diff options
Diffstat (limited to '3042.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | 3042.txt | 5106 |
1 files changed, 5106 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/3042.txt b/3042.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..97b2857 --- /dev/null +++ b/3042.txt @@ -0,0 +1,5106 @@ +The Project Gutenberg EBook of The Hispanic Nations of the New World, by +William R. Shepherd + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: The Hispanic Nations of the New World + Volume 50 in The Chronicles Of America Series + +Author: William R. Shepherd + +Editor: Allen Johnson + +Posting Date: February 1, 2009 [EBook #3042] +Release Date: January, 2002 + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ASCII + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE HISPANIC NATIONS *** + + + + +Produced by The James J. Kelly Library Of St. Gregory's +University, Dianne Bean, Joseph Buersmeyer, and Alev Akman + + + + + + +THE HISPANIC NATIONS OF THE NEW WORLD, + +A CHRONICLE OF OUR SOUTHERN NEIGHBORS + +By William R. Shepherd + +New Haven: Yale University Press + +Toronto: Glasgow, Brook & Co. + +London: Humphrey Milford + +Oxford University Press + +1919 + + + +CONTENTS + + I. THE HERITAGE FROM SPAIN AND PORTUGAL + + II. "OUR OLD KING OR NONE" + + III. "INDEPENDENCE OR DEATH" + + IV. PLOUGHING THE SEA + + V. THE AGE OF THE DICTATORS + + VI. PERIL FROM ABROAD + + VII. GREATER STATES AND LESSER + + VIII. "ON THE MARGIN OF INTERNATIONAL LIFE" + + IX. THE REPUBLICS OF SOUTH AMERICA + + X. MEXICO IN REVOLUTION + + XI. THE REPUBLICS OF THE CARIBBEAN + + XII. PAN-AMERICANISM AND THE GREAT WAR + + BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTE + + + + +THE HISPANIC NATIONS OF THE NEW WORLD + + + + +CHAPTER I. THE HERITAGE FROM SPAIN AND PORTUGAL + +At the time of the American Revolution most of the New World still +belonged to Spain and Portugal, whose captains and conquerors had +been the first to come to its shores. Spain had the lion's share, but +Portugal held Brazil, in itself a vast land of unsuspected resources. +No empire mankind had ever yet known rivaled in size the illimitable +domains of Spain and Portugal in the New World; and none displayed such +remarkable contrasts in land and people. Boundless plains and forests, +swamps and deserts, mighty mountain chains, torrential streams and +majestic rivers, marked the surface of the country. This vast territory +stretched from the temperate prairies west of the Mississippi down to +the steaming lowlands of Central America, then up through tablelands in +the southern continent to high plateaus, miles above sea level, where +the sun blazed and the cold, dry air was hard to breathe, and then +higher still to the lofty peaks of the Andes, clad in eternal snow or +pouring fire and smoke from their summits in the clouds, and thence to +the lower temperate valleys, grassy pampas, and undulating hills of the +far south. + +Scattered over these vast colonial domains in the Western World were +somewhere between 12,000,000 and 19,000,000 people subject to Spain, and +perhaps 3,000,000, to Portugal; the great majority of them were Indians +and negroes, the latter predominating in the lands bordering on the +Caribbean Sea and along the shores of Brazil. Possibly one-fourth of +the inhabitants came of European stock, including not only Spaniards and +their descendants but also the folk who spoke English in the Floridas +and French in Louisiana. + +During the centuries which had elapsed since the entry of the Spaniards +and Portuguese into these regions an extraordinary fusion of races had +taken place. White, red, and black had mingled to such an extent that +the bulk of the settled population became half-caste. Only in the more +temperate regions of the far north and south, where the aborigines were +comparatively few or had disappeared altogether, did the whites remain +racially distinct. Socially the Indian and the negro counted for little. +They constituted the laboring class on whom all the burdens fell and for +whom advantages in the body politic were scant. Legally the Indian under +Spanish rule stood on a footing of equality with his white fellows, +and many a gifted native came to be reckoned a force in the community, +though his social position remained a subordinate one. Most of the +negroes were slaves and were more kindly treated by the Spaniards than +by the Portuguese. + +Though divided among themselves, the Europeans were everywhere +politically dominant. The Spaniard was always an individualist. Besides, +he often brought from the Old World petty provincial traditions which +were intensified in the New. The inhabitants of towns, many of which had +been founded quite independently of one another, knew little about their +remote neighbors and often were quite willing to convert their ignorance +into prejudice: The dweller in the uplands and the resident on the coast +were wont to view each other with disfavor. The one was thought heavy +and stupid, the other frivolous and lazy. Native Spaniards regarded the +Creoles, or American born, as persons who had degenerated more or less +by their contact with the aborigines and the wilderness. For their part, +the Creoles looked upon the Spaniards as upstarts and intruders, whose +sole claim to consideration lay in the privileges dispensed them by the +home government. In testimony of this attitude they coined for their +oversea kindred numerous nicknames which were more expressive than +complimentary. While the Creoles held most of the wealth and of the +lower offices, the Spaniards enjoyed the perquisites and emoluments of +the higher posts. + +Though objects of disdain to both these masters, the Indians generally +preferred the Spaniard to the Creole. The Spaniard represented a distant +authority interested in the welfare of its humbler subjects and came +less into actual daily contact with the natives. While it would hardly +be correct to say that the Spaniard was viewed as a protector and the +Creole as an oppressor, yet the aborigines unconsciously made some +such hazy distinction if indeed they did not view all Europeans with +suspicion and dislike. In Brazil the relation of classes was much the +same, except that here the native element was much less conspicuous as a +social factor. + +These distinctions were all the more accentuated by the absence both +of other European peoples and of a definite middle class of any race. +Everywhere in the areas tenanted originally by Spaniards and Portuguese +the European of alien stock was unwelcome, even though he obtained a +grudging permission from the home governments to remain a colonist. In +Brazil, owing to the close commercial connections between Great Britain +and Portugal, foreigners were not so rigidly excluded as in Spanish +America. The Spaniard was unwilling that lands so rich in natural +treasures should be thrown open to exploitation by others, even if the +newcomer professed the Catholic faith. The heretic was denied admission +as a matter of course. Had the foreigner been allowed to enter, the risk +of such exploitation doubtless would have been increased, but a middle +class might have arisen to weld the the discordant factions into a +society which had common desires and aspirations. With the development +of commerce and industry, with the growth of activities which bring +men into touch with each other in everyday affairs, something like a +solidarity of sentiment might have been awakened. In its absence the +only bond among the dominant whites was their sense of superiority to +the colored masses beneath them. + +Manual labor and trade had never attracted the Spaniards and the +Portuguese. The army, the church, and the law were the three callings +that offered the greatest opportunity for distinction. Agriculture, +grazing, and mining they did not disdain, provided that superintendence +and not actual work was the main requisite. The economic organization +which the Spaniards and Portuguese established in America was naturally +a more or less faithful reproduction of that to which they had +been accustomed at home. Agriculture and grazing became the chief +occupations. Domestic animals and many kinds of plants brought from +Europe throve wonderfully in their new home. Huge estates were the rule; +small farms, the exception. On the ranches and plantations vast droves +of cattle, sheep, and horses were raised, as well as immense crops. +Mining, once so much in vogue, had become an occupation of secondary +importance. + +On their estates the planter, the ranchman, and the mine owner lived +like feudal overlords, waited upon by Indian and negro peasants who also +tilled the fields, tended the droves, and dug the earth for precious +metals and stones. Originally the natives had been forced to work under +conditions approximating actual servitude, but gradually the harsher +features of this system had given way to a mode of service closely +resembling peonage. Paid a pitifully small wage, provided with a hut of +reeds or sundried mud and a tiny patch of soil on which to grow a +few hills of the corn and beans that were his usual nourishment, the +ordinary Indian or half-caste laborer was scarcely more than a beast of +burden, a creature in whom civic virtues of a high order were not likely +to develop. If he betook himself to the town his possible usefulness +lessened in proportion as he fell into drunken or dissolute habits, or +lapsed into a state of lazy and vacuous dreaminess, enlivened only by +chatter or the rolling of a cigarette. On the other hand, when employed +in a capacity where native talent might be tested, he often revealed a +power of action which, if properly guided, could be turned to excellent +account. As a cowboy, for example, he became a capital horseman, brave, +alert, skillful, and daring. + +Commerce with Portugal and Spain was long confined to yearly fairs and +occasional trading fleets that plied between fixed points. But when +liberal decrees threw open numerous ports in the mother countries +to traffic and the several colonies were given also the privilege of +exchanging their products among themselves, the volume of exports +and imports increased and gave an impetus to activity which brought a +notable release from the torpor and vegetation characterizing earlier +days. Yet, even so, communication was difficult and irregular. By sea +the distances were great and the vessels slow. Overland the natural +obstacles to transportation were so numerous and the methods of +conveyance so cumbersome and expensive that the people of one province +were practically strangers to their neighbors. + +Matters of the mind and of the soul were under the guardianship of the +Church. More than merely a spiritual mentor, it controlled education and +determined in large measure the course of intellectual life. Possessed +of vast wealth in lands and revenues, its monasteries and priories, its +hospitals and asylums, its residences of ecclesiastics, were the finest +buildings in every community, adorned with the masterpieces of sculptors +and painters. A village might boast of only a few squalid huts, yet +there in the "plaza," or central square, loomed up a massively imposing +edifice of worship, its towers pointing heavenward, the sign and symbol +of triumphant power. + +The Church, in fact, was the greatest civilizing agency that Spain +and Portugal had at their disposal. It inculcated a reverence for +the monarch and his ministers and fostered a deep-rooted sentiment of +conservatism which made disloyalty and innovation almost sacrilegious. +In the Spanish colonies in particular the Church not only protected the +natives against the rapacity of many a white master but taught them the +rudiments of the Christian faith, as well as useful arts and trades. In +remote places, secluded so far as possible from contact with Europeans, +missionary pioneers gathered together groups of neophytes whom they +rendered docile and industrious, it is true, but whom they often +deprived of initiative and selfreliance and kept illiterate and +superstitious. + +Education was reserved commonly for members of the ruling class. +As imparted in the universities and schools, it savored strongly of +medievalism. Though some attention was devoted to the natural sciences, +experimental methods were not encouraged and found no place in lectures +and textbooks. Books, periodicals, and other publications came under +ecclesiastical inspection, and a vigilant censorship determined what was +fit for the public to read. + +Supreme over all the colonial domains was the government of their +majesties, the monarchs of Spain and Portugal. A ministry and a council +managed the affairs of the inhabitants of America and guarded their +destinies in accordance with the theories of enlightened despotism +then prevailing in Europe. The Spanish dominions were divided into +viceroyalties and subdivided into captaincies general, presidencies, +and intendancies. Associated with the high officials who ruled them were +audiencias, or boards, which were at once judicial and administrative. +Below these individuals and bodies were a host of lesser functionaries +who, like their superiors, held their posts by appointment. In Brazil +the governor general bore the title of viceroy and carried on the +administration assisted by provincial captains, supreme courts, and +local officers. + +This control was by no means so autocratic as it might seem. Portugal +had too many interests elsewhere, and was too feeble besides, to keep +tight rein over a territory so vast and a population so much inclined +as the Brazilian to form itself into provincial units, jealous of the +central authority. Spain, on its part, had always practised the good old +Roman rule of "divide and govern." Its policy was to hold the balance +among officials, civil and ecclesiastical, and inhabitants, white and +colored. It knew how strongly individualistic the Spaniard was and +realized the full force of the adage, "I obey, but I do not fulfill!" +Legislatures and other agencies of government directly representative of +the people did not exist in Spanish or Portuguese America. The Spanish +cabildo, or town council, however, afforded an opportunity for the +expression of the popular will and often proved intractable. Its +membership was appointive, elective, hereditary, and even purchasable, +but the form did not affect the substance. The Spanish Americans had +an instinct for politics. "Here all men govern," declared one of the +viceroys; "the people have more part in political discussions than in +any other provinces in the world; a council of war sits in every house." + + + +CHAPTER II. "OUR OLD KING OR NONE" + +The movement which led eventually to the emancipation of the colonies +differed from the local uprisings which occurred in various parts +of South America during the eighteenth century. Either the arbitrary +conduct of individual governors or excessive taxation had caused the +earlier revolts. To the final revolution foreign nations and foreign +ideas gave the necessary impulse. A few members of the intellectual +class had read in secret the writings of French and English +philosophers. Others had traveled abroad and came home to whisper to +their countrymen what they had seen and heard in lands more progressive +than Spain and Portugal. The commercial relations, both licit and +illicit, which Great Britain had maintained with several of the colonies +had served to diffuse among them some notions of what went on in the +busy world outside. + +By gaining its independence, the United States had set a practical +example of what might be done elsewhere in America. Translated into +French, the Declaration of Independence was read and commented upon by +enthusiasts who dreamed of the possibility of applying its principles +in their own lands. More powerful still were the ideas liberated by the +French Revolution and Napoleon. Borne across the ocean, the doctrines of +"Liberty, Fraternity, Equality" stirred the ardent-minded to thoughts +of action, though the Spanish and Portuguese Americans who schemed +and plotted were the merest handful. The seed they planted was slow to +germinate among peoples who had been taught to regard things foreign as +outlandish and heretical. Many years therefore elapsed before the ideas +of the few became the convictions of the masses, for the conservatism +and loyalty of the common people were unbelieveably steadfast. + +Not Spanish and Portuguese America, but Santo Domingo, an island which +had been under French rule since 1795 and which was tenanted chiefly +by ignorant and brutalized negro slaves, was the scene of the first +effectual assertion of independence in the lands originally colonized +by Spain. Rising in revolt against their masters, the negroes had +won complete control under their remarkable commander, Toussaint +L'Ouverture, when Napoleon Bonaparte, then First Consul, decided to +restore the old regime. But the huge expedition which was sent to reduce +the island ended in absolute failure. After a ruthless racial warfare, +characterized by ferocity on both sides, the French retired. In 1804 the +negro leaders proclaimed the independence of the island as the "Republic +of Haiti," under a President who, appreciative of the example just set +by Napoleon, informed his followers that he too had assumed the august +title of "Emperor"! His immediate successor in African royalty was the +notorious Henri Christophe, who gathered about him a nobility garish +in color and taste--including their sable lordships, the "Duke of +Marmalade" and the "Count of Lemonade"; and who built the palace of +"Sans Souci" and the countryseats of "Queen's Delight" and "King's +Beautiful View," about which cluster tales of barbaric pleasure that +rival the grim legends clinging to the parapets and enshrouding the +dungeons of his mountain fortress of "La Ferriere." None of these black +or mulatto potentates, however, could expel French authority from +the eastern part of Santo Domingo. That task was taken in hand by the +inhabitants themselves, and in 1809 they succeeded in restoring the +control of Spain. Meanwhile events which had been occurring in South +America prepared the way for the movement that was ultimately to banish +the flags of both Spain and Portugal from the continents of the New +World. As the one country had fallen more or less tinder the influence +of France, so the other had become practically dependent upon Great +Britain. Interested in the expansion of its commerce and viewing the +outlying possessions of peoples who submitted to French guidance as +legitimate objects for seizure, Great Britain in 1797 wrested Trinidad +from the feeble grip of Spain and thus acquired a strategic position +very near South America itself. Haiti, Trinidad, and Jamaica, in fact, +all became Centers of revolutionary agitation and havens of refuge for. +Spanish American radicals in the troublous years to follow. + +Foremost among the early conspirators was the Venezuelan, Francisco +de Miranda, known to his fellow Americans of Spanish stock as the +"Precursor." Napoleon once remarked of him: "He is a Don Quixote, with +this difference--he is not crazy.... The man has sacred fire in his +soul." An officer in the armies of Spain and of revolutionary France +and later a resident of London, Miranda devoted thirty years of his +adventurous life to the cause of independence for his countrymen. With +officials of the British Government he labored long and zealously, +eliciting from them vague promises of armed support and some financial +aid. It was in London, also, that he organized a group of sympathizers +into the secret society called the "Grand Lodge of America." With it, +or with its branches in France and Spain, many of the leaders of the +subsequent revolution came to be identified. + +In 1806, availing himself of the negligence of the United States and +having the connivance of the British authorities in Trinidad, Miranda +headed two expeditions to the coast of Venezuela. He had hoped that his +appearance would be the signal for a general uprising; instead, he was +treated with indifference. His countrymen seemed to regard him as a tool +of Great Britain, and no one felt disposed to accept the blessings +of liberty under that guise. Humiliated, but not despairing, Miranda +returned to London to await a happier day. + +Two British expeditions which attempted to conquer the region about +the Rio de la Plata in 1806 and 1807 were also frustrated by this +same stubborn loyalty. When the Spanish viceroy fled, the inhabitants +themselves rallied to the defense of the country and drove out the +invaders. Thereupon the people of Buenos Aires, assembled in cabildo +abierto, or town meeting, deposed the viceroy and chose their victorious +leader in his stead until a successor could be regularly appointed. + +Then, in 1808, fell the blow which was to shatter the bonds uniting +Spain to its continental dominions in America. The discord and +corruption which prevailed in that unfortunate country afforded +Napoleon an opportunity to oust its feeble king and his incompetent son, +Ferdinand, and to place Joseph Bonaparte on the throne. But the master +of Europe underestimated the fighting ability of Spaniards. Instead of +humbly complying with his mandate, they rose in arms against the usurper +and created a central junta, or revolutionary committee, to govern in +the name of Ferdinand VII, as their rightful ruler. + +The news of this French aggression aroused in the colonies a spirit of +resistance as vehement as that in the mother country. Both Spaniards and +Creoles repudiated the "intruder king." Believing, as did their comrades +oversea, that Ferdinand was a helpless victim in the hands of Napoleon, +they recognized the revolutionary government and sent great sums of +money to Spain to aid in the struggle against the French. Envoys from +Joseph Bonaparte seeking an acknowledgment of his rule were angrily +rejected and were forced to leave. + +The situation on both sides of the ocean was now an extraordinary +one. Just as the junta in Spain had no legal right to govern, so the +officials in the colonies, holding their posts by appointment from a +deposed king, had no legal authority, and the people would not allow +them to accept new commissions from a usurper. The Church, too, +detesting Napoleon as the heir of a revolution that had undermined the +Catholic faith and regarding him as a godless despot who had made +the Pope a captive, refused to recognize the French pretender. Until +Ferdinand VII could be restored to his throne, therefore, the colonists +had to choose whether they would carry on the administration under +the guidance of the self-constituted authorities in Spain, or should +themselves create similar organizations in each of the colonies to take +charge of affairs. The former course was favored by the official element +and its supporters among the conservative classes, the latter by the +liberals, who felt that they had as much right as the people of the +mother country to choose the form of government best suited to their +interests. + +Each party viewed the other with distrust. Opposition to the more +democratic procedure, it was felt, could mean nothing less than +secret submission to the pretensions of Joseph Bonaparte; whereas the +establishment in America of any organizations like those in Spain surely +indicated a spirit of disloyalty toward Ferdinand VII himself. Under +circumstances like these, when the junta and its successor, the council +of regency, refused to make substantial concessions to the colonies, +both parties were inevitably drifting toward independence. In the phrase +of Manuel Belgrano, one of the great leaders in the viceroyalty of La +Plata, "our old King or none" became the watchword that gradually shaped +the thoughts of Spanish Americans. + +When, therefore, in 1810, the news came that the French army had overrun +Spain, democratic ideas so long cherished in secret and propagated so +industriously by Miranda and his followers at last found expression in +a series of uprisings in the four viceroyalties of La Plata, Peru, +New Granada, and New Spain. But in each of these viceroyalties the +revolution ran a different course. Sometimes it was the capital +city that led off; sometimes a provincial town; sometimes a group of +individuals in the country districts. Among the actual participants +in the various movements very little harmony was to be found. Here +a particular leader claimed obedience; there a board of self-chosen +magistrates held sway; elsewhere a town or province refused to +acknowledge the central authority. To add to these complications, in +1812, a revolutionary Cortes, or legislative body, assembled at Cadiz, +adopted for Spain and its dominions a constitution providing for +direct representation of the colonies in oversea administration. Since +arrangements of this sort contented many of the Spanish Americans who +had protested against existing abuses, they were quite unwilling to +press their grievances further. Given all these evidences of division +in activity and counsel, one does not find it difficult to foresee the +outcome. + +On May 25, 1810, popular agitation at Buenos Aires forced the Spanish +viceroy of La Plata to resign. The central authority was thereupon +vested in an elected junta that was to govern in the name of Ferdinand +VII. Opposition broke out immediately. The northern and eastern parts +of the viceroyalty showed themselves quite unwilling to obey these +upstarts. Meantime, urged on by radicals who revived the Jacobin +doctrines of revolutionary France, the junta strove to suppress in +rigorous fashion any symptoms of disaffection; but it could do nothing +to stem the tide of separation in the rest of the viceroyalty--in +Charcas (Bolivia), Paraguay, and the Banda Oriental, or East Bank, of +the Uruguay. + +At Buenos Aires acute difference of opinion--about the extent to +which the movement should be carried and about the permanent form +of government to be adopted as well as the method of establishing +it--produced a series of political commotions little short of anarchy. +Triumvirates followed the junta into power; supreme directors alternated +with triumvirates; and constituent assemblies came and went. Under one +authority or another the name of the viceroyalty was changed to "United +Provinces of La Plata River"; a seal, a flag, and a coat of arms were +chosen; and numerous features of the Spanish regime were abolished, +including titles of nobility, the Inquisition, the slave trade, and +restrictions on the press. But so chaotic were the conditions within and +so disastrous the campaigns without, that eventually commissioners were +sent to Europe, bearing instructions to seek a king for the distracted +country. + +When Charcas fell under the control of the viceroy of Peru, Paraguay +set up a regime for itself. At Asuncion, the capital, a revolutionary +outbreak in 1811 replaced the Spanish intendant by a triumvirate, +of which the most prominent member was Dr. Jose Gaspar Rodriguez de +Francia. A lawyer by profession, familiar with the history of Rome, an +admirer of France and Napoleon, a misanthrope and a recluse, possessing +a blind faith in himself and actuated by a sense of implacable hatred +for all who might venture to thwart his will, this extraordinary +personage speedily made himself master of the country. A population +composed chiefly of Indians, docile in temperament and submissive for +many years to the paternal rule of Jesuit missionaries, could not fail +to become pliant instruments in his hands. At his direction, therefore, +Paraguay declared itself independent of both Spain and La Plata. This +done, an obedient Congress elected Francia consul of the republic and +later invested him with the title of dictator. In the Banda Oriental two +distinct movements appeared. Montevideo, the capital, long a center +of royalist sympathies and for some years hostile to the revolutionary +government in Buenos Aires, was reunited with La Plata in 1814. +Elsewhere the people of the province followed the fortunes of Jose +Gervasio Artigas, an able and valiant cavalry officer, who roamed +through it at will, bidding defiance to any authority not his own. +Most of the former viceroyalty of La Plata had thus, to all intents and +purposes, thrown off the yoke of Spain. + +Chile was the only other province that for a while gave promise of +similar action. Here again it was the capital city that took the lead. +On receipt of the news of the occurrences at Buenos Aires in May, 1810, +the people of Santiago forced the captain general to resign and, on the +18th of September, replaced him by a junta of their own choosing. +But neither this body, nor its successors, nor even the Congress that +assembled the following year, could establish a permanent and effective +government. Nowhere in Spanish America, perhaps, did the lower classes +count for so little, and the upper class for so much, as in Chile. +Though the great landholders were disposed to favor a reasonable amount +of local autonomy for the country, they refused to heed the demands +of the radicals for complete independence and the establishment of a +republic. Accordingly, in proportion as their opponents resorted to +measures of compulsion, the gentry gradually withdrew their support and +offered little resistance when troops dispatched by the viceroy of +Peru restored the Spanish regime in 1814. The irreconcilable among the +patriots fled over the Andes to the western part of La Plata, where they +found hospitable refuge. + +But of all the Spanish dominions in South America none witnessed so +desperate a struggle for emancipation as the viceroyalty of New Granada. +Learning of the catastrophe that had befallen the mother country, the +leading citizens of Caracas, acting in conjunction with the cabildo, +deposed the captain general on April 19, 1810, and created a junta +in his stead. The example was quickly followed by most of the smaller +divisions of the province. Then when Miranda returned from England to +head the revolutionary movement, a Congress, on July 5, 1811, declared +Venezuela independent of Spain. Carried away, also, by the enthusiasm +of the moment, and forgetful of the utter unpreparedness of the country, +the Congress promulgated a federal constitution modeled on that of the +United States, which set forth all the approved doctrines of the rights +of man. + +Neither Miranda nor his youthful coadjutor, Simon Bolivar, soon to +become famous in the annals of Spanish American history, approved of +this plunge into democracy. Ardent as their patriotism was, they knew +that the country needed centralized control and not experiments in +confederation or theoretical liberty. They speedily found out, also, +that they could not count on the support of the people at large. Then, +almost as if Nature herself disapproved of the whole proceeding, a +frightful earthquake in the following year shook many a Venezuelan town +into ruins. Everywhere the royalists took heart. Dissensions broke out +between Miranda and his subordinates. Betrayed into the hands of his +enemies, the old warrior himself was sent away to die in a Spanish +dungeon. And so the "earthquake" republic collapsed. + +But the rigorous measures adopted by the royalists to sustain their +triumph enabled Bolivar to renew the struggle in 1813. He entered upon +a campaign which was signalized by acts of barbarity on both sides. +His declaration of "war to the death" was answered in kind. Wholesale +slaughter of prisoners, indiscriminate pillage, and wanton destruction +of property spread terror and desolation throughout the country. +Acclaimed "Liberator of Venezuela" and made dictator by the people of +Caracas, Bolivar strove in vain to overcome the half-savage llaneros, +or cowboys of the plains, who despised the innovating aristocrats of +the capital. Though he won a few victories, he did not make the cause +of independence popular, and, realizing his failure, he retired into New +Granada. + +In this region an astounding series of revolutions and +counter-revolutions had taken place. Unmindful of pleas for cooperation, +the Creole leaders in town and district, from 1810 onward, seized +control of affairs in a fashion that betokened a speedy disintegration +of the country. Though the viceroy was deposed and a general Congress +was summoned to meet at the capital, Bogota, efforts at centralization +encountered opposition in every quarter. Only the royalists managed to +preserve a semblance of unity. Separate republics sprang into being and +in 1813 declared their independence of Spain. Presidents and congresses +were pitted against one another. Towns fought among themselves. Even +parishes demanded local autonomy. For a while the services of Bolivar +were invoked to force rebellious areas into obedience to the principle +of confederation, but with scant result. Unable to agree with his fellow +officers and displaying traits of moral weakness which at this time as +on previous occasions showed that he had not yet risen to a full sense +of responsibility, the Liberator renounced the task and fled to Jamaica. + +The scene now shifts northward to the viceroyalty of New Spain. Unlike +the struggles already described, the uprisings that began in 1810 in +central Mexico were substantially revolts of Indians and half-castes +against white domination. On the 16th of September, a crowd of natives +rose under the leadership of Miguel Hidalgo, a parish priest of the +village of Dolores. Bearing on their banners the slogan, "Long live +Ferdinand VII and down with bad government," the undisciplined crowd, +soon to number tens of thousands, aroused such terror by their behavior +that the whites were compelled to unite in self-defense. It mattered not +whether Hidalgo hoped to establish a republic or simply to secure for +his followers relief from oppression: in either case the whites could +expect only Indian domination. Before the trained forces of the whites a +horde of natives, so ignorant of modern warfare that some of them tried +to stop cannon balls by clapping their straw hats over the mouths of the +guns, could not stand their ground. Hidalgo was captured and shot, but +he was succeeded by Jose Maria Morelos, also a priest. Reviving the +old Aztec name for central Mexico, he summoned a "Congress of Anahuac," +which in 1813 asserted that dependence on the throne of Spain was +"forever broken and dissolved." Abler and more humane than Hidalgo, he +set up a revolutionary government that the authorities of Mexico failed +for a while to suppress. + +In 1814, therefore, Spain still held the bulk of its dominions. +Trinidad, to be sure, had been lost to Great Britain, and both Louisiana +and West Florida to the United States. Royalist control, furthermore, +had ceased in parts of the viceroyalties of La Plata and New Granada. +To regain Trinidad and Louisiana was hopeless: but a wise policy +conciliation or an overwhelming display of armed force might yet restore +Spanish rule where it had been merely suspended. + +Very different was the course of events in Brazil. Strangely enough, +the first impulse toward independence was given by the Portuguese royal +family. Terrified by the prospective invasion of the country by a French +army, late in 1807 the Prince Regent, the royal family, and a host of +Portuguese nobles and commoners took passage on British vessels and +sailed to Rio de Janeiro. Brazil thereupon became the seat of royal +government and immediately assumed an importance which it could never +have attained as a mere dependency. Acting under the advice of the +British minister, the Prince Regent threw open the ports of the colony +to the ships of all nations friendly to Portugal, gave his sanction to +a variety of reforms beneficial to commerce and industry, and even +permitted a printing press to be set up, though only for official +purposes. From all these benevolent activities Brazil derived great +advantages. On the other hand, the Prince Regent's aversion to popular +education or anything that might savor of democracy and the greed of +his followers for place and distinction alienated his colonial subjects. +They could not fail to contrast autocracy in Brazil with the liberal +ideas that had made headway elsewhere in Spanish America. As a +consequence a spirit of unrest arose which boded ill for the maintenance +of Portuguese rule. + + + +CHAPTER III "INDEPENDENCE OR DEATH" + +The restoration of Ferdinand VII to his throne in 1814 encouraged the +liberals of Spain, no less than the loyalists of Spanish America, to +hope that the "old King" would now grant a new dispensation. Freedom of +commerce and a fair measure of popular representation in government, it +was believed, would compensate both the mother country for the suffering +which it had undergone during the Peninsular War and the colonies for +the trials to which loyalty had been subjected. But Ferdinand VII was +a typical Bourbon. Nothing less than an absolute reestablishment of +the earlier regime would satisfy him. On both sides of the Atlantic, +therefore, the liberals were forced into opposition to the crown, +although they were so far apart that they could not cooperate with each +other. Independence was to be the fortune of the Spanish Americans, and +a continuance of despotism, for a while, the lot of the Spaniards. + +As the region of the viceroyalty of La Plata had been the first to +cast off the authority of the home government, so it was the first to +complete its separation from Spain. Despite the fact that disorder was +rampant everywhere and that most of the local districts could not or +would not send deputies, a congress that assembled at Tucuman voted +on July 9, 1816, to declare the "United Provinces in South America" +independent. Comprehensive though the expression was, it applied only to +the central part of the former viceroyalty, and even there it was little +more than an aspiration. Mistrust of the authorities at Buenos Aires, +insistence upon provincial autonomy, failure to agree upon a particular +kind of republican government, and a lingering inclination to monarchy +made progress toward national unity impossible. In 1819, to be sure, a +constitution was adopted, providing for a centralized government, but in +the country at large it encountered too much resistance from those who +favored a federal government to become effective. + +In the Banda Oriental, over most of which Artigas and his horsemen +held sway, chaotic conditions invited aggression from the direction of +Brazil. This East Bank of the Uruguay had long been disputed territory +between Spain and Portugal; and now its definite acquisition by the +latter seemed an easy undertaking. Instead, however, the task turned out +to be a truly formidable one. Montevideo, feebly defended by the forces +of the Government at Buenos Aires, soon capitulated, but four years +elapsed before the rest of the country could be subdued. Artigas fled to +Paraguay, where he fell into the clutches of Francia, never to escape. +In 1821 the Banda Oriental was annexed to Brazil as the Cisplatine +Province. + +Over Paraguay that grim and somber potentate, known as "The Supreme +One"--El Supremo--presided with iron hand. In 1817 Francia set up a +despotism unique in the annals of South America. Fearful lest contact +with the outer world might weaken his tenacious grip upon his subjects, +whom he terrorized into obedience, he barred approach to the country and +suffered no one to leave it. He organized and drilled an army obedient +to his will.. When he went forth by day, attended by an escort of +cavalry, the doors and windows of houses had to be kept closed and +no one was allowed on the streets. Night he spent till a late hour +in reading and study, changing his bedroom frequently to avoid +assassination. Religious functions that might disturb the public peace +he forbade. Compelling the bishop of Asuncion to resign on account of +senile debility, Francia himself assumed the episcopal office. Even +intermarriage among the old colonial families he prohibited, so as to +reduce all to a common social level. He attained his object. Paraguay +became a quiet state, whatever might be said of its neighbors! + +Elsewhere in southern Spanish America a brilliant feat of arms brought +to the fore its most distinguished soldier. This was Jose de San Martin +of La Plata. Like Miranda, he had been an officer in the Spanish army +and had returned to his native land an ardent apostle of independence. +Quick to realize the fact that, so long as Chile remained under royalist +control, the possibility of an attack from that quarter was a constant +menace to the safety of the newly constituted republic, he conceived +the bold plan of organizing near the western frontier an army--composed +partly of Chilean refugees and partly of his own countrymen--with which +he proposed to cross the Andes and meet the enemy on his own ground. +Among these fugitives was the able and valiant Bernardo O'Higgins, +son of an Irish officer who had been viceroy of Peru. Cooperating with +O'Higgins, San Martin fixed his headquarters at Mendoza and began to +gather and train the four thousand men whom he judged needful for the +enterprise. + +By January, 1817, the "Army of the Andes" was ready. To cross the +mountains meant to transport men, horses, artillery, and stores to an +altitude of thirteen thousand feet, where the Uspallata Pass afforded +an outlet to Chilean soil. This pass was nearly a mile higher than +the Great St. Bernard in the Alps, the crossing of which gave Napoleon +Bonaparte such renown. On the 12th of February the hosts of San Martin +hurled themselves upon the royalists entrenched on the slopes of +Chacabuco and routed them utterly. The battle proved decisive not of the +fortunes of Chile alone but of those of all Spanish South America. As a +viceroy of Peru later confessed, "it marked the moment when the cause of +Spain in the Indies began to recede." + +Named supreme director by the people of Santiago, O'Higgins fought +vigorously though ineffectually to drive out the royalists who, +reinforced from Peru, held the region south of the capital. That +he failed did not deter him from having a vote taken under military +auspices, on the strength of which, on February 12, 1818, he declared +Chile an independent nation, the date of the proclamation being changed +to the 1st of January, so as to make the inauguration of the new era +coincident with the entry of the new year. San Martin, meanwhile, had +been collecting reinforcements with which to strike the final blow. On +the 5th of April, the Battle of Maipo gave him the victory he desired. +Except for a few isolated points to the southward, the power of Spain +had fallen. + +Until the fall of Napoleon in 1815 it had been the native loyalists who +had supported the cause of the mother country in the Spanish dominions. +Henceforth, free from the menace of the European dictator, Spain +could look to her affairs in America, and during the next three years +dispatched twenty-five thousand men to bring the colonies to obedience. +These soldiers began their task in the northern part of South America, +and there they ended it--in failure. To this failure the defection of +native royalists contributed, for they were alienated not so much by the +presence of the Spanish troops as by the often merciless severity that +marked their conduct. The atrocities may have been provoked by the +behavior of their opponents; but, be this as it may, the patriots gained +recruits after each victory. + +A Spanish army of more than ten thousand, under the command of Pablo +Morillo, arrived in Venezuela in April, 1815. He found the province +relatively tranquil and even disposed to welcome the full restoration +of royal government. Leaving a garrison sufficient for the purpose +of military occupation, Morillo sailed for Cartagena, the key to +New Granada. Besieged by land and sea, the inhabitants of the town +maintained for upwards of three months a resistance which, in its +heroism, privation, and sacrifice, recalled the memorable defense of +Saragossa in the mother country against the French seven years before. +With Cartagena taken, regulars and loyalists united to stamp out the +rebellion elsewhere. At Bogoth, in particular, the new Spanish viceroy +installed by Morillo waged a savage war on all suspected of aiding the +patriot cause. He did not spare even women, and one of his victims was a +young heroine, Policarpa Salavarrieta by name. Though for her execution +three thousand soldiers were detailed, the girl was unterrified by her +doom and was earnestly beseeching the loyalists among them to turn their +arms against the enemies of their country when a volley stretched her +lifeless on the ground. + +Meanwhile Bolivar had been fitting out, in Haiti and in the Dutch island +of Curacao, an expedition to take up anew the work of freeing Venezuela. +Hardly had the Liberator landed in May, 1816, when dissensions with his +fellow officers frustrated any prospect of success. Indeed they obliged +him to seek refuge once more in Haiti. Eventually, however, most of the +patriot leaders became convinced that, if they were to entertain a +hope of success, they must entrust their fortunes to Bolivar as supreme +commander. Their chances of success were increased furthermore by +the support of the llaneros who had been won over to the cause of +independence. Under their redoubtable chieftain, Jose Antonio Paez, +these fierce and ruthless horsemen performed many a feat of valor in the +campaigns which followed. + +Once again on Venezuelan soil, Bolivar determined to transfer his +operations to the eastern part of the country, which seemed to offer +better strategic advantages than the region about Caracas. But even here +the jealousy of his officers, the insubordination of the free lances, +the stubborn resistance of the loyalists--upheld by the wealthy and +conservative classes and the able generalship of Morillo, who had +returned from New Granada--made the situation of the Liberator all +through 1817 and 1818 extremely precarious. Happily for his fading +fortunes, his hands were strengthened from abroad. The United States had +recognized the belligerency of several of the revolutionary governments +in South America and had sent diplomatic agents to them. Great Britain +had blocked every attempt of Ferdinand VII to obtain help from the Holy +Alliance in reconquering his dominions. And Ferdinand had contributed +to his own undoing by failing to heed the urgent requests of Morillo for +reinforcements to fill his dwindling ranks. More decisive still were +the services of some five thousand British, Irish, French, and German +volunteers, who were often the mainstay of Bolivar and his lieutenants +during the later phases of the struggle, both in Venezuela and +elsewhere. + +For some time the Liberator had been evolving a plan of attack upon the +royalists in New Granada, similar to the offensive campaign which San +Martin had conducted in Chile. More than that, he had conceived the +idea, once independence had been attained, of uniting the western part +of the viceroyalty with Venezuela into a single republic. The latter +plan he laid down before a Congress which assembled at Angostura in +February, 1819, and which promptly chose him President of the republic +and vested him with the powers of dictator. In June, at the head of 2100 +men, he started on his perilous journey over the Andes. + +Up through the passes and across bleak plateaus the little army +struggled till it reached the banks of the rivulet of Boyaca, in the +very heart of New Granada. Here, on the 7th of August, Bolivar inflicted +on the royalist forces a tremendous defeat that gave the deathblow to +the domination of Spain in northern South America. On his triumphal +return to Angostura, the Congress signalized the victory by declaring +the whole of the viceroyalty an independent state under the name of +the "Republic of Colombia" and chose the Liberator as its provisional +President. Two years later, a fundamental law it had adopted was +ratified with certain changes by another Congress assembled at Rosario +de Cucuta, and Bolivar was made permanent President. + +Southward of Colombia lay the viceroyalty of Peru, the oldest, richest, +and most conservative of the larger Spanish dominions on the continent. +Intact, except for the loss of Chile, it had found territorial +compensation by stretching its power over the provinces of Quito and +Charcas, the one wrenched off from the former New Granada, the other +torn away from what had been La Plata. Predominantly royalist +in sentiment, it was like a huge wedge thrust in between the two +independent areas. By thus cutting off the patriots of the north from +their comrades in the south, it threatened both with destruction of +their liberty. + +Again fortune intervened from abroad, this time directly from Spain +itself. Ferdinand VII, who had gathered an army of twenty thousand men +at Cadiz, was ready to deliver a crushing blow at the colonies when in +January, 1890, a mutiny among the troops and revolution throughout the +country entirely frustrated the plan. But although that reactionary +monarch was compelled to accept the Constitution of 1819, the Spanish +liberals were unwilling to concede to their fellows in America anything +more substantial than representation in the Cortes. Independence they +would not tolerate. On the other hand, the example of the mother country +in arms against its King in the name of liberty could not fail to give +heart to the cause of liberation in the provinces oversea and to hasten +its achievement. + +The first important efforts to profit by this situation were made by the +patriots in Chile. Both San Martin and O'Higgins had perceived that the +only effective way to eliminate the Peruvian wedge was to gain control +of its approaches by sea. The Chileans had already won some success +in this direction when the fiery and imperious Scotch sailor, Thomas +Cochrane, Earl of Dundonald, appeared on the scene and offered to +organize a navy. At length a squadron was put under his command. With +upwards of four thousand troops in charge of San Martin the expedition +set sail for Peru late in August, 1820. + +While Cochrane busied himself in destroying the Spanish blockade, his +comrade in arms marched up to the very gates of Lima, the capital, and +everywhere aroused enthusiasm for emancipation. When negotiations, which +had been begun by the viceroy and continued by a special commissioner +from Spain, failed to swerve the patriot leader from his demand for a +recognition of independence, the royalists decided to evacuate the town +and to withdraw into the mountainous region of the interior. San Martin, +thereupon, entered the capital at the head of his army of liberation and +summoned the inhabitants to a town meeting at which they might determine +for themselves what action should be taken. The result was easily +foreseen. On July 28, 1821, Peru was declared independent, and a few +days later San Martin was invested with supreme command under the title +of "Protector." + +But the triumph of the new Protector did not last long. For some reason +he failed to understand that the withdrawal of the royalists from the +neighborhood of the coast was merely a strategic retreat that made the +occupation of the capital a more or less empty performance. This blunder +and a variety of other mishaps proved destined to blight his military +career. Unfortunate in the choice of his subordinates and unable to +retain their confidence; accused of irresolution and even of cowardice; +abandoned by Cochrane, who sailed off to Chile and left the army +stranded; incapable of restraining his soldiers from indulgence in +the pleasures of Lima; now severe, now lax in an administration that +alienated the sympathies of the influential class, San Martin was indeed +an unhappy figure. It soon became clear that he must abandon all hope of +ever conquering the citadel of Spanish power in South America unless he +could prevail upon Bolivar to help him. + +A junction of the forces of the two great leaders was perfectly +feasible, after the last important foothold of the Spaniards on the +coast of Venezuela had been broken by the Battle of Carabobo, on July +24, 1821. Whether such a union would be made, however, depended upon two +things: the ultimate disposition of the province of Quito, lying +between Colombia and Peru, and the attitude which Bolivar and San Martin +themselves should assume toward each other. A revolution of the previous +year at the seaport town of Guayaquil in that province had installed +an independent government which besought the Liberator to sustain its +existence. Prompt to avail himself of so auspicious an opportunity of +uniting this former division of the viceroyalty of New Granada to his +republic of Colombia, Bolivar appointed Antonio Jose de Sucre, his +ablest lieutenant and probably the most efficient of all Spanish +American soldiers of the time, to assume charge of the campaign. On his +arrival at Guayaquil, this officer found the inhabitants at odds among +themselves. Some, hearkening to the pleas of an agent of San Martin, +favored union with Peru; others, yielding to the arguments of a +representative of Bolivar, urged annexation to Colombia; still +others regarded absolute independence as most desirable. Under these +circumstances Sucre for a while made little headway against the +royalists concentrated in the mountainous parts of the country despite +the partial support he received from troops which were sent by the +southern commander. At length, on May 24, 1822, scaling the flanks of +the volcano of Pichincha, near the capital town of Quito itself, he +delivered the blow for freedom. Here Bolivar, who had fought his way +overland amid tremendous difficulties, joined him and started for +Guayaquil, where he and San Martin were to hold their memorable +interview. + +No characters in Spanish American history have called forth so much +controversy about their respective merits and demerits as these two +heroes of independence--Bolivar and San Martin. Even now it seems quite +impossible to obtain from the admirers of either an opinion that does +full justice to both; and foreigners who venture to pass judgment are +almost certain to provoke criticism from one set of partisans or the +other. Both Bolivar and San Martin were sons of country gentlemen, +aristocratic by lineage and devoted to the cause of independence. +Bolivar was alert, dauntless, brilliant, impetuous, vehemently +patriotic, and yet often capricious, domineering, vain, ostentatious, +and disdainful of moral considerations--a masterful man, fertile in +intellect, fluent in speech and with pen, an inspiring leader and one +born to command in state and army. Quite as earnest, equally courageous, +and upholding in private life a higher standard of morals, San Martin +was relatively calm, cautious, almost taciturn in manner, and slower in +thought and action. He was primarily a soldier, fitted to organize +and conduct expeditions, rather than, a man endowed with that supreme +confidence in himself which brings enthusiasm, affection, and loyalty in +its train. + +When San Martin arrived at Guayaquil, late in July, 1822, his hope of +annexing the province of Quito to Peru was rudely shattered by the news +that Bolivar had already declared it a part of Colombia. Though it was +outwardly cordial and even effusive, the meeting of the two men held out +no prospect of accord. In an interchange of views which lasted but a +few hours, mutual suspicion, jealousy, and resentment prevented their +reaching an effective understanding. The Protector, it would seem, +thought the Liberator actuated by a boundless ambition that would not +endure resistance. Bolivar fancied San Martin a crafty schemer plotting +for his own advancement. They failed to agree on the three fundamental +points essential to their further cooperation. Bolivar declined to give +up the province of Quito. He refused also to send an army into Peru +unless he could command it in person, and then he declined to undertake +the expedition on the ground that as President of Colombia he ought +not to leave the territory of the republic. Divining this pretext, San +Martin offered to serve under his orders--a feint that Bolivar parried +by protesting that he would not hear of any such self-denial on the part +of a brother officer. + +Above all, the two men differed about the political form to be adopted +for the new independent states. Both of them realized that anything like +genuine democracies was quite impossible of attainment for many years +to come, and that strong administrations would be needful to tide the +Spanish Americans over from the political inexperience of colonial days +and the disorders of revolution to intelligent self-government, which +could come only after a practical acquaintance with public concerns on +a large scale. San Martin believed that a limited monarchy was the best +form of government under the circumstances. Bolivar held fast to the +idea of a centralized or unitary republic, in which actual power should +be exercised by a life president and an hereditary senate until the +people, represented in a lower house, should have gained a sufficient +amount of political experience. + +When San Martin returned to Lima he found affairs in a worse state than +ever. The tyrannical conduct of the officer he had left in charge had +provoked an uprising that made his position insupportable. Conscious +that his mission had come to an end and certain that, unless he gave +way, a collision with Bolivar was inevitable, San Martin resolved to +sacrifice himself lest harm befall the common cause in which both had +done such yeoman service. Accordingly he resigned his power into the +hands of a constituent congress and left the country. But when he found +that no happier fortune awaited him in Chile and in his own native +land, San Martin decided to abandon Spanish America forever and go into +selfimposed exile. Broken in health and spirit, he took up his residence +in France, a recipient of bounty from a Spaniard who had once been his +comrade in arms. + +Meanwhile in the Mexican part of the viceroyalty of New Spain the cry +of independence raised by Morelos and his bands of Indian followers had +been stifled by the capture and execution of the leader. But the cause +of independence was not dead even if its achievement was to be entrusted +to other hands. Eager to emulate the example of their brethren in South +America, small parties of Spaniards and Creoles fought to overturn +the despotic rule of Ferdinand VII, only to encounter defeat from the +royalists. Then came the Revolution of 1820 in the mother country. +Forthwith demands were heard for a recognition of the liberal regime. +Fearful of being displaced from power, the viceroy with the support of +the clergy and aristocracy ordered Agustin de Iturbide, a Creole +officer who had been an active royalist, to quell an insurrection in the +southern part of the country. + +The choice of this soldier was unfortunate. Personally ambitious and +cherishing in secret the thought of independence, Iturbide, faithless +to his trust, entered into negotiations with the insurgents which +culminated February 24, 1821, in what was called the "Plan of Iguala." +It contained three main provisions, or "guarantees," as they were +termed: the maintenance of the Catholic religion to the exclusion of +all others; the establishment of a constitutional monarchy separate from +Spain and ruled by Ferdinand himself, or, if he declined the honor, +by some other European prince; and the union of Mexicans and Spaniards +without distinction of caste or privilege. A temporary government also, +in the form of a junta presided over by the viceroy, was to be created; +and provision was made for the organization of an "Army of the Three +Guarantees." + +Despite opposition from the royalists, the plan won increasing favor. +Powerless to thwart it and inclined besides to a policy of conciliation, +the new viceroy, Juan O'Donoju, agreed to ratify it on condition--in +obedience to a suggestion from Iturbide--that the parties concerned +should be at liberty, if they desired, to choose any one as emperor, +whether he were of a reigning family or not. Thereupon, on the 28th of +September, the provisional government installed at the city of Mexico +announced the consummation of an "enterprise rendered eternally +memorable, which a genius beyond all admiration and eulogy, love and +glory of his country, began at Iguala, prosecuted and carried into +effect, overcoming obstacles almost insuparable"--and declared the +independence of a "Mexican Empire." The act was followed by the +appointment of a regency to govern until the accession of Ferdinand VII, +or some other personage, to the imperial throne. Of this body Iturbide +assumed the presidency, which carried with it the powers of commander in +chief and a salary of 120,000 pesos, paid from the day on which the Plan +of Iguala was signed. O'Donoju contented himself with membership on the +board and a salary of one-twelfth that amount, until his speedy demise +removed from the scene the last of the Spanish viceroys in North +America. + +One step more was needed. Learning that the Cortes in Spain had rejected +the entire scheme, Iturbide allowed his soldiers to acclaim him emperor, +and an unwilling Congress saw itself obliged to ratify the choice. On +July 21, 1822, the destinies of the country were committed to the charge +of Agustin the First. + +As in the area of Mexico proper, so in the Central American part of the +viceroyalty of New Spain, the Spanish Revolution of 1820 had unexpected +results. Here in the five little provinces composing the captaincy +general of Guatemala there was much unrest, but nothing of a serious +nature occurred until after news had been brought of the Plan of Iguala +and its immediate outcome. Thereupon a popular assembly met at the +capital town of Guatemala, and on September 15, 1821, declared the +country an independent state. This radical act accomplished, the patriot +leaders were unable to proceed further. Demands for the establishment +of a federation, for a recognition of local autonomy, for annexation to +Mexico, were all heard, and none, except the last, was answered. While +the "Imperialists" and "Republicans" were arguing it out, a message +from Emperor Agustin announced that he would not allow the new state +to remain independent. On submission of the matter to a vote of the +cabildos, most of them approved reunion with the northern neighbor. +Salvador alone among the provinces held out until troops from Mexico +overcame its resistance. + +On the continents of America, Spain had now lost nearly all its its +possessions. In 1822 the United States had already acquired East Florida +on its own account, led off in recognizing the independence of the +several republics. Only in Peru and Charcas the royalists still battled +on behalf of the mother country. In the West Indies, Santo Domingo +followed the lead of its sister colonies on the mainland by asserting in +1821 its independence; but its brief independent life was snuffed out +by the negroes of Haiti, once more a republic, who spread their control +over the entire island. Cuba also felt the impulse of the times. But, +apart from the agitation of secret societies like the "Rays and Suns of +Bolivar," which was soon checked, the colony remained tranquil. + +In Portuguese America the knowledge of what had occurred throughout the +Spanish dominions could not fail to awaken a desire for independence. +The Prince Regent was well aware of the discontent of the Brazilians, +but he thought to allay it by substantial concessions. In 1815 he +proceeded to elevate the colony to substantial equality with the mother +country by joining them under the title of "United Kingdom of Portugal, +Brazil, and the Algarves." The next year the Prince Regent himself +became King under the name of John IV. The flame of discontent, +nevertheless, continued to smolder. Republican outbreaks, though quelled +without much difficulty, recurred. Even the reforms which had been +instituted by John himself while Regent, and which had assured freer +communication with the world at large, only emphasized more and more the +absurdity of permitting a feeble little land like Portugal to retain its +hold upon a region so extensive and valuable as Brazil. + +The events of 1820 in Portugal hastened the movement toward +independence. Fired by the success of their Spanish comrades, the +Portuguese liberals forthwith rose in revolt, demanded the establishment +of a limited monarchy, and insisted that the King return to his people. +In similar fashion, also, they drew up a constitution which provided for +the representation of Brazil by deputies in a future Cortes. Beyond this +they would concede no special privileges to the colony. Indeed their +idea seems to have been that, with the King once more in Lisbon, their +own liberties would be secure and those of Brazil would be reduced to +what were befitting a mere dependency. Yielding to the inevitable, the +King decided to return to Portugal, leaving the young Crown Prince to +act as Regent in the colony. A critical moment for the little country +and its big dominion oversea had indubitably arrived. John understood +the trend of the times, for on the eve of his departure he said to his +son: "Pedro, if Brazil is to separate itself from Portugal, as seems +likely, you take the crown yourself before any one else gets it!" + +Pedro was liberal in sentiment, popular among the Brazilians, and +well-disposed toward the aspirations of the country for a larger +measure of freedom, and yet not blind to the interests of the dynasty of +Braganza. He readily listened to the urgent pleas of the leaders of the +separatist party against obeying the repressive mandaes of the Cortes. +Laws which abolished the central government of the colony and made +the various provinces individually subject to Portugal he declined to +notice. With equal promptness he refused to heed an order bidding him +return to Portugal immediately. To a delegation of prominent Brazilians +he said emphatically: "For the good of all and the general welfare of +the nation, I shall stay." More than that, in May, 1822, he accepted +from the municipality of Rio de Janeiro the title of "Perpetual and +Constitutional Defender of Brazil," and in a series of proclamations +urged the people of the country to begin the great work of emancipation +by forcibly resisting, if needful, any attempt at coercion. + +Pedro now believed the moment had come to take the final step. While on +a journey through the province of Sao Paulo, he was overtaken on the 7th +of September, near a little stream called the Ypiranga, by messengers +with dispatches from Portugal. Finding that the Cortes had annulled +his acts and declared his ministers guilty of treason, Pedro forthwith +proclaimed Brazil an independent state. The "cry of Ypiranga" was echoed +with tremendous enthusiasm throughout the country. When Pedro appeared +in the theater at Rio de Janeiro, a few days later, wearing on his arm a +ribbon on which were inscribed the words "Independence or Death," he was +given a tumultuous ovation. On the first day of December the youthful +monarch assumed the title of Emperor, and Brazil thereupon took its +place among the nations of America. + + + +CHAPTER IV. PLOUGHING THE SEA + +When the La Plata Congress at Tucuman took the decisive action that +severed the bond with Spain, it uttered a prophecy for all Spanish +America. To quote its language: "Vast and fertile regions, climates +benign and varied, abundant means of subsistence, treasures of gold +and silver... and fine productions of every sort will attract to our +continent innumerable thousands of immigrants, to whom we shall open a +safe place of refuge and extend a beneficent protection." More hopeful +still were the words of a spokesman for another independent country: +"United, neither the empire of the Assyrians, the Medes or the Persians, +the Macedonian or the Roman Empire, can ever be compared with this +colossal republic." + +Very different was the vision of Bolivar. While a refugee in Jamaica he +wrote: "We are a little human species; we possess a world apart... new +in almost all the arts and sciences, and yet old, after a fashion, in +the uses of civil society.... Neither Indians nor Europeans, we are a +species that lies midway .... Is it conceivable that a people recently +freed of its chains can launch itself into the sphere of liberty without +shattering its wings, like Icarus, and plunging into the abyss? Such a +prodigy is inconceivable, never beheld." Toward the close of his +career he declared: "The majority are mestizos, mulattoes, Indians, +and negroes. An ignorant people is a blunt instrument for its own +destruction. To it liberty means license, patriotism means disloyalty, +and justice means vengeance." "Independence," he exclaimed, "is the only +good we have achieved, at the cost of everything else." + +Whether the abounding confidence of the prophecy or the anxious doubt of +the vision would come true, only the future could tell. In 1822, at all +events, optimism was the watchword and the total exclusion of Spain from +South America the goal of Bolivar and his lieutenants, as they started +southward to complete the work of emancipation which had been begun by +San Martin. + +The patriots of Peru, indeed, had fallen into straits so desperate that +an appeal to the Liberator offered the only hope of salvation. While the +royalists under their able and vigilant leader, Jose Canterac, continued +to strengthen their grasp upon the interior of the country and to uphold +the power of the viceroy, the President chosen by the Congress had been +driven by the enemy from Lima. A number of the legislators in wrath +thereupon declared the President deposed. Not to be outdone, that +functionary on his part declared the Congress dissolved. The malcontents +immediately proceeded to elect a new chief magistrate, thus bringing +two Presidents into the field and inaugurating a spectacle destined to +become all too common in the subsequent annals of Spanish America. + +When Bolivar arrived at Callao, the seaport of Lima, in September, 1823, +he acted with prompt vigor. He expelled one President, converted the +other into a passive instrument of his will, declined to promulgate a +constitution that the Congress had prepared, and, after obtaining from +that body an appointment to supreme command, dissolved the Congress +without further ado. Unfortunately none of these radical measures had +any perceptible effect upon the military situation. Though Bolivar +gathered together an army made up of Colombians, Peruvians, and remnants +of San Martin's force, many months elapsed before he could venture upon +a serious campaign. Then events in Spain played into his hands. The +reaction that had followed the restoration of Ferdinand VII to absolute +power crossed the ocean and split the royalists into opposing factions. +Quick to seize the chance thus afforded, Bolivar marched over the +Andes to the plain of Junin. There, on August 6, 1824, he repelled an +onslaught by Canterac and drove that leader back in headlong flight. +Believing, however, that the position he held was too perilous to risk +an offensive, he entrusted the military command to Sucre and returned to +headquarters. + +The royalists had now come to realize that only a supreme effort could +save them. They must overwhelm Sucre before reinforcements could reach +him, and to this end an army of upwards of ten thousand was assembled. +On the 9th of December it encountered Sucre and his six thousand +soldiers in the valley of Ayacucho, or "Corner of Death," where the +patriot general had entrenched his army with admirable skill. The result +was a total defeat for the royalists--the Waterloo of Spain in South +America. The battle thus won by ragged and hungry soldiers--whose +countersign the night before had been "bread and cheese"--threw off the +yoke of the mother country forever. The viceroy fell wounded into their +hands and Canterac surrendered. On receipt of the glorious news, +the people of Lima greeted Bolivar with wild enthusiasm. A Congress +prolonged his dictatorship amid adulations that bordered on the +grotesque. + +Eastward of Peru in the vast mountainous region of Charcas, on the +very heights of South America, the royalists still found a refuge. In +January, 1825, a patriot general at the town of La Paz undertook on his +own responsibility to declare the entire province independent, alike of +Spain, Peru, and the United Provinces of La Plata. This action was too +precipitous, not to say presumptuous, to suit Bolivar and Sucre. The +better to control the situation, the former went up to La Paz and the +latter to Chuquisaca, the capital, where a Congress was to assemble +for the purpose of imparting a more orderly turn to affairs. Under the +direction of the "Marshal of Ayacucho," as Sucre was now called, +the Congress issued on the 6th of August a formal declaration of +independence. In honor of the Liberator it christened the new republic +"Bolivar"--later Latinized into "Bolivia"--and conferred upon him the +presidency so long as he might choose to remain. In November, 1896, a +new Congress which had been summoned to draft a constitution accepted, +with slight modifications, an instrument that the Liberator himself had +prepared. That body also renamed the capital "Sucre" and chose the hero +of Ayacucho as President of the republic. + +Now, the Liberator thought, was the opportune moment to impose upon +his territorial namesake a constitution embodying his ideas of a stable +government which would give Spanish Americans eventually the political +experience they needed. Providing for an autocracy represented by a life +President, it ran the gamut of aristocracy and democracy, all the way +from "censors" for life, who were to watch over the due enforcement of +the laws, down to senators and "tribunes" chosen by electors, who in +turn were to be named by a select citizenry. Whenever actually present +in the territory of the republic, the Liberator was to enjoy supreme +command, in case he wished to exercise it. + +In 1826 Simon Bolivar stood at the zenith of his glory and power. No +adherents of the Spanish regime were left in South America to menace the +freedom of its independent states. In January a resistance kept up for +nine years by a handful of royalists lodged on the remote island of +Chiloe, off the southern coast of Chile, had been broken, and the +garrison at the fortress of Callao had laid down its arms after a +valiant struggle. Among Spanish Americans no one was comparable to the +marvelous man who had founded three great republics stretching from the +Caribbean Sea to the Tropic of Capricorn. Hailed as the "Liberator" +and the "Terror of Despots," he was also acclaimed by the people as the +"Redeemer, the First-Born Son of the New World!" National destinies +were committed to his charge, and equestrian statues were erected in +his honor. In the popular imagination he was ranked with Napoleon as a +peerless conqueror, and with Washington as the father of his country. +That megalomania should have seized the mind of the Liberator under +circumstances like these is not strange. + +Ever a zealous advocate of large states, Bolivar was an equally ardent +partisan of confederation. As president of three republics--of +Colombia actually, and of its satellites, Peru and Bolivia, through his +lieutenants--he could afford now to carry out the plan that he had long +since cherished of assembling at the town of Panama, on Colombian soil, +an "august congress" representative of the independent countries of +America. Here, on the isthmus created by nature to join the continents, +the nations created by men should foregather and proclaim fraternal +accord. Presenting to the autocratic governments of Europe a solid front +of resistance to their pretensions as well as a visible symbol of unity +in sentiment, such a Congress by meeting periodically would also promote +friendship among the republics of the western hemisphere and supply a +convenient means of settling their disputes. + +At this time the United States was regarded by its sister republics with +all the affection which gratitude for services rendered to the cause +of emancipation could evoke. Was it not itself a republic, its people a +democracy, its development astounding, and its future radiant with +hope? The pronouncement of President Monroe, in 1823, protesting against +interference on the part of European powers with the liberties of +independent America, afforded the clearest possible proof that the +great northern republic was a natural protector, guide, and friend +whose advice and cooperation ought to be invoked. The United States was +accordingly asked to take part in the assembly--not to concert military +measures, but simply to join its fellows to the southward in a solemn +proclamation of the Monroe Doctrine by America at large and to discuss +means of suppressing the slave trade. + +The Congress that met at Panama, in June, 1826, afforded scant +encouragement to Bolivar's roseate hope of interAmerican solidarity. +Whether because of the difficulties of travel, or because of internal +dissensions, or because of the suspicion that the megalomania of the +Liberator had awakened in Spanish America, only the four continental +countries nearest the isthmus--Mexico, Central America, Colombia, and +Peru--were represented. The delegates, nevertheless, signed a compact +of "perpetual union, league, and confederation," provided for mutual +assistance to be rendered by the several nations in time of war, and +arranged to have the Areopagus of the Americas transferred to Mexico. +None of the acts of this Congress was ratified by the republics +concerned, except the agreement for union, which was adopted by +Colombia. + +Disheartening to Bolivar as this spectacle was, it proved merely the +first of a series of calamities which were to overshadow the later years +of the Liberator. His grandiose political structure began to crumble, +for it was built on the shifting sands of a fickle popularity. The +more he urged a general acceptance of the principles of his autocratic +constitution, the surer were his followers that he coveted royal honors. +In December he imposed his instrument upon Peru. Then he learned that +a meeting in Venezuela, presided over by Paez, had declared itself in +favor of separation from Colombia. Hardly had he left Peru to check this +movement when an uprising at Lima deposed his representative and led +to the summons of a Congress which, in June, 1827, restored the former +constitution and chose a new President. In Quito, also, the government +of the unstable dictator was overthrown. + +Alarmed by symptoms of disaffection which also appeared in the western +part of the republic, Bolivar hurried to Bogota. There in the hope +of removing the growing antagonism, he offered his "irrevocable" +resignation, as he had done on more than one occasion before. Though the +malcontents declined to accept his withdrawal from office, they insisted +upon his calling a constitutional convention. Meeting at Ocana, in +April, 1828, that body proceeded to abolish the life tenure of the +presidency, to limit the powers of the executive, and to increase +those of the legislature. Bolivar managed to quell the opposition in +dictatorial fashion; but his prestige had by this time fallen so low +that an attempt was made to assassinate him. The severity with which he +punished the conspirators served only to diminish still more the popular +confidence which he had once enjoyed. Even in Bolivia his star of +destiny had set. An outbreak of Colombian troops at the capital forced +the faithful Sucre to resign and leave the country. The constitution was +then modified to meet the demand for a less autocratic government, and a +new chief magistrate was installed. + +Desperately the Liberator strove to ward off the impending collapse. +Though he recovered possession of the division of Quito, a year of +warfare failed to win back Peru, and he was compelled to renounce all +pretense of governing it. Feeble in body and distracted in mind, he +condemned bitterly the machinations of his enemies. "There is no good +faith in Colombia," he exclaimed, "neither among men nor among nations. +Treaties are paper; constitutions, books; elections, combats; liberty, +anarchy, and life itself a torment." + +But the hardest blow was yet to fall. Late in December, 1829, an +assembly at Caracas declared Venezuela a separate state. The great +republic was rent in twain, and even what was left soon split apart. +In May, 1830, came the final crash. The Congress at Bogota drafted a +constitution, providing for a separate republic to bear the old Spanish +name of "New Granada," accepted definitely the resignation of Bolivar, +and granted him a pension. Venezuela, his native land, set up a congress +of its own and demanded that he be exiled. The division of Quito +declared itself independent, under the name of the "Republic of the +Equator" (Ecuador). Everywhere the artificial handiwork of the Liberator +lay in ruins. "America is ungovernable. Those who have served in the +revolution have ploughed the sea," was his despairing cry. + +Stricken to death, the fallen hero retired to an estate near Santa +Marta. Here, like his famous rival, San Martin, in France, he found +hospitality at the hands of a Spaniard. On December 17, 1830, the +Liberator gave up his troubled soul. + +While Bolivar's great republic was falling apart, the United Provinces +of La Plata had lost practically all semblance of cohesion. So broad +were their notions of liberty that the several provinces maintained a +substantial independence of one another, while within each province the +caudillos, or partisan chieftains, fought among themselves. + +Buenos Aires alone managed to preserve a measure of stability. This +comparative peace was due to the financial and commercial measures +devised by Bernardino Rivadavia, one of the most capable statesmen of +the time, and to the energetic manner in which disorder was suppressed +by Juan Manuel de Rosas, commander of the gaucho, or cowboy, militia. +Thanks also to the former leader, the provinces were induced in 1826 to +join in framing a constitution of a unitary character, which vested in +the administration at Buenos Aires the power of appointing the local +governors and of controlling foreign affairs. The name of the +country was at the same time changed to that of the "Argentine +Confederation"(c)-a Latin rendering of "La Plata." + +No sooner had Rivadavia assumed the presidency under the new order of +things than dissension at home and warfare abroad threatened to destroy +all that he had accomplished. Ignoring the terms of the constitution, +the provinces had already begun to reject the supremacy of Buenos +Aires, when the outbreak of a struggle with Brazil forced the contending +parties for a while to unite in the face of the common enemy. As +before, the object of international dispute was the region of the Banda +Oriental. The rule of Brazil had not been oppressive, but the people +of its Cisplatine Province, attached by language and sympathy to their +western neighbors, longed nevertheless to be free of foreign control. In +April, 1825, a band of thirty-three refugees arrived from Buenos Aires +and started a revolution which spread throughout the country. Organizing +a provisional government, the insurgents proclaimed independence of +Brazil and incorporation with the United Provinces of La Plata. As soon +as the authorities at Buenos Aires had approved this action, war was +inevitable. Though the Brazilians were decisively beaten at the Battle +of Ituzaingo, on February 20, 1827, the struggle lasted until August 28, +1828, when mediation by Great Britain led to the conclusion of a treaty +at Rio de Janeiro, by which both Brazil and the Argentine Confederation +recognized the absolute independence of the disputed province as the +republic of Uruguay. + +Instead of quieting the discord that prevailed among the Argentinos, +these victories only fomented trouble. The federalists had ousted +Rivadavia and discarded the constitution, but the federal idea for +which they stood had several meanings. To an inhabitant of Buenos Aires +federalism meant domination by the capital, not only over the province +of the same name but over the other provinces; whereas, to the people of +the provinces, and even to many of federalist faith in the province +of Buenos Aires itself, the term stood for the idea of a loose +confederation in which each provincial governor or chieftain should be +practically supreme in his own district, so long as he could maintain +himself. The Unitaries were opponents of both, except in so far as their +insistence upon a centralized form of government for the nation would +necessarily lead to the location of that government at Buenos Aires. +This peculiar dual contest between the town and the province of Buenos +Aires, and of the other provinces against either or both, persisted for +the next sixty years. In 1829, however, a prolonged lull set in, when +Rosas, the gaucho leader, having won in company with other caudillos +a decisive triumph over the Unitaries, entered the capital and took +supreme command. + +In Chile the course of events had assumed quite a different aspect. +Here, in 1818, a species of constitution had been adopted by popular +vote in a manner that appeared to show remarkable unanimity, for the +books in which the "ayes" and "noes" were to be recorded contained +no entries in the negative! What the records really prove is that +O'Higgins, the Supreme Director, enjoyed the confidence of the ruling +class. In exercise of the autocratic power entrusted to him, he now +proceeded to introduce a variety of administrative reforms of signal +advantage to the moral and material welfare of the country. But as the +danger of conquest from any quarter lessened, the demand for a more +democratic organization grew louder, until in 1822 it became so +persistent that O'Higgins called a convention to draft a new fundamental +law. But its provisions suited neither himself nor his opponents. +Thereupon, realizing that his views of the political capacity of the +people resembled those of Bolivar and were no longer applicable, and +that his reforms had aroused too much hostility, the Supreme Director +resigned his post and retired to Peru. Thus another hero of emancipation +had met the ingratitude for which republics are notorious. + +Political convulsions in the country followed the abdication of +O'Higgins. Not only had the spirit of the strife between Unitaries and +Federalists been communicated to Chile from the neighboring republic +to the eastward, but two other parties or factions, divided on still +different lines, had arisen. These were the Conservative and the +Liberal, or Bigwigs (pelucones) and Greenhorns (pipiolos), as the +adherents of the one derisively dubbed the partisans of the other. +Although in the ups and downs of the struggle two constitutions were +adopted, neither sufficed to quiet the agitation. Not until 1830, when +the Liberals sustained an utter defeat on the field of battle, did the +country enter upon a period of quiet progress along conservative lines. +From that time onward it presented a surprising contrast to its fellow +republics, which were beset with afflictions. + +Far to the northward, the Empire of Mexico set up by Iturbide in 1822 +was doomed to a speedy fall. "Emperor by divine providence," that +ambitious adventurer inscribed on his coins, but his countrymen knew +that the bayonets of his soldiers were the actual mainstay of his +pretentious title. Neither his earlier career nor the size of his +following was sufficiently impressive to assure him popular support if +the military prop gave way. His lavish expenditures, furthermore, and +his arbitrary replacement of the Congress by a docile body which would +authorize forced loans at his command, steadily undermined his position. +Apart from the faults of Iturbide himself, the popular sentiment of a +country bordering immediately upon the United States could not fail to +be colored by the ideas and institutions of its great neighbor. So, too, +the example of what had been accomplished, in form at least, by their +kinsmen elsewhere in America was bound to wield a potent influence on +the minds of the Mexicans. As a result, their desire for a republic grew +stronger from day to day. + +Iturbide, in fact, had not enjoyed his exalted rank five months when +Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna, a young officer destined later to become a +conspicuous figure in Mexican history, started a revolt to replace +the "Empire" by a republic. Though he failed in his object, two of +Iturbide's generals joined the insurgents in demanding a restoration of +the Congress--an act which, as the hapless "Emperor" perceived, would +amount to his dethronement. Realizing his impotence, Iturbide summoned +the Congress and announced his abdication. But instead of recognizing +this procedure, that body declared his accession itself null and void; +it agreed, however, to grant him a pension if he would leave the country +and reside in Italy. With this disposition of his person Iturbide +complied; but he soon wearied of exile and persuaded himself that he +would not lack supporters if he tried to regain his former control +in Mexico. This venture he decided to make in complete ignorance of a +decree ordering his summary execution if he dared to set foot again on +Mexican soil. He had hardly landed in July, 1824, when he was seized and +shot. + +Since a constituent assembly had declared itself in favor of +establishing a federal form of republic patterned after that of the +United States, the promulgation of a constitution followed on October 4, +1824, and Guadalupe Victoria, one of the leaders in the revolt against +Iturbide, was chosen President of the United Mexican States. Though +considerable unrest prevailed toward the close of his term, the new +President managed to retain his office for the allotted four years. In +most respects, however, the new order of things opened auspiciously. In +November, 1825, the surrender of the fortress of San Juan de Ulua, in +the harbor of Vera Cruz, banished the last remnant of Spanish power, +and two years later the suppression of plots for the restoration +of Ferdinand VII, coupled with the expulsion of a large number of +Spaniards, helped to restore calm. There were those even who dared to +hope that the federal system would operate as smoothly in Mexico as it +had done in the United States. + +But the political organization of a country so different from its +northern neighbor in population, traditions, and practices, could not +rest merely on a basis of imitation, even more or less modified. The +artificiality of the fabric became apparent enough as soon as ambitious +individuals and groups of malcontents concerted measures to mold it into +a likeness of reality. Two main political factions soon appeared. For +the form they assumed British and American influences were responsible. +Adopting a kind of Masonic organization, the Conservatives and +Centralists called themselves Escoceses (Scottish-Rite Men), whereas +the Radicals and Federalists took the name of Yorkinos (York-Rite Men). +Whatever their respective slogans and professions of political faith, +they were little more than personal followers of rival generals or +politicians who yearned to occupy the presidential chair. + +Upon the downfall of Iturbide, the malcontents in Central America +bestirred themselves to throw off the Mexican yoke. On July 1,1823, a +Congress declared the region an independent republic under the name of +the "United Provinces of Central America." In November of the next year, +following the precedent established in Mexico, and obedient also to +local demand, the new republic issued a constitution, in accordance +with which the five little divisions of Guatemala, Honduras, Salvador, +Nicaragua, and Costa Rica were to become states of a federal union, each +having the privilege of choosing its own local authorities. Immediately +Federalists and Centralists, Radicals and Conservatives, all wished, it +would seem, to impose their particular viewpoint upon their fellows. +The situation was not unlike that in the Argentine Confederation. The +efforts of Guatemala--the province in which power had been concentrated +under the colonial regime--to assert supremacy over its fellow states, +and their refusal to respect either the federal bond or one another's +rights made civil war inevitable. The struggle which broke out among +Guatemala, Salvador, and Honduras, lasted until 1829, when Francisco +Morazan, at the head of the "Allied Army, Upholder of the Law," entered +the capital of the republic and assumed dictatorial power. + +Of all the Hispanic nations, however, Brazil was easily the most stable. +Here the leaders, while clinging to independence, strove to avoid +dangerous innovations in government. Rather than create a political +system for which the country was not prepared, they established a +constitutional monarchy. But Brazil itself was too vast and its interior +too difficult of access to allow it to become all at once a unit, either +in organization or in spirit. The idea of national solidarity had as yet +made scant progress. The old rivalry which existed between the provinces +of the north, dominated by Bahia or Pernambuco, and those of the south, +controlled by Rio de Janeiro or Sao Paulo, still made itself felt. What +the Empire amounted to, therefore, was an agglomeration of provinces, +held together by the personal prestige of a young monarch. + +Since the mother country still held parts of northern Brazil, the +Emperor entrusted the energetic Cochrane, who had performed such valiant +service for Chile and Peru, with the task of expelling the foreign +soldiery. When this had been accomplished and a republican outbreak +in the same region had been suppressed, the more difficult task of +satisfying all parties by a constitution had to be undertaken. There +were partisans of monarchy and advocates of republicanism, men of +conservative and of liberal sympathies; disagreements, also, between the +Brazilians and the native Portuguese residents were frequent. So far as +possible Pedro desired to meet popular desires, and yet without imposing +too many limitations on the monarchy itself. But in the assembly called +to draft the constitution the liberal members made a determined effort +to introduce republican forms. Pedro thereupon dissolved that body and +in 1826 promulgated a constitution of his own. + +The popularity of the Emperor thereafter soon began to wane, partly +because of the scandalous character of his private life, and partly +because he declined to observe constitutional restrictions and chose his +ministers at will. His insistent war in Portugal to uphold the claims +of his daughter to the throne betrayed, or seemed to betray, dynastic +ambitions. His inability to hold Uruguay as a Brazilian province, and +his continued retention of foreign soldiers who had been employed in the +struggle with the Argentine Confederation, for the apparent purpose of +quelling possible insurrections in the future, bred much discontent. So +also did the restraints he laid upon the press, which had been infected +by the liberal movements in neighboring republics. When he failed +to subdue these outbreaks, his rule became all the more discredited. +Thereupon, menaced by a dangerous uprising at Rio de Janeiro in 1831, he +abdicated the throne in favor of his son, Pedro, then five years of age, +and set sail for Portugal. + +Under the influence of Great Britain the small European mother country +had in 1825 recognized the independence of its big transatlantic +dominion; but it was not until 1836 that the Cortes of Spain authorized +the Crown to enter upon negotiations looking to the same action in +regard to the eleven republics which had sprung out of its colonial +domain. Even then many years elapsed before the mother country +acknowledged the independence of them all. + + + +CHAPTER V. THE AGE OF THE DICTATORS + +Independence without liberty and statehood without respect for law are +phrases which sum up the situation in Spanish America after the failure +of Bolivar's "great design." The outcome was a collection of +crude republics, racked by internal dissension and torn by mutual +jealousy--patrias bobas, or "foolish fatherlands," as one of their own +writers has termed them. + +Now that the bond of unity once supplied by Spain had been broken, the +entire region which had been its continental domain in America dissolved +awhile into its elements. The Spanish language, the traditions and +customs of the dominant class, and a "republican" form of government, +were practically the sole ties which remained. Laws, to be sure, had +been enacted, providing for the immediate or gradual abolition of +negro slavery and for an improvement in the status of the Indian and +half-caste; but the bulk of the inhabitants, as in colonial times, +remained outside of the body politic and social. Though the so-called +"constitutions" might confer upon the colored inhabitants all the +privileges and immunities of citizens if they could read and write, +and even a chance to hold office if they could show possession of a +sufficient income or of a professional title of some sort, their usual +inability to do either made their privileges illusory. Their only share +in public concerns lay in performing military service at the behest of +their superiors. Even where the language of the constitutions did +not exclude the colored inhabitants directly or indirectly, practical +authority was exercised by dictators who played the autocrat, or by +"liberators" who aimed at the enjoyment of that function themselves. + +Not all the dictators, however, were selfish tyrants, nor all the +liberators mere pretenders. Disturbed conditions bred by twenty years +of warfare, antique methods of industry, a backward commerce, inadequate +means of communication, and a population ignorant, superstitious, and +scant, made a strong ruler more or less indispensable. Whatever his +official designation, the dictator was the logical successor of +the Spanish viceroy or captain general, but without the sense of +responsibility or the legal restraint of either. These circumstances +account for that curious political phase in the development of the +Spanish American nations--the presidential despotism. + +On the other hand, the men who denounced oppression, unscrupulousness, +and venality, and who in rhetorical pronunciamentos urged the +"people" to overthrow the dictators, were often actuated by motives of +patriotism, even though they based their declarations on assumptions +and assertions, rather than on principles and facts. Not infrequently a +liberator of this sort became "provisional president" until he +himself, or some person of his choice, could be elected "constitutional +president"--two other institutions more or less peculiar to Spanish +America. + +In an atmosphere of political theorizing mingled with ambition for +personal advancement, both leaders and followers were professed devotees +of constitutions. No people, it was thought, could maintain a real +republic and be a true democracy if they did not possess a written +constitution. The longer this was, the more precise its definition +of powers and liberties, the more authentic the republic and the more +genuine the democracy was thought to be. In some countries the notion +was carried still farther by an insistence upon frequent changes in the +fundamental law or in the actual form of government, not so much to meet +imperative needs as to satisfy a zest for experimentation or to suit the +whims of mercurial temperaments. The congresses, constituent assemblies, +and the like, which drew these instruments, were supposed to be faithful +reproductions of similar bodies abroad and to represent the popular +will. In fact, however, they were substantially colonial cabildos, +enlarged into the semblance of a legislature, intent upon local or +personal concerns, and lacking any national consciousness. In any case +the members were apt to be creatures of a republican despot or else +delegates of politicians or petty factions. + +Assuming that the leaders had a fairly clear conception of what they +wanted, even if the mass of their adherents did not, it is possible to +aline the factions or parties somewhat as follows: on the one hand, the +unitary, the military, the clerical, the conservative, and the moderate; +on the other, the federalist, the civilian, the lay, the liberal, and the +radical. Interspersed among them were the advocates of a presidential or +congressional system like that of the United States, the upholders of a +parliamentary regime like that of European nations, and the supporters +of methods of government of a more experimental kind. Broadly speaking, +the line of cleavage was made by opinions, concerning the form of +government and by convictions regarding the relations of Church and +State. These opinions were mainly a product of revolutionary experience; +these convictions, on the other hand, were a bequest from colonial +times. + +The Unitaries wished to have a system of government modeled upon that +of France. They wanted the various provinces made into administrative +districts over which the national authority should exercise full sway. +Their direct opponents, the Federalists, resembled to some extent the +Antifederalists rather than the party bearing the former title in the +earlier history of the United States; but even here an exact +analogy fails. They did not seek to have the provinces enjoy local +self-government or to have perpetuated the traditions of a sort of +municipal home rule handed down from the colonial cabildos, so much +as to secure the recognition of a number of isolated villages or small +towns as sovereign states--which meant turning them over as fiefs to +their local chieftains. Federalism, therefore, was the Spanish American +expression for a feudalism upheld by military lordlets and their +retainers. + +Among the measures of reform introduced by one republic or another +during the revolutionary period, abolition of the Inquisition had been +one of the foremost; otherwise comparatively little was done to curb +the influence of the Church. Indeed the earlier constitutions regularly +contained articles declaring Roman Catholicism the sole legal faith as +well as the religion of the state, and safeguarding in other respects +its prestige in the community. Here was an institution, wealthy, proud, +and influential, which declined to yield its ancient prerogatives and +privileges and to that end relied upon the support of clericals and +conservatives who disliked innovations of a democratic sort and viewed +askance the entry of immigrants professing an alien faith. Opposed +to the Church stood governments verging on bankruptcy, desirous of +exercising supreme control, and dominated by individuals eager to put +theories of democracy into practice and to throw open the doors of the +republic freely to newcomers from other lands. In the opinion of these +radicals the Church ought to be deprived both of its property and of its +monopoly of education. The one should be turned over to the nation, +to which it properly belonged, and should be converted into public +utilities; the other should be made absolutely secular, in order to +destroy clerical influence over the youthful mind. In this program +radicals and liberals concurred with varying degrees of intensity, +while the moderates strove to hold the balance between them and their +opponents. + +Out of this complex situation civil commotions were bound to arise. +Occasionally these were real wars, but as a rule only skirmishes or +sporadic insurrections occurred. They were called "revolutions," not +because some great principle was actually at stake but because the term +had been popular ever since the struggle with Spain. As a designation +for movements aimed at securing rotation in office, and hence control of +the treasury, it was appropriate enough! At all events, whether serious +or farcical, the commotions often involved an expenditure in life and +money far beyond the value of the interests affected. Further, both +the prevalent disorder and the centralization of authority impelled the +educated and well-to-do classes to take up their residence at the seat +of government. Not a few of the uprisings were, in fact, protests on +the part of the neglected folk in the interior of the country against +concentration of population, wealth, intellect, and power in the Spanish +American capitals. + +Among the towns of this sort was Buenos Aires. Here, in 1829, Rosas +inaugurated a career of rulership over the Argentine Confederation, +culminating in a despotism that made him the most extraordinary figure +of his time. Originally a stockfarmer and skilled in all the exercises +of the cowboy, he developed an unusual talent for administration. His +keen intelligence, supple statecraft, inflexibility of purpose, and +vigor of action, united to a shrewd understanding of human follies and +passions, gave to his personality a dominance that awed and to his word +of command a power that humbled. Over his fellow chieftains who held the +provinces in terrorized subjection, he won an ascendancy that insured +compliance with his will. The instincts of the multitude he flattered +by his generous simplicity, while he enlisted the support of the +responsible class by maintaining order in the countryside. The desire, +also, of Buenos Aires to be paramount over the other provinces had no +small share in strengthening his power. + +Relatively honest in money matters, and a stickler for precision and +uniformity, Rosas sought to govern a nation in the rough-and-ready +fashion of the stock farm. A creature of his environment, no better +and no worse than his associates, but only more capable than they, +and absolutely convinced that pitiless autocracy was the sole means of +creating a nation out of chaotic fragments, this "Robespierre of +South America" carried on his despotic sway, regardless of the fury of +opponents and the menace of foreign intervention. + +During the first three years of his control, however, except for the +rigorous suppression of unitary movements and the muzzling of the press, +few signs appeared of the "black night of Argentine history" which was +soon to close down on the land. Realizing that the auspicious moment had +not yet arrived for him to exercise the limitless power that he +thought needful, he declined an offer of reelection from the provincial +legislature, in the hope that, through a policy of conciliation, his +successor might fall a prey to the designs of the Unitaries. When this +happened, he secretly stirred up the provinces into a renewal of the +earlier disturbances, until the evidence became overwhelming that Rosas +alone could bring peace and progress out of turmoil and backwardness. +Reluctantly the legislature yielded him the power it knew he wanted. +This he would not accept until a "popular" vote of some 9000 to 4 +confirmed the choice. In 1835, accordingly, he became dictator for the +first of four successive terms of five years. + +Then ensued, notably in Buenos Aires itself, a state of affairs at once +grotesque and frightful. Not content with hunting down and inflicting +every possible, outrage upon those suspected of sympathy with the +Unitaries, Rosas forbade them to display the light blue and white colors +of their party device and directed that red, the sign of Federalism, +should be displayed on all occasions. Pink he would not tolerate as +being too attenuated a shade and altogether too suggestive of political +trimming! A band of his followers, made up of ruffians, and called the +Mazorca, or "Ear of Corn," because of the resemblance of their close +fellowship to its adhering grains, broke into private houses, destroyed +everything light blue within reach, and maltreated the unfortunate +occupants at will. No man was safe also who did not give his face a +leonine aspect by wearing a mustache and sidewhiskers--emblems, the one +of "federalism," and the other of "independence." To possess a visage +bare of these hirsute adornments or a countenance too efflorescent +in that respect was, under a regime of tonsorial politics, to invite +personal disaster! Nothing apparently was too cringing or servile to +show how submissive the people were to the mastery of Rosas. Private +vengeance and defamation of the innocent did their sinister work +unchecked. Even when his arbitrary treatment of foreigners had compelled +France for a while to institute a blockade of Buenos Aires, the wily +dictator utilized the incident to turn patriotic resentment to his own +advantage. + +Meanwhile matters in Uruguay had come to such a pass that Rosas saw an +opportunity to extend his control in that direction also. Placed +between Brazil and the Argentine Confederation and so often a bone of +contention, the little country was hardly free from the rule of the +former state when it came near falling under the domination of the +latter. Only a few years of relative tranquillity had elapsed when two +parties sprang up in Uruguay: the "Reds" (Colorados) and the "Whites" +(Blancos). Of these, the one was supposed to represent the liberal and +the other the conservative element. In fact, they were the followings +of partisan chieftains, whose struggles for the presidency during many +years to come retarded the advancement of a country to which nature had +been generous. + +When Fructuoso Rivera, the President up to 1835, thought of choosing +some one to be elected in constitutional fashion as his successor, he +unwisely singled out Manuel Oribe, one of the famous "Thirty-three" who +had raised the cry of independence a decade before. But instead of a +henchman he found a rival. Both of them straightway adopted the colors +and bid for the support of one of the local factions; and both appealed +to the factions of the Argentine Confederation for aid, Rivera to the +Unitaries and Oribe to the Federalists. In 1843, Oribe, at the head of +an army of Blancos and Federalists and with the moral support of Rosas, +laid siege to Montevideo. Defended by Colorados, Unitaries, and numerous +foreigners, including Giuseppe Garibaldi, the town held out valiantly +for eight years--a feat that earned for it the title of the "New Troy." +Anxious to stop the slaughter and destruction that were injuring their +nationals, France, Great Britain, and Brazil offered their mediation; +but Rosas would have none of it. What the antagonists did he cared +little, so long as they enfeebled the country and increased his +chances of dominating it. At length, in 1845, the two European powers +established a blockade of Argentine ports, which was not lifted +until the dictator grudgingly agreed to withdraw his troops from the +neighboring republic. + +More than any other single factor, this intervention of France and Great +Britain administered a blow to Rosas from which he could not recover. +The operations of their fleets and the resistance of Montevideo had +lowered the prestige of the dictator and had raised the hopes of +the Unitaries that a last desperate effort might shake off his hated +control. In May, 1851, Justo Jose de Urquiza, one of his most trusted +lieutenants, declared the independence of his own province and called +upon the others to rise against the tyrant. Enlisting the support +of Brazil, Uruguay, and Paraguay, he assembled a "great army of +liberation," composed of about twenty-five thousand men, at whose head +he marched to meet the redoubtable Rosas. On February 3,1852, at a spot +near Buenos Aires, the man of might who, like his contemporary Francia +in Paraguay, had held the Argentine Confederation in thralldom for so +many years, went down to final defeat. Embarking on a British warship he +sailed for England, there to become a quiet country gentleman in a land +where gauchos and dictators were unhonored. + +In the meantime Paraguay, spared from such convulsion as racked its +neighbor on the east, dragged on its secluded existence of backwardness +and stagnation. Indians and half-castes vegetated in ignorance and +docility, and the handful of whites quaked in terror, while the +inexorable Francia tightened the reins of commercial and industrial +restriction and erected forts along the frontiers to keep out the +pernicious foreigner. At his death, in 1840, men and women wept at his +funeral in fear perchance, as one historian remarks, lest he come +back to life; and the priest who officiated at the service likened the +departed dictator to Caesar and Augustus! + +Paraguay was destined, however, to fall under a despot far worse than +Francia when in 1862 Francisco Solano Lopez became President. The new +ruler was a man of considerable intelligence and education. While a +traveler in Europe he had seen much of its military organizations, and +he had also gained no slight acquaintance with the vices of its capital +cities. This acquired knowledge he joined to evil propensities until +he became a veritable monster of wickedness. Vain, arrogant, reckless, +absolutely devoid of scruple, swaggering in victory, dogged in defeat, +ferociously cruel at all times, he murdered his brothers and his best +friends; he executed, imprisoned, or banished any one whom he thought +too influential; he tortured his mother and sisters; and, like the +French Terrorists, he impaled his officers upon the unpleasant dilemma +of winning victories or losing their lives. Even members of the American +legation suffered torment at his hands, and the minister himself barely +escaped death. + +Over his people, Lopez wielded a marvelous power, compounded of +persuasive eloquence and brute force. If the Paraguayans had obeyed +their earlier masters blindly, they were dumb before this new despot +and deaf to other than his word of command. To them he was the "Great +Father," who talked to them in their own tongue of Guarani, who was +the personification of the nation, the greatest ruler in the world, the +invincible champion who inspired them with a loathing and contempt for +their enemies. Such were the traits of a man and such the traits of a +people who waged for six years a warfare among the most extraordinary in +human annals. + +What prompted Lopez to embark on his career of international madness and +prosecute it with the rage of a demon is not entirely clear. A vision +of himself as the Napoleon of southern South America, who might cause +Brazil, Argentina, and Uruguay to cringe before his footstool, while he +disposed at will of their territory and fortunes, doubtless stirred his +imagination. So, too, the thought of his country, wedged in between two +huge neighbors and threatened with suffocation between their overlapping +folds, may well have suggested the wisdom of conquering overland a +highway to the sea. At all events, he assembled an army of upwards of +ninety thousand men, the greatest military array that Hispanic America +had ever seen. Though admirably drilled and disciplined, they were +poorly armed, mostly with flintlock muskets, and they were also +deficient in artillery except that of antiquated pattern. With this +mighty force at his back, yet knowing that the neighboring countries +could eventually call into the field armies much larger in size equipped +with repeating rifles and supplied with modern artillery, the "Jupiter +of Paraguay" nevertheless made ready to launch his thunderbolt. + +The primary object at which he aimed was Uruguay. In this little state +the Colorados, upheld openly or secretly by Brazil and Argentina, were +conducting a "crusade of liberty" against the Blanco government at +Montevideo, which was favored by Paraguay. Neither of the two great +powers wished to see an alliance formed between Uruguay and Paraguay, +lest when united in this manner the smaller nations might become too +strong to tolerate further intervention in their affairs. For her part, +Brazil had motives for resentment arising out of boundary disputes with +Paraguay and Uruguay, as well as out of the inevitable injury to its +nationals inflicted by the commotions in the latter country; whereas +Argentina cherished grievances against Lopez for the audacity with which +his troops roamed through her provinces and the impudence with which his +vessels, plying on the lower Parana, ignored the customs regulations. +Thus it happened that obscure civil discords in one little republic +exploded into a terrific international struggle which shook South +America to its foundations. + +In 1864, scorning the arts of diplomacy which he did not apparently +understand, Lopez sent down an order for the two big states to leave the +matter of Uruguayan politics to his impartial adjustment. At both Rio +de Janeiro and Buenos Aires a roar of laughter went up from the press at +this notion of an obscure chieftain of a band of Indians in the tropical +backwoods daring to poise the equilibrium of much more than half a +continent on his insolent hand. But the merriment soon subsided, as +Brazilians and Argentinos came to realize what their peril might be +from a huge army of skilled and valiant soldiers, a veritable horde of +fighting fanatics, drawn up in a compact little land, centrally located +and affording in other respects every kind of strategic advantage. + +When Brazil invaded Uruguay and restored the Colorados to power, Lopez +demanded permission from Argentina to cross its frontier, for the +purpose of assailing his enemy from another quarter. When the permission +was denied, Lopez declared war on Argentina also. It was in every +respect a daring step, but Lopez knew that Argentina was not so well +prepared as his own state for a war of endurance. Uruguay then entered +into an alliance in 1865 with its two big "protectors." In accordance +with its terms, the allies agreed not to conclude peace until Lopez had +been overthrown, heavy indemnities had been exacted of Paraguay, its +fortifications demolished, its army disbanded, and the country forced to +accept any boundaries that the victors might see fit to impose. + +Into the details of the campaigns in the frightful conflict that +ensued it is not necessary to enter. Although, in 1866, the allies had +assembled an army of some fifty thousand men, Lopez continued taking +the offensive until, as the number and determination of his adversaries +increased, he was compelled to retreat into his own country. Here he and +his Indian legions levied terrific toll upon the lives of their enemies +who pressed onward, up or down the rivers and through tropical swamps +and forests. Inch by inch he contested their entry upon Paraguayan +soil. When the able-bodied men gave out, old men, boys, women, and girls +fought on with stubborn fury, and died before they would surrender. The +wounded escaped if they could, or, cursing their captors, tore off +their bandages and bled to death. Disease wrought awful havoc in all the +armies engaged; yet the struggle continued until flesh and blood could +endure no more. Flying before his pursuers into the wilds of the north +and frantically dragging along with him masses of fugitive men, women, +and children, whom he remorselessly shot, or starved to death, or left +to perish of exhaustion, Lopez turned finally at bay, and, on March 1, +1870, was felled by the lance of a cavalryman. He had sworn to die for +his country and he did, though his country might perish with him. + +No land in modern times has ever reached a point so near annihilation as +Paraguay. Added to the utter ruin of its industries and the devastation +of its fields, dwellings, and towns, hundreds of thousands of men, +women, and children had perished. Indeed, the horrors that had befallen +it might well have led the allies to ask themselves whether it was worth +while to destroy a country in order to change its rulers. Five years +before Lopez came into power the population of Paraguay had been +reckoned at something between 800,000 and 1,400,000--so unreliable were +census returns in those days. In 1878 it was estimated at about 230,000, +of whom women over fifteen years of age outnumbered the men nearly four +to one. Loose polygamy was the inevitable consequence, and women became +the breadwinners. Even today in this country the excess of females over +males is very great. All in all, it is not strange that Paraguay should +be called the "Niobe among nations." + +Unlike many nations of Spanish America in which a more or less +anticlerical regime was in the ascendant, Ecuador fell under a sort +of theocracy. Here appeared one of the strangest characters in a story +already full of extraordinary personages--Gabriel Garcia Moreno, +who became President of that republic in 1861. In some respects the +counterpart of Francia of Paraguay, in others both a medieval mystic +and an enlightened ruler of modern type, he was a man of remarkable +intellect, constructive ability, earnest patriotism, and disinterested +zeal for orderliness and progress. On his presidential sash were +inscribed the words: "My Power in the Constitution"; but is real power +lay in himself and in the system which he implanted. + +Garcia Moreno had a varied career. He had been a student of chemistry +and other natural sciences. He had spent his youth in exile in Europe, +where he prepared himself for his subsequent career as a journalist and +a university professor. Through it all he had been an active participant +in public affairs. Grim of countenance, austere in bearing, violent of +temper, relentless in severity, he was a devoted believer in the Roman +Catholic faith and in this Church as the sole effective basis upon which +a state could be founded or social and political regeneration could be +assured. In order to render effective his concept of what a nation +ought to be, Garcia Moreno introduced and upheld in all rigidity an +administration the like of which had been known hardly anywhere since +the Middle Ages. He recalled the Jesuits, established schools of the +"Brothers of the Christian Doctrine," and made education a matter wholly +under ecclesiastical control. He forbade heretical worship, called the +country the "Republic of the Sacred Heart," and entered into a concordat +with the Pope under which the Church in Ecuador became more subject to +the will of the supreme pontiff than western Europe had been in the days +of Innocent III. + +Liberals in and outside of Ecuador tried feebly to shake off this +masterful theocracy, for the friendship which Garcia Moreno displayed +toward the diplomatic representatives of the Catholic powers of Europe, +notably those of Spain and France, excited the neighboring republics. +Colombia, indeed, sent an army to liberate the "brother democrats of +Ecuador from the rule of Professor Garcia Moreno," but the mass of the +people stood loyally by their President. For this astounding obedience +to an administration apparently so unrelated to modern ideas, the +ecclesiastical domination was not solely or even chiefly responsible. +In more ways than one Garcia Moreno, the professor President, was a +statesman of vision and deed. He put down brigandage and lawlessness; +reformed the finances; erected hospitals; promoted education; and +encouraged the study of natural science. Even his salary he gave over to +public improvements. His successors in the presidential office found it +impossible to govern the country without Garcia Moreno. Elected for a +third term to carry on his curious policy of conservatism and reaction +blended with modern advancement, he fell by the hand of an assassin in +1875. But the system which he had done so much to establish in Ecuador +survived him for many years. + +Although Brazil did not escape the evils of insurrection which retarded +the growth of nearly all of its neighbors, none of its numerous +commotions shook the stability of the nation to a perilous degree. By +1850 all danger of revolution had vanished. The country began to enter +upon a career of peace and progress under a regime which combined +broadly the federal organization of the United States with the form of +a constitutional monarchy. Brazil enjoyed one of the few enlightened +despotisms in South America. Adopting at the outset the parliamentary +system, the Emperor Pedro II chose his ministers from among the liberals +or conservatives, as one party or the other might possess a majority +in the lower house of the Congress. Though the legislative power of the +nation was enjoyed almost entirely by the planters and their associates +who formed the dominant social class, individual liberty was fully +guaranteed, and even freedom of conscience and of the press was allowed. +Negro slavery, though tolerated, was not expressly recognized. + +Thanks to the political discretion and unusual personal qualities of +"Dom Pedro," his popularity became more and more marked as the years +went on. A patron of science and literature, a scholar rather than a +ruler, a placid and somewhat eccentric philosopher, careless of the +trappings of state, he devoted himself without stint to the public +welfare. Shrewdly divining that the monarchical system might not survive +much longer, he kept his realm pacified by a policy of conciliation. +Pedro II even went so far as to call himself the best republican in the +Empire. He might have said, with justice perhaps, that he was the best +republican in the whole of Hispanic America. What he really accomplished +was the successful exercise of a paternal autocracy of kindness and +liberality over his subjects. + +If more or less permanent dictators and occasional liberators were the +order of the day in most of the Spanish American republics, intermittent +dictators and liberators dashed across the stage in Mexico from 1829 +well beyond the middle of the century. The other countries could show +numerous instances in which the occupant of the chief magistracy held +office to the close of his constitutional term; but Mexico could not +show a single one! What Mexico furnished, instead, was a kaleidoscopic +spectacle of successive presidents or dictators, an unstable array of +self-styled "generals" without a presidential succession. There were +no fewer than fifty such transient rulers in thirty-two years, with +anywhere from one to six a year, with even the same incumbent twice in +one year, or, in the case of the repetitious Santa Anna, nine times +in twenty years--in spite of the fact that the constitutional term of +office was four years. This was a record that made the most turbulent +South American states seem, by comparison, lands of methodical +regularity in the choice of their national executive. And as if this +instability in the chief magistracy were not enough, the form of +government in Mexico shifted violently from federal to centralized, and +back again to federal. Mad struggles raged between partisan chieftains +and their bands of Escoceses and Yorkinos, crying out upon the +"President" in power because of his undue influence upon the choice of a +successor, backing their respective candidates if they lost, and waiting +for a chance to oust them if they won. + +This tumultuous epoch had scarcely begun when Spain in 1829 made a final +attempt to recover her lost dominion in Mexico. Local quarrels were +straightway dropped for two months until the invaders had surrendered. +Thereupon the great landholders, who disliked the prevailing Yorkino +regime for its democratic policies and for favoring the abolition +of slavery, rallied to the aid of a "general" who issued a manifesto +demanding an observance of the constitution and the laws! After Santa +Anna, who was playing the role of a Mexican Warwick, had disposed of +this aspirant, he switched blithely over to the Escoceses, reduced the +federal system almost to a nullity, and in 1836 marched away to conquer +the revolting Texans. But, instead, they conquered him and gained their +independence, so that his reward was exile. + +Now the Escoceses were free to promulgate a new constitution, to abolish +the federal arrangement altogether, and to replace it by a strongly +centralized government under which the individual States became mere +administrative districts. Hardly had this radical change been effected +when in 1838 war broke out with France on account of the injuries which +its nationals, among whom were certain pastry cooks, had suffered during +the interminable commotions. Mexico was forced to pay a heavy indemnity; +and Santa Anna, who had returned to fight the invader, was unfortunate +enough to lose a leg in the struggle. This physical deprivation, +however, did not interfere with that doughty hero's zest for tilting +with other unquiet spirits who yearned to assure national regeneration +by continuing to elevate and depose "presidents." + +Another swing of the political pendulum had restored the federal system +when again everything was overturned by the disastrous war with the +United States. Once more Santa Anna returned, this time, however, +to joust in vain with the "Yankee despoilers" who were destined to +dismember Mexico and to annex two-thirds of its territory. Again Santa +Anna was banished--to dream of a more favorable opportunity when he +might become the savior of a country which had fallen into bankruptcy +and impotence. + +His opportunity came in 1853, when conservatives and clericals indulged +the fatuous hope that he would both sustain their privileges and lift +Mexico out of its sore distress. Either their memories were short +or else distance had cast a halo about his figure. At all events, +he returned from exile and assumed, for the ninth and last time, +a presidency which he intended to be something more than a mere +dictatorship. Scorning the formality of a Congress, he had himself +entitled "Most Serene Highness," as indicative of his ambition to become +a monarch in name as well as in fact. + +Royal or imperial designs had long since brought one military upstart to +grief. They were now to cut Santa Anna's residence in Mexico similarly +short. Eruptions of discontent broke out all over the country. Unable to +make them subside, Santa Anna fell back upon an expedient which recalls +practices elsewhere in Spanish America. He opened registries in which +all citizens might record "freely" their approval or disapproval of +his continuance in power. Though he obtained the huge majority of +affirmative votes to be expected in such cases, he found that these +pen-and-ink signatures were no more serviceable than his soldiers. +Accordingly the dictator of many a day, fallen from his former estate +of highness, decided to abandon his serenity also, and in 1854 fled the +country--for its good and his own. + + + +CHAPTER VI. PERIL FROM ABROAD + +Apart from the spoliation of Mexico by the United States, the +independence of the Hispanic nations had not been menaced for more +than thirty years. Now comes a period in which the plight of their big +northern neighbor, rent in twain by civil war and powerless to enforce +the spirit of the Monroe Doctrine, caused two of the countries to become +subject a while to European control. One of these was the Dominican +Republic. + +In 1844 the Spanish-speaking population of the eastern part of the +island of Santo Domingo, writhing under the despotic yoke of Haiti, had +seized a favorable occasion to regain their freedom. But the magic word +"independence" could not give stability to the new state any more than +it had done in the case of its western foes. The Haitians had +lapsed long since into a condition resembling that of their African +forefathers. They reveled in the barbarities of Voodoo, a sort of snake +worship, and they groveled before "presidents" and "emperors" who rose +and fell on the tide of decaying civilization. The Dominicans unhappily +were not much more progressive. Revolutions alternated with invasions +and counter-invasions and effectually prevented enduring progress. + +On several occasions the Dominicans had sought reannexation to Spain +or had craved the protection of France as a defense against continual +menace from their negro enemies and as a relief from domestic turmoil. +But every move in this direction failed because of a natural reluctance +on the part of Spain and France, which was heightened by a refusal +of the United States to permit what it regarded as a violation of the +Monroe Doctrine. In 1861, however, the outbreak of civil war in the +United States appeared to present a favorable opportunity to obtain +protection from abroad. If the Dominican Republic could not remain +independent anyway, reunion with the old mother country seemed +altogether preferable to reconquest by Haiti. The President, therefore, +entered into negotiations with the Spanish Governor and Captain General +of Cuba, and then issued a proclamation signed by himself and four of +his ministers announcing that by the "free and spontaneous will" of +its citizens, who had conferred upon him the power to do so, the nation +recognized Queen Isabella II as its lawful sovereign! Practically +no protest was made by the Dominicans against this loss of their +independence. + +Difficulties which should have been foreseen by Spain were quick to +reveal themselves. It fell to the exPresident, now a colonial +governor and captain general, to appoint a host of officials and, not +unnaturally, he named his own henchmen. By so doing he not only aroused +the animosity of the disappointed but stimulated that of the otherwise +disaffected as well, until both the aggrieved factions began to plot +rebellion. Spain, too, sent over a crowd of officials who could not +adjust themselves to local conditions. The failure of the mother country +to allow the Dominicans representation in the Spanish Cortes and +its readiness to levy taxes stirred up resentment that soon ended +in revolution. Unable to check this new trouble, and awed by the +threatening attitude of the United States, Spain decided to withdraw +in 1865. The Dominicans thus were left with their independence and +a chance--which they promptly seized--to renew their commotions. So +serious did these disturbances become that in 1869 the President of +the reconstituted republic sought annexation to the United States but +without success. American efforts, on the other hand, were equally +futile to restore peace and order in the troubled country until many +years later. + +The intervention of Spain in Santo Domingo and its subsequent withdrawal +could not fail to have disastrous consequences in its colony of Cuba, +the "Pearl of the Antilles" as it was proudly called. Here abundant +crops of sugar and tobacco had brought wealth and luxury, but not many +immigrants because of the havoc made by epidemics of yellow fever. +Nearly a third of the insular population was still composed of negro +slaves, who could hardly relish the thought that, while the mother +country had tolerated the suppression of the hateful institution in +Santo Domingo, she still maintained it in Cuba. A bureaucracy, also, +prone to corruption owing to the temptations of loose accounting at the +custom house, governed in routinary, if not in arbitrary, fashion. +Under these circumstances dislike for the suspicious and repressive +administration of Spain grew apace, and secret societies renewed their +agitation for its overthrow. The symptoms of unrest were aggravated by +the forced retirement of Spain from Santo Domingo. If the Dominicans +had succeeded so well, it ought not to be difficult for a prolonged +rebellion to wear Spain out and compel it to abandon Cuba also. At this +critical moment news was brought of a Spanish revolution across the +seas. + +Just as the plight of Spain in 1808, and again in 1820, had afforded a +favorable opportunity for its colonies on the continents of America to +win their independence, so now in 1868 the tidings that Queen Isabella +had been dethroned by a liberal uprising aroused the Cubans to action +under their devoted leader, Carlos Manuel de Cespedes. The insurrection +had not gained much headway, however, when the provisional government of +the mother country instructed a new Governor and Captain General--whose +name, Dulce (Sweet), had an auspicious sound--to open negotiations with +the insurgents and to hold out the hope of reforms. But the royalists, +now as formerly, would listen to no compromise. Organizing themselves +into bodies of volunteers, they drove Dulce out. He was succeeded by one +Caballero de Rodas (Knight of Rhodes) who lived up to his name by trying +to ride roughshod over the rebellious Cubans. Thus began the Ten Years' +War--a war of skirmishes and brief encounters, rarely involving a +decisive action, which drenched the soil of Cuba with blood and laid +waste its fields in a fury of destruction. + +Among the radicals and liberals who tried to retain a fleeting control +over Mexico after the final departure of Santa Anna was the first +genuine statesman it had ever known in its history as a republic--Benito +Pablo Juarez, an Indian. At twelve years of age he could not read +or write or even speak Spanish. His employer, however, noted his +intelligence and had him educated. Becoming a lawyer, Juarez entered +the political arena and rose to prominence by dint of natural talent +for leadership, an indomitable perseverance, and a sturdy patriotism. A +radical by conviction, he felt that the salvation of Mexico could never +be attained until clericalism and militarism had been banished from its +soil forever. + +Under his influence a provisional government had already begun a +policy of lessening the privileges of the Church, when the conservative +elements, with a cry that religion was being attacked, rose up in arms +again. This movement repressed, a Congress proceeded in 1857 to issue +a liberal constitution which was destined to last for sixty years. It +established the federal system in a definite fashion, abolished special +privileges, both ecclesiastical and military, and organized the country +on sound bases worthy of a modern nation. Mexico seemed about to enter +upon a rational development. But the newly elected President, yielding +to the importunities of the clergy, abolished the constitution, +dissolved the legislature, and set up a dictatorship, in spite of the +energetic protests of Juarez, who had been chosen Chief Justice of the +Supreme Court, and who, in accordance with the terms of the temporarily +discarded instrument, was authorized to assume the presidency should +that office fall vacant. The rule of the usurper was short-lived, +however. Various improvised "generals" of conservative stripe put +themselves at the head of a movement to "save country, religion, and the +rights of the army," drove the would-be dictator out, and restored the +old regime. + +Juarez now proclaimed himself acting President, as he was legally +entitled to do, and set up his government at Vera Cruz while one +"provisional president" followed another. Throughout this trying time +Juarez defended his position vigorously and rejected every offer +of compromise. In 1859 he promulgated his famous Reform Laws which +nationalized ecclesiastical property, secularized cemeteries, suppressed +religious communities, granted freedom of worship, and made marriage +a civil contract. For Mexico, however, as for other Spanish American +countries, measures of the sort were far too much in advance of their +time to insure a ready acceptance. Although Juarez obtained a great +moral victory when his government was recognized by the United States, +he had to struggle two years more before he could gain possession of the +capital. Triumphant in 1861, he carried his anticlerical program to the +point of actually expelling the Papal Nuncio and other ecclesiastics +who refused to obey his decrees. By so doing he leveled the way for +the clericals, conservatives, and the militarists to invite foreign +intervention on behalf of their desperate cause. But, even if they had +not been guilty of behavior so unpatriotic, the anger of the Pope over +the treatment of his Church, the wrath of Spain over the conduct of +Juarez, who had expelled the Spanish minister for siding with the +ecclesiastics, the desire of Great Britain to collect debts due to her +subjects, and above all the imperialistic ambitions of Napoleon III, who +dreamt of converting the intellectual influence of France in Hispanic +America into a political ascendancy, would probably have led to European +occupation in any event, so long at least as the United States was slit +asunder and incapable of action. + +Some years before, the Mexican Government under the clerical and +militarist regime had made a contract with a Swiss banker who for a +payment of $500,000 had received bonds worth more than fifteen times the +value of the loan. When, therefore, the Mexican Congress undertook to +defer payments on a foreign debt that included the proceeds of this +outrageous contract, the Governments of France, Great Britain, and Spain +decided to intervene. According to their agreement the three powers were +simply to hold the seaports of Mexico and collect the customs duties +until their pecuniary demands had been satisfied. Learning, however, +that Napoleon III had ulterior designs, Great Britain and Spain withdrew +their forces and left him to proceed with his scheme of conquest. After +capturing Puebla in May, 1863, a French army numbering some thirty +thousand men entered the capital and installed an assemblage of notables +belonging to the clerical and conservative groups. This body thereupon +proclaimed the establishment of a constitutional monarchy under an +emperor. The title was to be offered to Maximilian, Archduke of Austria. +In case he should not accept, the matter was to be referred to the +"benevolence of his majesty, the Emperor of the French," who might then +select some other Catholic prince. + +On his arrival, a year later, the amiable and well-meaning Maximilian +soon discovered that, instead of being an "Emperor," he was actually +little more than a precarious chief of a faction sustained by the +bayonets of a foreign army. In the northern part of Mexico, Juarez, +Porfirio Diaz,--later to become the most renowned of presidential +autocrats,--and other patriot leaders, though hunted from place to +place, held firmly to their resolve never to bow to the yoke of the +pretender. Nor could Maximilian be sure of the loyalty of even his +supposed adherents. Little by little the unpleasant conviction intruded +itself upon him that he must either abdicate or crush all resistance in +the hope that eventually time and good will might win over the Mexicans. +But do what they would, his foreign legions could not catch the wary +and stubborn Juarez and his guerrilla lieutenants, who persistently wore +down the forces of their enemies. Then the financial situation became +grave. Still more menacing was the attitude of the United States now +that its civil war was at an end. On May 31, 1866, Maximilian received +word that Napoleon III had decided to withdraw the French troops. +He then determined to abdicate, but he was restrained by the unhappy +Empress Carlotta, who hastened to Europe to plead his cause with +Napoleon. Meantime, as the French troops were withdrawn, Juarez occupied +the territory. + +Feebly the "Emperor" strove to enlist the favor of his adversaries by a +number of liberal decrees; but their sole result was his abandonment +by many a lukewarm conservative. Inexorably the patriot armies closed +around him until in May, 1867, he was captured at Queretaro, where he +had sought refuge. Denied the privilege of leaving the country on a +promise never to return, he asked Escobedo, his captor, to treat him +as a prisoner of war. "That's my business," was the grim reply. On the +pretext that Maximilian had refused to recognize the competence of the +military court chosen to try him, Juarez gave the order to shoot him. +On the 19th of June the Austrian archduke paid for a fleeting glory +with his life. Thus failed the second attempt at erecting an empire in +Mexico. For thirty-four years diplomatic relations between that country +and Austria-Hungary were severed. The clerical-military combination had +been overthrown, and the Mexican people had rearmed their independence. +As Juarez declared: "Peace means respect for the rights of others." + +Even if foreign dreams of empire in Mexico had vanished so abruptly, it +could hardly be expected that a land torn for many years by convulsions +could become suddenly tranquil. With Diaz and other aspirants to +presidential power, or with chieftains who aimed at setting up little +republics of their own in the several states, Juarez had to contend for +some time before he could establish a fair amount of order. Under his +successor, who also was a civilian, an era of effective reform began. In +1873 amendments to the constitution declared Church and State absolutely +separate and provided for the abolition of peonage--a provision which +was more honored in, the breach than in the observance. + + + +CHAPTER VII. GREATER STATES AND LESSER + +During the half century that had elapsed since 1826, the nations of +Hispanic America had passed through dark ages. Their evolution had +always been accompanied by growing pains and had at times been arrested +altogether or unduly hastened by harsh injections of radicalism. It was +not an orderly development through gradual modifications in the social +and economic structure, but rather a fitful progress now assisted and +now retarded by the arbitrary deeds of men of action, good and bad, who +had seized power. Dictators, however, steadily decreased in number and +gave place often to presidential autocrats who were continued in office +by constant reelection and who were imbued with modern ideas. In 1876 +these Hispanic nations stood on the threshold of a new era. Some were +destined to advance rapidly beyond it; others, to move slowly onward; +and a few to make little or no progress. + +The most remarkable feature in the new era was the rise of four +states--Mexico, Brazil, Argentina, and Chile--to a position of eminence +among their fellows. Extent of territory, development of natural +resources, the character of the inhabitants and the increase of their +numbers, and the amount of popular intelligence and prosperity, all +contributed to this end. Each of the four nations belonged to a fairly +well-defined historical and geographical group in southern North +America, and in eastern and western South America, respectively. In +the first group were Mexico, the republics of Central America, and the +island countries of the Caribbean; in the second, Brazil, Argentina, +Uruguay, and Paraguay; and in the third, Chile, Peru, and Bolivia. In a +fourth group were Ecuador, Colombia, and Venezuela. + +When the President of Mexico proceeded, in 1876, to violate the +constitution by securing his reelection, the people were prepared by +their earlier experiences and by the rule of Juarez to defend their +constitutional rights. A widespread rebellion headed by Diaz broke +out. In the so-called "Plan of Tuxtepec" the revolutionists declared +themselves in favor of the principle of absolutely no reelection. +Meantime the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court handed down a decision +that the action of the Congress in sustaining the President was illegal, +since in reality no elections had been held because of the abstention +of voters and the seizure of the polls by revolutionists or government +forces. "Above the constitution, nothing; above the constitution, no +one," he declared. But as this assumption of a power of judgment on +matters of purely political concern was equally a violation of the +constitution and concealed, besides, an attempt to make the Chief +Justice President, Diaz and his followers drove both of the pretenders +out. Then in 1876 he managed to bring about his own election instead. + +Porfirio Diaz was a soldier who had seen active service in nearly every +important campaign since the war with the United States. Often himself +in revolt against presidents, legal and illegal, Diaz was vastly more +than an ordinary partisan chieftain. Schooled by a long experience, +he had come to appreciate the fact that what Mexico required for its +national development was freedom from internal disorders and a fair +chance for recuperation. Justice, order, and prosperity, he felt, could +be assured only by imposing upon the country the heavy weight of an iron +hand. Foreign capital must be invested in Mexico and then protected; +immigration must be encouraged, and other material, moral, and +intellectual aid of all sorts must be drawn from abroad for the +upbuilding of the nation. + +To effect such a transformation in a land so tormented and impoverished +as Mexico--a country which, within the span of fifty-five years had +lived under two "emperors," and some thirty-six presidents, nine +"provisional presidents," ten dictators, twelve "regents," and five +"supreme councilors"--required indeed a masterful intelligence and a +masterful authority. Porfirio Diaz possessed and exercised both. He was, +in fact, just the man for the times. An able administrator, stern and +severe but just, rather reserved in manner and guarded in utterance, +shrewd in the selection of associates, and singularly successful in +his dealings with foreigners, he entered upon a "presidential reign" of +thirty-five years broken by but one intermission of four--which brought +Mexico out upon the highway to new national life. + +Under the stable and efficient rulership of Diaz, "plans," +"pronunciamentos," "revolutions," and similar devices of professional +trouble makers, had short shrift. Whenever an uprising started, it was +promptly quelled, either by a well-disciplined army or by the rurales, +a mounted police made up to some extent of former bandits to whom the +President gave the choice of police service or of sharp punishment for +their crimes. Order, in fact, was not always maintained, nor was justice +always meted out, by recourse to judges and courts. Instead, a novel +kind of lynch law was invoked. The name it bore was the ley fuga, or +"flight law," in accordance with which malefactors or political suspects +taken by government agents from one locality to another, on the excuse +of securing readier justice, were given by their captors a pretended +chance to escape and were then shot while they ran! The only difference +between this method and others of the sort employed by Spanish American +autocrats to enforce obedience lay in its purpose. Of Diaz one might say +what Bacon said of King Henry VII: "He drew blood as physicians do, to +save life rather than to spill it." If need be, here and there, disorder +and revolt were stamped out by terrorism; but the Mexican people did not +yield to authority from terror but rather from a thorough loyalty to the +new regime. + +Among the numerous measures of material improvement which Diaz undertook +during his first term, the construction of railways was the most +important. The size of the country, its want of navigable rivers, and +its relatively small and widely scattered population, made imperative +the establishment of these means of communication. Despite the +misgivings of many intelligent Mexicans that the presence of foreign +capital would impair local independence in some way, Diaz laid the +foundations of future national prosperity by granting concessions to +the Mexican Central and National Mexican companies, which soon began +construction. Under his successor a national bank was created; and +when Diaz was again elected he readjusted the existing foreign debt and +boldly contracted new debts abroad. + +At the close of his first term, in 1880, a surplus in the treasury was +not so great a novelty as the circumstance altogether unique in the +political annals of Mexico-that Diaz turned over the presidency +in peaceful fashion to his properly elected successor! He did so +reluctantly, to be sure, but he could not afford just yet to ignore his +own avowed principle, which had been made a part of the constitution +shortly after his accession. Although the confidence he reposed in that +successor was not entirely justified, the immense personal popularity +of Diaz saved the prestige of the new chief magistrate. Under his +administration the constitution was amended in such a way as to deprive +the Chief Justice of the privilege of replacing the President in case +of a vacancy, thus eliminating that official from politics. After his +resumption of office, Diaz had the fundamental law modified anew, so +as to permit the reelection of a President for one term only! For this +change, inconsistent though it may seem, Diaz was not alone responsible. +Circumstances had changed, and the constitution had to change with them. + +Had the "United Provinces of Central America," as they came forth from +under the rule of Spain, seen fit to abstain from following in the +unsteady footsteps of Mexico up to the time of the accession of Diaz to +power, had they done nothing more than develop their natural wealth and +utilize their admirable geographical situation, they might have become +prosperous and kept their corporate name. As it was, their history +for upwards of forty years had little to record other than a +momentary cohesion and a subsequent lapse into five quarrelsome little +republics--the "Balkan States" of America. Among them Costa Rica had +suffered least from arbitrary management or internal commotion and +showed the greatest signs of advancement. + +In Guatemala, however, there had arisen another Diaz, though a man quite +inferior in many respects to his northern counterpart. When Justo Rufino +Barrios became President of that republic in 1873 he was believed +to have conservative leanings. Ere long, however, he astounded his +compatriots by showing them that he was a thoroughgoing radical with +methods of action to correspond to his convictions. Not only did he +keep the Jesuits out of the country but he abolished monastic orders +altogether and converted their buildings to public use. He made marriage +a civil contract and he secularized the burying grounds. Education +he encouraged by engaging the services of foreign instructors, and he +brought about a better observance of the law by the promulgation of +new codes. He also introduced railways and telegraph lines. Since +the manufacture of aniline dyes abroad had diminished the demand for +cochineal, Barrios decided to replace this export by cultivating coffee. +To this end, he distributed seeds among the planters and furnished +financial aid besides, with a promise to inspect the fields in due +season and see what had been accomplished. Finding that in many cases +the seeds had been thrown away and the money wasted in drink and +gambling, he ordered the guilty planters to be given fifty lashes, with +the assurance that on a second offense he would shoot them on sight. +Coffee planting in Guatemala was pursued thereafter with much alacrity! + +Posts in the government service Barrios distributed quite impartially +among Conservatives and Democrats, deserving or otherwise, for he had +them both well under control. At his behest a permanent constitution was +promulgated in 1880. While he affected to dislike continual reelection, +he saw to it nevertheless that he himself should be the sole candidate +who was likely to win. + +Barrios doubtless could have remained President of Guatemala for +the term of his natural life if he had not raised up the ghost of +federation. All the republics of Central America accepted his invitation +in 1876 to send delegates to his capital to discuss the project. But +nothing was accomplished because Barrios and the President of Salvador +were soon at loggerheads. Nine years later, feeling himself stronger, +Barrios again proposed federation. But the other republics had by this +time learned too much of the methods of the autocrat of Guatemala, even +while they admired his progressive policy, to relish the thought of a +federation dominated by Guatemala and its masterful President. Though +he "persuaded" Honduras to accept the plan, the three other republics +preferred to unite in self-defense, and in the ensuing struggle the +quixotic Barrios was killed. A few years later the project was revived +and the constitution of a "Republic of Central America" was agreed upon, +when war between Guatemala and Salvador again frustrated its execution. + +In Brazil two great movements were by this time under way: the total +abolition of slavery and the establishment of a republic. Despite the +tenacious opposition of many of the planters, from about the year 1883 +the movement for emancipation made great headway. There was a growing +determination on the part of the majority of the inhabitants to remove +the blot that made the country an object of reproach among the civilized +states of the world. Provinces and towns, one after another, freed +the slaves within their borders. The imperial Government, on its part, +hastened the process by liberating its own slaves and by imposing upon +those still in bondage taxes higher than their market value; it fixed a +price for other slaves; it decreed that the older slaves should be set +free; and it increased the funds already appropriated to compensate +owners of slaves who should be emancipated. In 1887 the number of slaves +had fallen to about 720,000, worth legally about $650 each. A year later +came the final blow, when the Princess Regent assented to a measure +which abolished slavery outright and repealed all former acts relating +to slavery. So radical a proceeding wrought havoc in the coffee-growing +southern provinces in particular, from which the negroes now freed +migrated by tens of thousands to the northern provinces. Their places, +however, were taken by Italians and other Europeans who came to work the +plantations on a cooperative basis. All through the eighties, in fact, +immigrants from Italy poured into the temperate regions of southern +Brazil, to the number of nearly two hundred thousand, supplementing the +many thousands of Germans who had settled, chiefly in the province of +Rio Grande do Sul, thirty years before. + +Apart from the industrial problem thus created by the abolition of +slavery, there seemed to be no serious political or economic questions +before the country. Ever since 1881, when a law providing for direct +elections was passed, the Liberals had been in full control. The old +Dom Pedro, who had endeared himself to his people, was as much liked +and respected as ever. But as he had grown feeble and almost blind, +the heiress to the throne, who had marked absolutist and clerical +tendencies, was disposed to take advantage of his infirmities. + +For many years, on the other hand, doctrines opposed to the principle of +monarchy had been spread in zealous fashion by members of the military +class, notable among whom was Deodoro da Fonseca. And now some of the +planters longed to wreak vengeance on a ruler who had dared to +thwart their will by emancipating the slaves. Besides this persistent +discontent, radical republican newspapers continually stirred up fresh +agitation. Whatever the personal service rendered by the Emperor to the +welfare of the country, to them he represented a political system which +deprived the provinces of much of their local autonomy and the Brazilian +people at large of self-government. + +But the chief reason for the momentous change which was about to take +place was the fact that the constitutional monarchy had really completed +its work as a transitional government. Under that regime Brazil had +reached a condition of stability and had attained a level of progress +which might well enable it to govern itself. During all this time the +influence of the Spanish American nations had been growing apace. +Even if they had fallen into many a political calamity, they were +nevertheless "republics," and to the South American this word had a +magic sound. Above all, there was the potent suggestion of the success +of the United States of North America, whose extension of its federal +system over a vast territory suggested what Brazil with its provinces +might accomplish in the southern continent. Hence the vast majority of +intelligent Brazilians felt that they had become self-reliant enough +to establish a republic without fear of lapsing into the unfortunate +experiences of the other Hispanic countries. + +In 1889, when provision was made for a speedy abdication of the Emperor +in favor of his daughter, the republican newspapers declared that a +scheme was being concocted to exile the chief military agitators and +to interfere with any effort on the part of the army to prevent the +accession of the new ruler. Thereupon, on the 15th of November, the +radicals at Rio de Janeiro, aided by the garrison, broke out in open +revolt. Proclaiming the establishment of a federal republic under +the name of the "United States of Brazil," they deposed the imperial +ministry, set up a provisional government with Deodoro da Fonseca at its +head, arranged for the election of a constitutional convention, and bade +Dom Pedro and his family leave the country within twenty-four hours. + +On the 17th of November, before daybreak, the summons was obeyed. Not +a soul appeared to bid the old Emperor farewell as he and his family +boarded the steamer that was to bear them to exile in Europe. Though +seemingly an act of heartlessness and ingratitude, the precaution was +a wise one in that it averted, possible conflict and bloodshed. For the +second time in its history, a fundamental change had been wrought in +the political system of the nation without a resort to war! The United +States of Brazil accordingly took its place peacefully among its fellow +republics of the New World. + +Meanwhile Argentina, the great neighbor of Brazil to the southwest, had +been gaining territory and new resources. Since the definite adoption +of a federal constitution in 1853, this state had attained to a +considerable degree of national consciousness under the leadership of +able presidents such as Bartolome Mitre, the soldier and historian, +and Domingo Faustino Sarmiento, the publicist and promoter of popular +education. One evidence of this new nationalism was a widespread +belief in the necessity of territorial expansion. Knowing that Chile +entertained designs upon Patagonia, the Argentine Government forestalled +any action by conducting a war of practical extermination against the +Indian tribes of that region and by adding it to the national domain. +The so-called "conquest of the desert" in the far south of the continent +opened to civilization a vast habitable area of untold economic +possibilities. + +In the electoral campaign of 1880 the presidential candidates were Julio +Argentino Roca and the Governor of the province of Buenos Aires. The +former, an able officer skilled in both arms and politics, had on +his side the advantage of a reputation won in the struggle with the +Patagonian Indians, the approval of the national Government, and the +support of most of the provinces. Feeling certain of defeat at the +polls, the partisans of the latter candidate resorted to the timeworn +expedient of a revolt. Though the uprising lasted but twenty days, the +diplomatic corps at the capital proffered its mediation between the +contestants, in order to avoid any further bloodshed. The result was +that the fractious Governor withdrew his candidacy and a radical change +was effected in the relations of Buenos Aires, city and province, to the +country at large. The city, together with its environs, was converted +into a federal district and became solely and distinctively the national +capital. Its public buildings, railways, and telegraph service, as well +as the provincial debt, were taken over by the general Government. The +seat of provincial authority was transferred to the village of Ensenada, +which thereupon was rechristened La Plata. + +A veritable tide of wealth and general prosperity was now rolling over +Argentina. By 1885 its population had risen to upwards of 3,000,000. +Immigration increased to a point far beyond the wildest expectations. +In 1889 alone about 300,000 newcomers arrived and lent their aid in +the promotion of industry and commerce. Fields hitherto uncultivated or +given over to grazing now bore vast crops of wheat, maize, linseed, and +sugar. Large quantities of capital, chiefly from Great Britain, also +poured into the country. As a result, the price of land rose high, +and feverish speculation became the order of the day. Banks and other +institutions of credit were set up, colonizing schemes were devised, and +railways were laid out. To meet the demands of all these enterprises, +the Government borrowed immense sums from foreign capitalists and issued +vast quantities of paper money, with little regard for its ultimate +redemption. Argentina spent huge sums in prodigal fashion on all sorts +of public improvements in an effort to attract still more capital and +immigration, and thus entered upon a dangerous era of inflation. + +Of the near neighbors of Argentina, Uruguay continued along the +tortuous path of alternate disturbance and progress, losing many of its +inhabitants to the greater states beyond, where they sought relative +peace and security; while Paraguay, on the other hand, enjoyed freedom +from civil strife, though weighed down with a war debt and untold +millions in indemnities exacted by Argentina and Brazil, which it could +never hope to pay. In consequence, this indebtedness was a useful club +to brandish over powerless Paraguay whenever that little country might +venture to question the right of either of its big neighbors to break +the promise they had made of keeping its territory intact. Argentina, +however, consented in 1878 to refer certain claims to the decision of +the President of the United States. When Paraguay won the arbitration, +it showed its gratitude by naming one of its localities Villa Hayes. +As time went on, however, its population increased and hid many of the +scars of war. + +On the western side of South America there broke out the struggle known +as the "War of the Pacific" between Chile, on the one side, and Peru and +Bolivia as allies on the other. In Peru unstable and corrupt governments +had contracted foreign loans under conditions that made their repayment +almost impossible and had spent the proceeds in so reckless and +extravagant a fashion as to bring the country to the verge of +bankruptcy. Bolivia, similarly governed, was still the scene of +the orgies and carnivals which had for some time characterized its +unfortunate history. One of its buffoon "presidents," moreover, had +entered into boundary agreements with both Chile and Brazil, under which +the nation lost several important areas and some of its territory on the +Pacific. The boundaries of Bolivia, indeed, were run almost everywhere +on purely arbitrary lines drawn with scant regard for the physical +features of the country and with many a frontier question left wholly +unsettled. For some years Chilean companies and speculators, aided by +foreign capital mainly British in origin, had been working deposits +of nitrate of soda in the province of Antofagasta, or "the desert +of Atacama," a region along the coast to the northward belonging to +Bolivia, and also in the provinces of Tacna, Arica, and Tarapaca, still +farther to the northward, belonging to Peru. Because boundary lines were +not altogether clear and because the three countries were all eager to +exploit these deposits, controversies over this debatable ground were +sure to rise. For the privilege of developing portions of this region, +individuals and companies had obtained concessions from the various +governments concerned; elsewhere, industrial free lances dug away +without reference to such formalities. + +It is quite likely that Chile, whose motto was "By Right or by +Might," was prepared to sustain the claims of its citizens by either +alternative. At all events, scenting a prospective conflict, Chile had +devoted much attention to the development of its naval and military +establishment--a state of affairs which did not escape the observation +of its suspicious neighbors. + +The policy of Peru was determined partly by personal motives and partly +by reasons of state. In 1873 the President, lacking sufficient financial +and political support to keep himself in office, resolved upon the risky +expedient of arousing popular passion against Chile, in the hope that he +might thereby replenish the national treasury. Accordingly he +proceeded to pick a quarrel by ordering the deposits in Tarapaca to be +expropriated with scant respect for the concessions made to the Chilean +miners. Realizing, however, the possible consequences of such an +action, he entered into an alliance with Bolivia. This country thereupon +proceeded to levy an increased duty on the exportation of nitrates from +the Atacama region. Chile, already aware of the hostile combination +which had been formed, protested so vigorously that a year later Bolivia +agreed to withdraw the new regulations and to submit the dispute to +arbitration. + +Such were the relations of these three states in 1878, when Bolivia, +taking advantage of differences of opinion between Chile and Argentina +regarding the Patagonian region, reimposed its export duty, canceled the +Chilean concessions, and confiscated the nitrate deposits. Chile then +declared war in February, 1879, and within two months occupied the +entire coast of Bolivia up to the frontiers of Peru. On his part the +President of Bolivia was too much engrossed in the festivities connected +with a masquerade to bother about notifying the people that their land +had been invaded until several days after the event had occurred! + +Misfortunes far worse than anything which had fallen to the lot of its +ally now awaited Peru, which first attempted an officious mediation and +then declared war on the 4th of April. Since Peru and Bolivia together +had a population double that of Chile, and since Peru possessed a much +larger army and navy than Chile, the allies counted confidently on +victory. But Peru's army of eight thousand--having within four hundred +as many officers as men, directed by no fewer than twenty-six generals, +and presided over by a civil government altogether inept--was no match +for an army less than a third of its size to be sure, but well drilled +and commanded, and with a stable, progressive, and efficient government +at its back. The Peruvian forces, lacking any substantial support from +Bolivia, crumpled under the terrific attacks of their adversaries. +Efforts on the part of the United States to mediate in the struggle +were blocked by the dogged refusal of Chile to abate its demands for +annexation. Early in 1881 its army entered Lima in triumph, and the war +was over. + +For a while the victors treated the Peruvians and their capital city +shamefully. The Chilean soldiers stripped the national library of +its contents, tore up the lamp-posts in the streets, carried away +the benches in the parks, and even shipped off the local menagerie to +Santiago! What they did not remove or destroy was disposed of by the +rabble of Lima itself. But in two years so utterly chaotic did the +conditions in the hapless country become that Chile at length had to set +up a government in order to conclude a peace. It was not until October +20, 1883, that the treaty was signed at Lima and ratified later at +Ancon. Peru was forced to cede Tarapaca outright and to agree that Tacna +and Arica should be held by Chile for ten years. At the expiration of +this period the inhabitants of the two provinces were to be allowed to +choose by vote the country to which they would prefer to belong, and the +nation that won the election was to pay the loser 10,000,000 pesos. +In April, 1884, Bolivia, also, entered into an arrangement with Chile, +according to which a portion of its seacoast should be ceded absolutely +and the remainder should be occupied by Chile until a more definite +understanding on the matter could be reached. + +Chile emerged from the war not only triumphant over its northern rivals +but dominant on the west coast of South America. Important developments +in Chilean national policy followed. To maintain its vantage and to +guard against reprisals, the victorious state had to keep in military +readiness on land and sea. It therefore looked to Prussia for a pattern +for its army and to Great Britain for a model for its navy. + +Peru had suffered cruelly from the war. Its territorial losses deprived +it of an opportunity to satisfy its foreign creditors through a grant +of concessions. The public treasury, too, was empty, and many a private +fortune had melted away. Not until a military hand stronger than its +competitors managed to secure a firm grip on affairs did Peru begin once +more its toilsome journey toward material betterment. + +Bolivia, on its part, had emerged from the struggle practically a +landlocked country. Though bereft of access to the sea except by +permission of its neighbors, it had, however, not endured anything +like the calamities of its ally. In 1880 it had adopted a permanent +constitution and it now entered upon a course of slow and relatively +peaceful progress. + +In the republics to the northward struggles between clericals and +radicals caused sharp, abrupt alternations in government. In Ecuador the +hostility between clericals and radicals was all the more bitter because +of the rivalry of the two chief towns, Guayaquil the seaport and Quito +the capital, each of which sheltered a faction. No sooner therefore had +Garcia Moreno fallen than the radicals of Guayaquil rose up against the +clericals at Quito. Once in power, they hunted their enemies down until +order under a dictator could be restored. The military President who +assumed power in 1876 was too radical to suit the clericals and too +clerical to suit the radicals. Accordingly his opponents decided to make +the contest three-cornered by fighting the dictator and one another. +When the President had been forced out, a conservative took charge until +parties of bushwhackers and mutinous soldiers were able to install a +military leader, whose retention of power was brief. In 1888 another +conservative, who had been absent from the country when elected and who +was an adept in law and diplomacy, managed to win sufficient support +from all three factions to retain office for the constitutional period. + +In Colombia a financial crisis had been approaching ever since the +price of coffee, cocoa, and other Colombian products had fallen in the +European markets. This decrease had caused a serious diminution in +the export trade and had forced gold and silver practically out of +circulation. At the same time the various "states" were increasing their +powers at the expense of the federal Government, and the country was +rent by factions. In order to give the republic a thoroughly centralized +administration which would restore financial confidence and bring back +the influence of the Church as a social and political factor, a genuine +revolution, which was started in 1876, eventually put an end to both +radicalism and states' rights. At the outset Rafael Nunez, the unitary +and clerical candidate and a lawyer by profession, was beaten on the +field, but at a subsequent election he obtained the requisite number of +votes and, in 1880, assumed the presidency. That the loser in war should +become the victor in peace showed the futility of bloodshed in such +revolutions. + +Not until Nunez came into office again did he feel himself strong enough +to uproot altogether the radicalism and disunion which had flourished +since 1860. Ignoring the national Legislature, he called a Congress +of his own, which in 1886 framed a constitution that converted the +"sovereign states" into "departments," or mere administrative +districts, to be ruled as the national Government saw fit. Further, the +presidential term was lengthened from two years to six, and the name of +the country was changed, finally, to "Republic of Colombia." Two years +later the power of the Church was strengthened by a concordat with the +Pope. + +Venezuela on its part had undergone changes no less marked. A liberal +constitution promulgated in 1864 had provided for the reorganization +of the country on a federal basis. The name chosen for the republic was +"United States of Venezuela." More than that, it had anticipated Mexico +and Guatemala in being the first of the Hispanic nations to witness +the establishment of a presidential autocracy of the continuous and +enlightened type. + +Antonio Guzman Blanco was the man who imposed upon Venezuela for about +nineteen years a regime of obedience to law, and, to some extent, of +modern ideas of administration such as the country had never known +before. A person of much versatility, he had studied medicine and law +before he became a soldier and a politician. Later he displayed another +kind of versatility by letting henchmen hold the presidential office +while he remained the power behind the throne. Endowed with a masterful +will and a pronounced taste for minute supervision, he had exactly the +ability necessary to rule Venezuela wisely and well. + +Amid considerable opposition he began, in 1870, the first of his +three periods of administration--the Septennium, as it was termed. The +"sovereign" states he governed through "sovereign" officials of his +own selection. He stopped the plundering of farms and the dragging +of laborers off to military service. He established in Venezuela an +excellent monetary system. Great sums were expended in the erection +of public and private buildings and in the embellishment of Caracas. +European capital and immigration were encouraged to venture into a +country hitherto so torn by chronic disorder as to deprive both labor +and property of all guarantees. Roads, railways, and telegraph lines +were constructed. The ministers of the Church were rendered submissive +to the civil power. Primary education became alike free and compulsory. +As the phrase went, Guzman Blanco "taught Venezuela to read." At the end +of his term of office he went into voluntary retirement. + +In 1879 Guzman Blanco put himself at the head of a movement which he +called a "revolution of replevin"--which meant, presumably, that he +was opposed to presidential "continuism," and in favor of republican +institutions! Although a constitution promulgated in 1881 fixed the +chief magistrate's term of office at two years, the success which Guzman +Blanco had attained enabled him to control affairs for five years--the +Quinquennium, as it was called. Thereupon he procured his appointment to +a diplomatic post in Europe; but the popular demand for his presence +was too strong for him to remain away. In 1886 he was elected by +acclamation. He held office two years more and then, finding that his +influence had waned, he left Venezuela for good. Whatever his faults +in other respects, Guzman Blanco--be it said to his credit--tried to +destroy the pest of periodical revolutions in his country. Thanks to +his vigorous suppression of these uprisings, some years of at least +comparative security were made possible. More than any other President +the nation had ever had, he was entitled to the distinction of having +been a benefactor, if not altogether a regenerator, of his native land. + + + +CHAPTER VIII. "ON THE MARGIN OF INTERNATIONAL LIFE" + +During the period from 1889 to 1907 two incidents revealed the standing +that the republics of Hispanic America had now acquired in the world +at large. In 1889 at Washington, and later in their own capital cities, +they met with the United States in council. In 1899, and again in 1907, +they joined their great northern neighbor and the nations of Europe and +Asia at The Hague for deliberation on mutual concerns, and they were +admitted to an international fellowship and cooperation far beyond +a mere recognition of their independence and a formal interchange of +diplomats and consuls. + +Since attempts of the Hispanic countries themselves to realize the aims +of Bolivar in calling the Congress at Panama had failed, the United +States now undertook to call into existence a sort of inter-American +Congress. Instead of being merely a supporter, the great republic of the +north had resolved to become the director of the movement for greater +solidarity in thought and action. By linking up the concerns of the +Hispanic nations with its own destinies it would assert not so much its +position as guardian of the Monroe Doctrine as its headship, if not its +actual dominance, in the New World, and would so widen the bounds of its +political and commercial influence--a tendency known as "imperialism." +Such was the way, at least, in which the Hispanic republics came to +view the action of the "Colossus of the North" in inviting them to +participate in an assemblage meeting more or less periodically and +termed officially the "International Conference of American States," and +popularly the "Pan-American Conference." + +Whether the mistrust the smaller countries felt at the outset was +lessened in any degree by the attendance of their delegates at the +sessions of this conference remains open to question. Although these +representatives, in common with their colleagues from the United States, +assented to a variety of conventions and passed a much larger number of +resolutions, their acquiescence seemed due to a desire to gratify their +powerful associate, rather than to a belief in the possible utility of +such measures. The experience of the earlier gatherings had demonstrated +that political issues would have to be excluded from consideration. +Propositions, for example, such as that to extend the basic idea of the +Monroe Doctrine into a sort of self-denying ordinance, under which all +the nations of America should agree to abstain thereafter from acquiring +any part of one another's territory by conquest, and to adopt, also, the +principle of compulsory arbitration, proved impossible of acceptance. +Accordingly, from that time onward the matters treated by the Conference +dealt for the most part with innocuous, though often praiseworthy, +projects for bringing the United States and its sister republics into +closer commercial, industrial, and intellectual relations. + +The gathering itself, on the other hand, became to a large extent a +fiesta, a festive occasion for the display of social amenities. Much +as the Hispanic Americans missed their favorite topic of politics, they +found consolation in entertaining the distinguished foreign visitors +with the genial courtesy and generous hospitality for which they +are famous. As one of their periodicals later expressed it, since +a discussion of politics was tabooed, it were better to devote the +sessions of the Conference to talking about music and lyric poetry! +At all events, as far as the outcome was concerned, their national +legislatures ratified comparatively few of the conventions. + +Among the Hispanic nations of America only Mexico took part in the First +Conference at The Hague. Practically all of them were represented at the +second. The appearance of their delegates at these august assemblages +of the powers of earth was viewed for a while with mixed feelings. The +attitude of the Great Powers towards them resembled that of parents of +the old regime: children at the international table should be "seen and +not heard." As a matter of fact, the Hispanic Americans were both seen +and heard--especially the latter! They were able to show the Europeans +that, even if they did happen to come from relatively weak states, they +possessed a skillful intelligence, a breadth of knowledge, a capacity +for expression, and a consciousness of national character, which would +not allow them simply to play "Man Friday" to an international Crusoe. +The president of the second conference, indeed, confessed that they had +been a "revelation" to him. + +Hence, as time went on, the progress and possibilities of the republics +of Hispanic America came to be appreciated more and more by the world at +large. Gradually people began to realize that the countries south of the +United States were not merely an indistinguishable block on the map, +to be referred to vaguely as "Central and South America" or as "Latin +America." The reading public at least knew that these countries were +quite different from one another, both in achievements and in prospects. + +Yet the fact remains that, despite their active part in these American +and European conferences, the Hispanic countries of the New World +did not receive the recognition which they felt was their due. Their +national associates in the European gatherings were disinclined to admit +that the possession of independence and sovereignty entitled them to +equal representation on international council boards. To a greater or +less degree, therefore, they continued to stay in the borderland where +no one either affirmed or denied their individuality. To quote +the phrase of an Hispanic American, they stood "on the margin of +international life." How far they might pass beyond it into the full +privileges of recognition and association on equal terms, would depend +upon the readiness with which they could atone for the errors or +recover from the misfortunes of the past, and upon their power to attain +stability, prosperity, strength, and responsibility. + +Certain of the Hispanic republics, however, were not allowed to remain +alone on their side of "the margin of international life." Though +nothing so extreme as the earlier French intervention took place, +foreign nations were not at all averse to crossing over the marginal +line and teaching them what a failure to comply with international +obligations meant. The period from 1889 to 1907, therefore, is +characterized also by interference on the part of European powers, and +by interposition on the part of the United States, in the affairs of +countries in and around the Caribbean Sea. Because of the action taken +by the United States two more republics--Cuba and Panama--came into +being, thus increasing the number of political offshoots from Spain +in America to eighteen. Another result of this interposition was the +creation of what were substantially American protectorates. Here +the United States did not deprive the countries concerned of their +independence and sovereignty, but subjected them to a kind of +guardianship or tutelage, so far as it thought needful to insure +stability, solvency, health, and welfare in general. Foremost in the +northern group of Hispanic nations, Mexico, under the guidance of +Diaz, marched steadily onward. Peace, order, and law; an increasing +population; internal wealth and well-being; a flourishing industry +and commerce; suitable care for things mental as well as material; the +respect and confidence of foreigners--these were blessings which the +country had hitherto never beheld. The Mexicans, once in anarchy and +enmity created by militarists and clericals, came to know one another in +friendship, and arrived at something like a national consciousness. + +In 1889 there was held the first conference on educational problems +which the republic had ever had. Three years later a mining code was +drawn up which made ownership inviolable on payment of lawful dues, +removed uncertainties of operation, and stimulated the industry in +a remarkable fashion. Far less beneficial in the long run was a law +enacted in 1894. Instead of granting a legal title to lands held by +prescriptive rights through an occupation of many years, it made such +property part of the public domain, which might be acquired, like +a mining claim, by any one who could secure a grant of it from the +Government. Though hailed at the time as a piece of constructive +legislation, its unfortunate effect was to enable large landowners who +wished to increase their possessions to oust poor cultivators of +the soil from their humble holdings. On the other hand, under the +statesmanlike management of Jose Yves Limantour, the Minister of +Finance, the monetary situation at home and abroad was strengthened +beyond measure, and banking interests were promoted accordingly. +Further, an act abolishing the alcabala, a vexatious internal revenue +tax, gave a great stimulus to freedom of commerce throughout the +country. In order to insure a continuance of the new regime, the +constitution was altered in three important respects. The amendment of +1890 restored the original clause of 1857, which permitted indefinite +reelection to the presidency; that of 1896 established a presidential +succession in case of a vacancy, beginning with the Minister of Foreign +Affairs; and that of 1904 lengthened the term of the chief magistrate +from four years to six and created the office of Vice President. + +In Central America two republics, Guatemala and Costa Rica, set an +excellent example both because they were free from internal commotions +and because they refrained from interference in the affairs of their +neighbors. The contrast between these two quiet little nations, under +their lawyer Presidents, and the bellicose but equally small Nicaragua, +Honduras, and Salvador, under their chieftains, military and juristic, +was quite remarkable. Nevertheless another attempt at confederation +was made. In 1895 the ruler of Honduras, declaring that reunion was a +"primordial necessity," invited his fellow potentates of Nicaragua and +Salvador to unite in creating the "Greater Republic of Central America" +and asked Guatemala and Costa Rica to join. Delegates actually appeared +from all five republics, attended fiestas, gave expression to pious +wishes, and went home! Later still, in 1902, the respective Presidents +signed a "convention of peace and obligatory arbitration" as a means +of adjusting perpetual disagreements about politics and boundaries; but +nothing was done to carry these ideas into effect. + +The personage mainly responsible for these failures was Jose Santos +Zelaya, one of the most arrant military lordlets and meddlers that +Central America had produced in a long time. Since 1893 he had been +dictator of Nicaragua, a country not only entangled in continuous +wrangles among its towns and factions, but bowed under an enormous +burden of debt created by excessive emissions of paper money and by the +contraction of more or less scandalous foreign loans. Quite undisturbed +by the financial situation, Zelaya promptly silenced local bickerings +and devoted his energies to altering the constitution for his +presidential benefit and to making trouble for his neighbors. Nor did +he refrain from displays of arbitrary conduct that were sure to provoke +foreign intervention. Great Britain, for example, on two occasions +exacted reparation at the cannon's mouth for ill treatment of its +citizens. + +Zelaya waxed wroth at the spectacle of Guatemala, once so active in +revolutionary arts but now quietly minding its own business. In +1906, therefore, along with parties of Hondurans, Salvadoreans, and +disaffected Guatemalans, he began an invasion of that country and +continued operations with decreasing success until, the United States +and Mexico offering their mediation, peace was signed aboard an American +cruiser. Then, when Costa Rica invited the other republics to discuss +confederation within its calm frontiers, Zelaya preferred his own +particular occupation to any such procedure. Accordingly, displeased +with a recent boundary decision, he started along with Salvador to fight +Honduras. Once more the United States and Mexico tendered their good +offices, and again a Central American conflict was closed aboard an +American warship. About the only real achievement of Zelaya was the +signing of a treaty by which Great Britain recognized the complete +sovereignty of Nicaragua over the Mosquito Indians, whose buzzing for a +larger amount of freedom and more tribute had been disturbing unduly the +"repose" of that small nation! + +To the eastward the new republic of Cuba was about to be born. Here a +promise of adequate representation in the Spanish Cortes and of a +local legislature had failed to satisfy the aspirations of many of its +inhabitants. The discontent was aggravated by lax and corrupt methods of +administration as well as by financial difficulties. Swarms of Spanish +officials enjoyed large salaries without performing duties of equivalent +value. Not a few of them had come over to enrich themselves at +public expense and under conditions altogether scandalous. On Cuba, +furthermore, was saddled the debt incurred by the Ten Years' War, while +the island continued to be a lucrative market for Spanish goods without +obtaining from Spain a corresponding advantage for its own products. + +As the insistence upon a removal of these abuses and upon a grant of +genuine self-government became steadily more clamorous, three political +groups appeared. The Constitutional Unionists, or "Austrianizers," as +they were dubbed because of their avowed loyalty to the royal house of +Bourbon-Hapsburg, were made up of the Spanish and conservative elements +and represented the large economic interests and the Church. The +Liberals, or "Autonomists," desired such reforms in the administration +as would assure the exercise of self-government and yet preserve the +bond with the mother country. On the other hand, the Radicals, or +"Nationalists"--the party of "Cuba Free"--would be satisfied with +nothing short of absolute independence. All these differences of opinion +were sharpened by the activities of a sensational press. + +From about 1890 onward the movement toward independence gathered +tremendous strength, especially when the Cubans found popular sentiment +in the United States so favorable to it. Excitement rose still higher +when the Spanish Government proposed to bestow a larger measure +of autonomy. When, however, the Cortes decided upon less liberal +arrangements, the Autonomists declared that they had been deceived, and +the Nationalists denounced the utter unreliability of Spanish promises. +Even if the concessions had been generous, the result probably would +have been the same, for by this time the plot to set Cuba free had +become so widespread, both in the island itself and among the refugees +in the United States, that the inevitable struggle could not have been +deferred. + +In 1895 the revolution broke out. The whites, headed by Maximo Gomez, +and the negroes and mulattoes by their chieftain, Antonio Maceo, both +of whom had done valiant service in the earlier war, started upon a +campaign of deliberate terrorism. This time they were resolved to win +at any cost. Spurning every offer of conciliation, they burned, ravaged, +and laid waste, spread desolation along their pathway, and reduced +thousands to abject poverty and want. + +Then the Spanish Government came to the conclusion that nothing but the +most rigorous sort of reprisals would check the excesses of the rebels. +In 1896 it commissioned Valeriano Weyler, an officer who personified +ferocity, to put down the rebellion. If the insurgents had fancied that +the conciliatory spirit hitherto displayed by the Spaniards was due to +irresolution or weakness, they found that these were not the qualities +of their new opponent. Weyler, instead of trying to suppress the +rebellion by hurrying detachments of troops first to one spot and +then to another in pursuit of enemies accustomed to guerrilla tactics, +determined to stamp it out province by province. To this end he planted +his army firmly in one particular area, prohibited the planting or +harvesting of crops there, and ordered the inhabitants to assemble in +camps which they were not permitted to leave on any pretext whatever. +This was his policy of "reconcentration." Deficient food supply, lack of +sanitary precautions, and absence of moral safeguards made conditions +of life in these camps appalling. Death was a welcome relief. +Reconcentration, combined with executions and deportations, could have +but one result--the "pacification" of Cuba by converting it into a +desert. + +Not in the United States alone but in Spain itself the story of these +drastic measures kindled popular indignation to such an extent that, in +1897, the Government was forced to recall the ferocious Weyler and +to send over a new Governor and Captain General, with instructions to +abandon the worst features of his predecessor's policy and to establish +a complete system of autonomy in both Cuba and Porto Rico. Feeling +assured, however, that an ally was at hand who would soon make +their independence certain, the Cuban patriots flatly rejected these +overtures. In their expectations they were not mistaken. By its armed +intervention, in the following year the United States acquired Porto +Rico for itself and compelled Spain to withdraw from Cuba. * + + * See "The Path of Empire", by Carl Russell Fish (in "The + Chronicles of America"). + +The island then became a republic, subject only to such limitations on +its freedom of action as its big guardian might see fit to impose. Not +only was Cuba placed under American rule from 1899 to 1902, but it had +to insert in the Constitution of 1901 certain clauses that could not +fail to be galling to Cuban pride. Among them two were of special +significance. One imposed limitations on the financial powers of the +Government of the new nation, and the other authorized the United +States, at its discretion, to intervene in Cuban affairs for the purpose +of maintaining public order. The Cubans, it would seem, had exchanged a +dependence on Spain for a restricted independence measured by the will +of a country infinitely stronger. + +Cuba began its life as a republic in 1902, under a government for which +a form both unitary and federal had been provided. Tomas Estrada Palma, +the first President and long the head of the Cuban junta in the +United States, showed himself disposed from the outset to continue the +beneficial reforms in administration which had been introduced under +American rule. Prudent and conciliatory in temperament, he tried to +dispel as best he could the bitter recollections of the war and to +repair its ravages. In this policy he was upheld by the conservative +class, or Moderates. Their opponents, the Liberals, dominated by men +of radical tendencies, were eager to assert the right, to which they +thought Cuba entitled as an independent sovereign nation, to make +possible mistakes and correct them without having the United States +forever holding the ferule of the schoolmaster over it. They were well +aware, however, that they were not at liberty to have their country pass +through the tempestuous experience which had been the lot of so many +Hispanic republics. They could vent a natural anger and disappointment, +nevertheless, on the President and his supporters. Rather than continue +to be governed by Cubans not to their liking, they were willing to bring +about a renewal of American rule. In this respect the wishes of the +Radicals were soon gratified. Hardly had Estrada Palma, in 1906, assumed +office for a second time, when parties of malcontents, declaring that +he had secured his reelection by fraudulent means, rose up in arms and +demanded that he annul the vote and hold a fair election. The President +accepted the challenge and waged a futile conflict, and again the United +States intervened. Upon the resignation of Estrada Palma, an American +Governor was again installed, and Cuba was told in unmistakable fashion +that the next intervention might be permanent. + +Less drastic but quite as effectual a method of assuring order and +regularity in administration was the action taken by the United States +in another Caribbean island. A little country like the Dominican +Republic, in which few Presidents managed to retain their offices for +terms fixed by changeable constitutions, could not resist the temptation +to rid itself of a ruler who had held power for nearly a quarter of a +century. After he had been disposed of by assassination in 1899, the +government of his successor undertook to repudiate a depreciated paper +currency by ordering the customs duties to be paid in specie; and it +also tried to prevent the consul of an aggrieved foreign nation from +attaching certain revenues as security for the payment of the arrears +of an indemnity. Thereupon, in 1905, the President of the United States +entered into an arrangement with the Dominican Government whereby, in +return for a pledge from the former country to guarantee the territorial +integrity of the republic and an agreement to adjust all of its external +obligations of a pecuniary sort, American officials were to take charge +of the custom house send apportion the receipts from that source in such +a manner as to satisfy domestic needs and pay foreign creditors. * + + * See "The Path of Empire", by Carl Russell Fish (in "The + Chronicles of America"). + + + +CHAPTER IX. THE REPUBLICS OF SOUTH AMERICA + +Even so huge and conservative a country as Brazil could not start out +upon the pathway of republican freedom without some unrest; but the +political experience gained under a regime of limited monarchy had a +steadying effect. Besides, the Revolution of 1889 had been effected by a +combination of army officers and civilian enthusiasts who knew that the +provinces were ready for a radical change in the form of government, +but who were wise enough to make haste slowly. If a motto could mean +anything, the adoption of the positivist device, "Order and Progress," +displayed on the national flag seemed a happy augury. + +The constitution promulgated in 1891 set up a federal union broadly +similar to that of the United States, except that the powers of the +general Government were somewhat more restricted. Qualifications for +the suffrage were directly fixed in the fundamental law itself, but the +educational tests imposed excluded the great bulk of the population +from the right to vote. In the constitution, also, Church and State were +declared absolutely separate, and civil marriage was prescribed. + +Well adapted as the constitution was to the particular needs of Brazil, +the Government erected under it had to contend awhile with political +disturbances. Though conflicts occurred between the president and the +Congress, between the federal authority and the States, and between +the civil administration and naval and military officials, none were +so constant, so prolonged, or so disastrous as in the Spanish American +republics. Even when elected by the connivance of government officials, +the chief magistrate governed in accordance with republican forms. +Presidential power, in fact, was restrained both by the huge size of the +country and by the spirit of local autonomy upheld by the States. + +Ever since the war with Paraguay the financial credit of Brazil had been +impaired. The chronic deficit in the treasury had been further increased +by a serious lowering in the rate of exchange, which was due to an +excessive issue of paper money. In order to save the nation from +bankruptcy Manoel Ferraz de Campos Salles, a distinguished jurist, was +commissioned to effect an adjustment with the British creditors. As a +result of his negotiations a "funding loan" was obtained, in return +for which an equivalent amount in paper money was to be turned over +for cancellation at a fixed rate of exchange. Under this arrangement +depreciation ceased for awhile and the financial outlook became +brighter. + +The election of Campos Salles to the presidency in 1898, as a reward for +his success, was accompanied by the rise of definite political +parties. Among them the Radicals or Progressists favored a policy of +centralization under military auspices and exhibited certain antiforeign +tendencies. The Moderates or Republicans, on the contrary, with Campos +Salles as their candidate, declared for the existing constitution and +advocated a gradual adoption of such reforms as reason and time might +suggest. When the latter party won the election, confidence in the +stability of Brazil returned. + +As if Uruguay had not already suffered enough from internal discords, +two more serious conflicts demonstrated once again that this little +country, in which political power had been held substantially by one +party alone since 1865, could not hope for permanent peace until either +the excluded and apparently irreconcilable party had been finally and +utterly crushed, or, far better still, until the two factions could +manage to agree upon some satisfactory arrangement for rotation in +office. The struggle of 1897 ended in the assassination of the president +and in a division of the republic into two practically separate areas, +one ruled by the Colorados at Montevideo, the other by the Blancos. +A renewal of civil war in 1904 seemed altogether preferable to an +indefinite continuance of this dualism in government, even at the risk +of friction with Argentina, which was charged with not having observed +strict neutrality. This second struggle came to a close with the death +of the insurgent leader; but it cost the lives of thousands and did +irreparable damage to the commerce and industry of the country. + +Uruguay then enjoyed a respite from party upheavals until 1910, +when Jose Batlle, the able, resolute, and radical-minded head of the +Colorados, announced that he would be a candidate for the presidency. +As he had held the office before and had never ceased to wield a strong +personal influence over the administration of his successor, the +Blancos decided that now was the time to attempt once more to oust +their opponents from the control which they had monopolized for half a +century. Accusing the Government of an unconstitutional centralization +of power in the executive, of preventing free elections, and of +crippling the pastoral industries of the country, they started a revolt, +which ran a brief course. Batlle proved himself equal to the situation +and quickly suppressed the insurrection. Though he did make a wide use +of his authority, the President refrained from indulging in political +persecution and allowed the press all the liberty it desired in so far +as was consistent with the law. It was under his direction that Uruguay +entered upon a remarkable series of experiments in the nationalization +of business enterprises. Further, more or less at the suggestion of +Battle, a new constitution was ratified by popular vote in 1917. It +provided for a division of the executive power between the President +and a National Council of Administration, forbade the election of +administrative and military officials to the Congress, granted to that +body a considerable increase of power, and enlarged the facilities for +local self-government. In addition, it established the principle of +minority representation and of secrecy of the ballot, permitted the +Congress to extend the right of suffrage to women, and dissolved the +union between Church and State. If the terms of the new instrument are +faithfully observed, the old struggle between Blancos and Colorados will +have been brought definitely to a close. + +Paraguay lapsed after 1898 into the earlier sins of Spanish America. +Upon a comparatively placid presidential regime followed a series +of barrack uprisings or attacks by Congress on the executive. The +constitution became a farce. No longer, to be sure, an abode of Arcadian +seclusion as in colonial times, or a sort of territorial cobweb from the +center of which a spiderlike Francia hung motionless or darted upon his +hapless prey, or even a battle ground on which fanatical warriors might +fight and die at the behest of a savage Lopez, Paraguay now took on +the aspect of an arena in which petty political gamecocks might try out +their spurs. Happily, the opposing parties spent their energies in high +words and vehement gestures rather than in blows and bloodshed. The +credit of the country sank lower and lower until its paper money stood +at a discount of several hundred per cent compared with gold. + +European bankers had begun to view the financial future of Argentina +also with great alarm. In 1890 the mad careering of private speculation +and public expenditure along the roseate pathway of limitless credit +reached a veritable "crisis of progress." A frightful panic ensued. +Paper money fell to less than a quarter of its former value in gold. +Many a firm became bankrupt, and many a fortune shriveled. As is usual +in such cases, the Government had to shoulder the blame. A four-day +revolution broke out in Buenos Aires, and the President became the +scapegoat; but the panic went on, nevertheless, until gold stood at +nearly five to one. Most of the banks suspended payment; the national +debt underwent a huge increase; and immigration practically ceased. + +By 1895, however, the country had more or less resumed its normal +condition. A new census showed that the population had risen to four +million, about a sixth of whom resided in the capital. The importance +which agriculture had attained was attested by the establishment of a +separate ministry in the presidential cabinet. Industry, too, made such +rapid strides at this time that organized labor began to take a hand +in politics. The short-lived "revolution" of 1905, for example, was +not primarily the work of politicians but of strikers organized into +a workingmen's federation. For three months civil guarantees were +suspended, and by a so-called "law of residence," enacted some years +before and now put into effect, the Government was authorized to expel +summarily any foreigner guilty of fomenting strikes or of disturbing +public order in any other fashion. + +Political agitation soon assumed a new form. Since the +Autonomist-National party had been in control for thirty years or more, +it seemed to the Civic-Nationalists, now known as Republicans, to the +Autonomists proper, and to various other factions, that they ought to do +something to break the hold of that powerful organization. Accordingly +in 1906 the President, supported by a coalition of these factions, +started what was termed an "upward-downward revolution"--in other +words, a series of interventions by which local governors and members +of legislatures suspected of Autonomist-National leanings were to +be replaced by individuals who enjoyed the confidence of the +Administration. Pretexts for such action were not hard to find under +the terms of the constitution; but their political interests suffered so +much in the effort that the promoters had to abandon it. + +Owing to persistent obstruction on the part of Congress, which took the +form of a refusal either to sanction his appointments or to approve the +budget, the President suspended the sessions of that body in 1908 and +decreed a continuance of the estimates for the preceding year. The +antagonism between the chief executive and the legislature became so +violent that, if his opponents had not been split up into factions, +civil war might have ensued in Argentina. + +To remedy a situation made worse by the absence--usual in most of the +Hispanic republics--of a secret ballot and by the refusal of political +malcontents to take part in elections, voting was made both obligatory +and secret in 1911, and the principle of minority representation was +introduced. Legislation of this sort was designed to check bribery and +intimidation and to enable the radical-minded to do their duty at the +polls. Its effect was shown five years later, when the secret ballot +was used substantially for the first time. The radicals won both the +presidency and a majority in the Congress. + +One of the secrets of the prosperity of Argentina, as of Brazil, in +recent years has been its abstention from warlike ventures beyond its +borders and its endeavor to adjust boundary conflicts by arbitration. +Even when its attitude toward its huge neighbor had become embittered +in consequence of a boundary decision rendered by the President of +the United States in 1895, it abated none of its enthusiasm for the +principle of a peaceful settlement of international disputes. Four +years later, in a treaty with Uruguay, the so-called "Argentine Formula" +appeared. To quote its language: "The contracting parties agree to +submit to arbitration all questions of any nature which may arise +between them, provided they do not affect provisions of the constitution +of either state, and cannot be adjusted by direct negotiation." This +Formula was soon put to the test in a serious dispute with Chile. + +In the Treaty of 1881, in partitioning Patagonia, the crest of the +Andes had been assumed to be the true continental watershed between the +Atlantic and the Pacific and hence was made the boundary line between +Argentina and Chile. The entire Atlantic coast was to belong to +Argentina, the Pacific coast to Chile; the island of Tierra del Fuego +was to be divided between them. At the same time the Strait of Magellan +was declared a neutral waterway, open to the ships of all nations. Ere +long, however, it was ascertained that the crest of the Andes did not +actually coincide with the continental divide. Thereupon Argentina +insisted that the boundary line should be made to run along the crest, +while Chile demanded that it be traced along the watershed. Since the +mountainous area concerned was of little value, the question at bottom +was simply one of power and prestige between rival states. + +As the dispute waxed warmer, a noisy press and populace clamored for +war. The Governments of the two nations spent large sums in increasing +their armaments; and Argentina, in imitation of its western neighbor, +made military service compulsory. But, as the conviction gradually +spread that a struggle would leave the victor as prostrate as the +vanquished, wiser counsels prevailed. In 1899, accordingly, the matter +was referred to the King of Great Britain for decision. Though the award +was a compromise, Chile was the actual gainer in territory. + +By their treaties of 1902 both republics declared their intention to +uphold the principle of arbitration and to refrain from interfering in +each other's affairs along their respective coasts. They also agreed +upon a limitation of armaments--the sole example on record of a +realization of the purpose of the First Hague Conference. To commemorate +still further their international accord, in 1904 they erected on the +summit of the Uspallata Pass, over which San Martin had crossed with +his army of liberation in 1817, a bronze statue of Christ the Redeemer. +There, amid the snow-capped peaks of the giant Andes, one may read +inscribed upon the pedestal: "Sooner shall these mountains crumble to +dust than Argentinos and Chileans break the peace which at the feet of +Christ the Redeemer they have sworn to maintain!" Nor has the peace been +broken. + +Though hostilities with Argentina had thus been averted, Chile had +experienced within its own frontiers the most serious revolution it had +known in sixty years. The struggle was not one of partisan chieftains +or political groups but a genuine contest to determine which of +two theories of government should prevail--the presidential or the +parliamentary, a presidential autocracy with the spread of real +democracy or a congressional oligarchy based on the existing order. The +sincerity and public spirit of both contestants helped to lend dignity +to the conflict. + +Jose Manuel Balmaceda, a man of marked ability, who became President in +1886, had devoted much of his political life to urging an enlargement +of the executive power, a greater freedom to municipalities in the +management of their local affairs, and a broadening of the suffrage. +He had even advocated a separation of Church and State. Most of these +proposals so conservative a land as Chile was not prepared to accept. +Though civil marriage was authorized and ecclesiastical influence +was lessened in other respects, the Church stood firm. During his +administration Balmaceda introduced many reforms, both material and +educational. He gave a great impetus to the construction of public +works, enhanced the national credit by a favorable conversion of the +public debt, fostered immigration, and devoted especial attention to the +establishment of secondary schools. Excellent as the administration of +Balmaceda had been in other respects, he nevertheless failed to combine +the liberal factions into a party willing to support the plans of reform +which he had steadily favored. The parliamentary system made Cabinets +altogether unstable, as political groups in the lower house of the +Congress alternately cohered and fell apart. This defect, Balmaceda +thought, should be corrected by making the members of his official +family independent of the legislative branch. The Council of State, a +somewhat anomalous body placed between the President and Cabinet on the +one side and the Congress on the other, was an additional obstruction to +a smooth-running administration. For it he would substitute a tribunal +charged with the duty of resolving conflicts between the two chief +branches of government. Balmaceda believed, also, that greater liberty +should be given to the press and that existing taxes should be altered +as rarely as possible. On its side, the Congress felt that the President +was trying to establish a dictatorship and to replace the unitary system +by a federal union, the probable weakness of which would enable him to +retain his power more securely. + +Toward the close of his term in January, 1891, when the Liberals +declined to support his candidate for the presidency, Balmaceda, furious +at the opposition which he had encountered, took matters into his own +hands. Since the Congress refused to pass the appropriation bills, he +declared that body dissolved and proceeded to levy the taxes by decree. +To this arbitrary and altogether unconstitutional performance the +Congress retorted by declaring the President deposed. Civil war broke +out forthwith, and a strange spectacle presented itself. The two chief +cities, Santiago and Valparaiso, and most of the army backed Balmaceda, +whereas the country districts, especially in the north, and practically +all the navy upheld the Congress. + +These were, indeed, dark days for Chile. During a struggle of about +eight months the nation suffered more than it had done in years of +warfare with Peru and Bolivia. Though the bulk of the army stood by +Balmaceda, the Congress was able to raise and organize a much stronger +fighting force under a Prussian drillmaster. The tide of battle turned; +Santiago and Valparaiso capitulated; and the presidential cause was +lost. Balmaceda, who had taken refuge in the Argentina legation, +committed suicide. But the Balmacedists, who were included in a general +amnesty, still maintained themselves as a party to advocate in a +peaceful fashion the principles of their fallen leader. + +Chile had its reputation for stability well tested in 1910 when +the executive changed four times without the slightest political +disturbance. According to the constitution, the officer who takes the +place of the President in case of the latter's death or disability, +though vested with full authority, has the title of Vice President only. +It so happened that after the death of the President two members of the +Cabinet in succession held the vice presidency, and they were followed +by the chief magistrate, who was duly elected and installed at the +close of the year. In 1915, for the first time since their leader +had committed suicide, one of the followers of Balmaceda was chosen +President--by a strange coalition of Liberal-Democrats, or Balmacedists, +Conservatives, and Nationalists, over the candidate of the Radicals, +Liberals, and Democrats. The maintenance of the parliamentary system, +however, continued to produce frequent alterations in the personnel of +the Cabinet. + +In its foreign relations, apart from the adjustment reached with +Argentina, Chile managed to settle the difficulties with Bolivia arising +out of the War of the Pacific. By the terms of treaties concluded in +1895 and 1905, the region tentatively transferred by the armistice of +1884 was ceded outright to Chile in return for a seaport and a narrow +right of way to it through the former Peruvian province of Tarapaca. +With Peru, Chile was not so fortunate. Though the tension over the +ultimate disposal of the Tacna and Arica question was somewhat reduced, +it was far from being removed. Chile absolutely refused to submit the +matter to arbitration, on the ground that such a procedure could not +properly be applied to a question arising out of a war that had taken +place so many years before. Chile did not wish to give the region up, +lest by so doing it might expose Tarapaca to a possible attack from +Peru. The investment of large amounts of foreign capital in the +exploitation of the deposits of nitrate of soda had made that province +economically very valuable, and the export tax levied on the product was +the chief source of the national revenue. These were all potent +reasons why Chile wanted to keep its hold on Tacna and Arica. Besides, +possession was nine points in the law! + +On the other hand, the original plan of having the question decided by a +vote of the inhabitants of the provinces concerned was not carried +into effect, partly because both claimants cherished a conviction that +whichever lost the election would deny its validity, and partly because +they could not agree upon the precise method of holding it. Chile +suggested that the international commission which was selected to +take charge of the plebiscite, and which was composed of a Chilean, a +Peruvian, and a neutral, should be presided over by the Chilean member +as representative of the country actually in possession, whereas Peru +insisted that the neutral should act as chairman. Chile proposed also +that Chileans, Peruvians, and foreigners resident in the area six months +before the date of the elections should vote, provided that they had +the right to do so under the terms of the constitutions of both states. +Peru, on its part, objected to the length of residence, and wished to +limit carefully the number of Chilean voters, to exclude foreigners +altogether from the election, and to disregard qualifications for the +suffrage which required an ability to read and write. Both countries, +moreover, appeared to have a lurking suspicion that in any event +the other would try to secure a majority at the polls by supplying a +requisite number of voters drawn from their respective citizenry who +were not ordinarily resident in Tacna and Arica! Unable to overcome the +deadlock, Chile and Peru agreed in 1913 to postpone the settlement for +twenty years longer. At the expiration of this period, when Chile would +have held the provinces for half a century, the question should be +finally adjusted on bases mutually satisfactory. Officially amicable +relations were then restored. + +While the political situation in Bolivia remained stable, so much could +not be said of that in Peru and Ecuador. If the troubles in the former +were more or less military, a persistence of the conflict between +clericals and radicals characterized the commotions in the latter, +because of certain liberal provisions in the Constitution of 1907. +Peru, on the other hand, in 1915 guaranteed its people the enjoyment of +religious liberty. + +Next to the Tacna and Arica question, the dubious boundaries of Ecuador +constituted the most serious international problem in South America. The +so-called Oriente region, lying east of the Andes and claimed by Peru, +Brazil, and Colombia, appeared differently on different maps, according +as one claimant nation or another set forth its own case. Had all three +been satisfied, nothing would have been left of Ecuador but the strip +between the Andes and the Pacific coast, including the cities of Quito +and Guayaquil. The Ecuadorians, therefore, were bitterly sensitive on +the subject. + +Protracted negotiations over the boundaries became alike tedious and +listless. But the moment that the respective diplomats had agreed upon +some knotty point, the Congress of one litigant or another was almost +sure to reject the decision and start the controversy all over again. +Even reference of the matter to the arbitral judgment of European +monarchs produced, so far as Ecuador and Peru were concerned, riotous +attacks upon the Peruvian legation and consulates, charges and +countercharges of invasion of each other's territory, and the suspension +of diplomatic relations. Though the United States, Argentina, and Brazil +had interposed to ward off an armed conflict between the two republics +and, in 1911, had urged that the dispute be submitted to the Hague +Tribunal, nothing would induce Ecuador to comply. + +Colombia was even more unfortunate than its southern neighbor, for in +addition to political convulsions it suffered financial disaster and +an actual deprivation of territory. Struggles among factions, official +influence at the elections, dictatorships, and fighting between the +departments and the national Government plunged the country, in 1899, +into the worst civil war it had known for many a day. Paper money, +issued in unlimited amounts and given a forced circulation, made the +distress still more acute. Then came the hardest blow of all. Since +1830 Panama, as province or state, had tried many times to secede from +Colombia. In 1903 the opportunity it sought became altogether favorable. +The parent nation, just beginning to recover from the disasters of civil +strife, would probably be unable to prevent a new attempt at withdrawal. +The people of Panama, of course, knew how eager the United States was +to acquire the region of the proposed Canal Zone, since it had failed to +win it by negotiation with Colombia. Accordingly, if they were to +start a "revolution," they had reason to believe that it would not lack +support--or at least, connivance--from that quarter. + +On the 3d of November the projected "revolution" occurred, on schedule +time, and the United States recognized the independence of the "Republic +of Panama" three days later! In return for a guarantee of independence, +however, the United States stipulated, in the convention concluded +on the 18th of November, that, besides authority to enforce sanitary +regulations in the Canal Zone, it should also have the right of +intervention to maintain order in the republic itself. More than +once, indeed, after Panama adopted its constitution in 1904, elections +threatened to become tumultuous; whereupon the United States saw to it +that they passed off quietly. + +Having no wish to flout their huge neighbor to the northward, the +Hispanic nations at large hastened to acknowledge the independence of +the new republic, despite the indignation that prevailed in press and +public over what was regarded as an act of despoilment. In view of the +resentful attitude of Colombia and mindful also of the opinion of many +Americans that a gross injustice had been committed, the United States +eventually offered terms of settlement. It agreed to express regret for +the ill feeling between the two countries which had arisen out of the +Panama incident, provided that such expression were made mutual; and, as +a species of indemnity, it agreed to pay for canal rights to be acquired +in Colombian territory and for the lease of certain islands as naval +stations. But neither the terms nor the amount of the compensation +proved acceptable. Instead, Colombia urged that the whole matter be +referred to the judgment of the tribunal at The Hague. + +Alluding to the use made of the liberties won in the struggle for +emancipation from Spain by the native land of Miranda, Bolivar, and +Sucre, on the part of the country which had been in the vanguard of +the fight for freedom from a foreign yoke, a writer of Venezuela once +declared that it had not elected legally a single President; had not put +democratic ideas or institutions into practice; had lived wholly under +dictatorships; had neglected public instruction; and had set up a large +number of oppressive commercial monopolies, including the navigation +of rivers, the coastwise trade, the pearl fisheries, and the sale of +tobacco, salt, sugar, liquor, matches, explosives, butter, grease, +cement, shoes, meat, and flour. Exaggerated as the indictment is and +applicable also, though in less degree, to some of the other backward +countries of Hispanic America, it contains unfortunately a large measure +of truth. Indeed, so far as Venezuela itself is concerned, this critic +might have added that every time a "restorer," "regenerator," or +"liberator" succumbed there, the old craze for federalism again broke +out and menaced the nation with piecemeal destruction. Obedient, +furthermore, to the whims of a presidential despot, Venezuela +perpetrated more outrages on foreigners and created more international +friction after 1899 than any other land in Spanish America had ever +done. + +While the formidable Guzman Blanco was still alive, the various +Presidents acted cautiously. No sooner had he passed away than disorder +broke out afresh. Since a new dictator thought he needed a longer term +of office and divers other administrative advantages, a constitution +incorporating them was framed and published in the due and customary +manner. This had hardly gone into operation when, in 1895, a contest +arose with Great Britain about the boundaries between Venezuela and +British Guiana. Under pressure from the United States, however, the +matter was referred to arbitration, and Venezuela came out substantially +the loser. + +In 1899 there appeared on the scene a personage compared with whom +Zelaya was the merest novice in the art of making trouble. This was +Cipriano Castro, the greatest international nuisance of the early +twentieth century. A rude, arrogant, fearless, energetic, capricious +mountaineer and cattleman, he regarded foreigners no less than his +own countryfolk, it would seem, as objects for his particular scorn, +displeasure, exploitation, or amusement, as the case might be. He was +greatly angered by the way in which foreigners in dispute with +local officials avoided a resort to Venezuelan courts and--still +worse--rejected their decisions and appealed instead to their diplomatic +representatives for protection. He declared such a procedure to be an +affront to the national dignity. Yet foreigners were usually correct in +arming that judges appointed by an arbitrary President were little more +than figureheads, incapable of dispensing justice, even were they so +inclined. + +Jealous not only of his personal prestige but of what he imagined, or +pretended to imagine, were the rights of a small nation, Castro tried +throughout to portray the situation in such a light as to induce the +other Hispanic republics also to view foreign interference as a +dire peril to their own independence and sovereignty; and he further +endeavored to involve the United States in a struggle with European +powers as a means possibly of testing the efficacy of the Monroe +Doctrine or of laying bare before the world the evil nature of American +imperialistic designs. + +By the year 1901, in which Venezuela adopted another constitution, the +revolutionary disturbances had materially diminished the revenues from +the customs. Furthermore Castro's regulations exacting military service +of all males between fourteen and sixty years of age had filled the +prisons to overflowing. Many foreigners who had suffered in consequence +resorted to measures of self-defense--among them representatives of +certain American and British asphalt companies which were working +concessions granted by Castro's predecessors. Though familiar with what +commonly happens to those who handle pitch, they had not scrupled to +aid some of Castro's enemies. Castro forthwith imposed on them enormous +fines which amounted practically to a confiscation of their rights. + +While the United States and Great Britain were expostulating over this +behavior of the despot, France broke off diplomatic relations with +Venezuela because of Castro's refusal either to pay or to submit to +arbitration certain claims which had originated in previous revolutions. +Germany, aggrieved in similar fashion, contemplated a seizure of the +customs until its demands for redress were satisfied. And then came +Italy with like causes of complaint. As if these complications were not +sufficient, Venezuela came to blows with Colombia. + +As the foreign pressure on Castro steadily increased, Luis Maria Drago, +the Argentine Minister of Foreign Affairs, formulated in 1902 the +doctrine with which his name has been associated. It stated in substance +that force should never be employed between nations for the collection +of contractual debts. Encouraged by this apparent token of support from +a sister republic, Castro defied his array of foreign adversaries more +vigorously than ever, declaring that he might find it needful to invade +the United States, by way of New Orleans, to teach it the lesson it +deserved! But when he attempted, in the following year, to close the +ports of Venezuela as a means of bringing his native antagonists to +terms, Great Britain, Germany, and Italy seized his warships, blockaded +the coast, and bombarded some of his forts. Thereupon the United States +interposed with a suggestion that the dispute be laid before the Hague +Tribunal. Although Castro yielded, he did not fail to have a clause +inserted in a new "constitution" requiring foreigners who might wish +to enter the republic to show certificates of good character from the +Governments of their respective countries. + +These incidents gave much food for thought to Castro as well as to +his soberer compatriots. The European powers had displayed an apparent +willingness to have the United States, if it chose to do so, assume the +role of a New World policeman and financial guarantor. Were it to assume +these duties, backward republics in the Caribbean and its vicinity were +likely to have their affairs, internal as well as external, supervised +by the big nation in order to ward off European intervention. At +this moment, indeed, the United States was intervening in Panama. The +prospect aroused in many Hispanic countries the fear of a "Yankee peril" +greater even than that emanating from Europe. Instead of being a kindly +and disinterested protector of small neighbors, the "Colossus of the +North" appeared rather to resemble a political and commercial ogre bent +upon swallowing them to satisfy "manifest destiny." + +Having succeeded in putting around his head an aureole of local +popularity, Castro in 1905 picked a new set of partially justified +quarrels with the United States, Great Britain, France, Italy, Colombia, +and even with the Netherlands, arising out of the depredations of +revolutionists; but an armed menace from the United States induced him +to desist from his plans. He contented himself accordingly with issuing +a decree of amnesty for all political offenders except the leaders. When +"reelected," he carried his magnanimity so far as to resign awhile in +favor of the Vice President, stating that, if his retirement were to +bring peace and concord, he would make it permanent. But as he saw to it +that his temporary withdrawal should not have this happy result, he came +back again to his firmer position a few months later. + +Venting his wrath upon the Netherlands because its minister had reported +to his Government an outbreak of cholera at La Guaira, the chief seaport +of Venezuela, the dictator laid an embargo on Dutch commerce, seized +its ships, and denounced the Dutch for their alleged failure to check +filibustering from their islands off the coast. When the minister +protested, Castro expelled him. Thereupon the Netherlands instituted a +blockade of the Venezuelan ports. What might have happened if Castro +had remained much longer in charge, may be guessed. Toward the close +of 1908, however, he departed for Europe to undergo a course of medical +treatment. Hardly had he left Venezuelan shores when Juan Vicente Gomez, +the able, astute, and vigorous Vice President, managed to secure his +own election to the presidency and an immediate recognition from +foreign states. Under his direction all of the international tangles of +Venezuela were straightened out. + +In 1914 the country adopted its eleventh constitution and thereby +lengthened the presidential term to seven years, shortened that +of members of the lower house of the Congress to four, determined +definitely the number of States in the union, altered the apportionment +of their congressional representation, and enlarged the powers of the +federal Government--or, rather, those of its executive branch! In 1914 +Gomez resigned office in favor of the Vice President, and secured an +appointment instead as commander in chief of the army. This procedure +was promptly denounced as a trick to evade the constitutional +prohibition of two consecutive terms. A year later he was unanimously +elected President, though he never formally took the oath of office. + +Whatever may be thought of the political ways and means of this +new Guzmin Blanco to maintain himself as a power behind or on the +presidential throne, Gomez gave Venezuela an administration of a sort +very different from that of his immediate predecessor. He suppressed +various government monopolies, removed other obstacles to the material +advancement of the country, and reduced the national debt. He did much +also to improve the sanitary conditions at La Guaira, and he promoted +education, especially the teaching of foreign languages. + +Gomez nevertheless had to keep a watchful eye on the partisans of +Castro, who broke out in revolt whenever they had an opportunity. The +United States, Great Britain, France, the Netherlands, Denmark, Cuba, +and Colombia eyed the movements of the ex-dictator nervously, as +European powers long ago were wont to do in the case of a certain Man +of Destiny, and barred him out of both their possessions and Venezuela +itself. International patience, never Job-like, had been too sorely +vexed to permit his return. Nevertheless, after the manner of the +ancient persecutor of the Biblical martyr, Castro did not refrain from +going to and fro in the earth. In fact he still "walketh about" seeking +to recover his hold upon Venezuela! + + + +CHAPTER X. MEXICO IN REVOLUTION + +When, in 1910, like several of its sister republics, Mexico celebrated +the centennial anniversary of its independence, the era of peace +and progress inaugurated by Porfirio Diaz seemed likely to last +indefinitely, for he was entering upon his eighth term as President. +Brilliant as his career had been, however, and greatly as Mexico had +prospered under his rigid rule, a sullen discontent had been brewing. +The country that had had but one continuous President in twenty-six +years was destined to have some fourteen chief magistrates in less than +a quarter of that time, and to surpass all its previous records for +rapidity in presidential succession, by having one executive who is said +to have held office for precisely fifty-six minutes! + +It has often been asserted that the reason for the downfall of Diaz +and the lapse of Mexico into the unhappy conditions of a half century +earlier was that he had grown too old to keep a firm grip on the +situation. It has also been declared that his insistence upon reelection +and upon the elevation of his own personal candidate to the vice +presidency, as a successor in case of his retirement, occasioned his +overthrow. The truth of the matter is that these circumstances were only +incidental to his downfall; the real causes of revolution lay deeprooted +in the history of these twenty-six years. The most significant feature +of the revolt was its civilian character. A widespread public opinion +had been created; a national consciousness had been awakened which was +intolerant of abuses and determined upon their removal at any cost; and +this public opinion and national consciousness were products of general +education, which had brought to the fore a number of intelligent men +eager to participate in public affairs and yet barred out because of +their unwillingness to support the existing regime. + +Some one has remarked, and rightly, that Diaz in his zeal for the +material advancement of Mexico, mistook the tangible wealth of the +country for its welfare. Desirable and even necessary as that material +progress was, it produced only a one-sided prosperity. Diaz was +singularly deaf to the just complaints of the people of the laboring +classes, who, as manufacturing and other industrial enterprises +developed, were resolved to better their conditions. In the country at +large the discontent was still stronger. Throughout many of the rural +districts general advancement had been retarded because of the holding +of huge areas of fertile land by a comparatively few rich families, who +did little to improve it and were content with small returns from the +labor of throngs of unskilled native cultivators. Wretchedly paid and +housed, and toiling long hours, the workers lived like the serfs of +medieval days or as their own ancestors did in colonial times. Ignorant, +poverty-stricken, liable at any moment to be dispossessed of the tiny +patch of ground on which they raised a few hills of corn or beans, most +of them were naturally a simple, peaceful folk who, in spite of their +misfortunes, might have gone on indefinitely with their drudgery in +a hopeless apathetic fashion, unless their latent savage instincts +happened to be aroused by drink and the prospect of plunder. On the +other hand, the intelligent among them, knowing that in some of the +northern States of the republic wages were higher and treatment fairer, +felt a sense of wrong which, like that of the laboring class in the +towns, was all the more dangerous because it was not allowed to find +expression. + +Diaz thought that what Mexico required above everything else was the +development of industrial efficiency and financial strength, assured +by a maintenance of absolute order. Though disposed to do justice in +individual cases, he would tolerate no class movements of any kind. +Labor unions, strikes, and other efforts at lightening the burden of the +workers he regarded as seditious and deserving of severe punishment. In +order to attract capital from abroad as the best means of exploiting the +vast resources of the country, he was willing to go to any length, it +would seem, in guaranteeing protection. Small wonder, therefore, that +the people who shared in none of the immediate advantages from that +source should have muttered that Mexico was the "mother of foreigners +and the stepmother of Mexicans." And, since so much of the capital came +from the United States, the antiforeign sentiment singled Americans out +for its particular dislike. + +If Diaz appeared unable to appreciate the significance of the +educational and industrial awakening, he was no less oblivious of the +political outcome. He knew, of course, that the Mexican constitution +made impossible demands upon the political capacity of the people. He +was himself mainly of Indian blood and he believed that he understood +the temperament and limitations of most Mexicans. Knowing how +tenaciously they clung to political notions, he believed that it was +safer and wiser to forego, at least for a time, real popular government +and to concentrate power in the hands of a strong man who could maintain +order. + +Accordingly, backed by his political adherents, known as cientificos +(doctrinaires), some of whom had acquired a sinister ascendancy over +him, and also by the Church, the landed proprietors, and the foreign +capitalists, Diaz centered the entire administration more and more in +himself. Elections became mere farces. Not only the federal officials +themselves but the state governors, the members of the state +legislatures, and all others in authority during the later years of his +rule owed their selection primarily to him and held their positions only +if personally loyal to him. Confident of his support and certain that +protests against misgovernment would be regarded by the President as +seditious, many of them abused their power at will. Notable among them +were the local officials, called jefes politicos, whose control of the +police force enabled them to indulge in practices of intimidation and +extortion which ultimately became unendurable. + +Though symptoms of popular wrath against the Diaz regime, or diazpotism +as the Mexicans termed it, were apparent as early as 1908, it was not +until January, 1911, that the actual revolution came. It was headed by +Francisco I. Madero, a member of a wealthy and distinguished family +of landed proprietors in one of the northern States. What the +revolutionists demanded in substance was the retirement of the +President, Vice President, and Cabinet; a return to the principle of no +reelection to the chief magistracy; a guarantee of fair elections at +all times; the choice of capable, honest, and impartial judges, jefes +politicos, and other officials; and, in particular, a series of agrarian +and industrial reforms which would break up the great estates, create +peasant proprietorships, and better the conditions of the working +classes. Disposed at first to treat the insurrection lightly, Diaz soon +found that he had underestimated its strength. Grants of some of the +demands and promises of reform were met with a dogged insistence upon +his own resignation. Then, as the rebellion spread to the southward, the +masterful old man realized that his thirty-one years of rule were at an +end. On the 25th of May, therefore, he gave up his power and sailed for +Europe. + +Madero was chosen President five months later, but the revolution soon +passed beyond his control. He was a sincere idealist, if not something +of a visionary, actuated by humane and kindly sentiments, but he lacked +resoluteness and the art of managing men. He was too prolific, also, of +promises which he must have known he could not keep. Yielding to family +influence, he let his followers get out of hand. Ambitious chieftains +and groups of Radicals blocked and thwarted him at every turn. When +he could find no means of carrying out his program without wholesale +confiscation and the disruption of business interests, he was accused of +abandoning his duty. One officer after another deserted him and turned +rebel. Brigandage and insurrection swept over the country and threatened +to involve it in ugly complications with the United States and European +powers. At length, in February, 1913, came the blow that put an end to +all of Madero's efforts and aspirations. A military uprising in the +city of Mexico made him prisoner, forced him to resign, and set up a +provisional government under the dictatorship of Victoriano Huerta, +one of his chief lieutenants. Two weeks later both Madero and the Vice +President were assassinated while on their way supposedly to a place of +safety. + +Huerta was a rough soldier of Indian origin, possessed of unusual force +of character and strength of will, ruthless, cunning, and in bearing +alternately dignified and vulgar. A scientifico in political faith, he +was disposed to restore the Diaz regime, so far as an application of +shrewdness and force could make it possible. But from the outset he +found an obstacle confronting him that he could not surmount. Though +acknowledged by European countries and by many of the Hispanic +republics, he could not win recognition from the United States, either +as provisional President or as a candidate for regular election to the +office. Whether personally responsible for the murder of Madero or +not, he was not regarded by the American Government as entitled to +recognition, on the ground that he was not the choice of the Mexican +people. In its refusal to recognize an administration set up merely by +brute force, the United States was upheld by Argentina, Brazil, Chile, +and Cuba. The elimination of Huerta became the chief feature for a while +of its Mexican policy. + +Meanwhile the followers of Madero and the pronounced Radicals had found +a new northern leader in the person of Venustiano Carranza. They +called themselves Constitutionalists, as indicative of their purpose to +reestablish the constitution and to choose a successor to Madero in +a constitutional manner. What they really desired was those radical +changes along social, industrial, and political lines, which Madero had +championed in theory. They sought to introduce a species of socialistic +regime that would provide the Mexicans with an opportunity for +self-regeneration. While Diaz had believed in economic progress +supported by the great landed proprietors, the moral influence of the +Church, and the application of foreign capital, the Constitutionalists, +personified in Carranza, were convinced that these agencies, if left +free and undisturbed to work their will, would ruin Mexico. Though not +exactly antiforeign in their attitude, they wished to curb the power +of the foreigner; they would accept his aid whenever desirable for the +economic development of the country, but they would not submit to his +virtual control of public affairs. In any case they would tolerate no +interference by the United States. Compromise with the Huerta regime, +therefore, was impossible. Huerta, the "strong man" of the Diaz type, +must go. On this point, at least, the Constitutionalists were in +thorough agreement with the United States. + +A variety of international complications ensued. Both Huertistas and +Carranzistas perpetrated outrages on foreigners, which evoked sharp +protests and threats from the United States and European powers. +While careful not to recognize his opponents officially, the American +Government resorted to all kinds of means to oust the dictator. An +embargo was laid on the export of arms and munitions; all efforts to +procure financial help from abroad were balked. The power of Huerta was +waning perceptibly and that of the Constitutionalists was increasing +when an incident that occurred in April, 1914, at Tampico brought +matters to a climax. A number of American sailors who had gone ashore +to obtain supplies were arrested and temporarily detained. The United +States demanded that the American flag be saluted as reparation for the +insult. Upon the refusal of Huerta to comply, the United States sent a +naval expedition to occupy Vera Cruz. + +Both Carranza and Huerta regarded this move as equivalent to an act of +war. Argentina, Brazil, and Chile then offered their mediation. But +the conference arranged for this purpose at Niagara Falls, Canada, +had before it a task altogether impossible of accomplishment. Though +Carranza was willing to have the Constitutionalists represented, if +the discussion related solely to the immediate issue between the United +States and Huerta, he declined to extend the scope of the conference so +as to admit the right of the United States to interfere in the internal +affairs of Mexico. The conference accomplished nothing so far as the +immediate issue was concerned. The dictator did not make reparation for +the "affronts and indignities" he had committed; but his day was over. +The advance of the Constitutionalists southward compelled him in July +to abandon the capital and leave the country. Four months later the +American forces were withdrawn from Vera Cruz. The "A B C" Conference, +however barren it was of direct results, helped to allay suspicions of +the United States in Hispanic America and brought appreciably nearer a +"concert of the western world." + +While far from exercising full control throughout Mexico, the "first +chief" of the Constitutionalists was easily the dominant figure in +the situation. At home a ranchman, in public affairs a statesman of +considerable ability, knowing how to insist and yet how to temporize, +Carranza carried on a struggle, both in arms and in diplomacy, which +singled him out as a remarkable character. Shrewdly aware of the +advantageous circumstances afforded him by the war in Europe, he turned +them to account with a degree of skill that blocked every attempt at +defeat or compromise. No matter how serious the opposition to him in +Mexico itself, how menacing the attitude of the United States, or how +persuasive the conciliatory disposition of Hispanic American nations, he +clung stubbornly and tenaciously to his program. + +Even after Huerta had been eliminated, Carranza's position was not +assured, for Francisco, or "Pancho," Villa, a chieftain whose personal +qualities resembled those of the fallen dictator, was equally determined +to eliminate him. For a brief moment, indeed, peace reigned. Under +an alleged agreement between them, a convention of Constitutionalist +officers was to choose a provisional President, who should be ineligible +as a candidate for the permanent presidency at the regular elections. +When Carranza assumed both of these positions, Villa declared his act +a violation of their understanding and insisted upon his retirement. +Inasmuch as the convention was dominated by Villa, the "first chief" +decided to ignore its election of a provisional President. + +The struggle between the Conventionalists headed by Villa and the +Constitutionalists under Carranza plunged Mexico into worse discord and +misery than ever. Indeed it became a sort of three-cornered contest. The +third party was Emiliano Zapata, an Indian bandit, nominally a supporter +of Villa but actually favorable to neither of the rivals. Operating near +the capital, he plundered Conventionalists and Constitutionalists with +equal impartiality, and as a diversion occasionally occupied the city +itself. These circumstances gave force to the saying that Mexico was a +"land where peace breaks out once in a while!" + +Early in 1915 Carranza proceeded to issue a number of radical decrees +that exasperated foreigners almost beyond endurance. Rather than resort +to extreme measures again, however, the United States invoked the +cooperation of the Hispanic republics and proposed a conference to +devise some solution of the Mexican problem. To give the proposed +conference a wider representation, it invited not only the "A B C" +powers, but Bolivia, Uruguay, and Guatemala to participate. Meeting +at Washington in August, the mediators encountered the same difficulty +which had confronted their predecessors at Niagara Falls. Though the +other chieftains assented, Carranza, now certain of success, declined to +heed any proposal of conciliation. Characterizing efforts of the kind as +an unwarranted interference in the internal affairs of a sister nation, +he warned the Hispanic republics against setting up so dangerous a +precedent. In reply Argentina stated that the conference obeyed a "lofty +inspiration of Pan-American solidarity, and, instead of finding any +cause for alarm, the Mexican people should see in it a proof of their +friendly consideration that her fate evokes in us, and calls forth our +good wishes for her pacification and development." However, as the only +apparent escape from more watchful waiting or from armed intervention on +the part of the United States, in October the seven Governments decided +to accept the facts as they stood, and accordingly recognized Carranza +as the de facto ruler of Mexico. + +Enraged at this favor shown to his rival, Villa determined deliberately +to provoke American intervention by a murderous raid on a town in New +Mexico in March, 1916. When the United States dispatched an expedition +to avenge the outrage, Carranza protested energetically against its +violation of Mexican territory and demanded its withdrawal. Several +clashes, in fact, occurred between American soldiers and Carranzistas. +Neither the expedition itself, however, nor diplomatic efforts to find +some method of cooperation which would prevent constant trouble along +the frontier served any useful purpose, since Villa apparently could +not be captured and Carranza refused to yield to diplomatic persuasion. +Carranza then proposed that a joint commission be appointed to settle +these vexed questions. Even this device proved wholly unsatisfactory. +The Mexicans would not concede the right of the United States to send +an armed expedition into their country at any time, and the Americans +refused to accept limitations on the kind of troops that they might +employ or on the zone of their operations. In January, 1917, the joint +commission was dissolved and the American soldiers were withdrawn. Again +the "first chief" had won! + +On the 5th of February a convention assembled at Queretaro promulgated +a constitution embodying substantially all of the radical program +that Carranza had anticipated in his decrees. Besides providing for an +elaborate improvement in the condition of the laboring classes and +for such a division of great estates as might satisfy their particular +needs, the new constitution imposed drastic restrictions upon foreigners +and religious bodies. Under its terms, foreigners could not acquire +industrial concessions unless they waived their treaty rights and +consented to regard themselves for the purpose as Mexican citizens. +In all such cases preference was to be shown Mexicans over foreigners. +Ecclesiastical corporations were forbidden to own real property. No +primary school and no charitable institution could be conducted by +any religious mission or denomination, and religious publications must +refrain from commenting on public affairs. The presidential term was +reduced from six years to four; reelection was prohibited; and the +office of Vice President was abolished. + +When, on the 1st of May, Venustiano Carranza was chosen President, +Mexico had its first constitutional executive in four years. After +a cruel and obstinately intolerant struggle that had occasioned +indescribable suffering from disease and starvation, as well as the +usual slaughter and destruction incident to war, the country began to +enjoy once more a measure of peace. Financial exhaustion, however, had +to be overcome before recuperation was possible. Industrial progress had +become almost paralyzed; vast quantities of depreciated paper money had +to be withdrawn from circulation; and an enormous array of claims for +the loss of foreign life and property had rolled up. + + + +CHAPTER XI. THE REPUBLICS OF THE CARIBBEAN + +The course of events in certain of the republics in and around the +Caribbean Sea warned the Hispanic nations that independence was a +relative condition and that it might vary in direct ratio with nearness +to the United States. After 1906 this powerful northern neighbor showed +an unmistakable tendency to extend its influence in various ways. Here +fiscal and police control was established; there official recognition +was withheld from a President who had secured office by unconstitutional +methods. Nonrecognition promised to be an effective way of maintaining +a regime of law and order, as the United States understood those terms. +Assurances from the United States of the full political equality of all +republics, big or little, in the western hemisphere did not always carry +conviction to Spanish American ears. The smaller countries in and around +the Caribbean Sea, at least, seemed likely to become virtually American +protectorates. + +Like their Hispanic neighbor on the north, the little republics of +Central America were also scenes of political disturbance. None of them +except Panama escaped revolutionary uprisings, though the loss of life +and property was insignificant. On the other hand, in these early years +of the century the five countries north of Panama made substantial +progress toward federation. As a South American writer has expressed +it, their previous efforts in that direction "amid sumptuous festivals, +banquets and other solemn public acts" at which they "intoned in +lyric accents daily hymns for the imperishable reunion of the isthmian +republics," had been as illusory as they were frequent. Despite the +mediation of the United States and Mexico in 1906, while the latter +was still ruled by Diaz, the struggle in which Nicaragua, Honduras, +Guatemala, and Salvador had been engaged was soon renewed between +the first two belligerents. Since diplomatic interposition no longer +availed, American marines were landed in Nicaragua, and the bumptious +Zelaya was induced to have his country meet its neighbors in a +conference at Washington. Under the auspices of the United States and +Mexico, in December, 1907, representatives of the five republics signed +a series of conventions providing for peace and cooperation. An arbitral +court of justice, to be erected in Costa Rica and composed of one judge +from each nation, was to decide all matters of dispute which could not +be adjusted through ordinary diplomatic means. Here, also, an institute +for the training of Central American teachers was to be established. +Annual conferences were to discuss, and an office in Guatemala was to +record, measures designed to secure uniformity in financial, commercial, +industrial, sanitary, and educational regulations. Honduras, the storm +center of weakness, was to be neutralized. None of the States was +thereafter to recognize in any of them a government which had been set +up in an illegal fashion. A "Constitutional Act of Central American +Fraternity," moreover, was adopted on behalf of peace, harmony, and +progress. Toward a realization of the several objects of the conference, +the Presidents of the five republics were to invite their colleagues +of the United States and Mexico, whenever needful, to appoint +representatives, to "lend their good offices in a purely friendly way." + +Though most of these agencies were promptly put into operation, the +results were not altogether satisfactory. Some discords, to be sure, +were removed by treaties settling boundary questions and providing for +reciprocal trade advantages; but it is doubtful whether the arrangements +devised at Washington would have worked at all if the United States had +not kept the little countries under a certain amount of observation. +What the Central Americans apparently preferred was to be left alone, +some of them to mind their own business, others to mind their neighbor's +affairs. + +Of all the Central American countries Honduras was, perhaps, the one +most afflicted with pecuniary misfortunes. In 1909 its foreign debt, +along with arrears of interest unpaid for thirty-seven years, was +estimated at upwards of $110,000,000. Of this amount a large part +consisted of loans obtained from foreign capitalists, at more or less +extortionate rates, for the construction of a short railway, of which +less than half had been built. That revolutions should be rather +chronic in a land where so much money could be squandered and where +the temperaments of Presidents and ex-Presidents were so bellicose, +was natural enough. When the United States could not induce the warring +rivals to abide by fair elections, it sent a force of marines to overawe +them and gave warning that further disturbances would not be allowed. + +In Nicaragua the conditions were similar. Here Zelaya, restive under the +limitations set by the conference at Washington, yearned to become the +"strong man" of Central America, who would teach the Yankees to stop +their meddling. But his downfall was imminent. In 1909, as the result of +his execution of two American soldiers of fortune who had taken part in +a recent insurrection, the United States resolved to tolerate Zelaya no +longer. Openly recognizing the insurgents, it forced the dictator out of +the country. Three years later, when a President-elect started to assume +office before the legally appointed time, a force of American marines +at the capital convinced him that such a procedure was undesirable. The +"corrupt and barbarous" conditions prevailing in Zelaya's time, he was +informed, could not be tolerated. The United States, in fact, notified +all parties in Nicaragua that, under the terms of the Washington +conventions, it had a "moral mandate to exert its influence for the +preservation of the general peace of Central America." Since those +agreements had vested no one with authority to enforce them, such an +interpretation of their language, aimed apparently at all disturbances, +foreign as well as domestic, was rather elastic! At all events, after +1912, when a new constitution was adopted, the country became relatively +quiet and somewhat progressive. Whenever a political flurry did take +place, American marines were employed to preserve the peace. Many +citizens, therefore, declined to vote, on the ground that the moral and +material support thus furnished by the great nation to the northward +rendered it futile for them to assume political responsibilities. + +Meanwhile negotiations began which were ultimately to make Nicaragua a +fiscal protectorate of the United States. American officials were chosen +to act as financial advisers and collectors of customs, and favorable +arrangements were concluded with American bankers regarding the monetary +situation; but it was not until 1916 that a treaty covering this +situation was ratified. According to its provisions, in return for a +stipulated sum to be expended under American direction, Nicaragua was +to grant to the United States the exclusive privilege of constructing a +canal through the territory of the republic and to lease to it the Corn +Islands and a part of Fonseca Bay, on the Pacific coast, for use as +naval stations. The prospect of American intervention alarmed the +neighboring republics. Asserting that the treaty infringed upon their +respective boundaries, Costa Rica, and Salvador brought suit against +Nicaragua before the Central American Court. With the exception of +the Nicaraguan representative, the judges upheld the contention of the +plaintiffs that the defendant had no right to make any such concessions +without previous consultation with Costa Rica, Salvador, and Honduras, +since all three alike were affected by them. The Court observed, +however, that it could not declare the treaty void because the +United States, one of the parties concerned, was not subject to its +jurisdiction. Nicaragua declined to accept the decision; and the United +States, the country responsible for the existence of the Court and +presumably interested in helping to enforce its judgment, allowed it to +go out of existence in 1918 on the expiration of its ten-year term. + +The economic situation of Costa Rica brought about a state of affairs +wholly unusual in Central American politics. The President, Alfredo +Gonzalez, wished to reform the system of taxation so that a fairer share +of the public burdens should fall on the great landholders who, like +most of their brethren in the Hispanic countries, were practically +exempt. This project, coupled with the fact that certain American +citizens seeking an oil concession had undermined the power of the +President by wholesale bribery, induced the Minister of War, in 1917, +to start a revolt against him. Rather than shed the blood of his fellow +citizens for mere personal advantages, Gonzalez sustained the good +reputation of Costa Rica for freedom from civil commotions by quietly +leaving the country and going to the United States to present his case. +In consequence, the American Government declined to recognize the de +facto ruler. + +Police and fiscal supervision by the United States has characterized +the recent history of Panama. Not only has a proposed increase in the +customs duties been disallowed, but more than once the unrest attending +presidential elections has required the calming presence of American +officials. As a means of forestalling outbreaks, particularly in view +of the cosmopolitan population resident on the Isthmus, the republic +enacted a law in 1914 which forbade foreigners to mix in local politics +and authorized the expulsion of naturalized citizens who attacked the +Government through the press or otherwise. With the approval of the +United States, Panama entered into an agreement with American financiers +providing for the creation of a national bank, one-fourth of the +directors of which should be named by the Government of the republic. + +The second period of American rule in Cuba lasted till 1909. Control of +the Government was then formally transferred to Jose Miguel Gomez, the +President who had been chosen by the Liberals at the elections held in +the previous year; but the United States did not cease to watch over its +chief Caribbean ward. A bitter controversy soon developed in the Cuban +Congress over measures to forbid the further purchase of land by aliens, +and to insure that a certain percentage of the public offices should +be held by colored citizens. Though both projects were defeated, they +revealed a strong antiforeign sentiment and much dissatisfaction on the +part of the negro population. It was clear also that Gomez, intended to +oust all conservatives from office, for an obedient Congress passed a +bill suspending the civil service rules. + +The partisanship of Gomez, and his supporters, together with the +constant interference of military veterans in political affairs, +provoked numerous outbreaks, which led the United States, in 1912, to +warn Cuba that it might again be compelled to intervene. Eventually, +when a negro insurrection in the eastern part of the island menaced the +safety of foreigners, American marines were landed. Another instance +of intervention was the objection by the United States to an employers' +liability law that would have given a monopoly of the insurance business +to a Cuban company to the detriment of American firms. + +After the election of Mario Menocal, the Conservative candidate, to the +presidency in 1912, another occasion for intervention presented itself. +An amnesty bill, originally drafted for the purpose of freeing the +colored insurgents and other offenders, was amended so as to empower +the retiring President to grant pardon before trial to persons whom +his successor wished to prosecute for wholesale corruption in financial +transactions. Before the bill passed, however, notice was sent from +Washington that, since the American Government had the authority to +supervise the finances of the republic, Gomez would better veto the +bill, and this he accordingly did. + +A sharp struggle arose when it became known that Menocal would be a +candidate for reelection. The Liberal majority in the Congress passed +a bill requiring that a President who sought to succeed himself should +resign two months before the elections. When Menocal vetoed this +measure, his opponents demanded that the United States supervise the +elections. As the result of the elections was doubtful, Gomez and his +followers resorted in 1917 to the usual insurrection; whereupon the +American Government warned the rebels that it would not recognize their +claims if they won by force. Active aid from that quarter, as well as +the capture of the insurgent leader, caused the movement to collapse +after the electoral college had decided in favor of Menocal. + +In the Dominican Republic disturbances were frequent, notwithstanding +the fact that American officials were in charge of the customhouses and +by their presence were expected to exert a quieting influence. Even +the adoption, in 1908, of a new constitution which provided for the +prolongation of the presidential term to six years and for the abolition +of the office of Vice President--two stabilizing devices quite common +in Hispanic countries where personal ambition is prone to be a source of +political trouble--did not help much to restore order. The assassination +of the President and the persistence of age-long quarrels with Haiti +over boundaries made matters worse. Thereupon, in 1913, the United +States served formal notice on the rebellious parties that it would +not only refuse to recognize any Government set up by force but would +withhold any share in the receipts from the customs. As this procedure +did not prevent a revolutionary leader from demanding half a million +dollars as a financial sedative for his political nerves and from +creating more trouble when the President failed to dispense it, the +heavy hand of an American naval force administered another kind +of specific, until commissioners from Porto Rico could arrive to +superintend the selection of a new chief magistrate. Notwithstanding the +protest of the Dominican Government, the "fairest and freest" elections +ever known in the country were held under the direction of those +officials--as a "body of friendly observers"! + +However amicable this arrangement seemed, it did not smother the flames +of discord. In 1916, when an American naval commander suggested that a +rebellious Minister of War leave the capital, he agreed to do so if the +"fairest and freest" of chosen Presidents would resign. Even after both +of them had complied with the suggestions, the individuals who assumed +their respective offices were soon at loggerheads. Accordingly the +United States placed the republic under military rule, until a President +could be elected who might be able to retain his post without too much +"friendly observation" from Washington, and a Minister of War could be +appointed who would refrain from making war on the President! Then the +organization of a new party to combat the previous inordinate display +of personalities in politics created some hope that the republic would +accomplish its own redemption. + +Only because of its relation to the wars of emancipation and to the +Dominican Republic, need the negro state of Haiti, occupying the western +part of the Caribbean island, be mentioned in connection with the story +of the Hispanic nations. Suffice it to say that the fact that their +color was different and that they spoke a variant of French instead of +Spanish did not prevent the inhabitants of this state from offering a +far worse spectacle of political and financial demoralization than +did their neighbors to the eastward. Perpetual commotions and repeated +interventions by American and European naval forces on behalf of the +foreign residents, eventually made it imperative for the United States +to take direct charge of the republic. In 1916, by a convention +which placed the finances under American control, created a native +constabulary under American officers, and imposed a number of other +restraints, the United States converted Haiti into what is practically a +protectorate. + + + +CHAPTER XII. PAN-AMERICANISM AND THE GREAT WAR + +While the Hispanic republics were entering upon the second century of +their independent life, the idea of a certain community of interests +between themselves and the United States began to assume a fairly +definite form. Though emphasized by American statesmen and publicists +in particular, the new point of view was not generally understood or +appreciated by the people of either this country or its fellow nations +to the southward. It seemed, nevertheless, to promise an effective +cooperation in spirit and action between them and came therefore to be +called "Pan-Americanism." + +This sentiment of inter-American solidarity sprang from several sources. +The periodical conferences of the United States and its sister republics +gave occasion for an interchange of official courtesies and expressions +of good feeling. Doubtless, also, the presence of delegates from the +Hispanic countries at the international gatherings at The Hague served +to acquaint the world at large with the stability, strength, wealth, and +culture of their respective lands. Individual Americans took an active +interest in their fellows of Hispanic stock and found their interest +reciprocated. Motives of business or pleasure and a desire to obtain +personal knowledge about one another led to visits and countervisits +that became steadily more frequent. Societies were created to encourage +the friendship and acquaintance thus formed. Scientific congresses were +held and institutes were founded in which both the United States and +Hispanic America were represented. Books, articles, and newspaper +accounts about one another's countries were published in increasing +volume. Educational institutions devoted a constantly growing attention +to inter-American affairs. Individuals and commissions were dispatched +by the Hispanic nations and the United States to study one another's +conditions and to confer about matters of mutual concern. Secretaries of +State, Ministers of Foreign Affairs, and other distinguished personages +interchanged visits. Above all, the common dangers and responsibilities +falling upon the Americas at large as a consequence of the European war +seemed likely to bring the several nations into a harmony of feeling and +relationship to which they had never before attained. + +Pan-Americanism, however, was destined to remain largely a generous +ideal. The action of the United States in extending its direct influence +over the small republics in and around the Caribbean aroused +the suspicion and alarm of Hispanic Americans, who still feared +imperialistic designs on the part of that country now more than ever the +Colossus of the North. "The art of oratory among the Yankees," declared +a South American critic, "is lavish with a fraternal idealism; but +strong wills enforce their imperialistic ambitions." Impassioned +speakers and writers adjured the ghost of Hispanic confederation to rise +and confront the new northern peril. They even advocated an appeal +to Great Britain, Germany, or Japan, and they urged closer economic, +social, and intellectual relations with the countries of Europe. + +It was while the United States was thus widening the sphere of its +influence in the Caribbean that the "A B C" powers--Argentina, Brazil, +and Chile--reached an understanding which was in a sense a measure of +self-defense. For some years cordial relations had existed among these +three nations which had grown so remarkably in strength and prestige. +It was felt that by united action they might set up in the New World +the European principle of a balance of power, assume the leadership +in Hispanic America, and serve in some degree as a counterpoise to the +United States. Nevertheless they were disposed to cooperate with their +northern neighbor in the peaceable adjustment of conflicts in which +other Hispanic countries were concerned, provided that the mediation +carried on by such a "concert of the western world" did not include +actual intervention in the internal affairs of the countries involved. + +With this attitude of the public mind, it is not strange that the +Hispanic republics at large should have been inclined to look with scant +favor upon proposals made by the United States, in 1916, to render the +spirit of Pan-Americanism more precise in its operation. The proposals +in substance were these: that all the nations of America "mutually agree +to guarantee the territorial integrity" of one another; to "maintain a +republican form of government"; to prohibit the "exportation of arms +to any but the legally constituted governments"; and to adopt laws of +neutrality which would make it "impossible to filibustering expeditions +to threaten or carry on revolutions in neighboring republics." These +proposals appear to have received no formal approval beyond what is +signified by the diplomatic expression "in principle." Considering the +disparity in strength, wealth, and prestige between the northern +country and its southern fellows, suggestions of the sort could be made +practicable only by letting the United States do whatever it might +think needful to accomplish the objects which it sought. Obviously the +Hispanic nations, singly or collectively, would hardly venture to take +any such action within the borders of the United States itself, if, for +example, it failed to maintain what, in their opinion, was "a republican +form of government." A full acceptance of the plan accordingly would +have amounted to a recognition of American overlordship, and this they +were naturally not disposed to admit. + +The common perils and duties confronting the Americas as a result of +the Great War, however, made close cooperation between the Hispanic +republics and the United States up to a certain point indispensable. +Toward that transatlantic struggle the attitude of all the nations of +the New World at the outset was substantially the same. Though strongly +sympathetic on the whole with the "Allies" and notably with France, the +southern countries nevertheless declared their neutrality. More than +that, they tried to convert neutrality into a Pan-American policy, +instead of regarding it as an official attitude to be adopted by the +republics separately. Thus when the conflict overseas began to injure +the rights of neutrals, Argentina and other nations urged that the +countries of the New World jointly agree to declare that direct maritime +commerce between American lands should be considered as "inter-American +coastwise trade," and that the merchant ships engaged in it, whatever +the flag under which they sailed, should be looked upon as neutral. +Though the South American countries failed to enlist the support of +their northern neighbor in this bold departure from international +precedent, they found some compensation for their disappointment in the +closer commercial and financial relations which they established with +the United States. + +Because of the dependence of the Hispanic nations, and especially those +of the southern group, on the intimacy of their economic ties with the +belligerents overseas, they suffered from the ravages of the struggle +more perhaps than other lands outside of Europe. Negotiations for +prospective loans were dropped. Industries were suspended, work on +public improvements was checked, and commerce brought almost to a +standstill. As the revenues fell off and ready money became scarce, +drastic measures had to be devised to meet the financial strain. For the +protection of credit, bank holidays were declared, stock exchanges were +closed, moratoria were set up in nearly all the countries, taxes +and duties were increased, radical reductions in expenditure were +undertaken, and in a few cases large quantities of paper money were +issued. + +With the European market thus wholly or partially cut off, the +Hispanic republics were forced to supply the consequent shortage with +manufactured articles and other goods from the United States and to send +thither their raw materials in exchange. To their northern neighbor they +had to turn also for pecuniary aid. A Pan-American financial conference +was held at Washington in 1915, and an international high commission was +appointed to carry its recommendations into effect. Gradually most of +the Hispanic countries came to show a favorable trade balance. Then, as +the war drew into its fourth year, several of them even began to enjoy +great prosperity. That Pan-Americanism had not meant much more than +cooperation for economic ends seemed evident when, on April 6, 1917, +the United States declared war on Germany. Instead of following +spontaneously in the wake of their great northern neighbor, the Hispanic +republics were divided by conflicting currents of opinion and hesitated +as to their proper course of procedure. While a majority of them +expressed approval of what the United States had done, and while Uruguay +for its part asserted that "no American country, which in defense of its +own rights should find itself in a state of war with nations of other +continents, would be treated as a belligerent," Mexico veered almost to +the other extreme by proposing that the republics of America agree to +lay an embargo on the shipment of munitions to the warring powers. + +As a matter of fact, only seven out of the nineteen Hispanic nations saw +fit to imitate the example set by their northern neighbor and to declare +war on Germany. These were Cuba--in view of its "duty toward the United +States," Panama, Guatemala, Brazil, Honduras, Nicaragua, and Costa Rica. +Since the Dominican Republic at the time was under American military +control, it was not in a position to choose its course. Four countries +Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia, and Uruguay--broke off diplomatic relations +with Germany. The other seven republics--Mexico, Salvador, Colombia, +Venezuela, Chile, Argentina, and Paraguay--continued their formal +neutrality. In spite of a disclosure made by the United States of +insulting and threatening utterances on the part of the German charge +d'affaires in Argentina, which led to popular outbreaks at the capital +and induced the national Congress to declare in favor of a severance of +diplomatic relations with that functionary's Government, the President +of the republic stood firm in his resolution to maintain neutrality. +If Pan-Americanism had ever involved the idea of political cooperation +among the nations of the New World, it broke down just when it might +have served the greatest of purposes. Even the "A B C" combination +itself had apparently been shattered. + +A century and more had now passed since the Spanish and Portuguese +peoples of the New World had achieved their independence. Eighteen +political children of various sizes and stages of advancement, or +backwardness, were born of Spain in America, and one acknowledged the +maternity of Portugal. Big Brazil has always maintained the happiest +relations with the little mother in Europe, who still watches with +pride the growth of her strapping youngster. Between Spain and her +descendants, however, animosity endured for many years after they had +thrown off the parental yoke. Yet of late, much has been done on both +sides to render the relationship cordial. The graceful act of Spain in +sending the much-beloved Infanta Isabel to represent her in Argentina +and Chile at the celebration of the centennial anniversary of their cry +for independence, and to wish them Godspeed on their onward journey, was +typical of the yearning of the mother country for her children overseas, +despite the lapse of years and political ties. So, too, her ablest men +of intellect have striven nobly and with marked success to revive +among them a sense of filial affection and gratitude for all that Spain +contributed to mold the mind and heart of her kindred in distant +lands. On their part, the Hispanic Americans have come to a clearer +consciousness of the fact that on the continents of the New World there +are two distinct types of civilization, with all that each connotes of +differences in race, psychology, tradition, language, and custom--their +own, and that represented by the United States. Appreciative though +the southern countries are of their northern neighbor, they cling +nevertheless to their heritage from Spain and Portugal in whatever seems +conducive to the maintenance of their own ideals of life and thought. + + + + +BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTE + +For anything like a detailed study of the history of the Hispanic +nations of America, obviously one must consult works written in Spanish +and Portuguese. There are many important books, also, in French and +German; but, with few exceptions, the recommendations for the general +reader will be limited to accounts in English. + +A very useful outline and guide to recent literature on the subject is +W. W. Pierson, Jr., "A Syllabus of Latin-American History" (Chapel Hill, +North Carolina, 1917). A brief introduction to the history and present +aspects of Hispanic American civilization is W. R. Shepherd, "Latin +America" (New York, 1914). The best general accounts of the Spanish +and Portuguese colonial systems will be found in Charles de Lannoy and +Herman van der Linden, "Histoire de L'Expansion Coloniale des Peuples +Europeans: Portugal et Espagne" (Brussels and Paris, 1907), and Kurt +Simon, "Spanien and Portugal als See and Kolonialmdchte" (Hamburg, +1913). For the Spanish colonial regime alone, E. G. Bourne, "Spain in +America" (New York, 1904) is excellent. The situation in southern South +America toward the close of Spanish rule is well described in Bernard +Moses, "South America on the Eve of Emancipation" (New York, 1908). +Among contemporary accounts of that period, Alexander von Humboldt and +Aime Bonpland, "Personal Narrative of Travels to the Equinoctial Regions +of America", 3 vols. (London, 1881); Alexander von Humboldt, "Political +Essay on the Kingdom of New Spain", 4 vols. (London,1811-1822); and F. +R. J. de Pons, "Travels in South America", 2 vols. (London, 1807), are +authoritative, even if not always easy to read. + +On the wars of independence, see the scholarly treatise by W. S. +Robertson, "Rise of the Spanish-American Republics as Told in the +Lives of their Liberators" (New York, 1918); Bartolome Mitre, "The +Emancipation of South America" (London, 1893)--a condensed translation +of the author's "Historia de San Martin", and wholly favorable to that +patriot; and F. L. Petre, "Simon Bolivar" (London, 1910)--impartial +at the expense of the imagination. Among the numerous contemporary +accounts, the following will be found serviceable: W. D. Robinson, +"Memoirs of the Mexican Revolution" (Philadelphia, 1890); J. R. +Poinsett, "Notes on Mexico" (London, 1825); H. M. Brackenridge, "Voyage +to South America," 2 vols. (London, 1820); W. B. Stevenson, "Historical +and Descriptive Narrative of Twenty Years' Residence in South America", +3 vols. (London, 1895); J. Miller, "Memoirs of General Miller in the +Service of the Republic of Peru", 2 vols. (London, 1828); H. L. V. +Ducoudray Holstein, "Memoirs of Simon Bolivar", 2 vols. (London, 1830), +and John Armitage, "History of Brazil", 2 vols. (London, 1836). + +The best books on the history of the republics as a whole since the +attainment of independence, and written from an Hispanic American +viewpoint, are F. Garcia Calderon, "Latin America, its Rise and +Progress" (New York, 1913), and M. de Oliveira Lima, "The Evolution of +Brazil Compared with that of Spanish and Anglo-Saxon America" (Stanford +University, California, 1914). The countries of Central America are +dealt with by W. H. Koebel, "Central America" (New York, 1917), and of +South America by T. C. Dawson, "The South American Republics", 2 vols. +(New York, 1903-1904), and C. E. Akers, "History of South America" +(London, 1912), though in a manner that often confuses rather than +enlightens. + +Among the histories and descriptions of individual countries, arranged +in alphabetical order, the following are probably the most useful to the +general reader: W. A. Hirst, "Argentina" (New York, 1910); Paul Walle, +"Bolivia" (New York, 1914); Pierre Denis, "Brazil" (New York, 1911); +G. F. S. Elliot, "Chile" (New York, 1907); P. J. Eder, "Colombia" (New +York, 1913); J. B. Calvo, "The Republic of Costa Rica" (Chicago, 1890); +A. G. Robinson, "Cuba, Old and New" (New York, 1915); Otto Schoenrich, +"Santo Domingo" (New York, 1918); C. R. Enock, "Ecuador" (New York, +1914); C. R. Enock, "Mexico" (New York, 1909); W. H. Koebel, "Paraguay" +(New York, 1917); C. R. Enock, "Peru" (New York, 1910); W. H. Koebel, +"Uruguay" (New York, 1911), and L. V. Dalton, "Venezuela" (New York, +1912). Of these, the books by Robinson and Eder, on Cuba and Colombia, +respectively, are the most readable and reliable. + +For additional bibliographical references see "South America" and the +articles on individual countries in "The Encyclopaedia Britannica", 11th +edition, and in Marrion Wilcox and G. E. Rines, "Encyclopedia of Latin +America" (New York, 1917). + +Of contemporary or later works descriptive of the life and times of +eminent characters in the history of the Hispanic American republics +since 1830, a few may be taken as representative. Rosas: J. A. King, +"Twenty-four Years in the Argentine Republic" (London, 1846), and +Woodbine Parish, "Buenos Ayres and the Provinces of the Rio de la Plata" +(London, 1850). Francia: J. R. Rengger, "Reign of Dr. Joseph Gaspard +Roderick [!] de Francia in Paraguay" (London, 1827); J. P. and W. P. +Robertson, "Letters on South America", 3 vols. (London, 1843), and E. +L. White, "El Supremo", a novel (New York, 1916). Santa Anna: Waddy +Thompson, "Recollections of Mexico" (New York, 1846), and F. E. Ingles, +Calderon de la Barca, "Life in Mexico" (London, 1859.). Juarez: U. +R. Burke, "Life of Benito Juarez" (London, 1894). Solano Lopez: T. J. +Hutchinson, "Parana; with Incidents of the Paraguayan War and South +American Recollections" (London, 1868); George Thompson, "The War in +Paraguay" (London, 1869); R. F. Burton, "Letters from the Battle-fields +of Paraguay" (London, 1870), and C. A. Washburn, "The History of +Paraguay", 2 vols. (Boston, 1871). Pedro II: J. C. Fletcher and D. P. +Kidder, "Brazil and the Brazilians" (Boston, 1879), and Frank Bennett, +"Forty Years in Brazil"(London, 1914). Garcia Moreno: Frederick +Hassaurek, "Four Years among Spanish Americans"(New York, 1867). Guzman +Blanco: C. D. Dance, "Recollections of Four Years in Venezuela" (London, +1876). Diaz: James Creelman, "Diaz, Master of Mexico" (New York, 1911). +Balmaceda: M. H. Hervey, "Dark Days in Chile" (London, 1891-1890. +Carranza: L. Gutierrez de Lara and Edgcumb Pinchon, "The Mexican People: +their Struggle for Freedom" (New York, 1914). + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of The Hispanic Nations of the New World, by +William R. Shepherd + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE HISPANIC NATIONS *** + +***** This file should be named 3042.txt or 3042.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + http://www.gutenberg.org/3/0/4/3042/ + +Produced by The James J. Kelly Library Of St. Gregory's +University, Dianne Bean, Joseph Buersmeyer, and Alev Akman + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +http://gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS' WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at http://www.pglaf.org. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Its 501(c)(3) letter is posted at +http://pglaf.org/fundraising. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at http://pglaf.org + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit http://pglaf.org + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. +To donate, please visit: http://pglaf.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart is the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + http://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. |