural result of his +desire to change into a more civilized being. The people in the world +may be divided into three classes, according to the way they decide +the conflict. + +=The Primitive.= The first class merely capitulate to their primitive +desires. They may not be nervous, but it is safe to say that they are +rarely happy. The voice of conscience is hard to drown, even when it +is not strong enough to control conduct. Happily it often succeeds in +making us miserable, when we desert the ways that have proved best for +our kind. The "immoral" person has not yet "arrived"; he simply +disregards the collective wisdom of society and gives the victory to +the primitive forces which try to keep man back on his old level. We +cannot break the ideals by which man lives, and still be happy. + +=The Salt of the Earth.= The second class of people decide the +conflict in a way that satisfies both themselves and society. They +give the victory to the higher trends and at the same time make a +lasting peace by winning over the energy of the undesirable impulses. +By sublimation they divert the threatening force to useful work and +turn it out into real life, using its steam to make the world's wheels +go round. Their love-force, unhampered by childish habits, is free to +give itself to adult relationships or to express itself symbolically +in socially helpful ways. + +=Nervous People.= To the third class belong the people who have not +finished the fight. These are the folk with "nerves," the people in +whom the conflict is fiercest because both sides are too strong. The +victory goes to neither side; the tug of war ends in a tie. Since the +energy of the nervous person is divided between the effort to repress +and the effort to gain expression, there is little left for the +external world. There is plenty of energy wasted on emotion, physical +symptoms, phantasy, or useless acts symbolizing the struggle. + +A neurotic is a normal person, "only more so." His impulses are the +same impulses as those of every other person; his complexes are the +same kind of complexes, only more intense. He is an exaggerated human +being. He may be only slightly exaggerated, showing merely a little +character-weakness or a slight physical symptom, or he may be so +intensified as to make life miserable for himself and everybody near +him. It is quantity, not quality, that ails him, for he differs from +his steady-going neighbor not in kind but in degree. More of him is +repressed and a larger part of him is fixed in a childish mold. + +=Tricking Ourselves.= A neurosis is a confidence game that we play on +ourselves. It is an attempt to get stolen fruit and to look pious at +the same time,--not in order to fool somebody else but to fool +ourselves. + +No nervous symptom is what it seems to be. It is an arch pretender. It +pretends to be afraid of something it does not fear at all, or to +ignore something that interests it intensely. It pretends to be a +physical disease, when primarily it has nothing to do with the body; +and the person most deluded is the one who "owns" the symptom. Its +purpose is to avoid the pain of disillusionment and to furnish relief +to a distracted soul which dares not face itself. + +Although the true meaning of a symptom is hidden, there is fortunately +a clue by which it can be traced. Sometimes it takes the art of a +psychic detective to follow the clues down, down through the different +layers of the subconscious mind, until the troublesome impulses and +complexes are found and dragged forth,--not to be punished for +breaking the peace but to be led toward reconciliation. But "that is +another story," and belongs to another chapter. We are approaching THE +WAY OUT. + +PART III--THE MASTERY OF "NERVES" + + + + +CHAPTER VIII + +_In which we pick up the clue_ + +THE WAY OUT + +THE SCIENCE OF RE-EDUCATION + + +There is a story of an Irishman at the World's Fair in Chicago. +Although his funds were getting low, he made up his mind that he would +not go home without a ride on a camel. For several minutes he stood +before a sign reading: "First ride 25c, second ride 15c, third ride +10c." Then, scratching his head, he exclaimed, "Faith, and I'll take +the third ride!" Should there by any chance be a reader who, eager to +find the way out without paying the price of knowledge, is tempted to +say to himself "Faith, and I'll begin with Part III," we give him fair +warning that if he does so, he will in all probability end by putting +down the book in a confused and skeptical frame of mind. + +It is difficult to find our way out of a maze without some faint idea +of the path by which we got in. He who brings to this chapter the +popular notion that nervousness is the result of worn-out +nerve-cells, can hardly be expected to understand how it can be cured +by a process of mental adjustment. Suggestion to that effect can +scarcely fail to appear to him faddish and unpractical. But once a +person has grasped the idea that "nerves" are merely a slip in the cog +of hidden mental machinery, and has acquired at least a +working-knowledge of "the way the wheels go round," he can scarcely +fail to understand that the only logical cure must consist in some +kind of readjustment of this underground machinery. If "nerves" were +physical, then only physical measures could cure, but as they are +psychic, the only effective measures must be psychic. + +=Gross Misconceptions.= Nervousness is caused by a lack of adjustment +to the world as it is; therefore the only possible cure must be some +sort of readjustment between the person's inner forces and the demands +of the social world. As this lack of adjustment is concerned chiefly +with the repressed instinct of reproduction, it is only natural that +there should be people who believe that "the way out" lies in some +form of physical satisfaction of the sex-impulse--in marriage, in +changing or ignoring the social code, in homo-sexual relations or in +the practice of masturbation. But we have only to look about us to see +that this prescription does not cure. Freud naively asks whether he +would be likely to take three years to uncover and loosen the psychic +resistances of his patients, if the simple prescription of sex-license +would give relief. + +Since there are as many married neurotics as single, it is evident +that even marriage is not a sure preventive of nervousness. License, +on the other hand, can satisfy only a part of the individual's +craving. Freud insists that the sex-instinct has a psychic component +as well as a physical one, and that it is this psychic part which is +most often repressed. He maintains that for complete satisfaction +there must be psychic union between mates, and that gratification of +the physical component of sex when dissociated from psychic +satisfaction, results in an accumulation of tension that reacts badly +on the whole organism. + +The psychic tension accumulating in adult sex-relations has its +inception in the mistaken attitude on the part of the wife, who +remains true to her childhood training that any pleasure in sex is +vulgar; or on the part of the man, who reacts to the mood of the wife, +or is held by his own unbroken mother-son complex; or on the part of +both the tension piles up because of society's taboo upon rearing +large families. As the first two factors in this lack of adjustment +grew largely out of some kind of faulty education or from faulty +reaction to early experiences, the only effective way to secure a +better adaptation must be through a re-education which reaches down +to that part of the personality that bears the stamp of the +unfortunate early factors. + +=Remaking Ourselves.= As a matter of fact, the science of +psychotherapy or mental treatment is simply the science of +re-education,--a process designed to break up old unhealthy complexes +which disrupt the forces of the individual, and to build up healthy +complexes which adjust him to the social world and enable him to use +his energy in useful ways. + +Fortunately, minds can be changed. It is easier to make over an +unhealthy complex than to make over a weak heart, to straighten out a +warped idea than to straighten a bent back. Remarkable indeed have +been some of the transformations in people who are supposed to have +passed the plastic period in life. While it is true that some persons +become "set" in middle life, and almost impervious to new ideas, it is +also true that a person at fifty has more richness of experience upon +which to draw, more appreciation of the value of the good, than has a +person at twenty. If he really wants to change himself, he can do +wonderful things by re-education. + +The first step in this re-education is a grasp of the facts. If you +want to pull yourself out of a nervous disorder, first of all learn as +much as you can about the causes of "nerves," about the general laws +of mind and body, and about your own mental quirks. If this is not +sufficient, go to a specialist trained in psychotherapy and let him +help you uncover those trouble-making parts of your personality which +you cannot find for yourself. It is the purpose of this book to +summarize the facts which most need to be known. Let us now consider +those methods which the psychopathologist finds most useful in helping +his patients to self-knowledge and readjustment. + +=Various Methods.= As there are a number of schools of medicine, so +there are a number of distinct methods of psychotherapy, each with its +own theories and methods of procedure, and each with its ardent +supporters. These methods may be classified into two groups. The first +group includes those methods, hypnosis and psycho-analysis, which make +a thorough search through the subconscious mind for the buried +complexes causing the trouble, and might, therefore, be called +"re-education with subconscious exploration." The other group, +includes so-called explanation and suggestion, or methods of +"re-education without subconscious exploration," which content +themselves with making a general survey and building up new complexes +without going to the trouble of uncovering the buried past. Although +the theory and the technique vary greatly, the aim of all these +methods is the same,--the readjustment of the individual to life. + +RE-EDUCATION WITH SUBCONSCIOUS EXPLORATION + +=Hypnosis.= The method by which most of the important early +discoveries were made is hypnosis, or artificial sleep, a method by +which the conscious mind is dissociated and the subconscious brought +to the fore. It was through hypnosis that Freud, Janet, Prince, and +Sidis made their first investigations into the nature of nervousness +and worked their first cures. With the conscious mind asleep and its +inhibitions out of the way, a hypnotized patient is often able to +remember and to disclose to the physician hidden complexes of which he +is unaware when awake. Hypnosis may thus be a valuable aid to +diagnosis, enabling the physician to determine the cause of +troublesome symptoms. He may then begin to make suggestions calculated +to break up the old complexes and to build new ones, made up of more +healthful ideas, desirable emotions and happy feeling-tones. As we +have seen, a hypnotized subject is highly suggestible. His +counter-suggestions inactivated, he believes almost anything told him +and is extremely susceptible to the doctor's influence. + +The dangers of hypnosis have been much exaggerated. Indeed, as an +instrument in the hands of a competent physician, it is not to be +feared at all. It has, however, its limitations. Many times the very +memories which need to be unearthed refuse to come to the surface. +Stubborn resistances are more likely to be subconscious than +conscious, and may prove too strong to be overcome in this way. +Moreover, the road to superficial success is very inviting. It is easy +to cure the symptom, leaving the ultimate cause untouched and ready to +break out in new manifestations. The drug and drink habits may be +broken up without making any attempt to discover the unsatisfied +longings which were responsible for the habit. A pain may be cured +without finding the mental cause of the pain or initiating any +measures to guard against its return, and without giving the patient +any insight into the inner forces with which he still has to deal. + +Since nervousness is a state of exaggerated suggestibility and +abnormal dissociation, many psychologists believe that it is unwise to +employ a method which heightens the state of suggestibility and +encourages the habit of dissociation. They feel that it is wiser to +use less artificial methods which rest on the rational control of the +conscious mind and make the patient better acquainted with his own +inner forces and more permanently able to cope with new manifestations +of those forces. They believe that the character of the patient is +strengthened and his morale raised by methods which increase the +sovereignty of reason and decrease the role of unreasoning +suggestibility. + +=Psycho-Analysis.= Freud's contribution has been not only a discovery +of the general causes of nervousness, but a special means of locating +the cause in any particular case. Abandoning hypnosis, he developed +another method which he called psycho-analysis. What chemical analysis +is to chemistry, psycho-analysis is to the science of the mind. It +splits up the mental content into its component parts, the better to +be examined and modified by the conscious mind. Psycho-analysis is +merely a technical process for discovering repressed complexes and +bringing them into consciousness, where they may be recognized for +what they are and altered to meet the demands of real life. It is a +device for finding and removing the cause of nervousness,--for +bringing to light hidden desires which may be honestly faced and +efficiently directed instead of being left to seethe in dangerous +insurrection. In order permanently to break up a real neurosis, a man +must first know himself and then change himself. He must gain insight +into his own mental processes and then systematically set to work to +change those processes that unfit him for life. + +We shall later find that a detailed self-discovery through +psycho-analysis is not always necessary, and that a more general +understanding of oneself is sufficient for the milder kinds of +nervousness. But because of the promise which psycho-analysis holds +out to those stubborn cases before which other methods are powerless; +because of the invaluable understanding of human nature which it +places at the disposal of all nervous people, who may profit by its +findings without undergoing an analysis; and because of the flood of +light which it sheds on the motives, conduct, and character of every +human being, no educated person can afford to be without a general +knowledge of psycho-analysis.[41] + +[Footnote 41: It is unfortunate that the records of an analysis are +too voluminous for use in so brief an account as this. Since the +report of one case would fill a book, and a condensed summary would +require a chapter, we must refer to some of the volumes which deal +exclusively with the psychoanalytic principles. For a list of these +books, see Bibliography.] + +=A Chain of Associations.= Psycho-analysis is not, like hypnosis, +based on dissociation; it is based on the association of ideas. Its +main feature is a process of uncritical thinking called "free +association." To understand it, one must realize how intricately woven +together are the thoughts of a human being and how trivial are the +bonds of association between these ideas. One person reminds us of +another because his hair is the same color or because he handles his +fork in the same way. Two words are associated because they sound +alike. Two ideas are connected because they once occurred to us at the +same time. A subtle odor or a stray breeze serves to remind us of some +old experience. Connections that seem far-fetched to other people may +be quite strong enough to bind together in our minds ideas and +emotions which have once been associated, even unconsciously, in past +experience. + +In this way, thoughts in consciousness and in the upper layers of the +subconscious are connected by a series of associations, forming links +in invisible chains that lead to the deepest, most repressed ideas. +Even a dissociated complex has some connection with the rest of the +mind, if we only have the patience to discover it. Therefore, by +adopting a passive attitude, by simply letting his thoughts wander, by +talking out to the physician everything that comes to his mind without +criticizing or calling any thought irrelevant or far-fetched, and +without rejecting any thought because of its painful character, the +patient is helped to trace down and unearth the troublesome complex +which may have been absolutely forgotten for many years. He is helped +to relive the childhood experiences back of the over-strong habits +which lasted into maturity. + +=Resisting the Probe.= Naturally, it is not all fair sailing. The +subconscious impulses which repressed the painful complex in the first +place still shrink from uncovering it. In many cases the resistance is +very strong. It, therefore, often happens that after a time the +patient becomes restive; he begins to criticize the doctor and to +ridicule the method. His mind goes blank and no thought will come; or +he refuses to tell what does come. The nearer the probe comes to the +sore spot, the greater the pain of the repressing impulses and the +stronger the resistance. Usually a strange thing happens; the patient, +instead of consciously remembering the forgotten experiences, begins +to relive them with his original emotions transferred on to the +doctor. Depending upon what person of his childhood he identifies with +him, the patient develops either a strong affection or an intense +antagonism to the physician, attitudes called in technical terms +positive and negative transference. If the analyst is skilful, he is +able to circumvent all the subterfuges of the resisting forces and to +uncover and modify the troublesome complexes. Sometimes this can be +accomplished at one sitting, but more often it requires long hours of +conversation. Freud has spent three years on a single difficult case, +and very frequently the analysis drags out through weeks or months. +The amount of mental material is so great, especially in a person who +is no longer young, that every analysis would probably be an +interminable affair if it were not for three valuable ways of finding +the clue and picking up the scent somewhere near the end of the trail. +The first of these clues is nothing else than so despised a phenomenon +as the patient's own night-dreams, which turn out to be not +meaningless jargon, as we have supposed, but significant utterances of +the inner man. + +=The Message of the Dream.= When Freud rescued dreams from the mental +scrap-basket and learned how to piece them together so that their +message to man about himself became for the first time intelligible, +he furnished the human race with what will probably be considered its +most valuable key to the hidden mysteries of the mind. Freeing the +dream from the superstition of olden times and from the neglect of +later days, Freud was the first to discover that it is part and parcel +of man's mental life, that it has a purpose and a meaning and that the +meaning may be scientifically deciphered. It then invariably reveals +itself to be not a prophecy for the future but an interpretation of +the present and of the past, an invaluable synopsis of the drama which +is being staged within the personality of the dreamer. + +As modern man has swung away from the idea of the dream as a warning +or a prophecy, he has accepted the even more untrue conception of +dreaming as the mere sport of sleep,--the "babble of the mind," the +fantastic and insignificant freak-play of undirected mental processes, +or the result of physical sensations without relation to the rest of +mental life. No wonder, then, that Freud's startling dictum, "A dream +is a disguised fulfilment of a repressed wish," should be met with +astonishment and incredulity. When a person is confronted for the +first time with this statement, he invariably begins to cite dreams in +which he is pursued by wild beasts, or in which his loved ones are +seen lying dead. He then triumphantly asserts that no such dream +could be the fulfilment of a wish. + +The trouble is that he has overlooked the word "disguised." Like wit +and some figures of speech, a dream says something different from what +it means. It deals in symbols. Its "manifest content" may be merely a +fantastic and impossible scene without apparent rhyme or reason, but +the "latent content," the hidden meaning, always expresses some urgent +personal problem. Although the dream may seem to be impersonal and +unemotional, it nevertheless deals in every case with some matter of +vital concern to the dreamer himself. It is a condensed and composite +picture of some present problem and of some related childish repressed +wish which the experiences of the preceding day have aroused. + +As Frink says, a dream is like a cartoon with the labels +omitted--absolutely unintelligible until its symbols are interpreted. +Although some dreams whose symbolism is that which man has always +used, can be easily understood by a person who knows, many dreams are +meaningless, even to an experienced analyst, until the patient himself +furnishes the labels by telling what each bit of the picture brings to +his mind. The dream, as a rule, merely furnishes the starting-point +for free association. + +Each symbol is an arrow pointing the way to forbidden impulses which +are repressed in waking life but which find partial expression during +sleep. The subconscious part of the conscience is still on the job, so +the repressed desires can express themselves only in distorted ways +which will not arouse the censor and disturb sleep. The purpose of the +dream is thus two-fold,--to relieve the tensions of unsatisfied +desire, and to do this in such a subtle way as to keep the dreamer +asleep. Sometimes it fails of its purpose, but when there is danger of +our discovering too much about ourselves, we immediately wake up, +saying that we have had a bad dream. + +It is at first difficult to believe that we are capable of this +elaborate mental work while we are fast asleep. However, a little +investigation shows us to be more clever than we realize. The +subconscious mind, in its effort to satisfy both the repressing and +the repressed impulses, carries on very complicated processes, +disguises material by allowing one person to stand for another, two +persons to stand for one, or one person to stand for two; it shifts +emotion from important to trivial matters, dramatizes, condenses, and +elaborates, with a skill that is amazing. We are all of us very clever +playwrights and makers of allegories--in our sleep. Also, we are all +very clever at getting what we want, and the dream secures for us, in +a way, something which we want very much indeed and which the world +of social restraint or our own warped childish notion denies us. + +Not every one can become an interpreter of dreams. It takes a skilled +and patient specialist thoroughly to understand the process. But it is +fortunate indeed that we possess such a valuable means of diagnosis +when extraordinary conditions make it necessary to explore the +subconscious in the search for trouble-making complexes.[42] + +[Footnote 42: For further study of the dream, see Freud: +_Interpretation of Dreams_; and _General Introduction to +Psycho-Analysis_.] + +=The Word-Test.= Although dreams furnish the main clues to buried +complexes, they are by no means the only instrument of the +psycho-analyst. Another device, called the association word-test, has +been developed by Dr. Carl Jung of Switzerland. The analyst prepares a +list of perhaps one hundred words, which he reads one by one to the +patient, hoping in this way to strike some of the emotional reactions +of which the patient himself is unaware. The latter responds with the +first word that comes into his mind, no matter how absurd it may seem. +The responses themselves are often significant, but the time that +elapses is even more so. It usually happens that it takes very much +longer for some responses than for others. If a patient's average time +is one or two seconds, some responses may take five or ten or twenty +seconds. Sometimes no word comes at all and the patient says that his +mind is a blank. He coughs or blushes, grows pale or trembles, showing +all the signs of emotion even when he himself has no notion of the +cause. The significant word has hit upon a subconscious association +with some emotional complex. The blocking of the mind is an effort of +the resistance to keep the painful ideas out of consciousness. The +telltale word then furnishes a starting point for further +associations. + +One of my patients blocked on the word "long." Instead of saying +"short" or "pencil" or "road" or "day" or any other word which might +naturally be associated with "long," she laughed and said that no word +would come. Finally an emotional memory came to light. It seems that +this woman had been courted by a man whom she unconsciously loved, but +whom she had "turned down" because she was ambitious for a career. +After the man had moved to another town, my patient heard that he was +engaged to another girl. She then realized that she loved him and +began to long for him with her whole heart. The meaningful word "long" +thus led us to one of the emotional memories for which we were +seeking. + +="Chance" Signs.= There are other clues to hidden inner processes, +other sign-posts pointing to the cause of a neurosis. Not only through +dreams and through emotional reactions to certain words does the +subconscious reveal its desires, but also through the little slips of +the tongue and of the pen, the "chance" acts and unconscious +mannerisms which are usually ignored as entirely insignificant. When +we "make a break" and say what we secretly mean but wish to hide from +ourselves or others; when we forget an appointment which part of us +really wishes to avoid, or forget a name with which we are perfectly +familiar; when we lose the pen so that we cannot write or the desk key +so that we cannot work; when we blunder and drop things and do what we +did not mean to do; then we may know--the normal as well as the +nervous person--that our subconscious minds with their repressed +desires are trying to get the reins and are partially succeeding. + +An example from my own life may illustrate the point. In building a +number of houses, I had occasion often to use the word studding, but +on every occasion, I forgot the word and always had to end lamely by +saying "those pieces of timber that go up and down." Each time the +builder supplied the word, but the next time it was no more +accessible. Finally, the reason came to me. One day when I was a +little child I looked out of the window and cried, "Oh, see that great +big beautiful horse." My grandmother exclaimed, "Sh! sh! that is a +stud horse." Over-reaction to that impression repressed the word stud +so successfully that as a grown woman I could not recall another word +which happened to contain the same syllable. + +During an analysis a patient of mine who had a mother-in-law situation +on her hands told me a dream of the night before. "I dreamed that my +mother-in-law, who has really been very ill, was taken with a +sinking-spell. I rushed to the telephone to call the doctor, but found +to my terror that I could not remember his number." "What is his +number?" I asked, knowing that she ought to know it perfectly. +"Two-eight-nine-six," she answered at once. The number really was +2876. Asleep and awake, her repressed desire for release from the +mother-in-law's querulous presence was attempting to have its way. In +the dream, she avoided calling the doctor by forgetting his number +entirely. Awake, she evaded the issue by remembering a wrong number. +In the dream she thinly disguised her desire by displacing the anxious +emotion from the sense of her own guilty wishes to the idea of the +mother-in-law's death. When confronted with this interpretation, the +woman readily acknowledged its truth. + +Even stammering, which has always been considered a physical disorder, +has been proved, by psycho-analysis, to be the sign of an emotional +disturbance. H. Addington Bruce reports the case of one of Dr. Brill's +patients, a young man who had been stammering for several years. +Observation revealed the fact that his chief difficulty was with +words beginning with K and although at first he firmly denied any +significance to the letter, he later confessed that his sweetheart +whose name began with K had eloped with his best friend and that he +had vowed never to mention her name again. Upon Dr. Brill's suggestion +he tried to think of the unfaithful lover as Miss W., but soon +returned, saying that he was stammering worse than ever. Investigation +showed that the additional unpronounceable words contained the letter +W. When he was induced to renounce his oath never to call the girl's +name again, he found that he had no more difficulty with his +speech.[43] + +[Footnote 43: H. Addington Bruce; "Stammering and Its Cure," +_McClure's_, February, 1913.] + +Thus we see that even the halting tongue of a stammerer may point the +way to the buried complex for which search is being made. + +Since there is no accident in mental life, and since there is behind +every action a force or group of forces, no smallest action is +insignificant to the person trained to understand. + +If this at first seems disturbing, it is only because we do not +realize that there is nothing within of which we need be ashamed. +People are very much alike, especially in the deeper layers of their +being. What belongs to the whole human race does not need to be +hidden away in darkness. There is nothing to lose and everything to +gain by an increasing understanding of the chance signals which reveal +the forces at work within the depths of the mind. To the analyst every +little unconscious act is a valuable clue pointing toward the end of +his quest.[44] + +[Footnote 44: For further discussion of this subject, see Freud's +_Psycho-pathology of Everyday Life_, translated by A.A. Brill.] + +=The Aim of Psycho-Analysis.= As we have seen, the object of all this +technique is the discovery and the removal of the resistances which +have been keeping the emotional conflicts in the dark. It is a long +step just to learn that there are resistances; and by reliving, bit by +bit, the earlier experiences responsible for unfortunate habits, we +find that the habits themselves lose much of their old power. They can +be seen for what they are, and changed to suit present conditions. A +wish is incomparably stronger when unconscious than when conscious; +and the old stereotyped, automatic reactions tend to cease when once +they have been seen for what they are. They become assimilated with +the rest of the personality and modified by the mature attitudes of +the conscious mind. The person then re-educates himself by the very +act of discovering himself. In other cases, the uncovering is merely +the first step in the process of re-education. The analyst then +assumes the role of educator, cutting away old shackles, breaking down +false standards, building up new complexes, showing the patient the +naturalness of his desires, inducing him to look at them as biologic +facts, and showing him how to sublimate those which may not find +direct expression; in fact, leading him out into the self-expression +of a free, unhampered life.[45] + +[Footnote 45: "It will be readily understood that in the +reconstruction of the shattered purposes, the frustrated hopes and the +outraged instincts which are found to lie at the source of those human +woes we call 'nervous disorders,' there takes place a gradual +transposition of values, a total recasting of ideas, and that through +the whole process, education in the deepest meaning of the word, +enters at last into its full sovereign rights."--Trigant Burrow.] + +Among my patients at one time was a woman subject to terrible fits of +despondency. She was happily married and enjoyed the marriage +relationship, but could not free herself from a terrible sense of +guilt and degradation, a sense which was so acute that she wanted to +end her life. Although she was an active member of a church, she was +starving for the real message of the church, continually bound by a +feeling of aloofness which made her a stranger in the midst of +friends. Psycho-analysis revealed an experience of her childhood which +she had kept a secret all these years. It seems that when she was +seven years of age an old minister had driven her into town and had +made some sort of sex-approach on the way. Although ignorant of its +significance, the child was badly frightened and overcome with a sense +of guilt. She had already inferred that such subjects were not to be +mentioned and she hesitated long before telling even her mother. +Smoldering within her through the years had been this emotional +complex about the sex-life and about people connected with a church, +so that even as a grown woman the relationships of her mature years +were completely ruined by her old childish reaction. With insight as +to the cause of her trouble, she was able to modify her attitudes and +to live a free and happy life. + +Several years ago there came to me a man of exceptional intellectual +ability, who for years had been totally incapacitated because of blind +resistances built up in childhood. Although married to a woman whom he +thoroughly liked and admired, he was absolutely miserable in his +married life. He had, in fact, a deep-rooted complex against marriage, +and had only allowed himself to be captured because the woman, with +whom he had been good friends, had cried when he refused to marry her. +During analysis it transpired that as a little boy of four he had +often seen his silly young mother cry because she could not have a new +dress. He had taken her side and bitterly felt that she was abused by +his father. Later, at six, he had heard some coarse stories about sex +to which he had over-reacted. Still later he had heard the workmen on +the farm say that they could not go to the gold-fields because they +had wives and were held back by marriage. "There are no idle words +where children are," and this little boy had built up such a strong +complex against marriage that he could not possibly be happy as a +grown man. He was as much crippled by the old scar as is an arm which +is bent and stunted from a deep scar in the flesh. After the analysis +had broken up the adhesions, he found himself free, able to give +mature expression to his repressed and dissatisfied love-instincts. + +Psycho-analysis is not a process of addition, but one of subtraction. +Like a surgical operation, it undoes the results of old injuries, +removes foreign material, and gives nature a chance to develop freely +in her own satisfactory way. + + +RE-EDUCATION WITHOUT SUBCONSCIOUS EXPLORATION + +=Simple Explanation.= So far, "the way out" sounds rather involved. It +seems to require a special kind of doctor and a complicated, lengthy +process before the exact trouble can be determined. But, fortunately +for the average nervous patient, this lengthy process of analysis is +by no means always necessary. People with troublesome nervous +symptoms, and even those who have had a serious breakdown, are +constantly being cured by a kind of re-education which breaks up +subconscious complexes without trying to bring them to the surface. If +the dead past can be let alone, so much the better. Sometimes a +bullet buried in the flesh sends up a constant stream of discomfort +until it is dug out and removed; but if it has carried in no infection +and the body can adjust itself, it is usually considered better to let +it remain. + +The subconscious makes its own deductions. If resistances are not too +strong it is often possible to introduce healthy ideas by way of the +conscious reason, to break up old habits, and make over the mentality +without going to the trouble of uncovering some of the reactions which +are responsible for the difficulty. + +=Moral Hygiene.= Because this is true, there has grown up a kind of +psychotherapy which is known as simple explanation, or persuasion. As +usually practised, this kind of re-education pays very little +attention to the ultimate cause of "nerves." It has little to say +about repressed instincts or the real reasons for fearful emotions and +physical symptoms. Instead, it attacks the symptom itself, contenting +itself with teaching the patient that his trouble is psychic in +origin; that it is based on exaggerated suggestibility and +uncontrolled emotionalism; that it is made out of false ideas about +the body, illogical conclusions, and unhealthy feeling-tones; and that +it may be cured by a kind of moral hygiene, which breaks up these old +habits and replaces them with new and better ones. It tries to +inculcate the cheerful attitude of mind; to give the patient the +conviction of power; to correct his false ideas about his stomach, his +heart, or his head; to train him out of his emotionalism; to lead him +into a state of mind more largely controlled by reason; and to make +him find some useful and absorbing work. + +This kind of mental and moral treatment has been sufficient to cure +many neuroses of long standing. In cases that are helped by this +method, the patient's love-force, robbed of the material out of which +it has woven its disguise, and trained out of its bad habits by +re-education, automatically makes its own readjustments and forces new +channels for itself out into more useful activities. Very many nervous +persons seem to need nothing more than this simple kind of help. + +=When Simple Explanation Does not Explain.= For very many cases, +however, this procedure, good as it is, does not go deep enough. +Although it gives a sound objective education about the facts of one's +body, it furnishes only the most superficial subjective knowledge of +one's inner life. If the inner struggle be bitter, the competing +forces will hold on to their poor refuge in the symptom, despite any +number of explanations that the symptom can have no physical cause. +Sometimes it is enough for a person to be shown that he is too +suggestible, but often it is far more helpful for him to get an +inkling as to why he likes unhealthy suggestions, and to understand +something of his starved instincts which he may learn to satisfy in +better ways. + + +PSYCHOLOGICAL EXPLANATION + +Between the two extremes of the cases which need a real analysis and +those which are cured by simple explanation, I have found the great +bulk of nervous cases. To simple explanation with its highly useful +information, I therefore add what might be called psychological +explanation, a re-education which makes use of all that illuminating +material unearthed by the explorations of hypnosis and especially of +psycho-analysis. Along with correct ideas about such matters as +digestion, sleep, and fatigue, I give, so far as the patient is able +to understand, a comprehension of the rights of the denied instincts, +the ways of the subconscious, the fettering hold of unfortunate +childish habits, the various mental mechanisms by which we fool +ourselves, and the ways by which we may make better adaptations. + +=According to the Patient.= The treatment varies according to the +nature of the trouble, and is somewhat dependent on the mentality of +the patient. There are many people who would only be confused by being +forced into a study of mental phenomena. Not being students, they +would be more bewildered than helped by the details of their inner +mechanisms. Others, of studious habits and inquiring minds, are +encouraged to browse at will in a library of psychotherapy and to +learn all that they can from the best authorities. + +In any case, I give the patients as much as they are able to take of +my own understanding of the subject. There are no secrets in this +method. The patient is treated as a rational human being who has +nothing to lose and everything to gain by the fullest knowledge that +he is able to acquire. Without forcing him to plunge in over his +depth, I encourage him to understand himself to the fullest possible +extent. Besides individual private conferences, we have twice a day an +informal gathering of all the patients in my household--"the family" +as we like to call ourselves--for a reading or talk on the various +ways of the body and the mind, which need to be understood for normal +living and for the cure of nerves. Very often people of only average +education, long without the opportunity of study, gain in a +surprisingly short time enough insight to make new adaptations and +cure themselves. For this, a college education is not nearly so +important as an open mind. It is because of the success of this method +that I have been encouraged to reach a larger number of people by +means of a book, based on the same plan of re-education. + +=Explanation vs. Suggestion.= Re-education through this kind of +explanation is simply a matter of learning the truth and acting upon +it. It is a process of real enlightenment, and is very different from +suggestion which trades upon the patient's credulity, increasing his +already exaggerated suggestibility. + +Freud illustrates the difference between suggestion and +psycho-analysis by saying that suggestion is like painting and +psycho-analysis like sculpture. Painting adds something from the +outside, plastering over the canvas with extraneous matter, while +sculpture cuts away the unnecessary material and reveals the angel in +the marble. So suggestion covers over the real trouble by crying, +"Peace, peace, when there is no peace." Without attempting to remove +the cause, it says to the patient: "You have no pain. You are not +tired. You will sleep to-night. You will be cheerful." Sometimes the +suggestion works and sometimes it does not, but at best the relief is +likely to be a mere temporary makeshift. The symptom may be relieved, +but the character is not changed and therefore no permanent relief is +assured. It is far better for a nervous person to say to himself, +"There is something wrong and I am going to find it," than to keep +repeating over and over, "There is nothing wrong," and so on through a +list of half-believed autosuggestions. + +On the other hand, psycho-analysis, and this kind of re-education +based on psycho-analytic principles, do not pay a great deal of +attention to the individual symptom. Instead of adding from without +they try to take away whatever has proved a hindrance to normal +growth and development, and to remove unnecessary resistances which +are responsible for the symptom, and which have been holding the +patient back from the fullest self-expression. + +=Incantation vs. Knowledge.= There came to me one day a well-known +public woman who had suffered from nervous indigestion for many years. +As she was able to be with me for only one night, we had time for just +one conversation, but in that time she discovered what she was doing +and lost her indigestion. In the course of the conversation she turned +to me, saying: "Doctor, I know what a force suggestion is. I believe +in its power. Will you tell me why I have not been able to cure myself +of this trouble? Every night after I go to bed I repeat over and over +these Bible verses," naming a number of passages relating to God's +goodness and care for His children. My answer was something like this: +"You are too intelligent a woman to be cured by an incantation. When +you feel surging up within you the sense of God's goodness, or when +you actually want to realize His loving kindness, then by all means +repeat the verses. But don't prostitute those wonderful words by +making them into a charm and then expect them to cure your +indigestion. It is a desecration of the words and a denial of your own +intelligence. Autosuggestion is a powerful force, but real +psychotherapy is based not on the mechanical repetition of any set of +words, but on a knowledge of the truth." + +=The "Bullying Method."= Sometimes, to be sure, explanation is not +enough. The brain paths between the associated ideas are so deeply +worn that no amount of persuasion avails. It is easy for the doubter +to say: "Well, that sounds very well, but my case is different. I have +tried over and over again and I know." With people of this sort, an +ounce of demonstration is worth a pound of argument. + +By way of illustration we might mention the man who couldn't eat eggs. +To be sure, he had tried many times but always had suffered the most +intense cramps in his stomach, and no amount of talk could make him +believe that an egg was not poison to him. I took the straight road of +simply proving to him that he was mistaken, and had him eat an egg. +After a time of apprehension and retching, he vomited the egg, +thinking, of course, that he had proved his point. To his +astonishment, I said, "Now, let's go and eat another." With great +consternation, he finally complied, evidently expecting to die on the +spot; but as I immediately prescribed a game of tennis, he scarcely +had time to think of the pain, which in fact failed to appear. +However, as he thereafter insisted on eating four eggs a day,--with +eggs at top-notch price I decided that the joke was on the doctor! + +=Enjoying the Right Things.= In substituting healthful complexes for +unhealthful ones, psychotherapy not only changes ideas and emotions, +but alters the feelings of pleasure or pain that are bound up with the +ideas. Dr. Tom A. Williams writes: "The essence of psychotherapy and +education is to associate useful activities with agreeable +feeling-tones and to dissociate from injurious acts the agreeable +feeling-tones that may have been acquired." Right character consists +not so much in enjoying things as in enjoying the right things. + +Some people enjoy being martyrs. They love to tell about the terrible +strain they have been under, the amount of work they have done, or the +number of times they have collapsed. One of my patients gave every +evidence of satisfaction as he told about his various breakdowns. "The +last time I was ill," or "That time when I was in the sanatorium," +were frequent phrases on his lips. Finally, after I had asked him if +he would boast about the number of times he had awkwardly fallen down +in the street, and had shown him that a neurosis is not really a +matter to be proud of, he saw the point and stopped taking pleasure in +his mistakes. + +Such signs of pleasure in the wrong things are evidence of suppressed +wishes which we do not acknowledge but try to gratify in indirect +ways.[46] The pleasure which ought to be associated with the idea of +good work well done has somehow been switched over to the idea of +being an invalid. The satisfaction which ought to go with a sense of +power and ability to do things has attached itself to the idea of +weakness and inability. The pleasurable feeling-tone which normally +belongs to ministering to others, regresses in the nervous invalid to +the infantile satisfaction of being ministered unto. + +[Footnote 46: For a further elaboration of this theme, see Holt: _The +Freudian Wish_.] + +But these things are only a habit. A good look in the mirror soon +makes one right about face and start in the other direction. Once +started, a good habit is built up with surprising ease. It is really +much more satisfying to cook a good dinner for the family's comfort +than to think about one's ills; much pleasanter to enjoy a good meal +than to insist on hot water and toast. Once we have satisfied our +suppressed longings in more desirable ways, or by a process of +self-training have initiated a new set of habits, we feel again the +old zest in normal affairs, the old interest and pleasure in +activities which add to the joy of life. Thus does re-education fit a +man to take his place in the world's work as a socially useful being, +no longer a burden, but a contributor to the sum total of human +happiness. + + +SUMMARY + +=Knowing and Doing.= Having set out to learn how to outwit our +nerves, we are now ready to sum up conclusions and in the following +chapters to apply them to the more common nervous symptoms. It has +been shown that a nervous person is in great need of change,--not, +indeed, a change in climate or in scene, in work or in diet, but a +change in the hidden recesses of his own being. Outwitting nerves +means first and foremost changing one's mind, an inner and spiritual +process very different from the kind of change which used to be +prescribed for the nervous invalid. + +As Putnam says, the slogan of the suggestion-school of psychotherapy +has always been, "You can do better if you try"; while that of the +psycho-analytic school is, "You can do better when you know." Refuting +the old adage, "Where ignorance is bliss 'tis folly to be wise," the +best methods of psychotherapy insist that the first step in any +thorough-going attempt to change oneself must be the great step of +self-knowledge. As the conflicts which result in "nerves" are always +far beyond those mental regions which are open to scrutiny, a real +self-knowledge requires an examination of the half-conscious or wholly +unconscious longings which are usually ignored. A real understanding +of self comes only when one is willing, to analyze his motives until +he sees the connection between them and his nervous symptoms, which +are but the symbolic gratification of desires he dares not +acknowledge. + +Although these deeply buried complexes are the real force behind a +nervous illness, the material out of which the symptoms are +manufactured is taken largely from superficial misconceptions +concerning the bodily functions. It is therefore a great help, also, +to possess a fund of information,--not technical nor detailed but +accurate as far as it goes,--about the more important workings of the +bodily machinery. A little knowledge about the actual chemistry of +fatigue and the way it is automatically cared for by the body is +likely to do away with the idea of nervous exhaustion as resulting +from accumulation of fatigue. A simple understanding of the biological +and physiological facts concerning the assimilation of food and the +elimination of waste material leaves the intelligent person less ready +to convert his psychic discomfort into indigestion and constipation. +Chapters IX to XIII in this book, which at first glance may seem to +belong to a work on physiology rather than on psychology are designed +to give just such needed insight. + +But knowing the truth is only the first half of the way out. Every +neurosis is a deliberate choice by a part of the personality. +Self-discovery is helpful only when it leads to better ways of +self-expression. The final aim of psychotherapy is the happy +adjustment of the individual to the demands of society and the +establishment of useful outlets for his energy. This phase of the +subject will be discussed more fully in Chapter XVI. + +=The Future Hope.= Much has been said about the cure of a neurosis. +There are enough people already in the maze of nervousness to warrant +the setting up of numerous signs reading, "This way out." But after +all, is not a blocking of the way in of vastly more importance? As it +is always easier to prevent than to cure, so it is easier to train +than to reform. If re-education is the cure, why is not education the +ounce of prevention which shall settle the problem for all time? + +If the general public understood what "nerves" are, it is hardly +conceivable that there could be so many breakdowns as there are at +present. If a man's family and friends, to say nothing of himself, +understood what he is doing when he suddenly collapses and has to quit +work, it is not likely that he would choose that way out of his +difficulties. + +Most important of all, when parents know that the foundation of +nervousness is laid in childhood, they will see to it that their +children are started right on the road to health. When fathers and +mothers realize that an over-strong bond between parents and children +is responsible for a large proportion of nervous troubles, most of +them will make sure that such exaggeration is not allowed to develop. + +And, finally, when parents are freed from their "conspiracy of +silence" by a reverent attitude toward the whole of life, their very +saneness will impart to their children a wholesome respect for the +reproductive instinct. There will then be found in the next generation +fewer half-starved men and women carrying the burden of unnecessary +repressions and the pain of unsatisfied yearnings. + +Not that such a day will usher in the millennium. We are not +suggesting a panacea for all the social ills. There is an inevitable +conflict between the instinctive urge of the life-force and the +demands of society, a conflict which makes men and women either finer +or baser, according to the way they handle it. What is claimed is that +the right kind of education--using the word in its largest, deepest +sense--will remove the most fruitful cause of nervousness by taking +away the extra burden of misconception and making it easier for people +to be "content with being moral."[47] + +[Footnote 47: Frink: _Morbid Fears and Compulsions._] + + + + +CHAPTER IX + +_In which we discover new stores of energy and learn the truth about +fatigue_ + +THAT TIRED FEELING + +UNFAILING RESOURCES + + +"They that wait upon the Lord shall renew their strength. They shall +mount up with wings as eagles. They shall run and not be weary. They +shall walk and not faint." + +It is safe to say that many a person loves this promise of the prophet +Isaiah without taking it in anything like a literal sense. The words +are considered to be so figurative and so highly spiritualized that +they seem scarcely to relate at all to this earthly life, much less to +the possibilities of these physical bodies. + +Besides the nervous folk who feel themselves so weary that they +scarcely have strength to live, there are thousands upon thousands of +men and women who are called normal but who have lost much of the joy +of life because they feel their bodies inadequate to meet the demands +of everyday living. + +To such men and women the Biblical promise, "As thy day, so shall thy +strength be," comes now as the message of modern science. Nature is +not stingy. She has not given the human race a meager inheritance. She +did not blunder when she made the human body, nor did she allow the +spirit of man to develop a civilization to whose demand his body is +not equal. After its long process of development through the survival +of the fittest, the human body, unless definitely diseased, is a +perfectly adequate instrument, as abundantly able to cope with the +complex demands of modern society as with the simpler but more +strenuous life of the stone age. The body has stored within its cells +enough energy in the shape of protein, carbohydrate and fat to meet +and more than meet any drains that are likely to be made upon it, +either through the monotony of the daily grind or the excitement of +sudden emergency. Nature never runs on a narrow margin. Her motto +seems everywhere to be, "Provide for the emergency, enough and to +spare, good measure, pressed down, running over." She does not start +her engines out with insufficient steam to complete the journey. On +the contrary, she has in most instances reserve boilers which are +almost never touched. As a rule the trouble is not so much a lack of +steam as the ignorance of the engineer who is unacquainted with his +engine and afraid to "let her out." + +="The Energies of Men."= Perhaps nothing has done so much to reveal +the hidden powers of mankind as that remarkable essay of Professor +William James, "The Energies of Men."[48] Listen to his introductory +paragraph as he opens up to us new "levels of energy" which are +usually "untapped": + +[Footnote 48: James: _On Vital Reserves_.] + + Every one knows what it is to start a piece of work, either + intellectual or muscular, feeling stale--or _cold_, as an + Adirondack guide once put it to me. And everybody knows what it + is to "warm up to his job." The process of warming up gets + particularly striking in the phenomenon known as the "second + wind." On usual occasions we make a practice of stopping an + occupation as soon as we meet the first effective layer (so to + call it) of fatigue. We have then walked, played or worked + "enough," so we desist. That amount of fatigue is an efficacious + obstruction on this side of which our usual life is cast. But if + an unusual necessity forces us to press onward, a surprising + thing occurs. The fatigue gets worse up to a certain critical + point, when gradually or suddenly it passes away, and we are + fresher than before. We have evidently tapped a level of new + energy, masked until then by the fatigue-obstacle usually obeyed. + There may be layer after layer of this experience. A third and + fourth "wind" may supervene. Mental activity shows the phenomenon + as well as physical, and in exceptional cases we + may find, beyond the very extremity of fatigue-distress, amounts + of ease and power that we never dreamed ourselves to own, sources + of strength habitually not taxed at all, because habitually we + never push through the obstruction, never pass those early + critical points. + +Again Professor James says: + + Of course there are limits; the trees don't grow into the sky. + But the plain fact remains that men the world over possess + amounts of resource which only very exceptional individuals push + to their extremes of use. But the very same individual, pushing + his energies to their extreme, may in a vast number of cases keep + the pace up day after day, and find no "reaction" of a bad sort, + so long as decent hygienic conditions are preserved. His more + active rate of energizing does not wreck him; for the organism + adapts itself, and as the rate of waste augments, augments + correspondingly the rate of repair.[49] + +[Footnote 49: Ibid., pp. 6-7.] + +Another psychologist, Boris Sidis, writes: "But a very small fraction +of the total amount of energy possessed by the organism is used in its +relation with the ordinary stimuli of its environment."[50] These +men--Professor James and Dr. Sidis--represent not young enthusiasts +who ignorantly fancy that every one shares their own abundant +strength, but careful men of science who have repeatedly been able to +unearth unsuspected supplies of energy in "worn out" men and women, +supposed to be at the end of their resources. Every successful +physician and every leader of men knows the truth of these statements. +What would have happened in the great war if Marshal Foch had not +known that his men possessed powers far beyond their ken, and had not +had sublime faith in the "second wind"? + +[Footnote 50: Sidis: P. 112 of the composite volume +_Pychotherapeutics_.] + +=What about Being Tired?= If all these things are true, why do people +need to be told? If man's equipment is so adequate and his reserves +are so ample, why after all these centuries of living does the human +race need to learn from science the truth about its own powers? The +average man is very likely to say that it is all very well for a +scientist sitting in his laboratory to tell him about hidden +resources, but that he knows what it is to be tired. Is not the crux +of the whole question summed up in that word "tired"? If we do not +need to rest, why should fatigue exist? If the purpose of fatigue +seems to be to slow down our efforts, why should we disregard it or +seek to evade its warnings? The whole question resolves itself into +this: What is fatigue? In view of the hampering effect of +misconception on this point, it is evident that the question is not +academic, but intensely practical. We shall find that fatigue is of +two kinds,--true and false, or physical and moral, or physiological +and nervous,--and that while the two kinds feel very much alike, +their origin and behavior are quite different. + + +PHYSIOLOGICAL FATIGUE + +=Fatigue, not Exhaustion.= In the first place, then, fatigue very +seldom means a lack of strength or an exhaustion of energy. The +average man in the course of a lifetime probably never knows what it +is to be truly exhausted. If he should become so tired that he could +in no circumstances run for his life, no matter how many wild beasts +were after him, then it might seem that he had drained himself of all +his store of energy. But even in that case, a large part of his +fatigue would be the result of another cause. + +=A Matter of Chemistry.= True fatigue is a chemical affair. It is the +result of recent effort,--physical, mental, or emotional,--and is the +sum of sensations arising from the presence of waste material in the +muscles and the blood. The whole picture becomes clear if we think of +the body as a factory whose fires continuously burn, yielding heat and +energy, together with certain waste material,--carbon dioxide and ash. +Within man's body the fuel, instead of being the carbon of coal is the +carbon of glycogen or animal starch, taken in as food and stored away +within the cells of the muscles and the liver. The oxygen for +combustion is continuously supplied by the lungs. So far the factory +is well equipped to maintain its fires. Nor does it fail when it comes +to carrying away waste products. Like all factories, the body has its +endless chain arrangement, the blood stream, which automatically picks +up the debris in its tiny buckets--the blood-cells and serum--and +carries it away to the several dumping-grounds in lungs, kidneys, +intestines, and skin. + +Besides the products of combustion, there are always to be washed away +some broken-down particles from the tissues themselves, which, like +all machinery, are being continuously worn out and repaired. By +chemical tests in the laboratory, the physiologist finds that a muscle +which has recently been in violent exercise contains among other +things carbon dioxid, urea, creatin, and sarco-lactic acid, none of +which are found in a rested muscle. Since all this debris is acid in +reaction and since we are "marine animals," at home only in salt water +or alkaline solution, the cells must be quickly washed of the fatigue +products, which, if allowed to accumulate, would very soon poison the +body and put out the fires. + +=No Back Debts.= The human machine is regulated to carry away its +fatigue products as fast as they are made, with but slight lagging +behind that is made good in the hours of sleep, when bodily activities +are lessened and time is allowed for repair. Unless the body is +definitely diseased, it virtually never carries over its fatigue from +one day to another. In the matter of fatigue, there are no old debts +to pay. Nature renews herself in cycles, and her cycle is twenty-four +hours,--not nine or ten months as many school-teachers seem to +imagine, or eleven months as some business men suppose. In order to +make assurance doubly sure, many set apart every seventh day for a +rest day, for change of occupation and thought, and for catching up +any slight arrears which might exist. But the point is that a healthy +body never gets far behind. + +If through some flaw in the machine, waste products do pile up, they +destroy the machine. If the heart leaks or the blood-cells fail in +their carrying-power, or if lungs, kidneys or skin are out of repair, +there is sometimes an accumulation of fatigue products which poisons +the whole system and ends in death. But the person with tuberculosis +or heart trouble does not usually allow this to happen. The body +incapacitated by disease limits its activities as closely as possible +within the range of its power to take care of waste matter. Even the +sick body does not carry about its old toxins. The man who had not +eliminated the poisons of a month-old effort would not be a tired man. +He would be a dead man. + +=A Sliding Scale.= If all this be true, real fatigue can only be the +result of recent effort. If one is still alive, the results of earlier +effort must long since have disappeared. The tissue-cells retain not +the slightest trace of its effects. Fatigue cannot possibly last, +because it either kills us or cures itself. Up to a certain point, far +beyond our usual high-water mark, the more a person does the more he +can do. As Professor James has pointed out, the rate of repair +increases with the rate of combustion. Under unusual stress, the rate +of the whole machine is increased: the heart-pump speeds up, +respirations deepen and quicken, the blood flows faster, the endless +chain of filling and emptying buckets hurries the interchange of +oxygen and carbon dioxid, until the extreme capacity is reached and +the organism refuses to do more without a period of rest. + +The whole arrangement illustrates the wonderful provisions of Nature. +Although each individual is continuously manufacturing enough +carbonic-acid gas to kill himself in a very few minutes, he need not +be alarmed for fear that he may forget to expel his own poisons. +Nobody can hold his breath for more than a few minutes. The naughty +baby sometimes tries, but when he begins to get black in the face, he +takes a breath in spite of himself. The presence of carbonic-acid gas +in the circulation automatically regulates breathing, and the greater +the amount of gas the deeper the breath. The faster we burn the faster +we blow. As with breathing, so with all the rest of elimination and +repair. The body dares not get behind. + +="Second Wind."= A city man frequently sets out on a mountain tramp +without any muscular preparation for the trip. He walks ten or fifteen +miles when his average is not over one or two. Sometimes after a few +hours he feels himself exhausted, but a glorious view opens out before +him and he goes on with new zest. He has merely increased his rate of +repair and drawn on a new stock of energy. That night he is tired, and +the next day he is likely to be stiff and sore. There is a little +fatigue left in him, but it takes only a day or two for the body to be +wholly refreshed, especially if he hastens the process by another good +walk. Up to a certain point, far beyond our usual limit, the more we +do, the more we can do. + +One day after a long walk my little daughter said that she could go no +farther and waited to be carried. But she soon spied a dog on ahead +and ran off after him with new zest. She followed the dog back and +forth, running more than a mile before she reached home, and then in +the exuberance of her spirits, ran around the house three times. + +=The Emotions Again.= What is the key that unlocks new stores of +energy and drives away fatigue? What is it in the amateur +mountain-climbers that helps the body maintain its new standard? What +keeps indefatigable workers on the job long after the ordinary man has +tired? Is it not always an invigorating emotion,--the zest of +pursuit, the joy of battle, intense interest in work, or a new +enthusiasm? All great military commanders know the importance of +morale. They know that troops can stand more while they are going +forward than while running away, that the more contented and hopeful +they are, the better fighters they make; discouragement, lack of +interest, the fighting of a losing game, dearth of appreciation, +futility of effort, monotony of task, all conspire in soldier or +civilian to use up and to lock up energy which might have been +available for real work. Approaching the matter from a new angle, we +find once more that the difference between strength and weakness is in +many cases merely a difference in the emotions and feeling-tones which +habitually control. + +Fatigue is a safety-device of nature to keep us within safe limits, +but it is a device toward which we must not become too sensitive. As a +rule it makes us stop long before the danger point is reached. If we +fall into the habit of watching its first signals, they may easily +become so insistent that they monopolize attention. Attention +increases any sensation, especially if colored by fear. Fear adds to +the waste matter of fatigue little driblets of adrenalin and other +secretions which must somehow be eliminated before equilibrium is +reestablished. This creates a vicious circle. We are tired, hence we +are discouraged. We are discouraged, hence we are more tired. This +kind of "tire" is a chemical condition, but it is produced not by work +but by an emotion. He who learns to take his fatigue philosophically, +as a natural and harmless phenomenon which will soon disappear if +ignored, is likely to find himself possessed of exceptional strength. +We can stand almost any amount of work, provided we do not multiply it +by worry. We can even stand a good deal of real anxiety provided it is +not turned in on ourselves and directed toward our own health. + +="Decent Hygienic Conditions."= If fatigue products cannot pile up, +why is extra rest ever needed? Because there is a limit to the supply +of fuel. If the fat-supply stored away for such emergencies finally +becomes low, we may need an extra dose of sleeping and eating in order +to let the reservoirs fill again. But this never takes very long. The +body soon fills in its reserves if it has anything like common-sense +care. The doctrine of reserve energy does not warrant a careless +burning of the candle at both ends. It presupposes "decent hygienic +conditions,"--eight hours in bed, three square meals a day, and a fair +amount of fresh air and exercise. + +="Over There."= On the other hand, the stories that floated back to us +from the war zone illustrate in the most powerful way what the human +body can do when necessity forbids the slightest attention to its +needs. One of the best of these stories is Dorothy Canfield's account +of Dr. Girard-Mangin, "France's Fighting Woman Doctor." Better than +any abstract discussion of human endurance is this vibrant narrative +of that little woman, "not very strong, slightly built, with some +serious constitutional weakness," who lived through hardships and +accomplished feats of daring which would have been considered beyond +the range of possibility--before the war. + +Think of her out there in her leaky makeshift hospital with her twenty +crude helpers and her hundreds of mortally sick typhoid patients; four +hundred and seventy days of continuous service with no place to +sleep--when there was a chance--except a freezing, wind-swept attic in +a deserted village. Think of her in the midst of that terrible Battle +of Verdun, during four black nights without a light, among those +delirious men, and then during the long, long ride with her dying +patients over the shell-swept roads. Listen to her as she speaks of +herself at the end of that ride, without a place to lay her head: "Oh, +then I did feel tired! That morning for the first time I knew how +tired I was, as I went dragging myself from door to door begging for a +room and a bed. It was because I was no longer working, you see. As +long as you have work to do you can go on." Then listen to her as she +receives her orders to rush to a new post, before she has had time to +lay herself on the bed she has finally found. "Then at once my +tiredness went away. It only lasted while I thought of getting to bed. +When I knew we were going into action once more, I was myself again." +Watch her as she rides on through the afternoon and the long dangerous +night; as she swallows her coffee and plum-cake, and operates for five +hours without stopping; as she sleeps in the only place there is--a +"quite comfortable chair" in a corner; and as she keeps up this life +for twenty days before she is sent--not on a vacation, mind you, but +to another strenuous post.[51] + +[Footnote 51: Dorothy Canfield: _The Day of Glory._] + +This brave little woman is not an isolated example of extraordinary +powers. The human race in the great war tapped new reservoirs of power +and discovered itself to be greater than it knew. Professor James's +assertions are completely proved,--that "as a rule men habitually use +only a small part of the powers which they actually possess," and that +"most of us may learn to push the barrier (of fatigue) further off, +and to live in perfect comfort on much higher levels of power." + +=How?= The practical question is: how may we--the men and women of +ordinary powers, away from the extraordinary stimulus of a crisis like +the great war--attain our maximum and drop off the dreary mantle of +fatigue which so often holds us back from our best efforts? It may be +that the first step is simply getting a true conception of physical +fatigue as something which needs to be feared only in case of a +diseased body, and which is quite likely to disappear under a little +judicious neglect. + +In the second place, fatigue shows itself to be closely bound up with +emotions and instincts. The great releasers of energy are the +instincts. What but the mothering instinct and the love of country +could uncover all those unsuspected reserves of Dr. Girard-Mangin and +others of her kind? What is it but the enthusiasm for work which +explains the indefatigable energy of Edison and Roosevelt? If the +wrong kind of emotion locks up energy, the right kind just as surely +unlocks great stores which have hitherto lain dormant. If most people +live below their possibilities, it is either because they have not +learned how to utilize the energy of their instinctive emotions in the +work they find to do, or because some of their strongest instincts +which are meant to supply motive power to the rest of life are locked +away by false ideas and unnecessary repressions, and so fail to feed +in the energy which they control. In such a case, the "spring tonic" +that is needed is a self-knowledge which shall release us from +hampering inhibitions and set us free for enthusiastic +self-expression. + + +NERVOUS FATIGUE + +_What of the Nervous Invalid?_ If the normal man lives constantly +below his maximum, what shall we say of the nervous invalid? +Fatigability is the very earmark of his condition. In many instances +he seems scarcely able to raise his hand to his head. Sometimes he can +scarcely speak for weariness. Frequently to walk a block sends him to +bed for a week. I once had a patient who felt that she had to raise +her eyelids very slowly for fear of over-exertion. She could speak +only about two or three words a day, the rest of the time talking in +whispers. She could not raise a glass to her lips if it were full of +water, but could manage it if only half full. A person nearly dead +with some fatal disease does not appear more powerless than a typical +neurasthenic. + +If it he true that accumulation of fatigue is promptly fatal, what +shall we say of the woman who says that she is still exhausted from +the labor of a year ago,--or of ten years ago? What of the business +man who travels from sanatorium to sanatorium because five years ago +he went through a strenuous year? What of the college student who is +broken down because he studied too hard, or the teacher who is worn +out because of ten hard years of teaching? There can be but one +answer. No matter what their feelings, they can be suffering from no +true physiological fatigue. Something very real has happened to them, +but only through ignorance and the power of suggestion can it be +called fatigue and attributed to overwork. + +=Stories of Real People.= Perhaps if we look over the stories of a few +people who have been members of my household, we may work our way to +an understanding of the truth. We give only the barest outline of the +facts, thinking that the cumulative effect of a number of cases will +outweigh a more detailed description of one or two. The most casual +survey shows that whatever it was that burdened these fine men and +women, it was not lack of energy. No matter how extreme had been their +exhaustion, they were able at once, without rest or any other physical +treatment, to summon strength for exertions quite up to those of a +normal person. + +The second point that stands out clearly to any one acquainted with +these inner histories is the conviction that in each case the trouble +was related in some way to the unsatisfied love-life, to the insistent +and thwarted instinct of reproduction. In some cases no search was +made for the cause. The simple explanation that there was no lack of +power was sufficient to release inhibited energy. But in every case +where the cause was sought, it was found to be some outer lack of +satisfaction, or some inner repression of the love-force. + +=From Prostration to Tennis.= One young woman, Miss A., had suffered +for ten years from the extremest kind of fatigue. She could not walk a +block without support and without the feeling of great exhaustion. +Before her illness she had had a sweetheart. Not understanding her +normal physical sensations when he was near, she had felt them +extremely wicked and had repressed them with all her strength. Later, +she broke off the engagement, and a little while after developed the +neurosis. Within a week after coming to my house, she was playing +tennis, walking three miles to church, and generally living the life +of a normal person. + +=Making Her Own Discoveries.= Then there was Miss B. who for four +years had been "exhausted." She had such severe pains in her legs that +she was almost helpless. If she sewed for half an hour on the sewing +machine, she would be in bed for two weeks. Although she was engaged +to be married, she could not possibly shop for her trousseau. Two +years before, a very able surgeon had been of the opinion that the +pain in the legs was caused by an ovarian tumor. He removed the tumor, +assuring the patient that she would be cured. However, despite the +operation and the force of the suggestion, the pains persisted. + +After she had been with me for a few days, she sewed for an hour on +the machine. In a day or so she took a four-mile walk in a canon near +the house and, on returning in the afternoon, walked two and a half +miles down town to do some shopping. I did not make an analysis in +her case because she recovered so quickly,--going home well within two +weeks. But she declared that she had found the cause while reading in +one of the books on psychology. I had my suspicions that the +long-drawn-out engagement had something to do with the trouble, but I +did not confirm my opinion. A long engagement, by continually +stimulating desire without satisfying it, only too often leads to +nervous illness. + +=Afraid of Heat.= Professor X., of a large Eastern college, had been +incapacitated for four years with a severe fatigue neurosis and an +intense fear of heat. Constantly watching the weather reports, he was +in the habit of fleeing to the Maine coast whenever the +weather-prophet predicted warm weather. After a short reeducation, he +discovered that his fatigue was symbolic of an inner feeling of +inadequacy, and that it bore no relation to his body. Discarding his +weariness and throwing all his energies into the Liberty Loan +Campaign, he found himself speaking almost continuously throughout one +of the hottest days in the history of California, with the thermometer +standing at 107 degrees. After that he had no doubt as to his cure. + +=In Bed from Fear.= Miss C. was carried into my house rolled in a +blanket. She had been confined to her bed except for fifteen minutes a +day, during which time she was able to lie in a hammock! It seems +that her illness was the result of fear, an over-reaction to early +teaching about self-abuse. Her mother had frightened her terribly by +giving her the false idea that this practice often leads to insanity. +Having indulged in self-abuse, she believed herself going insane, and +very naturally succumbed to the effects of such a fear. After a few +days of re-education, she was as strong as any average person. Having +no clothing but for a sick-room, she borrowed hat, skirt, and shoes, +and walked to church, a three-mile walk. + +=Empty Hands.= Miss Y., a fine woman of middle age, suffering from +extreme fatigue could neither sleep nor eat. She could only weep. She +had spent her life taking care of an invalid girl who had recently +died. Now her hands were empty. Like many a mother whose family has +grown up, she had no outlet for her mothering instinct, and her sense +of impotency expressed itself in the only way it knew how,--through +her body. As there is never any lack of unselfish work to be done, or +of people who need mothering, she soon found herself and learned how +to sublimate her energy in useful activities. + +=Defying Nature.= One young man from Wyoming had felt himself obliged +to give up his business because he could neither work nor eat. It soon +cropped out that he and his wife had decided that they must not have +any children. With a better understanding of the great forces which +they were defying, his strength and his appetite came back and he went +back to work, rejoicing. + +=Left-over Habits.= Often a state of fatigue is the result of a +carried-over habit. One of my patients, a young girl, had several +years before been operated on for exophthalmic goiter. This is a +disease of the thyroid gland, and is characterized by rapid heart, +extreme fatigue, and numerous other symptoms. Although this girl's +goiter had been removed, the symptoms still persisted. She could not +walk nor do even a little work, like wiping a few dishes. I took her +down on the beach, let her feel her own pulse and mine and then ran +with her on the sand. Again I let her feel our pulses and discover for +herself that hers had quickened no more than was normal and had slowed +down as soon as mine. After a few such lessons, she was convinced that +her symptoms were reverberations for which there was no longer any +physical cause. + +Another young girl, Miss L., had had a similar operation for goiter +six years before. Since that time she had been virtually bedridden. +During the first meal she had at my house her sister sat by her couch +because she must not be left alone. By the second meal the sister had +gone, and Miss L. ate at the table with the other guests. That night +she managed to crawl upstairs, with a good deal of assistance and +with great terror at the probable results of such an effort. After +that, she walked up-stairs alone whenever she had occasion to go to +her room. Her heart will always be a little rapid and her body will +never be very strong, but she now lives a helpful happy life at home +and among her friends. + +In cases like this the exaggeration proves the counterfeit. Nobody +could have been so down and out _physically_ without dying. The +exaggeration secures attention and gives the little satisfaction to +the natural desires which are denied expression, and which gain an +outlet through habit along the lines previously worn by the real +disease. Many a person is still suffering from an old pain or an old +disability whose cause has long since disappeared, but which is +stamped on the mind and believed in as a present reality. Since the +sensation is as real as ever, it is sometimes very hard to believe +that it is not legitimate, but if the person is intelligent, a little +explanation and re-education usually suffices. + +=Twenty Years an Invalid.= Mr. S., from Ohio, had spent much of his +time for twenty years going from one sanatorium to another. There was +scarcely a health resort in the country with which he was not +familiar. The day he came to me he felt himself completely exhausted +by the two-block walk from the car. He explained that he could +scarcely listen to what I was saying because his brain was so fagged +that concentration was impossible. When asked to read a book, he +dramatically exclaimed, "Books and I have parted company!" I set him +to work reading "Dear Enemy" but it was not a week before he was +devouring the deeper books on psychology, in complete forgetfulness of +the pains in his head. Playing golf and walking at least six miles +every day, he rejoiced in a new sense of strength in his body, which +for twenty years he had considered "used up." He is now doing a +man-sized job in the business and philanthropic life of his home city. + +=Brain-fag.= This feeling of brain-fag is one of the commonest nervous +symptoms; and almost always it is supposed to be the result of +intellectual overwork. Some people who easily accept the idea that +physical work cannot cause nervous breakdown can scarcely give up the +deep-rooted notion that intense mental work is harmful. Intellectual +effort does give rise to fatigue in exactly the same way as does +physical exertion, but the body takes care of the waste products of +the one just as it does those of the other. Du Bois says that out of +all his nervous cases he has not found one which can be traced to +intellectual overwork. I can say the same thing, and I know no case in +all the literature of the subject whose symptoms I can believe to be +the result of mental labor. + +The college students who break down are not wrecked by intellectual +work. In some cases, one strong factor in their undoing is the strain +and readjustment necessary because of the discrepancies between some +of their deepest religious beliefs and the truth as they learn it in +the class-room. The other factors are merely those which play their +part in any neurosis. + +=Re-educating the Teacher.= School-teachers are prone to believe +themselves worn out from the mental work and the strain of the +strenuous life of teaching. Many a fine, conscientious teacher has +come to me with this story of overwork. But the school-teacher is as +easily re-educated as is any one else. I usually begin the process by +stating that I taught school myself for ten years and can speak from +experience. After I explain that there is no physical reason why the +teachers of some cities are fagged out at the end of nine months while +those in other cities whose session is longer can hold on for ten +months, and stenographers who lead just as strenuous a life manage to +exist with only a two-weeks' vacation, they begin to see that perhaps +after all they have been fooling themselves by a suggestion, "setting" +themselves for just so long and expecting to be done up at the end of +the term. Many of these same teachers have gone back to their work +with a new sense of "enough and to spare" and some of them have +written back that they have passed triumphantly through especially +trying years with no sense of depletion. + +In any work, it is the feeling of strain which tells, the emotionalism +and feeling sorry for oneself because one has a hard job. It is +wonderful what a sense of power comes from the simple idea that we are +equal to our tasks. + +=Sudden Relief.= The story of Mr. V. illustrates Professor James's +statement that often the fatigue gets worse up to a certain critical +point, and then suddenly passes away. Mr. V. was another patient who +was "physically exhausted." When the rest of "the family" went +clamming on the beach, he felt himself too weak for such exertions, so +I left him on the sand to hold the bag while the rest of us dug for +clams. The minute I turned my back he disappeared. I found him lying +flat on his back, resting, behind the bulk-head. I decided that he +needed the two-mile walk home and we all set out to walk. "Doctor, +this is cruel. It is dangerous. My knees can never stand this. I shall +be ill!" ran the constant refrain for the first mile. Then things went +a bit better. Toward the last he found, to his absolute astonishment, +that the fatigue had entirely rolled away. The last half-mile he +accomplished with perfect ease. Needless to say, he never again +complained of physical exhaustion. + +=False Neuritis.= Miss T. was suffering from fatigue and very severe +pains in her arms, pains which were supposed to be the result of real +neuritis, but which did not correspond to the physiological picture of +that disease. A consultation revealed the fact that her love-instinct +had been repeatedly stimulated, and then at the last, when it had +expected satisfaction, had been disappointed. A discussion of her +life, its inner forces, and her future aims helped to pull her +together again and give her instinct new outlets. The pains and the +fatigue disappeared at once. + +=Something Wrong.= These cases are chosen at random and are typical of +scores of others. In no single case was the trouble feigned or +imaginary or unreal. But in every case it was a mistake. _The sense of +loss of muscular power was really a sense of loss of power on the part +of the soul._ Some inner force was reaching out, reaching out after +something which it could never quite attain. As it happened, in every +case that I analyzed, the force which felt itself defeated and +inadequate was the thwarted instinct of reproduction. Like a man +pinned to the ground by a stronger force, it felt itself most helpless +while struggling the hardest. Just as we feel a thrill of fright when +we step up in the dark and find no step there, so this instinct had +gotten itself ready for a step which was not there. Inner repressions +or outer circumstances had denied satisfaction and left only an +undefined sense that something was wrong. The life-force, feeling +itself helpless, limp, tired, had no way of expressing itself except +in terms of the body. Since expression is itself a relief and an +outlet for feeling, the denied desire had seized on suggestions of +overwork to explain its sense of weariness, and had symbolized its +soul-pain by converting it into a physical pain. The feeling of +inadequacy was very real, but it was simply displaced from one part of +the personality to another,--from an unknown, inarticulate part to one +which was more familiar and which had its own means of expression. + +=Locked-up Energy.= We do not know just how the soul can make its pain +so intensely real to the body, but we do know that any conviction on +the part of the subconscious mind is quickly expressed in the physical +machine. A conviction of pain or of powerlessness is very soon +converted into a feeling which can scarcely be denied. The mere +suggestion that the body is overworked is enough to make it tired. + +We know, too, that the instincts are the great releasers of energy. So +it happens that when our most dynamic instinct--that for the +reproduction of the race--is repressed, we lack one of the greatest +sources of usable energy. The energy is there, but it is not +accessible. Inhibited and locked away, it is not fed into the engine, +and we feel exactly as though it were _nil_. Despite its name, the +disease neurasthenia does not signify a real asthenia or weakness. +Rather, it is a disorder in which there is plenty of energy that has +somehow been temporarily misplaced. Then, too, we must remember that +under the depressing influence of chronic fear, not quite so much +energy is stored away as would otherwise be. All the bodily functions +are slowed down; food is not so completely assimilated, the heart-beat +is weakened, the breathing is more shallow, and fatigue products are +more slowly eliminated. As Du Bois says, "An emotion tires the +organism more than the most intense physical or intellectual work." + +=Avoid the Rest-Cure.= It is a healthful sign that the rest-cure is +fast going out of style. Wherever it has helped a nervous patient, the +real curative agent has been the personality of the doctor and the +patient's faith in him. The whole theory was based on ignorance of the +cause of nerves. People suffering from "nervous exhaustion" are likely +to be just as "tired" after a month in bed as they were before. Why +not? Physical fatigue is quickly remedied, and what can rest do after +that? What possible effect can rest have on the fatigue of a +discouraged instinct? Since the best releaser of energy is enthusiasm, +don't try to get that by lying around in bed or playing checkers at a +health resort. + + +SUMMARY + +If you are chronically and perpetually fatigued, or if you tire more +easily than the other people you know, consult a competent physician +and let him look you over. If he tells you that you have neither +tuberculosis, heart trouble, Bright's disease, nor any other +demonstrable disease, that you are physically fit and "merely +nervous," give yourself a good shake and commit the following +paragraphs to memory. + + + A CATECHISM FOR THE WEARY ONE + + WHAT? + + Q. What is fatigue? + + A. It is a chemical condition resulting from effort that is very + recent. + + Q. What else creates fatigue? + + A. Worry, fear, resentment, discontent, and other depressing + emotions. + + Q. What magnifies fatigue? + + A. Attention to the feeling. + + Q. What makes us weary long after the cause is removed? + + A. Habit. + + WHY? + + Q. Why do many people believe themselves over-worked? + + A. Because of the power of suggestion. + + Q. Why do they take the suggestion? + + A. Because it serves their need and expresses their inner feelings. + + Q. Why are they willing to choose such an uncomfortable mode of + expression? + + A. Because they don't know what they are doing, and the + subconscious is very insistent. + + WHO? + + Q. Who gets up tired every morning? + + A. The neurotic. + + Q. Who fancies his brain so exhausted that a little concentration + is impossible? + + A. The neurotic. + + Q. Who still believes himself exhausted as the result of work that + is now ancient history? + + A. The neurotic. + + Q. Who lays all his woes to overwork? + + A. The neurotic. + + Q. Who complains of fatigue before he has well begun? + + A. The neurotic. + + Q. Who may drop his fatigue as soon as he "gets the idea?" + + A. The neurotic. + + HOW? + + Q. How can he get the idea? + + A. By understanding himself. + + Q. How may he express his inner feelings? + + A. By choosing a better way. + + Q. How can he forget his fatigue? + + A. By ignoring it. + + Q. How can he ignore it? + + A. By finding a good stiff job. + + If he wants advice in a nutshell, here it is: Get understanding! + Get courage! Get busy! + + + + +CHAPTER X + +_In which the ban is lifted_ + +DIETARY TABOOS + +MISUNDERSTOOD STOMACHS + + +=Modern Improvements.= Most people have heard the story of the little +girl who wanted to know what made her hair snap. After she had been +informed that there was probably electricity in her hair, she sat +quiet for a few minutes and then exclaimed: "Our family has all the +modern improvements! I have electricity in my hair and Grandma has gas +on her stomach!" Judged by this standard many American families are +well abreast of the times; and if we include among the modern +improvements not only gas on the stomach but also nervous dyspepsia, +acid stomach, indigestion, sick-headache, and biliousness, we must +conclude that a good proportion of the population is both modern and +improved. + +Despite all this the stomach is one of the best-equipped mechanisms in +the world. It, at least, is not modern. After their age-long +development the organs of the body are remarkably standardized and +adapted to the work required of them. It is safe to say that ninety +per cent. of all so-called "stomach trouble" is due not to any +inherent weakness of the organ itself but to a misunderstanding +between the stomach and its owner. + +=Organic Trouble.= Unfortunately, there are a few real organic causes +for trouble. There are a few cancers of the stomach and a certain +number of ulcers. But if the patients whom I have seen are in any way +typical, the ulcers that really are cannot compare in number with the +ulcers that are supposed to be. Patients go to physicians with so many +tales of digestive distress that even the best doctors are fooled +unless they are especially alert to the ways of "nerves." They must +find some explanation for all the various functional disturbances +which the patients report, and as they are in the habit of taking only +the body into account, they find the diagnosis of stomach ulcer as +satisfactory as any. + +There is, of course, such a thing as an enlarged or sagging stomach. +But it is only in the rarest of cases that such a condition leads to +any functional disturbances unless complicated by suggestion. In most +cases a person can go about his business as happily as ever unless he +gets the idea that ptosis must inevitably lead to pain and discomfort. + +Confusion sometimes arises when the stomach is blamed for +disturbances which originate elsewhere. One day a very sick-looking +girl came to me with eager expectation written all over her face. Her +stomach was misbehaving and she had heard that I could cure nervous +indigestion. It needed little more than a glance to know that she was +suffering from organic heart trouble. A boy of sixteen had been taking +a stomach-tonic for three months, but the thin, wiry pulse pointed to +a different ailment. His digestive disturbances were merely the echo +of an organic disease of the kidneys. When the body is burdened by +disease, it may have little energy left for digesting food, but in +that case the trouble must be sought in other quarters than the +stomach. + +Aside from a few organic difficulties, there is almost no real disease +of the stomach. Its misdoings are not matters of food and chemistry, +muscle-power and nerve supply, but are the end results of slips in the +mental and emotional life of its owner. + +=Fads Dynamogenic.= What is it that gives the impetus to fads about +eating, or about religious belief? Are they advocated by the +individual whose libido is finding abundant expression in the natural +channels of business and family life, or by his less fortunate brother +who can gain a sense of power only by means of some unaccustomed idea? +William James says: + + This leads me to say a word about ideas considered as dynamogenic + agents or stimuli for unlocking what would otherwise be unused + reservoirs of individual power.... In general, whether a given + idea shall be a live idea depends more on the person into whose + mind it is injected than on the idea itself. Which is the + suggestive idea for this person and which for that one? Mr. + Fletcher's disciples regenerate themselves by the idea (and the + fact) that they are chewing and re-chewing and super-chewing + their food. Dr. Dewey's pupils regenerate themselves by going + without their breakfast--a fact, but also an ascetic idea. Not + every one can use these ideas with the same success. + +Because it is so adaptable and sturdy, the stomach lends itself +readily to these devices for gaining self-expression; but the danger +lies in bringing the process of digestion into conscious attention +which interferes with automatic functioning. Still further, the +disregard of physiological chemistry is likely to deprive the body of +food-stuffs which it requires. + +The average person is too sensible to be carried off his feet by the +enthusiasm of the health-crank, but as most of us are likely to pick +up a few false notions, it may be well to be armed with the simple +principles of food chemistry in order to combat the fads which so +easily beset us and to know why we are right when we insist on eating +three regular meals of the mixed and varied diet which has proved +best for the race through so many years of trial and experience. + + +WHAT WE NEED TO EAT + +=The Essence of Dietetics.= To the layman the average discussion of +food principles is, to say the least, confusing. Dealing largely, as +it does, with unfamiliar terms like carbohydrate and hydrocarbon and +calories, it is hard to translate into the terms of the potatoes left +over from dinner and the vegetables we can afford to buy. But the +practical deductions are not at all difficult to understand. Boiled +down to their simplest terms, the essential principles may be stated +in a few sentences. The body must secure from the food that we eat, +tissue for its cells, energy for immediate use or to be stored for +emergency, mineral salts, vitamins, water and a certain bulk from +fruits and vegetables,--this latter to aid in the elimination of waste +matter. + +Food for repairing bodily tissue is called protein and is secured from +meat, eggs, milk, and certain vegetables, notably peas. Fuel for heat +and energy is in two forms--carbohydrate (starch and sugar) and fat. +We get sugar from sugar-cane and beets, and from syrups, fruit, and +honey. Starch is furnished from flour products--mainly bread--from +rice, potatoes, macaroni, tapioca, and many vegetables. Fats come from +milk and butter, from nuts, from meat-fat--bacon, lard and suet--and +from vegetable oils. The mineral salts are obtained mainly from fruit +and vegetables, which also provide certain mysterious vitamins +necessary for health, but as yet not well understood. + +=What the Market Affords.= The moral from all this is plain. The human +body needs all the foods which are ordinarily served on the table. +Whenever, through fad or through fear, we leave out of our diet any +standard food, we are running a risk of cutting the body down on some +element which it needs. They say that variety is the spice of life. In +the matter of food it is more than that, it is the essence of life. +Eat everything that the market affords and you will be sure to be well +nourished. If you leave out meat you will make your body work overtime +to secure enough tissue material from other foods. If you leave out +white bread, you will lose one of the greatest sources of energy. If +you leave out tomatoes and cucumbers and strawberries, you deprive +your body of the salts and vitamins which are essential. + +=A Simple Rule.= There is one point that is good to remember. The +average person needs twice as much starch as he needs of protein and +fat together. That is, if he needs four parts of protein and three of +fat, he ought to eat about fourteen parts of starch. This does not +mean that we need to bother ourselves with troublesome tables of what +to eat, but only to keep in mind in a general way that we need more +bread and potatoes than we do meat and eggs. The body does not have +to rebuild itself every day. It is probable that a good many people +eat too much protein food. If a man is doing hearty work he must have +a good supply of meat, but the average person needs only a moderate +amount. Here again, the habits of the more intelligent families are +likely to come pretty near the dictates of science. + +=For the Children.= The mother of a family ought to know that the +children need plenty of bread, butter, and milk. Despite all the +notions to the contrary, good well-baked white bread is neither +indigestible nor constipating. It is indeed the staff of life. Two +large slices should form the background of every meal, unless there is +an extraordinary amount of other starchy food or unless the person is +too fat. Milk-fat (from whole milk, cream, and butter) is by far the +best fat for children. Besides fat, it furnishes a certain +growth-principle necessary for development. As the dairyman cannot +raise good calves on skimmed milk, so we cannot raise robust children +without plenty of butter and milk. The pity of it is that poor people +are forced to try! Milk is also the best protein for children, whose +kidneys may be overstrained by trying to care for the waste matter +from an excessive quantity of eggs and meat. Bread and butter, milk, +fruit, vegetables, and sugar in ample quantities and meat and eggs in +moderate quantities are pretty sure to make the kind of children we +want. Above all things, let us train them not to be afraid of normal +amounts of any regular food or of any combination of foods. + +=The Fear of Mixtures.= There are many people who can without +flinching face almost any single food, but who quail before mixtures. +Perhaps there is no notion which is more firmly entrenched in the +popular mind than this fear of certain food-combinations, acquired +largely from the advertisements of certain so-called "food +specialists." + +The most persistent idea is the fear of acid and milk. It is +interesting to watch the new people when they first come to my table. +Confronted with grape-fruit and cream at the same meal, or oranges and +milk, or cucumbers and milk, they eat under protest, in consternation +over the disastrous results that are sure to follow. Out of all these +scores of people, many of whom are supposed to have weak stomachs, I +have never had one case of indigestion from such a combination. When a +person knows that the stomach juices themselves include hydrochloric +acid which is far more acid than any orange or grapefruit, that the +milk curdles as soon as it reaches the stomach, and that it must +curdle if it is to be digested, he has to be very "set" indeed if he +is to cling to any remnant of fear. + +Of course to say that the stomach is well prepared chemically, +muscularly, and by its nerve supply to handle any combination of +ordinary food in ordinary amounts is not the same thing as saying that +we may devour with impunity any amount of anything. It is a good thing +for every one to know when he has reached his limit, and a person with +organic heart disease should avoid eating large quantities at one +time, or when he is extraordinarily fatigued or emotionally disturbed, +lest at such a time he may put a fatal strain on the pneumogastric +nerve that controls both stomach and heart. + + +THE FEAR OF CERTAIN FOODS + +=Physical Idiosyncrasies.= Most of our false fears on food subjects +come from some tradition--either a social tradition or a little +private, pet tradition of one's own. Some one once was ill after +eating strawberries and cream. What more natural than to look back to +those little curdles in the dish and to start the tradition that such +mixtures are dangerous? The worst of it is that the taboo habit is +very likely to grow. One after another, innocent foods are thrown out +until one wonders what is left. A patient of mine, Mr. G., told me +that he had a short time before gone to a physician with a tale of woe +about his sour stomach. "What are you eating?" asked the doctor. "Bran +crackers and prunes." "Then," said the learned doctor, "you will have +to cut out the prunes!" Needless to say, this man ate everything at my +table, and flourished accordingly. + +There may be such a thing as physical idiosyncrasies for certain +foods. I have often heard of them, but I have never seen one. I have +often challenged my patients to show me some of the "spells" which +they say invariably follow the eating of certain foods, but I have +almost never been given an exhibition. The man who couldn't eat eggs +did throw up once, but he couldn't do it a second time. Many people +have threatened to break out with hives after strawberries. One woman +triumphantly brought me what looked like a nice eruption, but which +proved to be the after-results of a hungry flea! After that she ate +strawberries,--without the flea and without the hives. + +=Not Miracles but Ideas.= Conversions on food subjects are so common +at my table that I should have difficulty in remembering the +individual stories. Scores of them run together in my mind and make a +sort of composite narrative something like this: "Oh, no, thank you, I +don't eat this. You really must excuse me. I have tried many times and +it is invariably disastrous." Then a reluctant yielding and a day or +two later some talk about miracles. "It really is wonderful. I don't +understand," etc. Experiences like these only go to show the power of +the subconscious mind, both in building up wrong habit-reactions and +in quickly substituting healthy ones, once the false idea is removed. + +Among my stomach-patients there were two men, brothers-in-law, +immigrants from the Austrian Tyrol, and now resident in one of the +cow-boy states. Leonardo spoke little English, and though Giovanni +understood a very little, he spoke only Italian. + +Several years before I knew them, Giovanni had developed a severe case +of stomach trouble and had finally gone to a medical center for +operation. The disturbance, however, was not relieved by the operation +and before long his brother-in-law fell into the same kind of trouble. +For several years the two had spent much of their time dieting, +vomiting, and worrying over their sour stomachs. Giovanni finally +became so ill that his sick-benefit society had actually assessed its +members to pay for his funeral expenses. About this time a business +man of their town, impressed by the cure of a former patient who had +made a quick recovery after seven years of invalidism, persuaded the +two men to take their little savings and come to California to be +under my care. The evening meal and breakfast went smoothly enough, +although the menu included articles which they had been taught to +avoid. However, as I left the house on a necessary absence soon after +breakfast, I saw Leonardo weeping in the garden and Giovanni spitting +up his breakfast, out at the entrance gate. On my return, I found one +of "the family" literally sitting on the coat-tails of Leonardo, while +Giovanni hovered at a distance, safe from capture. Leonardo upbraided +me bitterly for having undone all the gain they had made in the long +months of rigid dieting, for now the vomiting had returned, because +they had eaten sugar on their oatmeal at breakfast! I made Leonardo +drink an egg-nog, took him into the consultation-room and held my hand +on his knee to keep him in his chair, while explaining to him as best +I could the physiologic action of the hydrochloric acid on the +digestive juice, which he feared as a sour stomach, the sign of +indigestion. + +During the conversation I said, "I suppose Giovanni imitated you in +this mistaken fear about your health." The reply was, "No, I got it +off him!" Nearly two hours later he exclaimed in astonishment: "Why, +that milk hasn't come up! Maybe I am cured!" "Of course you are +cured," I answered; "there never was anything really the matter with +your stomach, so you are cured as soon as you think you are." + +Later Giovanni was inveigled into the house by the promise that he +would have to eat nothing more than milk soup. All was smooth sailing +after this. For my own part I feared for the permanency of the cure, +for they were returning to the old environment. But more than three +years have passed, and grateful letters still come telling of their +continued health. + +Another patient, a teacher of domestic science in a big Eastern +university, had lived on skimmed milk and lime-water from Easter to +Thanksgiving. Several attempts to enlarge the dietary by adding cream +or white of egg had only served to increase the sense of discomfort. +Finding nothing in the history of the case to warrant a diagnosis of +organic disease of the stomach, I served her plate with the regular +dinner, bidding her have no hesitancy even over the pork chops and +potato chips. She gained nine pounds in weight the first week, and in +two and a half months was forty pounds to the good. + +=When Re-education Failed.= But there is one patient who has had to +have his lesson repeated at intervals. This man laughingly calls +himself a disgrace to his doctor because he is a "repeater." His story +illustrates the power of an autosuggestion and the disastrous effect +of attention to a physiological function. When Mr. T. came first to me +he weighed only 120 pounds, although he is over six feet tall and of +large frame. From the age of sixteen he had followed fads in eating +and thought he had a weak stomach. I treated his "weak stomach" to +everything there was in the market, including mince-pies, cabbage, +cheese, and all the other so-called indigestibles. He gained 16-1/2 +pounds the first week and 31 pounds in five weeks. One would think +that the idea about the weak stomach would have died a natural death, +but it did not. Again and again he came back to me like a living +skeleton, the last time weighing only 105 pounds, and again and again +he has gone back to his home in the Middle West plump and well. Twice +while he was at home he underwent unnecessary operations, once for an +ulcer that was not there and once for supposed chronic spasm of the +pylorus. Needless to say, the operations did not help. You cannot cut +out an idea with a knife. Neither can you wash it out with a +stomach-pump; else would Mr. T. long ago have been cured! This +particular idea of his seems to be proof against all my best efforts +at re-education. Psycho-analysis is impracticable, partly because of +the duration of the habit of repression, but the history, and certain +symbolic symptoms, indicate the Freudian mechanisms at work. All I can +do is to feed him up, bully him along, and keep him from starving to +death. Just now he is doing very well at home, although he has moved +to California so as not to be too far away from "the miracle-worker." + +If Mr. T.'s case had been typical, I should long ago have lost my +faith in psychotherapy. Keeping people from starving is worth while, +but is less satisfactory than curing them of what ails them. The +nervous patient who has a relapse is no credit to his doctor. It is +only when the origin of his trouble is not removed that the bond of +transference tends to become permanent. The neurotic who is well only +while under the influence of his physician is still a neurotic. +However, as most people's complexes are neither so deeply buried nor +so obstinate as this, a simple explanation or a single demonstration +is usually enough to loose the fettering hold of old misconceptions. + + +COMMON AILMENTS + +="Gas on the Stomach."= We all know people who suffer from "gas." +Indeed, very few of us escape an occasional desire to belch after a +hearty meal. But the person with nervous indigestion rolls out the +"gas" with such force that the noise can sometimes be heard all over +the house. He may keep this up for hours at a time, under the +conviction that he is freeing himself from the products of fermenting +food. He may exhibit a well-bloated stomach as proof of the disastrous +effect of certain articles of diet. The gas and the bloating are +supposed to be the sign and the seal of indigestion, a positive +evidence that undigested food is fermenting in the stomach. + +But what is fermentation? It is, necessarily, a question of the growth +of bacteria and is a process which we may easily watch in our own +kitchens. Bread rises when the yeast-cells have multiplied and acted +on the starch of the flour, producing enough gas to raise the whole +mass. Potatoes ferment because bacteria have multiplied within them. +Canned fruit blows up because enough bacteria have developed inside to +produce sufficient gas to blow open the can. Every housewife knows +that it takes time for each of these processes. Bread has to stand +several hours before it will rise; potatoes do not ferment under +twelve hours, and canned fruit is not considered safe from the +fermenting process under three days. Evidently there is some mistake +when a person begins to belch forth "gas" within an hour or two after +a meal. As a matter of fact, it is not gas at all but merely air that +is swallowed with the food or that was present in the empty stomach. + +When the food enters the stomach it necessarily displaces air, which +normally comes out automatically and noiselessly. But if, through fear +or attention, a certain set of muscles contract, the pent-up air may +come forth awkwardly and noisily or it may stay imprisoned until we +take measures to let it out. A hearty laugh is as good as anything, +but if that cannot be managed, we may have to resort to a cup of hot +water which gives the stomach a slap and makes it let go. Two belches +are enough to relieve the pressure. After that we merely go on +swallowing air and letting it out again, a habit both awkward and +useless. + +If the emotion which ties the muscle-knot is very intense, and the +stomach refuses to let go under ordinary measures, the pain may be +severe. But a quantity of hot water or a dose of ipecac is sure to +relieve the situation. If the person is able to give himself a good +moral slap and relax his unruly muscles, he reaches the same end by a +much pleasanter road. + +Some people are fond of the popular remedy of hot water and soda. +Their faith in its efficacy is likely to be increased by the good +display of gas which is sure to follow. As any cook knows, soda and +acid always fizz. The soda is broken up by the hydrochloric acid of +the stomach and forms salt and carbon dioxid, a gas. However, as the +avowed aim of the remedy is the relief of gas rather than its +manufacture, and as the soda uses up the hydrochloric acid needed in +digestion, the practice cannot be recommended as reasonable. + +=Gastritis.= I once knew a woman who went to a big city to consult a +fashionable doctor. When she returned she told with great satisfaction +that the doctor had pronounced her case gastritis. "It must be true," +she added, "because I have so much gas on my stomach!" The diagnosis +of gastritis used to be very common. The ending _itis_ means +inflammation,--gastritis, enteritis, colitis, each meaning +inflammation of the corresponding organ. An inflammation implies an +irritant. There can be no kind of _itis_ without the presence of +something which irritates the membrane of the affected part. If we +get unusual and irritating bacteria in some spoiled food, we are +likely to have an acute inflammation until the offending bacteria are +expelled. But an inflammation of this kind never lasts. People who +have had ptomaine poisoning sometimes assert that they are afterwards +susceptible to poisoning by the kind of food which first made them +ill. Such a susceptibility is not so much a hold-over effect from the +poison as a hold-over fear which tends to repeat the physical reaction +whenever that food is eaten. I, myself, have had ptomaine poisoning +from canned salmon, but I have never since had any trouble about +eating salmon. + +=Sour Stomach.= Sometimes when a person lies down an hour or so after +a meal, some of the contents of his stomach comes up in his throat. +Then if he be ignorant of physiology, he may be very much alarmed +because his stomach is "sour." Not knowing that he would have far +greater cause for alarm if his stomach were _not_ sour, he may, if the +idea is interesting to him, begin to restrict his diet, to take +digestive tablets, and to develop a regular case of nervous dyspepsia. +Sometimes when the specialists measure the amount of hydrochloric acid +in the stomach, they do find too much or too little acid; but this +merely means that an emotion has made the glands work overtime or has +stopped their action for a little while. The functions of the body +are so very, very old that there is little likelihood of permanent +disturbance. + +=Biliousness.= The stomach is not the only part of the body concerning +which we lack proper confidence. Next to it the liver is the most +maligned organ in the whole body. Although the liver is about as +likely to be upset in its process of secreting bile as the ocean is +likely to be lacking in salt, many an intelligent person labels every +little disturbance "biliousness" and lays it at the door of his +faithful, dependable liver. + +As a matter of fact, the liver is liable to injury from virtually but +three sources--alcohol, bacterial infection, and cancer--and even a +liver hardened by alcohol goes on secreting bile as usual. The patient +dies of dropsy but not of "liver complaint." + +Some people act as if they thought bile were a poison. On the +contrary, it is a very useful digestant; it aids in keeping down the +number of harmful bacteria and helps to carry the food from intestines +to blood. Every day the liver manufactures at least a pint of this +important fluid. The body uses what it needs and stores the surplus +for reserve in the gall-bladder. The flow is continuous and, despite +all appearances to the contrary, there is no such thing as a torpid or +an over-active liver. + +It is true that after a "bilious" person has vomited for a few minutes +he is likely to throw up a certain amount of bile, which is supposed +to have been lying in his stomach and causing the nausea. In fact, +however, this bile is merely a part of the usual supply stored away in +the gall-bladder. By the very act of retching, the bile is forced out +of the bile channels into the stomach and thence up into the mouth. +Anybody can throw up bile at any time if he only tries hard enough. + +One of the favorite habits of certain people is the taking of calomel +and salts. After such a dose they view with satisfaction the green +character of the stools and conclude that they have rid themselves of +a great amount of harmful matter. As a matter of fact, the greater +part of the coloring in the stools is from the calomel itself, changed +in the intestines from one salt of mercury to another. Any excess bile +is the result of the irritating action of the calomel on the +intestinal wall, an irritation which makes the bowel hurry to cast out +this foreign substance without waiting for the bile to be absorbed as +usual. + +A patient once told me that he had bought medicine from a street fakir +and by his direction had followed it with a dose of salts. He saved +the bowel movement, washed it in a sieve, and discovered a great +number of "gall-stones," which the medicine had so effectively washed +from his system. He was much astonished when I told him that his +gall-stones were merely pieces of soap. He did not know that +everybody manufactures soap in his body every day, and that by taking +an extra quantity of oil in the shape of the fakir's medicine and an +extra quantity of potash in the salts, he had merely augmented a +normal physiological process. The supposed action of calomel belongs +to the same class of phenomena, and has no slightest effect on the +liver or on real gall-stones, which are the precipitate of bile-salts +in the gall-bladder, and which cannot be reached by any medicine. + +If the popular notions about biliousness are ill founded, what then +causes the disturbances which undoubtedly do occur and which show +themselves in attacks of nausea or sick headache? The answer can be +given in a word of four letters; a coated tongue, a bilious attack and +a sick headache are all the outcome of a mood. Stocks have gone down +or the wife is cranky or the neighbors are hateful. Adrenalin and +thyroid secretions are poured out as the result of emotion; digestion +is stopped, circulation disturbed, and the whole apparatus thrown out +of gear. + +=Sick-Headache.= Sick-headache is primarily a circulatory disturbance; +and although the disturbance may have been inaugurated by some +chemical unbalance, the sum total of the force that makes a +sick-headache is emotional. The emotion, of course, need not be +conscious in order to be effective. If we picture the arteries all +over the body as being supplied with, among other things, a wall of +circular muscles, and then imagine messages of emotion being flashed +to the nerves controlling this muscle wall, we may get an idea of what +happens just before a sick-headache. Some parts of the arteries +contract too much and other parts relax. The arteries to the head +tighten up at the extremities and become loose lower down. The force +of the blood-stream against the constricted portion can hardly fail to +cause pain. The sick part of the headache is merely a sympathetic +strike of the nerves which control circulation and stomach. + +The moral of all this is plain. If a sick-headache is the result of an +emotional spasm of the blood-vessels, the obvious cure is a change of +the emotion. Some people manage it by going to a party or a picnic, +others by ignoring the symptoms and keeping on with their work. A +woman physician whom I know was in the midst of a violent headache +when called out on an obstetrical case. She felt sorry for herself, +but went on the case. In the strenuous work which followed, she quite +forgot the headache, which disappeared as if by magic. + +Sometimes it happens that a headache recurs periodically or at regular +intervals. It is easy to see that in such cases the exciting cause is +fear and expectation. At some time in the past, headaches have +occurred at an interval of, say, fourteen days; as the next +fourteenth day approaches the sufferer says to himself: "It is about +time for another headache. I am afraid it will come to-morrow," and of +course it comes. One man told me that if he ate Sunday-night supper he +inevitably had a headache on Monday morning. We were about to sit down +to a simple Sunday supper and he refused very positively to join us. I +told him he could stay all night and that I would take care of him if +the Monday sickness appeared. He accepted my challenge but was unable +to produce a headache. In fact, he felt so unusually flourishing the +next morning that he insisted on frying the bacon for my entire +family. That was the end of the Monday headaches. + +=A Few Examples.= As sick-headache has always been considered a rather +stubborn difficulty, not amenable to most forms of treatment, it may +be well to cite a few cases which were helped by educational methods. +A patient came home from a walk one day and announced that he was +going to bed. When questioned, be said: "I am tired and I have a +sick-headache. Isn't it logical to go to bed?" To which I answered +that it would be far more logical to put some food into his stomach +and change the circulation than to lie in bed and think about his +pain. This man was completely cured. I have had patients throw up one +meal, and very rarely two, but I have never had to supply more than +three meals at a time. The waste of food I consider amply justified by +the benefit to the patient. + +There once came to me an elderly woman, the wife of a poor minister. +She was suffering from attacks of nausea, which recurred every five to +ten days with intense pain through the eyes, and with photo-phobia or +fear of light. I found that she had by dint of heroic efforts raised a +large and promising family on the salary of an itinerant +minister--from four hundred to six hundred a year! All the time she +had been feeling sorry for herself because her husband did not +appreciate her. One day, after reading one of his letters which seemed +to show an utter lack of appreciation of all that she was doing, she +fell down in the field beside her plow, paralyzed. From that time on +she had been more or less of an invalid, continually nursing her +grudge and complaining that she ought not to have been made to bear so +many children. + +After I had heard this plaint over and over for about a week, I said: +"Perhaps you ought not to have had that little daughter, the little +ewe-lamb. Maybe she was one too many." "Oh, no," came the quick +response. "I couldn't have spared _her_." Then I went down the line of +the fine stalwart sons. Perhaps she could have spared John or Tom or +Fred? Finally she saw the whole matter in a different light,--saw +herself as a queen among women, the mother of such a family. + +As to the husband, I tried to show her that she was not very clever +to live with a man all those years without discovering that he was not +likely to change. "You can't change him but you can change your +reaction to him. If something keeps hurting your hand, you don't keep +on being sore. You grow callous. Isn't it about time you grew a moral +callous, too?" + +I put her on the roof to sleep, on account of her fear of light. Only +once did she start a headache, which I quickly nipped in the bud by +making her get up and dress. She had come to stay "three months or +four,--if I get along well." At the end of four weeks she left, an +apparently well woman. The last I heard of her she was stumping the +state for temperance, the oldest of an automobile party of speakers, +and the sturdiest physically. With the emotional grievance, +disappeared also the physical effects in stomach and head. + +Miss S., a very brilliant woman, ambitious to make the most of her +life, had been shelved for twenty-five years because of violent +sick-headaches which made it impossible for her to undertake any kind +of work. She had not been able to read a half-hour a day without +bringing on a terrible headache. I insisted on her reading, and very +soon she was so deep in psychological literature that I had difficulty +in making her go to bed at all. After learning the cause of her +headaches and gaining greater emotional control, she succeeded so +well in freeing herself from the old habit, that she now leads the +busiest kind of useful life with only an occasional headache, perhaps +once in six months. + +A certain minister suffered constantly from a dull pain in his head, +besides having violent headaches every few days. He started in to have +a bad spell the day after his arrival at my house. As I was going out +of the door, he caught my sleeve. "Doctor," he said, "would it be bad +manners to run away?" "Manners?" I answered. "They don't count, but +morals, yes." He stayed--and that was his last bad headache. Both +chronic and periodic pains disappeared for good. + +One woman who had suffered from bad headaches for eighteen years lost +them completely under a process of re-education. On the other hand, I +have had patients who were not helped at all. The principles held good +in their cases, but they were simply not able to lose the old habit of +tightening up the body under emotion. + +=Hysterical Nausea.= Sometimes nausea is merely the physical symbol of +a subconscious moral disgust. We have already told the stories of "the +woman with the nausea" (Chapter V) and of Mrs. Y. (Chapter VII). These +cases are typical of many others. Their bodies were perfectly normal, +and when, through psycho-analysis and re-education, they were helped +to make over their childish attitudes toward the sex-life, the nausea +disappeared. + +=Loss of Appetite.= A nervous patient with a good appetite is "the +exception that proves the rule." The neurotic is usually under weight +and often complains that he feels satiated almost as soon as he begins +to eat. Loss of appetite may, of course, mean that the body is busy +combating toxins in the blood, but in a nervous person it usually +means a symbolic loss of appetite for something in life, a struggle of +the personality against something for which he has "no stomach." +Psycho-analysis often reveals the source of the trouble, and a little +bullying helps along the good work. By simply taking away a harmful +means of expression, we may often force the subconscious mind to find +a better language. + + +SUMMARY + +Since the stomach seems to be an organ which is much better fitted to +care for food than to care for a depressing emotion or a false idea, +it seems far more sensible to change our minds than to keep enlarging +our list of eatables which are taboo. + +And since most indigestion is in very truth nothing more nor less than +an emotional disturbance, worked up by fear, anger, discontent, worry, +ignorance, suggestion, attention to bodily functions which are meant +to be ignored, love of notice and the conversion of moral distress +into physical distress, the best diet list which can be furnished to +Mr. Everyman in search of health must read something like this: + + MENU + + Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, + Sunday + + A Calm Spirit Plenty of Good Cheer + A Varied Diet Commonsense + Good Cooking + Judicious Neglect of Symptoms + Forgetfulness of the Digestive Process + A Little Accurate Knowledge + A Determination to + BE LIKE FOLKS + + + + +CHAPTER XI + +_In which we relearn an old trick_ + +THE BUGABOO OF CONSTIPATION + +POPULAR SUPERSTITIONS + + +In line with the taboos connected with the taking of food are the +ceremonials attendant upon its elimination. Taking anxious thought +about functions well established by nature is a feature of +conversion-hysteria, the displacement of emotional desire from its +psychic realm into symbolic physical expression. Whatever other +symptoms nervous people may manifest, they are almost sure to be +troubled with chronic constipation. It is true that there are many +constipated people who do not seem to be nervous and who resent being +classed among the neurotics. Everybody knows that the occasional +individual who has difficulty in swallowing his food is nervous and +that the, trouble lies not in the muscles of his throat but in the +ideas of his mind. But very few people seem to realize that the more +common individual who makes hard work of that other simple +process--elimination of his intestinal waste matter--is suffering +from the same kind of disturbance and giving way to a nervous trick. +When all the facts are in, the constipated person will have hard work +to clear himself of at least one count on the charge of nerves. + +=An Oft-told Tale.= Sooner or later, then, the neurotic, whether he +calls himself a neurotic or not, is very likely to begin worrying over +his diet or his sedentary occupation. He imagines himself the victim +of autointoxication, afflicted with paralysis of the colon or dearth +of intestinal secretions. He leaves off eating white bread, berries, +cheese, chocolate, and many another innocent food, and insists on a +diet of bran-biscuit, flaxseed breakfast-foods, prunes, spinach, +cream, and olive-oil with doses of mineral oil between meals. In all +probability, he begins a course of massage or he starts to take extra +long walks and to exercise night and morning, pulling his knees up to +his chin and touching his fingers to his toes. When all these measures +fail, he gives in to the morning enema or the nightly pill, in +imminent danger of succumbing to a life-long habit. + + +THE TRUTH ABOUT CONSTIPATION + +=What the Colon Is For.= It is well, then to have a fair understanding +of the structure and purpose of our intestinal machinery. Contrary to +general opinion, the intestines are not a dumping-ground but a +digestive organ. After the food is partly digested in the stomach, it +passes through a twenty-two foot tube (the small intestine) into a +five-foot tube (the large intestine or colon) where digestion is +completed, the nutriment is absorbed, and the waste matter is passed +on and out through the rectum. As the food passes along the colon, +pushed slowly ahead by the peristaltic wave, or rhythmic muscular +contractions of the intestinal wall, it is seized upon by the four +hundred varieties of friendly bacteria which inhabit the intestines of +every healthy person, and is changed into a form which the body can +assimilate. Digestion in the stomach and small intestine is carried on +by means of certain digestive juices, but in the large intestine it is +the bacteria which do the work. Without them we could not live. + +Around the colon is a thick network of little blood vessels, all of +which lead straight to the liver, the storehouse of the body. After +the food is fully digested, it is passed through the thin intestinal +wall into these tiny vessels and carried away to liver and muscles for +storage or for immediate use. + +This process of absorption is carried on throughout the whole length +of the colon. Not until the very end of the intestine is reached is +all the nutrition abstracted. The bowel-content can properly be called +waste matter only after it has reached the rectum or pouch at the +lower end of the colon. Even then, this waste matter is not poison, +but merely indigestible material which the body cannot handle. + +=Food, not Poison.= The colon is not a cesspool but a digestive and +assimilating organ. Its content is not poison but food. Active +elimination is important not so much because delay causes +autointoxication or poisoning as because too large a mass is hard to +manage and irritates the intestinal wall. The problem is not so much +one of toxicology as of simple mechanics. If Nature had put within the +body five feet of tubing which could easily become a cesspool and a +breeder of poison, it is not at all likely that she would have laid +alongside an elaborate system of blood vessels leading not out to the +kidneys but into the storehouse of the liver; and if civilized man's +changed manner of living had so upset Nature's plans as easily to +transform his internal machinery into a chronic source of danger, we +may be sure that he would long ago have gone the way of the unfit and +succumbed to his own poisons. + +=Possible Invasions.= It is true that the intestinal tract, like the +rest of the body, is open to attack by harmful bacteria. But in a +great majority of cases, these enemy bacteria are either quickly +destroyed by the beneficent microbes within or are immediately cast +out as unfit. Any germs irritating to the intestinal wall cause the +mucous membrane to produce an unusual flow of mucus which washes away +the offending bacteria in what we call a diarrhea.[52] + +[Footnote 52: If the invading army proves obstinate and the diarrhea +continues a day or so, it is wise to assist Nature by a dose of +castor-oil, which gives an additional insult to the intestinal wall, +spurs it on to a desperate effort, and hastens the cleansing process. +In severe cases the more promptly the castor-oil is administered the +better. Such emergency measures are very different from the habitual +use of insulting drugs.] + +Sometimes the wrong kind of bacteria do persist, causing anemia, +rheumatism, sciatica, or neuritis. When these disorders are not the +result of infection from teeth, tonsils, or other sources of poison, +but are really caused by intestinal bacteria, I have found that a diet +of buttermilk (lactic acid bacteria), with turnip-tops or spinach to +supply the necessary mineral salts, often succeeds in planting the +right bacteria and driving out the disturbing ones. These disorders +are invasions from without, like tuberculosis or malaria, and are as +likely to attack the person with easy bowel movements as the one with +the most chronic constipation. + +=Autointoxication.= A good deal of the talk about autointoxication is +just talk. It sounds well and affords an easy explanation for all +sorts of ills, but in a large majority of cases the diagnosis can +hardly be substantiated. Uninformed writers of newspaper articles on +the care of the body, or purveyors of purgatives or apparatus for +internal baths are fond of dilating on the "foulness of the colon" as +a leading cause of disease. As a rule, they advise either a strict +diet, some kind of cathartic, or an elaborate process of washing out +the colon to clear the body of its terrible accumulation of poisons. + +=Cathartics and Enemas.= He who makes a practice of flushing out his +intestinal tract with high enemas and internal baths is like a person +who eats a good dinner and then proceeds to wash out his stomach. In +the mistaken idea that he is making himself clean, he is washing what +was never intended to be washed and robbing the body of the nutrition +which it needs. And the man who persists in the pill habit is making a +worse mistake, adding insult to injury and forcing the mucous membrane +to toughen itself against such malicious attacks. + +=Cathartics and Operations.= Even in emergencies, the use of +purgatives as a routine measure is happily decreasing year by year. +For many years I have deplored the use of purgatives before and after +operations. That other practitioners are coming to the same conclusion +is witnessed by a number of papers recently read in medical societies +condemning purgation at the time of operation. + +Among the most favorably received papers of the California Medical +Societies have been one by Emmet L. Rixford, surgeon of the Stanford +University Medical College, read before the Southern California +Medical Society at Los Angeles December 8, 1916, and one by W.D. +Alvarez at the California Medical Society, Del Monte, 1918,--both +condemning the use of purgatives as a routine measure before +operations. An article entitled the "Use and Abuse of Cathartics" in +the "Journal of the American Medical Association" admirably summarizes +the disadvantages of purgation at such a time.[53] + +[Footnote 53: "1 Danger of dissemination of infection throughout the +peritoneal cavity, in case localized infection exists. + +"2 Increased absorption of toxins and greater bacterial activity by +reason of the fact that undigested food has been carried down into the +colon to serve as pabulum for bacteria, and that liquid feces form a +better culture medium than solid feces. + +"3 Increased distention of the intestine with gas and fluid, when it +should be empty.... + +"4 Psychic and physical weakness produced by dehydration of the body, +disturbance in the salt balance of the system, and the loss of sleep +occasioned by the frequent purging during the night preceding the +operation. As Oliver Wendell Holmes says: 'If it were known that a +prize fighter were to have a drastic purgative administered two or +three days before a contest, no one will question that it would affect +the betting on his side unfavorably. If this be true for a powerful +man in perfect health, how much more true must it be of the sick man +battling for life.' + +"5 Increase in postoperative distress and danger: thirst, gas pains, +and even ileus...."--_Journal of American Medical Association_, Vol. +73, No. 17, p. 1285, Oct. 25. 1919.] + +Four years ago I was called to a near-by city to see a former patient +who two days before had had a minor operation,--removal of a cyst of +the breast. She was dazed, almost in a state of surgical shock and +very near collapse. I found that she had been put through the usual +course of purgation before operation and starvation afterward, and I +diagnosed her condition as a state bordering on acidosis, or lowering +of the alkaline salts of the body. I ordered food at once. She rallied +and recovered. + +A few months later this same woman had to undergo a much more serious +operation for multiple fibroids of the uterus and removal of the +appendix. This time I advised the surgeon against the use of any +purgative, and he took my remarks so seriously that he did not even +allow an enema to be given. This time the patient showed no signs of +exhaustion and had very few gas pains. I firmly believe that the day +will soon come when a patient under operation, or a patient after +childbirth, will no longer be depleted by a weakening and dehydrating +cathartic and by a period of starvation, at a time when he needs all +the energy he can summon. + +=Cathartics and Childbirth.= The article referred to in the "Journal +of the American Medical Association" cites the experiences of Dr. R. +McPherson of the Lying-in Hospital of New York, "who showed that the +routine purgation after confinement is not only useless but harmful. +Of 322 women who were not purged, only three had fever (and one of +them a mammary abscess); most of them had normal bowel movements and +those who did not were given an enema every third day. Of 322 women +who were delivered by the same technique and the same operators but +were purged in the usual routine manner, twenty-eight had some fever." +This experience of one physician is corroborated by that of others who +find that the more we tamper with the natural functions in time of +stress the harder do we make the recuperative process. There are +certainly times when catharsis is necessary but "one thing is certain, +the day for routine purgation is past."[54] Even in emergencies we +need to know why we administer cathartics and in chronic cases we may +be sure that they are always a mistake. + +[Footnote 54: Ibid, p. 1286.] + +="An Old Trick."= Before we make a practice of interfering with +Nature's processes, it is well to remember how old and stable those +processes are. As long as there has been the taking in of food, there +has been also the casting out of waste matter. The sea-anemone closes +in on the little mollusk that floats against its waving petals, +assimilates what it can and rejects the rest. In the long line from +sea-anemone to man, this automatic process of elimination has gone on +without a hitch, adapting itself with perfect success to the changing +habits of the varying types of life. So old a process is not easily +upset. And, be it noted, in the human body this automatic, involuntary +process still goes on with very little trouble until it reaches a +point in the body where man, the thinking animal, tries to control it +by conscious thought. + +=A Question of Evacuation.= Much of the misconception about +constipation arises from the mistaken idea that this is a disorder of +the whole intestine or at least of the whole colon. As a matter of +fact, the trouble is almost wholly in the rectum. There is no trouble +with the general traffic movement, but only with the unloading at the +terminus. In my experience, the patient reports that he feels the +fecal mass in the lower part of the rectum, but that he is unable to +expel it. Examination by finger or by X-ray reveals a mass in the +rectal pouch. If there is a piling up of freight further back on the +line, it is only because the unloading process has been delayed at the +terminus. + +So long as the bowel-content is in the region of automatic control, +there is very little likelihood of trouble. An occasional case of +organic trouble--appendicitis, lead-colic, mechanical obstruction, new +growths or spinal-cord disease--may cause a real blockade, but in +ninety-nine cases out of every hundred there is little trouble so long +as the involuntary muscles, working automatically under the direction +of the subconscious mind, are in control. By slow or rapid stages, on +time or behind time, the bowel-content reaches the upper part of the +rectum and passes through a little valve into the lower pouch. Here is +where the trouble begins. + +=Meddlesome Interference.= In the natural state the little human, like +the other animals, empties his bowel whenever the fecal mass enters +the lower portion of the rectum. The presence of the mass in the +rectum constitutes a call to stool which is responded to as +unthinkingly as is the desire for air in the taking of a breath. But +the tiny child soon has to learn to control some of his natural +functions. At the lower end of the rectum there is a purse-string +muscle called the _Sphincter-ani_, an involuntary muscle which may +with training be brought partly under voluntary control. Under the +demands of civilization, the baby learns to tighten up this muscle +until the proper time for evacuation. Then, if he be normal, he lets +go, the muscles higher up contract and the bowel empties itself +automatically, as it always did before civilization began. + +There is, however, a possibility of trouble whenever the conscious +mind tries to assume control of functions which are meant to be +automatic. Under certain conditions necessary control becomes +meddlesome interference. If the child for one reason or another takes +too much interest in the function of elimination; if he likes too much +the sense-gratification from stimulation of the rectal nerves and +learns to increase this gratification by holding back the fecal mass; +if he gets the idea that the function is "not nice" and takes the +interest that one naturally feels in subjects that are taboo; or if he +catches from his elders the suggestion that the bowel movement is a +highly important process and that something disastrous is likely to +happen unless it is successfully performed every day; then his very +interest in the matter tends to interfere with automatic regulation, +and to cause trouble. + +Just as people often find it hard to let go the bladder muscle and +urinate when in a hurry or under observation, and just as an +apprehensive woman in childbirth tightens up the purse-string muscle +of the womb, so the little child, or the grown up who catches the +suggestion of difficulty in the bowel movement, loses the trick of +letting go. Instead of merely exercising control by temporarily +inhibiting the function, he tries to carry through the process itself +by voluntary control--and fails. Constipation is a perfect example of +the power of suggestion, and of the troublesome effect of a fear-idea +in the realm of automatic functions. + + +FOOD AND CONSTIPATION + +Since the waste matter from all foods finally reaches the rectum, and +since constipation is merely a difficulty in the forces of expulsion, +it is hard to see how any normal food in the quantities usually eaten +could have the slightest effect on the problem. When we remember that +it takes food from twelve to twenty-four hours to reach the rectum, +and that it has during all that time been subjected to the action of +the powerful chemicals of the digestive tract, it is hard to imagine a +piece of cheese, of whatever variety, strong enough to stop the +contraction of the muscles of the upper rectum or to tie the +sphincter-muscle into a knot. It would be difficult to find a food +which could pass without effect through twenty-seven feet of +intestinal tubing only to become suddenly effective on the wall of the +rectum. If the wrong kind of food is the cause of constipation, why +does the rectum prove to be the most refractory portion of the tube? +On what principle could a piece of chocolate inhibit the call to stool +or contract the sphincter muscle? On the other hand, even if it should +be conceded that constipation were the result of lack of lubricating +secretions in the colon, how could two tablespoonfuls of mineral oil +be a sufficient lubricant after being mixed with liquid and solid food +through many feet of the intestinal tract? + +=An Adaptable Apparatus.= The lining of the intestines has plenty of +secretions to take care of its function. It is as well adapted to the +vicissitudes of life as are the other parts of the body. The muscular +coat is no more liable to paralysis or spasm than are the voluntary +muscles. As the skin adapts itself to all waters and all weathers, +and as the lungs adjust themselves to varying air-pressures, so the +intestinal wall makes ready adaptation to any common-sense demands, +adjusting itself with ease to an athletic or a sedentary life, and to +the normal variations of diet. What man has eaten throughout the +centuries man may eat to-day. If you will but believe it, your +intestines will make no more objection to white bread, blackberries, +and cheese, along with all other ordinary articles of food, than the +skin makes to varying kinds of water. Naturally, the suggested idea +that a food will constipate tends to carry itself out to fulfilment +and to prevent the call to stool from rising to the level of +consciousness; but the real force lies not in the food but in the +suggestion. + +=The Bran Fad.= It is when we try to improve on the normal human diet +that we really insult the body. He who leaves off eating nourishing +white bread and takes to bran muffins is simply cheating his body. +Bran has a small food value, but the human body is not made to extract +it. Not only does bran fail to give us any nourishment itself, but it +lessens the power of the intestines to care for other food.[55] The +fad for bran is based on the well-known fact that we need a certain +quantity of bulk in order to stimulate the intestinal wall to normal +peristalsis. We do need bulk, but not more than we naturally get from +a normal and varied diet including a reasonable amount of fruit and +vegetables. + +[Footnote 55: See an article entitled "Bread and Bran," _Journal of +American Medical Association_, July 5, 1919, p. 36.] + +It is true that the suggestion of the efficacy of bran, dates, +spinach, or any other food is frequently quite sufficient to give +relief, temporarily, just as massage, manipulation of the vertebrae, +the surgeon's knife, or mineral oil may be enough to carry the +conviction of power to a suggestible individual. But who wants to take +his suggestions in such inconvenient forms as these? + +=Change of Water.= Another popular superstition centers around +drinking-waters. There are people who cannot move from one town to +another, much less take an extensive trip, without a fit of +constipation--or a box of pills. If they only knew it, there is no +water on earth which could make a person constipated. A new water, +full of unusual minerals, might hasten the bowel movement, but on what +possible principle could it retard it? Constipation has nothing to do +with food or with water, but solicitous care about either can hardly +fail to create the trouble which it tries to avoid. + + +THE CURE + +=Taking off the Brakes.= Since constipation is wholly due to the +acceptance of a false suggestion, the only logical cure must be +release from the power of that suggestion. "He is able as soon as he +thinks he is able"; not that thought gives the power, but that the +right thought releases the inhibition of the mistaken thought. As soon +as the brakes are taken off, the internal machinery is quite able to +make the wheels go round. The bowel will empty itself if we let it. +The function of elimination is not a new trick learned with difficulty +by the aged, but a trick as old and as elemental as life itself. Like +balancing on a bicycle, it may not be done by any voluntary muscular +effort, but it just does itself when one learns how. + +Once the sense of power comes, once the mind forgets to be doubtful or +afraid, then the old automatic habit invariably reasserts itself. +Meddlesome interference may throw the mechanism out of gear, but +fortunately it cannot strip the gears. Constipation is an inhibition +or restraint of function, but is never a loss of function. No one is +too old, no one is too fixed in the bad habit to relearn the old +trick. I have had a good many patients with chronic constipation, but +I have never had one who failed to learn. Real conviction speedily +brings success, and in many cases success seems to outrun conviction. +So efficient is Nature if she has only half a chance! + +=Some People Who Learned.= Unless you are over ninety-two, do not +despair. One old lady of that age, a sort of patient by proxy, was +able to cure herself without even one consultation. Her daughter had +been a patient of mine and had been cured of the constipation with +which she had been busy for many years. The mother, who believed her +own bowel paralyzed, had been in the habit of lying on the bed and +taking a copious enema every second day of her life. When, however, +she heard of her daughter's cure, the bright old woman gave up her +enemas and let her bowels do their own functioning. She stayed cured +until her death at ninety-five. + +=A Fifty-year Habit.= Another old lady was not quite so easily +convinced. She ridiculed the idea that her son of fifty, who had been +"constipated in his cradle" could be cured of his lifelong habit, but +he was cured. As long as there is life and the light of reason, so +long may Nature's functions be reestablished. + +=The Whole Family.= Nor is any one too young to learn. A tiny baby is +easily taught. There came to me for two consultations a mother and her +two babies, all three constipated. The four-year-old child, mentally +deficient, had been fed on milk of magnesia from his infancy, and the +four-months-old baby had been started on the same path. I explained to +the mother the mechanism of elimination, told her to give up +cathartics, and to set a regular time for herself and the baby, but +was a little dubious about the mentally deficient four-year-old. +However she soon reported that they had all three promptly acquired +the new habit. Four years later she told me that they had never had +any more trouble. + +=A Record History.= When Miss H. first came to my house, she told a +story that was almost incredible. She said that for many months she +had been taking eight tablespoonfuls of mineral oil three times a day +besides a cathartic at night, and an enema in the morning. No wonder +she was a little dubious over such mild treatment as mine seemed to +be! + +Constipation was only one of this young woman's troubles. She could +not sleep and was so fatigued that she believed herself at the end of +her physical capital. When she first came to me she had tears in her +eyes most of the time and used to confide to various people that she +was sure she was a patient that I could not cure,--a very common +belief among nervous invalids! She was sure that I did not understand +her case, and that she could not get anything out of this kind of +treatment. + +It was only a very short time, however, before her bowels were +functioning like those of a normal person. She lost her insomnia and +her fatigue and went away as well as ever. When she got back to her +office, she found that her old position, which she had believed secure +to her, had been given to another. She had to go out and hunt a new +job and face conditions harder than she had had before, but she came +through with flying colors. A short time ago Miss H. came back to see +me,--a happy, robust young woman, very different from the person I had +first known. She assured me that she had never had any return of her +old symptoms and that she was as well as a person could be. + +=Living up to a Suggestion.= Mrs. T. had not had a natural movement of +the bowels in twenty-five years. After the birth of a child, +twenty-five years before, her physician had told her that her muscles +had been so badly torn in labor that they could not carry through a +natural movement. After that she had never gone a day without a pill +or an enema. I explained to her that when any muscle of the rectum is +injured in childbirth, it is the sphincter-ani, and that since this is +the muscle whose contraction holds back the bowel content, its injury +would tend to over-free evacuation rather than to constipation. She +saw the point and within two or three days regained her old power of +spontaneous evacuation. + +=Practical Steps.= The first step, then, in acquiring normal habits is +the conviction of the integrity of our physical machines and a +determination not to interfere by thought, or by physical meddling, +with the elemental functions of our bodies. After this all-important +step, there are a few practical suggestions which it is well to +follow. Most of them are nothing more than the common-sense habits of +personal hygiene which are so obvious as to be almost axiomatic, but +which are nevertheless often neglected: + +1 Eat three square meals a day. + +2 Drink when thirsty, having conveniently at hand the facilities for +drinking. + +3 Heed the call to stool as you heed the call of hunger. When the +stool passes the little valve between the upper and lower portions of +the rectum, it gives the signal that the time for evacuation has come. +If this signal is always heeded, it will automatically start the +machinery that leads to evacuation. If it is persistently ignored +because one is too busy, or because the mind is filled with the idea +of disability, the call very soon fails to rise to the level of +consciousness. The feces remain in the rectum, and the bad habit is +begun. + +4 Choose a regular time and keep that appointment with yourself as +regularly as possible. In all the activities of Nature, there is a +rhythm which it is well to observe. + +5 Take time to acquire the habit. Do not be in a hurry. Do not strain. +No amount of effort will start the movement. Just let it come of +itself. + +6 Finally, should the unconscious suggestion of lack of power +stubbornly remain in force, take a small enema on the third day. If +the waste matter accumulates for three or more days, the bulk becomes +so great that the circular muscles of the rectum are unable to handle +it, just as the fingers cannot squeeze down to expel water from too +large a mass of wet blankets. Take only a small enema--never over a +quart at a time--and expel the water immediately. One or two such +measures will bring away the mass in the rectum. The material farther +up still contains food elements and is not yet ready for expulsion. +Lessen the amount of water each time until no outside help is needed. +Once you get the right idea, all enemas will be superfluous. + + +SUMMARY + +If you would have in a nutshell an epitome of the truth about +constipation, indigestion, insomnia, and the other functional +disturbances common to nervous folk, you can do, no better than to +commit to memory and store away for future reference that choice +limerick of the centipede, which so admirably sums up the whole matter +of meddlesome interference: + + A centipede was happy quite + Until a frog in fun + Said, "Pray, which leg comes after which?" + This raised her mind to such a pitch, + She lay distracted in the ditch, + Considering how to run. + +Whoever tries to consider "which leg comes after which" in any line +of physiological activity, is pretty sure to find himself in the ditch +considering how to run. Wherefore, remember the centipede! + + + + +CHAPTER XII + +_In which handicaps are dropped_ + +A WOMAN'S ILLS + +"THE FEMALE OF THE SPECIES" + + +If ever there was a man who wished himself a woman, he has hidden away +the desire within the recesses of his own heart. But one does not have +to wait long to hear a member of the female sex exclaim with evident +emotion, "Oh, dear, I wish I had been born a man!" It is probable that +if these same women were given the chance to transform themselves +overnight, they would hesitate long when it actually came to the +point. The joys of being a woman are real joys. However, in too many +cases these joys seem hardly to compensate for the discomforts of the +feminine organism. It is the body that drags. Painful menstrual +periods, the dreaded "change of life," various "female troubles" with +a number of pregnancies scattered along between, make some of the +daughters of Eve feel that they spend a good deal of their lives +paying a penalty merely for being women. Brought up to believe +themselves heirs to a curse laid on the first woman, they accept their +discomforts with resignation and try to make the best of a bad +business. + +="Since the War."= Nothing is quite the same since the war. Among +other things we have learned that many of our so-called handicaps were +nothing but illusions,--base libels on the female body. Under the +stern necessity of war the women of the world discovered that they +could stand up under jobs which have until now been considered quite +beyond their powers. Society girls, who were used to coddling +themselves, found a new joy in hard and continuous work; middle-aged +women, who were supposed to be at the time of life when little could +be expected of them, quite forgot themselves in service. Ambulance +drivers, nurses, welfare workers, farmerettes, Red-Cross workers, +street-car conductors and "bell-boys," revealed to themselves and to +the world unsuspected powers of endurance in a woman's body. Although +some of the heavier occupations still seem to be "man's work," better +fitted for a man's sturdier body, we know now that many of these +disabilities were merely a matter of tradition and of faulty training. + +There still remains, however, a goodly number of women who are +continuously or periodically below par because of some form of +feminine disability. Some of these women are suffering from real +physical handicaps, but many of them need to be told that they are +disabled not by reason of being women but by reason of being nervous +women. + +="Nerves" Again.= Despite the organic disturbances which may beset the +reproductive organs, and despite the havoc wrought by venereal +diseases, it may be said with absolute assurance that the majority of +feminine ills are the result neither of the natural frailty of the +female body, nor even of man's infringement of the social law, but are +the direct result of false suggestion and of false attitudes toward +the facts of the reproductive life. The trouble is less a difficulty +with the reproductive organs than a difficulty with the reproductive +instinct. "Something wrong" with the instinct is translated by the +subconscious mind into "something wrong" with the related generative +organs, and converted into a physical pain. + +That this relation has always been dimly felt is shown by the fact +that the early Greeks called nervous disorders _hysteria_, from the +Greek word for womb. It is only lately, however, that the blame has +been put in the right place and the trouble traced to the _instinct_ +rather than to the _organs_ of reproduction. + +=Why Women Are Nervous.= Although women hold no monopoly, it must be +conceded that they are particularly prone to "nerves." The reason is +not hard to find. Since the leading factor in a neurosis is a +disturbance of the insistent instinct of reproduction, a disturbance +usually based on repression, then any class of persons in whom the +instinct is particularly repressed would, in the very nature of the +case, be particularly liable to nervousness. + +No one who thoroughly knows human nature would attempt to deny that +woman is as strongly endowed as man with the great urge toward the +perpetuation of the race, or that she has had to repress the instinct +more severely than has man. The man insists on knowing that the +children he provides for are his own children. Whatever the degree of +his own fidelity, he must be sure that his wife is true to him. Thus +has grown up the insistence that, no matter what man does, woman, if +she is to be counted respectable, shall control the urge of the +instinct and live up to the requirements of continence set for her by +society. + +Unfortunately, however, there is more often blind repression than +rational control. The measures taken to prevent a girl's becoming a +tom-boy are measures of sex-repression quite as much as of +sex-differentiation. Over-reaction of sensitive little souls to +lessons in modesty often causes distortion of normal sex-development. +Ignorance concerning the phenomena of life is commended as innocence, +while it really implies a sex-curiosity which has been too severely +repressed. The young woman blushes at thoughts of love, while the +young man is filled with a sense of dignity. We smile at the picture +of "Miss Philura's" confusion as she hesitatingly sends up to her +Creator a petition for the much-desired boon of a husband. But really, +why shouldn't she want one? Many a young woman, in order to deaden her +senses to the unsuspected lure of the reproductive instinct by what is +really an awkward attempt at _sublimation_, makes a fetish of dress +and social position and considers only the marriage of convenience; +or, on the other hand, she scorns men altogether and throws herself +into a "career." + +Young men are not so often taught to repress, but neither are they +taught to swing their vital energies into altruistic channels through +sublimation. Since the woman of his class will not marry him until he +has money, the young man too often satisfies his undirected instincts +in a commercial way. The statistics of venereal diseases prove that +here, as elsewhere, goods subject to barter are subject to +contamination. In a late marriage, too often a contaminated body +accompanies the material possessions which the standards of society +have demanded of a husband. + +But the woman pays in still other coin for the repressions arising +from faulty childhood training. Unable to find expression for herself +either in marriage or in devotion to work, because some old childish +repression is still denying all outlet to her legitimate desire, she +frequently falls into a neurosis; or if she escapes a real breakdown, +she gives expression to unsatisfied longings in some isolated nervous +symptoms which in many cases center about the organs of generation. +There then results any one of the various functional disturbances +which are only too often mistaken for organic disease. What is needed +in cases like this is not a gynecologist nor a surgeon, but a +psycho-pathologist--or perhaps only a grasp of the facts. Let us look +at the more common of these disturbances in order to gain an +understanding of the situation. + + +THE MENSTRUAL PERIOD + +=Potential Motherhood.= Among the normal phenomena of a woman's life +is the recurring cycle of potential motherhood. Every three or four +weeks a new ovum or egg matures in the ovary and undergoes certain +chemical changes, which send into the blood a substance called a +hormone. This hormone is a messenger, stimulating the mucous membrane +of the womb into making its velvet pile longer and softer, and its +nutrient juices more abundant in readiness for the ovum. + +The same stimulus causes the whole organism to make ready for a new +life. As in hunger, the chemistry of the body produces the +muscle-tension that is felt as a craving for food, so this recurring +chemical stimulus produces a definite craving in body and mind. This +craving brings about an increased irritability or sensitiveness to +stimuli which may result either in a joyous or a fretful mood. + +During sleep the social inhibitions are felt less distinctly and the +sleeper dreams love-dreams woven from messages coming up from all the +minute nerve-endings in the expectant reproductive organs. But if no +germ-cell travels up the womb-canal and tube to meet and impregnate +the ovum, the womb-lining rejects the egg as chemically unfit. All the +furbishings are loosened from the walls and slowly cast out, +constituting the menstrual flow. The phenomenon as a whole is a +physiological function and should be accompanied by a sense of +well-being and comfort as is the exercise of any other function, such +as digestion or muscular activity. Only too often, however, it is +dreaded as an unmitigated disaster, a time for giving up work or fun +and going to bed with a hot-water bottle until "the worst is over." +Let us see how this perversion comes about. + +=Why Menstruation Is Painful.= What sort of atmosphere is created for +the young girl as she attains puberty? Most girls get their first +inkling of the menstrual period from the periodic "sick spells" of +mother or sister. This knowledge comes without conscious thought and +is a direct observation of the subconscious mind, which records +impressions with the accuracy and completeness of a photographic +plate. Hearing the talk about a "sick-time" and observing the signs of +"cramps" among older friends, the young girl's subconscious mind plays +up to the suggestion and recoils with fear from the newly experienced +sensations in the maturing organs of reproduction. + +This recoil of fear interferes with the circulation in the functioning +organs, just as fear blanches the face or hinders digestion. There is +several times as much blood in the stomach when it is full of food as +there is between meals, but we do not for this reason fancy that we +have a pain after each meal. There is more blood in the generative +organs during their functioning, but this means pain only when fear +ties up the circulation and causes undue congestion. Fear acts further +on the sturdy muscle of the womb, tying it up into just such knots as +we feel in the esophagus when we say that we have a lump in the +throat. It is safe to say that ninety-five cases of painful +menstruation out of every hundred are caused by fear and by the +expectation of pain. The cysts and tumors responsible for pain are so +rare as to be fairly negligible, when compared with these other +causes. + +Dr. Clelia Duel Mosher of Stanford University has for many years +carried on careful investigations among the students of the +university. After describing in detail certain physical exercises +which she has found of value, she continues: + + But more important even than this is an alteration of the morbid + attitude of women themselves toward this function; and almost + equally essential is a fundamental change in the habit of mind on + our part as physicians; for do we not tend to translate too much, + the whole of a woman's life into terms of menstruation? If every + young girl were taught that menstruation is not normally a "bad + time" and that pain or incapacity at that period is as + discreditable and unnecessary as bad breath due to decaying + teeth, we might almost look for a revolution in the physical life + of women.... In my experience the traditional treatment of rest + in bed, directing the attention solely to the sex-zone of the + body, and the accepted theory that it is an inevitable illness + while at the same time the mind is without occupation, produces a + morbid attitude and favors the development and exaggeration of + whatever symptoms there may be.[56] + +[Footnote 56: Clelia Duel Mosher: _Health and the Woman Movement_, pp. +25, 26, 19.] + +=Pre-Menstrual Discomfort.= If it be objected that women often feel +badly for a day or two before the period begins, before they know that +it is due, and that this feeling of discomfort could not be caused by +fear and expectation, it is easy to reply that the subconscious mind +knows perfectly what is happening within the body. The emotion of +fear, working within the subconscious, is able to translate all the +varying bodily sensations into feelings of distress without any +knowledge on the part of the conscious mind. + +Sometimes before the period begins, a girl feels blue and upset for a +day or two, a sign that the instinct is getting discouraged. The whole +body is saying, "Get ready, get ready," but it has gotten ready many +times before, and to no purpose. Unsatisfied striving brings +discouragement. What reaches consciousness is a feeling of pessimism +and a general dissatisfaction with life as a whole. If, instead of +giving in to the blues or going to bed and predicting a pain, the girl +finds other outlets for her energy, she finds that after all, her +instinct may be satisfied in indirect ways and that she has strangely +come into a new supply of _vim_. + +=The Purpose of the Pain.= Although suggestion is behind all nervous +symptoms, there is a deeper reason for the disturbance. When an +unhealthy suggestion is seized and acted upon, it is because some +unsatisfied part of the personality sees in it a chance for +accomplishing its own ends. The pre-menstrual period is the +blooming-time, the mating-time, the springtime of the organism. That +means eminently a time for coming into notice, that one's charms may +attract the desired complement. But if the rightfully insistent +instinctive desires are held in check by unnatural repressions and +misapplied social restrictions, the starved instinct can obtain +expression only by a concealment of purpose. The disguise assumed is +often one of indifference or positive distaste for the allurements of +the other sex. But, as we know, an instinctive desire will not be +denied. In this case, the misguided instinct which has been given the +suggestion that menstruation means illness, fits this conception into +the scheme of things and obtains notice in a roundabout way by the +attention given to the invalid. + +=The Treatment.= To find that the symptom has a purpose rather than a +cause gives the indication for the treatment. Judicious neglect causes +the symptom to cease by defeating its very purpose,--that of drawing +attention to itself. The person who never mentions her discomfort, +thinks about it as little as possible, and goes about her business as +usual, is likely to find her trouble gone before she realizes it.[57] + +[Footnote 57: Violent exercise at this time is unwise, but continuing +one's usual activity helps the circulation and keeps the mind from +centering on the affected part. The physiological congestion is unduly +intensified by standing; therefore all employments should afford +facilities for the woman to sit at least part of the time while +continuing work.] + +A little explanation gives the patient insight into the workings of +her own mind, and usually causes the pain to disappear in short order. +Astonished, indeed, and filled with gratitude have been some of my +young-women patients who had all their lives been unable to plan any +work or social engagements for the time of this functioning. Many of +them were the worst kind of doubters when they were told that to go to +bed and center their attention on the generative organs only made the +muscles tighten up and the circulation congest. They could not +conceive themselves up and around, pursuing their normal life during +such a time. However, as they have found by experience that this point +of view is not an optimistic dream, they have broken up the +confidence-game which their subconscious had been playing on them, and +have gone on their way rejoicing. + +There was one young girl, a doctor's daughter, who suffered +continuously from pain in the abdomen, and from back-pain which +increased so greatly at the time of the menses that she was in the +habit of going to bed for several days, to be waited on with +solicitous care by her family. In an attempt to cure the trouble she +had undergone an operation to suspend the uterus, but the pain had +continued as before. When she came to me, I explained to her that +there was no physical difficulty and that her trouble was wholly +nervous. I made her play tennis every day and she had just finished a +game when her period came on. She stayed up for luncheon, went for a +walk in the afternoon, ate her dinner with the family, and behaved +like other people. Her mother telephoned that evening and when I told +her what her daughter had been doing, she gasped in astonishment. She +had difficulty in believing that the new order was not miracle but +simply the working out of natural law. Since that time her daughter +has had no more trouble. + +=The Ounce of Prevention.= If young girls had wiser counselors in +their mothers and physicians, the misconception would never occur, and +such an indirect outlet would not be needed; the organic sensations +incident to puberty and the recurring menstrual period would have +something of the significance of the annunciation to Mary, bringing +wonder and a sense of well-being. + +When your little daughter arrives at maturity, give her a joyous +initiation into the noble order of women. She will welcome the new +function as a badge of womanhood and as a harbinger of wonderful +things to come. + +A girl of fifteen came under my care to be helped out of a mood of +increasing depression and uneasiness. Her glance was furtive, yet +anxiously expectant. Tears came unbidden as she sat alone or fingered +the keys of the piano. Tactful questioning elicited no response as to +reasons for her unhappiness. Opportunities for giving confidence were +not accepted. At a chance moment our talk drifted to the subject of +menstruation. "Your periods are regular and easy; and do you know what +they are for?" Then I painted for her a picture of the preparations +that are made throughout the whole organism, for the germ-cell that +comes each month and has in it all the possibilities of a new little +life. + +The result of this confidential talk may seem fanciful to any one but +an eye-witness. We had only a week's association, but the depression +ceased, the furtive look and deprecatory manner were replaced by a +joyous buoyancy. In a few weeks the thin neck and awkward body rounded +out into the symmetry which usually precedes the establishment of +puberty, but which was delayed in this case until the unconscious +conflict resolved itself. + +=In the Large.= Looked at from any angle, this subject is an important +one. There are involved not only the physical comfort and convenience +of the sufferers themselves, but also the economic prospects of women +as a whole. If women are to demand equal opportunity and equal pay, +they must be able to do equal work without periodic times of illness. +When employers of women tell us that they regularly have to hire extra +help because some of their workers lose time each month, we realize +how great is the aggregate of economic waste, a waste which would +assuredly be justified if the health of the country's womanhood were +really involved, but which is inefficient and unnecessary when caused +merely by ignorant tradition. "Up to standard every day of every +week," is a slogan quite within the range of possibility for all but +the seriously ill. When reduced to their lowest terms, the +inconveniences of this function are not great and are not too dear a +price to pay for the possibilities of motherhood. + + +THE "CHANGE OF LIFE" + +=Another Phantom Peril.= As the young girl is taught to fear the +menstrual period, so the older woman is taught to dread the time when +the periods shall cease. Despite the general enlightenment of this day +and age, the menopause or "change of life" is all too frequently +feared as a "critical period" in a woman's life, a time of distressing +physical sensations and even of danger to mental balance. + +As a matter of fact, the menopause is a physiological process which +should be accomplished with as little mental and physical disturbance +as accompanies the establishment of puberty. The same internal +secretion is concerned in both. When the function of ovulation ceases +the body has to find a new way to dispose of the internal secretion of +the ovary. Its presence in the blood is the cause of the sudden +dilatation of the blood-vessels that is known as the "hot flash." + +The matter is altogether a problem of chemistry, with the necessity +for a new adjustment among the glands of internal secretion. The body +easily manages this if left to itself, but is greatly interfered with +by the wrong suggestion and emotion. We have already seen how quickly +emotion affects all secretions and how easily the adrenal and thyroid +glands are influenced by fear. This is the root of the trouble in many +cases of difficult "change." If an occasional body is not quite able +to regulate the chemical readjustment, we may have to administer the +glands of some other animal, but in the majority of cases, the body, +unhampered by an extra burden of fear, is quite able to make its own +adjustments. The hot flash passes in a moment, if not prolonged by +emotion or if not converted into a habit by attention. + +One source of trouble in the menopause is that it comes at a time in a +woman's life when she is likely to have too much leisure. In no way +can a woman so easily handicap her body at this time as by stopping +work and being afraid. Those women who have to go on as usual find +themselves past the change almost before they know it,--unless they +consider themselves abused, and worry over the necessity for working +through such a "critical time." + +=Three Rules.= Here are a few pointers which have have been of help to +a number of women: + +1 Remember that this is a physiological process and therefore +abundantly safeguarded by Nature. If you don't expect trouble you will +not be likely to find it. + +2 Remember that the sweating and flushing are made worse by notice. + +3 Do everything in your power to keep from the public the knowledge +that you are no longer a potential mother. If you are past forty, do +not mop your face or gasp for breath or carry a fan to the theater! +Shun attention and fear, and you will be surprised at the ease with +which the "change" is effected. + +=Nature's Last Chance.= While we are on the subject of the middle-aged +woman, it may be well to mention a phenomenon sometimes noticed in the +early forties. Often an "old maid" who has considered herself settled +for life in her bachelor estate, suddenly takes to herself a husband. +(I use the verb advisedly!) Mothers who have thought their +child-bearing days long past sometimes find themselves pregnant. "The +child of her old age" is not an uncommon occurrence. Unmarried women +who have "kept straight" all their lives sometimes go down before +temptation at this late time. There is a reason. It is as though +Nature were making a last desperate attempt to produce another life +before it is too late, speeding up all the internal secretions and +flashing insistent messages throughout the whole organism. + +It may help some woman who feels herself inexplicably impelled toward +the male sex to know that she is not being "tempted by the devil" but +merely driven by the insistent chemicals within her body. She is +likely to rationalize and tell herself that it is too bad for a +worth-while person like herself to leave no progeny behind her; or she +may say, as one of my patients did when contemplating running away +with another woman's husband,--that she could make that man so much +happier than his wife did, and that she really owed it to him as well +as to herself. When a woman knows what is the matter with her, it +makes it easier to bide her time and wait for the demands of Nature to +subside. Chemicals may not be so romantic as love, but neither are +they so melodramatic! + + +OTHER TROUBLES + +="Speaking of Operations."= Physicians are often called upon to +diagnose some such vague symptom as pain in the abdomen, back and +head; ache in the legs; constipation, or loss of appetite. Since the +patient is very insistent that something shall be done, the physician +may be driven to operate, even when he has an uneasy feeling that the +trouble is "merely nervous." Sixty per cent. of the operations on +women are necessitated by the results of gonorrheal infection. Next in +frequency up to recent date, have been operations for nervous symptoms +which could in no way be reached by the knife. Only too often a +nerve-specialist hears the tale of an operation which was supposed to +cure a certain pain but which left it worse rather than better. It is +a pleasure to see some of these pains disappear under a little +re-education, but one cannot help wishing that the re-education had +come before the knife instead of after it. + +A skilled surgeon can cut almost anything out of a person's body, but +he cannot cut out an instinct. It sometimes takes great skill to +determine whether the trouble is an organic affection or a functional +disturbance caused by the misdirected instinct of reproduction. Often, +however, the clinical pictures are so different as to leave no room +for doubt, provided the diagnostician has his eyes open and is not +over-persuaded by the importunity of the poor neurotic, who insists +that the surgeon shall remove her appendix, her gall-bladder, her +genital organs, and her tonsils, and who finally comes back that he +may have a whack at the operation scar. + +=The Bearing of Children.= A number of years ago I became acquainted +with a charming young married woman who had all her life recoiled with +fear from the phenomena of sex. She had been afraid of menstruation +and of marriage, and had at this time almost a phobia for pregnancy +and childbirth. Before long she came to me in terror, telling me that +she had become pregnant. I explained to her that pregnancy is the time +when most women are at their best, that the nausea which is often +troublesome in the beginning is caused merely by a mixing of messages +from the autonomic nerves, which refer new sensations in the womb to +the more usual center of activity in the stomach; and that after the +body has become accustomed to these sensations, most women experience +a greater sense of well-being and peace than at any other time in +life. We had a conversation or two on the subject and everything +seemed to go well for a while. + +As it happened, this young woman and her husband came to call on me +one afternoon just before the baby was expected. During the visit she +began to show signs of being in labor. Again she was in terror. Again +I explained the phenomena of labor, telling her that the +womb-contractions are caused by the presence in the blood of a +chemical secretion (hormone) which continues its good work as long as +there is a state of confidence, but which sometimes stops under fear +or apprehension. I explained that these womb-efforts are a peristaltic +movement, a contraction of the upper muscles and a letting go of the +purse-string muscle at the mouth of the womb, and that fear only tends +to tie up this purse-string muscle, making a difficult process out of +one which was intended by Nature to be much more simple. She seemed to +understand and to lose a good deal of her fright. + +About six o'clock the couple went home on the street car from the +upper end of Pasadena to the far end of Los Angeles. The next morning +I had a jubilant telephone message from the happy father, announcing +that the boy-baby had arrived at midnight and that, wonderful to +relate, he had come without the mother's experiencing any pain +whatever. + +I give this account for what it is worth, without of course contending +that labor could always be as easy as this. It happened that this girl +was a normal, healthy woman and that there were no complications of +any kind in the process of childbirth. A right attitude of mind could +not have corrected any physical difficulty, but it did seem to help +her let go of her fear, which would of itself have caused long and +painful labor. + +A patient once told me that when her first baby came, she happened to +be out in the country where she had to call in a doctor whom she did +not know. He was an uncouth sort of fellow who inspired fear rather +than confidence. She soon found that labor stopped whenever he came +into the room, and started again when he went out. She had the good +sense to send him out and complete her labor with only the help of her +mother. Unfortunate is the obstetrician who does not know how to +inspire a feeling of confidence in his patients. Even childbirth may +be mightily helped or hindered by the mother's state of mind. + + +SUMMARY + +A woman's body has more stability than she knows. It is sometimes out +of order, but it is more often misunderstood; usually it is an +unobtrusive and satisfactory instrument, quite fit for its daily +tasks. The average woman is really well put together. We hear about +the ones who have difficulty, but not about the great majority who do +not. We notice the few who are upset during the menopause, and forget +all the others. To be comfortable and efficient most of the time is, +after all, merely to be "like folks." + +The special functions which Nature has been perfecting in a woman's +body are as a rule, easily carried through unless complicated by false +ideas or by fear. + +If the woman who has no organic difficulty but who still finds herself +handicapped by her body, will cease being either resigned to her +languishing lot or envious of her stalwart brothers; if instead she +will set out to learn how to be efficient as a woman, she will find +that many of her ills are not the blunders of an inefficient Creator, +but are home-made products, which quickly vanish in the light of +understanding. + + + + +CHAPTER XIII + +_In which we lose our dread of night._ + +THAT INTERESTING INSOMNIA + +THE FEAR OF STAYING AWAKE + + +To sleep or not to sleep! That is the question. In all the world there +is nothing to equal it in importance,--to the man with insomnia. His +days are mere interludes between troubled nights spent in restless +tossing to and fro and feverish worry over the weary day to come. His +mind filled with ideas about the disastrous effects of insomnia, he +imagines himself fast sliding down hill toward the grave or the +insane-asylum. It is true that his conversation very often politely +begins something like this: "Good morning. Did you sleep well last +night?" but if we fail to respond by an equally polite "and I hope you +had a good night?" he seems restless until he has somehow +disillusioned us by stating the exact number of hours and minutes +during which he was able to lose himself in slumber. + +We must not ridicule the man who doesn't sleep. We are all very much +alike. If any one of us happens to lie awake for a night or two, he is +likely to get into a panic, and if the spell should last a week, he +begins looking up steamship agents and talking of voyages to Southern +seas. The fact is that most people are dreadfully afraid of insomnia. +Knowing the effects of a few nights of enforced wakefulness, and +having had a little experience with the fagged feeling after a +restless night, they believe themselves only logical when they fall +into a panic over the prospect of persistent insomnia. + +=Two Kinds of Wakefulness.= As a matter of fact, insomnia is a phantom +peril. There is not the slightest danger from lying awake nights, +provided one is not kept awake by some irritating physical stimulus. +All fear of insomnia is based on ignorance of the difference between +enforced wakefulness and deliberate wakefulness, or insomnia. The man +who has acquired the habit may stay awake almost indefinitely without +appreciable harm, but the one who is kept awake for a week by a pain, +by a chemical poison from infection, or by the necessity for staying +up on his job, may easily be in a state of exhaustion. Even in cases +of prolonged pain or over-exertion, the body tends to maintain its +equilibrium by hastening its rate of repair and by falling asleep +before the danger point is reached. It is almost impossible to impair +permanently the tissue of the brain except in the presence of a +chemical irritant. In case of infection we often have to give medicine +to neutralize the effect of the poison or to resort to narcotics which +make the brain cells less susceptible to irritation. But nervous +insomnia is another story. + + +A HARMLESS HABIT + +=Long-Lived Insomniacs.= A man of my acquaintance once said in all +seriousness and with evident alarm: "I am following in the footsteps +of my mother. She lived to be seventy years old and she had insomnia +all her life." If this man had been preaching a sermon on the +harmlessness of chronic insomnia, he could not have chosen a better +text, but he seemed just as much concerned about himself as if his +mother had died from the effects of three months' wakefulness. People +can live healthy lives during twenty or thirty years of insomnia +because chronic insomnia is nothing more or less than a habit, and +"habit spells ease." The brain cells are not irritated by either +internal or external stimuli; there is no effort to keep awake; +virtually no energy is expended,--except in restless tossing and +worry. If the body is kept still and emotion eliminated, fatigue +products are washed away and the reserves are filled in with perfect +ease. + +=Thinking in Circles.= Habit means automatic, subconscious activity, +with the least expenditure of energy and the least amount of fatigue. +We have already noted the ease with which heart and diaphragm muscles +carry on their work from the beginning of life to its end. Anything +relegated to the subconscious mind can be kept up almost indefinitely +without tire, and to this subconscious type of activity belong the +thoughts of a chronic insomniac. Despite all assertions to the +contrary, his conscious mind is not really awake. If he is questioned +about the happenings of the night, he is likely to have been unaware +of the most audible noises. The thoughts that run through his brain +are not new, constructive, energy-consuming thoughts, but the same old +thoughts that have been going around in circles for days and weeks at +a time. + +It is true that a person sometimes chooses to wake up and do his +constructive planning in the night. This kind of thought does bring +fatigue, up to a certain point. After that the body hastens its rate +of repair or automatically goes to sleep. Activity of this kind is +always a matter of choice. He who really prefers sleep will shut the +drawers containing the day's business and leave them shut until +morning. + +=Day-Dreaming at Night.= However, the man who makes a practice of +staying awake rarely does much real thinking. He lets the thoughts run +through his mind as they will, builds air-castles of things he would +like to do and can't, or other kinds of air-castles about the +disastrous effects of his insomnia on the day that is to come; he +worries over his health, or his finances, and grieves over his +sorrows. He is really indulging himself, thinking the thoughts he +likes most to think, and these consume but little energy. Like a horse +that knows the rounds, they can go jogging on indefinitely without +guidance from the driver. + + +WHAT CAUSES THE FATIGUE + +=Tossing and Fretting.= The thing that tires is not the insomnia but +the emotion over the insomnia. If people who fail to sleep are +perpetually fagged out, it is not from loss of sleep, but from worry +and tossing. Often they spend a good deal of the night feeling sorry +for themselves. They turn and toss, exclaiming with each turn: "Why +don't I sleep? How badly I shall feel to-morrow! What a night! What a +night!" Such a spree of emotionalism can hardly fail to tire, but it +is not fair to blame the insomnia. + +He who makes up his mind to it can rest almost as well without sleep +as with it, provided he keeps his mind calm and his body relaxed. +"Decent hygienic conditions" demand not necessarily eight hours of +sleep but eight hours of quiet rest in bed. Tossing about drives away +sleep and uses up energy. I make it a rule that my patients shall not +turn over more than four times during the night. This is more +important than that they should sleep. To be sure, I do not stay awake +to enforce the rule, but most people catch the idea very quickly and +before they know it they are sleeping. + + +HOW TO GO TO SLEEP + +=Ceasing to Care.= The best way to learn to sleep is not to care +whether you do or not. Nothing could be better than DuBois's advice: +"Don't look for sleep; it flies away like a pigeon when one pursues +it."[58] Attention to anything keeps the mind awake, and most of all, +attention to sleep. More than one person has waked up to see whether +or not he was going to sleep. We cannot, however, fool ourselves by +merely pretending indifference. The only sensible way is to get the +facts firmly fixed in our minds so that we actually realize that we do +not need more sleep than our bodies take. As soon as it is realized +that insomnia is really of no importance, it tends to disappear. + +[Footnote 58: DuBois: _Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders_, p. +339.] + +=Catching the Idea.= There came one day for consultation a very +healthy-looking woman, a deaconess of the Lutheran Church. "Doctor," +she said, "I came to get relief from insomnia. For twenty years I have +not slept more than one or two hours a night." "Why do you want more?" +I asked. "Why, isn't it very unhealthy not to sleep?" she exclaimed +in astonishment. "Evidently not," I answered. + +This woman had tried every doctor she could think of, including the +splendid S. Weir Mitchell. Her insomnia had become a preoccupation +with her, her chief thought in life. All I did was to explain to her +that her body had been getting all the sleep it needed, and that +neither body nor mind was in the least run down after twenty years of +sleeplessness. "When you cease being interested in your insomnia, it +will go away, although from a health standpoint it matters very little +whether it does or not." We had two conversations on the subject, and +a week later she came back to tell me that she was sleeping eight +hours a night. + +One woman had had insomnia for thirty years. After I had explained to +her that her body had adjusted itself to this way of living and that +she need not try to get more sleep, she snored so loud all night and +every night that the rest of the family began to complain! + +A certain banker proved very quick at catching the idea. He had been +so troubled with insomnia and intense weakness that his doctors +prescribed a six-months voyage in Southern waters. Knowing that my +prescriptions involved a change in point of view rather than in scene, +he came to me. Although he had been getting only about half an hour's +sleep a night, he went to sleep in his chair the first evening, and +then went upstairs and slept all night. He resumed his duties at the +bank, walking a mile and a half the first day and three miles the +second. During the months following, he reported, "No more insomnia." + +=Keeping Account.= A bright young college graduate came to me for a +number of ailments, chief among them being sleeplessness. She was also +overcome by fatigue, having spent four months in bed. A four-mile walk +in the canon and a few other such outings soon dispelled the fatigue, +but the insomnia proved more obstinate. After she had been with me for +a week or two, I took her aside one day for a little talk. "Well?" I +said as we sat down. Then she began: "Sunday night I was awake from +half-past one to four, Monday from twelve to one, Tuesday from one to +three, Wednesday from two to four, Thursday--" By this time she became +aware of the quizzical expression on my face and began to be +embarrassed. Then she stopped and laughed. "Well," she said, "I did +not know that I was paying so much attention to my sleep." She was +bright enough to see the point at once, gave up her preoccupation in +the all-absorbing topic and promptly forgot to have any trouble with +so natural a function as sleep. + +=Making New Associations.= Examples like this show how natural is +childlike slumber when once we take away the inhibitions of a +hampering idea. Age-old habits like sleep are not lost, but they may +easily be interfered with by a little too much attention. When a +person who can scarcely keep his eyes open all the evening is +instantly wide awake as soon as his head touches the pillow, we may be +sure that a part of his trouble comes from the wrong associations +which he has built up with the thought of night. When a dear little +old lady told me of her constant state of apprehension about going to +bed, I said to her: "When I go to my room, the darkness says sleep. +When I take off my clothes, the very act says sleep. When I put my +head on the pillow, the pillow says sleep." She liked that and found +herself able to sleep all night. The next evening she wanted another +"sleeping-potion" but as I did not want her to become dependent on +anybody's suggestion, I put my mouth up close to her ear and +whispered, "Abra ca dabra, dum, dum, dum." She laughed, but saw the +point. After that she slept very well. She merely broke the habit by +making a new kind of association with the thought of bed. Nature did +the rest. + +It seems hardly necessary to remark that drug-taking is the most +inefficient way of handling the situation. Everybody knows that +narcotics are harmful to the delicate cells of the brain and that the +dose has to be continuously increased in cases of chronic insomnia. +If a person realizes that the drug is far more harmful than the +insomnia itself, he is weak indeed to yield to temptation for the sake +of a few nights of sleep. As the cause of insomnia is psychic, so the +only logical cure is a new idea and a new attitude of mind. + + +THE PURPOSE OF INSOMNIA + +Like all nervous symptoms, insomnia is not an affliction but an +indulgence. Somehow, and in ways unknown to the conscious mind, it +brings a certain amount of satisfaction to a part of the personality. +No matter how unpleasant it may be, no matter how much we consciously +fear it, something inside chooses to stay awake. + +Started, as a rule, through suggestion or imitation, insomnia is +sometimes kept up as a means of making ourselves seem important,--to +ourselves and to others. It at least provides an excuse for thinking +and talking about ourselves, and furnishes a certain feeling of +distinction. If something within us craves attention, even staying +awake may not be too dear a price to pay for that attention. Strange +to say, there are other times when the insomnia is chosen by the +primitive subconscious mind with the idea of doing penance for +supposed sins whose evil effects might possibly be avoided by this +kind of expiation. Analysis shows that motives like this are not so +uncommon as might be supposed. In other cases insomnia is chosen for +the chance it gives for phantasy-building. A person denied the right +kind of outlet for his instincts may so enjoy the day-dreaming habit +that he prolongs it into the night, really preferring it to sleep. +Such a state of affairs is not at all incompatible with an intense +conscious desire to sleep and a real fear of insomnia. So strange may +be the motives hidden away within the depths of the most prosaic +individual! + + +SUMMARY + +Nervous insomnia is something which a part of us makes use of and +another part fears. It is a mistake on both sides. Although not in the +least dangerous, the habit can hardly be considered a satisfactory +form of amusement. Nature has provided a better way to spend the +night, a way to which she speedily brings us when we choose to let her +do it. + +We do not have to ask for sleep as for a special boon which may be +denied. We simply have to lie down in trust, expecting to be carried +away like a child. If our expectation is not at once realized we can +still trust, as with relaxed mind and body we lie in calm content, +knowing that Nature is, minute by minute, restoring us for another +day. + + + + +CHAPTER XIV + +_In which we raise our thresholds_ + +FEELING OUR FEELINGS + +FINELY STRUNG VIOLINS + + +The young girl had been telling me about her symptoms. "You know, +Doctor," she said. "I am a very sensitive person. In fact, I have +always been told that I am like a finely strung violin." There was +pride in every tone of her voice,--pride and satisfaction over +possessing an organization so superior to the common clay of the +average person. It was a typical remark, and showed clearly that this +girl belonged among the nervous folk. For the nervous person is not +only over-sensitive, but he accepts his condition with a secret and +half-conscious pride as a token of superiority. + +It seems that there are a good many kinds of sensitiveness. Whether it +is a good or bad possession depends entirely on what kind of things a +person is sensitive to. If he is quick to take in a situation, easily +impressed with the needs of others, open-doored to beauty and to the +appeal of the spiritual, keenly alive to the humorous, even when the +joke is on himself and the situation uncomfortable, then surely he has +a right to be glad of his sensitiveness. But too often the word means +something else. It means feeling, intensely, physical sensations of +which most people are unaware, or reacting emotionally to situations +which call for no such response. It means, in short, feeling our +feelings and liking to feel them. There seems to be nothing +particularly praiseworthy or desirable about this kind of +sensitiveness. If this is what it means to be a "finely-wrought +violin," it might even be better to be a bass drum which can stand a +few poundings without ruin to its constitution. + +"But," says the sensitive person, "are we not born either violins or +drums? Is not heredity rather than choice to blame? And what can a +person do about it?" These questions are so closely bound up with the +problems of nervous symptoms of indigestion, fatigue, a woman's ills, +hysterical pains and sensations, and with all the problems of +emotional control, that we shall do well to look more carefully into +this question of sensibility, which is really the question of the +relation of the individual to his environment. + + +SELECTING OUR SENSATIONS + +=Reaction and Over-Reaction.= Every organism, if it is to live, must +be normally sensitive to its environment. It must possess the power +of response to stimuli. As the sea-anemone curls up at touch, and as +the tiny baby blinks at the light, so must every living thing be able +to sense and to react to the presence of a dangerous or a friendly +force. Only by a certain degree of irritability can it survive in the +struggle for existence. The five senses are simply different phases of +the apparatus for receiving communications from the outside world. +Other parts of the machinery catch the manifold messages continually +pouring into the brain from within our bodies themselves. These +communications cannot be stopped nor can we prevent their impress on +the cells of the brain and spinal cord, but we do have a good deal to +say as to which ones shall be brought into the focus of attention and +receive enough notice to become real, conscious sensations. + +=Paying Attention.= If a human being had to give conscious attention +to every stimulus from the outer world and from his own body, to every +signal which flashes itself along his sensory nerves to his brain, he +would need a different kind of mind from his present efficient but +limited apparatus. As it is, there is an admirable provision for +taking care of the messages without overburdening consciousness. The +stream of messages never stops, not even in sleep. But the conscious +mind has its private secretary, the subconscious, to receive the +messages and to answer them. + +During any five minutes of a walk down a city street a man has +hundreds of visual images flashed upon the retina of the eye. His eye +sees every little line in the faces of the passers-by, every detail of +their clothing, the decorations on the buildings, the street signs +overhead, the articles in the shop-windows, the paving of the +sidewalks, the curbings and tracks which he crosses, and scores of +other objects to most of which the man himself is oblivious. His ear +hears every sound within hearing distance,--the honk of every horn, +the clang of every bell, the voices of the people and the shuffle of +feet. Some part of his mind feels the press of his foot on the +pavement, the rubbing of his heel on his stocking, the touch of his +clothing all over his body, and all those so-called kinesthetic +sensations,--sensations of motion and balance which keep him in +equilibrium and on the move, to say nothing of the never-ending stream +of messages from every cell of every muscle and tissue of his body. + +Out of this constant rush of stimuli our man gives attention to only +the smallest fraction. Whatever is interesting to him, that he sees +and hears and feels. All other sensations he passes by as indifferent. +Unless they come with extraordinary intensity, they do not get over +into his consciousness at all. + +="Listening-in" on the Subconscious.= The subconscious mind knows and +needs to know what is happening in the farthermost cell of the body. +It needs to know at any moment where the knees are, and the feet; +otherwise the individual would fall in a heap whenever he forgot to +watch his step. It needs to know just how much light is entering the +eye, and how much blood is in the stomach. To this end it has a system +of communication from every point in the body and this system is in +constant operation. Its messages never cease. But these messages were +never meant to be in the focus of attention. They are meant only for +the subconscious mind and are generally so low-toned as to be easily +ignored unless one falls into the habit of listening for them. Unless +they are invested with a significance which does not belong to them, +they will not emerge into consciousness as real sensations. + +=Psychic Thresholds.= Boris Sidis has given us a word which has proved +very useful in this connection. The limit of sensitivity of a +cell--the degree of irritability--he calls the stimulus-threshold.[59] +As the wind must come in gusts to drive the rain in over a high +doorsill, so must any stimulus--an idea or a sensation--come with +sufficient force to get over the obstructions at the doorway of +consciousness. These psychic thresholds do not maintain a constant +level. They are raised or lowered at will by a hidden and automatic +machinery, which is dependent entirely on the ideas already in +consciousness, by the interest bestowed upon the newcomer. The +intensity of the stimuli cannot be controlled, but the interest we +feel in them and the welcome given them are very largely a matter of +choice. + +[Footnote 59: Sidis: _Foundations of Normal and Abnormal Psychology_, +Chap. XXX.] + +Each organism has a wide field of choice as to which ideas and which +physical stimuli it shall welcome and which it shall shut out. We may +raise our thresholds, build up a bulwark of indifference to a whole +class of excitations, shut our mental doors, and pull down the shades; +or we may lower the thresholds so that the slightest flicker of an +idea or the smallest pin-prick of a sensation finds ready access to +the center of attention. + +=Thresholds and Character.= There are certain thresholds made to shift +frequently and easily. When one is hungry any food tastes good, for +the threshold is low; but the food must be most tempting to be +acceptable just after a hearty meal. On the other hand, a fairly +constant threshold is maintained for many different kinds of stimuli. +These stimuli are always bound together in groups, and make appeal +depending upon the predominating interest. As anything pertaining to +agriculture is noticed by a farmer, or any article of dress by a +fashionable woman, so any stimulus coming from a "warm" group is +welcomed, while any from a "cold" group is met by a high threshold. +The kind of person one is depends on what kind of things are "warm" +to him and what kind are "cold." The superman is one who has gained +such conscious control of his psychic thresholds that he can raise and +lower them at will in the interests of the social good. + +=Thresholds and Sensations.= The importance of these principles is +obvious. The next chapter will show more of their influence on ideas +and emotions; but for the present we will consider their lessons in +the sphere of the physical. Psychology speaks here in no uncertain +terms to physiology. Whoever becomes fascinated by the processes of +his own body is bound to magnify the sensations from those processes, +until the most insignificant message from the subconscious becomes a +distressing and alarming symptom. The person whose mental ear is +strained to catch every little creaking of his internal machinery can +always hear some kind of rumble. If he deliberately lowers his +thresholds to the whole class of stimuli pertaining to himself, there +is small wonder that they sweep over the boundaries into consciousness +with irresistible force. + +=The Motives for Sensitiveness.= Sensitiveness is largely a matter of +choice, but what determines choice? Why is it that one person chooses +altruism as the master threshold that determines the level of all the +others, while another person who ought to be equally fine lowers his +thresholds only to himself? What makes a person too interested in his +own sensations and feelings? As usual there is a cause. + +The real cause back of most cases of chronic sensitiveness is an +abnormal desire for attention. Sometimes this love of attention arises +from an under-developed instinct of self-assertion, or "inferiority +complex." If there is a sense of inadequacy, a feeling of not being so +important as other people, a person is quite likely to over-compensate +by making himself seem important to himself and to others in the only +way he knows. All unconsciously he develops an extreme sensitiveness +which somehow heightens his self-regard by making him believe himself +finely and delicately organized, and by securing the notice of his +associates. + +Or, again, the love of attention may be simply a sign of arrested +development, a fixation of the Narcissistic period of childhood which +loves to look at itself and make the world look. Or there may be lack +of satisfaction of the normal adult love-life, a lack of the love and +attention which the love-instinct naturally craves. If this instinct +is not getting normal outlet, either directly through personal +relationships or indirectly through a sublimated activity, what is +more natural than that it should turn in on itself, dissociate its +interest in other things and occupy itself with its own feelings, and +at the same time secure the coveted attention through physical +disability, with its necessity for special ministration? + +In any case there is likely to develop a general overreaction to all +outside stimulation, a hypersensitiveness to some particular kind of +stimulus, or a chronic hysterical pain which somehow serves the +personality in ways unknown to itself. No one "feels his feelings" +unless, despite all discomfort, he really enjoys them. A hard +statement to accept perhaps, but one that is repeatedly proved by a +specialist in "nerves"! + + +DETERMINING CAUSES + +=Accidental Association.= In many cases, the form which the +sensitiveness takes is merely a matter of accident. Often it is based +on some small physical disability, as when a slight tendency to take +cold is magnified into an intense fear of fresh air. + +Sometimes a past fleeting pain which has become associated with the +stream of thought of an emotional moment--what Boris Sidis calls the +moment-consciousness--is perpetuated in consciousness in place of the +repressed emotion. "In the determination of the pathology of hysteria, +the accidental moment plays a much greater part than is generally +recognized; if a painful affect--emotion--originates while eating but +is repressed, it may produce nausea and vomiting and continue for +months as an hysterical symptom."[60] + +[Footnote 60: Freud: _Selected Papers_, p. 2.] + +One of Freud's patients, Miss Rosalie H----, found while taking +singing-lessons that she often choked over notes of the middle +register, although she took with ease notes higher and lower in the +scale. It was revealed that this girl, who had a most unhappy home +life, had, during a former period, often experienced this choking +sensation from a painful emotion just before she went for her music +lesson. Some of the left-over sensations had remained during the +singing, and as the middle notes happen to involve the same muscles as +does a lump in one's throat, she had often found herself choking over +these notes. Later on, while living in a different city and in a +wholly different environment, the physical sensations from her throat +muscles, as they took these middle notes, brought back the associated +sensations of choking,--without, however, uncovering the buried +emotion.[61] Many a painful hysterical affliction is based on just +such mechanisms as these. As Freud remarks, "The hysteric suffers +mostly from reminiscences."[62] + +[Footnote 61: Ibid, p. 43.] + +[Footnote 62: Ibid, p. 5.] + +=Subconscious Symbolism.= Sometimes, as we have seen, the form which +a hypersensitiveness assumes is not determined by any physical +sensation, either past or symbolism which acts out in the body the +drama of the soul. + +=Facing the Facts.= Whatever the motives and whatever the determining +causes, hypersensibility is in any case a feeling of feelings which is +not warranted by the present situation. Hypersensitiveness is never +anything but a makeshift kind of satisfaction. Despite certain +subconscious reasoning, it does not make one more important nor more +beloved. Neither does it furnish a real expression for that great +creative love-instinct whose outlet, if it is to bring satisfaction, +must be a real outlet into the external world. An understanding of the +motives is helpful only when it makes clear that they are +short-sighted motives and that the real desires back of them may be +satisfied in better ways. + + +SOME LOWERED THRESHOLDS + +As the public appetite for specific cases appears to be insatiable, we +will give from real life some examples of low thresholds which were +raised through re-education. One hesitates to write down these +examples because when they are on paper they sound like advertisements +of patent medicines. However, there is no magic in any of these cures, +but only the working out of definite laws which may be used by other +sufferers, if they only know. Re-education through a knowledge of +oneself and the laws at work really does remarkable things when it has +a chance. + +="Danger-Signals" without the Danger.= There was the man who had queer +feelings all over his body, especially in his head and stomach, and +who considered these sensations as danger-signals warning him to stop. +This man had worked up from messenger boy to a position next to the +president in one of the transcontinental railroad systems. On the +appearance of these "danger-signals" he had tried to resign but had +been given a year's leave of absence instead. Half the year had gone +in rest-cure, but he was still afraid to eat or work, and believed +himself "done for." After three weeks of re-education he saw that +instead of having overdrawn his capital, he had in another sense +overdrawn his sensations. He went away as fit as ever, finished his +leave of absence doing hard labor on his farm, and then went back to +even harder tasks, working for the Government in the administration of +the railroads during the war. He is still at work. + +=Enjoying Poor Health.= There was the woman who had been an invalid +for twenty years, doing little else during all that time than to feel +her own feelings. Because of the distressing sensations in her +stomach, she had for a year taken nothing but liquid nourishment. She +had queer feelings in her solar-plexus and indeed a general luxury of +over-feeling. She could not leave her room nor have any visitors. She +was the star invalid of the family, waited on by her two hard-working +sisters who earned the living for them all. + +Her sisters had inveigled her to my house under false pretenses, +calling it a boarding-house and omitting to mention that I was a +doctor, because "she guessed she knew more about her case than any +doctor." For the first week I got in only one sentence a day,--just +before I slipped out of the door after taking in her "liquid +nourishment." But at the end of the week I announced that thereafter +her meals would be served in the dining-room. When she found that +there was to be no more liquid nourishment, she had to appear at the +family table. After that it was only a short time before she was at +home, cooking for her sisters. When she saw the role she had been +unconsciously playing, she could hardly wish to go on with it. + +=Feeling His Legs.= Mr. R. suffered from such severe and distressing +pains in his legs that he believed himself on the verge of paralysis. +He was also bothered by a chronic emotional state which made him look +like a "weepy" woman. His eyes were always full of tears and his chin +a-quiver, and he had, as he said, a perpetual lump in his throat. +Under re-education both lump and paralysis disappeared completely and +Mr. R. took his wife across the continent, driving his machine with +his own hands--and feet. + +=A Subconscious Association.= Mr. D.'s case admirably illustrates the +return of symptoms through an unconscious association. He was a +lawyer, prominent in public affairs of the Middle West, who had been +my patient for several weeks and who had gone home cured of many +striking disabilities. Before he came to me, he had given up his +public work and was believed by all his associates to be afflicted +with softening of the brain, and "out of the game" for good. From +being one of the ablest men of his State, he had fallen into such a +condition that he could neither read a letter nor write one. He could +not stand the least sunshine on his head, and to walk half a mile was +an impossibility. He was completely "down and out" and expected to be +an invalid for the rest of his life. + +But these symptoms had one by one disappeared during his five-weeks +stay with me. He had done good stiff work in the garden, carried a +heavy sack of grapefruit a mile in the hot sun, and was generally his +old self again. Now he was back in the harness, hard at work as of +old. Suddenly, as he sat reading in his home one evening, all his old +symptoms swept over him,--the pains in his head and legs, the pounding +of the heart, the "all-gone" sensations as though he were going to die +on the spot. He became almost completely dissociated, but through it +all he clung to the idea which he had learned,--namely that this +experience was not really physical as it seemed but was the result of +some idea, and would pass. He did not tell any one of the attack, +ignored it as much as possible, and waited. In a few minutes he was +himself again. Then he looked for the cause and realized that the +article he was reading was one he had read several months previous, +when suffering most severely from the whole train of symptoms. When +the familiar words had again gone into his mind, they had pressed the +button for the whole physiological experience which had once before +been associated with them. This is the same mechanism as that involved +in Prince's case, Miss Beauchamp, who became completely dissociated at +one time when a breeze swept across her face. When Dr. Prince looked +for the cause, he found that once before she had experienced certain +distressing emotions while a breeze was fanning her cheek. The +recurrence of the physical stimulation had been sufficient to bring +back in its entirety the former emotional complex. + +=Another Kind of Association.= One of my women patients illustrates +another kind of association-mechanism, based not on proximity in time +but proximity of position in the body. This woman had complained for +years of "bladder trouble" although no physical examination had been +able to reveal any organic difficulty. She referred to a constant +distress in the region of the bladder and was never without a certain +red blanket which she wrapped around her every time she sat down. +During psycho-analysis she recounted an experience of years before +which she had never mentioned to anybody. During a professional +consultation her physician, a married man, had suddenly seized her and +exclaimed, "I love you! I love you!" In spite of herself, the woman +felt a certain appeal, followed by a great sense of guilt. In the +conflict between the physiological reflex and her moral repugnance, +she had shunted out of consciousness the real sex-sensation and had +replaced it with a sensation which had become associated in her +subconscious mind with the original temptation. Since the nerves from +the genital region and from the bladder connect with the same segment +of the spinal cord, she had unconsciously chosen to mix her messages, +and to cling to the substitute sensation without being in the least +Conscious of the cause. As soon as she had described the scene to me +and had discerned its connection with her symptoms, the bladder +trouble disappeared. + +=Afraid of the Cold.= Patients who are sensitive to cold are very +numerous. Mr. G.--he of the prunes and bran biscuits--was so afraid of +a draft that he could detect the air current if a window was opened a +few inches anywhere in a two-story house. He always wore two suits of +underwear, but despite his precautions he had a swollen red throat +much of the time. His prescription was a cold bath every morning, a +source of delight to the other men patients, who made him stay in the +water while they counted five. He was required to dress and live like +other folks and of course his sensitiveness and his sore throat +disappeared. + +Dr. B----, when he came to me, was the most wrapped-up man I had ever +met. He had on two suits of underwear, a sweater, a vest and suit +coat, an overcoat, a bear-skin coat and a Jaeger scarf--all in +Pasadena in May! + +Besides this fear of cold, he was suffering from a hypersensitiveness +of several other varieties. So sensitive was his skin that he had his +clothes all made several sizes too big for him so that they would not +make pressure. He was so aware of the muscles of the neck that he +believed himself unable to hold up his head, and either propped it +with his hands or leaned it against the back of a chair. + +He had been working on the eighth edition of his book, a scientific +treatise of nation-wide importance, but his eyes were so sensitive +that he could not possibly use them and had to keep them shaded from +the glare. He was so conscious of the messages of fatigue that he was +unable to walk at all, and he suffered from the usual trouble with +constipation. All these symptoms of course belonged together and were +the direct result of a wrong state of mind. When he had changed his +mind, he took off his extra clothes, walked a mile and a half at the +first try, gave up his constipation, and went back to work. Later on I +had a letter from him saying that his favorite seat was an overturned +nail-keg in the garden and that he was thinking of sawing the backs +off his chairs. + +Miss Y---- had worn cotton in her ears for a year or two because she +had once had an inflammation of the middle ear, and believed the +membrane still sensitive to cold. There was Miss E----, whose +underwear always reached to her throat and wrists and who spent her +time following the sun; and Dr. I----, who never forgot her heavy +sweater or her shawl over her knees, even in front of the fire. The +procession of "cold ones" is almost endless, but always they find that +their sensitiveness is of their own making and that it disappears when +they choose to ignore it. + +=Fear of Light.= Fear of cold is no more common than fear of light. +Nervous folk with half-shut eyes are very frequent indeed. From one +woman I took at least seven pairs of dark glasses before she learned +that her eye was made for light. A good example is furnished by a +woman who was not a patient of mine at all, but merely the sister of a +patient. After my patient had been cured of a number of distressing +symptoms--pain in the spine, sore heels, a severe nervous cough, +indigestion and other typical complaints,--she began to scheme to get +her sister to come to me. + +This sister, the wife of a minister in the Middle West, had a constant +pain in her eyes, compelling her to hold them half-shut all the time. +When she was approached about coming to me, she said indignantly, "If +that doctor thinks that my trouble is nervous, she is much mistaken," +and then proceeded to get well. Once the subconscious mind gets the +idea that its game is recognized, it is very apt to give it up, and it +can do this without loss of time if it really wants to. + +=Pain at the Base of the Brain.= Of all nervous pains, that in the +back of the neck is by all odds the most common. It is rare indeed to +find a nervous patient without this complaint, and among supposedly +well folk it is only too frequent. Indeed, it almost seems that in +some quarters such a pain stands as a badge of the fervor and zeal of +one's work. + +But work is never responsible for this sense of discomfort. Only an +over-sensitiveness to feelings or a false emotionalism can produce a +pain of this kind, unless it should happen to be caused by some poison +circulating in the blood. The trouble is not with the nerves or with +the spine, despite the fad about misplaced vertebrae. When a doctor +examines a sensitive spine, marking the sore spots with a blue pencil, +and a few minutes later repeats the process, he finds almost +invariably that the spots have shifted. They are not true physical +pains and they rarely remain long in the same place. + +Pain in the spine and neck is an example of exaggerated sensibility or +over-awareness. Since all messages from every part of trunk and limb +must go through the spinal cord, and since very many of them enter the +cord in the region of the neck and shoulder blades, it is only natural +that an over-feeling of these messages should be especially noticed in +this zone. + +Sometimes a false emotionalism adds to the discomfort by tensing the +whole muscular system and making the messages more intense. When a +social worker or a business man gets tense over his work or ties +himself into knots over a committee meeting, he not only foolishly +wastes his energy but makes his nerves carry messages that are more +urgent than usual. Then if he is on the look-out for sensations, he +all the more easily becomes aware of the central station in the spine +where the messages are received. By centering his attention on this +station and tightening up his back-muscles, he increases this +over-awareness and easily gets himself into the clutch of a vicious +habit. + +Sometimes a tenseness of the body is the result, not of a false +attitude toward one's work, but of a lack of satisfaction in other +directions. If the love-force is not getting what it wants, it may +keep the body in a state of tension, with all the undesirable results +of such tension. The person who keeps himself tense, whether because +of his work or because of tension in other directions, has not really +learned how to throw himself into his job and to forget himself, his +emotions, and his body. + +=Various Pains.= Tender spots may appear in almost any part of the +body. There was the girl with the sore scalp, who was frequently so +sensitive that she could not bear to have a single hair touched at its +farthermost end, and who could not think of brushing her hair at such +a time. There was the man whose wrists and ankles were so painful that +the slightest touch was excruciating; the woman with the false +sciatica; the man with the so-called appendicitis pains; and the man +with the false neuritis, who always wore jersey coats several sizes +too large. Each one of these false pains was removed by the process of +re-education. + +=Low Thresholds to Fatigue.= Mr. H. was habitually so overcome by +fatigue that he could not make himself carry through the slightest +piece of work, even when necessity demanded it. On Sunday night, when +there was no one else to milk the cow, he had had to stop in the +middle of the process and go into the house to lie down. To carry the +milk was impossible, so low were his thresholds to the slightest +message of fatigue. It turned out that things were not going right in +the reproductive life. His threshold was low in this direction, and it +carried down with it all other thresholds. After a general revaluation +of values, he found himself able to keep his thresholds at the normal +level. + +A fine, efficient missionary from the Orient had been so overcome with +fatigue that he was forced to give up all work and return to this +country. He had been with me for a while and was again ready to go to +work. He came one day with a radiant face to bid me good-by. "Why are +you so joyous?" I asked. "Because," he answered, "before I came home I +was so fatigued that it used me up completely just to see the native +servants pack our luggage. Now we are taking back twice as much, and I +not only packed it all myself but made the boxes with my own hands. No +more fatigue for me!" + +A charming young girl who in many ways was an inspiration to all her +associates fell into the habit of over-feeling her fatigue. "You know, +Doctor," she said, "that I give out too much of myself; everybody +tells me so." That was just the trouble. Everybody had told her so, +and the suggestion had worked. It did not take her long to learn that +in scattering abroad she was enriching herself, and that her "giving +out" was not exhausting to her but rather the truest kind of +self-expression. It is only when a "giving out" is accompanied by a +"looking in" that it can ever deplete. The "See how much I am +giving," and "How tired I shall be," attitude could hardly fail to +exhaust, but a real self-expression and the fulfilment of a real +desire to give are never anything else than exhilarating. There is +something wrong with the minister who is used up after his Sunday +sermons. If his message and not himself is his real concern, he will +have only a normal amount of fatigue, accompanied by a general sense +of accomplishment and well-being, after he has fed his flock. To be +sure, I have never been a minister, but I have had a goodly number +among my patients and I speak from a fairly close acquaintance with +their problems. + +=Stopping Our Ears.= Roosters seem to be a perpetual source of +annoyance to the folk whose thresholds are not under proper control. +But as roosters seem to be necessary to an egg-eating nation, it seems +simpler to change the threshold than to abolish the roosters. There +was one woman who complained especially about being disturbed by +early-morning Chanticleers. I explained that the crowing called for no +action on her part, and that therefore she should not allow it to come +into consciousness. "Do you mean," she said, "that I could keep from +hearing them?" As it happened, she was sitting under the clock, which +had just struck seven. "Did you hear the clock strike?" I asked. "No," +she said; "did it strike?" + +This poor little woman, who suffered from a very painful back and +other distressing symptoms, had been married at sixteen to a roue of +forty; and, without experiencing any of the psychic feelings of sex, +had been immediately plunged into the physical sex-relations. Since +sex is psycho-physical and since any attempt to separate the two +elements is both desecrating and unsatisfactory; it is not surprising +that misery, and finally divorce, had been her portion. Another +equally unpleasant experience had followed, and the poor woman in the +strain and disappointment of her love-life, and in the lowering of the +thresholds pertaining to this thwarted instinct, had unconsciously +lowered the thresholds to all physical stimuli, until she was no +longer master of herself in any line. When she saw the reason for her +exaggerated reactions, she was able to gain control of herself, and to +find outlet in other ways. + +Too many persons fall into the way of being disturbed by noises which +are no concern of theirs. As nurses learn to sleep through all sounds +but the call of their own patients, so any one may learn to ignore all +sounds but those which he needs to hear. Connection with the outside +world can be severed by a mental attitude in much the same way as this +is accomplished by the physical effect of an anaesthetic. Then the +usual noises, those which the subconscious recognizes as without +significance, will be without power to disturb. The well-known New +York publisher who spent his last days on his private yacht, on which +everything was rubber-heeled and velvet-cushioned, thought that he +couldn't stand noises; but how much more fun he would have had, if +some one had only told him about thresholds! + + +SUMMARY + +There are two kinds of people in the world,--masters and puppets. +There is the man in control of his thresholds, at leisure from himself +and master of circumstance, free to use his energy in fruitful ways; +and there is the over-sensitive soul, wondering where the barometer +stands and whether people are going to be quiet, feeling his feelings +and worrying because no one else feels them, forever wasting his +energy in exaggerated reactions to normal situations. + +This "ticklish" person is not better equipped than his neighbor, but +more poorly equipped. True adjustment to the environment requires the +faculty of putting out from consciousness all stimuli that do not +require conscious attention. The nervous person is lacking in this +faculty, but he usually fails to realize that this lack places him in +the class of defectives. A paralyzed man is a cripple because he +cannot run with the crowd; a nervous individual is a cripple, but only +because he thinks that to run with the crowd lacks distinction. +Something depends on the accident of birth, but far more depends on +his own choice. Understanding, judicious neglect of symptoms, +whole-souled absorption in other interests, and a good look in the +mirror, are sure to put him back in the running with a wholesome +delight in being once more "like folks." + + + + +CHAPTER XV + +_In which we learn discrimination_ + +CHOOSING OUR EMOTIONS + +LIKING THE TASTE + + +It was a summer evening by the seaside, and a group of us were sitting +on the porch, having a sort of heart-to-heart talk about +psychology,--which means, of course, that we were talking about +ourselves. One by one the different members of the family spoke out +the questions that had been troubling them, or brought up their +various problems of character or of health. At length a splendid Red +Cross nurse who had won medals for distinguished service in the early +days of the war, broke out with the question: "Doctor, how can I get +rid of my terrible temper? Sometimes it is very bad, and always it has +been one of the trials of my life." She spoke earnestly and sincerely, +but this was my answer: "You like your temper. Something in you enjoys +it, else you would give it up." Her face was a study in astonishment. +"I don't like it," she stammered; "always after I have had an +outburst of anger I am in the depths of remorse. Many a time I have +cried my eyes out over this very thing." "And you like that, too," I +answered. "You are having an emotional spree, indulging yourself first +in one kind of emotion and then in another. If you really hated it as +much as you say you do, you would never allow yourself the indulgence, +much less speak of it afterward." Her astonishment was still further +increased when several of the group said they, too, had sensed her +satisfaction with her moods. + +Hard as it is to believe, we do choose our emotions. We like emotion +as we do salt in our food, and too often we choose it because +something in us likes the savor, and not because it leads to the +character or the conduct that we know to be good. + + +THE POWER OF CHOICE + +Whether we believe it or not, and whether we like it or not, the fact +remains that we ourselves decide which of all the possible emotions we +shall choose, or we decide not to press the button for any emotion at +all. + +To a very large extent man, if he knows how and really wishes, may +select the emotion which is suitable in that it leads to the right +conduct, has a beneficial effect on the body, adapts him to his social +environment, and makes him the kind of man he wants to be. + +=The Test of Feeling.= The psychologist to-day has a sure test of +character. He says in substance: "Tell me what you feel and I will +tell you what you are. Tell me what things you love, what things you +fear, and what makes you angry and I will describe with a fair degree +of accuracy your character, your conduct, and a good deal about the +state of your physical health." + +Since this test of emotion is fundamentally sound, it is not +surprising that the nervous man is in a state of distress. +Indigestion, fatigue, over-sensibility, sound like problems in +physiology, but we cannot go far in the discussion of any of them +without coming face to face with the emotions as the real factors in +the case. When we turn to the mental characteristics of nervous folk, +we even more quickly find ourselves in the midst of an emotional +disturbance. Worried, fearful, anxious, self-pitying, excitable, or +melancholy, the nervous person proves that whatever else a neurosis +may be, it is, in essence, a riot of the emotions. + +There is small wonder that a riot at the heart of the empire should +lead to insurrection in every province of the personality. It is only +for the purpose of discussion that we can separate feeling from +thinking and doing. Every thought and every act has in it something of +all three elements. An emotion is not an isolated phenomenon; it is +bound up on the one hand with ideas and on the other with bodily +states and conduct. Whoever runs amuck in his emotions runs amuck in +his whole being. The nervous invalid with his exhausted and sensitive +body, his upset mind and irrational conduct is a living illustration +of the central place of the emotions in the realm of the personality. + +But it is not the nervous person only who needs a better understanding +of his emotional life. The well man also gets angry for childish +reasons; he is prejudiced and envious, unhappy and suspicious for the +very same reason as is the nervous man. Since the working-capital of +energy is limited to a definite amount, the control of the emotions +becomes a central problem in any life,--a deciding factor in the +output and the outcome, as well as in comfort and happiness by the +way. + +Nothing is harder for the average man to believe than this fact that +he really has the power to choose his emotions. He has been +dissatisfied with himself in his past reactions, and yet he has not +known how to change them. His anger or his depression has appeared so +undesirable to his best judgment and to his conscious reason that it +has seemed to be not a part of himself at all but an invasion from +without which has swept over him without his consent and quite beyond +control. + + +A HOUSE DIVIDED AGAINST ITSELF + +Most of the confusion comes from the fact that we know only a part of +ourselves. What we do not consciously enjoy we believe we do not enjoy +at all. What we do not consciously choose we believe to be beyond our +power of choice,--the work of the evil one, or the natural depravity +of human nature, perhaps; but certainly not anything of our choosing. + +The point is that a human being is so constituted that he can, without +knowing it, entertain at the same time two diametrically opposite +desires. The average person is not so unified as he believes, but is, +in fact, "a house divided against itself." + +The words of the apostle Paul express for most of us the truth about +ourselves: "For what I would, that I do not; but what I hate that I +do." What Paul calls the law of his members warring against the law of +his mind is simply what we call to-day the instinctive desires coming +into conflict with our conscious ideal. + +=Hidden Desires.= Although we choose our emotions, we choose in many +cases in response to a buried part of ourselves of which we are wholly +unaware, or only half-aware. When we do not like what we have chosen, +it is because the conscious part of us is out of harmony with another +part and that part is doing the choosing. If the emotions which we +choose are not those that the whole of us--or at least the +conscious--would desire, it is because we are choosing in response to +hidden desires, and giving satisfaction to cravings which we have not +recognized. Repeated indulgence of such desires is responsible for the +emotional habits which we are too likely to consider an inevitable +part of our personality, inherited from ancestors who are not on hand +to defend themselves. When we form the habit of being afraid of things +that other people do not fear, or of being irritated or depressed, or +of giving way to fits of temper, it is because these habit-reactions +satisfy the inner cravings that in the circumstances can get +satisfaction in no better way. + +These hidden desires are of several different kinds, when squarely +looked at. Some of the cravings are found to be childish, and so out +of keeping with our real characters that we could not possibly hold on +to them as conscious desires. Others turn out to be so natural and so +inevitable that we wonder how we could ever have imagined that they +ought to be repressed. Still others, legitimate in themselves, but +denied because of outer circumstances, are found to be easily +satisfied in indirect ways which bear no resemblance to their old +unfortunate forms of outlet. + + +WHEN KNOWLEDGE HELPS + +The way to get rid of an undesirable emotion is not by working at the +emotion itself, but by realizing that this is merely an offshoot of a +deeper root, hidden below the surface. The great point is to recognize +this deeper root. + +=Childish Anger.= It helps to know that uncalled-for anger is a +defense reaction--a sort of camouflage or smoke cloud which we throw +out to hide from ourselves and others the fact that we are being +worsted in an argument, or being shown up in an undesirable light. +Better than any amount of weeping over a hot temper is an +understanding of the fact that when we fly into unseemly rage we are +usually giving indulgence to a childhood desire to run away from +unpleasant facts and to cover up our own faults. + +=Enjoying the Blues.= It helps to know that the easiest way to fight +the blues is by realizing that they are a deliberate, if unconscious, +attempt to gain the pity of ourselves and others. There seems to be in +undeveloped human nature something that really enjoys being pitied, +and if we cannot get the commiseration of other people, we can, +without much trouble, work up a case of self-pity. Most of us would +have to acknowledge that we seldom find tears in our eyes except when +our own woes are under consideration. "Whatever else the blues +accomplish, they certainly afford us a chance to submerge ourselves +in a sea of self-engrossment."[63] + +[Footnote 63: Putnam: _Human Motives_.] + +=The Chip on the Shoulder.= It helps to know that irritability and +over-sensitiveness are usually the result of tension from unsatisfied +desires which must find some kind of outlet. If a person is secretly +restive under the fact that he cannot have the kind of clothes he +wants, cannot shine in society, or secure a college education or a +large fortune,--all of which minister to our insistent and rarely +satisfied instinct of self-assertion,--or if he is secretly yearning +for the satisfaction of the marriage relation, or for the sense of +completion in parenthood; then the tension from these unsatisfied +desires shows itself in a hundred little everyday instances of lack of +self-control. These mystify him and his friends, but they are +understandable when the whole truth is known. + +=Anxiety and Fear.= Nowhere is understanding more valuable than when +we approach the subject of anxiety and fear. Whenever a person falls +into a state of abnormal fear, his friends and his physician spend a +good deal of time in attempting to prove to him that there is no cause +for apprehension, and in exhorting him to use his reason and give up +his fear. But how can a person help himself when he is fighting in the +dark? How can he free himself when the thing he thinks he fears is +merely a symbol of what he really fears? The woman who was afraid she +would choke her child had been several months in the hands of +Christian Scientists, and had earnestly tried to replace fear with +courage. But in the circumstances, and without further knowledge, this +was as impossible as it is for a man to lift himself by his own +boot-straps. She had no point of contact with her real fear, as the +man has no leverage contact with the earth from which he wishes to +lift himself. + +To be sure there are many cases in which an assumed cheerfulness and +courage do have a mighty effect on the inner man. The forces of the +personality are not set, but plastic, and are constantly acting and +interacting upon one another. Surface habits do influence the forces +below the surface. William James's advice, "Square your shoulders, +speak in a major key, smile, and turn a compliment," is good for most +occasions, but sometimes even a little understanding of the cause is +far more effective. + +It helps to know that persistent anxiety, lacking obvious cause, is +found to be the anxiety of the thwarted instinct of reproduction. When +the sex-instinct is repeatedly stimulated and then checked it sets in +motion some of the same glands that are activated in fear. What comes +up into consciousness is therefore very naturally a fear or dread of +impending disaster, very like the poignant anxiety that one feels +when stepping up in the dark to a step that is not there. + +Simultaneous with the fear lest these repressed desires should not be +satisfied, there is an intense fear lest they should. The more +insistent the repressed desire, and the more it seems likely to break +through into consciousness, the keener the anguish of the ethical +impulses. Abnormal fear, however it may seem to be externalized, +always implies at the bottom a fear of something within. There is no +truth which is harder to believe on first hearing but which grows more +compelling with further knowledge, than this truth that an exaggerated +fear always implies a desire which somehow offends the total +personality. When we observe the various distressing phobias, such as +the common fear of contamination, a woman's fear to undress at night, +a fear that the gas was not turned off, or that one's clothing is out +of order; fear lest the exact truth has not been told, or that the +uttermost farthing of one's obligations has not been met,--then we may +know that there is something in the fear situation which either +directly or symbolically refers to some hidden desire; a desire which +the individual would not for the world acknowledge to himself, but +which is too keen to be altogether repressed. + +The close connection between fear and desire is often shown in the +unfounded fear of having committed a crime. Both doctors and lawyers +in their professional work occasionally come upon individuals who +believe that they have committed some heinous crime of which they are +really innocent, and who insist upon their guilt despite all evidence +to the contrary. A quiet, gentle youth who at the age of twenty was +under my medical care, is still not sure in his own whether he, at +twelve years of age, was the burglar who broke into the village store +and killed the owner. It is difficult for the normally self-satisfied +individual to understand the appeal of heroics to a person whose +starved instinct of self-assertion makes him choose to be known as a +villain rather than not to be known at all. + +=Breaking the Spell.= When once we bring up into consciousness these +hidden desires that manifest themselves in such troublesome ways, we +find that we have robbed them of much of their power over our lives. +Sometimes, it is true, a detailed and thorough exploration by +psycho-analysis is necessary, but in many cases it is sufficient just +to know that there are underlying causes. To know these things is far +from excusing ourselves because of them. Even though emotions are +determined by forces that are deep in the subconscious, we may still +choose in opposition to those forces, if we but know that we can do +so. The fact that some of the roots of our bad habits reach down into +the subconscious is no excuse for not digging them up. As Dr. Putnam +says, "It is the whole of us that acts, and we are as responsible for +the supervision of the unseen as for the obvious factors that are at +work. The moon may be only half illumined and half visible, but the +invisible half goes on, none the less, exerting its full share of +influence on the motion of the tides and earth."[64] + +[Footnote 64: Putnam: _Freud's Psychoanalytic Method and Its +Evolution_, p. 34.] + + +THE HIGHEST KIND OF CHOICE + +There is no easier way to enliven any conversation than by dropping +the remark that a human being always does what he wants to do. Simple +as the statement seems, it is quite enough to quicken the dullest +table-talk and loosen the most reticent tongue. + +"I don't do what I want to do," says the college student. "I want to +play tennis every afternoon; but what I do is to sit in a stuffy room +and study." + +"I don't do what I want to do," says the mother of a family. "At night +I want to sit down and read the latest magazine, but what I do is to +darn stockings by the hour." + +Nevertheless we shall see that, even in cases like these, each of us +is acting in accordance with his strongest desire. There may be--there +often is--a bitter conflict, but in the end the desire that is really +stronger always conquers and works itself out into action. + +It is possible to imagine a situation in which a man would be +physically unable to do what he wanted to do. Bound by physical cords, +held by prison walls, or weakened by illness, he might be actually +unable to carry out his desires. But apart from physical restraint, it +is hard to imagine a situation in real life in which a person does not +actually do what he wants to do; that is, what _in the circumstances +he wants to do_. This is simply saying in another way that we act in +accordance with the emotion which is at the moment strongest. + +=Will Is Choice.= Just here we can imagine an earnest protest: "But +why do you ignore the human will? Why do you try to make man the +creature of feeling? A high-grade man does--not what he wants to do +but what he thinks he ought to do. In any person worthy of the +adjective 'civilized' it is conscience, not desire, which is the +motive power of his life." + +It is true: in the better kind of man the will is of central +importance; but what is "will"? Let us imagine a raw soldier in the +trenches just before a charge into No-Man's Land. He is afraid, but +the word of command comes, and instantly he is a new creature. His +fear drops away and, energized by the lust of battle, he rushes +forward, obviously driven by the stronger emotion. He goes ahead +because he really wants to, and we say that he does not have to use +his will. + +Imagine another soldier in the same situation; with him fear seems +uppermost. His knees shake and his legs want to carry him in the wrong +direction, but he still goes forward. And he goes forward, not so much +because there is no other possibility as because, in the +circumstances, he really wants to. All his life, and especially during +his military training, he has been filled with ideals of loyalty and +courage. More than he fears the guns of the enemy or of his +firing-squad does he fear the loss of his own self-respect and the +respect of his comrades. Greater than his "will to live" is his desire +to play the man. There is conflict, and the desire which seems at the +moment weaker is given the victory because it is reinforced by that +other permanent desire to be a worthy man, brave, and dependable in a +crisis. He goes forward, because in the circumstances, he really wants +to, but in this case we say that he had to use his will. + +Is it not apparent that will itself is choice,--the selection by the +whole personality of the emotion and the action which best fit into +its ideals? Will is choice by the part of us which has ideals. +McDougall points out that will is the reinforcement of the weaker +desire by the master desire to be a certain kind of a character.[65] + +[Footnote 65: "The essential mark of volition is that the personality +as a whole, or the central feature or nucleus of the personality, the +man himself, is thrown upon the side of the weaker +motive."--McDougall: _Introduction to Social Psychology_, p. 240.] + +Each human being as he goes through life acquires a number of moral +ideals and sentiments which he adopts as his own. They become linked +with the instinct of self-assertion, which henceforth acts as the +motive power behind them, and attempts to drive from the field any +emotion which happens to conflict. + +Men, like the lower animals, are ruled by desire, but, as G.A. Coe +says, "Men mold themselves. They form desires not merely to have this +or that object, but to be this or that kind of a man."[66] + +[Footnote 66: Coe: _Psychology of Religion_.] + +If a man be worthy of the name, he is not swayed by the emotion which +happens for the moment to be strongest. He has the power to reinforce +and make dominant those impulses which fit into the ideal he has built +for himself. In other words, he has the power to choose between his +desires, and this power depends largely upon the ideals which he has +incorporated into his life by the complexes and sentiments which +compose his personality. + +_Ideas and Ideals_. If emotion is the heart of humanity, ideas are its +head. In our emphasis on emotion, we must not forget that as emotion +controls action, so ideas control emotion. But ideas, of themselves, +are not enough. Everybody has seen weaklings who were full of pious +platitudes. Ideas do control life, but only when linked up with some +strong emotion. No moral sentiment is strong enough to withstand an +intense instinctive desire. If ideas are to be dynamic factors in a +life, they must become ideals and be really desired. They must be +backed up by the impulse of self-assertion, incorporated with the +sentiment of self-regard, and so made a permanent part of the central +personality. + +Parents and teachers who try to "break a child's will" and to punish +every evidence of independence and self-assertion little know that +they are undermining the foundations of morality itself, and doing +their utmost to leave the child at the mercy of his chance whims and +emotions. There can be no strength of character without self-regard, +and self-regard is built on the instinctive desire of self-assertion. + +=Education and Religion.= It is easy to see how important education is +in this process of giving the right content to the self-regarding +sentiment. The child trained to regard "temper" as a disgrace, +self-pity as a vice, over-sensitiveness as a sign of selfishness, and +all forms of exaggerated emotionalism as a token of weakness, has +acquired a powerful weapon against temptation in later life. +Indulgence in any of these forms of gratification he will regard as +unworthy and out of keeping with his personality. + +It is easy, too, to see how central a place a vital religious faith +has in enriching and ennobling the ego-ideal, and in giving it +driving-power. A force which makes a high ideal seem both imperative +and possible of achievement could hardly fail to be a deciding factor. +Every student of human nature knows in how many countless lives the +Christian religion has made all the difference between mere good +intentions and the power to realize those intentions; how many times +it has furnished the motive power which nothing else seemed able to +supply. Moral sentiments which have been merely sentiments become, +through the magic of a new faith, incorporated into conscience and +endowed with new power. + +Just here lies the value of any great love, or any intense devotion to +a cause. As Royce says: "To have a conscience, then, is to have a +cause; to unify your life by means of an ideal determined by this +cause, and to compare this ideal and the life."[67] + +[Footnote 67: Royce: _Philosophy of Loyalty_, p. 175.] + +=Avoiding the Strain.= It seems that a human being is to a large +extent controlled by will, and that will is in itself the highest kind +of choice. But too often will is crippled because it does not speak +for the whole personality. Knowledge helps a person to relate +conscience with hitherto hidden parts of himself, to assert his will, +and to choose only those emotions and outlets which the connected-up, +the unified personality wants. Sometimes, indeed, a little knowledge +makes the exercise of the will power unnecessary. Using will power +is, after all, likely to be a strenuous business. It implies the +presence of conflict, and the strain of defeating the desire which has +to be denied.[68] Why struggle to subdue emotional bad habits when a +little insight dispels the desire back of them, and makes them melt +away as if by magic? For example, why use our will to keep down fear +or anger when a little understanding dissipates these emotions without +effort? + +[Footnote 68: Freud: _Introduction to Psychoanalysis_, p. 42.] + +Whatever we do with difficulty we are not doing well. When it requires +effort to do our duty this means that a great part of us does not want +to do it. When we get rid of our hidden resistances we work with ease. +As a strong wind, applied in the right way, drives the ship without +effort, just so the forces in our lives, if they are adjusted to one +another, will without strain or stress easily and naturally work +together to carry us in the direction we have chosen. When we get rid +of blind conflicts, even the business of ruling our spirits becomes +feasible. + + +SUMMARY + +=Various "Sprees."= The human animal has a constitutional dislike for +dullness and will seize upon almost any device which promises to lift +him out of what he considers the monotony of daily grind. An elaborate +essay might be written on the means which human beings have taken to +create the sense of _aliveness_ which they so much crave. Some of +them--we call them savages--have found satisfactory certain wild +orgies in primitive war-dances; others--we shall soon call them "out +of date"--have found simpler a bottle of whisky or a glass of +champagne; still others find a cold shower more invigorating, or a +brisk walk or a good stiff job which sets them aglow with the sense of +accomplishment. But there are always those who, for one reason or +another, find most satisfactory of all a chronic emotional tippling, +or a good old-fashioned emotional spree. Persons who would be shocked +at the idea of whisky or champagne allow themselves this other kind of +indulgence without in the least knowing why. + +Nor is the connection between alcoholism and emotionalism so +far-fetched as it seems. Psycho-analytic investigations have +repeatedly revealed the fact that both are indulged in because they +remove inhibitions, give vent to repressed desires, and bring a sense +of life and power which has somehow been lost in the normal living. +Both kinds of spree are followed by the inevitable "morning after" +with its proverbial headache, remorse, and vows of repentance but +despite all this, both are clung to because the satisfaction they +bring is too deep to be easily relinquished. + +Whenever an emotion quite out of keeping with conscious desire is +allowed to become habitual, we may know that it is being chosen by a +part of the personality which needs to be uncovered and squarely +faced. Nervous symptoms and exaggerated emotionalism are alike +evidence of the fact that the wrong part of us is doing the choosing +and that the will needs to be enlightened on what is taking place in +the outer edge of its domain. In the choice between emotionalism and +equanimity, the selection of the former can only be in response to +unrecognized desire. + +A nervous person is invariably an emotional person, and as a rule lays +the blame for his condition upon past experiences. But experience is +what happens to us _plus_ the way we take it. We cannot always ward +off the blow, but we can decide upon our reaction. "Even if the +conduct of others has been the cause of our emotion, it is really we +ourselves who have created it by the way in which we have +reacted."[69] + +[Footnote 69: DuBois: _Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders_, p. +155.] + + One ship drives east, another drives west, + While the self-same breezes blow; + 'Tis the set of the sail, and not the gale + That bids them where to go. + Like the winds of the sea are the ways of fate, + As we journey along through life; + 'Tis the set of the soul that decides the goal, + And not the calm or the strife. + REBECCA R. WILLIAMS. + + + + +CHAPTER XVI + +_In which we find new use for our steam_ + +FINDING VENT IN SUBLIMATION + +THE RE-DIRECTION OF ENERGY + + +A child pent up on a rainy day is a troublesome child. His energy +keeps piling up, but there is no opportunity for him to expend it. The +nervous person is just such a pent-up child. A portion of his +personality is developing steam which goes astray in its search for +vent; this portion is found to be the psychic side of his sex-life. +Something has blocked the satisfactory achievement of instinctive ends +and turned his interest in on himself. + +Perhaps he does not come into complete psychic satisfaction of his +love-life because his wife is out of sympathy or is held back by her +own childish repressions. Perhaps his love-instinct is baffled by +finding itself thwarted in its purpose of creating children, +restrained by the social ban and the desire for a luxurious standard +of living. Perhaps he is jealous of his chief, or of an older +relative whose business stride he cannot equal. + +Jung has pointed out how frequently introversion or turning in of the +life-force is brought about by the painfulness of present reality and +by the lack of the power of adaptation to things as they are. But this +lack always has its roots in childhood. The woman who is shocked at +the thought of sex is the little girl who reacted too strongly to +early impressions. The man of forty who is disgruntled because he is +not made manager of a business created by others is the little boy who +was jealous of his father and wanted to usurp his place of power. The +man who suffers from a sense of inferiority because his friend has a +handsomer or more intellectual wife is the same little boy who strove +with his father for possession of the mother, the most desired object +in his childish environment. The measure of escape from these childish +attitudes means the measure of success in life. + +Fortunately for society, the average person achieves this success. The +normal person in his childhood learned how to switch the energy of his +primitive desires into channels approved by society. Stored away in +his subconscious, this acquired faculty carries him without conscious +effort through all the necessary adjustments in maturity. The nervous +person, less well equipped in childhood, may fortunately acquire the +faculty in all its completeness, although at the cost of genuine +effort and patient self-study. + +=Sublimation the Key Word.= In the prevention and in the cure of +nervous disorders there is one factor of central importance, and that +factor is sublimation--or the freeing of sex-energy for socially +useful, non-sexual ends. To sublimate is to find vent for oneself and +to serve society as well; for sublimation opens up new channels for +pent-up energy, utilizing all the surplus of the sex-instinct in +substitute activities. When the dynamic of this impulse is turned +outward, not inward, it proves to be one of man's greatest +possessions, a valuable contribution of energy to creative activities +and personal relationships of every kind. + +=The Failure to Sublimate.= A neurosis is nonconstructive use of one's +surplus steam. The trouble with a nervous person is that his +love-force is turned in on himself instead of out into the world of +reality. This is what his friends mean when they say that he is +self-absorbed; and this is what the psychologists mean when they say +that a neurotic is introverted. A person, in so far as he is nervous, +does not see other people at all--that is, he does not see them as +real persons, but only as auditors who may be made to listen to the +tale of his woes. His own problems loom so large that he becomes +especially afflicted with what Cabot calls "the sin of impersonality"; +or to use President King's words, he lacks that "reverence for +personality" which enables one to see people vividly as real persons +and not as street-car conductors or servants or merely as members of +one's family. To be sure, many a so-called normal individual is +afflicted with this same kind of blindness; here as elsewhere the +neurotic simply exaggerates. Engrossed in his own mental conflicts and +physical symptoms, he is likely to find his interest withdrawing more +and more from other people and centering upon himself. + +=Sublimation and Religion.= We do not need psychology to tell us that +engrossment in self is a disastrous condition. When the psycho-analyst +says that the life-force must be turned out, not in, he is approaching +from a new angle the truth as it is found in the gospel,--"Thou shalt +love the Lord thy God with all thy heart," and "thy neighbor as +thyself." Religion provides the love-object in the Creator; altruism +provides it in the "neighbor." Christianity and psychology agree that +as soon as love ceases to be an outgoing force, just so soon does the +individual become an incomplete and disrupted personality.[70] + +[Footnote 70: For emphasis on religion as a means to sublimation, see +Freud, Putnam, Pfister, James, and DuBois.] + +=Carlyle's Doctrine of Work.= "Produce! produce! produce!" Life for a +social being involves not only rich personal relationships, but +absorbing, creative work. No nervous person is cured until he is +willing to take and to keep a "man-size job." A good piece of work is +not only the sign of a cure; it is the final step without which no +cure is complete. + +=Along Nature's Lines.= If the psychologist is asked what kind of task +this is to be, he answers that each person must decide for himself his +own life-work. An individual may not know why, but he does know that +there are certain things which he most likes to do. Sublimation is +more readily accomplished if his energy is directed toward self-chosen +interests. Parents or teachers or physicians who try to force another +person into any definite plan of action are making a grievous blunder. +Help may be given toward self-knowledge and the understanding of +general principles, but advice should never be specific. + +Taken in the large, it is found that men and women choose different +ways of sublimation. Man and woman differ in the psychic components of +the sex-life even as they differ in the physical. Sublimation to be +successful must follow the lines laid down by nature. The urge of the +average man is toward construction, domination, mastery. The urge of +the average woman is toward mothering, protection, nurture. The +masculine characteristics find ready sublimation in a career; the man +builds bridges, digs canals, harnesses mountain streams, conquers +pests, overcomes gravity, brings the ends of the earth together by +"wireless" or by rail; he provides for the weak and the helpless--his +own progeny--or, incarnated in the body of a Hoover, he gives life to +the children of the world. + +In woman, the dominant force is the nurturing instinct. Child and man +of her own come first, but when these are lacking, to paraphrase +Kipling, in default of closer ties, she is wedded to convictions; +Heaven help him who denies! Only as a career opens up full vent for +this nurturing instinct, will it provide satisfactory substitute in +sublimation. Its natural trend can be seen in the recent tidal wave of +social legislation--for prohibition, child-labor laws, sanitation, +recognition and control of venereal disease, acknowledgment of +paternity to the illegitimate child. + +Since the women of the day, in numbers up to the million, have been +compelled to sacrifice both man and unformed babe to the grim +Juggernaut of war, this nurturing urge may press hard against many of +the social and business barriers now impeding its flow. But if society +understands and readjusts these barriers, making it possible for its +citizens--women as well as men--to approximate the natural instinctive +bent, it will not only save itself much unrest but will also go far +toward preventing the spread of nervous invalidism. + + +SUMMARY + +That which a nervous invalid most needs is a redirection of energy. +Since, in spite of appearances, there is never any real lack of +energy, no time is needed for the making of strength, and a cure can +take place just as soon as the inner forces allow the energy to flow +out in the right direction. Sometimes, indeed, an outer change may +start the inner process. Often the "work cure" does cure; occasionally +the sudden necessity to earn one's living or to mother a little child +frees the life-force from its old preoccupation and forces it into +other channels. In most cases, however, the nervous invalid is +suffering not from lack of opportunities for outside interest but from +an inner inability to meet the opportunities which present themselves. +The great change that has to be made is not in external conditions and +habits but in the hidden corners of the mind; a change that can be +accomplished only by self-knowledge and re-education. + +But if self-knowledge is the first step in any cure, so self-giving +must be the final step. Sooner or later in the life of every nervous +invalid there comes a time when nothing will serve to unify his +disorganized forces but steady and unswerving responsibility for a +good stiff piece of work. Happy for him that this is so and that he is +living in a day when science no longer tells him to fold his hands and +wait. + + + + +GLOSSARY + + +_Autonomic nervous system:_ The vegetative nervous system which +controls vital functions,--as digestion, respiration, circulation. + +_Censor:_ A hypothetical faculty of the fore-conscious mind which +resists the emergence into consciousness of questionable desires. + +_Common path:_ In physiology, the final route over which response is +made to physical stimulation; similarly in psychology, the one outlet +for the finally dominant impulse. + +_Compensation:_ Exaggerated manifestation of one character-trend as a +defense against its opposite which is painfully repressed; relief in +substitute symptom formation. + +_Complex:_ A group of ideas held together by emotion (usually +referring to a group which is wholly or in part unconscious). + +_Compulsion:_ A persistent compelling impulse to perform some +seemingly unreasonable (but really substitute or symbolic) act, or to +hold some irrational fear or idea; an emotional force which has been +separated from the original idea. + +_Conflict:_ (Special) Struggle between instincts (unconscious). + +_Conversion:_ (Special) The process by which a repressed mental +complex expresses itself through a physical symptom. + +_Displacement:_ 1. Transposition of an emotion from its original idea +to one more acceptable to the personality. 2. The shifting of +emphasis, in dreams, from essential to less significant elements. + +_Dissociation:_ 1. The state of being shut out from taking active part +(applied to a group of ideas), as in normal forgetfulness. 2. +(Abnormal) An exaggerated degree of separation of groups of ideas, +with loss to the personality of the forces or memories which these +groups contain, as in double personality. + +_Fixation:_ Establishment in childhood of over-strong habit-reactions. + +_Free Association:_ A device for uncovering buried complexes by +letting the mind wander without conscious direction. + +_Homo-sexual:_ The quality of being more attracted by an individual of +the same sex (abnormal) than by one of the opposite sex +(hetero-sexual, normal). + +_Hysteria:_ That form of functional nervous disorder which manifests +itself in physical symptoms; an attempt to dramatize unconscious +repressed desires. + +_Inhibition:_ Restraint (Special) limitation of function, physical or +ideational, due to unconscious emotional attitudes. + +_Libido:_ Life-force, elan vital, or (restricted) the energy of the +sex-instinct. + +_Neurosis:_ Used loosely for psycho-neurosis or nervous disorder. + +_Obsession:_ A compulsive idea inaccessible to reason. + +_Oedipus Complex:_ Over-strong bond between mother and son, or (more +loosely) between father and daughter. + +_Over-determined:_ Used of an impulse made over-strong by lack of +discharge, with accumulation of emotional tension from added factors. + +_Phobia:_ A persistent, unreasoning fear of some object or situation. + +_Psycho-neurosis:_ "A perversion of normal (psychic) reactions," +(Prince); a general term for functional dissociation of the +personality, resulting in: psychasthenia--disturbed ideation; +neurasthenia--disturbed emotions; hysteria--disturbed motor or sensory +activity. + +_Psychotherapy:_ Treatment by psychic or mental measures. + +_Rationalization:_ The process of substituting a plausible, false +explanation for a repressed, unconscious desire. + +_Repression:_ Expulsion from consciousness of a pain-provoking mental +process. + +_Resistance:_ The force which impedes the return of a repressed +complex to consciousness. + +_Subconscious:_ That part of the mind of which one is unaware; the +storehouse of memories ancestral and personal. + +_Sublimation:_ The act of freeing sex-energy from definitely sexual +aims; utilization of sex-energy for nonsexual ends. + +_Suggestion:_ The process by which any idea, true or false, takes hold +of one; the idea may enter the mind consciously or unconsciously, +through reason or through impulse. + +_Symbol:_ An object or an attitude which stands for an ides or a +quality; (Special) that which stands for or represents some +unconscious mental process. + +_Threshold_ (door-sill): A figure which represents the level of the +barrier erected by the mind against the perception of an idea or +sensation. + +_Transference:_ Unconscious identification of a present personal +relationship with an earlier one, with conveyance of the earlier +emotional attitudes (hostile or affectionate) to the present +relationship. + + + + +BIBLIOGRAPHY + + +BOOKS ON THE GENERAL LAWS OF BODY AND MIND + +Cannon, Walter B: Bodily Changes in Pain, Hunger, +Fear and Rage. + +Crile, George W.: The Origin and Nature of the Emotions. + +Coe, George Albert: The Psychology of Religion. + +Hudson, Thomas Jay: The Law of Psychic Phenomena. + +Janet, Pierre: The Major Symptoms of Hysteria; The +Mental State of Hystericals. + +James, William: Psychology; Talks to Teachers on Psychology; +Varieties of Religious Experience. + +Jastrow, Joseph: The Subconscious. + +Kempf, Edward J.: The Tonus of Autonomic Segments +in Psychopathology. + +Long, Constance: Psychology of Fantasy. + +McDougall, William: Social Psychology. + +Mosher, Clelia Duel: Health and the Woman Movement. + +Phillips, D. E.: Elementary Psychology. + +Prince, Morton: The Unconscious; The Dissociation of +a Personality; My Life as a Dissociated Personality. + +Sherrington, Charles L.: The Integrative Action of the +Nervous System. + +Sidis, Boris: The Foundations of Normal and Abnormal +Psychology; Psychopathological Researches. + +Tansley, A. G.: The New Psychology. + +Thomson, William Hanna: Brain and Personality. + +White, William A.: Principles of Mental Hygiene; + The Mental Hygiene of Childhood. + +Proceedings of the International Conference of Women Physicians. +(National Board, Y.W.C.A., 600 Lexington Avenue, New York City.) + + +BOOKS ON MENTAL HYGIENE + +Brown, Charles R.: Faith and Health. + +Bruce, H. Addington: Scientific Mental Healing. + +Cabot, Richard: What Men Live By; + Social Service and the Art of Healing. + +DuBois, Paul: The Psychic Treatment of Nervous Disorders. + +Huckel, Oliver: Mental Medicine. + +James, William: Vital Reserves. + +Prince, Morton, and others: Psychotherapeutics. + +Sadler, William S.: The Physiology of Faith and Fear. + +Worcester, Elwood } +McComb, Samuel } Religion and Medicine. +Coriat, Isador H. } + + +BOOKS ON PSYCHO-ANALYSIS + +Brill, A. A.: Fundamentals of Psychoanalysis. + +Emerson, L. E.: Nervousness. + +Freud, Sigmund: The Interpretation of Dreams; + The Psychopathology of Everyday Life; + Wit and the Unconscious; + Selected Papers and Sexual Theory; + A General Introduction to Psychoanalysis. + +Frink, H. W.: Morbid Fears and Compulsions. + +Hitschmann, E.: Freud's Theories of the Neuroses. + +Holt, E. B.: The Freudian Wish. + +Jung, Carl G.: The Psychology of the Unconscious; Analytical +Psychology. + +Jones, Ernest: Psycho-analysis; Treatment of the Neuroses, Including +Psychoneuroses--in Modern Treatment of Nervous and Mental +Diseases--White and Jelliffe. + +Pfister, Oskar: The Psychoanalytic Method. + +Putnam, James Jackson: Addresses on Psychoanalysis--Human +Motives. + +Tridon, Andre: Psychoanalysis. + +White, William A.: The Mechanisms of Character +Formation. + + +JOURNALS DEVOTED TO THE SUBJECT OF NERVOUS DISORDERS + +Journal of Abnormal Psychology, published in Boston. + +Psychoanalytic Review, published in Washington, D.C. + +International Journal of Psychoanalysis, published in +London. + + + + +INDEX + + +A + +Acid and Milk, 21, 257 + +Acidosis, 285 + +Adjustment + a neurosis an effort at, 169 + to new conditions causes consciousness, 82 + of the race, in subconscious, 78 + to the social whole, 164, 216, 380 + +Adolescence, 59 + +Adrenal Secretion, 42, 48, 133, 229, 270 + +Alcoholism, relation to unconscious desires, 377 + +Alvarez, W.D., 284 + +Ames, Thaddeus Hoyt, 170 + +Amnesia, 113 + +Anaemia, buttermilk in, 282 + +Anger, 47 ff. + +Anxiety and Fear, 366, 367, 368 + +Anxiety Neurosis, 7, 109 + +Anxious thought in conversion hysteria, 277 + +Appetite, symbolic loss of, 276 + +Association + accidental, 341 + a chain of, 191 + free, 101, 191 + making new, 329, 330 + of ideas, 106 + subconscious, 346 + word test, 197, 198 + +Audience, secured in a neurosis, 169 + +Auto-eroticism, 57 + +Auto-intoxication, 279, 282 + +Automatic writing, 96, 97 + +Autonomic nervous system, 86, 126, 319 + +Auto-suggestion, 129, 210 + + +B + +Bacteria, in anaemia, sciatica, rheumatism, 281 + +Bashfulness, 46 + +Bergson, 90 + +Biliousness, 268 + +Birth-Theories, 158, 160, 161 + +Blocking, in word association, 198 + +Bodily Response to Emotional States, 134 + +Brain, + diseased in insanity, sound in neurosis, 13 + fag, 125, 241 + records, 89 + +Bran fad, 291 + +Breuer, Joseph, 142 + +Brill, A.A., 58, 69, 201, 202 + +Bruce, H. Addington, 200, 201 + +Burrow, Trigant, 173, 203 + +Buttermilk in anaemia, 282 + + +C + +Cabot, Richard, 27, 381 + +Canfield, Dorothy, 231 + +Cannon, Walter B., 49, 134 + +Capitalizing an Illness, 170 + +Catechism, 247 + +Cathartics, 283 + and acidosis, 286 + and bacterial infection, 282 + and child birth, 285, 286 + and operations, 284 + +Causes of Nerves, 146, 164 + +Censor, psychic, 104, 195 + +Change of life, 314 + +Character and health, 24, 25, 362 + +Chemistry, 61, 190, 224, 225, 230, 247, 306, 315, 317, 324 + +Child, + birth-theories of, 158 + father to the man, 90 + habit-fixation of, 150 + love-life, four periods 54, 55 + questions, 158 + too much bossing of, 154 + too much petting of, 57 + training, 160 + +Childhood, + bonds too strong, 72 + determines future character, 91, 148 + experiences, 149 + reactions, 148 + +Choosing our Emotions, 360 + a neurosis, 122, 169, 216 + our Sensations, 339 + +Christian religion, 74, 374 + +Coe, George A., 71, 373 + +Colon, function of, 279, 280 + +Common Path, 52 + +Compensation, 168, 340 + +Complex, + against marriage, 204 + and conditioned reflex, 108 + and personality, 105 + breaking up of, 109, 186 + buried, 187, 192, 197, 201, 202, 215 + chance signs of, 198 + definition, 107 + dissociated, 111 + emotional, 198, 345 + father-mother, 152 + feeling-tone of, 130 + formation of, 129 + forming a resistance, 159 + making over, 187, 190 + mother-son, 185 + physiological, 108 + repressed, 112, 157, 190 + unconscious, 108 + +Compromise, 163, 164, 165 + +Compulsion neuroses, 7, 109, 156 + +Conditioned reflex, 108 + +Conduct, kind of, 168, 191, 360 + +Conflict, 59, 64, 112, 145, 154, 164, 178, 200, 218, 313, 372, 376 + +Conscience, 164, 173, 177, 196, 376 + +Consciousness, + displaced threshold of, 91 +relation to the subconscious, 82 + rise of, 82 + +Constipation, 277 ff. + and food, 289, 290 + cure of, 294 + due to suggestion, 294 + purpose of, 288 + +Conversion-hysteria, 174, 236, 237, 238, 245, 277, 302 + +Crile, George W., 41, 44 + +Curiosity, + child's concerning sex, 58 + displacement over to scientific investigation, 45 + + +D + +Day-dreaming, 162, 325, 326 + +Defence-reaction, 365 + +Desire + energy of, 78 + in dreams, 194 + in emotional habits, 364 + in nervous disorders, 167 + instinctive, 38 + instinctive and ideals, 363 + tensions of, 196 + +Diarrhoea, bacterial, 281 + +Dietetics, essence of, 254 + +Digestion, 86, 133, 250, 251 + +Disease, + of the ego, 15 + physical, 12, 13, 28 + psychic, 12, 13, 14, 28 + +Disorders, functional and organic, 13 + +Displacement, 109, 110, 165, 174 + +Dissociation, 111 + abnormal, 189 + an example of, 92, 347 + in hypnosis, 123 + in hysteria, 111, 123 + in neurasthenia, 111 + increases suggestibility, 122 + normal, 111 + of a "Personality," 113 + of memory picture of walking, 125 + of power of sight, 170 + +Dreams, 193 ff. + Freud's dictum, 193 + latent content, 195 + manifest content, 195 + purpose of, 195 + work of, 196 + +DuBois, Paul, 4, 127, 246, 327, 382 + + +E + +Education, 202, 218 + in Emotional Control, 374 + +Emotion, 35, 360 ff. + and complexes, 108 + and fatigue, 229, 247 + and instincts, 40 ff. + and muscle tone, 137 + blood-pressure in, 136 + bodily response to, 133 + feeling tones in, 130 + precocious, 150 + repressed (see repression) + secretions in, 132 + the strongest cement, 107 + tonic and poisonous, 131 + unrecognized desire in, 364 + +Energy, + adaptable, 67 + creative, 34, 69, 71 + inhibited, 235 + libido, 36, 252 + misdirected, 28, 379 + new level of, 221 + physiological reserve, 117 + redirection of, 385 + releasers of, 245 + three uses of, 23 + utilization of, 68, 165 + +"Energies of Men", 221 + +Environment, 33, 96, 149, 334 + +Evolution, 73 + +Exhaustion, nervous, 216, 224, 243, 246 + +Explanation vs Suggestion, 206 ff. + + +F + +Fads-dynamogenic, 252 + +Faith, 118 + +Family complex, 153 + +Fatigue, 219 ff. + a Matter of Chemistry, 225 + and insomnia, 326, 327 + and moral tension, 166 + and sex-repression, 235, 244 + true and false, 223 + +Fear, 40 ff. + exaggerated, 368 + externalized, 368 + of cold, 348 + of fatigue, 219, 354 + of food, 133, 251 + of heat, 237 + of noise, 355 + physical effects of, 41 + purpose of, 41 + symbolic of desire, 368 + +Feeling our Feelings, 333 ff. + +Feeling-tones, 130, 206, 213, 229 + +Fermentation, 264 + +Finding New Vents, 379 + +Fixation of Habits, 150, 151, 162 + +Flat-foot, 138 + +Food, 254 ff. + and constipation, 289, 290 + for the children, 256 + idiosyncrasies, 258 + mixtures, 255 + variety essential, 255 + +Foreconscious, 79 + +Free Association, 101, 191, 195 + +Freud, Sigmund, 69, 74, 83, 84, 104, 142, 149, 153, 163, 185, 188, 193, + 210, 342, 376, 382 + +Freudian principles, 143, 144, 147 + misconceptions concerning, 184, 185 + +Frink, H.W., 89, 107, 158, 162, 171, 195, 218 + + +G + +Gall-stones, 269 + +Gas on the stomach, 264 + +Gastric juice, 86, 134 + +Gastritis, 266 + +Genius, 116 + +Girard-Mangin, Dr., 231 + +Goitre, 239 + + +H + +Habit, + defined, 150 + dissociation, 189 + dreaming, 162 + fixation of, 150, 152 + of insomnia, 322 + of loving, 150, 164 + of rebelling, 150, 164 + of repressing normal instincts, 151 + reactions, 364 + +Heredity, 148 + +Hidden desires, 363, 368 + +Hinkle, Bertha M., 154 + +Holt, E.B., 213 + +Homosexuality, 184 + +Hoover, Herbert A., 384 + +Hormone, 305, 319 + +Hudson, J.W., 91, 95 + +Hydrochloric Acid, 267 + +Hygiene, + laws of, 127 + moral, 206 + +Hygienic conditions, 222, 230 + +Hypersensitiveness, 342 + +Hypnosis, 84 ff. + aid to diagnosis, 187 + its drawbacks, 188 + suggestibility in, 189 + +Hysteria, 7, 111 + +Hysterical pains, 353 + +Hysterical pregnancy, (case), 127 + + +I + +Ideas, + and emotions, 23 + ascetic, 253 + contagion of, 120 + dynamogenic, 253 + not surgical, 262 + +Idiosyncrasies, physical, 258 + +Identification, 110 + +Imagination, 162 + +Incantation, 211 + +Indigestion; 211, 250 + +Inferiority complex, 340, 380 + +Inhibition, 188, 245, 293, 306, 330, 377 + +Insomnia, 322 ff. + +Instincts and their Emotions, 33 ff., 51 ff. + +Instincts, + beneficent, 85 + energy releasers, 233 + race-inheritance, 85 + repressed, 28, 103, 147, 169, 172 + sex (see under sex) + thwarted, 235, 244, 340, 356, 367, 379 + +Internal Secretion, + of ovary, 316, 317 + (see Adrenal) + (see Thyroid) + +Introspection, 26 + +Introversion, 380, 381 + + +J + +James, William, 49, 221, 227, 243, 253, 347, 382 + +Janet, Pierre, 188 + +Jealousy, 154, 380 + +Jelliffe, Smith Ely, 98, 114, 153, 163 + +Jones, Ernest, 69 + +Judicious neglect, 127 + +Jung, C.G., 8, 64, 69, 163, 197, 380 + + +K + +Kempf, Edward J., 86 + +Kinaesthetic sensations, 336 + + +L + +Latency period, 60 + +Libido, 36, 147, 252 + +Liver trouble, 268 + + +M + +Masturbation, 184 + +McDougall, Wm., 49, 122, 372 + +Memories, 84 ff. + +Menopause, 314 + +Menstruation, 306 + +Mind (see Consciousness and Subconscious) + +Misconceptions, + about the body, 21, 22 + about theory of sex, 184 + +Mixtures, fear of, 257 + +Monogamy, 63 + +Moral hygiene, 206 + +Mosher, Clelia Duel, 308 + +Muscle-tone, 137, 244 + +Myth, 146 + + +N + +Narcissus, 55, 152, 340 + +Nausea, 101, 177, 275 + of pregnancy, 319 + +Nerves, + attitude toward, 3 + causes of, 28, 148 + drama of, 10, 29 + medical schools and, 16 + not physical, 14 + prevention of, 385 + +Neurasthenia, 111, 246 + +Neuritis, 14, 244 + +Neurosis, + a compromise, 167 + a confidence game, 179 + a failure of sublimation, 381 + a flight from reality, 170 + an ethical struggle, 177 + an introversion, 381 + and shell-shock, 147 + and suggestion, 129 + anxiety, 7, 109 + awkwardness of, 213 + compulsion, 109 + caused by buried complexes, 108, 190 + definition 112 + origin in childhood, 149, 157, 217 + purpose of, 167 + root-complex of, 153 + + +O + +Obsession, 7, 204 + +Oedipus Complex, 154 + +Organic trouble, 11, 12, 251 + +Ouija Board, 97 + +Over-awareness, 352 + +Over-compensation, 67 + +Over-determined, 148 + + +P + +Pain, + at base of the brain, 351 + chronic hysterical, 341 + menstrual, 306 + +Personality, + alterations of, 7, 15, 20 + and emotions, 362, 369 + and will, 372 + choice by, 216 + complexes and, 107 + disrupted, 382 + multiple, 111, 131 + nervousness a disorder of, 15 + reverence for, 383 + unified, 375 + +Persuasion, 206 + +Pfister, Oskar, 153, 166, 382 + +Phantasy, 153, 163 + +Phobia, 7, 368 + +Plagiarism, 98 + +Popular Misconceptions, 21 + +Prince, Morton, 79, 84, 89, 95, 97, 112, 132, 188, 347 + +Psycho-analysis, 189 ff. + +Psychological explanation, 208 + +Psychology, 25, 27, 94 + +Psycho-neurosis, 144, 147, 163, 169 (see also neurosis) + +Psycho-therapy, 74, 187, 216 + +Ptosis, 139, 251 + +Putnam, James J., 3, 34, 69, 215, 366, 370, 382 + + +R + +Race-memories, 84 + +Rationalization, 90, 155, 168, 317 + +Reaction and over-reaction, 149, 198, 202, 238, 335 + +Reality, flight from, 164, 379 + +Re-education, 183 ff. + +Reflex, + conditioned, 108 + physiological, 349 + +Regression to infantile state, 163, 164 + case of, 92 + +Religion, 74, 89, 374, 382 + +Reminiscences, hysteric suffers from, 7 + +Repression, 104, 156, 160, 162, 235, 245, 304 + +Resistance, 160, 188, 192, 202, 211 + +Rest-cure, 246 + +Rheumatism, buttermilk treatment of, 282 + +Rixford, Emmet L., 283 + +Royce, Josiah, 375 + + +S + +Sadler, Wm., 126, 136 + +School, four grade, 54 + +Second wind, 221 + +Self-abuse, 184, 238 + +Self-pity, 365 + +Self-regard, 45, 103, 157, 374 + +Sensations, lowered threshold to, 333 ff. + +Sensitiveness, 333, 340 + +Sex, + and artistic creation, 379 + and "Nerves," 141 ff. + glands, secretion of, 305, 314, 316 +instinct organically aroused, 65 + instinct thwarted, 161, 367, 379 + instruction, 160 + license, 184 + life, 143, 146, 157 + perversion, 152 + phantasy, 163 + psychic component of, 185, 356, 379, 383 + repressed, 104 + sublimation of, 233, 379 + +Shell-shock, (see foreword) + also 145, 147 + +Sherrington, Chas., 39 + +Sick-headache, 270 + +Sidis, Boris, 24, 84, 188, 222, 337, 341 + +Slips of tongue, etc., 199 + +Slogan, + of psychoanalytic school, 215 + woman's, 314 + +Social code, 184 + +Soda, misuse of, 266 + +"Sour-stomach," 260, 266 + +Sprees, 376 + +Stammering, 200 + +Standard, + double, 66 + single, 62 + +Stomach, 133 + and conversion hysteria, 250 ff. + fads, 252 + gas on, 252 + +Subconscious mind, 77 ff. + amenable to control by suggestion, emotion, 119 + functions of, 85, 335, 337 + habits of, 105, 259 + physical expression of, 245 + playing confidence game, 311 + store-house of memories, 84, 89 + tireless, 325 + +Sublimation, 379 ff. + a synthesis, 164 + and religion, 74, 382 + definition (Freud), 69, 70 + failure of, 71, 147, 381 + in a career, 385 + in artistic creation, 68 + natural trends of, 383 + of energy, 178, 238, 309 + +Success, measure of, 380 + +Sugar in urine, 133 + +Suggestion, + a method of psychotherapy, 208 + constipation the result of, 289, 298 + definition, 121 + false, 302 + in child training, 121 + in hypnosis, 99, 188 + in sleep, 99 + inconvenient forms of, 296 + power of, 45 + unhealthy, 310 + +Suggestibility, 122, 189, 206 + +Superman, 339 + +Symbolism, 171, 176, 275, 342 + +Symptoms, purpose of, 168 + + +T + +Taboos, + dietary, 250 ff. + interest in, 289 + +Tensions, psychic, 69, 85, 353, 366 + +Thresholds, psychic, 337 ff. + +Thyroid secretion, 42, 133, 185, 270 + +Transference, 109, 193, 264 + +Trotter, W., 46 + + +U + +Unconscious, (see subconscious) + + +V + +Venereal disease, 304, 317 + +Vitamins, 255 + + +W + +White, Wm. A., 69, 82, 83, 98 + +Will, 371 + +Williams, Tom A., 21, 213 + +Wish fulfilment, 171, 194, 200, 214 + +Word-association test, 197 + +Work-cure, 385 + + + + +ILLUSTRATIONS FROM CASES + + +A + +Adolescence and depression, 312, 313 + +Anger and circulation, 136 + +Angina pectoris, false, 129 + +Anxiety-neurosis, 175 + + +B + +Bearing children, 318 + +Brain fag, 241 + +Bran crackers and prunes, 258 + + +C + +Cathartics, abuse of, 284 + +Childhood sex-reactions, 203 + +Constipation and lacerations in labor, 296 + +Constipation and Mineral Oil, 295 + +Constipation, recovery from, (some cases), 294 + +Contamination, fear of, 159 + +Conversion of moral distress to physical, 348 + + +D + +Danger-signals and the railroad man, 344 + +Dissociated state, memories in, 92 + + +E + +Emotion and sick-headache, 273 + +"Enjoying" poor health, 213, 345 + +"Exhaustion," 243 + +Eye-strain, twenty-five years, 274 + + +F + +Fatigue, 228, 234, (two cases), 239 + +Fatigue and emotion, (three cases), 354 + +Fear, 237, + of heat, 237 + +Fear of air, 348, 349 + +Fear of cold, (three cases), 348, 349 + +Fear of light, (two cases), 350 + +Fear complicating labor, 320 + +"Flat-foot," 137 + +Forgetting and repressed wish, 200 + +Free-love, chemical cause of, 317 + + +G + +Gall-stones, 269 + + +I + +Idiosyncrasy for eggs, 212 + +Insomnia and attention, 329 + +Insomnia and point of view, 328 + +Insomnia and wrong associations, 330 + +Insomnia, chronic, 328 + + +L + +Library, child fear of, 100 + +Locomotor Ataxia, exaggeration of symptoms, 128 + + +M + +Menstrual pain, unnecessary, 220 + +Muscle-tumors, phantom, 127, 128 + + +N + +Nausea, in sex-repression, 101, 177 + +Nervous indigestion, 211 + +"Neuritis," 174, + false, 244 + +Noise, fear of, 355 + + +O + +Obsession against marriage, 204 + + +P + +Paralysis, fear of, 345, 346 + +Physical illness mistaken for functional, 252 + +Plagiarism, 98 + + +R + +Recovering lost word, 80 + +Repression and disgust, 199 + + +S + +Sick-headache, 271, 274 + +Skim-milk diet, 262 + +"Sour stomach" and two Tyrolese, 260 + +T + +Temper, an indulgence, 359 + +The "Repeater" gains in weight, 263 + +Thyroid disturbance, fatigue in, 239, 240 + + +U + +Unconscious Association and symptoms, 346 + + +W + +Walking, lost power of, 124 + +Word Association test, 198 + + +Transcriber's Notes + +The following typographical errors were noted and corrected: + +On page 146 of the book: Heading changed from "A Searching Queston" + to "A Searching Question". +On page 152, "Narcisstic" changed to "Narcissistic". +On page 276, "..the nausea disappearaed." changed to "disappeared". +On page 294, "...Nature's functions re reestablished" changed to "be". +On page 302, "...nor even of man's infringment..." changed to + "infringement". +On page 330, "I put my mouth up close to to her ear...", removed the + duplicate "to". +On page 346, for the paragraph starting "But these symptoms...", + "disappeaared" changed to "disappeared". +In the Index, page 401, "Thesholds" changed to "Thresholds". + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Outwitting Our Nerves +by Josephine A. Jackson and Helen M. Salisbury + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK OUTWITTING OUR NERVES *** + +***** This file should be named 14980.txt or 14980.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + https://www.gutenberg.org/1/4/9/8/14980/ + +Produced by Rick Niles, Ronald Holder and the PG Online Distributed +Proofreading Team. + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +https://gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS' WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, is critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at https://www.pglaf.org. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Its 501(c)(3) letter is posted at +https://pglaf.org/fundraising. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at https://pglaf.org + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit https://pglaf.org + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including including checks, online payments and credit card +donations. To donate, please visit: https://pglaf.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + https://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. diff --git a/14980.zip b/14980.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..1a071f8 --- /dev/null +++ b/14980.zip diff --git a/LICENSE.txt b/LICENSE.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6312041 --- /dev/null +++ b/LICENSE.txt @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +This eBook, including all associated images, markup, improvements, +metadata, and any other content or labor, has been confirmed to be +in the PUBLIC DOMAIN IN THE UNITED STATES. + +Procedures for determining public domain status are described in +the "Copyright How-To" at https://www.gutenberg.org. + +No investigation has been made concerning possible copyrights in +jurisdictions other than the United States. Anyone seeking to utilize +this eBook outside of the United States should confirm copyright +status under the laws that apply to them. diff --git a/README.md b/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b187cc1 --- /dev/null +++ b/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +Project Gutenberg (https://www.gutenberg.org) public repository for +eBook #14980 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/14980) |
