diff options
| author | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 05:27:52 -0700 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 05:27:52 -0700 |
| commit | 839b1a3cc9a0b36201f148ed6daeebda9eb1f3b9 (patch) | |
| tree | ba3cadf05c07e2929119e1ee836d53568a3478eb /old/6589.txt | |
Diffstat (limited to 'old/6589.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | old/6589.txt | 40756 |
1 files changed, 40756 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/old/6589.txt b/old/6589.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fef70e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/old/6589.txt @@ -0,0 +1,40756 @@ +Project Gutenberg's History of Modern Europe 1972-1878, by C. A. Fyffe + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: History of Modern Europe 1972-1878 + +Author: C. A. Fyffe + +Release Date: April 25, 2014 [EBook #6589] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ASCII + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK HISTORY OF MODERN EUROPE 1972-1878 *** + + + + +Produced by Tom Allen, Charles Franks, David Gundry and +the Online Distributed Proofreading Team. + + + + + + + + + + + +HISTORY + +OF + +MODERN EUROPE + +1792-1878 + + +BY + +C. A. FYFFE, M.A. + +Barrister-at-Law; Fellow of University College, Oxford; +Vice-President of the Royal Historical Society + + +POPULAR EDITION + +With Maps + + + + +PREFACE. + + +In acceding to the Publishers' request for a re-issue of the "History of +Modern Europe," in the form of a popular edition, I feel that I am only +fulfilling what would have been the wish of the Author himself. A few +manuscript corrections and additions found in his own copy of the work have +been adopted in the present edition; in general, however, my attention in +revising each sheet for the press has been devoted to securing an accurate +reproduction of the text and notes as they appeared in the previous +editions in three volumes. I trust that in this cheaper and more portable +form the work will prove, both to the student and the general reader, even +more widely acceptable than heretofore. + +HENRIETTA F. A. FYFFE. + +London, November, 1895. + + + + +PREFACE TO THE FIRST EDITION. + + +The object of this work is to show how the States of Europe have gained the +form and character which they possess at the present moment. The outbreak +of the Revolutionary War in 1792, terminating a period which now appears +far removed from us, and setting in motion forces which have in our own day +produced a united Germany and a united Italy, forms the natural +starting-point of a history of the present century. I have endeavoured to +tell a simple story, believing that a narrative in which facts are chosen +for their significance, and exhibited in their real connection, may be made +to convey as true an impression as a fuller history in which the writer is +not forced by the necessity of concentration to exercise the same rigour +towards himself and his materials. The second volume of the work will bring +the reader down to the year 1848: the third, down to the present time. + +London, 1880. + + + + +PREFACE TO THE SECOND EDITION OF THE FIRST VOLUME. [1] + + +In revising this volume for the second edition I have occupied myself +mainly with two sources of information--the unpublished Records of the +English Foreign Office, and the published works which have during recent +years resulted from the investigation of the Archives of Vienna. The +English Records from 1792 to 1814, for access to which I have to express my +thanks to Lord Granville, form a body of firsthand authority of +extraordinary richness, compass, and interest. They include the whole +correspondence between the representatives of Great Britain at Foreign +Courts and the English Foreign Office; a certain number of private +communications between Ministers and these representatives; a quantity of +reports from consuls, agents, and "informants" of every description; and in +addition to these the military reports, often admirably vivid and full of +matter, sent by the British officers attached to the head-quarters of our +Allies in most of the campaigns from 1792 to 1814. It is impossible that +any one person should go through the whole of this material, which it took +the Diplomatic Service a quarter of a century to write. I have endeavoured +to master the correspondence from each quarter of Europe which, for the +time being, had a preponderance in political or military interest, leaving +it when its importance became obviously subordinate to that of others; and +although I have no doubt left untouched much that would repay +investigation, I trust that the narrative has gained in accuracy from a +labour which was not a light one, and that the few short extracts which +space has permitted me to throw into the notes may serve to bring the +reader nearer to events. At some future time I hope to publish a selection +from the most important documents of this period. It is strange that our +learned Societies, so appreciative of every distant and trivial chronicle +of the Middle Ages, should ignore the records of a time of such surpassing +interest, and one in which England played so great a part. No just +conception can be formed of the difference between English statesmanship +and that of the Continental Courts in integrity, truthfulness, and public +spirit, until the mass of diplomatic correspondence preserved at London has +been studied; nor, until this has been done, can anything like an adequate +biography of Pitt be written. + +The second and less important group of authorities with which I have busied +myself during the work of revision comprises the works of Hueffer, Vivenot, +Beer, Helfert, and others, based on Austrian documents, along with the +Austrian documents and letters that have been published by Vivenot. The +last-named writer is himself a partizan, but the material which he has +given to the world is most valuable. The mystery in which the Austrian +Government until lately enveloped all its actions caused some of these to +be described as worse than they really were; and I believe that in the +First Edition I under-estimated the bias of Prussian and North-German +writers. Where I have seen reasons to alter any statements, I have done so +without reserve, as it appears to me childish for any one who attempts to +write history to cling to an opinion after the balance of evidence seems to +be against it. The publication of the second volume of this work has been +delayed by the revision of the first; but I hope that it will appear before +many months more. I must express my obligations to Mr. Oscar Browning, a +fellow-labourer in the same field, who not only furnished me with various +corrections, but placed his own lectures at my disposal; and to Mr. Alfred +Kingston, whose unfailing kindness and courtesy make so great a difference +to those whose work lies in the department of the Record Office which is +under his care. + +London, 1883. + + + + +PREFACE TO THE SECOND VOLUME. [2] + + +In writing this volume I have not had the advantage of consulting the +English Foreign Office Records for a later period than the end of 1815. A +rule not found necessary at Berlin and some other foreign capitals still +closes to historical inquirers the English documents of the last seventy +years. Restrictions are no doubt necessary in the case of transactions of +recent date, but the period of seventy years is surely unnecessarily long. +Public interests could not be prejudiced, nor could individuals be even +remotely affected, by the freest examination of the papers of 1820 or 1830. + +The London documents of 1814-1815 are of various degrees of interest and +importance. Those relating to the Congress of Vienna are somewhat +disappointing. Taken all together, they add less to our knowledge on the +one or two points still requiring elucidation than the recently-published +correspondence of Talleyrand with Louis XVIII. The despatches from Italy +are on the other hand of great value, proving, what I believe was not +established before, that the Secret Treaty of 1815, whereby Austria gained +a legal right to prevent any departure from absolute Government at Naples, +was communicated to the British Ministry and received its sanction. This +sanction explains the obscure and embarrassed language of Castlereagh in +1820, which in its turn gave rise to the belief in Italy that England was +more deeply committed to Austria than it actually was, and probably +occasioned the forgery of the pretended Treaty of July 27, 1813, exposed in +vol. i. of this work, p. 538, 2nd edit. [3] The papers from France and +Spain are also interesting, though not establishing any new conclusions. + +While regretting that I have not been able to use the London archives later +than 1815, I believe that it is nevertheless possible, without recourse to +unpublished papers, to write the history of the succeeding thirty years +with substantial correctness. There exist in a published form, apart from +documents printed officially, masses of first-hand material of undoubtedly +authentic character, such as the great English collection known by the +somewhat misleading name of Wellington Despatches, New Series; or again, +the collection printed as an appendix to Prokesch von Osten's History of +the Greek Rebellion, or the many volumes of Gentz' Correspondence belonging +to the period about 1820, when Gentz was really at the centre of affairs. +The Metternich papers, interesting as far as they go, are a mere selection. +The omissions are glaring, and scarcely accidental. Many minor collections +bearing on particular events might be named, such as those in Guizot's +Memoires. Frequent references will show my obligation to the German series +of historical works constituting the Leipzig Staatengeschichte, as well as +to French authors who, like Viel-Castel, have worked with original sources +of information before them. There exist in English literature singularly +few works on this period of Continental history. + +A greater publicity was introduced into political affairs on the Continent +by the establishment of Parliamentary Government in France in 1815, and +even by the attempts made to introduce it in other States. In England we +have always had freedom of discussion, but the amount of information made +public by the executive in recent times has been enormously greater than it +was at the end of the last century. The only documents published at the +outbreak of the war of 1793 were, so far as I can ascertain, the well-known +letters of Chauvelin and Lord Grenville. During the twenty years' struggle +with France next to nothing was known of the diplomatic transactions +between England and the Continental Powers. But from the time of the Reform +Bill onwards the amount of information given to the public has been +constantly increasing, and the reader of Parliamentary Papers in our own +day is likely to complain of diffusiveness rather than of reticence. +Nevertheless the perusal of published papers can never be quite the same +thing as an examination of the originals; and the writer who first has +access to the English archives after 1815 will have an advantage over those +who have gone before him. + +The completion of this volume has been delayed by almost every circumstance +adverse to historical study and production, including a severe +Parliamentary contest. I trust, however, that no trace of partisanship or +unrest appears in the work, which I have valued for the sake of the mental +discipline which it demanded. With quieter times the third volume will, I +trust, advance more rapidly. + +LONDON, October, 1886. + +NOTE.--The third volume was published in 1889. + + + + +CONTENTS. + + +CHAPTER I. + +FRANCE AND GERMANY AT THE OUTBREAK OF THE REVOLUTIONARY WAR. + +Outbreak of the Revolutionary War in 1792--Its immediate causes-- +Declaration of Pillnitz made and withdrawn--Agitation of the Priests and +Emigrants--War Policy of the Gironde--Provocations offered to France by the +Powers--State of Central Europe in 1792--The Holy Roman Empire--Austria-- +Rule of the Hapsburgs--The Reforms of Maria Theresa and Joseph II.--Policy +of Leopold II.--Government and Foreign Policy of Francis II.--Prussia-- +Government of Frederick William II.--Social Condition of Prussia--Secondary +States of Germany--Ecclesiastical States--Free Cities--Knights--Weakness of +Germany + +CHAPTER II. + +THE WAR, DOWN TO THE TREATIES OF BASLE AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE +DIRECTORY. + +French and Austrian Armies on the Flemish Frontier--Prussia enters the +War--Brunswick invades France--His Proclamation--Insurrection of Aug. 10 at +Paris--Massacres of September--Character of the War--Brunswick, checked at +Valmy, retreats--The War becomes a Crusade of France--Neighbours of +France--Custine enters Mainz--Dumouriez conquers the Austrian Netherlands-- +Nice and Savoy annexed--Decree of the Convention against all Governments-- +Execution of Louis XVI.--War with England, followed by war with the +Mediterranean States--Condition of England--English Parties, how affected +by the Revolution--The Gironde and the Mountain--Austria recovers the +Netherlands--The Allies invade France--La Vendee--Revolutionary System of +1793--Errors of the Allies--New French Commanders and Democratic +Army--Victories of Jourdan, Hoche, and Pichegru--Prussia withdrawing from +the War--Polish Affairs--Austria abandons the Netherlands--Treaties of +Basle--France in 1795--Insurrection of 13 Vendemiaire--Constitution of +1795--The Directory--Effect of the Revolution on the Spirit of Europe up to +1795 + +CHAPTER III. + +ITALIAN CAMPAIGNS: TREATY OF CAMPO FORMIO. + +Triple attack on Austria--Moreau, Jourdan--Bonaparte in Italy--Condition +of the Italian States--Professions and real intentions of Bonaparte and the +Directory--Battle of Montenotte--Armistice with Sardinia--Campaign in +Lombardy--Treatment of the Pope, Naples, Tuscany--Siege of Mantua-- +Castiglione--Moreau and Jourdan in Germany--Their retreat--Secret Treaty +with Prussia--Negotiations with England--Cispadane Republic--Rise of the +idea of Italian Independence--Battles of Arcola and Rivoli--Peace with the +Pope at Tolentino--Venice--Preliminaries of Leoben--The French in +Venice--The French take the Ionian Islands and give Venice to +Austria--Genoa--Coup d'etat of 17 Fructidor in Paris--Treaty of Campo +Formio--Victories of England at Sea--Bonaparte's project against Egypt + +CHAPTER IV. + +FROM THE CONGRESS OF RASTADT TO THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE CONSULATE. + +Congress of Rastadt--The Rhenish Provinces ceded--Ecclesiastical States of +Germany suppressed--French Intervention in Switzerland--Helvetic +Republic--The French invade the Papal States--Roman Republic--Expedition to +Egypt--Battle of the Nile--Coalition of 1798--Ferdinand of Naples enters +Rome--Mack's defeats--French enter Naples--Parthenopean Republic--War with +Austria and Russia--Battle of Stockach--Murder of the French Envoys at +Rastadt--Campaign in Lombardy--Reign of Terror at Naples--Austrian designs +upon Italy--Suvaroff and the Austrians--Campaign in Switzerland--Campaign +in Holland--Bonaparte returns from Egypt--Coup d'etat of 18 Brumaire-- +Constitution of 1799--System of Bonaparte in France--Its effect on the +influence of France abroad + +CHAPTER V. + +FROM MARENGO TO THE RUPTURE OF THE PEACE OF AMIENS. + +Overtures of Bonaparte to Austria and England--The War continues--Massena +besieged in Genoa--Moreau invades Southern Germany--Bonaparte crosses the +St. Bernard, and descends in the rear of the Austrians--Battle of +Marengo--Austrians retire behind the Mincio--Treaty between England and +Austria--Austria continues the War--Battle of Hohenlinden--Peace of +Luneville--War between England and the Northern Maritime League--Battle +of Copenhagen--Murder of Paul--End of the Maritime War--English Army +enters Egypt--French defeated at Alexandria--They capitulate at Cairo and +Alexandria--Preliminaries of Peace between England and France signed at +London, followed by Peace of Amiens--Pitt's Irish Policy and his +retirement--Debates on the Peace--Aggressions of Bonaparte during the +Continental Peace--Holland, Italy, Switzerland--Settlement of Germany +under French and Russian influence--Suppression of Ecclesiastical States +and Free Cities--Its effects--Stein--France under the Consulate--The +Civil Code--The Concordat + +CHAPTER VI. + +THE EMPIRE, TO THE PEACE OF PRESBURG. + +England claims Malta--War renewed--Bonaparte occupies Hanover, and +blockades the Elbe--Remonstrances of Prussia--Cadoudal's Plot--Murder +of the Duke of Enghien--Napoleon Emperor--Coalition of 1805--Prussia +holds aloof--State of Austria--Failure of Napoleon's Attempt to gain +Naval Superiority in the Channel--Campaign in Western Germany-- +Capitulation of Ulm--Trafalgar--Treaty of Potsdam between Prussia and +the Allies--The French enter Vienna--Haugwitz sent to Napoleon with +Prussian Ultimatum--Battle of Austerlitz--Haugwitz signs a Treaty of +Alliance with Napoleon--Peace--Treaty of Presburg--End of the Holy +Roman Empire--Naples given to Joseph Bonaparte--Battle of Maida--The +Napoleonic Empire and Dynasty--Federation of the Rhine--State of +Germany--Possibility of maintaining the Empire of 1806 + +CHAPTER VII. + +DEATH OF PITT, TO THE PEACE OF TILSIT. + +Death of Pitt--Ministry of Fox and Grenville--Napoleon forces Prussia into +war with England, and then offers Hanover to England--Prussia resolves on +war with Napoleon--State of Prussia--Decline of the Army--Southern Germany +with Napoleon--Austria neutral--England and Russia about to help Prussia, +but not immediately--Campaign of 1806--Battles of Jena and Auerstaedt--Ruin +of the Prussian Army--Capitulation of Fortresses--Demands of Napoleon--The +War continues--Berlin Decree--Exclusion of English goods from the +Continent--Russia enters the war--Campaign in Poland and East +Prussia--Eylau--Treaty of Bartenstein--Friedland--Interview at +Tilsit--Alliance of Napoleon and Alexander--Secret Articles--English +expedition to Denmark--The French enter Portugal--Prussia after the Peace +of Tilsit--Stein's Edict of Emancipation--The Prussian Peasant--Reform of +the Prussian Army, and creation of Municipalities--Stein's other projects +of Reform, which are not carried out + +CHAPTER VIII. + +SPAIN, TO THE FALL OF SARAGOSSA. + +Spain in 1806--Napoleon uses the quarrel between Ferdinand and Godoy--He +affects to be Ferdinand's Protector--Dupont's Army enters Spain--Murat in +Spain--Charles abdicates--Ferdinand King--Savary brings Ferdinand to +Bayonne--Napoleon makes both Charles and Ferdinand resign--Spirit of the +Spanish Nation--Contrast with Germany--Rising of all Spain--The Notables +at Bayonne--Campaign of 1808--Capitulation of Baylen--Wellesley lands in +Portugal--Vimieiro--Convention of Cintra--Effect of the Spanish Rising on +Europe--War Party in Prussia--Napoleon and Alexander at Erfurt--Stein +resigns, and is proscribed--Napoleon in Spain--Spanish Misgovernment-- +Campaign on the Ebro--Campaign of Sir John Moore--Corunna--Napoleon +leaves Spain--Siege of Saragossa--Successes of the French + +CHAPTER IX. + +WAR OF 1809: THE NAPOLEONIC EMPIRE--SPAIN, TO THE BATTLE OF SALAMANCA. + +Austria preparing for war--The war to be one on behalf of the German +Nation--Patriotic movement in Prussia--Expected Insurrection in North +Germany--Plans of Campaign--Austrian Manifesto to the Germans--Rising of +the Tyrolese--Defeats of the Archduke Charles in Bavaria--French in +Vienna--Attempts of Doernberg and Schill--Battle of Aspern--Second passage +of the Danube--Battle of Wagram--Armistice of Znaim--Austria waiting for +Events--Wellesley in Spain--He gains the Battle of Talavera, but +retreats--Expedition against Antwerp fails--Austria makes Peace--Treaty of +Vienna--Real Effects of the War of 1809--Austria after 1809--Metternich-- +Marriage of Napoleon with Marie Louise--Severance of Napoleon and +Alexander--Napoleon annexes the Papal States, Holland, Le Valais, and the +North German Coast--The Napoleonic Empire: its benefits and wrongs--The +Czar withdraws from Napoleon's Commercial System--War with Russia +imminent--Wellington in Portugal; Lines of Torres Vedras; Massena's +Campaign of 1810, and retreat--Soult in Andalusia--Wellington's Campaign +of 1811--Capture of Ciudad Rodrigo and Badajoz--Salamanca + +CHAPTER X. + +RUSSIAN CAMPAIGN, TO THE TREATY OF KALISCH. + +War approaching between France and Russia--Policy of Prussia--Hardenberg's +Ministry--Prussia forced into Alliance with Napoleon--Austrian Alliance-- +Napoleon's Preparations--He enters Russia--Alexander and Bernadotte--Plan +of Russians to fight a battle at Drissa frustrated--They retreat on +Witepsk--Sufferings of the French--French enter Smolensko--Battle of +Borodino--Evacuation of Moscow--Moscow fired--The Retreat from Moscow-- +French at Smolensko--Advance of Russian Armies from North and South--Battle +of Krasnoi--Passage of the Beresina--The French reach the Niemen--York's +Convention with the Russians--The Czar and Stein--Russian Army enters +Prussia--Stein raises East Prussia--Treaty of Kalisch--Prussia declares +War--Enthusiasm of the Nation--Idea of German Unity--The Landwehr + +CHAPTER XI. + +WAR OF LIBERATION, TO THE PEACE OF PARIS. + +The War of Liberation--Bluecher crosses the Elbe--Battle of Luetzen--The +Allies retreat to Silesia--Battle of Bautzen--Armistice--Napoleon intends +to intimidate Austria--Mistaken as to the Forces of Austria--Metternich's +Policy--Treaty of Reichenbach--Austria offers its Mediation--Congress of +Prague--Austria enters the War--Armies and Plans of Napoleon and the +Allies--Campaign of August--Battles of Dresden, Grosbeeren, the Katzbach, +and Kulm--Effect of these Actions--Battle of Dennewitz--German Policy of +Austria favourable to the Princes of the Rhenish Confederacy--Frustrated +hopes of German Unity--Battle of Leipzig--The Allies reach the Rhine-- +Offers of Peace at Frankfort--Plan of Invasion of France--Backwardness of +Austria--The Allies enter France--Campaign of 1814--Congress of +Chatillon--Napoleon moves to the rear of the Allies--The Allies advance +on Paris--Capitulation of Paris--Entry of the Allies--Dethronement of +Napoleon--Restoration of the Bourbons--The Charta--Treaty of Paris-- +Territorial effects of the War, 1792-1814--Every Power except France had +gained--France relatively weaker in Europe--Summary of the permanent +effects of this period on Europe + +END OF VOL. I. (ORIGINAL EDITION). + + +CHAPTER XII. + +THE RESTORATION. + +The Restoration of 1814--Norway--Naples--Westphalia--Spain--The Spanish +Constitution overthrown: victory of the clergy--Restoration in France--The +Charta--Encroachments of the nobles and clergy--Growing hostility to the +Bourbons--Congress of Vienna--Talleyrand and the Four Powers--The Polish +question--The Saxon question--Theory of Legitimacy--Secret alliance +against Russia and Prussia--Compromise--The Rhenish Provinces--Napoleon +leaves Elba and lands in France--His declarations--Napoleon at Grenoble, +at Lyons, at Paris--The Congress of Vienna unites Europe against +France--Murat's action in Italy--The Acte Additionnel--The Champ de +Mai--Napoleon takes up the offensive--Battles of Ligny, Quatre Bras, +Waterloo--Affairs at Paris--Napoleon sent to St. Helena--Wellington and +Fouche--Arguments on the proposed cession of French territory--Treaty of +Holy Alliance--Second Treaty of Paris--Conclusion of the work of the +Congress of Vienna--Federation of Germany--Estimate of the Congress of +Vienna and of the Treaties of 1815--The Slave Trade + +CHAPTER XIII. + +THE PROGRESS OF REACTION. + +Concert of Europe after 1815--Spirit of the Foreign Policy of Alexander, of +Metternich, and of the English Ministry--Metternich's action in Italy, +England's in Sicily and Spain--The Reaction in France--Richelieu and the +New Chamber--Execution of Ney--Imprisonments and persecutions--Conduct of +the Ultra-Royalists in Parliament--Contests on the Electoral Bill and the +Budget--The Chamber prorogued--Affair of Grenoble--Dissolution of the +Chamber--Electoral Law and Financial Settlement of 1817--Character of the +first years of peace in Europe generally--Promise of a Constitution in +Prussia--Hardenberg opposed by the partisans of autocracy and +privilege--Schmalz' Pamphlet--Delay of Constitutional Reform in Germany at +large--The Wartburg Festival--Progress of Reaction--The Czar now inclines +to repression--Congress of Aix-la-Chapelle--Evacuation of France--Growing +influence of Metternich in Europe--His action on Prussia--Murder of +Kotzebue--The Carlsbad Conference and measures of repression in +Germany--Richelieu and Decazes--Murder of the Duke of Berry--Progress of +the reaction in France--General causes of the victory of reaction in Europe + +CHAPTER XIV. + +THE MEDITERRANEAN MOVEMENTS OF 1820. + +Movements in the Mediterranean States beginning in 1820--Spain from +1814 to 1820--The South American Colonies--The Army at Cadiz: Action +of Quiroga and Riego--Movement at Corunna--Ferdinand accepts the +Constitution of 1812--Naples from 1815 to 1820--The Court-party, the +Muratists, the Carbonari--The Spanish Constitution proclaimed at +Naples--Constitutional movement in Portugal--Alexander's proposal with +regard to Spain--The Conference and Declaration of Troppau--Protest of +England--Conference of Laibach--The Austrians invade Naples and restore +absolute Monarchy--Insurrection in Piedmont, which fails--Spain from +1820 to 1822--Death of Castlereagh--The Congress of Verona--Policy of +England--The French invade Spain--Restoration of absolute Monarchy, and +violence of the reaction--England prohibits the conquest of the Spanish +Colonies by France, and subsequently recognises their independence-- +Affairs in Portugal--Canning sends troops to Lisbon--The Policy of +Canning--Estimate of his place in the history of Europe + +CHAPTER XV. + +GREECE AND EASTERN AFFAIRS. + +Condition of Greece: its Races and Institutions--The Greek Church +--Communal System--The AEgaean Islands--The Phanariots--Greek intellectual +revival: Koraes--Beginning of Greek National Movement; Contact of Greece +with the French Revolution and Napoleon--The Hetaeria Philike--Hypsilanti's +Attempt in the Danubian Provinces: its failure--Revolt of the Morea: +Massacres: Execution of Gregorius, and Terrorism at Constantinople +--Attitude of Russia, Austria, and England--Extension of the Revolt: +Affairs at Hydra--The Greek Leaders--Fall of Tripolitza--The Massacre of +Chios--Failure of the Turks in the Campaign of 1822--Dissensions of the +Greeks--Mahmud calls upon Mehemet Ali for Aid--Ibrahim conquers Crete and +invades the Murea--Siege of Missolonghi--Philhellenism in Europe--Russian +proposal for Intervention--Conspiracies in Russia: Death of Alexander: +Accession of Nicholas--Military Insurrection at St. Petersburg-- +Anglo-Russian Protocol--Treaty between England, Russia, and France--Death +of Canning--Navarino--War between Russia and Turkey--Campaigns of 1828 and +1829--Treaty of Adrianople--Capodistrias President of Greece--Leopold +accepts and then declines the Greek Crown--Murder of Capodistrias--Otho, +King of Greece + +CHAPTER XVI. + +THE MOVEMENTS OF 1830. + +France before 1830--Reign of Charles X.--Ministry of Martignac--Ministry +of Polignac--The Duke of Orleans--War in Algiers--The July Ordinances-- +Revolution of July--Louis Philippe King--Nature and effects of the July +Revolution--Affairs in Belgium--The Belgian Revolution--The Great +Powers--Intervention, and establishment of the Kingdom of Belgium--Affairs +of Poland--Insurrection at Warsaw--War between Russia and Poland--Overthrow +of the Poles: End of the Polish Constitution--Affairs of Italy-- +Insurrection in the Papal States--France and Austria--Austrian +Intervention--Ancona occupied by the French--Affairs of Germany--Prussia; +the Zollverein--Brunswick, Hanover, Saxony--The Palatinate--Reaction in +Germany--The exiles in Switzerland: Incursion into Savoy--Dispersion of the +Exiles--France under Louis Philippe: Successive risings--Period of +Parliamentary activity--England after 1830: The Reform Bill + +CHAPTER XVII. + +SPANISH AND EASTERN AFFAIRS. + +France and England after 1830--Affairs of Portugal--Don Miguel--Don Pedro +invades Portugal--Ferdinand of Spain--The Pragmatic Sanction--Death of +Ferdinand: Regency of Christina--The Constitution--Quadruple +Alliance--Miguel and Carlos expelled from Portugal--Carlos enters +Spain--The Basque Provinces--Carlist War: Zumalacarregui--The Spanish +Government seeks French assistance, which is refused--Constitution of +1837--End of the War--Regency of Espartero--Isabella Queen--Affairs of +the Ottoman Empire--Ibrahim invades Syria; his victories--Rivalry of +France and Russia at Constantinople--Peace of Kutaya and Treaty of Unkiar +Skelessi--Effect of this Treaty--France and Mehemet Ali--Commerce of the +Levant--Second War between Mehemet and the Porte--Ottoman disasters--The +Policy of the Great Powers--Quadruple Treaty without France--Ibrahim +expelled from Syria--Final Settlement--Turkey after 1840--Attempted +reforms of Reschid Pasha + +CHAPTER XVIII. + +EUROPE BEFORE 1848. + +Europe during the Thirty-years' Peace--Italy and Austria--Mazzini--The +House of Savoy--Gioberti--Election of Pius IX.--Reforms expected-- +Revolution at Palermo--Agitation in Northern Italy--Lombardy--State of +the Austrian Empire--Growth of Hungarian national spirit--The Magyars +and Slavs--Transylvania--Parties among the Magyars--Kossuth--The Slavic +national movements in Austria--The government enters on reforms in +Hungary--Policy of the Opposition--The Rural system of Austria-- +Insurrection in Galicia: the nobles and the peasants--Agrarian +edict--Public opinion in Vienna--Prussia--Accession and character of +King Frederick William IV.--Convocation of the United Diet--Its +debates and dissolution--France--The Spanish Marriages--Reform +movement--Socialism--Revolution of February--End of the Orleanist +Monarchy + +END OF VOL. II. (ORIGINAL EDITION). + + +CHAPTER XIX. + +THE MARCH REVOLUTION, 1848. + +Europe in 1789 and in 1848--Agitation in Western Germany before and +after the Revolution at Paris--Austria and Hungary--The March Revolution +at Vienna--Flight of Metternich--The Hungarian Diet--Hungary wins its +independence--Bohemian movement--Autonomy promised to Bohemia-- +Insurrection of Lombardy--Of Venice--Piedmont makes war on Austria--A +general Italian war against Austria imminent--The March Days at +Berlin--Frederick William IV.--A National Assembly promised-- +Schleswig-Holstein--Insurrection in Holstein--War between Germany and +Denmark--The German Ante-Parliament--Republican Rising in Baden--Meeting +of the German National Assembly at Frankfort--Europe generally in March, +1848--The French Provisional Government--The National Workshops--The +Government and the Red Republicans--French National Assembly--Riot of +May 15--Measures against the National Workshops--The Four Days of +June--Cavaignac--Louis Napoleon--He is elected to the Assembly--Elected +President + +CHAPTER XX. + +THE PERIOD OF CONFLICT, DOWN TO THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE SECOND FRENCH +EMPIRE. + +Austria and Italy--Vienna from March to May--Flight of the Emperor +--Bohemian National Movement--Windischgraetz subdues Prague--Campaign around +Verona--Papal Allocution--Naples in May--Negotiations as to Lombardy-- +Reconquest of Venetia--Battle of Custozza--The Austrians enter +Milan--Austrian Court and Hungary--The Serbs in Southern Hungary--Serb +Congress at Carlowitz--Jellacic--Affairs of Croatia--Jellacic, the Court +and the Hungarian Movement--Murder of Lamberg--Manifesto of October 3-- +Vienna on October 6--The Emperor at Olmuetz--Windischgraetz conquers +Vienna--The Parliament at Kremsier--Schwarzenberg Minister--Ferdinand +abdicates--Dissolution of the Kremsier Parliament--Unitary Edict--Hungary +--The Roumanians in Transylvania--The Austrian Army occupies Pesth-- +Hungarian Government at Debreczin--The Austrians driven out of +Hungary--Declaration of Hungarian Independence--Russian Intervention--The +Hungarian Summer Campaign--Capitulation of Vilagos--Italy--Murder of +Rossi--Tuscany--The March Campaign in Lombardy--Novara--Abdication of +Charles Albert--Victor Emmanuel--Restoration in Tuscany--French +Intervention in Rome--Defeat of Oudinot--Oudinot and Lesseps--The French +enter Rome--The Restored Pontifical Government--Fall of Venice--Ferdinand +reconquers Sicily--Germany--The National Assembly at Frankfort--The +Armistice of Malmoe--Berlin from April to September--The Prussian Army--Last +Days of the Prussian Parliament--Prussian Constitution granted by +Edict--The German National Assembly and Austria--Frederick William IV. +elected Emperor--He refuses the Crown--End of the National Assembly-- +Prussia attempts to form a separate Union--The Union Parliament at +Erfurt--Action of Austria--Hesse-Cassel--The Diet of Frankfort +restored--Olmuetz--Schleswig-Holstein--Germany after 1849--Austria after +1851--France after 1848--Louis Napoleon--The October Message--Law Limiting +the Franchise--Louis Napoleon and the Army--Proposed Revision of the +Constitution--The Coup d'Etat--Napoleon III. Emperor + +CHAPTER XXI. + +THE CRIMEAN WAR. + +England and France in 1851--Russia under Nicholas--The Hungarian +Refugees--Dispute between France and Russia on the Holy Places--Nicholas +and the British Ambassador--Lord Stratford de Redcliffe--Menschikoff's +Mission--Russian troops enter the Danubian Principalities--Lord Aberdeen's +Cabinet--Movements of the Fleets--The Vienna Note--The Fleets pass the +Dardanelles--Turkish Squadron destroyed at Sinope--Declaration of +War--Policy of Austria--Policy of Prussia--The Western Powers and the +European Concert--Siege of Silistria--The Principalities evacuated-- +Further objects of the Western Powers--Invasion of the Crimea--Battle of +the Alma--The Flank March--Balaclava--Inkermann--Winter in the +Crimea--Death of Nicholas--Conference of Vienna--Austria--Progress of the +Siege--Plans of Napoleon III.--Canrobert and Pelissier--Unsuccessful +Assault--Battle of the Tchernaya--Capture of the Malakoff--Fall of +Sebastopol--Fall of Kars--Negotiations for Peace--The Conference of +Paris--Treaty of Paris--The Danubian Principalities--Continued discord in +the Ottoman Empire--Revision of the Treaty of Paris in 1871 + +CHAPTER XXII. + +THE CREATION OF THE ITALIAN KINGDOM. + +Piedmont after 1849--Ministry of Azeglio--Cavour Prime Minister--Designs +of Cavour--His Crimean Policy--Cavour at the Conference of Paris--Cavour +and Napoleon III.--The Meeting at Plombieres--Preparations in Italy--Treaty +of January, 1859--Attempts at Mediation--Austrian Ultimatum--Campaign of +1859--Magenta--Movement in Central Italy--Solferino--Napoleon and +Prussia--Interview of Villafranca--Cavour resigns--Peace of Zuerich--Central +Italy after Villafranca--The Proposed Congress--"The Pope and the +Congress"--Cavour resumes office--Cavour and Napoleon--Union of the Duchies +and the Romagna with Piedmont--Savoy and Nice added to France--Cavour on +this cession--European opinion--Naples--Sicily--Garibaldi lands at +Marsala--Capture of Palermo--The Neapolitans evacuate Sicily--Cavour and +the Party of Action--Cavour's Policy as to Naples--Garibaldi on the +mainland--Persano and Villamarina at Naples--Garibaldi at Naples--The +Piedmontese Army enters Umbria and the Marches--Fall of Ancona--Garibaldi +and Cavour--The Armies on the Volturno--Fall of Gaeta--Cavour's Policy +with regard to Rome and Venice--Death of Cavour--The Free Church in the +Free State + +CHAPTER XXIII. + +GERMAN ASCENDENCY WON BY PRUSSIA. + +Germany after 1858--The Regency in Prussia--Army-reorganisation--King +William I.--Conflict between the Crown and the Parliament--Bismarck--The +struggle continued--Austria from 1859--The October Diploma--Resistance of +Hungary--The Reichsrath--Russia under Alexander II.--Liberation of the +Serfs--Poland--The Insurrection of 1863--Agrarian measures in Poland-- +Schleswig-Holstein--Death of Frederick VII.--Plans of Bismarck--Campaign +in Schleswig--Conference of London--Treaty of Vienna--England and Napoleon +III.--Prussia and Austria--Convention of Gastein--Italy--Alliance of +Prussia with Italy--Proposals for a Congress fail--War between Austria and +Prussia--Napoleon III.--Koeniggraetz--Custozza--Mediation of Napoleon +--Treaty of Prague--South Germany--Projects for compensation to +France--Austria and Hungary--Deak--Establishment of the Dual System in +Austria-Hungary + +CHAPTER XXIV. + +THE WAR BETWEEN FRANCE AND GERMANY. + +Napoleon III.--The Mexican Expedition--Withdrawal of the French and death +of Maximilian--The Luxemburg Question--Exasperation in France against +Prussia--Austria--Italy--Mentana--Germany after 1866--The Spanish +Candidature of Leopold of Hohenzollern--French declaration--Benedetti and +King William--Withdrawal of Leopold and demand for guarantees--The telegram +from Ems--War--Expected Alliances of France--Austria--Italy--Prussian +plans--The French army--Causes of French inferiority--Weissenburg--Woerth-- +Spicheren--Borny--Mars-la-Tour--Gravelotte--Sedan--The Republic proclaimed +at Paris--Favre and Bismarck--Siege of Paris--Gambetta at Tours--The Army +of the Loire--Fall of Metz--Fighting at Orleans--Sortie of Champigny--The +Armies of the North, of the Loire, of the East--Bourbaki's ruin-- +Capitulation of Paris and Armistice--Preliminaries of Peace--Germany-- +Establishment of the German Empire--The Commune of Paris--Second Siege-- +Effects of the war as to Russia and Italy--Rome + +CHAPTER XXV. + +EASTERN AFFAIRS. + +France after 1871--Alliance of the Three Emperors--Revolt of Herzegovina-- +The Andrassy Note--Murder of the Consuls at Salonika--The Berlin +Memorandum--Rejected by England--Abdul Aziz deposed--Massacres in +Bulgaria--Servia and Montenegro declare War--Opinion in England--Disraeli-- +Meeting of Emperors at Reichstadt--Servian Campaign--Declaration of the +Czar--Conference at Constantinople--Its Failure--The London Protocol-- +Russia declares War--Advance on the Balkans--Osman at Plevna--Second Attack +on Plevna--The Shipka Pass--Roumania--Third Attack on Plevna--Todleben-- +Fall of Plevna--Passage of the Balkans--Armistice--England--The Fleet +passes the Dardanelles--Treaty of San Stefano--England and Russia--Secret +Agreement--Convention with Turkey--Congress of Berlin--Treaty of +Berlin--Bulgaria + + +MAPS. + +EUROPEAN STATES IN 1792 + +CENTRAL EUROPE IN 1812 + + + + +MODERN EUROPE. + + + + +CHAPTER I. + + +Outbreak of the Revolutionary War in 1792--Its immediate causes-- +Declaration of Pillnitz made and withdrawn--Agitation of the Priests and +Emigrants--War Policy of the Gironde--Provocations offered to France by +the Powers--State of Central Europe in 1792--The Holy Roman Empire-- +Austria--Rule of the Hapsburgs--The Reforms of Maria Theresa and Joseph +II.--Policy of Leopold II.--Government and Foreign Policy of Francis +II.--Prussia--Government of Frederick William II.--Social condition or +Prussia--Secondary States of Germany--Ecclesiastical States--Free +Cities--Knights--Weakness of Germany + + +On the morning of the 19th of April, 1792, after weeks of stormy agitation +in Paris, the Ministers of Louis XVI. brought down a letter from the King +to the Legislative Assembly of France. The letter was brief but +significant. It announced that the King intended to appear in the Hall of +Assembly at noon on the following day. Though the letter did not disclose +the object of the King's visit, it was known that Louis had given way to +the pressure of his Ministry and the national cry for war, and that a +declaration of war against Austria was the measure which the King was about +to propose in person to the Assembly. On the morrow the public thronged the +hall; the Assembly broke off its debate at midday in order to be in +readiness for the King. Louis entered the hall in the midst of deep +silence, and seated himself beside the President in the chair which was now +substituted for the throne of France. At the King's bidding General +Dumouriez, Minister of Foreign Affairs, read a report to the Assembly upon +the relations of France to foreign Powers. The report contained a long +series of charges against Austria, and concluded with the recommendation of +war. When Dumouriez ceased reading Louis rose, and in a low voice declared +that he himself and the whole of the Ministry accepted the report read to +the Assembly; that he had used every effort to maintain peace, and in vain; +and that he was now come, in accordance with the terms of the Constitution, +to propose that the Assembly declare war against the Austrian Sovereign. It +was not three months since Louis himself had supplicated the Courts of +Europe for armed aid against his own subjects. The words which he now +uttered were put in his mouth by men whom he hated, but could not resist: +the very outburst of applause that followed them only proved the fatal +antagonism that existed between the nation and the King. After the +President of the Assembly had made a short answer, Louis retired from the +hall. The Assembly itself broke up, to commence its debate on the King's +proposal after an interval of some hours. When the House re-assembled in +the evening, those few courageous men who argued on grounds of national +interest and justice against the passion of the moment could scarcely +obtain a hearing. An appeal for a second day's discussion was rejected; the +debate abruptly closed; and the declaration of war was carried against +seven dissentient votes. It was a decision big with consequences for France +and for the world. From that day began the struggle between Revolutionary +France and the established order of Europe. A period opened in which almost +every State on the Continent gained some new character from the aggressions +of France, from the laws and political changes introduced by the conqueror, +or from the awakening of new forces of national life in the crisis of +successful resistance or of humiliation. It is my intention to trace the +great lines of European history from that time to the present, briefly +sketching the condition of some of the principal States at the outbreak of +the Revolutionary War, and endeavouring to distinguish, amid scenes of +ever-shifting incident, the steps by which the Europe of 1792 has become +the Europe of today. + +[First threats of foreign Courts against France, 1791.] + +The first two years of the Revolution had ended without bringing France +into collision with foreign Powers. This was not due to any goodwill that +the Courts of Europe bore to the French people, or to want of effort on the +part of the French aristocracy to raise the armies of Europe against their +own country. The National Assembly, which met in 1789, had cut at the roots +of the power of the Crown; it had deprived the nobility of their privilees, +and laid its hand upon the revenues of the Church. The brothers of King +Louis XVI., with a host of nobles too impatient to pursue a course of +steady political opposition at home, quitted France, and wearied foreign +Courts with their appeals for armed assistance. The absolute monarchs of +the Continent gave them a warm and even ostentatious welcome; but they +confined their support to words and tokens of distinction, and until the +summer of 1791 the Revolution was not seriously threatened with the +interference of the stranger. The flight of King Louis from Paris in June, +1791, followed by his capture and his strict confinement within the +Tuileries, gave rise to the first definite project of foreign intervention. +[4] Louis had fled from his capital and from the National Assembly; he +returned, the hostage of a populace already familiar with outrage and +bloodshed. For a moment the exasperation of Paris brought the Royal Family +into real jeopardy. The Emperor Leopold, brother of Marie Antoinette, +trembled for the safety of his unhappy sister, and addressed a letter to +the European Courts from Padua, on the 6th of July, proposing that the +Powers should unite to preserve the Royal Family of France from popular +violence. Six weeks later the Emperor and King Frederick William II. of +Prussia met at Pillnitz, in Saxony. A declaration was published by the two +Sovereigns, stating that they considered the position of the King of France +to be matter of European concern, and that, in the event of all the other +great Powers consenting to a joint action, they were prepared to supply an +armed force to operate on the French frontier. + +[Declaration of Pillnitz withdrawn.] + +Had the National Assembly instantly declared war on Leopold and Frederick +William, its action would have been justified by every rule of +international law. The Assembly did not, however, declare war, and for a +good reason. It was known at Paris that the manifesto was no more than a +device of the Emperor's to intimidate the enemies of the Royal Family. +Leopold, when he pledged himself to join a coalition of all the Powers, was +in fact aware that England would be no party to any such coalition. He was +determined to do nothing that would force him into war; and it did not +occur to him that French politicians would understand the emptiness of his +threats as well as he did himself. Yet this turned out to be the case; and +whatever indignation the manifesto of Pillnitz excited in the mass of the +French people, it was received with more derision than alarm by the men who +were cognisant of the affairs of Europe. All the politicians of the +National Assembly knew that Prussia and Austria had lately been on the +verge of war with one another upon the Eastern question; they even +underrated the effect of the French revolution in appeasing the existing +enmities of the great Powers. No important party in France regarded the +Declaration of Pillnitz as a possible reason for hostilities; and the +challenge given to France was soon publicly withdrawn. It was withdrawn +when Louis XVI., by accepting the Constitution made by the National +Assembly, placed himself, in the sight of Europe, in the position of a free +agent. On the 14th September, 1791, the King, by a solemn public oath, +identified his will with that of the nation. It was known in Paris that he +had been urged by the emigrants to refuse his assent, and to plunge the +nation into civil war by an open breach with the Assembly. The frankness +with which Louis pledged himself to the Constitution, the seeming sincerity +of his patriotism, again turned the tide of public opinion in his favour. +His flight was forgiven; the restrictions placed upon his personal liberty +were relaxed. Louis seemed to be once more reconciled with France, and +France was relieved from the ban of Europe. The Emperor announced that the +circumstances which had provoked the Declaration of Pillnitz no longer +existed, and that the Powers, though prepared to revive the League if +future occasion should arise, suspended all joint action in reference to +the internal affairs of France. + +[Priests and emigrants keep France in agitation.] + +The National Assembly, which, in two years, had carried France so far +towards the goal of political and social freedom, now declared its work +ended. In the mass of the nation there was little desire for further +change. The grievances which pressed most heavily upon the common course of +men's lives--unfair taxation, exclusion from public employment, monopolies +among the townspeople, and the feudal dues which consumed the produce of +the peasant--had been swept away. It was less by any general demand for +further reform than by the antagonisms already kindled in the Revolution +that France was forced into a new series of violent changes. The King +himself was not sincerely at one with the nation; in everything that most +keenly touched his conscience he had unwillingly accepted the work of the +Assembly. The Church and the noblesse were bent on undoing what had already +been done. Without interfering with doctrine or ritual, the National +Assembly had re-organised the ecclesiastical system of France, and had +enforced that supremacy of the State over the priesthood to which, +throughout the eighteenth century, the Governments of Catholic Europe had +been steadily tending. The Civil Constitution of the Clergy, which was +created by the National Assembly in 1790, transformed the priesthood from a +society of landowners into a body of salaried officers of the State, and +gave to the laity the election of their bishops and ministers. The change, +carried out in this extreme form, threw the whole body of bishops and a +great part of the lower clergy into revolt. Their interests were hurt by +the sale of the Church lands; their consciences were wounded by the system +of popular election, which was condemned by the Pope. In half the pulpits +of France the principles of the Revolution were anathematised, and the +vengeance of heaven denounced against the purchasers of the secularised +Church lands. Beyond the frontier the emigrant nobles, who might have +tempered the Revolution by combining with the many liberal men of their +order who remained at home, gathered in arms, and sought the help of +foreigners against a nation in which they could see nothing but rebellious +dependents of their own. The head-quarters of the emigrants were at +Coblentz in the dominions of the Elector of Treves. They formed themselves +into regiments, numbering in all some few thousands, and occupied +themselves with extravagant schemes of vengeance against all Frenchmen who +had taken part in the destruction of the privileges of their caste. + +[Legislative Assembly. Oct. 1791.] + +[War policy of the Gironde.] + +Had the elections which followed the dissolution of the National Assembly +sent to the Legislature a body of men bent only on maintaining the +advantages already won, it would have been no easy task to preserve the +peace of France in the presence of the secret or open hostility of the +Court, the Church, and the emigrants. But the trial was not made. The +leading spirits among the new representatives were not men of compromise. +In the Legislative Body which met in 1791 there were all the passions of +the Assembly of 1789, without any of the experience which that Assembly had +gained. A decree, memorable among the achievements of political folly, had +prohibited members of the late Chamber from seeking re-election. The new +Legislature was composed of men whose political creed had been drawn almost +wholly from literary sources; the most dangerous theorists of the former +Assembly were released from Parliamentary restraints, and installed, like +Robespierre, as the orators of the clubs. Within the Chamber itself the +defenders of the Monarchy and of the Constitution which had just been given +to France were far outmatched by the party of advance. The most conspicuous +of the new deputies formed the group named after the district of the +Gironde, where several of their leaders had been elected. The orator +Vergniaud, pre-eminent among companions of singular eloquence, the +philosopher Condorcet, the veteran journalist Brissot, gave to this party +an ascendancy in the Chamber and an influence in the country the more +dangerous because it appeared to belong to men elevated above the ordinary +regions of political strife. Without the fixed design of turning the +monarchy into a republic, the orators of the Gironde sought to carry the +revolutionary movement over the barrier erected against it in the +Constitution of 1791. From the moment of the opening of the Assembly it was +clear that the Girondins intended to precipitate the conflict between the +Court and the nation by devoting all the wealth of their eloquence to the +subjects which divided France the most. To Brissot and the men who +furnished the ideas of the party, it would have seemed a calamity that the +Constitution of 1791, with its respect for the prerogative of the Crown and +its tolerance of mediaeval superstition, should fairly get underway. In +spite of Robespierre's prediction that war would give France a strong +sovereign in the place of a weak one, the Girondins persuaded themselves +that the best means of diminishing or overthrowing monarchical power in +France was a war with the sovereigns of Europe; and henceforward they +laboured for war with scarcely any disguise. [5] + +[Notes of Kaunitz, Dec. 21, Feb. 17.] + +Nor were occasions wanting, if war was needful for France. The protection +which the Elector of Treves gave to the emigrant army at Coblentz was so +flagrant a violation of international law that the Gironde had the support +of the whole nation when they called upon the King to demand the dispersal +of the emigrants in the most peremptory form. National feeling was keenly +excited by debates in which the military preparations of the emigrants and +the encouragement given to them by foreign princes were denounced with all +the energy of southern eloquence. On the 13th of December Louis declared to +the Electors of Treves and Mainz that he would treat them as enemies unless +the armaments within their territories were dispersed by January 15th; and +at the same time he called upon the Emperor Leopold, as head of the +Germanic body, to use his influence in bringing the Electors to reason. The +demands of France were not resisted. On the 16th January, 1792, Louis +informed the Assembly that the emigrants had been expelled from the +electorates, and acknowledged the good offices of Leopold in effecting this +result. The substantial cause of war seemed to have disappeared; but +another had arisen in its place. In a note of December 21st the Austrian +Minister Kaunitz used expressions which implied that a league of the Powers +was still in existence against France. Nothing could have come more +opportunely for the war-party in the Assembly. Brissot cried for an +immediate declaration of war, and appealed to the French nation to +vindicate its honour by an attack both upon the emigrants and upon their +imperial protector. The issue depended upon the relative power of the Crown +and the Opposition. Leopold saw that war was inevitable unless the +Constitutional party, which was still in office, rallied for one last +effort, and gained a decisive victory over its antagonists. In the hope of +turning public opinion against the Gironde, he permitted Kaunitz to send a +despatch to Paris which loaded the leaders of the war-party with abuse, and +exhorted the French nation to deliver itself from men who would bring upon +it the hostility of Europe. (Feb. 17.) [6] The despatch gave singular proof +of the inability of the cleverest sovereign and the most experienced +minister of the age to distinguish between the fears of a timid cabinet and +the impulses of an excited nation. Leopold's vituperations might have had +the intended effect if they had been addressed to the Margrave of Baden or +the Doge of Venice; addressed to the French nation and its popular Assembly +in the height of civil conflict, they were as oil poured upon the flames. +Leopold ruined the party which he meant to reinforce; he threw the nation +into the arms of those whom he attacked. His despatch was received in the +Assembly with alternate murmurs and bursts of laughter; in the clubs it +excited a wild outburst of rage. The exchange of diplomatic notes continued +for a few weeks more; but the real answer of France to Austria was the +"Marseillaise," composed at Strasburg almost simultaneously with Kaunitz' +attack upon the Jacobins. The sudden death of the Emperor on March 1st +produced no pause in the controversy. Delessart, the Foreign Minister of +Louis, was thrust from office, and replaced by Dumouriez, the +representative of the war-party. + +[War declared, April 20th, 1792.] + +Expostulation took a sharper tone; old subjects of complaint were revived; +and the armies on each side were already pressing towards the frontier when +the unhappy Louis was brought down to the Assembly by his Ministers, and +compelled to propose the declaration of war. + +[Pretended grounds of war.] + +[Expectation of foreign attack real among the French people; not real among +the French politicians.] + +It is seldom that the professed grounds correspond with the real motives of +a war; nor was this the case in 1792. The ultimatum of the Austrian +Government demanded that compensation should be made to certain German +nobles whose feudal rights over their peasantry had been abolished in +Alsace; that the Pope should be indemnified for Avignon and the Venaissin, +which had been taken from him by France; and that a Government should be +established at Paris capable of affording the Powers of Europe security +against the spread of democratic agitation. No one supposed the first two +grievances to be a serious ground for hostilities. The rights of the German +nobles in Alsace over their villagers were no doubt protected by the +treaties which ceded those districts to France; but every politician in +Europe would have laughed at a Government which allowed the feudal system +to survive in a corner of its dominions out of respect for a settlement a +century and a half old: nor had the Assembly refused to these foreign +seigneurs a compensation claimed in vain by King Louis for the nobles of +France. As to the annexation of Avignon and the Venaissin, a power which, +like Austria, had joined in dismembering Poland, and had just made an +unsuccessful attempt to dismember Turkey, could not gravely reproach France +for incorporating a district which lay actually within it, and whose +inhabitants, or a great portion of them, were anxious to become citizens of +France. The third demand, the establishment of such a government as Austria +should deem satisfactory, was one which no high-spirited people could be +expected to entertain. Nor was this, in fact, expected by Austria. Leopold +had no desire to attack France, but he had used threats, and would not +submit to the humiliation of renouncing them. He would not have begun a war +for the purpose of delivering the French Crown; but, when he found that he +was himself certain to be attacked, he accepted a war with the Revolution +without regret. On the other side, when the Gironde denounced the league of +the Kings, they exaggerated a far-off danger for the ends of their domestic +policy. The Sovereigns of the Continent had indeed made no secret of their +hatred to the Revolution. Catherine of Russia had exhorted every Court in +Europe to make war; Gustavus of Sweden was surprised by a violent death in +the midst of preparations against France; Spain, Naples, and Sardinia were +ready to follow leaders stronger than themselves. But the statesmen of the +French Assembly well understood the interval that separates hostile feeling +from actual attack; and the unsubstantial nature of the danger to France, +whether from the northern or the southern Powers, was proved by the very +fact that Austria, the hereditary enemy of France, and the country of the +hated Marie Antoinette, was treated as the main enemy. Nevertheless, the +Courts had done enough to excite the anger of millions of French people who +knew of their menaces, and not of their hesitations and reserves. The man +who composed the "Marseillaise" was no maker of cunningly-devised fables; +the crowds who first sang it never doubted the reality of the dangers which +the orators of the Assembly denounced. The Courts of Europe had heaped up +the fuel; the Girondins applied the torch. The mass of the French nation +had little means of appreciating what passed in Europe; they took their +facts from their leaders, who considered it no very serious thing to plunge +a nation into war for the furtherance of internal liberty. Events were soon +to pass their own stern and mocking sentence upon the wisdom of the +Girondin statesmanship. + +[Germany follows Austria into the war.] + +[State of Germany.] + +After voting the Declaration of War the French Assembly accepted a +manifesto, drawn up by Condorcet, renouncing in the name of the French +people all intention of conquest. The manifesto expressed what was +sincerely felt by men like Condorcet, to whom the Revolution was still too +sacred a cause to be stained with the vulgar lust of aggrandisement. But +the actual course of the war was determined less by the intentions with +which the French began it than by the political condition of the States +which bordered upon the French frontier. The war was primarily a war with +Austria, but the Sovereign of Austria was also the head of Germany. The +German Ecclesiastical Princes who ruled in the Rhenish provinces had been +the most zealous protectors of the emigrants; it was impossible that they +should now find shelter in neutrality. Prussia had made an alliance with +the Emperor against France; other German States followed in the wake of one +or other of the great Powers. If France proved stronger than its enemy, +there were governments besides that of Austria which would have to take +their account with the Revolution. Nor indeed was Austria the power most +exposed to violent change. The mass of its territory lay far from France; +at the most, it risked the loss of Lombardy and the Netherlands. Germany at +large was the real area threatened by the war, and never was a political +community less fitted to resist attack than Germany at the end of the +eighteenth century. It was in the divisions of the German people, and in +the rivalries of the two leading German governments, that France found its +surest support throughout the Revolutionary war, and its keenest stimulus +to conquest. It will throw light upon the sudden changes that now began to +break over Europe if we pause to make a brief survey of the state of +Germany at the outbreak of the war, to note the character and policy of its +reigning sovereigns, and to cast a glance over the circumstances which had +brought the central district of Europe into its actual condition. + +[Since 1648, all the German States independent of the Emperor.] + +[Holy Roman Empire.] + +Germany at large still preserved the mediaeval name and forms of the Holy +Roman Empire. The members of this so-called Empire were, however, a +multitude of independent States; and the chief of these States, Austria, +combined with its German provinces a large territory which did not even in +name form part of the Germanic body. The motley of the Empire was made up +by governments of every degree of strength and weakness. Austria and +Prussia possessed both political traditions and resources raising them to +the rank of great European Powers; but the sovereignties of the second +order, such as Saxony and Bavaria, had neither the security of strength nor +the free energy often seen in small political communities; whilst in the +remaining petty States of Germany, some hundreds in number, all public life +had long passed out of mind in a drowsy routine of official benevolence or +oppression. In theory there still existed a united Germanic body; in +reality Germany was composed of two great monarchies in embittered rivalry +with one another, and of a multitude of independent principalities and +cities whose membership in the Empire involved little beyond a liability to +be dragged into the quarrels of their more powerful neighbours. A German +national feeling did not exist, because no combination existed uniting the +interests of all Germany. The names and forms of political union had come +down from a remote past, and formed a grotesque anachronism amid the +realities of the eighteenth century. The head of the Germanic body held +office not by hereditary right, but as the elected successor of Charlemagne +and the Roman Caesars. Since the fifteenth century the imperial dignity had +rested with the Austrian House of Hapsburg; but, with the exception of +Charles V., no sovereign of that House had commanded forces adequate to the +creation of a united German state, and the opportunity which then offered +itself was allowed to pass away. The Reformation severed Northern Germany +from the Catholic monarchy of the south. The Thirty Years' War, terminating +in the middle of the seventeenth century, secured the existence of +Protestantism on the Continent of Europe, but it secured it at the cost of +Germany, which was left exhausted and disintegrated. By the Treaty of +Westphalia, A.D. 1648, the independence of every member of the Empire was +recognised, and the central authority was henceforth a mere shadow. The +Diet of the Empire, where the representatives of the Electors, of the +Princes, and of the Free Cities, met in the order of the Middle Ages, sank +into a Heralds' College, occupied with questions of title and precedence; +affairs of real importance were transacted by envoys from Court to Court. +For purposes of war the Empire was divided into Circles, each Circle +supplying in theory a contingent of troops; but this military organisation +existed only in letter. The greater and the intermediate States regulated +their armaments, as they did their policy, without regard to the Diet of +Ratisbon; the contingents of the smaller sovereignties and free cities were +in every degree of inefficiency, corruption, and disorder; and in spite of +the courage of the German soldier, it could make little difference in a +European war whether a regiment which had its captain appointed by the city +of Gmuend, its lieutenant by the Abbess of Rotenmuenster, and its ensign by +the Abbot of Gegenbach, did or did not take the field with numbers fifty +per cent. below its statutory contingent. [7] How loose was the connection +subsisting between the members of the Empire, how slow and cumbrous its +constitutional machinery, was strikingly proved after the first inroads of +the French into Germany in 1792, when the Diet deliberated for four weeks +before calling out the forces of the Empire, and for five months before +declaring war. + +[Austria.] + +[Catholic policy of the Hapsburgs.] + +The defence of Germany rested in fact with the armies of Austria and +Prussia. The Austrian House of Hapsburg held the imperial title, and +gathered around it the sovereigns of the less progressive German States. +While the Protestant communities of Northern Germany identified their +interests with those of the rising Prussian Monarchy, religious sympathy +and the tradition of ages attached the minor Catholic Courts to the +political system of Vienna. Austria gained something by its patronage; it +was, however, no real member of the German family. Its interests were not +the interests of Germany; its power, great and enduring as it proved, was +not based mainly upon German elements, nor used mainly for German ends. The +title of the Austrian monarch gave the best idea of the singular variety of +races and nationalities which owed their political union only to their +submission to a common head. In the shorter form of state the reigning +Hapsburg was described as King of Hungary, Bohemia, Croatia, Slavonia, and +Galicia; Archduke of Austria; Grand Duke of Transylvania; Duke of Styria, +Carinthia, and Carniola; and Princely Count of Hapsburg and Tyrol. At the +outbreak of the war of 1792 the dominions of the House of Austria included +the Southern Netherlands and the Duchy of Milan, in addition to the great +bulk of the territory which it still governs. Eleven distinct languages +were spoken in the Austrian monarchy, with countless varieties of dialects. +Of the elements of the population the Slavic was far the largest, numbering +about ten millions, against five million Germans and three million Magyars; +but neither numerical strength nor national objects of desire coloured the +policy of a family which looked indifferently upon all its subject races as +instruments for its own aggrandisement. Milan and the Netherlands had come +into the possession of Austria since the beginning of the eighteenth +century, but the destiny of the old dominions of the Hapsburg House had +been fixed for many generations in the course of the Thirty Years' War. In +that struggle, as it affected Austria, the conflict of the ancient and the +reformed faith had become a conflict between the Monarchy, allied with the +Church, and every element of national life and independence, allied with +the Reformation. Protestantism, then dominant in almost all the Hapsburg +territories, was not put down without extinguishing the political liberties +of Austrian Germany, the national life of Bohemia, the spirit and ambition +of the Hungarian nobles. The detestable desire of the Emperor Ferdinand, +"Rather a desert than a country full of heretics," was only too well +fulfilled in the subsequent history of his dominions. In the German +provinces, except the Tyrol, the old Parliaments, and with them all trace +of liberty, disappeared; in Bohemia the national Protestant nobility lost +their estates, or retained them only at the price of abandoning the +religion, the language, and the feelings of their race, until the country +of Huss passed out of the sight of civilised Europe, and Bohemia +represented no more than a blank, unnoticed mass of tillers of the soil. In +Hungary, where the nation was not so completely crushed in the Thirty +Years' War, and Protestantism survived, the wholesale executions in 1686, +ordered by the Tribunal known as the "Slaughter-house of Eperies," +illustrated the traditional policy of the Monarchy towards the spirit of +national independence. Two powers alone were allowed to subsist in the +Austrian dominions, the power of the Crown and the power of the Priesthood; +and, inasmuch as no real national unity could exist among the subject +races, the unity of a blind devotion to the Catholic Church was enforced +over the greater part of the Monarchy by all the authority of the State. + +[Reforms of Maria Theresa, 1740-1780.] + +Under the pressure of this soulless despotism the mind of man seemed to +lose all its finer powers. The seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, in +which no decade passed in England and France without the production of some +literary masterpiece, some scientific discovery, or some advance in +political reasoning, are marked by no single illustrious Austrian name, +except that of Haydn the musician. When, after three generations of torpor +succeeding the Thirty Years' War, the mind of North Germany awoke again in +Winckelmann and Lessing, and a widely-diffused education gave to the middle +class some compensation for the absence of all political freedom, no trace +of this revival appeared in Austria. The noble hunted and slept; the serf +toiled heavily on; where a school existed, the Jesuit taught his schoolboys +ecclesiastical Latin, and sent them away unable to read their +mother-tongue. To this dull and impenetrable society the beginnings of +improvement could only be brought by military disaster. The loss of Silesia +in the first years of Maria Theresa disturbed the slumbers of the +Government, and reform began. Although the old provincial Assemblies, +except in Hungary and the Netherlands, had long lost all real power, the +Crown had never attempted to create a uniform system of administration: the +collection of taxes, the enlistment of recruits, was still the business of +the feudal landowners of each district. How such an antiquated order was +likely to fare in the presence of an energetic enemy was clearly enough +shown in the first attack made upon Austria by Frederick the Great. As the +basis of a better military organisation, and in the hope of arousing a +stronger national interest among her subjects, Theresa introduced some of +the offices of a centralised monarchy, at the same time that she improved +the condition of the serf, and substituted a German education and German +schoolmasters for those of the Jesuits. The peasant, hitherto in many parts +of the monarchy attached to the soil, was now made free to quit his lord's +land, and was secured from ejectment so long as he fulfilled his duty of +labouring for the lord on a fixed number of days in the year. Beyond this +Theresa's reform did not extend. She had no desire to abolish the feudal +character of country life; she neither wished to temper the sway of +Catholicism, nor to extinguish those provincial forms which gave to the +nobles within their own districts a shadow of political independence. +Herself conservative in feeling, attached to aristocracy, and personally +devout, Theresa consented only to such change as was recommended by her +trusted counsellors, and asked no more than she was able to obtain by the +charm of her own queenly character. + +[Joseph II., 1780-1790.] + +With the accession of her son Joseph II. in 1780 a new era began for +Austria. The work deferred by Theresa was then taken up by a monarch whose +conceptions of social and religious reform left little for the boldest +innovators of France ten years later to add. There is no doubt that the +creation of a great military force for enterprises of foreign conquest was +an end always present in Joseph's mind, and that the thirst for +uncontrolled despotic power never left him; but by the side of these +coarser elements there was in Joseph's nature something of the true fire of +the man who lives for ideas. Passionately desirous of elevating every class +of his subjects at the same time that he ignored all their habits and +wishes, Joseph attempted to transform the motley and priest-ridden +collection of nations over whom he ruled into a single homogeneous body, +organised after the model of France and Prussia, worshipping in the spirit +of a tolerant and enlightened Christianity, animated in its relations of +class to class by the humane philosophy of the eighteenth century. In the +first year of his reign Joseph abolished every jurisdiction that did not +directly emanate from the Crown, and scattered an army of officials from +Ostend to the Dniester to conduct the entire public business of his +dominions under the immediate direction of the central authority at Vienna. +In succeeding years edict followed edict, dissolving monasteries, +forbidding Church festivals and pilgrimages, securing the protection of the +State to every form of Christian worship, abolishing the exemption from +land-tax and the monopoly of public offices enjoyed by the nobility, +transforming the Universities from dens of monkish ignorance into schools +of secular learning, converting the peasant's personal service into a +rent-charge, and giving him in the officer of the Crown a protector and an +arbiter in all his dealings with his lord. Noble and enlightened in his +aims, Joseph, like every other reformer of the eighteenth century, +underrated the force which the past exerts over the present; he could see +nothing but prejudice and unreason in the attachment to provincial custom +or time-honoured opinion; he knew nothing of that moral law which limits +the success of revolutions by the conditions which precede them. What was +worst united with what was best in resistance to his reforms. The bigots of +the University of Louvain, who still held out against the discoveries of +Newton, excited the mob to insurrection against Joseph, as the enemy of +religion; the Magyar landowners in Hungary resisted a system which +extinguished the last vestiges of their national independence at the same +time that it destroyed the harsh dominion which they themselves exercised +over their peasantry. Joseph alternated between concession and the extreme +of autocratic violence. At one moment he resolved to sweep away every local +right that fettered the exercise of his power; then, after throwing the +Netherlands into successful revolt, and forcing Hungary to the verge of +armed resistance, he revoked his unconstitutional ordinances (January 28, +1790), and restored all the institutions of the Hungarian monarchy which +existed at the date of his accession. + +[Leopold II., 1790-1792.] + +A month later, death removed Joseph from his struggle and his sorrows. His +successor, Leopold II., found the monarchy involved as Russia's ally in an +attack upon Turkey; threatened by the Northern League of Prussia, England, +and Holland; exhausted in finance; weakened by the revolt of the +Netherlands; and distracted in every province by the conflict of the +ancient and the modern system of government, and the assertion of new +social rights that seemed to have been created only in order to be +extinguished. The recovery of Belgium and the conclusion of peace with +Turkey were effected under circumstances that brought the adroit and +guarded statesmanship of Leopold into just credit. His settlement of the +conflict between the Crown and the Provinces, between the Church and +education, between the noble and the serf, marked the line in which, for +better or for worse, Austrian policy was to run for sixty years. Provincial +rights, the privileges of orders and corporate bodies, Leopold restored; +the personal sovereignty of his house he maintained unimpaired. In the more +liberal part of Joseph's legislation, the emancipation of learning from +clerical control, the suppression of unjust privilege in taxation, the +abolition of the feudal services of the peasant, Leopold was willing to +make concessions to the Church and the aristocracy; to the spirit of +national independence which his predecessor's aggression had excited in +Bohemia as well as in Hungary, he made no concession beyond the restoration +of certain cherished forms. An attempt of the Magyar nobles to affix +conditions to their acknowledgment of Leopold as King of Hungary was +defeated; and, by creating new offices at Vienna for the affairs of Illyria +and Transylvania, and making them independent of the Hungarian Diet, +Leopold showed that the Crown possessed an instrument against the dominant +Magyar race in the Slavic and Romanic elements of the Hungarian Kingdom. +[8] On the other hand, Leopold consented to restore to the Church its +control over the higher education, and to throw back the burden of taxation +upon land not occupied by noble owners. He gave new rigour to the +censorship of the press; but the gain was not to the Church, to which the +censorship had formerly belonged, but to the Government, which now employed +it as an instrument of State. In the great question of the emancipation of +the serf Leopold was confronted by a more resolute and powerful body of +nobility in Hungary than existed in any other province. The right of the +lord to fetter the peasant to the soil and to control his marriage Leopold +refused to restore in any part of his dominions; but, while in parts of +Bohemia he succeeded in maintaining the right given by Joseph to the +peasant to commute his personal service for a money payment, in Hungary he +was compelled to fall back upon the system of Theresa, and to leave the +final settlement of the question to the Diet. Twenty years later the +statesman who emancipated the peasants of Prussia observed that Hungary was +the only part of the Austrian dominions in which the peasant was not in a +better condition than his fellows in North Germany; [9] and so torpid was +the humanity of the Diet that until the year 1835 the prison and the +flogging-board continued to form a part of every Hungarian manor. + +[Death of Leopold, March 1, 1792.] + +[Francis II., 1792.] + +Of the self-sacrificing ardour of Joseph there was no trace in Leopold's +character; yet his political aims were not low. During twenty-four years' +government of Tuscany he had proved himself almost an ideal ruler in the +pursuit of peace, of religious enlightenment, and of the material +improvement of his little sovereignty. Raised to the Austrian throne, the +compromise which he effected with the Church and the aristocracy resulted +more from a supposed political necessity than from his own inclination. So +long as Leopold lived, Austria would not have wanted an intelligence +capable of surveying the entire field of public business, nor a will +capable of imposing unity of action upon the servants of State. To the +misfortune of Europe no less than of his own dominions, Leopold was carried +off by sickness at the moment when the Revolutionary War broke out. An +uneasy reaction against Joseph's reforms and a well-grounded dread of the +national movements in Hungary and the Netherlands were already the +principal forces in the official world at Vienna; in addition to these came +the new terror of the armed proselytism of the Revolution. The successor of +Leopold, Francis II., was a sickly prince, in whose homely and +unimaginative mind the great enterprises of Joseph, amidst which he had +been brought up, excited only aversion. Amongst the men who surrounded him, +routine and the dread of change made an end of the higher forms of public +life. The Government openly declared that all change should cease so long +as the war lasted; even the pressing question of the peasant's relation to +his lord was allowed to remain unsettled by the Hungarian Diet, lest the +spirit of national independence should find expression in its debates. Over +the whole internal administration of Austria the torpor of the days before +Theresa seemed to be returning. Its foreign policy, however, bore no trace +of this timorous, conservative spirit. Joseph, as restless abroad as at +home, had shared the ambition of the Russian Empress Catherine, and +troubled Europe with his designs upon Turkey, Venice, and Bavaria. These +and similar schemes of territorial extension continued to fill the minds of +Austrian courtiers and ambassadors. Shortly after the outbreak of war with +France the aged minister Kaunitz, who had been at the head of the Foreign +Office during three reigns, retired from power. In spite of the first +partition of Poland, made in combination with Russia and Prussia in 1772, +and in spite of subsequent attempts of Joseph against Turkey and Bavaria, +the policy of Kaunitz had not been one of mere adventure and shifting +attack. He had on the whole remained true to the principle of alliance with +France and antagonism to Prussia; and when the revolution brought war +within sight, he desired to limit the object of the war to the restoration +of monarchical government in France. The conditions under which the young +Emperor and the King of Prussia agreed to turn the war to purposes of +territorial aggrandisement caused Kaunitz, with a true sense of the fatal +import of this policy, to surrender the power which he had held for forty +years. It was secretly agreed between the two courts that Prussia should +recoup itself for its expenses against France by seizing part of Poland. On +behalf of Austria it was demanded that the Emperor should annex Bavaria, +giving Belgium to the Elector as compensation. Both these schemes violated +what Kaunitz held to be sound policy. He believed that the interests of +Austria required the consolidation rather than the destruction of Poland; +and he declared the exchange of the Netherlands for Bavaria to be, in the +actual state of affairs, impracticable. [10] Had the coalition of 1792 been +framed on the principles advocated by Kaunitz, though Austria might not +have effected the restoration of monarchial power in France, the alliance +would not have disgracefully shattered on the crimes and infamies attending +the second partition of Poland. + +From the moment when Kaunitz retired from office, territorial extension +became the great object of the Austrian Court. To prudent statesmen the +scattered provinces and varied population of the Austrian State would have +suggested that Austria had more to lose than any European Power; to the men +of 1792 it appeared that she had more to gain. The Netherlands might be +increased with a strip of French Flanders; Bavaria, Poland, and Italy were +all weak neighbours, who might be made to enrich Austria in their turn. A +sort of magical virtue was attached to the acquisition of territory. If so +many square miles and so many head of population were gained, whether of +alien or kindred race, mutinous or friendly, the end of all statesmanship +was realised, and the heaviest sacrifice of life and industry repaid. +Austria affected to act as the centre of a defensive alliance, and to fight +for the common purpose of giving a Government to France which would respect +the rights of its neighbours. In reality, its own military operations were +too often controlled, and an effective common warfare frustrated, at one +moment by a design upon French Flanders, at another by the course of Polish +or Bavarian intrigue, at another by the hope of conquests in Italy. Of all +the interests which centred in the head of the House of Hapsburg, the least +befriended at Vienna was the interest of the Empire and of Germany. + +[Prussia.] + +Nor, if Austria was found wanting, had Germany any permanent safeguard in +the rival Protestant State. Prussia, the second great German Power and the +ancient enemy of Austria, had been raised to an influence in Europe quite +out of proportion to its scanty resources by the genius of Frederick the +Great and the earlier Princes of the House of Hohenzollern. Its population +was not one-third of that of France or Austria; its wealth was perhaps not +superior to that of the Republic of Venice. That a State so poor in men and +money should play the part of one of the great Powers of Europe was +possible only so long as an energetic ruler watched every movement of that +complicated machinery which formed both army and nation after the prince's +own type. Frederick gave his subjects a just administration of the law; he +taught them productive industries; he sought to bring education to their +doors [11]; but he required that the citizen should account himself before +all the servant of the State. Every Prussian either worked in the great +official hierarchy or looked up to it as the providence which was to direct +all his actions and supply all his judgments. The burden of taxation +imposed by the support of an army relatively three times as great as that +of any other Power was wonderfully lightened by Frederick's economy: far +more serious than the tobacco-monopoly and the forage-requisitions, at +which Frederick's subjects grumbled during his life-time, was the danger +that a nation which had only attained political greatness by its obedience +to a rigorous administration should fall into political helplessness, when +the clear purpose and all-controlling care of its ruler no longer animated +a system which, without him, was only a pedantic routine. What in England +we are accustomed to consider as the very substance of national life,--the +mass of political interest and opinion, diffused in some degree amongst all +classes, at once the support and the judge of the servants of the +State,--had in Prussia no existence. Frederick's subjects obeyed and +trusted their Monarch; there were probably not five hundred persons outside +the public service who had any political opinions of their own. Prussia did +not possess even the form of a national representation; and, although +certain provincial assemblies continued to meet, they met only to receive +the instructions of the Crown-officers of their district. In the absence of +all public criticism, the old age of Frederick must in itself have +endangered the efficiency of the military system which had raised Prussia +to its sudden eminence. [12] The impulse of Frederick's successor was +sufficient to reverse the whole system of Prussian foreign policy, and to +plunge the country in alliance with Austria into a speculative and +unnecessary war. + +[Frederick William II., 1786.] + +[Alliance with Austria against France, Feb., 1792.] + +On the death of Frederick in 1786, the crown passed to Frederick William +II., his nephew. Frederick William was a man of common type, showy and +pleasure-loving, interested in public affairs, but incapable of acting on +any fixed principle. His mistresses gave the tone to political society. A +knot of courtiers intrigued against one another for the management of the +King; and the policy of Prussia veered from point to point as one unsteady +impulse gave place to another. In countries less dependent than Prussia +upon the personal activity of the monarch, Frederick William's faults might +have been neutralised by able Ministers; in Prussia the weakness of the +King was the decline of the State. The whole fabric of national greatness +had been built up by the royal power; the quality of the public service, +apart from which the nation was politically non-existent, was the quality +of its head. When in the palace profusion and intrigue took the place of +Frederick the Great's unflagging labour, the old uprightness, industry, and +precision which had been the pride of Prussian administration fell out of +fashion everywhere. Yet the frivolity of the Court was a less active cause +of military decline than the abandonment of the first principles of +Prussian policy. [13] If any political sentiment existed in the nation, it +was the sentiment of antagonism to Austria. The patriotism of the army, +with all the traditions of the great King, turned wholly in this direction. +When, out of sympathy with the Bourbon family and the emigrant French +nobles, Frederick William allied himself with Austria (Feb. 1792), and +threw himself into the arms of his ancient enemy in order to attack a +nation which had not wronged him, he made an end of all zealous obedience +amongst his servants. Brunswick, the Prussian Commander-in-Chief, hated the +French emigrants as much as he did the Revolution; and even the generals +who did not originally share Brunswick's dislike to the war recovered their +old jealousy of Austria after the first defeat, and exerted themselves only +to get quit of the war at the first moment that Prussia could retire from +it without disgrace. The very enterprise in which Austria had consented +that the Court of Berlin should seek its reward--the seizure of a part of +Poland--proved fatal to the coalition. The Empress Catherine was already +laying her hand for the second time upon this unfortunate country. It was +easy for the opponents of the Austrian alliance who surrounded King +Frederick William to contrast the barren effort of a war against France +with the cheap and certain advantages to be won by annexation, in concert +with Russia, of Polish territory. To pursue one of these objects with +vigour it was necessary to relinquish the other. Prussia was not rich +enough to maintain armies both on the Vistula and the Rhine. Nor, in the +opinion of its rulers, was it rich enough to be very tender of its honour +or very loyal towards its allies. [14] + +[Social system of Prussia.] + +In the institutions of Prussia two opposite systems existed side by side, +exhibiting in the strongest form a contrast which in a less degree was +present in most Continental States. The political independence of the +nobility had long been crushed; the King's Government busied itself with +every detail of town and village administration; yet along with this +rigorous development of the modern doctrine of the unity and the authority +of the State there existed a social order more truly archaic than that of +the Middle Ages at their better epochs. The inhabitants of Prussia were +divided into the three classes of nobles, burghers, and peasants, each +confined to its own stated occupations, and not marrying outside its own +order. The soil of the country bore the same distinction; peasant's land +could not be owned by a burgher; burgher's land could not be owned by a +noble. No occupation was lawful for the noble, who was usually no more than +a poor gentleman, but the service of the Crown; the peasant, even where +free, might not practise the handicraft of a burgher. But the mass of the +peasantry in the country east of the Elbe were serfs attached to the soil; +and the noble, who was not permitted to exercise the slightest influence +upon the government of his country, inherited along with his manor a +jurisdiction and police-control over all who were settled within it. +Frederick had allowed serfage to continue because it gave him in each +manorial lord a task-master whom he could employ in his own service. System +and obedience were the sources of his power; and if there existed among his +subjects one class trained to command and another trained to obey, it was +so much the easier for him to force the country into the habits of industry +which he required of it. In the same spirit, Frederick officered his army +only with men of the noble caste. They brought with them the habit of +command ready-formed; the peasants who ploughed and threshed at their +orders were not likely to disobey them in the presence of the enemy. It was +possible that such a system should produce great results so long as +Frederick was there to guard against its abuses; Frederick gone, the +degradation of servitude, the insolence of caste, was what remained. When +the army of France, led by men who had worked with their fathers in the +fields, hunted a King of Prussia amidst his capitulating grandees from the +centre to the verge of his dominions, it was seen what was the permanent +value of a system which recognised in the nature of the poor no capacity +but one for hereditary subjection. The French peasant, plundered as he was +by the State, and vexed as he was with feudal services, knew no such +bondage as that of the Prussian serf, who might not leave the spot where he +was born; only in scattered districts in the border-provinces had serfage +survived in France. It is significant of the difference in self-respect +existing in the peasantry of the two countries that the custom of striking +the common soldier, universal in Germany, was in France no more than an +abuse, practised by the admirers of Frederick, and condemned by the better +officers themselves. + +[Minor States of Germany.] + +[Ecclesiastical States.] + +In all the secondary States of Germany the government was an absolute +monarchy; though, here and there, as in Wuertemberg, the shadow of the old +Assembly of the Estates survived; and in Hanover the absence of the +Elector, King George III., placed power in the hands of a group of nobles +who ruled in his name. Society everywhere rested on a sharp division of +classes similar in kind to that of Prussia; the condition of the peasant +ranging from one of serfage, as it existed in Mecklenburg, [15] to one of +comparative freedom and comfort in parts of the southern and western +States. The sovereigns differed widely in the enlightenment or selfishness +of their rule; but, on the whole, the character of government had changed +for the better of late years; and, especially in the Protestant States, +efforts to improve the condition of the people were not wanting. Frederick +the Great had in fact created a new standard of monarchy in Germany. Forty +years earlier, Versailles, with its unfeeling splendours, its glorification +of the personal indulgence of the monarch, had been the ideal which, with a +due sense of their own inferiority, the German princes had done their best +to imitate. To be a sovereign was to cover acres of ground with state +apartments, to lavish the revenues of the country upon a troop of +mistresses and adventurers, to patronise the arts, to collect with the same +complacency the masterpieces of ancient painting that adorn the Dresden +Gallery, or an array of valuables scarcely more interesting than the chests +of treasure that were paid for them. In the ecclesiastical States, headed +by the Electorates of Mainz, Treves, and Cologne, the affectations of a +distinctive Christian or spiritual character had long been abandoned. The +prince-bishop and canons, who were nobles appointed from some other +province, lived after the gay fashion of the time, at the expense of a land +in which they had no interest extending beyond their own lifetime. The only +feature distinguishing the ecclesiastical residence from that of one of the +minor secular princes was that the parade of state was performed by monks +in the cathedral instead of by soldiers on the drill-ground, and that even +the pretence of married life was wanting among the flaunting harpies who +frequented a celibate Court. Yet even on the Rhine and on the Moselle the +influence of the great King of Prussia had begun to make itself felt. The +intense and penetrating industry of Frederick was not within the reach of +every petty sovereign who might envy its results; but the better spirit of +the time was seen under some of the ecclesiastical princes in the +encouragement of schools, the improvement of the roads, and a retrenchment +in courtly expenditure. That deeply-seated moral disease which resulted +from centuries of priestly rule was not to be so lightly shaken off. In a +district where Nature most bountifully rewards the industry of man, +twenty-four out of every hundred of the population were monks, nuns, or +beggars. [16] + +[Petty States. Free Cities. Knights.] + +Two hundred petty principalities, amongst which Weimar, the home of Goethe, +stood out in the brightest relief from the level of princely routine and +self-indulgence; fifty imperial cities, in most of which the once vigorous +organism of civic life had shrivelled to the type of the English rotten +borough, did not exhaust the divisions of Germany. Several hundred Knights +of the Empire, owing no allegiance except to the Emperor, exercised, each +over a domain averaging from three to four hundred inhabitants, all the +rights of sovereignty, with the exception of the right to make war and +treaties. The districts in which this order survived were scattered over +the Catholic States of the south-west of Germany, where the knights +maintained their prerogatives by federations among themselves and by the +support of the Emperor, to whom they granted sums of money. There were +instances in which this union of the rights of the sovereign and the +landlord was turned to good account; but the knight's land was usually the +scene of such poverty and degradation that the traveller needed no guide to +inform him when he entered it. Its wretched tracks interrupted the great +lines of communication between the Rhine and further Germany; its hovels +were the refuge of all the criminals and vagabonds of the surrounding +country; for no police existed but the bailiffs of the knight, and the only +jurisdiction was that of the lawyer whom the knight brought over from the +nearest town. Nor was the disadvantage only on the side of those who were +thus governed. The knight himself, even if he cherished some traditional +reverence for the shadow of the Empire, was in the position of a man who +belongs to no real country. If his sons desired any more active career than +that of annuitants upon the family domains, they could obtain it only by +seeking employment at one or other of the greater Courts, and by +identifying themselves with the interests of a land which they entered as +strangers. + +Such was in outline the condition of Germany at the moment when it was +brought into collision with the new and unknown forces of the French +Revolution. A system of small States, which in the past of Greece and Italy +had produced the finest types of energy and genius, had in Germany resulted +in the extinction of all vigorous life, and in the ascendancy of all that +was stagnant, little, and corrupt. If political disorganisation, the decay +of public spirit, and the absence of a national idea, are the signs of +impending downfall, Germany was ripe for foreign conquest. The obsolete and +dilapidated fabric of the Empire had for a century past been sustained only +by the European tradition of the Balance of Power, or by the absence of +serious attack from without. Austria once overpowered, the Empire was ready +to fall to pieces by itself: and where, among the princes or the people of +Germany, were the elements that gave hope of its renovation in any better +form of national life? + + + + +CHAPTER II. + + +French and Austrian armies on the Flemish frontier--Prussia enters the +war--Brunswick invades France--His Proclamation--Insurrection of Aug. 10 +at Paris--Massacres of September--Character of the war--Brunswick, checked +at Valmy, retreats--The War becomes a Crusade of France--Neighbours of +France--Custine enters Mainz--Dumouriez conquers the Austrian Netherlands +--Nice and Savoy annexed--Decree of the Convention against all Governments +--Execution of Louis XVI.--War with England, followed by war with the +Mediterranean States--Condition of England--English Parties, how affected +by the Revolution--The Gironde and the Mountain--Austria recovers the +Netherlands--The Allies invade France--La Vendee--Revolutionary System of +1793--Errors of the Allies--New French Commanders and Democratic Army-- +Victories of Jourdan, Hoche, and Pichegru--Prussia withdrawing from the War +--Polish Affairs--Austria abandons the Netherlands--Treaties of +Basle--France in 1795--Insurrection of 13 Vendemiaire--Constitution of +1795--The Directory--Effect of the Revolution on the spirit of Europe up +to 1795. + + +[Fighting on Flemish frontier, April, 1792.] + +[Prussian army invades France, July, 1792. Proclamation.] + +The war between France and Austria opened in April, 1792, on the Flemish +frontier. The first encounters were discreditable to the French soldiery, +who took to flight and murdered one of their generals. The discouragement +with which the nation heard of these reverses deepened into sullen +indignation against the Court, as weeks and months passed by, and the +forces lay idle on the frontier or met the enemy only in trifling +skirmishes which left both sides where they were before. If at this crisis +of the Revolution, with all the patriotism, all the bravery, all the +military genius of France burning for service, the Government conducted the +war with results scarcely distinguishable from those of a parade, the +suggestion of treason on the part of the Court was only too likely to be +entertained. The internal difficulties of the country were increasing. The +Assembly had determined to banish from France the priests who rejected the +new ecclesiastical system, and the King had placed his veto upon their +decree. He had refused to permit the formation of a camp of volunteers in +the neighbourhood of Paris. He had dismissed the popular Ministry forced +upon him by the Gironde. A tumult on the 20th of June, in which the mob +forced their way into the Tuileries, showed the nature of the attack +impending upon the monarchy if Louis continued to oppose himself to the +demands of the nation; but the lesson was lost upon the King. Louis was as +little able to nerve himself for an armed conflict with the populace as to +reconcile his conscience to the Ecclesiastical Decrees, and he surrendered +himself to a pious inertia at a moment when the alarm of foreign invasion +doubled revolutionary passion all over France. Prussia, in pursuance of a +treaty made in February, united its forces to those of Austria. Forty +thousand Prussian troops, under the Duke of Brunswick, the best of +Frederick's surviving generals, advanced along the Moselle. From Belgium +and the upper Rhine two Austrian armies converged upon the line of +invasion; and the emigrant nobles were given their place among the forces +of the Allies. + +On the 25th of July the Duke of Brunswick, in the name of the Emperor and +the King of Prussia, issued a proclamation to the French people, which, but +for the difference between violent words and violent deeds, would have left +little to be complained of in the cruelties that henceforward stained the +popular cause. In this manifesto, after declaring that the Allies entered +France in order to deliver Louis from captivity, and that members of the +National Guard fighting against the invaders would be punished as rebels +against their king, the Sovereigns addressed themselves to the city of +Paris and to the representatives of the French nation:--"The city of Paris +and its inhabitants are warned to submit without delay to their King; to +set that Prince at entire liberty, and to show to him and to all the Royal +Family the inviolability and respect which the law of nature and of nations +imposes on subjects towards their Sovereigns. Their Imperial and Royal +Majesties will hold all the members of the National Assembly, of the +Municipality, and of the National Guard of Paris responsible for all events +with their heads, before military tribunals, without hope of pardon. They +further declare that, if the Tuileries be forced or insulted, or the least +violence offered to the King, the Queen, or the Royal Family, and if +provision be not at once made for their safety and liberty, they will +inflict a memorable vengeance, by delivering up the city of Paris to +military execution and total overthrow, and the rebels guilty of such +crimes to the punishment they have merited." [17] + +[Insurrection August 10, 1972.] + +This challenge was not necessary to determine the fate of Louis. Since the +capture of the Bastille in the first days of the Revolution the National +Government had with difficulty supported itself against the populace of the +capital; and, even before the foreigner threatened Paris with fire and +sword, Paris had learnt to look for the will of France within itself. As +the columns of Brunswick advanced across the north-eastern frontier, Danton +and the leaders of the city-democracy marshalled their army of the poor and +the desperate to overthrow that monarchy whose cause the invader had made +his own. The Republic which had floated so long in the thoughts of the +Girondins was won in a single day by the populace of Paris, amid the roar +of cannons and the flash of bayonets. On the 10th of August Danton let +loose the armed mob upon the Tuileries. Louis quitted the Palace without +giving orders to the guard either to fight or to retire; but the guard were +ignorant that their master desired them to offer no resistance, and one +hundred and sixty of the mob were shot down before an order reached the +troops to abandon the Palace. The cruelties which followed the victory of +the people indicated the fate in store for those whom the invader came to +protect. It is doubtful whether the foreign Courts would have made any +serious attempt to undo the social changes effected by the Revolution in +France; but no one supposed that those thousands of self-exiled nobles who +now returned behind the guns of Brunswick had returned in order to take +their places peacefully in the new social order. In their own imagination, +as much as in that of the people, they returned with fire and sword to +repossess themselves of rights of which they had been despoiled, and to +take vengeance upon the men who were responsible for the changes made in +France since 1789. [18] In the midst of a panic little justified by the +real military situation, Danton inflamed the nation with his own passionate +courage and resolution; he unhappily also thought it necessary to a +successful national defence that the reactionary party at Paris should be +paralysed by a terrible example. The prisons were filled with persons +suspected of hostility to the national cause, and in the first days of +September many hundreds of these unfortunate persons were massacred by +gangs of assassins paid by a committee of the Municipality. Danton did not +disguise his approval of the act. He had made up his mind that the work of +the Revolution could only be saved by striking terror into its enemies, and +by preventing the Royalists from co-operating with the invader. But the +multitudes who flocked to the standards of 1792 carried with them the +patriotism of Danton unstained by his guilt. Right or wrong in its origin, +the war was now unquestionably a just one on the part of France, a war +against a privileged class attempting to recover by force the unjust +advantages that they had not been able to maintain, a war against the +foreigner in defence of the right of the nation to deal with its own +government. Since the great religious wars there had been no cause so +rooted in the hearts, so close to the lives of those who fought for it. +Every soldier who joined the armies of France in 1792 joined of his own +free will. No conscription dragged the peasant to the frontier. Men left +their homes in order that the fruit of the poor man's labour should be his +own, in order that the children of France should inherit some better +birthright than exaction and want, in order that the late-won sense of +human right should not be swept from the earth by the arms of privilege and +caste. It was a time of high-wrought hope, of generous and pathetic +self-sacrifice; a time that left a deep and indelible impression upon those +who judged it as eye-witnesses. Years afterwards the poet Wordsworth, then +alienated from France and cold in the cause of liberty, could not recall +without tears the memories of 1792. [19] + +[Brunswick checked at Valmy, Sept. 20.] + +[Retreat of Brunswick.] + +The defence of France rested on General Dumouriez. The fortresses of Longwy +and Verdun, covering the passage of the Meuse, had fallen after the +briefest resistance; the troops that could be collected before Brunswick's +approach were too few to meet the enemy in the open field. Happily for +France the slow advance of the Prussian general permitted Dumouriez to +occupy the difficult country of the Argonne, where, while waiting for his +reinforcements, he was able for some time to hold the invaders in check. At +length Brunswick made his way past the defile which Dumouriez had chosen +for his first line of defence; but it was only to find the French posted in +such strength on his flank that any further advance would imperil his own +army. If the advance was to be continued, Dumouriez must be dislodged. +Accordingly, on the 20th of September, Brunswick directed his artillery +against the hills of Valmy, where the French left was encamped. The +cannonade continued for some hours, but it was followed by no general +attack. The firmness of the French under Brunswick's fire made it clear +that they would not be displaced without an obstinate battle; and, +disappointed of victory, the King of Prussia began to listen to proposals +of peace sent to him by Dumouriez. [20] A week spent in negotiation served +only to strengthen the French and to aggravate the scarcity and sickness +within the German camp. Dissensions broke out between the Prussian and +Austrian commanders; a retreat was ordered; and to the astonishment of +Europe the veteran forces of Brunswick fell back before the mutinous +soldiery and unknown generals of the Revolution, powerless to delay for a +single month the evacuation of France and the restoration of the fortresses +which they had captured. + +[The Convention meets. Proclaims Republic, Sept. 21.] + +[The war becomes a crusade of democracy.] + +In the meantime the Legislative Assembly had decreed its own dissolution in +consequence of the overthrow of the monarchy on August both, and had +ordered the election of representatives to frame a constitution for France. +The elections were held in the crisis of invasion, in the height of +national indignation against the alliance of the aristocracy with the +foreigner, and, in some districts, under the influence of men who had not +shrunk from ordering the massacres in the prisons. At such a moment a +Constitutional Royalist had scarcely more chance of election than a +detected spy from the enemy's camp. The Girondins, who had been the party +of extremes in the Legislative Assembly, were the party of moderation and +order in the Convention. By their side there were returned men whose whole +being seemed to be compounded out of the forces of conflict, men who, +sometimes without conscious depravity, carried into political and social +struggles that direct, unquestioning employment of force which has +ordinarily been reserved for war or for the diffusion of religious +doctrines. The moral differences that separated this party from the Gironde +were at once conspicuous: the political creed of the two parties appeared +at first to be much the same. Monarchy was abolished, and France declared a +Republic (Sept. 21). Office continued in the hands of the Gironde; but the +vehement, uncompromising spirit of their rivals, the so-called party of the +Mountain, quickly made itself felt in all the relations of France to +foreign Powers. The intention of conquest might still be disavowed, as it +had been five months before; but were the converts to liberty to be denied +the right of uniting themselves to the French people by their own free +will? When the armies of the Republic had swept its assailants from the +border-provinces that gave them entrance into France, were those provinces +to be handed back to a government of priests and nobles? The scruples which +had condemned all annexation of territory vanished in that orgy of +patriotism which followed the expulsion of the invader and the discovery +that the Revolution was already a power in other lands than France. The +nation that had to fight the battle of European freedom must appeal to the +spirit of freedom wherever it would answer the call: the conflict with +sovereigns must be maintained by arming their subjects against them in +every land. In this conception of the universal alliance of the nations, +the Governments with which France was not yet at war were scarcely +distinguished from those which had pronounced against her. The +frontier-lines traced by an obsolete diplomacy, the artificial guarantees +of treaties, were of little account against the living and inalienable +sovereignty of the people. To men inflamed with the passions of 1792 an +argument of international law scarcely conveyed more meaning than to Peter +the Hermit. Among the statesmen of other lands, who had no intention of +abandoning all the principles recognised as the public right of Europe, the +language now used by France could only be understood as the avowal of +indiscriminate aggression. + +[The neighbors of France.] + +The Revolution had displayed itself in France as a force of union as well +as of division. It had driven the nobles across the frontier; it had torn +the clergy from their altars; but it had reconciled sullen Corsica; and by +abolishing feudal rights it had made France the real fatherland of the +Teutonic peasant in Alsace and Lorraine. It was now about to prove its +attractive power in foreign lands. At the close of the last century the +nationalities of Europe were far less consolidated than they are at +present; only on the Spanish and the Swiss frontier had France a neighbour +that could be called a nation. On the north, what is now the kingdom of +Belgium was in 1792 a collection of provinces subject to the House of +Austria. The German population both of the districts west of the Rhine and +of those opposite to Alsace was parcelled out among a number of petty +principalities. Savoy, though west of the chain of the Alps and French in +speech, formed part of the kingdom of Piedmont, which was itself severed by +history and by national character from the other States of Northern Italy. +Along the entire frontier, from Dunkirk to the Maritime Alps, France +nowhere touched a strong, united, and independent people; and along this +entire frontier, except in the country opposite Alsace, the armed +proselytism of the French Revolution proved a greater force than the +influences on which the existing order of things depended. In the Low +Countries, in the Principalities of the Rhine, in Switzerland, in Savoy, in +Piedmont itself, the doctrines of the Revolution were welcomed by a more or +less numerous class, and the armies of France appeared, though but for a +moment, as the missionaries of liberty and right rather than as an invading +enemy. + +[Custine enters Mainz, Oct. 20.] + +No sooner had Brunswick been brought to a stand by Dumouriez at Valmy than +a French division under Custine crossed the Alsatian frontier and advanced +upon Spires, where Brunswick had left large stores of war. The garrison was +defeated in an encounter outside the town; Spires and Worms surrendered to +Custine. In the neighbouring fortress of Mainz, the key to Western Germany, +Custine's advance was watched by a republican party among the inhabitants, +from whom the French general learnt that he had only to appear before the +city to become its master. Brunswick had indeed apprehended the failure of +his invasion of France, but he had never given a thought to the defence of +Germany; and, although the King of Prussia had been warned of the +defenceless state of Mainz, no steps had been taken beyond the payment of a +sum of money for the repair of the fortifications, which money the +Archbishop expended in the purchase of a wood belonging to himself and the +erection of a timber patchwork. On news arriving of the capture of Spires, +the Archbishop fled, leaving the administration to the Dean, the +Chancellor, and the Commandant. The Chancellor made a speech, calling upon +his "beloved brethren" the citizens to defend themselves to the last +extremity, and daily announced the overthrow of Dumouriez and the +approaching entry of the Allies into Paris, until Custine's soldiers +actually came into sight. [21] Then a council of war declared the city to +be untenable; and before Custine had brought up a single siege-gun the +garrison capitulated, and the French were welcomed into Mainz by the +partisans of the Republic (Oct. 20). With the French arms came the French +organisation of liberty. A club was formed on the model of the Jacobin Club +of Paris; existing officers and distinctions of rank were abolished; and +although the mass of the inhabitants held aloof, a Republic was finally +proclaimed, and incorporated with the Republic of France. + +[Dumouriez invades the Netherlands.] + +[Battle of Jemappes, Nov. 6.] + +The success of Custine's raid into Germany did not divert the Convention +from the design of attacking Austria in the Netherlands, which Dumouriez +had from the first pressed upon the Government. It was not three years +since the Netherlands had been in revolt against the Emperor Joseph. In its +origin the revolt was a reactionary movement of the clerical party against +Joseph's reforms; but there soon sprang up ambitions and hopes at variance +with the first impulses of the insurrection; and by the side of monks and +monopolists a national party came into existence, proclaiming the +sovereignty of the people, and imitating all the movements of the French +Revolution. During the brief suspension of Austrian rule the popular and +the reactionary parties attacked one another; and on the restoration of +Leopold's authority in 1791 the democratic leaders, with a large body of +their followers, took refuge beyond the frontier, looking forward to the +outbreak of war between Austria and France. Their partisans formed a French +connection in the interior of the country; and by some strange illusion, +the priests themselves and the close corporations which had been attacked +by Joseph supposed that their interests would be respected by Revolutionary +France. [22] Thus the ground was everywhere prepared for a French invasion. +Dumouriez crossed the frontier. The border fortresses no longer existed; +and after a single battle won by the French at Jemappes on the 6th of +November, [23] the Austrians, finding the population universally hostile, +abandoned the Netherlands without a struggle. + +[Nice and Savoy annexed.] + +[Decree of Dec. 15.] + +The victory of Jemappes, the first pitched battle won by the Republic, +excited an outburst of revolutionary fervour in the Convention which deeply +affected the relations of France to Great Britain, hitherto a neutral +spectator of the war. A manifesto was published declaring that the French +nation offered its alliance to all peoples who wished to recover their +freedom, and charging the generals of the Republic to give their protection +to all persons who might suffer in the cause of liberty (Nov. 19). A week +later Savoy and Nice were annexed to France, the population of Savoy having +declared in favour of France and Sardinia. On the 15th of December the +Convention proclaimed that social and political revolution was henceforth +to accompany every movement of its armies on foreign soil. "In every +country that shall be occupied by the armies of the French Republic"--such +was the substance of the Decree of December 15th--"the generals shall +announce the abolition of all existing authorities; of nobility, of +serfage, of every feudal right and every monopoly; they shall proclaim the +sovereignty of the people, and convoke the inhabitants in assemblies to +form a provisional Government, to which no officer of a former Government, +no noble, nor any member of the former privileged corporations shall be +eligible. They shall place under the charge of the French Republic all +property belonging to the Sovereign or his adherents, and the property of +every civil or religious corporation. The French nation will treat as +enemies any people which, refusing liberty and equality, desires to +preserve its prince and privileged castes, or to make any accommodation +with them." + +[England arms.] + +[The Schelde.] + +[Execution of Louis XVI., Jan. 21, 1793.] + +This singular announcement of a new crusade caused the Government of Great +Britain to arm. Although the decree of the Convention related only to +States with which France was at war, the Convention had in fact formed +connections with the English revolutionary societies; and the French +Minister of Marine informed his sailors that they were about to carry fifty +thousand caps of liberty to their English brethren. No prudent statesman +would treat a mere series of threats against all existing authorities as +ground for war; but the acts of the French Government showed that it +intended to carry into effect the violent interference in the affairs of +other nations announced in its manifestoes. Its agents were stirring up +dissatisfaction in every State; and although the annexation of Savoy and +the occupation of the Netherlands might be treated as incidental to the +conflict with Austria and Sardinia, in which Great Britain had pledged +itself to neutrality, other acts of the Convention were certainly +infringements of the rights of allies of England. A series of European +treaties, oppressive according to our own ideas, but in keeping with the +ideas of that age, prohibited the navigation of the River Schelde, on which +Antwerp is situated, in order that the commerce of the North Sea might flow +exclusively into Dutch ports. On the conquest of Belgium the French +Government gave orders to Dumouriez to send a flotilla down the river, and +to declare Antwerp an open port in right of the law of nature, which +treaties cannot abrogate. Whatever the folly of commercial restraints, the +navigation of the Schelde was a question between the Antwerpers and the +Dutch, and one in which France had no direct concern. The incident, though +trivial, was viewed in England as one among many proofs of the intention of +the French to interfere with the affairs of neighbouring States at their +pleasure. In ordinary times it would not have been easy to excite much +interest in England on behalf of a Dutch monopoly; but the feeling of this +country towards the French Revolution had been converted into a passionate +hatred by the massacres of September, and by the open alliance between the +Convention and the Revolutionary societies in England itself. Pitt indeed, +whom the Parisians imagined to be their most malignant enemy, laboured +against the swelling national passion, and hoped against all hope for +peace. Not only was Pitt guiltless of the desire to add this country to the +enemies of France, but he earnestly desired to reconcile France with +Austria, in order that the Western States, whose embroilment left Eastern +Europe at the mercy of Catherine of Russia, might unite to save both Poland +and Turkey from falling into the hands of a Power whose steady aggression +threatened Europe more seriously than all the noisy and outspoken +excitement of the French Convention. Pitt, moreover, viewed with deep +disapproval the secret designs of Austria and Prussia. [24] If the French +executive would have given any assurance that the Netherlands should not be +annexed, or if the French ambassador, Chauvelin, who was connected with +English plotters, had been superseded by a trustworthy negotiator, it is +probable that peace might have been preserved. But when, on the execution +of King Louis (Jan. 21, 1793), Chauvelin was expelled from England as a +suspected alien, war became a question of days. [25] + +[Holland and Mediterranean States enter the war.] + +[War with England, Feb. 1st, 1793.] + +Points of technical right figured in the complaints of both sides; but the +real ground of war was perfectly understood. France considered itself +entitled to advance the Revolution and the Rights of Man wherever its own +arms or popular insurrection gave it the command. England denied the right +of any Power to annul the political system of Europe at its pleasure. No +more serious, no more sufficient, ground of war ever existed between two +nations; yet the event proved that, with the highest justification for war, +the highest wisdom would yet have chosen peace. England's entry into the +war converted it from an affair of two or three campaigns into a struggle +of twenty years, resulting in more violent convulsions, more widespread +misery, and more atrocious crimes, than in all probability would have +resulted even from the temporary triumph of the revolutionary cause in +1793. But in both nations political passion welcomed impending calamity; +and the declaration of war by the Convention on February 1st only +anticipated the desire of the English people. Great Britain once committed +to the struggle, Pitt spared neither money nor intimidation in his efforts +to unite all Europe against France. Holland was included with England in +the French declaration of war. The Mediterranean States felt that the navy +of England was nearer to them than the armies of Austria and Prussia; and +before the end of the summer of 1793, Spain, Portugal, Naples, Tuscany, and +the Papal States had joined the Coalition. + +[French wrongly think England inclined to revolution.] + +The Jacobins of Paris had formed a wrong estimate of the political +condition of England. At the outbreak of the war they believed that England +itself was on the verge of revolution. They mistook the undoubted +discontent of a portion of the middle and lower classes, which showed +itself in the cry for parliamentary reform, for a general sentiment of +hatred towards existing institutions, like that which in France had swept +away the old order at a single blow. The Convention received the addresses +of English Radical societies, and imagined that the abuses of the +parliamentary system under George III. had alienated the whole nation. What +they had found in Belgium and in Savoy--a people thankful to receive the +Rights of Man from the soldiers of the Revolution--they expected to find +among the dissenting congregations of London and the factory-hands of +Sheffield. The singular attraction exercised by each class in England upon +the one below it, as well as the indifference of the nation generally to +all ideals, was little understood in France, although the Revolutions of +the two countries bore this contrast on their face. A month after the fall +of the Bastille, the whole system of class-privilege and monopoly had +vanished from French law; fifteen years of the English Commonwealth had +left the structure of English society what it had been at the beginning. +But political observation vanished in the delirium of 1793; and the French +only discovered, when it was too late, that in Great Britain the Revolution +had fallen upon an enemy of unparalleled stubbornness and inexhaustible +strength. + +[The Whigs not democratic.] + +[Political condition of England.] + +In the first Assembly of the Revolution it was usual to speak of the +English as free men whom the French ought to imitate; in the Convention it +was usual to speak of them as slaves whom the French ought to deliver. The +institutions of England bore in fact a very different aspect when compared +with the absolute monarchy of the Bourbons and when compared with the +democracy of 1793. Frenchmen who had lived under the government of a Court +which made laws by edict and possessed the right to imprison by +letters-patent looked with respect upon the Parliament of England, its +trial by jury, and its freedom of the press. The men who had sent a king to +prison and confiscated the estates of a great part of the aristocracy could +only feel compassion for a land where three-fourths of the national +representatives were nominees of the Crown or of wealthy peers. Nor, in +spite of the personal sympathy of Fox with the French revolutionary +movement, was there any real affinity between the English Whig party and +that which now ruled in the Convention. The event which fixed the character +of English liberty during the eighteenth century, the Revolution of 1688, +had nothing democratic in its nature. That revolution was directed against +a system of Roman Catholic despotism; it gave political power not to the +mass of the nation, which had no desire and no capacity to exercise it, but +to a group of noble families and their retainers, who, during the reigns of +the first two Georges, added all the patronage and influence of the Crown +to their social and constitutional weight in the country. The domestic +history of England since the accession of George III. had turned chiefly +upon the obstinate struggle of this monarch to deliver himself from all +dependence upon party. The divisions of the Whigs, their jealousies, but, +above all, their real alienation from the mass of the people whose rights +they professed to defend, ultimately gave the King the victory, when, after +twenty years of errors, be found in the younger Pitt a Minister capable of +uniting the interests of the Crown with the ablest and most patriotic +liberal statesmanship. Bribes, threats, and every species of base influence +had been employed by King George to break up the great Coalition of 1783, +which united all sections of the Whigs against him under the Ministry of +Fox and North; but the real support of Pitt, whom the King placed in office +with a minority in the House of Commons, was the temper of the nation +itself, wearied with the exclusiveness, the corruption, and the +party-spirit of the Whigs, and willing to believe that a popular Minister, +even if he had entered upon power unconstitutionally, might do more for the +country than the constitutional proprietors of the rotten boroughs. + +[Pitt Minister, 1783.] + +[Effect of French Revolution on English Parties.] + +From 1783 down to the outbreak of the French Revolution, Pitt, as a Tory +Minister confronted by a Whig Opposition, governed England on more liberal +principles than any statesman who had held power during the eighteenth +century. These years were the last of the party-system of England in its +original form. The French Revolution made an end of that old distinction in +which the Tory was known as the upholder of Crown-prerogative and the Whig +as the supporter of a constitutional oligarchy of great families. It +created that new political antagonism in which, whether under the names of +Whig and Tory, or of Liberal and Conservative, two great parties have +contended, one for a series of beneficial changes, the other for the +preservation of the existing order. The convulsions of France and the dread +of revolutionary agitation in England transformed both Pitt and the Whigs +by whom he was opposed. Pitt sacrificed his schemes of peaceful progress to +foreign war and domestic repression, and set his face against the reform of +Parliament which he had once himself proposed. The Whigs broke up into two +sections, led respectively by Burke and by Fox, the one denouncing the +violence of the Revolution, and ultimately uniting itself with Pitt; the +other friendly to the Revolution, in spite of its excesses, as the cause of +civil and religious liberty, and identifying itself, under the healthy +influence of parliamentary defeat and disappointment, with the defence of +popular rights in England and the advocacy of enlightened reform. + +[Burke's "Reflections," Oct. 1790.] + +[Most of the Whigs support Pitt against France.] + +The obliteration of the old dividing-line in English politics may be said +to date from the day when the ancient friendship of Burke and Fox was +bitterly severed by the former in the House of Commons (May 6, 1791). The +charter of the modern Conservative party was that appeal to the nation +which Burke had already published, in the autumn of 1790, under the title +of "Reflections on the French Revolution." In this survey of the political +forces which he saw in action around him, the great Whig writer, who in +past times had so passionately defended the liberties of America and the +constitutional tradition of the English Parliament against the aggression +of George III., attacked the Revolution as a system of violence and caprice +more formidable to freedom than the tyranny of any Crown. He proved that +the politicians and societies of England who had given it their sympathy +had given their sympathy to measures and to theories opposed to every +principle of 1688. Above all, he laid bare that agency of riot and +destructiveness which, even within the first few months of the Revolution, +filled him with presentiment of the calamities about to fall upon France. +Burke's treatise was no dispassionate inquiry into the condition of a +neighbouring state: it was a denunciation of Jacobinism as fierce and as +little qualified by political charity as were the maledictions of the +Hebrew prophets upon their idolatrous neighbours; and it was intended, like +these, to excite his own countrymen against innovations among themselves. +It completely succeeded. It expressed, and it heightened, the alarm arising +among the Liberal section of the propertied class, at first well inclined +to the Revolution; and, although the Whigs of the House of Commons +pronounced in favour of Fox upon his first rupture with Burke, the tide of +public feeling, rising higher with every new outrage of the Revolution, +soon invaded the legislature, and carried the bulk of the Whig party to the +side of the Minister, leaving to Fox and his few faithful adherents the +task of maintaining an unheeded protest against the blind passions of war, +and the increasing rigour with which Pitt repressed every symptom of +popular disaffection. + +[The Gironde and the Mountain in the Convention.] + +[The Gironde and the Commune of Paris.] + +The character of violence which Burke traced and condemned in the earliest +acts of the Revolution displayed itself in a much stronger light after the +overthrow of the Monarchy by the insurrection of August 10th. That event +was the work of men who commanded the Parisian democracy, not the work of +orators and party-leaders in the Assembly. The Girondins had not hesitated +to treat the victory as their own, by placing the great offices of State, +with one exception, in the hands of their leaders; they instantly found +that the real sovereignty lay elsewhere. The Council of the Commune, or +Municipality, of Paris, whose members had seized their post at the moment +of the insurrection, was the only administrative body that possessed the +power to enforce its commands; in the Ministries of State one will alone +made itself felt, that of Danton, whom the Girondins had unwillingly +admitted to office along with themselves. The massacres of September threw +into full light the powerlessness of the expiring Assembly. For five +successive days it was unable to check the massacres; it was unable to +bring to justice the men who had planned them, and who called upon the rest +of France to follow their example. With the meeting of the Convention, +however, the Girondins, who now regarded themselves as the legitimate +government, and forgot that they owed office to an insurrection, expected +to reduce the capital to submission. They commanded an overwhelming +majority in the new chamber; they were supported by the middle class in all +the great cities of France. The party of the Mountain embraced at first +only the deputies of Paris, and a group of determined men who admitted no +criticism on the measures which the democracy of Paris had thought +necessary for the Revolution. In the Convention they were the assailed, not +the assailants. Without waiting to secure themselves by an armed force, the +orators of the Gironde attempted to crush both the Municipality and the +deputies who ruled at the Clubs. They reproached the Municipality with the +murders of September; they accused Robespierre of aiming at the +Dictatorship. It was under the pressure of these attacks that the party of +the Mountain gathered its strength within the Convention, and that the +populace of Paris transferred to the Gironde the passionate hatred which it +had hitherto borne to the King and the aristocracy. The gulf that lay +between the people and those who had imagined themselves to be its leaders +burst into view. The Girondins saw with dismay that the thousands of hungry +workmen whose victory had placed them in power had fought for something +more tangible than Republican phrases from Tacitus and Plutarch. On one +side was a handful of orators and writers, steeped in the rhetoric and the +commonplace of ancient Rome, and totally strange to the real duties of +government; on the other side the populace of Paris, such as centuries of +despotism, privilege, and priestcraft had made it: sanguinary, unjust, +vindictive; convulsed since the outbreak of the Revolution with every +passion that sways men in the mass; taught no conception of progress but +the overthrow of authority, and acquainted with no title to power but that +which was bestowed by itself. If the Girondins were to remain in power, +they could do so only by drawing an army from the departments, or by +identifying themselves with the multitude. They declined to take either +course. Their audience was in the Assembly alone; their support in the +distant provinces. Paris, daily more violent, listened to men of another +stamp. The Municipality defied the Government; the Mountain answered the +threats and invectives of the majority in the Assembly by displays of +popular menace and tumult. In the eyes of the common people, who after so +many changes of government found themselves more famished and more +destitute than ever, the Gironde was now but the last of a succession of +tyrannies; its statesmen but impostors who stood between the people and the +enjoyment of their liberty. + +Among the leaders of the Mountain, Danton aimed at the creation of a +central Revolutionary Government, armed with absolute powers for the +prosecution of the war; and he attacked the Girondins only when they +themselves had rejected his support. Robespierre, himself the author of +little beyond destruction, was the idol of those whom Rousseau's writings +had filled with the idea of a direct exercise of sovereignty by the people. +It was in the trial of the King that the Gironde first confessed its +submission to the democracy of Paris. The Girondins in their hearts desired +to save the King; they voted for his death with the hope of maintaining +their influence in Paris, and of clearing themselves from the charge of +lukewarmness in the cause of the Revolution. But the sacrifice was as vain +as it was dishonourable. The populace and the party of the Mountain took +the act in its true character, as an acknowledgment of their own victory. A +series of measures was brought forward providing for the poorer classes at +the expense of the wealthy. The Gironde, now forced to become the defenders +of property, encountered the fatal charge of deserting the cause of the +people; and from this time nothing but successful foreign warfare could +have saved their party from ruin. + +[Defeat and treason of Dumouriez, March, 1793.] + +Instead of success came inaction, disaster, and treason. The army of +Flanders lay idle during January and February for want of provisions and +materials of war; and no sooner had Dumouriez opened the campaign against +Holland than he was recalled by intelligence that the Austrians had fallen +upon his lieutenant, Miranda, at Maestricht, and driven the French army +before them. Dumouriez returned, in order to fight a pitched battle before +Brussels. He attacked the Austrians at Neerwinden (March 18), and suffered +a repulse inconsiderable in itself, but sufficient to demoralise an army +composed in great part of recruits and National Guards. [26] His defeat +laid Flanders open to the Austrians; but Dumouriez intended that it should +inflict upon the Republic a far heavier blow. Since the execution of the +King, he had been at open enmity with the Jacobins. He now proposed to the +Austrian commander to unite with him in an attack upon the Convention, and +in re-establishing monarchy in France. The first pledge of Dumouriez's +treason was the surrender of three commissioners sent by the Convention to +his camp; the second was to have been the surrender of the fortress of +Conde. But Dumouriez had overrated his influence with the army. Plainer +minds than his own knew how to deal with a general who intrigues with the +foreigner. Dumouriez's orders were disregarded; his movements watched; and +he fled to the Austrian lines under the fire of his own soldiers. About +thirty officers and eight hundred men passed with him to the enemy. + +[Defeats on the North and East. Revolt of La Vendee, March, 1793.] + +[The Commune crushes the Gironde, June 2.] + +The defeat and treason of Dumouriez brought the army of Austria over the +northern frontier. Almost at the same moment Custine was overpowered in the +Palatinate; and the conquests of the previous autumn, with the exception of +Mainz, were lost as rapidly as they had been won. Custine fell back upon +the lines of Weissenburg, leaving the defence of Mainz to a garrison of +17,000 men, which, alone among the Republican armies, now maintained its +reputation. In France itself civil war broke out. The peasants of La +Vendee, a district destitute of large towns, and scarcely touched either by +the evils which had produced the Revolution or by the hopes which animated +the rest of France, had seen with anger the expulsion of the parish priests +who refused to take the oath to the Constitution. A levy of 300,000 men, +which was ordered by the Convention in February, 1793, threw into revolt +the simple Vendeans, who cared for nothing outside their own parishes, and +preferred to fight against their countrymen rather than to quit their +homes. The priests and the Royalists fanned these village outbreaks into a +religious war of the most serious character. Though poorly armed, and +accustomed to return to their homes as soon as fighting was over, the +Vendean peasantry proved themselves a formidable soldiery in the moment of +attack, and cut to pieces the half-disciplined battalions which the +Government sent against them. On the north, France was now assailed by the +English as well as by the Austrians. The Allies laid siege to Conde and +Valenciennes, and drove the French army back in disorder at Famars. Each +defeat was a blow dealt to the Government of the Gironde at Paris. With +foreign and civil war adding disaster to disaster, with the general to whom +the Gironde had entrusted the defence of the Republic openly betraying it +to its enemies, the fury of the capital was easily excited against the +party charged with all the misfortunes of France. A threatening movement of +the middle classes in resistance to a forced loan precipitated the +struggle. The Girondins were accused of arresting the armies of the +Republic in the midst of their conquests, of throwing the frontier open to +the foreigner, and of kindling the civil war of La Vendee. On the 31st of +May a raging mob invaded the Convention. Two days later the representatives +of France were surrounded by the armed forces of the Commune; the +twenty-four leading members of the Gironde were placed under arrest, and +the victory of the Mountain was completed. [27] + +[Civil War. The Committee of Public Safety.] + +The situation of France, which was serious before, now became desperate; +for the Girondins, escaping from their arrest, called the departments to +arms against Paris. Normandy, Bordeaux, Marseilles, Lyons, rose in +insurrection against the tyranny of the Mountain, and the Royalists of the +south and west threw themselves into a civil war which they hoped to turn +to their own advantage. But a form of government had now arisen in France +well fitted to cope with extraordinary perils. It was a form of government +in which there was little trace of the constitutional tendencies of 1789, +one that had come into being as the stress of conflict threw into the +background the earlier hopes and efforts of the Revolution. In the two +earlier Assemblies it had been a fixed principle that the representatives +of the people were to control the Government, but were not to assume +executive powers themselves. After the overthrow of Monarchy on the 10th +August, the Ministers, though still nominally possessed of powers distinct +from the representative body, began to be checked by Committees of the +Convention appointed for various branches of the public service; and in +March, 1793, in order to meet the increasing difficulties of the war, a +Committee of Public Safety was appointed, charged with the duty of +exercising a general surveillance over the administration. In this +Committee, however, as in all the others, the Gironde were in the majority; +and the twenty-four members who composed it were too numerous a body to act +with effect. The growing ascendancy of the Mountain produced that +concentration of force which the times required. The Committee was reduced +in April to nine members, and in this form it ultimately became the supreme +central power. It was not until after the revolt of Lyons that the +Committee, exchanging Danton's influence for that of Robespierre, adopted +the principle of Terror which has made the memory of their rule one of the +most sinister in history. Their authority steadily increased. The members +divided among themselves the great branches of government. One directed the +army, another the navy, another foreign affairs; the signature of three +members practically gave to any measure the force of law, for the +Convention accepted and voted their reports as a matter of course. + +[Commissioners of the Convention] + +Whilst the Committee gave orders as the supreme executive, eighty of the +most energetic of the Mountain spread themselves over France, in parties of +two and three, with the title of Commissioners of the Convention, and with +powers over-riding those of all the local authorities. They were originally +appointed for the purpose of hastening on the levy ordered by the +Convention in March, but their powers were gradually extended over the +whole range of administration. Their will was absolute, their authority +supreme. Where the councillors of the Departments or the municipal officers +were good Jacobins, the Commissioners availed themselves of local +machinery; where they suspected their principles, they sent them to the +scaffold, and enforced their own orders by whatever means were readiest. +They censured and dismissed the generals; one of them even directed the +movements of a fleet at sea. What was lost by waste and confusion and by +the interference of the Commissioners in military movements was more than +counterbalanced by the vigour which they threw into all the preparations of +war, and by the unity of purpose which, at the price of unsparing +bloodshed, they communicated to every group where Frenchmen met together. + +[Local revolutionary system of 1793] + +But no individual energy could have sustained these dictatorships without +the support of a popular organisation. All over France a system of +revolutionary government sprang up, which superseded all existing +institutions just as the authority of the Commissioners of the Convention +superseded all existing local powers. The local revolutionary +administration consisted of a Committee, a Club, and a Tribunal. [28] In +each of 21,000 communes a committee of twelve was elected by the people, +and entrusted by the Convention, as the Terror gained ground, with +boundless powers of arrest and imprisonment. Popular excitement was +sustained by clubs, where the peasants and labourers assembled at the close +of their day's work, and applauded the victories or denounced the enemies +of the Revolution. A Tribunal with swift procedure and powers of life and +death sat in each of the largest towns, and judged the prisoners who were +sent to it by the committees of the neighbouring district. Such was the +government of 1793--an executive of uncontrolled power drawn from the +members of a single Assembly, and itself brought into immediate contact +with the poorest of the people in their assemblies and clubs. The balance +of interests which creates a constitutional system, the security of life, +liberty, and property, which is the essence of every recognised social +order, did not now exist in France. One public purpose, the defence of the +Revolution, became the law before which all others lost their force. +Treating all France like a town in a state of siege, the Government took +upon itself the duty of providing support for the poorest classes by +enactments controlling the sale and possession of the necessaries of life. + +[Law of the Maximum] + +The price of corn and other necessaries was fixed; and, when the traders +and producers consequently ceased to bring their goods to market, the +Commissioners of the Convention were empowered to make requisition of a +certain quantity of corn for every acre of ground. Property was thus placed +at the disposal of the men who already exercised absolute political power. +"The state of France," said Burke, "is perfectly simple. It consists of but +two descriptions, the oppressors and the oppressed." It is in vain that the +attempt has been made to extenuate the atrocious and senseless cruelties of +this time by extolling the great legislative projects of the Convention, or +pleading the dire necessity of a land attacked on every side by the +foreigner, and rent with civil war. The more that is known of the Reign of +Terror, the more hateful, the meaner and more disgusting is the picture +unveiled. France was saved not by the brutalities, but by the energy, of +the faction that ruled it. It is scarcely too much to say that the cause of +European progress would have been less injured by the military overthrow of +the Republic, by the severance of the border provinces from France and the +restoration of some shadow of the ancient _regime_, than by the traditions +of horror which for the next fifty years were inseparably associated in +men's minds with the victory of the people over established power. + +[French disasters, March-Sept., 1793.] + +The Revolutionary organisation did not reach its full vigour till the +autumn of 1793, when the prospects of France were at their worst. Custine, +who was brought up from Alsace to take command of the Army of the North, +found it so demoralised that he was unable to attempt the relief of the +fortresses which were now besieged by the Allies. Conde surrendered to the +Austrians on the 10th of July; Valenciennes capitulated to the Duke of York +a fortnight later. In the east the fortune of war was no better. An attack +made on the Prussian army besieging Mainz totally failed; and on the 23rd +of July this great fortress, which had been besieged since the middle of +April, passed back into the hands of the Germans. On every side the +Republic seemed to be sinking before its enemies. Its frontier defences had +fallen before the victorious Austrians and English; Brunswick was ready to +advance upon Alsace from conquered Mainz; Lyons and Toulon were in revolt; +La Vendee had proved the grave of the forces sent to subdue it. It was in +this crisis of misfortune that the Convention placed the entire male +population of France between the ages of eighteen and twenty-five at the +disposal of the Government, and turned the whole country into one great +camp and arsenal of war. Nor was there wanting a mind equal to the task of +giving order to this vast material. The appointment of Carnot, an officer +of engineers, to a seat on the Committee of Public Safety placed the +military administration of France in the hands of a man who, as an +organiser, if not as a strategist, was soon to prove himself without equal +in Europe. + +[The Allies seek each their separate ends.] + +Nevertheless, it was to the dissensions and to the bad policy of the Allies +more than to the energy of its own Government that France owed its safety. +The object for which the Allies professed to be carrying on the war, the +establishment of a pacific Government in France, was subordinated to +schemes of aggrandisement, known as the acquisition of just indemnities. +While Prussia, bent chiefly on preventing the Emperor from gaining Bavaria +in exchange for Belgium, kept its own army inactive on the Rhine, [29] +Austria, with the full approval of Pitt's Cabinet, claimed annexations in +Northern France, as well as Alsace, and treated the conquered town of Conde +as Austrian territory. [30] Henceforward all the operations of the northern +army were directed to the acquisition of frontier territory, not to the +pursuit and overthrow of the Republican forces. The war was openly +converted from a war of defence into a war of spoliation. It was a change +which mocked the disinterested professions with which the Allies had taken +up arms; in its military results it was absolutely ruinous. In face of the +immense levies which promised the French certain victory in a long war, the +only hope for the Allies lay in a rapid march to Paris; they preferred the +extreme of division and delay. No sooner had the advance of their united +armies driven Custine from his stronghold at Famars, than the English +commander led off his forces to besiege Dunkirk, while the Austrians, under +Prince Coburg, proceeded to invest Cambray and Le Quesnoy. The line of the +invaders thus extended from the Channel to Brunswick's posts at Landau, on +the border of Alsace; the main armies were out of reach of one another, and +their strength was diminished by the corps detached to keep up their +communications. The French held the inner circle; and the advantage which +this gave them was well understood by Carnot, who now inspired the measures +of the Committee. In steadiness and precision the French recruits were no +match for the trained armies of Germany; but the supply of them was +inexhaustible, and Carnot knew that when they were thrown in sufficient +masses upon the enemy their courage and enthusiasm would make amends for +their inexperience. The successes of the Allies, unbroken from February to +August, now began to alternate with defeats; the flood of invasion was +first slowly and obstinately repelled, then swept away before a victorious +advance. + +[York driven from Dunkirk Sept. 8.] + +It was on the British commander that the first blow was struck. The forces +that could be detached from the French Northern army were not sufficient to +drive York from before Dunkirk; but on the Moselle there were troops +engaged in watching an enemy who was not likely to advance; and the +Committee did not hesitate to leave this side of France open to the +Prussians in order to deal a decisive stroke in the north. Before the +movement was noticed by the enemy, Carnot had transported 30,000 men from +Metz to the English Channel; and in the first week of September the German +corps covering York was assailed by General Houchard with numbers double +its own. The Germans were driven back upon Dunkirk; York only saved his own +army from destruction by hastily raising the siege and abandoning his heavy +artillery. The victory of the French, however, was ill followed up. +Houchard was sent before the Revolutionary Tribunal, and he paid with his +life for his mistakes. Custine had already perished, unjustly condemned for +the loss of Mainz and Valenciennes. + +[Commands given to men of the people.] + +[Jourdan's victory at Wattignies, Oct 15.] + +It was no unimportant change for France when the successors of Custine and +Houchard received their commands from the Committee of Public Safety. The +levelling principle of the Reign of Terror left its effect on France +through its operation in the army, and through this almost alone. Its +executions produced only horror and reaction; its confiscations were soon +reversed; but the creation of a thoroughly democratic army, the work of the +men who overthrew the Gironde, gave the most powerful and abiding impulse +to social equality in France. The first generals of the Revolution had been +officers of the old army, men, with a few exceptions, of noble birth, who, +like Custine, had enrolled themselves on the popular side when most of +their companions quitted the country. These generals were connected with +the politicians of the Gironde, and were involved in its fall. The victory +of the Mountain brought men of another type into command. Almost all the +leaders appointed by the Committee of Public Safety were soldiers who had +served in the ranks. In the levies of 1792 and 1793 the officers of the +newly-formed battalions were chosen by the recruits themselves. Patriotism, +energy of character, acquaintance with warfare, instantly brought men into +prominence. Soldiers of the old army, like Massena, who had reached middle +life with their knapsacks on their backs; lawyers, like the Breton Moreau; +waiters at inns, like Murat, found themselves at the head of their +battalions, and knew that Carnot was ever watching for genius and ability +to call it to the highest commands. With a million of men under arms, there +were many in whom great natural gifts supplied the want of professional +training. It was also inevitable that at the outset command should +sometimes fall into the hands of mere busy politicians; but the character +of the generals steadily rose as the Committee gained the ascendancy over a +knot of demagogues who held the War Ministry during the summer of 1793; and +by the end of the year there was scarcely one officer in high command who +had not proved himself worthy of his post. In the investigation into +Houchard's conduct at Dunkirk, Carnot learnt that the victory had in fact +been won by Jourdan, one of the generals of division. Jourdan had begun +life as a common soldier fifteen years before. Discharged at the end of the +American War, he had set up a draper's shop in Limoges, his native town. He +joined the army a second time on the outbreak of the Revolutionary War, and +the men of his battalion elected him captain. His ability was noticed; he +was made successively general of brigade and general of division; and, upon +the dismissal of Houchard, Carnot summoned him to the command of the Army +of the North. The Austrians were now engaged in the investment of Maubeuge. +On the 15th of October Jourdan attacked and defeated their covering army at +Wattignies. His victory forced the Austrians to raise the siege, and +brought the campaign to an end for the winter. + +[Lyons, Toulon, La Vendee, conquered Oct.-Dec. 1793.] + +Thus successful on the northern frontier, the Republic carried on war +against its internal enemies without pause and without mercy. Lyons +surrendered in October; its citizens were slaughtered by hundreds in cold +blood. Toulon had thrown itself into the hands of the English, and +proclaimed King Louis XVII. It was besieged by land; but the operations +produced no effect until Napoleon Bonaparte, captain of artillery, planned +the capture of a ridge from which the cannon of the besiegers would command +the English fleet in the harbour. Hood, the British admiral, now found his +position hopeless. He took several thousands of the inhabitants on board +his ships, and put out to sea, blowing up the French ships which he left in +the harbour. Hood had received the fleet from the Royalists in trust for +their King; its destruction gave England command of the Mediterranean and +freed Naples from fear of attack; and Hood thought too little of the +consequences which his act would bring down upon those of the inhabitants +of Toulon whom he left behind. [31] + +The horrors that followed the entry of the Republican army into the city +did not prevent Pitt from including among the subjects of congratulation in +the King's Speech of 1794 "the circumstances attending the evacuation of +Toulon." It was perhaps fortunate for the Royalists in other parts of +France that they failed to receive the assistance of England. Help was +promised to the Vendeans, but it arrived too late. The appearance of Kleber +at the head of the army which had defended Mainz had already turned the +scale. Brave as they were, the Vendeans could not long resist trained +armies. The war of pitched battles ended on the Loire with the year 1793. +It was succeeded by a war of merciless and systematic destruction on the +one side, and of ambush and surprises on the other. + +[Prussia withdrawing from the war on account of Polish affairs.] + +At home the foes of the Republic were sinking; its invaders were too much +at discord with one another to threaten it any longer with serious danger. +Prussia was in fact withdrawing from the war. It has been seen that when +King Frederick William and the Emperor concerted the autumn campaign of +1792, the understanding was formed that Prussia, in return for its efforts +against France, should be allowed to seize part of western Poland, if the +Empress Catherine should give her consent. With this prospect before it, +the thoughts of the Prussian Government had been from the first busied more +with Poland, where it hoped to enter into possession, than with France, +where it had only to fight Austria's battles. Negotiations on the Polish +question had been actively carried on between Berlin and St. Petersburg +during the first months of the war; and in January, 1793, the Empress +Catherine had concluded a Treaty of Partition with King Frederick William, +in virtue of which a Prussian army under General Mollendorf immediately +entered western Poland. It was thought good policy to keep the terms of +this treaty secret from Austria, as it granted a much larger portion of +Poland to Prussia than Austria was willing that it should receive. Two +months passed before the Austrian Sovereign learnt how he had been treated +by his ally. He then denounced the treaty, and assumed so threatening an +attitude that the Prussians thought it necessary to fortify the territory +that they had seized. [32] The Ministers who had been outwitted by the +Court of Berlin were dismissed; Baron Thugut, who from the first had +prophesied nothing but evil of the Prussian alliance, was called to power. +The history of this statesman, who for the next eight years directed the +war-policy of Austria, and filled a part in Europe subordinate only to +those of Pitt and Bonaparte, has until a recent date been drawn chiefly +from the representations of his enemies. Humbly born, scornful and +inaccessible, Thugut was detested by the Viennese aristocracy; the French +emigrants hated and maligned him on account of his indifference to their +cause; the public opinion of Austria held him responsible for unparalleled +military disasters; Prussian generals and ambassadors, whose reports have +formed the basis of Prussian histories, pictured him as a Satanic +antagonist. It was long believed of Thugut that while ambassador at +Constantinople he had sold the Austrian cypher to the French; that in 1794 +he prevented his master's armies from winning victories because he had +speculated in the French funds; and that in 1799 he occasioned the murder +of the French envoys at Rastadt, in order to recover documents +incriminating himself. Better sources of information are now opened, and a +statesman, jealous, bitter, and over-reaching, but not without great +qualities of character, stands in the place of the legendary criminal. It +is indeed clear that Thugut's hatred of Prussia amounted almost to mania; +it is also clear that his designs of aggression, formed in the school of +the Emperor Joseph, were fatally in conflict with the defensive principles +which Europe ought to have opposed to the aggressions of France. Evidence +exists that during the eight years of Thugut's ministry he entertained, +together or successively, projects for the annexation of French Flanders, +Bavaria, Alsace, part of Poland, Venice and Dalmatia, Salzburg, the Papal +Legations, the Republic of Genoa, Piedmont, and Bosnia; and to this list +Tuscany and Savoy ought probably to be added. But the charges brought +against Thugut of underhand dealings with France, and of the willing +abandonment of German interests in return for compensation to Austria in +Italy, rest on insufficient ground. Though, like every other politician at +Vienna and Berlin, he viewed German affairs not as a matter of nationality +but in subordination to the general interests of his own Court, Thugut +appears to have been, of all the Continental statesmen of that time, the +steadiest enemy of French aggression, and to have offered the longest +resistance to a peace that was purchased by the cession of German soil. +[33] + +[Victories of Hoche and Pichegru at Woerth and Weissenburg, Dec. 23, 26.] + +Nevertheless, from the moment when Thugut was called to power the alliance +between Austria and Prussia was doomed. Others might perhaps have averted a +rupture; Thugut made no attempt to do so. The siege of Mainz was the last +serious operation of war which the Prussian army performed. The mission of +an Austrian envoy, Lehrbach, to the Prussian camp in August, 1793, and his +negotiations on the Polish and the Bavarian questions, only widened the +breach between the two Courts. It was known that the Austrians were +encouraging the Polish Diet to refuse the cession of the provinces occupied +by Prussia; and the advisers of King Frederick William in consequence +recommended him to quit the Rhine, and to place himself at the head of an +army in Poland. At the headquarters of the Allies, between Mainz and the +Alsatian frontier, all was dissension and intrigue. The impetuosity of the +Austrian general, Wurmser, who advanced upon Alsace without consulting the +King, was construed as a studied insult. On the 29th of September, after +informing the allied Courts that Prussia would henceforth take only a +subordinate part in the war, King Frederick William quitted the army, +leaving orders with the Duke of Brunswick to fight no great battle. It was +in vain that Wurmser stormed the lines of Weissenburg (Oct. 13), and +victoriously pushed forward into Alsace. The hopes of a Royalist +insurrection in Strasburg proved illusory. The German sympathies shown by a +portion of the upper and middle classes of Alsace only brought down upon +them a bloody vengeance at the hands of St. Just, commissioner of the +Convention. The peasantry, partly from hatred of the feudal burdens of the +old _regime_, partly from fear of St. Just and the guillotine, thronged to +the French camp. In place of the beaten generals came Hoche and Pichegru: +Hoche, lately a common soldier in the Guards, earning by a humble industry +little sums for the purchase of books, now, at the age of twenty-six, a +commander more than a match for the wrangling veterans of Germany; +Pichegru, six years older, also a man sprung from the people, once a +teacher in the military school of Brienne, afterwards a private of +artillery in the American War. A series of harassing encounters took place +during December. At length, with St. Just cheering on the Alsatian peasants +in the hottest of the fire, these generals victoriously carried the +Austrian positions at Woerth and at Weissenburg (Dec. 23, 26). The Austrian +commander declared his army to be utterly ruined; and Brunswick, who had +abstained from rendering his ally any real assistance, found himself a +second time back upon the Rhine. [34] + +[Pitt's bargain with Prussia, April, 1794.] + +[Revolt of Kosciusko. April, 1794.] + +[Moellendorf refuses to help in Flanders.] + +The virtual retirement of Prussia from the Coalition was no secret to the +French Government: amongst the Allies it was viewed in various lights. The +Empress Catherine, who had counted on seeing her troublesome Prussian +friend engaged with her detested French enemy, taunted the King of Prussia +with the loss of his personal honour. Austria, conscious of the antagonism +between Prussian and Austrian interests and of the hollow character of the +Coalition, would concede nothing to keep Prussia in arms. Pitt alone was +willing to make a sacrifice, in order to prevent the rupture of the +alliance. The King of Prussia was ready to continue the struggle with +France if his expenses were paid, but not otherwise. Accordingly, after +Austria had refused to contribute the small sum which Pitt asked, a bargain +was struck between Lord Malmesbury and the Prussian Minister Haugwitz, by +which Great Britain undertook to furnish a subsidy, provided that 60,000 +Prussian troops, under General Moellendorf, were placed at the disposal of +the Maritime Powers. [35] It was Pitt's intention that the troops which he +subsidised should be massed with Austrian and English forces for the +defence of Belgium: the Prussian Ministry, availing themselves of an +ambiguous expression in the treaty, insisted on keeping them inactive upon +the Upper Rhine. Moellendorf wished to guard Mainz: other men of influence +longed to abandon the alliance with Austria, and to employ the whole of +Prussia's force in Poland. At the moment when Haugwitz was contracting to +place Moellendorf's army at Pitt's disposal, Poland had risen in revolt +under Kosciusko, and the Russian garrison which occupied Warsaw had been +overpowered and cut to pieces. Catherine called upon the King of Prussia +for assistance; but it was not so much a desire to rescue the Empress from +a momentary danger that excited the Prussian Cabinet as the belief that her +vengeance would now make an absolute end of what remained of the Polish +kingdom. The prey was doomed; the wisdom of Prussia was to be the first to +seize and drag it to the ground. So large a prospect offered itself to the +Power that should crush Poland during the brief paralysis of the Russian +arms, that, on the first news of the outbreak, the King's advisers urged +him instantly to make peace with France and to throw his whole strength +into the Polish struggle. Frederick William could not reconcile himself to +making peace with the Jacobins; but he ordered an army to march upon +Warsaw, and shortly afterwards placed himself at its head (May, 1794). When +the King, who was the only politician in Prussia who took an interest in +the French war, thus publicly acknowledged the higher importance of the +Polish campaign, his generals upon the Rhine made it their only object to +do nothing which it was possible to leave undone without actually +forfeiting the British subsidy. Instead of fighting, Moellendorf spent his +time in urging other people to make peace. It was in vain that Malmesbury +argued that the very object of Pitt's bargain was to keep the French out of +the Netherlands: Moellendorf had made up his mind that the army should not +be committed to the orders of Pitt and the Austrians. He continued in the +Palatinate, alleging that any movement of the Prussian army towards the +north would give the French admittance to southern Germany. Pitt's hope of +defending the Netherlands now rested on the energy and on the sincerity of +the Austrian Cabinet, and on this alone. + +[Battles on the Sambre, May-June, 1794.] + +After breaking up from winter quarters in the spring of 1794, the Austrian +and English allied forces had successfully laid siege to Landrecies, and +defeated the enemy in its neighbourhood. [36] Their advance, however, was +checked by a movement of the French Army of the North, now commanded by +Pichegru, towards the Flemish coast. York and the English troops were +exposed to the attack, and suffered a defeat at Turcoing. The decision of +the campaign lay, however, not in the west of Flanders, but at the other +end of the Allies' position, at Charleroi on the Sambre, where a French +victory would either force the Austrians to fall back eastwards, leaving +York to his fate, or sever their communications with Germany. This became +evident to the French Government; and in May the Commissioners of the +Convention forced the generals on the Sambre to fight a series of battles, +in which the French repeatedly succeeded in crossing the Sambre, and were +repeatedly driven back again. The fate of the Netherlands depended, +however, on something beside victory or defeat on the Sambre. The Emperor +had come with Baron Thugut to Belgium in the hope of imparting greater +unity and energy to the allied forces, but his presence proved useless. +Among the Austrian generals and diplomatists there were several who desired +to withdraw from the contest in the Netherlands, and to follow the example +of Prussia in Poland. The action of the army was paralysed by intrigues. +"Every one," wrote Thugut, "does exactly as he pleases: there is absolute +anarchy and disorder." [37] At the beginning of June the Emperor quitted +the army; the combats on the Sambre were taken up by Jourdan and 50,000 +fresh troops brought from the army of the Moselle; and on the 26th of June +the French defeated Coburg at Fleurus, as he advanced to the relief of +Charleroi, unconscious that Charleroi had surrendered on the day before. +Even now the defence of Belgium was not hopeless; but after one council of +war had declared in favour of fighting, a second determined on a retreat. +It was in vain that the representatives of England appealed to the good +faith and military honour of Austria. Namur and Louvain were abandoned; the +French pressed onwards; and before the end of July the Austrian army had +fallen back behind the Meuse. York, forsaken by the allies, retired +northwards before the superior forces of Pichegru, who entered Antwerp and +made himself master of the whole of the Netherlands up to the Dutch +frontier. [38] + +[England disappointed by the Allies.] + +Such was the result of Great Britain's well-meant effort to assist the two +great military Powers to defend Europe against the Revolution. To the aim +of the English Minister, the defence of existing rights against democratic +aggression, most of the public men alike of Austria and Prussia were now +absolutely indifferent. They were willing to let the French seize and +revolutionise any territory they pleased, provided that they themselves +obtained their equivalent in Poland. England was in fact in the position of +a man who sets out to attack a highway robber, and offers each of his arms +to a pickpocket. The motives and conduct of these politicians were justly +enough described by the English statesmen and generals who were brought +into closest contact with them. In the councils of Prussia, Malmesbury +declared that he could find no quality but "great and shabby art and +cunning; ill-will, jealousy, and every sort of dirty passion." From the +head quarters of Moellendorf he wrote to a member of Pitt's Cabinet: "Here I +have to do with knavery and dotage.... If we listened only to our feelings, +it would be difficult to keep any measure with Prussia. We must consider it +an alliance with the Algerians, whom it is no disgrace to pay, or any +impeachment of good sense to be cheated by." To the Austrian commander the +Duke of York addressed himself with royal plainness: "Your Serene Highness, +the British nation, whose public opinion is not to be despised, will +consider that it has been bought and sold." [39] + +[French reach the Rhine, Oct., 1794.] + +[Pichegru conquers Holland, Dec., 1794.] + +The sorry concert lasted for a few months longer. Coburg, the Austrian +commander, was dismissed at the peremptory demand of Great Britain; his +successor, Clerfayt, after losing a battle on the Ourthe, offered no +further resistance to the advance of the Republican army, and the campaign +ended in the capture of Cologne by the French, and the disappearance of the +Austrians behind the Rhine. The Prussian subsidies granted by England +resulted in some useless engagements between Moellendorf's corps in the +Palatinate and a French army double its size, followed by the retreat of +the Prussians into Mainz. It only remained for Great Britain to attempt to +keep the French out of Holland. The defence of the Dutch, after everything +south of the river Waal had been lost, Pitt determined to entrust to abler +hands than those of the Duke of York; but the presence of one high-born +blunderer more or less made little difference in a series of operations +conceived in indifference and perversity. Clerfayt would not, or could not, +obey the Emperor's orders and succour his ally. City after city in Holland +welcomed the French. The very elements seemed to declare for the Republic. +Pichegru's army marched in safety over the frozen rivers; and, when the +conquest of the land was completed, his cavalry crowned the campaign by the +capture of the Dutch fleet in the midst of the ice-bound waters of the +Texel. The British regiments, cut off from home, made their way eastward +through the snow towards the Hanoverian frontier, in a state of prostrate +misery which is compared by an eye-witness of both events to that of the +French on their retreat in 1813 after the battle of Leipzig. [40] + +[Treaties of Basle with Prussia, April 5, and Spain, July 22, 1795.] + +The first act of the struggle between France and the Monarchies of Europe +was concluded. The result of three years of war was that Belgium, Nice, and +Savoy had been added to the territory of the Republic, and that French +armies were in possession of Holland, and the whole of Germany west of the +Rhine. In Spain and in Piedmont the mountain-passes and some extent of +country had been won. Even on the seas, in spite of the destruction of the +fleet at Toulon, and of a heavy defeat by Lord Howe off Ushant on the 1st +of June, 1794, the strength of France was still formidable; and the losses +which she inflicted on the commercial marine of her enemies exceeded those +which she herself sustained. England, which had captured most of the French +West Indian Islands, was the only Power that had wrested anything from the +Republic. The dream of suppressing the Revolution by force of arms had +vanished away; and the States which had entered upon the contest in levity, +in fanaticism, or at the bidding of more powerful allies, found it +necessary to make peace upon such terms as they could obtain. Holland, in +which a strong Republican party had always maintained connection with +France, abolished the rule of its Stadtholder, and placed its resources at +the disposal of its conquerors. Sardinia entered upon abortive +negotiations. Spain, in return for peace, ceded to the Republic the Spanish +half of St. Domingo (July 22, 1795). Prussia concluded a Treaty at Basle +(April 5), which marked and perpetuated the division of Germany by +providing that, although the Empire as a body was still at war with France, +the benefit of Prussia's neutrality should extend to all German States +north of a certain line. A secret article stipulated that, upon the +conclusion of a general peace, if the Empire should cede to France the +principalities west of the Rhine, Prussia should cede its own territory +lying in that district, and receive compensation elsewhere. [41] + +[Austria and England continue the war, 1795.] + +Humiliating such a peace certainly was; yet it would probably have been the +happiest issue for Europe had every Power been forced to accept its +conditions. The territory gained by France was not much more than the very +principle of the Balance of Power would have entitled it to demand, at a +moment when Russia, victorious over the Polish rebellion, was proceeding to +make the final partition of Poland among the three Eastern Monarchies; and, +with all its faults, the France of 1795 would have offered to Europe the +example of a great free State, such as the growth of the military spirit +made impossible after the first of Napoleon's campaigns. But the dark +future was withdrawn from the view of those British statesmen who most +keenly felt the evils of the present; and England, resolutely set against +the course of French aggression, still found in Austria an ally willing to +continue the struggle. The financial help of Great Britain, the Russian +offer of a large share in the spoils of Poland, stimulated the flagging +energy of the Emperor's government. Orders were sent to Clerfayt to advance +from the Rhine at whatever risk, in order to withdraw the troops of the +Republic from the west of France, where England was about to land a body of +Royalists. Clerfayt, however, disobeyed his instructions, and remained +inactive till the autumn. He then defeated a French army pushing beyond the +Rhine, and drove back the besiegers of Mainz; but the British expedition +had already failed, and the time was passed when Clerfayt's successes might +have produced a decisive result. [42] + +[Landing at Quiberon, June 27, 1795.] + +[France in 1795.] + +A new Government was now entering upon power in France. The Reign of Terror +had ended in July, 1794, with the life of Robespierre. The men by whom +Robespierre was overthrown were Terrorists more cruel and less earnest than +himself, who attacked him only in order to save their own lives, and +without the least intention of restoring a constitutional Government to +France. An overwhelming national reaction forced them, however, to +represent themselves as the party of clemency. The reaction was indeed a +simple outburst of human feeling rather than a change in political opinion. +Among the victims of the Terror the great majority had been men of the +lower or middle class, who, except in La Vendee and Brittany, were as +little friendly to the old _regime_ as their executioners. Every class in +France, with the exception of the starving city mobs, longed for security, +and the quiet routine of life. After the disorders of the Republic a +monarchical government naturally seemed to many the best guarantee of +peace; but the monarchy so contemplated was the liberal monarchy of 1791, +not the ancient Court, with its accessories of a landed Church and +privileged noblesse. Religion was still a power in France; but the peasant, +with all his superstition and all his desire for order, was perfectly free +from any delusions about the good old times. He liked to see his children +baptised; but he had no desire to see the priest's tithe-collector back in +his barn: he shuddered at the summary marketing of Conventional +Commissioners; but he had no wish to resume his labours on the fields of +his late seigneur. To be a Monarchist in 1795, among the shopkeepers of +Paris or the farmers of Normandy, meant no more than to wish for a +political system capable of subsisting for twelve months together, and +resting on some other basis than forced loans and compulsory sales of +property. But among the men of the Convention, who had abolished monarchy +and passed sentence of death upon the King, the restoration of the Crown +seemed the bitterest condemnation of all that the Convention had done for +France, and a sentence of outlawry against themselves. If the will of the +nation was for the moment in favour of a restored monarchy, the Convention +determined that its will must be overpowered by force or thwarted by +constitutional forms. Threatened alternately by the Jacobin mob of Paris +and by the Royalist middle class, the Government played off one enemy +against the other, until an ill-timed effort of the emigrant noblesse gave +to the Convention the prestige of a decisive victory over Royalists and +foreigners combined. On the 27th of June, 1795, an English fleet landed the +flower of the old nobility of France at the Bay of Quiberon in southern +Brittany. It was only to give one last fatal proof of their incapacity that +these unhappy men appeared once more on French soil. Within three weeks +after their landing, in a region where for years together the peasantry, +led by their landlords, baffled the best generals of the Republic, this +invading army of the nobles, supported by the fleet, the arms, and the +money of England, was brought to utter ruin by the discord of its own +leaders. Before the nobles had settled who was to command and who was to +obey, General Hoche surprised their fort, beat them back to the edge of the +peninsula where they had landed, and captured all who were not killed +fighting or rescued by English boats (July 20). The Commissioner Tallien, +in order to purge himself from the just suspicion of Royalist intrigues, +caused six hundred prisoners to be shot in cold blood. [43] + +[Project of Constitution, 1795.] + +At the moment when the emigrant army reached France, the Convention was +engaged in discussing the political system which was to succeed its own +rule. A week earlier, the Committee appointed to draw up a new constitution +for France had presented its report. The main object of the new +constitution in its original form was to secure France against a recurrence +of those evils which it had suffered since 1792. The calamities of the last +three years were ascribed to the sovereignty of a single Assembly. A vote +of the Convention had established the Revolutionary Tribunal, proscribed +the Girondins, and placed France at the mercy of eighty individuals +selected by the Convention from itself. The legislators of 1795 desired a +guarantee that no party, however determined, should thus destroy its +enemies by a single law, and unite supreme legislative and executive power +in its own hands. With the object of dividing authority, the executive was, +in the new draft-constitution, made independent of the legislature, and the +legislature itself was broken up into two chambers. A Directory of five +members, chosen by the Assemblies, but not responsible except under actual +impeachment, was to conduct the administration, without the right of +proposing laws; a Chamber of five hundred was to submit laws to the +approval of a Council of two hundred and fifty Ancients, or men of middle +life; but neither of these bodies was to exercise any influence upon the +actual government. One director and a third part of each of the legislative +bodies were to retire every year. [44] + +[Constitution of 1795. Insurrection of Vendemiaire, Oct. 4.] + +The project thus outlined met with general approval, and gained even that +of the Royalists, who believed that a popular election would place them in +a majority in the two new Assemblies. Such an event was, however, in the +eyes of the Convention, the one fatal possibility that must be averted at +every cost. In the midst of the debates upon the draft-constitution there +arrived the news of Hoche's victory at Quiberon. The Convention gained +courage to add a clause providing that two-thirds of the new deputies +should be appointed from among its own members, thus rendering a Royalist +majority in the Chambers impossible. With this condition attached to it, +the Constitution was laid before the country. The provinces accepted it; +the Royalist middle class of Paris rose in insurrection, and marched +against the Convention in the Tuileries. Their revolt was foreseen; the +defence of the Convention was entrusted to General Bonaparte, who met the +attack of the Parisians in a style unknown in the warfare of the capital. +Bonaparte's command of trained artillery secured him victory; but the +struggle of the 4th of October (13 Vendemiaire) was the severest that took +place in Paris during the Revolution, and the loss of life in fighting +greater than on the day that overthrew the Monarchy. + +[The Directory, Oct., 1795.] + +The new Government of France now entered into power. Members of the +Convention formed two-thirds of the new legislative bodies; the one-third +which the country was permitted to elect consisted chiefly of men of +moderate or Royalist opinions. The five persons who were chosen Directors +were all Conventionalists who had voted for the death of the King; Carnot, +however, who had won the victories without sharing in the cruelties of the +Reign of Terror, was the only member of the late Committee of Public Safety +who was placed in power. In spite of the striking homage paid to the great +act of regicide in the election of the five Directors, the establishment of +the Directory was accepted by Europe as the close of revolutionary +disorder. The return of constitutional rule in France was marked by a +declaration on the part of the King of England of his willingness to treat +for peace. A gentler spirit seemed to have arisen in the Republic. Although +the laws against the emigrants and non-juring priests were still +unrepealed, the exiles began to return unmolested to their homes. Life +resumed something of its old aspect in the capital. The rich and the gay +consoled themselves with costlier luxury for all the austerities of the +Reign of Terror. The labouring classes, now harmless and disarmed, were +sharply taught that they must be content with such improvement in their lot +as the progress of society might bring. + +[What was new to Europe in the Revolution.] + +[Absolute governments of 18th century engaged in reforms.] + +At the close of this first period of the Revolutionary War we may pause to +make an estimate of the new influences which the French Revolution had +brought into Europe, and of the effects which had thus far resulted from +them. The opinion current among the French people themselves, that the +Revolution gave birth to the modern life not of France only but of the +Western Continent generally, is true of one great set of facts; it is +untrue of another. There were conceptions in France in 1789 which made +France a real contrast to most of the Continental monarchies; there were +others which it shared in common with them. The ideas of social, legal, and +ecclesiastical reform which were realised in 1789 were not peculiar to +France; what was peculiar to France was the idea that these reforms were to +be effected by the nation itself. In other countries reforms had been +initiated by Governments, and forced upon an unwilling people. Innovation +sprang from the Crown; its agents were the servants of the State. A +distinct class of improvements, many of them identical with the changes +made by the Revolution in France, attracted the attention in a greater or +less degree of almost all the Western Courts of the eighteenth century. The +creation of a simple and regular administrative system; the reform of the +clergy; the emancipation of the Church from the jurisdiction of the Pope, +and of all orders in the State from the jurisdiction of the Church; the +amelioration of the lot of the peasant; the introduction of codes of law +abolishing both the cruelties and the confusion of ancient practice,--all +these were purposes more or less familiar to the absolute sovereigns of the +eighteenth century, whom the French so summarily described as benighted +tyrants. It was in Austria, Prussia, and Tuscany that the civilising energy +of the Crown had been seen in its strongest form, but even the Governments +of Naples and Spain had caught the spirit of change. The religious +tolerance which Joseph gave to Austria, the rejection of Papal authority +and the abolition of the punishment of death which Leopold effected in +Tuscany, were bolder efforts of the same political rationalism which in +Spain minimised the powers of the Inquisition and in Naples attempted to +found a system of public education. In all this, however, there was no +trace of the action of the people, or of any sense that a nation ought to +raise itself above a state of tutelage. Men of ideas called upon +Governments to impose better institutions upon the people, not upon the +people to wrest them from the Governments. + +[In France, the nation itself acted.] + +In France alone a view of public affairs had grown up which impelled the +nation to create its reforms for itself. If the substance of many of the +French revolutionary changes coincided with the objects of Austrian or of +Tuscan reform, there was nothing similar in their method. In other +countries reform sprang from the command of an enlightened ruler; in France +it started with the Declaration of the Rights of Man, and aimed at the +creation of local authority to be exercised by the citizens themselves. The +source of this difference lay partly in the influence of England and +America upon French opinion, but much more in the existence within France +of a numerous and energetic middle class, enriched by commerce, and keenly +interested in all the speculation and literary activity of the age. This +was a class that both understood the wrongs which the other classes +inflicted or suffered, and felt itself capable of redressing them. For the +flogged and over-driven peasant in Naples or Hungary no ally existed but +the Crown. In most of those poor and backward States which made up +monarchical Europe, the fraction of the inhabitants which neither enjoyed +privilege nor stood in bondage to it was too small to think of forcing +itself into power. The nobles sought to preserve their feudal rights: the +Crown sought to reduce them; the nation, elsewhere than in France, did not +intervene and lay hands upon power for itself, because the nation was +nothing but the four mutually exclusive classes of the landlords who +commanded, the peasants who served, the priests who idled, and the soldiers +who fought. France differed from all the other monarchies of the Continent +in possessing a public which blended all classes and was dominated by none; +a public comprehending thousands of men who were familiar with the great +interests of society, and who, whether noble or not noble, possessed the +wealth and the intelligence that made them rightly desire a share in power. + +[Movements against governments outside France.] + +Liberty, the right of the nation to govern itself, seemed at the outset to +be the great principle of the Revolution. The French people themselves +believed the question at issue to be mainly between authority and popular +right; the rest of Europe saw the Revolution under the same aspect. Hence, +in those countries where the example of France produced political +movements, the effect was in the first instance to excite agitation against +the Government, whatever might be the form of the latter. In England the +agitation was one of the middle class against the aristocratic +parliamentary system; in Hungary, it was an agitation of the nobles against +the Crown; on the Rhine it was an agitation of the commercial classes +against ecclesiastical rule. But in every case in which the reforming +movement was not supported by the presence of French armies, the terrors +which succeeded the first sanguine hopes of the Revolution struck the +leaders of these movements with revulsion and despair, and converted even +the better Governments into engines of reaction. In France itself it was +seen that the desire for liberty among an enlightened class could not +suddenly transform the habits of a nation accustomed to accept everything +from authority. Privilege was destroyed, equality was advanced; but instead +of self-government the Revolution brought France the most absolute rule it +had ever known. It was not that the Revolution had swept by, leaving things +where they were before: it had in fact accomplished most of those great +changes which lay the foundation of a sound social life: but the faculty of +self-government, the first condition of any lasting political liberty, +remained to be slowly won. + +[Reaction.] + +Outside France reaction set in without the benefit of previous change. At +London, Vienna, Naples, and Madrid, Governments gave up all other objects +in order to devote themselves to the suppression of Jacobinism. Pitt, whose +noble aims had been the extinction of the slave-trade, the reform of +Parliament, and the advance of national intercourse by free trade, +surrendered himself to men whose thoughts centred upon informers, Gagging +Acts, and constructive treasons, and who opposed all legislation upon the +slave-trade because slaves had been freed by the Jacobins of the +Convention. State trials and imprisonments became the order of the day; but +the reaction in England at least stopped short of the scaffold. At Vienna +and Naples fear was more cruel. The men who either were, or affected to be, +in such fear of revolution that they discovered a Jacobinical allegory in +Mozart's last opera, [45] did not spare life when the threads of anything +like a real conspiracy were placed in their hands. At Vienna terror was +employed to crush the constitutional opposition of Hungary to the Austrian +Court. In Naples a long reign of cruelty and oppression began with the +creation of a secret tribunal to investigate charges of conspiracy made by +informers. In Mainz, the Archbishop occupied the last years of his +government, after his restoration in 1793, with a series of brutal +punishments and tyrannical precautions. + +These were but instances of the effect which the first epoch of the +Revolution produced upon the old European States. After a momentary +stimulus to freedom it threw the nations themselves into reaction and +apathy; it totally changed the spirit of the better governments, attaching +to all liberal ideas the stigma of Revolution, and identifying the work of +authority with resistance to every kind of reform. There were States in +which this change, the first effect of the Revolution, was also its only +one; States whose history, as in the case of England, is for a whole +generation the history of political progress unnaturally checked and thrown +out of its course. There were others, and these the more numerous, where +the first stimulus and the first reaction were soon forgotten in new and +penetrating changes produced by the successive victories of France. The +nature of these changes, even more than the warfare which introduced them, +gives its interest to the period on which we are about to enter. + + + + +CHAPTER III. + + +Triple attack on Austria--Moreau, Jourdan--Bonaparte in Italy--Condition of +the Italian States--Professions and real intentions of Bonaparte and the +Directory--Battle of Montenotte--Armistice with Sardinia--Campaign in +Lombardy--Treatment of the Pope, Naples, Tuscany--Siege of Mantua-- +Castiglione, Moreau and Jourdan in Germany Their retreat--Secret Treaty +with Prussia--Negotiations with England--Cispadane Republic--Rise of the +idea of Italian Independence--Battles of Arcola and Rivoli--Peace with the +Pope at Tolentino--Venice--Preliminaries of Leoben--The French in +Venice--The French take the Ionian Islands and give Venice to +Austria--Genoa--Coup d'etat of 17 Fructidor in Paris--Treaty of Campo +Formio--Victories of England at sea--Bonaparte's project against Egypt. + + +[Armies of Italy, the Danube, and the Main, 1796.] + +With the opening of the year 1796 the leading interest of European history +passes to a new scene. Hitherto the progress of French victory had been in +the direction of the Rhine: the advance of the army of the Pyrenees had +been cut short by the conclusion of peace with Spain; the army of Italy had +achieved little beyond some obscure successes in the mountains. It was the +appointment of Napoleon Bonaparte to the command of the latter force, in +the spring of 1796, that first centred the fortunes of the Republic in the +land beyond the Alps. Freed from Prussia by the Treaty of Basle, the +Directory was now able to withdraw its attention from Holland and from the +Lower Rhine, and to throw its whole force into the struggle with Austria. +By the advice of Bonaparte a threefold movement was undertaken against +Vienna, by way of Lombardy, by the valley of the Danube, and by the valley +of the Main. General Jourdan, in command of the army that had conquered the +Netherlands, was ordered to enter Germany by Frankfort; Moreau crossed the +Rhine at Strasburg: Bonaparte himself, drawing his scanty supplies along +the coast-road from Nice, faced the allied forces of Austria and Sardinia +upon the slopes of the Maritime Apennines, forty miles to the west of +Genoa. The country in which he was about to operate was familiar to +Bonaparte from service there in 1794; his own descent and language gave him +singular advantages in any enterprise undertaken in Italy. Bonaparte was no +Italian at heart; but he knew at least enough of the Italian nature to work +upon its better impulses, and to attach its hopes, so long as he needed the +support of Italian opinion, to his own career of victory. + +[Condition of Italy.] + +Three centuries separated the Italy of that day from the bright and +vigorous Italy which, in the glow of its Republican freedom, had given so +much to Northern Europe in art, in letters, and in the charm of life. A +long epoch of subjection to despotic or foreign rule, of commercial +inaction, of decline in mind and character, had made the Italians of no +account among the political forces of Europe. Down to the peace of +Aix-la-Chapelle in 1748 their provinces were bartered between the Bourbons +and the Hapsburgs; and although the settlement of that date left no part of +Italy, except the Duchy of Milan, incorporated in a foreign empire, yet the +crown of Naples was vested in a younger branch of the Spanish Bourbons, and +the marriage of Maria Theresa with the Archduke Francis made Tuscany an +appanage of the House of Austria. Venice and Genoa retained their +independence and their republican government, but little of their ancient +spirit. At the outbreak of the Revolutionary War, Austrian influence was +dominant throughout the peninsula, Marie Caroline, the Queen and the ruler +of Ferdinand of Naples, being the sister of the Emperor Leopold and Marie +Antoinette. With the exception of Piedmont, which preserved a strong +military sentiment and the tradition of an active and patriotic policy, the +Italian States were either, like Venice and Genoa, anxious to keep +themselves out of danger by seeming to hear and see nothing that passed +around them, or governed by families in the closest connection with the +great reigning Houses of the Continent. Neither in Italy itself, nor in the +general course of European affairs during the Napoleonic period, was +anything determined by the sentiment of the Italian people. The peasantry +at times fought against the French with energy; but no strong impulse, like +that of the Spaniards, enlisted the upper class of Italians either on the +side of Napoleon or on that of his enemies. Acquiescence and submission had +become the habit of the race; the sense of national unity and worth, the +personal pride which makes the absence of liberty an intolerable wrong, +only entered the Italian character at a later date. + +[Revival after 1740.] + +Yet, in spite of its political nullity, Italy was not in a state of +decline. Its worst days had ended before the middle of the eighteenth +century. The fifty years preceding the French Revolution, if they had +brought nothing of the spirit of liberty, had in all other respects been +years of progress and revival. In Lombardy the government of Maria Theresa +and Joseph awoke life and motion after ages of Spanish torpor and misrule. +Traditions of local activity revived; the communes were encouraged in their +works of irrigation and rural improvement; a singular liberality towards +public opinion and the press made the Austrian possessions the centre of +the intellectual movement of Italy. In the south, progress began on the day +when the last foreign Viceroy disappeared from Naples (1735), and King +Charles III., though a member of the Spanish House, entered upon the +government of the two Sicilies as an independent kingdom. Venice and the +Papal States alone seemed to be untouched by the spirit of material and +social improvement, so active in the rest of Italy before the interest in +political life had come into being. + +Nor was the age without its intellectual distinction. If the literature of +Italy in the second half of the eighteenth century had little that recalled +the inspiration of its splendid youth, it showed at least a return to +seriousness and an interest in important things. The political economists +of Lombardy were scarcely behind those of England; the work of the Milanese +Beccaria on "Crimes and Punishments" stimulated the reform of criminal law +in every country in Europe; an intelligent and increasing attention to +problems of agriculture, commerce, and education took the place of the +fatuous gallantries and insipid criticism which had hitherto made up the +life of Italians of birth and culture. One man of genius, Vittorio Alfieri, +the creator of Italian tragedy, idealised both in prose and verse a type of +rugged independence and resistance to tyrannical power. Alfieri was neither +a man of political judgment himself nor the representative of any real +political current in Italy; but the lesson which he taught to the Italians, +the lesson of respect for themselves and their country, was the one which +Italy most of all required to learn; and the appearance of this manly and +energetic spirit in its literature gave hope that the Italian nation would +not long be content to remain without political being. + +[Social condition.] + +[Tuscany.] + +Italy, to the outside world, meant little more than the ruins of the Roman +Forum, the galleries of Florence, the paradise of Capri and the Neapolitan +coast; the singular variety in its local conditions of life gained little +attention from the foreigner. There were districts in Italy where the +social order was almost of a Polish type of barbarism; there were others +where the rich and the poor lived perhaps under a happier relation than in +any other country in Europe. The difference depended chiefly upon the +extent to which municipal life had in past time superseded the feudal order +under which the territorial lord was the judge and the ruler of his own +domain. In Tuscany the city had done the most in absorbing the landed +nobility; in Naples and Sicily it had done the least. When, during the +middle ages, the Republic of Florence forced the feudal lords who +surrounded it to enter its walls as citizens, in some cases it deprived +them of all authority, in others it permitted them to retain a jurisdiction +over their peasants; but even in these instances the sovereignty of the +city deprived the feudal relation of most of its harshness and force. After +the loss of Florentine liberty, the Medici, aping the custom of older +monarchies, conferred the title of marquis and count upon men who preferred +servitude to freedom, and accompanied the grant of rank with one of +hereditary local authority; but the new institutions took no deep hold on +country life, and the legislation of the first Archduke of the House of +Lorraine (1749) left the landed aristocracy in the position of mere country +gentlemen. [46] Estates were not very large: the prevalent agricultural +system was, as it still is, that of the _mezzeria_, a partnership between +the landlord and tenant; the tenant holding by custom in perpetuity, and +sharing the produce with the landlord, who supplied a part of the stock and +materials for farming. In Tuscany the conditions of the _mezzeria_ were +extremely favourable to the tenant; and if a cheerful country life under a +mild and enlightened government were all that a State need desire, Tuscany +enjoyed rare happiness. + +[Naples and Sicily.] + +[Piedmont.] + +Far different was the condition of Sicily and Naples. Here the growth of +city life had never affected the rough sovereignty which the barons +exercised over great tracts of country withdrawn from the civilised world. +When Charles III. ascended the throne in 1735, he found whole provinces in +which there was absolutely no administration of justice on the part of the +State. The feudal rights of the nobility were in the last degree +oppressive, the barbarism of the people was in many districts extreme. Out +of two thousand six hundred towns and villages in the kingdom, there were +only fifty that were not subject to feudal authority. In the manor of San +Gennaro di Palma, fifteen miles from Naples, even down to the year 1786 the +officers of the baron were the only persons who lived in houses; the +peasants, two thousand in number, slept among the corn-ricks. [47] Charles, +during his tenure of the Neapolitan crown, from 1735 to 1759, and the +Ministers Tanucci and Caraccioli under his feeble successor Ferdinand IV., +enforced the authority of the State in justice and administration, and +abolished some of the most oppressive feudal rights of the nobility; but +their legislation, though bold and even revolutionary according to an +English standard, could not in the course of two generations transform a +social system based upon centuries of misgovernment and disorder. At the +outbreak of the French Revolution the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies was, as +it still in a less degree is, a land of extreme inequalities of wealth and +poverty, a land where great estates wasted in the hands of oppressive or +indolent owners, and the peasantry, untrained either by remunerative +industry or by a just and regular enforcement of the law, found no better +guide than a savage and fanatical priesthood. Over the rest of Italy the +conditions of life varied through all degrees between the Tuscan and the +Neapolitan type. Piedmont, in military spirit and patriotism far superior +to the other Italian States, was socially one of the most backward of all. +It was a land of priests, nobles, and soldiers, where a gloomy routine and +the repression of all originality of thought and character drove the most +gifted of its children, like the poet Alfieri, to seek a home on some more +liberal soil. + +[Professions and real intentions of the Directory and Bonaparte, 1796.] + +During the first years of the Revolution, an attempt had been made by +French enthusiasts to extend the Revolution into Italy by means of +associations in the principal towns; but it met with no great success. A +certain liberal movement arose among the young men of the upper classes at +Naples, where, under the influence of Queen Marie Caroline, the Government +had now become reactionary; and in Turin and several of the Lombard cities +the French were not without partisans; but no general disaffection like +that of Savoy existed east of the Alps. The agitation of 1789 and 1792 had +passed by without bringing either liberty or national independence to the +Italians. When Bonaparte received his command, that fervour of Republican +passion which, in the midst of violence and wrong, had seldom been wanting +in the first leaders of the Revolutionary War, had died out in France. The +politicians who survived the Reign of Terror and gained office in the +Directory repeated the old phrases about the Rights of Man and the +Liberation of the Peoples only as a mode of cajolery. Bonaparte entered +Italy proclaiming himself the restorer of Italian freedom, but with the +deliberate purpose of using Italy as a means of recruiting the exhausted +treasury of France. His correspondence with the Directory exposes with +brazen frankness this well-considered system of pillage and deceit, in +which the general and the Government were cordially at one. On the further +question, how France should dispose of any territory that might be +conquered in Northern Italy, Bonaparte and the Directory had formed no +understanding, and their purposes were in fact at variance. The Directory +wished to conquer Lombardy in order to hand it back to Austria in return +for the Netherlands; Bonaparte had at least formed the conception that an +Italian State was possible, and he intended to convert either Austrian +Lombardy itself, or some other portion of Northern Italy, into a Republic, +serving as a military outwork for France. + +[Bonaparte separates the Austrian and Sardinian Armies, April, 1796.] + +[Armistice and peace with Sardinia.] + +The campaign of 1796 commenced in April, in the mountains above the +coast-road connecting Nice and Genoa. Bonaparte's own army numbered 40,000 +men; the force opposed to it consisted of 38,000 Austrians, under Beaulieu, +and a smaller Sardinian army, so placed upon the Piedmontese Apennines as +to block the passes from the coast-road into Piedmont, and to threaten the +rear of the French if they advanced eastward against Genoa. The Piedmontese +army drew its supplies from Turin, the Austrian from Mantua; to sever the +two armies was to force them on to lines of retreat conducting them farther +and farther apart from one another. Bonaparte foresaw the effect which such +a separation of the two armies would produce upon the Sardinian Government. +For four days he reiterated his attacks at Montenotte and Millesimo, until +he had forced his own army into a position in the centre of the Allies; +then, leaving a small force to watch the Austrians, he threw the mass of +his troops upon the Piedmontese, and drove them back to within thirty miles +of Turin. The terror-stricken Government, anticipating an outbreak in the +capital itself, accepted an armistice from Bonaparte at Cherasco (April +28), and handed over to the French the fortresses of Coni, Ceva, and +Tortona, which command the entrances of Italy. It was an unworthy +capitulation for Turin could not have been taken before the Austrians +returned in force; but Bonaparte had justly calculated the effect of his +victory; and the armistice, which was soon followed by a treaty of peace +between France and Sardinia, ceding Savoy to the Republic, left him free to +follow the Austrians, untroubled by the existence of some of the strongest +fortresses of Europe behind him. + +[Bridge of Lodi, May 10.] + +In the negotiations with Sardinia Bonaparte demanded the surrender of the +town of Valenza, as necessary to secure his passage over the river Po. +Having thus led the Austrian Beaulieu to concentrate his forces at this +point, he suddenly moved eastward along the southern bank of the river, and +crossed at Piacenza, fifty miles below the spot where Beaulieu was awaiting +him. It was an admirable movement. The Austrian general, with the enemy +threatening his communications, had to abandon Milan and all the country +west of it, and to fall back upon the line of the Adda. Bonaparte followed, +and on the 10th of May attacked the Austrians at Lodi. He himself stormed +the bridge of Lodi at the head of his Grenadiers. The battle was so +disastrous to the Austrians that they could risk no second engagement, and +retired upon Mantua and the line of the Mincio. [48] + +[Bonaparte in Milan. Extortions.] + +Bonaparte now made his triumphal entry into Milan (May 15). The splendour +of his victories and his warm expressions of friendship for Italy excited +the enthusiasm of a population not hitherto hostile to Austrian rule. A new +political movement began. With the French army there came all the partisans +of the French Republic who had been expelled from other parts of Italy. +Uniting with the small revolutionary element already existing in Milan, +they began to form a new public opinion by means of journals and patriotic +meetings. It was of the utmost importance to Bonaparte that a Republican +party should be organised among the better classes in the towns of +Lombardy; for the depredations of the French army exasperated the peasants, +and Bonaparte's own measures were by no means of a character to win him +unmixed goodwill. The instructions which he received from the Directory +were extremely simple. "Leave nothing in Italy," they wrote to him on the +day of his entry into Milan, "which will be useful to us, and which the +political situation will allow you to remove." If Bonaparte had felt any +doubt as to the meaning of such an order, the pillage of works of art in +Belgium and Holland in preceding years would have shown him that it was +meant to be literally interpreted. Accordingly, in return for the gift of +liberty, the Milanese were invited to offer to their deliverers twenty +million francs, and a selection from the paintings in their churches and +galleries. The Dukes of Parma and Modena, in return for an armistice, were +required to hand over forty of their best pictures, and a sum of money +proportioned to their revenues. The Dukes and the townspeople paid their +contributions with good grace: the peasantry of Lombardy, whose cattle were +seized in order to supply an army that marched without any stores of its +own, rose in arms, and threw themselves into Pavia, killing all the French +soldiers who fell in their way. The revolt was instantly suppressed, and +the town of Pavia given up to pillage. In deference to the Liberal party of +Italy, the movement was described as a conspiracy of priests and nobles. + +[Venice.] + +[Battle on the Mincio, May 29.] + +The way into Central Italy now lay open before Bonaparte. Rome and Naples +were in no condition to offer resistance; but with true military judgment +the French general declined to move against this feeble prey until the army +of Austria, already crippled, was completely driven out of the field. +Instead of crossing the Apennines, Bonaparte advanced against the Austrian +positions upon the Mincio. It suited him to violate the neutrality of the +adjacent Venetian territory by seizing the town of Brescia. His example was +followed by Beaulieu, who occupied Peschiera, at the foot of the Lake of +Garda, and thus held the Mincio along its whole course from the lake to +Mantua. A battle was fought and lost by the Austrians half-way between the +lake and the fortress. Beaulieu's strength was exhausted; he could meet the +enemy no more in the field, and led his army out of Italy into the Tyrol, +leaving Mantua to be invested by the French. The first care of the +conqueror was to make Venice pay for the crime of possessing territory +intervening between the eastern and western extremes of the Austrian +district. Bonaparte affected to believe that the Venetians had permitted +Beaulieu to occupy Peschiera before he seized upon Brescia himself. He +uttered terrifying threats to the envoys who came from Venice to excuse an +imaginary crime. He was determined to extort money from the Venetian +Republic; he also needed a pretext for occupying Verona, and for any future +wrongs. "I have purposely devised this rupture," he wrote to the Directory +(June 7th), "in case you should wish to obtain five or six millions of +francs from Venice. If you have more decided intentions, I think it would +be well to keep up the quarrel." The intention referred to was the +disgraceful project of sacrificing Venice to Austria in return for the +cession of the Netherlands, a measure based on plans familiar to Thugut as +early as the year 1793. [49] + +[Armistice with Naples, June 6.] + +[Armistice with the Pope, June 23.] + +The Austrians were fairly driven out of Lombardy, and Bonaparte was now +free to deal with southern Italy. He advanced into the States of the +Church, and expelled the Papal Legate from Bologna. Ferdinand of Naples, +who had lately called heaven and earth to witness the fury of his zeal +against an accursed horde of regicides, thought it prudent to stay +Bonaparte's hand, at least until the Austrians were in a condition to renew +the war in Lombardy. He asked for a suspension of hostilities against his +own kingdom. The fleet and the sea-board of Naples gave it importance in +the struggle between France and England, and Bonaparte granted the king an +armistice on easy terms. The Pope, in order to gain a few months' truce, +had to permit the occupation of Ferrara, Ravenna, and Ancona, and to +recognise the necessities, the learning, the taste, and the virtue of his +conquerors by a gift of twenty million francs, five hundred manuscripts, a +hundred pictures, and the busts of Marcus and Lucius Brutus. The rule of +the Pope was unpopular in Bologna, and a Senate which Bonaparte placed in +power, pending the formation of a popular Government gladly took the oath +of fidelity to the French Republic. Tuscany was the only State that +remained to be dealt with. Tuscany had indeed made peace with the Republic +a year before, but the ships and cargoes of the English merchants at +Leghorn were surely fair prey; and, with the pretence of punishing insults +offered by the English to the French flag, Bonaparte descended upon +Leghorn, and seized upon everything that was not removed before his +approach. Once established in Leghorn, the French declined to quit it. By +way of adjusting the relations of the Grand Duke, the English seized his +harbour of Porto Ferraio, in the island of Elba. + +[Battles of Lonato and Castiglione, July, Aug., 1796.] + +Mantua was meanwhile invested, and thither, after his brief incursion into +Central Italy, Bonaparte returned. Towards the end of July an Austrian +relieving army, nearly double the strength of Bonaparte's, descended from +the Tyrol. It was divided into three corps: one, under Quosdanovich, +advanced by the road on the west of Lake Garda; the others, under Wurmser, +the commander-in-chief, by the roads between the lake and the river Adige. +The peril of the French was extreme; their outlying divisions were defeated +and driven in; Bonaparte could only hope to save himself by collecting all +his forces at the foot of the lake, and striking at one or other of the +Austrian armies before they effected their junction on the Mincio. He +instantly broke up the siege of Mantua, and withdrew from every position +east of the river. On the 30th of July, Quosdanovich was attacked and +checked at Lonato, on the west of the Lake of Garda. Wurmser, unaware of +his colleague's repulse, entered Mantua in triumph, and then set out, +expecting to envelop Bonaparte between two fires. But the French were ready +for his approach. Wurmser was stopped and defeated at Castiglione, while +the western Austrian divisions were still held in check at Lonato. The +junction of the Austrian armies had become impossible. In five days the +skill of Bonaparte and the unsparing exertions of his soldiery had more +than retrieved all that appeared to have been lost. [50] The Austrians +retired into the Tyrol, beaten and dispirited, and leaving 15,000 prisoners +in the hands of the enemy. + +Bonaparte now prepared to force his way into Germany by the Adige, in +fulfilment of the original plan of the campaign. In the first days of +September he again routed the Austrians, and gained possession of Roveredo +and Trent. Wurmser hereupon attempted to shut the French up in the +mountains by a movement southwards; but, while he operated with +insufficient forces between the Brenta and the Adige, he was cut off from +Germany, and only escaped capture by throwing himself into Mantua with the +shattered remnant of his army. The road into Germany through the Tyrol now +lay open; but in the midst of his victories Bonaparte learnt that the +northern armies of Moreau and Jourdan, with which he had intended to +co-operate in an attack upon Vienna, were in full retreat. + +[Invasion of Germany by Moureau and Jourdan, June-Oct. 1796.] + +[The Archduke Charles overpowers Jourdan.] + +Moreau's advance into the valley of the Danube had, during the months of +July and August, been attended with unbroken military and political +success. The Archduke Charles, who was entrusted with the defence of the +Empire, found himself unable to bring two armies into the field capable of +resisting those of Moreau and Jourdan separately, and he therefore +determined to fall back before Moreau towards Nuremberg, ordering +Wartensleben, who commanded the troops facing Jourdan on the Main, to +retreat in the same direction, in order that the two armies might throw +their collected force upon Jourdan while still at some distance north of +Moreau. [51] The design of the Archduke succeeded in the end, but it opened +Germany to the French for six weeks, and showed how worthless was the +military constitution of the Empire, and how little the Germans had to +expect from one another. After every skirmish won by Moreau some +neighbouring State abandoned the common defence and hastened to make its +terms with the invader. On the 17th of July the Duke of Wuertemberg +purchased an armistice at the price of four million francs; a week later +Baden gained the French general's protection in return for immense supplies +of food and stores. The troops of the Swabian Circle of the Empire, who +were ridiculed as "harlequins" by the more martial Austrians, dispersed to +their homes; and no sooner had Moreau entered Bavaria than the Bavarian +contingent in its turn withdrew from the Archduke. Some consideration was +shown by Moreau's soldiery to those districts which had paid tribute to +their general; but in the region of the Main, Jourdan's army plundered +without distinction and without mercy. They sacked the churches, they +maltreated the children, they robbed the very beggars of their pence. +Before the Archduke Charles was ready to strike, the peasantry of this +country, whom their governments were afraid to arm, had begun effective +reprisals of their own. At length the retreating movement of the Austrians +stopped. Leaving 30,000 men on the Lech to disguise his motions from +Moreau, Charles turned suddenly northwards from Neuburg on the [***] August, +met Wartensleben at Amberg, and attacked Jourdan at this place with greatly +superior numbers. Jourdan was defeated and driven back in confusion towards +the Rhine. The issue of the campaign was decided before Moreau heard of his +colleague's danger. It only remained for him to save his own army by a +skilful retreat. Jourdan's soldiers, returning through districts which they +had devastated, suffered heavier losses from the vengeance of the peasantry +than from the army that pursued them. By the autumn of 1796 no Frenchman +remained beyond the Rhine. The campaign had restored the military spirit of +Austria and given Germany a general in whom soldiers could trust; but it +had also shown how willing were the Governments of the minor States to +become the vassals of a foreigner, how little was wanting to convert the +western half of the Empire into a dependency of France. + +[Secret Treaty with Prussia, Aug. 5.] + +With each change in the fortunes of the campaign of 1796 the diplomacy of +the Continent had changed its tone. When Moreau won his first victories, +the Court of Prussia, yielding to the pressure of the Directory, +substituted for the conditional clauses of the Treaty of Basle a definite +agreement to the cession of the left bank of the Rhine, and a stipulation +that Prussia should be compensated for her own loss by the annexation of +the Bishopric of Muenster. Prussia could not itself cede provinces of the +Empire: it could only agree to their cession. In this treaty, however, +Prussia definitely renounced the integrity of the Empire, and accepted the +system known as the Secularisation of Ecclesiastical States, the first step +towards an entire reconstruction of Germany. [52] The engagement was kept +secret both from the Emperor and from the ecclesiastical princes. In their +negotiations with Austria the Directory were less successful. Although the +long series of Austrian disasters had raised a general outcry against +Thugut's persistence in the war, the resolute spirit of the Minister never +bent; and the ultimate victory of the Archduke Charles more than restored +his influence over the Emperor. Austria refused to enter into any +negotiation not conducted in common with England, and the Directory were +for the present foiled in their attempts to isolate England from the +Continental Powers. It was not that Thugut either hoped or cared for that +restoration of Austrian rule in the Netherlands which was the first object +of England's Continental policy. The abandonment of the Netherlands by +France was, however, in his opinion necessary for Austria, as a step +towards the acquisition of Bavaria, which was still the cherished hope of +the Viennese Government. It was in vain that the Directory suggested that +Austria should annex Bavaria without offering Belgium or any other +compensation to its ruler. Thugut could hardly be induced to listen to the +French overtures. He had received the promise of immediate help from the +Empress Catherine; he was convinced that the Republic, already anxious for +peace, might by one sustained effort be forced to abandon all its +conquests; and this was the object for which, in the winter of 1796, army +after army was hurled against the positions where Bonaparte kept his guard +on the north of the still unconquered Mantua. [53] + +[Malmesbury sent to Paris, Oct., 1796.] + +In England itself the victory of the Archduke Charles raised expectations +of peace. The war had become unpopular through the loss of trade with +France, Spain, and Holland, and petitions for peace daily reached +Parliament. Pitt so far yielded to the prevalent feeling as to enter into +negotiations with the Directory, and despatched Lord Malmesbury to Paris; +but the condition upon which Pitt insisted, the restoration of the +Netherlands to Austria, rendered agreement hopeless; and as soon as Pitt's +terms were known to the Directory, Malmesbury was ordered to leave Paris. +Nevertheless, the negotiation was not a mere feint on Pitt's part. He was +possessed by a fixed idea that the resources of France were exhausted, and +that, in spite of the conquest of Lombardy and the Rhine, the Republic must +feel itself too weak to continue the war. Amid the disorders of +Revolutionary finance, and exaggerated reports of suffering and distress, +Pitt failed to recognise the enormous increase of production resulting from +the changes which had given the peasant full property in his land and +labour, and thrown vast quantities of half-waste domain into the busy hands +of middling and small proprietors. [54] + +Whatever were the resources of France before the Revolution, they were now +probably more than doubled. Pitt's belief in the economic ruin of France, +the only ground on which he could imagine that the Directory would give up +Belgium without fighting for it, was wholly erroneous, and the French +Government would have acted strangely if they had listened to his demand. + +[Bonaparte creates a Cispadane Republic, Oct., 1796.] + +Nevertheless, though the Directory would not hear of surrendering Belgium, +they were anxious to conclude peace with Austria, and unwilling to enter +into any engagements in the conquered provinces of Italy which might render +peace with Austria more difficult. They had instructed Bonaparte to stir up +the Italians against their Governments, but this was done with the object +of paralysing the Governments, not of emancipating the peoples. They looked +with dislike upon any scheme of Italian reconstruction which should bind +France to the support of newly-formed Italian States. Here, however, the +scruples of the Directory and the ambition of Bonaparte were in direct +conflict. Bonaparte intended to create a political system in Italy which +should bear the stamp of his own mind and require his own strong hand to +support it. In one of his despatches to the Directory he suggested the +formation of a client Republic out of the Duchy of Modena, where +revolutionary movements had broken out. Before it was possible for the +Government to answer him, he published a decree, declaring the population +of Modena and Reggio under the protection of the French army, and deposing +all the officers of the Duke (Oct. 4). When, some days later, the answer of +the Directory arrived, it cautioned Bonaparte against disturbing the +existing order of the Italian States. Bonaparte replied by uniting to +Modena the Papal provinces of Bologna and Ferrara, and by giving to the +State which he had thus created the title of the Cispadane Republic. [55] + +[Idea of free Italy.] + +The event was no insignificant one. It is from this time that the idea of +Italian independence, though foreign to the great mass of the nation, may +be said to have taken birth as one of those political hopes which wane and +recede, but do not again leave the world. A class of men who had turned +with dislike from the earlier agitation of French Republicans in Italy +rightly judged the continued victories of Bonaparte over the Austrians to +be the beginning of a series of great changes, and now joined the +revolutionary movement in the hope of winning from the overthrow of the old +Powers some real form of national independence. In its origin the French +party may have been composed of hirelings and enthusiasts. This ceased to +be the case when, after the passage of the Mincio, Bonaparte entered the +Papal States. Among the citizens of Bologna in particular there were men of +weight and intelligence who aimed at free constitutional government, and +checked in some degree the more numerous popular party which merely +repeated the phrases of French democracy. Bonaparte's own language and +action excited the brightest hopes. At Modena he harangued the citizens +upon the mischief of Italy's divisions, and exhorted them to unite with +their brethren whom he had freed from the Pope. A Congress was held at +Modena on the 16th of October. The representatives of Modena, Reggio, +Bologna, and Ferrara declared themselves united in a Republic under the +protection of France. They abolished feudal nobility, decreed a national +levy, and summoned a General Assembly to meet at Reggio two months later, +in order to create the Constitution of the new Cispadane Republic. It was +in the Congress of Modena, and in the subsequent Assembly of Reggio (Dec. +23), that the idea of Italian unity and independence first awoke the +enthusiasm of any considerable body of men. With what degree of sincerity +Bonaparte himself acted may be judged from the circumstance that, while he +harangued the Cispadanes on the necessity of Italian union, he imprisoned +the Milanese who attempted to excite a popular movement for the purpose of +extending this union to themselves. Peace was not yet made with Austria, +and it was uncertain to what account Milan might best be turned. + +[Rivoli, Jan. 14, 15, 1797.] + +[Arcola, Nov. 15-17.] + +Mantua still held out, and in November the relieving operations of the +Austrians were renewed. Two armies, commanded by Allvintzy and Davidovich, +descended the valleys of the Adige and the Piave, offering to Bonaparte, +whose centre was at Verona, a new opportunity of crushing his enemy in +detail. Allvintzy, coming from the Piave, brought the French into extreme +danger in a three days' battle at Arcola, but was at last forced to retreat +with heavy loss. Davidovich, who had been successful on the Adige, retired +on learning the overthrow of his colleague. Two months more passed, and the +Austrians for the third time appeared on the Adige. A feint made below +Verona nearly succeeded in drawing Bonaparte away from Rivoli, between the +Adige and Lake Garda, where Allvintzy and his main army were about to make +the assault; but the strength of Allvintzy's force was discovered before it +was too late, and by throwing his divisions from point to point with +extraordinary rapidity, Bonaparte at length overwhelmed the Austrians in +every quarter of the battle-field. This was their last effort. The +surrender of Mantua on the 2nd February, 1797, completed the French +conquest of Austrian Lombardy. [56] + +[Peace of Tolentino, Feb. 19, 1797.] + +The Pope now found himself left to settle his account with the invaders, +against whom, even after the armistice, he had never ceased to intrigue. +[57] His despatches to Vienna fell into the hands of Bonaparte, who +declared the truce broken, and a second time invaded the Papal territory. A +show of resistance was made by the Roman troops; but the country was in +fact at the mercy of Bonaparte, who advanced as far as Tolentino, thirty +miles south of Ancona. Here the Pope tendered his submission. If the Roman +Court had never appeared to be in a more desperate condition, it had never +found a more moderate or a more politic conqueror. Bonaparte was as free +from any sentiment of Christian piety as Nero or Diocletian; but he +respected the power of the Papacy over men's minds, and he understood the +immense advantage which any Government of France supported by the +priesthood would possess over those who had to struggle with its hostility. +In his negotiations with the Papal envoys he deplored the violence of the +French Executive, and consoled the Church with the promise of his own +protection and sympathy. The terms of peace which he granted, although they +greatly diminished the ecclesiastical territory were in fact more +favourable than the Pope had any right to expect. Bologna, Ferrara, and the +Romagna, which had been occupied in virtue of the armistice, were now ceded +by the Papacy. But conditions affecting the exercise of the spiritual power +which had been proposed by the Directory were withdrawn; and, beyond a +provision for certain payments in money, nothing of importance was added to +the stipulations of the armistice. + +The last days of the Venetian Republic were now at hand. It was in vain +that Venice had maintained its neutrality when all the rest of Italy joined +the enemies of France; its refusal of a French alliance was made an +unpardonable crime. So long as the war with Austria lasted, Bonaparte +exhausted the Venetian territory with requisitions: when peace came within +view, it was necessary that he should have some pretext for seizing it or +handing it over to the enemy. In fulfilment of his own design of keeping a +quarrel open, he had subjected the Government to every insult and wrong +likely to goad it into an act of war. When at length Venice armed for the +purpose of protecting its neutrality, the organs of the invader called upon +the inhabitants of the Venetian mainland to rise against the oligarchy, and +to throw in their lot with the liberated province of Milan. A French +alliance was once more urged upon Venice by Bonaparte: it was refused, and +the outbreak which the French had prepared instantly followed. Bergamo and +Brescia, where French garrisons deprived the Venetian Government of all +power of defence, rose in revolt, and renounced all connection with Venice. +The Senate begged Bonaparte to withdraw the French garrisons; its +entreaties drew nothing from him but repeated demands for the acceptance of +the French alliance, which was only another name for subjection. Little as +the Venetians suspected it, the only doubt now present to Bonaparte was +whether he should add the provinces of Venetia to his own Cispadane +Republic or hand them over to Austria in exchange for other cessions which +France required. + +[Preliminaries of Leoben, April 18.] + +Austria could defend itself in Italy no longer. Before the end of March the +mountain-passes into Carinthia were carried by Bonaparte. His army drove +the enemy before it along the road to Vienna, until both pursuers and +pursued were within eighty miles of the capital. At Leoben, on the 7th of +April, Austrian commander asked for a suspension of arms. It was granted, +and negotiations for peace commenced. [58] Bonaparte offered the Venetian +provinces, but not the city of Venice, to the Emperor. On the 18th of April +preliminaries of peace were signed at Leoben, by which, in return for the +Netherlands and for Lombardy west of the river Oglio, Bonaparte secretly +agreed to hand over to Austria the whole of the territory of Venice upon +the mainland east of the Oglio, in addition to its Adriatic provinces of +Istria and Dalmatia. To disguise the act of spoliation, it was pretended +that Bologna and Ferrara should be offered to Venice in return. [59] + +[French enter Venice.] + +But worse was yet to come. While Bonaparte was in conference at Leoben, an +outbreak took place at Verona, and three hundred French soldiers, including +the sick in the hospital, perished by popular violence. The Venetian Senate +despatched envoys to Bonaparte to express their grief and to offer +satisfaction; in the midst of the negotiations intelligence arrived that +the commander of a Venetian fort had fired upon a French vessel and killed +some of the crew. Bonaparte drove the envoys from his presence, declaring +that he could not treat with men whose hands were dripping with French +blood. A declaration of war was published, charging the Senate with the +design of repeating the Sicilian Vespers, and the panic which it was +Bonaparte's object to inspire instantly followed. The Government threw +themselves upon his mercy. Bonaparte pretended that he desired no more than +to establish a popular government in Venice in the place of the oligarchy. +His terms were accepted. The Senate consented to abrogate the ancient +Constitution of the Republic, and to introduce a French garrison into +Venice. On the 12th of May the Grand Council voted its own dissolution. +Peace was concluded. The public articles of the treaty declared that there +should be friendship between the French and the Venetian Republics; that +the sovereignty of Venice should reside in the body of the citizens; and +that the French garrison should retire so soon as the new Government +announced that it had no further need of its support. Secret articles +stipulated for a money payment, and for the usual surrender of works of +art; an indefinite expression relating to an exchange of territory was +intended to cover the surrender of the Venetian mainland, and the union of +Bologna and Ferrara with what remained of Venice. The friendship and +alliance of France, which Bonaparte had been so anxious to bestow on +Venice, were now to bear their fruit. "I shall do everything in my power," +he wrote to the new Government of Venice, "to give you proof of the great +desire I have to see your liberty take root, and to see this unhappy Italy, +freed from the rule of the stranger, at length take its place with glory on +the scene of the world, and resume, among the great nations, the rank to +which nature, destiny, and its own position call it." This was for Venice; +for the French Directory Bonaparte had a very different tale. "I had +several motives," he wrote (May 19), "in concluding the treaty:--to enter +the city without difficulty; to have the arsenal and all else in our +possession, in order to take from it whatever we needed, under pretext of +the secret articles; ... to evade the odium attaching to the Preliminaries +of Leoben; to furnish pretexts for them, and to facilitate their +execution." + +[French seize Ionian islands.] + +[Venice to be given to Austria.] + +As the first fruits of the Venetian alliance, Bonaparte seized upon Corfu +and the other Ionian Islands. "You will start," he wrote to General +Gentili, "as quickly and as secretly as possible, and take possession of +all the Venetian establishments in the Levant.... If the inhabitants +should be inclined for independence, you should flatter their tastes, and +in all your proclamations you should not fail to allude to Greece, Athens, +and Sparta." This was to be the French share in the spoil. Yet even now, +though stripped of its islands, its coasts, and its ancient Italian +territory, Venice might still have remained a prominent city in Italy. It +was sacrificed in order to gain the Rhenish Provinces for France. Bonaparte +had returned to the neighbourhood of Milan, and received the Austrian +envoy, De Gallo, at the villa of Montebello. Wresting a forced meaning from +the Preliminaries of Leoben, Bonaparte claimed the frontier of the Rhine, +offering to Austria not only the territory of Venice upon the mainland, but +the city of Venice itself. De Gallo yielded. Whatever causes subsequently +prolonged the negotiation, no trace of honour or pity in Bonaparte led him +even to feign a reluctance to betray Venice. "We have to-day had our first +conference on the definitive treaty," he wrote to the Directory, on the +night of the 26th of May, "and have agreed to present the following +propositions: the line of the Rhine for France; Salzburg, Passau for the +Emperor; ... the maintenance of the Germanic Body; ... Venice for the +Emperor. Venice," he continued, "which has been in decadence since the +discovery of the Cape of Good Hope and the rise of Trieste and Ancona, can +scarcely survive the blows we have just struck. With a cowardly and +helpless population in no way fit for liberty, without territory and +without rivers, it is but natural that she should go to those to whom we +give the mainland." Thus was Italy to be freed from foreign intervention; +and thus was Venice to be regenerated by the friendship of France! + +[Genoa.] + +In comparison with the fate preparing for Venice, the sister-republic of +Genoa met with generous treatment. A revolutionary movement, long prepared +by the French envoy, overthrew the ancient oligarchical Government; but +democratic opinion and French sympathies did not extend below the middle +classes of the population; and, after the Government had abandoned its own +cause, the charcoal-burners and dock-labourers rose in its defence, and +attacked the French party with the cry of "Viva Maria," and with figures of +the Virgin fastened to their hats, in the place where their opponents wore +the French tricolour. Religious fanaticism won the day; the old Government +was restored, and a number of Frenchmen who had taken part in the conflict +were thrown into prison. The imprisonment of the Frenchmen gave Bonaparte a +pretext for intervention. He disclaimed all desire to alter the Government, +and demanded only the liberation of his countrymen and the arrest of the +enemies of France. But the overthrow of the oligarchy had been long +arranged with Faypoult, the French envoy; and Genoa received a democratic +constitution which place the friends of France in power (June 5). + +[France in 1797.] + +While Bonaparte, holding Court in the Villa of Montebello, continued to +negotiate with Austria upon the basis of the Preliminaries of Leoben, +events took place in France which offered him an opportunity of interfering +directly in the government of the Republic. The elections which were to +replace one-third of the members of the Legislature took place in the +spring of 1797. The feeling of the country was now much the same as it had +been in 1795, when a large Royalist element was returned for those seats in +the Councils which the Convention had not reserved for its own members. +France desired a more equitable and a more tolerant rule. The Directory had +indeed allowed the sanguinary laws against non-juring priests and returning +emigrants to remain unenforced; but the spirit and traditions of official +Jacobinism were still active in the Government. The Directors themselves +were all regicides; the execution of the King was still celebrated by a +national _fete_; offices, great and small, were held by men who had risen +in the Revolution; the whole of the old gentry of France was excluded from +participation in public life. It was against this revolutionary class-rule, +against a system which placed the country as much at the mercy of a few +directors and generals as it had been at the mercy of the Conventional +Committee, that the elections of 1797 were a protest. Along with certain +Bourbonist conspirators, a large majority of men were returned who, though +described as Royalists, were in fact moderate Constitutionalists, and +desired only to undo that part of the Revolution which excluded whole +classes of the nation from public life. [60] + +[Opposition to the Directory.] + +Such a party in the legislative body naturally took the character of an +Opposition to the more violent section of the Directory. The Director +retiring in 1797 was replaced by the Constitutionalist Barthelemy, +negotiator of the treaty of Basle; Carnot, who continued in office, took +part with the Opposition, justly fearing that the rule of the Directory +would soon amount to nothing more than the rule of Bonaparte himself. The +first debates in the new Chamber arose upon the laws relating to emigrants; +the next, upon Bonaparte's usurpation of sovereign power in Italy. On the +23rd of June a motion for information on the affairs of Venice and Genoa +was brought forward in the Council of Five Hundred. Dumolard, the mover, +complained of the secrecy of Bonaparte's action, of the contempt shown by +him to the Assembly, of his tyrannical and un-republican interference with +the institutions of friendly States. No resolution was adopted by the +Assembly; but the mere fact that the Assembly had listened to a hostile +criticism of his own actions was sufficient ground in Bonaparte's eyes to +charge it with Royalism and with treason. Three of the Directors, Barras, +Rewbell, and Lareveillere, had already formed the project of overpowering +the Assembly by force. Bonaparte's own interests led him to offer them his +support. If the Constitutional party gained power, there was an end to his +own unshackled rule in Italy; if the Bourbonists succeeded, a different +class of men would hold all the honours of the State. However feeble the +Government of the Directory, its continuance secured his own present +ascendency, and left him the hope of gaining supreme power when the public +could tolerate the Directory no longer. + +[Coup d'etat, 17 Fructidor (Sept. 3).] + +The fate of the Assembly was sealed. On the anniversary of the capture of +the Bastille, Bonaparte issued a proclamation to his army declaring the +Republic to be threatened by Royalist intrigues. A banquet was held, and +the officers and soldiers of every division signed addresses to the +Directory full of threats and fury against conspiring aristocrats. +"Indignation is at its height in the army," wrote Bonaparte to the +Government; "the soldiers are asking with loud cries whether they are to be +rewarded by assassination on their return home, as it appears all patriots +are to be so dealt with. The peril is increasing every day, and I think, +citizen Directors, you must decide to act one way or other." The Directors +had no difficulty in deciding after such an exhortation as this; but, as +soon as Bonaparte had worked up their courage, he withdrew into the +background, and sent General Augereau, a blustering Jacobin, to Paris, to +risk the failure or bear the odium of the crime. Augereau received the +military command of the capital; the air was filled with rumours of an +impending blow; but neither the majority in the Councils nor the two +threatened Directors, Carnot and Barthelemy, knew how to take measures of +defence. On the night of the 3rd September (17 Fructidor) the troops of +Augereau surrounded the Tuileries. Barthelemy was seized at the Luxembourg; +Carnot fled for his life; the members of the Councils, marching in +procession to the Tuileries early the next morning, were arrested or +dispersed by the soldiers. Later in the day a minority of the Councils was +assembled to ratify the measures determined upon by Augereau and the three +Directors. Fifty members of the Legislature, and the writers, proprietors, +and editors of forty-two journals, were sentenced to exile; the elections +of forty-eight departments were annulled; the laws against priests and +emigrants were renewed; and the Directory was empowered to suppress all +journals at its pleasure. This coup d'etat was described as the suppression +of a Royalist conspiracy. It was this, but it was something more. It was +the suppression of all Constitutional government, and all but the last step +to the despotism of the chief of the army. + +[Peace signed with Austria, Oct. 17.] + +The effect of the movement was instantly felt in the negotiations with +Austria and with England. Lord Malmesbury was now again in France, treating +for peace with fair hopes of success, since the Preliminaries of Leoben had +removed England's opposition to the cession of the Netherlands, the +discomfiture of the moderate party in the Councils brought his mission to +an abrupt end. Austria, on the other hand, had prolonged its negotiations +because Bonaparte claimed Mantua and the Rhenish Provinces in addition to +the cessions agreed upon at Leoben. Count Ludwig Cobenzl, Austrian +ambassador at St. Petersburg, who had protected his master's interests only +too well in the last partition of Poland, was now at the head of the +plenipotentiaries in Italy, endeavouring to bring Bonaparte back to the +terms fixed in the Preliminaries, or to gain additional territory for +Austria in Italy. The Jacobin victory at Paris depressed the Austrians as +much as it elated the French leader. Bonaparte was resolved on concluding a +peace that should be all his own, and this was only possible by +anticipating an invasion of Germany, about to be undertaken by Augereau at +the head of the Army of the Rhine. It was to this personal ambition of +Bonaparte that Venice was sacrificed. The Directors were willing that +Austria should receive part of the Venetian territory: they forbade the +proposed cession of Venice itself. Within a few weeks more, the advance of +the Army of the Rhine would have enabled France to dictate its own terms; +but no consideration either for France or for Italy could induce Bonaparte +to share the glory of the Peace with another. On the 17th of October he +signed the final treaty of Campo Formio, which gave France the frontier of +the Rhine, and made both the Venetian territory beyond the Adige and Venice +itself the property of the Emperor. For a moment it seemed that the Treaty +might be repudiated at Vienna as well as at Paris. Thugut protested against +it, because it surrendered Mantua and the Rhenish Provinces without gaining +for Austria the Papal Legations; and he drew up the ratification only at +the absolute command of the Emperor. The Directory, on the other hand, +condemned the cession of Venice. But their fear of Bonaparte and their own +bad conscience left them impotent accessories of his treachery; and the +French nation at large was too delighted with the peace to resent its baser +conditions. [61] + +[Treaty of Campo Formio, Oct. 17.] + +By the public articles of the Treaty of Campo Formio, the Emperor ceded to +France the Austrian possessions in Lombardy and in the Netherlands, and +agreed to the establishment of a Cisalpine Republic, formed out of Austrian +Lombardy, the Venetian territory west of the Adige, and the districts +hitherto composing the new Cispadane State. France took the Ionian Islands, +Austria the City of Venice, with Istria and Dalmatia, and the Venetian +mainland east of the Adige. For the conclusion of peace between France and +the Holy Roman Empire, it was agreed that a Congress should meet at +Rastadt; but a secret article provided that the Emperor should use his +efforts to gain for France the whole left bank of the Rhine, except a tract +including the Prussian Duchies of Cleve and Guelders. With humorous +duplicity the French Government, which had promised Prussia the Bishopric +of Muenster in return for this very district, now pledged itself to Austria +that Prussia should receive no extension whatever, and affected to exclude +the Prussian Duchies from the Rhenish territory which was to be made over +to France. Austria was promised the independent Bishopric of Salzburg, and +that portion of Bavaria which lies between the Inn and the Salza. The +secular princes dispossessed in the Rhenish Provinces were to be +compensated in the interior of the Empire by a scheme framed in concert +with France. + +[Austria sacrifices Germany.] + +The immense advantages which the Treaty of Campo Formio gave to France--its +extension over the Netherlands and the Rhenish Provinces, and the virtual +annexation of Lombardy, Modena, and the Papal Legations under the form of a +client republic--were not out of proportion to its splendid military +successes. Far otherwise was it with Austria. With the exception of the +Archduke's campaign of 1796, the warfare of the last three years had +brought Austria nothing but a series of disasters; yet Austria gained by +the Treaty of Campo Formio as much as it lost. In the place of the distant +Netherlands and of Milan it gained, in Venice and Dalmatia, a territory +touching its own, nearly equal to the Netherlands and Milan together in +population, and so situated as to enable Austria to become one of the naval +Powers of the Mediterranean. The price which Austria paid was the +abandonment of Germany, a matter which, in spite of Thugut's protests, +disturbed the Court of Vienna as little as the betrayal of Venice disturbed +Bonaparte. The Rhenish Provinces were surrendered to the stranger; German +districts were to be handed over to compensate the ejected Sovereigns of +Holland and of Modena; the internal condition and order of the Empire were +to be superseded by one framed not for the purpose of benefiting Germany, +but for the purpose of extending the influence of France. + +[Policy of Bonaparte.] + +As defenders of Germany, both Prussia and Austria had been found wanting. +The latter Power seemed to have reaped in Italy the reward of its firmness +in prolonging the war. Bonaparte ridiculed the men who, in the earlier +spirit of the Revolution, desired to found a freer political system in +Europe upon the ruins of Austria's power. "I have not drawn my support in +Italy," he wrote to Talleyrand (Oct. 7), "from the love of the peoples for +liberty and equality, or at least but a very feeble support. The real +support of the army of Italy has been its own discipline, ... above all, +our promptitude in repressing malcontents and punishing those who declared +against us. This is history; what I say in my proclamations and speeches is +a romance.... If we return to the foreign policy of 1793, we shall do so +knowing that a different policy has brought us success, and that we have no +longer the great masses of 1793 to enrol in our armies, nor the support of +an enthusiasm which has its day and does not return." Austria might well, +for the present, be left in some strength, and France was fortunate to have +so dangerous an enemy off her hands. England required the whole forces of +the Republic. "The present situation," wrote Bonaparte, after the Peace of +Campo Formio, "offers us a good chance. We must set all our strength upon +the sea; we must destroy England; and the Continent is at our feet." + +[Battles of St. Vincent, Feb. 14, 1797, and Camperdown, Oct. 6.] + +It had been the natural hope of the earlier Republicans that the Spanish +and the Dutch navies, if they could be brought to the side of France, would +make France superior to Great Britain as a maritime Power. The conquest of +Holland had been planned by Carnot as the first step towards an invasion of +England. For a while these plans seemed to be approaching their fulfilment, +Holland was won; Spain first made peace, and then entered into alliance +with the Directory (Aug. 1796). But each increase in the naval forces of +the Republic only gave the admirals of Great Britain new material to +destroy. The Spanish fleet was beaten by Jarvis off St. Vincent; even the +mutiny of the British squadrons at Spithead and the Nore, in the spring and +summer of 1797, caused no change in the naval situation in the North Sea. +Duncan, who was blockading the Dutch fleet in the Texel when his own +squadron joined the mutineers, continued the blockade with one ship beside +his own, signalling all the while as if the whole fleet were at his back; +until the misused seamen, who had lately turned their guns upon the Thames, +returned to the admiral, and earned his forgiveness by destroying the Dutch +at Camperdown as soon as they ventured out of shelter. + +[Bonaparte about to invade Egypt.] + +It is doubtful whether at any time after his return from Italy Bonaparte +seriously entertained the project of invading England. The plan was at any +rate soon abandoned, and the preparations, which caused great alarm in the +English coast-towns, were continued only for the purpose of disguising +Bonaparte's real design of an attack upon Egypt. From the beginning of his +career Bonaparte's thoughts had turned towards the vast and undefended +East. While still little known, he had asked the French Government to send +him to Constantinople to organise the Turkish army; as soon as Venice fell +into his hands, he had seized the Ionian Islands as the base for a future +conquest of the Levant. Every engagement that confirmed the superiority of +England upon the western seas gave additional reason for attacking her +where her power was most precarious, in the East. Bonaparte knew that +Alexander had conquered the country of the Indus by a land-march from the +Mediterranean, and this was perhaps all the information which he possessed +regarding the approaches to India; but it was enough to fix his mind upon +the conquest of Egypt and Syria, as the first step towards the destruction +of the Asiatic Empire of England. Mingled with the design upon India was a +dream of overthrowing the Mohammedan Government of Turkey, and attacking +Austria from the East with an army drawn from the liberated Christian races +of the Ottoman Empire. The very vagueness of a scheme of Eastern conquest +made it the more attractive to Bonaparte's genius and ambition. Nor was +there any inclination on the part of the Government to detain the general +at home. The Directory, little concerned with the real merits or dangers of +the enterprise, consented to Bonaparte's project of an attack upon Egypt, +thankful for any opportunity of loosening the grasp which was now closing +so firmly upon themselves. + + + + +CHAPTER IV. + + +Congress of Rastadt--The Rhenish Provinces ceded--Ecclesiastical States of +Germany suppressed--French intervention in Switzerland--Helvetic Republic-- +The French invade the Papal States--Roman Republic--Expedition to Egypt-- +Battle of the Nile--Coalition of 1798--Ferdinand of Naples enters +Rome--Mack's defeats--French enter Naples--Parthenopean Republic--War with +Austria and Russia--Battle of Stockach--Murder of the French Envoys at +Rastadt--Campaign in Lombardy--Reign of Terror at Naples--Austrian designs +upon Italy--Suvaroff and the Austrians--Campaign in Switzerland--Campaign +in Holland--Bonaparte returns from Egypt--Coup d'etat of 18 Brumaire-- +Constitution of 1799--System of Bonaparte in France--Its effect on the +influence of France abroad. + + +[Congress of Rastadt, Nov. 1797.] + +The public articles of the Treaty of Campo Formio contained only the terms +which had been agreed upon by France and Austria in relation to Italy and +the Netherlands: the conditions of peace between France and the Germanic +Body, which had been secretly arranged between France and the two leading +Powers, were referred by a diplomatic fiction to a Congress that was to +assemble at Rastadt. Accordingly, after Prussia and Austria had each signed +an agreement abandoning the Rhenish Provinces, the Congress was duly +summoned. As if in mockery of his helpless countrymen, the Emperor informed +the members of the Diet that "in unshaken fidelity to the great principle +of the unity and indivisibility of the German Empire, they were to maintain +the common interests of the Fatherland with noble conscientiousness and +German steadfastness; and so, united with their imperial head, to promote a +just and lasting peace, founded upon the basis of the integrity of the +Empire and of its Constitution." [62] Thus the Congress was convoked upon +the pretence of preserving what the two greater States had determined to +sacrifice; while its real object, the suppression of the ecclesiastical +principalities and the curtailment of Bavaria, was studiously put out of +sight. + +[Rivalry of the Germans.] + +The Congress was composed of two French envoys, of the representatives of +Prussia and Austria, and of a committee, numbering with their secretaries +seventy-four persons, appointed by the Diet of Ratisbon. But the recognised +negotiators formed only a small part of the diplomatists who flocked to +Rastadt in the hope of picking up something from the wreck of the Empire. +Every petty German sovereign, even communities which possessed no political +rights at all, thought it necessary to have an agent on the spot, in order +to filch, if possible, some trifling advantage from a neighbour, or to +catch the first rumour of a proposed annexation. It was the saturnalia of +the whole tribe of busybodies and intriguers who passed in Germany for men +of state. They spied upon one another; they bribed the secretaries and +doorkeepers, they bribed the very cooks and coachmen, of the two omnipotent +French envoys. Of the national humiliation of Germany, of the dishonour +attaching to the loss of entire provinces and the reorganisation of what +remained at the bidding of the stranger, there seems to have been no sense +in the political circles of the day. The collapse of the Empire was viewed +rather as a subject of merriment. A gaiety of life and language prevailed, +impossible among men who did not consider themselves as the spectators of a +comedy. Cobenzl, the chief Austrian plenipotentiary, took his travels in a +fly, because his mistress, the _citoyenne_ Hyacinthe, had decamped with all +his carriages and horses. A witty but profane pamphlet was circulated, in +which the impending sacrifice of the Empire was described in language +borrowed from the Gospel narrative, Prussia taking the part of Judas +Iscariot, Austria that of Pontius Pilate, the Congress itself being the +chief priests and Pharisees assembling that they may take the Holy Roman +Empire by craft, while the army of the Empire figures as the "multitude who +smote upon their breasts and departed." In the utter absence of any German +pride or patriotism the French envoys not only obtained the territory that +they required, but successfully embroiled the two leading Powers with one +another, and accustomed the minor States to look to France for their own +promotion at the cost of their neighbours. The contradictory pledges which +the French Government had given to Austria and to Prussia caused it no +embarrassment. To deceive one of the two powers was to win the gratitude of +the other; and the Directory determined to fulfil its engagement to Prussia +at the expense of the bishoprics, and to ignore what it had promised to +Austria at the expense of Bavaria. + +[Rhenish Provinces.] + +[Ecclesiastical States suppressed.] + +A momentary difficulty arose upon the opening of the Congress, when it +appeared that, misled by the Emperor's protestations, the Diet had only +empowered its Committee to treat upon the basis of the integrity of the +Empire (Dec. 9). The French declined to negotiate until the Committee had +procured full powers: and the prospects of the integrity of the Empire were +made clear enough a few days later by the entry of the French into Mainz, +and the formal organisation of the Rhenish Provinces as four French +Departments. In due course a decree of the Diet arrived, empowering the +Committee to negotiate at their discretion: and for some weeks after the +inhabitants of the Rhenish Provinces had been subjected to the laws, the +magistracy, and the taxation of France, the Committee deliberated upon the +proposal for their cession with as much minuteness and as much impartiality +as if it had been a point of speculative philosophy. At length the French +put an end to the tedious trifling, and proceeded to the question of +compensation for the dispossessed lay Princes. This they proposed to effect +by means of the disestablishment, or secularisation, of ecclesiastical +States in the interior of Germany. Prussia eagerly supported the French +proposal, both with a view to the annexation of the great Bishopric of +Muenster, and from ancient hostility to the ecclesiastical States as +instruments and allies of Catholic Austria. The Emperor opposed the +destruction of his faithful dependents; the ecclesiastical princes +themselves raised a bitter outcry, and demonstrated that the fall of their +order would unloose the keystone of the political system of Europe; but +they found few friends. If Prussia coveted the great spoils of Muenster, the +minor sovereigns, as a rule, wore just as eager for the convents and abbeys +that broke the continuity of their own territories: only the feeblest of +all the members of the Empire, the counts, the knights, and the cities, +felt a respectful sympathy for their ecclesiastical neighbours, and foresaw +that in a system of annexation their own turn would come next. The +principle of secularisation was accepted by the Congress without much +difficulty, all the energy of debate being reserved for the discussion of +details: arrangements which were to transfer a few miles of ground and half +a dozen custom-houses from some bankrupt ecclesiastic to some French-bought +duke excited more interest in Germany than the loss of the Rhenish +Provinces, and the subjection of a tenth part of the German nation to a +foreign rule. + +[Austria determines on war, 1798.] + +One more question was unexpectedly presented to the Congress. After +proclaiming for six years that the Rhine was the natural boundary of +France, the French Government discovered that a river cannot be a military +frontier at all. Of what service, urged the French plenipotentiaries, were +Strasburg and Mainz, so long as they were commanded by the guns on the +opposite bank? If the Rhine was to be of any use to France, France must be +put in possession of the fortresses of Kehl and Castel upon the German +side. Outrageous as such a demand appears, it found supporters among the +venal politicians of the smaller Courts, and furnished the Committee with +material for arguments that extended over four months. But the policy of +Austria was now taking a direction that rendered the resolutions of the +Congress of very little importance. It had become clear that France was +inclining to an alliance with Prussia, and that the Bavarian annexations +promised to Austria by the secret articles of Campo Formio were to be +withheld. Once convinced, by the failure of a private negotiation in +Alsace, that the French would neither be content with their gains of 1797, +nor permit Austria to extend its territory in Italy, Thugut determined upon +a renewal of the war. [63] In spite of a powerful opposition at Court, +Thugut's stubborn will still controlled the fortune of Austria: and the +aggressions of the French Republic in Switzerland and the Papal States, at +the moment when it was dictating terms of peace to the Empire, gave only +too much cause for the formation of a new European league. + +[French intervention in Switzerland.] + +At the close of the last century there was no country where the spirit of +Republican freedom was so strong, or where the conditions of life were so +level, as in Switzerland; its inhabitants, however, were far from enjoying +complete political equality. There were districts which stood in the +relation of subject dependencies to one or other of the ruling cantons: the +Pays de Vaud was governed by an officer from Berne; the valley of the +Ticino belonged to Uri; and in most of the sovereign cantons themselves +authority was vested in a close circle of patrician families. Thus, +although Switzerland was free from the more oppressive distinctions of +caste, and the Governments, even where not democratic, were usually just +and temperate, a sufficiently large class was excluded from political +rights to give scope to an agitation which received its impulse from Paris. +It was indeed among communities advanced in comfort and intelligence, and +divided from those who governed them by no great barrier of wealth and +prestige, that the doctrines of the Revolution found a circulation which +they could never gain among the hereditary serfs of Prussia or the +priest-ridden peasantry of the Roman States. As early as the year 1792 a +French army had entered the territory of Geneva, in order to co-operate +with the democratic party in the city. The movement was, however, checked +by the resolute action of the Bernese Senate; and the relations of France +to the Federal Government had subsequently been kept upon a friendly +footing by the good sense of Barthelemy, the French ambassador at Berne, +and the discretion with which the Swiss Government avoided every occasion +of offence. On the conquest of Northern Italy, Bonaparte was brought into +direct connection with Swiss affairs by a reference of certain points in +dispute to his authority as arbitrator. Bonaparte solved the difficulty by +annexing the district of the Valteline to the Cisalpine Republic; and from +that time he continued in communication with the Swiss democratic leaders +on the subject of a French intervention in Switzerland, the real purpose of +which was to secure the treasure of Berne, and to organise a government, +like that of Holland and the Cisalpine Republic, in immediate dependence +upon France. + +[Helvetic Republic, April 12.] + +[War between France and Swiss Federation, June, 1798.] + +At length the moment for armed interference arrived. On the 15th December, +1797, a French force entered the Bishopric of Basle, and gave the signal +for insurrection in the Pays de Vaud. The Senate of Berne summoned the Diet +of the Confederacy to provide for the common defence: the oath of +federation was renewed, and a decree was passed calling out the Federal +army. It was now announced by the French that they would support the +Vaudois revolutionary party, if attacked. The Bernese troops, however, +advanced; and the bearer of a flag of truce having been accidentally +killed, war was declared between the French Republic and the Government of +Berne. Democratic movements immediately followed in the northern and +western cantons; the Bernese Government attempted to negotiate with the +French invaders, but discovered that no terms would be accepted short of +the entire destruction of the existing Federal Constitution. Hostilities +commenced; and the Bernese troops, supported by contingents from most of +the other cantons, offered a brave but ineffectual resistance to the +advance of the French, who entered the Federal capital on the 6th of March, +1798. The treasure of Berne, amounting to about L800,000, accumulated by +ages of thrift and good management, was seized in order to provide for +Bonaparte's next campaign, and for a host of voracious soldiers and +contractors. A system of robbery and extortion, more shameless even than +that practised in Italy, was put in force against the cantonal governments, +against the monasteries, and against private individuals. In compensation +for the material losses inflicted upon the country, the new Helvetic +Republic, one and indivisible, was proclaimed at Aarau. It conferred an +equality of political rights upon all natives of Switzerland, and +substituted for the ancient varieties of cantonal sovereignty a single +national government, composed, like that of France, of a Directory and two +Councils of Legislature. + +The towns and districts which had been hitherto excluded from a share in +government welcomed a change which seemed to place them on a level with +their former superiors: the mountain-cantons fought with traditional +heroism in defence of the liberties which they had inherited from their +fathers; but they were compelled, one after another, to submit to the +overwhelming force of France, and to accept the new constitution. Yet, even +now, when peace seemed to have been restored, and the whole purpose of +France attained, the tyranny and violence of the invaders exhausted the +endurance of a spirited people. The magistrates of the Republic were +expelled from office at the word of a French Commission; hostages were +seized; at length an oath of allegiance to the new order was required as a +condition for the evacuation of Switzerland by the French army. Revolt +broke out in Unterwalden, and a handful of peasants met the French army at +the village of Stanz, near the eastern shore of the Lake of Lucerne (Sept. +8). There for three days they fought with unyielding courage. Their +resistance inflamed the French to a cruel vengeance; slaughtered families +and burning villages renewed, in this so-called crusade of liberty, the +savagery of ancient war. + +[French intrigues in Rome.] + +Intrigues at Rome paved the way for a French intervention in the affairs of +the Papal States, coincident in time with the invasion of Switzerland. The +residence of the French ambassador at Rome, Joseph Bonaparte, was the +centre of a democratic agitation. The men who moved about him were in great +part strangers from the north of Italy, but they found adherents in the +middle and professional classes in Rome itself, although the mass of the +poor people, as well as the numerous body whose salaries or profits +depended upon ecclesiastical expenditure, were devoted to the priests and +the Papacy. In anticipation of disturbances, the Government ordered +companies of soldiers to patrol the city. A collision occurred on the 28th +December, 1797, between the patrols and a band of revolutionists, who, +being roughly handled by the populace as well as by the soldiers, made +their way for protection to the courtyard of the Palazzo Corsini, where +Joseph Bonaparte resided. Here, in the midst of a confused struggle, +General Duphot, a member of the Embassy, was shot by a Papal soldier. [64] + +[Berthier enters Rome, Feb. 10, 1798.] + +[Roman Republic, Feb. 15, 1798.] + +The French had now the pretext against the Papal Government which they +desired. Joseph Bonaparte instantly left the city, and orders were sent to +Berthier, chief of the staff in northern Italy, to march upon Rome. +Berthier advanced amid the acclamations of the towns and the curses of the +peasantry, and entered Rome on the 10th of February, 1798. Events had +produced in the capital a much stronger inclination towards change than +existed on the approach of Bonaparte a year before. The treaty of Tolentino +had shaken the prestige of Papal authority; the loss of so many well-known +works of art, the imposition of new and unpopular taxes, had excited as +much hatred against the defeated government as against the extortionate +conquerors; even among the clergy and their retainers the sale of a portion +of the Church-lands and the curtailment of the old Papal splendours had +produced alienation and discontent. There existed too within the Italian +Church itself a reforming party, lately headed by Ricci, bishop of Pistoia, +which claimed a higher degree of independence for the clergy, and condemned +the assumption of universal authority by the Roman See. The ill-judged +exercise of the Pope's temporal power during the last six years had gained +many converts to the opinion that the head of the Church would best perform +his office if emancipated from a worldly sovereignty, and restored to his +original position of the first among the bishops. Thus, on its approach to +Rome, the Republican army found the city ripe for revolution. On the 15th +of February an excited multitude assembled in the Forum, and, after +planting the tree of liberty in front of the Capitol, renounced the +authority of the Pope, and declared that the Roman people constituted +itself a free Republic. The resolution was conveyed to Berthier, who +recognised the Roman Commonwealth, and made a procession through the city +with the solemnity of an ancient triumph. The Pope shut himself up in the +Vatican. His Swiss guard was removed, and replaced by one composed of +French soldiers, at whose hands the Pontiff, now in his eighty-first year, +suffered unworthy insults. He was then required to renounce his temporal +power, and, upon his refusal, was removed to Tuscany, and afterwards beyond +the Alps to Valence, where in 1799 he died, attended by a solitary +ecclesiastic. + +In the liberated capital a course of spoliation began, more thorough and +systematic than any that the French had yet effected. The riches of Rome +brought all the brokers and contractors of Paris to the spot. The museums, +the Papal residence, and the palaces of many of the nobility were robbed of +every article that could be moved; the very fixtures were cut away, when +worth the carriage. On the first meeting of the National Institute in the +Vatican it was found that the doors had lost their locks; and when, by +order of the French, masses were celebrated in the churches in expiation of +the death of Duphot, the patrols who were placed at the gates to preserve +order rushed in and seized the sacred vessels. Yet the general robbery was +far less the work of the army than of the agents and contractors sent by +the Government. In the midst of endless peculation the soldiers were in +want of their pay and their food. A sense of the dishonour done to France +arose at length in the subordinate ranks of the army; and General Massena, +who succeeded Berthier, was forced to quit his command in consequence of +the protests of the soldiery against a system to which Massena had +conspicuously given his personal sanction. It remained to embody the +recovered liberties of Rome in a Republican Constitution, which was, as a +matter of course, a reproduction of the French Directory and Councils of +Legislature, under the practical control of the French general in command. +What Rome had given to the Revolution in the fashion of classical +expressions was now more than repaid. The Directors were styled Consuls; +the divisions of the Legislature were known as the Senate and the +Tribunate; the Praetorship and the Quaestorship were recalled to life in the +Courts of Justice. That the new era might not want its classical memorial, +a medal was struck, with the image and superscription of Roman heroism, to +"Berthier, the restorer of the city," and to "Gaul, the salvation of the +human race." + +[Expedition to Egypt, May, 1798.] + +It was in the midst of these enterprises in Switzerland and Central Italy +that the Directory assembled the forces which Bonaparte was to lead to the +East. The port of Expedition to embarkation was Toulon; and there, on the +9th of May, 1798, Bonaparte took the command of the most formidable +armament that had ever left the French shores. Great Britain was still but +feebly represented in the Mediterranean, a detachment from St. Vincent's +fleet at Cadiz, placed under the command of Nelson, being the sole British +force in these waters. Heavy reinforcements were at hand; but in the +meantime Nelson had been driven by stress of weather from his watch upon +Toulon. On the 19th of May the French armament put out to sea, its +destination being still kept secret from the soldiers themselves. It +appeared before Malta on the 16th of June. By the treachery of the knights +Bonaparte was put in possession of this stronghold, which he could not even +have attempted to besiege. After a short delay the voyage was resumed, and +the fleet reached Alexandria without having fallen in with the English, who +had now received their reinforcements. The landing was safely effected, and +Alexandria fell at the first assault. After five days the army advanced +upon Cairo. At the foot of the Pyramids the Mameluke cavalry vainly threw +themselves upon Bonaparte's soldiers. They were repulsed with enormous loss +on their own side and scarcely any on that of the French. Their camp was +stormed; Cairo was occupied; and there no longer existed a force in Egypt +capable of offering any serious resistance to the invaders. + +[Battle of the Nile, Aug. 1.] + +But the fortune which had brought Bonaparte's army safe into the Egyptian +capital was destined to be purchased by the utter destruction of his fleet. +Nelson had passed the French in the night, when, after much perplexity, he +decided on sailing in the direction of Egypt. Arriving at Alexandria before +his prey, he had hurried off in an imaginary pursuit to Rhodes and Crete. +At length he received information which led him to visit Alexandria a +second time. He found the French fleet, numbering thirteen ships of the +line and four frigates, at anchor in Aboukir Bay. [65] His own fleet was +slightly inferior in men and guns, but he entered battle with a +presentiment of the completeness of his victory. Other naval battles have +been fought with larger forces; no destruction was ever so complete as that +of the Battle of the Nile (August 1). Two ships of the line and two +frigates, out of the seventeen sail that met Nelson, alone escaped from his +hands. Of eleven thousand officers and men, nine thousand were taken +prisoners, or perished in the engagement. The army of Bonaparte was cut off +from all hope of support or return; the Republic was deprived of +communication with its best troops and its greatest general. + +[Coalition of 1798.] + +A coalition was now gathering against France superior to that of 1793 in +the support of Russia and the Ottoman Empire, although Spain was now on the +side of the Republic, and Prussia, in spite of the warnings of the last two +years, refused to stir from its neutrality. The death of the Empress +Catherine, and the accession of Paul, had caused a most serious change in +the prospects of Europe. Hitherto the policy of the Russian Court had been +to embroil the Western Powers with one another, and to confine its efforts +against the French Republic to promises and assurances; with Paul, after an +interval of total reaction, the professions became realities. [66] No +monarch entered so cordially into Pitt's schemes for a renewal of the +European league; no ally had joined the English minister with a sincerity +so like his own. On the part of the Ottoman Government, the pretences of +friendship with which Bonaparte disguised the occupation of Egypt were +taken at their real worth. War was declared by the Porte; and a series of +negotiations, carried on during the autumn of 1798, united Russia, England, +Turkey, and Naples in engagements of mutual support against the French +Republic. + +[Nelson at Naples, Sept., 1798.] + +A Russian army set out on its long march towards the Adriatic: the levies +of Austria prepared for a campaign in the spring of 1799; but to the +English Government every moment that elapsed before actual hostilities was +so much time given to uncertainties; and the man who had won the Battle of +the Nile ridiculed the precaution which had hitherto suffered the French to +spread their intrigues through Italy, and closed the ports of Sicily and +Naples to his own most urgent needs. Towards the end of September, Nelson +appeared in the Bay of Naples, and was received with a delirium that +recalled the most effusive scenes in the French Revolution. [67] In the +city of Naples, as in the kingdom generally, the poorest classes were the +fiercest enemies of reform, and the steady allies of the Queen and the +priesthood against that section of the better-educated classes which had +begun to hope for liberty. The system of espionage and persecution with +which the sister of Marie Antoinette avenged upon her own subjects the +sufferings of her kindred had grown more oppressive with every new victory +of the Revolution. In the summer of 1798 there were men languishing for the +fifth year in prison, whose offences had never been investigated, and whose +relatives were not allowed to know whether they were dead or alive. A mode +of expression, a fashion of dress, the word of an informer, consigned +innocent persons to the dungeon, with the possibility of torture. In the +midst of this tyranny of suspicion, in the midst of a corruption which made +the naval and military forces of the kingdom worse than useless, King +Ferdinand and his satellites were unwearied in their theatrical invocations +of the Virgin and St. Januarius against the assailants of divine right and +the conquerors of Rome. A Court cowardly almost beyond the example of +Courts, a police that had trained every Neapolitan to look upon his +neighbour as a traitor, an administration that had turned one of the +hardiest races in Europe into soldiers of notorious and disgraceful +cowardice--such were the allies whom Nelson, ill-fitted for politics by his +sailor-like inexperience and facile vanity, heroic in his tenderness and +fidelity, in an evil hour encouraged to believe themselves invincible +because they possessed his own support. On the 14th of November, 1798, King +Ferdinand published a proclamation, which, without declaring war on the +French, announced that the King intended to occupy the Papal States and +restore the Papal government. The manifesto disclaimed all intention of +conquest, and offered a free pardon to all compromised persons. Ten days +later the Neapolitan army crossed the frontier, led by the Austrian +general, Mack, who passed among his admirers for the greatest soldier in +Europe. [68] + +[Ferdinand enters Rome, Nov. 29.] + +The mass of the French troops, about twelve thousand in number, lay in the +neighbourhood of Ancona; Rome and the intermediate stations were held by +small detachments. Had Mack pushed forward towards the Upper Tiber, his +inroad, even if it failed to crush the separated wings of the French army, +must have forced them to retreat; but, instead of moving with all his +strength through Central Italy, Mack led the bulk of his army upon Rome, +where there was no French force capable of making a stand, and sent weak +isolated columns towards the east of the peninsula, where the French were +strong enough to make a good defence. On the approach of the Neapolitans to +Rome, Championnet, the French commander, evacuated the city, leaving a +garrison in the Castle of St. Angelo, and fell back on Civita Castellana, +thirty miles north of the capital. The King of Naples entered Rome on the +29th November. The restoration of religion was celebrated by the erection +of an immense cross in the place of the tree of liberty, by the immersion +of several Jews in the Tiber, by the execution of a number of compromised +persons whose pardon the King had promised, and by a threat to shoot one of +the sick French soldiers in the hospital for every shot fired by the guns +of St. Angelo. [69] Intelligence was despatched to the exiled Pontiff of +the discomfiture of his enemies. "By help of the divine grace," wrote King +Ferdinand, "and of the most miraculous St. Januarius, we have to-day with +our army entered the sacred city of Rome, so lately profaned by the +impious, who now fly terror-stricken at the sight of the Cross and of my +arms. Leave then, your Holiness, your too modest abode, and on the wings of +cherubim, like the virgin of Loreto, come and descend upon the Vatican, to +purify it by your sacred presence." A letter to the King of Piedmont, who +had already been exhorted by Ferdinand to encourage his peasants to +assassinate French soldiers, informed him that "the Neapolitans, guided by +General Mack, had sounded the hour of death to the French, and proclaimed +to Europe, from the summit of the Capitol, that the time of the Kings had +come." + +[Mack defeated by Championnet, Dec. 6-13.] + +The despatches to Piedmont fell into the hands of the enemy, and the usual +modes of locomotion would scarcely have brought Pope Pius to Rome in time +to witness the exit of his deliverer. Ferdinand's rhapsodies were cut short +by the news that his columns advancing into the centre and east of the +Papal States had all been beaten or captured. Mack, at the head of the main +army, now advanced to avenge the defeat upon the French at Civita +Castellana and Terni. But his dispositions were as unskilful as ever: +wherever his troops encountered the enemy they were put to the rout; and, +as he had neglected to fortify or secure a single position upon his line of +march, his defeat by a handful of French soldiers on the north of Rome +involved the loss of the country almost up to the gates of Naples. On the +first rumour of Mack's reverses the Republican party at Rome declared for +France. King Ferdinand fled; Championnet re-entered Rome, and, after a few +days' delay, advanced into Neapolitan territory. Here, however, he found +himself attacked by an enemy more formidable than the army which had been +organised to expel the French from Italy. The Neapolitan peasantry, who, in +soldiers' uniform and under the orders of Mack, could scarcely be brought +within sight of the French, fought with courage when an appeal to their +religious passions collected them in brigand-like bands under leaders of +their own. Divisions of Championnet's army sustained severe losses; they +succeeded, however, in effecting their junction upon the Volturno; and the +stronghold of Gaeta, being defended by regular soldiers and not by +brigands, surrendered to the French at the first summons. + +[French enter Naples, Jan. 23, 1799.] + +Mack was now concentrating his troops in an entrenched camp before Capua. +The whole country was rising against the invaders; and, in spite of lost +battles and abandoned fortresses, the Neapolitan Government if it had +possessed a spark of courage, might still have overthrown the French army, +which numbered only 18,000 men. But the panic and suspicion which the +Government had fostered among its subjects were now avenged upon itself. +The cry of treachery was raised on every side. The Court dreaded a +Republican rising; the priests and the populace accused the Court of +conspiracy with the French; Mack protested that the soldiers were resolved +to be beaten; the soldiers swore that they were betrayed by Mack. On the +night of the 21st of December, the Royal Family secretly went on board +Nelson's ship the _Vanguard_, and after a short interval they set sail +for Palermo, leaving the capital in charge of Prince Pignatelli, a courtier +whom no one was willing to obey. [70] Order was, however, maintained by a +civic guard enrolled by the Municipality, until it became known that Mack +and Pignatelli had concluded an armistice with the French, and surrendered +Capua and the neighbouring towns. Then the populace broke into wild uproar. +The prisons were thrown open; and with the arms taken from the arsenal the +lazzaroni formed themselves into a tumultuous army, along with thousands of +desperate men let loose from the gaols and the galleys. The priests, +hearing that negotiations for peace were opened, raised the cry of treason +anew; and, with the watchword of the Queen, "All the gentlemen are +Jacobins; only the people are faithful," they hounded on the mob to riot +and murder. On the morning of January 15th hordes of lazzaroni issued from +the gates to throw themselves upon the French, who were now about nine +miles from the city; others dragged the guns down from the forts to defend +the streets. The Republican party, however, and that considerable body +among the upper class which was made Republican by the chaos into which the +Court, with its allies, the priests, and the populace, had thrown Naples, +kept up communication with Championnet, and looked forward to the entrance +of the French as the only means of averting destruction and massacre. By a +stratagem carried out on the night of the 20th they gained possession of +the fort of St. Elmo, while the French were already engaged in a bloody +assault upon the suburbs. On the 23rd Championnet ordered the attack to be +renewed. The conspirators within St. Elmo hoisted the French flag and +turned their guns upon the populace; the fortress of the Carmine was +stormed by the French; and, before the last struggle for life and death +commenced in the centre of the city, the leaders of the lazzaroni listened +to words of friendship which Championnet addressed to them in their own +language, and, with the incoherence of a half-savage race, escorted his +soldiers with cries of joy to the Church of St. Januarius, which +Championnet promised to respect and protect. + +[Parthenopean Republic.] + +Championnet used his victory with a discretion and forbearance rare amongst +French conquerors. He humoured the superstition of the populace; he +encouraged the political hopes of the enlightened. A vehement revulsion of +feeling against the fugitive Court and in favour of Republican government +followed the creation of a National Council by the French general, and his +ironical homage to the patron saint. The Kingdom of Naples was converted +into the Parthenopean Republic. New laws, new institutions, discussed in a +representative assembly, excited hopes and interests unknown in Naples +before. But the inevitable incidents of a French occupation, extortion and +impoverishment, with all their bitter effects on the mind of the people, +were not long delayed. In every country district the priests were exciting +insurrection. The agents of the new Government, men with no experience in +public affairs, carried confusion wherever they went. Civil war broke out +in fifty different places; and the barbarity of native leaders of +insurrection, like Fra Diavolo, was only too well requited by the French +columns which traversed the districts in revolt. + +[War with Austria and Russia, March, 1799.] + +The time was ill chosen by the French Government for an extension of the +area of combat to southern Italy. Already the first division of the Russian +army, led by Suvaroff, had reached Moravia, and the Court of Vienna was +only awaiting its own moment for declaring war. So far were the +newly-established Governments in Rome and Naples from being able to assist +the French upon the Adige, that the French had to send troops to Rome and +Naples to support the new Governments. The force which the French could +place upon the frontier was inferior to that which two years of preparation +had given to Austria: the Russians, who were expected to arrive in Lombardy +in April, approached with the confidence of men who had given to the French +none of their recent triumphs. Nor among the leaders was personal +superiority any longer markedly on the side of the French, as in the war of +the First Coalition. Suvaroff and the Archduke Charles were a fair match +for any of the Republican generals, except Bonaparte, who was absent in +Egypt. The executive of France had deeply declined. Carnot was in exile; +the work of organisation which he had pursued with such energy and +disinterestedness flagged under his mediocre and corrupt successors. +Skilful generals and brave soldiers were never wanting to the Republic; but +no single controlling will, no storm of national passion, inspired the +Government with the force which it had possessed under the Convention, and +which returned to it under Napoleon. + +A new character was given to the war now breaking out by the inclusion of +Switzerland in the area of combat. In the war of the First Coalition, +Switzerland had been neutral territory; but the events of 1798 had left the +French in possession of all Switzerland west of the Rhine, and an Austrian +force subsequently occupied the Grisons. The line separating the combatants +now ran without a break from Mainz to the Adriatic. The French armies were +in continuous communication with one another, and the movements of each +could be modified according to the requirements of the rest. On the other +hand, a disaster sustained at any one point of the line endangered every +other point; for no neutral territory intervened, as in 1796, to check a +lateral movement of the enemy, and to protect the communications of a +French army in Lombardy from a victorious Austrian force in southern +Germany. The importance of the Swiss passes in this relation was understood +and even overrated by the French Government; and an energy was thrown into +their mountain warfare which might have produced greater results upon the +plains. + +[The Archduke Charles defeats Jourdan at Stockach, March, 25.] + +Three armies formed the order of battle on either side. Jourdan held the +French command upon the Rhine; Massena in Switzerland; Scherer, the least +capable of the Republican generals, on the Adige. On the side of the +Allies, the Archduke Charles commanded in southern Germany; in Lombardy the +Austrians were led by Kray, pending the arrival of Suvaroff and his corps; +in Switzerland the command was given to Hotze, a Swiss officer who had +gained some distinction in foreign service. It was the design of the French +to push their centre under Massena through the mountains into the Tyrol, +and by a combined attack of the central and the southern army to destroy +the Austrians upon the upper Adige, while Jourdan, also in communication +with the centre, drove the Archduke down the Danube upon Vienna. Early in +March the campaign opened. Massena assailed the Austrian positions east of +the head-waters of the Rhine, and forced back the enemy into the heart of +the Orisons. Jourdan crossed the Rhine at Strasburg, and passed the Black +Forest with 40,000 men. His orders were to attack the Archduke Charles, +whatever the Archduke's superiority of force. The French and the Austrian +armies met at Stockach, near the head of the Lake of Constance (March 25). +Overwhelming numbers gave the Archduke a complete victory. Jourdan was not +only stopped in his advance, but forced to retreat beyond the Rhine. +Whatever might be the fortune of the armies of Switzerland and Italy, all +hope of an advance upon Vienna by the Danube was at an end. + +[Murder of the French envoys at Rastadt, April 28.] + +Freed from the invader's presence, the Austrians now spread themselves over +Baden, up to the gates of Rastadt, where, in spite of the war between +France and Austria, the envoys of the minor German States still continued +their conferences with the French agents. On the 28th of April the French +envoys, now three in number, were required by the Austrians to depart +within twenty-four hours. An escort, for which they applied, was refused. +Scarcely had their carriages passed through the city gates when they were +attacked by a squadron of Austrian hussars. Two of French envoys the French +envoys were murdered; the third left for dead. Whether this frightful +violation of international law was the mere outrage of a drunken soldiery, +as it was represented to be by the Austrian Government; whether it was to +any extent occasioned by superior civil orders, or connected with French +emigrants living in the neighbourhood, remains unknown. Investigations +begun by the Archduke Charles were stopped by the Cabinet, in order that a +more public inquiry might be held by the Diet. This inquiry, however, never +took place. In the year 1804 all papers relating to the Archduke's +investigation were removed by the Government from the military archives. +They have never since been discovered. [71] + +[Battle of Magnano, April 5.] + +The outburst of wrath with which the French people learnt the fate of their +envoys would have cost Austria dear if Austria had now been the losing +party in the war; but, for the present, everything seemed to turn against +the Republic. Jourdan had scarcely been overthrown in Germany before a +ruinous defeat at Magnano, on the Adige, drove back the army of Italy to +within a few miles of Milan; while Massena, deprived of the fruit of his +own victories by the disasters of his colleagues, had to abandon the +eastern half of Switzerland, and to retire upon the line of the river +Limnat, Lucerne, and the Gothard. Charles now moved from Germany into +Switzerland. Massena fixed his centre at Zuerich, and awaited the Archduke's +assault. For five weeks Charles remained inactive: at length, on the 4th of +June, he gave battle. After two days' struggle against greatly superior +forces, Massena was compelled to evacuate Zuerich. He retreated, however, no +farther than to the ridge of the Uetliberg, a few miles west of the city; +and here, fortifying his new position, he held obstinately on, while the +Austrians established themselves in the central passes of Switzerland, and +disaster after disaster seemed to be annihilating the French arms in Italy. + +[Suvaroff's Campaign in Lombardy, April-June.] + +Suvaroff, at the head of 17,000 Russians, had arrived in Lombardy in the +middle of April. His first battle was fought, and his first victory won, at +the passage of the Adda on the 25th of April. It was followed by the +surrender of Milan and the dissolution of the Cisalpine Republic. Moreau, +who now held the French command, fell back upon Alessandria, intending to +cover both Genoa and Turin; but a sudden movement of Suvaroff brought the +Russians into the Sardinian capital before it was even known to be in +jeopardy. The French general, cut off from the roads over the Alps, threw +himself upon the Apennines above Genoa, and waited for the army which had +occupied Naples, and which, under the command of Macdonald, was now +hurrying to his support, gathering with it on its march the troops that lay +scattered on the south of the Po. Macdonald moved swiftly through central +Italy, and crossed the Apennines above Pistoia in the beginning of June. +His arrival at Modena with 20,000 men threatened to turn the balance in +favour of the French. Suvaroff, aware of his danger, collected all the +troops within reach with the utmost despatch, and pushed eastwards to meet +Macdonald on the Trebbia. Moreau descended from the Apennines in the same +direction; but he had underrated the swiftness of the Russian general; and, +before he had advanced over half the distance, Macdonald was attacked by +Suvaroff on the Trebbia, and overthrown in three days of the most desperate +fighting that had been seen in the war (June 18). [72] + +[Naples.] + +All southern Italy now rose against the Governments established by the +French. Cardinal Ruffo, with a band of fanatical peasants, known as the +Army of the Faith, made himself master of Apulia and Calabria amid scenes +of savage cruelty, and appeared before Naples, where the lazzaroni were +ready to unite with the hordes of the Faithful in murder and pillage. +Confident of support within the city, and assisted by some English and +Russian vessels in the harbour, Ruffo attacked the suburbs of Naples on the +morning of the 13th of June. Massacre and outrage continued within and +without the city for five days. On the morning of the 19th, the Cardinal +proposed a suspension of arms. It was accepted by the Republicans, who were +in possession of the forts. Negotiations followed. On the 23rd conditions +of peace were signed by Ruffo on behalf of the King of Naples, and by the +representatives of Great Britain and of Russia in guarantee for their +faithful execution. It was agreed that the Republican garrison should march +out with the honours of war; that their persons and property should be +respected; that those who might prefer to leave the country should be +conveyed to Toulon on neutral vessels; and that all who remained at home +should be free from molestation. + +[Reign of Terror.] + +The garrison did not leave the forts that night. On the following morning, +while they were embarking on board the polaccas which were to take them to +Toulon, Nelson's fleet appeared in the Bay of Naples. Nelson declared that +in treating with rebels Cardinal Ruffo had disobeyed the King's orders, and +he pronounced the capitulation null and void. The polaccas, with the +Republicans crowded on board, were attached to the sterns of the English +ships, pending the arrival of King Ferdinand. On the 29th of June, Admiral +Caracciolo, who had taken office under the new Government, and on its fall +had attempted to escape in disguise, was brought a captive before Nelson. +Nelson ordered him to be tried by a Neapolitan court-martial, and, in spite +of his old age, his rank, and his long service to the State, caused him to +be hanged from a Neapolitan ship's yard-arm, and his body to be thrown into +the sea. Some days later, King Ferdinand arrived from Palermo, and Nelson +now handed over all his prisoners to the Bourbon authorities. A reign of +terror followed. Innumerable persons were thrown into prison. +Courts-martial, or commissions administering any law that pleased +themselves, sent the flower of the Neapolitan nation to the scaffold. Above +a hundred sentences of death were carried out in Naples itself: +confiscation, exile, and imprisonment struck down thousands of families. It +was peculiar to the Neapolitan proscriptions that a Government with the +names of religion and right incessantly upon its lips selected for +extermination both among men and women those who were most distinguished in +character, in science, and in letters, whilst it chose for promotion and +enrichment those who were known for deeds of savage violence. The part +borne by Nelson in this work of death has left a stain on his glory which +time cannot efface. [73] + +[Austrian designs in Italy.] + +[New plan of the War.] + +It was on the advance of the Army of Naples under Macdonald that the French +rested their last hope of recovering Lombardy. The battle of the Trebbia +scattered this hope to the winds, and left it only too doubtful whether +France could be saved from invasion. Suvaroff himself was eager to fall +upon Moreau before Macdonald could rally from his defeat, and to drive him +westwards along the coast-road into France. It was a moment when the +fortune of the Republic hung in the scales. Had Suvaroff been permitted to +follow his own counsels, France would probably have seen the remnant of her +Italian armies totally destroyed, and the Russians advancing upon Lyons or +Marseilles. The Republic was saved, as it had been in 1793, by the +dissensions of its enemies. It was not only for the purpose of resisting +French aggression that Austria had renewed the war, but for the purpose of +extending its own dominion in Italy. These designs were concealed from +Russia; they were partially made known by Thugut to the British Ambassador, +under the most stringent obligation to secrecy. On the 17th of August, +1799, Lord Minto acquainted his Government with the intentions of the +Austrian Court. "The Emperor proposes to retain Piedmont, and to take all +that part of Savoy which is important in a military view. I have no doubt +of his intention to keep Nice also, if he gets it, which will make the Var +his boundary with France. The whole territory of the Genoese Republic seems +to be an object of serious speculation ... The Papal Legations will, I am +persuaded, be retained by the Emperor ... I am not yet master of the +designs on Tuscany." [74] This was the sense in which Austria understood +the phrase of defending the rights of Europe against French aggression. It +was not, however, for this that the Czar had sent his army from beyond the +Carpathians. Since the opening of the campaign Suvaroff had been in +perpetual conflict with the military Council of Vienna. [75] Suvaroff was +bent upon a ceaseless pursuit of the enemy; the Austrian Council insisted +upon the reduction of fortresses. What at first appeared as a mere +difference of military opinion appeared in its true political character +when the allied troops entered Piedmont. The Czar desired with his whole +soul to crush the men of the Revolution, and to restore the governments +which France had overthrown. As soon as his troops entered Turin, Suvaroff +proclaimed the restoration of the House of Savoy, and summoned all +Sardinian officers to fight for their King. He was interrupted by a letter +from Vienna requiring him to leave political affairs in the hands of the +Viennese Ministry. [76] The Russians had already done as much in Italy as +the Austrian Cabinet desired them to do, and the first wish of Thugut was +now to free himself from his troublesome ally. Suvaroff raged against the +Austrian Government in every despatch, and tendered his resignation. His +complaints inclined the Czar to accept a new military scheme, which was +supported by the English Government in the hope of terminating the +contention between Suvaroff and the Austrian Council. It was agreed at St. +Petersburg that, as soon as the French armies were destroyed, the reduction +of the Italian fortresses should be left exclusively to the Austrians; and +that Suvaroff, uniting with a new Russian army now not far distant, should +complete the conquest of Switzerland, and then invade France by the Jura, +supported on his right by the Archduke Charles. An attack was to be made at +the same time upon Holland by a combined British and Russian force. + +If executed in its original form, this design would have thrown a +formidable army upon France at the side of Franche Comte, where it is least +protected by fortresses. But at the last moment an alteration in the plan +was made at Vienna. The prospect of an Anglo-Russian victory in Holland +again fixed the thoughts of the Austrian Minister upon Belgium, which had +been so lightly abandoned five years before, and which Thugut now hoped to +re-occupy and to barter for Bavaria or some other territory. "The Emperor," +he wrote, "cannot turn a deaf ear to the appeal of his subjects. He cannot +consent that the Netherlands shall be disposed of without his own +concurrence." [77] The effect of this perverse and mischievous resolution +was that the Archduke Charles received orders to send the greater part of +his army from Switzerland to the Lower Rhine, and to leave only 25,000 men +to support the new Russian division which, under General Korsakoff, was +approaching from the north to meet Suvaroff. The Archduke, as soon as the +new instructions reached him, was filled with the presentiment of disaster, +and warned his Government that in the general displacement of forces an +opportunity would be given to Massena, who was still above Zuerich, to +strike a fatal blow. Every despatch that passed between Vienna and St. +Petersburg now increased the Czar's suspicion of Austria. The Pope and the +King of Naples were convinced that Thugut had the same design upon their +own territories which had been shown in his treatment of Piedmont. [78] +They appealed to the Czar for protection. The Czar proposed a European +Congress, at which the Powers might learn one another's real intentions. +The proposal was not accepted by Austria; but, while disclaiming all desire +to despoil the King of Sardinia, the Pope, or the King of Naples, Thugut +admitted that Austria claimed an improvement of its Italian frontier, in +other words, the annexation of a portion of Piedmont, and of the northern +part of the Roman States. The Czar replied that he had taken up arms in +order to check one aggressive Government, and that he should not permit +another to take its place. + +[Battle of Novi, Aug. 15.] + +For the moment, however, the allied forces continued to co-operate in Italy +against the French army on the Apennines covering Genoa. This army had +received reinforcements, and was now placed under the command of Joubert, +one of the youngest and most spirited of the Republican generals. Joubert +determined to attack the Russians before the fall of Mantua should add the +besieging army to Suvaroff's forces in the field. But the information which +he received from Lombardy misled him. In the second week of August he was +still unaware that Mantua had fallen a fortnight before. He descended from +the mountains to attack Suvaroff at Tortona, with a force about equal to +Suvaroff's own. On reaching Novi he learnt that the army of Mantua was also +before him (Aug. 15). It was too late to retreat; Joubert could only give +to his men the example of Republican spirit and devotion. Suvaroff himself, +with Kray, the conqueror of Mantua, began the attack: the onset of a second +Austrian corps, at the moment when the strength of the Russians was +failing, decided the day. Joubert did not live to witness the close of a +defeat which cost France eleven thousand men. [79] + +[Suvaroff goes into Switzerland.] + +The allied Governments had so framed their plans that the most overwhelming +victory could produce no result. Instead of entering France, Suvaroff was +compelled to turn back into Switzerland, while the Austrians continued to +besiege the fortresses of Piedmont. In Switzerland Suvaroff had to meet an +enemy who was forewarned of his approach, and who had employed every +resource of military skill and daring to prevent the union of the two +Russian armies now advancing from the south and the north. Before Suvaroff +could leave Italy, a series of admirably-planned attacks had given Massena +the whole network of the central Alpine passes, and closed every avenue of +communication between Suvaroff and the army with which he hoped to +co-operate. The folly of the Austrian Cabinet seconded the French general's +exertions. No sooner had Korsakoff and the new Russian division reached +Schaffhausen than the Archduke Charles, forced by his orders from Vienna, +turned northwards (Sept. 3), leaving the Russians with no support but +Hotze's corps, which was scattered over six cantons. [80] Korsakoff +advanced to Zuerich; Massena remained in his old position on the Uetliberg. +It was now that Suvaroff began his march into the Alps, sorely harassed and +delayed by the want of the mountain-teams which the Austrians had promised +him, and filled with the apprehension that Korsakoff would suffer some +irreparable disaster before his own arrival. + +[Second Battle of Zuerich, Sept. 26.] + +Two roads lead from the Italian lakes to central Switzerland; one, starting +from the head of Lago Maggiore and crossing the Gothard, ends on the shore +of Lake Lucerne; the other, crossing the Spluegen, runs from the Lake of +Como to Reichenau, in the valley of the Rhine. The Gothard in 1799 was not +practicable for cannon; it was chosen by Suvaroff, however, for his own +advance, with the object of falling upon Massena's rear with the utmost +possible speed. He left Bellinzona on the 21st of September, fought his way +in a desperate fashion through the French outposts that guarded the defiles +of the Gothard, and arrived at Altorf near the Lake of Lucerne. Here it was +discovered that the westward road by which Suvaroff meant to strike upon +the enemy's communications had no existence. Abandoning this design, +Suvaroff made straight for the district where his colleague was encamped, +by a shepherd's path leading north-eastwards across heights of 7,000 feet +to the valley of the Muotta. Over this desolate region the Russians made +their way; and the resolution which brought them as far as the Muotta would +have brought them past every other obstacle to the spot where they were to +meet their countrymen. But the hour was past. While Suvaroff was still +struggling in the mountains, Massena advanced against Zuerich, put +Korsakoff's army to total rout, and drove it, with the loss of all its +baggage and of a great part of its artillery, outside the area of +hostilities. + +[Retreat of Suvaroff.] + +The first rumours of the catastrophe reached Suvaroff on the Muotta; he +still pushed on eastwards, and, though almost without ammunition, overthrew +a corps commanded by Massena in person, and cleared the road over the +Pragel at the point of the bayonet, arriving in Glarus on the 1st of +October. Here the full extent of Korsakoff's disaster was made known to +him. To advance or to fall back was ruin. It only remained for Suvaroff's +army to make its escape across a wild and snow-covered mountain-tract into +the valley of the Rhine, where the river flows below the northern heights +of the Grisons. This exploit crowned a campaign which filled Europe with +astonishment. The Alpine traveller of to-day turns with some distrust from +narratives which characterise with every epithet of horror and dismay +scenes which are the delight of our age; but the retreat of Suvaroff's +army, a starving, footsore multitude, over what was then an untrodden +wilderness of rock, and through fresh-fallen autumn snow two feet deep, had +little in common with the boldest feats of Alpine hardihood. [81] It was +achieved with loss and suffering; it brought the army from a position of +the utmost danger into one of security; but it was followed by no renewed +attack. Proposals for a combination between Suvaroff and the Archduke +Charles resulted only in mutual taunts and menaces. The co-operation of +Russia in the war was at an end. The French remained masters of the whole +of the Swiss territory that they had lost since the beginning of the +campaign. + +[British and Russian expedition against Holland Aug. 1799.] + +In the summer months of 1799 the Czar had relieved his irritation against +Austria by framing in concert with the British Cabinet the plan for a joint +expedition against Holland. It was agreed that 25,000 English and 17,000 +Russian troops, brought from the Baltic in British ships, should attack the +French in the Batavian Republic, and raise an insurrection on behalf of the +exiled Stadtholder. Throughout July the Kentish coast-towns were alive with +the bustle of war; and on the 13th of August the first English division, +numbering 12,000 men, set sail from Deal under the command of Sir Ralph +Abercromby. After tossing off the Dutch coast for a fortnight, the troops +landed at the promontory of the Helder. A Dutch corps was defeated on the +sand-hills, and the English captured the fort of the Helder, commanding the +Texel anchorage. Immediately afterwards a movement in favour of the +Stadtholder broke out among the officers of the Dutch fleet. The captains +hoisted the Orange flag, and brought their ships over to the English. + +This was the first and the last result of the expedition. The Russian +contingent and a second English division reached Holland in the middle of +September, and with them came the Duke of York, who now took the command +out of the hands of Abercromby. On the other side reinforcements daily +arrived from France, until the enemy's troops, led by General Brune, were +equal in strength to the invaders. A battle fought at Alkmaar on the 19th +of September gave the Allies some partial successes and no permanent +advantage; and on the 3rd of October the Duke of York gained one of those +so-called victories which result in the retreat of the conquerors. Never +were there so many good reasons for a bad conclusion. The Russians moved +too fast or too slow; the ditches set at nought the rules of strategy; it +was discovered that the climate of Holland was unfavourable to health, and +that the Dutch had not the slightest inclination to get back their +Stadtholder. The result of a series of mischances, every one of which would +have been foreseen by an average midshipman in Nelson's fleet, or an +average sergeant in Massena's army, was that York had to purchase a retreat +for the allied forces at a price equivalent to an unconditional surrender. +He was allowed to re-embark on consideration that Great Britain restored to +the French 8,000 French and Dutch prisoners, and handed over in perfect +repair all the military works which our own soldiers had erected at the +Helder. Bitter complaints were raised among the Russian officers against +York's conduct of the expedition. He was accused of sacrificing the Russian +regiments in battle, and of courting a general defeat in order not to +expose his own men. The accusation was groundless. Where York was, +treachery or bad faith was superfluous. York in command, the feeblest enemy +became invincible. Incompetence among the hereditary chiefs of the English +army had become part of the order of nature. The Ministry, when taxed with +failure, obstinately shut their eyes to the true cause of the disaster. +Parliament was reminded that defeat was the most probable conclusion of any +military operations that we might undertake, and that England ought not to +expect success when Prussia and Austria had so long met only with +misfortune. Under the command of Nelson, English sailors were indeed +manifesting that kind of superiority to the seamen of other nations which +the hunter possesses over his prey; yet this gave no reason why foresight +and daring should count for anything ashore. If the nation wished to see +its soldiers undefeated, it must keep them at home to defend their country. +Even among the Opposition no voice was raised to protest against the system +which sacrificed English life and military honour to the dignity of the +Royal Family. The collapse of the Anglo-Russian expedition was viewed with +more equanimity in England than in Russia. The Czar dismissed his +unfortunate generals. York returned home, to run horses at Newmarket, to +job commissions with his mistress, and to earn his column at St. James's +Park. + +[Unpopularity of the Directory.] + +[Plans of Sieyes 1799.] + +It was at this moment, when the tide of military success was already +turning in favour of the Republic, that the revolution took place which +made Bonaparte absolute ruler of France. Since the attack of the Government +upon the Royalists in Fructidor, 1797, the Directory and the factions had +come no nearer to a system of mutual concession, or to a peaceful +acquiescence in the will of a parliamentary majority. The Directory, +assailed both by the extreme Jacobins and by the Constitutionalists, was +still strong enough to crush each party in its turn. The elections of 1798, +which strengthened the Jacobins, were annulled with as little scruple as +the Royalist elections in the preceding year; it was only when defeat in +Germany and Italy had brought the Government into universal discredit that +the Constitutionalist party, fortified by the return of a large majority in +the elections of 1799, dared to turn the attack upon the Directors +themselves. The excitement of foreign conquest had hitherto shielded the +abuses of Government from criticism; but when Italy was lost, when generals +and soldiers found themselves without pay, without clothes, without +reinforcements, one general outcry arose against the Directory, and the +nation resolved to have done with a Government whose outrages and +extortions had led to nothing but military ruin. The disasters of France in +the spring of 1799, which resulted from the failure of the Government to +raise the armies to their proper strength, were not in reality connected +with the defects of the Constitution. They were caused in part by the +shameless jobbery of individual members of the Administration, in part by +the absence of any agency, like that of the Conventional Commissioners of +1793, to enforce the control of the central Government over the local +authorities, left isolated and independent by the changes of 1789. Faults +enough belonged, however, to the existing political order; and the +Constitutionalists, who now for the second time found themselves with a +majority in the Councils, were not disposed to prolong a system which from +the first had turned their majorities into derision. A party grew up around +the Abbe Sieyes intent upon some change which should give France a +government really representing its best elements. What the change was to be +few could say; but it was known that Sieyes, who had taken a leading part +in 1789, and had condemned the Constitution of 1795 from the moment when it +was sketched, had elaborated a scheme which he considered exempt from every +error that had vitiated its predecessors. As the first step to reform, +Sieyes himself was elected to a Directorship then falling vacant. Barras +attached himself to Sieyes; the three remaining Directors, who were +Jacobins and popular in Paris, were forced to surrender their seats. Sieyes +now only needed a soldier to carry out his plans. His first thought had +turned on Joubert, but Joubert was killed at Novi. Moreau scrupled to raise +his hand against the law; Bernadotte, a general distinguished both in war +and in administration, declined to play a secondary part. Nor in fact was +the support of Sieyes indispensable to any popular and ambitious soldier +who was prepared to attack the Government. Sieyes and his friends offered +the alliance of a party weighty in character and antecedents; but there +were other well-known names and powerful interests at the command of an +enterprising leader, and all France awaited the downfall of a Government +whose action had resulted only in disorder at home and defeat abroad. + +[Bonaparte returns from Egypt, Oct., 1799.] + +Such was the political situation when, in the summer of 1799, Bonaparte, +baffled in an attack upon the Syrian fortress of St. Jean d'Acre, returned +to Egypt, and received the first tidings from Europe which had reached him +since the outbreak of the war. He saw that his opportunity had arrived. He +determined to leave his army, whose ultimate failure was inevitable, and to +offer to France in his own person that sovereignty of genius and strength +for which the whole nation was longing. On the 7th of October a despatch +from Bonaparte was read in the Council of Five Hundred, announcing a +victory over the Turks at Aboukir. It brought the first news that had been +received for many months from the army of Egypt; it excited an outburst of +joyous enthusiasm for the general and the army whom a hated Government was +believed to have sent into exile; it recalled that succession of victories +which had been unchecked by a single defeat, and that Peace which had given +France a dominion wider than any that her Kings had won. While every +thought was turned upon Bonaparte, the French nation suddenly heard that +Bonaparte himself had landed on the coast of Provence. "I was sitting that +day," says Beranger in his autobiography, "in our reading-room with thirty +or forty other persons. Suddenly the news was brought in that Bonaparte had +returned from Egypt. At the words, every man in the room started to his +feet and burst into one long shout of joy." The emotion portrayed by +Beranger was that of the whole of France. Almost everything that now +darkens the early fame of Bonaparte was then unknown. His falsities, his +cold, unpitying heart were familiar only to accomplices and distant +sufferers; even his most flagrant wrongs, such as the destruction of +Venice, were excused by a political necessity, or disguised as acts of +righteous chastisement. The hopes, the imagination of France saw in +Bonaparte the young, unsullied, irresistible hero of the Republic. His fame +had risen throughout a crisis which had destroyed all confidence in others. +The stale placemen of the factions sank into insignificance by his side; +even sincere Republicans, who feared the rule of a soldier, confessed that +it is not always given to a nation to choose the mode of its own +deliverance. From the moment that Bonaparte landed at Frejus, he was master +of France. + +[Conspiracy of Sieyes and Bonaparte.] + +Sieyes saw that Bonaparte, and no one else, was the man through whom he +could overthrow the existing Constitution. [82] So little sympathy existed, +however, between Sieyes and the soldier to whom he now offered his support, +that Bonaparte only accepted Sieyes' project after satisfying himself that +neither Barras nor Bernadotte would help him to supreme power. Once +convinced of this, Bonaparte closed with Sieyes' offers. It was agreed that +Sieyes and his friend Ducos should resign their Directorships, and that the +three remaining Directors should be driven from office. The Assemblies, or +any part of them favourable to the plot, were to appoint a Triumvirate +composed of Bonaparte, Sieyes, and Ducos, for the purpose of drawing up a +new Constitution. In the new Constitution it was understood, though without +any definite arrangement, that Bonaparte and Sieyes were to be the leading +figures. The Council of Ancients was in great part in league with the +conspirators: the only obstacle likely to hinder the success of the plot +was a rising of the Parisian populace. As a precaution against attack, it +was determined to transfer the meeting of the Councils to St. Cloud. +Bonaparte had secured the support of almost all the generals and troops in +Paris. His brother Lucien, now President of the Council of Five Hundred, +hoped to paralyse the action of his own Assembly, in which the conspirators +were in the minority. + +[Coup d'etat, 18 Brumaire (Nov. 9), 1799.] + +Early on the morning of the 9th of November (18 Brumaire), a crowd of +generals and officers met before Bonaparte's house. At the same moment a +portion of the Council of Ancients assembled, and passed a decree which +adjourned the session to St. Cloud, and conferred on Bonaparte the command +over all the troops in Paris. The decree was carried to Bonaparte's house +and read to the military throng, who acknowledged it by brandishing their +swords. Bonaparte then ordered the troops to their posts, received the +resignation of Barras, and arrested the two remaining Directors in the +Luxembourg. During the night there was great agitation in Paris. The arrest +of the two Directors and the display of military force revealed the true +nature of the conspiracy, and excited men to resistance who had hitherto +seen no great cause for alarm. The Councils met at St. Cloud at two on the +next day. The Ancients were ready for what was coming; the Five Hundred +refused to listen to Bonaparte's accomplices, and took the oath of fidelity +to the Constitution. Bonaparte himself entered the Council of Ancients, and +in violent, confused language declared that he had come to save the +Republic from unseen dangers. He then left the Assembly, and entered the +Chamber of the Five Hundred, escorted by armed grenadiers. A roar of +indignation greeted the appearance of the bayonets. The members rushed in a +mass upon Bonaparte, and drove him out of the hall. His brother now left +the President's chair and joined the soldiers outside, whom he harangued in +the character of President of the Assembly. The soldiers, hitherto +wavering, were assured by Lucien's civil authority and his treacherous +eloquence. The drums beat; the word of command was given; and the last free +representatives of France struggled through doorways and windows before the +levelled and advancing bayonets. + +[Sieyes' plan of Constitution.] + +The Constitution which Sieyes hoped now to impose upon France had been +elaborated by its author at the close of the Reign of Terror. Designed at +that epoch, it bore the trace of all those apprehensions which gave shape +to the Constitution of 1795. The statutory outrages of 1793, the Royalist +reaction shown in the events of Vendemiaire, were the perils from which +both Sieyes and the legislators of 1795 endeavoured to guard the future of +France. It had become clear that a popular election might at any moment +return a royalist majority to the Assembly: the Constitution of 1795 +averted this danger by prolonging the power of the Conventionalists; Sieyes +overcame it by extinguishing popular election altogether. He gave to the +nation no right but that of selecting half a million persons who should be +eligible to offices in the Communes, and who should themselves elect a +smaller body of fifty thousand, eligible to offices in the Departments. The +fifty thousand were in their turn to choose five thousand, who should be +eligible to places in the Government and the Legislature. The actual +appointments were to be made, however, not by the electors, but by the +Executive. With the irrational multitude thus deprived of the power to +bring back its old oppressors, priests, royalists, and nobles might safely +do their worst. By way of still further precaution, Sieyes proposed that +every Frenchman who had been elected to the Legislature since 1789 should +be inscribed for ten years among the privileged five thousand. + +Such were the safeguards provided against a Bourbonist reaction. To guard +against a recurrence of those evils which France had suffered from the +precipitate votes of a single Assembly, Sieyes broke up the legislature +into as many chambers as there are stages in the passing of a law. The +first chamber, or Council of State, was to give shape to measures suggested +by the Executive; a second chamber, known as the Tribunate, was to discuss +the measures so framed, and ascertain the objections to which they were +liable; the third chamber, known as the Legislative Body, was to decide in +silence for or against the measures, after hearing an argument between +representatives of the Council and of the Tribunate. As a last impregnable +bulwark against Jacobins and Bourbonists alike, Sieyes created a Senate +whose members should hold office for life, and be empowered to annul every +law in which the Chambers might infringe upon the Constitution. + +It only remained to invent an Executive. In the other parts of his +Constitution, Sieyes had borrowed from Rome, from Greece, and from Venice; +in his Executive he improved upon the political theories of Great Britain. +He proposed that the Government should consist of two Consuls and a Great +Elector; the Elector, like an English king, appointing and dismissing the +Consuls, but taking no active part in the administration himself. The +Consuls were to be respectively restricted to the affairs of peace and of +war. Grotesque under every aspect, the Constitution of Sieyes was really +calculated to effect in all points but one the end which he had in view. +His object was to terminate the convulsions of France by depriving every +element in the State of the power to create sudden change. The members of +his body politic, a Council that could only draft, a Tribunate that could +only discuss, a Legislature that could only vote, Yes or No, were impotent +for mischief; and the nation itself ceased to have a political existence as +soon as it had selected its half-million notables. + +[Sieyes and Bonaparte.] + +So far, nothing could have better suited the views of Bonaparte; and up to +this point Bonaparte quietly accepted Sieyes' plan. But the general had his +own scheme for what was to follow. Sieyes might apportion the act of +deliberation among debating societies and dumb juries to the full extent of +his own ingenuity; but the moment that he applied his disintegrating method +to the Executive, Bonaparte swept away the flimsy reasoner, and set in the +midst of his edifice of shadows the reality of an absolute personal rule. +The phantom Elector, and the Consuls who were to be the Elector's +tenants-at-will, corresponded very little to the power which France desired +to see at its head. "Was there ever anything so ridiculous?" cried +Bonaparte. "What man of spirit could accept such a post?" It was in vain +that Sieyes had so nicely set the balance. His theories gave to France only +the pageants which disguised the extinction of the nation beneath a single +will: the frame of executive government which the country received in 1799 +was that which Bonaparte deduced from the conception of an absolute central +power. The First Consul summed up all executive authority in his own +person. By his side there were set two colleagues whose only function was +to advise. A Council of State placed the highest skill and experience in +France at the disposal of the chief magistrate, without infringing upon his +sovereignty. All offices, both in the Ministries of State and in the +provinces, were filled by the nominees of the First Consul. No law could be +proposed but at his desire. + +[Contrast of the Institutions of 1791 and 1799.] + +[Centralisation of 1799.] + +The institutions given to France by the National Assembly of 1789 and those +given to it in the Consulate exhibited a direct contrast seldom found +outside the region of abstract terms. Local customs, survivals of earlier +law, such as soften the difference between England and the various +democracies of the United States, had no place in the sharp-cut types in +which the political order of France was recast in 1791 and 1799. The +Constituent Assembly had cleared the field before it began to reconstruct. +Its reconstruction was based upon the Rights of Man, identified with the +principle of local self-government by popular election. It deduced a system +of communal administration so completely independent that France was +described by foreign critics as partitioned into 40,000 republics; and the +criticism was justified when, in 1793, it was found necessary to create a +new central Government, and to send commissioners from the capital into the +provinces. In the Constitution of 1791, judges, bishops, officers of the +National Guard, were all alike subjected to popular election; the Minister +of War could scarcely move a regiment from one village to another without +the leave of the mayor of the commune. In the Constitution of 1799 all +authority was derived from the head of the State. A system of +centralisation came into force with which France under her kings had +nothing to compare. All that had once served as a check upon monarchical +power, the legal Parliaments, the Provincial Estates of Brittany and +Languedoc, the rights of lay and ecclesiastical corporations, had vanished +away. In the place of the motley of privileges that had tempered the +Bourbon monarchy, in the place of the popular Assemblies of the Revolution, +there sprang up a series of magistracies as regular and as absolute as the +orders of military rank. [83] Where, under the Constitution of 1791, a body +of local representatives had met to conduct the business of the Department, +there was now a Prefet, appointed by the First Consul, absolute, like the +First Consul himself, and assisted only by the advice of a nominated +council, which met for one fortnight in the year. In subordination to the +Prefet, an officer and similar council transacted the local business of the +Arrondissement. Even the 40,000 Maires with their communal councils were +all appointed directly or indirectly by the Chief of the State. There +existed in France no authority that could repair a village bridge, or light +the streets of a town, but such as owed its appointment to the central +Government. Nor was the power of the First Consul limited to the +administration. With the exception of the lowest and the highest members of +the judicature, he nominated all judges, and transferred them at his +pleasure to inferior or superior posts. + +Such was the system which, based to a great extent upon the preferences of +the French people, fixed even more deeply in the national character the +willingness to depend upon an omnipresent, all-directing power. Through its +rational order, its regularity, its command of the highest science and +experience, this system of government could not fail to confer great and +rapid benefits upon the country. It has usually been viewed by the French +themselves as one of the finest creations of political wisdom. In +comparison with the self-government which then and long afterwards existed +in England, the centralisation of France had all the superiority of +progress and intelligence over torpor and self-contradiction. Yet a heavy, +an incalculable price is paid by every nation which for the sake of +administrative efficiency abandons its local liberties, and all that is +bound up with their enjoyment. No practice in the exercise of public right +armed a later generation of Frenchmen against the audacity of a common +usurper: no immortality of youth secured the institutions framed by +Napoleon against the weakness and corruption which at some period undermine +all despotisms. The historian who has exhausted every term of praise upon +the political system of the Consulate lived to declare, as Chief of the +State himself, that the first need of France was the decentralisation of +power. [84] + +[State policy of Bonaparte.] + +After ten years of disquiet, it was impossible that any Government could be +more welcome to the French nation than one which proclaimed itself the +representative, not of party or of opinion, but of France itself. No +section of the nation had won a triumph in the establishment of the +Consulate; no section had suffered a defeat. In his own elevation Bonaparte +announced the close of civil conflict. A Government had arisen which +summoned all to its service which would employ all, reward all, reconcile +all. The earliest measures of the First Consul exhibited the policy of +reconciliation by which he hoped to rally the whole of France to his side. +The law of hostages, under which hundreds of families were confined in +retaliation for local Royalist disturbances, was repealed, and Bonaparte +himself went to announce their liberty to the prisoners in the Temple. +Great numbers of names were struck off the list of the emigrants, and the +road to pardon was subsequently opened to all who had not actually served +against their country. In the selection of his officers of State, Bonaparte +showed the same desire to win men of all parties. Cambaceres, a regicide, +was made Second Consul; Lebrun, an old official of Louis XVI., became his +colleague. In the Ministries, in the Senate, and in the Council of State +the nation saw men of proved ability chosen from all callings in life and +from all political ranks. No Government of France had counted among its +members so many names eminent for capacity and experience. One quality +alone was indispensable, a readiness to serve and to obey. In that +intellectual greatness which made the combination of all the forces of +France a familiar thought in Bonaparte's mind, there was none of the moral +generosity which could pardon opposition to himself, or tolerate energy +acting under other auspices than his own. He desired to see authority in +the best hands; he sought talent and promoted it, but on the understanding +that it took its direction from himself. Outside this limit ability was his +enemy, not his friend; and what could not be caressed or promoted was +treated with tyrannical injustice. While Bonaparte boasted of the career +that he had thrown open to talent, he suppressed the whole of the +independent journalism of Paris, and banished Mme. de Stael, whose guests +continued to converse, when they might not write, about liberty. Equally +partial, equally calculated, was Bonaparte's indulgence towards the ancient +enemies of the Revolution, the Royalists and the priests. He felt nothing +of the old hatred of Paris towards the Vendean noble and the superstitious +Breton; he offered his friendship to the stubborn Breton race, whose +loyalty and piety he appreciated as good qualities in subjects; but failing +their submission, he instructed his generals in the west of France to burn +down their villages, and to set a price upon the heads of their chiefs. +Justice, tolerance, good faith, were things which had no being for +Bonaparte outside the circle of his instruments and allies. + +[France ceases to excite democracy abroad, but promotes equality under +monarchical systems.] + +[Effect of Bonaparte's autocracy outside France.] + +In the foreign relations of France it was not possible for the most +unscrupulous will to carry aggression farther than it had been already +carried; yet the elevation of Bonaparte deeply affected the fortunes of all +those States whose lot depended upon France. It was not only that a mind +accustomed to regard all human things as objects for its own disposal now +directed an irresistible military force, but from the day when France +submitted to Bonaparte, the political changes accompanying the advance of +the French armies took a different character. Belgium and Holland, the +Rhine Provinces, the Cisalpine, the Roman, and the Parthenopean Republics, +had all received, under whatever circumstances of wrong, at least the forms +of popular sovereignty. The reality of power may have belonged to French +generals and commissioners; but, however insincerely uttered, the call to +freedom excited hopes and aspirations which were not insincere themselves. +The Italian festivals of emancipation, the trees of liberty, the rhetoric +of patriotic assemblies, had betrayed little enough of the instinct for +self-government; but they marked a separation from the past; and the period +between the years 1796 and 1799 was in fact the birth-time of those hopes +which have since been realised in the freedom and the unity of Italy. So +long as France had her own tumultuous assemblies, her elections in the +village and in the county-town, it was impossible for her to form republics +beyond the Alps without introducing at least some germ of republican +organisation and spirit. But when all power was concentrated in a single +man, when the spoken and the written word became an offence against the +State, when the commotion of the old municipalities was succeeded by the +silence and the discipline of a body of clerks working round their chief, +then the advance of French influence ceased to mean the support of popular +forces against the Governments. The form which Bonaparte had given to +France was the form which he intended for the clients of France. Hence in +those communities which directly received the impress of the Consulate, as +in Bavaria and the minor German States, authority, instead of being +overthrown, was greatly strengthened. Bonaparte carried beyond the Rhine +that portion of the spirit of the Revolution which he accepted at home, the +suppression of privilege, the extinction of feudal rights, the reduction of +all ranks to equality before the law, and the admission of all to the +public service. But this levelling of the social order in the client-states +of France, and the establishment of system and unity in the place of +obsolete privilege, cleared the way not for the supremacy of the people, +but for the supremacy of the Crown. The power which was taken away from +corporations, from knights, and from ecclesiastics, was given, not to a +popular Representative, but to Cabinet Ministers and officials ranged after +the model of the official hierarchy of France. What the French had in the +first epoch of their Revolution endeavoured to impart to Europe--the spirit +of liberty and self-government--they had now renounced themselves. The +belief in popular right, which made the difference between the changes of +1789 and those attempted by the Emperor Joseph, sank in the storms of the +Revolution. + +[Bonaparte legislates in the spirit of the reforming monarchs of the 18th +century.] + +Yet the statesmanship of Bonaparte, if it repelled the liberal and +disinterested sentiment of 1789, was no mere cunning of a Corsican soldier, +or exploit of mediaeval genius born outside its age. Subject to the fullest +gratification of his own most despotic or most malignant impulse, Bonaparte +carried into his creations the ideas upon which the greatest European +innovators before the French Revolution had based their work. What +Frederick and Joseph had accomplished, or failed to accomplish, was +realised in Western Germany when its Sovereigns became the clients of the +First Consul. Bonaparte was no child of the French Revolution; he was the +last and the greatest of the autocratic legislators who worked in an unfree +age. Under his rule France lost what had seemed to be most its own; it most +powerfully advanced the forms of progress common to itself and the rest of +Europe. Bonaparte raised no population to liberty: in extinguishing +privilege and abolishing the legal distinctions of birth, in levelling all +personal and corporate authority beneath the single rule of the State, he +prepared the way for a rational freedom, when, at a later day, the +Government of the State should itself become the representative of the +nation's will. + + + + +CHAPTER V. + + +Overtures of Bonaparte to Austria and England--The War continues--Massena +besieged in Genoa--Moreau invades Southern Germany--Bonaparte crosses the +St. Bernard, and descends in the rear of the Austrians--Battle of +Marengo--Austrians retire behind the Mincio--Treaty between England and +Austria--Austria continues the War--Battle of Hohenlinden--Peace of +Luneville--War between England and the Northern Maritime League--Battle of +Copenhagen--Murder of Paul--End of the Maritime War--English Army enters +Egypt--French defeated at Alexandria--They capitulate at Cairo and +Alexandria--Preliminaries of Peace between England and France signed at +London, followed by Peace of Amiens--Pitt's Irish Policy and his +retirement--Debates on the Peace--Aggressions of Bonaparte during the +Continental Peace--Holland, Italy, Switzerland--Settlement of Germany under +French and Russian influence--Suppression of Ecclesiastical States and Free +Cities--Its effects--Stein--France under the Consulate--The Civil Code--The +Concordat. + + +[Overtures of Bonaparte to Austria and to England, 1799.] + +The establishment of the Consulate gave France peace from the strife of +parties. Peace from foreign warfare was not less desired by the nation; and +although the First Consul himself was restlessly planning the next +campaign, it belonged to his policy to represent himself as the mediator +between France and Europe. Discarding the usual diplomatic forms, Bonaparte +addressed letters in his own name to the Emperor Francis and to King George +III., deploring the miseries inflicted by war upon nations naturally +allied, and declaring his personal anxiety to enter upon negotiations for +peace. The reply of Austria which was courteously worded, produced an offer +on the part of Bonaparte to treat for peace upon the basis of the Treaty of +Campo Formio. Such a proposal was the best evidence of Bonaparte's real +intentions. Austria had re-conquered Lombardy, and driven the armies of the +Republic from the Adige to within a few miles of Nice. To propose a peace +which should merely restore the situation existing at the beginning of the +war was pure irony. The Austrian Government accordingly declared itself +unable to treat without the concurrence of its allies. The answer of +England to the overtures of the First Consul was rough and defiant. It +recounted the causes of war and distrust which precluded England from +negotiating with a revolutionary Government; and, though not insisting on +the restoration of the Bourbons as a condition of peace, it stated that no +guarantee for the sincerity and good behaviour of France would be so +acceptable to Great Britain as the recall of the ancient family. [85] + +Few State papers have been distinguished by worse faults of judgment than +this English manifesto. It was intended to recommend the Bourbons to France +as a means of procuring peace: it enabled Bonaparte to represent England as +violently interfering with the rights of the French people, and the +Bourbons as seeking their restoration at the hand of the enemy of their +country. The answer made to Pitt's Government from Paris was such as one +high-spirited nation which had recently expelled its rulers might address +to another that had expelled its rulers a century before. France, it was +said, had as good a right to dismiss an incapable dynasty as Great Britain. +If Talleyrand's reply failed to convince King George that before restoring +the Bourbons he ought to surrender his own throne to the Stuarts, it +succeeded in transferring attention from the wrongs inflicted by France to +the pretensions advanced by England. That it affected the actual course of +events there is no reason to believe. The French Government was well +acquainted with the real grounds of war possessed by England, in spite of +the errors by which the British Cabinet weakened the statement of its +cause. What the mass of the French people now thought, or did not think, +had become a matter of very little importance. + +[Situation of the Armies.] + +[Moreau invades South Germany, April, 1800.] + +The war continued. Winter and the early spring of 1800 passed in France +amidst vigorous but concealed preparations for the campaign which was to +drive the Austrians from Italy. In Piedmont the Austrians spent months in +inaction, which might have given them Genoa and completed the conquest of +Italy before Bonaparte's army could take the field. It was not until the +beginning of April that Melas, their general, assailed the French positions +on the Genoese Apennines; a fortnight more was spent in mountain warfare +before Massena, who now held the French command, found himself shut up in +Genoa and blockaded by land and sea. The army which Bonaparte was about to +lead into Italy lay in between Dijon and Geneva, awaiting the arrival of +the First Consul. On the Rhine, from Strasburg to Schaffhausen, a force of +100,000 men was ready to cross into Germany under the command of Moreau, +who was charged with the task of pushing the Austrians back from the Upper +Danube, and so rendering any attack through Switzerland upon the +communications of Bonaparte's Italian force impossible. Moreau's army was +the first to move. An Austrian force, not inferior to Moreau's own, lay +within the bend of the Rhine that covers Baden and Wuertemberg. Moreau +crossed the Rhine at various points, and by a succession of ingenious +manoeuvres led his adversary, Kray, to occupy all the roads through the +Black Forest except those by which the northern divisions of the French +were actually passing. A series of engagements, conspicuous for the skill +of the French general and the courage of the defeated Austrians, gave +Moreau possession of the country south of the Danube as far as Ulm, where +Kray took refuge in his entrenched camp. Beyond this point Moreau's +instructions forbade him to advance. His task was fulfilled by the +severance of the Austrian army from the roads into Italy. + +[Bonaparte crosses the Alps, May, 1800.] + +Bonaparte's own army was now in motion. Its destination was still secret; +its very existence was doubted by the Austrian generals. On the 8th of May +the First Consul himself arrived at Geneva, and assumed the command. The +campaign upon which this army was now entering was designed by Bonaparte to +surpass everything that Europe had hitherto seen most striking in war. The +feats of Massena and Suvaroff in the Alps had filled his imagination with +mountain warfare. A victory over nature more imposing than theirs might, in +the present position of the Austrian forces in Lombardy, be made the +prelude to a victory in the field without a parallel in its effects upon +the enemy. Instead of relieving Genoa by an advance along the coast-road, +Bonaparte intended to march across the Alps and to descend in the rear of +the Austrians. A single defeat would then cut the Austrians off from their +communications with Mantua, and result either in the capitulation of their +army or in the evacuation of the whole of the country that they had won, +Bonaparte led his army into the mountains. The pass of the Great St. +Bernard, though not a carriage-road, offered little difficulty to a +commander supplied with every resource of engineering material and skill; +and by this road the army crossed the Alps. The cannons were taken from +their carriages and dragged up the mountain in hollowed trees; thousands of +mules transported the ammunition and supplies; workshops for repairs were +established on either slope of the mountain; and in the Monastery of St. +Bernard there were stores collected sufficient to feed the soldiers as they +reached the summit during six successive days (May 15-20). The passage of +the St. Bernard was a triumph of organisation, foresight, and good +management; as a military exploit it involved none of the danger, none of +the suffering, none of the hazard, which gave such interest to the campaign +of Massena and Suvaroff. + +[Bonaparte cuts off the Austrian army from Eastern Lombardy.] + +Bonaparte had rightly calculated upon the unreadiness of his enemy. The +advanced guard of the French army poured down the valley of the Dora-Baltea +upon the scanty Austrian detachments at Ivrea and Chiusella, before Melas, +who had in vain been warned of the departure of the French from Geneva, +arrived with a few thousand men at Turin to dispute the entrance into +Italy. Melas himself, on the opening of the campaign, had followed a French +division to Nice, leaving General Ott in charge of the army investing +Genoa. On reaching Turin he discovered the full extent of his peril, and +sent orders to Ott to raise the siege of Genoa and to join him with every +regiment that he could collect. Ott, however, was unwilling to abandon the +prey at this moment falling into his grasp. He remained stationary till the +5th of June, when Massena, reduced to the most cruel extremities by famine, +was forced to surrender Genoa to the besiegers. But his obstinate endurance +had the full effect of a battle won. Ott's delay rendered Melas powerless +to hinder the movements of Bonaparte, when, instead of marching upon Genoa, +as both French and Austrians expected him to do, he turned eastward, and +thrust his army between the Austrians and their own fortresses. Bonaparte +himself entered Milan (June 2); Lannes and Murat were sent to seize the +bridges over the Po and the Adda. The Austrian detachment guarding Piacenza +was overpowered; the communications of Melas with the country north of the +Powere completely severed. Nothing remained for the Austrian commander but +to break through the French or to make his escape to Genoa. + +[Battle of Marengo, June 14, 1800.] + +[Conditions of Armistice.] + +The French centre was now at Stradella, half-way between Piacenza and +Alessandria. Melas was at length joined by Ott at Alessandria, but so +scattered were the Austrian forces, that out of 80,000 men Melas had not +more than 33,000 at his command. Bonaparte's forces were equal in number; +his only fear was that Melas might use his last line of retreat, and escape +to Genoa without an engagement. The Austrian general, however, who had +shared with Suvaroff the triumph over Joubert at Novi, resolved to stake +everything upon a pitched battle. He awaited Bonaparte's approach at +Alessandria. On the 12th of June Bonaparte advanced westward from +Stradella. His anxiety lest Melas might be escaping from his hands +increased with every hour of the march that brought him no tidings of the +enemy; and on the 13th, when his advanced guard had come almost up to the +walls of Alessandria without seeing an enemy, he could bear the suspense no +longer, and ordered Desaix to march southward towards Novi and hold the +road to Genoa. Desaix led off his division. Early the next morning the +whole army of Melas issued from Alessandria, and threw itself upon the +weakened line of the French at Marengo. The attack carried everything +before it: at the end of seven hours' fighting, Melas, exhausted by his +personal exertions, returned into Alessandria, and sent out tidings of a +complete victory. It was at this moment that Desaix, who had turned at the +sound of the cannon, appeared on the field, and declared that, although one +battle had been lost, another might be won. A sudden cavalry-charge struck +panic into the Austrians, who believed the battle ended and the foe +overthrown. Whole brigades threw down their arms and fled; and ere the day +closed a mass of fugitives, cavalry and infantry, thronging over the +marshes of the Bormida, was all that remained of the victorious Austrian +centre. The suddenness of the disaster, the desperate position of the army, +cut off from its communications, overthrew the mind of Melas, and he agreed +to an armistice more fatal than an unconditional surrender. The Austrians +retired behind the Mincio, and abandoned to the French every fortress in +Northern Italy that lay west of that river. A single battle had produced +the result of a campaign of victories and sieges. Marengo was the most +brilliant in conception of all Bonaparte's triumphs. If in its execution +the genius of the great commander had for a moment failed him, no mention +of the long hours of peril and confusion was allowed to obscure the +splendour of Bonaparte's victory. Every document was altered or suppressed +which contained a report of the real facts of the battle. The descriptions +given to the French nation claimed only new homage to the First Consul's +invincible genius and power. [86] + +[Austria continues the war.] + +At Vienna the military situation was viewed more calmly than in Melas' +camp. The conditions of the armistice were generally condemned, and any +sudden change in the policy of Austria was prevented by a treaty with +England, binding Austria, in return for British subsidies, and for a secret +promise of part of Piedmont, to make no separate peace with France before +the end of February, 1801. This treaty was signed a few hours before the +arrival of the news of Marengo. It was the work of Thugut, who still +maintained his influence over the Emperor, in spite of growing unpopularity +and almost universal opposition. Public opinion, however, forced the +Emperor at least to take steps for ascertaining the French terms of peace. +An envoy was sent to Paris; and, as there could be no peace without the +consent of England, conferences were held with the object of establishing a +naval armistice between England and France. England, however, refused the +concessions demanded by the First Consul; and the negotiations were broken +off in September. But this interval of three months had weakened the +authority of the Minister and stimulated the intrigues which at every great +crisis paralysed the action of Austria. At length, while Thugut was +receiving the subsidies of Great Britain and arranging for the most +vigorous prosecution of the war, the Emperor, concealing the transaction +from his Minister, purchased a new armistice by the surrender of the +fortresses of Ulm and Ingolstadt to Moreau's army. [87] + +[Battle of Hohenlinden, Dec. 3, 1800.] + +A letter written by Thugut after a council held on the 25th of September +gives some indication of the stormy scene which then passed in the +Emperor's presence. Thugut tendered his resignation, which was accepted; +and Lehrbach, the author of the new armistice, was placed in office. But +the reproaches of the British ambassador forced the weak Emperor to rescind +this appointment on the day after it had been published to the world. There +was no one in Vienna capable of filling the vacant post; and after a short +interval the old Minister resumed the duties of his office, without, +however, openly resuming the title. The remainder of the armistice was +employed in strengthening the force opposed to Moreau, who now received +orders to advance upon Vienna. The Archduke John, a royal strategist of +eighteen, was furnished with a plan for surrounding the French army and +cutting it off from its communications. Moreau lay upon the Isar; the +Austrians held the line of the Inn. On the termination of the armistice the +Austrians advanced and made some devious marches in pursuance of the +Archduke's enterprise, until a general confusion, attributed to the +weather, caused them to abandon their manoeuvres and move straight against +the enemy. On the 3rd of December the Austrians plunged into the +snow-blocked roads of the Forest of Hohenlinden, believing that they had +nothing near them but the rear-guard of a retiring French division. Moreau +waited until they had reached the heart of the forest, and then fell upon +them with his whole force in front, in flank, and in the rear. The defeat +of the Austrians was overwhelming. What remained of the war was rather a +chase than a struggle. Moreau successively crossed the Inn, the Salza, and +the Traun; and on December 25th the Emperor, seeing that no effort of Pitt +could keep Moreau out of Vienna, accepted an armistice at Steyer, and +agreed to treat for peace without reference to Great Britain. + +[Peace of Luneville, Feb. 9, 1801.] + +Defeats on the Mincio, announced during the following days, increased the +necessity for peace. Thugut was finally removed from power. Some resistance +was offered to the conditions proposed by Bonaparte, but these were +directed more to the establishment of French influence in Germany than to +the humiliation of the House of Hapsburg. Little was taken from Austria but +what she had surrendered at Campo Formio. It was not by the cession of +Italian or Slavonic provinces that the Government of Vienna paid for +Marengo and Hohenlinden, but at the cost of that divided German race whose +misfortune it was to have for its head a sovereign whose interests in the +Empire and in Germany were among the least of all his interests. The Peace +of Luneville, [88] concluded between France and the Emperor on the 9th of +February, 1801, without even a reference to the Diet of the Empire, placed +the minor States of Germany at the mercy of the French Republic. It left to +the House of Hapsburg the Venetian territory which it had gained in 1797; +it required no reduction of the Hapsburg influence in Italy beyond the +abdication of the Grand Duke of Tuscany; but it ceded to France, without +the disguises of 1797, the German provinces west of the Rhine, and it +formally bound the Empire to compensate the dispossessed lay Sovereigns in +such a manner as should be approved by France. The French Republic was thus +made arbiter, as a matter of right, in the rearrangement of the maimed and +shattered Empire. Even the Grand Duke of Tuscany, like his predecessor in +ejection, the Duke of Modena, was to receive some portion of the German +race for his subjects, in compensation for the Italians taken from him. To +such a pass had political disunion brought a nation which at that time +could show the greatest names in Europe in letters, in science, and in art. + +[Peace with Naples.] + +[Russia turns against England.] + +[Northern Maritime League, Dec., 1800.] + +Austria having succumbed, the Court of Naples, which had been the first of +the Allies to declare war, was left at the mercy of Bonaparte. Its +cruelties and tyranny called for severe punishment; but the intercession of +the Czar kept the Bourbons upon the throne, and Naples received peace upon +no harder condition than the exclusion of English vessels from its ports. +England was now left alone in its struggle with the French Republic. Nor +was it any longer to be a struggle only against France and its +dependencies. The rigour with which the English Government had used its +superiority at sea, combined with the folly which it had shown in the +Anglo-Russian attack upon Holland, raised against it a Maritime League +under the leadership of a Power which England had offended as a neutral and +exasperated as an ally. Since the pitiful Dutch campaign, the Czar had +transferred to Great Britain the hatred which he had hitherto borne to +France. The occasion was skilfully used by Bonaparte, to whom, as a +soldier, the Czar felt less repugnance than to the Government of advocates +and contractors which he had attacked in 1799. The First Consul restored +without ransom several thousands of Russian prisoners, for whom the +Austrians and the English had refused to give up Frenchmen in exchange, and +followed up this advance by proposing that the guardianship of Malta, which +was now blockaded by the English, should be given to the Czar. Paul had +caused himself to be made Grand Master of the Maltese Order of St. John of +Jerusalem. His vanity was touched by Bonaparte's proposal, and a friendly +relation was established between the French and Russian Governments. +England, on the other hand, refused to place Malta under Russian +guardianship, either before or after its surrender. This completed the +breach between the Courts of London and St. Petersburg. The Czar seized all +the English vessels in his ports and imprisoned their crews (Sept. 9). A +difference of long standing existed between England and the Northern +Maritime Powers, which was capable at any moment of being made a cause of +war. The rights exercised over neutral vessels by English ships in time of +hostilities, though good in international law, were so oppressive that, at +the time of the American rebellion, the Northern Powers had formed a +league, known as the Armed Neutrality, for the purpose of resisting by +force the interference of the English with neutral merchantmen upon the +high seas. Since the outbreak of war with France, English vessels had again +pushed the rights of belligerents to extremes. The Armed Neutrality of 1780 +was accordingly revived under the auspices of the Czar. The League was +signed on the 16th of December, 1800, by Russia, Sweden, and Denmark. Some +days later Prussia gave in its adhesion. [89] + +[Points at issue.] + +The points at issue between Great Britain and the Neutrals were such as +arise between a great naval Power intent upon ruining its adversary and +that larger part of the world which remains at peace and desires to carry +on its trade with as little obstruction as possible. It was admitted on all +sides that a belligerent may search a neutral vessel in order to ascertain +that it is not conveying contraband of war, and that a neutral vessel, +attempting to enter a blockaded port, renders itself liable to forfeiture; +but beyond these two points everything was in dispute. A Danish ship +conveys a cargo of wine from a Bordeaux merchant to his agent in New York. +Is the wine liable to be seized in the mid-Atlantic by an English cruiser, +to the destruction of the Danish carrying-trade, or is the Danish flag to +protect French property from a Power whose naval superiority makes capture +upon the high seas its principal means of offence? England announces that a +French port is in a state of blockade. Is a Swedish vessel, stopped while +making for the port in question, to be considered a lawful prize, when, if +it had reached the port, it would as a matter of fact have found no real +blockade in existence? A Russian cargo of hemp, pitch, and timber is +intercepted by an English vessel on its way to an open port in France. Is +the staple produce of the Russian Empire to lose its market as contraband +of war? Or is an English man-of-war to allow material to pass into France, +without which the repair of French vessels of war would be impossible? + +[War between England and the Northern Maritime Powers, Jan., 1801.] + +These were the questions raised as often as a firm of shipowners in a +neutral country saw their vessel come back into port cleared of its cargo, +or heard that it was lying in the Thames awaiting the judgment of the +Admiralty Court. Great Britain claimed the right to seize all French +property, in whatever vessel it might be sailing, and to confiscate, as +contraband of war, not only muskets, gunpowder, and cannon, but wheat, on +which the provisioning of armies depended, and hemp, pitch, iron, and +timber, out of which the navies of her adversary were formed. The Neutrals, +on the other hand, demanded that a neutral flag should give safe passage to +all goods on board, not being contraband of war; that the presence of a +vessel of State as convoy should exempt merchantmen from search; that no +port should be considered in a state of blockade unless a competent +blockading force was actually in front of it; and that contraband of war +should include no other stores than those directly available for battle. +Considerations of reason and equity may be urged in support of every +possible theory of the rights of belligerents and neutrals; but the theory +of every nation has, as a matter of fact, been that which at the time +accorded with its own interests. When a long era of peace had familiarised +Great Britain with the idea that in the future struggles of Europe it was +more likely to be a spectator than a belligerent, Great Britain accepted +the Neutrals' theory of international law at the Congress of Paris in 1856; +but in 1801, when the lot of England seemed to be eternal warfare, any +limitation of the rights of a belligerent appeared to every English jurist +to contradict the first principles of reason. Better to add a general +maritime war to the existing difficulties of the country than to abandon +the exercise of its naval superiority in crippling the commerce of an +adversary. The Declaration of armed Neutrality, announcing the intention of +the Allied Powers to resist the seizure of French goods on board their own +merchantmen, was treated in this country as a declaration of war. The +Government laid an embargo upon all vessels of the allied neutrals lying in +English ports (Jan. 14th, 1801), and issued a swarm of privateers against +the trading ships making for the Baltic. Negotiations failed to lower the +demands of either side, and England prepared to deal with the navies of +Russia, Denmark, Sweden, and Prussia. + +[Battle of Copenhagen, April 2, 1801.] + +At the moment, the concentrated naval strength of England made it more than +a match for its adversaries. A fleet of seventeen ships of the line sailed +from Yarmouth on the 12th of March, under the command of Parker and Nelson, +with orders to coerce the Danes and to prevent the junction of the +confederate navies. The fleet reached the Sound. The Swedish batteries +commanding the Sound failed to open fire. Nelson kept to the eastern side +of the channel, and brought his ships safely past the storm of shot poured +upon them from the Danish guns at Elsinore. He appeared before Copenhagen +at mid-day on the 30th of March. Preparations for resistance were made by +the Danes with extraordinary spirit and resolution. The whole population of +Copenhagen volunteered for service on the ships, the forts, and the +floating batteries. Two days were spent by the English in exploring the +shallows of the channel; on the morning of the 2nd of April Nelson led his +ships into action in front of the harbour. Three ran aground; the Danish +fire from land and sea was so violent that after some hours Admiral Parker, +who watched the engagement from the mid-channel, gave the signal of recall. +Nelson laughed at the signal, and continued the battle. In another hour the +six Danish men-of-war and the whole of the floating batteries were disabled +or sunk. The English themselves had suffered most severely from a +resistance more skilful and more determined than anything that they had +experienced from the French, and Nelson gladly offered a truce as soon as +his own victory was assured. The truce was followed by negotiation, and the +negotiation by an armistice for fourteen weeks, a term which Nelson +considered sufficient to enable him to visit and to overthrow the navies of +Sweden and Russia. + +[Murder of Paul, March 23.] + +[Peace between England and the Northern Powers.] + +But an event had already occurred more momentous in its bearing upon the +Northern Confederacy than the battle of Copenhagen itself. On the night of +the 23rd of March the Czar of Russia was assassinated in his palace. Paul's +tyrannical violence, and his caprice verging upon insanity, had exhausted +the patience of a court acquainted with no mode of remonstrance but +homicide. Blood-stained hands brought to the Grand Duke Alexander the crown +which he had consented to receive after a pacific abdication. Alexander +immediately reversed the policy of his father, and sent friendly +communications both to the Government at London and to the commander of the +British fleet in the Baltic. The maintenance of commerce with England was +in fact more important to Russia than the protection of its carrying trade. +Nelson's attack was averted. A compromise was made between the two +Governments, which saved Russia's interests, without depriving England of +its chief rights against France. The principles of the Armed Neutrality +were abandoned by the Government of St. Petersburg in so far as they +related to the protection of an enemy's goods by the neutral flag. Great +Britain continued to seize French merchandise on board whatever craft it +might be found; but it was stipulated that the presence of a ship of war +should exempt neutral vessels from search by privateers, and that no port +should be considered as in a state of blockade unless a reasonable +blockading force was actually in front of it. The articles condemned as +contraband were so limited as not to include the flax, hemp, and timber, on +whose export the commerce of Russia depended. With these concessions the +Czar was easily brought to declare Russia again neutral. The minor Powers +of the Baltic followed the example of St. Petersburg; and the naval +confederacy which had threatened to turn the balance in the conflict +between England and the French Republic left its only trace in the +undeserved suffering of Denmark. + +[Affairs in Egypt.] + +Eight years of warfare had left France unassailable in Western Europe, and +England in command of every sea. No Continental armies could any longer be +raised by British subsidies: the navies of the Baltic, with which Bonaparte +had hoped to meet England on the seas, lay at peace in their ports. Egypt +was now the only arena remaining where French and English combatants could +meet, and the dissolution of the Northern Confederacy had determined the +fate of Egypt by leaving England in undisputed command of the approach to +Egypt by sea. The French army, vainly expecting reinforcements, and +attacked by the Turks from the east, was caught in a trap. Soon after the +departure of Bonaparte from Alexandria, his successor, General Kleber, had +addressed a report to the Directory, describing the miserable condition of +the force which Bonaparte had chosen to abandon. The report was intercepted +by the English, and the Government immediately determined to accept no +capitulation which did not surrender the whole of the French army as +prisoners of war. An order to this effect was sent to the Mediterranean. +Before, however, the order reached Sir Sidney Smith, the English admiral +cooperating with the Turks, an agreement had been already signed by him at +El Arish, granting Kleber's army a free return to France (Feb. 24, 1800). +After Kleber, in fulfilment of the conditions of the treaty, had withdrawn +his troops from certain positions, Sir Sidney Smith found himself compelled +to inform the French General that in the negotiations of El Arish he had +exceeded his powers, and that the British Government insisted upon the +surrender of the French forces. Kleber replied by instantly giving battle +to the Turks at Heliopolis, and putting to the rout an army six times as +numerous as his own. The position of the French seemed to be growing +stronger in Egypt, and the prospect of a Turkish re-conquest more doubtful, +when the dagger of a fanatic robbed the French of their able chief, and +transferred the command to General Menou, one of the very few French +officers of marked incapacity who held command at any time during the war. +The British Government, as soon as it learnt what had taken place between +Kleber and Sir Sidney Smith, declared itself willing to be bound by the +convention of El Arish. The offer was, however, rejected by the French. It +was clear that the Turks could never end the war by themselves; and the +British Ministry at last came to understand that Egypt must be re-conquered +by English arms. + +[English army lands in Egypt, March, 1801.] + +[French capitulate at Cairo, June 27, 1801.] + +[And at Alexandria, Aug. 30.] + +On the 8th of March, 1801, a corps of 17,000 men, led by Sir Ralph +Abercromby, landed at Aboukir Bay. According to the plan of the British +Government, Abercromby's attack was to be supported by a Turkish corps from +Syria, and by an Anglo-Indian division brought from Ceylon to Kosseir, on +the Red Sea. The Turks and the Indian troops were, however, behind their +time, and Abercromby opened the campaign alone. Menou had still 27,000 +troops at his disposal. Had he moved up with the whole of his army from +Cairo, he might have destroyed the English immediately after their landing. +Instead of doing so, he allowed weak isolated detachments of the French to +sink before superior numbers. The English had already gained confidence of +victory when Menou advanced in some force in order to give battle in front +of Alexandria. The decisive engagement took place on the 21st of March. The +French were completely defeated. Menou, however, still refused to +concentrate his forces; and in the course of a few weeks 13,000 French +troops which had been left behind at Cairo were cut off from communication +with the rest of the army. A series of attempts made by Admiral Ganteaume +to land reinforcements from France ended fruitlessly. Towards the end of +June the arrival of a Turkish force enabled the English to surround the +French in Cairo. The circuit of the works was too large to be successfully +defended; on the other hand, the English were without the heavy artillery +necessary for a siege. Under these circumstances the terms which had +originally been offered at El Arish were again proposed to General Belliard +for himself and the army of Cairo. They were accepted, and Cairo was +surrendered to the English on condition that the garrison should be +conveyed back to France (June 27). Soon after the capitulation General +Baird reached Lower Egypt with an Anglo-Indian division. Menou with the +remainder of the French army was now shut up in Alexandria. His forts and +outworks were successively carried; his flotilla was destroyed; and when +all hope of support from France had been abandoned, the army of Alexandria, +which formed the remnant of the troops with which Bonaparte had won his +earliest victories in Italy, found itself compelled to surrender the last +stronghold of the French in Egypt (Aug. 30). It was the first important +success which had been gained by English soldiers over the troops of the +Republic; the first campaign in which English generalship had permitted the +army to show itself in its true quality. + +[Negotiations for peace.] + +[Preliminaries of London, Oct. 1, 1801.] + +[Peace of Amiens, March 27, 1802.] + +Peace was now at hand. Soon after the Treaty of Luneville had withdrawn +Austria from the war, unofficial negotiations had begun between the +Governments of Great Britain and France. The object with which Pitt had +entered upon the war, the maintenance of the old European system against +the aggression of France, was now seen to be one which England must +abandon. England had borne its share in the defence of the Continent. If +the Continental Powers could no longer resist the ascendancy of a single +State, England could not struggle for the Balance of Power alone. The +negotiations of 1801 had little in common with those of 1796. Belgium, +which had been the burden of all Pitt's earlier despatches, no longer +figured as an object of contention. The frontier of the Rhine, with the +virtual possession of Holland and Northern Italy, under the title of the +Batavian, Ligurian, and Cisalpine Republics, was tacitly conceded to +France. In place of the restoration of the Netherlands, the negotiators of +1801 argued about the disposal of Egypt, of Malta, and of the colonies +which Great Britain had conquered from France and its allies. Events +decided the fate of Egypt. The restoration of Malta to the Knights of St. +John was strenuously demanded by France, and not refused by England. It was +in relation to the colonial claims of France that the two Governments found +it most difficult to agree. Great Britain, which had lost no territory +itself, had conquered nearly all the Asiatic and Atlantic colonies of the +French Republic and of its Dutch and Spanish allies. In return for the +restoration of Ceylon, the Cape of Good Hope, Guiana, Trinidad, and various +East and West Indian settlements, France had nothing to offer to Great +Britain but peace. If peace, however, was to be made, the only possible +settlement was by means of a compromise; and it was finally agreed that +England should retain Ceylon and Trinidad, and restore the rest of the +colonies which it had taken from France, Spain, and Holland. Preliminaries +of peace embodying these conditions were signed at London on the 1st of +October, 1801. Hostilities ceased; but an interval of several months +between the preliminary agreement and the conclusion of the final treaty +was employed by Bonaparte in new usurpations upon the Continent, to which +he forced the British Government to lend a kind of sanction in the +continuance of the negotiations. The Government, though discontented, was +unwilling to treat these acts as new occasions of war. The conferences were +at length brought to a close, and the definitive treaty between France and +Great Britain was signed at Amiens on the 27th of March, 1802. [90] + +[Pitt's retirement. Its cause.] + +[Union of Ireland and Great Britain, 1800.] + +The Minister who, since the first outbreak of war, had so resolutely +struggled for the freedom of Europe, was no longer in power when Great +Britain entered into negotiations with the First Consul. In the same week +that Austria signed the Peace of Luneville, Pitt had retired from office. +The catastrophe which dissolved his last Continental alliance may possibly +have disposed Pitt to make way for men who could treat for peace with a +better grace than himself, but the immediate cause of his retirement was an +affair of internal policy. Among the few important domestic measures which +Pitt had not sacrificed to foreign warfare was a project for the +Legislative Union of Great Britain and Ireland. Ireland had up to this time +possessed a Parliament nominally independent of that of Great Britain. Its +population, however, was too much divided to create a really national +government; and, even if the internal conditions of the country had been +better, the practical sovereignty of Great Britain must at that time have +prevented the Parliament of Dublin from being more than an agency of +ministerial corruption. It was the desire of Pitt to give to Ireland, in +the place of a fictitious independence, that real participation in the +political life of Great Britain which has more than recompensed Scotland +and Wales for the loss of separate nationality. As an earnest of +legislative justice, Pitt gave hopes to the leaders of the Irish Catholic +party that the disabilities which excluded Roman Catholics from the House +of Commons and from many offices in the public service would be no longer +maintained. On this understanding the Catholics of Ireland abstained from +offering to Pitt's project a resistance which would probably have led to +its failure. A majority of members in the Protestant Parliament of Dublin +accepted the price which the Ministry offered for their votes. A series of +resolutions in favour of the Legislative Union of the two countries was +transmitted to England in the spring of 1800; the English Parliament passed +the Act of Union in the same summer; and the first United Parliament of +Great Britain and Ireland assembled in London at the beginning of the year +1801. + +[Pitt desires to emancipate the Catholics.] + +[Pitt resigns Feb. 1801.] + +[Addington Minister.] + +Pitt now prepared to fulfil his virtual promise to the Irish Catholics. A +measure obliterating the ancient lines of civil and religious enmity, and +calling to public life a class hitherto treated as alien and hostile to the +State, would have been in true consonance with all that was best in Pitt's +own statesmanship. But the ignorant bigotry of King George III. was excited +against him by men who hated every act of justice or tolerance to Roman +Catholics; and it proved of greater force than the genius of the Minister. +The old threat of the King's personal enmity was publicly addressed to +Pitt's colleague, Dundas, when the proposal for Catholic emancipation was +under discussion in the Cabinet; and, with a just regard for his own +dignity, Pitt withdrew from office (Feb. 5, 1801), unable to influence a +Sovereign who believed his soul to be staked on the letter of the +Coronation Oath. The ablest members of Pitt's government, Grenville, +Dundas, and Windham, retired with their leader. Addington, Speaker of the +House of Commons, became Prime Minister, with colleagues as undistinguished +as himself. It was under the government of Addington that the negotiations +were begun which resulted in the signature of Preliminaries of Peace in +October 1801. + +[The Peace of 1801.] + +Pitt himself supported the new Ministry in their policy of peace; +Grenville, lately Pitt's Foreign Minister, unsparingly condemned both the +cession of the conquered colonies and the policy of granting France peace +on any terms whatever. Viewed by the light of our own knowledge of events, +the Peace of 1801 appears no more than an unprofitable break in an +inevitable war; and perhaps even then the signs of Bonaparte's ambition +justified those who, like Grenville, urged the nation to give no truce to +France, and to trust to Bonaparte's own injustice to raise us up allies +upon the Continent. But, for the moment, peace seemed at least worth a +trial. The modes of prosecuting a war of offence were exhausted; the cost +of the national defence remained the same. There were no more navies to +destroy, no more colonies to seize; the sole means of injuring the enemy +was by blockading his ports, and depriving him of his maritime commerce. On +the other hand, the possibility of a French invasion required the +maintenance of an enormous army and militia in England, and prevented any +great reduction in the expenses of the war, which had already added two +hundred millions to the National Debt. Nothing was lost by making peace, +except certain colonies and military positions which few were anxious to +retain. The argument that England could at any moment recover what she now +surrendered was indeed a far sounder one than most of those which went to +prove that the positions in question were of no real service. Yet even on +the latter point there was no want of high authority. It was Nelson himself +who assured the House of Lords that neither Malta nor the Cape of Good Hope +could ever be of importance to Great Britain. [91] In the face of such +testimony, the men who lamented that England should allow the adversary to +recover any lost ground in the midst of a struggle for life or death, +passed for obstinate fanatics. The Legislature reflected the general +feeling of the nation; and the policy of the Government was confirmed in +the Lords and the Commons by majorities of ten to one. + +[Aggressions of Bonaparte during the Continental peace.] + +[Holland, Sept., 1801.] + +Although the Ministry of Addington had acted with energy both in Egypt and +in the Baltic, it was generally felt that Pitt's retirement marked the +surrender of that resolute policy which had guided England since 1793. When +once the Preliminaries of Peace had been signed in London, Bonaparte +rightly judged that Addington would waive many just causes of complaint, +rather than break off the negotiations which were to convert the +Preliminaries into a definitive treaty. Accordingly, in his instructions to +Joseph Bonaparte, who represented France at the conferences held at Amiens, +the First Consul wrote, through Talleyrand, as follows:--"You are forbidden +to entertain any proposition relating to the King of Sardinia, or to the +Stadtholder, or to the internal affairs of Batavia, of Helvetia, or the +Republic of Italy. None of these subjects have anything to do with the +discussions of England." The list of subjects excluded from the +consideration of England was the list of aggressions by which Bonaparte +intended to fill up the interval of Continental peace. In the Treaty of +Luneville, the independence of the newly-established republics in Holland, +Switzerland, and Italy had been recognised by France. The restoration of +Piedmont to the House of Savoy had been the condition on which the Czar +made peace. But on every one of these points the engagements of France were +made only to be broken. So far from bringing independence to the +client-republics of France, the peace of Luneville was but the introduction +to a series of changes which brought these States directly into the hands +of the First Consul. The establishment of absolute government in France +itself entailed a corresponding change in each of its dependencies, and the +creation of an executive which should accept the First Consul's orders with +as little question as the Prefect of a French department. Holland received +its new constitution while France was still at war with England. The +existing Government and Legislature of the Batavian Republic were dissolved +(Sept., 1801), and replaced by a council of twelve persons, each holding +the office of President in turn for a period of three months, and by a +legislature of thirty-five, which met only for a few days in the year. The +power given to the new President during his office was enough, and not more +than enough, to make him an effective servant: a three-months' Minister and +an Assembly that met and parted at the word of command were not likely to +enter into serious rivalry with the First Consul. The Dutch peaceably +accepted the constitution thus forced upon them; they possessed no means of +resistance, and their affairs excited but little interest upon the +Continent. + +[Bonaparte made President of the Italian Republic, Jan., 1802.] + +[Piedmont annexed to France, Sept., 1802.] + +Far more striking was the revolution next effected by the First Consul. In +obedience to orders sent from Paris to the Legislature of the Cisalpine +Republic, a body of four hundred and fifty Italian representatives crossed +the Alps in the middle of winter in order to meet the First Consul at +Lyons, and to deliberate upon a constitution for the Cisalpine Republic. +The constitution had, as a matter of fact, been drawn up by Talleyrand, and +sent to the Legislature at Milan some months before. But it was not for the +sake of Italy that its representatives were collected at Lyons, in the +presence of the First Consul, with every circumstance of national +solemnity. It was the most striking homage which Bonaparte could exact from +a foreign race in the face of all France; it was the testimony that other +lands besides France desired Bonaparte to be their sovereign. When all the +minor offices in the new Cisalpine Constitution had been filled, the +Italians learnt that the real object of the convocation was to place the +sceptre in Bonaparte's hands. They accepted the part which they found +themselves forced to play, and offered to the First Consul the presidency +of the Cisalpine State (Jan. 25, 1802). Unlike the French Consulate, the +chief magistracy in the new Cisalpine Constitution might be prolonged +beyond the term of ten years. Bonaparte had practically won the Crown of +Lombardy; and he had given to France the example of a submission more +unqualified than its own. A single phrase rewarded the people who had thus +placed themselves in his hands. The Cisalpine Republic was allowed to +assume the name of Italian Republic. The new title indicated the national +hopes which had sprung up in Italy during the past ten years; it indicated +no real desire on the part of Bonaparte to form either a free or a united +Italian nation. In the Cisalpine State itself, although a good +administration and the extinction of feudal privileges made Bonaparte's +government acceptable, patriots who asked for freedom ran the risk of exile +or imprisonment. What further influence was exercised by France upon +Italian soil was not employed for the consolidation of Italy. Tuscany was +bestowed by Bonaparte upon the Spanish Prince of Parma, and controlled by +agents of the First Consul. Piedmont, which had long been governed by +French generals, was at length definitely annexed to France. + +[Intervention in Switzerland.] + +[Bonaparte Mediator of the Helvetic League, Oct. 4, 1802.] + +Switzerland had not, like the Cisalpine Republic, derived its liberty from +the victories of French armies, nor could Bonaparte claim the presidency of +the Helvetic State under the title of its founder. The struggles of the +Swiss parties, however, placed the country at the mercy of France. Since +the expulsion of the Austrians by Massena in 1799, the antagonism between +the Democrats of the town and the Federalists of the Forest Cantons had +broken out afresh. A French army still occupied Switzerland; the Minister +of the First Consul received instructions to interfere with all parties and +consolidate none. In the autumn of 1801, the Federalists were permitted to +dissolve the central Helvetic Government, which had been created by the +Directory in 1798. One change followed another, until, on the 19th of May, +1802, a second Constitution was proclaimed, based, like that of 1798, on +centralising and democratic principles, and almost extinguishing the old +local independence of the members of the Swiss League. No sooner had French +partisans created this Constitution, which could only be maintained by +force against the hostility of Berne and the Forest Cantons, than the +French army quitted Switzerland. Civil war instantly broke out, and in the +course of a few weeks the Government established by the French had lost all +Switzerland except the Pays de Vaud. This was the crisis for which +Bonaparte had been waiting. On the 4th of October a proclamation appeared +at Lausanne, announcing that the First Consul had accepted the office of +Mediator of the Helvetic League. A French army entered Switzerland. +Fifty-six deputies from the cantons were summoned to Paris; and, in the +beginning of 1803, a new Constitution, which left the central Government +powerless in the hands of France and reduced the national sovereignty to +cantonal self-administration, placed Switzerland on a level with the +Batavian and the Cisalpine dependencies of Bonaparte. The Rhone Valley, +with the mountains crossed by the new road over the Simplon, was converted +into a separate republic under the title of La Valais. The new chief +magistrate of the Helvetic Confederacy entered upon his office with a +pension paid out of Bonaparte's secret police fund. + +[Settlement of Germany.] + +Such was the nature of the independence which the Peace of Luneville gave +to Holland, to Northern Italy, and to Switzerland. The re-organisation of +Germany, which was provided for by the same treaty, affected larger +interests, and left more permanent traces upon European history. In the +provinces ceded to France lay the territory of the ancient ecclesiastical +princes of the empire, the Electors of Mainz, Cologne, and Treves; but, +besides these spiritual sovereigns, a variety of secular potentates, +ranging from the Elector Palatine, with 600,000 subjects, to the Prince of +Wiedrunkel, with a single village, owned territory upon the left bank of +the Rhine; and for the dispossessed lay princes new territories had now to +be formed by the destruction of other ecclesiastical States in the interior +of Germany. Affairs returned to the state in which they had stood in 1798, +and the comedy of Rastadt was renewed at the point where it had been broken +off: the only difference was that the French statesmen who controlled the +partition of ecclesiastical Germany now remained in Paris, instead of +coming to the Rhine, to run the risk of being murdered by Austrian hussars. +Scarcely was the Treaty of Luneville signed when the whole company of +intriguers who had touted at Rastadt posted off to the French capital with +their maps and their money-bags, the keener for the work when it became +known that by common consent the Free Cities of the Empire were now to be +thrown into the spoil. Talleyrand and his confidant Mathieu had no occasion +to ask for bribes, or to manoeuvre for the position of arbiters in Germany. +They were overwhelmed with importunities. Solemn diplomatists of the old +school toiled up four flights of stairs to the office of the needy +secretary, or danced attendance at the parties of the witty Minister. They +hugged Talleyrand's poodle; they vied with one another in gaining a smile +from the child whom he brought up at his house. [92] The shrewder of them +fortified their attentions with solid bargains, and made it their principal +care not to be outbidden at the auction. Thus the game was kept up as long +as there was a bishopric or a city in the market. + +This was the real process of the German re-organisation. A pretended one +was meanwhile enacted by the Diet of Ratisbon. The Diet deliberated during +the whole of the summer of 1801 without arriving at a single resolution. +Not even the sudden change of Russian policy that followed the death of the +Emperor Paul and deprived Bonaparte of the support of the Northern Maritime +League, could stimulate the German Powers to united action. The old +antagonism of Austria and Prussia paralysed the Diet. Austria sought a +German indemnity for the dethroned Grand Duke of Tuscany; Prussia aimed at +extending its influence into Southern Germany by the annexation of Wuerzburg +and Bamberg. Thus the summer of 1801 was lost in interminable debate, until +Bonaparte regained the influence over Russia which he had held before the +death of Paul, and finally set himself free from all check and restraint by +concluding peace with England. + +[German policy of Bonaparte.] + +No part of Bonaparte's diplomacy was more ably conceived or more likely to +result in a permanent empire than that which affected the secondary States +of Germany. The rivalry of Austria and Prussia, the dread of Austrian +aggression felt in Bavaria, the grotesque ambition of the petty sovereigns +of Baden and Wuertemburg, were all understood and turned to account in the +policy which from this time shaped the French protectorate beyond the +Rhine. Bonaparte intended to give to Prussia such an increase of territory +upon the Baltic as should counterbalance the power of Austria; and for this +purpose he was willing to sacrifice Hanover or Mecklenburg: but he forbade +Prussia's extension to the south. Austria, so far from gaining new +territory in Bavaria, was to be deprived of its own outlying possessions in +Western Germany, and excluded from all influence in this region. Bavaria, +dependent upon French protection against Austria, was to be greatly +strengthened. Baden and Wuertemberg, enriched by the spoil of little +sovereignties, of Bishoprics and Free Cities, were to look to France for +further elevation and aggrandisement. Thus, while two rival Powers balanced +one another upon the Baltic and the Lower Danube, the sovereigns of central +and western Germany, owing everything to the Power that had humbled +Austria, would find in submission to France the best security for their own +gains, and the best protection against their more powerful neighbours. + +[Treaty between France and Russia for joint action in Germany, Oct. 11, +1801.] + +One condition alone could have frustrated a policy agreeable to so many +interests, namely, the existence of a national sentiment among the Germans +themselves. But the peoples of Germany cared as little about a Fatherland +as their princes. To the Hessian and the Bavarian at the centre of the +Empire, Germany was scarcely more than it was to the Swiss or the Dutch, +who had left the Empire centuries before. The inhabitants of the Rhenish +Provinces had murmured for a while at the extortionate rule of the +Directory; but their severance from Germany and their incorporation with a +foreign race touched no fibre of patriotic regret; and after the +establishment of a better order of things under the Consulate the +annexation to France appears to have become highly popular. [93] Among a +race whose members could thus be actually conquered and annexed without +doing violence to their feelings Bonaparte had no difficulty in finding +willing allies. While the Diet dragged on its debates upon the settlement +of the Empire, the minor States pursued their bargainings with the French +Government; and on the 14th of August, 1801, Bavaria signed the first of +those treaties which made the First Consul the patron of Western Germany. +Two months later a secret treaty between France and Russia admitted the new +Czar, Alexander, to a share in the reorganisation of the Empire. The +Governments of Paris and St. Petersburg pledged themselves to united action +for the purpose of maintaining an equilibrium between Austria and Prussia; +and the Czar further stipulated for the advancement of his own relatives, +the Sovereigns of Bavaria, Baden, and Wuertemberg. The relationship of these +petty princes to the Russian family enabled Bonaparte to present to the +Czar, as a graceful concession, the very measure which most vitally +advanced his own power in Germany. Alexander's intervention made resistance +on the part of Austria hopeless. One after another the German Sovereigns +settled with their patrons for a share in the spoil; and on the 3rd of +June, 1802, a secret agreement between France and Russia embodied the whole +of these arrangements, and disposed of almost all the Free Cities and the +entire ecclesiastical territory of the Empire. + +[Diet of Ratisbon accepts French Scheme.] + +[End of German Ecclesiastical States and forty-five Free Cities, March, +1803.] + +When everything had thus been settled by the foreigners, a Committee, to +which the Diet of Ratisbon had referred the work of re-organisation, began +its sessions, assisted by a French and a Russian representative. The Scheme +which had been agreed upon between France and Russia was produced entire; +and in spite of the anger and the threats of Austria it passed the +Committee with no greater delay than was inseparable from everything +connected with German affairs. The Committee presented the Scheme to the +Diet: the Diet only agitated itself as to the means of passing the Scheme +without violating those formalities which were the breath of its life. The +proposed destruction of all the Ecclesiastical States, and of forty-five +out of the fifty Free Cities, would extinguish a third part of the members +of the Diet itself. If these unfortunate bodies were permitted to vote upon +the measure, their votes might result in its rejection: if unsummoned, +their absence would impair the validity of the resolution. By a masterpiece +of conscientious pedantry it was agreed that the doomed prelates and cities +should be duly called to vote in their turn, and that upon the mention each +name the answer "absent" should be returned by an officer. Thus, faithful +to its formalities, the Empire voted the destruction of its ancient +Constitution; and the sovereignties of the Ecclesiastics and Free Cities, +which had lasted for so many centuries, vanished from Europe (March, 1803). +[94] + +[Effect on Germany.] + +The loss was small indeed. The internal condition of the priest-ruled +districts was generally wretched; heavy ignorance, beggary, and intolerance +reduced life to a gross and dismal inertia. Except in their patronage of +music, the ecclesiastical princes had perhaps rendered no single service to +Germany. The Free Cities, as a rule, were sunk in debt; the management of +their affairs had become the perquisite of a few lawyers and privileged +families. For Germany, as a nation, the destruction of these petty +sovereignties was not only an advantage but an absolute necessity. The +order by which they were superseded was not devised in the interest of +Germany itself; yet even in the arrangements imposed by the foreigner +Germany gained centres from which the institutions of modern political life +entered into regions where no public authority had yet been known beyond +the court of the bishop or the feudal officers of the manor. [95] Through +the suppression of the Ecclesiastical States a Protestant majority was +produced in the Diet. The change bore witness to the decline of Austrian +and of Catholic energy during the past century; it scarcely indicated the +future supremacy of the Protestant rival of Austria; for the real interests +of Germany were but faintly imaged in the Diet, and the leadership of the +race was still open to the Power which should most sincerely identify +itself with the German nation. The first result of the changed character of +the Diet was the confiscation of all landed property held by religious or +charitable bodies, even where these had never advanced the slightest claim +to political independence. The Diet declared the whole of the land held in +Germany by pious foundations to be at the disposal of the Governments for +purposes of religion, of education, and of financial relief. The more needy +courts immediately seized so welcome an opportunity of increasing their +revenues. Germany lost nothing by the dissolution of some hundreds of +monasteries; the suppression of hospitals and the impoverishment of +Universities was a doubtful benefit. Through the destruction of the +Ecclesiastical States and the confiscation of Church lands, the support of +an army of priests was thrown upon the public revenues. The Elector of +Cologne, who had been an indifferent civil ruler, became a very prosperous +clergyman on L20,000 a year. All the members of the annexed or disendowed +establishments, down to the acolytes and the sacristans, were credited with +annuities equal in value to what they had lost. But in the confusion caused +by war the means to satisfy these claims was not always forthcoming; and +the ecclesiastical revolution, so beneficial on the whole to the public +interest, was not effected without much severe and undeserved individual +suffering. + +[Governments in Germany become more absolute and more regular.] + +[Bavaria. Reforms of Montgelas.] + +[Suppression of the Knights.] + +The movement of 1803 put an end to an order of things more curious as a +survival of the mixed religious and political form of the Holy Roman Empire +than important in the actual state of Europe. The temporal power now lost +by the Church in Germany had been held in such sluggish hands that its +effect was hardly visible except in a denser prejudice and an idler life +than prevailed under other Governments. The first consequence of its +downfall was that a great part of Germany which had hitherto had no +political organisation at all gained the benefit of a regular system of +taxation, of police, of civil and of criminal justice. If harsh and +despotic, the Governments which rose to power at the expense of the Church +were usually not wanting in the love of order and uniformity. Officers of +the State administered a fixed law where custom and privilege had hitherto +been the only rule. Appointments ceased to be bought or inherited; trades +and professions were thrown open; the peasant was relieved of his heaviest +feudal burdens. Among the newly consolidated States, Bavaria was the one +where the reforming impulse of the time took the strongest form. A new +dynasty, springing from the west of the Rhine, brought something of the +spirit of French liberalism into a country hitherto unsurpassed in Western +Europe for its ignorance and bigotry. [96] The Minister Montgelas, a +politician of French enlightenment, entered upon the same crusade against +feudal and ecclesiastical disorder which Joseph had inaugurated in Austria +twenty years before. His measures for subjecting the clergy to the law, and +for depriving the Church of its control over education, were almost +identical with those which in 1790 had led to the revolt of Belgium; and +the Bavarian landowners now unconsciously reproduced all the mediaeval +platitudes of the University of Louvain. Montgelas organised and levelled +with a remorseless common sense. Among his victims there was a class which +had escaped destruction in the recent changes. The Knights of the Empire, +with their village jurisdictions, were still legally existent; but to +Montgelas such a class appeared a mere absurdity, and he sent his soldiers +to disperse their courts and to seize their tolls. Loud lamentation +assailed the Emperor at Vienna. If the dethroned bishops had bewailed the +approaching extinction of Christianity in Europe, the knights just as +convincingly deplored the end of chivalry. Knightly honour, now being swept +from the earth, was proved to be the true soul of German nationality, the +invisible support of the Imperial throne. For a moment the intervention of +the Emperor forced Montgelas to withdraw his grasp from the sacred rents +and turnpikes; but the threatening storm passed over, and the example of +Bavaria was gradually followed by the neighbouring Courts. + +[Stein and the Duke of Nassau.] + +[Stein's attack on the Minor Princes.] + +It was to the weak and unpatriotic princes who were enriched by the French +that the knights fell victims. Among the knights thus despoiled by the Duke +of Nassau was the Ritter vom Stein, a nobleman who had entered the Prussian +service in the reign of Frederick the Great, and who had lately been placed +in high office in the newly-acquired province of Muenster. Stein was +thoroughly familiar with the advantages of systematic government; the loss +of his native parochial jurisdiction was not a serious one to a man who had +become a power in Prussia; and although domestic pride had its share in +Stein's resentment, the protest now published by him against the +aggressions of the Duke of Nassau sounded a different note from that of his +order generally. That a score of farmers should pay their dues and take off +their hats to the officer of the Duke of Nassau instead of to the bailiff +of the Ritter vom Stein was not a matter to excite deep feeling in Europe; +but that the consolidation of Germany should be worked out in the interest +of French hirelings instead of in the interests of the German people was +justly treated by Stein as a subject for patriotic anger. In his letter +[97] to the Duke of Nassau, Stein reproached his own despoiler and the +whole tribe of petty princes with that treason to German interests which +had won them the protection of the foreigner. He argued that the knights +were a far less important obstacle to German unity than those very princes +to whom the knights were sacrificed; and he invoked that distant day which +should give to Germany a real national unity, over knights and princes +alike, under the leadership of a single patriotic sovereign. Stein's appeal +found little response among his contemporaries. Like a sober man among +drunkards, he seemed to be scarcely rational. The simple conception of a +nation sacrificing its internal rivalries in order to avert foreign rule +was folly to the politicians who had all their lives long been outwitting +one another at Vienna or Berlin, or who had just become persons of +consequence in Europe through the patronage of Bonaparte. Yet, if years of +intolerable suffering were necessary before any large party in Germany rose +to the idea of German union, the ground had now at least been broken. In +the changes that followed the Peace of Luneville the fixity and routine of +Germany received its death-blow. In all but name the Empire had ceased to +exist. Change and re-constitution in one form or another had become +familiar to all men's minds; and one real statesman at the least was +already beginning to learn the lesson which later events were to teach to +the rest of the German race. + +[France, 1801-1804.] + +[Civil Code.] + +Four years of peace separated the Treaty of Luneville from the next +outbreak of war between France and any Continental Power. They were years +of extension of French influence in every neighbouring State; in France +itself, years of the consolidation of Bonaparte's power, and of the decline +of everything that checked his personal rule. The legislative bodies sank +into the insignificance for which they had been designed; everything that +was suffered to wear the appearance of strength owed its vigour to the +personal support of the First Consul. Among the institutions which date +from this period, two, equally associated with the name of Napoleon, have +taken a prominent place in history, the Civil Code and the Concordat. Since +the middle of the eighteenth century the codification of law had been +pursued with more or less success by almost every Government in Europe. In +France the Constituent Assembly of 1789 had ordered the statutes, by which +it superseded the old variety of local customs, to be thus cast into a +systematic form. A Committee of the Convention had completed the draft of a +Civil Code. The Directory had in its turn appointed a Commission; but the +project still remained unfulfilled when the Directory was driven from +power. Bonaparte instinctively threw himself into a task so congenial to +his own systematising spirit, and stimulated the efforts of the best +jurists in France by his personal interest and pride in the work of +legislation. A Commission of lawyers, appointed by the First Consul, +presented the successive chapters of a Civil Code to the Council of State. +In the discussions in the Council of State Bonaparte himself took an +active, though not always a beneficial, part. The draft of each chapter, as +it left the Council of State, was submitted, as a project of Law, to the +Tribunate and to the Legislative Body. For a moment the free expression of +opinion in the Tribunate caused Bonaparte to suspend his work in impatient +jealousy. The Tribunate, however, was soon brought to silence; and in +March, 1804, France received the Code which has formed from that time to +the present the basis of its civil rights. + +[Napoleon as a legislator.] + +When Napoleon declared that he desired his fame to rest upon the Civil +Code, he showed his appreciation of the power which names exercise over +mankind. It is probable that a majority of the inhabitants of Western +Europe believe that Napoleon actually invented the laws which bear his +name. As a matter of fact, the substance of these laws was fixed by the +successive Assemblies of the Revolution; and, in the final revision which +produced the Civil Code, Napoleon appears to have originated neither more +nor less than several of the members of his Council whose names have long +been forgotten. He is unquestionably entitled to the honour of a great +legislator, not, however, as one who, like Solon or like Mahomet, himself +created a new body of law, but as one who most vigorously pursued the work +of consolidating and popularising law by the help of all the skilled and +scientific minds whose resources were at his command. Though faulty in +parts, the Civil Code, through its conciseness, its simplicity, and its +justice, enabled Napoleon to carry a new and incomparably better social +order into every country that became part of his Empire. Four other Codes, +appearing at intervals from the year 1804 to the year 1810, embodied, in a +corresponding form, the Law of Commerce, the Criminal Law, and the Rules of +Civil and of Criminal Process. [98] The whole remains a monument of the +legal energy of the period which began in 1789, and of the sagacity with +which Napoleon associated with his own rule all the science and the +reforming zeal of the jurists of his day. + +[The Concordat.] + +[The Concordat destroys the Free Church.] + +Far more distinctively the work of Napoleon's own mind was the +reconciliation with the Church of Rome effected by the Concordat. It was a +restoration of religion similar to that restoration of political order +which made the public service the engine of a single will. The bishops and +priests, whose appointment the Concordat transferred from their +congregations to the Government, were as much instruments of the First +Consul as his prefects and his gendarmes. The spiritual wants of the +public, the craving of the poor for religious consolation, were made the +pretext for introducing the new theological police. But the situation of +the Catholic Church was in reality no worse in France at the commencement +of the Consulate than its present situation in Ireland. The Republic had +indeed subjected the non-juring priests to the heaviest penalties, but the +exercise of Christian worship, which, even in the Reign of Terror, had only +been interrupted by local and individual fanaticism, had long recovered the +protection of the law, services in the open air being alone prohibited. +[99] Since 1795 the local authorities had been compelled to admit the +religious societies of their district to the use of church-buildings. +Though the coup d'etat of Fructidor, 1797, renewed the persecution of +non-juring priests, it in no way checked the activity of the Constitutional +Church, now free from all connection with the Civil Government. While the +non-juring priests, exiled as political offenders, or theatrically adoring +the sacred elements in the woods, pretended that the age of the martyrs had +returned to France, a Constitutional Church, ministering in 4,000 parishes, +unprivileged but unharassed by the State, supplied the nation with an +earnest and respectable body of clergy. [100] But in the eyes of the First +Consul everything left to voluntary association was so much lost to the +central power. In the order of nature, peasants must obey priests, priests +must obey bishops, and bishops must obey the First Consul. An alliance with +the Pope offered to Bonaparte the means of supplanting the popular +organisation of the Constitutional Church by an imposing hierarchy, rigid +in its orthodoxy and unquestioning in its devotion to himself. In return +for the consecration of his own rule, Bonaparte did not shrink from +inviting the Pope to an exercise of authority such as the Holy See had +never even claimed in France. The whole of the existing French Bishops, +both the exiled non-jurors and those of the Constitutional Church, were +summoned to resign their Sees into the hands of the Pope; against all who +refused to do so sentence of deposition was pronounced by the Pontiff, +without a word heard in defence, or the shadow of a fault alleged. The Sees +were re-organised, and filled up by nominees of the First Consul. The +position of the great body of the clergy was substantially altered in its +relation to the Bishops. Episcopal power was made despotic, like all other +power in France: thousands of the clergy, hitherto secure in their livings, +were placed at the disposal of their bishop, and rendered liable to be +transferred at the pleasure of their superior from place to place. The +Constitutional Church vanished, but religion appeared to be honoured by +becoming part of the State. + +[Results in Ultramontanism.] + +In its immediate action, the Napoleonic Church served the purpose for which +it was intended. For some few years the clergy unflaggingly preached, +prayed, and catechised to the glory of their restorer. In the greater cycle +of religious change, the Concordat of Bonaparte appears in another light. +However little appreciated at the time, it was the greatest, the most +critical, victory which the Roman See has ever gained over the more +enlightened and the more national elements in the Catholic Church. It +converted the Catholicism of France from a faith already far more +independent than that of Fenelon and Bossuet into the Catholicism which in +our own day has outstripped the bigotry of Spain and Austria in welcoming +the dogma of Papal infallibility. The lower clergy, condemned by the State +to an intolerable subjection, soon found their only hope in an appeal to +Rome, and instinctively worked as the emissaries of the Roman See. The +Bishops, who owed their office to an unprecedented exercise of Papal power +and to the destruction of religious independence in France, were not the +men who could maintain a struggle with the Papacy for the ancient Gallican +liberties. In the resistance to the Papacy which had been maintained by the +Continental Churches in a greater or less degree during the eighteenth +century, France had on the whole taken the most effective part; but, from +the time when the Concordat dissolved both the ancient and the +revolutionary Church system of France, the Gallican tradition of the past +became as powerless among the French clergy as the philosophical liberalism +of the Revolution. + +[So do the German changes.] + +In Germany the destruction of the temporal power of the Church tended +equally to Ultramontanism. An archbishop of Cologne who governed half a +million subjects was less likely to prostrate himself before the Papal +Chair than an archbishop of Cologne who was only one among a regiment of +churchmen. The spiritual Electors and Princes who lost their dominions in +1801 had understood by the interests of their order something more tangible +than a body of doctrines. When not hostile to the Papacy, they had usually +treated it with indifference. The conception of a Catholic society exposed +to persecution at the hands of the State on account of its devotion to Rome +was one which had never entered the mind of German ecclesiastics in the +eighteenth century. Without the changes effected in Germany by the Treaty +of Luneville, without the Concordat of Bonaparte, Catholic orthodoxy would +never have become identical with Ultramontanism. In this respect the +opening years of the present century mark a turning-point in the relation +of the Church to modern life. Already, in place of the old monarchical +Governments, friendly on the whole to the Catholic Church, events were +preparing the way for that changed order with which the century seems +destined to close--an emancipated France, a free Italy, a secular, +state-disciplined Germany, and the Church in conspiracy against them all. + + + + +CHAPTER VI. + + +England claims Malta--War renewed--Bonaparte occupies Hanover, and +blockades the Elbe--Remonstrances of Prussia--Cadoudal's Plot--Murder of +the Duke of Enghien--Napoleon Emperor--Coalition of 1805--Prussia holds +aloof--State of Austria--Failure of Napoleon's attempt to gain naval +superiority in the Channel--Campaign in Western Germany--Capitulation of +Ulm--Trafalgar--Treaty of Potsdam between Prussia and the Allies--The +French enter Vienna--Haugwitz sent to Napoleon with Prussian Ultimatum-- +Battle of Austerlitz--Haugwitz signs a Treaty of Alliance with +Napoleon--Peace--Treaty of Presburg--End of the Holy Roman Empire-- +Naples given to Joseph Bonaparte--Battle of Maida--The Napoleonic Empire +and Dynasty--Federation of the Rhine--State of Germany--Possibility of +maintaining the Empire of 1806. + + +[England prepares for war, Nov., 1802.] + +[England claims Malta.] + +War was renewed between France and Great Britain in the spring of 1803. +Addington's Government, in their desire for peace, had borne with +Bonaparte's aggressions during all the months of negotiation at Amiens; +they had met his complaints against the abuse of the English press by +prosecuting his Royalist libellers; throughout the Session of 1802 they had +upheld the possibility of peace against the attacks of their parliamentary +opponents. The invasion of Switzerland in the autumn of 1802, following the +annexation of Piedmont, forced the Ministry to alter its tone. The King's +Speech at the meeting of Parliament in November declared that the changes +in operation on the Continent demanded measures of security on the part of +Great Britain. The naval and military forces of the country were restored +to a war-footing; the evacuation of Malta by Great Britain, which had +hitherto been delayed chiefly through a misunderstanding with Russia, was +no longer treated as a matter of certainty. While the English Government +still wavered, a challenge was thrown down by the First Consul which forced +them into decided action. The _Moniteur_ published on the 13th of January, +1803, a report upon Egypt by Colonel Sebastiani, pointing in the plainest +terms to the renewal of French attacks upon the East. The British +Government demanded explanations, and declared that until satisfaction was +given upon this point they should retain possession of Malta. Malta was in +fact appropriated by Great Britain as an equivalent for the Continental +territory added to France since the end of the war. [101] + +[War, May, 1803.] + +It would have been better policy if, some months earlier, Bonaparte had +been required to withdraw from Piedmont or from Switzerland, under pain of +hostilities with England. Great Britain had as little technical right to +retain Malta as Bonaparte had to annex Piedmont. The desire for peace had, +however, led Addington's Government to remain inactive until Bonaparte's +aggressions had become accomplished facts. It was now too late to attempt +to undo them: England could only treat the settlement of Amiens as +superseded, and claim compensation on its own side. Malta was the position +most necessary to Great Britain, in order to prevent Bonaparte from +carrying out projects in Egypt and Greece of which the Government had +evidence independent of Sebastiani's report. The value of Malta, so lately +denied by Nelson, was now fully understood both in France and England. No +sooner had the English Ministry avowed its intention of retaining the +island than the First Consul declared himself compelled to take up arms in +behalf of the faith of treaties. Ignoring his own violations of +treaty-rights in Italy and Switzerland, Bonaparte declared the retention of +Malta by Great Britain to be an outrage against all Europe. He assailed the +British Ambassador with the utmost fury at a reception held at the +Tuileries on the 13th of March; and, after a correspondence of two months, +which probably marked his sense of the power and obstinacy of his enemy, +the conflict was renewed which was now to continue without a break until +Bonaparte was driven from his throne. + +[Bonaparte and Hanover.] + +So long as England was without Continental allies its warfare was limited +to the seizure of colonies and the blockade of ports: on the part of France +nothing could be effected against the island Power except by actual +invasion. There was, however, among the communities of Germany one which, +in the arguments of a conqueror, might be treated as a dependency of +England, and made to suffer for its connection with the British Crown. +Hanover had hitherto by common agreement been dissociated from the wars in +which its Elector engaged as King of England; even the personal presence of +King George II. at the battle of Dettingen had been held no ground for +violating its neutrality. Bonaparte, however, was untroubled by precedents +in a case where he had so much to gain. Apart from its value as a possible +object of exchange in the next treaty with England, Hanover would serve as +a means of influencing Prussia: it was also worth so many millions in cash +through the requisitions which might be imposed upon its inhabitants. The +only scruple felt by Bonaparte in attacking Hanover arose from the +possibility of a forcible resistance on the part of Prussia to the +appearance of a French army in North Germany. Accordingly, before the +invasion began, General Duroc was sent to Berlin to inform the King of the +First Consul's intentions, and to soothe any irritation that might be felt +at the Prussian Court by assurances of friendship and respect. + +[Prussia and Hanover.] + +It was a moment of the most critical importance to Prussia. Prussia was the +recognised guardian of Northern Germany; every consideration of interest +and of honour required that its Government should forbid the proposed +occupation of Hanover--if necessary, at the risk of actual war. Hanover in +the hands of France meant the extinction of German independence up to the +frontiers of the Prussian State. If, as it was held at Berlin, the cause of +Great Britain was an unjust one, and if the connection of Hanover with the +British Crown was for the future to make that province a scapegoat for the +offences of England, the wisest course for Prussia would have been to +deliver Hanover at once from its French and from its English enemies by +occupying it with its own forces. The Foreign Minister, Count Haugwitz, +appears to have recommended this step, but his counsels were overruled. +King Frederick William III., who had succeeded his father in 1797, was a +conscientious but a timid and spiritless being. Public affairs were in the +hands of his private advisers, of whom the most influential were the +so-called cabinet-secretaries, Lombard and Beyme, men credulously anxious +for the goodwill of France, and perversely blind to the native force and +worth which still existed in the Prussian Monarchy. [102] Instead of +declaring the entry of the French into Hanover to be absolutely +incompatible with the safety of the other North German States, King +Frederick William endeavoured to avert it by diplomacy. He tendered his +mediation to the British Government upon condition of the evacuation of +Malta; and, when this proposal was bluntly rejected, he offered to the +First Consul his personal security that Hanover should pay a sum of money +in order to be spared the intended invasion. + +[French enter Hanover, May, 1803.] + +[Oppression in Hanover, 1803-1805.] + +Such a proposal marked the depth to which Prussian statemanship had sunk; +it failed to affect the First Consul in the slightest degree. While +negotiations were still proceeding, a French division, commanded by General +Mortier, entered Hanover (May, 1803). The Hanoverian army was lost through +the follies of the civil Government; the Duke of Cambridge, commander of +one of its divisions, less ingenious than his brother the Duke of York in +finding excuses for capitulation, resigned his commission, and fled to +England, along with many brave soldiers, who subsequently found in the army +of Great Britain the opportunity for honourable service which was denied to +them at home. Hanover passed into the possession of France, and for two +years the miseries of French occupation were felt to the full. Extortion +consumed the homely wealth of the country; the games and meetings of the +people were prohibited; French spies violated the confidences of private +life; law was administered by foreign soldiers; the press existed only for +the purpose of French proselytism. It was in Hanover that the bitterness of +that oppression was first felt which subsequently roused all North Germany +against a foreign master, and forced upon the race the long-forgotten +claims of patriotism and honour. + +[French blockade the Elbe.] + +[Vain remonstrance of Prussia.] + +Bonaparte had justly calculated upon the inaction of the Prussian +Government when he gave the order to General Mortier to enter Hanover; his +next step proved the growth of his confidence in Prussia's impassivity. A +French force was despatched to Cuxhaven, at the mouth of the Elbe, in order +to stop the commerce of Great Britain with the interior of Germany. The +British Government immediately informed the Court of Berlin that it should +blockade the Elbe and the Weser against the ships of all nations unless the +French soldiers withdrew from the Elbe. As the linen trade of Silesia and +other branches of Prussian industry depended upon the free navigation of +the Elbe, the threatened reprisals of the British Government raised very +serious questions for Prussia. It was France, not England, that had first +violated the neutrality of the river highway; and the King of Prussia now +felt himself compelled to demand assurances Bonaparte that the interests of +Germany should suffer no further injury at his hands. A letter was written +by the King to the First Consul, and entrusted to the cabinet-secretary, +Lombard, who carried it to Napoleon at Brussels (July, 1803). Lombard, the +son of French parents who had settled at Berlin in the reign of Frederick +the Great, had risen from a humble station through his skill in expression +in the two languages that were native to him; and the accomplishments which +would have made him a good clerk or a successful journalist made him in the +eyes of Frederick William a counsellor for kings. The history of his +mission to Brussels gives curious evidence both of the fascination +exercised by Napoleon over common minds, and of the political helplessness +which in Prussia could now be mistaken for the quality of a statesman. +Lombard failed to obtain from Napoleon any guarantee or security whatever; +yet he wrote back in terms of the utmost delight upon the success of his +mission. Napoleon had infatuated him by the mere exercise of his personal +charm. "What I cannot describe," said Lombard, in his report to the King +relating his interview with the First Consul, [103] "is the tone of +goodness and noble frankness with which he expressed his reverence for your +Majesty's rights, and asked for that confidence from your Majesty which he +so well deserves." "I only wish," he cried at the close of Napoleon's +address, "that I could convey to the King, my master, every one of your +words and the tone in which they are uttered; he would then, I am sure, +feel a double joy at the justice with which you have always been treated at +his hands." Lombard's colleagues at Berlin were perhaps not stronger men +than the envoy himself, but they were at least beyond the range of +Napoleon's voice and glance, and they received this rhapsody with coldness. +They complained that no single concession had been made by the First Consul +upon the points raised by the King. Cuxhaven continued in French hands; the +British inexorably blockaded the Germans upon their own neutral waters; and +the cautious statecraft of Prussia proved as valueless to Germany as the +obstinate, speculating warfare of Austria. + +[Alexander displeased.] + +There was, however, a Power which watched the advance of French dominion +into Northern Germany with less complaisance than the Germans themselves. +The Czar of Russia had gradually come to understand the part allotted to +him by Bonaparte since the Peace of Luneville, and was no longer inclined +to serve as the instrument of French ambition. Bonaparte's occupation of +Hanover changed the attitude of Alexander into one of coldness and +distrust. Alexander saw and lamented the help which he himself had given to +Bonaparte in Germany: events that now took place in France itself, as well +as the progress of French intrigues in Turkey, [104] threw him into the +arms of Bonaparte's enemies, and prepared the way for a new European +coalition. + +[Bonaparte about to become Emperor.] + +[Murder of the Duke of Enghien, March 20, 1804.] + +The First Bonaparte Consul had determined to assume the dignity of Emperor. +The renewal of war with England excited a new outburst of enthusiasm for +his person; nothing was wanting to place the crown on his head but the +discovery of a plot against his life. Such a plot had been long and +carefully followed by the police. A Breton gentleman, Georges Cadoudal, had +formed the design of attacking the First Consul in the streets of Paris in +the midst of his guards. Cadoudal and his fellow-conspirators, including +General Pichegru, were traced by the police from the coast of Normandy to +Paris: an unsuccessful attempt was made to lure the Count of Artois, and +other royal patrons of the conspiracy, from Great Britain. When all the +conspirators who could be enticed to France were collected within the +capital, the police, who had watched every stage of the movement, began to +make arrests. Moreau, the last Republican soldier of France, was charged +with complicity in the plot. Pichegru and Cadoudal were thrown into prison, +there to await their doom; Moreau, who probably wished for the overthrow of +the Consular Government, but had no part in the design against Bonaparte's +life, [105] was kept under arrest and loaded with official calumny. One +sacrifice more remained to be made, in place of the Bourbon d'Artois, who +baffled the police of the First Consul beyond the seas. In the territory of +Baden, twelve miles from the French frontier, there lived a prince of the +exiled house, the Duke of Enghien, a soldier under the first Coalition +against France, now a harmless dependent on the bounty of England. French +spies surrounded him; his excursions into the mountains gave rise to a +suspicion that he was concerned in Pichegru's plot. This was enough to mark +him for destruction. Bonaparte gave orders that he should be seized, +brought to Paris, and executed. On the 15th of March, 1804, a troop of +French soldiers crossed the Rhine and arrested the Duke in his own house at +Ettenheim. They arrived with him at Paris on the 20th. He was taken to the +fort of Vincennes without entering the city. On that same night a +commission of six colonels sat in judgment upon the prisoner, whose grave +was already dug, and pronounced sentence of death without hearing a word of +evidence. At daybreak the Duke was led out and shot. + +[Napoleon Emperor, May 18, 1804.] + +If some barbaric instinct made the slaughter of his predecessor's kindred +in Bonaparte's own eyes the omen of a successful usurpation, it was not so +with Europe generally. One universal sense of horror passed over the +Continent. The Court of Russia put on mourning; even the Diet of Ratisbon +showed signs of human passion at the indignity done to Germany by the +seizure of the Duke of Enghien on German soil. Austria kept silent, but +watched the signs of coming war. France alone showed no pity. Before the +Duke of Enghien had been dead a week, the Senate besought Napoleon to give +to France the security of a hereditary throne. Prefects, bishops, mayors, +and councils with one voice repeated the official prayer. A resolution in +favour of imperial rule was brought forward in the Tribunate, and passed, +after a noble and solitary protest on the part of Carnot. A decree of the +Senate embodied the terms of the new Constitution; and on the 18th of May, +without waiting for the sanction of a national vote, Napoleon assumed the +title of Emperor of the French. + +[Title of Emperor of Austria, Aug., 1804.] + +In France itself the change was one more of the name than of the substance +of power. Napoleon could not be vested with a more absolute authority than +he already possessed; but the forms of republican equality vanished; and +although the real social equality given to France by the Revolution was +beyond reach of change, the nation had to put up with a bastard Court and a +fictitious aristocracy of Corsican princes, Terrorist excellencies, and +Jacobin dukes. The new dynasty was recognised at Vienna and Berlin: on the +part of Austria it received the compliment of an imitation. Three months +after the assumption of the Imperial title by Napoleon, the Emperor Francis +(Emperor in Germany, but King in Hungary and Bohemia) assumed the title of +Emperor of all his Austrian dominions. The true reason for this act was the +virtual dissolution of the Germanic system by the Peace of Luneville, and +the probability that the old Imperial dignity, if preserved in name, would +soon be transferred to some client of Napoleon or to Napoleon himself. Such +an apprehension was, however, not one that could be confessed to Europe. +Instead of the ruin of Germany, the grandeur of Austria was made the +ostensible ground of change. In language which seemed to be borrowed from +the scriptural history of Nebuchadnezzar, the Emperor Francis declared +that, although no possible addition could be made to his own personal +dignity, as Roman Emperor, yet the ancient glory of the Austrian House, the +grandeur of the principalities and kingdoms which were united under its +dominion, required that the Sovereigns of Austria should hold a title equal +to that of the greatest European throne. A general war against Napoleon was +already being proposed by the Court of St. Petersburg; but for the present +the Corsican and the Hapsburg Caesar exchanged their hypocritical +congratulations. [106] + +[Pitt again Minister, May, 1804.] + +[Coalition of 1805.] + +Almost at the same time that Bonaparte ascended the throne, Pitt returned +to power in Great Britain. He was summoned by the general distrust felt in +Addington's Ministry, and by the belief that no statesman but himself could +rally the Powers of Europe against the common enemy. Pitt was not long in +framing with Russia the plan of a third Coalition. The Czar broke off +diplomatic intercourse with Napoleon in September, 1804, and induced the +Court of Vienna to pledge itself to resist any further extension of French +power. Sweden entered into engagements with Great Britain. On the opening +of Parliament at the beginning of 1805, King George III. announced that an +understanding existed between Great Britain and Russia, and asked in +general terms for a provision for Continental subsidies. In April, a treaty +was signed at St. Petersburg by the representatives of Russia and Great +Britain, far more comprehensive and more serious in its provisions than any +which had yet united the Powers against France. [107] Russia and England +bound themselves to direct their efforts to the formation of a European +League capable of placing five hundred thousand men in the field. Great +Britain undertook to furnish subsidies to every member of the League; no +peace was to be concluded with France but by common consent; conquests +made by any of the belligerents were to remain unappropriated until the +general peace; and at the termination of the war a Congress was to fix +certain disputed points of international right, and to establish a +federative European system for their maintenance and enforcement. As the +immediate objects of the League, the treaty specified the expulsion of +the French from Holland, Switzerland, Italy, and Northern Germany; the +re-establishment of the King of Sardinia in Piedmont, with an increase of +territory; and the creation of a solid barrier against any future +usurpations of France. The last expression signified the union of Holland +and part of Belgium under the House of Orange. In this respect, as in the +provision for a common disposal of conquests and for the settlement of +European affairs by a Congress, the Anglo-Russian Treaty of 1805 defined +the policy actually carried out in 1814. Other territorial changes now +suggested by Pitt, including the annexation of the Rhenish Provinces to +the Prussian Monarchy, were not embodied in the treaty, but became from +this time understood possibilities. + +[Policy of Prussia.] + +[Prussia neutral.] + +England and Russia had, however, some difficulty in securing allies. +Although in violation of his promises to Austria, Napoleon had accepted the +title of King of Italy from the Senate of the Italian Republic, and had +crowned himself with the Iron Crown of Lombardy (March, 1805), the +Ministers at Vienna would have preferred peace, if that had been possible; +and their master reluctantly consented to a war against Napoleon when war +in some form or other seemed inevitable. The policy of Prussia was +doubtful. For two years past Napoleon had made every effort to induce +Prussia to enter into alliance with himself. After the invasion of Hanover +he had doubled his attentions to the Court of Berlin, and had spared +nothing in the way of promises and assurances of friendship to win the King +over to his side. The neutrality of Prussia was of no great service to +France: its support would have been of priceless value, rendering any +attack upon France by Russia or Austria almost impossible, and thus +enabling Napoleon to throw his whole strength into the combat with Great +Britain. In the spring of 1804, the King of Prussia, uncertain of the +friendship of the Czar, and still unconvinced of the vanity of Napoleon's +professions, had inclined to a defensive alliance with France. The news of +the murder of the Duke of Enghien, arriving almost simultaneously with a +message of goodwill from St. Petersburg, led him to abandon this project of +alliance, but caused no breach with Napoleon. Frederick William adhered to +the temporising policy which Prussia had followed since 1795, and the +Foreign Minister, Haugwitz, who had recommended bolder measures, withdrew +for a time from the Court. [108] Baron Hardenberg, who had already acted as +his deputy, stepped into his place. Hardenberg, the negotiator of the peace +of Basle, had for the last ten years advocated a system of neutrality. A +politician quick to grasp new social and political ideas, he was without +that insight into the real forces at work in Europe which, in spite of +errors in detail, made the political aims of Pitt, and of many far inferior +men, substantially just and correct. So late as the end of the year 1804, +Hardenberg not only failed to recognise the dangers to which Prussia was +exposed from Napoleon's ambition, but conceived it to be still possible for +Prussia to avert war between France and the Allied Powers by maintaining a +good understanding with all parties alike. Hardenberg's neutrality excited +the wrath of the Russian Cabinet. While Metternich, the Austrian ambassador +at Berlin, cautiously felt his way, the Czar proposed in the last resort to +force Prussia to take up arms. A few months more passed; and, when +hostilities were on the point of breaking out, Hanover was definitely +offered to Prussia by Napoleon as the price of an alliance. Hardenberg, +still believing that it lay within the power of Prussia, by means of a +French alliance, both to curb Napoleon and to prevent a European war, urged +the King to close with the offer of the French Emperor. [109] But the King +shrank from a decision which involved the possibility of immediate war. The +offer of Hanover was rejected, and Prussia connected itself neither with +Napoleon nor his enemies. + +[State of Austria. The army.] + +Pitt, the author of the Coalition of 1805, had formed the most sanguine +estimate of the armaments of his allies. Austria was said to have entered +upon a new era since the peace of Luneville, and to have turned to the best +account all the disasters of its former campaigns. There had indeed been no +want of fine professions from Vienna, but Pitt knew little of the real +state of affairs. The Archduke Charles had been placed at the head of the +military administration, and entrusted with extraordinary powers; but the +whole force of routine and corruption was ranged against him. He was +deceived by his subordinates; and after three years of reorganisation he +resigned his post, confessing that he left the army no nearer efficiency +than it was before. Charles was replaced at the War Office by General Mack. +Within six months this bustling charlatan imagined himself to have effected +the reorganisation of which the Archduke despaired, [110] while he had in +fact only introduced new confusion into an army already hampered beyond any +in Europe by its variety of races and languages. + +[Political condition of Austria.] + +If the military reforms of Austria were delusive, its political reforms +were still more so. The Emperor had indeed consented to unite the +Ministers, who had hitherto worked independently, in a Council of State; +but here reform stopped. Cobenzl, who was now First Minister, understood +nothing but diplomacy. Men continued in office whose presence was an +insuperable bar to any intelligent action: even in that mechanical routine +which, in the eyes of the Emperor Francis, constituted the life of the +State, everything was antiquated and self-contradictory. In all that +affected the mental life of the people the years that followed the peace of +Luneville were distinctly retrograde. Education was placed more than ever +in the hands of the priests; the censorship of the press was given to the +police; a commission was charged with the examination of all the books +printed during the reign of the Emperor Joseph, and above two thousand +works, which had come into being during that brief period of Austrian +liberalism, were suppressed and destroyed. Trade regulations were issued +which combined the extravagance of the French Reign of Terror with the +ignorance of the Middle Ages. All the grain in the country was ordered to +be sold before a certain date, and the Jews were prohibited from carrying +on the corn-trade for a year. Such were the reforms described by Pitt in +the English Parliament as having effected the regeneration of Austria. +Nearer home things were judged in a truer light. Mack's paper-regiments, +the helplessness and unreality of the whole system of Austrian officialism, +were correctly appreciated by the men who had been most in earnest during +the last war. Even Thugut now thought a contest hopeless. The Archduke +Charles argued to the end for peace, and entered upon the war with the +presentiment of defeat and ruin. + +[Plans of campaign, 1805.] + +The plans of the Allies for the campaign of 1805 covered an immense field. +[111] It was intended that one Austrian army should operate in Lombardy +under the Archduke Charles, while a second, under General Mack, entered +Bavaria, and there awaited the arrival of the Russians, who were to unite +with it in invading France: British and Russian contingents were to combine +with the King of Sweden in Pomerania, and with the King of Naples in +Southern Italy. At the head-quarters of the Allies an impression prevailed +that Napoleon was unprepared for war. It was even believed that his +character had lost something of its energy under the influence of an +Imperial Court. Never was there a more fatal illusion. The forces of France +had never been so overwhelming; the plans of Napoleon had never been worked +out with greater minuteness and certainty. From Hanover to Strasburg masses +of troops had been collected upon the frontier in readiness for the order +to march; and, before the campaign opened, the magnificent army of +Boulogne, which had been collected for the invasion of England, was thrown +into the scale against Austria. + +[Failure of Napoleon's naval designs against England.] + +[Nelson and Villeneuve, April-June, 1805.] + +Events had occurred at sea which frustrated Napoleon's plan for an attack +upon Great Britain. This attack, which in 1797 had been but lightly +threatened, had, upon the renewal of war with England in 1803, become the +object of Napoleon's most serious efforts. An army was concentrated at +Boulogne sufficient to overwhelm the military forces of England, if once it +could reach the opposite shore. Napoleon's thoughts were centred on a plan +for obtaining the naval superiority in the Channel, if only for the few +hours which it would take to transport the army from Boulogne to the +English coast. It was his design to lure Nelson to the other side of the +Atlantic by a feigned expedition against the West Indies, and, during the +absence of the English admiral, to unite all the fleets at present lying +blockaded in the French ports, as a cover for the invading armament. +Admiral Villeneuve was ordered to sail to Martinique, and, after there +meeting with some other ships, to re-cross the Atlantic with all possible +speed, and liberate the fleets blockaded in Ferrol, Brest, and Rochefort. +The junction of the fleets would give Napoleon a force of fifty sail in the +British Channel, a force more than sufficient to overpower all the +squadrons which Great Britain could possibly collect for the defence of its +shores. Such a design exhibited all the power of combination which marked +Napoleon's greatest triumphs; but it required of an indifferent marine the +precision and swiftness of movement which belonged to the land-forces of +France; it assumed in the seamen of Great Britain the same absence of +resource which Napoleon had found among the soldiers of the Continent. In +the present instance, however, Napoleon had to deal with a man as far +superior to all the admirals of France as Napoleon himself was to the +generals of Austria and Prussia. Villeneuve set sail for the West Indies in +the spring of 1805, and succeeded in drawing Nelson after him; but, before +he could re-cross the Atlantic, Nelson, incessantly pursuing the French +squadron in the West-Indian seas, and at length discovering its departure +homewards at Antigua (June 13), had warned the English Government of +Villeneuve's movement by a message sent in the swiftest of the English +brigs. [112] The Government, within twenty-four hours of receiving Nelson's +message, sent orders to Sir Robert Calder instantly to raise the blockades +of Ferrol and Rochefort, and to wait for Villeneuve off Cape Finisterre. +Here Villeneuve met the English fleet (July 22). He was worsted in a +partial engagement, and retired into the harbour of Ferrol. The pressing +orders of Napoleon forced the French admiral, after some delay, to attempt +that movement on Brest and Rochefort on which the whole plan of the +invasion of England depended. But Villeneuve was no longer in a condition +to meet the English force assembled against him. He put back without +fighting, and retired to Cadiz. All hope of carrying out the attack upon +England was lost. + +[March of French armies on Bavaria, Sept.] + +It only remained for Napoleon to avenge himself upon Austria through the +army which was baulked of its English prey. On the 1st of September, when +the Austrians were now on the point of crossing the Inn, the camp of +Boulogne was broken up. The army turned eastwards, and distributed itself +over all the roads leading from the Channel to the Rhine and the Upper +Danube. Far on the north-east the army of Hanover, commanded by Bernadotte, +moved as its left wing, and converged upon a point in Southern Germany +half-way between the frontiers of France and Austria. In the fables that +long disguised the true character of every action of Napoleon, the +admirable order of march now given to the French armies appears as the +inspiration of a moment, due to the rebound of Napoleon's genius after +learning the frustration of all his naval plans. In reality, the employment +of the "Army of England" against a Continental coalition had always been an +alternative present to Napoleon's mind; and it was threateningly mentioned +in his letters at a time when Villeneuve's failure was still unknown. + +[Austrians invade Bavaria, Sept. 8.] + +The only advantage which the Allies derived from the remoteness of the +Channel army was that Austria was able to occupy Bavaria without +resistance. General Mack, who was charged with this operation, crossed the +Inn on the 8th of September. The Elector of Bavaria was known to be +secretly hostile to the Coalition. The design of preventing his union with +the French was a correct one; but in the actual situation of the allied +armies it was one that could not be executed without great risk. The +preparations of Russia required more time than was allowed for them; no +Russian troops could reach the Inn before the end of October; and, in +consequence, the entire force operating in Western Germany did not exceed +seventy thousand men. Any doubts, however, as to the prudence of an advance +through Bavaria were silenced by the assurance that Napoleon had to bring +the bulk of his army from the British Channel. [113] In ignorance of the +real movements of the French, Mack pushed on to the western limit of +Bavaria, and reached the river Iller, the border of Wuertemberg, where he +intended to stand on the defensive until the arrival of the Russians. + +[Mack at Ulm, October.] + +[Capitulation of Ulm, Oct. 17.] + +Here, in the first days of October, he became aware of the presence of +French troops, not only in front but to the east of his own position. +With some misgiving as to the situation of the enemy, Mack nevertheless +refused to fall back from Ulm. Another week revealed the true state of +affairs. Before the Russians were anywhere near Bavaria, the vanguard of +Napoleon's Army of the Channel and the Army of Hanover had crossed +North-Western Germany, and seized the roads by which Mack had advanced +from Vienna. Every hour that Mack remained in Ulm brought new divisions +of the French into the Bavarian towns and villages behind him. Escape was +only possible by a retreat into the Tyrol, or by breaking through the +French line while it was yet incompletely formed. Resolute action might +still have saved the Austrian army; but the only energy that was shown +was shown in opposition to the general. The Archduke Ferdinand, who was +the titular commander-in-chief, cut his way through the French with part +of the cavalry; Mack remained in Ulm, and the iron circle closed around +him. At the last moment, after the hopelessness of the situation had +become clear even to himself, Mack was seized by an illusion that some +great disaster had befallen the French in their rear, and that in the +course of a few days Napoleon would be in full retreat. "Let no man utter +the word 'Surrender'"--he proclaimed in an order of October 15th--"the +enemy is in the most fearful straits; it is impossible that he can +continue more than a few days in the neighbourhood. If provisions run +short, we have three thousand horses to nourish us." "I myself," continued +the general, "will be the first to eat horseflesh." Two days later the +inevitable capitulation took place; and Mack with 25,000 men, fell into the +hands of the enemy without striking a blow. A still greater number of the +Austrians outside Ulm surrendered in detachments. [114] + +[Trafalgar, Oct. 21.] + +[Effects.] + +All France read with wonder Napoleon's bulletins describing the capture of +an entire army and the approaching presentation of forty Austrian standards +to the Senate at Paris. No imperial rhetoric acquainted the nation with an +event which, within four days of the capitulation of Ulm, inflicted a +heavier blow on France than Napoleon himself had ever dealt to any +adversary. On the 21st of October Nelson's crowning victory of Trafalgar, +won over Villeneuve venturing out from Cadiz, annihilated the combined +fleets of France and Spain. Nelson fell in the moment of his triumph; but +the work which his last hours had achieved was one to which years prolonged +in glory could have added nothing. He had made an end of the power of +France upon the sea. Trafalgar was not only the greatest naval victory, it +was the greatest and most momentous victory won either by land or by sea +during the whole of the Revolutionary War. No victory, and no series of +victories, of Napoleon produced the same effect upon Europe. Austria was in +arms within five years of Marengo, and within four years of Austerlitz; +Prussia was ready to retrieve the losses of Jena in 1813; a generation +passed after Trafalgar before France again seriously threatened England at +sea. The prospect of crushing the British navy, so long as England had the +means to equip a navy, vanished: Napoleon henceforth set his hopes on +exhausting England's resources by compelling every State on the Continent +to exclude her commerce. Trafalgar forced him to impose his yoke upon all +Europe, or to abandon the hope of conquering Great Britain. If national +love and pride have idealised in our great sailor a character which, with +its Homeric force and freshness, combined something of the violence and the +self-love of the heroes of a rude age, the common estimate of Nelson's work +in history is not beyond the truth. So long as France possessed a navy, +Nelson sustained the spirit of England by his victories; his last triumph +left England in such a position that no means remained to injure her but +those which must result in the ultimate deliverance of the Continent. + +[Treaty of Potsdam, Nov. 3.] + +[Violation of Prussian territory.] + +The consequences of Trafalgar lay in the future; the military situation in +Germany after Mack's catastrophe was such that nothing could keep the army +of Napoleon out of Vienna. In the sudden awakening of Europe to its danger, +one solitary gleam of hope appeared in the attitude of the Prussian Court. +Napoleon had not scrupled, in his anxiety for the arrival of the Army of +Hanover, to order Bernadotte, its commander, to march through the Prussian +territory of Anspach, which lay on his direct route towards Ulm. It was +subsequently alleged by the Allies that Bernadotte's violation of Prussian +neutrality had actually saved him from arriving too late to prevent Mack's +escape; but, apart from all imaginary grounds of reproach, the insult +offered to Prussia by Napoleon was sufficient to incline even Frederick +William to decided action. Some weeks earlier the approach of Russian +forces to his frontier had led Frederick William to arm; the French had now +more than carried out what the Russians had only suggested. When the +outrage was made known to the King of Prussia, that cold and reserved +monarch displayed an emotion which those who surrounded him had seldom +witnessed. [115] The Czar was forthwith offered a free passage for his +armies through Silesia; and, before the news of Mack's capitulation reached +the Russian frontier, Alexander himself was on the way to Berlin. The +result of the deliberations of the two monarchs was the Treaty of Potsdam, +signed on November 3rd. By this treaty Prussia undertook to demand from +Napoleon an indemnity for the King of Piedmont, and the evacuation of +Germany, Switzerland, and Holland: failing Napoleon's acceptance of +Prussia's mediation upon these terms, Prussia engaged to take the field +with 180,000 men. + +[French enter Vienna, Nov. 13.] + +Napoleon was now close upon Vienna. A few days after the capitulation of +Ulm thirty thousand Russians, commanded by General Kutusoff, had reached +Bavaria; but Mack's disaster rendered it impossible to defend the line of +the Inn, and the last detachments of the Allies disappeared as soon as +Napoleon's vanguard approached the river. The French pushed forth in +overpowering strength upon the capital. Kutusoff and the weakened Austrian +army could neither defend Vienna nor meet the invader in the field. It was +resolved to abandon the city, and to unite the retreating forces on the +northern side of the Danube with a second Russian army now entering +Moravia. On the 7th of November the Court quitted Vienna. Six days later +the French entered the capital, and by an audacious stratagem of Murat's +gained possession of the bridge connecting the city with the north bank of +the Danube, at the moment when the Austrian gunners were about to blow it +into the air. [116] The capture of this bridge deprived the allied army of +the last object protecting it from Napoleon's pursuit. Vienna remained in +the possession of the French. All the resources of a great capital were now +added to the means of the conqueror; and Napoleon prepared to follow his +retreating adversary beyond the Danube, and to annihilate him before he +could reach his supports. + +[The Allies and Napoleon in Moravia, Nov.] + +The retreat of the Russian army into Moravia was conducted with great skill +by General Kutusoff, who retorted upon Murat the stratagem practised at the +bridge of Vienna, and by means of a pretended armistice effected his +junction with the newly-arrived Russian corps between Olmuetz and Bruenn. +Napoleon's anger at the escape of his prey was shown in the bitterness of +his attacks upon Murat. The junction of the allied armies in Moravia had in +fact most seriously altered the prospects of the war. For the first time +since the opening of the campaign, the Allies had concentrated a force +superior in numbers to anything that Napoleon could bring against it. It +was impossible for Napoleon, while compelled to protect himself on the +Italian side, to lead more than 70,000 men into Moravia. The Allies had now +80,000 in camp, with the prospect of receiving heavy reinforcements. The +war, which lately seemed to be at its close, might now, in the hands of a +skilful general, be but beginning. Although the lines of Napoleon's +communication with France were well guarded, his position in the heart of +Europe exposed him to many perils; the Archduke Charles had defeated +Massena at Caldiero on the Adige, and was hastening northwards; above all, +the army of Prussia was preparing to enter the field. Every mile that +Napoleon advanced into Moravia increased the strain upon his resources; +every day that postponed the decision of the campaign brought new strength +to his enemies. Merely to keep the French in their camp until a Prussian +force was ready to assail their communications seemed enough to ensure the +Allies victory; and such was the counsel of Kutusoff, who made war in the +temper of the wariest diplomatist. But the scarcity of provisions was +telling upon the discipline of the army, and the Czar was eager for battle. +[117] The Emperor Francis gave way to the ardour of his allies. Weyrother, +the Austrian chief of the staff, drew up the most scientific plans for a +great victory that had ever been seen even at the Austrian head-quarters; +and towards the end of November it was agreed by the two Emperors that the +allied army should march right round Napoleon's position near Bruenn, and +fight a battle with the object of cutting off his retreat upon Vienna. + +[Haugwitz comes with Prussian demands to Napoleon, Nov. 28.] + +[Haugwitz goes away to Vienna.] + +It was in the days immediately preceding the intended battle, and after +Napoleon had divined the plans of his enemy, that Count Haugwitz, bearing +the demands of the Cabinet of Berlin, reached the French camp at Bruenn. +[118] Napoleon had already heard something of the Treaty of Potsdam, and +was aware that Haugwitz had started from Berlin. He had no intention of +making any of those concessions which Prussia required; at the same time it +was of vital importance to him to avoid the issue of a declaration of war +by Prussia, which would nerve both Austria and Russia to the last +extremities. He therefore resolved to prevent Haugwitz by every possible +method from delivering his ultimatum, until a decisive victory over the +allied armies should have entirely changed the political situation. The +Prussian envoy himself played into Napoleon's hands. Haugwitz had obtained +a disgraceful permission from his sovereign to submit to all Napoleon's +wishes, if, before his arrival, Austria should be separately treating for +peace; and he had an excuse for delay in the fact that the military +preparations of Prussia were not capable of being completed before the +middle of December. He passed twelve days on the journey from Berlin, and +presented himself before Napoleon on the 28th of November. The Emperor, +after a long conversation, requested that he would proceed to Vienna and +transact business with Talleyrand. He was weak enough to permit himself to +be removed to a distance with his ultimatum to Napoleon undelivered. When +next the Prussian Government heard of their envoy, he was sauntering in +Talleyrand's drawing-rooms at Vienna, with the cordon of the French Legion +of Honour on his breast, exchanging civilities with officials who politely +declined to enter upon any question of business. + +[Austerlitz, Dec. 2.] + +[Armistice, Dec. 4.] + +Haugwitz once removed to Vienna, and the Allies thus deprived of the +certainty that Prussia would take the field, Napoleon trusted that a single +great defeat would suffice to break up the Coalition. The movements of the +Allies were exactly those which he expected and desired. He chose his own +positions between Bruenn and Austerlitz in the full confidence of victory; +and on the morning of the 2nd of December, when the mists disappeared +before a bright wintry sun, he saw with the utmost delight that the Russian +columns were moving round him in a vast arc, in execution of the +turning-movement of which he had forewarned his own army on the day before. +Napoleon waited until the foremost columns were stretched far in advance of +their supports; then, throwing Soult's division upon the gap left in the +centre of the allied line, he cut the army into halves, and crushed its +severed divisions at every point along the whole line of attack. The +Allies, although they outnumbered Napoleon, believed themselves to be +overpowered by an army double their own size. The incoherence of the allied +movements was as marked as the unity and effectiveness of those of the +French. It was alleged in the army that Kutusoff, the commander-in-chief, +had fallen asleep while the Austrian Weyrother was expounding his plans for +the battle; a truer explanation of the palpable errors in the allied +generalship was that the Russian commander had been forced by the Czar to +carry out a plan of which he disapproved. The destruction in the ranks of +the Allies was enormous, for the Russians fought with the same obstinacy as +at the Trebbia and at Novi. Austria had lost a second army in addition to +its capital; and the one condition which could have steeled its Government +against all thoughts of peace--the certainty of an immediate Prussian +attack upon Napoleon--had vanished with the silent disappearance of the +Prussian envoy. Two days after the battle, the Emperor Francis met his +conqueror in the open field, and accepted an armistice, which involved the +withdrawal of the Russian army from his dominions. + +[Haugwitz signs Treaty with Napoleon, Dec. 15.] + +Yet even now the Czar sent appeals to Berlin for help, and the negotiation +begun by Austria would possibly have been broken off if help had been +given. But the Cabinet of Frederick William had itself determined to evade +its engagements; and as soon as the news of Austerlitz reached Vienna, +Haugwitz had gone over heart and soul to the conqueror. While negotiations +for peace were carried on between France and Austria, a parallel +negotiation was carried on with the envoy of Prussia; and even before the +Emperor Francis gave way to the conqueror's demands, Haugwitz signed a +treaty with Napoleon at Schoenbrunn, by which Prussia, instead of attacking +Napoleon, entered into an alliance with him, and received from him in +return the dominion of Hanover (December 15, 1805). [119] Had Prussia been +the defeated power at Austerlitz, the Treaty of Schoenbrunn could not have +more completely reversed the policy to which King Frederick William had +pledged himself six weeks before. While Haugwitz was making his pact with +Napoleon, Hardenberg had been arranging with an English envoy for the +combination of English and Russian forces in Northern Germany. [120] + +There were some among the King's advisers who declared that the treaty must +be repudiated, and the envoy disgraced. But the catastrophe of Austerlitz, +and the knowledge that the Government of Vienna was entering upon a +separate negotiation, had damped the courage of the men in power. The +conduct of Haugwitz was first excused, then supported, then admired. The +Duke of Brunswick disgraced himself by representing to the French +Ambassador in Berlin that the whole course of Prussian policy since the +beginning of the campaign had been an elaborate piece of dissimulation in +the interest of France. The leaders of the patriotic party in the army +found themselves without influence or following; the mass of the nation +looked on with the same stupid unconcern with which it had viewed every +event of the last twenty years. The King finally decided that the treaty by +which Haugwitz had thrown the obligations of his country to the winds +should be ratified, with certain modifications, including one that should +nominally reserve to King George III. a voice in the disposal of Hanover. +[121] + +[Treaty of Presburg, Dec. 27.] + +[End of the Holy Roman Empire, Aug. 6, 1806.] + +Ten days after the departure of the Prussian envoy from Vienna, peace was +concluded between France and Austria by the Treaty of Presburg [122] +(December 27). At the outbreak of the war Napoleon had declared to his army +that he would not again spare Austria, as he had spared her at Campo Formio +and at Luneville; and he kept his word. The Peace of Presburg left the +Austrian State in a condition very different from that in which it had +emerged from the two previous wars. The Treaty of Campo Formio had only +deprived Austria of Belgium in order to replace it by Venice; the +Settlement of Luneville had only substituted French for Austrian influence +in Western Germany: the Treaty that followed the battle of Austerlitz +wrested from the House of Hapsburg two of its most important provinces, and +cut it off at once from Italy, from Switzerland, and from the Rhine. +Venetia was ceded to Napoleon's kingdom of Italy; the Tyrol was ceded to +Bavaria; the outlying districts belonging to Austria in Western Germany +were ceded to Baden and to Wuertemberg. Austria lost 28,000 square miles of +territory and 3,000,000 inhabitants. The Emperor recognised the sovereignty +and independence of Bavaria, Baden, and Wuertemberg, and renounced all +rights over those countries as head of the Germanic Body. The Electors of +Bavaria and Wuertemberg, along with a large increase of territory, received +the title of King. The constitution of the Empire ceased to exist even in +name. It only remained for its chief, the successor of the Roman Caesars, to +abandon his title at Napoleon's bidding; and on the 6th of August, 1806, an +Act, published by Francis II. at Vienna, made an end of the outworn and +dishonoured fiction of a Holy Roman Empire. + +[Naples given to Joseph Bonaparte.] + +Though Russia had not made peace with Napoleon, the European Coalition was +at an end. Now, as in 1801, the defeat of the Austrian armies left the +Neapolitan Monarchy to settle its account with the conqueror. Naples had +struck no blow; but it was only through the delays of the Allies that the +Neapolitan army had not united with an English and a Russian force in an +attack upon Lombardy. What had been pardoned in 1801 was now avenged upon +the Bourbon despot of Naples and his Austrian Queen, who from the first had +shown such bitter enmity to France. Assuming the character of a judge over +the sovereigns of Europe, Napoleon pronounced from Vienna that the House of +Naples had ceased to reign (Dec. 27, 1805). The sentence was immediately +carried into execution. Ferdinand fled, as he had fled in 1798, to place +himself under the protection of the navy of Great Britain. The vacant +throne was given by Napoleon to his own brother, Joseph Bonaparte. +Ferdinand, with the help of the English fleet, maintained himself in +Sicily. A thread of sea two miles broad was sufficient barrier against the +Power which had subdued half the Continent; and no attempt was made either +by Napoleon or his brother to gain a footing beyond the Straits of Messina. +In Southern Italy the same fanatical movements took place among the +peasantry as in the previous period of French occupation. When the armies +of Austria and Russia were crushed, and the continent lay at the mercy of +France, Great Britain imagined that it could effect something against +Napoleon in a corner of Italy, with the help of some ferocious villagers. A +British force, landing near Maida, on the Calabrian coast, in the summer of +1806, had the satisfaction of defeating the French at the point of the +bayonet, of exciting a horde of priests and brigands to fruitless +barbarities, and of abandoning them to their well-merited chastisement. + +[Battle of Maida, July 6, 1806.] + +[The Empire. Napoleonic dynasty and titles.] + +The elevation of Napoleon's brother Joseph to the throne of Naples was the +first of a series of appointments now made by Napoleon in the character of +Emperor of the West. He began to style himself the new Charlemagne; his +thoughts and his language were filled with pictures of universal +sovereignty; his authority, as a military despot who had crushed his +neighbours, became strangely confused in his own mind with that half-sacred +right of the Caesars from which the Middle Ages derived all subordinate +forms of power. He began to treat the government of the different countries +of Western Europe as a function to be exercised by delegation from himself. +Even the territorial grants which under the Feudal System accompanied +military or civil office were now revived and the commander of a French +army-corps or the chief of the French Foreign Office became the titular +lord of some obscure Italian principality. [123] Napoleon's own family were +to reign in many lands, as the Bourbons and the Hapsburgs had reigned +before them, but in strict dependence on their head. Joseph Bonaparte had +not long been installed at Naples when his brother Louis was compelled to +accept the Crown of Holland. Jerome, for whom no kingdom was at present +vacant, was forced to renounce his American wife, in order that he might +marry the daughter of the King of Wuertemberg. Eugene Beauharnais, +Napoleon's step-son, held the office of Viceroy of Italy; Murat, who had +married Napoleon's sister, had the German Duchy of Berg. Bernadotte, +Talleyrand, and Berthier found themselves suzerains of districts whose +names were almost unknown to them. Out of the revenues of Northern Italy a +yearly sum was reserved as an endowment for the generals whom the Emperor +chose to raise to princely honours. + +[Federation of the Rhine.] + +More statesmanlike, more practical than Napoleon's dynastic policy, was his +organisation of Western Germany under its native princes as a dependency of +France. The object at which all French politicians had aimed since the +outbreak of the Revolutionary War, the exclusion of both Austria and +Prussia from influence in Western Germany, was now completely attained. The +triumph of French statesmanship, the consummation of two centuries of +German discord, was seen in the Act of Federation subscribed by the Western +German Sovereigns in the summer of 1806. By this Act the Kings of Bavaria +and Wuertemberg, the Elector of Baden, and thirteen minor princes, united +themselves, in the League known as the Rhenish Confederacy, under the +protection of the French Emperor, and undertook to furnish contingents, +amounting to 63,000 men, in all wars in which the French Empire should +engage. Their connection with the ancient Germanic Body was completely +severed; the very town in which the Diet of the Empire had held its +meetings was annexed by one of the members of the Confederacy. The +Confederacy itself, with a population of 8,000,000, became for all purposes +of war and foreign policy a part of France. Its armies were organised by +French officers; its frontiers were fortified by French engineers; its +treaties were made for it at Paris. In the domestic changes which took +place within these States the work of consolidation begun in 1801 was +carried forward with increased vigour. Scores of tiny principalities which +had escaped dissolution in the earlier movement were now absorbed by their +stronger neighbours. Governments became more energetic, more orderly, more +ambitious. The princes who made themselves the vassals of Napoleon assumed +a more despotic power over their own subjects. Old constitutional forms +which had imposed some check on the will of the sovereign, like the Estates +of Wuertemberg, were contemptuously suppressed; the careless, ineffective +routine of the last age gave place to a system of rigorous precision +throughout the public services. Military service was enforced in countries +hitherto free from it. The burdens of the people became greater, but they +were more fairly distributed. The taxes were more equally levied; justice +was made more regular and more simple. A career both in the army and the +offices of Government was opened to a people to whom the very conception of +public life had hitherto been unknown. + +[No national unity in Germany.] + +The establishment of German unity in our own day after a victorious +struggle with France renders it difficult to imagine the voluntary +submission of a great part of the race to a French sovereign, or to excuse +a policy which, like that of 1806, appears the opposite of everything +honourable and patriotic. But what seems strange now was not strange then. +No expression more truly describes the conditions of that period than one +of the great German poet who was himself so little of a patriot. "Germany," +said Goethe, "is not a nation." Germany had indeed the unity of race; but +all that truly constitutes a nation, the sense of common interest, a common +history, pride, and desire, Germany did not possess at all. Bavaria, the +strongest of the western States, attached itself to France from a +well-grounded fear of Austrian aggression. To be conquered by Austria was +just as much conquest for Bavaria as to be conquered by any other Power; it +was no step to German unity, but a step in the aggrandisement of the House +of Hapsburg. The interests of the Austrian House were not the interests of +Germany any more than they were the interests of Croatia, or of Venice, or +of Hungary. Nor, on the other hand, had Prussia yet shown a form of +political life sufficiently attractive to lead the southern States to +desire to unite with it. Frederick's genius had indeed made him the hero of +Germany, but his military system was harsh and tyrannical. In the actual +condition of Austria and Prussia, it is doubtful whether the population of +the minor States would have been happier united to these Powers than under +their own Governments. Conquest in any case was impossible, and there was +nothing to stimulate to voluntary union. It followed that the smaller +States were destined to remain without a nationality, until the violence of +some foreign Power rendered weakness an intolerable evil, and forced upon +the better minds of Germany the thought of a common Fatherland. + +[What German unity desirable.] + +The necessity of German unity is no self-evident political truth. Holland +and Switzerland in past centuries detached themselves from the Empire, and +became independent States, with the highest advantage to themselves. +Identity of blood is no more conclusive reason for political union between +Holstein and the Tyrol than between Great Britain and the United States of +America. The conditions which determine both the true area and the true +quality of German unity are, in fact, something more complex than an +ethnological law or an outburst of patriotic indignation against the +French. Where local circumstances rendered it possible for a German +district, after detaching itself from the race, to maintain a real national +life and defend itself from foreign conquest, there it was perhaps better +that the connection with Germany should be severed; where, as in the great +majority of minor States, independence resulted only in military +helplessness and internal stagnation, there it was better that independence +should give place to German unity. But the conditions of any tolerable +unity were not present so long as Austria was the leading Power. Less was +imperilled in the future of the German people by the submission of the +western States to France than would have been lost by their permanent +incorporation under Austria. + +[The Empire of 1806 might have been permanent.] + +[Limits of a possible Napoleonic Empire.] + +With the establishment of the Rhenish Confederacy and the conquest of +Naples, Napoleon's empire reached, but did not overpass, the limits within +which the sovereignty of France might probably have been long maintained. +It has been usual to draw the line between the sound statesmanship and the +hazardous enterprises of Napoleon at the Peace of Luneville: a juster +appreciation of the condition of Western Europe would perhaps include +within the range of a practical, though mischievous, ideal the whole of the +political changes which immediately followed the war of 1805, and which +extended Napoleon's dominion to the Inn and to the Straits of Messina. +Italy and Germany were not then what they have since become. The districts +that lay between the Rhine and the Inn were not more hostile to the +foreigner than those Rhenish Provinces which so readily accepted their +union with France. The more enterprising minds in Italy found that the +Napoleonic rule, with all its faults, was superior to anything that Italy +had known in recent times. If we may judge from the feeling with which +Napoleon was regarded in Germany down to the middle of the year 1806, and +in Italy down to a much later date, the Empire then founded might have been +permanently upheld, if Napoleon had abstained from attacking other States. +No comparison can be made between the attractive power exercised by the +social equality of France, its military glory, and its good administration, +and the slow and feeble process of assimilation which went on within the +dominions of Austria; yet Austria succeeded in uniting a greater variety of +races than France sought to unite in 1806. The limits of a possible France +were indeed fixed, and fixed more firmly than by any geographical line, in +the history and national character of two other peoples. France could not +permanently overpower Prussia, and it could not permanently overpower +Spain. But within a boundary-line drawn roughly from the mouth of the Elbe +to the head of the Adriatic, that union of national sentiment and material +force which checks the formation of empires did not exist. The true +turning-point in Napoleon's career was the moment when he passed beyond the +policy which had planned the Federation of the Rhine, and roused by his +oppression the one State which was still capable of giving a national life +to Germany. + + + + +CHAPTER VII. + + +Death of Pitt--Ministry of Fox and Grenville--Napoleon forces Prussia into +War with England, and then offers Hanover to England--Prussia resolves on +War with Napoleon--State of Prussia--Decline of the Army--Southern Germany +with Napoleon--Austria Neutral--England and Russia about to help Prussia, +but not immediately--Campaign of 1806--Battles of Jena and Auerstaedt--Ruin +of the Prussian Army--Capitulation of Fortresses--Demands of Napoleon--The +War continues--Berlin Decree--Exclusion of English Goods from the +Continent--Russia enters the War--Campaign in Poland and East +Prussia--Eylau--Treaty of Bartenstein--Friedland--Interview at +Tilsit--Alliance of Napoleon and Alexander--Secret Articles--English +Expedition to Denmark--The French enter Portugal--Prussia after the Peace +of Tilsit--Stein's Edict of Emancipation--The Prussian Peasant--Reform of +the Prussian Army, and Creation of Municipalities--Stein's other Projects +of Reform, which are not carried out. + + +[Death of Pitt, Jan. 23rd, 1806.] + +[Coalition Ministry of Fox and Grenville.] + +Six weeks after the tidings of Austerlitz reached Great Britain, the +statesman who had been the soul of every European coalition against France +was carried to the grave. [124] Pitt passed away at a moment of the deepest +gloom. His victories at sea appeared to have effected nothing; his +combinations on land had ended in disaster and ruin. If during Pitt's +lifetime a just sense of the greatness and patriotism of all his aims +condoned the innumerable faults of his military administration, that +personal ascendancy which might have disarmed criticism even after the +disaster of Austerlitz belonged to no other member of his Ministry. His +colleagues felt their position to be hopeless. Though the King attempted to +set one of Pitt's subordinates in the vacant place, the prospects of Europe +were too dark, the situation of the country too serious, to allow a +Ministry to be formed upon the ordinary principles of party-organisation or +in accordance with the personal preferences of the monarch. The nation +called for the union of the ablest men of all parties in the work of +government; and, in spite of the life-long hatred of King George to Mr. +Fox, a Ministry entered upon office framed by Fox and Grenville conjointly; +Fox taking the post of Foreign Secretary, with a leading influence in the +Cabinet, and yielding to Grenville the title of Premier. Addington received +a place in the Ministry, and carried with him the support of a section of +the Tory party, which was willing to countenance a policy of peace. + +[Napoleon hopes to intimidate Fox through Prussia.] + +Fox had from the first given his whole sympathy to the French Revolution, +as the cause of freedom. He had ascribed the calamities of Europe to the +intervention of foreign Powers in favour of the Bourbon monarchy: he had +palliated the aggressions of the French Republic as the consequences of +unjust and unprovoked attack: even the extinction of liberty in France +itself had not wholly destroyed his faith in the honour and the generosity +of the soldier of the Revolution. In the brief interval of peace which in +1802 opened the Continent to English travellers, Fox had been the guest of +the First Consul. His personal feeling towards the French Government had in +it nothing of that proud and suspicious hatred which made negotiation so +difficult while Pitt continued in power. It was believed at Paris, and with +good reason, that the first object of Fox on entering upon office would be +the restoration of peace. Napoleon adopted his own plan in view of the +change likely to arise in the spirit of the British Cabinet. It was his +habit, wherever he saw signs of concession, to apply more violent means of +intimidation. In the present instance he determined to work upon the +pacific leanings of Fox by adding Prussia to the forces arrayed against +Great Britain. Prussia, isolated and discredited since the battle of +Austerlitz, might first be driven into hostilities with England, and then +be made to furnish the very satisfaction demanded by England as the primary +condition of peace. + +[The King of Prussia wishes to disguise the cession of Hanover.] + +[Napoleon forces Prussia into war with England, March, 1806.] + +At the moment when Napoleon heard of Pitt's death, he was expecting the +arrival of Count Haugwitz at Paris for the purpose of obtaining some +modification in the treaty which he had signed on behalf of Prussia after +the battle of Austerlitz. The principal feature in that treaty had been the +grant of Hanover to Prussia by the French Emperor in return for its +alliance. This was the point which above all others excited King Frederick +William's fears and scruples. He desired to retain Hanover, but he also +desired to derive his title rather from its English owner than from its +French invader. It was the object of Haugwitz' visit to Paris to obtain an +alteration in the terms of the treaty which should make the Prussian +occupation of Hanover appear to be merely provisional, and reserve to the +King of England at least a nominal voice in its ultimate transfer. In full +confidence that Napoleon would agree to such a change, the King of Prussia +had concealed the fact of its cession to himself by Napoleon, and published +an untruthful proclamation, stating that, in the interests of the +Hanoverian people themselves, a treaty had been signed and ratified by the +French and Prussian Governments, in virtue of which Hanover was placed +under the protection of the King of Prussia until peace should be concluded +between Great Britain and France. The British Government received +assurances of Prussia's respect for the rights of King George III.: the +bitter truth that the treaty between France and Prussia contained no single +word reserving the rights of the Elector, and that the very idea of +qualifying the absolute cession of Hanover was an afterthought, lay hidden +in the conscience of the Prussian Cabinet. Never had a Government more +completely placed itself at the mercy of a pitiless enemy. Count Haugwitz, +on reaching Paris, was received by Napoleon with a storm of invective +against the supposed partisans of England at the Prussian Court. Napoleon +declared that the ill faith of Prussia had made an end even of that +miserable pact which had been extorted after Austerlitz, and insisted that +King Frederick William should openly defy Great Britain by closing the +ports of Northern Germany to British vessels, and by declaring himself +endowed by Napoleon with Hanover in virtue of Napoleon's own right of +conquest. Haugwitz signed a second and more humiliating treaty embodying +these conditions; and the Prussian Government, now brought into the depths +of contempt, but unready for immediate war, executed the orders of its +master. [125] A proclamation, stating that Prussia had received the +absolute dominion of Hanover from its conqueror Napoleon, gave the lie to +the earlier announcements of King Frederick William. A decree was published +excluding the ships of England from the ports of Prussia and from those of +Hanover itself (March 28, 1806). It was promptly answered by the seizure of +four hundred Prussian vessels in British harbours, and by the total +extinction of Prussian maritime commerce by British privateers. [126] + +[Napoleon negotiates with Fox. Offers Hanover to England.] + +Scarcely was Prussia committed to this ruinous conflict with Great Britain, +when Napoleon opened negotiations for peace with Mr. Fox's Government. The +first condition required by Great Britain was the restitution of Hanover to +King George III. It was unhesitatingly granted by Napoleon. [127] Thus was +Prussia to be mocked of its prey, after it had been robbed of all its +honour. For the present, however, no rumour of this part of the negotiation +reached Berlin. The negotiation itself, which dragged on through several +months, turned chiefly upon the future ownership of Sicily. Napoleon had in +the first instance agreed that Sicily should be left in the hands of +Ferdinand of Naples, who had never been expelled from it by the French. +Finding, however, that the Russian envoy d'Oubril, who had been sent to +Paris with indefinite instructions by the Emperor Alexander, was willing to +separate the cause of Russia from that of England, and to sign a separate +peace, Napoleon retracted his promise relating to Sicily, and demanded that +this island should be ceded to his brother Joseph. D'Oubril signed +Preliminaries on behalf of Russia on the 20th of July, and left the English +negotiator to obtain what terms he could. Fox had been willing to recognise +the order of things established by Napoleon on the Italian mainland; he +would even have ceded Sicily, if Russia had urged this in a joint +negotiation; but he was too good a statesman to be cheated out of Sicily by +a mere trick. He recalled the English envoy from Paris, and waited for the +judgment of the Czar upon the conduct of his own representative. The Czar +disavowed d'Oubril's negotiations, and repudiated the treaty which he +brought back to St. Petersburg. Napoleon had thus completely overreached +himself, and, instead of severing Great Britain and Russia by separate +agreements, had only irritated and displeased them both. The negotiations +went no further; their importance lay only in the effect which they +produced upon Prussia, when Napoleon's offer of Hanover to Great Britain +became known at Berlin. + +[Prussia learns of Napoleon's offer of Hanover to England, Aug. 7.] + +[Prussia determines on war.] + +From the time when Haugwitz' second treaty placed his master at Napoleon's +feet, Prussia had been subjected to an unbroken series of insults and +wrongs. Murat, as Duke of Berg, had seized upon territory allotted to +Prussia in the distribution of the ecclesiastical lands; the establishment +of a North German Confederacy under Prussian leadership was suggested by +Napoleon himself, only to be summarily forbidden as soon as Prussia +attempted to carry the proposal into execution. There was scarcely a +courtier in Berlin who did not feel that the yoke of the French had become +past endurance; even Haugwitz himself now considered war as a question of +time. The patriotic party in the capital and the younger officers of the +army bitterly denounced the dishonoured Government, and urged the King to +strike for the credit of his country. [128] In the midst of this deepening +agitation, a despatch arrived from Lucchesini, the Prussian Ambassador at +Paris (August 7), relating the offer of Hanover made by Napoleon to the +British Government. For nearly three months Lucchesini had caught no +glimpse of the negotiations between Great Britain and France; suddenly, on +entering into conversation with the English envoy at a dinner-party, he +learnt the blow which Napoleon had intended to deal to Prussia. Lucchesini +instantly communicated with the Court of Berlin; but his despatch was +opened by Talleyrand's agents before it left Paris, and the French +Government was thus placed on its guard against the sudden explosion of +Prussian wrath. Lucchesini's despatch had indeed all the importance that +Talleyrand attributed to it. It brought that spasmodic access of resolution +to the irresolute King which Bernadotte's violation of his territory had +brought in the year before. The whole Prussian army was ordered to prepare +for war; Brunswick was summoned to form plans of a campaign; and appeals +for help were sent to Vienna, to St. Petersburg, and even to the hostile +Court of London. + +[Condition of Prussia.] + +[Ministers not in the King's Cabinet.] + +The condition of Prussia at this critical moment was one which filled with +the deepest alarm those few patriotic statesmen who were not blinded by +national vanity or by slavery to routine. The foreign policy of Prussia in +1805, miserable as it was, had been but a single manifestation of the +helplessness, the moral deadness that ran through every part of its +official and public life. Early in the year 1806 a paper was drawn up by +Stein, [129] exposing, in language seldom used by a statesman, the +character of the men by whom Frederick William was surrounded, and +declaring that nothing but a speedy change of system could save the +Prussian State from utter downfall and ruin. Two measures of immediate +necessity were specified by Stein, the establishment of a responsible +council of Ministers, and the removal of Haugwitz and all his friends from +power. In the existing system of government the Ministers were not the +monarch's confidential advisers. The Ministers performed their work in +isolation from one another; the Cabinet, or confidential council of the +King, was composed of persons holding no public function, and free from all +public responsibility. No guarantee existed that the policy of the country +would be the same for two days together. The Ministers were often unaware +of the turn that affairs had taken in the Cabinet; and the history of +Haugwitz' mission to Austerlitz showed that an individual might commit the +State to engagements the very opposite of those which he was sent to +contract. The first necessity for Prussia was a responsible governing +council: with such a council, formed from the heads of the actual +Administration, the reform of the army and of the other branches of the +public service, which was absolutely hopeless under the present system, +might be attended with some chance of success. + +[State of the Prussian Army.] + +[Higher officers.] + +The army of Prussia, at an epoch when the conscription and the genius of +Napoleon had revolutionised the art of war, was nothing but the army of +Frederick the Great grown twenty years older. [130] It was obvious to all +the world that its commissariat and marching-regulations belonged to a time +when weeks were allowed for movements now reckoned by days; but there were +circumstances less conspicuous from the outside which had paralysed the +very spirit of soldiership, and prepared the way for a military collapse in +which defeats in the field were the least dishonourable event. Old age had +rendered the majority of the higher officers totally unfit for military +service. In that barrack-like routine of officialism which passed in +Prussia for the wisdom of government, the upper ranks of the army formed a +species of administrative corps in time of peace, and received for their +civil employment double the pay that they could earn in actual war. Aged +men, with the rank of majors, colonels, and generals, mouldered in the +offices of country towns, and murmured at the very mention of a war, which +would deprive them of half their salaries. Except in the case of certain +princes, who were placed in high rank while young, and of a few vigorous +patriarchs like Bluecher, all the energy and military spirit of the army was +to be found in men who had not passed the grade of captain. The higher +officers were, on an average, nearly double the age of French officers of +corresponding rank. [131] Of the twenty-four lieutenant-generals, eighteen +were over sixty; the younger ones, with a single exception, were princes. +Five out of the seven commanders of infantry were over seventy; even the +sixteen cavalry generals included only two who had not reached sixty-five. +These were the men who, when the armies of Prussia were beaten in the +field, surrendered its fortresses with as little concern as if they had +been receiving the French on a visit of ceremony. Their vanity was as +lamentable as their faint-heartedness. "The army of his Majesty," said +General Ruechel on parade, "possesses several generals equal to Bonaparte." +Faults of another character belonged to the generation which had grown up +since Frederick. The arrogance and licentiousness of the younger officers +was such that their ruin on the field of Jena caused positive joy to a +great part of the middle classes of Prussia. But, however hateful their +manners, and however rash their self-confidence, the vices of these younger +men had no direct connection with the disasters of 1806. The gallants who +sharpened their swords on the window-sill of the French Ambassador received +a bitter lesson from the plebeian troopers of Murat; but they showed +courage in disaster, and subsequently gave to their country many officers +of ability and honour. + +[Common soldiers.] + +What was bad in the higher grades of the army was not retrieved by any +excellence on the part of the private soldier. The Prussian army was +recruited in part from foreigners, but chiefly from Prussian serfs, who +were compelled to serve. Men remained with their regiments till old age; +the rough character of the soldiers and the frequency of crimes and +desertions occasioned the use of brutal punishments, which made the +military service an object of horror to the better part of the middle and +lower classes. The soldiers themselves, who could be flogged and drilled +into high military perfection by a great general like Frederick, felt a +surly indifference to their present taskmasters, and were ready to desert +in masses to their homes as soon as a defeat broke up the regimental muster +and roll-call. A proposal made in the previous year to introduce that +system of general service which has since made Prussia so great a military +power was rejected by a committee of generals, on the ground that it "would +convert the most formidable army of Europe into a militia." But whether +Prussia entered the war with a militia or a regular army, under the men who +held command in 1806 it could have met with but one fate. Neither soldiery +nor fortresses could have saved a kingdom whose generals knew only how to +capitulate. + +[Southern Germany. Execution of Palm, Aug. 26.] + +All southern Germany was still in Napoleon's hands. As the probability of a +war with Prussia became greater and greater, Napoleon had tightened his +grasp upon the Confederate States. Publications originating among the +patriotic circles of Austria were beginning to appeal to the German people +to unite against a foreign oppressor. An anonymous pamphlet, entitled +"Germany in its Deep Humiliation," was sold by various booksellers in +Bavaria, among others by Palm, a citizen of Nuremberg. There is no evidence +that Palm was even acquainted with the contents of the pamphlet; but as in +the case of the Duke of Enghien, two years before, Napoleon had required a +victim to terrify the House of Bourbon, so now he required a victim to +terrify those who among the German people might be inclined to listen to +the call of patriotism. Palm was not too obscure for the new Charlemagne. +The innocent and unoffending man, innocent even of the honourable crime of +attempting to save his country, was dragged before a tribunal of French +soldiers, and executed within twenty-four hours, in pursuance of the +imperative orders of Napoleon (August 26). The murder was an unnecessary +one, for the Bavarians and the Wuertembergers were in fact content with the +yoke they bore; its only effect was to arouse among a patient and +home-loving class the doubt whether the German citizen and his family might +not after all have some interest in the preservation of national +independence. + +[Austria neutral. England and Russia can give Prussia no prompt help.] + +When, several years later, the oppressions of Napoleon had given to a great +part of the German race at least the transient nobleness of a real +patriotism, the story of Palm's death was one of those that kindled the +bitterest sense of wrong: at the time, it exercised no influence upon the +course of political events. Southern Germany remained passive, and supplied +Napoleon with a reserve of soldiers: Prussia had to look elsewhere for +allies. Its prospects of receiving support were good, if the war should +prove a protracted one, but not otherwise. Austria, crippled by the +disasters of 1805, could only hope to renew the struggle if victory should +declare against Napoleon. In other quarters help might be promised, but it +could not be given at the time and at the place where it was needed. The +Czar proffered the whole forces of his Empire; King George III. forgave the +despoilers of his patrimony when he found that they really intended to +fight the French; but the troops of Alexander lay far in the East, and the +action of England in any Continental war was certain to be dilatory and +ineffective. Prussia was exposed to the first shock of the war alone. In +the existing situation of the French armies, a blow unusually swift and +crushing might well be expected by all who understood Napoleon's warfare. + +[Situation of the French and Prussian armies, Sept., 1806.] + +[French on the Main.] + +[Prussians on the Saale.] + +A hundred and seventy thousand French soldiers, with contingents from the +Rhenish Confederate States, lay between the Main and the Inn. The last +weeks of peace, in which the Prussian Government imagined themselves to be +deceiving the enemy while they pushed forward their own preparations, were +employed by Napoleon in quietly concentrating this vast force upon the Main +(September, 1806). Napoleon himself appeared to be absorbed in friendly +negotiations with General Knobelsdorff, the new Prussian Ambassador at +Paris. In order to lull Napoleon's suspicions, Haugwitz had recalled +Lucchesini from Paris, and intentionally deceived his successor as to the +real designs of the Prussian Cabinet. Knobelsdorff confidentially informed +the Emperor that Prussia was not serious in its preparations for war. +Napoleon, caring very little whether Prussia intended to fight or not, +continued at Paris in the appearance of the greatest calm, while his +lieutenants in Southern Germany executed those unobserved movements which +were to collect the entire army upon the Upper Main. In the meantime the +advisers of King Frederick William supposed themselves to have made +everything ready for a vigorous offensive. Divisions of the Prussian army, +numbering nearly 130,000 men, were concentrated in the neighbourhood of +Jena, on the Saale. The bolder spirits in the military council pressed for +an immediate advance through the Thuringian Forest, and for an attack upon +what were supposed to be the scattered detachments of the French in +Bavaria. Military pride and all the traditions of the Great Frederick +impelled Prussia to take the offensive rather than to wait for the enemy +upon the strong line of the Elbe. Political motives pointed in the same +direction, for the support of Saxony was doubtful if once the French were +permitted to approach Dresden. + +[Confusion of the Prussians.] + +On the 23rd of September King Frederick William arrived at the +head-quarters of the army, which were now at Naumburg, on the Saale. But +his presence brought no controlling mind to the direction of affairs. +Councils of war held on the two succeeding days only revealed the discord +and the irresolution of the military leaders of Prussia. Brunswick, the +commander-in-chief, sketched the boldest plans, and shrank from the +responsibility of executing them. Hohenlohe, who commanded the left wing, +lost no opportunity of opposing his superior; the suggestions of officers +of real ability, like Scharnhorst, chief of the staff, fell unnoticed among +the wrangling of pedants and partisans. Brunswick, himself a man of great +intelligence though of little resolution, saw the true quality of the men +who surrounded him. "Ruechel," he cried, "is a tin trumpet, Moellendorf a +dotard, Kalkreuth a cunning trickster. The generals of division are a set +of stupid journeymen. Are these the people with whom one can make war on +Napoleon? No. The best service that I could render to the King would be to +persuade him to keep the peace." [132] It was ultimately decided, after two +days of argument, that the army should advance through the Thuringian +Forest, while feints on the right and left deceived the French as to its +real direction. The diplomatists, however, who were mad enough to think +that an ultimatum which they had just despatched to Paris would bring +Napoleon on to his knees, insisted that the opening of hostilities should +be deferred till the 8th of October, when the term of grace which they had +given to Napoleon would expire. + +[Prussians at Erfurt, Oct. 4.] + +A few days after this decision had been formed, intelligence arrived at +head-quarters that Napoleon himself was upon the Rhine. Before the +ultimatum reached the hands of General Knobelsdorff in Paris, Napoleon had +quitted the capital, and the astonished Ambassador could only send the +ultimatum in pursuit of him after he had gone to place himself at the head +of 200,000 men. The news that Napoleon was actually in Mainz confounded the +diplomatists in the Prussian camp, and produced an order for an immediate +advance. This was the wisest as well as the boldest determination that had +yet been formed; and an instant assault upon the French divisions on the +Main might perhaps even now have given the Prussian army the superiority in +the first encounter. But some fatal excuse was always at hand to justify +Brunswick in receding from his resolutions. A positive assurance was +brought into camp by Lucchesini that Napoleon had laid his plans for +remaining on the defensive on the south of the Thuringian Forest. If this +were true, there might yet be time to improve the plan of the campaign; and +on the 4th of October, when every hour was of priceless value, the forward +march was arrested, and a new series of deliberations began at the +head-quarters at Erfurt. In the council held on the 4th of October, a total +change in the plan of operations was urged by Hohenlohe's staff. They +contended, and rightly, that it was the design of Napoleon to pass the +Prussian army on the east by the valley of the Saale, and to cut it off +from the roads to the Elbe. The delay in Brunswick's movements had in fact +brought the French within striking distance of the Prussian communications. +Hohenlohe urged the King to draw back the army from Erfurt to the Saale, or +even to the east of it, in order to cover the roads to Leipzig and the +Elbe. His theory of Napoleon's movements, which was the correct one, was +adopted by the council, and the advance into the Thuringian Forest was +abandoned; but instead of immediately marching eastwards with the whole +army, the generals wasted two more days in hesitations and half-measures. +At length it was agreed that Hohenlohe should take post at Jena, and that +the mass of the army should fall back to Weimar, with the object of +striking a blow at some undetermined point on the line of Napoleon's +advance. + +[Encounter at Saalfeld, Oct. 10.] + +[Napoleon defeats Hohenlohe at Jena, Oct. 14.] + +[Davoust defeats Brunswick at Auerstaedt, Oct. 14.] + +[Ruin of the Prussian Army.] + +Napoleon, who had just received the Prussian ultimatum with unbounded +ridicule and contempt, was now moving along the roads that lead from +Bamberg and Baireuth to the Upper Saale. On the 10th of October, as the +division of Lannes was approaching Saalfeld, it was attacked by Prince +Louis Ferdinand at the head of Hohenlohe's advanced guard. The attack was +made against Hohenlohe's orders. It resulted in the total rout of the +Prussian force. Though the numbers engaged were small, the loss of +magazines and artillery, and the death of Prince Louis Ferdinand, the hero +of the war-party, gave to this first repulse the moral effect of a great +military disaster. Hohenlohe's troops at Jena were seized with panic; +numbers of men threw away their arms and dispersed; the drivers of +artillery-waggons and provision-carts cut the traces and rode off with +their horses. Brunswick, however, and the main body of the army, were now +at Weimar, close at hand; and if Brunswick had decided to fight a great +battle at Jena, the Prussians might have brought nearly 90,000 men into +action. But the plans of the irresolute commander were again changed. It +was resolved to fall back upon Magdeburg and the Elbe. Brunswick himself +moved northwards to Naumburg; Hohenlohe was ordered to hold the French in +check at Jena until this movement was completed. Napoleon reached Jena. He +had no intelligence of Brunswick's retreat, and imagined the mass of the +Prussian army to be gathered round Hohenlohe, on the plateau before him. He +sent Davoust, with a corps 27,000 strong, to outflank the enemy by a march +in the direction of Naumburg, and himself prepared to make the attack in +front with 90,000 men, a force more than double Hohenlohe's real army. The +attack was made on the 14th of October. Hohenlohe's army was dashed to +pieces by Napoleon, and fled in wild disorder. Davoust's weak corps, which +had not expected to meet with any important forces until it fell upon +Hohenlohe's flank, found itself in the presence of Brunswick's main army, +when it arrived at Auerstaedt, a few miles to the north. Fortune had given +to the Prussian commander an extraordinary chance of retrieving what +strategy had lost. A battle conducted with common military skill would not +only have destroyed Davoust, but have secured, at least for the larger +portion of the Prussian forces, a safe retreat to Leipzig or the Elbe. The +French general, availing himself of steep and broken ground, defeated +numbers nearly double his own through the confusion of his adversary, who +sent up detachment after detachment instead of throwing himself upon +Davoust with his entire strength. The fighting was as furious on the +Prussian side as its conduct was unskilful. King Frederick William, who led +the earlier cavalry charges, had two horses killed under him. Brunswick was +mortally wounded. Many of the other generals were killed or disabled. There +remained, however, a sufficient number of unbroken regiments to preserve +some order in the retreat until the army came into contact with the remnant +of Hohenlohe's forces, flying for their lives before the cavalry of Murat. +Then all hope was lost. The fugitive mass struck panic and confusion into +the retreating columns; and with the exception of a few regiments which +gathered round well-known leaders, the soldiers threw away their arms and +spread over the country in headlong rout. There was no line of retreat, and +no rallying-point. The disaster of a single day made an end of the Prussian +army as a force capable of meeting the enemy in the field. A great part of +the troops was captured by the pursuing enemy during the next few days. The +regiments which preserved their coherence were too weak to make any attempt +to check Napoleon's advance, and could only hope to save themselves by +escaping to the fortresses on the Oder. + +[Haugwitz and Lord Morpeth.] + +[Retreat and surrender of Hohenlohe.] + +Two days before the battle of Jena, an English envoy, Lord Morpeth, had +arrived at the head-quarters of the King of Prussia, claiming the +restoration of Hanover, and bearing an offer of the friendship and support +of Great Britain. At the moment when the Prussian monarchy was on the point +of being hurled to the ground, its Government might have been thought +likely to welcome any security that it should not be abandoned in its +utmost need. Haugwitz, however, was at head-quarters, dictating lying +bulletins, and perplexing the generals with ridiculous arguments of policy +until the French actually opened fire. When the English envoy made known +his arrival, he found that no one would transact business with him. +Haugwitz had determined to evade all negotiations until the battle had been +fought. He was unwilling to part with Hanover, and he hoped that a victory +over Napoleon would enable him to meet Lord Morpeth with a bolder +countenance on the following day. When that day arrived, Ministers and +diplomatists were flying headlong over the country. The King made his +escape to Weimar, and wrote to Napoleon, begging for an armistice; but the +armistice was refused, and the pursuit of the broken army was followed up +without a moment's pause. The capital offered no safe halting-place; and +Frederick William only rested when he had arrived at Graudenz, upon the +Vistula. Hohenlohe's poor remnant of an army passed the Elbe at Magdeburg, +and took the road for Stettin, at the mouth of the Oder, leaving Berlin to +its fate. The retreat was badly conducted; alternate halts and strained +marches discouraged the best of the soldiers. As the men passed their +native villages they abandoned the famishing and broken-spirited columns; +and at the end of a fortnight's disasters Prince Hohenlohe surrendered to +his pursuers at Prenzlau with his main body, now numbering only 10,000 men +(Oct. 28). + +[Bluecher at Luebeck.] + +Bluecher, who had shown the utmost energy and fortitude after the +catastrophe of Jena, was moving in the rear of Hohenlohe with a +considerable force which his courage had gathered around him. On learning +of Hohenlohe's capitulation, he instantly reversed his line of march, and +made for the Hanoverian fortress of Hameln, in order to continue the war in +the rear of the French. Overwhelming forces, however, cut off his retreat +to the Elbe; he was hemmed in on the east and on the west; and nothing +remained for him but to throw himself into the neutral town of Luebeck, and +fight until food and ammunition failed him. The French were at his heels. +The magistrates of Luebeck prayed that their city might not be made into a +battle-field, but in vain; Bluecher refused to move into the open country. +The town was stormed by the French, and put to the sack. Bluecher was driven +out, desperately fighting, and pent in between the Danish frontier and the +sea. Here, surrounded by overpowering numbers, without food, without +ammunition, he capitulated on the 7th of November, after his courage and +resolution had done everything that could ennoble both general and soldiers +in the midst of overwhelming calamity. + +[Napoleon at Berlin, Oct. 27.] + +[Capitulation of Prussian fortresses.] + +The honour of entering the Prussian capital was given by Napoleon to +Davoust, whose victory at Auerstaedt had in fact far surpassed his own. +Davoust entered Berlin without resistance on the 25th of October; Napoleon +himself went to Potsdam, and carried off the sword and the scarf that lay +upon the grave of Frederick the Great. Two days after Davoust, the Emperor +made his own triumphal entry into the capital. He assumed the part of the +protector of the people against the aristocracy, ordering the formation of +a municipal body and of a civic guard for the city of Berlin. The military +aristocracy he treated with the bitterest hatred and contempt. "I will make +that noblesse," he cried, "so poor that they shall beg their bread." The +disaster of Jena had indeed fearfully punished the insolence with which the +officers of the army had treated the rest of the nation. The Guards were +marched past the windows of the citizens of Berlin, a miserable troop of +captives; soldiers of rank who remained in the city had to attend upon the +French Emperor to receive his orders. But calamity was only beginning. The +overthrow of Jena had been caused by faults of generalship, and cast no +stain upon the courage of the officers; the surrender of the Prussian +fortresses, which began on the day when the French entered Berlin, attached +the utmost personal disgrace to their commanders. Even after the +destruction of the army in the field, Prussia's situation would not have +been hopeless if the commanders of fortresses had acted on the ordinary +rules of military duty. Magdeburg and the strongholds upon the Oder were +sufficiently armed and provisioned to detain the entire French army, and to +give time to the King to collect upon the Vistula a force as numerous as +that which he had lost. But whatever is weakest in human nature--old age, +fear, and credulity--seemed to have been placed at the head of Prussia's +defences. The very object for which fortresses exist was forgotten; and the +fact that one army had been beaten in the field was made a reason for +permitting the enemy to forestall the organisation of another. Spandau +surrendered on the 25th of October, Stettin on the 29th. These were places +of no great strength; but the next fortress to capitulate, Kuestrin on the +Oder, was in full order for a long siege. It was surrendered by the older +officers, amidst the curses of the subalterns and the common soldiers: the +artillerymen had to be dragged from their guns by force. Magdeburg, with a +garrison of 24,000 men and enormous supplies, fell before a French force +not numerous enough to beleaguer it (Nov. 8). + +[Napoleon's demands.] + +Neither Napoleon himself nor any one else in Europe could have foreseen +such conduct on the part of the Prussian commanders. The unexpected series +of capitulations made him demand totally different terms of peace from +those which he had offered after the battle of Jena. A week after the +victory, Napoleon had demanded, as the price of peace, the cession of +Prussia's territory west of the Elbe, with the exception of the town of +Magdeburg, and the withdrawal of Prussia from the affairs of Germany. These +terms were communicated to King Frederick William; he accepted them, and +sent Lucchesini to Berlin to negotiate for peace upon this basis. +Lucchesini had scarcely reached the capital when the tidings arrived of +Hohenlohe's capitulation, followed by the surrender of Stettin and Kuestrin. +The Prussian envoy now sought in vain to procure Napoleon's ratification of +the terms which he had himself proposed. No word of peace could be +obtained: an armistice was all that the Emperor would grant, and the terms +on which the armistice was offered rose with each new disaster to the +Prussian arms. On the fall of Magdeburg becoming known, Napoleon demanded +that the troops of Prussia should retire behind the Vistula, and surrender +every fortress that they still retained, with the single exception of +Koenigsberg. Much as Prussia had lost, it would have cost Napoleon a second +campaign to make himself master of what he now asked; but to such a depth +had the Prussian Government sunk, that Lucchesini actually signed a +convention at Charlottenburg (November 16), surrendering to Napoleon, in +return for an armistice, the entire list of uncaptured fortresses, +including Dantzig and Thorn on the Lower Vistula, Breslau, with the rest of +the untouched defences of Silesia, Warsaw and Praga in Prussian Poland, and +Colberg upon the Pomeranian coast. [133] + +[Frederick William continues the war.] + +The treaty, however, required the King's ratification. Frederick William, +timorous as he was, hesitated to confirm an agreement which ousted him from +his dominions as completely as if the last soldier of Prussia had gone into +captivity. The patriotic party, headed by Stein, pleaded for the honour of +the country against the miserable Cabinet which now sought to complete its +work of ruin. Assurances of support arrived from St. Petersburg. The King +determined to reject the treaty, and to continue the war to the last +extremity. Haugwitz hereupon tendered his resignation, and terminated a +political career disastrous beyond any recorded in modern times. For a +moment, it seemed as if the real interests of the country were at length to +be recognised in the appointment of Stein to one of the three principal +offices of State. But the King still remained blind to the necessity of +unity in the government, and angrily dismissed Stein when he refused to +hold the Ministry if representatives of the old Cabinet and of the +peace-party were to have places beside him. The King's act was ill +calculated to serve the interests of Prussia, either at home or abroad. +Stein was the one Minister on whom the patriotic party of Prussia and the +Governments of Europe could rely with perfect confidence. [134] His +dismissal at this crisis proved the incurable poverty of Frederick +William's mental nature; it also proved that, so long as any hope remained +of saving the Prussian State by the help of the Czar of Russia, the +patriotic party had little chance of creating a responsible government at +home. + +[Napoleon at Berlin.] + +[The Berlin decree against English commerce, Nov. 21, 1806.] + +Throughout the month of November French armies overran Northern Germany: +Napoleon himself remained at Berlin, and laid the foundations of a +political system corresponding to that which he had imposed upon Southern +Germany after the victory of Austerlitz. The Houses of Brunswick and +Hesse-Cassel were deposed, in order to create a new client-kingdom of +Westphalia; Saxony, with Weimar and four other duchies, entered the +Confederation of the Rhine. A measure more widely affecting the Continent +of Europe dated from the last days of the Emperor's residence at the +Prussian capital. On the 21st of November, 1806, a decree was published at +Berlin prohibiting the inhabitants of the entire European territory allied +with France from carrying on any commerce with Great Britain, or admitting +any merchandise that had been produced in Great Britain or in its colonies. +[135] The line of coast thus closed to the shipping and the produce of the +British Empire included everything from the Vistula to the southern point +of Dalmatia, with the exception of Denmark and Portugal and the Austrian +port of Trieste. All property belonging to English subjects, all +merchandise of British origin, whoever might be the owner, was ordered to +be confiscated: no vessel that had even touched at a British port was +permitted to enter a Continental harbour. It was the fixed purpose of +Napoleon to exhaust Great Britain, since he could not destroy its navies, +or, according to his own expression, to conquer England upon the Continent. +All that was most harsh and unjust in the operation of the Berlin Decree +fell, however, more upon Napoleon's own subjects than upon Great Britain. +The exclusion of British ships from the harbours of the allies of France +was no more than the exercise of a common right in war; even the seizure of +the property of Englishmen, though a violation of international law, bore +at least an analogy to the seizure of French property at sea; but the +confiscation of the merchandise of German and Dutch traders, after it had +lain for weeks in their own warehouses, solely because it had been produced +in the British Empire, was an act of flagrant and odious oppression. The +first result of the Berlin Decree was to fill the trading towns of North +Germany with French revenue-officers and inquisitors. Peaceable tradesmen +began to understand the import of the battle of Jena when French gendarmes +threw their stock into the common furnace, or dragged them to prison for +possessing a hogshead of Jamaica sugar or a bale of Leeds cloth. The +merchants who possessed a large quantity of English or colonial wares were +the heaviest sufferers by Napoleon's commercial policy: the public found +the markets supplied by American and Danish traders, until, at a later +period, the British Government adopted reprisals, and prevented the ships +of neutrals from entering any port from which English vessels were +excluded. Then every cottage felt the stress of the war. But if the full +consequences of the Berlin Decree were delayed until the retaliation of +Great Britain reached the dimensions of Napoleon's own tyranny, the Decree +itself marked on the part of Napoleon the assumption of a power in conflict +with the needs and habits of European life. Like most of the schemes of +Napoleon subsequent to the victories of 1806, it transgressed the limits of +practical statesmanship, and displayed an ambition no longer raised above +mere tyranny by its harmony with forms of progress and with the better +tendencies of the age. + +[Napoleon and the Poles.] + +Immediately after signing the Berlin Decree, Napoleon quitted the Prussian +capital (Nov. 25). The first act of the war had now closed. The Prussian +State was overthrown; its territory as far as the Vistula lay at the mercy +of the invader; its King was a fugitive at Koenigsberg, at the eastern +extremity of his dominions. The second act of the war began with the +rejection of the armistice which had been signed by Lucchesini, and with +the entry of Russia into the field against Napoleon. The scene of +hostilities was henceforward in Prussian Poland and in the Baltic Province +lying between the lower Vistula and the Russian frontier. Napoleon entered +Poland, as he had entered Italy ten years before, with the pretence of +restoring liberty to an enslaved people. Kosciusko's name was fraudulently +attached to a proclamation summoning the Polish nation to arms; and +although Kosciusko himself declined to place any trust in the betrayer of +Venice, thousands of his countrymen flocked to Napoleon's standard, or +anticipated his arrival by capturing and expelling the Prussian detachments +scattered through their country. Promises of the restoration of Polish +independence were given by Napoleon in abundance; but the cause of Poland +was the last to attract the sympathy of a man who considered the sacrifice +of the weak to the strong to be the first principle of all good policy. To +have attempted the restoration of Polish independence would have been to +make permanent enemies of Russia and Prussia for the sake of an ally weaker +than either of them. The project was not at this time seriously entertained +by Napoleon. He had no motive to face a work of such enormous difficulty as +the creation of a solid political order among the most unpractical race in +Europe. He was glad to enrol the Polish nobles among his soldiers; he knew +the value of their enthusiasm, and took pains to excite it; but, when the +battle was over, it was with Russia, not Poland, that France had to settle; +and no better fate remained, even for the Prussian provinces of Poland, +than in part to be formed into a client-state, in part to be surrendered as +a means of accommodation with the Czar. + +[Campaign in Poland against Russia, Dec., 1806.] + +The armies of Russia were at some distance from the Vistula when, in +November, 1806, Napoleon entered Polish territory. Their movements were +slow, their numbers insufficient. At the moment when all the forces of the +Empire were required for the struggle against Napoleon, troops were being +sent into Moldavia against the Sultan. Nor were the Russian commanders +anxious to save what still remained of the Prussian kingdom. The disasters +of Prussia, like those of Austria at the beginning of the campaign of 1805, +excited less sympathy than contempt; and the inclination of the Czar's +generals was rather to carry on the war upon the frontier of their own +country than to commit themselves to a distant campaign with a despised +ally. Lestocq, who commanded the remnant of the Prussian army upon the +Vistula, was therefore directed to abandon his position at Thorn and to +move eastwards. The French crossed the Vistula higher up the river; and by +the middle of December the armies of France and Russia lay opposite to one +another in the neighbourhood of Pultusk, upon the Ukra and the Narew. The +first encounter, though not of a decisive character, resulted in the +retreat of the Russians. Heavy rains and fathomless mud checked the +pursuit. War seemed almost impossible in such a country and such a climate; +and Napoleon ordered his troops to take up their winter quarters along the +Vistula, believing that nothing more could be attempted on either side +before the spring. + +[Eylau, Feb. 8, 1807.] + +[Napoleon and Bennigsen in East Prussia.] + +But the command of the Russian forces was now transferred from the aged and +half-mad Kamenski, [136] who had opened the campaign, to a general better +qualified to cope with Napoleon. Bennigsen, the new commander-in-chief, was +an active and daring soldier. Though a German by birth, his soldiership was +of that dogged and resolute order which suits the character of Russian +troops; and, in the mid-winter of 1806, Napoleon found beyond the Vistula +such an enemy as he had never encountered in Western Europe. Bennigsen +conceived the design of surprising the extreme left of the French line, +where Ney's division lay stretched towards the Baltic, far to the +north-east of Napoleon's main body. Forest and marsh concealed the movement +of the Russian troops, and both Ney and Bernadotte narrowly escaped +destruction. Napoleon now broke up his winter quarters, and marched in +great force against Bennigsen in the district between Koenigsberg and the +mouth of the Vistula. Bennigsen manoeuvred and retired until his troops +clamoured for battle. He then took up a position at Eylau, and waited for +the attack of the French. The battle of Eylau, fought in the midst of +snowstorms on the 8th of February, 1807, was unlike anything that Napoleon +had ever yet seen. His columns threw themselves in vain upon the Russian +infantry. Augereau's corps was totally destroyed in the beginning of the +battle. The Russians pressed upon the ground where Napoleon himself stood; +and, although the superiority of the Emperor's tactics at length turned the +scale, and the French began a forward movement, their advance was stopped +by the arrival of Lestocq and a body of 13,000 Prussians. At the close of +the engagement 30,000 men lay wounded or dead in the snow; the positions of +the armies remained what they had been in the morning. Bennigsen's +lieutenants urged him to renew the combat on the next day; but the +confusion of the Russian army was such that the French, in spite of their +losses and discouragement, would probably have gained the victory in a +second battle; [137] and the Russian commander determined to fall back +towards Koenigsberg, content with having disabled the enemy and given +Napoleon such a check as he had never received before. Napoleon, who had +announced his intention of entering Koenigsberg in triumph, fell back upon +the river Passarge, and awaited the arrival of reinforcements. + +[Sieges of Dantzig and Colberg, March, 1807.] + +[Inaction of England.] + +[Fall of Grenville's Ministry, March 24, 1807.] + +[Treaty of Barrenstein between Russia, Prussia, England, and Sweden. +April, 1807.] + +The warfare of the next few months was confined to the reduction of the +Prussian fortresses which had not yet fallen into the hands of the French. +Dantzig surrendered after a long and difficult siege; the little town of +Colberg upon the Pomeranian coast prolonged a defence as honourable to its +inhabitants as to the military leaders. Two soldiers of singularly +different character, each destined to play a conspicuous part in coming +years, first distinguished themselves in the defence of Colberg. Gneisenau, +a scientific soldier of the highest order, the future guide of Bluecher's +victorious campaigns, commanded the garrison; Schill, a cavalry officer of +adventurous daring, gathered round him a troop of hardy riders, and +harassed the French with an audacity as perplexing to his military +superiors as to the enemy. The citizens, led by their burgomaster, threw +themselves into the work of defence with a vigour in striking contrast to +the general apathy of the Prussian people; and up to the end of the war +Colberg remained uncaptured. Obscure as Colberg was, its defence might have +given a new turn to the war if the Government of Great Britain had listened +to the entreaties of the Emperor Alexander, and despatched a force to the +Baltic to threaten the communications of Napoleon. The task was not a +difficult one for a Power which could find troops, as England now did, to +send to Constantinople, to Alexandria, and to Buenos Ayres; but military +judgment was more than ever wanting to the British Cabinet. Fox had died at +the beginning of the war; his successors in Grenville's Ministry, though +they possessed a sound theory of foreign policy, [138] were not fortunate +in its application, nor were they prompt enough in giving financial help to +their allies. Suddenly, however, King George quarrelled with his Ministers +upon the ancient question of Catholic Disabilities, and drove them from +office (March 24). The country sided with the King. A Ministry came into +power, composed of the old supporters of Pitt, men, with the exception of +Canning and Castlereagh, of narrow views and poor capacity, headed by the +Duke of Portland, who, in 1793, had given his name to the section of the +Whig party which joined Pitt. The foreign policy of the new Cabinet, which +concealed its total lack of all other statesmanship, returned to the lines +laid down by Pitt in 1805. Negotiations were opened with Russia for the +despatch of an English army to the Baltic; arms and money were promised to +the Prussian King. For a moment it seemed as if the Powers of Europe had +never been united in so cordial a league. The Czar embraced the King of +Prussia in the midst of his soldiers, and declared with tears that the two +should stand or fall together. The Treaty of Bartenstein, signed in April +1807 pledged the Courts of St. Petersburg, Stockholm, and Berlin to a joint +prosecution of the war, and the common conclusion of peace. Great Britain +joined the pact, and prepared to fulfil its part in the conflict upon the +Baltic. But the task was a difficult one, for Grenville's Ministry had +dispersed the fleet of transports; and, although Canning determined upon +the Baltic expedition in April, two months passed before the fleet was +ready to sail. + +[Summer campaign in East Prussia, 1807.] + +[Battle of Friedland.] + +In the meantime army upon army was moving to the support of Napoleon, from +France, from Spain, from Holland, and from Southern Germany. The fortresses +of the Elbe and the Oder, which ought to have been his barrier, had become +his base of operations; and so enormous were the forces at his command, +that, after manning every stronghold in Central Europe, he was able at the +beginning of June to bring 140,000 men into the field beyond the Vistula. +The Russians had also received reinforcements, but Bennigsen's army was +still weaker than that of the enemy. It was Bennigsen, nevertheless, who +began the attack; and now, as in the winter campaign, he attempted to +surprise and crush the northern corps of Ney. The same general movement of +the French army followed as in January. The Russian commander, outnumbered +by the French, retired to his fortified camp at Heilsberg. After sustaining +a bloody repulse in an attack upon this position, Napoleon drew Bennigsen +from his lair by marching straight upon Koenigsberg. Bennigsen supposed +himself to be in time to deal with an isolated corps; he found himself face +to face with the whole forces of the enemy at Friedland, accepted battle, +and was unable to save his army from a severe and decisive defeat (June +14). The victory of Friedland brought the French into Koenigsberg. Bennigsen +retired behind the Niemen; and on the 19th of June an armistice closed the +operations of the hostile forces upon the frontiers of Russia. [139] + +The situation of Bennigsen's army was by no means desperate. His men had +not been surrounded; they had lost scarcely any prisoners; they felt no +fear of the French. But the general exaggerated the seriousness of his +defeat. Like most of his officers, he was weary of the war, and felt no +sympathy with the motives which led the Emperor to fight for the common +cause of Europe. The politicians who surrounded Alexander urged him to +withdraw Russia from a conflict in which she had nothing to gain. The +Emperor wavered. The tardiness of Great Britain, the continued neutrality +of Austria, cast a doubt upon the wisdom of his own disinterestedness; and +he determined to meet Napoleon, and ascertain the terms on which Russia +might be reconciled to the master of half the Continent. + +[Interview of Napoleon and Alexander at Tilsit, June 25.] + +On the 25th of June the two sovereigns met one another on the raft of +Tilsit, in the midstream of the river Niemen. The conversation, which is +alleged to have been opened by Alexander with an expression of hatred +towards England, was heard by no one but the speakers. But whatever the +eagerness or the reluctance of the Russian monarch to sever himself from +Great Britain, the purpose of Napoleon was effected. Alexander surrendered +himself to the addresses of a conqueror who seemed to ask for nothing and +to offer everything. The negotiations were prolonged; the relations of the +two monarchs became more and more intimate; and the issue of the struggle +for life or death was that Russia accepted the whole scheme of Napoleonic +conquest, and took its place by the side of the despoiler in return for its +share of the prey. It was in vain that the King of Prussia had rejected +Napoleon's offers after the battle of Eylau, in fidelity to his engagements +towards his ally. Promises, treaties, and pity were alike cast to the +winds. The unfortunate Frederick William received no more embraces; the +friend with whom he was to stand or fall bargained away the larger half of +his dominions to Napoleon, and even rectified the Russian frontier at his +expense. Prussia's continued existence in any shape whatever was described +as a concession made by Napoleon to Alexander. By the public articles of +the Treaties of Tilsit, signed by France, Russia, and Prussia in the first +week of July, the King of Prussia ceded to Napoleon the whole of his +dominions west of the Elbe, and the entire territory which Prussia had +gained in the three partitions of Poland, with the exception of a district +upon the Lower Vistula connecting Pomerania with Eastern Prussia. Out of +the ceded territory on the west of the Elbe a Kingdom of Westphalia was +created for Napoleon's brother Jerome; the Polish provinces of Prussia, +with the exception of a strip made over to Alexander, were formed into the +Grand-Duchy of Warsaw, and presented to Napoleon's vassal, the King of +Saxony. Russia recognised the Napoleonic client-states in Italy, Holland, +and Germany. The Czar undertook to offer his mediation in the conflict +between France and Great Britain; a secret article provided that, in the +event of Great Britain and France being at war on the ensuing 1st of +December, Prussia should declare war against Great Britain. + +[Secret Treaty of Alliance.] + +[Conspiracy of the two Emperors.] + +Such were the stipulations contained in the formal Treaties of Peace +between the three Powers. These, however, contained but a small part of the +terms agreed upon between the masters of the east and of the west. +A secret Treaty of Alliance, distinct from the Treaty of Peace, was also +signed by Napoleon and Alexander. In the conversations which won over the +Czar to the cause of France, Napoleon had offered to Alexander the spoils +of Sweden and the Ottoman Empire. Finland and the Danubian provinces were +not too high a price for the support of a Power whose arms could paralyse +Austria and Prussia. In return for the promise of this extension of his +Empire, Alexander undertook, in the event of Great Britain refusing terms +of peace dictated by himself, to unite his arms to those of Napoleon, and +to force the neutral maritime Powers, Denmark and Portugal, to take part in +the struggle against England. The annexation of Moldavia and Wallachia to +the Russian Empire was provided for under the form of a French mediation. +In the event of the Porte declining this mediation, Napoleon undertook to +assist Russia to liberate all the European territory subject to the yoke of +the Sultan, with the exception of Roumelia and Constantinople. A partition +of the liberated territory between France and Russia, as well as the +establishment of the Napoleonic house in Spain, probably formed the subject +rather of a verbal understanding than of any written agreement. [140] + +Such was this vast and threatening scheme, conceived by the man whose whole +career had been one consistent struggle for personal domination, accepted +by the man who among the rulers of the Continent had hitherto shown the +greatest power of acting for a European end, and of interesting himself in +a cause not directly his own. In the imagination of Napoleon, the national +forces of the western continent had now ceased to exist. Austria excepted, +there was no State upon the mainland whose army and navy were not +prospectively in the hands of himself and his new ally. The commerce of +Great Britain, already excluded from the greater part of Europe, was now to +be shut out from all the rest; the armies which had hitherto fought under +British subsidies for the independence of Europe, the navies which had +preserved their existence by neutrality or by friendship with England, were +soon to be thrown without distinction against that last foe. If even at +this moment an English statesman who had learnt the secret agreement of +Tilsit might have looked without fear to the future of his country, it was +not from any imperfection in the structure of Continental tyranny. The +fleets of Denmark and Portugal might be of little real avail against +English seamen; the homes of the English people might still be as secure +from foreign invasion as when Nelson guarded the seas; but it was not from +any vestige of political honour surviving in the Emperor Alexander. Where +Alexander's action was of decisive importance, in his mediation between +France and Prussia, he threw himself without scruple on to the side of +oppression. It lay within his power to gain terms of peace for Prussia as +lenient as those which Austria had gained at Campo Formio and at Luneville: +he sacrificed Prussia, as he allied himself against the last upholders of +national independence in Europe, in order that he might himself receive +Finland and the Danubian Provinces. + +[English expedition against Denmark, July, 1807.] + +Two days before the signature of the Treaty of Tilsit the British troops +which had once been so anxiously expected by the Czar landed in the island +of Ruegen. The struggle in which they were intended to take their part was +over. Sweden alone remained in arms; and even the Quixotic pugnacity of +King Gustavus was unable to save Stralsund from a speedy capitulation. But +the troops of Great Britain were not destined to return without striking a +blow. The negotiations between Napoleon and Alexander had scarcely begun, +when secret intelligence of their purport was sent to the British +Government. [141] It became known in London that the fleet of Denmark was +to be seized by Napoleon, and forced to fight against Great Britain. +Canning and his colleagues acted with the promptitude that seldom failed +the British Government when it could effect its object by the fleet alone. +They determined to anticipate Napoleon's violation of Danish neutrality, +and to seize upon the navy which would otherwise be seized by France and +Russia. + +[Bombardment of Copenhagen, Sept. 2.] + +On the 28th of July a fleet with 20,000 men on board set sail from the +British coast. The troops landed in Denmark in the middle of August, and +united with the corps which had already been despatched to Ruegen. The +Danish Government was summoned to place its navy in the hands of Great +Britain, in order that it might remain as a deposit in some British port +until the conclusion of peace. While demanding this sacrifice of Danish +neutrality, England undertook to protect the Danish nation and colonies +from the hostility of Napoleon, and to place at the disposal of its +Government every means of naval and military defence. Failing the surrender +of the fleet, the English declared that they would bombard Copenhagen. The +reply given to this summons was such as might be expected from a courageous +nation exasperated against Great Britain by its harsh treatment of neutral +ships of commerce, and inclined to submit to the despot of the Continent +rather than to the tyrants of the seas. Negotiations proved fruitless, and +on the 2nd of September the English opened fire on Copenhagen. For three +days and nights the city underwent a bombardment of cruel efficiency. +Eighteen hundred houses were levelled, the town was set on fire in several +places, and a large number of the inhabitants lost their lives. At length +the commander found himself compelled to capitulate. The fleet was handed +over to Great Britain, with all the stores in the arsenal of Copenhagen. It +was brought to England, no longer under the terms of a friendly neutrality, +but as a prize of war. + +The captors themselves were ashamed of their spoil. England received an +armament which had been taken from a people who were not our enemies, and +by an attack which was not war, with more misgiving than applause. In +Europe the seemingly unprovoked assault upon a weak neutral State excited +the utmost indignation. The British Ministry, who were prevented from +making public the evidence which they had received of the intention of the +two Emperors, were believed to have invented the story of the Secret +Treaty. The Danish Government denied that Napoleon had demanded their +co-operation; Napoleon and Alexander themselves assumed the air of +indignant astonishment. But the facts alleged by Canning and his colleagues +were correct. The conspiracy of the two Emperors was no fiction. The only +question still remaining open--and this is indeed an essential one--relates +to the engagements entered into by the Danish Government itself. Napoleon +in his correspondence of this date alludes to certain promises made to him +by the Court of Denmark, but he also complains that these promises had not +been fulfilled; and the context of the letter renders it almost certain +that, whatever may have been demanded by Napoleon, nothing more was +promised by Denmark than that its ports should be closed to English +vessels. [142] Had the British Cabinet possessed evidence of the +determination of the Danish Government to transfer its fleet to Napoleon +without resistance, the attack upon Denmark, considered as virtually an act +of war, would not have been unjust. But beyond an alleged expression of +Napoleon at Tilsit, no such evidence was even stated to have reached +London; and the undoubted conspiracy of the Emperors against Danish +neutrality was no sufficient ground for an action on the part of Great +Britain which went so far beyond the mere frustration of their designs. The +surrender of the Danish fleet demanded by England would have been an +unqualified act of war on the part of Denmark against Napoleon; it was no +mere guarantee for a continued neutrality. Nor had the British Government +the last excuse of an urgent and overwhelming necessity. Nineteen Danish +men-of-war would not have turned the scale against England. The memory of +Trafalgar might well have given a British Ministry courage to meet its +enemies by the ordinary methods of war. Had the forces of Denmark been far +larger than they actually were, the peril of Great Britain was not so +extreme as to excuse the wrong done to mankind by an example encouraging +all future belligerents to anticipate one another in forcing each neutral +state to take part with themselves. + +[Napoleon's demands upon Portugal.] + +The fleet which Napoleon had meant to turn against this country now lay +safe within Portsmouth harbour. Denmark, in bitter resentment, declared war +against Great Britain, and rendered some service to the Continental League +by the attacks of its privateers upon British merchant-vessels in the +Baltic. The second neutral Power whose fate had been decided by the two +Emperors at Tilsit received the summons of Napoleon a few days before the +attack on Copenhagen. The Regent of Portugal himself informed the British +Government that he had been required by Napoleon to close his ports to +British vessels, to declare war on England, and to confiscate all British +property within his dominions. Placed between a Power which could strip him +of his dominions on land, and one which could despoil him of everything he +possessed beyond the sea, the Regent determined to maintain his ancient +friendship with Great Britain, and to submit to Napoleon only in so far as +the English Government would excuse him, as acting under coercion. Although +a nominal state of war arose between Portugal and England, the Regent +really acted in the interest of England, and followed the advice of the +British Cabinet up to the end. + +[Treaty of Fontainebleau between France and Spain for the partition of +Portugal, Oct. 27.] + +The end was soon to come. The demands of Napoleon, arbitrary and oppressive +as they were, by no means expressed his full intentions towards Portugal. +He had determined to seize upon this country, and to employ it as a means +for extending his own dominion over the whole of the Spanish Peninsula. An +army-corps, under the command of Junot, had been already placed in the +Pyrenees. On the 12th of October Napoleon received the answer of the Regent +of Portugal, consenting to declare war upon England, and only rejecting the +dishonourable order to confiscate all English property. This single act of +resistance was sufficient for Napoleon's purpose. He immediately recalled +his ambassador from Lisbon, and gave orders to Junot to cross the frontier, +and march upon Portugal. The King of Spain, who was to be Napoleon's next +victim, was for the moment employed as his accomplice. A treaty was +concluded at Fontainebleau between Napoleon and King Charles IV. for the +partition of Portugal (Oct. 27). [143] In return for the cession of the +kingdom of Etruria, which was still nominally governed by a member of the +Spanish house, the King of Spain was promised half the Portuguese colonies, +along with the title of Emperor of the Indies; the northern provinces of +Portugal were reserved for the infant King of Etruria, its southern +provinces for Godoy, Minister of Charles IV.; the central districts were to +remain in the hands of France, and to be employed as a means of regaining +the Spanish colonies from England upon the conclusion of a general peace. + +[Junot invades Portugal, Nov., 1807.] + +[Flight of the House of Braganza.] + +Not one of these provisions was intended to be carried into effect. The +conquest of Portugal was but a part of the conquest of the whole peninsula. +But neither the Spanish Court nor the Spanish people suspected Napoleon's +design. Junot advanced without resistance through the intervening Spanish +territory, and pushed forward upon Lisbon with the utmost haste. The speed +at which Napoleon's orders forced him to march reduced his army to utter +prostration, and the least resistance would have resulted in its ruin. But +the Court of Lisbon had determined to quit a country which they could not +hope to defend against the master of the Continent. Already in the +seventeenth and eighteenth centuries the House of Braganza had been +familiar with the project of transferring the seat of their Government to +Brazil; and now, with the approval of Great Britain, the Regent resolved to +maintain the independence of his family by flight across the Atlantic. As +Junot's troops approached the capital, the servants of the palace hastily +stowed the royal property on ship-board. On the 29th of November, when the +French were now close at hand, the squadron which bore the House of +Braganza to its colonial home dropped down the Tagus, saluted by the cannon +of the English fleet that lay in the same river. Junot entered the capital +a few hours later, and placed himself at the head of the Government without +encountering any opposition. The occupation of Portugal was described by +Napoleon as a reprisal for the bombardment of Copenhagen. It excited but +little attention in Europe; and even at the Spanish Court the only feeling +was one of satisfaction at the approaching aggrandisement of the Bourbon +monarchy. The full significance of Napoleon's intervention in the affairs +of the Peninsula was not discovered until some months were passed. + +[Prussia after the Peace of Tilsit.] + +[Stein Minister, Oct. 5, 1807.] + +Portugal and Denmark had felt the consequences of the peace made at Tilsit. +Less, however, depended upon the fate of the Danish fleet and the +Portuguese Royal Family than upon the fate of Prussia, the most cruelly +wronged of all the victims sacrificed by Alexander's ambition. The +unfortunate Prussian State, reduced to half its former extent, devastated +and impoverished by war, and burdened with the support of a French army, +found in the crisis of its ruin the beginning of a worthier national life. +Napoleon, in his own vindictive jealousy, unwittingly brought to the head +of the Prussian Government the ablest and most patriotic statesman of the +Continent. Since the spring of 1807 Baron Hardenberg had again been the +leading Minister of Prussia, and it was to his counsel that the King's +honourable rejection of a separate peace after the battle of Eylau was due. +Napoleon could not permit this Minister, whom he had already branded as a +partisan of Great Britain, to remain in power; he insisted upon +Hardenberg's dismissal, and recommended the King of Prussia to summon +Stein, who was as yet known to Napoleon only as a skilful financier, likely +to succeed in raising the money which the French intended to extort. + +[Edict of Emancipation, Oct. 9, 1807.] + +Stein entered upon office on the 5th of October, 1807, with almost +dictatorial power. The need of the most radical changes in the public +services, as well as in the social order of the Prussian State, had been +brought home to all enlightened men by the disasters of the war; and a +commission, which included among its members the historian Niebuhr, had +already sketched large measures of reform before Hardenberg quitted office. +Stein's appointment brought to the head of the State a man immeasurably +superior to Hardenberg in the energy necessary for the execution of great +changes, and gave to those who were the most sincerely engaged in civil or +military reform a leader unrivalled in patriotic zeal, in boldness, and in +purity of character. The first great legislative measure of Stein was the +abolition of serfage, and of all the legal distinctions which fixed within +the limits of their caste the noble, the citizen, and the peasant. In +setting his name to the edict [144] which, on the 9th of October, 1807, +made an end of the mediaeval framework of Prussian society, Stein was indeed +but consummating a change which the progress of neighbouring States must +have forced upon Prussia, whoever held its government. The Decree was +framed upon the report of Hardenberg's Commission, and was published by +Stein within six days after his own entry upon office. Great as were the +changes involved in this edict of emancipation, it contained no more than +was necessary to bring Prussia up to the level of the least advanced of the +western Continental States. In Austria pure serfage had been abolished by +Maria Theresa thirty years before; it vanished, along with most of the +legal distinctions of class, wherever the victories of France carried a new +political order; even the misused peasantry of Poland had been freed from +their degrading yoke within the borders of the newly-founded Duchy of +Warsaw. If Prussia was not to renounce its partnership in European progress +and range itself with its barbarous eastern neighbour, that order which +fettered the peasant to the soil, and limited every Prussian to the +hereditary occupations of his class could no longer be maintained. It is +not as an achievement of individual genius, but as the most vivid +expression of the differences between the old and the new Europe, that the +first measure of Stein deserves a closer examination. + +[The Prussian peasant before and after the Edict of Oct. 9.] + +The Edict of October 9, 1807, extinguished all personal servitude; it +permitted the noble, the citizen, and the peasant to follow any calling; it +abolished the rule which prevented land held by a member of one class from +passing into the hands of another class; it empowered families to free +their estates from entail. Taken together, these enactments substitute the +free disposition of labour and property for the outworn doctrine which +Prussia had inherited from the feudal ages, that what a man is born that he +shall live and die. The extinction of serfage, though not the most +prominent provision of the Edict, was the one whose effects were the +soonest felt. In the greater part of Prussia the marks of serfage, as +distinct from payments and services amounting to a kind of rent, were the +obligation of the peasant to remain on his holding, and the right of the +lord to take the peasant's children as unpaid servants into his house. A +general relation of obedience and command existed, as between an hereditary +subject and master, although the lord could neither exact an arbitrary +amount of labour nor inflict the cruel punishments which had been common in +Poland and Hungary. What the villein was in England in the thirteenth +century, that the serf was in Prussia in the year 1806; and the change +which in England gradually elevated the villein into the free copyholder +was that change which, so many centuries later, the Prussian legislator +effected by one great measure. Stein made the Prussian peasant what the +English copyholder had become at the accession of Henry VII., and what the +French peasant had been before 1789, a free person, but one bound to render +fixed dues and service to the lord of the manor in virtue of the occupation +of his land. These feudal dues and services, which the French peasant, +accustomed for centuries before the Revolution to consider himself as the +full proprietor of the land, treated as a mere grievance and abuse, Stein +considered to be the best form in which the joint interest of the lord and +the peasant could be maintained. It was reserved for Hardenberg, four years +later, to free the peasant from all obligations towards his lord, and to +place him in unshackled proprietorship of two-thirds of his former holding, +the lord receiving the remaining one-third in compensation for the loss of +feudal dues. Neither Stein nor Hardenberg interfered with the right of the +lord to act as judge and police-magistrate within the limits of his manor; +and the hereditary legal jurisdiction, which was abolished in Scotland in +1747, and in France in 1789, continued unchanged in Prussia down to the +year 1848. + +[Relative position of the peasant in Prussia and England.] + +The history of Agrarian Reform upon the Continent shows how vast was the +interval of time by which some of the greatest social changes in England +had anticipated the corresponding changes in almost all other nations. But +if the Prussian peasant at the beginning of this century remained in the +servile condition which had passed out of mind in Great Britain before the +Reformation, the early prosperity of the peasant in England was dearly +purchased by a subsequent decline which has made his present lot far +inferior to that of the children or grandchildren of the Prussian serf. +However heavy the load of the Prussian serf, his holding was at least +protected by law from absorption into the domain of his lord. Before +sufficient capital had been amassed in Prussia to render landed property an +object of competition, the forced military service of Frederick had made it +a rule of State that the farmsteads of the peasant class must remain +undiminished in number, at whatever violence to the laws of the market or +the desires of great landlords. No process was permitted to take place +corresponding to that by which in England, after the villein had become the +free copyholder, the lord, with or without technical legal right, +terminated the copyhold tenure of his retainer, and made the land as much +his own exclusive property as the chairs and tables in his house. In +Prussia, if the law kept the peasant on the land, it also kept the land for +the peasant. Economic conditions, in the absence of such control in +England, worked against the class of small holders. Their early +enfranchisement in fact contributed to their extinction. It would perhaps +have been better for the English labouring class to remain bound by a +semi-servile tie to their land, than to gain a free holding which the law, +siding with the landlord, treated as terminable at the expiration of +particular lives, and which the increasing capital of the rich made its +favourite prey. It is little profit to the landless, resourceless English +labourer to know that his ancestor was a yeoman when the Prussian was a +serf. Long as the bondage of the peasant on the mainland endured, +prosperity came at last. The conditions which once distinguished +agricultural England from the Continent are now reversed. Nowhere on the +Continent is there a labouring class so stripped and despoiled of all +interest in the soil, so sedulously excluded from all possibilities of +proprietorship, as in England. In England alone the absence of internal +revolution and foreign pressure has preserved a class whom a life spent in +toil leaves as bare and dependent as when it began, and to whom the only +boon which their country can offer is the education which may lead them to +quit it. + +[Reform of Prussian Army.] + +[Short service.] + +Besides the commission which had drafted the Edict of Emancipation, Stein +found a military commission engaged on a plan for the reorganisation of the +Prussian army. The existing system forced the peasant to serve in the ranks +for twenty years, and drew the officers from the nobility, leaving the +inhabitants of towns without either the duty or the right to enter the army +at all. Since the battle of Jena, no one doubted that the principle of +universal liability to military service must be introduced into Prussia; on +the other hand, the very disasters of the State rendered it impossible to +maintain an army on anything approaching to its former scale. With half its +territory torn from it, and the remainder devastated by war, Prussia could +barely afford to keep 40,000 soldiers in arms. Such were the conditions +laid before the men who were charged with the construction of a new +Prussian military system. Their conclusions, imperfect in themselves, and +but partially carried out in the succeeding years, have nevertheless been +the basis of the latest military organisation of Prussia and of Europe +generally. The problem was solved by the adoption of a short period of +service and the rapid drafting of the trained conscript into a +reserve-force. Scharnhorst, President of the Military Commission, to whom +more than to any one man Prussia owed its military revival, proposed to +maintain an Active Army of 40,000 men; a Reserve, into which soldiers +should pass after short service in the active army; a Landwehr, to be +employed only for the internal defence of the country; and a Landsturm, or +general arming of the population, for a species of guerilla warfare. +Scharnhorst's project was warmly supported by Stein, who held a seat and a +vote on the Military Commission; and the system of short service, with a +Reserve, was immediately brought into action, though on a very limited +scale. The remainder of the scheme had to wait for the assistance of +events. The principle of universal military obligation was first proclaimed +in the war of 1813, when also the Landwehr was first enrolled. + +[Stein's plans of political reform.] + +[Design for a Parliament, for Municipalities, and District boards.] + +The reorganisation of the Prussian military system and the emancipation of +the peasant, though promoted by Stein's accession to power, did not +originate in Stein himself; the distinctive work of Stein was a great +scheme of political reform. Had Stein remained longer in power, he would +have given to Prussia at least the beginnings of constitutional government. +Events drove him from office when but a small part of his project was +carried into effect; but the project itself was great and comprehensive. He +designed to give Prussia a Parliament, and to establish a system of +self-government in its towns and country districts. Stein had visited +England in his youth. The history and the literature of England interested +him beyond those of any other country; and he had learnt from England that +the partnership of the nation in the work of government, so far from +weakening authority, animates it with a force which no despotic system can +long preserve. Almost every important State-paper written by Stein +denounces the apathy of the civil population of Prussia, and attributes it +to their exclusion from all exercise of public duties. He declared that the +nation must be raised from its torpor by the establishment of +representative government and the creation of free local institutions in +town and country. Stein was no friend of democracy. Like every other +Prussian statesman he took for granted the exercise of a vigorous +monarchical power at the centre of the State; but around the permanent +executive he desired to gather the Council of the Nation, checking at least +the caprices of Cabinet-rule, and making the opinion of the people felt by +the monarch. Stein's Parliament would have been a far weaker body than the +English House of Commons, but it was at least not intended to be a mockery, +like those legislative bodies which Napoleon and his clients erected as the +disguise of despotism. The transaction of local business in the towns and +country districts, which had hitherto belonged to officials of the Crown, +Stein desired to transfer in part to bodies elected by the inhabitants +themselves. The functions allotted to the new municipal bodies illustrated +the modest and cautious nature of Stein's attempt in the direction of +self-government, including no more than the care of the poor, the +superintendence of schools, and the maintenance of streets and public +buildings. Finance remained partly, police wholly, in the hands of the +central Government. Equally limited were the powers which Stein proposed to +entrust to the district councils elected by the rural population. In +comparison with the self-government of England or America, the +self-government which Stein would have introduced into Prussia was of the +most elementary character; yet his policy stood out in striking contrast to +that which in every client-state of Napoleon was now crushing out the last +elements of local independence under a rigid official centralisation. + +[Municipal reform alone carried out.] + +Stein was indeed unable to transform Prussia as he desired. Of the +legislative, the municipal, and the district reforms which he had sketched, +the municipal reform was the only one which he had time to carry out before +being driven from power; and for forty years the municipal institutions +created by Stein were the only fragment of liberty which Prussia enjoyed. A +vehement opposition to reform was excited among the landowners, and +supported by a powerful party at the Court. Stein was detested by the +nobles whose peasants he had emancipated, and by the Berlin aristocracy, +which for the last ten years had maintained the policy of friendship with +France, and now declared the only safety of the Prussian State to lie in +unconditional submission to Napoleon. The fire of patriotism, of energy, of +self-sacrifice, which burned in Stein made him no representative of the +Prussian governing classes of his time. It was not long before the +landowners, who deemed him a Jacobin, and the friends of the French, who +called him a madman, had the satisfaction of seeing the Minister sent into +banishment by order of Napoleon himself (Dec., 1808). Stein left the +greater part of his work uncompleted, but he had not laboured in vain. The +years of his ministry in 1807 and 1808 were the years that gathered +together everything that was worthiest in Prussia in the dawn of a national +revival, and prepared the way for that great movement in which, after an +interval of the deepest gloom, Stein was himself to light the nation to its +victory. + + + + +CHAPTER VIII. + + +Spain in 1806--Napoleon uses the quarrel between Ferdinand and Godoy--He +affects to be Ferdinand's protector--Dupont's army enters Spain--Murat in +Spain--Charles abdicates--Ferdinand King--Savary brings Ferdinand to +Bayonne--Napoleon makes both Charles and Ferdinand resign--Spirit of the +Spanish Nation--Contrast with Germany--Rising of all Spain--The Notables at +Bayonne--Campaign of 1808--Capitulation of Baylen--Wellesley lands in +Portugal--Vimieiro--Convention of Cintra--Effect of the Spanish Rising on +Europe--War Party in Prussia--Napoleon and Alexander at Erfurt--Stein +resigns, and is proscribed--Napoleon in Spain--Spanish Misgovernment-- +Campaign on the Ebro--Campaign of Sir John Moore--Corunna--Napoleon +leaves Spain--Siege of Saragossa--Successes of the French. + + +[Spanish affairs, 1793-1806.] + +[Spain in 1806.] + +Spain, which had played so insignificant a part throughout the +Revolutionary War, was now about to become the theatre of events that +opened a new world of hope to Europe. Its King, the Bourbon Charles IV., +was more weak and more pitiful than any sovereign of the age. Power +belonged to the Queen and to her paramour Godoy, who for the last fourteen +years had so conducted the affairs of the country that every change in its +policy had brought with it new disaster. In the war of the First Coalition +Spain had joined the Allies, and French armies had crossed the Pyrenees. In +1796 Spain entered the service of France, and lost the battle of St. +Vincent. At the Peace of Amiens, Napoleon surrendered its colony Trinidad +to England; on the renewal of the war he again forced it into hostilities +with Great Britain, and brought upon it the disaster of Trafalgar. This +unbroken humiliation of the Spanish arms, combined with intolerable +oppression and impoverishment at home, raised so bitter an outcry against +Godoy's government, that foreign observers, who underrated the loyalty of +the Spanish people, believed the country to be on the verge of revolution. +At the Court itself the Crown Prince Ferdinand, under the influence of his +Neapolitan wife, headed a party in opposition to Godoy and the supporters +of French dominion. Godoy, insecure at home, threw himself the more +unreservedly into the arms of Napoleon, who bestowed upon him a +contemptuous patronage, and flattered him with the promise of an +independent principality in Portugal. Izquierdo, Godoy's agent at Paris, +received proposals from Napoleon which were concealed from the Spanish +Ambassador; and during the first months of 1806 Napoleon possessed no more +devoted servant than the man who virtually held the government of Spain. + +[Spain intends to join Prussia in 1806.] + +The opening of negotiations between Napoleon and Fox's Ministry in May, +1806, first shook this relation of confidence and obedience. Peace between +France and England involved the abandonment on the part of Napoleon of any +attack upon Portugal; and Napoleon now began to meet Godoy's inquiries +after his Portuguese principality with an ominous silence. The next +intelligence received was that the Spanish Balearic Islands had been +offered by Napoleon to Great Britain, with the view of providing an +indemnity for Ferdinand of Naples, if he should give up Sicily to Joseph +Bonaparte (July, 1806.) This contemptuous appropriation of Spanish +territory, without even the pretence of consulting the Spanish Government, +excited scarcely less anger at Madrid than the corresponding proposal with +regard to Hanover excited at Berlin. The Court began to meditate a change +of policy, and watched the events which were leading Prussia to arm for the +war of 1806. A few weeks more passed, and news arrived that Buenos Ayres, +the capital of Spanish South America, had fallen into the hands of the +English. This disaster produced the deepest impression, for the loss of +Buenos Ayres was believed, and with good reason, to be but the prelude to +the loss of the entire American empire of Spain. Continuance of the war +with England was certain ruin; alliance with the enemies of Napoleon was at +least not hopeless, now that Prussia was on the point of throwing its army +into the scale against France. An agent was despatched by the Spanish +Government to London (Sept., 1806); and, upon the commencement of +hostilities by Prussia, a proclamation was issued by Godoy, which, without +naming any actual enemy, summoned the Spanish people to prepare for a war +on behalf of their country. + +[Treaty of Fontainebleau, Oct., 1807.] + +Scarcely had the manifesto been read by the Spaniards when the Prussian +army was annihilated at Jena. The dream of resistance to Napoleon vanished +away; the only anxiety of the Spanish Government was to escape from the +consequences of its untimely daring. Godoy hastened to explain that his +martial proclamation had been directed not against the Emperor of the +French, but against the Emperor of Morocco. Napoleon professed himself +satisfied with this palpable absurdity: it appeared as if the events of the +last few months had left no trace on his mind. Immediately after the Peace +of Tilsit he resumed his negotiations with Godoy upon the old friendly +footing, and brought them to a conclusion in the Treaty of Fontainebleau +(Oct., 1807), which provided for the invasion of Portugal by a French and a +Spanish army, and for its division into principalities, one of which was to +be conferred upon Godoy himself. The occupation of Portugal was duly +effected, and Godoy looked forward to the speedy retirement of the French +from the province which was to be his portion of the spoil. + +[Napoleon uses the enmity of Ferdinand against Godoy.] + +[Napoleon about to intervene as protector of Ferdinand.] + +Napoleon, however, had other ends in view. Spain, not Portugal, was the +true prize. Napoleon had gradually formed the determination of taking Spain +into his own hands, and the dissensions of the Court itself enabled him to +appear upon the scene as the judge to whom all parties appealed. The Crown +Prince Ferdinand had long been at open enmity with Godoy and his own +mother. So long as Ferdinand's Neapolitan wife was alive, her influence +made the Crown Prince the centre of the party hostile to France; but after +her death in 1806, at a time when Godoy himself inclined to join Napoleon's +enemies, Ferdinand took up a new position, and allied himself with the +French Ambassador, at whose instigation he wrote to Napoleon, soliciting +the hand of a princess of the Napoleonic House. [145] Godoy, though unaware +of the letter, discovered that Ferdinand was engaged in some intrigue. King +Charles was made to believe that his son had entered into a conspiracy to +dethrone him. The Prince was placed under arrest, and on the 30th of +October, 1807, a royal proclamation appeared at Madrid, announcing that +Ferdinand had been detected in a conspiracy against his parents, and that +he was about to be brought to justice along with his accomplices. King +Charles at the same time wrote a letter to Napoleon, of whose connection +with Ferdinand he had not the slightest suspicion, stating that he intended +to exclude the Crown Prince from the succession to the throne of Spain. No +sooner had Napoleon received the communication from the simple King than he +saw himself in possession of the pretext for intervention which he had so +long desired. The most pressing orders were given for the concentration of +troops on the Spanish frontier; Napoleon appeared to be on the point of +entering Spain as the defender of the hereditary rights of Ferdinand. The +opportunity, however, proved less favourable than Napoleon had expected. +The Crown Prince, overcome by his fears, begged forgiveness of his father, +and disclosed the negotiations which had taken place between himself and +the French Ambassador. Godoy, dismayed at finding Napoleon's hand in what +he had supposed to be a mere palace-intrigue, abandoned all thought of +proceeding further against the Crown Prince; and a manifesto announced that +Ferdinand was restored to the favour of his father. Napoleon now +countermanded the order which he had given for the despatch of the Rhenish +troops to the Pyrenees, and contented himself with directing General +Dupont, the commander of an army-corps nominally destined for Portugal, to +cross the Spanish frontier and advance as far as Vittoria. + +[Dupont enters Spain, Dec., 1807.] + +[French welcomed in Spain as Ferdinand's protectors.] + +Dupont's troops entered Spain in the last days of the year 1807, and were +received with acclamations. It was universally believed that Napoleon had +espoused the cause of Ferdinand, and intended to deliver the Spanish nation +from the detested rule of Godoy. Since the open attack made upon Ferdinand +in the publication of the pretended conspiracy, the Crown Prince, who was +personally as contemptible as any of his enemies, had become the idol of +the people. For years past the hatred of the nation towards Godoy and the +Queen had been constantly deepening, and the very reforms which Godoy +effected in the hope of attaching to himself the more enlightened classes +only served to complete his unpopularity with the fanatical mass of the +nation. The French, who gradually entered the Peninsula to the number of +80,000, and who described themselves as the protectors of Ferdinand and of +the true Catholic faith, were able to spread themselves over the northern +provinces without exciting suspicion. It was only when their commanders, by +a series of tricks worthy of American savages, obtained possession of the +frontier citadels and fortresses, that the wiser part of the nation began +to entertain some doubt as to the real purpose of their ally. At the Court +itself and among the enemies of Ferdinand the advance of the French roused +the utmost alarm. King Charles wrote to Napoleon in the tone of ancient +friendship; but the answer he received was threatening and mysterious. The +utterances which the Emperor let fall in the presence of persons likely to +report them at Madrid were even more alarming, and were intended to terrify +the Court into the resolution to take flight from Madrid. The capital once +abandoned by the King, Napoleon judged that he might safely take everything +into his own hands on the pretence of restoring to Spain the government +which it had lost. + +[Murat sent to Spain, Feb., 1808.] + +[Charles IV. abdicates, March 17, 1808.] + +On the 20th of February, 1808, Murat was ordered to quit Paris in order to +assume the command in Spain. Not a word was said by Napoleon to him before +his departure. His instructions first reached him at Bayonne; they were of +a military nature, and gave no indication of the ultimate political object +of his mission. Murat entered Spain on the 1st of March, knowing no more +than that he was ordered to reassure all parties and to commit himself to +none, but with full confidence that he himself was intended by Napoleon to +be the successor of the Bourbon dynasty. It was now that the Spanish Court, +expecting the appearance of the French army in Madrid, resolved upon that +flight which Napoleon considered so necessary to his own success. The +project was not kept a secret. It passed from Godoy to the Ministers of +State, and from them to the friends of Ferdinand. The populace of Madrid +was inflamed by the report that Godoy was about to carry the King to a +distance, in order to prolong the misgovernment which the French had +determined to overthrow. A tumultuous crowd marched from the capital to +Aranjuez, the residence of the Court. On the evening of the 17th of March, +the palace of Godoy was stormed by the mob. Godoy himself was seized, and +carried to the barracks amid the blows and curses of the populace. The +terrified King, who already saw before him the fate of his cousin, Louis +XVI., first published a decree depriving Godoy of all his dignities, and +then abdicated in favour of his son. On the 19th of March Ferdinand was +proclaimed King. + +[French enter Madrid, March 23.] + +Such was the unexpected intelligence that met Murat as he approached +Madrid. The dissensions of the Court, which were to supply his ground of +intervention, had been terminated by the Spaniards themselves: in the place +of a despised dotard and a menaced favourite, Spain had gained a youthful +sovereign around whom all classes of the nation rallied with the utmost +enthusiasm. Murat's position became a very difficult one; but he supplied +what was wanting in his instructions by the craft of a man bent upon +creating a vacancy in his own favour. He sent his aide-de-camp, Monthieu, +to visit the dethroned sovereign, and obtained a protest from King Charles +IV., declaring his abdication to have been extorted from him by force, and +consequently to be null and void. This document Murat kept secret; but he +carefully abstained from doing anything which might involve a recognition +of Ferdinand's title. On the 23rd of March the French troops entered +Madrid. Nothing had as yet become known to the public that indicated an +altered policy on the part of the French; and the soldiers of Murat, as the +supposed friends of Ferdinand, met with as friendly a reception in Madrid +as in the other towns of Spain. On the following day Ferdinand himself made +his solemn entry into the capital, amid wild demonstrations of an almost +barbaric loyalty. + +[Savary brings Ferdinand to Bayonne, April, 1808.] + +In the tumult of popular joy it was noticed that Murat's troops continued +their exercises without the least regard to the pageant that so deeply +stirred the hearts of the Spaniards. Suspicions were aroused; the +enthusiasm of the people for the French soldiers began to change into +irritation and ill-will. The end of the long drama of deceit was in fact +now close at hand. On the 4th of April General Savary arrived at Madrid +with instructions independent of those given to Murat. He was charged to +entice the new Spanish sovereign from his capital, and to bring him, either +as a dupe or as a prisoner, on to French soil. The task was not a difficult +one. Savary pretended that Napoleon had actually entered Spain, and that he +only required an assurance of Ferdinand's continued friendship before +recognising him as the legitimate successor of Charles IV. Ferdinand, he +added, could show no greater mark of cordiality to his patron than by +advancing to meet him on the road. Snared by these hopes, Ferdinand set out +from Madrid, in company with Savary and some of his own foolish confidants. +On reaching Burgos, the party found no signs of the Emperor. They continued +their journey to Vittoria. Here Ferdinand's suspicions were aroused, and he +declined to proceed farther. Savary hastened to Bayonne to report the delay +to Napoleon. He returned with a letter which overcame Ferdinand's scruples +and induced him to cross the Pyrenees, in spite of the prayers of statesmen +and the loyal violence of the simple inhabitants of the district. At +Bayonne Ferdinand was visited by Napoleon, but not a word was spoken on the +object of his journey. In the afternoon the Emperor received Ferdinand and +his suite at a neighbouring chateau, but preserved the same ominous +silence. When the other guests departed, the Canon Escoiquiz, a member of +Ferdinand's retinue, was detained, and learned from Napoleon's own lips the +fate in store for the Bourbon Monarchy. Savary returned to Bayonne with +Ferdinand, and informed the Prince that he must renounce the crown of +Spain. [146] + +[Charles and Ferdinand surrender their rights to Napoleon.] + +[Attack on the French in Madrid, May 2.] + +For some days Ferdinand held out against Napoleon's demands with a +stubbornness not often shown by him in the course of his mean and +hypocritical career. He was assailed not only by Napoleon but by those +whose fall had been his own rise; for Godoy was sent to Bayonne by Murat, +and the old King and Queen hurried after their son in order to witness his +humiliation. Ferdinand's parents attacked him with an indecency that +astonished even Napoleon himself; but the Prince maintained his refusal +until news arrived from Madrid which terrified him into submission. The +irritation of the capital had culminated in an armed conflict between the +populace and the French troops. On an attempt being made by Murat to remove +the remaining members of the royal family from the palace, the capital had +broken into open insurrection, and wherever French soldiers were found +alone or in small bodies they were massacred. (May 2.) Some hundreds of the +French perished; but the victory of Murat was speedy, and his vengeance +ruthless. The insurgents were driven into the great central square of the +city, and cut down by repeated charges of cavalry. When all resistance was +over, numbers of the citizens were shot in cold blood. Such was the +intelligence which reached Bayonne in the midst of Napoleon's struggle with +Ferdinand. There was no further need of argument. Ferdinand was informed +that if he withheld his resignation for twenty-four hours longer he would +be treated as a rebel. He yielded; and for a couple of country houses and +two life-annuities the crown of Spain and the Indies was renounced in +favour of Napoleon by father and son. + +[National spirit of the Spaniards.] + +The crown had indeed been won without a battle. That there remained a +Spanish nation ready to fight to the death for its independence was not a +circumstance which Napoleon had taken into account. His experience had as +yet taught him of no force but that of Governments and armies. In the +larger States, or groups of States, which had hitherto been the spoil of +France, the sense of nationality scarcely existed. Italy had felt it no +disgrace to pass under the rule of Napoleon. The Germans on both sides of +the Rhine knew of a fatherland only as an arena of the keenest jealousies. +In Prussia and in Austria the bond of citizenship was far less the love of +country than the habit of obedience to government. England and Russia, +where patriotism existed in the sense in which it existed in Spain, had as +yet been untouched by French armies. Judging from the action of the Germans +and the Italians, Napoleon might well suppose that in settling with the +Spanish Government he had also settled with the Spanish people, or, at the +worst, that his troops might have to fight some fanatical peasants, like +those who resisted the expulsion of the Bourbons from Naples. But the +Spanish nation was no mosaic of political curiosities like the Holy Roman +Empire, and no divided and oblivious family like the population of Italy. +Spain, as a single nation united under its King, had once played the +foremost part in Europe: when its grandeur departed, its pride had remained +behind: the Spaniard, in all his torpor and impoverishment, retained the +impulse of honour, the spirited self-respect, which periods of national +greatness leave behind them among a race capable of cherishing their +memory. Nor had those influences of a common European culture, which +directly opposed themselves to patriotism in Germany, affected the +home-bred energy of Spain. The temper of mind which could find satisfaction +in the revival of a form of Greek art when Napoleon's cavalry were scouring +Germany, or which could inquire whether mankind would not profit by the +removal of the barriers between nations, was unknown among the Spanish +people. Their feeling towards a foreign invader was less distant from that +of African savages than from that of the civilised and literary nations +which had fallen so easy a prey to the French. Government, if it had +degenerated into everything that was contemptible, had at least failed to +reduce the people to the passive helplessness which resulted from the +perfection of uniformity in Prussia. Provincial institutions, though +corrupted, were not extinguished; provincial attachments and prejudices +existed in unbounded strength. Like the passion of the Spaniard for his +native district, his passion for Spain was of a blind and furious +character. Enlightened conviction, though not altogether absent, had small +place in the Spanish war of defence. Religious fanaticism, hatred of the +foreigner, delight in physical barbarity, played their full part by the +side of nobler elements in the struggle for national independence. + +[Rising of Spain, May, 1808.] + +The captivity of Ferdinand, and the conflict of Murat's troops with the +inhabitants of Madrid, had become known in the Spanish cities before the +middle of May. On the 20th of the same month the _Gaceta_ announced +the abdication of the Bourbon family. Nothing more was wanting to throw +Spain into tumult. The same irresistible impulse seized provinces and +cities separated by the whole breadth of the Peninsula. Without +communication, and without the guidance of any central authority, the +Spanish people in every part of the kingdom armed themselves against the +usurper. Carthagena rose on the 22nd. Valencia forced its magistrates to +proclaim King Ferdinand on the 23rd. Two days later the mountain-district +of Asturias, with a population of half a million, formally declared war on +Napoleon, and despatched envoys to Great Britain to ask for assistance. On +the 26th, Santander and Seville, on opposite sides of the Peninsula, joined +the national movement. Corunna, Badajoz, and Granada declared themselves on +the Feast of St. Ferdinand, the 30th of May. Thus within a week the entire +country was in arms, except in those districts where the presence of French +troops rendered revolt impossible. The action of the insurgents was +everywhere the same. They seized upon the arms and munitions of war +collected in the magazines, and forced the magistrates or commanders of +towns to place themselves at their head. Where the latter resisted, or were +suspected of treachery to the national cause, they were in many cases put +to death. Committees of Government were formed in the principal cities, and +as many armies came into being as there were independent centres of the +insurrection. + +[Joseph Bonaparte made King.] + +[Napoleon's Assembly at Bayonne, June, 1808.] + +Napoleon was in the meantime collecting a body of prelates and grandees at +Bayonne, under the pretence of consulting the representatives of the +Spanish nation. Half the members of the intended Assembly received a +personal summons from the Emperor; the other half were ordered to be chosen +by popular election. When the order, however, was issued from Bayonne, the +country was already in full revolt. Elections were held only in the +districts occupied by the French, and not more than twenty representatives +so elected proceeded to Bayonne. The remainder of the Assembly, which +numbered in all ninety-one persons, was composed of courtiers who had +accompanied the Royal Family across the Pyrenees, and of any Spaniards of +distinction upon whom the French could lay their hands. Joseph Bonaparte +was brought from Naples to receive the crown of Spain. [147] On the 15th of +June the Assembly of the Notables was opened. Its discussions followed the +order prescribed by Napoleon on all similar occasions. Articles disguising +a central absolute power with some pretence of national representation were +laid before the Assembly, and adopted without criticism. Except in the +privileges accorded to the Church, little indicated that the Constitution +of Bayonne was intended for the Spanish rather than for any other nation. +Its political forms were as valuable or as valueless as those which +Napoleon had given to his other client States; its principles of social +order were those which even now despotism could not dissever from French +supremacy--the abolition of feudal services, equality of taxation, +admission of all ranks to public employment. Titles of nobility were +preserved, the privileges of nobility abolished. One genuine act of homage +was rendered to the national character. The Catholic religion was declared +to be the only one permitted in Spain. + +[Attempts of Napoleon to suppress the Spanish rising.] + +While Napoleon was thus emancipating the peasants from the nobles, and +reconciling his supremacy with the claims of the Church, peasants and +townspeople were flocking to arms at the call of the priests, who so little +appreciated the orthodoxy of their patron as to identify him in their +manifestos with Calvin, with the Antichrist, and with Apollyon. [148] The +Emperor underrated the military efficiency of the national revolt, and +contented himself with sending his lieutenants to repress it, while he +himself, expecting a speedy report of victory, remained in Bayonne. +Divisions of the French army moved in all directions against the +insurgents. Dupont was ordered to march upon Seville from the capital, +Moncey upon Valencia; Marshal Bessieres took command of a force intended to +disperse the main army of the Spaniards, which threatened the roads from +the Pyrenees to Madrid. The first encounters were all favourable to the +practised French troops; yet the objects which Napoleon set before his +generals were not achieved. Moncey failed to reduce Valencia; Dupont found +himself outnumbered on passing the Sierra Morena, and had to retrace his +steps and halt at Andujar, where the road to Madrid leaves the valley of +the Guadalquivir. Without sustaining any severe loss, the French divisions +were disheartened by exhausting and resultless marches; the Spaniards +gained new confidence on each successive day which passed without +inflicting upon them a defeat. At length, however, the commanders of the +northern army were forced by Marshal Bessieres to fight a pitched battle at +Rio Seco, on the west of Valladolid (July 13th). Bessieres won a complete +victory, and gained the lavish praises of his master for a battle which, +according to Napoleon's own conception, ended the Spanish war by securing +the roads from the Pyrenees to Madrid. + +[Capitulation of Baylen, July 19.] + +[Dupont in Andalusia.] + +Never had Napoleon so gravely mistaken the true character of a campaign. +The vitality of the Spanish insurrection lay not in the support of the +capital, which had never passed out of the hands of the French, but in the +very independence of the several provincial movements. Unlike Vienna and +Berlin, Madrid might be held by the French without the loss being felt by +their adversary; Cadiz, Corunna, Lisbon, were equally serviceable bases for +the insurrection. The victory of Marshal Bessieres in the north preserved +the communication between France and Madrid, and it did nothing more. It +failed to restore the balance of military force in the south of Spain, or +to affect the operations of the Spanish troops which were now closing round +Dupont upon the Guadalquivir. On the 15th of July Dupont was attacked at +Andujar by greatly superior forces. His lieutenant, Vedel, knowing the +Spaniards to be engaged in a turning movement, made a long march northwards +in order to guard the line of retreat. In his absence the position of +Baylen, immediately in Dupont's rear, was seized by the Spanish general +Reding. Dupont discovered himself to be surrounded. He divided his army +into two columns, and moved on the night of the 18th from Andujar towards +Baylen, in the hope of overpowering Reding's division. At daybreak on the +19th the positions of Reding were attacked by the French. The struggle +continued until mid-day, though the French soldiers sank exhausted with +thirst and with the burning heat. At length the sound of cannon was heard +in the rear. Castanos, the Spanish general commanding at Andujar, had +discovered Dupont's retreat, and pressed behind him with troops fresh and +unwearied by conflict. Further resistance was hopeless. Dupont had to +negotiate for a surrender. He consented to deliver up Vedel's division as +well as his own, although Vedel's troops were in possession of the road to +Madrid, the Spanish commander promising, on this condition, that the +captives should not be retained as prisoners of war in Spain, but be +permitted to return by sea to their native country. The entire army of +Andalusia, numbering 23,000 men, thus passed into the hands of an enemy +whom Napoleon had not believed to possess a military existence. Dupont's +anxiety to save something for France only aggravated the extent of the +calamity; for the Junta of Seville declined to ratify the terms of the +capitulation, and the prisoners, with the exception of the superior +officers, were sent to the galleys at Cadiz. The victorious Spaniards +pushed forwards upon Madrid. King Joseph, who had entered the city only a +week before, had to fly from his capital. The whole of the French troops in +Spain were compelled to retire to a defensive position upon the Ebro. + +[Wellesley lands in Portugal, Aug. 1, 1808.] + +[Vimeiro, Aug. 21.] + +[Convention of Cintra, Aug. 30.] + +The disaster of Baylen did not come alone. Napoleon's attack upon Portugal +had brought him within the striking-range of Great Britain. On the 1st of +August an English army, commanded by Sir Arthur Wellesley, landed on the +Portuguese coast at the mouth of the Mondego. Junot, the first invader of +the Peninsula, was still at Lisbon; his forces in occupation of Portugal +numbered nearly 30,000 men, but they were widely dispersed, and he was +unable to bring more than 13,000 men into the field against the 16,000 with +whom Wellesley moved upon Lisbon. Junot advanced to meet the invader. A +battle was fought at Vimieiro, thirty miles north of Lisbon, on the 21st of +August. The victory was gained by the British; and had the first advantage +been followed up, Junot's army would scarcely have escaped capture. But the +command had passed out of Wellesley's hands. His superior officer, Sir +Harry Burrard, took up the direction of the army immediately the battle +ended, and Wellesley had to acquiesce in a suspension of operations at a +moment when the enemy seemed to be within his grasp. Junot made the best +use of his reprieve. He entered into negotiations for the evacuation of +Portugal, and obtained the most favourable terms in the Convention of +Cintra, signed on the 30th of August. The French army was permitted to +return to France with its arms and baggage. Wellesley, who had strongly +condemned the inaction of his superior officers after the battle of the +21st, agreed with them that, after the enemy had once been permitted to +escape, the evacuation of Portugal was the best result which the English +could obtain. [149] Junot's troops were accordingly conveyed to French +ports at the expense of the British Government, to the great displeasure of +the public, who expected to see the marshal and his army brought prisoners +into Portsmouth. The English were as ill-humoured with their victory as the +French with their defeat. When on the point of sending Junot to a +court-martial for his capitulation, Napoleon learnt that the British +Government had ordered its own generals to be brought to trial for +permitting the enemy to escape them. + +[Effect of Spanish rising on Europe.] + +[War-party in Austria and Prussia.] + +[Napoleon and Prussia.] + +If the Convention of Cintra gained little glory for England, the tidings of +the successful uprising of the Spanish people against Napoleon, and of +Dupont's capitulation at Baylen, created the deepest impression in every +country of Europe that still entertained the thought of resistance to +France. The first great disaster had befallen Napoleon's arms. It had been +inflicted by a nation without a government, without a policy, without a +plan beyond that of the liberation of its fatherland from the foreigner. +What Coalition after Coalition had failed to effect, the patriotism and +energy of a single people deserted by its rulers seemed about to +accomplish. The victory of the regular troops at Baylen was but a part of +that great national movement in which every isolated outbreak had had its +share in dividing and paralysing the Emperor's force. The capacity of +untrained popular levies to resist practised troops might be exaggerated in +the first outburst of wonder and admiration caused by the Spanish rising; +but the difference made in the nature of the struggle by the spirit of +popular resentment and determination was one upon which mistake was +impossible. A sudden light broke in upon the politicians of Austria and +Prussia, and explained the powerlessness of those Coalitions in which the +wars had always been the affair of the Cabinets, and never the affair of +the people. What the Spanish nation had effected for itself against +Napoleon was not impossible for the German nation, if once a national +movement like that of Spain sprang up among the German race. "I do not +see," wrote Bluecher some time afterwards, "why we should not think +ourselves as good as the Spaniards." The best men in the Austrian and +Prussian Governments began to look forward to the kindling of popular +spirit as the surest means for combating the tyranny of Napoleon. Military +preparations were pushed forward in Austria with unprecedented energy and +on a scale rivalling that of France itself. In Prussia the party of Stein +determined upon a renewal of the war, and decided to risk the extinction of +the Prussian State rather than submit to the extortions by which Napoleon +was completing the ruin of their country. It was among the patriots of +Northern Germany that the course of the Spanish struggle excited the +deepest emotion, and gave rise to the most resolute purpose of striking for +European liberty. + +Since the nominal restoration of peace between France and Prussia by the +cession of half the Prussian kingdom, not a month had passed without the +infliction of some gross injustice upon the conquered nation. The +evacuation of the country had in the first instance been made conditional +upon the payment of certain requisitions in arrear. While the amount of +this sum was being settled, all Prussia, except Koenigsberg, remained in the +hands of the French, and 157,000 French soldiers lived at free quarters +upon the unfortunate inhabitants. At the end of the year 1807 King +Frederick William was informed that, besides paying to Napoleon 60,000,000 +francs in money, and ceding domain lands of the same value, he must +continue to support 40,000 French troops in five garrison-towns upon the +Oder. Such was the dismay caused by this announcement, that Stein quitted +Koenigsberg, now the seat of government, and passed three months at the +head-quarters of the French at Berlin, endeavouring to frame some +settlement less disastrous to his country. Count Daru, Napoleon's +administrator in Prussia, treated the Minister with respect, and accepted +his proposal for the evacuation of Prussian territory on payment of a fixed +sum to the French. But the agreement required Napoleon's ratification, and +for this Stein waited in vain. [150] + +[Stein urges war.] + +[Demands of Napoleon, Sept., 1808.] + +Month after month dragged on, and Napoleon made no reply. At length the +victories of the Spanish insurrection in the summer of 1808 forced the +Emperor to draw in his troops from beyond the Elbe. He placed a bold front +upon his necessities, and demanded from the Prussian Government, as the +price of evacuation, a still larger sum than that which had been named in +the previous winter: he insisted that the Prussian army should be limited +to 40,000 men, and the formation of the Landwehr abandoned; and he required +the support of a Prussian corps of 16,000 men, in the event of hostilities +breaking out between France and Austria. Not even on these conditions was +Prussia offered the complete evacuation of her territory. Napoleon still +insisted on holding the three principal fortresses on the Oder with a +garrison of 10,000 men. Such was the treaty proposed to the Prussian Court +(September, 1808) at a time when every soldierly spirit thrilled with the +tidings from Spain, and every statesman was convinced by the events of the +last few months that Napoleon's treaties were but stages in a progression +of wrongs. Stein and Scharnhorst urged the King to arm the nation for a +struggle as desperate as that of Spain, and to delay only until Napoleon +himself was busied in the warfare of the Peninsula. Continued submission +was ruin; revolt was at least not hopeless. However forlorn the condition +of Prussia, its alliances were of the most formidable character. Austria +was arming without disguise; Great Britain had intervened in the warfare of +the Peninsula with an efficiency hitherto unknown in its military +operations; Spain, on the estimate of Napoleon himself, required an army of +200,000 men. Since the beginning of the Spanish insurrection Stein had +occupied himself with the organisation of a general outbreak throughout +Northern Germany. Rightly or wrongly, he believed the train to be now laid, +and encouraged the King of Prussia to count upon the support of a popular +insurrection against the French in all the territories which they had taken +from Prussia, from Hanover, and from Hesse. + +[Stein resigns, Nov. 24. Proscribed by Napoleon.] + +[Napoleon and Alexander meet at Erfurt, Oct. 7, 1808.] + +In one point alone Stein was completely misinformed. He believed that +Alexander, in spite of the Treaty of Tilsit, would not be unwilling to see +the storm burst upon Napoleon, and that in the event of another general war +the forces of Russia would more probably be employed against France than in +its favour. The illusion was a fatal one. Alexander was still the +accomplice of Napoleon. For the sake of the Danubian Principalities, +Alexander was willing to hold central Europe in check while Napoleon +crushed the Spaniards, and to stifle every bolder impulse in the simple +King of Prussia. Napoleon himself dreaded the general explosion of Europe +before Spain was conquered, and drew closer to his Russian ally. +Difficulties that had been placed in the way of the Russian annexation of +Roumania vanished. The Czar and the Emperor determined to display to all +Europe the intimacy of their union by a festal meeting at Erfurt in the +midst of their victims and their dependents. The whole tribe of vassal +German sovereigns was summoned to the meeting-place; representatives +attended from the Courts of Vienna and Berlin. On the 7th of October +Napoleon and Alexander made their entry into Erfurt. Pageants and +festivities required the attendance of the crowned and titled rabble for +several days; but the only serious business was the settlement of a treaty +confirming the alliance of France and Russia, and the notification of the +Czar to the envoy of the King of Prussia that his master must accept the +terms demanded by Napoleon, and relinquish the idea of a struggle with +France. [151] Count Goltz, the Prussian envoy, unwillingly signed the +treaty which gave Prussia but a partial evacuation at so dear a cost, and +wrote to the King that no course now remained for him but to abandon +himself to unreserved dependence upon France, and to permit Stein and the +patriotic party to retire from the direction of the State. Unless the King +could summon up courage to declare war in defiance of Alexander, there was, +in fact, no alternative left open to him. Napoleon had discovered Stein's +plans for raising an insurrection in Germany several weeks before, and had +given vent to the most furious outburst of wrath against Stein in the +presence of the Prussian Ambassador at Erfurt. If the great struggle on +which Stein's whole heart and soul were set was to be relinquished, if +Spain was to be crushed before Prussia moved an arm, and Austria was to be +left to fight its inevitable battle alone, then the presence of Stein at +the head of the Prussian State was only a snare to Europe, a peril to +Prussia, and a misery to himself. Stein asked for and received his +dismissal. (Nov. 24, 1808.) + +Stein's retirement averted the wrath of Napoleon from the King of Prussia; +but the whole malignity of that Corsican nature broke out against the +high-spirited patriot as soon as fresh victories had released Napoleon from +the ill-endured necessity of self-control. On the 16th of December, when +Madrid had again passed into the possession of the French, an imperial +order appeared, which gave the measure of Napoleon's hatred of the fallen +Minister. Stein was denounced as the enemy of the Empire; his property was +confiscated; he was ordered to be seized by the troops of the Emperor or +his allies wherever they could lay their hands upon him. As in the days of +Roman tyranny, the west of Europe could now afford no asylum to the enemies +of the Emperor. Russia and Austria remained the only refuge of the exile. +Stein escaped into Bohemia; and, as the crowning humiliation of the +Prussian State, its police were forced to pursue as a criminal the +statesman whose fortitude had still made it possible in the darkest days +for Prussian patriots not to despair of their country. + +[Misgovernment of the Spanish Junta.] + +[Napoleon goes to Spain, Nov., 1808.] + +Central Europe secured by the negotiations with Alexander at Erfurt, +Napoleon was now able to place himself at the head of the French forces in +Spain without fear of any immediate attack from the side of Germany. Since +the victory of Baylen the Spaniards had made little progress either towards +good government or towards a good military administration. The provincial +Juntas had consented to subordinate themselves to a central committee +chosen from among their own members; but this new supreme authority, which +held its meetings at Aranjuez, proved one of the worst governments that +even Spain itself had ever endured. It numbered thirty persons, +twenty-eight of whom were priests, nobles, or officials. [152] Its +qualities were those engrained in Spanish official life. In legislation it +attempted absolutely nothing but the restoration of the Inquisition and the +protection of Church lands; its administration was confined to a foolish +interference with the better generals, and the acquisition of enormous +supplies of war from Great Britain, which were either stolen by contractors +or allowed to fall into the hands of the French. While the members of the +Junta discussed the titles of honour which were to attach to them +collectively and individually, and voted themselves salaries equal to those +of Napoleon's generals, the armies fell into a state of destitution which +scarcely any but Spanish troops would have been capable of enduring. The +energy of the humbler classes alone prolonged the military existence of the +insurrection; the Government organised nothing, comprehended nothing. Its +part in the national movement was confined to a system of begging and +boasting, which demoralised the Spaniards, and bewildered the agents and +generals of England who first attempted the difficult task of assisting the +Spaniards to help themselves. When the approach of army after army, the +levies of Germany, Poland, Holland, and Italy, in addition to Napoleon's +own veteran troops of Austerlitz and Jena, gave to the rest of the world +some idea of the enormous force which Napoleon was about to throw on to +Spain, the Spanish Government could form no better design than to repeat +the movement of Baylen against Napoleon himself on the banks of the Ebro. + +[Napoleon enters Madrid, Dec. 4.] + +[Campaign on the Ebro, Nov., 1808.] + +The Emperor for the first time crossed the Pyrenees in the beginning of +November, 1808. The victory of the Spaniards in the summer had forced the +invaders to retire into the district between the Ebro and the Pyrenees, and +the Ebro now formed the dividing-line between the hostile armies. It was +the intention of Napoleon to roll back the extremes of the Spanish line to +the east and the west, and, breaking through its centre, to move straight +upon Burgos and Madrid. The Spaniards, for their part, were not content to +act upon the defensive. When Napoleon arrived at Vittoria on the 5th of +November, the left wing of the Spanish army under General Blake had already +received orders to move eastwards from the upper waters of the Ebro, and to +cut the French off from their communication with the Pyrenees. The movement +was exactly that which Napoleon desired; for in executing it, Blake had +only to march far enough eastwards to find himself completely surrounded by +French divisions. A premature movement of the French generals themselves +alone saved Blake from total destruction. He was attacked and defeated at +Espinosa, on the upper Ebro, before he had advanced far enough to lose his +line of retreat (Nov. 10); and, after suffering great losses, he succeeded +in leading off a remnant of his army into the mountains of Asturias. In the +centre, Soult drove the enemy before him, and captured Burgos. Of the army +which was to have cleared Spain of the French, nothing now remained but a +corps on the right at Tudela, commanded by Palafox. The destruction of this +body was committed by the Emperor to Lannes and Ney. Ney was ordered to +take a long march southwards in order to cut off the retreat of the +Spaniards; he found it impossible, however, to execute his march within the +time prescribed; and Palafox, beaten by Lannes at Tudela, made good his +retreat into Saragossa. A series of accidents had thus saved the divisions +of the Spanish army from actual capture, but there no longer existed a +force capable of meeting the enemy in the field. Napoleon moved forward +from Burgos upon Madrid. The rest of his march was a triumph. The batteries +defending the mountain-pass of Somo Sierra were captured by a charge of +Polish cavalry; and the capital itself surrendered, after a short artillery +fire, on the 4th of December, four weeks after the opening of the campaign. + +[Campaign of Sir John Moore.] + +An English army was slowly and painfully making its way towards the Ebro at +the time when Napoleon broke in pieces the Spanish line of defence. On the +14th of October Sir John Moore had assumed the command of 20,000 British +troops at Lisbon. He was instructed to march to the neighbourhood of +Burgos, and to co-operate with the Spanish generals upon the Ebro. +According to the habit of the English, no allowance was made for the +movements of the enemy while their own were under consideration; and the +mountain-country which Moore had to traverse placed additional obstacles in +the way of an expedition at least a month too late in its starting. Moore +believed it to be impossible to carry his artillery over the direct road +from Lisbon to Salamanca, and sent it round by way of Madrid, while he +himself advanced through Ciudad Rodrigo, reaching Salamanca on the 13th of +November. Here, while still waiting for his artillery, rumours reached him +of the destruction of Blake's army at Espinosa, and of the fall of Burgos. +Later came the report of Palafox's overthrow at Tudela. Yet even now Moore +could get no trustworthy information from the Spanish authorities. He +remained for some time in suspense, and finally determined to retreat into +Portugal. Orders were sent to Sir David Baird, who was approaching with +reinforcements from Corunna, to turn back towards the northern coast. +Scarcely had Moore formed this decision, when despatches arrived from +Frere, the British agent at Madrid, stating that the Spaniards were about +to defend the capital to the last extremity, and that Moore would be +responsible for the ruin of Spain and the disgrace of England if he failed +to advance to its relief. To the great joy of his soldiers, Moore gave +orders for a forward march. The army advanced upon Valladolid, with the +view of attacking the French upon their line of communication, while the +siege of the capital engaged them in front. Baird was again ordered +southwards. It was not until the 14th of December, ten days after Madrid +had passed into the hands of the French, that Moore received intelligence +of its fall. Neither the Spanish Government nor the British agent who had +caused Moore to advance took the trouble to inform him of the surrender of +the capital; he learnt it from an intercepted French despatch. From the +same despatch Moore learnt that to the north of him, at Saldanha, on the +river Carrion, there lay a comparatively small French force under the +command of Soult. The information was enough for Moore, heart-sick at the +mockery to which his army had been subjected, and burning for decisive +action. He turned northwards, and marched against Soult, in the hope of +surprising him before the news of his danger could reach Napoleon in the +capital. + +[Napoleon marches against Moore, Dec. 19.] + +[Retreat of the English.] + +[Corunna, Jan. 16, 1809.] + +On the 19th of December a report reached Madrid that Moore had suspended +his retreat on Portugal. Napoleon instantly divined the actual movement of +the English, and hurried from Madrid against Moore at the head of 40,000 +men. Moore had met Baird on the 20th at Mayorga; on the 23rd the united +British divisions reached Sahagun, scarcely a day's march from Soult at +Saldanha. Here the English commander learnt that Napoleon himself was on +his track. Escape was a question of hours. Napoleon had pushed across the +Guadarama mountains in forced marches through snow and storm. Had his +vanguard been able to seize the bridge over the river Esla at Benavente +before the English crossed it, Moore would have been cut off from all +possibility of escape. The English reached the river first and blew up the +bridge. This rescued them from immediate danger. The defence of the river +gave Moore's army a start which rendered the superiority of Napoleon's +numbers of little effect. For a while Napoleon followed Moore towards the +northern coast. On the 1st of January, 1809, he wrote an order which showed +that he looked upon Moore's escape as now inevitable, and on the next day +he quitted the army, leaving to his marshals the honour of toiling after +Moore to the coast, and of seizing some thousands of frozen or drunken +British stragglers. Moore himself pushed on towards Corunna with a rapidity +which was dearly paid for by the demoralisation of his army. The sufferings +and the excesses of the troops were frightful; only the rear-guard, which +had to face the enemy, preserved soldierly order. At length Moore found it +necessary to halt and take up position, in order to restore the discipline +of his army. He turned upon Soult at Lugo, and offered battle for two +successive days; but the French general declined an engagement; and Moore, +satisfied with having recruited his troops, continued his march upon +Corunna. Soult still followed. On January 11th the English army reached the +sea; but the ships which were to convey them back to England were nowhere +to be seen. A battle was inevitable, and Moore drew up his troops, 14,000 +in number, on a range of low hills outside the town to await the attack of +the French. On the 16th, when the fleet had now come into harbour, Soult +gave battle. The French were defeated at every point of their attack. Moore +fell at the moment of his victory, conscious that the army which he had so +bravely led had nothing more to fear. The embarkation was effected that +night; on the next day the fleet put out to sea. + +[Siege of Saragossa, Dec., 1808.] + +[Napoleon leaves Spain, Jan 19, 1809.] + +Napoleon quitted Spain on the 19th of January, 1809, leaving his brother +Joseph again in possession of the capital, and an army of 300,000 men under +the best generals of France engaged with the remnants of a defeated force +which had never reached half that number. No brilliant victories remained +to be won; no enemy remained in the field important enough to require the +presence of Napoleon. Difficulties of transit and the hostility of the +people might render the subjugation of Spain a slower process than the +subjugation of Prussia or Italy; but, to all appearance, the ultimate +success of the Emperor's plans was certain, and the worst that lay before +his lieutenants was a series of wearisome and obscure exertions against an +inconsiderable foe. Yet, before the Emperor had been many weeks in Paris, a +report reached him from Marshal Lannes which told of some strange form of +military capacity among the people whose armies were so contemptible in the +field. The city of Saragossa, after successfully resisting its besiegers in +the summer of 1808, had been a second time invested after the defeats of +the Spanish armies upon the Ebro. [153] The besiegers themselves were +suffering from extreme scarcity when, on the 22nd of January, 1809, Lannes +took up the command. Lannes immediately called up all the troops within +reach, and pressed the battering operations with the utmost vigour. On the +29th, the walls of Saragossa were stormed in four different places. + +[Defeats of the Spaniards, March, 1809.] + +According to all ordinary precedents of war, the French were now in +possession of the city. But the besiegers found that their real work was +only beginning. The streets were trenched and barricaded; every dwelling +was converted into a fortress; for twenty days the French were forced to +besiege house by house. In the centre of the town the popular leaders +erected a gallows, and there they hanged every one who flinched from +meeting the enemy. Disease was added to the horrors of warfare. In the +cellars, where the women and children crowded in filth and darkness, a +malignant pestilence broke out, which, at the beginning of February, raised +the deaths to five hundred a day. The dead bodies were unburied; in that +poisoned atmosphere the slightest wound produced mortification and death. +At length the powers of the defenders sank. A fourth part of the town had +been won by the French; of the townspeople and peasants who were within the +walls at the beginning of the siege, it is said that thirty thousand had +perished; the remainder could only prolong their defence to fall in a few +days more before disease or the enemy. Even now there were members of the +Junta who wished to fight as long as a man remained, but they were +outnumbered. On the 20th of February what was left of Saragossa +capitulated. Its resistance gave to the bravest of Napoleon's soldiers an +impression of horror and dismay new even to men who had passed through +seventeen years of revolutionary warfare, but it failed to retard +Napoleon's armies in the conquest of Spain. No attempt was made to relieve +the heroic or ferocious city. Everywhere the tide of French conquest +appeared to be steadily making its advance. Soult invaded Portugal; in +combination with him, two armies moved from Madrid upon the southern and +the south-western provinces of Spain. Oporto fell on the 28th of March; in +the same week the Spanish forces covering the south were decisively beaten +at Ciudad Real and at Medellin upon the line of the Guadiana. The hopes of +Europe fell. Spain itself could expect no second Saragossa. It appeared as +if the complete subjugation of the Peninsula could now only be delayed by +the mistakes of the French generals themselves, and by the untimely removal +of that controlling will which had hitherto made every movement a step +forward in conquest. + + + + +CHAPTER IX. + + +Austria preparing for war--The war to be one on behalf of the German +Nation--Patriotic Movement in Prussia--Expected Insurrection in North +Germany--Plans of Campaign--Austrian Manifesto to the Germans--Rising of +the Tyrolese--Defeats of the Archduke Charles in Bavaria--French in +Vienna--Attempts of Doernberg and Schill--Battle of Aspern--Second Passage +of the Danube--Battle of Wagram--Armistice of Znaim--Austria waiting for +events--Wellesley in Spain--He gains the Battle of Talavera, but +retreats--Expedition against Antwerp fails--Austria makes Peace--Treaty of +Vienna--Real Effects of the War of 1809--Austria after 1809--Metternich-- +Marriage of Napoleon with Marie Louise--Severance of Napoleon and +Alexander--Napoleon annexes the Papal States, Holland, La Valais, and the +North German Coast--The Napoleonic Empire: Its Benefits and Wrongs--The +Czar withdraws from Napoleon's Commercial System--War with Russia +imminent--Wellington in Portugal: Lines of Torres Vedras; Massena's +Campaign of 1810, and retreat--Soult in Andalusia--Wellington's Campaign +of 1810--Capture of Ciudad Rodrigo and Badajoz--Salamanca. + + +[Austria preparing for war, 1808-9.] + +Napoleon, quitting Spain in the third week of January, 1809, travelled to +Paris with the utmost haste. He believed Austria to be on the point of +declaring war; and on the very day of his arrival at the capital he called +out the contingents of the Rhenish Federation. In the course of the next +few weeks, however, he formed the opinion that Austria would either decline +hostilities altogether, or at least find it impossible to declare war +before the middle of May. For once the efforts of Austria outstripped the +calculations of her enemy. Count Stadion, the earnest and enlightened +statesman who had held power in Austria since the Peace of Presburg, had +steadily prepared for a renewal of the struggle with France. He was +convinced that Napoleon would soon enter upon new enterprises of conquest, +and still farther extend his empire at the expense of Austria, unless +attacked before Spain had fallen under his dominion. Metternich, now +Austrian Ambassador at Paris, reported that Napoleon was intending to +divide Turkey as soon as he had conquered Spain; and, although he advised +delay, he agreed with the Cabinet at Vienna that Austria must sooner or +later strike in self-defence. [154] Stadion, more sanguine, was only +prevented from declaring war in 1808 by the counsels of the Archduke +Charles and of other generals who were engaged in bringing the immense mass +of new levies into military formation. Charles himself attached little +value to the patriotic enthusiasm which, since the outbreak of the Spanish +insurrection, had sprung up in the German provinces of Austria. He saw the +approach of war with more apprehension than pleasure; but, however faint +his own hopes, he laboured earnestly in creating for Austria a force far +superior to anything that she had possessed before, and infused into the +mass of the army that confident and patriotic spirit which he saw in others +rather than felt in himself. By the beginning of March, 1809, Austria had +260,000 men ready to take the field. + +[The war of 1809 to be a war for Germany.] + +The war now breaking out was to be a war for the German nation, as the +struggle of the Spaniards had been a struggle for Spain. The animated +appeals of the Emperor's generals formed a singular contrast to the silence +with which the Austrian Cabinet had hitherto entered into its wars. The +Hapsburg sovereign now stood before the world less as the inheritor of an +ancient empire and the representative of the Balance of Power than as the +disinterested champion of the German race. On the part of the Emperor +himself the language of devotion for Germany was scarcely more than +ironical. Francis belonged to an age and to a system in which the idea of +nationality had no existence; and, like other sovereigns, he regarded his +possessions as a sort of superior property which ought to be defended by +obedient domestic dogs against marauding foreign wolves. The same personal +view of public affairs had hitherto satisfied the Austrians. It had been +enough for them to be addressed as the dutiful children of a wise and +affectionate father. The Emperor spoke the familiar Viennese dialect; he +was as homely in his notions and his prejudices as any beerseller in his +dominions; his subjects might see him at almost any hour of the day or +night; and out of the somewhat tough material of his character popular +imagination had no difficulty in framing an idol of parental geniality and +wisdom. Fifteen years of failure and mismanagement had, however, impaired +the beauty of the domestic fiction; and although old-fashioned Austrians, +like Haydn, the composer of the Austrian Hymn, were ready to go down to the +grave invoking a blessing on their gracious master, the Emperor himself and +his confidants were shrewd enough to see that the newly-excited sense of +German patriotism would put them in possession of a force which they could +hardly evoke by the old methods. + +[Austrian Parties.] + +One element of reality lay in the professions which were not for the most +part meant very seriously. There was probably now no statesman in Austria +who any longer felt a jealousy of the power of Prussia. With Count Stadion +and his few real supporters the restoration of Germany was a genuine and +deeply-cherished desire; with the majority of Austrian politicians the +interests of Austria herself seemed at least for the present to require the +liberation of North Germany. Thus the impassioned appeals of the Archduke +Charles to all men of German race to rise against their foreign oppressor, +and against their native princes who betrayed the interests of the +Fatherland, gained the sanction of a Court hitherto very little inclined to +form an alliance with popular agitation. If the chaotic disorder of the +Austrian Government had been better understood in Europe, less importance +would have been attached to this sudden change in its tone. No one in the +higher ranks at Vienna was bound by the action of his colleagues. The +Emperor, though industrious, had not the capacity to enforce any coherent +system of government. His brothers caballed one against another, and +against the persons who figured as responsible ministers. State-papers were +brought by soldiers to the Emperor for his signature without the knowledge +of his advisers. The very manifestos which seemed to herald a new era for +Germany owed most of their vigour to the literary men who were entrusted +with their composition. [155] + +[Patriotic movement in Prussia.] + +[Governing classes in South Germany on the side of Napoleon.] + +The answer likely to be rendered by Germany to the appeal of Austria was +uncertain. In the Rhenish Federation there were undoubted signs of +discontent with French rule among the common people; but the official +classes were universally on the side of Napoleon, who had given them their +posts and their salaries; while the troops, and especially the officers, +who remembered the time when they had been mocked by the Austrians as +"harlequins" and "nose-bags," were won by the kindness of the great +conqueror, who organised them under the hands of his own generals, and gave +them the companionship of his own victorious legions. Little could be +expected from districts where to the mass of the population the old regime +of German independence had meant nothing more than attendance at the +manor-court of a knight, or the occasional spectacle of a ducal wedding, or +a deferred interest in the droning jobbery of some hereditary +town-councillor. In Northern Germany there was far more prospect of a +national insurrection. There the spirit of Stein and of those who had +worked with him was making itself felt, in spite of the fall of the +Minister. Scharnhorst's reforms had made the Prussian army a school of +patriotism, and the work of statesmen and soldiers was promoted by men who +spoke to the feelings and the intelligence of the nation. Literature lost +its indifference to nationality and to home. The philosopher Fichte, the +poet Arndt, the theologian Schleiermacher pressed the claims of Germany and +of the manlier virtues upon a middle class singularly open to literary +influences, singularly wanting in the experience and the impulses of active +public life. [156] In the Kingdom of Westphalia preparations for an +insurrection against the French were made by officers who had served in the +Prussian and the Hessian armies. In Prussia itself, by the side of many +nobler agencies, the newly-founded Masonic society of the Tugendbund, or +League of Virtue, made the cause of the Fatherland popular among thousands +to whom it was an agreeable novelty to belong to any society at all. No +spontaneous, irresistible uprising, like that which Europe had seen in the +Spanish Peninsula, was to be expected among the unimpulsive population of +the North German plains; but the military circles of Prussia were generally +in favour of war, and an insurrection of the population west of the Elbe +was not improbable in the event of Napoleon's army being defeated by +Austria in the field. King Frederick William, too timid to resolve upon war +himself, too timid even to look with satisfaction upon the bold attitude of +Austria, had every reason for striking, if once the balance should incline +against Napoleon: even against his own inclination it was possible that the +ardour of his soldiers might force him into war. + +[Plans of campaign.] + +So strong were the hopes of a general rising in Northern Germany, that the +Austrian Government to some extent based its plans for the campaign on this +event. In the ordinary course of hostilities between France and Austria the +line of operations in Germany is the valley of the Danube; but in preparing +for the war of 1809 the Austrian Government massed its forces in the +north-west of Bohemia, with the object of throwing them directly upon +Central Germany. The French troops which were now evacuating Prussia were +still on their way westwards at the time when Austria was ready to open the +campaign. Davoust, with about 60,000 men, was in Northern Bavaria, +separated by a great distance from the nearest French divisions in Baden +and on the Rhine. By a sudden incursion of the main army of Austria across +the Bohemian mountains, followed by an uprising in Northern Germany, +Davoust and his scattered detachments could hardly escape destruction. Such +was the original plan of the campaign, and it was probably a wise one in +the present exceptional superiority of the Austrian preparations over those +of France. For the first time since the creation of the Consulate it +appeared as if the opening advantages of the war must inevitably be upon +the side of the enemies of France. Napoleon had underrated both the energy +and the resources of his adversary. By the middle of March, when the +Austrians were ready to descend upon Davoust from Bohemia, Napoleon's first +troops had hardly crossed the Rhine. Fortunately for the French commander, +the Austrian Government, at the moment of delivering its well-planned blow, +was seized with fear at its own boldness. Recollections of Hohenlinden and +Ulm filled anxious minds with the thought that the valley of the Danube was +insufficiently defended; and on the 20th of March, when the army was on the +point of breaking into Northern Bavaria, orders were given to divert the +line of march to the south, and to enter the Rhenish Confederacy by the +roads of the Danube and the Inn. Thus the fruit of so much energy, and of +the enemy's rare neglectfulness, was sacrificed at the last moment. It was +not until the 9th of April that the Austrian movement southward was +completed, and that the army lay upon the line of the Inn, ready to attack +Napoleon in the territory of his principal German ally. + +[Austrian manifesto to the Germans.] + +The proclamations now published by the Emperor and the Archduke bore +striking testimony to the influence of the Spanish insurrection in exciting +the sense of national right, and awakening the Governments of Europe to the +force which this placed in their hands. For the first time in history a +manifesto was addressed "to the German nation." The contrast drawn in the +Archduke's address to his army between the Spanish patriots dying in the +defence of their country, and the German vassal-contingents dragged by +Napoleon into Spain to deprive a gallant nation of its freedom, was one of +the most just and the most telling that tyranny has ever given to the +leaders of a righteous cause. [157] The Emperor's address "to the German +nation" breathed the same spirit. It was not difficult for the politicians +of the Rhenish Federation to ridicule the sudden enthusiasm for liberty and +nationality shown by a Government which up to the present time had dreaded +nothing so much as the excitement of popular movements; but, however +unconcernedly the Emperor and the old school of Austrian statesmen might +adopt patriotic phrases which they had no intention to remember when the +struggle was over, such language was a reality in the effect which it +produced upon the thousands who, both in Austria and other parts of +Germany, now for the first time heard the summons to unite in defence of a +common Fatherland. + +[Austrians invade Bavaria, April 9, 1809.] + +[Rising of the Tyrol, April, 1809.] + +[Its causes religious.] + +The leading divisions of the Archduke's army crossed the Inn on the 9th of +April. Besides the forces intended for the invasion of Bavaria, which +numbered 170,000 men, the Austrian Government had formed two smaller +armies, with which the Princes Ferdinand and John were to take up the +offensive in the Grand Duchy of Warsaw and in Northern Italy. On every side +Austria was first in the field; but even before its regular forces could +encounter the enemy, a popular outbreak of the kind that the Government had +invoked wrested from the French the whole of an important province. While +the army crossed the Inn, the Tyrolese people rose, and overpowered the +French and Bavarian detachments stationed in their country. The Tyrol had +been taken from Austria at the Peace of Presburg, and attached to +Napoleon's vassal kingdom of Bavaria. In geographical position and in +relationship of blood the Tyrolese were as closely connected with the +Bavarians as with the Austrians; and the annexation would probably have +caused no lasting discontent if the Bavarian Government had condescended to +take some account of the character of its new subjects. Under the rule of +Austria the Tyrolese had enjoyed many privileges. They were exempt from +military service, except in their own militia; they paid few taxes; they +possessed forms of self-government which were at least popular enough to be +regretted after they had been lost. The people adored their bishops and +clergy. Nowhere could the Church exhibit a more winning example of unbroken +accord between a simple people and a Catholic Crown. Protestantism and the +unholy activities of reason had never brought trouble into the land. The +people believed exactly what the priests told them, and delighted in the +innumerable holidays provided by the Church. They had so little cupidity +that no bribe could induce a Tyrolese peasant to inform the French of any +movement; they had so little intelligence that, when their own courage and +stout-heartedness had won their first battle, they persuaded one another +that they had been led by a Saint on a white horse. Grievances of a +substantial character were not wanting under the new Bavarian rule; but it +was less the increased taxation and the enforcement of military service +that exasperated the people than the attacks made by the Government upon +the property and rights of the Church. Montgelas, the reforming Bavarian +minister, treated the Tyrolese bishops with as little ceremony as the +Swabian knights. The State laid claim to all advowsons; and upon the +refusal of the bishops to give up their patronage, the bishops themselves +were banished and their revenues sequestrated. A passion for uniformity and +common sense prompted the Government to revive the Emperor Joseph's edicts +against pilgrimages and Church holidays. It became a police-offence to shut +up a shop on a saint's day, or to wear a gay dress at a festival. Bavarian +soldiers closed the churches at the end of a prescribed number of masses. +At a sale of Church property, ordered by the Government, some of the sacred +vessels were permitted to fall into the hands of the Jews. + +These were the wrongs that fired the simple Tyrolese. They could have borne +the visits of the tax-gatherer and the lists of conscription; they could +not bear that their priests should be overruled, or that their observances +should be limited to those sufficient for ordinary Catholics. Yet, with all +its aspect of unreason, the question in the Tyrol was also part of that +larger question whether Napoleon's pleasure should be the rule of European +life, or nations should have some voice in the disposal of their own +affairs. The Tyrolese were not more superstitious, and they were certainty +much less cruel, than the Spaniards. They fought for ecclesiastical +absurdities; but their cause was also the cause of national right, and the +admiration which their courage excited in Europe was well deserved. + +[Tyrolese expel Bavarians and French, April 1809.] + +Early in the year 1809 the Archduke John had met the leaders of the +Tyrolese peasantry, and planned the first movements of a national +insurrection. As soon as the Austrian army crossed the Inn, the peasants +thronged to their appointed meeting-places. Scattered detachments of the +Bavarians were surrounded, and on the 12th of April the main body of the +Tyrolese, numbering about 15,000 men, advanced upon Innsbruck. The town was +invested; the Bavarian garrison, consisting of 3,000 regular troops, found +itself forced to surrender after a severe engagement. On the next morning a +French column, on the march from Italy to the Danube, approached Innsbruck, +totally unaware of the events of the preceding day. The Tyrolese closed +behind it as it advanced. It was not until the column was close to the town +that its commander, General Brisson, discovered that Innsbruck had fallen +into an enemy's hands. Retreat was impossible; ammunition was wanting for a +battle; and Brisson had no choice but to surrender to the peasants, who had +already proved more than a match for the Bavarian regular troops. The +Tyrolese had done their work without the help of a single Austrian +regiment. In five days the weak fabric of Bavarian rule had been thrown to +the ground. The French only maintained themselves in the lower valley of +the Adige: and before the end of April their last positions at Trent and +Roveredo were evacuated, and no foreign soldier remained on Tyrolese soil. + +[Campaign of Archduke Charles in Bavaria.] + +The operations of the Austrian commanders upon the Inn formed a melancholy +contrast to the activity of the mountaineers. In spite of the delay of +three weeks in opening the campaign, Davoust had still not effected his +junction with the French troops in Southern Bavaria, and a rapid movement +of the Austrians might even now have overwhelmed his isolated divisions at +Ratisbon. Napoleon himself had remained in Paris till the last moment, +instructing Berthier, the chief of the staff, to concentrate the vanguard +at Ratisbon, if by the 15th of April the enemy had not crossed the Inn, but +to draw back to the line of the Lech if the enemy crossed the Inn before +that day. [158] The Archduke entered Bavaria on the 9th; but, instead of +retiring to the Lech, Berthier allowed the army to be scattered over an +area sixty miles broad, from Ratisbon to points above Augsburg. Davoust lay +at Ratisbon, a certain prey if the Archduke pushed forwards with vigour and +thrust his army between the northern and the southern positions of the +French. But nothing could change the sluggishness of the Austrian march. +The Archduke was six days in moving from the Inn to the Isar; and before +the order was given for an advance upon Ratisbon, Napoleon himself had +arrived at Donauwoerth, and taken the command out of the hands of his feeble +lieutenant. + +[Napoleon restores superiority of French, April 18, 19.] + +It needed all the Emperor's energy to snatch victory from the enemy's +grasp. Davoust was bidden to fall back from Ratisbon to Neustadt; the most +pressing orders were sent to Massena, who commanded the right at Augsburg, +to push forward to the north-east in the direction of his colleague, before +the Austrians could throw the mass of their forces upon Davoust's weak +corps. Both generals understood the urgency of the command. Davoust set out +from Ratisbon on the morning of the 19th. He was attacked by the Archduke, +but so feebly and irresolutely that, with all their superiority in numbers, +the Austrians failed to overpower the enemy at any one point. Massena, +immediately after receiving his orders, hurried from Augsburg +north-eastwards, while Napoleon himself advanced into the mid-space between +the two generals, and brought the right and left wings of the French army +into communication with one another. In two days after the Emperor's +arrival all the advantages of the Austrians were gone: the French, so +lately exposed to destruction, formed a concentrated mass in the presence +of a scattered enemy. The issue of the campaign was decided by the +movements of these two days. Napoleon was again at the head of 150,000 men; +the Archduke, already baulked in his first attack upon Davoust, was seized +with unworthy terror when he found that Napoleon himself was before him, +and resigned himself to anticipations of ruin. + +[Austrian defeats at Landshut and Eggmuehl, April 22.] + +[French enter Vienna, May 13.] + +A series of manoeuvres and engagements in the finest style of Napoleonic +warfare filled the next three days with French victories and Austrian +disasters. On April the 20th the long line of the Archduke's army was cut +in halves by an attack at Abensberg. The left was driven across the Isar at +Landshut; the right, commanded by the Archduke himself, was overpowered at +Eggmuehl on the 22nd, and forced northwards. The unbroken mass of the French +army now thrust itself between the two defeated wings of the enemy. The +only road remaining open to the Archduke was that through Ratisbon to the +north of the Danube. In five days, although no engagement of the first +order had taken place between the French and Austrian armies, Charles had +lost 60,000 men; the mass of his army was retreating into Bohemia, and the +road to Vienna lay scarcely less open than after Mack's capitulation at Ulm +four years before. A desperate battle fought against the advancing French +at Edelsberg by the weak divisions that had remained on the south of the +Danube, proved that the disasters of the campaign were due to the faults of +the general, not to the men whom he commanded. But whatever hopes of +ultimate success might still be based on the gallant temper of the army, it +was impossible to prevent the fall of the capital. The French, leaving the +Archduke on the north of the Danube, pressed forwards along the direct +route from the Inn to Vienna. The capital was bombarded and occupied. On +the 13th of May Napoleon again took up his quarters in the palace of the +Austrian monarchs where he had signed the Peace of 1806. The divisions +which had fallen back before him along the southern road crossed the Danube +at Vienna, and joined the Archduke on the bank of the river opposite the +capital. + +[Attempts of Doernberg and Schill in Northern Germany, April, 1809.] + +The disasters of the Bavarian campaign involved the sacrifice of all that +had resulted from Austrian victories elsewhere, and of all that might have +been won by a general insurrection in Northern Germany. In Poland and in +Italy the war had opened favourably for Austria. Warsaw had been seized; +Eugene Beauharnais, the Viceroy of Italy, had been defeated by the Archduke +John at Sacile, in Venetia; but it was impossible to pursue these +advantages when the capital itself was on the point of falling into the +hands of the enemy. The invading armies halted, and ere long the Archduke +John commenced his retreat into the mountains. In Northern Germany no +popular uprising could be expected when once Austria had been defeated. The +only movements that took place were undertaken by soldiers, and undertaken +before the disasters in Bavaria became known. The leaders in this military +conspiracy were Doernberg, an officer in the service of King Jerome of +Westphalia, and Schill, the Prussian cavalry leader who had so brilliantly +distinguished himself in the defence of Colberg. Doernberg had taken service +under Jerome with the design of raising Jerome's own army against him. It +had been agreed by the conspirators that at the same moment Doernberg should +raise the Hessian standard in Westphalia, and Schill, marching from Berlin +with any part of the Prussian army that would follow him, should proclaim +war against the French in defiance of the Prussian Government. Doernberg had +made sure of the support of his own regiment; but at the last moment the +plot was discovered, and he was transferred to the command of a body of men +upon whom he could not rely. He placed himself at the head of a band of +peasants, and raised the standard of insurrection. King Jerome's troops met +the solicitations of their countrymen with a volley of bullets. Doernberg +fled for his life; and the revolt ended on the day after it had begun +(April 23). Schill, unconscious of Doernberg's ruin, and deceived by reports +of Austrian victories upon the Danube, led out his regiment from Berlin as +if for a day's manoeuvring, and then summoned his men to follow him in +raising a national insurrection against Napoleon. The soldiers answered +Schill's eloquent words with shouts of applause; the march was continued +westwards, and Schill crossed the Elbe, intending to fall upon the +communications of Napoleon's army, already, as he believed, staggering +under the blows delivered by the Archduke in the valley of the Danube. + +[Schill at Stralsund, May 23.] + +On reaching Halle, Schill learnt of the overthrow of the Archduke and of +Doernberg's ruin in Westphalia. All hope of success in the enterprise on +which he had quitted Berlin was dashed to the ground. The possibility of +raising a popular insurrection vanished. Schill, however, had gone too far +to recede; and even now it was not too late to join the armies of +Napoleon's enemies. Schill might move into Bohemia, or to some point on the +northern coast where he would be within reach of English vessels. But in +any case quick and steady decision was necessary; and this Schill could not +attain. Though brave even to recklessness, and gifted with qualities which +made him the idol of the public, Schill lacked the disinterestedness and +self-mastery which calm the judgment in time of trial. The sudden ruin of +his hopes left him without a plan. He wasted day after day in purposeless +marches, while the enemy collected a force to overwhelm him. His influence +over his men became impaired; the denunciations of the Prussian Government +prevented other soldiers from joining him. At length Schill determined to +recross the Elbe, and to throw himself into the coast town of Stralsund, in +Swedish Pomerania. He marched through Mecklenburg, and suddenly appeared +before Stralsund at moment when the French cannoneers in garrison were +firing a salvo in honour of Napoleon's entry into Vienna. A hand-to-hand +fight gave Schill possession of the town, with all its stores. For a moment +it seemed as if Stralsund might become a second Saragossa; but the French +were at hand before it was possible to create works of defence. Schill had +but eighteen hundred men, half of whom were cavalry; he understood nothing +of military science, and would listen to no counsels. A week after his +entry into Stralsund the town was stormed by a force four times more +numerous than its defenders. Capitulation was no word for the man who had +dared to make a private war upon Napoleon; Schill could only set the +example of an heroic death. [159] The officers who were not so fortunate as +to fall with their leader were shot in cold blood, after trial by a French +court-martial. Six hundred common soldiers who surrendered were sent to the +galleys of Toulon to sicken among French thieves and murderers. The cruelty +of the conqueror, the heroism of the conquered, gave to Schill's +ill-planned venture the importance of a great act of patriotic martyrdom. +Another example had been given of self-sacrifice in the just cause. +Schill's faults were forgotten; his memory deepened the passion with which +all the braver spirits of Germany now looked for the day of reckoning with +their oppressor. [160] + +[Napoleon crosses the Danube, May 20.] + +[Battle of Aspern, May 21, 22.] + +Napoleon had finished the first act of the war of 1809 by the occupation of +Vienna; but no peace was possible until the Austrian army, which lay upon +the opposite bank of the river, had been attacked and beaten. Four miles +below Vienna the Danube is divided into two streams by the island of Lobau: +the southern stream is the main channel of the river, the northern is only +a hundred and fifty yards broad. It was here that Napoleon determined to +make the passage. The broad arm of the Danube, sheltered by the island from +the enemy's fire, was easily bridged by boats; the passage from the island +to the northern bank, though liable to be disputed by the Austrians, was +facilitated by the narrowing of the stream. On the 18th of May, Napoleon, +supposing himself to have made good the connection between the island and +the southern bank, began to bridge the northern arm of the river. His +movements were observed by the enemy, but no opposition was offered. On the +20th a body of 40,000 French crossed to the northern bank, and occupied the +villages of Aspern and Essling. This was the movement for which the +Archduke Charles, who had now 80,000 men under arms, had been waiting. +Early on the 21st a mass of heavily-laden barges was let loose by the +Austrians above the island. The waters of the Danube were swollen by the +melting of the snows, and at midday the bridges of the French over the +broad arm of the river were swept away. A little later, dense Austrian +columns were seen advancing upon the villages of Aspern and Essling, where +the French, cut off from their supports, had to meet an overpowering enemy +in front, with an impassable river in their rear. The attack began at four +in the afternoon; when night fell the French had been driven out of Aspern, +though they still held the Austrians at bay in their other position at +Essling. During the night the long bridges were repaired; forty thousand +additional troops moved across the island to the northern bank of the +Danube; and the engagement was renewed, now between equal numbers, on the +following morning. Five times the village of Aspern was lost and won. In +the midst of the struggle the long bridges were again carried away. Unable +to break the enemy, unable to bring up any new forces from Vienna, Napoleon +ordered a retreat. The army was slowly withdrawn into the island of Lobau. +There for the next two days it lay without food and without ammunition, +severed from Vienna, and exposed to certain destruction if the Archduke +could have thrown his army across the narrow arm of the river and renewed +the engagement. But the Austrians were in no condition to follow up their +victory. Their losses were enormous; their stores were exhausted. The +moments in which a single stroke might have overthrown the whole fabric of +Napoleon's power were spent in forced inaction. By the third day after the +battle of Aspern the communications between the island and the mainland +were restored, and Napoleon's energy had brought the army out of immediate +danger. + +[Effect on Europe.] + +[Brunswick invades Saxony.] + +Nevertheless, although the worst was averted, and the French now lay secure +in their island fortress, the defeat of Aspern changed the position of +Napoleon in the eyes of all Europe. The belief in his invincibility was +destroyed; he had suffered a defeat in person, at the head of his finest +troops, from an enemy little superior in strength to himself. The disasters +of the Austrians in the opening of the campaign were forgotten; everywhere +the hopes of resistance woke into new life. Prussian statesmen urged their +King to promise his support if Austria should gain one more victory. Other +enemies were ready to fall upon Napoleon without waiting for this +condition. England collected an immense armament destined for an attack +upon some point of the northern coast. Germany, lately mute and nerveless, +gave threatening signs. The Duke of Brunswick, driven from his inheritance +after his father's death at Jena, invaded the dominions of Napoleon's +vassal, the King of Saxony, and expelled him from his capital. Popular +insurrections broke out in Wuertemberg and in Westphalia, and proved the +rising force of national feeling even in districts where the cause of +Germany lately seemed so hopelessly lost. + +[Napoleon's preparations for the second passage of the Danube, June.] + +[French cross the Danube, July 4.] + +But Napoleon concerned himself little with these remoter enemies. Every +energy of his mind was bent to the one great issue on which victory +depended, the passage of the Danube. His chances of success were still +good, if the French troops watching the enemy between Vienna and the +Adriatic could be brought up in time for the final struggle. The Archduke +Charles was in no hurry for a battle, believing that every hour increased +the probability of an attack upon Napoleon by England or Prussia, or +insurgent Germany. Never was the difference between Napoleon and his ablest +adversaries more strikingly displayed than in the work which was +accomplished by him during this same interval. He had determined that in +the next battle his army should march across the Danube as safely and as +rapidly as it could march along the streets of Vienna. Two solid bridges +were built on piles across the broad arm of the river; no less than six +bridges of rafts were made ready to be thrown across the narrow arm when +the moment arrived for the attack. By the end of June all the outlying +divisions of the French army had gathered to the great rallying-point; a +hundred and eighty thousand men were in the island, or ready to enter it; +every movement, every position to be occupied by each member of this vast +mass in its passage and advance, was fixed down to the minutest details. +Napoleon had decided to cross from the eastern, not from the northern side +of the island, and thus to pass outside the fortifications which the +Archduke had erected on the former battlefield. Towards midnight on the 4th +of July, in the midst of a violent storm, the six bridges were successively +swung across the river. The artillery opened fire. One army corps after +another, each drawn up opposite to its own bridge, marched to the northern +shore, and by sunrise nearly the whole of Napoleon's force deployed on the +left bank of the Danube. The river had been converted into a great highway; +the fortifications which had been erected by the Archduke were turned by +the eastward direction of the passage. All that remained for the Austrian +commander was to fight a pitched battle on ground that was now at least +thoroughly familiar to him. Charles had taken up a good position on the +hills that look over the village of Wagram. Here, with 130,000 men, he +awaited the attack of the French. The first attack was made in the +afternoon after the crossing of the river. It failed; and the French army +lay stretched during the night between the river and the hills, while the +Archduke prepared to descend upon their left on the morrow, and to force +himself between the enemy and the bridges behind them. + +[Battle of Wagram, July 5, 6.] + +[Armistice of Zuaim, July 12.] + +Early on the morning of the 6th the two largest armies that had ever been +brought face to face in Europe began their onslaught. Spectators from the +steeples of Vienna saw the fire of the French little by little receding on +their left, and dense masses of the Austrians pressing on towards the +bridges, on whose safety the existence of the French army depended. But ere +long the forward movement stopped. Napoleon had thrown an overpowering +force against the Austrian centre, and the Archduke found himself compelled +to recall his victorious divisions and defend his own threatened line. +Gradually the superior numbers of the French forced the enemy back. The +Archduke John, who had been ordered up from Presburg, failed to appear on +the field; and at two o'clock Charles ordered a retreat. The order of the +Austrians was unbroken; they had captured more prisoners than they had +lost; their retreat was covered by so powerful an artillery that the French +could make no pursuit. The victory was no doubt Napoleon's, but it was a +victory that had nothing in common with Jena and Austerlitz. Nothing was +lost by the Austrians at Wagram but their positions and the reputation of +their general. The army was still in fighting-order, with the fortresses of +Bohemia behind it. Whether Austria would continue the war depended on the +action of the other European Powers. If Great Britain successfully landed +an armament in Northern Germany or dealt any overwhelming blow in Spain, if +Prussia declared war on Napoleon, Austria might fight on. If the other +Powers failed, Austria, must make peace. The armistice of Zuaim, concluded +on the 12th of July, was recognised on all sides as a mere device to gain +time. There was a pause in the great struggle in the central Continent. Its +renewal or its termination depended upon the issue of events at a distance. + +[Wellesley invades Spain, June, 1809.] + +[Talavera, July 27.] + +[Wellesley retreats to Portugal.] + +For the moment the eyes of all Europe were fixed upon the British army in +Spain. Sir Arthur Wellesley, who took command at Lisbon in the spring, had +driven Soult out of Oporto, and was advancing by the valley of the Tagus +upon the Spanish capital. Some appearance of additional strength was given +to him by the support of a Spanish army under the command of General +Cuesta. Wellesley's march had, however, been delayed by the neglect and bad +faith of the Spanish Government, and time had been given to Soult to +collect a large force in the neighbourhood of Salamanca, ready either to +fall upon Wellesley from the north, or to unite with another French army +which lay at Talavera, if its commander, Victor, had the wisdom to postpone +an engagement. The English general knew nothing of Soult's presence on his +flank: he continued his march towards Madrid along the valley of the Tagus, +and finally drew up for battle at Talavera, when Victor, after retreating +before Cuesta to some distance, hunted back his Spanish pursuer to the +point from which he had started. [161] The first attack was made by Victor +upon the English positions at evening on the 27th of July. Next morning the +assault was renewed, and the battle became general. Wellesley gained a +complete victory, but the English themselves suffered heavily, and the army +remained in its position. Within the next few days Soult was discovered to +be descending from the mountains between Salamanca and the Tagus. A force +superior to Wellesley's own threatened to close upon him from the rear, and +to hem him in between two fires. The sacrifices of Talavera proved to have +been made in vain. Wellesley had no choice but to abandon his advance upon +the Spanish capital, and to fall back upon Portugal by the roads south of +the Tagus. In spite of the defeat of Victor, the French were the winners of +the campaign. Madrid was still secure; the fabric of French rule in the +Spanish Peninsula was still unshaken. The tidings of Wellesley's retreat +reached Napoleon and the Austrian negotiators, damping the hopes of +Austria, and easing Napoleon's fears. Austria's continuance of the war now +depended upon the success or failure of the long-expected descent of an +English army upon the northern coast of Europe. + +Three months before the Austrian Government declared war upon Napoleon, it +had acquainted Great Britain with its own plans, and urged the Cabinet to +dispatch an English force to Northern Germany. Such a force, landing at the +time of the battle of Aspern, would certainly have aroused both Prussia and +the country between the Elbe and the Maine. But the difference between a +movement executed in time and one executed weeks and months too late was +still unknown at the English War Office. The Ministry did not even begin +their preparations till the middle of June, and then they determined, in +pursuance of a plan made some years earlier, to attack the French fleet and +docks at Antwerp, and to ignore that patriotic movement in Northern Germany +from which they had so much to hope. + +[British Expedition against Antwerp, July, 1809.] + +[Total failure.] + +On the 28th of July, two months after the battle of Aspern and three weeks +after the battle of Wagram, a fleet of thirty-seven ships of the line, with +innumerable transports and gunboats, set sail from Dover for the Schelde. +Forty thousand troops were on board; the commander of the expedition was +the Earl of Chatham, a court-favourite in whom Nature avenged herself upon +Great Britain for what she had given to this country in his father and his +younger brother. The troops were landed on the island of Walcheren. Instead +of pushing forward to Antwerp with all possible haste, and surprising it +before any preparations could be made for its defence, Lord Chatham placed +half his army on the banks of various canals, and with the other half +proceeded to invest Flushing. On the 16th of August this unfortunate town +surrendered, after a bombardment that had reduced it to a mass of ruins. +During the next ten days the English commander advanced about as many +miles, and then discovered that for all prospect of taking Antwerp he might +as well have remained in England. Whilst Chatham was groping about in +Walcheren, the fortifications of Antwerp were restored, the fleet carried +up the river, and a mass of troops collected sufficient to defend the town +against a regular siege. Defeat stared the English in the face. At the end +of August the general recommended the Government to recall the expedition, +only leaving a force of 15,000 soldiers to occupy the marshes of Walcheren. +Chatham's recommendations were accepted; and on a spot so notoriously +pestiferous that Napoleon had refused to permit a single French soldier to +serve there on garrison duty, [162] an English army-corps, which might at +least have earned the same honour as Schill and Brunswick in Northern +Germany, was left to perish of fever and ague. When two thousand soldiers +were in their graves, the rest were recalled to England. + +[Austria makes peace.] + +Great Britain had failed to weaken or to alarm Napoleon; the King of +Prussia made no movement on behalf of the losing cause; and the Austrian +Government unwillingly found itself compelled to accept conditions of +peace. It was not so much a deficiency in its forces as the universal +distrust of its generals that made it impossible for Austria to continue +the war. The soldiers had fought as bravely as the French, but in vain. "If +we had a million soldiers," it was said, "we must make peace; for we have +no one to command them." Count Stadion, who was for carrying on the war to +the bitter end, despaired of throwing his own energetic courage into the +men who surrounded the Emperor, and withdrew from public affairs. For week +after week the Emperor fluctuated between the acceptance of Napoleon's hard +conditions and the renewal of a struggle which was likely to involve his +own dethronement as well as the total conquest of the Austrian State. At +length Napoleon's demands were presented in the form of an ultimatum. In +his distress the Emperor's thoughts turned towards the Minister who, eight +years before, had been so strong, so resolute, when all around him wavered. +Thugut, now seventy-six years old, was living in retirement. The Emperor +sent one of his generals to ask his opinion on peace or war. "I thought to +find him," reported the general, "broken in mind and body; but the fire of +his spirit is in its full force." Thugut's reply did honour to his +foresight: "Make peace at any price. The existence of the Austrian monarchy +is at stake: the dissolution of the French Empire is not far off." On the +14th of October the Emperor Francis accepted his conqueror's terms, and +signed conditions of peace. [163] + +[Peace of Vienna, Oct. 14, 1809.] + +[Real effects of the war of 1809.] + +The Treaty of Vienna, the last which Napoleon signed as a conqueror, took +from the Austrian Empire 50,000 square miles of territory and more than +4,000,000 inhabitants. Salzburg, with part of Upper Austria, was ceded to +Bavaria; Western Galicia, the territory gained by Austria in the final +partition of Poland, was transferred to the Grand-Duchy of Warsaw; part of +Carinthia, with the whole of the country lying between the Adriatic and the +Save as far as the frontier of Bosnia, was annexed to Napoleon's own +Empire, under the title of the Illyrian Provinces. Austria was cut off from +the sea, and the dominion of Napoleon extended without a break to the +borders of Turkey. Bavaria and Saxony, the outposts of French sovereignty +in Central Europe, were enriched at the expense of the Power which had +called Germany to arms; Austria, which at the beginning of the +Revolutionary War had owned territory upon the Rhine and exercised a +predominating influence over all Italy, seemed now to be finally excluded +both from Germany and the Mediterranean. Yet, however striking the change +of frontier which gave to Napoleon continuous dominion from the Straits of +Calais to the border of Bosnia, the victories of France in 1809 brought in +their train none of those great moral changes which had hitherto made each +French conquest a stage in European progress. The campaign of 1796 had +aroused the hope of national independence in Italy; the settlements of 1801 +and 1806 had put an end to Feudalism in Western Germany; the victories of +1809 originated nothing but a change of frontier such as the next war might +obliterate and undo. All that was permanent in the effects of the year 1809 +was due, not to any new creations of Napoleon, but to the spirit of +resistance which France had at length excited in Europe. The revolt of the +Tyrol, the exploits of Brunswick and Schill, gave a stimulus to German +patriotism which survived the defeat of Austria. Austria itself, though +overpowered, had inflicted a deadly injury upon Napoleon, by withdrawing +him from Spain at the moment when he might have completed its conquest, and +by enabling Wellesley to gain a footing in the Peninsula. Napoleon appeared +to have gathered a richer spoil from the victories of 1809 than from any of +his previous wars; in reality he had never surrounded himself with so many +dangers. Russia was alienated by the annexation of West Galicia to the +Polish Grand Duchy of Warsaw; Northern Germany had profited by the examples +of courage and patriotism shown so largely in 1809 on behalf of the +Fatherland; Spain, supported by Wellesley's army, was still far from +submission. The old indifference which had smoothed the way for the earlier +French conquests was no longer the characteristic of Europe. The +estrangement of Russia, the growth of national spirit in Germany and in +Spain, involved a danger to Napoleon's power which far outweighed the +visible results of his victory. + +[Austria and the Tyrol.] + +Austria itself could only acquiesce in defeat: nor perhaps would the +permanent interests of Europe have been promoted by its success. The +championship of Germany which it assumed at the beginning of the war would +no doubt have resulted in the temporary establishment of some form of +German union under Austrian leadership, if the event of the war had been +different; but the sovereign of Hungary and Croatia could never be the true +head of the German people; and the conduct of the Austrian Government after +the peace of 1809 gave little reason to regret its failure to revive a +Teutonic Empire. No portion of the Emperor's subjects had fought for him +with such determined loyalty as the Tyrolese. After having been the first +to throw off the yoke of the stranger, they had again and again freed their +country when Napoleon's generals supposed all resistance overcome; and in +return for their efforts the Emperor had solemnly assured them that he +would never accept a peace which did not restore them to his Empire. If +fair dealing was due anywhere it was due from the Court of Austria to the +Tyrolese. Yet the only reward of the simple courage of these mountaineers +was that the war-party at head-quarters recklessly employed them as a means +of prolonging, hostilities after the armistice of Znaim, and that up to the +moment when peace was signed they were left in the belief that the Emperor +meant to keep his promise, Austria, however, could not ruin herself to +please the Tyrolese. Circumstances were changed; and the phrases of +patriotism which had excited so much rejoicing at the beginning of the war +were now fallen out of fashion at Vienna. Nothing more was heard about the +rights of nations and the deliverance of Germany. Austria had made a great +venture and failed; and the Government rather resumed than abandoned its +normal attitude in turning its back upon the professions of 1809. + +[Austrian policy after 1809.] + +[Metternich.] + +Henceforward the policy of Austria was one of calculation, untinged by +national sympathies. France had been a cruel enemy; yet if there was a +prospect of winning something for Austria by a French alliance, +considerations of sentiment could not be allowed to stand in the way. A +statesman who, like Count Stadion, had identified the interests of Austria +with the liberation of Germany, was no fitting helmsman for the State in +the shifting course that now lay before it. A diplomatist was called to +power who had hitherto by Napoleon's own desire represented the Austrian +State at Paris. Count Metternich, the new Chief Minister, was the son of a +Rhenish nobleman who had held high office under the Austrian crown. His +youth had been passed at Coblentz, and his character and tastes were those +which in the eighteenth century had marked the court-circles of the little +Rhenish Principalities, French in their outer life, unconscious of the +instinct of nationality, polished and seductive in that personal management +which passed for the highest type of statesmanship. Metternich had been +ambassador at Dresden and at Berlin before he went to Paris. Napoleon had +requested that he might be transferred to the Court of the Tuileries, on +account of the marked personal courtesy shown by Metternich to the French +ambassador at Berlin during the war between France and Austria in 1805. +Metternich carried with him all the friendliness of personal intercourse +which Napoleon expected in him, but he also carried with him a calm and +penetrating self-possession, and the conviction that Napoleon would give +Europe no rest until his power was greatly diminished. He served Austria +well at Paris, and in the negotiations for peace which followed the battle +of Wagram he took a leading part. After the disasters of 1809, when war was +impossible and isolation ruin, no statesman could so well serve Austria as +one who had never confessed himself the enemy of any Power; and, with the +full approval of Napoleon, the late Ambassador at Paris was placed at the +head of the Austrian State. + +[Marriage of Napoleon with Marie Louise, 1810.] + +[Severance of Napoleon and Alexander.] + +Metternich's first undertaking gave singular evidence of the flexibility of +system which was henceforward to guard Austria's interests. Before the +grass had grown over the graves at Wagram, the Emperor Francis was +persuaded to give his daughter in marriage to Napoleon. For some time past +Napoleon had determined on divorcing Josephine and allying himself to one +of the reigning houses of the Continent. His first advances were made at +St. Petersburg; but the Czar hesitated to form a connection which his +subjects would view as a dishonour; and the opportunity was seized by the +less fastidious Austrians as soon as the fancies of the imperial suitor +turned towards Vienna. The Emperor Francis, who had been bullied by +Napoleon upon the field of Austerlitz, ridiculed and insulted in every +proclamation issued during the late campaign, gave up his daughter for what +was called the good of his people, and reconciled himself to a son-in-law +who had taken so many provinces for his dowry. Peace had not been +proclaimed four months when the treaty was signed which united the House of +Bonaparte to the family of Marie Antoinette. The Archduke Charles +represented Napoleon in the espousals; the Archbishop of Vienna anointed +the bride with the same sacred oil with which he had consecrated the +banners of 1809; the servile press which narrated the wedding festivities +found no space to mention that the Emperor's bravest subject, the Tyrolese +leader Hofer, was executed by Napoleon as a brigand in the interval between +the contract and the celebration of the marriage. Old Austrian families, +members of the only aristocracy upon the Continent that still possessed +political weight and a political tradition, lamented the Emperor's consent +to a union which their prejudices called a mis-alliance, and their +consciences an adultery; but the object of Metternich was attained. The +friendship between France and Russia, which had inflicted so much evil on +the Continent since the Peace of Tilsit, was dissolved; the sword of +Napoleon was turned away from Austria for at least some years; the +restoration of the lost provinces of the Hapsburg seemed not impossible, +now that Napoleon and Alexander were left face to face in Europe, and the +alliance of Austria had become so important to the power which had hitherto +enriched itself at Austria's expense. + +[Napoleon annexes Papal States, May, 1809.] + +Napoleon crowned his new bride, and felt himself at length the equal of the +Hapsburgs and the Bourbons. Except in Spain, his arms were no longer +resisted upon the Continent, and the period immediately succeeding the +Peace of Vienna was that which brought the Napoleonic Empire to its widest +bounds. Already, in the pride of the first victories of 1809, Napoleon had +completed his aggressions upon the Papal sovereignty by declaring the +Ecclesiastical States to be united to the French Empire (May 17, 1809). The +Pope retorted upon his despoiler with a Bull of Excommunication; but the +spiritual terrors were among the least formidable of those then active in +Europe, and the sanctity of the Pontiff did not prevent Napoleon's soldiers +from arresting him in the Quirinal, and carrying him as a prisoner to +Savona. Here Pius VII., was detained for the next three years. The Roman +States received the laws and the civil organisation of France. [164] +Bishops and clergy who refused the oath of fidelity to Napoleon were +imprisoned or exiled; the monasteries and convents were dissolved; the +cardinals and great officers, along with the archives and the whole +apparatus of ecclesiastical rule, were carried to Paris. In relation to the +future of European Catholicism, the breach between Napoleon and Pius VII., +was a more important event than was understood at the time; its immediate +and visible result was that there was one sovereign the fewer in Europe, +and one more province opened to the French conscription. + +[Napoleon annexes, Holland, July, 1810.] + +The next of Napoleon's vassals who lost his throne was the King of Holland. +Like Joseph in Spain, and like Murat in Naples, Louis Bonaparte had made an +honest effort to govern for the benefit of his subjects. He had endeavoured +to lighten the burdens which Napoleon laid upon the Dutch nation, already +deprived of its colonies, its commerce, and its independence; and every +plea which Louis had made for his subjects had been treated by Napoleon as +a breach of duty towards himself. The offence of the unfortunate King of +Holland became unpardonable when he neglected to enforce the orders of +Napoleon against the admission of English goods. Louis was summoned to +Paris, and compelled to sign a treaty, ceding part of his dominions and +placing his custom-houses in the hands of French officers. He returned to +Holland, but affairs grew worse and worse. French troops overran the +country; Napoleon's letters were each more menacing than the last; and at +length Louis fled from his dominions (July 1, 1810), and delivered himself +from a royalty which had proved the most intolerable kind of servitude. A +week later Holland was incorporated with the French Empire. + +[Annexation of Le Valais, and of the North German coast.] + +Two more annexations followed before the end of the year. The Republic of +the Valais was declared to have neglected the duty imposed upon it of +repairing the road over the Simplon, and forfeited its independence. The +North German coast district, comprising the Hanse towns, Oldenburg, and +part of the Kingdom of Westphalia, was annexed to the French Empire, with +the alleged object of more effectually shutting out British goods from the +ports of the Elbe and the Weser. Hamburg, however, and most of the +territory now incorporated with France, had been occupied by French troops +ever since the war of 1806, and the legal change in its position scarcely +made its subjection more complete. Had the history of this annexation been +written by men of the peasant-class, it would probably have been described +in terms of unmixed thankfulness and praise. In the Decree introducing the +French principle of the free tenure of land, thirty-six distinct forms of +feudal service are enumerated, as abolished without compensation. [165] + +[Extent of Napoleon's Empire and Dependencies, 1810.] + +Napoleon's dominion had now reached its widest bounds. The frontier of the +Empire began at Luebeck on the Baltic, touched the Rhine at Wesel, and +followed the river and the Jura mountains to the foot of the Lake of +Geneva; then, crossing the Alps above the source of the Rhone, it ran with +the rivers Sesia and Po to a point nearly opposite Mantua, mounted to the +watershed of the Apennines, and descended to the Mediterranean at +Terracina. The late Ecclesiastical States were formed into the two +Departments of the Tiber and of Trasimene; Tuscany, also divided into +French Departments, and represented in the French Legislative Body, gave +the title of Archduchess and the ceremonial of a Court to Napoleon's sister +Eliza; the Kingdom of Italy, formed by Lombardy, Venice, and the country +east of the Apennines as far south as Ascoli, belonged to Napoleon himself, +but was not constitutionally united with the French Empire. On the east of +the Adriatic the Illyrian Provinces extended Napoleon's rule to the borders +of Bosnia and Montenegro. Outside the frontier of this great Empire an +order of feudatories ruled in Italy, in Germany, and in Poland. Murat, King +of Naples, and the client-princes of the Confederation of the Rhine, +holding all Germany up to the frontiers of Prussia and Austria, as well as +the Grand-Duchy of Warsaw, were nominally sovereigns within their own +dominions; but they held their dignities at Napoleon's pleasure, and the +population and revenues of their States were at his service. + +[Benefits of Napoleon's rule.] + +[Wrongs of Napoleon's rule.] + +[Commercial blockade.] + +The close of the year 1810 saw the last changes effected which Europe was +destined to receive at the hands of Napoleon. The fabric of his sovereignty +was raised upon the ruins of all that was obsolete and forceless upon the +western Continent; the benefits as well as the wrongs or his supremacy were +now seen in their widest operation. All Italy, the northern districts of +Germany which were incorporated with the Empire, and a great part of the +Confederate Territory of the Rhine, received in the Code Napoleon a law +which, to an extent hitherto unknown in Europe, brought social justice into +the daily affairs of life. The privileges of the noble, the feudal burdens +of the peasant, the monopolies of the guilds, passed away, in most +instances for ever. The comfort and improvement of mankind were vindicated +as the true aim of property by the abolition of the devices which convert +the soil into an instrument of family pride, and by the enforcement of a +fair division of inheritances among the children of the possessor. Legal +process, both civil and criminal, was brought within the comprehension of +ordinary citizens, and submitted to the test of publicity. These were among +the fruits of an earlier enlightenment which Napoleon's supremacy bestowed +upon a great part of Europe. The price which was paid for them was the +suppression of every vestige of liberty, the conscription, and the +Continental blockade. On the whole, the yoke was patiently borne. The +Italians and the Germans of the Rhenish Confederacy cared little what +Government they obeyed; their recruits who were sent to be killed by the +Austrians or the Spaniards felt it no especial hardship to fight Napoleon's +battles. More galling was the pressure of Napoleon's commercial system and +of the agencies by which he attempted to enforce it. In the hope of ruining +the trade of Great Britain, Napoleon spared no severity against the owners +of anything that had touched British hands, and deprived the Continent of +its entire supply of colonial produce, with the exception of such as was +imported at enormous charges by traders licensed by himself. The possession +of English goods became a capital offence. In the great trading towns a +system of permanent terrorism was put in force against the merchants. +Soldiers ransacked their houses; their letters were opened; spies dogged +their steps. It was in Hamburg, where Davoust exercised a sort of +independent sovereignty, that the violence and injustice of the Napoleonic +commercial system was seen in its most repulsive form; in the greater part +of the Empire it was felt more in the general decline of trade and in a +multitude of annoying privations than in acts of obtrusive cruelty. [166] +The French were themselves compelled to extract sugar from beetroot, and to +substitute chicory for coffee; the Germans, less favoured by nature, and +less rapid in adaptation, thirsted and sulked. Even in such torpid +communities as Saxony political discontent was at length engendered by +bodily discomfort. Men who were proof against all the patriotic exaltation +of Stein and Fichte felt that there must be something wrong in a system +which sent up the price of coffee to five shillings a pound, and reduced +the tobacconist to exclusive dependence upon the market-gardener. + +[The Czar withdraws from Napoleon's commercial system, Dec., 1810.] + +[France and Russia preparing for war, 1811.] + +It was not, however, by its effects upon Napoleon's German vassals that the +Continental system contributed to the fall of its author. Whatever the +discontent of these communities, they obeyed Napoleon as long as he was +victorious, and abandoned him only when his cause was lost. Its real +political importance lay in the hostility which it excited between France +and Russia. The Czar, who had attached himself to Napoleon's commercial +system at the Peace of Tilsit, withdrew from it in the year succeeding the +Peace of Vienna. The trade of the Russian Empire had been ruined by the +closure of its ports to British vessels and British goods. Napoleon had +broken his promise to Russia by adding West Galicia to the Polish Duchy of +Warsaw; and the Czar refused to sacrifice the wealth of his subjects any +longer in the interest of an insincere ally. At the end of the year 1810 an +order was published at St. Petersburg, opening the harbours of Russia to +all ships bearing a neutral flag, and imposing a duty upon many of the +products of France. This edict was scarcely less than a direct challenge to +the French Emperor. Napoleon exaggerated the effect of his Continental +prohibitions upon English traffic. He imagined that the command of the +European coast-line, and nothing short of this, would enable him to exhaust +his enemy; and he was prepared to risk a war with Russia rather than permit +it to frustrate his long-cherished hopes. Already in the Austrian marriage +Napoleon had marked the severance of his interests from those of Alexander. +An attempted compromise upon the affairs of Poland produced only new +alienation and distrust; an open affront was offered to Alexander in the +annexation of the Duchy of Oldenburg, whose sovereign was a member of his +own family. The last event was immediately followed by the publication of +the new Russian tariff. In the spring of 1811 Napoleon had determined upon +war. With Spain still unsubdued, he had no motive to hurry on hostilities; +Alexander on his part was still less ready for action; and the forms of +diplomatic intercourse were in consequence maintained for some time longer +at Paris and St. Petersburg. But the true nature of the situation was shown +by the immense levies that were ordered both in France and Russia; and the +rest of the year was spent in preparations for the campaign which was +destined to decide the fate of Europe. + +[Affairs in Spain and Portugal, 1809-1812.] + +[Lines of Torres Vedras, 1809-1810.] + +We have seen that during the period of more than two years that elapsed +between the Peace of Vienna and the outbreak of war with Russia, Napoleon +had no enemy in arms upon the Continent except in the Spanish Peninsula. +Had the Emperor himself taken up the command in Spain, he would probably +within a few months have crushed both the Spanish armies and their English +ally. A fatal error in judgment made him willing to look on from a distance +whilst his generals engaged with this last foe. The disputes with the Pope +and the King of Holland might well have been adjourned for another year; +but Napoleon felt no suspicions that the conquest of the Spanish Peninsula +was too difficult a task for his marshals; nor perhaps would it have been +so if Wellington had been like any of the generals whom Napoleon had +himself encountered. The French forces in the Peninsula numbered over +300,000 men: in spite of the victory of Talavera, the English had been +forced to retreat into Portugal. But the warfare of Wellington was a +different thing from that even of the best Austrian or Russian commanders. +From the time of the retreat from Talavera he had foreseen that Portugal +would be invaded by an army far outnumbering his own; and he planned a +scheme of defence as original, as strongly marked with true military +insight, as Napoleon's own most daring schemes of attack. Behind Lisbon a +rugged mountainous tract stretches from the Tagus to the sea: here, while +the English army wintered in the neighbourhood of Almeida, Wellington +employed thousands of Portuguese labourers in turning the promontory into +one vast fortress. No rumour of the operation was allowed to reach the +enemy. A double series of fortifications, known as the Lines of Torres +Vedras, followed the mountain-bastion on the north of Lisbon, and left no +single point open between the Tagus and the sea. This was the barrier to +which Wellington meant in the last resort to draw his assailants, whilst +the country was swept of everything that might sustain an invading army, +and the irregular troops of Portugal closed in upon its rear. [167] + +[Retreat of Massena, 1810-11.] + +[Massena's campaign against Wellington, 1810.] + +In June, 1810, Marshal Massena, who had won the highest distinction at +Aspern and Wagram, arrived in Spain, and took up the command of the army +destined for the conquest of Portugal. Ciudad Rodrigo was invested: +Wellington, too weak to effect its relief, too wise to jeopardise his army +for the sake of Spanish praise, lay motionless while this great fortress +fell into the hands of the invader. In September, the French, 70,000 +strong, entered Portugal. Wellington retreated down the valley of the +Mondego, devastating the country. At length he halted at Busaco and gave +battle (September 27). The French were defeated; the victory gave the +Portuguese full confidence in the English leader; but other roads were open +to the invader, and Wellington continued his retreat. Massena followed, and +heard for the first time of the fortifications of Torres Vedras when he was +within five days' march of them. On nearing the mountain-barrier, Massena +searched in vain for an unprotected point. Fifty thousand English and +Portuguese regular troops, besides a multitude of Portuguese militia, were +collected behind the lines; with the present number of the French an +assault was hopeless. Massena waited for reinforcements. It was with the +utmost difficulty that he could keep his army from starving; at length, +when the country was utterly exhausted, he commenced his retreat (Nov. 14). +Wellington descended from the heights, but his marching force was still too +weak to risk a pitched battle. Massena halted and took post at Santarem, on +the Tagus. Here, and in the neighbouring valley of the Zezere, he +maintained himself during the winter. But in March, 1811, reinforcements +arrived from England: Wellington moved forward against his enemy, and the +retreat of the French began in real earnest. Massena made his way +northwards, hard pressed by the English, and devastating the country with +merciless severity in order to retard pursuit. Fire and ruin marked the +track of the retreating army; but such were the sufferings of the French +themselves, both during the invasion and the retreat, that when Massena +re-entered Spain, after a campaign in which only one pitched battle had +been fought, his loss exceeded 30,000 men. + +[Soult conquers Spain as far as Cadiz.] + +[Wellington's campaign of 1811.] + +Other French armies, in spite of a most destructive guerilla warfare, were +in the meantime completing the conquest of the south and the east of Spain. +Soult captured Seville, and began to lay siege to Cadiz. Here, at the end +of 1810, an order reached him from Napoleon to move to the support of +Massena. Leaving Victor in command at Cadiz, Soult marched northwards, +routed the Spaniards, and conquered the fortress of Badajoz, commanding the +southern road into Portugal. Massena, however, was already in retreat, and +Soult's own advance was cut short by intelligence that Graham, the English +general in Cadiz, had broken out upon the besiegers and inflicted a heavy +defeat. Soult returned to Cadiz and resumed the blockade. Wellington, thus +freed from danger of attack from the south, and believing Massena to be +thoroughly disabled, considered that the time had come for a forward +movement into Spain. It was necessary for him to capture the fortresses of +Almeida and Ciudad Rodrigo on the northern road, and to secure his own +communications with Portugal by wresting back Badajoz from the French. He +left a small force to besiege Almeida, and moved to Elvas to make +arrangements with Beresford for the siege of Badajoz. But before the +English commander had deemed it possible, the energy of Massena had +restored his troops to efficiency; and the two armies of Massena and Soult +were now ready to assail the English on the north and the south. Massena +marched against the corps investing Almeida. Wellington hastened back to +meet him, and fought a battle at Fuentes d'Onoro. The French were defeated; +Almeida passed into the hands of the English. In the south, Soult advanced +to the relief of Badajoz. He was overthrown by Beresford in the bloody +engagement of Albuera (May 16th); but his junction with the army of the +north, which was now transferred from Massena to Marmont, forced the +English to raise the siege; and Wellington, after audaciously offering +battle to the combined French armies, retired within the Portuguese +frontier, and marched northwards with the design of laying siege to Ciudad +Rodrigo. Again outnumbered by the French, he was compelled to retire to +cantonments on the Coa. + +[Capture of Ciudad Rodrigo, Jan. 19, 1812.] + +[Capture of Badajoz, April 6.] + +Throughout the autumn months, which were spent in forced inaction, +Wellington held patiently to his belief that the French would be unable to +keep their armies long united, on account of the scarcity of food. His +calculations were correct, and at the close of the year 1811 the English +were again superior in the field. Wellington moved against Ciudad Rodrigo, +and took it by storm on the 19th of January, 1812. The road into Spain was +opened; it only remained to secure Portugal itself by the capture of +Badajoz. Wellington crossed the Tagus on the 8th of March, and completed +the investment of Badajoz ten days later. It was necessary to gain +possession of the city, at whatever cost, before Soult could advance to its +relief. On the night of the 6th of April Wellington gave orders for the +assault. The fury of the attack, the ferocity of the English soldiers in +the moment of their victory, have made the storm of Badajoz conspicuous +amongst the most terrible events of war. But the purpose of Wellington was +effected; the base of the English army in Portugal was secured from all +possibility of attack; and at the moment when Napoleon was summoning his +veteran regiments from beyond the Pyrenees for the invasion of Russia, the +English commander, master of the frontier fortresses of Spain, was +preparing to overwhelm the weakened armies in the Peninsula, and to drive +the French from Madrid. + +[Wellington invades Spain, June 1812.] + +[Salamanca, July 22.] + +[Wellington retires to Portugal.] + +It was in the summer of 1812, when Napoleon was now upon the point of +opening the Russian campaign, that Wellington advanced against Marmont's +positions in the north of Spain and the French lines of communication with +the capital. Marmont fell back and allowed Wellington to pass Salamanca; +but on reaching the Douro he turned upon his adversary, and by a succession +of swift and skilful marches brought the English into some danger of losing +their communications with Portugal. Wellington himself now retreated as far +as Salamanca, and there gave battle (July 22). A decisive victory freed the +English army from its peril, and annihilated all the advantages gained by +Marmont's strategy and speed. The French were so heavily defeated that they +had to fall back on Burgos. Wellington marched upon Madrid. At his approach +King Joseph fled from the capital, and ordered Soult to evacuate Andalusia, +and to meet him at Valencia, on the eastern coast. Wellington entered +Madrid amidst the wild rejoicing of the Spaniards, and then turned +northwards to complete the destruction of the army which he had beaten at +Salamanca. But the hour of his final success was not yet come. His advance +upon Madrid, though wise as a political measure, had given the French +northern army time to rally. He was checked by the obstinate defence of +Burgos; and finding the French strengthened by the very abandonment of +territory which his victory had forced upon them, he retired to Portugal, +giving to King Joseph a few months' more precarious enjoyment of his +vassal-sovereignty before his final and irrevocable overthrow. + +[The war excites a constitutional movement in Spain.] + +In Spain itself the struggle of the nation for its independence had +produced a political revolution as little foreseen by the Spaniards as by +Napoleon himself when the conflict began. When, in 1808, the people had +taken up arms for its native dynasty, the voices of those who demanded a +reform in the abuses of the Bourbon government had scarcely been heard amid +the tumult of loyal enthusiasm for Ferdinand. There existed, however, a +group of liberally-minded men in Spain; and as soon as the invasion of the +French and the subsequent successes of the Spaniards had overthrown both +the old repressive system of the Bourbons and that which Napoleon attempted +to put in its place, the opinions of these men, hitherto scarcely known +outside the circle of their own acquaintances, suddenly became a power in +the country through the liberation of the press. Jovellanos, an upright and +large-minded statesman, who had suffered a long imprisonment in the last +reign in consequence of his labours in the cause of progress, now +represented in the Central Junta the party of constitutional reform. The +Junta itself acted with but little insight or sincerity. A majority of its +members neither desired nor understood the great changes in government +which Jovellanos advocated; yet the Junta itself was an irregular and +revolutionary body, and was forced to appeal to the nation in order to hold +its ground against the old legal Councils of the monarchy, which possessed +not only a better formal right, but all the habits of authority. The +victories of Napoleon at the end of 1808, and the threatening attitude both +of the old official bodies and of the new provincial governments which had +sprung up in every part of the kingdom, extorted from the Junta in the +spring of 1809 a declaration in favour of the assembling of the Cortes, or +National Parliament, in the following year. Once made, the declaration +could not be nullified or withdrawn. It was in vain that the Junta, alarmed +at the progress of popular opinions, restored the censorship of the press, +and attempted to suppress the liberal journals. The current of political +agitation swept steadily on; and before the end of the year 1809 the +conflict of parties, which Spain was henceforward to experience in common +with the other Mediterranean States, had fairly begun. [168] + +[Spanish Liberals in 1809 and 1810.] + +The Spanish Liberals of 1809 made the same attack upon despotic power, and +upheld the same theories of popular right, as the leaders of the French +nation twenty years before. Against them was ranged the whole force of +Spanish officialism, soon to be supported by the overwhelming power of the +clergy. In the outset, however, the Liberals carefully avoided infringing +on the prerogatives of the Church. Thus accommodating its policy to the +Catholic spirit of the nation, the party of reform gathered strength +throughout the year 1809, as disaster after disaster excited the wrath of +the people against both the past and the present holders of power. It was +determined by the Junta that the Cortes should assemble on the 1st of +March, 1810. According to the ancient usage of Spain, each of the Three +Estates, the Clergy, the Nobles, and the Commons, would have been +represented in the Cortes by a separate assembly. The opponents of reform +pressed for the maintenance of this mediaeval order, the Liberals declared +for a single Chamber; the Junta, guided by Jovellanos, adopted a middle +course, and decided that the higher clergy and nobles should be jointly +represented by one Chamber, the Commons by a second. Writs of election had +already been issued, when the Junta, driven to Cadiz by the advance of the +French armies, and assailed alike by Liberals, by reactionists, and by city +mobs, ended its ineffective career, and resigned its powers into the hands +of a Regency composed of five persons (Jan. 30, 1810). Had the Regency +immediately taken steps to assemble the Cortes, Spain would probably have +been content with the moderate reforms which two Chambers, formed according +to the plans of Jovellanos, would have been likely to sanction. The +Regency, however, preferred to keep power in its own hands and ignored the +promise which the Junta had given to the nation. Its policy of obstruction, +which was continued for months after the time when the Cortes ought to have +assembled, threw the Liberal party into the hands of men of extremes, and +prepared the way for revolution instead of reform. It was only when the +report reached Spain that Ferdinand was about to marry the daughter of King +Joseph, and to accept the succession to the Spanish crown from the usurper +himself, that the Regency consented to convoke the Cortes. But it was now +no longer possible to create an Upper House to serve as a check upon the +popular Assembly. A single Chamber was elected, and elected in great part +within the walls of Cadiz itself; for the representatives of districts +where the presence of French soldiery rendered election impossible were +chosen by refugees from those districts within Cadiz, amid the tumults of +political passion which stir a great city in time of war and revolution. + +[Constitution made by the Cortes, 1812.] + +On the 24th of September, 1810, the Cortes opened. Its first act was to +declare the sovereignty of the people, its next act to declare the freedom +of the Press. In every debate a spirit of bitter hatred towards the old +system of government and of deep distrust towards Ferdinand himself +revealed itself in the speeches of the Liberal deputies, although no one in +the Assembly dared to avow the least want of loyalty towards the exiled +House. The Liberals knew how passionate was the love of the Spanish people +for their Prince; but they resolved that, if Ferdinand returned to his +throne, he should return without the power to revive the old abuses of +Bourbon rule. In this spirit the Assembly proceeded to frame a Constitution +for Spain. The Crown was treated as the antagonist and corrupter of the +people; its administrative powers were jealously reduced; it was confronted +by an Assembly to be elected every two years, and the members of this +Assembly were prohibited both from holding office under the Crown, and from +presenting themselves for re-election at the end of their two years' +service. To a Representative Body thus excluded from all possibility of +gaining any practical acquaintance with public affairs was entrusted not +only the right of making laws, but the control of every branch of +government. The executive was reduced to a mere cypher. + +[The Clergy against the Constitution.] + +Such was the Constitution which, under the fire of the French artillery now +encompassing Cadiz, the Cortes of Spain proclaimed in the spring of the +year 1812. Its principles had excited the most vehement opposition within +the Assembly itself; by the nation, or at least that part of it which was +in communication with Cadiz, it appeared to be received with enthusiasm. +The Liberals, who had triumphed over their opponents in the debates in the +Assembly, believed that their own victory was the victory of the Spanish +people over the forces of despotism. But before the first rejoicings were +over, ominous signs appeared of the strength of the opposite party, and of +the incapacity of the Liberals themselves to form any effective Government. +The fanaticism of the clergy was excited by a law partly ratifying the +suppression of monasteries begun by Joseph Bonaparte; the enactments of the +Cortes regarding the censorship of religious writings threw the Church into +open revolt. In declaring the freedom of the Press, the Cortes had +expressly guarded themselves against extending this freedom to religious +discussion; the clergy now demanded the restoration of the powers of the +Inquisition, which had been in abeyance since the beginning of the war. The +Cortes were willing to grant to the Bishops the right of condemning any +writing as heretical, and they were willing to enforce by means of the +ordinary tribunals the law which declared the Catholic religion to be the +only one permitted in Spain; but they declined to restore the jurisdiction +of the Holy Office (Feb., 1813). Without this engine for the suppression of +all mental independence the priesthood of Spain conceived its cause to be +lost. The anathema of the Church went out against the new order. Uniting +with the partisans of absolutism, whom Wellington, provoked by the +extravagances of the Liberals, now took under his protection, the clergy +excited an ignorant people against its own emancipators, and awaited the +time when the return of Ferdinand, and a combination of all the interests +hostile to reform, should overthrow the Constitution which the Liberals +fondly imagined to have given freedom to Spain. + + + + +CHAPTER X. + + +War approaching between France and Russia--Policy of Prussia--Hardenberg's +Ministry--Prussia forced into Alliance with Napoleon--Austrian Alliance-- +Napoleon's Preparations--He enters Russia--Alexander and Bernadotte--Plan +of the Russians to fight a Battle at Drissa frustrated--They retreat on +Witepsk--Sufferings of the French--French enter Smolensko--Battle of +Borodino--Evacuation of Moscow--Moscow fired--The Retreat from Moscow--The +French at Smolensko--Advance of Russian Armies from North and South-- +Battle of Krasnoi--Passage of the Beresina--The French reach the Niemen-- +York's Convention with the Russians--The Czar and Stein--Russian Army +enters Prussia--Stein raises East Prussia--Treaty of Kalisch--Prussia +declares War--Enthusiasm of the Nation--Idea of German Unity--The Landwehr. + + +[Austria and Prussia in 1811.] + +[Hardenberg's Ministry.] + +War between France and Russia was known to be imminent as early as the +spring of 1811. The approach of the conflict was watched with the deepest +anxiety by the two States of central Europe which still retained some +degree of independence. The Governments of Berlin and Vienna had been drawn +together by misfortune. The same ultimate deliverance formed the secret +hope of both; but their danger was too great to permit them to combine in +open resistance to Napoleon's will. In spite of a tacit understanding +between the two powers, each was compelled for the present to accept the +conditions necessary to secure its own existence. The situation of Prussia +in especial was one of the utmost danger. Its territory lay directly +between the French Empire and Russia; its fortresses were in the hands of +Napoleon, its resources were certain to be seized by one or other of the +hostile armies. Neutrality was impossible, however much desired by Prussia +itself; and the only question to be decided by the Government was whether +Prussia should enter the war as the ally of France or of Russia. Had the +party of Stein been in power, Prussia would have taken arms against +Napoleon at every risk. Stein, however, was in exile his friends, though +strong in the army, were not masters of the Government; the foreign policy +of the country was directed by a statesman who trusted more to time and +prudent management than to desperate resolves. Hardenberg had been recalled +to office in 1810, and permitted to resume the great measures of civil +reform which had been broken off two years before. The machinery of +Government was reconstructed upon principles that had been laid down by +Stein; agrarian reform was carried still farther by the abolition of +peasant's service, and the partition of peasant's land between the occupant +and his lord; an experiment, though a very ill-managed one, was made in the +forms of constitutional Government by the convocation of three successive +assemblies of the Notables. On the part of the privileged orders Hardenberg +encountered the most bitter opposition; his own love of absolute power +prevented him from winning popular confidence by any real approach towards +a Representative System. Nor was the foreign policy of the Minister of a +character to excite enthusiasm. A true patriot at heart, he seemed at times +to be destitute of patriotism, when he was in fact only destitute of the +power to reveal his real motives. + +[Hardenburg's foreign policy, 1811.] + +Convinced that Prussia could not remain neutral in the coming war, and +believing some relief from its present burdens to be absolutely necessary, +Hardenberg determined in the first instance to offer Prussia's support to +Napoleon, demanding in return for it a reduction of the payments still due +to France, and the removal of the limits imposed upon the Prussian army. +[169] The offer of the Prussian alliance reached Napoleon in the spring of +1811: he maintained an obstinate silence. While the Prussian envoy at Paris +vainly waited for an audience, masses of troops advanced from the Rhine +towards the Prussian frontier, and the French garrisons on the Oder were +raised far beyond their stipulated strength. In July the envoy returned +from Paris, announcing that Napoleon declined even to enter upon a +discussion of the terms proposed by Hardenberg. King Frederick William +now wrote to the Czar, proposing an alliance between Prussia and Russia. +It was not long before the report of Hardenberg's military preparations +reached Paris. Napoleon announced that if they were not immediately +suspended he should order Davoust to march on Berlin; and he presented a +counter-proposition for a Prussian alliance, which was in fact one of +unqualified submission. The Government had to decide between accepting a +treaty which placed Prussia among Napoleon's vassals, or certain war. +Hardenberg, expecting favourable news from St. Petersburg, pronounced in +favour of war; but the Czar, though anxious for the support of Prussia, +had determined on a defensive plan of operations, and declared that he +could send no troops beyond the Russian frontier. + +[Prussia accepts alliance with Napoleon Feb, 1812.] + +Prussia was thus left to face Napoleon alone. Hardenberg shrank from the +responsibility of proclaiming a war for life or death, and a treaty was +signed which added the people of Frederick the Great to that inglorious +crowd which fought at Napoleon's orders against whatever remained of +independence and nationality in Europe. [170] (Feb. 24th, 1812.) Prussia +undertook to supply Napoleon with 20,000 men for the impending campaign, +and to raise no levies and to give no orders to its troops without +Napoleon's consent. Such was the bitter termination of all those patriotic +hopes and efforts which had carried Prussia through its darkest days. +Hardenberg himself might make a merit of bending before the storm, and of +preserving for Prussia the means of striking when the time should come; but +the simpler instincts of the patriotic party felt his submission to be the +very surrender of national existence. Stein in his exile denounced the +Minister with unsparing bitterness. Scharnhorst resigned his post; many of +the best officers in the Prussian army quitted the service of King +Frederick William in order to join the Russians in the last struggle for +European liberty. + +[Alliance of Austria with Napoleon.] + +The alliance which Napoleon pressed upon Austria was not of the same +humiliating character as that which Prussia was forced to accept. Both +Metternich and the Emperor Francis would have preferred to remain neutral, +for the country was suffering from a fearful State-bankruptcy, and the +Government had been compelled to reduce its paper money, in which all debts +and salaries were payable, to a fifth of its nominal value. Napoleon, +however, insisted on Austria's co-operation. The family-relations of the +two Emperors pointed to a close alliance, and the reward which Napoleon +held out to Austria, the restoration of the Illyrian provinces, was one of +the utmost value. Nor was the Austrian contingent to be treated, like the +Prussian, as a mere French army-corps. Its operations were to be separate +from those of the French, and its command was to be held by an Austrian +general, subordinate only to Napoleon himself. On these terms Metternich +was not unwilling to enter the campaign. He satisfied his scruples by +inventing a strange diplomatic form in which Austria was still described as +a neutral, although she took part in the war, [171] and felt as little +compunction in uniting with France as in explaining to the Courts of St. +Petersburg and Berlin that the union was a hypocritical one. The Sovereign +who was about to be attacked by Napoleon, and the Sovereigns who sent their +troops to Napoleon's support, perfectly well understood one another's +position. The Prussian corps, watched and outnumbered by the French, might +have to fight the Russians because they could not help it; the Austrians, +directed by their own commander, would do no serious harm to the Russians +so long as the Russians did no harm to them. Should the Czar succeed in +giving a good account of his adversary, he would have no difficulty in +coming to a settlement with his adversary's forced allies. + +[Preparations of Napoleon for invasion of Russia.] + +The Treaties which gave to Napoleon the hollow support of Austria and +Prussia were signed early in the year 1812. During the next three months +all Northern Germany was covered with enormous masses of troops and +waggon-trains, on their way from the Rhine to the Vistula. No expedition +had ever been organised on anything approaching to the scale of the +invasion of Russia. In all the wars of the French since 1793 the enemy's +country had furnished their armies with supplies, and the generals had +trusted to their own exertions for everything but guns and ammunition. Such +a method could not, however, be followed in an invasion of Russia. The +country beyond the Niemen was no well-stocked garden, like Lombardy or +Bavaria. Provisions for a mass of 450,000 men, with all the means of +transport for carrying them far into Russia, had to be collected at Dantzig +and the fortresses of the Vistula. No mercy was shown to the unfortunate +countries whose position now made them Napoleon's harvest-field and +storehouse. Prussia was forced to supplement its military assistance with +colossal grants of supplies. The whole of Napoleon's troops upon the march +through Germany lived at the expense of the towns and villages through +which they passed; in Westphalia such was the ruin caused by military +requisitions that King Jerome wrote to Napoleon, warning him to fear the +despair of men who had nothing more to lose. [172] + +[Napoleon crosses Russian frontier, June, 1812.] + +[Alexander and Bernadotte.] + +At length the vast stores were collected, and the invading army reached the +Vistula. Napoleon himself quitted Paris on the 9th of May, and received the +homage of the Austrian and Prussian Sovereigns at Dresden. The eastward +movement of the army continued. The Polish and East Prussian districts +which had been the scene of the combats of 1807 were again traversed by +French columns. On the 23rd of June the order was given to cross the Niemen +and enter Russian territory. Out of 600,000 troops whom Napoleon had +organised for this campaign, 450,000 were actually upon the frontier. Of +these, 380,000 formed the central army, under Napoleon's own command, at +Kowno, on the Niemen; to the north, at Tilsit, there was formed a corps of +32,000, which included the contingent furnished by Prussia; the Austrians, +under Schwarzenburg, with a small French division, lay to the south, on the +borders of Galicia. Against the main army of Napoleon, the real invading +force, the Russians could only bring up 150,000 men. These were formed into +the First and Second Armies of the West. The First, or Northern Army, with +which the Czar himself was present, numbered about 100,000, under the +command of Barclay de Tolly; the Second Army, half that strength, was led +by Prince Bagration. In Southern Poland and on the Lower Niemen the French +auxiliary corps were faced by weak divisions. In all, the Russians had only +220,000 men to oppose to more than double that number of the enemy. The +principal reinforcements which they had to expect were from the armies +hitherto engaged with the Turks upon the Danube. Alexander found it +necessary to make peace with the Porte at the cost of a part of the spoils +of Tilsit. The Danubian provinces, with the exception of Bessarabia, were +restored to the Sultan, in order that Russia might withdraw its forces from +the south. Bernadotte, Crown Prince of Sweden, who was threatened with the +loss of his own dominions in the event of Napoleon's victory, concluded an +alliance with the Czar. In return for the co-operation of a Swedish army, +Alexander undertook, with an indifference to national right worthy of +Napoleon himself, to wrest Norway from Denmark, and to annex it to the +Swedish crown. + +[Russians intend to fight at Drissa.] + +[Russian armies severed, and retreat on Witepsk.] + +The head-quarters of the Russian army were at Wilna when Napoleon crossed +the Niemen. It was unknown whether the French intended to advance upon +Moscow or upon St. Petersburg; nor had any systematic plan of the campaign +been adopted by the Czar. The idea of falling back before the enemy was +indeed familiar in Russia since the war between Peter the Great and Charles +XII. of Sweden, and there was no want of good counsel in favour of a +defensive warfare; [173] but neither the Czar nor any one of his generals +understood the simple theory of a retreat in which no battles at all should +be fought. The most that was understood by a defensive system was the +occupation of an entrenched position for battle, and a retreat to a second +line of entrenchments before the engagement was repeated. The actual course +of the campaign was no result of a profound design; it resulted from the +disagreements of the general's plans, and the frustration of them all. It +was intended in the first instance to fight a battle at Drissa, on the +river Dwina. In this position, which was supposed to cover the roads both +to Moscow and St. Petersburg, a great entrenched camp had been formed, and +here the Russian army was to make its first stand against Napoleon. +Accordingly, as soon as the French crossed the Niemen, both Barclay and +Bagration were ordered by the Czar to fall back upon Drissa. But the +movements of the French army were too rapid for the Russian commanders to +effect their junction. Bagration, who lay at some distance to the south, +was cut off from his colleague, and forced to retreat along the eastern +road towards Witepsk. Barclay reached Drissa in safety, but he knew himself +to be unable to hold it alone against 300,000 men. He evacuated the lines +without waiting for the approach of the French, and fell back in the +direction taken by the second army. The first movement of defence had thus +failed, and the Czar now quitted the camp, leaving to Barclay the command +of the whole Russian forces. + +[Collapse of the French transport.] + +[Barclay and Bagration unite at Smolensko, Aug. 3.] + +Napoleon entered Wilna, the capital of Russian Poland, on the 28th of June. +The last Russian detachments had only left it a few hours before; but the +French were in no condition for immediate pursuit. Before the army reached +the Niemen the unparalleled difficulties of the campaign had become only +too clear. The vast waggon-trains broke down on the highways. The stores +were abundant, but the animals which had to transport them died of +exhaustion. No human genius, no perfection of foresight and care, could +have achieved the enormous task which Napoleon had undertaken. In spite of +a year's preparations the French suffered from hunger and thirst from the +moment that they set foot on Russian soil. Thirty thousand stragglers had +left the army before it reached Wilna; twenty-five thousand sick were in +the hospitals; the transports were at an unknown distance in the rear. At +the end of six days' march from the Niemen, Napoleon found himself +compelled to halt for nearly three weeks. The army did not leave Wilna till +the 16th of July, when Barclay had already evacuated the camp at Drissa. +When at length a march became possible, Napoleon moved upon the Upper +Dwina, hoping to intercept Barclay upon the road to Witepsk; but +difficulties of transport again brought him to a halt, and the Russian +commander reached Witepsk before his adversary. Here Barclay drew up for +battle, supposing Bagration's army to be but a short distance to the south. +In the course of the night intelligence arrived that Bagration's army was +nowhere near the rallying-point, but had been driven back towards +Smolensko. Barclay immediately gave up the thought of fighting a battle, +and took the road to Smolensko himself, leaving his watch-fires burning. +His movement was unperceived by the French; the retreat was made in good +order; and the two severed Russian armies at length effected their junction +at a point three hundred miles distant from the frontier. + +[The French waste away.] + +[French enter Smolensko, Aug. 18.] + +[Barclay superseded by Kutusoff.] + +Napoleon, disappointed of battle, entered Witepsk on the evening after the +Russians had abandoned it (July 28). Barclay's escape was, for the French, +a disaster of the first magnitude, since it extinguished all hope of +crushing the larger of the two Russian armies by overwhelming numbers in +one great and decisive engagement. The march of the French during the last +twelve days showed at what cost every further step must be made. Since +quitting Wilna the 50,000 sick and stragglers had risen to 100,000. Fever +and disease struck down whole regiments. The provisioning of the army was +beyond all human power. Of the 200,000 men who still remained, it might +almost be calculated in how many weeks the last would perish. So fearful +was the prospect that Napoleon himself thought of abandoning any further +advance until the next year, and of permitting the army to enter into +winter-quarters upon the Dwina. But the conviction that all Russian +resistance would end with the capture of Moscow hurried him on. The army +left Witepsk on the 13th of August, and followed the Russians to Smolensko. +Here the entire Russian army clamoured for battle. Barclay stood alone in +perceiving the necessity for retreat. The generals caballed against him; +the soldiers were on the point of mutiny; the Czar himself wrote to express +his impatience for an attack upon the French. Barclay nevertheless +persisted in his resolution to abandon Smolensko. He so far yielded to the +army as to permit the rearguard to engage in a bloody struggle with the +French when they assaulted the town; but the evacuation was completed under +cover of night; and when the French made their entrance into Smolensko on +the next morning they found it deserted and in rums. The surrender of +Smolensko was the last sacrifice that Barclay could extort from Russian +pride. He no longer opposed the universal cry for battle, and the retreat +was continued only with the intention of halting at the first strong +position. Barclay himself was surveying a battleground when he heard that +the command had been taken out of his hands. The Czar had been forced by +national indignation at the loss of Smolensko to remove this able soldier, +who was a Livonian by birth, and to transfer the command to Kutusotff, a +thorough Russian, whom a life-time spent in victories over the Turk had +made, in spite of his defeat at Austerlitz, the idol of the nation. + +[The French advance from Smolensko.] + +When Kutusoff reached the camp, the prolonged miseries of the French +advance had already reduced the invaders to the number of the army opposed +to them. As far as Smolensko the French had at least not suffered from the +hostility of the population, who were Poles, not Russians; but on reaching +Smolensko they entered a country where every peasant was a fanatical enemy. +The villages were burnt down by their inhabitants, the corn destroyed, and +the cattle driven into the woods. Every day's march onward from Smolensko +cost the French three thousand men. On reaching the river Moskwa in the +first week of September, a hundred and seventy-five thousand out of +Napoleon's three hundred and eighty thousand soldiers were in the +hospitals, or missing, or dead. About sixty thousand guarded the line of +march. The Russians, on the other hand, had received reinforcements which +covered their losses at Smolensko; and although detachments had been sent +to support the army of Riga, Kutusoff was still able to place over one +hundred thousand men in the field. + +[Battle of Borodino, Sept. 7.] + +[Evacuation of Moscow. French enter Moscow, Sept. 14.] + +On the 5th of September the Russian army drew up for battle at Borodino, on +the Moskwa, seventy miles west of the capital. At early morning on the 7th +the French advanced to the attack. The battle was, in proportion to its +numbers, the most sanguinary of modern times. Forty thousand French, thirty +thousand Russians were struck down. At the close of the day the French were +in possession of the enemy's ground, but the Russians, unbroken in their +order, had only retreated to a second line of defence. Both sides claimed +the victory; neither had won it. It was no catastrophe such as Napoleon +required for the decision of the war, it was no triumph sufficient to save +Russia from the necessity of abandoning its capital. Kutusoff had sustained +too heavy a loss to face the French beneath the walls of Moscow. Peace was +no nearer for the 70,000 men who had been killed or wounded in the fight. +The French steadily advanced; the Russians retreated to Moscow, and +evacuated the capital when their generals decided that they could not +encounter the French assault. The Holy City was left undefended before the +invader. But the departure of the army was the smallest part of the +evacuation. The inhabitants, partly of their own free will, partly under +the compulsion of the Governor, abandoned the city in a mass. No gloomy or +excited crowd, as at Vienna and Berlin, thronged the streets to witness the +entrance of the great conqueror, when on the 14th of September Napoleon +took possession of Moscow. His troops marched through silent and deserted +streets. In the solitude of the Kremlin Napoleon received the homage of a +few foreigners, who alone could be collected by his servants to tender to +him the submission of the city. + +[Moscow fired.] + +But the worst was yet to come. On the night after Napoleon's entry, fires +broke out in different parts of Moscow. They were ascribed at first to +accident; but when on the next day the French saw the flames gaining ground +in every direction, and found that all the means for extinguishing fire had +been removed from the city, they understood the doom to which Moscow had +been devoted by its own defenders. Count Rostopchin, the governor, had +determined on the destruction of Moscow without the knowledge of the Czar. +The doors of the prisons were thrown open. Rostopchin gave the signal by +setting fire to his own palace, and let loose his bands of incendiaries +over the city. For five days the flames rose and fell; and when, on the +evening of the 20th, the last fires ceased, three-fourths of Moscow lay in +ruins. + +[Napoleon at Moscow, Sept. 14-Oct. 19.] + +Such was the prize for which Napoleon had sacrificed 200,000 men, and +engulfed the weak remnant of his army six hundred miles deep in an enemy's +country. Throughout all the terrors of the advance Napoleon had held fast +to the belief that Alexander's resistance would end with the fall of his +capital. The events that accompanied the entry of the French into Moscow +shook his confidence; yet even now Napoleon could not believe that the Czar +remained firm against all thoughts of peace. His experience in all earlier +wars had given him confidence in the power of one conspicuous disaster to +unhinge the resolution of kings. His trust in the deepening impression made +by the fall of Moscow was fostered by negotiations begun by Kutusoff for +the very purpose of delaying the French retreat. For five weeks Napoleon +remained at Moscow as if spell-bound, unable to convince himself of his +powerlessness to break Alexander's determination, unable to face a retreat +which would display to all Europe the failure of his arms and the +termination of his career of victory. At length the approach of winter +forced him to action. It was impossible to provision the army at Moscow +during the winter months, even if there had been nothing to fear from the +enemy. Even the mocking overtures of Kutusoff had ceased. The frightful +reality could no longer be concealed. On the 19th of October the order for +retreat was given. It was not the destruction of Moscow, but the departure +of its inhabitants, that had brought the conqueror to ruin. Above two +thousand houses were still standing; but whether the buildings remained or +perished made little difference; the whole value of the capital to Napoleon +was lost when the inhabitants, whom he could have forced to procure +supplies for his army, disappeared. Vienna and Berlin had been of such +incalculable service to Napoleon because the whole native administration +placed itself under his orders, and every rich and important citizen became +a hostage for the activity of the rest. When the French gained Moscow, they +gained nothing beyond the supplies which were at that moment in the city. +All was lost to Napoleon when the class who in other capitals had been his +instruments fled at his approach. The conflagration of Moscow acted upon +all Europe as a signal of inextinguishable national hatred; as a military +operation, it neither accelerated the retreat of Napoleon nor added to the +miseries which his army had to undergo. + +[Napoleon leaves Moscow, Oct. 19.] + +[Forced to retreat by the same road.] + +The French forces which quitted Moscow in October numbered about 100,000 +men. Reinforcements had come in during the occupation of the city, and the +health of the soldiers had been in some degree restored by a month's rest. +Everything now depended upon gaining a line of retreat where food could be +found. Though but a fourth part of the army which entered Russia in the +summer, the army which left Moscow was still large enough to protect itself +against the enemy, if allowed to retreat through a fresh country; if forced +back upon the devastated line of its advance it was impossible for it to +escape destruction. Napoleon therefore determined to make for Kaluga, on +the south of Moscow, and to endeavour to gain a road to Smolensko far +distant from that by which he had come. The army moved from Moscow in a +southern direction. But its route had been foreseen by Kutusoff. At the end +of four days' march it was met by a Russian corps at Jaroslavitz. A bloody +struggle left the French in possession of the road: they continued their +advance; but it was only to find that Kutusoff, with his full strength, had +occupied a line of heights farther south, and barred the way to Kaluga. The +effort of an assault was beyond the powers of the French. Napoleon surveyed +the enemy's position, and recognised the fatal necessity of abandoning the +march southwards and returning to the wasted road by which he had advanced. +The meaning of the backward movement was quickly understood by the army. +From the moment of quitting Jaroslavitz, disorder and despair increased +with every march. Thirty thousand men were lost upon the road before a +pursuer appeared in sight. When, on the 2nd of November, the army reached +Wiazma, it numbered no more than 65,000 men. + +[Kutusoff follows by parallel road.] + +Kutusoff was unadventurous in pursuit. The necessity of moving his army +along a parallel road south of the French, in order to avoid starvation, +diminished the opportunities for attack; but the general himself disliked +risking his forces, and preferred to see the enemy's destruction effected +by the elements. At Wiazma, where, on the 3rd of November, the French were +for the first time attacked in force, Kutusoff's own delay alone saved them +from total ruin. In spite of heavy loss the French kept possession of the +road, and secured their retreat to Smolensko, where stores of food had been +accumulated, and where other and less exhausted French troops were at hand. + +[Frost, Nov. 6.] + +[French reach Smolensko, Nov. 9.] + +Up to the 6th of November the weather had been sunny and dry. On the 6th +the long-delayed terrors of Russian winter broke upon the pursuers and the +pursued. Snow darkened the air and hid the last traces of vegetation from +the starving cavalry trains. The temperature sank at times to forty degrees +of frost. Death came, sometimes in the unfelt release from misery, +sometimes in horrible forms of mutilation and disease. Both armies were +exposed to the same sufferings; but the Russians had at least such succour +as their countrymen could give; where the French sank, they died. The order +of war disappeared under conditions which made life itself the accident of +a meal or of a place by the camp-fire. Though most of the French soldiery +continued to carry their arms, the Guard alone kept its separate formation; +the other regiments marched in confused masses. From the 9th to the 13th of +November these starving bands arrived one after another at Smolensko, +expecting that here their sufferings would end. But the organisation for +distributing the stores accumulated in Smolensko no longer existed. The +perishing crowds were left to find shelter where they could; sacks of corn +were thrown to them for food. + +[Russian armies from north and south attempt to cut off French retreat.] + +[Krasnoi, Nov. 17.] + +It was impossible for Napoleon to give his wearied soldiers rest, for new +Russian armies were advancing from the north and the south to cut off their +retreat. From the Danube and from the Baltic Sea troops were pressing +forward to their meeting-point upon the rear of the invader. Witgenstein, +moving southwards at the head of the army of the Dwina, had overpowered the +French corps stationed upon that river, and made himself master of Witepsk. +The army of Bucharest, which had been toiling northwards ever since the +beginning of August, had advanced to within a few days' march of its +meeting-point with the army of the Dwina upon the line of Napoleon's +communications. Before Napoleon reached Smolensko he sent orders to Victor, +who was at Smolensko with some reserves, to march against Witgenstein and +drive him back upon the Dwina. Victor set out on his mission. During the +short halt of Napoleon in Smolensko, Kutusoff pushed forward to the west of +the French, and took post at Krasnoi, thirty miles farther along the road +by which Napoleon had to pass. The retreat of the French seemed to be +actually cut off. Had the Russian general dared to face Napoleon and his +Guards, he might have held the French in check until the arrival of the two +auxiliary armies from the north and south enabled him to capture Napoleon +and his entire force. Kutusoff, however, preferred a partial and certain +victory to a struggle with Napoleon for life or death. He permitted +Napoleon and the Guard to pass by unattacked, and then fell upon the hinder +divisions of the French army. (Nov. 17.) These unfortunate troops were +successively cut to pieces. Twenty-six thousand were made prisoners. Ney, +with a part of the rear-guard, only escaped by crossing the Dnieper on the +ice. Of the army that had quitted Moscow there now remained but 10,000 +combatants and 20,000 followers. Kutusoff himself was brought to such a +state of exhaustion that he could carry the pursuit no further, and entered +into quarters upon the Dnieper. + +[Victor joins Napoleon.] + +[Passage of the Beresina, Nov. 28th.] + +It was a few days after the battle at Krasnoi that the divisions of Victor, +coming from the direction of the Dwina, suddenly encountered the remnant +of Napoleon's army. Though aware that Napoleon was in retreat, they knew +nothing of the calamities that had befallen him, and were struck with +amazement when, in the middle of a forest, they met with what seemed more +like a miserable troop of captives than an army upon the march. Victor's +soldiers of a mere auxiliary corps found themselves more than double the +effective strength of the whole army of Moscow. Their arrival again placed +Napoleon at the head of 30,000 disciplined troops, and gave the French a +gleam of victory in the last and seemingly most hopeless struggle in the +campaign. Admiral Tchitchagoff, in command of the army marching from the +Danube, had at length reached the line of Napoleon's retreat, and +established himself at Borisov, where the road through Poland crosses the +river Beresina. The bridge was destroyed by the Russians, and Tchitchagoff +opened communication with Witgenstein's army, which lay only a few miles to +the north. It appeared as if the retreat of the French was now finally +intercepted, and the surrender of Napoleon inevitable. Yet even in this +hopeless situation the military skill and daring of the French worked with +something of its ancient power. The army reached the Beresina; Napoleon +succeeded in withdrawing the enemy from the real point of passage; bridges +were thrown across the river, and after desperate fighting a great part of +the army made good its footing upon the western bank (Nov. 28). But the +losses even among the effective troops were enormous. The fate of the +miserable crowd that followed them, torn by the cannon-fire of the +Russians, and precipitated into the river by the breaking of one of the +bridges, has made the passage of the Beresina a synonym for the utmost +degree of human woe. + +[French reach the Niemen, Dec. 13.] + +This was the last engagement fought by the army. The Guards still preserved +their order: Marshal Ney still found soldiers capable of turning upon the +pursuer with his own steady and unflagging courage; but the bulk of the +army struggled forward in confused crowds, harassed by the Cossacks, and +laying down their arms by thousands before the enemy. The frost, which had +broken up on the 19th, returned on the 30th of November with even greater +severity. Twenty thousand fresh troops which joined the army between the +Beresina and Wilna scarcely arrested the process of dissolution. On the 3rd +of December Napoleon quitted the army. Wilna itself was abandoned with all +its stores; and when at length the fugitives reached the Niemen, they +numbered little more than twenty thousand. Here, six months earlier, three +hundred and eighty thousand men had crossed with Napoleon. A hundred +thousand more had joined the army in the course of its retreat. Of all this +host, not the twentieth part reached the Prussian frontier. A hundred and +seventy thousand remained prisoners in the hands of the Russians; a greater +number had perished. Of the twenty thousand men who now beheld the Niemen, +probably not seven thousand had crossed with Napoleon. In the presence of a +catastrophe so overwhelming and so unparalleled the Russian generals might +well be content with their own share in the work of destruction. Yet the +event proved that Kutusoff had done ill in sparing the extremest effort to +capture or annihilate his foe. Not only was Napoleon's own escape the +pledge of continued war, but the remnant that escaped with him possessed a +military value out of all proportion to its insignificant numbers. The best +of the army were the last to succumb. Out of those few thousands who +endured to the end, a very large proportion were veteran officers, who +immediately took their place at the head of Napoleon's newly-raised armies, +and gave to them a military efficiency soon to be bitterly proved by Europe +on many a German battle-field. + +[York's convention with the Russians, Dec. 30.] + +[York and the Prussian contingent at Riga.] + +Four hundred thousand men were lost to a conqueror who could still stake +the lives of half a million more. The material power of Napoleon, though +largely, was not fatally diminished by the Russian campaign; it was through +its moral effect, first proved in the action of Prussia, that the retreat +from Moscow created a new order of things in Europe. The Prussian +contingent, commanded by General von York, lay in front of Riga, where it +formed part of the French subsidiary army-corps led by Marshal Macdonald. +Early in November the Russian governor of Riga addressed himself to York, +assuring him that Napoleon was ruined, and soliciting York himself to take +up arms against Macdonald. [174] York had no evidence, beyond the word of +the Russian commander, of the extent of Napoleon's losses; and even if the +facts were as stated, it was by no means clear that the Czar might not be +inclined to take vengeance on Prussia on account of its alliance with +Napoleon. York returned a guarded answer to the Russian, and sent an +officer to Wilna to ascertain the real state of the French army. On the 8th +of December the officer returned, and described what he had himself seen. +Soon afterwards the Russian commandant produced a letter from the Czar, +declaring his intention to deal with Prussia as a friend, not as an enemy. +On these points all doubt was removed; York's decision was thrown upon +himself. York was a rigid soldier of the old Prussian type, dominated by +the idea of military duty. The act to which the Russian commander invited +him, and which the younger officers were ready to hail as the liberation of +Prussia, might be branded by his sovereign as desertion and treason. +Whatever scruples and perplexity might be felt in such a situation by a +loyal and obedient soldier were felt by York. He nevertheless chose the +course which seemed to be for his country's good; and having chosen it, he +accepted all the consequences which it involved. On the 30th of December a +convention was signed at Tauroggen, which, under the guise of a truce, +practically withdrew the Prussian army from Napoleon, and gave the Russians +possession of Koenigsberg. The momentous character of the act was recognised +by Napoleon as soon as the news reached Paris. York's force was the +strongest military body upon the Russian frontier; united with Macdonald, +it would have forced the Russian pursuit to stop at the Niemen; abandoning +Napoleon, it brought his enemies on to the Vistula, and threatened +incalculable danger by its example to all the rest of Germany. For the +moment, however, Napoleon could count upon the spiritless obedience of King +Frederick William. In the midst of the French regiments that garrisoned +Berlin, the King wrote orders pronouncing York's convention null and void, +and ordering York himself to be tried by court-martial. The news reached +the loyal soldier: he received it with grief, but maintained his resolution +to act for his country's good. "With bleeding heart," he wrote, "I burst +the bond of obedience, and carry on the war upon my own responsibility. The +army desires war with France; the nation desires it; the King himself +desires it, but his will is not free. The army must make his will free." + +[The Czar and Stein.] + +[Alexander enters Prussia, Jan., 1813.] + +York's act was nothing less than the turning-point in Prussian history. +Another Prussian, at this great crisis of Europe, played as great, though +not so conspicuous, a part. Before the outbreak of the Russian war, the +Czar had requested the exile Stein to come to St. Petersburg to aid him +with his counsels during the struggle with Napoleon. Stein gladly accepted +the call; and throughout the campaign he encouraged the Czar in the +resolute resistance which the Russian nation itself required of its +Government. So long as French soldiers remained on Russian soil, there was +indeed little need for a foreigner to stimulate the Czar's energies; but +when the pursuit had gloriously ended on the Niemen, the case became very +different. Kutusoff and the generals were disinclined to carry the war into +Germany. The Russian army had itself lost three-fourths of its numbers; +Russian honour was satisfied; the liberation of Western Europe might be +left to Western Europe itself. Among the politicians who surrounded +Alexander, there were a considerable number, including the first minister +Romanzoff, who still believed in the good policy of a French alliance. +These were the influences with which Stein had to contend, when the +question arose whether Russia should rest satisfied with its own victories, +or summon all Europe to unite in overthrowing Napoleon's tyranny. No record +remains of the stages by which Alexander's mind rose to the clear and firm +conception of a single European interest against Napoleon; indications +exist that it was Stein's personal influence which most largely affected +his decision. Even in the darkest moments of the war, when the forces of +Russia seemed wholly incapable of checking Napoleon's advance, Stein had +never abandoned his scheme for raising the German nation against Napoleon. +The confidence with which he had assured Alexander of ultimate victory over +the invader had been thoroughly justified; the triumph which he had +predicted had come with a rapidity and completeness even surpassing his +hopes. For a moment Alexander identified himself with the statesman who, in +the midst of Germany's humiliation, had been so resolute, so far-sighted, +so aspiring. [175] The minister of the peace-party was dismissed: Alexander +ordered his troops to advance into Prussia, and charged Stein himself to +assume the government of the Prussian districts occupied by Russian armies. +Stein's mission was to arm the Landwehr, and to gather all the resources of +the country for war against France; his powers were to continue until some +definite arrangement should be made between the King of Prussia and the +Czar. + +[Stein's commission from Alexander.] + +[Province of East Prussia arms, Jan., 1813.] + +Armed with this commission from a foreign sovereign, Stein appeared at +Koenigsberg on the 22nd of January, 1813, and published an order requiring +the governor of the province of East Prussia to convoke an assembly for the +purpose of arming the people. Stein would have desired York to appear as +President of the Assembly; but York, like most of the Prussian officials, +was alarmed and indignant at Stein's assumption of power in Prussia as the +representative of the Russian Czar, and hesitated to connect himself with +so revolutionary a measure as the arming of the people. It was only upon +condition that Stein himself should not appear in the Assembly that York +consented to recognise its powers. The Assembly met. York entered the +house, and spoke a few soul-stirring words. His undisguised declaration of +war with France was received with enthusiastic cheers. A plan for the +formation of a Landwehr, based on Scharnhorst's plans of 1808, was laid +before the Assembly, and accepted. Forty thousand men were called to arms +in a province which included nothing west of the Vistula. The nation itself +had begun the war, and left its Government no choice but to follow. Stein's +task was fulfilled; and he retired to the quarters of Alexander, unwilling +to mar by the appearance of foreign intervention the work to which the +Prussian nation had now committed itself beyond power of recall. It was the +fortune of the Prussian State, while its King dissembled before the French +in Berlin, to possess a soldier brave enough to emancipate its army, and a +citizen bold enough to usurp the government of its provinces. Frederick +William forgave York his intrepidity; Stein's action was never forgiven by +the timid and jealous sovereign whose subjects he had summoned to arm +themselves for their country's deliverance. + +[Policy of Hardenberg.] + +[Treaty of Kalisch, Feb. 27.] + +The Government of Berlin, which since the beginning of the Revolutionary +War had neither been able to fight, nor to deceive, nor to be honest, was +at length forced by circumstances into a certain effectiveness in all three +forms of action. In the interval between the first tidings of Napoleon's +disasters and the announcement of York's convention with the Russians, +Hardenberg had been assuring Napoleon of his devotion, and collecting +troops which he carefully prevented from joining him. [176] The desire of +the King was to gain concessions without taking part in the war either +against Napoleon or on his side. When, however, the balance turned more +decidedly against Napoleon, he grew bolder; and the news of York's +defection, though it seriously embarrassed the Cabinet for the moment, +practically decided it in favour of war with France. The messenger who was +sent to remove York from his command received private instructions to fall +into the hands of the Russians, and to inform the Czar that, if his troops +advanced as far as the Oder, King Frederick William would be ready to +conclude an alliance. Every post that arrived from East Prussia +strengthened the warlike resolutions of the Government. At length the King +ventured on the decisive step of quitting Berlin and placing himself at +Breslau (Jan. 25). At Berlin he was in the power of the French; at Breslau +he was within easy reach of Alexander. The significance of the journey +could not be mistaken: it was immediately followed by open preparation for +war with France. On February 3rd there appeared an edict inviting +volunteers to enrol themselves: a week later all exemptions from military +service were abolished, and the entire male population of Prussia between +the ages of seventeen and twenty-four was declared liable to serve. General +Knesebeck was sent to the headquarters of the Czar, which were now between +Warsaw and Kalisch, to conclude a treaty of alliance. Knesebeck demanded +securities for the restoration to Prussia of all the Polish territory which +it had possessed before 1806; the Czar, unwilling either to grant this +condition or to lose the Prussian alliance, kept Knesebeck at his quarters, +and sent Stein with a Russian plenipotentiary to Breslau to conclude the +treaty with Hardenberg himself. Stein and Hardenberg met at Breslau on the +26th of February. Hardenberg accepted the Czar's terms, and the treaty, +known as the Treaty of Kalisch, [177] was signed on the following day. By +this treaty, without guaranteeing the restoration of Prussian Poland, +Russia undertook not to lay down its arms until the Prussian State as a +whole was restored to the area and strength which it had possessed before +1806. For this purpose annexations were promised in Northern Germany. With +regard to Poland, Russia promised no more than to permit Prussia to retain +what it had received in 1772, together with a strip of territory to connect +this district with Silesia. The meaning of the agreement was that Prussia +should abandon to Russia the greater part of its late Polish provinces, and +receive an equivalent German territory in its stead. The Treaty of Kalisch +virtually surrendered to the Czar all that Prussia had gained in the +partitions of Poland made in 1793 and in 1795. The sacrifice was deemed a +most severe one by every Prussian politician, and was accepted only as a +less evil than the loss of Russia's friendship, and a renewed submission to +Napoleon. No single statesman, not even Stein himself, appears to have +understood that in exchanging its Polish conquests for German annexations, +in turning to the German west instead of to the alien Slavonic east, +Prussia was in fact taking the very step which made it the possible head of +a future united Germany. + +[French retreat to the Elbe.] + +War was still undeclared upon Napoleon by King Frederick William, but +throughout the month of February the light cavalry of the Russians pushed +forward unhindered through Prussian territory towards the Oder, and crowds +of volunteers, marching through Berlin on their way to the camps in +Silesia, gave the French clear signs of the storm that was about to burst +upon them. [178] The remnant of Napoleon's army, now commanded by Eugene +Beauharnais, had fallen back step by step to the Oder. Here, resting on the +fortresses, it might probably have checked the Russian advance; but the +heart of Eugene failed; the line of the Oder was abandoned, and the retreat +continued to Berlin and the Elbe. The Cossacks followed. On the 20th of +February they actually entered Berlin and fought with the French in the +streets. The French garrison was far superior in force; but the appearance +of the Cossacks caused such a ferment that, although the alliance between +France and Prussia was still in nominal existence, the French troops +expected to be cut to pieces by the people. For some days they continued to +bivouac in the streets, and as soon as it became known that a regular +Russian force had reached the Oder, Eugene determined to evacuate Berlin. +On the 4th of March the last French soldier quitted the Prussian capital. +The Cossacks rode through the town as the French left it, and fought with +their rear-guard. Some days later Witgenstein appeared with Russian +infantry. On March 17th York made his triumphal entry at the head of his +corps, himself cold and rigid in the midst of tumultuous outbursts of +patriotic joy. + +[King of Prussia declares war March 17.] + +It was on this same day that King Frederick William issued his proclamation +to the Prussian people, declaring that war had begun with France, and +summoning the nation to enter upon the struggle as one that must end either +in victory or in total destruction. The proclamation was such as became a +monarch conscious that his own faint-heartedness had been the principal +cause of Prussia's humiliation. It was simple and unboastful, admitting +that the King had made every effort to preserve the French alliance, and +ascribing the necessity for war to the intolerable wrongs inflicted by +Napoleon in spite of Prussia's fulfilment of its treaty-obligations. The +appeal to the great memories of Prussia's earlier sovereigns, and to the +example of Russia, Spain, and all countries which in present or in earlier +times had fought for their independence against a stronger foe, was worthy +of the truthful and modest tone in which the King spoke of the misfortunes +of Prussia under his own rule. + +[Spirit of the Prussian nation.] + +[Idea of Germany unity.] + +But no exhortations were necessary to fire the spirit of the Prussian +people. Seven years of suffering and humiliation had done their work. The +old apathy of all classes had vanished under the pressure of a bitter sense +of wrong. If among the Court party of Berlin and the Conservative +landowners there existed a secret dread of the awakening of popular forces, +the suspicion could not be now avowed. A movement as penetrating and as +universal as that which France had experienced in 1792 swept through the +Prussian State. It had required the experience of years of wretchedness, +the intrusion of the French soldier upon the peace of the family, the sight +of the homestead swept bare of its stock to supply the invaders of Russia, +the memory of Schill's companions shot in cold blood for the cause of the +Fatherland, before the Prussian nation caught that flame which had +spontaneously burst out in France, in Spain, and in Russia at the first +shock of foreign aggression. But the passion of the Prussian people, if it +had taken long to kindle, was deep, steadfast, and rational. It was +undisgraced by the frenzies of 1792, or by the religious fanaticism of the +Spanish war of liberation; where religion entered into the struggle, it +heightened the spirit of self-sacrifice rather than that of hatred to the +enemy. Nor was it a thing of small moment to the future of Europe that in +every leading mind the cause of Prussia was identified with the cause of +the whole German race. The actual condition of Germany warranted no such +conclusion, for Saxony, Bavaria, and the whole of the Rhenish Federation +still followed Napoleon: but the spirit and the ideas which became a living +force when at length the contest with Napoleon broke out were those of men +like Stein, who in the depths of Germany's humiliation had created the +bright and noble image of a common Fatherland. It was no more given to +Stein to see his hopes fulfilled than it was given to Mirabeau to establish +constitutional liberty in France, or to the Italian patriots of 1797 to +create a united Italy. A group of States where kings like Frederick William +and Francis, ministers like Hardenberg and Metternich, governed millions of +people totally destitute of political instincts and training, was not to be +suddenly transformed into a free nation by the genius of an individual or +the patriotism of a single epoch. But if the work of German union was one +which, even in the barren form of military empire, required the efforts of +two more generations, the ideals of 1813 were no transient and ineffective +fancy. Time was on the side of those who called the Prussian monarchy the +true centre round which Germany could gather. If in the sequel Prussia was +slow to recognise its own opportunities, the fault was less with patriots +who hoped too much than with kings and ministers who dared too little. + +[Formation of the Landwehr.] + +For the moment, the measures of the Prussian Government were worthy of the +spirit shown by the nation. Scharnhorst's military system had given Prussia +100,000 trained soldiers ready to join the existing army of 45,000. The +scheme for the formation of a Landwehr, though not yet carried into effect, +needed only to receive the sanction of the King. On the same day that +Frederick William issued his proclamation to the people, he decreed the +formation of the Landwehr and the Landsturm. The latter force, which was +intended in case of necessity to imitate the peasant warfare of Spain and +La Vendee, had no occasion to act: the Landwehr, though its arming was +delayed by the poverty and exhaustion of the country, gradually became a +most formidable reserve, and sent its battalions to fight by the side of +the regulars in some of the greatest engagements in the war. It was the +want of arms and money, not of willing soldiers, that prevented Prussia +from instantly attacking Napoleon with 200,000 men. The conscription was +scarcely needed from the immense number of volunteers who joined the ranks. +Though the completion of the Prussian armaments required some months more, +Prussia did not need to stand upon the defensive. An army of 50,000 men was +ready to cross the Elbe immediately on the arrival of the Russians, and to +open the next campaign in the territory of Napoleon's allies of the Rhenish +Federation. + + + + +CHAPTER XI. + + +The War of Liberation--Bluecher crosses the Elbe--Battle of Luetzen--The +Allies retreat to Silesia--Battle of Bautzen--Armistice--Napoleon intends +to intimidate Austria--Mistaken as to the Forces of Austria--Metternich's +Policy--Treaty of Reichenbach--Austria offers its Mediation--Congress of +Prague--Austria enters the War--Armies and Plans of Napoleon and the +Allies--Campaign of August--Battles of Dresden, Grosbeeren, the Katzbach, +and Kulm--Effect of these Actions--Battle of Dennewitz--German Policy of +Austria favourable to the Princes of the Rhenish Confederacy--Frustrated +Hopes of German Unity--Battle of Leipzig--The Allies reach the Rhine-- +Offers of Peace at Frankfort--Plan of Invasion of France--Backwardness of +Austria--The Allies enter France--Campaign of 1814--Congress of Chatillon-- +Napoleon moves to the rear of the Allies--The Allies advance on Paris-- +Capitulation of Paris--Entry of the Allies--Dethronement of Napoleon-- +Restoration of the Bourbons--The Charta--Treaty of Paris--Territorial +Effects of the War, 1792-1814--Every Power except France had gained--France +relatively weaker in Europe--Summary of the Permanent Effects of this +Period on Europe. + + +[Napoleon in 1813.] + +The first three months of the year 1813 were spent by Napoleon in vigorous +preparation for a campaign in Northern Germany. Immediately after receiving +the news of York's convention with the Russians he had ordered a levy of +350,000 men. It was in vain that Frederick William and Hardenberg affected +to disavow the general as a traitor; Napoleon divined the national +character of York's act, and laid his account for a war against the +combined forces of Prussia and Russia. In spite of the catastrophe of the +last campaign, Napoleon was still stronger than his enemies. Italy and the +Rhenish Federation had never wavered in their allegiance; Austria, though a +cold ally, had at least shown no signs of hostility. The resources of an +empire of forty million inhabitants were still at Napoleon's command. It +was in the youth and inexperience of the new soldiers, and in the scarcity +of good officers, [179] that the losses of the previous year showed their +most visible effect. Lads of seventeen, commanded in great part by officers +who had never been through a campaign, took the place of the soldiers who +had fought at Friedland and Wagram. They were as brave as their +predecessors, but they failed in bodily strength and endurance. Against +them came the remnant of the men who had pursued Napoleon from Moscow, and +a Prussian army which was but the vanguard of an armed nation. +Nevertheless, Napoleon had no cause to expect defeat, provided that Austria +remained on his side. Though the Prussian nation entered upon the conflict +in the most determined spirit, a war on the Elbe against Russia and Prussia +combined was a less desperate venture than a war with Russia alone beyond +the Niemen. + +[Bluecher crosses the Elbe, March, 1813.] + +When King Frederick William published his declaration of war (March 17), +the army of Eugene had already fallen back as far west as Magdeburg, +leaving garrisons in most of the fortresses between the Elbe and the +Russian frontier. Napoleon was massing troops on the Main, and preparing +for an advance in force, when the Prussians, commanded by Bluecher, and some +weak divisions of the Russian army, pushed forward to the Elbe. On the 18th +of March the Cossacks appeared in the suburbs of Dresden, on the right bank +of the river. Davoust, who was in command of the French garrison, blew up +two arches of the bridge, and retired to Magdeburg: Bluecher soon afterwards +entered Dresden, and called upon the Saxon nation to rise against Napoleon. +But he spoke to deaf ears. The common people were indifferent; the +officials waited to see which side would conquer. Bluecher could scarcely +obtain provisions for his army; he passed on westwards, and came into the +neighbourhood of Leipzig. Here he found himself forced to halt, and to wait +for his allies. Though a detachment of the Russian army under Witgenstein +had already crossed the Elbe, the main army, with Kutusoff, was still +lingering at Kalisch on the Polish frontier, where it had arrived six weeks +before. As yet the Prussians had only 50,000 men ready for action; until +the Russians came up, it was unsafe to advance far beyond the Elbe. Bluecher +counted every moment lost that kept him from battle: the Russian +commander-in-chief, sated with glory and sinking beneath the infirmities of +a veteran, could scarcely be induced to sign an order of march. At length +Kutusoff's illness placed the command in younger hands. His strength failed +him during the march from Poland; he was left dying in Silesia; and on the +24th of April the Czar and the King of Prussia led forward his veteran +troops into Dresden. + +[Napoleon enters Dresden, May 14.] + +[Battle of Luetzen, May 2.] + +Napoleon was now known to be approaching with considerable force by the +roads of the Saale. A pitched battle west of the Elbe was necessary before +the Allies could hope to win over any of the States of the Rhenish +Confederacy; the flat country beyond Leipzig offered the best possible +field for cavalry, in which the Allies were strong and Napoleon extremely +deficient. It was accordingly determined to unite all the divisions of the +army with Bluecher on the west of Leipzig, and to attack the French as soon +as they descended from the hilly country of the Saale, and began their +march across the Saxon plain. The Allies took post at Luetzen: the French +advanced, and at midday on the 2nd of May the battle of Luetzen began. Till +evening, victory inclined to the Allies. The Prussian soldiery fought with +the utmost spirit; for the first time in Napoleon's campaigns, the French +infantry proved weaker than an enemy when fighting against them in equal +numbers. But the generalship of Napoleon turned the scale. Seventy thousand +of the French were thrown upon fifty thousand of the Allies; the battle was +fought in village streets and gardens, where cavalry were useless; and at +the close of the day, though the losses on each side were equal, the Allies +were forced from the positions which they had gained. Such a result was +equivalent to a lost battle. Napoleon's junction with the army of Eugene at +Magdeburg was now inevitable, unless a second engagement was fought and +won. No course remained to the Allies but to stake everything upon a +renewed attack, or to retire behind the Elbe and meet the reinforcements +assembling in Silesia. King Frederick William declared for a second battle; +[180] he was over-ruled, and the retreat commenced. Napoleon entered +Dresden on May 14th. No attempt was made by the Allies to hold the line of +the Elbe; all the sanguine hopes with which Bluecher and his comrades had +advanced to attack Napoleon within the borders of the Rhenish Confederacy +were dashed to the ground. The Fatherland remained divided against itself. +Saxony and the rest of the vassal States were secured to France by the +victory of Luetzen; the liberation of Germany was only to be wrought by +prolonged and obstinate warfare, and by the wholesale sacrifice of Prussian +life. + +[Armistice, June 4.] + +[Battle of Bautzen, May 21.] + +It was with deep disappointment, but not with any wavering of purpose, that +the allied generals fell back before Napoleon towards the Silesian +fortresses. The Prussian troops which had hitherto taken part in the war +were not the third part of those which the Government was arming; new +Russian divisions were on the march from Poland. As the Allies moved +eastwards from the Elbe, both their own forces and those of Napoleon +gathered strength. The retreat stopped at Bautzen, on the river Spree; and +here, on the 19th of May, 90,000 of the Allies and the same number of the +French drew up in order of battle. The Allies held a long, broken chain of +hills behind the river, and the ground lying between these hills and the +village of Bautzen. On the 20th the French began the attack, and won the +passage of the river. In spite of the approach of Ney with 40,000 more +troops, the Czar and the King of Prussia determined to continue the battle +on the following day. The struggle of the 21st was of the same obstinate +and indecisive character as that at Luetzen. Twenty-five thousand French had +been killed or wounded before the day was over, but the bad generalship of +the Allies had again given Napoleon the victory. The Prussian and Russian +commanders were all at variance; Alexander, who had to decide in their +contentions, possessed no real military faculty. It was not for want of +brave fighting and steadfastness before the enemy that Bautzen was lost. +The Allies retreated in perfect order, and without the loss of a single +gun. Napoleon followed, forcing his wearied regiments to ceaseless +exertion, in the hope of ruining by pursuit an enemy whom he could not +overthrow in battle. In a few more days the discord of the allied generals +and the sufferings of the troops would probably have made them unable to +resist Napoleon's army, weakened as it was. But the conqueror himself +halted in the moment of victory. On the 4th of June an armistice of seven +weeks arrested the pursuit, and brought the first act of the War of +Liberation to a close. + +[Napoleon and Austria.] + +Napoleon's motive for granting this interval to his enemies, the most fatal +step in his whole career, has been vaguely sought among the general reasons +for military delay; as a matter of fact, Napoleon was thinking neither of +the condition of his own army nor of that of the Allies when he broke off +hostilities, but of the probable action of the Court of Vienna. [181] "I +shall grant a truce," he wrote to the Viceroy of Italy (June 2, 1813), "on +account of the armaments of Austria, and in order to gain time to bring up +the Italian army to Laibach to threaten Vienna." Austria had indeed +resolved to regain, either by war or negotiation, the provinces which it +had lost in 1809. It was now preparing to offer its mediation, but it was +also preparing to join the Allies in case Napoleon rejected its demands. +Metternich was anxious to attain his object, if possible, without war. The +Austrian State was bankrupt; its army had greatly deteriorated since 1809; +Metternich himself dreaded both the ambition of Russia and what he +considered the revolutionary schemes of the German patriots. It was his +object not to drive Napoleon from his throne, but to establish a European +system in which neither France nor Russia should be absolutely dominant. +Soon after the retreat from Moscow the Cabinet of Vienna had informed +Napoleon, though in the most friendly terms, that Austria could not longer +remain in the position of a dependent ally. [182] Metternich stated, and +not insincerely, that by certain concessions Napoleon might still count on +Austria's friendship; but at the same time he negotiated with the allied +Powers, and encouraged them to believe that Austria would, under certain +circumstances, strike on their behalf. The course of the campaign of May +was singularly favourable to Metternich's policy. Napoleon had not won a +decided victory; the Allies, on the other hand, were so far from success +that Austria could set almost any price it pleased upon its alliance. By +the beginning of June it had become a settled matter in the Austrian +Cabinet that Napoleon must be made to resign the Illyrian Provinces +conquered in 1809 and the districts of North Germany annexed in 1810; but +it was still the hope of the Government to obtain this result by peaceful +means. Napoleon saw that Austria was about to change its attitude, but he +had by no means penetrated the real intentions of Metternich. He credited +the Viennese Government with a stronger sentiment of hostility towards +himself than it actually possessed; at the same time he failed to +appreciate the fixed and settled character of its purpose. He believed that +the action of Austria would depend simply upon the means which he possessed +to intimidate it; that, if the army of Italy were absent, Austria would +attack him; that, on the other hand, if he could gain time to bring the +army of Italy into Carniola, Austria would keep the peace. It was with this +belief, and solely for the purpose of bringing up a force to menace +Austria, that Napoleon stayed his hand against the Prussian and Russian +armies after the battle of Bautzen, and gave time for the gathering of the +immense forces which were destined to effect his destruction. + +[Metternich offers Austria's mediation.] + +Immediately after the conclusion of the armistice of June 4th, Metternich +invited Napoleon to accept Austria's mediation for a general peace. The +settlement which Metternich contemplated was a very different one from that +on which Stein and the Prussian patriots had set their hopes. Austria was +willing to leave to Napoleon the whole of Italy and Holland, the frontier +of the Rhine, and the Protectorate of Western Germany: all that was +required by Metternich, as arbiter of Europe, was the restoration of the +provinces taken from Austria after the war of 1809, the reinstatement of +Prussia in Western Poland, and the abandonment by France of the +North-German district annexed in 1810. But to Napoleon the greater or less +extent of the concessions asked by Austria was a matter of no moment. He +was determined to make no concessions at all, and he entered into +negotiations only for the purpose of disguising from Austria the real +object with which he had granted the armistice. While Napoleon affected to +be weighing the proposals of Austria, he was in fact calculating the number +of marches which would place the Italian army on the Austrian frontier; +this once effected, he expected to hear nothing more of Metternich's +demands. + +[Napoleon deceived as to the forces of Austria.] + +It was a game of deceit; but there was no one who was so thoroughly +deceived as Napoleon himself. By some extraordinary miscalculation on the +part of his secret agents, he was led to believe that the forces of [***] +whole force of Austria, both in the north and the south, amounted to only +100,000 men, [183] and it was on this estimate that he had formed his plans +of intimidation. In reality Austria had double that number of men ready to +take the field. By degrees Napoleon saw reason to suspect himself in error. +On the 11th of July he wrote to his Foreign Minister, Maret, bitterly +reproaching him with the failure of the secret service to gain any +trustworthy information. It was not too late to accept Metternich's terms. +Yet even now, when the design of intimidating Austria had proved an utter +delusion, and Napoleon was convinced that Austria would fight, and fight +with very powerful forces, his pride and his invincible belief in his own +superiority prevented him from drawing back. He made an attempt to enter +upon a separate negotiation with Russia, and, when this failed, he resolved +to face the conflict with the whole of Europe. + +[Treaty of Reichenbach, June 27.] + +There was no longer any uncertainty among Napoleon's enemies. On the 27th +of June, Austria had signed a treaty at Reichenbach, pledging itself to +join the allied Powers in the event of Napoleon rejecting the conditions to +be proposed by Austria as mediator; and the conditions so to be proposed +were fixed by the same treaty. They were the following:--The suppression of +the Duchy of Warsaw; the restoration to Austria of the Illyrian Provinces; +and the surrender by Napoleon of the North-German district annexed to his +Empire in 1810. Terms more hostile to France than these Austria declined to +embody in its mediation. The Elbe might still sever Prussia from its German +provinces lost in 1807; Napoleon might still retain, as chief of the +Rhenish Confederacy, his sovereignty over the greater part of the German +race. + +[Austria enters the war, Aug. 10.] + +[Congress of Prague, July 15-Aug. 10.] + +From the moment when these conditions were fixed, there was nothing which +the Prussian generals so much dreaded as that Napoleon might accept them, +and so rob the Allies of the chance of crushing him by means of Austria's +support. But their fears were groundless. The counsels of Napoleon were +exactly those which his worst enemies would have desired him to adopt. War, +and nothing but war, was his fixed resolve. He affected to entertain +Austria's propositions, and sent his envoy Caulaincourt to a Congress which +Austria summoned at Prague; but it was only for the purpose of gaining a +few more weeks of preparation. The Congress met; the armistice was +prolonged to the 10th of August. Caulaincourt, however, was given no power +to close with Austria's demands. He was ignorant that he had only been sent +to Prague in order to gain time. He saw the storm gathering: unable to +believe that Napoleon intended to fight all Europe rather than make the +concessions demanded of him, he imagined that his master still felt some +doubt whether Austria and the other Powers meant to adhere to their word. +As the day drew nigh which closed the armistice and the period given for a +reply to Austria's ultimatum, Caulaincourt implored Napoleon not to deceive +himself with hopes that Austria would draw back. Napoleon had no such hope; +he knew well that Austria would declare war, and he accepted the issue. +Caulaincourt heard nothing more. At midnight on the 10th of August the +Congress declared itself dissolved. Before the dawn of the next morning the +army in Silesia saw the blaze of the beacon-fires which told that +negotiation was at an end, and that Austria was entering the war on the +side of the Allies. [184] + +[Armies of Napoleon and the Allies.] + +Seven days' notice was necessary before the commencement of actual +hostilities. Napoleon, himself stationed at Dresden, held all the lower +course of the Elbe; and his generals had long had orders to be ready to +march on the morning of the 18th. Forces had come up from all parts of the +Empire, raising the French army at the front to 300,000 men; but, for the +first time in Napoleon's career, his enemies had won from a pause in war +results even surpassing his own. The strength of the Prussian and Russian +armies was now enormously different from what it had been at Luetzen and +Bautzen. The Prussian Landwehr, then a weaponless and ill-clad militia +drilling in the villages, was now fully armed, and in great part at the +front. New Russian divisions had reached Silesia. Austria took the field +with a force as numerous as that which had checked Napoleon in 1809. At the +close of the armistice, 350,000 men actually faced the French positions +upon the Elbe; 300,000 more were on the march, or watching the German +fortresses and the frontier of Italy. The allied troops operating against +Napoleon were divided into three armies. In the north, between Wittenberg +and Berlin, Bernadotte commanded 60,000 Russians and Prussians, in addition +to his own Swedish contingent. Bluecher was placed at the head of 100,000 +Russians and Prussians in Silesia. The Austrians remained undivided, and +formed, together with some Russian and Prussian divisions, the great army +of Bohemia, 200,000 strong, under the command of Schwarzenberg. The plan of +the campaign had been agreed upon by the Allies soon after the Treaty of +Reichenbach had been made with Austria. It was a sound, though not a daring +one. + +[Plan of the Allies.] + +The three armies, now forming an arc from Wittenberg to the north of +Bohemia, were to converge upon the line of Napoleon's communications behind +Dresden; if separately attacked, their generals were to avoid all hazardous +engagements, and to manoeuvre so as to weary the enemy and preserve their +own general relations, as far as possible, unchanged. Bluecher, as the most +exposed, was expected to content himself the longest with the defensive; +the great army of Bohemia, after securing the mountain-passes between +Bohemia and Saxony, might safely turn Napoleon's position at Dresden, and +so draw the two weaker armies towards it for one vast and combined +engagement in the plain of Leipzig. + +[Napoleon's plan of attack.] + +In outline, the plan of the Allies was that which Napoleon expected them to +adopt. His own design was to anticipate it by an offensive of extraordinary +suddenness and effect. Hostilities could not begin before the morning of +the 18th of August; by the 21st or the 22nd, Napoleon calculated that he +should have captured Berlin. Oudinot, who was at Wittenberg with 80,000 +men, had received orders to advance upon the Prussian capital at the moment +that the armistice expired, and to force it, if necessary by bombardment, +into immediate surrender. The effect of this blow, as Napoleon supposed, +would be to disperse the entire reserve-force of the Prussian monarchy, and +paralyse the action of its army in the field. While Oudinot marched on +Berlin, Bluecher was to be attacked in Silesia, and prevented from rendering +any assistance either on the north or on the south. The mass of Napoleon's +forces, centred at Dresden, and keeping watch upon the movements of the +army of Bohemia, would either fight a great battle, or, if the Allies made +a false movement, march straight upon Prague, the centre of Austria's +supplies, and reach it before the enemy. All the daring imagination of +Napoleon's earlier campaigns displayed itself in such a project, which, if +successful, would have terminated the war within ten days; but this +imagination was no longer, as in those earlier campaigns, identical with +insight into real possibilities. The success of Napoleon's plan involved +the surprise or total defeat of Bernadotte before Berlin, the disablement +of Bluecher, and a victory, or a strategical success equivalent to a +victory, over the vast army of the south. It demanded of a soldiery, +inferior to the enemy in numerical strength, the personal superiority which +had belonged to the men of Jena and Austerlitz, when in fact the French +regiments of conscripts had ceased to be a match for equal numbers of the +enemy. But no experience could alter Napoleon's fixed belief in the fatuity +of all warfare except his own. After the havoc of Borodino, after the even +struggles of Luetzen and Bautzen, he still reasoned as if he had before him +the armies of Brunswick and Mack. His plan assumed the certainty of success +in each of its parts; for the failure of a single operation hazarded all +the rest, by requiring the transfer of reinforcements from armies already +too weak for the tasks assigned to them. Nevertheless, the utmost that +Napoleon would acknowledge was that the execution of his design needed +energy. He still underrated the force which Austria had brought into the +field against him. Though ignorant of the real position and strength of the +army in Bohemia, and compelled to wait for the enemy's movements before +striking on this side, he already in imagination saw the war decided by the +fall of the Prussian capital. + +[Triple movement, Aug. 18-26.] + +[Battle of Dresden, Aug. 26, 27.] + +[Battles of Grossbeeren, Aug. 23, and the Katzbach, Aug. 26.] + +On the 18th of August the forward movement began. Oudinot advanced from +Wittenberg towards Berlin; Napoleon himself hurried into Silesia, intending +to deal Bluecher one heavy blow, and instantly to return and place himself +before Schwarzenberg. On the 21st, and following days, the Prussian general +was attacked and driven eastwards. Napoleon committed the pursuit to +Macdonald, and hastened back to Dresden, already threatened by the advance +of the Austrians from Bohemia. Schwarzenberg and the allied sovereigns, as +soon as they heard that Napoleon had gone to seek Bluecher in Silesia, had +in fact abandoned their cautious plans, and determined to make an assault +upon Dresden with the Bohemian army alone. But it was in vain that they +tried to surprise Napoleon. He was back at Dresden on the 25th, and ready +for the attack. Never were Napoleon's hopes higher than on this day. His +success in Silesia had filled him with confidence. He imagined Oudinot to +be already in Berlin; and the advance of Schwarzenberg against Dresden gave +him the very opportunity which he desired for crushing the Bohemian army in +one great battle, before it could draw support either from Bluecher or from +Bernadotte. Another Austerlitz seemed to be at hand. Napoleon wrote to +Paris that he should be in Prague before the enemy; and, while he completed +his defences in front of Dresden, he ordered Vandamme, with 40,000 men, to +cross the Elbe at Koenigstein, and force his way south-westwards on to the +roads into Bohemia, in the rear of the Great Army, in order to destroy its +magazines and menace its line of retreat on Prague. On August 26th +Schwarzenberg's host assailed the positions of Napoleon on the slopes and +gardens outside Dresden. Austrians, Russians, and Prussians all took part +in the attack. Moreau, the victor of Hohenlinden, stood by the side of the +Emperor Alexander, whom he had come to help against his own countrymen. He +lived only to witness one of the last and greatest victories of France. The +attack was everywhere repelled: the Austrian divisions were not only +beaten, but disgraced and overthrown. At the end of two days' fighting the +Allies were in full retreat, leaving 20,000 prisoners in the hands of +Napoleon. It was a moment when the hearts of the bravest sank, and when +hope itself might well vanish, as the rumour passed through the Prussian +regiments that Metternich was again in friendly communication with +Napoleon. But in the midst of Napoleon's triumph intelligence arrived which +robbed it of all its worth. Oudinot, instead of conquering Berlin, had been +defeated by the Prussians of Bernadotte's army at Grossbeeren (Aug. 23), +and driven back upon the Elbe. Bluecher had turned upon Macdonald in +Silesia, and completely overthrown his army on the river Katzbach, at the +very moment when the Allies were making their assault upon Dresden. It was +vain to think of a march upon Prague, or of the annihilation of the +Austrians, when on the north and the east Napoleon's troops were meeting +with nothing but disaster. The divisions which had been intended to support +Vandamme's movement from Koenigstein upon the rear of the Great Army were +retained in the neighbourhood of Dresden, in order to be within reach of +the points where their aid might be needed. Vandamme, ignorant of his +isolation, was left with scarcely 40,000 men to encounter the Great Army in +its retreat. + +[Battle of Kulm, Aug. 29, 30.] + +He threw himself upon a Russian corps at Kulm, in the Bohemian mountains, +on the morning of the 29th. The Russians, at first few in number, held +their ground during the day; in the night, and after the battle had +recommenced on the morrow, vast masses of the allied troops poured in. The +French fought desperately, but were overwhelmed. Vandamme himself was made +prisoner, with 10,000 of his men. The whole of the stores and most of the +cannon of his army remained in the enemy's hands. + +[Effect of the twelve days, Aug. 18-30.] + +[Battle of Dennewitz, Sept. 6.] + +The victory at Kulm secured the Bohemian army from pursuit, and almost +extinguished the effects of its defeat at Dresden. Thanks to the successes +of Bluecher and of Bernadotte's Prussian generals, which prevented Napoleon +from throwing all his forces on to the rear of the Great Army, +Schwarzenberg's rash attack had proved of no worse significance than an +unsuccessful raid. The Austrians were again in the situation assigned to +them in the original plan of the campaign, and capable of resuming their +advance into the interior of Saxony: Bluecher and the northern commanders +had not only escaped separate destruction, but won great victories over the +French: Napoleon, weakened by the loss of 100,000 men, remained exactly +where he had been at the beginning of the campaign. Had the triple movement +by which he meant to overwhelm his adversaries been capable of execution, +it would now have been fully executed. The balance, however, had turned +against Napoleon; and the twelve days from the 18th to the 29th of August, +though marked by no catastrophe like Leipzig or Waterloo, were in fact the +decisive period in the struggle of Europe against Napoleon. The attack by +which he intended to prevent the junction of the three armies had been +made, and had failed. Nothing now remained for him but to repeat the same +movements with a discouraged force against an emboldened enemy, or to quit +the line of the Elbe, and prepare for one vast and decisive encounter with +all three armies combined. Napoleon drove from his mind the thought of +failure; he ordered Ney to take command of Oudinot's army, and to lead it +again, in increased strength, upon Berlin; he himself hastened to +Macdonald's beaten troops in Silesia, and rallied them for a new assault +upon Bluecher. All was in vain. Ney, advancing on Berlin, was met by the +Prussian general Billow at Dennewitz, and totally routed (Sept. 6): +Bluecher, finding that Napoleon himself was before him, skilfully avoided +battle, and forced his adversary to waste in fruitless marches the brief +interval which he had [***] from his watch on Schwarzenberg. Each conflict +with the enemy, each vain and exhausting march, told that the superiority +had passed from the French to their foes, and that Napoleon's retreat was +now only a matter of time. "These creatures have learnt something," said +Napoleon in the bitterness of his heart, as he saw the columns of Bluecher +manoeuvring out of his grasp. Ney's report of his own overthrow at +Dennewitz sounded like an omen of the ruin of Waterloo. "I have been +totally defeated," he wrote, "and do not yet know whether my army has +re-assembled. The spirit of the generals and officers is shattered. To +command in such conditions is but half to command. I had rather be a common +grenadier." + +[Metternich.] + +[German policy of Stein and of Austria.] + +The accession of Austria had turned the scale in favour of the Allies; it +rested only with the allied generals themselves to terminate the warfare +round Dresden, and to lead their armies into the heart of Saxony. For a +while the course of the war flagged, and military interests gave place to +political. It was in the interval between the first great battles and the +final advance on Leipzig that the future of Germany was fixed by the three +allied Powers. In the excitement of the last twelve months little thought +had been given, except by Stein and his friends, to the political form to +be set in the place of the Napoleonic Federation of the Rhine. Stein, in +the midst of the Russian campaign, had hoped for a universal rising of the +German people against Napoleon, and had proposed the dethronement of all +the German princes who supported his cause. His policy had received the +general approval of Alexander, and, on the entrance of the Russian army +into Germany, a manifesto had been issued appealing to the whole German +nation, and warning the vassals of Napoleon that they could only save +themselves by submission. [185] A committee had been appointed by the +allied sovereigns, under the presidency of Stein himself, to administer the +revenues of all Confederate territory that should be occupied by the allied +armies. Whether the reigning Houses should be actually expelled might +remain in uncertainty; but it was the fixed hope of Stein and his friends +that those princes who were permitted to retain their thrones would be +permitted to retain them only as officers in a great German Empire, without +sovereign rights either over their own subjects or in relation to foreign +States. The Kings of Bavaria and Wuertemberg had gained their titles and +much of their despotic power at home from Napoleon; their independence of +the Head of Germany had made them nothing more than the instruments of a +foreign conqueror. Under whatever form the central authority might be +revived, Stein desired that it should be the true and only sovereign Power +in Germany, a Power to which every German might appeal against the +oppression of a minor Government, and in which the whole nation should find +its representative before the rest of Europe. In the face of such a central +authority, whether an elected Parliament or an Imperial Council, the minor +princes could at best retain but a fragment of their powers; and such was +the theory accepted at the allied head-quarters down to the time when +Austria proffered its mediation and support. Then everything changed. The +views of the Austrian Government upon the future system of Germany were in +direct opposition to those of Stein's party. Metternich dreaded the thought +of popular agitation, and looked upon Stein, with his idea of a National +Parliament and his plans for dethroning the Rhenish princes, as little +better than the Jacobins of 1792. The offer of a restored imperial dignity +in Germany was declined by the Emperor of Austria at the instance of his +Minister. With characteristic sense of present difficulties, and blindness +to the great forces which really contained their solution, Metternich +argued that the minor princes would only be driven into the arms of the +foreigner by the establishment of any supreme German Power. They would +probably desert Napoleon if the Allies guaranteed to them everything that +they at present possessed; they would be freed from all future temptation +to attach themselves to France if Austria contented itself with a +diplomatic influence and with the ties of a well-constructed system of +treaties. In spite of the influence of Stein with the Emperor Alexander, +Metternich's views prevailed. Austria had so deliberately kept itself in +balance during the first part of the year 1813, that the Allies were now +willing to concede everything, both in this matter and in others, in return +for its support. Nothing more was heard of the dethronement of the +Confederate princes, or even of the limitation of their powers. It was +agreed by the Treaty of Teplitz, signed by Prussia, Russia, and Austria on +September 9th, that every State of the Rhenish Confederacy should be placed +in a position of absolute independence. Negotiations were opened with the +King of Bavaria, whose army had steadily fought on the side of Napoleon in +every campaign since 1806. Instead of being outlawed as a criminal, he was +welcomed as an ally. The Treaty of Ried, signed on the 3rd of October, +guaranteed to the King of Bavaria, in return for his desertion of Napoleon, +full sovereign rights, and the whole of the territory which he had received +from Napoleon, except the Tyrol and the Austrian district on the Inn. What +had been accorded to the King of Bavaria could not be refused to the rest +of Napoleon's vassals who were willing to make their peace with the Allies +in time. Germany was thus left at the mercy of a score of petty Cabinets. +It was seen by the patriotic party in Prussia at what price the alliance of +Austria had been purchased. Austria had indeed made it possible to conquer +Napoleon, but it had also made an end of all prospect of the union of the +German nation. + +[Allies cross the Elbe, Oct. 3.] + +Till the last days of September the position of the hostile armies round +Dresden remained little changed, Napoleon unweariedly repeated his attacks, +now on one side, now on another, but without result. The Allies on their +part seemed rooted to the soil. Bernadotte, balanced between the desire to +obtain Norway from the Allies and a foolish hope of being called to the +throne of France, was bent on doing the French as little harm as possible; +Schwarzenberg, himself an indifferent general, was distracted by the +councillors of all the three monarchs; Bluecher alone pressed for decided +and rapid action. At length the Prussian commander gained permission to +march northwards, and unite his army with Bernadotte's in a forward +movement across the Elbe. The long-expected Russian reserves, led by +Bennigsen, reached the Bohemian mountains; and at the beginning of October +the operation began which was to collect the whole of the allied forces in +the plain of Leipzig. Bluecher forced the passage of the Elbe at Wartenburg. +It was not until Napoleon learnt that the army of Silesia had actually +crossed the river that he finally quitted Dresden. Then, hastening +northwards, he threw himself upon the Prussian general; but Bluecher again +avoided battle, as he had done in Silesia; and on the 7th of October his +army united with Bernadotte's, which had crossed the Elbe two days before. + +The enemy was closing in upon Napoleon. Obstinately as he had held on to +the line of the Elbe, he could hold on no longer. In the frustration of all +his hopes there flashed across his mind the wild project of a march +eastwards to the Oder, and the gathering of all the besieged garrisons for +a campaign in which the enemy should stand between himself and France; but +the dream lasted only long enough to gain a record. Napoleon ventured no +more than to send a corps back to the Elbe to threaten Berlin, in the hope +of tempting Bluecher and Bernadotte to abandon the advance which they had +now begun in co-operation with the great army of Schwarzenberg. From the +10th to the 14th of October, Napoleon [***] at Dueben, between Dresden and +Leipzig, restlessly expecting to hear of Bluecher's or Bernadotte's retreat. +The only definite information that he could gain was that Schwarzenberg was +pressing on towards the west. At length he fell back to Leipzig, believing +that Bluecher, but not Bernadotte, was advancing to meet Schwarzenberg and +take part in a great engagement. As he entered Leipzig on October 14th the +cannon of Schwarzenberg was heard on the south. + +[Battle of Leipzig. Oct 16-19.] + +Napoleon drew up for battle. The number of his troops in position around +the city was 170,000: about 15,000 others lay within call. He placed +Marmont and Ney on the north of Leipzig at the village of Moeckern, to meet +the expected onslaught of Bluecher; and himself, with the great mass of his +army, took post on the south, facing Schwarzenberg. On the morning of the +16th, Schwarzenberg began the attack. His numbers did not exceed 150,000, +for the greater part of the Russian army was a march in the rear. The +battle was an even one. The Austrians failed to gain ground: with one more +army-corps Napoleon saw that he could overpower the enemy. He was still +without intelligence of Bluecher's actual appearance in the north; and in +the rash hope that Bluecher's coming might be delayed, he sent orders to Ney +and Marmont to leave their positions and hurry to the south to throw +themselves upon Schwarzenberg. Ney obeyed. Marmont, when the order reached +him, was actually receiving Bluecher's first fire. He determined to remain +and defend the village of Moeckern, though left without support. York, +commanding the vanguard of Bluecher's army, assailed him with the utmost +fury. A third part of the troops engaged on each side were killed or +wounded before the day closed; but in the end the victory of the Prussians +was complete. It was the only triumph won by the Allies on this first day +of the battle, but it turned the scale against Napoleon. Marmont's corps +was destroyed; Ney, divided between Napoleon and Marmont, had rendered no +effective help to either. Schwarzenberg, saved from a great disaster, +needed only to wait for Bernadotte and the Russian reserves, and to renew +the battle with an additional force of 100,000 men. + +[Storm of Leipzig, 19th. French retreat.] + +[Battle of the 18th.] + +In the course of the night Napoleon sent proposals for peace. It was in the +vain hope of receiving some friendly answer from his father-in-law, the +Austrian Emperor, that he delayed making his retreat during the next day, +while it might still have been unmolested. No answer was returned to his +letter. In the evening of the 17th, Bennigsen's army reached the field of +battle. Next morning began that vast and decisive encounter known in the +language of Germany as "the battle of the nations," the greatest battle in +all authentic history, the culmination of all the military effort of the +Napoleonic age. Not less than 300,000 men fought on the side of the Allies; +Napoleon's own forces numbered 170,000. The battle raged all round Leipzig, +except on the west, where no attempt was made to interpose between Napoleon +and the line of his retreat. As in the first engagement, the decisive +successes were those of Bluecher, now tardily aided by Bernadotte, on the +north; Schwarzenberg's divisions, on the south side of the town, fought +steadily, but without gaining much ground. But there was no longer any +doubt as to the issue of the struggle. If Napoleon could not break the +Allies in the first engagement, he had no chance against them now when they +had been joined by 100,000 more men. The storm of attack grew wilder and +wilder: there were no new forces to call up for the defence. Before the day +was half over Napoleon drew in his outer line, and began to make +dispositions for a retreat from Leipzig. At evening long trains of wounded +from the hospitals passed through the western gates of the city along the +road towards the Rhine. In the darkness of night the whole army was +withdrawn from its positions, and dense masses poured into the town, until +every street was blocked with confused and impenetrable crowds of cavalry +and infantry. The leading divisions moved out of the gates before sunrise. +As the throng lessened, some degree of order was restored, and the troops +which Napoleon intended to cover the retreat took their places under the +walls of Leipzig. The Allies advanced to the storm on the morning of the +19th. The French were driven into the town; the victorious enemy pressed on +towards the rear of the retreating columns. In the midst of the struggle an +explosion was heard above the roar of the battle. The bridge over the +Elster, the only outlet from Leipzig to the west, had been blown up by +--the mistake of a French soldier before the rear-guard began to cross. The +mass of fugitives, driven from the streets of the town, found before them +an impassable river. Some swam to the opposite bank or perished in +attempting to do so; the rest, to the number of 15,000, laid down their +arms. This was the end of the battle. Napoleon had lost in the three days +40,000 killed and wounded, 260 guns, and 30,000 prisoners. The killed and +wounded of the Allies reached the enormous sum of 54,000. + +[Conditions of peace offered to Napoleon at Frankfort, Nov. 9th.] + +[Allies follow Napoleon to the Rhine.] + +The campaign was at an end. Napoleon led off a large army, but one that was +in no condition to turn upon its pursuers. At each stage in the retreat +thousands of fever-stricken wretches were left to terrify even the pursuing +army with the dread of their infection. It was only when the French found +the road to Frankfort blocked at Hanau by a Bavarian force that they +rallied to the order of battle. The Bavarians were cut to pieces; the road +was opened; and, a fortnight after the Battle of Leipzig, Napoleon, with +the remnant of his great army, re-crossed the Rhine. Behind him the fabric +of his Empire fell to the ground. Jerome fled from Westphalia; [186] the +princes of the Rhenish Confederacy came one after another to make their +peace with the Allies; Buelow, with the army which had conquered Ney at +Dennewitz, marched through the north of Germany to the deliverance of +Holland. Three days after Napoleon had crossed the Rhine the Czar reached +Frankfort; and here, on the 7th of November, a military council was held, +in which Bluecher and Gneisenau, against almost all the other generals, +advocated an immediate invasion of France. The soldiers, however, had time +to re-consider their opinions, for, on the 9th, it was decided by the +representatives of the Powers to send an offer of peace to Napoleon, and +the operations of the war were suspended by common consent. The condition +on which peace was offered to Napoleon was the surrender of the conquests +of France beyond the Alps and the Rhine. The Allies were still willing to +permit the Emperor to retain Belgium, Savoy, and the Rhenish Provinces; +they declined, however, to enter into any negotiation until Napoleon had +accepted this basis of peace; and they demanded a distinct reply before the +end of the month of November. + +[Offer of peace withdrawn, Dec. 1.] + +[Plan of invasion of France.] + +[Allies enter France, Jan., 1814.] + +Napoleon, who had now arrived in Paris, and saw around him all the signs of +power, returned indefinite answers. The month ended without the reply which +the Allies required; and on the 1st of December the offer of peace was +declared to be withdrawn. It was still undecided whether the war should +take the form of an actual invasion of France. The memory of Brunswick's +campaign of 1792, and of the disasters of the first coalition in 1793, even +now exercised a powerful influence over men's minds. Austria was unwilling +to drive Napoleon to extremities, or to give to Russia and Prussia the +increased influence which they would gain in Europe from the total +overthrow of Napoleon's power. It was ultimately determined that the allied +armies should enter France, but that the Austrians, instead of crossing the +north-eastern frontier, should make a detour by Switzerland, and gain the +plateau of Langres in Champagne, from which the rivers Seine, Marne, and +Aube, with the roads following their valleys, descend in the direction of +the capital. The plateau of Langres was said to be of such strategical +importance that its occupation by an invader would immediately force +Napoleon to make peace. As a matter of fact, the plateau was of no +strategical importance whatever; but the Austrians desired to occupy it, +partly with the view of guarding against any attack from the direction of +Italy and Lyons, partly from their want of the heavy artillery necessary +for besieging the fortresses farther north, [187] and from a just +appreciation of the dangers of a campaign conducted in a hostile country +intersected by several rivers. Anything was welcomed by Metternich that +seemed likely to avert, or even to postpone, a struggle with Napoleon for +life or death. Bluecher correctly judged the march through Switzerland to be +mere procrastination. He was himself permitted to take the straight road +into France, though his movements were retarded in order to keep pace with +the cautious steps of Schwarzenberg. On the last day of the year 1813 the +Prussian general crossed the Rhine near Coblentz; on the 18th of January, +1814, the Austrian army, having advanced from Switzerland by Belfort and +Vesoul, reached its halting-place on the plateau of Langres. Here the march +stopped; and here it was expected that terms of peace would be proposed by +Napoleon. + +[Wellington entering France from the south.] + +It was not on the eastern side alone that the invader was now entering +France. Wellington had passed the Pyrenees. His last victorious march into +the north of Spain began on the day when the Prussian and Russian armies +were defeated by Napoleon at Bautzen (May 21, 1813). During the armistice +of Dresden, a week before Austria signed the treaty which fixed the +conditions of its armed mediation, he had gained an overwhelming triumph at +Vittoria over King Joseph and the French army, as it retreated with all the +spoils gathered in five years' occupation of Spain (June 21). A series of +bloody engagements had given the English the passes of the Pyrenees in +those same days of August and September that saw the allied armies close +around Napoleon at Dresden; and when, after the catastrophe of Leipzig, the +wreck of Napoleon's host was retreating beyond the Rhine, Soult, the +defender of the Pyrenees, was driven by the British general from his +entrenchments on the Nivelle, and forced back under the walls of Bayonne. + +[French armies unable to hold the frontier.] + +[Napoleon's plan of defence.] + +Twenty years had passed since, in the tempestuous morn of the Revolution, +Hoche swept the armies of the first coalition across the Alsatian frontier. +Since then, French soldiers had visited every capital, and watered every +soil with their blood; but no foreign soldier had set foot on French soil. +Now the cruel goads of Napoleon's military glory had spent the nation's +strength, and the force no longer existed which could bar the way to its +gathered enemies. The armies placed upon the eastern frontier had to fall +back before an enemy five times more numerous than themselves. Napoleon had +not expected that the Allies would enter France before the spring. With +three months given him for organisation, he could have made the +frontier-armies strong enough to maintain their actual positions; the +winter advance of the Allies compelled him to abandon the border districts +of France, and to concentrate his defence in Champagne, between the Marne, +the Seine, and the Aube. This district was one which offered extraordinary +advantages to a great general acting against an irresolute and +ill-commanded enemy. By holding the bridges over the three rivers, and +drawing his own supplies along the central road from Paris to +Arcis-sur-Aube, Napoleon could securely throw the bulk of his forces from +one side to the other against the flank of the Allies, while his own +movements were covered by the rivers, which could not be passed except at +the bridges. A capable commander at the head of the Allies would have +employed the same river-strategy against Napoleon himself, after conquering +one or two points of passage by main force; but Napoleon had nothing of the +kind to fear from Schwarzenberg; and if the Austrian head-quarters +continued to control the movements of the allied armies, it was even now +doubtful whether the campaign would close at Paris or on the Rhine. + +[Campaign of 1814.] + +For some days after the arrival of the monarchs and diplomatists at Langres +(Jan. 22), Metternich and the more timorous among the generals opposed any +further advance into France, and argued that the army had already gained +all it needed by the occupation of the border provinces. It was only upon +the threat of the Czar to continue the war by himself that the Austrians +consented to move forward upon Paris. After several days had been lost in +discussion, the advance from Langres was begun. Orders were given to +Bluecher, who had pushed back the French divisions commanded by Marmont and +Mortier, and who was now near St. Dizier on the Marne, to meet the Great +Army at Brienne. This was the situation of the Allies when, on the 25th of +January, Napoleon left Paris, and placed himself at Chalons on the Marne, +at the head of his left wing, having his right at Troyes and at Arcis, +guarding the bridges over the Seine and the Aube. Napoleon knew that +Bluecher was moving towards the Austrians; he hoped to hold the Prussian +general in check at St. Dizier, and to throw himself upon the heads of +Schwarzenberg's columns as they moved towards the Aube. Bluecher, however, +had already passed St. Dizier when Napoleon reached it. Napoleon pursued, +and overtook the Prussians at Brienne. After an indecisive battle, Bluecher +fell back towards Schwarzenberg. The allied armies effected their junction, +and Bluecher, now supported by the Austrians, turned and marched down the +right bank of the Aube to meet Napoleon. Napoleon, though far outnumbered, +accepted battle. He was attacked at La Rothiere close above Brienne, and +defeated with heavy loss (Feb. 1). A vigorous pursuit would probably have +ended the war; but the Austrians held back. Schwarzenberg believed peace to +be already gained, and condemned all further action as useless waste of +life. In spite of the protests of the Emperor Alexander, he allowed +Napoleon to retire unmolested. Schwarzenberg's inaction was no mere error +in military judgment. There was a direct conflict between the Czar and the +Austrian Cabinet as to the end to be obtained by the war. Alexander already +insisted on the dethronement of Napoleon; the Austrian Government would +have been content to leave Napoleon in power if he would accept a peace +giving France no worse a frontier than it had possessed in 1791. +Castlereagh, who had come from England, and Hardenberg were as yet inclined +to support Metternich's policy, although the whole Prussian army, the +public opinion of Great Britain, and the counsels of Stein and all the +bolder Prussian statesmen, were on the side of the Czar. [188] + +[Congress of Chatillon, Feb. 5-9.] + +Already the influence of the peace-party was so far in the ascendant that +negotiations had been opened with Napoleon. Representatives of all the +Powers assembled at Chatillon, in Burgundy; and there, towards the end of +January, Caulaincourt appeared on behalf of France. The first sitting took +place on the 5th of February; on the following day Caulaincourt received +full powers from Napoleon to conclude peace. The Allies laid down as the +condition of peace the limitation of France to the frontiers of 1791. Had +Caulaincourt dared to conclude peace instantly on these terms, Napoleon +would have retained his throne; but he was aware that Napoleon had only +granted him full powers in consequence of the disastrous battle of La +Rothiere, and he feared to be disavowed by his master as soon as the army +had escaped from danger. Instead of simply accepting the Allies' offer, he +raised questions as to the future of Italy and Germany. The moment was +lost; on the 9th of February the Czar recalled his envoy from Chatillon, +and the sittings of the Congress were broken off. + +[Defeats of Bluecher on the Marne Feb. 10-14.] + +[Montereau, Feb 18.] + +[Austrians fall back towards Langres.] + +Schwarzenberg was now slowly and unwillingly moving forwards along the +Seine towards Troyes. Bluecher was permitted to return to the Marne, and to +advance upon Paris by an independent line of march. He crossed the country +between the Aube and the Marne, and joined some divisions which he had left +behind him on the latter river. But his dispositions were outrageously +careless: his troops were scattered over a space of sixty miles from +Chalons westward, as if he had no enemy to guard against except the weak +divisions commanded by Mortier and Marmont, which had uniformly fallen back +before his advance. Suddenly Napoleon himself appeared at the centre of the +long Prussian line at Champaubert. He had hastened northwards in pursuit of +Bluecher with 30,000 men, as soon as Schwarzenberg entered Troyes; and on +February 10th a weak Russian corps that lay in the centre of Bluecher's +column was overwhelmed before it was known the Emperor had left the Seine. +Then, turning leftwards, Napoleon overthrew the Prussian vanguard at +Montmirail, and two days later attacked and defeated Bluecher himself, who +was bringing up the remainder of his troops in total ignorance of the enemy +with whom he had to deal. In four days Bluecher's army, which numbered +70,000 men, had thrice been defeated in detail by a force of 30,000. +Bluecher was compelled to fall back upon Chalons; Napoleon instantly +returned to the support of Oudinot's division, which he had left in front +of Schwarzenberg. In order to relieve Bluecher, the Austrians had pushed +forward on the Seine beyond Montereau. Within three days after the battle +with Bluecher, Napoleon was back upon the Seine, and attacking the heads of +the Austrian column. On the 18th of February he gained so decisive a +victory at Montereau that Schwarzenberg abandoned the advance, and fell +back upon Troyes, sending word to Bluecher to come southwards again and help +him to fight a great battle. Bluecher moved off with admirable energy, and +came into the neighbourhood of Troyes within a week after his defeats upon +the Marne. But the design of fighting a great battle was given up. The +disinclination of the Austrians to vigorous action was too strong to be +overcome; and it was finally determined that Schwarzenberg should fall back +almost to the plateau of Langres, leaving Bluecher to unite with the troops +of Buelow which had conquered Holland, and to operate on the enemy's flank +and rear. + +[Congress of Chatillon resumed, Feb. 17-March 15.] + +The effect of Napoleon's sudden victories on the Marne was instantly seen +in the councils of the allied sovereigns. Alexander, who had withdrawn his +envoy from Chatillon, could no longer hold out against negotiations with +Napoleon. He restored the powers of his envoy, and the Congress +re-assembled. But Napoleon already saw himself in imagination driving the +invaders beyond the Rhine, and sent orders to Caulaincourt to insist upon +the terms proposed at Frankfort, which left to France both the Rhenish +Provinces and Belgium. At the same time he attempted to open a private +negotiation with his father-in-law the Emperor of Austria, and to detach +him from the cause of the Allies. The attempt failed; the demands now made +by Caulaincourt overcame even the peaceful inclinations of the Austrian +Minister; and on the 1st of March the Allies signed a new treaty at +Chaumont, pledging themselves to conclude no peace with Napoleon that did +not restore the frontier of 1791, and to maintain a defensive alliance +against France for a period of twenty years. [189] Caulaincourt continued +for another fortnight at Chatillon, instructed by Napoleon to prolong the +negotiations, but forbidden to accept the only conditions which the Allies +were willing to grant. + +[Napoleon follows Bluecher to the north. Battle of Laon, March 10.] + +Bluecher was now on his way northwards to join the so-called army of +Bernadotte upon the Aisne. Since the Battle of Leipzig, Bernadotte himself +had taken no part in the movements of the army nominally under his command. +The Netherlands had been conquered by Buelow and the Russian general +Winzingerode, and these officers were now pushing southwards in order to +take part with Bluecher in a movement against Paris. Napoleon calculated +that the fortress of Soissons would bar the way to the northern army, and +enable him to attack and crush Bluecher before he could effect a junction +with his colleagues. He set out in pursuit of the Prussians, still hoping +for a second series of victories like those he had won upon the Marne. But +the cowardice of the commander of Soissons ruined his chances of success. +The fortress surrendered to the Russians at the first summons. Bluecher met +the advanced guard of the northern army upon the Aisne on the 4th of March, +and continued his march towards Laon for the purpose of uniting with its +divisions which lay in the rear. The French followed, but the only +advantage gained by Napoleon was a victory over a detached Russian corps at +Craonne. Marmont was defeated with heavy loss by a sally of Bluecher from +his strong position on the hill of Laon (March 10); and the Emperor +himself, unable to restore the fortune of the battle, fell back upon +Soissons, and thence marched southward to throw himself again upon the line +of the southern army. + +[Napoleon marches to the rear of the Allies, March 23.] + +[The Allies advance on Paris.] + +Schwarzenberg had once more begun to move forward on the news of Bluecher's +victory at Laon. His troops were so widely dispersed that Napoleon might +even now have cut the line in halves had he known Schwarzenberg's real +position. But he made a detour in order to meet Oudinot's corps, and gave +the Austrians time to concentrate at Arcis-sur-Aube. Here, on the 20th of +March, Napoleon found himself in face of an army of 100,000 men. His own +army was less than a third of that number; yet with unalterable contempt +for the enemy he risked another battle. No decided issue was reached in the +first day's fighting, and Napoleon remained in position, expecting that +Schwarzenberg would retreat during the night. But on the morrow the +Austrians were still fronting him. Schwarzenberg had at length learnt his +own real superiority, and resolved to assist the enemy no longer by a +wretched system of retreat. A single act of firmness on the part of the +Austrian commander showed Napoleon that the war of battles was at an end. +He abandoned all hope of resisting the invaders in front: it only remained +for him to throw himself on to their rear, and, in company with the +frontier-garrisons and the army of Lyons, to attack their communications +with Germany. The plan was no unreasonable one, if Paris could either have +sustained a siege or have fallen into the enemy's hands without terminating +the war. But the Allies rightly judged that Napoleon's power would be +extinct from the moment that Paris submitted. They received the +intelligence of the Emperor's march to the east, and declined to follow +him. The armies of Schwarzenberg and Bluecher approached one another, and +moved together on Paris. It was at Vitry, on March 27th, that Napoleon +first discovered that the troops which had appeared to be following his +eastward movement were but a detachment of cavalry, and that the allied +armies were in full march upon the capital. He instantly called up every +division within reach, and pushed forward by forced marches for the Seine, +hoping to fall upon Schwarzenberg's rear before the allied vanguard could +reach Paris. But at each hour of the march it became more evident that the +enemy was far in advance. For two days Napoleon urged his men forward; at +length, unable to bear the intolerable suspense, he quitted the army on the +morning of the 30th, and drove forward at the utmost speed along the road +through Fontainebleau to the capital. As day sank, he met reports of a +battle already begun. When he reached the village of Fromenteau, fifteen +miles from Paris, at ten o'clock at night, he heard that Paris had actually +surrendered. + +[Attack on Paris, March 30.] + +[Capitulation of Marmont.] + +[Allies enter Paris, March 31.] + +The Allies had pressed forward without taking any notice of Napoleon's +movements, and at early morning on the 30th they had opened the attack on +the north-eastern heights of Paris. Marmont, with the fragments of a beaten +army and some weak divisions of the National Guard, had but 35,000 men to +oppose to three times that number of the enemy. The Government had taken no +steps to arm the people, or to prolong resistance after the outside line of +defence was lost, although the erection of barricades would have held the +Allies in check until Napoleon arrived with his army. While Marmont fought +in the outer suburbs, masses of the people were drawn up on Montmartre, +expecting the Emperor's appearance, and the spectacle of a great and +decisive battle. But the firing in the outskirts stopped soon after noon: +it was announced that Marmont had capitulated. The report struck the people +with stupor and fury. They had vainly been demanding arms since early +morning; and even after the capitulation unsigned papers were handed about +by men of the working classes, advocating further resistance. [190] But the +people no longer knew how to follow leaders of its own. Napoleon had +trained France to look only to himself: his absence left the masses, who +were still eager to fight for France, helpless in the presence of the +conqueror: there were enemies enough of the Government among the richer +classes to make the entry of the foreigner into Paris a scene of actual joy +and exultation. To such an extent had the spirit of caste and the malignant +delight in Napoleon's ruin overpowered the love of France among the party +of the old noblesse, that upon the entry of the allied forces into Paris on +the 31st of March hundreds of aristocratic women kissed the hands, or the +very boots and horses, of the leaders of the train, and cheered the +Cossacks who escorted a band of French prisoners, bleeding and exhausted, +through the streets. + +[Napoleon dethroned, April 2.] + +Napoleon's reign was indeed at an end. Since the rupture of the Congress of +Chatillon on the 18th of March, the Allies had determined to make his +dethronement a condition of peace. As the end approached, it was seen that +no successor was possible but the chief of the House of Bourbon, although +Austria would perhaps have consented to the establishment of a Regency +under the Empress Marie Louise, and the Czar had for a time entertained the +project of placing Bernadotte at the head of the French State. Immediately +after the entry into Paris it was determined to raise the exile Louis +XVIII. to the throne. The politicians of the Empire who followed Talleyrand +were not unwilling to unite with the conquerors, and with the small party +of Royalist noblesse, in recalling the Bourbon dynasty. Alexander, who was +the real master of the situation, rightly judged Talleyrand to be the man +most capable of enlisting the public opinion of France on the side of the +new order. He took up his abode at Talleyrand's house, and employed this +dexterous statesman as the advocate both of the policy of the Allies, and +of the principles of constitutional liberty, which at this time Alexander +himself sincerely befriended. A Provisional Government was appointed under +Talleyrand's leadership. On the 2nd of April the Senate proclaimed the +dethronement of Napoleon. On the 6th it published a Constitution, and +recalled the House of Bourbon. + +Louis XVIII. was still in England: his brother, the Count of Artois, had +joined the invaders in France and assumed the title of Lieutenant of the +Kingdom; but the influence of Alexander was necessary to force this +obstinate and unteachable man into anything like a constitutional position. +The Provisional Government invited the Count to take up the administration +until the King's arrival, in virtue of a decree of the Senate. D'Artois +declined to recognise the Senate's competency, and claimed the Lieutenancy +of the Kingdom as his brother's representative. The Senate refusing to +admit the Count's divine right, some unmeaning words were exchanged when +d'Artois entered Paris; and the Provisional Government, disregarding the +claims of the Royal Lieutenant, continued in the full exercise of its +powers. At length the Czar insisted that d'Artois should give way. The +decree of the Senate was accordingly accepted by him at the Tuileries on +the 14th of April; the Provisional Government retired, and a Council of +State was formed, in which Talleyrand still continued to exercise the real +powers of government. In the address made by d'Artois on this occasion, he +stated that although the King had not empowered him to accept the +Constitution made by the Senate on the 6th of April, he entertained no +doubt that the King would accept the principles embodied in that +Constitution, which were those of Representative Government, of the freedom +of the press, and of the responsibility of ministers. A week after +d'Artois' declaration, Louis XVIII. arrived in France. + +[Louis XVIII. and the Czar.] + +[Louis XVIII. enters Paris, May 3.] + +Louis XVIII., though capable of adapting himself in practice to a +constitutional system, had never permitted himself to question the divine +right of the House of Bourbon to sovereign power. The exiles who surrounded +him were slow to understand the needs of the time. They recommended the +King to reject the Constitution. Louis made an ambiguous answer when the +Legislative Body met him at Compiegne and invited an expression of the +royal policy. It was again necessary for the Czar to interfere, and to +explain to the King that France could no longer be an absolute monarchy. +Louis, however, was a better arguer than the Count of Artois. He reasoned +as a man whom the sovereigns of Europe had felt it their duty to restore +without any request from himself. If the Senate of Napoleon, he urged, had +the right to give France a Constitution, he himself ought never to have +been brought from his peaceful English home. He was willing to grant a free +Constitution to his people in exercise of his own royal rights, but he +could not recognise one created by the servants of an usurper. Alexander +was but half satisfied with the liberal professions of Louis: he did not, +however, insist on his acceptance of the Constitution drawn up by the +Senate, but he informed him that until the promises made by d'Artois were +confirmed by a royal proclamation, there would be no entry into Paris. The +King at length signed a proclamation written by Talleyrand, and made his +festal entry into the capital on the 3rd of May. + +[Feeling of Paris.] + +The promises of Louis himself, the unbroken courtesy and friendliness shown +by the Allies to Paris since their victory a month before, had almost +extinguished the popular feeling of hostility towards a dynasty which owed +its recall to the overthrow of French armies. The foreign leaders +themselves had begun to excite a certain admiration and interest. Alexander +was considered, and with good reason, as a generous enemy; the simplicity +of the King of Prussia, his misfortunes, his well-remembered gallantry at +the Battle of Jena, gained him general sympathy. It needed but little on +the part of the returning Bourbons to convert the interest and curiosity of +Paris into affection. The cortege which entered the capital with Louis +XVIII. brought back, in a singular motley of obsolete and of foreign +costumes, the bearers of many unforgotten names. The look of the King +himself, as he drove through Paris, pleased the people. The childless +father of the murdered Duke of Enghien gained the pitying attention of +those few who knew the face of a man twenty-five years an exile. But there +was one among the members of the returning families whom every heart in +Paris went out to meet. The daughter of Louis XVI., who had shared the +captivity of her parents and of her brother, the sole survivor of her +deeply-wronged house, now returned as Duchess of Angouleme. The uniquely +mournful history of her girlhood, and her subsequent marriage with her +cousin, the son of the Count of Artois, made her the natural object of a +warmer sympathy than could attach to either of the brothers of Louis XVI. +But adversity had imprinted its lines too deeply upon the features and the +disposition of this joyless woman for a moment's light to return. Her voice +and her aspect repelled the affection which thousands were eager to offer +to her. Before the close of the first days of the restored monarchy, it was +felt that the Bourbons had brought back no single person among them who was +capable of winning the French nation's love. + +[Napoleon sent to Elba.] + +[Napoleon.] + +The recall of the ancient line had been allowed to appear to the world as +the work of France itself; Napoleon's fate could only be fixed by his +conquerors. After the fall of Paris, Napoleon remained at Fontainebleau +awaiting events. The soldiers and the younger officers of his army were +still ready to fight for him; the marshals, however, were utterly weary, +and determined that France should no longer suffer for the sake of a single +man. They informed Napoleon that he must abdicate. Yielding to their +pressure, Napoleon, on the 3rd of April, drew up an act of abdication in +favour of his infant son, and sent it by Caulaincourt to the allied +sovereigns at Paris. The document was rejected by the Allies; Caulaincourt +returned with the intelligence that Napoleon must renounce the throne for +himself and all his family. For a moment the Emperor thought of renewing +the war; but the marshals refused their aid more resolutely than before, +and, on the 6th of April, Napoleon signed an unconditional surrender of the +throne for himself and his heirs. He was permitted by the Allies to retain +the unmeaning title of Emperor, and to carry with him a body-guard and a +considerable revenue to the island of Elba, henceforward to be his +principality and his prison. The choice of this island, within easy reach +of France and Italy, and too extensive to be guarded without a large fleet, +was due to Alexander's ill-judged generosity towards Napoleon, and to a +promise made to Marmont that the liberty of the Emperor should be +respected. Alexander was not left without warning of the probable effects +of his leniency. Sir Charles Stewart, military representative of Great +Britain at the allied head-quarters, urged both his own and the allied +Governments to substitute some more distant island for Elba, if they +desired to save Europe from a renewed Napoleonic war, and France from the +misery of a second invasion. The Allies, though not without misgivings, +adhered to their original plan, and left it to time to justify the +predictions of their adviser. + +[Treaty of Paris, May 30.] + +It was well known what would be the terms of peace, now that Napoleon was +removed from the throne. The Allies had no intention of depriving France of +any of the territory that it had held before 1792: the conclusion of a +definitive Treaty was only postponed until the Constitution, which +Alexander required King Louis XVIII. to grant, had been drawn up by a royal +commission and approved by the King. On the 27th of May the draft of this +Constitution, known as the Charta, was laid before the King, and sanctioned +by him; on the 30th, the Treaty of Paris was signed by the representatives +of France and of all the great Powers. [191] France, surrendering all its +conquests, accepted the frontier of the 1st of January, 1792, with a slight +addition of territory on the side of Savoy and at points on its northern +and eastern border. It paid no indemnity. It was permitted to retain all +the works of art accumulated by twenty years of rapine, except the trophies +carried from the Brandenburg Gate of Berlin and the spoils of the Library +of Vienna. It received back nearly all the colonies which had been taken +from it by Great Britain. By the clauses of the Treaty disposing of the +territory that had formed the Empire and the dependencies of Napoleon, +Holland was restored to the House of Orange, with the provision that its +territory should be largely increased; Switzerland was declared +independent; it was stipulated that Italy, with the exception of the +Austrian Provinces, should consist of independent States, and that Germany +should remain distributed among a multitude of sovereigns, independent, but +united by a Federal tie. The navigation of the Rhine was thrown open. By a +special agreement with Great Britain the French Government undertook to +unite its efforts to those of England in procuring the suppression of the +Slave-trade by all the Powers, and pledged itself to abolish the +Slave-trade among French subjects within five years at the latest. For the +settlement of all European questions not included in the Treaty of Paris it +was agreed that a Congress of the Powers should, within two months, +assemble at Vienna. These were the public articles of the Treaty of Paris. +Secret clauses provided that the Allies--that is, the Allies independently +of France--should control the distributions of territory to be made at the +Congress; that Austria should receive Venetia and all Northern Italy as far +as the Ticino; that Genoa should be given to the King of Sardinia; and that +the Southern Netherlands should be united into a single kingdom with +Holland, and thus form a solid bulwark against France on the north. No +mention was made of Naples, whose sovereign, Murat, had abandoned Napoleon +and allied himself with Austria, but without fulfilling in good faith the +engagements into which he had entered against his former master. A nominal +friend of the Allies, he knew that he had played a double game, and that +his sovereignty, though not yet threatened, was insecure. [192] + +[Territorial arrangements of 1814.] + +Much yet remained to be settled by the Congress at Vienna, but in the +Treaty of Paris two at least of the great Powers saw the objects attained +for which they had straggled so persistently through all the earlier years +of the war, and which at a later time had appeared to pass almost out of +the range of possibility. England saw the Netherlands once more converted +into a barrier against France, and Antwerp held by friendly hands. Austria +reaped the full reward of its cool and well-balanced diplomacy during the +crisis of 1813, in the annexation of an Italian territory that made it the +real mistress of the Peninsula. Castlereagh and every other English +politician felt that Europe had done itself small honour in handing Venice +back to the Hapsburg; but this had been the condition exacted by Metternich +at Prague before he consented to throw the sword of Austria into the +trembling scale; [193] and the Republican traditions both of Venice and of +Genoa counted for little among the statesmen of 1814, in comparison with +the divine right of a Duke of Modena or a Prince of Hesse Cassel. [194] +France itself, though stripped of the dominion won by twenty years of +warfare, was permitted to retain, for the benefit of a restored line of +kings, the whole of its ancient territory, and the spoil of all the +galleries and museums of Western Europe. It would have been no unnatural +wrong if the conquerors of 1814 had dealt with the soil of France as France +had dealt with other lands; it would have been an act of bare justice to +restore to its rightful owners the pillage that had been brought to Paris, +and to recover from the French treasury a part of the enormous sums which +Napoleon had extorted from conquered States. But the Courts were too well +satisfied with their victory to enter into a strict account upon secondary +matters; and a prudent regard on the part of the Allies to the prospects of +the House of Bourbon saved France from experiencing what it had inflicted +upon others. + +[All the Powers except France gained territory by the war, 1792-1814.] + +The policy which now restored to France the frontier of 1792 was viewed +with a very different feeling in France and in all other countries. Europe +looked with a kind of wonder upon its own generosity; France forgot the +unparalleled provocations which it had offered to mankind, and only +remembered that Belgium and the Rhenish Provinces had formed part of the +Republic and the Empire for nearly twenty years. These early conquests of +the Republic, which no one had attempted to wrest from France since 1795, +had undoubtedly been the equivalent for which, in the days of the +Directory, Austria had been permitted to extend itself in Italy, and +Prussia in Germany. In the opinion of men who sincerely condemned +Napoleon's distant conquests, the territory between France and the Rhine +was no more than France might legitimately demand, as a counterpoise to the +vast accessions falling to one or other of the Continental Powers out of +the territory of Poland, Venice, and the body of suppressed States in +Germany. Poland, excluding the districts taken from it before 1792, +contained a population twice as great as that of Belgium and the Rhenish +Provinces together: Venice carried with it, in addition to a commanding +province on the Italian mainland, the Eastern Adriatic Coast as far as +Ragusa. If it were true that the proportionate increase of power formed the +only solid principle of European policy, France sustained a grievous injury +in receiving back the limits of 1791, when every other State on the +Continent was permitted to retain the territory, or an equivalent for the +territory, which it had gained in the great changes that took place between +1791 and 1814. But in fact there had never been a time during the last +hundred and fifty years when France, under an energetic Government, had not +possessed a force threatening to all its neighbours. France, reduced to its +ancient limits, was still the equal, and far more than the equal, of any of +the Continental Powers, with all that they had gained during the +Revolutionary War. It remained the first of European nations, though no +longer, as in the eighteenth century, the one great nation of the western +continent. Its efforts after universal empire had aroused other nations +into life. Had the course of French conquest ceased before Napoleon grasped +power, France would have retained its frontier of the Rhine, and long have +exercised an unbounded influence over both Germany and Italy, through the +incomparably juster and brighter social life which the Revolution, combined +with all that France had inherited from the past, enabled it to display to +those countries. Napoleon, in the attempt to impose his rule upon all +Europe, created a power in Germany whose military future was to be not less +solid than that of France itself, and left to Europe, in the accord of his +enemies, a firmer security against French attack than any that the efforts +of statesmen had ever framed. + +[Permanent effect on Europe of period 1792-1814.] + +[National sense excited in Germany and Italy.] + +The league of the older monarchies had proved stronger in the end than the +genius and the ambition of a single man. But if, in the service of +Napoleon, France had exhausted its wealth, sunk its fleets, and sacrificed +a million lives, only that it might lose all its earlier conquests, and +resume limits which it had outgrown before Napoleon held his first command, +it was not thus with the work which, for or against itself, France had +effected in Europe during the movements of the last twenty years. In the +course of the epoch now ending the whole of the Continent up to the +frontiers of Austria and Russia had gained the two fruitful ideas of +nationality and political freedom. There were now two nations in Europe +where before there had been but aggregates of artificial States. Germany +and Italy were no longer mere geographical expressions: in both countries, +though in a very unequal degree, the newly-aroused sense of nationality had +brought with it the claim for unity and independence. In Germany, Prussia +had set a great example, and was hereafter to reap its reward; in Italy +there had been no State and no statesman to take the lead either in +throwing off Napoleon's rule, or in forcing him, as the price of support, +to give to his Italian kingdom a really national government. Failing to act +for itself, the population of all Italy, except Naples, was parcelled out +between Austria and the ancient dynasties; but the old days of passive +submission to the foreigner were gone for ever, and time was to show +whether those were the dreamers who thought of a united Italy, or those who +thought that Metternich's statesmanship had for ever settled the fate of +Venice and of Milan. + +[Desire for political liberty.] + +The second legacy of the Revolutionary epoch, the idea of constitutional +freedom, which in 1789 had been as much wanting in Spain, where national +spirit was the strongest, as in those German States where it was the +weakest, had been excited in Italy by the events of 1796 and 1798, in Spain +by the disappearance of the Bourbon king and the self-directed struggle of +the nation against the invader; in Prussia it had been introduced by the +Government itself when Stein was at the head of the State. "It is +impossible," wrote Lord Castlereagh in the spring of 1814, "not to perceive +a great moral change coming on in Europe, and that the principles of +freedom are in full operation." [195] There was in fact scarcely a Court in +Europe which was not now declaring its intention to frame a Constitution. +The professions might be lightly made; the desire and the capacity for +self-government might still be limited to a narrower class than the friends +of liberty imagined; but the seed was sown, and a movement had begun which +was to gather strength during the next thirty years of European history, +while one revolution after another proved that Governments could no longer +with safety disregard the rights of their subjects. + +[Social changes.] + +Lastly, in all the territory that had formed Napoleon's Empire and +dependencies, and also in Prussia, legal changes had been made in the +rights and relations of the different classes of society, so important as +almost to create a new type of social life. Within the Empire itself the +Code Napoleon, conferring upon the subjects of France the benefits which +the French had already won for themselves, had superseded a society resting +on class-privilege, on feudal service, and on the despotism of custom, by a +society resting on equality before the law, on freedom of contract, and on +the unshackled ownership and enjoyment of land, whether the holder +possessed an acre or a league. The principles of the French Code, if not +the Code itself, had been introduced into Napoleon's kingdom of Italy, into +Naples, and into almost all the German dependencies of France. In Prussia +the reforms of Stein and Hardenberg had been directed, though less boldly, +towards the same end; and when, after 1814, the Rhenish Provinces were +annexed to Prussia by the Congress of Vienna, the Government was wise +enough and liberal enough to leave these districts in the enjoyment of the +laws which France had given them, and not to risk a comparison between even +the best Prussian legislation and the Code Napoleon. In other territory now +severed from France and restored to German or Italian princes, attempts +were not wanting to obliterate the new order and to re-introduce the +burdens and confusions of the old regime. But these reactions, even where +unopposed for a time, were too much in conflict with the spirit of the age +to gain more than a temporary and precarious success. The people had begun +to know good and evil: examples of a free social order were too close at +hand to render it possible for any part of the western continent to relapse +for any very long period into the condition of the eighteenth century. + +[Limits.] + +It was indeed within a distinct limit that the Revolutionary epoch effected +its work of political and social change. Neither England nor Austria +received the slightest impulse to progress. England, on the contrary, +suspended almost all internal improvement during the course of the war; the +domestic policy of the Austrian Court, so energetic in the reign +immediately preceding the Revolution, became for the next twenty years, +except where it was a policy of repression, a policy of pure vacancy and +inaction. But in all other States of Western Europe the period which +reached its close with Napoleon's fall left deep and lasting traces behind +it. Like other great epochs of change, it bore its own peculiar character. +It was not, like the Renaissance and the Reformation, a time when new +worlds of faith and knowledge transformed the whole scope and conception of +human life; it was not, like our own age, a time when scientific discovery +and increased means of communication silently altered the physical +conditions of existence; it was a time of changes directly political in +their nature, and directly effected by the political agencies of +legislation and of war. In the perspective of history the Napoleonic age +will take its true place among other, and perhaps greater, epochs. Its +elements of mere violence and disturbance will fill less space in the eyes +of mankind; its permanent creations, more. As an epoch of purely political +energy, concentrating the work of generations within the compass of twenty +five years, it will perhaps scarcely find a parallel. + + + + +CHAPTER XII. + + +The Restoration of 1814--Norway--Naples--Westphalia--Spain--The Spanish +Constitution overthrown: Victory of the Clergy--Restoration in France--The +Charta--Encroachments of the Nobles and Clergy--Growing Hostility to the +Bourbons--Congress of Vienna--Talleyrand and the Four Powers--The Polish +Question--The Saxon Question--Theory of Legitimacy--Secret Alliance against +Russia and Prussia--Compromise--The Rhenish Provinces--Napoleon leaves Elba +and lands in France--His Declarations--Napoleon at Grenoble, at Lyon, at +Paris--The Congress of Vienna unites Europe against France--Murat's Action +in Italy--The Acte Additionnel--The Champ de Mai--Napoleon takes up the +offensive--Battles of Ligny, Quatre Bras, Waterloo--Affairs at +Paris--Napoleon sent to St. Helena--Wellington and Fouche--Arguments on the +proposed Cession of French Territory--Treaty of Holy Alliance--Second +Treaty of Paris--Conclusion of the Work of the Congress of Vienna-- +Federation of Germany--Estimate of the Congress of Vienna and of the +Treaties of 1815--The Slave Trade. + + +Of all the events which, in the more recent history of mankind, have struck +the minds of nations with awe, and appeared to reveal in its direct +operation a power overruling the highest human effort, there is none equal +in grandeur and terror to the annihilation of Napoleon's army in the +invasion of Russia. It was natural that a generation which had seen State +after State overthrown, and each new violation of right followed by an +apparent consolidation of the conqueror's strength, should view in the +catastrophe of 1812 the hand of Providence visibly outstretched for the +deliverance of Europe. [196] Since that time many years have passed. Perils +which then seemed to envelop the future of mankind now appear in part +illusory; sacrifices then counted cheap have proved of heavy cost. The +history of the two last generations shows that not everything was lost to +Europe in passing subjection to a usurper, nor everything gained by the +victory of his opponents. It is now not easy to suppress the doubt whether +the permanent interests of mankind would not have been best served by +Napoleon's success in 1812. His empire had already attained dimensions that +rendered its ultimate disruption certain: less depended upon the +postponement or the acceleration of its downfall than on the order of +things ready to take its place. The victory of Napoleon in 1812 would have +been followed by the establishment of a Polish kingdom in the provinces +taken from Russia. From no generosity in the conqueror, from no sympathy on +his part with a fallen people, but from the necessities of his political +situation, Poland must have been so organised as to render it the bulwark +of French supremacy in the East. The serf would have been emancipated. The +just hatred of the peasant to the noble, which made the partition of 1772 +easy, and has proved fatal to every Polish uprising from that time to the +present, would have been appeased by an agrarian reform executed with +Napoleon's own unrivalled energy and intelligence, and ushered in with +brighter hopes than have at any time in the history of Poland lit the dark +shades of peasant-life. The motives which in 1807 had led Napoleon to stay +his hand, and to content himself with half-measures of emancipation in the +Duchy of Warsaw [197], could have had no place after 1812, when Russia +remained by his side, a mutilated but inexorable enemy, ever on the watch +to turn to its own advantage the first murmurs of popular discontent beyond +the border. Political independence, the heritage of the Polish noble, might +have been withheld, but the blessing of landed independence would have been +bestowed on the mass of the Polish people. In the course of some years this +restored kingdom, though governed by a member of the house of Bonaparte, +would probably have gained sufficient internal strength to survive the +downfall of Napoleon's Empire or his own decease. England, Austria, and +Turkey would have found it no impossible task to prevent its absorption by +Alexander at the re-settlement of Europe, if indeed the collapse of Russia +had not been followed by the overthrow of the Porte, and the establishment +of a Greek, a Bulgarian, and a Roumanian Kingdom under the supremacy of +France. By the side of the three absolute monarchs of Central and Eastern +Europe there would have remained, upon Napoleon's downfall, at least one +people in possession of the tradition of liberty: and from the example of +Poland, raised from the deep but not incurable degradation of its social +life, the rulers of Russia might have gained courage to emancipate the +serf, without waiting for the lapse of another half-century and the +occurrence of a second ruinous war. To compare a possible sequence of +events with the real course of history, to estimate the good lost and evil +got through events which at the time seemed to vindicate the moral +governance of the world, is no idle exercise of the imagination. It may +serve to give caution to the judgment: it may guard us against an arbitrary +and fanciful interpretation of the actual. The generation which witnessed +the fall of Napoleon is not the only one which has seen Providence in the +fulfilment of its own desire, and in the storm-cloud of nature and history +has traced with too sanguine gaze the sacred lineaments of human equity and +love. + +[Settlement of 1814.] + +[Norway.] + +[Naples.] + +The Empire of Napoleon had indeed passed away. The conquests won by the +first soldiers of the Republic were lost to France along with all the +latest spoils of its Emperor; but the restoration which was effected in +1814 was no restoration of the political order which had existed on the +Continent before the outbreak of the Revolutionary War. The Powers which +had overthrown Napoleon had been partakers, each in its own season, in the +system of aggrandisement which had obliterated the old frontiers of Europe. +Russia had gained Finland, Bessarabia, and the greater part of Poland; +Austria had won Venice, Dalmatia, and Salzburg; Prussia had received +between the years 1792 and 1806 an extension of territory in Poland and +Northern Germany that more than doubled its area. It was now no part of the +policy of the victorious Courts to reinstate the governments which they had +themselves dispossessed: the settlement of 1814, in so far as it deserved +the name of a restoration, was confined to the territory taken from +Napoleon and from princes of his house. Here, though the claims of +Republics and Ecclesiastical Princes were forgotten, the titles of the old +dynasties were freely recognised. In France itself, in the Spanish +Peninsula, in Holland, Westphalia, Piedmont, and Tuscany, the banished +houses resumed their sovereignty. It cost the Allies nothing to restore +these countries to their hereditary rulers, and it enabled them to describe +the work of 1814 in general terms as the restoration of lawful government +and national independence. But the claims of legitimacy, as well as of +national right, were, as a matter of fact, only remembered where there +existed no motive to disregard them; where they conflicted with +arrangements of policy, they received small consideration. Norway, which +formed part of the Danish monarchy, had been promised by Alexander to +Bernadotte, Crown Prince of Sweden, in 1812, in return for his support +against Napoleon, and the bargain had been ratified by the Allies. As soon +as Napoleon was overthrown, Bernadotte claimed his reward. It was in vain +that the Norwegians, abandoned by their king, declared themselves +independent, and protested against being handed over like a flock of sheep +by the liberators of Europe. The Allies held to their contract; a British +fleet was sent to assist Bernadotte in overpowering his new subjects, and +after a brief resistance the Norwegians found themselves compelled to +submit to their fate (April--Aug., 1814). [198] At the other extremity of +Europe a second of Napoleon's generals still held his throne among the +restored legitimate monarchs. Murat, King of Naples, had forsaken Napoleon +in time to make peace and alliance with Austria. Great Britain, though +entering into a military convention, had not been a party to this treaty; +and it had declared that its own subsequent support of Murat would depend +upon the condition that he should honourably exert himself in Italy against +Napoleon's forces. This condition Murat had not fulfilled. The British +Government was, however, but gradually supplied with proofs of his +treachery; nor was Lord Liverpool, the Prime Minister, inclined to raise +new difficulties at Vienna by pressing the claim of Ferdinand of Sicily to +his territories on the mainland. [199] Talleyrand, on behalf of the +restored Bourbons of Paris, intended to throw all his strength into a +diplomatic attack upon Murat before the end of the Congress; but for the +present Murat's chances seemed to be superior to those of his rival. +Southern Italy thus continued in the hands of a soldier of fortune, who, +unlike Bernadotte, was secretly the friend of Napoleon, and ready to +support him in any attempt to regain his throne. + +[Restoration in Westphalia.] + +The engagement of the Allies towards Bernadotte, added to the stipulations +of the Peace of Paris, left little to be decided by the Congress of Vienna +beyond the fate of Poland, Saxony, and Naples, and the form of political +union to be established in Germany. It had been agreed that the Congress +should assemble within two months after the signature of the Peace of +Paris: this interval, however, proved to be insufficient, and the autumn +had set in before the first diplomatists arrived at Vienna, and began the +conferences which preceded the formal opening of the Congress. In the +meantime a singular spectacle was offered to Europe by the Courts whose +restoration was the subject of so much official thanksgiving. Before King +Louis XVIII. returned to Paris, the exiled dynasties had regained their +thrones in Northern Germany and in Spain. The process of reaction had begun +in Hanover and in Hesse as soon as the battle of Leipzig had dissolved the +Kingdom of Westphalia and driven Napoleon across the Rhine. Hanover indeed +did not enjoy the bodily presence of its Sovereign: its character was +oligarchical, and the reaction here was more the affair of the privileged +classes than of the Government. In Hesse a prince returned who was the very +embodiment of divine right, a prince who had sturdily fought against French +demagogues in 1792, and over whose stubborn, despotic nature the +revolutions of a whole generation and the loss of his own dominions since +the battle of Jena had passed without leaving a trace. The Elector was +seventy years old when, at the end of the year 1813, his faithful subjects +dragged his carriage in triumph into the streets of Cassel. On the day +after his arrival he gave orders that the Hessian soldiery who had been +sent on furlough after the battle of Jena should present themselves, every +man in the garrison-town where he had stood on the 1st of November, 1806. A +few weeks later all the reforms of the last seven years were swept away +together. The Code Napoleon ceased to be the law of the land; the old +oppressive distinctions of caste, with the special courts for the +privileged orders, came again into force, in defiance of the spirit of the +age. The feudal burdens of the peasantry were revived, the purchasers of +State-lands compelled to relinquish the land without receiving back any of +their purchase-money. The decimal coinage was driven out of the country. +The old system of taxation, with its iniquitous exemptions, was renewed. +All promotions, all grants of rank made by Jerome's Government were +annulled: every officer, every public servant resumed the station which he +had occupied on the 1st of November, 1806. The very pigtails and powder of +the common soldier under the old regime were revived. [200] + +[Restoration in Spain.] + +The Hessians and their neighbours in North-Western Germany had from of old +been treated with very little ceremony by their rulers; and if they +welcomed back a family which had been accustomed to hire them out at so +much a head to fight against the Hindoos or by the side of the North +American Indians, it only proved that they preferred their native +taskmasters to Jerome Bonaparte and his French crew of revellers and +usurers. The next scene in the European reaction was a far more mournful +one. Ferdinand of Spain had no sooner re-crossed the Pyrenees in the spring +of 1814, than, convinced of his power by the transports of popular +enthusiasm that attended his progress through Northern Spain, he determined +to overthrow the Constitution of 1812, and to re-establish the absolute +monarchy which had existed before the war. The courtiers and ecclesiastics +who gathered round the King dispelled any scruples that he might have felt +in lifting his hand against a settlement accepted by the nation. They +represented to him that the Cortes of 1812--which, whatever their faults, +had been recognised as the legitimate Government of Spain by both England +and Russia--consisted of a handful of desperate men, collected from the +streets of Cadiz, who had taken upon themselves to insult the Crown, to rob +the Church, and to imperil the existence of the Catholic Faith. On the +entry of the King into Valencia, the cathedral clergy expressed the wishes +of their order in the address of homage which they offered to Ferdinand. +"We beg your Majesty," their spokesman concluded, "to take the most +vigorous measures for the restoration of the Inquisition, and of the +ecclesiastical system that existed in Spain before your Majesty's +departure." "These," replied the King, "are my own wishes, and I will not +rest until they are fulfilled." [201] + +[Spanish Constitution overthrown.] + +The victory of the clergy was soon declared. On the 11th of May the King +issued a manifesto at Valencia, proclaiming the Constitution of 1812 and +every decree of the Cortes null and void, and denouncing the penalties of +high treason against everyone who should defend the Constitution by act, +word, or writing. A variety of promises, made only to be broken, +accompanied this assertion of the rights of the Crown. The King pledged +himself to summon new Cortes as soon as public order should be restored, to +submit the expenditure to the control of the nation, and to maintain +inviolate the security of person and property. It was a significant comment +upon Ferdinand's professions of Liberalism that on the very day on which +the proclamation was issued the censorship of the Press was restored. But +the King had not miscalculated his power over the Spanish people. The same +storm of wild, unreasoning loyalty which had followed Ferdinand's +reappearance in Spain followed the overthrow of the Constitution. The mass +of the Spaniards were ignorant of the very meaning of political liberty: +they adored the King as a savage adores his fetish: their passions were at +the call of a priesthood as brutish and unscrupulous as that which in 1798 +had excited the Lazzaroni of Naples against the Republicans of Southern +Italy. No sooner had Ferdinand set the example, by arresting thirty of the +most distinguished of the Liberals, than tumults broke out in every part of +the country against Constitutionalist magistrates and citizens. Mobs, +headed by priests bearing the standard of the Inquisition, destroyed the +tablets erected in honour of the Constitution of 1812, and burned Liberal +writings in bonfires in the market-places. The prisons were filled with men +who, but a short time before, had been the objects of popular adulation. + +[The clergy in power.] + +Whatever pledges of allegiance had been given to the Constitution of 1812, +it was clear that this Constitution had no real hold on the nation, and +that Ferdinand fulfilled the wish of the majority of Spaniards in +overthrowing it. A wise and energetic sovereign would perhaps have allowed +himself to use this outburst of religious fanaticism for the purpose of +substituting some better order for the imprudent arrangements of 1812. +Ferdinand, an ignorant, hypocritical buffoon, with no more notion of +political justice or generosity than the beasts of the field, could only +substitute for the fallen Cortes a government by palace-favourites and +confessors. It was in vain, that the representatives of Great Britain urged +the King to fulfil his constitutional promises, and to liberate the persons +who had unjustly been thrown into prison. [202] The clergy were masters of +Spain and of the King: their influence daily outweighed even that of +Ferdinand's own Ministers, when, under the pressure of financial necessity, +the Ministers began to offer some resistance to the exorbitant demands of +the priesthood. On the 23rd of May the King signed an edict restoring all +monasteries throughout Spain, and reinstating them in their lands. On the +24th of June the clergy were declared exempt from taxation. On the 21st of +July the Church won its crowning triumph in the re-establishment of the +Inquisition. In the meantime the army was left without pay, in some places +actually without food. The country was at the mercy of bands of guerillas, +who, since the disappearance of the enemy, had turned into common brigands, +and preyed upon their own countrymen. Commerce was extinct; agriculture +abandoned; innumerable villages were lying in ruins; the population was +barbarised by the savage warfare with which for years past it had avenged +its own sufferings upon the invader. Of all the countries of Europe, Spain +was the one in which the events of the Revolutionary epoch seemed to have +left an effect most nearly approaching to unmixed evil. + +[Restoration in France.] + +In comparison with the reaction in the Spanish Peninsula the reaction in +France was sober and dignified. Louis XVIII. was at least a scholar and a +man of the world. In the old days, among companions whose names were now +almost forgotten, he had revelled in Voltaire and dallied with the +fashionable Liberalism of the time. In his exile he had played the king +with some dignity; he was even believed to have learnt some political +wisdom by his six years' residence in England. If he had not character, +[203] he had at least some tact and some sense of humour; and if not a +profound philosopher, he was at least an accomplished epicurean. He hated +the zealotry of his brother, the Count of Artois. He was more inclined to +quiz the emigrants than to sacrifice anything on their behalf; and the +whole bent of his mind made him but an insincere ally of the priesthood, +who indeed could hardly expect to enjoy such an orgy in France as their +brethren were celebrating in Spain. The King, however, was unable to impart +his own indifference to the emigrants who returned with him, nor had he +imagination enough to identify himself, as King of France, with the +military glories of the nation and with the democratic army that had won +them. Louis held high notions of the royal prerogative: this would not in +itself have prevented him from being a successful ruler, if he had been +capable of governing in the interest of the nation at large. There were few +Republicans remaining in France; the centralised institutions of the Empire +remained in full vigour; and although the last months of Napoleon's rule +had excited among the educated classes a strong spirit of constitutional +opposition, an able and patriotic Bourbon accepting his new position, and +wielding power for the benefit of the people and not of a class, might +perhaps have exercised an authority not much inferior to that possessed by +the Crown before 1789. But Louis, though rational, was inexperienced and +supine. He was ready enough to admit into his Ministry and to retain in +administrative posts throughout the country men who had served under +Napoleon; but when the emigrants and the nobles, led by the Count of +Artois, pushed themselves to the front of the public service, and treated +the restoration of the Bourbons as the victory of their own order, the King +offered but a faint resistance, and allowed the narrowest class-interests +to discredit a monarchy whose own better traditions identified it not with +an aristocracy but with the State. + +[The Charta.] + +The Constitution promulgated by King Louis XVIII. on the 4th of June, 1814, +and known as the Charta, [204] was well received by the French nation. +Though far less liberal than the Constitution accepted by Louis XVI. in +1791, it gave to the French a measure of representative government to which +they had been strangers under Napoleon. It created two legislative +chambers, the Upper House consisting of peers who were nominated by the +Crown at its pleasure, whether for life-peerages or hereditary dignity; the +Lower House formed by national election, but by election restricted by so +high a property-qualification [205] that not one person in two hundred +possessed a vote. The Crown reserved to itself the sole power of proposing +laws. In spite of this serious limitation of the competence of the two +houses, the Lower Chamber possessed, in its right of refusing taxes and of +discussing and rejecting all measures laid before it, a reality of power +such as no representative body had possessed in France since the beginning +of the Consulate. The Napoleonic nobility was placed on an equality with +the old noblesse of France, though neither enjoyed, as nobles, anything +more than a titular distinction. [206] Purchasers of landed property sold +by the State since the beginning of the Revolution were guaranteed in their +possessions. The principles of religious freedom, of equality before the +law, and of the admissibility of all classes to public employment, which +had taken such deep root during the Republic and the Empire, were declared +to form part of the public law of France; and by the side of these +deeply-cherished rights the Charta of King Louis XVIII. placed, though in a +qualified form, the long-forgotten principle of the freedom of the Press. + +[Encroachments of Nobles.] + +Under such a Constitution there was little room for the old noblesse to +arrogate to itself any legal superiority over the mass of the French +nation. What was wanting in law might, however, in the opinion of the Count +of Artois and his friends, be effected by administration. Of all the +institutions of France the most thoroughly national and the most thoroughly +democratic was the army; it was accordingly against the army that the +noblesse directed its first efforts. Financial difficulties made a large +reduction in the forces necessary. Fourteen thousand officers and sergeants +were accordingly dismissed on half-pay; but no sooner had this measure of +economy been effected than a multitude of emigrants who had served against +the Republic in the army of the Prince of Conde or in La Vendee were +rewarded with all degrees of military rank. Naval officers who had quitted +the service of France and entered that of its enemies were reinstated with +the rank which they had held in foreign navies. [207] The tricolor, under +which every battle of France had been fought from Jemappes to Montmartre, +was superseded by the white flag of the House of Bourbon, under which no +living soldier had marched to victory. General Dupont, known only by his +capitulation at Baylen in 1808, was appointed Minister of War. The Imperial +Guard was removed from service at the Palace, and the so-called Military +Household of the old Bourbon monarchy revived, with the privileges and the +insignia belonging to the period before 1775. Young nobles who had never +seen a shot fired crowded into this favoured corps, where the musketeer and +the trooper held the rank and the pay of a lieutenant in the army. While in +every village of France some battered soldier of Napoleon cursed the +Government that had driven him from his comrades, the Court revived at +Paris all the details of military ceremonial that could be gathered from +old almanacks, from the records of court-tailors, and from the memories of +decayed gallants. As if to convince the public that nothing had happened +during the last twenty-two years, the aged Marquis de Chansenets, who had +been Governor of the Tuileries on the 10th of August, 1792, and had then +escaped by hiding among the bodies of the dead, [208] resumed his place at +the head of the officers of the Palace. + +[Encroachments of the clergy.] + +[Growing hostility to the Bourbons.] + +These were but petty triumphs for the emigrants and nobles, but they were +sufficient to make the restored monarchy unpopular. Equally injurious was +their behaviour in insulting the families of Napoleon's generals, in +persecuting men who had taken part in the great movement of 1789, and in +intimidating the peasant-owners of land that had been confiscated and sold +by the State. Nor were the priesthood backward in discrediting the +Government of Louis XVIII. in the service of their own order. It might be +vain to think of recovering the Churchlands, or of introducing the +Inquisition into France, but the Court might at least be brought to invest +itself with the odour of sanctity, and the parish-priest might be made as +formidable a person within his own village as the mayor or the agent of the +police-minister. Louis XVIII. was himself sceptical and self-indulgent. +This, however, did not prevent him from publishing a letter to the Bishops +placing his kingdom under the especial protection of the Virgin Mary, and +from escorting the image of the patron-saint through the streets of Paris +in a procession in which Marshal Soult and other regenerate Jacobins of the +Court braved the ridicule of the populace by acting as candle-bearers. +Another sign of the King's submission to the clergy was the publication of +an edict which forbade buying and selling on Sundays and festivals. + +Whatever the benefits of a freely-observed day of rest, this enactment, +which was not submitted to the Chambers, passed for an arrogant piece of +interference on the part of the clergy with national habits; and while it +caused no inconvenience to the rich, it inflicted substantial loss upon a +numerous and voluble class of petty traders. The wrongs done to the +French nation by the priests and emigrants who rose to power in 1814 were +indeed the merest trifle in comparison with the wrongs which it had +uncomplainingly borne at the hands of Napoleon. But the glory of the +Empire, the strength and genius of its absolute rule, were gone. In its +place there was a family which had been dissociated from France during +twenty years, which had returned only to ally itself with an unpopular +and dreaded caste, and to prove that even the unexpected warmth with +which it had been welcomed home could not prevent it from becoming, at +the end of a few months, utterly alien and uninteresting. The indifference +of the nation would not have endangered the Bourbon monarchy if the army +had been won over by the King. But here the Court had excited the +bitterest enmity. The accord which for a moment had seemed possible even +to Republicans of the type of Carnot had vanished at a touch. [209] +Rumours of military conspiracies grew stronger with every month. +Wellington, now British Ambassador at Paris, warned his Government of the +changed feeling of the capital, of the gatherings of disbanded officers, +of possible attacks upon the Tuileries. "The truth is," he wrote, "that +the King of France without the army is no King." Wellington saw the more +immediate danger: [210] he failed to see the depth and universality of +the movement passing over France, which before the end of the year 1814 +had destroyed the hold of the Bourbon monarchy except in those provinces +where it had always found support, and prepared the nation at large to +welcome back the ruler who so lately seemed to have fallen for ever. + +[Congress of Vienna, Sept., 1814.] + +Paris and Madrid divided for some months after the conclusion of peace the +attention of the political world. At the end of September the centre of +European interest passed to Vienna. The great council of the Powers, so +long delayed, was at length assembled. The Czar of Russia, the Kings of +Prussia, Denmark, Bavaria, and Wuertemberg, and nearly all the statesmen of +eminence in Europe, gathered round the Emperor Francis and his Minister, +Metternich, to whom by common consent the presidency of the Congress was +offered. Lord Castlereagh represented England, and Talleyrand France. +Rasumoffsky and other Russian diplomatists acted under the immediate +directions of their master, who on some occasions even entered into +personal correspondence with the Ministers of the other Powers. +Hardenberg stood in a somewhat freer relation to King Frederick William; +Stein was present, but without official place. The subordinate envoys and +attaches of the greater Courts, added to a host of petty princes and the +representatives who came from the minor Powers, or from communities which +had ceased to possess any political existence at all, crowded Vienna. In +order to relieve the antagonisms which had already come too clearly into +view, Metternich determined to entertain his visitors in the most +magnificent fashion; and although the Austrian State was bankrupt, and in +some districts the people were severely suffering, a sum of about L10,000 +a day was for some time devoted to this purpose. The splendour and the +gaieties of Metternich were emulated by his guests; and the guardians of +Europe enjoyed or endured for months together a succession of fetes, +banquets, dances, and excursions, varied, through the zeal of Talleyrand +to ingratiate himself with his new master, by a Mass of great solemnity +on the anniversary of the execution of Louis XVI. [211] One incident +lights the faded and insipid record of vanished pageants and defunct +gallantries. Beethoven was in Vienna. The Government placed the great +Assembly-rooms at his disposal, and enabled the composer to gratify a +harmless humour by sending invitations in his own name to each of the +Sovereigns and grandees then in Vienna. Much personal homage, some +substantial kindness from these gaudy creatures of the hour, made the +period of the Congress a bright page in that wayward and afflicted life +whose poverty has enriched mankind with such immortal gifts. + +[Talleyrand and the four Powers.] + +The Congress had need of its distractions, for the difficulties which faced +it were so great that, even after the arrival of the Sovereigns, it was +found necessary to postpone the opening of the regular sittings until +November. By the secret articles of the Peace of Paris, the Allies had +reserved to themselves the disposal of all vacant territory, although their +conclusions required to be formally sanctioned by the Congress at large. +The Ministers of Austria, England, Prussia, and Russia accordingly +determined at the outset to decide upon all territorial questions among +themselves, and only after their decisions were completely formed to submit +them to France and the other Powers. [212] Talleyrand, on hearing of this +arrangement, protested that France itself was now one of the Allies, and +demanded that the whole body of European States should at once meet in open +Congress. The four Courts held to their determination, and began their +preliminary sittings without Talleyrand. But the French statesman had, +under the form of a paradox, really stated the true political situation. +The greater Powers were so deeply divided in their aims that their old bond +of common interest, the interest of union against France, was now less +powerful than the impulse that made them seek the support of France against +one another. Two men had come to the Congress with a definite aim: +Alexander had resolved to gain the Duchy of Warsaw, and to form it, with or +without some part of Russian Poland, into a Polish kingdom, attached to his +own crown: Talleyrand had determined, either on the question of Poland, or +on the question of Saxony, which arose out of it, to break allied Europe +into halves, and to range France by the side of two of the great Powers +against the two others. The course of events favoured for a while the +design of the Minister: Talleyrand himself prosecuted his plan with an +ability which, but for the untimely return of Napoleon from Elba, would +have left France, without a war, the arbiter and the leading Power of +Europe. + +[Polish question.] + +Since the Russian victories of 1812, the Emperor Alexander had made no +secret of his intention to restore a Polish Kingdom and a Polish +nationality. [213] Like many other designs of this prince, the project +combined a keen desire for personal glorification with a real generosity of +feeling. Alexander was thoroughly sincere in his wish not only to make the +Poles again a people, but to give them a Parliament and a free +Constitution. The King of Poland, however, was to be no independent prince, +but Alexander himself: although the Duchy of Warsaw, the chief if not the +sole component of the proposed new kingdom, had belonged to Austria and +Prussia after the last partition of Poland, and extended into the heart of +the Prussian monarchy. Alexander insisted on his anxiety to atone for the +crime of Catherine in dismembering Poland: the atonement, however, was to +be made at the sole cost of those whom Catherine had allowed to share the +booty. Among the other Governments, the Ministry of Great Britain would +gladly have seen a Polish State established in a really independent form; +[214] failing this, it desired that the Duchy of Warsaw should be divided, +as formerly, between Austria and Prussia. Metternich was anxious that the +fortress of Cracow, at any rate, should not fall into the hands of the +Czar. Stein and Hardenberg, and even Alexander's own Russian counsellors, +earnestly opposed the Czar's project, not only on account of the claims of +Prussia on Warsaw, but from dread of the agitation likely to be produced by +a Polish Parliament among all Poles outside the new State. King Frederick +William, however, was unaccustomed to dispute the wishes of his ally; and +the Czar's offer of Saxony in substitution for Warsaw gave to the Prussian +Ministers, who were more in earnest than their master, at least the +prospect of receiving a valuable equivalent for what they might surrender. + +[Saxon question.] + +By the Treaty of Kalisch, made when Prussia united its arms with those of +Russia against Napoleon (Feb. 27th, 1813), the Czar had undertaken to +restore the Prussian monarchy to an extent equal to that which it had +possessed in 1805. It was known before the opening of the Congress that the +Czar proposed to do this by handing over to King Frederick William the +whole of Saxony, whose Sovereign, unlike his colleagues in the Rhenish +Confederacy, had supported Napoleon up to his final overthrow at Leipzig. +Since that time the King of Saxony had been held a prisoner, and his +dominions had been occupied by the Allies. The Saxon question had thus +already gained the attention of all the European Governments, and each of +the Ministers now at Vienna brought with him some more or less distinct +view upon the subject. Castlereagh, who was instructed to foster the union +of Prussia and Austria against Alexander's threatening ambition, was +willing that Prussia should annex Saxony if in return it would assist him +in keeping Russia out of Warsaw: [215] Metternich disliked the annexation, +but offered no serious objection, provided that in Western Germany Prussia +would keep to the north of the Main: Talleyrand alone made the defence of +the King of Saxony the very centre of his policy, and subordinated all +other aims to this. His instructions, like those of Castlereagh, gave +priority to the Polish question; [216] but Talleyrand saw that Saxony, not +Poland, was the lever by which he could throw half of Europe on to the side +of France; and before the four Allied Courts had come to any single +conclusion, the French statesman had succeeded, on what at first passed for +a subordinate point, in breaking up their concert. + +[Talleyrand's action on Saxony.] + +For a while the Ministers of Austria, Prussia, and England appeared to be +acting in harmony; and throughout the month of October all three +endeavoured to shake the purpose of Alexander regarding Warsaw. [217] +Talleyrand, however, foresaw that the efforts of Prussia in this direction +would not last very long, and he wrote to Louis XVIII. asking for his +permission to make a definite offer of armed assistance to Austria in case +of need. Events took the turn which Talleyrand expected. Early in November +the King of Prussia completely yielded to Alexander, and ordered Hardenberg +to withdraw his opposition to the Russian project. Metternich thus found +himself abandoned on the Polish question by Prussia; and at the same moment +the answer of King Louis XVIII. arrived, and enabled Talleyrand to assure +the Austrian Minister that, if resistance to Russia and Prussia should +become necessary, he might count on the support of a French army. +Metternich now completely changed his position on the Saxon question, and +wrote to Hardenberg (Dec. 10) stating that, inasmuch as Prussia had chosen +to sacrifice Warsaw, the Emperor Francis absolutely forbade the annexation +of more than a fifth part of the kingdom of Saxony. Castlereagh, disgusted +with the obstinacy of Russia and the subserviency of King Frederick +William, forgave Talleyrand for not supporting him earlier, and cordially +entered into this new plan for thwarting the Northern Powers. The leading +member of the late Rhenish Confederacy, the King of Bavaria, threw himself +with eagerness into the struggle against Prussia and against German unity. +In proportion as Stein and the patriots of 1813 urged the claims of German +nationality under Prussian leadership against the forfeited rights of a +Court which had always served on Napoleon's side, the politicians of the +Rhenish Confederacy declaimed against the ambition and the Jacobinism of +Prussia, and called upon Europe to defend the united principles of +hereditary right and of national independence in the person of the King of +Saxony. + +[Theory of Legitimacy.] + +Talleyrand's object was attained. He had isolated Russia and Prussia, and +had drawn to his own side not only England and Austria but the whole body +of the minor German States. Nothing was wanting but a phrase, or an idea, +which should consecrate the new league in the opinion of Europe as a league +of principle, and bind the Allies, in matters still remaining open, to the +support of the interests of the House of Bourbon. Talleyrand had made his +theory ready. In notes to Castlereagh and Metternich, [218] he declared +that the whole drama of the last twenty years had been one great struggle +between revolution and established right, a struggle at first between +Republicanism and Monarchy, afterwards between usurping dynasties and +legitimate dynasties. The overthrow of Napoleon had been the victory of the +principle of legitimacy; the task of England and Austria was now to extend +the work of restitution to all Europe, and to defend the principle against +new threatened aggressions. In the note to Castlereagh, Talleyrand added a +practical corollary. "To finish the revolution, the principle of legitimacy +must triumph without exception. The kingdom of Saxony must be preserved; +the kingdom of Naples must return to its legitimate king." + +[Alliance against Russia and Prussia, Jan. 3, 1815.] + +As an historical summary of the Napoleonic wars, Talleyrand's doctrine was +baseless. No one but Pitt had cared about the fate of the Bourbons; no one +would have hesitated to make peace with Napoleon, if Napoleon would have +accepted terms of peace. The manifesto was not, however, intended to meet a +scientific criticism. In the English Foreign Office it was correctly +described as a piece of drollery; and Metternich was too familiar with the +language of principles himself to attach much meaning to it in the mouth of +anyone else. Talleyrand, however, kept a grave countenance. With inimitable +composure the old Minister of the Directory wrote to Louis XVIII. lamenting +that Castlereagh did not appear to care much about the principle of +legitimacy, and in fact did not quite comprehend it; [219] and he added his +fear that this moral dimness on the part of the English Minister arose from +the dealing of his countrymen with Tippoo Sahib. But for Europe at +large,--for the English Liberal party, who looked upon the Saxons and the +Prussians as two distinct nations, and for the Tories, who forgot that +Napoleon had made the Elector of Saxony a king; for the Emperor of Austria, +who had no wish to see the Prussian frontier brought nearer to Prague; +above all, for the minor German courts who dreaded every approach towards +German unity,--Talleyrand's watchword was the best that could have been +invented. His counsel prospered. On the 3rd of January, 1815, after a rash +threat of war uttered by Hardenberg, a secret treaty [220] was signed by +the representatives of France, England, and Austria, pledging these Powers +to take the field, if necessary, against Russia and Prussia in defence of +the principles of the Peace of Paris. The plan of the campaign was drawn +up, the number of the forces fixed. Bavaria had already armed; Piedmont, +Hanover, and even the Ottoman Porte, were named as future members of the +alliance. + +[Compromise on Polish and Saxon questions.] + +[Prussia gains Rhenish Provinces.] + +It would perhaps be unfair to the French Minister to believe that he +actually desired to kindle a war on this gigantic scale. Talleyrand had +not, like Napoleon, a love for war for its own sake. His object was rather +to raise France from its position as a conquered and isolated Power; to +surround it with allies; to make the House of Bourbon the representatives +of a policy interesting to a great part of Europe; and, having thus undone +the worst results of Napoleon's rule, to trust to some future complication +for the recovery of Belgium and the frontier of the Rhine. Nor was +Talleyrand's German policy adopted solely as the instrument of a passing +intrigue. He appears to have had a true sense of the capacity of Prussia to +transform Germany into a great military nation; and the policy of alliance +with Austria and protection of the minor States which he pursued in 1814 +was that which he had advocated throughout his career. The conclusion of +the secret treaty of January 3rd marked the definite success of his plans. +France was forthwith admitted into the council hitherto known as that of +the Four Courts, and from this time its influence visibly affected the +action of Russia and Prussia, reports of the secret treaty having reached +the Czar immediately after its signature. [221] The spirit of compromise +now began to animate the Congress. Alexander had already won a virtual +decision in his favour on the Polish question, but he abated something of +his claims, and while gaining the lion's share of the Duchy of Warsaw, he +ultimately consented that Cracow, which threatened the Austrian frontier, +should be formed into an independent Republic, and that Prussia should +receive the fortresses of Dantzic and Thorn on the Vistula, with the +district lying between Thorn and the border of Silesia. [222] This was +little for Alexander to abandon; on the Saxon question the allies of +Talleyrand gained most that they demanded. The King of Saxony was restored +to his throne, and permitted to retain Dresden and about half of his +dominions. Prussia received the remainder. In lieu of a further expansion +in Saxony, Prussia was awarded territory on the left bank of the Rhine, +which, with its recovered Westphalian provinces, restored the monarchy to +an area and population equal to that which it had possessed in 1805. But +the dominion given to Prussia beyond the Rhine, though considered at the +time to be a poor equivalent for the second half of Saxony, was in reality +a gift of far greater value. It made Prussia, in defence of its own soil, +the guardian and bulwark of Germany against France. It brought an element +into the life of the State in striking contrast with the aristocratic and +Protestant type predominant in the older Prussian provinces,--a Catholic +population, liberal in its political opinions, and habituated by twenty +years' union with France to the democratic tendencies of French social +life. It gave to Prussia something more in common with Bavaria and the +South, and qualified it, as it had not been qualified before, for its +future task of uniting Germany under its own leadership. + +[Napoleon leaves Elba, Feb. 26.] + +[Lands in France, March 1.] + +The Polish and Saxon difficulties, which had threatened the peace of +Europe, were virtually settled before the end of the month of January. +Early in February Lord Castlereagh left Vienna, to give an account of his +labours and to justify his policy before the English House of Commons. His +place at the Congress was taken by the Duke of Wellington. There remained +the question of Naples, the formation of a Federal Constitution for +Germany, and several matters of minor political importance, none of which +endangered the good understanding of the Powers. Suddenly the action of the +Congress was interrupted by the most startling intelligence. On the night +of March 6th Metternich was roused from sleep to receive a despatch +informing him that Napoleon had quitted Elba. The news had taken eight days +to reach Vienna. Napoleon had set sail on the 26th of February. In the +silence of his exile he had watched the progress of events in France: he +had convinced himself of the strength of the popular reaction against the +priests and emigrants; and the latest intelligence which he had received +from Vienna led him to believe that the Congress itself was on the point of +breaking up. There was at least some chance of success in an attempt to +regain his throne; and, the decision once formed, Napoleon executed it with +characteristic audacity and despatch. Talleyrand, on hearing that Napoleon +had left Elba, declared that he would only cross into Italy and there raise +the standard of Italian independence: instead of doing this, Napoleon made +straight for France, with the whole of his guard, eleven hundred in number, +embarked on a little flotilla of seven ships. The voyage lasted three days: +no French or English vessels capable of offering resistance met the +squadron. On the 1st of March Napoleon landed at the bay of Jouan, three +miles to the west of Antibes. A detachment of his guards called upon the +commandant of Antibes to deliver up the town to the Emperor; the commandant +refused, and the troops bivouacked that evening, with Napoleon among them, +in the olive-woods by the shore of the Mediterranean. + +[Moves on Grenoble.] + +[Troops at La Mure.] + +Before daybreak began the march that was to end in Paris. Instead of +following the coast road of Provence, which would have brought him to +Toulon and Marseilles, where most of the population were fiercely Royalist, +[223] and where Massena and other great officers might have offered +resistance, Napoleon struck northwards into the mountains, intending to +descend upon Lyons by way of Grenoble. There were few troops in this +district, and no generals capable of influencing them. The peasantry of +Dauphine were in great part holders of land that had been taken from the +Church and the nobles: they were exasperated against the Bourbons, and, +like the peasantry of France generally, they identified the glory of the +country which they loved with the name and the person of Napoleon. As the +little band penetrated into the mountains the villagers thronged around +them, and by offering their carts and horses enabled Napoleon to march +continuously over steep and snowy roads at the rate of forty miles a day. +No troops appeared to dispute these mountain passages: it was not until the +close of the fifth day's march that Napoleon's mounted guard, pressing on +in front of the marching column, encountered, in the village of La Mure, +twenty miles south of Grenoble, a regiment of infantry wearing the white +cockade of the House of Bourbon. The two bodies of troops mingled and +conversed in the street: the officer commanding the royal infantry fearing +the effect on his men, led them back on the road towards Grenoble. +Napoleon's lancers also retired, and the night passed without further +communication. At noon on the following day the lancers, again advancing +towards Grenoble, found the infantry drawn up to defend the road. They +called out that Napoleon was at hand, and begged the infantry not to fire. +Presently Napoleon's column came in sight; one of his _aides-de-camp_ +rode to the front of the royal troops, addressed them, and pointed out +Napoleon. The regiment was already wavering, the officer commanding had +already given the order of retreat, when the men saw their Emperor +advancing towards them. They saw his face, they heard his voice: in another +moment the ranks were broken, and the soldiers were pressing with shouts +and tears round the leader whom nature had created with such transcendent +capacity for evil, and endowed with such surpassing power of attracting +love. + +[Enters Grenoble, March 7.] + +[Declaration of his purpose.] + +Everything was decided by this first encounter. "In six days," said +Napoleon, "we shall be in the Tuileries." The next pledge of victory came +swiftly. Colonel Labedoyere, commander of the 7th Regiment of the Line, had +openly declared for Napoleon in Grenoble, and appeared on the road at the +head of his men a few hours after the meeting at La Mure. Napoleon reached +Grenoble the same evening. The town had been in tumult all day. The Prefet +fled: the general in command sent part of his troops away, and closed the +gates. On Napoleon's approach the population thronged the ramparts with +torches; the gates were burst open; Napoleon was borne through the town in +triumph by a wild and intermingled crowd of soldiers and workpeople. The +whole mass of the poorer classes of the town welcomed him with enthusiasm: +the middle classes, though hostile to the Church and the Bourbons, saw too +clearly the dangers to France involved in Napoleon's return to feel the +same joy. [224] They remained in the background, neither welcoming Napoleon +nor interfering with the welcome offered him by others. Thus the night +passed. On the morning of the next day Napoleon received the magistrates +and principal inhabitants of the town, and addressed them in terms which +formed the substance of every subsequent declaration of his policy. "He had +come," he said, "to save France from the outrages of the returning nobles; +to secure to the peasant the possession of his land; to uphold the rights +won in 1789 against a minority which sought to re-establish the privileges +of caste and the feudal burdens of the last century. France had made trial +of the Bourbons: it had done well to do so; but the experiment had failed. +The Bourbon monarchy had proved incapable of detaching itself from its +worst supports, the priests and nobles: only the dynasty which owed its +throne to the Revolution could maintain the social work of the Revolution. +As for himself, he had learnt wisdom by misfortune. He renounced conquest. +He should give France peace without and liberty within. He accepted the +Treaty of Paris and the frontiers of 1792. Freed from the necessities which +had forced him in earlier days to found a military Empire, he recognised +and bowed to the desire of the French nation for constitutional government. +He should henceforth govern only as a constitutional sovereign, and seek +only to leave a constitutional crown to his son." + +[Feeling of the various classes.] + +[Napoleon enters Lyons, March 10.] + +This language was excellently chosen. It satisfied the peasants and the +workmen, who wished to see the nobles crushed, and it showed at least a +comprehension of the feelings uppermost in the minds of the wealthier and +more educated middle classes, the longing for peace, and the aspiration +towards political liberty. It was also calculated to temper the unwelcome +impression that an exiled ruler was being forced upon France by the +soldiery. The military movement was indeed overwhelmingly decisive, yet the +popular movement was scarcely less so. The Royalists were furious, but +impotent to act; thoughtful men in all classes held back, with sad +apprehensions of returning war and calamity; [225] but from the time when +Napoleon left Grenoble, the nation at large was on his side. There was +nowhere an effective centre of resistance. The Prefets and other civil +officers appointed under the Empire still for the most part held their +posts; they knew themselves to be threatened by the Bourbonist reaction, +but they had not yet been displaced; their professions of loyalty to Louis +XVIII. were forced, their instincts of obedience to their old master, even +if they wished to have done with him, profound. From this class, whose +cowardice and servility find too many parallels in history, [226] Napoleon +had little to fear. Among the marshals and higher officers charged with the +defence of the monarchy, those who sincerely desired to serve the Bourbons +found themselves powerless in the midst of their troops. Macdonald, who +commanded at Lyons, had to fly from his men, in order to escape being made +a prisoner. The Count of Artois, who had come to join him, discovered that +the only service he could render to the cause of his family was to take +himself out of sight. Napoleon entered Lyons on the 10th of March, and now +formally resumed his rank and functions as Emperor. His first edicts +renewed that appeal to the ideas and passions of the Revolution which had +been the key-note of every one of his public utterances since leaving Elba. +Treating the episode of Bourbon restoration as null and void, the edicts of +Lyons expelled from France every emigrant who had returned without the +permission of the Republic or the Emperor; they drove from the army the +whole mass of officers intruded by the Government of Louis XVIII.; they +invalidated every appointment and every dismissal made in the magistracy +since the 1st of April, 1814; and, reverting to the law of the Constituent +Assembly of 1789, abolished all nobility except that which had been +conferred by the Emperor himself. + +[Marshal Ney.] + +[The Chambers in Paris.] + +[Napoleon enters Paris, March 20.] + +From this time all was over. Marshal Ney, who had set out from Paris +protesting that Napoleon deserved to be confined in an iron cage, [227] +found, when at some distance from Lyons, that the nation and army were on +the side of the Emperor, and proclaimed his own adherence to him in an +address to his troops. The two Chambers of Legislature, which had been +prorogued, were summoned by King Louis XVIII. as soon as the news of +Napoleon's landing reached the capital. The Chambers met on the 13th of +March. The constitutionalist party, though they had opposed various +measures of King Louis' Government as reactionary, were sincerely loyal to +the Charta, and hastened, in the cause of constitutional liberty, to offer +to the King their cordial support in resisting Bonaparte's military +despotism. The King came down to the Legislative Chamber, and, in a scene +concerted with his brother, the Count of Artois, made, with great dramatic +effect, a declaration of fidelity to the Constitution. Lafayette and the +chiefs of the Parliamentary Liberals hoped to raise a sufficient force from +the National Guard of Paris to hold Napoleon in check. The project, +however, came to nought. The National Guard, which represented the middle +classes of Paris, was decidedly in favour of the Charta and Constitutional +Government; but it had no leaders, no fighting-organisation, and no +military spirit. The regular troops who were sent out against Napoleon +mounted the tricolor as soon as they were out of sight of Paris, and joined +their comrades. The courtiers passed from threats to consternation and +helplessness. On the night of March 19th King Louis fled from the +Tuileries. Napoleon entered the capital the next evening, welcomed with +acclamations by the soldiers and populace, but not with that general +rejoicing which had met him at Lyons, and at many of the smaller towns +through which he had passed. + +[Congress of Vienna outlaws Napoleon.] + +[Napoleon's preparations for defence.] + +France was won: Europe remained behind. On the 13th of March the Ministers +of all the Great Powers, assembled at Vienna, published a manifesto +denouncing Napoleon Bonaparte as the common enemy of mankind, and declaring +him an outlaw. The whole political structure which had been reared with so +much skill by Talleyrand vanished away. France was again alone, with all +Europe combined against it. Affairs reverted to the position in which they +had stood in the month of March, 1814, when the Treaty of Chaumont was +signed, which bound the Powers to sustain their armed concert against +France, if necessary, for a period of twenty years. That treaty was now +formally renewed. [228] The four great Powers undertook to employ their +whole available resources against Bonaparte until he should be absolutely +unable to create disturbance, and each pledged itself to keep permanently +in the field a force of at least a hundred and fifty thousand men. The +presence of the Duke of Wellington at Vienna enabled the Allies to decide +without delay upon the general plan for their invasion of France. It was +resolved to group the allied troops in three masses; one, composed of the +English and the Prussians under Wellington and Bluecher, to enter France by +the Netherlands; the two others, commanded by the Czar and Prince +Schwarzenberg, to advance from the middle and upper Rhine. Nowhere was +there the least sign of political indecision. The couriers sent by Napoleon +with messages of amity to the various Courts were turned back at the +frontiers with their despatches undelivered. It was in vain for the Emperor +to attempt to keep up any illusion that peace was possible. After a brief +interval he himself acquainted France with the true resolution of his +enemies. The most strenuous efforts were made for defence. The old soldiers +were called from their homes. Factories of arms and ammunition began their +hurried work in the principal towns. The Emperor organised with an energy +and a command of detail never surpassed at any period of his life; the +nature of the situation lent a new character to his genius, and evoked in +the organisation of systematic defence all that imagination and resource +which had dazzled the world in his schemes of invasion and surprise. Nor, +as hitherto, was the nation to be the mere spectator of his exploits. The +population of France, its National Guard, its _levee en masse_, as +well as its armies and its Emperor, was to drive the foreigner from French +soil. Every operation of defensive warfare, from the accumulation of +artillery round the capital to the gathering of forest-guards and +free-shooters in the thickets of the Vosges and the Ardennes, occupied in +its turn the thoughts of Napoleon. [229] Had France shared his resolution +or his madness, had the Allies found at the outset no chief superior to +their Austrian leader in 1814, the war on which they were now about to +enter would have been one of immense difficulty and risk, its ultimate +issue perhaps doubtful. + +[Campaign and fall of Murat, April, 1815] + +Before Napoleon or his adversaries were ready to move, hostilities broke +out in Italy. Murat, King of Naples, had during the winter of 1814 been +represented at Vienna by an envoy: he was aware of the efforts made by +Talleyrand to expel him from his throne, and knew that the Government of +Great Britain, convinced of his own treachery during the pretended +combination with the Allies in 1814, now inclined to act with France. [230] +The instinct of self-preservation led him to risk everything in raising the +standard of Italian independence, rather than await the loss of his +kingdom; and the return of Napoleon precipitated his fall. At the moment +when Napoleon was about to leave Elba, Murat, who knew his intention, asked +the permission of Austria to move a body of troops through Northern Italy +for the alleged purpose of attacking the French Bourbons, who were +preparing to restore his rival, Ferdinand. Austria declared that it should +treat the entry either of French or of Neapolitan troops into Northern +Italy as an act of war. Murat, as soon as Napoleon's landing in France +became known, protested to the Allies that he intended to remain faithful +to them, but he also sent assurances of friendship to Napoleon, and +forthwith invaded the Papal States. He acted without waiting for Napoleon's +instructions, and probably with the intention of winning all Italy for +himself even if Napoleon should victoriously re-establish his Empire. On +the 10th of April, Austria declared war against him. Murat pressed forward +and entered Bologna, now openly proclaiming the unity and independence of +Italy. The feeling of the towns and of the educated classes generally +seemed to be in his favour, but no national rising took place. After some +indecisive encounters with the Austrians, Murat retreated. As he fell back +towards the Neapolitan frontier, his troops melted away. The enterprise +ended in swift and total ruin; and on the 22nd of May an English and +Austrian force took possession of the city of Naples in the name of King +Ferdinand. Murat, leaving his family behind him, fled to France, and sought +in vain to gain a place by the side of Napoleon in his last great struggle, +and to retrieve as a soldier the honour which he had lost as a king. [231] + +[The Acte Additionnel, April 23, 1815.] + +In the midst of his preparations for war with all Europe, Napoleon found it +necessary to give some satisfaction to that desire for liberty which was +again so strong in France. He would gladly have deferred all political +change until victory over the foreigner had restored his own undisputed +ascendency over men's minds; he was resolved at any rate not to be harassed +by a Constituent Assembly, like that of 1789, at the moment of his greatest +peril; and the action of King Louis XVIII. in granting liberty by Charta +gave him a precedent for creating a Constitution by an Edict supplementary +to the existing laws of the Empire. Among the Liberal politicians who had +declared for King Louis XVIII. while Napoleon was approaching Paris, one of +the most eminent was Benjamin Constant, who had published an article +attacking the Emperor with great severity on the very day when he entered +the capital. Napoleon now invited Constant to the Tuileries, assured him +that he no longer either desired or considered it possible to maintain an +absolute rule in France, and requested Constant himself to undertake the +task of drawing up a Constitution. Constant, believing the Emperor to be in +some degree sincere, accepted the proposals made to him, and, at the cost +of some personal consistency, entered upon the work, in which Napoleon by +no means allowed him entire freedom. [232] The result of Constant's labours +was the Decree known as the Acte Additionnel of 1815. The leading +provisions of this Act resembled those of the Charta: both professed to +establish a representative Government and the responsibility of Ministers; +both contained the usual phrases guaranteeing freedom of religion and +security of person and property. The principal differences were that the +Chamber of Peers was now made wholly hereditary, and that the Emperor +absolutely refused to admit the clause of the Charta abolishing +confiscation as a penalty for political offences. On the other hand, +Constant definitely extinguished the censorship of the Press, and provided +some real guarantee for the free expression of opinion by enacting that +Press-offences should be judged only in the ordinary Jury-courts. Constant +was sanguine enough to believe that the document which he had composed +would reduce Napoleon to the condition of a constitutional king. As a +Liberal statesman, he pressed the Emperor to submit the scheme to a +Representative Assembly, where it could be examined and amended. This +Napoleon refused to do, preferring to resort to the fiction of a Plebiscite +for the purpose of procuring some kind of national sanction for his Edict. +The Act was published on the 23rd of April, 1815. Voting lists were then +opened in all the Departments, and the population of France, most of whom +were unable to read or write, were invited to answer Yes or No to the +question whether they approved of Napoleon's plan for giving his subjects +Parliamentary government. + +[The Chambers summoned for June.] + +There would have been no difficulty in obtaining some millions of votes for +any absurdity that the Emperor might be pleased to lay before the French +people; but among the educated minority who had political theories of their +own, the publication of this reform by Edict produced the worst possible +impression. No stronger evidence, it was said, could have been given of the +Emperor's insincerity than the dictatorial form in which he affected to +bestow liberty upon France. Scarcely a voice was raised in favour of the +new Constitution. The measure had in fact failed of its effect. Napoleon's +object was to excite an enthusiasm that should lead the entire nation, the +educated classes as well as the peasantry, to rally round him in a struggle +with the foreigner for life or death: he found, on the contrary, that he +had actually injured his cause. The hostility of public opinion was so +serious that Napoleon judged it wise to make advances to the Liberal party, +and sent his brother Joseph to Lafayette, to ascertain on what terms he +might gain his support. [233] Lafayette, strongly condemning the form of +the Acte Additionnel, stated that the Emperor could only restore public +confidence by immediately convoking the Chambers. This was exactly what +Napoleon desired to avoid, until he had defeated the English and Prussians; +nor in fact had the vote of the nation accepting the new Constitution yet +been given. But the urgency of the need overcame the Emperor's inclinations +and the forms of law. Lafayette's demand was granted: orders were issued +for an immediate election, and the meeting of the Chambers fixed for the +beginning of June, a few days earlier than the probable departure of the +Emperor to open hostilities on the northern frontier. + +[Elections.] + +Lafayette's counsel had been given in sincerity, but Napoleon gained little +by following it. The nation at large had nothing of the faith in the +elections which was felt by Lafayette and his friends. In some places not a +single person appeared at the poll: in most, the candidates were elected by +a few scores of voters. The Royalists absented themselves on principle: the +population generally thought only of the coming war, and let the professed +politicians conduct the business of the day by themselves. Among the +deputies chosen there were several who had sat in the earlier Assemblies of +the Revolution; and, mingled with placemen and soldiers of the Empire, a +considerable body of men whose known object was to reduce Napoleon's power. +One interest alone was unrepresented--that of the Bourbon family, which so +lately seemed to have been called to the task of uniting the old and the +new France around itself. + +[Champ de Mai.] + +Napoleon, troubling himself little about the elections, laboured +incessantly at his preparations for war, and by the end of May two hundred +thousand men were ready to take the field. The delay of the Allies, though +necessary, enabled their adversary to take up the offensive. It was the +intention of the Emperor to leave a comparatively small force to watch the +eastern frontier, and himself, at the head of a hundred and twenty-five +thousand men, to fall upon Wellington and Bluecher in the Netherlands, and +crush them before they could unite their forces. With this object the +greater part of the army was gradually massed on the northern roads at +points between Paris, Lille, and Maubeuge. Two acts of State remained to be +performed by the Emperor before he quitted the capital; the inauguration of +the new Constitution and the opening of the Chambers of Legislature. The +first, which had been fixed for the 26th of May, and announced as a revival +of the old Frankish Champ de Mai, was postponed till the beginning of the +following month. On the 1st of June the solemnity was performed with +extraordinary pomp and splendour, on that same Champ de Mars where, +twenty-five years before, the grandest and most affecting of all the +festivals of the Revolution, the Act of Federation, had been celebrated by +King Louis XVI. and his people. Deputations from each of the constituencies +of France, from the army, and from every public body, surrounded the +Emperor in a great amphitheatre enclosed at the southern end of the plain: +outside there were ranged twenty thousand soldiers of the Guard and other +regiments; and behind them spread the dense crowd of Paris. When the total +of the votes given in the Plebiscite had been summed up and declared, the +Emperor took the oath to the Constitution, and delivered one of his +masterpieces of political rhetoric. The great officers of State took the +oath in their turn: mass was celebrated, and Napoleon, leaving the enclosed +space, then presented their standards to the soldiery in the Champ de Mars, +addressing some brief, soul-stirring word to each regiment as it passed. +The spectacle was magnificent, but except among the soldiers themselves a +sense of sadness and disappointment passed over the whole assembly. The +speech of the Emperor showed that he was still the despot at heart: the +applause was forced: all was felt to be ridiculous, all unreal. [234] + +[Plan of Napoleon.] + +The opening of the Legislative Chambers took place a few days later, and on +the night of the 11th of June Napoleon started for the northern frontier. +The situation of the forces opposed to him in this his last campaign +strikingly resembled that which had given him his first Italian victory in +1796. Then the Austrians and Sardinians, resting on opposite bases, covered +the approaches to the Sardinian capital, and invited the assailant to break +through their centre and drive the two defeated wings along diverging and +severed paths of retreat. Now the English and the Prussians covered +Brussels, the English resting westward on Ostend, the Prussians eastward on +Cologne, and barely joining hands in the middle of a series of posts nearly +eighty miles long. The Emperor followed the strategy of 1796. He determined +to enter Belgium by the central road of Charleroi, and to throw his main +force upon Bluecher, whose retreat, if once he should be severed from his +colleague, would carry him eastwards towards Liege, and place him outside +the area of hostilities round Brussels. Bluecher driven eastwards, Napoleon +believed that he might not only push the English commander out of Brussels, +but possibly, by a movement westwards, intercept him from the sea and cut +off his communication with Great Britain. [235] + +[Situation of the armies.] + +On the night of the 13th of June, the French army, numbering a hundred and +twenty-nine thousand men, had completed its concentration, and lay gathered +round Beaumont and Philippeville. Wellington was at Brussels; his troops, +which consisted of thirty-five thousand English and about sixty thousand +Dutch, Germans, and Belgians, [236] guarded the country west of the +Charleroi road as far as Oudenarde on the Scheldt. Bluecher's headquarters +were at Namur; he had a hundred and twenty thousand Prussians under his +command, who were posted between Charleroi, Namur, and Liege. Both the +English and Prussian generals were aware that very large French forces had +been brought close to the frontier, but Wellington imagined Napoleon to be +still in Paris, and believed that the war would be opened by a forward +movement of Prince Schwarzenberg into Alsace. It was also his fixed +conviction that if Napoleon entered Belgium he would throw himself not upon +the Allied centre, but upon the extreme right of the English towards the +sea. [237] In the course of the 14th, the Prussian outposts reported that +the French were massed round Beaumont: later in the same day there were +clear signs of an advance upon Charleroi. Early next morning the attack on +Charleroi began. The Prussians were driven out of it, and retreated in the +direction of Ligny, whither Bluecher now brought up all the forces within +his reach. It was unknown to Wellington until the afternoon of the 15th +that the French had made any movement whatever: on receiving the news of +their advance, he ordered a concentrating movement of all his forces +eastward, in order to cover the road to Brussels and to co-operate with the +Prussian general. A small division of the British army took post at Quatre +Bras that night, and on the morning of the 16th Wellington himself rode to +Ligny, and promised his assistance to Bluecher, whose troops were already +drawn up and awaiting the attack of the French. + +[Ligny, June 16.] + +But the march of the invader was too rapid for the English to reach the +field of battle. Already, on returning to Quatre Bras in the afternoon, +Wellington found his own troops hotly engaged. Napoleon had sent Ney along +the road to Brussels to hold the English in check and, if possible, to +enter the capital, while he himself, with seventy thousand men, attacked +Bluecher. The Prussian general had succeeded in bringing up a force superior +in number to his assailants; but the French army, which consisted in a +great part of veterans recalled to the ranks, was of finer quality than any +that Napoleon had led since the campaign of Moscow, and it was in vain that +Bluecher and his soldiers met them with all the gallantry and even more than +the fury of 1813. There was murderous hand-to-hand fighting in the villages +where the Prussians had taken up their position: now the defenders, now the +assailants gave way: but at last the Prussians, with a loss of thirteen +thousand men, withdrew from the combat, and left the battlefield in +possession of the enemy. If the conquerors had followed up the pursuit that +night, the cause of the Allies would have been ruined. The effort of battle +had, however, been too great, or the estimate which Napoleon made of his +adversary's rallying power was too low. He seems to have assumed that +Bluecher must necessarily retreat eastwards towards Namur; while in reality +the Prussian was straining every nerve to escape northwards, and to restore +his severed communication with his ally. + +[Quatre Bras, June 16.] + +At Quatre Bras the issue of the day was unfavourable to the French. Ney +missed his opportunity of seizing this important point before it was +occupied by the British in any force; and when the battle began the British +infantry-squares unflinchingly bore the attack of Ney's cavalry, and drove +them back again and again with their volleys, until successive +reinforcements had made the numbers on both sides even. At the close of the +day the French marshal, baffled and disheartened, drew back his troops to +their original position. The army-corps of General d'Erlon, which Napoleon +had placed between himself and Ney in order that it might act wherever +there was the greatest need, was first withdrawn from Ney to assist at +Ligny, and then, as it was entering into action at Ligny, recalled to +Quatre Bras, where it arrived only after the battle was over. Its presence +in either field would probably have altered the issue of the campaign. + +[Prussian movement.] + +Bluecher, on the night of the 16th, lay disabled and almost senseless; his +lieutenant, Gneisenau, not only saved the army, but repaired, and more than +repaired, all its losses by a memorable movement northwards that brought +the Prussians again into communication with the British. Napoleon, after an +unexplained inaction during the night of the 16th and the morning of the +17th, committed the pursuit of the Prussians to Marshal Grouchy, ordering +him never to let the enemy out of his sight; but Bluecher and Gneisenau had +already made their escape, and had concentrated so large a body in the +neighbourhood of Wavre, that Grouchy could not now have prevented a force +superior to his own from uniting with the English, even if he had known the +exact movements of each of the three armies, and, with a true presentiment +of his master's danger, had attempted to rejoin him on the morrow. + +Wellington, who had both anticipated that Bluecher would be beaten at Ligny, +and assured himself that the Prussian would make good his retreat +northwards, moved on the 17th from Quatre Bras to Waterloo, now followed by +Napoleon and the mass of the French army. At Waterloo he drew up for +battle, trusting to the promise of the gallant Prussian that he would +advance in that direction on the following day. Bluecher, in so doing, +exposed himself to the risk of having his communications severed and half +his army captured, if Napoleon should either change the direction of his +main attack and bend eastwards, or should crush Wellington before the +arrival of the Prussians, and seize the road from Brussels to Louvain with +a victorious force. Such considerations would have driven a commander like +Schwarzenberg back to Liege, but they were thrown to the winds by Bluecher +and Gneisenau. In just reliance on his colleague's energy, Wellington, with +thirty thousand English and forty thousand Dutch, Germans, and Belgians, +awaited the attack of Napoleon, at the head of seventy-four thousand +veteran soldiers. The English position extended two miles along the brow of +a gentle slope of cornfields, and crossed at right angles the great road +from Charleroi to Brussels; the chateau of Hugomont, some way down the +slope on the right, and the farmhouse of La Haye Sainte, on the high-road +in front of the left centre, served as fortified outposts. The French +formed on the opposite and corresponding slope; the country was so open +that, but for the heavy rain on the evening of the 17th, artillery could +have moved over almost any part of the field with perfect freedom. + +[Waterloo, June 18.] + +At eleven o'clock on Sunday, the 18th of June, the battle began. Napoleon, +unconscious of the gathering of the Prussians on his right, and +unacquainted with the obstinacy of English troops, believed the victory +already thrown into his hands by Wellington's hardihood. His plan was to +burst through the left of the English line near La Haye Sainte, and thus to +drive Wellington westwards and place the whole French army between its two +defeated enemies. The first movement was an assault on the buildings of +Hugomont, made for the purpose of diverting Wellington from the true point +of attack. The English commander sent detachments to this outpost +sufficient to defend it, but no more. After two hours' indecisive fighting +and a heavy cannonade, Ney ordered D'Erlon's corps forward to the great +onslaught on the centre and left. As the French column pressed up the +slope, General Picton charged at the head of a brigade. The English leader +was among the first to fall, but his men drove the enemy back, and at the +same time the Scots Greys, sweeping down from the left, cut right through +both the French infantry and their cavalry supports, and, charging far up +the opposite slope, reached and disabled forty of Ney's guns, before they +were in their turn overpowered and driven back by the French dragoons. The +English lost heavily, but the onslaught of the enemy had totally failed, +and thousands of prisoners remained behind. There was a pause in the +infantry combat; and again the artillery of Napoleon battered the English +centre, while Ney marshalled fresh troops for a new and greater effort. +About two o'clock the attack was renewed on the left. La Haye Sainte was +carried, and vast masses of cavalry pressed up the English slope, and rode +over the plateau to the very front of the English line. Wellington sent no +cavalry to meet them, but trusted, and trusted justly, to the patience and +endurance of the infantry themselves, who, hour after hour, held their +ground, unmoved by the rush of the enemy's horse and the terrible spectacle +of havoc and death in their own ranks; for all through the afternoon the +artillery of Napoleon poured its fire wherever the line was left open, or +the assault of the French cavalry rolled back. + +At last the approach of the Prussians visibly told. Napoleon had seen their +vanguard early in the day, and had detached Count Lobau with seven thousand +men to hold them in check; but the little Prussian corps gradually swelled +to an army, and as the day wore on it was found necessary to reinforce +Count Lobau with some of the finest divisions of the French infantry. Still +reports came in of new Prussian columns approaching. At six o'clock +Napoleon prepared to throw his utmost strength into one grand final attack +upon the British, and to sweep them away before the battle became general +with their allies. Two columns of the Imperial Guard, supported by every +available regiment, moved from the right and left towards the English +centre. The column on the right, unchecked by the storm of Wellington's +cannon-shot from front and flank, pushed to the very ridge of the British +slope, and came within forty yards of the cross-road where the English +Guard lay hidden. Then Wellington gave the order to fire. The French +recoiled; the English advanced at the charge, and drove the enemy down the +hill, returning themselves for a while to their own position. The left +column of the French Guard attacked with equal bravery, and met with the +same fate. Then, while the French were seeking to re-form at the bottom of +the hill, Wellington commanded a general advance. The whole line of the +British infantry and cavalry swept down into the valley; before them the +baffled and sorely-stricken host of the enemy broke into a confused mass; +only the battalions of the old Guard, which had halted in the rear of the +attacking columns, remained firm together. Bluecher, from the east, dealt +the death-blow, and, pressing on to the road by which the French were +escaping, turned the defeat into utter ruin and dispersion. The pursuit, +which Wellington's troops were too exhausted to attempt, was carried on +throughout the night by the Prussian cavalry with memorable ardour and +terrible success. Before the morning the French army was no more than a +rabble of fugitives. + +[Napoleon at Paris.] + +[Allies enter Paris, July 7.] + +Napoleon fled to Philippeville, and made some ineffectual attempts both +there and at Laon to fix a rallying point for his vanished forces. From +Laon he hastened to Paris, which he reached at sunrise on the 21st. His +bulletin describing the defeat of Waterloo was read to the Chambers on the +same morning. The Lower House immediately declared against the Emperor, and +demanded his abdication. Unless Napoleon seized the dictatorship his cause +was lost. Carnot and Lucien Bonaparte urged him to dismiss the Chambers and +to stake all on his own strong will; but they found no support among the +Emperor's counsellors. On the next day Napoleon abdicated in favour of his +son. But it was in vain that he attempted to impose an absent successor +upon France, and to maintain his own Ministers in power. It was equally in +vain that Carnot, filled with the memories of 1793, called upon the +Assembly to continue the war and to provide for the defence of Paris. A +Provisional Government entered upon office. Days were spent in inaction and +debate while the Allies advanced through France. On the 28th of June, the +Prussians appeared on the north of the capital; and, as the English +followed, they moved to the south of the Seine, out of the range of the +fortifications with which Napoleon had covered the side of St. Denis and +Montmartre. Davoust, with almost all the generals in Paris, declared +defence to be impossible. On the 3rd of July, a capitulation was signed. +The remnants of the French army were required to withdraw beyond the Loire. +The Provisional Government dissolved itself; the Allied troops entered the +capital and on the following day the Members of the Chamber of Deputies, on +arriving at their Hall of Assembly, found the gates closed, and a +detachment of soldiers in possession. France was not, even as a matter of +form, consulted as to its future government. Louis XVIII. was summarily +restored to his throne. Napoleon, who had gone to Rochefort with the +intention of sailing to the United States, lingered at Rochefort until +escape was no longer possible, and then embarked on the British ship +_Bellerophon_, commending himself, as a second Themistocles, to the +generosity of the Prince Regent of England. He who had declared that the +lives of a million men were nothing to him [238] trusted to the folly or +the impotence of the English nation to provide him with some agreeable +asylum until he could again break loose and deluge Europe with blood. But +the lesson of 1814 had been learnt. Some island in the ocean far beyond the +equator formed the only prison for a man whom no European sovereign could +venture to guard, and whom no fortress-walls could have withdrawn from the +attention of mankind. Napoleon was conveyed to St. Helena. There, until at +the end of six years death removed him, he experienced some trifling share +of the human misery that he had despised. + +[Wellington and Fouche.] + +Victory had come so swiftly that the Allied Governments were unprepared +with terms of peace. The Czar and the Emperor of Austria were still at +Heidelberg when the battle of Waterloo was fought; they had advanced no +further than Nancy when the news reached them that Paris had surrendered. +Both now hastened to the capital, where Wellington was already exercising +the authority to which his extraordinary successes as well as his great +political superiority over all the representatives of the Allies then +present, entitled him. Before the entry of the English and Prussian troops +into Paris he had persuaded Louis XVIII. to sever himself from the party of +reaction by calling to office the regicide Fouche, head of the existing +Provisional Government. Fouche had been guilty of the most atrocious crimes +at Lyons in 1793; he had done some of the worst work of each succeeding +government in France; and, after returning to his old place as Napoleon's +Minister of Police during the Hundred Days, he had intrigued as early as +possible for the restoration of Louis XVIII., if indeed he had not held +treasonable communication with the enemy during the campaign. His sole +claim to power was that every gendarme and every informer in France had at +some time acted as his agent, and that, as a regicide in office, he might +possibly reconcile Jacobins and Bonapartists to the second return of the +Bourbon family. Such was the man whom, in association with Talleyrand, the +Duke of Wellington found himself compelled to propose as Minister to Louis +XVIII. The appointment, it was said, was humiliating, but it was necessary; +and with the approval of the Count of Artois the King invited this +blood-stained eavesdropper to an interview and placed him in office. Need +subdued the scruples of the courtiers: it could not subdue the resentment +of that grief-hardened daughter of Louis XVI. whom Napoleon termed the only +man of her family. The Duchess of Angouleme might have forgiven the Jacobin +Fouche the massacres at Lyons: she refused to speak to a Minister whom she +termed one of the murderers of her father. + +[Disagreement on terms of peace.] + +Fouche had entered into a private negotiation with Wellington while the +English were on the outskirts of Paris, and while the authorised envoys of +the Assembly were engaged elsewhere. Wellington's motive for recommending +him to the King was the indifference or hostility felt by some of the +Allies to Louis XVIII. personally, which led the Duke to believe that if +Louis did not regain his throne before the arrival of the sovereigns he +might never regain it at all. [239] Fouche was the one man who could at +that moment throw open the road to the Tuileries. If his overtures were +rejected, he might either permit Carnot to offer some desperate resistance +outside Paris, or might retire himself with the army and the Assembly +beyond the Loire, and there set up a Republican Government. With Fouche and +Talleyrand united in office under Louis XVIII., there was no fear either of +a continuance of the war or of the suggestion of a change of dynasty on the +part of any of the Allies. By means of the Duke's independent action Louis +XVIII. was already in possession when the Czar arrived at Paris, and +nothing now prevented the definite conclusion of peace but the disagreement +of the Allies themselves as to the terms to be exacted. Prussia, which had +suffered so bitterly from Napoleon, demanded that Europe should not a +second time deceive itself with the hollow guarantee of a Bourbon +restoration, but should gain a real security for peace by detaching Alsace +and Lorraine, as well as a line of northern fortresses, from the French +monarchy. Lord Liverpool, Prime Minister of England, stated it to be the +prevailing opinion in this country that France might fairly be stripped of +the principal conquests made by Louis XIV.; but he added that if Napoleon, +who was then at large, should become a prisoner, England would waive a +permanent cession of territory, on condition that France should be occupied +by foreign armies until it had, at its own cost, restored the +barrier-fortresses of the Netherlands. [240] Metternich for a while held +much the same language as the Prussian Minister: Alexander alone declared +from the first against any reduction of the territory of France, and +appealed to the declarations of the Powers that the sole object of the war +was the destruction of Napoleon and the maintenance of the order +established by the Peace of Paris. + +[Arguments for and against cessions.] + +[Prussia isolated.] + +[Second Treaty of Paris, Nov. 20.] + +The arguments for and against the severance of the border-provinces from +France were drawn at great length by diplomatists, but all that was +essential in them was capable of being very briefly put. On the one side, +it was urged by Stein and Hardenberg that the restoration of the Bourbons +in 1814 with an undiminished territory had not prevented France from +placing itself at the end of a few months under the rule of the military +despot whose life was one series of attacks on his neighbours: that the +expectation of long-continued peace, under whatever dynasty, was a vain one +so long as the French possessed a chain of fortresses enabling them at any +moment to throw large armies into Germany or the Netherlands: and finally, +that inasmuch as Germany, and not England or Russia, was exposed to these +irruptions, Germany had the first right to have its interests consulted in +providing for the public security. On the other side, it was argued by the +Emperor Alexander, and with far greater force by the Duke of Wellington, +[241] that the position of the Bourbons would be absolutely hopeless if +their restoration, besides being the work of foreign armies, was +accompanied by the loss of French provinces: that the French nation, +although it had submitted to Napoleon, had not as a matter of fact offered +the resistance to the Allies which it was perfectly capable of offering: +and that the danger of any new aggressive or revolutionary movement might +be effectually averted by keeping part of France occupied by the Allied +forces until the nation had settled down into tranquillity under an +efficient government. Notes embodying these arguments were exchanged +between the Ministers of the great Powers during the months of July and +August. The British Cabinet, which had at first inclined to the Prussian +view, accepted the calm judgment of Wellington, and transferred itself to +the side of the Czar. Metternich went with the majority. Hardenberg, thus +left alone, abandoned point after point in his demands, and consented at +last that France should cede little more than the border-strips which had +been added by the Peace of 1814 to its frontier of 1791. Chambery and the +rest of French Savoy, Landau and Saarlouis on the German side, +Philippeville and some other posts on the Belgian frontier, were fixed upon +as the territory to be surrendered. The resolution of the Allied +Governments was made known to Louis XVIII. towards the end of September. +Negotiation on details dragged on for two months more, while France itself +underwent a change of Ministry; and the definitive Treaty of Peace, known +as the second Treaty of Paris, was not signed until November the 20th. +France escaped without substantial loss of territory; it was, however, +compelled to pay indemnities amounting in all to about L40,000,000; to +consent to the occupation of its northern provinces by an Allied force of +150,000 men for a period not exceeding five years; and to defray the cost +of this occupation out of its own revenues. The works of art taken from +other nations, which the Allies had allowed France to retain in 1814, had +already been restored to their rightful owners. No act of the conquerors in +1815 excited more bitter or more unreasonable complaint. + +[Treaty of Holy Alliance, Sept. 26.] + +It was in the interval between the entry of the Allies into Paris and the +definitive conclusion of peace that a treaty was signed which has gained a +celebrity in singular contrast with its real insignificance, the Treaty of +Holy Alliance. Since the terrible events of 1812 the Czar's mind had taken +a strongly religious tinge. His private life continued loose as before; his +devotion was both very well satisfied with itself and a prey to mysticism +and imposture in others; but, if alloyed with many weaknesses, it was at +least sincere, and, like Alexander's other feelings, it naturally sought +expression in forms which seemed theatrical to stronger natures. Alexander +had rendered many public acts of homage to religion in the intervals of +diplomatic and military success in the year 1814; and after the second +capture of Paris he drew up a profession of religious and political faith, +embodying, as he thought, those high principles by which the Sovereigns of +Europe, delivered from the iniquities of Napoleon, were henceforth to +maintain the reign of peace and righteousness on earth. [242] This +document, which resembled the pledge of a religious brotherhood, formed the +draft of the Treaty of the Holy Alliance. The engagement, as one binding on +the conscience, was for the consideration of the Sovereigns alone, not of +their Ministers; and in presenting it to the Emperor Francis and King +Frederick William, the Czar is said to have acted with an air of great +mystery. The King of Prussia, a pious man, signed the treaty in +seriousness; the Emperor of Austria, who possessed a matter-of-fact humour, +said that if the paper related to doctrines of religion, he must refer it +to his confessor, if to secrets of State, to Prince Metternich. What the +confessor may have thought of the Czar's political evangel is not known: +the opinion delivered by the Minister was not a sympathetic one. "It is +verbiage," said Metternich; and his master, though unwillingly, signed the +treaty. With England the case was still worse. As the Prince Regent was not +in Paris, Alexander had to confide the articles of the Holy Alliance to +Lord Castlereagh. Of all things in the world the most incomprehensible to +Castlereagh was religious enthusiasm. "The fact is," he wrote home to the +English Premier, "that the Emperor's mind is not completely sound." [243] +Apart, however, from the Czar's sanity or insanity, it was impossible for +the Prince Regent, or for any person except the responsible Minister, to +sign a treaty, whether it meant anything or nothing, in the name of Great +Britain. Castlereagh was in great perplexity. On the one hand, he feared to +wound a powerful ally; on the other, he dared not violate the forms of the +Constitution. A compromise was invented. The Treaty of the Holy Alliance +was not graced with the name of the Prince Regent, but the Czar received a +letter declaring that his principles had the personal approval of this +great authority on religion and morality. The Kings of Naples and Sardinia +were the next to subscribe, and in due time the names of the witty glutton, +Louis XVIII., and of the abject Ferdinand of Spain were added. Two +potentates alone received no invitation from the Czar to enter the League: +the Pope, because he possessed too much authority within the Christian +Church, and the Sultan, because he possessed none at all. + +[Treaty between the Four Powers, Nov. 20.] + +Such was the history of the Treaty of Holy Alliance, of which, it may be +safely said, no single person connected with it, except the Czar and the +King of Prussia, thought without a smile. The common belief that this +Treaty formed the basis of a great monarchical combination against Liberal +principles is erroneous; for, in the first place, no such combination +existed before the year 1818; and, in the second place, the Czar, who was +the author of the Treaty, was at this time the zealous friend of Liberalism +both in his own and in other countries. The concert of the Powers was +indeed provided for by articles signed on the same day as the Peace of +Paris; but this concert, which, unlike the Holy Alliance, included England, +was directed towards the perpetual exclusion of Napoleon from power, and +the maintenance of the established Government in France. The Allies pledged +themselves to act in union if revolution or usurpation should again +convulse France and endanger the repose of other States, and undertook to +resist with their whole force any attack that might be made upon the army +of occupation. The federative unity which for a moment Europe seemed to +have gained from the struggle against Napoleon, and the belief existing in +some quarters in its long continuance, were strikingly shown in the last +article of this Quadruple Treaty, which provided that, after the holding of +a Congress at the end of three or more years, the Sovereigns or Ministers +of all the four great Powers should renew their meetings at fixed +intervals, for the purpose of consulting upon their common interests, and +considering the measures best fitted to secure the repose and prosperity of +nations, and the continuance of the peace of Europe. [244] + +[German Federation.] + +Thus terminated, certainly without any undue severity, yet not without some +loss to the conquered nation, the work of 1815 in France. In the meantime +the Congress of Vienna, though interrupted by the renewal of war, had +resumed and completed its labours. One subject of the first importance +remained unsettled when Napoleon returned, the federal organisation of +Germany. This work had been referred by the Powers in the autumn of 1814 to +a purely German committee, composed of the representatives of Austria and +Prussia and of three of the Minor States; but the first meetings of the +committee only showed how difficult was the problem, and how little the +inclination in most quarters to solve it. The objects with which statesmen +like Stein demanded an effective federation were thoroughly plain and +practical. They sought, in the first place, that Germany should be rendered +capable of defending itself against the foreigner; and in the second place, +that the subjects of the minor princes, who had been made absolute rulers +by Napoleon, should now be guaranteed against despotic oppression. To +secure Germany from being again conquered by France, it was necessary that +the members of the League, great and small, should abandon something of +their separate sovereignty, and create a central authority with the sole +right of making war and alliances. To protect the subjects of the minor +princes from the abuse of power, it was necessary that certain definite +civil rights and a measure of representative government should be assured +by Federal Law to the inhabitants of every German State, and enforced by +the central authority on the appeal of subjects against their Sovereigns. +There was a moment when some such form of German union had seemed to be +close at hand, the moment when Prussia began its final struggle with +Napoleon, and the commander of the Czar's army threatened the German +vassals of France with the loss of their thrones (Feb., 1813). But even +then no statesman had satisfied himself how Prussia and Austria were to +unite in submission to a Federal Government; and from the time when Austria +made terms with the vassal princes little hope of establishing a really +effective authority at the centre of Germany remained. Stein, at the +Congress of Vienna, once more proposed to restore the title and the +long-vanished powers of the Emperor; but he found no inclination on the +part of Metternich to promote his schemes for German unity, while some of +the minor princes flatly refused to abandon any fraction of their +sovereignty over their own subjects. The difficulties in the way of +establishing a Federal State were great, perhaps insuperable; the statesmen +anxious for it few in number; the interests opposed to it all but +universal. Stein saw that the work was intended to be unsubstantial, and +withdrew himself from it before its completion. The Act of Federation, +[245] which was signed on the 8th of June, created a Federal Diet, forbade +the members of the League to enter into alliances against the common +interest, and declared that in each State, Constitutions should be +established. But it left the various Sovereigns virtually independent of +the League; it gave the nomination of members of the Diet to the +Governments absolutely, without a vestige of popular election; and it +contained no provision for enforcing in any individual State, whose ruler +might choose to disregard it, the principle of constitutional rule. Whether +the Federation would in any degree have protected Germany in case of attack +by France or Russia is matter for conjecture, since a long period of peace +followed the year 1815; but so far was it from securing liberty to the +Minor States, that in the hands of Metternich the Diet, impotent for every +other purpose, became an instrument for the persecution of liberal opinion +and for the suppression of the freedom of the press. + +[Final Act of the Congress, June 10.] + +German affairs, as usual, were the last to be settled at the Congress; when +these were at length disposed of, the Congress embodied the entire mass of +its resolutions in one great Final Act [246] of a hundred and twenty-one +articles, which was signed a few days before the battle of Waterloo was +fought. This Act, together with the second Treaty of Paris, formed the +public law with which Europe emerged from the warfare of a quarter of a +century, and entered upon a period which proved, even more than it was +expected to prove, one of long-lasting peace. Standing on the boundary-line +between two ages, the legislation of Vienna forms a landmark in history. +The provisions of the Congress have sometimes been criticised as if that +body had been an assemblage of philosophers, bent only on advancing the +course of human progress, and endowed with the power of subduing the +selfish impulses of every Government in Europe. As a matter of fact the +Congress was an arena where national and dynastic interests struggled for +satisfaction by every means short of actual war. To inquire whether the +Congress accomplished all that it was possible to accomplish for Europe is +to inquire whether Governments at that moment forgot all their own +ambitions and opportunities, and thought only of the welfare of mankind. +Russia would not have given up Poland without war; Austria would not have +given up Lombardy and Venice without war. The only measures of 1814-15 in +which the common interest was really the dominant motive were those adopted +either with the view of strengthening the States immediately exposed to +attack by France, or in the hope of sparing France itself the occasion for +new conflicts. The union of Holland and Belgium, and the annexation of the +Genoese Republic to Sardinia, were the means adopted for the former end; +for the latter, the relinquishment of all claims to Alsace and Lorraine. +These were the measures in which the statesmen of 1814-15 acted with their +hands free, and by these their foresight may fairly be judged. Of the union +of Belgium to Holland it is not too much to say that, although planned by +Pitt, and treasured by every succeeding Ministry as one of his wisest +schemes, it was wholly useless and inexpedient. The tranquillity of Western +Europe was preserved during fifteen years, not by yoking together +discordant nationalities, but by the general desire to avoid war; and as +soon as France seriously demanded the liberation of Belgium from Holland, +it had to be granted. Nor can it be believed that the addition of the +hostile and discontented population of Genoa to the kingdom of Piedmont +would have saved that monarchy from invasion if war had again arisen. The +annexation of Genoa was indeed fruitful of results, but not of results +which Pitt and his successors had anticipated. It was intended to +strengthen the House of Savoy for the purpose of resistance to France: +[247] it did strengthen the House of Savoy, but as the champion of Italy +against Austria. It was intended to withdraw the busy trading city Genoa +from the influences of French democracy: in reality it brought a strong +element of innovation into the Piedmontese State itself, giving, on the one +hand, a bolder and more national spirit to its Government, and, on the +other hand, elevating to the ideal of a united Italy those who, like the +Genoese Mazzini, were now no longer born to be the citizens of a free +Republic. In sacrificing the ancient liberty of Genoa, the Congress itself +unwittingly began the series of changes which was to refute the famous +saying of Metternich, that Italy was but a geographical expression. + +[Alsace and Lorraine.] + +But if the policy of 1814-15 in the affairs of Belgium and Piedmont only +proves how little an average collection of statesmen can see into the +future, the policy which, in spite of Waterloo, left France in possession +of an undiminished territory, does no discredit to the foresight, as it +certainly does the highest honour to the justice and forbearance of +Wellington, whose counsels then turned the scale. The wisdom of the +resolution has indeed been frequently impugned. German statesmen held then, +and have held ever since, that the opportunity of disarming France once for +all of its weapons of attack was wantonly thrown away. Hardenberg, when his +arguments for annexation of the frontier-fortresses were set aside, +predicted that streams of blood would hereafter flow for the conquest of +Alsace and Lorraine, [248] and his prediction has been fulfilled. Yet no +one perhaps would have been more astonished than Hardenberg himself, could +he have known that fifty-five years of peace between France and Prussia +would precede the next great struggle. When the same period of peace shall +have followed the acquisition of Metz and Strasburg by Prussia, it will be +time to condemn the settlement of 1815 as containing the germ of future +wars; till then, the effects of that settlement in maintaining peace are +entitled to recognition. It is impossible to deny that the Allies, in +leaving to France the whole of its territory in 1815, avoided inflicting +the most galling of all tokens of defeat upon a spirited and still most +powerful nation. The loss of Belgium and the frontier of the Rhine was +keenly enough felt for thirty years to come, and made no insignificant part +of the French people ready at any moment to rush into war; how much greater +the power of the war-cry, how hopeless the task of restraint, if to the +other motives for war there had been added the liberation of two of the +most valued provinces of France. Without this the danger was great enough. +Thrice at least in the next thirty years the balance seemed to be turning +against the continuance of peace. An offensive alliance between France and +Russia was within view when the Bourbon monarchy fell; the first years of +Louis Philippe all but saw the revolutionary party plunge France into war +for Belgium and for Italy; ten years later the dismissal of a Ministry +alone prevented the outbreak of hostilities on the distant affairs of +Syria. Had Alsace and Lorraine at this time been in the hands of disunited +Germany, it is hard to believe that the Bourbon dynasty would not have +averted, or sought to avert, its fall by a popular war, or that the victory +of Louis Philippe over the war-party, difficult even when there was no +French soil to reconquer, would have been possible. The time indeed came +when a new Bonaparte turned to enterprises of aggression the resources +which Europe had left unimpaired to his country; but to assume that the +cessions proposed in 1815 would have made France unable to move, with or +without allies, half a century afterwards, is to make a confident guess in +a doubtful matter; and, with Germany in the condition in which it remained +after 1815, it is at least as likely that the annexation of Alsace and +Lorraine would have led to the early reconquest of the Rhenish provinces by +France, or to a war between Austria and Prussia, as that it would have +prolonged the period of European peace beyond that distant limit which it +actually reached. + +[English efforts at the Congress to abolish the slave-trade.] + +Among the subjects which were pressed upon the Congress of Vienna there was +one in which the pursuit of national interests and calculations of policy +bore no part, the abolition of the African slave-trade. The British people, +who, after twenty years of combat in the cause of Europe, had earned so +good a right to ask something of their allies, probably attached a deeper +importance to this question than to any in the whole range of European +affairs, with the single exception of the personal overthrow of Napoleon. +Since the triumph of Wiberforce's cause in the Parliament of 1807, and the +extinction of English slave-traffic, the anger with which the nation viewed +this detestable cruelty, too long tolerated by itself, had become more and +more vehement and widespread. By the year 1814 the utterances of public +opinion were so loud and urgent that the Government, though free from +enthusiasm itself, was forced to place the international prohibition of the +slave-trade in the front rank of its demands. There were politicians on the +Continent credulous enough to believe that this outcry of the heart and the +conscience of the nation was but a piece of commercial hypocrisy. +Talleyrand, with far different insight, but not with more sympathy, spoke +of the state of the English people as one of frenzy. [249] Something had +already been effected at foreign courts. Sweden had been led to prohibit +slave-traffic in 1813, Holland in the following year. Portugal had been +restrained by treaty from trading north of the line. France had pledged +itself in the first Treaty of Paris to abolish the commerce within five +years. Spain alone remained unfettered, and it was indeed intolerable that +the English slavers should have been forced to abandon their execrable +gains only that they should fall into the hands of the subjects of King +Ferdinand. It might be true that the Spanish colonies required a larger +supply of slaves than they possessed; but Spain had at any rate not the +excuse that it was asked to surrender an old and profitable branch of +commerce. It was solely through the abolition of the English slave-trade +that Spain possessed any slave-trade whatever. Before the year 1807 no +Spanish ship had been seen on the coast of Africa for a century, except one +in 1798 fitted out by Godoy. [250] As for the French trade, that had been +extinguished by the capture of Senegal and Goree; and along the two +thousand miles of coast from Cape Blanco to Cape Formosa a legitimate +commerce with the natives was gradually springing up in place of the +desolating traffic in flesh and blood. It was hoped by the English people +that Castlereagh would succeed in obtaining a universal and immediate +prohibition of the slave-trade by all the Powers assembled at Vienna. The +Minister was not wanting in perseverance, but he failed to achieve this +result. France, while claiming a short delay elsewhere, professed itself +willing, like Portugal, to abolish at once the traffic north of the line; +but the Government on which England had perhaps the greatest claim, that of +Spain, absolutely refused to accept this restriction, or to bind itself to +a final prohibition before the end of eight years. Castlereagh then +proposed that a Council of Ambassadors at London and Paris should be +charged with the international duty of expediting the close of the +slave-trade; the measure which he had in view being the punishment of +slave-dealing States by a general exclusion of their exports. Against this +Spain and Portugal made a formal protest, treating the threat as almost +equivalent to one of war. The project dropped, and the Minister of England +had to content himself with obtaining from the Congress a solemn +condemnation of the slave-trade, as contrary to the principles of +civilisation and human right (Feb., 1815). + +The work was carried a step further by Napoleon's return from Elba. +Napoleon understood the impatience of the English people, and believed that +he could make no higher bid for its friendship than by abandoning the +reserves made by Talleyrand at the Congress, and abolishing the French +slave-trade at once and for all. This was accomplished; and the Bourbon +ally of England, on his second restoration could not undo what had been +done by the usurper. Spain and Portugal alone continued to pursue--the +former country without restriction, the latter on the south of the line--a +commerce branded by the united voice of Europe as infamous. The Governments +of these countries alleged in their justification that Great Britain itself +had resisted the passing of the prohibitory law until its colonies were far +better supplied with slaves than those of its rivals now were. This was +true, but it was not the whole truth. The whole truth was not known, the +sincerity of English feeling was not appreciated, until, twenty years +later, the nation devoted a part of its wealth to release the slave from +servitude, and the English race from the reproach of slave holding. Judged +by the West Indian Emancipation of 1833, the Spanish appeal to English +history sounds almost ludicrous. But the remembrance of the long years +throughout which the advocates of justice encountered opposition in England +should temper the severity of our condemnation of the countries which still +defended a bad interest. The light broke late upon ourselves: the darkness +that still lingered elsewhere had too long been our own. + + + + +CHAPTER XIII. + + +Concert of Europe after 1815--Spirit of the Foreign Policy of Alexander, of +Metternich, and of the English Ministry--Metternich's action in Italy, +England's in Sicily and Spain--The Reaction in France--Richelieu and the +New Chamber--Execution of Ney--Imprisonments and persecutions--Conduct of +the Ultra-Royalists in Parliament--Contests on the Electoral Bill and the +Budget--The Chamber prorogued--Affair of Grenoble--Dissolution of the +Chamber--Electoral Law and Financial Settlement of 1817--Character of the +first years of peace in Europe generally--Promise of a Constitution in +Prussia--Hardenberg opposed by the partisans of autocracy and +privilege--Schmalz's Pamphlet--Delay of Constitutional Reform in Germany at +large--The Wartburg Festival--Progress of Reaction--The Czar now inclines +to repression--Congress of Aix-la-Chapelle--Evacuation of France--Growing +influence of Metternich in Europe--His action on Prussia--Murder of +Kotzebue--The Carlsbad Conference and measures of repression in +Germany--Richelieu and Decazes--Murder of the Duke of Berry--Progress of +the reaction in France--General causes of the victory of reaction in +Europe. + + +[Concert of Europe regarding France.] + +For nearly twenty years the career of Bonaparte had given to European +history the unity of interest which belongs to a single life. This unity +does not immediately disappear on the disappearance of his mighty figure. +The Powers of Europe had been too closely involved in the common struggle, +their interests were too deeply concerned in the maintenance of the +newly-established order, for the thoughts of Governments to be withdrawn +from foreign affairs, and the currents of national policy to fall at once +apart into separate channels. The Allied forces continued to occupy France +with Wellington as commander-in-chief; the defence of the Bourbon monarchy +had been declared the cause of Europe at large; the conditions under which +the numbers of the army of occupation might be reduced, or the period of +occupation shortened, remained to be fixed by the Allies themselves. France +thus formed the object of a common European deliberation; nor was the +concert of the Powers without its peculiar organ. An International Council +was created at Paris, consisting of the Ambassadors of the four great +Courts. The forms of a coalition were, for the first time, preserved after +the conclusion of peace. Communications were addressed to the Government of +Louis XVIII., in the name of all the Powers together. The Council of +Ambassadors met at regular intervals, and not only transacted business +relating to the army of occupation and the payment of indemnities, but +discussed the domestic policy of the French Government, and the situation +of parties or the signs of political opinion in the Assembly and the +nation. + +[Action of the Powers outside France.] + +In thus watching over the restored Bourbon monarchy, the Courts of Europe +were doing no more than they had bound themselves to do by treaty. Paris, +however, was not the only field for a busy diplomacy. In most of the minor +capitals of Europe each of the Great Powers had its own supposed interests +to pursue, or its own principles of government to inculcate. An age of +transition seemed to have begun. Constitutions had been promised in many +States, and created in some; in Spain and in Sicily they had reached the +third stage, that of suppression. It was not likely that the statesmen who +had succeeded to Napoleon's power in Europe should hold themselves entirely +aloof from the affairs of their weaker neighbours, least of all when a +neighbouring agitation might endanger themselves. In one respect the +intentions of the British, the Austrian, and the Russian Governments were +identical, and continued to be so, namely, in the determination to +countenance no revolutionary movement. Revolution, owing to the experience +of 1793, had come to be regarded as synonymous with aggressive warfare. +Jacobins, anarchists, disturbers of the public peace, were only different +names for one and the same class of international criminals, who were +indeed indigenous to France, but might equally endanger the peace of +mankind in other countries. Against these fomenters of mischief all the +Courts were at one. + +[Alexander.] + +Here, however, agreement ceased. It was admitted that between revolutionary +disturbance and the enjoyment of constitutional liberty a wide interval +existed, and the statesmen of the leading Powers held by no means the same +views as to the true relation between nations and their rulers. The most +liberal in theory among the Sovereigns of 1815 was the Emperor Alexander. +Already, in the summer of 1815, he had declared the Duchy of Warsaw to be +restored to independence and nationality, under the title of the Kingdom of +Poland; and before the end of the year he had granted it a Constitution, +which created certain representative assemblies, and provided the new +kingdom with an army and an administration of its own, into which no person +not a Pole could enter. The promised introduction of Parliamentary life +into Poland was but the first of a series of reforms dimly planned by +Alexander, which was to culminate in the bestowal of a Constitution upon +Russia itself, and the emancipation of the serf. [251] Animated by hopes +like these for his own people, hopes which, while they lasted, were not +merely sincere but ardent, Alexander was also friendly to the cause of +constitutional government in other countries. Ambition mingled with +disinterested impulses in the foreign policy of the Czar. It was impossible +that Alexander should forget the league into which England and Austria had +so lately entered against him. He was anxious to keep France on his side; +he was not inclined to forego the satisfaction of weakening Austria by +supporting national hopes in Italy; [252] and he hoped to create some +counterpoise to England's maritime power by allying Russia with a +strengthened and better-administered Spain. Agents of the Czar abounded in +Italy and in Germany, but in no capital was the Ambassador of Russia more +active than in Madrid. General Tatistcheff, who was appointed to this post +in 1814, became the terror of all his colleagues and of the Cabinet of +London from his extraordinary activity in intrigue; but in relation to the +internal affairs of Spain his influence was beneficial; and it was +frequently directed towards the support of reforming Ministers, whom King +Ferdinand, if free from foreign pressure, would speedily have sacrificed to +the pleasure of his favourites and confessors. + +[Metternich.] + +[Metternich's policy in Germany.] + +[In Italy.] + +In the eyes of Prince Metternich, the all-powerful Minister of Austria, +Alexander was little better than a Jacobin. The Austrian State, though its +frontiers had been five times changed since 1792, had continued in a +remarkable degree free from the impulse to internal change. The Emperor +Francis was the personification of resistance to progress; the Minister +owed his unrivalled position not more to his own skilful statesmanship in +the great crisis of 1813 than to a genuine accord with the feelings of his +master. If Francis was not a man of intellect, Metternich was certainly a +man of character; and for a considerable period they succeeded in +impressing the stamp of their own strongly-marked Austrian policy upon +Europe. The force of their influence sprang from no remote source; it was +due mainly to a steady intolerance of all principles not their own. +Metternich described his system with equal simplicity and precision as an +attempt neither to innovate nor to go back to the past, but to keep things +as they were. In the old Austrian dominions this was not difficult to do, +for things had no tendency to move and remained fixed of themselves; [253] +but on the outside, both on the north and on the south, ideas were at work +which, according to Metternich, ought never to have entered the world, but, +having unfortunately gained admittance, made it the task of Governments to +resist their influence by all available means. Stein and the leaders of the +Prussian War of Liberation had agitated Germany with hopes of national +unity, of Parliaments, and of the impulsion of the executive powers of +State by public opinion. Against these northern innovators, Metternich had +already won an important victory in the formation of the Federal +Constitution. The weakness and timidity of the King of Prussia made it +probable that, although he was now promising his subjects a Constitution, +he might at no distant date be led to unite with other German Governments +in a system of repression, and in placing Liberalism under the ban of the +Diet. In Italy, according to the conservative statesman, the same dangers +existed and the same remedies were required. Austria, through the +acquisition of Venice, now possessed four times as large a territory beyond +the Alps as it had possessed before 1792; but the population was no longer +the quiescent and contented folk that it had been in the days of Maria +Theresa. Napoleon's kingdom and army of Italy had taught the people +warfare, and given them political aims and a more masculine spirit. +Metternich's own generals had promised the Italians independence when they +entered the country in 1814; Murat's raid a year later had actually been +undertaken in the name of Italian unity. These were disagreeable incidents, +and signs were not wanting of the existence of a revolutionary spirit in +the Italian provinces of Austria, especially among the officers who had +served under Napoleon. Metternich was perfectly clear as to the duties of +his Government. The Italians might have a Viceroy to keep Court at Milan, a +body of native officials to conduct their minor affairs, and a mock +Congregation or Council, without any rights, powers, or functions whatever; +if this did not satisfy them, they were a rebellious people, and government +must be conducted by means of spies, police, and the dungeons of the +Spielberg. [254] + +[Scheme of an Austrian Protectorate over Italy.] + +On this system, backed by great military force, there was nothing to fear +from the malcontents of Lombardy and Venice: it remained for Metternich to +extend the same security to the rest of the peninsula, and by a series of +treaties to effect the double end of exterminating constitutional +government and of establishing an Austrian Protectorate over the entire +country, from the Alps to the Sicilian Straits. The design was so ambitious +that Metternich had not dared to disclose it at the Congress of Vienna; it +was in fact a direct violation of the Treaty of Paris, and of the +resolution of the Congress, that Italy, outside the possessions of Austria, +should consist of independent States. The first Sovereign over whom the net +was cast was Ferdinand of Naples. On the 15th of June, 1815, immediately +after the overthrow of Murat, King Ferdinand signed a Treaty of Alliance +with Austria, which contained a secret clause, pledging the King to +introduce no change into his recovered kingdom inconsistent with its own +old monarchical principles, or with the principles which had been adopted +by the Emperor of Austria for the government of his Italian provinces. +[255] Ferdinand, two years before, had been compelled by Great Britain to +grant Sicily a Constitution, and was at this very moment promising one to +Naples. The Sicilian Constitution was now tacitly condemned; the +Neapolitans were duped. By a further secret clause, the two contracting +Sovereigns undertook to communicate to one another everything that should +come to their knowledge affecting the security and tranquillity of the +Italian peninsula; in other words, the spies and the police of Ferdinand +were now added to Metternich's staff in Lombardy. Tuscany, Modena, and +Parma entered into much the same condition of vassalage; but the scheme for +a universal federation of Italy under Austria's leadership failed through +the resistance of Piedmont and of the Pope. Pius VII. resented the attempts +of Austria, begun in 1797 and repeated at the Congress of Vienna, to +deprive the Holy See of Bologna and Ravenna. The King of Sardinia, though +pressed by England to accept Metternich's offer of alliance, maintained +with great decision the independence of his country, and found in the +support of the Czar a more potent argument than any that he could have +drawn from treaties. [256] + +[Spirit of England's foreign policy.] + +The part played by the British Government at this epoch has been severely +judged not only by the later opinion of England itself, but by the +historical writers of almost every nation in Europe. It is perhaps +fortunate for the fame of Pitt that he did not live to witness the +accomplishment of the work in which he had laboured for thirteen years. The +glory of a just and courageous struggle against Napoleon's tyranny remains +with Pitt; the opprobrium of a settlement hostile to liberty has fallen on +his successors. Yet there is no good ground for believing that Pitt would +have attached a higher value to the rights or inclinations of individual +communities than his successors did in re-adjusting the balance of power; +on the contrary, he himself first proposed to destroy the Republic of +Genoa, and to place Catholic Belgium under the Protestant Crown of Holland; +nor was any principle dearer to him than that of aggrandising the House of +Austria as a counterpoise to the power of France. [257] The Ministry of +1815 was indeed but too faithfully walking in the path into which Pitt had +been driven by the King and the nation in 1793. Resistance to France had +become the one absorbing care, the beginning and end of English +statesmanship. Government at home had sunk to a narrow and unfeeling +opposition to the attempts made from time to time to humanise the mass of +the people, to reform an atrocious criminal law, to mitigate the civil +wrongs inflicted in the name and the interest of a State-religion. No one +in the Cabinet doubted that authority, as such, must be wiser than +inexperienced popular desire, least of all the statesman who now, in +conjunction with the Duke of Wellington, controlled the policy of Great +Britain upon the Continent. Lord Castlereagh had no sympathy with cruelty +or oppression in Continental rulers; he had just as little belief in the +value of free institutions to their subjects. [258] The nature of his +influence, which has been drawn sometimes in too dark colours, may be +fairly gathered from the course of action which he followed in regard to +Sicily and to Spain. + +[In Sicily.] + +In Sicily the representative of Great Britain, Lord William Bentinck, had +forced King Ferdinand, who could not have maintained himself for an hour +without the arms and money of England, to establish in 1813 a Parliament +framed on the model of our own. The Parliament had not proved a wise or a +capable body, but its faults were certainly not equal to those of King +Ferdinand, and its re-construction under England's auspices would have been +an affair of no great difficulty. Ferdinand, however, had always detested +free institutions, and as soon as he regained the throne of Naples he +determined to have done with the Sicilian Parliament. A correspondence on +the intended change took place between Lord Castlereagh and A'Court, the +Ambassador who had now succeeded Lord William Bentinck. [259] That the +British Government, which had protected the Sicilian Crown against Napoleon +at the height of his power, could have protected the Sicilian Constitution +against King Ferdinand's edicts without detaching a single man-of-war's +boat, is not open to doubt. Castlereagh, however, who for years past had +been paying, stimulating, or rebuking every Government in Europe, and who +had actually sent the British fleet to make the Norwegians submit to +Bernadotte, now suddenly adopted the principle of non-intervention, and +declared that, so long as Ferdinand did not persecute the Sicilians who at +the invitation of England had taken part in political life, or reduce the +privileges of Sicily below those which had existed prior to 1813, Great +Britain would not interfere with his action. These stipulations were +inserted in order to satisfy the House of Commons, and to avert the charge +that England had not only abandoned the Sicilian Constitution, but +consented to a change which left the Sicilians in a worse condition than if +England had never intervened in their affairs. Lord Castlereagh shut his +eyes to the confession involved, that he was leaving the Sicilians to a +ruler who, but for such restraint, might be expected to destroy every +vestige of public right, and to take the same bloody and unscrupulous +revenge upon his subjects which he had taken when Nelson restored him to +power in 1799. + +[Action of England in Spain.] + +The action of the British Government in Spain showed an equal readiness to +commit the future to the wisdom of Courts. Lord Castlereagh was made +acquainted with the Spanish Ferdinand's design of abolishing the +Constitution on his return in the year 1814. "So far," he replied, "as the +mere existence of the Constitution is at stake, it is impossible to believe +that any change tranquilly effected can well be worse." [260] In this case +the interposition of England would perhaps not have availed against a +reactionary clergy and nation: Castlereagh, was, moreover, deceived by +Ferdinand's professions that he had no desire to restore absolute +government. He credited the King with the same kind of moderation which had +led Louis XVIII. to accept the Charta in France, and looked forward to the +maintenance of a constitutional regime, though under conditions more +favourable to the executive power and to the influence of the great landed +proprietors and clergy. [261] Events soon proved what value was to be +attached to the word of the King; the flood of reaction and vengeance broke +over the country; and from this time the British Government, half +confessing and half excusing Ferdinand's misdeeds, exerted itself to check +the outrages of despotism, and to mitigate the lot of those who were now +its victims. In the interest of the restored monarchies themselves, as much +as from a regard to the public opinion of Great Britain, the Ambassadors of +England urged moderation upon all the Bourbon Courts. This, however, was +also done by Metternich, who neither took pleasure in cruelty, nor desired +to see new revolutions produced by the extravagances of priests and +emigrants. It was not altogether without cause that the belief arose that +there was little to choose, in reference to the constitutional liberties of +other States, between the sentiments of Austria and those of the Ministers +of free England. A difference, however, did exist. Metternich actually +prohibited the Sovereigns over whom his influence extended from granting +their subjects liberty: England, believing the Sovereigns to be more +liberal than they were, did not interfere to preserve constitutions from +destruction. + +[Outrages of the Royalists in the south of France, June-August.] + +Such was the general character of the influence now exercised by the three +leading Powers of Europe. Prussia, which had neither a fleet like England, +an Italian connection like Austria, nor an ambitious Sovereign like Russia, +concerned itself little with distant States, and limited its direct action +to the affairs of France, in which it possessed a substantial interest, +inasmuch as the indemnities due from Louis XVIII. had yet to be paid. The +possibility of recovering these sums depended upon the maintenance of peace +and order in France; and from the first it was recognised by every +Government in Europe that the principal danger to peace and order arose +from the conduct of the Count of Artois and his friends, the party of +reaction. The counterrevolutionary movement began in mere riot and outrage. +No sooner had the news of the battle of Waterloo reached the south of +France than the Royalist mob of Marseilles drove the garrison out of the +town, and attacked the quarter inhabited by the Mameluke families whom +Napoleon had brought from Egypt. Thirteen of these unfortunate persons, and +about as many Bonapartist citizens, were murdered. [262] A few weeks later +Nismes was given over to anarchy and pillage. Religious fanaticism here +stimulated the passion of political revenge. The middle class in Nismes +itself and a portion of the surrounding population were Protestant, and had +hailed Napoleon's return from Elba as a deliverance from the ascendancy of +priests, and from the threatened revival of the persecutions which they had +suffered under the old Bourbon monarchy. The Catholics, who were much more +numerous, included the lowest class in the town, the larger landed +proprietors of the district, and above half of the peasantry. Bands of +volunteers had been formed by the Duke of Angouleme at the beginning of the +Hundred Days, in the hope of sustaining a civil war against Napoleon. After +capitulating to the Emperor's generals, some companies had been attacked by +villagers and hunted down like wild beasts. The bands now reassembled and +entered Nismes. The garrison, after firing upon them, were forced to give +up their arms, and in this defenceless state a considerable number of the +soldiers were shot down (July 17). On the next day the leaders of the armed +mob began to use their victory. For several weeks murder and outrage, +deliberately planned and publicly announced, kept not only Nismes itself, +but a wide extent of the surrounding country in constant terror. The +Government acted slowly and feebly; the local authorities were intimidated; +and, in spite of the remonstrances of Wellington and the Russian +Ambassador, security was not restored until the Allies took the matter into +their own hands, and a detachment of Austrian troops occupied the +Department of the Gard. Other districts in the south of France witnessed +the same outbreaks of Royalist ferocity. Avignon was disgraced by the +murder of Marshal Brune, conqueror of the Russians and English in the Dutch +campaign of 1799, an honest soldier, who after suffering Napoleon's neglect +in the time of prosperity, had undertaken the heavy task of governing +Marseilles during the Hundred Days. At Toulouse, General Ramel, himself a +Royalist, was mortally wounded by a band of assassins, and savagely +mutilated while lying disabled and expiring. + +[Elections of 1815.] + +Crimes like these were the counterpart of the September massacres of 1792; +and the terrorism exercised by the Royalists in 1815 has been compared, as +a whole, with the Republican Reign of Terror twenty-two years earlier. But +the comparison does little credit to the historical sense of those who +suggested it. The barbarities of 1815 were strictly local: shocking as they +were, they scarcely amounted in all to an average day's work of Carrier or +Fouche in 1794; and the action of the established Government, though +culpably weak, was not itself criminal. A second and more dangerous stage +of reaction began, however, when the work of popular vengeance closed. +Elections for a new Chamber of Deputies were held at the end of August. The +Liberals and the adherents of Napoleon, paralysed by the disasters of +France and the invaders' presence, gave up all as lost: the Ministers of +Louis XVIII. abstained from the usual electoral manoeuvres, Talleyrand +through carelessness, Fouche from a desire to see parties evenly balanced: +the ultra-Royalists alone had extended their organisation over France, and +threw themselves into the contest with the utmost passion and energy. +Numerically weak, they had the immense forces of the local administration +on their side. The Prefets had gone over heart and soul to the cause of the +Count of Artois, who indeed represented to them that he was acting under +the King's own directions. The result was that an Assembly was elected to +which France has seen only one parallel since, namely in the Parliament of +1871, elected when invaders again occupied the country, and the despotism +of a second Bonaparte had ended in the same immeasurable calamity. The bulk +of the candidates returned were country gentlemen whose names had never +been heard of in public life since 1789, men who had resigned themselves to +inaction and obscurity under the Republic and the Empire, and whose one +political idea was to reverse the injuries done by the Revolution to their +caste and to their Church. They were Royalists because a Bourbon monarchy +alone could satisfy their claims: they called themselves ultra-Royalists, +but they were so only in the sense that they required the monarchy to +recognise no ally but themselves. They had already shown before Napoleon's +return that their real chief was the Count of Artois, not the King; in what +form their ultra-Royalism would exhibit itself in case the King should not +submit to be their instrument remained to be proved. + +[Fall of Talleyrand and Fouche.] + +[Richelieu's Ministry, Sept., 1815.] + +The first result of the elections was the downfall of Talleyrand's Liberal +Ministry. The Count of Artois and the courtiers, who had been glad enough +to secure Fouche's services while their own triumph was doubtful, now +joined in the outcry of the country gentlemen again this monster of +iniquity. Talleyrand promptly disencumbered himself of his old friend, and +prepared to meet the new Parliament as an ultra-Royalist; but in the eyes +of the victorious party Talleyrand himself, the married priest and the +reputed accomplice in the murder of the Duke of Enghien, was little better +than his regicide colleague; and before the Assembly met he was forced to +retire from power. + +[Richelieu's Ministry, Sept. 1815.] + +His successor, the Duc de Richelieu, was recommended to Louis XVIII. by the +Czar. Richelieu had quitted France early in the Revolution, and, unlike +most of the emigrants, had played a distinguished part in the country which +gave him refuge. Winning his first laurels in the siege of Ismail under +Suvaroff, he had subsequently been made Governor of the Euxine provinces of +Russia, and the flourishing town of Odessa had sprung up under his rule. +His reputation as an administrator was high; his personal character +singularly noble and disinterested. Though the English Government looked at +first with apprehension upon a Minister so closely connected with the Czar +of Russia, Richelieu's honesty and truthfulness soon gained him the respect +of every foreign Court. His relation to Alexander proved of great service +to France in lightening the burden of the army of occupation; his equity, +his acquaintance with the real ends of monarchical government, made him, +though no lover of liberty, a valuable Minister in face of an Assembly +which represented nothing but the passions and the ideas of a reactionary +class. But Richelieu had been too long absent from France to grasp the +details of administration with a steady hand. The men, the parties of 1815, +were new to him: it is said that he was not acquainted by sight with most +of his colleagues when he appointed them to their posts. The Ministry in +consequence was not at unity within itself. Some of its members, like +Decazes, were more liberal than their chief; others, like Clarke and +Vaublanc, old servants of Napoleon now turned ultra-Royalists, were eager +to make themselves the instruments of the Count of Artois, and to carry +into the work of government the enthusiasm of revenge which had already +found voice in the elections. + +[Violence of the Chamber of 1815.] + +The session opened on the 7th of October. Twenty-nine of the peers, who had +joined Napoleon during the Hundred Days, were excluded from the House, and +replaced by adherents of the Bourbons; nevertheless the peers as a body +opposed themselves to extreme reaction, and, in spite of Chateaubriand's +sanguinary harangues, supported the moderate policy of Richelieu against +the majority of the Lower House. The first demand of the Chamber of +Deputies was for retribution upon traitors; [263] their first conflict with +the Government of Louis XVIII. arose upon the measures which were brought +forward by the Ministry for the preservation of public security and the +punishment of seditious acts. The Ministers were attacked, not because +their measures were too severe, but because they were not severe enough. +While taking power to imprison all suspected persons without trial, or to +expel them from their homes, Decazes, the Police-Minister, proposed to +punish incitements to sedition by fines and terms of imprisonment varying +according to the gravity of the offence. So mild a penalty excited the +wrath of men whose fathers and brothers had perished on the guillotine. +Some cried out for death, others for banishment to Cayenne. When it was +pointed out that the infliction of capital punishment for the mere attempt +at sedition would place this on a level with armed rebellion, it was +answered that a distinction might be maintained by adding in the latter +case the ancient punishment of parricide, the amputation of the hand. +Extravagances like this belonged rather to the individuals than to a party; +but the vehemence of the Chamber forced the Government to submit to a +revision of its measure. Transportation to Cayenne, but not death, was +ultimately included among the penalties for seditious acts. The Minister of +Justice, M. Barbe-Marbois, who had himself been transported to Cayenne by +the Jacobins in 1797, was able to satisfy the Chamber from his own +experience that they were not erring on the side of mercy. [264] + +[Ney executed, Dec. 7.] + +It was in the midst of these heated debates that Marshal Ney was brought to +trial for high treason. A so-called Edict of Amnesty had been published by +the King on the 24th of July, containing the names of nineteen persons who +were to be tried by courts-martial on capital charges, and of thirty-eight +others who were to be either exiled or brought to justice, as the Chamber +might determine. Ney was included in the first category. Opportunities for +escape had been given to him by the Government, as indeed they had to +almost every other person on the list. King Louis XVIII. well understood +that his Government was not likely to be permanently strengthened by the +execution of some of the most distinguished men in France; the emigrants, +however, and especially the Duchess of Angouleme, were merciless, and the +English Government acted a deplorable part. "One can never feel that the +King is secure on his throne," wrote Lord Liverpool, "until he has dared to +spill traitors' blood." It is not that many examples would be necessary; +but the daring to make a few will alone manifest any strength in the +Government. [265] Labedoyere had already been executed. On the 9th of +November Ney was brought before a court-martial, at which Castlereagh and +his wife had the bad taste to be present. The court-martial, headed by +Ney's old comrade Jourdan, declared itself incompetent to judge a peer of +France accused of high treason, [266] Ney was accordingly tried before the +House of Peers. The verdict was a foregone conclusion, and indeed the legal +guilt of the Marshal could hardly be denied. Had the men who sat in +judgment upon him been a body of Vendean peasants who had braved fire and +sword for the Bourbon cause, the sentence of death might have been +pronounced with pure, though stern lips: it remains a deep disgrace to +France that among the peers who voted not only for Ney's condemnation but +for his death, there were some who had themselves accepted office and pay +from Napoleon during the Hundred Days. A word from Wellington would still +have saved the Marshal's life, but in interceding for Ney the Duke would +have placed himself in direct opposition to the action of his own +Government. When the Premier had dug the grave, it was not for Wellington +to rescue the prisoner. It is permissible to hope that he, who had so +vehemently reproached Bluecher for his intention to put Napoleon to death if +he should fall into his hands, would have asked clemency for Ney had he +considered himself at liberty to obey the promptings of his own nature. The +responsibility for Marshal Ney's death rests, more than upon any other +individual, upon Lord Liverpool. + +On the 7th of December the sentence was executed. Ney was shot at early +morning in an unfrequented spot, and the Government congratulated itself +that it had escaped the dangers of a popular demonstration and heard the +last of a disagreeable business. Never was there a greater mistake. No +crime committed in the Reign of Terror attached a deeper popular opprobrium +to its authors than the execution of Ney did to the Bourbon family. The +victim, a brave but rough half-German soldier, [267] rose in popular legend +almost to the height of the Emperor himself. His heroism in the retreat +from Moscow became, and with justice, a more glorious memory than Davoust's +victory at Jena or Moreau's at Hohenlinden. Side by side with the thought +that the Bourbons had been brought back by foreign arms, the remembrance +sank deep into the heart of the French people that this family had put to +death "the bravest of the brave." It would have been no common good fortune +for Louis XVIII. to have pardoned or visited with light punishment a great +soldier whose political feebleness had led him to an act of treason, +condoned by the nation at large. Exile would not have made the transgressor +a martyr. But the common sense of mankind condemns Ney's execution: the +public opinion of France has never forgiven it. + +[Amnesty Bill, Dec 8.] + +On the day after the great example was made, Richelieu brought forward the +Amnesty Bill of the Government in the House of Representatives. The King, +while claiming full right of pardon, desired that the Chamber should be +associated with him in its exercise, and submitted a project of law +securing from prosecution all persons not included in the list published on +July 24th. Measures of a very different character had already been +introduced under the same title into the Chamber. Though the initiative in +legislation belonged by virtue of the Charta to the Crown, resolutions +might be moved by members in the shape of petition or address, and under +this form the leaders of the majority had drawn up schemes for the +wholesale proscription of Napoleon's adherents. It was proposed by M. la +Bourdonnaye to bring to trial all the great civil and military officers +who, during the Hundred Days, had constituted the Government of the +usurper; all generals, prefets, and commanders of garrisons, who had obeyed +Napoleon before a certain day, to be named by the Assembly; and all voters +for the death of Louis XVI. who had recognised Napoleon by signing the Acte +Additionnel. The language in which these prosecutions were urged was the +echo of that which had justified the bloodshed of 1793; its violence was +due partly to the fancy that Napoleon's return was no sudden and unexpected +act, but the work of a set of conspirators in high places, who were still +plotting the overthrow of the monarchy. [268] + +[Persecution of suspected persons over all France.] + +It was in vain that Richelieu intervened with the expression of the King's +own wishes, and recalled the example of forgiveness shown in the testament +of Louis XVI. The committee which was appointed to report on the projects +of amnesty brought up a scheme little different from that of La +Bourdonnaye, and added to it the iniquitous proposal that civil actions +should be brought against all condemned persons for the damages sustained +by the State through Napoleon's return. This was to make a mock of the +clause in the Charta which abolished confiscation. The report of the +committee caused the utmost dismay both in France itself and among the +representatives of foreign Powers at Paris. The conflict between the men of +reaction and the Government had openly broken out; Richelieu's Ministry, +the guarantee of peace, seemed to be on the point of falling. On the 2nd of +January, 1816, the Chamber proceeded to discuss the Bill of the Government +and the amendments of the committee. The debate lasted four days; it was +only by the repeated use of the King's own name that the Ministers +succeeded in gaining a majority of nine votes against the two principal +categories of exception appended to the amnesty by their opponents. The +proposal to restore confiscation under the form of civil actions was +rejected by a much greater majority, but on the vote affecting the +regicides the Government was defeated. This indeed was considered of no +great moment. Richelieu, content with having averted measures which would +have exposed several hundred persons to death, exile, or pecuniary ruin, +consented to banish from France the regicides who had acknowledged +Napoleon, along with the thirty-eight persons named in the second list of +July 24th. Among other well-known men, Carnot, who had rendered such great +services to his country, went to die in exile. Of the seventeen companions +of Ney and Labedoyere in the first list of July 24th, most had escaped from +France; one alone suffered death. [269] But the persons originally excluded +from the amnesty and the regicides exiled by the Assembly formed but a +small part of those on whom the vengeance of the Royalists fell; for it was +provided that the amnesty-law should apply to no one against whom +proceedings had been taken before the formal promulgation of the law. The +prisons were already crowded with accused persons, who thus remained +exposed to punishment; and after the law had actually passed the Chamber, +telegraph-signals were sent over the country by Clarke, the Minister of +War, ordering the immediate accusation of several others. One distinguished +soldier at least, General Travot, was sentenced to death on proceedings +thus instituted between the passing and the promulgation of the law of +amnesty. [270] Executions, however, were not numerous except in the south +of France, but an enormous number of persons were imprisoned or driven from +their homes, some by judgment of the law-courts, some by the exercise of +the powers conferred on the administration by the law of Public Security. +[271] The central government indeed had less part in this species of +persecution than the Prefets and other local authorities, though within +their own departments Clarke and Vaublanc set an example which others were +not slow to follow. Royalist committees were formed all over the country, +and assumed the same kind of irregular control over the officials of their +districts as had been practised by the Jacobin committees of 1793. +Thousands of persons employed in all grades of the public service, in +schools and colleges as well as in the civil administration, in the +law-courts as well as in the army and navy, were dismissed from their +posts. The new-comers were professed agents of the reaction; those who were +permitted to retain their offices strove to outdo their colleagues in their +renegade zeal for the new order. It was seen again, as it had been seen +under the Republic and under the Empire, that if virtue has limits, +servility has none. The same men who had hunted down the peasant for +sheltering his children from Napoleon's conscription now hunted down those +who were stigmatised as Bonapartists. The clergy threw in their lot with +the victorious party, and denounced to the magistrates their parishioners +who treated them with disrespect. [272] Darker pages exist in French +history than the reaction of 1815, none more contemptible. It is the +deepest condemnation of the violence of the Republic and the despotism of +the Empire that the generation formed by it should have produced the class +who could exhibit, and the public who could tolerate, the prodigies of +baseness which attended the second Bourbon restoration. + +[The reactionists adopt Parliamentary theory.] + +Within the Chamber of Deputies the Ultra-Royalist majority had gained +Parliamentary experience in the debates on the Amnesty Bill and the Law of +Public Security: their own policy now took a definite shape, and to +outbursts of passion there succeeded the attempt to realise ideas. Hatred +of the Revolution and all its works was still the dominant impulse of the +Assembly; but whatever may have been the earlier desire of the +Ultra-Royalist noblesse, it was no longer their intention to restore the +political system that existed before 1789. They would in that case have +desired to restore absolute monarchy, and to surrender the power which +seemed at length to have fallen into the hands of their own class. With +Artois on the throne this might have been possible, for Artois, though heir +to the crown, was still what he had been in his youth, the chief of a +party: with Louis XVIII. and Richelieu at the head of the State, the +Ultra-Royalists became the adversaries of royal prerogative and the +champions of the rights of Parliament. Before the Revolution the noblesse +had possessed privileges; it had not possessed political power. The +Constitution of 1814 had unexpectedly given it, under representative forms, +the influence denied to it under the old monarchy. New political vistas +opened; and the men who had hitherto made St. Louis and Henry IV. the +subject of their declamations, now sought to extend the rights of +Parliament to the utmost, and to perpetuate in succeeding assemblies the +rule of the present majority. An electoral law favourable to the great +landed proprietors was the first necessity. This indeed was but a means to +an end; another and a greater end might be attained directly, the +restoration of a landed Church, and of the civil and social ascendancy of +the clergy. + +[Ecclesiastical schemes of the reaction.] + +It had been admitted by King Louis XVIII. that the clause in the Charta +relating to elections required modification, and on this point the +Ultra-Royalists in the Chamber were content to wait for the proposals of +the Government. In their ecclesiastical policy they did not maintain the +same reserve. Resolutions in favour of the State-Church were discussed in +the form of petitions to be presented to the Crown. It was proposed to make +the clergy, as they had been before the Revolution, the sole keepers of +registers of birth and marriage; to double the annual payment made to them +by the State; to permit property of all kinds to be acquired by the Church +by gift or will; to restore all Church lands not yet sold by the State; +and, finally, to abolish the University of France, and to place all schools +and colleges throughout the country under the control of the Bishops. One +central postulate not only passed the Chamber, but was accepted by the +Government and became law. Divorce was absolutely abolished; and for two +generations after 1816 no possible aggravation of wrong sufficed in France +to release either husband or wife from the mockery of a marriage-tie. The +power to accept donations or legacies was granted to the clergy, subject, +however, in every case to the approval of the Crown. The allowance made to +them out of the revenues of the State was increased by the amount of +certain pensions as they should fall in, a concession which fell very far +short of the demands of the Chamber. In all, the advantages won for the +Church were scarcely proportioned to the zeal displayed in its cause. The +most important question, the disposal of the unsold Church lands, remained +to be determined when the Chamber should enter upon the discussion of the +Budget. + +[Electoral Bill, Dec. 18, 1815.] + +The Electoral Bill of the Government, from which the Ultra-Royalists +expected so much, was introduced at the end of the year 1815. It showed in +a singular manner the confusion of ideas existing within the Ministry as to +the nature of the Parliamentary liberty now supposed to belong to France. +The ex-prefet Vaublanc, to whom the framing of the measure was entrusted, +though he imagined himself purged from the traditions of Napoleonism, could +conceive of no relation between the executive and the legislative power but +that which exists between a substance and its shadow. It never entered his +mind that the representative institutions granted by the Charta were +intended to bring an independent force to bear upon the Government, or that +the nation should be treated as more than a fringe round the compact and +lasting body of the administration. The language in which Vaublanc +introduced his measure was grotesquely candid. Montesquieu, he said, had +pointed out that powers must be subordinate; therefore the electoral power +must be controlled by the King's Government. [273] By the side of the +electors in the Canton and the Department there was accordingly placed, in +the Ministerial scheme, an array of officials numerous enough to carry the +elections, if indeed they did not actually outnumber the private voters. +The franchise was confined to the sixty richest persons in each Canton: +these, with the officials of the district, were to elect the voters of the +Department, who, with a similar contingent of officials, were to choose the +Deputies. Re-affirming the principle laid down in the Constitution of 1795 +and repeated in the Charta, Vaublanc proposed that a fifth part of the +Assembly should retire each year. + +[Counter-project of Villele.] + +If the Minister had intended to give the Ultra-Royalists the best possible +means of exalting the peculiar policy of their class into something like a +real defence of liberty, he could not have framed a more fitting measure. +The creation of constituent bodies out of mayors, crown-advocates, and +justices of the peace, was described, and with truth, as a mere Napoleonic +juggle. The limitation of the franchise to a fixed number of rich persons +was condemned as illiberal and contrary to the spirit of the Charta: the +system of yearly renovation by fifths, which threatened to curtail the +reign of the present majority, was attributed to the dread of any complete +expression of public opinion. It was evident that the Bill of the +Government would either be rejected or altered in such a manner as to give +it a totally different character. In the Committee of the Chamber which +undertook the task of drawing up amendments, the influence was first felt +of a man who was soon to become the chief and guiding spirit of the +Ultra-Royalist party. M. de Villele, spokesman of the Committee, had in his +youth been an officer in the navy of Louis XVI. On the dethronement of the +King he had quitted the service, and settled in the Isle of Bourbon, where +he gained some wealth and an acquaintance with details of business and +finance rare among the French landed gentry. Returning to France under the +Empire, he took up his abode near Toulouse, his native place, and was made +Mayor of that city on Napoleon's second downfall. Villele's politics gained +a strong and original colour from his personal experience and the character +of the province in which he lived. The south was the only part of France +known to him. There the reactionary movement of 1815 had been a really +popular one, and the chief difficulty of the Government, at the end of the +Hundred Days, had been to protect the Bonapartists from violence. Villele +believed that throughout France the wealthier men among the peasantry were +as ready to follow the priests and nobles as they were in Provence and La +Vendee. His conception of the government of the future was the rule of a +landed aristocracy, resting, in its struggle against monarchical +centralisation and against the Liberalism of the middle class, on the +conservative and religious instincts of the peasantry. Instead of excluding +popular forces, Villele welcomed them as allies. He proposed to lower the +franchise to one-sixth of the sum named in the Charta, and, while retaining +a system of double-election, to give a vote in the primary assemblies to +every Frenchman paying annual taxes to the amount of fifty francs. In +constituencies so large as to include all the more substantial peasantry, +while sufficiently limited to exclude the ill-paid populace in towns, +Villele believed that the Church and the noblesse would on the whole +control the elections. In the interest of the present majority he rejected +the system of renovation by fifths proposed by the Government, and demanded +that the present Chamber should continue unchanged until its dissolution, +and the succeeding Chamber be elected entire. + +[Result of debates on Electoral Bill.] + +Villele's scheme, if carried, would in all probability have failed at the +first trial. The districts in which the reaction of 1815 was popular were +not so large as he supposed: in the greater part of France the peasantry +would not have obeyed the nobles except under intimidation. This was +suspected by the majority, in spite of the confident language in which they +spoke of the will of the nation as identical with their own. Villele's +boldness alarmed them: they anticipated that these great constituencies of +peasants, if really left masters of the elections, would be more likely to +return a body of Jacobins and Bonapartists than one of hereditary +landlords. It was not necessary, however, to sacrifice the well-sounding +principle of a low franchise, for the democratic vote at the first stage of +the elections might effectively be neutralised by putting the second stage +into the hands of the chief proprietors. The Assembly had in fact only to +imitate the example of the Government, and to appoint a body of persons who +should vote, as of right, by the side of the electors chosen in the primary +assemblies. The Government in its own interest had designated a troop of +officials as electors: the Assembly, on the contrary, resolved that in the +Electoral College of each Department, numbering in all about 150 persons, +the fifty principal landowners of the Department should be entitled to +vote, whether they had been nominated by the primary constituencies or not. +Modified by this proviso, the project of Villele passed the Assembly. The +Government saw that under the disguise of a series of amendments a measure +directly antagonistic to their own had been carried. The franchise had been +altered; the real control of the elections placed in the hands of the very +party which was now in open opposition to the King and his Ministers. No +compromise was possible between the law proposed by the Government and that +passed by the Assembly. The Government appealed to the Chamber of Peers. +The Peers threw out the amendments of the Lower House. A provisional +measure was then introduced by Richelieu for the sake of providing France +with at least some temporary rule for the conduct of elections. It failed; +and the constitutional legislation of the country came to a dead-lock, +while the Government and the Assembly stood face to face, and it became +evident that one or the other must fall. The Ministers of the Great Powers +at Paris, who watched over the restored dynasty, debated whether or not +they should recommend the King to resort to the extreme measure of a +dissolution. + +[Contest on the Budget.] + +[The Chambers prorogued, April 29.] + +The Electoral Bill was not the only object of conflict between Richelieu's +Ministry and the Chamber, nor indeed the principal one. The Budget excited +fiercer passions, and raised greater issues. It was for no mere scheme of +finance that the Government had to fight, but against a violation of public +faith which would have left France insolvent and creditless in the face of +the Powers who still held its territory in pledge. The debt incurred by the +nation since 1813 was still unfunded. That part of it which had been raised +before the summer of 1814 had been secured by law upon the unsold forests +formerly belonging to the Church, and upon the Communal lands which +Napoleon had made the property of the State: the remainder, which included +the loans made during the Hundred Days, had no specified security. It was +now proposed by the Government to place the whole of the unfunded debt upon +the same level, and to provide for its payment by selling the so-called +Church forests. The project excited the bitterest opposition on the side of +the Count of Artois and his friends. If there was one object which the +clerical and reactionary party pursued with religious fervour, it was the +restoration of the Church lands: if there was one class which they had no +scruple in impoverishing, it was the class that had lent money to Napoleon. +Instead of paying the debts of the State, the Committee of the Chamber +proposed to repeal the law of September, 1814, which pledged the Church +forests, and to compel both the earlier and the later holders of the +unfunded debt to accept stock in satisfaction of their claims, though the +stock was worth less than two-thirds of its nominal value. The resolution +was in fact one for the repudiation of a third part of the unfunded debt. +Richelieu, seeing in what fashion his measure was about to be transformed, +determined upon withdrawing it altogether: the majority in the Chamber, +intent on executing its own policy and that of the Count of Artois, refused +to recognise the withdrawal. Such a step was at once an insult and a +usurpation of power. So great was the scandal and alarm caused by the +scenes in the Chamber, that the Duke of Wellington, at the instance of the +Ambassadors, presented a note to King Louis XVIII. requiring him in plain +terms to put a stop to the machinations of his brother. [274] The +interference of the foreigner provoked the Ultra-Royalists, and failed to +excite energetic action on the part of King Louis, who dreaded the sour +countenance of the Duchess of Angouleme more than he did Wellington's +reproofs. In the end the question of a settlement of the unfunded debt was +allowed to remain open. The Government was unable to carry the sale of the +Church forests, the Chamber did not succeed in its project of confiscation. +The Budget for the year, greatly altered in the interest of the landed +proprietors, was at length brought into shape. A resolution of the Lower +House restoring the unsold forests to the Church was ignored by the Crown; +and the Government, having obtained the means of carrying on the public +services, gladly abstained from further legislation, and on the 29th of +April ended the turmoil which surrounded it by proroguing the Chambers. + +[Rising at Grenoble, May 6th. Executions.] + +It was hoped that with the close of the Session the system of imprisonment +and surveillance which prevailed in the Departments would be brought to an +end. Vaublanc, the Minister of coercion, was removed from office. But the +troubles of France were not yet over. On the 6th of May, a rising of +peasants took place at Grenoble. According to the report of General +Donnadieu, commander of the garrison, which brought the news to the +Government, the revolt had only been put down after the most desperate +fighting. "The corpses of the King's enemies," said the General in his +despatch, "cover all the roads for a league round Grenoble." [275] It was +soon known that twenty-four prisoners had been condemned to death by +court-martial, and sixteen of these actually executed: the court-martial +recommended the other eight to the clemency of the Government. But the +despatches of Donnadieu had thrown the Cabinet into a panic. Decazes, the +most liberal of the Ministers, himself signed the hasty order requiring the +remaining prisoners to be put to death. They perished; and when it was too +late the Government learnt that Donnadieu's narrative was a mass of the +grossest exaggerations, and that the affair which he had represented as an +insurrection of the whole Department was conducted by about 300 peasants, +half of whom were unarmed. The violence and illegality with which the +General proceeded to establish a regime of military law soon brought him +into collision with the Government. He became the hero of the +Ultra-Royalists; but the Ministry, which was unwilling to make a public +confession that it had needlessly put eight persons to death, had to bear +the odium of an act of cruelty for which Donnadieu was really responsible. +The part into which Decazes had been entrapped probably strengthened the +determination of this Minister, who was now gaining great influence over +the King, to strike with energy against the Ultra-Royalist faction. From +this time he steadily led the King towards the only measure which could +free the country from the rule of the Count of Artois and the +reactionists--the dissolution of Parliament. + +[Decazes.] + +[Dissolution of the Chamber, Sept. 5, 1816.] + +Louis XVIII. depended much on the society of some personal favourite. +Decazes was young and an agreeable companion; his business as +Police-Minister gave him the opportunity of amusing the King with anecdotes +and gossip much more congenial to the old man's taste than discussions on +finance or constitutional law. Louis came to regard Decazes almost as a +son, and gratified his own studious inclination by teaching him English. +The Minister's enemies said that he won the King's heart by taking private +lessons from some obscure Briton, and attributing his extraordinary +progress to the skill of his royal master. But Decazes had a more effective +retort than witticism. He opened the letters of the Ultra-Royalists and +laid them before the King. Louis found that these loyal subjects jested +upon his infirmities, called him a dupe in the hands of Jacobins, and +grumbled at him for so long delaying the happy hour when Artois should +ascend the throne. Humorous as Louis was, he was not altogether pleased to +read that he "ought either to open his eyes or to close them for ever." At +the same time the reports of Decazes' local agents proved that the +Ultra-Royalist party were in reality weak in numbers and unpopular +throughout the greater part of the country. The project of a dissolution +was laid before the Ministers and some of the King's confidants. Though the +Ambassadors were not consulted on the measure, it was certain that they +would not resist it. No word of the Ministerial plot reached the rival camp +of Artois. The King gained courage, and on the 5th of September signed the +Ordonnance which appealed from the Parliament to the nation, and, to the +anger and consternation of the Ultra-Royalists, made an end of the +intractable Chamber a few weeks before the time which had been fixed for +its re-assembling. + +[Electoral law, 1817.] + +France was well rid of a body of men who had been elected at a moment of +despair, and who would either have prolonged the occupation of the country +by foreign armies, or have plunged the nation into civil war. The elections +which followed were favourable to the Government. The questions fruitlessly +agitated in the Assembly of 1815 were settled to the satisfaction of the +public in the new Parliament. An electoral law was passed, which, while it +retained the high franchise fixed by the Charta, and the rule of renewing +the Chamber by fifths, gave life and value to the representative system by +making the elections direct. Though the constituent body of all France +scarcely numbered under this arrangement a hundred thousand persons, it was +extensive enough to contain a majority hostile to the reactionary policy of +the Church and the noblesse. The men who had made wealth by banking, +commerce, or manufactures, the so-called higher bourgeoisie, greatly +exceeded in number the larger landed proprietors; and although they were +not usually democratic in their opinions, they were liberal, and keenly +attached to the modern as against the old institutions of France, inasmuch +as their industrial interests and their own personal importance depended +upon the maintenance of the victory won in 1789 against aristocratic +privilege and monopoly. So strong was the hostility between the civic +middle class and the landed noblesse, that the Ultra-Royalists in the +Chamber sought, as they had done in the year before, to extend the +franchise to the peasantry, in the hope of overpowering wealth with +numbers. The electoral law, however, passed both Houses in the form in +which it had been drawn up by the Government. Though deemed narrow and +oligarchical by the next generation, it was considered, and with justice, +as a great victory won by liberalism at the time. The middle class of Great +Britain had to wait for fifteen years before it obtained anything like the +weight in the representation given to the middle class of France by the law +of 1817. + +[Establishment of financial credit.] + +Not many of the persons who had been imprisoned under the provisional acts +of the last year now remained in confinement. It was considered necessary +to prolong the Laws of Public Security, and they were re-enacted, but under +a much softened form. It remained for the new Chamber to restore the +financial credit of the country by making some equitable arrangement for +securing the capital and paying the interest of the unfunded debt. Projects +of repudiation now gained no hearing. Richelieu consented to make an annual +allowance to the Church, equivalent to the rental of the Church forests; +but the forests themselves were made security for the debt, and the power +of sale was granted to the Government. Pending such repayment of the +capital, the holders of unfunded debt received stock, calculated at its +real, not at its titular, value. The effect of this measure was at once +evident. The Government was enabled to enter into negotiations for a loan, +which promised it the means of paying the indemnities due to the foreign +Powers. On this payment depended the possibility of withdrawing the army of +occupation. Though Wellington at first offered some resistance, thirty +thousand men were removed in the spring of 1817; and the Czar allowed +Richelieu to hope that, if no further difficulties should arise, the +complete evacuation of French territory might take place in the following +year. + +[Character of the years 1816-18.] + +Thus the dangers with which reactionary passion had threatened France +appeared to be passing away. The partial renovation of the Chamber which +took place in the autumn of 1817 still further strengthened the Ministry of +Richelieu and weakened the Ultra-Royalist opposition. A few more months +passed, and before the third anniversary of Waterloo, the Czar was ready to +advise the entire withdrawal of foreign armies from France. An invitation +was issued to the Powers to meet in Conference at Aix-la-Chapelle. There +was no longer any doubt that the five years' occupation, contemplated when +the second Treaty of Paris was made, would be abandoned. The good will of +Alexander, the friendliness of his Ambassador, Pozzo di Borgo, who, as a +native of Corsica, had himself been a French subject, and who now aspired +to become Minister of France, were powerful influences in favour of Louis +XVIII. and his kingdom; much, however, of the speedy restoration of +confidence was due to the temperate rule of Richelieu. The nation itself, +far from suffering from Napoleon's fall, regained something of the +spontaneous energy so rich in 1789, so wanting at a later period. The cloud +of military disaster lifted; new mental and political life began; and under +the dynasty forced back by foreign arms France awoke to an activity unknown +to it while its chief gave laws to Europe. Parliamentary debate offered the +means of legal opposition to those who bore no friendship to the Court: +conspiracy, though it alarmed at the moment, had become the resort only of +the obscure and the powerless. Groups of able men were gathering around +recognised leaders, or uniting in defence of a common political creed. The +Press, dumb under Napoleon except for purposes of sycophancy, gradually +became a power in the land. Even the dishonest eloquence of Chateaubriand, +enforcing the principles of legal and constitutional liberty on behalf of a +party which would fain have used every weapon of despotism in its own +interest, proved that the leaden weight that had so long crushed thought +and expression existed no more. + +[Prussia after 1815.] + +[Edict promising a Constitution, May 22, 1815.] + +But if the years between 1815 and 1819 were in France years of hope and +progress, it was not so with Europe generally. In England they were years +of almost unparalleled suffering and discontent; in Italy the rule of +Austria grew more and more anti-national; in Prussia, though a vigorous +local and financial administration hastened the recovery of the +impoverished land, the hopes of liberty declined beneath the reviving +energy of the nobles and the resistance of the friends of absolutism. When +Stein had summoned the Prussian people to take up arms for their +Fatherland, he had believed that neither Frederick William nor Alexander +would allow Prussia to remain without free institutions after the battle +was won. The keener spirits in the War of Liberation had scarcely +distinguished between the cause of national independence and that of +internal liberty. They returned from the battlefields of Saxony and France, +knowing that the Prussian nation had unsparingly offered up life and wealth +at the call of patriotism, and believing that a patriot-king would rejoice +to crown his triumph by inaugurating German freedom. For a while the hope +seemed near fulfilment. On the 22nd of May, 1815, Frederick William +published an ordinance, declaring that a Representation of the People +should be established. [276] For this end the King stated that the existing +Provincial Estates should be re-organised, and new ones founded where none +existed, and that out of the Provincial Estates the Assembly of +Representatives of the country should be chosen. It was added that a +commission would be appointed, to organise under Hardenberg's presidency +the system of representation, and to draw up a written Constitution. The +right of discussing all legislative measures affecting person or property +was promised to the Assembly. Though foreign affairs seemed to be directly +excluded from parliamentary debate, and the language of the Edict suggested +that the representative body would only have a consultative voice, without +the power either of originating or of rejecting laws, these reservations +only showed the caution natural on the part of a Government divesting +itself for the first time of absolute power. Guarded as it was, the scheme +laid down by the King would hardly have displeased the men who had done the +most to make constitutional rule in Prussia possible. + +[Resistance of feudal and autocratic parties.] + +But the promise of Frederick William was destined to remain unfulfilled. It +was no good omen for Prussia that Stein, who had rendered such glorious +services to his country and to all Europe, was suffered to retire from +public life. The old court-party at Berlin, politicians who had been forced +to make way for more popular men, landowners who had never pardoned the +liberation of the serf, all the interests of absolutism and class-privilege +which had disappeared for a moment in the great struggle for national +existence, gradually re-asserted their influence over the King, and +undermined the authority of Hardenberg, himself sinking into old age amid +circumstances of private life that left to old age little of its honour. To +decide even in principle upon the basis to be given to the new Prussian +Constitution would have taxed all the foresight and all the constructive +skill of the most experienced statesman; for by the side of the ancient +dominion of the Hohenzollerns there were now the Rhenish and the Saxon +Provinces, alien in spirit and of doubtful loyalty, in addition to Polish +territory and smaller German districts acquired at intervals between 1792 +and 1815. Hardenberg was right in endeavouring to link the Constitution +with something that had come down from the past; but the decision that the +General Assembly should be formed out of the Provincial Estates was +probably an injudicious one; for these Estates, in their present form, were +mainly corporations of nobles, and the spirit which animated them was at +once the spirit of class-privilege and of an intensely strong localism. +Hardenberg had not only occasioned an unnecessary delay by basing the +representative system upon a reform of the Provincial Estates, but had +exposed himself to sharp attacks from these very bodies, to whom nothing +was more odious than the absorption of their own dignity by a General +Assembly. It became evident that the process of forming a Constitution +would be a tedious one; and in the meantime the opponents of the popular +movement opened their attack upon the men and the ideas whose influence in +the war of Liberation appeared to have made so great a break between the +German present and the past. + +[Schmalz's pamphlet, 1815.] + +The first public utterance of the reaction was a pamphlet issued in July, +1815, by Schmalz, a jurist of some eminence, and brother-in-law of +Scharnhorst, the re-organiser of the army. Schmalz, contradicting a +statement which attributed to him a highly honourable part in the patriotic +movement of 1808, attacked the Tugendbund, and other political associations +dating from that epoch, in language of extreme violence. In the stiff and +peremptory manner of the old Prussian bureaucracy, he denied that popular +enthusiasm had anything whatever to do with the victory of 1813, [277] +attributing the recovery of the nation firstly to its submission to the +French alliance in 1812, and secondly to the quiet sense of duty with +which, when the time came, it took up arms in obedience to the King. Then, +passing on to the present aims of the political societies, he accused them +of intending to overthrow all established governments, and to force unity +upon Germany by means of revolution, murder, and pillage. Stein was not +mentioned by name, but the warning was given to men of eminence who +encouraged Jacobinical societies, that in such combinations the giants end +by serving the dwarfs. Schmalz's pamphlet, which was written with a +strength and terseness of style very unusual in Germany, made a deep +impression, and excited great indignation in Liberal circles. It was +answered, among other writers, by Niebuhr; and the controversy thickened +until King Frederick William, in the interest of public tranquillity, +ordered that no more should be said on either side. It was in accordance +with Prussian feeling that the King should thus interfere to stop the +quarrels of his subjects. There would have been nothing unseemly in an act +of impartial repression. But the King made it impossible to regard his act +as of this character. Without consulting Hardenberg, he conferred a +decoration upon the author of the controversy. Far-sighted men saw the true +bearing of the act. They warned Hardenberg that, if he passed over this +slight, he would soon have to pass over others more serious, and urged him +to insist upon the removal of the counsellors on whose advice the King had +acted. [278] But the Minister disliked painful measures. He probably +believed that no influence could ever supplant his own with the King, and +looked too lightly upon the growth of a body of opponents, who, whether in +open or in concealed hostility to himself, were bent upon hindering the +fulfilment of the constitutional reforms which he had at heart. + +[The promised Constitutions delayed in Germany.] + +In the Edict of the 22nd of May, 1815, the King had ordered that the work +of framing a Constitution should be begun in the following September. +Delays, however, arose; and when the commission was at length appointed, +its leading members were directed to travel over the country in order to +collect opinions upon the form of representation required. Two years passed +before even this preliminary operation began. In the meantime very little +progress had been made towards the establishment of constitutional +government in Germany at large. One prince alone, the Grand Duke of Weimar, +already eminent in Europe from his connection with Goethe and Schiller, +loyally accepted the idea of a free State, and brought representative +institutions into actual working. In Hesse, the Elector summoned the +Estates, only to dismiss them with contumely when they resisted his +extortions. In most of the minor States contests or negotiations took place +between the Sovereigns and the ancient Orders, which led to little or no +result. The Federal Diet, which ought to have applied itself to the +determination of certain principles of public right common to all Germany, +remained inactive. Though hope had not yet fallen, a sense of discontent +arose, especially among the literary class which had shown such enthusiasm +in the War of Liberation. It was characteristic of Germany that the demand +for free government came not from a group of soldiers, as in Spain, not +from merchants and men of business, as in England, but from professors and +students, and from journalists, who were but professors in another form. +The middle class generally were indifferent: the higher nobility, and the +knights who had lost their semi-independence in 1803, sought for the +restoration of privileges which were really incompatible with any +State-government whatever. The advocacy of constitutional rule and of +German unity was left, in default of Prussian initiative, to the ardent +spirits of the Universities and the Press, who naturally exhibited in the +treatment of political problems more fluency than knowledge, and more zeal +than discretion. Jena, in the dominion of the Duke of Weimar, became, on +account of the freedom of printing which existed there, the centre of the +new Liberal journalism. Its University took the lead in the Teutonising +movement which had been inaugurated by Fichte twelve years before in the +days of Germany's humiliation, and which had now received so vigorous an +impulse from the victory won over the foreigner. + +[The Wartburg Festival, Oct., 1817.] + +On the 18th of October, 1817, the students of Jena, with deputations from +all the Protestant Universities of Germany, held a festival at Eisenach, to +celebrate the double anniversary of the Reformation and of the battle of +Leipzig. Five hundred young patriots, among them scholars who had been +decorated for bravery at Waterloo, bound their brows with oak-leaves, and +assembled within the venerable hall of Luther's Wartburg Castle; sang, +prayed, preached, and were preached to; dined; drank to German liberty, the +jewel of life, to Dr. Martin Luther, the man of God, and to the Grand Duke +of Saxe-Weimar; then descended to Eisenach, fraternised with the Landsturm +in the market-place, and attended divine service in the parish church +without mishap. In the evening they edified the townspeople with +gymnastics, which were now the recognised symbol of German vigour, and +lighted a great bonfire on the hill opposite the castle. Throughout the +official part of the ceremony a reverential spirit prevailed; a few rash +words were, however, uttered against promise-breaking kings, and some of +the hardier spirits took advantage of the bonfire to consign to the flames, +in imitation of Luther's dealing with the Pope's Bull, a quantity of what +they deemed un-German and illiberal writings. Among these was Schmalz's +pamphlet. They also burnt a soldier's strait-jacket, a pigtail, and a +corporal's cane, emblems of the military brutalism of past times which were +now being revived in Westphalia. [279] Insignificant as the whole affair +was, it excited a singular alarm not only in Germany but at foreign Courts. +Richelieu wrote from Paris to inquire whether revolution was breaking out. +The King of Prussia sent Hardenberg to Weimar to make investigations on the +spot. Metternich, who saw conspiracy and revolution everywhere and in +everything, congratulated himself that his less sagacious neighbours were +at length awakening to their danger. The first result of the Wartburg +scandal was that the Duke of Weimar had to curtail the liberties of his +subjects. Its further effects became only too evident as time went on. It +left behind it throughout Germany the impression that there were forces of +disorder at work in the Press and in the Universities which must be crushed +at all cost by the firm hand of Government; and it deepened the anxiety +with which King Frederick William was already regarding the promises of +liberty which he had made to the Prussian people two years before. + +[Alexander in 1818.] + +Twelve months passed between the Wartburg festival and the beginning of the +Conferences at Aix-la-Chapelle. In the interval a more important person +than the King of Prussia went over to the side of reaction. Up to the +summer of 1818, the Czar appeared to have abated nothing of his zeal for +constitutional government. In the spring of that year, he summoned the +Polish Diet; addressed them in a speech so enthusiastic as to alarm not +only the Court of Vienna but all his own counsellors; and stated in the +clearest possible language his intention of extending the benefits of a +representative system to the whole Russian Empire. [280] At the close of +the brief session he thanked the Polish Deputies for their boldness in +throwing out a measure proposed by himself. Alexander's popular rhetoric at +Warsaw might perhaps be not incompatible with a settled purpose to permit +no encroachment on authority either there or elsewhere; but the change in +his tone was so great when he appeared at Aix-la-Chapelle a few months +afterwards, that some strange and sudden cause has been thought necessary +to explain it. It is said that during the Czar's residence at Moscow, in +June, 1818, the revelation was made to him of the existence of a mass of +secret societies in the army, whose aim was the overthrow of his own +Government. Alexander's father had died by the hands of murderers: his own +temperament, sanguine and emotional, would make the effects of such a +discovery, in the midst of all his benevolent hopes for Russia, poignant to +the last degree. It is not inconsistent either with his character or with +earlier events in his personal history that the Czar should have yielded to +a single shock of feeling, and have changed in a moment from the liberator +to the despot. But the evidence of what passed in his mind is wanting. +Hearsay, conjecture, gossip, abound; [281] the one man who could have told +all has left no word. This only is certain, that from the close of the year +1818, the future, hitherto bright with dreams of peaceful progress, became +in Alexander's view a battle-field between the forces of order and anarchy. +The task imposed by Providence on himself and other kings was no longer to +spread knowledge and liberty among mankind, but to defend existing +authority, and even authority that was oppressive and un-Christian, against +the madness that was known as popular right. + +[Conferences of Aix-la-Chapelle, Oct., 1818.] + +[France evacuated.] + +[Proposed Quintuple Alliance.] + +[Canning.] + +At the end of September, 1818, the Sovereigns or Ministers of the Great +Powers assembled at Aix-la-Chapelle, and the Conferences began. The first +question to be decided was whether the Allied Army might safely be +withdrawn from France; the second, in what form the concert of Europe +should hereafter be maintained. On the first question there was no +disagreement: the evacuation of France was resolved upon and promptly +executed. The second question was a more difficult one. Richelieu, on +behalf of King Louis XVIII., represented that France now stood on the same +footing as any other European Power, and proposed that the Quadruple +Alliance of 1815 should be converted into a genuine European federation by +adding France to it as a fifth member. The plan had been communicated to +the English Government, and would probably have received its assent but for +the strong opposition raised by Canning within the Cabinet. Canning took a +gloomy but a true view of the proposed concert of the Powers. He foresaw +that it would really amount to a combination of governments against +liberty. Therefore, while recognising the existing engagements of this +country, he urged that England ought to join in no combination except that +to which it had already pledged itself, namely, the combination made with +the definite object of resisting French disturbance. To combine with three +Powers to prevent Napoleon or the Jacobins from again becoming masters of +France was a reasonable act of policy: to combine with all the Great Powers +of Europe against nothing in particular was to place the country on the +side of governments against peoples, and to involve England in any +enterprise of repression which the Courts might think fit to undertake. +Canning's warning opened the eyes of his colleagues to the view which was +likely to be taken of such a general alliance by Parliament and by public +opinion. Lord Castlereagh was forbidden to make this country a party to any +abstract union of Governments. In memorable words the Prime Minister +described the true grounds for the decision: "We must recollect in the +whole of this business, and ought to make our Allies feel, that the general +and European discussion of these questions will be in the British +Parliament." [282] Fear of the rising voice of the nation, no longer forced +by military necessities to sanction every measure of its rulers, compelled +Lords Liverpool and Castlereagh to take account of scruples which were not +their own. On the same grounds, while the Ministry agreed that Continental +difficulties which might hereafter arise ought to be settled by a friendly +discussion among the Great Powers, it declined to elevate this occasional +deliberation into a system, and to assent to the periodical meeting of a +Congress. Peace might or might not be promoted by the frequent gatherings +of Sovereigns and statesmen; but a council so formed, if permanent in its +nature, would necessarily extinguish the independence of every minor State, +and hand over the government of all Europe to the Great Courts, if only +they could agree with one another. + +[Declarations and Secret Treaty of Aix-la-Chapelle.] + +It was the refusal of England to enter into a general league that +determined the form in which the results of the Conference of 1818 were +embodied. In the first place the Quadruple Alliance against French +revolution was renewed, and with such seriousness that the military centres +were fixed, at which, in case of any outbreak, the troops of each of the +Great Powers should assemble. [283] This Treaty, however, was kept secret, +in order not to add to the difficulties of Richelieu. The published +documents breathed another spirit. [284] Without announcing an actual +alliance with King Louis XVIII., the Courts, including England, declared +that through the restoration of legitimate and constitutional monarchy +France had regained its place in the councils of Europe, and that it would +hereafter co-operate in maintaining the general peace. For this end +meetings of the sovereigns or their ministers might be necessary; such +meetings would, however, be arranged by the ordinary modes of negotiation, +nor would the affairs of any minor State be discussed by the Great Powers, +except at the direct invitation of that State, whose representatives would +then be admitted to the sittings. In these guarded words the intention of +forming a permanent and organised Court of Control over Europe was +disclaimed. A manifesto, addressed to the world at large, declared that the +sovereigns of the five great States had no other object in their union than +the maintenance of peace on the basis of existing treaties. They had formed +no new political combinations; their rule was the observance of +international law; their object the prosperity and moral welfare of their +subjects. + +[Repressive tone of the Conference.] + +[Metternich and Austrian principles henceforth dominant.] + +The earnestness with which the statesmen of 1818, while accepting the +conditions laid down by England, persevered in the project of a joint +regulation of European affairs may suggest the question whether the plan +which they had at heart would not in truth have operated to the benefit of +mankind. The answer is, that the value of any International Council depends +firstly on the intelligence which it is likely to possess, and secondly on +the degree in which it is really representative. Experience proved that the +Congresses which followed 1818 possessed but a limited intelligence, and +that they represented nothing at all but authority. The meeting at +Aix-la-Chapelle was itself the turning-point in the constitutional history +of Europe. Though no open declaration was made against constitutional +forms, every Sovereign and every minister who attended the Conference left +it with the resolution to draw the reins of government tighter. A note of +alarm had been sounded. Conspiracies in Belgium, an attempt on the life of +Wellington, rumours of a plot to rescue Napoleon from St. Helena, combined +with the outcry against the German Universities and the whispered tales +from Moscow in filling the minds of statesmen with apprehensions. The +change which had taken place in Alexander himself was of the most serious +moment. Up to this time Metternich, the leader of European Conservatism, +had felt that in the Czar there were sympathies with Liberalism and +enlightenment which made the future of Europe doubtful. [285] To check the +dissolution of existing power, to suppress all tendency to change, was the +habitual object of Austria, and the Czar was the one person who had seemed +likely to prevent the principles of Austria from becoming the law of +Europe. Elsewhere Metternich had little to fear in the way of opposition. +Hardenberg, broken in health and ill-supported by his King, had ceased to +be a power. Yielding to the apprehensions of Frederick William, perhaps +with the hope of dispelling them at some future time, he took his place +among the alarmists of the day, and suffered the German policy of Prussia, +to which so great a future lay open a few years before, to become the mere +reflex of Austrian inaction and repression. [286] England, so long as it +was represented on the Continent by Castlereagh and Wellington, scarcely +counted for anything on the side of liberty. The sudden change in Alexander +removed the one check that stood in Austria's way; and from this time +Metternich exercised an authority in Europe such as few statesmen have ever +possessed. His influence, overborne by that of the Czar during 1814 and +1815, struck root at the Conference of Aix-la-Chapelle, maintained itself +unimpaired during five eventful years, and sank only when the death of Lord +Castlereagh allowed the real voice of England once more to be heard, and +Canning, too late to forbid the work of repression in Italy and in Spain, +inaugurated, after an interval of forced neutrality, that worthier concert +which established the independence of Greece. + +[Metternich's advice to Prussia, 1818.] + +If it is the mark of a clever statesman to know where to press and where to +give way, Metternich certainly proved himself one in 1818. Before the end +of the Conference he delivered to Hardenberg and to the King of Prussia two +papers containing a complete set of recommendations for the management of +Prussian affairs. The contents of these documents were singular enough: it +is still more singular that they form the history of what actually took +place in Prussia during the succeeding years. Starting with the assumption +that the party of revolution had found its lever in the promise of King +Frederick William to create a Representative System, Metternich +demonstrated in polite language to the very men who had made this promise, +that any central Representation would inevitably overthrow the Prussian +State; pointed out that the King's dominions consisted of seven Provinces; +and recommended Frederick William to fulfil his promise only by giving to +each Province a Diet for the discussion of its own local concerns. Having +thus warned the King against creating a National Parliament, like that +which had thrown France into revolution in 1789, Metternich exhibited the +specific dangers of the moment and the means of overcoming them. These +dangers were Universities, Gymnastic establishments, and the Press. "The +revolutionists," he said, "despairing of effecting their aim themselves, +have formed the settled plan of educating the next generation for +revolution. The Gymnastic establishment is a preparatory school for +University disorders. The University seizes the youth as he leaves boyhood, +and gives him a revolutionary training. This mischief is common to all +Germany, and must be checked by joint action of the Governments. Gymnasia, +on the contrary, were invented at Berlin, and spring from Berlin. For +these, palliative measures are no longer sufficient. It has become a duty +of State for the King of Prussia to destroy the evil. The whole institution +in every shape must be closed and uprooted." With regard to the abuse of +the Press, Metternich contented himself with saying that a difference ought +to be made between substantial books and mere pamphlets or journals; and +that the regulation of the Press throughout Germany at large could only be +effected by an agreement between Austria and Prussia. [287] + +[Stourdza's pamphlet.] + +With a million men under arms, the Sovereigns who had overthrown Napoleon +trembled because thirty or forty journalists and professors pitched their +rhetoric rather too high, and because wise heads did not grow upon +schoolboys' shoulders. The Emperor Francis, whose imagination had failed to +rise to the glories of the Holy Alliance, alone seems to have had some +suspicion of the absurdity of the present alarms. [288] The Czar +distinguished himself by his zeal against the lecturers who were turning +the world upside down. As if Metternich had not frightened the Congress +enough already, the Czar distributed at Aix-la-Chapelle a pamphlet +published by one Stourdza, a Moldavian, which described Germany as on the +brink of revolution, and enumerated half a score of mortal disorders which +racked that unfortunate country. The chief of all was the vicious system of +the Universities, which instead of duly developing the vessel of the +Christian State from the cradle of Moses, [289] brought up young men to be +despisers of law and instruments of a licentious Press. The ingenious +Moldavian, whose expressions in some places bear a singular resemblance to +those of Alexander, while in others they are actually identical with +reflections of Metternich's not then published, went on to enlighten the +German Governments as to the best means of rescuing their subjects from +their perilous condition. Certain fiscal and administrative changes were +briefly suggested, but the main reform urged was exactly that propounded by +Metternich, the enforcement of a better discipline and of a more +rigidly-prescribed course of study at the Universities, along with the +supervision of all journals and periodical literature. + +[The murder of Kotzebue, March 23, 1819.] + +Stourdza's pamphlet, in which loose reasoning was accompanied by the +coarsest invective, would have gained little attention if it had depended +on its own merits or on the reputation of its author: it became a different +matter when it was known to represent the views of the Czar. A vehement but +natural outcry arose at the Universities against this interference of the +foreigner with German domestic affairs. National independence, it seemed, +had been won in the deadly struggle against France only in order that +internal liberty, the promised fruit of this independence, should be +sacrificed at the bidding of Russia. The Czar himself was out of reach: the +vengeance of outraged patriotism fell upon an insignificant person who had +the misfortune to be regarded as his principal agent. A dramatic author +then famous, now forgotten, August Kotzebue, held the office of Russian +agent in Central Germany, and conducted a newspaper whose object was to +throw ridicule on the national movement of the day, and especially on those +associations of students where German enthusiasm reached its climax. Many +circumstances embittered popular feeling against this man, and caused him +to be regarded less as a legitimate enemy than as a traitor and an +apostate. Kotzebue had himself been a student at Jena, and at one time had +turned liberal sentiments to practical account in his plays. Literary +jealousies and wounded vanity had subsequently alienated him from his +country, and made him the willing and acrid hireling of a foreign Court. +The reports which, as Russian agent, he sent to St. Petersburg were +doubtless as offensive as the attacks on the Universities which he +published in his journal; but it was an extravagant compliment to the man +to imagine that he was the real author of the Czar's desertion from +Liberalism to reaction. This, however, was the common belief, and it cost +Kotzebue dear. A student from Erlangen, Carl Sand, who had accompanied the +standard at the Wartburg festival, formed the silent resolve of sacrificing +his own life in order to punish the enemy of his country. Sand was a man of +pure and devout, though ill-balanced character. His earlier life marked him +as one whose whole being was absorbed by what he considered a divine call. +He thought of the Greeks who, even in their fallen estate, had so often +died to free their country from Turkish oppression, and formed the +deplorable conclusion that by murdering a decayed dramatist he could strike +some great blow against the powers of evil. [290] He sought the unfortunate +Kotzebue in the midst of his family, stabbed him to the heart, and then +turned his weapon against himself. Recovering from his wounds, he was +condemned to death, and perished, after a year's interval, on the scaffold, +calling God to witness that he died for Germany to be free. + +[Action of Metternich.] + +The effects of Sand's act were very great, and their real nature was at +once recognised. Hardenberg, the moment that he heard of Kotzebue's death, +exclaimed that a Prussian Constitution had now become impossible. +Metternich, who had thought the Czar mad because he desired to found a +peaceful alliance of Sovereigns on religious principles, was not likely to +make allowance for a kind of piety that sent young rebels over the country +on missions of murder. The Austrian statesman was in Rome when the news of +Kotzebue's assassination reached him. He saw that the time had come for +united action throughout Germany, and, without making any public utterance, +drew up a scheme of repressive measures, and sent out proposals for a +gathering of the Ministers of all the principal German Courts. In the +summer he travelled slowly northwards, met the King of Prussia at Teplitz, +in Bohemia, and shortly afterwards opened the intended Conference of +Ministers in the neighbouring town of Carlsbad. A number of innocent +persons had already, at his instigation, been arrested in Prussia and other +States, under circumstances deeply discreditable to Government. Private +papers were seized, and garbled extracts from them published in official +prints as proof of guilt. [291] "By the help of God," Metternich wrote, "I +hope to defeat the German Revolution, just as I vanquished the conqueror of +the world. The revolutionists thought me far away, because I was five +hundred leagues off. They deceived themselves; I have been in the midst of +them, and now I am striking my blows." [292] Metternich's plan was to +enforce throughout Germany, by means of legislation in the Federal Diet, +the principle which he had already privately commended to the King of +Prussia. There were two distinct objects of policy before him: the first, +to prevent the formation in any German State of an assembly representing +the whole community, like the English House of Commons or the French +Chamber of Deputies; the second, to establish a general system of +censorship over the Press and over the Universities, and to create a +central authority, vested, as the representative of the Diet, with +inquisitorial powers. + +[The South-Western States become constitutional as Prussia relapses.] + +[Bavarian Constitution, May 26, 1818.] + +The first of these objects, the prevention of general assemblies, had been +rendered more difficult by recent acts of the Governments of Bavaria and +Baden. A singular change had taken place in the relation between Prussia +and the Minor States which had formerly constituted the Federation of the +Rhine. When, at the Congress of Vienna, Prussian statesmen had endeavoured +to limit the arbitrary rule of petty sovereigns by charging the Diet with +the protection of constitutional right over all Germany, the Kings of +Bavaria and Wuertemberg had stoutly refused to part with sovereign power. To +submit to a law of liberty, as it then seemed, was to lose their own +separate existence, and to reduce themselves to dependence upon the +Jacobins of Berlin. This apprehension governed the policy of the Minor +Courts from 1813 to 1815. But since that time events had taken an +unexpected turn. Prussia, which once threatened to excite popular movement +over all Germany in its own interest, had now accepted Metternich's +guidance, and made its representative in the Diet the mouthpiece of +Austrian interest and policy. It was no longer from Berlin but from Vienna +that the separate existence of the Minor States was threatened. The two +great Courts were uniting against the independence of their weaker +neighbours. The danger of any popular invasion of kingly rights in the name +of German unity had passed away, and the safety of the lesser sovereigns +seemed now to lie not in resisting the spirit of constitutional reform but +in appealing to it. In proportion as Prussia abandoned itself to +Metternich's direction, the Governments of the South-Western States +familiarised themselves with the idea of a popular representation; and at +the very time when the conservative programme was being drawn up for the +Congress of Aix-la-Chapelle, the King of Bavaria published a Constitution. +Baden followed after a short interval, and in each of these States, +although the Legislature was divided into two Chambers, the representation +established was not merely provincial, according to Metternich's plan, or +wholly on the principle of separate Estates or Orders, as before the +Revolution, but to some extent on the type of England and France, where the +Lower Chamber, in theory, represented the public at large. This was enough +to make Metternich condemn the new Constitutions as radically bad and +revolutionary. [293] He was, however, conscious of the difficulty of making +a direct attack upon them. This task he reserved for a later time. His +policy at present was to obtain a declaration from the Diet which should +prevent any other Government within the League from following in the same +path; while, by means of Press-laws, supervision of the Universities, and a +central commission of inquiry, he expected to make the position of +rebellious professors and agitators so desperate that the forces of +disorder, themselves not deeply rooted in German nature, would presently +disappear. + +[Conference of Carlsbad, Aug., 1819.] + +The Conference of Ministers at Carlsbad, which in the memory of the German +people is justly associated with the suppression of their liberty for an +entire generation, began and ended in the month of August, 1819. Though +attended by the representatives of eight German Governments, it did little +more than register the conclusions which Metternich had already formed. +[294] The zeal with which the envoy of Prussia supported every repressive +measure made it useless for the Ministers of the Minor Courts to offer an +open opposition. Nothing more was required than that the Diet should +formally sanction the propositions thus privately accepted by all the +leading Ministers. On the 20th of September this sanction was given. The +Diet, which had sat for three years without framing a single useful law, +ratified all Metternich's oppressive enactments in as many hours. It was +ordered that in every State within the Federation the Government should +take measures for preventing the publication of any journal or pamphlet +except after licence given, and each Government was declared responsible to +the Federation at large for any objectionable writing published within its +own territory. The Sovereigns were required to appoint civil commissioners +at the Universities, whose duty it should be to enforce public order and to +give a salutary direction to the teaching of the professors. They were also +required to dismiss all professors who should overstep the bounds of their +duty, and such dismissed persons were prohibited from being employed in any +other State. It was enacted that within fifteen days of the passing of the +decree an extraordinary Commission should assemble at Mainz to investigate +the origin and extent of the secret revolutionary societies which +threatened the safety of the Federation. The Commission was empowered to +examine and, if necessary, to arrest any subject of any German State. All +law-courts and other authorities were required to furnish it with +information and with documents, and to undertake all inquiries which the +Commission might order. The Commission, however, was not a law-court +itself: its duty was to report to the Diet, which would then create such +judicial machinery as might be necessary. [295] + +[Supplementary Act of Vienna, June, 1820.] + +These measures were of an exceptional, and purported to be of a temporary, +character. There were, however, other articles which Metternich intended to +raise to the rank of organic laws, and to incorporate with the Act of 1815, +which formed the basis of the German Federation. The conferences of +Ministers were accordingly resumed after a short interval, but at Vienna +instead of at Carlsbad. They lasted for several months, a stronger +opposition being now made by the Minor States than before. A second body of +federal law was at length drawn up, and accepted by the Diet on the 8th of +June, 1820. [296] The most important of its provisions was that which +related to the Constitutions admissible within the German League. It was +declared that in every State, with the exception of the four free cities, +supreme power resided in the Sovereign and in him alone, and that no +Constitution might do more than bind the Sovereign to co-operate with the +Estates in certain definite acts of government. [297] + +In cases where a Government either appealed for help against rebellious +subjects, or was notoriously unable to exert authority, the Diet charged +itself with the duty of maintaining public order. + +[The reaction in Prussia.] + +From this time whatever liberty existed in Germany was to be found in the +Minor States, in Bavaria and Baden, and in Wuertemberg, which received a +Constitution a few days before the enrolment of the decrees of Carlsbad. In +Prussia the reaction carried everything before it. Humboldt, the best and +most liberal of the Ministers, resigned, protesting in vain against the +ignominious part which the King had determined to play. He was followed by +those of his colleagues whose principles were dearer to them than their +places. Hardenberg remained in office, a dying man, isolated, neglected, +thwarted; clinging to some last hope of redeeming his promises to the +Prussian people, yet jealous of all who could have given him true aid; +dishonouring by tenacity of place a career associated with so much of his +country's glory, and ennobled in earlier days by so much fortitude in time +of evil. There gathered around the King a body of men who could see in the +great patriotic efforts and reforms of the last decade nothing but an +encroachment of demagogues on the rights of power. They were willing that +Prussia should receive its orders from Metternich and serve a foreign Court +in the work of repression, rather than that it should take its place at the +head of all Germany on the condition of becoming a free and constitutional +State. [298] The stigma of disloyalty was attached to all who had kindled +popular enthusiasm in 1808 and 1812. To have served the nation was to have +sinned against the Government. Stein was protected by his great name from +attack, but not from calumny. His friend Arndt, whose songs and addresses +had so powerfully moved the heart of Germany during the War of Liberation, +was subjected to repeated legal process, and, although unconvicted of any +offence, was suspended from the exercise of his professorship for twenty +years. Other persons, whose fault at the most was to have worked for German +unity, were brought before special tribunals, and after long trial either +refused a public acquittal or sentenced to actual imprisonment. Free +teaching, free discussion, ceased. The barrier of authority closed every +avenue of political thought. Everywhere the agent of the State prescribed +an orthodox opinion, and took note of those who raised a dissentient voice. + +[The Commission at Mainz.] + +The pretext made at Carlsbad for this crusade against liberty, which was +more energetically carried out in Prussia than elsewhere, was the existence +of a conspiracy or agitation for the overthrow of Governments and of the +present constitution of the German League. It was stated that proofs +existed of the intention to establish by force a Republic one and +indivisible, like that of France in 1793. But the very Commission which was +instituted by the Carlsbad Ministers to investigate the origin and nature +of this conspiracy disproved its existence. The Commission assembled at +Mainz, examined several hundred persons and many thousand documents, and +after two years' labour delivered a report to the Diet. The report went +back to the time of Fichte's lectures and the formation of the Tugendbund +in 1808, traced the progress of all the students' associations and other +patriotic societies from that time to 1820; and, while exhibiting in the +worst possible light the aims and conduct of the advocates of German unity, +acknowledged that scarcely a single proof had been discovered of +treasonable practice, and that the loyalty of the mass of the people was +itself a sufficient guarantee against the impulses of the evil-minded. +[299] Such was the impression of triviality and imposture produced at the +Diet by this report, that the representatives of several States proposed +that the Commission should forthwith be dissolved as useless and +unnecessary. This, however, could not be tolerated by Metternich and his +new disciples. The Commission was allowed to continue in existence, and +with it the regime of silence and repression. The measures which had been +accepted at Carlsbad as temporary and provisional became more and more a +part of the habitual system of government. Prosecutions succeeded one +another; letters were opened; spies attended the lectures of professors and +the meetings of students; the newspapers were everywhere prohibited from +discussing German affairs. In a country where there were so many printers +and so many readers journalism could not altogether expire. It was still +permissible to give the news and to offer an opinion about foreign lands: +and for years to come the Germans, like beggars regaling themselves with +the scents from rich men's kitchens, [300] followed every stage of the +political struggles that were agitating France, England, and Spain, while +they were not allowed to express a desire or to formulate a grievance of +their own. + +[Prussian Provincial Estates, June, 1823.] + +[Redeeming features of Prussian absolutism.] + +In the year 1822 Hardenberg died. All hope of a fulfilment of the promises +made in Prussia in 1815 had already become extinct. Not many months after +the Minister's death, King Frederick William established the Provincial +Estates which had been recommended to him by Metternich, and announced that +the creation of a central representative system would be postponed until +such time as the King should think fit to introduce it. This meant that the +project was finally abandoned; and Prussia in consequence remained without +a Parliament until the Revolution of 1848 was at the door. The Provincial +Estates, with which the King affected to temper absolute rule, met only +once in three years. Their function was to express an opinion upon local +matters when consulted by the Government: their enemies said that they were +aristocratic and did harm, their partizans could not pretend that they did +much good. In the bitterness of spirit with which, at a later time, the +friends of liberty denounced the betrayal of the cause of freedom by the +Prussian Court, a darker colour has perhaps been introduced into the +history of this period than really belongs to it. The wrongs sustained by +the Prussian nation have been compared to those inflicted by the despotism +of Spain. But, however contemptible the timidity of King Frederick William, +however odious the ingratitude shown to the truest friends of King and +people, the Government of 1819 is not correctly represented in such a +parallel. To identify the thousand varieties of wrong under the common name +of oppression, is to mistake words for things, and to miss the +characteristic features which distinguish nations from one another. The +greatest evils which a Government can inflict upon its subjects are +probably religious persecution, wasteful taxation, and the denial of +justice in the daily affairs of life. None of these were present in Prussia +during the darkest days of reaction. The hand of oppression fell heavily on +some of the best and some of the most enlightened men; it violated +interests so precious as those of free criticism and free discussion of +public affairs; but the great mass of the action of Government was never on +the side of evil. The ordinary course of justice was still pure, the +administration conscientious and thrifty. The system of popular education, +which for the first time placed Prussia in advance of Saxony and other +German States, dates from these years of warfare against liberty. A +reactionary despotism built the schools and framed the laws whose +reproduction in free England half a century later is justly regarded as the +chief of all the liberal measures of our day. So strong, so lasting, was +that vital tradition which made monarchy in Prussia an instrument for the +execution of great public ends. + +[A new Liberalism grows up in Germany after 1820.] + +[Interest in France.] + +But the old harmony between rulers and subjects in Germany perished in +the system of coercion which Metternich established in 1819. Patient as +the Germans were, loyal as they had proved themselves to Frederick William +and to worse princes through good and evil, the galling disappointment of +noble hopes, the silencing of the Press, the dissolution of societies,-- +calumnies, expulsions, prosecutions,--embittered many an honest mind +against authority. The Commission of Mainz did not find conspirators, but +it made them. As years went by, and all the means of legitimately working +for the improvement of German public life were one after another +extinguished, men of ardent character thought of more violent methods. +Secret societies, such as Metternich had imagined, came into actual being. +[301] And among those who neither sank into apathy and despair nor enrolled +themselves against existing power, a new body of ideas supplanted the old +loyal belief in the regeneration of Germany by its princes. The +Parliamentary struggles of France, the revolutionary movements in Italy and +in Spain which began at this epoch, drew the imagination away from that +pictured restoration of a free Teutonic past which had proved so barren of +result, and set in its place the idea of a modern universal or European +Liberalism. The hatred against France, especially among the younger men, +disappeared. A distinction was made between the tyrant Napoleon and the +people who were now giving to the rest of the Continent the example of a +free and animated public life, and illuminating the age with a political +literature so systematic and so ingenious that it seemed almost like a +political philosophy. The debates in the French Assembly, the writings of +French publicists, became the school of the Germans. Paris regained in +foreign eyes something of the interest that it had possessed in 1789. Each +victory or defeat of the French popular cause awoke the joy or the sorrow +of German Liberals, to whom all was blank at home: and when at length the +throne of the Bourbons fell, the signal for deliverance seemed to have +sounded in many a city beyond the Rhine. + +[France after 1818.] + +[Richelieu resigns, Dec., 1818. Decazes keeps power.] + +We have seen that in Central Europe the balance between liberty and +reaction, wavering in 1815, definitely fell to the side of reaction at the +Congress of Aix-la-Chapelle. It remains to trace the course of events which +in France itself suspended the peaceful progress of the nation, and threw +power for some years into the hands of a faction which belonged to the +past. The measures carried by Decazes in 1817, which gave so much +satisfaction to the French, were by no means viewed with the same approval +either at London or at Vienna. The two principal of these were the +Electoral Law, and a plan of military reorganisation which brought back +great numbers of Napoleon's old officers and soldiers to the army. +Richelieu, though responsible as the head of the Ministry, felt very grave +fears as to the results of this legislation. He had already become anxious +and distressed when the Congress of Aix-la-Chapelle met; and the events +which took place in France during his absence, as well as the +communications which passed between himself and the foreign Ministers, +convinced him that a change of internal policy was necessary. The busy mind +of Metternich had already been scheming against French Liberalism. Alarmed +at the energy shown by Decazes, the Austrian statesman had formed the +design of reconciling Artois and the Ultra-Royalists to the King's +Government; and he now urged Richelieu, if his old opponents could be +brought to reason, to place himself at the head of a coalition of all the +conservative elements in the State. [302] While the Congress of +Aix-la-Chapelle was sitting, the partial elections for the year 1818, the +second under the new Electoral Law, took place. Among the deputies returned +there were some who passed for determined enemies of the Bourbon +restoration, especially Lafayette, whose name was so closely associated +with the humiliations of the Court in 1789. Richelieu received the news +with dismay, and on his return to Paris took steps which ended in the +dismissal of Decazes, and the offer of a seat in the Cabinet to Villele, +the Ultra-Royalist leader. But the attempted combination failed. Richelieu +accordingly withdrew from office; and a new Ministry was formed, of which +Decazes, who had proved himself more powerful than his assailants, was the +real though not the nominal chief. + +[Election of Gregoire, Sept., 1819.] + +The victory of the young and popular statesman was seen with extreme +displeasure by all the foreign Courts, nor was his success an enduring one. +For awhile the current of Liberal opinion in France and the favour of King +Louis XVIII. enabled Decazes to hold his own against the combinations of +his opponents and the ill-will of all the most powerful men in Europe. An +attack made on the Electoral Law by the Upper House was defeated by the +creation of sixty new Peers, among whom there were several who had been +expelled in 1815. But the forces of Liberalism soon passed beyond the +Minister's own control, and his steady dependence upon Louis XVIII. now +raised against him as resolute an opposition among the enemies of the House +of Bourbon as among the Ultra-Royalists. In the elections of 1819 the +candidates of the Ministry were beaten by men of more pronounced opinions. +Among the new members there was one whose victory caused great astonishment +and alarm. The ex-bishop Gregoire, one of the authors of the destruction of +the old French Church in 1790, and mover of the resolution which +established the Republic in 1792, was brought forward from his retirement +and elected Deputy by the town of Grenoble. To understand the panic caused +by this election we must recall, not the events of the Revolution, but the +legends of them which were current in 1819. The history of Gregoire by no +means justifies the outcry which was raised against him; his real actions, +however, formed the smallest part of the things that were alleged or +believed by his enemies. It was said he had applauded the execution of King +Louis XVI., when he had in fact protested against it: [303] his courageous +adherence to the character of a Christian priest throughout the worst days +of the Convention, his labours in organising the Constitutional Church when +the choice lay between that and national atheism, were nothing, or worse +than nothing, in the eyes of men who felt themselves to be the despoiled +heirs of that rich and aristocratic landed society, called the Feudal +Church, which Gregoire had been so active in breaking up. Unluckily for +himself, Gregoire, though humane in action, had not abstained from the +rhodomontades against kings in general which were the fashion in 1793. +Louis XVIII., forgetting that he had himself lately made the regicide +Fouche a Minister, interpreted Gregoire's election by the people of +Grenoble, to which the Ultra-Royalists had cunningly contributed, as a +threat against the Bourbon family. He showed the displeasure usual with him +when any slight was offered to his personal dignity, and drew nearer to his +brother Artois and the Ultra-Royalists, whom he had hitherto shunned as his +favourite Minister's worst enemies. Decazes, true to his character as the +King's friend, now confessed that he had gone too far in the legislation of +1817, and that the Electoral Law, under which such a monster as Gregoire +could gain a seat, required to be altered. A project of law was sketched, +designed to restore the preponderance in the constituencies to the landed +aristocracy. Gregoire's election was itself invalidated; and the Ministers +who refused to follow Decazes in his new policy of compromise were +dismissed from their posts. + +[Murder of the Duke of Berry, Feb. 13, 1820.] + +[Reaction sets in.] + +[Fall of Decazes. Richelieu Minister, Feb., 1820.] + +A few months more passed, and an event occurred which might have driven a +stronger Government than that of Louis XVIII. into excesses of reaction. +The heirs to the Crown next in succession to the Count of Artois were his +two sons, the Dukes of Angouleme and Berry. Angouleme was childless; the +Duke of Berry was the sole hope of the elder Bourbon line, which, if he +should die without a son, would, as a reigning house, become extinct, the +Crown of France not descending to a female. [304] The circumstance which +made Berry's life so dear to Royalists made his destruction the +all-absorbing purpose of an obscure fanatic, who abhorred the Bourbon +family as the lasting symbol of the foreigner's victory over France. +Louvel, a working man, had followed Napoleon to exile in Elba. After +returning to his country he had dogged the footsteps of the Bourbon princes +for years together, waiting for the chance of murder. On the night of the +13th of February, 1820, he seized the Duke of Berry as he was leaving the +Opera House, and plunged a knife into his breast. The Duke lingered for +some hours, and expired early the next morning in the presence of King +Louis XVIII., the Princes, and all the Ministers. Terrible as the act was, +it was the act of a single resolute mind: no human being had known of +Louvel's intention. But it was impossible that political passion should +await the quiet investigation of a law-court. No murder ever produced a +stronger outburst of indignation among the governing classes, or was more +skilfully turned to the advantage of party. The Liberals felt that their +cause was lost. While fanatical Ultra-Royalists, abandoning themselves to a +credulity worthy of the Reign of Terror, accused Decazes himself of +complicity with the assassin, their leaders fixed upon the policy which was +to be imposed on the King. It was in vain that Decazes brought forward his +reactionary Electoral Law, and proposed to invest the officers of State +with arbitrary powers of arrest and to re-establish the censorship of the +Press. The Count of Artois insisted upon the dismissal of the Minister, as +the only consolation which could be given to him for the murder of his son +The King yielded; and, as an Ultra-Royalist administration was not yet +possible, Richelieu unwillingly returned to office, assured by Artois that +his friends had no other desire than to support his own firm and temperate +rule. + +[Progress of the reaction in France.] + +[Ultra-Royalist Ministry, Dec., 1821.] + +[The Congregation.] + +Returning to power under such circumstances, Richelieu became, in spite of +himself, the Minister of reaction. The Press was fettered, the legal +safeguards of personal liberty were suspended, the electoral system was +transformed by a measure which gave a double vote to men of large property. +So violent were the passions which this retrograde march of Government +excited, that for a moment Paris seemed to be on the verge of revolution. +Tumultuous scenes occurred in the streets; but the troops, on whom +everything depended, obeyed the orders given to them, and the danger passed +away. The first elections under the new system reduced the Liberal party to +impotence, and brought back to the Chamber a number of men who had sat in +the reactionary Parliament of 1816. Villele and other Ultra-Royalists were +invited to join Richelieu's Cabinet. For awhile it seemed as if the +passions of Church and aristocracy might submit to the curb of a practical +statesmanship, friendly, if not devoted, to their own interests. But +restraint was soon cast aside. The Count of Artois saw the road to power +open, and broke his promise of supporting the Minister who had taken office +at his request. Censured and thwarted in the Chamber of Deputies, Richelieu +confessed that he had undertaken a hopeless task, and bade farewell to +public life. King Louis, now nearing the grave, could struggle no longer +against the brother who was waiting to ascend his throne. The next Ministry +was nominated not by the King but by Artois. Around Villele, the real head +of the Cabinet, there was placed a body of men who represented not the new +France, or even that small portion of it which was called to exercise the +active rights of citizenship, but the social principles of a past age, and +that Catholic or Ultramontane revival which was now freshening the surface +but not stirring the depths of the great mass of French religious +indifference. A religious society known as the Congregation, which had +struck its first roots under the storm of Republican persecution, and grown +up during the Empire, a solitary yet unobserved rallying-place for Catholic +opponents of Napoleon's despotism, now expanded into a great organism of +government. The highest in blood and in office sought membership in it: its +patronage raised ambitious men to the stations they desired, its hostility +made itself felt against the small as well as against the great. The spirit +which now gained the ascendancy in French government was clerical even more +than it was aristocratic. It was monarchical too, but rather from dislike +to the secularist tone of Liberalism and from trust in the orthodoxy of the +Count of Artois than from any fixed belief in absolutist principles. There +might be good reason to oppose King Louis XVIII.; but what priest, what +noble, could doubt the divine right of a prince who was ready to compensate +the impoverished emigrants out of the public funds, and to commit the whole +system of public education to the hands of the clergy? + +[Bourbon rule before and after 1821.] + +In the middle class of France, which from this time began to feel itself in +opposition to the Bourbon Government, there had been no moral change +corresponding to that which made so great a difference between the +governing authority of 1819 and that of 1822. Public opinion, though +strongly affected, was not converted into something permanently unlike +itself by the murder of the Duke of Berry. The courtiers, the devotees, the +great ladies, who had laid a bold hand upon power, had not the nation on +their side, although for a while the nation bore their sway submissively. +But the fate of the Bourbon monarchy was in fact decided when Artois and +his confidants became its representatives. France might have forgotten that +the Bourbons owed their throne to foreign victories; it could not be +governed in perpetuity by what was called the _Parti Pretre_. Twenty +years taken from the burden of age borne by Louis XVIII., twenty years of +power given to Decazes, might have prolonged the rule of the restored +family perhaps for some generations. If military pride found small +satisfaction in the contrast between the Napoleonic age and that which +immediately succeeded it, there were enough parents who valued the blood of +their children, there were enough speakers and writers who valued the +liberty of discussion, enough capitalists who valued quiet times, for the +new order to be recognised as no unhopeful one. France has indeed seldom +had a better government than it possessed between 1816 and 1820, nor could +an equal period be readily named during which the French nation, as a +whole, enjoyed greater happiness. + +[General causes of the victory of reaction in Europe.] + +Political reaction had reached its full tide in Europe generally about five +years after the end of the great war. The phenomena were by no means the +same in all countries, nor were the accidents of personal influence without +a large share in the determination of events: yet, underlying all +differences, we may trace the operation of certain great causes which were +not limited by the boundaries of individual States. The classes in which +any fixed belief in constitutional government existed were nowhere very +large; outside the circle of state officials there was scarcely any one who +had had experience in the conduct of public affairs. In some countries, as +in Russia and Prussia, the conception of progress towards self-government +had belonged in the first instance to the holders of power: it had +exercised the imagination of a Czar, or appealed to the understanding of a +Prussian Minister, eager, in the extremity of ruin, to develop every +element of worth and manliness existing within his nation. The cooling of a +warm fancy, the disappearance of external dangers, the very agitation which +arose when the idea of liberty passed from the rulers to their subjects, +sufficed to check the course of reform. And by the side of the Kings and +Ministers who for a moment had attached themselves to constitutional +theories there stood the old privileged orders, or what remained of them, +the true party of reaction, eager to fan the first misgivings and alarms of +Sovereigns, and to arrest a development more prejudicial to their own power +and importance than to the dignity and security of the Crown. Further, +there existed throughout Europe the fatal and ineradicable tradition of the +convulsions of the first Revolution, and of the horrors of 1793. No votary +of absolutism, no halting and disquieted friend of freedom, could ever be +at a loss for images of woe in presaging the results of popular +sovereignty; and the action of one or two infatuated assassins owed its +wide influence on Europe chiefly to the ancient name and memory of +Jacobinism. + +There was also in the very fact that Europe had been restored to peace by +the united efforts of all the governments something adverse to the success +of a constitutional or a Liberal party in any State. Constitutional systems +had indeed been much praised at the Congress of Vienna; but the group of +men who actually controlled Europe in 1815, and who during the five +succeeding years continued in correspondence and in close personal +intercourse with one another, had, with one exception, passed their lives +in the atmosphere of absolute government, and learnt to regard the conduct +of all great affairs as the business of a small number of very eminent +individuals. Castlereagh, the one Minister of a constitutional State, +belonged to a party which, to a degree almost unequalled in Europe, +identified political duty with the principle of hostility to change. It is +indeed in the correspondence of the English Minister himself, and in +relation to subjects of purely domestic government in England, that the +community of thought which now existed between all the leading statesmen of +Europe finds its most singular exhibition. Both Metternich and Hardenberg +took as much interest in the suppression of Lancashire Radicalism, and in +the measures of coercion which the British Government thought it necessary +to pass in the year 1819, as in the chastisement of rebellious pamphleteers +upon the Rhine, and in the dissolution of the students' clubs at Jena. It +was indeed no very great matter for the English people, who were now close +upon an era of reform, that Castlereagh received the congratulations of +Vienna and Berlin for suspending the Habeas Corpus Act and the right of +public meeting, [305] or that Metternich believed that no one but himself +knew the real import of the shouts with which the London mob greeted Sir +Francis Burdett. [306] Neither the impending reform of the English Criminal +Law nor the emancipation of Irish Catholics resulted from the enlightenment +of foreign Courts, or could be hindered by their indifference. But on the +Continent of Europe the progress towards constitutional freedom was indeed +likely to be a slow and a chequered one when the Ministers of absolutism +formed so close and intimate a band, when the nations contained within them +such small bodies of men in any degree versed in public affairs, and when +the institutions on which it was proposed to base the liberty of the future +were so destitute of that strength which springs from connection with the +past. + + + + +CHAPTER XIV. + + +Movements in the Mediterranean States beginning in 1820--Spain from 1814 to +1820--The South American Colonies--The Army at Cadiz: Action of Quiroga +and Riego--Movement at Corunna--Ferdinand accepts the Constitution of +1812--Naples from 1815 to 1820--The Court-party, the Muratists, the +Carbonari--The Spanish Constitution proclaimed at Naples--Constitutional +movement in Portugal--Alexander's proposal with regard to Spain--The +Conference and Declaration of Troppau--Protest of England--Conference of +Laibach--The Austrians invade Naples and restore absolute Monarchy-- +Insurrection in Piedmont, which fails--Spain from 1820 to 1822--Death of +Castlereagh--The Congress of Verona--Policy of England--The French invade +Spain--Restoration of absolute Monarchy, and violence of the reaction-- +England prohibits the conquest of the Spanish Colonies by France, and +subsequently recognises their independence--Affairs in Portugal--Canning +sends troops to Lisbon--The Policy of Canning--Estimate of his place in the +history of Europe. + + +[The Mediterranean movements, beginning in 1820.] + +When the guardians of Europe, at the end of the first three years of peace, +scanned from their council-chamber at Aix-la-Chapelle that goodly heritage +which, under Providence, their own parental care was henceforth to guard +against the assaults of malice and revolution, they had fixed their gaze +chiefly on France, Germany, and the Netherlands, as the regions most +threatened by the spirit of change. The forecast was not an accurate one. +In each of these countries Government proved during the succeeding years to +be much more than a match for its real or imaginary foes: it was in the +Mediterranean States, which had excited comparatively little anxiety, that +the first successful attack was made upon established power. Three +movements arose successively in the three southern peninsulas, at the time +when Metternich was enjoying the silence which he had imposed upon Germany, +and the Ultra-Royalists of France were making good the advantage which the +crime of an individual and the imprudence of a party had thrown into their +hands. In Spain and in Italy a body of soldiers rose on behalf of +constitutional government: in Greece a nation rose against the rule of the +foreigner. In all three countries the issue of these movements was, after a +longer or shorter interval, determined by the Northern Powers. All three +movements were at first treated as identical in their character, and all +alike condemned as the work of Jacobinism. But the course of events, and a +change of persons in the government of one great State, brought about a +truer view of the nature of the struggle in Greece. The ultimate action of +Europe in the affairs of that country was different from its action in the +affairs of Italy and Spain. It is now only remembered as an instance of +political recklessness or stupidity that a conflict of race against race +and of religion against religion should for a while have been confused by +some of the leading Ministers of Europe with the attempt of a party to make +the form of domestic government more liberal. The Hellenic rising had +indeed no feature in common with the revolutions of Naples and Cadiz; and, +although in order of time the opening of the Greek movement long preceded +the close of the Spanish movement, the historian, who has neither the +politician's motive for making a confusion, nor the protection of his +excuse of ignorance, must in this case neglect the accidents of chronology, +and treat the two as altogether apart. + +[Spain between 1814 and 1820.] + +King Ferdinand of Spain, after overthrowing the Constitution which he found +in existence on his return to his country, had conducted himself as if his +object had been to show to what lengths a legitimate monarch might abuse +the fidelity of his subjects and defy the public opinion of Europe. The +leaders of the Cortes, whom he had arrested in 1814, after being declared +innocent by one tribunal after another were sentenced to long terms of +imprisonment by an arbitrary decree of the King, without even the pretence +of judicial forms. Men who had been conspicuous in the struggle of the +nation against Napoleon were neglected or disgraced; many of the highest +posts were filled by politicians who had played a double part, or had even +served under the invader. Priests and courtiers intrigued for influence +over the King; even when a capable Minister was placed in power through the +pressure of the ambassadors, and the King's name was set to edicts of +administrative reform, these edicts were made a dead letter by the powerful +band who lived upon the corruption of the public service. Nothing was +sacred except the interest of the clergy; this, however, was enough to keep +the rural population on the King's side. The peasant, who knew that his +house would not now be burnt by the French, and who heard that true +religion had at length triumphed over its enemies, understood, and cared to +understand, nothing more. Rumours of kingly misgovernment and oppression +scarcely reached his ears. Ferdinand was still the child of Spain and of +the Church; his return had been the return of peace; his rule was the +victory of the Catholic faith. + +[The nation satisfied: the officers discontented.] + +But the acquiescence of the mass of the people was not shared by the +officers of the army and the educated classes in the towns. The overthrow +of the Constitution was from the first condemned by soldiers who had won +distinction under the government of the Cortes; and a series of military +rebellion, though isolated and on the smallest scale, showed that the +course on which Ferdinand had entered was not altogether free from danger. +The attempts of General Mina in 1814, and of Porlier and Lacy in succeeding +years, to raise the soldiery on behalf of the Constitution, failed, through +the indifference of the soldiery themselves, and the power which the +priesthood exercised in garrison-towns. Discontent made its way in the army +by slow degrees; and the ultimate declaration of a military party against +the existing Government was due at least as much to Ferdinand's absurd +system of favouritism, and to the wretched condition into which the army +had been thrown, as to an attachment to the memory or the principles of +constitutional rule. Misgovernment made the treasury bankrupt; soldiers and +sailors received no pay for years together; and the hatred with which the +Spanish people had now come to regard military service is curiously shown +by an order of the Government that all the beggars in Madrid and other +great towns should be seized on a certain night (July 23, 1816), and +enrolled in the army. [307] But the very beggars were more than a match for +Ferdinand's administration. They heard of the fate in store for them, and +mysteriously disappeared, so frustrating a measure by which it had been +calculated that Spain would gain sixty thousand warriors. + +[Struggle of Spain with its colonies, 1810-1820.] + +The military revolution which at length broke out in the year 1820 was +closely connected with the struggle for independence now being made by the +American colonies of Spain; and in its turn it affected the course of this +struggle and its final result. The colonies had refused to accept the rule +either of Joseph Bonaparte or of the Cortes of Cadiz when their legitimate +sovereign was dispossessed by Napoleon. While acting for the most part in +Ferdinand's name, they had engaged in a struggle with the National +Government of Spain. They had tasted independence; and although after the +restoration of Ferdinand they would probably have recognised the rights of +the Spanish Crown if certain concessions had been made, they were not +disposed to return to the condition of inferiority in which they had been +held during the last century, or to submit to rulers who proved themselves +as cruel and vindictive in moments of victory as they were incapable of +understanding the needs of the time. The struggle accordingly continued. +Regiment after regiment was sent from Spain, to perish of fever, of forced +marches, or on the field. The Government of King Ferdinand, despairing of +its own resources, looked around for help among the European Powers. +England would have lent its mediation, and possibly even armed assistance, +if the Court of Madrid would have granted a reasonable amount of freedom to +the colonies, and have opened their ports to British commerce. This, +however, was not in accordance with the views of Ferdinand's advisers. +Strange as it may appear, the Spanish Government demanded that the alliance +of Sovereigns, which had been framed for the purpose of resisting the +principle of rebellion and disorder in Europe, should intervene against its +revolted subjects on the other side of the Atlantic, and it implied that +England, if acting at all, should act as the instrument of the Alliance. +[308] Encouragement was given to the design by the Courts of Paris and St. +Petersburg. Whether a continent claimed its independence, or a German +schoolboy wore a forbidden ribbon in his cap, the chiefs of the Holy +Alliance now assumed the frown of offended Providence, and prepared to +interpose their own superior power and wisdom to save a misguided world +from the consequences of its own folly. Alexander had indeed for a time +hoped that the means of subduing the colonies might be supplied by himself; +and in his zeal to supplant England in the good graces of Ferdinand he sold +the King a fleet of war on very moderate terms. To the scandal of Europe +the ships, when they reached Cadiz, turned out to be thoroughly rotten and +unseaworthy. As it was certain that the Czar's fleet and the Spanish +soldiers, however holy their mission, would all go to the bottom together +as soon as they encountered the waves of the Atlantic, the expedition was +postponed, and the affairs of America were brought before the Conference of +Aix-la-Chapelle. The Envoys of Russia and France submitted a paper, in +which, anticipating the storm-warnings of more recent times, they described +the dangers to which monarchical Europe would be exposed from the growth of +a federation of republics in America; and they suggested that Wellington, +as "the man of Europe," should go to Madrid, to preside over a negotiation +between the Court of Spain and all the ambassadors with reference to the +terms to be offered to the Transatlantic States. [309] England, however, in +spite of Lord Castlereagh's dread of revolutionary contagion, adhered to +the principles which it had already laid down; and as the counsellors of +King Ferdinand declined to change their policy, Spain was left to subdue +its colonies by itself. + +[Conspiracy in the Army of Cadiz.] + +It was in the army assembled at Cadiz for embarkation in the summer of 1819 +that the conspiracy against Ferdinand's Government found its leaders. +Secret societies had now spread themselves over the principal Spanish +towns, and looked to the soldiery on the coast for the signal of revolt. +Abisbal, commander at Cadiz, intending to make himself safe against all +contingencies, encouraged for awhile the plots of the discontented +officers: then, foreseeing the failure of the movement, he arrested the +principal men by a stratagem, and went off to Madrid, to reveal the +conspiracy to the Court and to take credit for saving the King's crown +(July, 1819). [310] If the army could have been immediately despatched to +America, the danger would possibly have passed away. This, however, was +prevented by an outbreak of yellow fever, which made it necessary to send +the troops into cantonments for several months. The conspirators gained +time to renew their plans. The common soldiers, who had hitherto been +faithful to the Government, heard in their own squalor and inaction the +fearful stories of the few sick and wounded who returned from beyond the +seas, and learnt to regard the order of embarkation as a sentence of death. +Several battalions were won over to the cause of constitutional liberty by +their commanders. The leaders imprisoned a few months before were again in +communication with their followers. After the treachery of Abisbal, it was +agreed to carry out the revolt without the assistance of generals or +grandees. The leaders chosen were two colonels, Quiroga and Riego, of whom +the former was in nominal confinement in a monastery near Medina Sidonia, +twenty miles east of Cadiz, while Riego was stationed at Cabezas, a few +marches distant on the great road to Seville. The first day of the year +1820 was fixed for the insurrection. It was determined that Riego should +descend upon the head-quarters, which were at Arcos, and arrest the +generals before they could hear anything of the movement, while Quiroga, +moving from the east, gathered up the battalions stationed on the road, and +threw himself into Cadiz, there to await his colleague's approach. + +[Action of Quiroga and Riego, Jan. 1820.] + +The first step in the enterprise proved successful. Riego, proclaiming the +Constitution of 1812, surprised the headquarters, seized the generals, and +rallied several companies to his standard. Quiroga, however, though he +gained possession of San Fernando, at the eastern end of the peninsula of +Leon, on which Cadiz is situated, failed to make his entrance into Cadiz. +The commandant, hearing of the capture of the head-quarters, had closed the +city gates, and arrested the principal inhabitants whom he suspected of +being concerned in the plot. The troops within the town showed no sign of +mutiny. Riego, when he arrived at the peninsula of Leon, found that only +five thousand men in all had joined the good cause, while Cadiz, with a +considerable garrison and fortifications of great strength, stood hostile +before him. He accordingly set off with a small force to visit and win over +the other regiments which were lying in the neighbouring towns and +villages. The commanders, however, while not venturing to attack the +mutineers, drew off their troops to a distance, and prevented them from +entering into any communication with Riego. The adventurous soldier, +leaving Quiroga in the peninsula of Leon, then marched into the interior of +Andalusia (January 27), endeavouring to raise the inhabitants of the towns. +But the small numbers of his band, and the knowledge that Cadiz and the +greater part of the army still held by the Government, prevented the +inhabitants from joining the insurrection, even where they received Riego +with kindness and supplied the wants of his soldiers. During week after +week the little column traversed the country, now cut off from retreat, +exhausted by forced marches in drenching rain, and harassed by far stronger +forces sent in pursuit. The last town that Riego entered was Cordova. The +enemy was close behind him. No halt was possible. He led his band, now +numbering only two hundred men, into the mountains, and there bade them +disperse (March 11). + +[Corunna proclaims the Constitution Feb. 20.] + +[Abisbal's defection March 4.] + +With Quiroga lying inactive in the peninsula of Leon and Riego hunted from +village to village, it seemed as if the insurrection which they had begun +could only end in the ruin of its leaders. But the movement had in fact +effected its object. While the courtiers around King Ferdinand, unwarned by +the news from Cadiz, continued their intrigues against one another, the +rumour of rebellion spread over the country. If no great success had been +achieved by the rebels, it was also certain that no great blow had been +struck by the Government. The example of bold action had been set; the +shock given at one end of the peninsula was felt at the other; and a +fortnight before Riego's band dispersed, the garrison and the citizens of +Corunna together declared for the Constitution (February 20). From Corunna +the revolutionary movement spread to Ferrol and to all the other +coast-towns of Galicia. The news reached Madrid, terrifying the Government, +and exciting the spirit of insurrection in the capital itself. The King +summoned a council of the leading men around him. The wisest of them +advised him to publish a moderate Constitution, and, by convoking a +Parliament immediately, to stay the movement, which would otherwise result +in the restoration of the Assembly and the Constitution of 1812. They also +urged the King to abolish the Inquisition forthwith. Ferdinand's brother, +Don Carlos, the head of the clerical party, succeeded in preventing both +measures. Though the generals in all quarters of Spain wrote that they +could not answer for the troops, there were still hopes of keeping down the +country by force of arms. Abisbal, who was at Madrid, was ordered to move +with reinforcements towards the army in the south. He set out, protesting +to the King that he knew the way to deal with rebels. When he reached Ocana +he proclaimed the Constitution himself (March 4). + +[Ferdinand accepts the Constitution 1812, March 9.] + +It was now clear that the cause of absolute monarchy was lost. The ferment +in Madrid increased. On the night of the 6th of March all the great bodies +of State assembled for council in the King's palace, and early on the 7th +Ferdinand published a proclamation, stating that he had determined to +summon the Cortes immediately. This declaration satisfied no one, for the +Cortes designed by the King might be the mere revival of a mediaeval form, +and the history of 1814 showed how little value was to be attached to +Ferdinand's promises. Crowds gathered in the great squares of Madrid, +crying for the Constitution of 1812. The statement of the Minister of War +that the Guard was on the point of joining the people now overcame even the +resistance of Don Carlos and the confessors; and after a day wasted in +dispute, Ferdinand announced to his people that he was ready to take the +oath to the Constitution which they desired. The next day was given up to +public rejoicings; the book of the Constitution was carried in procession +through the city with the honours paid to the Holy Sacrament, and all +political prisoners were set at liberty. The prison of the Inquisition was +sacked, the instruments of torture broken in pieces. On the 9th the leaders +of the agitation took steps to make the King fulfil his promise. A mob +invaded the court and threshold of the palace. At their demand the +municipal council of 1814 was restored; its members were sent, in company +with six deputies chosen by the populace, to receive the pledges of the +King. Ferdinand, all smiles and bows, while he looked forward to the day +when force or intrigue should make him again absolute master of Spain, and +enable him to take vengeance upon the men who were humiliating, him, took +the oath of fidelity to the Constitution of 1812. [311] New Ministers were +immediately called to office, and a provisional Junta was placed by their +side as the representative of the public until the new Cortes should be +duly elected. + +[Condition of Naples, 1815-1820.] + +Tidings of the Spanish revolution passed rapidly over Europe, disquieting +the courts and everywhere reviving the hopes of the friends of popular +right. Before four months had passed, the constitutional movement begun in +Cadiz was taken up in Southern Italy. The kingdom of Naples was one of +those States which had profited the most by French conquest. During the +nine years that its crown was held by Joseph Bonaparte and Murat, the laws +and institutions which accompanied Napoleon's supremacy had rudely broken +up the ancient fixity of confusions which passed for government, and had +aroused no insignificant forces of new social life. The feudal tenure of +land, and with it something of the feudal structure of society, had passed +away: the monasteries had been dissolved; the French civil code, and a +criminal code based upon that of France, had taken the place of a thousand +conflicting customs and jurisdictions; taxation had been made, if not +light, yet equitable and simple; justice was regular, and the same for +baron and peasant; brigandage had been extinguished; and, for the first +time in many centuries, the presence of a rational and uniform +administration was felt over all the south of Italy. Nor on the restoration +of King Ferdinand had any reaction been permitted to take place like that +which in a moment destroyed the work of reform in Spain and in Westphalia. +England and Austria insisted that there should be neither vengeance nor +counterrevolution. Queen Marie Caroline, the principal agent in the +cruelties of 1799, was dead; Ferdinand himself was old and indolent, and +willing to leave affairs in the hands of Ministers more intelligent than +himself. Hence the laws and the administrative system of Murat remained on +the whole unchanged. [312] As in France, a Bourbon Sovereign placed himself +at the head of a political order fashioned by Napoleon and the Revolution. +Where changes in the law were made, or acts of State revoked, it was for +the most part in consequence of an understanding with the Holy See. Thus, +while no attempt was made to eject the purchasers of Church-lands, the +lands not actually sold were given back to the Church; a considerable +number of monasteries were restored; education was allowed to fall again +into the hands of the clergy; the Jesuits were recalled, and the Church +regained its jurisdiction in marriage-causes, as well as the right of +suppressing writings at variance with the Catholic faith. + +[Hostility between the Court party and the Muratists.] + +But the legal and recognised changes which followed Ferdinand's return by +no means expressed the whole change in the operation of government. If +there were not two conflicting systems at work, there were two conflicting +bodies of partisans in the State. Like the emigrants who returned with +Louis XVIII., a multitude of Neapolitans, high and low, who had either +accompanied the King in his exile to Sicily or fought for him on the +mainland in 1799 and 1806, now expected their reward. In their interest the +efficiency of the public service was sacrificed and the course of justice +perverted. Men who had committed notorious crimes escaped punishment if +they had been numbered among the King's friends; the generals and officials +who had served under Murat, though not removed from their posts, were +treated with discourtesy and suspicion. It was in the army most of all that +the antagonism of the two parties was felt. A medal was struck for service +in Sicily, and every year spent there in inaction was reckoned as two in +computing seniority. Thus the younger officers of Murat found their way +blocked by a troop of idlers, and at the same time their prospects suffered +from the honest attempts made by Ministers to reduce the military +expenditure. Discontent existed in every rank. The generals were familiar +with the idea of political change, for during the last years of Murat's +reign they had themselves thought of compelling him to grant a +Constitution: the younger officers and the sergeants were in great part +members of the secret society of the Carbonari, which in the course of the +last few years had grown with the weakness of the Government, and had now +become the principal power in the Neapolitan kingdom. + +[The Carbonari.] + +The origin of this society, which derived its name and its symbolism from +the trade of the charcoal-burner, as Freemasonry from that of the builder, +is uncertain. Whether its first aim was resistance to Bourbon tyranny after +1799, or the expulsion of the French and Austrians from Italy, in the year +1814 it was actively working for constitutional government in opposition to +Murat, and receiving encouragement from Sicily, where Ferdinand was then +playing the part of constitutional King. The maintenance of absolute +government by the restored Bourbon Court severed the bond which for a time +existed between legitimate monarchy and conspiracy; and the lodges of the +Carbonari, now extending themselves over the country with great rapidity, +became so many centres of agitation against despotic rule. By the year 1819 +it was reckoned that one person out of every twenty-five in the kingdom of +Naples had joined the society. Its members were drawn from all classes, +most numerously perhaps from the middle class in the towns; but even +priests had been initiated, and there was no branch of the public service +that had not Carbonari in its ranks. The Government, apprehending danger +from the extension of the sect, tried to counteract it by founding a rival +society of Calderari, or Braziers, in which every miscreant who before 1815 +had murdered and robbed in the name of King Ferdinand and the Catholic +faith received a welcome. But though the number of such persons was not +small, the growth of this fraternity remained far behind that of its model; +and the chief result of the competition was that intrigue and mystery +gained a greater charm than ever for the Italians, and that all confidence +in Government perished, under the sense that there was a hidden power in +the land which was only awaiting the due moment to put forth its strength +in revolutionary action. + +[Morelli's movement, July 2, 1820.] + +After the proclamation of the Spanish Constitution, an outbreak in the +kingdom of Naples had become inevitable. The Carbonari of Salerno, where +the sect had its headquarters, had intended to rise at the beginning of +June; their action, however, was postponed for some months, and it was +anticipated by the daring movement of a few sergeants belonging to a +cavalry regiment stationed at Nola, and of a lieutenant, named Morelli, +whom they had persuaded to place himself at their head. Leading out a +squadron of a hundred and fifty men in the direction of Avellino on the +morning of July 2nd, Morelli proclaimed the Constitution. One of the +soldiers alone left the band; force or persuasion kept others to the +Standard, though they disapproved of the enterprise. The inhabitants of the +populous places that lie between Nola and Avellino welcomed the squadron, +or at least offered it no opposition: the officer commanding at Avellino +came himself to meet Morelli, and promised him assistance. The band +encamped that night in a village; on the next day they entered Avellino, +where the troops and townspeople, headed by the bishop and officers, +declared in their favour. From Avellino the news of the movement spread +quickly over the surrounding country. The Carbonari were everywhere +prepared for revolt; and before the Government had taken a single step in +its own defence, the Constitution had been joyfully and peacefully +accepted, not only by the people but by the militia and the regular troops, +throughout the greater part of the district that lies to the east of +Naples. + +[Affairs at Naples, July 2-7.] + +The King was on board ship in the bay, when, in the afternoon of July 2nd, +intelligence came of Morelli's revolt at Nola. Nothing was done by the +Ministry on that day, although Morelli and his band might have been +captured in a few hours if any resolute officer, with a few trustworthy +troops, had been sent against them. On the next morning, when the garrison +of Avellino had already joined the mutineers, and taken up a strong +position commanding the road from Naples, General Carrascosa was sent, not +to reduce the insurgents--for no troops were given to him--but to pardon, +to bribe, and to coax them into submission. [313] Carrascosa failed to +effect any good; other generals, who, during the following days, attempted +to attack the mutineers, found that their troops would not follow them, and +that the feeling of opposition to the Government, though it nowhere broke +into lawlessness, was universal in the army as well as the nation. If the +people generally understood little of politics, they had learnt enough to +dislike arbitrary taxation and the power of arbitrary arrest. Not a single +hand or voice was anywhere raised in defence of absolutism. Escaping from +Naples, where he was watched by the Government, General Pepe, who was at +once the chief man among the Carbonari and military commandant of the +province in which Avellino lies, went to place himself at the head of the +revolution. Naples itself had hitherto remained quiet, but on the night of +July 6th a deputation from the Carbonari informed the King that they could +no longer preserve tranquillity in the city unless a Constitution was +granted. The King, without waiting for morning, published an edict +declaring that a Constitution should be drawn up within eight days; +immediately afterwards he appointed a new Ministry, and, feigning illness, +committed the exercise of royal authority to his son, the Duke of Calabria. + +[Ferdinand takes the Oath to the Spanish Constitution, July 13.] + +Ferdinand's action was taken by the people as a stratagem. He had employed +the device of a temporary abdication some years before in cajoling the +Sicilians; and the delay of eight days seemed unnecessary to ardent souls +who knew that a Spanish Constitution was in existence and did not know of +its defects in practice. There was also on the side of the Carbonari the +telling argument that Ferdinand, as a possible successor to his nephew, the +childless King of Spain, actually had signed the Spanish Constitution in +order to preserve his own contingent rights to that crown. What Ferdinand +had accepted as Infante of Spain he might well accept as King of Naples. +The cry was therefore for the immediate proclamation of the Spanish +Constitution of 1812. The court yielded, and the Duke of Calabria, as +viceroy, published an edict making this Constitution the law of the kingdom +of the Two Sicilies. But the tumult continued, for deceit was still feared, +until the edict appeared again, signed by the King himself. Then all was +rejoicing. Pepe, at the head of a large body of troops, militia and +Carbonari, made a triumphal entry into the city, and, in company with +Morelli and other leaders of the military rebellion, was hypocritically +thanked by the Viceroy for his services to the nation. On the 13th of July +the King, a hale but venerable-looking man of seventy, took the oath to the +Constitution before the altar in the royal chapel. The form of words had +been written out for him; but Ferdinand was fond of theatrical acts of +religion, and did not content himself with reading certain solemn phrases. +Raising his eyes to the crucifix above the altar, he uttered aloud a prayer +that if the oath was not sincerely taken the vengeance of God might fall +upon his head. Then, after blessing and embracing his sons, the venerable +monarch wrote to the Emperor of Austria, protesting that all that he did +was done under constraint, and that his obligations were null and void. +[314] + +[Affairs in Portugal, 1807-1820.] + +A month more passed, and in a third kingdom absolute government fell before +the combined action of soldiers and people. The Court of Lisbon had +migrated to Brazil in 1807, when the troops of Napoleon first appeared upon +the Tagus, and Portugal had since then been governed by a Regency, acting +in the name of the absent Sovereign. The events of the Peninsular War had +reduced Portugal almost to the condition of a dependency of Great Britain. +Marshal Beresford, the English commander-in-chief of its army, kept his +post when the war was over, and with him there remained a great number of +English officers who had led the Portuguese regiments in Wellington's +campaigns. The presence of these English soldiers was unwelcome, and +commercial rivalry embittered the natural feeling of impatience towards an +ally who remained as master rather than guest. Up to the year 1807 the +entire trade with Brazil had been confined by law to Portuguese merchants; +when, however, the Court had established itself beyond the Atlantic, it had +opened the ports of Brazil to British ships, in return for the assistance +given by our own country against Napoleon. Both England and Brazil profited +by the new commerce, but the Portuguese traders, who had of old had the +monopoly, were ruined. The change in the seat of government was in fact +seen to be nothing less than a reversal of the old relations between the +European country and its colony. Hitherto Brazil had been governed in the +interests of Portugal; but with a Sovereign fixed at Rio Janeiro, it was +almost inevitable that Portugal should be governed in the interests of +Brazil. Declining trade, the misery and impoverishment resulting from a +long war, resentment against a Court which could not be induced to return +to the kingdom and against a foreigner who could not be induced to quit it, +filled the army and all classes in the nation with discontent. Conspiracies +were discovered as early as 1817, and the conspirators punished with all +the barbarous ferocity of the Middle Ages. Beresford, who had not +sufficient tact to prevent the execution of a sentence ordering twelve +persons to be strangled, beheaded, and then burnt in the streets of Lisbon, +found, during the two succeeding years, that the state of the country was +becoming worse and worse. In the spring of 1820, when the Spanish +revolution had made some change in the neighbouring kingdom, either for +good or evil, inevitable, Beresford set out for Rio Janeiro, intending to +acquaint the King with the real condition of affairs, and to use his +personal efforts in hastening the return of the Court to Lisbon. Before he +could recross the Atlantic, the Government which he left behind him at +Lisbon had fallen. + +[Revolution at Oporto, August 1820.] + +The grievances of the Portuguese army made it the natural centre of +disaffection, but the military conspirators had their friends among all +classes. On the 24th of August, 1820, the signal of revolt was given at +Oporto. Priests and magistrates, as well as the town-population, united +with officers of the army in declaring against the Regency, and in +establishing a provisional Junta, charged with the duty of carrying on the +government in the name of the King until the Cortes should assemble and +frame a Constitution. No resistance was offered by any of the civil or +military authorities at Oporto. The Junta entered upon its functions, and +began by dismissing all English officers, and making up the arrears of pay +due to the soldiers. As soon as the news of the revolt reached Lisbon, the +Regency itself volunteered to summon the Cortes, and attempted to +conciliate the remainder of the army by imitating the measures of the Junta +of Oporto. [315] The troops, however, declined to act against their +comrades, and on the 15th of September the Regency was deposed, and a +provisional Junta installed in the capital. Beresford, who now returned +from Brazil, was forbidden to set foot on Portuguese soil. The two rival +governing-committees of Lisbon and Oporto coalesced; and after an interval +of confusion the elections to the Cortes were held, resulting in the return +of a body of men whose loyalty to the Crown was not impaired by their +hostility to the Regency. The King, when the first tidings of the +constitutional movement reached Brazil, gave a qualified consent to the +summoning of the Cortes which was announced by the Regency, and promised to +return to Europe. Beresford, continuing his voyage to England without +landing at Lisbon, found that the Government of this country had no +disposition to interfere with the domestic affairs of its ally. + +[Alexander proposes joint action with regard to Spain, April, 1820.] + +It was the boast of the Spanish and Italian Liberals that the revolutions +effected in 1820 were undisgraced by the scenes of outrage which had +followed the capture of the Bastille and the overthrow of French absolutism +thirty years before. [316] The gentler character of these southern +movements proved, however, no extenuation in the eyes of the leading +statesmen of Europe: on the contrary, the declaration of soldiers in favour +of a Constitution seemed in some quarters more ominous of evil than any +excess of popular violence. The alarm was first sounded at St. Petersburg. +As soon as the Czar heard of Riego's proceedings at Cadiz, he began to +meditate intervention; and when it was known that Ferdinand had been forced +to accept the Constitution of 1812, he ordered his ambassadors to propose +that all the Great Powers, acting through their Ministers at Paris, should +address a remonstrance to the representative of Spain, requiring the Cortes +to disavow the crime of the 8th of March, by which they had been called +into being, and to offer a pledge of obedience to their King by enacting +the most rigorous laws against sedition and revolt. [317] In that case, and +in that alone, the Czar desired to add, would the Powers maintain their +relations of confidence and amity with Spain. + +[England prevents joint diplomatic intervention.] + +This Russian proposal was viewed with some suspicion at Vienna; it was +answered with a direct and energetic negative from London. Canning was +still in the Ministry. The words with which in 1818 he had protested +against a league between England and autocracy were still ringing in the +ears of his colleagues. Lord Liverpool's Government knew itself to be +unpopular in the country; every consideration of policy as well as of +self-interest bade it resist the beginnings of an intervention which, if +confined to words, was certain to be useless, and, if supported by action, +was likely to end in that alliance between France and Russia which had been +the nightmare of English statesmen ever since 1814, and in a second +occupation of Spain by the very generals whom Wellington had spent so many +years in dislodging. Castlereagh replied to the Czar's note in terms which +made it clear that England would never give its sanction to a collective +interference with Spain. [318] Richelieu, the nominal head of the French +Government, felt too little confidence in his position to act without the +concurrence of Great Britain; and the crusade of absolutism against Spanish +liberty was in consequence postponed until the victory of the +Ultra-Royalists at Paris was complete, and the overthrow of Richelieu had +brought to the head of the French State a group of men who felt no scruple +in entering upon an aggressive war. + +[Naples and the Great Powers.] + +[Austria.] + +[England admits Austrian but not joint intervention.] + +But the shelter of circumstances which for a while protected Spain from the +foreigner did not extend to Italy, when in its turn the Neapolitan +revolution called a northern enemy into the field. Though the kingdom of +the Two Sicilies was in itself much less important than Spain, the +established order of the Continent was more directly threatened by a change +in its government. No European State was exposed to the same danger from a +revolution in Madrid as Austria from a revolution in Naples. The Czar had +invoked the action of the Courts against Spain, not because his own +dominions were in peril, but because the principle of monarchical right was +violated: with Austria the danger pressed nearer home. The establishment of +constitutional liberty in Naples was almost certain to be followed by an +insurrection in the Papal States and a national uprising in the Venetian +provinces; and among all the bad results of Austria's false position in +Italy, one of the worst was that in self-defence it was bound to resist +every step made towards political liberty beyond its own frontier. The +dismay with which Metternich heard of the collapse of absolute government +at Naples [319] was understood and even shared by the English Ministry, who +at this moment were deprived of their best guide by Canning's withdrawal. +Austria, in peace just as much as in war, had uniformly been held to be the +natural ally of England against the two aggressive Courts of Paris and St. +Petersburg. It seemed perfectly right and natural to Lord Castlereagh that +Austria, when its own interests were endangered by the establishment of +popular sovereignty at Naples, should intervene to restore King Ferdinand's +power; the more so as the secret treaty of 1815, by which Metternich had +bound this sovereign to maintain absolute monarchy, had been communicated +to the ambassador of Great Britain, and had received his approval. But the +right to intervene in Italy belonged, according to Lord Castlereagh, to +Austria alone. The Sovereigns of Europe had no more claim, as a body, to +interfere with Naples than they had to interfere with Spain. Therefore, +while the English Government sanctioned and even desired the intervention +of Austria, as a State acting in protection of its own interests against +revolution in a neighbouring country, it refused to sanction any joint +intervention of the European Powers, and declared itself opposed to the +meeting of a Congress where any such intervention might be discussed. [320] + +[Conference at Troppau, Oct. 1820.] + +Had Metternich been free to follow his own impulses, he would have thrown +an army into Southern Italy as soon as soldiers and stores could be +collected, and have made an end of King Ferdinand's troubles forthwith. It +was, however, impossible for him to disregard the wishes of the Czar, and +to abandon all at once the system of corporate action, which was supposed +to have done such great things for Europe. [321] A meeting of sovereigns +and Ministers was accordingly arranged, and at the end of October the +Emperor of Austria received the Czar and King Frederick William in the +little town of Troppau, in Moravia. France had itself first recommended the +summoning of a Congress to deal with Neapolitan affairs, and it was +believed for a while that England would be isolated in its resistance to a +joint intervention. But before the Congress assembled, the firm language of +the English Ministry had drawn Richelieu over to its side; [322] and +although one of the two French envoys made himself the agent of the +Ultra-Royalist faction, it was not possible for him to unite his country +with the three Eastern Courts. France, through the weakness of its +Government and the dissension between its representatives, counted for +nothing at the Congress. England sent its ambassador from Vienna, but with +instructions to act as an observer and little more; and in consequence the +meeting at Troppau resolved itself into a gathering of the three Eastern +autocrats and their Ministers. As Prussia had ceased to have any +independent foreign policy whatever, Metternich needed only to make certain +of the support of the Czar in order to range on his side the entire force +of eastern and central Europe in the restoration of Neapolitan despotism. + +[Contest between Metternich and Capodistrias.] + +[Circular of Troppau, Dec. 8, 1820.] + +[The principle of intervention laid down by three Courts.] + +The plan of the Austrian statesman was not, however, to be realised without +some effort. Alexander had watched with jealousy Metternich's recent +assumption of a dictatorship over the minor German Courts; he had never +admitted Austria's right to dominate in Italy; and even now some vestiges +of his old attachment to liberal theories made him look for a better +solution of the Neapolitan problem than in that restoration of despotism +pure and simple which Austria desired. While condemning every attempt of a +people to establish its own liberties, Alexander still believed that in +some countries sovereigns would do well to make their subjects a grant of +what he called sage and liberal institutions. It would have pleased him +best if the Neapolitans could have been induced by peaceful means to +abandon their Constitution, and to accept in return certain chartered +rights as a gift from their King; and the concurrence of the two Western +Powers might in this case possibly have been regained. This project of a +compromise, by which Ferdinand would have been freed from his secret +engagement with Austria, was exactly what Metternich desired to frustrate. +He found himself matched, and not for the first time, against a statesman +who was even more subtle than himself. This was Count Capodistrias, a Greek +who from a private position had risen to be Foreign Minister of Russia, and +was destined to become the first sovereign, in reality if not in title, of +his native land. Capodistrias, the sympathetic partner of the Czar's +earlier hopes, had not travelled so fast as his master along the +reactionary road. He still represented what had been the Italian policy of +Alexander some years before, and sought to prevent the re-establishment of +absolute rule at Naples, at least by the armed intervention of Austria. +Metternich's first object was to discredit the Minister in the eyes of his +sovereign. It is said that he touched the Czar's keenest fears in a +conversation relating to a mutiny that had just taken place among the +troops at St. Petersburg, and so in one private interview cut the ground +from under Capodistrias' feet; he also humoured the Czar by reviving that +monarch's own favourite scheme for a mutual guarantee of all the Powers +against revolution in any part of Europe. Alexander had proposed in 1818 +that the Courts should declare resistance to authority in any country to be +a violation of European peace, entitling the Allied Powers, if they should +think fit, to suppress it by force of arms. This doctrine, which would have +empowered the Czar to throw the armies of a coalition upon London if the +Reform Bill had been carried by force, had hitherto failed to gain +international acceptance owing to the opposition of Great Britain. It was +now formally accepted by Austria and Prussia. Alexander saw the federative +system of European monarchy, with its principle of collective intervention, +recognised as an established fact by at least three of the great Powers; +[323] and in return he permitted Metternich to lay down the lines which, in +the case of Naples, this intervention should follow. It was determined to +invite King Ferdinand to meet his brother-sovereigns at Laibach, in the +Austrian province of Carniola, and through him to address a summons to the +Neapolitan people, requiring them, in the name of the three Powers, and +under threat of invasion, to abandon their Constitution. This determination +was announced, as a settled matter, to the envoys of England and France; +and a circular was issued from Troppau by the three Powers to all the +Courts of Europe (Dec. 8), embodying the doctrine of federative +intervention, and expressing a hope that England and France would approve +its immediate application in the case of Naples. [324] + +[Protest of England.] + +There was no ground whatever for this hope with regard to England. On the +contrary, in proportion as the three Courts strengthened their union and +insisted on their claim to joint jurisdiction over Europe, they drove +England away from them. Lord Castlereagh had at first promised the moral +support of this country to Austria in its enterprise against Naples; but +when this enterprise ceased to be the affair of Austria alone, and became +part of the police-system of the three despotisms, it was no longer +possible for the English Government to view it with approval or even with +silence. The promise of a moral support was withdrawn: England declared +that it stood strictly neutral with regard to Naples, and protested against +the doctrine contained in the Troppau circular, that a change of government +in any State gave the Allied Powers the right to intervene. [325] + +France made no such protest; but it was still hoped at Paris that an +Austrian invasion of Southern Italy, so irritating to French pride, might +be averted. King Louis XVIII. endeavoured, but in vain, to act the part of +mediator, and to reconcile the Neapolitan House of Bourbon at once with its +own subjects and with the Northern Powers. + +[Conference at Laibach, Jan., 1821.] + +The summons went out from the Congress to King Ferdinand to appear at +Laibach. It found him enjoying all the popularity of a constitutional King, +surrounded by Ministers who had governed under Murat, exchanging +compliments with a democratic Parliament, lavishing distinctions upon the +men who had overthrown his authority, and swearing to everything that was +set before him. As the Constitution prohibited the King from leaving the +country without the consent of the Legislature, it was necessary for +Ferdinand to communicate to Parliament the invitation which he had received +from the Powers, and to take a vote of the Assembly on the subject of his +journey. Ferdinand's Ministers possessed some political experience; they +recognised that it would be impossible to maintain the existing +Constitution against the hostility of three great States, and hoped that +the Parliament would consent to Ferdinand's departure on condition that he +pledged himself to uphold certain specified principles of free government. +A message to the Assembly was accordingly made public, in which the King +expressed his desire to mediate with the Powers on this basis. But the +Ministers had not reckoned with the passions of the people. As soon as it +became known that Ferdinand was about to set out, the leaders of the +Carbonari mustered their bands. A host of violent men streamed into Naples +from the surrounding country. The Parliament was intimidated, and Ferdinand +was prohibited from leaving Naples until he had sworn to maintain the +Constitution actually in force, that, namely, which Naples had borrowed +from Spain. Ferdinand, whose only object was to escape from the country as +quickly as possible, took the oath with his usual effusions of patriotism. +He then set out for Leghorn, intending to cross from thence into Northern +Italy. No sooner had he reached the Tuscan port than he addressed a letter +to each of the five principal sovereigns of Europe, declaring that his last +acts were just as much null and void as all his earlier ones. He made no +attempt to justify, or to excuse, or even to explain his conduct; nor is +there the least reason to suppose that he considered the perjuries of a +prince to require a justification. "These sorry protests," wrote the +secretary of the Congress of Troppau, "will happily remain secret. No +Cabinet will be anxious to draw them from the sepulchre of its archives. +Till then there is not much harm done." + +[Ferdinand at Laibach.] + +[Demands of the Allies on Naples.] + +Ferdinand reached Laibach, where the Czar rewarded him for the fatigues of +his journey by a present of some Russian bears. His arrival was peculiarly +agreeable to Metternich, whose intentions corresponded exactly with his +own; and the fact that he had been compelled to swear to maintain the +Spanish Constitution at Naples acted favourably for the Austrian Minister, +inasmuch as it enabled him to say to all the world that negotiation was now +out of the question. [326] Capodistrias, brought face to face with failure, +twisted about, according to his rival's expression, like a devil in holy +water, but all in vain. It was decided that Ferdinand should be restored as +absolute monarch by an Austrian army, and that, whether the Neapolitans +resisted or submitted, their country should be occupied by Austrian troops +for some years to come. The only difficulty remaining was to vest King +Ferdinand's conduct in some respectable disguise. Capodistrias, when +nothing else was to be gained, offered to invent an entire correspondence, +in which Ferdinand should proudly uphold the Constitution to which he had +sworn, and protest against the determination of the Powers to force the +sceptre of absolutism back into his hand. [327] This device, however, was +thought too transparent. A letter was sent in the King's name to his son, +the Duke of Calabria, stating that he had found the three Powers determined +not to tolerate an order of things sprung from revolution; that submission +alone would avert war; but that even in case of submission certain +securities for order, meaning the occupation of the country by an Austrian +army, would be exacted. The letter concluded with the usual promises of +reform and good government. It reached Naples on the 9th of February, 1821. +No answer was either expected or desired. On the 6th the order had been +given to the Austrian army to cross the Po. + +[State of Naples and Sicily.] + +[The Austrians enter Naples, March 24, 1821.] + +[Third Neapolitan restoration.] + +There was little reason to fear any serious resistance on the part of the +Neapolitans. The administration of the State was thoroughly disorganised; +the agitation of the secret societies had destroyed all spirit of obedience +among the soldiers; a great part of the army was absent in Sicily, keeping +guard over a people who, under wiser management, might have doubled the +force which Naples now opposed to the invader. When the despotic government +of Ferdinand was overthrown, the island of Sicily, or that part of it which +was represented by Palermo, had claimed the separate political existence +which it had possessed between 1806 and 1815, offering to remain united to +Naples in the person of the sovereign, but demanding a National Parliament +and a National Constitution of its own. The revolutionary Ministers of +Naples had, however, no more sympathy with the wishes of the Sicilians than +the Spanish Liberals of 1812 had with those of the American Colonists. They +required the islanders to accept the same rights and duties as any other +province of the Neapolitan kingdom, and, on their refusal, sent over a +considerable force and laid siege to Palermo. [328] The contest soon ended +in the submission of the Sicilians, but it was found necessary to keep +twelve thousand troops on the island in order to prevent a new revolt. The +whole regular army of Naples numbered little more than forty thousand; and +although bodies of Carbonari and of the so-called Militia set out to join +the colours of General Pepe and to fight for liberty, they remained for the +most part a disorderly mob, without either arms or discipline. The invading +army of Austria, fifty thousand strong, not only possessed an immense +superiority in organisation and military spirit, but actually outnumbered +the forces of the defence. At the first encounter, which took place at +Rieti, in the Papal States, the Neapolitans were put to the rout. Their +army melted away, as it had in Murat's campaign in 1815. Nothing was heard +among officers and men but accusations of treachery; not a single strong +point was defended; and on the 24th of March the Austrians made their entry +into Naples. Ferdinand, halting at Florence, sent on before him the worst +instruments of his former despotism. It was indeed impossible for these men +to renew, under Austrian protection, the scenes of reckless bloodshed which +had followed the restoration of 1799; and a great number of compromised +persons had already been provided with the means of escape. But the hand of +vengeance was not easily stayed. Courts-martial and commissions of judges +began in all parts of the kingdom to sentence to imprisonment and death. An +attempted insurrection in Sicily and some desperate acts of rebellion in +Southern Italy cost the principal actors their lives; and when an amnesty +was at length proclaimed, an exception was made against those who were now +called the deserters, and who were lately called the Sacred Band, of Nola, +that is to say, the soldiers who had first risen for the Constitution. +Morelli, who had received the Viceroy's treacherous thanks for his conduct, +was executed, along with one of his companions; the rest were sent in +chains to labour among felons. Hundreds of persons were left lying, +condemned or uncondemned, in prison; others, in spite of the amnesty, were +driven from their native land; and that great, long-lasting stream of +fugitives now began to pour into England, which, in the early memories of +many who are not yet old, has associated the name of Italian with the image +of an exile and a sufferer. + +[Insurrection in Piedmont, March 10.] + +There was a moment in the campaign of Austria against Naples when the +invading army was threatened with the most serious danger. An insurrection +broke out in Piedmont, and the troops of that country attempted to unite +with the patriotic party of Lombardy in a movement which would have thrown +all Northern Italy upon the rear of the Austrians. In the first excess of +alarm, the Czar ordered a hundred thousand Russians to cross the Galician +frontier, and to march in the direction of the Adriatic. It proved +unnecessary, however, to continue this advance. The Piedmontese army was +divided against itself; part proclaimed the Spanish Constitution, and, on +the abdication of the King, called upon his cousin, the Regent, Charles +Albert of Carignano, to march against the Austrians; part adhered to the +rightful heir, the King's brother, Charles Felix, who was absent at Modena, +and who, with an honesty in strong contrast to the frauds of the Neapolitan +Court, refused to temporise with rebels, or to make any compromise with the +Constitution. The scruples of the Prince of Carignano, after he had gone +some way with the military party of action, paralysed the movement of +Northern Italy. Unsupported by Piedmontese troops, the conspirators of +Milan failed to raise any open insurrection. Austrian soldiers thronged +westwards from the Venetian fortresses, and entered Piedmont itself; the +collapse of the Neapolitan army destroyed the hopes of the bravest +patriots; and the only result of the Piedmontese movement was that the +grasp of Austria closed more tightly on its subject provinces, while the +martyrs of Italian freedom passed out of the sight of the world, out of the +range of all human communication, buried for years to come in the silent, +unvisited prison of the North. [329] + +[The French Ultra Royalists urging attack on Spain.] + +Thus the victory of absolutism was completed, and the law was laid down to +Europe that a people seeking its liberties elsewhere than in the grace and +spontaneous generosity of its legitimate sovereign became a fit object of +attack for the armies of the three Great Powers. It will be seen in a later +chapter how Metternich persuaded the Czar to include under the anathema +issued by the Congress of Laibach (May, 1821) [330] the outbreak of the +Greeks, which at this moment began, and how Lord Castlereagh supported the +Austrian Minister in denying to these rebels against the Sultan all right +or claim to the consideration of Europe. Spain was for the present left +unmolested; but the military operations of 1821 prepared the way for a +similar crusade against that country by occasioning the downfall of +Richelieu's Ministry, and throwing the government of France entirely into +the hands of the Ultra-Royalists. All parties in the French Chamber, +whether they condemned or approved the suppression of Neapolitan liberty, +censured a policy which had kept France in inaction, and made Austria +supreme in Italy. The Ultra-Royalists profited by the general discontent to +overthrow the Minister whom they had promised to support (Dec., 1821); and +from this time a war with Spain, conducted either by France alone or in +combination with the three Eastern Powers, became the dearest hope of the +rank and file of the dominant faction. Villele, their nominal chief, +remained what he had been before, a statesman among fanatics, and desired +to maintain the attitude of observation as long as this should be possible. +A body of troops had been stationed on the southern frontier in 1820 to +prevent all intercourse with the Spanish districts afflicted with the +yellow fever. This epidemic had passed away, but the number of the troops +was now raised to a hundred thousand. It was, however, the hope of Villele +that hostilities might be averted unless the Spaniards should themselves +provoke a combat, or, by resorting to extreme measures against King +Ferdinand, should compel Louis XVIII. to intervene on behalf of his +kinsman. The more violent section of the French Cabinet, represented by +Montmorency, the Foreign Minister, called for an immediate march on Madrid, +or proposed to delay operations only until France should secure the support +of the other Continental Powers. + +[Spain from 1820 to 1822.] + +[Ferdinand plots with the Serviles against the Constitution.] + +The condition of Spain in the year 1822 gave ample encouragement to those +who longed to employ the arms of France in the royalist cause. The hopes of +peaceful reform, which for the first few months after the revolution had +been shared even by foreign politicians at Madrid, had long vanished. In +the moment of popular victory Ferdinand had brought the leaders of the +Cortes from their prisons and placed them in office. These men showed a +dignified forgetfulness of the injuries which they had suffered. Misfortune +had calmed their impetuosity, and taught them more of the real condition of +the Spanish people. They entered upon their task with seriousness and good +faith, and would have proved the best friends of constitutional monarchy if +Ferdinand had had the least intention of co-operating with them loyally. +But they found themselves encountered from the first by a double enemy. The +clergy, who had overthrown the Constitution six years before, intrigued or +openly declared against it as soon as it was revived; the more violent of +the Liberals, with Riego at their head, abandoned themselves to +extravagances like those of the club-orators of Paris in 1791, and did +their best to make any peaceable administration impossible. After combating +these anarchists, or Exaltados, with some success, the Ministry was forced +to call in their aid, when, at the instigation of the Papal Nuncio, the +King placed his veto upon a law dissolving most of the monasteries [331] +(Oct., 1820). Ferdinand now openly combined with the enemies of the +Constitution, and attempted to transfer the command of the army to one of +his own agents. The plot failed; the Ministry sent the alarm over the whole +country, and Ferdinand stood convicted before his people as a conspirator +against the Constitution which he had sworn to defend. The agitation of the +clubs, which the Ministry had hitherto suppressed, broke out anew. A storm +of accusations assailed Ferdinand himself. He was compelled at the end of +the year 1820 to banish from Madrid most of the persons who had been his +confidants; and although his dethronement was not yet proposed, he had +already become, far more than Louis XVI. of France under similar +conditions, the recognised enemy of the revolution, and the suspected +patron of every treason against the nation. + +[The Ministry between the Exaltados and Serviles, 1821.] + +[Attempted coup d'etat, July 6, 1822.] + +[Royalists revolt in the north.] + +The attack of the despotic Courts on Naples in the spring of 1821 +heightened the fury of parties in Spain, encouraging the Serviles, or +Absolutists, in their plots, and forcing the Ministry to yield to the cry +for more violent measures against the enemies of the Constitution. In the +south of Spain the Exaltados gained possession of the principal military +and civil commands, and openly refused obedience to the central +administration when it attempted to interfere with their action Seville, +Carthagena, and Cadiz acted as if they were independent Republics and even +spoke of separation from Spain. Defied by its own subordinates in the +provinces, and unable to look to the King for any sincere support, the +moderate governing party lost all hold upon the nation. In the Cortes +elected in 1822 the Exaltados formed the majority, and Riego was appointed +President. Ferdinand now began to concert measures of action with the +French Ultra-Royalists. The Serviles, led by priests, and supported by +French money, broke into open rebellion in the north. When the session of +the Cortes ended, the King attempted to overthrow his enemies by military +force. Three battalions of the Royal Guard, which had been withdrawn from +Madrid, received secret orders to march upon the capital (July 6, 1822), +where Ferdinand was expected to place himself at their head. They were, +however, met and defeated in the streets by other regiments, and Ferdinand, +vainly attempting to dissociate himself from the action of his partisans, +found his crown, if not his life, in peril. He wrote to Louis XVIII. that +he was a prisoner. Though the French King gave nothing more than good +counsel, the Ultra-Royalists in the French Cabinet and in the army now +strained every nerve to accelerate a war between the two countries. The +Spanish Absolutists seized the town of Seo d'Urgel, and there set up a +provisional government. Civil war spread over the northern provinces. The +Ministry, which was now formed of Riego's friends, demanded and obtained +from the Cortes dictatorial powers like those which the French Committee of +Public Safety had wielded in 1793, but with far other result. Spain found +no Danton, no Carnot, at this crisis, when the very highest powers of +intellect and will would have been necessary to arouse and to arm a people +far less disposed to fight for liberty than the French were in 1793. One +man alone, General Mina, checked and overthrew the rebel leaders of the +north with an activity superior to their own. The Government, boastful and +violent in its measures, effected scarcely anything in the organisation of +a national force, or in preparing the means of resistance against those +foreign armies with whose attack the country was now plainly threatened. + +[England and the Congress of 1822.] + +When the Congress of Laibach broke up in the spring of 1821. its members +determined to renew their meeting in the following year, in order to decide +whether the Austrian army might then be withdrawn from Naples, and to +discuss other questions affecting their common interests. The progress of +the Greek insurrection and a growing strife between Russia and Turkey had +since then thrown all Italian difficulties into the shade. The Eastern +question stood in the front rank of European politics; next in importance +came the affairs of Spain. It was certain that these, far more than the +occupation of Naples, would supply the real business of the Congress of +1822. England had a far greater interest in both questions than in the +Italian negotiations of the two previous years. It was felt that the system +of abstention which England had then followed could be pursued no longer, +and that the country must be represented not by some casual and wandering +diplomatist, but by its leading Minister, Lord Castlereagh. The intentions +of the other Powers in regard to Spain were matter of doubt; it was the +fixed policy of Great Britain to leave the Spanish revolution in Europe to +run its own course, and to persuade the other Powers to do the same. But +the difficulties connected with Spain did not stop at the Spanish frontier. +The South American colonies had now in great part secured their +independence. They had developed a trade with Great Britain which made it +impossible for this country to ignore their flag and the decisions of their +law courts. The British navigation-laws had already been modified by +Parliament in favour of their shipping; and although it was no business of +the English Government to grant a formal title to communities which had +made themselves free, the practical recognition of the American States by +the appointment of diplomatic agents could in several cases not be justly +delayed. Therefore, without interfering with any colonies which were still +fighting or still negotiating with Spain, the British Minister proposed to +inform the Allied cabinets of the intention of this country to accredit +agents to some of the South American Republics, and to recommend to them +the adoption of a similar policy. + +[Death of Castlereagh, Aug. 12, 1822.] + +Such was the tenour of the instructions which, a few weeks before his +expected departure for the Continent, Castlereagh drew up for his own +guidance, and submitted to the Cabinet and the King. [332] Had he lived to +fulfil the mission with which he was charged, the recognition of the South +American Republics, which adds so bright a ray to the fame of Canning, +would probably have been the work of the man who, more than any other, is +associated in popular belief with the traditions of a hated and outworn +system of oppression. Two more years of life, two more years of change in +the relations of England to the Continent, would have given Castlereagh a +different figure in the history both of Greece and of America. No English +statesman in modern times has been so severely judged. Circumstances, down +to the close of his career, withheld from Castlereagh the opportunities +which fell to his successor; ties from which others were free made it hard +for him to accelerate the breach with the Allies of 1814. Antagonists +showed Castlereagh no mercy, no justice. The man whom Byron disgraced +himself by ridiculing after his death possessed in a rich measure the +qualities which, in private life, attract esteem and love. His public life, +if tainted in earlier days by the low political morality of the time, rose +high above that of every Continental statesman of similar rank, with the +single exception of Stein. The best testimony to his integrity is the +irritation which it caused to Talleyrand. [333] If the consciousness of +labour unflaggingly pursued in the public cause, and animated on the whole +by a pure and earnest purpose, could have calmed the distress of a breaking +mind, the decline of Castlereagh's days might have been one of peace. His +countrymen would have recognised that, if blind to the rights of nations, +Castlereagh had set to foreign rulers the example of truth and good faith. +But the burden of his life was too heavy to bear. Mists of despondency +obscured the outlines of the real world, and struck chill into his heart. +Death, self-invoked, brought relief to the over-wrought brain, and laid +Castlereagh, with all his cares, in everlasting sleep. + +[Canning Foreign Secretary. Wellington deputed to the Congress, Sept., +1822.] + +[Congress of Verona, Oct., 1822.] + +The vacant post was filled by Canning, by far the most gifted of the band +of statesmen who had begun their public life in the school of Pitt. +Wellington undertook to represent England at the Congress of 1822, which +was now about to open at Vienna. His departure was, however, delayed for +several weeks, and the preliminary meeting, at which it had been intended +to transact all business not relating to Italy, was almost over before his +arrival. Wellington accordingly travelled on to Verona, where Italian +affairs were to be dealt with; and the Italian Conference, which the +British Government had not intended to recognise, thus became the real +Congress of 1822. Anxious as Lord Castlereagh had been on the question of +foreign interference with Spain, he hardly understood the imminence of the +danger. In passing through Paris, Wellington learnt for the first time that +a French or European invasion of Spain would be the foremost object of +discussion among the Powers; and on reaching Verona he made the unwelcome +discovery that the Czar was bent upon sending a Russian army to take part, +as the mandatary of Europe, in overthrowing the Spanish Constitution. +Alexander's desire was to obtain a joint declaration from the Congress like +that which had been issued against Naples by the three Courts at Troppau, +but one even more formidable, since France might be expected in the present +case to give its concurrence, which had been withheld before. France indeed +occupied, according to the absolutist theory of the day, the same position +in regard to a Jacobin Spain as Austria in regard to a Jacobin Naples, and +might perhaps claim to play the leading military part in the crusade of +repression. But the work was likely to be a much more difficult one than +that of 1821. The French troops, said the Czar, were not trustworthy; and +there was a party in France which might take advantage of the war to +proclaim the second Napoleon or the Republic. King Louis XVIII. could not +therefore be allowed to grapple with Spain alone. It was necessary that the +principal force employed by the alliance should be one whose loyalty and +military qualities were above suspicion: the generals who had marched from +Moscow to Paris were not likely to fail beyond the Pyrenees: and a campaign +of the Russian army in Western Europe promised to relieve the Czar of some +of the discontent of his soldiers, who had been turned back after entering +Galicia in the previous year, and who had not been allowed to assist their +fellow-believers in Greece in their struggle against the Sultan. [334] + +[No joint declaration by made by the Congress against Spain.] + +Wellington had ascertained, while in Paris, that King Louis XVIII. and +Villele were determined under no circumstances to give Russian troops a +passage through France. His knowledge of this fact enabled him to speak +with some confidence to Alexander. It was the earnest desire of the English +Government to avert war, and its first object was therefore to prevent the +Congress, as a body, from sending an ultimatum to Spain. If all the Powers +united in a declaration like that of Troppau, war was inevitable; if France +were left to settle its own disputes with its neighbour, English mediation +might possibly preserve peace. The statement of Wellington, that England +would rather sever itself from the great alliance than consent to a joint +declaration against Spain, had no doubt its effect in preventing such a +declaration being proposed; but a still weightier reason against it was the +direct contradiction between the intentions of the French Government and +those of the Czar. If the Czar was determined to be the soldier of Europe, +while on the other hand King Louis absolutely denied him a passage through +France, it was impossible that the Congress should threaten Spain with a +collective attack. No great expenditure of diplomacy was therefore +necessary to prevent the summary framing of a decree against Spain like +that which had been framed against Naples two years before. In the first +despatches which he sent back to England Wellington expressed his belief +that the deliberations of the Powers would end in a decision to leave the +Spaniards to themselves. + +[Course of the negotiation against Spain.] + +But the danger was only averted in appearance. The impulse to war was too +strong among the French Ultra-Royalists for the Congress to keep silence on +Spanish affairs. Villele indeed still hoped for peace, and, unlike other +members of his Cabinet, he desired that, if war should arise, France should +maintain entire freedom of action, and enter upon the struggle as an +independent Power, not as the instrument of the European concert. This did +not prevent him, however, from desiring to ascertain what assistance would +be forthcoming, if France should be hard pressed by its enemy. Instructions +were given to the French envoys at Verona to sound the Allies on this +question. [335] It was out of the inquiry so suggested that a negotiation +sprang which virtually combined all Europe against Spain. The envoy +Montmorency, acting in the spirit of the war party, demanded of all the +Powers whether, in the event of France withdrawing its ambassador from +Madrid, they would do the same, and whether, in case of war, France would +receive their moral and material support. Wellington in his reply protested +against the framing of hypothetical cases; the other envoys answered +Montmorency's questions in the affirmative. The next step was taken by +Metternich, who urged that certain definite acts of the Spanish people or +Government ought to be specified as rendering war obligatory on France and +its allies, and also that, with a view of strengthening the Royalist party +in Spain, notes ought to be presented by all the ambassadors at Madrid, +demanding a change in the Constitution. This proposal was in its turn +submitted to Wellington and rejected by him. It was accepted by the other +plenipotentiaries, and the acts of the Spanish people were specified on +which war should necessarily follow. These were, the commission of any act +of violence against a member of the royal family, the deposition of the +King, or an attempt to change the dynasty. A secret clause was added to the +second part of the agreement, to the effect that if the Spanish Government +made no satisfactory answer to the notes requiring a change in the +Constitution, all the ambassadors should be immediately withdrawn. A draft +of the notes to be presented was sketched; and Montmorency, who thought +that he had probably gone too far in his stipulations, returned to Paris to +submit the drafts to the King before handing them over to the ambassadors +at Paris for transmission to Madrid. + +[Villele and Montmorency.] + +[Speech of Louis XVIII., Jan. 27, 1823.] + +It was with great dissatisfaction that Villele saw how his colleague had +committed France to the direction of the three Eastern Powers. There was no +likelihood that the Spanish Government would make the least concession of +the kind required, and in that case France stood pledged, if the action of +Montmorency was ratified, to withdraw its ambassador from Madrid at once. +Villele accordingly addressed himself to the ambassadors at Paris, asking +that the despatch of the notes might be postponed. No notice was taken of +his request: the notes were despatched forthwith. Roused by this slight, +Villele appealed to the King not to submit to the dictation of foreign +Courts. Louis XVIII. declared in his favour against all the rest of the +Cabinet, and Montmorency had to retire from office. But the decision of the +King meant that he disapproved of the negotiations of Verona as shackling +the movements of France, not that he had freed himself from the influence +of the war-party. Chateaubriand, the most reckless agitator for +hostilities, was appointed Foreign Minister. The mediation of Great Britain +was rejected; [336] and in his speech at the opening of the Chambers of +1823, King Louis himself virtually published the declaration of war. + +[England in 1823.] + +[French invasion of Spain, April, 1823.] + +The ambassadors of the three Eastern Courts had already presented their +notes at Madrid demanding a change in the Constitution; and, after +receiving a high-spirited answer from the Ministers, they had quitted the +country. Canning, while using every diplomatic effort to prevent an unjust +war, had made it clear to the Spaniards that England could not render them +armed assistance. The reasons against such an intervention were indeed +overwhelming. Russia, Austria, and Prussia would have taken the field +rather than have permitted the Spanish Constitution to triumph; and +although, if leagued with Spain in a really national defence like that of +1808, Great Britain might perhaps have protected the Peninsula against all +the Powers of Europe combined, it was far otherwise when the cause at stake +was one to which a majority of the Spanish nation had shown itself to be +indifferent, and against which the northern provinces had actually taken up +arms. The Government and the Cortes were therefore left to defend +themselves as best they could against their enemies. They displayed their +weakness by enacting laws of extreme severity against deserters, and by +retiring, along with the recalcitrant King, from Madrid to Seville. On the +7th of April the French troops, led by the Duke of Angouleme, crossed the +frontier. The priests and a great part of the peasantry welcomed them as +deliverers: the forces opposed to them fell back without striking a blow. +As the invader advanced towards the capital, gangs of royalists, often led +by monks, spread such terror and devastation over the northern provinces +that the presence of foreign troops became the only safeguard for the +peaceable inhabitants. [337] Madrid itself was threatened by the corps of a +freebooter named Bessieres. The commandant sent his surrender to the French +while they were still at some distance, begging them to advance as quickly +as possible in order to save the city from pillage. The message had +scarcely been sent when Bessieres and his bandits appeared in the suburbs. +The governor drove them back, and kept the royalist mob within the city at +bay for four days more. On the 23rd of May the advance-guard of the French +army entered the capital. + +[Angouleme and the Regency, and the ambassadors.] + +It had been the desire of King Louis XVIII. and Angouleme to save Spain +from the violence of royalist and priestly fanaticism. On reaching Madrid, +Angouleme intended to appoint a provisional, government himself; he was, +however, compelled by orders from Paris to leave the election in the hands +of the Council of Castille, and a Regency came into power whose first acts +showed in what spirit the victory of the French was to be used. Edicts were +issued declaring all the acts of the Cortes affecting the monastic orders +to be null and void, dismissing all officials appointed since March 7, +1820, and subjecting to examination those who, then being in office, had +not resigned their posts. [338] The arrival of the ambassadors of the three +Eastern Powers encouraged the Regency in their antagonism to the French +commander. It was believed that the Cabinet of Paris was unwilling to +restore King Ferdinand as an absolute monarch, and intended to obtain from +him the grant of institutions resembling those of the French Charta. Any +such limitation of absolute power was, however, an object of horror to the +three despotic Courts. Their ambassadors formed themselves into a council +with the express object of resisting the supposed policy of Angouleme. The +Regency grew bolder, and gave the signal for general retribution upon the +Liberals by publishing an order depriving all persons who had served in the +voluntary militia since March, 1820, of their offices, pensions, and +titles. The work inaugurated in the capital was carried much further in the +provinces. The friends of the Constitution, and even soldiers who were +protected by their capitulation with the French, were thrown into prison by +the new local authorities. The violence of the reaction reached such a +height that Angouleme, now on the march to Cadiz, was compelled to publish +an ordinance forbidding arrests to be made without the consent of a French +commanding officer, and ordering his generals to release the persons who +had been arbitrarily imprisoned. The council of ambassadors, blind in their +jealousy of France to the danger of an uncontrolled restoration, drew up a +protest against his ordinance, and desired that the officers of the Regency +should be left to work their will. + +[The Cortes at Cadiz.] + +[Ferdinand liberated, Oct. 1.] + +After spending some weeks in idle debates at Seville, the Cortes had been +compelled by the appearance of the French on the Sierra Morena to retire to +Cadiz. As King Ferdinand refused to accompany them, he was declared +temporarily insane, and forced to make the journey (June 12). Angouleme, +following the French vanguard after a considerable interval, appeared +before Cadiz in August, and sent a note to King Ferdinand, recommending him +to publish an amnesty, and to promise the restoration of the mediaeval +Cortes. It was hoped that the terms suggested in this note might be +accepted by the Government in Cadiz as a basis of peace, and so render an +attack upon the city unnecessary. The Ministry, however, returned a defiant +answer in the King's name. The siege of Cadiz accordingly began in earnest. +On the 30th of August the fort of the Trocadero was stormed; three weeks +later the city was bombarded. In reply to all proposals for negotiation +Angouleme stated that he could only treat when King Ferdinand was within +his own lines. There was not the least hope of prolonging the defence of +Cadiz with success, for the combat was dying out even in those few +districts of Spain where the constitutional troops had fought with energy. +Ferdinand himself pretended that he bore no grudge against his Ministers, +and that the Liberals had nothing to fear from his release. On the 30th of +September he signed, as if with great satisfaction, an absolute and +universal amnesty. [339] On the following day he was conveyed with his +family across the bay to Angouleme's head-quarters. + +[Violence of the Restoration.] + +The war was over: the real results of the French invasion now came into +sight. Ferdinand had not been twelve hours in the French camp when, +surrounded by monks and royalist desperadoes, he published a proclamation +invalidating every act of the constitutional Government of the last three +years, on the ground that his sanction had been given under constraint. The +same proclamation ratified the acts of the Regency of Madrid. As the +Regency of Madrid had declared all persons concerned in the removal of the +King to Cadiz to be liable to the penalties of high treason, Ferdinand had +in fact ratified a sentence of death against several of the men from whom +he had just parted in friendship. [340] Many of these victims of the King's +perfidy were sent into safety by the French. But Angouleme was powerless to +influence Ferdinand's policy and conduct. Don Saez, the King's confessor, +was made First Secretary of State. On the 4th of October an edict was +issued banishing for ever from Madrid, and from the country fifty miles +round it, every person who during the last three years had sat in the +Cortes, or who had been a Minister, counsellor of State, judge, commander, +official in any public office, magistrate, or officer in the so-called +voluntary militia. It was ordered that throughout Spain a solemn service +should be celebrated in expiation of the insults offered to the Holy +Sacrament; that missions should be sent over the land to combat the +pernicious and heretical doctrines associated with the late outbreak, and +that the bishops should relegate to monasteries of the strictest observance +the priests who had acted as the agents of an impious faction. [341] Thus +the war of revenge was openly declared against the defeated party. It was +in vain that Angouleme indignantly reproached the King, and that the +ambassadors of the three Eastern Courts pressed him to draw up at least +some kind of amnesty. Ferdinand travelled slowly towards Madrid, saying +that he could take no such step until he reached the capital. On the 7th of +November, Riego was hanged. Thousands of persons were thrown into prison, +or compelled to fly from the country. Except where order was preserved by +the French, life and property were at the mercy of royalist mobs and the +priests who led them; and although the influence of the Russian statesman +Pozzo di Borgo at length brought a respectable Ministry into office, this +only roused the fury of the clerical party, and led to a cry for the +deposition of the King, and for the elevation of his more fanatical +brother, Don Carlos, to the throne. Military commissions were instituted at +the beginning of 1824 for the trial of accused persons, and a pretended +amnesty, published six months later, included in its fifteen classes of +exception the participators in almost every act of the revolution. +Ordinance followed upon ordinance, multiplying the acts punishable with +death, and exterminating the literature which was believed to be the source +of all religious and social heterodoxy. Every movement of life was watched +by the police; every expression of political opinion was made high treason. +Young men were shot for being freemasons; women were sent to prison for ten +years for possessing a portrait of Riego. The relation of the restored +Government to its subjects was in fact that which belonged to a state of +civil war. Insurrections arose among the fanatics who were now taking the +name of the Carlist or Apostolic party, as well as among a despairing +remnant of the Constitutionalists. After a feeble outbreak of the latter at +Tarifa, a hundred and twelve persons were put to death by the military +commissions within eighteen days. [342] It was not until the summer of 1825 +that the jurisdiction of these tribunals and the Reign of Terror ended. + +[England prohibits the conquest of Spanish colonies by France or its +allies.] + +[England recognises the independence of the colonies. 1824-5.] + +France had won a cheap and inglorious victory. The three Eastern Courts had +seen their principle of absolutism triumph at the cost of everything that +makes government morally better than anarchy. One consolation remained for +those who felt that there was little hope for freedom on the Continent of +Europe. The crusade against Spanish liberty had put an end for ever to the +possibility of a joint conquest of Spanish America in the interest of +despotism. The attitude of England was no longer what it had been in 1818. +When the Czar had proposed at the Congress of Aix-la-Chapelle that the +allied monarchs should suppress the republican principle beyond the seas, +Castlereagh had only stated that England could bear no part in such an +enterprise; he had not said that England would effectually prevent others +from attempting it. This was the resolution by which Canning, isolated and +baffled by the conspiracy of Verona, proved that England could still do +something to protect its own interest and the interests of mankind against +a league of autocrats. There is indeed little doubt that the independence +of the Spanish colonies would have been recognised by Great Britain soon +after the war of 1823, whoever might have been our Minister for Foreign +Affairs, but this recognition was a different matter in the hands of +Canning from what it would have been in the hands of his predecessor. The +contrast between the two men was one of spirit rather than of avowed rules +of action. Where Castlereagh offered apologies to the Continental +sovereigns, Canning uttered defiance [343] The treaties of 1815, which +connected England so closely with the foreign courts, were no work of his; +though he sought not to repudiate them, he delighted to show that in spite +of them England has still its own policy, its own sympathies, its own +traditions. In face of the council of kings and its assumption of universal +jurisdiction, he publicly described himself as an enthusiast for the +independence of nations. If others saw little evidence that France intended +to recompense itself for its services to Ferdinand by appropriating some of +his rebellious colonies, Canning was quick to lay hold of every suspicious +circumstance. At the beginning of the war of 1823 he gave a formal warning +to the ambassador of Louis XVIII. that France would not be permitted to +bring any of these provinces under its dominion, whether by conquest or +cession. [344] When the war was over, he rejected the invitation of +Ferdinand's Government to take part in a conference at Paris, where the +affairs of South America were to be laid before the Allied Powers. [345] +What these Powers might or might not think on the subject of America was +now a matter of indifference, for the policy of England was fixed, and it +was useless to debate upon a conclusion that could not be altered. British +consular agents were appointed in most of the colonies before the close of +the year 1823; and after some interval the independence of Buenos Ayres, +Colombia, and Mexico were formally recognised by the conclusion of +commercial treaties. "I called the New World into existence," cried +Canning, when reproached with permitting the French occupation of Spain, +"in order to redress the balance of the Old." The boast, famous in our +Parliamentary history, has left an erroneous impression of the part really +played by Canning at this crisis. He did not call the New World into +existence; he did not even assist it in winning independence, as France had +assisted the United States fifty years before; but when this independence +had been won, he threw over it the aegis of Great Britain, declaring that +no other European Power should reimpose the yoke which Spain had not been +able to maintain. + +[Affairs in Portugal.] + +[Constitution granted by Petro, May, 1826.] + +The overthrow of the Spanish Constitution by foreign arms led to a series +of events in Portugal which forced England to a more direct intervention in +the Peninsula than had yet been necessary, and heightened the conflict that +had sprung up between its policy and that of Continental absolutism. The +same parties and the same passions, political and religious, existed in +Portugal as in Spain, and the enemies of the Constitution found the same +support at foreign Courts. The King of Portugal, John VI., was a weak but +not ill-meaning man; his wife, who was a sister of Ferdinand of Spain, and +his son Don Miguel were the chiefs of the conspiracy against the Cortes. In +June, 1823, a military revolt, arranged by Miguel, brought the existing +form of government to an end: the King promised, however, when dissolving +the Cortes, that a Constitution should be bestowed by himself upon +Portugal; and he seems to have intended to keep his word. The ambassadors +of France and Austria were, however, busy in throwing hindrances in the +way, and Don Miguel prepared to use violence to prevent his father from +making any concession to the Liberals. King John, in fear for his life, +applied to England for troops; Canning declined to land soldiers at Lisbon, +but sent a squadron, with orders to give the King protection. The winter of +1823 was passed in intrigues; in May, 1824, Miguel arrested the Ministers +and surrounded the King's palace with troops. After several days of +confusion King John made his escape to the British ships, and Miguel, who +was alternately cowardly and audacious, then made his submission, and was +ordered to leave the country. King John died in the spring of 1826 without +having granted a Constitution. Pedro, his eldest son, had already been made +Emperor of Brazil; and, as it was impossible that Portugal and Brazil could +again be united, it was arranged that Pedro's daughter, when of sufficient +age, should marry her uncle Miguel, and so save Portugal from the danger of +a contested succession. Before renouncing the crown of Portugal, Pedro +granted a Constitution to that country. A Regency had already been +appointed by King John, in which neither the Queen-dowager nor Miguel was +included. + +[Desertion of Portuguese soldiery, 1826.] + +[Spain permits the deserters to attack Portugal.] + +[Canning sends troops to Lisbon, Dec., 1826.] + +Miguel had gone to Vienna. Although a sort of Caliban in character and +understanding, this Prince met with the welcome due to a kinsman of the +Imperial house, and to a representative of the good cause of absolutism. He +was received by Metternich with great interest, and his fortunes were taken +under the protection of the Austrian Court. In due time, it was hoped this +savage and ignorant churl would do yeoman's service to Austrian principles +in the Peninsula. But the Regency and the new Constitution of Portugal had +not to wait for the tardy operation of Metternich's covert hostility. The +soldiery who had risen at Miguel's bidding in 1823 now proclaimed him King, +and deserted to Spanish soil. Within the Spanish frontier they were +received by Ferdinand's representatives with open arms. The demands made by +the Portuguese ambassador at Madrid for their dispersion and for the +surrender of their weapons were evaded. The cause of these armed bands on +the frontier became the cause of the Clerical and Ultra-Royalist party over +all Europe. Money was sent to them from France and Austria. They were +joined by troops of Spanish Carlists or Apostolicals; they were fed, +clothed, and organised, if not by the Spanish Government itself, at least +by those over whose action the Spanish Government exercised control. [346] +Thus raised to considerable military strength, they made incursions into +Portugal, and at last attempted a regular invasion. The Regency of Lisbon, +justly treating these outrages as the act of the Spanish Government, and +appealing to the treaties which bound Great Britain to defend Portugal +against foreign attack, demanded the assistance of this country. More was +involved in the action taken by Canning than a possible contest with Spain; +the seriousness of the danger lay in the fact that Spain was still occupied +by French armies, and that a war with Spain might, and probably would, +involve a war with France, if not with other Continental Powers. But the +English Ministry waited only for the confirmation of the alleged facts by +their own ambassador. The treaty-rights of Portugal were undoubted; the +temper of the English Parliament and nation, strained to the utmost by the +events of the last three years, was such that a war against Ferdinand and +against the destroyers of Spanish liberty would have caused more rejoicing +than alarm. Nine days after the formal demand of the Portuguese arrived, +four days after their complaint was substantiated by the report of our +ambassador, Canning announced to the House of Commons that British troops +were actually on the way to Lisbon. In words that alarmed many of his own +party, and roused the bitter indignation of every Continental Court, +Canning warned those whose acts threatened to force England into war, that +the war, if war arose, would be a war of opinion, and that England, however +earnestly she might endeavour to avoid it, could not avoid seeing ranked +under her banner all the restless and discontented of any nation with which +she might come into conflict. As for the Portuguese Constitution which +formed the real object of the Spanish attack, it had not, Canning said, +been given at the instance of Great Britain, but he prayed that Heaven +might prosper it. It was impossible to doubt that a Minister who spoke +thus, and who, even under expressions of regret, hinted at any alliance +with the revolutionary elements in France and Spain, was formidably in +earnest. The words and the action of Canning produced the effect which he +desired. The Government of Ferdinand discovered the means of checking the +activity of the Apostolicals: the presence of the British troops at Lisbon +enabled the Portuguese Regency to throw all its forces upon the invaders +and to drive them from the country. They were disbanded when they +re-crossed the Spanish frontier; the French Court loudly condemned their +immoral enterprise; and the Constitution of Portugal seemed, at least for +the moment, to have triumphed over its open and its secret enemies. + +[The policy of Canning.] + +The tone of the English Government had indeed changed since the time when +Metternich could express a public hope that the three Eastern Powers would +have the approval of this country in their attack upon the Constitution of +Naples. In 1820 such a profession might perhaps have passed for a mistake; +in 1826 it would have been a palpable absurdity. Both in England and on the +Continent it was felt that the difference between the earlier and the later +spirit of our policy was summed up in the contrast between Canning and +Castlereagh. It has become an article of historical faith that +Castlereagh's melancholy death brought one period of our foreign policy to +a close and inaugurated another: it has been said that Canning liberated +England from its Continental connexions; it has even been claimed for him +that he performed for Europe no less a task than the dissolution of the +Holy Alliance. [347] The figure of Canning is indeed one that will for ever +fill a great space in European history; and the more that is known of the +opposition which he encountered both from his sovereign and from his great +rival Wellington, the greater must be our admiration for his clear, strong +mind, and for the conquering force of his character. But the legend which +represents English policy as taking an absolutely new departure in 1822 +does not correspond to the truth of history. Canning was a member of the +Cabinet from 1816 to 1820; it is a poor compliment to him to suppose that +he either exercised no influence upon his colleagues or acquiesced in a +policy of which he disapproved; and the history of the Congress of +Aix-la-Chapelle proves that his counsels had even at that time gained the +ascendant. The admission made by Castlereagh in 1820, after Canning had +left the Cabinet, that Austria, as a neighbouring and endangered State, had +a right to suppress the revolutionary constitution of Naples, would +probably not have gained Canning's assent; in all other points, the action +of our Government at Troppau and Laibach might have been his own. Canning +loved to speak of his system as one of neutrality, and of non-interference +in that struggle between the principles of despotism and of democracy which +seemed to be spreading over Europe. He avowed his sympathy for Spain as the +object of an unjust and unprovoked war, but he most solemnly warned the +Spaniards not to expect English assistance. He prayed that the Constitution +of Portugal might prosper, but he expressly disclaimed all connection with +its origin, and defended Portugal not because it was a Constitutional +State, but because England was bound by treaties to defend it against +foreign invasion. The arguments against intervention on behalf of Spain +which Canning addressed to the English sympathisers with that country might +have been uttered by Castlereagh; the denial of the right of foreign Powers +to attack the Spanish Constitution, with which Castlereagh headed his own +instructions for Verona, might have been written by Canning. + +[Canning and the European concert.] + +The statements that Canning withdrew England from the Continental system, +and that he dissolved the Holy Alliance, cannot be accepted without large +correction. The general relations existing between the Great Powers were +based, not on the ridiculous and obsolete treaty of Holy Alliance, but on +the Acts which were signed at the Conference of Aix-la-Chapelle. The first +of these was the secret Quadruple Treaty which bound England and the three +Eastern Powers to attack France in case a revolution in that country should +endanger the peace of Europe; the second was the general declaration of all +the five Powers that they would act in amity and take counsel with one +another. From the first of these alliances Canning certainly did not +withdraw England. He would perhaps have done so in 1823 if the Quadruple +Treaty had bound England to maintain the House of Bourbon on the French +throne; but it had been expressly stated that the deposition of the +Bourbons would not necessarily and in itself be considered by England as +endangering the peace of Europe. This treaty remained in full force up to +Canning's death; and if a revolutionary army had marched from Paris upon +Antwerp, he would certainly have claimed the assistance of the three +Eastern Powers. With respect to the general concert of Europe, established +or confirmed by the declaration of Aix-la-Chapelle, this had always been +one of varying extent and solidity. Both France and England had held +themselves aloof at Troppau. The federative action was strongest and most +mischievous not before but after the death of Castlereagh, and in the +period that followed the Congress of Verona; for though the war against +Spain was conducted by France alone, the three Eastern Powers had virtually +made themselves responsible for the success of the enterprise, and it was +the influence of their ambassadors at Paris and Madrid which prevented any +restrictions from being imposed upon Ferdinand's restored sovereignty. + +Canning is invested with a spurious glory when it is said that his action +in Spain and in Portugal broke up the league of the Continental Courts. +Canning indeed shaped the policy of our own country with equal independence +and wisdom, but the political centre of Europe was at this time not London +but Vienna. The keystone of the European fabric was the union of Austria +and Russia, and this union was endangered, not by anything that could take +place in the Spanish Peninsula, but by the conflicting interests of these +two great States in regard to the Ottoman Empire. From the moment when the +Treaty of Paris was signed, every Austrian politician fixed his gaze upon +the roads leading to the Lower Danube, and anxiously noted the signs of +coming war, or of continued peace, between Russia and the Porte. [348] It +was the triumph of Metternich to have diverted the Czar's thoughts during +the succeeding years from his grievances against Turkey, and to have +baffled the Russian diplomatists and generals who, like Capodistrias, +sought to spur on their master to enterprises of Eastern conquest. At the +Congress of Verona the shifting and incoherent manoeuvres of Austrian +statecraft can indeed only be understood on the supposition that Metternich +was thinking all the time less of Spain than of Turkey, and struggling at +whatever cost to maintain that personal influence over Alexander which had +hitherto prevented the outbreak of war in the East. But the antagonism so +long suppressed broke out at last. The progress of the Greek insurrection +brought Austria and Russia not indeed into war, but into the most +embittered hostility with one another. It was on this rock that the +ungainly craft which men called the Holy Alliance at length struck and went +to pieces. Canning played his part well in the question of the East, but he +did not create this question. There were forces at work which, without his +intervention, would probably have made an end of the despotic amities of +1815. It is not necessary to the title of a great statesman that he should +have called into being the elements which make a new political order +possible; it is sufficient praise that he should have known how to turn +them to account. + + + + +CHAPTER XV. + + +Condition of Greece: its Races and Institutions--The Greek Church--Communal +System--The AEgaean Islands--The Phanariots--Greek Intellectual Revival; +Koraes--Beginning of Greek National Movement; Contact of Greece with the +French Revolution and Napoleon--The Hetaeria Philike--Hypsilanti's Attempt +in the Danubian Provinces; its Failure--Revolt of the Morea: Massacres: +Execution of Gregorius, and Terrorism at Constantinople--Attitude of +Russia, Austria, and England--Extension of the Revolt: Affairs at +Hydra--The Greek Leaders--Fall of Tripolitza--The Massacre of Chios-- +Failure of the Turks in the Campaign of 1822--Dissensions of the +Greeks--Mahmud calls upon Mehemet Ali for Aid--Ibrahim conquers Crete and +invades the Morea--Siege of Missolonghi--Philhellenism in Europe--Russian +Proposal for Intervention--Conspiracies in Russia: Death of Alexander: +Accession of Nicholas--Military Insurrection at St. Petersburg-- +Anglo-Russian Protocol--Treaty between England, Russia, and France--Death +of Canning--Navarino--War between Russia and Turkey--Campaigns of 1828 and +1829--Treaty of Adrianople--Capodistrias President of Greece--Leopold +accepts and then declines the Greek Crown--Murder of Capodistrias--Otho, +King of Greece. + + +[Greece in the Napoleonic age.] + +Of the Christian races which at the beginning of the third decade of this +century peopled the European provinces of the Ottoman Empire, the Greek was +that which had been least visibly affected by the political and military +events of the Napoleonic age. Servia, after a long struggle, had in the +year 1817 gained local autonomy under its own princes, although Turkish +troops still garrisoned its fortresses, and the sovereignty of the Sultan +was acknowledged by the payment of tribute. The Romanic districts, +Wallachia and Moldavia, which, in the famous interview of Tilsit, Napoleon +had bidden the Czar to make his own, were restored by Russia to the Porte +in the Treaty of Bucharest in 1812, but under conditions which virtually +established a Russian protectorate. Greece, with the exception of the +Ionian Islands, had neither been the scene of any military operations, nor +formed the subject of any treaty. Yet the age of the French Revolution and +of the Napoleonic wars had silently wrought in the Greek nation the last of +a great series of changes which fitted it to take its place among the free +peoples of Europe. The signs were there from which those who could read the +future might have gathered that the political resurrection of Greece was +near at hand. There were some who, with equal insight and patriotism, +sought during this period to lay the intellectual foundation for that +national independence which they foresaw that their children would win with +the sword. + +[Greece in the eighteenth century.] + +The forward movement of the Greek nation may be said, in general terms, to +have become visible during the first half of the eighteenth century. +Serfage had then disappeared; the peasant was either a free-holder, or a +farmer paying a rent in kind for his land. In the gradual and unobserved +emancipation of the labouring class the first condition of national revival +had already been fulfilled. The peasantry had been formed which, when the +conflict with the Turk broke out, bore the brunt of the long struggle. In +comparison with the Prussian serf, the Greek cultivator at the beginning of +the eighteenth century was an independent man: in comparison with the +English labourer, he was well fed and well housed. The evils to which the +Greek population was exposed, wherever Greeks and Turks lived together, +were those which brutalised or degraded the Christian races in every +Ottoman province. There was no redress for injury inflicted by a Mohammedan +official or neighbour. If a wealthy Turk murdered a Greek in the fields, +burnt down his house, and outraged his family, there was no court where the +offender could be brought to justice. The term by which the Turk described +his Christian neighbour was "our rayah," that is, "our subject." A +Mohammedan landowner might terrorise the entire population around him, +carry off the women, flog and imprison the men, and yet feel that he had +committed no offence against the law; for no law existed but the Koran, and +no Turkish court of justice but that of the Kadi, where the complaint of +the Christian passed for nothing. + +This was the monstrous relation that existed between the dominant and the +subject nationalities, not in Greece only, but in every part of the Ottoman +Empire where Mohammedans and Christians inhabited the same districts. The +second great and general evil was the extortion practised by the +tax-gatherers, and this fell upon the poorer Mohammedans equally with the +Christians, except in regard to the poll-tax, or haratsch, the badge of +servitude, which was levied on Christians alone. All land paid tithe to the +State; and until the tax-gatherer had paid his visit it was not permitted +to the peasant to cut the ripe crop. This rule enabled the tax-gatherer, +whether a Mohammedan or a Christian, to inflict ruin upon those who did not +bribe himself or his masters; for by merely postponing his visit he could +destroy the value of the harvest. Round this central institution of tyranny +and waste, there gathered, except in the districts protected by municipal +privileges, every form of corruption natural to a society where the State +heard no appeals, and made no inquiry into the processes employed by those +to whom it sold the taxes. What was possible in the way of extortion was +best seen in the phenomenon of well-built villages being left tenantless, +and the population of rich districts dying out in a time of peace, without +pestilence, without insurrection, without any greater wrong on the part of +the Sultan's government than that normal indifference which permitted the +existence of a community to depend upon the moderation or the caprice of +the individual possessors of force. + +[Origin of modern Greece Byzantine, not classic.] + +[Slavonic and Albanian elements.] + +Such was the framework, or, as it may be said, the common-law of the mixed +Turkish and Christian society of the Ottoman Empire. On this background we +have now to trace the social and political features which stood out in +Greek life, which preserved the race from losing its separate nationality, +and which made the ultimate recovery of its independence possible. In the +first outburst of sympathy and delight with which every generous heart in +western Europe hailed the standard of Hellenic freedom upraised in 1821, +the twenty centuries which separated the Greece of literature from the +Greece of to-day were strangely forgotten. The imagination went straight +back to Socrates and Leonidas, and pictured in the islander or the hillsman +who rose against Mahmud II. the counterpart of those glorious beings who +gave to Europe the ideals of intellectual energy, of plastic beauty, and of +poetic truth. The illusion was a happy one, if it excited on behalf of a +brave people an interest which Servia or Montenegro might have failed to +gain; but it led to a reaction when disappointments came; it gave +inordinate importance to the question of the physical descent of the +Greeks; and it produced a false impression of the causes which had led up +to the war of independence, and of the qualities, the habits, the bonds of +union, which exercised the greatest power over the nation. These were, to a +great extent, unlike anything existing in the ancient world; they had +originated in Byzantine, not in classic Greece; and where the scenes of old +Hellenic history appeared to be repeating themselves, it was due more to +the continuing influence of the same seas and the same mountains than to +the survival of any political fragments of the past. The Greek population +had received a strong Slavonic infusion many centuries before. More +recently, Albanian settlers had expelled the inhabitants from certain +districts both in the mainland and in the Morea. Attica, Boeotia, Corinth, +and Argolis were at the outbreak of the war of independence peopled in the +main by a race of Albanian descent, who still used, along with some Greek, +the Albanian language. [349] The sense of a separate nationality was, +however, weak among these settlers, who, unlike some small Albanian +communities in the west of the Morea, were Christians, not Mohammedans. +Neighbourhood, commerce, identity of religion and similarity of local +institutions were turning these Albanians into Greeks; and no community of +pure Hellenic descent played a greater part in the national war, or +exhibited more of the maritime energy and daring which we associate +peculiarly with the Hellenic name, than the islanders of Hydra and Spetza, +who had crossed from the Albanian parts of the Morea and taken possession +of these desert rocks not a hundred years before. The same phenomenon of an +assimilation of Greeks and Albanians was seen in southern Epirus, the +border-ground between the two races. The Suliotes, Albanian mountaineers, +whose military exploits form one of the most extraordinary chapters in +history, showed signs of Greek influences before the Greek war of +independence began, and in this war they made no distinction between the +Greek cause and their own. Even the rule of the ferocious Ali Pasha at +Janina had been favourable to the extension of Greek civilisation in +Epirus. Under this Mohammedan tyrant Janina contained more schools than +Athens. The Greek population of the district increased; and in the sense of +a common religious antagonism to the Mohammedan, the Greek and the Albanian +Christians in Epirus forgot their difference of race. + +[The Greek Church.] + +[Lower clergy.] + +[The Patriarch an imperial functionary.] + +[The Bishops civil magistrates.] + +The central element in modern Greek life was the religious profession of +the Orthodox Eastern Church. Where, as in parts of Crete, the Greek adopted +Mohammedanism, all the other elements of his nationality together did not +prevent him from amalgamating with the Turk. The sound and popular forces +of the Church belonged to the lower clergy, who, unlike the priests of the +Roman Church, were married and shared the life of the people. If ignorant +and bigoted, they were nevertheless the real guardians of national spirit; +and if their creed was a superstition rather than a religion, it at least +kept the Greeks in a wholesome antagonism to the superstition of their +masters. The higher clergy stood in many respects in a different position. +The Patriarch of Constantinople was a great officer of the Porte. His +dignities and his civil jurisdiction had been restored and even enlarged by +the Mohammedan conquerors of the Greek Empire, with the express object of +employing the Church as a means of securing obedience to themselves: and it +was quite in keeping with the history of this great office that, when the +Greek national insurrection at last broke out, the Patriarch Gregorius IV. +should have consented, though unwillingly, to launch the curse of the +Church against it. The Patriarch gained his office by purchase, or through +intrigues at the Divan; he paid an enormous annual backsheesh for it; and +he was liable to be murdered or deposed as soon as his Mussulman patrons +lost favour with the Sultan, or a higher bid was made for his office by a +rival ecclesiastic. To satisfy the claims of the Palace the Patriarch was +compelled to be an extortioner himself. The bishoprics in their turn were +sold in his ante-chambers, and the Bishops made up the purchase-money by +fleecing their clergy. But in spite of a deserved reputation for venality, +the Bishops in Greece exercised very great influence, both as ecclesiastics +and as civil magistrates. Whether their jurisdiction in lawsuits between +Christians arose from the custom of referring disputes to their arbitration +or was expressly granted to them by the Sultan, they virtually displaced in +all Greek communities the court of the Kadi, and afforded the merchant or +the farmer a tribunal where his own law was administered in his own +language. Even a Mohammedan in dispute with a Christian would sometimes +consent to bring the matter before the Bishops' Court rather than enforce +his right to obtain the dilatory and capricious decision of an Ottoman +judge. + +[Communal organisation.] + +[The Morea.] + +The condition of the Greeks living in the country that now forms the +Hellenic Kingdom and in the AEgaean Islands exhibited strong local contrasts. +It was, however, common to all that, while the Turk held the powers of +State in his hand, the details of local administration in each district +were left to the inhabitants, the Turk caring nothing about these matters +so long as the due amount of taxes was paid and the due supply of sailors +provided. The apportionment of taxes among households and villages seems to +have been the germ of self-government from which several types of municipal +organisation, some of them of great importance in the history of the Greek +nation, developed. In the Paschalik of the Morea the taxes were usually +farmed by the Voivodes, or Beys, the Turkish governors of the twenty-three +provinces into which the Morea was divided. But in each village or township +the inhabitants elected officers called Proestoi, who, besides collecting +the taxes and managing the affairs of their own communities, met in a +district-assembly, and there determined what share of the district-taxation +each community should bear. One Greek officer, called Primate, and one +Mohammedan, called Ayan, were elected to represent the district, and to +take part in the council of the Pasha of the Morea, who resided at +Tripolitza. [350] The Primates exercised considerable power. Created +originally by the Porte to expedite the collection of the revenue, they +became a Greek aristocracy. They were indeed an aristocracy of no very +noble kind. Agents of a tyrannical master, they shared the vices of the +tyrant and of the slave. Often farmers of the taxes themselves, obsequious +and intriguing in the palace of the Pasha at Tripolitza, grasping and +despotic in their native districts, they were described as a species of +Christian Turk. But whatever their vices, they saved the Greeks from being +left without leaders. They formed a class accustomed to act in common, +conversant with details of administration, and especially with the +machinery for collecting and distributing supplies. It was this financial +experience of the Primates of the Morea which gave to the rebellion of the +Greeks what little unity of organisation it exhibited in its earliest +stage. + +[Northern Greece. The Armatoli and the Klephts.] + +On the north of the Gulf of Corinth the features of the communal system +were less distinct than in the Morea. There was, however, in the +mountain-country of AEtolia and Pindus a rough military organisation which +had done great service to Greece in keeping alive the national spirit and +habits of personal independence. The Turks had found a local militia +established in this wild region at the time of their conquest, and had not +interfered with it for some centuries. The Armatoli, or native soldiery, +recruited from peasants, shepherds, and muleteers, kept Mohammedan +influences at a distance, until, in the eighteenth century, the Sultans +made it a fixed rule of policy to diminish their numbers and to reduce the +power of their captains. Before 1820 the Armatoli had become comparatively +few and weak; but as they declined, bands of Klephts, or brigands, grew in +importance; and the mountaineer who was no longer allowed to practise arms +as a guardian of order, enlisted himself among the robbers. Like the +freebooters of our own northern border, these brigands became the heroes of +song. Though they plundered the Greek as well as the Mohammedan, the +national spirit approved their exploits. It was, no doubt, something, that +the physical energy of the marauder and the habit of encountering danger +should not be wholly on the side of the Turk and the Albanian. But the +influence of the Klephts in sustaining Greek nationality has been +overrated. They had but recently become numerous, and the earlier +organisation of the northern Armatoli was that to which the sound and +vigorous character of the Greek peasantry in these regions, the finest part +of the Greek race on the mainland, was really due. [351] + +[The AEgaean Islands.] + +[Chios.] + +In the islands of the AEgaean the condition of the Greeks was on the whole +happy and prosperous. Some of these islands had no Turkish population; in +others the caprice of a Sultana, the goodwill of the Capitan Pasha who +governed the Archipelago, or the judicious offer of a sum of money when +money was wanted by the Porte, had so lightened the burden of Ottoman +sovereignty, that the Greek island-community possessed more liberty than +was to be found in any part of Europe, except Switzerland. The taxes +payable to the central government, including the haratsch or poll-tax +levied on all Christians, had often been commuted for a fixed sum, which +was raised without the interposition of the Turkish tax-gatherer. In Hydra, +Spetza, and Psara, the so-called nautical islands, the supremacy of the +Turk was felt only in the obligation to furnish sailors to the Ottoman +navy, and in the payment of a tribute of about L100 per annum. The +government of these three islands was entirely in the hands of the +inhabitants. In Chios, though a considerable Mussulman population existed +by the side of the Greek, there was every sign of peace and prosperity. +Each island bore its own peculiar social character, and had its municipal +institutions of more or less value. The Hydriote was quarrelsome, +turbulent, quick to use the knife, but outspoken, honest in dealing, and an +excellent sailor. The picture of Chian life, as drawn even by those who +have judged the Greeks most severely, is one of singular beauty and +interest; the picture of a self-governing society in which the family +trained the citizen in its own bosom, and in which, while commerce enriched +all, the industry of the poor within their homes and in their gardens was +refined by the practice of an art. The skill which gave its value to the +embroidery and to the dyes of Chios was exercised by those who also worked +the hand-loom and cultivated the mastic and the rose. The taste and the +labour of man requited nature's gifts of sky, soil, and sea; and in the +pursuit of occupations which stimulated, not deadened, the faculties of the +worker, idleness and intemperance were alike unknown. [352] How bright a +scene of industry, when compared with the grime and squalor of the English +factory-town, where the human and the inanimate machine grind out their +yearly mountains of iron-ware and calico, in order that the employer may +vie with his neighbours in soulless ostentation, and the workman consume +his millions upon millions in drink. + +[The Greeks have ecclesiastical power in other Turkish provinces.] + +The territory where the Greeks formed the great majority of the population +included, beyond the boundaries of the present Hellenic Kingdom, the +islands adjacent to the coast of Asia Minor, Crete, and the Chalcidic +peninsula in Macedonia. But the activity of the race was not confined +within these limits. If the Greek was a subject in his own country, he was +master in the lands of some of his neighbours. A Greek might exercise power +over other Christian subjects of the Porte either as an ecclesiastic, or as +the delegate of the Sultan in certain fixed branches of the administration. +The authority of the Patriarch of Constantinople was recognised over the +whole of the European provinces of Turkey, except Servia. The Bishops in +all these provinces were Greeks; the services of the Church were conducted +in the Greek tongue; the revenues of the greater part of the Church-lands, +and the fees of all the ecclesiastical courts, went into Greek pockets. In +things religious, and in that wide range of civil affairs which in +communities belonging to the Eastern Church appertains to the higher +religious office, the Greeks had in fact regained the ascendancy which they +had possessed under the Byzantine Empire. The dream of the Churchman was +not the creation of an independent kingdom of Greece, but the restoration +of the Eastern Empire under Greek supremacy. When it was seen that the Slav +and the Rouman came to the Greek for law, for commercial training, for +religious teaching, and looked to the Patriarch of Constantinople as the +ultimate judge of all disputes, it was natural that the belief should arise +that, when the Turk passed away, the Greek would step into his place. But +the influence of the Greeks, great as it appeared to be, did not in reality +reach below the surface, except in Epirus. The bishops were felt to be +foreigners and extortioners. There was no real process of assimilation at +work, either in Bulgaria or in the Danubian Provinces. The slow and +plodding Bulgarian peasant, too stupid for the Greek to think of him as a +rival, preserved his own unchanging tastes and nationality, sang to his +children the songs which he had learnt from his parents, and forgot the +Greek which he had heard in the Church when he re-entered his home. [353] +In Roumania, the only feeling towards the Greek intruder was one of intense +hatred. + +[The Phanariot officials of the Porte.] + +[Greek Hospodars.] + +Four great offices of the Ottoman Empire were always held by Greeks. These +were the offices of Dragoman, [354] or Secretary, of the Porte, Dragoman of +the Fleet, and the governorships, called Hospodariates, of Wallachia and +Moldavia. The varied business of the Patriarchate of Constantinople, the +administration of its revenues, the conduct of its law-courts, had drawn a +multitude of pushing and well-educated Greeks to the quarter of +Constantinople called the Phanar, in which the palace of the Patriarch is +situated. Merchants and professional men inhabited the same district. These +Greeks of the capital, the so-called Phanariots, gradually made their way +into the Ottoman administration as Turkish energy declined, and the +conquering race found that it could no longer dispense with the weapons of +calculation and diplomacy. The Treaty of Carlowitz, made in 1699, after the +unsuccessful war in which the Turks laid siege to Vienna, was negotiated on +behalf of the Porte by Alexander Maurokordatos, a Chian by birth, who had +become physician to the Sultan and was virtually the Foreign Minister of +Turkey. His sons, Nicholas and Constantine, were made Hospodars of +Wallachia and Moldavia early in the eighteenth century; and from this time +forward, until the outbreak of the Greek insurrection, the governorships of +the Roumanian provinces were entrusted to Phanariot families. The result +was that a troop of Greek adventurers passed to the north of the Danube, +and seized upon every office of profit in these unfortunate lands. There +were indeed individuals among the Hospodars, especially among the +Maurokordati, who rendered good service to their Roumanian subjects; but on +the whole the Phanariot rule was grasping, dishonest, and cruel. [355] Its +importance in relation to Greece was not that it Hellenised the Danubian +countries, for that it signally failed to do; but that it raised the +standard of Greek education, and enlarged the range of Greek thought, by +opening a political and administrative career to ambitious men. The +connection of the Phanariots with education was indeed an exceedingly close +one. Alexander Maurokordatos was the ardent and generous founder of schools +for the instruction of his countrymen in Constantinople as well as in other +cities, and for the improvement of the existing language of Greece. His +example was freely followed throughout the eighteenth century. It is, +indeed, one of the best features in the Greek character that the owner of +wealth has so often been, and still so often is, the promoter of the +culture of his race. As in Germany in the last century, and in Hungary and +Bohemia at a more recent date, the national revival of Greece was preceded +by a striking revival of interest in the national language. + +[Greek intellectual movement in the eighteenth century.] + +The knowledge of ancient Greek was never wholly lost among the priesthood, +but it had become useless. Nothing was read but the ecclesiastic +commonplace of a pedantic age; and in the schools kept by the clergy before +the eighteenth century the ancient language was taught only as a means of +imparting divinity. The educational movement promoted by men like +Maurokordatos had a double end; it revived the knowledge of the great age +of Greece through its literature, and it taught the Greek to regard the +speech which he actually used not as a mere barbarous patois which each +district had made for itself, but as a language different indeed from that +of the ancient world, yet governed by its own laws, and capable of +performing the same functions as any other modern tongue. It was now that +the Greek learnt to call himself Hellen, the name of his forefathers, +instead of Romaios, a Roman. As the new schools grew up and the old ones +were renovated or transformed, education ceased to be merely literary. In +the second half of the eighteenth century science returned in a humble form +to the land that had given it birth, and the range of instruction was +widened by men who had studied law, physics, and moral philosophy at +foreign Universities. Something of the liberal spirit of the inquirers of +Western Europe arose among the best Greek teachers. Though no attack was +made upon the doctrines of the Church, and no direct attack was made upon +the authority of the Sultan, the duty of religious toleration was +proclaimed in a land where bigotry had hitherto reigned supreme, and the +political freedom of ancient Greece was held up as a glorious ideal to a +less happy age. Some of the higher clergy and of the Phanariot instruments +of Turkish rule took fright at the independent spirit of the new learning, +and for a while it seemed as if the intellectual as well as the political +progress of Greece might be endangered by ecclesiastical ill-will. But the +attachment of the Greek people to the Church was so strong and so universal +that, although satire might be directed against the Bishops, a breach with +the Church formed no part of the design of any patriot. The antagonism +between episcopal and national feeling, strongest about the end of the +eighteenth century, declined during succeeding years, and had almost +disappeared before the outbreak of the war of liberation. + +[Koraes, 1748-1833.] + +[The language of Modern Greece.] + +The greatest scholar of modern Greece was also one of its greatest +patriots. Koraes, known as the legislator of the Greek language, was born +in 1748, of Chian parents settled at Smyrna. The love of learning, combined +with an extreme independence of character, made residence insupportable to +him in a land where the Turk was always within sight, and where few +opportunities existed for gaining wide knowledge. His parents permitted him +to spend some years at Amsterdam, where a branch of their business was +established. Recalled to Smyrna at the age of thirty, Koraes almost +abandoned human society. The hand of a beautiful heiress could not tempt +him from the austere and solitary life of the scholar; and quitting his +home, he passed through the medical school of Montpellier, and settled at +Paris. He was here when the French Revolution began. The inspiration of +that time gave to his vast learning and inborn energy a directly patriotic +aim. For forty years Koraes pursued the work of serving Greece by the means +open to the scholar. The political writings in which he addressed the +Greeks themselves or appealed to foreigners in favour of Greece, admirable +as they are, do not form the basis of his fame. The peculiar task of Koraes +was to give to the reviving Greek nation the national literature and the +form of expression which every civilised people reckons among its most +cherished bonds of unity. Master, down to the minutest details, of the +entire range of Greek writings, and of the history of the Greek language +from classical times down to our own century, Koraes was able to select the +Hellenic authors, Christian as well as Pagan, whose works were best suited +for his countrymen in their actual condition, and to illustrate them as no +one could who had not himself been born and bred among Greeks. This was one +side of Koraes' literary task. The other was to direct the language of the +future Hellenic kingdom into its true course. Classical writing was still +understood by the educated in Greece, but the spoken language of the people +was something widely different. Turkish and Albanian influences had +barbarised the vocabulary; centuries of ignorance had given play to every +natural irregularity of local dialect. When the restoration of Greek +independence came within view, there were some who proposed to revive +artificially each form used in the ancient language, and thus, without any +real blending, to add the old to the new: others, seeing this to be +impossible, desired that the common idiom, corrupt as it was, should be +accepted as a literary language. Koraes chose the middle and the rational +path. Taking the best written Greek of the day as his material, he +recommended that the forms of classical Greek, where they were not wholly +obsolete, should be fixed in the grammar of the language. While ridiculing +the attempt to restore modes of expression which, even in the written +language, had wholly passed out of use, he proposed to expunge all words +that were in fact not Greek at all, but foreign, and to replace them by +terms formed according to the natural laws of the language. The Greek, +therefore, which Koraes desired to see his countrymen recognise as their +language, and which he himself used in his writings, was the written Greek +of the most cultivated persons of his time, purged of its foreign elements, +and methodised by a constant reference to a classical model, which, +however, it was not to imitate pedantically. The correctness of this theory +has been proved by its complete success. The patois which, if it had been +recognised as the language of the Greek kingdom, would now have made +Herodotus and Plato foreign authors in Athens, is indeed still preserved in +familiar conversation, but it is little used in writing and not taught in +schools. A language year by year more closely approximating in its forms to +that of classical Greece unites the Greeks both with their past and among +themselves, and serves as the instrument of a widening Hellenic +civilization in the Eastern Mediterranean. The political object of Koraes +has been completely attained. No people in Europe is now prouder of its +native tongue, or turns it to better account in education, than his +countrymen. In literature, the renovated language has still its work before +it. The lyric poetry that has been written in Greece since the time of +Koraes is not wanting, if a foreigner may express an opinion, in tenderness +and grace The writer who shall ennoble Greek prose with the energy and +directness of the ancient style has yet to arise [356] + +[Development of Greek commerce, 1750-1820.] + +[The Treaty of Kainardji, 1774.] + +The intellectual advance of the Greeks in the eighteenth century was +closely connected with the development of their commerce, and this in its +turn was connected with events in the greater cycle of European history. A +period of comparative peace and order in the Levantine waters, following +the final expulsion of the Venetians from the Morea in 1718, gave play to +the natural aptitude of the Greek islanders for coasting-trade. Then ships, +still small and unfit to venture on long voyages, plied between the +harbours in the AEgaean and in the Black Sea, and brought profit to their +owners in spite of the imposition of burdens from which not only many of +the Mussulman subjects of the Sultan, but foreign nations protected by +commercial treaties, were free. It was at this epoch, after Venice had lost +its commercial supremacy in the Eastern Mediterranean, that Russia began to +exercise a direct influence upon the fortunes of Greece. The Empress +Catherine had formed the design of conquering Constantinople, and intended, +under the title of Protectress of the Christian Church, to use the Greeks +as her allies. In the war which broke out between Russia and Turkey in +1768, a Russian expeditionary force landed in the Morea, and the Greeks +were persuaded to take up arms. The Moreotes themselves paid dearly for the +trust which they had placed in the orthodox Empress. They were virtually +abandoned to the vengeance of their oppressors; but to Greece at large the +conditions on which peace was made proved of immense benefit. The Treaty of +Kainardji, signed in 1774, gave Russia the express right to make +representations at Constantinople on behalf of the Christian inhabitants of +the Danubian provinces; it also bound the Sultan to observe certain +conditions in his treatment of the Greek islanders. Out of these clauses, +Russian diplomacy constructed a general right of interference on behalf of +any Christian subjects of the Porte. The Treaty also opened the Black Sea +to Russian ships of commerce, and conferred upon Russia the commercial +privileges of the most favoured nation. [357] The result of this compact +was a very remarkable one. The Russian Government permitted hundreds of +Greek shipowners to hoist its own flag, and so changed the footing of Greek +merchantmen in every port of the Ottoman Empire. The burdens which had +placed the Greek trader at a disadvantage, when compared with the +Mohammedan, vanished. A host of Russian consular agents, often Greeks +themselves, was scattered over the Levant. Eager for opportunities of +attaching the Greeks to their Russian patrons, quick to make their +newly-won power felt by the Turks, these men extracted a definite meaning +from the clauses of the Treaty of Kainardji, by which the Porte had bound +itself to observe the rights of its Christian subjects. The sense of +security in the course of their business, no less than the emancipation +from commercial fetters, gave an immense impulse to Greek traders. Their +ships were enlarged; voyages, hitherto limited to the Levant, were extended +to England and even to America; and a considerable armament of cannon was +placed on board each ship for defence against the attack of Algerian +pirates. + +[Foundation of Odessa, 1792.] + +[Death of Rhegas, 1798.] + +[Influence of the French Revolution on Greece.] + +Before the end of the eighteenth century another war between Turkey and +Russia, resulting in the cession of the district of Oczakoff on the +northern shore of the Black Sea, made the Greeks both carriers and vendors +of the corn-export of Southern Russia. The city of Odessa was founded on +the ceded territory. The merchants who raised it to its sudden prosperity +were not Russians but Greeks; and in the course of a single generation many +a Greek trading-house, which had hitherto deemed the sum of L3,000 to be a +large capital, rose to an opulence little behind that of the great London +firms. Profiting by the neutrality of Turkey or its alliance with England +during a great part of the revolutionary war, the Greeks succeeded to much +of the Mediterranean trade that was lost by France and its dependencies. +The increasing intelligence of the people was shown in the fact that +foreigners were no longer employed by Greek merchants as their travelling +agents in distant countries; there were countrymen enough of their own who +could negotiate with an Englishman or a Dane in his own language. The +richest Greeks were no doubt those of Odessa and Salonica, not of Hellas +proper; but even the little islands of Hydra and Spetza, the refuge of the +Moreotes whom Catherine had forsaken in 1770, now became communities of no +small wealth and spirit. Psara, which was purely Greek, formed with these +Albanian colonies the nucleus of an AEgaean naval Power. The Ottoman +Government, cowed by its recent defeats, and perhaps glad to see the means +of increasing its resources, made no attempt to check the growth of the +Hellenic armed marine. Under the very eyes of the Sultan, the Hydriote and +Psarian captains, men as venturesome as the sea-kings of ancient Greece, +accumulated the artillery which was hereafter to hold its own against many +an Ottoman man-of-war, and to sweep the Turkish merchantmen from the +AEgaean. Eighteen years before the Greek insurrection broke out, Koraes, +calling the attention of Western Europe to the progress made by his +country, wrote the following significant words:--"If the Ottoman Government +could have foreseen that the Greeks would create a merchant-navy, composed +of several hundred vessels, most of them regularly armed, it would have +crushed the movement at its commencement. It is impossible to calculate the +effects which may result from the creation of this marine, or the influence +which it may exert both upon the destiny of the oppressed nation and upon +that of its oppressors." [358] Like its classic sisterland in the +Mediterranean, Greece was stirred by the far-sounding voices of the French +Revolution. The Declaration of the Rights of Man, the revival of a supposed +antique Republicanism, the victories of Hoche and Bonaparte, successively +kindled the enthusiasm of a race already restless under the Turkish yoke. +France drew to itself some of the hopes that had hitherto been fixed +entirely upon Russia. Images and ideas of classic freedom invaded the +domain where the Church had hitherto been all in all; the very sailors +began to call their boats by the names of Spartan and Athenian heroes, as +well as by those of saints and martyrs. In 1797 Venice fell, and Bonaparte +seized its Greek possessions, the Ionian Islands. There was something of +the forms of liberation in the establishment of French rule; the +inhabitants of Zante were at least permitted to make a bonfire of the +stately wigs worn by their Venetian masters. Great changes seemed to be +near at hand. It was not yet understood that France fought for empire, not +for justice; and the man who, above all others, represented the early +spirit of the revolution among the Greeks, the poet Rhegas, looked to +Bonaparte to give the signal for the rising of the whole of the Christian +populations subject to Mohammedan rule. Rhegas, if he was not a wise +politician, was a thoroughly brave man, and he was able to serve his +country as a martyr. While engaged in Austria in conspiracies against the +Sultan's Government, and probably in intrigues with Bernadotte, French +ambassador at Vienna, he was arrested by the agents of Thugut, and handed +over to the Turks. He was put to death at Belgrade, with five of his +companions, in May, 1798. The songs of Rhegas soon passed through every +household in Greece. They were a precious treasure to his countrymen, and +they have immortalised his name as a patriot. But the work which he had +begun languished for a time after his death. The series of events which +followed Bonaparte's invasion of Egypt extinguished the hope of the +liberation of Greece by the French Republic. Among the higher Greek clergy +the alliance with the godless followers of Voltaire was seen with no +favourable eye. The Porte was even able to find a Christian Patriarch to +set his name to a pastoral, warning the faithful against the sin of +rebellion, and reminding them that, while Satan was creating the Lutherans +and Calvinists, the infinite mercy of God had raised up the Ottoman Power +in order that the Orthodox Church might be preserved pure from the heresies +of the West. [359] + +[The Ionian Islands. 1798-1815.] + +[Ali Pasha, 1798-1821.] + +From the year 1798 down to the Peace of Paris, Greece was more affected by +the vicissitudes of the Ionian Islands and by the growth of dominion of Ali +Pasha in Albania than by the earlier revolutionary ideas. France was +deprived of its spoils by the combined Turkish and Russian fleets in the +coalition of 1799, and the Ionian Islands were made into a Republic under +the protection of the Czar and the Sultan. It was in the native +administration of Corfu that the career of Capodistrias began. At the peace +of Tilsit the Czar gave these islands back to Napoleon, and Capodistrias, +whose ability had gained general attention, accepted an invitation to enter +the Russian service. The islands were then successively beleaguered and +conquered by the English, with the exception of Corfu; and after the fall +of Napoleon they became a British dependency. Thus the three greatest +Powers of Europe were during the first years of this century in constant +rivalry on the east of the Adriatic, and a host of Greeks, some fugitives, +some adventurers, found employment among their armed forces. The most +famous chieftain in the war of liberation, Theodore Kolokotrones, a Klepht +of the Morea, was for some years major of a Greek regiment in the pay of +England. In the meantime Ali Pasha, on the neighbouring mainland, neither +rested himself nor allowed any of his neighbours to rest. The Suliotes, +vanquished after years of heroic defence, migrated in a body to the Ionian +Islands in 1804. Every Klepht and Armatole of the Epirote border had fought +at some time either for Ali or against him; for in the extension of his +violent and crafty rule Ali was a friend to-day and an enemy to-morrow +alike to Greek, Turk, and Albanian. When his power was at its height, Ali's +court at Janina was as much Greek as it was Mohammedan: soldiers, +merchants, professors, all, as it was said, with a longer or a shorter rope +round their necks, played their part in the society of the Epirote capital. +[360] Among the officers of Ali's army there were some who were soon to be +the military rivals of Kolokotrones in the Greek insurrection: Ali's +physician, Dr. Kolettes, was gaining an experience and an influence among +these men which afterwards placed him at the head of the Government. For +good or for evil, it was felt that the establishment of a virtually +independent kingdom of Albania must deeply affect the fate of Greece; and +when at length Ali openly defied the Sultan, and Turkish armies closed +round his castle at Janina, the conflict between the Porte and its most +powerful vassal gave the Greeks the signal to strike for their own +independence. + +[The Hetaeria Philike.] + +The secret society, which under the name of Hetaeria Philike, or association +of friends, inaugurated the rebellion of Greece, was founded in 1814, after +it had become clear that the Congress of Vienna would take no steps on +behalf of the Christian subjects of the Porte. The founders of this society +were traders of Odessa, and its earliest members seem to have been drawn +more from the Greeks in Russia and in the Danubian provinces than from +those of Greece Proper. The object of the conspiracy was the expulsion of +the Turk from Europe, and the re-establishment of a Greek Eastern Empire. +It was pretended by the council of directors that the Emperor Alexander had +secretly joined them; and the ingenious fiction was circulated that a +society for the preservation of Greek antiquities, for which Capodistrias +had gained the patronage of the Czar and other eminent men at the Congress +of Vienna, was in fact this political association in disguise. The real +chiefs of the conspiracy always spoke of themselves as acting under the +instructions of a nameless superior power. They were as little troubled by +scruple in thus deceiving their followers as they were in planning a +general massacre of the Turks, and in murdering their own agents when they +wished to have them out of the way. The ultimate design of the Hetaeria was +an unsound one, and its operations were based upon an imposture; but in +exciting the Greeks against Turkish rule, and in inspiring confidence in +its own resources and authority, it was completely successful. In the +course of six years every Greek of note, both in Greece itself and in the +adjacent countries, had joined the association. The Turkish Government had +received warnings of the danger which threatened it, but disregarded them +until revolt was on the point of breaking out. The very improvement in the +condition of the Christians, the absence of any crying oppression or +outrage in Greece during late years, probably lulled the anxieties of +Sultan Mahmud, who, terrible as he afterwards proved himself, had not +hitherto been without sympathy for the Rayah. But the history of France, no +less than the history of Greece, shows that it is not the excess, but the +sense, of wrong that produces revolution. A people may be so crushed by +oppression as to suffer all conceivable misery with patience. It is when +the pulse has again begun to beat strong, when the eye is fixed no longer +on the ground, and the knowledge of good and evil again burns in the heart, +that the right and the duty of resistance is felt. + +[Capodistrias and Hypsilanti.] + +Early in 1820 the ferment in Greece had become so general that the chiefs +of the Hetaeria were compelled to seek at St. Petersburg for the Russian +leader who had as yet existed only in their imagination. There was no +dispute as to the person to whom the task of restoring the Eastern Empire +rightfully belonged. Capodistrias, at once a Greek and Foreign Minister of +Russia, stood in the front rank of European statesmen; he was known to love +the Greek cause; he was believed to possess the strong personal affection +of the Emperor Alexander. The deputies of the Hetaeria besought him to place +himself at its head. Capodistrias, however, knew better than any other man +the force of those influences which would dissuade the Czar from assisting +Greece. He had himself published a pamphlet in the preceding year +recommending his countrymen to take no rash step; and, apart from all +personal considerations, he probably believed that he could serve Greece +better as Minister of Russia than by connecting himself with any dangerous +enterprise. He rejected the offers of the Hetaerists, who then turned to a +soldier of some distinction in the Russian army, Prince Alexander +Hypsilanti, a Greek exile, whose grandfather, after governing Wallachia as +Hospodar, had been put to death by the Turks for complicity with the +designs of Rhegas. It is said that Capodistrias encouraged Hypsilanti to +attempt the task which he had himself declined, and that he allowed him to +believe that if Greece once rose in arms the assistance of Russia could not +long be withheld. [361] Hypsilanti, sacrificing his hopes of the recovery +of a great private fortune through the intercession of the Czar at +Constantinople, placed himself at the head of the Hetaeria, and entered upon +a career, for which, with the exception of personal courage proved in the +campaigns against Napoleon, he seems to have possessed no single +qualification. + +[The Heraerist plan.] + +In October, 1820, the leading Hetaerists met in council at Ismail to decide +whether the insurrection against the Turk should begin in Greece itself or +in the Danubian provinces. Most of the Greek officers in the service of +Sutsos, the Hospodar of Moldavia, were ready to join the revolt. With the +exception of a few companies serving as police, there were no Turkish +soldiers north of the Danube, the Sultan having bound himself by the Treaty +of Bucharest to send no troops into the Principalities without the Czar's +consent. It does not appear that the Hetaerists had yet formed any +calculation as to the probable action of the Roumanian people: they had +certainly no reason to believe that this race bore good-will to the Greeks, +or that it would make any effort to place a Greek upon the Sultan's throne. +The conspirators at Ismail were so far on the right track that they decided +that the outbreak should begin, not on the Danube, but in Peloponnesus. +Hypsilanti, however, full of the belief that Russia would support him, +reversed this conclusion, and determined to raise his standard in Moldavia. +[362] And now for the first time some account was taken of the Roumanian +population. It was known that the mass of the people groaned under the +feudal oppression of the Boyards, or landowners, and that the Boyards +themselves detested the government of the Greek Hospodars. A plan found +favour among Hypsilanti's advisers that the Wallachian peasantry should +first be called to arms by a native leader for the redress of their own +grievances, and that the Greeks should then step in and take control of the +insurrectionary movement. Theodor Wladimiresco, a Roumanian who had served +in the Russian army, was ready to raise the standard of revolt among his +countrymen. It did not occur to the Hetaerists that Wladimiresco might have +a purpose of his own, or that the Roumanian population might prefer to see +the Greek adventure fail. No sovereign by divine right had a firmer belief +in his prerogative within his own dominions than Hypsilanti in his power to +command or outwit Roumanians, Slavs, and all other Christian subjects of +the Sultan. + +[Hypsilanti in Roumania March, 1821.] + +The feint of a native rising was planned and executed. In February, 1821, +while Hypsilanti waited on the Russian frontier, Wladimiresco proclaimed +the abolition of feudal services, and marched with a horde of peasants upon +Bucharest. On the 16th of March the Hetaerists began their own insurrection +by a deed of blood that disgraced the Christian cause. Karavias, a +conspirator commanding the Greek troops of the Hospodar at Galatz, let +loose his soldiers and murdered every Turk who could be hunted down. +Hypsilanti crossed the Pruth next day, and appeared at Jassy with a few +hundred followers. A proclamation was published in which the Prince called +upon all Christian subjects of the Porte to rise, and declared that a great +European Power, meaning Russia, supported him in his enterprise. Sutsos, +the Hospodar, at once handed over all the apparatus of government, and +supplied the insurgents with a large sum of money. Two thousand armed men, +some of them regular troops, gathered round Hypsilanti at Jassy. The roads +to the Danube lay open before him; the resources of Moldavia were at his +disposal; and had he at once thrown a force into Galatz and Ibraila, he +might perhaps have made it difficult for Turkish troops to gain a footing +on the north of the Danube. + +[The Czar disavows the movement.] + +But the incapacity of the leader became evident from the moment when he +began his enterprise. He loitered for a week at Jassy, holding court and +conferring titles, and then, setting out for Bucharest, wasted three weeks +more upon the road. In the meantime the news of the insurrection, and of +the fraudulent use that had been made of his own name, reached the Czar, +who was now engaged at the Congress of Laibach. Alexander was at this +moment abandoning himself heart and soul to Metternich's reactionary +influence, and ordering his generals to make ready a hundred thousand men +to put down the revolution in Piedmont. He received with dismay a letter +from Hypsilanti invoking his aid in a rising which was first described in +the phrases of the Holy Alliance as the result of a divine inspiration, and +then exhibited as a master-work of secret societies and widespread +conspiracy. A stern answer was sent back. Hypsilanti was dismissed from the +Russian service; he was ordered to lay down his arms, and a manifesto was +published by the Russian Consul at Jassy declaring that the Czar repudiated +and condemned the enterprise with which his name had been connected. The +Patriarch of Constantinople, helpless in the presence of Sultan Mahmud, now +issued a ban of excommunication against the leader and all his followers. +Some weeks later the Congress of Laibach officially branded the Greek +revolt as a work of the same anarchical spirit which had produced the +revolutions of Italy and Spain. [363] + +[The enterprise fails.] + +The disavowal of the Hetaerist enterprise by the Czar was fatal to its +success. Hypsilanti, indeed, put on a bold countenance and pretended that +the public utterances of the Russian Court were a mere blind, and in +contradiction to the private instructions given him by the Czar; but no one +believed him. The Roumanians, when they knew that aid was not coming from +Russia, held aloof, or treated insurgents as enemies. Turkish troops +crossed the Danube, and Hypsilanti fell back from Bucharest towards the +Austrian frontier. Wladimiresco followed him, not however to assist him in +his struggle, but to cut off his retreat and to betray him to the enemy. It +was in vain that the bravest of Hypsilanti's followers, Georgakis, a Greek +from Olympus, sought the Wallachian at his own headquarters, exposed his +treason to the Hetaerist officers who surrounded him, and carried him, a +doomed man, to the Greek camp. Wladimiresco's death was soon avenged. The +Turks advanced. Hypsilanti was defeated in a series of encounters, and fled +ignobly from his followers, to seek a refuge, and to find a prison, in +Austria. Bands of his soldiers, forsaken by their leader, sold their lives +dearly in a hopeless struggle. At Skuleni, on the Pruth, a troop of four +hundred men refused to cross to Russian soil until they had given battle to +the enemy. Standing at bay, they met the onslaught of ten times their +number of pursuers. Georgakis, who had sworn that he would never fall alive +into the enemy's hands, kept his word. Surrounded by Turkish troops in the +tower of a monastery, he threw open the doors for those of his comrades who +could to escape, and then setting fire to a chest of powder, perished in +the explosion, together with his assailants. + +[Revolt of Morea, April 2, 1891.] + +The Hetaerist invasion of the Principalities had ended in total failure, and +with it there passed away for ever the dream of re-establishing the Eastern +Empire under Greek ascendancy. But while this enterprise, planned in vain +reliance upon foreign aid and in blind assumption of leadership over an +alien race, collapsed through the indifference of a people to whom the +Greeks were known only as oppressors, that genuine uprising of the Greek +nation, which, in spite of the nullity of its leaders, in spite of the +crimes, the disunion, the perversity of a race awaking from centuries of +servitude, was to add one more to the free peoples of Europe, broke out in +the real home of the Hellenes, in the Morea and the islands of the AEgaean. +Soon after Hypsilanti's appearance in Moldavia the Turkish governor of the +Morea, anticipating a general rebellion of the Greeks, had summoned the +Primates of his province to Tripolitza, with the view of seizing them as +hostages. The Primates of the northern district set out, but halted on +their way, debating whether they should raise the standard of insurrection +or wait for events. While they lingered irresolutely at Kalavryta the +decision passed out of their hands, and the people rose throughout the +Morea. The revolt of the Moreot Greeks against their oppressors was from +the first, and with set purpose, a war of extermination. "The Turk," they +sang in their war-songs, "shall live no longer, neither in Morea nor in the +whole earth." This terrible resolution was, during the first weeks of the +revolt, carried into literal effect. The Turks who did not fly from their +country-houses to the towns where there were garrisons or citadels to +defend them, were attacked and murdered with their entire families, men, +women and children. This was the first act of the revolution; and within a +few weeks after the 2nd of April, on which the first outbreaks occurred, +the open country was swept clear of its Ottoman population, which had +numbered about 25,000, and the residue of the lately dominant race was +collected within the walls of Patras, Tripolitza, and other towns, which +the Greeks forthwith began to beleaguer. [364] + +[Terrorism at Constantinople.] + +[Execution of the Patriarch, April 22.] + +The news of the revolt of the Morea and of the massacre of Mohammedans +reached Constantinople, striking terror into the politicians of the Turkish +capital, and rousing the Sultan Mahmud to a vengeance tiger-like in its +ferocity, but deliberate and calculated like every bloody deed of this +resolute and able sovereign. Reprisals had already been made upon the +Greeks at Constantinople for the acts of Hypsilanti, and a number of +innocent persons had been put to death by the executioner, but no general +attack upon the Christians had been suggested, nor had the work of +punishment passed out of the hands of the government itself. Now, however, +the fury of the Mohammedan populace was let loose upon the infidel. The +Sultan called upon his subjects to arm themselves in defence of their +faith. Executions were redoubled; soldiers and mobs devastated Greek +settlements on the Bosphorus; and on the most sacred day of the Greek +Church a blow was struck which sent a thrill over Eastern Europe. The +Patriarch of Constantinople had celebrated the service which ushers in the +dawn of Easter Sunday, when he was summoned by the Dragoman of the Porte to +appear before a Synod hastily assembled. There an order of the Sultan was +read declaring Gregorius IV. a traitor, and degrading him from his office. +The Synod was commanded to elect his successor. It did so. While the new +Archbishop was receiving his investiture, Gregorius was led out, and was +hanged, still wearing his sacred robes, at the gate of his palace. His body +remained during Easter Sunday and the two following days at the place of +execution. It was then given to the Jews to be insulted, dragged through +the streets, and cast into the sea. The Archbishops of Adrianople, +Salonica, and Tirnovo suffered death on the same Easter Sunday. The body of +Gregorius, floating in the waves, was picked up by a Greek ship and carried +to Odessa. Brought, as it was believed, by a miracle to Christian soil, the +relics of the Patriarch received at the hands of the Russian government the +funeral honours of a martyr. Gregorius had no doubt had dealings with the +Hetaerists; but he was put to death untried; and whatever may have been the +real extent of his offence, he was executed not for this but in order to +strike terror into the Sultan's Christian subjects. + +[Massacre of Christians, April-October.] + +[Effect on Russia.] + +[Russian ambassador leaves Constantinople, July 27.] + +During the succeeding months, in Asia Minor as well as in Macedonia and at +Constantinople itself, there were wholesale massacres of the Christians, +and the churches of the Greeks were pillaged or destroyed by their enemies, +both Jews and Turks. Smyrna, Adrianople, and Salonica, in so far as these +towns were Greek, were put to the sack; thousands of the inhabitants were +slain by the armed mobs who held command, or were sold into slavery. It was +only the fear of a war with Russia which at length forced Sultan Mahmud to +stop these deeds of outrage and to restore some of the conditions of +civilised life in the part of his dominions which was not in revolt. The +Russian army and nation would have avenged the execution of the Patriarch +by immediate war if popular instincts had governed its ruler. Strogonoff, +the ambassador at Constantinople, at once proposed to the envoys of the +other Powers to unite in calling up war-ships for the protection of the +Christians. Joint action was, however, declined by Lord Strangford, the +representative of England, and the Porte was encouraged by the attitude of +this politician to treat the threats of Strogonoff with indifference. There +was an interval during which the destiny of a great part of Eastern Europe +depended upon the fluctuations of a single infirm will. The Czar had +thoroughly identified himself while at Laibach with the principles and the +policy of European conservatism, and had assented to the declaration in +which Metternich placed the Greek rebellion, together with the Spanish and +Italian insurrections, under the ban of Europe. Returning to St. +Petersburg, Alexander, in spite of the veil that intercepts from every +sovereign the real thoughts and utterances of his people, found himself +within the range of widely different influences. Russian passions were not +roused by what might pass in Italy or Spain. The Russian priest, the +soldier, the peasant understood nothing of theories of federal +intervention, and of the connection between Neapolitan despotism and the +treaties of 1815: but his blood boiled when he heard that the chief priest +of his Church had been murdered by the Sultan, and that a handful of his +brethren were fighting for their faith unhelped. Alexander felt to some +extent the throb of national spirit. There had been a time in his life when +a single hour of strong emotion or of overpowering persuasion had made him +renounce every obligation and unite with Napoleon against his own allies; +and there were those who in 1821 believed that the Czar would as suddenly +break loose from his engagements with Metternich and throw himself, with a +fanatical army and nation, into a crusade against the Turk. Sultan Mahmud +had himself given to the Russian party of action a ground for denouncing +him in the name of Russian honour and interests independently of all that +related to Greece. In order to prevent the escape of suspected persons, the +Porte had ordered Russian vessels to be searched at Constantinople, and it +had forced all corn-ships coming from the Euxine to discharge their cargoes +at the Bosphorus, under the apprehension that the corn-supplies of the +capital would be cut off by Greek vessels in command of the AEgaean. +Further, Russia had by treaty the right to insist that the Danubian +Principalities should be governed by their civil authorities, the +Hospodars, and not by Turkish Pashas, insurrection in Wallachia had been +put down, but the rule of Hospodars had not been restored; Turkish +generals, at the head of their forces, still administered their provinces +under military law. On all these points Russia had at least the semblance +of grievances of its own. The outrages which shocked all Europe were not +the only wrong which Russian pride called upon the Czar to redress. The +influence of Capodistrias revived at St. Petersburg. A despatch was sent to +Constantinople declaring that the Porte had begun a war for life or death +with the Christian religion, and that its continued existence among the +Powers of Europe must depend upon its undertaking to restore the churches +which had been destroyed, to guarantee the inviolability of Christian +worship in the future, and to discriminate in its punishments between the +innocent and the guilty. Presenting ultimatum from his master, Strogonoff, +in accordance with his instructions, demanded a written answer within eight +days. No such answer came. On the 27th of July the ambassador quitted +Constantinople. War seemed to be on the point of breaking out. + +[Eastern policy of Austria.] + +The capital where these events were watched with the greatest apprehension +was Vienna. The fortunes of the Ottoman Empire have always been most +intimately connected with those of Austria; and although the long struggle +of the House of Hapsburg with Napoleon and its wars in recent times with +Prussia and with Italy have made the western aspect of Austrian policy more +prominent and more familiar than its eastern one, the eastern interests of +the monarchy have always been at least as important in the eyes of its +actual rulers. Before the year 1720 Austria, not Russia, was the great +enemy of Turkey and the aggressive Power of the east of Europe. After 1780 +the Emperor Joseph had united with Catherine of Russia in a plan for +dividing the Sultan's dominions in Europe, and actually waged a war for +this purpose. In 1795 the alliance, with the same object, had been +prospectively revived by Thugut; in 1809, after the Treaty of Tilsit, +Metternich had determined in the last resort to combine with Napoleon and +Alexander in dismembering Turkey, if all diplomatic means should fail to +prevent a joint attack on the Porte by France and Russia. But this +resolution had been adopted by Metternich only as a matter of necessity, +and in view of a combination which threatened to reduce Austria to the +position of a vassal State. Metternich's own definite and consistent policy +after 1814 was the maintenance of the Ottoman Empire. His statesmanship +was, as a rule, governed by fear; and his fear of Alexander was second only +to his old fear of Napoleon. Times were changed since Joseph and Thugut +could hope to enter upon a game of aggression with Russia upon equal terms. +The Austrian army had been beaten in every battle that it had fought during +nearly twenty years. Province after province had been severed from it, +without, except in the Tyrol, raising a hand in its support; and when in +1821 the Minister compared Austria's actual Empire and position in Europe, +won and maintained in great part by his own diplomacy, with the ruin to +which a series of wars had brought it ten years before, he might well thank +Heaven that international Congresses were still so much in favour with the +Courts, and tremble at the clash of arms which from the remote Morea +threatened to call Napoleon's northern conquerors once more into the field +[365] + +[Eastern policy of England.] + +England was not, like Austria, exposed to actual danger by the advance of +Russia towards the AEgaean; but the growth of Russian power had been viewed +with alarm by English politicians since 1788, when Pitt had formed a triple +alliance with Prussia and Holland for the purpose of defending the Porte +against the attacks of Catherine and Joseph. The interest of Great Britain +in the maintenance of the Ottoman Empire had not been laid down as a +principle before that date, nor was it then acknowledged by the Whig party. +It was asserted by Pitt from considerations relating to the European +balance of power, not, as in our own times, with a direct reference to +England's position in India. The course of events from 1792 to 1807 made +England and Russia for awhile natural allies; but this friendship was +turned into hostility by the Treaty of Tilsit; and although after a few +years Alexander was again fighting for the same cause as Great Britain, and +the public opinion of this country enthusiastically hailed the issue of the +Moscow campaign, English statesmen never forgot the interview upon the +Niemen, and never, in the brightest moments of victory, regarded Alexander +without some secret misgivings. During the campaign of 1814 in France, +Castlereagh's willingness to negotiate with Bonaparte was due in great part +to the fear that Alexander's high-wrought resolutions would collapse before +Napoleon could be thoroughly crushed, and that reaction would carry him +into a worse peace than that which he then disdained. [366] The +negotiations at the Congress of Vienna brought Great Britain and Russia, as +it has been seen, into an antagonism which threatened to end in the resort +to arms; and the tension which then and for some time afterwards existed +between the two governments led English Ministers to speak, certainly in +exaggerated and misleading language, of the mutual hostility of the English +and the Russian nations. From 1815 to 1821 the Czar had been jealously +watched. It had been rumoured over and over again that he was preparing to +invade the Ottoman Empire; and when the rebellion of the Greeks broke out, +the one thought of Castlereagh and his colleagues was that Russia must be +prevented from throwing itself into the fray, and that the interests of +Great Britain required that the authority of the Sultan should as soon as +possible be restored throughout his dominions. + +[Fears of new period of warfare.] + +[Metternich and the Greeks.] + +Both at London therefore and at Vienna the rebellion of Greece was viewed +by governments only as an unfortunate disturbance which was likely to +excite war between Russia and its neighbours, and to imperil the peace of +Europe at large. It may seem strange that the spectacle of a nation rising +to assert its independence should not even have aroused the question +whether its claims deserved to be considered. But to do justice at least to +the English Ministers of 1821, it must be remembered how terrible, how +overpowering, were the memories left by the twenty years of European war +that had closed in 1815, and at how vast a cost to mankind the regeneration +of Greece would have been effected, if, as then seemed probable, it had +ranged the Great Powers again in arms against one another, and re-kindled +the spirit of military aggression which for a whole generation had made +Europe the prey of rival coalitions. It is impossible to read the letter in +which Castlereagh pleaded with the Czar to sacrifice his own glory and +popularity to the preservation of European peace, without perceiving in +what profound earnestness the English statesman sought to avert the renewal +of an epoch of conflict, and how much the apprehension of coming calamity +predominated in his own mind over the mere jealousy of an extension of +Russian power. [367] If Castlereagh had no thought for Greece itself, it +was because the larger interests of Europe wholly absorbed him, and because +he lacked the imagination and the insight to conceive of a better +adjustment of European affairs under the widening recognition of national +rights. The Minister of Austria, to whom at this crisis Castlereagh looked +as his natural ally, had no doubt the same dread of a renewed convulsion of +Europe, but in his case it was mingled with considerations of a much +narrower kind. It is not correct to say that Metternich was indifferent to +the Greek cause; he actually hated it, because it gave a stimulus to the +liberal movement of Germany. In his empty and pedantic philosophy of human +action, Metternich linked together every form of national aspiration and +unrest as something presumptuous and wanton. He understood nothing of the +debt that mankind owes to the spirit of freedom. He was just as ready to +dogmatise upon the wickedness of the English Reform Bill as he was to trace +the hand of Capodistrias in every tumult in Servia or the Morea: and even +if there had been no fear of Russian aggression in the background, he would +instinctively have condemned the Greek revolt when he saw that the +light-headed professors in the German Universities were beginning to +agitate in its favour, and that the recalcitrant minor Courts regarded it +with some degree of sympathy. + +[Alexander adheres to policy of peace.] + +[Capdostrias retires, Aug 1822.] + +The policy of Metternich in the Eastern Question had for its object the +maintenance of the existing order of things; and as it was certain that +some satisfaction or other must be given to Russian pride, Metternich's +counsel was that the grievances of the Czar which were specifically Russian +should be clearly distinguished from questions relating to the independence +of Greece; and that on the former the Porte should be recommended to agree +with its adversary quickly, the good offices of Europe being employed +within given limits on the Czar's behalf; so that, the Russian causes of +complaint being removed, Alexander might without loss of honour leave the +Greeks to be subdued, and resume the diplomatic relations with +Constantinople which had been so perilously severed by Strogonoff's +departure. It remained for the Czar to decide whether, as head of Russia +and protector of the Christians of the East, he would solve the Eastern +Question by his own sword, or whether, constant to the principle and ideal +of international action to which he had devoted himself since 1815, he +would commit his cause to the joint mediation of Europe, and accept such +solution of the problem as his allies might attain. In the latter case it +was clear that no blow would be struck on behalf of Greece. For a year or +more the balance wavered; at length the note of triumph sounded in the +Austrian Cabinet. Capodistrias, the representative of the Greek cause at +St. Petersburg, rightly measured the force of the opposing impulses in the +Czar's mind. He saw that Alexander, interested as he was in Italy and +Spain, would never break with that federation of the Courts which he had +himself created, nor shake off the influences of legitimism which had +dominated him since the Congress of Aix-la-Chapelle. Submitting when +contention had become hopeless, and anticipating his inevitable fall by a +voluntary retirement from public affairs, Capodistrias, still high in +credit and reputation, quitted St. Petersburg under the form leave of +absence, and withdrew to Geneva, there to await events, and to enjoy the +distinction of a patriot whom love for Greece had constrained to abandon +one of the most splendid positions in Europe. Grave, melancholy, and +austere, as one who suffered with his country, Capodistrias remained in +private life till the vanquished cause had become the victorious one, and +the liberated Greek nation called him to place himself at its head. + +[Extension of the Greek revolt.] + +[Central Greece.] + +[Fall of Ali Pasha, Feb., 1822.] + +[Chalcidice.] + +An international diplomatic campaign of vast activity and duration began in +the year 1821, but the contest of arms was left, as Metternich desired, to +the Greeks and the Turks alone. The first act of the war was the +insurrection of the Morea: the second was the extension of this +insurrection over parts of Continental Greece and the Archipelago, and its +summary extinction by the Turk in certain districts, which in consequence +remained for the future outside the area of hostilities, and so were not +ultimately included in the Hellenic Kingdom. Central Greece, that is, the +country lying immediately north of the Corinthian Gulf, broke into revolt a +few weeks later than the Morea. The rising against the Mohammedans was +distinguished by the same merciless spirit: the men were generally +massacred; the women, if not killed, were for the most part sold into +slavery; and when, after an interval of three years, Lord Byron came to +Missolonghi, he found that a miserable band of twenty-three captive women +formed the sole remnant of the Turkish population of that town. Thessaly, +with some exceptions, remained passive, and its inaction was of the utmost +service to the Turkish cause; for Ali Pasha in Epirus was now being +besieged by the Sultan's armies, and if Thessaly had risen in the rear of +these troops, they could scarcely have escaped destruction. Khurshid, the +Ottoman commander conducting the siege of Janina, held firmly to his task, +in spite of the danger which threatened his communications, and in spite of +the circumstance that his whole household had fallen into the hands of the +Moreot insurgents. His tenacity saved the border-provinces for the Ottoman +Empire. No combination was effected between Ali and the Greeks, and at the +beginning of 1822 the Albanian chieftain lost both his stronghold and his +life. In the remoter district of Chalcidice, on the Macedonian coast, where +the promontory of Athos and the two parallel peninsulas run out into the +AEgaean, and a Greek population, clearly severed from the Slavic inhabitants +of the mainland, maintained its own communal and religious organisation, +the national revolt broke out under Hetaerist leaders. The monks of Mount +Athos, like their neighbours, took up arms. But there was little sympathy +between the privileged chiefs of these abbeys and the desperate men who had +come to head the revolt. The struggle was soon abandoned; and, partly by +force of arms, partly by negotiation, the authority of the Sultan was +restored without much difficulty throughout this region. + +[The AEgaean Islands.] + +The settlements of the AEgaean which first raised the flag of Greek +independence were the so-called Nautical Islands, Hydra, Spetza, and Psara, +where the absence of a Turkish population and the enjoyment of a century of +self-government had allowed the bold qualities of an energetic maritime +race to grow to their full vigour. Hydra and Spetza were close to the Greek +coast, Psara was on the farther side of the archipelago, almost within view +of Asia Minor; so that in joining the insurrection its inhabitants showed +great heroism, for they were exposed to the first attack of any Turkish +force that could maintain itself for a few hours at sea, and the whole +adjacent mainland was the recruiting-ground of the Sultan. At Hydra the +revolt against the Ottoman was connected with the internal struggles of the +little community, and these in their turn were connected with the great +economical changes of Europe which, at the opposite end of the continent, +and in a widely different society, led to the enactment of the English Corn +Laws, and to the strife of classes which resulted from them. During +Napoleon's wars the carrying-trade of most nations had become extinct; +little corn reached England, and few besides Greek ships navigated the +Euxine and Mediterranean. When peace opened the markets and the ports of +all nations, just as the renewed importation of foreign corn threatened to +lower the profits of English farmers and the rents of English landlords, so +the reviving freedom of navigation made an end of the monopoly of the +Hydriote and Psarian merchantmen. The shipowners formed an oligarchy in +Hydra; the captains and crews of their ships, though they shared the +profits of each voyage, were excluded from any share in the government of +the island. Failure of trade, want and inactivity, hence led to a political +opposition. The shipowners, wealthy and privileged men, had no inclination +to break with the Turk; the captains and sailors, who had now nothing to +lose, declared for Greek independence. There was a struggle in which for +awhile nothing but the commonest impulses of need and rapacity came into +play; but the greater cause proved its power: Hydra threw in its lot with +Greece; and although private greed and ill-faith, as well as great cruelty, +too often disgraced both the Hydriote crews and those of the other islands, +the nucleus of a naval force was now formed which made the achievement of +Greek independence possible. The three islands which led the way were soon +followed by the wealthier and more populous Samos and by the greater part +of the Archipelago. Crete, inhabited by a mixed Greek and Turkish +population, also took up arms, and was for years to come the scene of a +bloody and destructive warfare. + +[The Greek leaders.] + +Within the Morea the first shock of the revolt had made the Greeks masters +of everything outside the fortified towns. The reduction of these places +was at once undertaken by the insurgents. Tripolitza, lately the seat of +the Turkish government, was the centre of operations, and in the +neighbourhood of this town the first provisional government of the Greeks, +called the Senate of Kaltesti, was established. Demetrius Hypsilanti, a +brother of the Hetaerist leader, whose failure in Roumania was not yet +known, landed in the Morea and claimed supreme power. He was tumultuously +welcomed by the peasant-soldiers, though the Primates, who had hitherto +held undisputed sway, bore him no good will. Two other men became prominent +at this time as leaders in the Greek war of liberation. These were +Maurokordatos, a descendant of the Hospodars of Wallachia--a politician +superior to all his rivals in knowledge and breadth of view, but wanting in +the faculty of action required by the times--and Kolokotrones, a type of +the rough fighting Klepht; a mere savage in attainments, scarcely able to +read or write, cunning, grossly avaricious and faithless, incapable of +appreciating either military or moral discipline, but a born soldier in his +own irregular way, and a hero among peasants as ignorant as himself. There +was yet another, who, if his character had been equal to his station, would +have been placed at the head of the government of the Morea. This was +Petrobei, chief of the family of Mauromichalis, ruler of the rugged +district of Maina, in the south-west of Peloponnesus, where the Turk had +never established more than nominal sovereignty. A jovial, princely person, +exercising among his clansmen a mild Homeric sway, Petrobei, surrounded by +his nine vigorous sons, was the most picturesque figure in Greece. But he +had no genius for great things. A sovereignty, which in other hands might +have expanded to national dominion, remained with Petrobei a mere ornament +and curiosity; and the power of the deeply-rooted clan-spirit of the Maina +only made itself felt when, at a later period, the organisation of a united +Hellenic State demanded its sacrifice. + +[Fall of Tripolitza, Oct. 5, 1821.] + +Anarchy, egotism, and ill-faith disgraced the Greek insurrection from its +beginning to its close. There were, indeed, some men of unblemished honour +among the leaders, and the peasantry in the ranks fought with the most +determined courage year after year; but the action of most of those who +figured as representatives of the people brought discredit upon the +national cause. Their first successes were accompanied by gross treachery +and cruelty. Had the Greek leaders been Bourbon kings, nurtured in all the +sanctities of divine right, instead of tax-gatherers and cattle-lifters, +truants from the wild school of Turkish violence and deceit, they could not +have perjured themselves with lighter hearts. On the surrender of Navarino, +in August, 1821, after a formal capitulation providing for the safety of +its Turkish inhabitants, men, women, and children were indiscriminately +massacred. The capture of Tripolitza, which took place two months later, +was changed from a peaceful triumph into a scene of frightful slaughter by +the avarice of individual chiefs, who, while negotiations were pending, +made their way into the town, and bargained with rich inhabitants to give +them protection in return for their money and jewels. The soldiery, who had +undergone the labours of the siege for six months, saw that their reward +was being pilfered from them. Defying all orders, and in the absence of +Demetrius Hypsilanti, the commander-in-chief, they rushed upon the +fortifications of Tripolitza, and carried them by storm. A general massacre +of the inhabitants followed. For three days the work of carnage was +continued in the streets and houses, until few out of a population of many +thousands remained living. According to the testimony of Kolokotrones +himself, the roads were so choked with the dead, that as he rode from the +gateway to the citadel his horse's hoofs never touched the ground. [368] + +[The Massacre of Chios, April-June, 1822.] + +In the opening scenes of the Greek insurrection the barbarity of Christians +and of Ottomans was perhaps on a level. The Greek revenged himself with the +ferocity of the slave who breaks his fetters; the Turk resorted to +wholesale massacre and extermination as the normal means of government in +troubled times. And as experience has shown that the savagery of the +European yields in one generation to the influences of civilised rule, +while the Turk remains as inhuman to-day as he was under Mahmud II., so the +history of 1822 proved that the most devilish passions of the Greek were in +the end but a poor match for disciplined Turkish prowess in the work of +butchery. It was no easy matter for the Sultan to requite himself for the +sack of Tripolitza upon Kolokotrones and his victorious soldiers; but there +was a peaceful and inoffensive population elsewhere, which offered all the +conditions for free, unstinted, and unimperilled vengeance which the Turk +desires. A body of Samian troops had landed in Chios, and endeavoured, but +with little success, to excite the inhabitants to revolt, the absence of +the Greek fleet rendering them an almost certain prey to the Sultan's +troops on the mainland. The Samian leader nevertheless refused to abandon +the enterprise, and laid siege to the citadel, in which there was a Turkish +garrison. Before this fortress could be reduced, a relieving army of seven +thousand Turks, with hosts of fanatical volunteers, landed on the island. +The Samians fled; the miserable population of Chios was given up to +massacre. For week after week the soldiery and the roving hordes of +Ottomans slew, pillaged, and sold into slavery at their pleasure. In parts +of the island where the inhabitants took refuge in the monasteries, they +were slaughtered by thousands together; others, tempted back to their homes +by the promulgation of an amnesty, perished family by family. The lot of +those who were spared was almost more pitiable than of those who died. The +slave-markets of Egypt and Tunis were glutted with Chian captives. The +gentleness, the culture, the moral worth of the Chian community made its +fate the more tragical. No district in Europe had exhibited a civilisation +more free from the vices of its type: on no community had there fallen in +modern times so terrible a catastrophe. The estimates of the destruction of +life at Chios are loosely framed; among the lowest is that which sets the +number of the slain and the enslaved at thirty thousand. The island, lately +thronging with life and activity, became a thinly-populated place. After a +long period of depression and the slow return of some fraction of its +former prosperity, convulsions of nature have in our own day again made +Chios a ruin. A new life may arise when the Turk is no longer master of its +shores, but the old history of Chios is closed for ever. + +[Exploit of Kanaris, June 18th, 1822.] + +The impression made upon public opinion in Europe by the massacre of 1822 +was a deep and lasting one, although it caused no immediate change in the +action of Governments. The general feeling of sympathy for the Greeks and +hatred for the Turks, which ultimately forced the Governments to take up a +different policy, was intensified by a brilliant deed of daring by which a +Greek captain avenged the Chians upon their devastor, and by the unexpected +success gained by the insurgents on the mainland against powerful armies of +the Sultan. The Greek executive, which was now headed by Maurokordatos, had +been guilty of gross neglect in not sending over the fleet in time to +prevent the Turks from landing in Chios. When once this landing had been +effected, the ships which afterwards arrived were powerless to prevent the +massacre, and nothing could be attempted except against the Turkish fleet +itself. The instrument of destruction employed by the Greeks was the +fire-ship, which had been used with success against the Turk in these same +waters in the war of 1770. The sacred month of the Ramazan was closing, and +on the night of June 18, Kara Ali, the Turkish commander, celebrated the +festival of Bairam with above a thousand men on board his flag-ship. The +vessel was illuminated with coloured lanterns. In the midst of the +festivities, Constantine Kanaris, a Psarian captain, brought his fire-ship +unobserved right up to the Turkish man-of-war, and drove his bowsprit +firmly into one of her portholes; then, after setting fire to the +combustibles, he stepped quietly into a row-boat, and made away. A breeze +was blowing, and in a moment the Turkish crew were enveloped in a mass of +flames. The powder on board exploded; the boats were sunk; and the vessel, +with its doomed crew, burned to the water-edge, its companions sheering off +to save themselves from the shower of blazing fragments that fell all +around. Kara Ali was killed by a broken mast; a few of his men saved their +lives by swimming or were picked up by rescuers; the rest perished. Such +was the consternation caused by the deed of Kanaris, that the Ottoman fleet +forthwith quitted the AEgaean waters, and took refuge under the guns of the +Dardanelles. Kanaris, unknown before, became from this exploit a famous man +in Europe. It was to no stroke of fortune or mere audacity that he owed his +success, but to the finest combination of nerve and nautical skill. His +feat, which others were constantly attempting, but with little success, to +imitate, was repeated by him in the same year. He was the most brilliant of +Greek seamen, a simple and modest hero; and after his splendid achievements +in the war of liberation, he served his country well in a political career. +Down to his death in a hale old age, he was with justice the idol and pride +of the Greek nation. + +[Double invasion of Greece 1822.] + +[Destruction of the Pilhellenes near Arta, July 16.] + +[Unsuccessful siege of Missolonghi, Nov., 1822.] + +The fall of the Albanian rebel, Ali Pasha, in the spring of 1822 made it +possible for Sultan Mahmud, who had hitherto been crippled by the +resistance of Janina, to throw his whole land-force against the Hellenic +revolt; and the Greeks of the mainland, who had as yet had to deal only +with scattered detachments or isolated garrisons, now found themselves +exposed to the attack of two powerful armies. Kurshid, the conqueror of Ali +Pasha, took up his headquarters at Larissa in Thessaly, and from this base +the two invading armies marched southwards on diverging lines. The first, +under Omer Brionis, was ordered to make its way through Southern Epirus to +the western entrance of the Corinthian Gulf, and there to cross into the +Morea; the second, under Dramali, to reduce Central Greece, and enter the +Morea by the isthmus of Corinth; the conquest of Tripolitza and the relief +of the Turkish coast-fortresses which were still uncaptured being the +ultimate end to be accomplished by the two armies in combination with one +another and with the Ottoman fleet. Not less than fifty thousand men were +under the orders of the Turkish commanders, the division of Dramali being +by far the larger of the two. Against this formidable enemy the Greeks +possessed poor means of defence, nor were their prospects improved when +Maurokordatos, the President, determined to take a military command, and to +place himself at the head of the troops in Western Greece. There were +indeed urgent reasons for striking with all possible force in this quarter. +The Suliotes, after seventeen years of exile in Corfu, had returned to +their mountains, and were now making common cause with Greece. They were +both the military outwork of the insurrection, and the political link +between the Hellenes and the Christian communities of Albania, whose action +might become of decisive importance in the struggle against the Turks. +Maurokordatos rightly judged the relief of Suli to be the first and most +pressing duty of the Government. Under a capable leader this effort would +not have been beyond the power of the Greeks; directed by a politician who +knew nothing of military affairs, it was perilous in the highest degree. +Maurokordatos, taking the command out of abler hands, pushed his troops +forward to the neighbourhood of Arta, mismanaged everything, and after +committing a most important post to Botzares, an Albanian chieftain of +doubtful fidelity, left two small regiments exposed to the attack of the +Turks in mass. One of these regiments, called the corps of Philhellenes, +was composed of foreign officers who had volunteered to serve in the Greek +cause as common soldiers. Its discipline was far superior to anything that +existed among the Greeks themselves; and at its head were men who had +fought in Napoleon's campaigns. But this corps, which might have become the +nucleus of a regular army, was sacrificed to the incapacity of the general +and the treachery of his confederate. Betrayed and abandoned by the +Albanian, the Philhellenes met the attack of the Turks gallantly, and +almost all perished. Maurokordatos and the remnant of the Greek troops now +retired to Missolonghi. The Suliotes, left to their own resources, were +once more compelled to quit their mountain home, and to take refuge in +Corfu. Their resistance, however, delayed the Turks for some months, and it +was not until the beginning of November that the army of Omer Brionis, +after conquering the intermediate territory, appeared in front of +Missolonghi. Here the presence of Maurokordatos produced a better effect +than in the field. He declared that he would never leave the town as long +as a man remained to fight the Turks. Defences were erected, and the +besiegers kept at bay for two months. On the 6th of January, 1823, Brionis +ordered an assault. It was beaten back with heavy loss; and the Ottoman +commander, hopeless of maintaining his position throughout the winter, +abandoned his artillery, and retired into the interior of the country. +[369] + +[Dramali passes the Isthmus of Corinth, July 1822.] + +[His retreat and destruction, Aug., 1822.] + +In the meantime Dramali had advanced from Thessaly with twenty-four +thousand infantry and six thousand cavalry, the most formidable armament +that had been seen in Greece since the final struggle between the Turks and +Venetians in 1715. At the terror of his approach all hopes of resistance +vanished. He marched through Boeotia and Attica, devastating the country, +and reached the isthmus of Corinth in July, 1822. The mountain passes were +abandoned by the Greeks; the Government, whose seat was at Argos, +dispersed; and Dramali moved on to Nauplia, where the Turkish garrison was +on the point of surrendering to the Greeks. The entrance to the Morea had +been won; the very shadow of a Greek government had disappeared, and the +definite suppression of the revolt seemed now to be close at hand. But two +fatal errors of the enemy saved the Greek cause. Dramali neglected to +garrison the passes through which he had advanced; and the commander of the +Ottoman fleet, which ought to have met the land-force at Nauplia, disobeyed +his instructions and sailed on to Patras. Two Greeks, at this crisis of +their country's history, proved themselves equal to the call of events. +Demetrius Hypsilanti, now President of the Legislature, refused to fly with +his colleagues, and threw himself, with a few hundred men, into the +Acropolis of Argos. Kolokotrones, hastening to Tripolitza, called out every +man capable of bearing arms, and hurried back to Argos, where the Turks +were still held at bay by the defenders of the citadel. Dramali could no +longer think of marching into the interior of the Morea. The gallantry of +Demetrius had given time for the assemblage of a considerable force, and +the Ottoman general now discovered the ruinous effect of his neglect to +garrison the passes in his rear. These were seized by Kolokotrones. The +summer-drought threatened the Turkish army with famine; the fleet which +would have rendered them independent of land-supplies was a hundred miles +away; and Dramali, who had lately seen all Greece at his feet, now found +himself compelled to force his way back through the enemy to the isthmus of +Corinth. The measures taken by Kolokotrones to intercept his retreat were +skilfully planned, and had they been adequately executed not a man of the +Ottoman army would have escaped. It was only through the disorder and the +cupidity of the Greeks themselves that a portion of Dramali's force +succeeded in cutting its way back to Corinth. Baggage was plundered while +the retreating enemy ought to have been annihilated, and divisions which +ought to have co-operated in the main attack sought trifling successes of +their own. But the losses and the demoralisation of the Turkish army were +as ruinous to it as total destruction. Dramali himself fell ill and died; +and the remnant of his troops which had escaped from the enemy's hands +perished in the neighbourhood of Corinth from sickness and want. + +[Greek Civil Wars, 1824.] + +The decisive events of 1822 opened the eyes of European Governments to the +real character of the Greek national rising, and to the probability of its +ultimate success. The forces of Turkey were exhausted for the moment, and +during the succeeding year no military operations could be undertaken by +the Sultan on anything like the same scale. It would perhaps have been +better for the Greeks themselves if the struggle had been more continuously +sustained. Nothing but foreign pressure could give unity to the efforts of +a race distracted by so many local rivalries, and so many personal +ambitions and animosities. Scarcely was the extremity of danger passed when +civil war began among the Greeks themselves. Kolokotrones set himself up in +opposition to the Legislature, and seized on some of the strong places in +the Morea. This first outbreak of the so-called military party against the +civil authorities was, however, of no great importance. The Primates of the +Morea took part with the representatives of the islands and of Central +Greece against the disturber of the peace, and an accommodation was soon +arranged. Konduriottes, a rich ship-owner of Hydra, was made President, +with Kolettes, a politician of great influence in Central Greece, as his +Minister. But in place of the earlier antagonism between soldier and +civilian, a new and more dangerous antagonism, that of district against +district, now threatened the existence of Greece. The tendency of the new +government to sacrifice everything to the interest of the islands at once +became evident. Konduriottes was a thoroughly incompetent man, and made +himself ridiculous by appointing his friends, the Hydriote sea-captains, to +the highest military and civil posts. Rebellion again broke out, and +Kolokotrones was joined by his old antagonists, the Primates of the Morea. +A serious struggle ensued, and the government, which was really conducted +by Kolettes, displayed an energy that surprised both its friends and its +foes. The Morea was invaded by a powerful force from Hydra. No mercy was +shown to the districts which supported the rebels. Kolokotrones was +thoroughly defeated, and compelled to give himself up to the Government. He +was carried to Hydra and thrown into prison, where he remained until new +peril again rendered his services indispensable to Greece. + +[Mahmud calls for the help of Egypt.] + +After the destruction of Dramali's army and the failure of the Ottoman navy +to effect any result whatever, the Sultan appears to have conceived a doubt +whether the subjugation of Greece might not in fact be a task beyond his +own unaided power. Even if the mainland were conquered, it was certain that +the Turkish fleet could never reduce the islands, nor prevent the passage +of supplies and reinforcements from these to the ports of the Morea. +Strenuous as Mahmud had hitherto shown himself in crushing his vassals who, +like Ali Pasha, attempted to establish an authority independent of the +central government, he now found himself compelled to apply to the most +dangerous of them all for assistance. Mehemet Ali, Pasha of Egypt, had +risen to power in the disturbed time that followed the expulsion of +Napoleon's forces from Egypt. His fleet was more powerful than that of +Turkey. He had organised an army composed of Arabs, negroes, and fellahs, +and had introduced into it, by means of French officers, the military +system and discipline of Europe. The same reform had been attempted in +Turkey seventeen years before by Mahmud's predecessor, Selim III., but it +had been successfully resisted by the soldiery of Constantinople, and Selim +had paid for his innovations with his life. Mahmud, silent and tenacious, +had long been planning the destruction of the Janissaries, the mutinous and +degraded representatives of a once irresistible force, who would now +neither fight themselves nor permit their rulers to organise any more +effective body of troops in their stead. It is possible that the Sultan may +have believed that a victory won over the enemies of Islam by the +re-modelled forces of Egypt would facilitate the execution of his own plans +of military reform; it is also possible that he may not have been unwilling +to see his vassal's resources dissipated by a distant and hazardous +enterprise. Not without some profound conviction of the urgency of the +present need, not without some sinister calculation as to the means of +dealing with an eventual rival in the future, was the offer of +aggrandisement--if we may judge from the whole tenor of Sultan Mahmud's +career and policy--made to the Pasha of Egypt by his jealous and far-seeing +master. The Pasha was invited to assume the supreme command of the Ottoman +forces by land and sea, and was promised the island of Crete in return for +his co-operation against the Hellenic revolt. Messages to this effect +reached Alexandria at the beginning of 1824. Mehemet, whose ambition had no +limits, welcomed the proposals of his sovereign with ardour, and, while +declining the command for himself, accepted it on behalf of Ibrahim, his +adopted son. + +[Turkish-Egyptian plans.] + +[Egyptians conquer Crete, April, 1824.] + +[Destruction of Psara, July, 1824.] + +The most vigorous preparations for war were now made at Alexandria. The +army was raised to 90,000 men, and new ships were added to the navy from +English dockyards. A scheme was framed for the combined operation of the +Egyptian and the Turkish forces which appeared to render the ultimate +conquest of Greece certain. It was agreed that the island of Crete, which +is not sixty miles distant from the southern extremity of the Morea, should +be occupied by Ibrahim, and employed as his place of arms; that +simultaneous or joint attacks should then be made upon the principal +islands of the AEgaean; and that after the capture of these strongholds and +the destruction of the maritime resources of the Greeks, Ibrahim's troops +should pass over the narrow sea between Crete and the Morea, and complete +their work by the reduction of the mainland, thus left destitute of all +chance of succour from without. Crete, like Sicily, is a natural +stepping-stone between Europe and Africa; and when once the assistance of +Egypt was invoked by the Sultan, it was obvious that Crete became the +position which above all others it was necessary for the Greeks to watch +and to defend. But the wretched Government of Konduriottes was occupied +with its domestic struggles. The appeal of the Cretans for protection +remained unanswered, and in the spring of 1824 a strong Egyptian force +landed on this island, captured its fortresses, and suppressed the +resistance of the inhabitants with the most frightful cruelty. The base of +operations had been won, and the combined attacks of the Egyptian and +Turkish fleets upon the smaller islands followed. Casos, about thirty miles +east of Crete, was surprised by the Egyptians, and its population +exterminated. Psara was selected for the attack of the Turkish fleet. Since +the beginning of the insurrection the Psariotes had been the scourge and +terror of the Ottoman coasts. The services that they had rendered in the +Greek navy had been priceless; and if there was one spot of Greek soil +which ought to have been protected as long as a single boat's crew remained +afloat, it was the little rock of Psara. Yet, in spite of repeated +warnings, the Greek Government allowed the Turkish fleet to pass the +Dardanelles unobserved, and some clumsy feints were enough to blind it to +the real object of an expedition whose aim was known to all Europe. There +were ample means for succouring the islanders, as subsequent events proved; +but when the Turkish admiral, Khosrew, with 10,000 men on board, appeared +before Psara, the Greek fleet was far away. The Psariotes themselves were +over-confident. They trusted to their batteries on land, and believed their +rocks to be impregnable. They were soon undeceived. While a corps of +Albanians scaled the cliffs behind the town, the Turks gained a footing in +front, and overwhelmed their gallant enemy by weight of numbers. No mercy +was asked or given. Eight thousand of the Psarians were slain or carried +away as slaves. Not more than one-third of the population succeeded in +escaping to the neighbouring islands. [370] + +[Greek successes off the coast of Asia Minor, September, 1824.] + +[Ibrahim reaches Crete. December, 1824.] + +The first part of the Turko-Egyptian plan had thus been successfully +accomplished, and if Khosrew had attacked Samos immediately after his first +victory, this island would probably have fallen before help could arrive. +But, like other Turkish commanders, Khosrew loved intervals of repose, and +he now sailed off to Mytilene to celebrate the festival of Bairam. In the +meantime the catastrophe of Psara had aroused the Hydriote Government to a +sense of its danger. A strong fleet was sent across the AEgaean, and adequate +measures were taken to defend Samos both by land and sea. The Turkish fleet +was attacked with some success, and though Ibrahim with the Egyptian +contingent now reached the coast of Asia Minor, the Greeks proved +themselves superior to their adversaries combined. The operations of the +Mussulman commanders led to no result; they were harassed and terrified by +the Greek fireships; and when at length all hope of a joint conquest of +Samos had been abandoned, and Ibrahim set sail for Crete to carry out his +own final enterprise alone, he was met on the high seas by the Greeks, and +driven back to the coast of Asia Minor. During the autumn of 1824 the +disasters of the preceding months were to some extent retrieved, and the +situation of the Egyptian fleet would have become one of some peril if the +Greeks had maintained their guard throughout the winter. But they +underrated the energy of Ibrahim, and surrendered themselves to the belief +that he would not repeat the attempt to reach Crete until the following +spring. Careless, or deluded by false information, they returned to Hydra, +and left the seas unwatched. Ibrahim saw his opportunity, and, setting sail +for Crete at the beginning of December, he reached it without falling in +with the enemy. + +[Ibrahim in the Morea, Feb., 1825.] + +The snowy heights of Taygetus are visible on a clear winter's day from the +Cretan coast; yet, with their enemy actually in view of them, the Greeks +neglected to guard the passage to the Morea. On the 22nd of February, 1825, +Ibrahim crossed the sea unopposed and landed five thousand men at Modon. He +was even able to return to Crete and bring over a second contingent of +superior strength before any steps were taken to hinder his movements. The +fate of the mainland was now settled. Ibrahim marched from Modon upon +Navarino, defeated the Greek forces on the way, and captured the garrison +placed in the Island of Sphakteria--the scene of the first famous surrender +of the Spartans--before the Greek fleet could arrive to relieve it. The +forts of Navarino then capitulated, and Ibrahim pushed on his victorious +march towards the centre of the Morea. It was in vain that the old chief +Kolokotrones was brought from his prison at Hydra to take supreme command. +The conqueror of Dramali was unable to resist the onslaught of Ibrahim's +regiments, recruited from the fierce races of the Soudan, and fighting +with the same arms and under the same discipline as the best troops in +Europe. Kolokotrones was driven back through Tripolitza, and retired as the +Russians had retired from Moscow, leaving a deserted capital behind him. +Ibrahim gave his troops no rest; he hurried onwards against Nauplia, and on +the 24th of June reached the summit of the mountain-pass that looks down +upon the Argolic Gulf. "Ah, little island," he cried, as he saw the rock of +Hydra stretched below him, "how long wilt thou escape me?" At Nauplia +itself the Egyptian commander rode up to the very gates and scanned the +defences, which he hoped to carry at the first assault. Here, however, a +check awaited him. In the midst of general flight and panic, Demetrius +Hypsilanti was again the undaunted soldier. He threw himself with some few +hundreds of men into the mills of Lerna, and there beat back Ibrahim's +vanguard when it attempted to carry this post by storm. The Egyptian +recognised that with men like these in front of him Nauplia could be +reduced only by a regular siege. He retired for a while upon Tripolitza, +and thence sent out his harrying columns, slaughtering and devastating in +every direction. It seemed to be his design not merely to exhaust the +resources of his enemy but to render the Morea a desert, and to exterminate +its population. In the very birthplace of European civilisation, it was +said, this savage, who had already been nominated Pasha of the Morea, +intended to extinguish the European race and name, and to found for himself +upon the ashes of Greece a new barbaric state composed of African negroes +and fellaheen. That such design had actually been formed was denied by the +Turkish government in answer to official inquiries, and its existence was +not capable of proof. But the brutality of one age is the stupidity of the +next, and Ibrahim's violence recoiled upon himself. Nothing in the whole +struggle between the Sultan and the Greeks gave so irresistible an argument +to the Philhellenes throughout Europe, or so directly overcame the scruples +of Governments in regard to an armed intervention in favour of Greece, as +Ibrahim's alleged policy of extermination and re-settlement. The days were +past when Europe could permit its weakest member to be torn from it and +added to the Mohammedan world. + +[Siege of Missolongi, April, 1825-April, 1826.] + +One episode of the deepest tragic interest yet remained in the +Turko-Hellenic conflict before the Powers of Europe stepped in and struck +with weapons stronger than those which had fallen from dying hands. The +town of Missolonghi was now beleaguered by the Turks, who had invaded +Western Greece while Ibrahim was overrunning the Morea. Missolonghi had +already once been besieged without success; and, as in the case of +Saragossa, the first deliverance appears to have inspired the townspeople +with the resolution, maintained even more heroically at Missolonghi than at +the Spanish city, to die rather than capitulate. From the time when +Reschid, the Turkish commander, opened the second attack by land and sea in +the spring of 1825, the garrison and the inhabitants met every movement of +the enemy with the most obstinate resistance. It was in vain that Reschid +broke through the defences with his artillery, and threw mass after mass +upon the breaches which he made. For month after month the assaults of the +Turks were uniformly repelled, until at length the arrival of a Hydriote +squadron forced the Turkish fleet to retire from its position, and made the +situation of Reschid himself one of considerable danger. And now, as winter +approached, and the guerilla bands in the rear of the besiegers grew more +and more active, the Egyptian army with its leader was called from the +Morea to carry out the task in which the Turks had failed. The Hydriote +sea-captains had departed, believing their presence to be no longer needed; +and although they subsequently returned for a short time, their services +were grudgingly rendered and ineffective. Ibrahim, settling down to his +work at the beginning of 1826, conducted his operations with the utmost +vigour, boasting that he would accomplish in fourteen days what the Turks +could not effect in nine months. But his veteran soldiers were thoroughly +defeated when they met the Greeks hand to hand; and the Egyptian, furious +with his enemy, his allies, and his own officers, confessed that +Missolonghi could only be taken by blockade. He now ordered a fleet of +flat-bottomed boats to be constructed and launched upon the lagoons that +lie between Missolonghi and the open sea. Missolonghi was thus completely +surrounded; and when the Greek admirals appeared for the last time and +endeavoured to force an entrance through the shallows, they found the +besieger in full command of waters inaccessible to themselves, and after +one unsuccessful effort abandoned Missolonghi to its fate. In the third +week of April, 1826, exactly a year after the commencement of the siege, +the supply of food was exhausted. The resolution, long made, that the +entire population, men, women, and children, should fall by the enemy's +sword rather than surrender, was now actually carried out. On the night of +the 22nd of April all the Missolonghiots, with the exception of those whom +age, exhaustion, or illness made unable to leave their homes, were drawn up +in bands at the city gates, the women armed and dressed as men, the +children carrying pistols. Preceded by a body of soldiers, they crossed the +moat under Turkish fire. The attack of the vanguard carried everything +before it, and a way was cut through the Turkish lines. But at this moment +some cry of confusion was mistaken by those who were still on the bridges +for an order to retreat. A portion of the non-combatants returned into the +town, and with them the rearguard of the military escort. The leading +divisions, however, continued their march forward, and would have escaped +with the loss of some of the women and children, had not treachery already +made the Turkish commander acquainted with the routes which they intended +to follow. They had cleared the Turkish camp, and were expecting to meet +the bands of Greek armatoli, who had promised to fall upon the enemy's +rear, when, instead of friends, they encountered troop after troop of +Ottoman cavalry and of Albanians placed in ambush along the road between +Missolonghi and the mountains. Here, exhausted and surprised, they were cut +down without mercy, and out of a body numbering several thousand not more +than fifteen hundred men, with a few women and children, ultimately reached +places of safety. Missolonghi itself was entered by the Turks during the +sortie. The soldiers who had fallen back during the confusion on the +bridges, proved that they had not acted from cowardice. They fought +unflinchingly to the last, and three bands, establishing themselves in the +three powder magazines of the town, set fire to them when surrounded by the +Turks, and perished in the explosion Some thousands of women and children +were captured around and within the town, or wandering on the mountains; +but the Turks had few other prisoners. The men were dead or free. + +[Fall of the Acropolis of Athens, June 5, 1827.] + +From Missolonghi the tide of Ottoman conquest rolled eastward, and the +Acropolis of Athens was in its turn the object of a long and arduous siege. +The Government, which now held scarcely any territory on the mainland +except Nauplia, where it was itself threatened by Ibrahim, made the most +vigorous efforts to prevent the Acropolis from falling into Reschid's +hands. All, however, was in vain. The English officers, Church and +Cochrane, who were now placed at the head of the military and naval forces +of Greece, failed ignominiously in the attacks which they made on Reschid's +besieging army; and the garrison capitulated on June 5, 1827. But the time +was past when the liberation of Greece could be prevented by any Ottoman +victory. The heroic defence of the Missolonghiots had achieved its end. +Greece had fought long enough to enlist the Powers of Europe on its side; +and in the same month that Missolonghi fell the policy of non-intervention +was definitely abandoned by those Governments which were best able to carry +their intentions into effect. If the struggle had ended during the first +three years of the insurrection, no hand would have been raised to prevent +the restoration of the Sultan's rule. Russia then lay as if spell-bound +beneath the diplomacy of the Holy Alliance; and although in the second year +of the war the death of Castlereagh and the accession of Canning to power +had given Greece a powerful friend instead of a powerful foe within the +British Ministry, it was long before England stirred from its neutrality. +Canning indeed made no secret of his sympathies for Greece, and of his +desire to give the weaker belligerent such help as a neutral might afford; +but when he took up office the time had not come when intervention would +have been useful or possible. Changes in the policy of other great Powers +and in the situation of the belligerents themselves were, he considered, +necessary before the influence of England could be successfully employed in +establishing peace in the East. + +[First Russian project of joint intervention, 12 Jan., 1824.] + +A vigorous movement of public opinion in favour of Greece made itself felt +throughout Western Europe as the struggle continued; and the vivid and +romantic interest excited over the whole civilised world by the death of +Lord Byron in 1823, among the people whom he had come to free, probably +served the Greek cause better than all that Byron could have achieved had +his life been prolonged. In France and England, where public opinion had +great influence on the action of the Government, as well as in Germany, +where it had none whatever, societies were formed for assisting the Greeks +with arms, stores, and money. The first proposal, however, for a joint +intervention in favour of Greece came from St. Petersburg. The undisguised +good-will of Canning towards the insurgents led the Czar's Government to +anticipate that England itself might soon assume that championship of the +Greek cause which Russia, at the bidding of Metternich and of Canning's +predecessor, had up to that time declined. If the Greeks were to be +befriended, it was intolerable that others should play the part of the +patron. Accordingly, on the 12th of January, 1824, a note was submitted in +the Czar's name to all the Courts of Europe, containing a plan for a +settlement of the Greek question, which it was proposed that the great +Powers of Europe should enforce upon Turkey either by means of an armed +demonstration or by the threat of breaking off all diplomatic relations. +According to this scheme, Greece, apart from the islands, was to be divided +into three Principalities, each tributary to the Sultan and garrisoned by +Turkish troops, but in other respects autonomous, like the Principalities +of Moldavia and Wallachia. The islands were to retain their municipal +organisation as before. In one respect this scheme was superior to all that +have succeeded it, for it included in the territory of the Greeks both +Crete and Epirus; in all other respects it was framed in the interest of +Russia alone. Its object was simply to create a second group of provinces, +like those on the Danube, which should afford Russia a constant opportunity +for interfering with the Ottoman Empire, and which at the same time should +prevent the Greeks from establishing an independent and self-supporting +State. The design cannot be called insidious, for its object was so +palpable that not a single politician in Europe was deceived by it; and a +very simple ruse of Metternich's was enough to draw from the Russian +Government an explicit declaration against the independence of Greece, +which was described by the Czar as a mere chimera. But of all the parties +concerned, the Greeks themselves were loudest in denounciation of the +Russian plan. Their Government sent a protest against it to London, and was +assured by Canning in reply that the support of this country should never +be given to any scheme for disposing of the Greeks without their own +consent. Elsewhere the Czar's note was received with expressions of +politeness due to a Court which it might be dangerous to contradict; and a +series of conferences was opened at St. Petersburg for the purpose of +discussing propositions which no one intended to carry into execution. +Though Canning ordered the British ambassador at St. Petersburg to +dissociate himself from these proceedings, the conferences dragged on, with +long adjournments, from the spring of 1824 to the summer of the following +year. [371] + +[Discontent and conspiracies in Russia.] + +In the meantime a strong spirit of discontent was rising in the Russian +army and nation. The religious feeling no less than the pride of the people +was deeply wounded by Alexander's refusal to aid the Greeks in their +struggle, and by the pitiful results of his attempted diplomatic concert. +Alone among the European nations the Russians understood the ecclesiastical +character of the Greek insurrection, and owed nothing of their sympathy +with it to the spell of classical literature and art. It is characteristic +of the strength of the religious element in the political views of the +Russian people, that the floods of the Neva which overwhelmed St. +Petersburg in the winter of 1825 should have been regarded as a sign of +divine anger at the Czar's inaction in the struggle between the Crescent +and the Cross. But other causes of discontent were not wanting in Russia. +Though Alexander had forgotten his promises to introduce constitutional +rule, there were many, especially in the army, who had not done so. +Officers who served in the invasion of France in 1815, and in the three +years' occupation which followed it, returned from Western Europe with +ideas of social progress and of constitutional rights which they could +never have gathered in their own country. And when the bright hopes which +had been excited by the recognition of these same ideas by the Czar passed +away, and Russia settled down into the routine of despotism and corruption, +the old unquestioning loyalty of the army was no longer proof against the +workings of the revolutionary spirit. In a land where legal means of +opposition to government and of the initiation of reform were wholly +wanting, discontent was forced into its most dangerous form, that of +military conspiracy. The army was honeycombed with secret societies. Both +in the north and in the south of Russia men of influence worked among the +younger officers, and gained a strong body of adherents to their design of +establishing a constitution by force. The southern army contained the most +resolute and daring conspirators. These men had definitely abandoned the +hope of effecting any public reform as long as Alexander lived, and they +determined to sacrifice the sovereign, as his father and others before him +had been sacrificed, to the political necessities of the time. If the +evidence subsequently given by those implicated in the conspiracy is worthy +of credit, a definite plan had been formed for the assassination of the +Czar in the presence of his troops at one of the great reviews intended to +be held in the south of Russia in the autumn of 1825. On the death of the +monarch a provisional government was at once to be established, and a +constitution proclaimed. + +[Death of the Czar, Dec. 1, 1825.] + +Alexander, aware of the rising indignation of his people, and irritated +beyond endurance by the failure of his diplomatic efforts, had dissolved +the St. Petersburg Conferences in August, 1825, and declared that Russia +would henceforth act according to its own discretion. He quitted St. +Petersburg and travelled to the Black Sea, accompanied by some of the +leaders of the war-party. Here, plunged in a profound melancholy, conscious +that all his early hopes had only served to surround him with conspirators, +and that his sacrifice of Russia's military interests to international +peace had only rendered his country impotent before all Europe, he still +hesitated to make the final determination between peace and war. A certain +mystery hung over his movements, his acts, and his intentions. Suddenly, +while all Europe waited for the signal that should end the interval of +suspense, the news was sent out from a lonely port on the Black Sea that +the Czar was dead. Alexander, still under fifty years of age, had welcomed +the illness which carried him from a world of cares, and closed a career in +which anguish and disappointment had succeeded to such intoxicating glory +and such unbounded hope. Young as he still was for one who had reigned +twenty-four years, Alexander was of all men the most life-weary. Power, +pleasure, excitement, had lavished on him hours of such existence as none +but Napoleon among all his contemporaries had enjoyed. They had left him +nothing but the solace of religious resignation, and the belief that a +Power higher than his own might yet fulfil the purposes in which he himself +had failed. Ever in the midst of great acts and great events, he had missed +greatness himself. Where he had been best was exactly where men inferior to +himself considered him to have been worst--in his hopes; and these hopes he +had himself abandoned and renounced. Strength, insight, unity of purpose, +the qualities which enable men to mould events, appeared in him but +momentarily or in semblance. For want of them the large and fair horizon of +his earlier years was first obscured and then wholly blotted out from his +view, till in the end nothing but his pietism and his generosity +distinguished him from the politicians of repression whose instrument he +had become. + +[Military insurrection at St. Petersburg, Dec 26, 1825.] + +The sudden death of Alexander threw the Russian Court into the greatest +confusion, for it was not known who was to succeed him. The heir to the +throne was his brother Constantine, an ignorant and brutal savage, who had +just sufficient sense not to desire to be Czar of Russia, though he +considered himself good enough to tyrannise over the Poles. Constantine had +renounced his right to the crown some years before, but the renunciation +had not been made public, nor had the Grand Duke Nicholas, Constantine's +younger brother, been made aware that the succession was irrevocably fixed +upon himself. Accordingly, when the news of Alexander's death reached St. +Petersburg, and the document embodying Constantine's abdication was brought +from the archives by the officials to whose keeping it had been entrusted, +Nicholas refused to acknowledge it as binding, and caused the troops to +take the oath of allegiance to Constantine, who was then at Warsaw. +Constantine, on the other hand, proclaimed his brother emperor. An +interregnum of three weeks followed, during which messages passed between +Warsaw and St. Petersburg, Nicholas positively refusing to accept the crown +unless by his elder brother's direct command. This at length arrived, and +on the 26th of December Nicholas assumed the rank of sovereign. But the +interval of uncertainty had been turned to good account by the conspirators +at St. Petersburg. The oath already taken by the soldiers to Constantine +enabled the officers who were concerned in the plot to denounce Nicholas as +a usurper, and to disguise their real designs under the cloak of loyalty to +the legitimate Czar. Ignorant of the very meaning of a constitution, the +common soldiers mutinied because they were told to do so; and it is said +that they shouted the word Constitution, believing it to be the name of +Constantine's wife. When summoned to take the oath to Nicholas, the Moscow +Regiment refused it, and marched off to the place in front of the Senate +House, where it formed square, and repulsed an attack made upon it by the +Cavalry of the Guard. Companies from other regiments now joined the +mutineers, and symptoms of insurrection began to show themselves among the +civil population. Nicholas himself did not display the energy of character +which distinguished him through all his later life; on the contrary, his +attitude was for some time rather that of resignation than of +self-confidence. Whether some doubt as to the justice of his cause haunted +him, or a trial like that to which he was now exposed was necessary to +bring to its full strength the iron quality of his nature, it is certain +that the conduct of the new Czar during these critical hours gave to those +around him little indication of the indomitable will which was hence forth +to govern Russia. Though the great mass of the army remained obedient, it +was but slowly brought up to the scene of revolt. Officers of high rank +were sent to harangue the insurgents, and one of these, General +Miloradovitsch, a veteran of the Napoleonic campaigns, was mortally wounded +while endeavouring to make himself heard. It was not until evening that the +artillery was ordered into action, and the command given by the Czar to +fire grape-shot among the insurgents. The effect was decisive. The +mutineers fled before a fire which they were unable to return, and within a +few minutes the insurrection was over. It had possessed no chief of any +military capacity; its leaders were missing at the moment when a forward +march or an attack on the palace of the Czar might have given them the +victory; and among the soldiers at large there was not the least desire to +take part in any movement against the established system of Russia. The +only effect left by the conspiracy within Russia itself was seen in the +rigorous and uncompromising severity with which Nicholas henceforward +enforced the principle of autocratic rule. The illusions of the previous +reign were at an end. A man with the education and the ideas of a +drill-sergeant and the religious assurance of a Covenanter was on the +throne; rebellion had done its worst against him; and woe to those who in +future should deviate a hair's breadth from their duty of implicit +obedience to the sovereign's all-sufficing power. [372] + +[Anglo-Russian Protocol, April 4, 1826.] + +It has been stated, and with some probability of truth, that the military +insurrection of 1825 disposed the new Czar to a more vigorous policy +abroad. The conspirators, when on their trial, declared it to have been +their intention to throw the army at once into an attack upon the Turks; +and in so doing they would certainly have had the feeling of the nation on +their side. Nicholas himself had little or no sympathy for the Greeks. They +were a democratic people, and the freedom which they sought to gain was +nothing but anarchy. "Do not speak of the Greeks," he said to the +representative of a foreign power, "I call them the rebels." Nevertheless, +little as Nicholas wished to serve the Greek democracy, both inclination +and policy urged him to make an end of his predecessor's faint-hearted +system of negotiation, and to bring the struggle in the East to a summary +close. Canning had already, in conversation with the Russian ambassador at +London, discussed a possible change of policy on the part of the two rival +Courts. He now saw that time had come for establishing new relations +between Great Britain and Russia, and for attempting that co-operation in +the East which he had held to be impracticable during Alexander's reign. +The Duke of Wellington was sent to St. Petersburg, nominally to offer the +usual congratulations to the new sovereign, in reality to dissuade him from +going to war, and to propose either the separate intervention of England or +a joint intervention by England and Russia on behalf of Greece. The mission +was successful. It was in vain that Metternich endeavoured to entangle the +new Czar in the diplomatic web that had so long held his predecessor. The +spell of the Holy Alliance was broken. Nicholas looked on the past +influence of Austria on the Eastern Question only with resentment; he would +hear of no more conferences of ambassadors; and on the 4th of April, 1826, +a Protocol was signed at St. Petersburg, by which Great Britain and Russia +fixed the conditions under which the mediation of the former Power was to +be tendered to the Porte. Greece was to remain tributary to the Sultan; it +was, however, to be governed by its own elected authorities, and to be +completely independent in its commercial relations. The policy known in our +own day as that of bag-and-baggage expulsion was to be carried out in a far +more extended sense than that in which it has been advocated by more recent +champions of the subject races of the East; the Protocol of 1826 +stipulating for the removal not only of Turkish officials but of the entire +surviving Turkish population of Greece. All property belonging to the +Turks, whether on the continent or in the islands, was to be purchased by +the Greeks. [373] + +Thus was the first step taken in the negotiations which ended in the +establishment of Hellenic independence. The Protocol, which had been +secretly signed, was submitted after some interval to the other Courts of +Europe. At Vienna it was received with the utmost disgust. Metternich had +at first declared the union of England and Russia to be an impossibility. +When this union was actually established, no language was sufficiently +strong to express his mortification and his spite. At one moment he +declared that Canning was a revolutionist who had entrapped the young and +inexperienced Czar into an alliance with European radicalism; at another, +that England had made itself the cat's-paw of Russian ambition. Not till +now, he protested, could Europe understand what it had lost in Castlereagh. +Nor did Metternich confine himself to lamentations. While his +representatives at Paris and Berlin spared no effort to excite the +suspicion of those Courts against the Anglo-Russian project of +intervention, the Austrian ambassador at London worked upon King George's +personal hostility to Canning, and conspired against the Minister with that +important section of the English aristocracy which was still influenced by +the traditional regard for Austria. Berlin, however, was the only field +where Metternich's diplomacy still held its own. King Frederick William had +not yet had time to acquire the habit of submission to the young Czar +Nicholas, and was therefore saved the pain of deciding which of two masters +he should obey. In spite of his own sympathy for the Greeks, he declined to +connect Prussia with the proposed joint-intervention, and remained passive, +justifying this course by the absence of any material interests of Prussia +in the East. Being neither a neighbour of the Ottoman Empire nor a maritime +Power, Prussia had in fact no direct means of making its influence felt. + +[Treaty between England, Russia and France, July, 1827.] + +France, on whose action much more depended, was now governed wholly in the +interests of the Legitimist party. Louis XVIII. had died in 1824, and the +Count of Artois had succeeded to the throne, under the title of Charles X. +The principles of the Legitimists would logically have made them defenders +of the hereditary rights of the Sultan against his rebellious subjects; but +the Sultan, unlike Ferdinand of Spain, was not a Bourbon nor even a +Christian; and in a case where the legitimate prince was an infidel and the +rebels were Christians, the conscience of the most pious Legitimist might +well recoil from the perilous task of deciding between the divine rights of +the Crown and the divine rights of the Church, and choose, in so painful an +emergency, the simpler course of gratifying the national love of action. +There existed, both among Liberals and among Ultramontanes, a real sympathy +for Greece, and this interest was almost the only one in which all French +political sections felt that they had something in common. Liberals +rejoiced in the prospect of making a new free State in Europe; Catholics, +like Charles X. himself, remembered Saint Louis and the Crusades; +diplomatists understood the extreme importance of the impending breach +between Austria and Russia, and of the opportunity of allying France with +the latter Power. Thus the natural and disinterested impulse of the greater +part of the public coincided exactly with the dictates of a far-seeing +policy; and the Government, in spite of its Legitimist principles and of +some assurances given to Metternich in person when he visited Paris in +1825, determined to accept the policy of the Anglo-Russian intervention in +the East, and to participate in the active measures about to be taken by +the two Powers. The Protocol of St. Petersburg formed the basis of a +definitive treaty which was signed at London in July, 1827. By this act +England, Russia, and France undertook to put an end to the conflict in the +East, which, through the injury done to the commerce of all nations, had +become a matter of European concern. The contending parties were to be +summoned to accept the mediation of the Powers and to consent to an +armistice. Greece was to be made autonomous, under the paramount +sovereignty of the Sultan; the Mohammedan population of the Greek provinces +was, as in the Protocol of St. Petersburg, to be entirely removed; and the +Greeks were to enter upon possession of all Turkish property within their +limits, paying an indemnity to the former owners. Each of the three +contracting Governments pledged itself to seek no increase of territory in +the East, and no special commercial advantages. In the secret articles of +the treaty provisions were made for the case of the rejection by the Turks +of the proposed offer of mediation. Should the armistice not be granted +within one month, the Powers agreed that they would announce to each +belligerent their intention to prevent further encounters, and that they +would take the necessary steps for enforcing this declaration, without, +however, taking part in hostilities themselves. Instructions in conformity +with the Treaty were to be sent to the Admirals commanding the +Mediterranean squadrons of the three Powers. [374] + +[Death of Canning, August, 1827.] + +[Policy of Canning.] + +Scarcely was the Treaty of London signed when Canning died. He had +definitely broken from the policy of his predecessors, that policy which, +for the sake of guarding against Russia's advance, had condemned the +Christian races of the East to 1827. eternal subjection to the Turk, and +bound up Great Britain with the Austrian system of resistance to the very +principle and name of national independence. Canning was no blind friend to +Russia. As keenly as any of his adversaries he appreciated the importance +of England's interests in the East; of all English statesmen of that time +he would have been the last to submit to any diminution of England's just +influence or power. But, unlike his predecessors, he saw that there were +great forces at work which, whether with England's concurrence or in spite +of it, would accomplish that revolution in the East for which the time was +now come; and he was statesman enough not to acquiesce in the belief that +the welfare of England was in permanent and necessary antagonism to the +moral interests of mankind and the better spirit of the age. Therefore, +instead of attempting to maintain the integrity of the Ottoman Empire, or +holding aloof and resorting to threats and armaments while Russia +accomplished the liberation of Greece by itself, he united with Russia in +this work, and relied on concerted action as the best preventive against +the undue extension of Russia's influence in the East. In committing +England to armed intervention, Canning no doubt hoped that the settlement +of the Greek question arranged by the Powers would be peacefully accepted +by the Sultan, and that a separate war between Russia and the Porte, on +this or any other issue, would be averted. Neither of these hopes was +realised. The joint-intervention had to be enforced by arms, and no sooner +had the Allies struck their common blow than a war between Turkey and +Russia followed. How far the course of events might have been modified had +Canning's life not been cut short it is impossible to say; but whether his +statesmanship might or might not have averted war on the Danube, the +balance of results proved his policy to have been the right one. Greece was +established as an independent State, to supply in the future a valuable +element of resistance to Slavic preponderance in the Levant; and the +encounter between Russia and Turkey, so long dreaded, produced none of +those disastrous effects which had been anticipated from it. On the +relative value of Canning's statesmanship as compared with that of his +predecessors, the mind of England and of Europe has long been made up. He +stands among those who have given to this country its claim to the respect +of mankind. His monument, as well as his justification, is the existence of +national freedom in the East; and when half a century later a British +Government reverted to the principle of nonintervention, as it had been +understood by Castlereagh, and declined to enter into any effective +co-operation with Russia for the emancipation of Bulgaria, even then, when +the precedent of Canning's action in 1827 stood in direct and glaring +contradiction to the policy of the hour, no effective attempt was made by +the leaders of the party to which Canning had belonged to impugn his +authority, or to explain away his example. It might indeed be alleged that +Canning had not explicitly resolved on the application of force; but those +who could maintain that Canning would, like Wellington, have used the +language of apology and regret when Turkish obstinacy had made it +impossible to effect the object of his intervention by any other means, had +indeed read the history of Canning's career in vain. [375] + +[Intervention of the Admirals, Sept., 1927.] + +The death of Canning, which brought his rival, the Duke of Wellington, +after a short interval to the head of affairs, caused at the moment no +avowed change in the execution of his plans. In accordance with the +provisions of the Treaty of London the mediation of the allied Powers was +at once tendered to the belligerents, and an armistice demanded. The +armistice was accepted by the Greeks; it was contemptuously refused by the +Turks. In consequence of this refusal the state of war continued, as it +would have been absurd to ask the Greeks to sit still and be massacred +because the enemy declined to lay down his arms. The Turk being the party +resisting the mediation agreed upon, it became necessary to deprive him of +the power of continuing hostilities. Heavy reinforcements had just arrived +from Egypt, and an expedition was on the point of sailing from Navarino, +the gathering place of Ibrahim's forces, against Hydra, the capture of +which would have definitely made an end of the Greek insurrection. Admiral +Codrington, the commander of the British fleet, and the French Admiral De +Rigny, were now off the coast of Greece. They addressed themselves to +Ibrahim, and required from him a promise that he would make no movement +until further orders should arrive from Constantinople. Ibrahim made this +promise verbally on the 25th of September. A few days later, however, +Ibrahim learnt that while he himself was compelled to be inactive, the +Greeks, continuing hostilities as they were entitled to do, had won a +brilliant naval victory under Captain Hastings within the Gulf of Corinth. +Unable to control his anger, he sailed out from the harbour of Navarino, +and made for Patras. Codrington, who had stationed his fleet at Zante, +heard of the movement, and at once threw himself across the track of the +Egyptian, whom he compelled to turn back by an energetic threat to sink his +fleet. Had the French and Russian contingents been at hand, Codrington +would have taken advantage of Ibrahim's sortie to cut him off from all +Greek harbours, and to force him to return direct to Alexandria, thus +peaceably accomplishing the object of the intervention. This, however, to +the misfortune of Ibrahim's seamen, the English admiral could not do alone. +Ibrahim re-entered Navarino, and there found the orders of the Sultan for +which it had been agreed that he should wait. These orders were dictated by +true Turkish infatuation. They bade Ibrahim continue the subjugation of the +Morea with the utmost vigour, and promised him the assistance of Reschid +Pasha, his rival in the siege of Missolonghi. Ibrahim, perfectly reckless +of the consequences, now sent out his devastating columns again. No life, +and nothing that could support life, was spared. Not only were the crops +ravaged, but the fruit-trees, which are the permanent support of the +country, were cut down at the roots. Clouds of fire and smoke from burning +villages showed the English officers who approached the coast in what +spirit the Turk met their proposals for a pacification. "It is supposed +that if Ibrahim remained in Greece," wrote Captain Hamilton, "more than a +third of its inhabitants would die of absolute starvation." + +[Battle of Navarino, Oct. 20th, 1827.] + +It became necessary to act quickly, the more so as the season was far +advanced, and a winter blockade of Ibrahim's fleet was impossible. A +message was sent to the Egyptian head-quarters, requiring that hostilities +should cease, that the Morea should be evacuated, and the Turko-Egyptian +fleet return to Constantinople and Alexandria. In answer to this message +there came back a statement that Ibrahim had left Navarino for the interior +of the country, and that it was not known where to find him. Nothing now +remained for the admirals but to make their presence felt. On the 18th of +October it was resolved that the English, French, and Russian fleets, which +were now united, should enter the harbour of Navarino in battle order. The +movement was called a demonstration, and in so far as the admirals had not +actually determined upon making an attack, it was not directly a hostile +measure; but every gun was ready to open fire, and it was well understood +that any act of resistance on the part of the opposite fleet would result +in hostilities. Codrington, as senior officer, took command of the allied +squadron, and the instructions which he gave to his colleagues for the +event of a general engagement concluded with Nelson's words, that no +captain could do very wrong who placed his ship alongside that of an enemy. + +Thus, ready to strike hard, the English admiral sailed into the harbour of +Navarino at noon on October 20, followed by the French and the Russians. +The allied fleet advanced to within pistol-shot of the Ottoman ships and +there anchored. A little to the windward of the position assigned to the +English corvette _Dartmouth_ there lay a Turkish fire-ship. A request +was made that this dangerous vessel might be removed to a safer distance; +it was refused, and a boat's crew was then sent to cut its cable. The boat +was received with musketry fire. This was answered by the _Dartmouth_ +and by a French ship, and the battle soon became general. Codrington, still +desirous to avoid bloodshed, sent his pilot to Moharem Bey, who commanded +in Ibrahim's absence, proposing to withhold fire on both sides. Moharem +replied with cannon-shot, killing the pilot and striking Codrington's own +vessel. This exhausted the patience of the English admiral, who forthwith +made his adversary a mere wreck. The entire fleets on both sides were now +engaged. The Turks had a superiority of eight hundred guns, and fought with +courage. For four hours the battle raged at close quarters in the +land-locked harbour, while twenty thousand of Ibrahim's soldiers watched +from the surrounding hills the struggle in which they could take no part. +But the result of the combat was never for a moment doubtful. The confusion +and bad discipline of the Turkish fleet made it an easy prey. Vessel after +vessel was sunk or blown to pieces, and before evening fell the work of the +allies was done. When Ibrahim returned from his journey on the following +day he found the harbour of Navarino strewed with wrecks and dead bodies. +Four thousand of his seamen had fallen; the fleet which was to have +accomplished the reduction of Hydra was utterly ruined. [376] + +[Inaction of England after Navarino.] + +Over all Greece it was at once felt that the nation was saved. The +intervention of the Powers had been sudden and decisive beyond the most +sanguine hopes; and though this intervention might be intended to establish +something less than the complete independence of Greece, the violence of +the first collision bade fair to carry the work far beyond the bounds +originally assigned to it. The attitude of the Porte after the news of the +battle of Navarino reached Constantinople was exactly that which its worst +enemies might have desired. So far from abating anything in its resistance +to the mediation of the three Powers, it declared the attack made upon its +navy to be a crime and an outrage, and claimed satisfaction for it from the +ambassadors of the Allied Powers. Arguments proved useless, and the united +demand for an armistice with the Greeks having been finally and +contemptuously refused, the ambassadors, in accordance with their +instructions, quitted the Turkish capital (Dec. 8). Had Canning been still +living, it is probable that the first blow of Navarino would have been +immediately followed by the measures necessary to make the Sultan submit to +the Treaty of London, and that the forces of Great Britain would have been +applied with sufficient vigour to render any isolated action on the part of +Russia both unnecessary and impossible. But at this critical moment a +paralysis fell over the English Government. Canning's policy was so much +his own, he had dragged his colleagues so forcibly with him in spite of +themselves, that when his place was left empty no one had the courage +either to fulfil or to reverse his intentions, and the men who succeeded +him acted as if they were trespassers in the fortress which Canning had +taken by storm. The very ground on which Wellington, no less than Canning, +had justified the agreement made with Russia in 1826 was the necessity of +preventing Russia from acting alone; and when Russian and Turkish ships had +actually fought at Navarino, and war was all but formally declared, it +became more imperative than ever that Great Britain should keep the most +vigorous hold upon its rival, and by steady, consistent pressure let it be +known to both Turks and Russians that the terms of the Treaty of London and +no others must be enforced. To retire from action immediately after dealing +the Sultan one dire, irrevocable blow, without following up this stroke or +attaining the end agreed upon--to leave Russia to take up the armed +compulsion where England had dropped it, and to win from its crippled +adversary the gains of a private and isolated war--was surely the weakest +of all possible policies that could have been adopted. Yet this was the +policy followed by English Ministers during that interval of transition and +incoherence that passed between Canning's death and the introduction of the +Reform Bill. + +[War between Russia and Turkey, April, 1828.] + +By the Russian Government nothing was more ardently desired than a contest +with Turkey, in which England and France, after they had destroyed the +Turkish fleet, should be mere on-lookers, debarred by the folly of the +Porte itself from prohibiting or controlling hostilities between it and its +neighbour. There might indeed be some want of a pretext for war, since all +the points of contention between Russia and Turkey other than those +relating to Greece had been finally settled in Russia's favour by a Treaty +signed at Akerman in October, 1826. But the spirit of infatuation had +seized the Sultan, or a secret hope that the Western Powers would in the +last resort throw over the Court of St. Petersburg led him to hurry on +hostilities by a direct challenge to Russia. A proclamation which reads +like the work of some frantic dervish, though said to have been composed by +Mahmud himself, called the Mussulman world to arms. Russia was denounced as +the instigator of the Greek rebellion, and the arch-enemy of Islam. The +Treaty of Akerman was declared to have been extorted by compulsion and to +have been signed only for the purpose of gaining time. "Russia has imparted +its own madness to the other Powers and persuaded them to make an alliance +to free the Rayah from his Ottoman master. But the Turk does not count his +enemies. The law forbids the people of Islam to permit any injury to be +done to their religion; and if all the unbelievers together unite against +them, they will enter on the war as a sacred duty, and trust in God for +protection." This proclamation was followed by a levy of troops and the +expulsion of most of the Christian residents in Constantinople. Russia +needed no other pretext. The fanatical outburst of the Sultan was treated +by the Court of St. Petersburg as if it had been the deliberate expression +of some civilised Power, and was answered on the 26th of April, 1828, by a +declaration of war. In order to soften the effect of this step and to reap +the full benefit of its subsisting relations with France and England, +Russia gave a provisional undertaking to confine its operations as a +belligerent to the mainland and the Black Sea, and within the Mediterranean +to act still as one of the allied neutrals under the terms of the Treaty of +London. + +[Military condition of Turkey.] + +The moment seized by Russia for the declaration of war was one singularly +favourable to itself and unfortunate for its adversary. Not only had the +Turkish fleet been destroyed by the neutrals, but the old Turkish force of +the Janissaries had been destroyed by its own master, and the new-modelled +regiments which were to replace it had not yet been organised. The Sultan +had determined in 1826 to postpone his long-planned military reform no +longer, and to stake everything on one bold stroke against the Janissaries. +Troops enough were brought up from the other side of the Bosphorus to make +Mahmud certain of victory. The Janissaries were summoned to contribute a +proportion of their number to the regiments about to be formed on the +European pattern; and when they proudly refused to do so and raised the +standard of open rebellion they were cut to pieces and exterminated by +Mahmud's Anatolian soldiers in the midst of Constantinople. [377] The +principal difficulty in the way of a reform of the Turkish army was thus +removed and the work of reorganisation was earnestly taken in hand; but +before there was time to complete it the enemy entered the field. Mahmud +had to meet the attack of Russia with an army greatly diminished in number, +and confused by the admixture of European and Turkish discipline. The +resources of the empire were exhausted by the long struggle with Greece, +and, above all, the destruction of the Janissaries had left behind it an +exasperation which made the Sultan believe that rebellion might at any +moment break out in his own capital. Nevertheless, in spite of its inherent +weakness and of all the disadvantages under which it entered into war, +Turkey succeeded in prolonging its resistance through two campaigns, and +might, with better counsels, have tried the fortune of a third. + +[Military condition of Russia.] + +The actual military resources of Russia were in 1828 much below what they +were believed to be by all Europe. The destruction of Napoleon's army in +1812 and the subsequent exploits of Alexander in the campaigns which ended +in the capture of Paris had left behind them an impression of Russian +energy and power which was far from corresponding with the reality, and +which, though disturbed by the events of 1828, had by no means vanished at +the time of the Crimean War. The courage and patience of the Russian +soldier were certainly not over-rated; but the progress supposed to have +been made in Russian military organisation since the campaign of 1799, when +it was regarded in England and Austria as little above that of savages, was +for the most part imaginary. The proofs of a radically bad system--scanty +numbers, failing supplies, immense sickness--were never more conspicuous +than in 1828. Though Russia had been preparing for war for at least seven +years, scarcely seventy thousand soldiers could be collected on the Pruth. +The general was Wittgenstein, one of the heroes of 1812, but now a veteran +past effective work. Nicholas came to the camp to make things worse by +headstrong interference. The best Russian officer, Paskiewitsch, was put in +command of the forces about to operate in Asia Minor, and there, thrown on +his own resources and free to create a system of his own, he achieved +results in strong contrast to the failure of the Russian arms on the +Danube. + +[Campaign of 1828.] + +In entering on the campaign of 1828, it was necessary for the Czar to avoid +giving any unnecessary causes of anxiety to Austria, which had already made +unsuccessful attempts to form a coalition against him. The line of +operations was therefore removed as far as possible from the Austrian +frontier; and after the Roumanian principalities had been peacefully +occupied, the Danube was crossed at a short distance above the point where +its mouths divide (June 7). The Turks had no intention of meeting the enemy +in a pitched battle; they confined themselves to the defence of fortresses, +the form of warfare to which, since the decline of the military art in +Turkey, the patience and abstemiousness of the race best fit them. Ibraila +and Silistria on the Danube, Varna and Shumla in the neighbourhood of the +Balkans, were their principal strongholds; of these Ibraila was at once +besieged by a considerable force, while Silistria was watched by a weak +contingent, and the vanguard of the Russian army pushed on through the +Dobrudscha towards the Black Sea, where, with the capture of the minor +coast-towns, it expected to enter into communication with the fleet. The +first few weeks of the campaign were marked by considerable successes. +Ibraila capitulated on the 18th of June, and the military posts in the +Dobrudscha fell one after another into the hands of the invaders, who met +with no effective resistance in this district. But their serious work was +only now beginning. The Russian army, in spite of its weakness, was divided +into three parts, occupied severally in front of Silistria, Shumla, and +Varna. At Shumla the mass of the Turkish army, under Omer Brionis, was +concentrated. The force brought against it by the invader was inadequate to +its task, and the attempts which were made to lure the Turkish army from +its entrenched camp into the open field proved unsuccessful. The +difficulties of the siege proved so great that Wittgenstein after a while +proposed to abandon offensive operations at this point, and to leave a mere +corps of observation before the enemy until Varna should have fallen. This, +however, was forbidden by the Czar. As the Russians wasted away before +Shumla with sickness and fatigue, the Turks gained strength, and on the +24th of September Omer broke out from his entrenchments and moved eastwards +to the relief of Varna. Nicholas again over-ruled his generals, and ordered +his cousin, Prince Eugene of Wuertemberg, to attack the advancing Ottomans +with the troops then actually at his disposal. Eugene did so, and suffered +a severe defeat. A vigorous movement of the Turks would probably have made +an end of the campaign, but Omer held back at the critical moment, and on +the 10th of October Varna surrendered. This, however, was the only conquest +made by the Russians. The season was too far advanced for them either to +cross the Balkans or to push forward operations against the uncaptured +fortresses. Shumla and Silistria remained in the hands of their defenders, +and the Russians, after suffering enormous losses in proportion to the +smallness of their numbers, withdrew to Varna and the Danube, to resume the +campaign in the spring of the following year. [378] + +[Campaign of 1829.] + +The spirits of the Turks and of their European friends were raised by the +unexpected failure of the Czar's arms. Metternich resumed his efforts to +form a coalition, and tempted French Ministers with the prospect of +recovering the Rhenish provinces, but in vain. The Sultan began +negotiations, but broke them off when he found that the events of the +campaign had made no difference in the enemy's tone. The prestige of Russia +was in fact at stake, and Nicholas would probably have faced a war with +Austria and Turkey combined rather than have made peace without restoring +the much-diminished reputation of his troops. The winter was therefore +spent in bringing up distant reserves. Wittgenstein was removed from his +command; the Czar withdrew from military operations in which he had done +nothing but mischief; and Diebitsch, a Prussian by birth and training, was +placed at the head of the army, untrammelled by the sovereign presence or +counsels which had hampered his predecessor. The intention of the new +commander was to cross the Balkans as soon as Silistria should have fallen, +without waiting for the capture of Shumla. In pursuance of this design the +fleet was despatched early in the spring of 1829 to seize a port beyond the +mountain-range. Diebitsch then placed a corps in front of Silistria, and +made his preparations for the southward march; but before any progress had +been made in the siege the Turks themselves took the field. Reschid Pasha, +now Grand Vizier, moved eastwards from Shumla at the beginning of May +against the weak Russian contingent that still lay in winter quarters +between that place and Varna. The superiority of his force promised him +an easy victory; but after winning some unimportant successes, and +advancing to a considerable distance from his stronghold, he allowed +himself to be held at bay until Diebitsch, with the army of the Danube, +was ready to fall upon his rear. The errors of the Turks had given to the +Russian commander, who hastened across Bulgaria on hearing of his +colleague's peril, the choice of destroying their army, or of seizing +Shumla by a _coup-de-main_. Diebitsch determined upon attacking his +enemy in the open field, and on the 10th of June Reschid's army, attempting +to regain the roads to Shumla, was put to total rout at Kulewtscha. A +fortnight later Silistria surrendered, and Diebitsch, reinforced by the +troops that had besieged that fortress, was now able to commence his +march across the Balkans. + +[Crossing of the Balkans, July, 1829.] + +Rumour magnified into hundreds of thousands the scanty columns which for +the first time carried the Russian flag over the Balkan range. Resistance +everywhere collapsed. The mountains were crossed without difficulty, and on +the 19th of August the invaders appeared before Adrianople, which +immediately surrendered. Putting on the boldest countenance in order to +conceal his real weakness, Diebitsch now struck out right and left, and +sent detachments both to the Euxine and the Aegean coast. The fleet +co-operated with him, and the ports of the Black Sea, almost as far south +as the Bosphorus, fell into the invaders' hands. The centre of the army +began to march upon Constantinople. If the Sultan had known the real +numbers of the force which threatened his capital, a force not exceeding +twenty thousand men, he would probably have recognised that his assailant's +position was a more dangerous one than his own. Diebitsch had advanced into +the heart of the enemy's country with a mere handful of men. Sickness was +daily thinning his ranks; his troops were dispersed over a wide area from +sea to sea; and the warlike tribes of Albania threatened to fall upon his +communications from the west. For a moment the Sultan spoke of fighting +upon the walls of Constantinople; but the fear of rebellion within his own +capital, the discovery of conspiracies, and the disasters sustained by his +arms in Asia, where Kars and Erzeroum had fallen into the enemy's hands, +soon led him to make overtures of peace and to accept the moderate terms +which the Russian Government, aware of its own difficulties, was willing to +grant. It would have been folly for the Czar to stimulate the growing +suspicion of England and to court the attack of Austria by prolonging +hostilities; and although King Charles X. and the French Cabinet, reverting +to the ideas of Tilsit, proposed a partition of the Ottoman Empire, and a +general re-arrangement of the map of Europe which would have given Belgium +and the Palatinate to France, the plan was originated too late to produce +any effect. [379] Russia had everything to lose and nothing to gain by a +European war. It had reduced Turkey to submission, and might fairly hope to +maintain its ascendency at Constantinople during coming years without +making any of those great territorial changes which would have given its +rivals a pretext for intervening on the Sultan's behalf. Under the guise of +a generous forbearance the Czar extricated himself from a dangerous +position with credit and advantage. As much had been won as could be +maintained without hazard; and on the 14th of September peace was concluded +in Adrianople. + +[Treaty of Adrianople, Sept. 14, 1829.] + +The Treaty of Adrianople gave Russia a slight increase of territory in +Asia, incorporating with the Czar's dominions the ports of Anapa and Poti +on the eastern coast of the Black Sea; but its most important provisions +were those which confirmed and extended the Protectorate exercised by the +Czar over the Danubian Principalities, and guaranteed the commercial rights +of Russian subjects throughout the Ottoman Empire both by land and sea. In +order more effectively to exclude the Sultan's influence from Wallachia and +Moldavia, the office of Hospodar, hitherto tenable for seven years, was now +made an appointment for life, and the Sultan specifically engaged to permit +no interference on the part of his neighbouring Pashas with the affairs of +these provinces. No fortified point was to be retained by the Turks on the +left bank of the Danube; no Mussulman was to be permitted to reside within +the Principalities; and those possessing landed estates there were to sell +them within eighteen months. The Porte pledged itself never again to detain +Russian ships of commerce coming from the Black Sea, and acknowledged that +such an act would amount to an infraction of treaties justifying Russia in +having recourse to reprisals. The Straits of Constantinople and the +Dardanelles were declared free and open to the merchant ships of all Powers +at peace with the Porte, upon the same conditions which were stipulated for +vessels under the Russian flag. The same freedom of trade and navigation +was recognised within the Black Sea. All treaties and conventions hitherto +concluded between Turkey and Russia were recognised as in force, except in +so far as modified by the present agreement. The Porte further gave its +adhesion to the Treaty of London relating to Greece, and to an Act entered +into by the Allied Powers in March, 1829, for regulating the Greek +frontier. An indemnity in money was declared to be owing to Russia; and as +the amount of this remained to be fixed by mutual agreement, the means were +still left open to the Russian Government for exercising a gentle pressure +at Constantinople, or for rewarding the compliance of the conquered. [380] + +[Capodistrias elected President of Greece, April, 1827.] + +The war between Turkey and Russia, while it left the European frontier +between the belligerents unchanged, exercised a two-fold influence upon the +settlement of Greece. On the one hand, by exciting the fears and suspicions +of Great Britain, it caused the Government of our own country, under the +Duke of Wellington, to insist on the limitation of the Greek State to the +narrowest possible area; [381] on the other hand, by reducing Turkey itself +almost to the condition of a Russian dependency, it led to the abandonment +of the desire to maintain the Sultan's supremacy in any form over the +emancipated provinces, and resulted in the establishment of an absolutely +independent Hellenic kingdom. An important change had taken place within +Greece itself just at the time when the allied Powers determined upon +intervention. The parts of the local leaders were played out, and in April, +1827, Capodistrias, ex-Minister of Russia, was elected President for seven +years. Capodistrias accepted the call. He was then, as he had been +throughout the insurrection, at a distance from Greece; and before making +his way thither, he visited the principal Courts of Europe, with the view +of ascertaining what moral or financial support he should be likely to +receive from them. His interview with the Czar Nicholas led to a clear +statement by that sovereign of the conditions which he expected +Capodistrias, in return for Russia's continued friendship, to fulfil. +Greece was to be rescued from revolution: in other words, personal was to +be substituted for popular government. The State was to remain tributary to +the Sultan: that is, in both Greece and Turkey the door was to be kept open +for Russia's interference. Whether Capodistrias had any intention of +fulfilling the latter condition is doubtful. His love for Greece and his +own personal ambition prevented his regard for Russia, strong though this +might be, from making him the mere instrument of the Court of St. +Petersburg; and while outwardly acquiescing in the Czar's decision that +Greece should remain a tributary State, he probably resolved from the first +to aim at establishing its complete independence. With regard to the Czar's +demand that the system of local self-government should be superseded within +Greece itself by one of autocratic rule, Capodistrias was in harmony with +his patron. He had been the Minister of a centralised despotism himself. +His experience was wholly that of the official of an absolute sovereign; +and although Capodistrias had represented the more liberal tendencies of +the Russian Court when it was a question of arguing against Metternich +about the complete or the partial restoration of despotic rule in Italy, he +had no real acquaintance and no real sympathy with the action of free +institutions, and moved in the same circle of ideas as the autocratic +reformers of the eighteenth century, of whom Joseph II. was the type. [382] + +[The Protocols of Nov., 1828, and March, 1829.] + +The Turks were still masters of the Morea when Capodistrias reached Greece. +The battle of Navarino had not caused Ibrahim to relax his hold upon the +fortresses, and it was deemed necessary by the Allies to send a French +army-corps to dislodge him from his position. This expeditionary force, +under General Maison, landed in Greece in the summer of 1828, and Ibrahim, +not wishing to fight to the bitter end, contented himself with burning +Tripolitza to the ground and sowing it with salt, and then withdrew. The +war between Turkey and Russia had now begun. Capodistrias assisted the +Russian fleet in blockading the Dardanelles, and thereby gained for himself +the marked ill-will of the British Government. At a conference held in +London by the representatives of France, England, and Russia, in November, +1828, it was resolved that the operations of the Allies should be limited +to the Morea and the islands. Capodistrias, in consequence of this +decision, took the most vigorous measures for continuing the war against +Turkey. What the allies refused to guarantee must be won by force of arms; +and during the winter of 1829, while Russia pressed upon Turkey from the +Danube, Capodistrias succeeded in reconquering Missolonghi and the whole +tract of country immediately to the north of the Gulf of Corinth. The +Porte, in prolonging its resistance after the November conference, played +as usual into its enemy's hands. The negotiations at London were resumed in +a spirit somewhat more favourable to Greece, and a Protocol was signed on +the 22nd of March, 1829, extending the northern frontier of Greece up to a +line drawn from the Gulf of Arta to the Gulf of Volo. Greece, according to +this Protocol, was still to remain under the Sultan's suzerainty: its ruler +was to be a hereditary prince belonging to one of the reigning European +families, but not to any of the three allied Courts. [383] + +[Leopold accepts the Greek Crown, Feb., 1830.] + +The mediation of Great Britain was now offered to the Porte upon the terms +thus laid down, and for the fourteenth time its mediation was rejected. But +the end was near at hand. Diebitsch crossed the Balkans, and it was in vain +that the Sultan then proposed the terms which he had scouted in November. +The Treaty of Adrianople enforced the decisions of the March Protocol. +Greece escaped from a limitation of its frontier, which would have left +both Athens and Missolonghi Turkish territory. The principle of the +admission of the provinces north of the Gulf of Corinth within the Hellenic +State was established, and nothing remained for the friends of the Porte +but to cut down to the narrowest possible area the district which had been +loosely indicated in the London Protocol. While Russia, satisfied with its +own successes against the Ottoman Empire and anxious to play the part of +patron of the conquered, ceased to interest itself in Greece, the +Government of Great Britain contested every inch of territory proposed to +be ceded to the new State, and finally induced the Powers to agree upon a +boundary-line which did not even in letter fulfil the conditions of the +treaty. Northern Acarnania and part of AEtolia were severed from Greece, +and the frontier was drawn from the mouth of the river Achelous to a spot +near Thermopylae. On the other hand, as Russian influence now appeared to +be firmly established and likely to remain paramount at Constantinople, the +Western Powers had no motive to maintain the Sultan's supremacy over +Greece. This was accordingly by common consent abandoned; and the Hellenic +Kingdom, confined within miserably narrow limits on the mainland, and +including neither Crete nor Samos among its islands, was ultimately offered +in full sovereignty to Prince Leopold of Saxe-Coburg, the widower of +Charlotte, daughter of George IV. After some negotiations, in which Leopold +vainly asked for a better frontier, he accepted the Greek crown on the 11th +of February, 1830. + +[Government of Capodistrias.] + +In the meantime, Capodistrias was struggling hard to govern and to organise +according to his own conceptions a land in which every element of anarchy, +ruin, and confusion appeared to be arrayed against the restoration of +civilised life. The country was devastated, depopulated, and in some places +utterly barbarised. Out of a population of little more than a million, it +was reckoned that three hundred thousand had perished during the conflict +with the Turk. The whole fabric of political and social order had to be +erected anew; and, difficult as this task would have been for the wisest +ruler, it was rendered much more difficult by the conflict between +Capodistrias' own ideal and the character of the people among whom he had +to work. Communal or local self-government lay at the very root of Greek +nationality. In many different forms this intense provincialism had +maintained itself unimpaired up to the end of the war, in spite of national +assemblies and national armaments. The Hydriote ship-owners, the Primates +of the Morea, the guerilla leaders of the north, had each a type of life +and a body of institutions as distinct as the dialects which they spoke or +the saints whom they cherished in their local sanctuaries. If antagonistic +in some respects to national unity, this vigorous local life had +nevertheless been a source of national energy while Greece had still its +independence to win; and now that national independence was won, it might +well have been made the basis of a popular and effective system of +self-government. But to Capodistrias, as to greater men of that age, the +unity of the State meant the uniformity of all its parts; and, shutting his +eyes to all the obstacles in his path, he set himself to create an +administrative system as rigorously centralised as that which France had +received from Napoleon. Conscious of his own intellectual superiority over +his countrymen, conscious of his own integrity and of the sacrifice of all +his personal wealth in his country's service, he put no measure on his +expressions of scorn for the freebooters and peculators whom he believed to +make up the Greek official world, and he both acted and spoke as if, in the +literal sense of the words, all who ever came before him were thieves and +robbers. The peasants of the mainland, who had suffered scarcely less from +Klephts and Primates than from Turks, welcomed Capodistrias' levelling +despotism, and to the end his name was popular among them; but among the +classes which had supplied the leaders in the long struggle for +independence, and especially among the ship-owners of the Archipelago, who +felt the contempt expressed by Capodistrias for their seven years' efforts +to be grossly unjust, a spirit of opposition arose which soon made it +evident that Capodistrias would need better instruments than those which he +had around him to carry out his task of remodelling Greece. + +[Leopold renounces the crown, May, 1830.] + +It was in the midst of this growing antagonism that the news reached +Capodistrias that Leopold of Saxe-Coburg had been appointed King of Greece. +The resolution made by the Powers in March, 1829, that the sovereign of +Greece should belong to some reigning house, had perhaps not wholly +destroyed the hopes of Capodistrias that he might become Prince or Hospodar +of Greece himself. There were difficulties in the way of filling the +throne, and these difficulties, after the appointment of Leopold, +Capodistrias certainly did not seek to lessen. His subtlety, his command of +the indirect methods of effecting a purpose, were so great and so habitual +to him that there was little chance of his taking any overt step for +preventing Leopold's accession to the crown; there appears, however, to be +evidence that he repressed the indications of assent which the Greeks +attempted to offer to Leopold; and a series of letters written by him to +that prince was probably intended, though in the most guarded language, to +give Leopold the impression that the task which awaited him was a hopeless +one. Leopold himself, at the very time when he accepted the crown, was +wavering in his purpose. He saw with perfect clearness that the territory +granted to the Greek State was too small to secure either its peace or its +independence. The severance of Acarnania and Northern AEtolia meant the +abandonment of the most energetic part of the Greek inland population, and +a probable state of incessant warfare upon the northern frontier; the +relinquishment of Crete meant that Greece, bankrupt as it was, must +maintain a navy to protect the south coast of the Morea from Turkish +attack. These considerations had been urged upon the Powers by Leopold +before he accepted the crown, and he had been induced for the moment to +withdraw them. But he had never fully acquiesced in the arrangements +imposed upon him: he remained irresolute for some months; and at last, +whether led to this decision by the letters of Capodistrias or by some +other influences, he declared the conditions under which he was called upon +to rule Greece to be intolerable, and renounced the crown (May, 1830). +[384] + +[Government and death of Capodistrias.] + +Capodistrias thus found himself delivered from his rival, and again face to +face with the task to which duty or ambition called him. The candidature of +Leopold had embittered the relations between Capodistrias and all who +confronted him in Greece, for it gave him the means of measuring their +hostility to himself by the fervour of their addresses to this unknown +foreigner. A dark shadow fell over his government. As difficulties +thickened and resistance grew everywhere more determined, the President +showed himself harsher and less scrupulous in the choice of his means. The +men about him were untrustworthy; to crush them, he filled the offices of +government with relatives and creatures of his own who were at once +tyrannous and incapable. Thwarted and checked, he met opposition by +imprisonment and measures of violence, suspended the law-courts, and +introduced the espionage and the police-system of St. Petersburg. At length +armed rebellion broke out, and while Miaoulis, the Hydriote admiral, blew +up the best ships of the Greek navy to prevent them falling into the +President's hands, the wild district of Maina, which had never admitted the +Turkish tax-gatherer, refused to pay taxes to the Hellenic State. The +revolt was summarily quelled by Capodistrias, and several members of the +family of Mauromichalis, including the chief Petrobei, formerly feudal +ruler of Maina, were arrested. Some personal insult, imaginary or real, was +moreover offered by Capodistrias to this fallen foe, after the aged mother +of Petrobei, who had lost sixty-four kinsmen in the war against the Turks, +had begged for his release. The vendetta of the Maina was aroused. A son +and a nephew of Petrobei laid wait for the President, and as he entered the +Church of St. Spiridion at Nauplia on the 9th of October, 1831, a +pistol-shot and a blow from a yataghan laid him dead on the ground. He had +been warned that his life was sought, but had refused to make any change in +his habits, or to allow himself to be attended by a guard. + +[Otho King of Greece, Feb. 1, 1833.] + +The death of Capodistrias excited sympathies and regrets which to a great +extent silenced criticism upon his government, and which have made his name +one of those most honoured by the Greek nation. His fall threw the country +into anarchy. An attempt was made by his brother Augustine to retain +autocratic power, but the result was universal dissension and the +interference of the foreigner. At length the Powers united in finding a +second sovereign for Greece, and brought the weary scene of disorder to a +close. Prince Otho of Bavaria was sent to reign at Athens, and with him +there came a group of Bavarian officials to whom the Courts of Europe +persuaded themselves that the future of Greece might be safely entrusted. A +frontier somewhat better than that which had been offered to Leopold was +granted to the new sovereign, but neither Crete, Thessaly, nor Epirus was +included within his kingdom. Thus hemmed in within intolerably narrow +limits, while burdened with the expenses of an independent state, alike +unable to meet the calls upon its national exchequer and to exclude the +intrigues of foreign Courts, Greece offered during the next generation +little that justified the hopes that had been raised as to its future. But +the belief of mankind in the invigorating power of national independence is +not wholly vain, nor, even under the most hostile conditions, will the +efforts of a liberated people fail to attract the hope and the envy of +those branches of its race which still remain in subjection. Poor and +inglorious as the Greek kingdom was, it excited the restless longings not +only of Greeks under Turkish bondage, but of the prosperous Ionian Islands +under English rule; and in 1864 the first step in the expansion of the +Hellenic kingdom was accomplished by the transfer of these islands from +Great Britain to Greece. Our own day has seen Greece further strengthened +and enriched by the annexation of Thessaly. The commercial and educational +development of the kingdom is now as vigorous as that of any State in +Europe: in agriculture and in manufacturing industry it still lingers far +behind. Following the example of Cavour and the Sardinian statesmen who +judged no cost too great in preparing for Italian union, the rulers of +Greece burden the national finances with the support of an army and navy +excessive in comparison both with the resources and with the present +requirements of the State. To the ideal of a great political future the +material progress of the land has been largely sacrificed. Whether, in the +re-adjustment of frontiers which must follow upon the gradual extrusion of +the Turk from Eastern Europe, Greece will gain from its expenditure +advantages proportionate to the undoubted evils which it has involved, the +future alone can decide. + + + + +CHAPTER XVI. + + +France before 1830--Reign of Charles X.--Ministry of Martignac--Ministry of +Polignac--The Duke of Orleans--War in Algiers--The July Ordinances-- +Revolution of July--Louis Philippe King--Nature and Effects of the July +Revolution--Affairs in Belgium--The Belgian Revolution--The Great +Powers--Intervention, and Establishment of the Kingdom of Belgium--Affairs +of Poland--Insurrection at Warsaw--War between Russia and Poland--Overthrow +of the Poles: End of the Polish Constitution--Affairs of Italy-- +Insurrection in the Papal States--France and Austria--Austrian +Intervention--Ancona occupied by the French--Affairs of Germany--Prussia; +the Zollverein--Brunswick, Hanover, Saxony--The Palatinate--Reaction in +Germany--Exiles in Switzerland; Incursion into Savoy--Dispersion of the +Exiles--France under Louis Philippe: Successive Risings--Period of +Parliamentary Activity--England after 1830: The Reform Bill. + + +When the Congress of Vienna re-arranged the map of Europe after Napoleon's +fall, Lord Castlereagh expressed the opinion that no prudent statesman +would forecast a duration of more than seven years for any settlement that +might then be made. At the end of a period twice as long the Treaties of +1815 were still the public law of Europe. The grave had peacefully closed +over Napoleon; the revolutionary forces of France had given no sign of +returning life. As the Bourbon monarchy struck root, and the elements of +opposition grew daily weaker in France, the perils that lately filled all +minds appeared to grow obsolete, and the very Power against which the +anti-revolutionary treaties of 1815 had been directed took its place, as of +natural right, by the side of Austria and Russia in the struggle against +revolution. The attack of Louis XVIII. upon the Spanish Constitutionalists +marked the complete reconciliation of France with the Continental dynasties +which had combined against it in 1815; and from this time the Treaties of +Chaumont and Aix-la-Chapelle, though their provisions might be still +unchallenged, ceased to represent the actual relations existing between the +Powers. There was no longer a moral union of the Courts against a supposed +French revolutionary State; on the contrary, when Eastern affairs reached +their crisis, Russia detached itself from its Hapsburg ally, and definitely +allied itself with France. If after the Peace of Adrianople any one Power +stood isolated, it was Austria; and if Europe was threatened by renewed +aggression, it was not under revolutionary leaders or with revolutionary +watchwords, but as the result of an alliance between Charles X. and the +Czar of Russia. After the Bourbon Cabinet had resolved to seek an extension +of French territory at whatever sacrifice of the balance of power in the +East, Europe could hardly expect that the Court of St. Petersburg would +long reject the advantages offered to it. The frontiers of 1815 seemed +likely to be obliterated by an enterprise which would bring Russia to the +Danube and France to the Rhine. From this danger the settlement of 1815 was +saved by the course of events that took place within France itself. The +Revolution of 1830, insignificant in its immediate effects upon the French +people, largely influenced the governments and the nations of Europe; and +while within certain narrow limits it gave a stimulus to constitutional +liberty, its more general result was to revive the union of the three +Eastern Courts which had broken down in 1826, and to reunite the principal +members of the Holy Alliance by the sense of a common interest against the +Liberalism of the West. + +[Government of Charles X., 1824-1827.] + +In the person of Charles X. reaction and clericalism had ascended the +French throne. The minister, Villele, who had won power in 1820 as the +representative of the Ultra-Royalists, had indeed learnt wisdom while in +office, and down to the death of Louis XVIII. in 1824 he had kept in check +the more violent section of his party. But he now retained his post only at +the price of compliance with the Court, and gave the authority of his name +to measures which his own judgment condemned. It was characteristic of +Charles X. and of the reactionaries around him that out of trifling matters +they provoked more exasperation than a prudent Government would have +aroused by changes of infinitely greater importance. Thus in a +sacrilege-law which was introduced in 1825 they disgusted all reasonable +men by attempting to revive the barbarous mediaeval punishment of amputation +of the hand; and in a measure conferring some fractional rights upon the +eldest son in cases of intestacy they alarmed the whole nation by a +preamble declaring the French principle of the equal division of +inheritances to be incompatible with monarchy. Coming from a Government +which had thus already forfeited public confidence, a law granting the +emigrants a compensation of L40,000,000 for their estates which had been +confiscated during the Revolution excited the strongest opposition, +although, apart from questions of equity, it benefited the nation by for +ever setting at rest all doubt as to the title of the purchasers of the +confiscated lands. The financial operations by which, in order to provide +the vast sum allotted to the emigrants, the national debt was converted +from a five per cent, to a three per cent, stock, alienated all +stockholders and especially the powerful bankers of Paris. But more than +any single legislative act, the alliance of the Government with the +priestly order, and the encouragement given by it to monastic corporations, +whose existence in France was contrary to law, offended the nation. The +Jesuits were indicted before the law-courts by Montlosier, himself a +Royalist and a member of the old noblesse. A vehement controversy sprang up +between the ecclesiastics and their opponents, in which the Court was not +spared. The Government, which had lately repealed the law of censorship, +now restored it by edict. The climax of its unpopularity was reached; its +hold upon the Chamber was gone, and the very measure by which Villele, when +at the height of his power, had endeavoured to give permanence to his +administration, proved its ruin. He had abolished the system of partial +renovation, by which one-fifth of the Chamber of Deputies was annually +returned, and substituted for it the English system of septennial +Parliaments with general elections. In 1827 King Charles, believing his +Ministers to be stronger in the country than in the Chamber, exercised his +prerogative of dissolution. The result was the total defeat of the +Government, and the return of an assembly in which the Liberal opposition +outnumbered the partisans of the Court by three to one. Villele's Ministry +now resigned. King Charles, unwilling to choose his successor from the +Parliamentary majority, thought for a moment of violent resistance, but +subsequently adopted other counsels, and, without sincerely intending to +bow to the national will, called to office the Vicomte de Martignac, a +member of the right centre, and the representative of a policy of +conciliation and moderate reform (January 2, 1828). + +[Ministry of Martignac, 1828-29.] + +[Polignac Minister, Aug. 9, 1829.] + +It was not the fault of this Minister that the last chance of union between +the French nation and the elder Bourbon line was thrown away. Martignac +brought forward a measure of decentralisation conferring upon the local +authorities powers which, though limited, were larger than they had +possessed at any time since the foundation of the Consulate; and he +appealed to the Liberal sections of the Chamber to assist him in winning an +instalment of self-government which France might well have accepted with +satisfaction. But the spirit of opposition within the Assembly was too +strong for a coalition of moderate men, and the Liberals made the success +of Martignac's plan impossible by insisting on concessions which the +Minister was unable to grant. The reactionists were ready to combine with +their opponents. King Charles himself was in secret antagonism to his +Minister, and watched with malicious joy his failure to control the +majority in the Chamber. Instead of throwing all his influence on to the +side of Martignac, and rallying all doubtful forces by the pronounced +support of the Crown, he welcomed Martignac's defeat as a proof of the +uselessness of all concessions, and dismissed the Minister from office, +declaring that the course of events had fulfilled his own belief in the +impossibility of governing in accord with a Parliament. The names of the +Ministers who were now called to power excited anxiety and alarm not only +in France but throughout the political circles of Europe. They were the +names of men known as the most violent and embittered partisans of +reaction; men whose presence in the councils of the King could mean nothing +but a direct attack upon the existing Parliamentary system of France. At +the head was Jules Polignac, then French ambassador at London, a man +half-crazed with religious delusions, who had suffered a long imprisonment +for his share in Cadoudal's attempt to kill Napoleon, and on his return to +France in 1814 had refused to swear to the Charta because it granted +religious freedom to non-Catholics. Among the subordinate members of the +Ministry were General Bourmont, who had deserted to the English at +Waterloo, and La Bourdonnaye, the champion of the reactionary Terrorists in +1816. [385] + +[Prospects in 1830. The Orleanists.] + +The Ministry having been appointed immediately after the close of the +session of 1829, an interval of several months passed before they were +brought face to face with the Chambers. During this interval the prospect +of a conflict with the Crown became familiar to the public mind, though no +general impression existed that an actual change of dynasty was close at +hand. The Bonapartists were without a leader, Napoleon's son, their natural +head, being in the power of the Austrian Court; the Republicans were +neither numerous nor well organised, and the fatal memories of 1793 still +weighed upon the nation; the great body of those who contemplated +resistance to King Charles X. looked only to a Parliamentary struggle, or, +in the last resort, to the refusal of payment of taxes in case of a breach +of the Constitution. There was, however, a small and dexterous group of +politicians which, at a distance from all the old parties, schemed for the +dethronement of the reigning branch of the House of Bourbon, and for the +elevation of Louis Philippe, Duke of Orleans, to the throne. The chief of +this intrigue was Talleyrand. Slighted and thwarted by the Court, the old +diplomatist watched for the signs of a falling Government, and when the +familiar omens met his view he turned to the quarter from which its +successor was most likely to arise. Louis Philippe stood high in credit +with all circles of Parliamentary Liberals. His history had been a strange +and eventful one. He was the son of that Orleans who, after calling himself +Egalite, and voting for the death of his cousin, Louis XVI., had himself +perished during the Reign of Terror. Young Louis Philippe had been a member +of the Jacobin Club, and had fought for the Republic at Jemappes. Then, +exiled and reduced to penury, he had earned his bread by teaching +mathematics in Switzerland, and had been a wanderer in the new as well as +in the old world. After awhile his fortunes brightened. A marriage with the +daughter of Ferdinand of Sicily restored him to those relations with the +reigning houses of Europe which had been forfeited by his father, and +inspired him with the hope of gaining a crown. During Napoleon's invasion +of Spain he had caballed with politicians in that country who were inclined +to accept a substitute for their absent sovereign; at another time he had +entertained hopes of being made king of the Ionian Islands. After the peace +of Paris, when the allied sovereigns and their ministers visited England, +Louis Philippe was sent over by his father-in-law to intrigue among them +against Murat, and in pursuance of this object he made himself acquainted +not only with every foreign statesman then in London but with every leading +English politician. He afterwards settled in France, and was reinstated in +the vast possessions of the House of Orleans, which, though confiscated, +had not for the most part been sold during the Revolution. His position at +Paris under Louis XVIII. and Charles X. was a peculiar one. Without taking +any direct part in politics or entering into any avowed opposition to the +Court, he made his home, the Palais Royale, a gathering-place for all that +was most distinguished in the new political and literary society of the +capital; and while the Tuileries affected the pomp and the ceremoniousness +of the old regime, the Duke of Orleans moved with the familiarity of a +citizen among citizens. He was a clever, ready, sensible man, equal, as it +seemed, to any practical task likely to come in his way, but in reality +void of any deep insight, of any far-reaching aspiration, of any profound +conviction. His affectation of a straightforward middle-class geniality +covered a decided tendency towards intrigue and a strong love of personal +power. Later events indeed gave rise to the belief that, while professing +the utmost loyalty to Charles X., Louis Philippe had been scheming to oust +him from his throne; but the evidence really points the other way, and +indicates that, whatever secret hopes may have suggested themselves to the +Duke, his strongest sentiment during the Revolution of 1830 was the fear of +being driven into exile himself, and of losing his possessions. He was not +indeed of a chivalrous nature; but when the Crown came in his way, he was +guilty of no worse offence than some shabby evasions of promises. + +[Meeting and Prorogation of the Chambers, March, 1830.] + +Early in March, 1830, the French Chambers assembled after their recess. The +speech of King Charles at the opening of the session was resolute and even +threatening. It was answered by an address from the Lower House, requesting +him to dismiss his Ministers. The deputation which presented this address +was received by the King in a style that left no doubt as to his +intentions, and on the following day the Chambers were prorogued for six +months. It was known that they would not be permitted to meet again, and +preparations for a renewed general election were at once made with the +utmost vigour by both parties throughout France. The Court unsparingly +applied all the means of pressure familiar to French governments; it +moreover expected to influence public opinion by some striking success in +arms or in diplomacy abroad. The negotiations with Russia for the +acquisition of Belgium were still before the Cabinet, and a quarrel with +the Dey of Algiers gave Polignac the opportunity of beginning a war of +conquest in Africa. General Bourmont left the War Office, to wipe out the +infamy still attaching to his name by a campaign against the Arabs; and the +Government trusted that, even in the event of defeat at the elections, the +nation at large would at the most critical moment be rallied to its side by +an announcement of the capture of Algiers. + +[Polignac's project.] + +While the dissolution of Parliament was impending, Polignac laid before the +King a memorial expressing his own views on the courses open to Government +in case of the elections proving adverse. The Charta contained a clause +which, in loose and ill-chosen language, declared it to be the function of +the King "to make the regulations and ordinances necessary for the +execution of the laws and for the security of the State." These words, +which no doubt referred to the exercise of the King's normal and +constitutional powers, were interpreted by Polignac as authorising the King +to suspend the Constitution itself, if the Representative Assembly should +be at variance with the King's Ministers. Polignac in fact entertained the +same view of the relation between executive and deliberative bodies as +those Jacobin directors who made the _coup-d'etat_ of Fructidor, 1797; +and the measures which he ultimately adopted were, though in a softened +form, those adopted by Barras and Lareveillere after the Royalist elections +in the sixth year of the Republic. To suspend the Constitution was not, he +suggested, to violate the Charta, for the Charta empowered the sovereign to +issue the ordinances necessary for the security of the State; and who but +the sovereign and his advisers could be the judges of this necessity? This +was simple enough; there was nevertheless among Polignac's colleagues some +doubt both as to the wisdom and as to the legality of his plans. King +Charles who, with all his bigotry, was anxious not to violate the letter of +the Charta, brooded long over the clause which defined the sovereign's +powers. At length he persuaded himself that his Minister's interpretation +was the correct one, accepted the resignation of the dissentients within +the Cabinet, and gave his sanction to the course which Polignac +recommended. [386] + +[Elections of 1830.] + +The result of the general election, which took place in June, surpassed all +the hopes of the Opposition and all the fears of the Court. The entire body +of Deputies which had voted the obnoxious address to the Crown in March was +returned, and the partisans of Government lost in addition fifty seats. The +Cabinet, which had not up to this time resolved upon the details of its +action, now deliberated upon several projects submitted to it, and, after +rejecting all plans that might have led to a compromise, determined to +declare the elections null and void, to silence the press, and to supersede +the existing electoral system by one that should secure the mastery of the +Government both at the polling-booths and in the Chamber itself. All this +was to be done by Royal Edict, and before the meeting of the new +Parliament. The date fixed for the opening of the Chambers had been placed +as late as possible in order to give time to General Bourmont to win the +victory in Africa from which the Court expected to reap so rich a harvest +of prestige. On the 9th of July news arrived that Algiers had fallen. The +announcement, which was everywhere made with the utmost pomp, fell flat on +the country. The conflict between the Court and the nation absorbed all +minds, and the rapturous congratulations of Bishops and Prefects scarcely +misled even the blind _coterie_ of the Tuileries. Public opinion was +no doubt with the Opposition; King Charles, however, had no belief that the +populace of Paris, which alone was to be dreaded as a fighting body, would +take up arms on behalf of the middle-class voters and journalists against +whom his Ordinances were to be directed. The populace neither read nor +voted: why should it concern itself with constitutional law? Or why, in a +matter that related only to the King and the Bourgeoisie, should it not +take part with the King against this new and bastard aristocracy which +lived on others' labour? Politicians who could not fight were troublesome +only when they were permitted to speak and to write. There was force enough +at the King's command to close the gates of the Chamber of Deputies, and to +break up the printing-presses of the journals; and if King Louis XVI. had +at last fallen by the hands of men of violence, it was only because he had +made concessions at first to orators and politicians. Therefore, without +dreaming that an armed struggle would be the immediate result of their +action, King Charles and Polignac determined to prevent the meeting of the +Chamber, and to publish, a week before the date fixed for its opening, the +Edicts which were to silence the brawl of faction and to vindicate +monarchical government in France. + +[The Ordinances, July 26, 1830.] + +Accordingly, on the 26th of July, a series of Ordinances appeared in the +_Moniteur_, signed by the King and counter-signed by the Ministers. +The first Ordinance forbade the publication of any journal without royal +permission; the second dissolved the Chamber of Deputies; the third raised +the property-qualification of voters, established a system of +double-election, altered the duration of Parliaments, and re-enacted the +obsolete clause of the Charta confining the initiative in all legislation +to the Government. Other Ordinances convoked a Chamber to be elected under +the new rules, and called to the Council of State a number of the most +notorious Ultra-Royalists and fanatics in France. Taken together, the +Ordinances left scarcely anything standing of the Constitutional and +Parliamentary system of the day. The blow fell first on the press, and the +first step in resistance was taken by the journalists of Paris, who, under +the leadership of the young Thiers, editor of the _National_, +published a protest declaring that they would treat the Ordinances as +illegal, and calling upon the Chambers and nation to join in this +resistance. For a while the journalists seemed likely to stand alone. Paris +at large remained quiet, and a body of the recently elected Deputies, to +whom the journalists appealed as representatives of the nation, proved +themselves incapable of any action or decision whatsoever. It was not from +these timid politicians, but from a body of obscure Republicans, that the +impulse proceeded which overthrew the Bourbon throne. Unrepresented in +Parliament and unrepresented in the press, there were a few active men who +had handed down the traditions of 1792, and who, in sympathy with the +Carbonari and other conspirators abroad, had during recent years founded +secret societies in Paris, and enlisted in the Republican cause a certain +number of workmen, of students, and of youths of the middle classes. While +the journalists discussed legal means of resistance, and the Deputies +awaited events, the Republican leaders met and determined upon armed +revolt. They were assisted, probably without direct concert, by the +printing firms and other employers of labour, who, in view of the general +suspension of the newspapers, closed their establishments on the morning of +July 27, and turned their workmen into the streets. + +[July 27.] + +[July 28.] + +Thus on the day after the appearance of the Edicts the aspect of Paris +changed. Crowds gathered, and revolutionary cries were raised. Marmont, who +was suddenly ordered to take command of the troops, placed them around the +Tuileries, and captured two barricades which were erected in the +neighbourhood; but the populace was not yet armed, and no serious conflict +took place. In the evening Lafayette reached Paris, and the revolution had +now a real, though not an avowed, leader. A body of his adherents met +during the night at the office of the _National_, and, in spite of +Thiers' resistance, decided upon a general insurrection. Thiers himself, +who desired nothing but a legal and Parliamentary attack upon Charles X., +quitted Paris to await events. The men who had out-voted him placed +themselves in communication with all the district committees of Paris, and +began the actual work of revolt by distributing arms. On the morning of +Wednesday, July 28th, the first armed bands attacked and captured the +arsenals and several private depots of weapons and ammunition. Barricades +were erected everywhere. The insurgents swelled from hundreds to thousands, +and, converging on the old rallying-point of the Commune of Paris, they +seized the Hotel de Ville, and hoisted the tricolor flag on its roof. +Marmont wrote to the King, declaring the position to be most serious, and +advising concession; he then put his troops in motion, and succeeded, after +a severe conflict, in capturing several points of vantage, and in expelling +the rebels from the Hotel de Ville. + +[July 29.] + +In the meantime the Deputies, who were assembled at the house of one of +their number in pursuance of an agreement made on the previous day, gained +sufficient courage to adopt a protest declaring that in spite of the +Ordinances they were still the legal representatives of the nation. They +moreover sent a deputation to Marmont, begging him to put a stop to the +fighting, and offering their assistance in restoring order if the King +would withdraw his Edicts. Marmont replied that he could do nothing without +the King's command, but he despatched a second letter to St. Cloud, urging +compliance. The only answer which he received was a command to concentrate +his troops and to act in masses. The result of this was that the positions +which had been won by hard fighting were abandoned before evening, and that +the troops, famished and exhausted, were marched back through the streets +of Paris to the Tuileries. On the march some fraternised with the people, +others were surrounded and disarmed. All eastern Paris now fell into the +hands of the insurgents; the middle-class, as in 1789 and 1792, remained +inactive, and allowed the contest to be decided by the populace and the +soldiery. Messages from the capital constantly reached St. Cloud, but the +King so little understood his danger and so confidently reckoned on the +victory of the troops in the Tuileries that he played whist as usual during +the evening; and when the Duc de Mortemart, French Ambassador at St. +Petersburg, arrived at nightfall, and pressed for an audience, the King +refused to receive him until the next morning. When morning came, the march +of the insurgents against the Tuileries began. Position after position fell +into their hands. The regiments stationed in the Place Vendome abandoned +their commander, and marched off to place themselves at the disposal of the +Deputies. Marmont ordered the Swiss Guard, which had hitherto defended the +Louvre, to replace them; and in doing so he left the Louvre for a moment +without any garrison. The insurgents saw the building empty, and rushed +into it. From the windows they commanded the Court of the Tuileries, where +the troops in reserve were posted; and soon after mid-day all was over. A +few isolated battalions fought and perished, but the mass of the soldiery +with their commander fell back upon the Place de la Concorde, and then +evacuated Paris. [387] + +The Duke of Orleans was all this time in hiding. He had been warned that +the Court intended to arrest him, and, whether from fear of the Court or of +the populace, he had secreted himself at a hunting-lodge in his woods, +allowing none but his wife and his sister to know where he was concealed. +His partisans, of whom the rich and popular banker, Laffitte, was the most +influential among the Deputies, were watching for an opportunity to bring +forward his name; but their chances of success seemed slight. The Deputies +at large wished only for the withdrawal of the Ordinances, and were wholly +averse from a change of dynasty. It was only through the obstinacy of King +Charles himself, and as the result of a series of accidents, that the Crown +passed from the elder Bourbon line. King Charles would not hear of +withdrawing the Ordinances until the Tuileries had actually fallen; he then +gave way and charged the Duc de Mortemart to form a new Ministry, drawn +from the ranks of the Opposition. But instead of formally repealing the +Edicts by a public Decree, he sent two messengers to Paris to communicate +his change of purpose to the Deputies by word of mouth. The messengers +betook themselves to the Hotel de Ville, where a municipal committee under +Lafayette had been installed; and, when they could produce no written +authority for their statements, they were referred by this committee to the +general body of Deputies, which was now sitting at Laffitte's house. The +Deputies also demanded a written guarantee. Laffitte and Thiers spoke in +favour of the Duke of Orleans, but the Assembly at large was still willing +to negotiate with Charles X., and only required the presence of the Duc de +Mortemart himself, and a copy of the Decree repealing the Ordinances. + +[July 30.] + +It was now near midnight. The messengers returned to St. Cloud, and were +not permitted to deliver their intelligence until the King awoke next +morning. Charles then signed the necessary document, and Mortemart set out +for Paris; but the night's delay had given the Orleanists time to act, and +before the King was up Thiers had placarded the streets of Paris with a +proclamation extolling Orleans as the prince devoted to the cause of the +Revolution, as the soldier of Jemappes, and the only constitutional King +now possible. Some hours after this manifesto had appeared the Deputies +again assembled at Laffitte's house, and waited for the appearance of +Mortemart. But they waited in vain. Mortemart's carriage was stopped on the +road from St. Cloud, and he was compelled to make his way on foot by a long +circuit and across a score of barricades. When he approached Laffitte's +house, half dead with heat and fatigue, he found that the Deputies had +adjourned to the Palais Bourbon, and, instead of following them, he ended +his journey at the Luxemburg, where the Peers were assembled. His absence +was turned to good account by the Orleanists. At the morning session the +proposition was openly made to call Louis Philippe to power; and when the +Deputies reassembled in the afternoon and the Minister still failed to +present himself, it was resolved to send a body of Peers and Deputies to +Louis Philippe to invite him to come to Paris and to assume the office of +Lieutenant-General of the kingdom. No opposition was offered to this +proposal in the House of Peers, and a deputation accordingly set out to +search for Louis Philippe at his country house at Neuilly. The prince was +not to be found; but his sister, who received the deputation, undertook +that he should duly appear in Paris. She then communicated with her brother +in his hiding-place, and induced him, in spite of the resistance of his +wife, to set out for the capital. He arrived at the Palais Royale late on +the night of the 30th. Early the next morning he received a deputation from +the Assembly, and accepted the powers which they offered him. A +proclamation was then published, announcing to the Parisians that in order +to save the country from anarchy and civil war the Duke of Orleans had +assumed the office of Lieutenant-General of the kingdom. + +[The Hotel de Ville.] + +But there existed another authority in Paris beside the Assembly of +Representatives, and one that was not altogether disposed to permit Louis +Philippe and his satellites to reap the fruits of the people's victory. +Lafayette and the Municipal Committee, which occupied the Hotel de Ville, +had transformed themselves into a provisional government, and sat +surrounded by the armed mob which had captured the Tuileries two days +before. No single person who had fought in the streets had risked his life +for the sake of making Louis Philippe king; in so far as the Parisians had +fought for any definite political idea, they had fought for the Republic. +It was necessary to reconcile both the populace and the provisional +government to the assumption of power by the new Regent; and with this +object Louis Philippe himself proceeded to the Hotel de Ville, accompanied +by an escort of Deputies and Peers. It was a hazardous moment when he +entered the crowd on the Place de Greve; but Louis Philippe's readiness of +speech stood him in good stead, and he made his way unhurt through the +throng into the building, where Lafayette received him. Compliments and +promises were showered upon this veteran of 1789, who presently appeared on +a balcony and embraced Louis Philippe, while the Prince grasped the +tricolor flag, the flag which had not waved in Paris since 1815. The +spectacle was successful. The multitude shouted applause; and the few +determined men who still doubted the sincerity of a Bourbon and demanded +the proclamation of the Republic were put off with the promise of an +ultimate appeal to the French people. + +[Charles X.] + +In the meantime Charles X. had withdrawn to Rambouillet, accompanied by the +members of his family and by a considerable body of troops. Here the news +reached him that Orleans had accepted from the Chambers the office of +Lieutenant-General. It was a severe blow to the old king, who, while others +doubted of Louis Philippe's loyalty, had still maintained his trust in this +prince's fidelity. For a moment he thought of retiring beyond the Loire and +risking a civil war; but the troops now began to disperse, and Charles, +recognising that his cause was hopeless, abdicated together with the +Dauphin in favour of his grandson the young Chambord, then called Duc de +Bordeaux. He wrote to Louis Philippe, appointing him, as if on his own +initiative, Lieutenant-General of the kingdom, and required him to proclaim +Henry V. king, and to undertake the government during the new sovereign's +minority. It is doubtful whether Louis Philippe had at this time formed any +distinct resolve, and whether his answer to Charles X. was inspired by mere +good nature or by conscious falsehood; for while replying officially that +he would lay the king's letter before the Chambers, he privately wrote to +Charles X. that he would retain his new office only until he could safely +place the Duc de Bordeaux upon the throne. Having thus soothed the old +man's pride, Louis Philippe requested him to hasten his departure from the +neighbourhood of Paris; and when Charles ignored the message, he sent out +some bands of the National Guard to terrify him into flight. This device +succeeded, and the royal family, still preserving the melancholy ceremonial +of a court, moved slowly through France towards the western coast. At +Cherbourg they took ship and crossed to England, where they were received +as private persons. Among the British nation at large the exiled Bourbons +excited but little sympathy. They were, however, permitted to take up their +abode in the palace of Holyrood, and here Charles X. resided for two years. +But neither the climate nor the society of the Scottish capital offered any +attraction to the old and failing chief of a fallen dynasty. He sought a +more congenial shelter in Austria, and died at Goritz in November, 1836. + +[Louis Philippe made King, Aug. 7.] + +The first public notice of the abdication of King Charles was given by +Louis Philippe in the Chamber of Deputies, which was convoked by him, as +Lieutenant-General of the Kingdom, on the 3rd of August. In addressing the +Deputies, Louis Philippe stated that he had received a letter containing +the abdication both of the King and of the Dauphin, but he uttered no +single word regarding the Duc de Bordeaux, in whose favour both his +grandfather and his uncle had renounced their rights. Had Louis Philippe +mentioned that the abdications were in fact conditional, and had he +declared himself protector of the Duc de Bordeaux during his minority, +there is little doubt that the legitimate heir would have been peaceably +accepted both by the Chamber and by Paris. Louis Philippe himself had up to +this time done nothing that was inconsistent with the assumption of a mere +Regency; the Chamber had not desired a change of dynasty; and, with the +exception of Lafayette, the men who had actually made the Revolution bore +as little goodwill to an Orleanist as to a Bourbon monarchy. But from the +time when Louis Philippe passed over in silence the claims of the grandson +of Charles X., his own accession to the throne became inevitable. It was +left to an obscure Deputy to propose that the crown should be offered to +Louis Philippe, accompanied by certain conditions couched in the form of +modifications of the Charta. The proposal was carried in the Chamber on the +7th of August, and the whole body of representatives marched to the Palais +Royale to acquaint the prince with its resolution. Louis Philippe, after +some conventional expressions of regret, declared that he could not resist +the call of his country. When the Lower Chamber had thus disposed of the +crown, the House of Peers, which had proved itself a nullity throughout the +crisis, adopted the same resolution, and tendered its congratulations in a +similar fashion. Two days later Louis Philippe took the oath to the Charta +as modified by the Assembly, and was proclaimed King of the French. + +[Nature of the Revolution of 1830.] + +Thus ended a revolution, which, though greeted with enthusiasm at the time, +has lost much of its splendour and importance in the later judgment of +mankind. In comparison with the Revolution of 1789, the movement which +overthrew the Bourbons in 1830 was a mere flutter on the surface. It was +unconnected with any great change in men's ideas, and it left no great +social or legislative changes behind it. Occasioned by a breach of the +constitution on the part of the Executive Government, it resulted mainly in +the transfer of administrative power from one set of politicians to +another: the alterations which it introduced into the constitution itself +were of no great importance. France neither had an absolute Government +before 1830, nor had it a popular Government afterwards. Instead of a +representative of divine right, attended by guards of nobles and counselled +by Jesuit confessors, there was now a citizen-king, who walked about the +streets of Paris with an umbrella under his arm and sent his sons to the +public schools, but who had at heart as keen a devotion to dynastic +interests as either of his predecessors, and a much greater capacity for +personal rule. The bonds which kept the entire local administration of +France in dependence upon the central authority were not loosened; +officialism remained as strong as ever; the franchise was still limited to +a mere fraction of the nation. On the other hand, within the administration +itself the change wrought by the July Revolution was real and lasting. It +extinguished the political power of the clerical interest. Not only were +the Bishops removed from the House of Peers, but throughout all departments +of Government the influence of the clergy, which had been so strong under +Charles X., vanished away. The State took a distinctly secular colour. The +system of public education was regulated with such police-like +exclusiveness that priests who insisted upon opening schools of their own +for Catholic teaching were enabled to figure as champions of civil liberty +and of freedom of opinion against despotic power. The noblesse lost +whatever political influence it had regained during the Restoration. The +few surviving Regicides who had been banished in 1815 were recalled to +France, among them the terrorist Barrere, who was once more returned to the +Assembly. But the real winners in the Revolution of 1830 were not the men +of extremes, but the middle-class of France. This was the class which Louis +Philippe truly represented; and the force which for eighteen years kept +Louis Philippe on the throne was the middle-class force of the National +Guard of Paris. Against this sober, prosaic, unimaginative power there +struggled the hot and restless spirit which had been let loose by the +overthrow of the Bourbon dynasty, and which, fired at once with the +political ideal of a Republic, with dreams of the regeneration of Europe by +French armies, and with the growing antagonism between the labouring class +and the owners of property, threatened for awhile to overthrow the +newly-constituted monarchy in France, and to plunge Europe into war. The +return of the tricolor flag, the long-silenced strains of the Republic and +the Empire, the sense of victory with which men on the popular side +witnessed the expulsion of the dynasty which had been forced upon France +after Waterloo, revived that half-romantic military ardour which had +undertaken the liberation of Europe in 1792. France appeared once more in +the eyes of enthusiasts as the deliverer of nations. The realities of the +past epoch of French military aggression, its robberies, its corruption, +the execrations of its victims, were forgotten; and when one people after +another took up the shout of liberty that was raised in Paris, and +insurrections broke out in every quarter of Europe, it was with difficulty +that Louis Philippe and the few men of caution about him could prevent the +French nation from rushing into war. + +[Affairs in Belgium.] + +The State first affected by the events of July was the kingdom of the +Netherlands. The creation of this kingdom, in which the Belgian provinces +formerly subject to Austria were united with Holland to serve as an +effective barrier against French aggression on the north, had been one of +Pitt's most cherished schemes, and it had been carried into effect ten +years after his death by the Congress of Vienna. National and religious +incongruities had been little considered by the statesmen of that day, and +at the very moment of union the Catholic bishops of Belgium had protested +against a constitution which gave equal toleration to all religions under +the rule of a Protestant King. The Belgians had been uninterruptedly united +with France for the twenty years preceding 1814; the French language was +not only the language of their literature, but the spoken language of the +upper classes; and though the Flemish portion of the population was nearly +related to the Dutch, this element had not then asserted itself with the +distinctness and energy which it has since developed. The antagonism +between the northern and the southern Netherlands, though not insuperable, +was sufficiently great to make a harmonious union between the two countries +a work of difficulty, and the Government of The Hague had not taken the +right course to conciliate its opponents. The Belgians, though more +numerous, were represented by fewer members in the National Assembly than +the Dutch. Offices were filled by strangers from Holland; finance was +governed by a regard for Dutch interests; and the Dutch language was made +the official language for the whole kingdom. But the chief grievances were +undoubtedly connected with the claims of the clerical party in Belgium to a +monopoly of spiritual power and the exclusive control of education. The one +really irreconcilable enemy of the Protestant House of Orange was the +Church; and the governing impulse in the conflicts which preceded the +dissolution of the kingdom of the Netherlands in 1830 sprang from the same +clerical interest which had thrown Belgium into revolt against the Emperor +Joseph forty years before. There was again seen the same strange phenomenon +of a combination between the Church and a popular or even revolutionary +party. For the sake of an alliance against a constitution distasteful to +both, the clergy of Belgium accepted the democratic principles of the +political Opposition, and the Opposition consented for a while to desist +from their attacks upon the Papacy. The contract was faithfully observed on +both sides until the object for which it was made was attained. [388] + +[Belgian Revolution, August, 1830.] + +For some months before the Revolution of July, 1830, the antagonism between +the Belgians and their Government had been so violent that no great shock +from outside was necessary to produce an outbreak. The convulsions of Paris +were at once felt at Brussels, and on the 25th of August the performance of +a revolutionary opera in that city gave the signal for the commencement of +insurrection. From the capital the rebellion spread from town to town +throughout the southern Netherlands. The King summoned the Estates General, +and agreed to the establishment of an administration for Belgium separate +from that of Holland: but the storm was not allayed; and the appearance of +a body of Dutch troops at Brussels was sufficient to dispel the expectation +of a peaceful settlement. Barricades were erected; a conflict took place in +the streets; and the troops, unable to carry the city by assault, retired +to the outskirts and kept up a desultory attack for several days. They then +withdrew, and a provisional government, which was immediately established, +declared the independence of Belgium. For a moment there appeared some +possibility that the Crown Prince of Holland, who had from the first +assumed the part of mediator, might be accepted as sovereign of the +newly-formed State; but the growing violence of the insurrection, the +activity of French emissaries and volunteers, and the bombardment of +Antwerp by the Dutch soldiers who garrisoned its citadel, made an end of +all such hopes. Belgium had won its independence, and its connection with +the House of Orange could be re-established only by force of arms. + +[France and the Belgian Revolution.] + +[France and England.] + +The accomplishment of this revolution in one of the smallest Continental +States threatened to involve all Europe in war. Though not actually +effected under the auspices of a French army, it was undoubtedly to some +extent effected in alliance with the French revolutionary party. It broke +up a kingdom established by the European Treaties of 1814; and it was so +closely connected with the overthrow of the Bourbon monarchy as to be +scarcely distinguishable from those cases in which the European Powers had +pledged themselves to call their armies into the field. Louis Philippe, +however, had been recognised by most of the European Courts as the only +possible alternative to a French Republic; and a general disposition +existed to second any sincere effort that should be made by him to prevent +the French nation from rushing into war. This was especially the case with +England; and it was to England that Louis Philippe turned for co-operation +in the settlement of the Belgian question. Louis Philippe himself had every +possible reason for desiring to keep the peace. If war broke out, France +would be opposed to all the Continental Powers together. Success was in the +last degree improbable; it could only be hoped for by a revival of the +revolutionary methods and propaganda of 1793; and failure, even for a +moment, would certainly cost him his throne, and possibly his life. His +interest no less than his temperament made him the strenuous, though +concealed, opponent of the war-party in the Assembly; and he found in the +old diplomatist who had served alike under the Bourbons, the Republic, and +the Empire, an ally thoroughly capable of pursuing his own wise though +unpopular policy of friendship and co-operation with England. Talleyrand, +while others were crying for a revenge for Waterloo, saw that the first +necessity for France was to rescue it from its isolation; and as at the +Congress of Vienna he had detached Austria and England from the two +northern Courts, so now, before attempting to gain any extension of +territory, he sought to make France safe against the hostility of the +Continent by allying it with at least one great Power. Russia had become an +enemy instead of a friend. The expulsion of the Bourbons had given mortal +offence to the Czar Nicholas, and neither Austria nor Prussia was likely to +enter into close relations with a Government founded upon revolution. +England alone seemed a possible ally, and it was to England that the French +statesman of peace turned in the Belgian crisis. Talleyrand, now nearly +eighty years old, came as ambassador to London, where he had served in +1792. He addressed himself to Wellington and to the new King, William IV., +assuring them that, under the Government of Louis Philippe, France would +not seek to use the Belgian revolution for its own aggrandisement; and, +with his old aptness in the invention of general principles to suit a +particular case, he laid down the principle of non-intervention as one that +ought for the future to govern the policy of Europe. His efforts were +successful. So complete an understanding was established between France and +England on the Belgian question, that all fear of an armed intervention of +the Eastern Courts on behalf of the King of Holland, which would have +rendered a war with France inevitable, passed away. The regulation of +Belgian affairs was submitted to a Conference at London. Hostilities were +stopped, and the independence of the new kingdom was recognised in +principle by the Conference before the end of the year. A Protocol defining +the frontiers of Belgium and Holland, and apportioning to each State its +share in the national debt, was signed by the representatives of the Powers +in January, 1831. [389] + +[Leopold elected King, June 4.] + +Thus far, a crisis which threatened the peace of Europe had been surmounted +with unexpected ease. But the first stage of the difficulty alone was +passed; it still remained for the Powers to provide a king for Belgium, and +to gain the consent of the Dutch and Belgian Governments to the territorial +arrangements drawn up for them. The Belgians themselves, with whom a +connection with France was popular, were disposed to elect as their +sovereign the Duc de Nemours, second son of Louis Philippe; and although +Louis Philippe officially refused his sanction to this scheme, which in the +eyes of all Europe would have turned Belgium into a French dependency, he +privately encouraged its prosecution after a Bonapartist candidate, the son +of Eugene Beauharnais, had appeared in the field. The result was that the +Duc de Nemours was elected king on the 3rd of February, 1831. Against this +appointment the Conference of the Powers at London had already pronounced +its veto, and the British Government let it be understood that it would +resist any such extension of French influence by force. Louis Philippe now +finally refused the crown for his son, and, the Bonapartist candidate being +withdrawn, the two rival Powers agreed in recommending Prince Leopold of +Saxe-Coburg, on the understanding that, if elected King of Belgium, he +should marry a daughter of Louis Philippe. The Belgians fell in with the +advice given them, and elected Leopold on the 4th of June. He accepted the +crown, subject to the condition that the London Conference should modify in +favour of Belgium some of the provisions relating to the frontiers and to +the finances of the new State which had been laid down by the Conference, +and which the Belgian Government had hitherto refused to accept. + +[Settlement of the Belgian frontier.] + +The difficulty of arranging the Belgian frontier arose principally from the +position of the Grand Duchy of Luxemburg. This territory, though subject to +Austria before the French Revolution, had always been treated as distinct +from the body of the Austrian Netherlands. When, at the peace of 1814, it +was given to the King of Holland in substitution for the ancient +possessions of his family at Nassau, its old character as a member of the +German federal union was restored to it, so that the King of Holland in +respect of this portion of his dominions became a German prince, and the +fortress of Luxemburg, the strongest in Europe after Gibraltar, was liable +to occupation by German troops. The population of the Duchy had, however, +joined the Belgians in their revolt, and, with the exception of the +fortress itself, the territory had passed into possession of the Belgian +Government. In spite of this actual overthrow of Dutch rule, the Conference +of London had attached such preponderating importance to the military and +international relations of Luxemburg that it had excluded the whole of the +Duchy from the new Belgian State, and declared it still to form part of the +dominions of the King of Holland. The first demand of Leopold was for the +reversal or modification of this decision, and the Powers so far gave way +as to substitute for the declaration of January a series of articles, in +which the question of Luxemburg was reserved for future settlement. The +King of Holland had assented to the January declaration; on hearing of its +abandonment, he took up arms, and threw fifty thousand men into Belgium. +Leopold appealed to France for assistance, and a French army immediately +crossed the frontier. The Dutch now withdrew, and the French in their turn +were recalled, after Leopold had signed a treaty undertaking to raze the +fortifications of five towns on his southern border. The Conference again +took up its work, and produced a third scheme, in which the territory of +Luxemburg was divided between Holland and Belgium. This was accepted by +Belgium, and rejected by Holland. The consequence was that a treaty was +made between Leopold and the Powers; and at the beginning of 1832 the +kingdom of Belgium, as defined by the third award of the Conference, was +recognised by all the Courts, Lord Palmerston on behalf of England +resolutely refusing to France even the slightest addition of territory, on +the ground that, if annexations once began, all security for the +continuance of peace would be at an end. On this wise and firm policy the +concert of Europe in the establishment of the Belgian kingdom was +successfully maintained; and it only remained for the Western Powers to +overcome the resistance of the King of Holland, who still held the citadel +of Antwerp and declined to listen either to reason or authority. A French +army corps was charged with the task of besieging the citadel; an English +fleet blockaded the river Scheldt. After a severe bombardment the citadel +surrendered. Hostilities ceased, and negotiations for a definitive +settlement recommenced. As, however, the Belgians were in actual occupation +of all Luxemburg with the exception of the fortress, they had no motive to +accelerate a settlement which would deprive them of part of their existing +possessions; on the other hand, the King of Holland held back through mere +obstinacy. Thus the provisional state of affairs was prolonged for year +after year, and it was not until April, 1839, that the final Treaty of +Peace between Belgium and Holland was executed. + +[Affairs of Poland.] + +The consent of the Eastern Powers to the overthrow of the kingdom of the +United Netherlands, and to the establishment of a State based upon a +revolutionary movement, would probably have been harder to gain if in the +autumn of 1830 Russia had been free to act with all its strength. But at +this moment an outbreak took place in Poland, which required the +concentration of all the Czar's forces within his own border. The conflict +was rather a war of one armed nation against another than the insurrection +of a people against its government. Poland--that is to say, the territory +which had formerly constituted the Grand Duchy of Warsaw--had, by the +treaties of 1814, been established as a separate kingdom, subject to the +Czar of Russia, but not forming part of the Russian Empire. It possessed an +administration and an army of its own, and the meetings of its Diet gave to +it a species of parliamentary government to which there was nothing +analogous within Russia proper. During the reign of Alexander the +constitutional system of Poland had, on the whole, been respected; and +although the real supremacy of an absolute monarch at St. Petersburg had +caused the Diet to act as a body in opposition to the Russian Government, +the personal connection existing between Alexander and the Poles had +prevented any overt rebellion during his own life-time. But with the +accession of Nicholas all such individual sympathy passed away, and the +hard realities of the actual relation between Poland and the Court of +Russia came into full view. In the conspiracies of 1825 a great number of +Poles were implicated. Eight of these persons, after a preliminary inquiry, +were placed on trial before the Senate at Warsaw, which, in spite of strong +evidence of their guilt, acquitted them. Pending the decision, Nicholas +declined to convoke the Diet: he also stationed Russian troops in Poland, +and violated the constitution by placing Russians in all branches of the +administration. Even without these grievances the hostility of the mass of +the Polish noblesse to Russia would probably have led sooner or later to +insurrection. The peasantry, ignorant and degraded, were but instruments in +the hands of their territorial masters. In so far as Poland had rights of +self-government, these rights belonged almost exclusively to the nobles, or +landed proprietors, a class so numerous that they have usually been +mistaken in Western Europe for the Polish nation itself. The so-called +emancipation of the serfs, effected by Napoleon after wresting the Grand +Duchy of Warsaw from Prussia in 1807, had done little for the mass of the +population; for, while abolishing the legal condition of servitude, +Napoleon had given the peasant no vestige of proprietorship in his holding, +and had consequently left him as much at the mercy of his landlord as he +was before. The name of freedom appears in fact to have worked actual +injury to the peasant; for in the enjoyment of a pretended power of free +contract he was left without that protection of the officers of State +which, under the Prussian regime from 1795 to 1807, had shielded him from +the tyranny of his lord. It has been the fatal, the irremediable bane of +Poland that its noblesse, until too late, saw no country, no right, no law, +outside itself. The very measures of interference on the part of the Czar +which this caste resented as unconstitutional were in part directed against +the abuse of its own privileges; and although in 1830 a section of the +nobles had learnt the secret of their country's fall, and were prepared to +give the serf the real emancipation of proprietorship, no universal impulse +worked in this direction, nor could the wrong of ages be undone in the +tumult of war and revolution. + +[Insurrection at Warsaw, Nov. 29.] + +A sharp distinction existed between the narrow circle of the highest +aristocracy of Poland and the mass of the poor and warlike noblesse. The +former, represented by men like Czartoryski, the friend of Alexander I. and +ex-Minister of Russia, understood the hopelessness of any immediate +struggle with the superior power, and advocated the politic development of +such national institutions as were given to Poland by the constitution of +1815, institutions which were certainly sufficient to preserve Poland from +absorption by Russia, and to keep alive the idea of the ultimate +establishment of its independence. It was among the lesser nobility, among +the subordinate officers of the army and the population of Warsaw itself, +who jointly formed the so-called democratic party, that the spirit of +revolt was strongest. Plans for an outbreak had been made during the +Turkish war of 1828; but unhappily this opportunity, which might have been +used with fatal effect against Russia, was neglected, and it was left for +the French Revolution of 1830 to kindle an untimely and ineffective flame. +The memory of Napoleon's campaigns and the wild voices of French democracy +filled the patriots at Warsaw with vain hopes of a military union with +western Liberalism, and overpowered the counsels of men who understood the +state of Europe better. Revolt broke out on the 29th of November, 1830. The +Polish regiments in Warsaw joined the insurrection, and the Russian troops, +under the Grand Duke Constantine, withdrew from the capital, where their +leader had narrowly escaped with his life. [390] + +[Attempted negotiation with the Czar.] + +The Government of Poland had up to this time been in the hands of a Council +nominated by the Czar as King of Poland, and controlled by instructions +from a secretary at St. Petersburg. The chief of the Council was Lubecki, a +Pole devoted to the Emperor Nicholas. On the victory of the insurrection at +Warsaw, the Council was dissolved and a provisional Government installed. +Though the revolt was the work of the so-called democratic party, the +influence of the old governing families of the highest aristocracy was +still so great that power was by common consent placed in their hands. +Czartoryski became president, and the policy adopted by himself and his +colleagues was that of friendly negotiation with Russia. The insurrection +of November was treated not as the beginning of a national revolt, but as a +mere disturbance occasioned by unconstitutional acts of the Government. So +little did the committee understand the character of the Emperor Nicholas, +as to imagine that after the expulsion of his soldiers and the overthrow of +his Ministers at Warsaw he would peaceably make the concessions required of +him, and undertake for the future faithfully to observe the Polish +constitution. Lubecki and a second official were sent to St. Petersburg to +present these demands, and further (though this was not seriously intended) +to ask that the constitution should be introduced into all the Russian +provinces which had once formed part of the Polish State. The reception +given to the envoys at the frontier was of an ominous character. They were +required to describe themselves as officers about to present a report to +the Czar, inasmuch as no representatives of rebels in arms could be +received into Russia. Lubecki appears now to have shaken the dust of Poland +off his feet; his colleague pursued his mission, and was admitted to the +Czar's presence. Nicholas, while expressing himself in language of injured +tenderness, and disclaiming all desire to punish the innocent with the +guilty, let it be understood that Poland had but two alternatives, +unconditional submission or annihilation. The messenger who in the +meanwhile carried back to Warsaw the first despatches of the envoy reported +that the roads were already filled with Russian regiments moving on their +prey. + +[Diebitsch invades Poland, Feb. 1831.] + +Six weeks of precious time were lost through the illusion of the Polish +Government that an accommodation with the Emperor Nicholas was possible. +Had the insurrection at Warsaw been instantly followed by a general levy +and the invasion of Lithuania, the resources of this large province might +possibly have been thrown into the scale against Russia. Though the mass of +the Lithuanian population, in spite or several centuries of union with +Poland, had never been assimilated to the dominant race, and remained in +language and creed more nearly allied to the Russians than the Poles, the +nobles formed an integral part of the Polish nation, and possessed +sufficient power over their serfs to drive them into the field to fight for +they knew not what. The Russian garrisons in Lithuania were not strong, and +might easily have been overpowered by a sudden attack. When once the +population of Warsaw had risen in arms against Nicholas, the only +possibility of success lay in the extension of the revolt over the whole of +the semi-Polish provinces, and in a general call to arms. But beside other +considerations which disinclined the higher aristocracy at Warsaw to +extreme measures, they were influenced by a belief that the Powers of +Europe might intervene on behalf of the constitution of the Polish kingdom +as established by the treaty of Vienna; while, if the struggle passed +beyond the borders of that kingdom, it would become a revolutionary +movement to which no Court could lend its support. It was not until the +envoy returned from St. Petersburg bearing the answer of the Emperor +Nicholas that the democratic party carried all before it, and all hopes of +a peaceful compromise vanished away. The Diet then passed a resolution +declaring that the House of Romanoff had forfeited the Polish crown, and +preparations began for a struggle for life or death with Russia. But the +first moments when Russia stood unguarded and unready had been lost beyond +recall. Troops had thronged westwards into Lithuania; the garrisons in the +fortresses had been raised to their full strength; and in February, 1831, +Diebitsch took up the offensive, and crossed the Polish frontier with a +hundred and twenty thousand men. + +[Campaign in Poland, 1831.] + +[Capture of Warsaw, Sept. 8, 1831.] + +The Polish army, though far inferior in numbers to the enemy which it had +to meet, was no contemptible foe. Among its officers there were many who +had served in Napoleon's campaigns; it possessed, however, no general +habituated to independent command; and the spirit of insubordination and +self-will, which had wrought so much ruin in Poland, was still ready to +break out when defeat had impaired the authority of the nominal chiefs. In +the first encounters the advancing Russian army was gallantly met; and, +although the Poles were forced to fall back upon Warsaw, the losses +sustained by Diebitsch were so serious that he had to stay his operations +and to wait for reinforcements. In March the Poles took up the offensive +and surprised several isolated divisions of the enemy; their general, +however, failed to push his advantages with the necessary energy and +swiftness; the junction of the Russians was at length effected, and on the +26th of May the Poles were defeated after obstinate resistance in a pitched +battle at Ostrolenka. Cholera now broke out in the Russian camp. Both +Diebitsch and the Grand Duke Constantine were carried off in the midst of +the campaign, and some months more were added to the struggle of Poland, +hopeless as this had now become. Incursions were made into Lithuania and +Podolia, but without result. Paskiewitch, the conqueror of Kars, was called +up to take the post left vacant by the death of his rival. New masses of +Russian troops came in place of those who had perished in battle and in the +hospitals; and while the Governments of Western Europe lifted no hand on +behalf of Polish independence, Prussia, alarmed lest the revolt should +spread into its own Polish provinces, assisted the operations of the +Russian general by supplying stores and munition of war. Blow after blow +fell upon the Polish cause. Warsaw itself became the prey of disorder, +intrigue, and treachery; and at length the Russian army made its entrance +into the capital, and the last soldiers of Poland laid down their arms, or +crossed into Prussian or Austrian territory. The revolt had been rashly and +unwisely begun: its results were fatal and lamentable. The constitution of +Poland was abolished; it ceased to be a separate kingdom, and became a +province of the Russian Empire. Its defenders were exiles over the face of +Europe or forgotten in Siberia. All that might have been won by the gradual +development of its constitutional liberties without breach with the Czar's +sovereignty was sacrificed. The future of Poland, like that of Russia +itself, now depended on the enlightenment and courage of the Imperial +Government, and on that alone. The very existence of a Polish nationality +and language seemed for a while to be threatened by the measures of +repression that followed the victory of 1831: and if it be true that +Russian autocracy has at length done for the Polish peasants what their +native masters during centuries of ascendency refused to do, this +emancipation would probably not have come the later for the preservation of +some relics of political independence, nor would it have had the less value +if unaccompanied by the proscription of so great a part of that class which +had once been held to constitute the Polish nation. [391] + +[Insurrection in the Papal States, Feb., 1831.] + +During the conflict on the banks of the Vistula, the attitude of the +Austrian Government had been one of watchful neutrality. Its own Polish +territory was not seriously menaced with disturbance, for in a great part +of Galicia the population, being of Ruthenian stock and belonging to the +Greek Church, had nothing in common with the Polish and Catholic noblesse +of their province, and looked back upon the days of Polish dominion as a +time of suffering and wrong. Austria's danger in any period of European +convulsion lay as yet rather on the side of Italy than on the East, and the +vigour of its policy in that quarter contrasted with the equanimity with +which it watched the struggle of its Slavic neighbours. Since the +suppression of the Neapolitan constitutional movement in 1821, the +Carbonari and other secret societies of Italy had lost nothing of their +activity. Their head-quarters had been removed from Southern Italy to the +Papal States, and the numerous Italian exiles in France and elsewhere kept +up a busy communication at once with French revolutionary leaders like +Lafayette and with the enemies of the established governments in Italy +itself. The death of Pope Pius VIII., on November 30, 1830, and the +consequent paralysis of authority within the Ecclesiastical States, came at +an opportune moment; assurances of support arrived from Paris; and the +Italian leaders resolved upon a general insurrection throughout the minor +Principalities on the 5th of February, 1831. Anticipating the signal, +Menotti, chief of a band of patriots at Modena, who appears to have been +lured on by the Grand Duke himself, assembled his partisans on February 3. +He was overpowered and imprisoned; but the outbreak of the insurrection in +Bologna, and its rapid extension over the northern part of the Papal +States, soon caused the Grand Duke to fly to Austrian territory, carrying +his prisoner Menotti with him, whom he subsequently put to death. The new +Pope, Gregory XVI., had scarcely been elected when the report reached him +that Bologna had declared the temporal power of the Papacy to be at an end. +Uncertain of the character of the revolt, he despatched Cardinal Benvenuti +northwards, to employ conciliation or force as occasion might require. The +Legate fell into the hands of the insurgents; the revolt spread southwards; +and Gregory, now hopeless of subduing it by the forces at his own command, +called upon Austria for assistance. [392] + +[Attitude of France.] + +The principle which, since the Revolution of July, the government of France +had repeatedly laid down as the future basis of European politics was that +of non-intervention. It had disclaimed any purpose of interfering with the +affairs of its neighbours, and had required in return that no foreign +intervention should take place in districts which, like Belgium and Savoy, +adjoined its own frontier. But there existed no real unity of purpose in +the councils of Louis Philippe. The Ministry had one voice for the +representatives of foreign powers, another for the Chamber of Deputies, and +another for Lafayette and the bands of exiles and conspirators who were +under his protection. The head of the government at the beginning of 1831 +was Laffitte, a weak politician, dominated by revolutionary sympathies and +phrases, but incapable of any sustained or resolute action, and equally +incapable of resisting Louis Philippe after the King had concluded his +performance of popular leader, and assumed his real character as the wary +and self-seeking chief of a reigning house. Whether the actual course of +French policy would be governed by the passions of the streets or by the +timorousness of Louis Philippe was from day to day a matter of conjecture. +The official answer given to the inquiries of the Austrian ambassador as to +the intentions of France in case of an Austrian intervention in Italy was, +that such intervention might be tolerated in Parma and Modena, which +belonged to sovereigns immediately connected with the Hapsburgs, but that +if it was extended to the Papal States war with France would be probable, +and if extended to Piedmont, certain. On this reply Metternich, who saw +Austria's own dominion in Italy once more menaced by the success of an +insurrectionary movement, had to form his decision. He could count on the +support of Russia in case of war; he knew well the fears of Louis Philippe, +and knew that he could work on these fears both by pointing to the presence +of the young Louis Bonaparte and his brother with the Italian insurgents as +evidence of the Bonapartist character of the movement, and by hinting that +in the last resort he might himself let loose upon France Napoleon's son, +the Duke of Reichstadt, now growing to manhood at Vienna, before whom Louis +Philippe's throne would have collapsed as speedily as that of Louis XVIII. +in 1814. Where weakness existed, Metternich was quick to divine it and to +take advantage of it. He rightly gauged Louis Philippe. Taking at their +true value the threats of the French Government, he declared that it was +better for Austria to fall, if necessary, by war than by revolution; and, +resolving at all hazards to suppress the Roman insurrection, he gave orders +to the Austrian troops to enter the Papal States. + +[Austrians suppress Roman revolt, March, 1831.] + +[Casimir Perier, March, 1831.] + +The military resistance which the insurgents could offer to the advance of +the Pope's Austrian deliverers was insignificant, and order was soon +restored. But all Europe expected the outbreak of war between Austria and +France. The French ambassador at Constantinople had gone so far as to offer +the Sultan an offensive and defensive alliance, and to urge him to make +preparations for an attack upon both Austria and Russia on their southern +frontiers. A despatch from the ambassador reached Paris describing the +warlike overtures he had made to the Porte. Louis Philippe saw that if this +despatch reached the hands of Laffitte and the war party in the Council of +Ministers the preservation of peace would be almost impossible. In concert +with Sebastiani, the Foreign Minister, he concealed the despatch from +Laffitte. The Premier discovered the trick that had been played upon him, +and tendered his resignation. It was gladly accepted by Louis Philippe. +Laffitte quitted office, begging pardon of God and man for the part that he +had taken in raising Louis Philippe to the throne. His successor was +Casimir Perier, a man of very different mould; resolute, clear-headed, and +immovably true to his word; a constitutional statesman of the strictest +type, intolerant of any species of disorder, and a despiser of popular +movements, but equally proof against royal intrigues, and as keen to +maintain the constitutional system of France against the Court on one side +and the populace on the other as he was to earn for France the respect of +foreign powers by the abandonment of a policy of adventure, and the steady +adherence to the principles of international obligation which he had laid +down. Under his firm hand the intrigues of the French Government with +foreign revolutionists ceased; it was felt throughout Europe that peace was +still possible, and that if war was undertaken by France it would be +undertaken only under conditions which would make any moral union of all +the great Powers against France impossible. The Austrian expedition into +the Papal States had already begun, and the revolutionary Government had +been suppressed; the most therefore that Casimir Perier could demand was +that the evacuation of the occupied territory should take place as soon as +possible, and that Austria should add its voice to that of the other Powers +in urging the Papal Government to reform its abuses. Both demands were +granted. For the first time Austria appeared as the advocate of something +like a constitutional system. A Conference held at Rome agreed upon a +scheme of reforms to be recommended to the Pope; the prospects of peace +grew daily fairer; and in July, 1831, the last Austrian soldiers quitted +the Ecclesiastical States. [393] + +[Second Austrian intervention, Jan., 1832.] + +[French occupy Ancona, February, 1832.] + +It now remained to be seen whether Pope Gregory and his cardinals had the +intelligence and good-will necessary for carrying out the reforms on the +promise of which France had abstained from active intervention. If any such +hopes existed they were doomed to speedy disappointment. The apparatus of +priestly maladministration was restored in all its ancient deformity. An +amnesty which had been promised by the Legate Benvenuti was disregarded, +and the Pope set himself to strengthen his authority by enlisting new bands +of ruffians and adventurers under the standard of St. Peter. Again +insurrection broke out, and again at the Pope's request the Austrians +crossed the frontier (January, 1832). Though their appearance was fatal to +the cause of liberty, they were actually welcomed as protectors in towns +which had been exposed to the tender mercies of the Papal condottieri. +There was no disorder, no severity, where the Austrian commandants held +sway; but their mere presence in central Italy was a threat to European +peace; and Casimir Perier was not the man to permit Austria to dominate in +Italy at its will. Without waiting for negotiations, he despatched a French +force to Ancona, and seized this town before the Austrians could approach +it. The rival Powers were now face to face in Italy; but Perier had no +intention of forcing on war if his opponent was still willing to keep the +peace. Austria accepted the situation, and made no attempt to expel the +French from the position they had seized. Casimir Perier, now on his +death-bed, defended the step that he had taken against the remonstrances of +ambassadors and against the protests of the Pope, and declared the presence +of the French at Ancona to be no incentive to rebellion, but the mere +assertion of the rights of a Power which had as good a claim to be in +central Italy as Austria itself. Had his life been prolonged, he would +probably have insisted upon the execution of the reforms which the Powers +had urged upon the Papal government, and have made the occupation of Ancona +an effectual means for reaching this end. But with his death the wrongs of +the Italians themselves and the question of a reformed government in the +Papal States gradually passed out of sight. France and Austria jealously +watched one another on the debatable land; the occupation became a mere +incident of the balance of power, and was prolonged for year after year, +until, in 1838, the Austrians having finally withdrawn all their troops, +the French peacefully handed over the citadel of Ancona to the Holy See. + +[Prussia in 1830.] + +[The Zollverein, 1828-1836.] + +The arena in which we have next to follow the effects of the July +Revolution, in action and counter-action, is Germany. It has been seen that +in the southern German States an element of representative government, if +weak, yet not wholly ineffective, had come into being soon after 1815, and +had survived the reactionary measures initiated by the conference of +Ministers at Carlsbad. In Prussia the promises of King Frederick William to +his people had never been fulfilled. Years had passed since exaggerated +rumours of conspiracy had served as an excuse for withholding the +Constitution. Hardenberg had long been dead; the foreign policy of the +country had taken a freer tone; the rigours of the police-system had +departed; but the nation remained as completely excluded from any share in +the government as it had been before Napoleon's fall. It had in fact become +clear that during the lifetime of King Frederick William things must be +allowed to remain in their existing condition; and the affection of the +people for their sovereign, who had been so long and so closely united with +Prussia in its sufferings and in its glories, caused a general willingness +to postpone the demand for constitutional reform until the succeeding +reign. The substantial merits of the administration might moreover have +reconciled a less submissive people than the Prussians to the absolute +government under which they lived. Under a wise and enlightened financial +policy the country was becoming visibly richer. Obstacles to commercial +development were removed, communications opened; and finally, by a series +of treaties with the neighbouring German States, the foundations were laid +for that Customs-Union which, under the name of the Zollverein, ultimately +embraced almost the whole of non-Austrian Germany. As one Principality +after another attached itself to the Prussian system, the products of the +various regions of Germany, hitherto blocked by the frontier dues of each +petty State, moved freely through the land, while the costs attending the +taxation of foreign imports, now concentrated upon the external line of +frontier, were enormously diminished. Patient, sagacious, and even liberal +in its negotiations with its weaker neighbours, Prussia silently connected +with itself through the ties of financial union States which had hitherto +looked to Austria as their natural head. The semblance of political union +was carefully avoided, but the germs of political union were nevertheless +present in the growing community of material interests. The reputation of +the Prussian Government, no less than the welfare of the Prussian people, +was advanced by each successive step in the extension of the Zollverein; +and although the earlier stages alone had been passed in the years before +1830, enough had already been done to affect public opinion; and the +general sense of material progress combined with other influences to close +Prussia to the revolutionary tendencies of that year. + +[Insurrections in Brunswick and Cassel.] + +[Constitutions in Hanover and Saxony, 1830-1833.] + +There were, however, other States in northern Germany which had all the +defects of Prussian autocracy without any of its redeeming qualities. In +Brunswick and in Hesse Cassel despotism existed in its most contemptible +form; the violence of a half-crazy youth in the one case, and the caprices +of an obstinate dotard in the other, rendering authority a mere nuisance to +those who were subject to it. Here accordingly revolution broke out. The +threatened princes had made themselves too generally obnoxious or +ridiculous for any hand to be raised in their defence. Their disappearance +excited no more than the inevitable lament from Metternich; and in both +States systems of representative government were introduced by their +successors. In Hanover and in Saxony agitation also began in favour of +Parliamentary rule. The disturbance that arose was not of a serious +character, and it was met by the Courts in a conciliatory spirit. +Constitutions were granted, the liberty of the Press extended, and trial by +jury established. On the whole, the movement of 1830, as it affected +northern Germany, was rationally directed and salutary in its results. +Changes of real value were accomplished with a sparing employment of +revolutionary means, and, in the more important cases, through the friendly +co-operation of the sovereigns with their subjects. It was not the fault of +those who had asked for the same degree of liberty in northern Germany +which the south already possessed, that Germany at large again experienced +the miseries of reaction and repression which had afflicted it ten years +before. + +[Movement in the Palatinate.] + +Like Belgium and the Rhenish Provinces, the Bavarian Palatinate had for +twenty years been incorporated with France. Its inhabitants had grown +accustomed to the French law and French institutions, and had caught +something of the political animation which returned to France after +Napoleon's fall. Accordingly when the government of Munich, alarmed by the +July Revolution, showed an inclination towards repressive measures, the +Palatinate, severed from the rest of the Bavarian monarchy and in immediate +contact with France, became the focus of a revolutionary agitation. The +Press had already attained some activity and some influence in this +province; and although the leaders of the party of progress were still to a +great extent Professors, they had so far advanced upon the patriots of 1818 +as to understand that the liberation of the German people was not to be +effected by the lecturers and the scholars of the Universities. The design +had been formed of enlisting all classes of the public on the side of +reform, both by the dissemination of political literature and by the +establishment of societies not limited, as in 1818, to academic circles, +but embracing traders as well as soldiers and professional men. Even the +peasant was to be reached and instructed in his interests as a citizen. It +was thought that much might be effected by associating together all the +Oppositions in the numerous German Parliaments; but a more striking feature +of the revolutionary movement which began in the Palatinate, and one +strongly distinguishing it from the earlier agitation of Jena and Erfurt, +was its cosmopolitan character. France in its triumph and Poland in its +death-struggle excited equal interest and sympathy. In each the cause of +European liberty appeared to be at stake. The Polish banner was saluted in +the Palatinate by the side of that of united Germany; and from that time +forward in almost every revolutionary movement of Europe, down to the +insurrection of the Commune of Paris in 1871, Polish exiles have been +active both in the organisation of revolt and in the field. + +[Reaction in Germany.] + +Until the fall of Warsaw, in September, 1831, the German governments, +uncertain of the course which events might take in Europe, had shown a +certain willingness to meet the complaints of their subjects, and had in +especial relaxed the supervision exercised over the press. The fall of +Warsaw, which quieted so many alarms, and made the Emperor Nicholas once +more a power outside his own dominions, inaugurated a period of reaction in +Germany. The Diet began the campaign against democracy by suppressing +various liberal newspapers, and amongst them the principal journal of the +Palatinate. It was against this movement of regression that the agitation +in the Palatinate and elsewhere was now directed. A festival, or +demonstration, was held at the Castle of Hambach, near Zweibruecken, at +which a body of enthusiasts called upon the German people to unite against +their oppressors, and some even urged an immediate appeal to arms (May 27, +1832). Similar meetings, though on a smaller scale, were held in other +parts of Germany. Wild words abounded, and the connection of the German +revolutionists with that body of opponents of all established governments +which had its council-chamber at Paris and its head in Lafayette was openly +avowed. Weak and insignificant as the German demagogues were, their +extravagance gave to Metternich and to the Diet sufficient pretext for +revising the reactionary measures of 1819. Once more the subordination of +all representative bodies to the sovereign's authority was laid down by the +Diet as a binding principle for every German state. The refusal of taxes by +any legislature was declared to be an act of rebellion which would be met +by the armed intervention of the central Powers. All political meetings and +associations were forbidden; the Press was silenced; the introduction of +German books printed abroad was prohibited, and the Universities were again +placed under the watch of the police (July, 1832). [394] + +[Attempt at Frankfort, April, 1833.] + +If among the minor sovereigns of Germany there were some who, as in Baden, +sincerely desired the development of free institutions, the authority +exercised by Metternich and his adherents in reaction bore down all the +resistance that these courts could offer, and the hand of despotism fell +everywhere heavily upon the party of political progress. The majority of +German Liberals, not yet prepared for recourse to revolutionary measures, +submitted to the pressure of the times, and disclaimed all sympathy with +illegal acts; a minority, recognising that nothing was now to be gained by +constitutional means, entered into conspiracies, and determined to liberate +Germany by force. One insignificant group, relying upon the armed +co-operation of Polish bands in France, and deceived by promises of support +from some Wuertemberg soldiers, actually rose in insurrection at Frankfort. +A guard-house was seized, and a few soldiers captured; but the citizens of +Frankfort stood aloof, and order was soon restored (April, 1833). It was +not to be expected that the reactionary courts should fail to draw full +advantage from this ill-timed outbreak of their enemies. Prussian troops +marched into Frankfort, and Metternich had no difficulty in carrying +through the Diet a decree establishing a commission to superintend and to +report upon the proceedings instituted against political offenders +throughout Germany. For several years these investigations continued, and +the campaign against the opponents of government was carried on with +various degrees of rigour in the different states. About two thousand +persons altogether were brought to trial: in Prussia thirty-nine sentences +of death were pronounced, but not executed. In the struggle against +revolution the forces of monarchy had definitely won the victory. Germany +again experienced, as it had in 1819, that the federal institutions which +were to have given it unity existed only for the purposes of repression. +The breach between the nation and its rulers, in spite of the apparent +failure of the democratic party, remained far deeper and wider than it had +been before; and although Metternich, victor once more over the growing +restlessness of the age, slumbered on for another decade in fancied +security, the last of his triumphs had now been won, and the next uprising +proved how blind was that boasted statesmanship which deemed the sources of +danger exhausted when once its symptoms had been driven beneath the +surface. + +[Conspirators and exiles.] + +[Dispersion of the Swiss exiles, 1834.] + +In half the states of Europe there were now bodies of exasperated, +uncompromising men, who devoted their lives to plotting against +governments, and who formed, in their community of interest and purpose, a +sort of obverse of the Holy Alliance, a federation of kings' enemies, a +league of principle and creed, in which liberty and human right stood +towards established rule as light to darkness. As the grasp of authority +closed everywhere more tightly upon its baffled foes, more and more of +these men passed into exile. Among them was the Genoese Mazzini, who, after +suffering imprisonment in 1831, withdrew to Marseilles, and there, in +combination with various secret societies, planned an incursion into the +Italian province of Savoy. It was at first intended that this enterprise +should be executed simultaneously with the German rising at Frankfort. +Delays, however, arose, and it was not until the beginning of the following +year that the little army, which numbered more Poles than Italians, was +ready for its task. The incursion was made from Geneva in February, 1834, +and ended disastrously. [395] Mazzini returned to Switzerland, where +hundreds of exiles, secure under the shelter of the Republic, devised +schemes of attack upon the despots of Europe, and even rioted in honour of +freedom in the streets of the Swiss cities which protected them. The effect +of the revolutionary movement of the time in consolidating the alliance of +the three Eastern Powers, so rudely broken by the Greek War of Liberation, +now came clearly into view. The sovereigns of Russia and Austria had met at +Muenchengraetz in Bohemia in the previous autumn, and, in concert with +Prussia, had resolved upon common principles of action if their +intervention should be required against disturbers of order. Notes were now +addressed from every quarter to the Swiss Government, requiring the +expulsion of all persons concerned in enterprises against the peace of +neighbouring States. Some resistance to this demand was made by individual +cantons; but the extravagance of many of the refugees themselves alienated +popular sympathy, and the greater part of them were forced to quit +Switzerland and to seek shelter in England or in America. With the +dispersion of the central band of exiles the open alliance which had +existed between the revolutionists of Europe gradually passed away. The +brotherhood of the kings had proved a stern reality, the brotherhood of the +peoples a delusive vision. Mazzini indeed, who up to this time had scarcely +emerged from the rabble of revolutionary leaders, was yet to prove how +deeply the genius, the elevation, the fervour of one man struggling against +the powers of the world may influence the history of his age; but the fire +that purified the fine gold charred and consumed the baser elements; and of +those who had hoped the most after 1830, many now sank into despair, or +gave up their lives to mere restless agitation and intrigue. + +[Difficulties of Louis Philippe.] + +[Insurrections, 1832-1834.] + +[Repressive Laws, Sept., 1835.] + +It was in France that the revolutionary movement was longest maintained. +During the first year of Louis Philippe's rule the opposition to his +government was inspired not so much by Republicanism as by a wild and +inconsiderate sympathy with the peoples who were fighting for liberty +elsewhere, and by a headstrong impulse to take up arms on their behalf. The +famous decree of the Convention in 1792, which promised the assistance of +France to every nation in revolt against its rulers, was in fact the true +expression of what was felt by a great part of the French nation in 1831; +and in the eyes of these enthusiasts it was the unpardonable offence of +Louis Philippe against the honour of France that he allowed Poland and +Italy to succumb without drawing his sword against their conquerors. That +France would have had to fight the three Eastern Powers combined, if it had +allied itself with those in revolt against any one of the three, passed for +nothing among the clamorous minority in the Chamber and among the orators +of Paris. The pacific policy of Casimir Perier was misunderstood; it passed +for mere poltroonery, when in fact it was the only policy that could save +France from a recurrence of the calamities of 1815. There were other causes +for the growing unpopularity of the King and of his Ministers, but the +first was their policy of peace. As the attacks of his opponents became +more and more bitter, the government of Casimir Perier took more and more +of a repressive character. Disappointment at the small results produced in +France itself by the Revolution of July worked powerfully in men's minds. +The forces that had been set in motion against Charles X. were not to be +laid at rest at the bidding of those who had profited by them, and a +Republican party gradually took definite shape and organisation. Tumult +succeeded tumult. In the summer of 1832 the funeral of General Lamarque, a +popular soldier, gave the signal for insurrection at Paris. There was +severe fighting in the streets; the National Guard, however, proved true to +the king, and shared with the army in the honours of its victory. +Repressive measures and an unbroken series of prosecutions against +seditious writers followed this first armed attack upon the established +government. The bitterness of the Opposition, the discontent of the working +classes, far surpassed anything that had been known under Charles X. The +whole country was agitated by revolutionary societies and revolutionary +propaganda. Disputes between masters and workmen, which, in consequence of +the growth of French manufacturing industry, now became both frequent and +important, began to take a political colour. Polish and Italian exiles +connected their own designs with attacks to be made upon the French +Government from within; and at length, in April, 1834, after the passing of +a law against trades-unions, the working classes of Lyons, who were on +strike against their employers, were induced to rise in revolt. After +several days' fighting the insurrection was suppressed. Simultaneous +outbreaks took place at St. Etienne, Grenoble, and many other places in the +south and centre of France; and on a report of the success of the +insurgents reaching Paris, the Republic was proclaimed and barricades were +erected. Again civil war raged in the streets, and again the forces of +Government gained the victory. A year more passed, during which the +investigations into the late revolt and the trial of a host of prisoners +served rather to agitate than to reassure the public mind; and in the +summer of 1835 an attempt was made upon the life of the King so terrible +and destructive in its effects as to amount to a public calamity. An +infernal machine composed of a hundred gun-barrels was fired by a Corsican +named Fieschi, as the King with a large suite was riding through the +streets of Paris on the anniversary of the Revolution of July. Fourteen +persons were killed on the spot, among whom was Mortier, one of the oldest +of the marshals of France; many others were fatally or severely injured. +The King, however, with his three sons, escaped unhurt, and the repressive +laws that followed this outrage marked the close of open revolutionary +agitation in France. Whether in consequence of the stringency of the new +laws, or of the exhaustion of a party discredited in public estimation by +the crimes of a few of its members and the recklessness of many more, the +constitutional monarchy of Louis Philippe now seemed to have finally +vanquished its opponents. Repeated attempts were made on the life of the +King, but they possessed for the most part little political significance. +Order was welcome to the nation at large; and though in the growth of a +socialistic theory and creed of life which dates from this epoch there lay +a danger to Governments greater than any purely political, Socialism was as +yet the affair of thinkers rather than of active workers either in the +industrial or in the Parliamentary world. The Government had beaten its +enemies outside the Chamber. Within the Chamber, the parties of extremes +ceased to exercise any real influence. Groups were formed, and rival +leaders played against one another for office; but they were separated by +no far-reaching differences of aim, and by no real antagonism of +constitutional principle. During the succeeding years of Louis Philippe's +reign there was little visible on the surface but the normal rivalry of +parties under a constitutional monarchy. The middle-class retained its +monopoly of power: authority, centralised as before, maintained its old +prestige in France, and softened opposition by judicious gifts of office +and emolument. Revolutionary passion seemed to have died away: and the +triumphs or reverses of party-leaders in the Chamber of Deputies succeeded +to the harassing and doubtful conflict between Government and insurrection. + +[The English Reform movement.] + +The near coincidence in time between the French Revolution of 1830 and the +passing of the English Reform Bill is apt to suggest to those who look for +the operation of wide general causes in history that the English Reform +movement should be viewed as a part of the great current of political +change which then traversed the continent of Europe. But on a closer +examination this view is scarcely borne out by facts, and the coincidence +of the two epochs of change appears to be little more than accidental. The +general unity that runs through the history of the more advanced +continental states is indeed stronger than appears to a superficial reader +of history; but this correspondence of tendency does not always embrace +England; on the contrary, the conditions peculiar to England usually +preponderate over those common to England and other countries, exhibiting +at times more of contrast than of similarity, as in the case of the +Napoleonic epoch, when the causes which drew together the western half of +the continent operated powerfully to exclude our own country from the +current influences of the time, and made the England of 1815, in opinion, +in religion, and in taste much more insular than the England of 1780. The +revolution which overthrew Charles X. did no doubt encourage and stimulate +the party of Reform in Great Britain; but, unlike the Belgian, the German, +and the Italian movements, the English Reform movement would unquestionably +have run the same course and achieved the same results even if the revolt +against the ordinances of Charles X. had been successfully repressed, and +the Bourbon monarchy had maintained itself in increased strength and +reputation. A Reform of Parliament had been acknowledged to be necessary +forty years before. Pitt had actually proposed it in 1785, and but for the +outbreak of the French Revolution would probably have carried it into +effect before the close of the last century. The development of English +manufacturing industry which took place between 1790 and 1830, accompanied +by the rapid growth of towns and the enrichment of the urban middle class, +rendered the design of Pitt, which would have transferred the +representation of the decayed boroughs to the counties alone, obsolete, and +made the claims of the new centres of population too strong to be resisted. +In theory the representative system of the country was completely +transformed; but never was a measure which seemed to open the way to such +boundless possibilities of change so thoroughly safe and so thoroughly +conservative. In spite of the increased influence won by the wealthy part +of the commercial classes, the House of Commons continued to be drawn +mainly from the territorial aristocracy. Cabinet after Cabinet was formed +with scarcely a single member included in it who was not himself a man of +title, or closely connected with the nobility: the social influence of rank +was not diminished; and although such measures as the Reform of Municipal +Corporations attested the increased energy of the Legislature, no party in +the House of Commons was weaker than that which supported the democratic +demands for the Ballot and for Triennial Parliaments, nor was the repeal of +the Corn Laws seriously considered until famine had made it inevitable. +That the widespread misery which existed in England after 1832, as the +result of the excessive increase of our population and the failure alike of +law and of philanthropy to keep pace with the exigencies of a vast +industrial growth, should have been so quietly borne, proves how great was +the success of the Reform Bill as a measure of conciliation between +Government and people. But the crowning justification of the changes made +in 1832, and the complete and final answer to those who had opposed them as +revolutionary, was not afforded until 1848, when, in the midst of European +convulsion, the monarchy and the constitution of England remained unshaken. +Bold as the legislation of Lord Grey appeared to men who had been brought +up amidst the reactionary influences dominant in England since 1793, the +Reform Bill belongs not to the class of great creative measures which have +inaugurated new periods in the life of nations, but to the class of those +which, while least affecting the general order of society, have most +contributed to political stability and to the avoidance of revolutionary +change. + + + + +CHAPTER XVII. + + +France and England after 1830--Affairs of Portugal--Don Miguel--Don Pedro +invades Portugal--Ferdinand of Spain--The Pragmatic Sanction--Death of +Ferdinand: Regency of Christina--The Constitution--Quadruple Alliance-- +Miguel and Carlos expelled from Portugal--Carlos enters Spain--The Basque +Provinces--Carlist War: Zumalacarregui--The Spanish Government seeks French +assistance, which is refused--Constitution of 1837--End of the War--Regency +of Espartero--Isabella Queen--Affairs of the Ottoman Empire--Ibrahim +invades Syria; his victories--Rivalry of France and Russia at +Constantinople--Peace of Kutaya and Treaty of Unkiar Skelessi--Effect of +this Treaty--France and Mehemet Ali--Commerce of the Levant--Second War +between Mehemet and the Porte--Ottoman disasters--The Policy of the Great +Powers--Quadruple Treaty without France--Ibrahim expelled from Syria--Final +Settlement--Turkey after 1840--Attempted reforms of Reschid Pasha. + + +[France and England after 1830.] + +Alliances of opinion usually cover the pursuit on one or both sides of some +definite interest; and to this rule the alliance which appeared to be +springing up between France and England after the changes of 1830 was no +exception. In the popular view, the bond of union between the two States +was a common attachment to principles of liberty; and on the part of the +Whig statesmen who now governed England this sympathy with free +constitutional systems abroad was certainly a powerful force: but other +motives than mere community of sentiment combined to draw the two +Governments together, and in the case of France these immediate interests +greatly outweighed any abstract preference for a constitutional ally. Louis +Philippe had an avowed and obstinate enemy in the Czar of Russia, who had +been his predecessor's friend: the Court of Vienna tolerated usurpers only +where worse mischief would follow from attacking them; Prussia had no +motive for abandoning the connexions which it had maintained since 1815. As +the union between the three Eastern Courts grew closer in consequence of +the outbreak of revolution beyond the borders of France, a good +understanding with Great Britain became more and more obviously the right +policy for Louis Philippe; on the other hand, the friendship of France +seemed likely to secure England from falling back into that isolated +position which it had occupied when the Holy Alliance laid down the law to +Europe, and averted the danger to which the Ottoman Empire, as well as the +peace of the world, had been exposed by the combination of French with +Russian schemes of aggrandizement. If Canning, left without an ally in +Europe, had called the new world into existence to redress the balance of +the old, his Whig successors might well look with some satisfaction on that +shifting of the weights which had brought over one of the Great Powers to +the side of England, and anticipate, in the concert of the two great +Western States, the establishment of a permanent force in European politics +which should hold in check the reactionary influences of Vienna and St. +Petersburg. To some extent these views were realised. A general relation of +friendliness was recognised as subsisting between the Governments of Paris +and London, and in certain European complications their intervention was +arranged in common. But even here the element of mistrust was seldom +absent; and while English Ministers jealously watched each action of their +neighbour, the French Government rarely allowed the ties of an informal +alliance to interfere with the prosecution of its own views. Although down +to the close of Louis Philippe's reign the good understanding between +England and France was still nominally in existence, all real confidence +had then long vanished; and on more than one occasion the preservation of +peace between the two nations had been seriously endangered. + +[Affairs of Portugal, 1826-1830.] + +It was in the establishment of the kingdom of Belgium that the combined +action of France and England produced its first and most successful result. +A second demand was made upon the Governments of the two constitutional +Powers by the conflicts which agitated the Spanish Peninsula, and which +were stimulated in the general interests of absolutism by both the Austrian +and the Russian Court. The intervention of Canning in 1826 on behalf of the +constitutional Regency of Portugal against the foreign supporters of Don +Miguel, the head of the clerical and reactionary party, had not permanently +restored peace to that country. Miguel indeed accepted the constitution, +and, after betrothing himself to the infant sovereign, Donna Maria, who was +still with her father Pedro, in Brazil, entered upon the Regency which his +elder brother had promised to him. But his actions soon disproved the +professions of loyalty to the constitution which he had made; and after +dissolving the Cortes, and re-assembling the mediaeval Estates, he caused +himself to be proclaimed King (June, 1828). A reign of terror followed. The +constitutionalists were completely crushed. Miguel's own brutal violence +gave an example to all the fanatics and ruffians who surrounded him; and +after an unsuccessful appeal to arms, those of the adherents of Donna Maria +and the constitution who escaped from imprisonment or execution took refuge +in England or in the Azore islands, where Miguel had not been able to +establish his authority. Though Miguel was not officially recognised as +Sovereign by most of the foreign Courts, his victory was everywhere seen +with satisfaction by the partisans of absolutism; and in Great Britain, +where the Duke of Wellington was still in power, the precedent of Canning's +intervention was condemned, and a strict neutrality maintained. Not only +was all assistance refused to Donna Maria, but her adherents who had taken +refuge in England were prevented from making this country the basis of any +operations against the usurper. + +[Invasion of Portugal by Pedro. July, 1832.] + +Such was the situation of Portuguese affairs when the events of 1830 +brought an entirely new spirit into the foreign policy of both England and +France. Miguel, however, had no inclination to adapt his own policy to the +change of circumstances; on the contrary, he challenged the hostility of +both governments by persisting in a series of wanton attacks upon English +and French subjects resident at Lisbon. Satisfaction was demanded, and +exacted by force. English and French squadrons successively appeared in the +Tagus. Lord Palmerston, now Foreign Secretary in the Ministry of Earl Grey, +was content with obtaining a pecuniary indemnity for his countrymen, +accompanied by a public apology from the Portuguese Government: the French +admiral, finding some difficulty in obtaining redress, carried off the best +ships of Don Miguel's navy. [396] A weightier blow was, however, soon to +fall upon the usurper. His brother, the Emperor Pedro, threatened with +revolution in Brazil, resolved to return to Europe and to enforce the +rights of his daughter to the throne of Portugal. Pedro arrived in London +in July, 1831, and was permitted by the Government to raise troops and to +secure the services of some of the best naval officers of this country. The +gathering place of his forces was Terceira, one of the Azore islands, and +in the summer of 1832 a sufficiently strong body of troops was collected to +undertake the reconquest of Portugal. A landing was made at Oporto, and +this city fell into the hands of Don Pedro without resistance. Miguel, +however, now marched against his brother, and laid siege to Oporto. For +nearly a year no progress was made by either side; at length the arrival of +volunteers from various countries, among whom was Captain Charles Napier, +enabled Pedro to divide his forces and to make a new attack on Portugal +from the south. Napier, in command of the fleet, annihilated the navy of +Don Miguel off St. Vincent; his colleague, Villa Flor, landed and marched +on Lisbon. The resistance of the enemy was overcome, and on the 28th of +July, 1833, Don Pedro entered the capital. But the war was not yet at an +end, for Miguel's cause was as closely identified with the interests of +European absolutism as that of his brother was with constitutional right, +and assistance both in troops and money continued to arrive at his camp. +The struggle threatened to prove a long and obstinate one, when a new turn +was given to events in the Peninsula by the death of Ferdinand, King of +Spain. + +[Death of Ferdinand, Sept., 1833.] + +Since the restoration of absolute Government in Spain in 1823, Ferdinand, +in spite of his own abject weakness and ignorance, had not given complete +satisfaction to the fanatics of the clerical party. Some vestiges of +statesmanship, some sense of political necessity, as well as the influence +of foreign counsellors, had prevented the Government of Madrid from +completely identifying itself with the monks and zealots who had first +risen against the constitution of 1820, and who now sought to establish the +absolute supremacy of the Church. The Inquisition had not been restored, +and this alone was enough to stamp the King as a renegade in the eyes of +the ferocious and implacable champions of mediaeval bigotry. Under the name +of Apostolicals, these reactionaries had at times broken into open +rebellion. Their impatience had, however, on the whole been restrained by +the knowledge that in the King's brother and heir, Don Carlos, they had an +adherent whose devotion to the priestly cause was beyond suspicion, and who +might be expected soon to ascend the throne. Ferdinand had been thrice +married; he was childless; his state of health miserable; and his life +likely to be a short one. The succession to the throne of Spain had +moreover, since 1713, been governed by the Salic Law, so that even in the +event of Ferdinand leaving female issue Don Carlos would nevertheless +inherit the crown. These confident hopes were rudely disturbed by the +marriage of the King with his cousin Maria Christina of Naples, followed by +an edict, known as the Pragmatic Sanction, repealing the Salic Law which +had been introduced with the first Bourbon, and restoring the ancient +Castilian custom under which women were capable of succeeding to the crown. +A daughter, Isabella, was shortly afterwards born to the new Queen. On the +legality of the Pragmatic Sanction the opinions of publicists differed; it +was judged, however, by Europe at large not from the point of view of +antiquarian theory, but with direct reference to its immediate effect. The +three Eastern Courts emphatically condemned it, as an interference with +established monarchical right, and as a blow to the cause of European +absolutism through the alliance which it would almost certainly produce +between the supplanters of Don Carlos and the Liberals of the Spanish +Peninsula. [397] To the clerical and reactionary party at Madrid, it +amounted to nothing less than a sentence of destruction, and the utmost +pressure was brought to bear upon the weak and dying King with the object +of inducing him to undo the alleged wrong which he had done to his brother. +In a moment of prostration Ferdinand revoked the Pragmatic Sanction; but, +subsequently, regaining some degree of strength, he re-enacted it, and +appointed Christina Regent during the continuance of his illness. Don +Carlos, protesting against the violation of his rights, had betaken himself +to Portugal, where he made common cause with Miguel. His adherents had no +intention of submitting to the change of succession. Their resentment was +scarcely restrained during Ferdinand's life-time, and when, in September, +1833, his long-expected death took place, and the child Isabella was +declared Queen under the Regency of her mother, open rebellion broke out, +and Carlos was proclaimed King in several of the northern provinces. + +[The Regency and the Carlists.] + +[Quadruple Treaty, April 22, 1834.] + +[Miguel and Carlos removed, May, 1834.] + +For the moment the forces of the Regency seemed to be far superior to those +of the insurgents, and Don Carlos failed to take advantage of the first +outburst of enthusiasm and to place himself at the head of his followers. +He remained in Portugal, while Christina, as had been expected, drew nearer +to the Spanish Liberals, and ultimately called to power a Liberal minister, +Martinez de la Rosa, under whom a constitution was given to Spain by Royal +Statute (April 10, 1834). At the same time negotiations were opened with +Portugal and with the Western Powers, in the hope of forming an alliance +which should drive both Miguel and Carlos from the Peninsula. On the 22nd +of April, 1834, a Quadruple Treaty was signed at London, in which the +Spanish Government undertook to send an army into Portugal against Miguel, +the Court of Lisbon pledging itself in return to use all the means in its +power to expel Don Carlos from Portuguese territory. England engaged to +co-operate by means of its fleet. The assistance of France, if it should be +deemed necessary for the attainment of the objects of the Treaty, was to be +rendered in such manner as should be settled by common consent. In +pursuance of the policy of the Treaty, and even before the formal +engagement was signed, a Spanish division under General Rodil crossed the +frontier and marched against Miguel. The forces of the usurper were +defeated. The appearance of the English fleet and the publication of the +Treaty of Quadruple Alliance rendered further resistance hopeless, and on +the 22nd of May Miguel made his submission, and in return for a large +pension renounced all rights to the crown, and undertook to quit the +Peninsula for ever. Don Carlos, refusing similar conditions, went on board +an English ship, and was conducted to London. [398] + +[Carlos appears in Spain.] + +With respect to Portugal, the Quadruple Alliance had completely attained +its object; and in so far as the Carlist cause was strengthened by the +continuance of civil war in the neighbouring country, this source of +strength was no doubt withdrawn from it. But in its effect upon Don Carlos +himself the action of the Quadruple Alliance was worse than useless. While +fulfilling the letter of the Treaty, which stipulated for the expulsion of +the two pretenders from the Peninsula, the English Admiral had removed +Carlos from Portugal, where he was comparatively harmless, and had taken no +effective guarantee that he should not re-appear in Spain itself and +enforce his claim by arms. Carlos had not been made a prisoner of war; he +had made no promises and incurred no obligations; nor could the British +Government, after his arrival in this country, keep him in perpetual +restraint. Quitting England after a short residence, he travelled in +disguise through France, crossed the Pyrenees, and appeared on the 10th of +July, 1834, at the headquarters of the Carlist insurgents in Navarre. + +[The Basque Provinces.] + +In the country immediately below the western Pyrenees, the so-called Basque +Provinces, lay the chief strength of the Carlist rebellion. These +provinces, which were among the most thriving and industrious parts of +Spain, might seem by their very superiority an unlikely home for a movement +which was directed against everything favourable to liberty, tolerance, and +progress in the Spanish kingdom. But the identification of the Basques with +the Carlist cause was due in fact to local, not to general, causes; and in +fighting to impose a bigoted despot upon the Spanish people, they were in +truth fighting to protect themselves from a closer incorporation with +Spain. Down to the year 1812, the Basque provinces had preserved more than +half of the essentials of independence. Owing to their position on the +French frontier, the Spanish monarchy, while destroying all local +independence in the interior of Spain, had uniformly treated the Basques +with the same indulgence which the Government of Great Britain has shown to +the Channel Islands, and which the French monarchy, though in a less +degree, showed to the frontier province of Alsace in the seventeenth and +eighteenth centuries. The customs-frontier of the north of Spain was drawn +to the south of these districts. The inhabitants imported what they pleased +from France without paying any duties; while the heavy import-dues levied +at the border of the neighbouring Spanish provinces gave them the +opportunity of carrying on an easy and lucrative system of smuggling. The +local administration remained to a great extent in the hands of the people +themselves; each village preserved its active corporate life; and the +effect of this survival of a vigorous local freedom was seen in the +remarkable contrast described by travellers between the aspect of the +Basque districts and that of Spain at large. The Fueros, or local rights, +as the Basques considered them, were in reality, when viewed as part of the +order of the Spanish State, a series of exceptional privileges; and it was +inevitable that the framers of the Constitution of 1812, in their attempt +to create a modern administrative and political system doing justice to the +whole of the nation, should sweep away the distinctions which had hitherto +marked off one group of provinces from the rest of the community. The +continuance of war until the return of Ferdinand, and the overthrow of the +Constitution, prevented the plans of the Cortes from being at that time +carried into effect; but the revolution of 1820 brought them into actual +operation, and the Basques found themselves, as a result of the victory of +Liberal principles, compelled to pay duties on their imports, robbed of the +profits of their smuggling, and supplanted in the management of their local +affairs by an army of officials from Madrid. They had gained by the +Constitution little that they had not possessed before, and their losses +were immediate, tangible, and substantial. The result was, that although +the larger towns, like Bilbao, remained true to modern ideas, the country +districts, led chiefly by priests, took up arms on behalf of the absolute +monarchy, assisted the French in the restoration of despotism in 1823, and +remained the permanent enemies of the constitutional cause. [399] On the +death of Ferdinand they declared at once for Don Carlos, and rose in +rebellion against the Government of Queen Christina, by which they +considered the privileges of the Basque Provinces and the interests of +Catholic orthodoxy to be alike threatened. + +[Carlist victories, 1834-5.] + +There was little in the character of Don Carlos to stimulate the loyalty +even of his most benighted partizans. Of military and political capacity he +was totally destitute, and his continued absence in Portugal when the +conflict had actually begun proved him to be wanting in the natural +impulses of a brave man. It was, however, his fortune to be served by a +soldier of extraordinary energy and skill; and the first reverses of the +Carlists were speedily repaired, and a system of warfare organised which +made an end of the hopes of easy conquest with which the Government of +Christina had met the insurrection. Fighting in a worthless cause, and +commanding resources scarcely superior to those of a brigand chief, the +Carlist leader, Zumalacarregui, inflicted defeat after defeat upon the +generals who were sent to destroy him. The mountainous character of the +country and the universal hostility of the inhabitants made the exertions +of a regular soldiery useless against the alternate flights and surprises +of men who knew every mountain track, and who gained information of the +enemy's movements from every cottager. Terror was added by Zumalacarregui +to all his other methods for demoralising his adversary. In the exercise of +reprisals he repeatedly murdered all his prisoners in cold blood, and gave +to the war so savage a character that foreign Governments at last felt +compelled to urge upon the belligerents some regard for the usages of the +civilised world. The appearance of Don Carlos himself in the summer of 1834 +raised still higher the confidence already inspired by the victories of his +general. It was in vain that the old constitutionalist soldier, Mina, who +had won so great a name in these provinces in 1823, returned after long +exile to the scene of his exploits. Enfeebled and suffering, he was no +longer able to place himself at the head of his troops, and he soon sought +to be relieved from a hopeless task. His successor, the War Minister +Valdes, took the field announcing his determination to act upon a new +system, and to operate with his troops in mass instead of pursuing the +enemy's bands with detachments. The result of this change of tactics was a +defeat more ruinous and complete than had befallen any of Valdes' +predecessors. He with difficulty withdrew the remainder of his army from +the insurgent provinces; and the Carlist leader master of the open country +up to the borders of Castile, prepared to cross the Ebro and to march upon +Madrid. [400] + +[Request to France for assistance, May, 1835.] + +The Ministers of Queen Christina, who had up till this time professed +themselves confident in their power to deal with the insurrection, could +now no longer conceal the real state of affairs. Valdes himself declared +that the rebellion could not be subdued without foreign aid; and after +prolonged discussion in the Cabinet it was determined to appeal to France +for armed assistance. The flight of Don Carlos from England had already +caused an additional article to be added to the Treaty of the Quadruple +Alliance, in which France undertook so to watch the frontier of the +Pyrenees that no reinforcements or munition of war should reach the +Carlists from that side, while England promised to supply the troops of +Queen Christina with arms and stores, and, if necessary, to render +assistance with a naval force (18th August, 1834). The foreign supplies +sent to the Carlists had thus been cut off both by land and sea; but more +active assistance seemed indispensable if Madrid was to be saved from +falling into the enemy's hands. The request was made to Louis Philippe's +Government to occupy the Basque Provinces with a corps of twelve thousand +men. Reasons of weight might be addressed to the French Court in favour of +direct intervention. The victory of Don Carlos would place upon the throne +of Spain a representative of all those reactionary influences throughout +Europe which were in secret or in open hostility to the House of Orleans, +and definitely mark the failure of that policy which had led France to +combine with England in expelling Don Miguel from Portugal. On the other +hand, the experience gained from earlier military enterprises in Spain +might well deter even bolder politicians than those about Louis Philippe +from venturing upon a task whose ultimate issues no man could confidently +forecast. Napoleon had wrecked his empire in the struggle beyond the +Pyrenees not less than in the march to Moscow: and the expedition of 1823, +though free from military difficulties, had exposed France to the +humiliating responsibility for every brutal act of a despotism which, in +the very moment of its restoration, had scorned the advice of its +restorers. The constitutional Government which invoked French assistance +might, moreover, at any moment give place to a democratic faction which +already harassed it within the Cortes, and which, in its alliance with the +populace in many of the great cities, threatened to throw Spain into +anarchy, or to restore the ill-omened constitution of 1812. But above all, +the attitude of the three Eastern Powers bade the ruler of France hesitate +before committing himself to a military occupation of Spanish territory. +Their sympathies were with Don Carlos, and the active participation of +France in the quarrel might possibly call their opposing forces into the +field and provoke a general war. In view of the evident dangers arising out +of the proposed intervention, the French Government, taking its stand on +that clause of the Quadruple Treaty which provided that the assistance of +France should be rendered in such manner as might be agreed upon by all the +parties to the Treaty, addressed itself to Great Britain, inquiring whether +this country would undertake a joint responsibility in the enterprise and +share with France the consequences to which it might give birth. Lord +Palmerston in reply declined to give the assurance required. He stated that +no objection would be raised by the British Government to the entry of +French troops into Spain, but that such intervention must be regarded as +the work of France alone, and be undertaken by France at its own peril. +This answer sufficed for Louis Philippe and his Ministers. The Spanish +Government was informed that the grant of military assistance was +impossible, and that the entire public opinion of France would condemn so +dangerous an undertaking. As a proof of goodwill, permission was given to +Queen Christina to enrol volunteers both in England and France. Arms were +supplied; and some thousands of needy or adventurous men ultimately made +their way from our own country as well as from France, to earn under +Colonel De Lacy Evans and other leaders a scanty harvest of profit or +renown. + +[Continuance of the war.] + +The first result of the rejection of the Spanish demand for the direct +intervention of France was the downfall of the Minister by whom this demand +had been made. His successor, Toreno, though a well-known patriot, proved +unable to stem the tide of revolution that was breaking over the country. +City after city set up its own Junta, and acted as if the central +government had ceased to exist. Again the appeal for help was made to Louis +Philippe, and now, not so much to avert the victory of Don Carlos as to +save Spain from anarchy and from the constitution of 1812. Before an answer +could arrive, Toreno in his turn had passed away. Mendizabal, a banker who +had been entrusted with financial business at London, and who had entered +into friendly relations with Lord Palmerston, was called to office, as a +politician acceptable to the democratic party, and the advocate of a close +connection with England rather than with France. In spite of the confident +professions of the Minister, and in spite of some assistance actually +rendered by the English fleet, no real progress was made in subduing the +Carlists, or in restoring administrative and financial order. The death of +Zumalacarregui, who was forced by Don Carlos to turn northwards and besiege +Bilbao instead of marching upon Madrid immediately after his victories, had +checked the progress of the rebellion at a critical moment; but the +Government, distracted and bankrupt, could not use the opportunity which +thus offered itself, and the war soon blazed out anew not only in the +Basque Provinces but throughout the north of Spain. For year after year the +monotonous struggle continued, while Cortes succeeded Cortes and faction +supplanted faction, until there remained scarcely an officer who had not +lost his reputation or a politician who was not useless and discredited. + +[Constitution of 1837.] + +[End of the war, Sept., 1839.] + +The Queen Regent, who from the necessities of her situation had for awhile +been the representative of the popular cause, gradually identified herself +with the interests opposed to democratic change; and although her name was +still treated with some respect, and her policy was habitually attributed +to the misleading advice of courtiers, her real position was well +understood at Madrid, and her own resistance was known to be the principal +obstacle to the restoration of the Constitution of 1812. It was therefore +determined to overcome this resistance by force; and on the 13th of August, +1836, a regiment of the garrison of Madrid, won over by the Exaltados, +marched upon the palace of La Granja, invaded the Queen's apartments, and +compelled her to sign an edict restoring the Constitution of 1812 until the +Cortes should establish that or some other. Scenes of riot and murder +followed in the capital. Men of moderate opinions, alarmed at the approach +of anarchy, prepared to unite with Don Carlos. King Louis Philippe, who had +just consented to strengthen the French legion by the addition of some +thousands of trained soldiers, now broke entirely from the Spanish +connection, and dismissed his Ministers who refused to acquiesce in this +change of policy. Meanwhile the Eastern Powers and all rational partisans +of absolutism besought Don Carlos to give those assurances which would +satisfy the wavering mass among his opponents, and place him on the throne +without the sacrifice of any right that was worth preserving. It seemed as +if the opportunity was too clear to be misunderstood; but the obstinacy and +narrowness of Don Carlos were proof against every call of fortune. Refusing +to enter into any sort of engagement, he rendered it impossible for men to +submit to him who were not willing to accept absolutism pure and simple. On +the other hand, a majority of the Cortes, whose eyes were now opened to the +dangers around them, accepted such modifications of the Constitution of +1812 that political stability again appeared possible (June, 1837). The +danger of a general transference of all moderate elements in the State to +the side of Don Carlos was averted; and, although the Carlist armies took +up the offensive, menaced the capital, and made incursions into every part +of Spain, the darkest period of the war was now over; and when, after +undertaking in person the march upon Madrid, Don Carlos swerved aside and +ultimately fell back in confusion to the Ebro, the suppression of the +rebellion became a certainty. General Espartero, with whom such distinction +remained as was to be gathered in this miserable war, forced back the +adversary step by step, and carried fire and sword into the Basque +Provinces, employing a system of devastation which alone seemed capable of +exhausting the endurance of the people. Reduced to the last extremity, the +Carlist leaders turned their arms against one another. The priests +excommunicated the generals, and the generals shot the priests; and +finally, on the 14th September, after the surrender of almost all his +troops to Espartero, Don Carlos crossed the French frontier, and the +conflict which during six years had barbarised and disgraced the Spanish +nation, reached its close. + +[End of the Regency, Isabella, Queen, Nov., 1843.] + +The triumph of Queen Christina over her rivals was not of long duration. +Confronted by a strong democratic party both in the Cortes and in the +country, she endeavoured in vain to govern by the aid of Ministers of her +own choice. Her popularity had vanished away. The scandals of her private +life gave just offence to the nation, and fatally weakened her political +authority. Forced by insurrection to bestow office on Espartero, as the +chief of the Progressist party, she found that the concessions demanded by +this general were more than she could grant, and in preference to +submitting to them she resigned the Regency, and quitted Spain (Oct., +1840). Espartero, after some interval, was himself appointed Regent by the +Cortes. For two years he maintained himself in power, then in his turn he +fell before the combined attack of his political opponents and the extreme +men of his own party, and passed into exile. There remained in Spain no +single person qualified to fill the vacant Regency, and in default of all +other expedients the young princess Isabella, who was now in her fourteenth +year, was declared of full age, and placed on the throne (Nov., 1843). +Christina returned to Madrid. After some rapid changes of Ministry, a more +durable Government was formed from the Moderado party under General +Narvaez; and in comparison with the period that had just ended, the first +few years of the new reign were years of recovery and order. + +[War between Mehemet Ali and the Porte, 1832.] + +The withdrawal of Louis Philippe from his engagements after the +capitulation of Maria Christina to the soldiery at La Granja in 1836 had +diminished the confidence placed in the King by the British Ministry; but +it had not destroyed the relations of friendship existing between the two +Governments. Far more serious causes of difference arose out of the course +of events in the East, and the extension of the power of Mehemet Ali, +Viceroy of Egypt. The struggle between Mehemet and his sovereign, long +foreseen, broke out in the year 1832. After the establishment of the +Hellenic Kingdom, the island of Crete had been given to Mehemet in return +for his services to the Ottoman cause by land and sea. This concession, +however, was far from satisfying the ambition of the Viceroy, and a quarrel +with Abdallah, Pasha of Acre, gave him the opportunity of throwing an army +into Palestine without directly rebelling against his sovereign (Nov., +1831). Ibrahim, in command of his father's forces, laid siege to Acre; and +had this fortress at once fallen, it would probably have been allowed by +the Sultan to remain in its conqueror's hands as an addition to his own +province, since the Turkish army was not ready for war, and it was no +uncommon thing in the Ottoman Empire for one provincial governor to possess +himself of territory at the expense of another. So obstinate, however, was +the defence of Acre that time was given to the Porte to make preparations +for war; and in the spring of 1832, after the issue of a proclamation +declaring Mehemet and his son to be rebels, a Turkish army led by Hussein +Pasha entered Syria. + +[Ibrahim conquers Syria and Asia Minor.] + +Ibrahim, while the siege of Acre was proceeding, had overrun the +surrounding country. He was now in possession of all the interior of +Palestine, and the tribes of Lebanon had joined him in the expectation of +gaining relief from the burdens of Turkish misgovernment. The fall of Acre, +while the relieving army was still near Antioch, enabled him to throw his +full strength against his opponent in the valley of the Orontes. It was the +intention of the Turkish general, whose forces, though superior in number, +had not the European training of Ibrahim's regiments, to meet the assault +of the Egyptians in an entrenched camp near Hama. The commander of the +vanguard, however, pushed forward beyond this point, and when far in +advance of the main body of the army was suddenly attacked by Ibrahim at +Homs. Taken at a moment of complete disorder, the Turks were put to the +rout. Their overthrow and flight so alarmed the general-in-chief that he +determined to fall back upon Aleppo, leaving Antioch and all the valley of +the Orontes to the enemy. Aleppo was reached, but the governor, won over by +Ibrahim, closed the gates of the city against the famishing army, and +forced Hussein to continue his retreat to the mountains which form the +barrier between Syria and Cilicia. Here, at the pass of Beilan, he was +attacked by Ibrahim, outmanoeuvred, and forced to retreat with heavy loss +(July 29). The pursuit was continued through the province of Cilicia. +Hussein's army, now completely demoralised, made its escape to the centre +of Asia Minor; the Egyptian, after advancing as far as Mount Taurus and +occupying the passes in this range, took up his quarters in the conquered +country in order to refresh his army and to await reinforcements. After two +months' halt he renewed his march, crossed Mount Taurus and occupied +Konieh, the capital of this district. Here the last and decisive blow was +struck. A new Turkish army, led by Reschid Pasha, Ibrahim's colleague in +the siege of Missolonghi, advanced from the north. Against his own advice, +Reschid was compelled by orders from Constantinople to risk everything in +an engagement. He attacked Ibrahim at Konieh on the 21st of December, and +was completely defeated. Reschid himself was made a prisoner; his army +dispersed; the last forces of the Sultan were exhausted, and the road to +the Bosphorus lay open before the Egyptian invader. + +[Russian aid offered to the Sultan.] + +[Peace of Kutaya, April, 1833.] + +In this extremity the Sultan looked around for help; nor were offers of +assistance wanting. The Emperor Nicholas had since the Treaty of Adrianople +assumed the part of the magnanimous friend; his belief was that the Ottoman +Empire might by judicious management and without further conquest be +brought into a state of habitual dependence upon Russia; and before the +result of the battle of Konieh was known General Muravieff had arrived at +Constantinople bringing the offer of Russian help both by land and sea, and +tendering his own personal services in the restoration of peace. Mahmud had +to some extent been won over by the Czar's politic forbearance in the +execution of the Treaty of Adrianople. His hatred of Mehemet Ali was a +consuming passion; and in spite of the general conviction both of his +people and of his advisers that no possible concession to a rebellious +vassal could be so fatal as the protection of the hereditary enemy of +Islam, he was disposed to accept the Russian tender of assistance. As a +preliminary, Muravieff was sent to Alexandria with permission to cede Acre +to Mehemet Ali, if in return the Viceroy would make over his fleet to the +Sultan. These were conditions on which no reasonable man could have +expected that Mehemet would make peace; and the intention of the Russian +Court probably was that Muravieff's mission should fail. The envoy soon +returned to Constantinople announcing that his terms were rejected. Mahmud +now requested that Russian ships might be sent to the Bosphorus, and to the +dismay of the French and English embassies a Russian squadron appeared +before the capital. Admiral Roussin, the French ambassador, addressed a +protest to the Sultan and threatened to leave Constantinople. His +remonstrances induced Mahmud to consent to some more serious negotiation +being opened with Mehemet Ali. A French envoy was authorised to promise the +Viceroy the governorship of Tripoli in Syria as well as Acre; his +overtures, however, were not more acceptable than those of Muravieff, and +Mehemet openly declared that if peace were not concluded on his own terms +within six weeks, he should order Ibrahim, who had halted at Kutaya, to +continue his march on the Bosphorus. Thoroughly alarmed at this threat, and +believing that no Turkish force could keep Ibrahim out of the capital, +Mahmud applied to Russia for more ships and also for troops. Again Admiral +Roussin urged upon the Sultan that if Syria could be reconquered only by +Russian forces it was more than lost to the Porte. His arguments were +supported by the Divan, and with such effect that a French diplomatist was +sent to Ibrahim with power to negotiate for peace on any terms. +Preliminaries were signed at Kutaya under French mediation on the 10th of +April, 1833, by which the Sultan made over to his vassal not only the whole +of Syria but the province of Adana which lies between Mount Taurus and the +Mediterranean. After some delay these Preliminaries were ratified by +Mahmud; and Ibrahim, after his dazzling success both in war and in +diplomacy, commenced the evacuation of northern Anatolia. + +[Treaty of Unkiar Skelessi, July, 1833.] + +For the moment it appeared that French influence had decisively prevailed +at Constantinople, and that the troops of the Czar had been summoned from +Sebastopol only to be dismissed with the ironical compliments of those who +were most anxious to get rid of them. But this was not really the case. +Whether the fluctuations in the Sultan's policy had been due to mere fear +and irresolution, or whether they had to some extent proceeded from the +desire to play off one Power against another, it was to Russia, not France, +that his final confidence was given. The soldiers of the Czar were encamped +by the side of the Turks on the eastern shore of the Bosphorus; his ships +lay below Constantinople. Here on the 8th of July a Treaty was signed at +the palace of Unkiar Skelessi, [401] in which Russia and Turkey entered +into a defensive alliance of the most intimate character, each Power +pledging itself to render assistance to the other, not only against the +attack of an external enemy, but in every event where its peace and +security might be endangered. Russia undertook, in cases where its support +should be required, to provide whatever amount of troops the Sultan should +consider necessary both by sea and land, the Porte being charged with no +part of the expense beyond that of the provisioning of the troops. The +duration of the Treaty was fixed in the first instance for eight years. A +secret article, which, however, was soon afterwards published, declared +that, in order to diminish the burdens of the Porte, the Czar would not +demand the material help to which the Treaty entitled him; while, in +substitution for such assistance, the Porte undertook, when Russia should +be at war, to close the Dardanelles to the war-ships of all nations. + +[Effect of this Treaty.] + +By the Treaty of Unkiar Skelessi, Russia came nearer than it has at any +time before or since to that complete ascendency at Constantinople which +has been the modern object of its policy. The success of its diplomatists +had in fact been too great; for, if the abstract right of the Sultan to +choose his own allies had not yet been disputed by Europe at large, the +clause in the Treaty which related to the Dardanelles touched the interests +of every Power which possessed a naval station in the Mediterranean. By the +public law of Europe the Black Sea, which until the eighteenth century was +encompassed entirely by the Sultan's territory, formed no part of the open +waters of the world, but a Turkish lake to which access was given through +the Dardanelles only at the pleasure of the Porte. When, in the eighteenth +century, Russia gained a footing on the northern shore of the Euxine, this +carried with it no right to send war-ships through the straits into the +Mediterranean, nor had any Power at war with Russia the right to send a +fleet into the Black Sea otherwise than by the Sultan's consent. The Treaty +of Unkiar Skelessi, in making Turkey the ally of Russia against all its +enemies, converted the entrance to the Black Sea into a Russian fortified +post, from behind which Russia could freely send forth its ships of war +into the Mediterranean, while its own ports and arsenals remained secure +against attack. England and France, which were the States whose interests +were principally affected, protested against the Treaty, and stated they +reserved to themselves the right of taking such action in regard to it as +occasion might demand. Nor did the opposition rest with the protests of +diplomatists. The attention both of the English nation and of its +Government was drawn far more than hitherto to the future of the Ottoman +Empire. Political writers exposed with unwearied vigour, and not without +exaggeration, the designs of the Court of St. Petersburg in Asia as well as +in Europe; and to this time, rather than to any earlier period, belongs the +first growth of that strong national antagonism to Russia which found its +satisfaction in the Crimean War, and which has by no means lost its power +at the present day. + +[France and Mehemet Ali.] + +In desiring to check the extension of Russia's influence in the Levant, +Great Britain and France were at one. The lines of policy, however, +followed by these two States were widely divergent. Great Britain sought to +maintain the Sultan's power in its integrity; France became in an +increasing degree the patron and the friend of Mehemet Ali. Since the +expedition of Napoleon to Egypt in 1798, which was itself the execution of +a design formed in the reign of Louis XVI., Egypt had largely retained its +hold on the imagination of the leading classes in France. Its monuments, +its relics of a mighty past, touched a livelier chord among French men of +letters and science than India has at any time found among ourselves; and +although the hope of national conquest vanished with Napoleon's overthrow, +Egypt continued to afford a field of enterprise to many a civil and +military adventurer. Mehemet's army and navy were organised by French +officers; he was surrounded by French agents and men of business; and after +the conquest of Algiers had brought France on to the southern shore of the +Mediterranean, the advantages of a close political relation with Egypt did +not escape the notice of statesmen who saw in Gibraltar and Malta the most +striking evidences of English maritime power. Moreover the personal fame of +Mehemet strongly affected French opinion. His brilliant military reforms, +his vigorous administration, and his specious achievements in finance +created in the minds of those who were too far off to know the effects of +his tyranny the belief that at the hands of this man the East might yet +awaken to new life. Thus, from a real conviction of the superiority of +Mehemet's rule over that of the House of Osman no less than from +considerations of purely national policy, the French Government, without +any public or official bond of union, gradually became the acknowledged +supporters of the Egyptian conqueror, and connected his interests with +their own. + +[Rule of Mehemet and Ibrahim.] + +Sultan Mahmud had ratified the Preliminaries of Kutaya with wrath in his +heart; and from this time all his energies were bent upon the creation of a +force which should wrest back the lost provinces and take revenge upon his +rebellious vassal. As eager as Mehemet himself to reconstruct his form of +government upon the models of the West, though far less capable of +impressing upon his work the stamp of a single guiding will, thwarted +moreover by the jealous interference of Russia whenever his reforms seemed +likely to produce any important result, he nevertheless succeeded in +introducing something of European system and discipline into his army under +the guidance of foreign soldiers, among whom was a man then little known, +but destined long afterwards to fill Europe with his fame, the Prussian +staff-officer Moltke. On the other side Mehemet and Ibrahim knew well that +the peace was no more than an armed truce, and that what had been won by +arms could only be maintained by constant readiness to meet attack. Under +pressure of this military necessity, Ibrahim sacrificed whatever sources of +strength were open to him in the hatred borne by his new subjects to the +Turkish yoke, and in their hopes of relief from oppression under his own +rule. Welcomed at first as a deliverer, he soon proved a heavier +task-master than any who had gone before him. The conscription was +rigorously enforced; taxation became more burdensome; the tribes who had +enjoyed a wild independence in the mountains were disarmed and reduced to +the level of their fellow-subjects. Thus the discontent which had so +greatly facilitated the conquest of the border-provinces soon turned +against the conqueror himself, and one uprising after another shook +Ibrahim's hold upon Mount Lebanon and the Syrian desert. The Sultan watched +each outbreak against his adversary with grim joy, impatient for the moment +when the re-organisation of his own forces should enable him to re-enter +the field and to strike an overwhelming blow. + +[The commerce of the Levant.] + +With all its characteristics of superior intelligence in the choice of +means, the system of Mehemet All was in its end that of the genuine +Oriental despot. His final object was to convert as many as possible of his +subjects into soldiers, and to draw into his treasury the profits of the +labour of all the rest. With this aim he gradually ousted from their rights +of proprietorship the greater part of the land-owners of Egypt, and finally +proclaimed the entire soil to be State-domain, appropriating at prices +fixed by himself the whole of its produce. The natural commercial +intercourse of his dominions gave place to a system of monopolies carried +on by the Government itself. Rapidly as this system, which was introduced +into the newly-conquered provinces, filled the coffers of Mehemet Ali, it +offered to the Sultan, whose paramount authority was still acknowledged, +the means of inflicting a deadly injury upon him by a series of commercial +treaties with the European Powers, granting to western traders a free +market throughout the Ottoman Empire. Resistance to such a measure would +expose Mehemet to the hostility of the whole mercantile interest of Europe; +submission to it would involve the loss of a great part of that revenue on +which his military power depended. It was probably with this result in +view, rather than from any more obvious motive, that in the year 1838 the +Sultan concluded a new commercial Treaty with England, which was soon +followed by similar agreements with other States. + +[Campaign of Nissib, June, 1839.] + +The import of the Sultan's commercial policy was not lost upon Mehemet, who +had already determined to declare himself independent. He saw that war was +inevitable, and bade Ibrahim collect his forces in the neighbourhood of +Aleppo, while the generals of the Sultan massed on the upper Euphrates the +troops that had been successfully employed in subduing the wild tribes of +Kurdistan. The storm was seen to be gathering, and the representatives of +foreign Powers urged the Sultan, but in vain, to refrain from an enterprise +which might shatter his empire. Mahmud was now a dying man. Exhausted by +physical excess and by the stress and passion of his long reign, he bore in +his heart the same unquenchable hatreds as of old; and while assuring the +ambassadors of his intention to maintain the peace, he despatched a letter +to his commander-in-chief, without the knowledge of any single person, +ordering him to commence hostilities. The Turkish army crossed the frontier +on the 23rd of May, 1839. In the operations which followed, the advice and +protests of Moltke and the other European officers at head-quarters were +persistently disregarded. The Turks were outmanoeuvred and cut off from +their communications, and on the 24th of June the onslaught of Ibrahim +swept them from their position at Nissib in utter rout. The whole of their +artillery and stores fell into the hands of the enemy: the army dispersed. +Mahmud did not live to hear of the catastrophe. Six days after the battle +of Nissib was fought, and while the messenger who bore the news was still +in Anatolia, he expired, leaving the throne to his son, Abdul Medjid, a +youth of sixteen. Scarcely had the new Sultan been proclaimed when it +became known that the Admiral, Achmet Fewzi, who had been instructed to +attack the Syrian coast, had sailed into the port of Alexandria, and handed +over the Turkish fleet to Mehemet Ali himself. + +[Relations of the Powers to Mehemet.] + +[Quadruple Treaty without France. July, 1840.] + +The very suddenness of these disasters, which left the Ottoman Empire +rulerless and without defence by land or sea, contributed ultimately to its +preservation, inasmuch as it impelled the Powers to combined action, which, +under less urgent pressure, would probably not have been attainable. On the +announcement of the exorbitant conditions of peace demanded by Mehemet, the +ambassadors addressed a collective note to the Divan, requesting that no +answer might be made until the Courts had arrived at some common +resolution. Soon afterwards the French and English fleets appeared at the +Dardanelles, nominally to protect Constantinople against the attack of the +Viceroy, in reality to guard against any sudden movement on the part of +Russia. This display of force was, however, not necessary, for the Czar, in +spite of some expressions to the contrary, had already convinced himself +that it was impossible to act upon the Treaty of Unkiar Skelessi and to +make the protectorate of Turkey the affair of Russia alone. The tone which +had been taken by the English Government during the last preceding years +proved that any attempt to exercise exclusive power at Constantinople would +have been followed by war with Great Britain, in which most, if not all, of +the European Powers would have stood on the side of the latter. Abandoning +therefore the hope of attaining sole control, the Russian Government +addressed itself to the task of widening as far as possible the existing +divergence between England and France. Nor was this difficult. The Cabinet +of the Tuileries desired to see Mehemet Ali issue with increased strength +from the conflict, or even to establish his dynasty at Constantinople in +place of the House of Osman. Lord Palmerston, always jealous and suspicious +of Louis Philippe, refused to believe that the growth of Russian power +could be checked by dividing the Ottoman Empire, or that any system of +Eastern policy could be safely based on the personal qualities of a ruler +now past his seventieth year. [402] He had moreover his own causes of +discontent with Mehemet. The possibility of establishing an overland route +to India either by way of the Euphrates or of the Red Sea had lately been +engaging the attention of the English Government, and Mehemet had not +improved his position by raising obstacles to either line of passage. It +was partly in consequence of the hostility of Mehemet, who was now master +of a great part of Arabia, and of his known devotion to French interests, +that the port of Aden in the Red Sea was at this time occupied by England. +If, while Russia accepted the necessity of combined European action and +drew nearer to its rival, France persisted in maintaining the claim of +the Viceroy to extended dominion, the exclusion of France from the +European concert was the only possible result. There was no doubt as to +the attitude of the remaining Powers. Metternich, whether from genuine +pedantry, or in order to avoid the expression of those fears of Russia +which really governed his Eastern policy, repeated his threadbare +platitudes on the necessity of supporting legitimate dynasties against +rebels, and spoke of the victor of Konieh and Nissib as if he had been a +Spanish constitutionalist or a recalcitrant German professor. The Court +of Berlin followed in the same general course. In all Europe Mehemet Ali +had not a single ally, with the exception of the Government of Louis +Philippe. Under these circumstances it was of little avail to the Viceroy +that his army stood on Turkish soil without a foe before it, and that the +Sultan's fleet lay within his own harbour of Alexandria. The intrigues by +which he hoped to snatch a hasty peace from the inexperience of the young +Sultan failed, and he learnt in October that no arrangement which he +might make with the Porte without the concurrence of the Powers would be +recognised as valid. In the meantime Russia was suggesting to the English +Government one project after another for joint military action with the +object of driving Mehemet from Syria and restoring this province to the +Porte; and at the beginning of the following year it was determined on +Metternich's proposition that a Conference should forthwith be held in +London for the settlement of Eastern affairs. The irreconcilable +difference between the intentions of France and those of the other Powers +at once became evident. France proposed that all Syria and Egypt should +be given in hereditary dominion to Mehemet Ali, with no further +obligation towards the Porte than the payment of a yearly tribute. The +counter-proposal of England was that Mehemet, recognising the Sultan's +authority, should have the hereditary government of Egypt alone, that he +should entirely withdraw from all Northern Syria, and hold Palestine only +as an ordinary governor appointed by the Porte for his lifetime. To this +proposition all the Powers with the exception of France gave their +assent. Continued negotiation only brought into stronger relief the +obstinacy of Lord Palmerston, and proved the impossibility of attaining +complete agreement. At length, when it had been discovered that the +French Cabinet was attempting to conduct a separate mediation, the Four +Powers, without going through the form of asking for French sanction, +signed on the 15th of July a Treaty with the Sultan pledging themselves +to enforce upon Mehemet Ali the terms arranged. The Sultan undertook in +the first instance to offer Mehemet Egypt in perpetuity and southern +Syria for his lifetime. If this offer was not accepted within ten days, +Egypt alone was to be offered. If at the end of twenty days Mehemet still +remained obstinate, that offer in its turn was to be withdrawn, and the +Sultan and the Allies were to take such measures as the interests of the +Ottoman Empire might require. [403] + +[Warlike spirit in France, 1840.] + +The publication of this Treaty, excluding France as it did from the concert +of Europe, produced a storm of indignation at Paris. Thiers, who more than +any man had by his writings stimulated the spirit of aggressive warfare +among the French people and revived the worship of Napoleon, was now at the +head of the Government. His jealousy for the prestige of France, his +comparative indifference to other matters when once the national honour +appeared to be committed, his sanguine estimate of the power of his +country, rendered him a peculiarly dangerous Minister at the existing +crisis. It was not the wrongs or the danger of Mehemet Ali, but the slight +offered to France, and the revived League of the Powers which had humbled +it in 1814, that excited the passion of the Minister and the nation. Syria +was forgotten; the cry was for the recovery of the frontier of the Rhine, +and for revenge for Waterloo. New regiments were enrolled, the fleet +strengthened, and the long-delayed fortification of Paris begun. Thiers +himself probably looked forward to a campaign in Italy, anticipating that +successfully conducted by Napoleon III. in 1859, rather than to an attack +upon Prussia; but the general opinion both in France itself and in other +states was that, if war should break out, an invasion of Germany was +inevitable. The prospect of this invasion roused in a manner little +expected the spirit of the German people. Even in the smaller states, and +in the Rhenish provinces themselves, which for twenty years had shared the +fortunes of France, and in which the introduction of Prussian rule in 1814 +had been decidedly unpopular, a strong national movement carried everything +before it; and the year 1840 added to the patriotic minstrelsy of Germany a +war-song, written by a Rhenish citizen, not less famous than those of 1813 +and 1870. [404] That there were revolutionary forces smouldering throughout +Europe, from which France might in a general war have gained some +assistance, the events of 1848 sufficiently proved; but to no single +Government would a revolutionary war have been fraught with more imminent +peril than to that of France itself, and to no one was this conviction more +habitually present than to King Louis Philippe. Relying upon his influence +within the Chamber of Deputies, itself a body representing the wealth and +the caution rather than the hot spirit of France, the King refused to read +at the opening of the session in October the speech drawn up for him by +Thiers, and accepted the consequent resignation of the Ministry. Guizot, +who was ambassador in London, and an advocate for submission to the will of +Europe, was called to office, and succeeded after long debate in gaining a +vote of confidence from the Chamber. Though preparations for war continued, +a policy of peace was now assured. Mehemet Ali was left to his fate; and +the stubborn assurance of Lord Palmerston, which had caused so much +annoyance to the English Ministry itself, received a striking justification +in the face of all Europe. + +[Ibrahim expelled from Syria, Sept.-Nov., 1840.] + +[Final settlement, Feb., 1841.] + +[The Dardanelles.] + +The operations of the Allies against Mehemet Ali had now begun. While +Prussia kept guard on the Rhine, and Russia undertook to protect +Constantinople against any forward movement of Ibrahim, an Anglo-Austrian +naval squadron combined with a Turkish land-force in attacking the Syrian +coast-towns. The mountain-tribes of the interior were again in revolt. Arms +supplied to them by the Allies, and the insurrection soon spread over the +greater part of Syria. Ibrahim prepared for an obstinate defence, but his +dispositions were frustrated by the extension of the area of conflict, and +he was unable to prevent the coast-towns from falling one after another +into the hands of the Allies. On the capture of Acre by Sir Charles Napier +he abandoned all hope of maintaining himself any longer in Syria, and made +his way with the wreck of his army towards the Egyptian frontier. Napier +had already arrived before Alexandria, and there executed a convention with +the Viceroy, by which the latter, abandoning all claim upon his other +provinces, and undertaking to restore the Turkish fleet, was assured of the +hereditary possession of Egypt. The convention was one which the English +admiral had no authority to conclude, but it contained substantially the +terms which the Allies intended to enforce; and after Mehemet had made a +formal act of submission to the Sultan, the hereditary government of Egypt +was conferred upon himself and his family by a decree published by the +Sultan and sanctioned by the Powers. This compromise had been proposed by +the French Government after the expiry of the twenty days named in the +Treaty of July, and immediately before the fall of M. Thiers, but +Palmerston would not then listen to any demand made under open or implied +threats of war. Since that time a new and pacific Ministry had come into +office; it was no part of Palmerston's policy to keep alive the antagonism +between England and France; and he readily accepted an arrangement which, +while it saved France from witnessing the total destruction of an ally, +left Egypt to a ruler who, whatever his faults, had certainly shown a +greater capacity for government than any Oriental of that age. It remained +for the Powers to place upon record some authoritative statement of the law +recognised by Europe with regard to the Bosphorus and Dardanelles. Russia +had already virtually consented to the abrogation of the Treaty of Unkiar +Skelessi. It now joined with all the other Powers, including France, in a +declaration that the ancient rule of the Ottoman Empire which forbade the +passage of these straits to the war-ships of all nations, except when the +Porte itself should be at war, was accepted by Europe at large. Russia thus +surrendered its chance of gaining by any separate arrangement with Turkey +the permanent right of sending its fleets from the Black Sea into the +Mediterranean, and so becoming a Mediterranean Power. On the other hand, +Sebastopol and the arsenals of the Euxine remained safe against the attack +of any maritime Power, unless Turkey itself should take up arms against the +Czar. Having regard to the great superiority of England over Russia at sea, +and to the accessibility and importance of the Euxine coast towns, it is an +open question whether the removal of all international restrictions upon +the passage of the Bosphorus and Dardanelles would not be more to the +advantage of England than of its rival. This opinion, however, had not been +urged before the Crimean War, nor has it yet been accepted in our own +country. + +[Turkey after 1840.] + +[Legislation of Reschid.] + +The conclusion of the struggle of 1840 marked with great definiteness the +real position which the Ottoman Empire was henceforth to occupy in its +relations to the western world. Rescued by Europe at large from the +alternatives of destruction at the hands of Ibrahim or complete vassalage +under Russia, the Porte entered upon the condition nominally of an +independent European State, really of a State existing under the protection +of Europe, and responsible to Europe as well for its domestic government as +for its alliances and for the conduct of its foreign policy. The necessity +of conciliating the public opinion of the West was well understood by the +Turkish statesman who had taken the leading part in the negotiations which +freed the Porte from dependence upon Russia. Reschid Pasha, the younger, +Foreign Minister at the accession of the new Sultan, had gained in an +unusual degree the regard and the confidence of the European Ministers with +whom, as a diplomatist, he had been brought into contact. As the author of +a wide system of reforms, it was his ambition so to purify and renovate the +internal administration of the Ottoman Empire that the contrasts which it +presented to the civilised order of the West should gradually disappear, +and that Turkey should become not only in name but in reality a member of +the European world. Stimulated no doubt by the achievements of Mehemet Ali, +and anxious to win over to the side of the Porte the interest which +Mehemet's partial adoption of European methods and ideas had excited on his +behalf, Reschid in his scheme of reform paid an ostentatious homage to the +principles of western administration and law, proclaiming the security of +person and property, prohibiting the irregular infliction of punishment, +recognising the civil rights of Christians and Jews, and transferring the +collection of taxes from the provincial governors to the officers of the +central authority. The friends of the Ottoman State, less experienced then +than now in the value of laws made in a society where there exists no power +that can enforce them, and where the agents of government are themselves +the most lawless of all the public enemies, hailed in Reschid's enlightened +legislation the opening of a new epoch in the life of the Christian and +Oriental races subject to the Sultan. But the fall of the Minister before a +palace-intrigue soon proved on how slight a foundation these hopes were +built. Like other Turkish reformers, Reschid had entered upon a hopeless +task; and the name of the man who was once honoured as the regenerator of a +great Empire is now almost forgotten. + + + + +CHAPTER XVIII. + + +Europe during the Thirty-years' Peace--Italy and Austria--Mazzini--The +House of Savoy--Gioberti--Election of Pius IX.--Reforms expected-- +Revolution at Palermo--Agitation in Northern Italy--Lombardy--State of +the Austrian Empire--Growth of Hungarian National Spirit--The Magyars and +Slavs--Transylvania--Parties among the Magyars--Kossuth--The Slavic +National Movements in Austria--The Government enters on Reform in +Hungary--Policy of the Opposition--The Rural System of Austria-- +Insurrection in Galicia: the Nobles and the Peasants--Agrarian +Edict--Public Opinion in Vienna--Prussia--Accession and Character of King +Frederick William IV.--Convocation of the United Diet--Its Debates and +Dissolution--France--The Spanish Marriages--Reform Movement--Socialism-- +Revolution of February--End of the Orleanist Monarchy. + + +The characteristic of Continental history during the second quarter of this +century is the sense of unrest. The long period of European peace which +began in 1815 was not one of internal repose; the very absence of those +engrossing and imperious interests which belong to a time of warfare gave +freer play to the feelings of discontent and the vague longings for a +better political order which remained behind after the convulsions of the +revolutionary epoch and the military rule of Napoleon had passed away. +During thirty years of peace the breach had been widening between those +Governments which still represented the system of 1815, and the peoples +over whom they ruled. Ideas of liberty, awakenings of national sense, were +far more widely diffused in Europe than at the time of the revolutionary +war. The seed then prematurely forced into an atmosphere of storm and +reaction had borne its fruit: other growths, fertilised or accelerated by +Western Liberalism, but not belonging to the same family, were springing up +in unexpected strength, and in regions which had hitherto lain outside the +movement of the modern world. New forces antagonistic to Government had +come into being, penetrating an area unaffected by the constitutional +struggles of the Mediterranean States, or by the weaker political efforts +of Germany. In the homes of the Magyar and the Slavic subjects of Austria, +so torpid throughout the agitation of an earlier time, the passion of +nationality was every hour gaining new might. The older popular causes, +vanquished for the moment by one reaction after another, had silently +established a far stronger hold on men's minds. Working, some in exile and +conspiracy, others through such form of political literature as the +jealousy of Governments permitted, the leaders of the democratic movement +upon the Continent created a power before which the established order at +length succumbed. They had not created, nor was it possible under the +circumstances that they should create, an order which was capable of taking +its place. + +[Italy. 1831-1848.] + +Italy, rather than France, forms the central figure in any retrospect of +Europe immediately before 1848 in which the larger forces at work are not +obscured by those for the moment more prominent. The failure of the +insurrection of 1831 had left Austria more visibly than before master over +the Italian people even in those provinces in which Austria was not +nominally sovereign. It had become clear that no effort after reform could +be successful either in the Papal States or in the kingdom of Naples so +long as Austria held Lombardy and Venice. The expulsion of the foreigner +was therefore not merely the task of those who sought to give the Italian +race its separate and independent national existence, it was the task of +all who would extinguish oppression and misgovernment in any part of the +Italian peninsula. Until the power of Austria was broken, it was vain to +take up arms against the tyranny of the Duke of Modena or any other +contemptible oppressor. Austria itself had twice taught this lesson; and if +the restoration of Neapolitan despotism in 1821 could be justified by the +disorderly character of the Government then suppressed, the circumstances +attending the restoration of the Pope's authority in 1831 had extinguished +Austria's claim to any sort of moral respect; for Metternich himself had +united with the other European Courts in declaring the necessity for +reforms in the Papal Government, and of these reforms, though a single +earnest word from Austria would have enforced their execution, not one had +been carried into effect. Gradually, but with increasing force as each +unhappy year passed by, the conviction gained weight among all men of +serious thought that the problem to be faced was nothing less than the +destruction of the Austrian yoke. Whether proclaimed as an article of faith +or veiled in diplomatic reserve, this belief formed the common ground among +men whose views on the immediate future of Italy differed in almost every +other particular. + +[Mazzini.] + +Three main currents of opinion are to be traced in the ferment of ideas +which preceded the Italian revolution of 1848. At a time not rich in +intellectual or in moral power, the most striking figure among those who +are justly honoured as the founders of Italian independence is perhaps that +of Mazzini. Exiled during nearly the whole of his mature life, a +conspirator in the eyes of all Governments, a dreamer in the eyes of the +world, Mazzini was a prophet or an evangelist among those whom his +influence led to devote themselves to the one cause of their country's +regeneration. No firmer faith, no nobler disinterestedness, ever animated +the saint or the patriot; and if in Mazzini there was also something of the +visionary and the fanatic, the force with which he grasped the two vital +conditions of Italian revival--the expulsion of the foreigner and the +establishment of a single national Government--proves him to have been a +thinker of genuine political insight. Laying the foundation of his creed +deep in the moral nature of man, and constructing upon this basis a fabric +not of rights but of duties, he invested the political union with the +immediateness, the sanctity, and the beauty of family life. With him, to +live, to think, to hope, was to live, to think, to hope for Italy; and the +Italy of his ideal was a Republic embracing every member of the race, +purged of the priestcraft and the superstition which had degraded the man +to the slave, indebted to itself alone for its independence, and +consolidated by the reign of equal law. The rigidity with which Mazzini +adhered to his own great project in its completeness, and his impatience +with any bargaining away of national rights, excluded him from the work of +those practical politicians and men of expedients who in 1859 effected with +foreign aid the first step towards Italian union; but the influence of his +teaching and his organisation in preparing his countrymen for independence +was immense; and the dynasty which has rendered to United Italy services +which Mazzini thought impossible, owes to this great Republican scarcely +less than to its ablest friends. + +[Hopes of Piedmont.] + +Widely separated from the school of Mazzini in temper and intention was the +group of politicians and military men, belonging mostly to Piedmont, who +looked to the sovereign and the army of this State as the one hope of Italy +in its struggle against foreign rule. The House of Savoy, though foreign in +its origin, was, and had been for centuries, a really national dynasty. It +was, moreover, by interest and traditional policy, the rival rather than +the friend of Austria in Northern Italy. If the fear of revolution had at +times brought the Court of Turin into close alliance with Vienna, the +connection had but thinly veiled the lasting antagonism of two States +which, as neighbours, had habitually sought expansion each at the other's +cost. Lombardy, according to the expression of an older time, was the +artichoke which the Kings of Piedmont were destined to devour leaf by leaf. +Austria, on the other hand, sought extension towards the Alps: it had in +1799 clearly shown its intention of excluding the House of Savoy altogether +from the Italian mainland; and the remembrance of this epoch had led the +restored dynasty in 1815 to resist the plans of Metternich for establishing +a league of all the princes of Italy under Austria's protection. The +sovereign, moreover, who after the failure of the constitutional movement +of 1821 had mounted the throne surrounded by Austrian bayonets, was no +longer alive. Charles Albert of Carignano, who had at that time played so +ambiguous a part, and whom Metternich had subsequently endeavoured to +exclude from the succession, was on the throne. He had made his peace with +absolutism by fighting in Spain against the Cortes in 1823; and since his +accession to the throne he had rigorously suppressed the agitation of +Mazzini's partizans within his own dominions. But in spite of strong +clerical and reactionary influences around him, he had lately shown an +independence of spirit in his dealings with Austria which raised him in the +estimation of his subjects; and it was believed that his opinions had been +deeply affected by the predominance which the idea of national independence +was now gaining over that of merely democratic change. If the earlier +career of Charles Albert himself cast some doubt upon his personal +sincerity, and much more upon his constancy of purpose, there was at least +in Piedmont an army thoroughly national in its sentiment, and capable of +taking the lead whenever the opportunity should arise for uniting Italy +against the foreigner. In no other Italian State was there an effective +military force, or one so little adulterated with foreign elements. + +[Hopes of the Papacy.] + +A third current of opinion in these years of hope and of illusion was that +represented in the writings of Gioberti, the depicter of a new and glorious +Italy, regenerated not by philosophic republicanism or the sword of a +temporal monarch, but by the moral force of a reformed and reforming +Papacy. The conception of the Catholic Church as a great Liberal power, +strange and fantastic as it now appears, was no dream of an isolated +Italian enthusiast; it was an idea which, after the French Revolution of +1830, and the establishment of a government at once anti-clerical and +anti-democratic, powerfully influenced some of the best minds in France, +and found in Montalembert and Lamennais exponents who commanded the ear of +Europe. If the corruption of the Papacy had been at once the spiritual and +the political death of Italy, its renovation in purity and in strength +would be also the resurrection of the Italian people. Other lands had +sought, and sought in vain, to work out their problems under the guidance +of leaders antagonistic to the Church, and of popular doctrines divorced +from religious faith. To Italy belonged the prerogative of spiritual power. +By this power, aroused from the torpor of ages, and speaking, as it had +once spoken, to the very conscience of mankind, the gates of a glorious +future would be thrown open. Conspirators might fret, and politicians +scheme, but the day on which the new life of Italy would begin would be +that day when the head of the Church, taking his place as chief of a +federation of Italian States, should raise the banner of freedom and +national right, and princes and people alike should follow the +all-inspiring voice. + +[Election of Pius IX., June, 1846.] + +[Reforms expected from Pius.] + +[Ferrara, June, 1847.] + +A monk, ignorant of everything but cloister lore, benighted, tyrannical, +the companion in his private life of a few jolly priests and a gossiping +barber, was not an alluring emblem of the Church of the future. But in 1846 +Pope Gregory XVI., who for the last five years had been engaged in one +incessant struggle against insurgents, conspirators, and reformers, and +whose prisons were crowded with the best of his subjects, passed away. +[405] His successor, Mastai Ferretti, Bishop of Imola, was elected under +the title of Pius IX., after the candidate favoured by Austria had failed +to secure the requisite number of votes (June 17). The choice of this +kindly and popular prelate was to some extent a tribute to Italian feeling; +and for the next eighteen months it appeared as it Gioberti had really +divined the secret of the age. The first act of the new Pope was the +publication of a universal amnesty for political offences. The prison doors +throughout his dominions were thrown open, and men who had been sentenced +to confinement for life returned in exultation to their homes. The act +created a profound impression throughout Italy, and each good-humoured +utterance of Pius confirmed the belief that great changes were at hand. A +wild enthusiasm seized upon Rome. The population abandoned itself to +festivals in honour of the Pontiff and of the approaching restoration of +Roman liberty. Little was done; not much was actually promised; everything +was believed. The principle of representative government was discerned in +the new Council of State now placed by the side of the College of +Cardinals; a more serious concession was made to popular feeling in the +permission given to the citizens of Rome, and afterwards to those of the +provinces, to enrol themselves in a civic guard. But the climax of +excitement was reached when, in answer to a threatening movement of +Austria, occasioned by the growing agitation throughout Central Italy, the +Papal Court protested against the action of its late protector. By the +Treaties of Vienna Austria had gained the right to garrison the citadel of +Ferrara, though this town lay within the Ecclesiastical States. Placing a +new interpretation on the expression used in the Treaties, the Austrian +Government occupied the town of Ferrara itself (June 17th, 1847). The +movement was universally understood to be the preliminary to a new +occupation of the Papal States, like that of 1831; and the protests of the +Pope against the violation of his territory gave to the controversy a +European importance. The English and French fleets appeared at Naples; the +King of Sardinia openly announced his intention to take the field against +Austria if war should break out. By the efforts of neutral Powers a +compromise on the occupation of Ferrara was at length arranged; but the +passions which had been excited were not appeased, and the Pope remained in +popular imagination the champion of Italian independence against Austria, +as well as the apostle of constitutional Government and the rights of the +people. + +[Revolution at Palermo, Jan., 1848.] + +In the meantime the agitation begun in Rome was spreading through the north +and the south of the peninsula, and beyond the Sicilian Straits. The +centenary of the expulsion of the Austrians from Genoa in December, 1746, +was celebrated throughout central Italy with popular demonstrations which +gave Austria warning of the storm about to burst upon it. In the south, +however, impatience under domestic tyranny was a far more powerful force +than the distant hope of national independence. Sicily had never forgotten +the separate rights which it had once enjoyed, and the constitution given +to it under the auspices of England in 1812. Communications passed between +the Sicilian leaders and the opponents of the Bourbon Government on the +mainland, and in the autumn of 1847 simultaneous risings took place in +Calabria and at Messina. These were repressed without difficulty; but the +fire smouldered far and wide, and on the 13th of January, 1848, the +population of Palermo rose in revolt. For fourteen days the conflict +between the people and the Neapolitan troops continued. The city was +bombarded, but in the end the people were victorious, and a provisional +government was formed by the leaders of the insurrection. One Sicilian town +after another followed the example of the capital, and expelled its +Neapolitan garrison. Threatened by revolution in Naples itself, King +Ferdinand II., grandson of the despot of 1821, now imitated the policy of +his predecessor, and proclaimed a constitution. A Liberal Ministry was +formed, but no word was said as to the autonomy claimed by Sicily, and +promised, as it would seem, by the leaders of the popular party on the +mainland. After the first excitement of success was past, it became clear +that the Sicilians were as widely at variance with the newly-formed +Government at Naples as with that which they had overthrown. + +[Agitation in Austrian Italy.] + +The insurrection of Palermo gave a new stimulus and imparted more of +revolutionary colour to the popular movement throughout Italy. +Constitutions were granted in Piedmont and Tuscany. In the Austrian +provinces national exasperation against the rule of the foreigner grew +daily more menacing. Radetzky, the Austrian Commander-in-chief, had long +foreseen the impending struggle, and had endeavoured, but not with complete +success, to impress his own views upon the imperial Government. Verona had +been made the centre of a great system of fortifications, and the strength +of the army under Radetzky's command had been considerably increased, but +it was not until the eleventh hour that Metternich abandoned the hope of +tiding over difficulties by his old system of police and spies, and +permitted the establishment of undisguised military rule. In order to +injure the finances of Austria, a general resolution had been made by the +patriotic societies of Upper Italy to abstain from the use of tobacco, from +which the Government drew a large part of its revenue. On the first Sunday +in 1848 Austrian officers, smoking in the streets of Milan, were attacked +by the people. The troops were called to arms: a conflict took place, and +enough blood was shed to give to the tumult the importance of an actual +revolt. In Padua and elsewhere similar outbreaks followed. Radetzky issued +a general order to his troops, declaring that the Emperor was determined to +defend his Italian dominion whether against an external or domestic foe. +Martial law was proclaimed; and for a moment, although Piedmont gave signs +of throwing itself into the Italian movement, the awe of Austria's military +power hushed the rising tempest. A few weeks more revealed to an astonished +world the secret that the Austrian State, so great and so formidable in the +eyes of friend and foe, was itself on the verge of dissolution. + +[Austria.] + +[Affairs in Hungary.] + +It was to the absence of all stirring public life, not to any real +assimilative power or any high intelligence in administration, that the +House of Hapsburg owed, during the eighteenth century, the continued union +of that motley of nations or races which successive conquests, marriages, +and treaties had brought under its dominion. The violence of the attack +made by the Emperor Joseph upon all provincial rights first re-awakened the +slumbering spirit of Hungary; but the national movement of that time, which +excited such strong hopes and alarms, had been succeeded by a long period +of stagnation, and during the Napoleonic wars the repression of everything +that appealed to any distinctively national spirit had become more avowedly +than before the settled principle of the Austrian Court. In 1812 the +Hungarian Diet had resisted the financial measures of the Government. The +consequence was that, in spite of the law requiring its convocation every +three years, the Diet was not again summoned till 1825. During the +intermediate period, the Emperor raised taxes and levies by edict alone. +Deprived of its constitutional representation, the Hungarian nobility +pursued its opposition to the encroachments of the Crown in the Sessions of +each county. At these assemblies, to which there existed no parallel in the +western and more advanced States of the Continent, each resident land-owner +who belonged to the very numerous caste of the noblesse was entitled to +speak and to vote. Retaining, in addition to the right of free discussion +and petition, the appointment of local officials, as well as a considerable +share in the actual administration, the Hungarian county-assemblies, +handing down a spirit of rough independence from an immemorial past, were +probably the hardiest relic of self-government existing in any of the great +monarchical States of Europe. Ignorant, often uncouth in their habits, +oppressive to their peasantry, and dominated by the spirit of race and +caste, the mass of the Magyar nobility had indeed proved as impervious to +the humanising influences of the eighteenth century as they had to the +solicitations of despotism. The Magnates, or highest order of noblesse, who +formed a separate chamber in the Diet, had been to some extent +denationalised; they were at once more European in their culture, and more +submissive to the Austrian Court. In banishing political discussion from +the Diet to the County Sessions, the Emperor's Government had intensified +the provincial spirit which it sought to extinguish. Too numerous to be won +over by personal inducements, and remote from the imperial agencies which +had worked so effectively through the Chamber of Magnates, the lesser +nobility of Hungary during these years of absolutism carried the habit of +political discussion to their homes, and learnt to baffle the imperial +Government by withholding all help and all information from its subordinate +agents. Each county-assembly became a little Parliament, and a centre of +resistance to the usurpation of the Crown. The stimulus given to the +national spirit by this struggle against unconstitutional rule was seen not +less in the vigorous attacks made upon the Government on the re-assembling +of the Diet in 1825, than in the demand that Magyar, and not Latin as +heretofore, should be the language used in recording the proceedings of the +Diet, and in which communications should pass between the Upper and the +Lower House. + +[Magyars and Slavs.] + +There lay in this demand for the recognition of the national language the +germ of a conflict of race against race which was least of all suspected by +those by whom the demand was made. Hungary, as a political unity, +comprised, besides the Slavic kingdom of Croatia, wide regions in which the +inhabitants were of Slavic or Roumanian race, and where the Magyar was +known only as a feudal lord. The district in which the population at large +belonged to the Magyar stock did not exceed one-half of the kingdom. For +the other races of Hungary, who were probably twice as numerous as +themselves, the Magyars entertained the utmost contempt, attributing to +them the moral qualities of the savage, and denying to them the possession +of any nationality whatever. In a country combining so many elements +ill-blended with one another, and all alike subject to a German Court at +Vienna, Latin, as the language of the Church and formerly the language of +international communication, had served well as a neutral means of +expression in public affairs. There might be Croatian deputies in the Diet +who could not speak Magyar; the Magyars could not understand Croatian; both +could understand and could without much effort express themselves in the +species of Latin which passed muster at Presburg and at Vienna. Yet no +freedom of handling could convert a dead language into a living one; and +when the love of country and of ancient right became once more among the +Magyars an inspiring passion, it naturally sought a nobler and more +spontaneous utterance than dog-latin. Though no law was passed upon the +subject in the Parliament in which it was first mooted, speakers in the +Diet of 1832 used their mother-tongue; and when the Viennese Government +forbade the publication of the debates, reports were circulated in +manuscript through the country by Kossuth, a young deputy, who after the +dissolution of the Diet in 1836 paid for his defiance of the Emperor by +three years' imprisonment. + +[Hungary after 1830.] + +[The Diet of 1832-36.] + +[Szechenyi.] + +Hungary now seemed to be entering upon an epoch of varied and rapid +national development. The barriers which separated it from the Western +world were disappearing. The literature, the ideas, the inventions of +Western Europe were penetrating its archaic society, and transforming a +movement which in its origin had been conservative and aristocratic into +one of far-reaching progress and reform. Alone among the opponents of +absolute power on the Continent, the Magyars had based their resistance on +positive constitutional right, on prescription, and the settled usage of +the past; and throughout the conflict with the Crown between 1812 and 1825 +legal right was on the side not of the Emperor but of those whom he +attempted to coerce. With excellent judgment the Hungarian leaders had +during these years abstained from raising any demand for reforms, +appreciating the advantage of a purely defensive position in a combat with +a Court pledged in the eyes of all Europe, as Austria was, to the defence +of legitimate rights. This policy had gained its end; the Emperor, after +thirteen years of conflict, had been forced to re-convoke the Diet, and to +abandon the hope of effecting a work in which his uncle, Joseph II., had +failed. But, the constitution once saved, that narrow and exclusive body of +rights for which the nobility had contended no longer satisfied the needs +or the conscience of the time. [406] Opinion was moving fast; the claims of +the towns and of the rural population were making themselves felt; the +agitation that followed the overthrow of the Bourbons in 1830 reached +Hungary too, not so much through French influence as through the Polish war +of independence, in which the Magyars saw a struggle not unlike their own, +enlisting their warmest sympathies for the Polish armies so long as they +kept the field, and for the exiles who came among them when the conflict +was over. By the side of the old defenders of class-privilege there arose +men imbued with the spirit of modern Liberalism. The laws governing the +relation of the peasant to his lord, which remained nearly as they had been +left by Maria Theresa, were dealt with by the Diet of 1832 in so liberal a +spirit that the Austrian Government, formerly far in advance of Hungarian +opinion on this subject, refused its assent to many of the measures passed. +Great schemes of social and material improvement also aroused the public +hopes in these years. The better minds became conscious of the real aspect +of Hungarian life in comparison with that of civilised Europe--of its +poverty, its inertia, its boorishness. Extraordinary energy was thrown into +the work of advance by Count Szechenyi, a nobleman whose imagination had +been fired by the contrast which the busy industry of Great Britain and the +practical interests of its higher classes presented to the torpor of his +own country. It is to him that Hungary owes the bridge uniting its double +capital at Pesth, and that Europe owes the unimpeded navigation of the +Danube, which he first rendered possible by the destruction of the rocks +known as the Iron Gates at Orsova. Sanguine, lavishly generous, an ardent +patriot, Szechenyi endeavoured to arouse men of his own rank, the great and +the powerful in Hungary, to the sense of what was due from them to their +country as leaders in its industrial development. He was no revolutionist, +nor was he an enemy to Austria. A peaceful political future would best have +accorded with his own designs for raising Hungary to its due place among +nations. + +[Transylvania.] + +That the Hungarian movement of this time was converted from one of fruitful +progress into an embittered political conflict ending in civil war was due, +among other causes, to the action of the Austrian Cabinet itself. Wherever +constitutional right existed, there Austria saw a natural enemy. The +province of Transylvania, containing a mixed population of Magyars, +Germans, and Roumanians, had, like Hungary, a Diet of its own, which Diet +ought to have been summoned every year. It was, however, not once assembled +between 1811 and 1834. In the agitation at length provoked in Transylvania +by this disregard of constitutional right, the Magyar element naturally +took the lead, and so gained complete ascendancy in the province. When the +Diet met in 1834, its language and conduct were defiant in the highest +degree. It was speedily dissolved, and the scandal occasioned by its +proceedings disturbed the last days of the Emperor Francis, who died in +1835, leaving the throne to his son Ferdinand, an invalid incapable of any +serious exertion. It soon appeared that nothing was changed in the +principles of the Imperial Government, and that whatever hopes had been +formed of the establishment of a freer system under the new reign were +delusive. The leader of the Transylvanian Opposition was Count Wesselenyi, +himself a Magnate in Hungary, who, after the dissolution of the Diet, +betook himself to the Sessions of the Hungarian counties, and there +delivered speeches against the Court which led to his being arrested and +brought to trial for high treason. His cause was taken up by the Hungarian +Diet, as one in which the rights of the local assemblies were involved. The +plea of privilege was, however, urged in vain, and the sentence of exile +which was passed upon Count Wesselenyi became a new source of contention +between the Crown and the Magyar Estates. [407] + +[Parties among the Magyars.] + +[The Diet of 1843.] + +The enmity of Government was now a sufficient passport to popular favour. +On emerging from his prison under a general amnesty in 1840, Kossuth +undertook the direction of a Magyar journal at Pesth, which at once gained +an immense influence throughout the country. The spokesman of a new +generation, Kossuth represented an entirely different order of ideas from +those of the orthodox defenders of the Hungarian Constitution. They had +been conservative and aristocratic; he was revolutionary: their weapons had +been drawn from the storehouse of Hungarian positive law; his inspiration +was from the Liberalism of western Europe. Thus within the national party +itself there grew up sections in more or less pronounced antagonism to one +another, though all were united by a passionate devotion to Hungary and by +an unbounded faith in its future. Szechenyi, and those who with him +subordinated political to material ends, regarded Kossuth as a dangerous +theorist. Between the more impetuous and the more cautious reformers stood +the recognised Parliamentary leaders of the Liberals, among whom Deak had +already given proof of political capacity of no common order. In Kossuth's +journal the national problems of the time were discussed both by his +opponents and by his friends. Publicity gave greater range as well as +greater animation to the conflict of ideas; and the rapid development of +opinion during these years was seen in the large and ambitious measures +which occupied the Diet of 1843. Electoral and municipal reform, the +creation of a code of criminal law, the introduction of trial by jury, the +abolition of the immunity of the nobles from taxation; all these, and +similar legislative projects, displayed at once the energy of the time and +the influence of western Europe in transforming the political conceptions +of the Hungarian nation. Hitherto the forty-three Free Cities had possessed +but a single vote in the Diet, as against the sixty-three votes possessed +by the Counties. It was now generally admitted that this anomaly could not +continue; but inasmuch as civic rights were themselves monopolised by small +privileged orders among the townsmen, the problem of constitutional reform +carried with it that of a reform of the municipalities. Hungary in short +was now face to face with the task of converting its ancient system of the +representation of the privileged orders into the modern system of a +representation of the nation at large. Arduous at every epoch and in every +country, this work was one of almost insuperable difficulty in Hungary, +through the close connection with the absolute monarchy of Austria; through +the existence of a body of poor noblesse, numbered at two hundred thousand, +who, though strong in patriotic sentiment, bitterly resented any attack +upon their own freedom from taxation; and above all through the variety of +races in Hungary, and the attitude assumed by the Magyars, as the dominant +nationality, towards the Slavs around them. In proportion as the energy of +the Magyars and their confidence in the victory of the national cause +mounted high, so rose their disdain of all claims beside their own within +the Hungarian kingdom. It was resolved by the Lower Chamber of the Diet of +1843 that no language but Magyar should be permitted in debate, and that at +the end of ten years every person not capable of speaking the Magyar +language should be excluded from all public employment. The Magnates +softened the latter provision by excepting from it the holders of merely +local offices in Slavic districts; against the prohibition of Latin in the +Diet the Croatians appealed to the Emperor. A rescript arrived from Vienna +placing a veto upon the resolution. So violent was the storm excited in the +Diet itself by this rescript, and so threatening the language of the +national leaders outside, that the Cabinet, after a short interval, revoked +its decision, and accepted a compromise which, while establishing Magyar as +the official language of the kingdom, and requiring that it should be +taught even in Croatian schools, permitted the use of Latin in the Diet for +the next six years. In the meantime the Diet had shouted down every speaker +who began with the usual Latin formula, and fighting had taken place in +Agram, the Croatian capital, between the national and the Magyar factions. + +[The Slavic national movements.] + +It was in vain that the effort was made at Presburg to resist all claims +but those of one race. The same quickening breath which had stirred the +Magyar nation to new life had also passed over the branches of the Slavic +family within the Austrian dominions far and near. In Bohemia a revival of +interest in the Czech language and literature, which began about 1820, had +in the following decade gained a distinctly political character. Societies +originally or professedly founded for literary objects had become the +centres of a popular movement directed towards the emancipation of the +Czech elements in Bohemia from German ascendancy, and the restoration of +something of a national character to the institutions of the kingdom. Among +the southern Slavs, with whom Hungary was more directly concerned, the +national movement first became visible rather later. Its earliest +manifestations took, just as in Bohemia, a literary or linguistic form. +Projects for the formation of a common language which, under the name of +Illyrian, should draw together all the Slavic populations between the +Adriatic and the Black Sea, occupied for a while the fancy of the learned; +but the more ambitious part of this design, which had given some umbrage to +the Turkish Government, was abandoned in obedience to instructions from +Vienna; and the movement first gained political importance when its scope +was limited to the Croatian and Slavonic districts of Hungary, and it was +endowed with the distinct task of resisting the imposition of Magyar as an +official language. In addition to their representation in the Diet of the +Kingdom at Presburg, the Croatian landowners had their own Provincial Diet +at Agram. In this they possessed not only a common centre of action, but an +organ of communication with the Imperial Government at Vienna, which +rendered them some support in their resistance to Magyar pretensions. Later +events gave currency to the belief that a conflict of races in Hungary was +deliberately stimulated by the Austrian Court in its own interest. But the +whole temper and principle of Metternich's rule was opposed to the +development of national spirit, whether in one race or another; and the +patronage which the Croats appeared at this time to receive at Vienna was +probably no more than an instinctive act of conservatism, intended to +maintain the balance of interests, and to reduce within the narrowest +possible limits such changes as might prove inevitable. + +[Agitation after 1843.] + +Of all the important measures of reform which were brought before the +Hungarian Diet of 1843, one alone had become law. The rest were either +rejected by the Chamber of Magnates after passing the Lower House, or were +thrown out in the Lower House in spite of the approval of the majority, in +consequence of peremptory instructions sent to Presburg by the county +assemblies. The representative of a Hungarian constituency was not free to +vote at his discretion; he was the delegate of the body of nobles which +sent him, and was legally bound to give his vote in accordance with the +instructions which he might from time to time receive. However zealous the +Legislature itself, it was therefore liable to be paralysed by external +pressure as soon as any question was raised which touched the privileges of +the noble caste. This was especially the case with all projects involving +the expenditure of public revenue. Until the nobles bore their share of +taxation it was impossible that Hungary should emerge from a condition of +beggarly need; yet, be the inclination of the Diet what it might, it was +controlled by bodies of stubborn squires or yeomen in each county, who +fully understood their own power, and stoutly forbade the passing of any +measure which imposed a share of the public burdens upon themselves. The +impossibility of carrying out reforms tinder existing conditions had been +demonstrated by the failures of 1843. In order to overcome the obstruction +as well of the Magnates as of the county assemblies, it was necessary that +an appeal should be made to the country at large, and that a force of +public sentiment should be aroused which should both overmaster the +existing array of special interests, and give birth to legislation merging +them for the future in a comprehensive system of really national +institutions. To this task the Liberal Opposition addressed itself; and +although large differences existed within the party, and the action of +Kossuth, who now exchanged the career of the journalist for that of the +orator, was little fettered by the opinions of his colleagues, the general +result did not disappoint the hopes that had been formed. Political +associations and clubs took vigorous root in the country. The magic of +Kossuth's oratory left every hearer a more patriotic, if not a wiser man; +and an awakening passion for the public good seemed for a while to throw +all private interests into the shade. + +[Government Policy of Reform.] + +[Programme of the Opposition.] + +It now became plain to all but the blindest that great changes were +inevitable; and at the instance of the more intelligent among the +Conservative party in Hungary the Imperial Government resolved to enter the +lists with a policy of reform, and, if possible, to wrest the helm from the +men who were becoming masters of the nation. In order to secure a majority +in the Diet, it was deemed requisite by the Government first to gain a +predominant influence in the county-assemblies. As a preliminary step, most +of the Lieutenants of counties, to whose high dignity no practical +functions attached, were removed from their posts, and superseded by paid +administrators, appointed from Vienna. Count Apponyi, one of the most +vigorous of the conservative and aristocratic reformers, was placed at the +head of the Ministry. In due time the proposals of the Government were made +public. They comprised the taxation of the nobles, a reform of the +municipalities, modifications in the land-system, and a variety of economic +measures intended directly to promote the material development of the +country. The latter were framed to some extent on the lines laid down by +Szechenyi, who now, in bitter antagonism to Kossuth, accepted office under +the Government, and gave to it the prestige of his great name. It remained +for the Opposition to place their own counter-proposals before the country. +Differences within the party were smoothed over, and a manifesto, drawn up +by Deak, gave statesmanlike expression to the aims of the national leaders. +Embracing every reform included in the policy of the Government, it added +to them others which the Government had not ventured to face, and gave to +the whole the character of a vindication of its own rights by the nation, +in contrast to a scheme of administrative reform worked out by the officers +of the Crown. Thus while it enforced the taxation of the nobles, it claimed +for the Diet the right of control over every branch of the national +expenditure. It demanded increased liberty for the Press, and an unfettered +right of political association; and finally, while doing homage to the +unity of the Crown, it required that the Government of Hungary should be +one in direct accord with the national representation in the Diet, and that +the habitual effort of the Court of Vienna to place this kingdom on the +same footing as the Emperor's non-constitutional provinces should be +abandoned. With the rival programmes of the Government and the Opposition +before it, the country proceeded to the elections of 1847. Hopefulness and +enthusiasm abounded on every side; and at the close of the year the Diet +assembled from which so great a work was expected, and which was destined +within so short a time to witness, in storm and revolution, the passing +away of the ancient order of Hungarian life. + +[The Rural System of Hungary.] + +The directly constitutional problems with which the Diet of Presburg had to +deal were peculiar to Hungary itself, and did not exist in the other parts +of the Austrian Empire. There were, however, social problems which were not +less urgently forcing themselves upon public attention alike in Hungary and +in those provinces which enjoyed no constitutional rights. The chief of +these was the condition of the peasant-population. In the greater part of +the Austrian dominions, though serfage had long been abolished, society was +still based upon the manorial system. The peasant held his land subject to +the obligation of labouring on his lord's domain for a certain number of +days in the year, and of rendering him other customary services: the +manor-court, though checked by the neighbourhood of crown-officers, +retained its jurisdiction, and its agents frequently performed duties of +police. Hence the proposed extinction of the so-called feudal tie, and the +conversion of the semi-dependent cultivator into a freeholder bound only to +the payment of a fixed money-charge, or rendered free of all obligation by +the surrender of a part of his holding, involved in many districts the +institution of new public authorities and a general reorganisation of the +minor local powers. From this task the Austrian Government had shrunk in +mere lethargy, even when, as in 1835, proposals for change had come from +the landowners themselves. The work begun by Maria Theresa and Joseph +remained untouched, though thirty years of peace had given abundant +opportunity for its completion, and the legislation of Hardenberg in 1810 +afforded precedents covering at least part of the field. + +[Insurrection in Galicia, Feb., 1846.] + +[Rural Edict, Dec., 1845.] + +At length events occurred which roused the drowsiest heads in Vienna from +their slumbers. The party of action among the Polish refugees at Paris had +determined to strike another blow for the independence of their country. +Instead, however, of repeating the insurrection of Warsaw, it was arranged +that the revolt should commence in Prussian and Austrian Poland, and the +beginning of the year 1846 was fixed for the uprising. In Prussia the +Government crushed the conspirators before a blow could be struck. In +Austria, though ample warning was given, the precautions taken were +insufficient. General Collin occupied the Free City of Cracow, where the +revolutionary committee had its headquarters; but the troops under his +command were so weak that he was soon compelled to retreat, and to await +the arrival of reinforcements. Meanwhile the landowners in the district of +Tarnow in northern Galicia raised the standard of insurrection, and sought +to arm the country. The Ruthenian peasantry, however, among whom they +lived, owed all that was tolerable in their condition to the protection of +the Austrian crown-officers, and detested the memory of an independent +Poland. Instead of following their lords into the field, they gave +information of their movements, and asked instructions from the nearest +Austrian authorities. They were bidden to seize upon any persons who +instigated them to rebellion, and to bring them into the towns. A war of +the peasants against the nobles forthwith broke out. Murder, pillage, and +incendiary fires brought both the Polish insurrection and its leaders to a +miserable end. The Polish nobles, unwilling to acknowledge the humiliating +truth that their own peasants were their bitterest enemies, charged the +Austrian Government with having set a price on their heads, and with having +instigated the peasants to a communistic revolt. Metternich, disgraced by +the spectacle of a Jacquerie raging apparently under his own auspices, +insisted, in a circular to the European Courts, that the attack of the +peasantry upon the nobles had been purely spontaneous, and occasioned by +attempts to press certain villagers into the ranks of the rebellion by +brute force. But whatever may have been the measure of responsibility +incurred by the agents of the Government, an agrarian revolution was +undoubtedly in full course in Galicia, and its effects were soon felt in +the rest of the Austrian monarchy. The Arcadian contentment of the rural +population, which had been the boast, and in some degree the real strength, +of Austria, was at an end. Conscious that the problem which it had so long +evaded must at length be faced, the Government of Vienna prepared to deal +with the conditions of land-tenure by legislation extending over the whole +of the Empire. But the courage which was necessary for an adequate solution +of the difficulty nowhere existed within the official world, and the Edict +which conveyed the last words of the Imperial Government on this vital +question contained nothing more than a series of provisions for +facilitating voluntary settlements between the peasants and their lords. In +the quality of this enactment the Court of Vienna gave the measure of its +own weakness. The opportunity of breaking with traditions of impotence had +presented itself and had been lost. Revolution was at the gates; and in the +unsatisfied claim of the rural population the Government had handed over to +its adversaries a weapon of the greatest power. [408] + +[Vienna.] + +In the purely German provinces of Austria there lingered whatever of the +spirit of tranquillity was still to be found within the Empire. This, +however, was not the case in the districts into which the influence of the +capital extended. Vienna had of late grown out of its old careless spirit. +The home in past years of a population notoriously pleasure-loving, +good-humoured, and indifferent to public affairs, it had now taken +something of a more serious character. The death of the Emperor Francis, +who to the last generation of Viennese had been as fixed a part of the +order of things as the river Danube, was not unconnected with this change +in the public tone. So long as the old Emperor lived, all thought that was +given to political affairs was energy thrown away. By his death not only +had the State lost an ultimate controlling power, if dull, yet practised +and tenacious, but this loss was palpable to all the world. The void stood +bare and unrelieved before the public eye. The notorious imbecility of the +Emperor Ferdinand, the barren and antiquated formalism of Metternich and of +that entire system which seemed to be incorporated in him, made Government +an object of general satire, and in some quarters of rankling contempt. In +proportion as the culture and intelligence of the capital exceeded that of +other towns, so much the more galling was the pressure of that part of the +general system of tutelage which was especially directed against the +independence of the mind. The censorship was exercised with grotesque +stupidity. It was still the aim of Government to isolate Austria from the +ideas and the speculation of other lands, and to shape the intellectual +world of the Emperor's subjects into that precise form which tradition +prescribed as suitable for the members of a well-regulated State. In +poetry, the works of Lord Byron were excluded from circulation, where +custom-house officers and market-inspectors chose to enforce the law; in +history and political literature, the leading writers of modern times lay +under the same ban. Native production was much more effectively controlled. +Whoever wrote in a newspaper, or lectured at a University, or published a +work of imagination, was expected to deliver himself of something agreeable +to the constituted authorities, or was reduced to silence. Far as Vienna +fell short of Northern Germany in intellectual activity, the humiliation +inflicted on its best elements by this life-destroying surveillance was +keenly felt and bitterly resented. More perhaps by its senile warfare +against mental freedom than by any acts of direct political repression, the +Government ranged against itself the almost unanimous opinion of the +educated classes. Its hold on the affection of the capital was gone. Still +quiescent, but ready to unite against the Government when opportunity +should arrive, there stood, in addition to the unorganised mass of the +middle ranks, certain political associations and students' societies, a +vigorous Jewish element, and the usual contingent furnished by poverty and +discontent in every great city from among the labouring population. +Military force sufficient to keep the capital in subjection was not +wanting; but the foresight and the vigour necessary to cope with the first +onset of revolution were nowhere to be found among the holders of power. + +[Prussia.] + +[Frederick William IV., 1840.] + +At Berlin the solid order of Prussian absolutism already shook to its +foundation. With King Frederick William III., whose long reign ended in +1840, there departed the half-filial, half-spiritless acquiescence of the +nation in the denial of the liberties which had been so solemnly promised +to it at the epoch of Napoleon's fall. The new Sovereign, Frederick William +IV., ascended the throne amid high national hopes. The very contrast which +his warm, exuberant nature offered to the silent, reserved disposition of +his father impressed the public for awhile in his favour. In the more +shining personal qualities he far excelled all his immediate kindred. His +artistic and literary sympathies, his aptitude of mind and readiness of +speech, appeared to mark the man of a new age, and encouraged the belief +that, in spite of the mediaeval dreams and reactionary theories to which, +as prince, he had surrendered himself, he would, as King, appreciate the +needs of the time, and give to Prussia the free institutions which the +nation demanded. The first acts of the new reign were generously conceived. +Political offenders were freely pardoned. Men who had suffered for their +opinions were restored to their posts in the Universities and the public +service, or selected for promotion. But when the King approached the +constitutional question, his utterances were unsatisfactory. Though +undoubtedly in favour of some reform, he gave no sanction to the idea of a +really national representation, but seemed rather to seek occasions to +condemn it. Other omens of ill import were not wanting. Allying his +Government with a narrow school of theologians, the King offended men of +independent mind, and transgressed against the best traditions of Prussian +administration. The prestige of the new reign was soon exhausted. Those who +had believed Frederick William to be a man of genius now denounced him as a +vaporous, inflated dilettante; his enthusiasm was seen to indicate nothing +in particular; his sonorous commonplaces fell flat on second delivery. Not +only in his own kingdom, but in the minor German States, which looked to +Prussia as the future leader of a free Germany, the opinion rapidly gained +ground that Frederick William IV. was to be numbered among the enemies +rather than the friends of the good cause. + +[United Diet convoked at Berlin, Feb. 3, 1847.] + +In the Edicts by which the last King of Prussia had promised his people a +Constitution, it had been laid down that the representative body was to +spring from the Provincial Estates, and that it was to possess, in addition +to its purely consultative functions in legislation, a real power of +control over all State loans and over all proposed additions to taxation. +The interdependence of the promised Parliament and the Provincial Estates +had been seen at the time to endanger the success of Hardenberg's scheme; +nevertheless, it was this conception which King Frederick William IV. made +the very centre of his Constitutional policy. A devotee to the distant +past, he spoke of the Provincial Estates, which in their present form had +existed only since 1823, as if they were a great national and historic +institution which had come down unchanged through centuries. His first +experiment was the summoning of a Committee from these bodies to consider +certain financial projects with which the Government was occupied (1842). +The labours of the Committee were insignificant, nor was its treatment at +the hands of the Crown Ministers of a serious character. Frederick William, +however, continued to meditate over his plans, and appointed a Commission +to examine the project drawn up at his desire by the Cabinet. The agitation +in favour of Parliamentary Government became more and more pressing among +the educated classes; and at length, in spite of some opposition from his +brother, the Prince of Prussia, afterwards Emperor of Germany, the King +determined to fulfil his father's promise and to convoke a General Assembly +at Berlin. On the 3rd of February, 1847, there appeared a Royal Patent, +which summoned all the Provincial Estates to the capital to meet as a +United Diet of the Kingdom. The Diet was to be divided into two Chambers, +the Upper Chamber including the Royal Princes and highest nobles, the Lower +the representatives of the knights, towns, and peasants. The right of +legislation was not granted to the Diet; it had, however, the right of +presenting petitions on internal affairs. State-loans and new taxes were +not, in time of peace, to be raised without its consent. No regular +interval was fixed for the future meetings of the Diet, and its financial +rights were moreover reduced by other provisions, which enacted that a +United Committee from the Provincial Estates was to meet every four years +for certain definite objects, and that a special Delegation was to sit each +year for the transaction of business relating to the National Debt. [409] + +[King Frederick William and the Diet.] + +The nature of the General Assembly convoked by this Edict, the functions +conferred upon it, and the guarantees offered for Representative Government +in the future, so little corresponded with the requirements of the nation, +that the question was at once raised in Liberal circles whether the +concessions thus tendered by the King ought to be accepted or rejected. The +doubt which existed as to the disposition of the monarch himself was +increased by the speech from the throne at the opening of the Diet (April +11). In a vigorous harangue extending over half an hour, King Frederick +William, while he said much that was appropriate to the occasion, denounced +the spirit of revolution that was working in the Prussian Press, warned the +Deputies that they had been summoned not to advocate political theories, +but to protect each the rights of his own order, and declared that no power +on earth should induce him to change his natural relation to his people +into a constitutional one, or to permit a written sheet of paper to +intervene like a second Providence between Prussia and the Almighty. So +vehement was the language of the King, and so uncompromising his tone, that +the proposal was forthwith made at a private conference that the Deputies +should quit Berlin in a body. This extreme course was not adopted; it was +determined instead to present an address to the King, laying before him in +respectful language the shortcomings in the Patent of February 3rd. In the +debate on this address began the Parliamentary history of Prussia. The +Liberal majority in the Lower Chamber, anxious to base their cause on some +foundation of positive law, treated the Edicts of Frederick William III. +defining the rights of the future Representative Body as actual statutes of +the realm, although the late King had never called a Representative Body +into existence. From this point of view the functions now given to +Committees and Delegations were so much illegally withdrawn from the rights +of the Diet. The Government, on the other hand, denied that the Diet +possessed any rights or claims whatever beyond those assigned to it by the +Patent of February 3rd, to which it owed its origin. In receiving the +address of the Chambers, the King, while expressing a desire to see the +Constitution further developed, repeated the principle already laid down +by his Ministers, and refused to acknowledge any obligation outside those +which he had himself created. + +[Proceedings and Dissolution of the Diet.] + +When, after a series of debates on the political questions at issue, the +actual business of the Session began, the relations between the Government +and the Assembly grew worse rather than better. The principal measures +submitted were the grant of a State-guarantee to certain land-banks +established for the purpose of extinguishing the rent-charges on peasants' +holdings, and the issue of a public loan for the construction of railways +by the State. Alleging that the former measure was not directly one of +taxation, the Government, in laying it before the Diet, declared that they +asked only for an opinion, and denied that the Diet possessed any right of +decision. Thus challenged, as it were, to make good its claims, the Diet +not only declined to assent to this guarantee, but set its veto on the +proposed railway-loan. Both projects were in themselves admitted to be to +the advantage of the State; their rejection by the Diet was an emphatic +vindication of constitutional rights which the Government seemed indisposed +to acknowledge. Opposition grew more and more embittered; and when, as a +preliminary to the dissolution of the Diet, the King ordered its members to +proceed to the election of the Committees and Delegation named in the Edict +of February 3rd, an important group declined to take part in the elections, +or consented to do so only under reservations, on the ground that the Diet, +and that alone, possessed the constitutional control over finance which the +King was about to commit to other bodies. Indignant at this protest, the +King absented himself from the ceremony which brought the Diet to a close +(June 26th). Amid general irritation and resentment the Assembly broke up. +Nothing had resulted from its convocation but a direct exhibition of the +antagonism of purpose existing between the Sovereign and the national +representatives. Moderate men were alienated by the doctrines promulgated +from the Throne; and an experiment which, if more wisely conducted, might +possibly at the eleventh hour have saved all Germany from revolution, left +the Monarchy discredited and exposed to the attack of the most violent of +its foes. + +[Louis Philippe.] + +The train was now laid throughout central Europe; it needed but a flash +from Paris to kindle the fire far and wide. That the Crown which Louis +Philippe owed to one popular outbreak might be wrested from him by another, +had been a thought constantly present not only to the King himself but to +foreign observers during the earlier years of his reign. The period of +comparative peace by which the first Republican movements after 1830 had +been succeeded, the busy working of the Parliamentary system, the keen and +successful pursuit of wealth which seemed to have mastered all other +impulses in France, had made these fears a thing of the past. The Orleanist +Monarchy had taken its place among the accredited institutions of Europe; +its chief, aged, but vigorous in mind, looked forward to the future of his +dynasty, and occupied himself with plans for extending its influence or its +sway beyond the limits of France itself. At one time Louis Philippe had +hoped to connect his family by marriage with the Courts of Vienna or +Berlin; this project had not met with encouragement; so much the more +eagerly did the King watch for opportunities in another direction, and +devise plans for restoring the family-union between France and Spain which +had been established by Louis XIV. and which had so largely influenced the +history of Europe down to the overthrow of the Bourbon Monarchy. The Crown +of Spain was now held by a young girl; her sister was the next in +succession; to make the House of Orleans as powerful at Madrid as it was at +Paris seemed under these circumstances no impossible task to a King and a +Minister who, in the interests of the dynasty, were prepared to make some +sacrifice of honour and good faith. + +[The Spanish Marriage, October, 1846.] + +While the Carlist War was still continuing, Lord Palmerston had convinced +himself that Louis Philippe intended to marry the young Queen Isabella, if +possible, to one of his sons. Some years later this project was +unofficially mentioned by Guizot to the English statesman, who at once +caused it to be understood that England would not permit the union. +Abandoning this scheme, Louis Philippe then demanded, by a misconstruction +of the Treaty of Utrecht, that the Queen's choice of a husband should be +limited to the Bourbons of the Spanish or Neapolitan line. To this claim +Lord Aberdeen, who had become Foreign Secretary in 1841, declined to give +his assent; he stated, however, that no step would be taken by England in +antagonism to such marriage, if it should be deemed desirable at Madrid. +Louis Philippe now suggested that his youngest son, the Duke of +Montpensier, should wed the Infanta Fernanda, sister of the Queen of Spain. +On the express understanding that this marriage should not take place until +the Queen should herself have been married and have had children, the +English Cabinet assented to the proposal. That the marriages should not be +simultaneous was treated by both Governments as the very heart and +substance of the arrangement, inasmuch as the failure of children by the +Queen's marriage would make her sister, or her sister's heir, inheritor of +the Throne. This was repeatedly acknowledged by Louis Philippe and his +Minister, Guizot, in the course of communications with the British Court +which extended over some years. Nevertheless, in 1846, the French +Ambassador at Madrid, in conjunction with the Queen's mother, Maria +Christina, succeeded in carrying out a plan by which the conditions laid +down at London and accepted at Paris were utterly frustrated. Of the +Queen's Spanish cousins, there was one, Don Francisco, who was known to be +physically unfit for marriage. To this person it was determined by Maria +Christina and the French Ambassador that the young Isabella should be +united, her sister being simultaneously married to the Duke of Montpensier. +So flagrantly was this arrangement in contradiction to the promises made at +the Tuileries, that, when intelligence of it arrived at Paris, Louis +Philippe declared for a moment that the Ambassador must be disavowed and +disgraced. Guizot, however, was of better heart than his master, and asked +for delay. In the very crisis of the King's perplexity the return of Lord +Palmerston to office, and the mention by him of a Prince of Saxe-Coburg as +one of the candidates for the Spanish Queen's hand, afforded Guizot a +pretext for declaring that Great Britain had violated its engagements +towards the House of Bourbon by promoting the candidature of a Coburg. In +reality the British Government had not only taken no part in assisting the +candidature of the Coburg Prince, but had directly opposed it. This, +however, was urged in vain at the Tuileries. Whatever may have been the +original intentions of Louis Philippe or of Guizot, the temptation of +securing the probable succession to the Spanish Crown was too strong to be +resisted. Preliminaries were pushed forward with the utmost haste, and on +the 10th of October, 1846, the marriages of Queen Isabella and her sister, +as arranged by the French Ambassador and the Queen-Mother, were +simultaneously solemnised at Madrid. [410] + +[Louis Philippe and Guizot, 1847.] + +Few intrigues have been more disgraceful than that of the Spanish +Marriages; none more futile. The course of history mocked its ulterior +purposes; its immediate results were wholly to the injury of the House of +Orleans. The cordial understanding between France and Great Britain, which +had been revived after the differences of 1840, was now finally shattered, +Louis Philippe stood convicted before his people of sacrificing a valuable +alliance to purely dynastic ends; his Minister, the austere and +sanctimonious Guizot, had to defend himself against charges which would +have covered with shame the most hardened man of the world. Thus stripped +of its garb of moral superiority, condemned as at once unscrupulous and +unpatriotic, the Orleanist Monarchy had to meet the storm of popular +discontent which was gathering over France as well as over neighbouring +lands. For the lost friendship of England it was necessary to seek a +substitute in the support of some Continental Power. Throwing himself into +the reactionary policy of the Court of Vienna, Guizot endeavoured to +establish a diplomatic concert from which England should be excluded, as +France had been in 1840. There were circumstances which gave some +countenance to the design. The uncompromising vigour with which Lord +Palmerston supported the Liberal movement now becoming so formidable in +Italy made every absolute Government in Europe his enemy; and had time been +granted, the despotic Courts would possibly have united with France in some +more or less open combination against the English Minister. But the moments +were now numbered; and ere the projected league could take substance, the +whirlwind descended before which Louis Philippe and his Minister were the +first to fall. + +[Demand for Parliamentary Reform.] + +A demand for the reform of the French Parliamentary system had been made +when Guizot was entering upon office in the midst of the Oriental crisis of +1840. It had then been silenced and repressed by all the means at the +disposal of the Executive; King Louis Philippe being convinced that with a +more democratic Chamber the maintenance of his own policy of peace would be +impossible. The demand was now raised again with far greater energy. +Although the franchise had been lowered after the Revolution of July, it +was still so high that not one person in a hundred and fifty possessed a +vote, while the property-qualification which was imposed upon the Deputies +themselves excluded from the Chamber all but men of substantial wealth. +Moreover, there existed no law prohibiting the holders of administrative +posts under the Government from sitting in the Assembly. The consequence +was that more than one-third of the Deputies were either officials who had +secured election, or representatives who since their election had accepted +from Government appointments of greater or less value. Though Parliamentary +talent abounded, it was impossible that a Chamber so composed could be the +representative of the nation at large. The narrowness of the franchise, the +wealth of the Deputies themselves, made them, in all questions affecting +the social condition of the people, a mere club of capitalists; the +influence which the Crown exercised through the bestowal of offices +converted those who ought to have been its controllers into its dependents, +the more so as its patronage was lavished on nominal opponents even more +freely than on avowed friends. Against King Louis Philippe the majority in +the Chamber had in fact ceased to possess a will of its own. It represented +wealth; it represented to some extent the common-sense of France; but on +all current matters of dispute it only represented the executive government +in another form. So thoroughly had the nation lost all hope in the Assembly +during the last years of Louis Philippe, that even the elections had ceased +to excite interest. On the other hand, the belief in the general prevalence +of corruption was every day receiving new warrant. A series of State-trials +disclosed the grossest frauds in every branch of the administration, and +proved that political influence was habitually used for purposes of +pecuniary gain. Taxed with his tolerance of a system scarcely +distinguishable from its abuses, the Minister could only turn to his own +nominees in the Chamber and ask them whether they felt themselves +corrupted; invited to consider some measure of Parliamentary reform, he +scornfully asserted his policy of resistance. Thus, hopeless of obtaining +satisfaction either from the Government or from the Chamber itself, the +leaders of the Opposition resolved in 1847 to appeal to the country at +large; and an agitation for Parliamentary reform, based on the methods +employed by O'Connell in Ireland, soon spread through the principal towns +of France. + +[Socialism.] + +But there were other ideas and other forces active among the labouring +population of Paris than those familiar to the politicians of the Assembly. +Theories of Socialism, the property of a few thinkers and readers during +the earlier years of Louis Philippe's reign, had now sunk deep among the +masses, and become, in a rough and easily apprehended form, the creed of +the poor. From the time when Napoleon's fall had restored to France its +faculty of thought, and, as it were, turned the soldier's eyes again upon +his home, those questionings as to the basis of the social union which had +occupied men's minds at an earlier epoch were once more felt and uttered. +The problem was still what it had been in the eighteenth century; the +answer was that of a later age. Kings, priests, and nobles had been +overthrown, but misery still covered the world. In the teaching of +Saint-Simon, under the Restoration, religious conceptions blended with a +great industrial scheme; in the Utopia of Fourier, produced at the same +fruitful period, whatever was valuable belonged to its suggestions in +co-operative production. But whether the doctrine propounded was that of +philosopher, or sage, or charlatan, in every case the same leading ideas +were visible;--the insufficiency of the individual in isolation, the +industrial basis of all social life, the concern of the community, or of +its supreme authority, in the organisation of labour. It was naturally in +no remote or complex form that the idea of a new social order took +possession of the mind of the workman in the faubourgs of Paris. He read in +Louis Blanc, the latest and most intelligible of his teachers of the right +to labour, of the duty of the State to provide work for its citizens. This +was something actual and tangible. For this he was ready upon occasion to +take up arms; not for the purpose of extending the franchise to another +handful of the Bourgeoisie, or of shifting the profits of government from +one set of place-hunters to another. In antagonism to the ruling Minister +the Reformers in the Chamber and the Socialists in the streets might for a +moment unite their forces: but their ends were irreconcilable, and the +allies of to-day were necessarily the foes of to-morrow. + +[The February Revolution, 1848.] + +[Feb. 22nd.] + +At the close of the year 1847 the last Parliament of the Orleanist Monarchy +assembled. The speech from the Throne, delivered by Louis Philippe himself, +denounced in strong terms the agitation for Reform which had been carried +on during the preceding months, though this agitation had, on the whole, +been the work of the so-called Dynastic Opposition, which, while demanding +electoral reform, was sincerely loyal to the Monarchy. The King's words +were a challenge; and in the debate on the Address, the challenge was taken +up by all ranks of Monarchical Liberals as well as by the small Republican +section in the Assembly. The Government, however, was still secure of its +majority. Defeated in the votes on the Address, the Opposition determined, +by way of protest, to attend a banquet to be held in the Champs Elysees on +the 22nd of February by the Reform-party in Western Paris. It was at first +desired that by some friendly arrangement with the Government, which had +declared the banquet illegal, the possibility of recourse to violence +should be avoided. Misunderstandings, however, arose, and the Government +finally prohibited the banquet, and made preparations for meeting any +disturbance with force of arms. The Deputies, anxious to employ none but +legal means of resistance, now resolved not to attend the banquet; on the +other hand, the Democratic and Socialist leaders welcomed a possible +opportunity for revolt. On the morning of the 22nd masses of men poured +westwards from the workmen's quarter. The city was in confusion all day, +and the erection of barricades began. Troops were posted in the streets; no +serious attack, however, was made by either side, and at nightfall quiet +returned. + +[Feb. 23rd.] + +On the next morning the National Guard of Paris was called to arms. +Throughout the struggle between Louis Philippe and the populace of Paris in +the earlier years of his reign, the National Guard, which was drawn +principally from the trading classes, had fought steadily for the King. +Now, however, it was at one with the Liberal Opposition in the Assembly, +and loudly demanded the dismissal of the Ministers. While some of the +battalions interposed between the regular troops and the populace and +averted a conflict, others proceeded to the Chamber with petitions for +Reform. Obstinately as Louis Philippe had hitherto refused all concession, +the announcement of the threatened defection of the National Guard at +length convinced him that resistance was impossible. He accepted Guizot's +resignation, and the Chamber heard from the fallen Minister himself that he +had ceased to hold office. Although the King declined for awhile to commit +the formation of a Ministry to Thiers, the recognised chief of the +Opposition, and endeavoured to place a politician more acceptable to +himself in office, it was felt that with the fall of Guizot all real +resistance to Reform was broken. Nothing more was asked by the +Parliamentary Opposition or by the middle-class of Paris. The victory +seemed to be won, the crisis at an end. In the western part of the capital +congratulation and good-humour succeeded to the fear of conflict. The +troops fraternised with the citizens and the National Guard; and when +darkness came on, the boulevards were illuminated as if for a national +festival. + +[Feb. 24th.] + +In the midst, however, of this rejoicing, and while the chiefs of the +revolutionary societies, fearing that the opportunity had been lost for +striking a blow at the Monarchy, exhorted the defenders of the barricades +to maintain their positions, a band of workmen came into conflict, +accidentally or of set purpose, with the troops in front of the Foreign +Office. A volley was fired, which killed or wounded eighty persons. Placing +the dead bodies on a waggon, and carrying them by torchlight through the +streets in the workmen's quarter, the insurrectionary leaders called the +people to arms. The tocsin sounded throughout the night; on the next +morning the populace marched against the Tuileries. In consequence of the +fall of the Ministry and the supposed reconciliation of the King with the +People, whatever military dispositions had been begun had since been +abandoned. At isolated points the troops fought bravely; but there was no +systematic defence. Shattered by the strain of the previous days, and +dismayed by the indifference of the National Guard when he rode out among +them, the King, who at every epoch of his long life had shown such +conspicuous courage in the presence of danger, now lost all nerve and all +faculty of action. He signed an act of abdication in favour of his +grandson, the Count of Paris, and fled. Behind him the victorious mob burst +into the Tuileries and devastated it from cellar to roof. The Legislative +Chamber, where an attempt was made to proclaim the Count of Paris King, was +in its turn invaded. In uproar and tumult a Provisional Government was +installed at the Hotel de Ville; and ere the day closed the news went out +to Europe that the House of Orleans had ceased to reign, and that the +Republic had been proclaimed. It was not over France alone, it was over the +Continent at large, that the tide of revolution was breaking. + + +END OF VOL. II. + + + + + + +VOLUME III. + + + +CHAPTER XIX. + + +Europe in 1789 and in 1848--Agitation in Western Germany before and +after the Revolution at Paris--Austria and Hungary--The March +Revolution at Vienna--Flight of Metternich--The Hungarian Diet--Hungary +wins its independence--Bohemian movement--Autonomy promised to Bohemia-- +Insurrection of Lombardy--Of Venice--Piedmont makes war on Austria--A +general Italian war against Austria imminent--The March Days at +Berlin--Frederick William IV.--A National Assembly promised-- +Schleswig-Holstein--Insurrection in Holstein--War between Germany and +Denmark--The German Ante-Parliament--Republican rising in Baden--Meeting +of the German National Assembly at Frankfort--Europe generally in March, +1848--The French Provisional Government--The National Workshops--The +Government and the Red Republicans--French National Assembly--Riot of May +15--Measures against the National Workshops--The Four Days of June-- +Cavaignac--Louis Napoleon--He is elected to the Assembly--Elected +President. + + +[Europe in 1789 and 1848.] + +There were few statesmen living in 1848 who, like Metternich and like Louis +Philippe, could remember the outbreak of the French Revolution. To those +who could so look back across the space of sixty years, a comparison of the +European movements that followed the successive onslaughts upon authority +in France afforded some measure of the change that had passed over the +political atmosphere of the Continent within a single lifetime. The +Revolution of 1789, deeply as it stirred men's minds in neighbouring +countries, had occasioned no popular outbreak on a large scale outside +France. The expulsion of Charles X. in 1830 had been followed by national +uprisings in Italy, Poland, and Belgium, and by a struggle for +constitutional government in the smaller States of Northern Germany. The +downfall of Louis Philippe in 1848 at once convulsed the whole of central +Europe. From the Rhenish Provinces to the Ottoman frontier there was no +government but the Swiss Republic that was not menaced; there was no race +which did not assert its claim to a more or less complete independence. +Communities whose long slumber had been undisturbed by the shocks of the +Napoleonic period now vibrated with those same impulses which, since 1815, +no pressure of absolute power had been able wholly to extinguish in Italy +and Germany. The borders of the region of political discontent had been +enlarged; where apathy, or immemorial loyalty to some distant crown, had +long closed the ear to the voices of the new age, now all was restlessness, +all eager expectation of the dawning epoch of national life. This was +especially the case with the Slavic races included in the Austrian Empire, +races which during the earlier years of this century had been wholly mute. +These in their turn now felt the breath of patriotism, and claimed the +right of self-government. Distinct as the ideas of national independence +and of constitutional liberty are in themselves, they were not distinct in +their operation over a great part of Europe in 1848; and this epoch will be +wrongly conceived if it is viewed as no more than a repetition on a large +scale of the democratic outbreak of Paris with which it opened. More was +sought in Europe in 1848 than the substitution of popular for monarchical +or aristocratic rule. The effort to make the State one with the nation +excited wider interests than the effort to enlarge and equalise citizen +rights; and it is in the action of this principle of nationality that we +find the explanation of tendencies of the epoch which appear at first view +to be in direct conflict with one another. In Germany a single race was +divided under many Governments: here the national instinct impelled to +unity. In Austria a variety of races was held together by one crown: here +the national instinct impelled to separation. In both these States, as in +Italy, where the predominance of the foreigner and the continuance of +despotic government were in a peculiar manner connected with one another, +the efforts of 1848 failed; but the problems which then agitated Europe +could not long be set aside, and the solution of them complete, in the case +of Germany and Italy, partial and tentative in the case of Austria, renders +the succeeding twenty-five years a memorable period in European history. + +[Agitation in Western Germany.] + +The sudden disappearance of the Orleanist monarchy and the proclamation of +the Republic at Paris struck with dismay the Governments beyond the Rhine. +Difficulties were already gathering round them, opposition among their own +subjects was daily becoming more formidable and more outspoken. In Western +Germany a meeting of Liberal deputies had been held in the autumn of 1847, +in which the reform of the Federal Constitution and the establishment of a +German Parliament had been demanded: a Republican or revolutionary party, +small but virulent, had also its own avowed policy and its recognised +organs in the press. No sooner had the news of the Revolution at Paris +passed the frontier than in all the minor German States the cry for reform +became irresistible. Ministers everywhere resigned; the popular demands +were granted; and men were called to office whose names were identified +with the struggle for the freedom of the Press, for trial by jury, and for +the reform of the Federal Constitution. The Federal Diet itself, so long +the instrument of absolutism, bowed beneath the stress of the time, +abolished the laws of censorship, and invited the Governments to send +Commissioners to Frankfort to discuss the reorganisation of Germany. It was +not, however, at Frankfort or at the minor capitals that the conflict +between authority and its antagonists was to be decided. Vienna, the +stronghold of absolutism, the sanctuary from which so many interdicts had +gone forth against freedom in every part of Europe, was itself invaded by +the revolutionary spirit. The clear sky darkened, and Metternich found +himself powerless before the storm. + +[Austria.] + +There had been until 1848 so complete an absence of political life in the +Austrian capital, that, when the conviction suddenly burst upon all minds +that the ancient order was doomed, there were neither party-leaders to +confront the Government, nor plans of reform upon which any considerable +body of men were agreed. The first utterances of public discontent were +petitions drawn up by the Chamber of Commerce and by literary associations. +These were vague in purport and far from aggressive in their tone. A +sterner note sounded when intelligence reached the capital of the +resolutions that had been passed by the Hungarian Lower House on the 3rd of +March, and of the language in which these had been enforced by Kossuth. +Casting aside all reserve, the Magyar leader had declared that the reigning +dynasty could only be saved by granting to Hungary a responsible Ministry +drawn from the Diet itself, and by establishing constitutional government +throughout the Austrian dominions. "From the charnel-house of the Viennese +system," he cried, "a poison-laden atmosphere steals over us, which +paralyses our nerves and bows us when we would soar. The future of Hungary +can never be secure while in the other provinces there exists a system of +government in direct antagonism to every constitutional principle. Our task +it is to found a happier future on the brotherhood of all the Austrian +races, and to substitute for the union enforced by bayonets and police the +enduring bond of a free constitution." When the Hungarian Assembly had thus +taken into its own hands the cause of the rest of the monarchy, it was not +for the citizens of Vienna to fall short in the extent of their demands. +The idea of a Constitution for the Empire at large was generally accepted +and it was proposed that an address embodying this demand should be sent in +to the Emperor by the Provincial Estates of Lower Austria, whose meeting +happened to be fixed for the 13th of March. In the meantime the students +made themselves the heroes of the hour. The agitation of the city +increased; rumours of State bankruptcy and of the impending repudiation of +the paper currency filled all classes with the belief that some catastrophe +was near at hand. [411] + +[The March Revolution at Vienna.] + +The Provincial Estates of Lower Austria had long fallen into such +insignificance that in ordinary times their proceedings were hardly noticed +by the capital. The accident that they were now to assemble in the midst of +a great crisis elevated them to a sudden importance. It was believed that +the decisive word would be spoken in the course of their debates; and on +the morning of the 13th of March masses of the populace, led by a +procession of students, assembled round the Hall of the Diet. While the +debate proceeded within, street-orators inflamed the passions of the crowd +outside. The tumult deepened; and when at length a note was let down from +one of the windows of the Hall stating that the Diet were inclining to +half-measures, the mob broke into uproar, and an attack was made upon the +Diet Hall itself. The leading members of the Estates were compelled to +place themselves at the head of a deputation, which proceeded to the +Emperor's palace in order to enforce the demands of the people. The Emperor +himself, who at no time was capable of paying serious attention to +business, remained invisible during this and the two following days; the +deputation was received by Metternich and the principal officers of State, +who were assembled in council. Meanwhile the crowds in the streets became +denser and more excited; soldiers approached, to protect the Diet Hall and +to guard the environs of the palace; there was an interval of confusion; +and on the advance of a new regiment, which was mistaken for an attack, the +mob who had stormed the Diet Hall hurled the shattered furniture from the +windows upon the soldiers' heads. A volley was now fired, which cost +several lives. At the sound of the firing still deeper agitation seized the +city. Barricades were erected, and the people and soldiers fought hand to +hand. As evening came on, deputation after deputation pressed into the +palace to urge concession upon the Government. Metternich, who, almost +alone in the Council, had made light of the popular uprising, now at length +consented to certain definite measures of reform. He retired into an +adjoining room to draft an order abolishing the censorship of the Press. +During his absence the cry was raised among the deputations that thronged +the Council-chamber, "Down with Metternich!" The old man returned, and +found himself abandoned by his colleagues. There were some among them, +members of the Imperial family, who had long been his opponents; others who +had in vain urged him to make concessions before it was too late. +Metternich saw that the end of his career was come; he spoke a few words, +marked by all the dignity and self-possession of his greatest days, and +withdrew, to place his resignation in the Emperor's hands. + +[Flight of Metternich.] + +For thirty-nine years Metternich had been so completely identified with the +Austrian system of government that in his fall that entire system seemed to +have vanished away. The tumult of the capital subsided on the mere +announcement of his resignation, though the hatred which he had excited +rendered it unsafe for him to remain within reach of hostile hands. He was +conveyed from Vienna by a faithful secretary on the night of the 14th of +March, and, after remaining for a few days in concealment, crossed the +Saxon frontier. His exile was destined to be of some duration, but no exile +was ever more cheerfully borne, or sweetened by a profounder satisfaction +at the evils which a mad world had brought upon itself by driving from it +its one thoroughly wise and just statesman. Betaking himself in the general +crash of the Continental Courts to Great Britain, which was still as safe +as when he had visited it fifty-five years before, Metternich received a +kindly welcome from the Duke of Wellington and the leaders of English +society; and when the London season was over he sought and found at +Brighton something of the liveliness and the sunshine of his own southern +home. [412] + +[The Hungarian Diet.] + +The action of the Hungarian Diet under Kossuth's leadership had powerfully +influenced the course of events at Vienna. The Viennese outbreak in its +turn gave irresistible force to the Hungarian national movement. Up to the +13th of March the Chamber of Magnates had withheld their assent from the +resolution passed by the Lower House in favour of a national executive; +they now accepted it without a single hostile vote; and on the 15th a +deputation was sent to Vienna to lay before the Emperor an address +demanding not only the establishment of a responsible Ministry but the +freedom of the Press, trial by jury, equality of religion, and a system of +national education. At the moment when this deputation reached Vienna the +Government was formally announcing its compliance with the popular demand +for a Constitution for the whole of the Empire. The Hungarians were +escorted in triumph through the streets, and were received on the following +day by the Emperor himself, who expressed a general concurrence with the +terms of the address. The deputation returned to Presburg, and the +Palatine, or representative of the sovereign in Hungary, the Archduke +Stephen, forthwith charged Count Batthyany, one of the most popular of the +Magyar nobles, with the formation of a national Ministry. Thus far the Diet +had been in the van of the Hungarian movement; it now sank almost into +insignificance by the side of the revolutionary organisation at Pesth, +where all the ardour and all the patriotism of the Magyar race glowed in +their native force untempered by the political experience of the statesmen +who were collected at Presburg, and unchecked by any of those influences +which belong to the neighbourhood of an Imperial Court. At Pesth there +broke out an agitation at once so democratic and so intensely national that +all considerations of policy and of regard for the Austrian Government +which might have affected the action of the Diet were swept away before it. +Kossuth, himself the genuine representative of the capital, became supreme. +At his bidding the Diet passed a law abolishing the departments of the +Central Government by which the control of the Court over the Hungarian +body politic had been exercised. A list of Ministers was submitted and +approved, including not only those who were needed for the transaction of +domestic business, but Ministers of War, Finance, and Foreign Affairs; and +in order that the entire nation might rally round its Government, the +peasantry were at one stroke emancipated from all services attaching to the +land, and converted into free proprietors. Of the compensation to be paid +to the lords for the loss of these services, no more was said than that it +was a debt of honour to be discharged by the nation. + +[Hungary wins independence.] + +Within the next few days the measures thus carried through the Diet by +Kossuth were presented for the Emperor's ratification at Vienna. The fall +of Metternich, important as it was, had not in reality produced that effect +upon the Austrian Government which was expected from it by popular opinion. +The new Cabinet at Vienna was drawn from the ranks of the official +hierarchy; and although some of its members were more liberally disposed +than their late chief, they had all alike passed their lives in the +traditions of the ancient system, and were far from intending to make +themselves the willing agents of revolution. These men saw clearly enough +that the action of the Diet at Presburg amounted to nothing less than the +separation of Hungary from the Austrian Empire. With the Ministries of War, +Finance, and Foreign Affairs established in independence of the central +government, there would remain no link between Hungary and the Hereditary +States but the person of a titular, and, for the present time, an imbecile +sovereign. Powerless and distracted, Metternich's successors looked in all +directions for counsel. The Palatine argued that three courses were open to +the Austrian Government. It might endeavour to crush the Hungarian movement +by force of arms; for this purpose, however, the troops available were +insufficient: or it might withdraw from the country altogether, leaving the +peasants to attack the nobles, as they had done in Galicia; this was a +dishonourable policy, and the action of the Diet had, moreover, secured to +the peasant everything that he could gain by a social insurrection: or +finally, the Government might yield for the moment to the inevitable, make +terms with Batthyany's Ministry, and quietly prepare for vigorous +resistance when opportunity should arrive. The last method was that which +the Palatine recommended; the Court inclined in the same direction, but it +was unwilling to submit without making some further trial of the temper of +its antagonists. A rescript was accordingly sent to Presburg, announcing +that the Ministry formed by Count Batthyany was accepted by the Emperor, +but that the central offices which the Diet had abolished must be +preserved, and the functions of the Ministers of War and Finance be reduced +to those of chiefs of departments, dependent on the orders of a higher +authority at Vienna. From the delay that had taken place in the despatch of +this answer the nationalist leaders at Pesth and at Presburg had augured no +good result. Its publication brought the country to the verge of armed +revolt. Batthyany refused to accept office under the conditions named; the +Palatine himself declared that he could remain in Hungary no longer. +Terrified at the result of its own challenge, the Court now withdrew from +the position that it had taken up, and accepted the scheme of the Diet in +its integrity, stipulating only that the disposal of the army outside +Hungary in time of war, and the appointment to the higher commands, should +remain with the Imperial Government. [413] + +[Bohemian movement.] + +[Autonomy promised.] + +Hungary had thus made good its position as an independent State connected +with Austria only through the person of its monarch. Vast and momentous as +was the change, fatal as it might well appear to those who could conceive +of no unity but the unity of a central government, the victory of the +Magyars appears to have excited no feeling among the German Liberals at +Vienna but one of satisfaction. So odious, so detested, was the fallen +system of despotism, that every victory won by its adversaries was hailed +as a triumph of the good cause, be the remoter issues what they might. Even +where a powerful German element, such as did not exist in Hungary itself, +was threatened by the assertion of provincial claims, the Government could +not hope for the support of the capital if it should offer resistance. The +example of the Magyars was speedily followed by the Czechs in Bohemia. +Forgotten and obliterated among the nationalities of Europe, the Czechs had +preserved in their language, and in that almost alone, the emblem of their +national independence. Within the borders of Bohemia there was so large a +German population that the ultimate absorption of the Slavic element by +this wealthier and privileged body had at an earlier time seemed not +unlikely. Since 1830, however, the Czech national movement had been +gradually gaining ground. In the first days of the agitation of 1848 an +effort had been made to impress a purely constitutional form upon the +demands made in the name of the people of Prague, and so to render the +union of all classes possible. This policy, however, received its deathblow +from the Revolution in Vienna and from the victory of the Magyars. The +leadership at Prague passed from men of position and experience, +representing rather the intelligence of the German element in Bohemia than +the patriotism of the Czechs, to the nationalist orators who commanded the +streets. An attempt made by the Cabinet at Vienna to evade the demands +drawn up under the influence of the more moderate politicians resulted only +in the downfall of this party, and in the tender of a new series of demands +of far more revolutionary character. The population of Prague were +beginning to organise a national guard; arms were being distributed; +authority had collapsed. The Government was now forced to consent to +everything that was asked of it, and a legislative Assembly with an +independent local administration was promised to Bohemia. To this Assembly, +as soon as it should meet, the new institutions of the kingdom were to be +submitted. + +[Insurrection of Lombardy, March 18.] + +Thus far, if the authority of the Court of Vienna, had been virtually +shaken off by a great part of its subjects, the Emperor had at least not +seen these subjects in avowed rebellion against the House of Hapsburg, nor +supported in their resistance by the arms of a foreign Power. South of the +Alps the dynastic connection was openly severed, and the rule of Austria +declared for ever at an end. Lombardy had since the beginning of the year +1848 been held in check only by the display of great military force. The +Revolution at Paris had excited both hopes and fears; the Revolution at +Vienna was instantly followed by revolt in Milan. Radetzky, the Austrian +commander, a veteran who had served with honour in every campaign since +that against the Turks in 1788, had long foreseen the approach of an armed +conflict; yet when the actual crisis arrived his dispositions had not been +made for meeting it. The troops in Milan were ill placed; the offices of +Government were moreover separated by half the breadth of the city from the +military head-quarters. Thus when on the 18th of March the insurrection +broke out, it carried everything before it. The Vice-Governor, O'Donell, +was captured, and compelled to sign his name to decrees handing over the +government of the city to the Municipal Council. Radetzky now threw his +soldiers upon the barricades, and penetrated to the centre of the city; but +he was unable to maintain himself there under the ceaseless fire from the +windows and the housetops, and withdrew on the night of the 19th to the +line of fortifications. Fighting continued during the next two days in the +outskirts and at the gates of the city. The garrisons of all the +neighbouring towns were summoned to the assistance of their general, but +the Italians broke up the bridges and roads, and one detachment alone out +of all the troops in Lombardy succeeded in reaching Milan. A report now +arrived at Radetzky's camp that the King of Piedmont was on the march +against him. Preferring the loss of Milan to the possible capture of his +army, he determined to evacuate the city. On the night of the 22nd of March +the retreat was begun, and Radetzky fell back upon the Mincio and Verona, +which he himself had made the centre of the Austrian system of defence in +Upper Italy. [414] + +[Insurrection of Venice.] + +[Piedmont makes war.] + +Venice had already followed the example of the Lombard capital. The tidings +received from Vienna after the 13th of March appear to have completely +bewildered both the military and the civil authorities on the Adriatic +coast. They released their political prisoners, among whom was Daniel +Manin, an able and determined foe of Austria; they entered into +constitutional discussions with the popular leaders; they permitted the +formation of a national guard, and finally handed over to this guard the +arsenals and the dockyards with all their stores. From this time all was +over. Manin proclaimed the Republic of St. Mark, and became the chief of a +Provisional Government. The Italian regiments in garrison joined the +national cause; the ships of war at Pola, manned chiefly by Italian +sailors, were only prevented from sailing to the assistance of the rebels +by batteries that were levelled against them from the shore. Thus without a +blow being struck Venice was lost to Austria. The insurrection spread +westwards and northwards through city and village in the interior, till +there remained to Austria nothing but the fortresses on the Adige and the +Mincio, where Radetzky, deaf to the counsels of timidity, held his ground +unshaken. The national rising carried Piedmont with it. It was in vain that +the British envoy at Turin urged the King to enter into no conflict with +Austria. On the 24th of March Charles Albert published a proclamation +promising his help to the Lombards. Two days later his troops entered +Milan. [415] + +[General war against Austria, beginning in Italy.] + +Austria had for thirty years consistently laid down the principle that its +own sovereignty in Upper Italy vested it with the right to control the +political system of every other State in the peninsula. It had twice +enforced this principle by arms: first in its intervention in Naples in +1820, afterwards in its occupation of the Roman States in 1831. The +Government of Vienna had, as it were with fixed intention, made it +impossible that its presence in any part of Italy should be regarded as the +presence of an ordinary neighbour, entitled to quiet possession until some +new provocation should be given. The Italians would have proved themselves +the simplest of mankind if, having any reasonable hope of military success, +they had listened to the counsels of Palmerston and other statesmen who +urged them not to take advantage of the difficulties in which Austria was +now placed. The paralysis of the Austrian State was indeed the one +unanswerable argument for immediate war. So long as the Emperor retained +his ascendency in any part of Italy, his interests could not permanently +suffer the independence of the rest. If the Italians should chivalrously +wait until the Cabinet of Vienna had recovered its strength, it was quite +certain that their next efforts in the cause of internal liberty would be +as ruthlessly crushed as their last. Every clearsighted patriot understood +that the time for a great national effort had arrived. In some respects the +political condition of Italy seemed favourable to such united action. Since +the insurrection of Palermo in January, 1848, absolutism had everywhere +fallen. Ministries had come into existence containing at least a fair +proportion of men who were in real sympathy with the national feeling. +Above all, the Pope seemed disposed to place himself at the head of a +patriotic union against the foreigner. Thus, whatever might be the secret +inclinations of the reigning Houses, they were unable for the moment to +resist the call to arms. Without an actual declaration of war troops were +sent northwards from Naples, from Florence, and from Rome, to take part, as +it was supposed, in the national struggle by the side of the King of +Piedmont. Volunteers thronged to the standards. The Papal benediction +seemed for once to rest on the cause of manhood and independence. On the +other hand, the very impetus which had brought Liberal Ministries into +power threatened to pass into a phase of violence and disorder. The +concessions already made were mocked by men who expected to win all the +victories of democracy in an hour. It remained to be seen whether there +existed in Italy the political sagacity which, triumphing over all local +jealousies, could bend to one great aim the passions of the multitude and +the fears of the Courts, or whether the cause of the whole nation would be +wrecked in an ignoble strife between demagogues and reactionists, between +the rabble of the street and the camarilla round the throne. [416] + +[The March Days at Berlin.] + +Austria had with one hand held down Italy, with the other it had weighed on +Germany. Though the Revolutionary movement was in full course on the east +of the Rhine before Metternich's fall, it received, especially at Berlin, a +great impetus from this event. Since the beginning of March the Prussian +capital had worn an unwonted aspect. In this city of military discipline +public meetings had been held day after day, and the streets had been +blocked by excited crowds. Deputations which laid before the King demands +similar to those now made in every German town received halting and evasive +answers. Excitement increased, and on the 13th of March encounters began +between the citizens and the troops, which, though insignificant, served to +exasperate the people and its leaders. The King appeared to be wavering +between resistance and concession until the Revolution at Vienna, which +became known at Berlin on the 15th of March, brought affairs to their +crisis. On the 17th the tumult in the streets suddenly ceased; it was +understood that the following day would see the Government either +reconciled with the people or forced to deal with an insurrection on a +great scale. Accordingly on the morning of the 18th crowds made their way +towards the palace, which was surrounded by troops. About midday there +appeared a Royal edict summoning the Prussian United Diet for the 2nd of +April, and announcing that the King had determined to promote the creation +of a Parliament for all Germany and the establishment of Constitutional +Government in every German State. This manifesto drew fresh masses towards +the palace, desirous, it would seem, to express their satisfaction; its +contents, however, were imperfectly understood by the assembly already in +front of the palace, which the King vainly attempted to address. When +called upon to disperse, the multitude refused to do so, and answered by +cries for the withdrawal of the soldiery. In the midst of the confusion two +shots were fired from the ranks without orders; a panic followed, in which, +for no known reason, the cavalry and infantry threw themselves upon the +people. The crowd was immediately put to flight, but the combat was taken +up by the population of Berlin. Barricades appeared in the streets; +fighting continued during the evening and night. Meanwhile the King, who +was shocked and distressed at the course that events had taken, received +deputations begging that the troops might be withdrawn from the city. +Frederick William endeavoured for awhile to make the surrender of the +barricades the condition for an armistice; but as night went on the troops +became exhausted, and although they had gained ground, the resistance of +the people was not overcome. Whether doubtful of the ultimate issue of the +conflict or unwilling to permit further bloodshed, the King gave way, and +at daybreak on the 19th ordered the troops to be withdrawn. His intention +was that they should continue to garrison the palace, but the order was +misunderstood, and the troops were removed to the outside of Berlin. The +palace was thus left unprotected, and, although no injury was inflicted +upon its inmates, the King was made to feel that the people could now +command his homage. The bodies of the dead were brought into the court of +the palace; their wounds were laid bare, and the King, who appeared in a +balcony, was compelled to descend into the court, and to stand before them +with uncovered head. Definite political expression was given to the changed +state of affairs by the appointment of a new Ministry. [417] + +The conflict between the troops and the people at Berlin was described, and +with truth, as the result of a misunderstanding. Frederick William had +already determined to yield to the principal demands of his subjects; nor +on the part of the inhabitants of Berlin had there existed any general +hostility towards the sovereign, although a small group of agitators, in +part foreign, had probably sought to bring about an armed attack on the +throne. Accordingly, when once the combat was broken off, there seemed to +be no important obstacle to a reconciliation between the King and the +people. Frederick William chose a course which spared and even gratified +his own self-love. In the political faith of all German Liberals the +establishment of German unity was now an even more important article than +the introduction of free institutions into each particular State. The +Revolution at Berlin had indeed been occasioned by the King's delay in +granting internal reform; but these domestic disputes might well be +forgotten if in the great cause of German unity the Prussians saw their +King rising to the needs of the hour. Accordingly the first resolution of +Frederick William, after quiet had returned to the capital, was to appear +in public state as the champion of the Fatherland. A proclamation announced +on the morning of the 21st of March that the King had placed himself at the +head of the German nation, and that he would on that day appear on +horseback wearing the old German colours. In due time Frederick William +came forth at the head of a procession, wearing the tricolor of gold, +white, and black, which since 1815 had been so dear to the patriots and so +odious to the Governments of Germany. As he passed through the streets he +was saluted as Emperor, but he repudiated the title, asserting with oaths +and imprecations that he intended to rob no German prince of his +sovereignty. At each stage of his theatrical progress he repeated to +appropriate auditors his sounding but ambiguous allusions to the duties +imposed upon him by the common danger. A manifesto, published at the close +of the day, summed up the utterances of the monarch in a somewhat less +rhetorical form. "Germany is in ferment within, and exposed from without to +danger from more than one side. Deliverance from this danger can come only +from the most intimate union of the German princes and people under a +single leadership. I take this leadership upon me for the hour of peril. I +have to-day assumed the old German colours, and placed myself and my people +under the venerable banner of the German Empire. Prussia henceforth is +merged in Germany." [418] + +[National Assembly promised.] + +The ride of the King through Berlin, and his assumption of the character of +German leader, however little it pleased the minor sovereigns, or gratified +the Liberals of the smaller States, who considered that such National +authority ought to be conferred by the nation, not assumed by a prince, was +successful for the moment in restoring to the King some popularity among +his own subjects. He could now without humiliation proceed with the +concessions which had been interrupted by the tragical events of the 18th +of March. In answer to a deputation from Breslau, which urged that the +Chamber formed by the union of the Provincial Diets should be replaced by a +Constituent Assembly, the King promised that a national Representative +Assembly should be convoked as soon as the United Diet had passed the +necessary electoral law. To this National Assembly the Government would +submit measures securing the liberty of the individual, the right of public +meeting and of associations, trial by jury, the responsibility of +Ministers, and the independence of the judicature. A civic militia was to +be formed, with the right of choosing its own officers, and the standing +army was to take the oath of allegiance to the Constitution. Hereditary +jurisdictions and manorial rights of police were to be abolished; equality +before the law was to be universally enforced; in short, the entire scheme +of reforms demanded by the Constitutional Liberals of Prussia was to be +carried into effect. In Berlin, as in every other capital in Germany, the +victory of the party of progress now seemed to be assured. The Government +no longer represented a power hostile to popular rights; and when, on the +22nd of March, the King spontaneously paid the last honours to those who +had fallen in combat with his troops, as the long funeral procession passed +his palace, it was generally believed that his expression of feeling was +sincere. + +[Schleswig-Holstein.] + +In the passage of his address in which King Frederick William spoke of the +external dangers threatening Germany, he referred to apprehensions which +had for a while been current that the second French Republic would revive +the aggressive energy of the first. This fear proved baseless; +nevertheless, for a sovereign who really intended to act as the champion of +the German nation at large, the probability of war with a neighbouring +Power was far from remote. The cause of the Duchies of Schleswig-Holstein, +which were in rebellion against the Danish Crown, excited the utmost +interest and sympathy in Germany. The population of these provinces, with +the exception of certain districts in Schleswig, was German; Holstein was +actually a member of the German Federation. The legal relation of the +Duchies to Denmark was, according to the popular view, very nearly that of +Hanover to England before 1837. The King of Denmark was also Duke of +Schleswig and of Holstein, but these were no more an integral portion of +the Danish State than Hanover was of the British Empire; and the laws of +succession were moreover different in Schleswig-Holstein, the Crown being +transmitted by males, while in Denmark females were capable of succession. +On the part of the Danes it was admitted that in certain districts in +Holstein the Salic law held good; it was, however, maintained that in the +remainder of Holstein and in all Schleswig the rules of succession were the +same as in Denmark. The Danish Government denied that Schleswig-Holstein +formed a unity in itself, as alleged by the Germans, and that it possessed +separate national rights as against the authority of the King's Government +at Copenhagen. The real heart of the difficulty lay in the fact that the +population of the Duchies was German. So long as the Germans as a race +possessed no national feeling, the union of the Duchies with the Danish +Monarchy had not been felt as a grievance. It happened, however, that the +great revival of German patriotism resulting from the War of Liberation in +1813 was almost simultaneous with the severance of Norway from the Danish +Crown, which compelled the Government of Copenhagen to increase very +heavily the burdens imposed on its German subjects in the Duchies. From +this time discontent gained ground, especially in Altona and Kiel, where +society was as thoroughly German as in the neighbouring city of Hamburg. +After 1830, when Provincial Estates were established in Schleswig and +Holstein, the German movement became formidable. The reaction, however, +which marked the succeeding period generally in Europe prevailed in Denmark +too, and it was not until 1844, when a posthumous work of Lornsen, the +exiled leader of the German party, vindicated the historical rights of the +Duchies, that the claims of German nationality in these provinces were +again vigorously urged. From this time the separation of Schleswig-Holstein +from Denmark became a question of practical politics. The King of Denmark, +Christain VIII., had but one son, who, though long married, was childless, +and with whom the male line of the reigning House would expire. In answer +to an address of the Danish Provincial Estates calling upon the King to +declare the unity of the Monarchy and the validity of the Danish law of +succession for all its parts, the Holstein Estates passed a resolution in +November, 1844, that the Duchies were an independent body, governed by the +rule of male descent, and indivisible. After an interval of two years, +during which a Commission examined the succession-laws, King Christian +published a declaration that the succession was the same in Schleswig as in +Denmark proper, and that, as regarded those parts of Holstein where a +different rule of succession existed, he would spare no effort to maintain +the unity of the Monarchy. On this the Provincial Estates both of Schleswig +and of Holstein addressed protests to the King, who refused to accept them. +The deputies now resigned in a mass, whilst on behalf of Holstein an appeal +was made to the German Federal Diet. The Diet merely replied by a +declaration of rights; but in Germany at large the keenest interest was +aroused on behalf of these severed members of the race who were so +resolutely struggling against incorporation with a foreign Power. The +deputies themselves, passing from village to village, excited a strenuous +spirit of resistance throughout the Duchies, which was met by the Danish +Government with measures of repression more severe than any which it had +hitherto employed. [419] + +[Insurrection in Holstein, March 24.] + +[War between Germany and Denmark.] + +Such was the situation of affairs when, on the 20th of January, 1848, King +Christian VIII. died, leaving the throne to Frederick VII., the last of the +male line of his House. Frederick's first act was to publish the draft of a +Constitution, in which all parts of the Monarchy were treated as on the +same footing. Before the delegates could assemble to whom the completion of +this work was referred, the shock of the Paris Revolution reached the North +Sea ports. A public meeting at Altona demanded the establishment of a +separate constitution for Schleswig-Holstein, and the admission of +Schleswig into the German Federation. The Provincial Estates accepted this +resolution, and sent a deputation to Copenhagen to present this and other +demands to the King. But in the course of the next few days a popular +movement at Copenhagen brought into power a thoroughly Danish Ministry, +pledged to the incorporation of Schleswig with Denmark as an integral part +of the Kingdom. Without waiting to learn the answer made by the King to the +deputation, the Holsteiners now took affairs into their own hands. A +Provisional Government was formed at Kiel (March 24), the troops joined the +people, and the insurrection instantly spread over the whole province. As +the proposal to change the law of succession to the throne had originated +with the King of Denmark, the cause of the Holsteiners was from one point +of view that of established right. The King of Prussia, accepting the +positions laid down by the Holstein Estates in 1844, declared that he would +defend the claims of the legitimate heir by force of arms, and ordered his +troops to enter Holstein. The Diet of Frankfort, now forced to express the +universal will of Germany, demanded that Schleswig, as the sister State of +Holstein, should enter the Federation. On the passing of this resolution, +the envoy who represented the Denmark. King of Denmark at the Diet, as Duke +of Holstein, quitted Frankfort, and a state of war ensued between Denmark +on the one side and Prussia with the German Federation on the other. + +[The German Ante-Parliament, March 30-April 4.] + +[Republican rising in Baden.] + +The passionate impulse of the German people towards unity had already +called into being an organ for the expression of national sentiment, which, +if without any legal or constitutional authority, was yet strong enough to +impose its will upon the old and discredited Federal Diet and upon most of +the surviving Governments. At the invitation of a Committee, about five +hundred Liberals who had in one form or another taken part in public +affairs assembled at Frankfort on the 30th of March to make the necessary +preparations for the meeting of a German national Parliament. This +Assembly, which is known as the Ante-Parliament, sat but for five days. Its +resolutions, so far as regarded the method of electing the new Parliament, +and the inclusion of new districts in the German Federation, were accepted +by the Diet, and in the main carried into effect. Its denunciation of +persons concerned in the repressive measures of 1819 and subsequent +reactionary epochs was followed by the immediate retirement of all members +of the Diet whose careers dated back to those detested days. But in the +most important work that was expected from the Ante-Parliament, the +settlement of a draft-Constitution to be laid before the future National +Assembly as a basis for its deliberations, nothing whatever was +accomplished. The debates that took place from the 31st of March to the 4th +of April were little more than a trial of strength between the Monarchical +and Republican parties. The Republicans, far outnumbered when they +submitted a constitutional scheme of their own, proposed, after this +repulse, that the existing Assembly should continue in session until the +National Parliament met; in other words, that it should take upon itself +the functions and character of a National Convention. Defeated also on this +proposal, the leaders of the extreme section of the Republican party, +strangely miscalculating their real strength, determined on armed +insurrection. Uniting with a body of German refugees beyond the Rhine, who +were themselves assisted by French and Polish soldiers of revolution, they +raised the Republican standard in Baden, and for a few days maintained a +hopeless and inglorious struggle against the troops which were sent to +suppress them. Even in Baden, which had long been in advance of all other +German States in democratic sentiment, and which was peculiarly open to +Republican influences from France and Switzerland, the movement was not +seriously supported by the population, and in the remainder of Germany it +received no countenance whatever. The leaders found themselves ruined men. +The best of them fled to the United States, where, in the great struggle +against slavery thirteen years later, they rendered better service to their +adopted than they had ever rendered to their natural Fatherland. + +[Meeting of the German National Assembly, May 18.] + +On breaking up on the 4th of April, the Ante-Parliament left behind it a +Committee of Fifty, whose task it was to continue the work of preparation +for the National Assembly to which it had itself contributed so little. One +thing alone had been clearly established, that the future Constitution of +Germany was not to be Republican. That the existing Governments could not +be safely ignored by the National Assembly in its work of founding the new +Federal Constitution for Germany was clear to those who were not blinded by +the enthusiasm of the moment. In the Committee of Fifty and elsewhere plans +were suggested for giving to the Governments a representation within the +Constituent Assembly, or for uniting their representatives in a Chamber +co-ordinate with this, so that each step in the construction of the new +Federal order should be at once the work of the nation and of the +Governments. Such plans were suggested and discussed; but in the haste and +inexperience of the time they were brought to no conclusion. The opening of +the National Assembly had been fixed for the 18th of May, and this brief +interval had expired before the few sagacious men who understood the +necessity of co-operation between the Governments and the Parliament had +decided upon any common course of action. To the mass of patriots it was +enough that Germany, after thirty years of disappointment, had at last won +its national representation. Before this imposing image of the united race, +Kings, Courts, and armies, it was fondly thought, must bow. Thus, in the +midst of universal hope, the elections were held throughout Germany in its +utmost federal extent, from the Baltic to the Italian border; Bohemia +alone, where the Czech majority resisted any closer union with Germany, +declining to send representatives to Frankfort. In the body of deputies +elected there were to be found almost all the foremost Liberal politicians +of every German community; a few still vigorous champions of the time of +the War of Liberation, chief among them the poet Arndt; patriots who in the +evil days that followed had suffered imprisonment and exile; historians, +professors, critics, who in the sacred cause of liberty have, like +Gervinus, inflicted upon their readers worse miseries than ever they +themselves endured at the hands of unregenerate kings; theologians, +journalists; in short, the whole group of leaders under whom Germany +expected to enter into the promised land of national unity and freedom. No +Imperial coronation ever brought to Frankfort so many honoured guests, or +attracted to the same degree the sympathy of the German race. Greeted with +the cheers of the citizens of Frankfort, whose civic militia lined the +streets, the members of the Assembly marched in procession on the afternoon +of the 18th of May from the ancient banqueting-hall of the Kaisers, where +they had gathered, to the Church of St. Paul, which had been chosen as +their Senate House. Their President and officers were elected on the +following day. Arndt, who in the frantic confusion of the first meeting had +been unrecognised and shouted down, was called into the Tribune, but could +speak only a few words for tears. The Assembly voted him its thanks for his +famous song, "What is the German's Fatherland?" and requested that he would +add to it another stanza commemorating the union of the race at length +visibly realised in that great Parliament. Four days after the opening of +the General Assembly of Frankfort, the Prussian national Parliament began +its sessions at Berlin. [420] + +[Europe generally in March, 1848.] + +At this point the first act in the Revolutionary drama of 1848 in Germany, +as in Europe generally, may be considered to have reached its close. A +certain unity marks the memorable epoch known generally as the March Days +and the events immediately succeeding. Revolution is universal; it scarcely +meets with resistance; its views seem on the point of being achieved; the +baffled aspirations of the last half-century seem on the point of being +fulfilled. There exists no longer in Central Europe such a thing as an +autocratic Government; and, while the French Republic maintains an +unexpected attitude of peace, Germany and Italy, under the leadership of +old dynasties now penetrated with a new spirit, appear to be on the point +of achieving each its own work of Federal union and of the expulsion of the +foreigner from its national soil. All Italy prepares to move under Charles +Albert to force the Austrians from their last strongholds on the Mincio and +the Adige; all Germany is with the troops of Frederick William of Prussia +as they enter Holstein to rescue this and the neighbouring German province +from the Dane. In Radetzky's camp alone, and at the Court of St. +Petersburg, the old monarchical order of Europe still survives. How +powerful were these two isolated centres of anti-popular energy the world +was soon to see. Yet they would not have turned back the tide of European +affairs and given one more victory to reaction had they not had their +allies in the hatred of race to race, in the incapacity and the errors of +peoples and those who represented them; above all, in the enormous +difficulties which, even had the generation been one of sages and martyrs, +the political circumstances of the time would in themselves have opposed to +the accomplishment of the ends desired. + +[The French Provisional Government.] + +[The National Workshops.] + +France had given to Central Europe the signal for the Revolution of 1848, +and it was in France, where the conflict was not one for national +independence but for political and social interests, that the Revolution +most rapidly ran its course and first exhausted its powers. On the flight +of Louis Philippe authority had been entrusted by the Chamber of Deputies +to a Provisional Government, whose most prominent member was the orator and +poet Lamartine. Installed at the Hotel de Ville, this Government had with +difficulty prevented the mob from substituting the Red Flag for the +Tricolor, and from proceeding at once to realise the plans of its own +leaders. The majority of the Provisional Government were Republicans of a +moderate type, representing the ideas of the urban middle classes rather +than those of the workmen; but by their side were Ledru Rollin, a +rhetorician dominated by the phrases of 1793, and Louis Blanc, who +considered all political change as but an instrument for advancing the +organisation of labour and for the emancipation of the artisan from +servitude, by the establishment of State-directed industries affording +appropriate employment and adequate remuneration to all. Among the first +proclamations of the Provisional Government was one in which, in answer to +a petition demanding the recognition of the Right to Labour, they undertook +to guarantee employment to every citizen. This engagement, the heaviest +perhaps that was ever voluntarily assumed by any Government, was followed +in a few days by the opening of national workshops. That in the midst of a +Revolution which took all parties by surprise plans for the conduct of a +series of industrial enterprises by the State should have been seriously +examined was impossible. The Government had paid homage to an abstract +idea; they were without a conception of the mode in which it was to be +realised. What articles were to be made, what works were to be executed, no +one knew. The mere direction of destitute workmen to the centres where they +were to be employed was a task for which a new branch of the administration +had to be created. When this was achieved, the men collected proved useless +for all purposes of industry. Their numbers increased enormously, rising in +the course of four weeks from fourteen to sixty-five thousand. The +Revolution had itself caused a financial and commercial panic, interrupting +all the ordinary occupations of business, and depriving masses of men of +the means of earning a livelihood. These, with others who had no intention +of working, thronged to the State workshops; while the certainty of +obtaining wages from the public purse occasioned a series of strikes of +workmen against their employers and the abandonment of private factories. +The chocks which had been intended to confine enrolment at the public works +to persons already domiciled in Paris completely failed; from all the +neighbouring departments the idle and the hungry streamed into the capital. +Every abuse incidental to a system of public relief was present in Paris in +its most exaggerated form; every element of experience, of wisdom, of +precaution, was absent. If, instead of a group of benevolent theorists, the +experiment of 1848 had had for its authors a company of millionaires +anxious to dispel all hope that mankind might ever rise to a higher order +than that of unrestricted competition of man against man, it could not have +been conducted under more fatal conditions. [421] + +[The Provisional Government and the Red Republicans.] + +[Elections, April 23.] + +The leaders of the democracy in Paris had from the first considered that +the decision upon the form of Government to be established in France in +place of the Orleanist monarchy belonged rather to themselves than to the +nation at large. They distrusted, and with good reason, the results of the +General Election which, by a decree of the Provisional Government, was to +be held in the course of April. A circular issued by Ledru Rollin, Minister +of the Interior, without the knowledge of his colleagues, to the +Commissioners by whom he had replaced the Prefects of the Monarchy gave the +first open indication of this alarm, and of the means of violence and +intimidation by which the party which Ledru Rollin represented hoped to +impose its will upon the country. The Commissioners were informed in plain +language that, as agents of a revolutionary authority, their powers were +unlimited, and that their task was to exclude from election all persons who +were not animated by revolutionary spirit, and pure from any taint of +association with the past. If the circular had been the work of the +Government, and not of a single member of it who was at variance with most +of his colleagues and whose words were far more formidable than his +actions, it would have clearly foreshadowed a return to the system of 1793. +But the isolation of Ledru Rollin was well understood. The attitude of the +Government generally was so little in accordance with the views of the Red +Republicans that on the 16th of April a demonstration was organised with +the object of compelling them to postpone the elections. The prompt +appearance in arms of the National Guard, which still represented the +middle classes of Paris, baffled the design of the leaders of the mob, and +gave to Lamartine and the majority in the Government a decisive victory +over their revolutionary colleague. The elections were held at the time +appointed; and, in spite of the institution of universal suffrage, they +resulted in the return of a body of Deputies not widely different from +those who had hitherto appeared in French Parliaments. The great majority +were indeed Republicans by profession, but of a moderate type; and the +session had no sooner opened than it became clear that the relation between +the Socialist democracy of Paris and the National Representatives could +only be one of more or less violent antagonism. + +[The National Assembly, May 4.] + +[Riot of May 15.] + +[Measures against the National Workshops.] + +The first act of the Assembly, which met on the 4th of May, was to declare +that the Provisional Government had deserved well of the country, and to +reinstate most of its members in office under the title of an Executive +Commission. Ledru Rollin's offences were condoned, as those of a man +popular with the democracy, and likely on the whole to yield to the +influence of his colleagues. Louis Blanc and his confederate, Albert, as +really dangerous persons, were excluded. The Jacobin leaders now proceeded +to organise an attack on the Assembly by main force. On the 15th of May the +attempt was made. Under pretence of tendering a petition on behalf of +Poland, a mob invaded the Legislative Chamber, declared the Assembly +dissolved, and put the Deputies to flight. But the triumph was of short +duration. The National Guard, whose commander alone was responsible for the +failure of measures of defence, soon rallied in force; the leaders of the +insurgents, some of whom had installed themselves as a Provisional +Government at the Hotel de Ville, were made captive; and after an interval +of a few hours the Assembly resumed possession of the Palais Bourbon. The +dishonour done to the national representation by the scandalous scenes of +the 15th of May, as well as the decisively proved superiority of the +National Guard over the half armed mob, encouraged the Assembly to declare +open war against the so-called social democracy, and to decree the +abolition of the national workshops. The enormous growth of these +establishments, which now included over a hundred thousand men, threatened +to ruin the public finances; the demoralisation which they engendered +seemed likely to destroy whatever was sound in the life of the working +classes of Paris. Of honest industry there was scarcely a trace to be found +among the masses who were receiving their daily wages from the State. +Whatever the sincerity of those who had founded the national workshops, +whatever the anxiety for employment on the part of those who first resorted +to them, they had now become mere hives of disorder, where the resources of +the State were lavished in accumulating a force for its own overthrow. It +was necessary, at whatever risk, to extinguish the evil. Plans for the +gradual dispersion of the army of workmen were drawn up by Committees and +discussed by the Assembly. If put in force with no more than the necessary +delay, these plans might perhaps have rendered a peaceful solution of the +difficulty possible. But the Government hesitated, and finally, when a +decision could no longer be avoided, determined upon measures more violent +and more sudden than those which the Committees had recommended. On the +21st of June an order was published that all occupants of the public +workshops between the ages of seventeen and twenty-five must enlist in the +army or cease to receive support from the State, and that the removal of +the workmen who had come into Paris from the provinces, for which +preparations had already been made, must be at once effected. [422] + +[The Four Days of June, 23-26.] + +The publication of this order was the signal for an appeal to arms. The +legions of the national workshops were in themselves a half-organised force +equal in number to several army-corps, and now animated by something like +the spirit of military union. The revolt, which began on the morning of the +23rd of June, was conducted as no revolt in Pans had ever been conducted +before. The eastern part of the city was turned into a maze of barricades. +Though the insurgents had not artillery, they were in other respects fairly +armed. The terrible nature of the conflict impending now became evident to +the Assembly. General Cavaignac, Minister of War, was placed in command, +and subsequently invested with supreme authority, the Executive Commission +resigning its powers. All the troops in the neighbourhood of Paris were at +once summoned to the capital, Cavaignac well understood that any attempt to +hold the insurrection in check by means of scattered posts would only end, +as in 1830, by the capture or the demoralisation of the troops. He treated +Paris as one great battle-field in which the enemy must be attacked in mass +and driven by main force from all his positions. At times the effort +appeared almost beyond the power of the forces engaged, and the insurgents, +sheltered by huge barricades and firing from the windows of houses, seemed +likely to remain masters of the field. The struggle continued for four +days, but Cavaignac's artillery and the discipline of his troops at last +crushed resistance; and after the Archbishop of Paris had been mortally +wounded in a heroic effort to stop further bloodshed, the last bands of the +insurgents, driven back into the north-eastern quarter of the city, and +there attacked with artillery in front and flank, were forced to lay down +their arms. + +[Fears left by the events of June.] + +Such was the conflict of the Four Days of June, a conflict memorable as one +in which the combatants fought not for a political principle or form of +Government, but for the preservation or the overthrow of society based on +the institution of private property. The National Guard, with some +exceptions, fought side by side with the regiments of the line, braved the +same perils, and sustained an equal loss. The workmen threw themselves the +more passionately into the struggle, inasmuch as defeat threatened them +with deprivation of the very means of life. On both sides acts of savagery +were committed which the fury of the conflict could not excuse. The +vengeance of the conquerors in the moment of success appears, however, to +have been less unrelenting than that which followed the overthrow of the +Commune in 1871, though, after the struggle was over, the Assembly had no +scruple in transporting without trial the whole mass of prisoners taken +with arms in their hands. Cavaignac's victory left the classes for whom he +had fought terror-stricken at the peril from which they had escaped, and +almost hopeless of their own security under any popular form of Government +in the future. Against the rash and weak concessions to popular demands +that had been made by the administration since February, especially in the +matter of taxation and finance, there was now a deep, if not loudly +proclaimed, reaction. The national workshops disappeared; grants were made +by the Legislature for the assistance of the masses who were left without +resource, but the money was bestowed in charitable relief or in the form of +loans to associations, not as wages from the State. On every side among the +holders of property the cry was for a return to sound principles of finance +in the economy of the State, and for the establishment of a strong central +power. + +[Cavaignac and Louis Napoleon.] + +[Louis Napoleon elected Deputy but resigns, June 14.] + +General Cavaignac after the restoration of order had laid down the supreme +authority which had been conferred on him, but at the desire of the +Assembly he continued to exercise it until the new Constitution should be +drawn up and an Executive appointed in accordance with its provisions. +Events had suddenly raised Cavaignac from obscurity to eminence, and seemed +to mark him out as the future ruler of France. But he displayed during the +six months following the suppression of the revolt no great capacity for +government, and his virtues as well as his defects made against his +personal success. A sincere Republican, while at the same time a rigid +upholder of law, he refused to lend himself to those who were, except in +name, enemies of Republicanism; and in his official acts and utterances he +spared the feelings of the reactionary classes as little as he would have +spared those of rioters and Socialists. As the influence of Cavaignac +declined, another name began to fill men's thoughts. Louis Napoleon, son of +the Emperor's brother Louis, King of Holland, had while still in exile been +elected to the National Assembly by four Departments. He was as yet almost +unknown except by name to his fellow-countrymen. Born in the Tuileries in +1808, he had been involved as a child in the ruin of the Empire, and had +passed into banishment with his mother Hortense, under the law that +expelled from France all members of Napoleon's family. He had been brought +up at Augsburg and on the shores of the Lake of Constance, and as a +volunteer in a Swiss camp of artillery he had gained some little +acquaintance with military life. In 1831 he had joined the insurgents in +the Romagna who were in arms against the Papal Government. The death of his +own elder brother, followed in 1832 by that of Napoleon's son, the Duke of +Reichstadt, made him chief of the house of Bonaparte. Though far more of a +recluse than a man of action, though so little of his own nation that he +could not pronounce a sentence of French without a marked German accent, +and had never even seen a French play performed, he now became possessed by +the fixed idea that he was one day to wear the French Crown. A few obscure +adventurers attached themselves to his fortunes, and in 1836 he appeared at +Strasburg and presented himself to the troops as Emperor. The enterprise +ended in failure and ridicule. Louis Napoleon was shipped to America by the +Orleanist Government, which supplied him with money, and thought it +unnecessary even to bring him to trial. He recrossed the Atlantic, made his +home in England, and in 1840 repeated at Boulogne the attempt that had +failed at Strasburg. The result was again disastrous. He was now sentenced +to perpetual imprisonment, and passed the next six years in captivity at +Ham, where he produced a treatise on the Napoleonic Ideas, and certain +fragments on political and social questions. The enthusiasm for Napoleon, +of which there had been little trace in France since 1815, was now +reviving; the sufferings of the epoch of conquest were forgotten; the +steady maintenance of peace by Louis Philippe seemed humiliating to young +and ardent spirits who had not known the actual presence of the foreigner. +In literature two men of eminence worked powerfully upon the national +imagination. The history of Thiers gave the nation a great stage-picture of +Napoleon's exploits; Beranger's lyrics invested his exile at St. Helena +with an irresistible, though spurious, pathos. Thus, little as the world +concerned itself with the prisoner at Ham, the tendencies of the time were +working in his favour; and his confinement, which lasted six years and was +terminated by his escape and return to England, appears to have deepened +his brooding nature, and to have strengthened rather than diminished his +confidence in himself. On the overthrow of Louis Philippe he visited Paris, +but was requested by the Provisional Government, on the ground of the +unrepealed law banishing the Bonaparte family, to quit the country. He +obeyed, probably foreseeing that the difficulties of the Republic would +create better opportunities for his reappearance. Meanwhile the group of +unknown men who sought their fortunes in a Napoleonic restoration busily +canvassed and wrote on behalf of the Prince, and with such success that, in +the supplementary elections that were held at the beginning of June, he +obtained a fourfold triumph. The Assembly, in spite of the efforts of the +Government, pronounced his return valid. Yet with rare self-command the +Prince still adhered to his policy of reserve, resigning his seat on the +ground that his election had been made a pretext for movements of which he +disapproved, while at the same time he declared in his letter to the +President of the Assembly that if duties should be imposed upon him by the +people he should know how to fulfil them. [423] + +[Louis Napoleon again elected, Sept. 17.] + +[Louis Napoleon elected President, Dec. 10.] + +From this time Louis Napoleon was a recognised aspirant to power. The +Constitution of the Republic was now being drawn up by the Assembly. The +Executive Commission had disappeared in the convulsion of June; Cavaignac +was holding the balance between parties rather than governing himself. In +the midst of the debates on the Constitution Louis Napoleon was again +returned elected, to the Assembly by the votes of five Departments. He saw +that he ought to remain no longer in the background, and, accepting the +call of the electors, he took his seat in the Chamber. It was clear that he +would become a candidate for the Presidency of the Republic, and that the +popularity of his name among the masses was enormous. He had twice +presented himself to France as the heir to Napoleon's throne; he had never +directly abandoned his dynastic claim; he had but recently declared, in +almost threatening language, that he should know how to fulfil the duties +that the people might impose upon him. Yet with all these facts before it +the Assembly, misled by the puerile rhetoric of Lamartine, decided that in +the new Constitution the President of the Republic, in whom was vested the +executive power, should be chosen by the direct vote of all Frenchmen, and +rejected the amendment of M. Grevy, who, with real insight into the future, +declared that such direct election by the people could only give France a +Dictator, and demanded that the President should be appointed not by the +masses but by the Chamber. Thus was the way paved for Louis Napoleon's +march to power. The events of June had dispelled any attraction that he had +hitherto felt towards Socialistic theories. He saw that France required an +upholder of order and of property. In his address to the nation announcing +his candidature for the Presidency he declared that he would shrink from no +sacrifice in defending society, so audaciously attacked; that he would +devote himself without reserve to the maintenance of the Republic, and make +it his pride to leave to his successor at the end of four years authority +strengthened, liberty unimpaired, and real progress accomplished. Behind +these generalities the address dexterously touched on the special wants of +classes and parties, and promised something to each. The French nation in +the election which followed showed that it believed in Louis Napoleon even +more than he did in himself. If there existed in the opinion of the great +mass any element beyond the mere instinct of self-defence against real or +supposed schemes of spoliation, it was reverence for Napoleon's memory. Out +of seven millions of votes given, Louis Napoleon received above five, +Cavaignac, who alone entered into serious competition with him, receiving +about a fourth part of that number. Lamartine and the men who ten months +before had represented all the hopes of the nation now found but a handful +of supporters. Though none yet openly spoke of Monarchy, on all sides there +was the desire for the restoration of power. The day-dreams of the second +Republic had fled. France had shown that its choice lay only between a +soldier who had crushed rebellion and a stranger who brought no title to +its confidence but an Imperial name. + + + + +CHAPTER XX. + + +Austria and Italy--Vienna from March to May--Flight of the Emperor-- +Bohemian National Movement--Windischgraetz subdues Prague--Campaign +around Verona--Papal Allocution--Naples in May--Negotiations as to +Lombardy--Reconquest of Venetia--Battle of Custozza--The Austrians enter +Milan--Austrian Court and Hungary--The Serbs in Southern Hungary--Serb +Congress at Carlowitz--Jellacic--Affairs of Croatia--Jellacic, the Court +and the Hungarian Movement--Murder of Lamberg--Manifesto of October 3 +Vienna on October 6--The Emperor at Olmuetz--Windischgraetz conquers +Vienna--The Parliament at Kremsier--Schwarzenberg Minister--Ferdinand +abdicates--Dissolution of the Kremsier Parliament--Unitary Edict-- +Hungary--The Roumanians in Transylvania--The Austrian Army occupies +Pesth--Hungarian Government at Debreczin--The Austrians driven out of +Hungary--Declaration of Hungarian Independence--Russian Intervention-- +The Hungarian Summer Campaign--Capitulation of Vilagos--Italy--Murder of +Rossi--Tuscany--The March Campaign in Lombardy--Novara--Abdication of +Charles Albert--Victor Emmanuel--Restoration in Tuscany--French +Intervention in Rome--Defeat of Oudinot--Oudinot and Lesseps--The French +enter Rome--The Restored Pontifical Government--Fall of Venice-- +Ferdinand reconquers Sicily Germany--The National Assembly at Frankfort-- +The Armistice of Malmoe--Berlin from April to September--The Prussian +Army--Last days of the Prussian Parliament--Prussian Constitution +granted by Edict--The German National Assembly and Austria--Frederick +William IV. elected Emperor--He refuses the Crown--End of the National +Assembly--Prussia attempts to form a separate Union--The Union +Parliament at Erfurt--Action of Austria--Hesse Cassel--The Diet of +Frankfort restored--Olmuetz--Schleswig-Holstein--Germany after 1849-- +Austria after 1851--France after 1848--Louis Napoleon--The October +Message--Law Limiting the Franchise--Louis Napoleon and the Army-- +Proposed Revision of the Constitution--The Coup d'Etat--Napoleon III. +Emperor + + +[Austria and Italy.] + +The plain of Northern Italy has ever been an arena on which the contest +between interests greater than those of Italy itself has been brought to an +issue, and it may perhaps be truly said that in the struggle between +established Governments and Revolution through out Central Europe in 1848 +the real turning point, if it can anywhere be fixed, lay rather in the +fortunes of a campaign in Lombardy than in any single combination of events +at Vienna or Berlin. The very existence of the Austrian Monarchy depended +on the victory of Radetzky's forces over the national movement at the head +of which Piedmont had now placed itself. If Italian independence should be +established upon the ruin of the Austrian arms, and the influence and +example of the victorious Italian people be thrown into the scale against +the Imperial Government in its struggle with the separatist forces that +convulsed every part of the Austrian dominions, it was scarcely possible +that any stroke of fortune or policy could save the Empire of the Hapsburgs +from dissolution. But on the prostration or recovery of Austria, as +represented by its central power at Vienna, the future of Germany in great +part depended. Whatever compromise might be effected between popular and +monarchical forces in the other German States if left free from Austria's +interference, the whole influence of a resurgent Austrian power could not +but be directed against the principles of popular sovereignty and national +union. The Parliament of Frankfort might then in vain affect to fulfil its +mandate without reckoning with the Court of Vienna. All this was indeed +obscured in the tempests that for a while shut out the political horizon. +The Liberals of Northern Germany had little sympathy with the Italian cause +in the decisive days of 1848. Their inclinations went rather with the +combatant who, though bent on maintaining an oppressive dominion, was +nevertheless a member of the German race and paid homage for the moment to +Constitutional rights. Yet, as later events were to prove, the fetters +which crushed liberty beyond the Alps could fit as closely on to German +limbs; and in the warfare of Upper Italy for its own freedom the battle of +German Liberalism was in no small measure fought and lost. + +[Vienna from March to May.] + +Metternich once banished from Vienna, the first popular demand was for a +Constitution. His successors in office, with a certain characteristic +pedantry, devoted their studies to the Belgian Constitution of 1831; and +after some weeks a Constitution was published by edict for the +non-Hungarian part of the Empire, including a Parliament of two Chambers, +the Lower to be chosen by indirect election, the Upper consisting of +nominees of the Crown and representatives of the great landowners. The +provisions of this Constitution in favour of the Crown and the Aristocracy, +as well as the arbitrary mode of its promulgation, displeased the Viennese. +Agitation recommenced in the city; unpopular officials were roughly handled +the Press grew ever more violent and more scurrilous. One strange result of +the tutelage in which Austrian society had been held was that the students +of the University became, and for some time continued to be, the most +important political body of the capital. Their principal rivals in +influence were the National Guard drawn from citizens of the middle class, +the workmen as yet remaining in the background. Neither in the Hall of the +University nor at the taverns where the civic militia discussed the events +of the hour did the office-drawn Constitution find favour. On the 13th of +May it was determined, with the view of exercising stronger pressure upon +the Government, that the existing committees of the National Guard and of +the students should be superseded by one central committee representing +both bodies. The elections to this committee had been held, and its +sittings had begun, when the commander of the National Guard declared such +proceedings to be inconsistent with military discipline, and ordered the +dissolution of the committee. Riots followed, during which the students and +the mob made their way into the Emperor's palace and demanded from his +Ministers not only the re-establishment of the central committee but the +abolition of the Upper Chamber in the projected Constitution, and the +removal of the checks imposed on popular sovereignty by a limited franchise +and the system of indirect elections. On point after point the Ministry +gave way; and, in spite of the resistance and reproaches of the Imperial +household, they obtained the Emperor's signature to a document promising +that for the future all the important military posts in the city should be +held by the National Guard jointly with the regular troops, that the latter +should never be called out except on the requisition of the National Guard, +and that the projected Constitution should remain without force until it +should have been submitted for confirmation to a single Constituent +Assembly elected by universal suffrage. + +[Flight of the Emperor, May 17.] + +[Tumult of May 26.] + +The weakness of the Emperor's intelligence rendered him a mere puppet in +the hands of those who for the moment exercised control over his actions. +During the riot of the 15th of May he obeyed his Ministers; a few hours +afterwards he fell under the sway of the Court party, and consented to fly +from Vienna. On the 18th the Viennese learnt to their astonishment that +Ferdinand was far on the road to the Tyrol. Soon afterwards a manifesto was +published, stating that the violence and anarchy of the capital had +compelled the Emperor to transfer his residence to Innsbruck; that he +remained true, however, to the promises made in March and to their +legitimate consequences; and that proof must be given of the return of the +Viennese to their old sentiments of loyalty before he could again appear +among them. A certain revulsion of feeling in the Emperor's favour now +became manifest in the capital, and emboldened the Ministers to take the +first step necessary towards obtaining his return, namely the dissolution +of the Students' Legion. They could count with some confidence on the +support of the wealthier part of the middle class, who were now becoming +wearied of the students' extravagances and alarmed at the interruption of +business caused by the Revolution; moreover, the ordinary termination of +the academic year was near at hand. The order was accordingly given for the +dissolution of the Legion and the closing of the University. But the +students met the order with the stoutest resistance. The workmen poured in +from the suburbs to join in their defence. Barricades were erected, and the +insurrection of March seemed on the point of being renewed. Once more the +Government gave way, and not only revoked its order, but declared itself +incapable of preserving tranquillity in the capital unless it should +receive the assistance of the leaders of the people. With the full +concurrence of the Ministers, a Committee of Public Safety was formed, +representing at once the students, the middle class, and the workmen; and +it entered upon its duties with an authority exceeding, within the limits +of the capital, that of the shadowy functionaries of State. [424] + +[Bohemian national movement.] + +[Windischgraetz subdues Prague, June 12-17.] + +In the meantime the antagonism between the Czechs and the Germans in +Bohemia was daily becoming more bitter. The influence of the party of +compromise, which had been dominant in the early days of March, had +disappeared before the ill-timed attempt of the German national leaders at +Frankfort to include Bohemia within the territory sending representatives +to the German national Parliament. By consenting to this incorporation the +Czech population would have definitely renounced its newly asserted claim +to nationality. If the growth of democratic spirit at Vienna was +accompanied by a more intense German national feeling in the capital, the +popular movements at Vienna and at Prague must necessarily pass into a +relation of conflict with one another. On the flight of the Emperor +becoming known at Prague, Count Thun, the governor, who was also the chief +of the moderate Bohemian party, invited Ferdinand to make Prague the seat +of his Government. This invitation, which would have directly connected the +Crown with Czech national interests, was not accepted. The rasher +politicians, chiefly students and workmen, continued to hold their meetings +and to patrol the streets; and a Congress of Slavs from all parts of the +Empire, which was opened on the 2nd of June, excited national passions +still further. So threatening grew the attitude of the students and workmen +that Count Windischgraetz, commander of the troops at Prague, prepared to +act with artillery. On the 12th of June, the day on which the Congress of +Slavs broke up, fighting began. Windischgraetz, whose wife was killed by a +bullet, appears to have acted with calmness, and to have sought to arrive +at some peaceful settlement. He withdrew his troops, and desisted from a +bombardment that he had begun, on the understanding that the barricades +which had been erected should be removed. This condition was not fulfilled. +New acts of violence occurred in the city, and on the 17th Windischgraetz +reopened fire. On the following day Prague surrendered, and Windischgraetz +re-entered the city as Dictator. The autonomy of Bohemia was at an end. The +army had for the first time acted with effect against a popular rising; the +first blow had been struck on behalf of the central power against the +revolution which till now had seemed about to dissolve the Austrian State +into its fragments. + +[Campaign around Verona, April-May.] + +At this point the dominant interest in Austrian affairs passes from the +capital and the northern provinces to Radetzky's army and the Italians with +whom it stood face to face. Once convinced of the necessity of a retreat +from Milan, the Austrian commander had moved with sufficient rapidity to +save Verona and Mantua from passing into the hands of the insurgents. He +was thus enabled to place his army in one of the best defensive positions +in Europe, the Quadrilateral flanked by the rivers Mincio and Adige, and +protected by the fortresses of Verona, Mantua, Peschiera, and Legnano. With +his front on the Mincio he awaited at once the attack of the Piedmontese +and the arrival of reinforcements from the north-east. On the 8th of April +the first attack was made, and after a sharp engagement at Goito the +passage of the Mincio was effected by the Sardinian army. Siege was now +laid to Peschiera; and while a Tuscan contingent watched Mantua, the bulk +of Charles Albert's forces operated farther northward with the view of +cutting off Verona from the roads to the Tyrol. This result was for a +moment achieved, but the troops at the King's disposal were far too weak +for the task of reducing the fortresses; and in an attempt that was made on +the 6th of May to drive the Austrians out of their positions in front of +Verona, Charles Albert was defeated at Santa Lucia and compelled to fall +back towards the Mincio. [425] + +[Papal Allocution, April 29.] + +[Naples in May.] + +A pause in the war ensued, filled by political events of evil omen for +Italy. Of all the princes who had permitted their troops to march +northwards to the assistance of the Lombards, not one was acting in full +sincerity. The first to show himself in his true colours was the Pope. On +the 29th of April an Allocution was addressed to the Cardinals, in which +Pius disavowed all participation in the war against Austria, and declared +that his own troops should do no more than defend the integrity of the +Roman States. Though at the moment an outburst of popular indignation in +Rome forced a still more liberal Ministry into power, and Durando, the +Papal general, continued his advance into Venetia, the Pope's renunciation +of his supposed national leadership produced the effect which its author +desired, encouraging every open and every secret enemy of the Italian +cause, and perplexing those who had believed themselves to be engaged in a +sacred as well as a patriotic war. In Naples things hurried far more +rapidly to a catastrophe. Elections had been held to the Chamber of +Deputies, which was to be opened on the 15th of May, and most of the +members returned were men who, while devoted to the Italian national cause +were neither Republicans nor enemies of the Bourbon dynasty, but anxious to +co-operate with their King in the work of Constitutional reform. +Politicians of another character, however, commanded the streets of Naples. +Rumours were spread that the Court was on the point of restoring despotic +government and abandoning the Italian cause. Disorder and agitation +increased from day to day; and after the Deputies had arrived in the city +and begun a series of informal meetings preparatory to the opening of the +Parliament, an ill-advised act of Ferdinand gave to the party of disorder, +who were weakly represented in the Assembly, occasion for an insurrection. +After promulgating the Constitution on February both, Ferdinand had agreed +that it should be submitted to the two Chambers for revision. He notified, +however, to the Representatives on the eve of the opening of Parliament +that they would be required to take an oath of fidelity to the +Constitution. They urged that such an oath would deprive them of their +right of revision. The King, after some hours, consented to a change in the +formula of the oath; but his demand had already thrown the city into +tumult. Barricades were erected, the Deputies in vain endeavouring to calm +the rioters and to prevent a conflict with the troops. While negotiations +were still in progress shots were fired. The troops now threw themselves +upon the people; there was a struggle, short in duration, but sanguinary +and merciless; the barricades were captured, some hundreds of the +insurgents slain, and Ferdinand was once more absolute master of Naples. +The Assembly was dissolved on the day after that on which it should have +met. Orders were at once sent by the King to General Pepe, commander of the +troops that were on the march to Lombardy, to return with his army to +Naples. Though Pepe continued true to the national cause, and endeavoured +to lead his army forward from Bologna in defiance of the King's +instructions, his troops now melted away; and when he crossed the Po and +placed himself under the standard of Charles Albert in Venetia there +remained with him scarcely fifteen hundred men. + +[Negotiations as to Lombardy.] + +[Reconquest of Venetia, June, July.] + +It thus became clear before the end of May that the Lombards would receive +no considerable help from the Southern States in their struggle for +freedom, and that the promised league of the Governments in the national +cause was but a dream from which there was a bitter awakening. Nor in +Northern Italy itself was there the unity in aim and action without which +success was impossible. The Republican party accused the King and the +Provisional Government at Milan of an unwillingness to arm the people; +Charles Albert on his part regarded every Republican as an enemy. On +entering Lombardy the King had stated that no question as to the political +organisation of the future should be raised until the war was ended; +nevertheless, before a fortress had been captured, he had allowed Modena +and Parma to declare themselves incorporated with the Piedmontese monarchy; +and, in spite of Mazzini's protest, their example was followed by Lombardy +and some Venetian districts. In the recriminations that passed between the +Republicans and the Monarchists it was even suggested that Austria had +friends of its own in certain classes of the population. This was not the +view taken by the Viennese Government, which from the first appears to have +considered its cause in Lombardy as virtually lost. The mediation of Great +Britain was invoked by Metternich's successors, and a willingness expressed +to grant to the Italian provinces complete autonomy under the Emperor's +sceptre. Palmerston, in reply to the supplications of a Court which had +hitherto cursed his influence, urged that Lombardy and the greater part of +Venetia should be ceded to the King of Piedmont. The Austrian Government +would have given up Lombardy to their enemy; they hesitated to increase his +power to the extent demanded by Palmerston, the more so as the French +Ministry was known to be jealous of the aggrandisement of Sardinia, and to +desire the establishment of weak Republics like those formed in 1796. +Withdrawing from its negotiations at London, the Emperor's Cabinet now +entered into direct communication with the Provisional Government at Milan, +and, without making any reference to Piedmont or Venice, offered complete +independence to Lombardy. As the union of this province with Piedmont had +already been voted by its inhabitants, the offer was at once rejected. +Moreover, even it the Italians had shown a disposition to compromise their +cause and abandon Venice, Radetzky would not have broken off the combat +while any possibility remained of winning over the Emperor from the side +of the peace-party. In reply to instructions directing him to offer an +armistice to the enemy, he sent Prince Felix Schwarzenberg to Innsbruck to +implore the Emperor to trust to the valour of his soldiers and to continue +the combat. Already there were signs that the victory would ultimately be +with Austria. Reinforcements had cut their way through the insurgent +territory and reached Verona; and although a movement by which Radetzky +threatened to sever Charles Albert's communications was frustrated by a +second engagement at Goito, and Peschiera passed into the besiegers' hands, +this was the last success won by the Italians. Throwing himself suddenly +eastwards, Radetzky appeared before Vicenza, and compelled this city, with +the entire Papal army, commanded by General Durando, to capitulate. The +fall of Vicenza was followed June, July, by that of the other cities on the +Venetian mainland till Venice alone on the east of the Adige defied the +Austrian arms. As the invader pressed onward, an Assembly which Manin had +convoked at Venice decided on union with Piedmont. Manin himself had been +the most zealous opponent of what he considered the sacrifice of Venetian +independence. He gave way nevertheless at the last, and made no attempt to +fetter the decision of the Assembly; but when this decision had been given +he handed over the conduct of affairs to others, and retired for awhile +into private life, declining to serve under a king. [426] + +[Battle of Custozza July 25.] + +[Austrians re-enter Milan, Aug. 6.] + +Charles Albert now renewed his attempt to wrest the central fortresses from +the Austrians. Leaving half his army at Peschiera and farther north, he +proceeded with the other half to blockade Mantua. Radetzky took advantage +of the unskilful generalship of his opponent, and threw himself upon the +weakly guarded centre of the long Sardinian line. The King perceived his +error, and sought to unite with his the northern detachments, now separated +from him by the Mincio. His efforts were baffled, and on the 25th of July, +after a brave resistance, his troops were defeated at Custozza. The retreat +across the Mincio was conducted in fair order, but disasters sustained by +the northern division, which should have held the enemy in check, destroyed +all hope, and the retreat then became a flight. Radetzky followed in close +pursuit. Charles Albert entered Milan, but declared himself unable to +defend the city. A storm of indignation broke out against the unhappy King +amongst the Milanese, whom he was declared to have betrayed. The palace +where he had taken up his quarters was besieged by the mob; his life was +threatened; and he escaped with difficulty on the night of August 5th under +the protection of General La Marmora and a few faithful Guards. A +capitulation was signed, and as the Piedmontese army evacuated the city +Radetzky's troops entered it in triumph. Not less than sixty thousand of +the inhabitants, according to Italian statements, abandoned their homes and +sought refuge in Switzerland or Piedmont rather than submit to the +conqueror's rule. Radetzky could now have followed his retreating enemy +without difficulty to Turin, and have crushed Piedmont itself under foot; +but the fear of France and Great Britain checked his career of victory, and +hostilities were brought to a close by an armistice at Vigevano on August +9th. [427] + +[The Austrian Court and Hungary.] + +The effects of Radetzky's triumph were felt in every province of the +Empire. The first open expression given to the changed state of affairs was +the return of the Imperial Court from its refuge at Innsbruck to Vienna. +The election promised in May had been held, and an Assembly representing +all the non-Hungarian parts of the Monarchy, with the exception of the +Italian provinces, had been opened by the Archduke John, as representative +of the Emperor, on the 22nd of July. Ministers and Deputies united in +demanding the return of the Emperor to the capital. With Radetzky and +Windischgraetz within call, the Emperor could now with some confidence face +his students and his Parliament. But of far greater importance than the +return of the Court to Vienna was the attitude which it now assumed towards +the Diet and the national Government of Hungary. The concessions made in +April, inevitable as they were, had in fact raised Hungary to the position +of an independent State. When such matters as the employment of Hungarian +troops against Italy or the distribution of the burden of taxation came +into question, the Emperor had to treat with the Hungarian Ministry almost +as if it represented a foreign and a rival Power. For some months this +humiliation had to be borne, and the appearance of fidelity to the new +Constitutional law maintained. But a deep, resentful hatred against the +Magyar cause penetrated the circles in which the old military and official +absolutism of Austria yet survived; and behind the men and the policy still +representing with some degree of sincerity the new order of things, there +gathered the passions and the intrigues of a reaction that waited only for +the outbreak of civil war within Hungary itself, and the restoration of +confidence to the Austrian army, to draw the sword against its foe. +Already, while Italy was still unsubdued, and the Emperor was scarcely safe +in his palace at Vienna, the popular forces that might be employed against +the Government at Pesth came into view. + +[The Serbs in Southern Hungary.] + +[Serb Congress at Carlowitz, May 13-15.] + +In one of the stormy sessions of the Hungarian Diet at the time when the +attempt was first made to impose the Magyar language upon Croatia the +Illyrian leader, Gai, had thus addressed the Assembly: "You Magyars are an +island in the ocean of Slavism. Take heed that its waves do not rise and +overwhelm you." The agitation of the spring of 1848 first revealed in its +full extent the peril thus foreshadowed. Croatia had for above a year been +in almost open mutiny, but the spirit of revolt now spread through the +whole of the Serb population of Southern Hungary, from the eastern limits +of Slavonia, [428] across the plain known as the Banat beyond the junction +of the Theiss and the Danube, up to the borders of Transylvania. The Serbs +had been welcomed into these provinces in the sixteenth and seventeenth +centuries by the sovereigns of Austria as a bulwark against the Turks. +Charters had been given to them, which were still preserved, promising them +a distinct political administration under their own elected Voivode, and +ecclesiastical independence under their own Patriarch of the Greek Church. +[429] These provincial rights had fared much as others in the Austrian +Empire. The Patriarch and the Voivode had disappeared, and the Banat had +been completely merged in Hungary. Enough, however, of Serb nationality +remained to kindle at the summons of 1848, and to resent with a sudden +fierceness the determination of the Magyar rulers at Pesth that the Magyar +language, as the language of State, should thenceforward bind together all +the races of Hungary in the enjoyment of a common national life. The Serbs +had demanded from Kossuth and his colleagues the restoration of the local +and ecclesiastical autonomy of which the Hapsburgs had deprived them, and +the recognition of their own national language and customs. They found, or +believed, that instead of a German they were now to have a Magyar lord, and +one more near, more energetic, more aggressive. Their reply to Kossuth's +defence of Magyar ascendency was the summoning of a Congress of Serbs at +Carlowitz on the Lower Danube. Here it was declared that the Serbs of +Austria formed a free and independent nation under the Austrian sceptre and +the common Hungarian Crown. A Voivode was elected and the limits of his +province were defined. A National Committee was charged with the duty of +organising a Government and of entering into intimate connection with the +neighbouring Slavic Kingdom of Croatia. + +[Jellacic in Croatia.] + +At Agram, the Croatian capital, all established authority had sunk in the +catastrophe of March, and a National Committee had assumed power. It +happened that the office of Governor, or Ban, of Croatia was then vacant. +The Committee sent a deputation to Vienna requesting that the colonel of +the first Croatian regiment, Jellacic, might be appointed. Without waiting +for the arrival of the deputation, the Court, by a patent dated the 23rd of +March, nominated Jellacic to the vacant post. The date of this appointment, +and the assumption of office by Jellacic on the 14th of April, the very day +before the Hungarian Ministry entered upon its powers, have been considered +proof that a secret understanding existed from the first between Jellacic +and the Court. No further evidence of this secret relation has, however, +been made public, and the belief long current among all friends of the +Magyar cause that Croatia was deliberately instigated to revolt against the +Hungarian Government by persons around the Emperor seems to rest on no +solid foundation. The Croats would have been unlike all other communities +in the Austrian Empire if they had not risen under the national impulse of +1848. They had been murmuring against Magyar ascendency for years past, and +the fire long smouldering now probably burst into flame here as elsewhere +without the touch of an incendiary hand. With regard to Jellacic's sudden +appointment it is possible that the Court, powerless to check the Croatian +movement, may have desired to escape the appearance of compulsion by +spontaneously conferring office on the popular soldier, who was at least +more likely to regard the Emperor's interests than the lawyers and +demagogues around him. Whether Jellacic was at this time genuinely +concerned for Croatian autonomy, or whether from the first, while he +apparently acted with the Croatian nationalists his deepest sympathies were +with the Austrian army, and his sole design was that of serving the +Imperial Crown with or without its own avowed concurrence, it is impossible +to say. That, like most of his countrymen, he cordially hated the Magyars, +is beyond doubt. The general impression left by his character hardly +accords with the Magyar conception of him as the profound and far-sighted +conspirator--he would seem, on the contrary, to have been a man easily +yielding to the impulses of the moment, and capable of playing +contradictory parts with little sense of his own inconsistency. [430] + +[Affairs of Croatia April 14-June 16.] + +Installed in office, Jellacic cast to the winds all consideration due to +the Emperor's personal engagements towards Hungary, and forthwith permitted +the Magyar officials to be driven out of the country. On the 2nd of May he +issued an order forbidding all Croatian authorities to correspond with the +Government at Pesth. Batthyany, the Hungarian Premier, at once hurried to +Vienna, and obtained from the Emperor a letter commanding Jellacic to +submit to the Hungarian Ministry. As the Ban paid no attention to this +mandate, General Hrabowsky, commander of the troops in the southern +provinces, received orders from Pesth to annul all that Jellacic had done, +to suspend him from his office, and to bring him to trial for high treason. +Nothing daunted, Jellacic on his own authority convoked the Diet of Croatia +for the 5th of June; the populace of Agram, on hearing of Hrabowsky's +mission, burnt the Palatine in effigy. This was a direct outrage on the +Imperial family, and Batthyany turned it to account. The Emperor had just +been driven from Vienna by the riot of the 15th of May. Batthyany sought +him at Innsbruck, and by assuring him of the support of his loyal +Hungarians against both the Italians and the Viennese obtained his +signature on June 10th to a rescript vehemently condemning the Ban's action +and suspending him from office. Jellacic had already been summoned to +appear at Innsbruck. He set out, taking with him a deputation of Croats and +Serbs, and leaving behind him a popular Assembly sitting at Agram, in +which, besides the representatives of Croatia, there were seventy Deputies +from the Serb provinces. On the very day on which the Ban reached +Innsbruck, the Imperial order condemning him and suspending him from his +functions was published by Batthyany at Pesth. Nor was the situation made +easier by the almost simultaneous announcement that civil war had broken +out on the Lower Danube, and that General Hrabowsky, on attempting to +occupy Carlowitz, had been attacked and compelled to retreat by the Serbs +under their national leader Stratimirovic. [431] + +[Jellacic, the Court, and the Hungarian Government.] + +It is said that the Emperor Ferdinand, during deliberations in council on +which the fate of the Austrian Empire depended, was accustomed to occupy +himself with counting the number of carriages that passed from right and +left respectively under the windows. In the struggle between Croatia and +Hungary he appears to have avoided even the formal exercise of authority, +preferring to commit the decision between the contending parties to the +Archduke John, as mediator or judge. John was too deeply immersed in other +business to give much attention to the matter. What really passed between +Jellacic and the Imperial family at Innsbruck is unknown. The official +request of the Ban was for the withdrawal or suppression of the rescript +signed by the Emperor on June 10th. Prince Esterhazy, who represented the +Hungarian Government at Innsbruck, was ready to make this concession; but +before the document could be revoked, it had been made public by Batthyany. +With the object of proving his fidelity to the Court, Jellacic now +published an address to the Croatian regiments serving in Lombardy, +entreating them not to be diverted from their duty to the Emperor in the +field by any report of danger to their rights and their nationality nearer +home. So great was Jellacic's influence with his countrymen that an appeal +from him of opposite tenor would probably have caused the Croatian +regiments to quit Radetzky in a mass, and so have brought the war in Italy +to an ignominious end. His action won for him a great popularity in the +higher ranks of the Austrian army, and probably gained for him, even if he +did not possess it before, the secret confidence of the Court. That some +understanding now existed is almost certain, for, in spite of the +unrepealed declaration of June 10th, and the postponement of the Archduke's +judgment, Jellacic was permitted to return to Croatia and to resume his +government. The Diet at Agram occupied itself with far-reaching schemes for +a confederation of the southern Slavs; but its discussions were of no +practical effect, and after some weeks it was extinguished under the form +of an adjournment. From this time Jellacic held dictatorial power. It was +unnecessary for him in his relations with Hungary any longer to keep up the +fiction of a mere defence of Croatian rights; he appeared openly as the +champion of Austrian unity. In negotiations which he held with Batthyany at +Vienna during the last days of July, he demanded the restoration of single +Ministries for War, Finance, and Foreign Affairs for the whole Austrian +Empire. The demand was indignantly refused, and the chieftains of the two +rival races quitted Vienna to prepare for war. + +[Imminent breach between Austria and Hungary.] + +[Jellacic restored to office, Sept. 3. He marches on Pesth.] + +The Hungarian National Parliament, elected under the new Constitution, had +been opened at Pesth on July 5th. Great efforts had been made, in view of +the difficulties with Croatia and of the suspected intrigues between the +Ban and the Court party, to induce the Emperor Ferdinand to appear at Pesth +in person. He excused himself from this on the ground of illness, but sent +a letter to the Parliament condemning not only in his own name but in that +of every member of the Imperial family the resistance offered to the +Hungarian Government in the southern provinces. If words bore any meaning, +the Emperor stood pledged to a loyal co-operation with the Hungarian +Ministers in defence of the unity and the constitution of the Hungarian +Kingdom as established by the laws of April. Yet at this very time the +Minister of War at Vienna was encouraging Austrian officers to join the +Serb insurgents. Kossuth, who conducted most of the business of the +Hungarian Government in the Lower Chamber at Pesth, made no secret of his +hostility to the central powers. While his colleagues sought to avoid a +breach with the other half of the Monarchy, it seemed to be Kossuth's +object rather to provoke it. In calling for a levy of two hundred thousand +men to crash the Slavic rebellion, he openly denounced the Viennese +Ministry and the Court as its promoters. In leading the debate upon the +Italian War, he endeavoured without the knowledge of his colleagues to +make the cession of the territory west of the Adige a condition of +Hungary's participation in the struggle. As Minister of Finance, he spared +neither word nor act to demonstrate his contempt for the financial +interests of Austria. Whether a gentler policy on the part of the most +powerful statesman in Hungary might have averted the impending conflict it +is vain to ask; but in the uncompromising enmity of Kossuth the Austrian +Court found its own excuse for acts in which shamelessness seemed almost to +rise into political virtue. No sooner had Radetzky's victories and the fall +of Milan brought the Emperor back to Vienna than the new policy came into +effect. The veto of the sovereign was placed upon the laws passed by the +Diet at Pesth for the defence of the Kingdom. The Hungarian Government was +required to reinstate Jellacic in his dignities, to enter into negotiations +at Vienna with him and the Austrian Ministry, and finally to desist from +all military preparations against the rebellious provinces. In answer to +these demands the Diet sent a hundred of its members to Vienna to claim +from the Emperor the fulfilment of his plighted word. The miserable man +received them on the 9th of September with protestations of his sincerity; +but even before the deputation had passed the palace-gates, there appeared +in the official gazette a letter under the Emperor's own hand replacing +Jellacic in office and acquitting him of every charge that had been brought +against him. It was for this formal recognition alone that Jellacic had +been waiting. On the 11th of September he crossed the Drave with his army, +and began his march against the Hungarian capital. [432] + +[Mission of Lamberg. He is murdered at Pesth, Sept. 28.] + +The Ministry now in office at Vienna was composed in part of men who had +been known as reformers in the early days of 1848; but the old order was +represented by Count Wessenberg, who had been Metternich's assistant at the +Congress of Vienna, and by Latour, the War Minister, a soldier of high +birth whose career dated back to the campaign of Austerlitz. Whatever +contempt might be felt by one section of the Cabinet for the other, its +members were able to unite against the independence of Hungary as they had +united against the independence of Italy. They handed in to the Emperor a +memorial in which the very concessions to which they owed their own +existence as a Constitutional Ministry were made a ground for declaring the +laws establishing Hungarian autonomy null and void. In a tissue of +transparent sophistries they argued that the Emperor's promise of a +Constitution to all his dominions on the 15th of March disabled him from +assenting, without the advice of his Viennese Ministry, to the resolutions +subsequently passed by the Hungarian Diet, although the union between +Hungary and the other Hereditary States had from the first rested solely on +the person of the monarch, and no German official had ever pretended to +exercise authority over Hungarians otherwise than by order of the sovereign +as Hungarian King. The publication of this Cabinet memorial, which appeared +in the journals at Pesth on the 15th of September, gave plain warning to +the Hungarians that, if they were not to be attacked by Jellacic and the +Austrian army simultaneously, they must make some compromise with the +Government at Vienna. Batthyany was inclined to concession, and after +resigning office in consequence of the Emperor's desertion he had already +re-assumed his post with colleagues disposed to accept his own pacific +policy. Kossuth spoke openly of war with Austria and of a dictatorship. As +Jellacic advanced towards Pesth, the Palatine took command of the Hungarian +army and marched southwards. On reaching Lake Baloton, on whose southern +shore the Croats were encamped, he requested a personal conference with +Jellacic, and sailed to the appointed place of meeting. But he waited in +vain for the Ban; and rightly interpreting this rejection of his overtures, +he fled from the army and laid down his office. The Emperor now sent +General Lamberg from Vienna with orders to assume the supreme command alike +over the Magyar and the Croatian forces, and to prevent an encounter. On +the success of Lamberg's mission hung the last chance of reconciliation +between Hungary and Austria. Batthyany, still clinging to the hope of +peace, set out for the camp in order to meet the envoy on his arrival. +Lamberg, desirous of obtaining the necessary credentials from the Hungarian +Government, made his way to Pesth. There he found Kossuth and a Committee +of Six installed in power. Under their influence the Diet passed a +resolution forbidding Lamberg to assume command of the Hungarian troops, +and declaring him a traitor if he should attempt to do so. The report +spread through Pesth that Lamberg had come to seize the citadel and bombard +the town; and before he could reach a place of safety he was attacked and +murdered by a raging mob. It was in vain that Batthyany, who now laid down +his office, besought the Government at Vienna to take no rash step of +vengeance. The pretext for annihilating Hungarian independence had been +given, and the mask was cast aside. A manifesto published by the Emperor on +the 3rd of October declared the Hungarian Parliament dissolved, and its +acts null and void. Martial law was proclaimed, and Jellacic appointed +commander of all the forces and representative of the sovereign. In the +course of the next few days it was expected that he would enter Pesth as +conqueror. + +[Manifesto of Oct. 3.] + +[Tumult of Oct. 6 at Vienna. Latour murdered.] + +In the meantime, however confidently the Government might reckon on +Jellacic's victory, the passions of revolution were again breaking loose in +Vienna itself. Increasing misery among the poor, financial panics, the +reviving efforts of professional agitators, had renewed the disturbances of +the spring in forms which alarmed the middle classes almost as much as the +holders of power. The conflict of the Government with Hungary brought +affairs to a crisis. After discovering the uselessness of negotiations with +the Emperor, the Hungarian Parliament had sent some of its ablest members +to request an audience from the Assembly sitting at Vienna, in order that +the representatives of the western half of the Empire might, even at the +last moment, have the opportunity of pronouncing a judgment upon the action +of the Court. The most numerous group in the Assembly was formed by the +Czech deputies from Bohemia. As Slavs, the Bohemian deputies had +sympathised with the Croats and Serbs in their struggle against Magyar +ascendency, and in their eyes Jellacic was still the champion of a national +cause. Blinded by their sympathies of race to the danger involved to all +nationalities alike by the restoration of absolutism, the Czech majority, +in spite of a singularly impressive warning given by a leader of the German +Liberals, refused a hearing to the Hungarian representatives. The Magyars, +repelled by the Assembly, sought and found allies in the democracy of +Vienna itself. The popular clubs rang with acclamations for the cause of +Hungarian freedom and with invectives against the Czech instruments of +tyranny. In the midst of this deepening agitation tidings arrived at Vienna +that Jellacic had been repulsed in his march on Pesth and forced to retire +within the Austrian frontier. It became necessary for the Viennese +Government to throw its own forces into the struggle, and an order was +given by Latour to the regiments in the capital to set out for the scene of +warfare. This order had, however, been anticipated by the democratic +leaders, and a portion of the troops had been won over to the popular side. +Latour's commands were resisted; and upon an attempt being made to enforce +the departure of the troops, the regiments fired on one another (October +6th). The battalions of the National Guard which rallied to the support of +the Government were overpowered by those belonging to the working men's +districts. The insurrection was victorious; the Ministers submitted once +more to the masters of the streets, and the orders given to the troops were +withdrawn. But the fiercer part of the mob was not satisfied with a +political victory. There were criminals and madmen among its leaders who, +after the offices of Government had been stormed and Latour had been +captured, determined upon his death. It was in vain that some of the +keenest political opponents of the Minister sought at the peril of their +own lives to protect him from his murderers. He was dragged into the court +in front of the War Office, and there slain with ferocious and yet +deliberate barbarity. [433] + +[The Emperor at Olmuetz.] + +[Windischgraetz marches on Vienna.] + +The Emperor, while the city was still in tumult, had in his usual fashion +promised that the popular demands should be satisfied; but as soon as he +was unobserved he fled from Vienna, and in his flight he was followed by +the Czech deputies and many German Conservatives, who declared that their +lives were no longer safe in the capital. Most of the Ministers gathered +round the Emperor at Olmuetz in Moravia; the Assembly, however, continued to +hold its sittings in Vienna, and the Finance Minister, apparently under +instructions from the Court, remained at his post, and treated the Assembly +as still possessed of legal powers. But for all practical purposes the +western half of the Austrian Empire had now ceased to have any Government +whatever; and the real state of affairs was bluntly exposed in a manifesto +published by Count Windischgraetz at Prague on the 11th of October, in +which, without professing to have received any commission from the Emperor, +he announced his intention of marching on Vienna in order to protect the +sovereign and maintain the unity of the Empire. In due course the Emperor +ratified the action of his energetic soldier; Windischgraetz was appointed +to the supreme command over all the troops of the Empire with the exception +of Radetzky's army, and his march against Vienna was begun. + +[Windischgraetz conquers Vienna, Oct. 26-Nov. 1.] + +To the Hungarian Parliament, exasperated by the decree ordering its own +dissolution and the war openly levied against the country by the Court in +alliance with Jellacic, the revolt of the capital seemed to bring a sudden +deliverance from all danger. The Viennese had saved Hungary, and the Diet +was willing, if summoned by the Assembly at Vienna, to send its troops to +the defence of the capital. But the urgency of the need was not understood +on either side till too late. The Viennese Assembly, treating itself as a +legitimate and constitutional power threatened by a group of soldiers who +had usurped the monarch's authority, hesitated to compromise its legal +character by calling in a Hungarian army. The Magyar generals on the other +hand were so anxious not to pass beyond the strict defence of their own +kingdom, that, in the absence of communication from a Viennese authority, +they twice withdrew from Austrian soil after following Jellacic in pursuit +beyond the frontier. It was not until Windischgraetz had encamped within +sight of Vienna, and had detained as a rebel the envoy sent to him by the +Hungarian Government, that Kossuth's will prevailed over the scruples of +weaker men, and the Hungarian army marched against the besiegers. In the +meantime Windischgraetz had begun his attack on the suburbs, which were +weakly defended by the National Guard and by companies of students and +volunteers, the nominal commander being one Messenhauser, formerly an +officer in the regular army, who was assisted by a soldier of far greater +merit than himself, the Polish general Bem. Among those who fought were two +members of the German Parliament of Frankfort, Robert Blum and Froebel, who +had been sent to mediate between the Emperor and his subjects, but had +remained at Vienna as combatants. The besiegers had captured the outskirts +of the city, and negotiations for surrender were in progress, when, on the +30th of October, Messenhauser from the top of the cathedral tower saw +beyond the line of the besiegers on the south-east the smoke of battle, and +announced that the Hungarian army was approaching. An engagement had in +fact begun on the plain of Schwechat between the Hungarians and Jellacic, +reinforced by divisions of Windischgraetz's troops. In a moment of wild +excitement the defenders of the capital threw themselves once more upon +their foe, disregarding the offer of surrender that had been already made. +But the tide of battle at Schwechat turned against the Hungarians. They +were compelled to retreat, and Windischgraetz, reopening his cannonade upon +the rebels who were also violators of their truce, became in a few hours +master of Vienna. He made his entry on the 31st of October, and treated +Vienna as a conquered city. The troops had behaved with ferocity during the +combat in the suburbs, and slaughtered scores of unarmed persons. No +Oriental tyrant ever addressed his fallen foes with greater insolence and +contempt for human right than Windischgraetz in the proclamations which, on +assuming government, he addressed to the Viennese; yet, whatever might be +the number of persons arrested and imprisoned, the number now put to death +was not great. The victims were indeed carefully selected; the most +prominent being Robert Blum, in whom, as a leader of the German Liberals +and a Deputy of the German Parliament inviolable by law, the Austrian +Government struck ostentatiously at the Parliament itself and at German +democracy at large. + +[The Parliament at Kremsier, Nov. 22.] + +[Schwarzenberg Minister.] + +In the subjugation of Vienna the army had again proved itself the real +political power in Austria; but the time had not yet arrived when absolute +government could be openly restored. The Bohemian deputies, fatally as they +had injured the cause of constitutional rule by their secession from +Vienna, were still in earnest in the cause of provincial autonomy, and +would vehemently have repelled the charge of an alliance with despotism. +Even the mutilated Parliament of Vienna had been recognised by the Court as +in lawful session until the 22nd of October, when an order was issued +proroguing the Parliament and bidding it re-assemble a month later at +Kremsier, in Moravia. There were indications in the weeks succeeding the +fall of Vienna of a conflict between the reactionary and the more liberal +influences surrounding the Emperor, and of an impending _coup d'etat_: +but counsels of prudence prevailed for the moment; the Assembly was +permitted to meet at Kremsier, and professions of constitutional principle +were still made with every show of sincerity. A new Ministry, however, came +into office, with Prince Felix Schwarzenberg at its head. Schwarzenberg +belonged to one of the greatest Austrian families. He had been ambassador +at Naples when the revolution of 1848 broke out, and had quitted the city +with words of menace when insult was offered to the Austrian flag. +Exchanging diplomacy for war, he served under Radetzky, and was soon +recognised as the statesman in whom the army, as a political power, found +its own peculiar representative. His career had hitherto been illustrated +chiefly by scandals of private life so flagrant that England and other +countries where he had held diplomatic posts had insisted on his removal; +but the cynical and reckless audacity of the man rose in his new calling as +Minister of Austria to something of political greatness. Few statesmen have +been more daring than Schwarzenberg; few have pushed to more excessive +lengths the advantages to be derived from the moral or the material +weakness of an adversary. His rule was the debauch of forces respited in +their extremity for one last and worst exertion. Like the Roman Sulla, he +gave to a condemned and perishing cause the passing semblance of restored +vigour, and died before the next great wave of change swept his creations +away. + +[Ferdinand abdicates, Dec. 2. Francis Joseph Emperor.] + +[Dissolution of the Kremsier Parliament, March 7, 1849.] + +[The Unitary Constitutional Edict, March, 1849.] + +Schwarzenberg's first act was the deposition of his sovereign. The +imbecility of the Emperor Ferdinand had long suggested his abdication or +dethronement, and the time for decisive action had now arrived. He gladly +withdrew into private life: the crown, declined by his brother and heir, +was passed on to his nephew, Francis Joseph, a youth of eighteen. This +prince had at least not made in person, not uttered with his own lips, not +signed with his own hand, those solemn engagements with the Hungarian +nation which Austria was now about to annihilate with fire and sword. He +had not moved in friendly intercourse with men who were henceforth doomed +to the scaffold. He came to the throne as little implicated in the acts of +his predecessor as any nominal chief of a State could be; as fitting an +instrument in the hands of Court and army as any reactionary faction could +desire. Helpless and well-meaning, Francis Joseph, while his troops poured +into Hungary, played for a while in Austria the part of a loyal observer of +his Parliament; then, when the moment had come for its destruction, he +obeyed his soldier-minister as Ferdinand had in earlier days obeyed the +students, and signed the decree for its dissolution (March 4, 1849). The +Assembly, during its sittings at Vienna, had accomplished one important +task: it had freed the peasantry from the burdens attaching to their land +and converted them into independent proprietors. This part of its work +survived it, and remained almost the sole gain that Austria derived from +the struggle of 1848. After the removal to Kremsier, a Committee of the +Assembly had been engaged with the formation of a Constitution for Austria, +and the draft was now completed. In the course of debate something had been +gained by the representatives of the German and the Slavic races in the way +of respect for one another's interests and prejudices; some political +knowledge had been acquired; some approach made to an adjustment between +the claims of the central power and of provincial autonomy. If the +Constitution sketched at Kremsier had come into being, it would at least +have given to Western Austria and to Galicia, which belonged to this half +of the Empire, a system of government based on popular desires and worthy, +on the part of the Crown, of a fair trial. But, apart from its own defects +from the monarchical point of view, this Constitution rested on the +division of the Empire into two independent parts; it assumed the +separation of Hungary from the other Hereditary States; and of a separate +Hungarian Kingdom the Minister now in power would hear no longer. That +Hungary had for centuries possessed and maintained its rights; that, with +the single exception of the English, no nation in Europe had equalled the +Magyars in the stubborn and unwearied defence of Constitutional law; that, +in an age when national spirit was far less hotly inflamed, the Emperor +Joseph had well-nigh lost his throne and wrecked his Empire in the attempt +to subject this resolute race to a centralised administration, was nothing +to Schwarzenberg and the soldiers who were now trampling upon revolution. +Hungary was declared to have forfeited by rebellion alike its ancient +rights and the contracts of 1848. The dissolution of the Parliament of +Kremsier was followed by the publication of an edict affecting to bestow a +uniform and centralised Constitution upon the entire Austrian Empire. All +existing public rights were thereby extinguished; and, inasmuch as the new +Constitution, in so far as it provided for a representative system, never +came into existence, but remained in abeyance until it was formally +abrogated in 1851, the real effect of the Unitary Edict of March, 1849, +which professed to close the period of revolution by granting the same +rights to all, was to establish absolute government and the rule of the +sword throughout the Emperor's dominions. Provincial institutions giving to +some of the German and Slavic districts a shadowy control of their own +local affairs only marked the distinction between the favoured and the +dreaded parts of the Empire. Ten years passed before freedom again came +within sight of the Austrian peoples. [434] + +[Hungary.] + +[The Roumanians in Transylvania.] + +The Hungarian Diet, on learning of the transfer of the crown from Ferdinand +to Francis Joseph, had refused to acknowledge this act as valid, on the +ground that it had taken place without the consent of the Legislature, and +that Francis Joseph had not been crowned King of Hungary. Ferdinand was +treated as still the reigning sovereign, and the war now became, according +to the Hungarian view, more than ever a war in defence of established +right, inasmuch as the assailants of Hungary were not only violators of a +settled constitution but agents of a usurping prince. The whole nation was +summoned to arms; and in order that there might be no faltering at +headquarters, the command over the forces on the Danube was given by +Kossuth to Goergei, a young officer of whom little was yet known to the +world but that he had executed Count Eugene Zichy, a powerful noble, for +holding communications with Jellacic. It was the design of the Austrian +Government to attack Hungary at once by the line of the Danube and from the +frontier of Galicia on the north-east. The Serbs were to be led forward +from their border-provinces against the capital; and another race, which +centuries of oppression had filled with bitter hatred of the Magyars, was +to be thrown into the struggle. The mass of the population of Transylvania +belonged to the Roumanian stock. The Magyars, here known by the name of +Szeklers, and a community of Germans, descended from immigrants who settled +in Transylvania about the twelfth century, formed a small but a privileged +minority, in whose presence the Roumanian peasantry, poor, savage, and +absolutely without political rights, felt themselves before 1848 scarcely +removed from serfdom. In the Diet of Transylvania the Magyars held command, +and in spite of the resistance of the Germans, they had succeeded in +carrying an Act, in May, 1848, uniting the country with Hungary. This Act +had been ratified by the Emperor Ferdinand, but it was followed by a +widespread insurrection of the Roumanian peasantry, who were already +asserting their claims as a separate nation and demanding equality with +their oppressors. The rising of the Roumanians had indeed more of the +character of an agrarian revolt than of a movement for national +independence. It was marked by atrocious cruelty; and although the Hapsburg +standard was raised, the Austrian commandant, General Puchner, hesitated +long before lending the insurgents his countenance. At length, in October, +he declared against the Hungarian Government. The union of the regular +troops with the peasantry overpowered for a time all resistance. The towns +fell under Austrian sway, and although the Szeklers were not yet disarmed, +Transylvania seemed to be lost to Hungary. General Puchner received orders +to lead his troops, with the newly formed Roumanian militia, westward into +the Banat, in order to co-operate in the attack which was to overwhelm the +Hungarians from every quarter of the kingdom. [435] + +[The Austrians occupy Pesth, Jan. 5, 1849.] + +On the 15th of December, Windischgraetz, in command of the main Austrian +army, crossed the river Leitha, the border between German and Magyar +territory. Goergei, who was opposed to him, had from the first declared that +Pesth must be abandoned and a war of defence carried on in Central Hungary. +Kossuth, however, had scorned this counsel, and announced that he would +defend Pesth to the last. The backwardness of the Hungarian preparations +and the disorder of the new levies justified the young general, who from +this time assumed the attitude of contempt and hostility towards the +Committee of Defence. Kossuth had in fact been strangely served by fortune +in his choice of Goergei. He had raised him to command on account of one +irretrievable act of severity against an Austrian partisan, and without any +proof of his military capacity. In the untried soldier he had found a +general of unusual skill; in the supposed devotee to Magyar patriotism he +had found a military politician as self-willed and as insubordinate as any +who have ever distracted the councils of a falling State. Dissensions and +misunderstandings aggravated the weakness of the Hungarians in the field. +Position after position was lost, and it soon became evident that the +Parliament and Government could remain no longer at Pesth. They withdrew to +Debreczin beyond the Theiss, and on the 5th of January, 1849, Windischgraetz +made his entry into the capital. [436] + +[The Hungarian Government at Debreczin.] + +[Kossuth and Goergei.] + +The Austrians now supposed the war to be at an end. It was in fact but +beginning. The fortress of Comorn, on the upper Danube, remained in the +hands of the Magyars; and by conducting his retreat northwards into a +mountainous country where the Austrians could not follow him Goergei gained +the power either of operating against Windischgraetz's communications or of +combining with the army of General Klapka, who was charged with the defence +of Hungary against an enemy advancing from Galicia. While Windischgraetz +remained inactive at Pesth, Klapka met and defeated an Austrian division +under General Schlick which had crossed the Carpathians and was moving +southwards towards Debreczin. Goergei now threw himself eastwards upon the +line of retreat of the beaten enemy, and Schlick's army only escaped +capture by abandoning its communications and seeking refuge with +Windischgraetz at Pesth. A concentration of the Magyar forces was effected +on the Theiss, and the command over the entire army was given by Kossuth to +Dembinski, a Pole who had gained distinction in the wars of Napoleon and in +the campaign of 1831. Goergei, acting as the representative of the officers +who had been in the service before the Revolution, had published an address +declaring that the army would fight for no cause but that of the +Constitution as established by Ferdinand, the legitimate King, and that it +would accept no commands but those of the Ministers whom Ferdinand had +appointed. Interpreting this manifesto as a direct act of defiance, and as +a warning that the army might under Goergei's command make terms on its own +authority with the Austrian Government, Kossuth resorted to the dangerous +experiment of superseding the national commanders by a Pole who was +connected with the revolutionary party throughout Europe. The act was +disastrous in its moral effects upon the army; and, as a general, Dembinski +entirely failed to justify his reputation. After permitting Schlick's corps +to escape him he moved forwards from the Theiss against Pesth. He was met +by the Austrians and defeated at Kapolna (February 26). Both armies retired +to their earlier positions, and, after a declaration from the Magyar +generals that they would no longer obey his orders, Dembinski was removed +from his command, though he remained in Hungary to interfere once more with +evil effect before the end of the war. + +[The Austrians driven out of Hungary, April.] + +The struggle between Austria and Hungary had reached this stage when the +Constitution merging all provincial rights in one centralised system was +published by Schwarzenberg. The Croats, the Serbs, the Roumanians, who had +so credulously flocked to the Emperor's banner under the belief that they +were fighting for their own independence, at length discovered their +delusion. Their enthusiasm sank; the bolder among them even attempted to +detach their countrymen from the Austrian cause; but it was too late to +undo what had already been done. Jellacic, now undistinguishable from any +other Austrian general, mocked the politicians of Agram who still babbled +of Croatian autonomy: Stratimirovic, the national leader of the Serbs, sank +before his rival the Patriarch of Carlowitz, a Churchman who preferred +ecclesiastical immunities granted by the Emperor of Austria to independence +won on the field of battle by his countrymen. Had a wiser or more generous +statesmanship controlled the Hungarian Government in the first months of +its activity, a union between the Magyars and the subordinate races against +Viennese centralisation might perhaps even now have been effected. But +distrust and animosity had risen too high for the mediators between Slav +and Magyar to attain any real success, nor was any distinct promise of +self-government even now to be drawn from the offers of concession which +were held out at Debreczin. An interval of dazzling triumph seemed indeed +to justify the Hungarian Government in holding fast to its sovereign +claims. In the hands of able leaders no task seemed too hard for Magyar +troops to accomplish. Bem, arriving in Transylvania without a soldier, +created a new army, and by a series of extraordinary marches and surprises +not only overthrew the Austrian and Roumanian troops opposed to him, but +expelled a corps of Russians whom General Puchner in his extremity had +invited to garrison Hermannstadt. Goergei, resuming in the first week of +April the movement in which Dembinski had failed, inflicted upon the +Austrians a series of defeats that drove them back to the walls of Pesth; +while Klapka, advancing on Comorn, effected the relief of this fortress, +and planted in the rear of the Austrians a force which threatened to cut +them off from Vienna. It was in vain that the Austrian Government removed +Windischgraetz from his command. His successor found that a force superior +to his own was gathering round him on every side. He saw that Hungary was +lost; and leaving a garrison in the fortress of Buda, he led off his army +in haste from the capital, and only paused in his retreat when he had +reached the Austrian frontier. + +[Declaration of Hungarian Independence, April 19.] + +The Magyars, rallying from their first defeats, had brilliantly achieved +the liberation of their land. The Court of Vienna, attempting in right of +superior force to overthrow an established constitution, had proved itself +the inferior power; and in mingled exaltation and resentment it was natural +that the party and the leaders who had been foremost in the national +struggle of Hungary should deem a renewed union with Austria impossible, +and submission to the Hapsburg crown an indignity. On the 19th of April, +after the defeat of Windischgraetz but before the evacuation of Pesth, the +Diet declared that the House of Hapsburg had forfeited its throne, and +proclaimed Hungary an independent State. No statement was made as to the +future form of government, but everything indicated that Hungary, if +successful in maintaining its independence, would become a Republic, with +Kossuth, who was now appointed Governor, for its chief. Even in the +revolutionary severance of ancient ties homage was paid to the legal and +constitutional bent of the Hungarian mind. Nothing was said in the +Declaration of April 19th of the rights of man; there was no Parisian +commonplace on the sovereignty of the people. The necessity of Hungarian +independence was deduced from the offences which the Austrian House had +committed against the written and unwritten law of the land, offences +continued through centuries and crowned by the invasion under +Windischgraetz, by the destruction of the Hungarian Constitution in the +edict of March 9th, and by the introduction of the Russians into +Transylvania. Though coloured and exaggerated by Magyar patriotism, the +charges made against the Hapsburg dynasty were on the whole in accordance +with historical fact; and if the affairs of States were to be guided by no +other considerations than those relating to the performance of contracts, +Hungary had certainly established its right to be quit of partnership with +Austria and of its Austrian sovereign. But the judgment of history has +condemned Kossuth's declaration of Hungarian independence in the midst of +the struggle of 1849 as a great political error. It served no useful +purpose; it deepened the antagonism already existing between the Government +and a large part of the army; and while it added to the sources of internal +discord, it gave colour to the intervention of Russia as against a +revolutionary cause. Apart from its disastrous effect upon the immediate +course of events, it was based upon a narrow and inadequate view both of +the needs and of the possibilities of the future. Even in the interests of +the Magyar nation itself as a European power, it may well be doubted +whether in severance from Austria such influence and such weight could +possibly have been won by a race numerically weak and surrounded by hostile +nationalities, as the ability and the political energy of the Magyars have +since won for them in the direction of the accumulated forces of the +Austro-Hungarian Empire. + +[Russian intervention against Hungary.] + +It has generally been considered a fatal error on the part of the Hungarian +commanders that, after expelling the Austrian army, they did not at once +march upon Vienna, but returned to lay siege to the fortress of Buda, which +resisted long enough to enable the Austrian Government to reorganise and to +multiply its forces. But the intervention of Russia would probably have +been fatal to Hungarian independence, even if Vienna had been captured and +a democratic government established there for a while in opposition to the +Court at Olmuetz. The plan of a Russian intervention, though this +intervention was now explained by the community of interest between Polish +and Hungarian rebels, was no new thing. Soon after the outbreak of the +March Revolution the Czar had desired to send his troops both into Prussia +and into Austria as the restorers of monarchical authority. His help was +declined on behalf of the King of Prussia; in Austria the project had been +discussed at successive moments of danger, and after the overthrow of the +Imperial troops in Transylvania by Bem the proffered aid was accepted. The +Russians who then occupied Hermannstadt did not, however, enter the country +as combatants; their task was to garrison certain positions still held by +the Austrians, and so to set free the Emperor's troops for service in the +field. On the declaration of Hungarian independence, it became necessary +for Francis Joseph to accept his protector's help without qualification or +disguise. An army of eighty thousand Russians marched across Galicia to +assist the Austrians in grappling with an enemy before whom, when +single-handed, they had succumbed. Other Russian divisions, while Austria +massed its troops on the Upper Danube, entered Transylvania from the south +and east, and the Magyars in the summer of 1849 found themselves compelled +to defend their country against forces three times more numerous than their +own. [437] + +[The summer campaign in Hungary, July-August, 1849.] + +[Capitulation of Vilagos, August 13.] + +[Vengeance of Austria.] + +When it became known that the Czar had determined to throw all his strength +into the scale, Kossuth saw that no ordinary operations of war could +possibly avert defeat, and called upon his countrymen to destroy their +homes and property at the approach of the enemy, and to leave to the +invader a flaming and devastated solitude. But the area of warfare was too +vast for the execution of this design, even if the nation had been prepared +for so desperate a course. The defence of Hungary was left to its armies, +and Goergei became the leading figure in the calamitous epoch that followed. +While the Government prepared to retire to Szegedin, far in the south-east, +Goergei took post on the Upper Danube, to meet the powerful force which the +Emperor of Austria had placed under the orders of General Haynau, a soldier +whose mingled energy and ferocity in Italy had marked him out as a fitting +scourge for the Hungarians, and had won for him supreme civil as well as +military powers. Goergei naturally believed that the first object of the +Austrian commander would be to effect a junction with the Russians, who, +under Paskiewitsch, the conqueror of Kars in 1829, were now crossing the +Carpathians; and he therefore directed all his efforts against the left of +the Austrian line. While he was unsuccessfully attacking the enemy on the +river Waag north of Comorn, Haynau with the mass of his forces advanced on +the right bank of the Danube, and captured Raab (June 28th). Goergei threw +himself southwards, but his efforts to stop Haynau were in vain, and the +Austrians occupied Pesth (July 11th). The Russians meanwhile were advancing +southwards by an independent line of march. Their vanguard reached the +Danube and the Upper Theiss, and Goergei seemed to be enveloped by the +enemy. The Hungarian Government adjured him to hasten towards Szegedin and +Arad, where Kossuth was concentrating all the other divisions for a final +struggle; but Goergei held on to his position about Comorn until his retreat +could only be effected by means of a vast detour northwards, and before he +could reach Arad all was lost. Dembinski was again in command. Charged with +the defence of the passage of the Theiss about Szegedin, he failed to +prevent the Austrians from crossing the river, and on the 5th of August was +defeated at Czoreg with heavy loss. Kossuth now gave the command to Bern, +who had hurried from Transylvania, where overpowering forces had at length +wrested victory from his grasp. Bern fought the last battle of the campaign +at Temesvar. He was overthrown and driven eastwards, but succeeded in +leading a remnant of his army across the Moldavian frontier and so escaped +capture. Goergei, who was now close to Arad, had some strange fancy that it +would dishonour his army to seek refuge on neutral soil. He turned +northwards so as to encounter Russian and not Austrian regiments, and +without striking a blow, without stipulating even for the lives of the +civilians in his camp, he led his army within the Russian lines at Vilagos, +and surrendered unconditionally to the generals of the Czar. His own life +was spared; no mercy was shown to those who were handed over as his +fellow-prisoners by the Russian to the Austrian Government, or who were +seized by Haynau as his troops advanced. Tribunals more resembling those of +the French Reign of Terror than the Courts of a civilised Government sent +the noblest patriots and soldiers of Hungary to the scaffold. To the deep +disgrace of the Austrian Crown, Count Batthyany, the Minister of Ferdinand, +was included among those whose lives were sacrificed. The vengeance of the +conqueror seemed the more frenzied and the more insatiable because it had +only been rendered possible by foreign aid. Crushed under an iron rule, +exhausted by war, the prey of a Government which knew only how to employ +its subject-races as gaolers over one another, Hungary passed for some +years into silence and almost into despair. Every vestige of its old +constitutional rights was extinguished. Its territory was curtailed by the +separation of Transylvania and Croatia; its administration was handed over +to Germans from Vienna. A conscription, enforced not for the ends of +military service but as the surest means of breaking the national spirit, +enrolled its youth in Austrian regiments, and banished them to the +extremities of the empire. No darker period was known in the history of +Hungary since the wars of the seventeenth century than that which followed +the catastrophe of 1849. [438] + +[Italian affairs, August, 1848-March, 1849.] + +[Murder of Rossi, Nov. 15. Flight of Pius IX.] + +[Roman Republic, Feb. 9, 1849.] + +[Tuscany.] + +The gloom which followed Austrian victory was now descending not on Hungary +alone but on Italy also. The armistice made between Radetzky and the King +of Piedmont at Vigevano in August, 1848, lasted for seven months, during +which the British and French Governments endeavoured, but in vain, to +arrange terms of peace between the combatants. With military tyranny in its +most brutal form crushing down Lombardy, it was impossible that Charles +Albert should renounce the work of deliverance to which he had pledged +himself. Austria, on the other hand, had now sufficiently recovered its +strength to repudiate the concessions which it had offered at an earlier +time, and Schwarzenberg on assuming power announced that the Emperor would +maintain Lombardy at every cost. The prospects of Sardinia as regarded help +from the rest of the Peninsula were far worse than when it took up arms in +the spring of 1848. Projects of a general Italian federation, of a military +union between the central States and Piedmont, of an Italian Constituent +Assembly, had succeeded one another and left no result. Naples had fallen +back into absolutism; Rome and Tuscany, from which aid might still have +been expected, were distracted by internal contentions, and hastening as it +seemed towards anarchy. After the defeat of Charles Albert at Custozza, +Pius IX., who was still uneasily playing his part as a constitutional +sovereign, had called to office Pellegrino Rossi, an Italian patriot of an +earlier time, who had since been ambassador of Louis Philippe at Rome, and +by his connection with the Orleanist Monarchy had incurred the hatred of +the Republican party throughout Italy. Rossi, as a vigorous and independent +reformer, was as much detested in clerical and reactionary circles as he +was by the demagogues and their followers. This, however, profited him +nothing; and on the 15th of November, as he was proceeding to the opening +of the Chambers, he was assassinated by an unknown hand. Terrified by this +crime, and by an attack upon his own palace by which it was followed, Pius +fled to Gaeta and placed himself under the protection of the King of +Naples. A Constituent Assembly was summoned and a Republic proclaimed at +Rome, between which and the Sardinian Government there was so little +community of feeling that Charles Albert would, if the Pope had accepted +his protection, have sent his troops to restore him to a position of +security. In Tuscany affairs were in a similar condition. The Grand Duke +had for some months been regarded as a sincere, though reserved, friend of +the Italian cause, and he had even spoken of surrendering his crown if this +should be for the good of the Italian nation. When, however, the Pope had +fled to Gaeta, and the project was openly avowed of uniting Tuscany with +the Roman States in a Republic, the Grand Duke, moved more by the +fulminations of Pius against his despoilers than by care for his own crown, +fled in his turn, leaving the Republicans masters of Florence. A miserable +exhibition of vanity, riot, and braggadocio was given to the world by the +politicians of the Tuscan State. Alike in Florence and in Rome all sense of +the true needs of the moment, of the absolute uselessness of internal +changes of Government if Austria was to maintain its dominion, seemed to +have vanished from men's minds. Republican phantoms distracted the heart +and the understanding; no soldier, no military administrator arose till too +late by the side of the rhetoricians and mob-leaders who filled the stage; +and when, on the 19th of March, the armistice was brought to a close in +Upper Italy, Piedmont took the field alone. [439] + +[The Match campaign, 1849.] + +[Battle of Novara, March 23.] + +The campaign which now began lasted but for five days. While Charles Albert +scattered his forces from Lago Maggiore to Stradella on the south of the +Po, hoping to move by the northern road upon Milan, Radetzky concentrated +his troops near Pavia, where he intended to cross the Ticino. In an evil +moment Charles Albert had given the command of his army to Chrzanowski, a +Pole, and had entrusted its southern division, composed chiefly of Lombard +volunteers, to another Pole, Ramorino, who had been engaged in Mazzini's +incursion into Savoy in 1833. Ramorino had then, rightly or wrongly, +incurred the charge of treachery. His relations with Chrzanowski were of +the worst character, and the habit of military obedience was as much +wanting to him as the sentiment of loyalty to the sovereign from whom he +had now accepted a command. The wilfulness of this adventurer made the +Piedmontese army an easy prey. Ramorino was posted on the south of the Po, +near its junction with the Ticino, but received orders on the commencement +of hostilities to move northwards and defend the passage of the Ticino at +Pavia, breaking up the bridges behind him. Instead of obeying this order he +kept his division lingering about Stradella. Radetzky, approaching the +Ticino at Pavia, found the passage unguarded. He crossed the river with the +mass of his army, and, cutting off Ramorino's division, threw himself upon +the flank of the scattered Piedmontese. Charles Albert, whose headquarters +were at Novara, hurried southwards. Before he could concentrate his troops, +he was attacked at Mortara by the Austrians and driven back. The line of +retreat upon Turin and Alessandria was already lost; an attempt was made to +hold Novara against the advancing Austrians. The battle which was fought in +front of this town on the 23rd of March ended with the utter overthrow of +the Sardinian army. So complete was the demoralisation of the troops that +the cavalry were compelled to attack bodies of half-maddened infantry in +the streets of Novara in order to save the town from pillage. [440] + +[Abdication of Charles Albert.] + +Charles Albert had throughout the battle of the 23rd appeared to seek +death. The reproaches levelled against him for the abandonment of Milan in +the previous year, the charges of treachery which awoke to new life the +miserable record of his waverings in 1821, had sunk into the very depths of +his being. Weak and irresolute in his earlier political career, harsh and +illiberal towards the pioneers of Italian freedom during a great part of +his reign, Charles had thrown his whole heart and soul into the final +struggle of his country against Austria. This struggle lost, life had +nothing more for him. The personal hatred borne towards him by the rulers +of Austria caused him to believe that easier terms of peace might be +granted to Piedmont if another sovereign were on its throne, and his +resolution, in case of defeat, was fixed and settled. When night fell after +the battle of Novara he called together his generals, and in their presence +abdicated his crown. Bidding an eternal farewell to his son Victor +Emmanuel, who knelt weeping before him, he quitted the army accompanied by +but one attendant, and passed unrecognised through the enemy's guards. He +left his queen, his capital, unvisited as he journeyed into exile. The +brief residue of his life was spent in solitude near Oporto. Six months +after the battle of Novara he was carried to the grave. + +[Beginning of Victor Emmanuel's reign.] + +It may be truly said of Charles Albert that nothing in his reign became him +like the ending of it. Hopeless as the conflict of 1849 might well appear, +it proved that there was one sovereign in Italy who was willing to stake +his throne, his life, the whole sum of his personal interests, for the +national cause; one dynasty whose sons knew no fear save that others should +encounter death before them on Italy's behalf. Had the profoundest +statesmanship, the keenest political genius, governed the counsels of +Piedmont in 1849, it would, with full prescience of the ruin of Novara, +have bidden the sovereign and the army strike in self-sacrifice their last +unaided blow. From this time there was but one possible head for Italy. The +faults of the Government of Turin during Charles Albert's years of peace +had ceased to have any bearing on Italian affairs; the sharpest tongues no +longer repeated, the most credulous ear no longer harboured the slanders of +1848; the man who, beaten and outnumbered, had for hours sat immovable in +front of the Austrian cannon at Novara had, in the depth of his misfortune, +given to his son not the crown of Piedmont only but the crown of Italy. +Honour, patriotism, had made the young Victor Emmanuel the hope of the +Sardinian army; the same honour and patriotism carried him safely past the +lures which Austria set for the inheritor of a ruined kingdom, and gave in +the first hours of his reign an earnest of the policy which was to end in +Italian union. It was necessary for him to visit Radetzky in his camp in +order to arrange the preliminaries of peace. There, amid flatteries offered +to him at his father's expense, it was notified to him that if he would +annul the Constitution that his father had made, he might reckon not only +on an easy quittance with the conqueror, but on the friendship and support +of Austria. This demand, though strenuously pressed in later negotiations, +Victor Emmanuel unconditionally refused. He had to endure for a while the +presence of Austrian troops in his kingdom, and to furnish an indemnity +which fell heavily on so small a State; but the liberties of his people +remained intact, and the pledge given by his father inviolate. Amid the +ruin of all hopes and the bankruptcy of all other royal reputations +throughout Italy, there proved to be one man, one government, in which the +Italian people could trust. This compensation at least was given in the +disasters of 1849, that the traitors to the cause of Italy and of freedom +could not again deceive, nor the dream of a federation of princes again +obscure the necessity of a single national government. In the fidelity of +Victor Emmanuel to the Piedmontese Constitution lay the pledge that when +Italy's next opportunity should arrive, the chief would be there who would +meet the nation's need. + +[Restoration in Tuscany.] + +[Rome and France.] + +[French intervention determined on.] + +The battle of Novara had not long been fought when the Grand Duke of +Tuscany was restored to his throne under an Austrian garrison, and his late +democratic Minister, Guerazzi, who had endeavoured by submission to the +Court-party to avert an Austrian occupation, was sent into imprisonment. At +Rome a far bolder spirit was shown. Mazzini had arrived in the first week +of March, and, though his exhortation to the Roman Assembly to forget the +offences of Charles Albert and to unite against the Austrians in Lombardy +came too late, he was able, as one of a Triumvirate with dictatorial +powers, to throw much of his own ardour into the Roman populace in defence +of their own city and State. The enemy against whom Rome had to be defended +proved indeed to be other than that against whom preparations were being +made. The victories of Austria had aroused the apprehension of the French +Government; and though the fall of Piedmont and Lombardy could not now be +undone, it was determined by Louis Napoleon and his Ministers to anticipate +Austria's restoration of the Papal power by the despatch of French troops +to Rome. All the traditions of French national policy pointed indeed to +such an intervention. Austria had already invaded the Roman States from the +north, and the political conditions which in 1832 had led so pacific a +minister as Casimir Perier to occupy Ancona were now present in much +greater force. Louis Napoleon could not, without abandoning a recognised +interest and surrendering something of the due influence of France, have +permitted Austrian generals to conduct the Pope back to his capital and to +assume the government of Central Italy. If the first impulses of the +Revolution of 1848 had still been active in France, its intervention would +probably have taken the form of a direct alliance with the Roman Republic; +but public opinion had travelled far in the opposite direction since the +Four Days of June; and the new President, if he had not forgotten his own +youthful relations with the Carbonari, was now a suitor for the solid +favours of French conservative and religious sentiment. His Ministers had +not recognised the Roman Republic. They were friends, no doubt, to liberty; +but when it was certain that the Austrians, the Spaniards, the Neapolitans, +were determined to restore the Pope, it might be assumed that the +continuance of the Roman Republic was an impossibility. France, as a +Catholic and at the same time a Liberal Power, might well, under these +circumstances, address itself to the task of reconciling Roman liberty with +the inevitable return of the Holy Father to his temporal throne. Events +were moving too fast for diplomacy; troops must be at once despatched, or +the next French envoy would find Radetzky on the Tiber. The misgivings of +the Republican part of the Assembly at Paris were stilled by French +assurances of the generous intentions of the Government towards the Roman +populations, and of its anxiety to shelter them from Austrian domination, +President, Ministers, and generals resolutely shut their eyes to the +possibility that a French occupation of Rome might be resisted by force by +the Romans themselves; and on the 22nd of April an armament of about ten +thousand men set sail for Civita Vecchia under the command of General +Oudinot, a son of the Marshal of that name. + +[The French at Civita Vecchia, April 25, 1849.] + +[Oudinot attacks Rome and is repelled, April 30.] + +Before landing on the Italian coast, the French general sent envoys to the +authorities at Civita Vecchia, stating that his troops came as friends, and +demanding that they should be admitted into the town. The Municipal Council +determined not to offer resistance, and the French thus gained a footing on +Italian soil and a basis for their operations. Messages came from French +diplomatists in Rome encouraging the general to advance without delay. The +mass of the population, it was said, would welcome his appearance; the +democratic faction, if reckless, was too small to offer any serious +resistance, and would disappear as soon as the French should enter the +city. On this point, however, Oudinot was speedily undeceived. In reply to +a military envoy who was sent to assure the Triumvirs of the benevolent +designs of the French, Mazzini bluntly answered that no reconciliation with +the Pope was possible; and on the 26th of April the Roman Assembly called +upon the Executive to repel force by force. Oudinot now proclaimed a state +of siege at Civita Vecchia, seized the citadel, and disarmed the garrison. +On the 28th he began his march on Rome. As he approached, energetic +preparations were made for resistance. Garibaldi, who had fought at the +head of a free corps against the Austrians in Upper Italy in 1848, had now +brought some hundreds of his followers to Rome. A regiment of Lombard +volunteers, under their young leader Manara, had escaped after the +catastrophe of Novara, and had come to fight for liberty in its last +stronghold on Italian soil. Heroes, exiles, desperadoes from all parts of +the Peninsula, met in the streets of Rome, and imparted to its people a +vigour and resolution of which the world had long deemed them incapable. +Even the remnant of the Pontifical Guard took part in the work of defence. +Oudinot, advancing with his little corps of seven thousand men, found +himself, without heavy artillery, in front of a city still sheltered by its +ancient fortifications, and in the presence of a body of combatants more +resolute than his own troops and twice as numerous. He attacked on the +30th, was checked at every point, and compelled to retreat towards Civita +Vecchia, leaving two hundred and fifty prisoners in the hands of the enemy. +[441] + +[French policy, April-May.] + +Insignificant as was this misfortune of the French arms, it occasioned no +small stir in Paris and in the Assembly. The Government, which had declared +that the armament was intended only to protect Rome against Austria, was +vehemently reproached for its duplicity, and a vote was passed demanding +that the expedition should not be permanently diverted from the end +assigned to it. Had the Assembly not been on the verge of dissolution it +would probably have forced upon the Government a real change of policy. A +general election, however, was but a few days distant, and until the result +of this election should be known the Ministry determined to temporise. M. +Lesseps, since famous as the creator of the Suez Canal, was sent to Rome +with instructions to negotiate for some peaceable settlement. More honest +than his employers, Lesseps sought with heart and soul to fulfil his task. +While he laboured in city and camp, the French elections for which the +President and Ministers were waiting took place, resulting in the return of +a Conservative and reactionary majority. The new Assembly met on the 28th +of May. In the course of the next few days Lesseps accepted terms proposed +by the Roman Government, which would have precluded the French from +entering Rome. Oudinot, who had been in open conflict with the envoy +throughout his mission, refused his sanction to the treaty, and the +altercations between the general and the diplomatist were still at their +height when despatches arrived from Paris announcing that the powers given +to Lesseps were at an end, and ordering Oudinot to recommence hostilities. +The pretence of further negotiation would have been out of place with the +new Parliament. On the 4th of June the French general, now strongly +reinforced, occupied the positions necessary for a regular siege of Rome. + +[Attempted insurrection in France, June 13.] + +[The French enter Rome, July 3.] + +Against the forces now brought into action it was impossible that the Roman +Republic could long defend itself. One hope remained, and that was in a +revolution within France itself. The recent elections had united on the one +side all Conservative interests, on the other the Socialists and all the +more extreme factions of the Republican party. It was determined that a +trial of strength should first be made within the Assembly itself upon the +Roman question, and that, if the majority there should stand firm, an +appeal should be made to insurrection. Accordingly on the 11th of June, +after the renewal of hostilities had been announced in Paris, Ledru Rollin +demanded the impeachment of the Ministry. His motion was rejected, and the +signal was given for an outbreak not only in the capital but in Lyons and +other cities. But the Government were on their guard, and it was in vain +that the resources of revolution were once more brought into play. General +Changarnier suppressed without bloodshed a tumult in Paris on June 13th; +and though fighting took place at Lyons, the insurrection proved feeble in +comparison with the movements of the previous year. Louis Napoleon and his +Ministry remained unshaken, and the siege of Rome was accordingly pressed +to its conclusion. Oudinot, who at the beginning of the month had carried +the positions held by the Roman troops outside the walls, opened fire with +heavy artillery on the 14th. The defence was gallantly sustained by +Garibaldi and his companions until the end of the month, when the breaches +made in the walls were stormed by the enemy, and further resistance became +impossible. The French made their entry into Rome on the 3rd of July, +Garibaldi leading his troops northwards in order to prolong the struggle +with the Austrians who were now in possession of Bologna, and, if possible, +to reach Venice, which was still uncaptured. Driven to the eastern coast +and surrounded by the enemy, he was forced to put to sea. He landed again, +but only to be hunted over mountain and forest. His wife died by his side. +Rescued by the devotion of Italian patriots, he made his escape to Piedmont +and thence to America, to reappear in all the fame of his heroic deeds and +sufferings at the next great crisis in the history of his country. + +[The restored Pontifical Government.] + +It had been an easy task for a French army to conquer Rome; it was not so +easy for the French Government to escape from the embarrassments of its +victory. Liberalism was still the official creed of the Republic, and the +protection of the Roman population from a reaction under Austrian auspices +had been one of the alleged objects of the Italian expedition. No +stipulation had, however, been made with the Pope during the siege as to +the future institutions of Rome; and when, on the 14th of July, the +restorations of Papal authority was formally announced by Oudinot, Pius and +his Minister Antonelli still remained unfettered by any binding engagement. +Nor did the Pontiff show the least inclination to place himself in the +power of his protectors. He remained at Gaeta, sending a Commission of +three Cardinals to assume the government of Rome. The first acts of the +Cardinals dispelled any illusion that the French might have formed as to +the docility of the Holy See. In the presence of a French Republican army +they restored the Inquisition, and appointed a Board to bring to trial all +officials compromised in the events that had taken place since the murder +of Rossi in November, 1848. So great was the impression made on public +opinion by the action of the Cardinals that Louis Napoleon considered it +well to enter the lists in person on behalf of Roman liberty; and in a +letter to Colonel Ney, a son of the Marshal, he denounced in language of +great violence the efforts that were being made by a party antagonistic to +France to base the Pope's return upon proscription and tyranny. Strong in +the support of Austria and the other Catholic Powers, the Papal Government +at Gaeta received this menace with indifference, and even made the +discourtesy of the President a ground for withholding concessions. Of the +re-establishment of the Constitution granted by Pius in 1848 there was now +no question; all that the French Ministry could hope was to save some +fragments in the general shipwreck of representative government, and to +avert the vengeance that seemed likely to fall upon the defeated party. A +Pontifical edict, known as the Motu Proprio, ultimately bestowed upon the +municipalities certain local powers, and gave to a Council, nominated by +the Pope from among the persons chosen by the municipalities, the right of +consultation on matters of finance. More than this Pius refused to grant, +and when he returned to Rome it was as an absolute sovereign. In its +efforts on behalf of the large body of persons threatened with prosecution +the French Government was more successful. The so-called amnesty which was +published by Antonelli with the Motu Proprio seemed indeed to have for its +object the classification of victims rather than the announcement of +pardon; but under pressure from the French the excepted persons were +gradually diminished in number, and all were finally allowed to escape +other penalties by going into exile. To those who were so driven from their +homes Piedmont offered a refuge. + +[Fall of Venice, Aug. 25.] + +[Sicily conquered by Ferdinand, April, May.] + +Thus the pall of priestly absolutism and misrule fell once more over the +Roman States, and the deeper the hostility of the educated classes to the +restored power the more active became the system of repression. For liberty +of person there was no security whatever, and, though the offences of 1848 +were now professedly amnestied, the prisons were soon thronged with persons +arrested on indefinite charges and detained for an unlimited time without +trial. Nor was Rome more unfortunate in its condition than Italy generally. +The restoration of Austrian authority in the north was completed by the +fall of Venice. For months after the subjugation of the mainland, Venice, +where the Republic had again been proclaimed and Manin had been recalled to +power, had withstood all the efforts of the Emperor's forces. Its hopes had +been raised by the victories of the Hungarians, which for a moment seemed +almost to undo the catastrophe of Novara. But with the extinction of all +possibility of Hungarian aid the inevitable end came in view. Cholera and +famine worked with the enemy; and a fortnight after Goergei had laid down +his arms at Vilagos the long and honourable resistance of Venice ended with +the entry of the Austrians (August 25th). In the south, Ferdinand of Naples +was again ruling as despot throughout the full extent of his dominions. +Palermo, which had struck the first blow for freedom in 1848, had soon +afterwards become the seat of a Sicilian Parliament, which deposed the +Bourbon dynasty and offered the throne of Sicily to the younger brother of +Victor Emmanuel. To this Ferdinand replied by a fleet to Messina, which +bombarded that city for five days and laid a great part of it in ashes. His +violence caused the British and French fleets to interpose, and hostilities +were suspended until the spring of 1849, the Western Powers ineffectually +seeking to frame some compromise acceptable at once to the Sicilians and to +the Bourbon dynasty. After the triumph of Radetzky at Novara and the +rejection by the Sicilian Parliament of the offer of a separate +constitution and administration for the island, Ferdinand refused to remain +any longer inactive. His fleet and army moved southwards from Messina, and +a victory won at the foot of Mount Etna over the Sicilian forces, followed +by the capture of Catania, brought the struggle to a close. The Assembly at +Palermo dispersed, and the Neapolitan troops made their entry into the +capital without resistance on the 15th of May. It was in vain that Great +Britain now urged Ferdinand to grant to Sicily the liberties which he had +hitherto professed himself willing to bestow. Autocrat he was, and autocrat +he intended to remain. On the mainland the iniquities practised by his +agents seem to have been even worse than in Sicily, where at least some +attempt was made to use the powers of the State for the purposes of +material improvement. For those who had incurred the enmity of Ferdinand's +Government there was no law and no mercy. Ten years of violence and +oppression, denounced by the voice of freer lands, had still to be borne by +the subjects of this obstinate tyrant ere the reckoning-day arrived, and +the deeply rooted jealousy between Sicily and Naples, which had wrought so +much ill to the cause of Italian freedom, was appeased by the fall of the +Bourbon throne. [442] + +[Germany from May, 1848.] + +[The National Assembly at Frankfort.] + +[Archduke John chosen Administrator, June 29.] + +We have thus far traced the stages of conflict between the old monarchical +order and the forces of revolution in the Austrian empire and in that +Mediterranean land whose destiny was so closely interwoven with that of +Austria. We have now to pass back into Germany, and to resume the history +of the German revolution at the point where the national movement seemed to +concentrate itself in visible form, the opening of the Parliament of +Frankfort on the 18th of May, 1848. That an Assembly representing the +entire German people, elected in unbounded enthusiasm and comprising within +it nearly every man of political or intellectual eminence who sympathised +with the national cause, should be able to impose its will upon the +tottering Governments of the individual German States, was not an unnatural +belief in the circumstances of the moment. No second Chamber represented +the interests of the ruling Houses, nor had they within the Assembly itself +the organs for the expression of their own real or unreal claims. With all +the freedom of a debating club or of a sovereign authority like the French +Convention, the Parliament of Frankfort entered upon its work of moulding +Germany afresh, limited only by its own discretion as to what it should +make matter of consultation with any other power. There were thirty-six +Governments in Germany, and to negotiate with each of these on the future +Constitution might well seem a harder task than to enforce a Constitution +on all alike. In the creation of a provisional executive authority there +was something of the same difficulty. Each of the larger States might, if +consulted, resist the selection of a provisional chief from one of its +rivals; and though the risk of bold action was not denied, the Assembly, on +the instance of its President, Von Gagern, a former Minister of +Hesse-Darmstadt, resolved to appoint an Administrator of the Empire by a +direct vote of its own. The Archduke John of Austria, long known as an +enemy of Metternich's system of repression and as a patron of the idea of +German union, was chosen Administrator, and he accepted the office. Prussia +and the other States acquiesced in the nomination, though the choice of a +Hapsburg prince was unpopular with the Prussian nation and army, and did +not improve the relations between the Frankfort Assembly and the Court of +Berlin. [443] Schmerling, an Austrian, was placed at the head of the +Archduke's Ministry. + +[The National Assembly. May-Sept.] + +In the preparation of a Constitution for Germany the Assembly could draw +little help from the work of legislators in other countries. Belgium, whose +institutions were at once recent and successful, was not a Federal State; +the founders of the American Union had not had to reckon with four kings +and to include in their federal territory part of the dominions of an +emperor. Instead of grappling at once with the formidable difficulties of +political organisation, the Committee charged with the drafting of a +Constitution determined first to lay down the principles of civil right +which were to be the basis of the German commonwealth. There was something +of the scientific spirit of the Germans in thus working out the +substructure of public law on which all other institutions were to rest; +moreover, the remembrance of the Decrees of Carlsbad and of the other +exceptional legislation from which Germany had so heavily suffered excited +a strong demand for the most solemn guarantees against arbitrary departure +from settled law in the future. Thus, regardless of the absence of any +material power by which its conclusions were to be enforced, the Assembly, +in the intervals between its stormy debates on the politics of the hour, +traced with philosophic thoroughness the consequences of the principles of +personal liberty and of equality before the law, and fashioned the order of +a modern society in which privileges of class, diversity of jurisdictions, +and the trammels of feudalism on industrial life were alike swept away. +Four months had passed, and the discussion of the so-called Primary Rights +was still unfinished, when the Assembly was warned by an outbreak of +popular violence in Frankfort itself of the necessity of hastening towards +a constitutional settlement. + +[The Armistice of Malmoe, Aug. 26.] + +[Outrages at Frankfort, Sept. 18.] + +The progress of the insurrection in Schleswig-Holstein against Danish +sovereignty had been watched with the greatest interest throughout Germany; +and in the struggle of these provinces for their independence the rights +and the honour of the German nation at large were held to be deeply +involved. As the representative of the Federal authority, King Frederick +William of Prussia had sent his troops into Holstein, and they arrived +there in time to prevent the Danish army from following up its first +successes and crushing the insurgent forces. Taking up the offensive, +General Wrangel at the head of the Prussian troops succeeded in driving the +Danes out of Schleswig, and at the beginning of May he crossed the border +between Schleswig and Jutland and occupied the Danish fortress of +Fredericia. His advance into purely Danish territory occasioned the +diplomatic intervention of Russia and Great Britain; and, to the deep +disappointment of the German nation and its Parliament, the King of Prussia +ordered his general to retire into Schleswig. The Danes were in the +meantime blockading the harbours and capturing the merchant-vessels of the +Germans, as neither Prussia nor the Federal Government possessed a fleet of +war. For some weeks hostilities were irresolutely continued in Schleswig, +while negotiations were pursued in foreign capitals and various forms of +compromise urged by foreign Powers. At length, on the 26th of August, an +armistice of seven months was agreed upon at Malmoe in Sweden by the +representatives of Denmark and Prussia, the Court of Copenhagen refusing to +recognise the German central Government at Frankfort or to admit its envoy +to the conferences. The terms of this armistice, when announced in Germany, +excited the greatest indignation, inasmuch as they declared all the acts of +the Provisional Government of Schleswig-Holstein null and void, removed all +German troops from the Duchies, and handed over their government during the +duration of the armistice to a Commission of which half the members were to +be appointed by the King of Denmark. Scornfully as Denmark had treated the +Assembly of Frankfort, the terms of the armistice nevertheless required its +sanction. The question was referred to a committee, which, under the +influence of the historian Dahlmann, himself formerly an official in +Holstein, pronounced for the rejection of the treaty. The Assembly, in a +scene of great excitement, resolved that the execution of the measures +attendant on the armistice should be suspended. The Ministry in consequence +resigned, and Dahlmann was called upon to replace it by one under his own +leadership. He proved unable to do so. Schmerling resumed office, and +demanded that the Assembly should reverse its vote. Though in severance +from Prussia the Central Government had no real means of carrying on a war +with Denmark, the most passionate opposition was made to this demand. The +armistice was, however, ultimately ratified by a small majority. Defeated +in the Assembly, the leaders of the extreme Democratic faction allied +themselves with the populace of Frankfort, which was ready for acts of +violence. Tumultuous meetings were held; the deputies who had voted for the +armistice were declared traitors to Germany. Barricades were erected, and +although the appearance of Prussian troops prevented an assault from being +made on the Assembly, its members were attacked in the streets, and two of +them murdered by the mob (Sept. 17th). A Republican insurrection was once +more attempted in Baden, but it was quelled without difficulty. [444] + +[Berlin, April-Sept., 1848.] + +The intervention of foreign Courts on behalf of Denmark had given +ostensible ground to the Prussian Government for not pursuing the war with +greater resolution; but though the fear of Russia undoubtedly checked King +Frederick William, this was not the sole, nor perhaps the most powerful +influence that worked upon him. The cause of Schleswig-Hulstein was, in +spite of its legal basis, in the main a popular and a revolutionary one, +and between the King of Prussia and the revolution there was an intense and +a constantly deepening antagonism. Since the meeting of the National +Assembly at Berlin on the 22nd of May the capital had been the scene of an +almost unbroken course of disorder. The Assembly, which was far inferior in +ability and character to that of Frankfort, soon showed itself unable to +resist the influence of the populace. On the 8th of June a resolution was +moved that the combatants in the insurrection of March deserved well of +their country. Had this motion been carried the King would have dissolved +the Assembly: it was outvoted, but the mob punished this concession to the +feelings of the monarch by outrages upon the members of the majority. A +Civic Guard was enrolled from citizens of the middle class, but it proved +unable to maintain order, and wholly failed to acquire the political +importance which was gained by the National Guard of Paris after the +revolution of 1830. Exasperated by their exclusion from service in the +Guard, the mob on the 14th of June stormed an arsenal and destroyed the +trophies of arms which they found there. Though violence reigned in the +streets the Assembly rejected a proposal for declaring the inviolability of +its members, and placed itself under the protection of the citizens of +Berlin. King Frederick William had withdrawn to Potsdam, where the leaders +of reaction gathered round him. He detested his Constitutional Ministers, +who, between a petulant king and a suspicious Parliament, were unable to +effect any useful work and soon found themselves compelled to relinquish +their office. In Berlin the violence of the working classes, the +interruption of business, the example of civil war in Paris, inclined men +of quiet disposition to a return to settled government at any price. +Measures brought forward by the new Ministry for the abolition of the +patrimonial jurisdictions, the hunting-rights and other feudal privileges +of the greater landowners, occasioned the organisation of a league for the +defence of property, which soon became the focus of powerful conservative +interests. Above all, the claims of the Archduke John, as Administrator of +the Empire, to the homage of the army, and the hostile attitude assumed +towards the army by the Prussian Parliament itself, exasperated the +military class and encouraged the king to venture on open resistance. A +tumult having taken place at Schweidnitz in Silesia, in which several +persons were shot by the soldiery, the Assembly, pending an investigation +into the circumstances, demanded that the Minister of War should publish an +order requiring the officers of the army to work with the citizens for the +realisation of Constitutional Government; and it called upon all officers +not loyally inclined to a Constitutional system to resign their commissions +as a matter of honour. Denying the right of the Chamber to act as a +military executive, the Minister of War refused to publish the order +required. The vote was repeated, and in the midst of threatening +demonstrations in the streets the Ministry resigned (Sept. 7th). [445] + +[The Prussian army.] + +[Count Brandenburg Minister, Nov. 2.] + +[Prorogation of the Prussian Assembly, Nov. 9.] + +It had been the distinguishing feature of the Prussian revolution that the +army had never for a moment wavered in its fidelity to the throne. The +success of the insurrection of March 18th had been due to the paucity of +troops and the errors of those in command, not to any military disaffection +such as had paralysed authority in Paris and in the Mediterranean States. +Each affront offered to the army by the democratic majority in the Assembly +supplied the King with new weapons; each slight passed upon the royal +authority deepened the indignation of the officers. The armistice of Malmoe +brought back to the neighbourhood of the capital a general who was longing +to crush the party of disorder, and regiments on whom he could rely; but +though there was now no military reason for delay, it was not until the +capture of Vienna by Windischgraetz had dealt a fatal blow at democracy in +Germany that Frederick William determined to have done with his own +mutinous Parliament and the mobs by which it was controlled. During +September and October the riots and tumults in the streets of Berlin +continued. The Assembly, which had rejected the draft of a Constitution +submitted to it by the Cabinet, debated the clauses of one drawn up by a +Committee of its own members, abolished nobility, orders and titles, and +struck out from the style of the sovereign the words that described him as +King by the Grace of God. When intelligence arrived in Berlin that the +attack of Windischgraetz upon Vienna had actually begun, popular passion +redoubled. The Assembly was besieged by an angry crowd, and a resolution in +favour of the intervention of Prussia was brought forward within the House. +This was rejected, and it was determined instead to invoke the mediation of +the Central Government at Frankfort between the Emperor and his subjects. +But the decision of the Assembly on this and every other point was now +matter of indifference. Events outstripped its deliberations, and with the +fall of Vienna its own course was run. On the 2nd of November the King +dismissed his Ministers and called to office the Count of Brandenburg, a +natural son of Frederick William II., a soldier in high command, and one of +the most outspoken representatives of the monarchical spirit of the army. +The meaning of the appointment was at once understood. A deputation from +the Assembly conveyed its protest to the King at Potsdam. The King turned +his back upon them without giving an answer, and on the 9th of November an +order was issued proroguing the Assembly, and bidding it to meet on the +27th at Brandenburg, not at Berlin. + +[Last days of the Prussian Assembly.] + +[Dissolution of the Assembly, Dec. 5.] + +[Prussian Constitution granted by edict.] + +The order of prorogation, as soon as signed by the King was brought into +the Assembly by the Ministers, who demanded that it should be obeyed +immediately and without discussion. The President allowing a debate to +commence, the Ministers and seventy-eight Conservative deputies left the +Hall. The remaining deputies, two hundred and eighty in number, then passed +a resolution declaring that they would not meet at Brandenburg; that the +King had no power to remove, to prorogue, or to dissolve the Assembly +without its own consent; and that the Ministers were unfit to hold office. +This challenge was answered by a proclamation of the Ministers declaring +the further meeting of the deputies illegal, and calling upon the Civic +Guard not to recognise them as a Parliament. On the following day General +Wrangel and his troops entered Berlin and surrounded the Assembly Hall. In +reply to the protests of the President, Wrangel answered that the +Parliament had been prorogued and must disappear. The members peaceably +left the Hall, but reassembled at another spot that they had selected in +anticipation of expulsion; and for some days they were pursued by the +military from one place of meeting to another. On the 15th of November they +passed a resolution declaring the expenditure of state funds and the +raising of taxes by the Government to be illegal so long as the Assembly +should not be permitted to continue its deliberations. The Ministry on its +part showed that it was determined not to brook resistance. The Civic Guard +was dissolved and ordered to surrender its arms. It did so without striking +a blow, and vanished from the scene, a memorable illustration of the +political nullity of the middle class in Berlin as compared with that of +Paris. The state of siege was proclaimed, the freedom of the Press and the +right of public meeting were suspended. On the 27th of November a portion +of the Assembly appeared, according to the King's order, at Brandenburg, +but the numbers present were not sufficient for the transaction of +business. The presence of the majority, however, was not required, for the +King had determined to give no further legal opportunities to the men who +had defied him. Treating the vote of November 15th as an act of rebellion +on the part of those concerned in it, the King dissolved the Assembly +(December 5th), and conferred upon Prussia a Constitution drawn up by his +own advisers, with the promise that this Constitution should be subject to +revision by the future representative body. Though the dissolution of the +Assembly occasioned tumults in Breslau and Cologne it was not actively +resented by the nation at large. The violence of the fallen body during its +last weeks of existence had exposed it to general discredit; its vote of +the 15th of November had been formally condemned by the Parliament of +Frankfort; and the liberal character of the new Constitution, which agreed +in the main with the draft-Constitution produced by the Committee of the +Assembly, disposed moderate men to the belief that in the conflict between +the King and the popular representatives the fault had not been on the side +of the sovereign. + +[The Frankfort Parliament and Austria, Oct.-Dec.] + +In the meantime the Parliament of Frankfort, warned against longer delay by +the disturbances of September 17th, had addressed itself in earnest to the +settlement of the Federal Constitution of Germany. Above a host of minor +difficulties two great problems confronted it at the outset. The first was +the relation of the Austrian Empire, with its partly German and partly +foreign territory, to the German national State; the other was the nature +of the headship to be established. As it was clear that the Austrian +Government could not apply the public law of Germany to its Slavic and +Hungarian provinces, it was enacted in the second article of the Frankfort +Constitution that where a German and a non-German territory had the same +sovereign, the relation between these countries must be one of purely +personal union under the sovereign, no part of Germany being incorporated +into a single State with any non-German land. At the time when this article +was drafted the disintegration of Austria seemed more probable than the +re-establishment of its unity; no sooner, however, had Prince Schwarzenberg +been brought into power by the subjugation of Vienna, than he made it plain +that the government of Austria was to be centralised as it had never been +before. In the first public declaration of his policy he announced that +Austria would maintain its unity and permit no exterior influence to modify +its internal organisation; that the settlement of the relations between +Austria and Germany could only be effected after each had gained some new +and abiding political form; and that in the meantime Austria would continue +to fulfil its duties as a confederate. [446] The interpretation put upon +this statement at Frankfort was that Austria, in the interest of its own +unity, preferred not to enter the German body, but looked forward to the +establishment of some intimate alliance with it at a future time. As the +Court of Vienna had evidently determined not to apply to itself the second +article of the Constitution, and an antagonism between German and Austrian +policy came within view, Schmerling, as an Austrian subject, was induced to +resign his office, and was succeeded in it by Gagern, hitherto President of +the Assembly (Dec. 16th). [447] + +[The Frankfort Parliament and Austria, Dec., Jan.] + +In announcing the policy of the new Ministry, Gagern assumed the exclusion +of Austria from the German Federation. Claiming for the Assembly, as the +representative of the German nation, sovereign power in drawing up the +Constitution, he denied that the Constitution could be made an object of +negotiation with Austria. As Austria refused to fulfil the conditions of +the second article, it must remain outside the Federation; the Ministry +desired, however, to frame some close and special connection between +Austria and Germany, and asked for authority to negotiate with the Court of +Vienna for this purpose. Gagern's declaration of the exclusion of Austria +occasioned a vehement and natural outburst of feeling among the Austrian +deputies, and was met by their almost unanimous protest. Some days later +there arrived a note from Schwarzenberg which struck at the root of all +that had been done and all that was claimed by the Assembly. Repudiating +the interpretation that had been placed upon his words, Schwarzenberg +declared that the affairs of Germany could only be settled by an +understanding between the Assembly and the Courts, and by an arrangement +with Austria, which was the recognised chief of the Governments and +intended to remain so in the new Federation. The question of the inclusion +or exclusion of Austria now threw into the shade all the earlier +differences between parties in the Assembly. A new dividing-line was drawn. +On the one side appeared a group composed of the Austrian representatives, +of Ultramontanes who feared a Protestant ascendency if Austria should be +excluded, and of deputies from some of the smaller States who had begun to +dread Prussian domination. On the other side was the great body of +representatives who set before all the cause of German national union, who +saw that this union would never be effected in any real form if it was made +to depend upon negotiations with the Austrian Court, and who held, with the +Minister, that to create a true German national State without the Austrian +provinces was better than to accept a phantom of complete union in which +the German people should be nothing and the Cabinet of Vienna everything. +Though coalitions and intrigues of parties obscured the political prospect +from day to day, the principles of Gagern were affirmed by a majority of +the Assembly, and authority to negotiate some new form of connection with +Austria, as a power outside the Federation, was granted to the Ministry. + +[The Federal Headship.] + +[King Frederick William IV. elected Emperor, March 28.] + +The second great difficulty of the Assembly was the settlement of the +Federal headship. Some were for a hereditary Emperor, some for a President +or Board, some for a monarchy alternating between the Houses of Prussia and +Austria, some for a sovereign elected for life or for a fixed period. The +first decision arrived at was that the head should be one of the reigning +princes of Germany, and that he should bear the title of Emperor. Against +the hereditary principle there was a strong and, at first, a successful +opposition. Reserving for future discussion other questions relating to the +imperial office, the Assembly passed the Constitution through the first +reading on February 3rd, 1849. It was now communicated to all the German +Governments, with the request that they would offer their opinions upon it. +The four minor kingdoms--Saxony, Hanover, Bavaria, and Wuertemberg--with one +consent declared against any Federation in which Austria should not be +included; the Cabinet of Vienna protested against the subordination of the +Emperor of Austria to a central power vested in any other German prince, +and proposed that the entire Austrian Empire, with its foreign as well as +its German elements, should enter the Federation. This note was enough to +prove that Austria was in direct conflict with the scheme of national union +which the Assembly had accepted; but the full peril of the situation was +not perceived till on the 9th of March Schwarzenberg published the +Constitution of Olmuetz, which extinguished all separate rights throughout +the Austrian Empire, and confounded in one mass, as subjects of the Emperor +Francis Joseph, Hungarians, Germans, Slavs and Italians. The import of the +Austrian demand now stood out clear and undisguised. Austria claimed to +range itself with a foreign population of thirty millions within the German +Federation; in other words, to reduce the German national union to a +partnership with all the nationalities of Central Europe, to throw the +weight of an overwhelming influence against any system of free +representative government, and to expose Germany to war where no interests +but those of the Pole or the Magyar might be at stake. So deep was the +impression made at Frankfort by the fall of the Kremsier Parliament and the +publication of Schwarzenberg's unitary edict, that one of the most eminent +of the politicians who had hitherto opposed the exclusion of Austria--the +Baden deputy Welcker--declared that further persistence in this course +would be treason to Germany. Ranging himself with the Ministry, he +proposed that the entire German Constitution, completed by a hereditary +chieftainship, should be passed at a single vote on the second reading, and +that the dignity of Emperor should be at once offered to the King of +Prussia. Though the Assembly declined to pass the Constitution by a single +vote, it agreed to vote upon clause by clause without discussion. The +hereditary principle was affirmed by the narrow majority of four in a House +of above five hundred. The second reading of the Constitution was completed +on the 27th of March, and on the following day the election of the +sovereign took place. Two hundred and ninety votes were given for the King +of Prussia. Two hundred and forty-eight members, hostile to the hereditary +principle or to the prince selected, abstained from voting. [448] + +[Frederick William IV.] + +Frederick William had from early years cherished the hope of seeing some +closer union of Germany established under Prussian influence. But he dwelt +in a world where there was more of picturesque mirage than of real insight. +He was almost superstitiously loyal to the House of Austria; and he failed +to perceive, what was palpable to men of far inferior endowments to his +own, that by setting Prussia at the head of the constitutional movement of +the epoch he might at any time from the commencement of his reign have +rallied all Germany round it. Thus the revolution of 1848 burst upon him, +and he was not the man to act or to lead in time of revolution. Even in +1848, had he given promptly and with dignity what, after blood had been +shed in his streets, he had to give with humiliation, he would probably +have been acclaimed Emperor on the opening of the Parliament of Frankfort, +and have been accepted by the universal voice of Germany. But the odium +cast upon him by the struggle of March 18th was so great that in the +election of a temporary Administrator of the Empire in June no single +member at Frankfort gave him a vote. Time was needed to repair his credit, +and while time passed Austria rose from its ruins. In the spring of 1849 +Frederick William could not have assumed the office of Emperor of Germany +without risk of a war with Austria, even had he been willing to accept this +office on the nomination of the Frankfort Parliament. But to accept the +Imperial Crown from a popular Assembly was repugnant to his deepest +convictions. Clear as the Frankfort Parliament had been, as a whole, from +the taint of Republicanism or of revolutionary violence, it had +nevertheless had its birth in revolution: the crown which it offered would, +in the King's expression, have been picked up from blood and mire. Had the +princes of Germany by any arrangement with the Assembly tendered the crown +to Frederick William the case would have been different; a new Divine right +would have emanated from the old, and conditions fixed by negotiation +between the princes and the popular Assembly might have been endured. That +Frederick William still aspired to German leadership in one form or another +no one doubted; his disposition to seek or to reject an accommodation with +the Frankfort Parliament varied with the influences which surrounded him. +The Ministry led by the Count of Brandenburg, though anti-popular in its +domestic measures, was desirous of arriving at some understanding with +Gagern and the friends of German union. Shortly before the first reading of +the Constitution at Frankfort, a note had been drafted in the Berlin +Cabinet admitting under certain provisions the exclusion of Austria from +the Federation, and proposing, not that the Assembly should admit the right +of each Government to accept or reject the Constitution, but that it should +meet in a fair spirit such recommendations as all the Governments together +should by a joint act submit to it. This note, which would have rendered an +agreement between the Prussian Court and the Assembly possible, Frederick +William at first refused to sign. He was induced to do so (Jan. 23rd) by +his confidant Bunsen, who himself was authorised to proceed to Frankfort. +During Bunsen's absence despatches arrived at Berlin from Schwarzenberg, +who, in his usual resolute way, proposed to dissolve the Frankfort +Assembly, and to divide Germany between Austria, Prussia, and the four +secondary kingdoms. Bunsen on his return found his work undone; the King +recoiled under Austrian pressure from the position which he had taken up, +and sent a note to Frankfort on the 16th of February, which described +Austria as a necessary part of Germany and claimed for each separate +Government the right to accept or reject the Constitution as it might think +fit. Thus the acceptance of the headship by Frederick William under any +conditions compatible with the claims of the Assembly was known to be +doubtful when, on the 28th of March, the majority resolved to offer him the +Imperial Crown. The disposition of the Ministry at Berlin was indeed still +favourable to an accommodation; and when, on the 2nd of April, the members +of the Assembly who were charged to lay its offer before Frederick William +arrived at Berlin, they were received with such cordiality by Brandenburg +that it was believed the King's consent had been won. + +[Frederick William IV. refuses the Crown, April 3.] + +The reply of the King to the deputation on the following day rudely +dispelled these hopes. He declared that before he could accept the Crown +not only must he be summoned to it by the Princes of Germany, but the +consent of all the Governments must be given to the Constitution. In other +words, he required that the Assembly should surrender its claims to +legislative supremacy, and abandon all those parts of the Federal +Constitution of which any of the existing Governments disapproved. As it +was certain that Austria and the four minor kingdoms would never agree to +any Federal union worthy of the name, and that the Assembly could not now, +without renouncing its past, admit that the right of framing the +Constitution lay outside itself, the answer of the King was understood to +amount to a refusal. The deputation left Berlin in the sorrowful conviction +that their mission had failed; and a note which was soon afterwards +received at Frankfort from the King showed that this belief was +correct. [449] + +[The Frankfort Constitution rejected by the Governments.] + +The answer of King Frederick William proved indeed much more than that he +had refused the Crown of Germany; it proved that he would not accept the +Constitution which the Assembly had enacted. The full import of this +determination, and the serious nature of the crisis now impending over +Germany, were at once understood. Though twenty-eight Governments +successively accepted the Constitution, these were without exception petty +States, and their united forces would scarcely have been a match for one of +its more powerful enemies. On the 5th of April the Austrian Cabinet +declared the Assembly to have been guilty of illegality in publishing the +Constitution, and called upon all Austrian deputies to quit Frankfort. The +Prussian Lower Chamber, elected under the King's recent edict, having +protested against the state of siege in Berlin, and having passed a +resolution in favour of the Frankfort Constitution, was forthwith +dissolved. Within the Frankfort Parliament the resistance of Governments +excited a patriotic resentment and caused for the moment a union of +parties. Resolutions were passed declaring that the Assembly would adhere +to the Constitution. A Committee was charged with the ascertainment of +measures to be adopted for enforcing its recognition; and a note was +addressed to all the hostile Governments demanding that they should abstain +from proroguing or dissolving the representative bodies within their +dominions with the view of suppressing the free utterance of opinions in +favour of the Constitution. + +[End of the German National Assembly, June, 1849.] + +On the ground of this last demand the Prussian official Press now began to +denounce the Assembly of Frankfort as a revolutionary body. The situation +of affairs daily became worse. It was in vain that the Assembly appealed to +the Governments, the legislative Chambers, the local bodies, the whole +people, to bring the Constitution into effect. The moral force on which it +had determined to rely proved powerless, and in despair of conquering the +Governments by public opinion the more violent members of the democratic +party determined to appeal to insurrection. On the 4th of May a popular +rising began at Dresden, where the King, under the influence of Prussia, +had dismissed those of his Ministers who urged him to accept the +Constitution, and had dissolved his Parliament. The outbreak drove the King +from his capital; but only five days had passed when a Prussian army-corps +entered the city and crushed the rebellion. In this interval, short as it +was, there had been indications that the real leaders of the insurrection +were fighting not for the Frankfort Constitution but for a Republic, and +that in the event of their victory a revolutionary Government, connected +with French and Polish schemes of subversion, would come into power. In +Baden this was made still clearer. There the Government of the Grand Duke +had actually accepted the Frankfort Constitution, and had ordered elections +to be held for the Federal legislative body by which the Assembly was to be +succeeded. Insurrection nevertheless broke out. The Republic was openly +proclaimed; the troops joined the insurgents; and a Provisional Government +allied itself with a similar body that had sprung into being with the help +of French and Polish refugees in the neighbouring Palatinate. Conscious +that these insurrections must utterly ruin its own cause, the Frankfort +Assembly on the suggestion of Gagern called upon the Archduke John to +suppress them by force of arms, and at the same time to protect the free +expression of opinion on behalf of the Constitution where threatened by +Governments. John, who had long clung to his office only to further the +ends of Austria, refused to do so, and Gagern in consequence resigned. With +his fall ended the real political existence of the Assembly. In reply to a +resolution which it passed on the 10th of May, calling upon John to employ +all the forces of Germany in defence of the Constitution, the Archduke +placed a mock-Ministry in office. The Prussian Government, declaring the +vote of the 10th of May to be a summons to civil war, ordered all Prussian +deputies to withdraw from the Assembly, and a few days later its example +was imitated by Saxony and Hanover. On the 20th of May sixty-five of the +best known of the members, including Arndt and Dahlmann, placed on record +their belief that in the actual situation the relinquishment of the task of +the Assembly was the least of evils, and declared their work at Frankfort +ended. Other groups followed them till there remained only the party of the +extreme Left, which had hitherto been a weak minority, and which in no +sense represented the real opinions of Germany. This Rump-Parliament, +troubling itself little with John and his Ministers, determined to withdraw +from Frankfort, where it dreaded the appearance of Prussian troops, into +Wuertemberg, where it might expect some support from the revolutionary +Governments of Baden and the Palatinate. On the 6th of June a hundred and +five deputies assembled at Stuttgart. There they proceeded to appoint a +governing Committee for all Germany, calling upon the King of Wuertemberg to +supply them with seven thousand soldiers, and sending out emissaries to +stir up the neighbouring population. But the world disregarded them. The +Government at Stuttgart, after an interval of patience, bade them begone; +and on the 18th of June their hall was closed against them and they were +dispersed by troops, no one raising a hand on their behalf. The overthrow +of the insurgents who had taken up arms in Baden and the Palatinate was not +so easy a matter. A campaign of six weeks was necessary, in which the army +of Prussia, led by the Prince of Prussia, sustained some reverses, before +the Republican levies were crushed, and with the fall of Rastadt the +insurrection was brought to a close. [450] + +[The Baden insurrection suppressed, July, 1849.] + +[Prussia attempts to form a separate union.] + +The end of the German Parliament, on which the nation had set such high +hopes and to which it had sent so much of what was noblest in itself, +contrasted lamentably with the splendour of its opening. Whether a better +result would have been attained if, instead of claiming supreme authority +in the construction of Federal union, the Assembly had from the first +sought the co-operation of the Governments, must remain matter of +conjecture. Austria would under all circumstances have been the great +hindrance in the way; and after the failure of the efforts made at +Frankfort to establish the general union of Germany, Austria was able +completely to frustrate the attempts which were now made at Berlin to +establish partial union upon a different basis. In notifying to the +Assembly his refusal of the Imperial Crown, King Frederick William had +stated that he was resolved to place himself at the head of a Federation to +be formed by States voluntarily uniting with him under terms to be +subsequently arranged; and in a circular note addressed to the German +Governments he invited such as were disposed to take counsel with Prussia +to unite in Conference at Berlin. The opening of the Conference was fixed +for the 17th of May. Two days before this the King issued a proclamation to +the Prussian people announcing that in spite of the failure of the Assembly +of Frankfort a German union was still to be formed. When the Conference +opened at Berlin, no envoys appeared but those of Austria, Saxony, Hanover, +and Bavaria. The Austrian representative withdrew at the end of the first +sitting, the Bavarian rather later, leaving Prussia to lay such foundations +as it could for German unity with the temporising support of Saxony and +Hanover. A confederation was formed, known as the League of the Three +Kingdoms. An undertaking was given that a Federal Parliament should be +summoned, and that a Constitution should be made jointly by this Parliament +and the Governments (May 26th). On the 11th of June the draft of a Federal +Constitution was published. As the King of Prussia was apparently acting in +good faith, and the draft-Constitution in spite of some defects seemed to +afford a fair basis for union, the question now arose among the leaders of +the German national movement whether the twenty-eight States which had +accepted the ill-fated Constitution of Frankfort ought or ought not to +enter the new Prussian League. A meeting of a hundred and fifty ex-members +of the Frankfort Parliament was held at Gotha; and although great +indignation was expressed by the more democratic faction, it was determined +that the scheme now put forward by Prussia deserved a fair trial. The whole +of the twenty-eight minor States consequently entered the League, which +thus embraced all Germany with the exception of Austria, Bavaria and +Wuertemberg. But the Courts of Saxony and Hanover had from the first been +acting with duplicity. The military influence of Prussia, and the fear +which they still felt of their own subjects, had prevented them from +offering open resistance to the renewed work of Federation; but they had +throughout been in communication with Austria, and were only waiting for +the moment when the complete restoration of Austria's military strength +should enable them to display their true colours. During the spring of +1849, while the Conferences at Berlin were being held, Austria was still +occupied with Hungary and Venice. The final overthrow of these enemies +enabled it to cast its entire weight upon Germany. The result was seen in +the action of Hanover and Saxony, which now formally seceded from the +Federation. Prussia thus remained at the end of 1849 with no support but +that of the twenty-eight minor States. Against it, in open or in tacit +antagonism to the establishment of German unity in any effective form, the +four secondary Kingdoms stood ranged by the side of Austria. + +[Prussia in 1849.] + +[The Union Parliament at Erfurt, March 1850.] + +It was not until the 20th of March, 1850, that the Federal Parliament, +which had been promised ten months before on the incorporation of the new +League, assembled at Erfurt. In the meantime reaction had gone far in many +a German State. In Prussia, after the dissolution of the Lower Chamber on +April 27th, 1849, the King had abrogated the electoral provisions of the +Constitution so recently granted by himself, and had substituted for them a +system based on the representation of classes. Treating this act as a +breach of faith, the Democratic party had abstained from voting at the +elections, with the result that in the Berlin Parliament of 1850 +Conservatives, Reactionists, and officials formed the great majority. The +revision of the Prussian Constitution, promised at first as a concession to +Liberalism, was conducted in the opposite sense. The King demanded the +strengthening of monarchical power; the Feudalists, going far beyond him, +attacked the municipal and social reforms of the last two years, and sought +to lead Prussia back to the system of its mediaeval estates. It was in the +midst of this victory of reaction in Prussia that the Federal Parliament at +Erfurt began its sittings. Though the moderate Liberals, led by Gagern and +other tried politicians of Frankfurt, held the majority in both Houses, a +strong Absolutist party from Prussia confronted them, and it soon became +clear that the Prussian Government was ready to play into the hands of this +party. The draft of the Federal Constitution, which had been made at +Berlin, was presented, according to the undertaking of May 28th, 1849, to +the Erfurt Assembly. Aware of the gathering strength of the reaction and of +the danger of delay, the Liberal majority declared itself ready to pass the +draft into law without a single alteration. The reactionary minority +demanded that a revision should take place; and, to the scandal of all who +understood the methods or the spirit of Parliamentary rule, the Prussian +Ministers united with the party which demanded alterations in the project +which they themselves had brought forward. A compromise was ultimately +effected; but the action of the Court of Prussia and the conduct of its +Ministers throughout the Erfurt debates struck with deep despondency those +who had believed that Frederick William might still effect the work in +which the Assembly of Frankfort had failed. The trust in the King's +sincerity or consistence of purpose sank low. The sympathy of the national +Liberal party throughout Germany was to a great extent alienated from +Prussia; while, if any expectation existed at Berlin that the adoption of a +reactionary policy would disarm the hostility of the Austrian Government to +the new League, this hope was wholly vain and baseless. [451] + +[Action of Austria.] + +Austria had from the first protested against the attempt of the King of +Prussia to establish any new form of union in Germany, and had declared +that it would recognise none of the conclusions of the Federal Parliament +of Erfurt. According to the theory now advanced by the Cabinet of Vienna +the ancient Federal Constitution of Germany was still in force. All that +had happened since March, 1848, was so much wanton and futile +mischief-making. The disturbance of order had at length come to an end, and +with the exit of the rioters the legitimate powers re-entered into their +rights. Accordingly, there could be no question of the establishment of new +Leagues. The old relation of all the German States to one another under the +ascendency of Austria remained in full strength; the Diet of Frankfort, +which had merely suspended its functions and by no means suffered +extinction, was still the legitimate central authority. That some +modifications might be necessary in the ancient Constitution was the most +that Austria was willing to admit. This, however, was an affair not for the +German people but for its rulers, and Austria accordingly invited all the +Governments to a Congress at Frankfort where the changes necessary might be +discussed. In reply to this summons, Prussia strenuously denied that the +old Federal Constitution was still in existence. The princes of the +numerous petty States which were included in the new Union assembled at +Berlin round Frederick William, and resolved that they would not attend the +Conference at Frankfort except under reservations and conditions which +Austria would not admit. Arguments and counter-arguments were exchanged; +but the controversy between an old and a new Germany was one to be decided +by force of will or force of arms, not by political logic. The struggle was +to be one between Prussia and Austria, and the Austrian Cabinet had well +gauged the temper of its opponent. A direct summons to submission would +have roused all the King's pride, and have been answered by war. Before +demanding from Frederick William the dissolution of the Union which he had +founded, Schwarzenberg determined to fix upon a quarrel in which the King +should be perplexed or alarmed at the results of his own policy. The +dominant conviction in the mind of Frederick William was that of the +sanctity of monarchical rule. If the League of Berlin could be committed to +some enterprise hostile to monarchical power, and could be charged with an +alliance with rebellion, Frederick William would probably falter in his +resolutions, and a resort to arms, for which, however, Austria was well +prepared, would become unnecessary. [452] + +[Hesse-Cassel.] + +[The Diet of Frankfort restored, Sept., 1850.] + +[Prussia and Austria.] + +[The Warsaw meeting, Oct. 29, 1850.] + +[Manteuffel at Olmuetz, Nov. 29.] + +Among the States whose Governments had been forced by public opinion to +join the new Federation was the Electorate of Hesse-Cassel. The Elector +was, like his predecessors, a thorough despot at heart, and chafed under +the restrictions which a constitutional system imposed upon his rule. +Acting under Austrian instigation, he dismissed his Ministers in the spring +of 1850, and placed in office one Hassenpflug, a type of the worst and most +violent class of petty tyrants produced by the officialism of the minor +German States. Hassenpflug immediately quarrelled with the Estates at +Cassel, and twice dissolved them, after which he proceeded to levy taxes by +force. The law-courts declared his acts illegal; the officers of the army, +when called on for assistance, began to resign. The conflict between the +Minister and the Hessian population was in full progress when, at the +beginning of September, Austria with its vassal Governments proclaimed the +re-establishment of the Diet of Frankfort. Though Prussia and most of the +twenty-eight States confederate with it treated this announcement as null +and void, the Diet, constituted by the envoys of Austria, the four minor +Kingdoms, and a few seceders from the Prussian Union, commenced its +sittings. To the Diet the Elector of Hesse forthwith appealed for help +against his subjects, and the decision was given that the refusal of the +Hessian Estates to grant the taxes was an offence justifying the +intervention of the central power. Fortified by this judgment, Hassenpflug +now ordered that every person offering resistance to the Government should +be tried by court-martial. He was baffled by the resignation of the entire +body of officers in the Hessian army; and as this completed the +discomfiture of the Elector, the armed intervention of Austria, as +identified with the Diet of Frankfort, now became a certainty. But to the +protection of the people of Hesse in their constitutional rights Prussia, +as chief of the League which Hesse had joined, stood morally pledged. It +remained for the King to decide between armed resistance to Austria or the +humiliation of a total abandonment of Prussia's claim to leadership in any +German union. Conflicting influences swayed the King in one direction and +another. The friends of Austria and of absolutism declared that the +employment of the Prussian army on behalf of the Hessians would make the +King an accomplice of revolution: the bolder and more patriotic spirits +protested against the abdication of Prussia's just claims and the evasion +of its responsibilities towards Germany. For a moment the party of action, +led by the Prince of Prussia, gained the ascendant. General Radowitz, the +projector of the Union, was called to the Foreign Ministry, and Prussian +troops entered Hesse. Austria now ostentatiously prepared for war. +Frederick William, terrified by the danger confronting him, yet unwilling +to yield all, sought the mediation of the Czar of Russia. Nicholas came +to Warsaw, where the Emperor of Austria and Prince Charles, brother of +the King of Prussia, attended by the Ministers of their States, met him. +The closest family ties united the Courts of St. Petersburg and Berlin +but the Russian sovereign was still the patron of Austria as he had been +in the Hungarian campaign. He resented the action of Prussia in +Schleswig-Holstein, and was offended that King Frederick William had not +presented himself at Warsaw in person. He declared in favour of all +Austria's demands, and treated Count Brandenburg with such indignity that +the Count, a high-spirited patriot, never recovered from its effect. He +returned to Berlin only to give in his report and die. Manteuffel, +Minister of the Interior, assured the King that the Prussian army was so +weak in numbers and so defective in organisation that, if it took the +field against Austria and its allies, it would meet with certain ruin. +Bavarian troops, representing the Diet of Frankfort, now entered Hesse at +Austria's bidding, and stood face to face with the Prussians. The moment +had come when the decision must be made between peace and war. At a +Council held at Berlin on November and the peace-party carried the King +with them. Radowitz gave up office; Manteuffel, the Minister of +repression within and of submission without, was set at the head of the +Government. The meaning of his appointment was well understood, and with +each new proof of the weakness of the King the tone of the Court of +Austria became more imperious. On the 9th of November Schwarzenberg +categorically demanded the dissolution of the Prussian Union, the +recognition of the Federal Diet, and the evacuation of Hesse by the +Prussian troops. The first point was at once conceded, and in hollow, +equivocating language Manteuffel made the fact known to the members of +the Confederacy. The other conditions not being so speedily fulfilled, +Schwarzenberg set Austrian regiments in motion, and demanded the +withdrawal of the Prussian troops from Hesse within twenty-four hours. +Manteuffel begged the Austrian Minister for an interview, and, without +waiting for an answer, set out for Olmuetz. His instructions bade him to +press for certain concessions; none of these did he obtain, and he made +the necessary submission without them. On the 29th of November a convention +was signed at Olmuetz, in which Prussia recognised the German Federal +Constitution of 1815 as still existing, undertook to withdraw all its +troops from Hesse with the exception of a single battalion, and consented +to the settlement of affairs both in Hesse and in Schleswig-Holstein by the +Federal Diet. One point alone in the scheme of the Austrian statesman was +wanting among the fruits of his victory at Olmuetz and of the negotiations +at Dresden by which this was followed. Schwarzenberg had intended that the +entire Austrian Empire should enter the German Federation; and if he had +had to reckon with no opponents but the beaten and humbled Prussia, he +would have effected his design. But the prospect of a central European +Power, with a population of seventy millions, controlled as this would +virtually be by the Cabinet of Vienna, alarmed other nations. England +declared that such a combination would undo the balance of power in Europe +and menace the independence of Germany; France protested in more +threatening terms; and the project fell to the ground, to be remembered +only as the boldest imagination of a statesman for whom fortune, veiling +the Nemesis in store, seemed to set no limit to its favours. + +[Schleswig-Holstein.] + +[The German National Fleet sold by auction, June, 1852.] + +The cause of Schleswig-Holstein, so intimately bound up with the efforts of +the Germans towards national union, sank with the failure of these efforts; +and in the final humiliation of Prussia it received what might well seem +its death-blow. The armistice of Malmoe, which was sanctioned by the +Assembly of Frankfort in the autumn of 1848, lasted until March 26th, 1849. +War was then recommenced by Prussia, and the lines of Dueppel were stormed +by its troops, while the volunteer forces of Schleswig-Holstein +unsuccessfully laid siege to Fredericia. Hostilities had continued for +three months, when a second armistice, to last for a year, and +Preliminaries of Peace, were agreed upon. At the conclusion of this +armistice, in July, 1850, Prussia, in the name of Germany, made peace with +Denmark. The inhabitants of the Duchies in consequence continued the war +for themselves, and though defeated with great loss at Idstedt on the 24th +of July, they remained unconquered at the end of the year. This was the +situation of affairs when Prussia, by the Treaty of Olmuetz, agreed that the +restored Federal Diet should take upon itself the restoration of order in +Schleswig-Holstein, and that the troops of Prussia should unite with those +of Austria to enforce its decrees. To the Cabinet of Vienna, the foe in +equal measure of German national union and of every democratic cause, the +Schleswig-Holsteiners were simply rebels in insurrection against their +Sovereign. They were required by the Diet, under Austrian dictation, to lay +down their arms; and commissioners from Austria and Prussia entered the +Duchies to compel them to do so. Against Denmark, Austria, and Prussia +together, it was impossible for Schleswig-Holstein to prolong its +resistance. The army was dissolved, and the Duchies were handed over to the +King of Denmark, to return to the legal status which was defined in the +Treaties of Peace. This was the nominal condition of the transfer; but the +Danish Government treated Schleswig as part of its national territory, and +in the northern part of the Duchy the process of substituting Danish for +German nationality was actively pursued. The policy of foreign Courts, +little interested in the wish of the inhabitants, had from the beginning of +the struggle of the Duchies against Denmark favoured the maintenance and +consolidation of the Danish Kingdom. The claims of the Duke of +Augustenburg, as next heir to the Duchies in the male line, were not +considered worth the risk of a new war; and by a protocol signed at London +on the 2nd of August, 1850, the Powers, with the exception of Prussia, +declared themselves in favour of a single rule of succession in all parts +of the Danish State. By a Treaty of the 8th of May, 1852, to which Prussia +gave its assent, the pretensions of all other claimants to the disputed +succession were set aside, and Prince Christian, of the House of +Gluecksburg, was declared heir to the throne, the rights of the German +Federation as established by the Treaties of 1815 being reserved. In spite +of this reservation of Federal rights, and of the stipulations in favour of +Schleswig and Holstein made in the earlier agreements, the Duchies appeared +to be now practically united with the Danish State. Prussia, for a moment +their champion, had joined with Austria in coercing their army, in +dissolving their Government, in annulling the legislation by which the +Parliament of Frankfort had made them participators in public rights +thenceforward to be the inheritance of all Germans. A page in the national +history was obliterated; Prussia had turned its back on its own +professions; there remained but one relic from the time when the whole +German people seemed so ardent for the emancipation of its brethren beyond +the frontier. The national fleet, created by the Assembly of Frankfort for +the prosecution of the struggle with Denmark, still lay at the mouth of the +Elbe. But the same power which had determined that Germany was not to be a +nation had also determined that it could have no national maritime +interests. After all that had passed, authority had little call to be nice +about appearances; and the national fleet was sold by auction, in +accordance with a decree of the restored Diet of Frankfort, in the summer +of 1852. [453] + +[Germany after 1849.] + +It was with deep disappointment and humiliation that the Liberals of +Germany, and all in whom the hatred of democratic change had not +overpowered the love of country, witnessed the issue of the movement of +1848. In so far as that movement was one directed towards national union it +had totally failed, and the state of things that had existed before 1848 +was restored without change. As a movement of constitutional and social +reform, it had not been so entirely vain; nor in this respect can it be +said that Germany after the year 1848 returned altogether to what it was +before it. Many of the leading figures of the earlier time re-appeared +indeed with more or less of lustre upon the stage. Metternich though +excluded from office by younger men, beamed upon Vienna with the serenity +of a prophet who had lived to see most of his enemies shot and of a martyr +who had returned to one of the most enviable Salons in Europe. No dynasty +lost its throne, no class of the population had been struck down with +proscription as were the clergy and the nobles of France fifty years +before. Yet the traveller familiar with Germany before the revolution found +that much of the old had now vanished, much of a new world come into being. +It was not sought by the re-established Governments to undo at one stroke +the whole of the political, the social, the agrarian legislation of the +preceding time, as in some other periods of reaction. The nearest approach +that was made to this was in a decree of the Diet annulling the Declaration +of Rights drawn up by the Frankfort Assembly, and requiring the Governments +to bring into conformity with the Federal Constitution all laws and +institutions made since the beginning of 1848. Parliamentary government was +thereby enfeebled, but not necessarily extinguished. Governments narrowed +the franchise, curtailed the functions of representative assemblies, filled +these with their creatures, coerced voters at elections; but, except in +Austria, there was no open abandonment of constitutional forms. In some +States, as in Saxony under the reactionary rule of Count Beust, the system +of national representation established in 1848 was abolished and the +earlier Estates were revived; in Prussia the two Houses of Parliament +continued in existence, but in such dependence upon the royal authority, +and under such strong pressure of an aristocratic and official reaction, +that, after struggling for some years in the Lower House, the Liberal +leaders at length withdrew in despair. The character which Government now +assumed in Prussia was indeed far more typical of the condition of Germany +at large than was the bold and uncompromising despotism of Prince +Schwarzenberg in Austria. Manteuffel, in whom the Prussian epoch of +reaction was symbolised, was not a cruel or a violent Minister; but his +rule was stamped with a peculiar and degrading meanness, more irritating to +those who suffered under it than harsher wrong. In his hands government was +a thing of eavesdropping and espionage, a system of petty persecution, a +school of subservience and hypocrisy. He had been the instrument at Olmuetz +of such a surrender of national honour and national interests as few +nations have ever endured with the chances of war still untried. This +surrender may, in the actual condition of the Prussian army, have been +necessary, but the abasement of it seemed to cling to Manteuffel and to +lower all his conceptions of government. Even where the conclusions of his +policy were correct they seemed to have been reached by some unworthy +process. Like Germany at large, Prussia breathed uneasily under an +oppression which was everywhere felt and yet was hard to define. Its best +elements were those which suffered the most: its highest intellectual and +political aims were those which most excited the suspicion of the +Government. Its King had lost whatever was stimulating or elevated in his +illusions. From him no second alliance with Liberalism, no further effort +on behalf of German unity, was to be expected: the hope for Germany and for +Prussia, if hope there was, lay in a future reign. + +[Austria after 1851.] + +[Austrian Concordat, Sept. 18, 1855.] + +The powerlessness of Prussia was the measure of Austrian influence and +prestige. The contrast presented by Austria in 1848 and Austria in 1851 was +indeed one that might well arrest political observers. Its recovery had no +doubt been effected partly by foreign aid, and in the struggle with the +Magyars a dangerous obligation had been incurred towards Russia; but +scarred and riven as the fabric was within, it was complete and imposing +without. Not one of the enemies who in 1848 had risen against the Court of +Vienna now remained standing. In Italy, Austria had won back what had +appeared to be hopelessly lost; in Germany it had more than vindicated its +old claims. It had thrown its rival to the ground, and the full measure of +its ambition was perhaps even yet not satisfied. "First to humiliate +Prussia, then to destroy it," was the expression in which Schwarzenberg +summed up his German policy. Whether, with his undoubted firmness and +daring, the Minister possessed the intellectual qualities and the +experience necessary for the successful administration of an Empire built +up, as Austria now was, on violence and on the suppression of every +national force, was doubted even by his admirers. The proof, however, was +not granted to him, for a sudden death carried him off in his fourth year +of power (April 5th, 1852). Weaker men succeeded to his task. The epoch of +military and diplomatic triumph was now ending, the gloomier side of the +reaction stood out unrelieved by any new succession of victories. Financial +disorder grew worse and worse. Clericalism claimed its bond from the +monarchy which it had helped to restore. In the struggle of the +nationalities of Austria against the central authority the Bishops had on +the whole thrown their influence on to the side of the Crown. The restored +despotism owed too much to their help and depended too much on their +continued goodwill to be able to refuse their demands. Thus the new +centralised administration, reproducing in general the uniformity of +government attempted by the Emperor Joseph II., contrasted with this in its +subservience to clerical power. Ecclesiastical laws and jurisdictions were +allowed to encroach on the laws and jurisdiction of the State; education +was made over to the priesthood; within the Church itself the bishops were +allowed to rule uncontrolled. The very Minister who had taken office under +Schwarzenberg as the representative of the modern spirit, to which the +Government still professed to render homage, became the instrument of an +act of submission to the Papacy which marked the lowest point to which +Austrian policy fell. Alexander Bach, a prominent Liberal in Vienna at the +beginning of 1848, had accepted office at the price of his independence, +and surrendered himself to the aristocratic and clerical influences that +dominated the Court. Consistent only in his efforts to simplify the forms +of government, to promote the ascendency of German over all other elements +in the State, to maintain the improvement in the peasant's condition +effected by the Parliament of Kremsier, Bach, as Minister of the Interior, +made war in all other respects on his own earlier principles. In the former +representative of the Liberalism of the professional classes in Vienna +absolutism had now its most efficient instrument; and the Concordat +negotiated by Bach with the Papacy in 1855 marked the definite submission +of Austria to the ecclesiastical pretensions which in these years of +political languor and discouragement gained increasing recognition +throughout Central Europe. Ultramontanism had sought allies in many +political camps since the revolution of 1848. It had dallied in some +countries with Republicanism; but its truer instincts divined in the +victory of absolutist systems its own surest gain. Accommodations between +the Papacy and several of the German Governments were made in the years +succeeding 1849; and from the centralised despotism of the Emperor Francis +Joseph the Church won concessions which since the time of Maria Theresa it +had in vain sought from any ruler of the Austrian State. + +[France after 1848.] + +[Louis Napoleon.] + +The European drama which began in 1848 had more of unity and more of +concentration in its opening than in its close. In Italy it ends with the +fall of Venice; in Germany the interest lingers till the days of Olmuetz; in +France there is no decisive break in the action until the Coup d'Etat +which, at the end of the year 1851, made Louis Napoleon in all but name +Emperor of France. The six million votes which had raised Louis Napoleon to +the Presidency of the Republic might well have filled with alarm all who +hoped for a future of constitutional rule; yet the warning conveyed by the +election seems to have been understood by but few. As the representative of +order and authority, as the declared enemy of Socialism, Louis Napoleon was +on the same side as the Parliamentary majority; he had even been supported +in his candidature by Parliamentary leaders such as M. Thiers. His victory +was welcomed as a victory over Socialism and the Red Republic; he had +received some patronage from the official party of order, and it was +expected that, as nominal chief of the State, he would act as the +instrument of this party. He was an adventurer, but an adventurer with so +little that was imposing about him, that it scarcely occurred to men of +influence in Paris to credit him with the capacity for mischief. His mean +look and spiritless address, the absurdities of his past, the +insignificance of his political friends, caused him to be regarded during +his first months of public life with derision rather than with fear. The +French, said M. Thiers long afterwards, made two mistakes about Louis +Napoleon: the first when they took him for a fool, the second when they +took him for a man of genius. It was not until the appearance of the letter +to Colonel Ney, in which the President ostentatiously separated himself +from his Ministers and emphasised his personal will in the direction of the +foreign policy of France, that suspicions of danger to the Republic from +his ambition arose. From this time, in the narrow circle of the Ministers +whom official duty brought into direct contact with the President, a +constant sense of insecurity and dread of some new surprise on his part +prevailed, though the accord which had been broken by the letter to Colonel +Ney was for a while outwardly re-established, and the forms of +Parliamentary government remained unimpaired. + +[Message of Oct. 31, 1849.] + +The first year of Louis Napoleon's term of office was drawing to a close +when a message from him was delivered to the Assembly which seemed to +announce an immediate attack upon the Constitution. The Ministry in office +was composed of men of high Parliamentary position; it enjoyed the entire +confidence of a great majority in the Assembly, and had enforced with at +least sufficient energy the measures of public security which the President +and the country seemed agreed in demanding. Suddenly, on the 31st of +October, the President announced to the Assembly by a message carried by +one of his aides-de-camp that the Ministry were dismissed. The reason +assigned for their dismissal was the want of unity within the Cabinet +itself; but the language used by the President announced much more than a +ministerial change. "France, in the midst of confusion, seeks for the hand, +the will of him whom it elected on the 10th of December. The victory won on +that day was the victory of a system, for the name of Napoleon is in itself +a programme. It signifies order, authority, religion, national prosperity +within; national dignity without. It is this policy, inaugurated by my +election, that I desire to carry to triumph with the support of the +Assembly and of the people." In order to save the Republic from anarchy, to +maintain the prestige of France among other nations, the President declared +that he needed men of action rather than of words; yet when the list of the +new Ministers appeared, it contained scarcely a single name of weight. +Louis Napoleon had called to office persons whose very obscurity had marked +them as his own instruments, and guaranteed to him the ascendency which he +had not hitherto possessed within the Cabinet. Satisfied with having given +this proof of his power, he resumed the appearance of respect, if not of +cordiality, towards the Assembly. He had learnt to beware of precipitate +action; above two years of office were still before him; and he had now +done enough to make it clear to all who were disposed to seek their +fortunes in a new political cause that their services on his behalf would +be welcomed, and any excess of zeal more than pardoned. From this time +there grew up a party which had for its watchword the exaltation of Louis +Napoleon and the derision of the methods of Parliamentary government. +Journalists, unsuccessful politicians, adventurers of every description, +were enlisted in the ranks of this obscure but active band. For their acts +and their utterances no one was responsible but themselves. They were +disavowed without compunction when their hardihood went too far; but their +ventures brought them no peril, and the generosity of the President was not +wanting to those who insisted on serving him in spite of himself. + +[Law limiting the Franchise, May 31, 1850.] + +France was still trembling with the shock of the Four Days of June; and +measures of repression formed the common ground upon which Louis Napoleon +and the Assembly met without fear of conflict. Certain elections which were +held in the spring of 1850, and which gave a striking victory in Paris and +elsewhere to Socialist or Ultra-Democratic candidates, revived the alarms +of the owners of property, and inspired the fear that with universal +suffrage the Legislature itself might ultimately fall into the hands of the +Red Republicans. The principle of universal suffrage had been proclaimed +almost by accident in the midst of the revolution of 1848. It had been +embodied in the Constitution of that year because it was found already in +existence. No party had seriously considered the conditions under which it +was to be exercised, or had weighed the political qualifications of the +mass to whom it was so lightly thrown. When election after election +returned to the Chamber men whose principles were held to menace society +itself, the cry arose that France must be saved from the hands of the vile +multitude; and the President called upon a Committee of the Assembly to +frame the necessary measures of electoral reform. Within a week the work of +the Committee was completed, and the law which it had drafted was brought +before the Assembly. It was proposed that, instead of a residence of six +months, a continuous residence of three years in the same commune should be +required of every voter, and that the fulfilment of this condition should +be proved, not by ordinary evidence, but by one of certain specified acts, +such as the payment of personal taxes. With modifications of little +importance the Bill was passed by the Assembly. Whether its real effect was +foreseen even by those who desired the greatest possible limitation of the +franchise is doubtful; it is certain that many who supported it believed, +in their ignorance of the practical working of electoral laws, that they +were excluding from the franchise only the vagabond and worthless class +which has no real place within the body politic. When the electoral lists +drawn up in pursuance of the measure appeared, they astounded all parties +alike. Three out of the ten millions of voters in France were +disfranchised. Not only the inhabitants of whole quarters in the great +cities but the poorer classes among the peasantry throughout France had +disappeared from the electoral body. The Assembly had at one blow converted +into enemies the entire mass of the population that lived by the wages of +bodily labour. It had committed an act of political suicide, and had given +to a man so little troubled with scruples of honour as Louis Napoleon the +fatal opportunity of appealing to France as the champion of national +sovereignty and the vindicator of universal suffrage against an Assembly +which had mutilated it in the interests of class. [454] + +[Prospects of Louis Napoleon.] + +The duration of the Presidency was fixed by the Constitution of 1848 at +four years, and it was enacted that the President should not be re-eligible +to his dignity. By the operation of certain laws imperfectly adjusted to +one another, the tenure of office by Louis Napoleon expired on the 8th of +May, 1852, while the date for the dissolution of the Assembly fell within a +few weeks of this day. France was therefore threatened with the dangers +attending the almost simultaneous extinction of all authority. The perils +of 1852 loomed only too visibly before the country, and Louis Napoleon +addressed willing hearers when, in the summer of 1850, he began to hint at +the necessity of a prolongation of his own power. The Parliamentary recess +was employed by the President in two journeys through the Departments; the +first through those of the south-east, where Socialism was most active, and +where his appearance served at once to prove his own confidence and to +invigorate the friends of authority; the second through Normandy, where the +prevailing feeling was strongly in favour of firm government, and +utterances could safely be made by the President which would have brought +him into some risk at Paris. In suggesting that France required his own +continued presence at the head of the State Louis Napoleon was not +necessarily suggesting a violation of the law. It was provided by the +Statutes of 1848 that the Assembly by a vote of three-fourths might order a +revision of the Constitution; and in favour of this revision petitions were +already being drawn up throughout the country. Were the clause forbidding +the re-election of the President removed from the Constitution, Louis +Napoleon might fairly believe that an immense majority of the French people +would re-invest him with power. He would probably have been content with a +legal re-election had this been rendered possible; but the Assembly showed +little sign of a desire to smooth his way, and it therefore became +necessary for him to seek the means of realising his aims in violation of +the law. He had persuaded himself that his mission, his destiny, was to +rule France; in other words, he had made up his mind to run such risks and +to sanction such crimes as might be necessary to win him sovereign power. +With the loftier impulses of ambition, motives of a meaner kind stimulated +him to acts of energy. Never wealthy, the father of a family though +unmarried, he had exhausted his means, and would have returned to private +life a destitute man, if not laden with debt. When his own resolution +flagged, there were those about him too deeply interested in his fortunes +to allow him to draw back. + +[Louis Napoleon and the army.] + +[Dismissal of Changarnier, Jan., 1851.] + +It was by means of the army that Louis Napoleon intended in the last resort +to make himself master of France, and the army had therefore to be won over +to his personal cause. The generals who had gained distinction either in +the Algerian wars or in the suppression of insurrection in France were +without exception Orleanists or Republicans. Not a single officer of +eminence was as yet included in the Bonapartist band. The President himself +had never seen service except in a Swiss camp of exercise; beyond his name +he possessed nothing that could possibly touch the imagination of a +soldier. The heroic element not being discoverable in his person or his +career, it remained to work by more material methods. Louis Napoleon had +learnt many things in England, and had perhaps observed in the English +elections of that period how much may be effected by the simple means of +money-bribes and strong drink. The saviour of society was not ashamed to +order the garrison of Paris double rations of brandy and to distribute +innumerable doles of half a franc or less. Military banquets were given, in +which the sergeant and the corporal sat side by side with the higher +officers. Promotion was skilfully offered or withheld. As the generals of +the highest position were hostile to Bonaparte, it was the easier to tempt +their subordinates with the prospect of their places. In the acclamations +which greeted the President at the reviews held at Paris in the autumn of +1850, in the behaviour both of officers and men in certain regiments, it +was seen how successful had been the emissaries of Bonapartism. The +Committee which represented the absent Chamber in vain called the Minister +of War to account for these irregularities. It was in vain that +Changarnier, who, as commander both of the National Guard of Paris and of +the first military division, seemed to hold the arbitrament between +President and Assembly in his hands, openly declared at the beginning of +1851 in favour of the Constitution. He was dismissed from his post; and +although a vote of censure which followed this dismissal led to the +resignation of the Ministry, the Assembly was unable to reinstate +Changarnier in his command, and helplessly witnessed the authority which he +had held pass into hostile or untrustworthy hands. + +[Proposed Revision of the Constitution.] + +[Revision of the Constitution rejected, July 19.] + +There now remained only one possible means of averting the attack upon the +Constitution which was so clearly threatened, and that was by subjecting +the Constitution itself to revision in order that Louis Napoleon might +legally seek re-election at the end of his Presidency. An overwhelming +current of public opinion pressed indeed in the direction of such a change. +However gross and undisguised the initiative of the local functionaries in +preparing the petitions which showered upon the Assembly, the national +character of the demand could not be doubted. There was no other candidate +whose name carried with it any genuine popularity or prestige, or around +whom even the Parliamentary sections at enmity with the President could +rally. The Assembly was divided not very unevenly between Legitimists, +Orleanists, and Republicans. Had indeed the two monarchical groups been +able to act in accord, they might have had some hope of re-establishing the +throne; and an attempt had already been made to effect a union, on the +understanding that the childless Comte de Chambord should recognise the +grandson of Louis Philippe as his heir, the House of Orleans renouncing its +claims during the lifetime of the chief of the elder line. These plans had +been frustrated by the refusal of the Comte de Chambord to sanction any +appeal to the popular vote, and the restoration of the monarchy was +therefore hopeless for the present. It remained for the Assembly to decide +whether it would facilitate Louis Napoleon's re-election as President by a +revision of the Constitution or brave the risk of his violent usurpation of +power. The position was a sad and even humiliating one for those who, while +they could not disguise their real feeling towards the Prince, yet knew +themselves unable to count on the support of the nation if they should +resist him. The Legitimists, more sanguine in temper, kept in view an +ultimate restoration of the monarchy, and lent themselves gladly to any +policy which might weaken the constitutional safeguards of the Republic. +The Republican minority alone determined to resist any proposal for +revision, and to stake everything upon the maintenance of the constitution +in its existing form. Weak as the Republicans were as compared with the +other groups in the Assembly when united against them, they were yet strong +enough to prevent the Ministry from securing that majority of three-fourths +without which the revision of the Constitution could not be undertaken. +Four hundred and fifty votes were given in favour of revision, two hundred +and seventy against it (July 19th). The proposal therefore fell to the +ground, and Louis Napoleon, who could already charge the Assembly with +having by its majority destroyed universal suffrage, could now charge it +with having by its minority forbidden the nation to choose its own head. +Nothing more was needed by him. He had only to decide upon the time and the +circumstances of the _coup d'etat_ which was to rid him of his adversaries +and to make him master of France. + +[Preparations for the _coup d'etat_.] + +Louis Napoleon had few intimate confidants; the chief among these were his +half-brother Morny, one of the illegitimate offspring of Queen Hortense, a +man of fashion and speculator in the stocks; Fialin or Persigny, a person +of humble origin who had proved himself a devoted follower of the Prince +through good and evil; and Fleury, an officer at this time on a mission in +Algiers. These were not men out of whom Louis Napoleon could form an +administration, but they were useful to him in discovering and winning over +soldiers and officials of sufficient standing to give to the execution of +the conspiracy something of the appearance of an act of Government. A +general was needed at the War Office who would go all lengths in +illegality. Such a man had already been found in St. Arnaud, commander of a +brigade in Algiers, a brilliant soldier who had redeemed a disreputable +past by years of hard service, and who was known to be ready to treat his +French fellow-citizens exactly as he would treat the Arabs. As St. Arnaud's +name was not yet familiar in Paris, a campaign was arranged in the summer +of 1851 for the purpose of winning him distinction. At the cost of some +hundreds of lives St. Arnaud was pushed into sufficient fame; and after +receiving congratulations proportioned to his exploits from the President's +own hand, he was summoned to Paris, in order at the right moment to be made +Minister of War. A troop of younger officers, many of whom gained a +lamentable celebrity as the generals of 1870, were gradually brought over +from Algiers and placed round the Minister in the capital. The command of +the army of Paris was given to General Magnan, who, though he preferred not +to share in the deliberations on the _coup d'etat_, had promised his +cooperation when the moment should arrive. The support, or at least the +acquiescence, of the army seemed thus to be assured. The National Guard, +which, under Changarnier, would probably have rallied in defence of the +Assembly, had been placed under an officer pledged to keep it in inaction. +For the management of the police Louis Napoleon had fixed upon M. Maupas, +Prefet of the Haute Garonne. This person, to whose shamelessness we owe the +most authentic information that exists on the _coup d'etat_, had, +while in an inferior station, made it his business to ingratiate himself +with the President by sending to him personally police reports which ought +to have been sent to the Ministers. The objects and the character of M. +Maupas were soon enough understood by Louis Napoleon. He promoted him to +high office; sheltered him from the censure of his superiors; and, when the +_coup d'etat_ was drawing nigh, called him to Paris, in the full and +well-grounded confidence that, whatever the most perfidious ingenuity could +contrive in turning the guardians of the law against the law itself, that +M. Maupas, as Prefet of Police, might be relied upon to accomplish. + +[The _coup d'etat_ fixed for December.] + +Preparations for the _coup d'etat_ had been so far advanced in +September that a majority of the conspirators had then urged Louis Napoleon +to strike the blow without delay, while the members of the Assembly were +still dispersed over France in the vacation. St. Arnaud, however, refused +his assent, declaring that the deputies, if left free, would assemble at a +distance from Paris, summon to them the generals loyal to the Constitution, +and commence a civil war. He urged that, in order to avoid greater +subsequent risks, it would be necessary to seize all the leading +representatives and generals from whom resistance might be expected, and to +hold them under durance until the crisis should be over. This simultaneous +arrest of all the foremost public men in France could only be effected at a +time when the Assembly was sitting. St. Arnaud therefore demanded that the +_coup d'etat_ should be postponed till the winter. Another reason made +for delay. Little as the populace of Paris loved the reactionary Assembly, +Louis Napoleon was not altogether assured that it would quietly witness his +own usurpation of power. In waiting until the Chamber should again be in +session, he saw the opportunity of exhibiting his cause as that of the +masses themselves, and of justifying his action as the sole means of +enforcing popular rights against a legislature obstinately bent on denying +them. Louis Napoleon's own Ministers had overthrown universal suffrage. +This might indeed be matter for comment on the part of the censorious, but +it was not a circumstance to stand in the way of the execution of a great +design. Accordingly Louis Napoleon determined to demand from the Assembly +at the opening of the winter session the repeal of the electoral law of May +31st, and to make its refusal, on which he could confidently reckon, the +occasion of its destruction. + +[Louis Napoleon demands repeal of Law of May 31.] + +[The Assembly refuses.] + +The conspirators were up to this time conspirators and nothing more. A +Ministry still subsisted which was not initiated in the President's designs +nor altogether at his command. On his requiring that the repeal of the law +of May 31st should be proposed to the Assembly, the Cabinet resigned. The +way to the highest functions of State was thus finally opened for the +agents of the _coup d'etat_. St. Arnaud was placed at the War Office, +Maupas at the Prefecture of Police. The colleagues assigned to them were +too insignificant to exercise any control over their actions. At the +reopening of the Assembly on the 4th of November an energetic message from +the President was read. On the one hand he denounced a vast and perilous +combination of all the most dangerous elements of society which threatened +to overwhelm France in the following year; on the other hand he demanded, +with certain undefined safeguards, the re-establishment of universal +suffrage. The middle classes were scared with the prospect of a Socialist +revolution; the Assembly was divided against itself, and the democracy of +Paris flattered by the homage paid to the popular vote. With very little +delay a measure repealing the Law of May 31st was introduced into the +Assembly. It was supported by the Republicans and by many members of the +other groups; but the majority of the Assembly, while anxious to devise +some compromise, refused to condemn its own work in the unqualified form on +which the President insisted. The Bill was thrown out by seven votes. +Forthwith the rumour of an impending _coup d'etat_ spread through +Paris. The Questors, or members charged with the safeguarding of the +Assembly, moved the resolutions necessary to enable them to secure +sufficient military aid. Even now prompt action might perhaps have saved +the Chamber. But the Republican deputies, incensed by their defeat on the +question of universal suffrage, plunged headlong into the snare set for +them by the President, and combined with his open or secret partisans to +reject the proposition of the Questors. Changarnier had blindly vouched for +the fidelity of the army; one Republican deputy, more imaginative than his +colleagues, bade the Assembly confide in their invisible sentinel, the +people. Thus the majority of the Chamber, with the clearest warning of +danger, insisted on giving the aggressor every possible advantage. If the +imbecility of opponents is the best augury of success in a bold enterprise, +the President had indeed little reason to anticipate failure. + +[The _coup d'etat_, Dec. 2.] + +The execution of the _coup d'etat_ was fixed for the early morning of +December 2nd. On the previous evening Louis Napoleon held a public +reception at the Elysee, his quiet self-possessed manner indicating nothing +of the struggle at hand. Before the guests dispersed the President withdrew +to his study. There the last council of the conspirators was held, and they +parted, each to the execution of the work assigned to him. The central +element in the plan was the arrest of Cavaignac, of Changarnier and three +other generals who were members of the Assembly, of eleven civilian +deputies including M. Thiers, and of sixty-two other politicians of +influence. Maupas summoned to the Prefecture of Police in the dead of night +a sufficient number of his trusted agents, received each of them on his +arrival in a separate room, and charged each with the arrest of one of the +victims. The arrests were accomplished before dawn, and the leading +soldiers and citizens of France met one another in the prison of Mazas. The +Palais Bourbon, the meeting-place of the Assembly, was occupied by troops. +The national printing establishment was seized by gendarmes, and the +proclamations of Louis Napoleon, distributed sentence by sentence to +different compositors, were set in type before the workmen knew upon what +they were engaged. When day broke the Parisians found the soldiers in the +streets, and the walls placarded with manifestoes of Louis Napoleon. The +first of these was a decree which announced in the name of the French +people that the National Assembly and the Council of State were dissolved, +that universal suffrage was restored, and that the nation was convoked in +its electoral colleges from the 14th to the 21st of December. The second +was a proclamation to the people, in which Louis Napoleon denounced at once +the monarchical conspirators within the Assembly and the anarchists who +sought to overthrow all government. His duty called upon him to save the +Republic by an appeal to the nation. He proposed the establishment of a +decennial executive authority, with a Senate, a Council of State, a +Legislative Body, and other institutions borrowed from the Consulate of +1799. If the nation refused him a majority of its votes he would summon a +new Assembly and resign his powers; if the nation believed in the cause of +which his name was the symbol, in France regenerated by the Revolution and +organised by the Emperor, it would prove this by ratifying his authority. A +third proclamation was addressed to the army. In 1830 and in 1848 the army +had been treated as the conquered, but its voice was now to be heard. +Common glories and sorrows united the soldiers of France with Napoleon's +heir, and the future would unite them in common devotion to the repose and +greatness of their country. + +[Paris on Dec. 2.] + +The full meaning of these manifestoes was not at first understood by the +groups who read them. The Assembly was so unpopular that the announcement +of its dissolution, with the restoration of universal suffrage, pleased +rather than alarmed the democratic quarters of Paris. It was not until some +hours had passed that the arrests became generally known, and that the +first symptoms of resistance appeared. Groups of deputies assembled at the +houses of the Parliamentary leaders; a body of fifty even succeeded in +entering the Palais Bourbon and in commencing a debate: they were, however, +soon dispersed by soldiers. Later in the day above two hundred members +assembled at the Mairie of the Tenth Arrondissement. There they passed +resolutions declaring the President removed from his office, and appointing +a commander of the troops at Paris. The first officers who were sent to +clear the Mairie flinched in the execution of their work, and withdrew for +further orders. The Magistrates of the High Court, whose duty it was to +order the impeachment of the President in case of the violation of his oath +to the Constitution, assembled, and commenced the necessary proceedings; +but before they could sign a warrant, soldiers forced their way into the +hall and drove the judges from the Bench. In due course General Forey +appeared with a strong body of troops at the Mairie, where the two hundred +deputies were assembled. Refusing to disperse, they were one and all +arrested, and conducted as prisoners between files of troops to the +Barracks of the Quai d'Orsay. The National Guard, whose drums had been +removed by their commander in view of any spontaneous movement to arms, +remained invisible. Louis Napoleon rode out amidst the acclamations of the +soldiery; and when the day closed it seemed as if Paris had resolved to +accept the change of Government and the overthrow of the Constitution +without a struggle. + +[December 3.] + +[December 4.] + +There were, however, a few resolute men at work in the workmen's quarters; +and in the wealthier part of the city the outrage upon the National +Representation gradually roused a spirit of resistance. On the morning of +December 3rd the Deputy Baudin met with his death in attempting to defend a +barricade which had been erected in the Faubourg St. Antoine. The artisans +of eastern Paris showed, however, little inclination to take up arms on +behalf of those who had crushed them in the Four Days of June; the +agitation was strongest within the Boulevards, and spread westwards towards +the stateliest district of Paris. The barricades erected on the south of +the Boulevards were so numerous, the crowds so formidable, that towards the +close of the day the troops were withdrawn, and it was determined that +after a night of quiet they should make a general attack and end the +struggle at one blow. At midday on December 4th divisions of the army +converged from all directions upon the insurgent quarter. The barricades +were captured or levelled by artillery, and with a loss on the part of the +troops of twenty-eight killed, and a hundred and eighty wounded resistance +was overcome. But the soldiers had been taught to regard the inhabitants of +Paris as their enemies, and they bettered the instructions given them. +Maddened by drink or panic, they commenced indiscriminate firing in the +Boulevards after the conflict was over, and slaughtered all who either in +the street or at the windows of the houses came within range of their +bullets. According to official admissions, the lives of sixteen civilians +paid for every soldier slain; independent estimates place far higher the +number of the victims of this massacre. Two thousand arrests followed, and +every Frenchman who appeared dangerous to Louis Napoleon's myrmidons, from +Thiers and Victor Hugo down to the anarchist orators of the wineshops, was +either transported, exiled, or lodged in prison. Thus was the Republic +preserved and society saved. + +[The Plebiscite, Dec. 20.] + +[Napoleon III. Emperor, Dec. 2, 1852.] + +France in general received the news of the _coup d'etat_ with indifference: +where it excited popular movements these movements were of such a character +that Louis Napoleon drew from them the utmost profit. A certain fierce, +blind Socialism had spread among the poorest of the rural classes in the +centre and south of France. In these departments there were isolated +risings, accompanied by acts of such murderous outrage and folly that a +general terror seized the surrounding districts. In the course of a few +days the predatory bands were dispersed, and an unsparing chastisement +inflicted on all who were concerned in their misdeeds; but the reports sent +to Paris were too serviceable to Louis Napoleon to be left in obscurity; +and these brutish village-outbreaks, which collapsed at the first +appearance of a handful of soldiers, were represented as the prelude to a +vast Socialist revolution from which the _coup d'etat_, and that alone, had +saved France. Terrified by the re-appearance of the Red Spectre, the French +nation proceeded on the 20th of December to pass its judgment on the +accomplished usurpation. The question submitted for the _plebiscite_ was, +whether the people desired the maintenance of Louis Napoleon's authority +and committed to him the necessary powers for establishing a Constitution +on the basis laid down in his proclamation of December 2nd. Seven million +votes answered this question in the affirmative, less than one-tenth of +that number in the negative. The result was made known on the last day of +the year 1851. On the first day of the new year Louis Napoleon attended a +service of thanksgiving at Notre Dame, took possession of the Tuileries, +and restored the eagle as the military emblem of France. He was now in all +but name an absolute sovereign. The Church, the army, the ever-servile body +of the civil administration, waited impatiently for the revival of the +Imperial title. Nor was the saviour of society the man to shrink from +further responsibilities. Before the year closed the people was once more +called upon to express its will. Seven millions of votes pronounced for +hereditary power; and on the anniversary of the _coup d'etat_ Napoleon III. +was proclaimed Emperor of the French. + + + + +CHAPTER XXI. + + +England and France in 1851--Russia under Nicholas--The Hungarian +Refugees--Dispute between France and Russia on the Holy Places--Nicholas +and the British Ambassador--Lord Stratford de Redcliffe--Menschikoff's +Mission--Russian Troops enter the Danubian Principalities--Lord Aberdeen's +Cabinet--Movements of the Fleets--The Vienna Note--The Fleets pass the +Dardanelles--Turkish Squadron destroyed at Sinope--Declaration of +War--Policy of Austria--Policy of Prussia--The Western Powers and the +European Concert--Siege of Silistria--The Principalities evacuated--Further +objects of the Western Powers--Invasion of the Crimea--Battle of the +Alma--The Flank March--Balaclava--Inkermann--Winter in the Crimea--Death of +Nicholas--Conference of Vienna--Austria--Progress of the Siege--Plans of +Napoleon III.--Canrobert and Pelissier--Unsuccessful Assault--Battle of the +Tchernaya--Capture of the Malakoff--Fall of Sebastopol--Fall of +Kars--Negotiations for Peace--The Conference of Paris--Treaty of Paris +--The Danubian Principalities--Continued discord in the Ottoman +Empire--Revision of the Treaty of Paris in 1871. + + +[England in 1851.] + +The year 1851 was memorable in England as that of the Great Exhibition. +Thirty-six years of peace, marked by an enormous development of +manufacturing industry, by the introduction of railroads, and by the +victory of the principle of Free Trade, had culminated in a spectacle so +impressive and so novel that to many it seemed the emblem and harbinger of +a new epoch in the history of mankind, in which war should cease, and the +rivalry of nations should at length find its true scope in the advancement +of the arts of peace. The apostles of Free Trade had idealised the cause +for which they contended. The unhappiness and the crimes of nations had, as +they held, been due principally to the action of governments, which plunged +harmless millions into war for dynastic ends, and paralysed human energy by +their own blind and senseless interference with the natural course of +exchange. Compassion for the poor and the suffering, a just resentment +against laws which in the supposed interest of a minority condemned the +mass of the nation to a life of want, gave moral fervour and elevation to +the teaching of Cobden and those who shared his spirit. Like others who +have been constrained by a noble enthusiasm, they had their visions; and in +their sense of the greatness of that new force which was ready to operate +upon human life, they both forgot the incompleteness of their own doctrine, +and under-estimated the influences which worked, and long must work, upon +mankind in an opposite direction. In perfect sincerity the leader of +English economical reform at the middle of this century looked forward to a +reign of peace as the result of unfettered intercourse between the members +of the European family. What the man of genius and conviction had +proclaimed the charlatan repeated in his turn. Louis Napoleon appreciated +the charm which schemes of commercial development exercised upon the +trading classes in France. He was ready to salute the Imperial eagles as +objects of worship and to invoke the memories of Napoleon's glory when +addressing soldiers; when it concerned him to satisfy the commercial world, +he was the very embodiment of peace and of peaceful industry. "Certain +persons," he said, in an address at Bordeaux, shortly before assuming the +title of Emperor, "say that the Empire is war. I say that the Empire is +peace; for France desires peace, and when France is satisfied the world is +tranquil. We have waste territories to cultivate, roads to open, harbours +to dig, a system of railroads to complete; we have to bring all our great +western ports into connection with the American continent by a rapidity of +communication which we still want. We have ruins to restore, false gods to +overthrow, truths to make triumphant. This is the sense that I attach to +the Empire; these are the conquests which I contemplate." Never had the +ideal of industrious peace been more impressively set before mankind than +in the years which succeeded the convulsion of 1848. Yet the epoch on which +Europe was then about to enter proved to be pre-eminently an epoch of war. +In the next quarter of a century there was not one of the Great Powers +which was not engaged in an armed struggle with its rivals. Nor were the +wars of this period in any sense the result of accident, or disconnected +with the stream of political tendencies which makes the history of the age. +With one exception they left in their train great changes for which the +time was ripe, changes which for more than a generation had been the +recognised objects of national desire, but which persuasion and revolution +had equally failed to bring into effect. The Crimean War alone was barren +in positive results of a lasting nature, and may seem only to have +postponed, at enormous cost of life, the fall of a doomed and outworn +Power. But the time has not yet arrived when the real bearing of the +overthrow of Russia in 1854 on the destiny of the Christian races of Turkey +can be confidently expressed. The victory of the Sultan's protectors +delayed the emancipation of these races for twenty years; the victory, or +the unchecked aggression, of Russia in 1854 might possibly have closed to +them for ever the ways to national independence. + +[Russian policy under Nicholas.] + +The plans formed by the Empress Catherine in the last century for the +restoration of the Greek Empire under a prince of the Russian House had +long been abandoned at St. Petersburg. The later aim of Russian policy +found its clearest expression in the Treaty of Unkiar Skelessi, extorted +from Sultan Mahmud in 1833 in the course of the first war against Mehemet +Ali. This Treaty, if it had not been set aside by the Western Powers, would +have made the Ottoman Empire a vassal State under the Czar's protection. In +the concert of Europe which was called into being by the second war of +Mehemet Ali against the Sultan in 1840, Nicholas had considered it his +interest to act with England and the German Powers in defence of the Porte +against its Egyptian rival and his French ally. A policy of moderation had +been imposed upon Russia by the increased watchfulness and activity now +displayed by the other European States in all that related to the Ottoman +Empire. Isolated aggression had become impracticable; it was necessary for +Russia to seek the countenance or support of some ally before venturing on +the next step in the extension of its power southwards. + +[Nicholas in England, 1844.] + +In 1844 Nicholas visited England. The object of his journey was to sound +the Court and Government, and to lay the foundation for concerted action +between Russia and England, to the exclusion of France, when circumstances +should bring about the dissolution of the Ottoman Empire, an event which +the Czar believed to be not far off. Peel was then Prime Minister; Lord +Aberdeen was Foreign Secretary. Aberdeen had begun his political career in +a diplomatic mission to the Allied Armies in 1814. His feelings towards +Russia were those of a loyal friend towards an old ally; and the +remembrance of the epoch of 1814, when the young Nicholas had made +acquaintance with Lord Aberdeen in France, appears to have given to the +Czar a peculiar sense of confidence in the goodwill of the English Minister +towards himself. Nicholas spoke freely with Aberdeen, as well as with Peel +and Wellington, on the impending fall of the Ottoman Empire. "We have," he +said, "a sick, a dying man on our hands. We must keep him alive so long as +it is possible to do so, but we must frankly take into view all +contingencies. I wish for no inch of Turkish soil myself, but neither will +I permit any other Power to seize an inch of it. France, which has designs +upon Africa, upon the Mediterranean, and upon the East, is the only Power +to be feared. An understanding between England and Russia will preserve the +peace of Europe." If the Czar pursued his speculations further into detail, +of which there is no evidence, he elicited no response. He was heard with +caution, and his visit appears to have produced nothing more than the +formal expression of a desire on the part of the British Government that +the existing treaty-rights of Russia should be respected by the Porte, +together with an unmeaning promise that, if unexpected events should occur +in Turkey, Russia and England should enter into counsel as to the best +course of action to be pursued in common. [455] + +[Nicholas in 1848.] + +[The Hungarian refugees, 1849.] + +Nicholas, whether from policy or from a sense of kingly honour which at +most times powerfully influenced him, did not avail himself of the +prostration of the Continental Powers in 1848 to attack Turkey. He detested +revolution, as a crime against the divinely ordered subjection of nations +to their rulers, and would probably have felt himself degraded had he, in +the spirit of his predecessor Catherine, turned the calamities of his +brother-monarchs to his own separate advantage. It accorded better with his +proud nature, possibly also with the schemes of a far-reaching policy, for +Russia to enter the field as the protector of the Hapsburgs against the +rebel Hungarians than for its armies to snatch from the Porte what the +lapse of time and the goodwill of European allies would probably give to +Russia at no distant date without a struggle. Disturbances at Bucharest and +at Jassy led indeed to a Russian intervention in the Danubian +Principalities in the interests of a despotic system of government; but +Russia possessed by treaty protectorial rights over these Provinces. The +military occupation which followed the revolt against the Hospodars was the +subject of a convention between Turkey and Russia; it was effected by the +armies of the two Powers jointly; and at the expiration of two years the +Russian forces were peacefully withdrawn. More serious were the +difficulties which arose from the flight of Kossuth and other Hungarian +leaders into Turkey after the subjugation of Hungary by the allied Austrian +and Russian armies. The Courts of Vienna and St. Petersburg united in +demanding from the Porte the surrender of these refugees; the Sultan +refused to deliver them up, and he was energetically supported by Great +Britain, Kossuth's children on their arrival at Constantinople being +received and cared for at the British Embassy. The tyrannous demand of the +two Emperors, the courageous resistance of the Sultan, excited the utmost +interest in Western Europe. By a strange turn of fortune, the Power which +at the end of the last century had demanded from the Court of Vienna the +Greek leader Rhegas, and had put him to death as soon as he was handed over +by the Austrian police, was now gaining the admiration of all free nations +as the last barrier that sheltered the champions of European liberty from +the vengeance of despotic might. The Czar and the Emperor of Austria had +not reckoned with the forces of public indignation aroused against them in +the West by their attempt to wrest their enemies from the Sultan's hand. +They withdrew their ambassadors from Constantinople and threatened to +resort to force. But the appearance of the British and French fleets at the +Dardanelles gave a new aspect to the dispute. The Emperors learnt that if +they made war upon Turkey for the question at issue they would have to +fight also against the Western Powers. The demand for the surrender of the +refugees was withdrawn; and in undertaking to keep the principal of them +under surveillance for a reasonable period, the Sultan gave to the two +Imperial Courts such satisfaction as they could, without loss of dignity, +accept. [456] + +[Dispute between France and Russia on the Holy Places, 1850-2.] + +The _coup d'etat_ of Louis Napoleon at the end of the year 1851 was +witnessed by the Czar with sympathy and admiration as a service to the +cause of order; but the assumption of the Imperial title by the Prince +displeased him exceedingly. While not refusing to recognise Napoleon III., +he declined to address him by the term (_mon frere_) usually employed +by monarchs in writing to one another. In addition to the question relating +to the Hungarian refugees, a dispute concerning the Holy Places in +Palestine threatened to cause strife between France and Russia. The same +wave of religious and theological interest which in England produced the +Tractarian movement brought into the arena of political life in France an +enthusiasm for the Church long strange to the Legislature and the governing +circles of Paris. In the Assembly of 1849 Montalembert, the spokesman of +this militant Catholicism, was one of the foremost figures. Louis Napoleon, +as President, sought the favour of those whom Montalembert led; and the +same Government which restored the Pope to Rome demanded from the Porte a +stricter enforcement of the rights of the Latin Church in the East. The +earliest Christian legends had been localised in various spots around +Jerusalem. These had been in the ages of faith the goal of countless +pilgrimages, and in more recent centuries they had formed the object of +treaties between the Porte and France. Greek monks, however, disputed +with Latin monks for the guardianship of the Holy Places; and as the +power of Russia grew, the privileges of the Greek monks had increased. +The claims of the rival brotherhoods, which related to doors, keys, stars +and lamps, might probably have been settled to the satisfaction of all +parties within a few hours by an experienced stage-manager; in the hands +of diplomatists bent on obtaining triumphs over one another they assumed +dimensions that overshadowed the peace of Europe. The French and the +Russian Ministers at Constantinople alternately tormented the Sultan in +the character of aggrieved sacristans, until, at the beginning of 1852, +the Porte compromised itself with both parties by adjudging to each +rights which it professed also to secure to the other. A year more, spent +in prevarications, in excuses, and in menaces, ended with the triumph of +the French, with the evasion of the promises made by the Sultan to +Russia, and with the discomfiture of the Greek Church in the person of +the monks who officiated at the Holy Sepulchre and the Shrine of the +Nativity. [457] + +[Nicholas and Sir H. Seymour, Jan., Feb., 1853.] + +Nicholas treated the conduct of the Porte as an outrage upon himself. A +conflict which had broken out between the Sultan and the Montenegrins, and +which now threatened to take a deadly form, confirmed the Czar in his +belief that the time for resolute action had arrived. At the beginning of +the year 1853 he addressed himself to Hamilton Seymour, British ambassador +at St. Petersburg, in terms much stronger and clearer than those which he +had used towards Lord Aberdeen nine years before. "The Sick Man," he said, +"was in extremities; the time had come for a clear understanding between +England and Russia. The occupation of Constantinople by Russian troops +might be necessary, but the Czar would not hold it permanently. He would +not permit any other Power to establish itself at the Bosphorus, neither +would he permit the Ottoman Empire to be broken up into Republics to afford +a refuge to the Mazzinis and the Kossuths of Europe. The Danubian +Principalities were already independent States under Russian protection. +The other possessions of the Sultan north of the Balkans might be placed on +the same footing. England might annex Egypt and Crete." After making this +communication to the British ambassador, and receiving the reply that +England declined to enter into any schemes based on the fall of the Turkish +Empire and disclaimed all desire for the annexation of any part of the +Sultan's dominions, Nicholas despatched Prince Menschikoff to +Constantinople, to demand from the Porte not only an immediate settlement +of the questions relating to the Holy Places, but a Treaty guaranteeing to +the Greek Church the undisturbed enjoyment of all its ancient rights and +the benefit of all privileges that might be accorded by the Porte to any +other Christian communities. [458] + +[The Claims of Russia.] + +The Treaty which Menschikoff was instructed to demand would have placed the +Sultan and the Czar in the position of contracting parties with regard to +the entire body of rights and privileges enjoyed by the Sultan's subjects +of the Greek confession, and would so have made the violation of these +rights in the case of any individual Christian a matter entitling Russia to +interfere, or to claim satisfaction as for the breach of a Treaty +engagement. By the Treaty of Kainardjie (1774) the Sultan had indeed bound +himself "to protect the Christian religion and its Churches"; but this +phrase was too indistinct to create specific matter of Treaty-obligation; +and if it had given to Russia any general right of interference on behalf +of members of the Greek Church, it would have given it the same right in +behalf of all the Roman Catholics and all the Protestants in the Sultan's +dominions, a right which the Czars had never professed to enjoy. Moreover, +the Treaty of Kainardjie itself forbade by implication any such +construction, for it mentioned by name one ecclesiastical building for +whose priests the Porte did concede to Russia the right of addressing +representations to the Sultan. Over the Danubian Principalities Russia +possessed by the Treaty of Adrianople undoubted protectorial rights; but +these Provinces stood on a footing quite different from that of the +remainder of the Empire. That the Greek Church possessed by custom and by +enactment privileges which it was the duty of the Sultan to respect, no one +contested: the novelty of Menschikoff's claim was that the observation of +these rights should be made matter of Treaty with Russia. The importance of +the demand was proved by the fact that Menschikoff strictly forbade the +Turkish Ministers to reveal it to the other Powers, and that Nicholas +caused the English Government to be informed that the mission of his envoy +had no other object than the final adjustment of the difficulties +respecting the Holy Places. [459] + +[Lord Stratford de Redcliffe.] + +[Menschikoff leaves Constantinople, May 21.] + +[Russian troops enter the Principalities.] + +When Menschikoff reached Constantinople the British Embassy was in the +hands of a subordinate officer. The Ambassador, Sir Stratford Canning, had +recently returned to England. Stratford Canning, a cousin of the Premier, +had been employed in the East at intervals since 1810. There had been a +period in his career when he had desired to see the Turk expelled from +Europe as an incurable barbarian; but the reforms of Sultan Mahmud had at a +later time excited his warm interest and sympathy, and as Ambassador at +Constantinople from 1842 to 1852 he had laboured strenuously for the +regeneration of the Turkish Empire, and for the improvement of the +condition of the Christian races under the Sultan's rule. His dauntless, +sustained energy, his noble presence, the sincerity of his friendship +towards the Porte, gave him an influence at Constantinople seldom, if ever, +exercised by a foreign statesman. There were moments when he seemed to be +achieving results of some value; but the task which he had attempted was +one that surpassed human power; and after ten years so spent as to win for +him the fame of the greatest ambassador by whom England has been +represented in modern times, he declared that the prospects of Turkish +reform were hopeless, and left Constantinople, not intending to return. +[460] Before his successor had been appointed, the mission of Prince +Menschikoff, the violence of his behaviour at Constantinople, and a rumour +that he sought far more than his ostensible object, alarmed the British +Government. Canning was asked to resume his post. Returning to +Constantinople as Lord Stratford de Redcliffe, he communicated on his +journey with the Courts of Paris and Vienna, and carried with him authority +to order the Admiral of the fleet at Malta to hold his ships in readiness +to sail for the East. He arrived at the Bosphorus on April 5th, learnt at +once the real situation of affairs, and entered into negotiation with +Menschikoff. The Russian, a mere child in diplomacy in comparison with his +rival, suffered himself to be persuaded to separate the question of the +Holy Places from that of the guarantee of the rights of the Greek Church. +In the first matter Russia had a good cause; in the second it was advancing +a new claim. The two being dissociated, Stratford had no difficulty in +negotiating a compromise on the Holy Places satisfactory to the Czar's +representative; and the demand for the Protectorate over the Greek +Christians now stood out unobscured by those grievances of detail with +which it had been at first interwoven. Stratford encouraged the Turkish +Government to reject the Russian proposal. Knowing, nevertheless, that +Menschikoff would in the last resort endeavour to intimidate the Sultan +personally, he withheld from the Ministers, in view of this last peril, the +strongest of all his arguments; and seeking a private audience with the +Sultan on the 9th of May, he made known to him with great solemnity the +authority which he had received to order the fleet at Malta to be in +readiness to sail. The Sultan placed the natural interpretation on this +statement, and ordered final rejection of Menschikoff's demand, though the +Russian had consented to a modification of its form, and would now have +accepted a note declaratory of the intentions of the Sultan towards the +Greek Church instead of a regular Treaty. On the 21st of May Menschikoff +quitted Constantinople; and the Czar, declaring that some guarantee must be +held by Russia for the maintenance of the rights of the Greek Christians, +announced that he should order his army to occupy the Danubian Provinces. +After an interval of some weeks the Russian troops crossed the Pruth, and +spread themselves over Moldavia and Wallachia. (June 22nd.) [461] + +[English Policy.] + +In the ordinary course of affairs the invasion of the territory of one +Empire by the troops of another is, and can be nothing else than, an act of +war, necessitating hostilities as a measure of defence on the part of the +Power invaded. But the Czar protested that in taking the Danubian +Principalities in pledge he had no intention of violating the peace; and as +yet the common sense of the Turks, as well as the counsels that they +received from without, bade them hesitate before issuing a declaration of +war. Since December, 1852, Lord Aberdeen had been Prime Minister of +England, at the head of a Cabinet formed by a coalition between followers +of Sir Robert Peel and the Whig leaders Palmerston and Russell. [462] There +was no man in England more pacific in disposition, or more anxious to +remain on terms of honourable friendship with Russia, than Lord Aberdeen. +The Czar had justly reckoned on the Premier's own forbearance; but he had +failed to recognise the strength of those forces which, both within and +without the Cabinet, set in the direction of armed resistance to Russia. +Palmerston was keen for action. Lord Stratford appears to have taken it for +granted from the first that, if a war should arise between the Sultan and +the Czar in consequence of the rejection of Menschikoff's demand, Great +Britain would fight in defence of the Ottoman Empire. He had not stated +this in express terms, but the communication which he made to the Sultan +regarding his own instructions could only have been intended to convey this +impression. If the fleet was not to defend the Sultan, it was a mere piece +of deceit to inform him that the Ambassador had powers to place it in +readiness to sail; and such deceit was as alien to the character of Lord +Stratford as the assumption of a virtual engagement towards the Sultan was +in keeping with his imperious will and his passionate conviction of the +duty of England. From the date of Lord Stratford's visit to the Palace, +although no Treaty or agreement was in existence, England stood bound in +honour, so long as the Turks should pursue the policy laid down by her +envoy, to fulfil the expectations which this envoy had held out. + +[British and French fleets moved to Besika Bay, July, 1853.] + +[The Vienna Note, July 28.] + +[Constantinople in September.] + +[British and French fleets pass the Dardanelles, Oct. 22.] + +Had Lord Stratford been at the head of the Government, the policy and +intentions of Great Britain would no doubt have been announced with such +distinctness that the Czar could have fostered no misapprehension as to the +results of his own acts. Palmerston, as Premier, would probably have +adopted the same clear course, and war would either have been avoided by +this nation or have been made with a distinct purpose and on a definite +issue. But the Cabinet of Lord Aberdeen was at variance with itself. +Aberdeen was ready to go to all lengths in negotiation, but he was not +sufficiently master of his colleagues and of the representatives of England +abroad to prevent acts and declarations which in themselves brought war +near; above all, he failed to require from Turkey that abstention from +hostilities on which, so long as negotiations lasted, England and the other +Powers which proposed to make the cause of the Porte their own ought +unquestionably to have insisted. On the announcement by the Czar that his +army was about to enter the Principalities, the British Government +despatched the fleet to Besika Bay near the entrance to the Dardanelles, +and authorised Stratford to call it to the Bosphorus, in case +Constantinople should be attacked. [463] The French fleet, which had come +into Greek waters on Menschikoff's appearance at Constantinople, took up +the same position. Meanwhile European diplomacy was busily engaged in +framing schemes of compromise between the Porte and Russia. The +representatives of the four Powers met at Vienna, and agreed upon a note +which, as they considered, would satisfy any legitimate claims of Russia on +behalf of the Greek Church, and at the same time impose upon the Sultan no +further obligations towards Russia than those which already existed. [464] +This note, however, was ill drawn, and would have opened the door to new +claims on the part of Russia to a general Protectorate not sanctioned by +its authors. The draft was sent to St. Petersburg, and was accepted by the +Czar. At Constantinople its ambiguities were at once recognised; and though +Lord Stratford in his official capacity urged its acceptance under a +European guarantee against misconstruction, the Divan, now under the +pressure of strong patriotic forces, refused to accept the note unless +certain changes were made in its expressions. France, England, and Austria +united in recommending to the Court of St. Petersburg the adoption of these +amendments. The Czar, however, declined to admit them, and a Russian +document, which obtained a publicity for which it was not intended, proved +that the construction of the note which the amendments were expressly +designed to exclude was precisely that which Russia meant to place upon it. +The British Ministry now refused to recommend the note any longer to the +Porte. [465] Austria, while it approved of the amendments, did not consider +that their rejection by the Czar justified England in abandoning the note +as the common award of the European Powers; and thus the concert of Europe +was interrupted, England and France combining in a policy which Austria and +Prussia were not willing to follow. In proportion as the chances of joint +European action diminished, the ardour of the Turks themselves, and of +those who were to be their allies, rose higher. Tumults, organised by the +heads of the war-party, broke out at Constantinople; and although Stratford +scorned the alarms of his French colleagues, who reported that a massacre +of the Europeans in the capital was imminent, he thought it necessary to +call up two vessels of war in order to provide for the security of the +English residents and of the Sultan himself. In England Palmerston and the +men of action in the Cabinet dragged Lord Aberdeen with them. The French +Government pressed for vigorous measures, and in conformity with its desire +instructions were sent from London to Lord Stratford to call the fleet to +the Bosphorus, and to employ it in defending the territory of the Sultan +against aggression. On the 22nd of October the British and French fleets +passed the Dardanelles. + +[The ultimatum of Omar Pasha rejected, Oct. 10.] + +[Turkish squadron destroyed at Sinope, Nov. 30.] + +The Turk, sure of the protection of the Western Powers, had for some weeks +resolved upon war; and yet the possibilities of a diplomatic settlement +were not yet exhausted. Stratford himself had forwarded to Vienna the draft +of an independent note which the Sultan was prepared to accept. This had +not yet been seen at St. Petersburg. Other projects of conciliation filled +the desks of all the leading politicians of Europe. Yet, though the belief +generally existed that some scheme could be framed by which the Sultan, +without sacrifice of his dignity and interest, might induce the Czar to +evacuate the Principalities, no serious attempt was made to prevent the +Turks from coming into collision with their enemies both by land and sea. +The commander of the Russian troops in the Principalities having, on the +10th of October, rejected an ultimatum requiring him to withdraw within +fifteen days, this answer was taken as the signal for the commencement of +hostilities. The Czar met the declaration of war with a statement that he +would abstain from taking the offensive, and would continue merely to hold +the Principalities as a material guarantee. Omar Pasha, the Ottoman +commander in Bulgaria, was not permitted to observe the same passive +attitude. Crossing the Danube, he attacked and defeated the Russians at +Oltenitza. Thus assailed, the Czar considered that his engagement not to +act on the offensive was at an end, and the Russian fleet, issuing from +Sebastopol, attacked and destroyed a Turkish squadron in the harbour of +Sinope on the southern coast of the Black Sea (November 30). The action was +a piece of gross folly on the part of the Russian authorities if they still +cherished the hopes of pacification which the Czar professed; but others +also were at fault. Lord Stratford and the British Admiral, if they could +not prevent the Turkish ships from remaining in the Euxine, where they were +useless against the superior force of Russia, might at least in exercise of +the powers given to them have sent a sufficient escort to prevent an +encounter. But the same ill-fortune and incompleteness that had marked all +the diplomacy of the previous months attended the counsels of the Admirals +at the Bosphorus; and the disaster of Sinope rendered war between the +Western Powers and Russia almost inevitable. [466] + +[Effect of the action at Sinope.] + +[Russian ships required to enter port, December.] + +[England and France declare war, March 27, 1854.] + +The Turks themselves had certainly not understood the declaration of the +Emperor Nicholas as assuring their squadron at Sinope against attack; and +so far was the Ottoman Admiral from being the victim of a surprise that he +had warned his Government some days before of the probability of his own +destruction. But to the English people, indignant with Russia since its +destruction of Hungarian liberty and its tyrannous demand for the surrender +of the Hungarian refugees, all that now passed heaped up the intolerable +sum of autocratic violence and deceit. The cannonade which was continued +against the Turkish crews at Sinope long after they had become defenceless +gave to the battle the aspect of a massacre; the supposed promise of the +Czar to act only on the defensive caused it to be denounced as an act of +flagrant treachery; the circumstance that the Turkish fleet was lying +within one of the Sultan's harbours, touching as it were the territory +which the navy of England had undertaken to protect, imparted to the attack +the character of a direct challenge and defiance to England. The cry rose +loud for war. Napoleon, eager for the alliance with England, eager in +conjunction with England to play a great part before Europe, even at the +cost of a war from which France had nothing to gain, proposed that the +combined fleets should pass the Bosphorus and require every Russian vessel +sailing on the Black Sea to re-enter port. His proposal was adopted by the +British Government. Nicholas learnt that the Russian flag was swept from +the Euxine. It was in vain that a note upon which the representatives of +the Powers at Vienna had once more agreed was accepted by the Porte and +forwarded to St. Petersburg (December 31). The pride of the Czar was +wounded beyond endurance, and at the beginning of February he recalled his +ambassadors from London and Paris. A letter written to him by Napoleon +III., demanding in the name of himself and the Queen of England the +evacuation of the Principalities, was answered by a reference to the +campaign of Moscow, Austria now informed the Western Powers that if they +would fix a delay for the evacuation of the Principalities, the expiration +of which should be the signal for hostilities, it would support the +summons; and without waiting to learn whether Austria would also unite with +them in hostilities in the event of the summons being rejected, the British +and French Governments despatched their ultimatum to St. Petersburg. +Austria and Prussia sought, but in vain, to reconcile the Court of St. +Petersburg to the only measure by which peace could now be preserved. The +ultimatum remained without an answer, and on the 27th of March England and +France declared war. + +[Policy of Austria.] + +The Czar had at one time believed that in his Eastern schemes he was sure +of the support of Austria; and he had strong reasons for supposing himself +entitled to its aid. But his mode of thought was simpler than that of the +Court of Vienna. Schwarzenberg, when it was remarked that the intervention +of Russia in Hungary would bind the House of Hapsburg too closely to its +protector, had made the memorable answer, "We will astonish the world by +our ingratitude." It is possible that an instance of Austrian gratitude +would have astonished the world most of all; but Schwarzenberg's successors +were not the men to sacrifice a sound principle to romance. Two courses of +Eastern policy have, under various modifications, had their advocates in +rival schools of statesmen at Vienna. The one is that of expansion +southward in concert with Russia; the other is that of resistance to the +extension of Russian power, and the consequent maintenance of the integrity +of the Ottoman Empire. During Metternich's long rule, inspired as this was +by a faith in the Treaties and the institutions of 1815, and by the dread +of every living, disturbing force, the second of these systems had been +consistently followed. In 1854 the determining motive of the Court of +Vienna was not a decided political conviction, but the certainty that if it +united with Russia it would be brought into war with the Western Powers. +Had Russia and Turkey been likely to remain alone in the arena, an +arrangement for territorial compensation would possibly, as on some other +occasions, have won for the Czar an Austrian alliance. Combination against +Turkey was, however, at the present time, too perilous an enterprise for +the Austrian monarchy; and, as nothing was to be gained through the war, it +remained for the Viennese diplomatists to see that nothing was lost and as +little as possible wasted. The presence of Russian troops in the +Principalities, where they controlled the Danube in its course between the +Hungarian frontier and the Black Sea, was, in default of some definite +understanding, a danger to Austria; and Count Buol, the Minister at Vienna, +had therefore every reason to thank the Western Powers for insisting on the +evacuation of this district. When France and England were burning to take +up arms, it would have been a piece of superfluous brutality towards the +Czar for Austria to attach to its own demand for the evacuation of the +Principalities the threat of war. But this evacuation Austria was +determined to enforce. It refused, as did Prussia, to give to the Czar the +assurance of its neutrality; and, inasmuch as the free navigation of the +Danube as far as the Black Sea had now become recognised as one of the +commercial interests of Germany at large, Prussia and the German Federation +undertook to protect the territory of Austria, if, in taking the measures +necessary to free the Principalities, it should itself be attacked by +Russia. [467] + +[Prussia.] + +The King of Prussia, clouded as his mind was by political and religious +phantasms, had nevertheless at times a larger range of view than his +neighbours; and his opinion as to the true solution of the difficulties +between Nicholas and the Porte, at the time of Menschikoff's mission, +deserved more attention than it received. Frederick William proposed that +the rights of the Christian subjects of the Sultan should be placed by +Treaty under the guarantee of all the Great Powers. This project was +opposed by Lord Stratford and the Turkish Ministers as an encroachment on +the Sultan's sovereignty, and its rejection led the King to write with some +asperity to his ambassador in London that he should seek the welfare of +Prussia in absolute neutrality. [468] At a later period the King demanded +from England, as the condition of any assistance from himself, a guarantee +for the maintenance of the frontiers of Germany and Prussia. He regarded +Napoleon III. as the representative of a revolutionary system, and believed +that under him French armies would soon endeavour to overthrow the order of +Europe established in 1815. That England should enter into a close alliance +with this man excited the King's astonishment and disgust; and unless the +Cabinet of London were prepared to give a guarantee against any future +attack on Germany by the French Emperor, who was believed to be ready for +every political adventure, it was vain for England to seek Prussia's aid. +Lord Aberdeen could give no such guarantee; still less could he gratify the +King's strangely passionate demand for the restoration of his authority in +the Swiss canton of Neuchatel, which before 1848 had belonged in name to +the Hohenzollerns. Many influences were brought to bear upon the King from +the side both of England and of Russia. The English Court and Ministers, +strenuously supported by Bunsen, the Prussian ambassador, strove to enlist +the King in an active concert of Europe against Russia by dwelling on the +duties of Prussia as a Great Power and the dangers arising to it from +isolation. On the other hand, the admiration felt by Frederick William for +the Emperor Nicholas, and the old habitual friendship between Prussia and +Russia, gave strength to the Czar's advocates at Berlin. Schemes for a +reconstruction of Europe, which were devised by Napoleon, and supposed to +receive some countenance from Palmerston, reached the King's ear. [469] He +heard that Austria was to be offered the Danubian Provinces upon condition +of giving up northern Italy; that Piedmont was to receive Lombardy, and in +return to surrender Savoy to France; that, if Austria should decline to +unite actively with the Western Powers, revolutionary movements were to be +stirred up in Italy and in Hungary. Such reports kindled the King's rage. +"Be under no illusion," he wrote to his ambassador; "tell the British +Ministers in their private ear and on the housetops that I will not suffer +Austria to be attacked by the revolution without drawing the sword in its +defence. If England and France let loose revolution as their ally, be it +where it may, I unite with Russia for life and death." Bunsen advocated the +participation of Prussia in the European concert with more earnestness than +success. While the King was declaiming against the lawlessness which was +supposed to have spread from the Tuileries to Downing Street, Bunsen, on +his own authority, sent to Berlin a project for the annexation of Russian +territory by Prussia as a reward for its alliance with the Western Courts. +This document fell into the hands of the Russian party at Berlin, and it +roused the King's own indignation. Bitter reproaches were launched against +the authors of so felonious a scheme. Bunsen could no longer retain his +office. Other advocates of the Western alliance were dismissed from their +places, and the policy of neutrality carried the day at Berlin. + +[Relation of the Western Powers to the European Concert.] + +The situation of the European Powers in April, 1854, was thus a very +strange one. All the Four Powers were agreed in demanding the evacuation of +the Principalities by Russia, and in the resolution to enforce this, if +necessary, by arms. Protocols witnessing this agreement were signed on the +9th of April and the 23rd of May, [470] and it was moreover declared that +the Four Powers recognised the necessity of maintaining the independence +and the integrity of the Ottoman Empire. But France and England, while they +made the presence of the Russians in the Principalities the avowed cause of +war, had in reality other intentions than the mere expulsion of the +intruder and the restoration of the state of things previously existing. It +was their desire so to cripple Russia that it should not again be in a +condition to menace the Ottoman Empire. This intention made it impossible +for the British Cabinet to name, as the basis of a European league, that +single definite object for which, and for which alone, all the Powers were +in May, 1854, ready to unite in arms. England, the nation and the +Government alike, chose rather to devote itself, in company with France, to +the task of indefinitely weakening Russia than, in company with all Europe, +to force Russia to one humiliating but inevitable act of submission. +Whether in the prosecution of their ulterior objects the Western Courts +might or might not receive some armed assistance from Austria and Prussia +no man could yet predict with confidence. That Austria would to some extent +make common cause with the Allies seemed not unlikely; that Prussia would +do so there was no real ground to believe; on the contrary, fair warning +had been given that there were contingencies in which Prussia might +ultimately be found on the side of the Czar. Striving to the utmost to +discover some principle, some object, or even some formula which might +expand the purely defensive basis accepted by Austria and Prussia into a +common policy of reconstructive action, the Western Powers could obtain +nothing more definite from the Conference at Vienna than the following +shadowy engagement:--"The Four Governments engage to endeavour in common to +discover the guarantees most likely to attach the existence of the Ottoman +Empire to the general equilibrium of Europe. They are ready to deliberate +as to the employment of means calculated to accomplish the object of their +agreement." This readiness to deliberate, so cautiously professed, was a +quality in which during the two succeeding years the Courts of Vienna and +Berlin were not found wanting; but the war in which England and France now +engaged was one which they had undertaken at their own risk, and they +discovered little anxiety on any side to share their labour. + +[Siege of Silistria, May.] + +[The Principalities evacuated, June.] + +During the winter of 1853 and the first weeks of the following year +hostilities of an indecisive character continued between the Turks and the +Russians on the Danube. At the outbreak of the war Nicholas had consulted +the veteran Paskiewitsch as to the best road by which to march on +Constantinople. Paskiewitsch, as a strategist, knew the danger to which a +Russian force crossing the Danube would be exposed from the presence of +Austrian armies on its flank; as commander in the invasion of Hungary in +1849 he had encountered, as he believed, ill faith and base dealing on the +part of his ally, and had repaid it with insult and scorn; he had learnt +better than any other man the military and the moral weakness of the +Austrian Empire in its eastern part. His answer to the Czar's inquiries +was, "The road to Constantinople lies through Vienna." But whatever +bitterness the Czar might have felt at the ingratitude of Francis Joseph, +he was not ready for a war with Austria, in which he could hardly have +avoided the assistance of revolutionary allies; moreover, if the road to +Constantinople lay through Vienna, it might be urged that the road to +Vienna lay through Berlin. The simpler plan was adopted of a march on the +Balkans by way of Shumla, to which the capture of Silistria was to be the +prelude. At the end of March the Russian vanguard passed the Danube at the +lowest point where a crossing could be made, and advanced into the +Dobrudscha. In May the siege of Silistria was undertaken by Paskiewitsch +himself. But the enterprise began too late, and the strength employed both +in the siege and in the field operations farther east was insufficient. The +Turkish garrison, schooled by a German engineer and animated by two young +English officers, maintained a stubborn and effective resistance. French +and English troops had already landed at Gallipoli for the defence of +Constantinople, and finding no enemy within range had taken ship for Varna +on the north of the Balkans. Austria, on the 3rd of June, delivered its +summons requiring the evacuation of the Principalities. Almost at the same +time Paskiewitsch received a wound that disabled him, and was forced to +surrender his command into other hands. During the succeeding fortnight the +besiegers of Silistria were repeatedly driven back, and on the 22nd they +were compelled to raise the siege. The Russians, now hard pressed by an +enemy whom they had despised, withdrew to the north of the Danube. The +retreating movement was continued during the succeeding weeks, until the +evacuation of the Principalities was complete, and the last Russian soldier +had recrossed the Pruth. As the invader retired, Austria sent its troops +into these provinces, pledging itself by a convention with the Porte to +protect them until peace should be concluded, and then to restore them to +the Sultan. + +[Further objects of the Western Powers.] + +With the liberation of the Principalities the avowed ground of war passed +away; but the Western Powers had no intention of making peace without +further concessions on the part of Russia. As soon as the siege of +Silistria was raised instructions were sent to the commanders of the allied +armies at Varna, pressing, if not absolutely commanding, them to attack +Sebastopol, the headquarters of Russian maritime power in the Euxine. The +capture of Sebastopol had been indicated some months before by Napoleon +III. as the most effective blow that could be dealt to Russia. It was from +Sebastopol that the fleet had issued which destroyed the Turks at Sinope: +until this arsenal had fallen, the growing naval might which pressed even +more directly upon Constantinople than the neighbourhood of the Czar's +armies by land could not be permanently laid low. The objects sought by +England and France were now gradually brought into sufficient clearness to +be communicated to the other Powers, though the more precise interpretation +of the conditions laid down remained open for future discussion. It was +announced that the Protectorate of Russia over the Danubian Principalities +and Servia must be abolished; that the navigation of the Danube at its +mouths must be freed from all obstacles; that the Treaty of July, 1841, +relating to the Black Sea and the Dardanelles, must be revised in the +interest of the balance of power in Europe; and that the claim to any +official Protectorate over Christian subjects of the Porte, of whatever +rite, must be abandoned by the Czar. Though these conditions, known as the +Four Points, were not approved by Prussia, they were accepted by Austria in +August, 1854, and were laid before Russia as the basis of any negotiation +for peace. The Czar declared in answer that Russia would only negotiate on +such a basis when at the last extremity. The Allied Governments, measuring +their enemy's weakness by his failure before Silistria, were determined to +accept nothing less; and the attack upon Sebastopol, ordered before the +evacuation of the Principalities, was consequently allowed to take its +course. [471] + +[Sebastopol.] + +[The Allies land in the Crimea, Sept. 14.] + +[Battle of the Alma, Sept. 20.] + +The Roadstead, or Great Harbour, of Sebastopol runs due eastwards inland +from a point not far from the south-western extremity of the Crimea. One +mile from the open sea its waters divide, the larger arm still running +eastwards till it meets the River Tchernaya, the smaller arm, known as the +Man-of-War Harbour, bending sharply to the south. On both sides of this +smaller harbour Sebastopol is built. To the seaward, that is from the +smaller harbour westwards, Sebastopol and its approaches were thoroughly +fortified. On its landward, southern, side the town had been open till +1853, and it was still but imperfectly protected, most weakly on the +south-eastern side. On the north of the Great Harbour Fort Constantine at +the head of a line of strong defences guarded the entrance from the sea; +while on the high ground immediately opposite Sebastopol and commanding the +town there stood the Star Fort with other military constructions. The +general features of Sebastopol were known to the Allied commanders; they +had, however, no precise information as to the force by which it was held, +nor as to the armament of its fortifications. It was determined that the +landing should be made in the Bay of Eupatoria, thirty miles north of the +fortress. Here, on the 14th of September, the Allied forces, numbering +about thirty thousand French, twenty-seven thousand English, and seven +thousand Turks, effected their disembarkation without meeting any +resistance. The Russians, commanded by Prince Menschikoff, lately envoy at +Constantinople, had taken post ten miles further south on high ground +behind the River Alma. On the 20th of September they were attacked in front +by the English, while the French attempted a turning movement from the sea. +The battle was a scene of confusion, and for a moment the assault of the +English seemed to be rolled back. But it was renewed with ever increasing +vigour, and before the French had made any impression on the Russian left +Lord Raglan's troops had driven the enemy from their positions. Struck on +the flank when their front was already broken, outnumbered and badly led, +the Russians gave up all for lost. The form of an orderly retreat was +maintained only long enough to disguise from the conquerors the +completeness of their victory. When night fell the Russian army abandoned +itself to total disorder, and had the pursuit been made at once it could +scarcely have escaped destruction. But St. Arnaud, who was in the last +stage of mortal illness, refused, in spite of the appeal of Lord Raglan, to +press on his wearied troops. Menschikoff, abandoning the hope of checking +the advance of the Allies in a second battle, and anxious only to prevent +the capture of Sebastopol by an enemy supposed to be following at his +heels, retired into the fortress, and there sank seven of his war-ships as +a barrier across the mouth of the Great Harbour, mooring the rest within. +The crews were brought on shore to serve in the defence by land; the guns +were dragged from the ships to the bastions and redoubts. Then, when it +appeared that the Allies lingered, the Russian commander altered his plan. +Leaving Korniloff, the Vice-Admiral, and Todleben, an officer of engineers, +to man the existing works and to throw up new ones where the town was +undefended, Menschikoff determined to lead off the bulk of his army into +the interior of the Crimea, in order to keep open his communications with +Russia, to await in freedom the arrival of reinforcements, and, if +Sebastopol should not at once fall, to attack the Allies at his own time +and opportunity. (September 24th.) + +[Flank march to south of Sebastopol.] + +[Ineffectual Bombardment, Sept. 17-25.] + +The English had lost in the battle of the Alma about two thousand men, the +French probably less than half that number. On the morning after the +engagement Lord Raglan proposed that the two armies should march straight +against the fortifications lying on the north of the Great Harbour, and +carry these by storm, so winning a position where their guns would command +Sebastopol itself. The French, supported by Burgoyne, the chief of the +English engineers, shrank from the risk of a front attack on works supposed +to be more formidable than they really were, and induced Lord Raglan to +consent to a long circuitous march which would bring the armies right round +Sebastopol to its more open southern side, from which, it was thought, an +assault might be successfully made. This flank-march, which was one of +extreme risk, was carried out safely, Menschikoff himself having left +Sebastopol, and having passed along the same road in his retreat into the +interior a little before the appearance of the Allies. Pushing southward, +the English reached the sea at Balaclava, and took possession of the +harbour there, accepting the exposed eastward line between the fortress and +the Russia is outside; the French, now commanded by Canrobert, continued +their march westwards round the back of Sebastopol, and touched the sea at +Kasatch Bay. The two armies were thus masters of the broken plateau which, +rising westwards from the plain of Balaclava and the valley of the +Tchernaya, overlooks Sebastopol on its southern side. That the garrison, +which now consisted chiefly of sailors, could at this moment have resisted +the onslaught of the fifty thousand troops who had won the battle of the +Alma, the Russians themselves did not believe; [472] but once more the +French staff, with Burgoyne, urged caution, and it was determined to wait +for the siege-guns, which were still at sea. The decision was a fatal one. +While the Allies chose positions for their heavy artillery and slowly +landed and placed their guns, Korniloff and Todleben made the +fortifications on the southern side of Sebastopol an effective barrier +before an enemy. The sacrifice of the Russian fleet had not been in vain. +The sailors were learning all the duties of a garrison: the cannon from the +ships proved far more valuable on land. Three weeks of priceless time were +given to leaders who knew how to turn every moment to account. When, on the +17th of October, the bombardment which was to precede the assault on +Sebastopol began, the French artillery, operating on the south-west, was +overpowered by that of the defenders. The fleets in vain thundered against +the solid sea-front of the fortress. At the end of eight days' cannonade, +during which the besiegers' batteries poured such a storm of shot and shell +upon Sebastopol as no fortress had yet withstood, the defences were still +unbroken. + +[Battle of Balaclava, Oct. 25.] + +Menschikoff in the meantime had received the reinforcements which he +expected, and was now ready to fall upon the besiegers from the east. His +point of attack was the English port of Balaclava and the fortified road +lying somewhat east of this, which formed the outer line held by the +English and their Turkish supports. The plain of Balaclava is divided by a +low ridge into a northern and a southern valley. Along this ridge runs the +causeway, which had been protected by redoubts committed to a weak Turkish +guard. On the morning of the 25th the Russians appeared in the northern +valley. They occupied the heights rising from it on the north and east, +attacked the causeway, captured three of the redoubts, and drove off the +Turks, left to meet their onset alone. Lord Raglan, who watched these +operations from the edge of the western plateau, ordered up infantry from a +distance, but the only English troops on the spot were a light and a heavy +brigade of cavalry, each numbering about six hundred men. The Heavy +Brigade, under General Scarlett, was directed to move towards Balaclava +itself, which was now threatened. While they were on the march, a dense +column of Russian cavalry, about three thousand strong, appeared above the +crest of the low ridge, ready, as it seemed, to overwhelm the weak troops +before them. But in their descent from the ridge the Russians halted, and +Scarlett with admirable courage and judgment formed his men for attack, and +charged full into the enemy with the handful who were nearest to him. They +cut their way into the very heart of the column; and before the Russians +could crush them with mere weight the other regiments of the same brigade +hurled themselves on the right and on the left against the huge inert mass. +The Russians broke and retreated in disorder before a quarter of their +number, leaving to Scarlett and his men the glory of an action which +ranks with the Prussian attack at Mars-la-Tour in 1870 as the most +brilliant cavalry operation in modern warfare. The squadrons of the Light +Brigade, during the peril and the victory of their comrades, stood +motionless, paralysed by the same defect of temper or intelligence in +command which was soon to devote them to a fruitless but ever-memorable +act of self-sacrifice. Russian infantry were carrying off the cannon from +the conquered redoubts on the causeway, when an aide-de-camp from the +general-in-chief brought to the Earl of Lucan, commander of the cavalry, +an order to advance rapidly to the front, and save these guns. Lucan, who +from his position could see neither the enemy nor the guns, believed +himself ordered to attack the Russian artillery at the extremity of the +northern valley, and he directed the Light Brigade to charge in this +direction. It was in vain that the leader of the Light Brigade, Lord +Cardigan, warned his chief, in words which were indeed but too weak, that +there was a battery in front, a battery on each flank, and that the +ground was covered with Russian riflemen. The order was repeated as that +of the head of the army, and it was obeyed. Thus + + "Into the valley of Death + Rode the Six Hundred." + +How they died there, the remnant not turning till they had hewn their way +past the guns and routed the enemy's cavalry behind them, the English +people will never forget. [473] + +[Battle of Inkermann, Nov. 5.] + +The day of Balaclava brought to each side something of victory and +something of failure. The Russians remained masters of the road that they +had captured, and carried off seven English guns; the English, where they +had met the enemy, proved that they could defeat overwhelming numbers. Not +many days passed before our infantry were put to the test which the cavalry +had so victoriously undergone. The siege-approaches of the French had been +rapidly advanced, and it was determined that on the 5th of November the +long-deferred assault on Sebastopol should be made. On that very morning, +under cover of a thick mist, the English right was assailed by massive +columns of the enemy. Menschikoff's army had now risen to a hundred +thousand men; he had thrown troops into Sebastopol, and had planned the +capture of the English positions by a combined attack from Sebastopol +itself, and by troops advancing from the lower valley of the Tchernaya +across the bridge of Inkermann. The battle of the 5th of November, on the +part of the English, was a soldier's battle, without generalship, without +order, without design. The men, standing to their ground whatever their own +number and whatever that of the foe, fought, after their ammunition was +exhausted, with bayonets, with the butt ends of their muskets, with their +fists and with stones. For hours the ever-surging Russian mass rolled in +upon them; but they maintained the unequal struggle until the arrival of +French regiments saved them from their deadly peril and the enemy were +driven in confusion from the field. The Russian columns, marching right up +to the guns, had been torn in pieces by artillery-fire. Their loss in +killed and wounded was enormous, their defeat one which no ingenuity could +disguise. Yet the battle of Inkermann had made the capture of Sebastopol, +as it had been planned by the Allies, impossible. Their own loss was too +great, the force which the enemy had displayed was too vast, to leave any +hope that the fortress could be mastered by a sudden assault. The terrible +truth soon became plain that the enterprise on which the armies had been +sent had in fact failed, and that another enterprise of a quite different +character, a winter siege in the presence of a superior enemy, a campaign +for which no preparations had been made, and for which all that was most +necessary was wanting, formed the only alternative to an evacuation of the +Crimea. + +[Storm of Nov. 14.] + +[Winter in the Crimea.] + +On the 14th of November the Euxine winter began with a storm which swept +away the tents on the exposed plateau, and wrecked twenty-one vessels +bearing stores of ammunition and clothing. From this time rain and snow +turned the tract between the camp and Balaclava into a morass. The loss of +the paved road which had been captured by the Russians three weeks before +now told with fatal effect on the British army. The only communication with +the port of Balaclava was by a hillside track, which soon became impassable +by carts. It was necessary to bring up supplies on the backs of horses; but +the horses perished from famine and from excessive labour. The men were too +few, too weak, too destitute of the helpful ways of English sailors, to +assist in providing for themselves. Thus penned up on the bleak promontory, +cholera-stricken, mocked rather than sustained during their benumbing toil +with rations of uncooked meat and green coffee-berries, the British +soldiery wasted away. Their effective force sank at midwinter to eleven +thousand men. In the hospitals, which even at Scutari were more deadly to +those who passed within them than the fiercest fire of the enemy, nine +thousand men perished before the end of February. The time indeed came when +the very Spirit of Mercy seemed to enter these abodes of woe, and in the +presence of Florence Nightingale nature at last regained its healing power, +pestilence no longer hung in the atmosphere which the sufferers breathed, +and death itself grew mild. But before this new influence had vanquished +routine the grave had closed over whole regiments of men whom it had no +right to claim. The sufferings of other armies have been on a greater +scale, but seldom has any body of troops furnished a heavier tale of loss +and death in proportion to its numbers than the British army during the +winter of the Crimean War. The unsparing exposure in the Press of the +mismanagement under which our soldiers were perishing excited an outburst +of indignation which overthrew Lord Aberdeen's Ministry and placed +Palmerston in power. It also gave to Europe at large an impression that +Great Britain no longer knew how to conduct a war, and unduly raised the +reputation of the French military administration, whose shortcomings, great +as they were, no French journalist dared to describe. In spite of Alma and +Inkermann, the military prestige of England was injured, not raised, by the +Crimean campaign; nor was it until the suppression of the Indian Mutiny +that the true capacity of the nation in war was again vindicated before the +world. + +[Death of Nicholas, March 2, 1855.] + +[Conference of Vienna, March-May, 1855.] + +[Austria.] + +"I have two generals who will not fail me," the Czar is reported to have +said when he heard of Menschikoff's last defeat, "Generals January and +February." General February fulfilled his task, but he smote the Czar too. +In the first days of March a new monarch inherited the Russian crown. [474] +Alexander II. ascended the throne, announcing that he would adhere to the +policy of Peter the Great, of Catherine, and of Nicholas. But the proud +tone was meant rather for the ear of Russia than of Europe, since Nicholas +had already expressed his willingness to treat for peace on the basis laid +down by the Western Powers in August, 1854. This change was not produced +wholly by the battles of Alma and Inkermann. Prussia, finding itself +isolated in Germany, had after some months of hesitation given a diplomatic +sanction to the Four Points approved by Austria as indispensable conditions +of peace. Russia thus stood forsaken, as it seemed, by its only friend, and +Nicholas could no longer hope to escape with the mere abandonment of those +claims which had been the occasion of the war. He consented to treat with +his enemies on their own terms. Austria now approached still more closely +to the Western Powers, and bound itself by treaty, in the event of peace +not being concluded by the end of the year on the stated basis, to +deliberate with France and England upon effectual means for obtaining the +object of the Alliance. [475] Preparations were made for a Conference at +Vienna, from which Prussia, still declining to pledge itself to warlike +action in case of the failure of the negotiations, was excluded. The +sittings of the Conference began a few days after the accession of +Alexander II. Russia was represented by its ambassador, Prince Alexander +Gortschakoff, who, as Minister of later years, was to play so conspicuous a +part in undoing the work of the Crimean epoch. On the first two Articles +forming the subject of negotiation, namely the abolition of the Russian +Protectorate over Servia and the Principalities, and the removal of all +impediments to the free navigation of the Danube, agreement was reached. +On the third Article, the revision of the Treaty of July, 1841, relating +to the Black Sea and the Dardanelles, the Russian envoy and the +representatives of the Western Powers found themselves completely at +variance. Gortschakoff had admitted that the Treaty of 1841 must be so +revised as to put an end to the preponderance of Russia in the Black Sea; +[476] but while the Western Governments insisted upon the exclusion of +Russian war-vessels from these waters, Gortschakoff would consent only to +the abolition of Russia's preponderance by the free admission of the +war-vessels of all nations, or by some similar method of counterpoise. +The negotiations accordingly came to an end, but not before Austria, +disputing the contention of the Allies that the object of the third +Article could be attained only by the specific means proposed by them, +had brought forward a third scheme based partly upon the limitation of +the Russian navy in the Euxine, partly upon the admission of war-ships of +other nations. This scheme was rejected by the Western Powers, whereupon +Austria declared that its obligations under the Treaty of December 2nd, +1854, had now been fulfilled, and that it returned in consequence to the +position of a neutral. + +Great indignation was felt and was expressed at London and Paris at this +so-called act of desertion, and at the subsequent withdrawal of Austrian +regiments from the positions which they had occupied in anticipation of +war. It was alleged that in the first two conditions of peace Austria had +seen its own special interests effectually secured; and that as soon as the +Court of St. Petersburg had given the necessary assurances on these heads +the Cabinet of Vienna was willing to sacrifice the other objects of the +Alliance and to abandon the cause of the Maritime Powers, in order to +regain, with whatever loss of honour, the friendship of the Czar. Though it +was answered with perfect truth that Austria had never accepted the +principle of the exclusion of Russia from the Black Sea, and was still +ready to take up arms in defence of that system by which it considered that +Russia's preponderance in the Black Sea might be most suitably prevented, +this argument sounded hollow to combatants convinced of the futility of all +methods for holding Russia in check except their own. Austria had +grievously injured its own position and credit with the Western Powers. On +the other hand it had wounded Russia too deeply to win from the Czar the +forgiveness which it expected. Its policy of balance, whether best +described as too subtle or as too impartial, had miscarried. It had +forfeited its old, without acquiring new friendships. It remained isolated +in Europe, and destined to meet without support and without an ally the +blows which were soon to fall upon it. + +[Progress of the siege, January-May, 1855.] + +[Canrobert succeeded by Pelissier, May.] + +[Unsuccessful assault, June 18.] + +[Battle of the Tchernaya, Aug. 16.] + +[Capture of the Malakoff, Sept. 8.] + +[Fall of Sebastopol, Sept. 9.] + +The prospects of the besieging armies before Sebastopol were in some +respects better towards the close of January, 1855, than they were when the +Conference of Vienna commenced its sittings six weeks later. Sardinia, +under the guidance of Cavour, had joined the Western Alliance, and was +about to send fifteen thousand soldiers to the Crimea. A new plan of +operations, which promised excellent results, had been adopted at +headquarters. Up to the end of 1854 the French had directed their main +attack against the Flagstaff bastion, a little to the west of the head of +the Man-of-War Harbour. They were now, however, convinced by Lord Raglan +that the true keystone to the defences of Sebastopol was the Malakoff, on +the eastern side, and they undertook the reduction of this formidable work, +while the British directed their efforts against the neighbouring Redan. +[477] The heaviest fire of the besiegers being thus concentrated on a +narrow line, it seemed as if Sebastopol must soon fall. But at the +beginning of February a sinister change came over the French camp. General +Niel arrived from Paris vested with powers which really placed him in +control of the general-in-chief; and though Canrobert was but partially +made acquainted with the Emperor's designs, he was forced to sacrifice to +them much of his own honour and that of the army. Napoleon had determined +to come to the Crimea himself, and at the fitting moment to end by one +grand stroke the war which had dragged so heavily in the hands of others. +He believed that Sebastopol could only be taken by a complete investment; +and it was his design to land with a fresh army on the south-eastern coast +of the Crimea, to march across the interior of the peninsula, to sweep +Menschikoff's forces from their position above the Tchernaya, and to +complete the investment of Sebastopol from the north. With this scheme of +operations in view, all labour expended in the attack on Sebastopol from +the south was effort thrown away. Canrobert, who had promised his most +vigorous co-operation to Lord Raglan, was fettered and paralysed by the +Emperor's emissary at headquarters. For three successive months the +Russians not only held their own, but by means of counter-approaches won +back from the French some of the ground that they had taken. The very +existence of the Alliance was threatened when, after Canrobert and Lord +Raglan had despatched a force to seize the Russian posts on the Sea of +Azof, the French portion of this force was peremptorily recalled by the +Emperor, in order that it might be employed in the march northwards across +the Crimea. At length, unable to endure the miseries of the position, +Canrobert asked to be relieved of his command. He was succeeded by General +Pelissier. Pelissier, a resolute, energetic soldier, one moreover who did +not owe his promotion to complicity in the _coup d'etat_, flatly +refused to obey the Emperor's orders. Sweeping aside the flimsy schemes +evolved at the Tuileries, he returned with all his heart to the plan agreed +upon by the Allied commanders at the beginning of the year; and from this +time, though disasters were still in store, they were not the result of +faltering or disloyalty at the headquarters of the French army. The general +assault on the Malakoff and the Redan was fixed for the 18th of June. It +was bravely met by the Russians; the Allies were driven back with heavy +loss, and three months more were added to the duration of the siege. Lord +Raglan did not live to witness the last stage of the war. Exhausted by his +labours, heartsick at the failure of the great attack, he died on the 28th +of June, leaving the command to General Simpson, an officer far his +inferior. As the lines of the besiegers approached nearer and nearer to the +Russian fortifications, the army which had been defeated at Inkermann +advanced for one last effort. Crossing the Tchernaya, it gave battle on the +16th of August. The French and the Sardinians, with little assistance from +the British army, won a decisive victory. Sebastopol could hope no longer +for assistance from without, and on the 8th of September the blow which had +failed in June was dealt once more. The French, throwing themselves in +great strength upon the Malakoff, carried this fortress by storm, and +frustrated every effort made for its recovery; the British, attacking the +Redan with a miserably weak force, were beaten and overpowered. But the +fall of the Malakoff was in itself equivalent to the capture of Sebastopol. +A few more hours passed, and a series of tremendous explosions made known +to the Allies that the Russian commander was blowing up his magazines and +withdrawing to the north of the Great Harbour. The prize was at length won, +and at the end of a siege of three hundred and fifty days what remained of +the Czar's great fortress passed into the hands of his enemies. + +[Exhaustion of Russia.] + +[Fall of Kars, Nov. 28.] + +[Negotiations for peace.] + +The Allies had lost since their landing in the Crimea not less than a +hundred thousand men. An enterprise undertaken in the belief that it would +be accomplished in the course of a few weeks, and with no greater sacrifice +of life than attends every attack upon a fortified place, had proved +arduous and terrible almost beyond example. Yet if the Crimean campaign was +the result of error and blindness on the part of the invaders, it was +perhaps even more disastrous to Russia than any warfare in which an enemy +would have been likely to engage with fuller knowledge of the conditions to +be met. The vast distances that separated Sebastopol from the military +depots in the interior of Russia made its defence a drain of the most +fearful character on the levies and the resources of the country. What tens +of thousands sank in the endless, unsheltered march without ever nearing +the sea, what provinces were swept of their beasts of burden, when every +larger shell fired against the enemy had to be borne hundreds of miles by +oxen, the records of the war but vaguely make known. The total loss of the +Russians should perhaps be reckoned at three times that of the Allies. Yet +the fall of Sebastopol was not immediately followed by peace. The +hesitation of the Allies in cutting off the retreat of the Russian army had +enabled its commander to retain his hold upon the Crimea; in Asia, the +delays of a Turkish relieving army gave to the Czar one last gleam of +success in the capture of Kars, which, after a strenuous resistance, +succumbed to famine on the 28th of November. But before Kars had fallen +negotiations for peace had commenced. France was weary of the war. +Napoleon, himself unwilling to continue it except at the price of French +aggrandisement on the Continent, was surrounded by a band of palace +stock-jobbers who had staked everything on the rise of the funds that would +result from peace. It was known at every Court of Europe that the Allies +were completely at variance with one another; that while the English +nation, stung by the failure of its military administration during the +winter, by the nullity of its naval operations in the Baltic, and by the +final disaster at the Redan, was eager to prove its real power in a new +campaign, the ruler of France, satisfied with the crowning glory of the +Malakoff, was anxious to conclude peace on any tolerable terms. Secret +communications from St. Petersburg were made at Paris by Baron Seebach, +envoy of Saxony, a son-in-law of the Russian Chancellor: the Austrian +Cabinet, still bent on acting the part of arbiter, but hopeless of the +results of a new Conference, addressed itself to the Emperor Napoleon +singly, and persuaded him to enter into a negotiation which was concealed +for a while from Great Britain. The two intrigues were simultaneously +pursued by our ally, but Seebach's proposals were such that even the +warmest friends of Russia at the Tuileries could scarcely support them, and +the Viennese diplomatists won the day. It was agreed that a note containing +Preliminaries of Peace should be presented by Austria at St. Petersburg as +its own ultimatum, after the Emperor Napoleon should have won from the +British Government its assent to these terms without any alteration. The +Austrian project embodied indeed the Four Points which Britain had in +previous months fixed as the conditions of peace, and in substance it +differed little from what, even after the fall of Sebastopol, British +statesmen were still prepared to accept; but it was impossible that a +scheme completed without the participation of Britain and laid down for its +passive acceptance should be thus uncomplainingly adopted by its +Government. Lord Palmerston required that the Four Articles enumerated +should be understood to cover points not immediately apparent on their +surface, and that a fifth Article should be added reserving to the Powers +the right of demanding certain further special conditions, it being +understood that Great Britain would require under this clause only that +Russia should bind itself to leave the Aland Islands in the Baltic Sea +unfortified. Modified in accordance with the demand of the British +Government, the Austrian draft was presented to the Czar at the end of +December, with the notification that if it as not accepted by the 16th of +January the Austrian ambassador would quit St. Petersburg. On the 15th a +Council was held in the presence of the Czar. Nesselrode, who first gave +his opinion, urged that the continuance of the war would plunge Russia into +hostilities with all Europe, and advised submission to a compact which +would last only until Russia had recovered its strength or new relations +had arisen among the Powers. One Minister after another declared that +Poland, Finland, the Crimea, and the Caucasus would be endangered if peace +were not now made; the Chief of the Finances stated that Russia could not +go through another campaign without bankruptcy. [478] At the end of the +discussion the Council declared unanimously in favour of accepting the +Austrian propositions; and although the national feeling was still in +favour of resistance, there appears to have been one Russian statesman +alone, Prince Gortschakoff, ambassador at Vienna, who sought to dissuade +the Czar from making peace. His advice was not taken. The vote of the +Council was followed by the despatch of plenipotentiaries to Paris, and +here, on the 25th of February, 1856, the envoys of all the Powers, with the +exception of Prussia, assembled in Conference, in order to frame the +definitive Treaty of Peace. [479] + +[Conference of Paris, Feb. 25, 1856.] + +[Treaty of Paris, March 30, 1856.] + +In the debates which now followed, and which occupied more than a month, +Lord Clarendon, who represented Great Britain, discovered that in each +contested point he had to fight against the Russian and the French envoys +combined, so completely was the Court of the Tuileries now identified with +a policy of conciliation and friendliness towards Russia. [480] Great +firmness, great plainness of speech was needed on the part of the British +Government, in order to prevent the recognised objects of the war from +being surrendered by its ally, not from a conviction that they were +visionary or unattainable, but from unsteadiness of purpose and from the +desire to convert a defeated enemy into a friend. The end, however, was at +length reached, and on the 30th of March the Treaty of Paris was signed. +The Black Sea was neutralised; its waters and ports, thrown open to the +mercantile marine of every nation, were formally and in perpetuity +interdicted to the war-ships both of the Powers possessing its coasts and +of all other Powers. The Czar and the Sultan undertook not to establish or +maintain upon its coasts any military or maritime arsenal. Russia ceded a +portion of Bessarabia, accepting a frontier which excluded it from the +Danube. The free navigation of this river, henceforth to be effectively +maintained by an international Commission, was declared part of the public +law of Europe. The Powers declared the Sublime Porte admitted to +participate in the advantages of the public law and concert of Europe, each +engaging to respect the independence and integrity of the Ottoman Empire, +and all guaranteeing in common the strict observance of this engagement, +and promising to consider any act tending to its violation as a question of +general interest. The Sultan "having, in his constant solicitude for the +welfare of his subjects, issued a firman recording his generous intentions +towards the Christian population of his empire, [481] and having +communicated it to the Powers," the Powers "recognised the high value of +this communication," declaring at the same time "that it could not, in any +case, give to them the right to interfere, either collectively or +separately, in the relations of the Sultan to his subjects, or in the +internal administration of his empire." The Danubian Principalities, +augmented by the strip of Bessarabia taken from Russia, were to continue to +enjoy, under the suzerainty of the Porte and under the guarantee of the +Powers, all the privileges and immunities of which they were in possession, +no exclusive protection being exercised by any of the guaranteeing +Powers. [482] + +[Agreement of the Conference on rights of neutrals.] + +Passing beyond the immediate subjects of negotiation, the Conference +availed itself of its international character to gain the consent of Great +Britain to a change in the laws of maritime war. England had always +claimed, and had always exercised, the right to seize an enemy's goods on +the high sea though conveyed in a neutral vessel, and to search the +merchant-ships of neutrals for this purpose. The exercise of this right had +stirred up against England the Maritime League of 1800, and was condemned +by nearly the whole civilised world. Nothing short of an absolute command +of the seas made it safe or possible for a single Power to maintain a +practice which threatened at moments of danger to turn the whole body of +neutral States into its enemies. Moreover, if the seizure of belligerents' +goods in neutral ships profited England when it was itself at war, it +injured England at all times when it remained at peace during the struggles +of other States. Similarly by the issue of privateers England inflicted +great injury on its enemies; but its own commerce, exceeding that of every +other State, offered to the privateers of its foes a still richer booty. +The advantages of the existing laws of maritime war were not altogether on +the side of England, though mistress of the seas; and in return for the +abolition of privateering, the British Government consented to surrender +its sharpest, but most dangerous, weapon of offence, and to permit the +products of a hostile State to find a market in time of war. The rule was +laid down that the goods of an enemy other than contraband of war should +henceforth be safe under a neutral flag. Neutrals' goods discovered on an +enemy's ship were similarly made exempt from capture. + +[Fictions of the Treaty of Paris as to Turkey.] + +The enactments of the Conference of Paris relating to commerce in time of +hostilities have not yet been subjected to the strain of a war between +England and any European State; its conclusions on all other subjects were +but too soon put to the test, and have one after another been found +wanting. If the Power which calls man into his moment of life could smile +at the efforts and the assumptions of its creature, such smile might have +been moved by the assembly of statesmen who, at the close of the Crimean +War, affected to shape the future of Eastern Europe. They persuaded +themselves that by dint of the iteration of certain phrases they could +convert the Sultan and his hungry troop of Pashas into the chiefs of a +European State. They imagined that the House of Osman, which in the stages +of a continuous decline had successively lost its sway over Hungary, over +Servia, over Southern Greece and the Danubian Provinces, and which would +twice within the last twenty-five years have seen its Empire dashed to +pieces by an Egyptian vassal but for the intervention of Europe, might be +arrested in its decadence by an incantation, and be made strong enough and +enlightened enough to govern to all time the Slavic and Greek populations +which had still the misfortune to be included within its dominions. +Recognising--so ran the words which read like bitter irony, but which were +meant for nothing of the kind--the value of the Sultan's promises of +reform, the authors of the Treaty of Paris proceeded, as if of set purpose, +to extinguish any vestige of responsibility which might have been felt at +Constantinople, and any spark of confidence that might still linger among +the Christian populations, by declaring that, whether the Sultan observed +or broke his promises, in no case could any right of intervention by Europe +arise. The helmsman was given his course; the hatches were battened down. +If words bore any meaning, if the Treaty of Paris was not an elaborate +piece of imposture, the Christian subjects of the Sultan had for the +future, whatever might be their wrongs, no redress to look for but in the +exertion of their own power. The terms of the Treaty were in fact such as +might have been imposed if the Western Powers had gone to war with Russia +for some object of their own, and had been rescued, when defeated and +overthrown, by the victorious interposition of the Porte. All was hollow, +all based on fiction and convention. The illusions of nations in time of +revolutionary excitement, the shallow, sentimental commonplaces of liberty +and fraternity have afforded just matter for satire; but no democratic +platitudes were ever more palpably devoid of connection with fact, more +flagrantly in contradiction to the experience of the past, or more +ignominiously to be refuted by each succeeding act of history, than the +deliberate consecration of the idol of an Ottoman Empire as the crowning +act of European wisdom in 1856. + +[The Danubian Principalities.] + +[Alexander Cuza Hospodar of both Provinces.] + +[Complete Union, 1862.] + +[Charles of Hohenzollern, Hereditary Prince, 1866.] + +Among the devotees of the Turk the English Ministers were the most +impassioned, having indeed in the possession of India some excuse for their +fervour on behalf of any imaginable obstacle that would keep the Russians +out of Constantinople. The Emperor of the French had during the Conferences +at Paris revived his project of incorporating the Danubian Principalities +with Austria in return for the cession of Lombardy, but the Viennese +Government had declined to enter into any such arrangement. Napoleon +consequently entered upon a new Eastern policy. Appreciating the growing +force of nationality in European affairs, and imagining that in the +championship of the principle of nationality against the Treaties of 1815 +he would sooner or later find means for the aggrandisement of himself and +France, he proposed that the Provinces of Moldavia and Wallachia, while +remaining in dependence upon the Sultan, should be united into a single +State under a prince chosen by themselves. The English Ministry would not +hear of this union. In their view the creation of a Roumanian Principality +under a chief not appointed by the Porte was simply the abstraction from +the Sultan of six million persons who at present acknowledged his +suzerainty, and whose tribute to Constantinople ought, according to Lord +Clarendon, to be increased. [483] Austria, fearing the effect of a +Roumanian national movement upon its own Roumanian subjects in +Transylvania, joined in resistance to Napoleon's scheme, and the political +organisation of the Principalities was in consequence reserved by the +Conference of Paris for future settlement. Elections were held in the +spring of 1857 under a decree from the Porte, with the result that +Moldavia, as it seemed, pronounced against union with the sister province. +But the complaint at once arose that the Porte had falsified the popular +vote. France and Russia had now established relations of such amity that +their ambassadors jointly threatened to quit Constantinople if the +elections were not annulled. A visit paid by the French Emperor to Queen +Victoria, with the object of smoothing over the difficulties which had +begun to threaten the Western alliance, resulted rather in increased +misunderstandings between the two Governments as to the future of the +Principalities than in any real agreement. The elections were annulled. New +representative bodies met at Bucharest and Jassy, and pronounced almost +unanimously for union (October, 1857). In the spring of 1858 the Conference +of Paris reassembled in order to frame a final settlement of the affairs of +the Principalities. It determined that in each Province there should be a +Hospodar elected for life, a separate judicature, and a separate +legislative Assembly, while a central Commission, formed by representatives +of both Provinces, should lay before the Assemblies projects of law on +matters of joint interest. In accordance with these provisions, Assemblies +were elected in each Principality at the beginning of 1859. Their first +duty was to choose the two Hospodars, but in both Provinces a unanimous +vote fell upon the same person, Prince Alexander Cuza. The efforts of +England and Austria to prevent union were thus baffled by the Roumanian +people itself, and after three years the elaborate arrangements made by the +Conference were similarly swept away, and a single Ministry and Assembly +took the place of the dual Government. It now remained only to substitute a +hereditary Prince for a Hospodar elected for life; and in 1866, on the +expulsion of Alexander Cuza by his subjects, Prince Charles of +Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen, a distant kinsman of the reigning Prussian +sovereign, was recognised by all Europe as Hereditary Prince of Roumania. +The suzerainty of the Porte, now reduced to the bare right to receive a +fixed tribute, was fated to last but for a few years longer. + +[Continued discord in Turkish Empire.] + +[Revision of the Treaty of Paris, 1871.] + +Europe had not to wait for the establishment of Roumanian independence in +order to judge of the foresight and the statesmanship of the authors of the +Treaty of Paris. Scarcely a year passed without the occurrence of some +event that cast ridicule upon the fiction of a self-regenerated Turkey, and +upon the profession of the Powers that the epoch of external interference +in its affairs was at an end. The active misgovernment of the Turkish +authorities themselves, their powerlessness or want of will to prevent +flagrant outrage and wrong among those whom they professed to rule, +continued after the Treaty of Paris to be exactly what they had been before +it. In 1860 massacres and civil war in Mount Lebanon led to the occupation +of Syria by French troops. In 1861 Bosnia and Herzegovina took up arms. In +1863 Servia expelled its Turkish garrisons. Crete, rising in the following +year, fought long for its independence, and seemed for a moment likely to +be united with Greece under the auspices of the Powers, but it was finally +abandoned to its Ottoman masters. At the end of fourteen years from the +signature of the Peace of Paris, the downfall of the French Empire enabled +Russia to declare that it would no longer recognise the provisions of the +Treaty which excluded its war-ships and its arsenals from the Black Sea. It +was for this, and for this almost alone, that England had gone through the +Crimean War. But for the determination of Lord Palmerston to exclude Russia +from the Black Sea, peace might have been made while the Allied armies were +still at Varna. This exclusion was alleged to be necessary in the interests +of Europe at large; that it was really enforced not in the interest of +Europe but in the interest of England was made sufficiently clear by the +action of Austria and Prussia, whose statesmen, in spite of the discourses +so freely addressed to them from London, were at least as much alive to the +interests of their respective countries as Lord Palmerston could be on +their behalf. Nor had France in 1854 any interest in crippling the power of +Russia, or in Eastern affairs generally, which could be remotely compared +with those of the possessors of India. The personal needs of Napoleon III. +made him, while he seemed to lead, the instrument of the British Government +for enforcing British aims, and so gave to Palmerston the momentary shaping +of a new and superficial concert of the Powers. Masters of Sebastopol, the +Allies had experienced little difficulty in investing their own conclusions +with the seeming authority of Europe at large; but to bring the +representatives of Austria and Prussia to a Council-table, to hand them the +pen to sign a Treaty dictated by France and England, was not to bind them +to a policy which was not their own, or to make those things interests of +Austria and Prussia which were not their interests before. Thus when in +1870 the French Empire fell, England stood alone as the Power concerned in +maintaining the exclusion of Russia from the Euxine, and this exclusion it +could enforce no longer. It was well that Palmerston had made the Treaty of +Paris the act of Europe, but not for the reasons which Palmerston had +imagined. The fiction had engendered no new relation in fact; it did not +prolong for one hour the submission of Russia after it had ceased to be +confronted in the West by a superior force; but it enabled Great Britain to +retire without official humiliation from a position which it had conquered +only through the help of an accidental Alliance, and which it was unable to +maintain alone. The ghost of the Conference of 1856 was, as it were, +conjured up in the changed world of 1871. The same forms which had once +stamped with the seal of Europe the instrument of restraint upon Russia now +as decorously executed its release. Britain accepted what Europe would not +resist; and below the slopes where lay the countless dead of three nations +Sebastopol rose from its ruins, and the ensign of Russia floated once more +over its ships of war. + + + + +CHAPTER XXII. + + +Piedmont after 1849--Ministry of Azeglio--Cavour Prime Minister--Designs of +Cavour--His Crimean Policy--Cavour at the Conference of Paris--Cavour and +Napoleon III.--The Meeting at Plombieres--Preparations in Italy--Treaty of +January, 1859--Attempts at Mediation--Austrian Ultimatum--Campaign of +1859--Magenta--Movement in Central Italy--Solferino--Napoleon and Prussia +--Interview of Villafranca--Cavour resigns--Peace of Zuerich--Central Italy +after Villafranca--The Proposed Congress--"The Pope and the Congress"-- +Cavour resumes office--Cavour and Napoleon--Union of the Duchies and the +Romagna with Piedmont--Savoy and Nice added to France--Cavour on this +cession--European opinion--Naples--Sicily--Garibaldi lands at Marsala-- +Capture of Palermo--The Neapolitans evacuate Sicily--Cavour and the Party +of Action--Cavour's Policy as to Naples--Garibaldi on the Mainland--Persano +and Villamarina at Naples--Garibaldi at Naples--The Piedmontese Army enters +Umbria and the Marches--Fall of Ancona--Garibaldi and Cavour--The Armies on +the Volturno--Fall of Gaeta--Cavour's Policy with regard to Rome and +Venice--Death of Cavour--The Free Church in the Free State. + + +[Piedmont after 1849.] + +In the gloomy years that followed 1849 the kingdom of Sardinia had stood +out in bright relief as a State which, though crushed on the battle-field, +had remained true to the cause of liberty while all around it the forces of +reaction gained triumph after triumph. Its King had not the intellectual +gifts of the maker of a great State, but he was one with whom those +possessed of such gifts could work, and on whom they could depend. With +certain grave private faults Victor Emmanuel had the public virtues of +intense patriotism, of loyalty to his engagements and to his Ministers, of +devotion to a single great aim. Little given to speculative thought, he saw +what it most concerned him to see, that Piedmont by making itself the home +of liberty could become the Master-State of Italy. His courage on the +battlefield, splendid and animating as it was, distinguished him less than +another kind of courage peculiarly his own. Ignorant and superstitious, he +had that rare and masculine quality of soul which in the anguish of +bereavement and on the verge of the unseen world remains proof against the +appeal and against the terrors of a voice speaking with more than human +authority. Rome, not less than Austria, stood across the path that led to +Italian freedom, and employed all its art, all its spiritual force, to turn +Victor Emmanuel from the work that lay before him. There were moments in +his life when a man of not more than common weakness might well have +flinched from the line of conduct on which he had resolved in hours of +strength and of insight; there were times when a less constant mind might +well have wavered and cast a balance between opposing systems of policy. It +was not through heroic greatness that Victor Emmanuel rendered his +priceless services to Italy. He was a man not conspicuously cast in a +different mould from many another plain, strong nature, but the qualities +which he possessed were precisely those which Italy required. Fortune, +circumstance, position favoured him and made his glorious work possible; +but what other Italian prince of this century, though placed on the throne +of Piedmont, and numbering Cavour among his subjects, would have played the +part, the simple yet all momentous part, which Victor Emmanuel played so +well? The love and the gratitude of Italy have been lavished without stint +on the memory of its first sovereign, who served his nation with qualities +of so homely a type, and in whose life there was so much that needed +pardon. The colder judgment of a later time will hardly contest the title +of Victor Emmanuel to be ranked among those few men without whom Italian +union would not have been achieved for another generation. + +[Ministry of Azeglio, 1849-52.] + +[Cavour Prime Minister, 1852.] + +On the conclusion of peace with Austria after the campaign of Novara, the +Government and the Parliament of Turin addressed themselves to the work of +emancipating the State from the system of ecclesiastical privilege and +clerical ascendency which had continued in full vigour down to the last +year of Charles Albert's reign. Since 1814 the Church had maintained, or +had recovered, both in Piedmont and in the island of Sardinia, rights which +had been long wrested from it in other European societies, and which were +out of harmony with the Constitution now taking root under Victor Emmanuel. +The clergy had still their own tribunals, and even in the case of criminal +offences were not subject to the jurisdiction of the State. The Bishops +possessed excessive powers and too large a share of the Church revenues; +the parochial clergy lived in want; monasteries and convents abounded. It +was not in any spirit of hostility towards the Church that Massimo +d'Azeglio, whom the King called to office after Novara, commenced the work +of reform by measures subjecting the clergy to the law-courts of the State, +abolishing the right of sanctuary in monasteries, and limiting the power of +corporations to acquire landed property. If the Papacy would have met +Victor Emmanuel in a fair spirit his Government would gladly have avoided a +dangerous and exasperating struggle; but all the forces and the passions of +Ultramontanism were brought to bear against the proposed reforms. The +result was that the Minister, abandoned by a section of the Conservative +party on whom he had relied, sought the alliance of men ready for a larger +and bolder policy, and called to office the foremost of those from whom he +had received an independent support in the Chamber, Count Cavour. Entering +the Cabinet in 1850 as Minister of Commerce, Cavour rapidly became the +master of all his colleagues. On his own responsibility he sought and won +the support of the more moderate section of the Opposition, headed by +Rattazzi; and after a brief withdrawal from office, caused by divisions +within the Cabinet, he returned to power in October, 1852, as Prime +Minister. + +[Cavour.] + +Cavour, though few men have gained greater fame as diplomatists, had not +been trained in official life. The younger son of a noble family, he had +entered the army in 1826, and served in the Engineers; but his sympathies +with the liberal movement of 1830 brought him into extreme disfavour with +his chiefs. He was described by Charles Albert, then Prince of Carignano, +as the most dangerous man in the kingdom, and was transferred at the +instance of his own father to the solitary Alpine fortress of Bard. Too +vigorous a nature to submit to inaction, too buoyant and too sagacious to +resort to conspiracy, he quitted the army, and soon afterwards undertook +the management of one of the family estates, devoting himself to scientific +agriculture on a large scale. He was a keen and successful man of business, +but throughout the next twelve years, which he passed in fruitful private +industry, his mind dwelt ardently on public affairs. He was filled with a +deep discontent at the state of society which he saw around him in +Piedmont, and at the condition of Italy at large under foreign and clerical +rule. Repeated visits to France and England made him familiar with the +institutions of freer lands, and gave definiteness to his political and +social aims. [484] In 1847, when changes were following fast, he founded +with some other Liberal nobles the journal _Risorgimento_, devoted to +the cause of national revival; and he was one of the first who called upon +King Charles Albert to grant a Constitution. During the stormy days of 1848 +he was at once the vigorous advocate of war with Austria and the adversary +of Republicans and Extremists who for their own theories seemed willing to +plunge Italy into anarchy. Though unpopular with the mob, he was elected to +the Chamber by Turin, and continued to represent the capital after the +peace. Up to this time there had been little opportunity for the proof of +his extraordinary powers, but the inborn sagacity of Victor Emmanuel had +already discerned in him a man who could not remain in a subordinate +position. "You will see him turn you all out of your places," the King +remarked to his Ministers, as he gave his assent to Cavour's first +appointment to a seat in the Cabinet. + +[Plans of Cavour.] + +[Cavour's Crimean policy.] + +The Ministry of Azeglio had served Piedmont with honour from 1849 to 1852, +but its leader scarcely possessed the daring and fertility of mind which +the time required. Cavour threw into the work of government a passion and +intelligence which soon produced results visible to all Europe. His +devotion to Italy was as deep, as all-absorbing, as that of Mazzini +himself, though the methods and schemes of the two men were in such +complete antagonism. Cavour's fixed purpose was to drive Austria out of +Italy by defeat in the battle-field, and to establish, as the first step +towards national union, a powerful kingdom of Northern Italy under Victor +Emmanuel. In order that the military and naval forces of Piedmont might be +raised to the highest possible strength and efficiency, he saw that the +resources of the country must be largely developed; and with this object he +negotiated commercial treaties with Foreign Powers, laid down railways, and +suppressed the greater part of the monasteries, selling their lands to +cultivators, and devoting the proceeds of sale not to State-purposes but to +the payment of the working clergy. Industry advanced; the heavy pressure of +taxation was patiently borne; the army and the fleet grew apace. But the +cause of Piedmont was one with that of the Italian nation, and it became +its Government to demonstrate this day by day with no faltering voice or +hand. Protection and support were given to fugitives from Austrian and +Papal tyranny; the Press was laid open to every tale of wrong; and when, +after an unsuccessful attempt at insurrection in Milan in 1853, for which +Mazzini and the Republican exiles were alone responsible, the Austrian +Government sequestrated the property of its subjects who would not return +from Piedmont, Cavour bade his ambassador quit Vienna, and appealed to +every Court in Europe. Nevertheless, Cavour did not believe that Italy, +even by a simultaneous rising, could permanently expel the Austrian armies +or conquer the Austrian fortresses. The experience of forty years pointed +to the opposite conclusion; and while Mazzini in his exile still imagined +that a people needed only to determine to be free in order to be free, +Cavour schemed for an alliance which should range against the Austrian +Emperor armed forces as numerous and as disciplined as his own. It was +mainly with this object that Cavour plunged Sardinia into the Crimean War. +He was not without just causes of complaint against the Czar; but the +motive with which he sent the Sardinian troops to Sebastopol was not that +they might take vengeance on Russia, but that they might fight side by side +with the soldiers of England and France. That the war might lead to +complications still unforeseen was no doubt a possibility present to +Cavour's mind, and in that case it was no small thing that Sardinia stood +allied to the two Western Powers; but apart from these chances of the +future, Sardinia would have done ill to stand idle when at any moment, as +it seemed, Austria might pass from armed neutrality into active concert +with England and France. Had Austria so drawn the sword against Russia +whilst Piedmont stood inactive, the influence of the Western Powers must +for some years to come have been ranged on the side of Austria in the +maintenance of its Italian possessions, and Piedmont could at the best have +looked only to St. Petersburg for sympathy or support. Cavour was not +scrupulous in his choice of means when the liberation of Italy was the end +in view, and the charge was made against him that in joining the coalition +against Russia he lightly entered into a war in which Piedmont had no +direct concern. But reason and history absolve, and far more than absolve, +the Italian statesman. If the cause of European equilibrium, for which +England and France took up arms, was a legitimate ground of war in the case +of these two Powers, it was not less so in the case of their ally; while if +the ulterior results rather than the motive of a war are held to constitute +its justification, Cavour stands out as the one politician in Europe whose +aims in entering upon the Crimean War have been fulfilled, not mocked, by +events. He joined in the struggle against Russia not in order to maintain +the Ottoman Empire, but to gain an ally in liberating Italy. The Ottoman +Empire has not been maintained; the independence of Italy has been +established, and established by means of the alliance which Cavour gained. +His Crimean policy is one of those excessively rare instances of +statesmanship where action has been determined not by the driving and +half-understood necessities of the moment, but by a distinct and true +perception of the future. He looked only in one direction, but in that +direction he saw clearly. Other statesmen struck blindfold, or in their +vision of a regenerated Turkey fought for an empire of mirage. It may with +some reason be asked whether the order of Eastern Europe would now be +different if our own English soldiers who fell at Balaclava had been +allowed to die in their beds: every Italian whom Cavour sent to perish on +the Tchernaya or in the cholera-stricken camp died as directly for the +cause of Italian independence as if he had fallen on the slopes of Custozza +or under the walls of Rome. + +[Cavour at the Conference of Paris.] + +[Change of Austrian policy, 1856.] + +At the Conference of Paris in 1856 the Sardinian Premier took his place in +right of alliance by the side of the representatives of the great Powers; +and when the main business of the Conference was concluded, Count Buol, the +Austrian Minister, was forced to listen to a vigorous denunciation by +Cavour of the misgovernment that reigned in Central and Southern Italy, of +the Austrian occupation which rendered this possible. Though the French +were still in Rome, their presence might by courtesy be described as a +measure of precaution rendered necessary by the intrusion of the Austrians +farther north; and both the French and English plenipotentiaries at the +Conference supported Cavour in his invective. Cavour returned to Italy +without any territorial reward for the services that Piedmont had rendered +to the Allies; but his object was attained. He had exhibited Austria +isolated and discredited before Europe; he had given to his country a voice +that it had never before had in the Councils of the Powers; he had produced +a deep conviction throughout Italy that Piedmont not only could and would +act with vigour against the national enemy, but that in its action it would +have the help of allies. From this time the Republican and Mazzinian +societies lost ground before the growing confidence in the House of Savoy, +in its Minister and its army. [485] The strongest evidence of the effect of +Cavour's Crimean policy and of his presence at the Conference of Paris was +seen in the action of the Austrian Government itself. From 1849 to 1856 its +rule in Northern Italy had been one not so much of severity as of brutal +violence. Now all was changed. The Emperor came to Milan to proclaim a +general amnesty and to win the affection of his subjects. The sequestrated +estates were restored to their owners. Radetzky, in his ninety-second year, +was at length allowed to pass into retirement; the government of the sword +was declared at an end; Maximilian, the gentlest and most winning of the +Hapsburgs, was sent with his young bride to charm away the sad memories of +the evil time. But it was too late. The recognition shown by the Lombards +of the Emperor's own personal friendliness indicated no reconciliation with +Austria; and while Francis Joseph was still in Milan, King Victor Emmanuel, +in the presence of a Lombard deputation, laid the first stone of the +monument erected by subscriptions from all Italy in memory of those who had +fallen in the campaigns of 1848 and 1849, the statue of a foot-soldier +waving his sword towards the Austrian frontier. The Sardinian Press +redoubled its attacks on Austria and its Italian vassals. The Government of +Vienna sought satisfaction; Cavour sharply refused it; and diplomatic +relations between the two Courts, which had been resumed since the +Conference of Paris, were again broken off. + +[Cavour and Napoleon III.] + +[Meeting at Plombieres, July, 1858.] + +Of the two Western Powers, Cavour would have preferred an alliance with +Great Britain, which had no objects of its own to seek in Italy; but when +he found that the Government of London would not assist him by arms against +Austria, he drew closer to the Emperor Napoleon, and supported him +throughout his controversy with England and Austria on the settlement of +the Danubian Principalities. Napoleon, there is no doubt, felt a real +interest in Italy. His own early political theories formed on a study of +the Napoleonic Empire, his youthful alliance with the Carbonari, point to a +sympathy with the Italian national cause which was genuine if not profound, +and which was not altogether lost in 1849, though France then acted as the +enemy of Roman independence. If Napoleon intended to remould the +Continental order and the Treaties of 1815 in the interests of France and +of the principle of nationality, he could make no better beginning than by +driving Austria from Northern Italy. It was not even necessary for him to +devise an original policy. Early in 1848, when it seemed probable that +Piedmont would be increased by Lombardy and part of Venetia, Lamartine had +laid it down that France ought in that case to be compensated by Savoy, in +order to secure its frontiers against so powerful a neighbour as the new +Italian State. To this idea Napoleon returned. Savoy had been incorporated +with France from 1792 to 1814; its people were more French than Italian; +its annexation would not directly injure the interests of any great Power. +Of the three directions in which France might stretch towards its old +limits of the Alps and the Rhine, the direction of Savoy was by far the +least dangerous. Belgium could not be touched without certain loss of the +English alliance, with which Napoleon could not yet dispense; an attack +upon the Rhenish Provinces would probably be met by all the German Powers +together; in Savoy alone was there the chance of gaining territory without +raising a European coalition against France. No sooner had the organisation +of the Danubian Principalities been completed by the Conference which met +in the spring of 1858 than Napoleon began to develop his Italian plans. An +attempt of a very terrible character which was made upon his life by +Orsini, a Roman exile, though at the moment it threatened to embroil +Sardinia with France, probably stimulated him to action. In the summer of +1858 he invited Cavour to meet him at Plombieres. The negotiations which +there passed were not made known by the Emperor to his Ministers; they were +communicated by Cavour to two persons only besides Victor Emmanuel. It +seems that no written engagement was drawn up; it was verbally agreed that +if Piedmont could, without making a revolutionary war, and without exposing +Napoleon to the charge of aggression, incite Austria to hostilities, France +would act as its ally. Austria was then to be expelled from Venetia as well +as from Lombardy. Victor Emmanuel was to become sovereign of North-Italy, +with the Roman Legations and Marches; the remainder of the Papal territory, +except Rome itself and the adjacent district, was to be added to Tuscany, +so constituting a new kingdom of Central Italy. The two kingdoms, together +with Naples and Rome, were to form an Italian Confederation under the +presidency of the Pope. France was to receive Savoy and possibly Nice. A +marriage between the King's young daughter Clotilde and the Emperor's +cousin Prince Jerome Napoleon was discussed, if not actually settled. [486] + +[Cavour in view of the French Alliance.] + +From this moment Cavour laboured night and day for war. His position was an +exceedingly difficult one. Not only had he to reckon with the irresolution +of Napoleon, and his avowed unwillingness to take up arms unless with the +appearance of some good cause; but even supposing the goal of war reached, +and Austria defeated, how little was there in common between Cavour's aims +for Italy and the traditional policy of France! The first Napoleon had +given Venice to Austria at Campo Formio; even if the new Napoleon should +fulfil his promise and liberate all Northern Italy, his policy in regard to +the centre and south of the Peninsula would probably be antagonistic to any +effective union or to any further extension of the influence of the House +of Savoy. Cavour had therefore to set in readiness for action national +forces of such strength that Napoleon, even if he desired to draw back, +should find it difficult to do so, and that the shaping of the future of +the Italian people should be governed not by the schemes which the Emperor +might devise at Paris, but by the claims and the aspirations of Italy +itself. It was necessary for him not only to encourage and subsidise the +National Society--a secret association whose branches in the other Italian +States were preparing to assist Piedmont in the coming war, and to unite +Italy under the House of Savoy--but to enter into communication with some +of the Republican or revolutionary party who had hitherto been at enmity +with all Crowns alike. He summoned Garibaldi in secrecy to Turin, and there +convinced him that the war about to be waged by Victor Emmanuel was one in +which he ought to take a prominent part. As the foremost defender of the +Roman Republic and a revolutionary hero, Garibaldi was obnoxious to the +French Emperor. Cavour had to conceal from Napoleon the fact that Garibaldi +would take the field at the head of a free-corps by the side of the Allied +armies; he had similarly to conceal from Garibaldi that one result of the +war would be the cession of Nice, his own birthplace, to France. Thus +plunged in intrigue, driving his Savoyards to the camp and raising from +them the last farthing in taxation, in order that after victory they might +be surrendered to a Foreign Power; goading Austria to some act of passion; +inciting, yet checking and controlling, the Italian revolutionary elements; +bargaining away the daughter of his sovereign to one of the most odious of +mankind, Cavour staked all on the one great end of his being, the +establishment of Italian independence. Words like those which burst from +Danton in the storms of the Convention--"Perish my name, my reputation, so +that France be free"--were the calm and habitual expression of Cavour's +thought when none but an intimate friend was by to hear. [487] Such tasks +as Cavour's are not to be achieved without means which, to a man noble in +view as Cavour really was, it would have been more agreeable to leave +unemployed. Those alone are entitled to pronounce judgment upon him who +have made a nation, and made it with purer hands. It was well for English +statesmen and philanthropists, inheritors of a world-wide empire, to +enforce the ethics of peace and to plead for a gentlemanlike frankness and +self-restraint in the conduct of international relations. English women had +not been flogged by Austrian soldiers in the market-place; the treaties of +1815 had not consecrated a foreign rule over half our race. To Cavour the +greatest crime would have been to leave anything undone which might +minister to Italy's liberation. [488] + +[Treaty of January, 1859.] + +[Attempts at mediation.] + +[Austrian ultimatum, April 23.] + +Napoleon seems to have considered that he would be ready to begin war in +the spring of 1859. At the reception at the Tuileries on the 1st of January +he addressed the Austrian ambassador in words that pointed to an +approaching conflict; a few weeks later a marriage-contract was signed +between Prince Napoleon and Clotilde, daughter of Victor Emmanuel, and part +of the agreement made at Plombieres was embodied in a formal Treaty. +Napoleon undertook to support Sardinia in a war that might arise from any +aggressive act on the part of Austria, and, if victorious, to add both +Lombardy and Venetia to Victor Emmanuel's dominions. France was in return +to receive Savoy, the disposal of Nice being reserved till the restoration +of peace. [489] Even before the Treaty was signed Victor Emmanuel had +thrown down the challenge to Austria, declaring at the opening of the +Parliament of Turin that he could not be insensible to the cry of suffering +that rose from Italy. In all but technical form the imminence of war had +been announced, when, under the influence of diplomatists and Ministers +about him, and of a financial panic that followed his address to the +Austrian ambassador, the irresolute mind of Napoleon shrank from its +purpose, and months more of suspense were imposed upon Italy and Europe, to +be terminated at last not by any effort of Napoleon's will but by the rash +and impolitic action of Austria itself. At the instance of the Court of +Vienna the British Government had consented to take steps towards +mediation. Lord Cowley, Ambassador at Paris, was sent to Vienna with +proposals which, it was believed, might form the basis for an amicable +settlement of Italian affairs. He asked that the Papal States should be +evacuated by both Austrian and French troops; that Austria should abandon +the Treaties which gave it a virtual Protectorate over Modena and Parma; +and that it should consent to the introduction of reforms in all the +Italian Governments. Negotiations towards this end had made some progress +when they were interrupted by a proposal sent from St. Petersburg, at the +instance of Napoleon, that Italian affairs should be submitted to a +European Congress. Austria was willing under certain conditions to take +part in a Congress, but it required, as a preliminary measure, that +Sardinia should disarm. Napoleon had now learnt that Garibaldi was to fight +at the head of the volunteers for Victor Emmanuel. His doubts as to the +wisdom of his own policy seem to have increased hour by hour; from Britain, +whose friendship he still considered indispensable to him, he received the +most urgent appeals against war; it was necessary that Cavour himself +should visit Paris in order to prevent the Emperor from acquiescing in +Austria's demand. In Cavour's presence Napoleon seems to have lost some of +his fears, or to have been made to feel that it was not safe to provoke his +confidant of Plombieres; [490] but Cavour had not long left Paris when a +proposal was made from London, that in lieu of the separate disarmament of +Sardinia the Powers should agree to a general disarmament, the details to +be settled by a European Commission. This proposal received Napoleon's +assent. He telegraphed to Cavour desiring him to join in the agreement. +Cavour could scarcely disobey, yet at one stroke it seemed that all his +hopes when on the very verge of fulfilment were dashed to the ground, all +his boundless efforts for the liberation of Italy through war with Austria +lost and thrown away. For some hours he appeared shattered by the blow. +Strung to the extreme point of human endurance by labour scarcely remitted +by day or night for weeks together, his strong but sanguine nature gave +way, and for a while the few friends who saw him feared that he would take +his own life. But the crisis passed: Cavour accepted, as inevitable, the +condition of general disarmament; and his vigorous mind had already begun +to work upon new plans for the future, when the report of a decision made +at Vienna, which was soon confirmed by the arrival of an Austrian +ultimatum, threw him into joy as intense as his previous despair. Ignoring +the British proposal for a general disarmament, already accepted at Turin, +the Austrian Cabinet demanded, without qualifications and under threat of +war within three days, that Sardinia should separately disarm. It was +believed at Vienna that Napoleon was merely seeking to gain time; that a +conflict was inevitable; and that Austria now stood better prepared for +immediate action than its enemies. Right or wrong in its judgment of +Napoleon's real intentions, the Austrian Government had undeniably taken +upon itself the part of the aggressor. Cavour had only to point to his own +acceptance of the plan of a general disarmament, and to throw upon his +enemy the responsibility for a disturbance of European peace. His reply was +taken as the signal for hostilities, and on the 29th of April Austrian +troops crossed the Ticino. A declaration of war from Paris followed without +delay. [491] + +[Campaign of 1859.] + +[Battle of Magenta, June 4.] + +For months past Austria had been pouring its troops into Northern Italy. It +had chosen its own time for the commencement of war; a feeble enemy stood +before it, its more powerful adversary could not reach the field without +crossing the Alps or the mountain-range above Genoa. Everything pointed to +a vigorous offensive on the part of the Austrian generals, and in Piedmont +itself it was believed that Turin must fall before French troops could +assist in its defence. From Turin as a centre the Austrians could then +strike with ease, and with superior numbers, against the detachments of the +French army as they descended the mountains at any points in the semicircle +from Genoa to Mont Cenis. There has seldom been a case where the necessity +and the advantages of a particular line of strategy have been so obvious; +yet after crossing the Ticino the Austrians, above a hundred thousand +strong, stood as if spell-bound under their incompetent chief, Giulay. +Meanwhile French detachments crossed Mont Cenis; others, more numerous, +landed with the Emperor at Genoa, and established communications with the +Piedmontese, whose headquarters were at Alessandria. Giulay now believed +that the Allies would strike upon his communications in the direction of +Parma. The march of Bonaparte upon Piacenza in 1796, as well as the +campaign of Marengo, might well inspire this fear; but the real intention +of Napoleon III. was to outflank the Austrians from the north and so to +gain Milan. Garibaldi was already operating at the extreme left of the +Sardinian line in the neighbourhood of Como. While the Piedmontese +maintained their positions in the front, the French from Genoa marched +northwards behind them, crossed the Po, and reached Vercelli before the +Austrians discovered their manoeuvre. Giulay, still lingering between the +Sesia and the Ticino, now called up part of his forces northwards, but not +in time to prevent the Piedmontese from crossing the Sesia and defeating +the troops opposed to them at Palestro (May 30). While the Austrians were +occupied at this point, the French crossed the river farther north, and +moved eastwards on the Ticino. Giulay was thus outflanked and compelled to +fall back. The Allies followed him, and on the 4th of June attacked the +Austrian army in its positions about Magenta on the road to Milan. The +assault of Macmahon from the north gave the Allies victory after a +hard-fought day. It was impossible for the Austrians to defend Milan; they +retired upon the Adda and subsequently upon the Mincio, abandoning all +Lombardy to the invaders, and calling up their troops from Bologna and the +other occupied towns in the Papal States, in order that they might take +part in the defence of the Venetian frontier and the fortresses that +guarded it. + +[Movement in Central Italy.] + +The victory of the Allies was at once felt throughout Central Italy. The +Grand Duke of Tuscany had already fled from his dominions, and the +Dictatorship for the period of the war had been offered by a Provisional +Government to Victor Emmanuel, who, while refusing this, had allowed his +envoy, Boncampagni, to assume temporary powers at Florence as his +representative. The Duke of Modena and the Duchess of Parma now quitted +their territories. In the Romagna the disappearance of the Austrians +resulted in the immediate overthrow of Papal authority. Everywhere the +demand was for union with Piedmont. The calamities of the last ten years +had taught their lesson to the Italian people. There was now nothing of the +disorder, the extravagance, the childishness of 1848. The populations who +had then been so divided, so suspicious, so easy a prey to demagogues, were +now watchful, self-controlled, and anxious for the guidance of the only +real national Government. As at Florence, so in the Duchies and in the +Romagna, it was desired that Victor Emmanuel should assume the +Dictatorship. The King adhered to the policy which he had adopted towards +Tuscany, avoiding any engagement that might compromise him with Europe or +his ally, but appointing Commissioners to enrol troops for the common war +against Austria and to conduct the necessary work of administration in +those districts. Farini, the historian of the Roman States, was sent to +Modena; Azeglio, the ex-Minister, to Bologna. Each of these officers +entered on his task in a spirit worthy of the time; each understood how +much might be won for Italy by boldness, how much endangered or lost by +untimely scruples. [492] + +[Battle of Solferino, June 24.] + +In his proclamations at the opening of the war Napoleon had declared that +Italy must be freed up to the shore of the Adriatic. His address to the +Italian people on entering Milan with Victor Emmanuel after the victory of +Magenta breathed the same spirit. As yet, however, Lombardy alone had been +won. The advance of the allied armies was accordingly resumed after an +interval of some days, and on the 23rd of June they approached the +positions held by the Austrians a little to the west of the Mincio. Francis +Joseph had come from Vienna to take command of the army. His presence +assisted the enemy, inasmuch as he had no plan of his own, and wavered from +day to day between the antagonistic plans of the generals at headquarters. +Some wished to make the Mincio the line of defence, others to hold the +Chiese some miles farther west. The consequence was that the army marched +backwards and forwards across the space between the two rivers according as +one or another general gained for the moment the Emperor's confidence. It +was while the Austrians were thus engaged that the allied armies came into +contact with them about Solferino. On neither side was it known that the +whole force of the enemy was close at hand. The battle of Solferino, one of +the bloodiest of recent times, was fought almost by accident. About a +hundred and fifty thousand men were present under Napoleon and Victor +Emmanuel; the Austrians had a slight superiority in force. On the north, +where Benedek with the Austrian right was attacked by the Piedmontese at +San Martino, it seemed as if the task imposed on the Italian troops was +beyond their power. Victor Emmanuel, fighting with the same courage as at +Novara, saw the positions in front of his troops alternately won and lost. +But the success of the French at Solferino in the centre decided the day, +and the Austrians withdrew at last from their whole line with a loss in +killed and wounded of fourteen thousand men. On the part of the Allies the +slaughter was scarcely less. + +[Napoleon and Prussia.] + +[Interview of Villafranca, July 11.] + +[Peace of Villafranca.] + +[Treaty of Zuerich, Nov. 10.] + +Napoleon stood a conqueror, but a conqueror at terrible cost; and in front +of him he saw the fortresses of the Quadrilateral, while new divisions were +hastening from the north and east to the support of the still unbroken +Austrian army. He might well doubt whether, even against his present +antagonist alone, further success was possible. The fearful spectacle of +Solferino, heightened by the effects of overpowering summer heat, probably +affected a mind humane and sensitive and untried in the experience of war. +The condition of the French army, there is reason to believe, was far +different from that represented in official reports, and likely to make the +continuance of the campaign perilous in the extreme. But beyond all this, +the Emperor knew that if he advanced farther Prussia and all Germany might +at any moment take up arms against him. There had been a strong outburst of +sympathy for Austria in the south-western German States. National +patriotism was excited by the attack of Napoleon on the chief of the German +sovereigns, and the belief was widely spread that French conquest in Italy +would soon be followed by French conquest on the Rhine. Prussia had +hitherto shown reserve. It would have joined its arms with those of Austria +if its own claims to an improved position in Germany had been granted by +the Court of Vienna; but Francis Joseph had up to this time refused the +concessions demanded. In the stress of his peril he might at any moment +close with the offers which he had before rejected; even without a distinct +agreement between the two Courts, and in mere deference to German public +opinion, Prussia might launch against France the armies which it had +already brought into readiness for the field. A war upon the Rhine would +then be added to the war before the Quadrilateral, and from the risks of +this double effort Napoleon might well shrink in the interest of France not +less than of his own dynasty. He determined to seek an interview with +Francis Joseph, and to ascertain on what terms peace might now be made. The +interview took place at Villafranca, east of the Mincio, on the 11th of +July. Francis Joseph refused to cede any part of Venetia without a further +struggle. He was willing to give up Lombardy, and to consent to the +establishment of an Italian Federation under the presidency of the Pope, of +which Federation Venetia, still under Austria's rule, should be a member; +but he required that Mantua should be left within his own frontier, and +that the sovereigns of Tuscany and Modena should resume possession of their +dominions. To these terms Napoleon assented, on obtaining a verbal +agreement that the dispossessed princes should not be restored by foreign +arms. Regarding Parma and the restoration of the Papal authority in the +Romagna no stipulations were made. With the signature of the Preliminaries +of Villafranca, which were to form the base of a regular Treaty to be +negotiated at Zuerich, and to which Victor Emmanuel added his name with +words of reservation, hostilities came to a close. The negotiations at +Zuerich, though they lasted for several months, added nothing of importance +to the matter of the Preliminaries, and decided nothing that had been left +in uncertainty. The Italian Federation remained a scheme which the two +Emperors, and they alone, undertook to promote. Piedmont entered into no +engagement either with regard to the Duchies or with regard to Federation. +Victor Emmanuel had in fact announced from the first that he would enter no +League of which a province governed by Austria formed a part, and from this +resolution he never swerved. [493] + +[Resignation of Cavour.] + +[Central Italy.] + +Though Lombardy was gained, the impression made upon the Italians by the +peace of Villafranca was one of the utmost dismay. Napoleon had so +confidently and so recently promised the liberation of all Northern Italy +that public opinion ascribed to treachery or weakness what was in truth an +act of political necessity. On the first rumour of the negotiations Cavour +had hurried from Turin, but the agreement was signed before his arrival. +The anger and the grief of Cavour are described by those who then saw him +as terrible to witness. [494] Napoleon had not the courage to face him; +Victor Emmanuel bore for two hours the reproaches of his Minister, who had +now completely lost his self-control. Cavour returned to Turin, and shortly +afterwards withdrew from office, his last act being the despatch of ten +thousand muskets to Farini at Modena. In accordance with the terms of +peace, instructions, which were probably not meant to be obeyed, were sent +by Cavour's successor, Rattazzi, to the Piedmontese Commissioners in +Central Italy, bidding them to return to Turin and to disband any forces +that they had collected. Farini, on receipt of this order, adroitly +divested himself of his Piedmontese citizenship, and, as an honorary +burgher of Modena, accepted the Dictatorship from his fellow-townsmen. +Azeglio returned to Turin, but took care before quitting the Romagna to +place four thousand soldiers under competent leaders in a position to +resist attack. It was not the least of Cavour's merits that he had gathered +about him a body of men who, when his own hand was for a while withdrawn, +could pursue his policy with so much energy and sagacity as was now shown +by the leaders of the national movement in Central Italy. Venetia was lost +for the present; but if Napoleon's promise was broken, districts which he +had failed or had not intended to liberate might be united with the Italian +Kingdom. The Duke of Modena, with six thousand men who had remained true to +him, lay on the Austrian frontier, and threatened to march upon his +capital. Farini mined the city gates, and armed so considerable a force +that it became clear that the Duke would not recover his dominions without +a serious battle. Parma placed itself under the same Dictatorship with +Modena; in the Romagna a Provisional Government which Azeglio had left +behind him continued his work. Tuscany, where Napoleon had hoped to find a +throne for his cousin, pronounced for national union, and organised a +common military force with its neighbours. During the weeks that followed +the Peace of Villafranca, declarations signed by tens of thousands, the +votes of representative bodies, and popular demonstrations throughout +Central Italy, showed in an orderly and peaceful form how universal was the +desire for union under the House of Savoy. + +[Cavour's Plans before Villafranca.] + +[Central Italy after Villafranca. July-November.] + +[Mazzini and Garibaldi. August-November.] + +Cavour, in the plans which he had made before 1859, had not looked for a +direct and immediate result beyond the creation of an Italian Kingdom +including the whole of the territory north of the Po. The other steps in +the consolidation of Italy would, he believed, follow in their order. They +might be close at hand, or they might be delayed for a while; but in the +expulsion of Austria, in the interposition of a purely Italian State +numbering above ten millions of inhabitants, mistress of the fortresses and +of a powerful fleet, between Austria and those who had been its vassals, +the essential conditions of Italian national independence would have been +won. For the rest, Italy might be content to wait upon time and +opportunity. But the Peace of Villafranca, leaving Venetia in the enemy's +hands, completely changed this prospect. The fiction of an Italian +Federation in which the Hapsburg Emperor, as lord of Venice, should forget +his Austrian interests and play the part of Italian patriot, was too gross +to deceive any one. Italy, on these terms, would either continue to be +governed from Vienna, or be made a pawn in the hands of its French +protector. What therefore Cavour had hitherto been willing to leave to +future years now became the need of the present. "Before Villafranca," in +his own words, "the union of Italy was a possibility; since Villafranca it +is a necessity." Victor Emmanuel understood this too, and saw the need for +action more clearly than Rattazzi and the Ministers who, on Cavour's +withdrawal in July, stepped for a few months into his place. The situation +was one that called indeed for no mean exercise of statesmanship. If Italy +was not to be left dependent upon the foreigner and the reputation of the +House of Savoy ruined, it was necessary not only that the Duchies of Modena +and Parma, but that Central Italy, including Tuscany and at least the +Romagna, should be united with the Kingdom of Piedmont; yet the +accomplishment of this work was attended with the utmost danger. Napoleon +himself was hoping to form Tuscany, with an augmented territory, into a +rival Kingdom of Etruria or Central Italy, and to place his cousin on its +throne. The Ultramontane party in France was alarmed and indignant at the +overthrow of the Pope's authority in the Romagna, and already called upon +the Emperor to fulfil his duties towards the Holy See. If the national +movement should extend to Rome itself, the hostile intervention of France +was almost inevitable. While the negotiations with Austria at Zuerich were +still proceeding, Victor Emmanuel could not safely accept the sovereignty +that was offered him by Tuscany and the neighbouring provinces, nor permit +his cousin, the Prince of Carignano, to assume the regency which, during +the period of suspense, it was proposed to confer upon him. Above all, it +was necessary that the Government should not allow the popular forces with +which it was co-operating to pass beyond its own control. In the critical +period that followed the armistice of Villafranca, Mazzini approached +Victor Emmanuel, as thirty years before he had approached his father, and +offered his own assistance in the establishment of Italian union under the +House of Savoy. He proposed, as the first step, to overthrow the Neapolitan +Government by means of an expedition headed by Garibaldi, and to unite +Sicily and Naples to the King's dominions; but he demanded in return that +Piedmont should oppose armed resistance to any foreign intervention +occasioned by this enterprise; and he seems also to have required that an +attack should be made immediately afterwards upon Rome and upon Venetia. To +these conditions the King could not accede; and Mazzini, confirmed in his +attitude of distrust towards the Court of Turin, turned to Garibaldi, who +was now at Modena. At his instigation Garibaldi resolved to lead an +expedition at once against Rome itself. Napoleon was at this very moment +promising reforms on behalf of the Pope, and warning Victor Emmanuel +against the annexation even of the Romagna (Oct. 20th). At the risk of +incurring the hostility of Garibaldi's followers and throwing their leader +into opposition to the dynasty, it was necessary for the Sardinian +Government to check him in his course. The moment was a critical one in the +history of the House of Savoy. But the soldier of Republican Italy proved +more tractable than its prophet. Garibaldi was persuaded to abandon or +postpone an enterprise which could only have resulted in disaster for +Italy; and with expressions of cordiality towards the King himself, and of +bitter contempt for the fox-like politicians who advised him, he resigned +his command and bade farewell to his comrades, recommending them, however, +to remain under arms, in full confidence that they would ere long find a +better opportunity for carrying the national flag southwards. [495] + +[The proposed Congress.] + +Soon after the Agreement of Villafranca, Napoleon had proposed to the +British Government that a Congress of all the Powers should assemble at +Paris in order to decide upon the many Italian questions which still +remained unsettled. In taking upon himself the emancipation of Northern +Italy Napoleon had, as it proved, attempted a task far beyond his own +powers. The work had been abruptly broken off; the promised services had +not been rendered, the stipulated reward had not been won. On the other +hand, forces had been set in motion which he who raised them could not +allay; populations stood in arms against the Governments which the +Agreement of Villafranca purported to restore; the Pope's authority in the +northern part of his dominions was at an end; the Italian League over which +France and Austria were to join hands of benediction remained the +laughing-stock of Europe. Napoleon's victories had added Lombardy to +Piedmont; for the rest, except from the Italian point of view, they had +only thrown affairs into confusion. Hesitating at the first between his +obligations towards Austria and the maintenance of his prestige in Italy, +perplexed between the contradictory claims of nationality and of +Ultramontanism, Napoleon would gladly have cast upon Great Britain, or upon +Europe at large, the task of extricating him from his embarrassment. But +the Cabinet of London, while favourable to Italy, showed little inclination +to entangle itself in engagements which might lead to war with Austria and +Germany in the interest of the French Sovereign. Italian affairs, it was +urged by Lord John Russell, might well be governed by the course of events +within Italy itself; and, as Austria remained inactive, the principle of +non-intervention really gained the day. The firm attitude of the population +both in the Duchies and in the Romagna, their unanimity and self-control, +the absence of those disorders which had so often been made a pretext for +foreign intervention, told upon the mind of Napoleon and on the opinion of +Europe at large. Each month that passed rendered the restoration of the +fallen Governments a work of greater difficulty, and increased the +confidence of the Italians in themselves. Napoleon watched and wavered. +When the Treaty of Zuerich was signed his policy was still undetermined. By +the prompt and liberal concession of reforms the Papal Government might +perhaps even now have turned the balance in its favour. But the obstinate +mind of Pius IX. was proof against every politic and every generous +influence. The stubbornness shown by Rome, the remembrance of Antonelli's +conduct towards the French Republic in 1849, possibly also the discovery of +a Treaty of Alliance between the Papal Government and Austria, at length +overcame Napoleon's hesitation in meeting the national demand of Italy, and +gave him courage to defy both the Papal Court and the French priesthood. He +resolved to consent to the formation of an Italian Kingdom under Victor +Emmanuel including the northern part of the Papal territories as well as +Tuscany and the other Duchies, and to silence the outcry which this act of +spoliation would excite among the clerical party in France by the +annexation of Nice and Savoy. + +["The Pope and the Congress," Dec. 24.] + +[Change of Ministry at Paris, Jan. 5, 1860.] + +[Cavour resumes office, Jan. 16.] + +The decision of the Emperor was foreshadowed by the publication on the 24th +of December of a pamphlet entitled "The Pope and the Congress." The +doctrine advanced in this essay was that, although a temporal authority was +necessary to the Pope's spiritual independence, the peace and unity which +should surround the Vicar of Christ would be best attained when his +temporal sovereignty was reduced within the narrowest possible limits. Rome +and the territory immediately around it, if guaranteed to the Pope by the +Great Powers, would be sufficient for the temporal needs of the Holy See. +The revenue lost by the separation of the remainder of the Papal +territories might be replaced by a yearly tribute of reverence paid by the +Catholic Powers to the Head of the Church. That the pamphlet advocating +this policy was written at the dictation of Napoleon was not made a secret. +Its appearance occasioned an indignant protest at Rome. The Pope announced +that he would take no part in the proposed Congress unless the doctrines +advanced in the pamphlet were disavowed by the French Government. Napoleon +in reply submitted to the Pope that he would do well to purchase the +guarantee of the Powers for the remainder of his territories by giving up +all claim to the Romagna, which he had already lost. Pius retorted that he +could not cede what Heaven had granted, not to himself, but to the Church; +and that if the Powers would but clear the Romagna of Piedmontese intruders +he would soon reconquer the rebellious province without the assistance +either of France or of Austria. The attitude assumed by the Papal Court +gave Napoleon a good pretext for abandoning the plan of a European +Congress, from which he could hardly expect to obtain a grant of Nice and +Savoy. It was announced at Paris that the Congress would be postponed; and +on the 5th of January, 1860, the change in Napoleon's policy was publicly +marked by the dismissal of his Foreign Minister, Walewski, and the +appointment in his place of Thouvenel, a friend to Italian union. Ten days +later Rattazzi gave up office at Turin, and Cavour returned to power. + +[Cavour and Napoleon, Jan-March.] + +[Union of the Duchies and the Romagna with Piedmont, March.] + +[Savoy and Nice ceded to France.] + +Rattazzi, during the six months that he had conducted affairs, had steered +safely past some dangerous rocks; but he held the helm with an unsteady and +untrusted hand, and he appears to have displayed an unworthy jealousy +towards Cavour, who, while out of office, had not ceased to render what +services he could to his country. Cavour resumed his post, with the resolve +to defer no longer the annexation of Central Italy, but with the heavy +consciousness that Napoleon would demand in return for his consent to this +union the cession of Nice and Savoy. No Treaty entitled France to claim +this reward, for the Austrians still held Venetia; but Napoleon's troops +lay at Milan, and by a march southwards they could easily throw Italian +affairs again into confusion, and undo all that the last six months had +effected. Cavour would perhaps have lent himself to any European +combination which, while directed against the extension, of France, would +have secured the existence of the Italian Kingdom; but no such alternative +to the French alliance proved possible; and the subsequent negotiations +between Paris and Turin were intended only to vest with a certain +diplomatic propriety the now inevitable transfer of territory from the +weaker to the stronger State. A series of propositions made from London +with the view of withdrawing from Italy both French and Austrian influence +led the Austrian Court to acknowledge that its army would not be employed +for the restoration of the sovereigns of Tuscany and Modena. Construing +this statement as an admission that the stipulations of Villafranca and +Zuerich as to the return of the fugitive princes had become impracticable, +Napoleon now suggested that Victor Emmanuel should annex Parma and Modena, +and assume secular power in the Romagna as Vicar of the Pope, leaving +Tuscany to form a separate Government. The establishment of so powerful a +kingdom on the confines of France was, he added, not in accordance with the +traditions of French foreign policy, and in self-defence France must +rectify its military frontier by the acquisition of Nice and Savoy (Feb. +24th). Cavour well understood that the mention of Tuscan independence, and +the qualified recognition of the Pope's rights in the Romagna, were no more +than suggestions of the means of pressure by which France might enforce the +cessions it required. He answered that, although Victor Emmanuel could not +alienate any part of his dominions, his Government recognised the same +popular rights in Savoy and Nice as in Central Italy; and accordingly that +if the population of these districts declared in a legal form their desire +to be incorporated with France, the King would not resist their will. +Having thus consented to the necessary sacrifice, and ignoring Napoleon's +reservations with regard to Tuscany and the Pope, Cavour gave orders that a +popular vote should at once be taken in Tuscany, as well as in Parma, +Modena, and the Romagna, on the question of union with Piedmont. The voting +took place early in March, and gave an overwhelming majority in favour of +union. The Pope issued the major excommunication against the authors, +abettors, and agents in this work of sacrilege, and heaped curses on +curses; but no one seemed the worse for them. Victor Emmanuel accepted the +sovereignty that was offered to him, and on the 2nd of April the Parliament +of the united kingdom assembled at Turin. It had already been announced to +the inhabitants of Nice and Savoy that the King had consented to their +union with France. The formality of a _plebiscite_ was enacted a few +days later, and under the combined pressure of the French and Sardinian +Governments the desired results were obtained. Not more than a few hundred +persons protested by their vote against a transaction to which it was +understood that the King had no choice but to submit. [496] + +[Cavour on the cession of Nice and Savoy.] + +That Victor Emmanuel had at one time been disposed to resist Cavour's +surrender of the home of his race is well known. Above a year, however, had +passed since the project had been accepted as the basis of the French +alliance; and if, during the interval of suspense after Villafranca, the +King had cherished a hope that the sacrifice might be avoided without +prejudice either to the cause of Italy or to his own relations with +Napoleon, Cavour had entertained no such illusions. He knew that the +cession was an indispensable link in the chain of his own policy, that +policy which had made it possible to defeat Austria, and which, he +believed, would lead to the further consolidation of Italy. Looking to +Rome, to Palermo, where the smouldering fire might at any moment blaze out, +he could not yet dispense with the friendship of Napoleon, he could not +provoke the one man powerful enough to shape the action of France in +defiance of Clerical and of Legitimist aims. Rattazzi might claim credit +for having brought Piedmont past the Treaty of Zuerich without loss of +territory; Cavour, in a far finer spirit, took upon himself the +responsibility for the sacrifice made to France, and bade the Parliament of +Italy pass judgment upon his act. The cession of the border-provinces +overshadowed what would otherwise have been the brightest scene in Italian +history for many generations, the meeting of the first North-Italian +Parliament at Turin. Garibaldi, coming as deputy from his birthplace, Nice, +uttered words of scorn and injustice against the man who had made him an +alien in Italy, and quitted the Chamber. Bitterly as Cavour felt, both now +and down to the end of his life, the reproaches that were levelled against +him, he allowed no trace of wounded feeling, of impatience, of the sense of +wrong, to escape him in the masterly speech in which he justified his +policy and won for it the ratification of the Parliament. It was not until +a year later, when the hand of death was almost upon him, that fierce words +addressed to him face to face by Garibaldi wrung from him the impressive +answer, "The act that has made this gulf between us was the most painful +duty of my life. By what I have felt myself I know what Garibaldi must have +felt. If he refuses me his forgiveness I cannot reproach him for it." [497] + +[The cession in relation to Europe and Italy.] + +The annexation of Nice and Savoy by Napoleon was seen with extreme +displeasure in Europe generally, and most of all in England. It directly +affected the history of Britain by the stimulus which it gave to the +development of the Volunteer Forces. Owing their origin to certain +demonstrations of hostility towards England made by the French army after +Orsini's conspiracy and the acquittal of one of his confederates in London, +the Volunteer Forces rose in the three months that followed the annexation +of Nice and Savoy from seventy to a hundred and eighty thousand men. If +viewed as an indication that the ruler of France would not be content with +the frontiers of 1815, the acquisition of the Sub-Alpine provinces might +with some reason excite alarm; on no other ground could their transfer be +justly condemned. Geographical position, language, commercial interests, +separated Savoy from Piedmont and connected it with France; and though in +certain parts of the County of Nice the Italian character predominated, +this district as a whole bore the stamp not of Piedmont or Liguria but of +Provence. Since the separation from France in 1815 there had always been, +both in Nice and Savoy, a considerable party which desired reunion with +that country. The political and social order of the Sardinian Kingdom had +from 1815 to 1848 been so backward, so reactionary, that the middle classes +in the border-provinces looked wistfully to France as a land where their +own grievances had been removed and their own ideals attained. The +constitutional system of Victor Emmanuel, and the despotic system of Louis +Napoleon had both been too recently introduced to reverse in the minds of +the greater number the political tradition of the preceding thirty years. +Thus if there were a few who, like Garibaldi, himself of Genoese descent +though born at Nice, passionately resented separation from Italy, they +found no considerable party either in Nice or in Savoy animated by the same +feeling. On the other hand, the ecclesiastical sentiment of Savoy rendered +its transfer to France an actual advantage to the Italian State. The Papacy +had here a deeply-rooted influence. The reforms begun by Azeglio's Ministry +had been steadily resisted by a Savoyard group of deputies in the interests +of Rome. Cavour himself, in the prosecution of his larger plans, had always +been exposed to the danger of a coalition between this ultra-Conservative +party and his opponents of the other extreme. It was well that in the +conflict with the Papacy, without which there could be no such thing as a +Kingdom of United Italy, these influences of the Savoyard Church and +Noblesse should be removed from the Parliament and the Throne. Honourable +as the Savoyard party of resistance had proved themselves in Parliamentary +life, loyal and faithful as they were to their sovereign, they were yet not +a part of the Italian nation. Their interests were not bound up with the +cause of Italian union; their leaders were not inspired with the ideal of +Italian national life. The forces that threatened the future of the new +State from within were too powerful for the surrender of a priest-governed +and half-foreign element to be considered as a real loss. + +[Naples.] + +Nice and Savoy had hardly been handed over to Napoleon when Garibaldi set +out from Genoa to effect the liberation of Sicily and Naples. King +Ferdinand II., known to his subjects and to Western Europe as King Bomba, +had died a few days before the battle of Magenta, leaving the throne to his +son Francis II. In consequence of the friendship shown by Ferdinand to +Russia during the Crimean War, and of his refusal to amend his tyrannical +system of government, the Western Powers had in 1856 withdrawn their +representatives from Naples. On the accession of Francis II. diplomatic +intercourse was renewed, and Cavour, who had been at bitter enmity with +Ferdinand, sought to establish relations of friendship with his son. In the +war against Austria an alliance with Naples would have been of value to +Sardinia as a counterpoise to Napoleon's influence, and this alliance +Cavour attempted to obtain. He was, however, unsuccessful; and after the +Peace of Villafranca the Neapolitan Court threw itself with ardour into +schemes for the restoration of the fallen Governments and the overthrow of +Piedmontese authority in the Romagna by means of a coalition with Austria +and Spain and a counterrevolutionary movement in Italy itself. A rising on +behalf of the fugitive Grand Duke of Tuscany was to give the signal for the +march of the Neapolitan army northwards. This rising, however, was expected +in vain, and the great Catholic design resulted in nothing. Baffled in its +larger aims, the Bourbon Government proposed in the spring of 1860 to +occupy Umbria and the Marches, in order to prevent the revolutionary +movement from spreading farther into the Papal States. Against this Cavour +protested, and King Francis yielded to his threat to withdraw the Sardinian +ambassador from Naples. Knowing that a conspiracy existed for the +restoration of the House of Murat to the Neapolitan throne, which would +have given France the ascendency in Southern Italy, Cavour now renewed his +demand that Francis II. should enter into alliance with Piedmont, accepting +a constitutional system of government and the national Italian policy of +Victor Emmanuel. But neither the summons from Turin, nor the agitation of +the Muratists, nor the warnings of Great Britain that the Bourbon dynasty +could only avert its fall by reform, produced any real change in the spirit +of the Neapolitan Court. Ministers were removed, but the absolutist and +anti-national system remained the same. Meanwhile Garibaldi was gathering +his followers round him in Genoa. On the 15th of April Victor Emmanuel +wrote to King Francis that unless his fatal system of policy was +immediately abandoned the Piedmontese Government itself might shortly be +forced to become the agent of his destruction. Even this menace proved +fruitless; and after thus fairly exposing to the Court of Naples the +consequence of its own stubbornness, Victor Emmanuel let loose against it +the revolutionary forces of Garibaldi. + +[Sicily.] + +[Garibaldi starts for Sicily, May 5.] + +[Garibaldi at Marsala, May 11.] + +Since the campaign of 1859 insurrectionary committees had been active in +the principal Sicilian towns. The old desire of the Sicilian Liberals for +the independence of the island had given place, under the influence of the +events of the past year, to the desire for Italian union. On the +abandonment of Garibaldi's plan for the march on Rome in November, 1859, +the liberation of Sicily had been suggested to him as a more feasible +enterprise, and the general himself wavered in the spring of 1860 between +the resumption of his Roman project and an attack upon the Bourbons of +Naples from the south. The rumour spread through Sicily that Garibaldi +would soon appear there at the head of his followers. On the 3rd of April +an attempt at insurrection was made at Palermo. It was repressed without +difficulty; and although disturbances broke out in other parts of the +island, the reports which reached Garibaldi at Genoa as to the spirit and +prospects of the Sicilians were so disheartening that for a while he seemed +disposed to abandon the project of invasion as hopeless for the present. It +was only when some of the Sicilian exiles declared that they would risk the +enterprise without him that he resolved upon immediate action. On the night +of the 5th of May two steamships lying in the harbour of Genoa were seized, +and on these Garibaldi with his Thousand put to sea. Cavour, though he +would have preferred that Sicily should remain unmolested until some +progress had been made in the consolidation of the North Italian Kingdom, +did not venture to restrain Garibaldi's movements, with which he was well +acquainted. He required, however, that the expedition should not touch at +the island of Sardinia, and gave ostensible orders to his admiral, Persano, +to seize the ships of Garibaldi if they should put into any Sardinian port. +Garibaldi, who had sheltered the Sardinian Government from responsibility +at the outset by the fiction of a sudden capture of the two merchant-ships, +continued to spare Victor Emmanuel unnecessary difficulties by avoiding the +fleet which was supposed to be on the watch for him off Cagliari in +Sardinia, and only interrupted his voyage by a landing at a desolate spot +on the Tuscan coast in order to take up artillery and ammunition which were +waiting for him there. On the 11th of May, having heard from some English +merchantmen that there were no Neapolitan vessels of war at Marsala, he +made for this harbour. The first of his two ships entered it in safety and +disembarked her crew; the second, running on a rock, lay for some time +within range of the guns of a Neapolitan war-steamer which was bearing up +towards the port. But for some unknown reason the Neapolitan commander +delayed opening fire, and the landing of Garibaldi's followers was during +this interval completed without loss. [498] + +[Garibaldi captures Palermo, May 26.] + +On the following day the little army, attired in the red shirts which are +worn by cattle-ranchers in South America, marched eastwards from Marsala. +Bands of villagers joined them as they moved through the country, and many +unexpected adherents were gained among the priests. On the third day's +march Neapolitan troops were seen in position at Calatafimi. They were +attacked by Garibaldi, and, though far superior in number, were put to the +rout. The moral effects of this first victory were very great. The +Neapolitan commander retired into Palermo, leaving Garibaldi master of the +western portion of the island. Insurrection spread towards the interior; +the revolutionary party at Palermo itself regained its courage and prepared +to co-operate with Garibaldi on his approach. On nearing the city Garibaldi +determined that he could not risk a direct assault upon the forces which +occupied it. He resolved, if possible, to lure part of the defenders into +the mountains, and during their absence to throw himself into the city and +to trust to the energy of its inhabitants to maintain himself there. This +strategy succeeded. While the officer in command of some of the Neapolitan +battalions, tempted by an easy victory over the ill-disciplined Sicilian +bands opposed to him, pursued his beaten enemy into the mountains, +Garibaldi with the best of his troops fought his way into Palermo on the +night of May 26th. Fighting continued in the streets during the next two +days, and the cannon of the forts and of the Neapolitan vessels in harbour +ineffectually bombarded the city. On the 30th, at the moment when the +absent battalions were coming again into sight, an armistice was signed on +board the British man-of-war _Hannibal_. The Neapolitan commander gave +up to Garibaldi the bank and public buildings, and withdrew into the forts +outside the town. But the Government at Naples was now becoming thoroughly +alarmed; and considering Palermo as lost, it directed the troops to be +shipped to Messina and to Naples itself. Garibaldi was thus left in +undisputed possession of the Sicilian capital. He remained there for nearly +two months, assuming the government of Sicily as Dictator in the name of +Victor Emmanuel, appointing Ministers, and levying taxes. Heavy +reinforcements reached him from Italy. The Neapolitans, driven from the +interior as well as from the towns occupied by the invader, now held only +the north-eastern extremity of the island. On the 20th of July Garibaldi, +operating both by land and sea, attacked and defeated them at Milazzo on +the northern coast. The result of this victory was that Messina itself, +with the exception of the citadel, was evacuated by the Neapolitans without +resistance. Garibaldi, whose troops now numbered eighteen thousand, was +master of the island from sea to sea, and could with confidence look +forward to the overthrow of Bourbon authority on the Italian mainland. + +[The Party of Action.] + +During Garibaldi's stay at Palermo the antagonism between the two political +creeds which severed those whose devotion to Italy was the strongest came +clearly into view. This antagonism stood embodied in its extreme form in +the contrast between Mazzini and Cavour. Mazzini, handling moral and +political conceptions with something of the independence of a +mathematician, laid it down as the first duty of the Italian nation to +possess itself of Rome and Venice, regardless of difficulties that might be +raised from without. By conviction he desired that Italy should be a +Republic, though under certain conditions he might be willing to tolerate +the monarchy of Victor Emmanuel. Cavour, accurately observing the play of +political forces in Europe, conscious above all of the strength of those +ties which still bound Napoleon to the clerical cause, knew that there were +limits which Italy could not at present pass without ruin. The centre of +Mazzini's hopes, an advance upon Rome itself, he knew to be an act of +self-destruction for Italy, and this advance he was resolved at all costs +to prevent. Cavour had not hindered the expedition to Sicily; he had not +considered it likely to embroil Italy with its ally; but neither had he +been the author of this enterprise. The liberation of Sicily might be +deemed the work rather of the school of Mazzini than of Cavour. Garibaldi +indeed was personally loyal to Victor Emmanuel; but around him there were +men who, if not Republicans, were at least disposed to make the grant of +Sicily to Victor Emmanuel conditional upon the king's fulfilling the will +of the so-called Party of Action, and consenting to an attack upon Rome. +Under the influence of these politicians Garibaldi, in reply to a +deputation expressing to him the desire of the Sicilians for union with the +Kingdom of Victor Emmanuel, declared that he had come to fight not for +Sicily alone but for all Italy, and that if the annexation of Sicily was to +take place before the union of Italy was assured, he must withdraw his hand +from the work and retire. The effect produced by these words of Garibaldi +was so serious that the Ministers whom he had placed in office resigned. +Garibaldi endeavoured to substitute for them men more agreeable to the +Party of Action, but a demonstration in Palermo itself forced him to +nominate Sicilians in favour of immediate annexation. The public opinion of +the island was hostile to Republicanism and to the friends of Mazzini; nor +could the prevailing anarchy long continue without danger of a reactionary +movement. Garibaldi himself possessed no glimmer of administrative faculty. +After weeks of confusion and misgovernment he saw the necessity of +accepting direction from Turin, and consented to recognise as Pro-Dictator +of the island a nominee of Cavour, the Piedmontese Depretis. Under the +influence of Depretis a commencement was made in the work of political and +social reorganisation. [499] + +[Cavour's policy with regard to Naples.] + +[Garibaldi crosses to the mainland, Aug. 19.] + +Cavour, during Garibaldi's preparation for his descent upon Sicily and +until the capture of Palermo, had affected to disavow and condemn the +enterprise as one undertaken by individuals in spite of the Government, and +at their own risk. The Piedmontese ambassador was still at Naples as the +representative of a friendly Court; and in reply to the reproaches of +Germany and Russia, Cavour alleged that the title of Dictator of Sicily in +the name of Victor Emmanuel had been assumed by Garibaldi without the +knowledge or consent of his sovereign. But whatever might be said to +Foreign Powers, Cavour, from the time of the capture of Palermo, recognised +that the hour had come for further steps towards Italian union; and, +without committing himself to any definite line of action, he began already +to contemplate the overthrow of the Bourbon dynasty at Naples. It was in +vain that King Francis now released his political prisoners, declared the +Constitution of 1848 in force, and tendered to Piedmont the alliance which +he had before refused. Cavour, in reply to his overtures, stated that he +could not on his own authority pledge Piedmont to the support of a dynasty +now almost in the agonies of dissolution, and that the matter must await +the meeting of Parliament at Turin. Thus far the way had not been +absolutely closed to a reconciliation between the two Courts; but after the +victory of Garibaldi at Milazzo and the evacuation of Messina at the end of +July Cavour cast aside all hesitation and reserve. He appears to have +thought a renewal of the war with Austria probable, and now strained every +nerve to become master of Naples and its fleet before Austria could take +the field. He ordered Admiral Persano to leave two ships of war to cover +Garibaldi's passage to the mainland, and with one ship to proceed to Naples +himself, and there excite insurrection and win over the Neapolitan fleet to +the flag of Victor Emmanuel. Persano reached Naples on the 3rd of August, +and on the next day the negotiations between the two Courts were broken +off. On the 19th Garibaldi crossed from Sicily to the mainland. His march +upon the capital was one unbroken triumph. + +[Persano and Villamarina at Naples.] + +[Departure of King Francis, Sept. 6.] + +[Garibaldi enters Naples, Sept. 7.] + +It was the hope of Cavour that before Garibaldi could reach Naples a +popular movement in the city itself would force the King to take flight, so +that Garibaldi on his arrival would find the machinery of government, as +well as the command of the fleet and the army, already in the hands of +Victor Emmanuel's representatives. If war with Austria was really +impending, incalculable mischief might be caused by the existence of a +semi-independent Government at Naples, reckless, in its enthusiasm for the +march on Rome, of the effect which its acts might produce on the French +alliance. In any case the control of Italian affairs could but half belong +to the King and his Minister if Garibaldi, in the full glory of his +unparalleled exploits, should add the Dictatorship of Naples to the +Dictatorship of Sicily. Accordingly Cavour plied every art to accelerate +the inevitable revolution. Persano and the Sardinian ambassador, +Villamarina, had their confederates in the Bourbon Ministry and in the +Royal Family itself. But their efforts to drive King Francis from Naples, +and to establish the authority of Victor Emmanuel before Garibaldi's +arrival, were baffled partly by the tenacity of the King and Queen, partly +by the opposition of the committees of the Party of Action, who were +determined that power should fall into no hands but those of Garibaldi +himself. It was not till Garibaldi had reached Salerno, and the Bourbon +generals had one after another declined to undertake the responsibility of +command in a battle against him, that Francis resolved on flight. It was +now feared that he might induce the fleet to sail with him, and even that +he might hand it over to the Austrians. The crews, it was believed, were +willing to follow the King; the officers, though inclined to the Italian +cause, would be powerless to prevent them. There was not an hour to lose. +On the night of September 5th, after the King's intention to quit the +capital had become known, Persano and Villamarina disguised themselves, and +in company with their partisans mingled with the crews of the fleet, whom +they induced by bribes and persuasion to empty the boilers and to cripple +the engines of their ships. When, on the 6th, King Francis, having +announced his intention to spare the capital bloodshed, went on board a +mail steamer and quitted the harbour, accompanied by the ambassadors of +Austria, Prussia, and Spain, only one vessel of the fleet of followed him. +An urgent summons was sent to Garibaldi, whose presence was now desired by +all parties alike in order to prevent the outbreak of disorders. Leaving +his troops at Salerno, Garibaldi came by railroad to Naples on the morning +of the 7th, escorted only by some of his staff. The forts were still +garrisoned by eight thousand of the Bourbon troops, but all idea of +resistance had been abandoned, and Garibaldi drove fearlessly through the +city in the midst of joyous crowds. His first act as Dictator was to +declare the ships of war belonging to the State of the Two Sicilies united +to those of King Victor Emmanuel under Admiral Persano's command. Before +sunset the flag of Italy was hoisted by the Neapolitan fleet. The army was +not to be so easily incorporated with the national forces. King Francis, +after abandoning the idea of a battle between Naples and Salerno, had +ordered the mass of his troops to retire upon Capua in order to make a +final struggle on the line of the Volturno, and this order had been obeyed. +[500] + +[The Piedmontese army enters Umbria and the Marches. Sept. 11.] + +[Fall of Ancona, Sept. 25.] + +As soon as it had become evident that the entry of Garibaldi into Naples +could not be anticipated by the establishment of Victor Emmanuel's own +authority, Cavour recognised that bold and aggressive action on the part of +the National Government was now necessity. Garibaldi made no secret or his +intention to carry the Italian arms to Rome. The time was past when the +national movement could be checked at the frontiers of Naples and Tuscany. +It remained only for Cavour to throw the King's own troops into the Papal +States before Garibaldi could move from Naples, and, while winning for +Italy the last foot of ground that could be won without an actual conflict +with France, to stop short at those limits where the soldiers of Napoleon +would certainly meet an invader with their fire. The Pope was still in +possession of the Marches, of Umbria, and of the territory between the +Apennines and the coast from Orvieto to Terracina. Cavour had good reason +to believe that Napoleon would not strike on behalf of the Temporal Power +until this last narrow district was menaced. He resolved to seize upon the +Marches and Umbria, and to brave the consequences. On the day of +Garibaldi's entry into Naples a despatch was sent by Cavour to the Papal +Government requiring, in the name of Victor Emmanuel, the disbandment of +the foreign mercenaries who in the previous spring had plundered Perugia, +and whose presence was a continued menace to the peace of Italy. The +announcement now made by Napoleon that he must break off diplomatic +relations with the Sardinian Government in case of the invasion of the +Papal States produced no effect. Cavour replied that by no other means +could he prevent revolution from mastering all Italy, and on the 10th of +September the French ambassador quitted Turin. Without waiting for +Antonelli's answer to his ultimatum, Cavour ordered the King's troops to +cross the frontier. The Papal army was commanded by Lamoriciere, a French +general who had gained some reputation in Algiers; but the resistance +offered to the Piedmontese was unexpectedly feeble. The column which +entered Umbria reached the southern limit without encountering any serious +opposition except from the Irish garrison of Spoleto. In the Marches, where +Lamoriciere had a considerable force at his disposal, the dispersion of the +Papal troops and the incapacity shown in their command brought the campaign +to a rapid and inglorious end. The main body of the defenders was routed on +the Musone, near Loreto, on the 19th of September. Other divisions +surrendered, and Ancona alone remained to Lamoriciere. Vigorously attacked +in this fortress both by land and sea, Lamoriciere surrendered after a +siege of eight days. Within three weeks from Garibaldi's entry into Naples +the Piedmontese army had completed the task imposed upon it, and Victor +Emmanuel was master of Italy as far as the Abruzzi. + +[Cavour, Garibaldi, and the Party of Action.] + +Cavour's successes had not come a day too soon, for Garibaldi, since his +entry into Naples, was falling more and more into the hands of the Party of +Action, and, while protesting his loyalty to Victor Emmanuel, was openly +announcing that he would march the Party of on Rome whether the King's +Government permitted it or no. In Sicily the officials appointed by this +Party were proceeding with such violence that Depretis, unable to obtain +troops from Cavour, resigned his post. Garibaldi suddenly appeared at +Palermo on the 11th of September, appointed a new Pro-Dictator, and +repeated to the Sicilians that their union with the Kingdom of Victor +Emmanuel must be postponed until all members of the Italian family were +free. But even the personal presence and the angry words of Garibaldi were +powerless to check the strong expression of Sicilian opinion in favour of +immediate and unconditional annexation. His visit to Palermo was answered +by the appearance of a Sicilian deputation at Turin demanding immediate +union, and complaining that the island was treated by Garibaldi's officers +like a conquered province. At Naples the rash and violent utterances of the +Dictator were equally condemned. The Ministers whom he had himself +appointed resigned. Garibaldi replaced them by others who were almost +Republicans, and sent a letter to Victor Emmanuel requesting him to consent +to the march upon Rome and to dismiss Cavour. It was known in Turin that at +this very moment Napoleon was taking steps to increase the French force in +Rome, and to garrison the whole of the territory that still remained to the +Pope. Victor Emmanuel understood how to reply to Garibaldi's letter. He +remained true to his Minister, and sent orders to Villamarina at Naples in +case Garibaldi should proclaim the Republic to break off all relations with +him and to secure the fleet. The fall of Ancona on September 28th brought a +timely accession of popularity and credit to Cavour. He made the Parliament +which assembled at Turin four days later arbiter in the struggle between +Garibaldi and himself, and received from it an almost unanimous vote of +confidence. Garibaldi would perhaps have treated lightly any resolution of +Parliament which conflicted with his own opinion: he shrank from a breach +with the soldier of Novara and Solferino. Now, as at other moments of +danger, the character and reputation of Victor Emmanuel stood Italy in good +stead. In the enthusiasm which Garibaldi's services to Italy excited in +every patriotic heart, there was room for thankfulness that Italy possessed +a sovereign and a statesman strong enough even to withstand its hero when +his heroism endangered the national cause. [501] + +[The armies on the Volturno.] + +[Meeting of Victor Emmanuel and Garibaldi, Oct. 26.] + +[Fall of Gaeta, Feb. 14, 1861.] + +The King of Naples had not yet abandoned the hope that one or more of the +European Powers would intervene in his behalf. The trustworthy part of his +army had gathered round the fortress of Capua on the Volturno, and there +were indications that Garibaldi would here meet with far more serious +resistance than he had yet encountered. While he was still in Naples, his +troops, which had pushed northwards, sustained a repulse at Cajazzo. +Emboldened by this success, the Neapolitan army at the beginning of October +assumed the offensive. It was with difficulty that Garibaldi, placing +himself again at the head of his forces, drove the enemy back to Capua. But +the arms of Victor Emmanuel were now thrown into the scale. Crossing the +Apennines, and driving before him the weak force that was intended to bar +his way at Isernia, the King descended in the rear of the Neapolitan army. +The Bourbon commander, warned of his approach, moved northwards on the line +of the Garigliano, leaving a garrison to defend Capua. Garibaldi followed +on his track, and in the neighbourhood of Teano met King Victor Emmanuel +(October 26th). The meeting is said to have been cordial on the part of the +King, reserved on the part of Garibaldi, who saw in the King's suite the +men by whom he had been prevented from invading the Papal States in the +previous year. In spite of their common patriotism the volunteers of +Garibaldi and the army of Victor Emmanuel were rival bodies, and the +relations between the chiefs of each camp were strained and difficult. +Garibaldi himself returned to the siege of Capua, while the King marched +northwards against the retreating Neapolitans. All that was great in +Garibaldi's career was now in fact accomplished. The politicians about him +had attempted at Naples, as in Sicily, to postpone the union with Victor +Emmanuel's monarchy, and to convoke a Southern Parliament which should fix +the conditions on which annexation would be permitted; but, after +discrediting the General, they had been crushed by public opinion, and a +popular vote which was taken at the end of October on the question of +immediate union showed the majority in favour of this course to be +overwhelming. After the surrender of Capua on the 2nd of November, Victor +Emmanuel made his entry into Naples. Garibaldi, whose request for the +Lieutenancy of Southern Italy for the space of a year with full powers was +refused by the King, [502] declined all minor honours and rewards, and +departed to his home, still filled with resentment against Cavour, and +promising his soldiers that he would return in the spring and lead them to +Rome and Venice. The reduction of Gaeta, where King Francis II. had taken +refuge, and of the citadel of Messina, formed the last act of the war. The +French fleet for some time prevented the Sardinians from operating against +Gaeta from the sea, and the siege in consequence made slow progress. It was +not until the middle of January, 1861, that Napoleon permitted the French +admiral to quit his station. The bombardment was now opened both by land +and sea, and after a brave resistance Gaeta surrendered on the 14th of +February. King Francis and his young Queen, a sister of the Empress of +Austria, were conveyed in a French steamer to the Papal States, and there +began their life-long exile. The citadel of Messina, commanded by one of +the few Neapolitan officers who showed any soldierly spirit, maintained its +obstinate defence for a month after the Bourbon flag had disappeared from +the mainland. + +[Cavour's policy with regard to Rome and Venice.] + +[The Free Church in the Free State.] + +Thus in the spring of 1861, within two years from the outbreak of war with +Austria, Italy with the exception of Rome and Venice was united under +Victor Emmanuel. Of all the European Powers, Great Britain alone watched +the creation of the new Italian Kingdom with complete sympathy and +approval. Austria, though it had made peace at Zuerich, declined to renew +diplomatic intercourse with Sardinia, and protested against the assumption +by Victor Emmanuel of the title of King of Italy. Russia, the ancient +patron of the Neapolitan Bourbons, declared that geographical conditions +alone prevented its intervention against their despoilers. Prussia, though +under a new sovereign, had not yet completely severed the ties which bound +it to Austria. Nevertheless, in spite of wide political ill-will, and of +the passionate hostility of the clerical party throughout Europe, there was +little probability that the work of the Italian people would be overthrown +by external force. The problem which faced Victor Emmanuel's Government was +not so much the frustration of reactionary designs from without as the +determination of the true line of policy to be followed in regard to Rome +and Venice. There were few who, like Azeglio, held that Rome might be +permanently left outside the Italian Kingdom; there were none who held this +of Venice. Garibaldi might be mad enough to hope for victory in a campaign +against Austria and against France at the head of such a troop as he +himself could muster; Cavour would have deserved ill of his country if he +had for one moment countenanced the belief that the force which had +overthrown the Neapolitan Bourbons could with success, or with impunity to +Italy, measure itself against the defenders of Venetia or of Rome. Yet the +mind of Cavour was not one which could rest in mere passive expectancy as +to the future, or in mere condemnation of the unwise schemes of others. His +intelligence, so luminous, so penetrating, that in its utterances we seem +at times to be listening to the very spirit of the age, ranged over wide +fields of moral and of spiritual interests in its forecast of the future of +Italy, and spent its last force in one of those prophetic delineations +whose breadth and power the world can feel, though a later time alone can +judge of their correspondence with the destined course of history. Venice +was less to Europe than Rome; its transfer to Italy would, Cavour believed, +be effected either by arms or negotiations so soon as the German race +should find a really national Government, and refuse the service which had +hitherto been exacted from it for the maintenance of Austrian interests. It +was to Prussia, as the representative of nationality in Germany, that +Cavour looked as the natural ally of Italy in the vindication of that part +of the national inheritance which still lay under the dominion of the +Hapsburg. Rome, unlike Venice, was not only defended by foreign arms, it +was the seat of a Power whose empire over the mind of man was not the sport +of military or political vicissitudes. Circumstances might cause France to +relax its grasp on Rome, but it was not to such an accident that Cavour +looked for the incorporation of Rome with Italy. He conceived that the time +would arrive when the Catholic world would recognise that the Church would +best fulfil its task in complete separation from temporal power. Rome would +then assume its natural position as the centre of the Italian State; the +Church would be the noblest friend, not the misjudging enemy, of the +Italian national monarchy. Cavour's own religious beliefs were perhaps less +simple than he chose to represent them. Occupying himself, however, with +institutions, not with dogmas, he regarded the Church in profound +earnestness as a humanising and elevating power. He valued its independence +so highly that even on the suppression of the Piedmontese monasteries he +had refused to give to the State the administration of the revenue arising +from the sale of their lands, and had formed this into a fund belonging to +the Church itself, in order that the clergy might not become salaried +officers of the State. Human freedom was the principle in which he trusted; +and looking upon the Church as the greatest association formed by men, he +believed that here too the rule of freedom, of the absence of +State-regulation, would in the end best serve man's highest interests. With +the passing away of the Pope's temporal power, Cavour imagined that the +constitution of the Church itself would become more democratic, more +responsive to the movement of the modern world. His own effort in +ecclesiastical reform had been to improve the condition and to promote the +independence of the lower clergy. He had hoped that each step in their +moral and material progress would make them more national at heart; and +though this hope had been but partially fulfilled, Cavour had never ceased +to cherish the ideal of a national Church which, while recognising its Head +in Rome, should cordially and without reserve accept the friendship of the +Italian State. [503] + +[Death of Cavour, June 6, 1861.] + +[Free Church in Free State.] + +It was in the exposition of these principles, in the enforcement of the +common moral interest of Italian nationality and the Catholic Church, that +Cavour gave his last counsels to the Italian Parliament. He was not himself +to lead the nation farther towards the Promised Land. The immense exertions +which he had maintained during the last three years, the indignation and +anxiety caused to him by Garibaldi's attacks, produced an illness which +Cavour's own careless habits of life and the unskilfulness of his doctors +rendered fatal. With dying lips he repeated to those about him the words in +which he had summed up his policy in the Italian Parliament: "A free Church +in a free State." [504] Other Catholic lands had adjusted by Concordats +with the Papacy the conflicting claims of temporal and spiritual authority +in such matters as the appointment of bishops, the regulation of schools, +the family-rights of persons married without ecclesiastical form. Cavour +appears to have thought that in Italy, where the whole nation was in a +sense Catholic, the Church might as safely and as easily be left to manage +its own affairs as in the United States, where the Catholic community is +only one among many religious societies. His optimism, his sanguine and +large-hearted tolerance, was never more strikingly shown than in this +fidelity to the principle of liberty, even in the case of those who for the +time declined all reconciliation with the Italian State. Whether Cavour's +ideal was an impracticable fancy a later age will decide. The ascendency +within the Church of Rome would seem as yet to have rested with the +elements most opposed to the spirit of the time, most obstinately bent on +setting faith and reason in irreconcilable enmity. In place of that +democratic movement within the hierarchy and the priesthood which Cavour +anticipated, absolutism has won a new crown in the doctrine of Papal +Infallibility. Catholic dogma has remained impervious to the solvents which +during the last thirty years have operated with perceptible success on the +theology of Protestant lands. Each conquest made in the world of thought +and knowledge is still noted as the next appropriate object of denunciation +by the Vatican. Nevertheless the cautious spirit will be slow to conclude +that hopes like those of Cavour were wholly vain. A single generation may +see but little of the seed-time, nothing of the harvests that are yet to +enrich mankind. And even if all wider interests be left out of view, enough +remains to justify Cavour's policy of respect for the independence of the +Church in the fact that Italy during the thirty years succeeding the +establishment of its union has remained free from civil war. Cavour was +wont to refer to the Constitution which the French National Assembly +imposed upon the clergy in 1790 as the type of erroneous legislation. Had +his own policy and that of his successors not been animated by a wiser +spirit; had the Government of Italy, after overthrowing the Pope's temporal +sovereignty, sought enemies among the rural priesthood and their +congregations, the provinces added to the Italian Kingdom by Garibaldi +would hardly have been maintained by the House of Savoy without a second +and severer struggle. Between the ideal Italy which filled the thoughts not +only of Mazzini but of some of the best English minds of that time--the +land of immemorial greatness, touched once more by the divine hand and +advancing from strength to strength as the intellectual and moral pioneer +among nations--between this ideal and the somewhat hard and commonplace +realities of the Italy of to-day there is indeed little enough resemblance. +Poverty, the pressure of inordinate taxation, the physical and moral habits +inherited from centuries of evil government,--all these have darkened in no +common measure the conditions from which Italian national life has to be +built up. If in spite of overwhelming difficulties each crisis has hitherto +been surmounted; if, with all that is faulty and infirm, the omens for the +future of Italy are still favourable, one source of its good fortune has +been the impress given to its ecclesiastical policy by the great statesman +to whom above all other men it owes the accomplishment of its union, and +who, while claiming for Italy the whole of its national inheritance, yet +determined to inflict no needless wound upon the conscience of Rome. + + + + +CHAPTER XXIII. + + +Germany after 1858--The Regency in Prussia--Army re-organisation--King +William I.--Conflict between the Crown and the Parliament--Bismarck--The +struggle continued--Austria from 1859--The October Diploma--Resistance of +Hungary--The Reichsrath--Russia under Alexander II.--Liberation of the +Serfs--Poland--The Insurrection of 1863--Agrarian measures in +Poland--Schleswig-Holstein--Death of Frederick VII.--Plans of +Bismarck--Campaign in Schleswig--Conference of London--Treaty of +Vienna--England and Napoleon III.--Prussia and Austria--Convention of +Gastein--Italy--Alliance of Prussia with Italy--Proposals for a Congress +fail--War between Austria and Prussia--Napoleon III.--Koeniggraetz-- +Custozza-Mediation of Napoleon--Treaty of Prague--South Germany--Projects +for compensation to France--Austria and Hungary--Deak--Establishment of +the Dual System in Austria-Hungary. + + +[Germany from 1858.] + +[The Regency in Prussia, Oct. 1858.] + +Shortly before the events which broke the power of Austria in Italy, the +German people believed themselves to have entered on a new political era. +King Frederick William IV., who, since 1848, had disappointed every hope +that had been fixed on Prussia and on himself, was compelled by mental +disorder to withdraw from public affairs in the autumn of 1858. His +brother, Prince William of Prussia, who had for a year acted as the King's +representative, now assumed the Regency. In the days when King Frederick +William still retained some vestiges of his reputation the Prince of +Prussia had been unpopular, as the supposed head of the reactionary party; +but the events of the last few years had exhibited him in a better aspect. +Though strong in his belief both in the Divine right of kings in general, +and in the necessity of a powerful monarchical rule in Prussia, he was +disposed to tolerate, and even to treat with a certain respect, the humble +elements of constitutional government which he found in existence. There +was more manliness in his nature than in that of his brother, more belief +in the worth of his own people. The espionage, the servility, the overdone +professions of sanctity in Manteuffel's regime displeased him, but most of +all he despised its pusillanimity in the conduct of foreign affairs. His +heart indeed was Prussian, not German, and the destiny which created him +the first Emperor of united Germany was not of his own making nor of his +own seeking; but he felt that Prussia ought to hold a far greater station +both in Germany and in Europe than it had held during his brother's reign, +and that the elevation of the State to the position which it ought to +occupy was the task that lay before himself. During the twelve months +preceding the Regency the retirement of the King had not been treated as +more than temporary, and the Prince of Prussia, though constantly at +variance with Manteuffel's Cabinet, had therefore not considered himself at +liberty to remove his brother's advisers. His first act on the assumption +of the constitutional office of Regent was to dismiss the hated Ministry. +Prince Antony of Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen was called to office, and posts +in the Government were given to men well known as moderate Liberals. Though +the Regent stated in clear terms that he had no intention of forming a +Liberal party-administration, his action satisfied public opinion. The +troubles and the failures of 1849 had inclined men to be content with far +less than had been asked years before. The leaders of the more advanced +sections among the Liberals preferred for the most part to remain outside +Parliamentary life rather than to cause embarrassment to the new +Government; and the elections of 1859 sent to Berlin a body of +representatives fully disposed to work with the Regent and his Ministers in +the policy of guarded progress which they had laid down. + +[Revival of idea of German union.] + +This change of spirit in the Prussian Government, followed by the events +that established Italian independence, told powerfully upon public opinion +throughout Germany. Hopes that had been crushed in 1849 now revived. With +the collapse of military despotism in the Austrian Empire the clouds of +reaction seemed everywhere to be passing away; it was possible once more to +think of German national union and of common liberties in which all Germans +should share. As in 1808 the rising of the Spaniards against Napoleon had +inspired Bluecher and his countrymen with the design of a truly national +effort against their foreign oppressor, so in 1859 the work of Cavour +challenged the Germans to prove that their national patriotism and their +political aptitude were not inferior to those of the Italian people. Men +who had been prominent in the National Assembly at Frankfort again met one +another and spoke to the nation. In the Parliaments of several of the minor +States resolutions were brought forward in favour of the creation of a +central German authority. Protests were made against the infringement of +constitutional rights that had been common during the last ten years; +patriotic meetings and demonstrations were held; and a National Society, in +imitation of that which had prepared the way for union with Piedmont in +Central and Southern Italy, was formally established. There was indeed no +such preponderating opinion in favour of Prussian leadership as had existed +in 1848. The southern States had displayed a strong sympathy with Austria +in its war with Napoleon III., and had regarded the neutrality of Prussia +during the Italian campaign as a desertion of the German cause. Here there +were few who looked with friendly eye upon Berlin. It was in the minor +states of the north, and especially in Hesse-Cassel, where the struggle +between the Elector and his subjects was once more breaking out, that the +strongest hopes were directed towards the new Prussian ruler, and the +measures of his government were the most anxiously watched. + +[The Regent of Prussia and the army.] + +[Scheme of reorganisation.] + +The Prince Regent was a soldier by profession and habit. He was born in +1797, and had been present at the battle of Arcis-sur-Aube, the last fought +by Napoleon against the Allies in 1814. During forty years he had served on +every commission that had been occupied with Prussian military affairs; no +man better understood the military organisation of his country, no man more +clearly recognised its capacities and its faults. The defective condition +of the Prussian army had been the principal, though not the sole, cause of +the miserable submission to Austria at Olmuetz in 1850, and of the +abandonment of all claims to German leadership on the part of the Court of +Berlin. The Prince would himself have risked all chances of disaster rather +than inflict upon Prussia the humiliation with which King Frederick William +then purchased peace; but Manteuffel had convinced his sovereign that the +army could not engage in a campaign against Austria without ruin. Military +impotence was the only possible justification for the policy then adopted, +and the Prince determined that Prussia should not under his own rule have +the same excuse for any political shortcomings. The work of reorganisation +was indeed begun during the reign of Frederick William IV., through the +enforcement of the three-years' service to which the conscript was liable +by law, but which had fallen during the long period of peace to two-years' +service. The number of troops with the colours was thus largely increased, +but no addition had been made to the yearly levy, and no improvement +attempted in the organisation of the Landwehr. When in 1859 the order for +mobilisation was given in consequence of the Italian war, it was discovered +that the Landwehr battalions were almost useless. The members of this force +were mostly married men approaching middle life, who had been too long +engaged in other pursuits to resume their military duties with readiness, +and whose call to the field left their families without means of support +and chargeable upon the public purse. Too much, in the judgment of the +reformers of the Prussian army, was required from men past youth, not +enough from youth itself. The plan of the Prince Regent was therefore to +enforce in the first instance with far more stringency the law imposing the +universal obligation to military service; and, while thus raising the +annual levy from 40,000 to 60,000 men, to extend the period of service in +the Reserve, into which the young soldier passed on the completion of his +three years with the colours, from two to four years. Asserting with +greater rigour its claim to seven years in the early life of the citizen, +the State would gain, without including the Landwehr, an effective army of +four hundred thousand men, and would practically be able to dispense with +the service of those who were approaching middle life, except in cases of +great urgency. In the execution of this reform the Government could on its +own authority enforce the increased levy and the full three years' service +in the standing army; for the prolongation of service in the Reserve, and +for the greater expenditure entailed by the new system, the consent of +Parliament was necessary. + +[The Prussian Parliament and the army, 1859-1861.] + +[Accession of King William, Jan., 1861.] + +The general principles on which the proposed reorganisation was based were +accepted by public opinion and by both Chambers of Parliament; it was, +however, held by the Liberal leaders that the increase of expenditure +might, without impairing the efficiency of the army, be avoided by +returning to the system of two-years service with the colours, which during +so long a period had been thought sufficient for the training of the +soldier. The Regent, however, was convinced that the discipline and the +instruction of three years were indispensable to the Prussian conscript, +and he refused to accept the compromise suggested. The mobilisation of 1859 +had given him an opportunity for forming additional battalions; and +although the Landwehr were soon dismissed to their homes the new formation +was retained, and the place of the retiring militiamen was filled by +conscripts of the year. The Lower Chamber, in voting the sum required in +1860 for the increased numbers of the army, treated this arrangement as +temporary, and limited the grant to one year; in spite of this the Regent, +who on the death of his brother in January, 1861, became King of Prussia, +formed the additional battalions into new regiments, and gave to these new +regiments their names and colours. The year 1861 passed without bringing +the questions at issue between the Government and the Chamber of Deputies +to a settlement. Public feeling, disappointed in the reserved and +hesitating policy which was still followed by the Court in German affairs, +stimulated too by the rapid consolidation of the Italian monarchy, which +the Prussian Government on its part had as yet declined to recognise, was +becoming impatient and resentful. It seemed as if the Court of Berlin still +shrank from committing itself to the national cause. The general confidence +reposed in the new ruler at his accession was passing away; and when in the +summer of 1861 the dissolution of Parliament took place, the elections +resulted in the return not only of a Progressist majority, but of a +majority little inclined to submit to measures of compromise, or to shrink +from the assertion of its full constitutional rights. + +[First Parliament of 1862.] + +[Dissolution, May, 1862.] + +[Second Parliament of 1862.] + +[Bismarck becomes Minister, Sept., 1862.] + +The new Parliament assembled at the beginning of 1862. Under the impulse +of public opinion, the Government was now beginning to adopt a more +vigorous policy in German affairs, and to re-assert Prussia's claims to +an independent leadership in defiance of the restored Diet of Frankfort. +But the conflict with the Lower Chamber was not to be averted by revived +energy abroad. The Army Bill, which was passed at once by the Upper +House, was referred to a hostile Committee on reaching the Chamber of +Deputies, and a resolution was carried insisting on the right of the +representatives of the people to a far more effective control over the +Budget than they had hitherto exercised. The result of this vote was the +dissolution of Parliament by the King, and the resignation of the +Ministry, with the exception of General Roon, Minister of War, and two of +the most conservative among his colleagues. Prince Hohenlohe, President +of the Upper House, became chief of the Government. There was now an open +and undisguised conflict between the Crown and the upholders of +Parliamentary rights. "King or Parliament" was the expression in which +the newly-appointed Ministers themselves summed up the struggle. The +utmost pressure was exerted by the Government in the course of the +elections which followed, but in vain. The Progressist Party returned in +overwhelming strength to the new Parliament; the voice of the country +seemed unmistakably to condemn the policy to which the King and his +advisers were committed. After a long and sterile discussion in the +Budget Committee, the debate on the Army Bill began in the Lower House on +the 11th of September. Its principal clauses were rejected by an almost +unanimous vote. An attempt made by General Roon to satisfy his opponents +by a partial and conditional admission of the principle of two-years' +service resulted only in increased exasperation on both sides. Hohenlohe +resigned, and the King now placed in power, at the head of a Ministry of +conflict, the most resolute and unflinching of all his friends, the most +contemptuous scorner of Parliamentary majorities, Herr von Bismarck. [505] + +[Bismarck.] + +The new Minister was, like Cavour, a country gentleman, and, like Cavour, +he owed his real entry into public life to the revolutionary movement of +1848. He had indeed held some obscure official posts before that epoch, but +it was as a member of the United Diet which assembled at Berlin in April, +1848, that he first attracted the attention of King or people. He was one +of two Deputies who refused to join in the vote of thanks to Frederick +William IV. for the Constitution which he had promised to Prussia. +Bismarck, then thirty-three years old, was a Royalist of Royalists, the +type, as it seemed, of the rough and masterful Junker, or Squire, of the +older parts of Prussia, to whom all reforms from those of Stein downwards +were hateful, all ideas but those of the barrack and the kennel alien. +Others in the spring of 1848 lamented the concessions made by the Crown to +the people; Bismarck had the courage to say so. When reaction came there +were naturally many, and among them King Frederick William, who were +interested in the man who in the heyday of constitutional enthusiasm had +treated the whole movement as so much midsummer madness, and had remained +faithful to monarchical authority as the one thing needful for the Prussian +State. Bismarck continued to take a prominent part in the Parliaments of +Berlin and Erfurt; it was not, however, till 1851 that he passed into the +inner official circle. He was then sent as the representative of Prussia to +the restored Diet of Frankfort. As an absolutist and a conservative, +brought up in the traditions of the Holy Alliance, Bismarck had in earlier +days looked up to Austria as the mainstay of monarchical order and the +historic barrier against the flood of democratic and wind-driven sentiment +which threatened to deluge Germany. He had even approved the surrender made +at Olmuetz in 1850, as a matter of necessity; but the belief now grew strong +in his mind, and was confirmed by all he saw at Frankfort, that Austria +under Schwarzenberg's rule was no longer the Power which had been content +to share the German leadership with Prussia in the period before 1848, but +a Power which meant to rule in Germany uncontrolled. In contact with the +representatives of that outworn system which Austria had resuscitated at +Frankfort, and with the instruments of the dominant State itself, Bismarck +soon learnt to detest the paltriness of the one and the insolence of the +other. He declared the so-called Federal system to be a mere device for +employing the secondary German States for the aggrandisement of Austria and +the humiliation of Prussia. The Court of Vienna, and with it the Diet of +Frankfort, became in his eyes the enemy of Prussian greatness and +independence. During the Crimean war he was the vigorous opponent of an +alliance with the Western Powers, not only from distrust of France, and +from regard towards Russia as on the whole the most constant and the most +natural ally of his own country, but from the conviction that Prussia ought +to assert a national policy wholly independent of that of the Court of +Vienna. That the Emperor of Austria was approaching more or less nearly to +union with France and England was, in Bismarck's view, a good reason why +Prussia should stand fast in its relations of friendship with St. +Petersburg. [506] The policy of neutrality, which King Frederick William +and Manteuffel adopted more out of disinclination to strenuous action than +from any clear political view, was advocated by Bismarck for reasons which, +if they made Europe nothing and Prussia everything, were at least inspired +by a keen and accurate perception of Prussia's own interests in its present +and future relations with its neighbours. When the reign of Frederick +William ended, Bismarck, who stood high in the confidence of the new +Regent, was sent as ambassador to St. Petersburg. He subsequently +represented Prussia for a short time at the Court of Napoleon III., and was +recalled by the King from Paris in the autumn of 1862 in order to be placed +at the head of the Government. Far better versed in diplomacy than in +ordinary administration, he assumed, together with the Presidency of the +Cabinet, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. + +[Bismarck and the Lower Chamber, 1862.] + +There were now at the head of the Prussian State three men eminently suited +to work with one another, and to carry out, in their own rough and military +fashion, the policy which was to unite Germany under the House of +Hohenzollern. The King, Bismarck, and Roon were thoroughly at one in their +aim, the enforcement of Prussia's ascendency by means of the army. The +designs of the Minister, which expanded with success and which involved a +certain daring in the choice of means, were at each new development so ably +veiled or disclosed, so dexterously presented to the sovereign, as to +overcome his hesitation on striking into many an unaccustomed path. Roon +and his workmen, who, in the face of a hostile Parliament and a hostile +Press, had to supply to Bismarck what a foreign alliance and enthusiastic +national sentiment had supplied to Cavour, forged for Prussia a weapon of +such temper that, against the enemies on whom it was employed, no +extraordinary genius was necessary to render its thrust fatal. It was no +doubt difficult for the Prime Minister, without alarming his sovereign and +without risk of an immediate breach with Austria, to make his ulterior aims +so clear as to carry the Parliament with him in the policy of military +reorganisation. Words frank even to brutality were uttered by him, but they +sounded more like menace and bluster than the explanation of a +well-considered plan. "Prussia must keep its forces together," he said in +one of his first Parliamentary appearances, "its boundaries are not those +of a sound State. The great questions of the time are to be decided not by +speeches and votes of majorities but by blood and iron." After the +experience of 1848 and 1850, a not too despondent political observer might +well have formed the conclusion that nothing less than the military +overthrow of Austria could give to Germany any tolerable system of national +government, or even secure to Prussia its legitimate field of action. This +was the keystone of Bismarck's belief, but he failed to make his purpose +and his motives intelligible to the representatives of the Prussian people. +He was taken for a mere bully and absolutist of the old type. His personal +characteristics, his arrogance, his sarcasm, his habit of banter, +exasperated and inflamed. Roon was no better suited to the atmosphere of a +popular assembly. Each encounter of the Ministers with the Chamber +embittered the struggle and made reconciliation more difficult. The +Parliamentary system of Prussia seemed threatened in its very existence +when, after the rejection by the Chamber of Deputies of the clause in the +Budget providing for the cost of the army-reorganisation, this clause was +restored by the Upper House, and the Budget of the Government passed in its +original form. By the terms of the Constitution the right of the Upper +House in matters of taxation was limited to the approval or rejection of +the Budget sent up to it from the Chamber of Representatives. It possessed +no power of amendment. Bismarck, however, had formed the theory that in the +event of a disagreement between the two Houses a situation arose for which +the Constitution had not provided, and in which therefore the Crown was +still possessed of its old absolute authority. No compromise, no +negotiation between the two Houses, was, in his view, to be desired. He was +resolved to govern and to levy taxes without a Budget, and had obtained the +King's permission to close the session immediately the Upper House had +given its vote. But before the order for prorogation could be brought down +the President of the Lower Chamber had assembled his colleagues, and the +unanimous vote of those present declared the action of the Upper House null +and void. In the agitation attending this trial of strength between the +Crown, the Ministry and the Upper House on one side and the Representative +Chamber on the other the session of 1862 closed. [507] + +[King William.] + +[The conflict continued, 1863.] + +[Measures against the Press.] + +The Deputies, returning to their constituencies, carried with them the +spirit of combat, and received the most demonstrative proofs of popular +sympathy and support. Representations of great earnestness were made to the +King, but they failed to shake in the slightest degree his confidence in +his Minister, or to bend his fixed resolution to carry out his military +reforms to the end. The claim of Parliament to interfere with matters of +military organisation in Prussia touched him in his most sensitive point. +He declared that the aim of his adversaries was nothing less than the +establishment of a Parliamentary instead of a royal army. In perfect +sincerity he believed that the convulsions of 1848 were on the point of +breaking out afresh. "You mourn the conflict between the Crown and the +national representatives," he said to the spokesman of an important +society; "do I not mourn it? I sleep no single night." The anxiety, the +despondency of the sovereign were shared by the friends of Prussia +throughout Germany; its enemies saw with wonder that Bismarck in his +struggle with the educated Liberalism of the middle classes did not shrink +from dalliance with the Socialist leaders and their organs. When Parliament +reassembled at the beginning of 1863 the conflict was resumed with even +greater heat. The Lower Chamber carried an address to the King, which, +while dwelling on the loyalty of the Prussian people to their chief, +charged the Ministers with violating the Constitution, and demanded their +dismissal. The King refused to receive the deputation which was to present +the address, and in the written communication in which he replied to it he +sharply reproved the Assembly for their errors and presumption. It was in +vain that the Army Bill was again introduced. The House, while allowing the +ordinary military expenditure for the year, struck out the costs of the +reorganisation, and declared Ministers personally answerable for the sums +expended. Each appearance of the leading members of the Cabinet now became +the signal for contumely and altercation. The decencies of debate ceased to +be observed on either side. When the President attempted to set some limit +to the violence of Bismarck and Roon, and, on resistance to his authority, +terminated the sitting, the Ministers declared that they would no longer +appear in a Chamber where freedom of speech was denied to them. Affairs +came to a deadlock. The Chamber again appealed to the King, and insisted +that reconciliation between the Crown and the nation was impossible so long +as the present Ministers remained in office. The King, now thoroughly +indignant, charged the Assembly with attempting to win for itself supreme +power, expressed his gratitude to his Ministers for their resistance to +this usurpation, and declared himself too confident in the loyalty of the +Prussian people to be intimidated by threats. His reply was followed by the +prorogation of the Assembly (May 26th). A dissolution would have been worse +than useless, for in the actual state of public opinion the Opposition +would probably have triumphed throughout the country. It only remained for +Bismarck to hold his ground, and, having silenced the Parliament for a +while, to silence the Press also by the exercise of autocratic power. The +Constitution authorised the King, in the absence of the Chambers, to +publish enactments on matters of urgency having the force of laws. No +sooner had the session been closed than an edict was issued empowering the +Government, without resort to courts of law, to suppress any newspaper +after two warnings. An outburst of public indignation branded this return +to the principles of pure despotism in Prussia; but neither King nor +Minister was to be diverted by threats or by expostulations from his +course. The Press was effectively silenced. So profound, however, was the +distrust now everywhere felt as to the future of Prussia, and so deep the +resentment against the Minister in all circles where Liberal influences +penetrated, that the Crown Prince himself, after in vain protesting against +a policy of violence which endangered his own prospective interests in the +Crown, publicly expressed his disapproval of the action of Government. For +this offence he was never forgiven. + +[Austria from 1859.] + +The course which affairs were taking at Berlin excited the more bitter +regret and disappointment among all friends of Prussia as at this very time +it seemed that constitutional government was being successfully established +in the western part of the Austrian Empire. The centralised military +despotism with which Austria emerged from the convulsions of 1848 had been +allowed ten years of undisputed sway; at the end of this time it had +brought things to such a pass that, after a campaign in which there had +been but one great battle, and while still in possession of a vast army and +an unbroken chain of fortresses, Austria stood powerless to move hand or +foot. It was not the defeat of Solferino or the cession of Lombardy that +exhibited the prostration of Austria's power, but the fact that while the +conditions of the Peace of Zuerich were swept away, and Italy was united +under Victor Emmanuel in defiance of the engagements made by Napoleon III. +at Villafranca, the Austrian Emperor was compelled to look on with folded +arms. To have drawn the sword again, to have fired a shot in defence of the +Pope's temporal power or on behalf of the vassal princes of Tuscany and +Modena, would have been to risk the existence of the Austrian monarchy. The +State was all but bankrupt; rebellion might at any moment break out in +Hungary, which had already sent thousands of soldiers to the Italian camp. +Peace at whatever price was necessary abroad, and at home the system of +centralised despotism could no longer exist, come what might in its place. +It was natural that the Emperor should but imperfectly understand at the +first the extent of the concessions which it was necessary for him to make. +He determined that the Provincial Councils which Schwarzenberg had promised +in 1850 should be called into existence, and that a Council of the Empire +(Reichsrath), drawn in part from these, should assemble at Vienna, to +advise, though not to control, the Government in matters of finance. So +urgent, however, were the needs of the exchequer, that the Emperor +proceeded at once to the creation of the Central Council, and nominated its +first members himself. (March, 1860.) + +[Hungary.] + +[Centralists and Federalists in the Council.] + +[The Diploma of Oct 20, 1860.] + +That the Hungarian members nominated by the Emperor would decline to appear +at Vienna unless some further guarantee was given for the restoration of +Hungarian liberty was well known. The Emperor accordingly promised to +restore the ancient county-organisation, which had filled so great a space +in Hungarian history before 1848, and to take steps for assembling the +Hungarian Diet. This, with the repeal of an edict injurious to the +Protestants, opened the way for reconciliation, and the nominated +Hungarians took their place in the Council, though under protest that the +existing arrangement could only be accepted as preparatory to the full +restitution of the rights of their country. The Council continued in +session during the summer of 1860. Its duties were financial; but the +establishment of financial equilibrium in Austria was inseparable from the +establishment of political stability and public confidence; and the +Council, in its last sittings, entered on the widest constitutional +problems. The non-German members were in the majority; and while all +parties alike condemned the fallen absolutism, the rival declarations of +policy submitted to the Council marked the opposition which was +henceforward to exist between the German Liberals of Austria and the +various Nationalist or Federalist groups. The Magyars, uniting with those +who had been their bitterest enemies, declared that the ancient +independence in legislation and administration of the several countries +subject to the House of Hapsburg must be restored, each country retaining +its own historical character. The German minority contended that the +Emperor should bestow upon his subjects such institutions as, while based +on the right of self-government should secure the unity of the Empire and +the force of its central authority. All parties were for a constitutional +system and for local liberties in one form or another; but while the +Magyars and their supporters sought for nothing less than national +independence, the Germans would at the most have granted a uniform system +of provincial self-government in strict subordination to a central +representative body drawn from the whole Empire and legislating for the +whole Empire. The decision of the Emperor was necessarily a compromise. By +a Diploma published on the 20th of October he promised to restore to +Hungary its old Constitution, and to grant wide legislative rights to the +other States of the Monarchy, establishing for the transaction of affairs +common to the whole Empire an Imperial Council, and reserving for the +non-Hungarian members of this Council a qualified right of legislation for +all the Empire except Hungary. [508] + +[Hungary resists the establishment of a Central Council.] + +The Magyars had conquered their King; and all the impetuous patriotism that +had been crushed down since the ruin of 1849 now again burst into flame. +The County Assemblies met, and elected as their officers men who had been +condemned to death in 1849 and who were living in exile; they swept away +the existing law-courts, refused the taxes, and proclaimed the legislation +of 1848 again in force. Francis Joseph seemed anxious to avert a conflict, +and to prove both in Hungary and in the other parts of the Empire the +sincerity of his promises of reform, on which the nature of the provincial +Constitutions which were published immediately after the Diploma of October +had thrown some doubt. At the instance of his Hungarian advisers he +dismissed the chief of his Cabinet, and called to office Schmerling, who, +in 1848, had been Prime Minister of the German National Government at +Frankfort. Schmerling at once promised important changes in the provincial +systems drawn up by his predecessor, but in his dealings with Hungary he +proved far less tractable than the Magyars had expected. If the Hungarians +had recovered their own constitutional forms, they still stood threatened +with the supremacy of a Central Council in all that related to themselves +in common with the rest of the Empire, and against this they rebelled. But +from the establishment of this Council of the Empire neither the Emperor +nor Schmerling would recede. An edict of February 26th, 1861, while it made +good the changes promised by Schmerling in the several provincial systems, +confirmed the general provisions of the Diploma of October, and declared +that the Emperor would maintain the Constitution of his dominions as now +established against an attack. + +[Conflict of Hungary with the Crown, 1861.] + +In the following April the Provincial Diets met throughout the Austrian +Empire, and the Diet of the Hungarian Kingdom assembled at Pesth. The first +duty of each of these bodies was to elect representatives to the Council of +the Empire which was to meet at Vienna. Neither Hungary nor Croatia, +however, would elect such representatives, each claiming complete +legislative independence, and declining to recognise any such external +authority as it was now proposed to create. The Emperor warned the +Hungarian Diet against the consequences of its action; but the national +spirit of the Magyars was thoroughly roused, and the County Assemblies vied +with one another in the violence of their addresses to the Sovereign. The +Diet, reviving the Constitutional difficulties connected with the +abdication of Ferdinand, declared that it would only negotiate for the +coronation of Francis Joseph after the establishment of a Hungarian +Ministry and the restoration of Croatia and Transylvania to the Hungarian +Kingdom. Accepting Schmerling's contention that the ancient constitutional +rights of Hungary had been extinguished by rebellion, the Emperor insisted +on the establishment of a Council for the whole Empire, and refused to +recede from the declarations which he had made in the edict of February. +The Diet hereupon protested, in a long and vigorous address to the King, +against the validity of all laws made without its own concurrence, and +declared that Francis Joseph had rendered an agreement between the King and +the nation impossible. A dissolution followed. The County Assemblies took +up the national struggle. They in their turn were suppressed; their +officers were dismissed, and military rule was established throughout the +land, though with explicit declarations on the part of the King that it was +to last only till the legally existing Constitution could be brought into +peaceful working. [509] + +[The Reichsrath at Vienna, May, 1861-Dec., 1862.] + +[Second session of the Reichsrath, 1863.] + +[The Reichsrath at Vienna, May, 1861-Dec., 1862.] + +[Second session of the Reichsrath, 1863.] + +Meanwhile the Central Representative Body, now by enlargement of its +functions and increase in the number of its members made into a Parliament +of the Empire, assembled at Vienna. Its real character was necessarily +altered by the absence of representatives from Hungary; and for some time +the Government seemed disposed to limit its competence to the affairs of +the Cis-Leithan provinces; but after satisfying himself that no accord with +Hungary was possible, the Emperor announced this fact to the Assembly, and +bade it perform its part as the organ of the Empire at large, without +regard to the abstention of those who did not choose to exercise their +rights. The Budget for the entire Empire was accordingly submitted to the +Assembly, and for the first time the expenditure of the Austrian State was +laid open to public examination and criticism. The first session of this +Parliament lasted, with adjournments, from May, 1861, to December, 1862. In +legislation it effected little, but its relations as a whole with the +Government remained excellent, and its long-continued activity, unbroken by +popular disturbances, did much to raise the fallen credit of the Austrian +State and to win for it the regard of Germany. On the close of the session +the Provincial Diets assembled, and throughout the spring of 1863 the +rivalry of the Austrian nationalities gave abundant animation to many a +local capital. In the next summer the Reichsrath reassembled at Vienna. +Though Hungary remained in a condition not far removed from rebellion, the +Parliamentary system of Austria was gaining in strength, and indeed, as it +seemed, at the expense of Hungary itself; for the Roumanian and German +population of Transylvania, rejoicing in the opportunity of detaching +themselves from the Magyars, now sent deputies to Vienna. While at Berlin +each week that passed sharpened the antagonism between the nation and its +Government, and made the Minister's name more odious, Austria seemed to +have successfully broken with the traditions of its past, and to be fast +earning for itself an honourable place among States of the constitutional +type. + +One of the reproaches brought against Bismarck by the Progressist majority +in the Parliament of Berlin was that he had isolated Prussia both in +Germany and in Europe. That he had roused against the Government of his +country the public opinion of Germany was true: that he had alienated +Prussia from all Europe was not the case; on the contrary, he had +established a closer relation between the Courts of Berlin and St. +Petersburg than had existed at any time since the commencement of the +Regency, and had secured for Prussia a degree of confidence and goodwill on +the part of the Czar which, in the memorable years that were to follow, +served it scarcely less effectively than an armed alliance. Russia, since +the Crimean War, had seemed to be entering upon an epoch of boundless +change. The calamities with which the reign of Nicholas had closed had +excited in that narrow circle of Russian society where thought had any +existence a vehement revulsion against the sterile and unchanging system of +repression, the grinding servitude of the last thirty years. From the +Emperor downwards all educated men believed not only that the system of +government, but that the whole order of Russian social life, must be +recast. The ferment of ideas which marks an age of revolution was in full +course; but in what forms the new order was to be moulded, through what +processes Russia was to be brought into its new life, no one knew. Russia +was wanting in capable statesmen; it was even more conspicuously wanting in +the class of serviceable and intelligent agents of Government of the second +rank. Its monarch, Alexander II., humane and well-meaning, was irresolute +and vacillating beyond the measure of ordinary men. He was not only devoid +of all administrative and organising faculty himself, but so infirm of +purpose that Ministers whose policy he had accepted feared to let him pass +out of their sight, lest in the course of a single journey or a single +interview he should succumb to the persuasions of some rival politician. In +no country in Europe was there such incoherence, such self-contradiction, +such absence of unity of plan and purpose in government as in Russia, where +all nominally depended upon a single will. Pressed and tormented by all the +rival influences that beat upon the centre of a great empire, Alexander +seems at times to have played off against one another as colleagues in the +same branch of Government the representatives of the most opposite schools +of action, and, after assenting to the plans of one group of advisers, to +have committed the execution of these plans, by way of counterpoise, to +those who had most opposed them. But, like other weak men, he dreaded +nothing so much as the reproach of weakness or inconstancy; and in the +cloud of half-formed or abandoned purposes there were some few to which he +resolutely adhered. The chief of these, the great achievement of his reign, +was the liberation of the serfs. + +[Liberation of the Serfs. March, 1861.] + +It was probably owing to the outbreak of the revolution of 1848 that the +serfs had not been freed by Nicholas. That sovereign had long understood +the necessity for the change, and in 1847 he had actually appointed a +Commission to report on the best means of effecting it. The convulsions of +1848, followed by the Hungarian and the Crimean Wars, threw the project +into the background during the remainder of Nicholas's reign; but if the +belief of the Russian people is well founded, the last injunction of the +dying Czar to his successor was to emancipate the serfs throughout his +empire. Alexander was little capable of grappling with so tremendous a +problem himself; in the year 1859, however, he directed a Commission to +make a complete inquiry into the subject, and to present a scheme of +emancipation. The labours of the Commission extended over two years; its +discussions were agitated, at times violent. That serfage must sooner or +later be abolished all knew; the points on which the Commission was divided +were the bestowal of land on the peasants and the regulation of the village +community. European history afforded abundant precedents in emancipation, +and under an infinite variety of detail three types of the process of +enfranchisement were clearly distinguishable from one another. Maria +Theresa, in liberating the serf, had required him to continue to render a +fixed amount of labour to his lord, and had given him on this condition +fixity of tenure in the land he occupied; the Prussian reformers had made a +division of the land between the peasant and the lord, and extinguished all +labour-dues; Napoleon, in enfranchising the serfs in the Duchy of Warsaw, +had simply turned them into free men, leaving the terms of their occupation +of land to be settled by arrangement or free contract with their former +lords. This example had been followed in the Baltic Provinces of Russia +itself by Alexander I. Of the three modes of emancipation, that based on +free contract had produced the worst results for the peasant; and though +many of the Russian landowners and their representatives in the Commission +protested against a division of the land between themselves and their serfs +as an act of agrarian revolution and spoliation, there were men in high +office, and some few among the proprietors, who resolutely and successfully +fought for the principle of independent ownership by the peasants. The +leading spirit in this great work appears to have been Nicholas Milutine, +Adjunct of the Minister of the Interior, Lanskoi. Milutine, who had drawn +up the Municipal Charta of St. Petersburg, was distrusted by the Czar as a +restless and uncompromising reformer. It was uncertain from day to day +whether the views of the Ministry of the Interior or those of the +territorial aristocracy would prevail; ultimately, however, under +instructions from the Palace, the Commission accepted not only the +principle of the division of the land, but the system of communal +self-government by the peasants themselves. The determination of the amount +of land to be held by the peasants of a commune and of the fixed rent to be +paid to the lord was left in the first instance to private agreement; but +where such agreement was not reached, the State, through arbiters elected +at local assemblies of the nobles, decided the matter itself. The rent once +fixed, the State enabled the commune to redeem it by advancing a capital +sum to be recouped by a quit-rent to the State extending over forty-nine +years. The Ukase of the Czar converting twenty-five millions of serfs into +free proprietors, the greatest act of legislation of modern times, was +signed on the 3rd of March, 1861, and within the next few weeks was read in +every church of the Russian Empire. It was a strange comment on the system +of government in Russia that in the very month in which the edict was +published both Lanskoi and Milutine, who had been its principal authors, +were removed from their posts. The Czar feared to leave them in power to +superintend the actual execution of the law which they had inspired. In +supporting them up to the final stage of its enactment Alexander had +struggled against misgivings of his own, and against influences of vast +strength alike at the Court, within the Government, and in the Provinces. +With the completion of the Edict of Emancipation his power of resistance +was exhausted, and its execution was committed by him to those who had been +its opponents. That some of the evils which have mingled with the good in +Russian enfranchisement might have been less had the Czar resolutely stood +by the authors of reform and allowed them to complete their work in +accordance with their own designs and convictions, is scarcely open to +doubt. [510] + +[Poland, 1861, 1862.] + +It had been the belief of educated men in Russia that the emancipation of +the serf would be but the first of a series of great organic changes, +bringing their country more nearly to the political and social level of its +European neighbours. This belief was not fulfilled. Work of importance was +done in the reconstruction of the judicial system of Russia, but in the +other reforms expected little was accomplished. An insurrection which broke +out in Poland at the beginning of 1863 diverted the energies of the +Government from all other objects; and in the overpowering outburst of +Russian patriotism and national feeling which it excited, domestic reforms, +no less than the ideals of Western civilisation, lost their interest. The +establishment of Italian independence, coinciding in time with the general +unsettlement and expectation of change which marked the first years of +Alexander's reign, had stirred once more the ill-fated hopes of the Polish +national leaders. From the beginning of the year 1861 Warsaw was the scene +of repeated tumults. The Czar was inclined, within certain limits, to a +policy of conciliation. The separate Legislature and separate army which +Poland had possessed from 1815 to 1830 he was determined not to restore; +but he was willing to give Poland a large degree of administrative +autonomy, to confide the principal offices in its Government to natives, +and generally to relax something of that close union with Russia which had +been enforced by Nicholas since the rebellion of 1831. But the concessions +of the Czar, accompanied as they were by acts of repression and severity, +were far from satisfying the demands of Polish patriotism. It was in vain +that Alexander in the summer of 1862 sent his brother Constantine as +Viceroy to Warsaw, established a Polish Council of State, placed a Pole, +Wielopolski, at the head of the Administration, superseded all the Russian +governors of Polish provinces by natives, and gave to the municipalities +and the districts the right of electing local councils; these concessions +seemed nothing, and were in fact nothing, in comparison with the national +independence which the Polish leaders claimed. The situation grew worse and +worse. An attempt made upon the life of the Grand Duke Constantine during +his entry into Warsaw was but one among a series of similar acts which +discredited the Polish cause and strengthened those who at St. Petersburg +had from the first condemned the Czar's attempts at conciliation. At length +the Russian Government took the step which precipitated revolt. A levy of +one in every two hundred of the population throughout the Empire had been +ordered in the autumn of 1862. Instructions were sent from St. Petersburg +to the effect that in raising this levy in Poland the country population +were to be spared, and that all persons who were known to be connected with +the disorders in the towns were to be seized as soldiers. This terrible +sentence against an entire political class was carried out, so far as it +lay within the power of the authorities, on the night of January 14th, +1863. But before the imperial press-gang surrounded the houses of its +victims a rumour of the intended blow had gone abroad. In the preceding +hours, and during the night of the 14th, thousands fled from Warsaw and the +other Polish towns into the forests. There they formed themselves into +armed bands, and in the course of the next few days a guerilla warfare +broke out wherever Russian troops were found in insufficient strength or +off their guard. [511] + +[Poland and Russia.] + +The classes in which the national spirit of Poland lived were the so-called +noblesse, numbering hundreds of thousands, the town populations, and the +priesthood. The peasants, crushed and degraded, though not nominally in +servitude, were indifferent to the national cause. On the neutrality, if +not on the support, of the peasants the Russian Government could fairly +reckon; within the towns it found itself at once confronted by an invisible +national Government whose decrees were printed and promulgated by unknown +hands, and whose sentences of death were mercilessly executed against those +whom it condemned as enemies or traitors to the national cause. So +extraordinary was the secrecy which covered the action of this National +Executive, that Milutine, who was subsequently sent by the Czar to examine +into the affairs of Poland, formed the conclusion that it had possessed +accomplices within the Imperial Government at St. Petersburg itself. The +Polish cause retained indeed some friends in Russia even after the outbreak +of the insurrection; it was not until the insurrection passed the frontier +of the kingdom and was carried by the nobles into Lithuania and Podolia +that the entire Russian nation took up the struggle with passionate and +vindictive ardour as one for life or death. It was the fatal bane of Polish +nationality that the days of its greatness had left it a claim upon vast +territories where it had planted nothing but a territorial aristocracy, and +where the mass of population, if not actually Russian, was almost +indistinguishable from the Russians in race and language, and belonged like +them to the Greek Church, which Catholic Poland had always persecuted. For +ninety years Lithuania and the border provinces had been incorporated with +the Czar's dominions, and with the exception of their Polish landowners +they were now in fact thoroughly Russian. When therefore the nobles of +these provinces declared that Poland must be reconstituted with the limits +of 1772, and subsequently took up arms in concert with the insurrectionary +Government at Warsaw, the Russian people, from the Czar to the peasant, +felt the struggle to be nothing less than one for the dismemberment or the +preservation of their own country, and the doom of Polish nationality, at +least for some generations, was sealed. The diplomatic intervention of the +Western Powers on behalf of the constitutional rights of Poland under the +Treaty of Vienna, which was to some extent supported by Austria, only +prolonged a hopeless struggle, and gave unbounded popularity to Prince +Gortschakoff, by whom, after a show of courteous attention during the +earlier and still perilous stage of the insurrection, the interference of +the Powers was resolutely and unconditionally repelled. By the spring of +1864 the insurgents were crushed or exterminated. General Muravieff, the +Governor of Lithuania, fulfilled his task against the mutinous nobles of +this province with unshrinking severity, sparing neither life nor fortune +so long as an enemy of Russia remained to be overthrown. It was at Wilna, +the Lithuanian capital, not at Warsaw, that the terrors of Russian +repression were the greatest. Muravieff's executions may have been less +numerous than is commonly supposed; but in the form of pecuniary +requisitions and fines he undoubtedly aimed at nothing less than the utter +ruin of a great part of the class most implicated in the rebellion. + +[Agrarian measures in Poland.] + +[Agrarian measures in Poland, 1864.] + +In Poland itself the Czar, after some hesitation, determined once and for +all to establish a friend to Russia in every homestead of the kingdom by +making the peasant owner of the land on which he laboured. The +insurrectionary Government at the outbreak of the rebellion had attempted +to win over the peasantry by promising enactments to this effect, but no +one had responded to their appeal. In the autumn of 1863 the Czar recalled +Milutine from his enforced travels and directed him to proceed to Warsaw, +in order to study the affairs of Poland on the spot, and to report on the +measures necessary to be taken for its future government and organisation. +Milutine obtained the assistance of some of the men who had laboured most +earnestly with him in the enfranchisement of the Russian serfs; and in the +course of a few weeks he returned to St. Petersburg, carrying with him the +draft of measures which were to change the face of Poland. He recommended +on the one hand that every political institution separating Poland from the +rest of the Empire should be swept away, and the last traces of Polish +independence utterly obliterated; on the other hand, that the peasants, as +the only class on which Russia could hope to count in the future, should be +made absolute and independent owners of the land they occupied. Prince +Gortschakoff, who had still some regard for the opinion of Western Europe, +and possibly some sympathy for the Polish aristocracy, resisted this daring +policy; but the Czar accepted Milutine's counsel, and gave him a free hand +in the execution of his agrarian scheme. The division of the land between +the nobles and the peasants was accordingly carried out by Milutine's own +officers under conditions very different from those adopted in Russia. The +whole strength of the Government was thrown on to the side of the peasant +and against the noble. Though the population was denser in Poland than in +Russia, the peasant received on an average four times as much land; the +compensation made to the lords (which was paid in bonds which immediately +fell to half their nominal value) was raised not by quit-rents on the +peasants' lands alone, as in Russia, but by a general land-tax falling +equally on the land left to the lords, who had thus to pay a great part of +their own compensation: above all, the questions in dispute were settled, +not as in Russia by arbiters elected at local assemblies of the nobles, but +by officers of the Crown. Moreover, the division of landed property was not +made once and for all, as in Russia, but the woods and pastures remaining +to the lords continued subject to undefined common-rights of the peasants. +These common-rights were deliberately left unsettled in order that a source +of contention might always be present between the greater and the lesser +proprietors, and that the latter might continue to look to the Russian +Government as the protector or extender of their interests. "We hold +Poland," said a Russian statesman, "by its rights of common." [512] + +[Russia and Polish nationality.] + +Milutine, who, with all the fiery ardour of his national and levelling +policy, seems to have been a gentle and somewhat querulous invalid, and who +was shortly afterwards struck down by paralysis, to remain a helpless +spectator of the European changes of the next six years, had no share in +that warfare against the language, the religion, and the national culture +of Poland with which Russia has pursued its victory since 1863. The public +life of Poland he was determined to Russianise; its private and social life +he would probably have left unmolested, relying on the goodwill of the +great mass of peasants who owed their proprietorship to the action of the +Czar. There were, however, politicians at Moscow and St. Petersburg who +believed that the deep-lying instinct of nationality would for the first +time be called into real life among these peasants by their very elevation +from misery to independence, and that where Russia had hitherto had three +hundred thousand enemies Milutine was preparing for it six millions. It was +the dread of this possibility in the future, the apprehension that material +interests might not permanently vanquish the subtler forces which pass from +generation to generation, latent, if still unconscious, where nationality +itself is not lost, that made the Russian Government follow up the +political destruction of the Polish noblesse by measures directed against +Polish nationality itself, even at the risk of alienating the class who for +the present were effectively won over to the Czar's cause. By the side of +its life-giving and beneficent agrarian policy Russia has pursued the +odious system of debarring Poland from all means of culture and improvement +associated with the use of its own language, and has aimed at eventually +turning the Poles into Russians by the systematic impoverishment and +extinction of all that is essentially Polish in thought, in sentiment, and +in expression. The work may prove to be one not beyond its power; and no +common perversity on the part of its Government would be necessary to turn +against Russia the millions who in Poland owe all they have of prosperity +and independence to the Czar: but should the excess of Russian +propagandism, or the hostility of Church to Church, at some distant date +engender a new struggle for Polish independence, this struggle will be one +governed by other conditions than those of 1831 or 1863, and Russia will, +for the first time, have to conquer on the Vistula not a class nor a city, +but a nation. + +[Berlin and St. Petersburg, 1863.] + +It was a matter of no small importance to Bismarck and to Prussia that in +the years 1863 and 1864 the Court of St. Petersburg found itself confronted +with affairs of such seriousness in Poland. From the opportunity which was +then presented to him of obliging an important neighbour, and of profiting +by that neighbour's conjoined embarrassment and goodwill, Bismarck drew +full advantage. He had always regarded the Poles as a mere nuisance in +Europe, and heartily despised the Germans for the sympathy which they had +shown towards Poland in 1848. When the insurrection of 1863 broke out, +Bismarck set the policy of his own country in emphatic contrast with that +of Austria and the Western Powers, and even entered into an arrangement +with Russia for an eventual military combination in case the insurgents +should pass from one side to the other of the frontier. [513] Throughout +the struggle with the Poles, and throughout the diplomatic conflict with +the Western Powers, the Czar had felt secure in the loyalty of the stubborn +Minister at Berlin; and when, at the close of the Polish revolt, the events +occurred which opened to Prussia the road to political fortune, Bismarck +received his reward in the liberty of action given him by the Russian +Government. The difficulties connected with Schleswig-Holstein, which, +after a short interval of tranquillity following the settlement of 1852, +had again begun to trouble Europe, were forced to the very front of +Continental affairs by the death of Frederick VII., King of Denmark, in +November, 1863. Prussia had now at its head a statesman resolved to pursue +to their extreme limit the chances which this complication offered to his +own country; and, more fortunate than his predecessors of 1848, Bismarck +had not to dread the interference of the Czar of Russia as the patron and +protector of the interests of the Danish court. + +[Schleswig-Holstein, 1852-1863.] + +[The Patent of March 30, 1863.] + +By the Treaty of London, signed on May 8th, 1852, all the great Powers, +including Prussia, had recognised the principle of the integrity of the +Danish Monarchy, and had pronounced Prince Christian of Gluecksburg to be +heir-presumptive to the whole dominions of the reigning King. The rights of +the German Federation in Holstein were nevertheless declared to remain +unprejudiced; and in a Convention made with Austria and Prussia before they +joined in this Treaty, King Frederick VII. had undertaken to conform to +certain rules in his treatment of Schleswig as well as of Holstein. The +Duke of Augustenburg, claimant to the succession in Schleswig-Holstein +through the male line, had renounced his pretensions in consideration of an +indemnity paid to him by the King of Denmark. This surrender, however, had +not received the consent of his son and of the other members of the House +of Augustenburg, nor had the German Federation, as such, been a party to +the Treaty of London. Relying on the declaration of the Great Powers in +favour of the integrity of the Danish Kingdom, Frederick VII. had resumed +his attempts to assimilate Schleswig, and in some degree Holstein, to the +rest of the Monarchy; and although the Provincial Estates were allowed to +remain in existence, a national Constitution was established in October, +1855, for the entire Danish State. Bitter complaints were made of the +system of repression and encroachment with which the Government of +Copenhagen was attempting to extinguish German nationality in the border +provinces; at length, in November, 1858, under threat of armed intervention +by the German Federation, Frederick consented to exclude Holstein from the +operation of the new Constitution. But this did not produce peace, for the +inhabitants of Schleswig, severed from the sister-province and now excited +by the Italian war, raised all the more vigorous a protest against their +own incorporation with Denmark; while in Holstein itself the Government +incurred the charge of unconstitutional action in fixing the Budget without +the consent of the Estates. The German Federal Diet again threatened to +resort to force, and Denmark prepared for war. Prussia took up the cause of +Schleswig in 1861; and even the British Government, which had hitherto +shown far more interest in the integrity of Denmark than in the rights of +the German provinces, now recommended that the Constitution of 1855 should +be abolished, and that a separate legislation and administration should be +granted to Schleswig as well as to Holstein. The Danes, however, were bent +on preserving Schleswig as an integral part of the State, and the +Government of King Frederick, while willing to recognise Holstein as +outside Danish territory proper, insisted that Schleswig should be included +within the unitary Constitution, and that Holstein should contribute a +fixed share to the national expenditure. A manifesto to this effect, +published by King Frederick on the 30th of March, 1863, was the immediate +ground of the conflict now about to break out between Germany and Denmark. +The Diet of Frankfort announced that if this proclamation were not revoked +it should proceed to Federal execution, that is, armed intervention, +against the King of Denmark as Duke of Holstein. Still counting upon +foreign aid or upon the impotence of the Diet, the Danish Government +refused to change its policy, and on the 29th of September laid before the +Parliament at Copenhagen the law incorporating Schleswig with the rest of +the Monarchy under the new Constitution. Negotiations were thus brought to +a close, and on the 1st of October the Diet decreed the long-threatened +Federal execution. [514] + +[Death of Frederick VII., November, 1863.] + +[Federal execution in Holstein. December, 1863.] + +Affairs had reached this stage, and the execution had not yet been put in +force, when, on the 15th of November, King Frederick VII. died. For a +moment it appeared possible that his successor, Prince Christian of +Gluecksburg, might avert the conflict with Germany by withdrawing from the +position which his predecessor had taken up. But the Danish people and +Ministry were little inclined to give way; the Constitution had passed +through Parliament two days before King Frederick's death, and on the 18th +of November it received the assent of the new monarch. German national +feeling was now as strongly excited on the question of Schleswig-Holstein +as it had been in 1848. The general cry was that the union of these +provinces with Denmark must be treated as at an end, and their legitimate +ruler, Frederick of Augustenburg, son of the Duke who had renounced his +rights, be placed on the throne. The Diet of Frankfort, however, decided to +recognise neither of the two rival sovereigns in Holstein until its own +intervention should have taken place. Orders were given that a Saxon and a +Hanoverian corps should enter the country; and although Prussia and Austria +had made a secret agreement that the settlement of the Schleswig-Holstein +question was to be conducted by themselves independently of the Diet, the +tide of popular enthusiasm ran so high that for the moment the two leading +Powers considered it safer not to obstruct the Federal authority, and the +Saxon and Hanoverian troops accordingly entered Holstein as mandatories of +the Diet at the end of 1863. The Danish Government, offering no resistance, +withdrew its troops across the river Eider into Schleswig. + +[Plans of Bismarck.] + +[Union of Austria and Prussia.] + +[Austrian and Prussian troops enter Schleswig. Feb., 1864.] + +From this time the history of Germany is the history of the profound and +audacious statecraft and of the overmastering will of Bismarck; the nation, +except through its valour on the battle-field, ceases to influence the +shaping of its own fortunes. What the German people desired in 1864 was +that Schleswig-Holstein should be attached, under a ruler of its own, to +the German Federation as it then existed; what Bismarck intended was that +Schleswig-Holstein, itself incorporated more or less directly with Prussia, +should be made the means of the destruction of the existing Federal system +and of the expulsion of Austria from Germany. That another petty State, +bound to Prussia by no closer tie than its other neighbours, should be +added to the troop among whom Austria found its vassals and its +instruments, would have been in Bismarck's eyes no gain but actual +detriment to Germany. The German people desired one course of action; +Bismarck had determined on something totally different; and with matchless +resolution and skill he bore down all opposition of people and of Courts, +and forced a reluctant nation to the goal which he had himself chosen for +it. The first point of conflict was the apparent recognition by Bismarck of +the rights of King Christian IX. as lawful sovereign in the Duchies as well +as in the rest of the Danish State. By the Treaty of London Prussia had +indeed pledged itself to this recognition; but the German Federation had +been no party to the Treaty, and under the pressure of a vehement national +agitation Bavaria and the minor States one after another recognised +Frederick of Augustenburg as Duke of Schleswig-Holstein. Bismarck was +accused alike by the Prussian Parliament and by the popular voice of +Germany at large of betraying German interests to Denmark, of abusing +Prussia's position as a Great Power, of inciting the nation to civil war. +In vain he declared that, while surrendering no iota of German rights, the +Government of Berlin must recognise those treaty-obligations with which its +own legal title to a voice in the affairs of Schleswig was intimately bound +up, and that the King of Prussia, not a multitude of irresponsible and +ill-informed citizens, must be the judge of the measures by which German +interests were to be effectually protected. His words made no single +convert either in the Prussian Parliament or in the Federal Diet. At +Frankfort the proposal made by the two leading Powers that King Christian +should be required to annul the November Constitution, and that in case of +his refusal Schleswig also should be occupied, was rejected, as involving +an acknowledgment of the title of Christian as reigning sovereign. At +Berlin the Lower Chamber refused the supplies which Bismarck demanded for +operations in the Duchies, and formally resolved to resist his policy by +every means at its command. But the resistance of Parliament and of Diet +were alike in vain. By a masterpiece of diplomacy Bismarck had secured the +support and co-operation of Austria in his own immediate Danish policy, +though but a few months before he had incurred the bitter hatred of the +Court of Vienna by frustrating its plans for a reorganisation of Germany by +a Congress of princes at Frankfort, and had frankly declared to the +Austrian ambassador at Berlin that if Austria did not transfer its +political centre to Pesth and leave to Prussia free scope in Germany, it +would find Prussia on the side of its enemies in the next war in which it +might be engaged. [515] But the democratic and impassioned character of the +agitation in the minor States in favour of the Schleswig-Holsteiners and +their Augustenburg pretender had enabled Bismarck to represent this +movement to the Austrian Government as a revolutionary one, and by a +dexterous appeal to the memories of 1848 to awe the Emperor's advisers into +direct concert with the Court of Berlin, as the representative of +monarchical order, in dealing with a problem otherwise too likely to be +solved by revolutionary methods and revolutionary forces. Count Rechberg, +the Foreign Minister at Vienna, was lured into a policy which, after +drawing upon Austria a full share of the odium of Bismarck's Danish plans, +after forfeiting for it the goodwill of the minor States with which it +might have kept Prussia in check, and exposing it to the risk of a European +war, was to confer upon its rival the whole profit of the joint enterprise, +and to furnish a pretext for the struggle by which Austria was to be +expelled alike from Germany and from what remained to it of Italy. But of +the nature of the toils into which he was now taking the first fatal and +irrevocable step Count Rechberg appears to have had no suspicion. A seeming +cordiality united the Austrian and Prussian Governments in the policy of +defiance to the will of all the rest of Germany and to the demands of their +own subjects. It was to no purpose that the Federal Diet vetoed the +proposed summons to King Christian and the proposed occupation of +Schleswig. Austria and Prussia delivered an ultimatum at Copenhagen +demanding the repeal of the November Constitution; and on its rejection +their troops entered Schleswig, not as the mandatories of the German +Federation, but as the instruments of two independent and allied Powers. +(Feb. 1, 1864.) + +[Campaign in Schleswig. Feb.-April, 1864.] + +Against the overwhelming forces by which they were thus attacked the Danes +could only make a brave but ineffectual resistance. Their first line of +defence was the Danewerke, a fortification extending east and west towards +the sea from the town of Schleswig. Prince Frederick Charles, who commanded +the Prussian right, was repulsed in an attack upon the easternmost part of +this work at Missunde; the Austrians, however, carried some positions in +the centre which commanded the defenders' lines, and the Danes fell back +upon the fortified post of Dueppel, covering the narrow channel which +separates the island of Alsen from the mainland. Here for some weeks they +held the Prussians in check, while the Austrians, continuing the march +northwards, entered Jutland. At length, on the 18th of April, after several +hours of heavy bombardment, the lines of Dueppel were taken by storm and the +defenders driven across the channel into Alsen. Unable to pursue the enemy +across this narrow strip of sea, the Prussians joined their allies in +Jutland, and occupied the whole of the Danish mainland as far as the Luem +Fiord. The war, however, was not to be terminated without an attempt on the +part of the neutral Powers to arrive at a settlement by diplomacy. A +Conference was opened at London on the 20th of April, and after three weeks +of negotiation the belligerents were induced to accept an armistice. As the +troops of the German Federation, though unconcerned in the military +operations of the two Great Powers, were in possession of Holstein, the +Federal Government was invited to take part in the Conference. It was +represented by Count Beust, Prime Minister of Saxony, a politician who was +soon to rise to much greater eminence; but in consequence of the diplomatic +union of Prussia and Austria the views entertained by the Governments of +the secondary German States had now no real bearing on the course of +events, and Count Beust's earliest appearance on the great European stage +was without result, except in its influence on his own career. [516] + +[Conference of London. April, 1864.] + +The first proposition laid before the Conference was that submitted by +Bernstorff, the Prussian envoy, to the effect that Schleswig-Holstein +should receive complete independence, the question whether King Christian +or some other prince should be sovereign of the new State being reserved +for future settlement. To this the Danish envoys replied that even on the +condition of personal union with Denmark through the Crown they could not +assent to the grant of complete independence to the Duchies. Raising their +demand in consequence of this refusal, and declaring that the war had made +an end of the obligations subsisting under the London Treaty of 1852, the +two German Powers then demanded that Schleswig-Holstein should be +completely separated from Denmark and formed into a single State under +Frederick of Augustenburg, who in the eyes of Germany possessed the best +claim to the succession. Lord Russell, while denying that the acts or +defaults of Denmark could liberate Austria and Prussia from their +engagements made with other Powers in the Treaty of London, admitted that +no satisfactory result was likely to arise from the continued union of the +Duchies with Denmark, and suggested that King Christian should make an +absolute cession of Holstein and of the southern part of Schleswig, +retaining the remainder in full sovereignty. The frontier-line he proposed +to draw at the River Schlei. To this principle of partition both Denmark +and the German Powers assented, but it proved impossible to reach an +agreement on the frontier-line. Bernstorff, who had at first required +nearly all Schleswig, abated his demands, and would have accepted a line +drawn westward from Flensburg, so leaving to Denmark at least half the +province, including the important position of Dueppel. The terms thus +offered to Denmark were not unfavourable. Holstein it did not expect, and +could scarcely desire, to retain; and the territory which would have been +taken from it in Schleswig under this arrangement included few districts +that were not really German. But the Government of Copenhagen, misled by +the support given to it at the Conference by England and Russia--a support +which was one of words only--refused to cede anything north of the town of +Schleswig. Even when in the last resort Lord Russell proposed that the +frontier-line should be settled by arbitration the Danish Government held +fast to its refusal, and for the sake of a few miles of territory plunged +once more into a struggle which, if it was not to kindle a European war of +vast dimensions, could end only in the ruin of the Danes. The expected help +failed them. Attacked and overthrown in the island of Alsen, the German +flag carried to the northern extremity of their mainland, they were +compelled to make peace on their enemies' terms. Hostilities were brought +to a close by the signature of Preliminaries on the 1st of August; and by +the Treaty of Vienna, concluded on the 30th of October, 1864, King +Christian ceded his rights in the whole of Schleswig-Holstein to the +sovereigns of Austria and Prussia jointly, and undertook to recognise +whatever dispositions they might make of those provinces. + +[Great Britain and Napoleon III.] + +The British Government throughout this conflict had played a sorry part, at +one moment threatening the Germans, at another using language towards the +Danes which might well be taken to indicate an intention of lending them +armed support. To some extent the errors of the Cabinet were due to the +relation which existed between Great Britain and Napoleon III. It had up to +this time been considered both at London and at Paris that the Allies of +the Crimea had still certain common interests in Europe; and in the +unsuccessful intervention at St. Petersburg on behalf of Poland in 1863 the +British and French Governments had at first gone hand in hand. But behind +every step openly taken by Napoleon III. there was some half-formed design +for promoting the interests of his dynasty or extending the frontiers of +France; and if England had consented to support the diplomatic concert at +St. Petersburg by measures of force, it would have found itself engaged in +a war in which other ends than those relating to Poland would have been the +foremost. Towards the close of the year 1863 Napoleon had proposed that a +European Congress should assemble, in order to regulate not only the +affairs of Poland but all those European questions which remained +unsettled. This proposal had been abruptly declined by the English +Government; and when in the course of the Danish war Lord Palmerston showed +an inclination to take up arms if France would do the same, Napoleon was +probably not sorry to have the opportunity of repaying England for its +rejection of his own overtures in the previous year. He had moreover hopes +of obtaining from Prussia an extension of the French frontier either in +Belgium or towards the Rhine. [517] In reply to overtures from London, +Napoleon stated that the cause of Schleswig-Holstein to some extent +represented the principle of nationality, to which France was friendly, and +that of all wars in which France could engage a war with Germany would be +the least desirable. England accordingly, if it took up arms for the Danes, +would have been compelled to enter the war alone; and although at a later +time, when the war was over and the victors were about to divide the spoil, +the British and French fleets ostentatiously combined in manoeuvres at +Cherbourg, this show of union deceived no one, least of all the resolute +and well-informed director of affairs at Berlin. To force, and force alone, +would Bismarck have yielded. Palmerston, now sinking into old age, +permitted Lord Russell to parody his own fierce language of twenty years +back; but all the world, except the Danes, knew that the fangs and the +claws were drawn, and that British foreign policy had become for the time a +thing of snarls and grimaces. + +[Intentions of Bismarck as to Schleswig-Holstein.] + +Bismarck had not at first determined actually to annex Schleswig-Holstein +to Prussia. He would have been content to leave it under the nominal +sovereignty of Frederick of Augustenburg if that prince would have placed +the entire military and naval resources of Schleswig-Holstein under the +control of the Government of Berlin, and have accepted on behalf of his +Duchies conditions which Bismarck considered indispensable to German +union under Prussian leadership. In the harbour of Kiel it was not +difficult to recognise the natural headquarters of a future German fleet; +the narrow strip of land projecting between the two seas naturally +suggested the formation of a canal connecting the Baltic with the German +Ocean, and such a work could only belong to Germany at large or to its +leading Power. Moreover, as a frontier district, Schleswig-Holstein was +peculiarly exposed to foreign attack; certain strategical positions +necessary for its defence must therefore be handed over to its protector. +That Prussia should have united its forces with Austria in order to win +for the Schleswig-Holsteiners the power of governing themselves as they +pleased, must have seemed to Bismarck a supposition in the highest degree +preposterous. He had taken up the cause of the Duchies not in the +interest of the inhabitants but in the interest of Germany; and by +Germany he understood Germany centred at Berlin and ruled by the House of +Hohenzollern. If therefore the Augustenburg prince was not prepared to +accept his throne on these terms, there was no room for him, and the +provinces must be incorporated with Prussia itself. That Austria would +not without compensation permit the Duchies thus to fall directly or +indirectly under Prussian sway was of course well known to Bismarck; but +so far was this from causing him any hesitation in his policy, that from +the first he had discerned in the Schleswig-Holstein question a favourable +pretext for the war which was to drive Austria out of Germany. + +[Relations of Prussia and Austria, Dec., 1854-Aug., 1865.] + +[Convention of Gastein, Aug. 14, 1865.] + +Peace with Denmark was scarcely concluded when, at the bidding of Prussia, +reluctantly supported by Austria, the Saxon and Hanoverian troops which had +entered Holstein as the mandatories of the Federal Diet were compelled to +leave the country. A Provisional Government was established under the +direction of an Austrian and a Prussian Commissioner. Bismarck had met the +Prince of Augustenburg at Berlin some months before, and had formed an +unfavourable opinion of the policy likely to be adopted by him towards +Prussia. All Germany, however, was in favour of the Prince's claims, and at +the Conference of London these claims had been supported by the Prussian +envoy himself. In order to give some appearance of formal legality to his +own action, Bismarck had to obtain from the Crown-jurists of Prussia a +decision that King Christian IX. had, contrary to the general opinion of +Germany, been the lawful inheritor of Schleswig-Holstein, and that the +Prince of Augustenburg had therefore no rights whatever in the Duchies. As +the claims of Christian had been transferred by the Treaty of Vienna to the +sovereigns of Austria and Prussia jointly, it rested with them to decide +who should be Duke of Schleswig-Holstein, and under what conditions. +Bismarck announced at Vienna on the 22nd of February, 1865, the terms on +which he was willing that Schleswig-Holstein should be conferred by the two +sovereigns upon Frederick of Augustenburg. He required, in addition to +community of finance, postal system, and railways, that Prussian law, +including the obligation to military service, should be introduced into the +Duchies; that their regiments should take the oath of fidelity to the King +of Prussia, and that their principal military positions should be held by +Prussian troops. These conditions would have made Schleswig-Holstein in all +but name a part of the Prussian State: they were rejected both by the Court +of Vienna and by Prince Frederick himself, and the population of +Schleswig-Holstein almost unanimously declared against them. Both Austria +and the Federal Diet now supported the Schleswig-Holsteiners in what +appeared to be a struggle on behalf of their independence against Prussian +domination; and when the Prussian Commissioner in Schleswig-Holstein +expelled the most prominent of the adherents of Augustenburg, his Austrian +colleague published a protest declaring the act to be one of lawless +violence. It seemed that the outbreak of war between the two rival Powers +could not long be delayed; but Bismarck had on this occasion moved too +rapidly for his master, and considerations relating to the other European +Powers made it advisable to postpone the rupture for some months. An +agreement was patched up at Gastein by which, pending an ultimate +settlement, the government of the two provinces was divided between their +masters, Austria taking the administration of Holstein, Prussia that of +Schleswig, while the little district of Lauenburg on the south was made +over to King William in full sovereignty. An actual conflict between the +representatives of the two rival governments at their joint headquarters in +Schleswig-Holstein was thus averted; peace was made possible at least for +some months longer; and the interval was granted to Bismarck which was +still required for the education of his Sovereign in the policy of blood +and iron, and for the completion of his own arrangements with the enemies +of Austria outside Germany. [518] + +[Bismarck at Biarritz, Sept., 1865.] + +The natural ally of Prussia was Italy; but without the sanction of Napoleon +III. it would have been difficult to engage Italy in a new war. Bismarck +had therefore to gain at least the passive concurrence of the French +Emperor in the union of Italy and Prussia against Austria. He visited +Napoleon at Biarritz in September, 1865, and returned with the object of +his journey achieved. The negotiation of Biarritz, if truthfully recorded, +would probably give the key to much of the European history of the next +five years. As at Plombieres, the French Emperor acted without his +Ministers, and what he asked he asked without a witness. That Bismarck +actually promised to Napoleon III. either Belgium or any part of the +Rhenish Provinces in case of the aggrandisement of Prussia has been denied +by him, and is not in itself probable. But there are understandings which +prove to be understandings on one side only; politeness may be +misinterpreted; and the world would have found Count Bismarck unendurable +if at every friendly meeting he had been guilty of the frankness with which +he informed the Austrian Government that its centre of action must be +transferred from Vienna to Pesth. That Napoleon was now scheming for an +extension of France on the north-east is certain; that Bismarck treated +such rectification of the frontier as a matter for arrangement is hardly to +be doubted; and if without a distinct and written agreement Napoleon was +content to base his action on the belief that Bismarck would not withhold +from him his reward, this only proved how great was the disparity between +the aims which the French ruler allowed himself to cherish and his mastery +of the arts by which alone such aims were to be realised. Napoleon desired +to see Italy placed in possession of Venice; he probably believed at this +time that Austria would be no unequal match for Prussia and Italy together, +and that the natural result of a well-balanced struggle would be not only +The completion of Italian union but the purchase of French neutrality or +mediation by the cession of German territory west of the Rhine. It was no +part of the duty of Count Bismarck to chill Napoleon's fancies or to teach +him political wisdom. The Prussian statesman may have left Biarritz with +the conviction that an attack on Germany would sooner or later follow the +disappointment of those hopes which he had flattered and intended to mock; +but for the present he had removed one dangerous obstacle from his path, +and the way lay free before him to an Italian alliance if Italy itself +should choose to combine with him in war. + +[Italy, 1862-65.] + +Since the death of Cavour the Italian Government had made no real progress +towards the attainment of the national aims, the acquisition of Rome and +Venice. Garibaldi, impatient of delay, had in 1862 landed again in Sicily +and summoned his followers to march with him upon Rome. But the enterprise +was resolutely condemned by Victor Emmanuel, and when Garibaldi crossed to +the mainland he found the King's troops in front of him at Aspromonte. +There was an exchange of shots, and Garibaldi fell wounded. He was treated +with something of the distinction shown to a royal prisoner, and when his +wound was healed he was released from captivity. His enterprise, however, +and the indiscreet comments on it made by Rattazzi, who was now in power, +strengthened the friends of the Papacy at the Tuileries, and resulted in +the fall of the Italian Minister. His successor, Minghetti, deemed it +necessary to arrive at some temporary understanding with Napoleon on the +Roman question. The presence of French troops at Rome offended national +feeling, and made any attempt at conciliation between the Papal Court and +the Italian Government hopeless. In order to procure the removal of this +foreign garrison Minghetti was willing to enter into engagements which +seemed almost to imply the renunciation of the claim on Rome. By a +Convention made in September, 1864, the Italian Government undertook not to +attack the territory of the Pope, and to oppose by force every attack made +upon it from without. Napoleon on his part engaged to withdraw his troops +gradually from Rome as the Pope should organise his own army, and to +complete the evacuation within two years. It was, however, stipulated in an +Article which was intended to be kept secret, that the capital of Italy +should be changed, the meaning of this stipulation being that Florence +should receive the dignity which by the common consent of Italy ought to +have been transferred from Turin to Rome and to Rome alone. The publication +of this Article, which was followed by riots in Turin, caused the immediate +fall of Minghetti's Cabinet. He was succeeded in office by General La +Marmora, under whom the negotiations with Prussia were begun which, after +long uncertainty, resulted in the alliance of 1866 and in the final +expulsion of Austria from Italy. [519] + +[La Marmora.] + +[Govone at Berlin, March, 1866.] + +[Treaty of April 8, 1856.] + +Bismarck from the beginning of his Ministry appears to have looked forward +to the combination of Italy and Prussia against the common enemy; but his +plans ripened slowly. In the spring of 1865, when affairs seemed to be +reaching a crisis in Schleswig-Holstein, the first serious overtures were +made by the Prussian ambassador at Florence. La Marmora answered that any +definite proposition would receive the careful attention of the Italian +Government, but that Italy would not permit itself to be made a mere +instrument in Prussia's hands for the intimidation of Austria. Such caution +was both natural and necessary on the part of the Italian Minister; and his +reserve seemed to be more than justified when, a few months later, the +Treaty of Gastein restored Austria and Prussia to relations of friendship. +La Marmora might now well consider himself released from all obligations +towards the Court of Berlin: and, entering on a new line of policy, he sent +an envoy to Vienna to ascertain if the Emperor would amicably cede Venetia +to Italy in return for the payment of a very large sum of money and the +assumption by Italy of part of the Austrian national debt. Had this +transaction been effected, it would probably have changed the course of +European history; the Emperor, however, declined to bargain away any part +of his dominions, and so threw Italy once more into the camp of his great +enemy. In the meantime the disputes about Schleswig-Holstein broke out +afresh. Bismarck renewed his efforts at Florence in the spring of 1866, +with the result that General Govone was sent to Berlin in order to discuss +with the Prussian Minister the political and military conditions of an +alliance. But instead of proposing immediate action, Bismarck stated to +Govone that the question of Schleswig-Holstein was insufficient to justify +a great war in the eyes of Europe, and that a better cause must be put +forward, namely, the reform of the Federal system of Germany. Once more the +subtle Italians believed that Bismarck's anxiety for a war with Austria was +feigned, and that he sought their friendship only as a means of extorting +from the Court of Vienna its consent to Prussia's annexation of the Danish +Duchies. There was an apparent effort on the part of the Prussian statesman +to avoid entering into any engagement which involved immediate action; the +truth being that Bismarck was still in conflict with the pacific influences +which surrounded the King, and uncertain from day to day whether his master +would really follow him in the policy of war. He sought therefore to make +the joint resort to arms dependent on some future act, such as the +summoning of a German Parliament, from which the King of Prussia could not +recede if once he should go so far. But the Italians, apparently not +penetrating the real secret of Bismarck's hesitation, would be satisfied +with no such indeterminate engagement; they pressed for action within a +limited time; and in the end, after Austria had taken steps which went far +to overcome the last scruples of King William, Bismarck consented to fix +three months as the limit beyond which the obligation of Italy to accompany +Prussia into war should not extend. On the 8th of April a Treaty of +offensive and defensive alliance was signed. It was agreed that if the King +of Prussia should within three months take up arms for the reform of the +Federal system of Germany, Italy would immediately after the outbreak of +hostilities declare war upon Austria. Both Powers were to engage in the +war with their whole force, and peace was not to be made but by common +consent, such consent not to be withheld after Austria should have agreed +to cede Venetia to Italy and territory with an equal population to Prussia. +[520] + +[Bismarck and Austria, Aug., 1865-April, 1866.] + +Eight months had now passed since the signature of the Convention of +Gastem. The experiment of an understanding with Austria, which King William +had deemed necessary, had been made, and it had failed; or rather, as +Bismarck expressed himself in a candid moment, it had succeeded, inasmuch +as it had cured the King of his scruples and raised him to the proper point +of indignation against the Austrian Court. The agents in effecting this +happy result had been the Prince of Augustenburg, the population of +Holstein, and the Liberal party throughout Germany at large. In Schleswig, +which the Convention of Gastein had handed over to Prussia, General +Manteuffel, a son of the Minister of 1850, had summarily put a stop to +every expression of public opinion, and had threatened to imprison the +Prince if he came within his reach; in Holstein the Austrian Government had +permitted, if it had not encouraged, the inhabitants to agitate in favour +of the Pretender, and had allowed a mass-meeting to be held at Altona on +the 23rd of January, where cheers were raised for Augustenburg, and the +summoning of the Estates of Schleswig-Holstein was demanded. This was +enough to enable Bismarck to denounce the conduct of Austria as an alliance +with revolution. He demanded explanations from the Government of Vienna, +and the Emperor declined to render an account of his actions. Warlike +preparations now began, and on the 16th of March the Austrian Government +announced that it should refer the affairs of Schleswig-Holstein to the +Federal Diet. This was a clear departure from the terms of the Convention +of Gastein, and from the agreement made between Austria and Prussia before +entering into the Danish war in 1864 that the Schleswig-Holstein question +should be settled by the two Powers independently of the German Federation. +King William was deeply moved by such a breach of good faith; tears filled +his eyes when he spoke of the conduct of the Austrian Emperor; and though +pacific influences were still active around him he now began to fall in +more cordially with the warlike policy of his Minister. The question at +issue between Prussia and Austria expanded from the mere disposal of the +Duchies to the reconstitution of the Federal system of Germany. In a note +laid before the Governments of all the Minor States Bismarck declared that +the time had come when Germany must receive a new and more effective +organisation, and inquired how far Prussia could count on the support of +allies if it should be attacked by Austria or forced into war. It was +immediately after this re-opening of the whole problem of Federal reform in +Germany that the draft of the Treaty with Italy was brought to its final +shape by Bismarck and the Italian envoy, and sent to the Ministry at +Florence for its approval. + +[Austria offers Venice, May 5.] + +Bismarck had now to make the best use of the three months' delay that was +granted to him. On the day after the acceptance of the Treaty by the +Italian Government, the Prussian representative at the Diet of Frankfort +handed in a proposal for the summoning of a German Parliament, to be +elected by universal suffrage. Coming from the Minister who had made +Parliamentary government a mockery in Prussia, this proposal was scarcely +considered as serious. Bavaria, as the chief of the secondary States, had +already expressed its willingness to enter upon the discussion of Federal +reform, but it asked that the two leading Powers should in the meantime +undertake not to attack one another. Austria at once acceded to this +request, and so forced Bismarck into giving a similar assurance. Promises +of disarmament were then exchanged; but as Austria declined to stay the +collection of its forces in Venetia against Italy, Bismarck was able to +charge his adversary with insincerity in the negotiation, and preparations +for war were resumed on both sides. Other difficulties, however, now came +into view. The Treaty between Prussia and Italy had been made known to the +Court of Vienna by Napoleon, whose advice La Marmora had sought before its +conclusion, and the Austrian Emperor had thus become aware of his danger. +He now determined to sacrifice Venetia if Italy's neutrality could be so +secured. On the 5th of May the Italian ambassador at Paris, Count Nigra, +was informed by Napoleon that Austria had offered to cede Venetia to him on +behalf of Victor Emmanuel if France and Italy would not prevent Austria +from indemnifying itself at Prussia's expense in Silesia. Without a war, at +the price of mere inaction, Italy was offered all that it could gain by a +struggle which was likely to be a desperate one, and which might end in +disaster. La Marmora was in sore perplexity. Though he had formed a juster +estimate of the capacity of the Prussian army than any other statesman or +soldier in Europe, he was thoroughly suspicious of the intentions of the +Prussian Government; and in sanctioning the alliance of the previous month +he had done so half expecting that Bismarck would through the prestige of +this alliance gain for Prussia its own objects without entering into war, +and then leave Italy to reckon with Austria as best it might. He would +gladly have abandoned the alliance and have accepted Austria's offer if +Italy could have done this without disgrace. But the sense of honour was +sufficiently strong to carry him past this temptation. He declined the +offer made through Paris, and continued the armaments of Italy, though +still with a secret hope that European diplomacy might find the means of +realising the purpose of his country without war. [521] + +[Proposals for a Congress.] + +The neutral Powers were now, with various objects, bestirring themselves in +favour of a European Congress. Napoleon believed the time to be come when +the Treaties of 1815 might be finally obliterated by the joint act of +Europe. He was himself ready to join Prussia with three hundred thousand +men if the King would transfer the Rhenish Provinces to France. Demands, +direct and indirect, were made on Count Bismarck on behalf of the Tuileries +for cessions of territory of greater or less extent. These demands were +neither granted nor refused. Bismarck procrastinated; he spoke of the +obstinacy of the King his master; he inquired whether parts of Belgium or +Switzerland would not better assimilate with France than a German province; +he put off the Emperor's representatives by the assurance that he could +more conveniently arrange these matters with the Emperor when he should +himself visit Paris. On the 28th of May invitations to a Congress were +issued by France, England, and Russia jointly, the objects of the Congress +being defined as the settlement of the affairs of Schleswig-Holstein, of +the differences between Austria and Italy, and of the reform of the Federal +Constitution of Germany, in so far as these affected Europe at large. The +invitation was accepted by Prussia and by Italy; it was accepted by Austria +only under the condition that no arrangement should be discussed which +should give an increase of territory or power to one of the States invited +to the Congress. This subtly-worded condition would not indeed have +excluded the equal aggrandisement of all. It would not have rendered the +cession of Venetia to Italy or the annexation of Schleswig-Holstein to +Prussia impossible; but it would either have involved the surrender of the +former Papal territory by Italy in order that Victor Emmanuel's dominions +should receive no increase, or, in the alternative, it would have entitled +Austria to claim Silesia as its own equivalent for the augmentation of the +Italian Kingdom. Such reservations would have rendered any efforts of the +Powers to preserve peace useless, and they were accepted as tantamount to a +refusal on the part of Austria to attend the Congress. Simultaneously with +its answer to the neutral Powers, Austria called upon the Federal Diet to +take the affairs of Schleswig-Holstein into its own hands, and convoked the +Holstein Estates. Bismarck thereupon declared the Convention of Gastein to +be at an end, and ordered General Manteuffel to lead his troops into +Holstein. The Austrian commander, protesting that he yielded only to +superior force, withdrew through Altona into Hanover. Austria at once +demanded and obtained from the Diet of Frankfort the mobilisation of the +whole of the Federal armies. The representative of Prussia, declaring that +this act of the Diet had made an end of the existing Federal union, handed +in the plan of his Government for the reorganisation of Germany, and +quitted Frankfort. Diplomatic relations between Austria and Prussia were +broken off on the 12th of June, and on the 15th Count Bismarck demanded of +the sovereigns of Hanover, Saxony, and Hesse-Cassel, that they should on +that very day put a stop to their military preparations and accept the +Prussian scheme of Federal reform. Negative answers being given, Prussian +troops immediately marched into these territories, and war began. Weimar, +Mecklenburg, and other petty States in the north took part with Prussia: +all the rest of Germany joined Austria. [522] + +[German Opinion.] + +The goal of Bismarck's desire, the end which he had steadily set before +himself since entering upon his Ministry, was attained; and, if his +calculations as to the strength of the Prussian army were not at fault, +Austria was at length to be expelled from the German Federation by force of +arms. But the process by which Bismarck had worked up to this result had +ranged against him the almost unanimous opinion of Germany outside the +military circles of Prussia itself. His final demand for the summoning of a +German Parliament was taken as mere comedy. The guiding star of his policy +had hitherto been the dynastic interest of the House of Hohenzollern; and +now, when the Germans were to be plunged into war with one another, it +seemed as if the real object of the struggle was no more than the +annexation of the Danish Duchies and some other coveted territory to the +Prussian Kingdom. The voice of protest and condemnation rose loud from +every organ of public opinion. Even in Prussia itself the instances were +few where any spontaneous support was tendered to the Government. The +Parliament of Berlin, struggling up to the end against the all-powerful +Minister, had seen its members prosecuted for speeches made within its own +walls, and had at last been prorogued in order that its insubordination +might not hamper the Crown in the moment of danger. But the mere +disappearance of Parliament could not conceal the intensity of ill-will +which the Minister and his policy had excited. The author of a fratricidal +war of Germans against Germans was in the eyes of many the greatest of all +criminals; and on the 7th of May an attempt was made by a young fanatic to +take Bismarck's life in the streets of Berlin. The Minister owed the +preservation of his life to the feebleness of his assailant's weapon and to +his own vigorous arm. But the imminence of the danger affected King William +far more than Bismarck himself. It spoke to his simple mind of supernatural +protection and aid; it stilled his doubts; and confirmed him in the belief +that Prussia was in this crisis the instrument for working out the +Almighty's will. + +[Napoleon III.] + +A few days before the outbreak of hostilities the Emperor Napoleon gave +publicity to his own view of the European situation. He attributed the +coming war to three causes: to the faulty geographical limits of the +Prussian State, to the desire for a better Federal system in Germany, and +to the necessity felt by the Italian nation for securing its independence. +These needs would, he conceived, be met by a territorial rearrangement in +the north of Germany consolidating and augmenting the Prussian Kingdom; by +the creation of a more effective Federal union between the secondary German +States; and finally, by the incorporation of Venetia with Italy, Austria's +position in Germany remaining unimpaired. Only in the event of the map of +Europe being altered to the exclusive advantage of one Great Power would +France require an extension of frontier. Its interests lay in the +preservation of the equilibrium of Europe, and in the maintenance of the +Italian Kingdom. These had already been secured by arrangements which would +not require France to draw the sword; a watchful but unselfish neutrality +was the policy which its Government had determined to pursue. Napoleon had +in fact lost all control over events, and all chance of gaining the Rhenish +Provinces, from the time when he permitted Italy to enter into the Prussian +alliance without any stipulation that France should at its option be +admitted as a third member of the coalition. He could not ally himself with +Austria against his own creation, the Italian Kingdom; on the other hand, +he had no means of extorting cessions from Prussia when once Prussia was +sure of an ally who could bring two hundred thousand men into the field. +His diplomacy had been successful in so far as it had assured Venetia to +Italy whether Prussia should be victorious or overthrown, but as regarded +France it had landed him in absolute powerlessness. He was unable to act on +one side; he was not wanted on the other. Neutrality had become a matter +not of choice but of necessity; and until the course of military events +should have produced some new situation in Europe, France might well be +watchful, but it could scarcely gain much credit for its disinterested +part. [523] + +[Hanover and Hesse-Cassel conquered.] + +[The Bohemian Campaign, June 26-July 3.] + +[Battle of Koeniggraetz, July 3.] + +Assured against an attack from the side of the Rhine, Bismarck was able to +throw the mass of the Prussian forces southwards against Austria, leaving +in the north only the modest contingent which was necessary to overcome the +resistance of Hanover and Hesse-Cassel. Through the precipitancy of a +Prussian general, who struck without waiting for his colleagues, the +Hanoverians gained a victory at Langensalza on the 27th of June; but other +Prussian regiments arrived on the field a few hours later, and the +Hanoverian army was forced to capitulate on the next day. The King made his +escape to Austria; the Elector of Hesse-Cassel, less fortunate, was made a +prisoner of war. Northern Germany was thus speedily reduced to submission, +and any danger of a diversion in favour of Austria in this quarter +disappeared. In Saxony no attempt was made to bar the way to the advancing +Prussians. Dresden was occupied without resistance, but the Saxon army +marched southwards in good time, and joined the Austrians in Bohemia. The +Prussian forces, about two hundred and fifty thousand strong, now gathered +on the Saxon and Silesian frontier, covering the line from Pirna to +Landshut. They were composed of three armies: the first, or central, army +under Prince Frederick Charles, a nephew of the King; the second, or +Silesian, army under the Crown Prince; the westernmost, known as the army +of the Elbe, under General Herwarth von Bittenfeld. Against these were +ranged about an equal number of Austrians, led by Benedek, a general who +had gained great distinction in the Hungarian and the Italian campaigns. It +had at first been thought probable that Benedek, whose forces lay about +Olmuetz, would invade Southern Silesia, and the Prussian line had therefore +been extended far to the east. Soon, however, it appeared that the +Austrians were unable to take up the offensive, and Benedek moved westwards +into Bohemia. The Prussian line was now shortened, and orders were given to +the three armies to cross the Bohemian frontier and converge in the +direction of the town of Gitschin. General Moltke, the chief of the staff, +directed their operations from Berlin by telegraph. The combined advance of +the three armies was executed with extraordinary precision; and in a series +of hard-fought combats extending from the 26th to the 29th of June the +Austrians were driven back upon their centre, and effective communication +was established between the three invading bodies. On the 30th the King of +Prussia, with General Moltke and Count Bismarck, left Berlin; on the 2nd of +July they were at headquarters at Gitschin. It had been Benedek's design to +leave a small force to hold the Silesian army in check, and to throw the +mass of his army westwards upon Prince Frederick Charles and overwhelm him +before he could receive help from his colleagues. This design had been +baffled by the energy of the Crown Prince's attack, and by the superiority +of the Prussians in generalship, in the discipline of their troops, and in +the weapon they carried; for though the Austrians had witnessed in the +Danish campaign the effects of the Prussian breech-loading rifle, they had +not thought it necessary to adopt a similar arm. Benedek, though no great +battle had yet been fought, saw that the campaign was lost, and wrote to +the Emperor on the 1st of July recommending him to make peace, for +otherwise a catastrophe was inevitable. He then concentrated his army on +high ground a few miles west of Koeniggraetz, and prepared for a defensive +battle on the grandest scale. In spite of the losses of the past week he +could still bring about two hundred thousand men into action. The three +Prussian armies were now near enough to one another to combine in their +attack, and on the night of July 2nd the King sent orders to the three +commanders to move against Benedek before daybreak. Prince Frederick +Charles, advancing through the village of Sadowa, was the first in the +field. For hours his divisions sustained an unequal struggle against the +assembled strength of the Austrians. Midday passed; the defenders now +pressed down upon their assailants; and preparations for a retreat had been +begun, when the long-expected message arrived that the Crown Prince was +close at hand. The onslaught of the army of Silesia on Benedek's right, +which was accompanied by the arrival of Herwarth at the other end of the +field of battle, at once decided the day. It was with difficulty that the +Austrian commander prevented the enemy from seizing the positions which +would have cut off his retreat. He retired eastwards across the Elbe with a +loss of eighteen thousand killed and wounded and twenty-four thousand +prisoners. His army was ruined; and ten days after the Prussians had +crossed the frontier the war was practically at an end. [524] + +[Battle of Custozza, June 24.] + +[Napoleon's mediation, July 5.] + +[Preliminaries of Nicolsburg, July 26.] + +[Treaty of Prague, Aug. 23.] + +The disaster of Koeniggraetz was too great to be neutralised by the success +of the Austrian forces in Italy. La Marmora, who had given up his place at +the head of the Government in order to take command of the army, crossed +the Mincio at the head of a hundred and twenty thousand men, but was +defeated by inferior numbers on the fatal ground of Custozza, and compelled +to fall back on the Oglio. This gleam of success, which was followed by a +naval victory at Lissa off the Istrian coast, made it easier for the +Austrian Emperor to face the sacrifices that were now inevitable. +Immediately after the battle of Koeniggraetz he invoked the mediation of +Napoleon III., and ceded Venetia to him on behalf of Italy. Napoleon at +once tendered his good offices to the belligerents, and proposed an +armistice. His mediation was accepted in principle by the King or Prussia, +who expressed his willingness also to grant an armistice as soon as +preliminaries of peace were recognised by the Austrian Court. In the +meantime, while negotiations passed between all four Governments, the +Prussians pushed forward until their outposts came within sight of Vienna. +If in pursuance of General Moltke's plan the Italian generals had thrown a +corps north-eastwards from the head of the Adriatic, and so struck at the +very heart of the Austrian monarchy, it is possible that the victors of +Koeniggraetz might have imposed their own terms without regard to Napoleon's +mediation, and, while adding the Italian Tyrol to Victor Emmanuel's +dominions, have completed the union of Germany under the House of +Hohenzollern at one stroke. But with Hungary still intact, and the Italian +army paralysed by the dissensions of its commanders, prudence bade the +great statesman of Berlin content himself with the advantages which he +could reap without prolongation of the war, and without the risk of +throwing Napoleon into the enemy's camp. He had at first required, as +conditions of peace, that Prussia should be left free to annex Saxony, +Hanover, Hesse-Cassel, and other North German territory; that Austria +should wholly withdraw from German affairs; and that all Germany, less the +Austrian Provinces, should be united in a Federation under Prussian +leadership. To gain the assent of Napoleon to these terms, Bismarck hinted +that France might by accord with Prussia annex Belgium. Napoleon, however, +refused to agree to the extension of Prussia's ascendency over all Germany, +and presented a counter-project which was in its turn rejected by Bismarck. +It was finally settled that Prussia should not be prevented from annexing +Hanover, Nassau, and Hesse-Cassel, as conquered territory that lay between +its own Rhenish Provinces and the rest of the kingdom; that Austria should +completely withdraw from German affairs; that Germany north of the Main, +together with Saxony, should be included in a Federation under Prussian +leadership; and that for the States south of the Main there should be +reserved the right of entering into some kind of national bond with the +Northern League. Austria escaped without loss of any of its non-Italian +territory; it also succeeded in preserving the existence of Saxony, which, +as in 1815, the Prussian Government had been most anxious to annex. +Napoleon, in confining the Prussian Federation to the north of the Main, +and in securing by a formal stipulation in the Treaty the independence of +the Southern States, imagined himself to have broken Germany into halves, +and to have laid the foundation of a South German League which should look +to France as its protector. On the other hand, Bismarck by his annexation +of Hanover and neighbouring districts had added a population of four +millions to the Prussian Kingdom, and given it a continuous territory; he +had forced Austria out of the German system; he had gained its sanction to +the Federal union of all Germany north of the Main, and had at least kept +the way open for the later extension of this union to the Southern States. +Preliminaries of peace embodying these conditions and recognising Prussia's +sovereignty in Schleswig-Holstein were signed at Nicolsburg on the 26th of +July, and formed the basis of the definitive Treaty of Peace which was +concluded at Prague on the 23rd of August. An illusory clause, added at the +instance of Napoleon, provided that if the population of the northern +districts of Schleswig should by a free vote express the wish to be united +with Denmark, these districts should be ceded to the Danish Kingdom. [525] + +[The South German States.] + +[Secret Treaties of the Southern States with Prussia.] + +Bavaria and the south-western allies of Austria, though their military +action was of an ineffective character, continued in arms for some weeks +after the battle of Koeniggraetz and the suspension of hostilities arranged +at Nicolsburg did not come into operation on their behalf till the 2nd of +August. Before that date their forces were dispersed and their power of +resistance broken by the Prussian generals Falckenstein and Manteuffel in a +series of unimportant engagements and intricate manoeuvres. The City of +Frankfort, against which Bismarck seems to have borne some personal hatred, +was treated for a while by the conquerors with extraordinary and most +impolitic harshness; in other respects the action of the Prussian +Government towards these conquered States was not such as to render future +union and friendship difficult. All the South German Governments, with the +single exception of Baden, appealed to the Emperor Napoleon for assistance +in the negotiations which they had opened at Berlin. But at the very moment +when this request was made and granted Napoleon was himself demanding from +Bismarck the cession of the Bavarian Palatinate and of the Hessian +districts west of the Rhine. Bismarck had only to acquaint the King of +Bavaria and the South German Ministers with the designs of their French +protector in order to reconcile them to his own chastening, but not +unfriendly, hand. The grandeur of a united Fatherland flashed upon minds +hitherto impenetrable by any national ideal when it became known that +Napoleon was bargaining for Oppenheim and Kaiserslautern. Not only were the +insignificant questions as to the war-indemnities to be paid to Prussia and +the frontier villages to be exchanged promptly settled, but by a series of +secret Treaties all the South German States entered into an offensive and +defensive alliance with the Prussian King, and engaged in case of war to +place their entire forces at his disposal and under his command. The +diplomacy of Napoleon III. had in the end effected for Bismarck almost more +than his earlier intervention had frustrated, for it had made the South +German Courts the allies of Prussia not through conquest or mere compulsion +but out of regard for their own interests. [526] It was said by the +opponents of the Imperial Government in France, and scarcely with +exaggeration, that every error which it was possible to commit had, in the +course of the year 1866, been committed by Napoleon III. One crime, one act +of madness, remained open to the Emperor's critics, to lash him and France +into a conflict with the Power whose union he had not been able to prevent. + +[Projects of compensation for France.] + +Prior to the battle of Koeniggraetz, it would seem that all the suggestions +of the French Emperor relating to the acquisition of Belgium were made to +the Prussian Government through secret agents, and that they were actually +unknown, or known by mere hearsay, to Benedetti, the French Ambassador at +Berlin. According to Prince Bismarck, these overtures had begun as early as +1862, when he was himself Ambassador at Paris, and were then made verbally +and in private notes to himself; they were the secret of Napoleon's +neutrality during the Danish war; and were renewed through relatives and +confidential agents of the Emperor when the struggle with Austria was seen +to be approaching. The ignorance in which Count Benedetti was kept of his +master's private diplomacy may to some extent explain the extraordinary +contradictions between the accounts given by this Minister and by Prince +Bismarck of the negotiations that passed between them in the period +following the campaign of 1866, after Benedetti had himself been charged to +present the demands of the French Government. In June, while the Ambassador +was still, as it would seem, in ignorance of what was passing behind his +back, he had informed the French Ministry that Bismarck, anxious for the +preservation of French neutrality, had hinted at the compensations that +might be made to France if Prussia should meet with great success in the +coming war. According to the report of the Ambassador, made at the time, +Count Bismarck stated that he would rather withdraw from public life than +cede the Rhenish Provinces with Cologne and Bonn, but that he believed it +would be possible to gain the King's ultimate consent to the cession of the +Prussian district of Treves on the Upper Moselle, which district, together +with Luxemburg or parts of Belgium and Switzerland, would give France an +adequate improvement of its frontier. The Ambassador added in his report, +by way of comment, that Count Bismarck was the only man in the kingdom who +was disposed to make any cession of Prussian territory whatever, and that a +unanimous and violent revulsion against France would be excited by the +slightest indication of any intention on the part of the French Government +to extend its frontiers towards the Rhine. He concluded his report with the +statement that, after hearing Count Bismarck's suggestions, he had brought +the discussion to a summary close, not wishing to leave the Prussian +Minister under the impression that any scheme involving the seizure of +Belgian or Swiss territory had the slightest chance of being seriously +considered at Paris. (June 4-8.) + +[Demand for Rhenish territory, July 25-Aug. 7, 1866.] + +[The Belgian project, Aug. 16-30.] + +Benedetti probably wrote these last words in full sincerity. Seven weeks +later, after the settlement of the Preliminaries at Nicolsburg, he was +ordered to demand the cession of the Bavarian Palatinate, of the portion of +Hesse-Darmstadt west of the Rhine, including Mainz, and of the strip of +Prussian territory on the Saar which had been left to France in 1814 but +taken from it in 1815. According to the statement of Prince Bismarck, which +would seem to be exaggerated, this demand was made by Benedetti as an +ultimatum and with direct threats of war, which were answered by Bismarck +in language of equal violence. In any case the demand was unconditionally +refused, and Benedetti travelled to Paris in order to describe what had +passed at the Prussian headquarters. His report made such an impression on +the Emperor that the demand for cessions on the Rhine was at once +abandoned, and the Foreign Minister, Drouyn de Lhuys, who had been disposed +to enforce this by arms, was compelled to quit office. Benedetti returned +to Berlin, and now there took place that negotiation relating to Belgium on +which not only the narratives of the persons immediately concerned, but the +documents written at the time, leave so much that is strange and +unexplained. According to Benedetti, Count Bismarck was keenly anxious to +extend the German Federation to the South of the Main, and desired with +this object an intimate union with at least one Great Power. He sought in +the first instance the support of France, and offered in return to +facilitate the seizure of Belgium. The negotiation, according to Benedetti, +failed because the Emperor Napoleon required that the fortresses in +Southern Germany should be held by the troops of the respective States to +which they belonged, while at the same time General Manteuffel, who had +been sent from Berlin on a special mission to St. Petersburg, succeeded in +effecting so intimate a union with Russia that alliance with France became +unnecessary. According to the counter-statement of Prince Bismarck, the +plan now proposed originated entirely with the French Ambassador, and was +merely a repetition of proposals which had been made by Napoleon during the +preceding four years, and which were subsequently renewed at intervals by +secret agents almost down to the outbreak of the war of 1870. Prince +Bismarck has stated that he dallied with these proposals only because a +direct refusal might at any moment have caused the outbreak of war between +France and Prussia, a catastrophe which up to the end he sought to avert. +In any case the negotiation with Benedetti led to no conclusion, and was +broken off by the departure of both statesmen from Berlin in the beginning +of autumn. [527] + +[Prussia and North Germany after the war.] + +The war of 1866 had been brought to an end with extraordinary rapidity; its +results were solid and imposing. Venice, perplexed no longer by its +Republican traditions or by doubts of the patriotism of the House of Savoy, +prepared to welcome King Victor Emmanuel; Bismarck, returning from the +battle-field of Koeniggraetz, found his earlier unpopularity forgotten in the +flood of national enthusiasm which his achievements and those of the army +had evoked. A new epoch had begun; the antagonisms of the past were out of +date; nobler work now stood before the Prussian people and its rulers than +the perpetuation of a barren struggle between Crown and Parliament. By none +was the severance from the past more openly expressed than by Bismarck +himself; by none was it more bitterly felt than by the old Conservative +party in Prussia, who had hitherto regarded the Minister as their own +representative. In drawing up the Constitution of the North German +Federation, Bismarck remained true to the principle which he had laid down +at Frankfort before the war, that the German people must be represented by +a Parliament elected directly by the people themselves. In the +incorporation of Hanover, Hesse-Cassel and the Danish Duchies with Prussia, +he saw that it would be impossible to win the new populations to a loyal +union with Prussia if the King's Government continued to recognise no +friends but the landed aristocracy and the army. He frankly declared that +the action of the Cabinet in raising taxes without the consent of +Parliament had been illegal, and asked for an Act of Indemnity. The +Parliament of Berlin understood and welcomed the message of reconciliation. +It heartily forgave the past, and on its own initiative added the name of +Bismarck to those for whose services to the State the King asked a +recompense. The Progressist party, which had constituted the majority in +the last Parliament, gave place to a new combination known as the National +Liberal party, which, while adhering to the Progressist creed in domestic +affairs, gave its allegiance to the Foreign and the German policy of the +Minister. Within this party many able men who in Hanover and the other +annexed territories had been the leaders of opposition to their own +Governments now found a larger scope and a greater political career. More +than one of the colleagues of Bismarck who had been appointed to their +offices in the years of conflict were allowed to pass into retirement, and +their places were filled by men in sympathy with the National Liberals. +With the expansion of Prussia and the establishment of its leadership in a +German Federal union, the ruler of Prussia seemed himself to expand from +the instrument of a military monarchy to the representative of a great +nation. + +[Hungary and Austria, 1865.] + +To Austria the battle of Koeniggraetz brought a settlement of the conflict +between the Crown and Hungary. The Constitution of February, 1861, +hopefully as it had worked during its first years, had in the end fallen +before the steady refusal of the Magyars to recognise the authority of a +single Parliament for the whole Monarchy. Within the Reichsrath itself the +example of Hungary told as a disintegrating force; the Poles, the Czechs +seceded from the Assembly; the Minister, Schmerling, lost his authority, +and was forced to resign in the summer of 1865. Soon afterwards an edict of +the Emperor suspended the Constitution. Count Belcredi, who took office in +Schmerling's place, attempted to arrive at an understanding with the Magyar +leaders. The Hungarian Diet was convoked, and was opened by the King in +person before the end of the year. Francis Joseph announced his abandonment +of the principle that Hungary had forfeited its ancient rights by +rebellion, and asked in return that the Diet should not insist upon +regarding the laws of 1848 as still in force. Whatever might be the formal +validity of those laws, it was, he urged, impossible that they should be +brought into operation unaltered. For the common affairs of the two halves +of the Monarchy there must be some common authority. It rested with the +Diet to arrive at the necessary understanding with the Sovereign on this +point, and to place on a satisfactory footing the relations of Hungary to +Transylvania and Croatia. As soon as an accord should have been reached on +these subjects, Francis Joseph stated that he would complete his +reconciliation with the Magyars by being crowned King of Hungary. + +[Deak.] + +In the Assembly to which these words were addressed the majority was +composed of men of moderate opinions, under the leadership of Francis Deak. +Deak had drawn up the programme of the Hungarian Liberals in the election +of 1847. He had at that time appeared to be marked out by his rare +political capacity and the simple manliness of his character for a great, +if not the greatest, part in the work that then lay before his country. But +the violence of revolutionary methods was alien to his temperament. After +serving in Batthyany's Ministry, he withdrew from public life on the +outbreak of war with Austria, and remained in retirement during the +dictatorship of Kossuth and the struggle of 1849. As a loyal friend to the +Hapsburg dynasty, and a clear-sighted judge of the possibilities of the +time, he stood apart while Kossuth dethroned the Sovereign and proclaimed +Hungarian independence. Of the patriotism and the disinterestedness of Deak +there was never the shadow of a doubt; a distinct political faith severed +him from the leaders whose enterprise ended in the catastrophe which he had +foreseen, and preserved for Hungary one statesman who could, without +renouncing his own past and without inflicting humiliation on the +Sovereign, stand as the mediator between Hungary and Austria when the time +for reconciliation should arrive. Deak was little disposed to abate +anything of what he considered the just demands of his country. It was +under his leadership that the Diet had in 1861 refused to accept the +Constitution which established a single Parliament for the whole Monarchy. +The legislative independence of Hungary he was determined at all costs to +preserve intact; rather than surrender this he had been willing in 1861 to +see negotiations broken off and military rule restored. But when Francis +Joseph, wearied of the sixteen years' struggle, appealed once more to +Hungary for union and friendship, there was no man more earnestly desirous +to reconcile the Sovereign with the nation, and to smooth down the +opposition to the King's proposals which arose within the Diet itself, than +Deak. + +[Scheme of Hungarian Committee, June 25, 1866.] + +Under his influence a committee was appointed to frame the necessary basis +of negotiation. On the 25th of June, 1866, the Committee gave in its +report. It declared against any Parliamentary union with the Cis-Leithan +half of the Monarchy, but consented to the establishment of common +Ministries for War, Finance, and Foreign Affairs, and recommended that the +Budget necessary for these joint Ministries should be settled by +Delegations from the Hungarian Diet and from the western Reichsrath. [528] +The Delegations, it was proposed, should meet separately, and communicate +their views to one another by writing. Only when agreement should not have +been thus attained were the Delegations to unite in a single body, in which +case the decision was to rest with an absolute majority of votes. + +[Negotiations with Hungary after Koeniggraetz.] + +[Federalism or Dualism.] + +[Settlement by Beust.] + +[Francis Joseph's Coronation, June 8, 1867.] + +The debates of the Diet on the proposals of King Francis Joseph had been +long and anxious; it was not until the moment when the war with Prussia was +breaking out that the Committee presented its report. The Diet was now +prorogued, but immediately after the battle of Koeniggraetz the Hungarian +leaders were called to Vienna, and negotiations were pushed forward on the +lines laid down by the Committee. It was a matter of no small moment to the +Court of Vienna that while bodies of Hungarian exiles had been preparing to +attack the Empire both from the side of Silesia and of Venice, Deak and his +friends had loyally abstained from any communication with the foreign +enemies of the House of Hapsburg. That Hungary would now gain almost +complete independence was certain; the question was not so much whether +there should be an independent Parliament and Ministry at Pesth as whether +there should not be a similarly independent Parliament and Ministry in each +of the territories of the Crown, the Austrian Sovereign becoming the head +of a Federation instead of the chief of a single or a dual State. Count +Belcredi, the Minister at Vienna, was disposed towards such a Federal +system; he was, however, now confronted within the Cabinet by a rival who +represented a different policy. After making peace with Prussia, the +Emperor called to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs Count Beust, who had +hitherto been at the head of the Saxon Government, and who had been the +representative of the German Federation at the London Conference of 1864. +Beust, while ready to grant the Hungarians their independence, advocated +the retention of the existing Reichsrath and of a single Ministry for all +the Cis-Leithan parts of the Monarchy. His plan, which pointed to the +maintenance of German ascendency in the western provinces, and which deeply +offended the Czechs and the Slavic populations, was accepted by the +Emperor: Belcredi withdrew from office, and Beust was charged, as President +of the Cabinet, with the completion of the settlement with Hungary (Feb. 7, +1867). Deak had hitherto left the chief ostensible part in the negotiations +to Count Andrassy, one of the younger patriots of 1848, who had been +condemned to be hanged, and had lived a refugee during the next ten years. +He now came to Vienna himself, and in the course of a few days removed the +last remaining difficulties. The King gratefully charged him with the +formation of the Hungarian Ministry under the restored Constitution, but +Deak declined alike all office, honours, and rewards, and Andrassy, who had +actually been hanged in effigy, was placed at the head of the Government. +The Diet, which had reassembled shortly before the end of 1866, greeted the +national Ministry with enthusiasm. Alterations in the laws of 1848 proposed +in accordance with the agreement made at Vienna, and establishing the three +common Ministries with the system of Delegations for common affairs, were +carried by large majorities. [529] The abdication of Ferdinand, which +throughout the struggle of 1849 Hungary had declined to recognise, was now +acknowledged as valid, and on the 8th of June, 1867, Francis Joseph was +crowned King of Hungary amid the acclamations of Pesth. The gift of money +which is made to each Hungarian monarch on his coronation Francis Joseph by +a happy impulse distributed among the families of those who had fallen in +fighting against him in 1849. A universal amnesty was proclaimed, no +condition being imposed on the return of the exiles but that they should +acknowledge the existing Constitution. Kossuth alone refused to return to +his country so long as a Hapsburg should be its King, and proudly clung to +ideas which were already those of the past. + +[Hungary since 1867.] + +The victory of the Magyars was indeed but too complete. Not only were Beust +and the representatives of the western half of the Monarchy so overmatched +by the Hungarian negotiators that in the distribution of the financial +burdens of the Empire Hungary escaped with far too small a share, but in +the more important problem of the relation of the Slavic and Roumanian +populations of the Hungarian Kingdom to the dominant race no adequate steps +were taken for the protection of these subject nationalities. That Croatia +and Transylvania should be reunited with Hungary if the Emperor and the +Magyars were ever to be reconciled was inevitable; and in the case of +Croatia certain conditions were no doubt imposed, and certain local rights +guaranteed. But on the whole the non-Magyar peoples in Hungary were handed +over to the discretion of the ruling race. The demand of Bismarck that the +centre of gravity of the Austrian States should be transferred from Vienna +to Pesth had indeed been brought to pass. While in the western half of the +Monarchy the central authority, still represented by a single Parliament, +seemed in the succeeding years to be altogether losing its cohesive power, +and the political life of Austria became a series of distracting +complications, in Hungary the Magyar Government resolutely set itself to +the task of moulding into one the nationalities over which it ruled. +Uniting the characteristic faults with the great qualities of a race marked +out by Nature and ancient habit for domination over more numerous but less +aggressive neighbours, the Magyars have steadily sought to the best of +their power to obliterate the distinctions which make Hungary in reality +not one but several nations. They have held the Slavic and the Roumanian +population within their borders with an iron grasp, but they have not +gained their affection. The memory of the Russian intervention in 1849 and +of the part then played by Serbs, by Croats and Roumanians in crushing +Magyar independence has blinded the victors to the just claims of these +races both within and without the Hungarian kingdom, and attached their +sympathy to the hateful and outworn empire of the Turk. But the +individuality of peoples is not to be blotted out in a day; nor, with all +its striking advance in wealth, in civilisation, and in military power, has +the Magyar State been able to free itself from the insecurity arising from +the presence of independent communities on its immediate frontiers +belonging to the same race as those whose language and nationality it seeks +to repress. + + + + +CHAPTER XXIV. + + +Napoleon III.--The Mexican Expedition--Withdrawal of the French and death +of Maximilian--The Luxemburg Question--Exasperation in France against +Prussia--Austria--Italy--Mentana--Germany after 1866--The Spanish +candidature of Leopold of Hohenzollern--French declaration--Benedetti and +King William--Withdrawal of Leopold and demand for guarantees--The +telegram from Ems--War--Expected Alliances of France--Austria--Italy-- +Prussian plans--The French army--Causes of French inferiority-- +Weissenburg--Woerth--Spicheren--Borny--Mars-la-Tour--Gravelotte--Sedan-- +The Republic proclaimed at Paris--Favre and Bismarck--Siege of +Paris--Gambetta at Tours--The Army of the Loire--Fall of Metz--Fighting +at Orleans--Sortie of Champigny--The Armies of the North, of the Loire, +of the East--Bourbaki's ruin--Capitulation of Paris and Armistice-- +Preliminaries of Peace--Germany--Establishment of the German Empire--The +Commune of Paris--Second siege--Effects of the war as to Russia and +Italy--Rome. + + +[Napoleon III.] + +The reputation of Napoleon III. was perhaps at its height at the end of the +first ten years of his reign. His victories over Russia and Austria had +flattered the military pride of France; the flowing tide of commercial +prosperity bore witness, as it seemed, to the blessings of a government at +once firm and enlightened; the reconstruction of Paris dazzled a generation +accustomed to the mean and dingy aspect of London and other capitals before +1850, and scarcely conscious of the presence or absence of real beauty and +dignity where it saw spaciousness and brilliance. The political faults of +Napoleon, the shiftiness and incoherence of his designs, his want of grasp +on reality, his absolute personal nullity as an administrator, were known +to some few, but they had not been displayed to the world at large. He had +done some great things, he had conspicuously failed in nothing. Had his +reign ended before 1863, he would probably have left behind him in popular +memory the name of a great ruler. But from this time his fortune paled. The +repulse of his intervention on behalf of Poland in 1863 by the Russian +Court, his petulant or miscalculating inaction during the Danish War of the +following year, showed those to be mistaken who had imagined that the +Emperor must always exercise a controlling power in Europe. During the +events which formed the first stage in the consolidation of Germany his +policy was a succession of errors. Simultaneously with the miscarriage of +his European schemes, an enterprise which he had undertaken beyond the +Atlantic, and which seriously weakened his resources at a time when +concentrated strength alone could tell on European affairs, ended in +tragedy and disgrace. + +[The Mexican Project.] + +There were in Napoleon III., as a man of State, two personalities, two +mental existences, which blended but ill with one another. There was the +contemplator of great human forces, the intelligent, if not deeply +penetrative, reader of the signs of the times, the brooder through long +years of imprisonment and exile, the child of Europe, to whom Germany, +Italy, and England had all in turn been nearer than his own country; and +there was the crowned adventurer, bound by his name and position to gain +for France something that it did not possess, and to regard the greatness +of every other nation as an impediment to the ascendency of his own. +Napoleon correctly judged the principle of nationality to be the dominant +force in the immediate future of Europe. He saw in Italy and in Germany +races whose internal divisions alone had prevented them from being the +formidable rivals of France, and yet he assisted the one nation to effect +its union, and was not indisposed, within certain limits, to promote the +consolidation of the other. That the acquisition of Nice and Savoy, and +even of the Rhenish Provinces, could not in itself make up to France for +the establishment of two great nations on its immediate frontiers Napoleon +must have well understood: he sought to carry the principle of +agglomeration a stage farther in the interests of France itself, and to +form some moral, if not political, union of the Latin nations, which should +embrace under his own ascendency communities beyond the Atlantic as well as +those of the Old World. It was with this design that in the year 1862 he +made the financial misdemeanours of Mexico the pretext for an expedition to +that country, the object of which was to subvert the native Republican +Government, and to place the Hapsburg Maximilian, as a vassal prince, on +its throne. England and Spain had at first agreed to unite with France in +enforcing the claims of the European creditors of Mexico; but as soon as +Napoleon had made public his real intentions these Powers withdrew their +forces, and the Emperor was left free to carry out his plans alone. + +[The Mexican Expedition, 1862-1865.] + +[Napoleon compelled to withdraw, 1866-7.] + +[Fall and Death of Maximilian.] + +The design of Napoleon to establish French influence in Mexico was +connected with his attempt to break up the United States by establishing +the independence of the Southern Confederacy, then in rebellion, through +the mediation of the Great Powers of Europe. So long as the Civil War in +the United States lasted, it seemed likely that Napoleon's enterprise in +Mexico would be successful. Maximilian was placed upon the throne, and the +Republican leader, Juarez, was driven into the extreme north of the +country. But with the overthrow of the Southern Confederacy and the +restoration of peace in the United States in 1865 the prospect totally +changed. The Government of Washington refused to acknowledge any authority +in Mexico but that of Juarez, and informed Napoleon in courteous terms that +his troops must be withdrawn. Napoleon had bound himself by Treaty to keep +twenty-five thousand men in Mexico for the protection of Maximilian. He +was, however, unable to defy the order of the United States. Early in 1866 +he acquainted Maximilian with the necessities of the situation, and with +the approaching removal of the force which alone had placed him and could +sustain him on the throne. The unfortunate prince sent his consort, the +daughter of the King of the Belgians, to Europe to plead against this act +of desertion; but her efforts were vain, and her reason sank under the just +presentiment of her husband's ruin. The utmost on which Napoleon could +venture was the postponement of the recall of his troops till the spring of +1867. He urged Maximilian to abdicate before it was too late; but the +prince refused to dissociate himself from his counsellors who still +implored him to remain. Meanwhile the Juarists pressed back towards the +capital from north and south. As the French detachments were withdrawn +towards the coast the entire country fell into their hands. The last French +soldiers quitted Mexico at the beginning of March, 1867, and on the 15th of +May, Maximilian, still lingering at Queretaro, was made prisoner by the +Republicans. He had himself while in power ordered that the partisans of +Juarez should be treated not as soldiers but as brigands, and that when +captured they should be tried by court-martial and executed within +twenty-four hours. The same severity was applied to himself. He was +sentenced to death and shot at Queretaro on the 19th of June. + +[Decline of Napoleon's reputation.] + +Thus ended the attempt of Napoleon III. to establish the influence of +France and of his dynasty beyond the seas. The doom of Maximilian excited +the compassion of Europe; a deep, irreparable wound was inflicted on the +reputation of the man who had tempted him to his treacherous throne, who +had guaranteed him protection, and at the bidding of a superior power had +abandoned him to his ruin. From this time, though the outward splendour of +the Empire was undiminished, there remained scarcely anything of the +personal prestige which Napoleon had once enjoyed in so rich a measure. He +was no longer in the eyes of Europe or of his own country the profound, +self-contained statesman in whose brain lay the secret of coming events; he +was rather the gambler whom fortune was preparing to desert, the usurper +trembling for the future of his dynasty and his crown. Premature old age +and a harassing bodily ailment began to incapacitate him for personal +exertion. He sought to loosen the reins in which his despotism held France, +and to make a compromise with public opinion which was now declaring +against him. And although his own cooler judgment set little store by any +addition of frontier strips of alien territory to France, and he would +probably have been best pleased to pass the remainder of his reign in +undisturbed inaction, he deemed it necessary, after failure in Mexico had +become inevitable, to seek some satisfaction in Europe for the injured +pride of his country. He entered into negotiations with the King of Holland +for the cession of Luxemburg, and had gained his assent, when rumours of +the transaction reached the North German Press, and the project passed from +out the control of diplomatists and became an affair of rival nations. + +[The Luxemburg question, Feb.-May, 1867.] + +Luxemburg, which was an independent Duchy ruled by the King of Holland, had +until 1866 formed a part of the German Federation; and although Bismarck +had not attempted to include it in his own North German Union, Prussia +retained by the Treaties of 1815 a right to garrison the fortress of +Luxemburg, and its troops were actually there in possession. The proposed +transfer of the Duchy to France excited an outburst of patriotic resentment +in the Federal Parliament at Berlin. The population of Luxemburg was indeed +not wholly German, and it had shown the strongest disinclination to enter +the North German league; but the connection of the Duchy with Germany in +the past was close enough to explain the indignation roused by Napoleon's +project among politicians who little suspected that during the previous +year Bismarck himself had cordially recommended this annexation, and that +up to the last moment he had been privy to the Emperor's plan. The Prussian +Minister, though he did not affect to share the emotion of his countrymen, +stated that his policy in regard to Luxemburg must be influenced by the +opinion of the Federal Parliament, and he shortly afterwards caused it to +be understood at Paris that the annexation of the Duchy to France was +impossible. As a warning to France he had already published the Treaties of +alliance between Prussia and the South German States, which had been made +at the close of the war of 1866, but had hitherto been kept secret. [530] +Other powers now began to tender their good offices. Count Beust, on behalf +of Austria, suggested that Luxemburg should be united to Belgium, which in +its turn should cede a small district to France. This arrangement, which +would have been accepted at Berlin, and which, by soothing the irritation +produced in France by Prussia's successes, would possibly have averted the +war of 1870, was frustrated by the refusal of the King of Belgium to part +with any of his territory--Napoleon, disclaiming all desire for territorial +extension, now asked only for the withdrawal of the Prussian garrison from +Luxemburg; but it was known that he was determined to enforce this demand +by arms. The Russian Government proposed that the question should be +settled by a Conference of the Powers at London. This proposal was accepted +under certain conditions by France and Prussia, and the Conference +assembled on the 7th of May. Its deliberations were completed in four days, +and the results were summed up in the Treaty of London signed on the 11th. +By this Treaty the Duchy of Luxemburg was declared neutral territory under +the collective guarantee of the Powers. Prussia withdrew its garrison, and +the King of Holland, who continued to be sovereign of the Duchy, undertook +to demolish the fortifications of Luxemburg, and to maintain it in the +future as an open town. [531] + +[Exasperation in France against Prussia.] + +Of the politicians of France, those who even affected to regard the +aggrandisement of Prussia and the union of Northern Germany with +indifference or satisfaction were a small minority. Among these was the +Emperor, who, after his attempts to gain a Rhenish Province had been +baffled, sought to prove in an elaborate State-paper that France had won +more than it had lost by the extinction of the German Federation as +established in 1815, and by the dissolution of the tie that had bound +Austria and Prussia together as members of this body. The events of 1866 +had, he contended, broken up a system devised in evil days for the purpose +of uniting Central Europe against France, and had restored to the Continent +the freedom of alliances; in other words, they had made it possible for the +South German States to connect themselves with France. If this illusion was +really entertained by the Emperor, it was rudely dispelled by the discovery +of the Treaties between Prussia and the Southern States and by their +publication in the spring of 1867. But this revelation was not necessary to +determine the attitude of the great majority of those who passed for the +representatives of independent political opinion in France. The Ministers +indeed were still compelled to imitate the Emperor's optimism, and a few +enlightened men among the Opposition understood that France must be content +to see the Germans effect their national unity; but the great body of +unofficial politicians, to whatever party they belonged, joined in the +bitter outcry raised at once against the aggressive Government of Prussia +and the feeble administration at Paris, which had not found the means to +prevent, or had actually facilitated, Prussia's successes. Thiers, who more +than any one man had by his writings popularised the Napoleonic legend and +accustomed the French to consider themselves entitled to a monopoly of +national greatness on the Rhine, was the severest critic of the Emperor, +the most zealous denouncer of the work which Bismarck had effected. It was +only with too much reason that the Prussian Government looked forward to an +attack by France at some earlier or later time as almost certain, and +pressed forward the military organisation which was to give to Germany an +army of unheard-of efficiency and strength. + +[France and Prussia after 1867.] + +There appears to be no evidence that Napoleon III. himself desired to +attack Prussia so long as that Power should strictly observe the +stipulations of the Treaty of Prague which provided for the independence of +the South German States. But the current of events irresistibly impelled +Germany to unity. The very Treaty which made the river Main the limit of +the North German Confederacy reserved for the Southern States the right of +attaching themselves to those of the North by some kind of national tie. +Unless the French Emperor was resolved to acquiesce in the gradual +development of this federal unity until, as regarded the foreigner, the +North and the South of Germany should be a single body, he could have no +confident hope of lasting peace. To have thus anticipated and accepted the +future, to have removed once and for all the sleepless fears of Prussia by +the frank recognition of its right to give all Germany effective Union, +would have been an act too great and too wise in reality, too weak and +self-renouncing in appearance, for any chief of a rival nation. Napoleon +did not take this course; on the other hand, not desiring to attack Prussia +while it remained within the limits of the Treaty of Prague, he refrained +from seeking alliances with the object of immediate and aggressive action. +The diplomacy of the Emperor during the period from 1866 to 1870 is indeed +still but imperfectly known; but it would appear that his efforts were +directed only to the formation of alliances with the view of eventual +action when Prussia should have passed the limits which the Emperor himself +or public opinion in Paris should, as interpreter of the Treaty of Prague, +impose upon this Power in its dealings with the South German States. + +[Negotiations with Austria, 1868-69.] + +The Governments to which Napoleon could look for some degree of support +were those of Austria and Italy. Count Beust, now Chancellor of the +Austrian Monarchy, was a bitter enemy to Prussia, and a rash and +adventurous politician, to whom the very circumstance of his sudden +elevation from the petty sphere of Saxon politics gave a certain levity and +unconstraint in the handling of great affairs. He cherished the idea of +recovering Austria's ascendency in Germany, and was disposed to repel the +extension of Russian influence westwards by boldly encouraging the Poles to +seek for the satisfaction of their national hopes in Galicia under the +Hapsburg Crown. To Count Beust France was the most natural of all allies. +On the other hand, the very system which Beust had helped to establish in +Hungary raised serious obstacles against the adoption of his own policy. +Andrassy, the Hungarian Minister, while sharing Beust's hostility to +Russia, declared that his countrymen had no interest in restoring Austria's +German connection, and were in fact better without it. In these +circumstances the negotiations of the French and the Austrian Emperor were +conducted by a private correspondence. The interchange of letters continued +during the years 1868 and 1869, and resulted in a promise made by Napoleon +to support Austria if it should be attacked by Prussia, while the Emperor +Francis Joseph promised to assist France if it should be attacked by +Prussia and Russia together. No Treaty was made, but a general assurance +was exchanged between the two Emperors that they would pursue a common +policy and treat one another's interests as their own. With the view of +forming a closer understanding the Archduke Albrecht visited Paris in +February, 1870, and a French general was sent to Vienna to arrange the plan +of campaign in case of war with Prussia. In such a war, if undertaken by +the two Powers, it was hoped that Italy would join. [532] + +[Italy after 1866.] + +[Mentana, Nov. 3, 1867.] + +The alliance of 1866 between Prussia and Italy had left behind it in each +of these States more of rancour than of good-will. La Marmora had from the +beginning to the end been unfortunate in his relations with Berlin. He had +entered into the alliance with suspicion; he would gladly have seen Venetia +given to Italy by a European Congress without war; and when hostilities +broke out, he had disregarded and resented what he considered an attempt of +the Prussian Government to dictate to him the military measures to be +pursued. On the other hand, the Prussians charged the Italian Government +with having deliberately held back its troops after the battle of Custozza +in pursuance of arrangements made between Napoleon and the Austrian Emperor +on the voluntary cession of Venice, and with having endangered or minimised +Prussia's success by enabling the Austrians to throw a great part of their +Italian forces northwards. There was nothing of that comradeship between +the Italian and the Prussian armies which is acquired on the field of +battle. The personal sympathies of Victor Emmanuel were strongly on the +side of the French Emperor; and when, at the close of the year 1866, the +French garrison was withdrawn from Rome in pursuance of the convention made +in September, 1864, it seemed probable that France and Italy might soon +unite in a close alliance. But in the following year the attempts of the +Garibaldians to overthrow the Papal Government, now left without its +foreign defenders, embroiled Napoleon and the Italian people. Napoleon was +unable to defy the clerical party in France; he adopted the language of +menace in his communications with the Italian Cabinet; and when, in the +autumn of 1867, the Garibaldians actually invaded the Roman States, he +despatched a body of French troops under General Failly to act in support +of those of the Pope. An encounter took place at Mentana on November 3rd, +in which the Garibaldians, after defeating the Papal forces, were put to +the rout by General Failly. The occupation of Civita Vecchia was renewed, +and in the course of the debates raised at Paris on the Italian policy of +the Government, the Prime Minister, M. Rouher, stated, with the most +passionate emphasis that, come what might, Italy should never possess +itself of Rome. "Never," he cried, "will France tolerate such an outrage on +its honour and its dignity." [533] + +[Napoleon and Italy after Mentana.] + +[Italy and Austria.] + +The affair of Mentana, the insolent and heartless language in which General +Failly announced his success, the reoccupation of Roman territory by French +troops, and the declaration made by M. Rouher in the French Assembly, +created wide and deep anger in Italy, and made an end for the time of all +possibility of a French alliance. Napoleon was indeed, as regarded Italy, +in an evil case. By abandoning Rome he would have turned against himself +and his dynasty the whole clerical interest in France, whose confidence he +had already to some extent forfeited by his policy in 1860; on the other +hand, it was vain for him to hope for the friendship of Italy whilst he +continued to bar the way to the fulfilment of the universal national +desire. With the view of arriving at some compromise he proposed a European +Conference on the Roman question; but this was resisted above all by Count +Bismarck, whose interest it was to keep the sore open; and neither England +nor Russia showed any anxiety to help the Pope's protector out of his +difficulties. Napoleon sought by a correspondence with Victor Emmanuel +during 1868 and 1869 to pave the way for a defensive alliance; but Victor +Emmanuel was in reality as well as in name a constitutional king, and +probably could not, even if he had desired, have committed Italy to +engagements disapproved by the Ministry and Parliament. It was made clear +to Napoleon that the evacuation of the Papal States must precede any treaty +of alliance between France and Italy. Whether the Italian Government would +have been content with a return to the conditions of the September +Convention, or whether it made the actual possession of Rome the price of a +treaty-engagement, is uncertain; but inasmuch as Napoleon was not at +present prepared to evacuate Civita Vecchia, he could aim at nothing more +than some eventual concert when the existing difficulties should have been +removed. The Court of Vienna now became the intermediary between the two +Powers who had united against it in 1859. Count Beust was free from the +associations which had made any approach to friendship with the kingdom of +Victor Emmanuel impossible for his predecessors. He entered into +negotiations at Florence, which resulted in the conclusion of an agreement +between the Austrian and the Italian Governments that they would act +together and guarantee one another's territories in the event of a war +between France and Prussia. This agreement was made with the assent of the +Emperor Napoleon, and was understood to be preparatory to an accord with +France itself; but it was limited to a defensive character, and it implied +that any eventual concert with France must be arranged by the two Powers in +combination with one another. [534] + +[Isolation of France.] + +At the beginning of 1870 the Emperor Napoleon was therefore without any +more definite assurance of support in a war with Prussia than the promise +of the Austrian Sovereign that he would assist France if attacked by +Prussia and Russia together, and that he would treat the interests of +France as his own. By withdrawing his protection from Rome Napoleon had +undoubtedly a fair chance of building up this shadowy and remote engagement +into a defensive alliance with both Austria and Italy. But perfect +clearness and resolution of purpose, as well as the steady avoidance of all +quarrels on mere incidents, were absolutely indispensable to the creation +and the employment of such a league against the Power which alone it could +have in view; and Prussia had now little reason to fear any such exercise +of statesmanship on the part of Napoleon. The solution of the Roman +question, in other words the withdrawal of the French garrison from Roman +territory, could proceed only from some stronger stimulus than the +declining force of Napoleon's own intelligence and will could now supply. +This fatal problem baffled his attempts to gain alliances; and yet the +isolation of France was but half acknowledged, but half understood; and a +host of rash, vainglorious spirits impatiently awaited the hour that should +call them to their revenge on Prussia for the triumphs in which it had not +permitted France to share. + +[Germany, 1867-1870.] + +Meanwhile on the other side Count Bismarck advanced with what was most +essential in his relations with the States of Southern Germany--the +completion of the Treaties of Alliance by conventions assimilating the +military systems of these States to that of Prussia. A Customs-Parliament +was established for the whole of Germany, which, it was hoped, would be the +precursor of a National Assembly uniting the North and the South of the +Main. But in spite of this military and commercial approximation, the +progress towards union was neither so rapid nor so smooth as the patriots +of the North could desire. There was much in the harshness and +self-assertion of the Prussian character that repelled the less disciplined +communities of the South. Ultramontanism was strong in Bavaria; and +throughout the minor States the most advanced of the Liberals were opposed +to a closer union with Berlin, from dislike of its absolutist traditions +and the heavy hand of its Government. Thus the tendency known as +Particularism was supported in Bavaria and Wuertemberg by classes of the +population who in most respects were in antagonism to one another; nor +could the memories of the campaign of 1866 and the old regard for Austria +be obliterated in a day. Bismarck did not unduly press on the work of +consolidation. He marked and estimated the force of the obstacles which too +rapid a development of his national policy would encounter. It is possible +that he may even have seen indications that religious and other influences +might imperil the military union which he had already established, and that +he may not have been unwilling to call to his aid, as the surest of all +preparatives for national union, the event which he had long believed to be +inevitable at some time or other in the future, a war with France. + +[The Spanish candidature of Leopold of Hohenzollern.] + +[Leopold accepts the Spanish Crown, July 3, 1870.] + +Since the autumn of 1868 the throne of Spain had been vacant in consequence +of a revolution in which General Prim had been the leading actor. It was +not easy to discover a successor for the Bourbon Isabella; and after other +candidatures had been vainly projected it occurred to Prim and his friends +early in 1869 that a suitable candidate might be found in Prince Leopold of +Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen, whose elder brother had been made Prince of +Roumania, and whose father, Prince Antony, had been Prime Minister of +Prussia in 1859. The House of Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen was so distantly +related to the reigning family of Prussia that the name alone preserved the +memory of the connection; and in actual blood-relationship Prince Leopold +was much more nearly allied to the French Houses of Murat and Beauharnais. +But the Sigmaringen family was distinctly Prussian by interest and +association, and its chief, Antony, had not only been at the head of the +Prussian Administration himself, but had, it is said, been the first to +suggest the appointment of Bismarck to the same office. The candidature of +a Hohenzollern might reasonably be viewed in France as an attempt to +connect Prussia politically with Spain; and with so much reserve was this +candidature at the first handled at Berlin that, in answer to inquiries +made by Benedetti in the spring of 1869, the Secretary of State who +represented Count Bismarck stated on his word of honour that the +candidature had never been suggested. The affair was from first to last +ostensibly treated at Berlin as one with which the Prussian Government was +wholly unconcerned, and in which King William was interested only as head +of the family to which Prince Leopold belonged. For twelve months after +Benedetti's inquiries it appeared as if the project had been entirely +abandoned; it was, however, revived in the spring of 1870, and on the 3rd +of July the announcement was made at Paris that Prince Leopold had +consented to accept the Crown of Spain if the Cortes should confirm his +election. + +[French Declaration, July 6.] + +At once there broke out in the French Press a storm of indignation against +Prussia. The organs of the Government took the lead in exciting public +opinion. On the 6th of July the Duke of Gramont, Foreign Minister, declared +to the Legislative Body that the attempt of a Foreign Power to place one of +its Princes on the throne of Charles V. imperilled the interests and the +honour of France, and that, if such a contingency were realised, the +Government would fulfil its duty without hesitation and without weakness. +The violent and unsparing language of this declaration, which had been +drawn up at a Council of Ministers under the Emperor's presidency, proved +that the Cabinet had determined either to humiliate Prussia or to take +vengeance by arms. It was at once seen by foreign diplomatists, who during +the preceding days had been disposed to assist in removing a reasonable +subject of complaint, how little was the chance of any peaceable settlement +after such a public challenge had been issued to Prussia in the Emperor's +name. One means of averting war alone seemed possible, the voluntary +renunciation by Prince Leopold of the offered Crown. To obtain this +renunciation became the task of those who, unlike the French Minister of +Foreign Affairs, were anxious to preserve peace. + +[Ollivier's Ministry.] + +The parts that were played at this crisis by the individuals who most +influenced the Emperor Napoleon are still but imperfectly known; but there +is no doubt that from the beginning to the end the Duke of Gramont, with +short intermissions, pressed with insane ardour for war. The Ministry now +in office had been called to their places in January, 1870, after the +Emperor had made certain changes in the constitution in a Liberal +direction, and had professed to transfer the responsibility of power from +himself to a body of advisers possessing the confidence of the Chamber. +Ollivier, formerly one of the leaders of the Opposition, had accepted the +Presidency of the Cabinet. His colleagues were for the most part men new to +official life, and little able to hold their own against such +representatives of unreformed Imperialism as the Duke of Gramont and the +War-Minister Leboeuf who sat beside them. Ollivier himself was one of the +few politicians in France who understood that his countrymen must be +content to see German unity established whether they liked it or not. He +was entirely averse from war with Prussia on the question which had now +arisen; but the fear that public opinion would sweep away a Liberal +Ministry which hesitated to go all lengths in patriotic extravagance led +him to sacrifice his own better judgment, and to accept the responsibility +for a policy which in his heart he disapproved. Gramont's rash hand was +given free play. Instructions were sent to Benedetti to seek the King of +Prussia at Ems, where he was taking the waters, and to demand from him, as +the only means of averting war, that he should order the Hohenzollern +Prince to revoke his acceptance of the Crown. "We are in great haste," +Gramont added, "for we must gain the start in case of an unsatisfactory +reply, and commence the movement of troops by Saturday in order to enter +upon the campaign in a fortnight. Be on your guard against an answer merely +leaving the Prince of Hohenzollern to his fate, and disclaiming on the part +of the King any interest in his future." [535] + +[Benedetti and King William at Ems, July 9-14.] + +Benedetti's first interview with the King was on the 9th of July. He +informed the King of the emotion that had been caused in France by the +candidature of the Hohenzollern Prince; he dwelt on the value to both +countries of the friendly relation between France and Prussia; and, while +studiously avoiding language that might wound or irritate the King, he +explained to him the requirements of the Government at Paris. The King had +learnt beforehand what would be the substance of Benedetti's communication. +He had probably been surprised and grieved at the serious consequences +which Prince Leopold's action had produced in France; and although he had +determined not to submit to dictation from Paris or to order Leopold to +abandon his candidature, he had already, as it seems, taken steps likely to +render the preservation of peace more probable. At the end of a +conversation with the Ambassador, in which he asserted his complete +independence as head of the family of Hohenzollern, he informed Benedetti +that he had entered into communication with Leopold and his father, and +that he expected shortly to receive a despatch from Sigmaringen. Benedetti +rightly judged that the King, while positively refusing to meet Gramont's +demands, was yet desirous of finding some peaceable way out of the +difficulty; and the report of this interview which he sent to Paris was +really a plea in favour of good sense and moderation. But Gramont was +little disposed to accept such counsels. "I tell you plainly," he wrote to +Benedetti on the next day, "public opinion is on fire, and will leave us +behind it. We must begin; we wait only for your despatch to call up the +three hundred thousand men who are waiting the summons. Write, telegraph, +something definite. If the King will not counsel the Prince of Hohenzollern +to resign, well, it is immediate war, and in a few days we are on the +Rhine." + +[Leopold withdraws, July 12.] + +[Guarantee against renewal demanded.] + +[Benedetti and the King, July 13.] + +Nevertheless Benedetti's advice was not without its influence on the +Emperor and his Ministers. Napoleon, himself wavering from hour to hour, +now inclined to the peace-party, and during the 11th there was a pause in +the military preparations that had been begun. On the 12th the efforts of +disinterested Governments, probably also the suggestions of the King of +Prussia himself, produced their effects. A telegram was received at Madrid +from Prince Antony stating that his son's candidature was withdrawn. A few +hours later Ollivier announced the news in the Legislative Chamber at +Paris, and exchanged congratulations with the friends of peace, who +considered that the matter was now at an end. But this pacific conclusion +little suited either the war-party or the Bonapartists of the old type, who +grudged to a Constitutional Ministry so substantial a diplomatic success. +They at once declared that the retirement of Prince Leopold was a secondary +matter, and that the real question was what guarantees had been received +from Prussia against a renewal of the candidature. Gramont himself, in an +interview with the Prussian Ambassador, Baron Werther, sketched a letter +which he proposed that King William should send to the Emperor, stating +that in sanctioning the candidature of Prince Leopold he had not intended +to offend the French, and that in associating himself with the Prince's +withdrawal he desired that all misunderstandings should be at an end +between the two Governments. The despatch of Baron Werther conveying this +proposition appears to have deeply offended King William, whom it reached +about midday on the 13th. Benedetti had that morning met the King on the +promenade at Ems, and had received from him the promise that as soon as the +letter which was still on its way from Sigmaringen should arrive he would +send for the Ambassador in order that he might communicate its contents at +Paris. The letter arrived; but Baron Werther's despatch from Paris had +arrived before it; and instead of summoning Benedetti as he had promised, +the King sent one of his aides-de-camp to him with a message that a written +communication had been received from Prince Leopold confirming his +withdrawal, and that the matter was now at an end. Benedetti desired the +aide-de-camp to inform the King that he was compelled by his instructions +to ask for a guarantee against a renewal of the candidature. The +aide-de-camp did as he was requested, and brought back a message that the +King gave his entire approbation to the withdrawal of the Prince of +Hohenzollern, but that he could do no more. Benedetti begged for an +audience with His Majesty. The King replied that he was compelled to +decline entering into further negotiation, and that he had said his last +word. Though the King thus refused any further discussion, perfect courtesy +was observed on both sides; and on the following morning the King and the +Ambassador, who were both leaving Ems, took leave of one another at the +railway station with the usual marks of respect. + +[Publication of the telegram from Ems, July 13.] + +[War decided at Paris, July 14.] + +That the guarantee which the French Government had resolved to demand would +not be given was now perfectly certain; yet, with the candidature of Prince +Leopold fairly extinguished, it was still possible that the cooler heads at +Paris might carry the day, and that the Government would stop short of +declaring war on a point on which the unanimous judgment of the other +Powers declared it to be in the wrong. But Count Bismarck was determined +not to let the French escape lightly from the quarrel. He had to do with an +enemy who by his own folly had come to the brink of an aggressive war, and, +far from facilitating his retreat, it was Bismarck's policy to lure him +over the precipice. Not many hours after the last message had passed +between King William and Benedetti, a telegram was officially published at +Berlin, stating, in terms so brief as to convey the impression of an actual +insult, that the King had refused to see the French Ambassador, and had +informed him by an aide-de-camp that he had nothing more to communicate to +him. This telegram was sent to the representatives of Prussia at most of +the European Courts, and to its agents in every German capital. Narratives +instantly gained currency, and were not contradicted by the Prussian +Government, that Benedetti had forced himself upon the King on the +promenade at Ems, and that in the presence of a large company the King had +turned his back upon the Ambassador. The publication of the alleged +telegram from Ems became known in Paris on the 14th. On that day the +Council of Ministers met three times. At the first meeting the advocates of +peace were still in the majority; in the afternoon, as the news from Berlin +and the fictions describing the insult offered to the French Ambassador +spread abroad, the agitation in Paris deepened, and the Council decided +upon calling up the Reserves; yet the Emperor himself seemed still disposed +for peace. It was in the interval between the second and the third meeting +of the Council, between the hours of six and ten in the evening, that +Napoleon finally gave way before the threats and importunities of the +war-party. The Empress, fanatically anxious for the overthrow of a great +Protestant Power, passionately eager for the military glory which alone +could insure the Crown to her son, won the triumph which she was so +bitterly to rue. At the third meeting of the Council, held shortly before +midnight, the vote was given for war. + +In Germany this decision had been expected; yet it made a deep impression +not only on the German people but on Europe at large that, when the +declaration of war was submitted to the French Legislative Body in the form +of a demand for supplies, no single voice was raised to condemn the war for +its criminality and injustice: the arguments which were urged against it by +M. Thiers and others were that the Government had fixed upon a bad cause, +and that the occasion was inopportune. Whether the majority of the Assembly +really desired war is even now matter of doubt. But the clamour of a +hundred madmen within its walls, the ravings of journalists and +incendiaries, who at such a time are to the true expression of public +opinion what the Spanish Inquisition was to the Christian religion, +paralysed the will and the understanding of less infatuated men. Ten votes +alone were given in the Assembly against the grant demanded for war; to +Europe at large it went out that the crime and the madness was that of +France as a nation. Yet Ollivier and many of his colleagues up to the last +moment disapproved of the war, and consented to it only because they +believed that the nation would otherwise rush into hostilities under a +reactionary Ministry who would serve France worse than themselves. They +found when it was too late that the supposed national impulse, which they +had thought irresistible, was but the outcry of a noisy minority. The +reports of their own officers informed them that in sixteen alone out of +the eighty-seven Departments of France was the war popular. In the other +seventy-one it was accepted either with hesitation or regret. [536] + +[Initial forces of either side.] + +[Expected Alliances of France.] + +[Austria preparing.] + +How vast were the forces which the North German Confederation could bring +into the field was well known to Napoleon's Government. Benedetti had kept +his employers thoroughly informed of the progress of the North German +military organisation; he had warned them that the South German States +would most certainly act with the North against a foreign assailant; he had +described with great accuracy and great penetration the nature of the tie +that existed between Berlin and St. Petersburg, a tie which was close +enough to secure for Prussia the goodwill, and in certain contingencies the +armed support, of Russia, while it was loose enough not to involve Prussia +in any Muscovite enterprise that would bring upon it the hostility of +England and Austria. The utmost force which the French military +administration reckoned on placing in the field at the beginning of the +campaign was two hundred and fifty thousand men, to be raised at the end of +three weeks by about fifty thousand more. The Prussians, even without +reckoning on any assistance from Southern Germany, and after allowing for +three army-corps that might be needed to watch Austria and Denmark, could +begin the campaign with three hundred and thirty thousand. Army to army, +the French thus stood according to the reckoning of their own War Office +outnumbered at the outset; but Leboeuf, the War-Minister, imagined that the +Foreign Office had made sure of alliances, and that a great part of the +Prussian Army would not be free to act on the western frontier. Napoleon +had in fact pushed forward his negotiations with Austria and Italy from the +time that war became imminent. Count Beust, while clearly laying it down +that Austria was not bound to follow France into a war made at its own +pleasure, nevertheless felt some anxiety lest France and Prussia should +settle their differences at Austria's expense; moreover from the victory of +Napoleon, assisted in any degree by himself, he could fairly hope for the +restoration of Austria's ascendency in Germany and the undoing of the work +of 1866. It was determined at a Council held at Vienna on the 18th of July +that Austria should for the present be neutral if Russia should not enter +the war on the side of Prussia; but this neutrality was nothing more than a +stage towards alliance with France if at the end of a certain brief period +the army of Napoleon should have penetrated into Southern Germany. In a +private despatch to the Austrian Ambassador at Paris Count Beust pointed +out that the immediate participation of Austria in the war would bring +Russia into the field on King William's side. "To keep Russia neutral," he +wrote, "till the season is sufficiently advanced to prevent the +concentration of its troops must be at present our object; but this +neutrality is nothing more than a means for arriving at the real end of our +policy, the only means for completing our preparations without exposing +ourselves to premature attack by Prussia or Russia." He added that Austria +had already entered into a negotiation with Italy with a view to the armed +mediation of the two Powers, and strongly recommended the Emperor to place +the Italians in possession of Rome. [537] + +[France, Austria, and Italy.] + +Negotiations were now pressed forward between Paris, Florence, and Vienna, +for the conclusion of a triple alliance. Of the course taken by these +negotiations contradictory accounts are given by the persons concerned in +them. According to Prince Napoleon, Victor Emmanuel demanded possession of +Rome and this was refused to him by the French Emperor, in consequence of +which the project of alliance failed. According to the Duke of Gramont, no +more was demanded by Italy than the return to the conditions of the +September Convention; this was agreed to by the Emperor, and it was in +pursuance of this agreement that the Papal States were evacuated by their +French garrison on the 2nd of August. Throughout the last fortnight of +July, after war had actually been declared, there was, if the statement of +Gramont is to be trusted, a continuous interchange of notes, projects, and +telegrams between the three Governments. The difficulties raised by Italy +and Austria were speedily removed, and though some weeks were needed by +these Powers for their military preparations, Napoleon was definitely +assured of their armed support in case of his preliminary success. It was +agreed that Austria and Italy, assuming at the first the position of armed +neutrality, should jointly present an ultimatum to Prussia in September +demanding the exact performance of the Treaty of Prague, and, failing its +compliance with this summons in the sense understood by its enemies, that +the two Powers would immediately declare war, their armies taking the field +at latest on the 15th of September. That Russia would in that case assist +Prussia was well known; but it would seem that Count Beust feared little +from his northern enemy in an autumn campaign. The draft of the Treaty +between Italy and Austria had actually, according to Gramont's statement, +been accepted by the two latter Powers, and received its last amendments in +a negotiation between the Emperor Napoleon and an Italian envoy, Count +Vimercati, at Metz. Vimercati reached Florence with the amended draft on +the 4th of August, and it was expected that the Treaty would be signed on +the following day. When that day came it saw the forces of the French +Empire dashed to pieces. [538] + +[Prussian Plans.] + +Preparations for a war with France had long occupied the general staff at +Berlin. Before the winter of 1868 a memoir had been drawn up by General +Moltke, containing plans for the concentration of the whole of the German +forces, for the formation of each of the armies to be employed, and the +positions to be occupied at the outset by each corps. On the basis of this +memoir the arrangements for the transport of each corps from its depot to +the frontier had subsequently been worked out in such minute detail that +when, on the 16th of July, King William gave the order for mobilisation, +nothing remained but to insert in the railway time-tables and +marching-orders the day on which the movement was to commence. This +minuteness of detail extended, however, only to that part of Moltke's plan +which related to the assembling and first placing of the troops. The events +of the campaign could not thus be arranged and tabulated beforehand; only +the general object and design could be laid down. That the French would +throw themselves with great rapidity upon Southern Germany was considered +probable. The armies of Baden, Wuertemberg, and Bavaria were too weak, the +military centres of the North were too far distant, for effective +resistance to be made in this quarter to the first blows of the invader. +Moltke therefore recommended that the Southern troops should withdraw from +their own States and move northwards to join those of Prussia in the +Palatinate or on the Middle Rhine, so that the entire forces of Germany +should be thrown upon the flank or rear of the invader; while, in the event +of the French not thus taking the offensive, France itself was to be +invaded by the collective strength of Germany along the line from +Saarbruecken to Landau, and its armies were to be cut off from their +communications with Paris by vigorous movements of the invader in a +northerly direction. [539] + +[German mobilisation.] + +The military organisation of Germany is based on the division of the +country into districts, each of which furnishes at its own depot a small +but complete army. The nucleus of each such corps exists in time of peace, +with its own independent artillery, stores, and material of war. On the +order for mobilisation being given, every man liable to military service, +but not actually serving, joins the regiment to which he locally belongs, +and in a given number of days each corps is ready to take the field in full +strength. The completion of each corps at its own depot is the first stage +in the preparation for a campaign. Not till this is effected does the +movement of troops towards the frontier begin. The time necessary for the +first act of preparation was, like that to be occupied in transport, +accurately determined by the Prussian War Office. It resulted from General +Moltke's calculations that, the order of mobilisation having been given on +the 16th of July, the entire army with which it was intended to begin the +campaign would be collected and in position ready to cross the frontier on +the 4th of August, if the French should not have taken up the offensive +before that day. But as it was apprehended that part at least of the French +army would be thrown into Germany before that date, the westward movement +of the German troops stopped short at a considerable distance from the +border, in order that the troops first arriving might not be exposed to the +attack of a superior force before their supports should be at hand. On the +actual frontier there was placed only the handful of men required for +reconnoitring, and for checking the enemy during the few hours that would +be necessary to guard against the effect of a surprise. + +[The French Army.] + +The French Emperor was aware of the numerical inferiority of his army to +that of Prussia; he hoped, however, by extreme rapidity of movement to +penetrate Southern Germany before the Prussian army could assemble, and so, +while forcing the Southern Governments to neutrality, to meet on the Upper +Danube the assisting forces of Italy and Austria. It was his design to +concentrate a hundred and fifty thousand men at Metz, a hundred thousand at +Strasburg, and with these armies united to cross the Rhine into Baden; +while a third army, which was to assemble at Chalons, protected the +north-eastern frontier against an advance of the Prussians. A few days +after the declaration of war, while the German corps were still at their +depots in the interior, considerable forces were massed round Metz and +Strasburg. All Europe listened for the rush of the invader and the first +swift notes of triumph from a French army beyond the Rhine; but week after +week passed, and the silence was still unbroken. Stories, incredible to +those who first heard them, yet perfectly true, reached the German +frontier-stations of actual famine at the advanced posts of the enemy, and +of French soldiers made prisoners while digging in potato-fields to keep +themselves alive. That Napoleon was less ready than had been anticipated +became clear to all the world; but none yet imagined the revelations which +each successive day was bringing at the headquarters of the French armies. +Absence of whole regiments that figured in the official order of battle, +defective transport, stores missing or congested, made it impossible even +to attempt the inroad into Southern Germany within the date up to which it +had any prospect of success. The design was abandoned, yet not in time to +prevent the troops that were hurrying from the interior from being sent +backwards and forwards according as the authorities had, or had not, heard +of the change of plan. Napoleon saw that a Prussian force was gathering on +the Middle Rhine which it would be madness to leave on his flank; he +ordered his own commanders to operate on the corresponding line of the +Lauter and the Saar, and despatched isolated divisions to the very +frontier, still uncertain whether even in this direction he would be able +to act on the offensive, or whether nothing now remained to him but to +resist the invasion of France by a superior enemy. Ollivier had stated in +the Assembly that he and his colleagues entered upon the war with a light +heart; he might have added that they entered upon it with bandaged eyes. +The Ministers seem actually not to have taken the trouble to exchange +explanations with one another. Leboeuf, the War-Minister, had taken it +for granted that Gramont had made arrangements with Austria which would +compel the Prussians to keep a large part of their forces in the interior. +Gramont, in forcing on the quarrel with Prussia, and in his negotiations +with Austria, had taken it for granted that Leboeuf could win a series of +victories at the outset in Southern Germany. The Emperor, to whom alone the +entire data of the military and the diplomatic services of France were +open, was incapable of exertion or scrutiny, purposeless, distracted with +pain, half-imbecile. + +[Causes of French military inferiority.] + +That the Imperial military administration was rotten to the core the +terrible events of the next few weeks sufficiently showed. Men were in high +place whose antecedents would have shamed the better kind of brigand. The +deficiencies of the army were made worse by the diversion of public funds +to private necessities; the looseness, the vulgar splendour, the base +standards of judgment of the Imperial Court infected each branch of the +public services of France, and worked perhaps not least on those who were +in military command. But the catastrophe of 1870 seemed to those who +witnessed it to tell of more than the vileness of an administration; in +England, not less than in Germany, voices of influence spoke of the doom +that had overtaken the depravity of a sunken nation; of the triumph of +simple manliness, of Godfearing virtue itself, in the victories of the +German army. There may have been truth in this; yet it would require a nice +moral discernment to appraise the exact degeneracy of the French of 1870 +from the French of 1854 who humbled Russia, or from the French of 1859 who +triumphed at Solferino; and it would need a very comprehensive acquaintance +with the lower forms of human pleasure to judge in what degree the +sinfulness of Paris exceeds the sinfulness of Berlin. Had the French been +as strict a race as the Spartans who fell at Thermopylae, as devout as the +Tyrolese who perished at Koeniggraetz, it is quite certain that, with the +numbers which took the field against Germany in 1870, with Napoleon III. at +the head of affairs, and the actual generals of 1870 in command, the armies +of France could not have escaped destruction. + +[Cause of German Success.] + +The main cause of the disparity of France and Germany in 1870 was in truth +that Prussia had had from 1862 to 1866 a Government so strong as to be able +to force upon its subjects its own gigantic scheme of military organisation +in defiance of the votes of Parliament and of the national will. In 1866 +Prussia, with a population of nineteen millions, brought actually into the +field three hundred and fifty thousand men, or one in fifty-four of its +inhabitants. There was no other government in Europe, with the possible +exception of Russia, which could have imposed upon its subjects, without +risking its own existence, so vast a burden of military service as that +implied in this strength of the fighting army. Napoleon III. at the height +of his power could not have done so; and when after Koeniggraetz he +endeavoured to raise the forces of France to an equality with those of the +rival Power by a system which would have brought about one in seventy of +the population into the field, his own nominees in the Legislative Body, +under pressure of public opinion, so weakened the scheme that the effective +numbers of the army remained little more than they were before. The true +parallel to the German victories of 1870 is to be found in the victories of +the French Committee of Public Safety in 1794 and in those of the first +Napoleon. A government so powerful as to bend the entire resources of the +State to military ends will, whether it is one of democracy run mad, or of +a crowned soldier of fortune, or of an ancient monarchy throwing new vigour +into its traditional system and policy, crush in the moment of impact +communities of equal or greater resources in which a variety of rival +influences limit and control the central power and subordinate military to +other interests. It was so in the triumphs of the Reign of Terror over the +First Coalition; it was so in the triumphs of King William over Austria and +France. But the parallel between the founders of German unity and the +organisers of victory after 1793 extends no farther than to the sources of +their success. Aggression and adventure have not been the sequels of the +war of 1870. The vast armaments of Prussia were created in order to +establish German union under the House of Hohenzollern, and they have been +employed for no other object. It is the triumph of statesmanship, and it +has been the glory of Prince Bismarck, after thus reaping the fruit of a +well-timed homage to the God of Battles, to know how to quit his shrine. + +[The frontier, Aug. 2.] + +[Saarbruecken, Aug 2.] + +[Weissenburg, Aug 4.] + +[Battle of Woerth, Aug. 6.] + +At the end of July, twelve days after the formal declaration of war, the +gathering forces of the Germans, over three hundred and eighty thousand +strong, were still some distance behind the Lauter and the Saar. Napoleon, +apparently without any clear design, had placed certain bodies of troops +actually on the frontier at Forbach, Weissenburg, and elsewhere, while +other troops, raising the whole number to about two hundred and fifty +thousand, lay round Metz and Strasburg, and at points between these and the +most advanced positions. The reconnoitring of the small German detachments +on the frontier was conducted with extreme energy: the French appear to +have made no reconnaissances at all, for when they determined at last to +discover what was facing them at Saarbruecken, they advanced with +twenty-five thousand men against one-tenth of that number. On the 2nd of +August Frossard's corps from Forbach moved upon Saarbruecken with the +Emperor in person. The garrison was driven out, and the town bombarded, but +even now the reconnaissance was not continued beyond the bridge across the +Saar which divides the two parts of the town. Forty-eight hours later the +alignment of the German forces in their invading order was completed, and +all was ready for an offensive campaign. The central army, commanded by +Prince Frederick Charles, spreading east and west behind Saarbruecken, +touched on its right the northern army commanded by General Steinmetz, on +its left the southern army commanded by the Crown Prince, which covered the +frontier of the Palatinate, and included the troops of Bavaria and +Wuertemberg. The general direction of the three armies was thus from +northwest to south-east. As the line of invasion was to be nearly due west, +it was necessary that the first step forwards should be made by the army of +the Crown Prince in order to bring it more nearly to a level with the +northern corps in the march into France. On the 4th of August the Crown +Prince crossed the Alsatian frontier and moved against Weissenburg. The +French General Douay, who was posted here with about twelve thousand men, +was neither reinforced nor bidden to retire. His troops met the attack of +an enemy many times more numerous with great courage; but the struggle was +a hopeless one, and after several hours of severe fighting the Germans were +masters of the field. Douay fell in the battle; his troops frustrated an +attempt made to cut off their retreat, and fell back southwards towards the +corps of McMahon, which lay about ten miles behind them. The Crown Prince +marched on in search of his enemy, McMahon, who could collect only +forty-five thousand men, desired to retreat until he could gain some +support; but the Emperor, tormented by fears of the political consequences +of the invasion, insisted upon his giving battle. He drew up on the hills +about Woerth, almost on the spot where in 1793 Hoche had overthrown the +armies of the First Coalition. On the 6th of August the leading divisions +of the Crown Prince, about a hundred thousand strong, were within striking +distance. The superiority of the Germans in numbers was so great that +McMahon's army might apparently have been captured or destroyed with far +less loss than actually took place if time had been given for the movements +which the Crown Prince's staff had in view, and for the employment of his +full strength. But the impetuosity of divisional leaders on the morning of +the 6th brought on a general engagement. The resistance of the French was +of the most determined character. With one more army-corps--and the corps +of General Failly was expected to arrive on the field--it seemed as if the +Germans might yet be beaten back. But each hour brought additional forces +into action in the attack, while the French commander looked in vain for +the reinforcements that could save him from ruin. At length, when the last +desperate charges of the Cuirassiers had shattered against the fire of +cannon and needle-guns, and the village of Froschwiller, the centre of the +French position, had been stormed house by house, the entire army broke and +fled in disorder. Nine thousand prisoners, thirty-three cannon, fell into +the hands of the conquerors. The Germans had lost ten thousand men, but +they had utterly destroyed McMahon's army as an organised force. Its +remnant disappeared from the scene of warfare, escaping by the western +roads in the direction of Chalons, where first it was restored to some +degree of order. The Crown Prince, leaving troops behind him to beleaguer +the smaller Alsatian fortresses, marched on untroubled through the northern +Vosges, and descended into the open country about Luneville and Nancy, +unfortified towns which could offer no resistance to the passage of an +enemy. + +[Spicheren, Aug. 6.] + +On the same day that the battle of Woerth was fought, the leading columns of +the armies of Steinmetz and Prince Frederick Charles crossed the frontier +at Saarbruecken. Frossard's corps, on the news of the defeat at Weissenburg, +had withdrawn to its earlier positions between Forbach and the frontier: it +held the steep hills of Spicheren that look down upon Saarbruecken, and the +woods that flank the high road where this passes from Germany into France. +As at Woerth, it was not intended that any general attack should be made on +the 6th; a delay of twenty-four hours would have enabled the Germans to +envelop or crush Frossard's corps with an overwhelming force. But the +leaders of the foremost regiments threw themselves impatiently upon the +French whom they found before them: other brigades hurried up to the sound +of the cannon, until the struggle took the proportion of a battle, and +after hours of fluctuating success the heights of Spicheren were carried by +successive rushes of the infantry full in the enemy's fire. Why Frossard +was not reinforced has never been explained, for several French divisions +lay at no great distance westward, and the position was so strong that, if +a pitched battle was to be fought anywhere east of Metz, few better points +could have been chosen. But, like Douay at Weissenburg, Frossard was left +to struggle alone against whatever forces the Germans might throw upon him. +Napoleon, who directed the operations of the French armies from Metz, +appears to have been now incapable of appreciating the simplest military +necessities, of guarding against the most obvious dangers. Helplessness, +infatuation ruled the miserable hours. + +[Paris after Aug. 6.] + +The impression made upon Europe by the battles of the 6th of August +corresponded to the greatness of their actual military effects. There was +an end to all thoughts of the alliance of Austria and Italy with France. +Germany, though unaware of the full magnitude of the perils from which it +had escaped, breathed freely after weeks of painful suspense; the very +circumstance that the disproportion of numbers on the battle-field of +Woerth was still unknown heightened the joy and confidence produced by the +Crown Prince's victory, a victory in which the South German troops, +fighting by the side of those who had been their foes in 1866, had borne +their full part. In Paris the consternation with which the news of +McMahon's overthrow was received was all the greater that on the previous +day reports had been circulated of a victory won at Landau and of the +capture of the Crown Prince with his army. The bulletin of the Emperor, +briefly narrating McMahon's defeat and the repulse of Frossard, showed in +its concluding words--"All may yet be retrieved"--how profound was the +change made in the prospects of the war by that fatal day. The truth was +at once apprehended. A storm of indignation broke out against the +Imperial Government at Paris. The Chambers were summoned. Ollivier, +attacked alike by the extreme Bonapartists and by the Opposition, laid +down his office. A reactionary Ministry, headed by the Count of Palikao, +was placed in power by the Empress, a Ministry of the last hour as it was +justly styled by all outside it. Levies were ordered, arms and stores +accumulated for the reserve-forces, preparations made for a siege of +Paris itself. On the 12th the Emperor gave up the command which he had +exercised with such miserable results, and appointed Marshal Bazaine, one +of the heroes of the Mexican Expedition, General-in-Chief of the Army of +the Rhine. + +[Napoleon at Metz. Aug. 7-11.] + +[Borny, Aug 14.] + +After the overthrow of McMahon and the victory of the Germans at Spicheren, +there seems to have been a period of utter paralysis in the French +headquarters at Metz. The divisions of Prince Frederick Charles and +Steinmetz did not immediately press forward; it was necessary to allow some +days for the advance of the Crown Prince through the Vosges; and during +these days the French army about Metz, which, when concentrated, numbered +nearly two hundred thousand men, might well have taken the positions +necessary for the defence of Moselle, or in the alternative might have +gained several marches in the retreat towards Verdun and Chalons. Only a +small part of this body had as yet been exposed to defeat. It included in +it the very flower of the French forces, tens of thousands of troops +probably equal to any in Europe, and capable of forming a most formidable +army if united to the reserves which would shortly be collected at Chalons +or nearer Paris. But from the 7th to the 12th of August Napoleon, too cowed +to take the necessary steps for battle in defence of the line of Moselle, +lingered purposeless a id irresolute at Metz, unwilling to fall back from +this fortress. It was not till the 14th that the retreat was begun. By this +time the Germans were close at hand, and their leaders were little disposed +to let the hesitating enemy escape them. While the leading divisions of the +French were crossing the Moselle, Steinmetz hurried forward his troops and +fell upon the French detachments still lying on the south-east of Metz +about Borny and Courcelles. Bazaine suspended his movement of retreat in +order to beat back an assailant who for once seemed to be inferior in +strength. At the close of the day the French commander believed that he had +gained a victory and driven the Germans off their line of advance; in +reality he had allowed himself to be diverted from the passage of the +Moselle at the last hour, while the Germans left under Prince Frederick +Charles gained the river farther south, and actually began to cross it in +order to bar his retreat. + +[Mars-la-Tour, Aug. 15.] + +From Metz westwards there is as far as the village of Gravelotte, which is +seven miles distant, but one direct road; at Gravelotte the road forks, the +southern arm leading towards Verdun by Vionville and Mars-la-Tour, the +northern by Conflans. During the 15th of August the first of Bazaine's +divisions moved as far as Vionville along the southern road; others came +into the neighbourhood of Gravelotte, but two corps which should have +advanced past Gravelotte on to the northern road still lay close to Metz. +The Prussian vanguard was meanwhile crossing the Moselle southwards from +Noveant to Pont-a-Mousson, and hurrying forwards by lines converging on the +road taken by Bazaine. Down to the evening of the 15th it was not supposed +at the Prussian headquarters that Bazaine could be overtaken and brought to +battle nearer than the line of the Meuse; but on the morning of the 16th +the cavalry-detachments which had pushed farthest to the north-west +discovered that the heads of the French columns had still not passed +Mars-la-Tour. An effort was instantly made to seize the road and block the +way before the enemy. The struggle, begun by a handful of combatants on +each side, drew to it regiment after regiment as the French battalions +close at hand came into action, and the Prussians hurried up in wild haste +to support their comrades who were exposed to the attack of an entire army. +The rapidity with which the Prussian generals grasped the situation before +them, the vigour with which they brought up their cavalry over a distance +which no infantry could traverse in the necessary time, and without a +moment's hesitation hurled this cavalry in charge after charge against a +superior foe, mark the battle of Mars-la-Tour as that in which the military +superiority of the Germans was most truly shown. Numbers in this battle had +little to do with the result, for by better generalship Bazaine could +certainly at any one point have overpowered his enemy. But while the +Germans rushed like a torrent upon the true point of attack--that is the +westernmost--Bazaine by some delusion considered it his primary object to +prevent the Germans from thrusting themselves between the retreating army +and Metz, and so kept a great part of his troops inactive about the +fortress. The result was that the Germans, with a loss of sixteen thousand +men, remained at the close of the day masters of the road at Vionville, and +that the French army could not, without winning a victory and breaking +through the enemy's line, resume its retreat along this line. + +[Gravelotte, Aug. 18.] + +It was expected during the 17th that Bazaine would make some attempt to +escape by the northern road, but instead of doing so he fell back on +Gravelotte and the heights between this and Metz, in order to fight a +pitched battle. The position was a well-chosen one; but by midday on the +18th the armies of Steinmetz and Prince Frederick Charles were ranged in +front of Bazaine with a strength of two hundred and fifty thousand men, and +in the judgment of the King these forces were equal to the attack. Again, +as at Woerth, the precipitancy of divisional commanders caused the sacrifice +of whole brigades before the battle was won. While the Saxon corps with +which Moltke intended to deliver his slow but fatal blow upon the enemy's +right flank was engaged in its long northward detour, Steinmetz pushed his +Rhinelanders past the ravine of Gravelotte into a fire where no human being +could survive, and the Guards, pressing forward in column over the smooth +unsheltered slope from St. Marie to St. Privat, sank by thousands without +reaching midway in their course. Until the final blow was dealt by the +Saxon corps from the north flank, the ground which was won by the Prussians +was won principally by their destructive artillery fire: their infantry +attacks had on the whole been repelled, and at Gravelotte itself it had +seemed for a moment as if the French were about to break the assailant's +line. But Bazaine, as on the 16th, steadily kept his reserves at a distance +from the points where their presence was most required, and, according to +his own account, succeeded in bringing into action no more than a hundred +thousand men, or less than two-thirds of the forces under his command. +[540] At the close of the awful day, when the capture of St. Privat by the +Saxons turned the defender's line, the French abandoned all their positions +and drew back within the defences of Metz. + +[McMahon is compelled to attempt Bazaine's relief.] + +The Germans at once proceeded to block all the roads round the fortress, +and Bazaine made no effort to prevent them. At the end of a few days the +line was drawn around him in sufficient strength to resist any sudden +attack. Steinmetz, who was responsible for a great part of the loss +sustained at Gravelotte, was now removed from his command; his army was +united with that under Prince Frederick Charles as the besieging force, +while sixty thousand men, detached from this great mass, were formed into a +separate army under Prince Albert of Saxony, and sent by way of Verdun to +co-operate with the Crown Prince against McMahon. The Government at Paris +knew but imperfectly what was passing around Metz from day to day; it knew, +however, that if Metz should be given up for lost the hour of its own fall +could not be averted. One forlorn hope remained, to throw the army which +McMahon was gathering at Chalons north-eastward to Bazaine's relief, though +the Crown Prince stood between Chalons and Metz, and could reach every +point in the line of march more rapidly than McMahon himself. Napoleon had +quitted Metz on the evening of the 15th; on the 17th a council of war was +held at Chalons, at which it was determined to fall back upon Paris and to +await the attack of the Crown Prince under the forts of the capital. No +sooner was this decision announced to the Government at Paris than the +Empress telegraphed to her husband warning him to consider what would be +the effects of his return, and insisting that an attempt should be made to +relieve Bazaine. [541] McMahon, against his own better judgment, consented +to the northern march. He moved in the first instance to Rheims in order to +conceal his intention from the enemy, but by doing this he lost some days. +On the 23rd, in pursuance of arrangements made with Bazaine, whose +messengers were still able to escape the Prussian watch, he set out +north-eastwards in the direction of Montmedy. + +[German movement northwards, Aug 26.] + +[Battle of Sedan, Sept. 1.] + +[Capitulation of Sedan, Sept. 2.] + +The movement was discovered by the Prussian cavalry and reported at the +headquarters at Bar-le-Duc on the 25th. Instantly the westward march of the +Crown Prince was arrested, and his army, with that of the Prince of Saxony, +was thrown northwards in forced marches towards Sedan. On reaching Le +Chesne, west of the Meuse, on the 27th, McMahon became aware of the enemy's +presence. He saw that his plan was discovered, and resolved to retreat +westwards before it was too late. The Emperor, who had attached himself to +the army, consented, but again the Government at Paris interfered with +fatal effect. More anxious for the safety of the dynasty than for the +existence of the army, the Empress and her advisers insisted that McMahon +should continue his advance. Napoleon seems now to have abdicated all +authority and thrown to the winds all responsibility. He allowed the march +to be resumed in the direction of Mouzon and Stenay. Failly's corps, which +formed the right wing, was attacked on the 29th before it could reach the +passage of the Meuse at the latter place, and was driven northwards to +Beaumont. Here the commander strangely imagined himself to be in security. +He was surprised in his camp on the following day, defeated, and driven +northwards towards Mouzon. Meanwhile the left of McMahon's army had crossed +the Meuse and moved eastwards to Carignan, so that his troops were severed +by the river and at some distance from one another. Part of Failly's men +were made prisoners in the struggle on the south, or dispersed on the west +of the Meuse; the remainder, with their commander, made a hurried and +disorderly escape beyond the river, and neglected to break down the bridges +by which they had passed. McMahon saw that if the advance was continued his +divisions would one after another fall into the enemy's hands. He recalled +the troops which had reached Carignan, and concentrated his army about +Sedan to fight a pitched battle. The passages of the Meuse above and below +Sedan were seized by the Germans. Two hundred and forty thousand men were +at Moltke's disposal; McMahon had about half that number. The task of the +Germans was not so much to defeat the enemy as to prevent them from +escaping to the Belgian frontier. On the morning of September 1st, while on +the east of Sedan the Bavarians after a desperate resistance stormed the +village of Bazeilles, Hessian and Prussian regiments crossed the Meuse at +Donchery several miles to the west. From either end of this line corps +after corps now pushed northwards round the French positions, driving in +the enemy wherever they found them, and, converging under the eyes of the +Prussian King, his general, and his Minister, each into its place in the +arc of fire before which the French Empire was to perish. The movement was +as admirably executed as designed. The French fought furiously but in vain: +the mere mass of the enemy, the mere narrowing of the once completed +circle, crushed down resistance without the clumsy havoc of Gravelotte. +From point after point the defenders were forced back within Sedan itself. +The streets were choked with hordes of beaten infantry and cavalry; the +Germans had but to take one more step forward and the whole of their +batteries would command the town. Towards evening there was a pause in the +firing, in order that the French might offer negotiations for surrender; +but no sign of surrender was made, and the Bavarian cannon resumed their +fire, throwing shells into the town itself. Napoleon now caused a white +flag to be displayed on the fortress, and sent a letter to the King of +Prussia, stating that as he had not been able to die in the midst of his +troops, nothing remained for him but to surrender his sword into the hands +of his Majesty. The surrender was accepted by King William, who added that +General Moltke would act on his behalf in arranging terms of capitulation. +General Wimpffen, who had succeeded to the command of the French army on +the disablement of McMahon by a wound, acted on behalf of Napoleon. The +negotiations continued till late in the night, the French general pressing +for permission for his troops to be disarmed in Belgium, while Moltke +insisted on the surrender of the entire army as prisoners of war. Fearing +the effect of an appeal by Napoleon himself to the King's kindly nature, +Bismarck had taken steps to remove his sovereign to a distance until the +terms of surrender should be signed. At daybreak on September 2nd Napoleon +sought the Prussian headquarters. He was met on the road by Bismarck, who +remained in conversation with him till the capitulation was completed on +the terms required by the Germans. He then conducted Napoleon to the +neighbouring chateau of Bellevue, where King William, the Crown Prince, and +the Prince of Saxony visited him. One pang had still to be borne by the +unhappy man. Down to his interview with the King, Napoleon had imagined +that all the German armies together had operated against him at Sedan, and +he must consequently have still had some hope that his own ruin might have +purchased the deliverance of Bazaine. He learnt accidentally from the King +that Prince Frederick Charles had never stirred from before Metz. A +convulsion of anguish passed over his face: his eyes filled with tears. +There was no motive for a prolonged interview between the conqueror and the +conquered, for, as a prisoner, Napoleon could not discuss conditions of +peace. After some minutes of conversation the King departed for the +Prussian headquarters. Napoleon remained in the chateau until the morning +of the next day, and then began his journey towards the place chosen for +his captivity, the palace of Wilhelmshoehe at Cassel. [542] + +[The Republic Proclaimed, Sept. 4.] + +[Circular of Jules Favre, Sept. 6.] + +Rumours of disaster had reached Paris in the last days of August, but to +each successive report of evil the Government replied with lying boasts of +success, until on the 3rd of September it was forced to announce a +catastrophe far surpassing the worst anticipations of the previous days. +With the Emperor and his entire army in the enemy's hands, no one supposed +that the dynasty could any longer remain on the throne: the only question +was by what form of government the Empire should be succeeded. The +Legislative Chamber assembled in the dead of night; Jules Favre proposed +the deposition of the Emperor, and was heard in silence. The Assembly +adjourned for some hours. On the morning of the 4th, Thiers, who sought to +keep the way open for an Orleanist restoration, moved that a Committee of +Government should be appointed by the Chamber itself, and that elections to +a new Assembly should be held as soon as circumstances should permit. +Before this and other propositions of the same nature could be put to the +vote, the Chamber was invaded by the mob. Gambetta, with most of the +Deputies for Paris, proceeded to the Hotel de Ville, and there proclaimed +the Republic. The Empress fled; a Government of National Defence came into +existence, with General Trochu at its head, Jules Favre assuming the +Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Gambetta that of the Interior. No hand was +raised in defence of the Napoleonic dynasty or of the institutions of the +Empire. The Legislative Chamber and the Senate disappeared without even +making an attempt to prolong their own existence. Thiers, without approving +of the Republic or the mode in which it had come into being, recommended +his friends to accept the new Government, and gave it his own support. On +the 6th of September a circular of Jules Favre, addressed to the +representatives of France at all the European Courts, justified the +overthrow of the Napoleonic Empire, and claimed for the Government by which +it was succeeded the goodwill of the neutral Powers. Napoleon III. was +charged with the responsibility for the war: with the fall of his dynasty, +it was urged, the reasons for a continuance of the struggle had ceased to +exist. France only asked for a lasting peace. Such peace, however, must +leave the territory of France inviolate, for peace with dishonour would be +but the prelude to a new war of extermination. "Not an inch of our soil +will we cede"--so ran the formula--"not a stone of our fortresses." [543] + +[Favre and Bismarck, Sept. 29.] + +The German Chancellor had nothing ready in the way of rhetoric equal to his +antagonist's phrases; but as soon as the battle of Sedan was won it was +settled at the Prussian headquarters that peace would not be made without +the annexation of Alsace and Lorraine. Prince Bismarck has stated that his +own policy would have stopped at the acquisition of Strasburg: Moltke, +however, and the chiefs of the army pronounced that Germany could not be +secure against invasion while Metz remained in the hands of France, and +this opinion was accepted by the King. For a moment it was imagined that +the victory of Sedan had given the conqueror peace on his own terms. This +hope, however, speedily disappeared, and the march upon Paris was resumed +by the army of the Crown Prince without waste of time. In the third week of +September the invaders approached the capital. Favre, in spite of his +declaration of the 6th, was not indisposed to enter upon negotiations; and, +trusting to his own arts of persuasion, he sought an interview with the +German Chancellor, which was granted to him at Ferrieres on the 19th, and +continued on the following day. Bismarck hesitated to treat the holders of +office in Paris as an established Government; he was willing to grant an +armistice in order that elections might be held for a National Assembly +with which Germany could treat for peace; but he required, as a condition +of the armistice, that Strasburg and Toul should be surrendered. Toul was +already at the last extremity; Strasburg was not capable of holding out ten +days longer; but of this the Government at Paris was not aware. The +conditions demanded by Bismarck were rejected as insulting to France, and +the war was left to take its course. Already, while Favre was negotiating +at Ferrieres, the German vanguard was pressing round to the west of Paris. +A body of French troops which attacked them on the 19th at Chatillon was +put to the rout and fled in panic. Versailles was occupied on the same day, +and the line of investment was shortly afterwards completed around the +capital. + +[Siege of Paris, Sept. 19.] + +[Tours.] + +[Gambetta at Tours.] + +The second act in the war now began. Paris had been fortified by Thiers +about 1840, at the time when it seemed likely that France might be engaged +in war with a coalition on the affairs of Mehemet Ali. The forts were not +distant enough from the city to protect it altogether from artillery with +the lengthened range of 1870; they were sufficient, however, to render an +assault out of the question, and to compel the besieger to rely mainly on +the slow operation of famine. It had been reckoned by the engineers of 1840 +that food enough might be collected to enable the city to stand a +two-months' siege; so vast, however, were the supplies collected in 1870 +that, with double the population, Paris had provisions for above four +months. In spite therefore of the capture and destruction of its armies the +cause of France was not hopeless, if, while Paris and Metz occupied four +hundred thousand of the invaders, the population of the provinces should +take up the struggle with enthusiasm, and furnish after some months of +military exercise troops more numerous than those which France had lost, to +attack the besiegers from all points at once and to fall upon their +communications. To organise such a national resistance was, however, +impossible for any Government within the besieged capital itself. It was +therefore determined to establish a second seat of Government on the Loire; +and before the lines were drawn round Paris three members of the Ministry, +with M. Cremieux at their head, set out for Tours. Cremieux, however, who +was an aged lawyer, proved quite unequal to his task. His authority was +disputed in the west and the south. Revolutionary movements threatened to +break up the unity of the national defence. A stronger hand, a more +commanding will, was needed. Such a hand, such a will belonged to Gambetta, +who on the 7th of October left Paris in order to undertake the government +of the provinces and the organisation of the national armies. The circle of +the besiegers was now too closely drawn for the ordinary means of travel to +be possible. Gambetta passed over the German lines in a balloon, and +reached Tours in safety, where he immediately threw his feeble colleagues +into the background and concentrated all power in his own vigorous grasp. +The effect of his presence was at once felt throughout France. There was an +end of the disorders in the great cities, and of all attempts at rivalry +with the central power. Gambetta had the faults of rashness, of excessive +self-confidence, of defective regard for scientific authority in matters +where he himself was ignorant: but he possessed in an extraordinary degree +the qualities necessary for a Dictator at such a national crisis: +boundless, indomitable courage; a simple, elemental passion of love for his +country that left absolutely no place for hesitations or reserve in the +prosecution of the one object for which France then existed, the war. He +carried the nation with him like a whirlwind. Whatever share the military +errors of Gambetta and his rash personal interference with commanders may +have had in the ultimate defeat of France, without him it would never have +been known of what efforts France was capable. The proof of his capacity +was seen in the hatred and the fear with which down to the time of his +death he inspired the German people. Had there been at the head of the army +of Metz a man of one-tenth of Gambetta's effective force, it is possible +that France might have closed the war, if not with success, at least with +undiminished territory. + +[Fall of Strasburg, Sept. 28.] + +[The army of the Loire.] + +[Tann takes Orleans, Oct. 12.] + +Before Gambetta left Paris the fall of Strasburg set free the army under +General Werder by which it had been besieged, and enabled the Germans to +establish a civil Government in Alsace, the western frontier of the new +Province having been already so accurately studied that, when peace was +made in 1871, the frontier-line was drawn not upon one of the earlier +French maps but on the map now published by the German staff. It was +Gambetta's first task to divide France into districts, each with its own +military centre, its own army, and its own commander. Four such districts +were made: the centres were Lille, Le Mans, Bourges, and Besancon. At +Bourges and in the neighbourhood considerable progress had already been +made in organisation. Early in October German cavalry-detachments, +exploring southwards, found that French troops were gathering on the Loire. +The Bavarian General Von der Tann was detached by Moltke from the besieging +army at Paris, and ordered to make himself master of Orleans. Von der Tann +hastened southwards, defeated the French outside Orleans on the 11th of +October, and occupied this city, the French retiring towards Bourges. +Gambetta removed the defeated commander, and set in his place General +Aurelle de Paladines. Von der Tann was directed to cross the Loire and +destroy the arsenals at Bourges; he reported, however, that this task was +beyond his power, in consequence of which Moltke ordered General Werder +with the army of Strasburg to move westwards against Bourges, after +dispersing the weak forces that were gathering about Besancon. Werder set +out on his dangerous march, but he had not proceeded far when an army of +very different power was thrown into the scale against the French levies on +the Loire. + +[Bazaine at Metz.] + +[Capitulation of Metz, Oct. 27.] + +In the battle of Gravelotte, fought on the 18th of August, the French +troops had been so handled by Bazaine as to render it doubtful whether he +really intended to break through the enemy's line and escape from Metz. At +what period political designs inconsistent with his military duty first +took possession of Bazaine's thoughts is uncertain. He had played a +political part in Mexico; it is probable that as soon as he found himself +at the head of the one effective army of France, and saw Napoleon +hopelessly discredited, he began to aim at personal power. Before the +downfall of the Empire he had evidently adopted a scheme of inaction with +the object of preserving his army entire: even the sortie by which it had +been arranged that he should assist McMahon on the day before Sedan was +feebly and irresolutely conducted. After the proclamation of the Republic +Bazaine's inaction became still more marked. The intrigues of an adventurer +named Regnier, who endeavoured to open a negotiation between the Prussians +and the exiled Empress Eugenie, encouraged him in his determination to keep +his soldiers from fulfilling their duty to France. Week after week passed +by; a fifth of the besieging army was struck down with sickness; yet +Bazaine made no effort to break through, or even to diminish the number of +men who were consuming the supplies of Metz by giving to separate +detachments the opportunity of escape. On the 12th of October, after the +pretence of a sortie on the north, he entered into communication with the +German headquarters at Versailles. Bismarck offered to grant a free +departure to the army of Metz on condition that the fortress should be +placed in his hands, that the army should undertake to act on behalf of the +Empress, and that the Empress should pledge herself to accept the Prussian +conditions of peace, whatever these might be. General Boyer was sent to +England to acquaint the Empress with these propositions. They were declined +by her, and after a fortnight had been spent in manoeuvres for a +Bonapartist restoration. Bazaine found himself at the end of his resources. +On the 27th the capitulation of Metz was signed. The fortress itself, with +incalculable cannon and material of war, and an army of a hundred and +seventy thousand men, including twenty-six thousand sick and wounded in the +hospitals, passed into the hands of the Germans. [544] + +[Bazaine.] + +Bazaine was at a later time tried by a court-martial, found guilty of the +neglect of duty, and sentenced to death. That sentence was not executed; +but if there is an infamy that is worse than death, such infamy will to all +time cling to his name. In the circumstances in which France was placed no +effort, no sacrifice of life could have been too great for the commander of +the army at Metz. To retain the besiegers in full strength before the +fortress would not have required the half of Bazaine's actual force. If +half his army had fallen on the field of battle in successive attempts to +cut their way through the enemy, brave men would no doubt have perished; +but even had their efforts failed their deaths would have purchased for +Metz the power to hold out for weeks or for months longer. The civil +population of Metz was but sixty thousand, its army was three times as +numerous; unlike Paris, it saw its stores consumed not by helpless millions +of women and children, but by soldiers whose duty it was to aid the defence +of their country at whatever cost. Their duty, if they could not cut their +way through, was to die fighting; and had they shown hesitation, which was +not the case, Bazaine should have died at their head. That Bazaine would +have fulfilled his duty even if Napoleon III. had remained on the throne is +more than doubtful, for his inaction had begun before the catastrophe of +Sedan. His pretext after that time was that the government of France had +fallen into the hands of men of disorder, and that it was more important +for his army to save France from the Government than from the invader. He +was the only man in France who thought so. The Government of September 4th, +whatever its faults, was good enough for tens of thousands of brave men, +Legitimists, Orleanists, Bonapartists, who flocked without distinction of +party to its banners: it might have been good enough for Marshal Bazaine. +But France had to pay the penalty for the political, the moral indifference +which could acquiesce in the Coup d'Etat of 1851, in the servility of the +Empire, in many a vile and boasted deed in Mexico, in China, in Algiers. +Such indifference found its Nemesis in a Bazaine. + +[Tann driven from Orleans, Nov. 9.] + +[Battles of Orleans, Nov. 28-Dec. 2.] + +[Sortie of Champigny, Nov. 29-Dec. 4.] + +[Battle of Amiens, Nov. 27.] + +The surrender of Metz and the release of the great army of Prince Frederick +Charles by which it was besieged fatally changed the conditions of the +French war of national defence. Two hundred thousand of the victorious +troops of Germany under some of their ablest generals were set free to +attack the still untrained levies on the Loire and in the north of France, +which, with more time for organisation, might well have forced the Germans +to raise the siege of Paris. The army once commanded by Steinmetz was now +reconstituted, and despatched under General Manteuffel towards Amiens; +Prince Frederick Charles moved with the remainder of his troops towards the +Loire. Aware that his approach could not long be delayed, Gambetta insisted +that Aurelle de Paladines should begin the march on Paris. The general +attacked Tann at Coulmiers on the 9th of November, defeated him, and +re-occupied Orleans, the first real success that the French had gained in +the war. There was great alarm at the German headquarters at Versailles; +the possibility of a failure of the siege was discussed; and forty thousand +troops were sent southwards in haste to the support of the Bavarian +general. Aurelle, however, did not move upon the capital: his troops were +still unfit for the enterprise; and he remained stationary on the north of +Orleans, in order to improve his organisation, to await reinforcements, and +to meet the attack of Frederick Charles in a strong position. In the third +week of November the leading divisions of the army of Metz approached, and +took post between Orleans and Paris. Gambetta now insisted that the effort +should be made to relieve the capital. Aurelle resisted, but was forced to +obey. The garrison of Paris had already made several unsuccessful attacks +upon the lines of their besiegers, the most vigorous being that of Le +Bourget on the 30th of October, in which bayonets were crossed. It was +arranged that in the last days of November General Trochu should endeavour +to break out on the southern side, and that simultaneously the army of the +Loire should fall upon the enemy in front of it and endeavour to force its +way to the capital. On the 28th the attack upon the Germans on the north of +Orleans began. For several days the struggle was renewed by one division +after another of the armies of Aurelle and Prince Frederick Charles. +Victory remained at last with the Germans; the centre of the French +position was carried; the right and left wings of the army were severed +from one another and forced to retreat, the one up the Loire, the other +towards the west. Orleans on the 5th of December passed back into the hands +of the Germans. The sortie from Paris, which began with a successful attack +by General Ducrot upon Champigny beyond the Marne, ended after some days of +combat in the recovery by the Germans of the positions which they had lost, +and in the retreat of Ducrot into Paris. In the same week Manteuffel, +moving against the relieving army of the north, encountered it near Amiens, +defeated it after a hard struggle, and gained possession of Amiens itself. + +[Rouen occupied, Dec. 6.] + +[Bapaume, Jan. 3.] + +[St. Quentin, Jan 19.] + +After the fall of Amiens, Manteuffel moved upon Rouen. This city fell into +his hands without resistance; the conquerors pressed on westwards, and at +Dieppe troops which had come from the confines of Russia gazed for the +first time upon the sea. But the Republican armies, unlike those which the +Germans had first encountered, were not to be crushed at a single blow. +Under the energetic command of Faidherbe the army of the North advanced +again upon Amiens. Goeben, who was left to defend the line of the Somme, +went out to meet him, defeated him on the 23rd of December, and drove him +back to Arras. But again, after a week's interval, Faidherbe pushed +forward. On the 3rd of January he fell upon Goeben's weak division at +Bapaume, and handled it so severely that the Germans would on the following +day have abandoned their position, if the French had not themselves been +the first to retire. Faidherbe, however, had only fallen back to receive +reinforcements. After some days' rest he once more sought to gain the road +to Paris, advancing this time by the eastward line through St. Quentin. In +front of this town Goeben attacked him. The last battle of the army of the +North was fought on the 19th of January. The French general endeavoured to +disguise his defeat, but the German commander had won all that he desired. +Faidherbe's army was compelled to retreat northwards in disorder; its part +in the war was at an end. + +[The Armies of the Loire and of the East.] + +[Le Mans, Jan. 12.] + +[Bourbaki.] + +[Montbeliard, Jan. 15-17.] + +[The Eastern army crosses the Swiss Frontier, Feb. 1.] + +During the last three weeks of December there was a pause in the operations +of the Germans on the Loire. It was expected that Bourbaki and the east +wing of The Armies of the French army would soon re-appear at Orleans and +endeavour to combine with Chanzy's troops. Gambetta, however, had formed +another plan. He considered that Chanzy, with the assistance of divisions +formed in Brittany, would be strong enough to encounter Prince Frederick +Charles, and he determined to throw the army of Bourbaki, strengthened by +reinforcements from the south, upon Germany itself. The design was a daring +one, and had the two French armies been capable of performing the work +which Gambetta required of them, an inroad into Baden, or even the +re-conquest of Alsace, would most seriously have affected the position of +the Germans before Paris. But Gambetta miscalculated the power of young, +untrained troops, imperfectly armed, badly fed, against a veteran enemy. In +a series of hard-fought struggles the army of the Loire under General +Chanzy was driven back at the beginning of January from Vendome to Le Mans. +On the 12th, Chanzy took post before this city and fought his last battle. +While he was making a vigorous resistance in the centre of the line, the +Breton regiments stationed on his right gave way; the Germans pressed round +him, and gained possession of the town. Chanzy retreated towards Laval, +leaving thousands of prisoners in the hands of the enemy, and saving only +the debris of an army. Bourbaki in the meantime, with a numerous but +miserably equipped force, had almost reached Belfort. The report of his +eastward movement was not at first believed at the German headquarters +before Paris, and the troops of General Werder, which had been engaged +about Dijon with a body of auxiliaries commanded by Garibaldi, were left to +bear the brunt of the attack without support. When the real state of +affairs became known Manteuffel was sent eastwards in hot haste towards the +threatened point. Werder had evacuated Dijon and fallen back upon Vesoul; +part of his army was still occupied in the siege of Belfort. As Bourbaki +approached he fell back with the greater part of his troops in order to +cover the besieging force, leaving one of his lieutenants to make a flank +attack upon Bourbaki at Villersexel. This attack, one of the fiercest in +the war, delayed the French for two days, and gave Werder time to occupy +the strong positions that he had chosen about Montbeliard. Here, on the +15th of January, began a struggle which lasted for three days. The French, +starving and perishing with cold, though far superior in number to their +enemy, were led with little effect against the German entrenchments. On the +18th Bourbaki began his retreat. Werder was unable to follow him; +Manteuffel with a weak force was still at some distance, and for a moment +it seemed possible that Bourbaki, by a rapid movement westwards, might +crush this isolated foe. Gambetta ordered Bourbaki to make the attempt: the +commander refused to court further disaster with troops who were not fit to +face an enemy, and retreated towards Pontarlier in the hope of making his +way to Lyons. But Manteuffel now descended in front of him; divisions of +Werder's army pressed down from the north; the retreat was cut off; and the +unfortunate French general, whom a telegram from Gambetta removed from his +command, attempted to take his own life. On the 1st of February, the wreck +of his army, still numbering eighty-five thousand men, but reduced to the +extremity of weakness and misery, sought refuge beyond the Swiss frontier. + +[Capitulation of Paris and Armistice, Jan. 28.] + +The war was now over. Two days after Bourbaki's repulse at Montbeliard the +last unsuccessful sortie was made from Paris. There now remained provisions +only for another fortnight; above forty thousand of the inhabitants had +succumbed to the privations of the siege; all hope of assistance from the +relieving armies before actual famine should begin disappeared. On the 23rd +of January Favre sought the German Chancellor at Versailles in order to +discuss the conditions of a general armistice and of the capitulation of +Paris. The negotiations lasted for several days; on the 28th an armistice +was signed with the declared object that elections might at once be freely +held for a National Assembly, which should decide whether the war should be +continued, or on what conditions peace should be made. The conditions of +the armistice were that the forts of Paris and all their material of war +should be handed over to the German army; that the artillery of the +enceinte should be dismounted; and that the regular troops in Paris should, +as prisoners of war, surrender their arms. The National Guard were +permitted to retain their weapons and their artillery. Immediately upon the +fulfilment of the first two conditions all facilities were to be given for +the entry of supplies of food into Paris. [545] + +[National Assembly at Bordeaux, Feb. 12.] + +[Preliminaries of Peace, Feb. 26.] + +The articles of the armistice were duly executed, and on the 30th of +January the Prussian flag waved over the forts of the French capital. +Orders were sent into the provinces by the Government that elections should +at once be held. It had at one time been feared by Count Bismarck that +Gambetta would acknowledge no armistice that might be made by his +colleagues at Paris. But this apprehension was not realised, for, while +protesting against a measure adopted without consultation with himself and +his companions at Bordeaux, Gambetta did not actually reject the armistice. +He called upon the nation, however, to use the interval for the collection +of new forces; and in the hope of gaining from the election an Assembly in +favour of a continuation of the war, he published a decree incapacitating +for election all persons who had been connected with the Government of +Napoleon III. Against this decree Bismarck at once protested, and at his +instance it was cancelled by the Government of Paris. Gambetta thereupon +resigned. The elections were held on the 8th of February, and on the 12th +the National Assembly was opened at Bordeaux. The Government of Defence now +laid down its powers. Thiers--who had been the author of those +fortifications which had kept the Germans at bay for four months after the +overthrow of the Imperial armies; who, in the midst of the delirium of +July, 1870, had done all that man could do to dissuade the Imperial +Government and its Parliament from war; who, in spite of his seventy years, +had, after the fall of Napoleon, hurried to London, to St. Petersburg, to +Florence, to Vienna, in the hope of winning some support for France,--was +the man called by common assent to the helm of State. He appointed a +Ministry, called upon the Assembly to postpone all discussions as to the +future Government of France, and himself proceeded to Versailles in order +to negotiate conditions of peace. For several days the old man struggled +with Count Bismarck on point after point in the Prussian demands. Bismarck +required the cession of Alsace and Eastern Lorraine, the payment of six +milliards of francs, and the occupation of part of Paris by the German army +until the conditions of peace should be ratified by the Assembly. Thiers +strove hard to save Metz, but on this point the German staff was +inexorable; he succeeded at last in reducing the indemnity to five +milliards, and was given the option between retaining Belfort and sparing +Paris the entry of the German troops. On the last point his patriotism +decided without a moment's hesitation. He bade the Germans enter Paris, and +saved Belfort for France. On the 26th of February preliminaries of peace +were signed. Thirty thousand German soldiers marched into the Champs +Elysees on the 1st of March; but on that same day the treaty was ratified +by the Assembly at Bordeaux, and after forty-eight hours Paris was freed +from the sight of its conquerors. The Articles of Peace provided for the +gradual evacuation of France by the German army as the instalments of the +indemnity, which were allowed to extend over a period of three years, +should be paid. There remained for settlement only certain matters of +detail, chiefly connected with finance; these, however, proved the object +of long and bitter controversy, and it was not until the 10th of May that +the definitive Treaty of Peace was signed at Frankfort. + +[German Unity.] + +France had made war in order to undo the work of partial union effected by +Prussia in 1866: it achieved the opposite result, and Germany emerged from +the war with the Empire established. Immediately after the victory of Woerth +the Crown Prince had seen that the time had come for abolishing the line of +division which severed Southern Germany from the Federation of the North. +His own conception of the best form of national union was a German Empire +with its chief at Berlin. That Count Bismarck was without plans for uniting +North and South Germany it is impossible to believe; but the Minister and +the Crown Prince had always been at enmity; and when, after the battle of +Sedan, they spoke together of the future, it seemed to the Prince as if +Bismarck had scarcely thought of the federation of the Empire or of the +re-establishment of the Imperial dignity, and as if he was inclined to it +only under certain reserves. It was, however, part of Bismarck's system to +exclude the Crown Prince as far as possible from political affairs, under +the strange pretext that his relationship to Queen Victoria would be abused +by the French proclivities of the English Court; and it is possible that +had the Chancellor after the battle of Sedan chosen to admit the Prince to +his confidence instead of resenting his interference, the difference +between their views as to the future of Germany would have been seen to be +one rather of forms and means than of intention. But whatever the share of +these two dissimilar spirits in the initiation of the last steps towards +German union, the work, as ultimately achieved, was both in form and in +substance that which the Crown Prince had conceived. In the course of +September negotiations were opened with each of the Southern States for its +entry into the Northern Confederation. Bavaria alone raised serious +difficulties, and demanded terms to which the Prussian Government could not +consent. Bismarck refrained from exercising pressure at Munich, but invited +the several Governments to send representatives to Versailles for the +purpose of arriving at a settlement. For a moment the Court of Munich drew +the sovereign of Wuertemberg to its side, and orders were sent to the envoys +of Wuertemberg at Versailles to act with the Bavarians in refusing to sign +the treaty projected by Bismarck. The Wuertemberg Ministers hereupon +tendered their resignation; Baden and Hesse-Darmstadt signed the treaty, +and the two dissentient kings saw themselves on the point of being excluded +from United Germany. They withdrew their opposition, and at the end of +November the treaties uniting all the Southern States with the existing +Confederation were executed, Bavaria retaining larger separate rights than +were accorded to any other member of the Union. + +[Proclamation of the Empire, Jan. 18.] + +In the acts which thus gave to Germany political cohesion there was nothing +that altered the title of its chief. Bismarck, however, had in the meantime +informed the recalcitrant sovereigns that if they did not themselves offer +the Imperial dignity to King William, the North German Parliament would do +so. At the end of November a letter was accordingly sent by the King of +Bavaria to all his fellow-sovereigns, proposing that the King of Prussia, +as President of the newly-formed Federation, should assume the title of +German Emperor. Shortly afterwards the same request was made by the same +sovereign to King William himself, in a letter dictated by Bismarck. A +deputation from the North German Reichstag, headed by its President, Dr. +Simson, who, as President of the Frankfort National Assembly, had in 1849 +offered the Imperial Crown to King Frederick William, expressed the +concurrence of the nation in the act of the Princes. It was expected that +before the end of the year the new political arrangements would have been +sanctioned by the Parliaments of all the States concerned, and the 1st of +January had been fixed for the assumption of the Imperial title. So +vigorous, however, was the opposition made in the Bavarian Chamber, that +the ceremony was postponed till the 18th. Even then the final approving +vote had not been taken at Munich; but a second adjournment would have been +fatal to the dignity of the occasion; and on the 18th of January, in the +midst of the Princes of Germany and the representatives of its army +assembled in the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles, King William assumed the +title of German Emperor. The first Parliament of the Empire was opened at +Berlin two months later. + +[The Commune of Paris.] + +[Troops withdrawn to Versailles, March 18.] + +[The Commune.] + +The misfortunes of France did not end with the fall of its capital and the +loss of its border provinces; the terrible drama of 1870 closed with civil +war. It is part of the normal order of French history that when an +established Government is overthrown, and another is set in its place, this +second Government is in its turn attacked by insurrection in Paris, and an +effort is made to establish the rule of the democracy of the capital +itself, or of those who for the moment pass for its leaders. It was so in +1793, in 1831, in 1848, and it was so again in 1870. Favre, Trochu, and the +other members of the Government of Defence had assumed power on the +downfall of Napoleon III. because they considered themselves the +individuals best able to serve the State. There were hundreds of other +persons in Paris who had exactly the same opinion of themselves; and when, +with the progress of the siege, the Government of Defence lost its +popularity and credit, it was natural that ambitious and impatient men of a +lower political rank should consider it time to try whether Paris could not +make a better defence under their own auspices. Attempts were made before +the end of October to overthrow the Government. They were repeated at +intervals, but without success. The agitation, however, continued within +the ranks of the National Guard, which, unlike the National Guard in the +time of Louis Philippe, now included the mass of the working class, and was +the most dangerous enemy, instead of the support, of Government. The +capitulation brought things to a crisis. Favre had declared that it would +be impossible to disarm the National Guard without a battle in the streets; +at his instance Bismarck allowed the National Guard to retain their +weapons, and the fears of the Government itself thus prepared the way for +successful insurrection. When the Germans were about to occupy western +Paris, the National Guard drew off its artillery to Montmartre and there +erected entrenchments. During the next fortnight, while the Germans were +withdrawing from the western forts in accordance with the conditions of +peace, the Government and the National Guard stood facing one another in +inaction; on the 18th of March General Lecomte was ordered to seize the +artillery parked at Montmartre. His troops, surrounded and solicited by the +National Guard, abandoned their commander. Lecomte was seized, and, with +General Clement Thomas, was put to death. A revolutionary Central Committee +took possession of the Hotel de Ville; the troops still remaining faithful +to the Government were withdrawn to Versailles, where Thiers had assembled +the Chamber. Not only Paris itself, but the western forts with the +exception of Mont Valerien, fell into the hands of the insurgents. On the +26th of March elections were held for the Commune. The majority of peaceful +citizens abstained from voting. A council was elected, which by the side of +certain harmless and well-meaning men contained a troop of revolutionists +by profession; and after the failure of all attempts at conciliation, +hostilities began between Paris and Versailles. + +[Second Siege--April 2, May 21.] + +There were in the ranks of those who fought for the Commune some who fought +in the sincere belief that their cause was that of municipal freedom; there +were others who believed, and with good reason, that the existence of the +Republic was threatened by a reactionary Assembly at Versailles; but the +movement was on the whole the work of fanatics who sought to subvert every +authority but their own; and the unfortunate mob who followed them, in so +far as they fought for anything beyond the daily pay which had been their +only means of sustenance since the siege began, fought for they knew not +what. As the conflict was prolonged, it took on both sides a character of +atrocious violence and cruelty. The murder of Generals Lecomte and Thomas +at the outset was avenged by the execution of some of the first prisoners +taken by the troops of Versailles. Then hostages were seized by the +Commune. The slaughter in cold blood of three hundred National Guards +surprised at Clamart by the besiegers gave to the Parisians the example of +massacre. When, after a siege of six weeks, in which Paris suffered far +more severely than it had suffered from the cannonade of the Germans, the +troops of Versailles at length made their way into the capital, humanity, +civilisation, seemed to have vanished in the orgies of devils. The +defenders, as they fell back, murdered their hostages, and left behind them +palaces, museums, the entire public inheritance of the nation in its +capital, in flames. The conquerors during several days shot down all whom +they took fighting, and in many cases put to death whole bands of prisoners +without distinction. The temper of the army was such that the Government, +even if it had desired, could probably not have mitigated the terrors of +this vengeance. But there was little sign anywhere of an inclination to +mercy. Courts-martial and executions continued long after the heat of +combat was over. A year passed, and the tribunals were still busy with +their work. Above ten thousand persons were sentenced to transportation or +imprisonment before public justice was satisfied. + +[Entry of Italian Troops into Rome, Sept. 20, 1870.] + +[The Papacy.] + +The material losses which France sustained at the hands of the invader and +in civil war were soon repaired; but from the battle of Woerth down to the +overthrow of the Commune France had been effaced as a European Power, and +its effacement was turned to good account by two nations who were not its +enemies. Russia, with the sanction of Europe, threw off the trammels which +had been imposed upon it in the Black Sea by the Treaty of 1856. Italy +gained possession of Rome. Soon after the declaration of war the troops of +France, after an occupation of twenty-one years broken only by an interval +of some months in 1867, were withdrawn from the Papal territory. Whatever +may have been the understanding with Victor Emmanuel on which Napoleon +recalled his troops from Civita Vecchia, the battle of Sedan set Italy +free; and on the 20th of September the National Army, after overcoming a +brief show of resistance, entered Rome. The unity of Italy was at last +completed; Florence ceased to be the national capital. A body of laws +passed by the Italian Parliament, and known as the Guarantees, assured to +the Pope the honours and immunities of a sovereign, the possession of the +Vatican and the Lateran palaces, and a princely income; in the appointment +of Bishops and generally in the government of the Church a fulness of +authority was freely left to him such as he possessed in no other European +land. But Pius would accept no compromise for the loss of his temporal +power. He spurned the reconciliation with the Italian people, which had now +for the first time since 1849 become possible. He declared Rome to be in +the possession of brigands; and, with a fine affectation of disdain for +Victor Emmanuel and the Italian Government, he invented, and sustained down +to the end of his life, before a world too busy to pay much heed to his +performance, the reproachful part of the Prisoner of the Vatican. + + + + +CHAPTER XXV. + + +France after 1871--Alliance of the Three Emperors--Revolt of +Herzegovina--The Andrassy Note--Murder of the Consuls at Salonika--The +Berlin Memorandum--Rejected by England--Abdul Aziz deposed--Massacres in +Bulgaria--Servia and Montenegro declare War--Opinion in England-- +Disraeli--Meeting of Emperors at Reichstadt--Servian Campaign--Declaration +of the Czar--Conference at Constantinople--Its Failure--The London +Protocol--Russia declares War--Advance on the Balkans--Osman at +Plevna--Second Attack on Plevna--The Shipka Pass--Roumania--Third attack +on Plevna--Todleben--Fall of Plevna--Passage of the Balkans--Armistice-- +England--The Fleet passes the Dardanelles--Treaty of San Stefano--England +and Russia--Secret Agreement--Convention with Turkey--Congress of +Berlin--Treaty of Berlin--Bulgaria. + + +[France after 1871.] + +The storm of 1870 was followed by some years of European calm. France, +recovering with wonderful rapidity from the wounds inflicted by the war, +paid with ease the instalments of its debt to Germany, and saw its soil +liberated from the foreigner before the period fixed by the Treaty of +Frankfort. The efforts of a reactionary Assembly were kept in check by M. +Thiers; the Republic, as the form of government which divided Frenchmen the +least, was preferred by him to the monarchical restoration which might have +won France allies at some of the European Courts. For two years Thiers +baffled or controlled the royalist majority at Versailles which sought to +place the Comte de Chambord or the chief of the House of Orleans on the +throne, and thus saved his country from the greatest of all perils, the +renewal of civil war. In 1873 he fell before a combination of his +opponents, and McMahon succeeded to the Presidency, only to find that the +royalist cause was made hopeless by the refusal of the Comte de Chambord to +adopt the Tricolour flag, and that France, after several years of trial, +definitely preferred the Republic. Meanwhile, Prince Bismarck had known how +to frustrate all plans for raising a coalition against victorious Germany +among the Powers which had been injured by its successes, or whose +interests were threatened by its greatness. He saw that a Bourbon or a +Napoleon on the throne of France would find far more sympathy and +confidence at Vienna and St. Petersburg than the shifting chief of a +Republic, and ordered Count Arnim, the German Ambassador at Paris, who +wished to promote a Napoleonic restoration, to desist from all attempts to +weaken the Republican Government. At St. Petersburg, where after the +misfortunes of 1815 France had found its best friends, the German statesman +had as yet little to fear. Bismarck had supported Russia in undoing the +Treaty of Paris; in announcing the conclusion of peace with France, the +German Emperor had assured the Czar in the most solemn language that his +services in preventing the war of 1870 from becoming general should never +be forgotten; and, whatever might be the feeling of his subjects, Alexander +II. continued to believe that Russia could find no steadier friend than the +Government of Berlin. + +[Alliance of the three Emperors.] + +With Austria Prince Bismarck had a more difficult part to play. He could +hope for no real understanding so long as Beust remained at the head of +affairs. But the events of 1870, utterly frustrating Beust's plans for a +coalition against Prussia, and definitely closing for Austria all hope of +recovering its position within Germany, had shaken the Minister's position. +Bismarck was able to offer to the Emperor Francis Joseph the sincere and +cordial friendship of the powerful German Empire, on the condition that +Austria should frankly accept the work of 1866 and 1870. He had dissuaded +his master after the victory of Koeniggraetz from annexing any Austrian +territory; he had imposed no condition of peace that left behind it a +lasting exasperation; and he now reaped the reward of his foresight. +Francis Joseph accepted the friendship offered him from Berlin, and +dismissed Count Beust from office, calling to his place the Hungarian +Minister Andrassy, who, by conviction as well as profession, welcomed the +establishment of a German Empire, and the definite abandonment by Austria +of its interference in German affairs. In the summer of 1872 the three +Emperors, accompanied by their Ministers, met in Berlin. No formal alliance +was made, but a relation was established of sufficient intimacy to insure +Prince Bismarck against any efforts that might be made by France to gain an +ally. For five years this so-called League of the three Emperors continued +in more or less effective existence, and condemned France to isolation. In +the apprehension of the French people, Germany, gorged with the five +milliards but still lean and ravenous, sought only for some new occasion +for war. This was not the case. The German nation had entered unwillingly +into the war of 1870; that its ruler, when once his great aim had been +achieved, sought peace not only in word but in deed the history of +subsequent years has proved. The alarms which at intervals were raised at +Paris and elsewhere had little real foundation; and when next the peace of +Europe was broken, it was not by a renewal of the struggle on the Vosges, +but by a conflict in the East, which, terrible as it was in the sufferings +and the destruction of life which it involved, was yet no senseless duel +between two jealous nations, but one of the most fruitful in results of all +modern wars, rescuing whole provinces from Ottoman dominion, and leaving +behind it in place of a chaos of outworn barbarism at least the elements +for a future of national independence among the Balkan population. + +[Revolt of Herzegovina, Aug., 1875.] + +[Andrassy Note, Jan. 31, 1876.] + +In the summer of 1875 Herzegovina rose against its Turkish masters, and in +Bosnia conflicts broke out between Christians and Mohammedans. The +insurrection was vigorously, though privately, supported by Servia and +Montenegro, and for some months baffled all the efforts made by the Porte +for its suppression. Many thousands of the Christians, flying from a +devastated land and a merciless enemy, sought refuge beyond the Austrian +frontier, and became a burden upon the Austrian Government. The agitation +among the Slavic neighbours and kinsmen of the insurgents threatened the +peace of Austria itself, where Slav and Magyar were almost as ready to fall +upon one another as Christian and Turk. Andrassy entered into +communications with the Governments of St. Petersburg and Berlin as to the +adoption of a common line of policy by the three Empires towards the Porte; +and a scheme of reforms, intended to effect the pacification of the +insurgent provinces, was drawn up by the three Ministers in concert with +one another. This project, which was known as the Andrassy Note, and which +received the approval of England and France, demanded from the Porte the +establishment of full and entire religious liberty, the abolition of the +farming of taxes, the application of the revenue produced by direct +taxation in Bosnia and Herzegovina to the needs of those provinces +themselves, the institution of a Commission composed equally of Christians +and Mohammedans to control the execution of these reforms and of those +promised by the Porte, and finally the improvement of the agrarian +condition of the population by the sale to them of waste lands belonging to +the State. The Note demanding these reforms was presented in Constantinople +on the 31st of January, 1876. The Porte, which had already been lavish of +promises to the insurgents, raised certain objections in detail, but +ultimately declared itself willing to grant in substance the concessions +which were specified by the Powers. [546] + +[Murder of the Consuls at Salonika, May 6.] + +Armed with this assurance, the representatives of Austria now endeavoured +to persuade the insurgents to lay down their arms and the refugees to +return to their homes. But the answer was made that promises enough had +already been given by the Sultan, and that the question was, not what more +was to be written on a piece of paper, but how the execution of these +promises was to be enforced. Without some guarantee from the Great Powers +of Europe the refugees refused to place themselves again at the mercy of +the Turk, and the leaders in Herzegovina refused to disband their troops. +The conflict broke out afresh with greater energy; the intervention of the +Powers, far from having produced peace, roused the fanatical passions of +the Mohammedans both against the Christian rayahs and against the foreigner +to whom they had appealed. A wave of religious, of patriotic agitation, of +political disquiet, of barbaric fury, passed over the Turkish Empire. On +the 6th of May the Prussian and the French Consuls at Salonika were +attacked and murdered by the mob. In Smyrna and Constantinople there were +threatening movements against the European inhabitants; in Bulgaria, the +Circassian settlers and the hordes of irregular troops whom the Government +had recently sent into that province waited only for the first sign of an +expected insurrection to fall upon their prey and deluge the land with +blood. + +[The Berlin Memorandum, May 13.] + +As soon as it became evident that peace was not to be produced by Count +Andrassy's Note, the Ministers of the three Empires determined to meet one +another with the view of arranging further diplomatic steps to be taken in +common. Berlin, which the Czar was about to visit, was chosen as the +meeting-place; the date of the meeting was fixed for the second week in +May. It was in the interval between the despatch of Prince Bismarck's +invitation and the arrival of the Czar, with Prince Gortschakoff and Count +Andrassy, that intelligence came of the murder of the Prussian and French +Consuls at Salonika. This event gave a deeper seriousness to the +deliberations now held. The Ministers declared that if the representatives +of two foreign Powers could be thus murdered in broad daylight in a +peaceful town under the eyes of the powerless authorities, the Christians +of the insurgent provinces might well decline to entrust themselves to an +exasperated enemy. An effective guarantee for the execution of the promises +made by the Porte had become absolutely necessary. The conclusions of the +Ministers were embodied in a Memorandum, which declared that an armistice +of two months must be imposed on the combatants; that the mixed Commission +mentioned in the Andrassy Note must be at once called into being, with a +Christian native of Herzegovina at its head; and that the reforms promised +by the Porte must be carried out under the superintendence of the +representatives of the European Powers. If before the end of the armistice +the Porte should not have given its assent to these terms, the Imperial +Courts declared that they must support these diplomatic efforts by measures +of a more effective character. [547] + +[England alone rejects the Berlin Memorandum.] + +On the same day that this Memorandum was signed, Prince Bismarck invited +the British, the French, and Italian Ambassadors to meet the Russian and +the Austrian Chancellors at his residence. They did so. The Memorandum was +read, and an urgent request was made that Great Britain France, and Italy +would combine with the Imperial Courts in support of the Berlin Memorandum +as they had in support of the Andrassy Note. As Prince Gortschakoff and +Andrassy were staying in Berlin only for two days longer, it was hoped that +answers might be received by telegraph within forty-eight hours. Within +that time answers arrived from the French and Italian Governments accepting +the Berlin Memorandum; the reply from London did not arrive till five days +later; it announced the refusal of the Government to join in the course +proposed. Pending further negotiations on this subject, French, German, +Austrian, Italian, and Russian ships of war were sent to Salonika to +enforce satisfaction for the murder of the Consuls. The Cabinet of London, +declining to associate itself with the concert of the Powers, and stating +that Great Britain, while intending nothing in the nature of a menace, +could not permit territorial changes to be made in the East without its own +consent, despatched the fleet to Besika Bay. + +[Abdul Aziz deposed, May 29.] + +[Massacres in Bulgaria.] + +[Servia and Montenegro declare war, July 2.] + +Up to this time little attention had been paid in England to the revolt of +the Christian subjects of the Porte or its effect on European politics. +Now, however, a series of events began which excited the interest and even +the passion of the English people in an extraordinary degree. The ferment +in Constantinople was deepening. On the 29th of May the Sultan Abdul Aziz +was deposed by Midhat Pasha and Hussein Avni, the former the chief of the +party of reform, the latter the representative of the older Turkish +military and patriotic spirit which Abdul Aziz had incensed by his +subserviency to Russia. A few days later the deposed Sultan was murdered. +Hussein Avni and another rival of Midhat were assassinated by a desperado +as they sat at the council; Murad V., who had been raised to the throne, +proved imbecile; and Midhat, the destined regenerator of the Ottoman Empire +as many outside Turkey believed, grasped all but the highest power in the +State. Towards the end of June reports reached western Europe of the +repression of an insurrection in Bulgaria with measures of atrocious +violence. Servia and Montenegro, long active in support of their kinsmen +who were in arms, declared war. The reports from Bulgaria, at first vague, +took more definite form; and at length the correspondents of German as well +as English newspapers, making their way to the district south of the +Balkans, found in villages still strewed with skeletons and human remains +the terrible evidence of what had passed. The British Ministry, relying +upon the statements of Sir H. Elliot, Ambassador at Constantinople, at +first denied the seriousness of the massacres: they directed, however, that +investigations should be made on the spot by a member of the Embassy; and +Mr. Baring, Secretary of Legation, was sent to Bulgaria with this duty. +Baring's report confirmed the accounts which his chief had refused to +believe, and placed the number of the victims, rightly or wrongly, at not +less than twelve thousand. [548] + +[Opinion in England.] + +The Bulgarian massacres acted on Europe in 1876 as the massacre of Chios +had acted on Europe in 1822. In England especially they excited the deepest +horror, and completely changed the tone of public opinion towards the Turk. +Hitherto the public mind had scarcely been conscious of the questions that +were at issue in the East. Herzegovina, Bosnia, Bulgaria, were not familiar +names like Greece; the English people hardly knew where these countries +were, or that they were not inhabited by Turks. The Crimean War had left +behind it the tradition of friendship with the Sultan; it needed some +lightning-flash, some shock penetrating all ranks of society, to dispel +once and for all the conventional idea of Turkey as a community resembling +a European State, and to bring home to the English people the true +condition of the Christian races of the Balkan under their Ottoman masters. +But this the Bulgarian massacres effectively did; and from this time the +great mass of the English people, who had sympathised so strongly with the +Italians and the Hungarians in their struggle for national independence, +were not disposed to allow the influence of Great Britain to be used for +the perpetuation of Turkish ascendency over the Slavic races. There is +little doubt that if in the autumn of 1876 the nation had had the +opportunity of expressing its views by a Parliamentary election, it would +have insisted on the adoption of active measures in concert with the Powers +which were prepared to force reform upon the Porte. But the Parliament of +1876 was but two years old; the majority which supported the Government was +still unbroken; and at the head of the Cabinet there was a man gifted with +extraordinary tenacity of purpose, with great powers of command over +others, and with a clear, cold, untroubled apprehension of the line of +conduct which he intended to pursue. It was one of the strangest features +of this epoch that a Minister who in a long career had never yet exercised +the slightest influence upon foreign affairs, and who was not himself +English by birth, should have impressed in such an extreme degree the stamp +of his own individuality upon the conduct of our foreign policy; that he +should have forced England to the very front in the crisis through which +Europe was passing; and that, for good or for evil, he should have reversed +the tendency which since the Italian war of 1859 had seemed ever to be +drawing England further and further away from Continental affairs. + +[Disraeli.] + +Disraeli's conception of Parliamentary politics was an ironical one. It had +pleased the British nation that the leadership of one of its great +political parties should be won by a man of genius only on the condition of +accommodating himself to certain singular fancies of his contemporaries; +and for twenty years, from the time of his attacks upon Sir Robert Peel for +the abolition of the corn-laws down to the time when he educated his party +into the democratic Reform Bill of 1867, Disraeli with an excellent grace +suited himself to the somewhat strange parts which he was required to play. +But after 1874, when he was placed in office at the head of a powerful +majority in both Houses of Parliament and of a submissive Cabinet, the +antics ended; the epoch of statesmanship, and of statesmanship based on the +leader's own individual thought not on the commonplace of public creeds, +began. At a time when Cavour was rice-growing and Bismarck unknown outside +his own county, Disraeli had given to the world in Tancred his visions of +Eastern Empire. Mysterious chieftains planned the regeneration of Asia by a +new crusade of Arab and Syrian votaries of the one living faith, and +lightly touched on the transfer of Queen Victoria's Court from London to +Delhi. Nothing indeed is perfect; and Disraeli's eye was favoured with such +extraordinary perceptions of the remote that it proved a little uncertain +in its view of matters not quite without importance nearer home. He thought +the attempt to establish Italian independence a misdemeanour; he listened +to Bismarck's ideas on the future of Germany, and described them as the +vapourings of a German baron. For a quarter of a century Disraeli had +dazzled and amused the House of Commons without, as it seemed, drawing +inspiration from any one great cause or discerning any one of the political +goals towards which the nations of Europe were tending. At length, however, +the time came for the realisation of his own imperial policy; and before +the Eastern question had risen conspicuously above the horizon in Europe, +Disraeli, as Prime Minister of England, had begun to act in Asia and +Africa. He sent the Prince of Wales to hold Durbars and to hunt tigers +amongst the Hindoos; he proclaimed the Queen Empress of India; he purchased +the Khedive's shares in the Suez Canal. Thus far it had been uncertain +whether there was much in the Minister's policy beyond what was theatrical +and picturesque; but when a great part of the nation began to ask for +intervention on behalf of the Eastern Christians against the Turks, they +found out that Disraeli's purpose was solid enough. Animated by a deep +distrust and fear of Russia, he returned to what had been the policy of +Tory Governments in the days before Canning, the identification of British +interests with the maintenance of Ottoman power. If a generation of +sentimentalists were willing to sacrifice the grandeur of an Empire to +their sympathies with an oppressed people, it was not Disraeli who would be +their instrument. When the massacre of Batak was mentioned in the House of +Commons, he dwelt on the honourable qualities of the Circassians; when +instances of torture were alleged, he remarked that an oriental people +generally terminated its connection with culprits in a more expeditious +manner. [549] There were indeed Englishmen enough who loved their country +as well as Disraeli, and who had proved their love by sacrifices which +Disraeli had not had occasion to make, who thought it humiliating that the +greatness of England should be purchased by the servitude and oppression of +other races, and that the security of their Empire should be deemed to rest +on so miserable a thing as Turkish rule. These were considerations to which +Disraeli did not attach much importance. He believed the one thing needful +to be the curbing of Russia; and, unlike Canning, who held that Russia +would best be kept in check by England's own armed co-operation with it in +establishing the independence of Greece, he declined from the first to +entertain any project of imposing reform on the Sultan by force, doubting +only to what extent it would be possible for him to support the Sultan in +resistance to other Powers. According to his own later statement he would +himself, had he been left unfettered, have definitely informed the Czar +that if he should make war upon the Porte England would act as its ally. +Public opinion in England, however, rendered this course impossible. The +knife of Circassian and Bashi-Bazouk had severed the bond with Great +Britain which had saved Turkey in 1854. Disraeli--henceforward Earl of +Beaconsfield--could only utter grim anathemas against Servia for presuming +to draw the sword upon its rightful lord and master, and chide those +impatient English who, like the greater man whose name is associated with +Beaconsfield, considered that the world need not be too critical as to the +means of getting rid of such an evil as Ottoman rule. [550] + +[Meeting and Treaty of Reichstadt, July 8.] + +[The Servian Campaign, July-Oct.] + +[Russian enforces an armistice, Oct. 30.] + +The rejection by England of the Berlin Memorandum and the proclamation of +war by Servia and Montenegro were followed by the closer union of the +three Imperial Courts. The Czar and the Emperor Francis Joseph, with +their Ministers, met at Reichstadt in Bohemia on the 8th of July. +According to official statements the result of the meeting was that the +two sovereigns determined upon non-intervention for the present, and +proposed only to renew the attempt to unite all the Christian Powers in a +common policy when some definite occasion should arise. Rumours, however, +which proved to be correct, went abroad that something of the nature of +an eventual partition of European Turkey had been the object of +negotiation. A Treaty had in fact been signed providing that if Russia +should liberate Bulgaria by arms, Austria should enter into possession of +Bosnia and Herzegovina. The neutrality of Austria had virtually been +purchased at this price, and Russia had thus secured freedom of action in +the event of the necessary reforms not being forced upon Turkey by the +concert of Europe. Sooner perhaps than Prince Gortschakoff had expected, +the religious enthusiasm of the Russian people and their sympathy for +their kinsmen and fellow-believers beyond the Danube forced the Czar into +vigorous action. In spite of the assistance of several thousands of +Russian volunteers and of the leadership of the Russian General +Tchernaieff, the Servians were defeated in their struggle with the Turks. +The mediation of England was in vain tendered to the Porte on the only +terms on which even at London peace was seen to be possible, the +maintenance of the existing rights of Servia and the establishment of +provincial autonomy in Bosnia, Herzegovina, and Bulgaria. After a brief +suspension of hostilities in September war was renewed. The Servians were +driven from their positions; Alexinatz was captured, the road to Belgrade +lay open, and the doom of Bulgaria seemed likely to descend upon the +conquered Principality. The Turks offered indeed a five months' armistice, +which would have saved them the risks of a winter campaign and enabled +them to crush their enemy with accumulated forces in the following +spring. This, by the advice of Russia, the Servians refused to accept. On +the 30th of October a Russian ultimatum was handed in at Constantinople +by the Ambassador Ignatieff, requiring within forty-eight hours the grant +to Servia of an armistice for two months and the cessation of hostilities. +The Porte submitted; and wherever Slav and Ottoman stood facing one +another in arms, in Herzegovina and Bosnia as well as Servia and +Montenegro, there was a pause in the struggle. + +[Declaration of the Czar, Nov. 2.] + +[England proposes a Conference.] + +The imminence of a war between Russia and Turkey in the last days of +October and the close connection between Russia and the Servian cause +justified the anxiety of the British Government. This anxiety the Czar +sought to dispel by a frank declaration of his own views. On the 2nd of +November he entered into conversation with the British Ambassador, Lord A. +Loftus, and assured him on his word of honour that he had no intention of +acquiring Constantinople; that if it should be necessary for him to occupy +part of Bulgaria his army would remain there only until peace was restored +and the security of the Christian population established; and, generally, +that he desired nothing more earnestly than a complete accord between +England and Russia in the maintenance of European peace and the improvement +of the condition of the Christian population in Turkey. He stated, however, +with perfect clearness that if the Porte should continue to refuse the +reforms demanded by Europe, and the Powers should put up with its continued +refusal, Russia would act alone. Disclaiming in words of great earnestness +all desire for territorial aggrandisement, he protested against the +suspicion with which his policy was regarded in England, and desired that +his words might be made public in England as a message of peace. [551] Lord +Derby, then Foreign Secretary, immediately expressed the satisfaction with +which the Government had received these assurances; and on the following +day an invitation was sent from London to all the European Powers proposing +a Conference at Constantinople, on the basis of a common recognition of the +integrity of the Ottoman Empire, accompanied by a disavowal on the part of +each of the Powers of all aims at aggrandisement or separate advantage. In +proposing this Conference the Government acted in conformity with the +expressed desire of the Czar. But there were two voices within the Cabinet. +Lord Beaconsfield, had it been in his power, would have informed Russia +categorically that England would support the Sultan if attacked. This the +country and the Cabinet forbade: but the Premier had his own opportunities +of utterance, and at the Guildhall Banquet on the 9th of November, six days +after the Foreign Secretary had acknowledged the Czar's message of +friendship, and before this message had been made known to the English +people, Lord Beaconsfield uttered words which, if they were not idle +bluster, could have been intended only as a menace to the Czar or as an +appeal to the war-party at home:--"Though the policy of England is peace, +there is no country so well prepared for war as our own. If England enters +into conflict in a righteous cause, her resources are inexhaustible. She is +not a country that when she enters into a campaign has to ask herself +whether she can support a second or a third campaign. She enters into a +campaign which she will not terminate till right is done." + +[Project of Ottoman Constitution.] + +The proposal made by the Earl of Derby for a Conference at Constantinople +was accepted by all the Powers, and accepted on the bases specified. Lord +Salisbury, then Secretary of State for India, was appointed to represent +Great Britain in conjunction with Sir H. Elliot, its Ambassador. The +Minister made his journey to Constantinople by way of the European +capitals, and learnt at Berlin that the good understanding between the +German Emperor and the Czar extended to Eastern affairs. Whether the +British Government had as yet gained any trustworthy information on the +Treaty of Reichstadt is doubtful; but so far as the public eye could judge, +there was now, in spite of the tone assumed by Lord Beaconsfield, a fairer +prospect of the solution of the Eastern question by the establishment of +some form of autonomy in the Christian provinces than there had been at any +previous time. The Porte itself recognised the serious intention of the +Powers, and, in order to forestall the work of the Conference, prepared a +scheme of constitutional reform that far surpassed the wildest claims of +Herzegovinian or of Serb. Nothing less than a complete system of +Parliamentary Government, with the very latest ingenuities from France and +Belgium, was to be granted to the entire Ottoman Empire. That Midhat Pasha, +who was the author of this scheme, may have had some serious end in view is +not impossible; but with the mass of Palace-functionaries at Constantinople +it was simply a device for embarrassing the West with its own inventions; +and the action of men in power, both great and small, continued after the +constitution had come into nominal existence to be exactly what it had been +before. The very terms of the constitution must have been unintelligible to +all but those who had been employed at foreign courts. The Government might +as well have announced its intention of clothing the Balkans with the flora +of the deep sea. + +[Demands settled at the Preliminary Conference, Dec. 11-21.] + +In the second week of December the representatives of the six Great Powers +assembled at Constantinople. In order that the demands of Europe should be +presented to the Porte with unanimity, they determined to hold a series of +preliminary meetings with one another before the formal opening of the +Conference and before communicating with the Turks. At these meetings, +after Ignatieff had withdrawn his proposal for a Russian occupation of +Bulgaria, complete accord was attained. It was resolved to demand the +cession of certain small districts by the Porte to Servia and Montenegro; +the grant of administrative autonomy to Bosnia, Herzegovina, and Bulgaria; +the appointment in each of these provinces of Christian governors, whose +terms of office should be for five years, and whose nomination should be +subject to the approval of the Powers; the confinement of Turkish troops to +the fortresses; the removal of the bands of Circassians to Asia; and +finally the execution of these reforms under the superintendence of an +International Commission, which should have at its disposal a corps of six +thousand gendarmes to be enlisted in Switzerland or Belgium. By these +arrangements, while the Sultan retained his sovereignty and the integrity +of the Ottoman Empire remained unimpaired, it was conceived that the +Christian population would be effectively secured against Turkish violence +and caprice. + +[The Turks refuse the demands of the Conference, Jan. 20, 1877.] + +All differences between the representatives of the European Powers having +been removed, the formal Conference was opened on the 23rd of December +under the presidency of the Turkish Foreign Minister, Savfet Pasha. The +proceedings had not gone far when they were interrupted by the roar of +cannon. Savfet explained that the new Ottoman constitution was being +promulgated, and that the salvo which the members of the Conference heard +announced the birth of an era of universal happiness and prosperity in the +Sultan's dominions. It soon appeared that in the presence of this great +panacea there was no place for the reforming efforts of the Christian +Powers. Savfet declared from the first that, whatever concessions might be +made on other points, the Sultan's Government would never consent to the +establishment of a Foreign Commission to superintend the execution of its +reforms, nor to the joint action of the Powers in the appointment of the +governors of its provinces. It was in vain argued that without such +foreign control Europe possessed no guarantee that the promises and the +good intentions of the Porte, however gratifying these might be, would be +carried into effect. Savfet replied that by the Treaty of 1856 the Powers +had declared the Ottoman Empire to stand on exactly the same footing as +any other great State in Europe, and had expressly debarred themselves +from interfering, under whatever circumstances, with its internal +administration. The position of the Turkish representative at the +Conference was in fact the only logical one. In the Treaty of Paris the +Powers had elaborately pledged themselves to an absurdity; and this +Treaty the Turk was never weary of throwing in their faces. But the +situation was not one for lawyers and for the interpretation of +documents. The Conference, after hearing the arguments and the +counter-projects of the Turkish Ministers, after reconsidering its own +demands and modifying these in many important points in deference to +Ottoman wishes, adhered to the demand for a Foreign Commission and for a +European control over the appointment of governors. Midhat, who was now +Grand Vizier, summoned the Great Council of the Empire, and presented to +it the demands of the Conference. These demands the Great Council +unanimously rejected. Lord Salisbury had already warned the Sultan what +would be the results of continued obstinacy; and after receiving Midhat's +final reply the ambassadors of all the Powers, together with the envoys +who had been specially appointed for the Conference, quitted +Constantinople. + +[The London Protocol, Mar. 31.] + +[The Porte rejects the Protocol.] + +[Russia declares war, April 24.] + +Russia, since the beginning of November, had been actively preparing for +war. The Czar had left the world in no doubt as to his own intentions in +case of the failure of the European Concert; it only remained for him to +ascertain whether, after the settlement of a definite scheme of reform by +the Conference and the rejection of this scheme by the Porte, the Powers +would or would not take steps to enforce their conclusion. England +suggested that the Sultan should be allowed a year to carry out his good +intentions: Gortschakoff inquired whether England would pledge itself to +action if, at the end of the year, reform was not effected; but no such +pledge was forthcoming. With the object either of discovering some +arrangement in which the Powers would combine, or of delaying the outbreak +of war until the Russian preparations were more advanced and the season +more favourable, Ignatieff was sent round to all the European Courts. He +visited England, and subsequently drew up, with the assistance of Count +Schouvaloff, Russian Ambassador at London, a document which gained the +approval of the British as well as the Continental Governments. This +document, known as the London Protocol, was signed on the 31st of March. +After a reference to the promises of reform made by the Porte, it stated +that the Powers intended to watch carefully by their representatives over +the manner in which these promises were carried into effect; that if their +hopes should be once more disappointed they should regard the condition of +affairs as incompatible with the interests of Europe; and that in such case +they would decide in common upon the means best fitted to secure the +well-being of the Christian population and the interests of general peace. +Declarations relative to the disarmament of Russia, which it was now the +principal object of the British Government to effect, were added. There was +indeed so little of a substantial engagement in this Protocol that it would +have been surprising had Russia disarmed without obtaining some further +guarantee for the execution of reform. But weak as the Protocol was, it was +rejected by the Porte. Once more the appeal was made to the Treaty of +Paris, once more the Sultan protested against the encroachment of the +Powers on his own inviolable rights. Lord Beaconsfield's Cabinet even now +denied that the last word had been spoken, and professed to entertain some +hope in the effect of subsequent diplomatic steps; but the rest of Europe +asked and expected no further forbearance on the part of Russia. The army +of operations already lay on the Pruth: the Grand Duke Nicholas, brother of +the Czar, was appointed to its command; and on the 24th of April the +Russian Government issued its declaration of war. + +[Passage of the Danube, June 27.] + +[Advance on the Balkans, July.] + +[Gourko south of the Balkans, July 15.] + +Between the Russian frontier and the Danube lay the Principality of +Roumania. A convention signed before the outbreak of hostilities gave to +the Russian army a free passage through this territory, and Roumania +subsequently entered the war as Russia's ally. It was not, however, until +the fourth week of June that the invaders were able to cross the Danube. +Seven army-corps were assembled in Roumania; of these one crossed the Lower +Danube into the Dobrudscha, two were retained in Roumania as a reserve, and +four crossed the river in the neighbourhood of Sistowa, in order to enter +upon the Bulgarian campaign. It was the desire of the Russians to throw +forward the central part of their army by the line of the river Jantra upon +the Balkans; with their left to move against Rustchuk and the Turkish +armies in the eastern fortresses of Bulgaria; with their right to capture +Nicopolis, and guard the central column against any flank attack from the +west. But both in Europe and in Asia the Russians had underrated the power +of their adversary, and entered upon the war with insufficient forces. +Advantages won by their generals on the Armenian frontier while the +European army was still marching through Roumania were lost in the course +of the next few weeks. Bayazid and other places that fell into the hands of +the Russians at the first onset were recovered by the Turks under Mukhtar +Pasha; and within a few days after the opening of the European campaign the +Russian divisions in Asia were everywhere retreating upon their own +frontier. The Bulgarian campaign was marked by the same rapid successes of +the invader at the outset, to be followed, owing to the same insufficiency +of force, by similar disasters. Encountering no effective opposition on the +Danube, the Russians pushed forward rapidly towards the Balkans by the line +of the Jantra. The Turkish army lay scattered in the Bulgarian fortresses, +from Widdin in the extreme west to Shumla at the foot of the Eastern +Balkans. It was considered by the Russian commanders that two army-corps +would be required to operate against the Turks in Eastern Bulgaria, while +one corps would be enough to cover the central line of invasion from the +west. There remained, excluding the two corps in reserve in Roumania and +the corps holding the Dobrudscha, but one corps for the march on the +Balkans and Adrianople. The command of the vanguard of this body was given +to General Gourko, who pressed on into the Balkans, seized the Shipka Pass, +and descended into Southern Bulgaria (July 15). The Turks were driven from +Kesanlik and Eski Sagra, and Gourko's cavalry, a few hundreds in number, +advanced to within two days' march of Adrianople. + +[Osman occupies Plevna, July 19.] + +[First engagement at Plevna, July 20.] + +[Second battle at Plevna, July 30.] + +[The Shipka Pass, Aug. 20-23.] + +The headquarters of the whole Russian army were now at Tirnova, the ancient +Bulgarian capital, about half-way between the Danube and the Balkans. Two +army-corps, commanded by the Czarewitch, moved eastwards against Rustchuk +and the so-called Turkish army of the Danube, which was gathering behind +the lines of the Kara Lom; another division, under General Krudener, turned +westward and captured Nicopolis with its garrison. Lovatz and other points +lying westward of the Jantra were occupied by weak detachments; but so +badly were the reconnaissances of the Russians performed in this direction +that they were unaware of the approach of a Turkish army from Widdin, +thirty-five thousand strong, till this was close on their flank. Before the +Russians could prevent him, Osman Pasha, with the vanguard of this army, +had occupied the town and heights of Plevna, between Nicopolis and Lovatz. +On the 20th of July, still unaware of their enemy's strength, the Russians +attacked him at Plevna: they were defeated with considerable loss, and +after a few days one of Osman's divisions, pushing forward upon the +invader's central line, drove them out of Lovatz. The Grand Duke now sent +reinforcements to Krudener, and ordered him to take Plevna at all costs. +Krudener's strength was raised to thirty-five thousand; but in the meantime +new Turkish regiments had joined Osman, and his troops, now numbering about +fifty thousand, had been working day and night entrenching themselves in +the heights round Plevna which the Russians had to attack. The assault was +made on the 30th of July; it was beaten back with terrible slaughter, the +Russians leaving a fifth of their number on the field. Had Osman taken up +the offensive and the Turkish commander on the Lom pressed vigorously upon +the invader's line, it would probably have gone ill with the Russian army +in Bulgaria. Gourko was at once compelled to abandon the country south of +the Balkans. His troops, falling back upon the Shipka Pass, were there +attacked from the south by far superior forces under Suleiman Pasha. The +Ottoman commander, prodigal of the lives of his men and trusting to mere +blindfold violence, hurled his army day after day against the Russian +positions (Aug. 20-23). There was a moment when all seemed lost, and the +Russian soldiers sent to their Czar the last message of devotion from men +who were about to die at their post. But in the extremity of peril there +arrived a reinforcement, weak, but sufficient to turn the scale against the +ill-commanded Turks. Suleiman's army withdrew to the village of Shipka at +the southern end of the pass. The pass itself, with the entrance from +northern Bulgaria, remained in the hands of the Russians. + +[Roumania.] + +[Third battle of Plevna, Sept 11-12.] + +After the second battle of Plevna it became clear that the Russians could +not carry on the campaign with their existing forces. Two army-corps were +called up which were guarding the coast of the Black Sea; several others +were mobilised in the interior of Russia, and began their journey towards +the Danube. So urgent, however, was the immediate need, that the Czar was +compelled to ask help from Roumania. This help was given. Roumanian troops, +excellent in quality, filled up the gap caused by Krudener's defeats, and +the whole army before Plevna was placed under the command of the Roumanian +Prince Charles. At the beginning of September the Russians were again ready +for action. Lovatz was wrested from the Turks, and the division which had +captured it moved on to Plevna to take part in a great combined attack. +This attack was made on the 11th of September under the eyes of the Czar. +On the north the Russians and Roumanians together, after a desperate +struggle, stormed the Grivitza redoubt. On the south Skobeleff carried the +first Turkish position, but could make no impression on their second line +of defence. Twelve thousand men fell on the Russian side before the day was +over, and the main defences of the Turks were still unbroken. On the morrow +the Turks took up the offensive. Skobeleff, exposed to the attack of a far +superior foe, prayed in vain for reinforcements. His men, standing in the +positions that they had won from the Turks, repelled one onslaught after +another, but were ultimately overwhelmed and driven from the field. At the +close of the second day's battle the Russians were everywhere beaten back +within their own lines, except at the Grivitza redoubt, which was itself +but an outwork of the Turkish defences, and faced by more formidable works +within. The assailants had sustained a loss approaching that of the Germans +at Gravelotte with an army one-third of the Germans' strength. Osman was +stronger than at the beginning of the campaign; with what sacrifices Russia +would have to purchase its ultimate victory no man could calculate. + +[Todleben besieges Plevna.] + +[Fall of Plevna, Dec. 10.] + +The three defeats at Plevna cast a sinister light upon the Russian military +administration and the quality of its chiefs. The soldiers had fought +heroically; divisional generals like Skobeleff had done all that man could +do in such positions; the faults were those of the headquarters and the +officers by whom the Imperial Family were surrounded. After the third +catastrophe, public opinion called for the removal of the authors of these +disasters and the employment of abler men. Todleben, the defender of +Sebastopol, who for some unknown reason had been left without a command, +was now summoned to Bulgaria, and virtually placed at the head of the army +before Plevna. He saw that the stronghold of Osman could only be reduced by +a regular siege, and prepared to draw his lines right round it. For a time +Osman kept open his communications with the south-west, and heavy trains of +ammunition and supplies made their way into Plevna from this direction; but +the investment was at length completed, and the army of Plevna cut off from +the world. In the meantime new regiments were steadily pouring into +Bulgaria from the interior of Russia. East of the Jantra, after many +alternations of fortune, the Turks were finally driven back behind the +river Lom. The last efforts of Suleiman failed to wrest the Shipka Pass +from its defenders. From the narrow line which the invaders had with such +difficulty held during three anxious months their forces, accumulating day +by day, spread out south and west up to the slopes of the Balkans, ready to +burst over the mountain-barrier and sweep the enemy back to the walls of +Constantinople when once Plevna should have fallen and the army which +besieged it should be added to the invader's strength. At length, in the +second week of December, Osman's supply of food was exhausted. Victor in +three battles, he refused to surrender without one more struggle. On the +10th of December, after distributing among his men what there remained of +provisions, he made a desperate effort to break out towards the west. His +columns dashed in vain against the besieger's lines; behind him his enemies +pressed forward into the positions which he had abandoned; a ring of fire +like that of Sedan surrounded the Turkish army; and after thousands had +fallen in a hopeless conflict, the general and the troops who for five +months had held in check the collected forces of the Russian Empire +surrendered to their conqueror. + +[Crossing of the Balkans, Dec. 25-Jan. 8.] + +[Capitulation of Shipka, Jan. 9.] + +[Russians enter Adrianople, Jan. 20, 1878.] + +If in the first stages of the war there was little that did credit to +Russia's military capacity, the energy that marked its close made amends +for what had gone before. Winter was descending in extreme severity: the +Balkans were a mass of snow and ice; but no obstacle could now bar the +invader's march. Gourko, in command of an army that had gathered to the +south-west of Plevna, made his way through the mountains above Etropol in +the last days of December, and, driving the Turks from Sophia, pressed on +towards Philippopolis and Adrianople. Farther east two columns crossed the +Balkans by bye-paths right and left of the Shipka Pass, and then, +converging on Shipka itself, fell upon the rear of the Turkish army which +still blocked the southern outlet. Simultaneously a third corps marched +down the pass from the north and assailed the Turks in front. After a +fierce struggle the entire Turkish army, thirty-five thousand strong, laid +down its arms. There now remained only one considerable force between the +invaders and Constantinople. This body, which was commanded by Suleiman, +held the road which runs along the valley of the Maritza, at a point +somewhat to the east of Philippopolis. Against it Gourko advanced from the +west, while the victors of Shipka, descending due south through Kesanlik, +barred the line of retreat towards Adrianople. The last encounter of the +war took place on the 17th of January. Suleiman's army, routed and +demoralised, succeeded in making its escape to the AEgean coast. Pursuit was +unnecessary, for the war was now practically over. On the 20th of January +the Russians made their entry into Adrianople; in the next few days their +advanced guard touched the Sea of Marmora at Rodosto. + +[Armistice, Jan. 31.] + +Immediately after the fall of Plevna the Porte had applied to the European +Powers for their mediation. Disasters in Asia had already warned it not to +delay submission too long; for in the middle of October Mukhtar Pasha had +been driven from his positions, and a month later Kars had been taken by +storm. The Russians had subsequently penetrated into Armenia and had +captured the outworks of Erzeroum. Each day that now passed brought the +Ottoman Empire nearer to destruction. Servia again declared war; the +Montenegrins made themselves masters of the coast-towns and of +border-territory north and south; Greece seemed likely to enter into the +struggle. Baffled in his attempt to gain the common mediation of the +Powers, the Sultan appealed to the Queen of England personally for her good +offices in bringing the conflict to a close. In reply to a telegram from +London, the Czar declared himself willing to treat for peace as soon as +direct communications should be addressed to his representatives by the +Porte. On the 14th of January commissioners were sent to the headquarters +of the Grand Duke Nicholas at Kesanlik to treat for an armistice and for +preliminaries of peace. The Russians, now in the full tide of victory, were +in no hurry to agree with their adversary. Nicholas bade the Turkish envoys +accompany him to Adrianople, and it was not until the 31st of January that +the armistice was granted and the preliminaries of peace signed. + +[England.] + +[Vote of Credit, Jan. 28-Feb. 8.] + +[Fleet passes the Dardanelles, Feb. 6.] + +While the Turkish envoys were on their journey to the Russian headquarters, +the session of Parliament opened at London. The Ministry had declared at +the outbreak of the war that Great Britain would remain neutral unless its +own interests should be imperilled, and it had defined these interests with +due clearness both in its communications with the Russian Ambassador and in +its statements in Parliament. It was laid down that Her Majesty's +Government could not permit the blockade of the Suez Canal, or the +extension of military operations to Egypt; that it could not witness with +indifference the passing of Constantinople into other hands than those of +its present possessors; and that it would entertain serious objections to +any material alterations in the rules made under European sanction for the +navigation of the Bosphorus and Dardanelles. [552] In reply to Lord Derby's +note which formulated these conditions of neutrality Prince Gortschakoff +had repeated the Czar's assurance that the acquisition of Constantinople +was excluded from his views, and had promised to undertake no military +operation in Egypt; he had, however, let it be understood that, as an +incident of warfare, the reduction of Constantinople might be necessary +like that of any other capital. In the Queen's speech at the opening of +Parliament, Ministers stated that the conditions on which the neutrality of +England was founded had not hitherto been infringed by either belligerent, +but that, should hostilities be prolonged, some unexpected occurrence might +render it necessary to adopt measures of precaution, measures which could +not be adequately prepared without an appeal to the liberality of +Parliament. From language subsequently used by Lord Beaconsfield's +colleagues, it would appear that the Cabinet had some apprehension that the +Russian army, escaping from the Czar's control, might seize and attempt +permanently to hold Constantinople. On the 23rd of January orders were sent +to Admiral Hornby, commander of the fleet at Besika Bay, to pass the +Dardanelles, and proceed to Constantinople. Lord Derby, who saw no +necessity for measures of a warlike character until the result of the +negotiations at Adrianople should become known, now resigned office; but on +the reversal of the order to Admiral Hornby he rejoined the Cabinet. On the +28th of January, after the bases of peace had been communicated by Count +Schouvaloff to the British Government but before they had been actually +signed, the Chancellor of the Exchequer moved for a vote of L6,000,000 for +increasing the armaments of the country. This vote was at first vigorously +opposed on the ground that none of the stated conditions of England's +neutrality had been infringed, and that in the conditions of peace between +Russia and Turkey there was nothing that justified a departure from the +policy which England had hitherto pursued. In the course of the debates, +however, a telegram arrived from Mr. Layard, Elliot's successor at +Constantinople, stating that notwithstanding the armistice the Russians +were pushing on towards the capital; that the Turks had been compelled to +evacuate Silivria on the Sea of Marmora; that the Russian general was about +to occupy Tchataldja, an outpost of the last line of defence not thirty +miles from Constantinople; and that the Porte was in great alarm, and +unable to understand the Russian proceedings. The utmost excitement was +caused at Westminster by this telegram. The fleet was at once ordered to +Constantinople. Mr. Forster, who had led the opposition to the vote of +credit, sought to withdraw his amendment; and although on the following +day, with the arrival of the articles of the armistice, it appeared that +the Russians were simply moving up to the accepted line of demarcation, and +that the Porte could hardly have been ignorant of this when Layard's +telegram was despatched, the alarm raised in London did not subside, and +the vote of credit was carried by a majority of above two hundred. [553] + +[Imminence of war with England.] + +When a victorious army is, without the intervention of some external Power, +checked in its work of conquest by the negotiation of an armistice, it is +invariably made a condition that positions shall be handed over to it which +it does not at the moment occupy, but which it might reasonably expect to +have conquered within a certain date, had hostilities not been suspended. +The armistice granted to Austria by Napoleon after the battle of Marengo +involved the evacuation of the whole of Upper Italy; the armistice which +Bismarck offered to the French Government of Defence at the beginning of +the siege of Paris would have involved the surrender of Strasburg and of +Toul. In demanding that the line of demarcation should be carried almost up +to the walls of Constantinople the Russians were asking for no more than +would certainly have been within their hands had hostilities been prolonged +for a few weeks, or even days. Deeply as the conditions of the armistice +agitated the English people, it was not in these conditions, but in the +conditions of the peace which was to follow, that the true cause of +contention between England and Russia, if cause there was, had to be found. +Nevertheless, the approach of the Russians to Gallipoli and the lines of +Tchataldja, followed, as it was, by the despatch of the British fleet to +Constantinople, brought Russia and Great Britain within a hair's breadth of +war. It was in vain that Lord Derby described the fleet as sent only for +the protection of the lives and property of British subjects. Gortschakoff, +who was superior in amenities of this kind, replied that the Russian +Government had exactly the same end in view, with the distinction that its +protection would be extended to all Christians. Should the British fleet +appear at the Bosphorus, Russian troops would, in the fulfilment of a +common duty of humanity, enter Constantinople. Yielding to this threat, +Lord Beaconsfield bade the fleet halt at a convenient point in the Sea of +Marmora. On both sides preparations were made for immediate action. The +guns on our ships stood charged for battle; the Russians strewed the +shallows with torpedoes. Had a Russian soldier appeared on the heights of +Gallipoli, had an Englishman landed on the Asiatic shore of the Bosphorus, +war would at once have broken out. But after some weeks of extreme danger +the perils of mere contiguity passed away, and the decision between peace +and war was transferred from the accidents of tent and quarter deck to the +deliberations of statesmen assembled in Congress. + +[Treaty of San Stefano, Mar. 3.] + +The bases of Peace which were made the condition of the armistice granted +at Adrianople formed with little alteration the substance of the Treaty +signed by Russia and Turkey at San Stefano, a village on the Sea of +Marmora, on the 3rd of March. By this Treaty the Porte recognised the +independence of Servia, Montenegro, and Roumania, and made considerable +cessions of territory to the two former States. Bulgaria was constituted an +autonomous tributary Principality, with a Christian Government and a +national militia. Its frontier, which was made so extensive as to include +the greater part of European Turkey, was defined as beginning near Midia on +the Black Sea, not sixty miles from the Bosphorus; passing thence westwards +just to the north of Adrianople; descending to the AEgean Sea, and following +the coast as far as the Thracian Chersonese; then passing inland westwards, +so as barely to exclude Salonika; running on to the border of Albania +within fifty miles of the Adriatic, and from this point following the +Albanian border up to the new Servian frontier. The Prince of Bulgaria was +to be freely elected by the population, and confirmed by the Porte with the +assent of the Powers; a system of administration was to be drawn up by an +Assembly of Bulgarian notables; and the introduction of the new system into +Bulgaria with the superintendence of its working was to be entrusted for +two years to a Russian Commissioner. Until the native militia was +organised, Russian troops, not exceeding fifty thousand in number, were to +occupy the country; this occupation, however, was to be limited to a term +approximating to two years. In Bosnia and Herzegovina the proposals laid +before the Porte at the first sitting of the Conference of 1876 were to be +immediately introduced, subject to such modifications as might be agreed +upon between Turkey, Russia, and Austria. The Porte undertook to apply +scrupulously in Crete the Organic Law which had been drawn up in 1868, +taking into account the previously expressed wishes of the native +population. An analogous law, adapted to local requirements, was, after +being communicated to the Czar, to be introduced into Epirus, Thessaly, and +the other parts of Turkey in Europe for which a special constitution was +not provided by the Treaty. Commissions, in which the native population was +to be largely represented, were in each province to be entrusted with the +task of elaborating the details of the new organisation. In Armenia the +Sultan undertook to carry into effect without further delay the +improvements and reforms demanded by local requirements, and to guarantee +the security of the Armenians from Kurds and Circassians. As an indemnity +for the losses and expenses of the war the Porte admitted itself to be +indebted to Russia in the sum of fourteen hundred million roubles; but in +accordance with the wishes of the Sultan, and in consideration of the +financial embarrassments of Turkey, the Czar consented to accept in +substitution for the greater part of this sum the cession of the Dobrudscha +in Europe, and of the districts of Ardahan, Kars, Batoum, and Bayazid in +Asia. As to the balance of three hundred million roubles left due to +Russia, the mode of payment or guarantee was to be settled by an +understanding between the two Governments. The Dobrudscha was to be given +by the Czar to Roumania in exchange for Bessarabia, which this State was to +transfer to Russia. The complete evacuation of Turkey in Europe was to take +place within three months, that of Turkey in Asia within six months, from +the conclusion of peace. [554] + +[Congress proposed.] + +[Opposite purposes of Russia and England.] + +It had from the first been admitted by the Russian Government that +questions affecting the interests of Europe at large could not be settled +by a Treaty between Russia and Turkey alone, but must form the subject of +European agreement. Early in February the Emperor of Austria had proposed +that a European Conference should assemble at his own capital. It was +subsequently agreed that Berlin, instead of Vienna, should be the place of +meeting, and instead of a Conference a Congress should be held, that is, an +international assembly of the most solemn form, in which each of the Powers +is represented not merely by an ambassador or an envoy, but by its leading +Ministers. But the question at once arose whether there existed in the mind +of the Russian Government a distinction between parts of the Treaty of San +Stefano bearing on the interests of Europe generally and parts which +affected no States but Russia and Turkey; and whether, in this case, Russia +was willing that Europe should be the judge of the distinction, or, on the +contrary, claimed for itself the right of withholding portions of the +Treaty from the cognisance of the European Court. In accepting the +principle of a Congress, Lord Derby on behalf of Great Britain made it a +condition that every article of the Treaty without exception should be laid +before the Congress, not necessarily as requiring the concurrence of the +Powers, but in order that the Powers themselves might in each case decide +whether their concurrence was necessary or not. To this demand Prince +Gortschakoff offered the most strenuous resistance, claiming for Russia the +liberty of accepting, or not accepting, the discussion of any question that +might be raised. It would clearly have been in the power of the Russian +Government, had this condition been granted, to exclude from the +consideration of Europe precisely those matters which in the opinion of +other States were most essentially of European import. Phrases of +conciliation were suggested; but no ingenuity of language could shade over +the difference of purpose which separated the rival Powers. Every day the +chances of the meeting of the Congress seemed to be diminishing, the +approach of war between Russia and Great Britain more unmistakable. Lord +Beaconsfield called out the Reserves and summoned troops from India; even +the project of seizing a port in Asia Minor in case the Sultan should fall +under Russian influence was discussed in the Cabinet. Unable to reconcile +himself to these vigorous measures, Lord Derby, who had long been at +variance with the Premier, now finally withdrew from the Cabinet (March +28). He was succeeded in his office by the Marquis of Salisbury, whose +comparison of his relative and predecessor to Titus Oates revived the +interest of the diplomatic world in a now forgotten period of English +history. + +[Circular of April 1.] + +The new Foreign Secretary had not been many days in office when a Circular, +despatched to all the Foreign Courts, summed up the objections of Great +Britain to the Treaty of San Stefano. It was pointed out that a strong +Slavic State would be created under the control of Russia, possessing +important harbours upon the shores of the Black Sea and the Archipelago, +and giving to Russia a preponderating influence over political and +commercial relations on both those seas; that a large Greek population +would be merged in a dominant Slavic majority; that by the extension of +Bulgaria to the Archipelago the Albanian and Greek provinces left to the +Sultan would be severed from Constantinople; that the annexation of +Bessarabia and of Batoum would make the will of the Russian Government +dominant over all the vicinity of the Black Sea; that the acquisition of +the strongholds of Armenia would place the population of that province +under the immediate influence of the Power that held these strongholds, +while through the cession of Bayazid the European trade from Trebizond to +Persia would become liable to be arrested by the prohibitory barriers of +the Russian commercial system. Finally, by the stipulation for an indemnity +which it was beyond the power of Turkey to discharge, and by the reference +of the mode of payment or guarantee to a later settlement, Russia had +placed it in its power either to extort yet larger cessions of territory, +or to force Turkey into engagements subordinating its policy in all things +to that of St. Petersburg. + +[Count Schouvaloff.] + +[Secret agreement, May 30th.] + +[Convention with Turkey, June 4.] + +[Cyprus.] + +It was the object of Lord Salisbury to show that the effects of the Treaty +of San Stefano, taken in a mass, threatened the peace and the interests of +Europe, and therefore, whatever might be advanced for or against individual +stipulations of the Treaty, that the Treaty as a whole, and not clauses +selected by one Power, must be submitted to the Congress if the examination +was not to prove illusory. This was a just line of argument. Nevertheless +it was natural to suppose that some parts of the Treaty must be more +distasteful than others to Great Britain; and Count Schouvaloff, who was +sincerely desirous of peace, applied himself to the task of discovering +with what concessions Lord Beaconsfield's Cabinet would be satisfied. He +found that if Russia would consent to modifications of the Treaty in +Congress excluding Bulgaria from the Aegean Sea, reducing its area on the +south and west, dividing it into two provinces, and restoring the Balkans +to the Sultan as a military frontier, giving back Bayazid to the Turks, and +granting to other Powers besides Russia a voice in the organisation of +Epirus, Thessaly, and the other Christian provinces of the Porte, England +might be induced to accept without essential change the other provisions of +San Stefano. On the 7th of May Count Schouvaloff quitted London for St. +Petersburg, in order to lay before the Czar the results of his +communications with the Cabinet, and to acquaint him with the state of +public opinion in England. On his journey hung the issues of peace or war. +Backed by the counsels of the German Emperor, Schouvaloff succeeded in his +mission. The Czar determined not to risk the great results already secured +by insisting on the points contested, and Schouvaloff returned to London +authorised to conclude a pact with the British Government on the general +basis which had been laid down. On the 30th of May a secret agreement, in +which the above were the principal points, was signed, and the meeting of +the Congress for the examination of the entire Treaty of San Stefano was +now assured. But it was not without the deepest anxiety and regret that +Lord Beaconsfield consented to the annexation of Batoum and the Armenian +fortresses. He obtained indeed an assurance in the secret agreement with +Schouvaloff that the Russian frontier should be no more extended on the +side of Turkey in Asia; but his policy did not stop short here. By a +Convention made with the Sultan on the 4th of June, Great Britain engaged, +in the event of any further aggression by Russia upon the Asiatic +territories of the Sultan, to defend these territories by force of arms. +The Sultan in return promised to introduce the necessary reforms, to be +agreed upon by the two Powers, for the protection of the Christian and +other subjects of the Porte in these territories, and further assigned the +Island of Cyprus to be occupied and administered by England. It was +stipulated by a humorous after-clause that if Russia should restore to +Turkey its Armenian conquests, Cyprus would be evacuated by England, and +the Convention itself should be at an end. [555] + +[Congress of Berlin, June 13-July 13.] + +[Treaty of Berlin, July 13.] + +The Congress of Berlin, at which the Premier himself and Lord Salisbury +represented Great Britain, opened on the 13th of June. Though the +compromise between England and Russia had been settled in general terms, +the arrangement of details opened such a series of difficulties that the +Congress seemed more than once on the point of breaking up. It was mainly +due to the perseverance and wisdom of Prince Bismarck, who transferred the +discussion of the most crucial points from the Congress to private meetings +of his guests, and who himself acted as conciliator when Gortschakoff +folded up his maps or Lord Beaconsfield ordered a special train, that the +work was at length achieved. The Treaty of Berlin, signed on the 13th of +July, confined Bulgaria, as an autonomous Principality, to the country +north of the Balkans, and diminished the authority which, pending the +establishment of its definitive system of government, would by the Treaty +of San Stefano have belonged to a Russian commissioner. The portion of +Bulgaria south of the Balkans, but extending no farther west than the +valley of the Maritza, and no farther south than Mount Rhodope, was formed +into a Province of East Roumelia, to remain subject to the direct political +and military authority of the Sultan, under conditions of administrative +autonomy. The Sultan was declared to possess the right of erecting +fortifications both on the coast and on the land-frontier of this province, +and of maintaining troops there. Alike in Bulgaria and in Eastern Roumelia +the period of occupation by Russian troops was limited to nine months. +Bosnia and Herzegovina were handed over to Austria, to be occupied and +administered by that Power. The cessions of territory made to Servia and +Montenegro in the Treaty of San Stefano were modified with the object of +interposing a broader strip between these two States; Bayazid was omitted +from the ceded districts in Asia, and the Czar declared it his intention to +erect Batoum into a free port, essentially commercial. At the instance of +France the provisions relating to the Greek Provinces of Turkey were +superseded by a vote in favour of the cession of part of these Provinces to +the Hellenic Kingdom. The Sultan was recommended to cede Thessaly and part +of Epirus to Greece, the Powers reserving to themselves the right of +offering their mediation to facilitate the negotiations. In other respects +the provisions of the Treaty of San Stefano were confirmed without +substantial change. + +[Comparison of the two Treaties.] + +Lord Beaconsfield returned to London, bringing, as he said, peace with +honour. It was claimed, in the despatch to our Ambassadors which +accompanied the publication of the Treaty of Berlin, that in this Treaty +the cardinal objections raised by the British Government to the Treaty of +San Stefano had found an entire remedy. "Bulgaria," wrote Lord Salisbury, +"is now confined to the river-barrier of the Danube, and consequently has +not only ceased to possess any harbour on the Archipelago, but is removed +by more than a hundred miles from the neighbourhood of that sea. On the +Euxine the important port of Bourgas has been restored to the Government of +Turkey; and Bulgaria retains less than half the sea-board originally +assigned to it, and possesses no other port except the roadstead of Varna, +which can hardly be used for any but commercial purposes. The replacement +under Turkish rule of Bourgas and the southern half of the sea-board on the +Euxine, and the strictly commercial character assigned to Batoum, have +largely obviated the menace to the liberty of the Black Sea. The political +outposts of Russian power have been pushed back to the region beyond the +Balkans; the Sultan's dominions have been provided with a defensible +frontier." It was in short the contention of the English Government that +while Russia, in the pretended emancipation of a great part of European +Turkey by the Treaty of San Stefano, had but acquired a new dependency, +England, by insisting on the division of Bulgaria, had baffled this plan +and restored to Turkey an effective military dominion over all the country +south of the Balkans. That Lord Beaconsfield did well in severing Macedonia +from the Slavic State of Bulgaria there is little reason to doubt; that, +having so severed it, he did ill in leaving it without a European guarantee +for good government, every successive year made more plain; the wisdom of +his treatment of Bulgaria itself must, in the light of subsequent events, +remain matter for controversy. It may fairly be said that in dealing with +Bulgaria English statesmen were, on the whole, dealing with the unknown. +Nevertheless, had guidance been accepted from the history of the other +Balkan States, analogies were not altogether wanting or altogether remote. +During the present century three Christian States had been formed out of +what had been Ottoman territory: Servia, Greece, and Roumania. Not one of +these had become a Russian Province, or had failed to develop and maintain +a distinct national existence. In Servia an attempt had been made to retain +for the Porte the right of keeping troops in garrison. This attempt had +proved a mistake. So long as the right was exercised it had simply been a +source of danger and disquiet, and it had finally been abandoned by the +Porte itself. In the case of Greece, Russia, with a view to its own +interests, had originally proposed that the country should be divided into +four autonomous provinces tributary to the Sultan: against this the Greeks +had protested, and Canning had successfully supported their protest. Even +the appointment of an ex-Minister of St. Petersburg, Capodistrias, as first +President of Greece in 1827 had failed to bring the liberated country under +Russian influence; and in the course of the half-century which had since +elapsed it had become one of the commonplaces of politics, accepted by +every school in every country of Western Europe, that the Powers had +committed a great error in 1833 in not extending to far larger dimensions +the Greek Kingdom which they then established. In the case of Roumania, the +British Government had, out of fear of Russia, insisted in 1856 that the +provinces of Moldavia and Wallachia should remain separate: the result was +that the inhabitants in defiance of England effected their union, and that +after a few years had passed there was not a single politician in England +who regarded their union otherwise than with satisfaction. If history +taught anything in the solution of the Eastern question, it taught that the +effort to reserve for the Sultan a military existence in countries which +had passed from under his general control was futile, and that the best +barrier against Russian influence was to be found not in the division but +in the strengthening and consolidation of the States rescued from Ottoman +dominions. + +It was of course open to English statesmen in 1878 to believe that all that +had hitherto passed in the Balkan Peninsula had no bearing upon the +problems of the hour, and that, whatever might have been the case with +Greece, Servia, and Roumania, Bulgaria stood on a completely different +footing, and called for the application of principles not based on the +experience of the past but on the divinations of superior minds. Should the +history of succeeding years bear out this view, should the Balkans become a +true military frontier for Turkey, should Northern Bulgaria sink to the +condition of a Russian dependency, and Eastern Roumelia, in severance from +its enslaved kin, abandon itself to a thriving ease behind the garrisons of +the reforming Ottoman, Lord Beaconsfield will have deserved the fame of a +statesman whose intuitions, undimmed by the mists of experience, penetrated +the secret of the future, and shaped, because they discerned, the destiny +of nations. It will be the task of later historians to measure the exact +period after the Congress of Berlin at which the process indicated by Lord +Beaconsfield came into visible operation; it is the misfortune of those +whose view is limited by a single decade to have to record that in every +particular, with the single exception of the severance of Macedonia from +the Slavonic Principality, Lord Beaconsfield's ideas, purposes and +anticipations, in so far as they related to Eastern Europe, have hitherto +been contradicted by events. What happened in Greece, Servia, and Roumania +has happened in Bulgaria. Experience, thrown to the winds by English +Ministers in 1878, has justified those who listened to its voice. There +exists no such thing as a Turkish fortress on the Balkans; Bourgas no more +belongs to the Sultan than Athens or Belgrade; no Turkish soldier has been +able to set foot within the territory whose very name, Eastern Roumelia, +was to stamp it as Turkish dominion. National independence, a living force +in Greece, in Servia, in Roumania, has proved its power in Bulgaria too. +The efforts of Russia to establish its influence over a people liberated by +its arms have been repelled with unexpected firmness. Like the divided +members of Roumania, the divided members of Bulgaria have effected their +union. In this union, in the growing material and moral force of the +Bulgarian State, Western Europe sees a power wholly favourable to its own +hopes for the future of the East, wholly adverse to the extension of +Russian rule: and it has been reserved for Lord Beaconsfield's colleague at +the Congress of Berlin, regardless of the fact that Bulgaria north of the +Balkans, not the southern Province, created that vigorous military and +political organisation which was the precursor of national union, to +explain that in dividing Bulgaria into two portions the English Ministers +of 1878 intended to promote its ultimate unity, and that in subjecting the +southern half to the Sultan's rule they laid the foundation for its +ultimate independence. + + + + + + +[1] Chapters I. to XI. of this Edition. + +[2] Chapters XII. to XVIII. of this Edition. + +[3] Page 362 of this Edition. + +[4] Ranke, Ursprung und Beginn der Revolutionskriege, p. 90, Vivenot, +Quellen zur Geschichte der Kaiserpolitik Oesterreichs, i. 185, 208. + +[5] Von Sybel, Geschichte der Revolutionszeit, i. 289. + +[6] Vivenot, Quellen, i. 372. Buchez et Roux, xiii. 340, xiv. 24. + +[7] Haeusser, Deutsche Geschichte, i. 88. Vivenot, Herzog Albrecht, i. 78. + +[8] Springer, Geschichte Oesterreichs, i. 46. + +[9] Pertz, Leben Stein, ii. 402. Paget, Travels in Hungary, i. 131. + +[10] Ranke, Ursprung und Beginn, p. 256. Vivenot, Quellen, i. 133, 165. The +acquisition of Bavaria was declared by the Austrian Cabinet to be the +_summum bonum_ of the monarchy. + +[11] Biedermann, Deutschland im Achtzehnten Jahrhundert, iv. 1144. + +[12] Carlyle, Friedrich, vi. 667. + +[13] Haeusser, i. 197. Hardenberg (Ranke), i. 139. Von Sybel, i. 272. + +[14] "The connection with the House of Austria and the present undertaking +continue to be very unpopular. It is openly said that one half of the +treasure was uselessly spent at Reichenbach, and that the other half will +be spent on the present occasion, and that the sovereign will be reduced to +his former level of Margrave of Brandenburg." Eden, from Berlin; June 19, +1792. Records: Prussia, vol. 151. "He (Moellendorf) reprobated the alliance +with Austria, condemning the present interference in the affairs of France +as ruinous, and censuring as undignified and contrary to the most important +interests of this country the leaving Russia sole arbitress of the fate of +Poland. He, however, said, what every Prussian without any exception of +party will say, that this country can never acquiesce in the establishment +of a good government in Poland, since in a short time it would rise to a +very decided superiority," _Id._, July 17. Mr. Cobden's theory that +the partition of Poland was effected in the interest of good government +must have caused some surprise at Berlin. + +[15] The condition of Mecklenburg is thus described in a letter written by +Stein during a journey in 1802:--"I found the aspect of the country as +cheerless as its misty northern sky; great estates, much of them in pasture +or fallow; an extremely thin population; the entire labouring class under +the yoke of serfage; stretches of land attached to solitary ill-built +farmhouses; in short, a monotony, a dead stillness, spreading over the +whole country, an absence of life and activity that quite overcame my +spirits. The home of the Mecklenburg noble, who weighs like a load on his +peasants instead of improving their condition, gives me the idea of the den +of some wild beast, who devastates even thing about him, and surrounds +himself with the silence of the grave." Pertz, Leben Stein, i. 192. For a +more cheerful description of Muenster, see _id._, i. 241. + +[16] Perthes, Staatsleben, p. 116. Rigby, Letters from France, p. 215. + +[17] Buchez et Roux, xvi. 279. One of the originals of this declaration, +handed to the British ambassador, is in the London Records: Prussia, vol. +151. + +[18] The accounts of the emigrants sent to England by Lord Elgin, envoy at +Brussels, and Sir J. Murray, our military attache with Brunswick's army (in +Records: Flanders, vol. 221) are instructive: "The conduct of the army +under the Princes of France is universally reprobated. Their appearance in +dress, in attendants, in preparations, is ridiculous. As an instance, +however trivial, it may be mentioned that on one of the waggons was written +_Toilette de Monsieur_. The spirit of vengeance, however, which they +discover on every occasion is far more serious. Wherever they have passed, +they have exercised acts of cruelty, in banishing and severely punishing +those persons who, though probably culpable, had yet been left untouched by +the Prussian commanders. To such an extent has this been carried that the +commander at Verdun would not suffer any Frenchman (emigrant) to pass a +night in the town without a special permission." Sept. 21. After the +failure of the campaign, Elgin writes of the emigrants: "They every-where +added to the cruelties for some of which several hussars had been executed: +carried to its extent the vengeance threatened in the Duke of Brunswick's +Declaration, in burning whole villages where a shot was fired on them: and +on the other hand by their self-sufficiency, want of subordination and +personal disrespect, have drawn upon themselves the contempt of the +combined armies." Oct. 6. So late as 1796, the exile Louis XVIII. declared +his intention to restore the "property and rights" (i.e. tithes, feudal +dues, etc.) of the nobles and clergy, and to punish the men who had +"committed offences." See Letter to Pichegru, May 4, 1796, in Manuscrit +Inedit de Louis XVIII., p. 464. + +[19] Wordsworth, Prelude, book ix. + +[20] The correspondence is in Ranke, Ursprung und Beginn, p. 371. Such was +the famine in the Prussian camp that Dumouriez sent the King of Prussia +twelve loaves, twelve pounds of coffee, and twelve pounds of sugar. The +official account of the campaign is in the _Berlinische Zeitung_ of +Oct. 11, 1792. + +[21] Forster, Werke, vi. 386. + +[22] "The very night the news of the late Emperor's (Leopold's) death +arrived here (Brussels), inflammatory advertisements and invitations to arm +were distributed." One culprit "belonged to the Choir of St. Gudule: he +chose the middle of the day, and in the presence of many people posted up a +paper in the church, exhorting to a general insurrection. The remainder of +this strange production was the description of a vision he pretended to +have seen, representing the soul of the late emperor on its way to join +that of Joseph, already suffering in the other world." Col. Gardiner, March +20, 1792. Records: Flanders, vol. 220. + +[23] Elgin, from Brussels, Nov. 6. "A brisk cannonade has been heard this +whole forenoon in the direction of Mons. It is at this moment somewhat +diminished, though not at an end" Nov. 7. "Several messengers have arrived +from camp in the course of the night, but all the Ministers (I have seen +them all) deny having received one word of detail.... Couriers have been +sent this night in every direction to call in all the detachments on the +frontiers.... The Government is making every arrangement for quitting +Brussels: their papers are already prepared, their carriages ready." ... +Then a PS. "A cannonade is distinctly heard again.... All the emigrants +now here are removing with the utmost haste." Nov. 9th. "The confusion +throughout the country is extreme. The roads are covered with emigrants, +and persons of these provinces flying from the French armies," Records: +Flanders, vol. 222. + +[24] In Nov. 1792, Grenville ordered the English envoys at Vienna and +Berlin to discover, if possible, the real designs of aggrandisement held by +those Courts. Mr. Straton, at Vienna, got wind of the agreement against +Poland. "I requested Count Philip Cobenzl" (the Austrian Minister) "that he +would have the goodness to open himself confidentially to me on the precise +object which the two allied Courts might have in contemplation. This, +however, the Count was by no means disposed to do; on the contrary, he went +round the compass of evasion in order to avoid a direct answer. But +determined as I was to push the Austrian Minister, I heaped question on +question, until I forced him to say, blushing, and with evident signs of +embarrassment, 'Count Stadion' (Ambassador at London) 'will be able to +satisfy the curiosity of the British Minister, to whatever point it may be +directed.'" Jan. 20, 1793. Records: Austria, vol. 32. Stadion accordingly +informed Lord Grenville of the Polish and Bavarian plans. Grenville +expressed his concern and regret at the aggression on Poland, and gave +reasons against the Bavarian exchange. To our envoy with the King of +Prussia Grenville wrote: "It may possibly be the intention of the Courts to +adopt a plan of indemnifying themselves for the expense of the war by fresh +acquisitions in Poland, and carrying into execution a new partition of that +country. You will not fail to explain in the most distinct and pointed +manner his Majesty's entire disapprobation of such a plan, and his +determination on no account to concur in any measures which may tend to the +completion of a design so unjust in itself." Jan. 4, 1793. Records: Army in +Germany, vol. 437. At Vienna Cobenzl declared, Feb. 9, that Austria could +not now "even manifest a wish to oppose the projects of Prussia in Poland, +as in that case his Prussian Majesty would probably withdraw his assistance +from the French war; nay, perhaps even enter into an alliance with that +nation and invade Bohemia." Records: Austria, vol. 32. + +[25] Auckland, ii. 464. Papers presented to Parliament, 1793. Mr. Oscar +Browning, in _Fortnightly Review_, Feb., 1883. + +[26] Von Sybel, ii. 259. Thugut, Vertrauliche Briefe, i. 17. Letters from +Brussels, 23rd March in Records: Flanders, vol. 222. "The Huzars are in +motion all round, so that we hope to have them here to-morrow. Most of the +French troops who arrived last, and which are mostly peasants armed with +pikes, are returning home, besides a great number of their volunteers." +24th March. "At this moment we hear the cannon. The French have just had it +cry'd in the town that all the tailors who are making coats for the army +must bring them made or unmade, and be paid directly.... They beat the +drums to drown the report of the cannon.... You have not a conception of +the confusion in the town.... This moment passed four Austrians with their +heads cut to pieces, and one with his eye poked out. The French are +retiring by the Porte d'Anderlecht." Ostend, April 4th. "This day, before +two of the clock, twenty-five Austrian huzars enter'd the town while the +inhabitants were employed burning the tree of liberty." + +[27] Mortimer-Ternaux, vii. 412. + +[28] Berriat-St.-Prix, La Justice Revolutionnaire, introd. + +[29] "The King of Prussia has been educated in the persuasion that the +execution of that exchange involves the ruin of his family, and he is the +more sore about it that by the qualified consent which he has given to its +taking place he has precluded himself from opposing it by arms. +Accordingly, every idle story which arrives from Munich which tends to +revive this apprehension makes an impression which I am unable, at the +first moment, to efface." Lord Yarmouth, from the Prussian camp, Aug. 12, +1793, Records: Army in Germany, 437. "Marquis Lucchesini, the effectual +director, is desirous of avoiding every expense and every exertion of the +troops; of leaving the whole burden of the war on Austria and the other +combined Powers; and of seeing difficulties multiply in the arrangements +which the Court of Vienna may wish to form I do not perceive any object +beyond this; no desire of diminishing the power of France; no system or +feeling for crushing the opinions, the doctrines, of that country." Elgin, +May 17. Records: Flanders, vol. 223. + +[30] Auckland, iii. 24. Thugut, Vertrauliche Briefe, i. 13. Grenville to +Eden, Sept. 7th, 1793, Records: Austria, vol. 34: a most important +historical document, setting out the principles of alliance between England +and Austria. Austria, if it will abandon the Bavarian exchange, may claim +annexations on the border of the Netherlands, in Alsace and Lorraine, and +in the intermediate parts of the frontier of France. England's indemnity +"must be looked for in the foreign settlements and colonies of France.... +His Majesty has an interest in seeing the House of Austria strengthen +itself by acquisitions on the French frontier. The Emperor must see with +pleasure the relative increase of the naval and commercial resources of +this country beyond those of France." In the face of this paper, it cannot +be maintained that the war of 1793 was, after the first few months, purely +defensive on England's part; though no doubt Pitt's notion of an indemnity +was fair and modest in comparison with the schemes and acts of his enemy. + +[31] The first mention of Bonaparte's name in any British document +occurs in an account of the army of Toulon sent to London in Dec. 1793 +by a spy. "Les capitaines d'artillerie, eleve dans cet etat, connoissent +leur service et ont tous du talens. Ils preferoient l'employer pour une +meilleure cause.... Le sixterne, nomme Bonaparte, tres republicain, a +ete tue sous les murs de Toulon." Records: France, vol. 599. Austria +undertook to send 5,000 troops from Lombardy to defend Toulon, but broke +its engagement. "You will wait on M. Thugut (the Austrian Minister) and +claim in the most peremptory terms the performance of this engagement. +It would be very offensive to his Majesty that a request made so +repeatedly on his part should be neglected; but it is infinitely more so +to see that, when this country is straining every nerve for the common +cause, a body of troops for the want of which Toulon may possibly at +this moment be lost, have remained inactive at Milan. You will admit of +no further excuses." Grenville to Eden, Nov. 24, 1793. Thugut's written +answer was, "The Emperor gave the order of march at a moment when the +town of Toulon had no garrison. Its preservation then seemed matter of +pressing necessity, but now all inquietude on this score has happily +disappeared. The troops of different nations already assembled at Toulon +put the place out of all danger." Records: Austria, vol. 35. + +[32] Haeusser, i. 482. "La Prusse," wrote Thugut at this time, "parviendra +au moyen de son alliance a nous faire plus de mal qu'elle ne nous a fait +par les guerres les plus sanglantes." Briefe, i. 12, 15. Thugut even +proposed that England should encourage the Poles to resist. Eden, April +15; Records: Austria, vol. 33. + +[33] The English Government found that Thugut was from the first +indifferent to their own aim, the restoration of the Bourbons, or +establishment of some orderly government in France. In so far as he +concerned himself with the internal affairs of France, he hoped rather for +continued dissension, as facilitating the annexation of French territory by +Austria. "Qu'on profite de ce conflit des partis en France pour tacher de +se rendre maitre des forteresses, afin de faire la loi au parti qui aura +prevalu, et l'obliger d'acheter la paix et la protection de l'empereur, en +lui cedant telle partie de ses conquetes que S.M. jugera de sa covenance." +Briefe, i. 13. + +[34] The despatches of Lord Yarmouth from the Prussian and Austrian +headquarters, from July 17 to Nov. 22, 1793, give a lively picture both of +the military operations and of the political intrigues of this period. They +are accompanied by the MS. journal of the Austrian army from Sept. 15 to +Dec. 14, each copy apparently with Wurmser's autograph, and by the original +letter of the Prussian Minister, Lucchesini, to Lord Yarmouth, announcing +the withdrawal of Prussia from the war, "M. de Lucchesini read it to me +very hastily, and seemed almost ashamed of a part of its contents." +Records: Army in Germany, vols. 437, 438, 439. + +[35] Hardenberg (Ranke), i. 181, Vivenot, Herzog Albrecht, i. 10. + +[36] Elgin reports after this engagement, May 1st, 1794--"The French army +appears to continue much what it has hitherto been, vigorous and +persevering where (as in villages and woods) the local advantages are of a +nature to supply the defects of military science; weak and helpless beyond +belief where cavalry can act, and manoeuvres are possible.... The magazines +of the army are stored, and the provisions regularly given out to the +troops, and good in quality. Indeed, it is singular to observe in all the +villages where we have been forward forage, etc., in plenty, and all the +country cultivated as usual. The inhabitants, however, have retired with +the French army; and to that degree that the tract we have lately taken +possession of is absolutely deserted.... The execution of Danton has +produced no greater effect in the army than other executions, and we have +found many papers on those who fell in the late actions treating it with +ridicule, and as a source of joy." Records: Flanders, 226. "I am in hopes +to hear from you on the subject of the French prisoners, as to where I am +to apply for the money I advance for their subsistence. They are a great +number of them almost naked, some entirely so. It is absolutely shocking to +humanity to see them. I would purchase some coarse clothing for those that +are in the worst state, but know not how far I should be authorised. They +are mostly old men and boys." Consul Harward, at Ostend, March 4th, +_id_. + +[37] These events are the subject of controversy. See Hueffer, Oestreich und +Preussen, p. 62 Von Sybel, iii. 138. Vivenot, Clerfayt, p. 38. The old +belief, defended by Von Sybel, was that Thugut himself had determined upon +the evacuation of Belgium, and treacherously deprived Coburg of forces for +its defence. But, apart from other evidence, the tone of exasperation that +runs through Thugut's private letters is irreconcilable with this theory. +Lord Elgin, whose reports are used by Von Sybel, no doubt believed that +Thugut was playing false; but he was a bad judge, being in the hands of +Thugut's opponents, especially General Mack, whom he glorifies in the most +absurd way. The other English envoy in Belgium, Lord Yarmouth, reported in +favour of Thugut's good faith in this matter, and against military +intriguers. Records: Army in Germany, vol. 440. A letter of Prince +Waldeck's in Thugut, i. 387, and a conversation between Mack and Sir Morton +Eden, on Feb. 3rd, 1797, reported by the latter in Records: Austria, vol. +48, appear to fix the responsibility for the evacuation of Belgium on these +two generals, Waldeck and Mack, and on the Emperor's confidential military +adviser, Rollin. + +[38] "Should the French come they will find this town perfectly empty. +Except my own, I do not think there are three houses in Ostend with a bed +in them. So general a panic I never witnessed." June 30th.--"To remain here +alone would be a wanton sacrifice. God knows 'tis an awful stroke to me to +leave a place just as I began to be comfortably settled." Consul Harward: +Records: Army in Germany, vol. 440. "All the English are arrested in +Ostend; the men are confined in the Capuchin convent, and the women in the +Convent des Soeurs Blancs. All the Flamands from the age of 17 to 32 are +forced to go for soldiers. At Bruges the French issued an order for 800 men +to present themselves. Thirty only came, in consequence of which they rang +a bell on the Grand Place, and the inhabitants thinking that it was some +ordinance, quitted their houses to hear it, when they were surrounded by +the French soldiers, and upwards of 1,000 men secured, gentle and simple, +who were all immediately set to work on the canals." Mr. W. Poppleton, +Flushing, Sept. 4. Records: Flanders, vol. 227. + +[39] Malmesbury, ii. 125. Von Sybel, iii. 168. Grenville made Coburg's +dismissal a _sine qua non_ of the continuance of English co-operation. +Instructions to Lord Spencer, July 19, 1794. Records: Austria, 36. But for +the Austrian complaints against the English, see Vivenot, Clerfayt, p. 50. + +[40] Schlosser, xv. 203: borne out by the Narrative of an Officer, printed +in Annual Register, 1795, p. 143. + +[41] Vivenot, Herzog Albrecht, iii. 59, 512. Martens, Recueil des Traites, +vi. 45, 52. Hardenberg, i. 287. Vivenot, Clerfayt, p. 32. "Le Roi de +Prusse," wrote the Empress Catherine, "est une mechante bete et un grand +cochon." Prussia made no attempt to deliver the unhappy son of Louis XVI. +from his captivity. + +[42] The British Government had formed the most sanguine estimate of the +strength of the Royalist movement in France. "I cannot let your servant +return without troubling you with these few lines to conjure you to use +every possible effort to give life and vigour to the Austrian Government at +this critical moment. Strongly as I have spoken in my despatch of the +present state of France, I have said much less than my information, drawn +from various quarters, and applying to almost every part of France, would +fairly warrant. We can never hope that the circumstances, as far as they +regard the state of France, can be more favourable than they now are. For +God's sake enforce these points with all the earnestness which I am sure +you will feel upon them." Grenville to Eden, April 17, 1795; Records: +Austria, vol. 41. After the failure of the expedition, the British +Government made the grave charge against Thugut that while he was +officially sending Clerfayt pressing orders to advance, he secretly told +him to do nothing. "It is in vain to reason with the Austrian Ministers on +the folly and ill faith of a system which they have been under the +necessity of concealing from you, and which they will probably endeavour to +disguise" Grenville to Eden, Oct., 1795; _id_., vol. 43. This charge, +repeated by historians, is disproved by Thugut's private letters. Briefe, +i. 221, _seq_. No one more bitterly resented Clerfayt's inaction. + +[43] The documents relating to the expedition to Quiberon, with several +letters of D'Artois, Charette, and the Vendean leaders, are in Records: +France, vol. 600. + +[44] Von Sybel, iii. 537. Buchez et Roux, xxxvi. 485. + +[45] For the police interpretation of the _Zauberfloete_, see Springer, +Geschichte Oesterreichs, vol. i. p. 49. + +[46] Zobi, Storia Civile della Toscana, i. 284. + +[47] Galanti, Descrizione delle Sicilie, 1786, i. 279. He adds, "The +Samnites and the Lucanians could not have shown so horrible a spectacle, +because they had no feudal laws." Galanti's book gives perhaps the best +idea of the immense task faced by monarchy in the eighteenth century in +its struggle against what he justly calls "gli orrori del governo +feudale." Nothing but a study of these details of actual life described by +eye-witnesses can convey an adequate impression of the completeness and the +misery of the feudal order in the more backward countries of Europe till +far down in the eighteenth century. There is a good anonymous account of +Sicily in 1810 in Castlereagh, 8, 317. + +[48] Correspondance de Napoleon, i. 260. Botta, lib. vi. Despatches of Col. +Graham, British attache with the Austrian army, in Records: Italian States, +vol. 57. These most interesting letters, which begin on May 19, show the +discord and suspicion prevalent from the first in the Austrian army. +"Beaulieu has not met with cordial co-operation from his own generals, +still less from the Piedmontese. He accuses them of having chosen to be +beat in order to bring about a peace promised in January last." "Beaulieu +was more violent than ever against his generals who have occasioned the +failure of his plans. He said nine of them were cowards. I believe some of +them are ill-affected to the cause." June 15.--"Many of the officers +comfort themselves with thinking that defeat must force peace, and others +express themselves in terms of despair." July 25,--Beaulieu told Graham +that if Bonaparte had pushed on after the battle of Lodi, he might have +gone straight into Mantua. The preparations for defence were made later. + +[49] Thugut, Briefe i. 107. A correspondence on this subject was carried on +in cypher between Thugut and Ludwig Cobenzl, Austrian Ambassador at St. +Petersburg in 1793-4. During Thugut's absence in Belgium, June, 1794, +Cobenzl sent a duplicate despatch, not in cypher, to Vienna. Old Prince +Kaunitz, the ex-minister, heard that a courier had arrived from St +Petersburg, and demanded the despatch at the Foreign Office "like a +dictator." It was given to him. "Ainsi," says Thugut, "adieu au secret qui +depuis un an a ete conserve avec tant de soins!" + +[50] Wurmser's reports are in Vivenot, Clerfayt, p. 477. Graham's daily +despatches from the Austrian head-quarters give a vivid picture of these +operations, and of the sudden change from exultation to despair. Aug. +1.--"I have the honour to inform your lordship that the siege of Mantua is +raised, the French having retreated last night with the utmost +precipitation." Aug. 2.--"The Austrians are in possession of all the French +mortars and cannon, amounting to about 140, with 190,000 shells and bombs; +the loss of the Imperial army is inconsiderable." Aug. 5.--"The rout of +this day has sadly changed the state of affairs. There are no accounts of +General Quosdanovich." Aug. 9.--"Our loss in men and cannon was much +greater than was imagined. I had no idea of the possibility of the extent +of such misfortunes as have overwhelmed us" Aug. 17.--"It is scarcely +possible to describe the state of disorder and discouragement that prevails +in the army. Were I free from apprehension, about the fate of my letter" +(he had lost his baggage and his cypher in it), "I should despair of +finding language adequate to convey a just idea of the discontent of the +officers with General Wurmser. From generals to subalterns the universal +language is 'qu'il faut faire la paix, car nous ne savons pas faire la +guerre.'" Aug. 18.--"Not only the commander-in-chief, but the greatest +number of the generals are objects of contempt and ridicule." Aug. 27.--"I +do not exaggerate when I say that I have met with instances of down-right +dotage." "It was in general orders that wine should be distributed to the +men previous to the attack of the 29th. There was some difficulty in +getting it up to Monte Baldo. General Bayolitzy observed that 'it did not +signify, for the men might get the value in money afterwards.' The men +marched at six in the evening without it, to attack at daybreak, and +received four kreutzers afterwards. This is a fact I can attest. In action +I saw officers sent on urgent messages going at a foot's pace: they say +that their horses are half starved, and that they cannot afford to kill +them." + +[51] Grundsaetze (Archduke Charles), ii. 202. Bulletins in Wiener Zeitung, +June-Oct., 1796. + +[52] Martens, vi. 59. + +[53] This seems to me to be the probable truth about Austria's policy in +1796, of which opposite views will be found in Haeusser, vol. ii. ch. 1-3, +and in Hueffer, Oestreich und Preussen, p. 142. Thugut professed in 1793 to +have given up the project of the Bavarian exchange in deference to England. +He admitted, however, soon afterwards, that he had again been pressing the +King of Prussia to consent to it, but said that this was a ruse, intended +to make Prussia consent to Austria's annexing a large piece of France +instead. Eden, Sept., 1793; Records: Austria, vol. 34. The incident shows +the difficulty of getting at the truth in diplomacy. + +[54] Yet the Government had had warning of this in a series of striking +reports sent by one of Lord Elgin's spies during the Reign of Terror. +"Jamais la France ne fut cultivee comme elle l'est. Il n'y a pas un arpent +qui ne soit ensemence, sauf dans les lieux ou operent les armees +belligerantes. Cette culture universelle a ete forcee par les Directrices la +ou on ne la faisait pas volontairement." June 8, 1794; Records: Flanders, +vol. 226. Elgin had established a line of spies from Paris to the Belgian +frontier. Every one of these persons was arrested by the Revolutionary +authorities. Elgin then fell in with the writer of the above, whose name is +concealed, and placed him on the Swiss frontier. He was evidently a person +thoroughly familiar with both civil and military administration. He appears +to have talked to every Frenchman who entered Switzerland; and his reports +contain far the best information that readied England during the Reign of +Terror, contradicting the Royalists, who said that the war was only kept up +by terrorism. He warned the English Government that the French nation in a +mass was on the side of the Revolution, and declared that the downfall of +Robespierre and the terrorists would make no difference in the prosecution +of the war. The Government seems to have paid no attention to his reports, +if indeed they were ever read. + +[55] Correspondance de Napoleon, ii. 28. Thugut, about this time, formed +the plan of annexing Bologna and Ferrara to Austria, and said that if this +result could be achieved, the French attack upon the Papal States would be +no bad matter. See the instructions to Allvintzy, in Vivenot, Clerfayt, p. +511, which also contain the first Austrian orders to imprison Italian +innovators, the beginning of Austria's later Italian policy. + +[56] Wurmser had orders to break out southwards into the Papal States. +"These orders he (Thugut) knew had reached the Marshal, but they were also +known to the enemy, as a cadet of Strasoldo's regiment, who was carrying +the duplicate, had been taken prisoner, and having been seen to swallow a +ball of wax, in which the order was wrapped up, he was immediately put to +death and the paper taken out of his stomach." Eden, Jan., 1797; Records: +Austria, vol. 48. Colonel Graham, who had been shut up in Mantua since +Sept. 10, escaped on Dec 17, and restored communication between Wurmser and +Allvintzy. He was present at the battle of Rivoli, which is described in +his despatches. + +[57] "We expect every hour to hear of the entry of the Neapolitan troops +and the declaration of a religious war. Every preparation has been made for +such an event." Graves to Lord Grenville, Oct. 1, 1796; Records; Rome, vol. +56. + +[58] "The clamours for peace have become loud and importunate. His Imperial +Majesty is constantly assailed by all his Ministers, M. de Thugut alone +excepted, and by all who approach his person. Attempts are even made to +alarm him with a dread of insurrection. In the midst of these calamities M. +de Thugut retains his firmness of mind, and continues to struggle against +the united voice of the nobility and the numerous and trying adversities +that press upon him." Eden, April 1. "The confusion at the army exceeds the +bounds of belief. Had Bonaparte continued his progress hither (Vienna), no +doubt is entertained that he might have entered the place without +opposition. That, instead of risking this enterprise, he should have +stopped and given the Austrians six days to recover from their alarm and to +prepare for defence, is a circumstance which it is impossible to account +for." April 12. "He" (Mack) "said that when this place was threatened by +the enemy, Her Imperial Majesty broke in upon the Emperor while in +conference with his Minister, and, throwing herself and her children at his +feet, determined His Majesty to open the negotiation which terminated in +the shameful desertion of his ally." Aug. 16; Records: Austria, vols. 49, +50. Thugut subsequently told Lord Minto that if he could have laid his hand +upon L500,000 in cash to stop the run on the Bank of Vienna, the war would +have been continued, in which case he believed he would have surrounded +Bonaparte's army. + +[59] The cession of the Rhenish Provinces was not, as usually stated, +contained in the Preliminaries. Corr. de Napoleon, 2, 497; Hueffer, p. 259, +where the details of the subsequent negotiations will be found. + +[60] Gohier, Memoires i. Carnot, Reponse a Bailleul. Correspondance de +Napoleon, ii. 188. Miot de Melito, ch. vi. + +[61] Martens, Traites, vi. 420; Thugut, Briefe, ii. 64. These letters +breathe a fire and passion rare among German statesmen of that day, and +show the fine side of Thugut's character. The well-known story of the +destruction of Cobenzl's vase by Bonaparte at the last sitting, with the +words, "Thus will I dash the Austrian Monarchy to pieces," is mythical. +Cobenzl's own account of the scene is as follows;--"Bonaparte, excited by +not having slept for two nights, emptied glass after glass of punch. When I +explained with the greatest composure, Bonaparte started up in a violent +rage, and poured out a flood of abuse, at the same time scratching his name +illegibly at the foot of the statement which he had handed in as protocol. +Then without waiting for our signatures, he put on his hat in the +conference-room itself, and left us. Until he was in the street he +continued to vociferate in a manner that could only be ascribed to +intoxication, though Clarke and the rest of his suite, who were waiting in +the hall, did their best to restrain him." "He behaved as if he had escaped +from a lunatic asylum. His own people are all agreed about this." Hueffer, +Oestreich und Preussen, p. 453. + +[62] Haeusser, Deutsche Geschichte, ii. 147. Vivenot, Rastadter Congress, p. +17. Von Lang, Memoiren, i. 33. It is alleged that the official who drew up +this document had not been made acquainted with the secret clauses. + +[63] "Tout annonce qu'il sera de toute impossibilite de finir avec ces +gueux de Francais autrement que par moyens de fermete." Thugut, ii. 105. +For the negotiation at Seltz, see Historische Zeitschrift, xxiii. 27. + +[64] Botta, lib. xiii. Letters of Mr. J. Denham and others in Records: +Sicily, vol. 44. + +[65] Nelson Despatches, iii. 48. + +[66] Bernhardi, Geschichte Russlands, ii. 2, 382. + +[67] "Quel bonheur, quelle gloire, quelle consolation pour cette grande et +illustre nation! Que je vous suis obligee, reconnaissante! J'ai pleure et +embrasse mes enfans, mon mari. Si jamais on fait un portrait du brave +Nelson je le veux avoir dans ma chambre. Hip, Hip, Hip, Ma chere Miladi je +suis folle de joye." Queen of Naples to Lady Hamilton, Sept. 4, 1798; +Records: Sicily, vol. 44. The news of the overwhelming victory of the Nile +seems literally to have driven people out of their senses at Naples. "Lady +Hamilton fell apparently dead, and is not yet (Sept 25) perfectly recovered +from her severe bruises." Nelson Despatches, 3, 130. On Nelson's arrival, +"up flew her ladyship, and exclaiming, 'O God, is it possible?' she fell +into my arms more dead than alive." It has been urged in extenuation of +Nelson's subsequent cruelties that the contagion of this frenzy, following +the effects of a severe wound in the head, had deprived his mind of its +balance. "My head is ready to split, and I am always so sick." Aug. 10. "It +required all the kindness of my friends to set me up." Sept. 25. + +[68] Sir W. Hamilton's despatch, Nov. 28, in Records: Sicily, vol. 44, +where there are originals of most of the Neapolitan proclamations, etc., of +this time. Mack had been a famous character since the campaign of 1793. +Elgin's letters to Lord Grenville from the Netherlands, private as well as +public, are full of extravagant praise of him. In July, 1796, Graham writes +from the Italian army: "In the opinion of all here, the greatest general in +Europe is the Quartermaster Mack, who was in England in 1793. Would to God +he was marching, and here now." Mack, on the other hand, did not grudge +flattery to the English:--"Je perdrais partout espoir et patience si je +n'avais pas vu pour mon bonheur et ma consolation l'adorable Triumvirat" +(Pitt, Grenville, Dundas) "qui surveille a Londres nos affaires. Soyez, mon +cher ami, l'organe de ma profonde veneration envers ces Ministres +incomparables." Mack to Elgin, 23. Feb., 1794. The British Government was +constantly pressing Thugut to make Mack commander-in chief. Thugut, who had +formed a shrewd notion of Mack's real quality, gained much obloquy by his +steady refusal. + +[69] Signed by Mack. Colletta, p. 176. Mack's own account of the campaign +is in Vivenot, Rastadter Congress, p. 83. + +[70] Nelson, iii. 210: Hamilton's despatch, Dec. 28, 1798, in Records; +Sicily, vol. 44. "It was impossible to prevent a suspicion getting abroad +of the intention of the Royal Family to make their escape. However, the +secret was so well kept that we contrived to get their Majesties' treasure +in jewels and money, to a very considerable extent, on board of H.M. ship +the _Vanguard_ the 20th of December, and Lord Nelson went on the next +night by a secret passage into the Palace, and brought off in his boats +their Sicilian Majesties and all the Royal Family. It was not discovered at +Naples, until very late at night, that the Royal Family had escaped.... On +the morning of Christmas Day, some hours before we got into Palermo, Prince +Albert, one of their Majesties' sons, six years of age, was, either from +fright or fatigue, taken with violent convulsions, and died in the arms of +Lady Hamilton, the Queen, the Princesses, and women attendants being in +such confusion as to be incapable of affording any assistance." + +[71] See Helfert, Der Rastatter Gesandtenmord, and Sybel's article thereon, +in Hist. Zeitschrift, vol. 32. + +[72] Danilevsky-Miliutin, ii. 214. Despatch of Lord W. Bentinck from the +allied head-quarters at Piacenza, June 23, in Records: Italian States, vol. +58. Bentinck arrived a few days before this battle; his despatches cover +the whole North-Italian campaign from this time. + +[73] Nelson Despatches, iii. 447; Sir W. Hamilton's Despatch of July 14, in +Records: Sicily, vol. 45. Helfert, Koenigin Karolina, p. 38. Details of the +proscription in Colletta, v. 6. According to Hamilton, some of the +Republicans in the forts had actually gone to their homes before Nelson +pronounced the capitulation void. "When we anchored in the Bay, the 24th of +June, the capitulation of the castles had in some measure taken place. +Fourteen large polacks had taken on board out of the castles the most +conspicuous and criminal of the Neapolitan rebels that had chosen to go to +Toulon; the others had already been permitted to return to their homes." If +this is so, Nelson's pretext that the capitulation had not been executed +was a mere afterthought. Helfert is mistaken in calling the letter or +proclamation of July 8th repudiating the treaty, a forgery. It is perfectly +genuine. It was published by Nelson in the King's name, and is enclosed in +Hamilton's despatch. Hamilton's exultations about himself and his wife, and +their share in these events, are sorry reading. "In short, Lord Nelson and +I, with Emma, have carried affairs to this happy crisis. Emma is really the +Queen's bosom friend.... You may imagine, when we three agree, what real +business is done.... At least I shall end my diplomatical career +gloriously, as you will see by what the King of Naples writes from this +ship to his Minister in London, owing the recovery of his kingdom to the +King's fleet, and Lord Nelson and me." (Aug. 4, _id_.) Hamilton states the +number of persons in prison at Naples on Sept. 12 to be above eight +thousand. + +[74] Castlereagh, iv.; Records: Austria, 56. Lord Minto had just succeeded +Sir Morton Eden as ambassador. The English Government was willing to grant +the House of Hapsburg almost anything for the sake "of strengthening that +barrier which the military means and resources of Vienna can alone oppose +against the future enterprises of France." Grenville to Minto, May 13, +1800. Though they felt some regard for the rights of the King of Piedmont, +Pitt and Grenville were just as ready to hand over the Republic of Genoa to +the Hapsburgs as Bonaparte had been to hand over Venice; in fact, they +looked forward to the destruction of the Genoese State with avowed +pleasure, because it easily fell under the influence of France. Their +principal anxiety was that if Austria "should retain Venice and Genoa and +possibly acquire Leghorn," it should grant England an advantageous +commercial treaty. Grenville to Minto, Feb. 8, 1800; Castlereagh, v. 3-11. + +[75] Lord Mulgrave to Grenville, Sept. 12, 1799; Records: Army of +Switzerland, vol. 80. "Suvaroff opened himself to me in the most unreserved +manner. He began by stating that he had been called at a very advanced +period of life from his retirement, where his ample fortune and honours +placed him beyond the allurement of any motives of interest. Attachment to +his sovereign and zeal for his God inspired him with the hope and the +expectation of conquests. He now found himself under very different +circumstances. He found himself surrounded by the parasites or spies of +Thugut, men at his devotion, creatures of his power: an army bigoted to a +defensive system, afraid even to pursue their successes when that system +had permitted them to obtain any; he had to encounter the further check of +a Government at Vienna averse to enterprise, etc." + +[76] Miliutin, 2, 20, 3, 186; Minto, Aug. 10, 1799; Records: Austria, vol. +56. "I had no sooner mentioned this topic (Piedmont) than I perceived I had +touched a very delicate point. M. de Thugut's manner changed instantly from +that of coolness and civility to a great show of warmth attended with some +sharpness. He became immediately loud and animated, and expressed chagrin +at the invitation sent to the King of Sardinia.... He considers the +conquest of Piedmont as one made by Austria of an enemy's country. He +denies that the King of Sardinia can be considered as an ally or as a +friend, or even as a neuter; and, besides imputing a thousand instances of +ill-faith to that Court, relies on the actual alliance made by it with the +French Republic by which the King of Sardinia had appropriated to himself +part of the Emperor's dominions in Lombardy, an offence which, I perceive, +will not be easily forgotten.... I mention these circumstances to show the +degree of passion which the Court of Vienna mixes with this discussion." +Minto answered Thugut's invective with the odd remark "that perhaps in the +present extraordinary period the most rational object of this war was to +restore the integrity of the moral principle both in civil and political +life, and that this principle of justice should take the lead in his mind +of those considerations of temporary convenience which in ordinary times +might not have escaped his notice." Thugut then said "that the Emperor of +Russia had desisted from his measure of the King of Sardinia's immediate +recall, leaving the time of that return to the Emperor." On the margin of +the despatch, against this sentence, is written in pencil, in Lord +Grenville's handwriting, "I am persuaded this is not true." + +[77] Miliutin, 3, 117. And so almost verbatim in a conversation described +in Eden's despatch, Aug. 31 Records: Austria, vol. 55. "M. de Thugut's +answer was evidently dictated by a suspicion rankling in his mind that the +Netherlands might be made a means of aggrandisement for Prussia. His +jealousy and aversion to that Power are at this moment more inveterate than +I have before seen them. It is probable that he may have some idea of +establishing there the Great Duke of Tuscany." + +[78] Thugut's territorial policy did actually make him propose to abolish +the Papacy not only as a temporal Power, but as a religious institution. +"Baron Thugut argued strongly on the possibility of doing without a Pope, +and of each sovereign taking on himself the function of head of the +National Church, as in England. I said that as a Protestant, I could not be +supposed to think the authority of the Bishop of Rome necessary; but that +in the present state of religious opinion, and considering the only +alternative in those matters, viz. the subsistence of the Roman Catholic +faith or the extinction of Christianity itself, I preferred, though a +Protestant, the Pope to the Goddess of Reason. However, the mind of Baron +Thugut is not open to any reasoning of a general nature when it is put in +competition with conquest or acquisition of territory." Minto to Grenville, +Oct. 22, 1799; Records: Austria, vol. 57. The suspicions of Austria current +at the Neapolitan Court are curiously shown in the Nelson Correspondence. +Nelson writes to Minto (Aug. 20) at Vienna: "For the sake of the civilised +world, let us work together, and as the best act of our lives manage to +hang Thugut ... As you are with Thugut, your penetrating mind will discover +the villain in all his actions.... That Thugut is caballing.... Pray keep +an eye upon the rascal, and you will soon find what I say is true. Let us +hang these three miscreants, and all will go smooth." Suvaroff was not more +complimentary. "How can that desk-worm, that night-owl, direct an army from +his dusky nest, even if he had the sword of Scanderbeg?" (Sept. 3.) + +[79] Miliutin, iii. 37; Bentinck, Aug. 16, from the battle-field; Records: +Italian States, vol. 58. His letter ends "I must apologise to your Lordship +for the appearance of this despatch" (it is on thin Italian paper and +almost illegible): "we" (_i.e._, Suvaroff's staff) "have had the misfortune +to have had our baggage plundered by the Cossacks." + +[80] Every capable soldier saw the ruinous mischief of the Archduke's +withdrawal. "Not only are all prospects of our making any progress in +Switzerland at an end, but the chance of maintaining the position now +occupied is extremely precarious. The jealousy and mistrust that exists +between the Austrians and Russians is inconceivable. I shall not pretend to +offer an opinion on what might be the most advantageous arrangement for the +army of Switzerland, but it is certain that none can be so bad as that +which at present exists." Colonel Crauford, English military envoy, Sept. +5, 1799; Records: Army of Switzerland, vol. 79. The subsequent Operations +of Korsakoff are described in despatches of Colonel Ramsay and Lord +Mulgrave, _id_. vol. 80, 81, Conversations with the Archduke Charles +in those of Mr. Wickham, _id_. vol. 77. + +[81] The despatches of Colonel Clinton, English attache with Suvaroff, are +in singular contrast to the highly-coloured accounts of this retreat common +in histories. Of the most critical part he only says: "On the 6th the army +passed the Panix mountain, which the snow that had fallen during the last +week had rendered dangerous, and several horses and mules were lost on the +march." He expresses the poorest opinion of Suvaroff and his officers: "The +Marshal is entirely worn out and incapable of any exertion: he will not +suffer the subject of the indiscipline of his army to be mentioned to him. +He is popular with his army because he puts no check whatever in its +licentiousness. His honesty is now his only remaining good quality." +Records: Army of Switzerland, vol. 80. The elaborate plan for Suvaroff's +and Korsakoff's combined movements, made as if Switzerland had been an open +country and Massena's army a flock of sheep, was constructed by the +Austrian colonel Weyrother, the same person who subsequently planned the +battle of Austerlitz. On learning the plan from Suvaroff, Lord Mulgrave, +who was no great genius, wrote to London demonstrating its certain failure, +and predicting almost exactly the events that took place. + +[82] Miot de Melito, ch. ix. Lucien Bonaparte, Revolution de Brumaire, p. +31. + +[83] Law of Feb. 17, 1800 (28 Pluvioese, viii.). + +[84] M. Thiers, Feb. 21, 1872. + +[85] Parl. Hist, xxxiv. 1198. Thugut, Briefe ii. 445. + +[86] Memorial du Depot de la Guerre, 1826, iv. 268. Bentinck's despatch, +June 16; Records: Italian States, vol. 59. + +[87] Thugut, Briefe ii. 227, 281, 393; Minto's despatch, Sept. 24, 1800; +Records: Austria, vol. 60. "The Emperor was in the act of receiving a +considerable subsidy for a vigorous prosecution of the war at the very +moment when he was clandestinely and in person making the most abject +submission to the common enemy. Baron Thugut was all yesterday under the +greatest uneasiness concerning the event which he had reason to apprehend, +but which was not yet certain. He still retained, however, a slight hope, +from the apparent impossibility of anyone's committing such an act of +infamy and folly. I never saw him or any other man so affected as he was +when he communicated this transaction to me to-day. I said that these +fortresses being demanded as pledges of sincerity, the Emperor should have +given on the same principle the arms and ammunition of the army. Baron +Thugut added that after giving up the soldiers' muskets, the clothes would +be required off their backs, and that if the Emperor took pains to acquaint +the world that he would not defend his crown, there would not be wanting +those who would take it from his head, and perhaps his head with it. He +became so strongly affected that, in laying hold of my hand to express the +strong concern he felt at the notion of having committed me and abused the +confidence I had reposed in his counsels, he burst into tears and literally +wept. I mention these details because they confirm the assurance that every +part of these feeble measures has either been adopted against his opinion +or executed surreptitiously and contrary to the directions he had given." +After the final collapse of Austria, Minto writes of Thugut: "He never for +a moment lost his presence of mind or his courage, nor ever bent to weak +and unbecoming counsels. And perhaps this can be said of him alone in this +whole empire." Jan. 3, 1801, _id._ + +[88] Martens, vii. 296. + +[89] Koch und Schoell, Histoire des Traites, vi. 6. Nelson Despatches, iv. +299. + +[90] De Clercq, Traites de la France i. 484. + +[91] Parl. Hist., Nov. 3, 1801. + +[92] Gagern, Mein Antheil, i. 119. He protests that he never carried the +dog. The waltz was introduced about this time at Paris by Frenchmen +returning from Germany, which gave occasion to the _mot_ that the +French had annexed even the national dance of the Germans. + +[93] Perthes, Politische Zustaende, i. 311. + +[94] Koch und Schoell, vi. 247. Beer, Zehn Jahre Oesterreichischer Politik, +p. 35 Haeusser, ii. 398. + +[95] Perthes, Politische Zustaende, ii. 402, _seq_. + +[96] Friedrich, Geschichte des Vatikanischen Konzils, i. 27, 174. + +[97] Pertz, Leben Stein, i. 257. Seeley's Stein, i. 125. + +[98] The first hand account of the formation of the Code Napoleon, with +the Proces Verbal of the Council of State and the principal reports, +speeches, etc., made in the Tribunate and the Legislative Bodies, is to +be found in the work of Baron Locre, "La Legislation de la France," +published at Paris in 1827. Locre was Secretary of the Council of State +under the Consulate and the Empire, and possessed a quantity of records +which had not been published before 1827. The Proces Verbal, though +perhaps not always faithful, contains the only record of Napoleon's own +share in the discussions of the Council of State. + +[99] The statement, so often repeated, that the Convention prohibited +Christian worship, or "abolished Christianity," in France, is a fiction. +Throughout the Reign of Terror the Convention maintained the State Church +as established by the Constituent Assembly in 1791. Though the salaries of +the clergy fell into arrear, the Convention rejected a proposal to cease +paying them. The non-juring priests were condemned by the Convention to +transportation, and were liable to be put to death if they returned to +France. But where churches were profaned, or constitutional priests +molested, it was the work of local bodies or of individual Conventionalists +on mission, not of the law. The Commune of Paris shut up most, but not all, +of the churches in Paris. Other local bodies did the same. After the Reign +of Terror ended, the Convention adopted the proposal which it had rejected +before, and abolished the State salary of the clergy (Sept. 20th, 1794). +This merely placed all sects on a level. But local fanatics were still busy +against religion; and the Convention accordingly had to pass a law (Feb. +23, 1795), forbidding all interference with Christian services. This law +required that worship should not be held in a distinctive building (_i.e._ +church), nor in the open air. Very soon afterwards the Convention (May 23) +permitted the churches to be used for worship. The laws against non-juring +priests were not now enforced, and a number of churches in Paris were +actually given up to non-juring priests. The Directory was inclined to +renew the persecution of this class in 1796, but the Assemblies would not +permit it; and in July, 1797, the Council of Five Hundred passed a motion +totally abolishing the legal penalties of non-jurors. This was immediately +followed by the coup d'etat of Fructidor. + +[100] Gregoire, Memoires, ii. 87. Annales de la Religion, x. 441; +Pressense, L'Eglise et la Revolution, p. 359. + +[101] Papers presented to Parliament, 1802-3, p. 95. + +[102] "The King and his Ministers are in the greatest distress and +embarrassment. The latter do not hesitate to avow it, and the King has for +the last week shown such evident symptoms of dejection that the least +observant could not but remark it. He has expressed himself most feelingly +upon the unfortunate predicament in which he finds himself. He would +welcome the hand that should assist him and the voice that should give him +courage to extricate himself."--F. Jackson's despatch from Berlin, May 16, +1803; Records; Prussia, vol. 189. + +[103] Haeusser ii. 472. There are interesting accounts of Lombard and the +other leading persons of Berlin in F. Jackson's despatches of this date. +The charge of gross personal immorality made against Lombard is brought +against almost every German public man of the time in the writings of +opponents. History and politics are, however, a bad tribunal of private +character. + +[104] Fournier, Gentz und Cobenzl, p. 79. Beer, Zehn Jahre, p. 49. The +despatches of Sir J. Warren of this date from St. Petersburg (Records: +Russia, vol. 175) are full of plans for meeting an expected invasion of the +Morea and the possible liberation of the Greeks by Bonaparte. They give the +impression that Eastern affairs were really the dominant interest with +Alexander in his breach with France. + +[105] Miot de Melito, i. 16. Savary, ii. 32. + +[106] A protest handed in at Vienna by Louis XVIII. against Napoleon's +title was burnt in the presence of the French ambassador. The Austrian +title was assumed on August 10, but the publication was delayed a day on +account of the sad memories of August 10, 1792. Fournier, p. 102. Beer, p. +60. + +[107] Papers presented to Parliament, 28th January, 1806, and 5th May, +1815. + +[108] Hardenberg, ii. 50: corrected in the articles on Hardenberg and +Haugwitz in the Deutsche Allgemeine Biographie. + +[109] Hardenberg, v. 167. Hardenberg was meanwhile representing himself to +the British and Russian envoys as the partisan of the Allies. "He declared +that he saw it was become impossible for this country to remain neutral, +and that he should unequivocally make known his sentiments to that effect +to the King. He added that if the decision depended upon himself, Russia +need entertain no apprehension as to the part he should take."--Jackson, +Sept. 3, 1805; Records: Prussia, vol. 194. + +[110] Gentz, Schriften, iii. 60, Beer, 132, 141. Fournier, 104. Springer, +i. 64. + +[111] Rustow, Krieg von 1805, p. 55. + +[112] Nelson Despatches, vi. 457. + +[113] "The reports from General Mack are of the most satisfactory nature, +and the apprehensions which were at one time entertained from the immense +force which Bonaparte is bringing into Germany gradually decrease."--Sir A. +Paget's Despatch from Vienna, Sept, 18; Records: Austria, vol. 75. + +[114] Rustow, p. 154. Schoenhals, Krieg von 1805, p. 33. Paget's despatch, +Oct. 25; Records: Austria, vol. 75. "The jealousy and misunderstanding +among the generals had reached such a pitch that no communication took +place between Ferdinand and Mack but in writing. Mack openly attributed his +calamities to the ill-will and opposition of the Archduke and the rest of +the generals. The Archduke accuses Mack of ignorance, of madness, of +cowardice, and of treachery. The consternation which prevails here (Vienna) +is at the highest pitch. The pains which are taken to keep the public in +the dark naturally increase the alarm. Not a single newspaper has been +delivered for several days past except the wretched _Vienna. Gazette_. +The Emperor is living at a miserable country-house, in order, as people +say, that he may effect his escape. Every bark on the Danube has been put +in requisition by the Government. The greatest apprehensions prevail on +account of the Russians, of whose excesses loud complaints are made. Their +arrival here is as much dreaded as that of the French. Cobenzl and +Collenbach are in such a state of mind as to render them totally unfit for +all business." Cobenzl was nevertheless still able to keep up his jocular +style in asking the ambassador for the English subsidies:--"Vous etes +malade, je le suis aussi un peu, mais ce qui est encore plus malade que +nous deux ce sont nos finances; ainsi pour l'amour de Dieu depechez vous de +nous donner vos deux cent mille livres sterlings. Je vous embrasse de tout +mon coeur,"--Cobenzl to Paget, enclosed in _id_. + +[115] Hardenberg, ii. 268. Jackson, Oct. 7. Records: Prussia, vol. 195. +"The intelligence was received yesterday at Potsdam, while M. de Hardenberg +was with the King of Prussia. His Prussian Majesty was very violently +affected by it, and in the first moment of anger ordered M. de Hardenberg +to return to Berlin and immediately to dismiss the French ambassador. After +a little reflection, however, he said that that measure should be +postponed." + +[116] Rapp, Memoires, p. 58. Beer, p. 188. + +[117] "The scarcity of provisions had been very great indeed. Much +discouragement had arisen in consequence, and a considerable degree of +insubordination, which, though less easy to produce in a Russian army than +in any other, is, when it does make its appearance, most prejudicial, was +beginning to manifest itself in various ways. The bread waggons were +pillaged on their way to the camp, and it became very difficult to repress +the excesses of the troops."--Report of General Ramsay, Dec. 10; Records: +Austria, vol. 78. + +[118] Hardenberg, ii. 345, Haugwitz had just become joint Foreign Minister +with Hardenberg. + +[119] Haugwitz' justification of himself, with Hardenberg's comments upon +it, is to be seen in Hardenberg, v. 220. But see also, for Hardenberg's own +bad faith, _id._ i. 551. + +[120] Lord Harrowby's despatch from Berlin, Dec. 7; Records: Prussia, vol. +196. The news of Austerlitz reached Berlin on the night of Dec. 7. Next day +Lord Harrowby called on Hardenberg. "He told me that in a council of war +held since the arrival of the first accounts of the disaster, it had been +decided to order a part of the Prussian army to march into Bohemia. These +events, he said, need not interrupt our negotiations." Then, on the 12th +came the news of the armistice: Harrowby saw Hardenberg that evening. "I +was struck with something like irritation in his manner, with a sort of +reference to the orders of the King, and with an expression which dropped +from him that circumstances might possibly arise in which Prussia could +look only to her own defence and security. I attributed this in a great +degree to the agitation of the moment, and I should have pushed the +question to a point if the entrance of Count Metternich and M. d'Alopeus +had not interrupted me.... Baron Hardenberg assured us that the military +movements of the Prussian army were proceeding without a moment's loss of +time." On the 25th Haugwitz arrived with his treaty. Hardenberg then +feigned illness. "Baron Hardenberg was too ill to see me, or, as far as I +could learn, any other person; and it has been impossible for me to +discover what intelligence is brought by Count Haugwitz." + +[121] Lefebvre, Histoire des Cabinets, ii. 217. + +[122] Martens, viii. 388; viii. 479. Beer, p. 232. + +[123] Correspondence de Napoleon, xii. 253. + +[Transcriber's Note: A corner had been torn from the page in our print +copy. A [***] sometimes indicates several missing words.] + +[124] The story of Pitt's "Austerlitz look" preceding his death is so +impressive and so well known that I cannot resist giving the real facts +about the reception of the news of Austerlitz in England. There were four +Englishmen who were expected to witness the battle, Sir A. Paget, +ambassador at Vienna, Lord L. Gower, ambassador with the Czar, Lord +Harrington and General Ramsay, military envoys. Of these, Lord Harrington +had left England too late to reach the armies; Sir A. Paget sat [***] +despatches at Olmuetz without hearing the firing, and on going out alter the +[***] astonished to fall in with the retreating army; Gower was too far in +[***] General Ramsay unfortunately went off on that very day to get some +[***] no Englishman witnessed the awful destruction that took [***] that +reached England, quite misrepresented [***] decisive one. Pitt actually +thought at first [***] to his policy, and likely to encourage [***] as +December 20th the following [***] "Even supposing the advantage of [***] +must have been obtained with a loss which cannot have left his force in a +condition to contend with the army of Prussia and at the same time to make +head against the Allies. If on the other hand it should appear that the +advantage has been with the Allies, there is every reason to hope that +Prussia will come forward with vigour to decide the contest." Records: +Prussia, vol. 196. It was the surrender of Ulm which really gave Pitt the +shock attributed to Austerlitz. The despatch then written--evidently from +Pitt's dictation--exhorting the Emperor to do his duty, is the most +impassioned and soul-stirring thing in the whole political correspondence +of the time. + +[125] Hardenberg, ii. 463. Hardenberg, who, in spite of his weak and +ambiguous conduct up to the end of 1805, felt bitterly the disgraceful +position in which Prussia had placed itself, now withdrew from office. "I +received this morning a message from Baron Hardenberg requesting me to call +on him. He said that he could no longer remain in office consistently with +his honour, and that he waited only for the return of Count Haugwitz to +give up to him the management of his department. 'You know,' he said, 'my +principles, and the efforts that I have made in favour of the good cause; +judge then of the pain that I must experience when I am condemned to be +accessory to this measure. You know, probably, that I was an advocate for +the acquisition of Hanover, but I wished it upon terms honourable to both +parties. I thought it a necessary bulwark to cover the Prussian dominions, +and I thought that the House of Hanover might have been indemnified +elsewhere. But now,' he added, 'j'abhorre les moyens infames par lesquels +nous faisons cette acquisition. Nous pourrions rester les amis de Bonaparte +sans etre ses esclaves.' He apologised for this language, and said I must +not consider it as coming from a Prussian Minister, but from a man who +unbosomed himself to his friend.... I have only omitted the distressing +picture of M. de Hardenberg's agitation during this conversation. He +bewailed the fate of Prussia, and complained of the hardships he had +undergone for the last three months, and of the want of firmness and +resolution in his Prussian Majesty. He several times expressed the hope +that his Majesty's Government and that of Russia would make some allowances +for the situation of this country. They had the means, he said, to do it an +infinity of mischief. The British navy might destroy the Prussian commerce, +and a Russian army might conquer some of her eastern provinces; but +Bonaparte would be the only gainer, as thereby Prussia would be thrown +completely into his arms."--F. Jackson's despatch from Berlin, March 27, +1806; Records: Prussia, vol. 197. + +[126] On the British envoy demanding his passports, Haugwitz entered into a +long defence of his conduct, alleging grounds of necessity. Mr. Jackson +said that there could be no accommodation with England till the note +excluding British vessels was reversed. "M. de Haugwitz immediately +rejoined, 'I was much surprised when I found that that note had been +delivered to you.' 'How,' I said, 'can _you_ be surprised who was the +author of the measures that give rise to it?' The only answer I received +was, 'Ah! ne dites pas cela.' He observed that it would be worth +considering whether our refusal to acquiesce in the present state of things +might not bring about one still more disastrous. I smiled, and asked if I +was to understand that a Prussian army would take a part in the threatened +invasion of England. He replied that he did not now mean to insinuate any +such thing, but that it might be impossible to answer for +events."--Jackson's Despatch, April 25. _id._ + +[127] Papers presented to Parliament, 1806, p. 63. + +[128] "An order has been issued to the officers of the garrison of Berlin +to abstain, under severe penalties, from speaking of the state of public +affairs. This order was given in consequence of the very general and loud +expressions of dissatisfaction which issued from all classes of people, but +particularly from the military, at the recent conduct of the Government; +for it has been in contemplation to publish an edict prohibiting the public +at large from discussing questions of state policy. The experience of a +very few days must convince the authors of this measure of the reverse of +their expectation, the satires and sarcasms upon their conduct having +become more universal than before."--Jackson's Despatch, March 22, +_id_. "On Thursday night the windows of Count Haugwitz' house were +completely demolished by some unknown person. As carbine bullets were +chiefly made use of for the purpose, it is suspected to have been done by +some of the garrison. The same thing had happened some nights before, but +the Count took no notice of it. Now a party of the police patrol the +street"--_Id_., April 27. + +[129] Pertz, i. 331. Seeley, i. 271. + +[130] Hopfner, Der Krieg von 1806, i. 48. + +[131] A list of all Prussian officers in 1806 of and above the rank of +major is given in Henckel von Donnersmarck, Erinnerungen, with their years +of service. The average of a colonel's service is 42 years; of a major's, +35. + +[132] Mueffling, Aus Meinem Leben, p. 15. Hopfner, i. 157. Correspondence de +Napoleon, xiii. 150. + +[133] Hopfner, ii. 390. Hardenberg, iii. 230. + +[134] "Count Stein, the only man of real talents in the administration, has +resigned or was dismissed. He is a considerable man, of great energy, +character, and superiority of mind, who possessed the public esteem in a +high degree, and, I have no doubt, deserved it.... During the negotiation +for an armistice, the expenses of Bonaparte's table and household at Berlin +were defrayed by the King of Prussia. Since that period one of the +Ministers called upon Stein, who was the chief of the finances, to pay +300,000 crowns on the same account. Stein refused with strong expressions +of indignation. The King spoke to him: he remonstrated with his Majesty in +the most forcible terms, descanted on the wretched humiliation of such mean +conduct, and said that he never could pay money on such an account unless +he had the order in writing from his Majesty. This order was given a few +days after the conversation."--Hutchinson's Despatch, Jan. 1, 1807; +Records: Prussia, vol. 200. + +[135] Corr. Nap. xiii. 555. + +[136] "It is still doubtful who commands, and whether Kamensky has or has +not given up the command. I wrote to him on the first moment of my arrival, +but have received no answer from him. On the 23rd, the day of the first +attack, he took off his coat and waistcoat, put all his stars and ribbons +over his shirt, and ran about the streets of Pultusk encouraging the +soldiers, over whom he is said to have great influence."--Lord Hutchinson's +Despatch, Jan. 1, 1807; Records: Prussia, vol. 200. + +[137] Hutchinson's letter, in Adair, Mission to Vienna, p. 373. + +[138] For the Whig foreign policy, see Adair, p. 11-13. Its principle was +to relinquish the attempt to raise coalitions of half-hearted Governments +against France by means of British subsidies, but to give help to States +which of their own free will entered into war with Napoleon. + +[139] The battle of Friedland is described in Lord Hutchinson's despatch +(Records: Prussia, vol. 200--in which volume are also Colonel Sonntag's +reports, containing curious details about the Russians, and some personal +matter about Napoleon in a letter from an inhabitant of Eylau; also +Gneisenau's appeal to Mr. Canning from Colberg). + +[140] Bignon, vi. 342. + +[141] Papers presented to Parliament, 1808, p. 106. The intelligence +reached Canning on the 21st of July. Canning's despatch to Brook Taylor, +July 22; Records: Denmark, vol. 196. It has never been known who sent the +information, but it must have been some one very near the Czar, for it +purported to give the very words used by Napoleon in his interview with +Alexander on the raft. It is clear, from Canning's despatch of July 22, +that this conversation and nothing else had up till then been reported. The +informant was probably one of the authors of the English alliance of 1805. + +[142] Napoleon to Talleyrand, July 31, 1807. He instructs Talleyrand to +enter into certain negotiations with the Danish Minister, which would be +meaningless if the Crown Prince had already promised to hand over the +fleet. The original English documents, in Records: Denmark, vols. 196, 197, +really show that Canning never considered that he had any proof of the +intentions of Denmark, and that he justified his action only by the +inability of Denmark to resist Napoleon's demands. + +[143] Cevallos, p. 73. + +[144] Pertz, ii. 23. Seeley, i. 430. + +[145] Cevallos, p. 13. Baumgarten, Geschichte Spaniens, i. 131. + +[146] Escoiquiz, Expose, p. 57, 107. + +[147] Miot de Melito, ii. ch. 7. Murat was made King of Naples. + +[148] Baumgarten, i. 242. + +[149] Wellington Despatches, iii. 135. + +[150] Haeusser, iii. 133. Seeley, i. 480. + +[151] For the striking part played at Erfurt by Talleyrand in opposition to +Napoleon see Metternich's paper of December 4, in Beer, p. 516. It seems +that Napoleon wished to involve the Czar in active measures against +Austria, but was thwarted by Talleyrand. + +[152] Baumgarten i. 311. + +[153] Napier, ii. 17. + +[154] Metternich, ii. 147. + +[155] Gentz, Tagebuecher, i. 60. + +[156] Steffens, vi. 153. Memoires du Roi Jerome, iii. 340. + +[157] Beer, p. 370. Haeusser, iii. 278. + +[158] Correspondance de Napoleon, xviii. 459, 472. Gentz, Tagebuecher, i. +120, Pelet, Memoires sur la Guerre de 1809, i. 223. + +[159] "Je n'ai jamais vu d'affaire aussi sanglante et aussi meurtriere." +Report of the French General, Memoires de Jerome, iv. 109. + +[160] See Arndt's Poem on Schill. Gedichte, i. 328 (ed. 1837). + +[161] Wellington Despatches, iv. 533. Sup. Desp. vi. 319, Napier, ii. 357. + +[162] Correspondance de Napoleon: Decision, Mai 23, 1806. Parliamentary +Papers, 1810, p. 123, 697. + +[163] Beer, p. 445, Gentz, Tagebuecher, i. 82, 118. + +[164] Correspondance de Napoleon, xix. 15, 265. + +[165] Corresp. de Napoleon, xxiii. 62, Decret, 9 Dec., 1811. + +[166] Memoires de Jerome, v. 185. + +[167] Wellington Supplementary Despatches, vi. 41. Napier, iii. 250. + +[168] Baumgarten, Geschichte Spaniens, i. 405. + +[169] Hardenberg (Ranke), iv. 268. Haeusser, iii. 535. Seeley, ii. 447. + +[170] Martens, Nouveau Recueil, i. 417. A copy, or the original, of this +Treaty was captured by the Russians with other of Napoleon's papers during +the retreat from Moscow, and a draft of it sent to London, which remains in +the Records. + +[171] Metternich, i. 122. + +[172] Memoires de Jerome, v. 247. + +[173] Bogdanowitsch, i. 72; Chambray, i. 186. Sir R. Wilson, Invasion of +Russia, p. 15. + +[174] Droysen, Leben des Grafen York. I. 394. + +[175] Pertz, iii. 211, _seq_. Seeley, iii. 21. + +[176] Oncken, Oesterreich und Preussen, i. 28. + +[177] Martens, N.R., III. 234. British and Foreign State Papers +(Hertslet), i. 49. + +[178] For Breslau in February, see Steffens, 7. 69. + +[179] For the difference between the old and the new officers, see +Correspondance de Napoleon, 27 Avril, 1813. + +[180] Henckel von Donnersmarck, p. 187. The battles of Luetzen, Bautzen, and +Leipzig are described in the despatches of Lord Cathcart, who witnessed +them in company with the Czar and King Frederick William. Records: Russia, +207, 209. + +[181] The account given in the following pages of Napoleon's motives and +action during the armistice is based upon the following letters printed in +the twenty-fifth volume of the Correspondence:--To Eugene, June 2, July 1, +July 17, Aug. 4; to Maret, July 8; to Daru, July 17; to Berthier, July 23; +to Davoust, July 24, Aug. 5; to Ney, Aug. 4, Aug. 12. The statement of +Napoleon's error as to the strength of the Austrian force is confirmed by +Metternich, i. 150. + +[182] Oncken, i. 80. + +[183] Napoleon to Eugene, 1st July, 1813. + +[184] Metternich, i. 163. + +[185] Haeusser, iv. 59. One of the originals is contained in Lord Cathcart's +despatch from Kalisch, March 28th, 1813. Records: Russia, Vol. 206. + +[186] Memoires de Jerome, vi. 223. + +[187] "Your lordship has only to recollect the four days' continued +fighting at Leipzig, followed by fourteen days' forced marches in the worst +weather, in order to understand the reasons that made some repose +absolutely necessary. The total loss of the Austrians alone, since the 10th +of August, at the time of our arrival at Frankfort, was 80,000 men. We were +entirely unprovided with heavy artillery, the nearest battery train not +having advanced further than the frontiers of Bohemia." It was thought for +a moment that the gates of Strasburg and Huningen might be opened by +bribery, and the Austrian Government authorised the expenditure of a +million florins for this purpose; in that case the march into Switzerland +would have been abandoned. The bribing plan, however, broke down.--Lord +Aberdeen's despatches, Nov. 24, Dec. 25, 1813. Records; Austria, 107. + +[188] Castlereagh's despatch from Langres, Jan. 29, 1814. Records: +Continent, Vol. II.: "As far as I have hitherto felt myself called on to +give an opinion, I have stated that the British Government did not decline +treating with Bonaparte." "The Czar said he observed my view of the +question was different from what he believed prevailed in England" +(_id._ Feb. 16). See Southey's fine Ode on the Negotiations of 1814. + +[189] British and Foreign State Papers, I. 131. + +[190] Beranger, Biographie, ed. duod., p. 354. + +[191] British and Foreign State Papers, I. 151. + +[192] Lord W. Bentinck, who was with Murat, warned him against the probable +consequences of his duplicity. Bentinck had, however, to be careful in his +language, as the following shows. Murat having sent him a sword of honour, +he wrote to the English Government, May 1, 1814: "It is a severe violence +to my feelings to incur any degree of obligation to an individual whom I so +entirely despise. But I feel it my duty not to betray any appearance of a +spirit of animosity." To Murat he wrote on the same day: "The sword of a +great captain is the most flattering present which a soldier can receive. +It is with the highest gratitude that I accept the gift, Sire, which you +have done me the honour to send."--Records: Sicily, Vol. 98. + +[193] Treaties of Teplitz, Sept. 9, 1813. In Bianchi, Storia Documentata +della Diplomazia Europea, i. 334, there is a long protest addressed by +Metternich to Castlereagh on May 26, 1814, referring with great minuteness +to a number of clauses in a secret Treaty signed by all the Powers at +Prague on July 27, 1813, and ratified at London on August 23, giving +Austria the disposal of all Italy. This protest, which has been accepted as +genuine in Reuchlin's Geschichte Italiens and elsewhere, is, with the +alleged secret Treaty, a forgery. My grounds for this statement are as +follows:--(1) There was no British envoy at Prague in July, 1813. (2) The +private as well as the official letters of Castlereagh to Lord Cathcart of +Sept. 13 and 18, and the instructions sent to Lord Aberdeen during August +and September, prove that no joint Treaty existed up to that date, to which +both England and Austria were parties. Records: Russia, 207, 209 A. +Austria, 105. (3) Lord Aberdeen's reports of his negotiations with +Metternich after this date conclusively prove that almost all Italian +questions, including even the Austrian frontier, were treated as matters to +be decided by the Allies in common. While Austria's right to a +preponderance in upper Italy is admitted, the affairs of Rome and Naples +are always treated as within the range of English policy. + +[194] The originals of the Genoese and Milanese petitions for independence +are in Records: Sicily, Vol. 98. "The Genoese universally desire the +restoration of their ancient Republic. They dread above all other +arrangements their annexation to Piedmont, to the inhabitants of which +there have always existed a peculiar aversion."--Bentick's Despatch, April +27, 1814, _id._ + +[195] Castlereagh, x. 18. + +[196] As Arndt, Schriften, ii. 311, Fuenf oder sechs Wunder Gottes. + +[197] Bernhardi, Geschichte Russlands, iii. 26. + +[198] Parl. Debates, xxvii. 634, 834. + +[199] Wellington, Sup. Des., x. 468; Castlereagh, x. 145. Records, Sicily, +vol. 97. The future King Louis Philippe was sent by his father-in-law, +Ferdinand, to England, to intrigue against Murat among the Sovereigns and +Ministers then visiting England. His own curious account of his +proceedings, with the secret sign for the Prince Regent, given him by Louis +XVIII., who was afraid to write anything, is in _id._, vol. 99. + +[200] Wippermann, Kurhessen, pp. 9-13. In Hanover torture was restored, and +occasionally practised till the end of 1818: also the punishment of death +by breaking on the wheel. See Hodgskin, Travels, ii. 51, 69. + +[201] Baumgarten, Geschichte Spaniens, ii. 30, Wellington, D., xii. 27; S. +D., ix. 17. + +[202] Wellington, S.D., ix. 328. + +[203] Compare his cringing letter to Pichegru in Manuscrit de Louis XVIII., +p. 463, with his answer in 1797 to the Venetian Senate, in Thiers. + +[204] _Moniteur_, 5 Juin. British and Foreign State Papers, 1812-14, +ii. 960. + +[205] The payment of L13 per annum in direct taxes. No one could be elected +who did not pay L40 per annum in direct taxes,--so large a sum, that the +Charta provided for the case of there not being fifty persons in a +department eligible. + +[206] Fourteen out of Napoleon's twenty marshals and three-fifths of his +Senators were called to the Chamber of Peers. The names of the excluded +Senators will be found in Vaulabelle, ii. 100; but the reader must not take +Vaulabelle's history for more than a collection of party-legends. + +[207] Ordonnance, in _Moniteur_, 26 Mai. + +[208] This poor creature owed his life, as he owes a shabby immortality, to +the beautiful and courageous Grace Dalrymple Elliot. Journal of Mrs. G.D. +Elliot, p. 79. + +[209] Carnot, Memoire adresse au Roi, p. 20. + +[210] Wellington Despatches, xii. 248. On the ground of his ready-money +dealings, it has been supposed that Wellington understood the French +people. On the contrary, he often showed great want of insight, both in his +acts and in his opinions, when the finer, and therefore more statesmanlike, +sympathies were in question. Thus, in the delicate position of ambassador +of a victorious Power and counsellor of a restored dynasty, he bitterly +offended the French country-population by behaving like a _grand seigneur_ +before 1789, and hunting with a pack of hounds over their young corn. The +matter was so serious that the Government of Louis XVIII. had to insist on +Wellington stopping his hunts. (Talleyrand et Louis XVIII., p. 141.) This +want of insight into popular feeling, necessarily resulted in some +portentous blunders: _e.g.,_ all that Wellington could make of +Napoleon's return from Elba was the following:--"He has acted upon false or +no information, and the King will destroy him without difficulty and in a +short time." Despatches, xii. 268. + +[211] A good English account of Vienna during the Congress will be found in +"Travels in Hungary," by Dr. R. Bright, the eminent physician. His visit to +Napoleon's son, then a child five years old, is described in a passage of +singular beauty and pathos. + +[212] British and Foreign State Papers, 1814-15, p. 554, _seq_. +Talleyrand et Louis XVIII., p. 13. Kluber, ix. 167. Seeley's Stein, iii. +248. Gentz, Depeches Inedites, i. 107. Records: Continent, vol. 7, Oct. 2. + +[213] Bernhardi, i. 2; ii. 2, 661. + +[214] Wellington, S.D., ix. 335. + +[215] Wellington, S.D., ix. 340. Records: Continent, vol. 7, Oct. 9, 14. + +[216] Talleyrand, p. 74. Records, _id.,_ Oct. 24, 25. + +[217] Wellington, S.D., ix. 331. Talleyrand, pp. 59, 82, 85, 109. Klueber, +vii. 21. + +[218] British and Foreign State Papers, 1814-15, p. 814. Klueber, vii. 61. + +[219] Talleyrand, p. 281. + +[220] B. and F. State Papers, 1814-15, ii. 1001. + +[221] Castlereagh did not contradict them. Records: Cont., vol. 10, Jan. 8. + +[222] British and Foreign State Papers, 1814-15, p. 642. Seeley's Stein, +iii. 303. Talleyrand, Preface, p. 18. + +[223] Chiefly, but not altogether, because Napoleon's war with England had +ruined the trade of the ports. See the report of Marshal Brune, in Daudet, +La Terreur Blanche, p. 173, and the striking picture of Marseilles in +Thiers, xviii. 340, drawn from his own early recollections. Bordeaux was +Royalist for the same reason. + +[224] Berriat-St. Prix, Napoleon a Grenoble, p. 10. + +[225] Beranger, Biographie, p. 373, ed. duod. + +[226] See their contemptible addresses, as well as those of the army, in +the _Moniteur_, from the 10th to the 19th of March to Louis XVIII., +from the 27th onwards to Napoleon. + +[227] _i.e._, Because he had abused his liberty. On Ney's trial two +courtiers alleged that Ney said he "would bring back Napoleon in an iron +cage." Ney contradicted, them. Proces de Ney, ii. 105, 113. + +[228] British and Foreign State Papers, 1814-15, ii. 443. + +[229] Correspondance de Napoleon, xxviii. 171, 267, etc. + +[230] British and Foreign State Papers, 1814-15, ii. 275. Castlereagh, ix. +512, Wellington, S.D., ix. 244. Records: Continent, vol. 12, Feb. 26. + +[231] Correspondance de Napoleon, xxviii. 111, 127. The order forbidding +him to come to Paris is wrongly dated April 19; probably for May 29. The +English documents relating to Ferdinand's return to Naples, with the +originals of many proclamations, etc., are in Records: Sicily, vols. 103, +104. They are interesting chiefly as showing the deep impression made on +England by Ferdinand's cruelties in 1799. + +[232] Benjamin Constant, Memoire sur les Cent Jours. + +[233] Lafayette, Memoires, v. 414. + +[234] Miot de Melito, iii. 434. + +[235] Napoleon to Ney; Correspondance, xxviii. 334. + +[236] "I have got an infamous army, very weak and ill-equipped, and a very +inexperienced staff." (Despatches, xii. 358.) So, even after his victory, +he writes:--"I really believe that, with the exception of my old Spanish +infantry, I have got not only the worst troops but the worst-equipped army, +with the worst staff that was ever brought together." (Despatches, xii. +509.) + +[237] Therefore he kept his forces more westwards, and further from +Bluecher, than if he had known Napoleon's actual plan. But the severance of +the English from the sea required to be guarded against as much as a defeat +of Bluecher. The Duke never ceased to regard it as an open question whether +Napoleon ought not to have thrown his whole force between Brussels and the +sea. (_Vide_ Memoir written in 1842 Wellington, S.D., ix. 530.) + +[238] Metternich, i., p. 155. + +[239] Wellington Despatches, xii. 649. + +[240] Wellington, S.D., xi. 24, 32. Maps of projected frontiers, Records: +Cont., vol 23. + +[241] Despatches, xii. 596. Seeley's Stein, iii. 332. + +[242] B. and F State Papers, 1815-16, iii. 201. The second article is the +most characteristic:--"Les trois Princes ... confessant que la nation +Chretienne dont eux et leurs peuples font partie n'a reellement d'autre +Souverain que celui a qui seul appartient en propriete la puissance ... +c'est-a-dire Dieu notre Divin Sauveur Jesus Christ, le Verbe du Tres Haut, +la parole de vie: leurs Majestes recommandent ... a leurs peuples ... de se +fortifier chaque jour davantage dans les principes et l'exercice des +devoirs que le Divin Sauveur a enseignes aux hommes." + +[243] Wellington, S.D., xi. 175. The account which Castlereagh gives of +the Czar's longing for universal peace appears to refute the theory that +Alexander had some idea of an attack upon Turkey in thus uniting +Christendom. According to Castlereagh, Metternich also thought that "it was +quite clear that the Czar's mind was affected," but for the singular reason +that "peace and goodwill engrossed all his thoughts, and that he had found +him of late friendly and reasonable on all points" (_Id_.) There was, +however, a strong popular impression at this time that Alexander was on the +point of invading Turkey. (Gentz, D.I., i. 197.) + +[244] B. and F. State Papers, 1815-16, iii. 273. Records; Continent, vol. +30. + +[245] Klueber, ii. 598. + +[246] Klueber, vi. 12. It covers, with its appendices, 205 pages. + +[247] In the first draft of the secret clauses of the Treaty of June 14, +1800, between England and Austria (see p. 150), Austria was to have had +Genoa. But the fear arising that Russia would not permit Austria's +extension to the Mediterranean, an alteration was made, whereby Austria was +promised half of Piedmont, Genoa to go to the King of Sardinia in +compensation. + +[248] Pertz, Leben Steins, iv 524. + +[249] Talleyrand, p. 277. + +[250] B. and F. State Papers, 1815-16, p. 928. + +[251] Bernhardi, iii. 2, 10, 666. + +[252] "We are now inundated with Russian agents of various descriptions, +some public and some secret, but all holding the same language, all +preaching 'Constitution and liberal principles,' and all endeavouring to +direct the eyes of the independents towards the North.... A copy of the +instructions sent to the Russian Minister here has fallen into the hands of +the Austrians." A'Court (Ambassador at Naples) to Castlereagh, Dec. 7, +1815, Records: Sicily, 104. + +[253] A profound reason has been ascribed to Metternich's conservatism by +some of his English apologists in high place, namely the fear that if ideas +of nationality should spring up, the non-German components of the Austrian +monarchy, viz., Bohemia, Hungary, Croatia, etc., would break off and become +independent States. But there is not a word in Metternich's writings which +shows that this apprehension had at this time entered his mind. To +generalise his Italian policy of 1815 into a great prophetic statesmanship, +is to interpret the ideas of one age by the history of the next. + +[254] In Moravia. For the system of espionage, see the book called "Carte +segrete della polizia Austriaca," consisting of police-reports which fell +into the hands of the Italians at Milan in 1848. + +[255] Bianchi, Storia Documentata, i. 208. The substance of this secret +clause was communicated to A'Court, the English Ambassador at Naples. "I +had no hesitation in saying that anything which contributed to the good +understanding now prevailing between Austria and Naples, could not but +prove extremely satisfactory to the British Government." A'Court to +Castlereagh, July 18, 1815. Records: Sicily, vol. 104. + +[256] Letters in Reuchlin, Geschichte Italiens, i. 71. The Holy Alliance +was turned to better account by the Sardinian statesmen than by the +Neapolitans. "Apres s'etre allie," wrote the Sardinian Ambassador at St. +Petersburg, "en Jesus-Christ notre Sauveur parole de vie, pourquoi et a +quel propos s'allier en Metternich?" + +[257] See the passages from Grenville's letters quoted in pp. 125, 126 of +this work. + +[258] Castlereagh, x. 18. "The danger is that the transition" (to liberty) +"may be too sudden to ripen into anything likely to make the world better +or happier.... I am sure it is better to retard than accelerate the +operation of this most hazardous principle which is abroad." + +[259] B. and F. State Papers, 1816-17, p. 553. Metternich, iii. 80. +Castlereagh had at first desired that the Constitution should be modified +under the influence of the English Ambassador. Instructions to A'Court, +March 14, 1814, marked "Most Secret"; Records: Sicily, vol. 99. A'Court +himself detested the Constitution. "I conceive the Sicilian people to be +totally and radically unfit to be entrusted with political power." July 23, +1814, id. + +[260] Castlereagh, x. 25. + +[261] "If his Majesty announces his determination to give effect to the +main principles of a constitutional regime, it is possible that he may +extinguish the existing arrangement with impunity, and re-establish one +more consistent with the efficiency of the executive power, and which may +restore the great landed proprietors and the clergy to a due share of +authority." Castlereagh, id. + +[262] Daudet, La Terreur Blanche, p. 186. The loss of the troops was a +hundred. The stories of wholesale massacres at Marseilles and other places +are fictions. + +[263] See the Address, in _Journal des Debats_, 15 Octobre: "Nous +oserons solliciter humblement la retribution necessaire," etc. For the +general history of the Session, see Duvergier de Hauranne, iii. 257; +Viel-Castal, iv. 139; Castlereagh's severe judgment of Artois. Records: +Cont., 28, Sept. 21. + +[264] _Journal des Debats_, 29 October. + +[265] Wellington, S.D., xi. 95. This self-confident folly is repeated in +many of Lord Liverpool's letters. + +[266] Proces du Marechal Ney, i. 212. + +[267] Ney was not, however, a mere fighting general. The Military Studies +published in English in 1833 from his manuscripts prove this. They abound +in acute remarks, and his estimate of the quality of the German soldier, at +a time when the Germans were habitually beaten and despised, is very +striking. He urges that when French infantry fight in three ranks, the +charge should be made after the two front ranks have fired, without waiting +for the third to fire. "The German soldier, formed by the severest +discipline, is cooler than any other. He would in the end obtain the +advantage in this kind of firing if it lasted long." (P. 100.) Ney's +parents appear to have been Wuertemberg people who had settled in Alsace. +The name was really Neu (New). + +[268] See the extracts from La Bourdonnaye's printed speech in _Journal +des Debits_, 19 Novembre: "Pour arreter leurs trames criminelles, il faut +des fers, des bourreaux, des supplices. La mort, la mort seule peut +effrayer leurs complices et mettre fin a leurs complots," etc. The journals +abound with similar speeches. + +[269] General Mouton-Duvernet. Several were sentenced to death in their +absence; some were acquitted on the singular plea that they had become +subjects of the Empire of Elba, and so could not be guilty of treason to +the King of France. + +[270] The sentence was commuted by the King to twelve years' imprisonment. +General Chartran was actually shot. It is stated, though it appears not to +be clear, that his prosecution began at the same late date. Duvergier de +Hauranne, iii. 335. + +[271] The highest number admitted by the Government to have been imprisoned +at any one time under the Law of Public Security was 319, in addition to +750 banished from their homes or placed under surveillance. No one has +collected statistics of the imprisonments by legal sentence. The old story +that there were 70,000 persons in prison is undoubtedly an absurd +exaggeration; but the numbers given by the Government, even if true at any +one moment, afford no clue to the whole number of imprisonments, for as +fast as one person gets out of prison in France in a time of political +excitement, another is put in. The writer speaks from personal experience, +having been imprisoned in 1871. Any one who has seen how these affairs are +conducted will know how ridiculous it would be to suppose that the central +government has information of every case. + +[272] See, _e.g._, the Petition aux Deux Chambres, 1816, at the +beginning of P.L. Courier's works. + +[273] _Journal des Debats_, 19 Decembre, 1815. + +[274] Wellington, S.D., xi 309. + +[275] Despatch in Duvergier de Hauranne, iii. 441. + +[276] Pertz, Leben Steins, iv. 428. + +[277] Schmalz, Berichtigung, etc., p. 14. + +[278] Pertz, Leben Steins, v. 23. + +[279] A curious account of the festival remains, written by Kieser, one of +the Professors who took part in it (Kieser, Das Wartburgfest, 1818). It is +so silly that it is hard to believe it to have been written by a grown-up +man. He says of the procession to the Wartburg, "There have indeed been +processions that surpassed this in outward glory and show; but in inner +significant value it cannot yield to any." But making allowance for the +author's personal weakness of head, his book is a singular and instructive +picture of the mental condition of "Young Germany" and its teachers at that +time--a subject that caused such extravagant anxiety to Governments, and so +seriously affected the course of political history. It requires some effort +to get behind the ridiculous side of the students' Teutonism; but there +were elements of reality there. Persons familiar with Wales will be struck +by the resemblance, both in language and spirit, between the scenes of 1818 +and the religious meetings or the Eisleddfodau of the Welsh, a resemblance +not accidental, but resulting from similarity of conditions, viz., a real +susceptibility to religious, patriotic, and literary ideas among a people +unacquainted with public or practical life on a large scale. But the +vigorous political action of the Welsh in 1880, when the landed interest +throughout the Principality lost seats which it had held for centuries, +surprised only those who had seen nothing but extravagance in the chapel +and the field-meeting. Welsh ardour, hitherto in great part undirected, +then had a practical effect because English organisation afforded it a +model: German ardour in 1817 proved sterile because it had no such example +at hand. + +[280] See the speech in Bernhardi, iii. 669. + +[281] Gentz, D.I., ii. 87, iii. 72. + +[282] Castlereagh, xii. 55, 62. + +[283] Wellington, S.D., xii. 835. + +[284] B. and F. State Papers, 1818-19, vi. 14. + +[285] Gentz, D.I., i. 400. Gentz, the confidant and adviser of Metternich, +was secretary to the Conference at Aix-la-Chapelle. His account of it in +this despatch is of the greatest value, bringing out in a way in which no +official documents do the conservative and repressive tone of the +Conference. The prevalent fear had been that Alexander would break with his +old Allies and make a separate league with France and Spain. See also +Castlereagh, xii. 47. + +[286] "I could write you a long letter about the honour which the Prussians +pay to everything Austrian, our whole position, our measures, our language. +Metternich has fairly enchanted them." Gentz, Nachlasse [Osten], i. 52. + +[287] Metternich, iii. 171. + +[288] See his remarks in Metternich, iii. 269; an oasis of sense in this +desert of Commonplace. + +[289] Stourdza, Denkschrift, etc., p. 31. The French original is not in the +British Museum. + +[290] The extracts from Sand's diaries, published in a little book in 1821 +(Tagebuecher, etc.), form a very interesting religious study. The last, +written on Dec. 31, 1818, is as follows:--"I meet the last day of this year +in an earnest festal spirit, knowing well that the Christmas which I have +celebrated will be my last. If our strivings are to result in anything, if +the cause of mankind is to succeed in our Fatherland, if all is not to be +forgotten, all our enthusiasm spent in vain, the evildoer, the traitor, the +corrupter of youth must die. Until I have executed this, I have no peace; +and what can comfort me until I know that I have with upright will set my +life at stake? O God, I pray only for the right clearness and courage of +soul, that in that last supreme hour I may not be false to myself" (p. +174). The reference to the Greeks is in a letter in the English memoir, p. +40. + +[291] The papers of the poet Arndt were seized. Among them was a copy of +certain short notes made by the King of Prussia, about 1808, on the +uselessness of a _levee en masse_. One of these notes was as +follows:--"As soon as a single clergyman is shot" (_i.e._ by the +French) "the thing would come to an end." These words were published in the +Prussian official paper as an indication that Arndt, worse than Sand, +advocated murdering clergymen! Welcker, Urkunden, p. 89. + +[292] Metternich, iii. 217, 258. + +[293] Metternich, iii. 268. + +[294] The minutes of the Conference are in Welcker, Urkunden, p. 104, +_seq_. See also Weech, Correspondenzen. + +[295] Protokolle der Bundesversammlung, 8, 266. Nauwerck, Thaetigkeit, etc., +2, 287. + +[296] AEgidi, Der Schluss-Acte, ii. 362, 446. + +[297] Article 57. The intention being that no assembly in any German State +might claim sovereign power as representing the people. If, for instance, +the Bavarian Lower House had asserted that it represented the sovereignty +of the people, and that the King was simply the first magistrate in the +State, this would have been an offence against Federal law, and have +entitled the Diet--_i.e._ Metternich--to armed interference. The +German State-papers of this time teem with the constitutional distinction +between a Representative Assembly (_i.e._ assembly representing +popular sovereignty) and an Assembly of Estates (_i.e._, of particular +orders with limited, definite rights, such as the granting of a tax). In +technical language, the question at issue was the true interpretation of +the phrase _Landstaendische Verfassungen_, used in the 13th article of +the original Act of Federation. + +[298] See, in Welcker, Urkunden, p. 356, the celebrated paper called +"Memorandum of a Prussian Statesman, 1822," which at the same time +recommends a systematic underhand rivalry with Austria, in preparation for +an ultimate breach. Few State-papers exhibit more candid and cynical +cunning. + +[299] Ilse, Politische Verfolgungen, p. 31. + +[300] The comparison is the Germans' own, not mine. "'How savoury a thin +roast veal is!' said one Hamburg beggar to another. 'Where did you eat it?' +said his friend, admiringly. 'I never ate it at all, but I smelt it as I +passed a great man's house while the dog was being fed.'" (Ilse, p. 57.) + +[301] The Commission at Mainz went on working until 1827. It seems to have +begun to discover real revolutionary societies about 1824. There is a long +list of persons remanded for trial in their several States, in Ilse, p. +595, with the verdicts and the sentences passed upon them, which vary from +a few months' to nineteen years' imprisonment. + +[302] Metternich, iii. 168; and see Wellington, S.D., xii. 878. + +[303] Gregoire, Memoires, i. 411. Had the Constitutional Church of France +succeeded, Gregoire would have left a great name in religious history. +Napoleon, by one of the most fatal acts of despotism, extinguished a +society likely, from its democratic basis and its association with a great +movement of reform, to become the most liberal and enlightened of all +Churches, and left France to be long divided between Ultramontane dogma and +a coarse kind of secularism. The life of Gregoire ought to be written in +English. From the enormous number of improvements for which he laboured, +his biography would give a characteristic picture of the finer side of the +generation of 1789. + +[304] The late Count of Chambord, or Henry V., son of the Duke of Barry, +was born some months after his father's death. + +[305] Castlereagh, xii. 162, 259. "The monster Radicalism still lives," +Castlereagh sorrowfully admits to Metternich. + +[306] Metternich, iii. 369. "A man must be like me, born and brought up +amid the storm of politics, to know what is the precise meaning of a shout +of triumph like those which now burst from Burdett and Co. He may have read +of it, but I have seen it with my eyes. I was living at the time of the +Federation of 1789. I was fifteen, and already a man." + +[307] Baumgarten, Geschichte Spaniens, ii. 175. + +[308] See the note of Fernan Nunez, in Wellington, S. D, xii 582. "Les +efforts unanimes de ces memes Puissances ont detruit le systeme +devastateur, d'ou naquit la rebellion Americaine; mais il leur restait +encore a le detruire dans l'Amerique Espagnole." + +[309] Wellington, S.D., xii. 807. + +[310] Jullian, Precis Historique, p. 78. + +[311] Historia de la vida de Fernando VII., ii. 158. + +[312] Carrascosa, Memoires, p. 25; Colletta, ii. 155. + +[313] Carrascosa p. 44. + +[314] Gentz. D.I., ii. 108, 122. It was rather too much even for the +Austrians. "La conduite de ce malheureux souverain n'a ete, des le +commencement des troubles, qu'un tissu de faiblesse et de duplicite," etc. +"Voila l'allie que le ciel a mis entre nos mains, et dont nous avons a +retablir les interets!" Ferdinand was guilty of such monstrous perjuries +and cruelties that the reader ought to be warned not to think of him as a +saturnine and Machiavellian Italian. He was a son of the Bourbon Charles +III. of Spain. His character was that of a jovial, rather stupid farmer, +whom a freak of fortune had made a king from infancy. A sort of grotesque +comic element runs through his life, and through every picture drawn by +persons in actual intercourse with him. The following, from one of +Bentinck's despatches of 1814 (when Ferdinand had just heard that Austria +had promised to keep Murat in Naples), is very characteristic: "I found his +Majesty very much afflicted and very much roused. He expressed his +determination never to renounce the rights which God had given him.... He +said he might be poor, but he would die honest, and his children should not +have to reproach him for having given up their rights. He was the son of +the honest Charles III. ... he was his unworthy offspring, but he would +never disgrace his family.... On my going away he took me by the hand, and +said he hoped I should esteem him as he did me, and begged me to take a +Pheasant pye to a gentleman who had been his constant shooting companion." +Records, Sicily, vol. 97. Ferdinand was the last sovereign who habitually +kept a professional fool, or jester, in attendance upon him. + +[315] British and Foreign State Papers, vii. 361, 995. + +[316] Except in Sicily, where, however, the course of events had not the +same publicity as on the mainland. + +[317] Verbatim from the Russian Note of April 18. B. and F. State Papers, +vii. 943. + +[318] Parliamentary Debates, N.S., viii. 1136. + +[319] Gentz, D.I., ii. 70. "M. le Prince Metternich s'est rendu chez +l'Empereur pour le mettre au fait de ces tristes circonstances. Depuis que +je le connais, je ne l'ai jamais vu aussi frappe d'aucun evenement qu'il +l'etait hier avant son depart." + +[320] Castlereagh, xii. 311. + +[321] Gentz, D.I., ii. 76. Metternich, iii. 395. "Our fire-engines were +not full in July, otherwise we should have set to work immediately." + +[322] Gentz, ii. 85. Gentz was secretary at the Congress of Troppau, as he +had been at Vienna and Aix-la-Chapelle. His letters exhibit the Austrian +and absolutist view of all European politics with striking clearness. He +speaks of the change in Richelieu's action as disagreeable but not fatal. +"Ces pruderies politiques sont sans doute lacheuses.... La Russie, +l'Autriche, et la Prusse, heureusement libres encore dans leurs mouvements, +et assez puissantes pour soutenir ce qu'elles arretent, pourraient adopter +sans le concours de l'Angleterre et de la France un systeme tel que les +besoins du moment le demandent." The description of the three despotisms as +"happily free in their movements" is very characteristic of the time. + +[323] This is the system conveniently but incorrectly named Holy Alliance, +from its supposed origination in he unmeaning Treaty of Holy Alliance in +1815. The reader will have seen that it took five years of reaction to +create a definitive agreement among the monarchs to intervene against +popular changes in other States, and that the principles of any operative +league planned by Alexander in 1815 would have been largely different from +those which he actually accepted in 1820. The Alexander who designed the +Holy Alliance was the Alexander who had forced Louis XVIII. to grant the +Charta. + +[324] Castlereagh, xii. 330. + +[325] Metternich, iii. 394. B. and F. State Papers, viii. 1160. Gentz, D. +I., ii. 112. The best narrative of the Congress of Troppau is in Duvergier +de Hauranne, vi. 93. The Life of Canning by his secretary, Stapleton, +though it is a work of some authority on this period, is full of +misstatements about Castlereagh. Stapleton says that Castlereagh took no +notice of the Troppau circular of December 8 until it had been for more +than a month in his possession, and suggests that he would never have +protested at all but for the unexpected disclosure of the circular in a +German newspaper. As a matter of fact, the first English protest against +the Troppau doctrine, expressed in a memorandum, "tres long, tres positif, +assez dur meme, et assez tranchant dans son langage," was handed in to the +Congress on December 16 or 19, along with a very unwelcome note to +Metternich. There is some gossip of another of Canning's secretaries in +Greville's Memoirs, i. 105, to the effect that Castlereagh's private +despatches to Troppau differed in tone from his official ones, which were +only written "to throw dust in the eyes of Parliament." It is sufficient to +read the Austrian documents of the time, teeming as they do with vexation +and disappointment at England's action, to see that this is a fiction. + +[326] Had Ferdinand's first proposals been accepted by the Neapolitan +Parliament, France and England, it was thought, might have insisted on a +compromise at Laibach. "Les Gouvernements de France et d'Angleterre +auraient fortement insiste sur l'introduction d'un regime constitutionnel +et representatif, regime que la Cour de Vienne croit absolument +incompatible avec la position des Etats de l'Italie, et avec la surete de +ses propres Etats." Gentz, D.I., ii. 110. + +[327] Gentz, Nachlasse (P. Osten), i. 67. Lest the reader should take a +prejudice against Capodistrias for his cunning, I ought to mention here +that he was a man of austere disinterestedness in private life, and one of +the few statesmen of the time who did not try to make money by politics. +His ambition, which was very great, rose above all the meaner objects which +tempt most men. The contrast between his personal goodness and his +unscrupulousness in diplomacy will become more clear later on. + +[328] Colletta, ii. 230. Bianchi, Diplomazia, ii. 47. + +[329] Gualterio, Ultimi Rivolgimenti, iii. 46. Silvio Pellico, Le mie +prigioni, ch. 57. + +[330] B. and F. State Papers, viii. 1203. + +[331] Baumgarten, ii. 325. + +[332] Wellington Despatches, N.S., i. 284. + +[333] Talleyrand et Louis XVIII., p. 333. + +[334] Wellington, i. 343. + +[335] Duvergier de Hauranne, vii. 140. + +[336] Canning denied that it was offered, but the despatches in Wellington +prove it. These papers, supplemented by the narrative of Duvergier de +Hauranne, drawn from the French documents which he specifies, are the +authority for the history of the Congress. Canning's celebrated speech of +April, 1823, is an effective _ex parte_ composition rather than a +historical summary. The reader who goes to the originals will be struck by +the immense superiority of Wellington's statements over those of all the +Continental statesmen at Verona, in point, in force, and in good sense, as +well as in truthfulness. The Duke, nowhere appears to greater advantage. + +[337] Report of Angouleme, Duvergier d'Hauranne, vii. "La ou sont nos +troupes, nous maintenons la paix avec beaucoup de peine; mais la ou nous +ne sommes pas, on massacre, on brule, on pille, on vole. Les corps +Espagnols, se disant royalistes, ne cherchent qu'a voler et a piller." + +[338] Decretos del Rey Fernando, vii. 35, 50, 75. This process, which was +afterwards extended even to common soldiers, was called Purificacion. +Committees were appointed to which all persons coming under the law had to +send in detailed evidence of correct conduct in and since 1820, signed by +some well-known royalists. But the committees also accepted any letters of +denunciation that might be sent to them, and were bound by law to keep them +secret, so that in practice the Purificacion became a vast system of +anonymous persecution. + +[339] Historia de la vida de Fernando VII., 1842, iii. 152. + +[340] Decretos del Rey Fernando, vii. 45. + +[341] Decretos, vii. 154. The preamble to this law is perhaps the most +astonishing of all Ferdinand's devout utterances. "My soul is confounded +with the horrible spectacle of the sacrilegious crimes which impiety has +dared to commit against the Supreme Maker of the universe. The ministers of +Christ have been persecuted and sacrificed; the venerable successor of St. +Peter has been outraged; the temples of the Lord have been profaned and +destroyed; the Holy Gospel depreciated; in fine, the inestimable legacy +which Jesus Christ gave in his last supper to secure our eternal felicity, +the Sacred Host, has been trodden under foot. My soul shudders, and will +not be able to return to tranquillity until, in union with my children, my +faithful subjects, I offer to God holocausts of piety," etc. But for some +specimens of Ferdinand's command of the vernacular, of a very different +character, see Wellington, N.S., ii. 37. + +[342] Revolution d'Espagne, examen critique (Paris, 1836), p. 151, from the +lists in the Gaceta de Madrid. The Gaceta for these years is wanting from +the copy in the British Museum, and in the large collection in that library +of historical and periodical literature relating to Spain I can find no +first hand authorities for the judicial murders of these years. Nothing +relating to the subject was permitted to be printed in Spain for many years +afterwards The work cited in this note, though bearing a French title, and +published at Paris in 1836, was in fact a Spanish book written in 1824. The +critical inquiry which has substantiated many of the worst traditions of +the French Reign of Terror from local records still remains to be +undertaken for this period of Spanish history. + +[343] See e.g., Stapleton, Canning and his Times p. 378. Wellington often +suggested the use of less peremptory language. Despatches, i. 134, +188[***], Metternich wrote as follows on hearing at Vienna of Castlereagh's +death: "Castlereagh was the only man in his country who had gained any +experience in foreign affairs. He had learned to understand me. He was +devoted to me in heart and spirit, not only from personal inclination, but +from conviction. I awaited him here as my second self." iii. 391. +Metternich, however, was apt to exaggerate his influence over the English +Minister. It was a great surprise to him that Castlereagh, after gaining +decisive majorities in the House of Commons on domestic questions in 1820, +in no wise changed the foreign policy expressed in the protest against the +Declaration of Troppau. + +[344] Stapleton, Political Life of Canning, ii. 18. + +[345] Wellington, i. 188. + +[346] Parl Hist., 12th Dec., 1826. + +[347] Stapleton, Life of Canning, i. 134. Martineau, p. 144. + +[348] Gentz, Nachlasse (Osten), ii. 165. + +[349] About the year 1830 the theory was started by Fallmerayer, a Tyrolese +writer, that the modern Greeks were the descendants of Slavonic invaders, +with scarcely a drop of Greek blood in their veins. Fallmerayer was +believed by some good scholars to have proved that the old Greek race had +utterly perished. More recent inquiries have discredited both Fallmerayer +and his authorities, and tend to establish the conclusion that, except in +certain limited districts, the Greeks left were always numerous enough to +absorb the foreign incomers. (Hopf, Griechenland; in Etsch and Gruber's +Encyklopaedie, vol. 85, p. 100.) The Albanian population of Greece in 1820 +is reckoned at about one-sixth. + +[350] Maurer, Das Griechische Volk, i. 64. + +[351] The Greek songs illustrate the conversion of the Armatole into the +Klepht in the age preceding the Greek revolution. Thus, in the fine ballad +called "The Tomb of Demos," which Goethe has translated, the dying man +says-- + +[Transcriber's Note: The following has been transliterated from the Greek] + + Kai pherte ton pneumatikon na m' exomologaisae + na tun eipo ta krimata osa cho kamomena + trianta chroni armatolos, c'eicosi echo klephtaes. + +"Bring the priest that he may shrive me; that I may tell him the sins that +I have committed, thirty years an Armatole and twenty years a Klepht." +--Fauriel, Chants Populaires, i. 56. + +[352] Finlay, Greece under Ottoman Domination, p. 284. + +[353] Kanitz, Donau-Bulgarien, i. 123. + +[354] Literally, _Interpreter_; the old theory of the Turks being that +in their dealings with foreign nations they had only to receive petitions, +which required to be translated into Turkish. + +[355] Zallonos, [Transliterated Greek] Pragmateia peri ton phanarioton, +p. 71. Kagalnitchau, La Walachie, i. 371. + +[356] A French translation of the Autobiography of Koraes, along with his +portrait, will be found in the Lettres Inedites de Coray, Paris, 1877. The +vehicle of expression usually chosen by Koraes for addressing his +countrymen was the Preface (written in modern Greek) to the edition of an +ancient author. The second half of the Preface to the Politics of +Aristotle, 1822, is a good specimen of his political spirit and manner. It +was separately edited by the Swiss scholar, Orelh, with a translation, for +the benefit of the German Philhellenes. Among the principal linguistic +prefaces are those to Heliodorus 1804, and the Prodromos, or introduction, +to the series of editions called Bibliotheca Graeca, begun in 1805, and +published at the expense of the brothers Zosimas of Odessa Most of the +editions published by Koraes bear on their title page a statement of the +patriotic purpose of the work, and indicate the persons who bore the +expense. The edition of the Ethics, published immediately after the +massacre of Chios, bears the affecting words 'At the expense of those who +have so cruelly suffered in Chios.' The costly form of these editions, some +of which contain fine engravings, seems somewhat inappropriate for works +intended for national instruction. Koraes, however, was not in a hurry. He +thought, at least towards the close of his life, that the Greeks ought to +have gone through thirty years more of commercial and intellectual +development before they drew the sword. They would in that case, he +believed, have crushed Turkey by themselves and have prevented the Greek +kingdom from becoming the sport of European diplomacy. Much miscellaneous +information on Greek affairs before 1820 (rather from the Phanariot point +of view) will be found, combined with literary history in the Cours de +Litterature Grecque of Rhizos Neroulos, 1827. The more recent treatise of R +Rhankabes on the same subject (also in French, Paris, 1877) exhibits what +appears to be characteristic of the modern Greeks, the inability to +distinguish between mere passable performances and really great work. + +[357] Zinkeisen, Geschichte des Osmanischen Reiches, v. 959. + +[358] Koraes, Memoire sur l'etat actual de la civilization de la Grece: +republished in the Lettres Inedites, p. 464. This memoir, read by Koraes to +a learned society in Paris, in January, 1803, is one of the most luminous +and interesting historical sketches ever penned. + +[359] [Greek text: Didaskalia Patrikae], by, or professing to be by, +Anthimos, Patriarch of Jerusalem, and printed "at the expense of the Holy +Sepulchre," p. 13. This curious work, in which the Patriarch at last breaks +out into doggrel, has found its way to the British Museum. It was answered +by Koraes. For the effect of Rhegas' songs on the people, see Fauriel, ii. +18. Mr. Finlay seems to be mistaken in calling Anthimos' book an answer to +the tract of Eugenios Bulgaris on religious toleration. That was written +about thirty years before. + +[360] Leake, Travels in Northern Greece, ch, v. 36, 37. + +[361] Mendelssohn Bartholdy, Geschichte Griechenlands, i. 145, from the +papers of Hypsilanti's brother. Otherwise in Prokesch-Osten, Abfall der +Griechen, i. 13. + +[362] Cordon, Greek Revolution, i. 96. + +[363] B. and F, State Papers, viii. 1203. + +[364] Finlay, i. 187; Gordon, i. 203; K. Mendelssohn, Geschichte +Griechenlands, i. 191; Prokesch-Osten, Abfall der Griechen, i. 20. + +[365] Metternich, iii. 622, 717; Prokewh-Ostett, i. 231, 303. B. and F. +State Papers, viii. 1247. + +[366] Records, Continent, iii. + +[367] Castlereagh, viii. 16; Metternich, iii. 504. + +[368] Kolokotrones, [Transliterated Greek] Aiaegaesis Symbanton, p. 82; +Tricoupis, [Transliterated Greek] Historia, i. 61, 92. + +[369] Gordon, i. 388; Finlay, i. 330; Mendelssohn, i. 269. + +[370] Gordon ii. 138. The news of this catastrophe reached Metternich at +Ischl on July 30th. "Prince Metternich was taking an excursion, in which, +unfortunately I could not accompany him. I at once sent Francis after him +with this important letter, which he received at a spot where the name of +the Capitan Pasha had probably never been heard before. The prince soon +came back to me; and (_pianissimo_ in order that the friends of Greece +might not hear it) we congratulate one another on the event, which may very +well prove _le commencement de la fin_ for the Greek insurrection." +(Gentz.) + +[371] Prokesch-Osten, i. 253, iv. 63. B. and F. State Papers, xii. 902. +Stapleton, Canning, p. 496 Metternich, 127. Wellington, N.S. ii. 372-396. + +[372] Korff, Accession of Nicholas, p. 253; Herzen, Russische Verschwoerung, +p. 106; Mendelssohn, i. 396. Schnitzler, Histoire Intime, i. 195. + +[373] B. and F. State Papers, xiv. 630; Metternich, iv. 161, 212, 320, 372; +Willington, N.S., ii. 85, 148, 244; Gentz, D.I., iii. 315. + +[374] B. and F. State Papers, xiv. 632; xvii. 20; Wellington, N.S., iv. 57. + +[375] Parl. Deb., May 11, 1877. Nothing can be more misleading than to say +that Canning never contemplated the possibility of armed action because a +clause in the Treaty of 1827 made the formal stipulation that the +contracting Powers would not "take part in the hostilities between the +contending parties." How, except by armed force, could the Allies "prevent, +in so far as might be in their power, all collision between the contending +parties," which, in the very same clause, they undertook to do? And what +was the meaning of the stipulation that they should "transmit instructions +to their Admirals conformable to these provisions"? Wellington himself, +_before_ the battle of Navarino, condemned the Treaty of London on the +very ground that it "specified means of compulsion which were neither more +nor less than measures of war;" and he protested against the statement that +the treaty arose directly out of the Protocol of St. Petersburg, which was +his own work. Wellington, N.S., iv. 137, 221. + +[376] Bourchier's Codrington, ii. 6[***]. Admiralty Despatches, Nov. 10, +1807, Parl. Deb., Feb. 14, 1828. + +[377] Rosen, Geschichte der Tuerkei, i. 57. + +[378] Moltke, Russisch-Turkische Feldzug, p. 226. Rosen, i. 67. + +[379] Viel-Castel, xx. 16. Russia was to have had the Danubian Provinces; +Austria was to have had Bosnia and Servia; Prussia was to have had Saxony +and Holland; the King of Holland was to have reigned at Constantinople. + +[380] Hertslet, Map of Europe by Treaty, ii. 813. Rosen, i. 108. + +[381] Wellington, N. S, iv. 297. + +[382] Mendelssohn, Graf Capodistrias, p. 64. + +[383] B. and F. State Papers, xvii. p. 132. Prokesch-Osten, v. 136. + +[384] Stockmar, i. 80; Mendelssohn; Capodistrias, p. 272. B. and F. State +Papers, xvii. 453. + +[385] Viel-Castel, xix. 574. Duvergier de Hauranne, x. 85. + +[386] Proces des ex-Ministres, i. 189. + +[387] Lafayette, vi. 383. Marmont, viii. 238. Dupin, Revolution de Juillet, +p. 7. Odilon Barrot, i. 105. Sarrans, Lafayette, i. 217. Berard, Revolution +de 1830, p. 60. Hillebrand, Die Juli-Revolution, p. 87. + +[388] Juste, Revolution Belge, i. 85. Congres National, i. 134. + +[389] Wellington, N.S. vii. 309. B. and F. State Papers, xviii. 761. +Metternich, v. 44. Hillebrand, Geschichte Frankreichs, i. 171. Stockmar, i. +143. Bulwers Palmerston, ii. 5. Hertslet, Map of Europe, iii. 81. + +[390] Smitt, Geschichte des Polnischen Aufstandes, i. 112. Spazier, +Geschichte des Aufstandes, i. 177. Leiewel, Histoire de Pologne, i. 300. + +[391] Leroy-Beaulieu, Milutine, p. 199; L'Empire des Tsars, i. 380. +Leiewel, Considerations, p. 317. + +[392] Bianchi, Ducati Estensi, i. 54. La Farina, v. 241. Farini, i. 34. + +[393] Bianchi, Diplomazia, iii. 48. Metternich, iv. 121. Hillebrand, +Geschichte Frankreichs, i. 206. Haussonville, i. 32. B. and F. State +Papers, xix. 1429. Guizot, Memoires, ii. 290. + +[394] Ilse, Untersuchungen, p. 262. Metternich, v. 347. Biedermann, +Dreissig Jahre, i. 6. + +[395] Mazzini, Scritti, iii. 310. Simoni, Conspirations Mazziniennes, p. +53. Metternich, v. 526. B. and F. State Papers, xxiv. 979. + +[396] B. and F. State Papers, xviii. 196. Palmerston, i. 300. + +[397] "La Reine Isabelle est la Revolution incarnee dans sa forme la plus +dangereuse; Don Carlos represente le principe Monarchique aux prises avec +la Revolution pure." Metternich, v. 615. B. and F. State Papers, xviii. +1365; xxii. 1394. Baumgarten, iii. 65. + +[398] Hertslet, Map of Europe, ii. 941. Miraflores, Memorias, i. 39. +Guizot, iv. 86. Palmerston ii. 180. + +[399] Essai historique sur les Provinces Basques, p. 58. W. Humboldt, Werke +iii. 213. + +[400] Henningsen, Campaign with Zumalacarregui, i. 93. Burgos, Anales, ii. +110. Baumgarten, iii. 257. + +[401] Rosen, i. 158. Prokesch von Osten, Kleine Schriften, vii. 56. Mehmed +Ali, p. 17. Hillebrand, i. 514 Metternich, v. 481. B. and F. State Papers, +xx. 1176; xxii. 140. + +[402] Palmerston understood little about the real condition of the Ottoman +Empire, and thought that with ten years of peace it might again become a +respectable Power. "All that we hear about the decay of the Turkish Empire +and its being a dead body or a sapless trunk, and so forth, is pure and +unadulterated nonsense." Bulwer's Palmerston, ii. 299. + +[403] Hertslet, Map of Europe, ii. 1008. Rosen, ii. 3. Guizot, v. 188. +Prokesch-Osten, Mehmed Ali, p. 89. Palmerston, ii. 356. Hillebrand, ii. +357. Greville Memoirs, 2nd part, vol. i. 297. + +[404] "Sie sollen ihn nicht haben + Den freien Deutschen Rhein." + +By Becker; answered by De Musset's "Nous avons eu votre Rhin Allemand." The +words of the much finer song "Die Wacht am Rhein" were also written at this +time--by Schneckenburger, a Wuertemberg man; but the music by which they are +known was not composed till 1854. + +[405] Farini, i. 153. Azeglio, Corresp. Politique, p. 24; Casi di Romagna, +p. 47. + +[406] Down to 1827 not only was all land inherited by nobles free from +taxation, but any taxable land purchased by a noble thereupon became +tax-free. The attempt of the Government to abolish this latter injustice +evoked a storm of anger in the Diet of 1825, and still more in the country +assemblies, some of the latter even resolving that such law, if passed, fey +the Diet, would be null and void. + +[407] Horvath, Fuenfundzwanzig Jahre, i. 408. Springer, i. 466. Gerando, +Esprit Public, 173. Kossuth, Gessammelte Werke, i. 29. Beschwerden und +Klagen der Slaven in Ungarn, 39. + +[408] Das Polen-Attentat, 1846, p. 203. Verhaeltnisse in Galizien, p. 57. +Briefe eines Polnischen Edelmannes, p. 31. Metternich, vii. 196. Cracow, +which had been made an independent Republic by the Congress of Vienna, was +now annexed by Austria with the consent of Russia and Prussia, and against +the protests of England and France. + +[409] Reden des Koenigs Friedrich Wilhelm IV., p. 17. Ranke's F. W, IV. in +Allg. Deutsche Biog. Biedermann, Dreissig Jahre, i. 186. + +[410] Guizot, viii. 101, Palmerston, iii. 194. Parl. Papers, 1847. Martin's +Prince Consort, i. 341. + +[411] Metternich, vii. 538, 603; Vitzthum, Berlin und Wien, 1845-62, p. 78; +Kossuth Werke (1850), ii. 78; Pillersdorff, Rueckblicke, p. 22; Reschauer, +Das Jahr 1848, i. 191; Springer, Geschichte Oesterreichs, ii. 185; Iranyi +et Chassin, Revolution de Hongrie, i. 128. + +[412] Metternich, viii. 181. The animation of his remarks on all sorts of +points in English life is wonderful. After a halt at Brussels and at his +Johannisburg estate Metternich returned to Vienna in 1852, and, though not +restored to office, resumed his great position in society. He lived through +the Crimean War, on which he wrote numerous memoranda, for whose use it +does not appear. Even on the outbreak of war with France in 1859 he was +still busy with his pen. He survived long enough to hear of the battle of +Magenta, but was spared the sorrow of witnessing the creation of the +Kingdom of Italy. He died on the 11th of June, 1859, in his eighty-seventh +year. Metternich was not the only statesman present at the Congress of +Vienna who lived to see the second Napoleonic Empire. Nesselrode, the +Russian Chancellor, lived till 1862; Czartoryski, who was Foreign Minister +of Russia at the time of the battle of Austerlitz, till 1861. + +[413] Adlerstein, Archiv des Ungarischen Ministeriums, i. 27; Iranyi et +Chassin, i. 184; Springer, ii. 219. + +[414] Casati Nuove Rivelazioni, ii. 72. Schoenhals, Campagnes d'ltalie de +1848 et 1849 p. 72. Cattaneo, Insurrezione di Milano, p. 29. Parl. Pap. +1849, lvii. (2) 210, 333. Senneidawind, Feldzug in 1848, i. 30. + +[415] Manin, Documents laisses, i. 106. Perlbach, Manin, p. 14. Contarini, +Memoriale Veneto, p. 10. Rovani, Manin, p. 25. Parliamentary Papers, 1849, +lvii. (a) 267. + +[416] Bianchi, Diplomazia Europea, v. 183. Farini, Stato Romano, ii. 16. +Parl. Papers, 1849, lvii. 285, 297, 319. Pasolini, Memorie, p. 91. + +[417] Die Berliner Maerz-Revolution, p. 55. Ausfuehrliche Beschreibung, p. 3. +Amtliche Berichte, p. 16. Stahr, Preussische Revolution, i. 91. S. Stern, +Geschichte des Deutschen Volkes, p. 58. Stern was an eye-witness at Berlin, +though not generally a good authority. + +[418] "Preussen geht fortan in Deutschland auf." Reden Friedrich Wilhelms, +p. 9. In conversation with Bassermann Frederick William at a later time +described his ride through Berlin as "a comedy which he had been made to +play." The bombast at any rate was all his own. + +[419] Droysen und Samwer, Schleswig-Holstein, p. 220. Bunsen, Memoir on +Schleswig-Holstein, p. 25. Schleswig-Holstein, Uebersichtliche Darstellung, +p 51. On the other side, Noten zur Beleuchtung, p. 12. + +[420] Verhandlungen der National-versammlung, i. 25. Biedermann Dreissig +Jahre, i. 278. Radowitz, Werke, ii. 36. + +[421] Actes du Gouvernement Provisoire, p. 12. Louis Blanc, Revelations +Historiques, i. 135. Gamier Pages, Revolution de 1848, vi 108, viii 148. +Emile Thomas, Histoire des Ateliers Nationaux, p. 93. + +[422] Barret, Memoires, ii. 103. Caussidiere, Memoires, p. 117. Gamier +Pages, x. 419. Normanby, Year of Revolution, i. 389. Granier de Cassagnac, +Chute de Louis Philippe, i. 359. De la Gorce, Seconde Republique, i. 273. +Falloux, Memoires, i. 328. + +[423] Oeuvres de Napoleon III., iii. 13, 24. Granier de Cassagnac, ii. 16. +Jerrold, Napoleon III., ii. 393. + +[424] Vitzthum, Wien, p. 108. Springer, ii. 293. Pillersdorff, Rueckblicke, +p. 68; Nachlass, p. 118. Reschauer, ii. 176. Dunder, October Revolution, p. +5. Ficquelmont, Aufklaerungen, p. 65. + +[425] Schoenhals, p. 117. Farini, ii. 9. Parl. Pap., 1849, lvii. 352. + +[426] Ficquelmont p. 6. Pillersdorfif, Nachlass, 93. Helfert, iv. 142. +Schfoenhais, p. 177. Parliamentary Papers, _id_. 332, 472, 597. Contarini, +p. 67. Azeglio, Operazioni del Durando, p. 6. Manin, Documents, i. 289. +Bianchi, Diplomazia, v. 257. Pasolini, p. 100. + +[427] Parliamentary Papers, 1849 lviii p. 128. Venice refused to +acknowledge the armistice, and detached itself from Sardinia, restoring +Manin to power. + +[428] Slavonia itself was attached to Croatia; Dalmatia also was claimed as +a member of this triple Kingdom under the Hungarian Crown in virtue of +ancient rights, though since its annexation in 1797 it had been governed +directly from Vienna, and in 1848 was represented in the Reichstag of +Vienna, not in that of Pesth. + +[429] The real meaning of the Charters is, however, contested. Springer, +ii. 281. Adlerstein, Archiv, i. 166. Helfert, ii. 255. Iranyi et Chassin, +i. 236. Die Serbische Wolwodschaftsfrage, p. 7. + +[430] But see Kossuth, Schriften (1880, ii. 215), for a conversation +between Jellacic and Batthyany, said to have been narrated to Kossuth by +the latter. If authentic, this certainly proves Jellacic to have used the +Slavic agitation from the first solely for Austrian ends. See also +Vitzthuin, p. 207. + +[431] Adlerstein, Archiv, i. 146. 156. Klapka, Erinnerungen, p. 30. Iranyi +et Chassin, i. 344. Serbische Bewegung, p. 106. + +[432] Iranyi et Chassin, ii. 56. Codex der neuen Gesetze (Pesth), i. 7. + +[433] Adlerstein, ii. 296. Helfert, Geschichte Oesterreichs, i. 79, ii. +192. Dunder, p. 77. Springer, ii. 520. Vitzthum, p. 143. Kossuth, Schriften +(1881), ii. 284. Reschauer, ii. 563. Pillersdorff, Nachlass, p. 163. Iranyi +et Chassin, ii. 98. + +[434] Codex der neuen Gesetze, i. 37. Helfert, iv. (3) 321. + +[435] Revolutionskrieg in Siebenburgen i. 30. Helfert, ii. 207. Bratiano et +Iranyi, Lettres Hongro-Roumaines, Adlerstein, ii. 105. + +[436] Klapka, Erinnerungen, p. 56. Helfert, iv. 199; Goergei, Leben und +Wirken, i. 145. Adlerstein, iii. 576, 648. + +[437] Helfert, iv. (2) 326. Klapka, War in Hungary, i. 23. Iranyi et +Chassin, ii. 534. Goergei, ii. 54. + +[438] Klapka, War, ii. 106. Erinnerungen, 58. Goergei, ii. 378. Kossuth, +Schriften (1880), ii. 291. Codex der neuen Gesetze, i. 75, 105. + +[439] Farini, ii. 404. Parl. Pap., 1849. lvii. 607; lviii. (2) 117. +Bianchi, Diplomazia, vi. 67. Gennarelli, Sventure, p. 29. Pasolini, p. 139. + +[440] Schoenhals, p. 332. Parl. Pap., 1849, lviii. (2) 216. Bianchi, +Politica Austriaca, p. 134. Lamarmora, Un Episodie, p. 175. Portafogli ci +Ramorino, p. 41. Ramorino was condemned to death, and executed. + +[441] Garibaldi, Epistolario, i. 33. Del Vecchio, L'assedio di Roma, p. 30. +Vaillant, Siege de Rome, p. 12. Bianchi, Diplomazia, vi. 213. Guerzoni, +Garibaldi, i. 266. Granier de Cassagnac, ii. 59. Lesseps, Memoire, p. 61. +Barrot, iii 191, Discours de Napoleon 3rd, p. 38. + +[442] Manin, Documents, ii. 340. Perlbach, Manin, p. 37. Gennarelli, +Governo Pontificio, i. 32. Contarini, p. 224. + +[443] Verhandlungen der National Versammlung. i. 576 Radowitz, Werke, iii. +369. Briefwechsel Friedrich Wilhelms, p. 205. Biedermann, Dreissig Jahre, +i. 295. + +[444] Verhandlungen der National Versammlung, ii. 1877, 2185. Herzog Ernst +II., Ausmeinem Leben, i. 313. Biedermann, i. 306. Beseier, Erlebtes, p. 68. +Waitz, Friede mit Daenemark. Radowitz, iii. 406. + +[445] Briefwechsel Friedrich Wilhelms, p. 184. Wagener, Erlebtes, p. 28. +Stahr, Preussische Revolution, i. 453. + +[446] _Seine Bundespflichten:_ an ambiguous expression that might mean +either its duties as an ally or its duties as a member of the German +Federation. The obscurity was probably intentional. + +[447] Verhandlungen der National Versammlung, vi. 4225. Haym, Deutsche +National Versammlung, ii. 112. Radowitz, iii. 459. Helfert, iv. 62. + +[448] Verhandlungen, viii. 6093. Beseler, p. 82. Helfert, iv. (3) 390, +Haym, ii. 317, Radowitz, v. 477. + +[449] Briefwechsel Friedrich Wilhelms, pp. 233, 269. Beseler, 87. +Biedermann, i. 389. Wagener, Politik Friedrich Wilhelm IV., p. 56. Ernst +II., i. 329. + +[450] Verhandlungen, etc., ix. 6695, 6886. Haym, in. 185. Barnberger, +Erlebnisse, p. 6. + +[451] Verhandlungen zu Erfurt, i. 114; ii. 143. Biedermann, i. 469. +Radowitz, ii. 138. + +[452] Der Fuersten Kongress, p. 13. Reden Friedrich Wilhelms, iv pp. 55, 69. +Konferenz der Verbundeten, 1850, pp. 26, 53. Beust, Erinnerungen, i. 115, +Ernst II., i. 525. Duncker, Vier Monate, p. 41. + +[453] Ernst II., i. 377. Hertslet, Map of Europe, ii. 1106, 1129, 1151. +Parl. Papers, 1864, lxiii., p. 29; 1804, lxv., pp. 30, 187. + +[454] Maupas, Memoires, i. 176. Oeuvres de Napoleon III., iii. 271. Barrot, +iv. 21. Granier de Cassagnac, Chute de Louis Philippe, ii. 128; Recit +complet, p. 1. Jerrold, Napoleon III., iii. 203. Tocqueville, Corresp. ii. +176. + +[455] Stockman, 396. Eastern Papers (_i.e._, Parliamentary Papers, +1854, vol. 71), part 6. Malmesbury, Memoirs of an ex-Minister, i. 402; the +last probably inaccurate. Diplomatic Study of the Crimean War, i. 11. This +work is a Russian official publication, and, though loose and +untrustworthy, is valuable as showing the Russian official view. + +[456] Ashley's Palmerston, ii. 142. Lane Poole, Stratford de Redcliffe, ii. +191. + +[457] Eastern Papers, i. 55. Diplomatic Study, i. 121. + +[458] Eastern Papers, v. 2, 19. + +[459] Eastern Papers, i. 102. Admitted in Diplomatic Study, i. 163. + +[460] He writes thus, April 5, 1851:--"The great game of improvement is +altogether up for the present. It is impossible for me to conceal that the +main object of my stay here is almost hopeless." Even Palmerston, in the +rare moments when he allowed his judgment to master his prepossessions on +this subject, expressed the same view. He wrote on November 24, 1850, +warning Reschid Pasha "the Turkish Empire is doomed to fall by the timidity +and irresolution of its Sovereign and of its Ministers; and it is evident +we shall ere long have to consider what other arrangements may be set up in +its place." Stratford left Constantinople on leave in June, 1852, but +resigned his Embassy altogether in January, 1853. (Lane Poole, Life of +Stratford de Redcliffe, ii. 112, 215.) + +[461] Eastern Papers, i. 253, 339. Lane Poole, Stratford, ii. 248. + +[462] Palmerston had accepted the office of Home Secretary, but naturally +exercised great influence in foreign affairs. The Foreign Secretary was +Lord Clarendon. + +[463] Eastern Papers, i. 210, ii. 116. Ashley's Palmerston, ii. 23. + +[464] Eastern Papers, ii. 23. + +[465] Eastern Papers, ii. 86, 91, 103. + +[466] Eastern Papers, ii. 203, 227, 299. + +[467] Treaty of April 20, 1854, and Additional Article, Eastern Papers, ix. +61. The Treaty between Austria and Prussia was one of general defensive +alliance, covering also the case of Austria incurring attack through an +advance into the Principalities. In the event of Russia annexing the +Principalities or sending its troops beyond the Balkans the alliance was to +be offensive. + +[468] Briefwechsel F. Wilhelms mit Bunsen, p. 310. Martin's Prince Consort, +iii. 39. On November 20, after the Turks had begun war, the King of Prussia +wrote thus to Bunsen (the italics, capitals, and exclamations are his own): +"All direct help which England _in unchristian folly!!!!!!_ gives TO +ISLAM AGAINST CHRISTIANS! will have (besides God's avenging judgment [hear! +hear!]) no other effect than to bring what is now Turkish territory at a +somewhat later period under Russian dominion" (Briefwechsel, p. 317). The +reader may think that the insanity to which Frederick William succumbed was +already mastering him; but the above is no rare specimen of his epistolary +style. + +[469] The Treaty of alliance between France and England, to which Prussia +was asked to accede, contained, however, a clause pledging the contracting +parties "under no circumstance to seek to obtain from the war any advantage +to themselves." + +[470] Eastern Papers, viii. I. + +[471] Eastern Papers, xi. 3. Ashley's Palmerston, ii. 60. For the +navigation of the mouths of the Danube, see Diplomatic Study, ii. 39. +Russia, which had been in possession of the mouths of the Danube since the +Treaty of Adrianople, and had undertaken to keep the mouths clear, had +allowed the passage to become blocked and had otherwise prevented traffic +descending, in order to keep the Black Sea trade in its own hands. + +[472] See, however, Burgoyne's Letter to the _Times_, August 4, 1868, +in Kinglake, iv. 465. Rousset, Guerre de Crimee, i. 280. + +[473] Statements of Raglan, Lucan, Cardigan; Kinglake, v. 108, 402. + +[474] On the death of Nicholas, the King of Prussia addressed the following +lecture to the unfortunate Bunsen:--"You little thought that, at the very +moment when you were writing to me, one of the noblest of men, one of the +grandest forms in history, one of the truest hearts, and at the same time +one of the greatest rulers of this narrow world, was called from faith to +sight. I thank God on my knees that He deemed me worthy to be, in the best +sense of the word, his [Nicholas'] friend, and to remain true to him. You, +dear Bunsen, thought differently of him, and you will now painfully confess +this before your conscience, most painfully of all the truth (which all +your letters in these late bad times have unfortunately shown me but too +plainly), that _you hated him_. You hated him, not as a man, but as +the representative of a principle, that of violence. If ever, redeemed like +him through simple faith in Christ's blood, you see him in eternal peace, +then remember what I now write to you: '_You will beg his pardon_. +Even here, my dear friend, may the blessing of repentance be granted to +you."--Briefwechsel, p. 325. Frederick William seems to have forgotten to +send the same pious wishes to the Poles in Siberia. + +[475] Parliamentary Papers, 1854-5, vol. 55, p. 1, Dec. 2, 1854. Ashley's +Palmerston, ii. 84. + +[476] Eastern Papers, Part 13, 1. + +[477] Kinglake, vii. 21. Rousset, ii. 35, 148. + +[478] Diplomatic Study, ii. 361. Martin, Prince Consort, iii. 394. + +[479] Prussia was admitted when the first Articles had been settled, and it +became necessary to revise the Treaty of July, 1841, of which Prussia had +been one of the signatories. + +[480] "In the course of the deliberation, whenever our [Russian] +plenipotentiaries found themselves in the presence of insurmountable +difficulties, they appealed to the personal intervention of this sovereign +[Napoleon], and had only to congratulate themselves on the +result."--Diplomatic Study, ii. 377. + +[481] Three pages of promises. Eastern Papers, xvii. One was kept +faithfully. "To accomplish these objects, means shall be sought to profit +by the science, the art, _and the funds_ of Europe." One of the +drollest of the prophecies of that time is the congratulatory address of +the Missionaries to Lord Stratford de Redcliffe, _id_. 1882.--"The +Imperial Hatti-sheriff has convinced us that our fond expectations are +likely to be realised. The light will shine upon those who have long sat in +darkness; and blest by social prosperity and religious freedom, the +millions of Turkey will, we trust, be seen ere long sitting peacefully +under their own vine and fig-tree." So they were, and with poor Lord +Stratford's fortune, among others, in their pockets. + +[482] All verbatim from the Treaty. Parl. Papers, 1856, vol 61, p. 1. + +[483] Martin, Prince Consort, iii. 452. Poole, Stratford, ii. 356. + +[484] Berti, Cavour avanti 1848, p. 110. La Rive, Cavour, p. 58. Cavour, +Lettere (ed. Chuala), introd. p. 73. + +[485] Cavour, Lettere (Chiala), ii. introd. p. 187. Guerzoni, Garibaldi, i. +412. Manin, the Ex-President of Venice, now in exile, declared from this +time for the House of Savoy. Garibaldi did the same. + +[486] Cavour, Lettere (Chiala), ii. introd. pp. 289, 324; iii. introd. p. +i. Bianchi, Diplomazia, vii. 1, Mazade, Cavour, p. 187, Massari, La +Marmora, p. 204. + +[487] "In mezzo alle piu angosciose crisi politiche, esclamava nelle +solitudine delle sue stanze; 'Perisca il mio nome, perisca la mia fama, +purche l'Italia sia,'" Artom (Cavour's secretary), Cavour in Parlameuto: +introd. p. 46. + +[488] La Farina Epistolaria, ii. 56, 81, 137, 426. The interview with +Garibaldi; Cavour, Letiere, id. introd. p. 297. Garibaldi, Epistolario, i. +55. + +[489] Cavour, Lettere (Chiala), iii. introd. p. 32. Bianchi, Diplomazia, +viii. II. The statement of Napoleon III. to Lord Cowley, in Martin Prince +Consort, v. 31, that there was no Treaty, is untrue. + +[490] Bianchi, Politique de Cavour, p. 328, where is Cavour's indignant +letter to Napoleon. The last paragraph of this seems to convey a veiled +threat to publish the secret negotiations. + +[491] Cavour, Lettere, iii. introd. p. 115; iii. 29. Bianchi, Politique de +Cavour, p. 333. Bianchi, Diplomazia, vii. 61. Massari, Cavour, p. 314. +Parliamentary Papers, 1859, xxxii. 204, 262. Merimee, Lettres a Panizzi, i. +21. Martin, Prince Consort, iv. 427. + +[492] La Farina, Epistolaria, ii. 172. Parliamentary Papers, 1859, xxxiii. +391, 470. + +[493] Cavour, Lettere, iii. introd. 212, iii. 107. Bianchi, Politique de +Cavour, p. 319. Bianchi, Diplomazia, viii. 145, 198. Massari, Vittorio +Emanuele, ii. 32. Kossuth, Memories p. 394. Parl. Pap. 1859, xxxii. 63, +1860, lxviii. 7. La Farina Epist, ii. 190. Ollivier, L'Eglise et l'Etat, +ii. 452. + +[494] Arrivabene, Italy under Victor Emmanuel, i. 268. + +[495] Cavour, Lettere, iii. introd. 301. Bianchi, viii. 180. Garibaldi, +Epist., i. 79. Guerzoni, i. 491. Reuchlin, iv. 410. + +[496] Cavour, Lettere, iv. introd. 20. Bianchi, Politique, p. 354. Bianchi, +Diplomazia, viii. 256. Parliamentary Papers, 1860, lxvii. 203; lxviii. 53. + +[497] Cavour in Parlamento, p. 536. + +[498] Garibaldi, Epist., i. 97. Persano, Diario, i. 14. Le Farina, Epist., +ii. 324. Guerzoni, ii. 23. Parliamentary Papers, 1860, lxviii. 2. Mundy, +H.M.S. _Hannibal_ at Palermo, p. 133. + +[499] Cavour, Lettere, iii. introd. 269. La Farina, Epist., ii. 336. +Bianchi, Politique, p. 366. Persano, Diario, i. 50, 72, 96. + +[500] Bianchi, Politique, p. 377. Persano, ii. p. 1-102. Persano sent his +Diary in MS. to Azeglio, and asked his advice on publishing it. Azeglio +referred to Cavour's saying, "If we did for ourselves what we are doing for +Italy, we should be sad blackguards," and begged Persano to let his secrets +be secrets, saying that since the partition of Poland no confession of such +"colossal blackguardism" had been published by any public man. + +[501] Bianchi, Politique, p. 383. Persano, iii. 61. Bianchi, Diplomazia, +viii. 337, Garibaldi, Epist., i. 127. + +[502] "Le Roi repondit tout court: 'C'est impossible.'" Cavour to his +ambassador at London, Nov. 16, in Bianchi, Politique, p. 386. La Farina, +Epist., ii. 438. Persano, iv. 44, Guerzoni, ii. 212. + +[503] Cavour in Parlamento, p. 630. Azeglio, Correspondance Politique, p. +180. La Rive, p. 313. Berti, Cavour avanti 1848, p. 302. + +[504] "Le comte le reconnu, lui serra la main et dit: 'Frate, frate, libera +chiesa in libero stato' Ce furent ses dernieres paroles." Account of the +death of Cavour by his niece, Countess Alfieri, in La Rive, Cavour, p. 319. + +[505] Berichte uber der Militair etat, p. 669. Schulthess, Europaischer +Geschichts Kalender, 1862, p. 122. + +[506] Poschinger, Preussen im Bundestag ii. 69, 97; iv. 178. Hahn, +Bismarck, i. 608. + +[507] Hahn, Fuerst Bismarck, i. 66. This work is a collection of documents, +speeches, and letters not only by Bismarck himself but on all the principal +matters in which Bismarck was concerned. It is perhaps, from the German +point of view, the most important repertory of authorities for the period +1862-1885. + +[508] Sammlung der Staatsacten Oesterreichs (1861), pp. 2, 33. Drei Jahre +Verfassungstreit, p. 107. + +[509] Sammlung der Staatsacten, p. 89. Der Ungarische Reichstag 1861, pp. +3, 194, 238. Arnold Forster, Life of Deak, p. 141. + +[510] Celestin, Russland, p. 3. Leroy-Beaulieu, L'Empire des Tsars, i. 400. +Homme d'Etat Russe, p. 73. Wallace, Russia, p. 485. + +[511] Raczynski, Memoires sur la Pologne, p. 14. B. and F. State Papers, +1862-63, p. 769. + +[512] Leroy-Beaulieu, Homme d'Etat Russe, p. 259. + +[513] Hahn, i. 112. Verhandl des Preuss, Abgeord. ueber Polen, p. 45. + +[514] Parliamentary Papers, 1864, vol. lxiv. pp. 28, 263. Hahn, Bismarck, +i. 165. + +[515] From Rechberg's despatch of Feb 28, 1863 (in Hahn, i. 84), apparently +quoting actual words uttered by Bismarck. Bismarck's account of the +conversation (id. 80) tones it down to a demand that Austria should not +encroach on Prussia's recognised joint-leadership in Germany. + +[516] B. and F. State Papers, 1863-4, p. 173. Beust, Erinnerungen, i. 136. + +[517] Bismarck's note of July 29th, 1870, in Hahn, i. 506, describing +Napoleon's Belgian project, which dated from the time when he was himself +ambassador at Paris in 1862, gives this as the explanation of Napoleon's +policy in 1864. The Commercial Treaty with Prussia and friendly personal +relations with Bismarck also influenced Napoleon's views. See Bismarck's +speech of Feb. 21st, 1879, on this subject, in Hahn, iii. 599. + +[518] Hahn, Bismarck, i. 271, 318. Oesterreichs Kaempfe in 1866, i. 8. + +[519] B. and F. State Papers, 1864-65, p. 460. + +[520] La Marmora, Un po piu di luce, pp. 109, 146, Jacini, Due Anni, p. +154. Hahn, i. 377. In the first draft of the Treaty Italy was required to +declare war not only on Austria but on all German Governments which should +join it. King William, who had still some compunction in calling in Italian +arms against the Fatherland, struck out these words. + +[521] La Marmora, Un po piu di luce, p. 204. Hahn, i. 402. + +[522] Hahn, Bismarck, i. 425. Hahn, Zwei Jahre, p. 60. Oesterreichs Kaempfe, +i. 30. + +[523] Discours de Napoleon III., p. 456. On May 11th, Nigra, Italian +ambassador at Paris, reported that Napoleon's ideas on the objects to be +attained by a Congress were as follows:--Venetia to Italy, Silesia to +Austria; the Danish Duchies and other territory in North Germany to +Prussia; the establishment of several small States on the Rhine under +French protection; the dispossessed German princes to be compensated in +Roumania. La Marmora, p. 228. Napoleon III. was pursuing in a somewhat +altered form the old German policy of the Republic and the Empire--namely, +the balancing of Austria and Prussia against one another, and the +establishment of a French protectorate over the group of secondary States. + +[524] Oesterreichs Kaempfe, ii. 341. Prussian Staff, Campaign of 1866 +(Hozier), p. 167. + +[525] Hahn, i. 476. Benedetti, Ma Mission en Prusse, p. 186. Reuchlin, v. +457. Massari, La Marmora, p. 350. + +[526] Hahn, i. 501, 505. + +[527] Benedetti, p. 191. Hahn, i. 508; ii. 328, 635. See also La Marmora's +Un po piu di luce, p. 242, and his Segreti di Stato, p. 274. Govone's +despatches strongly confirm the view that Bismarck was more than a mere +passive listener to French schemes for the acquisition of Belgium. That he +originated the plan is not probable; that he encouraged it seems to me +quite certain, unless various French and Italian documents unconnected with +one another are forgeries from beginning to end. On the outbreak of the war +of 1870 Bismarck published the text of the draft-treaty discussed in 1866 +providing for an offensive and defensive alliance between France and +Prussia, and the seizure of Belgium by France. The draft was in Benedetti's +handwriting, and written on paper of the French Embassy. Benedetti stated +in answer that he had made the draft at Bismarck's dictation. This might +seem very unlikely were it not known that the draft of the Treaty between +Prussia and Italy in 1866 was actually so written down by Barral, the +Italian Ambassador, at Bismarck's dictation. + +[528] Regelung der Verhaeltnisse, p. 4. Ausgleich mit Ungarn, p. 9. + +[529] Hungary retained a Ministry of National Defence for its Reserve +Forces, and a Finance Ministry for its own separate finance. Thus the +Ministry of Foreign Affairs was the only one of the three common Ministries +which covered the entire range of a department. + +[530] They had indeed been discovered by French agents in Germany. Rothan, +L'Affaire du Luxembourg, p. 74. + +[531] Hahn, i. 658. Rothan, Luxembourg, p. 246. Correspondenzen des K.K. +Minist. des Auessern, 1868, p. 24. Parl. Pap., 1867, vol. lxxiv., p. 427. + +[532] Sorel, Histoire Diplomatique, i. 38. But see the controversy between +Beust and Gramont in _Le Temps_, Jan. 11-16, 1873. + +[533] Rothan, La France en 1867, ii. 316. Reuchlin, v. 547. Two historical +expressions belong to Mentana: the "Never," of M. Rouher, and "The +Chassepots have done wonders," of General Failly. + +[534] Sorel, i. 40. Hahn, i. 720. Immediately after Mentana, on Nov. 17, +1867, Mazzini wrote to Bismarck and to the Prussian ambassador at Florence, +Count Usedom, stating that Napoleon had resolved to make war on Prussia and +had proposed an alliance to Victor Emmanuel, who had accepted it for the +price of Rome. Mazzini offered to employ revolutionary means to frustrate +this plan, and asked for money and arms. Bismarck showed caution, but did +not altogether disregard the communication. Politica Segreta Italiana, p. +339. + +[535] Benedetti, Ma Mission, p. 319, July 7. Gramont, La France et la +Prusse, p. 61. + +[536] Sorel, Histoire Diplomatique, i. 197. + +[537] Hahn, ii. 69. Sorel, i. 236. + +[538] Prince Napoleon, in Revue des Deux Mondes, April 1, 1878; Gramont, in +Revue de France, April 17, 1878. (Signed Andreas Memor.) Ollivier, L'Eglise +et l'Etat, ii. 473. Sorel, i. 245. + +[539] Der Deutsch Franzoesische Krieg, 1870-71 (Prussian General Staff), i. +72. + +[540] Bazaine, L'Armee du Rhin, p. 74. + +[541] Papiers Secrets du Second Empire (1875), pp. 33, 240. + +[542] Diary of the Emperor Frederick, Sept. 3. + +[543] Favre's circular alleged that the King of Prussia had declared that +he made war not on France but on the Imperial Dynasty. King William had +never stated anything of the kind. His proclamation on entering France, to +which Favre appears to have referred, merely said that the war was to he +waged against the French army, and not against the inhabitants, who, so +long as they kept quiet, would not be molested. + +[544] Deutsch-Franzoesiche Krieg, vol. III., p. 104. Bazaine, p. 166. Proces +de Bazaine, vol. ii., p. 219. Regnier, p. 20. Hahn, ii., 171. + +[545] Hahn, ii. 216. Valfrey, Diplomatie du Gouvernement de la Defense +Nationale, ii. 51. Hertsier, Map of Europe, iii. 1912, 1954. + +[546] Parl. Pap. 1876, vol. lxxxiv., pp. 74, 96. + +[547] Parl. Pap. 1876, vol. lxxxiv., p. 183. + +[548] Parl. Pap. 1877, vol. xc., p. 143. + +[549] Parl. Deb. July 10, 1876, verbatim. + +[550] See Burke's speech on the Russian armament, March 29, 1791, and the +passage on "the barbarous anarchic despotism" of Turkey in his Reflections +on the French Revolution, p. 150, Clar. edit. Burke lived and died in +Beaconsfield, and his grave is there. There seems, however, to be no +evidence for the story that he was about to receive a peerage with the +title of Beaconsfield, when the death of his son broke all his hopes. + +[551] Parl. Pap. 1877, vol. xc., p. 642; 1878, vol. lxxxi., p. 679. + +[552] Parl. Pap. 1877, vol. lxxxix., p. 135. + +[553] Parl. Pap. 1878, vol. lxxxi., pp. 661, 725. Parl. Deb., vol. +ccxxxvii. + +[554] The Treaty, with Maps, is in Parl. Pap. 1878, vol. lxxxiii. p. 239. + +[555] Parl. Pap. 1878, vl. lxxxii., p. 3. _Globe_, May 31, 1878. Hahn, +iii. 116. + + + + + + +[Transcriber's Note: (1) Footnotes have been numbered and collected at the +end of the work. (2) Sidenotes have been placed in brackets prior to the +paragraph in which they occur. (3) In a few places (all in the footnotes) +the text in our print copy was illegible and has been marked with a [***]. +(4) The spelling in the print copy was not always consistent. Irregular +words in the original (e.g., "ascendent," "Christain," and "Wuertemburg") +have been retained whenever possible.] + + + + + + + + + + + +End of Project Gutenberg's History of Modern Europe 1972-1878, by C. A. Fyffe + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK HISTORY OF MODERN EUROPE 1972-1878 *** + +***** This file should be named 6589.txt or 6589.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + http://www.gutenberg.org/6/5/8/6589/ + +Produced by Tom Allen, Charles Franks, David Gundry and +the Online Distributed Proofreading Team. + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License available with this file or online at + www.gutenberg.org/license. + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS', WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at 809 +North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887. Email +contact links and up to date contact information can be found at the +Foundation's web site and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit www.gutenberg.org/donate + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. +To donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For forty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. |
