diff options
Diffstat (limited to '30216-0.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | 30216-0.txt | 3837 |
1 files changed, 3837 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/30216-0.txt b/30216-0.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7341ff1 --- /dev/null +++ b/30216-0.txt @@ -0,0 +1,3837 @@ +The Project Gutenberg EBook of The Buddhist Catechism, by Henry S. Olcott + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: The Buddhist Catechism + +Author: Henry S. Olcott + +Release Date: October 30, 2009 [EBook #30216] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: UTF-8 + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE BUDDHIST CATECHISM *** + + + + +Produced by U Hla Maung. HTML and Unicode versions by Al Haines. + + + + + + + + + +_Namō Tassā Bhagavatō Arahatō Sammā Sambuddhassa_ + + + + +THE + +BUDDHIST CATECHISM + + +BY + +HENRY S. OLCOTT + + +PRESIDENT-FOUNDER OF THE THEOSOPHICAL SOCIETY + + + +_Approved and recommended for use in Buddhist schools by H. Sumangala, +Pradhana Nayaka Sthavira, High Priest of Sripada and the Western +Province and Principal of the Vidyodaya Parivena_ + + + +FORTY-FOURTH EDITION. (Corrected) + + + +Theosophical Publishing House, Adyar, Madras + + +LONDON AND BENARES: THEOSOPHICAL PUBLISHING SOCIETY + + +1915 + + + + +DEDICATION + +In token of respect and affection I dedicate to my counsellor and +friend of many years, Hikkaduwe Sumangala, Pradhāna Nāyaka +Sthavīra and High Priest of Adam's Peak (Sripada) and the Western +Province, THE BUDDHIST CATECHISM, in its revised form. + +H. S. OLCOTT + +_Adyar_, 1903. + + + + +CONTENTS + + +THE LIFE OF THE BUDDHA + +THE DHARMA OR DOCTRINE + +THE SANGHA + +THE RISE AND SPREAD OF BUDDHISM + +BUDDHISM AND SCIENCE + +APPENDIX--The Fourteen Propositions accepted by + the Northern and Southern Buddhists as a + Platform of Unity + + + + +CERTIFICATE TO THE FIRST EDITION + +VIDYODAYA COLLEGE, + +_Colombo_, 7_th July_, 1881. + +I hereby certify that I have carefully examined the Sinhalese version +of the Catechism prepared by Colonel H. S. Olcott, and that the same is +in agreement with the Canon of the Southern Buddhist Church. I +recommend the work to teachers in Buddhist schools, mid to all others +who may wish to impart information to beginners about the essential +features of our religion. + +H. SUMANGALA, + +_High Priest of Sripada and Galle, and Principal of the Vidyodaya +Parivena._ + + + + +VIDYODAYA COLLEGE, + +_April_ 7, 1897. + +I have gone over the thirty-third (English) edition of the Catechism, +with the help of interpreters, and confirm my recommendation for its +use in Buddhist schools. + +H. SUMANGALA. + + + + +PREFACE + +TO THE THIRTY-THIRD EDITION + +In the working out of my original plan, I have added more questions and +answers in the text of each new English edition of the Catechism, +leaving it to its translators to render them into whichever of the +other vernaculars they may be working in. The unpretending aim in view +is to give so succinct and yet comprehensive a digest of Buddhistic +history, ethics and philosophy as to enable beginners to understand and +appreciate the noble ideal taught by the Buddha, and thus make it +easier for them to follow out the Dharma in its details. In the +present edition a great many new questions and answers have been +introduced, while the matter has been grouped within five categories, +_viz._: (1) The Life of the Buddha; (2) the Doctrine; (3) the Sangha, +or monastic order; (4) a brief history of Buddhism, its Councils and +propaganda; (5) some reconciliation of Buddhism with science. This, it +is believed, will largely increase the value of the little book, and +make it even more suitable for use in Buddhist schools, of which, in +Ceylon, over one hundred have already been opened by the Sinhalese +people under the general supervision of the Theosophical Society. In +preparing this edition I have received valuable help from some of my +oldest and best qualified Sinhalese colleagues. The original edition +was gone over with me word by word, by that eminent scholar and +bhikkhu, H. Sumangala, Pradhāna Nāyaka, and the Assistant +Principal of his Pālī College at Colombo, Hyeyantuduve Anunayaka +Terunnanse; and the High Priest has also kindly scrutinised the present +revision and given me invaluable points to embody. It has the merit, +therefore, of being a fair presentation of the Buddhism of the +"Southern Church," chiefly derived from first-hand sources. The +Catechism has been published in twenty languages, mainly by Buddhists, +for Buddhists. + +H. S. O. + +ADYAR, 17_th May_, 1897. + + + + +PREFACE + +TO THE THIRTY-SIXTH EDITION + +The popularity of this little work seems undiminished, edition after +edition being called for. While the present one was in the press a +second German edition, re-translated by the learned Dr. Erich Bischoff, +was published at Leipzig, by the Griebens Co., and a third translation +into French, by my old friend and colleague, Commandant D. A. Courmes, +was being got ready at Paris. A fresh version in Sinhalese is also +preparing at Colombo. It is very gratifying to a declared Buddhist +like myself to read what so ripe a scholar as Mr. G. R. S. Mead, author +of _Fragments of of a Faith Forgotten_, _Pistis Sophia_, and many other +works on Christian origins, thinks of the value of the compilation. He +writes in the _Theosophical Review_: "It has been translated into no +less than twenty different languages, and may be said without the +faintest risk of contradiction, to have been the busiest instrument of +Buddhist propaganda for many a day in the annals of that long somnolent +dharma. The least that learned Buddhists of Ceylon can do to repay the +debt of gratitude they owe to Colonel Olcott and other members of the +Theosophical Society who have worked for them, is to bestir themselves +to throw some light on their own origins and doctrines." + +I am afraid we shall have to wait long for this help to come from the +Buddhist bhikkhus, almost the only learned men of Ceylon; at least I +have not been able during an intimate intercourse of twenty-two years, +to arouse their zeal. It has always seemed to me incongruous that an +American, making no claims at all to scholarship, should be looked to +by the Sinhalese to help them teach the dharma to their children; and +as I believe I have said in an earlier edition, I only consented to +write THE BUDDHIST CATECHISM after I had found that no bhikkhu would +undertake it. Whatever its demerits, I can at least say that the work +contains the essence of some 15,000 pages of Buddhist teaching that I +have read in connexion with my work. + +H. S. O. + +ADYAR, 7_th February_, 1903. + + + + +PREFACE + +TO THE FORTIETH EDITION + +The popularity of this little work is proved by the constant demand for +new editions, in English and other languages. In looking over the +matter for the present edition, I have found very little to change or +to add, for the work seems to present a very fair idea of the contents +of Southern Buddhism; and, as my object is never to write an extended +essay on the subject, I resist the temptation to wander off into +amplifications of details which, however interesting to the student of +comparative religion, are useless in a rational scheme of elementary +instruction. + +The new Sinhalese version (38th edition) which is being prepared by my +respected friend, D. B. Jayatilaka, Principal of Ānanda (Buddhist) +College, Colombo, is partly printed, but cannot be completed until he +is relieved of some of the pressure upon his time. The Tamil version +(41st edition) has been undertaken by the leaders of the Pañchama +community of Madras, and will shortly issue from the press. The +Spanish version (39th edition) is in the hands of my friend, Señor +Xifré, and the French one (37th edition) in those of Commandant Courmes. + +So the work goes on, and by this unpretending agency the teachings of +the Buddha Dharma are being carried throughout the world. + +H. S. O. + +ADYAR, 7_th January_, 1905. + + + + +PREFACE + +TO THE FORTY-SECOND EDITION + +The writer of this Catechism has passed away from earth, but, before he +left the body, he had arranged with the High Priest Sumangala to make +some small corrections in the text. These are incorporated in the +present edition by the High Priest's wish, expressed to me in Colombo, +in November 1907. + +I have not altered the numbering of the questions, as it might cause +confusion in a class to change the numbers, if some pupils had the +older editions and some the new. + + ADYAR, ) + 17_th February_, 1908. ) ANNIE BESANT + + + + +THE BUDDHIST CATECHISM + + +PART I + +THE LIFE OF THE BUDDHA + +1. Question. _Of what religion[1] are you?_ + +Answer. The Buddhist. + + + + +[1] The word "religion" is most inappropriate to apply to Buddhism +which is not a religion, but a moral philosophy, as I have shown later +on. But, by common usage the word has been applied to all groups of +people who profess a special moral doctrine, and is so employed by +statisticians. The Sinhalese Buddhists have never yet had any +conception of what Europeans imply in the etymological construction of +the Latin root of this term. In their creed there is no such thing as +a "binding" in the Christian sense--a submission to or merging of self +in a Divine Being. _Āgama_ is their vernacular word to express +their relation to Buddhism and the BUDDHA. It is pure Samskrt, and +means "approach, or coming"; and as "_Buddha_" is enlightenment, the +compound word by which they indicate Buddhism--_Buddhāgama_--would +be properly rendered as "an approach or coming to enlightenment," or +possibly as a following of the Doctrine of SĀKYAMUNI. The +missionaries, finding _Āgama_ ready to their hand, adopted it as the +equivalent for "religion"; and Christianity is written by them +_Christianāgama_, whereas it should be _Christianibandhana_, for +_bandhana_ is the etymological equivalent for "religion". The name +_Vibhajja vāda_--one who analyses--is another name given to a +Buddhist, and Advayavādī is a third. With this explanation, I +continue to employ under protest the familiar word when speaking of +Buddhistic philosophy, for the convenience of the ordinary reader. + + + +2. Q. _What is Buddhism?_ + +A. It is a body of teachings given out by the great personage known as +the Buddha. + +3. Q. _Is "Buddhism" the best name for this teaching?_ + +A. No; that is only a western term: the best name for it is Bauddha +Dharma. + +4. Q. _Would you call a person a Buddhist who had merely been born of +Buddha parents?_ + +A. Certainly not. A Buddhist is one who not only professes belief in +the Buddha as the noblest of Teachers, in the Doctrine preached by Him, +and in the Brotherhood of Arhats, but practises His precepts in daily +life. + +5. Q. _What is a male lay Buddhist called?_ + +A. An Upāsaka. + +6. Q. _What a female?_ + +A. An Upāsika. + +7. Q. _When was this doctrine first preached?_ + +A. There is some disagreement as to the actual date, but according to +the Sinhalese Scriptures it was in the year 2513 of the (present) +Kali-Yuga. + +8. Q. _Give the important dates in the last birth of the Founder?_ + +A. He was born under the constellation Visā on a Tuesday in May, in +the year 2478 (K.Y.); he retired to the jungle in the year 2506; became +Buddha in 2513; and, passing out of the round of rebirths, entered +Paranirvāna in the year 2558, aged eighty years. Each of these +events happened on a day of full moon, so all are conjointly celebrated +in the great festival of the full-moon of the month Wesak +(_Vaisākha_), corresponding to the month of May. + +9. Q. _Was the Buddha God?_ + +A. No. Buddha Dharma teaches no "divine" incarnation. + +10. Q. _Was he a man?_ + +A. Yes; but the wisest, noblest and most holy being, who had developed +himself in the course of countless births far beyond all other beings, +the previous BUDDHAS alone excepted. + +11. Q. _Were there other Buddhas before him?_ + +A. Yes; as will be explained later on. + +12. Q. _Was Buddha his name?_ + +A. No. It is the name of a condition or state of mind, of the mind +after it has reached the culmination of development. + +13. Q. _What is its meaning?_ + +A. Enlightened; or, he who has the all-perfect wisdom. The Pālī +phrase is _Sabbannu_, the One of Boundless Knowledge. In Samskrt it is +_Sarvajña_. + +14. Q. _What was the Buddha's real name then?_ + +A. SIDDHĀRTHA was his royal name, and GAUTAMA, or GOTAMA, his +family name. He was Prince of Kapilavāstu and belonged to the +illustrious family of the Okkāka, of the Solar race. + +15. Q. _Who were his father and mother?_ + +A. King Suddhodana and Queen Māyā, called Mahā Māyā. + +16. Q. _What people did this King reign over?_ + +A. The Sākyas; an Aryan tribe of Kshattriyas. + +17. Q. _Where was Kapilavāstu?_ + +A. In India, one hundred miles north-east of the City of Benares, and +about forty miles from the Himalaya mountains. It is situated in the +Nepāl Terai. The city is now in ruins. + +18. Q. _On what river?_ + +A. The Rohīnī, now called the Kohana. + +19. Q. _Tell me again when Prince Siddhārtha was born?_ + +A. Six hundred and twenty-three years before the Christian era. + +20. Q. _Is the exact spot known?_ + +A. It is now identified beyond question. An archaeologist in the +service of the Government of India has discovered in the jungle of the +Nepāl Terai a stone pillar erected by the mighty Buddhist sovereign, +Asoka, to mark the very spot. The place was known in those times as +the Lumbinī Garden. + +21. Q. _Had the Prince luxuries and splendours like other Princes?_ + +A. He had; his father, the King, built him three magnificent +palaces--for the three Indian seasons--the cold, the hot, and the +rainy--of nine, five, and three stories respectively, and handsomely +decorated. + +22. Q. _How were they situated?_ + +A. Around each palace were gardens of the most beautiful and fragrant +flowers, with fountains of spouting water, the trees full of singing +birds, and peacocks strutting over the ground. + +23. Q. _Was he living alone?_ + +A. No; in his sixteenth year he was married to the Princess +Yasodharā, daughter of the King Suprabuddha. Many beautiful +maidens, skilled in dancing and music, were also in continual +attendance to amuse him. + +24. Q. _How did he get his wife?_ + +A. In the ancient Kshattriya or warrior fashion, by overcoming all +competitors in games and exercises of skill and prowess, and then +selecting Yasodharā out of all the young princesses, whose fathers +had brought them to the tournament or _mela_. + +25. Q. _How, amid all this luxury, could a Prince become all-wise?_ + +A. He had such natural wisdom that when but a child he seemed to +understand all arts and sciences almost without study. He had the best +teachers, but they could teach him nothing that he did not seem to +comprehend immediately. + +26. Q. _Did he become Buddha in his splendid palaces?_ + +A. No. He left all and went alone into the jungle. + +27. Q. _Why did he do this?_ + +A. To discover the cause of our sufferings and the way to escape from +them. + +28. Q. _Was it not selfishness that made him do this?_ + +A. No; it was boundless love for all beings that made him devote +himself to their good. + +29. Q. _But how did he acquire this boundless love?_ + +A. Throughout numberless births and aeons of years he had been +cultivating this love, with the unfaltering determination to become a +Buddha. + +30. Q. _What did he this time relinquish?_ + +A. His beautiful palaces, his riches, luxuries and pleasures, his soft +beds, fine dresses, rich food, and his kingdom; he even left his +beloved wife and only son, Rāhula. + +31. Q. _Did any other man ever sacrifice so much for our sake?_ + +A. Not one in this present world-period: this is why Buddhists so love +him, and why good Buddhists try to be like him. + +32. Q. _But have not many men given up all earthly blessings, and +even life itself, for the sake of their fellow-men?_ + +A. Certainly. But we believe that this surpassing unselfishness and +love for humanity showed themselves in his renouncing the bliss of +Nirvāna countless ages ago, when he was born as the Brāhmana +Sumedha, in the time of Dīpānkara Buddha: he had then reached the +stage where he might have entered Nirvāna, had he not loved mankind +more than himself. This renunciation implied his voluntarily enduring +the miseries of earthly lives until he became Buddha, for the sake of +teaching all beings the way to emancipation and to give rest to the +world. + +33. Q. _How old was he when he went to the jungle?_ + +A. He was in his twenty-ninth year. + +34. Q. _What finally determined him to leave all that men usually +love so much and go to the jungle?_ + +A. A _Deva_[1] appeared to him when driving out in his chariot, under +four impressive forms, on four different occasions. + +35. Q. _What were these different forms?_ + +A. Those of a very old man broken down by age, of a sick man, of a +decaying corpse, and of a dignified hermit. + +36. Q. _Did he alone see these?_ + +A. No, his attendant, Channa, also saw them. + +37. Q. _Why should these sights, so familiar to everybody, have +caused him to go to the jungle?_ + +A. We often see such sights: he had not seen them, so they made a deep +impression on his mind. + +38. Q. _Why had he not also seen them?_ + +A. The Brāhmana astrologers had foretold at his birth that he would +one day resign his kingdom and, become a BUDDHA. The King, his father, +not wishing to lose an heir to his kingdom, had carefully prevented his +seeing any sights that might suggest to him human misery and death. No +one was allowed even to speak of such things to the Prince. He was +almost like a prisoner in his lovely palaces and flower gardens. They +were surrounded by high walls, and inside everything was made as +beautiful as possible, so that he might not wish to go and see the +sorrow and distress that are in the world. + +39. Q. _Was he so kind-hearted that the King feared he might really +wish to leave everything for the world's sake?_ + +A. Yes; he seems to have felt for all beings so strong a pity and love +as that. + +40. Q. _And how did he expect to learn the cause of sorrow in the +jungle?_ + +A. By removing far away from all that could prevent his thinking +deeply of the causes of sorrow and the nature of man. + +41. Q. _How did he escape from the palace?_ + +A. One night, when all were asleep, he arose, took a last look at his +sleeping wife and infant son; called Channa, mounted his favourite +white horse Kanthaka, and rode to the palace gate. The _Devas_ had +thrown a deep sleep upon the King's guard who watched the gate, so that +they could not hear the noise of the horse's hoofs. + +42. Q. _But the gate was locked, was it not?_ + +A. Yes; but the _Devas_ caused it to open without the slightest noise, +and he rode away into the darkness. + +43. Q. _Whither did he go?_ + +A. To the river Anomā, a long way from Kapilavāstu. + +44. Q. _What did he then do?_ + +A. He sprang from his horse, cut off his beautiful hair with his +sword, put on the yellow dress of an ascetic, and giving his ornaments +and horse to Channa, ordered him to take them back to his father, the +King. + +45. Q. _What then?_ + +A. He went afoot towards Rājagrha, the capital city of King +Bimbisāra, of Magadha. + +46. Q. _Who visited him there?_ + +A. The King with his whole Court.[2] + +46a. Q. _Thence whither did he go?_ + +A. To Uruvela, near the present Mahābōdhi Temple at Buddha +Gayā. + +47. Q. _Why did he go there?_ + +A. In the forests were hermits--very wise men, whose pupil he +afterwards became, in the hope of finding the knowledge of which he was +in search. + +48. Q. _Of what religion were they?_ + +A. The Hindu religion: they were Brāhmanas.[3] + +49. Q. _What did they teach?_ + +A. That by severe penances and torture of the body a man may acquire +perfect wisdom. + +50. Q. _Did the Prince find this to be so?_ + +A. No; he learned their systems and practised all their penances, but +he could not thus discover the cause of human sorrow and the way to +absolute emancipation. + +51. Q. _What did he then do?_ + +A. He went away into the forest near Uruvela, and spent six years in +deep meditation, undergoing the severest discipline in mortifying his +body. + +52. Q. _Was he alone?_ + +A. No; five Brāhman companions attended him. + +53. Q. _What were their names?_ + +A. Kondañña, Bhaddiya, Vappa, Mahānāma, and Assaji. + +54. Q. _What plan of discipline did he adopt to open his mind to know +the whole truth?_ + +A. He sat and meditated, concentrating his mind upon the higher +problems of life, and shutting out from his sight and hearing all that +was likely to interrupt his inward reflections. + +55. Q. _Did he fast?_ + +A. Yes, through the whole period. He took less and less food and +water until, it is said, he ate scarcely more than one grain of rice or +of sesamum seed each day. + +56. Q. _Did this give him the wisdom he longed for?_ + +A. No. He grew thinner and thinner in body and fainter in strength +until, one day, as he was slowly walking about and meditating, his +vital force suddenly left him and he fell to the ground unconscious. + +57. Q. _What did his companions think of that?_ + +A. They fancied he was dead; but after a time he revived. + +58. Q. _What then?_ + +A. The thought came to him that knowledge could never be reached by +mere fasting or bodily suffering, but must be gained by the opening of +the mind. He had just barely escaped death from self-starvation, yet +had not obtained the Perfect Wisdom. So he decided to eat, that he +might live at least long enough to become wise. + +59. Q. _Who gave him food?_ + +A. He received food from Sujatā, a nobleman's daughter, who saw him +sitting at the foot of a nyagrodha (banyan) tree. He arose, took his +alms-bowl, bathed in the river Nerañjāra, ate the food, and went +into the jungle. + +60. Q. _What did he do there?_ + +A. Having formed his determination after these reflections, he went at +evening to the Bōdhi, or Asvattha tree, where the present +Mahābōdhi Temple stands. + +61. Q. _What did he do there?_ + +A. He determined not to leave the spot until he attained perfect +wisdom. + +62. Q. _At which side of the tree did he seat himself?_ + +A. The side facing the east.[4] + +63. Q. _What did he obtain that night?_ + +A. The knowledge of his previous births, of the causes of rebirths, +and of the way to extinguish desires. Just before the break of the +next day his mind was entirely opened, like the full-blown lotus +flower; the light of supreme knowledge, or the Four Truths, poured in +upon him. He had become BUDDHA--the Enlightened, the all-knowing--the +Sarvajña. + +64. Q. _Had he at last discovered the cause of human misery?_ + +A. At last he had. As the light of the morning sun chases away the +darkness of night, and reveals to sight the trees, fields, rocks, seas, +rivers, animals, men and all things, so the full light of knowledge +rose in his mind, and he saw at one glance the causes of human +suffering and the way to escape from them. + +65. Q. _Had he great struggles before gaining this perfect wisdom?_ + +A. Yes, mighty and terrible struggles. He had to conquer in his body +all those natural defects and human appetites and desires that prevent +our seeing the truth. He had to overcome all the bad influences of the +sinful world around him. Like a soldier fighting desperately in battle +against many enemies, he struggled: like a hero who conquers, he gained +his object, and the secret of human misery was discovered. + +66. Q. _What use did he make of the knowledge thus gained?_ + +A. At first he was reluctant to teach it to the people at large. + +67. Q. _Why?_ + +A. Because of its profound importance and sublimity. He feared that +but few people would understand it. + +68. Q. _What made him alter this view?_[5] + +A. He saw that it was his duty to teach what he had learnt as clearly +and simply as possible, and trust to the truth impressing itself upon +the popular mind in proportion to each one's individual Karma. It was +the only way of salvation, and every being had an equal right to have +it pointed out to him. So he determined to begin with his five late +companions, who had abandoned him when he broke his fast. + +69. Q. _Where did he find them?_ + +A. In the deer-park at Isipatana, near Benares. + +70. Q. _Can the spot be now identified?_ + +A. Yes, a partly ruined stūpa, or dagoba, is still standing on that +very spot. + +71. Q. _Did those five companions readily listen to him?_ + +A. At first, no; but so great was the spiritual beauty of his +appearance, so sweet and convincing his teaching, that they soon turned +and gave him the closest attention. + +72. Q. _What effect did this discourse have upon them?_ + +A. The aged Kondañña, one who "understood" (_Anna_), was the first to +lose his prejudices, accept the Buddha's teaching, become his disciple, +and enter the Path leading to Arhatship. The other four soon followed +his example. + +73. Q. _Who were his next converts?_ + +A. A rich young layman, named Yasa, and his father, a wealthy +merchant. By the end of three months the disciples numbered sixty +persons. + +74. Q. _Who were the first women lay disciples?_ + +A. The mother and wife of Yasa. + +75. Q. _What did the Buddha do at that time?_[6] + +A. He called the disciples together, gave them full instructions, and +sent them out in all directions to preach his doctrine. + +76. Q. _What was the essence of it?_ + +A. That the way of emancipation lies in leading the holy life and +following the rules laid down, which will be explained later on. + +77. Q. _Tell me what name he gave to this course of life?_ + +A. The Noble Eightfold Path. + +78. Q. _How is it called in the Pālī language?_ + +A. _Ariyo atthangiko maggo_. + +79.. Q. _Whither did the Buddha then go?_ + +A. To Uruvela. + +80. Q. _What happened there?_ + +A. He converted a man named Kāshyapa, renowned for his learning and +teacher of the Jatilas, a great sect of fire-worshippers, all of whom +became also his followers. + +81. Q. _Who was his next great convert?_ + +A. King Bimbisāra, of Magadha. + +82. Q. _Which two of the Buddha's most learned and beloved disciples +were converted at about this time?_ + +A. Sāriputra and Moggallāna, formerly chief disciples of +Sañjaya, the ascetic. + +83. Q. _For what did they become renowned?_ + +A. Sāriputra for his profound learning (_Prajña_), Moggallāna +for his exceptional spiritual powers (_Iddhi_). + +84. Q. _Are these wonder-working powers miraculous?_ + +A. No, but natural to all men and capable of being developed by a +certain course of training. + +85. Q. _Did the Buddha hear again from his family after leaving them?_ + +A. Oh yes, seven years later, while he was living at Rājagrha, his +father. King Suddhodana, sent a message to request him to come and let +him see him again before he died. + +86. Q. _Did he go?_ + +A. Yes. His father went with all his relatives and ministers to meet +him and received him with great joy. + +87. Q. _Did he consent to resume his old rank?_ + +A. No. In all sweetness he explained to his father that the Prince +Siddhārtha had passed out of existence, as such, and was now changed +into the condition of a Buddha, to whom all beings were equally akin +and equally dear. Instead of ruling over one tribe or nation, like an +earthly king, he, through his Dharma, would win the hearts of all men +to be his followers. + +88. Q. _Did he see Yasodharā and his son Rāhula?_ + +A. Yes. His wife, who had mourned for him with deepest love, wept +bitterly. She also sent Rāhula to ask him to give him his +inheritance, as the son of a prince. + +89. Q. _What happened?_ + +A. To one and all he preached the Dharma as the cure for all sorrows. +His father, son, wife, Ānanda (his half-brother), Devadatta (his +cousin and brother-in-law), were all converted and became his +disciples. Two other famous ones were Anuruddha, afterwards a great +metaphysician, and Upāli, a barber, afterwards the greatest +authority on Vinaya. Both of these gained great renown. + +90. Q. _Who was the first Bhikkuni?_ + +A. Prajāpatī, the aunt and foster-mother of Prince +Siddhārtha. With her, Yasodharā and many other ladies were +admitted into the Order as _Bhikkhunis_ or female devotees. + +91. Q. _What effect did the taking up of the religious life by his +sons, Siddhārtha and Ānanda, his nephew, Devadatta, his son's +wife, Yasudharā, and his grandson, Rāhula, have upon the old King +Suddhodana?_ + +A. It grieved him much and he complained to the Buddha, who then made +it a rule of the Order that no person should thenceforth be ordained +without the consent of his parents if alive. + +92. Q. _Tell me about the fate of Devadatta?_ + +A. He was a man of great intelligence and rapidly advanced in the +knowledge of the Dharma, but being also extremely ambitious, he came to +envy and hate the Buddha, and at last plotted to kill him. He also +influenced Ajātashatru, son of King Bimbisāra, to murder his +noble father, and to become his--Devadatta's--disciple. + +93. Q. _Did he do any injury to the Buddha?_ + +A. Not the least, but the evil he plotted against him recoiled upon +himself, and he met with an awful death. + +94. Q. _For how many years was the Buddha engaged in teaching?_ + +A. Forty-five years, during which time he preached a great many +discourses. His custom and that of his disciples was to travel and +preach during the eight dry months, but during the season of Way--the +rains--he and they would stop in the pānsulas and vihāras which +had been built for them by various kings and other wealthy converts. + +95. Q. _Which were the most famous of these buildings?_ + +A. Jetāvanārāma; Veluvanārāma; Pubbārāma; +Nigrodhārāma and Isipatanārāma. + +96. Q. _What kind of people were converted by him and his disciples?_ + +A. People of all ranks, nations and castes; rājas and coolies, rich +and poor, mighty and humble, the illiterate and the most learned. His +doctrine was suited to all. + +97. Q. _Give some account of the decease of the Buddha?_ + +A. In the forty-fifth season after his attaining Buddhahood, on the +full-moon day of May, knowing that his end was near, he came at evening +to Kusināgāra, a place about one hundred and twenty miles from +Benares. In the sāla grove of the Mallas, the Uparvartana of +Kusināgāra, between two sāla trees, he had his bedding spread +with the head towards the north according to the ancient custom. He +lay upon it, and with his mind perfectly clear, gave his final +instructions to his disciples and bade them farewell. + +98. Q. _Did he also make new converts in those last tours?_ + +A. Yes, a very important one, a great Brāhmana pandit named +Subhadra. He had also preached to the Mallya princes and their +followers. + +99. Q. _At day-break what happened?_ + +A. He passed into the interior condition of _Samādhi_ and thence +into Nirvāna. + +100. Q. _What were his last words to his disciples?_ + +A. "Bhikkhus," he said, "I now impress it upon you, the parts and +powers of man must be dissolved. Work out your salvation with +diligence." + +101. Q. _What convincing proof have we that the Buddha, formerly +Prince Siddhārtha, was a historical personage?_ + +A. His existence is apparently as clearly proved as that of any other +character of ancient history. + +102. Q. _Name some of the proofs?_ + +A. (1) The testimony of those who personally knew him. + +(2) The discovery of places and the remains of buildings mentioned in +the narrative of his time. + +(3) The rock-inscriptions, pillars and dagobas made in memory of him by +sovereigns who were near enough to his time to be able to verify the +story of his life. + +(4) The unbroken existence of the Sangha which he founded, and their +possession of the facts of his life transmitted from generation to +generation from the beginning. + +(5) The fact that in the very year of his death and at various times +subsequently, conventions and councils of the Sangha were held, for the +verification of the actual teachings of the Founder, and the handing +down of those verified teachings from teacher to pupil, to the present +day. + +(6) After his cremation his relics were divided among eight kings and a +stūpa was erected over each portion. The portion given to King +Ajātashatru, and by him covered with a stūpa at Rājagrha, was +taken, less than two centuries later, by the Emperor Asoka and +distributed throughout his Empire. He, of course, had ample means of +knowing whether the relics were those of the Buddha or not, since they +had been in charge of the royal house of Patna from the beginning. + +(7) Many of the Buddha's disciples, being Arhats and thus having +control over their vital powers, must have lived to great ages, and +there was nothing to have prevented two or three of them, in succession +to each other, to have covered the whole period between the death of +the Buddha and the reign of Asoka, and thus to have enabled the latter +to get from his contemporary every desired attestation of the fact of +the Buddha's life.[8] + +(8) The "Mahāvansa," the best authenticated ancient history known to +us, records the events of Sinhalese history to the reign of King +Vijaya, 543 B.C.--almost the time of the Buddha--and gives most +particulars of his life, as well as those of the Emperor Asoka and all +other sovereigns related to Buddhistic history. + +103. Q. _By what names of respect is the Buddha called?_ + +A. Sākyamuni (the Sākya Sage); Sākya-Simha (the Sākyan +Lion); Sugata (the Happy One); Satthta (the Teacher); Jina (the +Conqueror), Bhagavat (the Blessed One); Lokanātha (the Lord of the +World); Sarvajña (the Omniscient One); Dharmarāja (the King of +Truth); Tathāgata (the Great Being), etc. + + + +[1] See the definition of _deva_ given later. + +[2] For an admirable account of this interview consult Dr. Paul Carus' +_Gospel of Buddha_, page 20, _et seq._ + +[3] The term Hindū, once a contemptuous term, used by the +Musalmāns to designate the people of Sindh, whom they conquered, is +now used in an ecclesiastical sense. + +[4] No reason is given in the canonical books for the choice of this +side of the tree, though an explanation is to be found in the popular +legends upon which the books of Bishop Bigandet and other European +commentators are based. There are always certain influences coming +upon us from the different quarters of the sky. Sometimes the +influence from one quarter will be best, sometimes that from another +quarter. But the Buddha thought that the perfected man is superior to +all extraneous influences. + +[5] The ancient story is that the God Brahmā himself implored him +not to withhold the glorious truth. + +[6] Brāhmanism not being offered to non-Hindūs, Buddhism is +consequently, the oldest missionary religion in the world. The early +missionaries endured every hardship, cruelty, and persecution, with +unfaltering courage. + +[7] At the Second Council there were two pupils of Ānanda, +consequently centenarians, while in Asoka's Council there were pupils +of those pupils. + + + + +PART II + +THE DHARMA OR DOCTRINE + +106. Q. _What is the meaning of the word Buddha?_ + +A. The enlightened, or he who has the perfect wisdom. + +107. Q. _You have said that there were other Buddhas before this one?_ + +A. Yes; our belief is that, under the operation of eternal causation, +a Buddha takes birth at intervals, when mankind have become plunged +into misery through ignorance, and need the wisdom which it is the +function of a Buddha to teach. (See also Q. 11.) + +108. Q. _How is a Buddha developed?_ + +A. A person, hearing and seeing one of the Buddhas on earth, becomes +seized with the determination so to live that at some future time, when +he shall become fitted for it, he also will be a Buddha for the guiding +of mankind out of the cycle of rebirth. + +109. Q. _How does he proceed?_ + +A. Throughout that birth and every succeeding one, he strives to +subdue his passions, to gain wisdom by experience, and to develop his +higher faculties. He thus grows by degrees wiser, nobler in character, +and stronger in virtue, until, finally, after numberless re-births he +reaches the state when he can become Perfected, Enlightened, All-wise, +the ideal Teacher of the human race. + +110. Q. _While this gradual development is going on throughout all +these births, by what name do we call him?_ + +A. Bōdhisat, or Bōdhisattva. Thus the Prince Siddhartha Gautama +was a Bōdhisattva up to the moment when, under the blessed Bōdhi +tree at Gayā, he became Buddha. + +111. Q. _Have we any account of his various rebirths as a +Bodhisattva?_ + +A. In the Jātakatthakathā, a book containing stories of the +Bōdhisattva's reincarnations, there are several hundred tales of +that kind. + +112. Q. _What lesson do these stories teach?_ + +A. That a man can carry, throughout a long series of reincarnations, +one great, good purpose which enables him to conquer bad tendencies and +develop virtuous ones. + +113. Q. _Can we fix the number of reincarnations through which a +Bōdhisattva must pass before he can become a Buddha?_ + +A. Of course not: that depends upon his natural character, the state +of development to which he has arrived when he forms the resolution to +become a Buddha, and other things. + +114. Q. _Have we a way of classifying Bōdhisattvas? If so, +explain it._ + +A. Bōdhisattvas--the future Buddhas--are divided into three classes. + +115. Q. _Proceed. How are these three kinds of Bōdhisats named?_ + +A. Pannādhika, or Udghatitajña--"he who attains least quickly"; +Saddhādhika, or Vipachitajña--"he who attains less quickly"; and +Viryādhika, or Gneyya--"he who attains quickly". The Pannādhika +Bōdhisats take the course of Intelligence; the Saddhādhika take +the course of Faith; the Viryaāhika take the course of energetic +Action. The first is guided by Intelligence and does not hasten; the +second is full of Faith, and does not care to take the guidance of +Wisdom; and the third never delays to do what is good. Regardless of +the consequences to himself, he does it when he sees that it is best +that it should be done. + +116. Q. _When our Bōdhisattva became Buddha, what did he see was +the cause of human misery? Tell me in one word._ + +A. Ignorance (Avidyā). + +117. Q. _Can you tell me the remedy?_ + +A. To dispel Ignorance and become wise (Prājña). + +118. Q. _Why does ignorance cause suffering?_ + +A. Because it makes us prize what is not worth prizing, grieve when we +should not grieve, consider real what is not real but only illusionary, +and pass our lives in the pursuit of worthless objects, neglecting what +is in reality most valuable. + +119. Q. _And what is that which is most valuable?_ + +A. To know the whole secret of man's existence and destiny, so that we +may estimate at no more than their actual value this life and its +relations; and so that we may live in a way to ensure the greatest +happiness and the least suffering for our fellow-men and ourselves. + +120. Q. _What is the light that can dispel this ignorance of ours and +remove all sorrows?_ + +A. The knowledge of the "Four Noble Truths," as the Buddha called them. + +121. Q. _Name these Four Noble Truths?_ + +A. 1. The miseries of evolutionary existence resulting in births and +deaths, life after life. + +2. The cause productive of misery, which is the selfish desire, ever +renewed, of satisfying one's self, without being able ever to secure +that end. + +3. The destruction of that desire, or the estranging of one's self +from it. + +4. The means of obtaining this destruction of desire. + +122. Q. _Tell me some things that cause sorrow?_ + +A. Birth, decay, illness, death, separation from objects we love, +association with those who are repugnant, craving for what cannot be +obtained. + +123. Q. _Do these differ with each individual?_ + +A. Yes: but all men suffer from them in degree. + +124. Q. _How can we escape the sufferings which result from +unsatisfied desires and ignorant cravings?_ + +A. By complete conquest over, and destruction of, this eager thirst +for life and its pleasures, which causes sorrow. + +125. Q. _How may we gain such a conquest?_ + +A. By following the Noble Eight-fold Path which the Buddha discovered +and pointed out. + +126. Q. _What do you mean by that word: what is this Noble Eight-fold +Path?_ (For the Pālī name see Q. 79.) + +A. The eight parts of this path are called _angas_. They are: 1. +Right Belief (as to the law of Causation, or Karma); 2. Right Thought; +3. Right Speech; 4. Right Action; 5. Right Means of Livelihood; 6. +Right Exertion; 7. Right Remembrance and Self-discipline; 8. Right +Concentration of Thought. The man who keeps these _angas_ in mind and +follows them will be free from sorrow and ultimately reach salvation. + +127. Q. _Can you give a better word for salvation?_ + +A. Yes, emancipation. + +128. Q. _Emancipation, then, from what?_ + +A. Emancipation from the miseries of earthly existence and of +rebirths, all of which are due to ignorance and impure lusts and +cravings. + +129. Q. _And when this salvation or emancipation is attained, what do +we reach?_ + +A. NIRVĀNA. + +130. Q. _What is Nirvāna?_ + +A. A condition of total cessation of changes, of perfect rest, of the +absence of desire and illusion and sorrow, of the total obliteration of +everything that goes to make up the physical man. Before reaching +Nirvāna man is constantly being reborn; when he reaches Nirvāna +he is born no more. + +131. Q. _Where can be found a learned discussion of the word +Nirvāna and a list of the other names by which the old Pālī +writers attempt to define it?_ + +A. In the famous Dictionary of the Pālī Language, by the late +Mr. B. O. Childers, is a complete list.[1] + +132. Q. _But some people imagine that Nirvāna is some sort of +heavenly place, a Paradise. Does Buddhism teach that?_ + +A. No. When Kūtadanta asked the Buddha "Where is Nirvāna," he +replied that it was "wherever the precepts are obeyed". + +133. Q. _What causes us to be reborn?_ + +A. The unsatisfied selfish desire (Skt., _trshnā_; Pālī, +tanhā) for things that belong to the state of personal existence in +the material world. This unquenched thirst for physical existence +(_bhāva_) is a force, and has a creative power in itself so strong +that it draws the being back into mundane life. + +134. Q. _Are our rebirths in any way affected by the nature of our +unsatisfied desires?_ + +A. Yes, and by our individual merits or demerits. + +135. Q. _Does our merit or demerit control the state, condition or +form in which we shall be re-born?_ + +A. It does. The broad rule is that if we have an excess of merit we +shall be well and happily born the next time; if an excess of demerit, +our next birth will be wretched and full of suffering. + +136. Q. _One chief pillar of Buddhistic doctrine is, then, the idea +that every effect is the result of an actual cause, is it not?_ + + A. It is; of a cause either immediate or remote. + +137. Q. _What do we call this causation?_ + +A. Applied to individuals, it is Karma, that is, action. It means +that our own actions or deeds bring upon us whatever of joy or misery +we experience. + +138. Q. _Can a bad man escape from the outworkings of his Karma?_ + +A. The _Dhammapada_ says: "There exists no spot on the earth, or in +the sky, or in the sea, neither is there any in the mountain-clefts, +where an (evil) deed does not bring trouble (to the doer)." + +139. Q. _Can a good man escape?_ + +A. As the result of deeds of peculiar merit, a man may attain certain +advantages of place, body, environment and teaching in his next stage +of progress, which ward off the effects of bad Karma and help his +higher evolution. + +140. _What are they called?_ + +A. _Gati Sampatti_, _Upādhi Sampatti_, _Kāla Sampatti_ and +_Payoga Sampatti_. + +141. Q. _Is that consistent or inconsistent with common sense and the +teachings of modern science?_ + +A. Perfectly consistent: there can be no doubt of it. + +142. Q. _May all men become Buddhas?_ + +A. It is not in the nature of every man to become a Buddha; for a +Buddha is developed only at long intervals of time, and seemingly, when +the state of humanity absolutely requires such a teacher to show it the +forgotten Path to Nirvāna. But every being may equally reach +Nirvāna, by conquering Ignorance and gaining Wisdom. + +143. Q. _Does Buddhism teach that man is reborn only upon our earth?_ + +A. As a general rule that would be the case, until he had evolved +beyond its level; but the inhabited worlds are numberless. The world +upon which a person is to have his next birth, as well as the nature of +the rebirth itself, is decided by the preponderance of the individual's +merit or demerit. In other words, it will be controlled by his +attractions, as science would describe it; or by his Karma, as we, +Buddhists, would say. + +144. Q. _Are there worlds more perfectly developed, and others less +so than our Earth?_ + +A. Buddhism teaches that there are whole _Sakwalas_, or systems of +worlds, of various kinds, higher and lower, and also that the +inhabitants of each world correspond in development with itself. + +145. Q. _Has not the Buddha summed up his whole doctrine in one +gāthā, or verse?_ + +A. Yes. + +146. Q. _Repeat it?_ + +A. _Sabba pāpassa akaranm, + Kusalassa upasampadā + Sachitta pariyo dapanam-- + Etam Buddhānusāsanam._ + + "To cease from all evil actions, + To generate all that is good, + To cleanse one's mind: + This is the constant advice of the Buddhas." + +147. Q. _Have the first three of these lines any very striking +characteristics?_ + +A. Yes: the first line embodies the whole spirit of the _Vinaya +Pitaka_, the second that of the _Sutta_, the third that of the +_Abhidhamma_. They comprise only eight Pālī words, yet, as the +dew-drop reflects the stars, they sparkle with the spirit of all the +Buddha Dharma. + +148. Q. _Do these precepts show that Buddhism is an active or a +passive religion?_ + +A. To "cease from sin" may be called passive, but to "get virtue" and +"to cleanse one's own heart," or mind, are altogether _active_ +qualities. Buddha taught that we should not merely not be evil, but +that we should be _positively_ good. + +149. Q. _Who or what are the "Three Guides"[2] that a Buddhist Is +supposed to follow?_ + +A. They are disclosed in the formula called the Tisarana: "I follow +Buddha as my Guide: I follow the Law as my Guide: I follow the Order as +my Guide." These three _are_, in fact, the Buddha Dharma. + +150. Q. _What does he mean when repeating this formula?_ + +A. He means that he regards the Buddha as his all-wise Teacher, Friend +and Exemplar; the Law, or Doctrine, as containing the essential and +immutable principles of Justice and Truth and the path that leads to +the realisation of perfect peace of mind on earth; and the Order as the +teachers and exemplars of that excellent Law taught by Buddha. + +151. Q. _But are not some of the members of this "Order" men +intellectually and morally inferior?_ + +A. Yes; but we are taught by the Buddha that only those who diligently +attend to the Precepts, discipline their minds, and strive to attain or +have attained one of the eight stages of holiness and perfection, +constitute his "Order". It is expressly stated that the Order referred +to in the "Tisarana" refers to the "Attha Ariya Puggala"--the Noble +Ones who have attained one of the eight stages of perfection. The mere +wearing of yellow robes, or even ordination, does not of itself make a +man pure or wise or entitle him to reverence. + +152. Q. _Then it is not such unworthy bhikkhus as they, whom the true +Buddhist would lake as his guides?_ + +A. Certainly not. + +153. Q. _What are the five observances, or universal precepts, called +the Pañcha Sīla, which are imposed on the laity in general?_ + +A. They are included in the following formula,, which Buddhists repeat +publicly at the vihāras (temples): + +I observe the precept to refrain from destroying the life of beings. + +I observe the precept to refrain from stealing. + +I observe the precept to abstain from unlawful sexual intercourse.[3] + +I observe the precept to refrain from falsehood. + +I observe the precept to abstain from using intoxicants. + +154. Q. What strikes the intelligent person on reading these Sīlas? + +A. That one who observes them strictly must escape from every cause +productive of human misery. If we study history we shall find that it +has all sprung from one or another of these causes. + +155. Q. In which Sīlas is the far-seeing wisdom of the Buddha most +plainly shown? + +A. In the first, third and fifth; for the taking of life, sensuality, +and the use of intoxicants, cause at least ninety-five per cent of the +sufferings among men. + +156. Q. _What benefits does a man derive from the observance of these +Precepts?_ + +A. He is said to acquire more or less merit according to the manner +and time of observing the precepts, and the number observed; that is, +if he observes only one precept, violating the other four, he acquires +the merit of the observance of that precept only; and the longer he +keeps that precept the greater will be the merit. He who keeps all the +precepts inviolate will cause himself to have a higher and happier +existence hereafter. + +157. Q. _What are the other observances which it is considered +meritorious for the laity as such to undertake voluntarily to keep?_ + +A. The _Atthanga Sīla_, or the Eightfold Precept, which embraces +the five above enumerated (omitting the word "unlawful" in the third), +with three additional; _viz._: + +I observe the precept to abstain from eating at an unseasonable time. + +I observe the precept to abstain from dancing, singing, music and +unbecoming shows, and from the use of garlands, scents, perfumes, +cosmetics, ointments, and ornaments. + +I observe the precept to abstain from using high and broad beds. + +The seats and couches here referred to are those used by the +worldly-minded for the sake of pleasure and sensual enjoyment. The +celibate should avoid these. + +158. Q. _How would a Buddhist describe true merit?_ + +A. There is no great merit in any merely outward act; all depends upon +the inward motive that provokes the deed. + +159. Q. _Give an example?_ + +A. A rich man may expend lakhs of rupees in building dāgobas or +vihāras, in erecting statues of Buddha, in festivals and +processions, in feeding priests, in giving alms to the poor, or in +planting trees, digging tanks, or constructing rest-houses by the +roadside for travellers, and yet have comparatively little merit if it +be done for display, or to hear himself praised by men, or for any +other selfish motives. But he who does the least of these things with +a kind motive, such as love for his fellow-men, gains great merit. A +good deed done with a bad motive benefits others, but not the doer. +One who approves of a good deed when done by another shares in the +merit, _if his sympathy is real, not pretended_. The same rule applies +to evil deeds. + +160. Q. _But which is said to be the greatest of all meritorious +actions?_ + +A. The _Dhammapada_ declares that the merit of disseminating the +Dharma, the Law of Righteousness, is greater than that of any other +good work. + +161. Q. _What books contain all the most excellent wisdom of the +Buddha's teachings?_ + +A. The three collections of books called _Tripitakas_ or "_Three +Baskets_". + +162. Q. _What are the names of the three Pitakas, or groups of books?_ + +A. The _Vinaya Pitaka_, the _Sutta Pitaka_ and the _Abhidhamma Pitaka_. + +163. Q. _What do they respectively contain?_ + +A. The first contains all that pertains to morality and the rules of +discipline for the government of the Sangha, or Order; the second +contains instructive discourses on ethics applicable to all; the third +explains the psychological teachings of the Buddha, including the +twenty-four transcendental laws explanatory of the workings of Nature. + +164. Q. _Do Buddhists relieve these books to be inspired, or +revealed, by a Divine Being?_ + +A. No; but they revere them as containing all the parts of that most +Excellent Law, by the knowing of which man may break through the +trammels of _Samsāra_. + +165. Q. _In the whole text of the three Pitakas how many words are +there?_ + +A. Dr. Rhys-Davids estimates them at 1,752,800. + +166. Q. _When were the Pitakas first reduced to writing?_ + +A. In 88-76 B.C., under the Sinhalese King, Wattagamini, or three +hundred and thirty years after the Paranirvāna of the Buddha. + +167. Q. _Have we reason to believe that all the discourses of the +Buddha are known to us?_ + +A. Probably not, and it would be strange if they were. Within the +forty-five years of his public life he must have preached many hundreds +of discourses. Of these, in times of war and persecution, many must +have been lost, many scattered to distant countries, and many +mutilated. History says that enemies of the Buddha Dharma burnt piles +of our books as high as a coco-nut tree. + +168. Q. _Do Buddhists consider the Buddha as one who by his own +virtue can save us from the consequence of our individual sins?_ + +A. Not at all. Man must emancipate himself. Until he does that he +will continue being born over and over and over again--the victim of +ignorance, the slave of unquenched passions. + +169. Q. _What, then, was the Buddha to us, and all other beings?_ + +A. An all-seeing, all-wise Counsellor; one who discovered the safe +path and pointed it out; one who showed the cause of, and the only cure +for, human suffering. In pointing to the road, in showing us how to +escape dangers, he became our Guide. He is to us like one leading a +blind man across a narrow bridge over a swift and deep stream and so +saving his life. + +170. Q. _If we were to try to represent the whole spirit of the +Buddha's doctrine by one word, which word should we choose?_ + +A. Justice. + +171. Q. _Why?_ + +A. Because it teaches that every man gets, under the operations of +unerring KARMA, exactly that reward or punishment which he has +deserved, no more and no less. No good deed or bad deed, however +trifling, and however secretly committed, escapes the evenly-balanced +scales of Karma. + +172. Q. _What is Karma?_[4] + +A. A causation operating on the moral, as well as on the physical and +other planes. Buddhists say there is no miracle in human affairs: what +a man sows that he must and will reap. + +173. Q. _What other good words have been used to express the essence +of Buddhism?_ + +A. Self-culture and universal love. + +174. Q. _What doctrine ennobles Buddhism, and gives it its exalted +place among the world's religions?_ + +A. That of _Mitta_ or _Maitreya_--compassionate kindness. The +importance of this doctrine is moreover emphasised in the giving of the +name "Maitri" (the Compassionate One), to the coming Buddha. + +175. Q. _Were all these points of Doctrine that you have explained +meditated upon by the Buddha near the Bo-tree?_ + +A. Yes, these and many more that may be read in the Buddhist +Scriptures. The entire system of Buddhism came to his mind during the +Great Enlightenment. + +176. Q. _How long did the Buddha remain near the Bo-tree?_ + +A. Forty-nine days. + +177. Q. _What do we call the first discourse preached by the +Buddha--that which he addressed to his five former companions?_ + +A. The _Dhammacakka-ppavattana sutta_--the Sūtra of the Definition +of the Rule of Doctrine.[5] + +178. Q. _What subjects were treated by him in this discourse?_ + +A. The "Four Noble Truths," and the "Noble Eightfold Path". He +condemned the extreme physical mortification of the ascetics, on the +one hand, and the enjoyment of sensual pleasures on the other; pointing +out and recommending the Noble Eightfold Path as the Middle Path. + +179. Q. _Did the Buddha hold with idol-worship?_ + +A. He did not; he opposed it. The worship of gods, demons, trees, +etc., was condemned by the Buddha. External worship is a fetter that +one has to break if he is to advance higher. + +180. Q. _But, do not Buddhists make reverence before the statue of +the Buddha, his relics, and the monuments enshrining them?_ + +A. Yes, but not with the sentiment of the idolater. + +181. Q. _What is the difference?_ + +A. Our Pagan brother not only takes his images as visible +representations of his unseen God or gods, but the refined idolater, in +worshipping, considers that the idol contains in its substance a +portion of the all-pervading divinity. + +182. Q. _What does the Buddhist think?_ + +A. The Buddhist reverences the Buddha's statue and the other things +you have mentioned, only as mementoes of the greatest, wisest, most +benevolent and compassionate man in this world-period (Kalpa). All +races and people preserve, treasure up, and value the relics and +mementoes of men and women who have been considered in any way great. +The Buddha, to us, seems more to be revered and beloved than any one +else, by every human being who knows sorrow. + +183. Q. _Has the Buddha himself given us something definite upon this +subject?_ + +A. Certainly. In the _Mahā Pari-Nirvāna Sutta_ he says that +emancipation is attainable only by leading the Holy life, according to +the Noble Eight-fold Path, not by eternal worship (_āmisa +pūjā_), nor by adoration of himself, or of another, or of any +image. + +184. Q. _What was the Buddha's estimate of ceremonialism?_ + +A. From the beginning, he condemned the observance of ceremonies and +other external practices, which only tend to increase our spiritual +blindness and our clinging to mere lifeless forms. + +185. Q. _What as to controversies?_ + +A. In numerous discourses he denounced this habit as most pernicious. +He prescribed penances for Bhikkhus who waste time and weaken their +higher intuitions in wrangling over theories and metaphysical +subtleties. + +186. Q. _Are charms, incantations, the observance of lucky hours and +devil-dancing a part of Buddhism?_ + +A. They are positively repugnant to its fundamental principles. They +are the surviving relics of fetishism and pantheistic and other foreign +religions. In the _Brāhmajāta Sutta_ the Buddha has +categorically described these and other superstitions as Pagan, mean +and spurious.[6] + +187. Q. _What striking contrasts are there between Buddhism and what +may be properly called "religions"?_ + +A. Among others, these: It teaches the highest goodness without a +creating God; a continuity of life without adhering to the +superstitious and selfish doctrine of an eternal, metaphysical +soul-substance that goes out of the body; a happiness without an +objective heaven; a method of salvation without a vicarious Saviour; +redemption by oneself as the Redeemer, and without rites, prayers, +penances, priests or intercessory saints; and a _summum bonum_, _i.e._, +Nirvāna, attainable in this life and in this world by leading a +pure, unselfish life of wisdom and of compassion to all beings. + +188. Q. _Specify the two main divisions of "meditation," i.e., of the +process by which one extinguishes passion and attains knowledge?_ + +A. _Samatha_ and _Vidarsama_: (1) the attenuation of passion by +leading the holy life and by continued effort to subdue the senses; (2) +the attainment of supernormal wisdom by reflection: each of which +embraces twenty aspects, but I need not here specify them. + +189. Q. _What are the four paths or stages of advancement that one +may attain to?_ + +A. (1) Sottāpatti--the beginning or entering into which follows +after one's clear perception of the "Four Noble Truths"; (2) +Sakardāgāmi--the path of one who has so subjugated lust, hatred +and delusion that he need only return once to this world; (3) +_Anāgami_--the path of those who have so far conquered self that +they need not return to this world; (4) _Arhat_--the path of the holy +and worthy Arhat, who is not only free from the necessity of +reincarnation, but has capacitated himself to enjoy perfect wisdom, +boundless pity for the ignorant and suffering, and measureless love for +all beings. + +190. Q. _Does popular Buddhism contain nothing but what is true, and +in accord with science?_ + +A. Like every other religion that has existed many centuries, it +certainly now contains untruth mingled with truth; ever gold is found +mixed with dross. The poetical imagination, the zeal, or the lingering +superstition of Buddhist devotees have, in various ages, and in various +lands, caused the noble principles of the Buddha's moral doctrines to +be coupled more or less with what might be removed to advantage. + +191. Q. _When such perversions are discovered, what should be the +true Buddhist's earnest desire?_ + +A. The true Buddhist should be ever ready and anxious to see the false +purged away from the true, and to assist, if he can. Three great +Councils of the Sangha were held for the express purpose of purging the +body of Teachings from all corrupt interpolations. + +192. Q. _When?_ + +A. The first, at Sattapanni cave, just after the death of the Buddha; +the second at Valukarama, in Vaisali; the third at Asokarama Vihāra, +at Pātaliputra, 235 years after Buddha's decease. + +193. Q. _In what discourse does the Buddha himself warn us to expect +this perversion of the true Doctrine?_ + +A. In the _Sanyutta Nikāya_. + +194. Q. _Are there any dogmas in Buddhism which we are required to +accept on faith?_ + +A. No: we are earnestly enjoined to accept nothing whatever on faith; +whether it be written in books, handed down from our ancestors, or +taught by the sages. + +195. Q. _Did he himself really teach that noble rule?_ + +A. Yes. The Buddha has said that we must not believe in a thing said +merely because it is said; nor in traditions because they have been +handed down from antiquity; nor rumours, as such; nor writings by +sages, merely because sages wrote them; nor fancies that we may suspect +to have been inspired in us by a Deva (that is, in presumed spiritual +inspiration); nor from inferences drawn from some haphazard assumption +we may have made; nor because of what seems an analogical necessity; +nor on the mere authority of our own teachers or masters. + +196. Q. _When, then, must we believe?_ + +A. We are to believe when the writing doctrine or saying is +corroborated by our own reason and consciousness. "For this," says he +in concluding, "I taught you not to believe merely because you have +heard, but when you believed of your own consciousness, then to act +accordingly and abundantly." (See the _Kālāma Sutta_ of the +_Anguttara Nikāya_, and the _Mahā Pari Nirvāna Sutta_.) + +197. Q. _What does the Buddha call himself?_ + +A. He says that he and the other Buddhas are only "preachers" of truth +who point out the way: we ourselves must make the effort. + +198. Q. _Where is this said?_ + +A. In the _Dhammapada_, Chapter xx. + +199. Q. _Does Buddhism countenance hypocrisy?_ + +A. The Dhammapada says: "Like a beautiful flower full of colour +without scent the fine words of him who does not act accordingly are +fruitless." + +200. Q. _Does Buddhism teach us to return evil for evil?_ + +A. In the _Dhammapada_ the Buddha said: "If a man foolishly does me +wrong, I will return to him the protection of my ungrudging love; the +more evil comes from him, the more good shall go from me." This is the +path followed by the Arhat.[7] To return evil for evil is positively +forbidden in Buddhism. + +201. Q. _Does it encourage cruelty?_ + +A. No, indeed. In the Five Precepts and in many of his discourses, +the Buddha teaches us to be merciful to all beings, to try and make +them happy, to love them all, to abstain from taking life, or +consenting to it, or encouraging its being done. + +202. Q. _In which discourse is this stated?_ + +A. The _Dhammika Sutta_ says: "Let him (the householder) not destroy, +or cause to be destroyed, any life at all, or _sanction the act of +those who do so_. Let him refrain from even hurting any creature."[8] + +203. Q. _Does it approve of drunkenness?_ + +A. In his _Dhammika Sutta_ we are warned against drinking liquors, +causing others to drink, or sanctioning the acts of those who drink.[9] + +204. Q. _To what are we told that drunkenness leads?_ + +A. To demerit, crime, insanity, and ignorance--which is the chief +cause of rebirth. + +205. Q. _What does Buddhism teach about marriage?_ + +A. Absolute chastity being a condition of full spiritual development, +is most highly commended; but a marriage to one wife and fidelity to +her is recognised as a kind of chastity. Polygamy was censured by the +Buddha as involving ignorance and promoting lust. + +206. Q. _In what discourse?_ + +A. The _Anguttara Nikāya_, Chapter iv, 55. + +207. Q. _What does it teach as to the duty of parents to children?_ + +A. They should restrain them from vice, train them in virtue; have +them taught arts and sciences; provide them with suitable wives and +husbands, and give them their inheritance. + +208. Q. What is the duty of children? + +A. To support their parents when old or needy; perform family duties +incumbent on them; guard their property; make themselves worthy to be +their heirs, and when they are gone, honour their memory. + +209. Q. _What of pupils to the teacher?_ + +A. To show him respect; minister to him; obey him; supply his wants; +attend to his instruction. + +210. Q. _What of husband to wife?_ + +A. To cherish her; treat her with respect and kindness; be faithful to +her; cause her to be honoured by others; provide her with suitable +ornaments and clothes. + +211. Q. _What of the wife to her husband?_ + +A. To show affection to him; order her household aright; be hospitable +to guests; be chaste; be thrifty; show skill and diligence in all +things. + +212. Q. Where are these precepts taught? + +A. In the Sigālovāda Sutta. + +213. Q. Do riches help a man to future happiness? + +A. The Dhammapada says: "One is the road that leads to wealth, another +the road that leads to Nirvāna." + +214. Q. Does that mean that no rich man can attain Nirvāna? + +A. That depends on which he loves most. If he uses his wealth for the +benefit of mankind--for the suffering, the oppressed, the +ignorant--then his wealth aids him to acquire merit. + +215. Q. But if the contrary? + +A. But if he loves and greedily hoards money for the sake of its +possession, then it weakens his moral sense, prompts him to crime, +brings curses upon him in this life, and their effects are felt in the +next birth. + +216. Q. _What says the "Dhammapada" about ignorance?_ + +A. That it is a taint worse than all taints that a man can put upon +himself. + +217. Q. _What does it say about uncharitableness towards others?_ + +A. That the fault of others is easily perceived, but that of oneself +difficult to perceive; a man winnows his neighbour's faults like chaff, +but his own fault he hides, as a cheat hides the bad die from the +gambler. + +218. Q. _What advice does the Buddha give us as to man's duty to the +poor?_ + +A. He says that a man's net income should be divided into four parts, +of which one should be devoted to philanthropic objects. + +219. Q. _What five occupations are said to be low and base?_ + +A. Selling liquor, selling animals for slaughter, selling poison, +selling murderous weapons, and dealing in slaves. + +220. Q. _Who are said to be incapable of progress in spirituality?_ + +A. The killers of father, mother, and holy Arhats; Bhikkhus who sow +discord in the Sangha; those who attempt to injure the person of a +Buddha; those who hold extremely nihilistic views as to the future +existence; and those who are extremely sensual. + +121. Q. _Does Buddhism specify places or conditions of torment into +which a bad man's Karma draws him on leaving this life?_ + +A. Yes. They are: Sanjīva; Kālasūtra; Sanghāta; Raurava; +Mahā-Raurava Tāpa; Pratāpa; Avīchi. + +222. Q. _Is the torment eternal?_ + +A. Certainly not. Its duration depends on a man's Karma. + +223. Q. _Does Buddhism declare that non-believers in Buddha will of +necessity be damned for their unbelief?_ + +A. No; by good deeds they may enjoy a limited term of happiness before +being drawn into rebirth by their unexhausted _tanhā_. To escape +rebirth, one must tread the Noble Eight-fold Path. + +224. Q. _What is the spiritual status of woman among Buddhists?_ + +A. According to our religion they are on a footing of perfect equality +with men. "Woman," says the Buddha, in the _Chullavedalla Sutta_, "may +attain the highest path of holiness that is open to man--Arhatship." + +225. Q. _What does a modern critic say about the effect of Buddhism +on woman?_ + +A. That "it has done more for the happiness and enfranchisement of +woman than any other creed" (Sir Lepel Griffin). + +226. Q. _What did the Buddha teach about caste?_ + +A. That one does not become of any caste, whether Pariah, the lowest, +or Brāhmana the highest, by birth, but by deeds. "By deeds," said +He, "one becomes an outcast, by deeds one becomes a Brāhmana" (See +_Vassala Sutta_). + +227. Q. _Tell me a story to illustrate this?_ + +A. Ananda, passing by a well, was thirsty and asked Prakrti, a girl of +the Mātanga, or Pariah, caste, to give him water. She said she was +of such low caste that he would become contaminated by taking water +from her hand. But Ananda replied: "I ask not for caste but for +water"; and the Mātanga girl's heart was glad and she gave him to +drink. The Buddha blessed her for it. + +228. Q. _What did the Buddha say in "Vasala Sutta" about a man of the +Pariah Sopāka caste?_ + +A. That by his merits he reached the highest fame; that many Khattiyas +(Kshattriyas) and Brāhmanas went to serve him; and that after death +he was born in the Brāhma-world: while there are many Brāhmanas +who for their evil deeds are born in hell. + +229. Q. Does Buddhism teach the immortality of the soul? + +A. It considers "soul" to be a word used by the ignorant to express a +false idea. If everything is subject to change, then man is included, +and every material part of him must change. That which is subject to +change is not permanent: so there can be no immortal survival of a +changeful thing.[10] + +230. Q. _What is so objectionable in this word "soul"?_ + +A. The idea associated with it that man can be an entity separated +from all other entities, and from the existence of the whole of the +Universe. This idea of separateness is unreasonable, not provable by +logic, nor supported by science. + +231. Q. _Then there is no separate "I," nor can we say "my" this or +that?_ + +A. Exactly so. + +232. Q. _If the idea of a separate human "soul" is to be rejected, +what is it in man which gives him the impression of having a permanent +personality?_ + +A. _Tanhā_, or the unsatisfied desire for existence. The being +having done that for which he must be rewarded or punished in future, +and having _Tanhā_, will have a rebirth through the influence of +Karma. + +233. Q. _What is it that is born?_ + +A. A new aggregation of Skandhas, or personality[11] caused by the last +generative thought of the dying person. + +234. Q. _How many Skandhas are there?_ + +A. Five. + +235. Q. _Name the five Skandhas?_ + +A. Rūpa, Vedanā, Saññā, Samkhārā,_ and _Viññāna_. + +236. Q. _Briefly explain what they are?_ + +A. __Rūpa_, material qualities; _Vedanā_, sensation; _Saññā_, +abstract ideas; _Samkhārā_, tendencies of mind; _Viññāna_, +mental powers, or consciousness. Of these we are formed; by them we +are conscious of existence; and through them communicate with the world +about us. + +237. Q. _To what cause must we attribute the differences in the +combination of the five Skandhas which make every individual differ +from every other individual?_ + +A. To the ripened Karma of the individual in his preceding births. + +238. Q. _What is the force of energy that is at work, under the +guidance of Karma, to produce the new being?_ + +A. Tanhā--the will to _live_.[12] + +239. Q. _Upon what is the doctrine of rebirths founded?_ + +A. Upon the perception that perfect justice, equilibrium and +adjustment are inherent in the universal system of Nature. Buddhists +do not believe that one life--even though it were extended to one +hundred or five hundred years--is long enough for the reward or +punishment of a man's deeds. The great circle of rebirths will be more +or less quickly run through according to the preponderating purity or +impurity of the several lives of the individual. + +240. Q. _Is this new aggregation of Skandhas--this new +personality--the same being as that in the previous birth, whose +Tanhā has brought it into existence?_ + +A. In one sense it is a new being; in another it is not. In +Pālī it is--"_nacha so nacha añño_" which means not the same nor +yet another. During this life the _Skandhas_ are constantly +changing;[13] and while the man A. B., of forty, is identical, as +regards personality, with the youth A. B., of eighteen, yet, by the +continual waste and reparation of his body, and change of mind and +character, he is a different being. Nevertheless, the man in his old +age justly reaps the reward of suffering consequent upon his thoughts +and actions at every previous stage of his life. So the new being of a +rebirth, being the same individuality as before, but with a changed +form, or new aggregation of _Skandhas_, justly reaps the consequences +of his actions and thoughts in the previous existence. + +241. Q. _But the aged man remembers the incidents of his youth, +despite his being physically and mentally changed. Why, then, is not +the recollection of past lives brought over by us from our last birth, +into the present birth?_ + +A. Because memory is included within the _Skandhas_; and the +_Skandhas_ having changed with the new reincarnation, a new memory, the +record of of that particular existence, develops. Yet the record or +reflection of all the past earth-lives must survive; for, when Prince +Siddhārtha became Buddha, the full sequence of his previous births +was seen by him. If their several incidents had left no trace behind, +this could not have been so, as there would have been nothing for him +to see. And any one who attains to the fourth state of _Dhyāna_ +(psychical insight) can thus retrospectively trace the line of his +lives. + +242. Q. _What is the ultimate point towards which tend all these +series of changes in form?_ + +A. Nirvāna. + +243. Q. _Does Buddhism teach that we should do good with the view of +reaching Nirvāna?_ + +A. No; that would be as absolute selfishness as though the reward +hoped for had been money, a throne, or any other sensual enjoyment. +Nirvāna cannot be so reached, and the unwise speculator is +foredoomed to disappointment. + +244. Q. _Please make it a little clearer?_ + +A. Nirvāna is the synonym of unselfishness, the entire surrender of +selfhood to truth. The ignorant man aspires to nirvānic happiness +without the least idea of its nature. Absence of selfishness is +Nirvāna. Doing good with the view to getting results, or leading +the holy life with the object of gaining heavenly happiness, is not the +Noble Life that the Buddha enjoined. Without hope of reward the Noble +Life should be lived, and that is the highest life. The nirvānic +state can be attained while one is living on this earth. + +245. Q. _Name the ten great obstacles to advancement, called +Sanyojanas, the Fetters?_ + +A. Delusion of self (_Sakkāya-ditthi_); Doubt (_Vicikicchā_); +Dependence on superstitious rites (_Sīlabbata-parāmāsa_); +Sensuality, bodily passions (_Kāma_); Hatred, ill-feeling +(_Patigha_); Love of life on earth (_Rūparāga_); Desire for life +in a heaven (_Arūparāga_); Pride (_Māna_); Self-righteousness +(Uddhacca); Ignorance (_Avijjā_). + +246. Q. _To become an Arhat, how many of these fetters must be +broken?_ + +A. All. + +247. Q. _What are the five Nirwāranas or Hindrances?_ + +A. Greed, Malice, Sloth, Pride, and Doubt. + +248. Q. _Why do we see this minute division of feelings, impulses, +workings of the mind, obstacles and aids to advancement so much used in +the Buddha's teachings? It is very confusing to a beginner._ + +A. It is to help us to obtain knowledge of ourselves, by training our +minds to think out every subject in detail. By following out this +system of self-examination, we come finally to acquire knowledge and +see truth as it is. This is the course taken by every wise teacher to +help his pupil's mind to develop. + +249. Q. _How many of the Buddha's disciples were specially renowned +for their superior qualities?_ + +A. There are eighty so distinguished. They are called the Asīti +Mahā Sāvakas. + +250. Q. _What did the Buddha's wisdom embrace?_ + +A. He knew the nature of the Knowable and the Unknowable, the Possible +and the Impossible, the cause of Merit and Demerit; he could read the +thoughts of all beings; he knew the laws of Nature, the illusions of +the senses and the means to suppress desires; he could distinguish the +birth and rebirth of individuals, and other things. + +251. Q. _What do we call the basic principle on which the whole of +the Buddha's teaching is constructed?_ + +A. It is called Paticca Samuppāda.[14] + +252. Q. _Is it easily grasped?_ + +A. It is most difficult; in fact, the full meaning and extent of it is +beyond the capacity of such as are not perfectly developed. + +253. Q. _What said the great commentator Buddha Ghosha about it?_ + +A. That even he was as helpless in this vast ocean of thought as one +who is drifting on the ocean of waters. + +254. Q. _Then why should the Buddha say, in the Parinibbāna Sutta, +that he "has no such thing as the closed fist of a teacher, who keeps +something back"? If his whole teaching was open to every one's +comprehension why should so great and learned a man as Buddha Ghosha +declare it so hard to understand?_ + +A. The Buddha evidently meant that he taught everything freely; but +equally certain is it that the real basis of the Dharma can only be +understood by him who has perfected his powers of comprehension. It +is, therefore, incomprehensible to common, unenlightened persons. + +255. Q. _How does the teaching of the Buddha support this view?_ + +A. The Buddha looked into the heart of each person, and preached to +suit the individual temperament and spiritual development of the hearer. + + + +[1] Mr. Childers takes a highly pessimistic view of the Nirvānic +state, regarding it as annihilation. Later students disagree with him. + +[2] _Saranam_. Wijesinha Mudaliar writes me: "This word has been +hitherto very inappropriately and erroneously rendered _Refuge_, by +European Pālī scholars, and thoughtlessly so accepted by native +Pālī scholars. Neither Pālī etymology nor Buddhistic +philosophy justifies the translation. _Refuge_, in the sense of a +_fleeing back or a place of shelter_, is quite foreign to true +Buddhism, which insists on every man working out his own emancipation. +The root _Sr_ in Samskrt (_sara_ in Pālī) means to move, to go; +so that _Suranim_ would denote a moving, or he or that which goes +before or with another--a Guide or Helper. I construe the passage +thus: _Gachchāmi_, I go, _Buddham_, to Buddha _Saranam_, as my +Guide. The translation of the _Tisarana_ as the "Three Refuges," has +given rise to much misapprehension, and has been made by anti-Buddhists +a fertile pretext for taunting Buddhists with the absurdity of taking +refuge in non-entities and believing in unrealities. The term refuge +is more applicable to Nirvāna, of which _Saranam_ is a synonym. The +High Priest Sumangala also calls my attention to the fact that the +Pālī root _Sara_ has the secondary meaning of killing, or that +which destroys. _Buddham saranam gachchhāmi_ might thus be rendered +"I go to Buddha, the Law, and the Order, as the destroyers of my +fears--the first by his preaching, the second by its axiomatic truth, +the third by their various examples and precepts." + +[3] This qualified form refers, of course, to laymen who only profess +to keep five precepts; a Bhikkhu must observe strict celibacy. So, +also, must the laic who binds himself to observe eight of the whole ten +Precepts for specified periods; during these periods he must be +celibate. The five Precepts were laid down by Buddha for all people. +Though one may not be a Buddhist, yet the five and eight Precepts may +profitably bo observed by all. It is the taking of the "Three Refuges" +that constitutes one a Buddhist. + +[4] Karma is defined as the sum total of a man's actions. The law of +Cause and Effect is called the _Patice a Samuppada Dhamma_. In the +_Anguttara Nikaya_ the Buddha teaches that my action is my possession, +my action is my inheritance, my action is the womb which bears me, my +action is my relative, my action is my refuge. + +[5] After the appearance of the first edition, I received from one of +the ablest Pālī scholars of Ceylon, the late L. Corneille +Wijesinha, Esq., Mudaliar of Matale, what seems a better rendering of +_Dhammacakka-ppavattana_ than the one previously given; he makes it +"The Establishment of the Reign of Law". Professor Rhys-Davids +prefers, "The Foundation of the Kingdom of Righteousness". Mr. +Wijesinha writes me: "You may use 'Kingdom of Righteousness,' too, but +it savours more of dogmatic theology than of philosophic ethics. +_Dhammacakkappavattana suttum_ is the discourse entitled 'The +Establishment of the Reign of Law'." Having shown this to the High +Priest, I am happy to be able to say that he assents to Mr. Wijesinha's +rendering. + +[6] The mixing of these arts and practices with Buddhism is a sign of +deterioration. Their facts and phenomena are real and capable of +scientific explanation. They are embraced in the term "magic," but +when resorted to, for selfish purposes, attract bad influences about +one, and impede spiritual advancement. When employed for harmless and +beneficent purposes, such as healing the sick, saving life, etc., the +Buddha permitted their use. + +[7] A Buddhist ascetic who, by a prescribed course of practice, has +attained to a superior state of spiritual and intellectual development. +Arhats may be divided into the two general groups of the +_Samathayanika_ and _Sukkha Vipassaka_. The former have destroyed +their passions, and fully developed their intellectual capacity or +mystical insight; the latter have equally conquered passion, but not +acquired the superior mental powers. The former can work phenomena, +the latter cannot. The Arhat of the former class, when fully +developed, is no longer a prey to the delusions of the senses, nor the +slave of passion or mortal frailty. _He penetrates to the root of +whatsoever subject his mind is applied to_ without following the slow +processes of reasoning. His self-conquest is complete; and in place of +the emotion and desire which vex and enthral the ordinary man, he is +lifted up into a condition which is best expressed in the term +"Nirvānic". There is in Ceylon a popular misconception that the +attainment of Arhatship is now impossible; that the Buddha had himself +prophesied that the power would die out in one millennium after his +death. This rumour--and the similar one that is everywhere heard in +India, _viz._, that this being the dark cycle of the _Kali Yuga_, the +practice of Yoga Vidyā, or sublime spiritual science, is +impossible--I ascribe to the ingenuity of those who should be as pure +and (to use a non-Buddhistic but very convenient term) psychically wise +as were their predecessors, but are not, and who therefore seek an +excuse! The Buddha taught quite the contrary idea. In the _Nīga +Nikāya_ he said: "Hear, Subbhadra! The world will never be without +Arhats if the ascetics (Bhikkhus) in my congregations _well and truly +keep my precepts_." (_Imeccha Subhaddabhikkhu samma vihareiyum asunno +loko Arahantehiassa._) + +[8] Kolb, in his _History of Culture_, says: "It is Buddhism we have to +thank for the sparing of prisoners of war, who heretofore had been +slain; also for the discontinuance of the carrying away into captivity +of the inhabitants of conquered lands." + +[9] The fifth Sīla has reference to the mere taking of intoxicants +and stupefying drugs, which leads ultimately to drunkenness. + +[10] The "soul" here criticised is the equivalent of the Greek +_psuche_. The word "material" covers other states of matter than that +of the physical body. + +[11] Upon reflection, I have substituted "personality" for +"individuality" as written in the first edition. The successive +appearances upon one or many earths, or "descents into generation," of +the _tanhaically_-coherent parts (_Skandhas_) of a certain being are a +succession of personalities. In each birth the _personality_ differs +from that of the previous, or next succeeding birth. Karma the _deus +ex machina_, masks (or shall we say reflects?) itself, now in the +personality of a sage, again as an artisan, and so on throughout the +string of births. But though personalities ever shift, the one line of +life along which they are strung like beads, runs unbroken, it is ever +_that particular line_, never any other. It is therefore +individual--an individual vital undulation--which is careering through +the objective side of Nature, under the impulse of Karma and the +creative direction of Tanhā and persists through many cyclic +changes. Professor Rhys-Davids calls that which passes from +personality to personality along the individual chain, "character" or +"doing". Since "character" is not a mere metaphysical abstraction, but +the sum of one's mental qualities and moral propensities, would it not +help to dispel what Professor Rhys-Davids calls "the desperate +expedient of a mystery" (_Buddhism_, p. 101), if we regarded the +life-undulation as individuality and each of its series of natal +manifestations as a separate personality? We _must_ have two words to +distinguish between the concepts, and I find none so clear and +expressive as the two I have chosen. The perfected individual, +Buddhistically speaking, is a Buddha, I should say; for a Buddha is but +the rare flower of humanity, without the least supernatural admixture. +And, as countless generations--"four_ asankhyyas_ and a hundred +thousand cycles" (Fausboll and Rhys-David's _Buddhist Birth Stories_, +No. 13)--are required to develop a man into a Buddha, and _the iron +will to become one runs throughout all the successive births_, what +shall we call that which thus wills and perseveres? Character, or +individuality? An individuality, but partly manifested in any one +birth, built up of fragments from all the births. + +The denial of "Soul" by Buddha (see _Sanyutta Nikāya_, the _Sutta +Pitaka_) points to the prevalent delusive belief in an independent +personality; an entity, which after one birth would go to a fixed place +or state where, as a perfect entity, it could eternally enjoy or +suffer. And what he shows is that the "I am I" consciousness is, as +regards permanency, logically impossible, since its elementary +constituents constantly change and the "I" of one birth differs from +the "I" of every other birth. But everything that I have found in +Buddhism accords with the theory of a gradual evolution of the +perfected man--_viz._, a Buddha--through numberless natal experiences. +And in the consciousness of that individual who, at the end of a given +chain of births, attains Buddhahood, or who succeeds in attaining the +fourth stage of Dhyāna, or mystic self-development, in any of his +births anterior to the final one, the scenes of all these serial births +are perceptible. In the _Jātakat-thavannana_--so well translated by +Professor Rhys-Davids--an expression continually recurs which, I think, +rather supports such an idea, _viz._: "Then the Blessed One _made +manifest an occurrence hidden by change of birth_," or "that which had +been hidden by," etc. Early Buddhism then clearly held to a permanency +of records in the Ākāsha, and the potential capacity of man to +read the same when he has evolved to the stage of true individual +enlightenment. At death, and in convulsions and trance, the _javana +chittā_ is transferred to the object last created by the desires. +The will to live brings all thoughts into objectivity. + +[12] The student may profitably consult Schopenhauer in this +connection. Arthur Schopenhauer, a modern German philosopher of the +most eminent ability, taught that "the Principle or Radical, of Nature, +and of all her objects, the human body included, is, intrinsically what +we ourselves are the most conscious of in our own body, _viz._, Will. +Intellect is a secondary capacity of the primary will, a function of +the brain in which this will reflects itself as Nature and object and +body, as in a mirror... Intellect is secondary, but may lead, in +saints, to a complete renunciation of will, as far as it urges "life" +and is then extinguished in Nirvāna (L. A. Sanders in _The +Theosophist_ for May 1882, p. 213). + +[13] Physiologically speaking, man's body is completely changed every +seven years. + +[14] This fundamental or basic principle may be designated in +Pālī, _Nidāna_--chain of causation or, literally, "Origination +of dependence". Twelve _Nidānas_ are specified, _viz._: +_Avijjā_--ignorance of the truth of natural religion; +_Samkhāra_--causal action, karma; _Viññana_--consciousness of +personality, the "I am I"; _Nāma rūpa_--name and form; +_Salayatana_--six senses; _Phassa_--contact, _Vedanā_--feeling, +_Tanhā_--desire for enjoyment; _Upādāna_--clinging, +_Bhava_--individualising existence; _Jāti---birth, caste; _Jarā, +narana, sokaparidesa, dukkha, domanassa, upāyāsa_--decay, death, +grief, lamentation, despair. + + + + +PART III + +THE SANGHA + + +256. Q. _How do Buddhist Bhikkhus differ from the priests of other +religions?_ + +A. In other religions the priests claim to be intercessors between men +and God, to help to obtain pardon of sins; the Buddhist Bhikkhus do not +acknowledge or expect anything from a divine power. + +257. Q. _But why then was it worth while to create this Order, or +Brotherhood, or Society, apart from the whole body of the people, if +they were not to do what other religious orders do?_ + +A. The object in view was to cause the most virtuous, intelligent, +unselfish and spiritually-minded persons to withdraw from the social +surroundings where their sensual and other selfish desires were +naturally strengthened, devote their lives to the acquisition of the +highest wisdom, and fit themselves to teach and guide others out of the +pleasant path leading towards misery, into the harder path that leads +to true happiness and final liberation. + +258. Q. _Besides the Eight, what two additional observances are +obligatory upon the Bhikkhus?_ + +A. I observe the precept to abstain from dancing, singing and +unbecoming shows. + +I observe the precept to abstain from receiving gold or silver. + +The whole _Dasa_, or _Bhikkhu Sīla_ or Ten Precepts, are binding on +_all_ Bhikkhus and _Samaneras_, or novices, but optional with lay +devotees. + +The _Atthanga Sīla_ are for those who aspire to higher stages beyond +the heavenly regions,[1] aspirants after Nirvāna. + +259. Q. _Are there separate Rules and Precepts for the guidance and +discipline of the Order?_ + +A. Yes: there are 250, but all come under the following four heads: + +Principal Disciplinary Rules {_Pātimokkha Samvara Sīla_). + +Observances for the repression of the senses (_Indriya Samvara +Sīla_). + +Regulations for justly procuring and using food, diet, robes, etc., +(_Paccaya Sannissita Sīla_). + +Directions for leading an unblemished life (_Ajivapari Suddha Sīla_). + +260. Q. _Enumerate some crimes and offences that Bhikkhus are +particularly prohibited from committing?_ + +A. Real Bhikkhus abstain from: + +Destroying the life of beings; + +Stealing; + +False exhibition of "occult" powers to deceive anybody; + +Sexual intercourse; + +Falsehood; + +The use of intoxicating liquors, and eating at unseasonable times; + +Dancing, singing, and unbecoming shows; + +Using garlands, scents, perfumes, etc.; + +Using high and broad beds, couches, or seats; receiving presents of +gold, silver, raw grain and meat, women, and maidens, slaves, cattle, +elephants, etc.; + +Defaming; + +Using harsh and reproachful language; + +Idle talk; + +Reading and hearing fabulous stories and tales; + +Carrying messages to and from laymen; + +Buying and selling; + +Cheating, bribing, deception, and fraud; + +Imprisoning, plundering, and threatening others; + +The practice of certain specified magical arts and sciences, such as +fortune-telling, astrological predictions, palmistry, and other +sciences, that go under the name of magic. Any of these would retard +the progress of one who aimed at the attainment of Nirvāna. + +261. Q. _What are the duties of Bhikkhus to the laity?_ + +A. Generally, to set them an example of the highest morality; to teach +and instruct them; to preach and expound the Law; to recite the +_Paritta_ (comforting texts) to the sick, and publicly in times of +public calamity, when requested to do so; and unceasingly to exhort the +people to virtuous actions. They should dissuade them from vice; be +compassionate and tender-hearted, and seek to promote the welfare of +all beings. + +262. Q. _What are the rules for admission into the Order?_ + +A. The candidate is not often taken before his tenth year; he must +have the consent of his parents; be free from leprosy, boils, +consumption and fits; be a free man; have no debts; and must not be a +criminal or deformed or in the royal service. + +263. Q. _As a novice what is he called?_ + +A. _Samanera_, a pupil.[2] + +264. Q. _At what age can a Samanera be ordained as _Sramana_--monk?_ + +A. Not before his twentieth year. + +265. Q. When ready for ordination what happens? + +A. At a meeting of Bhikkhus he is presented by a Bhikkhu as his +proposer, who reports that he is qualified, and the candidate says: "I +ask the Sangha, Reverend Sirs, for the _Upasampada_ (ordination) +ceremony, etc." + +His introducer then recommends that he be admitted. He is then +accepted. + +266. Q. _What then?_ + +A. He puts on the robes and repeats the Three Refuges {_Tisarana_) and +Ten Precepts (_Dasa Sīla_.) + +267. Q. _What are the two essentials to be observed?_ + +A. Poverty and Chastity. A Bhikkhu before ordination must possess +eight things, _viz._, his robes, a girdle for his loins, a +begging-bowl, water-strainer, razor, needle, fan, sandals. Within +limitations strictly specified in the Vināya, he may hold certain +other properties. + +268. Q. _What about the public confession of faults?_ + +A. Once every fortnight, a _Patimokka_ (Disburdenment) ceremony is +performed, when every Bhikkhu confesses to the assembly such faults as +he has committed and takes such penances as may be prescribed. + +269. Q. _What daily routine must he follow?_ + +A. He rises before daylight, washes, sweeps the vihāra, sweeps +around the Bo-tree that grows near every vihāra, brings the +drinking-water for the day and filters it; retires for meditation, +offers flowers before the dāgoba, or relic-mound, or before the +Bo-tree; then takes his begging-bowl and goes from house to house +collecting food--which he must not ask for, but receive in his bowl as +given voluntarily by the householders. He returns, bathes his feet and +eats, after which he resumes meditation. + +270. Q. _Must we believe that there is no merit in the offering of +flowers (mala pūjā) as an act of worship?_ + +A. That act itself is without merit as a mere formality; but if one +offers a flower as the sweetest, purest expression of heartfelt +reverence for a holy being, then, indeed, is the offering an act of +ennobling worship. + +271. Q. _What next does the Bhikkhu do?_ + +A. He pursues his studies. At sunset he again sweeps the sacred +places, lights a lamp, listens to the instructions of his superior, and +confesses to him any fault he may have committed. + +272. Q. _Upon what are his four earnest meditations +(Sati-patthāna) made?_ + +A. 1. On the body, Kayānapassānā. + 2. On the feeling, Vedanānupassānā. + 3. On the mind, Chittānnpassānā. + 4. On the doctrine, Dhammānupassānā. + +273. Q. _What is the aim of the four Great Efforts +(Sammappadhānā)?_ + +A. To suppress one's animal desires and grow in goodness. + +274. Q. _For the perception by the Bhikkhu of the highest truth, is +reason said to be the best, or intuition?_ + +A. Intuition--a mental state in which any desired truth is +instantaneously grasped. + +275. Q. _And when can that development be reached?_ + +A. When one, by the practice of Jñāna, comes to its fourth stage of +unfolding. + +276. Q. _Are we to believe that in the final stage of Jñāna, and +in the condition called Samādhi, the mind is a blank and thought is +arrested?_ + +A. Quite the contrary. It is then that one's consciousness is most +intensely active, and one's power to gain knowledge correspondingly +vast. + +277. Q. _Try to give me a simile?_ + +A. In the ordinary waking state one's view of knowledge is as limited +as the sight of a man who walks on a road between high hills; in the +higher consciousness of Jñāna and _Samādhi_ it is like the sight +of the eagle poised in the upper sky and overlooking a whole country. + +278. Q. _What do our books say about the Buddha's use of this +faculty?_ + +A. They tell us that it was his custom, every morning, to glance over +the world and, by his divine (clairvoyant) sight, see where there were +persons ready to receive the truth. He would then contrive, if +possible, that it should reach them. When persons visited him he would +look into their minds, read their secret motives, and then preach to +them according to their needs. + + + +[1] The Upāsaka and Upāsika observe these on the Buddhist +_Uposatha_ (Sabbath) days (in Skr. _Upavasata_). They are the 8th, +14th and 15th days of each half lunar month. + +[2] The relationship to his Guru, or teacher, is almost like that of +godson to godfather among Christians, only more real, for the teacher +becomes father, mother, family and all to him. + + + + +PART IV + +THE RISE AND SPREAD OF BUDDHISM + + +279. Q. _As regards the number its followers, how does Buddhism at +this date compare with the other chief religions?_ + +A. The followers of the Buddha Dharma outnumber those of every other +religion. + +280. Q. _What is the estimated number?_ + +A. About five hundred millions (5,000 lakhs or 500 crores): this is +five-thirteenths, or not quite half, of the estimated population of the +globe. + +281. Q. _Have many great battles been fought and many countries +conquered; has much human blood been spilt to spread the Buddha Dharma?_ + +A. History does not record one of those cruelties and crimes as having +been committed to propagate our religion. So far as we know, it has +not caused the spilling of a drop of blood. (See footnote +_ante_--Professor Kolb's testimony.) + +282. Q. _What, then, is the secret of its wonderful spread?_ + + +A. It can be nothing else than its intrinsic excellence: its +self-evident basis of truth, its sublime moral teaching, and its +sufficiency for all human needs. + +283. Q. _How has it been propagated?_ + +A. The Buddha, during the forty-five years of his life as a Teacher, +travelled widely in India and preached the Dharma. He sent his wisest +and best disciples to do the same throughout India. + +284. Q. _When did He send for his pioneer missionaries?_ + +A. On the full-moon day of the month _Wap_ (October). + +285. Q. _What did he tell them?_ + +A. He called them together and said: "Go forth, Bhikkhus, go and +preach the law to the world. Work for the good of others as well as +for your own.... Bear ye the glad tidings to every man. Let no two of +you take the same way." + +286. Q. _How long before the Christian era did this happen?_ + +A. About six centuries. + +287. Q. _What help did Kings give?_ + +A. Besides the lower classes, great Kings, Rājās and +Mahārājās were converted and gave their influence to spread +the religion. + +288. Q. _What about pilgrims?_ + +A. Learned pilgrims came in different centuries to India and carried +back with them books and teachings to their native lands. So, +gradually, whole nations forsook their own faiths and became Buddhists. + +289. Q. _To whom, more than to any other person, is the world +indebted for the permanent establishment of Buddha's religion?_ + +A. To the Emperor Ashoka, surnamed the Great, sometimes Piyadāsi, +sometimes Dharmāshoka. He was the son of Bindusāra, King of +Magadha, arid grandson of Chandragupta, who drove the Greeks out of +India. + +290. Q. _When did he reign?_ + +A. In the third century B.C., about two centuries after the Buddha's +time. Historians disagree as to his exact date, but not very greatly. + +291. Q. _What made him great?_ + +A. He was the most powerful monarch in Indian history, as warrior and +as statesman; but his noblest characteristics were his love of truth +and justice, tolerance of religious differences, equity of government, +kindness to the sick, to the poor, and to animals. His name is revered +from Siberia to Ceylon. + +292. Q. _Was he born a Buddhist?_ + +A. No, he was converted in the tenth year after his anointment as +King, by Nigrodha Samanera, an Arhat. + +293. Q. _What did he do for Buddhism?_ + +A. He drove out bad Bhikkhus, encouraged good ones, built monasteries +and dāgobas everywhere, established gardens, opened hospitals for +men and animals, convened a council at Patna to revise and re-establish +the Dharma, promoted female religious education, and sent embassies to +five Greek kings, his allies, and to all the sovereigns of India, to +preach the doctrines of the Buddha. It was he who built the monuments +at Kapilavastu, Buddha Gāya, Isipatana and Kusinārā, our four +chief places of pilgrimage, besides thousands more. + +294. Q. _What absolute proofs exist as to his noble character?_ + +A. Within recent years there have been discovered, in all parts of +India, fourteen Edicts of his, inscribed on living rocks, and eight on +pillars erected by his orders. They fully prove him to have been one +of the wisest and most high-minded sovereigns who ever lived. + +29.5. Q. _What character do these inscriptions give to Buddhism?_ + +A. They show it to be a religion of noble tolerance, of universal +brotherhood, of righteousness and justice. It has no taint of +selfishness, sectarianism or intolerance. They have done more than +anything else to win for it the respect in which it is now held by the +great pandits of western countries. + +296. Q. _What most precious gift did Dharmāshoka make to Buddhism?_ + +A. He gave his beloved son, Mahinda, and daughter, Sanghamitta, to the +Order, and sent them to Ceylon to introduce the religion. + +297. Q. _Is this fact recorded in the history of Ceylon?_ + +A. Yes, it is all recorded in the Mahāvansa, by the keepers of the +royal records, who were then living and saw the missionaries. + +298. Q. _Is there some proof of Sanghamitta's mission still visible?_ + +A. Yes; she brought with her to Ceylon a branch of the very Bodhi tree +under which the Buddha sat when he became Enlightened, and it is still +growing. + +299. Q. _Where?_ + +A. At Annrādhapura. The history of it has been officially +preserved to the present time. Planted in 306 B.C., it is the oldest +historical tree in the world. + +300. Q. _Who was the reigning sovereign at that time?_ + +A. Dēvanampiyatissa. His consort, Queen Anula, had invited +Sanghamitta to come and establish the Bhikkhuni branch of the Order. + +301. Q. _Who came with Sanghamitta?_ + +A. Many other Bhikkhunis. She, in due time, admitted the Queen and +many of her ladies, together with five hundred virgins, into the Order. + +302. Q. _Can we trace the effects of the foreign work of the Emperor +Ashoka's missionaries?_ + +A. His son and daughter introduced Buddhism into Ceylon: his monks +gave it to the whole of Northern India, to fourteen Indian nations +outside its boundaries, and to five Greek kings, his allies, with whom +he made treaties to admit his religious preachers. + +303. Q. _Can you name them?_ + +A. ANTIOCHUS of Syria, PTOLEMY of Egypt, ANTIGONUS of Macedon, MARGAS +of Cyrene, and ALEXANDER of Epiros. + + 304. Q. _Where do we learn this?_ + +A. From the Edicts themselves of Ashoka the Great, inscribed by him on +rocks and stone pillars, which are still standing and can be seen by +everybody who chooses to visit the places. + +305. Q. _Through what western religious brotherhoods did the Buddha +Dharma mingle itself with western thought?_ + +A. Through the sects of the Therapeuts of Egypt and the Essenes of +Palestine. + +306. Q. _When were Buddhist books first introduced into China?_ + +A. As early as the second or third century B.C. Five of +Dharmāshoka's monks are said--in the Samanta Pasādika and the +Sārattha Dīpanī--two Pālī books--to have been sent to +the five divisions of China. + +307. Q. _Whence and when did it reach Korea?_ + +A. From China, in the year A. D. 372. + +308. Q. _Whence and when did it reach Japan?_ + +A. From Korea, in A. D. 552. + +309. Q. _Whence and when did it reach Cochin China, Formosa, Java, +Mongolia, Yorkand, Balk, Bokhara, Afghanistan and other Central Asian +countries?_ + +A. Apparently in the fourth and fifth centuries A.D. + +310. Q. _From Ceylon, whither and when did it spread?_ + +A. To Burma, in A.D. 450, and thence gradually into Arakan, Kamboya +and Pegu. In the seventh century (A.D. 638) it spread to Siam, where +it is now, as it has been always since then, the State religion. + +311. Q. _From Kashmir, where else did it spread besides to China?_ + +A. To Nepāl and Tibet. + +312. Q. Why is it that Buddhism, which was once the prevailing +religion throughout India, is now almost extinct there? + +A. Buddhism was at first pure and noble, the very teaching of the +Tathagata; its Sangha were virtuous and observed the Precepts; it won +all hearts and spread joy through many nations, as the morning light +sends life through the flowers. But after some centuries, bad Bhikkhus +got ordination (_Upasampada_) the Sangha became rich, lazy, and +sensual, the Dharma was corrupted, and the Indian nation abandoned it. + +313. Q. _Did anything happen about the ninth or tenth century A.D. to +hasten its downfall?_ + +A. Yes. + +314. Q. _Anything besides the decay of spirituality, the corruption +of the Sangha, and the reaction of the populace from a higher ideal of +man to unintelligent idolatry?_ + +A. Yes. It is said that the Mussalmāns invaded, overran and +conquered large areas of India; everywhere doing their utmost to stamp +out our religion. + +315. Q. _What cruel acts are they charged with doing?_ + +A. They burnt, pulled down or otherwise destroyed our vihāras, +slaughtered our Bhikkhus, and consumed with fire our religious books. + +316. Q. _Was our literature completely destroyed in India?_ + +A. No. Many Bhikkhus fled across the borders into Tibet and other +safe places of refuge, carrying their books with them. + +317. Q. _Have any traces of these books been recently discovered?_ + +A. Yes. Rai Bhādur Sarat Chandra Dās, C.I.E., a noted Bengali +pandit, saw hundreds of them in the vihāra libraries of Tibet, +brought copies of some of the most important back with him, and is now +employed by the Government of India in editing and publishing them. + +318. Q. _In which country have we reason to believe the sacred books +of primitive Buddhism have been best preserved and least corrupted?_ + +A. Ceylon. The _Encyclopaedia Britannica_ says that in this island +Buddhism has, for specified reasons, "retained almost its pristine +purity to modern times". + +319. Q. _Has any revision of the text of the Pitakas been made in +modern times?_ + +A. Yes. A careful revision of the Vināya Pitaka was made in Ceylon +in the year A.D. 1875, by a convention of the most learned Bhikkhus, +under the presidency of H. Sumangala, Pradhāna Sthavīra. + +320. Q. _Has there been any friendly intercourse in the interest of +Buddhism between the peoples of the Southern and those of the Northern +Buddhist countries?_ + +A. In the year A.D. 1891, a successful attempt was made to get the +Pradhāna Nayakas of the two great divisions to agree to accept +fourteen propositions as embodying fundamental Buddhistic beliefs +recognised and taught by both divisions. These propositions, drafted +by Colonel Olcott, were carefully translated into Burmese, Sinhalese +and Japanese, discussed one by one, unanimously adopted and signed by +the chief monks, and published in January 1892. + +321. Q. _With what good result?_ + +A. As the result of the good understanding now existing, a number of +Japanese bhikkhus and samaneras have been sent to Ceylon and India to +study Pālī and Samskrt. + +322. Q. _Are there signs that the Buddha Dharma is growing in favour +in non-Buddhistic countries?_[1] + +A. There are. Translations of our more valuable books are appearing, +many articles in reviews, magazines and newspapers are being published, +and excellent original treatises by distinguished writers are coming +from the press. Moreover, Buddhist and non-Buddhist lecturers are +publicly discoursing on Buddhism to large audiences in western +countries. The Shin Shu sect of Japanese Buddhists have actually +opened missions at Honolulu, San Francisco, Sacramento and other +American places. + +323. Q. _What two leading ideas of ours are chiefly taking hold upon +the western mind?_ + +A. Those of Karma and Reincarnation. The rapidity of their acceptance +is very surprising. + +324. Q. _What is believed to be the explanation of this?_ + +A. Their appeals to the natural instinct of justice, and their evident +reasonableness. + + + + +[1] See Appendix. + + + + +PART V + +BUDDHISM AND SCIENCE + +325. Q. _Has Buddhism any right to be considered a scientific +religion, or may it be classified as a "revealed" one?_ + +A. Most emphatically it is not a revealed religion. The Buddha did +not so preach, nor is it so understood. On the contrary, he gave it +out as the statement of eternal truths, which his predecessors had +taught like himself. + +326. Q. _Repeat again the name of the Sutta, in which the Buddha +tells us not to believe in an alleged revelation without testing it by +one's reason and experience?_ + +A. The Kālāma Sutta, of the Anguthara Nikāya. + +327. Q. _Do Buddhists accept the theory that everything has been +formed out of nothing by a Creator?_ + +A. The Buddha taught that two things are causeless, _viz._, +Ākāsha, and Nirvāna. Everything has come ont of Ākāsha, +in obedience to a law of motion inherent in it, and, after a certain +existence, passes away. Nothing ever came out of nothing. We do not +believe in miracles; hence we deny creation, and cannot conceive of a +creation of something out of nothing. Nothing organic is eternal. +Everything is in a state of constant flux, and undergoing change and +reformation, keeping up the continuity according to the law of +evolution. + +328. Q. _Is Buddhism opposed to education, and to the study of +science?_ + +A. Quite the contrary: in the _Sigālowāda Sutta_ in a discourse +preached by the Buddha, He specified as one of the duties of a teacher +that he should give his pupils "instruction in science and lore". The +Buddha's higher teachings are for the enlightened, the wise, and the +thoughtful. + +329. Q. _Can you show any further endorsement of Buddhism by science?_ + +A. The Buddha's doctrine teaches that there were many progenitors of +the human race; also that there is a principle of differentiation among +men; certain individuals have a greater capacity for the rapid +attainment of Wisdom and arrival at Nirvāna than others. + +330. Q. _Any other?_ + +A. Buddhism supports the teaching of the indestructibility of force. + +331. Q. _Should Buddhism be called a chart of science or a code of +morals?_ + +A. Properly speaking, a pure moral philosophy, a system of ethics and +transcendental metaphysics. It is so eminently practical that the +Buddha kept silent when Malunka asked about the origin of things. + +332. Q. _Why did he do that?_ + +A. Because he thought that our chief aim should be to see things as +they exist around us and try to make them better, not to waste time in +intellectual speculations. + +333. Q. _What do Buddhists say is the reason for the occasional birth +of very good and wise children of bad parents, and that of very bad +ones of good parents?_ + +A. It is because of the respective Karmas of children and parents; +each may have deserved that such unusual relationships should be formed +in the present birth. + +334. Q. _Is anything said about the body of the Buddha giving out a +bright light?_ + +A. Yes, there was a divine radiance sent forth from within by the +power of his holiness. + +335. Q. _What is it called in Pālī?_ + +A. Buddharansi, the Buddha rays. + +336. Q. _How many colours could be seen in it?_ + +A. Six, linked in pairs. + +337. Q. _Their names?_ + +A. Nīla, Pita, Lohita, Avadata, Mangastā, Prabhasvra. + +338. Q. _Did other persons emit such shining light?_ + +A. Yes, all Arhats did and, in fact, the light shines stronger and +brighter in proportion to the spiritual development of the person. + +339. Q. _Where do we see these colours represented?_ + +A. In all vihāras where there are painted images of the Buddha. +They are also seen in the stripes of the Buddhist Flag, first made in +Ceylon but now widely adopted throughout Buddhist countries. + +340. Q. _In which discourse does the Buddha himself speak of this +shining about him?_ + +A. In the _Mahā-Parinibbana Suttā_, Ānanda his favourite +disciple, noticing the great splendour which came from his Master's +body, the Buddha said that on two occasions this extraordinary shining +occurs, (_a_) just after a Tathāgatā gains the supreme insight, +and (_b_) on the night when he passes finally away. + +341. Q. _Where do we read of this great brightness being emitted from +the body of another Buddha?_ + +A. In the story of Sumedha and Dipānkāra Buddha, found in the +_Nidānakathā_ of the _Jātaka_ book, or story of the +reincarnations of the Bodhisattva Siddhārtha Gautama. + +342. Q. _How is it described?_ + +A. As a halo of a fathom's depth. + +343. Q. _What do the Hindus call it?_ + +A. _Tejas_; its extended radiance they call Prākāsha. + +344. Q. _What do Europeans call it now?_ + +A. The human aura. + +345. Q. _What great scientist has proved the existence of this aura +by carefully conducted experiments?_ + +A. The Baron Von Reichenbach. His experiments are fully described in +his _Researches_, published in 1844-5. Dr. Baraduc, of Paris, has, +quite recently, photographed this light. + +346. Q. _Is this bright aura a miracle or a natural phenomenon?_ + +A. Natural. It has been proved that not only all human beings but +animals, trees, plants and even stones have it. + +347. Q. _What peculiarity has it in the case of a Buddha or an Arhat?_ + +A. It is immensely brighter and more extended than in cases of other +beings and objects. It is the evidence of their superior development +in the power of _Iddhī_. The light has been seen coming from +dāgobas in Ceylon where relics of the Buddha are said to be +enshrined. + +348. Q. _Do people of other religions besides Buddhism and +Hindūism also believe in this light?_ + +A. Yes, in all pictures of Christian artists this light is represented +as shining about the bodies of their holy personages. The same belief +is found to have existed in other religions. + +349. Q. _What historical incident supports the modern theory of +hypnotic suggestion?_ + +A. That of Chullapanthaka, as told in the Pālī Commentary on the +_Dhammapada_, etc. + +350. Q. _Give me the facts._ + +A. He was a bhikkhu who became an Arhat. On that very day the Buddha +sent a messenger to call him. When the man reached the Vihāra, he +saw three hundred bhikkhus in one group, each exactly like the others +in every respect. On his asking which was Chullapanthaka, every one of +the three hundred figures replied: "I am Chullapanthaka." + +351. Q. _What did the messenger do?_ + +A. In his confusion he returned and reported to the Buddha. + +352. Q. _What did the Buddha then tell him?_ + +A. To return to the vihāra and, if the same thing happened, to +catch by the arm the _first_ figure who said he was Chullapanthaka and +lead him to him. The Buddha knew that the new Arhat would make this +display of his acquired power to impress illusionary pictures of +himself upon the messenger. + +353. Q. _What is this power of illusion called in Pālī?_ + +A. _Manomaya Iddhī_. + +354. Q. _Were the illusionary copies of the Arhat's person material? +Were they composed of substance and could they have been felt and +handled by the messenger?_ + +A. No; they were pictures impressed by his thought and trained +will-power upon the messenger's mind. + +355. Q. _To what would you compare them?_ + +A. To a man's reflection in a mirror, being exactly like him yet +without solidity. + +356. Q. _To make such an illusion on the messenger's mind, what was +necessary?_ + +A. That Chullapanthaka should clearly conceive in his own mind his +exact appearance, and then impress that, with as many duplicates or +repetitions as he chose, upon the sensitive brain of the messenger. + +357. Q. _What is this process now called?_ + +A. Hypnotic suggestion. + +358. Q. _Could any third party have also seen these illusionary +figures?_ + +A. That would depend on the will of the Arhat or hypnotiser. + +359. Q. _What do you mean?_ + +A. Supposing that fifty or five hundred persons were there, instead of +one, the Arhat could will that the illusion should be seen by all +alike; or, if he chose, he could will that the messenger should be the +only one to see them. + +360. Q. _Is this branch of science well known in our day?_ + +A. Very well known; it is familiar to all students of mesmerism and +hypnotism. + +361. Q. _In what does our modern scientific belief support the theory +of Karma, as taught in Buddhism?_ + +A. Modern scientists teach that every generation of men is heir to the +consequences of the virtues and the vices of the preceding generation, +not in the mass, as such, but in every individual case. Every one of +us, according to Buddhism, gets a birth which represents the causes +generated by him in an antecedent birth. This is the idea of Karma. + +362. Q. _What say the Vāsettha Sutta about the causation in +Nature?_ + +A. It says: "The world exists by cause; all things exist by cause, all +beings are bound by cause." + +363. Q. _Does Buddhism teach the unchangeableness of the visible +universe; our earth, the sun, the moon, the stars, the mineral, +vegetable, animal and human kingdoms?_ + +A. No. It teaches that all are constantly changing, and all must +disappear in course of time. + +364. Q. _Never to reappear?_ + +A. Not so: the principle of evolution, guided by Karma, individual and +collective, will evolve another universe with its contents, as our +universe was evolved out of the Ākāsha. + +365. Q. _Does Buddhism admit that man has in his nature any latent +powers for the production of phenomena commonly called "miracles"?_ + +A. Yes; but they are natural, not supernatural. They may be developed +by a certain system which is laid down in our sacred books, the +Visuddhi Mārga for instance. + +366. Q. _What is this branch of science called?_ + +A. The Pālī name is Iddhi-vidhanānā. + +367. Q. _How many kinds are there?_ + +A. Two: _Bāhira_, _i.e._, one in which the phenomena-working power +may be temporarily obtained by ascetic practices and also by resort to +drugs, the recitation of _mantras_ (charms), or other extraneous aids; +and _Sasaniks_, that in which the power in question is acquired by +interior self-development, and covers all and more than the phenomena +of _Laukika Iddhī_. + +368. Q. _What class of men enjoy these powers?_ + +A. They gradually develop in one which pursues a certain course of +ascetic practice called _Dhyāna_. + +369. Q. Can this Iddhi power be lost?[1] + +A. The _Bāhira_ can be lost, but the _Sasanika_ never, when once +acquired. _Lokottara_ knowledge once obtained is never lost, and it is +by this knowledge _only_ that the absolute condition of Nirvāna is +known by the Arhat. And this knowledge can be got by following the +noble life of the Eightfold Path. + +370. Q. _Had Buddha the Lokottara Iddhī?_ + +A. Yes, in perfection. + +371. Q. _And his disciples also had it?_ + +A. Yes, some but not all equally; the capacity for acquiring these +occult powers varies with the individual. + +372. Q. _Give examples?_ + +A. Of all the disciples of the Buddha, Mogallāna was possessed of +the most extraordinary powers for making phenomena, while Ānanda +could develop none during the twenty-five years in which he was the +personal and intimate disciple of the Buddha himself. Later he did, as +the Buddha had foretold he would. + +373. Q. _Does a man acquire these powers suddenly or gradually?_ + +A. Normally, they gradually develop themselves as the disciple +progressively gains control over his lower nature in a series of +births.[2] + +374. Q. _Does Buddhism pretend that the miracle of raising those who +are dead is possible?_ + +A. No. The Buddha teaches the contrary, in that beautiful story of +Kisā Gotami and the mustard-seed. But when a person only seems to +be dead but is not actually so, resuscitation is possible. + +375. Q. _Give me an idea of these successive stages of the Lokottara +development in Iddhī?_ + +A. There are six degrees attainable by Arhats; what is higher than +them is to be reached only by a Buddha. + +376. Q. _Describe the six stages or degrees?_ + +A. We may divide them into two groups, of three each. The first to +include (1) Progressive retrospection, _viz._, a gradually acquired +power to look backward in time towards the origin of things; (2) +Progressive foresight, or power of prophecy; (3) Gradual extinction of +desires and attachments to material things. + +377. Q. _What would the second group include?_ + +A. The same faculties, but inimitably developed. Thus, the full Arhat +possesses perfect retrospection, perfect foresight, and has absolutely +extinguished the last trace of desire and selfish attractions. + +378. Q. _What are the four means for obtaining Iddhī?_ + +A. The will, its exertion, mental development, and discrimination +between right and wrong. + +379. Q. _Our Scriptures relate hundreds of instances of phenomena +produced by Arhats: what did you say was the name of this faculty or +power?_ + +A. _Iddhī vidha_. One possessing this can, by manipulating the +forces of Nature, produce any wonderful phenomenon, _i.e._, make any +scientific experiment he chooses. + +380. Q. _Did the Buddha encourage displays of phenomena?_ + +A. No; he expressly discouraged them as tending to create confusion in +the minds of those who were not acquainted with the principles +involved. They also tempt their possessors to show them merely to +gratify idle curiosity and their own vanity. Moreover, similar +phenomena can be shown by magicians and sorcerers learned in the +_Laukika_, or the baser form of _Iddhī_ science. All false +pretensions to supernatural attainment by monks are among the +unpardonable sins (_Tevijja Sutta_). + +381. Q. _You spoke of a "deva" having appeared to the Prince +Siddhārtha under a variety of forms; what do Buddhists believe +respecting races of elemental invisible beings having relations with +mankind?_ + +A. They believe that there are such beings who inhabit worlds or +spheres of their own. The Buddhist doctrine is that, by interior +self-development and conquest over his baser nature, the Arhat becomes +superior to even the most formidable of the devas, and may subject and +control the lower orders. + +382. Q. _How many kinds of devas are there?_ + +A. Three: _Kāmāvācharā_ (those who are still under the +domination of the passions); _Rūpāvācharā_ (a higher class, +which still retain an individual form): _Arāpāvācharā_ (the +highest in degree of purification, who are devoid of material forms). + +383. Q. _Should we fear any of them?_ + +A. He who is pure and compassionate in heart and of a courageous mind +need fear nothing: no man, god, _brahmarakkhas_, demon or deva, can +injure him, but some have power to torment the impure, as well as those +who invite their approach. + + + +[1] Sumangala Sthavīra explains to me that those transcendent powers +are permanently possessed only by one who has subdued all the passions +(_Klesa_), in other words, an Arhat. The powers may be developed by a +bad man and used for doing evil things, but their activity is but +brief, the rebellious passions again dominate the sorcerer, and he +becomes at last their victim. + +[2] When the powers suddenly show themselves, the inference is that the +individual had developed himself in the next anterior birth. We do not +believe in eccentric breaks in natural law. + + + + +APPENDIX + +The following text of the fourteen items of belief which have been +accepted as fundamental principles in both the Southern and Northern +sections of Buddhism, by authoritative committees to whom they were +submitted by me personally, have so much historical importance that +they are added to the present edition of THE BUDDHIST CATECHISM as an +Appendix. It has very recently been reported to me by H. E. Prince +Ouchtomsky, the learned Russian Orientalist, that having had the +document translated to them, the Chief Lamas of the great Mongolian +Buddhist monasteries declared to him that they accept every one of the +propositions as drafted, with the one exception that the date of the +Buddha is by them believed to have been some thousands of years earlier +than the one given by me. This surprising fact had not hitherto come +to my knowledge. Can it be that the Mongolian Sangha confuse the real +epoch of Sākya Muni with that of his alleged next predecessor? Be +this as it may, it is a most encouraging fact that the whole Buddhistic +world may now be said to have united to the extent at least of these +Fourteen Propositions. + +H. S. O. + + + +FUNDAMENTAL BUDDHISTIC BELIEFS + +I Buddhists are taught to show the same tolerance, forbearance, and +brotherly love to all men, without distinction; and an unswerving +kindness towards the members of the animal kingdom. + +II The universe was evolved, not created; and its functions according +to law, not according to the caprice of any God. + +III The truths upon which Buddhism is founded are natural. They have, +we believe, been taught in successive kalpas, or world-periods, by +certain illuminated beings called BUDDHAS, the name BUDDHA meaning +"Enlightened". + +IV The fourth Teacher in the present kalpa was Sākya Muni, or +Gautama Buddha, who was born in a Royal family in India about 2,500 +years ago. He is an historical personage and his name was +Siddhārtha Gautama. + +V Sākya Muni taught that ignorance produces desire, unsatisfied +desire is the cause of rebirth, and rebirth, the cause of sorrow. To +get rid of sorrow, therefore, it is necessary to escape rebirth; to +escape rebirth, it is necessary to extinguish desire; and to extinguish +desire, it is necessary to destroy ignorance. + +VI Ignorance fosters the belief that rebirth is a necessary thing. +When ignorance is destroyed the worthlessness of every such rebirth, +considered as an end in itself, is perceived, as well as the paramount +need of adopting a course of life by which the necessity for such +repeated rebirths can be abolished. Ignorance also begets the illusive +and illogical idea that there is only one existence for man, and the +other illusion that this one life is followed by states of unchangeable +pleasure or torment. + +VII The dispersion of all this ignorance can be attained by the +persevering practice of an all-embracing altruism in conduct, +development of intelligence, wisdom in thought, and destruction of +desire for the lower personal pleasures. + +VIII The desire to live being the cause of rebirth, when that is +extinguished rebirths cease and the perfected individual attains by +meditation that highest state of peace called _Nirvāna_. + +IX Sākya Muni taught that ignorance can be dispelled and sorrow +removed by the knowledge of the four Noble Truths, _viz._: + +1. The miseries of existence; + +2. The cause productive of misery, which is the desire ever renewed of +satisfying oneself without being able ever to secure that end; + +3. The destruction of that desire, or the estranging of oneself from it; + +4. The means of obtaining this destruction of desire. The means which +he pointed out is called the Noble Eightfold Path, _viz._: Right +Belief; Right Thought; Right Speech; Right Action; Right Means of +Livelihood; Right Exertion; Right Remembrance; Right Meditation. + +X Right Meditation leads to spiritual enlightenment, or the +development of that Buddha-like faculty which is latent in every man. + +XI The essence of Buddhism, as summed up by the Tathāgathā +(Buddha) himself, as: + + To cease from all sin, + To get virtue, + To purify the heart. + +XII The universe is subject to a natural causation known as "Karma". +The merits and demerits of a being in past existences determine his +condition in the present one. Each man, therefore, has prepared the +causes of the effects which he now experiences. + +XIII The obstacles to the attainment of good karma may be removed by +the observance of the following precepts, which are embraced in the +moral code of Buddhism, _viz._: (1) Kill not; (2) Steal not; (3) +Indulge in no forbidden sexual pleasure; (4) Lie not; (5) Take no +intoxication or stupefying drug or liquor. Five other precepts which +need not be here enumerated should be observed by those who would +attain, more quickly than the average layman, the release from misery +and rebirth. + +XIV Buddhism discourages superstitious credulity. Gautama Buddha +taught it to be the duty of a parent to have his child educated in +science and literature. He also taught that no one should believe what +is spoken by any sage, written in any book, or affirmed by tradition, +unless it accord with reason. + +Drafted as a common platform upon which all Buddhists can agree. + +H. S. OLCOTT, P.T.S. + + + +Respectfully submitted for the approval of the High Priests of the +nations which we severally represent, in the Buddhist Conference held +at Adyar, Madras, on the 8th, 9th, 10th, 11th, and 12th of January, +1891 (A.B. 2434). + + Japan . . . . . ( Kozen Gunaratana + ( Chiezo Tokuzawa + Burmah . . . . . U. Hmoay Tha Aung + Ceylon . . . . . Dhammapala Hevavitarana. + The Maghs of + Chittagong . . . Krshna Chandra Chowdry, by + his appointed Proxy, Maung + Tha Dwe. + +BURMAH + +Approved on behalf of the Buddhists of Burmah, this 3rd day of +February, 1891 (A. B. 2434): + +Tha-tha-na-baing Saydawgyi; Aung Myi Shwebōn Sayadaw; Me-ga-waddy +Sayadaw; Hmat-Khaya Sayadaw; Hti-lin Sayadaw; Myadaung Sayadaw; +Hla-Htwe Sayadaw; and sixteen others. + +CEYLON + +Approved on behalf of the Buddhists of Ceylon this 25th day of +February, 1891 (A.B. 2434); Mahannwara upawsatha puspārāma +vihārādhipati Hippola Dhamma Rakkhita Sobhitābhidhāna +Mahā Nāyaka Sthavirayan wahanse wamha. + +(Hippola Dhamma Rakkhita Sabhitābhidhana, High Priest of the +Malwatta Vihare at Kandy). + + (Sd.) HIPPOLA. + + +Mahanuwara Asgiri vihārādhipati Yatawattē +Chandajottyābhidhana Mahā Nāyaka Sthavirayan wahanse +wamha--(Yatawattē Chandajottyābhidhana, High Priest of Asgiri +Tihare at Kandy). + + (Sd.) YATAWATTE + + +Hikkaduwe Srī Sumangala Sripādasthāne saha Kolamba palate +pradhāna Nāyaka Sthavirayo (Hikkaduwe Srī Sumangala, High +Priest of Adam's Peak and the District of Colombo). + + (Sd.) H. SUMANGALA + + +Maligawe Prāchina Pustakālāyadhyakshaka Surīyagoda +Sonuttara Sthavirayo (Suriyagoda Sonuttara, Librarian of the Oriental +Library at the Temple of the Tooth Relic at Kandy). + + (Sd.) S. SONUTTARA + + +Sugata Sāsanadhaja Vinayā chāriya +Dhammalankārābhidhāna Nāyaka Sthavira. + + (Sd.) W. DHAMMALANKARA + + +Pawara neruttika chariya Mahā Vibhavi Subhuti of Waskaduwa. + + (Sd.) W. SUBHUTI + +JAPAN + +Accepted as included within the body of Northern Buddhism. + + Shaku Genyu (Shingon Shu) + Fukuda Nichiyo (Nichiren " ) + Sanada Seyko (Zen " ) + Ito Quan Shyu ( " " ) + Takehana Hakuyo (Jodo " ) + Kono Rioshin (Ji-Shu " ) + Kiro Ki-ko (Jodo Seizan " ) + Harutani Shinsho (Tendai " ) + Manabe Shun-myo (Shingon " ) + + +CHITTAGONG + +Accepted for the Buddhists of Chittagong. + + Nagawa Parvata Vihāarādhipati + Guna Megu Wini-Lankara, + Harbing, Chittagong, Bengal. + + + + +BIBLIOGRAPHY + +The Buddhist Catechism has been compiled from personal studies in +Ceylon, and in part from the following works: + + + _Vinaya Texts_ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Davids and Oldenberg. + _Buddhist Literature in China_ . . . . . . Beal. + _Catena of Buddhist Scriptures_ . . . . . Do. + _Buddhaghosa's Parables_ . . . . . . . . . Rogers. + _Buddhist Birth Stories_ . . . . . . . . . Fausboll and Davids. + _Legend of Gautama_ . . . . . . . . . . . Bigandet. + _Chinese Buddhism_ . . . . . . . . . . . . Edkins. + _Kalpa Sutra and Nava Patva_ . . . . . . . Stevenson. + _Buddha and Early Buddhism_ . . . . . . . Lillie. + _Sutta Nipāta_ . . . . . . . . . . . . Sir Coomara Swami. + _Nāgananda_ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Broyd. + _Kusa Jataka_ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Steele. + _Buddhism_ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rhys-Davids. + _Dhammapada_ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fausboll and Max Müller. + + _Romantic History of Buddha_ . . . . . . . Beal. + _Udānavarga_ . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rockhill. + _Twelve Japanese Buddhist Sects_ . . . . . B. Nanjio. + _The Gospel of Buddha_ . . . . . . . . . . Paul Carus. + _The Dharma_ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Do. + _Ancient India_ . . . . . . . . . . . . . R. C. Dutt. + _The "Sacred Books of the East" Series_ . Max Müller's Edition. + _Encyclopædia Britannica_ + + + + + + Printed by + Annie Besant + Vasanta Press + Adyar Madras + + + + + + + + + +End of Project Gutenberg's The Buddhist Catechism, by Henry S. Olcott + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE BUDDHIST CATECHISM *** + +***** This file should be named 30216-0.txt or 30216-0.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + https://www.gutenberg.org/3/0/2/1/30216/ + +Produced by U Hla Maung. HTML and Unicode versions by Al Haines. + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +https://gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS' WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at https://www.pglaf.org. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Its 501(c)(3) letter is posted at +https://pglaf.org/fundraising. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at https://pglaf.org + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit https://pglaf.org + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including including checks, online payments and credit card +donations. To donate, please visit: https://pglaf.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + https://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. |
