diff options
Diffstat (limited to '5134-0.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | 5134-0.txt | 4090 |
1 files changed, 4090 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/5134-0.txt b/5134-0.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..dfc6207 --- /dev/null +++ b/5134-0.txt @@ -0,0 +1,4090 @@ +The Project Gutenberg eBook, Discoveries Made Upon Men and Matter, by Ben +Jonson, Edited by Henry Morley + + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + + + + +Title: Discoveries Made Upon Men and Matter + and Some Poems + + +Author: Ben Jonson + +Editor: Henry Morley + +Release Date: August 14, 2014 [eBook #5134] +[This file was first posted on May 10, 2002] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: UTF-8 + + +***START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK DISCOVERIES MADE UPON MEN AND +MATTER*** + + +Transcribed from the 1892 Cassell & Company edition by David Price, email +ccx074@pglaf.org + + CASSELL’S NATIONAL LIBRARY. + + * * * * * + + + + + + DISCOVERIES + _MADE UPON MEN AND MATTER_ + AND + SOME POEMS + + + BY + BEN JOHNSON. + + [Picture: Decorative graphic] + + CASSELL & COMPANY, LIMITED: + _LONDON_, _PARIS & MELBOURNE_. + 1892. + + + + +INTRODUCTION + + +BEN JONSON’S “Discoveries” are, as he says in the few Latin words +prefixed to them, “A wood—Sylva—of things and thoughts, in Greek ‘ὕλη’” +[which has for its first meaning material, but is also applied peculiarly +to kinds of wood, and to a wood], “from the multiplicity and variety of +the material contained in it. For, as we are commonly used to call the +infinite mixed multitude of growing trees a wood, so the ancients gave +the name of Sylvæ—Timber Trees—to books of theirs in which small works of +various and diverse matter were promiscuously brought together.” + +In this little book we have some of the best thoughts of one of the most +vigorous minds that ever added to the strength of English literature. +The songs added are a part of what Ben Jonson called his “Underwoods.” + +Ben Jonson was of a north-country family from the Annan district that +produced Thomas Carlyle. His father was ruined by religious persecution +in the reign of Mary, became a preacher in Elizabeth’s reign, and died a +month before the poet’s birth in 1573. Ben Jonson, therefore, was about +nine years younger than Shakespeare, and he survived Shakespeare about +twenty-one years, dying in August, 1637. Next to Shakespeare Ben Jonson +was, in his own different way, the man of most mark in the story of the +English drama. His mother, left poor, married again. Her second husband +was a bricklayer, or small builder, and they lived for a time near +Charing Cross in Hartshorn Lane. Ben Jonson was taught at the parish +school of St. Martin’s till he was discovered by William Camden, the +historian. Camden was then second master in Westminster School. He +procured for young Ben an admission into his school, and there laid firm +foundations for that scholarship which the poet extended afterwards by +private study until his learning grew to be sworn-brother to his wit. + +Ben Jonson began the world poor. He worked for a very short time in his +step-father’s business. He volunteered to the wars in the Low Countries. +He came home again, and joined the players. Before the end of +Elizabeth’s reign he had written three or four plays, in which he showed +a young and ardent zeal for setting the world to rights, together with +that high sense of the poet’s calling which put lasting force into his +work. He poured contempt on those who frittered life away. He urged on +the poetasters and the mincing courtiers, who set their hearts on +top-knots and affected movements of their lips and legs:— + + “That these vain joys in which their wills consume + Such powers of wit and soul as are of force + To raise their beings to eternity, + May be converted on works fitting men; + And for the practice of a forcéd look, + An antic gesture, or a fustian phrase, + Study the native frame of a true heart, + An inward comeliness of bounty, knowledge, + And spirit that may conform them actually + To God’s high figures, which they have in power.” + +Ben Jonson’s genius was producing its best work in the earlier years of +the reign of James I. His _Volpone_, the _Silent Woman_, and the +_Alchemist_ first appeared side by side with some of the ripest works of +Shakespeare in the years from 1605 to 1610. In the latter part of +James’s reign he produced masques for the Court, and turned with distaste +from the public stage. When Charles I. became king, Ben Jonson was +weakened in health by a paralytic stroke. He returned to the stage for a +short time through necessity, but found his best friends in the best of +the young poets of the day. These looked up to him as their father and +their guide. Their own best efforts seemed best to them when they had +won Ben Jonson’s praise. They valued above all passing honours man could +give the words, “My son,” in the old poet’s greeting, which, as they +said, “sealed them of the tribe of Ben.” + + H. M. + + + + +SYLVA + + +_Rerum et sententiarum quasi Ὕλη dicta a multiplici materia et varietate +in iis contentá_. _Quemadmodùm enim vulgò solemus infinitam arborum +nascentium indiscriminatim multitudinem Sylvam dicere: ità etiam libros +suos in quibus variæ et diversæ materiæ opuscula temere congesta erant_, +Sylvas _appellabant antiqui_: Timber-trees. + + + + +TIMBER; +OR, +DISCOVERIES MADE UPON MEN AND MATTER, +AS THEY HAVE FLOWED OUT OF HIS DAILY READINGS, +OR HAD THEIR REFLUX TO HIS PECULIAR +NOTION OF THE TIMES. + + + _Tecum habita_, _ut nôris quam sit tibi curta supellex_ {11} + + PERS. Sat. 4. + +_Fortuna_.—Ill fortune never crushed that man whom good fortune deceived +not. I therefore have counselled my friends never to trust to her fairer +side, though she seemed to make peace with them; but to place all things +she gave them, so as she might ask them again without their trouble, she +might take them from them, not pull them: to keep always a distance +between her and themselves. He knows not his own strength that hath not +met adversity. Heaven prepares good men with crosses; but no ill can +happen to a good man. Contraries are not mixed. Yet that which happens +to any man may to every man. But it is in his reason, what he accounts +it and will make it. + +_Casus_.—Change into extremity is very frequent and easy. As when a +beggar suddenly grows rich, he commonly becomes a prodigal; for, to +obscure his former obscurity, he puts on riot and excess. + +_Consilia_.—No man is so foolish but may give another good counsel +sometimes; and no man is so wise but may easily err, if he will take no +others’ counsel but his own. But very few men are wise by their own +counsel, or learned by their own teaching. For he that was only taught +by himself {12} had a fool to his master. + +_Fama_.—A Fame that is wounded to the world would be better cured by +another’s apology than its own: for few can apply medicines well +themselves. Besides, the man that is once hated, both his good and his +evil deeds oppress him. He is not easily emergent. + +_Negotia_.—In great affairs it is a work of difficulty to please all. +And ofttimes we lose the occasions of carrying a business well and +thoroughly by our too much haste. For passions are spiritual rebels, and +raise sedition against the understanding. + +_Amor patriæ_.—There is a necessity all men should love their country: he +that professeth the contrary may be delighted with his words, but his +heart is there. + +_Ingenia_.—Natures that are hardened to evil you shall sooner break than +make straight; they are like poles that are crooked and dry, there is no +attempting them. + +_Applausus_.—We praise the things we hear with much more willingness than +those we see, because we envy the present and reverence the past; +thinking ourselves instructed by the one, and overlaid by the other. + +_Opinio_.—Opinion is a light, vain, crude, and imperfect thing; settled +in the imagination, but never arriving at the understanding, there to +obtain the tincture of reason. We labour with it more than truth. There +is much more holds us than presseth us. An ill fact is one thing, an ill +fortune is another; yet both oftentimes sway us alike, by the error of +our thinking. + +_Impostura_.—Many men believe not themselves what they would persuade +others; and less do the things which they would impose on others; but +least of all know what they themselves most confidently boast. Only they +set the sign of the cross over their outer doors, and sacrifice to their +gut and their groin in their inner closets. + +_Jactura vitæ_.—What a deal of cold business doth a man misspend the +better part of life in! in scattering compliments, tendering visits, +gathering and venting news, following feasts and plays, making a little +winter-love in a dark corner. + +Hypocrita.—_Puritanus Hypocrita est Hæreticus_, _quem opinio propriæ +perspicaciæ_, _quâ sibi videtur_, _cum paucis in Ecclesiâ dogmatibus +errores quosdam animadvertisse_, _de statu mentis deturbavit: unde sacro +furore percitus_, _phrenetice pugnat contra magistratus_, _sic ratus +obedientiam præstare Deo_. {14} + +_Mutua auxilia_.—Learning needs rest: sovereignty gives it. Sovereignty +needs counsel: learning affords it. There is such a consociation of +offices between the prince and whom his favour breeds, that they may help +to sustain his power as he their knowledge. It is the greatest part of +his liberality, his favour; and from whom doth he hear discipline more +willingly, or the arts discoursed more gladly, than from those whom his +own bounty and benefits have made able and faithful? + +_Cognit. univers_.—In being able to counsel others, a man must be +furnished with a universal store in himself, to the knowledge of all +nature—that is, the matter and seed-plot: there are the seats of all +argument and invention. But especially you must be cunning in the nature +of man: there is the variety of things which are as the elements and +letters, which his art and wisdom must rank and order to the present +occasion. For we see not all letters in single words, nor all places in +particular discourses. That cause seldom happens wherein a man will use +all arguments. + +_Consiliarii adjunct_. _Probitas_, _Sapientia_.—The two chief things +that give a man reputation in counsel are the opinion of his honesty and +the opinion of his wisdom: the authority of those two will persuade when +the same counsels uttered by other persons less qualified are of no +efficacy or working. + +_Vita recta_.—Wisdom without honesty is mere craft and cozenage. And +therefore the reputation of honesty must first be gotten, which cannot be +but by living well. A good life is a main argument. + +_Obsequentia_.—_Humanitas_.—_Solicitudo_.—Next a good life, to beget love +in the persons we counsel, by dissembling our knowledge of ability in +ourselves, and avoiding all suspicion of arrogance, ascribing all to +their instruction, as an ambassador to his master, or a subject to his +sovereign; seasoning all with humanity and sweetness, only expressing +care and solicitude. And not to counsel rashly, or on the sudden, but +with advice and meditation. (_Dat nox consilium_. {17a}) For many +foolish things fall from wise men, if they speak in haste or be +extemporal. It therefore behoves the giver of counsel to be circumspect; +especially to beware of those with whom he is not thoroughly acquainted, +lest any spice of rashness, folly, or self-love appear, which will be +marked by new persons and men of experience in affairs. + +_Modestia_.—_Parrhesia_.—And to the prince, or his superior, to behave +himself modestly and with respect. Yet free from flattery or empire. +Not with insolence or precept; but as the prince were already furnished +with the parts he should have, especially in affairs of state. For in +other things they will more easily suffer themselves to be taught or +reprehended: they will not willingly contend, but hear, with Alexander, +the answer the musician gave him: _Absit_, _o rex_, _ut tu meliùs hæc +scias_, _quàm ego_. {17b} + +_Perspicuitas_.—_Elegantia_.—A man should so deliver himself to the +nature of the subject whereof he speaks, that his hearer may take +knowledge of his discipline with some delight; and so apparel fair and +good matter, that the studious of elegancy be not defrauded; redeem arts +from their rough and braky seats, where they lay hid and overgrown with +thorns, to a pure, open, and flowery light, where they may take the eye +and be taken by the hand. + +_Natura non effæta_.—I cannot think Nature is so spent and decayed that +she can bring forth nothing worth her former years. She is always the +same, like herself; and when she collects her strength is abler still. +Men are decayed, and studies: she is not. + +_Non nimiùm credendum antiquitati_.—I know nothing can conduce more to +letters than to examine the writings of the ancients, and not to rest in +their sole authority, or take all upon trust from them, provided the +plagues of judging and pronouncing against them be away; such as are +envy, bitterness, precipitation, impudence, and scurrilous scoffing. For +to all the observations of the ancients we have our own experience, which +if we will use and apply, we have better means to pronounce. It is true +they opened the gates, and made the way that went before us, but as +guides, not commanders: _Non domini nostri_, _sed duces fuêre_. {19a} +Truth lies open to all; it is no man’s several. _Patet omnibus veritas_; +_nondum est occupata_. _Multum ex illâ_, _etiam futuris relicta est_. +{19b} + +_Dissentire licet_, _sed cum ratione_.—If in some things I dissent from +others, whose wit, industry, diligence, and judgment, I look up at and +admire, let me not therefore hear presently of ingratitude and rashness. +For I thank those that have taught me, and will ever; but yet dare not +think the scope of their labour and inquiry was to envy their posterity +what they also could add and find out. + +_Non mihi credendum sed veritati_.—If I err, pardon me: _Nulla ars simul +et inventa est et absoluta_. {19c} I do not desire to be equal to those +that went before; but to have my reason examined with theirs, and so much +faith to be given them, or me, as those shall evict. I am neither author +nor fautor of any sect. I will have no man addict himself to me; but if +I have anything right, defend it as Truth’s, not mine, save as it +conduceth to a common good. It profits not me to have any man fence or +fight for me, to flourish, or take my side. Stand for truth, and ’tis +enough. + +_Scientiæ liberales_.—Arts that respect the mind were ever reputed nobler +than those that serve the body, though we less can be without them, as +tillage, spinning, weaving, building, &c., without which we could scarce +sustain life a day. But these were the works of every hand; the other of +the brain only, and those the most generous and exalted wits and spirits, +that cannot rest or acquiesce. The mind of man is still fed with labour: +_Opere pascitur_. + +_Non vulgi sunt_.—There is a more secret cause, and the power of liberal +studies lies more hid than that it can be wrought out by profane wits. +It is not every man’s way to hit. There are men, I confess, that set the +carat and value upon things as they love them; but science is not every +man’s mistress. It is as great a spite to be praised in the wrong place, +and by a wrong person, as can be done to a noble nature. + +_Honesta ambitio_.—If divers men seek fame or honour by divers ways, so +both be honest, neither is to be blamed; but they that seek immortality +are not only worthy of love, but of praise. + +_Maritus improbus_.—He hath a delicate wife, a fair fortune, a family to +go to and be welcome; yet he had rather be drunk with mine host and the +fiddlers of such a town, than go home. + +_Afflictio pia magistra_.—Affliction teacheth a wicked person some time +to pray: prosperity never. + +_Deploratis facilis descensus Averni_.—_The devil take all_.—Many might +go to heaven with half the labour they go to hell, if they would venture +their industry the right way; but “The devil take all!” quoth he that was +choked in the mill-dam, with his four last words in his mouth. + +_Ægidius cursu superat_.—A cripple in the way out-travels a footman or a +post out of the way. + +_Prodigo nummi nauci_.—Bags of money to a prodigal person are the same +that cherry-stones are with some boys, and so thrown away. + +_Munda et sordida_.—A woman, the more curious she is about her face is +commonly the more careless about her house. + +_Debitum deploratum_.—Of this spilt water there is a little to be +gathered up: it is a desperate debt. + +_Latro sesquipedalis_.—The thief {22} that had a longing at the gallows +to commit one robbery more before he was hanged. + +And like the German lord, when he went out of Newgate into the cart, took +order to have his arms set up in his last herborough: said was he taken +and committed upon suspicion of treason, no witness appearing against +him; but the judges entertained him most civilly, discoursed with him, +offered him the courtesy of the rack; but he confessed, &c. + +_Calumniæ fructus_.—I am beholden to calumny, that she hath so +endeavoured and taken pains to belie me. It shall make me set a surer +guard on myself, and keep a better watch upon my actions. + +_Impertinens_.—A tedious person is one a man would leap a steeple from, +gallop down any steep lull to avoid him; forsake his meat, sleep, nature +itself, with all her benefits, to shun him. A mere impertinent; one that +touched neither heaven nor earth in his discourse. He opened an entry +into a fair room, but shut it again presently. I spoke to him of garlic, +he answered asparagus; consulted him of marriage, he tells me of hanging, +as if they went by one and the same destiny. + +_Bellum scribentium_.—What a sight it is to see writers committed +together by the ears for ceremonies, syllables, points, colons, commas, +hyphens, and the like, fighting as for their fires and their altars; and +angry that none are frighted at their noises and loud brayings under +their asses’ skins. + +There is hope of getting a fortune without digging in these quarries. +_Sed meliore (in omne) ingenio animoque quàm fortunâ_, _sum usus_. {23} + +“Pingue solum lassat; sed juvat ipse labor.” {24a} + +_Differentia inter doctos et sciolos_.—Wits made out their several +expeditions then for the discovery of truth, to find out great and +profitable knowledges; had their several instruments for the disquisition +of arts. Now there are certain scioli or smatterers that are busy in the +skirts and outsides of learning, and have scarce anything of solid +literature to commend them. They may have some edging or trimming of a +scholar, a welt or so; but it is no more. + +_Impostorum fucus_.—Imposture is a specious thing, yet never worse than +when it feigns to be best, and to none discovered sooner than the +simplest. For truth and goodness are plain and open; but imposture is +ever ashamed of the light. + +_Icunculorum motio_.—A puppet-play must be shadowed and seen in the dark; +for draw the curtain, _et sordet gesticulatio_. {24b} + +_Principes et administri_.—There is a great difference in the +understanding of some princes, as in the quality of their ministers about +them. Some would dress their masters in gold, pearl, and all true jewels +of majesty; others furnish them with feathers, bells, and ribands, and +are therefore esteemed the fitter servants. But they are ever good men +that must make good the times; if the men be naught, the times will be +such. _Finis exspectandus est in unoquoque hominum_; _animali ad +mutationem promptissmo_. {25a} + +_Scitum Hispanicum_.—It is a quick saying with the Spaniards, _Artes +inter hæredes non dividi_. {25b} Yet these have inherited their fathers’ +lying, and they brag of it. He is a narrow-minded man that affects a +triumph in any glorious study; but to triumph in a lie, and a lie +themselves have forged, is frontless. Folly often goes beyond her +bounds; but Impudence knows none. + +_Non nova res livor_.—Envy is no new thing, nor was it born only in our +times. The ages past have brought it forth, and the coming ages will. +So long as there are men fit for it, _quorum odium virtute relictâ +placet_, it will never be wanting. It is a barbarous envy, to take from +those men’s virtues which, because thou canst not arrive at, thou +impotently despairest to imitate. Is it a crime in me that I know that +which others had not yet known but from me? or that I am the author of +many things which never would have come in thy thought but that I taught +them? It is new but a foolish way you have found out, that whom you +cannot equal or come near in doing, you would destroy or ruin with evil +speaking; as if you had bound both your wits and natures ’prentices to +slander, and then came forth the best artificers when you could form the +foulest calumnies. + +_Nil gratius protervo lib_.—Indeed nothing is of more credit or request +now than a petulant paper, or scoffing verses; and it is but convenient +to the times and manners we live with, to have then the worst writings +and studies flourish when the best begin to be despised. Ill arts begin +where good end. + +_Jam literæ sordent_.—_Pastus hodiern. ingen_.—The time was when men +would learn and study good things, not envy those that had them. Then +men were had in price for learning; now letters only make men vile. He +is upbraidingly called a poet, as if it were a contemptible nick-name: +but the professors, indeed, have made the learning cheap—railing and +tinkling rhymers, whose writings the vulgar more greedily read, as being +taken with the scurrility and petulancy of such wits. He shall not have +a reader now unless he jeer and lie. It is the food of men’s natures; +the diet of the times; gallants cannot sleep else. The writer must lie +and the gentle reader rests happy to hear the worthiest works +misinterpreted, the clearest actions obscured, the innocentest life +traduced: and in such a licence of lying, a field so fruitful of +slanders, how can there be matter wanting to his laughter? Hence comes +the epidemical infection; for how can they escape the contagion of the +writings, whom the virulency of the calumnies hath not staved off from +reading? + +_Sed seculi morbus_.—Nothing doth more invite a greedy reader than an +unlooked-for subject. And what more unlooked-for than to see a person of +an unblamed life made ridiculous or odious by the artifice of lying? But +it is the disease of the age; and no wonder if the world, growing old, +begin to be infirm: old age itself is a disease. It is long since the +sick world began to dote and talk idly: would she had but doted still! +but her dotage is now broke forth into a madness, and become a mere +frenzy. + +_Alastoris malitia_.—This Alastor, who hath left nothing unsearched or +unassailed by his impudent and licentious lying in his aguish writings +(for he was in his cold quaking fit all the while), what hath he done +more than a troublesome base cur? barked and made a noise afar off; had a +fool or two to spit in his mouth, and cherish him with a musty bone? But +they are rather enemies of my fame than me, these barkers. + +_Mali Choragi fuere_.—It is an art to have so much judgment as to apparel +a lie well, to give it a good dressing; that though the nakedness would +show deformed and odious, the suiting of it might draw their readers. +Some love any strumpet, be she never so shop-like or meretricious, in +good clothes. But these, nature could not have formed them better to +destroy their own testimony and overthrow their calumny. + +_Hear-say news_.—That an elephant, in 1630, came hither ambassador from +the Great Mogul, who could both write and read, and was every day allowed +twelve cast of bread, twenty quarts of Canary sack, besides nuts and +almonds the citizens’ wives sent him. That he had a Spanish boy to his +interpreter, and his chief negociation was to confer or practise with +Archy, the principal fool of state, about stealing hence Windsor Castle +and carrying it away on his back if he can. + +_Lingua sapientis_, _potius quâm loquentis_.—A wise tongue should not be +licentious and wandering; but moved and, as it were, governed with +certain reins from the heart and bottom of the breast: and it was +excellently said of that philosopher, that there was a wall or parapet of +teeth set in our mouth, to restrain the petulancy of our words; that the +rashness of talking should not only be retarded by the guard and watch of +our heart, but be fenced in and defended by certain strengths placed in +the mouth itself, and within the lips. But you shall see some so abound +with words, without any seasoning or taste of matter, in so profound a +security, as while they are speaking, for the most part they confess to +speak they know not what. + +Of the two (if either were to be wished) I would rather have a plain +downright wisdom, than a foolish and affected eloquence. For what is so +furious and Bedlam like as a vain sound of chosen and excellent words, +without any subject of sentence or science mixed? + +_Optanda_.—_Thersites Homeri_.—Whom the disease of talking still once +possesseth, he can never hold his peace. Nay, rather than he will not +discourse he will hire men to hear him. And so heard, not hearkened +unto, he comes off most times like a mountebank, that when he hath +praised his medicines, finds none will take them, or trust him. He is +like Homer’s _Thersites_. + +Άμετροεπης, ακριτόμυθος; speaking without judgement or measure. + + “Loquax magis, quàm facundus, + Satis loquentiæ, sapientiæ parum.{31a} + Γλωσσης τοι θησαυρος εν ανθρωποισιν αριστος + φειδωλης, πλειστη δε χαρις κατα μετρον ιουσης. {31b} + Optimus est homini linguæ thesaurus, et ingens + Gratia, quæ parcis mensurat singula verbis.” + +_Homeri Ulysses_.—_Demacatus Plutarchi_.—Ulysses, in Homer, is made a +long-thinking man before he speaks; and Epaminondas is celebrated by +Pindar to be a man that, though he knew much, yet he spoke but little. +Demacatus, when on the bench he was long silent and said nothing, one +asking him if it were folly in him, or want of language, he answered, “A +fool could never hold his peace.” {31c} For too much talking is ever the +index of a fool. + + “Dum tacet indoctus, poterit cordatus haberi; + Is morbos animi namque tacendo tegit.” {32a} + +Nor is that worthy speech of Zeno the philosopher to be passed over with +the note of ignorance; who being invited to a feast in Athens, where a +great prince’s ambassadors were entertained, and was the only person that +said nothing at the table; one of them with courtesy asked him, “What +shall we return from thee, Zeno, to the prince our master, if he asks us +of thee?” “Nothing,” he replied, “more but that you found an old man in +Athens that knew to be silent amongst his cups.” It was near a miracle +to see an old man silent, since talking is the disease of age; but +amongst cups makes it fully a wonder. + +_Argute dictum_.—It was wittily said upon one that was taken for a great +and grave man so long as he held his peace, “This man might have been a +counsellor of state, till he spoke; but having spoken, not the beadle of +the ward.” Εχεμυθια. {32b} Pytag. quàm laudabilis! γλωσσης προ των +αλλων κρατει, θεοις επομενος. Linguam cohibe, præ aliis omnibus, ad +deorum exemplum. {33a} Digito compesce labellum. {33b} + +_Acutius cernuntur vitia quam virtutes_.—There is almost no man but he +sees clearlier and sharper the vices in a speaker, than the virtues. And +there are many, that with more ease will find fault with what is spoken +foolishly than can give allowance to that wherein you are wise silently. +The treasure of a fool is always in his tongue, said the witty comic +poet; {33c} and it appears not in anything more than in that nation, +whereof one, when he had got the inheritance of an unlucky old grange, +would needs sell it; {33d} and to draw buyers proclaimed the virtues of +it. Nothing ever thrived on it, saith he. No owner of it ever died in +his bed; some hung, some drowned themselves; some were banished, some +starved; the trees were all blasted; the swine died of the measles, the +cattle of the murrain, the sheep of the rot; they that stood were ragged, +bare, and bald as your hand; nothing was ever reared there, not a +duckling, or a goose. _Hospitium fuerat calamitatis_. {34a} Was not +this man like to sell it? + +_Vulgi expectatio_.—Expectation of the vulgar is more drawn and held with +newness than goodness; we see it in fencers, in players, in poets, in +preachers, in all where fame promiseth anything; so it be new, though +never so naught and depraved, they run to it, and are taken. Which +shews, that the only decay or hurt of the best men’s reputation with the +people is, their wits have out-lived the people’s palates. They have +been too much or too long a feast. + +_Claritas patriæ_.—Greatness of name in the father oft-times helps not +forth, but overwhelms the son; they stand too near one another. The +shadow kills the growth: so much, that we see the grandchild come more +and oftener to be heir of the first, than doth the second: he dies +between; the possession is the third’s. + +_Eloquentia_.—Eloquence is a great and diverse thing: nor did she yet +ever favour any man so much as to become wholly his. He is happy that +can arrive to any degree of her grace. Yet there are who prove +themselves masters of her, and absolute lords; but I believe they may +mistake their evidence: for it is one thing to be eloquent in the +schools, or in the hall; another at the bar, or in the pulpit. There is +a difference between mooting and pleading; between fencing and fighting. +To make arguments in my study, and confute them, is easy; where I answer +myself, not an adversary. So I can see whole volumes dispatched by the +umbratical doctors on all sides: but draw these forth into the just +lists: let them appear _sub dio_, and they are changed with the place, +like bodies bred in the shade; they cannot suffer the sun or a shower, +nor bear the open air; they scarce can find themselves, that they were +wont to domineer so among their auditors: but indeed I would no more +choose a rhetorician for reigning in a school, than I would a pilot for +rowing in a pond. + +_Amor et odium_.—Love that is ignorant, and hatred, have almost the same +ends: many foolish lovers wish the same to their friends, which their +enemies would: as to wish a friend banished, that they might accompany +him in exile; or some great want, that they might relieve him; or a +disease, that they might sit by him. They make a causeway to their +country by injury, as if it were not honester to do nothing than to seek +a way to do good by a mischief. + +_Injuria_.—Injuries do not extinguish courtesies: they only suffer them +not to appear fair. For a man that doth me an injury after a courtesy, +takes not away that courtesy, but defaces it: as he that writes other +verses upon my verses, takes not away the first letters, but hides them. + +_Beneficia_.—Nothing is a courtesy unless it be meant us; and that +friendly and lovingly. We owe no thanks to rivers, that they carry our +boats; or winds, that they be favouring and fill our sails; or meats, +that they be nourishing. For these are what they are necessarily. +Horses carry us, trees shade us, but they know it not. It is true, some +men may receive a courtesy and not know it; but never any man received it +from him that knew it not. Many men have been cured of diseases by +accidents; but they were not remedies. I myself have known one helped of +an ague by falling into a water; another whipped out of a fever; but no +man would ever use these for medicines. It is the mind, and not the +event, that distinguisheth the courtesy from wrong. My adversary may +offend the judge with his pride and impertinences, and I win my cause; +but he meant it not to me as a courtesy. I scaped pirates by being +shipwrecked; was the wreck a benefit therefore? No; the doing of +courtesies aright is the mixing of the respects for his own sake and for +mine. He that doeth them merely for his own sake is like one that feeds +his cattle to sell them; he hath his horse well dressed for Smithfield. + +_Valor rerum_.—The price of many things is far above what they are bought +and sold for. Life and health, which are both inestimable, we have of +the physician; as learning and knowledge, the true tillage of the mind, +from our schoolmasters. But the fees of the one or the salary of the +other never answer the value of what we received, but served to gratify +their labours. + +_Memoria_.—Memory, of all the powers of the mind, is the most delicate +and frail; it is the first of our faculties that age invades. Seneca, +the father, the rhetorician, confesseth of himself he had a miraculous +one, not only to receive but to hold. I myself could, in my youth, have +repeated all that ever I had made, and so continued till I was past +forty; since, it is much decayed in me. Yet I can repeat whole books +that I have read, and poems of some selected friends which I have liked +to charge my memory with. It was wont to be faithful to me; but shaken +with age now, and sloth, which weakens the strongest abilities, it may +perform somewhat, but cannot promise much. By exercise it is to be made +better and serviceable. Whatsoever I pawned with it while I was young +and a boy, it offers me readily, and without stops; but what I trust to +it now, or have done of later years, it lays up more negligently, and +oftentimes loses; so that I receive mine own (though frequently called +for) as if it were new and borrowed. Nor do I always find presently from +it what I seek; but while I am doing another thing, that I laboured for +will come; and what I sought with trouble will offer itself when I am +quiet. Now, in some men I have found it as happy as Nature, who, +whatsoever they read or pen, they can say without book presently, as if +they did then write in their mind. And it is more a wonder in such as +have a swift style, for their memories are commonly slowest; such as +torture their writings, and go into council for every word, must needs +fix somewhat, and make it their own at last, though but through their own +vexation. + +_Comit. suffragia_.—Suffrages in Parliament are numbered, not weighed; +nor can it be otherwise in those public councils where nothing is so +unequal as the equality; for there, how odd soever men’s brains or +wisdoms are, their power is always even and the same. + +_Stare à partibus_.—Some actions, be they never so beautiful and +generous, are often obscured by base and vile misconstructions, either +out of envy or ill-nature, that judgeth of others as of itself. Nay, the +times are so wholly grown to be either partial or malicious, that if he +be a friend all sits well about him, his very vices shall be virtues; if +an enemy, or of the contrary faction, nothing is good or tolerable in +him; insomuch that we care not to discredit and shame our judgments to +soothe our passions. + +_Deus in creaturis_.—Man is read in his face; God in His creatures; not +as the philosopher, the creature of glory, reads him; but as the divine, +the servant of humility; yet even he must take care not to be too +curious. For to utter truth of God but as he thinks only, may be +dangerous, who is best known by our not knowing. Some things of Him, so +much as He hath revealed or commanded, it is not only lawful but +necessary for us to know; for therein our ignorance was the first cause +of our wickedness. + +_Veritas proprium hominis_.—Truth is man’s proper good, and the only +immortal thing was given to our mortality to use. No good Christian or +ethnic, if he be honest, can miss it; no statesman or patriot should. +For without truth all the actions of mankind are craft, malice, or what +you will, rather than wisdom. Homer says he hates him worse than +hell-mouth that utters one thing with his tongue and keeps another in his +breast. Which high expression was grounded on divine reason; for a lying +mouth is a stinking pit, and murders with the contagion it venteth. +Beside, nothing is lasting that is feigned; it will have another face +than it had, ere long. {41} As Euripides saith, “No lie ever grows old.” + +_Nullum vitium sine patrocinio_.—It is strange there should be no vice +without its patronage, that when we have no other excuse we will say, we +love it, we cannot forsake it. As if that made it not more a fault. We +cannot, because we think we cannot, and we love it because we will defend +it. We will rather excuse it than be rid of it. That we cannot is +pretended; but that we will not is the true reason. How many have I +known that would not have their vices hid? nay, and, to be noted, live +like Antipodes to others in the same city? never see the sun rise or set +in so many years, but be as they were watching a corpse by torch-light; +would not sin the common way, but held that a kind of rusticity; they +would do it new, or contrary, for the infamy; they were ambitious of +living backward; and at last arrived at that, as they would love nothing +but the vices, not the vicious customs. It was impossible to reform +these natures; they were dried and hardened in their ill. They may say +they desired to leave it, but do not trust them; and they may think they +desire it, but they may lie for all that; they are a little angry with +their follies now and then; marry, they come into grace with them again +quickly. They will confess they are offended with their manner of living +like enough; who is not? When they can put me in security that they are +more than offended, that they hate it, then I will hearken to them, and +perhaps believe them; but many now-a-days love and hate their ill +together. + +_De vere argutis_.—I do hear them say often some men are not witty, +because they are not everywhere witty; than which nothing is more +foolish. If an eye or a nose be an excellent part in the face, therefore +be all eye or nose! I think the eyebrow, the forehead, the cheek, chin, +lip, or any part else are as necessary and natural in the place. But now +nothing is good that is natural; right and natural language seems to have +least of the wit in it; that which is writhed and tortured is counted the +more exquisite. Cloth of bodkin or tissue must be embroidered; as if no +face were fair that were not powdered or painted! no beauty to be had but +in wresting and writhing our own tongue! Nothing is fashionable till it +be deformed; and this is to write like a gentleman. All must be affected +and preposterous as our gallants’ clothes, sweet-bags, and +night-dressings, in which you would think our men lay in, like ladies, it +is so curious. + +_Censura de poetis_.—Nothing in our age, I have observed, is more +preposterous than the running judgments upon poetry and poets; when we +shall hear those things commended and cried up for the best writings +which a man would scarce vouchsafe to wrap any wholesome drug in; he +would never light his tobacco with them. And those men almost named for +miracles, who yet are so vile that if a man should go about to examine +and correct them, he must make all they have done but one blot. Their +good is so entangled with their bad as forcibly one must draw on the +other’s death with it. A sponge dipped in ink will do all:— + + “—Comitetur Punica librum + Spongia.—” {44a} + +Et paulò post, + + “Non possunt . . . multæ . . . lituræ + . . . una litura potest.” + +_Cestius_—_Cicero_—_Heath_—_Taylor_—_Spenser_.—Yet their vices have not +hurt them; nay, a great many they have profited, for they have been loved +for nothing else. And this false opinion grows strong against the best +men, if once it take root with the ignorant. Cestius, in his time, was +preferred to Cicero, so far as the ignorant durst. They learned him +without book, and had him often in their mouths; but a man cannot imagine +that thing so foolish or rude but will find and enjoy an admirer; at +least a reader or spectator. The puppets are seen now in despite of the +players; Heath’s epigrams and the Sculler’s poems have their applause. +There are never wanting that dare prefer the worst preachers, the worst +pleaders, the worst poets; not that the better have left to write or +speak better, but that they that hear them judge worse; _Non illi pejus +dicunt_, _sed hi corruptius judicant_. Nay, if it were put to the +question of the water-rhymer’s works, against Spenser’s, I doubt not but +they would find more suffrages; because the most favour common vices, out +of a prerogative the vulgar have to lose their judgments and like that +which is naught. + +Poetry, in this latter age, hath proved but a mean mistress to such as +have wholly addicted themselves to her, or given their names up to her +family. They who have but saluted her on the by, and now and then +tendered their visits, she hath done much for, and advanced in the way of +their own professions (both the law and the gospel) beyond all they could +have hoped or done for themselves without her favour. Wherein she doth +emulate the judicious but preposterous bounty of the time’s grandees, who +accumulate all they can upon the parasite or fresh-man in their +friendship; but think an old client or honest servant bound by his place +to write and starve. + +Indeed, the multitude commend writers as they do fencers or wrestlers, +who if they come in robustiously and put for it with a deal of violence +are received for the braver fellows; when many times their own rudeness +is a cause of their disgrace, and a slight touch of their adversary gives +all that boisterous force the foil. But in these things the unskilful +are naturally deceived, and judging wholly by the bulk, think rude things +greater than polished, and scattered more numerous than composed; nor +think this only to be true in the sordid multitude, but the neater sort +of our gallants; for all are the multitude, only they differ in clothes, +not in judgment or understanding. + +_De Shakspeare nostrat_.—_Augustus in Hat_.—I remember the players have +often mentioned it as an honour to Shakspeare, that in his writing +(whatsoever he penned) he never blotted out a line. My answer hath been, +“Would he had blotted a thousand,” which they thought a malevolent +speech. I had not told posterity this but for their ignorance who chose +that circumstance to commend their friend by wherein he most faulted; and +to justify mine own candour, for I loved the man, and do honour his +memory on this side idolatry as much as any. He was, indeed, honest, and +of an open and free nature, had an excellent phantasy, brave notions, and +gentle expressions, wherein he flowed with that facility that sometimes +it was necessary he should be stopped. “_Sufflaminandus erat_,” {47a} as +Augustus said of Haterius. His wit was in his own power; would the rule +of it had been so, too. Many times he fell into those things, could not +escape laughter, as when he said in the person of Cæsar, one speaking to +him, “Cæsar, thou dost me wrong.” He replied, “Cæsar did never wrong but +with just cause;” and such like, which were ridiculous. But he redeemed +his vices with his virtues. There was ever more in him to be praised +than to be pardoned. + +_Ingeniorum discrimina_.—_Not._ 1.—In the difference of wits I have +observed there are many notes; and it is a little maistry to know them, +to discern what every nature, every disposition will bear; for before we +sow our land we should plough it. There are no fewer forms of minds than +of bodies amongst us. The variety is incredible, and therefore we must +search. Some are fit to make divines, some poets, some lawyers, some +physicians; some to be sent to the plough, and trades. + +There is no doctrine will do good where nature is wanting. Some wits are +swelling and high; others low and still; some hot and fiery; others cold +and dull; one must have a bridle, the other a spur. + +_Not._ 2.—There be some that are forward and bold; and these will do +every little thing easily. I mean that is hard by and next them, which +they will utter unretarded without any shamefastness. These never +perform much, but quickly. They are what they are on the sudden; they +show presently, like grain that, scattered on the top of the ground, +shoots up, but takes no root; has a yellow blade, but the ear empty. +They are wits of good promise at first, but there is an _ingenistitium_; +{49a} they stand still at sixteen, they get no higher. + +_Not._ 3.—You have others that labour only to ostentation; and are ever +more busy about the colours and surface of a work than in the matter and +foundation, for that is hid, the other is seen. + +_Not._ 4.—Others that in composition are nothing but what is rough and +broken. _Quæ per salebras_, _altaque saxa cadunt_. {49b} And if it +would come gently, they trouble it of purpose. They would not have it +run without rubs, as if that style were more strong and manly that struck +the ear with a kind of unevenness. These men err not by chance, but +knowingly and willingly; they are like men that affect a fashion by +themselves; have some singularity in a ruff cloak, or hat-band; or their +beards specially cut to provoke beholders, and set a mark upon +themselves. They would be reprehended while they are looked on. And +this vice, one that is authority with the rest, loving, delivers over to +them to be imitated; so that ofttimes the faults which be fell into the +others seek for. This is the danger, when vice becomes a precedent. + +_Not._ 5.—Others there are that have no composition at all; but a kind of +tuning and rhyming fall in what they write. It runs and slides, and only +makes a sound. Women’s poets they are called, as you have women’s +tailors. + + “They write a verse as smooth, as soft as cream, + In which there is no torrent, nor scarce stream.” + +You may sound these wits and find the depth of them with your middle +finger. They are cream-bowl or but puddle-deep. + +_Not._ 6.—Some that turn over all books, and are equally searching in all +papers; that write out of what they presently find or meet, without +choice. By which means it happens that what they have discredited and +impugned in one week, they have before or after extolled the same in +another. Such are all the essayists, even their master Montaigne. +These, in all they write, confess still what books they have read last, +and therein their own folly so much, that they bring it to the stake raw +and undigested; not that the place did need it neither, but that they +thought themselves furnished and would vent it. + +_Not._ 7.—Some, again who, after they have got authority, or, which is +less, opinion, by their writings, to have read much, dare presently to +feign whole books and authors, and lie safely. For what never was, will +not easily be found, not by the most curious. + +_Not._ 8.—And some, by a cunning protestation against all reading, and +false venditation of their own naturals, think to divert the sagacity of +their readers from themselves, and cool the scent of their own fox-like +thefts; when yet they are so rank, as a man may find whole pages together +usurped from one author; their necessities compelling them to read for +present use, which could not be in many books; and so come forth more +ridiculously and palpably guilty than those who, because they cannot +trace, they yet would slander their industry. + +_Not._ 9.—But the wretcheder are the obstinate contemners of all helps +and arts; such as presuming on their own naturals (which, perhaps, are +excellent), dare deride all diligence, and seem to mock at the terms when +they understand not the things; thinking that way to get off wittily with +their ignorance. These are imitated often by such as are their peers in +negligence, though they cannot be in nature; and they utter all they can +think with a kind of violence and indisposition, unexamined, without +relation either to person, place, or any fitness else; and the more +wilful and stubborn they are in it the more learned they are esteemed of +the multitude, through their excellent vice of judgment, who think those +things the stronger that have no art; as if to break were better than to +open, or to rend asunder gentler than to loose. + +_Not._ 10.—It cannot but come to pass that these men who commonly seek to +do more than enough may sometimes happen on something that is good and +great; but very seldom: and when it comes it doth not recompense the rest +of their ill. For their jests, and their sentences (which they only and +ambitiously seek for) stick out, and are more eminent, because all is +sordid and vile about them; as lights are more discerned in a thick +darkness than a faint shadow. Now, because they speak all they can +(however unfitly), they are thought to have the greater copy; where the +learned use ever election and a mean, they look back to what they +intended at first, and make all an even and proportioned body. The true +artificer will not run away from Nature as he were afraid of her, or +depart from life and the likeness of truth, but speak to the capacity of +his hearers. And though his language differ from the vulgar somewhat, it +shall not fly from all humanity, with the Tamerlanes and Tamer-chains of +the late age, which had nothing in them but the scenical strutting and +furious vociferation to warrant them to the ignorant gapers. He knows it +is his only art so to carry it, as none but artificers perceive it. In +the meantime, perhaps, he is called barren, dull, lean, a poor writer, or +by what contumelious word can come in their cheeks, by these men who, +without labour, judgment, knowledge, or almost sense, are received or +preferred before him. He gratulates them and their fortune. Another +age, or juster men, will acknowledge the virtues of his studies, his +wisdom in dividing, his subtlety in arguing, with what strength he doth +inspire his readers, with what sweetness he strokes them; in inveighing, +what sharpness; in jest, what urbanity he uses; how he doth reign in +men’s affections; how invade and break in upon them, and makes their +minds like the thing he writes. Then in his elocution to behold what +word is proper, which hath ornaments, which height, what is beautifully +translated, where figures are fit, which gentle, which strong, to show +the composition manly; and how he hath avoided faint, obscure, obscene, +sordid, humble, improper, or effeminate phrase; which is not only praised +of the most, but commended (which is worse), especially for that it is +naught. + +_Ignorantia animæ_.—I know no disease of the soul but ignorance, not of +the arts and sciences, but of itself; yet relating to those it is a +pernicious evil, the darkener of man’s life, the disturber of his reason, +and common confounder of truth, with which a man goes groping in the +dark, no otherwise than if he were blind. Great understandings are most +racked and troubled with it; nay, sometimes they will rather choose to +die than not to know the things they study for. Think, then, what an +evil it is, and what good the contrary. + +_Scientia_.—Knowledge is the action of the soul and is perfect without +the senses, as having the seeds of all science and virtue in itself; but +not without the service of the senses; by these organs the soul works: +she is a perpetual agent, prompt and subtle; but often flexible and +erring, entangling herself like a silkworm, but her reason is a weapon +with two edges, and cuts through. In her indagations oft-times new +scents put her by, and she takes in errors into her by the same conduits +she doth truths. + +_Otium Studiorum_.—Ease and relaxation are profitable to all studies. +The mind is like a bow, the stronger by being unbent. But the temper in +spirits is all, when to command a man’s wit, when to favour it. I have +known a man vehement on both sides, that knew no mean, either to intermit +his studies or call upon them again. When he hath set himself to writing +he would join night to day, press upon himself without release, not +minding it, till he fainted; and when he left off, resolve himself into +all sports and looseness again, that it was almost a despair to draw him +to his book; but once got to it, he grew stronger and more earnest by the +ease. His whole powers were renewed; he would work out of himself what +he desired, but with such excess as his study could not be ruled; he knew +not how to dispose his own abilities, or husband them; he was of that +immoderate power against himself. Nor was he only a strong, but an +absolute speaker and writer; but his subtlety did not show itself; his +judgment thought that a vice; for the ambush hurts more that is hid. He +never forced his language, nor went out of the highway of speaking but +for some great necessity or apparent profit; for he denied figures to be +invented for ornament, but for aid; and still thought it an extreme +madness to bind or wrest that which ought to be right. + +_Stili eminentia_.—_Virgil_.—_Tully_.—_Sallust_.—It is no wonder men’s +eminence appears but in their own way. Virgil’s felicity left him in +prose, as Tully’s forsook him in verse. Sallust’s orations are read in +the honour of story, yet the most eloquent. Plato’s speech, which he +made for Socrates, is neither worthy of the patron nor the person +defended. Nay, in the same kind of oratory, and where the matter is one, +you shall have him that reasons strongly, open negligently; another that +prepares well, not fit so well. And this happens not only to brains, but +to bodies. One can wrestle well, another run well, a third leap or throw +the bar, a fourth lift or stop a cart going; each hath his way of +strength. So in other creatures—some dogs are for the deer, some for the +wild boar, some are fox-hounds, some otter-hounds. Nor are all horses +for the coach or saddle, some are for the cart and paniers. + +_De Claris Oratoribus_.—I have known many excellent men that would speak +suddenly to the admiration of their hearers, who upon study and +premeditation have been forsaken by their own wits, and no way answered +their fame; their eloquence was greater than their reading, and the +things they uttered better than those they knew; their fortune deserved +better of them than their care. For men of present spirits, and of +greater wits than study, do please more in the things they invent than in +those they bring. And I have heard some of them compelled to speak, out +of necessity, that have so infinitely exceeded themselves, as it was +better both for them and their auditory that they were so surprised, not +prepared. Nor was it safe then to cross them, for their adversary, their +anger made them more eloquent. Yet these men I could not but love and +admire, that they returned to their studies. They left not diligence (as +many do) when their rashness prospered; for diligence is a great aid, +even to an indifferent wit; when we are not contented with the examples +of our own age, but would know the face of the former. Indeed, the more +we confer with the more we profit by, if the persons be chosen. + +_Dominus Verulamius_.—One, though he be excellent and the chief, is not +to be imitated alone; for no imitator ever grew up to his author; +likeness is always on this side truth. Yet there happened in my time one +noble speaker who was full of gravity in his speaking; his language +(where he could spare or pass by a jest) was nobly censorious. No man +ever spake more neatly, more pressly, more weightily, or suffered less +emptiness, less idleness, in what he uttered. No member of his speech +but consisted of his own graces. His hearers could not cough, or look +aside from him, without loss. He commanded where he spoke, and had his +judges angry and pleased at his devotion. No man had their affections +more in his power. The fear of every man that heard him was lest he +should make an end. + +_Scriptorum catalogus_. {59a} Cicero is said to be the only wit that the +people of Rome had equalled to their empire. _Ingenium par imperio_. We +have had many, and in their several ages (to take in but the former +_seculum_) Sir Thomas More, the elder Wiat, Henry Earl of Surrey, +Chaloner, Smith, Eliot, B. Gardiner, were for their times admirable; and +the more, because they began eloquence with us. Sir Nicolas Bacon was +singular, and almost alone, in the beginning of Queen Elizabeth’s time. +Sir Philip Sidney and Mr. Hooker (in different matter) grew great masters +of wit and language, and in whom all vigour of invention and strength of +judgment met. The Earl of Essex, noble and high; and Sir Walter Raleigh, +not to be contemned, either for judgment or style. Sir Henry Savile, +grave, and truly lettered; Sir Edwin Sandys, excellent in both; Lord +Egerton, the Chancellor, a grave and great orator, and best when he was +provoked; but his learned and able (though unfortunate) successor is he +who hath filled up all numbers, and performed that in our tongue which +may be compared or preferred either to insolent Greece or haughty Rome. +In short, within his view, and about his times, were all the wits born +that could honour a language or help study. Now things daily fall, wits +grow downward, and eloquence grows backward; so that he may be named and +stand as the mark and ακμη of our language. + +_De augmentis scientiarum_.—_Julius Cæsar_.—_Lord St. Alban_.—I have ever +observed it to have been the office of a wise patriot, among the greatest +affairs of the State, to take care of the commonwealth of learning. For +schools, they are the seminaries of State; and nothing is worthier the +study of a statesman than that part of the republic which we call the +advancement of letters. Witness the care of Julius Cæsar, who, in the +heat of the civil war, writ his books of Analogy, and dedicated them to +Tully. This made the late Lord St. Alban entitle his work _Novum +Organum_; which, though by the most of superficial men, who cannot get +beyond the title of nominals, it is not penetrated nor understood, it +really openeth all defects of learning whatsoever, and is a book + + “Qui longum note scriptori proroget ævum.” {62a} + +My conceit of his person was never increased toward him by his place or +honours; but I have and do reverence him for the greatness that was only +proper to himself, in that he seemed to me ever, by his work, one of the +greatest men, and most worthy of admiration, that had been in many ages. +In his adversity I ever prayed that God would give him strength; for +greatness he could not want. Neither could I condole in a word or +syllable for him, as knowing no accident could do harm to virtue, but +rather help to make it manifest. + +_De corruptela morum_.—There cannot be one colour of the mind, another of +the wit. If the mind be staid, grave, and composed, the wit is so; that +vitiated, the other is blown and deflowered. Do we not see, if the mind +languish, the members are dull? Look upon an effeminate person, his very +gait confesseth him. If a man be fiery, his motion is so; if angry, it +is troubled and violent. So that we may conclude wheresoever manners and +fashions are corrupted, language is. It imitates the public riot. The +excess of feasts and apparel are the notes of a sick state, and the +wantonness of language of a sick mind. + +_De rebus mundanis_.—If we would consider what our affairs are indeed, +not what they are called, we should find more evils belonging to us than +happen to us. How often doth that which was called a calamity prove the +beginning and cause of a man’s happiness? and, on the contrary, that +which happened or came to another with great gratulation and applause, +how it hath lifted him but a step higher to his ruin? as if he stood +before where he might fall safely. + +_Vulgi mores_.—_Morbus comitialis_.—The vulgar are commonly ill-natured, +and always grudging against their governors: which makes that a prince +has more business and trouble with them than ever Hercules had with the +bull or any other beast; by how much they have more heads than will be +reined with one bridle. There was not that variety of beasts in the ark, +as is of beastly natures in the multitude; especially when they come to +that iniquity to censure their sovereign’s actions. Then all the +counsels are made good or bad by the events; and it falleth out that the +same facts receive from them the names, now of diligence, now of vanity, +now of majesty, now of fury; where they ought wholly to hang on his +mouth, as he to consist of himself, and not others’ counsels. + +_Princeps_.—After God, nothing is to be loved of man like the prince; he +violates Nature that doth it not with his whole heart. For when he hath +put on the care of the public good and common safety, I am a wretch, and +put off man, if I do not reverence and honour him, in whose charge all +things divine and human are placed. Do but ask of Nature why all living +creatures are less delighted with meat and drink that sustains them than +with venery that wastes them? and she will tell thee, the first respects +but a private, the other a common good, propagation. + +_De eodem_.—_Orpheus’ Hymn_.—He is the arbiter of life and death: when he +finds no other subject for his mercy, he should spare himself. All his +punishments are rather to correct than to destroy. Why are prayers with +Orpheus said to be the daughters of Jupiter, but that princes are thereby +admonished that the petitions of the wretched ought to have more weight +with them than the laws themselves. + +_De opt. Rege Jacobo_.—It was a great accumulation to His Majesty’s +deserved praise that men might openly visit and pity those whom his +greatest prisons had at any time received or his laws condemned. + +_De Princ. adjunctis_.—_Sed verè prudens haud concipi possit Princeps_, +_nisi simul et bonus_.—_Lycurgus_.—_Sylla_.—_Lysander_.—_Cyrus_.—Wise is +rather the attribute of a prince than learned or good. The learned man +profits others rather than himself; the good man rather himself than +others; but the prince commands others, and doth himself. + +The wise Lycurgus gave no law but what himself kept. Sylla and Lysander +did not so; the one living extremely dissolute himself, enforced +frugality by the laws; the other permitted those licenses to others which +himself abstained from. But the prince’s prudence is his chief art and +safety. In his counsels and deliberations he foresees the future times: +in the equity of his judgment he hath remembrance of the past, and +knowledge of what is to be done or avoided for the present. Hence the +Persians gave out their Cyrus to have been nursed by a bitch, a creature +to encounter it, as of sagacity to seek out good; showing that wisdom may +accompany fortitude, or it leaves to be, and puts on the name of +rashness. + +_De malign. studentium_.—There be some men are born only to suck out the +poison of books: _Habent venenum pro victu_; _imô_, _pro deliciis_. {66a} +And such are they that only relish the obscene and foul things in poets, +which makes the profession taxed. But by whom? Men that watch for it; +and, had they not had this hint, are so unjust valuers of letters as they +think no learning good but what brings in gain. It shows they themselves +would never have been of the professions they are but for the profits and +fees. But if another learning, well used, can instruct to good life, +inform manners, no less persuade and lead men than they threaten and +compel, and have no reward, is it therefore the worst study? I could +never think the study of wisdom confined only to the philosopher, or of +piety to the divine, or of state to the politic; but that he which can +feign a commonwealth (which is the poet) can govern it with counsels, +strengthen it with laws, correct it with judgments, inform it with +religion and morals, is all these. We do not require in him mere +elocution, or an excellent faculty in verse, but the exact knowledge of +all virtues and their contraries, with ability to render the one loved, +the other hated, by his proper embattling them. The philosophers did +insolently, to challenge only to themselves that which the greatest +generals and gravest counsellors never durst. For such had rather do +than promise the best things. + +_Controvers. scriptores_.—_More Andabatarum qui clausis oculis +pugnant_.—Some controverters in divinity are like swaggerers in a tavern +that catch that which stands next them, the candlestick or pots; turn +everything into a weapon: ofttimes they fight blindfold, and both beat +the air. The one milks a he-goat, the other holds under a sieve. Their +arguments are as fluxive as liquor spilt upon a table, which with your +finger you may drain as you will. Such controversies or disputations +(carried with more labour than profit) are odious; where most times the +truth is lost in the midst or left untouched. And the fruit of their +fight is, that they spit one upon another, and are both defiled. These +fencers in religion I like not. + +_Morbi_.—The body hath certain diseases that are with less evil tolerated +than removed. As if to cure a leprosy a man should bathe himself with +the warm blood of a murdered child, so in the Church some errors may be +dissimuled with less inconvenience than they can be discovered. + +_Jactantia intempestiva_.—Men that talk of their own benefits are not +believed to talk of them because they have done them; but to have done +them because they might talk of them. That which had been great, if +another had reported it of them, vanisheth, and is nothing, if he that +did it speak of it. For men, when they cannot destroy the deed, will yet +be glad to take advantage of the boasting, and lessen it. + +_Adulatio_.—I have seen that poverty makes me do unfit things; but honest +men should not do them; they should gain otherwise. Though a man be +hungry, he should not play the parasite. That hour wherein I would +repent me to be honest, there were ways enough open for me to be rich. +But flattery is a fine pick-lock of tender ears; especially of those whom +fortune hath borne high upon their wings, that submit their dignity and +authority to it, by a soothing of themselves. For, indeed, men could +never be taken in that abundance with the springes of others’ flattery, +if they began not there; if they did but remember how much more +profitable the bitterness of truth were, than all the honey distilling +from a whorish voice, which is not praise, but poison. But now it is +come to that extreme folly, or rather madness, with some, that he that +flatters them modestly or sparingly is thought to malign them. If their +friend consent not to their vices, though he do not contradict them, he +is nevertheless an enemy. When they do all things the worst way, even +then they look for praise. Nay, they will hire fellows to flatter them +with suits and suppers, and to prostitute their judgments. They have +livery-friends, friends of the dish, and of the spit, that wait their +turns, as my lord has his feasts and guests. + +_De vitâ humanâ_.—I have considered our whole life is like a play: +wherein every man forgetful of himself, is in travail with expression of +another. Nay, we so insist in imitating others, as we cannot when it is +necessary return to ourselves; like children, that imitate the vices of +stammerers so long, till at last they become such; and make the habit to +another nature, as it is never forgotten. + +_De piis et probis_.—Good men are the stars, the planets of the ages +wherein they live and illustrate the times. God did never let them be +wanting to the world: as Abel, for an example of innocency, Enoch of +purity, Noah of trust in God’s mercies, Abraham of faith, and so of the +rest. These, sensual men thought mad because they would not be partakers +or practisers of their madness. But they, placed high on the top of all +virtue, looked down on the stage of the world and contemned the play of +fortune. For though the most be players, some must be spectators. + +_Mores aulici_.—I have discovered that a feigned familiarity in great +ones is a note of certain usurpation on the less. For great and popular +men feign themselves to be servants to others to make those slaves to +them. So the fisher provides bait for the trout, roach, dace, &c., that +they may be food to him. + +_Impiorum querela_.—_Augusties_.—_Varus_.—_Tiberius_.—The complaint of +Caligula was most wicked of the condition of his times, when he said they +were not famous for any public calamity, as the reign of Augustus was, by +the defeat of Varus and the legions; and that of Tiberius, by the falling +of the theatre at Fidenæ; whilst his oblivion was eminent through the +prosperity of his affairs. As that other voice of his was worthier a +headsman than a head when he wished the people of Rome had but one neck. +But he found when he fell they had many hands. A tyrant, how great and +mighty soever he may seem to cowards and sluggards, is but one creature, +one animal. + +_Nobilium ingenia_.—I have marked among the nobility some are so addicted +to the service of the prince and commonwealth, as they look not for +spoil; such are to be honoured and loved. There are others which no +obligation will fasten on; and they are of two sorts. The first are such +as love their own ease; or, out of vice, of nature, or self-direction, +avoid business and care. Yet these the prince may use with safety. The +other remove themselves upon craft and design, as the architects say, +with a premeditated thought, to their own rather than their prince’s +profit. Such let the prince take heed of, and not doubt to reckon in the +list of his open enemies. + +_Principum. varia_.—_Firmissima verò omnium basis jus hæreditarium +Principis_.—There is a great variation between him that is raised to the +sovereignty by the favour of his peers and him that comes to it by the +suffrage of the people. The first holds with more difficulty, because he +hath to do with many that think themselves his equals, and raised him for +their own greatness and oppression of the rest. The latter hath no +upbraiders, but was raised by them that sought to be defended from +oppression: whose end is both easier and the honester to satisfy. +Beside, while he hath the people to friend, who are a multitude, he hath +the less fear of the nobility, who are but few. Nor let the common +proverb (of he that builds on the people builds on the dirt) discredit my +opinion: for that hath only place where an ambitious and private person, +for some popular end, trusts in them against the public justice and +magistrate. There they will leave him. But when a prince governs them, +so as they have still need of his administrations (for that is his art), +he shall ever make and hold them faithful. + +_Clementia_.—_Machiavell_.—A prince should exercise his cruelty not by +himself but by his ministers; so he may save himself and his dignity with +his people by sacrificing those when he list, saith the great doctor of +state, Machiavell. But I say he puts off man and goes into a beast, that +is cruel. No virtue is a prince’s own, or becomes him more, than this +clemency: and no glory is greater than to be able to save with his power. +Many punishments sometimes, and in some cases, as much discredit a +prince, as many funerals a physician. The state of things is secured by +clemency; severity represseth a few, but irritates more. {74a} The +lopping of trees makes the boughs shoot out thicker; and the taking away +of some kind of enemies increaseth the number. It is then most gracious +in a prince to pardon when many about him would make him cruel; to think +then how much he can save when others tell him how much he can destroy; +not to consider what the impotence of others hath demolished, but what +his own greatness can sustain. These are a prince’s virtues: and they +that give him other counsels are but the hangman’s factors. + +_Clementia tutela optima_.—He that is cruel to halves (saith the said St. +Nicholas {74b}) loseth no less the opportunity of his cruelty than of his +benefits: for then to use his cruelty is too late; and to use his favours +will be interpreted fear and necessity, and so he loseth the thanks. +Still the counsel is cruelty. But princes, by hearkening to cruel +counsels, become in time obnoxious to the authors, their flatterers, and +ministers; and are brought to that, that when they would, they dare not +change them; they must go on and defend cruelty with cruelty; they cannot +alter the habit. It is then grown necessary, they must be as ill as +those have made them: and in the end they will grow more hateful to +themselves than to their subjects. Whereas, on the contrary, the +merciful prince is safe in love, not in fear. He needs no emissaries, +spies, intelligencers to entrap true subjects. He fears no libels, no +treasons. His people speak what they think, and talk openly what they do +in secret. They have nothing in their breasts that they need a cypher +for. He is guarded with his own benefits. + +_Religio_. _Palladium Homeri_.—_Euripides_.—The strength of empire is in +religion. What else is the Palladium (with Homer) that kept Troy so long +from sacking? Nothing more commends the Sovereign to the subject than +it. For he that is religious must be merciful and just necessarily: and +they are two strong ties upon mankind. Justice the virtue that innocence +rejoiceth in. Yet even that is not always so safe, but it may love to +stand in the sight of mercy. For sometimes misfortune is made a crime, +and then innocence is succoured no less than virtue. Nay, oftentimes +virtue is made capital; and through the condition of the times it may +happen that that may be punished with our praise. Let no man therefore +murmur at the actions of the prince, who is placed so far above him. If +he offend, he hath his discoverer. God hath a height beyond him. But +where the prince is good, Euripides saith, “God is a guest in a human +body.” + +_Tyranni_.—_Sejanus_.—There is nothing with some princes sacred above +their majesty, or profane, but what violates their sceptres. But a +prince, with such a council, is like the god Terminus, of stone, his own +landmark, or (as it is in the fable) a crowned lion. It is dangerous +offending such a one, who, being angry, knows not how to forgive; that +cares not to do anything for maintaining or enlarging of empire; kills +not men or subjects, but destroyeth whole countries, armies, mankind, +male and female, guilty or not guilty, holy or profane; yea, some that +have not seen the light. All is under the law of their spoil and +licence. But princes that neglect their proper office thus their fortune +is oftentimes to draw a Sejanus to be near about them, who at last affect +to get above them, and put them in a worthy fear of rooting both them out +and their family. For no men hate an evil prince more than they that +helped to make him such. And none more boastingly weep his ruin than +they that procured and practised it. The same path leads to ruin which +did to rule when men profess a licence in government. A good king is a +public servant. + +_Illiteratus princeps_.—A prince without letters is a pilot without eyes. +All his government is groping. In sovereignty it is a most happy thing +not to be compelled; but so it is the most miserable not to be +counselled. And how can he be counselled that cannot see to read the +best counsellors (which are books), for they neither flatter us nor hide +from us? He may hear, you will say; but how shall he always be sure to +hear truth, or be counselled the best things, not the sweetest? They say +princes learn no art truly but the art of horsemanship. The reason is +the brave beast is no flatterer. He will throw a prince as soon as his +groom. Which is an argument that the good counsellors to princes are the +best instruments of a good age. For though the prince himself be of a +most prompt inclination to all virtue, yet the best pilots have needs of +mariners besides sails, anchor, and other tackle. + +_Character principis_.—_Alexander magnus_.—If men did know what shining +fetters, gilded miseries, and painted happiness thrones and sceptres were +there would not be so frequent strife about the getting or holding of +them; there would be more principalities than princes; for a prince is +the pastor of the people. He ought to shear, not to flay his sheep; to +take their fleeces, not their the soul of the commonwealth, and ought to +cherish it as his own body. Alexander the Great was wont to say, “He +hated that gardener that plucked his herbs or flowers up by the roots.” +A man may milk a beast till the blood come; churn milk and it yieldeth +butter, but wring the nose and the blood followeth. He is an ill prince +that so pulls his subjects’ feathers as he would not have them grow +again; that makes his exchequer a receipt for the spoils of those he +governs. No, let him keep his own, not affect his subjects’; strive +rather to be called just than powerful. Not, like the Roman tyrants, +affect the surnames that grow by human slaughters; neither to seek war in +peace, nor peace in war, but to observe faith given, though to an enemy. +Study piety toward the subject; show care to defend him. Be slow to +punish in divers cases, but be a sharp and severe revenger of open +crimes. Break no decrees or dissolve no orders to slacken the strength +of laws. Choose neither magistrates, civil or ecclesiastical, by favour +or price; but with long disquisition and report of their worth by all +suffrages. Sell no honours, nor give them hastily, but bestow them with +counsel and for reward; if he do, acknowledge it (though late), and mend +it. For princes are easy to be deceived; and what wisdom can escape +where so many court-arts are studied? But, above all, the prince is to +remember that when the great day of account comes, which neither +magistrate nor prince can shun, there will be required of him a reckoning +for those whom he hath trusted, as for himself, which he must provide. +And if piety be wanting in the priests, equity in the judges, or the +magistrates be found rated at a price, what justice or religion is to be +expected? which are the only two attributes make kings akin to God, and +is the Delphic sword, both to kill sacrifices and to chastise offenders. + +_De gratiosis_.—When a virtuous man is raised, it brings gladness to his +friends, grief to his enemies, and glory to his posterity. Nay, his +honours are a great part of the honour of the times; when by this means +he is grown to active men an example, to the slothful a spur, to the +envious a punishment. + +_Divites_.—_Heredes ex asse_. He which is sole heir to many rich men, +having (besides his father’s and uncle’s) the estates of divers his +kindred come to him by accession, must needs be richer than father or +grandfather; so they which are left heirs _ex asse_ of all their +ancestors’ vices, and by their good husbandry improve the old and daily +purchase new, must needs be wealthier in vice, and have a greater revenue +or stock of ill to spend on. + +_Fures publici_.—The great thieves of a state are lightly the officers of +the crown; they hang the less still, play the pikes in the pond, eat whom +they list. The net was never spread for the hawk or buzzard that hurt +us, but the harmless birds; they are good meat:— + + “Dat veniam corvis, vexat censura columbas.” {81a} + “Non rete accipitri tenditur, neque milvio.” {81b} + +_Lewis XI_.—But they are not always safe though, especially when they +meet with wise masters. They can take down all the huff and swelling of +their looks, and like dexterous auditors place the counter where he shall +value nothing. Let them but remember Lewis XI., who to a Clerk of the +Exchequer that came to be Lord Treasurer, and had (for his device) +represented himself sitting on fortune’s wheel, told him he might do well +to fasten it with a good strong nail, lest, turning about, it might bring +him where he was again. As indeed it did. + +_De bonis et malis_.—_De innocentiâ_.—A good man will avoid the spot of +any sin. The very aspersion is grievous, which makes him choose his way +in his life as he would in his journey. The ill man rides through all +confidently; he is coated and booted for it. The oftener he offends, the +more openly, and the fouler, the fitter in fashion. His modesty, like a +riding-coat, the more it is worn is the less cared for. It is good +enough for the dirt still, and the ways he travels in. An innocent man +needs no eloquence, his innocence is instead of it, else I had never come +off so many times from these precipices, whither men’s malice hath +pursued me. It is true I have been accused to the lords, to the king, +and by great ones, but it happened my accusers had not thought of the +accusation with themselves, and so were driven, for want of crimes, to +use invention, which was found slander, or too late (being entered so +fair) to seek starting-holes for their rashness, which were not given +them. And then they may think what accusation that was like to prove, +when they that were the engineers feared to be the authors. Nor were +they content to feign things against me, but to urge things, feigned by +the ignorant, against my profession, which though, from their hired and +mercenary impudence, I might have passed by as granted to a nation of +barkers that let out their tongues to lick others’ sores; yet I durst not +leave myself undefended, having a pair of ears unskilful to hear lies, or +have those things said of me which I could truly prove of them. They +objected making of verses to me, when I could object to most of them, +their not being able to read them, but as worthy of scorn. Nay, they +would offer to urge mine own writings against me, but by pieces (which +was an excellent way of malice), as if any man’s context might not seem +dangerous and offensive, if that which was knit to what went before were +defrauded of his beginning; or that things by themselves uttered might +not seem subject to calumny, which read entire would appear most free. +At last they upbraided my poverty: I confess she is my domestic; sober of +diet, simple of habit, frugal, painful, a good counseller to me, that +keeps me from cruelty, pride, or other more delicate impertinences, which +are the nurse-children of riches. But let them look over all the great +and monstrous wickednesses, they shall never find those in poor families. +They are the issue of the wealthy giants and the mighty hunters, whereas +no great work, or worthy of praise or memory, but came out of poor +cradles. It was the ancient poverty that founded commonweals, built +cities, invented arts, made wholesome laws, armed men against vices, +rewarded them with their own virtues, and preserved the honour and state +of nations, till they betrayed themselves to riches. + +_Amor nummi_.—Money never made any man rich, but his mind. He that can +order himself to the law of Nature is not only without the sense but the +fear of poverty. O! but to strike blind the people with our wealth and +pomp is the thing! What a wretchedness is this, to thrust all our riches +outward, and be beggars within; to contemplate nothing but the little, +vile, and sordid things of the world; not the great, noble, and precious! +We serve our avarice, and, not content with the good of the earth that is +offered us, we search and dig for the evil that is hidden. God offered +us those things, and placed them at hand, and near us, that He knew were +profitable for us, but the hurtful He laid deep and hid. Yet do we seek +only the things whereby we may perish, and bring them forth, when God and +Nature hath buried them. We covet superfluous things, when it were more +honour for us if we would contemn necessary. What need hath Nature of +silver dishes, multitudes of waiters, delicate pages, perfumed napkins? +She requires meat only, and hunger is not ambitious. Can we think no +wealth enough but such a state for which a man may be brought into a +premunire, begged, proscribed, or poisoned? O! if a man could restrain +the fury of his gullet and groin, and think how many fires, how many +kitchens, cooks, pastures, and ploughed lands; what orchards, stews, +ponds and parks, coops and garners, he could spare; what velvets, +tissues, embroideries, laces, he could lack; and then how short and +uncertain his life is; he were in a better way to happiness than to live +the emperor of these delights, and be the dictator of fashions; but we +make ourselves slaves to our pleasures, and we serve fame and ambition, +which is an equal slavery. Have not I seen the pomp of a whole kingdom, +and what a foreign king could bring hither? Also to make himself gazed +and wondered at—laid forth, as it were, to the show—and vanish all away +in a day? And shall that which could not fill the expectation of few +hours, entertain and take up our whole lives, when even it appeared as +superfluous to the possessors as to me that was a spectator? The bravery +was shown, it was not possessed; while it boasted itself it perished. It +is vile, and a poor thing to place our happiness on these desires. Say +we wanted them all. Famine ends famine. + +_De mollibus et effœminatis_.—There is nothing valiant or solid to be +hoped for from such as are always kempt and perfumed, and every day smell +of the tailor; the exceedingly curious that are wholly in mending such an +imperfection in the face, in taking away the morphew in the neck, or +bleaching their hands at midnight, gumming and bridling their beards, or +making the waist small, binding it with hoops, while the mind runs at +waste; too much pickedness is not manly. Not from those that will jest +at their own outward imperfections, but hide their ulcers within, their +pride, lust, envy, ill-nature, with all the art and authority they can. +These persons are in danger, for whilst they think to justify their +ignorance by impudence, and their persons by clothes and outward +ornaments, they use but a commission to deceive themselves: where, if we +will look with our understanding, and not our senses, we may behold +virtue and beauty (though covered with rags) in their brightness; and +vice and deformity so much the fouler, in having all the splendour of +riches to gild them, or the false light of honour and power to help them. +Yet this is that wherewith the world is taken, and runs mad to gaze +on—clothes and titles, the birdlime of fools. + +_De stultitiâ_.—What petty things they are we wonder at, like children +that esteem every trifle, and prefer a fairing before their fathers! +What difference is between us and them but that we are dearer fools, +coxcombs at a higher rate? They are pleased with cockleshells, whistles, +hobby-horses, and such like; we with statues, marble pillars, pictures, +gilded roofs, where underneath is lath and lime, perhaps loam. Yet we +take pleasure in the lie, and are glad we can cozen ourselves. Nor is it +only in our walls and ceilings, but all that we call happiness is mere +painting and gilt, and all for money. What a thin membrane of honour +that is! and how hath all true reputation fallen, since money began to +have any! Yet the great herd, the multitude, that in all other things +are divided, in this alone conspire and agree—to love money. They wish +for it, they embrace it, they adore it, while yet it is possessed with +greater stir and torment than it is gotten. + +_De sibi molestis_.—Some men what losses soever they have they make them +greater, and if they have none, even all that is not gotten is a loss. +Can there be creatures of more wretched condition than these, that +continually labour under their own misery and others’ envy? A man should +study other things, not to covet, not to fear, not to repent him; to make +his base such as no tempest shall shake him; to be secure of all opinion, +and pleasing to himself, even for that wherein he displeaseth others; for +the worst opinion gotten for doing well, should delight us. Wouldst not +thou be just but for fame, thou oughtest to be it with infamy; he that +would have his virtue published is not the servant of virtue, but glory. + +_Periculosa melancholia_.—It is a dangerous thing when men’s minds come +to sojourn with their affections, and their diseases eat into their +strength; that when too much desire and greediness of vice hath made the +body unfit, or unprofitable, it is yet gladded with the sight and +spectacle of it in others; and for want of ability to be an actor, is +content to be a witness. It enjoys the pleasure of sinning in beholding +others sin, as in dining, drinking, drabbing, &c. Nay, when it cannot do +all these, it is offended with his own narrowness, that excludes it from +the universal delights of mankind, and oftentimes dies of a melancholy, +that it cannot be vicious enough. + +_Falsæ species fugiendæ_.—I am glad when I see any man avoid the infamy +of a vice; but to shun the vice itself were better. Till he do that he +is but like the ’pientice, who, being loth to be spied by his master +coming forth of Black Lucy’s, went in again; to whom his master cried, +“The more thou runnest that way to hide thyself, the more thou art in the +place.” So are those that keep a tavern all day, that they may not be +seen at night. I have known lawyers, divines—yea, great ones—of this +heresy. + +_Decipimur specie_.—There is a greater reverence had of things remote or +strange to us than of much better if they be nearer and fall under our +sense. Men, and almost all sorts of creatures, have their reputation by +distance. Rivers, the farther they run, and more from their spring, the +broader they are, and greater. And where our original is known, we are +less the confident; among strangers we trust fortune. Yet a man may live +as renowned at home, in his own country, or a private village, as in the +whole world. For it is virtue that gives glory; that will endenizen a +man everywhere. It is only that can naturalise him. A native, if he be +vicious, deserves to be a stranger, and cast out of the commonwealth as +an alien. + +_Dejectio Aulic_.—A dejected countenance and mean clothes beget often a +contempt, but it is with the shallowest creatures; courtiers commonly: +look up even with them in a new suit, you get above them straight. +Nothing is more short-lived than pride; it is but while their clothes +last: stay but while these are worn out, you cannot wish the thing more +wretched or dejected. + +_Poesis_, _et pictura_.—_Plutarch_. Poetry and picture are arts of a +like nature, and both are busy about imitation. It was excellently said +of Plutarch, poetry was a speaking picture, and picture a mute poesy. +For they both invent, feign and devise many things, and accommodate all +they invent to the use and service of Nature. Yet of the two, the pen is +more noble than the pencil; for that can speak to the understanding, the +other but to the sense. They both behold pleasure and profit as their +common object; but should abstain from all base pleasures, lest they +should err from their end, and, while they seek to better men’s minds, +destroy their manners. They both are born artificers, not made. Nature +is more powerful in them than study. + +_De pictura_.—Whosoever loves not picture is injurious to truth and all +the wisdom of poetry. Picture is the invention of heaven, the most +ancient and most akin to Nature. It is itself a silent work, and always +of one and the same habit; yet it doth so enter and penetrate the inmost +affection (being done by an excellent artificer) as sometimes it +overcomes the power of speech and oratory. There are divers graces in +it, so are there in the artificers. One excels in care, another in +reason, a third in easiness, a fourth in nature and grace. Some have +diligence and comeliness, but they want majesty. They can express a +human form in all the graces, sweetness, and elegancy, but, they miss the +authority. They can hit nothing but smooth cheeks; they cannot express +roughness or gravity. Others aspire to truth so much as they are rather +lovers of likeness than beauty. Zeuxis and Parrhasius are said to be +contemporaries; the first found out the reason of lights and shadows in +picture, the other more subtlely examined the line. + +_De stylo_.—_Pliny_.—In picture light is required no less than shadow; so +in style, height as well as humbleness. But beware they be not too +humble, as Pliny pronounced of Regulus’s writings. You would think them +written, not on a child, but by a child. Many, out of their own obscene +apprehensions, refuse proper and fit words—as occupy, Nature, and the +like; so the curious industry in some, of having all alike good, hath +come nearer a vice than a virtue. + +_De progres. picturæ_. {93} Picture took her feigning from poetry; from +geometry her rule, compass, lines, proportion, and the whole symmetry. +Parrhasius was the first won reputation by adding symmetry to picture; he +added subtlety to the countenance, elegancy to the hair, love-lines to +the face, and by the public voice of all artificers, deserved honour in +the outer lines. Eupompus gave it splendour by numbers and other +elegancies. From the optics it drew reasons, by which it considered how +things placed at distance and afar off should appear less; how above or +beneath the head should deceive the eye, &c. So from thence it took +shadows, recessor, light, and heightnings. From moral philosophy it took +the soul, the expression of senses, perturbations, manners, when they +would paint an angry person, a proud, an inconstant, an ambitious, a +brave, a magnanimous, a just, a merciful, a compassionate, an humble, a +dejected, a base, and the like; they made all heightnings bright, all +shadows dark, all swellings from a plane, all solids from breaking. See +where he complains of their painting Chimæras {94} (by the vulgar unaptly +called grotesque) saying that men who were born truly to study and +emulate Nature did nothing but make monsters against Nature, which Horace +so laughed at. {95} The art plastic was moulding in clay, or potter’s +earth anciently. This is the parent of statuary, sculpture, graving, and +picture; cutting in brass and marble, all serve under her. Socrates +taught Parrhasius and Clito (two noble statuaries) first to express +manners by their looks in imagery. Polygnotus and Aglaophon were +ancienter. After them Zeuxis, who was the lawgiver to all painters; +after, Parrhasius. They were contemporaries, and lived both about +Philip’s time, the father of Alexander the Great. There lived in this +latter age six famous painters in Italy, who were excellent and emulous +of the ancients—Raphael de Urbino, Michael Angelo Buonarotti, Titian, +Antony of Correggio, Sebastian of Venice, Julio Romano, and Andrea +Sartorio. + +_Parasiti ad mensam_.—These are flatterers for their bread, that praise +all my oraculous lord does or says, be it true or false; invent tales +that shall please; make baits for his lordship’s ears; and if they be not +received in what they offer at, they shift a point of the compass, and +turn their tale, presently tack about, deny what they confessed, and +confess what they denied; fit their discourse to the persons and +occasions. What they snatch up and devour at one table, utter at +another; and grow suspected of the master, hated of the servants, while +they inquire, and reprehend, and compound, and dilate business of the +house they have nothing to do with. They praise my lord’s wine and the +sauce he likes; observe the cook and bottle-man; while they stand in my +lord’s favour, speak for a pension for them, but pound them to dust upon +my lord’s least distaste, or change of his palate. + +How much better is it to be silent, or at least to speak sparingly! for +it is not enough to speak good, but timely things. If a man be asked a +question, to answer; but to repeat the question before he answer is well, +that he be sure to understand it, to avoid absurdity; for it is less +dishonour to hear imperfectly than to speak imperfectly. The ears are +excused, the understanding is not. And in things unknown to a man, not +to give his opinion, lest by the affectation of knowing too much he lose +the credit he hath, by speaking or knowing the wrong way what he utters. +Nor seek to get his patron’s favour by embarking himself in the factions +of the family, to inquire after domestic simulties, their sports or +affections. They are an odious and vile kind of creatures, that fly +about the house all day, and picking up the filth of the house like pies +or swallows, carry it to their nest (the lord’s ears), and oftentimes +report the lies they have feigned for what they have seen and heard. + +_Imò serviles_.—These are called instruments of grace and power with +great persons, but they are indeed the organs of their impotency, and +marks of weakness. For sufficient lords are able to make these +discoveries themselves. Neither will an honourable person inquire who +eats and drinks together, what that man plays, whom this man loves, with +whom such a one walks, what discourse they hold, who sleeps with whom. +They are base and servile natures that busy themselves about these +disquisitions. How often have I seen (and worthily) these censors of the +family undertaken by some honest rustic and cudgelled thriftily! These +are commonly the off-scouring and dregs of men that do these things, or +calumniate others; yet I know not truly which is worse—he that maligns +all, or that praises all. There is as a vice in praising, and as +frequent, as in detracting. + +It pleased your lordship of late to ask my opinion touching the education +of your sons, and especially to the advancement of their studies. To +which, though I returned somewhat for the present, which rather +manifested a will in me than gave any just resolution to the thing +propounded, I have upon better cogitation called those aids about me, +both of mind and memory, which shall venture my thoughts clearer, if not +fuller, to your lordship’s demand. I confess, my lord, they will seem +but petty and minute things I shall offer to you, being writ for +children, and of them. But studies have their infancy as well as +creatures. We see in men even the strongest compositions had their +beginnings from milk and the cradle; and the wisest tarried sometimes +about apting their mouths to letters and syllables. In their education, +therefore, the care must be the greater had of their beginnings, to know, +examine, and weigh their natures; which, though they be proner in some +children to some disciplines, yet are they naturally prompt to taste all +by degrees, and with change. For change is a kind of refreshing in +studies, and infuseth knowledge by way of recreation. Thence the school +itself is called a play or game, and all letters are so best taught to +scholars. They should not be affrighted or deterred in their entry, but +drawn on with exercise and emulation. A youth should not be made to hate +study before he know the causes to love it, or taste the bitterness +before the sweet; but called on and allured, entreated and praised—yea, +when he deserves it not. For which cause I wish them sent to the best +school, and a public, which I think the best. Your lordship, I fear, +hardly hears of that, as willing to breed them in your eye and at home, +and doubting their manners may be corrupted abroad. They are in more +danger in your own family, among ill servants (allowing they be safe in +their schoolmaster), than amongst a thousand boys, however immodest. +Would we did not spoil our own children, and overthrow their manners +ourselves by too much indulgence! To breed them at home is to breed them +in a shade, whereas in a school they have the light and heat of the sun. +They are used and accustomed to things and men. When they come forth +into the common-wealth, they find nothing new, or to seek. They have +made their friendships and aids, some to last their age. They hear what +is commanded to others as well as themselves; much approved, much +corrected; all which they bring to their own store and use, and learn as +much as they hear. Eloquence would be but a poor thing if we should only +converse with singulars, speak but man and man together. Therefore I +like no private breeding. I would send them where their industry should +be daily increased by praise, and that kindled by emulation. It is a +good thing to inflame the mind; and though ambition itself be a vice, it +is often the cause of great virtue. Give me that wit whom praise +excites, glory puts on, or disgrace grieves; he is to be nourished with +ambition, pricked forward with honour, checked with reprehension, and +never to be suspected of sloth. Though he be given to play, it is a sign +of spirit and liveliness, so there be a mean had of their sports and +relaxations. And from the rod or ferule I would have them free, as from +the menace of them; for it is both deformed and servile. + +_De stylo_, _et optimo scribendi genere_.—For a man to write well, there +are required three necessaries—to read the best authors, observe the best +speakers, and much exercise of his own style; in style to consider what +ought to be written, and after what manner. He must first think and +excogitate his matter, then choose his words, and examine the weight of +either. Then take care, in placing and ranking both matter and words, +that the composition be comely; and to do this with diligence and often. +No matter how slow the style be at first, so it be laboured and accurate; +seek the best, and be not glad of the froward conceits, or first words, +that offer themselves to us; but judge of what we invent, and order what +we approve. Repeat often what we have formerly written; which beside +that it helps the consequence, and makes the juncture better, it quickens +the heat of imagination, that often cools in the time of setting down, +and gives it new strength, as if it grew lustier by the going back; as we +see in the contention of leaping, they jump farthest that fetch their +race largest; or, as in throwing a dart or javelin, we force back our +arms to make our loose the stronger. Yet, if we have a fair gale of +wind, I forbid not the steering out of our sail, so the favour of the +gale deceive us not. For all that we invent doth please us in conception +of birth, else we would never set it down. But the safest is to return +to our judgment, and handle over again those things the easiness of which +might make them justly suspected. So did the best writers in their +beginnings; they imposed upon themselves care and industry; they did +nothing rashly: they obtained first to write well, and then custom made +it easy and a habit. By little and little their matter showed itself to +them more plentifully; their words answered, their composition followed; +and all, as in a well-ordered family, presented itself in the place. So +that the sum of all is, ready writing makes not good writing, but good +writing brings on ready writing yet, when we think we have got the +faculty, it is even then good to resist it, as to give a horse a check +sometimes with a bit, which doth not so much stop his course as stir his +mettle. Again, whether a man’s genius is best able to reach thither, it +should more and more contend, lift and dilate itself, as men of low +stature raise themselves on their toes, and so ofttimes get even, if not +eminent. Besides, as it is fit for grown and able writers to stand of +themselves, and work with their own strength, to trust and endeavour by +their own faculties, so it is fit for the beginner and learner to study +others and the best. For the mind and memory are more sharply exercised +in comprehending another man’s things than our own; and such as accustom +themselves and are familiar with the best authors shall ever and anon +find somewhat of them in themselves, and in the expression of their +minds, even when they feel it not, be able to utter something like +theirs, which hath an authority above their own. Nay, sometimes it is +the reward of a man’s study, the praise of quoting another man fitly; and +though a man be more prone and able for one kind of writing than another, +yet he must exercise all. For as in an instrument, so in style, there +must be a harmony and consent of parts. + +_Præcipiendi modi_.—I take this labour in teaching others, that they +should not be always to be taught, and I would bring my precepts into +practice, for rules are ever of less force and value than experiments; +yet with this purpose, rather to show the right way to those that come +after, than to detect any that have slipped before by error, and I hope +it will be more profitable. For men do more willingly listen, and with +more favour, to precept, than reprehension. Among divers opinions of an +art, and most of them contrary in themselves, it is hard to make +election; and, therefore, though a man cannot invent new things after so +many, he may do a welcome work yet to help posterity to judge rightly of +the old. But arts and precepts avail nothing, except Nature be +beneficial and aiding. And therefore these things are no more written to +a dull disposition, than rules of husbandry to a soil. No precepts will +profit a fool, no more than beauty will the blind, or music the deaf. As +we should take care that our style in writing be neither dry nor empty, +we should look again it be not winding, or wanton with far-fetched +descriptions; either is a vice. But that is worse which proceeds out of +want, than that which riots out of plenty. The remedy of fruitfulness is +easy, but no labour will help the contrary; I will like and praise some +things in a young writer which yet, if he continue in, I cannot but +justly hate him for the same. There is a time to be given all things for +maturity, and that even your country husband-man can teach, who to a +young plant will not put the pruning-knife, because it seems to fear the +iron, as not able to admit the scar. No more would I tell a green writer +all his faults, lest I should make him grieve and faint, and at last +despair; for nothing doth more hurt than to make him so afraid of all +things as he can endeavour nothing. Therefore youth ought to be +instructed betimes, and in the best things; for we hold those longest we +take soonest, as the first scent of a vessel lasts, and the tint the wool +first receives; therefore a master should temper his own powers, and +descend to the other’s infirmity. If you pour a glut of water upon a +bottle, it receives little of it; but with a funnel, and by degrees, you +shall fill many of them, and spill little of your own; to their capacity +they will all receive and be full. And as it is fit to read the best +authors to youth first, so let them be of the openest and clearest. +{106a} As Livy before Sallust, Sidney before Donne; and beware of +letting them taste Gower or Chaucer at first, lest, falling too much in +love with antiquity, and not apprehending the weight, they grow rough and +barren in language only. When their judgments are firm, and out of +danger, let them read both the old and the new; but no less take heed +that their new flowers and sweetness do not as much corrupt as the +others’ dryness and squalor, if they choose not carefully. Spenser, in +affecting the ancients, writ no language; yet I would have him read for +his matter, but as Virgil read Ennius. The reading of Homer and Virgil +is counselled by Quintilian as the best way of informing youth and +confirming man. For, besides that the mind is raised with the height and +sublimity of such a verse, it takes spirit from the greatness of the +matter, and is tinctured with the best things. Tragic and lyric poetry +is good, too, and comic with the best, if the manners of the reader be +once in safety. In the Greek poets, as also in Plautus, we shall see the +economy and disposition of poems better observed than in Terence; and the +latter, who thought the sole grace and virtue of their fable the sticking +in of sentences, as ours do the forcing in of jests. + +_Fals. querel. fugiend. Platonis peregrinatio in Italiam_.—We should not +protect our sloth with the patronage of difficulty. It is a false +quarrel against Nature, that she helps understanding but in a few, when +the most part of mankind are inclined by her thither, if they would take +the pains; no less than birds to fly, horses to run, &c., which if they +lose, it is through their own sluggishness, and by that means become her +prodigies, not her children. I confess, Nature in children is more +patient of labour in study than in age; for the sense of the pain, the +judgment of the labour is absent; they do not measure what they have +done. And it is the thought and consideration that affects us more than +the weariness itself. Plato was not content with the learning that +Athens could give him, but sailed into Italy, for Pythagoras’ knowledge: +and yet not thinking himself sufficiently informed, went into Egypt, to +the priests, and learned their mysteries. He laboured, so must we. Many +things may be learned together, and performed in one point of time; as +musicians exercise their memory, their voice, their fingers, and +sometimes their head and feet at once. And so a preacher, in the +invention of matter, election of words, composition of gesture, look, +pronunciation, motion, useth all these faculties at once: and if we can +express this variety together, why should not divers studies, at divers +hours, delight, when the variety is able alone to refresh and repair us? +As, when a man is weary of writing, to read; and then again of reading, +to write. Wherein, howsoever we do many things, yet are we (in a sort) +still fresh to what we begin; we are recreated with change, as the +stomach is with meats. But some will say this variety breeds confusion, +and makes, that either we lose all, or hold no more than the last. Why +do we not then persuade husbandmen that they should not till land, help +it with marl, lime, and compost? plant hop-gardens, prune trees, look to +bee-hives, rear sheep, and all other cattle at once? It is easier to do +many things and continue, than to do one thing long. + +_Præcept. element_.—It is not the passing through these learnings that +hurts us, but the dwelling and sticking about them. To descend to those +extreme anxieties and foolish cavils of grammarians, is able to break a +wit in pieces, being a work of manifold misery and vainness, to be +_elementarii senes_. Yet even letters are, as it were, the bank of +words, and restore themselves to an author as the pawns of language: but +talking and eloquence are not the same: to speak, and to speak well, are +two things. A fool may talk, but a wise man speaks; and out of the +observation, knowledge, and the use of things, many writers perplex their +readers and hearers with mere nonsense. Their writings need sunshine. +Pure and neat language I love, yet plain and customary. A barbarous +phrase has often made me out of love with a good sense, and doubtful +writing hath wracked me beyond my patience. The reason why a poet is +said that he ought to have all knowledges is, that he should not be +ignorant of the most, especially of those he will handle. And indeed, +when the attaining of them is possible, it were a sluggish and base thing +to despair; for frequent imitation of anything becomes a habit quickly. +If a man should prosecute as much as could be said of everything, his +work would find no end. + +_De orationis dignitate_. ’Εγκυκλοπαιδεία.—_Metaphora_. Speech is the +only benefit man hath to express his excellency of mind above other +creatures. It is the instrument of society; therefore Mercury, who is +the president of language, is called _deorum hominumque interpres_. +{110a} In all speech, words and sense are as the body and the soul. The +sense is as the life and soul of language, without which all words are +dead. Sense is wrought out of experience, the knowledge of human life +and actions, or of the liberal arts, which the Greeks called +’Εγκυκλοπαιδείαν. Words are the people’s, yet there is a choice of them +to be made; for _verborum delectus origo est eloquentiæ_. {111a} They +are to be chosen according to the persons we make speak, or the things we +speak of. Some are of the camp, some of the council-board, some of the +shop, some of the sheepcote, some of the pulpit, some of the Bar, &c. +And herein is seen their elegance and propriety, when we use them fitly +and draw them forth to their just strength and nature by way of +translation or metaphor. But in this translation we must only serve +necessity (_nam temerè nihil transfertur à prudenti_) {111b} or +commodity, which is a kind of necessity: that is, when we either +absolutely want a word to express by, and that is necessity; or when we +have not so fit a word, and that is commodity; as when we avoid loss by +it, and escape obsceneness, and gain in the grace and property which +helps significance. Metaphors far-fetched hinder to be understood; and +affected, lose their grace. Or when the person fetcheth his translations +from a wrong place as if a privy councillor should at the table take his +metaphor from a dicing-house, or ordinary, or a vintner’s vault; or a +justice of peace draw his similitudes from the mathematics, or a divine +from a bawdy house, or taverns; or a gentleman of Northamptonshire, +Warwickshire, or the Midland, should fetch all the illustrations to his +country neighbours from shipping, and tell them of the main-sheet and the +bowline. Metaphors are thus many times deformed, as in him that said, +_Castratam morte Africani rempublicam_; and another, _Stercus curiæ +Glauciam_, and _Canâ nive conspuit Alpes_. All attempts that are new in +this kind, are dangerous, and somewhat hard, before they be softened with +use. A man coins not a new word without some peril and less fruit; for +if it happen to be received, the praise is but moderate; if refused, the +scorn is assured. Yet we must adventure; for things at first hard and +rough are by use made tender and gentle. It is an honest error that is +committed, following great chiefs. + +_Consuetudo_.—_Perspicuitas_, +_Venustas_.—_Authoritas_.—_Virgil_.—_Lucretius_.—_Chaucerism_.— +_Paronomasia_.—Custom is the most certain mistress of language, as the +public stamp makes the current money. But we must not be too frequent +with the mint, every day coining, nor fetch words from the extreme and +utmost ages; since the chief virtue of a style is perspicuity, and +nothing so vicious in it as to need an interpreter. Words borrowed of +antiquity do lend a kind of majesty to style, and are not without their +delight sometimes; for they have the authority of years, and out of their +intermission do win themselves a kind of grace like newness. But the +eldest of the present, and newness of the past language, is the best. +For what was the ancient language, which some men so dote upon, but the +ancient custom? Yet when I name custom, I understand not the vulgar +custom; for that were a precept no less dangerous to language than life, +if we should speak or live after the manners of the vulgar: but that I +call custom of speech, which is the consent of the learned; as custom of +life, which is the consent of the good. Virgil was most loving of +antiquity; yet how rarely doth he insert _aquai_ and _pictai_! Lucretius +is scabrous and rough in these; he seeks them: as some do Chaucerisms +with us, which were better expunged and banished. Some words are to be +culled out for ornament and colour, as we gather flowers to strew houses +or make garlands; but they are better when they grow to our style; as in +a meadow, where, though the mere grass and greenness delight, yet the +variety of flowers doth heighten and beautify. Marry, we must not play +or riot too much with them, as in Paronomasies; nor use too swelling or +ill-sounding words! _Quæ per salebras_, _altaque saxa cadunt_. {114a} +It is true, there is no sound but shall find some lovers, as the +bitterest confections are grateful to some palates. Our composition must +be more accurate in the beginning and end than in the midst, and in the +end more than in the beginning; for through the midst the stream bears +us. And this is attained by custom, more than care of diligence. We +must express readily and fully, not profusely. There is difference +between a liberal and prodigal hand. As it is a great point of art, when +our matter requires it, to enlarge and veer out all sail, so to take it +in and contract it, is of no less praise, when the argument doth ask it. +Either of them hath their fitness in the place. A good man always +profits by his endeavour, by his help, yea, when he is absent; nay, when +he is dead, by his example and memory. So good authors in their style: a +strict and succinct style is that where you can take away nothing without +loss, and that loss to be manifest. + +_De Stylo_.—_Tracitus_.—_The Laconic_.—_Suetonius_.—_Seneca and +Fabianus_.—The brief style is that which expresseth much in little; the +concise style, which expresseth not enough, but leaves somewhat to be +understood; the abrupt style, which hath many breaches, and doth not seem +to end, but fall. The congruent and harmonious fitting of parts in a +sentence hath almost the fastening and force of knitting and connection; +as in stones well squared, which will rise strong a great way without +mortar. + +_Periodi_.—_Obscuritas offundit tenebras_.—_Superlatio_.—Periods are +beautiful when they are not too long; for so they have their strength +too, as in a pike or javelin. As we must take the care that our words +and sense be clear, so if the obscurity happen through the hearer’s or +reader’s want of understanding, I am not to answer for them, no more than +for their not listening or marking; I must neither find them ears nor +mind. But a man cannot put a word so in sense but something about it +will illustrate it, if the writer understand himself; for order helps +much to perspicuity, as confusion hurts. (_Rectitudo lucem adfert_; +_obliquitas et circumductio offuscat_. {116a}) We should therefore speak +what we can the nearest way, so as we keep our gait, not leap; for too +short may as well be not let into the memory, as too long not kept in. +Whatsoever loseth the grace and clearness, converts into a riddle; the +obscurity is marked, but not the value. That perisheth, and is passed +by, like the pearl in the fable. Our style should be like a skein of +silk, to be carried and found by the right thread, not ravelled and +perplexed; then all is a knot, a heap. There are words that do as much +raise a style as others can depress it. Superlation and over-muchness +amplifies; it may be above faith, but never above a mean. It was +ridiculous in Cestius, when he said of Alexander: + + “Fremit oceanus, quasi indignetur, quòd terras relinquas.” {117a} + +But propitiously from Virgil: + + “Credas innare revulsas + Cycladas.” {117b} + +He doth not say it was so, but seemed to be so. Although it be somewhat +incredible, that is excused before it be spoken. But there are +hyperboles which will become one language, that will by no means admit +another. As _Eos esse_ P. R. _exercitus_, _qui cælum possint +perrumpere_, {118a} who would say with us, but a madman? Therefore we +must consider in every tongue what is used, what received. Quintilian +warns us, that in no kind of translation, or metaphor, or allegory, we +make a turn from what we began; as if we fetch the original of our +metaphor from sea and billows, we end not in flames and ashes: it is a +most foul inconsequence. Neither must we draw out our allegory too long, +lest either we make ourselves obscure, or fall into affectation, which is +childish. But why do men depart at all from the right and natural ways +of speaking? sometimes for necessity, when we are driven, or think it +fitter, to speak that in obscure words, or by circumstance, which uttered +plainly would offend the hearers. Or to avoid obsceneness, or sometimes +for pleasure, and variety, as travellers turn out of the highway, drawn +either by the commodity of a footpath, or the delicacy or freshness of +the fields. And all this is called εσχηματισμενη or figured language. + +_Oratio imago animi_.—Language most shows a man: Speak, that I may see +thee. It springs out of the most retired and inmost parts of us, and is +the image of the parent of it, the mind. No glass renders a man’s form +or likeness so true as his speech. Nay, it is likened to a man; and as +we consider feature and composition in a man, so words in language; in +the greatness, aptness, sound structure, and harmony of it. + +_Structura et statura_, _sublimis_, _humilis_, _pumila_.—Some men are +tall and big, so some language is high and great. Then the words are +chosen, their sound ample, the composition full, the absolution +plenteous, and poured out, all grave, sinewy, and strong. Some are +little and dwarfs; so of speech, it is humble and low, the words poor and +flat, the members and periods thin and weak, without knitting or number. + +_Mediocris plana et placida_.—The middle are of a just stature. There +the language is plain and pleasing; even without stopping, round without +swelling: all well-turned, composed, elegant, and accurate. + +_Vitiosa oratio_, _vasta_—_tumens_—_enormis_—_affectata_—_abjecta_.—The +vicious language is vast and gaping, swelling and irregular: when it +contends to be high, full of rock, mountain, and pointedness; as it +affects to be low, it is abject, and creeps, full of bogs and holes. And +according to their subject these styles vary, and lose their names: for +that which is high and lofty, declaring excellent matter, becomes vast +and tumorous, speaking of petty and inferior things; so that which was +even and apt in a mean and plain subject, will appear most poor and +humble in a high argument. Would you not laugh to meet a great +councillor of State in a flat cap, with his trunk hose, and a hobbyhorse +cloak, his gloves under his girdle, and yond haberdasher in a velvet +gown, furred with sables? There is a certain latitude in these things, +by which we find the degrees. + +_Figura_.—The next thing to the stature, is the figure and feature in +language—that is, whether it be round and straight, which consists of +short and succinct periods, numerous and polished; or square and firm, +which is to have equal and strong parts everywhere answerable, and +weighed. + +_Cutis sive cortex_. _Compositio_.—The third is the skin and coat, which +rests in the well-joining, cementing, and coagmentation of words; whenas +it is smooth, gentle, and sweet, like a table upon which you may run your +finger without rubs, and your nail cannot find a joint; not horrid, +rough, wrinkled, gaping, or chapped: after these, the flesh, blood, and +bones come in question. + +_Carnosa_—_adipata_—_redundans_.—We say it is a fleshy style, when there +is much periphrasis, and circuit of words; and when with more than +enough, it grows fat and corpulent: _arvina orationis_, full of suet and +tallow. It hath blood and juice when the words are proper and apt, their +sound sweet, and the phrase neat and picked—_oratio uncta_, _et benè +pasta_. But where there is redundancy, both the blood and juice are +faulty and vicious:—_Redundat sanguine_, _quia multo plus dicit_, _quam +necesse est_. Juice in language is somewhat less than blood; for if the +words be but becoming and signifying, and the sense gentle, there is +juice; but where that wanteth, the language is thin, flagging, poor, +starved, scarce covering the bone, and shows like stones in a sack. + +_Jejuna_, _macilenta_, _strigosa_.—_Ossea_, _et nervosa_.—Some men, to +avoid redundancy, run into that; and while they strive to have no ill +blood or juice, they lose their good. There be some styles, again, that +have not less blood, but less flesh and corpulence. These are bony and +sinewy; _Ossa habent_, _et nervos_. + +_Notæ domini Sti. Albani de doctrin. +intemper_.—_Dictator_.—_Aristoteles_.—It was well noted by the late Lord +St. Albans, that the study of words is the first distemper of learning; +vain matter the second; and a third distemper is deceit, or the likeness +of truth: imposture held up by credulity. All these are the cobwebs of +learning, and to let them grow in us is either sluttish or foolish. +Nothing is more ridiculous than to make an author a dictator, as the +schools have done Aristotle. The damage is infinite knowledge receives +by it; for to many things a man should owe but a temporary belief, and +suspension of his own judgment, not an absolute resignation of himself, +or a perpetual captivity. Let Aristotle and others have their dues; but +if we can make farther discoveries of truth and fitness than they, why +are we envied? Let us beware, while we strive to add, we do not diminish +or deface; we may improve, but not augment. By discrediting falsehood, +truth grows in request. We must not go about, like men anguished and +perplexed, for vicious affectation of praise, but calmly study the +separation of opinions, find the errors have intervened, awake antiquity, +call former times into question; but make no parties with the present, +nor follow any fierce undertakers, mingle no matter of doubtful credit +with the simplicity of truth, but gently stir the mould about the root of +the question, and avoid all digladiations, facility of credit, or +superstitious simplicity, seek the consonancy and concatenation of truth; +stoop only to point of necessity, and what leads to convenience. Then +make exact animadversion where style hath degenerated, where flourished +and thrived in choiceness of phrase, round and clean composition of +sentence, sweet falling of the clause, varying an illustration by tropes +and figures, weight of matter, worth of subject, soundness of argument, +life of invention, and depth of judgment. This is _monte potiri_, to get +the hill; for no perfect discovery can be made upon a flat or a level. + +_De optimo scriptore_.—_Cicero_.—Now that I have informed you in the +knowing of these things, let me lead you by the hand a little farther, in +the direction of the use, and make you an able writer by practice. The +conceits of the mind are pictures of things, and the tongue is the +interpreter of those pictures. The order of God’s creatures in +themselves is not only admirable and glorious, but eloquent: then he who +could apprehend the consequence of things in their truth, and utter his +apprehensions as truly, were the best writer or speaker. Therefore +Cicero said much, when he said, _Dicere recte nemo potest_, _nisi qui +prudenter intelligit_. {124a} The shame of speaking unskilfully were +small if the tongue only thereby were disgraced; but as the image of a +king in his seal ill-represented is not so much a blemish to the wax, or +the signet that sealed it, as to the prince it representeth, so +disordered speech is not so much injury to the lips that give it forth, +as to the disproportion and incoherence of things in themselves, so +negligently expressed. Neither can his mind be thought to be in tune, +whose words do jar; nor his reason in frame, whose sentence is +preposterous; nor his elocution clear and perfect, whose utterance breaks +itself into fragments and uncertainties. Were it not a dishonour to a +mighty prince, to have the majesty of his embassage spoiled by a careless +ambassador? and is it not as great an indignity, that an excellent +conceit and capacity, by the indiligence of an idle tongue, should be +disgraced? Negligent speech doth not only discredit the person of the +speaker, but it discrediteth the opinion of his reason and judgment; it +discrediteth the force and uniformity of the matter and substance. If it +be so then in words, which fly and escape censure, and where one good +phrase begs pardon for many incongruities and faults, how shall he then +be thought wise whose penning is thin and shallow? how shall you look for +wit from him whose leisure and head, assisted with the examination of his +eyes, yield you no life or sharpness in his writing? + +_De stylo epistolari_.—_Inventio_.—In writing there is to be regarded the +invention and the fashion. For the invention, that ariseth upon your +business, whereof there can be no rules of more certainty, or precepts of +better direction given, than conjecture can lay down from the several +occasions of men’s particular lives and vocations: but sometimes men make +baseness of kindness: As “I could not satisfy myself till I had +discharged my remembrance, and charged my letters with commendation to +you;” or, “My business is no other than to testify my love to you, and to +put you in mind of my willingness to do you all kind offices;” or, “Sir, +have you leisure to descend to the remembering of that assurance you have +long possessed in your servant, and upon your next opportunity make him +happy with some commands from you?” or the like; that go a-begging for +some meaning, and labour to be delivered of the great burden of nothing. +When you have invented, and that your business be matter, and not bare +form, or mere ceremony, but some earnest, then are you to proceed to the +ordering of it, and digesting the parts, which is had out of two +circumstances. One is the understanding of the persons to whom you are +to write; the other is the coherence of your sentence; for men’s capacity +to weigh what will be apprehended with greatest attention or leisure; +what next regarded and longed for especially, and what last will leave +satisfaction, and (as it were) the sweetest memorial and belief of all +that is passed in his understanding whom you write to. For the +consequence of sentences, you must be sure that every clause do give the +cue one to the other, and be bespoken ere it come. So much for invention +and order. + +_Modus_.—1. _Brevitas_.—Now for fashion: it consists in four things, +which are qualities of your style. The first is brevity; for they must +not be treatises or discourses (your letters) except it be to learned +men. And even among them there is a kind of thrift and saving of words. +Therefore you are to examine the clearest passages of your understanding, +and through them to convey the sweetest and most significant words you +can devise, that you may the easier teach them the readiest way to +another man’s apprehension, and open their meaning fully, roundly, and +distinctly, so as the reader may not think a second view cast away upon +your letter. And though respect be a part following this, yet now here, +and still I must remember it, if you write to a man, whose estate and +sense, as senses, you are familiar with, you may the bolder (to set a +task to his brain) venture on a knot. But if to your superior, you are +bound to measure him in three farther points: first, with interest in +him; secondly, his capacity in your letters; thirdly, his leisure to +peruse them. For your interest or favour with him, you are to be the +shorter or longer, more familiar or submiss, as he will afford you time. +For his capacity, you are to be quicker and fuller of those reaches and +glances of wit or learning, as he is able to entertain them. For his +leisure, you are commanded to the greater briefness, as his place is of +greater discharges and cares. But with your betters, you are not to put +riddles of wit, by being too scarce of words; not to cause the trouble of +making breviates by writing too riotous and wastingly. Brevity is +attained in matter by avoiding idle compliments, prefaces, protestations, +parentheses, superfluous circuit of figures and digressions: in the +composition, by omitting conjunctions [_not only_, _but also_; _both the +one and the other_, _whereby it cometh to pass_] and such like idle +particles, that have no great business in a serious letter but breaking +of sentences, as oftentimes a short journey is made long by unnessary +baits. + +_Quintilian_.—But, as Quintilian saith, there is a briefness of the parts +sometimes that makes the whole long: “As I came to the stairs, I took a +pair of oars, they launched out, rowed apace, I landed at the court gate, +I paid my fare, went up to the presence, asked for my lord, I was +admitted.” All this is but, “I went to the court and spake with my +lord.” This is the fault of some Latin writers within these last hundred +years of my reading, and perhaps Seneca may be appeached of it; I accuse +him not. + +2. _Perspicuitas_.—The next property of epistolary style is perspicuity, +and is oftentimes by affectation of some wit ill angled for, or +ostentation of some hidden terms of art. Few words they darken speech, +and so do too many; as well too much light hurteth the eyes, as too +little; and a long bill of chancery confounds the understanding as much +as the shortest note; therefore, let not your letters be penned like +English statutes, and this is obtained. These vices are eschewed by +pondering your business well and distinctly concerning yourself, which is +much furthered by uttering your thoughts, and letting them as well come +forth to the light and judgment of your own outward senses as to the +censure of other men’s ears; for that is the reason why many good +scholars speak but fumblingly; like a rich man, that for want of +particular note and difference can bring you no certain ware readily out +of his shop. Hence it is that talkative shallow men do often content the +hearers more than the wise. But this may find a speedier redress in +writing, where all comes under the last examination of the eyes. First, +mind it well, then pen it, then examine it, then amend it, and you may be +in the better hope of doing reasonably well. Under this virtue may come +plainness, which is not to be curious in the order as to answer a letter, +as if you were to answer to interrogatories. As to the first, first; and +to the second, secondly, &c. but both in method to use (as ladies do in +their attire) a diligent kind of negligence, and their sportive freedom; +though with some men you are not to jest, or practise tricks; yet the +delivery of the most important things may be carried with such a grace, +as that it may yield a pleasure to the conceit of the reader. There must +be store, though no excess of terms; as if you are to name store, +sometimes you may call it choice, sometimes plenty, sometimes +copiousness, or variety; but ever so, that the word which comes in lieu +have not such difference of meaning as that it may put the sense of the +first in hazard to be mistaken. You are not to cast a ring for the +perfumed terms of the time, as _accommodation_, _complement_, _spirit_ +&c., but use them properly in their place, as others. + +3. _Vigor_—There followeth life and quickness, which is the strength and +sinews, as it were, of your penning by pretty sayings, similitudes, and +conceits; allusions from known history, or other common-place, such as +are in the _Courtier_, and the second book of Cicero _De Oratore_. + +4. _Discretio_.—The last is, respect to discern what fits yourself, him +to whom you write, and that which you handle, which is a quality fit to +conclude the rest, because it doth include all. And that must proceed +from ripeness of judgment, which, as one truly saith, is gotten by four +means, God, nature, diligence, and conversation. Serve the first well, +and the rest will serve you. + +_De Poetica_.—We have spoken sufficiently of oratory, let us now make a +diversion to poetry. Poetry, in the primogeniture, had many peccant +humours, and is made to have more now, through the levity and inconstancy +of men’s judgments. Whereas, indeed, it is the most prevailing +eloquence, and of the most exalted caract. Now the discredits and +disgraces are many it hath received through men’s study of depravation or +calumny; their practice being to give it diminution of credit, by +lessening the professor’s estimation, and making the age afraid of their +liberty; and the age is grown so tender of her fame, as she calls all +writings aspersions. + +That is the state word, the phrase of court (placentia college), which +some call Parasites place, the Inn of Ignorance. + +_D. Hieronymus_.—Whilst I name no persons, but deride follies, why should +any man confess or betray himself why doth not that of S. Hierome come +into their mind, _Ubi generalis est de vitiis disputatio_, _ibi nullius +esse personæ injuriam_? {133a} Is it such an inexpiable crime in poets +to tax vices generally, and no offence in them, who, by their exception +confess they have committed them particularly? Are we fallen into those +times that we must not— + + “Auriculas teneras mordaci rodere vero.” {133b} + +_Remedii votum semper verius erat_, _quam spes_. {133c}—_Sexus fæmin_.—If +men may by no means write freely, or speak truth, but when it offends +not, why do physicians cure with sharp medicines, or corrosives? is not +the same equally lawful in the cure of the mind that is in the cure of +the body? Some vices, you will say, are so foul that it is better they +should be done than spoken. But they that take offence where no name, +character, or signature doth blazon them seem to me like affected as +women, who if they hear anything ill spoken of the ill of their sex, are +presently moved, as if the contumely respected their particular; and on +the contrary, when they hear good of good women, conclude that it belongs +to them all. If I see anything that toucheth me, shall I come forth a +betrayer of myself presently? No, if I be wise, I’ll dissemble it; if +honest, I’ll avoid it, lest I publish that on my own forehead which I saw +there noted without a title. A man that is on the mending hand will +either ingenuously confess or wisely dissemble his disease. And the wise +and virtuous will never think anything belongs to themselves that is +written, but rejoice that the good are warned not to be such; and the ill +to leave to be such. The person offended hath no reason to be offended +with the writer, but with himself; and so to declare that properly to +belong to him which was so spoken of all men, as it could be no man’s +several, but his that would wilfully and desperately claim it. It +sufficeth I know what kind of persons I displease, men bred in the +declining and decay of virtue, betrothed to their own vices; that have +abandoned or prostituted their good names; hungry and ambitious of +infamy, invested in all deformity, enthralled to ignorance and malice, of +a hidden and concealed malignity, and that hold a concomitancy with all +evil. + + + +_What is a Poet_? + + +_Poeta_.—A poet is that which by the Greeks is called κατ εξοχην, ο +ποιητής, a maker, or a feigner: his art, an art of imitation or feigning; +expressing the life of man in fit measure, numbers, and harmony, +according to Aristotle; from the word ποιειν, which signifies to make or +feign. Hence he is called a poet, not he which writeth in measure only, +but that feigneth and formeth a fable, and writes things like the truth. +For the fable and fiction is, as it were, the form and soul of any +poetical work or poem. + + + +_What mean_, _you by a Poem_? + + +_Poema_.—A poem is not alone any work or composition of the poet’s in +many or few verses; but even one verse alone sometimes makes a perfect +poem. As when Æneas hangs up and consecrates the arms of Abas with this +inscription:— + + “Æneas hæc de Danais victoribus arma.” {136a} + +And calls it a poem or carmen. Such are those in Martial:— + + “Omnia, Castor, emis: sic fiet, ut omnia vendas.” {136b} + +And— + + “Pauper videri Cinna vult, et est pauper.” {136c} + +_Horatius_.—_Lucretius_.—So were Horace’s odes called Carmina, his lyric +songs. And Lucretius designs a whole book in his sixth:— + + “Quod in primo quoque carmine claret.” {136d} + +_Epicum_.—_Dramaticum_.—_Lyricum_.—_Elegiacum_.—_Epigrammat_.—And +anciently all the oracles were called Carmina; or whatever sentence was +expressed, were it much or little, it was called an Epic, Dramatic, +Lyric, Elegiac, or Epigrammatic poem. + + + +_But how differs a Poem from what we call Poesy_? + + +_Poesis_.—_Artium regina_.—_Poet. +differentiæ_.—_Grammatic_.—_Logic_.—_Rhetoric_.—_Ethica_.—A poem, as I +have told you, is the work of the poet; the end and fruit of his labour +and study. Poesy is his skill or craft of making; the very fiction +itself, the reason or form of the work. And these three voices differ, +as the thing done, the doing, and the doer; the thing feigned, the +feigning, and the feigner; so the poem, the poesy, and the poet. Now the +poesy is the habit or the art; nay, rather the queen of arts, which had +her original from heaven, received thence from the Hebrews, and had in +prime estimation with the Greeks transmitted to the Latins and all +nations that professed civility. The study of it (if we will trust +Aristotle) offers to mankind a certain rule and pattern of living well +and happily, disposing us to all civil offices of society. If we will +believe Tully, it nourisheth and instructeth our youth, delights our age, +adorns our prosperity, comforts our adversity, entertains us at home, +keeps us company abroad, travels with us, watches, divides the times of +our earnest and sports, shares in our country recesses and recreations; +insomuch as the wisest and best learned have thought her the absolute +mistress of manners and nearest of kin to virtue. And whereas they +entitle philosophy to be a rigid and austere poesy, they have, on the +contrary, styled poesy a dulcet and gentle philosophy, which leads on and +guides us by the hand to action with a ravishing delight and incredible +sweetness. But before we handle the kinds of poems, with their special +differences, or make court to the art itself, as a mistress, I would lead +you to the knowledge of our poet by a perfect information what he is or +should be by nature, by exercise, by imitation, by study, and so bring +him down through the disciplines of grammar, logic, rhetoric, and the +ethics, adding somewhat out of all, peculiar to himself, and worthy of +your admittance or reception. + +1. +_Ingenium_.—_Seneca_.—_Plato_.—_Aristotle_.—_Helicon_.—_Pegasus_.— +_Parnassus_.—_Ovid_.—First, we require in our poet or maker (for that +title our language affords him elegantly with the Greek) a goodness of +natural wit. For whereas all other arts consist of doctrine and +precepts, the poet must be able by nature and instinct to pour out the +treasure of his mind, and as Seneca saith, _Aliquando secundum +Anacreontem insanire jucundum esse_; by which he understands the poetical +rapture. And according to that of Plato, _Frustrà poeticas fores sui +compos pulsavit_. And of Aristotle, _Nullum magnum ingenium sine mixturâ +dementiæ fuit_. _Nec potest grande aliquid_, _et supra cæteros loqui_, +_nisi mota mens_. Then it riseth higher, as by a divine instinct, when +it contemns common and known conceptions. It utters somewhat above a +mortal mouth. Then it gets aloft and flies away with his rider, whither +before it was doubtful to ascend. This the poets understood by their +Helicon, Pegasus, or Parnassus; and this made Ovid to boast, + + “Est deus in nobis, agitante calescimus illo + Sedibus æthereis spiritus ille venit.” {139a} + +_Lipsius_.—_Petron. in. Fragm_.—And Lipsius to affirm, _Scio_, _poetam +neminem præstantem fuisse_, _sine parte quadam uberiore divinæ auræ_. +And hence it is that the coming up of good poets (for I mind not +mediocres or imos) is so thin and rare among us. Every beggarly +corporation affords the State a mayor or two bailiffs yearly; but _Solus +rex_, _aut poeta_, _non quotannis nascitur_. To this perfection of +nature in our poet we require exercise of those parts, and frequent. + +2. _Exercitatio_.—_Virgil_.—_Scaliger_.—_Valer. +Maximus_.—_Euripides_.—_Alcestis_.—If his wit will not arrive suddenly at +the dignity of the ancients, let him not yet fall out with it, quarrel, +or be over hastily angry; offer to turn it away from study in a humour, +but come to it again upon better cogitation; try another time with +labour. If then it succeed not, cast not away the quills yet, nor +scratch the wainscot, beat not the poor desk, but bring all to the forge +and file again; torn it anew. There is no statute law of the kingdom +bids you be a poet against your will or the first quarter; if it comes in +a year or two, it is well. The common rhymers pour forth verses, such as +they are, _ex tempore_; but there never comes from them one sense worth +the life of a day. A rhymer and a poet are two things. It is said of +the incomparable Virgil that he brought forth his verses like a bear, and +after formed them with licking. Scaliger the father writes it of him, +that he made a quantity of verses in the morning, which afore night he +reduced to a less number. But that which Valerius Maximus hath left +recorded of Euripides, the tragic poet, his answer to Alcestis, another +poet, is as memorable as modest; who, when it was told to Alcestis that +Euripides had in three days brought forth but three verses, and those +with some difficulty and throes, Alcestis, glorying he could with ease +have sent forth a hundred in the space, Euripides roundly replied, “Like +enough; but here is the difference: thy verses will not last these three +days, mine will to all time.” Which was as much as to tell him he could +not write a verse. I have met many of these rattles that made a noise +and buzzed. They had their hum, and no more. Indeed, things wrote with +labour deserve to be so read, and will last their age. + +3. +_Imitatio_.—_Horatius_.—_Virgil_.—_Statius_.—_Homer_.—_Horat_.—_Archil_.— +_Alcæus_, &c.—The third requisite in our poet or maker is imitation, to +be able to convert the substance or riches of another poet to his own +use. To make choice of one excellent man above the rest, and so to +follow him till he grow very he, or so like him as the copy may be +mistaken for the principal. Not as a creature that swallows what it +takes in crude, raw, or undigested, but that feeds with an appetite, and +hath a stomach to concoct, divide, and turn all into nourishment. Not to +imitate servilely, as Horace saith, and catch at vices for virtue, but to +draw forth out of the best and choicest flowers, with the bee, and turn +all into honey, work it into one relish and savour; make our imitation +sweet; observe how the best writers have imitated, and follow them. How +Virgil and Statius have imitated Homer; how Horace, Archilochus; how +Alcæus, and the other lyrics; and so of the rest. + +4. _Lectio_.—_Parnassus_.—_Helicon_.—_Arscoron_.—_M. T. +Cicero_.—_Simylus_.—_Stob_.—_Horat_.—_Aristot_.—But that which we +especially require in him is an exactness of study and multiplicity of +reading, which maketh a full man, not alone enabling him to know the +history or argument of a poem and to report it, but so to master the +matter and style, as to show he knows how to handle, place, or dispose of +either with elegancy when need shall be. And not think he can leap forth +suddenly a poet by dreaming he hath been in Parnassus, or having washed +his lips, as they say, in Helicon. There goes more to his making than +so; for to nature, exercise, imitation, and study art must be added to +make all these perfect. And though these challenge to themselves much in +the making up of our maker, it is Art only can lead him to perfection, +and leave him there in possession, as planted by her hand. It is the +assertion of Tully, if to an excellent nature there happen an accession +or conformation of learning and discipline, there will then remain +somewhat noble and singular. For, as Simylus saith in Stobæus, Ουτε +φύσις ίκανη yινεται τεχνης ατερ, ουτε παν τέχνη μη φυσιν κεκτημένη, +without art nature can never be perfect; and without nature art can claim +no being. But our poet must beware that his study be not only to learn +of himself; for he that shall affect to do that confesseth his ever +having a fool to his master. He must read many, but ever the best and +choicest; those that can teach him anything he must ever account his +masters, and reverence. Among whom Horace and (he that taught him) +Aristotle deserved to be the first in estimation. Aristotle was the +first accurate critic and truest judge—nay, the greatest philosopher the +world ever had—for he noted the vices of all knowledges in all creatures, +and out of many men’s perfections in a science he formed still one art. +So he taught us two offices together, how we ought to judge rightly of +others, and what we ought to imitate specially in ourselves. But all +this in vain without a natural wit and a poetical nature in chief. For +no man, so soon as he knows this or reads it, shall be able to write the +better; but as he is adapted to it by nature, he shall grow the perfecter +writer. He must have civil prudence and eloquence, and that whole; not +taken up by snatches or pieces in sentences or remnants when he will +handle business or carry counsels, as if he came then out of the +declaimer’s gallery, or shadow furnished but out of the body of the +State, which commonly is the school of men. + +_Virorum schola respub_.—_Lysippus_.—_Apelles_.—_Nævius_.—The poet is the +nearest borderer upon the orator, and expresseth all his virtues, though +he be tied more to numbers, is his equal in ornament, and above him in +his strengths. And (of the kind) the comic comes nearest; because in +moving the minds of men, and stirring of affections (in which oratory +shows, and especially approves her eminence), he chiefly excels. What +figure of a body was Lysippus ever able to form with his graver, or +Apelles to paint with his pencil, as the comedy to life expresseth so +many and various affections of the mind? There shall the spectator see +some insulting with joy, others fretting with melancholy, raging with +anger, mad with love, boiling with avarice, undone with riot, tortured +with expectation, consumed with fear; no perturbation in common life but +the orator finds an example of it in the scene. And then for the +elegancy of language, read but this inscription on the grave of a comic +poet: + + “Immortales mortales si fas esset fiere, + Flerent divæ Camœnæ Nævium poetam; + Itaque postquam est Orcino traditus thesauro, + Obliti sunt Romæ linguâ loqui Latinâ.” {146a} + +_L. Ælius Stilo_.—_Plautus_.—_M. Varro_.—Or that modester testimony given +by Lucius Ælius Stilo upon Plautus, who affirmed, “_Musas_, _si Latinè +loqui voluissent_, _Plautino sermone fuisse loquuturas_.” And that +illustrious judgment by the most learned M. Varro of him, who pronounced +him the prince of letters and elegancy in the Roman language. + +_Sophocles_.—I am not of that opinion to conclude a poet’s liberty within +the narrow limits of laws which either the grammarians or philosophers +prescribe. For before they found out those laws there were many +excellent poets that fulfilled them, amongst whom none more perfect than +Sophocles, who lived a little before Aristotle. + +_Demosthenes_.—_Pericles_.—_Alcibiades_.—Which of the Greeklings durst +ever give precepts to Demosthenes? or to Pericles, whom the age surnamed +Heavenly, because he seemed to thunder and lighten with his language? or +to Alcibiades, who had rather Nature for his guide than Art for his +master? + +_Aristotle_.—But whatsoever nature at any time dictated to the most +happy, or long exercise to the most laborious, that the wisdom and +learning of Aristotle hath brought into an art, because he understood the +causes of things; and what other men did by chance or custom he doth by +reason; and not only found out the way not to err, but the short way we +should take not to err. + +_Euripides_.—_Aristophanes_.—Many things in Euripides hath Aristophanes +wittily reprehended, not out of art, but out of truth. For Euripides is +sometimes peccant, as he is most times perfect. But judgment when it is +greatest, if reason doth not accompany it, is not ever absolute. + +_Cens. Scal. in Lil. Germ_.—_Horace_.—To judge of poets is only the +faculty of poets; and not of all poets, but the best. _Nemo infeliciùs +de poetis judicavit_, _quàm qui de poetis scripsit_. {148a} But some +will say critics are a kind of tinkers, that make more faults than they +mend ordinarily. See their diseases and those of grammarians. It is +true, many bodies are the worse for the meddling with; and the multitude +of physicians hath destroyed many sound patients with their wrong +practice. But the office of a true critic or censor is, not to throw by +a letter anywhere, or damn an innocent syllable, but lay the words +together, and amend them; judge sincerely of the author and his matter, +which is the sign of solid and perfect learning in a man. Such was +Horace, an author of much civility, and (if any one among the heathen can +be) the best master both of virtue and wisdom; an excellent and true +judge upon cause and reason, not because he thought so, but because he +knew so out of use and experience. + +Cato, the grammarian, a defender of Lucilius. {149a} + + “Cato grammaticus, Latina syren, + Qui solus legit, et facit poetas.” + +Quintilian of the same heresy, but rejected. {149b} + +Horace, his judgment of Chœrillus defended against Joseph Scaliger. +{149c} And of Laberius against Julius. {149d} + +But chiefly his opinion of Plautus {149e} vindicated against many that +are offended, and say it is a hard censure upon the parent of all conceit +and sharpness. And they wish it had not fallen from so great a master +and censor in the art, whose bondmen knew better how to judge of Plautus +than any that dare patronise the family of learning in this age; who +could not be ignorant of the judgment of the times in which he lived, +when poetry and the Latin language were at the height; especially being a +man so conversant and inwardly familiar with the censures of great men +that did discourse of these things daily amongst themselves. Again, a +man so gracious and in high favour with the Emperor, as Augustus often +called him his witty manling (for the littleness of his stature), and, if +we may trust antiquity, had designed him for a secretary of estate, and +invited him to the palace, which he modestly prayed off and refused. + +_Terence_.—_Menander_. Horace did so highly esteem Terence’s comedies, +as he ascribes the art in comedy to him alone among the Latins, and joins +him with Menander. + +Now, let us see what may be said for either, to defend Horace’s judgment +to posterity and not wholly to condemn Plautus. + +_The parts of a comedy and tragedy_.—The parts of a comedy are the same +with a tragedy, and the end is partly the same, for they both delight and +teach; the comics are called διδάσκαλοι, of the Greeks no less than the +tragics. + +_Aristotle_.—_Plato_.—_Homer_.—Nor is the moving of laughter always the +end of comedy; that is rather a fowling for the people’s delight, or +their fooling. For, as Aristotle says rightly, the moving of laughter is +a fault in comedy, a kind of turpitude that depraves some part of a man’s +nature without a disease. As a wry face without pain moves laughter, or +a deformed vizard, or a rude clown dressed in a lady’s habit and using +her actions; we dislike and scorn such representations which made the +ancient philosophers ever think laughter unfitting in a wise man. And +this induced Plato to esteem of Homer as a sacrilegious person, because +he presented the gods sometimes laughing. As also it is divinely said of +Aristotle, that to seen ridiculous is a part of dishonesty, and foolish. + +_The wit of the old comedy_.—So that what either in the words or sense of +an author, or in the language or actions of men, is awry or depraved does +strangely stir mean affections, and provoke for the most part to +laughter. And therefore it was clear that all insolent and obscene +speeches, jests upon the best men, injuries to particular persons, +perverse and sinister sayings (and the rather unexpected) in the old +comedy did move laughter, especially where it did imitate any dishonesty, +and scurrility came forth in the place of wit, which, who understands the +nature and genius of laughter cannot but perfectly know. + +_Aristophanes_.—_Plautus_.—Of which Aristophanes affords an ample +harvest, having not only outgone Plautus or any other in that kind, but +expressed all the moods and figures of what is ridiculous oddly. In +short, as vinegar is not accounted good until the wine be corrupted, so +jests that are true and natural seldom raise laughter with the beast the +multitude. They love nothing that is right and proper. The farther it +runs from reason or possibility with them the better it is. + +_Socrates_.—_Theatrical wit_.—What could have made them laugh, like to +see Socrates presented, that example of all good life, honesty, and +virtue, to have him hoisted up with a pulley, and there play the +philosopher in a basket; measure how many foot a flea could skip +geometrically, by a just scale, and edify the people from the engine. +This was theatrical wit, right stage jesting, and relishing a playhouse, +invented for scorn and laughter; whereas, if it had savoured of equity, +truth, perspicuity, and candour, to have tasten a wise or a learned +palate,—spit it out presently! this is bitter and profitable: this +instructs and would inform us: what need we know any thing, that are +nobly born, more than a horse-race, or a hunting-match, our day to break +with citizens, and such innate mysteries? + +_The cart_.—This is truly leaping from the stage to the tumbril again, +reducing all wit to the original dung-cart. + + + +Of the magnitude and compass of any fable, epic or dramatic. + + +_What the measure of a fable is_.—_The fable or plot of a poem +defined_.—_The epic fable_, _differing from the dramatic_.—To the +resolving of this question we must first agree in the definition of the +fable. The fable is called the imitation of one entire and perfect +action, whose parts are so joined and knit together, as nothing in the +structure can be changed, or taken away, without impairing or troubling +the whole, of which there is a proportionable magnitude in the members. +As for example: if a man would build a house, he would first appoint a +place to build it in, which he would define within certain bounds; so in +the constitution of a poem, the action is aimed at by the poet, which +answers place in a building, and that action hath his largeness, compass, +and proportion. But as a court or king’s palace requires other +dimensions than a private house, so the epic asks a magnitude from other +poems, since what is place in the one is action in the other; the +difference is an space. So that by this definition we conclude the fable +to be the imitation of one perfect and entire action, as one perfect and +entire place is required to a building. By perfect, we understand that +to which nothing is wanting, as place to the building that is raised, and +action to the fable that is formed. It is perfect, perhaps not for a +court or king’s palace, which requires a greater ground, but for the +structure he would raise; so the space of the action may not prove large +enough for the epic fable, yet be perfect for the dramatic, and whole. + +_What we understand by whole_.—Whole we call that, and perfect, which +hath a beginning, a midst, and an end. So the place of any building may +be whole and entire for that work, though too little for a palace. As to +a tragedy or a comedy, the action may be convenient and perfect that +would not fit an epic poem in magnitude. So a lion is a perfect creature +in himself, though it be less than that of a buffalo or a rhinocerote. +They differ but in specie: either in the kind is absolute; both have +their parts, and either the whole. Therefore, as in every body so in +every action, which is the subject of a just work, there is required a +certain proportionable greatness, neither too vast nor too minute. For +that which happens to the eyes when we behold a body, the same happens to +the memory when we contemplate an action. I look upon a monstrous giant, +as Tityus, whose body covered nine acres of land, and mine eye sticks +upon every part; the whole that consists of those parts will never be +taken in at one entire view. So in a fable, if the action be too great, +we can never comprehend the whole together in our imagination. Again, if +it be too little, there ariseth no pleasure out of the object; it affords +the view no stay; it is beheld, and vanisheth at once. As if we should +look upon an ant or pismire, the parts fly the sight, and the whole +considered is almost nothing. The same happens in action, which is the +object of memory, as the body is of sight. Too vast oppresseth the eyes, +and exceeds the memory; too little scarce admits either. + +_What is the utmost bounds of a fable_.—Now in every action it behoves +the poet to know which is his utmost bound, how far with fitness and a +necessary proportion he may produce and determine it; that is, till +either good fortune change into the worse, or the worse into the better. +For as a body without proportion cannot be goodly, no more can the +action, either in comedy or tragedy, without his fit bounds: and every +bound, for the nature of the subject, is esteemed the best that is +largest, till it can increase no more; so it behoves the action in +tragedy or comedy to be let grow till the necessity ask a conclusion; +wherein two things are to be considered: first, that it exceed not the +compass of one day; next, that there be place left for digression and +art. For the episodes and digressions in a fable are the same that +household stuff and other furniture are in a house. And so far from the +measure and extent of a fable dramatic. + +_What by one and entire_.—Now that it should be one and entire. One is +considerable two ways; either as it is only separate, and by itself, or +as being composed of many parts, it begins to be one as those parts grow +or are wrought together. That it should be one the first away alone, and +by itself, no man that hath tasted letters ever would say, especially +having required before a just magnitude and equal proportion of the parts +in themselves. Neither of which can possibly be, if the action be single +and separate, not composed of parts, which laid together in themselves, +with an equal and fitting proportion, tend to the same end; which thing +out of antiquity itself hath deceived many, and more this day it doth +deceive. + +_Hercules_.—_Theseus_.—_Achilles_.—_Ulysses_.—_Homer and +Virgil_.—_Æneas_.—_Venus_.—So many there be of old that have thought the +action of one man to be one, as of Hercules, Theseus, Achilles, Ulysses, +and other heroes; which is both foolish and false, since by one and the +same person many things may be severally done which cannot fitly be +referred or joined to the same end: which not only the excellent tragic +poets, but the best masters of the epic, Homer and Virgil, saw. For +though the argument of an epic poem be far more diffused and poured out +than that of tragedy, yet Virgil, writing of Æneas, hath pretermitted +many things. He neither tells how he was born, how brought up, how he +fought with Achilles, how he was snatched out of the battle by Venus; but +that one thing, how he came into Italy, he prosecutes in twelve books. +The rest of his journey, his error by sea, the sack of Troy, are put not +as the argument of the work, but episodes of the argument. So Homer laid +by many things of Ulysses, and handled no more than he saw tended to one +and the same end. + +_Theseus_.—_Hercules_.—_Juvenal_.—_Codrus_.—_Sophocles_.—_Ajax_.— +_Ulysses_.—Contrary to which, and foolishly, those poets did, whom the +philosopher taxeth, of whom one gathered all the actions of Theseus, +another put all the labours of Hercules in one work. So did he whom +Juvenal mentions in the beginning, “hoarse Codrus,” that recited a volume +compiled, which he called his Theseide, not yet finished, to the great +trouble both of his hearers and himself; amongst which there were many +parts had no coherence nor kindred one with another, so far they were +from being one action, one fable. For as a house, consisting of divers +materials, becomes one structure and one dwelling, so an action, composed +of divers parts, may become one fable, epic or dramatic. For example, in +a tragedy, look upon Sophocles, his Ajax: Ajax, deprived of Achilles’ +armour, which he hoped from the suffrage of the Greeks, disdains; and, +growing impatient of the injury, rageth, and runs mad. In that humour he +doth many senseless things, and at last falls upon the Grecian flock and +kills a great ram for Ulysses: returning to his senses, he grows ashamed +of the scorn, and kills himself; and is by the chiefs of the Greeks +forbidden burial. These things agree and hang together, not as they were +done, but as seeming to be done, which made the action whole, entire, and +absolute. + +_The conclusion concerning the whole_, _and the parts_.—_Which are +episodes_.—_Ajax and Hector_.—_Homer_.—For the whole, as it consisteth of +parts, so without all the parts it is not the whole; and to make it +absolute is required not only the parts, but such parts as are true. For +a part of the whole was true; which, if you take away, you either change +the whole or it is not the whole. For if it be such a part, as, being +present or absent, nothing concerns the whole, it cannot be called a part +of the whole; and such are the episodes, of which hereafter. For the +present here is one example: the single combat of Ajax with Hector, as it +is at large described in Homer, nothing belongs to this Ajax of +Sophocles. + +You admire no poems but such as run like a brewer’s cart upon the stones, +hobbling:— + + “Et, quæ per salebras, altaque saxa cadunt, + Accius et quidquid Pacuviusque vomunt. + Attonitusque legis terraï, frugiferaï.” {160a} + + + + +SOME POEMS. + + +TO WILLIAM CAMDEN. + + + CAMDEN! most reverend head, to whom I owe + All that I am in arts, all that I know— + How nothing’s that! to whom my country owes + The great renown, and name wherewith she goes! + Than thee the age sees not that thing more grave, + More high, more holy, that she more would crave. + What name, what skill, what faith hast thou in things! + What sight in searching the most antique springs! + What weight, and what authority in thy speech! + Men scarce can make that doubt, but thou canst teach. + Pardon free truth, and let thy modesty, + Which conquers all, be once o’ercome by thee. + Many of thine, this better could, than I; + But for their powers, accept my piety. + + + +ON MY FIRST DAUGHTER. + + + HERE lies, to each her parents’ ruth, + Mary, the daughter of their youth; + Yet, all heaven’s gifts, being heaven’s due, + It makes the father less to rue. + At six months’ end, she parted hence, + With safety of her innocence; + Whose soul heaven’s queen, whose name she bears, + In comfort of her mother’s tears, + Hath placed amongst her virgin-train; + Where, while that severed doth remain, + This grave partakes the fleshly birth; + Which cover lightly, gentle earth! + + + +ON MY FIRST SON. + + + FAREWELL, thou child of my right hand, and joy; + My sin was too much hope of thee, loved boy; + Seven years thou wert lent to me, and I thee pay, + Exacted by thy fate, on the just day. + Oh! could I lose all father, now! for why, + Will man lament the state he should envy? + To have so soon ’scaped world’s, and flesh’s rage, + And, if no other misery, yet age! + Rest in soft peace, and, asked, say here doth lie + Ben Jonson his best piece of poetry; + For whose sake, henceforth, all his vows be such, + As what he loves may never like too much. + + + +TO FRANCIS BEAUMONT. + + + HOW I do love thee, Beaumont, and thy muse, + That unto me dost such religion use! + How I do fear myself, that am not worth + The least indulgent thought thy pen drops forth! + At once thou mak’st me happy, and unmak’st; + And giving largely to me, more thou takest! + What fate is mine, that so itself bereaves? + What art is thine, that so thy friend deceives? + When even there, where most thou praisest me, + For writing better, I must envy thee. + + + +OF LIFE AND DEATH. + + + THE ports of death are sins; of life, good deeds: + Through which our merit leads us to our meeds. + How wilful blind is he, then, that would stray, + And hath it in his powers to make his way! + This world death’s region is, the other life’s: + And here it should be one of our first strifes, + So to front death, as men might judge us past it: + For good men but see death, the wicked taste it. + + + +INVITING A FRIEND TO SUPPER. + + + TO-NIGHT, grave sir, both my poor house and I + Do equally desire your company; + Not that we think us worthy such a guest, + But that your worth will dignify our feast, + With those that come; whose grace may make that seem + Something, which else could hope for no esteem. + It is the fair acceptance, sir, creates + The entertainment perfect, not the cates. + Yet shall you have, to rectify your palate, + An olive, capers, or some bitter salad + Ushering the mutton; with a short-legged hen, + If we can get her, full of eggs, and then, + Lemons and wine for sauce: to these, a coney + Is not to be despaired of for our money; + And though fowl now be scarce, yet there are clerks, + The sky not falling, think we may have larks. + I’ll tell you of more, and lie, so you will come: + Of partridge, pheasant, woodcock, of which some + May yet be there; and godwit if we can; + Knat, rail, and ruff, too. Howsoe’er, my man + Shall read a piece of Virgil, Tacitus, + Livy, or of some better book to us, + Of which we’ll speak our minds, amidst our meat; + And I’ll profess no verses to repeat: + To this if aught appear, which I not know of, + That will the pastry, not my paper, show of. + Digestive cheese, and fruit there sure will be; + But that which most doth take my muse and me, + Is a pure cup of rich canary wine, + Which is the Mermaid’s now, but shall be mine: + Of which had Horace, or Anacreon tasted, + Their lives, as do their lines, till now had lasted. + Tobacco, nectar, or the Thespian spring, + Are all but Luther’s beer, to this I sing. + Of this we will sup free, but moderately, + And we will have no Pooly’ or Parrot by; + Nor shall our cups make any guilty men; + But at our parting we will be as when + We innocently met. No simple word + That shall be uttered at our mirthful board, + Shall make us sad next morning; or affright + The liberty that we’ll enjoy to-night. + + + +EPITAPH ON SALATHIEL PAVY, +A CHILD OF QUEEN ELIZABETH’S CHAPEL. + + + WEEP with me all you that read + This little story; + And know for whom a tear you shed, + Death’s self is sorry. + ’Twas a child that so did thrive + In grace and feature, + As heaven and nature seemed to strive + Which owned the creature. + Years he numbered scarce thirteen + When fates turned cruel; + Yet three filled zodiacs had he been + The stage’s jewel; + And did act, what now we moan, + Old men so duly; + As, sooth, the Parcæ thought him one + He played so truly. + So, by error to his fate + They all consented; + But viewing him since, alas, too late! + They have repented; + And have sought to give new birth, + In baths to steep him; + But, being so much too good for earth, + Heaven vows to keep him. + + + +EPITAPH ON ELIZABETH, L. H. + + + WOULDST thou hear what man can say + In a little? Reader, stay. + Underneath this stone doth lie + As much beauty as could die + Which in life did harbour give + To more virtue than doth live. + If, at all, she had a fault + Leave it buried in this vault. + One name was Elizabeth, + The other let it sleep with death. + Fitter, where it died, to tell, + Than that it lived at all. Farewell. + + + +EPITAPH ON THE COUNTESS OF PEMBROKE. + + + UNDERNEATH this sable hearse + Lies the subject of all verse, + Sidney’s sister, Pembroke’s mother: + Death! ere thou hast slain another, + Learned, and fair, and good as she, + Time shall throw a dart at thee. + + + +TO THE MEMORY OF MY BELOVED MASTER WILLIAM SHAKSPEARE, AND WHAT HE HATH +LEFT US. + + + TO draw no envy, Shakspeare, on thy name, + Am I thus ample to thy book and fame; + While I confess thy writings to be such, + As neither man, nor muse can praise too much. + ’Tis true, and all men’s suffrage. But these ways + Were not the paths I meant unto thy praise; + For silliest ignorance on these may light, + Which, when it sounds at best, but echoes right; + Or blind affection, which doth ne’er advance + The truth, but gropes, and urgeth all by chance; + Or crafty malice might pretend this praise, + And think to ruin, where it seemed to raise. + These are, as some infamous bawd, or whore, + Should praise a matron; what would hurt her more? + But thou art proof against them, and, indeed, + Above the ill-fortune of them, or the need. + I, therefore, will begin: Soul of the age! + The applause! delight! and wonder of our stage! + My Shakspeare rise! I will not lodge thee by + Chaucer, or Spenser, or bid Beaumont lie + A little further off, to make thee room: + Thou art a monument without a tomb, + And art alive still, while thy book doth live + And we have wits to read, and praise to give. + That I not mix thee so, my brain excuses, + I mean with great, but disproportioned Muses; + For if I thought my judgment were of years, + I should commit thee surely with thy peers, + And tell how far thou didst our Lily outshine, + Or sporting Kyd, or Marlow’s mighty line. + And though thou hadst small Latin and less Greek, + From thence to honour thee, I will not seek + For names: but call forth thundering Eschylus, + Euripides, and Sophocles to us, + Pacuvius, Accius, him of Cordoua dead, + To live again, to hear thy buskin tread, + And shake a stage; or, when thy socks were on, + Leave thee alone for the comparison + Of all that insolent Greece, or haughty Rome + Sent forth, or since did from their ashes come. + Triumph, my Britain, thou hast one to show, + To whom all scenes of Europe homage owe. + He was not of an age, but for all time! + And all the Muses still were in their prime, + When, like Apollo, he came forth to warm + Our ears, or like a Mercury to charm! + Nature herself was proud of his designs, + And joyed to wear the dressing of his lines! + Which were so richly spun, and woven so fit, + As, since, she will vouchsafe no other wit. + The merry Greek, tart Aristophanes, + Neat Terence, witty Plautus, now not please; + But antiquated and deserted lie, + As they were not of nature’s family. + Yet must I not give nature all; thy art, + My gentle Shakspeare, must enjoy a part. + For though the poet’s matter nature be, + His heart doth give the fashion: and, that he + Who casts to write a living line, must sweat, + (Such as thine are) and strike the second heat + Upon the Muse’s anvil; turn the same, + And himself with it, that he thinks to frame; + Or for the laurel, he may gain a scorn; + For a good poet’s made, as well as born. + And such wert thou! Look how the father’s face + Lives in his issue, even so the race + Of Shakspeare’s mind and manners brightly shines + In his well-turnèd, and true filèd lines; + In each of which he seems to shake a lance, + As brandished at the eyes of ignorance. + Sweet Swan of Avon! what a sight it were + To see thee in our water yet appear, + And make those flights upon the banks of Thames, + That so did take Eliza, and our James! + But stay, I see thee in the hemisphere + Advanced, and made a constellation there! + Shine forth, thou star of poets, and with rage, + Or influence, chide, or cheer the drooping stage, + Which, since thy flight from hence, hath mourned like night, + And despairs day, but for thy volume’s light. + + + +TO CELIA. + + + DRINK to me only with thine eyes, + And I will pledge with mine; + Or leave a kiss but in the cup, + And I’ll not look for wine. + The thirst that from the soul doth rise + Doth ask a drink divine: + But might I of Jove’s nectar sup, + I would not change for thine. + + I sent thee late a rosy wreath, + Not so much honouring thee, + As giving it a hope that there + It could not withered be. + But thou thereon didst only breathe, + And sent’st it back to me: + Since when it grows, and smells, I swear, + Not of itself, but thee. + + + +THE TRIUMPH OF CHARIS. + + + SEE the chariot at hand here of Love, + Wherein my lady rideth! + Each that draws is a swan or a dove, + And well the car Love guideth. + As she goes, all hearts do duty + Unto her beauty; + And, enamoured, do wish, so they might + But enjoy such a sight, + That they still were to run by her side, + Through swords, through seas, whither she would ride. + + Do but look on her eyes, they do light + All that Love’s world compriseth! + Do but look on her hair, it is bright + As Love’s star when it riseth! + Do but mark, her forehead’s smoother + Than words that soothe her! + And from her arched brows, such a grace + Sheds itself through the face, + As alone there triumphs to the life + All the gain, all the good, of the elements’ strife. + + Have you seen but a bright lily grow + Before rude hands have touched it? + Have you marked but the fall o’ the snow + Before the soil hath smutched it? + Have you felt the wool of beaver? + Or swan’s down ever? + Or have smelt o’ the bud o’ the brier? + Or the nard in the fire? + Or have tasted the bag of the bee? + O so white! O so soft! O so sweet is she! + + + +IN THE PERSON OF WOMANKIND. +A SONG APOLOGETIC. + + + MEN, if you love us, play no more + The fools or tyrants with your friends, + To make us still sing o’er and o’er + Our own false praises, for your ends: + We have both wits and fancies too, + And, if we must, let’s sing of you. + + Nor do we doubt but that we can, + If we would search with care and pain, + Find some one good in some one man; + So going thorough all your strain, + We shall, at last, of parcels make + One good enough for a song’s sake. + + And as a cunning painter takes, + In any curious piece you see, + More pleasure while the thing he makes, + Than when ’tis made—why so will we. + And having pleased our art, we’ll try + To make a new, and hang that by. + + + +ODE + + +_To the Immortal Memory and Friendship of that Noble Pair_, _Sir Lucius +Cary and Sir Henry Morison_. + + +I. + +THE TURN. + + + BRAVE infant of Saguntum, clear + Thy coming forth in that great year, + When the prodigious Hannibal did crown + His cage, with razing your immortal town. + Thou, looking then about, + Ere thou wert half got out, + Wise child, didst hastily return, + And mad’st thy mother’s womb thine urn. + How summed a circle didst thou leave mankind + Of deepest lore, could we the centre find! + + +THE COUNTER-TURN. + + + Did wiser nature draw thee back, + From out the horror of that sack, + Where shame, faith, honour, and regard of right, + Lay trampled on? the deeds of death and night, + Urged, hurried forth, and hurled + Upon th’ affrighted world; + Sword, fire, and famine, with fell fury met, + And all on utmost ruin set; + As, could they but life’s miseries foresee, + No doubt all infants would return like thee. + + +THE STAND. + + + For what is life, if measured by the space + Not by the act? + Or maskèd man, if valued by his face, + Above his fact? + Here’s one outlived his peers, + And told forth fourscore years; + He vexèd time, and busied the whole state; + Troubled both foes and friends; + But ever to no ends: + What did this stirrer but die late? + How well at twenty had he fallen or stood! + For three of his fourscore he did no good. + + +II. + +THE TURN + + + He entered well, by virtuous parts, + Got up, and thrived with honest arts; + He purchased friends, and fame, and honours then, + And had his noble name advanced with men: + But weary of that flight, + He stooped in all men’s sight + To sordid flatteries, acts of strife, + And sunk in that dead sea of life, + So deep, as he did then death’s waters sup, + But that the cork of title buoyed him up. + + +THE COUNTER-TURN + + + Alas! but Morison fell young: + He never fell,—thou fall’st, my tongue. + He stood a soldier to the last right end, + A perfect patriot, and a noble friend; + But most, a virtuous son. + All offices were done + By him, so ample, full, and round, + In weight, in measure, number, sound, + As, though his age imperfect might appear, + His life was of humanity the sphere. + + +THE STAND + + + Go now, and tell out days summed up with fears, + And make them years; + Produce thy mass of miseries on the stage, + To swell thine age; + Repeat of things a throng, + To show thou hast been long, + Not lived: for life doth her great actions spell. + By what was done and wrought + In season, and so brought + To light: her measures are, how well + Each syllabe answered, and was formed, how fair; + These make the lines of life, and that’s her air! + + +III. + +THE TURN + + + It is not growing like a tree + In bulk, doth make men better be; + Or standing long an oak, three hundred year, + To fall a log at last, dry, bald, and sear: + A lily of a day, + Is fairer far in May, + Although it fall and die that night; + It was the plant, and flower of light. + In small proportions we just beauties see; + And in short measures, life may perfect be. + + +THE COUNTER-TURN + + + Call, noble Lucius, then for wine, + And let thy looks with gladness shine: + Accept this garland, plant it on thy head + And think, nay know, thy Morison’s not dead + He leaped the present age, + Possessed with holy rage + To see that bright eternal day; + Of which we priests and poets say, + Such truths, as we expect for happy men: + And there he lives with memory and Ben. + + +THE STAND + + + Jonson, who sung this of him, ere he went, + Himself to rest, + Or taste a part of that full joy he meant + To have expressed, + In this bright Asterism! + Where it were friendship’s schism, + Were not his Lucius long with us to tarry, + To separate these twi- + Lights, the Dioscouri; + And keep the one half from his Harry, + But fate doth so alternate the design + Whilst that in heaven, this light on earth must shine. + + +IV. + +THE TURN + + + And shine as you exalted are; + Two names of friendship, but one star: + Of hearts the union, and those not by chance + Made, or indenture, or leased out t’advance + The profits for a time. + No pleasures vain did chime, + Of rhymes, or riots, at your feasts, + Orgies of drink, or feigned protests: + But simple love of greatness and of good, + That knits brave minds and manners more than blood. + + +THE COUNTER-TURN + + + This made you first to know the why + You liked, then after, to apply + That liking; and approach so one the t’other, + Till either grew a portion of the other: + Each styled by his end, + The copy of his friend. + You lived to be the great sir-names, + And titles, by which all made claims + Unto the virtue; nothing perfect done, + But as a Cary, or a Morison. + + +THE STAND + + + And such a force the fair example had, + As they that saw + The good, and durst not practise it, were glad + That such a law + Was left yet to mankind; + Where they might read and find + Friendship, indeed, was written not in words; + And with the heart, not pen, + Of two so early men, + Whose lines her rolls were, and records; + Who, ere the first down bloomed upon the chin, + Had sowed these fruits, and got the harvest in. + + +PRÆLUDIUM. + + + AND must I sing? What subject shall I choose! + Or whose great name in poets’ heaven use, + For the more countenance to my active muse? + + Hercules? alas, his bones are yet sore + With his old earthly labours t’ exact more + Of his dull godhead were sin. I’ll implore + + Phœbus. No, tend thy cart still. Envious day + Shall not give out that I have made thee stay, + And foundered thy hot team, to tune my lay. + + Nor will I beg of thee, lord of the vine, + To raise my spirits with thy conjuring wine, + In the green circle of thy ivy twine. + + Pallas, nor thee I call on, mankind maid, + That at thy birth mad’st the poor smith afraid. + Who with his axe thy father’s midwife played. + + Go, cramp dull Mars, light Venus, when he snorts, + Or with thy tribade trine invent new sports; + Thou, nor thy looseness with my making sorts. + + Let the old boy, your son, ply his old task, + Turn the stale prologue to some painted mask; + His absence in my verse is all I ask. + + Hermes, the cheater, shall not mix with us, + Though he would steal his sisters’ Pegasus, + And rifle him; or pawn his petasus. + + Nor all the ladies of the Thespian lake, + Though they were crushed into one form, could make + A beauty of that merit, that should take + + My muse up by commission; no, I bring + My own true fire: now my thought takes wing, + And now an epode to deep ears I sing. + + + +EPODE. + + + NOT to know vice at all, and keep true state, + Is virtue and not fate: + Next to that virtue, is to know vice well, + And her black spite expel. + Which to effect (since no breast is so sure, + Or safe, but she’ll procure + Some way of entrance) we must plant a guard + Of thoughts to watch and ward + At th’ eye and ear, the ports unto the mind, + That no strange, or unkind + Object arrive there, but the heart, our spy, + Give knowledge instantly + To wakeful reason, our affections’ king: + Who, in th’ examining, + Will quickly taste the treason, and commit + Close, the close cause of it. + ’Tis the securest policy we have, + To make our sense our slave. + But this true course is not embraced by many: + By many! scarce by any. + For either our affections do rebel, + Or else the sentinel, + That should ring ’larum to the heart, doth sleep: + Or some great thought doth keep + Back the intelligence, and falsely swears + They’re base and idle fears + Whereof the loyal conscience so complains. + Thus, by these subtle trains, + Do several passions invade the mind, + And strike our reason blind: + Of which usurping rank, some have thought love + The first: as prone to move + Most frequent tumults, horrors, and unrests, + In our inflamèd breasts: + But this doth from the cloud of error grow, + Which thus we over-blow. + The thing they here call love is blind desire, + Armed with bow, shafts, and fire; + Inconstant, like the sea, of whence ’tis born, + Rough, swelling, like a storm; + With whom who sails, rides on the surge of fear, + And boils as if he were + In a continual tempest. Now, true love + No such effects doth prove; + That is an essence far more gentle, fine, + Pure, perfect, nay, divine; + It is a golden chain let down from heaven, + Whose links are bright and even; + That falls like sleep on lovers, and combines + The soft and sweetest minds + In equal knots: this bears no brands, nor darts, + To murder different hearts, + But, in a calm and god-like unity, + Preserves community. + O, who is he that, in this peace, enjoys + Th’ elixir of all joys? + A form more fresh than are the Eden bowers, + And lasting as her flowers; + Richer than Time and, as Times’s virtue, rare; + Sober as saddest care; + A fixèd thought, an eye untaught to glance; + Who, blest with such high chance, + Would, at suggestion of a steep desire, + Cast himself from the spire + Of all his happiness? But soft: I hear + Some vicious fool draw near, + That cries, we dream, and swears there’s no such thing, + As this chaste love we sing. + Peace, Luxury! thou art like one of those + Who, being at sea, suppose, + Because they move, the continent doth so: + No, Vice, we let thee know + Though thy wild thoughts with sparrows’ wings do fly, + Turtles can chastely die; + And yet (in this t’ express ourselves more clear) + We do not number here + Such spirits as are only continent, + Because lust’s means are spent; + Or those who doubt the common mouth of fame, + And for their place and name, + Cannot so safely sin: their chastity + Is mere necessity; + Nor mean we those whom vows and conscience + Have filled with abstinence: + Though we acknowledge who can so abstain, + Makes a most blessèd gain; + He that for love of goodness hateth ill, + Is more crown-worthy still + Than he, which for sin’s penalty forbears: + His heart sins, though he fears. + But we propose a person like our Dove, + Graced with a Phœnix’ love; + A beauty of that clear and sparkling light, + Would make a day of night, + And turn the blackest sorrows to bright joys: + Whose odorous breath destroys + All taste of bitterness, and makes the air + As sweet as she is fair. + A body so harmoniously composed, + As if natùre disclosed + All her best symmetry in that one feature! + O, so divine a creature + Who could be false to? chiefly, when he knows + How only she bestows + The wealthy treasure of her love on him; + Making his fortunes swim + In the full flood of her admired perfection? + What savage, brute affection, + Would not be fearful to offend a dame + Of this excelling frame? + Much more a noble, and right generous mind, + To virtuous moods inclined, + That knows the weight of guilt: he will refrain + From thoughts of such a strain, + And to his sense object this sentence ever, + “Man may securely sin, but safely never.” + + + +AN ELEGY. + + + THOUGH beauty be the mark of praise, + And yours, of whom I sing, be such + As not the world can praise too much, + Yet is ’t your virtue now I raise. + + A virtue, like allay, so gone + Throughout your form, as though that move, + And draw, and conquer all men’s love, + This subjects you to love of one, + + Wherein you triumph yet: because + ’Tis of yourself, and that you use + The noblest freedom, not to choose + Against or faith, or honour’s laws. + + But who could less expect from you, + In whom alone Love lives again? + By whom he is restored to men; + And kept, and bred, and brought up true? + + His falling temples you have reared, + The withered garlands ta’en away; + His altars kept from the decay + That envy wished, and nature feared; + + And on them burns so chaste a flame, + With so much loyalty’s expense, + As Love, t’ acquit such excellence, + Is gone himself into your name. + + And you are he: the deity + To whom all lovers are designed, + That would their better objects find; + Among which faithful troop am I; + + Who, as an offering at your shrine, + Have sung this hymn, and here entreat + One spark of your diviner heat + To light upon a love of mine; + + Which, if it kindle not, but scant + Appear, and that to shortest view, + Yet give me leave t’ adore in you + What I, in her, am grieved to want. + + + + +FOOTNOTES + + +{11} “So live with yourself that you do not know how ill yow mind is +furnished.” + +{12} Αυτοδίδακτος + +{14} “A Puritan is a Heretical Hypocrite, in whom the conceit of his own +perspicacity, by which he seems to himself to have observed certain +errors in a few Church dogmas, has disturbed the balance of his mind, so +that, excited vehemently by a sacred fury, he fights frenzied against +civil authority, in the belief that he so pays obedience to God.” + +{17a} Night gives counsel. + +{17b} Plutarch in Life of Alexander. “Let it not be, O King, that you +know these things better than I.” + +{19a} “They were not our lords, but our leaders.” + +{19b} “Much of it is left also for those who shall be hereafter.” + +{19c} “No art is discovered at once and absolutely.” + +{22} With a great belly. Comes de Schortenhien. + +{23} “In all things I have a better wit and courage than good fortune.” + +{24a} “The rich soil exhausts; but labour itself is an aid.” + +{24b} “And the gesticulation is vile.” + +{25a} “An end is to be looked for in every man, an animal most prompt to +change.” + +{25b} Arts are not shared among heirs. + +{31a} “More loquacious than eloquent; words enough, but little +wisdom.”—_Sallust_. + +{31b} Repeated in the following Latin. “The best treasure is in that +man’s tongue, and he has mighty thanks, who metes out each thing in a few +words.”—_Hesiod_. + +{31c} _Vid._ Zeuxidis pict. Serm. ad Megabizum.—_Plutarch_. + +{32a} “While the unlearned is silent he may be accounted wise, for he +has covered by his silence the diseases of his mind.” + +{32b} Taciturnity. + +{33a} “Hold your tongue above all things, after the example of the +gods.”—_See_ Apuleius. + +{33b} “Press down the lip with the finger.”—Juvenal. + +{33c} Plautus. + +{33d} Trinummus, Act 2, Scen. 4. + +{34a} “It was the lodging of calamity.”—Mart. lib. 1, ep. 85. + +{41} [“Ficta omnia celeriter tanquam flosculi decidunt, nec simulatum +potest quidquam esse diuturnum.”—Cicero.] + +{44a} Let a Punic sponge go with the book.—Mart. 1. iv. epig. 10. + +{47a} He had to be repressed. + +{49a} A wit-stand. + +{49b} Martial. lib. xi. epig. 91. That fall over the rough ways and +high rocks. + +{59a} Sir Thomas More. Sir Thomas Wiat. Henry Earl of Surrey. Sir +Thomas Chaloner. Sir Thomas Smith. Sir Thomas Eliot. Bishop Gardiner. +Sir Nicolas Bacon, L.K. Sir Philip Sidney. Master Richard Hooker. +Robert Earl of Essex. Sir Walter Raleigh. Sir Henry Savile. Sir Edwin +Sandys. Sir Thomas Egerton, L.C. Sir Francis Bacon, L.C. + +{62a} “Which will secure a long age for the known writer.”—Horat. _de +Art. Poetica_. + +{66a} They have poison for their food, even for their dainty. + +{74a} Haud infima ars in principe, ubi lenitas, ubi severitas—plus +polleat in commune bonum callere. + +{74b} _i.e._, Machiavell. + +{81a} “Censure pardons the crows and vexes the doves.”—Juvenal. + +{81b} “Does not spread his net for the hawk or the kite.”—Plautus. + +{93} Parrhasius. Eupompus. Socrates. Parrhasius. Clito. Polygnotus. +Aglaophon. Zeuxis. Parrhasius. Raphael de Urbino. Mich. Angelo +Buonarotti. Titian. Antony de Correg. Sebast. de Venet. Julio Romano. +Andrea Sartorio. + +{94} Plin. lib. 35. c. 2, 5, 6, and 7. Vitruv. lib. 8 and 7. + +{95} Horat. in “Arte Poet.” + +{106a} Livy, Sallust, Sidney, Donne, Gower, Chaucer, Spenser, Virgil, +Ennius, Homer, Quintilian, Plautus, Terence. + +{110a} The interpreter of gods and men. + +{111a} Julius Cæsar. Of words, _see_ Hor. “De Art. Poet.;” Quintil. 1. +8, “Ludov. Vives,” pp. 6 and 7. + +{111b} A prudent man conveys nothing rashly. + +{114a} That jolt as they fall over the rough places and the rocks. + +{116a} Directness enlightens, obliquity and circumlocution darken. + +{117a} Ocean trembles as if indignant that you quit the land. + +{117b} You might believe that the uprooted Cyclades were floating in. + +{118a} Those armies of the people of Rome that might break through the +heavens.—Cæsar. Comment. circa fin. + +{124a} No one can speak rightly unless he apprehends wisely. + +{133a} “Where the discussion of faults is general, no one is injured.” + +{133b} “Gnaw tender little ears with biting truth.”—_Per Sat._ 1. + +{133c} “The wish for remedy is always truer than the hope.”—_Livius_. + +{136a} “Æneas dedicates these arms concerning the conquering +Greeks.”—_Virg. Æn._ lib. 3. + +{136b} “You buy everything, Castor; the time will come when you will +sell everything.”—_Martial_, lib. 8, epig. 19. + +{136c} “Cinna wishes to seem poor, and is poor.” + +{136d} “Which is evident in every first song.” + +{139a} “There is a god within us, and when he is stirred we grow warm; +that spirit comes from heavenly realms.” + +{146a} “If it were allowable for immortals to weep for mortals, the +Muses would weep for the poet Nævius; since he is handed to the chamber +of Orcus, they have forgotten how to speak Latin at Rome.” + +{148a} “No one has judged poets less happily than he who wrote about +them.”—_Senec. de Brev. Vit_, cap. 13, et epist. 88. + +{149a} Heins, de Sat. 265. + +{149b} Pag. 267. + +{149c} Pag. 270. 271. + +{149d} Pag. 273, _et seq._ + +{149e} Pag. in comm. 153, _et seq._ + +{160a} “And which jolt as they fall over the rough uneven road and high +rocks.”—_Martial_, lib. xi. epig. 91. + + + + +***END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK DISCOVERIES MADE UPON MEN AND +MATTER*** + + +******* This file should be named 5134-0.txt or 5134-0.zip ******* + + +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: +http://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/5/1/3/5134 + + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License available with this file or online at + www.gutenberg.org/license. + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS', WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at 809 +North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887. Email +contact links and up to date contact information can be found at the +Foundation's web site and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit www.gutenberg.org/donate + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. +To donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For forty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. |
